cover
next page >
Cover
title: author: publisher: isbn10 | asin: print isbn13: ebook isbn13: language: subject publication date: lcc: ddc: subject:
Educational Media and Technology Yearbook 2003. Vol. 28 Branch, Robert Maribe.; Orey, Michael.; Fitzgerald, Mary Ann. Libraries Unlimited 1591580323 9781591580324 9780313023002 English Educational technology, Teaching--Aids and devices, Instructional materials centers, Instructional materials personnel. 2003 LB1028.3E38 2003eb 371.3078 Educational technology, Teaching--Aids and devices, Instructional materials centers, Instructional materials personnel.
cover
next page >
< previous page
page_i
next page >
Page i EDUCATIONAL MEDIA AND TECHNOLOGY YEARBOOK
< previous page
page_i
next page >
< previous page
page_ii
next page >
page_ii
next page >
Page ii This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_iii
next page >
Page iii EDUCATIONAL MEDIA AND TECHNOLOGY YEARBOOK Mary Ann Fitzgerald, Michael Orey, and Robert Maribe Branch, Editors 2003 VOLUME 28 Published in Cooperation with the ERIC® Clearinghouse on Information & Technology and the Association for Educational Communications and Technology
A member of the Greenwood Publishing Group Westport, Connecticut • London
< previous page
page_iii
next page >
< previous page
page_iv
next page >
Page iv Copyright 2003 Libraries Unlimited All Rights Reserved Printed in the United States of America No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or other wise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. Libraries Unlimited A Member of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. 88 Post Road West Westport, CT 06881 www.lu.com Suggested cataloging supplied by Libraries Unlimited: Educational media and technology yearbook.—Westport, CT : Libraries Unlimited, A Division of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc., 1985v.Annual 2003- vol. 28“Published in cooperation with the ERIC Clearinghouse on Information and Technology and the Association for Educational Communications and Technology” Continues: Educational media yearbook ISBN 1-59158-032-3 1. Educational technology—United States—Yearbook. 2. Instructional materials centers—United States—Yearbook. 3. Instructional materials personnel—United States —Yearbook. I. Fitzgerald, Mary Ann, ed. II. Orey, Michael, ed. III. Branch, Robert Maribe, ed. IV. ERIC Clearinghouse on Information and Technology. V. Association for Educational Communications and Technology LB 1028.3.E372 2003 370.778 2003
< previous page
page_iv
next page >
< previous page
page_v
next page >
Page v Contents Preface Contributors Part One TRENDS AND ISSUES Introduction Michael Orey Issues and Trends in Instructional Technology: Treading Water Michael Molenda, Michael Sullivan A Content Analysis of Women’s Contributions to the Leading Instructional Technology Journals, 1995–2000 Anne L. Foley, Janet Morgan Developing Science Education Materials via Computer-Based Support Susan McKenney From Instruction to Construction: Learning in the Information Age Violet H. Harada Do You Want to Be in Control or Not? An Unasked Question in CBI Research Jung Lee Ethics and Privacy Considerations for Assessing Ethical Issues Erin Brewer, Nick Eastmond, Reed Geertsen Developing Ethical Behaviors in Students: What Schools Must Do Doug Johnson Privacy Primer for Educators Judith Lewandowski Manufacturing Technophobia: Computerization’s Mythical Fears Andrew R. J. Yeaman Distance Learning The Experience of Two Learners Learning at a Distance via the Internet a la Epic Learning Michael Orey, Lynne Koenecke A Systematic Approach to Determining the Scalability of a Distance Education Program Richard C. Snider, Ross A. Perkins, Glen A. Holmes, Barbara B. Lockee
< previous page
page_v
ix xi 1 3 21 32 40 49 67 77 90 98 115 122
next page >
< previous page
page_vi
next page >
Page vi Identifying Factors That Affect Learning Community Development and Performance in Asynchronous Distance Education Leslie A. Moller, Douglas Harvey, Margaret Downs, Veronica M. Godshalk Overcoming the Distance Divide: Streaming Video in a Teacher Preparation Program Peter Serdyukov, Mark Ryan, Clifford Russell, Ruth Black PT3 Grant Reports P3T3: Purdue Program for Preparing Tomorrow’s Teachers to Use Technology James D. Lehman Restructuring Teacher Education: Building a Theoretical Base Joyce A. Pittman InTime: Online Video Resources for Teacher Educators Featuring Technology Integration in PreK–12 Classrooms Karla Krueger, Marius Boboc, Yana Cornish Faculty Learning to Use Technology: PT3-Supported Systemic Reform Initiatives in Teacher Education Gregory L. Waddoups, Nancy Wentworth, Rodney Earle Integrating Technology Throughout a Preservice Teacher Education Program: A PT3 Grant Project at the University of Northern Colorado Donna Ferguson Pabst, Edward Caffarella Modeling Technology Integration in a Teacher Education Course Taralynn S. Hartsell, Steve Chi-Yin Yuen Part Two SCHOOL AND LIBRARY MEDIA Introduction Mary Ann Fitzgerald Proof of the Power: Recent Research on the Impact of School Library Media Programs on the Academic Achievement of U.S. Public School Students Keith Curry Lance Data Collection for Evaluating School Library Media Programs Nancy Everhart Standard Time: Integrating the 10 CONCEPTS with National and State Standards for a Dynamic Library Media Program Ruth Toor, Hilda K. Weisburg Fostering Library Media Specialist–Educational Technologist Collaboration Ruth V. Small, Celestia Ohrazda, Pamela Revercomb, J. Michael Spector Moving from Cooperation to Collaboration Through the Use of Technology: A Professional Development Model for School and Public Librarians Sandra Hughes-Hassell, Jacqueline C. Mancall, Sarah Reid, Sarena Deglin
< previous page
page_vi
139 152 161 169 183 198 205 213
225 228 238 247 250 260
next page >
< previous page
page_vii
Page vii Cataloging Update 101: How to Get the Most out of Your Online Catalog Elizabeth Haynes Part Three LEADERSHIP PROFILES Introduction Michael Orey Francis M. Dwyer: Visual Researcher Extraordinaire David M. (Mike) Moore Tribute to John G. Hedberg: Professor of Education, University of Wollongong Thomas Reeves Part Four ORGANIZATIONS AND ASSOCIATIONS IN NORTHAMERICA Introduction Anna E. Burdett United States Classified List Alphabetical List Canada/International Part Five GRADUATE PROGRAMS Introduction Anna E. Burdett Graduate Programs in Instructional Technology [IT] Classified List Alphabetical List International Programs Part Six MEDIAGRAPHY Print and Nonprint Resources Introduction Anna E. Burdett Mediagraphy Artificial Intelligence, Robotics, and Electronic Performance Support Systems Computer-Assisted Instruction Distance Education Educational Research
< previous page
page_vii
next page > 274
283 284 287
291 292 292 298 360 365 367 367 375 423 425 428 428 429 433 445
next page >
< previous page
page_viii
Page viii Educational Technology Information Science and Technology Instructional Design and Development Libraries and Media Centers Media Technologies Professional Development Simulation, Gaming, and Virtual Reality Special Education and Disabilities Telecommunications and Networking Index
< previous page
next page > 447 450 452 453 460 463 464 465 467 471
page_viii
next page >
< previous page
page_ix
next page >
Page ix Preface The purpose of the 28th volume of the Educational Media and Technology Yearbook is to explore current developments in the field of instructional technology as of early 2003 and to provide an historical sampling of instructional technology issues for the preceding year. In the year 2002, we noted several trends in the field, some new and others continuing from recent years. Distance learning continued to be a major trend, accompanied by a great deal of development but also with more critical restraint and emphasis on rational choices. The terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, and the subsequent emphasis on security measures made traveling more difficult, and thus corporate educators increased their use of online conferencing and e-learning avenues. It seemed clear that scholarship in the area of distance learning remained an important area of need, especially regarding the effectiveness of instructional strategies. On the education side, particularly in the areas of teacher education and higher education in general, the number of elearning opportunities for students increased. However, institutions used more caution in their choice of distance learning as a delivery mode, because of the fiscal failure of many early for-profit higher education distance learning initiatives (see the chapter by Molenda and Sullivan, ‘‘Issues and Trends in Instructional Technology: Treading Water”). Institutions (as well as corporations) were more likely to study the return-on-investment likelihood of distance learning initiatives. As a result, hybrid models—offerings employing a mixture of face-to-face, online, and virtual-learning opportunities—gained space in program offerings. Another idea gaining prominence was that instructional technology programs should consider undergraduate degrees or undergraduate programs. This idea is not new but garnered attention because of the need for instructional technology personnel in businesses and schools at a lower-entry level. In the realm of emerging technologies in educational contexts, wireless networks and “personal digital assistants,” or increasingly, “pocket PCs” or handheld computers, both gained ground. Both types of technologies appeared in educational settings, and development of educational applications for them prospered. The audience for the Yearbook consists of media and technology professionals in schools, higher education, and business contexts. Topics of interest to professionals practicing in these areas are broad, as the table of contents demonstrates. The theme unifying each of the following chapters is the use of technology to enable or enhance education. Forms of technology represented in this volume vary from traditional tools such as the book to the latest advancements in digital technology. Areas of education encompass widely ranging situations involving learning and teaching. As in prior volumes, the assumptions underlying the chapters presented here are as follows: • Technology represents tools that act as extensions of the educator. • Media serve as delivery systems for educational communications. • Technology is not restricted to machines and hardware but includes techniques and procedures derived from scientific research about ways to promote change in human performance.
< previous page
page_ix
next page >
< previous page
page_x
next page >
Page x • The fundamental tenet is that educational media and technology should be used to 1. achieve authentic learning objectives, 2. situate learning tasks, 3. negotiate the complexities of guided learning, 4. facilitate the construction of knowledge, 5. support skill acquisition, and 6. manage diversity. The Educational Media and Technology Yearbook has become a standard reference in many libraries and professional collections. Examined in relation to its companion volumes of the past, the present volume provides a valuable historical record of current ideas and developments in the field. Part 1, “Trends and Issues,” presents an array of chapters that develop some of the current themes listed here, as well as others. The chapters in part 2, “School and Library Media,” concentrates on issues of special relevance to K– 12 education, school learning resources, and school library media centers. In part 3, “Leadership Profiles,” authors provide biographical sketches of the careers of instructional technology leaders. Part 4, “Organizations and Associations in North America,” and part 5, ‘‘Graduate Programs in North America,” are, respectively, directories of instructional technology-related organizations and institutions of higher learning offering degrees in related fields. Finally, part 6, the “Mediagraphy,” presents an annotated listing of selected current publications related to the field. The editors of the Yearbook invite media and technology professionals to submit manuscripts for consideration for publication. Contact Mary Ann Fitzgerald (
[email protected]) for submission guidelines. Mary Ann Fitzgerald Robert Branch, Michael Orey, and Tom Reeves each contributed ideas to this preface.
< previous page
page_x
next page >
< previous page
page_xi
next page >
page_xi
next page >
Page xi Contributors Ruth Black Marius Boboc Robert Maribe Branch Erin Brewer Anna E. Burdett Edward Caffarella Yana Cornish Sarena Deglin Margaret Downs Francis M. Dwyer Rodney Earle Nick Eastmond Nancy Everhart Mary Ann Fitzgerald Anne L. Foley Reed Geertsen Veronica M. Godshalk Violet H. Harada Taralynn S. Hartsell Douglas Harvey Elizabeth Haynes John Hedberg Glen A. Holmes Sandra Hughes-Hassell Doug Johnson Lynne Koenecke Karla Krueger Keith Curry Lance Jung Lee James D. Lehman Judith Lewandowski Barbara B. Lockee Jacqueline C. Mancall Susan McKenney Michael Molenda Leslie A. Moller David M. (Mike) Moore Janet Morgan Celestia Ohrazda Michael Orey Donna Ferguson Pabst Ross A. Perkins Joyce A. Pittman Thomas Reeves Sarah Reid Pamela Revercomb Clifford Russell Mark Ryan Peter Serdyukov Ruth V. Small Richard C. Snider J. Michael Spector Michael Sullivan Ruth Toor Gregory L. Waddoups Hilda K. Weisburg Nancy Wentworth Andrew R. J. Yeaman Steve Chi-Yin Yuen
< previous page
< previous page
page_xii
next page >
page_xii
next page >
Page xii This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_1
next page >
Page 1 Part One Trends and Issues Introduction The primary focus of this yearbook is to identify trends and issues in the field of instructional technology, to document the normal ebb and flow of ideas, concepts, theories and applications that are a part of the nature of this field. This book is no different in that regard to its 27 predecessors. It tries to capture the essence of the field taken as a snapshot for this year. As was initiated in the last volume, the present volume further expands on the use of categories within part 1. This year it includes chapters under the categories “Ethics and Privacy,” “Distance Learning.” and “PT3 Grant Reports,” as well as several general chapters. The work in these three areas was substantial enough over the past year that this categorization scheme seems to continue to be warranted. The general chapters in the ‘‘Trends and Issues” section form a strong collection of things to think about within the field. Molenda and Sullivan have once again spent the time to figure out what we are doing in the field and making predications as to where we will be going. Some of the driving forces in the field are represented in the distance learning and PT3 categories, but many other issues suggest that all is not perfect in the field. The Foley and Morgan chapter represents the trend in the research toward critical theory and socially responsible research. Although this chapter focuses on the feminist perspective and women researchers in the field, its purpose is to help us not only embrace a feminist view in our research but to become advocates for it. The McKenney chapter also represents this socially responsible kind of idea. The project discussed by McKenney is designed to help teachers in less-developed countries (in Africa) and is spearheaded by one of best departments on instructional technology that is based in a developed country (the Netherlands). It also addresses the trend to be more fully engaged in the schools. Harada’s chapter further describes the kinds of issues facing our schools and the learning that goes on in them. As technology evolves, so do the methods used by teachers. Finally, Lee’s chapter brings us back to one of the bigger issues that we have faced in the past in multimedia development: user control. Because much of the learning that is going on today is mediated by technology, basic issues in the design of technologybased learning tools reemerges. Of the three subcategories that I created for this section, perhaps the most important in our information age is the category on ethics and privacy. Using a literary device employing cases, Edwards, Eastmond, and Geertsen explain ethical dilemmas and compare a humanist response to a religious response. In most cases, the responses are similar, and their chapter helps us to think about our own professional ethics. Johnson focuses on student ethical behavior. This chapter is helpful in discussing guidelines for student behavior as students face new technologies in the classroom. The Lewandowski chapter helps us understand many of the dangers that lurk on the Internet and guides us to teaching and modeling appropriate technology use that protects an individual’s privacy. In this day and age, we need to employ these teaching suggestions. Finally, the Yeaman chapter forces us to reflect on technology use. I, for one, find myself being the technology advocate. I want to use and figure out good ways of using the latest thing to develop. In my quest to use
< previous page
page_1
next page >
< previous page
page_2
next page >
Page 2 the technology, I must pause and reflect about how this technology might be bad for me or for my learners. The second subcategory, distance learning, is one of the hottest topics in the field. However, as the Molenda and Sullivan chapter suggests, this trend may be waning in the face of some of the highest-profile companies either going out of business or severely curtailing operations. In the end, we are relearning that the instructional solution needs to fit the needs of the learners in the situation in which they find themselves. To that end, Orey and Koenecke address online blended learning as a model for meeting various needs. Snider, Perkins, Holmes, and Lockee addresses the issues they are considering for expanding their online master’s degree program. Scalability is the big lure for online learning, and issues of scalability are complex. One of the most important issues with scalability is learning community development, an issue explored in more depth by the Moller, Harvey, Downs, and Godshalk chapter. Another dream of online learning researchers and practitioners is video. With broadband Internet connections increasing, video will soon be ubiquitous. Serdyukov, Ryan, Russell, and Black address many of the issues surrounding the use of video in online learning. The last category concerns PT3 (Preparing Tomorrow’s Teachers to Use Technology) grant reports. The goal of the PT3 grants is to help students studying to be teachers to learn how to use technology for improving their future students’ learning. The reports gathered here are few compared with the number of grants issued, but they show the extent of the impact of these grants. Some of the reports describe the blending of multiple strategies to achieve the goal (see Lehman’s, Pittman’s, and Pabst and Caffarella’s chapters). Others focus on innovative technologies employed to achieve the goal (the chapter by Krueger, Boboc, and Cornish). Each of these chapters describes the large-scale implementation under way that affects multiple faculty in multiple departments and in some cases at multiple universities. Hartsell and Yuen take the perspective of one or two of those faculty that are part of this larger effort. In the end, many good ideas are being implemented in preservice teacher education to better prepare teachers to use technology in the classroom. There is considerable overlap between the projects, but each chapter also provides some powerfully unique issues. Give them all a read, and you will come away with some very good ideas for working with teachers. Michael Orey
< previous page
page_2
next page >
< previous page
page_3
next page >
Page 3 Issues and Trends in Instructional Technology Treading Water Michael Molenda Indiana University Michael Sullivan Agency for Instructional Technology Instructional technology is not practiced in a vacuum. Since our previous review (Molenda and Sullivan 2002) went to press, the landscape has shifted dramatically. The bursting of the Internet stock bubble in late 2000 helped make 2001 the worst year in the history of the high-technology industry. One indicator of the scale of the debacle is the number of jobs lost—some 500,000 in the United States. Among the hardest-hit stalwarts were Lucent (40,000 jobs), Motorola (39,000 jobs), Xerox (8,600 jobs), AOL (4,100 jobs), Walt Disney (4,000 jobs), and IBM (2,800 jobs). Some of the other forces that have shaped events since then include stagnation of the national economy throughout 2001 and into 2002, leading to the reappearance of budget deficits at the state and national levels after a decade of growth; the election of a new administration at the federal level, signaling new priorities in education; and the terrorist attacks in September 2001, exacerbating the economic slump and provoking changes in national priorities, as well as undermining air travel in the short run. As in previous reviews (Molenda and Harris 2001; Molenda and Sullivan 2000, 2002), we have monitored developments in the three broad sectors in which instructional technology is employed—corporate training, higher education, and K–12 education—and report the status and trends in each sector. In addition to the external forces just mentioned, there are, of course, internal dynamics within each school, college, and other organization in which instructional media and technologies are used. We will discuss how these internal dynamics affect technology use as well and will show how the trends within these sectors add up to indicate that instructional technology is treading water—struggling to hold its place in adverse circumstances. CORPORATE TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT The use of instructional technology in the corporate sector was affected by larger forces operating in the national economy as well as by the imperatives within the domain of training and performance improvement. The bursting of the dot-com bubble had an immediate effect on the e-learning vendor business. Bankruptcies, mergers, and consolidation characterized 2001 and 2002—a complete turnaround from the trends of prior years. There were over two dozen major acquisitions, often motivated by larger vendors’ desire to add technological capability by picking off smaller innovative companies. Within companies’ training departments, the economic recession led to cuts in training budgets, slowing the pace of adoption of e-learning. The September 11 terrorist attacks brought a temporary loss of confidence in air travel, encouraging more organizations to look for technological substitutes, such as videoconferencing and Web-based courses. It is too soon to gauge whether any substantive changes in instructional technology use happened and whether they persisted after the travel slump relented.
< previous page
page_3
next page >
< previous page
page_4
next page >
Page 4 Heightened security concerns added impetus to the movement to decentralize large offices, with increased telecommuting. A survey conducted just prior to September 11, 2001, indicated that about one-fifth of the adult workforce do at least part of their work away from a central office setting (Davis and Polonko 2001). As the trend to work away from the office continues, so will the trend to learn away from the office. Issue 1: Use of Technology-BasedMedia for Delivery of Instruction Classroom Instruction Despite earlier predictions to the contrary, face-to-face classroom instruction is still the most universally applied format of training, being used “always” or “often” at 94 percent of companies (Galvin 2001, 66). In terms of the percentage of time spent in training, classroom instruction stands at about 77 percent overall, indicating an increase of about 4 percent over the prior year, while courses delivered via computer with no instructor declined by 2 percent, to just 11 percent of all training (Galvin 2001, 66). Over the past five years, there has been no detectable decrease in the use of face-to-face classroom instruction, whereas there is evidence that Internet and intranet delivery is steadily gaining momentum. One could conclude that Internet-based training is not replacing traditional training but rather supplementing it. Traditional Classroom Media Print materials—manuals and workbooks—remain high in popularity, being used in virtually all organizations, with an “often” or ‘‘always” rating of 78 percent (Galvin 2001, 56). Videotapes are used at least occasionally at 92 percent of companies, a rate comparable to that of 10 years ago. However, only 61 percent of responding companies used video materials “often” or “always.” The use of slides and overhead transparencies has not been tracked consistently over the years, but these media formats seem to be receding slowly, as they are replaced by computer-based display media. The use of games and simulations (non-computer-based) has held steady for the past four years, being used “often” or “always” at 31 percent of companies (Galvin 2001, 56). Telecommunications Media Videoconferences distributed over satellite or cable are used for training at about 40 percent of all companies but are not used for a large proportion of training time except in the military services. They tend to be used for special purposes, such as the rollout of new products or new tools at companies with widely scattered locations. Desktop computer-delivered streaming video is used “often” or “always” at about 5 percent of companies (Galvin 2001, 56). Computer-Based Media Computer-based delivery systems have made gradual advances in the past decade. In the early 1990s, this meant delivery via floppy disk or local network (LAN); more recently, this means delivery via CD-ROM, the Internet, or an intranet. About 40 percent of all companies report using CD-ROM–based instruction “often” or “always,” compared with 60 percent using Internet or intranet delivery (Galvin 2001, 67). Taken together, however, these computer-mediated delivery systems account for only about 9 percent of all time spent in training, holding just about steady for the past four years, according to an American Society for Training and Development (ASTD) survey (Van Buren and Erskine 2002, 44). This falls far short of the prediction of 23 percent made by this same audience three years earlier. If the ASTD findings are a valid indicator, the
< previous page
page_4
next page >
< previous page
page_5
next page >
Page 5 growth rate of e-learning seems to have hit a plateau, as we pointed out in our previous report (Molenda and Sullivan, 2002). The discrepancy between the bullish talk about e-learning and its low visibility on annual surveys may also be due in part to under-reporting of technology-based learning. As is discussed further below, there is a growing acceptance of the notion of “blended learning,” the mixing of face-to-face episodes with online episodes. If a training course meets face-to-face for two days at a central facility—during which there are several videoconferences with learners at other sites—and it is preceded and followed by practical exercises and small-group projects conducted over the Internet, should a respondent classify this as conventional training or e-learning? Issue 2: Constraints on Acceptance andUse of Technology The leveling off in the growth of e-learning may indicate that corporations are still struggling to find the proper fit of high-tech delivery within their overall training program. It may also reflect some resistance on the part of trainees. Researchers at ASTD contacted some of the companies that reported declines in the use of e-learning (Van Buren 2001, 17). Several managers reported that they faced declining enrollments in e-learning courses as a result of negative experiences of learners in such courses. Islam (2002) refers to e-learning dropout rates of 70 percent and proposes that inadequate instructional design may be the culprit. He points to the expository, text-heavy, “pedagogical” approach commonly found in e-learning courses, contrasting it with the problem-based, inductive, “androgogical” approach advocated for adult learners. Another constraint is the instability of the supply of off-the-shelf products. Vendors follow different technical standards on different platforms, which may or may not fit into a company’s learning management system. Further, bankruptcies and mergers may dissipate the brand identification of known and trusted products—here today, gone tomorrow. It is enough to drive a prudent training administrator to a ‘‘wait and see” approach. During the more adventuresome times of the Internet bubble, companies were purchasing whole libraries of e-learning courses and simply dumping them into the in-basket. By 2002 they were shifting to a much more selective pay-per-use basis (Welber 2002). Because much corporate e-learning is outsourced to external vendors, it looks as though the future use of e-learning is linked to the development of the industry that supplies the courseware. This industry, even with the massive consolidation seen in 2001–2002, is still characterized by a multitude of small players. The gurus of the e-learning business anticipate that a major change is around the corner—that the technology giants, such as Oracle, SAP, IBM, and Microsoft, will eventually enter and dominate the marketplace with what buyers are looking for: one-stop, totalsolution shopping centers (Harris 2002; Schelin and Smarte 2002). In summary, indications are that e-learning is stagnating at the present time and that its future prevalence will be limited. Indeed, the plateau effect we detected a year ago is now beginning to be reflected in the literature. Van Buren and Erskine now predict that “e-learning in the typical firm will finally settle in at 20 percent of all training… butit may take some years to get there” (2002, 18). Issue 3: Challenges to Existing Paradigms Blended Learning In everyday discussion, we tend to yield to the temptation to classify learning events into discrete categories: classroom, online, self-directed, action learning, and so on. In fact, however, corporate training programs consist more and more of hybrids: face-to-face classroom interspersed with Web-based team projects; satellite videoconferences followed by small-group discussions at remote sites; on-the-job action learning plus mentoring via
< previous page
page_5
next page >
< previous page
page_6
next page >
Page 6 e-mail. The idea of combining conventional and online methods has come to be recognized as a “third path,” referred to as blended learning. Online activities offer self-pacing, standardization of information dissemination, and rapid deployment of new material; but face-to-face learning allows practice with feedback, team building, networking, and the other functions that are tied to people’s emotional responses. There is a growing consensus that the future belongs to blended approaches (Zenger and Uehlein 2001). HIGHER EDUCATION The use of technology in the higher education sector has been much less immediately affected by the external events regarding the national economy and political affairs. The downturn of the national economy in 2000–2001 led to shortfalls in state tax revenues, which led to tightening of budgets at most state-supported universities, which in turn forced cutbacks in planned upgrades or expansions of academic computing. In addition, the collapse of the dotcom bubble forced many of the vendors of high-tech software and services into mergers or insolvency and reduced the flow of capital into entrepreneurial “eduventures.” However, the tempo of change is driven much more by the dynamics of forces within colleges and universities themselves. That is, investment in new technology tends to be driven by payoffs, particularly economic payoffs. Organizations implement technology with the hope that it will increase their benefits or decrease their costs. In the case of higher education, technology has not proven to be a cost reducer in the educational side of their operations. Indeed, as long as universities are organized as they are, there is little possibility to reduce instructional costs. So technology advocates are left with the claim that benefits increase—greater numbers of students reached, students more satisfied, faculty more content or productive, and the like. This argument is not as potent at the economic one, so the pace of adoption tends to be slower than in other sectors. Issue 1: Use of Technology-BasedMedia for Delivery of Instruction Classroom Media College and university media managers continue to struggle to support both the analog media—audio- and videocassettes, slides, and overhead transparencies—still preferred by many instructors and the digital media, which are seen as the technological future. The trend seems to be to gradually reduce support for analog media and increase support for digital. The challenge is to try to achieve a level of productivity with digital media that was never possible with the analog media. Managers are seeking standardization to allow compatibility within and across departments. Standardization would allow updating and expanding of existing materials without having to start all over, as is the case with analog media. As in the corporate sector, the dream is an enterprise-wide database for all the institution’s instructional media. We reported last year (Molenda and Sullivan 2002) that the pace of faculty adoption of computer-based media appeared to be slowing. According to the Campus Computing Project (2000), the percentage of courses using Internet resources rose between 1997 and 1999 by 10 percent, 8 percent, and 6 percent, respectively; then, between 1999 and 2000, it rose by only 4 percent. The comparable figures for courses having Web pages are 5 percent, 9 percent, 6 percent, and 3 percent. This points to a possible plateauing of adoption long before reaching universality. We projected an S-shaped adoption curve, with Internet resources plateauing around 45 percent of all courses and Web pages around 35 percent. Unfortunately, the Campus Computing Project did not continue to measure these indexes in 2001, so we cannot verify our projections. The one comparable question asked in the 2001 survey was whether each institution was supporting any “full online courses”
< previous page
page_6
next page >
< previous page
page_7
next page >
Page 7 as part of their Web services. On this index, the increase from 2000 to 2001 was only 1 percent—from 55 to 56 percent of all institutions—after a 10 percent increase the previous year (Campus Computing Project 2001, 2). This is one indicator that the plateau effect continues. Distance Education By the middle of 2002, it was clear that the distance education “land rush” was definitely over. After American universities had spent more than $100 million to develop Web-based course offerings, by 2002 the landscape was littered with the dry bones of failed e-learning enterprises. For example: • New York University, Temple, and University of Maryland closed their for-profit ventures in late 2001. • The U.S. branch of the Open University of the United Kingdom closed in June 2002. • Fathom (Columbia University) and UNext (Cardean University) scaled back and changed direction to short courses for the corporate training market. • SUNY Buffalo dropped its online master’s of business administration program. • Hungry Minds, California Virtual University, and several other for-profit enterprises have been sold, scaled back, or disbanded. • National Technological University, highly successful as a nonprofit distance university, formed a for-profit venture to pursue the corporate training market; in a few years it burned through all of its resources and was purchased by Sylvan Learning Systems (Arnone 2002b). And distance education seems to be dropping off the radar screens of campus information technology chiefs. For example, in EDUCAUSE’s annual survey of top issues facing administrators, on the question of issues with “a high potential for becoming significant in the coming year,” distance education dropped from first place in 2001 to sixth place in 2002 (Kobulnicky and Rudy 2002, 10). This does not mean that the distance education movement is doomed. In fact, distance education offerings and enrollments continue to increase. However, it has become clear that distance education is not a way for a traditional institution to get rich quick. The number of institutions actually offering distance education courses and programs is difficult to pin down precisely. The last scientific survey was conducted by the U.S. Department of Education for the 1997–98 academic year. One source of estimates is an annual survey by Market Data Retrieval. Their surveys indicate a steady growth in the number of American two-year and four-year institutions that offer “some” distance education—growing from 70 to 84 percent—and those that offer online courses leading to a degree—growing from 30 to 39 percent between 2000 and 2001 (Jecusco 2002). Of course, the offering of distance programs varies greatly by type of institution. Whereas relatively fewer community colleges or small liberal-arts colleges offer such programs, about 80 percent of four-year public universities offer distance programs, with the proportion rising to nearly 90 percent for larger institutions. It is quite clear that the growth is coming from courses offered wholly or in part via the Internet. Courses offered via one-way or two-way video have tended to remain stable. So, while the big-ticket for-profit ventures have stumbled, incremental growth continues. Distance education business model. Experiences early in the decade of 2000 showed that it was difficult for “dual mode” institutions—those that offer both traditional
< previous page
page_7
next page >
< previous page
page_8
next page >
Page 8 residential programs and distance programs—to offer distance programs profitably. Proprietary institutions such as University of Phoenix (37,000 online students) and Jones International University (6,000 online students) seem to have developed a successful business model. But traditional universities are still searching for a model. The period of 2000–2001 was notable for the rush of consortium building. Many universities were concluding that only by sharing the up-front costs—such as course development and marketing—could their distance education programs hope to be economically competitive. Many consortia were formed on a statewide basis; in fact, over 30 such consortia had been formed by 2001, including Illinois Virtual Campus, Kentucky Virtual University, and SUNY Learning Network. These consortia serve primarily as portals, offering a single front door to courses and degrees at many different institutions. All three of the states cited here—Illinois, Kentucky, and New York—reported steady increases in enrollments, all growing by 70 percent or more between 2000 and 2001. With total enrollments of over 25,000, programs such as the SUNY Learning Network appear to be on the path to financial viability. Issue 2: Constraints on Acceptance and Use of Technology Faculty Acceptance Incremental growth in faculty use of digital media continues, although perhaps at a reduced rate, as indicated by the trends in the Campus Computing Project reports between 1997 and 2000. Unfortunately, this question did not appear in the 2001 survey, so it is an open issue. For most faculty users, media are still incorporated in their teaching in supplementary ways. That is, technology is used to the extent that it is consistent with conventional roles, and face-to-face courses are designed to be teacher dependent. Faculty acceptance of technology is also being affected by their involvement in distance education, and as of 2000 about 10 percent of all faculty members were teaching or had taught distance courses (Abacus Associates 2000). Because most distance education courses are taught by the same faculty who teach face-to-face courses, the faculty tend to carry their distance education habits over into the conventional classroom. Course Web pages, links to Internet resources, team work spaces, and e-mail correspondence turn out to be just as valuable for face-to-face classes as they are for distance classes. Indeed, the trend in technology application is toward hybrid courses, courses that combine some face-to-face time with online experiences; this is much the same as the trend in corporate training toward “blended learning.” One must recognize, however, that a major constraint to faculty adoption of digital technology is that such work is still generally not given weight in faculty performance reviews. There is still a widespread perception that tenure and promotion decisions give precedence to research performance, whereas effort spent on integration of technology contributes only to the “teaching” part of the portfolio (Young 2002). And because technology-based instructional development consumes more time and effort than conventional teaching, the aspiring professor is “throwing good money after bad” when working with technology. Funding Infrastructure and Support Colleges and universities continue to struggle to pay for their information technology infrastructure. In the 2000– 2001 academic year information technology costs rose a median of 11 percent over the previous year, while overall expenditures rose only about 3 percent (Olsen 2001b). The budget squeeze hits hardest at smaller colleges that are already struggling to survive in the competitive American higher education marketplace. Many smaller
< previous page
page_8
next page >
< previous page
page_9
next page >
Page 9 colleges have not yet made structural changes to their budgets to account for information technology expenditures, instead improvising from year to year, using “budget dust’’ left over in other accounts to take care of technology needs (Phipps and Wellman 2001). The Campus Computing Survey of 2001 indicates that a growing number of respondents had experienced a decline in their academic computing budget for that academic year—with 18 percent reporting decreased budgets compared with 11 percent a year earlier (Campus Computing Project 2001, 3). The situation promises to be even more grim in the near future, especially at state-supported universities. The weakened national economy has led to budget deficits for 2002–2003 in 37 states. Harsh cuts in higher education funding have already been announced in California, Wisconsin, and Tennessee (Selingo 2002). In California the cuts will mean a slowdown in the upgrading of computers and reductions in tech support (Carnevale 2002). Wireless computing. As wireless technology develops, there is some hope that wireless systems may some day replace wired systems, at a lower overall cost. Not only is this a dubious proposition, but as of 2001, only about 6 percent of college campuses were fully wireless, a gain of only 2 percent over the previous year. However, about half of all campus have some wireless LANs in operation, a 20 percent leap from the previous year (Campus Computing Project 2001, 4). The battle of the bandwidth. Bandwidth, or network capacity, is a growing concern among computing administrators (Olsen 2001a). They see demand rising sharply with no end in sight. The major culprit is student downloading of audio and video materials. Downloading music is now the leading type of student computer use, with apparently insatiable appetites for ever more music. “Downloading MP3s can account for up to 85 percent of the Internet traffic at universities, MP3 downloads can consume as much as 85 percent of a normal university network’s capacity,” according to a Northwestern University spokesman (Majerowicz 2001). And yesterday’s music downloading pales in comparison to today’s student video-streaming of pirated films. Administrators are beginning to negotiate caps on how much bandwidth the university will subsidize rather than just endlessly adding capacity (Olsen 2001a). Information technology staff. One trend that has reversed quite sharply from previous years is the difficulty of retaining the necessary staff to take care of the infrastructure. Information technology staffing showed up as one of the top two concerns of respondents to the 2001 EDUCAUSE survey (Lembke and Rudy 2001) but a year later had fallen completely off the list of major concerns (Kobulnicky and Rudy 2002). The big difference is the swelling of supply of information technologists following the dot-com collapse. Faculty support. It has taken a few years for the realization to dawn, but many colleges and universities are coming to understand that their technology investments are unlikely to have an impact on improved teaching and learning until they actively support faculty use. To carry out this mission, a new enterprise is emerging: the Teaching, Learning, and Technology Center (TLTC). Hundreds of universities now support a one-stop shopping center where faculty can go to get help preparing technology-based instruction. Typically, according to Long (2001), these TLTCs combine the services of information technology support and faculty development, sometimes adding the library. Seen in the overall context of productivity improvement, the TLTC is yet another cost of the high-tech enterprise, one that is often overlooked in the accounting. An important project for the future will be to determine whether these investments actually yield improved outputs and in that way contribute to productivity improvement.
< previous page
page_9
next page >
< previous page
page_10
next page >
Page 10 Issue 3: Challenges to Existing Paradigms “Content” as a Valuable Asset During the boom years of the dot-com mania, it became commonplace to view course materials, as they become digitized, as “content” and as a valuable commodity. Universities sought ways to commercialize the “intellectual property” that they thought they owned (although professors tended to view this differently). Publishers, who already sat on huge piles of ‘‘content,” perceived themselves as being in a good position to launch online colleges. One notable example was an online college started by Harcourt Higher Education in 2000, with a prediction of 50,000 to 100,000 enrollments within five years. It disappeared in late 2001, having attracted a total of 32 students. As Wilson (2002) points out, the company acted as though content were the essence of education, whereas it is actually just one element in the “value chain,” and probably the lowest one. Those trying to start new online colleges discover that they have to build the rest of the value chain (including administrative structures, curricular integrity, student support, faculty guidance, academic credibility, and so on), which is expensive and time consuming. In the end, probably the hardest element to attain is the prestige of the degree—something that existing institutions have spent decades, if not centuries, developing. What the entrepreneurs have learned is that information is not education. Telling is not teaching, and watching is not learning. If it were, college libraries would not need all those other buildings surrounding them on campus. Digital Materials as Ephemeral We are beginning to understand not only that digital storage media (floppy disks, CDs, etc.) are physically degradable but also that they are subject to shrinkage due to market forces. As software applications become obsolete, information stored in earlier versions become less and less accessible. As server space becomes filled, older files may be deleted or discarded when the hardware is upgraded. Even more obvious is the loss of educationally useful material on the Web. Material that is available today may disappear tomorrow because it is obsolete or not maintained by the provider or because the provider goes out of business. “Link rot” is the term that has been coined to describe this phenomenon. Markwell and Brooks (2002) have calculated the extinction rate for 500-some links embedded in three biochemistry courses for high school teachers. In the first 21 months, about 100 links had gone dead, yielding a “half-life” of 55 months for such science education links. Offerors of distance education courses that are repeated over a number of years view link rot as a real and growing problem—one more ongoing maintenance expense. The Faculty and the Traditional Classroom Paradigm Plenty of evidence indicates that educational institutions are investing more and more in technology. There is not a lot of evidence that this investment is yielding greater productivity. In the business sector, such investments took a decade to yield results, but they eventually did. However, the crucial factor was that businesses were facing the necessity to undergo reengineering of business processes for greater efficiency. That has not happened yet at most colleges and universities. The economic problem is that most distance education and other technology-based instruction continue to follow the traditional labor-intensive paradigm of 25 students engaged with a professor, who plays the roles of subject-matter expert, designer, lecturer, orchestrator of all activities, giver of feedback, and evaluator. Putting the course syllabus on the Web in a face-to-face class does nothing to decrease overall costs or to increase learning. Likewise, setting up a distance education course with one all-purpose instructor and a capped limit of 25 students is like “installing a bullet train between Philadelphia and New York but mandating that it should only carry
< previous page
page_10
next page >
< previous page
page_11
next page >
Page 11 as many passengers as a sedan could accommodate. Furthermore, it should not move beyond 65 miles per hour” (Saba 2002). Changing the paradigm in ways that would affect the roles of faculty would not be popular. In fact, faculty groups have already spoken out clearly about the need to carry over traditional practices into distance education. Resolutions to that effect were passed at the American Federation of Teachers and National Education Association conventions in the summer of 2000 and also by the Nova Scotia Teachers Union in 2001 (Carr 2001). But the tools for restructuring the teaching-learning paradigm are now at hand; successful models are readily available. The Open University has successfully served over 12,000 students per year in an online course. The University of Illinois has tripled enrollment in its foreign language courses without adding faculty by relying heavily on a new software program that automates grading of homework exercises and quizzes. Virginia Tech has lowered costs while increasing enrollments and student success in mathematics with its lab-based Math Emporium. Technical Standards Movement A development that has come rapidly to the fore is the adoption of a single, campuswide course management system (CMS). These systems are meant to provide a common user interface for both on-campus “Web-enhanced” courses and online courses. The most popular proprietary CMSs are Blackboard, WebCT, and eCollege, in that order (Jecusco 2002). The dream of users and producers alike is to arrive at a set of technical standards that would allow interoperability among all of the CMSs. Just as the popularization of videocassette players was delayed until international standards evolved, experts feel that the advent of technical standards for online learning software will remove a big obstacle to the flourishing of online learning (Arnone 2002a). Such standards are also key to the realization of the concept of reusable learning objects, a critical element of cost-effective multimedia production. K–12 EDUCATION K–12 education, too, has been affected by economic and political forces at the national level. The demise of the dotcom world and the recession, exacerbated by the events of September 11, 2001, resulted in severe decreases in state tax revenues. By early 2002, 33 states reported that spending exceeded budgeted levels, and up to 17 states had cut or anticipated cutting K–12 education funding (Gehring 2002). In Indiana alone, there were $190 million in cuts to the K–12 budget and another $280 million in delayed payments. Of that, $40 million had been designated for computer hardware and $1.7 million for professional development in technology (Zehr 2002). Enthusiastically supported by the new Bush administration, the movement toward privatization marched on as the number of charter schools grew by 14 percent and the number of privately managed public schools showed signs of growth in Philadelphia and elsewhere (Cable 2002). There was a cloud on the horizon, however, as the largest private operator of schools, Edison Schools, Inc., faced a major financial crisis, stemming in part from questions about the effectiveness of their schooling model (Henriques and Steinberg 2002). In that Edison positioned itself as a strong user of technology, a failure in the marketplace may somewhat taint the instructional technology aura. Issue 1: Use of Technology-BasedMedia for Delivery of Instruction Traditional Audiovisual Media There has been little formal research to track school use of the older technologies at the national level. Piecing together some local and regional reports, plus interviews by the authors, can provide some outlines of the larger picture:
< previous page
page_11
next page >
< previous page
page_12
next page >
Page 12 • VHS video reigns: Regional media centers indicated that more than 80 percent of all titles circulated were VHS video materials and that circulation had increased in some districts but had decreased in others. Individual regional media centers loaned between 4,300 and 29,000 videos in the most recent year, with the average being about 6,500 (INFOhio 2002; MacIntyre 2002; National Association of Media and Technology Centers 2000; Smith 2002). • In some locales, VHS video collections have been dispersed from district collections to individual schools, so circulation figures are no longer available. • Digital video approaches: Public television stations and other suppliers in Virginia, Utah, North Carolina, and Texas have committed to digital video services. ASSET in Arizona has created a statewide, publicly controlled service for distributing digital material. • The majority of the digital video distribution is in the form of streaming video provided by commercial vendors, United Learning and AIMS Media being two of the larger. • Other companies, such as Dukane and Celerity, offer a local server model for video distribution. It appears that instructional video use is in a transitional phase, with distributors experimenting with different technologies and protocols while many continue to offer titles in conventional analog format. Many have assumed that DVD use would increase as new hardware was purchased and older media became obsolete. The growth of DVD in the consumer market has been barely short of spectacular, but in the K–12 world DVDs have hardly surfaced in circulation statistics. The authors’ surveys indicate that media centers are purchasing and distributing very few DVD titles, because of both a dearth of titles in education and a lack of demand in schools. One media director commented, “$50 VCRs look like a disposable item to schools, so why switch?” Of course, VCRs may eventually go the way of 16-mm film projectors, and CD drives may eventually be replaced as well, so there will be a transition. But it will not apparently happen any sooner than required in K–12 education. There is even less evidence on which to estimate the extent of use of other traditional media. Although sample surveys sponsored by the authors have revealed that most schools still have overhead projectors and audiocassette players, it is difficult to speculate about the extent of their use. The same schools also support computer projectors and CD players. Elementary schools still keep and use record players. The authors previously reported that schools increasingly had whiteboards, replacing chalkboards (Misanchuk, Pyke, and Tuzun 1999, 3). In summary, it appears that audiovisual media in the traditional analog formats, led by videocassettes, are still widely in demand by teachers; digital versions of these media play a growing but complementary role. Computer-Based Media The computer acquisition mania in the K–12 education community appears to be waning. The E-Rate program administered by the Federal Communications Commission has led to billions of dollars being spent to connect lesswealthy schools to the Internet. More than 92 percent of all schools now have access to the Internet, and 72 percent have a high-speed connection (Market Data Retrieval 2001). The oft-cited student-to-computer ratio has improved to 4:1, and a newer measure of students to multimedia computer has reached 7:1. The ratio of students to Internet–connected computer is also 7:1 (Market Data Retrieval 2001; Skinner 2002, 60).
< previous page
page_12
next page >
< previous page
page_13
next page >
Page 13 Student Computer Use Large-scale studies of actual student uses of technology are rare. A recent survey of Wisconsin educators asked about frequency of student use of various computer resources. The results can be summarized as follows: • Used every day: productivity tools (e.g., word processing, spreadsheets). • Used once a week: online research. • Used a few times per month: simulations, e-mail communication, problem solving with real data sets, visualization tools (e.g., Inspiration). • Used seldom: integrated learning systems (e.g., Jostens, PLATO). The categories that could be considered directly instructional—simulations, problem solving, and integrated learning systems—were concentrated among the least -used applications (Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction 2001). Special uses are arising as the technology matures. One of the most intriguing areas is special education. Open captioning of video for the hearing impaired has become quite common, and children with multiple disabilities are being helped in novel ways. One example is the outfitting of children with wearable computers that are capable of speech (Bruno 2002). These uses, which provide students with functionalities beyond the scope of a teacher or textbook, appear to be uncontroversial and easily accepted. Technology as the purveyor of instruction has yet to attain the same acceptance. Equity in Access The continuing concern over equity still exists, but to a lesser degree. Schools have addressed the issue of technological discrepancies between ethnic groups, males and females, and higher and lower socioeconomic groups. Schools with high minority enrollments have 4.7 students per computer, and schools with lower minority enrollment have 3.6 students per computer (Market Data Retrieval 2001). There are still indicators that different groups may use computers in different ways. A Maryland study revealed that 87 percent of low-poverty schools used computers for students to draft, revise, and publish writing, whereas only 50 percent of high-poverty schools reported that use. Other applications that may reveal a more constructivist approach to instruction had similar differences (Maryland State Department of Education 2002). Reflecting the priorities of the new administration, cutbacks in two federal programs may slow the trend toward equity. The Community Technology Centers Program and the Technology Opportunities Program are both slated to be eliminated or drastically reduced as of this writing (Dickard 2002). The current schedule of legislation has affected a number of programs that supported technology (e.g., Star Schools), but language within the bills permits some latitude in moving funds. It remains to be seen if technology can be a magnet for funds that school administrators could spend on other categories. Issue 2: Constraints on Acceptance andUse of Technology In-Service Training The issue of teacher preparation is now center stage. A bare majority of schools (51 percent) now report that a majority of their teachers are at least at the intermediate skill level in computer use, an 11 percent increase in one year (Cable 2002). The tremendous growth in access to the Internet has only recently been accompanied by hope for a corresponding effort in staff development to prepare teachers. In 1994 only half of all teachers had had professional development activities in the area of technology (National Education
< previous page
page_13
next page >
< previous page
page_14
next page >
Page 14 Goals Panel 1994). Since then, the funds available for professional development in technology use have been fairly constant at about 5 percent of the total technology budget (CEO Forum on Education and Technology 1999). The amount spent on staff development as a percentage of school technology budgets actually decreased from 2000 to 2001 (Skinner 2002, 55). So it appears that progress is being made, but funding support still lags. Preservice Training A major issue with teacher use has been the cohort of teachers who began teaching prior to the computer era. With an annual attrition rate of nearly 20 percent, the teaching population will change quite rapidly, and newer teachers are more likely to have a high comfort level with technology. They are also increasingly likely to have taken a required course in technology as part of a teacher preparation program; 34 states now are in arrangements with accrediting agencies requiring some form of computer education. There are currently 3 million teachers, so the process of replacing teachers to gain skill in technology usage will be a massive one. Teacher Acceptance Surveys indicate that in 78 percent of all schools, a majority of teachers use computers daily (Cable 2002). But among the total teacher population, only 39 percent are using computers, indicating that teachers are less likely to use computers than the population as a whole, 66 percent of whom are reported to be computer users and 54 percent of whom have an online connection (U.S. Department of Commerce 2002, 9). In fact, the authors’ earlier sponsored research indicates that teacher use of computers was concentrated on housekeeping tasks such as attendance, record keeping, word processing, and e-mail (Misanchuk, Pyke, and Tuzun 1999), indicating that even the 39 percent of teachers who are users may well be engaged in activities that have modest instructional impact. Teachers will increasingly be drawn into involvement with technology because of the demands being placed on their students. A great majority of states now have specific academic requirements for students to demonstrate technology competencies. In Wisconsin, for example, this takes the form of ‘‘Information and Technology Literacy Standards” (Skinner 2002, 56). This “bottom-up” pressure is added to the “top-down” pressure of teacher licensure requirements. Effectiveness Claims We have previously pointed out (Molenda and Sullivan 2000, 10) that there is a history of being unable to demonstrate a statistically significant difference in student learning in “method A versus method B” research studies. There is even a work, The No Significant Difference Phenomenon (Russell 1999), dedicated to documenting the hundreds of research reports that reach the conclusion that no particular technology can, in and of itself, be viewed as causing a significant learning increase. Russell’s book has now spawned a Web site (http://teleeducation.nb.ca/nosignificantdifference/) devoted to gathering summaries of new research studies reporting results that either support or refute the “no significant difference” position. Each new year brings new claims as to the instructional effectiveness of technology or some new application of technology. It was recently announced, for example, that there is a positive impact from the use of handheld computers in the classroom (SRI International 2002). But the results concerned a teacher survey rather than any measured learner improvement. Marshall (2002) reviews many of the studies of the past five years, concluding that certain applications in certain settings can be shown to have supported learning in a quantitative sense. Some the studies reviewed by Marshall concern computer applications; others deal with video. Although the author makes many strong claims, such as “Historical
< previous page
page_14
next page >
< previous page
page_15
next page >
Page 15 evidence suggests that technology can, and did teach” (vi) and “More than 50 research studies addressing voice, video, and computer-based learning provide conclusive evidence that students can, and do, learn from educational technologies” (vi), the review fails to mention the literature documenting less-favorable results, such as Chu and Schramm’s (1968) definitive reviews of research on television in the 1960s. So the debate goes on. A cottage industry is emerging for educators and evaluators who wish to attack the use of technology in instruction. Cuban and Kirkpatrick (1998) lead a long list of people questioning the use of technology. Criticism of technology will not cease, and technology will be blamed for many of society’s ills. Indeed, the critics still attack television regularly, and a new study even claims that technology induces obesity (Lakdawalla and Philipson, 2002). Whatever one may believe, there are studies to support it. It is unlikely, then, that the research will make a significant difference in teacher practice or use of technology. There is, in fact, little evidence that teachers are ever persuaded to change their practices because of research findings. A wealth of evidence, as Heinich points out in his classic paper “The Proper Study of Instructional Technology,” indicates that teachers’ media decisions “are based on totally different factors: accessibility of materials, level of supervision required, display requirements, delivery system capability, etc.” (Heinich 1984, 83). Issue 3: Challenges to Existing Paradigms Virtual Schools After a rocky start, distance learning has apparently found a niche in K–12 education. Twelve states have established online high school programs, and five others are developing them (Trotter 2002, 16). Of course, the 40,000 to 50,000 students enrolled represent only one-tenth of 1 percent of the K–12 population. If the Florida Virtual School is typical, 37 percent of the online students are home schooled and 8 percent are in private schools, leaving very few public school students who are actually enrolled in online programs (Doherty 2002, 20). One report (Peak Group 2002) predicts that the broader market, including noncredit classes such as advanced placement review and state test preparation, is estimated to grow to over 1 million students by the 2004–2005 school year. The Perceived Value of Technology The decline in the dot-com sector is not likely to be reversed in the near future. Venture capital investment in education dropped 73 percent from 2000 to 2001, and there is no indication of any turnaround soon (Evans 2001). Without the stimulation of new capital, technology ages quickly. One consequence is the already-discussed concept of “link rot’’ or hyperlink extinction. This challenges users and suppliers alike as educators are forced to constantly review lesson plans and assignments, and Web providers are challenged to maintain all links live and safe. The ultimate impact of teachers being concerned about content is that it “puts a floor on learning [but] it can also impose a ceiling by limiting exploration and scope” (Goldman, Cole, and Syer 1999, 2). The perceived value of technology is likely to be diminished if the rate and quality of change are perceived as negative. The Personal Computer as a Concept Another area of instability is the form of the technology itself. Schools, like other consumer groups, face the constant barrage of obsolescence and innovation. A recent paper informed schools that they did not need personal computers (PCs) but rather servers and thin clients. A statement declaring that “[p]utting personal computers in the classroom is
< previous page
page_15
next page >
< previous page
page_16
next page >
Page 16 absolutely the wrong idea” (Costlow 2001) challenges the basic concepts on which the information revolution in education is based. These same issues arise with operating system software, application software, and communication infrastructure. CONCLUSIONS Limits to Growth The perception of technology adoption progressing on a steep upward slope toward universal acceptance was brought into question in these pages last year when the authors claimed that a plateau had been reached. Our contention is that the adoption of new technologies follows an S-shaped curve, with the pace slowing as the market matures and becomes saturated. Nevertheless, there is still a popular misconception, fed by commercial interests and naive boosterism, that technology is being integrated into education at an ever-increasing pace. We contend that it is not. Naive misconceptions about technology adoption are frequently based on extrapolations from two or three data points on a graph. An example is the following pronouncement reported in a journal of the software industry: “Leaders of E-Mexico claim that by 2025, 98 percent of Mexican citizens will be online” (Fredell 2002, 14). This outlandish prediction is made in face of a reality in which only one of three Mexicans owns a radio (a cheap technology that has been mass marketed for over 70 years) and only one of ten owns a telephone (the technology most people use to access the Internet). Even the slightest glance at economic realities would lead to a far more modest projection of Internet penetration. However, if you ignore the reality and just look at the Mexican Internet adoption rate—doubling from 1 percent to 2 percent between 2000 and 2001—and then project that into the future in a straight line, you can come up with a prediction as absurd as this one. The reality is that the potential for “full adoption” may vary from product to product and market to market. In the case of the Mexican Internet, it may be that the realistic upper limit of adoption may be something in the range of 25 to 30 percent. So we might see a steep upward climb in adoption in the early stages and then see the slope taper off in the middle stage and flatten at the later stages. Much of the confusion about the supposed growth of technology stems from the ever-increasing expenditures for information technology in business and education. Institutions do indeed plan for expenditure increases most years, and total expenditures for information technology increase annually. In one sense—the economic one—this is growth. However, most of these expenditures are for replacement hardware, communications, and staff. Few of the customers would describe this as growth, although vendors might, and the staff hired would. If the definition of growth is level of expenditure, there may be growth. Much of the confusion concerns the definition of growth, as well as the definition of success. The Elusive Cost Barrier The growth in the expense of information technology appears to be contrary to past precedent. We have come to expect the traditional economic model of technology whereby increased penetration leads to lower capital costs as well as increased reliability and decreased operating costs. Radio, television, telephone, and air travel followed this model, with the $1,000 threshold being the critical barrier to large-scale consumer market penetration. Information technology first followed this trend but now appears to be following a contradictory model, with costs increasing as penetration increases. In particular, software costs have increased as Microsoft and others have removed product support from products a few years old, forcing customers to constantly upgrade. Many of the software
< previous page
page_16
next page >
< previous page
page_17
next page >
Page 17 upgrades also require hardware upgrades, leading to a situation in which accounting standards are likely to change to permit a more rapid depreciation of computer equipment. In higher education, annual increases in technology fees have become as predictable as tuition increases. The cost of technology per student is apparently increasing (if one takes the annual budgetary figures at face value). Because it is increasing on a per student basis, we conclude that all factors involved in information technology combine to cost more per year. This factor is actually being studied under the guise of total cost of ownership, or TCO. TCO is a methodology of analyzing all the costs involved in an information technology implementation, from electricity to staff development. TCO seems to be increasing. Information technology complexity has apparently not diminished to the point of requiring less training for operators, and hardware reliability has not increased to the point where machines are projected to have a longer usable life. Software continues to have planned obsolescence to the point where operating systems are not supported after five or six years. The entire information technology economic model appears to be based on increasing costs at a rate greater than increases in performance. Industry has reluctantly accepted that premise. Higher education is attempting to adapt to that premise, and K–12 education is struggling to stay behind. REFERENCES Abacus Associates. (2000). A survey of traditional and distance learning higher education members. Washington DC: National Education Association. Arnone, M. (2002a, May 24). Mixing and matching distance-education software. Chronicle of Higher Education, A33– A34. Arnone, M. (2002b, March 20). Sylvan Learning Systems to acquire National Technological U. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/free/2002/03/2002032001u.htm. (Accessed March 20, 2002). Bruno, M. J. (2002, May 10). High-tech help for disabled children. Washtech.com. [Online]. Available: http://www.washingtonpost.com/articles/A62798-2002May9.html. (Accessed May 10, 2002). Cable, C. (2002, January). Positive trends abound in schools this fall. Market Data Retrieval. [Online]. Available: http://www.schooldata.com/datapoint73.html. (Accessed May 10, 2002). Campus Computing Project. (2000). The 2000 national survey of information technology in higher education: Struggling with IT staffing. The Campus Computing Project. [Online]. Available: http://www.campuscomputing.net. (Accessed April 19, 2001). ———. (2001). eCommerce comes slowly to the campus. The Campus Computing Project. [Online]. Available: http://www.campuscomputing.net/summaries/2001/index.html. (Accessed November 1, 2001). Carnevale, D. (2002, May 23). California budget cuts will bring reductions in spending for campus technology. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/free/2002/05/2002052301t.htm. (Accessed May 23, 2002). Carr, S. (2001, May 29). A teachers’ union in Canada seeks more control over distance education. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/free/2001/05/2001052902u.htm. (Accessed May 29, 2001). CEO Forum on Education and Technology. (1999). Year two school technology and readiness report. Washington DC: CEO Forum. Chu, G. C., and Schramm, W. (1968). Learning from television. Washington, DC: National Association of Educational Broadcasters. Costlow, T. (2001, February 21). Schools need servers, not PCs. EE Times. [Online]. Available: http://www.eetimes.com/story/oeg20010221s0069. (Accessed May 3, 2002). Cuban, L., and Kirkpatrick, H. (1998). Computers make kids smarter—Right? Technos 7:2, 26–31.
< previous page
page_17
next page >
< previous page
page_18
next page >
Page 18 Davis, D. D., and Polonko, K. A. (2001). Telework in the United States: Telework America Survey 2001. Telework America. [Online]. Available: http://www.telecommute.org/twa/index.htm. (Accessed April 17, 2002). Dickard, N. E. (2002, April 24). Digital-divide disconnect. Education Week, 22. Doherty, K. (2002, May 9). Students speak out . Education Week, 19–24. Evans, T. (2001). Education industry revenues top the $100 billion mark. Boston, MA: Eduventures.com. Fredell, E. (2002, May). Mexico: Moving toward a true digital economy. Upgrade, 12–15. Galvin, T. (2001, October). Industry report 2001. Training, 40–75. Gehring, J. (2002, April 24). States short $27 billion in FY 2002 revenues, report says . Education Week, 29. Goldman, S., Cole, K., and Syer, C. (1999). The technology/content dilemma. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. Harris, P. (2002, April). E-learning: A consolidation update. Training and Development, 27–33. Heinich, R. (1984). The proper study of instructional technology. Educational communications and technology journal 32:2, 67–88. Henriques, D. B., and Steinberg, J. (2002, May 14). Financial crisis for largest private operator of schools. Chicago Tribune, 11. INFOhio. (2002). Preparing Ohio area media centers for statewide resources sharing. (Proposal). Columbus, OH: INFOhio. Islam, K. A. (2002, May). Is e-learning floundering? e-learning, 22–26. Jecusco, C. (2002, January). The college technology review 2001–2002. Market Data Retrieval. [Online]. Available: http://www.schooldata.com/datapoint74.html. (Accessed May 10, 2002). Kobulnicky, P., and Rudy, J. A. (2002). Third Annual EDUCAUSE survey identifies current IT issues. EDUCAUSE Quarterly 2002:2, 8–21. Lakdawalla, D., and Philipson, T. (2002). The growth of obesity and technological change: A theoretical and empirical examination (NBER Working Paper No. w8946). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research. Lembke, R., and Rudy, J. (2001). Second annual EDUCAUSE survey identifies key IT issues. EDUCAUSE. [Online]. Available: http://www.educause.edu/issues/survey2001/report.asp. (Accessed June 8, 2001). Long, P. D. (2001, June). Trends: Technology support trio. Syllabus, 8. MacIntyre, R. (2002). E-mail communication with Michael Molenda, May 17. Majerowicz, A. (2001, October 23). IT limits mp3 download space. Daily Northwestern Online. [Online]. Available: http://www.dailynorthwestern.com/daily/issues/2001/10/23/campus/n-packeteer.shtml. (Accessed November 19, 2001). Market Data Retrieval. (2001, November 5). Federal and state funding initiatives boost technology in K–12 public schools across the nation. Market Data Retrieval. [Online]. Available: http://www.schooldata.com/pr27.html. (Accessed May 10, 2002). Markwell, J., and Brooks, D. W. (2002, May 15). Broken links: Just how rapidly do science education hyperlinks go extinct? University of Nebraska. [Online]. Available: http://www-class.unl.edu/biochem/url/broken_links.html. (Accessed May 30, 2002). Marshall, J. M. (2002). Learning with technology: Evidence that technology can, and does, support learning. Alexandria, VA: Cable in the Classroom. Maryland State Department of Education. (2002). 2001–2002 MBRT/MSDE technology inventory: Technology inventory summary. Maryland State Department of Education. [Online]. Available: http://msde2.aws.com/summary.asp. (Accessed May 24, 2002). Misanchuk, M., Pyke, J. G., and Tuzun, H. (1999). Trends and issues in educational media and technology in K–12 public schools in the United States. Instructional Media 24, 3–5.
< previous page
page_18
next page >
< previous page
page_19
next page >
Page 19 Molenda, M., and Harris, P. (2001). Issues and trends in instructional technology. In R. M. Branch and M. A. Fitzgerald (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 2001: Volume 26. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Molenda, M., and Sullivan, M. (2000). Issues and trends in instructional technology. In R. M. Branch and M. A. Fitzgerald (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 2000: Volume 25. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. ———. (2002). Issues and trends in instructional technology: Hitting the plateau. In M. A. Fitzgerald, M. Orey, and R. M. Branch (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 2002: Volume 27. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. National Association of Media and Technology Centers. (2000). 2000 NAMTC bi-annual survey totals. Cedar Rapids, IA: National Association of Media and Technology Centers. National Education Goals Panel. (1994). National education goals. Washington, DC: National Education Goals Panel. Olsen, F. (2001a, November 2). How big a “pipe?’’ Colleges struggle to provide network bandwidth. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/free/v48/i10/10a04301.htm. (Accessed October 29, 2001). ———. (2001b, October 30). Survey of colleges’ spending on IT finds overall increase, hints of a digital divide. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/free/2001/10/2001103001t.htm. (Accessed October 30, 2001). Peak Group. (2002). Virtual schools across America: Trends in K–12 online education, 2002. Los Altos, CA: Peak Group. Phipps, R. A., and Wellman, J. V. (2001). Funding the “infostructure.” Indianapolis, IN: Lumina Foundation. Russell, T. L. (1999). The no significant difference phenomenon. Raleigh, NC: North Carolina State University. Saba, F. (2002, May 3). Connecting the dots: Cost of higher education, reduced resources. Distance-Educator.com. [Online]. Available: http://www.distance-educator.com/saba/modules. (Accessed May 15, 2002). Schelin, E., and Smarte, G. (2002, April 1). Straight talk: A conversation with Hemang Dave of THINQ Learning Solutions. e-learning, 98–100. Selingo, J. (2002, April 19). States with the biggest deficits take aim at higher education. Chronicle of Higher Education. [Online]. Available: http://chronicle.com/weekly/v48/i32/32a02401.htm. (Accessed May 15, 2002). Skinner, R. A. (2002, May 9). Tracking tech trends. Education Week, pp. 53–67. Smith, J. (2002). E-mail communication with Michael Molenda, May 17. SRI International. (2002, March 6). SRI International and Palm announce findings that show positive impact of handheld computers in classrooms. News release. [Online]. Available: http://www.sri.com/news/releases/03-0602.html. (Accessed May 3, 2002). Trotter, A. (2002, May 9). E-learning goes to school. Education Week, pp. 13–18. U.S. Department of Commerce. (2002). A nation online. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Commerce. Van Buren, M. E. (2001). The 2001 ASTD state of the industry report. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development. Van Buren, M. E., and Erskine, W. (2002). ASTD state of the industry report. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development. Welber, M. (2002, January). Where we’ve been and where we’re going. e-learning, 15–17. Wilson, J. M. (2002, May). More than digital content: Long live your course. Syllabus, 12–14. Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction. (2001). 2001 school district technology survey results. Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction. [Online]. Available: http://www.dpi.state.wi.us/dpi/dlcl/imt/01disreslt.html. (Accessed May 20, 2002).
< previous page
page_19
next page >
< previous page
page_20
next page >
Page 20 Young, J. R. (2002, February 22). Ever so slowly, colleges start to count work with technology in tenure decisions. Chronicle of Higher Education, A25–A27. Zehr, M. A. (2002, April 17). Indiana schools cutting back as economic realities hit home. Education Week, 22. Zenger, J., and Uehlein, C. (2001, August). Why blended will win. Training and Development, 54–60.
< previous page
page_20
next page >
< previous page
page_21
next page >
Page 21 A Content Analysis of Women’s Contributions to the Leading Instructional Technology Journals, 1995– 2000 Anne L. Foley Education Department University of Massachusetts Dartmouth Janet Morgan Instructional Design, Development, and Evaluation Syracuse University INTRODUCTION This study uses a content analysis to develop themes of the articles written by women in the leading instructional and educational technology journals between 1995 and 2000. A previous study of journal literature (Foley, Keener, and Branch 1994) examined women’s contributions to the literature from 1988 to 1992. This study provides a comparison of current findings to the trends and issues identified by Ely (1996), Molenda, Russell, and Smaldino (1998), and Foley, Keener, and Branch (1994). The current analysis adapted methods and categories comparable to Ely’s ongoing analyses of the literature of the field (Ely, Foley, Freeman, and Scheel 1992; Ely 1996). This study takes a critical look at these articles from a feminist perspective as a way to determine the status of gender issues being addressed by women in the educational and instructional technology field. RATIONALE A rationale for investigating women’s contributions to the literature in educational and instructional technology comes from several sources. Molenda (1996, 38, 40) describes an agenda for research in the field to “determine where the knowledge gaps are” and calls for an examination of the “adequacy of journals and periodicals” as a means of describing communication within the profession. In addition, Molenda calls for an examination of external forces that influence the field. Specifically, he asks, “What societal forces are affecting the profession? What are the forces that assist or impede the appropriate adoption of technology in education?’’ (41). A rationale for examining the contributions of women to the literature of the field cites a broad examination of societal forces that influence the profession, including gender issues emanating within a patriarchal society. In addition, feminists raise questions as to our interpretations of what is “appropriate” in the adoption of technology in education and how our design of media affects the messages sent to women in the field. The authors’ personal experiences in higher education and in the educational technology field have yielded real concerns in terms of how or if women’s perspectives are incorporated into the field. Most articles, books, and literature in the field to which instructional design students are exposed continue to be written by men from a clearly masculinist perspective. That the field has the potential to change is evidenced by the introduction of texts by women (Driscoll 1994, 1998; Seels and Glasgow 1990; Seels and Richey 1994; Smith and Ragan 1999) used in one of our foundational instructional design courses.
< previous page
page_21
next page >
< previous page
page_22
next page >
Page 22 A Focus on Women’s Contributions There are valid reasons for a study of the field to include a focus specifically on women’s contributions. As is documented in recent statistics, teaching is (still) a female-dominated profession. Findings from the 1993–1994 survey by the National Center for Education Statistics show that 73 percent of teachers in public K–12 education and 75 percent of teachers in private K–12 education are women (National Center for Education Statistics 2001). Ely (1996) states, “There is an insistence that teachers must become technologically literate.” As noted in both Ely (1996) and Molenda (1998), computers are pervasive in education settings, and educational technology is seen as a “major vehicle for educational reform” (Ely 1996, 25). Women, then, are potentially prime purveyors of the educational and instructional technology literature as it relates to K–12 education. As Knupfer (1997, 32) argues, “The fact is that the field of instructional design has been shaped by male influences for many years, and it will take many years to correct some of the inequitable practices that have resulted within a social system that perpetuates gender bias.’’ Knupfer expresses concern over the preparation of instructional designers and “teachers they train, who will not have an opportunity to examine [feminist] issues during their education, and to those who are influenced by these men’s recommendations for instructional practice whether directly or through the literature” (32). In their article on gender and curriculum, Bryson and de Castell (1995, 38) concur that technology is “pregendered” from a masculine stance and add that this works to disempower women by leaving “the gender of technology intact and [operating] in different ways on the regenderment of women.” They also observe that although it has not often been documented, “Women are usually involved significantly in the development and/or early uses of technologies and then squeezed out of the picture as ‘expertise’ coalesces around male technocrats” (22). They note that the technologies most often designed for or accessible to women tend to “reify and produce gender effects…which consolidate already inequitable class and race positionings” (22–23). An examination of multimedia by Henderson (1996, 87) mentions the “inclusions and exclusions that act in the interests of particular cultural, class and gendered groups” inherent in media design and that are derived from the unique perspectives of each designer. She cites the competitive, violent nature of computer gaming software and inequitable access to technology that “shape symbolic and material culture…. [And in] turn this molds the larger conceptual view of reality” (87). Henderson cites the need to include members of the various “minority groups” on design teams in order to develop a “multiple cultural” perspective (101). However, Damarin (1994, 34) notes that conservative groups have usurped the “radical” stance on equity as another “opportunity to capitalize upon ‘human resources’ from a larger pool of individuals” and sees technology as a tool for incorporating knowledge from “societal subgroups“ rather than as a tool for empowerment. From a feminist stance, Damarin discusses the qualities of equity and caring in relation to educational technology. She asks whether educational technology can function within an ethic of care from its “anti-ethical position” and responds, “the answer is ‘Maybe, and only with great effort’ ” (37). Reflections on Previous Studies In Ely’s most recent analysis of the publications in the field, he (1996) has identified eight trends, including the pervasive use of computers in education, networking as one of the fastest applications of technology, increased advocacy for the use of educational technology, increasing availability of computers outside of schools, educational technology as a vehicle for education reform, and the need for teachers to become technologically literate. Molenda, Russell, and Smaldino (1998) identified 10 key issues from their analysis of the literature of the field. The four most relevant to this analysis are the incorporation of computer- and telecommunications-based media into instruction, acceptance and support of educational technology, applications of interactive technologies, and restructuring of basic organizational processes. A previous analysis of the content of articles written by
< previous page
page_22
next page >
< previous page
page_23
next page >
Page 23 women (Foley, Keener, and Branch 1994) revealed that most articles concerned computers (11 percent), computerassisted instruction (5 percent), and the nonspecific category of design and development (8 percent). Only 2 percent of all the articles written by women in the same period addressed gender issues. The fact that so few women in the field were writing about gender raised the question concerning “the experiences of women attempting to publish in the field of instructional technology” (Foley, Keener, and Branch 1994, 59). METHODOLOGY AND LIMITATIONS Major Research Questions Two questions guided this current study: • What topics are women writing about in leading educational technology journals? • Are women in the field of instructional technology addressing issues of gender in the field? Journal Selection Selection of seven journals for inclusion in this analysis were based on Ely’s (1999) identification of those publications read by educational technologists. Six of the seven journals are cited as leading educational technology journals for publishing in the field (Price and Maushak 2000); Innovations in Education and Training is not included in that list. The seven journals included in this analysis are British Journal of Educational Technology, Educational Technology, Educational Technology Research and Development, Innovations in Education and Training International, Journal of Research on Computing in Education, Learning and Leading with Technology (formerly published as Computing Teacher ), and TechTrends. Analysis was conducted in these journals over a six-year period, 1995 to 2000. Author Identification Determination of an author’s gender was based on analysis of the first name of one of the first two authors. Some journals provided pictures of the primary authors or brief biographies that often included a feminine or masculine pronoun. Difficulties arose when authors were identified by first initials only and for those European names that are typically used by either women or men (Robin, Leslie, Lyn, etc.). Because neither of the coders were familiar with Asian, Arabic, Indian, and some European names, a list of unfamiliar names was distributed to colleagues from these geographic areas for further identification. For those cases in which gender could not be determined for first or second author, the article was not included in the analysis. Content Analysis This study employed a content analysis methodology based on previous studies by Ely, Foley, Freeman, and Scheel (1992) and Foley, Keener, and Branch (1994). The process of content analysis involved 1) identifying the total number of articles each year, excluding regularly published columns and editorials; 2) ascertaining the number of articles written by women as either first or second author; 3) describing the content of the article by two coders independently using the content categories shown in figure 1; and 4) determining final category placement through a negotiated dialogic process. Both coders, the authors of the present work, are experienced instructional designers. The coders examined each article authored by women and identified a category that best described the focus of the article. Whenever possible, the coders used the author’s words
< previous page
page_23
next page >
< previous page
page_24
next page >
Page 24 Figure 1. Categories for Content Analysis (with Total Number of Articles by Women Written on Each Topic) The Field (1) Status (11) History (3) Definitions (3) Legal Aspects (1) Standards (1) Future 0 Ethics 0 Personnel Professional Education 0 Roles & Responsibilities 0 Leadership Qualities 0 Individuals of Note 0 Management Implementation (14) Diffusion/Dissemination (8) Logistics/Operations (4) Planning Processes (2) Organization (1) Education Policy (1) Facilities (1) Policies (1) Finance/Budget 0 Technology (Technical Developments) Multimedia (35) Computer Software (27) Telecommunications (21) Computer Assisted Instruction (19) Hypermedia (11) Games/Simulations (10) Computer Related(Use) (10) Computer Networks (10) Video (6) Web Based Instruction (5) Virtual Reality (4) Television (4) Authoring Tools (2) Programming (2) Tutorials (1) Electronic Classrooms (1) Audio/Radio 0 Media 0 Instructional Processes & Services Distance Education (49) Expert Systems (17) Course Development (16) Assessment (12) Interactive Learning (9) Problem Solving (7) Product Evaluation (7) Product Development (6) Motivation Strategies (5) Formative Evaluation (5) Message Design (5) Curriculum Development (4*) Program Development (3) Process Evaluation (2) Program Evaluation (2) Cost Effectiveness (1) Learner characteristics (1) Needs Assessment (1) Task Analysis 0 Drill& Practice 0 Design & Development (1) Instructional Strategies (34) Learning Strategies (12) Context (1) Objectives (1) Cooperative Groups (1) Cooperative Learning (1) Front End Analysis 0 Content 0 Media Selection 0 Services(1) Student Services (4)
Learning Styles (2) Information Services (1) Curriculum Support 0 Skills Instruction 0 Society & Culture (1) Gender Issues (11) Multicultural Issues (10) Minority Issues (3) Research & Theory Research Theory (7) Model Construction (6) Application (6) Cognitive Theory (4) Constructivism (3) Research Methodologies (2) Case Studies (1) Behavioral Theory 0 Humanistic Theory 0 Proposals 0 New Categories WWW-Internet (40) Integration of Technology in Education (32) Effects of Technology (30) Teacher Education (29) Professional Development (26) Attitudes (11) Change (7) Education K-12 (6) Continuing Education (6) Computer Literacy (4) Performance Technology (4) Collaboration (3) Visual Literacy (3) Training (2) International Programs (2) Academic Achievement (2) Quality Control (1) Communication (1) Integrated Learning Systems (1) Ergonimics (1) Situated Learning (1) Anxiety (1) Instructional Systems Design (1) Adult Education 0 Library/Media Centers 0 Interpersonal Skills 0 *An additional 295 articles by women authors on the topic of curriculum development appeared in Learning and Leading with Technology and were not included in the present analysis. to assign a content category. In cases where different words described the same thing (i.e., computer-assisted instruction, computer-based instruction), one category was created for both (in this case, computer-assisted instruction). For the topics minority issues and multicultural issues, the separate categories were maintained and articles were counted in the category based on the author’s use of language. After independent coding, the coders negotiated differences in selection of category, making a case for one or the other or collaboratively choosing an alternate category that satisfied both coders. Because negotiation was an essential part of the process, analysis had to be conducted in a timely fashion. Articles had to be independently coded and discussed within a short working period so
< previous page
page_24
next page >
< previous page
page_25
next page >
Page 25 that the coders could remain familiar with the content of each article during negotiations. One difficulty in determining category arose when addressing process or product over context; for this, coders chose the focus determined by the authors when assigning categories. Finally, because the purpose of this study was to determine if women are writing about women’s issues in the field, gender was a primary category regardless of context. FINDINGS This study examined 993 articles published by women as first or second authors between the years 1995 and 2000 in the seven journals included in this study, 55 percent of the total articles published by these journals within this time frame (Foley and Morgan 2001). Two of the journals included in this study, British Journal of Educational Technology and Innovations in Education and Training, are published internationally, although no differences were noted in their content from those published in the United States. All of the journals included in the study except one had a research focus. Learning and Leading with Technology, the exception, is oriented to the K–12 education practitioner. This journal was unique in another feature—it published more than 600 articles in the six-year period of this study, nearly one-third of the total number of articles (1,809). Of the articles written by women in Learning and Leading with Technology, 295 were in the category of curriculum development. Because it was felt that this inordinate number of articles in one category from one journal would skew the findings, this number was not included in the final content analysis. The predominance of female teachers in public and private schools (National Center for Educational Statistics 2001) may account for the predominance of women authors publishing in this practitioner-oriented journal. Clearly, there is a difference between research- and practitioner-based journals both in terms of quantity of articles published, the gender of the primary authors, and the content of the articles they wrote. An examination of the content analysis was done on two levels. Categories were sequenced by the number of articles found in each category. The most frequent content categories and journals in which they were published are shown in table 1 in order from most to least number of articles. Further analysis clustered individual categories together into the themes found in table 2. Comparison of Findings This study found that computers and technology are clearly the most frequently addressed topics by women writing in the field. Technology is addressed on several levels: development (software, multimedia), implementation (distance education and instructional strategies), and preparation (continuing education, teacher education, and professional development). This makes intuitive sense, as technology addresses the main focus of research in the field. More specifically, women also wrote about computer networking and applications of technology, the World Wide Web and the Internet, telecommunications, multimedia, and hypermedia. In addition, much of the content of the literature in this study focused on the uses of technology to deliver instruction, specifically in the development of distance education as a means to effectively reach a wider audience of learners. In agreement with Ely’s (1996) findings, women in this study are writing about the need for more training and education in the use of technology, as evidenced by the numbers of articles on professional development, teacher education, and continuing education. Many of the articles in this study addressed the integration of technology in classrooms and curriculum, specifically computer-assisted instruction, Web-based instruction, and the use of expert systems. Similar to Molenda, Russell, and Smaldino’s findings (1998), the women in this study addressed how best to instruct students, with a focus on authentic, learner-centered activities, instructional strategies that support active and interactive learning, problem solving, and diverse learner styles and learning strategies. Women in this study addressed the integration of technology in education and the effects of technology as a way of moving education reform and meeting current needs for reaching teaching and learning standards.
< previous page
page_25
next page >
< previous page
page_26
next page >
Page 26 Table 1. Categories with 10 or More Articles by Women in the Leading Journals Journal Titles/Categories BJ ET ETRD IE JR LL TT Total Distance Education 5 9 5 4 3 6 17 49 WWW-Internet 2 10 9 2 4 6 7 40 Multimedia 5 3 5 7 9 2 4 35 Instructional Strategies 5 2 16 10 1 34 Integration of Tech. in Ed. 4 2 6 6 14 32 Effects of Tech. 8 5 1 3 3 7 3 30 Teacher Ed. 2 3 1 1 12 1 9 29 Software 1 3 3 1 10 7 2 27 Professional Development 3 2 13 2 4 2 26 Telecommunications 2 3 2 4 5 2 3 21 CAI 6 4 3 6 19 Expert Systems 5 7 1 1 1 2 17 Course Development 2 3 3 1 7 16 Implementation 1 1 5 1 4 2 14 Assessment 8 4 12 Learning Strategies 1 4 7 12 Status 2 5 1 3 11 Hypermedia 2 2 2 4 1 11 Gender Issues 4 6 1 11 Attitudes 3 8 11 Computer Related (use) 1 1 1 6 1 10 Simulations 3 4 2 1 10 Multicultural 3 3 2 1 1 10 Computer Networks 2 1 2 4 1 10 Note. BJ = British Journal of Educational Technology; ET = Educational Technology; ETRD = Educational Technology Research and Design; IE = Innovations in Education and Training; JR = Journal of Research on Computing in Education; LL = Learning and Leading with Technology; TT = TechTrends Questions Arising from the Findings Contrary to the findings of Molenda, Russell, and Smaldino (1998), articles by women in this study rarely addressed policy or advocacy in the use of technology, nor did they focus on management issues. An examination of the roles of women in the field may explain this lack of focus. How many women are in management and administrative positions where policy is addressed? The women in this study rarely cited instructional systems design or research paradigms, methodology, or theory. Are women’s articles more practitioner focused than men’s? How does the lack of articles on policy or management reflect the discriminatory notion that women are not suited to abstract thinking? This study revealed no articles addressing the role of computers or technology in homes or commu-
< previous page
page_26
next page >
< previous page
page_27
next page >
Page 27 Table 2. Themes by Percentages % Major Themes 25% Technology-Software, Media, Internet 24% Instructional Delivery Systems 15% Training and Education
of Articles Including Within-Theme Categories Within Theme Categories (WWW, Telecommunication, Computer Software, Games/Simulations, Multi/Hypermedia, Computer Networks) (Distance Education, Expert Systems, Computer Use, CAI/CBI, Instructional Strategies, Interactive Learning) (Integration of Technology in Education, Teacher Education, Professional Development) 10% Design, Development, and (Course Development, Assessment) Evaluation 8% Society and Culture (Effects of Technology, Gender Issues, Multicultural Issues) 5% Learners and Learning (Attitudes) 4% Utilization Processes (Implementation, Diffusion/Dissemination) 3.7%Research and Theory 3% The Field (Status) 1.4%Management nities. Is this a counter-reaction to women’s traditional place in the home and community and outside of the professional technological arena? Unlike the findings from the previous study, this study showed no strong focus on authentic assessment, although there were articles that addressed assessment in general. There were several surprising omissions found in the content analysis of these articles. Unlike Ely’s and Molenda’s previous studies, the articles analyzed here did not address the more traditional audiovisual media. Is it possible that as the media has become more pervasive, there is a tendency toward its unquestioned acceptance, much like the pervasive hum of electricity that incorporates our lives? Does technological convenience transform into technological necessity and therefore it no longer needs to be discussed? Can we imagine life before technology and what we have given up as well as gained since its introduction? Women tended to write about technology as a goal (product) rather than as a means to an end (process). There was no consideration of what that difference might entail but rather an acceptance of the product as something unquestionably good. These articles tended to describe technology with an uncritical gaze, without reflection on theo-
< previous page
page_27
next page >
< previous page Page 28 Figure 2. Comparison of Trends Ely (1996)
Molenda,Russell, & Smaldino (1998) • Computers are pervasive in schools and • Computer-based media has higher education institutions. Virtually every been into the instructional student in a formal education setting has mainstream. access to a computer. • Networking is one of the fastest growing • Telecommunications-based applications of technology in education. media has been incorporated into the instructional mainstream. • Access to television resources in the • Traditional audiovisual media school is almost universal. has been incorporated into the instructional mainstream. • Advocacy for the use of educational • There has been greater technology has increased among policy acceptance and support of the groups. concept of educational technology. • Educational technology is increasingly • The home is seen as locus of available in homes and community settings. technology-based learning. • New delivery systems for educational technology applications have grown in geometric proportions.
< previous page
next page >
page_28 Women's Contributions
• Computer software, interactive media, and the internet are pervasive themes. • Instructional delivery systems, including distance education and computer assisted instruction are predominant topics. • A few articles written about the uses of television and video.
• Articles frequently address the integration of technology in education, effects of technology on our learning, and professional development. • The effects of technology on society and culture, our every day lives were of concern. • There is greater application of • There is a focus on cutting edge advanced interactive technology and media, hypermedia, technologies (multi-media, multimedia, virtual reality, and the hypermedia, virtual reality). Internet.
page_28
next page >
< previous page Page 29 Ely (1996)
next page >
page_29 Molenda, Russell, & Smaldino (1998)
Women’s Contributions
• Educational technology is • Training and professional education are seen as perceived as a major vehicle in the ways to implement the change process. movement toward education reform. • There is a new insistence that • There is much focus on teacher preparation and teachers must become professional development initiatives in the use and technologically literate. integration of technology. • • There has been a • restructuring/reengineering of basic organizational processes. • • Paradigms and procedures • There is a much greater focus on implementation for instructional systems of media than development of research models and design are being updated. paradigms. • • There is growing interest in• Instructional delivery systems including learner-centered, inquiryinstructional strategies, learner strategies, learning based instruction. styles and interactive learning were frequently cited. • • There is a commitment to • Course and curriculum design, development, and increasingly authentic evaluation with a focus on implementation assessment. predominate the literature.
< previous page
page_29
next page >
< previous page
page_30
next page >
Page 30 retical frameworks or critiques. Figure 2 compares the trends found in Ely (1996), Molenda, Russell, and Smaldino (1998), and the current study. CONCLUSION We are concerned by the dearth of some topics in these articles. The statements of concern voiced by many feminists as to the gender inequities in the field were not reflected in the content of articles included in this study. Only 11 of the articles (1.5 percent) during the six-year period focused on gender issues. Comparing this figure to Foley’s previous findings of 2 percent (Foley, Keener, and Branch 1994), there is no real change and in fact a slight decrease in the percentage of articles regarding gender issues. As can be seen in table 1, most of the articles addressing gender issues were published in Journal of Research in Computing (6) and Educational Technology (4). Curiously, a quantitative analysis of these same journals within the same time frame found that Educational Technology had the overall lowest annual mean percentage of articles published by women (38 percent) (Foley and Morgan 2001). Nonetheless, others (Bryson and de Castell 1995; Damarin 1994; Henderson 1996; Knupfer 1997) are writing about gender bias and the design and applications of technology, indicating the gender issues that for some are not resolved in the field. Questions arise as to why this is not a more pervasive theme of women’s contributions to the literature in the publications identified as the leading journals in the educational and instructional technology field. If women are not writing about gender issues (typically seen as a woman’s problems), who is? If not in these leading journals in the field, where are gender issues being raised in relation to technology? Are they being raised at all? Why are women (still) not writing about gender and technology in the leading journals of the field? Is it an unacceptable topic for publication in journals? Is it threatening to a future career in educational and instructional technology to have a gender citation on a vita? Returning to the questions raised by Molenda (1996, 41) in his agenda: Why is gender not addressed as part of the “societal forces that affect the profession” in a patriarchal society and historically masculine field? How can gender help define the “appropriate adoption of technology in education’’ as well as the forces that assist or impede adoption? That the above questions were not found to be addressed in the content of articles included in this analysis of the literature certainly points to a gap of knowledge that needs to be addressed in the field. Although in general, gender issues are seen to be part of women’s domain of concerns, based on our findings only a few women in the educational and instructional technology field have shown interest in further developing our awareness of these issues. REFERENCES Bryson, M., and de Castell, S. (1995). So we’ve got a chip on our shoulder! Sexing the texts of “educational technology.” In J. Gaskell and J. Willinsky (eds.), Gender in/forms curriculum: From enrichment to transformation. New York: Teachers College Press. Damarin, S. K. (1994). Equity, caring, and beyond: Can feminist ethics inform educational technology? Educational Technology 34:2, 34–39. Driscoll, M. P. (1994). Psychology of learning for instruction. Boston: Allyn and Bacon. ———. (1998) . Web-based training: Using technology to design adult learning experiences. San Francisco: JosseyBass/Pfeiffer. Ely, D. P. (1999). The field of educational technology: Update 1997. In R. M. Branch and M. A. Fitzgerald (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 1999: Volume 24. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Ely, D. P. (1996). Trends in educational technology 1995. (Report No. ISBN-0-937597-40-6). Syracuse, NY: Information Resources Publications, Syracuse University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 396 717) Ely, D. P., Foley, A. L., Freeman, W., and Scheel, N. (1992). Trends in educational technology. Syracuse, NY: ERIC Clearinghouse on Information.
< previous page
page_30
next page >
< previous page
page_31
next page >
Page 31 Foley, A. L., Keener, P. G., and Branch, R. C. (1994). Women’s contributions to instructional technology journals. Educational Technology Research and Development 42:2, 55–62. Foley, A. L., and Morgan, J. (2001, October). Women’s contributions to the leading journals in instructional technology, 1995–2000. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Association for Educational Communication and Technology, Atlanta, GA. Henderson, L. (1996). Instructional design of interactive multimedia: A cultural critique. Educational Technology Research and Design 44:40, 85–104. Knupfer, N. N. (1997). Gendered by design. Educational Technology 37:2, 31–37. Molenda, M. H. (1996). An agenda for research on the educational media and technology profession. In D. P. Ely and B. B. Minor (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 1996: Volume 21. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Molenda, M. H., Russell, J. D., and Smaldino, S. (1998). Trends in media and technology in education and training. In R. M. Branch and M. A. Fitzgerald (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 1998: Volume 23. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. National Center for Education Statistics. (2001). NCES fast facts. [Online]. Available: http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/. (Accessed December 3, 2002). Price, R. V., and Maushak, N. J. (2000). Publishing in the field of educational technology: Getting started. Educational Technology 40:6, 47–52. Seels, B., and Glasgow, Z. (1990). Exercises in instructional design. Columbus, OH: Merrill. Seels, B. B., and Richey, R. C. (1994). Instructional technology: The definition and domains of the field. Washington, DC: Association for Educational Communications and Technology. Smith P. C., and Ragan, T. J. (1999). Instructional design. New York: Macmillan.
< previous page
page_31
next page >
< previous page
page_32
next page >
Page 32 Developing Science Education Materials via Computer-Based Support Susan McKenney OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY Exploring the computer’s potential supportive role in curriculum development has been included in various research agendas in the last decade, especially within the Faculty of Educational Science and Technology at the University of Twente in the Netherlands. From 1996 to 2001, this organization’s Department of Curriculum conducted a development research study entitled CASCADE-SEA (computer assisted curriculum analysis, design and evaluation for science education in Africa). The CASCADE-SEA project aimed to learn more about how electronic performance support systems (EPSSs) can contribute to curriculum development and the professional development of teachers in the domains of science and mathematics education. In particular, this study investigated ways of offering support to African science and mathematics teachers creating exemplary lesson materials for classroom use. This report describes the study’s origins, its research approach, and the results of the investigation. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK The CASCADE-SEA study was rooted in the notion that teacher professional development and curriculum development occur simultaneously, even synergistically. It aimed to support such development at a practical crossroads: the creation of exemplary lesson materials. Reflective practice has long held a place in the domain of professional development and is considered by many to be a key ingredient in in-service education (Fullan 1991; Loucks-Horsley, Hewson, Love, and Stiles 1998). By reflecting on one’s own ideas regarding good teaching practice and making those thoughts explicit for others (for example, in the form of exemplary teacher guides), teacher development takes place. When teachers use exemplary lesson materials to inspire, support, or improve their daily practice, curriculum development occurs. Particularly in developing nations, such lesson materials play a crucial role in curriculum development (de Feiter, Vonk, and Van den Akker 1995; McKenney and Van den Akker 1998). Whereas some countries are engaged in replacing out-dated or irrelevant materials, others strive to fill a profound void of teaching resources. Many countries in this region (Zimbabwe, Tanzania, Namibia, and the Republic of South Africa, to name a few) use regional resource centers to support teachers’ professional development. In most cases, such centers are staffed with specially trained teachers who are responsible for in-service activities. Often, these facilitator teachers coordinate regional projects, including the development of lesson plans and classroom materials. The notion of engaging teachers in materials development as an effective form of in-service is widely advocated (Ball and Cohen 1996; Ben-Peretz 1990; de Feiter, Vonk, and Van den Akker, 1995). And it is this practice that the CASCADE-SEA study aimed to support, via the computer. Previous exploration into the computer’s potential for offering added value to curriculum development produced promising results (Nieveen 1997), particularly with regard to the creation of classroom materials (Nieveen and Van den Akker 1999). CASCADE-SEA built on existing knowledge in this domain. It aimed to learn more about the characteristics of an EPSS that would support facilitator teachers engaged in the process of creating exemplary teacher guides. Simultaneously, this program was designed to promote
< previous page
page_32
next page >
< previous page
page_33
next page >
Page 33 the professional development of its users and advance curriculum implementation within the realm of secondarylevel science and mathematics education in southern Africa. RESEARCH DESIGN The CASCADE-SEA study was shaped by the pursuit of answers to the following main research question: What are the characteristics of a valid and practical support tool that has the potential to impact the performance of (resource) teachers in the creation of exemplary lesson materials for secondary-level science and mathematics education in southern Africa? The quality aspects that are central to this question were carefully defined, as illustrated below: • Validity. The system should include “state-of-the-art knowledge” and should be internally consistent. • Practicality. The system should meet the needs, wishes, and contextual constraints of the members of the target group. • Impact potential. The system should positively influence the curriculum development efforts of the target group and positively contribute to the professional development of its users. Inquiry into the supportive role of the computer in the creation of locally relevant and useful classroom materials took place through a development research approach. Seels and Richey (1994, 127) define this as “the systematic study of designing, developing and evaluating instructional programs, processes and products that must meet the criteria of internal consistency and effectiveness.” For additional information regarding this approach, refer to Richey and Nelson (1996), Van den Akker (1999), and Reeves (2000). The study took place in three main phases. The initial, analysis phase aimed to obtain a working knowledge of the target setting, user group, and areas in which a support tool could be used. Previous exploration into computer-based support for curriculum developers at the Dutch National Institute for Curriculum Development (SLO) yielded a tool (CASCADE) that served as a springboard throughout this study, especially in this analysis stage. For detailed information on this research, see Nieveen (1997). This phase consisted of two main cycles. Beginning with a study of relevant literature and interviews with experts and professional curriculum developers, the analysis phase culminated in visits to various curriculum development and teacher development programs in southern Africa. During the visits, an English version of the CASCADE tool (designed for the SLO) and initial analysis findings were presented to expert and user groups who were involved in materials development as part of an inservice scenario. They offered feedback in the form of initial design ideas, as well as tentative suggestions for future cooperative activities. The bulk of the research activities took place during the design and development phase, which relied heavily on the cooperation of these same (and other) institutions and individuals. Through iterative cycles of design, development, and prototype evaluation, the CASCADE-SEA tool evolved. The main criteria on which these (four) prototypes were evaluated during the design and development phase were validity and practicality. Finally, the end evaluation phase of this study explored the potential impact of the CASCADE-SEA system in terms of (potential) contributions to teacher development and curriculum development as a result of its use. This phase may best be described as “semi-summative” in nature. This is because the end evaluation mainly possessed characteristics of summative evaluation (in particular, the aim) but maintained a number of formative evaluation elements as well. Across the three phases of research, four basic strategies were employed: screening, expert appraisal, microevaluation, and tryout (see Nieveen 1997). The developers conduct a screening, which involves a comparison of that which has been developed and the initially defined desired characteristics. In an expert appraisal, experts are solicited for feedback
< previous page
page_33
next page >
< previous page
page_34
next page >
Page 34 on that which has been developed. The micro-evaluation strategy is used to evaluate prototypes with small groups of users or experts, usually trialled outside of the intended (or target) setting. Finally, during the tryout, the evaluand is tested by the target group in the target setting. In each of the three main phases of this study, two or three of the strategies were applied, as illustrated in figure 1. The figure is organized by phase, cycle, and circuit. The analysis and evaluation phases contained two cycles, and the design phase contained four cycles. Each cycle consisted of various circuits, involving different groups of actors (some more than once). These circuit descriptions are denoted by numbered sequence, group name, and (if applicable) that group’s participation number (e.g., NL2 refers to the second cycle in which the Dutch expert group participated). ABOUT THE PROGRAM Throughout its development, the CASCADE-SEA program evolved through four prototypes and a final version. During this evolution, two main kinds of changes took place. Each prototype aimed at learning more about a specific aspect or area of curriculum development (in this case, science education materials design); at the same time, fine-tuning design specifications for the program as a whole was also on the agenda. For example, the first prototype showed a general structure for integrating the processes of analysis, design, and evaluation. It also mapped out some of the anticipated forms of support that would be elaborated in later versions. The second prototype took one subcomponent (building individual lessons) and elaborated it in such a fashion that the sub-program could function independently of the “mother’’ program (first prototype). The third and fourth prototypes added further phases of materials development (rationale and analysis, respectively) while also attempting to integrate general design guidelines that had been generated in previous cycles of evaluation. The final version of CASCADE-SEA consists of two main elements: a CD-ROM (or 16 diskettes) and a Web site. Although the number of CASCADE-SEA users with Internet access is rapidly increasing, many still work with the system in an off-line setting. For this reason, the Web site is a supplement to the main program. It supports that to which the Internet is extremely well suited: communication. Whereas the CD-ROM aids the materials designer in making personal decisions about how to create a series of lesson plans (a teacher guide), the Web site aims to foster communication between materials designers. This is done through various means, especially a discussion forum and a shared database. The database contains a variety of completed lesson plans as well as building blocks for materials (clip art, activity ideas, etc.), which visitors are free to use. They are also encouraged to contribute any similar resources for biology, chemistry, physics, or mathematics. Figure 2 shows a snapshot of the CASCADE-SEA Web site from the database browse page. The CASCADE-SEA CD-ROM aims to support those groups and individuals involved in the process of creating exemplary lesson materials or teacher guides, usually to be shared among colleagues in the same region. Toward that end, the program asks the users to consider what they would like to achieve (why they are making materials, and what kinds of materials would be useful for that particular setting). If the developer already has a basic rationale in mind, then the computer helps to make this explicit and generates a “rationale profile” that may then be used in discussion with codevelopers. Should the users have difficulty determining key issues related to the materials they are about to develop, then CASCADE-SEA will recommend that the analysis section be visited. In the analysis portion of the program, support is offered in conducting a materials needs and context analysis, which (when completed) will then aid in forming a rationale. Once the user has generated sufficient specifications regarding the kind(s) of materials to be developed, the design phase supports the creation of these materials. It helps the user map out a lesson series, build individual lessons, and think about the layout, form, and style to be applied. For users who have completed some of the development (ranging from rationale formation to a complete lesson series), support is also available for conducting a formative
< previous page
page_34
next page >
< previous page
page_35
next page >
Page 35 Figure 1. Activity Overview
* = Carried out completely or in part by someone other than the primary researcher/ developer. Note. Strategies: DS = developer screening; EA = expert appraisal; ME micro-evaluation; TO = tryout. Users: PS = preservice teachers; IS in-service teachers; CD = curriculum development. Experts: SE = science education; CD = curriculum development; PS = performance support. See appendix A of McKenny (2001, 243) for definitions of group name acronyms. evaluation of that which has been designed so far. The evaluation component is heavily based on the original CASCADE program, although it has been translated in terms of both language and context. Figure 3 shows the main menu page from the CASCADE-SEA program. EVALUATION FINDINGS As described earlier, validity pertains to state-of-the-art knowledge (about curriculum development, teacher professional development, computer-based support, and how to
< previous page
page_35
next page >
< previous page
page_36
next page >
Page 36 Figure 2. Final Version of CASCADE-SEA (Support Web Site) at http://projects.edte.utwente.nl/cascade/seasite/
realize it via the interface) and internal consistency (coherence throughout the various system components). Few participants disputed CASCADE-SEA’s possession of state-of-the-art knowledge; similarly, sparse commentary was given concerning internal inconsistencies. In fact, numerous participants were enthusiastic about these aspects of the program. However, the degree to which the program may be labeled valid is much more difficult to pinpoint. For example, although participants generally agreed that CASCADE-SEA contains state-of-the-art knowledge, some found the volume to be overwhelming, some were satisfied with it, and still others considered it (present but) incomplete. Participant opinions also varied, though not as emphatically, about the internal consistency of the program. Whereas most participants were satisfied with this aspect in relation to the interface and support, opinions diverged with respect to the content of the program. Some participants appreciated the interconnectedness of the content in the various components, but the majority found this aspect to be (present yet) weak. Although determining where CASCADE-SEA’s validity should be placed on a quality continuum remains difficult, the participant reactions indicate that the support and interface are subject to less dispute than the content of the program. Practicality refers to the way in which CASCADE-SEA fits with contextual realities as well as the individual perceptions or beliefs of users in the target setting. This includes the notions of instrumentality (specifying procedures to complete a task), congruence (in this case, linking with the way teachers go about producing exemplary lesson materials in the target setting), and cost (the amount of investment effort compared to the return yielded). Generally speaking, the program was viewed to be practical; based on the participant responses, “quite practical” might be a better descriptor. Here, too, the main area in which opinions diverged was in relation to the content. With regard to instrumentality, participants generally appreciated the guidance offered by the program, although some concern was expressed (mostly by experts in curriculum development and
< previous page
page_36
next page >
< previous page
page_37
next page >
Page 37 Figure 3. CASCADE-SEA CD-ROM Main Menu Screen
teacher professional development) that CASCADE-SEA could offer too much step-by-step guidance. To some user groups, the level of English used was seen to present an overly difficult challenge. Most participants felt that the program was quite congruent with the needs and wishes of the target group, and many emphasized the importance of using the program within a training setting. Opinions were more mixed regarding the costs associated with using the program, particularly time investment. Whereas some participants found CASCADE-SEA to shorten the length of time they would otherwise invest, others found the opposite to be true, mostly because the program inspired them to be more thorough than otherwise would be the case. Although suggestions were given for improvements, participants were more consistently satisfied with the support and the interface aspects of the program. And even though their reactions were not always unanimous concerning the degree to which CASCADE-SEA may be labeled practical, the overall consensus was far less varied when compared with validity aspects. In the case of CASCADE-SEA, positively impacting the performance of its users means that it helps to create betterquality materials than those that would be made without the support of the computer. In addition, the program should contribute to the professional development of its users. The data collected throughout this study indicate that CASCADE-SEA does indeed possess the potential to positively impact the performance of its users but that the extent of this potential is strongly influenced by how the system is used and by the personal characteristics of those using it. The structured nature of the program was judged by participants as useful in helping them articulate procedural specifications for the teachers who eventually use the materials. The support and layout of the materials created with the aid of CASCADE-SEA were judged to be easy to use and comparable to or better than those created without the aid of the program. Further, participants generally indicated that they felt they learned from the CASCADE-SEA experience, although some (mostly experts, as well as a few user groups) raised concerns that the program could make things “too easy” for the user and either stifle creativity or encourage ‘‘laziness” as a result.
< previous page
page_37
next page >
< previous page
page_38
next page >
Page 38 Most participants noted that such concerns (as well as the potential benefits) would be influenced by contextual factors affecting implementation. DISCUSSION Through the development of a valid and practical system, this study has shown that the computer has the potential to positively impact curriculum development and teacher development by supporting the creation of exemplary lesson materials in southern Africa. Users (generally) produce better materials than they otherwise would and learn from this process due to the program’s combination of the following: • Content. CASCADE-SEA systematically structures the materials development process and illustrates its iterative nature through analysis, design, and evaluation activities that are guided by an explicit rationale. • Support. CASCADE-SEA blends generic and tailor-made advice, internal and external tools, implicit and explicit learning opportunities, and written and verbal communication aids to assist the user throughout the materials creation process. • Interface. CASCADE-SEA offers the content and support through a direct, consistent, and forgiving visual (and technical) representation, which grants the user both flexibility and control over the process. The desired quality aspects are neither absolute nor completely objective. In addition, the precise extent of the program’s validity, practicality, and impact potential is difficult to ascertain. In part, this stems from the nature of the quality aspects themselves, which tend to be inherently intersubjective. However, it is this author’s opinion that the relatively small scale and brief evaluation events (ranging from a half-day to one month, repeated over a period of six months) allow only a limited degree of insight into these areas. A follow-up study (or cluster of studies) featuring long-term evaluation of the program’s use in a professional development program may offer more robust and informative indications of these aspects, especially in terms of CASCADE-SEA’s impact potential. Although such a study could bolster the knowledge base on the quality of tools such as this, the fact would remain that the quality aspects are also relative to the context in which the program is employed, as well as to the needs, expectations, and beliefs of individual users. The CASCADE-SEA research highlighted the importance of continuously seeking heightened contextual understanding as an integral part of the design and development process. It is hoped that insights from this approach may help speak to the oft-cited criticism that the field of educational research is inadequately linked with practice. Additional information about the CASCADE-SEA research is available in McKenney (2001), which may also be found online at http://projects.edte.utwente.nl/cascade/seastudy/. REFERENCES Ball, D., and Cohen, D. (1996). Reform by the book: What is—or might be—the role of curriculum materials in teacher learning and instructional reform? Educational Researcher 25:9, 6–8, 14. Ben-Peretz, M. (1990). The teacher-curriculum encounter. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press . de Feiter, L., Vonk, H., and Van den Akker, J. (1995). Towards more effective science teacher development in southern Africa. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam. Fullan, M. (1991). The new meaning of educational change. London: Cassell. Loucks-Horsley, S., Hewson, P., Love, N., and Stiles, K. (1998). Designing professional development for teachers of science and mathematics. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. McKenney, S. (2001). Computer-based support for science education materials developers in Africa: Exploring potentials. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Twente.
< previous page
page_38
next page >
< previous page
page_39
next page >
Page 39 McKenney, S., and Van den Akker, J. (1998, April). Exploring CASCADE-SEA: Computer assisted curriculum analysis, design, and evaluation for science education in Africa. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association annual meeting, San Diego, CA. Nieveen, N. (1997). Computer support for curriculum developers. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Twente. Nieveen, N., and Van den Akker, J. (1999). Exploring the potential of a computer support tool for instructional developers. Educational Technology Research and Development 47:3, 77–98. Reeves, T. (2000). Socially responsible educational technology research. Educational Technology 40:6, 19–28. Richey, R., and Nelson, W. (1996). Developmental research. In D. Jonassen (ed.), Handbook of research on educational communications technology. New York: Macmillan. Seels, B., and Richey, R. (1994). Instructional technology: The definition and domains of the field. Washington, DC: Association for Educational Communications and Technology. Van den Akker, J. (1999). Principles and methods of development research. In J. Van den Akker, R. Branch, K. Gustafson, N. Nieveen, and T. Plomp (eds.), Design and development methodologies in education. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Kluwer.
< previous page
page_39
next page >
< previous page
page_40
next page >
Page 40 From Instruction to Construction Learning in the Information Age Violet H. Harada Library and Information Science Program University of Hawaii TODAY’S LANDSCAPE Technology permeates all aspects of our lives and evolves at a pace that is at once terrifying and exciting. The Internet attracts 1 million new users a month. The number of components on a silicon chip doubles approximately every 18 months, and processing speed doubles every year. Computers themselves continue to shrink in size, replacing pencils and paper notebooks at many work sites (Craver 1994; Pappas 1996). These developments are creating profound changes in the ways information is created, stored, and accessed. Wright (1993) cites the following examples: • Graphic interfaces and pointing devices allow easier access to multiple forms of information. • Online and electronic databases enable retrieval of finding tools and full-text formats and graphics. • Alternative input and output hardware and software provide touch screens, voice input and output, and video and still graphics. • Enhanced telecommunication capabilities make possible increasingly speedy and inexpensive access to remote databases. • New software for information creation and manipulation yields a range of simple authoring systems and artificial intelligence programs. For students growing up in a techno-society, digital technology is part of the natural landscape. Students use the Internet to “manage their personal finances, check the scores of their favorite team, chat online, go to a virtual birthday party…. [T]heir parting expression is ‘email me’ ” (Tapscott 1999, 8). In short, the electronic evolution affects the way we create wealth, manage our economy, deliver our entertainment, run our government, make scientific discoveries, and meet environmental challenges. It also influences how we learn and teach. In this reflective piece, I maintain that student empowerment in an information-rich society depends on the convergence of learning principles and instructional practices that harness technology’s power to extend and deepen learning. In forwarding this thesis, I summarize research findings and discuss their implications for rethinking traditional practice. WHAT RESEARCH TELLS US Studies conducted in the last decade have indicated that the effective application of technology offers many benefits, ranging from improvement in language skills development to promotion of student collaboration (Bialo and SivinKachala 1996). A sampling of the research follows. • Language arts. Technology enhanced students’ language development, specifically in understanding the relationships among the parts of the English language, in
< previous page
page_40
next page >
< previous page
page_41
next page >
Page 41 reading comprehension, in sound discrimination and decoding in context, and in creating oral narratives (MayfieldStewart et al. 1994; Foster, Erickson, Foster, Brinkman, and Torgesen 1994). • Critical thinking. Internet use produced significantly higher scores on measurements of information management, problem solving, communication, and presentation of ideas (Follansbee, Hughes, Pisha, and Stahl 1997; Means and Olson 1994). • Motivation and self-confidence. Use of electronic resources, including telecommunication projects and multimedia productions, resulted in positive effects on student attitudes and student motivation (Borgman, Hirsh, Walter, and Gallagher 1995; Mendrinos 1994). • Individualized instruction. Access to online resources created options for independent learning and strategies for individualizing classroom instruction, based on student needs. Use of these resources supported inquiry-based teaching and the inclusion of students with disabilities in mainstreamed classrooms (Kafai and Bates 1997; Peck and Dorricott 1994; Woronov 1994). • Student collaboration. Social interaction among students working together in electronic environments was shown to improve thinking skills, vocabulary development, and conversational competence (Morton 1996). Recent studies have experimented with designing online learning tools that help students construct representations of their learning using collaborative learning processes. One such study (Suthers and Hundhausen 2001) reported that alternative tools using text, graph, and matrix formats all improved the ability of students to express their emerging knowledge in a collaborative, electronic medium. Along with the benefits cited, other computer-related studies have more precisely defined obstacles faced by novice searchers. The inhibiting factors, which they identify, are not new to educators; they are familiar deficiencies magnified by the information glut that students face. According to Neuman (1995), the sophistication, complexity, and specificity of information obtained through electronic resources frequently exceed the comprehension levels of the students, as well as their needs. Some of the salient findings are summarized below: • Domain knowledge. Inadequate domain knowledge severely compromised the chance of a successful search experience because students were unable to pose appropriate research questions or select effective search terms. The students’ level of background knowledge determined not only the types of resources they most needed but also the relevance of the information and sources they eventually located (Gross 1997; Hirsch 1997; Scott and Van Noord 1996). • Basic language and literacy skills. Problems in reading comprehension, alphabetizing, spelling, and vocabulary resulted in students being unable to locate relevant sources or to skim and scan online texts for main ideas. Lacking these skills, students also encountered problems in selecting appropriate search terms and generating alternative terms (Fidel et al. 1999; Nahl and Harada 1996). • Evaluative competence. Young students were quick to assume that everything found on the Internet was correct. They also failed to apply criteria such as accuracy or adequacy to the information located (Kafai and Bates 1997; Watson 1998). • Information-handling skills. Young information users did not always perceive searching as a set of clear expectations with a sequence of activities and strategies. They also had little notion of information searching as a nonlinear and linked process (Neuman 1995). Consequently, they were unable to switch approaches
< previous page
page_41
next page >
< previous page
page_42
next page >
Page 42 when searching stalled (Fidel et al. 1999; Solomon 1994). This ability to manage a “process of learning” was also deemed critical in studies that extended to workplace skills (Kuhlthau 1999, 7). Lateral thinking processes, the ability to think in a relational way using databases, and searching for information were identified as essential for entry-level positions in many fields (Barner 1996). Pitts (1995) offers a grounded theory that synthesizes the complex relationships among these various cognitive strands. Based on her observations of high school students engaged in research, she posits that their ability to conduct effective searches and to create knowledge from data depends on their competence in several critical areas: content area knowledge, technical proficiency in product creation, and skills in information searching and problem solving. Weaknesses in any one of these spheres affected student progress throughout the assignment and ultimately influenced the quality of the students’ final presentation. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE A critical assumption underlying all of these studies is that computers in themselves do not automatically change the nature of teaching and learning. It is the way in which their use is integrated into classroom activity that produces educational benefits for students (Herring 1999; Kosakowski 2000). In short, the planning focus must be on the ‘‘individual educational needs of students and how educators meet those needs…rather than on what technology is or does” (National Education Association Special Committee on Educational Technology 1989, 11). To make our own professional sense of the growing body of research, we must examine these findings in the context of what needs to be learned and how learning occurs. Current teaching and learning beliefs support an interactive approach that relates new information to what is already known, that links abstractions to experience, and that evaluates ideas encountered in light of their relevance and utility (Thomas 1999). In this constructivist approach, there is a fundamental shift from instruction to construction and delivery. Learning is not simply assimilating knowledge transmitted by textbooks and instructors but personally building and communicating knowledge. In this paradigm, students “must DO not simply LISTEN” (Tapscott 1999, 9). If we wish to create information-rich cultures that support high expectations, a spirit of independence, and a sense of community, the following essential questions must be addressed (Donham 1998): • How will technology allow students to do something of significance substantially better than they could otherwise? • How will it empower them to function at higher cognitive levels? To begin making the critical connections between learning principles and their implications for practice, we need to identify the characteristics of effective learning environments and to examine how technology contributes to the creation of such communities. Figure 1 juxtaposes selected attributes of a dynamic learning culture (Bruner 1962; Gardner 1983; Newman, Secada, and Wehlage 1995; Papert 1996; Wright 1993) with research findings in information technology. To summarize, schools that capitalize on computer technology recognize that information is fluid and easily manipulated through the cognitive tools of the search process. In “post-modem schools,” the emphasis shifts from “descriptive research,” where students merely move words around, to “explanatory research,” where there is “real digging to answer how and why things are related” (McKenzie 1996). The use of electronic and online applications enables users to visually and concretely view their searches and results on the screen. Instantaneously, the abstract becomes the
< previous page
page_42
next page >
< previous page
page_43
next page >
Page 43 Figure 1. Information Technology: Attributes of a Dynamic Learning Culture and Their ResearchSupported Implications Attributes of Dynamic Learning Research-Supported Implications Culture • Learning is active and rigorous; • Online learning tools present new options for knowledge representations that it focuses on discovery and help students to map concepts and ideas and to outline terms visually as well as creative construction. abstractly. • Authoring tools encourage interactive modes of communication. • Learning is nonlinear and • Hypermedia tools allow for divergent and nonsequential manipulation of multisensory. information. • Electronic databases and indexes provide hierarchical and hyperlinked access to multiple forms of graphic, textual, and multimedia information. • Learning is collaborative and • Collaborative online learning tools encourage participants to comment on one social. another's notes, ask questions, and highlight what they find interesting. • Online networks expand opportunities to seek and share information with a global community. • Electronic publishing enables teams to generate a common electronic knowledge base. • Learning is diversified. • Electronic tools aid in customizing learning (e.g., online portfolios) and in accommodating different learning styles (e.g. authoring tools, application software with multiple learning options). • Networks and shared databases allow students to learn different things at the same time. They may also study separate aspects of a situation and share that knowledge with others. • Adaptive technologies allow students with disabilities to more fully engage in various learning experiences with their peers. • Learning is problem based, • Electronic simulations allow for real-world applications. Emphasis is on questions inquiry driven. and problem solving rather than simply answers. • Online access provides current links to human and electronic resources on timely issues throughout the world. • Learning is process oriented. • Information-literacy skills focus on learning how to learn, on articulating information seeking process and on problem-solving strategies. • Evaluation software programs help students assess and evaluate their own progress and retool and improve upon past practices. • Learning is guided rather than • Teacher is less lecturer, more coach. Working with computers allows instructors directed. to observe and to facilitate. There is more dialogue and mutual conversation than in teacher-controlled instruction. • Learning is student centered. • Electronic tools and online access to information places decision making more directly in the hands of learners. • Technology enhances opportunities for projects that are negotiated between student and instructor. • Learning is a lifelong endeavor. • Proficiency in information-literacy skills is essential in both classroom and workplace. • Electronic access dissolves the artificial boundaries of the school day and the classroom. Learning is possible anywhere, anytime. concrete. “The reasoning powers of the intellect interact with the sense of touch, sight, and hearing for a holistic learning experience that involves the cognitive, affective, and sensorimotor domains” (Mendrinos 1994, 13). In the electronic world, as learners are thinking, they are also doing. SNAPSHOTS OF EMERGING PRACTICES What does student learning look like in such information-literate communities? The literature abounds with promising illustrations of programs and projects that strive to
< previous page
page_43
next page >
< previous page
page_44
next page >
Page 44 integrate critical thinking and problem-solving skills in the new information landscape (e.g., CEO Forum on Education and Technology 2001; Follansbee et al. 1997; ThinkQuest n.d.). This section briefly considers several examples from two Hawaii-based projects: “Building Effective Teaching and Learning Partnerships” and “Hawaii Networked Learning Communities.” Partnerships Project The Partnerships Project, which was launched with an American Association of School Libraries/ABC-CLIO leadership grant, brought together over 20 teams of K–12 teachers and library media specialists (Harada 2001). Their collaboratively designed units focused on authentic, inquiry-driven learning experiences that included a range of electronic tools. Two of the elementary grade projects are briefly described here. Water Quality At Mililani Waena Elementary, upper-grade students joined with teams from neighboring schools to analyze the quality of water reserves in their community and how this affected their families. They formulated questions essential to their investigation, brain-stormed possible online and print resources to consult, collected data samples on field visits to wells and local streams, devised electronic mind maps of data gathered, learned to create graphs and spreadsheets, and ultimately presented their group findings at an environmental summit sponsored by the Mililani Community Association. Throughout the process, students maintained logs reflecting their informationseeking process. Assassin Bug When a kindergarten student at Waikele Elementary discovered a strange bug on the school playground, his finding initiated a flurry of interest in his classroom. He and two classmates volunteered to find more information about the bug. They involved their teacher and the library media specialist, and ultimately, they sent e-mail to an entomologist at the University of Hawaii. Learning the identity of the bug was not sufficient for these children; they wanted to know if it was dangerous and how they might share their information with the rest of the school. Through further email conversations with the entomologist, the kindergartners procured digital photographs and more information about the insect. Finally, they collaborated with their school technology coordinator, who helped them script and produce a two-minute video on their findings. Aired on the school’s closed-circuit television system, the team’s effort inspired other students in their class to embark on similar investigations of different insects. Finally, the class created a mind map of its collective information search process with the teacher’s guidance. Hawaii NetworkedLearning Communities The Hawaii Networked Learning Communities (HNLC) project (1999), recently awarded a five-year, $6 million grant by the National Science Foundation, is a rural systemic initiative targeting improvement of science and mathematics education in disadvantaged and geographically isolated K–12 schools in the state (see lilt.ics.hawaii.edu/hnlc). The enterprise focuses on inquiry-based, technology-enhanced learning. Examples of projects that are at the beginning stages of implementation are summarized here. Environmental Mapping Schools on the Big Island (Hawaii) plan to use Geographic Information Systems (GIS), computer programs designed to analyze spatial data and to create an efficient method for investigating relationships in the environment. They will gather and examine data along the Hamakua coastline and build databases on area characteristics, species present, and patterns of use. Global Positioning Systems (GPS) will be used to supplement the data
< previous page
page_44
next page >
< previous page
page_45
next page >
Page 45 gathered through GIS by allowing students to more precisely locate data points of interest. GPS will also allow them to identify specific resources, such as endangered plants, with a high degree of accuracy. A wireless network will connect schools as they collaboratively manage data collection to address issues in their respective communities. Numerous research opportunities may emerge from this network. For example, experts can assist students at any time or location while schools develop a growing database on native plant species. Because digital photographs and GPS data will be continually entered over several years, students can observe emerging trends as they conduct research in ways never possible in a one-year course. Endangered Plants The Hawaii Forestry and Communities Initiative has forged a partnership with Laupahoehoe High School to design and create an endangered species botanical garden, which will function as a “nurse forest” to regenerate native species in an understory for native dry land forest plants. Seeds and plants will then be distributed to the community for reforestation of the local area. As it grows, the nurse forest will be underplanted with other endangered and rare Hawaiian plants to form a viable plant and seed bank for the school and community. The project is envisioned as a cross-disciplinary endeavor. For example, bioagriculture classes will sample soil for composition, pH levels, and nutrients and analyze this data through graphical and statistical means. Business classes will gain skills in math and accounting by monitoring the sale of plants and expand their entrepreneurial skills by developing a Web site for the project. English and social studies classes will research the plants for their cultural significance and design brochures to increase the public’s awareness of these endangered species. Resource Management A K–12 school complex on the northeastern end of Oahu is presently engaged in a community study of land and sea restoration based on the Hawaiian concept of ahupuaa. In a unique system of resource management in ancient Hawaii, the ahupuaa was a highly developed segment of land and ocean that was also an economic, political, and cultural unit. Within each ahupuaa, people had to concentrate on renewable resources (solar energy, water, etc.) to sustain their social unit. In the present ecological project, students examine issues that integrate marine science with urban and agrarian concerns. They study how the environment has changed over time, how human activities have modified the ecosystem, and what society must do to promote its restoration. Electronic access to primary documents and to community experts will be critical in their investigation. Online chat rooms and interactive Web sites will be vital avenues for collaborative conversations and information documentation. In addition, the instructional team will be identifying various authoring tools that students might use to chart information and to communicate their findings. Common Threads Collectively, these snapshots capture certain attributes that are crucial to our understanding and appreciation of what learning can be in an information-rich environment: • Real-world problems and issues are fertile grounds for authentic learning opportunities. • The inquiry process begins with the learner’s genuine sense of curiosity; the learner’s questions lead to more questions. • Deep learning requires access to and use of information from a global bank of resources. • Knowledge construction is a social venture involving a collaborative community of learners of all ages bound together by a mutual interest or goal.
< previous page
page_45
next page >
< previous page
page_46
next page >
Page 46 • Learning opportunities are negotiated efforts between students and instructors; the latter become engineers who shape rather than dictate these opportunities. • A process approach to information searching and management must be incorporated into the total learning experience. • When shaped around critical community issues, these experiences can foster a lifelong sense of social responsibility and stewardship. The use of current and cutting-edge technologies extends and enhances our capacity for building these dynamic learning communities. They allow for a collaborative construction of knowledge that is built over time. Contributions to this knowledge base can be generated from various locales and can engage diverse partners. These applications also introduce creative and divergent alternatives for manipulating data and for presenting information and knowledge to a truly global community. MEETING OUR FUTURE Mind-boggling advances in telepower, telecommunication networks, interactive media, smart technologies, and virtual-reality applications proliferate the present information landscape. Whether we are ready for it or not, our future is upon us. The solution is not merely to acquire more hardware and to expand our network infrastructures. The real challenge we face is to make thoughtful decisions about what is worth learning and how to empower students to achieve this learning. McKenzie (1998) indicates that our goal should be to produce young people capable of navigating through a complex, often disorganized information network while making up their own minds about the important issues of their lives and their times. To do this, they must possess a ‘‘toolkit of thinking and problem-solving skills” to shape their own meaning making process. Indeed, learning in an information-rich environment engages all of us in the adventure of searching for connections. It invites us to explore and create new constructs. Ultimately, such learning entails forming bridges from data to new knowledge and insight. REFERENCES Barner, R. (1996). Seven changes that will challenge managers and workers. Futurist 30:2, 14–18. Bialo, E. R., and Sivin-Kachala, J. (1996). The effectiveness of technology in schools: A summary of recent research. School Library Media Quarterly 2:1, 51–57. Borgman C. L., Hirsh, S. G., Walter, V. A., and Gallagher, A. L. (1995). Children’s searching behavior on browsing and keyword online catalogs: The science library catalog project. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 46:9, 663–684. Bruner, J. (1962). On knowing: Essays for the left hand. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press. CEO Forum on Education and Technology. (2001). The CEO Forum school technology and readiness report. [Online]. Available: http://www.ceoforum.org/downloads/report4.pdf. (Accessed December 4, 2002). Craver, K. W. (1994). School library media centers in the 21st century. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. Donham, J. (1998). Enhancing teaching and learning: A leadership guide for school library media specialists. New York: Neal Schuman. Fidel, R., Davies, R. K., Douglass, M. H., Holder, J. K., Hopkins, C. J., Kushner, E. J., Miyagishima, B. K. , and Toney, C. D. (1999). A visit to the information mall: Web searching behavior of high school students. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 50:1, 24–37. Foster, K. C., Erickson, G. C., Foster, D. F., Brinkman, D., and Torgesen, J. K. (1994). Computer administered instruction in phonological awareness: Evaluation of the Daisy Quest program. Journal of Research and Development in Education 27, 126–137.
< previous page
page_46
next page >
< previous page
page_47
next page >
Page 47 Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. New York: Basic Books. Gross, M. (1997). Pilot study on the prevalence of imposed queries in a school library media center. School Library Media Quarterly 25:3, 157–166. Harada, V. H. (2001). Professional development as collaborative inquiry. Knowledge Quest 29:5, 13–19. Herring, J. E. (1999). The use of the Internet in school libraries: An international and comparative survey. In L. Lighthall and E. Howe (eds.), Unleash the power! Knowledge-technology-diversity: Papers presented at the Third International Forum on Research in School Librarianship. Seattle, WA: International Association of School Librarianship. Hirsch, S. G. (1997). How do children find information in different tasks? Children’s use of the science catalog. Library Trends 43:4, 725–745. Kafai, Y., and Bates, M. J. (1997). Internet Web-searching instruction in the elementary classroom: Building a foundation for information literacy. School Library Media Quarterly 25:2, 103–111. Kosakowski, J. (2000). The benefits of information technology. In R. M. Branch and M. A. Fitzgerald (eds.), Educational media and technology yearbook 2000: Volume 25. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Kuhlthau, C. C. (1999). Literacy and learning for the information age. In B. K. Stripling (ed.), Learning and libraries in an information age: Principles and practice. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Mayfield-Stewart, C., Moore, P., Sharp, D., Brophy, S., Hasselbring, T. Goldman, S., and Bransford, J. (1994, April). Evaluation of multimedia instruction on learning and transfer. Paper presented at the annual conference of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA. McKenzie, J. (1996). The post modem school in the new information landscape. FNO From Now On: The Educational Technology Journal. [Online]. Available: http://fromnowon.org/oct96/postmodem.html. (Accessed December 4, 2002). ———. (1998). Grazing the net: Raising a generation of free range students part one. FNO From Now On: The Educational Technology Journal. [Online]. Available: http://fromnowon.org/text/grazing.html. (Accessed December 4, 2002). Means, B., and Olson, K. (1994). The link between technology and authentic learning. Educational Leadership 51:7, 15–18. Mendrinos, R. (1994). Building information literacy using high technology: A guide for schools and libraries. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Morton, C. (1996). The modern land of Laputa: Where computers are used in education. Phi Delta Kappan 77:6, 416–419. Nahl, D., and Harada, V. (1996). Composing boolean search statements: Self-confidence, concept analysis, search log, and errors. School Library Media Quarterly 24:4, 199–207. National Education Association. (1989). Special committee on educational technology. Washington, DC: National Education Association. Neuman, D. (1995). High school students use of databases: Results of a national Delphi study. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 46:4, 284–298. Newman, F. M., Secada, W. G., and Wehlage, G. G. (1995). A guide to authentic instruction and assessment: Vision, standards, and scoring. Madison, WI: Wisconsin Center for Education. Papert, S. (1996). The connected family: Bridging the digital generation gap. Marietta, GA: Longstreet Press. Pappas, M. L. (1996). Electronic learning in 2002. School Library Media Activities Monthly 13:1, 37–38. Peck, K. L., and Dorricott, D. (1994). Why use technology? Educational Leadership 51:7, 11–14. Pitts, J. M. (1995). Mental models of information: The 1993–94 AASL/Highsmith research award study. School Library Media Quarterly 23:3, 177–184.
< previous page
page_47
next page >
< previous page
page_48
next page >
Page 48 Scott, M., and Van Noord, G. (1996). Conducting original research at the high school level: The student’s perspective. American Biology Teacher 58:4, 217–219. Solomon, P. (1994). Children, technology, and instruction: A case study of elementary school children using an online public access catalog (OPAC). School Library Media Quarterly 24:1, 43–51. Suthers, D. D., and Hundhausen, C. D. (2001). Learning by constructing collaborative representations: An empirical comparison of three alternatives. In P. Dillenbourg, A. Eurelings, and K. Hakkarainen (eds.), European Conference on Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, Proceedings, March 22–24, 2001. Maastricht, Netherlands: Universiteit Maastricht. Tapscott, D. (1999). Educating the net generation. Educational Leadership 56:5, 6–11. ThinkQuest. (n.d.). ThinkQuest library of entries. [Online]. Available: http://www.thinkquest.org/library/. Thomas, N. P. (1999). Information literacy and information skills instruction: Applying research to practice in the school library media center. Englewood, CO: Libraries Unlimited. Watson, J. S. (1998). If you don’t have it, you can’t find it: A close look at students’ perceptions of using technology. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 49:11, 1024–1036. Woronov, T. (1994). Machine dreams: Six myths (and five promising truths) about the uses of educational technology. Harvard Education Letter 10:5, 1–3. Wright, K. (1993). The challenge of technology: Action strategies for the school library media specialist. Chicago: American Library Association.
< previous page
page_48
next page >
< previous page
page_49
next page >
Page 49 Do You Want to Be in Control or Not? An Unasked Question in CBI Research Jung Lee Instructional Technology Richard Stockton College of New Jersey INTRODUCTION Since the 1960s, when computer-based instruction (CBI) was introduced to provide individualized lessons, a great deal of research has been done to determine the effects of learner-controlled instruction (LC) versus programcontrolled instruction (PC) (Williams 1997). Generally, under the assumption that providing instructional control might positively benefit students’ learning, these CBI studies compared the effectiveness of two separate groups: one under LC instruction and the other under PC instruction. Under LC, students have control over their learning by choosing learning activities; under PC, a program makes such decisions for students. However, until recently, none of the studies asked whether students liked to have the control over their learning. Researchers missed the fact that under LC, students lack the freedom of “giving up the control to the program.” In other words, under LC, they are forced to have control throughout the lesson. Some students may not like to have the control; instead, they may like to be taught by a computer program. Students’ preference of control in CBI had not been questioned. In Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior, Deci and Ryan (1985, 31) asserted that “people do not always want control of outcomes; indeed, they often prefer to have others take control. What people want is choice about whether to be in control.” According to Deci’s self-determination theory (Deci 1980; Deci and Ryan 1985), when people decide whether to have control, they are intrinsically motivated even when they decide not to be in control. On the other hand, even when people have control over their situation, if it is not their choice to have this control, they are not self-determined or intrinsically motivated. Thus the need for choice of whether to be in control is more important than the need for control. In addition, Steinberg (1991) argued that while some students were motivated by total freedom in learning, others were motivated by a totally controlled system. This claim suggests that there are individual differences in the motivational value of learner control. Thus, before providing the control of instruction, the initial choice of instructional control should be given to students to satisfy students’ differences in motivation as well to increase intrinsic motivation. If this assumption proves valid, then the type of instructional control should be the first choice instructional designers allow students to make in their learning environment. Through this study, I attempted to investigate whether allowing students to choose the type of instructional control (i.e., whether to be in control or not) in a CBI would influence students’ behaviors. Figure 1 illustrates the question asked in this study compared with the question asked in the previous studies. CHOICE AND ITS EFFECTS ON LEARNING Experimental studies have revealed that students who were allowed to make a choice showed positive learning behaviors. Langer (1975) and Swann and Pittman (1977) reported that even when the choices provided seemed ‘‘trivial” or completely “illusory,” subjects’ motivational effects remained apparent. When students have choices in their activities, their sense of control over their learning situation and their motivation increase. Those feelings can lead to positive effects on students’ behavior.
< previous page
page_49
next page >
< previous page
page_50
next page >
Page 50 Figure 1. Illustration of the Study
First, students motivated by the act of choosing have shown high performance (Maehr 1984; Stipek and Weisz 1981). Perlmuter and Monty (1977) summarized a series of studies in which they manipulated choice as a variable in paired-associate learning tasks. Their findings revealed a positive relationship between college students’ performance and the perception of control that the students gained by exercising choice over their instruction. White (as cited in Savage, Perlmuter, and Monty 1979) found similar positive effects for choice in a reading task. Fifth-grade students were given varying levels of choice over the selection of four stories that would be read to them during a reading comprehension test. Students who were allowed to choose as few as one story title did better on the test than those who had no choice. Cordova and Lepper’s (1996) study also showed high performance by students who had choices. Second, students who were allowed to make choices have shown higher satisfaction or enjoyment with the task or the instruction than students who were not given those choices. Cordova and Lepper’s study (1996) showed that students in the choice condition enjoyed and liked their learning more than students in the no-choice condition. Third, students who were given the freedom to choose showed different patterns in learning time from those students with no freedom to choose. From the literature review,
< previous page
page_50
next page >
< previous page
page_51
next page >
Page 51 I found that motivated students showed two patterns in learning time: persistence (Keller 1983; Maehr 1984) and intensive learning (Keller 1983). Swann and Pittman (1977) showed that when first, second, or third graders were allowed to choose the play activity, they persisted at the task longer than students who were simply assigned the activity. Kail’s (1975) study showed that undergraduate students who were allowed to choose a task from the five tasks presented to them persisted longer at the task than those who were not allowed to choose. Myrow’s (1979) study also showed a similar result. When 11th- and 12th-grade students had freedom to choose the topic of study from six alternatives, they spent more time studying the materials than when they had no freedom. In Zuckerman, Porac, Lathin, Smith, and Deci’s (1978) study, college students in the choice condition chose three puzzles from six puzzles and decided how much time they would spend on solving each puzzle. Meanwhile, subjects in the no-choice condition were given three puzzles and time for solving them. The subjects in the choice group demonstrated their intrinsic motivation by continuing their engagement with the puzzles during free time in the experimental period while the no-choice group engaged in other activities, such as reading magazines. These studies concluded that students’ increased motivation made them persist at the learning tasks. Motivated students also engage in intensive learning in a fixed time. In Perlmuter and Monty’s (1977) first experiment, the subjects who were allowed to choose a response word from five alternative words matching with a stimulus word learned more rapidly and became more proficient than the subjects who were assigned the response words. In Cordova and Lepper’s (1996) study, elementary school students who were allowed to make personal choices learned more in a fixed time period than the students who were assigned the instructional material. The results of this study suggest that students who make choices learn faster than those who do not have the choices. Previous researchers who attempted to investigate the relationship between motivation and learning time developed only one directional hypothesis. Whereas some studies hypothesized that students with high motivation would learn faster, others hypothesized that students with high motivation would persist longer at tasks. The present study attempts to combine these two hypotheses: Motivated students would either learn faster or persist longer at their task. Hence, a group of motivated students would demonstrate more spread-out learning time than a group of nonmotivated students. As Keller (1983, 388) argued, “People tend to persist longer, or more intensely for a shorter period at tasks when they are motivated than when they are not.” From this literature review, I hypothesized that the students who were allowed to choose a type of instructional control would show better performance, greater satisfaction, more intensive learning in a fixed time, or greater persistence than the students who were assigned a type of instructional control. RESEARCH HYPOTHESES An experimental research design was adopted for this study. College-level students in an experimental group were allowed to choose between two types of instructional control at the beginning of the instruction. Students in a control group were randomly assigned one type of instructional control. From the literature review, the following research hypotheses were developed concerning post-test performance, satisfaction with the instruction, and time-in-lesson. 1. Performance. Students who make a choice of instructional control at the beginning of the instruction will achieve higher scores in the two performance tests, (i.e., A: multiple-choice knowledge test; and B: hands-on application test) than students who are assigned a type of instructional control. 2. Satisfaction. Students who make a choice of instructional control at the beginning of the instruction will be more satisfied with the instruction than students who are assigned a type of instructional control.
< previous page
page_51
next page >
< previous page
page_52
next page >
Page 52 3. Time-in-lesson. Students who make a choice of instructional control will display greater variability in time-inlesson than students who are assigned a type of instructional control. RESEARCH METHOD Design andSubjects The primary independent variable was the choice of instructional control (choice versus no-choice). The dependent variables were students’ performance measured by two post-test scores (a multiple-choice test and an application test), satisfaction questionnaire, and time-in-lesson. Subjects were 90 college students enrolled in an undergraduate education course at a western university in the 1998 spring semester. They were 38 males and 52 females who were randomly assigned to the experimental group and control group. Their grade levels varied from college freshman to graduate school. There were no differences between the two groups in gender (χ2 = .357, df = 1, p = .55) or grade level (χ2 = 1.96, df = 5, p = .74). The course in which subjects were enrolled was an introductory computer course focusing on a hands-on experience with computers. This study was conducted toward the end of the semester, by which time subjects had learned computer operating systems and a word processing, spreadsheet, and presentation program by completing the previous modules offered in class. However, the class had no exposure to either CBI or online tutorials before the present study was conducted. CBI used for this study was a new type of instruction for most of the students. Materials Based on a HyperStudio tutorial produced by Roger Wagner, two different HyperStudio tutorials, an LC-type tutorial and a PC-type tutorial, were produced by the researcher to meet the particular requirements of the experiment. Both lessons (LC and PC) had identical content. However, in the LC lesson, students were free to determine the sequence of instruction by choosing from a range of topics. For the PC lesson, students followed a predetermined sequence established by the researcher. Experimental Group andControl Group The only difference between the experimental and the control group was whether they had the choice of instructional control at the beginning of the lesson. For the experimental group, the choice of LC and PC was given with the definition and characteristics of LC and PC at the beginning of the lesson (fig. 2). Subjects in the choice group started the lesson by making the choice of instructional control. Hence, in the experimental group, there were two subgroups of subjects: those who chose LC and those who chose PC. In the control group, subjects started the lesson with a type of instructional control already installed in the computer and did not know there was another type of instructional control (fig. 3 and fig. 4). Half of the subjects in the control group were given LC; half were given PC. While all students were working with the lesson, the HyperStudio program recorded each student’s choice of instructional control, path, and the amount of time he or she spent on each screen. RESULTS The hypotheses of this study were that the students’ choice of the instructional control might positively influence their behaviors regarding 1) performance on post-tests, 2) satisfaction with the lesson, and 3) the amount of time spent on the lesson. The test results for each hypothesis follow. T tests, correlation, chi-square tests, Bartlett tests, and Welch’s
< previous page
page_52
next page >
< previous page
page_53
next page >
Page 53 Figure 2. Choice Group (Experimental Group) Start Screen and the Information of the Screen
t′ tests were used to analyze the data. Table 1 shows the descriptive statistics for all variables.1 Due to the exploratory nature of this study, an alpha of .10 was set for the significance level. Preliminary Analyses Preliminary analyses were performed to determine whether any differences in subjects’ familiarity with computers, CBI, and authoring software existed between the two groups. Such initial differences in ability would have influenced the subjects’ performance. From the survey data, chi-square tests revealed that the two groups had no significant
< previous page
page_53
next page >
< previous page
page_54
next page >
Page 54 Figure 3. No-Choice LC (One of Two Control Groups) Start Screen
Figure 4. No-Choice PC (One of Two Control Groups) Start Screen
differences in their familiarity with computers (χ2 = 2.27, df = 4, p = .69), CBI (χ2 = 1.96 df = 4, p = .74), and authoring software (χ2 = 6.83, df = 4, p = .15). Thus, the two groups had equivalent abilities in computers, computer-based instruction, and authoring software at the beginning of this study. Also, because two types of instruction were used in this study, there was a possibility that their instructional effectiveness was not equal. Such differences might affect students’
< previous page
page_54
next page >
< previous page
page_55
next page >
Page 55 Table 1. Descriptive Statistics Variable Mean SD Minimum Maximum N Multiple-choice knowledge test Choice group 7.34 1.36 5.00 10.00 53 Choice LC 7.20 1.37 5.00 9.00 15 Choice PC 7.39 1.37 5.00 10.00 38 No-choice group 7.35 1.44 4.00 10.00 37 No-choice LC 7.26 1.45 4.00 9.00 19 No-choice PC 7.44 1.46 5.00 10.00 18 LC group (choice and no-choice) 7.24 1.39 4.00 9.00 34 PC group (Choice and no-choice) 7.41 1.39 5.00 10.00 56 Hands-on application test Choice group 9.68 2.33 2.00 12.00 53 Choice LC 10.00 1.89 6.00 12.00 15 Choice PC 9.55 2.49 2.00 12.00 38 No-choice group 8.89 2.90 1.00 12.00 37 No-choice LC 9.63 3.02 2.00 12.00 19 No-choice PC 8.11 2.63 1.00 12.00 18 LC group (choice and no-choice) 9.79 2.56 2.00 12.00 34 PC group (choice and no-choice) 9.09 2.60 1.00 12.00 56 Satisfaction score Choice group 3.79 .55 2.00 4.89 53 Choice LC 3.88 .48 3.33 4.78 15 Choice PC 3.76 .58 2.00 4.89 38 No-choice group 3.60 .50 1.67 4.22 37 No-choice LC 3.55 .62 1.67 4.22 19 No-choice PC 3.65 .35 2.89 4.17 18 LC group (choice and no-choice) 3.69 .58 1.67 4.78 34 PC group (choice and no-choice) 3.72 .51 2.00 4.89 56 Time in lesson (in seconds) Choice group 1073.0 401.98 90.00 2751.00 53 Choice LC 846.20 428.90 90.00 1919.00 15 Choice PC 1162.6 358.31 697.00 2751.00 38 No-choice group 1037.8 206.36 570.00 1565.00 37 No-choice LC 1017.1 205.89 570.00 1351.00 19 No-choice PC 1059.6 210.49 741.00 1565.00 18 LC group (choice and no-choice) 941.71 329.52 90.00 1919.00 34 PC group (choice and no-choice) 1129.5 320.03 697.00 2751.00 56 performance. Simply by choosing one type of instructional control, the performance of one group may have shown higher than those of the other group. In this case, the factor affecting better performance is not the act of choice but the type of instructional control. To verify the equivalence of two types of instruction, the two control groups’ characteristics and post-tests were analyzed. Chi-square tests revealed that the randomly assigned LC and PC groups were equivalent in gender (χ2 = .3, df = 1, p = .86), grade level (χ2 = 3.64, df = 4, p = .46), and familiarity with computers (χ2 = 5.68, df = 3, p = .13), CBI (χ2 = 1.11, df = 4, p = .89), and authoring software (χ2 = 3.59, df = 4, p = 4.64). The results of t tests showed no differences in the post-tests between two groups (multiple-choice test: t = .38, p = .71; application test: t = 1.63, p = .11). Therefore, it was verified that two types of instruction were equivalent in instructional effectiveness. Testing of Hypothesis 1: Performance Hypothesis 1 proposed that the choice group would show better performance measured by a multiple-choice test and an application test than the no-choice group. The z scores of the two post-tests were averaged into a single measure for the overall performance.2 The two groups’ overall performance were not different ( t = 1.01, p = .32).
< previous page
page_55
next page >
< previous page
page_56
next page >
Page 56 Hypothesis 1.A: Multiple-Choice Knowledge Test The results showed that the two groups’ mean scores were almost equal ( t = .04, p = .97). Therefore, hypothesis 1.A was not supported. Hypothesis 1.B: Hands-On Application Test Data showed that the choice group scored higher than the no-choice group, but the difference was not large enough to be statistically significant ( t = 1.43, p = .16). Therefore, hypothesis 1.B was not supported. Testing of Hypothesis 2: Satisfaction Hypothesis 2 proposed that the choice group would be more satisfied with the lesson than the no-choice group. The satisfaction means were 3.79 for the choice group and 3.60 for the no-choice group. This difference in mean satisfaction scores is represented in figure 5. (The circles in the figure represent outliers; the asterisk represents extreme outlier.) The difference was statistically significant at the .10 level (two-tailed) ( t = 1.71, p < .10). This finding indicates that subjects in the choice group were more satisfied with the instruction than those in the nochoice group. Thus, the hypothesis was supported. Effect size is .35, and power equals .49 (Cohen 1988). A t test was conducted to investigate whether there was any difference in satisfaction between the two choice groups. No difference was found ( t = .71, p = .48). Also a 2 (choice of instructional control) x 2 (the type of instructional control) factorial analysis was conducted to verify whether the type of instructional control influenced subjects’ overall satisfaction. There was no significant interaction between the two factors, F(1, 86) = .87, p = .35. Testing of Hypothesis 3: Time-in-Lesson Hypothesis 3 proposed that the choice group’s time-in-lesson would display greater variability than that of the nochoice group. Mean learning time was 1,073.08 seconds for the choice group and 1,037.81 seconds for the nochoice group. The two groups spent almost the same time finishing the lesson. However, the standard deviations were 401.98 for the choice group and 206.36 for the no-choice group. Bartlett’s test of homogeneity of variance showed that the two groups were significantly different in variance (.95X21 = 16.45, p < .05) (Glass and Hopkins, 1996). Thus, it was concluded that the two groups were heterogeneous in time-in-lesson. Figure 6 shows the actual distribution of the two groups’ time-in-lesson, which indicates that the choice group’s completion time is more spread out than the no-choice group’s.3 The two distributions have equal medians, but unequal variances. This finding supports the hypothesis. DISCUSSION The purpose of this study was to explore the effects of college students’ choice of the type of instructional control in CBI on achievement, satisfaction, and time-in-lesson. In performance tests, no significant differences were found between the choice and no-choice groups. The choice group, however, was more satisfied with the lesson than the no-choice group. Also, the choice group showed greater variability in time-in-lesson than the no-choice group. Effects of Choice on Performance Several considerations may explain why the t test did not reach the significant level on post-tests. First, some extraneous factors beyond the researcher’s control occurred during conducting of the research. The experiment was held in a real class situation, and in
< previous page
page_56
next page >
< previous page
page_57
next page >
page_57
next page >
Page 57 Figure 5. Satisfaction Box Plot
< previous page
< previous page
page_58
next page >
Page 58 Figure 6. Time-in-Lesson Box Plot
each section, approximately 15 students sat in an open-style computer laboratory. Although subjects were told to work individually, some interaction between subjects occurred while working with the lesson and post-tests. This opportunity to help each other could have contaminated post-test and satisfaction scores, as well as completion time. Second, the instructional material used for this study was a HyperStudio basic tutorial, in which overall instructions were not difficult for subjects with a basic knowledge about computer applications. With this relatively easy instructional material, along with the small size of this sample, statistical significance would be less likely. Third, the post-tests were too basic. In other words, the post-tests were constructed not to measure the maximum knowledge students acquired from the lesson but rather to measure basic knowledge. Because of high motivation, students in the choice group may have increased their knowledge above the minimum level that the post-tests measured. In addition, as indicated earlier, the item analysis revealed that the multiple-choice test was easy. The easiness of the multiple-choice test resulted from the researcher’s misinterpretation of the pilot testing. The original form of measuring the immediate retention of concepts was a short-essay form. After the first pilot testing, the form was changed to the multiple-choice test form to avoid any subjective scoring. The people participating at the second pilot testing were graduate students mostly majoring in adult learning and technology or undergraduate students who were familiar with the subject matter and computers. Hence, even though they had higher scores in the multiplechoice test, which indicated the easiness of the test, the researcher considered it was caused by the higher ability of the students in the subject matter than that of the target population. Effects of Choice on Satisfaction The results indicate that students in the choice group were more satisfied with the instruction than students in the no-choice group. Furthermore, whether students in the
< previous page
page_58
next page >
< previous page
page_59
next page >
Page 59 choice group chose LC or PC, their satisfaction with the instruction was equal. This result indicates that once students had made a choice about whether to be in control, their satisfaction was the same whether they or the computer program controlled their learning. This finding provides empirical support for Deci’s self-determination theory. Also, a 2 x 2 factorial analysis result showed that there was no interaction between the choice of instructional control and the type of instructional control. Therefore, it is generalized that the choice of instructional control was the only factor that made a difference in satisfaction rate. LC advocates argued that giving control to students would increase their motivation; however, this study shows that just giving students control over their learning (i.e., the no-choice LC condition in this study) did not influence students’ satisfaction. Even though the effect size was relatively small (.35), the practical significance of this exploratory study should not be ignored. As Cohen (1988, 25) has argued, ‘‘In new areas of research inquiry, effect sizes are likely to be small. This is because the phenomena under study are typically not under good experimental or measurement control or both.” In addition, he also pointed out that when phenomena that cannot be brought into the laboratory are studied, the influence of uncontrollable extraneous variables makes the size of the effect small. The present study is a new area of research and was conducted in an open classroom. Effects of Choice on Time-in-Lesson Previous researchers who tried to investigate the relationship between motivation and learning time developed only one directional hypothesis. Whereas some studies hypothesized that students with high motivation would learn faster, others hypothesized that students with high motivation would persist longer at tasks. This study tried to combine these two hypotheses: Motivated students would either learn faster or persist longer at their task. Hence, a group of motivated students would demonstrate more spread-out learning time than a group of non-motivated students. To once again quote Keller (1983, 388), “People tend to persist longer, or more intensely for a shorter period at tasks when they are motivated than when they are not.” The time-in-lesson data from this study show these patterns. Students in the choice group finished their lessons within a more widely varying range of time than those in the nochoice group. Students in the choice group tended to stay for either a shorter or longer time period than the nochoice group stayed. However, the learning time in the choice group was not related to students’ performance (multiple-choice test: r = .01; application test: r = −08). Also, their satisfaction was not related to the time-in-lesson ( r = .07). In other words, regardless of the time they spent, subjects in the choice group learned equally or were equally satisfied with the instruction. Therefore, it is concluded that early completion was no indication of lack of comprehension or interest in the lesson. As shown in figure 6, there were some outliers and one extreme in the choice group. It was thought that the data of these outliers and one extreme may have caused the difference in variability in time-in-lesson between the choice and no-choice groups. A Bartlett test was conducted to test this assumption after eliminating the data of outliers and extreme. The result revealed that there was also difference in variability between the two groups (.95X21 = 3.22, p < .10). The researcher observed that the subjects who finished quickly seemed to be already familiar with the instructional materials and concentrated on the part they did not know already. Their study pattern was considered as intensive learning. One might also assume that the subjects who spent a longer time than any others did not focus on the study. However, it was observed that the subjects who spent a long time did not do so because they were distracted from the lesson but simply because they continued working on it. Their study pattern was considered as persisted learning. As revealed in the preliminary analyses, there were no differences in the subjects’ backgrounds, such as prior knowledge of the subject, between the choice and no-choice groups. In other words, in the no-choice
< previous page
page_59
next page >
< previous page
page_60
next page >
Page 60 group, as in the choice group, some subjects were already familiar with the subject. However, the presence of all the outliers and the extreme only in the choice group implies that by enhancing their intrinsic motivation, the choice of instructional control gave the subjects a chance to assess their level of knowledge. In contrast, the subjects in the no-choice group followed the lesson rather mechanically. Therefore the no-choice group subjects all finished almost in the same length of time. CONCLUSION AND FUTURE STUDY Instructional designers have argued that LC has beneficial consequences for both motivation and cognition (Kinzie 1990; Merrill 1980; Ross and Morrison 1989). However, as Carrier (1985) pointed out, previous research does not support the argument: studies comparing the effectiveness of LC with PC have shown mixed and inconsistent results. Their failure to prove the effectiveness of LC in CBI could be viewed from the point of view of choice and control theory. In other words, this research ignored that students might not want the control and that, as a consequence, the freedom of choice does not link to positive learning behaviors. No previous study in CBI has been done from the learner’s role in making a choice of control. As an exploratory study, the generalizability of the present study has limitations; however, the results seem to have important implications for instructional design. The primary contribution of this study is the demonstration of the possibility that allowing students to choose the type of instructional control may increase students’ motivation. The choice group’s satisfaction and time-in-lesson data suggest they may have been more highly motivated. In a comprehensive review of LC, Williams (1997, 961) concluded that “learner control or program control might be better for some people or under some conditions, but not on the whole.” Hence, both types of instructional control play an important role in accommodating individual differences. This study opens a practical solution to this situation. With today’s technology, it is feasible to provide two types of instructional control and allow students to choose. If the definition of LC is allowing students to exercise their own judgment on their learning process, choosing the type of instructional control in CBI is one of the instructional decisions and can be a type of LC, but it has received little scholarly attention. As Freitag and Sullivan (1995) proposed, allowing students to choose the type of instructional control by providing both types of instruction may be an alternative form of LC. The results of this study also suggest that when the choice is given, the determinants of choice should be considered. In this information age, making choices plays an increasingly important role in shaping the course people follow through life. Often, people have too many choices or poor options. If choices are to be provided effectively, psychological determinants in giving and receiving choice should be considered. For instance, on a Web page, questions must be asked, such as how many choices should be given, how the options should be presented, or whether the visitors will be aware of these choices. Determinants of choice are issues we know little about in CBI. For example, Lepper and Malone (1987, 239) argued, “There is a potential danger in believing that additional choices will always enhance motivation.” Gray’s (1987) study reported that students showed more negative attitudes toward LC than toward PC in CBI, and she concluded that too much choice provided in LC could distract students. In Lahey and Crawford’s study (1976), when 16 possible strategies were given to navy students in studying electronics, most of the students used only three of the strategies consistently. Cordova and Lepper (1996) also pointed out the issues of novelty and habituation: if motivational embellishment strategies, such as providing choices, were overused, their positive effects could dissipate over time. This present study demonstrates that even when the choice is simple, but satisfies the conditions of determinants of choice, positive effects can be expected. As an exploratory study, the present study has some limitations and points to suggestions for further research. First, it assumed that allowing students to choose the type of
< previous page
page_60
next page >
< previous page
page_61
next page >
Page 61 instructional control at the beginning of the study with information about the options would satisfy the determinants of perceived choices. As a consequence, the choice may positively affect students’ behavior. However, this study did not ask subjects about the feeling of choice per se (i.e., the degree of the subject’s perception of choice). Among the choice group, the individuals’ degree of perceived choice might be different. The question of whether the provided choice options evoke the feeling of choice should be investigated. In addition, the relationship between the degree of perceived choice and motivation needs to be studied. Second, the study was conducted under the assumption that students were able to choose the effective type of instruction control based on their needs. It is also possible that students may have only a limited ability to choose their effective type of instruction. Cognitive or metacognitive characteristics of students may affect their choice. Research needs to be conducted to determine the relationship between the effectiveness of students’ choice and their cognitive or metacognitive characteristics. Third, the amount of information provided to the students to guide their decisions may be a critical variable and one that needs to be investigated in more detail. As too many choices do not enhance motivation, too much information provided with the choice options would not help the sense of choice either. Fourth, it is possible that the instructional control type students initially choose may not be the type of instruction they have expected. As a consequence, students’ choice may not heighten their achievement or enhance their satisfaction. Hannafin (1984) suggested that a provision should be made for switching to the other option in CBI. That is, if initial learning is ineffective under one control strategy, subjects should be able to switch to the other control option. Psychologically, students allowed to switch their first choice anytime may feel more freedom than when there is no way to switch after they have made the choice. Providing switch options would be another way to improve students’ learning in CBI. If two types of instructional control are available, it will also be feasible for the instructional designers to provide the switch option. Further research is needed on the provision of switching options. NOTES 1. To analyze the time-in-lesson data, the amount of time was converted to seconds. Even though the choice group and no-choice group had identical contents after they started the lesson, the choice group had one more selection step that the no-choice group did not have: making a choice between two types of instructional control. Hence, the choice group spent extra time in order to select the type of instructional control. Therefore, before analyzing the time-in-lesson, the actual selection time that individual subjects in the choice group spent on making a choice was subtracted from the amount of individuals’ completion time. The average of time spent for selecting a type in the choice group was 85.91 seconds ( s = 88.19). 2. Because the weights of two tests were different, the original scores were converted to z scores. 3. To compare two different means with different variability, the Welch t′ test was conducted. It showed that the two groups’ time difference was not significant ( t′ = 1.04; p > .1). REFERENCES Carrier, C. (1985). Introduction: Exploring computers and individual differences. Educational Communication and Technology Journal 33:3, 155–157. Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed.). New York: Academic Press. Cordova, D., and Lepper, M. R. (1996). Intrinsic motivation and the process of learning: Beneficial effects of contextualization, personalization, and choice. Journal of Educational Psychology 88:4, 715–730. Deci, E. L. (1980). The psychology of self-determination. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books. Deci, E. L. and Ryan, R. M. (1985). Intrinsic motivation and self-determinating in human behavior. New York: Plenum Press.
< previous page
page_61
next page >
< previous page
page_62
next page >
Page 62 Freitag, E., and Sullivan, H. J. (1995). Matching learner preference to amount of instruction: An alternative form of learner control. Educational Technology, Research, and Development 43:2, 5–13. Glass, G. V., and Hopkins, K. D. (1996). Statistical methods in education and psychology (3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Gray, S. H. (1987). The effect of sequence control on computer-assisted learning. Journal of Computer-Based Instruction 14:2, 54–56. Hannafin, M. (1984). Guidelines for using locus of instructional control in design of computer-assisted instruction. Journal of Instructional Development 7:3, 6–10. Harvey, J. H., and Johnston, S. (1973). Determinants of the perception of choice. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 9, 164–179. Jellison, J. M., and Harvey, J. H. (1973). Determinants of perceived choice and the relationship between perceived choice and perceived competence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 28, 376–382. Kail, R. V. Jr. (1975). Freedom of choice, task performance, and task persistence. Journal of Experimental Education 44:1, 33–35. Keller, J. M. (1983). Motivational design of instruction. In C. M. Reigeluth (ed.), Instructional-design theories and models: An overview of their current status. Hillsdale, NY: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Kinzie, M. B. (1990). Requirements and benefits of effective interactive instruction: Learner control, self-regulation, and continuing motivation. Educational Technology, Research, and Development 38:1, 1–21. Lahey, G. F., and Crawford, A.M. (1976, April). Learner control of lesson strategy: Some tentative results. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco. Langer, E. J. (1975). The illusion of control. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 32, 311–328. Lepper, M. R., and Malone, T. W. (1987). Intrinsic motivation and instructional effectiveness in computer-based education. In R. E. Snow and M. J. Farr (eds.), Aptitude, learning, and instruction: Aptitude and affective process and analyses. Volume 3. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Maehr, M. L. (1984). Meaning and motivation: toward a theory of personal investment. In R. E. Ames and C. Ames (eds.), Research on motivation in education. Orlando, FL: Academic Press. Merrill, M. D. (1980). Learner control in computer based learning. Computers and Education 4, 77–95. Myrow, D. (1979). Learner choice and task engagement. Journal of Experimental Education 47:3, 200–207. Perlmuter, L. C., and Monty, R. A. (1977). The importance of perceived control: Fact or fantasy? American Scientist 65, 759–765. Ross, S. M., and Morrison, G. R. (1989). In search of a happy medium in instructional technology research: Issues concerning external validity, media replications, and learner control. Educational Technology, Research, and Development 37:1, 19–33. Savage, R. E., Perlmuter, L. C., and Monty, R. A. (1979). Effect of reduction in the amount of choice and the perception of control on learning. In L. C. Perlmuter and R. A. Monty (eds.), Choice and perceived control. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Steinberg, E. R. (1991). Computer-assisted instruction: A synthesis of theory, practice, and technology. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Stipek, D. J., and Weisz, J. R. (1981). Perceived personal control and academic achievement. Review of Educational Research 51:1, 101–137. Swann, W. B. Jr. and Pittman, T. S. (1977). Initiating play activity of children: The moderating influence of verbal cues on intrinsic motivation. Child Development 48:3, 1128–1132.
< previous page
page_62
next page >
< previous page
page_63
next page >
Page 63 Williams, M. D. (1997). Learner-control and instructional technologies. In D. H. Jonassen (ed.), Handbook of research for educational communications and technology. New York: Macmillan Library. Zuckerman, M., Porac, J., Lathin, D., Smith, R., and Deci, E. L. (1978). On the importance of self-determination for intrinsically-motivated behavior. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 4:3, 443–446.
< previous page
page_63
next page >
< previous page
page_64
next page >
page_64
next page >
Page 64 This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_65
next page >
page_65
next page >
Page 65 Ethics and Privacy
< previous page
< previous page
page_66
next page >
page_66
next page >
Page 66 This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_67
next page >
Page 67 Considerations for Assessing Ethical Issues Erin Brewer Nick Eastmond Reed Geertsen Utah State University INTRODUCTION The code of ethics published by the Association for Educational Communications and Technology (AECT) (2002) is the authority usually cited in discussions of professional ethics in the field of instructional technology. This code offers time-tested prescriptions for measuring behavior to see if an action is acceptable to our peers. For many of us, the code offers a way of anticipating behaviors that could cause present or future difficulty. The AECT Code of Ethics can be thought of as a fence to keep people from engaging in behavior contrary to the interest of our community of professionals and the public we serve. In this article, we take a wider view to help identify ethical issues and to select strategies for handling behaviors ranging from inconsiderate or unprofessional to immoral or illegal. We offer a classification scheme along with a typology of reactions for dealing with the inappropriate actions of others. Our position is that if properly identified and handled in a socially responsible way, unacceptable professional behavior can be dealt with effectively with minimal disruption to people’s lives. The professional development of AECT is enhanced when all of us seek to build our own ethical sensitivity and thereby avoid engaging in inappropriate behavior. We can also raise each other’s sensitivity when ethical issues are examined and responded to within the framework of appropriate social roles. This way of looking at the world recognizes the fact that ethical judgments are based on values and social roles that overlap with our professional roles and affiliations. Furthermore, appropriate responses to inappropriate professional behavior varies according to one’s social location in relation to the violator. On the one hand, our extraprofessional roles contribute to the frames of reference we use to help shape our personal interpretations of professional ethics. In this regard, all interpretations of ethics are influenced by the fact that everyone has their own set of “cultural blinders,’’ so that some of our prescriptions may appear “cultural bound” to some readers. On the other hand, an appropriate response to a perceived ethical violation for a person in a superordinate position of authority may be ethically inappropriate for a person in a subordinate or parallel position to the violator. The question of inappropriate ethical behavior requires two separate judgments. First, how unacceptable is the behavior? Second, what is the appropriate response to the behavior? We believe that it is worthwhile and indeed possible to develop classification schemes and typologies to clarify these issues within any particular culture. The search for a common ground for these conventions among individuals with diverse backgrounds and different social locations is a worthwhile goal of any professional association. We further believe that ethical judgments that rely on different philosophical underpinnings have more in common with each other than most people might expect. To illustrate this, we will present ethical dilemmas and the responses to these dilemmas by two people with differing approaches. We realize that we are attempting to address a set of questions that have occupied philosophers, as well as secular and religious leaders, since the dawn of history. There are
< previous page
page_67
next page >
< previous page
page_68
next page >
Page 68 genuine differences of opinion among well-meaning people when these questions are discussed; this is what makes them “issues.” Some of these differences can be attributed to positional influences on social perceptions. We offer our ideas as a basis for future discussion but realize that this discussion will hardly be the last word or the definitive statement on this matter. If we can help clarify the issues and perhaps provide a broader social context for understanding ethical behavior, we will have succeeded in our task. A CONTINUUM FOR ASSESSING INAPPROPRIATE ACTIONS In our discussions with students learning about ethics and with professionals in the field, we find that it is helpful to be able to label actions according to their position on a continuum roughly from “Acceptable” to ‘‘Heinous,” recognizing that the actions that fall under these labels vary based on culture and environment (see fig. 1). As already mentioned, we believe that moral, ethical, and legal codes can be viewed as fences to keep people from social harm. Although some may view fences as containers, thus unduly constraining personal choice, we view these fences as guidelines that help us make more informed choices, which in turn can help us avoid decisions and actions that could be viewed as ethical compromises. Fences are put on the edge of cliffs to prevent people from falling. They are put around hazardous waste dumps to prevent people from being exposed to toxins. They are placed along freeways to prevent people from getting killed or maimed by oncoming cars. Just as physical fences are used to prevent people from physical harm, moral, ethical, and legal guidelines can help people avoid ethical violations and subsequent loss of professional esteem. They also keep us from inflicting social harm on others. Fences are also used to protect the collective interests of the many from the harmful actions of the few, such as by keeping trespassers off private property. Our position is that each of these categories—legal, ethical, and moral—serve as a “fence” to keep individuals from stepping into territory with potentially grievous consequences. In many instances, one, two, or three of these guidelines or “fences” signal an area of potential liability. Behavior can be unethical without being illegal, immoral without being unethical, and even illegal without being immoral. It is more likely, however, that these categories will overlap, thus providing multiple fences to help guard the individual from harm’s way. Three cases are presented below to help provide a clearer understanding of the ethical, legal, and moral fences that collectively inform both the perceptions of both our professional colleagues and the general public. Case 1 Sally Doe gave a presentation at recent conference. She exceeded her allotted time to such a degree that people coming to see the next scheduled presentation found her still presenting to an audience. Several people who came to see the next presenter left thinking there was a mistake in the schedule. Sally Doe ignored those entering and leaving the Figure 1. A Continuum of Inappropriate Actions
< previous page
page_68
next page >
< previous page
page_69
next page >
Page 69 room, an action that not only left the second presenter with very little time to present but also eliminated nearly all of her audience. How inappropriate was this behavior? What, if anything, could someone else have done? Although to many, the first presenter’s actions might be viewed as “inconsiderate,” they likely would not be seen as immoral. However, she was giving the presentation at a professional meeting and was therefore performing in a professional role. As a result, her behavior would most likely be viewed by her colleagues as “unprofessional” and bordering on “unethical” by way of Section 1.9 of the AECT Code of Ethics. That section reads that members “Shall refrain from any behavior that would be judged discriminatory, harassing, insensitive, or offensive and, thus, is in conflict with valuing and promoting each individual’s integrity, rights, and opportunity within a diverse profession and society.’’ The foregoing statement reflects a strong concern for the impact of one’s behavior on the social “rights” and “opportunities” of others. The social consequences of behavior are important considerations in most ethical assessments. These social consequences are also more difficult to anticipate than the more immediate reactions to the “discriminatory” or “harassing” aspects of behavior. Taking more than the allotted time expressing one’s point of view is considered rude in a professional conference setting. This sort of breach can have serious social consequences for others, as was the case for the next scheduled presenter and for those who wanted to hear his presentation. If Sally Doe had taken her discussion out into the hall rather than use the conference room, her behavior would have changed from unprofessional to inconsiderate. Nevertheless, it would still not be socially acceptable because by her continuing beyond her allotted time, individuals in her session are still probably drawn away from the audience for the next presentation. This, in turn, negatively impacts the social “opportunity” of the subsequent presenter. Case 2 An online course administration system was set up so that an instructor could receive an electronic copy of all emails students sent from the class site without the students knowing about it. The system allowed students to send both class-related as well as personal e-mails from the class site. Tom Doe, a faculty member using the carbon copy (CC) option, noticed a potentially embarrassing e-mail sent by a male student to a female who was probably his girlfriend. One of his colleagues heard Tom read this e-mail out loud in an area where several others could hear its contents and the name of the sender. Tom Doe laughed at the student and made a derogatory comment about the student’s lack of intelligence. How inappropriate was Tom’s behavior? What, if anything, should an observing colleague have done? Is this behavior illegal, unethical, or immoral? Secretly monitoring e-mail messages is certainly unethical. How does the instructor’s reading the e-mail from the class to his colleagues influence our ethical judgment of his action? Does it make it even more illegal? Although employers may have the right to monitor employee’s e-mails, a federally funded university probably does not. In addition to being potentially illegal, it is clearly unethical by way of the AECT Code of Ethics Section 1.4, which states that members “Shall conduct professional business so as to protect the privacy and maintain the personal integrity of the individual.” Even though this instructor’s behavior was clearly unethical and possibly illegal, it was apparently not immoral to him. Case 3 During the term in which a course was taught, one of the class members in a graduate seminar was involved in opening a restaurant. One day in class, he invited the entire class (about eight people) to hold class and eat at his restaurant during the next scheduled class period. Following the meal, when the instructor and other class members attempted to pay, the student refused, saying that he was acting as host and that providing the meal was something he just wanted to do. What should the instructor have done? Would accepting the student’s offer to cover costs be considered unethical or immoral?
< previous page
page_69
next page >
< previous page
page_70
next page >
Page 70 The third case presents a problem frequently encountered in indirect exchanges. In this type of exchange, one party is expected to perform a service for another but is not to receive direct payment for that service from the recipient because it might compromise the way that service is to be performed. Instead, the party performing the service is reciprocated from a third party who in turn is reciprocated from the party receiving the service. For example, university students pay fixed rates of tuition to the university, the university hires and pays faculty according to some set pay scale, and faculty teach and grade students using impartial standards. But in all three instances, the exchanges are to be kept impersonal and indirect in order for the system to work. These types of exchanges are typical in society, where people do things for others as representatives of some larger organization and in which evaluations must be made. In fact, where people are rewarded indirectly, the acceptance of a direct reward in what is supposed to be an impartial or impersonal relationship is against the rules. A professor who charges his or her students extra tuition for services rendered has compromised the system of indirect exchange and has engaged in inappropriate behavior. Although less extreme, paying for an instructor’s dinner, or several dinners, during the term in which the student is to receive a grade breaches the rules of indirect exchange because direct exchanges tend to obligate and induce reciprocity. In ethics this problem is often referred to as a “conflict of interest.” Assessments of “inappropriate” behavior are influenced by a variety of other social influences that overlap with professional work and affiliations. Religious training and involvement with youth groups are two such examples. These possible personal influences on ethical judgments are examined next. How someone responds to the above three cases will depend on many factors, but we would like to show how similar conclusions about the appropriateness of behavior in each of the cases presented can be reached by two people using very different perspectives. THE INFLUENCE OF RELIGION John Doe is an active member of a Christian church. Its religious code of moral behavior is generally more inclusive than either ethical or legal sanctions. In most cases, John seeks guidance from the Bible through regular Bible study. Through this study, he finds direction for his moral and ethical compass. By reading the scriptures daily as counseled by his ecclesiastical leaders and as counseled in Deuteronomy 17:19, he attempts to address life’s perplexing moral situations. Sometimes he falls short but recognizes that Christianity is built on the belief in divine help through repentance and faith in Christ, the cornerstone of his religion. He recognizes that others in his society may not share his specific beliefs, but it does not change the value of having the help of the scriptures for his own “moral compass.” Although the AECT Code of Ethics has provisions (Section 2.4) dealing with ethical dilemmas, he more frequently relies on scripture and a moral sense of right and wrong. Case 1 In the first situation, the presenter who has gone overtime has violated the Golden Rule, paraphrased as “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you” (Leviticus 19:18). The long-winded presenter has lost sight of the impact of her actions on others. No one would want to be treated this way. It is clearly a social violation. Case 2 In the case of the disclosed confidence about the contents of an e-mail message, the Golden Rule could again be invoked. However, more specific things about speech can give guidance. From Proverbs 16:21: “The wise in heart shall be called prudent, and the sweetness of the lips increaseth learning.’’ And verse 27: “An ungodly man diggeth up evil; and in his lips there is as a burning fire.” The problem here is that the teacher has not been careful with the confidential message entrusted to him.
< previous page
page_70
next page >
< previous page
page_71
next page >
Page 71 Case 3 A scripture from the Bible provides insight into the third case, which seems on the surface to be relatively harmless: “Judges and officers,…Thou shall not wrest judgment; thou shall not respect persons, neither take a gift; for a gift doth blind the eyes of the wise, and pervert the words of the righteous” (Deuteronomy 16:18–19). The teacher of this class would be in a position to judge the student’s performance when giving him a grade; therefore, accepting the gift would be morally wrong. THE INFLUENCE OF HUMAN RIGHTS Mary Doe is not an active member of any religious institution and therefore does not have a specific religious code on which to base her actions. Instead of relying on a religious code for informing her choices, she is heavily influenced by the notion of social contract, relying upon the Constitution of the United States and the Bill of Rights, as well as an internal sense of right and wrong based on a liberal humanist view that all people have inherent value. The fact that she and others have the freedom to wrestle with ethical decisions is a direct result of a social contract that provides a legal fence; however, it is not as prohibitive as the professional ethics fence. She finds that protecting individuals’ fundamental rights is a solid compass for assessing ethical dilemmas. In addition, because the framers of the Constitution were careful to preserve the rights of individuals, many ethical dilemmas are not clearly covered by legal dictate. In these cases, Mary is somewhat of a moral pragmatist, and once again, preservation of individual rights is a strong imperative in how she assesses behavior. On what basis does she make these extralegal judgments? Despite not having any specific religious doctrine to rely on as a moral compass, she finds that most of her specific moral beliefs are encapsulated in the Girl Scout Law. (She currently serves as a local Girl Scout leader.) As a leader, she teaches and has had her Girl Scouts memorize the following: I will do my best to be honest and fair, Friendly and helpful, Considerate and caring, Courageous and strong, And Responsible for what I say and do; And to Respect myself and others, Respect authority, Use resources wisely, Make the world a better place, And be a sister to every Girl Scout. She believes, as part of her moral compass, that the last line should be extended to “everyone.” It is interesting that this law was developed for a diverse religious and cultural population, as the Girl Scouts are an international organization. As a result of this need to be inclusive of a diverse population, it is also very general and therefore does not offer specific behavioral prescriptions. Because she does not have strict tenets to guide her behavior, Mary must grapple with each morally challenging situation and determine the correct ethical or moral choice for her. Surprisingly, though, despite its brevity and generality, she feels that Girl Scout Law captures the basics of most moral behavior; the difference between it and a religious doctrine is that it does not offer specific situational solutions to moral dilemmas. Case 1 When a proposal is accepted by a conference, presenters are given the opportunity to share their work with colleagues. In exchange, the presenters agree to adhere to the structures of the conference. In case 1, Sally Doe fails to adhere to the time allotted to her by conference organizers, thus violating a tacit agreement between her and the conference organizers. This behavior is therefore unethical because it threatens the core compact upon which conferences are built.
< previous page
page_71
next page >
< previous page
page_72
next page >
Page 72 Case 2 In case 2, Tom Doe is violating a student’s right to privacy, a right guaranteed by the Constitution. By sharing the contents of the email with a colleague, the instructor also violates the Federal Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA), an act designed to protect students’ privacy. Therefore this action is probably illegal on two fronts, violating the student’s Constitutional rights as well as violating FERPA. In addition, it is immoral. Instructors are vested with power over their students, and any behavior that exploits this power is immoral. Case 3 When the student suggested meeting in a different venue, Mary would have thanked him for his offer, but declined. The instructor has a contract with students to meet at a certain time in a specified place. Asking students to move class could have inconvenienced them, and social pressures may make it difficult for the students to express their concerns. Because members of professional groups frequently adhere to somewhat different moral standards, a professional code of ethics is helpful in bringing consensus to a diverse group, in much the same way that the Girl Scout Law provides general principles of behavior for Girl Scouts and their leaders. A professional code of ethics is important to bring consistency to how people with radically different moral codes like John Doe and Mary Doe deal with ethical dilemmas. What this means, however, is that there will be choices that are viewed by some as ethically wrong that may not be morally or legally wrong and vice versa. RESPONSES TO INAPPROPRIATE ACTIONS Although categorizing behaviors can be perplexing at times, determining an appropriate response to an inappropriate action can be even more challenging. It may sometimes be easier to take an ethical or legal relativist approach, but in some cases not addressing an ethical or legal violation can itself be unethical or illegal. And there are cases when a person feels morally required to take action even though there is no ethical or legal imperative. Just as there is a range of behaviors that can be classified from “appropriate” to ‘‘inappropriate,” there is a range of actions that can be taken when inappropriate behavior is encountered. These can be viewed as a continuum of interventions ranging from mild to severe (see fig. 2). We believe that just as a parent is better off intervening with action that is as benign as possible—a child should not be scolded or reprimanded if a simple “knowing look” obtains compliance—someone trying to deal with the inappropriate behavior of a coworker should use milder interventions before moving to severe ones. More severe interventions invite defensiveness, resistance, or retaliation, so the gentler correction is certainly preferable—if it works. The placement of choices along the continuum shown in figure 2 often reflects an individual’s personal style and intensity of commitment to moral codes. For example, some may be more inclined to confront a person directly before appealing to an authority figure, whereas others feel more comfortable passing the responsibility directly to an authority figure. With this in mind, we will look at how Mary and John say they would respond to each of the cases. In case 1, Mary and John are positioned as members of the presenter’s audience. In case 2, Mary and John are the faculty member with whom the offending instructor is sharing the e-mail. And in the third case, Mary is a student in the class where the proposal to meet at a restaurant was made, and John is the faculty member who teaches the class. John Doe John Doe’s reactions to the three cases are presented in the first person.
< previous page
page_72
next page >
< previous page
page_73
next page >
Page 73 Figure 2. Options for Intervention
Case 1 “As a member of the audience, I would be aware that one speaker has gone 10 minutes overtime. I would raise my hand and point out that fact and would probably do it as a question: ‘Am I right in assuming that the two of you were to divide the time equally? If so, I’m interested in hearing from Person X (oblique confrontation).’ If my hand was not recognized, I might stand up and blurt out the same message (direct confrontation), if I felt strongly enough about it (and that is not unlikely). If totally ignored, I would probably walk out (noncompliance). If I felt strongly enough about it, I might send a note to the conference organizers, letting them know of my displeasure (appeal to authority).” Case 2 “If I overheard another teacher talk about elements in the private e-mail of a student, I would probably go to the colleague in private and share my concern (direct confrontation). That decision, to confront or not, would depend on my relationship with that person, if I thought it was strong enough to handle a bit of strain. If not, I might take up the matter with an administrator over the program (appeal to authority). I most certainly would inform members of my class that the e-mails they are sending should not be considered private (preventing the situation). I would caution my students at least to avoid putting material into their e-mails that is overly personal. I would hold the communication between peers to be private, really none of my business, and as much as possible avoid monitoring or reading it, even if the technology did allow that option for teachers.” Case 3 “In the case of the gifted meal, as the instructor, I would have to see myself as a judge who had received a gift. Because my job would require that I judge or grade the student’s class performance, I would have to recognize that accepting the gift of the meal for the entire class could influence my judgment and therefore would be inappropriate. I would go to the student, possibly after the meal if I did not recognize this problem beforehand, assure the student that the class appreciated his hospitality, but I would insist that it was my moral obligation to pay for all class members. By insisting that the student accept the money, a potentially difficult situation would have been averted when grades were given out.” Although the AECT Code of Ethics has a similar provision (Section 2.4), for this particular instructor, it is more likely that the scripture would produced the realization that accepting the gift would be inappropriate. Another person might have felt obligated to pay for the meals by way of the AECT provision. Mary Doe Mary Doe’s responses to the three cases are also presented in the first person.
< previous page
page_73
next page >
< previous page
page_74
next page >
Page 74 Case 1 ‘‘As a member of an audience in which a presenter exceeds their allotted time, I would be uncomfortable because I do not have the authority to respond in a proactive way, but I would feel an imperative to do something. I can imagine a number of different responses, and of course these responses would be different depending on whether I was enjoying the presentation or anxious to have it conclude. If I was interested in the presentation, I would tell the presenter that I am interested in what she is saying and ask her if she could give me references to publications or Web sites so I could learn more because the time for the presentation had expired. If I was not enjoying the presentation, I would probably get up and leave when the presentation time had expired.” Case 2 “I would report this violation to an appropriate authority figure rather than confronting the colleague directly. In this case, I feel that the instructor acted both unethically and immorally, but the department head is also partly to blame for using a system that allowed the instructor to violate the student’s right to privacy. Confronting the instructor may have altered his behavior, but it would not get at the source of the problem. In this case, an appeal to authority would be the only way to ensure that the system would be changed to prevent future ethical, moral, or legal violations of students’ privacy.” Case 3 “As a student in this situation, I would make a counterproposal that we meet at the restaurant after the semester was over to celebrate classes being over, thus moving a social event to a more appropriate time and place. By doing this, the instructor would maintain the contract he or she made with the students to hold class at a specific time and place, and the students in the class would not feel that the student who owned the restaurant gained any advantage on them in the instructor’s eyes by treating the class to a meal.” In the professional setting of AECT, a person would be generally well advised to simply approach a coworker and suggest that there are ways to handle copyright within the law rather than blowing the whistle and notifying the employer or the owner of the copyright. The small number of cases actually reported to the AECT Ethics Committee (less than a handful of cases in the past decade) implies that most corrections of ethical violations take place elsewhere. Appealing to the professional ethics committee of AECT, a fairly serious step, might be seen as an “appeal to authority” among professional peers. Such actions are not taken lightly. In addition, Whicker and Kronenfeld (1994) report in a survey of workers on a college campus that 65 percent of faculty respondents reported being fearful of retaliation from coworkers if they chose to report inappropriate behaviors to an authority. The low number of cases brought to the AECT Ethics Committee could also indicate that members do not view AECT as a potent authority. Because AECT is in no way an exclusive association, a person expelled from AECT would have several alternative professional groups to join. Therefore censure by the AECT Ethics Committee may not pack the punch needed to be considered an authority as do organizations such as the American Medical Association or the American Bar Association. THE SOCIAL RELATIVITY OF RESPONSES TO INAPPROPRIATE ACTIONS It is possible to take ethical stances in our profession even when individuals are coming from quite different philosophical or religious positions, as illustrated by the views and responses of Mary Doe and John Doe. We would argue that this congruence indicates an underlying moral order to our society and a fairly high level of agreement among its individuals, including an agreement, generally, to tolerate differences. However, appropri-
< previous page
page_74
next page >
< previous page
page_75
next page >
Page 75 ate actions are always contingent on social circumstances, and this is where a well-intended response to a clearly agreed upon inappropriate behavior can still lead to trouble. Robert Merton (1957) was one of the first social scientists to point out that much of our behavior takes place within the context of social roles. Our performance in these roles is influenced by the reactions of other role partners, who are typically arrayed in what Merton calls a role set. Partners in a role set vary according to their authority and responsibility for monitoring the role behaviors of others in role relationships. They also vary in the frequency of their contact and in the observability of others’ role behavior. The idea of ethics is inherently connected to social roles and the social norms connected to these social roles because most ethical issues focus on the negative social impacts of unethical behaviors on others. The responses given by Mary and John could be radically different if their role in the situation was changed. For instance, if Mary were a conference organizer rather than just a member of the audience, chances are that she would have been much more active in her response to the presenter who was taking too much time. There are also the roles of current presenter, listener in the audience, session presider (if there is one), next presenter, intended listener to the next presenter, program coordinator, and so on. Some of these roles have official authority over conference activities, and other do not. Appropriate responses in one role may be inappropriate, and may even constitute an ethical violation, if carried out in another role. On the other hand, if someone does not act, then negative social consequences are inevitable. Otherwise, there would be no need for a normative time limit on presentations. Furthermore, when violations of ethical norms get ignored, ethical behaviors typically decline over time because people tend to pay greatest attention to those aspects of behavior that others deem to be important enough to sanction when inappropriate. But sanctioning also must be appropriate according to the recognized authority in role relationships. Otherwise, efforts to correct inappropriate behavior are likely to lead to hostility and retribution. An appropriate response to inappropriate behavior varies according to the social position of the responder. Even within the same role, Mary’s probable response in case 1 varies depending on her interest in the presentation. In either case, her response would be socially appropriate for someone in the role of an audience member. John is more active in his response by asking a question about the time, thus giving the presenter a chance to avoid a confrontation. Because these kinds of situations are not uncommon at conferences, our professional association may be well served by developing a series of tactful comments that anyone might use regardless of their role to reduce the likelihood of direct confrontations in situations such as this. Both Mary and John are sensitive to authority issues in the second case study. Mary seems less inclined to directly confront someone she knows and with whom she works. John seems more concerned about preserving a collegial relationship than about changing a system of numerous potential ethical violations. Both responses show a broader assessment of the social positions of those involved and a wider array of possible responses contingent on one’s social position. For example, John mediates his response by how well he knows the violator. Both have a concern for students’ rights to privacy; however, Mary is concerned about all students, whereas John is more concerned about his immediate role partners, that is, his own students. The reactions of the two respondents show how responses to inappropriate behavior may sometimes ignore the broader implications of social roles in deciding how to respond to a violation. They also show that in other instances, such as a personal colleague, greater consideration of social roles is more likely to enter into the decision of how to respond. Mary seems to be less patient in finding a solution and may be too quick to involve authority. However, as she noted, she feels that the crux of the problem was not with her colleague but with the system that allowed him to abuse his student’s rights. A personal confrontation with the colleague who read the e-mail is more consistent with the similarity in social standing of the two role partners. In all responses to inappropriate behaviors of professional colleagues, we would hope to see more responses prefaced by a statement indicating some reflection upon social circumstance: “It depends on my relationship to the
< previous page
page_75
next page >
< previous page
page_76
next page >
Page 76 violator! If I’m a lay member of the audience, if I’m the next presenter, if I’m the session coordinator,” and so on. Likewise, “I’m a close friend, I’m a department head, I’m the chair of the person’s tenure committee, I’m a close friend of the computer network administrator,” and so forth. In the third case, considerable difficulty can be avoided if the consequences of the action can be foreseen and thus avoided. Mary’s status as a student suggests a different course of action than John’s action as a teacher. And the timing of the response is important as well. If the dinner comes after grades are turned in for the class, as Mary suggests, then the influence of the gift on judgment is avoided. CONCLUDING THOUGHTS Just as some people work within dietary restrictions to maintain health, some will see actions mentioned here as outside their moral code. Followers of Mahatma Ghandi would disavow all use of force to bring about a change in another person, thus ignoring the option for personal use of force and avoiding the consequences of fighting and war but possibly losing their own life. A variety of other stances are possible. The appropriate response to the inappropriate actions of others, however, should not usurp the legitimate authority of others unless they fail to fulfill their obligations to protect our collective ethical obligations. Our classifications of items on both continua are meant not to give license to inappropriate action but rather to suggest the range of possibilities that we see. We have also tried to clarify some of the social circumstances that should be considered prior to responding to inappropriate behaviors that may threaten the ethical integrity of our profession. A moral relativist might feel most comfortable in a world without fences; however, in professional associations, it is important to have a code of ethics that provides a degree of common agreement for members. It is important to have a code of ethics to fall back on when assessing behavior. The code can act as something of a parent to those who have difficulty with arguing a decision made on ethical grounds. “I’d love to make an illegal copy of this software for you, but it is against the AECT code of ethics (and the law)” may be a moral cop-out, but it is one way to handle an uncomfortable situation. AECT’s fence does not suggest that the AECT Code of Ethics should supercede a moral or legal fence but suggests rather that there is common agreement about what actions lie within ethical behavior and what actions do not; therefore, the code acts more as a reinforcement to moral and legal fences. It should be noted that in many cases, a personal code of behavior will prevent the need to refer to the professional code. By following the AECT Code of Ethics, we ensure professional integrity and a set of common assumptions about what is acceptable and what is not. By knowing the basis for our action, we are more likely to act consistently and in harmony with principles and values to which we subscribe. At the same time, we must remember that ethics serve to protect the collectivity from the negative social consequences of inappropriate behavior. If we are not careful, however, our out-of-role responses to inappropriate behavior can have many of the same negative social consequences as the behaviors we are trying to prevent. REFERENCES Association for Educational Communications and Technology. (2002). AECT Code of Professional Ethics. [Online]. Available: http://aect.org/about/Ethics.htm. (Accessed February 2002). Merton, R. K. (1957). Social theory and social structure. Glencoe, IL: Free Press. Welliver, P. W., ed. (2001). A code of professional ethics: A guide to professional conduct in the field of educational communications and technology. Bloomington, IN: Association for Educational Technology. Whicker, M. L., and Kronenfeld, J. J. (1994). Dealing with ethical dilemmas on campus. Thousand Oaks, CA. Sage.
< previous page
page_76
next page >
< previous page
page_77
next page >
Page 77 Developing Ethical Behaviors in Students What Schools Must Do Doug Johnson Director of Media and Technology Mankato Area Public Schools, Mankato, Minnesota Stories abound that can cause any educator nightmares: • A student is caught downloading pornographic materials on school computers. • A student is abducted by a stranger she has met in an Internet chat room. • Students hack into a school server and cause damage. • A student uses the printer in the computer lab to print reams of encyclopedia pages. • A student sets up a satirical “school’’ Web site that appears critical of individual teachers. • Parents complain to the school board when their children are suspected of plagiarizing materials from the Internet. • A student receives unsavory spam sent to his school e-mail account. • Students use the Internet to locate information from hate groups. And the list goes on. Highly publicized stories like these are enough to make even the strongest proponent of technology use in schools wonder if technology is worth the problems it generates. It is sometimes difficult to remember that technology is neutral. It is neither evil nor holy. The same hammer that builds a cathedral can be efficiently used to break the cathedral’s windows. The same mechanical engineering that caused the traffic accident takes the injured to the hospital. The same Internet connection that helps students find great information for a term paper can be used to download pornography. Of all the understandings that school leaders need to have about technology, its proper use is easily the most important. Adults teach by example, so they must exemplify safe and ethical technology use. Administrators are responsible for enforcing ethical computer use through good policy writing, good staff development activities, and the enforcement of school rules related to technology use. All schools must take deliberate steps to ensure that students are not just being taught how to use technology but how to use it productively, safely, and wisely. Educators must plan deliberately if technology is to be safely, legally, and ethically used in schools and if schools are to be effective in creating young citizens who will continue to be safe and ethical users even when not being supervised. Such an effort has three major components: 1. It must develop adult awareness of the safe and ethical dimensions of technology use. 2. It must create good technology policies, guidelines, and rules.
< previous page
page_77
next page >
< previous page
page_78
next page >
Page 78 3. It must offer opportunities for both staff and students to build understandings and practice ethical actions. The components of such a plan are briefly examined here. WHAT ADULTS NEED TO UNDERSTAND When students start using technology, especially information technologies that consist of computers and computer networks, they start operating in a new world: a virtual world in which behaviors may not be easily judged to be right or wrong. If a student steals a music compact disc from a local store explaining that the reason she stole it was that she did not have the money to purchase it, we can easily judge that action to be both illegal and unethical. However, if a student downloads a copyrighted piece of music from the Internet, and he gives the same reason, we may question the impropriety of the action. Nothing physical was stolen. It is a common practice. The likelihood of being caught is negligible. Young people, especially teenagers, are more knowledgeable and more comfortable in the virtual world —“cyberspace”—than are most of the adults who now teach them. As reported by the Center for Media Education (2001): Yet while there has been substantial public debate about protecting children and teens from inappropriate and harmful content on the Internet, very little is really understood about the nature of the digital content and services created for and by teens—the actual Web sites where they spend so much time and to which they devote so much attention. As a consequence, even as this new medium is becoming a pervasive presence in teens’ lives, it remains largely under the radar of parents, scholars, and policymakers alike. As a first step in ensuring student ethical use of technologies, schools first need to make sure that teachers and other staff members understand some important concepts. What Technology (or Computer) Ethics Means Computer ethics, better labeled “information technology ethics,” deals with the proper use of a wide range of telecommunication and data storage devices. Ethics is the branch of philosophy that deals with moral judgments, issues of right and wrong, and determining what behaviors are humane and inhumane. Most Western codes of ethical behavior describe actions as “ethical’’ that do one or more of the following: • promote the general health of society • maintain or increase individual rights and freedoms • protect individuals from harm • treat all human beings as having an inherent value and accord those beings respect • uphold religious, social, cultural, and government laws and mores Simply, an “ethical action” does no harm to oneself, other individuals, or society. The terms ethical, safe, moral, appropriate, and legal are all used when discussing whether technology behaviors are right or wrong. Although often used almost interchangeably, there are distinctions among the terms: • Ethical use is the most generic term that applies to actions that may be considered right or wrong.
< previous page
page_78
next page >
< previous page
page_79
next page >
Page 79 • Safe use applies to situations in which physical harm may come to a user or user’s property. • Moral use applies to situations to which religious or spiritual values apply. (Is the action good or evil?) • Appropriate use applies to actions that may be right or wrong depending on when, where, and with whom they happen. • Legal use applies to situations in which established laws are violated. A single action may be unethical, unsafe, immoral, inappropriate, and illegal (such as sending a computer virus that harms data). But many acts fall more into one category than the others. The viewing of pornography arguably may be construed as immoral, but not unsafe or illegal if done by an adult in private. A student using a school computer to view sports scores is not illegal, but it could be considered inappropriate if it violates school guidelines. Any discussion about ethical behaviors is challenging because human beings usually place actions on an ethical continuum rather than simply judging them as ethical or unethical. Because of personal values established by religion, upbringing, education, and experience, it is difficult to reach consensus on many of these value-laden issues. A single act by a student can be construed as mischievous (or even ethical) by one teacher and malicious by another. The Responsibility of Schools in Teaching Computer Ethics In direct and indirect ways, children begin to learn ethical values from birth. And although families and religious institutions are assigned the primary responsibility for a child’s ethical education, schools have the societal charge to teach and reinforce some moral values, especially those directly related to citizenship and school behaviors. Nearly all ethical issues that surround technology deal with societal and school behaviors and are an appropriate and necessary part of the school curriculum. Schools not teaching ethical behavior are negligent in fulfilling the responsibilities expected of them by society. Why Technology Ethics Deserves Special Consideration Using technology to communicate and operate in a “virtual world,” one that only exists within computers and computer networks, is a new phenomenon that is not well understood by many adults who received their primary education prior to its existence. Both fear and romance accompany new technologies. Movies, as well as books and television programs, often make ethically questionable or illegal actions, such as breaking into secure computer systems, seem heroic or at least sympathetic. There are many parallels between the physical and virtual worlds that can help us place new virtual experiences into a more familiar context, but there are major differences between these worlds as well: • Intellectual property in digital formats, whether software, images, music, or text, can now be duplicated with incredible ease and speed, making copyright violations and plagiarism more common. • Prior to the Internet, minors faced physical barriers of access to sexually explicit, hate-group, and terrorist materials. • Access to strangers is no longer primarily seen as a physical threat and a known risk but can happen in chat rooms or via e-mail. • The ability to send unsolicited commercial messages to millions of Internet e-mail users (spamming) was not possible before there was e-mail or the Internet.
< previous page
page_79
next page >
< previous page
page_80
next page >
Page 80 • Digital photography has made the manipulation of images undetectable, an impossible feat with chemical photography. One of the most significant reasons that computer ethics deserves special attention is because of our rather human ability to view one’s actions in the intangible, virtual world of information technologies as being less serious than one’s actions in the real world. Most adults or children would never contemplate walking into a computer store and shoplifting a computer program. Yet software piracy (the illegal duplication of computer programs) costs the computer business billions of dollars each year. Most of us would never pick a lock, but guessing passwords to gain access to unauthorized information is a too-common activity. Information technology misuse by many people, especially the young, is viewed as a low-risk, gamelike challenge. Electronic fingerprints, footsteps, and other evidence of digital impropriety have historically been less detectable than physical evidence. There is a physical risk when breaking into a real office that does not exist when hacking into a computer database from one’s living room or den. Illegally copying a book is costly and time consuming; illegally copying a computer program can be easily done in seconds at very small expense. Pornography viewed on a Web site seems to disappear as soon as the browser window is closed. Educators need to be aware and understand that another, counter set of “ethical” behavior also exists—that espoused by hackers. Being described as a “hacker’’ once indicated only a strong interest and ability in computer use. Popular use of the word has changed, so that now “hacking” describes gaining unauthorized access to computerized systems and data. The term “cracker” is also used but is often applied to a hacker who has a malicious intent. Some common hacker beliefs include the following: • All information, especially digital information, should be free and available to all people. • Breaking into computer systems points out security features to those who are responsible for maintaining them. • Hacking is a form of learning about computers and is harmless. • Hackers help monitor the abuse of information by the government and business (D. G. Johnson 2000). Teachers need to know and understand these counterculture beliefs and be able to offer reasons why they need to be questioned for their logic and ethics. Existing Ethical Codes of Technology Use Not long ago, ethical technology questions were only of interest to a few specialists. But as the use of information technologies spreads throughout society and its importance to our national economies and individual careers grows, everyone will need to make good ethical decisions when using information technologies. Studies show that persons involved in computer crimes acquire both their interest and skills at an early age. Many organizations and individuals have written lists of ethical “rules” for technology use. One of the mostly widely used and easily understood sets of computer use principles is “The Ten Commandments of Computer Ethics” from the Computer Ethics Institute (1992), which reads much like the biblical Ten Commandments: “Thou shalt not use a computer to harm other people, thou shalt not interfere with other people’s computer work,” and so on. Arlene Rinaldi (1998) has written a well-respected set of Internet guidelines called “The Net: User Guidelines and Netiquette.” This more informal set of expected behaviors
< previous page
page_80
next page >
< previous page
page_81
next page >
Page 81 helps new users learn the manners and etiquette of an often-impatient online community. In her guide, newbies (inexperienced telecommunications users) learn that typing in all capital letters is considered shouting and therefore rude; sending chain letters via e-mail is improper and a waste of resources; and humor and sarcasm are easily viewed as criticism and should be used with care in electronic communications. A variety of guides should be made available to staff and students, and one should either be adopted or an original set of guidelines written. Although an entire school or district may wish to use a single set of guidelines, each classroom teacher needs to understand, teach, and model the guidelines. Simple, easily remembered guidelines are probably the best for children: Johnson’s 3 P’s of Technology Ethics 1. Privacy—I will protect my privacy and respect the privacy of others. 2. Property—I will protect my property and respect the property of others. 3. Appropriate use—I will use technology in constructive ways and in ways which do not break the rules of my family, religion, school, or government. (D. A. Johnson 1998) Although sometimes more difficult to enforce in a consistent manner, a set of a few guidelines rather than a lengthy set of specific rules is more beneficial to students in the long run. By applying guidelines rather than following rules, students engage in higher-level thinking processes and learn behaviors that will continue into their next classroom, their homes, and their adult lives. The Major Issues of Technology Ethics The scope of information technology ethics is very broad. In addressing ethical behaviors, categorizing the issues under the major headings of privacy, property, and appropriate use helps provide a framework for discussions. Scenarios and discussion questions for the issues discussed below can be found on the author’s Web site, www.doug-johnson.com/ethics/index.html (D. A. Johnson 2002). Privacy: Does my use of the technology violate the privacy of others, or am I giving information to others that I should not? Privacy issues are a hot-button topic as people become more aware of how easily technology can gather, hold, and analyze personal data. Students need to be aware of technology issues related to privacy both so that they can protect their own privacy and so that they can honor the privacy of others. Protecting one’s privacy • Students need to understand that businesses and organizations use information to market products, and that information is often gathered electronically, both overtly and covertly. Information given to one organization may well be sold to others. All citizens should be able to articulate and control to the degree possible the amount of information a company knows about them. A company that knows a lot about an individual can use it to customize products for the individual but also to manipulate that person. • As students use technology to communicate, they need to know that a stranger is a stranger, whether met on the playground or on the Internet. The same rules we
< previous page
page_81
next page >
< previous page
page_82
next page >
Page 82 teach children about physical strangers apply to virtual strangers. In conversing in chat rooms, with instant messaging programs, or through e-mail, students lose the visual clues to the other person. We know only what the other person tells about him- or herself (often much to the chagrin of those in search of romance on the Internet). • Schools have the right to search student and employee files that are created and stored on school-owned computer hardware. Schools have search policies on lockers and book bags, and the same policy can be extended to computer storage devices. Respecting others’ privacy • Information does not become public just by virtue of its appearance on a computer screen. Students who are accustomed to the public viewing of television monitors need to realize that student-created work on a computer screen should be treated as privately as work created in a paper journal. • Information inadvertently left accessible does not mean that it is appropriate to access it. Forgetting to lock one’s home is not the same as allowing anyone to enter it. Although information may be about students (such as grades), that information does not necessarily belong to them. Students certainly do not have the right to look at information about other students. One question that might be raised is: “What right do students have to check the accuracy of the data gathered about them, and what would be the correct procedure for making that check?” Property Issues: Do my actions respect the property of others, and am I taking steps to keep my property safe? Property issues, especially those regarding intellectual property, have come to the forefront of ethics discussions. As already noted, the ease with which property can be copied has led to greater instances of piracy, plagiarism, and even disdain for copyright laws, as evidenced in the rampant use of Napster-like music acquisition. As with privacy, students need to understand that property is a two-sided issue: they need to respect the property of others, as well as protect their own property from the abuses of others. Respecting the property of others • Students need to know that computer software is protected by copyright law. It is unlawful, as well as unethical, to make copies of computer programs without permission or payment to the producer of those programs. It also needs to be understood that when purchasing software, one is usually only purchasing the right to use the software. The ownership of the code that makes up the program stays with the producer. This means that one cannot alter the program or resell it. The vast majority of software licenses require that one copy of a program be purchased for each computer on which it is to be run. The inability to pay for software is not a justification for illegal copying. • Software falls into three main types: freeware (that which can be used indefinitely without payment), shareware (that which can be used for a trial period and then must either be erased or purchased), and commercial software (that which must be purchased before use). Understanding the concept of shareware is a good way of helping students understand why purchasing software benefits them. The profits that software producers make are partially used to fund the development of more software. If the profit motive is lost from software creation, less software and fewer improvements are likely to be made.
< previous page
page_82
next page >
< previous page
page_83
next page >
Page 83 • Plagiarism is easier than ever, thanks to the computer. Students need to understand when and how to cite information from a broad range of print, electronic, and primary sources. Academic work is increasingly becoming available for sale or downloading from the Internet. Online services now offer help in writing “personal” essays requested for college admissions offices. • Both hacking and creating viruses are property offenses because they cause damage or misuse technology resources such as bandwidth. • Students need to learn to treat intellectual property the same way they would treat physical property and that the theft or destruction of such property is unethical (and unlawful). Deleting a file or erasing a disk constitutes the destruction of property even though the magnetic medium of the hard drive or the plastic case of the computer disk is left intact. • Deliberate waste of school materials through excessive printing is not uncommon. Students need to understand that it is wrong to waste finite resources. Like vandalism, students need to understand that everyone is affected by such activities. Protecting one’s own property • Students need to know about the unethical practices of others and how to protect themselves from those practices. • Computer viruses, often infecting a computer through downloading software from the Internet, can be detected and destroyed by virus protection programs. Students need to know how to find, install, and use these protection programs. • Investment, health, and employment scams are rampant on the Internet. • Students need to know that their own original work is protected by copyright laws and that they have a right to give or not give permission for others to use it. • All technology users need to know that passwords must be kept confidential to prevent the unauthorized access to a student’s data (and to ensure privacy). • All citizens (including students) have the ethical responsibility for reporting wrongdoing, including destruction of property. Although there are many reasons students are reluctant to do so, as adults we need to express our beliefs that reporting unethical or criminal behavior serves a social purpose. Younger students often believe that school property is owned by the teachers and administrators and are surprised to learn that it is their parents’ taxes or fees that must be used to pay for vandalized or stolen school resources. Appropriate Use: Does this use of technology have educational value, and is it in keeping with the rules of my family, my religion, my school, and my government? Appropriate use is often a gray area of technology ethics. Rules made because of scarcity of resources, because of religious values, and for actions that may simply be tasteless or cause discomfort in others are difficult to create and enforce. The types of misuse of technology in this category range from the mischievous to the malicious. Place, audience, and purpose can all be factors in determining whether an action can be gauged as appropriate. Place • Most schools allow students to use free time in school to complete personal tasks—to read a book or magazine for enjoyment, to write a letter to a friend, or to draw
< previous page
page_83
next page >
< previous page
page_84
next page >
Page 84 for pleasure. Technology, too, should be available to students for uses not tied directly to the curriculum—to play games, to send personal e-mail, or to search for Internet information of personal interest. The ethical issue here becomes that of an allocation of resources. For most schools, the demand for technology has outpaced its acquisition. Computers and Internet access are usually in short supply, and priority needs to be given to students who have an academic task to complete. • Students may use personal technologies inappropriately at school. Personal digital assistants (PDAs), cell phones, pagers, and wireless laptop computers give students the ability to communicate surreptitiously. This form of communication can be used to cheat and can distract from classroom activities. Audience • A good deal of Internet content is tasteless, offensive, and lacking in educational value. Schools should define, and teachers should help students understand, the qualities and conditions under which an item becomes inappropriate for school use. Students need to understand the concepts of pornography, racism, and sexism. Students may be exposed to information produced by hate groups and political extremists. Such experiences may be springboards to meaningful discussions about propaganda and free-speech issues. Materials and topics that students may access from home without parental disapproval are not always appropriate for reading or viewing in schools where a wide range of value systems exist. • Most schools have harassment policies and appropriate-language rules. Students need to understand that harassment is wrong regardless of its medium, and of course, they need to recognize that language used among friends is not always the language used in public discourse of any kind. Purpose • As noted previously, technology is neutral. It can be used to generate attention and for mischief—two great goals children and young adults have always had. • Students can use technology to “edit” photographs. Deliberate distortion of events may harm both those involved in the event and the reputation of the reporter. Although such actions may seem frivolous, journalistic integrity is a serious issue of which even young photographers need to be aware. • Just as students have created “alternate” school newspapers of a satiric nature, they are now creating ‘‘alternate” school Web sites and personal student Web sites that are hosted on nonschool computers. Unless the messages on them can be proven to be libelous or threatening, these sites are protected by students’ First Amendment rights. School officials need to be careful in how they deal with such sites, despite the degree of embarrassment they might cause. • Disguise, impersonation, and other forms of “trying on” new personalities are common childhood and adolescent behaviors. The anonymity of the Internet limits such impersonation only to the degree that a lack of a student’s writing skills or sophistication of thought allows discovery. Role playing in a physical context is often seen as both healthy and educational. We need to help students ask when such activities are productive and when they might be harmful. • Students need to be aware that the Internet is rife with hoaxes and learn to check sites carefully for authenticity and accuracy (see U.S. Department of Energy 2002).
< previous page
page_84
next page >
< previous page
page_85
next page >
Page 85 WHAT ALL STUDENTS NEED TO UNDERSTAND It is quite obvious that students need to understand and apply both school rules and local and national laws that apply to information technology use, especially those related to privacy, property, and appropriateness as described above. They need to know the immediate and long-term consequences for both themselves and society if they choose to act against school rules or the law. Students also need to know that the ability of officials to detect technology misuse is growing. Network security systems are becoming more sophisticated in tracking who uses what resource at what time. Students need to realize that most Web browsers keep a viewable log of recently visited sites, that most e-mail messages include a return address, and that some schools are using programs that record all the keystrokes a student makes during a computer session. All of us need to understand that organizations have the right to search file-server space and read the e-mail messages of students (and staff), especially if there is probable cause. Electronic fingerprints, virtual footprints, and broken digital locks are growing more visible each day. Students need to understand both their rights and responsibilities related to information technology use. As the Internet becomes a more indispensable source of information and learning activities, it may become viewed as an integral part of one’s right to an education, but rights are accompanied by responsibilities. We have an obligation to teach students that they have a right to due process if charged with a violation of rules or laws. Pragmatically, students need to know how to protect themselves and their data from strangers, hackers, computer viruses, and unauthorized use. POLICIES, GUIDELINES, AND RULES SCHOOLS NEED TO HAVE School officials who understand the ethical issues surrounding technology use can use those understandings to formulate policies, rules, and guidelines for use by both students and staff. These rules should be in written form, readily available, and frequently revised. Acceptable Use Policies Most schools now have adopted an “Acceptable Use Policy” that governs the use of the Internet and other information technologies and networks in a school. This policy needs to be school board adopted and should apply to both staff and student technology use. Everyone in the school, as well as parents, needs to know and understand these policies. The Mankato, Minnesota, Schools’ Acceptable Use Policy (Mankato Area Public Schools 1998) describes the role of networked technologies in education, the due processes by which violators of