Digital Difference
EDUCATIONAL FUTURES RETHINKING THEORY AND PRACTICE Volume 50 Series Editors Michael A. Peters Univ...
113 downloads
1505 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Digital Difference
EDUCATIONAL FUTURES RETHINKING THEORY AND PRACTICE Volume 50 Series Editors Michael A. Peters University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA Editorial Board Michael Apple, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA Miriam David, Institute of Education, London University, UK Cushla Kapitzke, Queensland University of Technology, Australia Simon Marginson, University of Melbourne, Australia Mark Olssen, University of Surrey, UK Fazal Rizvi, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA Linda Tuahwai Smith, University of Waikato, New Zealand Susan Robertson, University of Bristol, UK Scope This series maps the emergent field of educational futures. It will commission books on the futures of education in relation to the question of globalisation and knowledge economy. It seeks authors who can demonstrate their understanding of discourses of the knowledge and learning economies. It aspires to build a consistent approach to educational futures in terms of traditional methods, including scenario planning and foresight, as well as imaginative narratives, and it will examine examples of futures research in education, pedagogical experiments, new utopian thinking, and educational policy futures with a strong accent on actual policies and examples.
Digital Difference Perspectives on Online Learning Edited by
Ray Land University of Strathclyde, UK
Siân Bayne University of Edinburgh, UK
SENSE PUBLISHERS ROTTERDAM/BOSTON/TAIPEI
A C.I.P. record for this book is available from the Library of Congress.
ISBN: 978-94-6091-578-9 (paperback) ISBN: 978-94-6091-579-6 (hardback) ISBN: 978-94-6091-580-2 (e-book)
Published by: Sense Publishers, P.O. Box 21858, 3001 AW Rotterdam, The Netherlands www.sensepublishers.com
Printed on acid-free paper
All Rights Reserved © 2011 Sense Publishers No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Editors’ Preface ....................................................................................................... vii Ray Land and Siân Bayne DIGITAL SELFHOOD 1. The Purloined Email: Death, Desire and Academic Subjectivity in the Haunted University ......................................................................................3 Cate Thomas 2. Structure, Authority and Other Noncepts: Teaching in Fool-ish Spaces ............15 Hamish Macleod and Jen Ross 3. Lurking on the Threshold: Being Learners in Silent Spaces ...............................29 Maggi Savin-Baden, Christine Sinclair, Christine Sanders and Second Wind TRANSFORMATIONS 4. Difference and Discontinuity – Making Meaning Through Hypertexts .............45 Colleen McKenna and Claire McAvinia 5. Speed and the Unsettling of Knowledge in the Digital University .....................61 Ray Land POLITICS OF THE DIGITAL 6. Logos and Mythos: The Political Dilemmas of Web 2.0 in an Accreditation-Driven Educational Environment .................................................73 Michael Begg, Rachel Ellaway, David Dewhurst and Hamish Macleod 7. How the Earth Moved: ‘Difference’ and Transformative Learning in an Online Course on Global Citizenship ..................................................................83 Leah P. Macfadyen and Anne Hewling 8. Negotiating the Digital Divide: Narratives from the Have and the Have-Nots .............................................................................................101 Debbie Holley and Martin Oliver 9. E-learning, Constructivism, and the Disappearance of Difference: Pedagogies of Productivity in the Modern Workplace .....................................115 Karim A. Remtulla
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A DIFFERENT GENERATION? 10. Beyond Difference: Reconfiguring Education for the User-Led Age ............133 Axel Bruns 11. Appropriation of Mobile Phones in and Across Formal and Informal Learning .....................................................................................145 John Cook and Norbert Pachler 12. ‘Digital Native’ and ‘Digital Immigrant’ Discourses: A Critique ..................159 Siân Bayne and Jen Ross List of Contributors ................................................................................................171 Index .......................................................................................................................177
vi
RAY LAND AND SIÂN BAYNE
EDITORS’ PREFACE
DIGITAL DISQUIETUDE
Discussing the manner in which digital culture within education might differ from its ‘analogue’ predecessors incurs the risk of resorting to increasingly roadworn metaphors of new frontiers, ‘cyber’ domains, inter-generational conflicts and, inevitably, the futurist utopias and dystopias characteristic of western media throughout the twentieth century. These imaginings now seem to belong to an earlier era of internet thinking, and we are perhaps freer, over two decades on, to re-evaluate digital difference from new perspectives. ‘That can only be a good thing;’ suggests Gunther Kress: ‘it frees us up to think a bit more slowly, with a bit more deliberateness, about which things move at what pace’ (Kress 2007). We have moved on from over-simplistic analyses of ‘difference’ based on generational determinisms, with a significant literature now available which reveals a far more complex picture of student attitudes to technology. This is one which resists homogenising claims for the existence of a ‘net generation’ while emphasising the cultural embedding of technology – and in particular social media – within the lifeworlds of students. It also demonstrates a general scepticism among students relating to the value of online approaches within formal education. (Jones et al., 2010; Jones and Healing, 2010; Kennedy et al., 2008; Salaway et al., 2008; Selwyn, 2008). Despite these more measured and empirically-based assessments of the operations of digital difference, moral panics remain readily available. Carr’s (2010) recent work on internet use, for example, worries that our neurological structures will be irrevocably modified, to our detriment, by dependence on search engines, while others, such as neurobiologist Blakemore (2010) have responded dismissively to such suggestions, countering such proposals by emphasising the plasticity of the brain, and pointing out that the basic genetic make-up of homo sapiens has been essentially unchanged for a quarter of a billion years. As Carr’s recent publication and the ensuing reviews indicate, a sense of disquietude seems ever present when discussing new digital practices. And to some extent perhaps it should, as the transformations incurred through new digital practices can be profound, troublesome in nature and far-reaching. Indeed, it is probably true to acknowledge that more or less everything that we encounter will have some effect on our cognitive processes – how could it not? But what is more interesting, for the purposes of this volume, are the opportunities opening up through these cultural shifts, the changes in ways of thinking and the re-invention of conventional practice that digital work seems to be fostering in the academy. It is these which form the body of the work presented in this volume.
vii
EDITORS’ PREFACE
CULTURE, TECHNOLOGY AND (ENVIRONMENTS OF) LEARNING
The chapters in this volume had their first airing at the final gathering of the ICE series of international symposia (Ideas in Cyberspace Education) organised by the Universities of Strathclyde and Edinburgh at Ross Priory on the shores of Loch Lomond in Scotland.1 In his keynote address Professor Gunther Kress emphasised the inevitable and ubiquitous link between technology and culture, however simple or complex the technology. It could not be otherwise, he argued, as our human, social and cultural resources can only go so far ahead of or away from what they are and where they have come from. Culture is, in that sense, he observed ‘an inertial force’, as are social factors, in two ways. ‘First, cultural resources are involved in the shaping of technologies in the first place; in that sense we cannot jump over our shadows. Second, in their social settings, that is, culture in the field of power, cultural resources set the field of potential application (and transformation) for that technology’. He also remarked that it is a commonplace to say that technologies are linked. ...while different technologies have their own rationale and dynamics, they are integrated in an environment where everything affects everything else. So for instance, one would not expect the changes in distribution and function of authorship, which digital technologies offer, to be independent of changes in authority, which characterize the much larger level social changes in which the users of digital technologies are embedded. Both must be seen in terms of the effects of changes in power from state to market, from citizen to consumer, which shape the lives of the users of the technologies. (Kress 2010) The chapters that follow in this collection reflect this complex embrace of culture, power and technology in relation to the learning environment. A variety of significant, often inter-related issues and challenges arise from the topics that they address. These range from social questions of consumption, speed, uncertainty, and risk to individual issues of identity, selfhood and desire, ethical matters involving equity and authority, as well as structural questions of order and ambiguity. From these themes emerges an engaging agenda for future educational research and practice in higher education over the coming decade. PERSPECTIVES ON ONLINE LEARNING
Digital Selfhood Cate Thomas in her striking opening chapter on the Haunted University draws attention to the way in which, given a gradual shift from an ‘analogue’ to a digital university, the uncanny or unheimliche nature of the online world is likely to replace the sense of a stable, fixed and knowable world (albeit perhaps misperceived as such), to one that is shifting and ambiguous. She presents the digital university as haunted in the sense that it affords numerous technological means of constructing the self, and in a witty but faintly disturbing analogy with the restless and unpredictable journey of a stolen letter in Edgar Alan Poe’s short story The Purloined Letter she demonstrates how email messages, as just one indicative digital technology viii
EDITORS’ PREFACE
employed within the university, have the same quality of ‘nowhereness’ as Poe’s notorious missive. The academic subject is haunted by often hastily written texts circulating through the digital university beyond their control and producing a situation where their selfhood becomes ‘clearly unfixed, de-stabilised, split, uncertain and constituted by the readings, utterances and gaze of others’. They lose authority and have little control over their self construction, yet like ghosts cannot ‘die’, as their spectral selves are endlessly reproducible. Like ghosts also they are ‘forced to speak and know in contexts not of their choosing.’ Hamish Macleod and Jen Ross (Chapter 2) are also concerned with the ambiguity and liminal nature of the online space. They note that in such spaces ‘social engagement and hierarchy become less clearly defined’ and this in turn renders the teacher’s authority online a ‘tricky’ matter. The same unstructured nature of the digital space that can offer rich opportunities and connections to foster learning and construct new meanings can also prove difficult for the tutor to regulate. In such terrain, they argue, the tutor’s role ‘is not to regulate, but rather to participate and provoke in creative and playful ways that open up passages or possibilities in chaotic online spaces’. They explore this notion further through the metaphors of jester, fool and trickster, seeing such potential positionings as a ‘frame of mind’ or ‘approach to being alongside students in challenging, chaotic, digital environments’. Such fool-ish practice offers ways of modelling ‘secure notknowing’ and ‘enjoyment of ambiguity’ as well as helping students cope with complexity and sense-making in environments that are uncertain and relatively disordered. They view this kind of disruptive practice as a form of troubling knowledge that will provoke students to see anew. Reporting on their experience of being e-learners in a range of digital environments, including immersive virtual worlds, Maggi Savin-Baden and Christine Sinclair (along with their Second Life avatars Christine Sanders and Second Wind) (Chapter 3) explore the notion that being an e-learning student ‘can sometimes feel like being in a silent space’. This seemed to take the form of a ‘pedagogical immobility’ and sense of ‘stuckness’. Drawing on Meyer and Land’s (2003) notion of threshold concepts, the authors characterise these experiences of lurking and stuckness as ‘liminal states resulting in liminal identities, which for most of the course have resulted in “chronic uncertainty” about ourselves and our relationships to the new environment’. In keeping with threshold theory the state of liminality tended to be characterised by ‘a stripping away of old identities, an oscillation between states and personal transformation’. Nonetheless both authors reported progress across thresholds and through liminal states and, interestingly, discovered that their immersive world avatars performed actions in Second Life that have led to their real life counterparts rethinking some of the things they do in their day-to-day practice in universities. Transformations Colleen McKenna and Claire McAvinia (Chapter 4) explore the opportunities that digital environments offer for new academic writing practices. Observing that whereas many academic digital texts occupy new sites of writing production, and ix
EDITORS’ PREFACE
often depart from conventional essay form, they remain broadly linear in terms of how they organise knowledge. Their interest is drawn to academic hypertext and how student writers in digital contexts are experimenting with hypertextual forms or how new curricula are making use of new digital writing genres. Through detailed examination of student scripts these authors conclude that hypertextual practice challenges conventional academic genres ‘by knowingly disrupting linear organisation and privileging the gaps that such an approach affords’. Hypertext, they find, requires new organisational techniques which displace standard argumentation, relying instead ‘on screen design, visual motifs and juxtaposition through linking. From a broader educational perspective this new form, the authors suggest, ‘might liberate the thinking of student writers as they work outside of established, and probably internalised, essayistic paradigms.’ The chapter by Ray Land (Chapter 5) argues that the nature of academic knowledge is inevitably being transformed in the digital university when its modes of production and exchange employ technologies that operate at the speed of light. Though wary of the perils of technological determinism, he draws on Virilio’s analysis of the relation between speed and power to differentiate the changing nature and uses of knowledge in digital environments from those familiar to us from print-based culture. Print culture, he contends, ‘in the form of the stable, bounded, individual and private text, has tended to operate within, and to reinforce, patterns of authority and identified authorship.’ On the other hand digital environments, ‘more protean and restless in nature, tend to be more concerned with image, openness, multimodality and collectivity.’ Their increased emphasis on collaboration, group self-regulation and self-explanation may lead to changed academic subjectivity, while technologies that operate in ‘fast time’ present significant challenges to practices based in the deliberative and contemplative ‘slow time’ of the cloistered academy. Politics of the Digital A new model of the digital academy – based on devolution and collaboration as opposed to hierarchy, traditional authority and exclusivity – is envisaged by Michael Begg and his colleagues Rachel Ellaway, David Dewhurst and Hamish Macleod (Chapter 6). These authors however anticipate political tensions between the unfixed and de-stabilised characteristics of digital spaces discussed earlier and the concerns and priorities of accreditation-focused institutions. They identify ‘Web 2.0’ as, in many ways, ‘just the latest challenge to reactionary and authoritative cultures in higher education and, as such, ... an essential part of the academy’s lifecycle’. They anticipate that the academy’s embrace of the digital will incur substantial challenges, practically and philosophically. Digital technologies have been a manifestation of globalisation as well as working to accelerate the processes of it. In the chapter 7 Leah Macfadyen and Anne Hewling evaluate an innovative online programme they offer at the University of British Columbia which encourages international students to make connections between the academic knowledge they acquire in their classes, and their roles and x
EDITORS’ PREFACE
responsibilities as members of local and global communities. They oblige these digital-age participants to engage personally and professionally with the practical and ethical complexities of global challenges often in uncomfortable and challenging ways. The authors freely acknowledge the programme’s overtly political aims and present their students with hard questions concerning whose interests are being advanced over others, and the prospect of changes to social or political structures that already well suit the interests of some established communities. The aim of this programme, Perspectives on Global Citizenship, which fully exploits the potential of digital environments in bringing together widely dispersed international participants, is ‘to create a forum where students would engage in issues of social and ecological justice through critical thought, moral commitment, and meaningful engagement in their learning and “coming to know” as global citizens’. As digital environments have become widely accessible over the last two decades, and the social, academic and economic benefits of internet usage have been recognised, debates over equality of access and entitlement have naturally arisen leading to the notion of a ‘digital divide’ between those able to make use of digital environments and those who are less able to do so. To date the central issue in these discussions has tended to be the question of ‘access’. However more recently this notion has been problematised as an over-simplification and in Chapter 8 Debbie Holley and Martin Oliver seek to develop a better understanding of what ‘access’ might actually mean to different groups of users. ‘The “flexibility” offered by online environments does not solve access issues, they point out, ‘but instead adds new spaces (e.g. the home) where these issues must be negotiated’. Their research indicates that even when open access facilities are provided, ‘the disadvantaged are not as well placed to take advantage of this as those who already hold social advantage.’ Access to digital environments in many ways still seems to replicate the unequal power structures of society. Karim Remtulla (Chapter 9) analyses the potential of digital pedagogies within the modern globalised workplace and doubts their capacity, given the evidence of current practice, to authentically deliver constructivist pedagogy, ‘with all its complexity, openness, interpretivism, and multi-dimensionality’. Instead he reports somewhat depressing tendencies towards homogenisation, normalisation and universalisation in prevailing e-learning approaches with adult workers. The pedagogies and epistemologies he encounters in the workplaces of globalised organisations seem poorly to reflect the needs of ‘a socially and demographically diverse, multicultural and multifaceted workforce’. Drawing on Baudrillard’s notion of simulation he argues that e-learning, as simulacrum, has led to the disappearance of face-to-face adult education and training in the workplace, with the overriding objective of ‘efficiency’ reducing all adult education and training in the workplace to questions of distribution and access to information, with solutions sought through investment in more hardware and media. He advocates an urgent need for a socio-cultural critique of e-learning that can offer a radical online pedagogy of difference, rather than pedagogies which occlude social and cultural difference. xi
EDITORS’ PREFACE
A Different Generation? Axel Bruns (in Chapter 10) explores ways in which digital environments enable students to become active producers of content, often able to do so on an ‘ad hoc, on-the-fly basis’. Digital technologies now permit them to ‘occupy a hybrid, userand-producer position which can be described usefully as that of a produser’. He, too, is eager to help participants develop a more informed, self-reflexive, and critical perspective on their own practices as information seekers, users, and providers and sees this as involving not just the adoption of new digital tools and technologies but a longer-term paradigm shift towards networked organisational and communicational structures. Perhaps most significantly he sees higher education, in its embrace of digital technologies, inevitably facing the same kind of ‘casual collapse’ as that experienced by other established hierarchies and institutions. Rather than defensively clinging to the status of a centuries-old brand, or dismissing such a transformative cultural shift as a passing fad he advocates a concomitant shift in service role for higher education institutions, focusing more on the quality assurance of both internal and external content creation activities. As an example of produsage John Cook and Norbert Pachler (Chapter 11) have identified mobile telephony as an area of digital activity in which user-learners are appropriating the technology to construct their own formal as well as informal learning situations. They regard mobile telephony as ‘a socially contingent form of cultural transmission and production’ in which mobile phone use is not an externally imposed commercial activity operating upon society but rather a phenomenon that is constructed, appropriated and understood by that society. In the examples of learners that they provide their underlying assumption is that mobile phones can be viewed as cultural resources for meaning-making in social contexts. Digital phones as artefacts come with culturally formed ways of usage, they argue, and traditionally learners have internalised set practices through patterns of acculturation. However their case studies provide evidence of learners appropriating the device in practices that are new to them. The authors stress the notion of agency on the part of the learner underpinning such processes of appropriation, in which they claim the technology for their own for purposes of ‘identity formation, social interaction, meaning-making and entertainment.’ For some, it is tempting to characterise such appropriation of digital technology by young people for these purposes as the practice of a new generation that is almost naturally technically adept – the so-called ‘digital natives’. In their chapter, however, Siân Bayne and Jen Ross (Chapter 12), seek to dispel such assumptions. They deconstruct the ‘native-immigrant’ binary opposition embedded within such discourse and challenge the positioning of young learners as subjects that are more comfortably ‘at one’ with the digital environment in ways that other ‘immigrant’ learners such as older people or teachers are unable to be. They challenge the primary metaphor of this discourse, pointing out that if the ‘inhabitants’ of technological spaces are the natives or immigrants, then this constructs the technological environment as the ‘nation-state’ or the ‘landmass’, an entity almost impossible to act on, hence minimising the agency and influence of teachers and learners and discouraging dissent. They emphasise the scholarly obligation to critique a shaping xii
EDITORS’ PREFACE
metaphor that is reductive, even racialised and divisive, and which has been glibly marketised. CONCLUSION
We hope that the chapters that follow in this book capture something of the challenge and engagement that characterised their initial presentation and debate at the ICE3 conference at Loch Lomond. Our thanks are due to the contributors to this volume, and to the generosity of their colleagues and students in contributing their time, thoughts and feelings in discussion and dialogue about digital difference. We would also like to record our gratitude to all the speakers and participants in the ICE series of conferences held in the United Kingdom between 2002 and 2007 with the support at different times of The University of Edinburgh, Queen Margaret University Edinburgh, Coventry University, the Institute of Education University of London, and the University of Strathclyde Glasgow. These symposia will be fondly recalled as some of the most enjoyable and valuable events of our academic careers. Ray Land and Siân Bayne Scotland 2010 NOTES 1
http://www.education.ed.ac.uk/ice3/
REFERENCES Baudrillard, J. (1988). Simulacra and simulations. In M. Poster (Ed.), Jean Baudrillard: Selected writings (pp. 166–184). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Blakemore, C. (2010, August 15). The net is no threat to our minds. In J. Naughton (Ed.), Is the Internet changing the way we think? (p. 20). The Observer, New Review. Carr, N. (2010). The shallows: How the Internet is changing the way we think, read and remember. London: Atlantic Books. Jones, et al. (2010). Net generation or digital natives: Is there a distinct new generation entering university? Computers & Education, 54, 722–732. Jones, & Healing. (2010, May 3–4). Learning nests and local habitations. In L. Dirckinck-Holmfeld, V. Hodgson, C. Jones, D. McConnell, & T. Ryberg (Eds.), Proceedings of the 7th international conference on networked learning. Aalborg. Kennedy, G., Judd, T. S., Churchward, A., Gray, K., & Krause, K. (2008). First year students’ experiences with technology: Are they really digital natives? ‘Questioning the net generation: A collaborative project in Australian higher education’. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 24(1), 108–122. Kress, G. (2007, March 21). Culture, technology and (environments of) learning. Opening address. In Ideas in Cyberspace Education 3 (ICE3): ‘Digital Difference’. Ross Priory, Loch Lomond, Scotland. Meyer, J., & Land, R. (2003). Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge: Linkages to ways of thinking and practising within the disciplines. In C. Rust (Ed.), Improving student learning – Ten years on. Oxford: OCSLD.
xiii
EDITORS’ PREFACE Salaway, G., Caruso, J. B., & Nelson, M. R. (2008). The ECAR study of undergraduate students and information technology (Research Study, Vol. 8). Boulder, CO: EDUCAUSE Center for Applied Research. Retrieved September 2, 2010, from http://www.educause.edu/ecar Selwyn, N. (2008). An investigation of differences in undergraduates’ academic use of the Internet. Active Learning in Higher Education, 9(11), 11–22. Stald, G. (2008). Mobile identity: Youth, identity, and mobile communication media. In D. Buckingham (Ed.), Youth, identity, and digital media (pp. 143–164). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Retrieved from http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1162/dmal.9780262524834.143 Virilio, P. (2000). Information bomb. London: Sage.
xiv
DIGITAL SELFHOOD
CATE THOMAS
1. THE PURLOINED EMAIL Death, Desire and Academic Subjectivity in the Haunted University
‘I sent a letter to my love, but on the way I dropped it Someone must have picked it up and put it in their pocket.’ Rhyme from a children’s playground game ‘…we cannot say of the purloined letter that, like other objects, it must be, or not be, in a particular place, but unlike them it will be and not be where it is, wherever it goes.’ Seminar on ‘The Purloined Letter’, Jacques Lacan INTRODUCTION
There is something uncanny about the Internet. The strange, the unexpected, the disturbing, the unaccountable, the familiar found in the midst of the alien, the alien that penetrates the home; the shocking, the obscene, the eerily beautiful; the sense that nothing is fixed, stable, certain or ultimately knowable, be that personal identity, the online environment itself, or the others with whom one’s online self communes – all these classic elements of the uncanny are (un)familiar territory to any regular Internet user. THE UNCANNY
Dolar (1991) describes the uncanny as irrupting with ‘the rise of scientific rationality’ (p. 7) and constantly haunting modernity ‘from the inside’(p. 7)1; how much more so has the uncanny grown and mutated with the development of our new technologies, so that it invades, haunts and possesses the world of the Internet, the very locus of technoculture. And if, as Poster (2001) points out, the technologies have contributed to the fact that we inhabit a cyberspace situated knowledge economy, then the uncanny is the unwholesome double that haunts that economy - ‘from the inside’. As Royle (2003) discusses in his comprehensive work on the uncanny, Freud’s attempt, in his originating 1919 essay Das Unheimliche (translated as The Uncanny), to make an exhaustive list of all that is uncanny, results in stopping, starting, contradiction and confusion, precisely because it is impossible to list all elements of R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 3–14. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
THOMAS
the uncanny. Because the realm is by nature inexhaustible and contradictory, any definition can never be complete or completely true. There is always a remainder, the definition has always to be partial. Similarly, any attempt to sum up what cyberspace ‘is’ necessarily results in failure; being so intimately intertwined with the uncanny, it shares the same characteristics of inexhaustibility and uncertainty. Freud’s notion of Unheimliche always containing its opposite term ‘Heimlich’ (which translates as the homely or familiar), and the homely and familiar always containing the uncanny, also relates intimately to the experience of navigating the Internet. One may, for example, unexpectedly come across something which is intimately familiar such as an old acquaintance or a childhood haunt when searching the world of the Internet for something completely unrelated; conversely, one may have the opposite experience of ‘Googling’ oneself (i.e. searching with one’s own name as the search term) and finding, not a familiar homepage but the eerie details (or worse still, photograph) of one’s unexpected and disturbing double. Freud describes the uncanny as ‘something which ought to have remained hidden but has come to light’ (p. 364). One of the characteristics of cyberspace is that nothing can any longer be hidden in the way that traditional print media permits for censorship. The world of the Internet, as those who celebrate its lack of boundaries and democratic access to publication expound, means the end of censorship. An example of this is how any event of significance has an internationally accessible presence in cyberspace within hours, or even minutes. Uncannily, it brings to light that which ought to be – or would otherwise be – hidden. If the online world is an uncanny space, how does this affect the Institution of the university, as we move from traditional, face to face, ways of working to a mode where online working is central to our activities? The move from an ‘analogue’2 to a digital university must surely be a move from a space which we collectively view (albeit mis-view) as stable, fixed and knowable, to one which is shifting, unstable and ambiguous. This is a domain where radical uncertainty predominates – the shadowy, unexpected, uncertain strangeness of the haunted university. THE ACADEMIC IN THE HAUNTED SPACE
And where is the academic in this haunted space? We are at an historical point when the online ‘crisis in authorship’ undermines scholarly authority for academics as researchers, as outlined in more detail later in this paper; similarly, a move to social constructivist influenced, student centred, collaborative pedagogic practice undermines the traditional authority-position of the academic as teacher. Against this background the question of who the online academic now is, and how that former ostensibly unified, authoritative pre-digital self is now being overtaken by a less stable, fixed or definable Subject, is key to our understanding of how the digital university differs from the ‘analogue’ institution. The last ten years have seen an increasing move away from face to face to digital teaching and learning practices in universities. There has also been a move, gathering increasing momentum, towards common usage of a variety of digital means for communication in the university workplace. Consequently, with 4
THE PURLOINED EMAIL
the use of technologies such as email, intranets, online shared workspaces and document management systems, virtual learning and research environments, videolink lectures, instant messaging, blogs, wikis, discussion tools and conferencing software of various kinds, academic staff in universities are more able to teach, and otherwise communicate, from a range of locations without necessarily seeing their students and colleagues. The academic Subject has always been constituted by the sum of their utterances, whether in oral form in the lecture hall, seminar, tutorial and conference presentation or in written form by inscription in books, articles and scholarly journals. The increasing disembodiment of the Subject means that the electronic self constructed through digital inscription, comes to constitute the day to day changing presence of the Subject, and begins to define them. Although there may still be embodied contact with colleagues and students, this Real Life (RL) contact is re-configured by the self created in the electronic environments, as in the following extrapolation from Zizek’s conception of the impact of cyberspace on RL. Zizek talks about the way in which sex with an RL, flesh and blood partner is impacted on by the experience of virtual3 sex, where a fantasy about the other substitutes for physical contact (Zizek 1998). He argues that this means that when one is engaged in RL sexual practice there are three people involved, oneself, one’s lover and the fantasy one has about one’s lover, as the virtual knowledge makes more explicit the fantasy that has always existed covertly. We might argue, if both parties have this ‘virtual knowledge’ that this could be further extrapolated to include the fantasy one’s lover has about oneself. Also, to include a narcissistic perspective, the projected fantasy of the self one has, could be included and the projected fantasy the lover has of themselves – making six entities in total! To apply this thinking to the rather more mundane everyday work situation of our academic Subject, we could say that when Dr X meets with Professor Y she is not just meeting with the Y she experiences in front of her, but with the Y that has been constructed through online virtual representation and her fantasised, (through online exchange, memory and the filling in of gaps between), Y. Similarly she brings her own virtual and projected selves to the room, so that the meeting of two people becomes haunted by their other selves. So the online world rewrites RL. The area of digital inscription in the online university is vast, as there are a range of technologies which invite and permit a variety of ways of constructing the self. This paper will concentrate on one technology, that of email. The use of email is such a central part of the daily business of work for academic staff in universities, that the Times Higher Education magazine carried an article guiding academics on the best way to use it effectively, so that communication would not be in any way confused or confounded and so that academics could represent themselves clearly (Swain 2006). THE ELECTRONIC ARCHIVE AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF SELF
This paper will consider the notion that email exchanges constitute part of an endless circulation of unfixed knowledge, where the impossibility of truth, let alone 5
THOMAS
clear communication, becomes foregrounded. Within this the academic Subject is constituted in a number of ways: through the permanent, haunting nature of the electronic archive; and through the transformation of distinctions between public and private; and through email chains of signification. In particular, the metaphor of the way in which the movement of the Purloined Letter in Edgar Alan Poe’s short story4 traces a symbolic circuit will be used, as will Lacan’s analysis of this (Lacan 1956). The use of this metaphor will aid us in exploring how the concepts used by Lacan (and subsequent works by others on Lacan’s Seminar on the Purloined Letter) might usefully help us consider the constitution of the digital Subject in the circulation of email letters, within the context of the uncanny space of online university In their anatomy or map of Lacan’s Seminar on the Purloined Letter, Muller and Richardson (1988) describe the letter as having ‘the property of nowhereness’, being ‘a symbol of absence [which] is and is not, wherever it may be’ (p. 79) and remaining even when destroyed. The resonance with email is significant – an electronic mail is and is not and is always elusive whilst being ever replicable and omnipresent. But it is its ability to remain when destroyed which concerns this part of our discussion, in its relationship with, or representation of, the archive. As soon as an email is sent, it exists in a number of places. It may be in the ‘sent items’ section of the sender’s software; it may exist on the server of the sender’s email service; it will exist on the server of the receiver’s email service; and it will be in the inbox of the receivers email software, which may mean it has been automatically downloaded to the hard drive(s) on the receiver’s computer(s). In addition to this, the email servers will be backed up in some way, so an additional copy of the mail will be held on both the sender and recipients service providers’ back-up servers. If either the sent or received email, or both, are downloaded to the sender and/or recipient’s hard drives by their email client software, a copy may exist which cannot easily be deleted. (Computer files on hard drives are not actually erased when the user ‘deletes’ them, but renamed, and then not easily accessible to the ordinary user). So, once sent, it can exist in up to eight (or more) places, seven of which are largely out of the reach or control of the sender. Once the email has been replied to or forwarded, the whole process of copies proliferating begins again. These multiple and distributed copies form an archive, in a literal sense. Additionally. the archive exists in a more metaphorical sense of a kind of total cultural inscription of all utterances. The electronic self, the self that is constituted by digital inscription, is and is not the Subject. But it cannot die, or, at least not easily. The Subject can die, in the sense of the embodied self expiring, but the digital double lives on. Because digital texts are Subject to archiving in their very creation, in a way that is completely outside the control of their original author, they become immortal. This archiving forces the Subject to live forever, making impossible, or barely possible, the option of death. But the immortal, revenant self, is and is not the Subject; it is the Subject’s double, the self constituted entirely by a specific arena of electronic discourse, a self simultaneously outside the control of the Subject, but eerily and intimately the ‘spirit’ of the Subject: the Subject’s digital spectre. 6
THE PURLOINED EMAIL
The relationship between archiving, the uncanny and the death drive is a complex and intimate one. Freud’s death drive tries to return the organism to its inorganic state and is characterized by repetition phenomena and by destructiveness. This repetition aspect is central to the uncanny. It is about the return of the repressed; it presents as something that has been banished but repeatedly comes back. The uncanny is ‘a compulsion to repeat’ (Freud p. 360) and ‘a constant recurrence of the same thing’ (Freud p. 356). It is, however, as both Derrida (1987) and Hertz (1985) have suggested, as noted by Royle (2003), not the actual thing that is being repeated which create the uncanny effect, but the act of the repetition itself. In Archive Fever, Derrida (1995) discusses the intimate nature of the relationship between the death drive and the archive. Because of its destructive properties, the death instinct incites the annihilation of memory and consequently produces the need to archive. The death drive, because it creates the compulsion to repeat, creates the archive – the archive being essentially a symptom of repetition compulsion. But the death instinct, being a principle of annihilation, seeks to destroy the archive. Therefore as Derrida points out, ‘The archive always works, and a priori, against itself ’ (p. 12). The heart of the archive is death. As discussed later in this paper, the existence of the email archive affects the Subject’s behaviour in a range of ways, but there is a specific and direct effect when archiving. The possibility of loss which the notion of the archive opens up creates great anxiety in the Subject; to lose the contents of one’s inbox in a work environment is to lose one’s way, one’s history and one’s self; on the other hand, the fact of the existence of the archive brings about anxiety in a variety of ways. This contradiction is neatly illustrated by the autoarchive function which many popular email handling software products utilize. At regular intervals, of perhaps a month, the archive speaks to us saying something like ‘would you like to auto-archive your old items now?’ Of course, the items are already archived elsewhere, so what it is really saying is ‘would you like the archive to which you have access to re-organize itself ?’. But this message creates anxiety in the two ways already mentioned. On the one hand we experience fear that the archive will hide parts of itself in a secret location which we will never be able to access. We will never again be able to know our own archive – and so our own self – or have control over it. We connect with the loss of self which the death drive implies. But on the other hand, this explicit reminder of the archive tells us we will be forced to live forever, but in a form over which we have no control. Thus the explicit reminder of archiving confronts us with the contradictions of the death drive and the implications for us as Subjects, constituted by the archive. To put this another way, when the ‘would you like to archive your old items now?’ message pops up on our screen, what it is really saying to us is ‘You’re going to die. And not only are you going to die, but I am going to make puppet representations of you live on, and the world will believe them to be you.’ Unsurprising then, that many of us, albeit guiltily, serially refuse the option to archive5. A significant aspect of the archive, discussed by Derrida, which has direct bearing on the role of email, is the way in which the existence of the archive does not just preserve the past but by doing so, impacts on the present. The existence of 7
THOMAS
an archive of our email correspondence affects our behaviour and thoughts, both when we write or reply to email, and also in other arenas. And in doing this, it changes the future. So the existence of the email archive does not just record, it produces. How does this affect the academic Subject? Partially constituted by the inscription of all the emails they have ever written and all the emails which have been written or copied to them, all of which remain forever in locations over which they have no control, they are also constituted on a present and future basis by the existence of this archive of the self. A sophisticated user of email self edits continually when writing mail, knowing that they have no control over its publication. The self that is created in the archive is permanent and is there to be gazed at at times, in places and by people unknowable for the Subject. In email exchanges we can never actually see the other’s gaze, so we are conscious that we never know what we are for the other and must fantasise what the other’s gaze may be. How much more is this insecure position compounded when we have knowledge of the existence of the archive, and the consequent awareness of the completely unknowable nature of the other. For the Subject, then, this knowledge of the archive increases the undermining of the imagined stable self, producing greater levels of uncertainty and instability. The email archive also speaks to us directly, creating an uncanny effect that echoes Derrida’s discussion of the disembodied voice on an answerphone message (p. 62) which asks us to speak to it. When the addressee of our mail has set up an automatic response which tells us that they are, perhaps, on holiday and will not respond to us immediately, we are spoken to by the phantom machinic voice of the archive. ‘Your letter has been processed’ it says ‘your utterance is now inscribed indelibly upon the archive and you will never be able to erase it’. But is not the addressee speaking to us, it is the archive itself. And, in a sense, all of the Subject’s letters are addressed to the archive, not to the apparent addressee, because the Subject is conscious of creating their public self in their utterances. So all of our utterances are addressed to death, or to the desire for immortality that the existence of death creates. The relationship of the archive, both to the death drive and the uncanny, is compounded by the silent nature of the email archive. In its creation it is, like the death drive, absolutely silent. One can imagine, when being physically on a university campus, the thousands of silent messages crossing and re-crossing in the ether, an entire, noiseless, set of discourses, sent by soundlessly chattering servers, congealing as soon as created into the archive. This paranoiac, but also fascinating, eerie and uncanny image of silent conversing, leads directly into the next topic of this paper: the idea of the collapse of the concept of a separation between public and private, in which email plays a significant, and in Derrida’s view, a ‘privileged’ (p. 17) role. THE OWNERSHIP OF EMAILS
To return the metaphor of Poe’s letter, it is significant that the letter is not stolen, but purloined. That which does not have a clear owner – and Lacan’s question of ‘to whom does the letter belong’ (p. 41) is always in play – cannot be stolen, merely purloined. How much more so than the letter does an email have dubious ownership, particularly an email written or received in a work context. Not only is there the complication of whether the sender or receiver is the ‘owner’, but the issue of who 8
THE PURLOINED EMAIL
owns an item created by a member of staff in the course of their paid employment is also brought to bear – perhaps the employer is the owner? And if the employer is part of the Public Sector, then, perhaps, the State is ultimately the owner. This is further complicated in the context of a university, where academic staff will sometimes own the intellectual property of their work. So we might pertinently ask the question, within a university environment ‘to whom does an email belong’, illustrated in Email Scenario One below: Email Scenario One Our Subject, Dr X, sends an email to a colleague, Professor Y. Y sends a response, which includes the text of the original. X then forwards the letter to W, for information, copying in Y. W replies to both X and Y, copying in A, B and C, who proceed to reply to all, adding their own comments. This ordinary, everyday example of university communication foregrounds some issues to do with the nature of ownership of emails. When Dr X sends the mail to Y, does this mail belong to the sender or the recipient? Similarly with Y’s response to X. In ‘showing’ the compound mail to W has X offended Y’s ownership rights in any way, by publishing the mail to W on his behalf? And has W, in showing the letters to three additional readers, offended X and Y’s rights? Do A, B and C have the right to comment publicly on utterances which were never spoken to them in the first place? If Y’s email contained an original idea which subsequently showed up in a paper by C, would C be plagiarising Y, or would he be building on a discussion in which he, Y and their other colleagues had all played a part? Or is all of this a practical performance of ‘de-authorisation’, started by Barthes’ announcement of the Death of the Author (Barthes 1977 [1967]), continued by Foucault’s notion of the author effect, and by the general thrust of post-Saussurean theory, further dissected by postmodernism, and brought into the realm of the digital by Poster (2003). Poster argues that the notion of authorship is problematised in a very evident way by the democratised shared publishing space provided by the Internet. In a public, digital space it is often impossible to know who is the author of a text, and there are always issues around the authenticity of any claimed identity. The ease with which digital online documents can be replicated and changed leads further to the undermining of author-ity, and this, enhanced by increasingly available technologies for sharing texts of often (seemingly) anonymous authorship, further undermines the traditional autonomous authority of the author. The only clarity in all of this is that the complex chain of utterances has no clear owner. This leaves the Subject in a position where they are obliged to operate on the principle that email exchange is always underpinned by a radical uncertainty as to whom one is addressing, and to assume that all emails are subject to being purloined. Indeed, given that university mail may or may not be the property of the employer or even the State, the emails may be, by their nature, purloined as soon as they are created. But whilst the Subject may be, on one level, aware of this, there are nevertheless forces at work which make us feel that we are operating in a private world when we engage with email. 9
THOMAS
When we delve into our inboxes to read, write or respond to an email, we are in an environment where we experience a powerful sensation of being on our own. We are usually operating in the seemingly confidential space of our own personal computer, at our own desk, in private office space. We compose an email silently, in complete privacy. In the secure box of our computer, the email software is another secure box, within which we write our specific mail in a delimited, defined box (i.e. a window). All of this provides us with an intense sense of privacy and security. The toolset which most of us use is unsophisticated and does not encourage editing, the ‘send’ button is always, invitingly and prominently, present, and the cultural norms which have arisen around the register used for email text invite informality. So, the overall effect for the Subject is a sense of sending a private, informal note to a specific person – as a colleague summed up the experience ‘it makes you feel as though you’re writing a note to your Mum, but in fact you’re writing to the world’. So the Subject is situated in the impossible, contradictory position of half believing their utterances to be private but knowing them to be public, and having to inscribe themselves on the electronic world accordingly. As Derrida has it ‘email transforms the entire public private space of humanity’ (p. 17). And in transforming the space transforms us. Despite the felt intimacy of email inscription, there is an aspect of the remoteness, impersonality, speed and simplicity of use that encourages staff and students in university settings to send emails to people to whom they would not send printed letters, or would not telephone if email was unavailable. The technology invites this. It makes the email addresses of all staff internally easily available to everyone in a university; it enables the sending of a mail to be quick and simple; and it encourages copying in, replying, forwarding, blind copying and replying to all, by making these options available as suggestions, to be performed at the click of a button. Students will email their lecturers quite casually, and senior university staff receive email communication from staff members who do not know them personally, and would not normally speak to them if this channel were not available. Whether this is democracy in action or a damned nuisance is a question of perspective, but its effect is that it increases significantly the number of occurrences and contexts in which the Subject is invited to speak. And, as discussed below, email invitations to speak are not without a directive element. An email is forced on the recipient, be they the formal addressee, the one step removed addressee to whom a mail is forwarded, or either of the two varieties of tangential addressee, the public bystander who is copied in, or the secret bystander who is blind copied in. The Subject, receiving the mail, is publicly forced to know of its contents, as the existence of the archive means there is always an audit trail which the sender – or future, unknown others – can easily make public at the click of mouse button. If the Subject is the formal addressee, the sender is publicly forcing a response from them; the Subject is forced to speak, and to write themselves in an exchange which may not be on their terms. Remaining silent is not an option, however unimportant the Subject may regard the received mail, as, in the culture of the modern university, such silence is seen as a dereliction of duty. Additionally, the 10
THE PURLOINED EMAIL
timescale within which knowledge of and/or a response is expected is short – in the region of a day or two. As the speed, ease of use, and culture of email usage invites this multiplication of utterances, an additional anxiety is created for the Subject, in that the volume of email increases and they cannot easily manage to read or respond to their mail. So the anxiety of not knowing, and being seen to be silent when they should speak is added to the picture. The overall effect on the Subject of this imperative to know and to speak is that they are publicly policed, have aspects of their work time and tasks determined by a random selection of others, which represents an erosion of their autonomy, and are forced to inscribe themselves on the digital university in contexts not of their choosing. It conjures up an interactive, internalised, version of Bentham’s panopticon, where all the participants who are being policed simultaneously encourage this policing by participating according to the established Law. But, in a sense, it both encompasses and moves beyond Foucault’s re-conjuring of the panopticon in his analysis of disciplinary societies (Foucault 1975). It has the hallmarks of Deleuze’s (1992) concept of societies of control, in that computers are the machine technology employed, and a control speaks itself though a strange kind of corporate post-hierarchical levelling. Interestingly, it is not university managers who play the most active part in this entire dance, but those in universities whose roles permit them time to send frequent emails, namely students and administrative staff. As these are two constituencies in relation to whom the academic Subject has traditionally occupied a position of relative power, this represents an intriguing shift in internal power relations brought about by the use of digital communication technology. Moving on to consider the way in which email circulation creates chains of signification and a strange, sometimes circular movement of unfixed knowledge and meaning, leads again back to Lacan’s reading of The Purloined Letter. Derrida’s (1979) concept that all texts contain a set of mechanisms or ‘heads’ for reading, with which we read other texts, is demonstrably true for the texts which constitute an email chain. The frequent effect of an answering text in the chain followed by a response or another answer from a different view, gives us a compound text apparently written by a range of unreliable narrators, where the reading of any component section of the text makes us view any other component section in a different light. At the same time, an email is positioned in the same way as the purloined letter, in that its movement around the various actors in the drama establish relationships, and create meaning, which is more than just the text within the letter; this creation of a symbolic circuit itself repositions the meaning of the texts within the letter. A second example of a typical university email, below, demonstrates a dimension of how meaning can be created by the insistence of the chain of signification Email Scenario Two Dr X sends an email to Professor Y subtly pointing out some mistake he has made or mentioning, in a coded manner, something he has omitted to do. She kindly adds that this does not matter because she, Dr X, has helped him by putting right his error or carrying out his neglected task. Dr X ccs the mail to Dean Z. 11
THOMAS
This email exchange echoes Felman’s diagrammatic illustration of the Purloined letter triads (Felman 1980, pp. 146) which is interpreted according to this context in Fig 1, below. Professor Y’s gaze is that of the Queen who sees that D__ (or X, in this case) sees but is powerless to act; Dean Z’s gaze is that of the King which takes the letter at face value, and sees nothing, i.e. no duplicity. And X’s gaze is that which sees Y is powerless and Z blind, and takes advantage of this to further her own self interest. In this scenario, the addressee is never the true destined receiver. The mail is intended for Z, and sending it to Y is merely a device for performing the statement to one in a position of power – ‘Y is negligent and I, diligently, bail him out’ – in a way that allows the meaning to unfold without having to baldly state it. Like Felman’s translations of the letter, the email represents the unconscious, with Z occupying the position of the Superego, the Law of the Father, like Poe’s ‘law’ which sees nothing; X occupying the position of the ego who can look at the other’s gaze and look at oneself in others eyes; and Y occupying the position of the unconscious or the Id, where substitutions can be made or acts can be carried out without thought for the consequences. When we read X’s Scenario One email, from whatever vantage point, we are seeing it in the chain of texts, and we are always constructing our Subject from their text(s). There are concrete echoes in this of Derrida’s (1995) point that the experience of reading conjures a ghost, and the ghostly Subject we conjure is perhaps an interesting metaphor for what the academic Subject is becoming in the haunted digital university. Where the email actually ‘is’ or ‘is not’ is also of significance in the creation of meaning in/by the signifying chain. In simple terms, the fact that X’s Scenario Two mail to Y is in the Dean’s inbox changes the whole meaning of the mail from a friendly one to a hostile, manipulative one. If Y fails to notice to whom the mail is Dean Z (The law/the superego The King)
Dr X (The ego D___)
Prof Y (The Id/unconscious The Queen) Fig 1. The Purloined Email (adapted from Felman p. 146).
12
THE PURLOINED EMAIL
copied, thus believing the mail to be in a place other than where it is, he will behave in a way vis a vis X and Z which may be damaging to him, much in the way that Minister D___ commits political suicide by continuing to act in the same way towards the Queen, because he assumes the letter is one place, when in fact it is in another. In more complex terms, the email is simultaneously nowhere, having no corporeal substance, and everywhere, forever, as it is in the archive. To paraphrase slightly Lacan’s comment on Poe’s letter ‘we cannot say of the purloined [email]… that, like other objects, it must be, or not be, in a particular place, but unlike them it will be and not be where it is, wherever it goes’. One way in which our email decidedly echoes Lacan’s purloined letter is in his point that ‘the sender, we tell you receives from the receiver his own message in reverse form…a letter always arrives at its destination’ (p. 53). The Subject of the purloined email quite literally receives, from the receiver, ‘their’ letter in reverse form, in an email chain where it’s meaning has been altered or ‘reversed’. And, in a slightly different sense, the destination of any email, because of its role in constructing the Subject, is, indeed, the sender or Subject themselves. The destination of an email is always death, the archive and the Subject. CONCLUSION
In summary, then, the academic Subject occupies a position in our haunted, digital university where their selfhood is clearly unfixed, de-stabilised, split, uncertain and constituted by the readings, utterances and gaze of others. They have little control over the construction of their selves, but they cannot die, although they commune with death and the self. They are conscious of the existence of their spectral double, and also conscious that they are that double. Their power is eroded by other constituencies within the university, and they are forced to speak and know in contexts not of their choosing. It is, essentially, a ghostly position that our digital academic occupies. The previously mentioned Times Higher Education article (Swain 2006) warns the digital academic that an email can raise a ghost by becoming ‘a hastily written missive that may come back to haunt you.’ The ghost it raises is the one which constitutes the self. When that early adopter of institutional electronic surveillance, the Abbess of Crewe, announces that ‘The age of the Father and the Son are past. We have now entered the age of the Holy Ghost,’ (Spark, 1974 p. 10), she might be speaking of the contemporary university. With the end of authority for academe, we, too, are entering the age of a ghost less holy; the spectral presence of ourselves within the haunted university. NOTES 1
2
Similarly, Birchall (2001) discusses the way in which contemporary rationality is haunted by conspiracy theories, which act as a necessary excess, permitting the closure of rationality by existing outside it and exceeding it. The Uncanny, I would argue, occupies a similar role as Birchall’s conspiracy theories. I’m using Poster’s (2001) terms ‘analogue’ to mean that which went before, or is not part of, a world which relies fundamentally on computers and the Internet, and ‘digital’ to mean that which is part of 13
THOMAS
3 4
5
that world. These terms are metaphorical rather than literal, and are not here used in their strictly technical sense. The term ‘virtual’ for Zizek, in this context may reasonably be taken to mean ‘online.’ In the narrative of ‘The Purloined Letter’ the Chief of Police, G, visits the narrator and his friend Dupin and asks for Dupin’s help with retrieving the titular letter. The letter in question was an illicit (presumably an amorous) missive, which was being read by the Queen when the King entered the room. She placed it face down, and the King did not notice it. The Minister D__, however, on entering the room perceives the letter and the meaning of it, and substitutes for it another letter. The Queen sees this but is unable to act without alerting the King to the existence of the letter. Possession of the letter, for D__ means political power as he gains influence over the Queen. The Queen asks G for his help in retrieving the letter, but G’s meticulous searching of D__’s apartments in his absence yields no result. Dupin, however, taking up G’s request for help, visits D__, perceives the letter, it’s appearance altered by being inverted and overwritten in open view on a card rack, and on a subsequent visit substitutes for it another pre-prepared identical letter. In the body of the letter he has written a quotation by means of which D___ will understand that it is by Dupin he has been duped, thus settling an old score he has with D___. An article called ‘Increasing Outlook user acceptance’ in the February 2006 online edition of Windows IT Pro identifies this reluctance on the part of email users to archive, suggesting technical solutions to the issue. (Joseph Neuberger).
REFERENCES Barthes, R. (1977 [1967]). Image-Music-Text. Glasgow: William Collins. Birchall, C. (2001). Conspiracy theories and academic discourses: The necessary possibility of popular (over)interpretation. Continuum, 15(1), 67–76. Deleuze, G. (1992). Postscript on the societies of control. October, 59, 3–7. Derrida, J. (1995). Archive fever. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Derrida, J. (1979). Living on: Border lines. In H. Bloom, et al. (Eds.), Deconstruction and criticism (pp. 75–176). New York: Continuum. Dolar, M. (1991). ‘I shall be with you on your wedding night’: Lacan and the Uncanny. October, 5–23. Felman, S. (1980). On reading poetry: Reflections of the limits and possibilities of psychoanalytic approaches. In J. P. Muller & W. J. Richardson (Eds.), (1988). The Purloined Poe (pp. 133–156). Maryland, MD: John Hopkins University Press. Foucault, M. (1991[1975]). Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison. England: Penguin. Freud, S. (1990-1). The complete Penguin Freud library. London: Penguin. Lacan, J. (1956). Seminar on the purloined letter (J. Mehlman, Trans.). In J. P. Muller & W. J. Richardson (Eds.), (1988). The Purloined Poe (pp. 6–27). Maryland, MD: John Hopkins University Press. Muller, J. P., & Richardson, W. J. (Eds.). The Purloined Poe. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press. Poster, M. (2001). What’s the matter with the Internet. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. Royle, N. (2003). The uncanny. Manchester: Manchester University Press. Spark, M. (1974). The Abbess of Crewe. Harmondsworth, England: Penguin. Swain, H. (2006, November 9). Be aware of the paperless trail. Times Higher Education, pp. 54–55. Williams, L. R. (1995). Critical desire: Psychoanalysis and the literary subject. London: Edward Arnold. Zizek, S. (1998). Interviewed in Telepolis. Retrieved from http://www.heise.de/tp/r4/artikel/2/2492/1.html
Cate Thomas UEA London University of East Anglia,UK
14
HAMISH MACLEOD AND JEN ROSS
2. STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS1 Teaching in Fool-ish Spaces
INTRODUCTION
As the rules of social engagement and hierarchy become less clearly defined in online spaces (Dubrovsky et al., 1991, Joinson 2002), so authority becomes an increasingly tricky notion in online teaching. In addition, unstructured digital spaces (wikis, live chat, virtual worlds) have great potential as sites of learning, connection and construction of meaning and self (Turkle, 1995), but the teacher’s capacity to control or regulate these spaces is limited (Land and Bayne, 2006). Indeed, we argue the tutor’s role in such a space is not to regulate, but rather to participate and provoke in creative and playful ways that open up passages or possibilities in chaotic online spaces. In choosing to talk about the role of the tutor, what it is that a learner needs of his or her senior colleague in an educational engagement, and what might be changed about the relationship between the tutor and the learner in the online learning environment, we come to our first noncept: the definition of tutoring itself. It is reassuring to find that, at time of writing, the entry ‘tutor’ in Wikipedia is a hotbed of controversy. The main article carries the warning that ‘This article appears to contradict itself ’ and the reader is directed away to the discussion about the topic on the ‘talk’ page. Superficially, the discussion seems to be about the differences in the way in which the word is used in the UK as compared with the rest of the world. On closer inspection however, the distinction being discussed is between the use of tutor as an academic rank and as academic role; between who tutors are, and what tutors do. The plot thickens considerably when we consider the term ‘tuition’. For some, tuition is what you receive when you engage in an educational exchange with another person. For others, tuition is what you pay, for… well, it is not clear what precisely. All the good words seem to be used up. The Wikipedia definition of online tutoring, on the other hand, is rather distressingly uncontroversial: Online tutoring refers to the process by which knowledge is imparted from a tutor or knowledge provider or expert to a student or knowledge recipient over the Internet.2 It does have the virtue of being clear. But it is hopelessly authoritarian and instructionist in conception, putting the sage firmly centre stage. The rhetoric is all transmission and content, without the slightest nod to a constructivist epistemology. R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 15–27. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
MACLEOD AND ROSS
Something has to be going on in a tutorial, but if it is simply knowledge transmission then a good textbook would probably serve us better. The notion of tutorless tutorials espoused by problem-based learning enthusiasts helps focus attention here. Something happens in such tutorials that is not dependent on the presence of an authority figure: the tutorial consists of conversations that contribute to building understanding. So what is it that tutors do, or should do, in support of the online learner? Some have sought to explore and clarify by the adoption of particular metaphors, such as moderator, mentor, or facilitator, to describe the tutor’s role. These terms have their value in guiding our behaviour as online tutors, but their force is primarily to warn us to stand aside. The evidence is that too much, or inappropriate, contribution to tutorial discussion by the tutor can inhibit contributions by the students (Mazzolini and Maddison, 2003). The rhetoric of facilitator and moderator speaks of a duty to liberate the students, and empower them to participate in their own learning. This has the ring of critical pedagogy about it, which would seek to remove the authority of the teacher, casting teacher and learner as equal participants in the educational endeavour. Such protestations of equality will ultimately show themselves to have been disingenuous, however, when the imperative of assessment rears its ugly head. Worse, though, is the fact that these formulations guide us about what we shouldn’t do, but remain rather silent about what we should be doing. If the online tutor is going to move from centre stage (King 1993) and sacrifice some ideas of his or her sagacity, what sorts of roles might be taken up to contribute to the guidance of the online learner? There are paradoxes here. We know that distance education (and, by implication, online engagement) is associated with particularly high discontinuation rates (Simpson, 2003; Tinto, 1993) and so it would seem that the online learner will need more, rather than less, perceived support from the teacher. Yet the online teacher has no physical presence to which the online learner can turn, and the nature of time-shifted asynchronous communication that supports much online learning will mean that significant delays must be tolerated between exchanges. In deliberately standing aside to allow the learner more personal autonomy, the online teacher must nevertheless make their virtual presence felt strongly (Garrison & Anderson, 2003). Steps must be taken to counter the remoteness and mediated nature of the relationship. In this paper we explore the notion of the presence of the online educator as being that of the jester, trickster or fool. To start with, here are some general thoughts about each of these archetypal characters. JESTER
They have ridden like froth down the whirlpools of time, They have jingled their caps in the councils of state, They have snared half the wisdom of life in a rhyme, And tripped into nothingness grinning at fate. (Don Marquis, from ‘The Jester’, 1915. http://www.thenoodlebowl.com/jesters/pages/jesters.html) 16
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS
And while the king was looking down, the jester stole his thorny crown… (Don McLean, ‘American Pie’) Who shall bring redemption, but the jesters? (The Talmud) Court jesters have been figures in European history and literature since ancient Roman times. Jesters in other traditions – Chinese, Middle-Eastern, Indian – have similarly long lineages (Otto, 2001). Though their characteristics and roles are not identical across these traditions, there are some common qualities: irreverence, wit, and a complex and shifting relationship with power. Jesters are irritants in the society around – like the proverbial grain of sand in an oyster. The responsibility of these characters is to poke fun at the established authority, and to ask questions about what would seem to be the obvious, natural order of things. TRICKSTER
Tricksters challenge the status quo and disrupt perceived boundaries. Whether foolishly, arrogantly, or bravely, tricksters face the monstrous, transforming the chaotic to create new worlds and new cultures. (Smith 1997, p. 2) Coyote, Raven, Loki, and Anansi are some names the trickster is known by. Tricksters emerge from their many cultural contexts as some combination of magical, powerful, arrogant, challenging, irresponsible, malicious, difficult-to-pin-down, shapeshifting, selfish, frightening and unpredictable. The trickster is a maker of mischief and a creator of tension, occasionally with actively malicious intent, but more often than not s/he (and indeed, ambiguity of sex, sexuality and gender is often a feature of the trickster’s persona) is also responsible for the resolution of the tension by fun and foolery (Radin 1956). FOOL
Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men. (I Corinthians 1:25) In considering the Fool as a metaphor, there are many stories and ideas to choose from. From sacred or mystical fools, to the ‘feast of fools’, to the Zen ‘beginner’s mind’ and Shakespearean and other literary fools, fools are characters who provoke new wisdom in others, rather than owning conventional wisdom in their own right. They are tolerated rather than loved by the objects of their attention, and yet their importance is tacitly acknowledged through assumptions of divine protection, commission, or even essence. The irritation that the fool engenders is frequently the source of insights on the part of others; protagonists frequently emerge as sadder, but wiser, following a fool’s ministrations. 17
MACLEOD AND ROSS
The fool’s mastery is of context (Welsford 1935, p. 5), not content. The trickster stands at thresholds and deals in liminality, and delights in the role of outsider, stranger, other. The jester is both grounded and exposed, and is therefore a lightningrod for aggression. S/he both challenges and upholds authority, while the trickster is more consistently subversive. As we will see, there is a place for all of these roles in online teaching. They are not easy to sustain – they are uncomfortable and, perhaps, quite lonely. By embracing discomfort and loneliness the teacher-fool can therefore also perhaps gain insight into their students’ sense of being lost in online spaces. By exploring themes and ideas relating to these archetypal characters, we invite teachers to embrace some of the challenges, contradictions and fun of teaching and learning online. What follows is divided into three sections, which reflect the insights and strategies we think the metaphors of fool, jester and trickster offer to online teaching: – authority, attention and risk; – innocence, danger and fun; – complexity, liminality and absurdity. AUTHORITY, ATTENTION AND RISK
First: a story about Anansi3, a trickster with West African origins, who is also often found in Caribbean folklore. He is both very clever and very greedy, and once went though many trials in order to be named the ‘King of All Stories’4. In this tale, he makes it his business to gather up and hoard all the world’s wisdom (or common sense) in a calabash. He succeeds eventually, and is looking for a place to hide the wisdom. He decides to hide it at the top of a tall tree, so he straps the calabash to his chest and begins to climb. However, the calabash keeps getting in his way, and Anansi becomes frustrated. A small child observes what Anansi is doing, and calls up to him to put the calabash on his back, instead. Anansi is furious that after all the work he has done, even a small child has wisdom that he doesn’t possess. He smashes the calabash, and the wisdom scatters everywhere, so that everyone has some, but no one has it all. Anansi wanted to control access to stories, and to define everyone’s relationship with knowledge, and this is one way of looking at the traditional ‘sage on the stage’ approach to teaching. Online, though, it is impossible to make authority/truth claims as if in a vacuum; the online space is one where the presence of other knowledge, and the willingness and ability of students to locate and articulate this, is never very far from the surface. And, in a medium that is itself evolving quickly, the tutor is not always going to be able to look like the source of all wisdom. What, then, is the online tutor’s role? A willingness to be the focus of critical attention – and, at times, a lightning-rod for aggression – is part of the function of the jester-teacher. It is possible that in online spaces any type of attention the tutor can attract is better than none at all. The volume of readily available information ‘out there’, where the tutor and the learner must meet, means that the ability to grab and hold a learner’s attention is challenged: “...in an information economy, the real scarce commodity will always be human attention” (Lanham 2006, online). To be impossible to ignore must, at times, be the 18
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS
tutor’s primary goal in entering the noisy silence of the online learner’s experience in chaotic spaces. As Roszak (1994) has it, ‘An excess of information may actually crowd out ideas, leaving the mind (young minds especially) distracted by sterile, disconnected facts, lost among shapeless heaps of data’. In Second Life, being impossible to ignore may involve donning fins and a wetsuit or a bright red mohawk and, quite literally (well, quite virtually), clowning. In textual spaces like wikis, it may mean being flagrantly provocative, in playing ‘devil’s advocate’5, and in demanding active debate and disagreement from students. Self-mockery or encouragement of critical attention from students can be challenging for tutors, though. Jesting demands exposure, while traditional models of ‘sage on the stage’ teaching serve to protect and distance the teacher from personal vulnerability, and, as such, provide little to prepare the online teacher for the lengths to which he or she may wish to go in inviting challenge and attracting attention. Part of the jester’s role has traditionally also been to mock and expose the folly of powerful people and ideas (Peterson 2003, online). However, the jester-teacher who encourages his or her students to question authority and speak truth to power must be prepared for the possibility that he or she will be the first casualty of any student brave enough to take such encouragement seriously. The flattening effect of online spaces, where students are already less likely to perceive the tutor as the source of all authority or respect the boundaries of a traditional, hierarchical student/ teacher relationship (Dubrovsky et al., 1991), enhances the likelihood that the jesting gaze will be turned on the tutor. The fear of exposure and loss of authority that could accompany such strategies may be heightened by the teacher’s own subject positions in terms of gender, age and ethnicity, for example. Some tutors may feel they cannot afford to allow their hard-won authority to be challenged. For others, it may be important for them to ask themselves what masking function playing the jester/fool might perform, in light of the their unquestionable authority to assess: ‘we should not forget that the metaphor of the Jester also implies the use of indirect and subtle ways to achieve desired results. There is a clear idea on the part of the Jester of which results are important to achieve...’ (Ashworth 2004, p. 80). Court jesters in history have often been ‘learned men’ in disguise (Welsford 1968, p. 23), and we do well to be reminded of the layers of identities the tutor as jester assumes. Ellsworth, who has problematised critical pedagogy as being insufficiently attentive to the tutor’s own position(s) of privilege, describes a shift from ‘dialogue’ to ‘working together across differences’ (Ellsworth, 1989). Such a shift acknowledges social positions and involves everyone – teachers and students – in attending to the circulation of power in their online classrooms. INNOCENCE, DANGER AND FUN
In a story about Mulla Nasrudin (sometimes Nasreddin), a mystic Turkish jester/fool: Nasrudin sat on a river bank when someone shouted to him from the opposite side: ‘Hey! how do I get across?’ ‘You are across!’ Nasrudin shouted back.6 19
MACLEOD AND ROSS
Nasrudin’s response hints at several possibilities for the online learner: that the place one is may be perfectly adequate; that there is not necessarily a need to rush off somewhere else. This may be particularly the case at times when ignorance is felt most keenly. Moments of not-knowing can be extremely uncomfortable, and extremely productive. The fool embodies secure not-knowing in a way which can serve as a model for teachers and students. Secure not-knowing might also be termed ‘beginner’s mind’ (shoshin), or ‘Zen mind’: The Zen way of calligraphy is to write in the most straightforward, simple way as if you were a beginner, not trying to make something skilful or beautiful, but simply writing with full attention as if you were discovering what you were writing for the first time; then your full nature will be in your writing. (Introduction to Suzuki 1996, p. 14) Students often fear, apologise for, or worst of all, conceal their feelings of ignorance. Convincing the student that it is perfectly acceptable not to know is not just a matter of tolerance and patience – not simply that the tutor should be courteous and unthreatening in his or her questioning. It is a matter of seeing the value in searching for an uncluttered perspective and a beginner’s mind. To quote Groucho Marx, ‘A child of five would understand this. Send someone to fetch a child of five’. The benefit for the learner of seeking to find nothing strange is the engagement of intelligence in the Piagetian sense of being ‘what you use when you don’t know what to do’ (Calvin, 1996). Attentive, ‘childlike’ curiosity on the part of tutors and students, and the accidental learning which can result is a gift that being Fool-ish might offer us. Willeford (1969) writes of confrontations with foolishness which require us to untangle ourselves from our assumptions about the world: Two Englishmen are riding in a train. FIRST ENGLISHMAN: ‘I say, is this Wembley?’ SECOND ENGLISHMAN: ‘No, Thursday.’ FIRST ENGLISHMAN: ‘I am, too.’ The Englishmen remain placid in what strikes us as their foolishness; they are [not] troubled by their incomprehension of each other... But their behaviour inflicts violence upon our assumptions of what people are and of how they ought to behave... we feel ourselves fooled by the irrational mess that has been made of a conventional conversation; in freeing ourselves from that mess, in which our conscious assumptions about the world have become for a moment stuck, we experience within ourselves the supremacy of the fugitive and irresponsible fool. The magical force that induces chaos in the presence of the fool often results in a transvaluation of values that could be the beginning of a new order. (p. 110–111) Good learning is often dependent on the ability to stand back from that which is already known. Alvin Toffler (1970) suggested not only the ability to learn as being central to literacy in the 21st Century, but also the ability to unlearn, and to relearn. Existing classifications of information should not be allowed to prevent us from seeing alternative patterns. Kurt Lewin (1947), in thinking about the challenge of 20
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS
social change, used the notion of ‘unfreezing’ to describe this need to challenge the obviously true in one’s cognitive structures. Indeed this can be seen in a very concrete way in the scholarship of physics teaching, where it can be shown that the active removal of incorrect, naive models is an important basis for establishment of more useful, predictive models of physical understanding (Hake, 1998). Perry’s (1970) model of the development of the student’s epistemology suggests that the learner new to higher studies begins with the view that the truth exists, is out there to be known, and that it is consequently the teacher’s job to set it forth, and the learner’s job to assimilate it. The view that knowledge is contested and conditional in all sorts of important ways is often a difficult one to arrive at from this starting point. However, tolerance of ambiguity, and a willingness to let go of the security felt in previous learning, can open doors to the complexity of a subject. Tutors in online spaces have a unique opportunity to demonstrate the partiality and situatedness of knowledge, much as Nasrudin does, by drawing parallels with that which is so obviously the case in a physical sense – that each learner is somewhere else, and that much depends on perspective. Even those disciplines which would seem to offer the possibility of certainty and objective truth are full of ‘partially correct’ models of the world which serve us well, and have been reinforced on many occasions. The reasons for this are explored in books by Gilovich (1991), and Piattelli-Palmarini (1994). There is evidence that individuals differ in the strength of their need for cognitive closure. But there is also evidence that a playful or humorous approach by a teacher in a child’s early years can encourage that child to be less upset by cognitive ambiguity (Tegano et al., 1999). Perhaps it is not too late for the higher education tutor. The jester-teacher, however, must be particularly careful to direct his or her antics away from the audience – to include and involve them without making them targets or demanding self-mockery in return. Even with this in mind, challenging forms of humour, such as satire, can be painful for learners. The actor and entertainer Michael Flanders once said that ‘The purpose of satire, it has been rightly said, is to strip off the veneer of comforting illusion and cosy half truth, and our job, as I see it, is to put it back again!’ Moving away from the comforting illusion and cosy half truth can be a distressing business. Sensitivity and care are needed in order to successfully tutor jest-fully; like juggling or tight-rope walking, there is skill involved. The skill in jesting is to make it look easy and spontaneous, while at the same time being aware of the limits of one’s audience: in other words, not to go too far. The tradition of humanitarian clowning may be a useful model here, one whose principal aim is to calm, heal and facilitate: ‘Most of the time we don’t know what rippling affect [sic] our little silliness has in calming situations and opening doors for others to do their work. We are not attached to results. The play of the moment is what is important’ (Shobhana Schwebke, hospital clown7). There is certainly a place for casting the chaos as fun and excitement, rather than threat and danger, in our role as tutors. The gentle clown also offers spaces for laughter and fun amongst the serious business of learning (Berk, 2003). ‘As a pedagogical device, humour can promote various objectives, such as to increase student interest and attention, facilitate the 21
MACLEOD AND ROSS
student-teacher relationship, provide students with a ‘mental break,’ or promote the understanding and retention of a concept.’ (LoSchiavo & Shatz, 2005, online). In addition, as Berk has found, ‘humour’s primary psychological role is as an emotional response or buffer to relieve physical stress… laughter has been shown to stimulate a physiological effect that decreases stress...’ (Stambor 2006, online). Space for fun and light-hearted moments can be difficult to provide for in asynchronous interactions. However, LoSchiave and Shatz found that ‘humour can… help create an online atmosphere that encourages participation, creativity, and exploration’ (2005). COMPLEXITY, LIMINALITY AND ABSURDITY
Unlike the jester, part of whose role is consciously and carefully to ‘speak truth to power’, the fool is often seen as revealing the truth unwittingly, and to the benefit of the audience rather than himself. Shakespearian fools, for example, can ‘test our capacity to hear truth, in slant, peculiar and painful forms, and to use it to take a few steps in the general direction of freedom” (Edmundson 2000, online). There is much that could be usefully drawn out here about individual fools in Shakespeare: Touchstone, ‘a wise fool who acts as a kind of guide or point of reference throughout the play, putting everyone, including himself, to the comic test’ (John Palmer8), and who travels with the protagonists into the Forest of Arden – the place between – where their fates are sorted out; Feste in Twelfth Night, both pivotal to, and slightly removed from, the action of the play; and Yorick, the silent Fool, whose absence deprived Hamlet of an usher ‘down the road not taken, a road on which he might have found some measure of happiness’ (Edmundson 2000, online). Generally speaking, though, Shakespearian fools draw attention to the depth and complexity of things, but often in sidelong ways, in minor roles, and rarely for more than a moment or two at a time – perhaps because the audience, once pointed in the right direction, can do much of the work of untangling complexity themselves. Indeed, it is necessary that we do untangle complexity ourselves. The online tutor is required to be so explicit and so prepared to have the first word that he or she may forget to leave spaces for the necessary work of the learner in constructing his or her own understanding of the material. These spaces can be a gift, and a vote of confidence: ‘In Shakespeare, to have a fool attending on you is generally a mark of distinction. It means that you’ve retained some flexibility, can learn things, might change; it means that you’re not quite past hope… To be assigned a fool in Shakespeare is often a sign that one is, potentially, wise’ (Edmundson 2000, online). The online tutor can often leap in too quickly, and make his or her guiding or clarifying input as soon as a student is seen as floundering. However, the evidences are that contributions from the tutor can lead to what Jean Wood has called ‘premature teacher closure of online learning conversations’ (Wood, 2003). The temptation for the students is to say ‘That’s alright then’ in response to the tutor’s contribution, and to hear the tutor’s input as definitive. When this happens in a faceto-face tutorial it is obvious, and there is usually the opportunity to repair it. When it happens online, it may not be noticed by the tutor until the moment has passed, and the opportunity is lost forever. 22
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS
On the other hand, and also following the model of a Shakespearian fool, the tutor should try to create a felt presence, so that the group, and the individual student, trusts that the tutor is aware of what is going on and is available to help out should it be needed. This may be an entirely psychological matter, or may be assisted by technology. For example, the manifestation of the presence of the tutor online within systems such as Blackboard/WebCT or through some application like Microsoft Messenger, or Skype, may serve to encourage and reassure the student. There is no implication here that the student will approach the tutor’s online presence – although this may happen if it needs to – but that a felt presence bolsters the student’s confidence to work, and take risks, on their own. Turner maintains that the wide presence of tricksters in world literatures: derives from their liminality, the “betwixt and between” state of transition and change that is a source of myth in all cultures (‘Myth and Symbol’ p. 580). As liminal beings, tricksters dwell at crossroads and thresholds and are endlessly multifaceted and ambiguous” (Smith 1997, p. 7–8). Online tutors, like tricksters, are the guardians of liminal spaces and of states of change and flux. These correspond, perhaps, to Meyer and Land’s (2005) ‘threshold concepts’. In the case of all online learners, regardless of discipline, one ‘troublesome knowledge’ (Perkins 1999) tricksters guard may be a practical understanding that there is always a position to take: Interpreter, storyteller, and transformer, the trickster is a master of borders and exchange, injecting multiple perspectives to challenge all that is stultifying, stratified, bland or prescriptive. (Smith 1997, p. xiii) The perceived boundaries of the self are more fluid in this medium (Turkle, 1995), and the online trickster-tutor has the opportunity to be present at this threshold and to demonstrate the power of exploring identity as a way of understanding what we hold sacred about ourselves – the sacred as a point of transition, not a starting point, nor necessarily a place of ultimate arrival. For example, we might consider what the medieval Feast of Fools (a day on which ecclesiastical hierarchies were inverted, choirboys dressed up as priests and elected a ‘bishop’ from among their number – see for example Jung, in Radin 1956) accomplishes by reversals and other acts which straddle the line9 between playful and radical. To perform a reversal or make fun of something in a Fool-ish or trickster-ish way does not necessarily mean that we are dismissing it. Rather, this is about bringing ideas into sharp relief so they can be examined. Self-awareness, reflexivity and the security of being able to recognise one’s own position (at any given moment) is a possible reward for the trouble of entering online spaces with an openness to their difference and our own difference within them. To provoke such exploration is sometimes to provoke fearful responses, and here, also, the trickster has something to offer. Fear can be a useful catalysing force, but: The important point here seems to be getting to know our fear, examining it closer, staring at it square in the eye – not as a means of solving our problem, but as a way of undoing old ways of seeing, thinking, and feeling…. The ‘trick’ 23
MACLEOD AND ROSS
is getting people to keep exploring and not bail out, especially when we discover something is not what we thought or expected it to be. (Sessums 2007, online) The trickster has the ability to play with and celebrate ambiguity. S/he prefers chaos to order, and such a preference opens up radical possibilities for structuring (or deconstructing) online learning situations. These possibilities fit well with the nonlinear, hypertextual/visual worlds in which online learners and teachers find themselves: pedagogical methods and intentions rooted in principles of textual stability and the dissemination of knowledge among stable, autonomous subjects [are] often at odds with a medium in which both text and subject are liable to metamorphosis, to the shape-shifting which is so much a feature of our lives in the digital realm. (Bayne 2005, online) One final story. Nasrudin was said to have ascended on three different days into the pulpit to preach, asking each time whether the audience knew what he was going to say. The first time, they said ‘no’, to which he replied ‘What shall I say to you until you do know?’, and left. The second time Nasrudin asked, the people said ‘yes’, and Nasrudin said ‘Some of you do know already, what should I have to say to you?’, and left again. The third time he asked, and after much discussion, some of the congregation replied ‘yes’, and some replied ‘no’. Nasrudin again left, this time telling them that ‘It were now well that those among ye who knew what the Cogia said should teach those that did not’ (Borrow 1884, online). Along with advocating a Web 2.0-style collaborative pedagogy, what is Nasreddin doing here? He may be poking fun at his followers and their desire to give the correct answer. He is also exposing them to absurdity. The ability to entertain absurdity and paradox is an important part of the process of arriving at new insights: old knowledge and understanding must be disrupted and reconfigured by new ideas or information in order for a more complex understanding of a subject to take shape. Piaget saw this disruption as a fundamental part of cognitive growth (Piaget, 1964). He described the way in which new knowledge, incompatible with existing knowledge structures, brings about a state of cognitive disequilibrium, thus motivating the cognitive resolution that follows. Similarly, Dewey (1934) observed that ‘equilibrium comes about not mechanically and inertly but out of, and because of, tension’. We are all inclined to want the safety of feeling sure of ourselves and certain that we have all the answers. Someone needs to come along and prise our white-knuckled fingers off the safety rail, and push us over the side, perhaps with a simple observation: the view is marvelous as you fall. This is what the trickster, fool and jester invite and challenge us to do for ourselves and for our students. CONCLUSION
As we have roamed through the territory opened up for us by the metaphors of jester, fool and trickster, we have often found the boundary between what we would wish to say about online ‘learners’ and ‘teachers/tutors’ blurring or dissolving entirely. 24
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS
The possibility that our approach might contribute to some of the ambiguity and surprise that we have celebrated through these characters is both pleasing and troubling. However, we have explored several aspects of what we consider to be fool-ish practice specifically for online tutors. In conclusion, our view is that online tutors should: – be willing to be the focus of critical attention, and to make themselves impossible to ignore in noisy online spaces; – support students to question and challenge authority (theirs and others’), but be aware of their own positions of power in doing so; – model ‘secure not-knowing’ and enjoyment of ambiguity; – find ways to provide a felt presence; – allow students to untangle complexity for themselves, in their own context; – be playful and use humour without making students a target; – make the sacred a point of transition. These are not practical ‘tips for teachers’, and nor do we intend them to be. Rather, they represent a frame of mind: a jester, trickster or fool’s approach to being alongside students in challenging, chaotic, digital environments. NOTES 1
2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9
The story goes that the title of the book by Marshall McLuhan and Quentin Fiore ‘The Medium is the Massage’ was actually a misprint which the authors allowed to stand because they felt that the event (the misprint) contributed to the point they were trying to make, and because they enjoyed its value as a pun. Our ‘noncepts’ word derived from a typo in an email exchange between us while discussing the paper, and has stuck as a way of expressing those ideas that we were trying to grapple with for which no appropriate words or metaphors existed. Judging by the relative proximity of the ‘c’ and ‘n’ keys on the QWERTY keyboard, this was more likely to have been a Freudian Slip than a typographical error, the word striving to combine the spirit of ‘concepts’ and ‘nonsense’. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_tutoring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anansi http://mythsandtales.com/_wsn/page17.html Playing devil’s advocate is in itself a challenging notion for many learners, who may, especially in their early years of higher education, be conditioned by what Stewart and Cohen call ‘lies to children’ (Pratchett, Stewart and Cohen, 1999) to expect simple and unambiguous questions and equally simple answers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasreddin http://www.hospitalclown.com/InfoPages/What%20is%20a%20Hospital%20Clown.htm http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Touchstone If there is such a line – ludic postmodernism, for example, would suggest that the playful is the radical. See Kellner and Best 1997, The Postmodern Turn.
REFERENCES Ashworth, P., Handl, G., Hole, C., Land, R., Orr, M., & Phipps, A. (2004). Who are “we”, who are “you”, who are “they”? Issues of role and identity in academic development. In L. Elvidge (Ed.), Exploring academic development in higher education - Issues of engagement. Cambridge: Jill Rogers Associates. Bayne, S. (2005). Deceit, desire and control: The identities of learners and teachers in cyberspace. In R. Land & S. Bayne (Eds.), Education in cyberspace. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
25
MACLEOD AND ROSS Berk, R. A. (2003). Professors are from Mars, students are from snickers: How to write and deliver humor in the classroom and in professional presentations. Sterling, VA: Stylus. Calvin, W. H. (1996). How brains think: Evolving intelligence, then and now. New York: Basic Books. Dubrovsky, B. J., Kiesler, S., & Sethna, B. (1991). The equalization phenomenon: Status effects in computer-mediated and face-to-face decision-making groups. Human-Computer Interaction, 6, 119–136. Edmundson, M. (2000, April). Playing the fool. New York Times, 2. online. Ellsworth, E. (1989). Why doesn’t this feel empowering? Working through the repressive myths of critical pedagogy. Harvard Educational Review, 59, 3. Festinger, L. (1957). A theory of cognitive dissonance. Evanston, IL: Row Peterson. Flanders, M., & Swann, D. (1964). At the drop of another hat. Parlophone PCS 3052. Recorded live during a performance at the Haymarket Theatre, London, 1963. Dewey, J. (1934). Art as experience. New York: Capricorn Books. Garrison, D. R., & Anderson, T. (2003). E-learning in the 21st century: A framework for research and practice. London: RoutledgeFalmer. Gilovich, T. (1991). How we know what isn’t so: The fallibility of human reason in everyday life. New York: Free Press. Joinson, A. N. (2002). Understanding the psychology of Internet behaviour: Virtual worlds, real lives. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Hake, R. R. (1998). Interactive-engagement versus traditional methods: A six-thousand-student survey of mechanics test data for introductory physics courses. American Journal of Physics, 66(1), 64–77. King, A. (1993). From sage on the stage to guide on the side. College Teaching, 41(1), 30–35. Land, R., & Bayne, S. (2002). Screen or monitor? Surveillance and disciplinary power in online learning environments. In C. Rust (Ed.), Improving student learning using learning technology (pp. 125–138). Oxford: OCSLD. Land, R., & Bayne, S. (2006). Issues in cyberspace education. In M. Savin-Baden & K. Wilkie (Eds.), Problem-based learning online. Maidenhead: Society for Research into Higher Education & Open University Press. Lanham, R. (2006). Economists of attention. In The economics of attention: Style and substance in the age of information. Extract online at http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/468828.html Lewin, K. (1947). Frontiers in group dynamics human relations. Reprinted in D. Cartwright (Ed.), Field theory in social science (Vol. 1, No. 1). London: Tavistock, 1952. LoSchiavo, F., & Shatz, M. (2005). Bringing life to online instruction with humor. Radical Pedagogy. Online at http://radicalpedagogy.icaap.org/content/issue8_2/shatz.html Mazzolini, M., & Maddison, S. (2003). Sage, guide or ghost? The effect of instructor intervention on student participation in online discussion forums. Computers & Education, 40(3), 237–253. Meyer, J. H. F., & Land, R. (2005). Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge (2): Epistemological considerations and a conceptual framework for teaching and learning. Higher Education, 49, 373–388. McWilliam, E. (2005). Unlearning pedagogy. Journal of Learning Design, 1(1). Mortola, P. (2001). Sharing disequilibrium. A link between Gestalt therapy theory and child development theory. Gestalt Review, 5(1), 45–56. Otto, B. (2001). Fools are everywhere: The court jester around the world. University of Chicago Press. Extract online at http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/640914.html Perkins, D. (1999). The many faces of constructivism. Educational Leadership, 57(3), 6–11. Perry, W. G., Jr. (1970). Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years: A scheme. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Peterson, B. (2003). Fools are everywhere: The court jester around the world (review). Journal of World History, 14(4), 555–559. Piaget, J. (1964). Development and learning. In R. E. Ripple & V. N. Rockcastle (Eds.), Piaget rediscovered. New York: Cornell University Press. Piattelli-Palmarini, M. (1994). Inevitable illusions: How mistakes of reason rule our minds. New York; Chichester: Wiley. Pratchett, T., Stewart, I., & Cohen, J. S. (1999). The science of discworld. London: Ebury. 26
STRUCTURE, AUTHORITY AND OTHER NONCEPTS Radin, P. (1956). The trickster. A study in American Indian mythology (With commentaries by Karl Kere & C. G. Jung, pp. xi, 211). London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Roszak, T. (1994). The cult of information: A neo-Luddite treatise on high tech, artificial intelligence, and the true art of thinking. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Sessums, C. (2007). Please panic! Allowing the moment to become the teacher. Online at http://elgg. net/csessums/weblog/147086.html Simpson, O. (2003). Student retention in online, open and distance learning. London: Kogan Page. Smith, J. R. (1997). Writing tricksters: Mythic gambols in American ethnic literature. London: University of California Press. Stambor, Z. (2006). How laughing leads to learning. Monitor on Psychology, 37(6). Online at http://www. apa.org/monitor/jun06/learning.html Suzuki, S. (1996). Zen mind, beginner’s mind. New York: Weatherhill. Tegano, D. W., Groves, M. M., & Catron, C. E. (1999). Early childhood teachers’ playfulness and ambiguity tolerance: Essential elements of encouraging creative potential of children. Journal of Early Childhood Teacher Education, 20(3), 291–300. Tinto, V. (1993). Leaving college: Rethinking the causes and cures of student attrition. Chicago; London: University of Chicago Press. Toffler, A. (1970). Future shock. London: Pan Books. Turkle, S. (1995). Life on the screen: Identity in the age of the Internet. New York: Simon & Schuster. Welsford, E. (1935). The fool; his social and literary history. New York: Farrar & Rinehart. Willeford, W. (1969). The fool and his sceptre. London: Edward Arnold (Publishers) Ltd. Wood, J. A. (2003). The ‘re-skilling’ of tertiary teachers for new learning environments. Victoria, Australia: Deakin University.
Hamish Macleod and Jen Ross University of Edinburgh, UK
27
MAGGI SAVIN-BADEN, CHRISTINE SINCLAIR, CHRISTINE SANDERS AND SECOND WIND1
3. LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD Being Learners in Silent Spaces
INTRODUCTION
This chapter presents our perspectives on being learners on the first two modules of a new and innovative MSc in E-Learning. We explore our reasons for undertaking this course, particularly as we are both fairly experienced academics, and we examine when and how we experienced ‘stuckness’, and the particular factors that created this sense of disjunction. We use narrative inquiry as our informing methodology. The chapter delineates the forms of stuckness we have experienced and identifies the catalysts for these forms. The final section of the chapter suggests that some of the stuckness we have experienced is related to a new form of lurking, and argues that our experience may have implications for other learners in online spaces. LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD: OUR STORIES
We begin by presenting our positions as both academics and learners and explore the notion that being an e-learning student can sometimes feel like being in a silent space. Christine/Christine Sanders: I had two motivations for undertaking the MSc in e-learning: one an awareness that I was slipping behind in understanding of the ‘e’ environment and the other, the main one, to experience actually being an e-learning student. I had already researched the experience of being an undergraduate student in a new discipline by becoming such a student again. (I had become a mechanical engineering student, though my background is philosophy and education.) Now I wanted to explore a new mode of study, as well as a new discipline, and from a postgraduate perspective As Christine Sanders, I have been enabled to enter a whole new environment (Second Life) and have even learned to fly and teleport myself. I have been surprised at how wary I have been about Second Life, given my enthusiasm for taking on an alternative perspective both in my early study and this current one. Maggi: Over the last five years I have enjoyed the shifts to e-learning and I like to fiddle and play with technology - even though most of the time I don’t R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 29–42. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
actually know what I am doing. However, as someone who has researched learning for many years I was constantly frustrated by what I saw as the ‘clunkiness’ of learning in online spaces. I hated the ordering strategies of VLEs and the discussions I had had with many experts was that the problem was not with the VLE but how I was choosing to use it. Having heard Sian Bayne speak about learning in cyberspace I realised that the problems might not just be with me. I felt I had given WebCT ‘a go’ but thought that if I wanted to learn differently then perhaps many others did too. I heard about this MSc and decided the best way to prevent any further courses I developed from being completely vanilla, being a learner for my ‘self ’ was the way forward. However, I didn’t expect the shift into liminal spaces to occur quite so quickly nor did I expect the course to be quite so addictive. As Second Wind I have found that I have been more playful and challenging than usual, particularly in group seminars on the beach. My biggest shock was how much my appearance affected how I was ‘seen’ and because of this I have changed from looking quite like my-self to looking like a goth-withattitude, (which probably reflects the subtext of my RL). Maggi’s identification of ‘liminal spaces’ is key to our interpretation of what has happened to us as students and occasionally to our avatars. This notion, originally derived from cultural anthropology, relates to transition and ambiguity and is considered further below in our account of how we approached our task. METHODOLOGY
Our stories show that the idea of using our own data as research material occurred to both of us from an early stage. We both saw a value in providing a thick description (Ryle, 1968; Geertz, 1973) of our experiences as students. In short, we adopted a form of narrative inquiry. Our new stories, we believed, could be a means of understanding experience as lived and told, through our blogs, assignments, discussions and the literature we read. Narrative inquiry can be seen in a variety of ways and tends to combine a number of different approaches and traditions such as biography, autobiography, life story and more recently life course research. In terms of locating it in the broad spectrum of qualitative research, it tends to be positioned within a constructivist stance with reflexivity, interpretivism and representation being primary features of the approach. It is possible to see these features by comparing how reflexivity is seen in narrative inquiry against other approaches. For example, Lincoln separated what she termed conventional qualitative methods from constructivist methods that emphasise holism. She highlighted the ontological stance of constructivist research as being that ‘realities are constructed entities’ (Lincoln, 1992, p.379), and emphasised the subjective nature of its epistemology. Our own stories, then, might be expected to relate to our own representations of our student experience. Differences about the issue of representation seem to be one of the strong points of disagreement between qualitative researchers who hold different perspectives. 30
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
This is not surprising, because to debate the issue of representation would usually draw into question the very processes by which the voices of participants are believed to be captured and presented. We consider that such opinions are, in turn, strongly influenced by views that are held about the nature of truth and truths. Denzin’s view of the representational crisis is characterised by the assumption that ‘much, if not all, qualitative and ethnographic writing is a narrative production…’ (Denzin, 1997, p.4). The assumption that follows is that ‘there is a world out there (the real) that can be captured by a ‘knowing’ author through the careful transcription (and analysis) of field materials (interviews, notes, etc.)’ (Denzin 1997, p.4). Denzin, positioned within critical post-structuralism, challenged these assumptions by stating that: Language and speech do not mirror experience: They create experience and in the process of creation constantly transform and defer that which is being described. The meanings of a subject’s statements are, therefore, always in motion. (Denzin 1997, p.5) It is in such transformations that a sense of liminality may be experienced. And when what is being described happens on the Internet ‘which draws users into peculiar kinds of ephemeral ‘places’ that we do not have words to adequately describe’ (Waskul, 2005, p.54), then inevitably we find ourselves in liminal spaces. However, we argue that narrative inquiry must go beyond the notion of just telling stories. By using our narratives at the beginning of this article we hope to begin the process of illuminating the difference between ‘stories’ as data and narrative inquiry. POSITIONING OURSELVES AS RESEARCHERS
Our interest in narrative inquiry emerged from our experiences of using stories in our teaching and in the notion of the blog and discussion forum as being a space for sharing experiences, journeying and telling stories. In practice, we: – read each others’ blogs – critiqued each others’ coursework – considered each others’ postings on the discussion board – interpreted these as data – from the data, located common and contradictory themes We opted to select and analyse excerpts from each others’ data. Through this process, we tried to understand each others’ stories and thus came to an appreciation of shared and informed consent. This chapter therefore contains both separate and joined stories; there are two voices with a shared interpretation. Yet the reading of each others’ blogs, for example, enabled us to see not only similarities and differences but also how one of us privileged some ideas, concepts and experiences that the other had barely noticed. Furthermore, the notion of what counted as a story and biography in this self reflexive study was something we necessarily saw as problematic, but how it was problematised was an issue that seemed to slip in and out of focus as we used it as a research method, as we illustrate in the examples below. 31
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
Although presented as separate themes, there is an overlap and intermeshing across them. The overarching themes across our stories comprised: – silence and stuckness – catalysts to stuck places – lurking on thresholds SILENCE AND STUCKNESS
The overarching sense of silence and stuckness pervaded the course for both of us. What we mean by silence is not only lurking on the discussion boards, but not knowing what we thought, how to position ourselves, what to say. While our stuckness was largely characterised by conflict, ambiguity and incoherence, sometimes it seemed as if we were just pedagogically immobile; at other times we were cross and frustrated, knowing there must be better ways of attempting tasks but not really knowing where to start. Paradoxically, online spaces can also seem to be very noisy places, with many people ‘talking’ at once and using a language that may be alien in part. For example, Phipps (2005) has discussed the notion of ‘sounds’ in academia and argues that the changes in sounds is having a somewhat unhelpful impact on the quality of academic life experiences. Phipps’ work, although located in a deconstruction of sounds, in many ways refers to the impact of noise on learning spaces. However, it is important to note at the outset that how we saw these concepts and the way we experienced them were both similar and different for both of us. Maggi had not expected so much liminality so soon. Christine had expected it – and was indeed looking out for it – but it came from unanticipated sources. Whilst this might seem negative, for us it was actually an exciting learning space and our sense of being in control of our learning destiny seemed to be out of focus most of the time. Positioning of Self The notion of what presence and embodiment mean in digital spaces was something that was constantly problematic for us. The way we seemed to cope in this silent space in the earlier stages of the course was to (super)impose what we ‘knew’ using an identity we felt we ‘had’. We both intuitively felt that this new learning space was distinctively different but it might be that we were imposing difference on it because it was new and unfamiliar, which would seem to be a contestable position, just as is the notion that we are somehow disembodied in cyberspace. Thus, there is an assumption that because we were not ‘seeing’ non-verbal cues such as eye contact and body language, this is making online learning and communication difficult. However, it might be the case that new and diverse forms of communication are emerging that are creating new textual and identity formations, not previously located or understood, as Christine reflected: But I don’t want to make the separation between the worlds as strongly as yesterday’s blog suggests. I always get annoyed when people contrast university with the ‘real’ world: though I suppose that does fit with students saying it feels like another planet. (I do think that these are two different issues though.) Some of the current discussions and next week’s reading are making some 32
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
very interesting points about what’s visible and available and the relationships between online and embodied identities. Yesterday I wrote in my journal, ‘I’m not convinced that the embodied identity can be ditched so easily’ and left myself an instruction to think about this. Sometimes not having a physical presence can be convenient. Maggi found that she welcomed the opportunity to decide where she should ‘be’. She had decided not to participate in the discussion thread but go off and explore Second Life in advance: I…wonder if it matters that I haven’t joined my group. Part of me feels it does matter but I have enjoyed ‘not’ being there which has given me a chance to reflect and play with some other things. For example, I have an avatar in Second Life and I managed to change my clothes and hair today. I feel as if I am really enjoying the experimental side of all this and feel very clueless but sort of more confident in my clueless-ness. At this stage, then, working with Second Wind seemed more comfortable for Maggi than the group discussions in WebCT. The idea of having a digital identity emerged predominantly from the notion of a mind-body split and the overarching sense when operating in cyberspace that there is a feeling of disembodiment and of not being present, a sense of being present and yet not being there but this was a notion to which neither of us subscribed. Yet our embodiment still appeared to be troubling because it prompted us to consider the nature of our identities in cyberspace and whether they were the same or different from our other identities. (Christine): Embodied people can’t lurk – they have presence. However, it occurred to me afterwards that there may well be disembodied lurkers in SL, as we show our RL colleagues what is going on on screen. I’ve done this a couple of times. I didn’t do it during our tutorial, but I might have – and now I’m questioning the ethics of this. Yet this in turn introduced concerns about lurking and lingering with questions about the extent to which the notion of lurking came from somewhat arbitrarily imposed boundaries. Imposed Boundaries Although we had both been engaged in digital spaces for some years we still felt we were new to them and thus felt we did not have a sense of how to be in these spaces. The result was that our face-to-face stances imposed pre-existing structures to online settings. However, in undertaking a module on digital game-based learning we both felt launched into liminal spaces as we felt that the games were positioning ‘us’ rather than be able to position ourselves in relation to the game, as Christine reflected: I have noticed two things that give me cause for concern: 1) I am positioned as having no choice but to engage in violence. I am unable to continue with the game if I do not. Carrying this message into real life is disturbing for a pacifist. 33
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
2) When my soldiers get killed, it is more ‘costly’ if they have good weapons as I have to replace them. Thus the more lightly armed soldiers’ life has less value. When I first noticed the second point, I said to myself: ‘But it’s just a game; I wouldn’t take that stance in real life.’ But the game seems to have exposed a side of me that has taken that stance and I don’t like it. Maggi’s journal shows similar deep concerns about violence in computer games and this was a strong theme from many of our fellow students too. Perhaps it is because as a society or even as an academic community we have become so focussed on signs, and because signs seem to change so fast, organising principles that once seemed stable are constantly shifting. Thus the ability to ‘take a position’ is not just shaped by our personal and pedagogical stances but also by the late modern focus on signs. Thus our position, even our ability to ‘take up’ a position, is located by the game, by our reaction to the game as well as the impact of our life world on/with the game. It seems to us then that positioning is probably more important than the game itself but it is only through understanding the subtext of our position through the game that we come to understand our responses and reaction to our selves. Thinking about games in new ways proved uncomfortable for us both and suggested some liminal spaces – but with the possibility of release through discussions with each other and with the tutor, as recorded by Maggi: After some very interesting email conversation with [the tutor] I have been challenged to think through a number of issues to do with games, but what is also interesting is firstly that I feel I am now on the cusp of my disjunction and things are on the move, and secondly that everywhere I look I now see games… Such discomfort introduced concerns about new pedagogies (as we saw them) and emergent power relations. Power and Pedagogy There seems to be relatively little understanding of how digital spaces are constituted, how they might be mapped, how they might be used differently, and the impact that such spaces are having on the nature of higher education. For example, the provision of information for students, the structuring of learning, the development of websites and learning materials, and the changing in patterns of communication are some of the noticeable but probably smaller impacts that digital spaces are having on the higher education experience for staff and students. Yet Christine wondered about the extent of the commitment of many university staff: My main point is that unless people have themselves experienced the presentation of self through blogs, portfolios and WebCT, they are not really in a position to make judgements about how other people do it. And then I have a question: is it the presentation of the self that we are judging or the actions and artefacts that tell us that this person is someone who can participate in a particular activity? And can these be separated? 34
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
One of Maggi’s blogs on the same topic (e-portfolios) takes the arguments a bit further. After reflecting that the issues involved are not that different from other types of portfolio, she concludes: Surely too the extent to which one allows the database to order and privilege for oneself is a matter of choice, creativity and structure, and choice of tool. There are also arguments by McAlpine [2005] that the e-portfolio becomes a virtual identity – yet it is not clear how this is different (or the same) as the identities that we present in discussion board and blogs. Ordering proved to be a source of discomfort for both of us. Ordering A subtext of control is evident in many VLEs, not only through semiotics, symbols and terminology, but also in the way learning is ordered in ways that suggest how teaching and learning should be. Whilst for many people these images of scaffolding, structure and safety suggest stability and control, for us there were times when the ordering brought into question our perspectives as both teachers and students; for example Christine reflected in her blog: The course is making me question some of my assumptions about my own practices, particularly in relation to written materials. There are some issues of control and boundaries here that are surprising me. Two specific triggers should perhaps be recorded: 1) the increased opportunities for collaboration afforded by technology 2) the role of technology in liberating or constraining what a student might do. All this is making me think that there might be another side to Gee’s [2003] ‘rules’ - perhaps an analysis that’s more from the student perspective: ‘what video games have to teach us about how we can get on at university’. Ordering strategies in VLE systems encouraged us as students not only to manage knowledge but also to manage our discussions and possibly sometimes to think and learn in linear ways. Thus, the way in which technology is employed in many universities is resulting in the sense of an institutional panopticon, where visibility and calculability are not seen as problematic. As Land has argued: The Web, for example, remains unruly, risky and troublesome, an implacable aspect of the supercomplexity and intractability of the post-modern condition. An intriguing irony is that though current commercial virtual learning environments (themselves global corporations) might be seen as spaces that dis-place older collegial spaces, symbolised by the quadrangle, they nonetheless still attempt to wall in their own ‘onscreen real estate’, to fend off, perhaps, the post-modern wildness of the Web. In this respect they function as an ordering strategy (Land and Bayne, 2006). Like many modernist practices and spaces, they are singularly rectangular. (Land 2006, p.108) Perhaps VLEs and other manifestations of the Web preserve some of the stereotypical or established teacher and learner roles. As both learners and teachers, we did, of course, have some observations to make on these roles. 35
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
Teacher and Learner Identity The way in which we portrayed and projected ourselves in digital spaces seemed very much to reflect our pedagogical stances, the way we see ourselves as learners, and teachers. Thus, the complexity of being a learner (and teacher) in a variety of digital spaces constantly challenged us to question what it meant to ‘be’ a learner in these kinds of spaces, not only in terms of portrayal and presentation, but also in relation to pedagogy and action. For example, while there has been much discussion about presence and forms of presence in the literature on digital learning there has been relatively little exploration of the impact of diverse forms of digital presence on pedagogy (see for example, Feenburg, 1989; Bayne, 2005, 2008; Land, 2006). Maggi summarised some of these issues succinctly in her blog after an early meeting we had to discuss this chapter: Yet, as Christine suggested, maybe our constant contestation was problematic to others and I also wondered whether my strong pedagogical stance might be intimidating at times to others. The use of the blog to expand on pedagogical issues was invaluable to Maggi. Later she said: I think due to so much going on I have struggled with the reading but really got fed up with the Dreyfus [2001] article. I think this is because of the way I see learning as approach and deeply connected to our multiple and changing identities and much of this and the other articles for the last 2 weeks seemed over simplistic…I avoided going on the discussion list about it all because I felt I might get too inflammatory… so here is really what I think… Although Maggi the student was fed up with the reading, Maggi the university teacher was prompted by the issues to keep writing for another page or so beyond this. These examples illustrate how pedagogy in digital spaces is continually changing and both this and the pedagogy of digital spaces are mutually shaping and changing each other. We both found exchanges with tutors on the two modules considered here particularly helpful, to move us on as students and also to take forward the implications to our own teaching. The interplay of student and teacher personas was both discussed and practised during the course. It might be argued then that the pedagogical discourse emerged at the boundaries of these. One of the tutors reflected: Teaching on this course involves engaging at the same time in multiple written conversations across multiple media - in a morning’s work I can be commenting on 15 weblogs (each of which are ‘voiced’ very differently), responding to a handful of discussion threads, talking synchronously in groups in Second Life, and also responding to individual emails both in WebCT and in my usual email client. Personally I love working in this way but it strikes me that the opportunities for the linguistic performance of ‘teacherliness’ are so complex here, that we’ve barely even begun really to explore what this complexity might mean for the ways in which power operates in the classroom, or for the ways in which academic developers might need to work with teachers in helping 36
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
them work with digital teaching spaces. I confess I’m still a little haunted by the chat session I had earlier in the semester, where - it emerged afterwards - the students couldn’t see my postings, and I didn’t even realise. What does that say about the operations of power in the online class, when the teacher can be quite literally invisible, yet can be continuing to teach without ever realising? However, there are further difficulties with the language of online learning. The notion of ‘moderating’ clearly locates the control with the lecturers. The notion of ‘lurking’ implies that silence and watching are inherently bad, while at the same time raising questions about what counts as presence in digital spaces – and who decides. However, these concerns about silence and stuckness enabled us to locate some of the catalysts to stuck places. CATALYSTS TO STUCK PLACES
We found becoming stuck in learning was both deeply problematic, useful and transformative. This is echoed in the similarities in our experience and also in the differences in our responses. However there were trends we shared and in particular we both felt that the stuckness did not necessarily always result in the displacement of identity (in the sense of a shift causing such a sense of disjunction that it resulted in costs personally and pedagogically, and hence has a life cost) but rather a shift in identity or role perception so that issues and concerns were seen and heard in new and different ways. The catalysts we experience included: Technical Difficulties and Understandings For both of us, despite being used to using a VLE, we found that the volume of links, information, reading and in particular the speed of communication and learning made us feel awash with complexity. While we enjoyed the stimulation, there were times when we fell silent because of feeling overwhelmed and almost voiceless in the discussion spaces. Pedagogical Concerns Our pedagogical concerns stemmed from not only our interest in how knowledge was created in and through the course but also around what might constitute the underlying pedagogy of the course. It seemed to be a course that was largely behaviourally constructed but was actually constructively positioned. For example we had learning objectives and a very traditional course guide with readings and the prerequisite guidance about plagiarism, but when ‘on ‘ and ‘in’ the course it was much less constrained or striated (Deleuze and Guattari, 1988) than we anticipated. There was also a sense of egalitarianism and reciprocity not only within the cohort, but also with tutors, who seemed to be learners too. Understanding the Conventions of the Media Used We were both familiar with some conventions of the e-learning environment though would not necessarily adopt them (Christine commented that she would not know 37
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
what she meant if she used a ‘smiley’). Others were very new conventions, though adaptations of the familiar – for example, behaviour in Second Life such as turntaking in conversations, bumping into people and how to respond to strangers’ suggestions. Finally, there were the norms and in-jokes of a developing group (Cutting, 2000) – made more difficult as some people’s references came from technical sources unknown to us and others came from a range of theoretical perspectives. For example, while we understood the references to ‘deep’ approaches to learning, some others were bemused (and amused) by them – though others could refer to technical processes and perspectives that were alien to us (and which we have now forgotten). Feeling Out of Control There were more fascinating leads to follow up than there was time available – an inevitable outcome of such a widely experienced group of staff and students. Feelings of being out of control would arise when we were not able to access the site for a while or could not keep up with tasks because of work and other commitments. In such circumstances, we found we had to regain control by focusing on essential tasks, such as blogging and completing assignments. Both of us found that we had far more to say than the allotted word count for our assignments: a ‘normal’ case of feeling out of control but taking steps to restore the balance. LURKING ON THRESHOLDS
The final theme is that of lurking on thresholds in the sense that the betwixt and between-ness of such lurking emerged from a number of behaviours and actions we adopted. The notion of a ‘threshold concept,’ (Meyer and Land, 2003) captures the idea of a portal that opens up a way of thinking that was previously inaccessible. This conceptualisation seems to resonate with the experiences that are emerging from the blogs. However, what is problematic, but also vital, about the notion of a threshold concept is that preliminal variation exists. Meyer and Land (2005) begin by suggesting that when students find particular concepts difficult they are in a state of liminality which tends to be characterised by a stripping away of old identities, an oscillation between states and personal transformation. For us, some of the thresholds themselves were entrances to places where we did not want to go – and some were entrancing places where we wanted to escape the more mundane tasks. The themes here illustrate this sense of lurking at entrances and being entranced. Avoiding Engagement Both of us are sufficiently experienced to ensure that we have done what we had to as students to get through the course, but there were aspects that we avoided. It has already been suggested that neither of us wanted to engage with the e-portfolio, but the reasons for that resistance were familiar to us from other personal development planning issues. (Resistance to PDP does, however, raise some interesting questions in relation to the fact that we are both quite keen bloggers.) 38
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
Again, we have already pointed out that neither of us wanted to engage with violent games, and this has brought out additional issues. Maggi reports not just having problems engaging with the games but also with the literature on games. The following extract throws an intriguing light on the use of the word ‘game’ – both in the unfamiliar and the familiar pedagogical contexts. I have had so many frustrating attempts on Pacman and other games I have decided to try something else.… However, I have decided that I am not getting to grips with a lot of this not just cos I don’t like the games but I don’t understand not only people’s fascination for them but also the literature. So I have done some searching and found some likely looking journal articles – that will at least make the researcher identity a little happier. However, I realised today that I also need to think about games differently, something [the tutor] indicated in the introduction to the module. For example, Perkins [1999] discusses the notion of ‘underlying games’ and epistemic games. In the process of avoiding engagement, we then might find our way back to more familiar territory and discourses. Yet there were others where we just found things too difficult. Sometimes moving on from one of the above positions would not take us far enough to have a voice in what the students in front were doing: for example, only getting on top of how to contribute to the wiki when all the excellent contributions were already there. Christine Sinclair also felt several steps behind in Second Life: avoiding the bigger tasks such as building, buying and selling and therefore being ‘invisible’ at some stages of the course, though her avatar Christine Sanders was actually pottering around in the shallows somewhere in Second Life and getting used to this new environment. However, there were other areas where we found ourselves doing the opposite. Over Engaging The idea of over engaging was that we became over keen and over involved in some areas of the course to the detriment of others (something we both find our students do). Second Life is probably the space that prompts the most different responses from us, and illustrate this theme best. Maggi’s preference for Second Life over some of the other more controlled spaces led her to wonder whether she was over-engaging: Yet what struck me was the juxtaposition of real life (RL) and Second Life (SL) and the extent to which one feels more ‘real’ in SL than in the online discussions – which I certainly seem to… I went back into SL this morning, flew, took my clothes off, and found the ski resort. I think I am getting addicted. However, maybe it can be used pedagogically to teach students to ask questions, good questions, since this is something we are not great at helping students to learn. Not sure how I could do this but would be worth more thought I think… As with avoiding engagement, thoughts about over-engagement are associated with a return to familiar ground and wondering how that can be integrated with the new ideas. 39
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL
RETURNING TO THE LITERATURE
It has been interesting to relate all of the above to what we are reading both as learners and as academics, especially work on liminality, thresholds and identity (Meyer and Land, 2003; Waskul, 2005). Such catalysts have promoted shifts into liminal states resulting in liminal identities, which for most of the course have resulted in ‘chronic uncertainty’ about our selves and our relationships to the new environment. The state of liminality tends to be characterised by a stripping away of old identities, an oscillation between states and personal transformation. Liminal spaces are thus suspended states and serve as a transformative function, as someone moves from one state or position to another. Engaging with liminal spaces may involve choice but in the case of troublesome spaces they are often more likely to be ‘stuck places’ (Ellsworth, 1997). Yet this conception of stuck places would seem to imply that stuckness is a place one travels to – whereas being stuck or disjunction is often a position one seems to find oneself in, often somewhat unexpectedly. There is little (if any) preparation and it may be because of this that disjunction is where people are before they reach a liminal space, prompted by a threshold concept or a new learning experience. Thus for us, having overcome the shock of the disjunction we find ourselves re-examining our position. Chronic uncertainty and liminal states should not necessarily be taken to be negative descriptions of where we are: the chapter identifies an associated excitement and stimulation prompted by these conditions. IMPLICATIONS
A number of implications emerge from the above findings. Each of us has been able to move on through our silent spaces to find ways of expressing ourselves as fledgling ‘e-learners’ and to integrate this new identity with our identities as teachers. Though we have still a long way to go, we have passed through some portals, perhaps never to return. A graphic example of this can be seen in our avatars: Christine Sanders and, especially, Second Wind have performed actions in Second Life that have led to their real life counterparts rethinking some of the things they do in their day-today practice in universities. Though we cannot return to our former neophyte state, we do have a wealth of information about the journey towards and through those portals. This helps us to prepare for the next ones. We know that when we are stuck it is likely that we will lurk around the threshold – either by avoidance or over-engagement in related activity – and will only pass through when we are ready. We believe that this may be a necessary phase; nevertheless, it may still be useful to seek ways to ensure that this phase is reached and satisfactorily transcended. CONCLUSIONS
This chapter has proved to be an interesting collaboration for a variety of reasons. We found it both reassuring and illuminating to read each others’ blogs about the same activity. Our experiences were liminal – arguably by definition because we were
40
LURKING ON THE THRESHOLD
serious learners – but the boundaries, edges and thresholds we encountered were sometimes similar and sometimes different, as were our responses to them. When we got stuck, we reacted to the silence in two distinctive ways – by avoiding or over-engaging. We regard both avoidance and over-engagement as manifestations of ‘lurking’. This is perhaps an extended definition, emphasising the ‘prowling’ aspect of lurking as well the ‘not responding’ aspect. As university teachers, we now have some increased insights into student responses that may be relevant not just for online liminality but also for dealing with stuckness in general. As researchers, we have some more questions about what our stories are revealing and how they are revealing them. POSTCRIPT
Since we wrote this paper both of have continued on the MSc. We thought about changing the chapter to reflect the new spaces we find ourselves lurking in, but we chose not to. Both of us feel the edgy rawness reflects our position of being new students on a new course. However, since that time Maggi has moved into developing PBL in SL and gained funding to research the socio-political impact of learning in Immersive Virtual Worlds. Her avatar remains a strong part of her identity as both student and teacher. Christine identifies much less with her avatar, and would be more comfortable in seeing her as a separate character in a digital story. She wants to do something creative online – perhaps involving digital writing – rather than just snipe from the edges when she’s stuck. Stuckness remains part of learning for both of us – so much so that Maggi nearly gave up on one module completely. But stuckness seems to grow in various forms though there is still a sense of moving forward in the silence. A fellow student has stimulated some further thoughts about silent spaces by asking: “How do you analyse ignoring?” This has extended our ideas about shared perspectives on the same situation: who determines whether someone is lurking, lingering or ignoring? Our reflexive ideas on our early experiences have reinforced our belief in the importance of sharing what we notice and value about what counts as learning, quality and assessment – and whose voice is privileged most in the silent spaces of online learning. NOTES 1
There are four names on this chapter: two of them belong to our ‘Second Life’ avatars. On occasion, these characters appear to be sources of observations that we might not have made ourselves.
REFERENCES Bayne, S. (2005). Deceit, desire and control: The identities of learners and teachers in cyberspace. In R. Land & S. Bayne (Eds.), Education in cyberspace. London: Routledge. Bayne, S (2008). Higher education as a visual practice: seeing through the virtual learning environment Teaching in Higher Education, Vol. 13(4), pp. 395-410. Cutting, J. (2000). Analysing the language of discourse communities. Oxford: Elsevier Science Ltd.
41
SAVIN-BADEN ET AL Deleuze, G., & Guattari, F. (1988). A thousand plateaus: Capitalism and schizophrenia. London: Continuum. Dreyfus, H. (2001). On the Internet. London: Routledge. Feenberg, A. (1989). The written world: On the theory and practice of computer conferencing. In R. Mason & A. Kaye (Eds.), Mindweave: Communication, computers and distance education. Elmsford, NY: Pergamon Press. Gee, J. (2003). What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy. Basingstoke: Palgrave MacMillan. Geertz, C. (1973). The interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books. Land, R. (2006). Paradigms lost: Academic practice and exteriorising technologies. E-Learning, 3(1), 100–110. McAlpine, M. (2005). E-portfolios and digital identity. E-Learning, 2(4), 378–387. Meyer, J., & Land, R. (2003). Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge: Linkages to ways of thinking and practising within the disciplines. C. Rust (Ed.), Improving student learning – Ten years on. Oxford: OCSLD. Meyer, J. H. F., & Land, R. (2005, April). Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge (2): Epistemological considerations and a conceptual framework for teaching and learning. Higher Education, 49(3), 373–388 (16). Perkins, D. (1999). The many faces of constructivism. Educational Leadership, 57(3), 6–11. Phipps, A. (2005). The sound of higher education. Accompanying text of the closing keynote lecture given at the annual conference of the Society for Research into Higher Education, 15th December 2005, at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland. Ryle, G. (1968). The thinking of thoughts: What is “Le Penseur” doing? University Lectures No. 18, the University of Saskatchewan. Waskul, D. (2005). Ekstasis and the Internet: Liminality and computer-mediated communication. New Media & Society, 7(1), 47–63.
Maggi Savin-Baden Coventry University, UK Christine Sinclair University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK
42
TRANSFORMATIONS
COLLEEN MCKENNA AND CLAIRE MCAVINIA
4. DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY – MAKING MEANING THROUGH HYPERTEXTS
INTRODUCTION
Digital writing is a practice with which university students engage regularly. Increasingly, students communicate with each other and their lecturers using email, message boards and online posts, among other forms. Unsurprisingly, the research into writing in digital contexts has focused on these types of texts, and although such writing departs in its production from more conventional ‘essayistic’ writing (Lillis 2001), it is still broadly linear in terms of the expression and organisation of knowledge. Indeed, as Goodfellow and Lea (2007) have persuasively argued, there is much similarity between this type of writing and other, non-digital, genres with which students engage: many digital texts occupy new ‘sites’ of writing production but they do not represent fundamentally different writing practices. However, a more radical but underused genre in higher education is hypertext writing. That is not to say that hypertext has not been theorized: a great deal has been written about hypertext fiction, blogging, and, to a lesser degree, professional, published, academic writing (Landow 1994, Kolb 1994, 2008; Bolter 2001 and Ingraham 2000). Nonetheless, relatively little research exists about how student writers are experimenting with academic hypertext or where such work might feature in curricula. This chapter considers how hypertext assignments might disrupt conventional academic narratives and offer new opportunities for expression by enabling the interplay between text, image and sound, among other modes. By analysing two student assignments, we will argue that hypertext poses a challenge to conventional essay writing by knowingly disrupting linear organisation and privileging the gaps that such an approach affords. In the place of standard argumentation, new organisational techniques are adopted which rely on screen design, visual motifs and juxtaposition through linking. We also suggest that in order to subvert the ‘argumentative line’ (which as Kolb, 1994, reminds us is itself a problematic context, and to some extent, an illusion), students must be alert to what it is they are undermining. So, the act of engaging with hypertext may enable writers to think more fully about rhetorical features of academic writing generally. We also have some evidence to suggest that writers of hypertext reconceptualise the relationship between writer and audience. We also explore how this new form might liberate the thinking of student writers as they work outside of established, and probably internalised, essayistic paradigms.
R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 45–60. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
For this paper, we are drawing on the work of students in two iterations of the course Communicating in a Digital Age: Issues in Electronic Literacy that we taught at UCL. The course involved about 12 students and we will refer to their coursework, self-commentaries and interviews conducted by the authors. We will briefly consider theoretical approaches to hypertext and essay writing followed by an account of the course, as well as a consideration of technical fluency. Then we will analyse the students’ work and we’ll consider ways in which they playfully subvert more conventional approaches, re-presenting academic argument in new spaces which combine text, image and sound. WRITING IN HYPERTEXT: THEORETICAL APPROACHES
Research into hypertext writing has largely concerned non-academic texts (fiction, poetry or reflective writing) with less attention devoted to potential shifts in the way academic knowledge is represented in digital spaces. Despite the capacity of technology to afford new shapes of writing, little has changed in the world of academic publishing: even when made available online, academic research continues to be published in standard, linear formats (Bolter 2001, Ingraham 2000). Additionally, as Kolb 2008, observes, despite the proliferation of argumentative hypertexts on the internet, the writing seems to generally lack complexity, in terms of linking and distribution. Therefore, as Ingraham has suggested, the potential for digital writing to compel us to reconsider ‘the ways in which scholarly argument is constructed’ and how we might value multimedia within scholarly discourse has largely gone unrealised. One possible reason for this apparent lack of interest in academic hypertexts might be the perceived inappropriateness of non-linear, unbounded, multimodal formats for expressing academic knowledge. However, in ‘Socrates and the labyrinth’, Kolb, who both analyses and publishes academic hypertexts, suggests that hypertext writing affords a different type of meaning making, one which privileges exploration over conclusion. Kolb argues that distributed, non-linear claims making; multiple pathways and voices; spaces and disruptions; and the juxtaposition of ideas offer alternative ways of knowing: ‘A text can still make a claim on you even if it does not support a particular proposition or present a particular abstract structure of argument’ (Kolb 1994, p.340.) Similarly, in his ‘Sprawling Places’ project, in which he wrote both a book and a hypertext on the same topic, he compares the media and suggests that with the latter, readers ‘see the argument coming into focus gradually as a whole’ rather than being guided through it step by step (Kolb, 2004). That said, in his most recent work he observes that there are still relatively few examples of elaborate, expository hypertexts and he asks whether the ‘ideal of complex hypertext rhetorical structures’ was ‘mistaken’ (Kolb 2008). Towards the end of his 2008 lecture, Kolb suggests that increased hybridity of text types and multimodality might attract academic writers and this idea resonates with our experience. For our student writers, the disruption of the textual line was accompanied by new possibilities for organisation and expression enabled by the inclusion of new modes accompanied by the movement from page to screen. Gunther 46
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
Kress and colleagues have written powerfully about the visual grammar of the screen and ways in which this offers an alternative approach to meaning making with the ‘logic of the image dominat[ing] the semiotic organisation of the screen’ (Kress, 2003). Kress distinguishes between the organisation of writing – largely sequentially and ‘temporally governed’ – and the organisation of the screen, ‘governed by the logic of space, and by the logic of simultaneity of its visual/depicted elements’ (Kress, 2003). However, the inclusion of modes such as sound and animation reintroduce a temporality to the screen and offer additional opportunities for disruption and juxtaposition, as we will show below with case study 2. One question that we are trying to understand is what does multimodality mean for academic writing and how might it challenge more conventional notions of argumentation for these students. What Might Hypertext be Challenging? As suggested above, there appears to be relatively little research on students’ academic writing in hypertext, and where students’ writing is mentioned in a wider discussion of hypertext publication, this is often with reference to potential future work (Burbules, 1998). Other case studies of students’ hypertext writing have focused on fictional narrative or on writing at secondary level rather than in a higher education context (Russell 1998, Dickson 2002). Writers in this area tend to focus on hypertext as an alternative to conventional writing, rather than as any kind of challenge to it (Carter 2003, Brooks 2002). Our thinking about disruption and discontinuity in student writing is informed by the academic literacies approach which problematises the dominance of certain conventions and genres, interrogates the way in which certain forms are seen to be naturalised, explores the impact of power relationships in student writing, and considers student writing in relation to issues of institutional regulation (Lillis 2001, Ivanic 1998, Lea and Street 1998). The academic literacies framework has been useful in helping us think about what hypertexts might be ‘challenging’ in terms of student writing in higher education and reminds us that the concepts ‘essay’ and ‘argument’ are themselves problematic. That is, although we’re positioning the work of our students against some notion of conventional writing, clearly the academic essay is not an agreed genre or text type that is static across all disciplines (Lillis 2001). Indeed, research by Lea and Street (1998) and Lillis and Turner (2001) has foregrounded the lack of agreement on the terminology of the academic essay. Nonetheless, there’s a general use of the term ‘essayistic’ which refers to academic writing that is broadly ‘linear’, that contains an argument and is characterised by certain shapes – usually an introduction, main body and conclusion. So, while we do not want to offer an essentialist account of academic writing and while we recognise there are other genres in use in higher education, we still feel able to speak about ‘essays’ in the belief that there is a broad, shared understanding of what we mean. As Lillis (2001) suggests,’ “essay” is really institutionalised shorthand for a particular way of constructing knowledge which has come to be privileged within the academy.’ 47
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
THE COURSE
The Communicating in a Digital Age course addressed theoretical and practical issues associated with writing in online contexts. Seminar topics included the history of online communication; the dynamics of electronic communities; hypertext theory; issues of identity in online writing; power and surveillance in digital spaces; audience and electronic publishing. Students were reasonably well-versed in hypertext theory. The course was taught over a ten week period, in which students had two hours weekly in a seminar setting, and one hour per week in a ‘lab’ session, which took place in a computer room. The lab sessions were designed to support students’ development of their hypertext documents, through a combination of teaching writing in HTML, and providing time to work on the hypertext projects with advice and supervision. The assessed components of the course were a hypertext document, an essay, and a portfolio of short writing. The hypertext document (deliberately not called an essay) had to be multimodal (combining at least text and image), and roughly 1,500 – 3,000 words in length. The hypertexts had to contain links to external sources and comprise at least 15 pages/images. Some attempt to develop academic argumentation in hypertext was required along with an analytical/critical approach to the topic and the work was expected to be appropriately referenced. Although the theoretical and discursive aspects of the course were taught separately from the technical elements in seminars, the lab sessions were deliberately planned to encourage students away from thinking they were receiving neutral inputs to ‘train’ them in the use of a particular technology. Instead, in the planning stages we identified ways in which the computer room sessions would draw on the discussions of the seminars and lead from those discussions into the students’ development of their hypertext assignments. Learning to Write in Hypertext: Technical Competency as Fluency? During the technical sessions, it became clear that some students had more ambitious plans than others for their hypertext documents, and these students worked hard to acquire the technical competency to realise these projects. This is not to suggest that particular technologies ‘led’ their work, but rather that many students invested additional effort to achieve a ‘fluency’, the competency they wished to have, in the medium. We noted that two students who were already competent writers of blogs did not produce hypertexts as rich as those of students who had no previous experience in writing for the web. Although we discuss here a small number of examples of students’ work, nonetheless we ask whether technical competency is a necessary pre-requisite for fluent writing in the online environment – the question of competency influences the extent to which a person can communicate, and the sophistication of his/her communication. Further, we ask whether the current emphasis on the use of so-called ‘Web 2.0’ technologies in higher education might unwittingly take away opportunities for students to learn to write in more sophisticated ways online. Spaces for self-publishing, while extremely popular in non-academic contexts, usually offer prescriptive 48
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
interfaces rather than blank canvasses in which an author can truly experiment. Of course, much good learning and reflection can take place in a blog, and in nonacademic contexts social networking has grown exponentially in popularity since the inception of the course we discuss here. However, we argue that these technologies have functions separate to the purpose of working with students to communicate their ideas through arguments in hypertext, particularly in the sense that Kolb means it. As Kolb (2008) points out, blogs may well reinforce a model of linearity, pointing outwards to other texts but not themselves breaking the narrative line. We suggest that what might now be called a more ‘traditional’ approach to writing in hypertext offered two possibilities that would be difficult to replace with the web publishing spaces currently so popular amongst many students. The first is that learning to storyboard and design a webpage from the blank screen means that the student is liberated from the structure of ready-made interfaces and design templates. The second is that there is no assumption that certain kinds of media or tools will be needed since these are not automatically on offer. If you think your site should include a discussion forum, you have to decide where it fits with your hypertext, then find one, and build it in. While not wishing to draw conclusions about how students may now be using the newer technologies now available to them, we are asking whether the Web 2.0 tools are as flexible as is often suggested. We will return to some of these questions later. We turn now to two examples of the students’ work and examine their hypertexts in closer detail.
Figure 1. The homepage of Manchi’s project.
49
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
Figure 2. Manchi’s discussion of current VR research.
Figure 3. Manchi’s discussion of avatars. 50
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
Figure 4. Manchi examines The VR Paradigm. DESCRIPTIONS OF TWO STUDENTS’ WORK
Manchi’s Project Manchi describes her project as a ‘discursive tour of virtual reality’. (Figures 1–4 above). She considers existing virtual reality technologies and outlines the possibilities they offer. Links are made to literature and popular culture in which virtual reality is a central theme, but the project also foretells the popularity of Second Life with its link to there.com. The design of this project is image-driven rather than text-driven, and in fact Manchi used image editing software to create all of the image maps forming the pages of the hypertext. A bubble design motif is used throughout this project to organize pieces of text, major sections, links and secondary references. Its listing of references and sources for the project as a series of differently sized text bubbles makes an interesting parallel with social bookmarking sites and ‘semantic clouds’, which were not in widespread use at the time this project was created. However, in contrast to the technologies that followed, this hypertext offers Manchi control over how the information is (un)organised and the variety of paths a reader may take to find it. Using images as the main medium of this project allowed Manchi to control absolutely the look of the project on the page: while other students struggled to organise their pages and to keep a consistent design across different platforms and browsers, for Manchi these technical issues were resolved by fixing the design in this way. 51
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
Shujon’s Project A Brief History of MUDs examines the development of Multi-User Domains through an essay in the form of a MUD (Figures 5–7 below). The hypertext is organised around the idea of a mansion as MUD, and the rooms of the mansion each house a different theme of the discussion. The map of the mansion indicates the organization of the hypertext. The Hallway provides a history of MUDs, the Lounge Bar recounts visits to a number of MUDS. A room designated only with a query symbol ‘?’ presents a view of the psychology of MUDs. The Dining Hall page talks about relationships between MUDs, while the Ballroom categorises different kinds of MUDs, for example combative versus social. The Balcony, fittingly, presents a view of the future development of MUDs, and (perhaps most strikingly) the Teleporter is used for references and links. Technically, this proved to be very ambitious project for the student author. In order to realise it fully, he wished to use a real MUD or similar environment, but this was not possible without access to server space and assistance from a technical administrator. Instead, he sought ways to exploit fully the potential of simple interlinked webpages in order to convey the structure and ‘feel’ of a MUD. He invested extensive time and effort into the image and audio-visual effects included in the site, and the result is a carefully structured hypertext drawing heavily on the design characteristics of MUD environments and gaming. In this case, the design the student wished to use was closely interlinked with the topic of the essay. In both projects, design is critical to the overall effect: in other words, it is difficult to imagine either of these hypertexts as a conventional essay, so closely are they related to the visual design motifs the students have chosen.
Figure 5. The lounge area of Shujon’s MUD hypertext. 52
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
Figure 6. Shujon discusses different types of MUD.
Figure 7. The Teleport Room of Shujon’s MUD hypertext. 53
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
SUBVERSIVE PLAY: METAPHOR, HUMOUR AND GENRE SWITCHING
This new genre allowed students to experiment with rhetorical features of academic writing. In more conventional essay writing, characteristics such as consistency of voice, argumentative line and tone are assumed and even internalised by student writers. As suggested in the previous section, the hypertext assignments offered an uncharted space in which the student writers were able to experiment with alternative rhetorical techniques. Two that we’ll explore here are organisation and genre switching. In terms of the former, the multimodal nature of the hypertexts meant that metaphor – both in terms of the organisation of entire sites and key elements of the assignments – was privileged. For example, one student, who created a hypertext essay on the solar system positioned the reader as a space traveller who journeyed to different areas of the site. As described above, Manchi wrote about virtual reality using a spatial metaphor, the bubble design motif, as an organising theme. For Manchi, this motif signalled difference; in her words, this approach was ‘not conventional’: ‘In an essay, it’s all square. And I had the text floating in these bubbles … there was [an] Escher piece that it was inspired by.’ The bubble motif functioned at two levels. Firstly, the images on the opening screen (Figure 1), in which smaller ‘bubbles’ containing themes were positioned around a larger circle containing introductory thoughts on the topic of virtual reality. (The bubbles are almost like satellites orbiting a planet; an interpretation encouraged by the background image of a galaxy.) The images of this opening screen were highly appropriate to the circular organisation of the site and they signalled from the outset a nonlinear approach to the assignment, about which we’ll say more below. Secondly, the circular motif provided a primary mode of organisation on each screen. So, nearly all communication (analytical text, image, rhetorical questions, fictional text, cartoon, web links) was bounded by circles on the page and this constructed a creative and potentially disruptive tension. On the one hand, these ‘bubbles’ gave the different modes and discourses a sort of equivalence to each other. (Although, the essayistic discourse was generally located in a larger bubble to the rest, thus it had a certain prominence. See Figure 3, for example.) On the other hand, the space between the items was foregrounded and the student writer imagined that the reader would have to – ‘jump… from one sphere of text to another’. Additionally, the bounding of these items (text, questions, images etc.) allows them to be positioned in different places on the screen on different pages. So, while the look of each page is familiar, the positioning of the items is changeable. Both the necessity of ‘jumping’ and the unpredictability of this use of space disrupt the reading process: conventional features, such as the movement from left to right or the salience of top and bottom, cannot be assumed. As described above, Shujon’s hypertext assignment uses a MUD mansion floorplan as a visual and thematic organising device, with each section accorded a room, as shown in Figures 5 and 6. Additionally, the text, notably the introduction, intermittently imitates the faux-gothic language of MUDs and shifts among a range of discourses (including academic, reflective and fictional genres) as well as adopting different subject positions, with shifts between first, second and third person expression frequently occurring on the same page. Furthermore, the site incorporates 54
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
sub-motifs – drawing on tropes from Star Wars and Star Trek. From the latter comes one of the most striking metaphorical elements of the assignment - the teleporter page (Figure 7) which replaces the traditional references section; buttons on the console form links to sites referenced elsewhere in the assignment. The use of the teleporter room as an analogue for a bibliography extends the assignment’s link between place and writing to include travel, and Shujon described his decision to construct a teleporter room in highly spatial terms: I was trying to make each room name relevant to the subject that was in it, so for the lounge bar I decided to put stories I had from MUDS in there, as it’s where people relax and tell you their adventures - a bit like tavern tales. When it came to [deciding] what room could [contain] the links, I thought of it being the room that is going to take you elsewhere from the site, and being a trekkie, the teleporter room came to mind. I thought it would also reinforce the idea of the user acknowledging they are leaving the ‘safety’ of this site. The student has re-conceptualised the rhetorical function of the bibliography/ references. Rather than simply an inert list at the end of an essay, the references page is transformed into a portal, offering excitement and perhaps ‘danger’ to the reader, who is re-positioned as a cyber-traveller. As with the previous example, the metaphorical frame, in this case the mansion, offers a (non-linear) structure within which the student writer can be highly experimental and disruptive: … I thought it would be funny to put in some things completely out of the blue, as in the beginning you are told you are in a mansion and it seems scary, then you walk into the lounge and you are in the Star Wars world, thinking am I still in the mansion? I wanted to make it act like a break in between reading pages and keep the user’s attention fresh as it breaks up the text, then allows the user to know this is a new section and they can focus on that. In academic writing, unless I was writing fictional stories, I usually did not use humour... Again, Shujon is knowingly constructing discordant spaces and gaps, and he imagines how a reader might respond to such disruption. Additionally, he seems to be referring to the playful and disruptive qualities of the genre-switching he uses throughout the assignment. Each page begins with a Gothic discourse in 2nd person which imitates the text of a MUD site: You jump as you hear a match being struck, and look to your left as the wall lamp is lit, casting an eerie glow around you. You see you are in the entrance of some kind of mansion, with a door directly in front of you. (opening screen) This discourse style appears at the top of every page, followed by contrasting genres. For example on the page entitled ‘MUD encounters’ (see Figure 5), this Gothic description is followed by a first person account of exploring MUDs as a novice, which is succeeded by a more conventional, 3rd person comparison of two seminal MUDs. The genres are visually distinguished by shifts in font and colour. Additionally, a large photograph is positioned prominently at the top of the page 55
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
and a sound file containing music with a ragtime feel starts playing as soon as the page is loaded. So the page is multimodal and multi-voiced and the reader experiences a charged, creatively chaotic space similar to Bakhtin’s state of heteroglossia, in which heterogeneity and multivocality are celebrated. FREEDOMS/CONTROL/CHALLENGES TO CONVENTIONAL ESSAYISTIC LITERACY
Argumentation One of the main shifts that hypertext affords is the loosening or even loss of the linearity that print-based text privileges. Most of the students viewed a lack of linearity as an opportunity. (One exception was a very confident essay writer who seemed uncomfortable with the thought of departing from the conventional narrative line. He imposed a strong sequential narrative onto his hypertext writing by setting out sections vertically and implying a prescribed reading order.) Nonetheless, the majority of students embraced the shift away from a strictly sequential approach and the move to online writing made them rethink the relationship between each part (screen or ‘page’) and its relationship to the whole (the entire hypertext assignment): I tried to make each page stand-alone yet be connected, so you could just read a page and understand it without having to read the other pages to do so. If you read them all, then you got the whole picture and each page complemented [the] other[s]. (Manchi) For Manchi this new approach to argumentation was more than a rhetorical shift; it shaped the way in which she conceptualised both the resultant text and the writing process. Here she explains the former in terms of spatial dimensions: ‘it wasn’t … a 2-dimensional sort of text – where you’re running through it from introduction to main argument to conclusion … it was trying to be a bit more 3-dimensional in that you could go from one bit of text to another without taking that linear approach.’ She suggested that while she lost an organisation afforded by the ‘traditional linear approach’, that she gained a different kind of cohesion through design by using ‘other markers’ particularly graphical ones: colour, style, repetition of images etc. For her, the writing process really was web-like, and she described her storyboard for the assignment as – ‘a web of ideas that went out from the introduction [which was] the central piece… the ideas were more circular … It wasn’t linear.’ Content and form are closely related and contribute to her sense of the writing process and the organisation of ideas. Additionally, she felt that the ‘argument’ was more implicit than explicit and she commented that she had no formal conclusion. Similarly, most of the hypertext assignments, opened with a well-defined introductory screen and most lacked a conclusion. A student who constructed an assignment on image manipulation, re-thought the rhetorical link between conclusion and argumentation and suggested that ‘argument’ could be achieved independently of ‘closure’. His approach and his assignment embraced Kolb’s notion that academic meaning-making can be about exploring a territory. As Goodfellow and Lea have 56
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
observed, neither the writing nor the reading ends at a fixed point in many of these texts. Another theme that emerged was students’ sense of potential readers being more active (less ‘controllable’) and their increased awareness of how audience influenced the writing process. This imagined online reader is reminiscent of the Bakhtinian superaddressee (McKenna, 2005). Audience is linked to argument because an awareness of it often affected decisions taken about the content of individual pages. As students observed, a writer cannot make assumptions about what a reader has already read in a hypertext environment and this reader ‘input’ had implications for the overall organisation. As one student observed, ‘the reader had a lot more input into it [the design]; maybe because they could choose their own path throughout the text, you had less control over the way it was read. Of course, you put in what you wanted in the actual content – but … the reader had more control.’ So a consideration of audience and an awareness of the shape of the hypertext seem to be linked. This view of hypertext readers and their ‘input’ mirrors Carusi’s sense of the reader as one who ‘co-creates’ the hypertext (2006). The students were, in part, accommodating an imagined reader and, in part, positioning themselves as readers in order to analyse their writing and a strong sense of audience was generally evident. Some students even made direct appeals for feedback from an anticipated, but unknown audience. Lastly, what seemed to appeal especially to students was a shift from a strictly written expression to a multimodal one with image and sound being the modes introduced most frequently followed by animation. For most of them, making meaning using images, sound or movement was a novel experience, and multimodal presentation offered the opportunity to disrupt assumptions about academic texts. In particular, multimodality enabled the introduction of humour and irony in the assignments through sound (the Star Wars bar tune, creaking door), image (cartoon cow, Lurch) and animation (one writer introduced a clip from the Simpsons). This integration of humour arguably enables the more formal elements of academic writing to be subverted, as Shujon suggests: ‘Instead of creating using just words, you can think of what appropriate music or sound can be used, what images you want to use to create the atmosphere you want. I think in this piece, the subject itself, MUDs allowed even more ‘playfulness’ as in MUDs you are usually roleplaying anyway.’ Additionally, imagery such as Manchi’s stylised galaxy (which formed the background to every screen) and the futuristic, computer-generated images that appeared alongside written text, both situated the material within a particular set of tropes and offered an additional dimension to meaning-making which both complemented and disrupted the written text. CONCLUSIONS
Bruce Ingraham (2000) has suggested that writing in online spaces might trigger the reimagining of academic argument: ‘If we are to fully exploit this technology …. This may compel us to re-think the ways in which scholarly argument is constructed’. 57
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA
It seems that these students have been trying to experiment with argumentation, by developing different and looser organisational devices: ones which rely on visual motifs; exploit and embrace rhetorical spaces and gaps; and predict but do not prescribe relationships between information. Although the sites’ designs varied, the students tended to create a clearly identified central or opening page after which the writer relinquished control of movement to the reader and relied on image, colour and repetition for coherence rather than relying upon sequence. There also seemed to be a balance struck between the whole and the part: the overall hypertext and the lexia or units of text on each screen (Kolb 1994, Carusi 2006). Nearly all the students agreed that print-based conclusions were difficult to reconstruct, or remediate (Bolter) and they seemed, instead, to gravitate towards Kolb’s idea of making claims through exploration. Another question we have asked, and one which we would wish to explore further since teaching this course, is whether teaching students to write in plain hypertext, and to explore it as a medium, offers a complementary skill to the development of reading online as it is conceived of in the information literacy debate. Much is made of the challenges to students searching for and evaluating information as researchers in the digital age. Australia, New Zealand and the US have all recently formalized standards and learning outcomes for information literacy curricula. Similar developments are underway in Ireland and the UK (Antonesa 2007, Secker et al., 2007). However, we ask where the parallel developments are in relation to students’ writing. The response that students are ‘digital natives’ (Prensky 2001) and somehow automatically equipped to write online because of their fluency in social networking software seems inadequate to us, given the possible constraints of those systems. An analogy we might make is that Google is to reading what ‘Web 2.0’ is to writing: the power of the technologies is undeniable, but without adequate understanding of each medium, a student may potentially be disenfranchised and in both researching and producing argument. We also wonder to what extent the novelty of the form and context had an impact upon student writing and their attitudes towards it. The multimodal nature of the texts both increased the possibilities for rhetorical complexity and meaning making while providing new challenges to the textual line. This is particularly apparent with Shujon’s work. In the introduction to Reading Images, Kress and Van Leeuwen suggest that within certain coded practices ‘only a small elite of experimenters is allowed to break the rules…visual communication is coming to be less and less the domain of specialists, and more… in the domain of public communication. Inevitably this will lead to new, and more rules, and to more formal, normative teaching’ (p. 3). For the moment, however, hypertext writing as we have described it still sits largely outside the ‘rules’ of writing in higher education and currently, there exists a freedom that perhaps students struggle to find elsewhere. And, of course, ultimately these assignments were judged within an academic examinations framework, thus the students experienced the tension, described by Goodfellow and Lea (2007), between engaging in seemingly innovative digital practices and remaining alert to (and actively challenging) dominant paradigms of writing. 58
DIFFERENCE AND DISCONTINUITY
That is, for these students there were few guidelines and not many examples upon which to model their work. We think they found this unchartedness initially unnerving but ultimately liberating. However, if more institutional guidelines and regulations were devised for such types of writing, would some of these playful and subversive qualities be lost? Why are creative and subversive spaces important? In his book, Learning to Write, Kress, considers the acculturation of school children into types of writing valued by schools, and he concludes that the prescribed genres come to ‘control’ their writers to an extent: the learning of the genres involves an increasing loss of creativity on the child’s part and a subordination of the child’s creative abilities to the demands of the norms of the genre. The child learns to control the genre, but in the process the genre comes to control the child. Given the cognitive and social implications of these generic forms, the consequences for the child are immense. (Kress, 1982) We would ask, to what extent would enabling the disruption of an established genre, like the academic essay and more broadly, the linear argument, ‘compel’ (to recall Ingraham) different approaches to thinking. Perhaps the consequences for students (and academics) are immense too. We think that the use of hypertext writing, with its capacity to enable other modes, offers a challenge to this dominance. As one of our students said, ‘It does disturb the standard writing practices … I definitely felt that in the hypertext I could not carry on writing like I did in an essay…’ ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank Shujon Chowdhury and Manchi Chung for their contributions to this work. REFERENCES Antonesa, M. (2007). Can information literacy motivate students to become global citizens? Sconul Focus (42), 28–30. Bakhtin, M. M. (1988). The dialogic imagination (M. Holquist, Ed., C. Emerson & M. Holquist, Trans.). Austin, TX: University of Texas Press. Bolter, J. D. (2001). Writing space: Computers, hypertext, and the remediation of print. New Jersey, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Brooks, K. (2002). Reading, writing and teaching creative hypertext: A genre-based pedagogy. Pedagogy, 2(3), 337–356. Burbules, N. (1998). Essay review: Digital texts and the future of scholarly writing and publication. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 30(1), 105–124. Carter, L. (2003). Argument in hypertext: Writing strategies and the problem of order in a nonsequential world. Computers and Composition, 20(1), 3–23. Carusi, A. (2006). Textual practitioners: A comparison of hypertext theory and phenomenology of reading. Arts and Humanities in Higher Education, 5(2), 163–180. Dickson, M. (2002). Click here to organize. Pedagogy, 2(2), 253–257.
59
MCKENNA AND MCAVINIA Goodfellow, R., & Lea, M. (2007). Challenging e-learning in the university: A literacies perspective. Maidenhead: Open University Press. Ingraham, B. (2000). Scholarly rhetoric in digital media. Journal of Interactive Media in Education. Retrieved October 5, 2008, from http://www-jime.open.ac.uk/00/ingraham/ingraham-t.html/ Kolb, D. (1994). Socrates in the labyrinth. In G. P. Landow (Ed.), Hyper/Text/Theory (pp. 323–342). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Kolb, D. (2008). The revenge of the page. Retrieved October 5, 2008, from http://www.dkolb.org/ fp002.kolb.pdf Kolb, D. (2004). Twin media. Retrieved October 5, 2008, from http://www.dkolb.org/twin.media.ht04/ covershe.html Kress, G. (1982). Learning to write. London: Routledge. Kress, G. (2003). Literacy in the new media age. London: Routledge. Kress, G., & van Leeuwen. (2006). Reading images. London: Routledge. Ivanic, R. (1998). Writing and identity: The discoursal construction of identity in academic writing. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Landow, G. (1997). Hypertext 2.0. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Lea, M., & Street, B. (1998). Student writing in higher education: An academic literacies approach. Studies in Higher Education, 11(3), 182–199. Lillis, T. (2001). Student writing: Access, regulation, desire. London: Routledge. Lillis, T., & Turner, J. (2001). Student writing in higher education: Contemporary confusion, traditional concerns. Teaching in Higher Education, 6(1), 57–68. McKenna, C. (2005). Words, bridges and dialogue: Issues of audience and addressivity in online communication. In R. Land & S. Bayne (Ed.), Education in cyberspace (pp. 140–162). Abingdon: RoutledgeFalmer. Prensky, M. (2001). Digital natives, digital immigrants. On the Horizon, 9(5). Russell, G. (1998). Elements and implications of a hypertext pedagogy. Computers and Education, 31(2), 185–193. Secker, J., Boden, D., & Price, G. (2007). The information literacy cookbook: Recipes for success. Oxford: Chandos. Senn Breivik, P., & Gee, E. G. (2006). Higher education in the Internet age: Libraries creating a strategic edge. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Colleen McKenna Centre for the Advancement of Learning and Teaching University College London Claire McAvinia Centre for Teaching and Learning National University of Ireland, Maynooth
60
RAY LAND
5. SPEED AND THE UNSETTLING OF KNOWLEDGE IN THE DIGITAL UNIVERSITY
INTRODUCTION
This chapter considers how the nature of academic knowledge is inevitably being transformed in the digital university when the latter’s modes of production and exchange employ technologies that transmit data, through fibre optics, at the speed of light. Whilst remaining aware of arguments that draw too easily on notions of technological determinism, the chapter will draw on Virilio’s analysis of the relation between speed and power to differentiate the changing nature and uses of knowledge in digital environments from those familiar to us from print-based culture and some of the implications of this digital transformation and changed temporality for academic authority, approaches to academic writing, and traditional ways of practising. PRINT CULTURE AND THE DIGITAL TURN
At the centre of many of the rather splendid heraldic crests proudly sported by our older universities lies the image of a printed text – the bound codex. This is not surprising, as in earlier centuries many universities were the printing houses of their town or city, and tended to regulate what was permitted to be printed. Cambridge University Press in the UK remains the oldest publishing house in the world. Harvard University’s crest features three open texts with the word VE-RI-TAS emblazoned across them. Truth becomes identified with and embodied within the bound text. We still swear ‘the whole truth’ on such a bound text in our courts of law. The printed page, and the wider print culture through which it is produced becomes the basis of reliability, of authorship, of academic authority and the higher education institutions in which it is inscribed (Bayne 2006a). The last two decades, however, have witnessed, as part of the wider phenomena of globalisation and supercomplexity, an inexorable shift in higher education away from this print-based culture to a digital culture. As the media through which learning activity is conducted move increasingly from the printed text to the digital forms enabled by internet-based technologies, learners and their tutors are implicitly asked to confront some quite fundamental notions concerning textual stability and the nature of academic knowledge. By destabilising and seemingly ‘disordering’ the academic text, digital media enable new forms of academic discourse, literacy and knowing to emerge. (Kress, 2003; Landow, 2004; Privateer, 1999). In doing so they alter the traditional roles of teacher and learner and, by extension, the nature of the R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 61–70. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
LAND
academic institution itself. It is no longer possible, Spender (1995) argues, for teachers to appear as experts in digital learning environments as there is just too much information for any one individual to master. Within the print-based university – the society of the closed, static text – knowledge was in short supply, a special commodity. This empowered the gatekeepers, the initiators into disciplines, to determine intellectual boundaries, to regulate entry to the next level of information. Lyman (1994) talks of an ‘ecology of knowledge’ in which, when knowledge is scarce, centralisation and conservation take precedence. In an information-saturated environment, however, selection as much as conservation is the distinctive information problem. At the textual level, this digital turn occasions a shift to openness, inconclusivity, and fluidity. In his pioneering work on hypertext and academic discourse, Landow (1997) outlined some of the possibilities such environments offer for the transformation of the student learning experience. Within digital space, students gain both information and habits of thinking in a critical fashion through using several different approaches and varied sources. The online environment, he argues, orients students towards the making of connections. This then fosters more participatory and engaged reading-and-writing practices which empower students by encouraging them to be research-minded. They operate within the domain of research and scholarly enquiry rather than on its margins. It enables students to explore and create new modes of discourse suited to the ways of reading, writing and collaborating that are increasingly used in digital space. The more recent forms of digital textuality loosely characterised as ‘Web 2.0’ – weblogs, wikis, social media, shared bookmarking – further reinforce these characteristics of connectivity, multiple approaches and causation. The digital environment affords excellent opportunity for collaborative learning, whereas the latter, as Ede and Lunsford (1990) demonstrate, tends to be mistrusted in closed-text environments, where a relatively unquestioned assumption is that writing is mainly a solitary and individual act. By predisposing students towards multilinear and multisequential patterns of thinking, and immersing them in environments of multivocality, digital environments may encourage the higher order processes of integration and contextualisation in ways not achievable by linear presentation techniques (Mayes et al., 1990). SHIFTS IN THE NATURE OF KNOWLEDGE
This growing emphasis on the modality of learning has occasioned different ways of generating and engaging with knowledge. Print culture, in the form of the stable, bounded, individual and private text, has tended to operate within, and to reinforce, patterns of authority and identified authorship. Digital environments, more protean and restless in nature, tend to be more concerned with image, openness, multimodality and collectivity. They foster collaborative enquiry and production, inviting contestability but also requiring consensus and trust. Social media entail a shift toward new, often volatile forms of textual mediation and subject formation (Bayne 2006a). Such developments place increasing emphasis on collaborative modes of enquiry and the importance of group self-regulation and self-explanation. They alter 62
SPEED AND THE UNSETTLING OF KNOWLEDGE
relations between process and artefact, permit fragmentation over cohesion, exploration over exposition, the visual over the textual and, perhaps, convenience over quality (Hemmi et al., 2009). Alexander (2006) suggests that it is the quality of ‘openness’ that is the characteristic hallmark of such media, ideologically and technologically. They are characterised by endless re-crafting and addition: These sections of the web break away from the page metaphor. Rather than following the notion of the web as book, they are predicated on microcontent. Blogs are about posts, not pages. Wikis are streams of conversation, revision, amendment, and truncation. (Alexander, 2006, p. 32) THE CHALLENGE TO ACADEMIC AUTHORITY
This capacity of the digital for rapid editing, instantaneous cut-and-paste, offers the promise of progress and unlimited perfectibility, though what is gained is, in reality, only ever provisional stability. The perplexing volatility and instability of digital text – infinitely re-editable and instantly distributable – defies methods for imposing closure and authorial control. The writing and learning spaces represented by this ‘read/write web’ are defined by what O’Reilly (2004) has called an ‘architecture of participation’, increasingly oriented toward distributed authorship, collaboration and social networking (Alexander 2006). Wikipedia, the best known wiki, is a salient example in this regard. Whereas the authority of, say, Encyclopaedia Britannica, rests with the prestige and authority of its authors, the authorship of Wikipedia, in contrast, is of little interest. Its reliability lies not in its authority but in the expectation that if an entry is incorrect it will rapidly be amended or revised by someone, and speedily. Within such digital texts continued exploration and contestability are emphasised in place of settled knowledge. The challenge of the endless incompleteness of open digital text, its permanent state of new ideas and emergence, its endless revisability and mutability, the networked nature of its knowledge, its privileging of access over possession (Hayles 2009), and furthermore, its unclear and ambiguous positioning on the public/private continuum (Bayne 2006b) all seem to undermine the authority of academic knowledge. The latter has traditionally been necessary as the foundation of research evidence, and hence of veracity and the verifiable. The playful modes of online interaction characterised as ‘Web 2.0’ often sit uncomfortably within existing higher education practice (Hemmi et al., 2009). Textual instability, according to Barnett (2005), comes to function as a reflection of instability in the university’s idea of itself. The new media, characterised by their volatility, multivocality and radical contestability, become implicated in the 21st century university’s difficulty in maintaining and asserting its traditional authority. In this way the communicative landscapes opened up by social media can be troublesome to the academy, and are redolent of the spaces of strangeness, both epistemologically and ontologically, of which Barnett (2005) speaks: 63
LAND
we now live in a world of radical contestation and challengeability, a world of uncertainty and unpredictability. In such a world, all such notions – as truth, fairness, accessibility and knowledge – come in for scrutiny. In such a process of continuing reflexivity, fundamental concepts do not dissolve but, on the contrary, become systematically elaborated. (Barnett 2005, p. 789) In this respect the changing nature of Web 2.0 media expose the university’s inability to claim universality in its pursuit of truth, and are characterised by the ‘supercomplexity’ Barnett sees as integral to the 21st century academy. In this process of infinite elaboration, concepts are broken open and subjected to multiple interpretations; and these interpretations may, and often do, conflict. As a result, we no longer have stable ways even of describing the world that we are in; the world becomes multiple worlds. (Barnett 2005, p. 789) THE ACADEMY AND SPEED
The processes of rapid amendment, revision and re-editing discussed earlier depend upon speed to be effective. From this perspective the rise of digital information technologies seems located within the neo-liberal ideology of globalisation, and caught inexorably within a logic of increasing acceleration and exponential growth of information. Virilio (1999, 2000) emphasises such a view, seeing the defining characteristic of early twenty-first century society, and an increasing source of its hazards, as its relentless acceleration and compression of time. ‘Our history is the history of acceleration’ he argues (2000, p. 51) and ‘Speed is power itself,’ (1999, p. 15.) He suggests that ‘Faster, smaller, cheaper’ – the slogan of NASA – could shortly become ‘the watchword of globalisation itself’ (2000, p. 66). Web 2.0 technologies are a product of this speed, operating through fibre optics literally at the speed of light. In relation to digital temporality, Virilio warns of the ‘death of geography’ created by speed which appears to by-pass physical spaces and leads to an ensuing decline in their potential for democratic action. The death of geography is a notion that eerily comes to pass, perhaps, in the unheimlich arbitrary temporality of the 3-D avatar world Second Life. Here (if it is a ‘here’) one exists in an eternal present where no-one ages, where private and public boundaries are hopelessly confused, and where space only comes into being as one’s avatar moves through it and then disappears behind the avatar. As one tele-ports, geography disappears altogether. In this view the important democratic and political space of cities and the cultural and creative traffic contained within these spaces is ultimately reduced by accelerated technology until cities are rendered mere ‘intersections of speed’ (Virilio 1999). TEXTUALITIES AND TEMPORALITIES: FAST AND SLOW TIME
Print and digital cultures seem to favour distinctive temporalities. Whereas print culture and the cloistered academy required ‘slow time’ (Eriksen 2001) and private space to foster contemplation and deliberation, the digital would seem to thrive, in the main, on ‘fast time’, immediacy of response, and universal virtual space. Web 2.0 64
SPEED AND THE UNSETTLING OF KNOWLEDGE
practices seem caught in an awkward tension, if not disjunction. The pedagogical claims made for them seem to be located within, and to require the integrative and deliberative logic of, what Eriksen characterises as slow time. As digital phenomena, however, they increasingly serve to constitute fast time, can only accelerate in their future modus operandi, and reinforce the dromocratic principle that fast time drives out and occupies the place of slow time. Despite the unquestioned benefits of speed, there rise potential threats from fast time to reflection and creativity. Adam (1998) puts forward a similar case when discussing the social risks of speed, pointing out that ‘an important indirect effect is created through the ever decreasing time for reflection, contemplation and deliberation on the processes and their effects’ (p. 69). Slow time, which characterised earlier cultures of the written and printed word, an attribute of the cloister, the library and silent reading, is traditionally considered necessary for certain kinds of intellectual and emotional experience, for the production of certain forms of thought, and for the generation of certain kinds of knowledge (Eriksen, 2001). Don Novello, the American comedian, in his alter ego of Fr. Guido Sarducci, rock critic of the Vatican’s l’Osservatore Romano, provides a light-hearted spoof of these issues in his Saturday Night Live TV sketch of ‘The Five Minute University’. For $20 his innovative University offers a five minute degree course in any subject, complete with orange juice snack and instamatic graduation photograph. What is provided as outcome is what remains from a $25,000 ivyleague education five years after graduation, when virtually all the content has been forgotten. What one learns in the ‘Economics’ degree at Five Minute U is ‘Supply and Demand’. In the ‘Business Studies’ degree ‘You buy something and sell it for more’. His amusing deadpan delivery, however, emphasises both the pointlessness of crammed curricula memorised (and quickly forgotten) through rote memorisation, and the relentless performative shortening and intensification of the modern modular degree. Speed also transforms the academic estate, replacing traditional closed spaces such as the library and the personal study with open plan spaces buzzing with email traffic. Reflection and deliberation are compromised, and so is creativity, which is displaced, according to Eriksen (2001), by a relentless stream of new combinations. The filling of gaps, which seems to be an effect of speed and is typical of the tyranny of the moment, ‘is seriously detrimental to creativity. The new arises unexpectedly from the gaps created by slack in time budgets, not from crowded schedules’ (Eriksen, 2001, p. 112). He elaborates further, arguing that when growing amounts of information are distributed at growing speed, it becomes increasingly difficult ‘to create narratives, orders, developmental sequences. Within the digital the fragment threatens to become hegemonic. This has consequences for the ways we relate to knowledge, work and lifestyle in a wide sense. Cause and effect, internal organic growth, maturity and experience; such categories are under heavy pressure in this situation (p. 113)’. Strate (2005) goes further and suggests that digital temporality, in its present-centredness, recreates the stored past as the present, making it available for instant replay, and attempts to bring the future into the present through simulation. 65
LAND
STUDENTS WRITING DIGITALLY: RE-THINKING THE NATURE OF AUTHORSHIP
These reflections have been borne out by empirical data derived form a recent national study funded by the UK Higher Education Academy. This study examined the experience of learners and teachers when Web 2.0 technologies, or social media, are employed within formal academic settings (Hemmi et al., 2009). We investigated four courses, two entirely online, two blended, in two large UK research universities1. The disciplinary contexts included E-Learning, Engineering Design and Divinity. Our observations of students working in digital environments, and specifically writing within wikis and blogs, provided an interesting re-thinking of the nature of authorship. There was a sense among some learners that the wiki space almost gives permission to ‘be’ a writer in a new way: The wiki has been a very engaging totally new experience as contributor/ author. At first, it was daunting. The idea of contributing content/s and with personalised examples to a web page that so many people can read, well, it’s just something that I thought only writers would want to get into. Reading by scrolling up, down; clicking back and forth and in a non linear way with the hyperlinks and videos made the reading of contents more dynamic and in my case more conducive to remembering and learning many new concepts. I loved the possibility of organising and editing your new /old contents with immediate hyperlinks to references, translations, images, other pages in the wiki or web with certain ease of use. (Discussion board contribution from Student A) These reflections on the nature of authorship within the wiki were echoed by students on other courses. As one wrote within his weblog: In making a couple of entries and rephrasing some of the headers it occurred to me that my ‘marks’ in the text are probably ephemeral. They will endure for as long as the interval between editing (minor or major). So a wiki is a dynamic text – it really doesn’t have a form but (changing) content. When is it considered completed? Is it just a provisional evolving set of microcontent, juxtaposed texts? Is it pure luck that the ‘authors’ who endure manage to leave a lasting trace are those who happen to arrive at the end – when the ‘uberauthor’ (the course tutor?) halts the process? The process, of course, could just go on, ended by boredom, or exhaustion (everyone ‘written out’). But then the process of social writing could simply be renewed as new ‘authors’ join the fray. (Weblog posting from Student B) In a textual space where text is characterised by ephemerality and authorship is problematised, students across all three courses were concerned about ways in which they might accurately attribute authorship and spent some time considering and negotiating the forms of etiquette which applied to the editing and re-factoring of each other’s work. In thinking about editing the text produced by someone else I felt a considerable reluctance. It somehow seemed unacceptable to mess around with someone’s work. Certainly this is an interesting collaborative exercise. Good fun if only 66
SPEED AND THE UNSETTLING OF KNOWLEDGE
I can allow myself more latitude to alter what is there without feeling I’ll give offence! I’m really intrigued by it – wicked. (Weblog posting by Student C) I do think wikis tend to present a finished product that is a consensus more than something like a discussion board, or at least lay out the arguments in several groups. …I think we have to not be afraid to delete each other’s text in the wiki, which is a different way of thinking than the discussion board, and a more sensitive one. (Discussion board posting by Student D) ASKING FOR TROUBLE: THRESHOLD CONCEPTS AND TROUBLESOME KNOWLEDGE
Knowledge is troublesome for a variety of reasons (Perkins 2006). It might be alien, inert, tacit, conceptually difficult, counter-intuitive, characterised by an inaccessible ‘underlying game’, or characterised by supercomplexity. Students who find the learning of certain concepts difficult, seem to enter transitional spaces akin to states of ‘liminality’ which tend to be transformative in function, and usually involve an individual or group being altered from one state into another. (Meyer and Land, 2006). As a result of such transformation the learner acquires new knowledge and subsequently a new status and identity within a community of practice. However, this state of liminality, the space of transformation, can also become a suspended state, or ‘stuck place’, in which understanding approximates to a kind of ‘mimicry’ or lack of authenticity. Insights gained by learners as they cross thresholds can be exhilarating but might also be unsettling, requiring an uncomfortable shift in identity. Paradoxically this may be experienced as a sense of loss as an earlier, more secure stance of familiar knowing has to be abandoned as new and unfamiliar knowledge is encountered. A further complication might be the operation of an ‘underlying game’ or episteme (Perkins 2006) which requires the learner to comprehend the often tacit games of enquiry or ways of thinking and practising inherent within specific disciplinary knowledge practices. Transformation can be protracted, over considerable periods of time, and involve oscillation between states, often with temporary regression to earlier status. It would appear however, that once the state of liminality is entered, though there may be temporary regression, there can be no ultimate full return to the pre-liminal state. There would seem to be no re-winding of the transformative process. Though digital environments, as suggested earlier, might afford opportunity for collaborative learning and awareness of the contestability of arguments, a countering tendency might arise in relation to the issue of speed and acceleration in such environments. A question arises as to whether the liminal or threshold space, and the transformative process – in which (necessarily) troublesome knowledge is negotiated and conceptual difficulty encountered and overcome – is actually truncated or eroded by fast time and the ‘consumptive’ university it ushers in, as in Fr Sarducci’s comedic Five Minute University. The liminal state permits an integration of new knowledge into a new way of seeing, a re-conceptualisation. It is the state of trouble, stuckness, letting go and changed subjectivity, without which the possibility of things being otherwise is unlikely to come into view (Perkins 2006, Meyer and 67
LAND
Land 2006). It is a transformative state that engages existing certainties and renders them problematic, and fluid. Such troublesomeness or disquietude, however, is purposeful, as it is the provoker of change that cannot be assimilated, and hence is the instigator of new learning and new ontological possibility. Is this increasingly ‘squeezed’ by what seems to be the increasingly accelerating nature of digital temporality? Or are the long hallowed academic prerequisites of slow time, reflection, tranquillity and solitude in (private) cloistered space merely residual factors of an older, analogue print culture that is increasingly irrelevant to a generation comfortable with rapid knowledge sharing through i-phones and i-pads? DIGITAL MEDIA AND DISTANCIATION
Finally, Giddens’ concept of ‘distanciation’, which includes the notion of our carrying around our social world with us, regardless of the time-space continuum, suggests that certain social media (Facebook being a prime example) permit learners to access existing higher education infrastructures, and their own private social worlds, simultaneously, as points of web presence, regardless of the geographical location of their embodied presence. The structuring of time-space distanciation relies on such social relations as ‘presence-availability’ – the organization of presence, absence proximity and availability, and the degree of co-present activities in relation to ‘tele-present’ activities. (Giddens, 1984) The Higher Education Academy-funded research described above encountered the notion that students in the digital age are ‘never away’ but permanently networked. This leads to the blurring of boundaries between social/informal and formal spaces and between public and private spaces. It is becoming commonplace, and increasingly accepted by teachers, for students to have laptops open and connected through wireless broadband throughout the working day, whether working privately or whether participating in large or small group settings such as lectures and seminars. Student familiarity with Web 2.0 technologies, and their collaborative, user-generated materials such as weblogs, social media, tagging and filesharing, means that they are increasingly ‘backchannelling’ and multi-tasking electronically, recording, searching for information, sharing data and comments – even across the space of the lecture theatre or seminar room whilst formal teaching is in progress. This apparent digital ‘unruliness’ can be seen initially as transgressing the norms of conventional transmissive or didactic pedagogies and challenging the authority and control of the tutor in those settings. Increasingly, however, such practices seem likely to develop graduates capable of coping with complex flows of information, successfully prioritising and regulating their own behaviours and adopting critical informed views through access to multi-perspectival data. Such technologies are now being integrated within inquiry-based and self-regulated learning which are congruent with and can help sustain effective research-led academic environments. These practices, rather than being resisted in teaching, might be purposefully incorporated and successfully exploited. However a negative effect of distanciation (and fast time) is that the contemplative (research or private study) space becomes 68
SPEED AND THE UNSETTLING OF KNOWLEDGE
dis-placed by requirements for open office space and student learning centres to the domestic sphere, where it is invaded and compromised anew by the digital in the form of 24/7 domestic broadband connection. I certainly don’t feel I have much of a distinction between home and work any more, with both functioning in more or less the same way as portals into the internet where almost all my work is. I wonder if that is bad, or a healthy deconstruction of the work/home opposition into simply ‘life’? (Face to face interview with Tutor A) CONCLUSION
Despite an understandable caution in the use of digital environments in the 21st century academy, and a wary curtailment of them, it was encouraging in the research reported here to see universities experimenting with these new spaces in novel, productive and enjoyable ways (Hemmi et al., 2009). In its appropriation and repurposing of digital environments the university is beginning to acknowledge, and engage with, the radical potential which these media represent. Higher education is perhaps beginning to acknowledge and adapt to the ontological state of speed, disquietude and radical uncertainty that the learners of the future must competently and critically navigate. In this way it may exploit the digital to discover alternative contemplative and creative spaces. Alternatively it might develop new forms of subjectivity that accommodate states of almost perpetual liminality, or, at least, quickly shifting provisional stabilities. Whichever way, it is unlikely that 21st century higher education can constrain indefinitely the radical implications of the digital turn ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The first presentation of ideas in this chapter was as a keynote address at the 15th Improving Student Learning Symposium held at Trinity College, Dublin in September 2007. An earlier version of the chapter was published in the proceedings of that symposium as Land R. (2008) ‘Asking for trouble: speed, slow time and troublesome knowledge in the 21st century academy’, in Improving Student Learning – For What? Ed C.Rust, OCSLD, Oxford. The author is grateful to Chris Rust and staff at the Oxford Centre for Staff and Learning Development for permission to publish this revised version of the chapter here. NOTES 1
This was a joint study by the Universities of Strathclyde and Edinburgh. I am indebted to my coresearchers at Edinburgh, Dr Siân Bayne and Dr Akiko Hemmi, for the data presented here.
REFERENCES Adam, B. (1998). Timescapes of modernity: The environmental and invisible hazards. London: Routledge.
69
LAND Alexander, B. (2006). Web 2.0: A new wave of innovation for teaching and learning? Educause Review, 41(2), 32–44. Retrieved January 6, 2008, from http://www.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERM0621.pdf Barnett, R. (2005). Recapturing the universal in the university. Educational Philosophy and Theory, 37(6). Bayne, S. (2005). Deceit, desire and control: The identities of learners and teachers in cyberspace. In R. Land & S. Bayne (Eds.), Education in cyberspace. London and New York: RoutledgeFalmer. Bayne, S. (2006a). Networked learning with digital texts. In Networked learning 2006 proceedings. Lancaster University. Bayne, S. (2006b). Temptation, trash and trust: The authorship and authority of digital texts (pdf). E-learning, 3(1). Eriksen, T. H. (2001). Tyranny of the moment: Fast and slow time in the information age. London: Pluto Press. Giddens, A. (1984). The constitution of society. Cambridge: Polity Press. Hayles, N. K. (1999). How we became posthuman: Virtual bodies in cybernetics, literature and informatics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Hemmi, A., Bayne, S., & Land, R. (2009). The appropriation and repurposing of social technologies in higher. Education Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 25(1), 19–30. Kahn, R., & Kelner, D. (2005). Reconstructing technoliteracy: A multiple literacies approach. E-learning, 2(3), 238–251. O’Reilly, T. (2004). Open source paradigm shift. Author. Retrieved January 6, 2008, from http://tim. oreilly.com/articles/paradigmshift_0504.html Meyer, J. H. F. & Land, R. (Eds.). (2006). Overcoming barriers to student understanding: Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge. London and New York: Routledge. Novello, D. (2007). Father Guido Sarducci’s five minute university. Retrieved from www.youtube.com/ watch?v=kO8x8eoU3L4 Pelletier, C. (2007). Learning through design: Subjectivity and meaning in young people’s computer game production work. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of London Institute of Education, London. Perkins, D. (2006). Constructivism and troublesome knowledge. In J. H. F. Meyer & R. Land (Eds.), Overcoming barriers to student understanding: Threshold concepts and troublesome knowledge. London and New York: Routledge. Strate, L. (2005). Eight bits about digital communication. Turner, V. W. (1969). The ritual process: Structure and anti-structure. Chicago: Aldine. Virilio, P. (1999). Politics of the very worst. New York: Semiotexte. Virilio, P. (2000). Information bomb. London: Sage.
Ray Land University of Strathclyde Glasgow UK
70
POLITICS OF THE DIGITAL
MICHAEL BEGG, RACHEL ELLAWAY, DAVID DEWHURST AND HAMISH MACLEOD
6. LOGOS AND MYTHOS The Political Dilemmas of Web 2.0 in an Accreditation-Driven Educational Environment
“Believers in progress are seeking from technology what they once looked for in political ideologies, and before that from religion: salvation from themselves” (Gray, 2004) INTRODUCTION
For a number of years teachers in higher education have been encouraged to make use of online learning to transform individual and institutional learning and teaching practices (Crook, 1994; HEFCE, 2005; Laurillard, 1993; Squires, Conole, & Jacobs, 2000). This push to adopt e-learning has been reinforced by political reactions to growing student numbers, falling per capita funding and the growing dominance of bureaucratic university cultures which see e-learning as a means of providing cheaper, more flexible and more scalable delivery of both courses and whole programmes of study. Such an imperative is in turn arguably symptomatic of a wider change in higher education marked by a shift in focus from education to accreditation (Jacobs, 2005). The other contextual drivers behind the widespread adoption of e-learning are the social and cultural imperatives driving the ‘information revolution’. Such has been the speed of change that despite computers now being common to most education environments their use is often adopted with scant regard to their impact beyond the immediate context of problem (Nardi & O’Day, 1999). Such is the momentum of these changes that critics often self-identify as reactionaries or luddites (Landauer, 1995; Tenner, 1996) or as working to bridge huge divides (Henning & Van der Westhuizen, 2004). The latest wave of enthusiasm and investment in e-learning has centred around the educational use of online technologies that support widespread collaboration, and the creation and sharing of ‘user content’ via the so called ‘Web 2.0’ generation of applications (Alexander, 2006). However, the devolution of authoring and control to end users – a defining aspect of Web 2.0 – would appear to be antithetical to the increasingly managerialist cultures of many HE institutions, with the result that the politics and economics of learning technology use in Higher Education are increasingly misaligned. The consequences of this are as yet unclear. This argument can be situated within a broader discourse concerning the principle (and for many the seeming inevitability) of progress that has underpinned Western R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 73–82. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
BEGG ET AL
thought since the Enlightenment. A prime tenet of technocratic and secular societies is that advancing knowledge and understanding will lead towards a convergence of interests and an end to conflict and social dissonance (Gray, 2004). However, there is, Gray argues, little evidence to show that progress has led to this kind of reconciliation. Homogenous and harmonious learning technology provision within higher education is unlikely given the conflicts of identity, purpose and control. Indeed, that would only underline Gray’s observations that this kind of hopeful convergence amounts to little more than groundless faith in technology. Although political aspects of learning technology adoption and use have been considered before (Jones, 2001; Roberts, 2002) this paper takes a different perspective by focusing on issues of alignment and misalignment arising from the use of Web 2.0 technologies (and their underlying philosophies) and some of the ways in which they can affect educational contexts and professional identities. In so doing we present methods to support the exploration of the political nature of different learning technology contexts, individual technical interventions/systems and practitioners’ roles to better support their alignment with their intended cultural and political outcomes. WEB 2.0
The phrase “Web 2.0” is generally used as a way of differentiating newer collaborative and social web applications from the more static and informational instances that marked the first wave of web development, or “Web 1.0”. Despite debate over what actually constitutes Web 2.0, common factors include devolved user ownership and management of data, extensive syndication (and therefore reuse and repurposing) of content, a major emphasis on participation, collaboration and community building, along with service oriented technical architectures (Wikipedia, 2007). In just a few years whole communities have grown up around Web 2.0 applications such as Facebook, Blogger, YouTube, Flickr, Delicious, and many others. More recently Tapscott has identified the properties of Web 2.0 as consisting of openness, peer-peer relationships, sharing and acting globally (Tapscott & Williams, 2006). The scale of this phenomenon was reflected in Time magazine awarding their ‘personality of the year’ in 2006 to ‘You’ i.e. the multitudes involved in creating, publishing and communicating online, predominantly in Web 2.0-like ways (Stengel, 2006). Although this emphasis on individuality and community might be seen as a highly democratic phenomenon, it should be borne in mind that a lot of the most popular applications are controlled by just a few global corporations: Google controls YouTube and Blogger, News International controls MySpace, and Yahoo! Controls both Flickr and Delicious. Despite the many issues and unknowns surrounding Web 2.0 we are already in a cycle of hype over the educational use of Web 2.0, in particular social and collaborative tools such as wikis, blogs and the use of various forms of syndicated content like podcasting and vodcasting (Alexander, 2006). While voicing enthusiasm for the engaging, self directed, collaborative approaches apparently enabled by 74
LOGOS AND MYTHOS
Web2.0 applications, institutions often remain slow to implement them until such time as they can be replicated within the controllable confines of institutionally provided systems. EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS AND WEB 2.0
There can be little doubt that information and communication technologies have had a significant effect on many if not most HE institutions. E-learning continues to be viewed as an umbrella term for much of this activity, even though in many cases the processes may largely be to do with management, administration, data handling, filtering and auditing, and other less pedagogically focused activities. For instance it is now increasingly commonplace for students to be enrolled in courses and programmes of study without once having engaged physically with their host institution. From an institutional perspective this affords opportunities to extend their business and influence, with expectations of increased revenue, streamlined processes associated with teaching and administration and other enterprise-focused benefits (Pollock, 2002). While novelty often inspires enthusiasts to explore what they can offer, institutions as a whole seem largely unprepared for the implications of this latest wave of technologies. New management techniques, such as Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), which model the institution as a business made up of well-understood and centralised processes seem to be antithetical to technologies that support massively devolved control of content and identity. Most commonly, concerns are raised such as the defence of intellectual property, quality control, data protection, user privacy and ownership, and although these concerns existed well before Web 2.0 the affordances of Web 2.0 have significantly emphasised these anxieties. LEARNING TECHNOLOGISTS AS PARTISANS
The authors have previously described how the sense of professional purpose of staff who develop and run these systems is typically focused on the creation and support of more effective learning opportunities for students (Ellaway, Begg, Dewhurst, & Macleod, 2005). However, in practice it is not uncommon for learning technologist responsibilities to be more directed to operational and logistical management of e-learning systems. The required result is clearly more about passing students through programmes of study than the development and improvement of those programmes. Nevertheless, educational innovation still happens, but often without a direct institutional mandate. It would be tempting, therefore, to portray educational technologists as some kind of partisan force – part of an academic underground challenging the status quo in order to better serve both their client communities and their own interests. Educational institutions are paradoxical in both preserving knowledge and simultaneously challenging their own orthodoxies. It may therefore be the case that change can be effected more quickly in more localised contexts. However, if our students are engaged with their own education as a means towards accreditation, rather than 75
BEGG ET AL
a period of their life devoted to self and societal enriching through academic engagement, then this begs the question: who is it the partisans are fighting for? LOGOS AND MYTHOS
Web 2.0 clearly represents a substantial challenge to the orthodoxies of the academy. However, it is a difficult task to find a voice that is representative of the institution as a whole, not least because ‘the university’ as a coherent identity is typically seen as being ‘elsewhere’ (Cornford & Pollock, 2003) and therefore more about exclusion than inclusion. There are several approaches to eliciting information about domains of practice that allow participants to examine their relationships with and understanding of their working environments, the systems that impact upon their practice within those environments, and their roles and relationships within the institution. By directing attention towards these critical areas in the consideration of current challenges, such as those posed by Web 2.0, the academy has a chance to redeem itself from an apparently growing industrialization. It is the thesis of this work that we can progress in a spirit of Logos with an emphasis on reason and forward looking, and step aside from the real and present danger of being implicated in what Jacobs has termed “society’s decline from cultural vigor” associated with a more backward looking, dogmatic, and fundamentalist Mythos (Jacobs, 2005). POLITICAL ALIGNMENT ANALYSIS
The dialectic between the corporate and the individual is reflected in the argument that contemporary institutional cultures tend to diminish institutional loyalty, diminish trust between workers and weaken institutional knowledge (Sennett, 2006). As a means to address this disconnect Sennett proposes an emphasis on core values around the themes of personal narratives and individual interpretations of events, individuals feeling useful and engaged with the organizational enterprise and personal craftsmanship expressed in doing something well for its own sake. The similarities between these ‘healing’ values and the affordances of Web 2.0 are notable, so perhaps it is in this socio-economic vein that we can explore issues around power and identity in higher education and the ways in which the environment can be used to control or direct those within it. Given that all technologies “embody specific forms of power and authority” (Winner, 1980) it follows that a political critique of the alignment between higher educational values (and the institutions that embody them) and the affordances of Web 2.0 technologies can provide particular insights into their significance and impact. Political orientation analysis involves mapping one or more entities onto a political continua diagram, such as the Political Compass or the Nolan Diagram (Nolan, 1971) (see figure 1), which present biaxial spaces defined by opposing right/left and libertarian/authoritarian (or totalitarian) positions. In practical terms respondents are required to place an entity such as a person, service, artefact or technology on two separate continua; one ranging between collectivism and individualism 76
LOGOS AND MYTHOS
Figure 1. Coordinate models of political alignment; the political compass1.
Figure 2. Results from the alignment analysis2. 77
BEGG ET AL
and the other between libertarianism and authoritarianism. Indicators of collectivism include communities, societies and tribes, and indicators of individualism include independence, self reliance and egotism. Indicators of libertarianism include independence, free expression and anarchism, and indicators of authoritarianism include social control, hierarchies and obedience. This instrument was applied with participants at the Ideas in Cyberspace Education meeting in Scotland in the spring of 2007 with 12 respondents from a variety of academic education technology backgrounds rating a number of 8 factors or technologies. The results were plotted in Adobe Illustrator and a number of aggregate plots created for each factor. Each respondent entry was set at a transparency of 50% to show overlays and densities – see figure 2. Although subject to the usual cautions over low sample sizes and a nonrepresentative respondent group the following tentative observations can be made: – The top row represents context; the university, teachers and students. Both the university and teachers were seen as occupying a moderately authoritative position but spanning collectivist and individualist perspectives. Students were seen as moderately individualistic and moderately libertarian. Interestingly there was more agreement over the position of teachers and students than there was for the university. – The middle row represents existing technology use; e-learning and virtual learning environments (VLEs). ELearning was largely seen as encompassing the entire continuum while VLEs were seen as moderately authoritarian but spanning collectivist and individualist perspectives. – The bottom row represents Web 2.0 technologies; blogs, wikis, Facebook. All three were seen as quite libertarian. Despite this blogs showed quite a pull towards authority along with a particularly individual perspective. Wikis showed a more collectivist perspective and Facebook a broader spread although notably individualistic. These ratings reflect the participants’ perceived affordances of the different phenomena they refer to and start to demonstrate the different political domains their use represents. Although these axial models can be useful as high-level illustrations it should be noted that there are several problems with such a method. For instance there are several credible choices of continua that could be used (such as between national and free market or between global and personal) and there are inevitable problems of overlap and the extent to which different continua are orthogonally related. Other credible templates for this kind of analysis include Boisot’s axial models of information economies (Boisot, 1995), and models of cultural alignment (Hofstede & Pedersen, 2002). PERSONAL CONSTRUCT ANALYSIS
A second method for generating a visual representation of alignment is to model how individuals construe a domain and the relationships between agents and/or applications within that domain. Personal construct psychology (Kelly, 1955) is 78
LOGOS AND MYTHOS
based on the idea that all phenomena are construed in terms of how they had been anticipated. In short, experience is evaluated in terms of existing knowledge and entered accordingly into a meaningful framework (the personal psychological construct) relating to that domain. Kelly developed tools and techniques for eliciting such constructs, most significantly the triadic elicitation of constructs mapped onto grids with associated conceptual elements. The theory and methods of personal construct psychology remain somewhat controversial as there is no single clear-cut method for eliciting data (data can emerge from both constructs and/or elements) and there are issues in aggregating data from multiple respondents in a satisfactorily objective fashion. Nevertheless, like the previous biaxial compass method, personal construct psychology tools and elicitation techniques may suggest ways for practitioners to explore their role and position in relation to their working environment. As an illustrative example, one of the authors used the (freely available) online grid elicitation tool provided by the University of Calgary to create a grid based on a few elements associated with the Web 2.0 and Higher Education. These elements were ‘blog’, ‘wiki’, ‘Myspace’, ‘WebCT’, ‘Moodle’, ‘discussion board’, ‘Facebook’, ‘Google’, and ‘email’. Examining the resulting grid (see figure 3) there is a clear cluster on the right hand side of the diagram. The elements ‘blog’, ‘Myspace’, ‘Google’ and ‘Facebook’ are closely linked to the construct poles learner centred, property of individual, cost effective, emphasis on independent learning and, interestingly, vulnerable to attack and threatens institutional control. If bipolar constructs based on a core set of negotiated elements were elicited from a number of individuals an empirical opportunity, similar to that offered by the political compass model would be suggested.
Figure 3. WebGrid of learning environment3.
79
BEGG ET AL
IN CONCLUSION
Winner asserts that technologies “are ways of building order in our world” (1980). From this kind of political perspective the analysis and critique of learning technology provision can be expected to provide insights unavailable from purely technical or educational perspectives. Indeed such perspectives have been shown to be essential in eliciting holistic representations of technology use in educational settings (Ellaway, 2006). Although it is possible that this kind of misalignment or dissonance may result from insufficient technological maturity, the identity of the academy (and those within it) faces substantial challenges in this new environment. Many individuals and institutions are making sizeable personal investments in Web 2.0. For instance we have observed that many teachers collate their materials outside their institution’s core services and they direct students towards home grown websites, or to personal blogs, despite working within HE contexts that provide opportunities to contain all such activity within a few centralised and normalised systems and environments. Learning technologists may wish to pursue developmental and exploratory uses of new technologies such as Web 2.0 but the pressures of ‘minding the shop’ mean that mainstream e-learning is increasingly about supporting logistical, administrative and managerial processes than rather than engaging with teaching and learning. Those who do manage to apply time and effort to improving student learning are often confounded by an audience more concerned with acquiring the institutional credit to allow them to advance their personal agendas rather than exploring the meaning and practice of effective learning. Given that technology is never politically neutral (Graham, 1999) and should be considered as indicative elements of a system (Bereano, 2003) the growing interest in Web 2.0 would appear to contribute to a disconnect between the intended and actual roles and service models for learning technologists. Furthermore although many Web 2.0 technologies afford unprecedented levels of user control, and opportunities to collaborate and interact in new ways, the Web2.0 mainstream is increasingly controlled by a small number of very wealthy, very powerful organizations using their position to market products and analyse and subsequently influence consumer behaviours. Within the framework of academic institutions, we often observe local champions seeking to utilise what they perceive to be the positive aspects of new technologies. Institutions on the one hand recognise their reflection in academic principles of openness and discourse while at the same time inhibiting their uptake with reactionary concerns regarding the nature of these same applications. Becker’s model of the art world (1982) reminds us that what we come to perceive or personally construct as an idea of art has been shaped not only by the artist, but by journalists, gallery owners, critics, commissioners, archivists, courts, politicians, educators, and many others. The same premise perhaps holds true here. Our perceptions of the phenomenon of e-learning are individual and heterogeneous and inevitably impact on how e-learning is constructed and how it impacts on our ways of working. The assumptions, sociopolitical positioning and alignment of students, teachers, academic managers, policy and strategic leaders, technology providers and vendors are all equally implicated. 80
LOGOS AND MYTHOS
If we accept that: “technology and organization are not ontologically separate categories, but rather mirror reflections of a mutual interchange of knowledge meanings and political interests” (Scarborough & Corbett, 1992, p. 157) and the university in the information age is about pursuing increasing flexibility and accommodation of individual student and faculty needs (Brown & Duguid, 1995), then the opportunities afforded by Web2.0 technologies would seem to provide ample opportunity for this to be realised. At the present time many institutions are teetering between embracing this new model of the academy based on devolution and collaboration and one based on authority and exclusivity. In many ways Web2.0 is just the latest challenge to reactionary and authoritative cultures in higher education and, as such, is an essential part of the academy’s lifecycle. To this extent, Web2.0 represents significant practical and philosophical challenges to the academy, and this time maybe the revolution will be televised after all. NOTES 1
2
3
Left – see http://www.politicalcompass.org accessed 2 March 2007) and the Nolan Diagram (Right – see (Nolan, 1971) and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolan_chart. The top row represents the context; the institution, teachers and students, the middle row represents existing e-learning and VLEs and the bottom row represents Web 2.0 technologies. An example of a map generated using the University of Calgary’s Webgrid tool showing the spread of elements and constructs associated with the proposition “Reifying relationships between institutions, applications and individuals” see http://tiger.cpsc.ucalgary.ca (accessed 13th March 2007)
REFERENCES Alexander, B. (2006, March–April). Web2.0: A new wave of innovation for teaching and learning? EDUCAUSE Review, 33–44. Becker, H. S. (1982). Art worlds. Berkley, CA: University of California Press. Bereano, P. (2003). Technology is a tool of the powerful. In M. D. Erman & M. S. Shauf (Eds.), Computers, Ethics and Society (pp. 85–90). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Boisot, M. H. (1995). Information space: A framework for learning in organizations, institutions and culture. London: Routledge. Brown, J. S., & Duguid, P. (1995). Universities in the digital age. Retrieved January 18, 2004, from www2.parc.com/ops/members/brown/papers/university.html Cornford, J., & Pollock, N. (2003). Putting the university online: Information, technology and organizational change. UK: Open University Press. Crook, C. (1994). Computers and the collaborative experience of learning. UK: Routledge. Ellaway, R. (2006). Evaluating a virtual learning environment in medical education. Unpublished PhD, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh. Ellaway, R., Begg, M., Dewhurst, D., & Macleod, H. (2005). In a glass darkly: Identity, agency and the role of the learning technologist in shaping the learning environment. E-learning, 3(1), 75–87. Graham, G. (1999). The Internet: A philosophical enquiry. Routledge. Gray, J. (2004). Heresies. London: Granta.
81
BEGG ET AL HEFCE. (2005). HEFCE strategy for e-learning: Higher Education Funding Council for England. Document Number. Henning, E., & Van der Westhuizen, D. (2004). Crossing the digital divide safely and trustingly: How ecologies of learning scaffold the journey. Computers & Education, 42(4), 333–352. Hofstede, G. J., & Pedersen, P. B. (2002). Exploring culture: Exercises, stories and synthetic cultures. Yarmouth, Maine: Intercultural Press. Jacobs, J. (2005). Dark age ahead. New York: Vintage. Jones, C. (2001). Do technologies have politics? The new paradigm and pedagogy in networked learning. Paper presented at the TPP - What Next? Calgary, CA. Kelly, G. (1955). Principals of personal construct psychology. New York: Norton. Landauer, T. K. (1995). The trouble with computers: Usefulness, usability, and productivity. USA: MIT Press. Laurillard, D. (1993). Rethinking university teaching - A framework for the effective use of educational technology. UK: Routledge. Nardi, B. A., & O’Day, V. L. (1999). Information ecologies: Using technology with heart. MIT Press. Nolan, D. (1971, August). The case for a libertarian political party. The Individualist. O’Reilly, T. (2005). What is Web2.0: O’Reilly Publishing. Document Number. Pollock, N. (2002). The informational view of the university. In W. H. Dutton & B. D. Loader (Eds.), Digital academe: The new media and institutions of higher education and learning (pp. 232–249). London, UK: Routledge. Roberts, G. (2002). Complexity, uncertainty and autonomy: The politics of networked learning. Paper presented at the Networked Learning, Sheffield, UK. Scarborough, H., & Corbett, J. M. (1992). Technology and organization: power, meaning and design. UK: Routledge. Sennett, R. (2006). The culture of the new capitalism. New Haven, CT; New York: Yale University Press. Squires, D., Conole, G., & Jacobs, G. (Eds.). (2000). The changing face of learning technology. UK: ALT. Stengel, R. (2006, December 25). Now it’s your turn. Time. Tapscott, D., & Williams, A. D. (2006). Wikinomics: How mass collaboration changes everything. New York: Portfolio. Tenner, E. (1996). Why things bite back: Predicting the problems of progress. Fourth Estate. Wikipedia. (2007, February 19). Web2.0. Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_2.0 Winner, L. (1980). Do artefacts have politics? Daedalus, 109(1).
Michael Begg, David Dewhurst and Hamish Macleod University of Edinburgh, UK Rachel Ellaway Northern Ontario School of Medicine, Canada
82
LEAH P. MACFADYEN AND ANNE HEWLING
7. HOW THE EARTH MOVED ‘Difference’ and Transformative Learning in an Online Course on Global Citizenship
BACKGROUND
In September 2005, we launched a new online course, Perspectives on Global Citizenship, at the University of British Columbia. As an educational undertaking, we hoped that it would not only allow students to acquire more ‘information’ about global issues, but also push them to reflect critically on their own assumptions about ‘how the world works’ and on their own social and political roles and responsibilities, locally and globally. The course explicitly introduces notions of social justice, equity, sustainability and social action, and it directly challenges students to examine their privileged worldview. Because exploration of such themes necessarily involves asking hard questions about whose interests are being advanced over others, and can involve proposing changes to social or political structures “that are already quite congenial to some people in the community…” (Eyler & Giles, 1999, p. 131), some may contend that the course has overtly political aims. We agree! Unless one fully embraces Freire’s (1970) contention that education itself is political, how can one possibly help students make connections between academic knowledge they acquire in their classes, and their roles and responsibilities as members of local and global communities? How else can one engage students personally and professionally with the practical and ethical complexities of global challenges? The ‘political’ ambitions we have for this course are, in fact, fully in line with Trek 20101, the Vision and Mission Statement of The University of British Columbia (hereafter, UBC), which articulates the wish that: …the graduates of UBC will value diversity, work with and for their communities, and be agents for positive change. They will acknowledge their obligations as global citizens, and strive to secure a sustainable and equitable future for all. Eyler & Giles (1999) note, “politics is about competing interests and controversy” (1999,. p. 131). Perspectives on Global Citizenship seeks to create a forum for students to engage in debate on the controversial and competing issues of social and ecological justice through critical thought, moral commitment and meaningful engagement in their learning and ‘coming to know’ as global citizens.
R. Land and S. Bayne (Eds.), Digital Difference: Perspectives on Online Learning, 83–100. © 2011 Sense Publishers. All rights reserved.
MACFADYEN AND HEWLING
Evidence from student feedback and course-based writing suggests that this course is achieving at least some of our educational goals. A student writes: …this class was different in a big way. Whereas in other classes, you can do readings and assignments, get the 3 credits and that’s it...walk away...I felt like suddenly we’ve identified ourselves not only as students but active participants in what we’re learning through the concept of global citizenship. Global citizens seemed like an abstract idea at first but slowly I think we realized that we were talking about ourselves As tutors in this course, we also feel that we regularly experience something extraordinary, taking us beyond what we have experienced in other courses. In this chapter we attempt to explore just how ‘the earth moves’ for learners in this course, and try to capture the nature of the ‘difference’ in learning experience that some of them describe. We investigate elements of course structure and pedagogy that triggered this different learning, in the hope of learning lessons of our own that will reposition our future online endeavours. DEVELOPMENT OF PERSPECTIVES ON GLOBAL CITIZENSHIP
The meaning of global citizenship is hotly debated and poorly defined (see, for example, Dower & Williams, 2002). Developing a course that would introduce this contested concept (Roman, 2003) – one that is so tightly connected to questions of global power, culture and values – was therefore no small undertaking. As the first course of a new interdisciplinary program collaboratively offered by UBC and a number of its Universitas 212 partner universities (currently Hong Kong (China), Nottingham (England), Melbourne and Queensland (Australia), Lund (Sweden) and Tecnológico de Monterrey (Mexico)), we recognized that participating students would represent a great diversity of cultural and disciplinary backgrounds, necessitating attention in the curriculum development process to cultural assumptions underlying contemporary models of citizenship and worldview. Nor could we assume deep background knowledge in any one topic area. We resolved therefore that topics within the purview of global citizenship would be presented for debate, discussion and critical analysis by each student cohort. We developed the initial course outline with input from a wide range of local and international colleagues. Topic areas were selected to create a course outline3 that would represent an introduction to a range of concepts and topics relevant to the discussion of global citizenship (Table 1). Twelve different subject matter experts, located at UBC and elsewhere in the world, drafted content for the modules contained in the course. Perspectives on Global Citizenship now comprises twelve weekly thematic modules, presented via a web-based course management system (WebCT CE4.1 from September 2005–December 2006, and Blackboard Vista from January 2007 – present). Tutors make use of course management system (CMS) communication tools to promote critical thinking and reflection through course readings, facilitated (asynchronous) discussion with tutors and international peers, and regular written work. 84
HOW THE EARTH MOVED
Table 1. List of course modules Module 1: Ethics of global citizenship Module 2: What is ‘citizenship’? Module 3: The challenge of global divisions: Race, ethnicity, nation, state Module 4: Challenging old conceptions of citizenship: Diversity and multiculturalism Module 5: The challenge of being informed: Media, communications and critical thinking Module 6: The universal requirements for a healthy society Module 7: Globalization, world trade and poverty Module 8: Consumption and consumerism in the global context Module 9: Human impact on the environment Module 10: Sustainability as a conceptual framework Module 11: Options for action: Politics, participation and civil society Module 12: Global citizenship in daily life?
Each module offers summary contextualizing pag