DEVELOPING STRATEGIES TO DEAL WITH TRAUMA IN CHILDREN
NATO Security through Science Series This Series presents the results of scientific meetings supported under the NATO Programme for Security through Science (STS). Meetings supported by the NATO STS Programme are in security-related priority areas of Defence Against Terrorism or Countering Other Threats to Security. The types of meeting supported are generally “Advanced Study Institutes” and “Advanced Research Workshops”. The NATO STS Series collects together the results of these meetings. The meetings are co-organized by scientists from NATO countries and scientists from NATO’s “Partner” or “Mediterranean Dialogue” countries. The observations and recommendations made at the meetings, as well as the contents of the volumes in the Series, reflect those of participants and contributors only; they should not necessarily be regarded as reflecting NATO views or policy. Advanced Study Institutes (ASI) are high-level tutorial courses to convey the latest developments in a subject to an advanced-level audience Advanced Research Workshops (ARW) are expert meetings where an intense but informal exchange of views at the frontiers of a subject aims at identifying directions for future action Following a transformation of the programme in 2004 the Series has been re-named and reorganised. Recent volumes on topics not related to security, which result from meetings supported under the programme earlier, may be found in the NATO Science Series. The Series is published by IOS Press, Amsterdam, and Springer Science and Business Media, Dordrecht, in conjunction with the NATO Public Diplomacy Division. Sub-Series A. B. C. D. E.
Chemistry and Biology Physics and Biophysics Environmental Security Information and Communication Security Human and Societal Dynamics
Springer Science and Business Media Springer Science and Business Media Springer Science and Business Media IOS Press IOS Press
http://www.nato.int/science http://www.springeronline.nl http://www.iospress.nl
Sub-Series E: Human and Societal Dynamics – Vol. 1
ISSN: 1574-5597
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children A Means of Ensuring Conflict Prevention, Security and Social Stability. Case Study: 12–15-Year-Olds in Serbia Edited by
Jill Donnelly Mouvement Mondial des Mères/World Movement of Mothers, Paris, France
Anna Kovacova Klinika detskej psychiatrie, Detskej fakultnej nemocnice, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
Joy Osofsky Professor of Pediatrics, Psychiatry & Public Health, LSU Health Sciences Center, New Orleans, USA
Howard Osofsky Professor and Head, Department of Psychiatry, Louisiana State University, New Orleans, USA
Caroline Paskell Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics, United Kingdom
and
Josi Salem-Pickartz Clinical Psychologist Amman, Jordan Associate Professor of Psychology, University of Oldenburg, Germany
Amsterdam • Berlin • Oxford • Tokyo • Washington, DC Published in cooperation with NATO Public Diplomacy Division
Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Developing Strategies to Deal with Post-Conflict Trauma in Children Bratislava, Slovak Republic 4–6 March 2004
© 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without prior written permission from the publisher. ISBN 1-58603-546-0 Library of Congress Control Number: 2005931630 Publisher IOS Press Nieuwe Hemweg 6B 1013 BG Amsterdam Netherlands fax: +31 20 687 0019 e-mail:
[email protected] Distributor in the UK and Ireland IOS Press/Lavis Marketing 73 Lime Walk Headington Oxford OX3 7AD England fax: +44 1865 750079
Distributor in the USA and Canada IOS Press, Inc. 4502 Rachael Manor Drive Fairfax, VA 22032 USA fax: +1 703 323 3668 e-mail:
[email protected]
LEGAL NOTICE The publisher is not responsible for the use which might be made of the following information. PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
v
Foreword Slovakia is at the heart of the whirlpool of the communist past and a reunified Europe. I was delighted to welcome specialist particpants from so many different cultures and experiences to my country, both as a mother and as a doctor at the Child Psychiatry Hospital of Bratislava. This meeting identified ways of ensuring that a child would keep happy memories of childhood and would not allow traumatic experiences of war and terrorism to harm their adult life. It was held symbolically in the Slovak Academy of Sciences Castle of Smolenice – just the place where, in a child’s fairytale, the king and queen will live happily ever after in a perfect world when the forces of good have overcome the forces of evil... But can this ideal ever come true? A life at peace is the basis for the success of every human endeavor. Unfortunately, this peace is threatened by wars, ideological extremism, the class struggle, political conflict, terrorism, rape, murder, injustice... in Slovakia and many countires, by the sudden economic changes of transition ... and, everywhere in the world, man’s unbridled desire for power over other men... NATO was founded to maintain peace in Europe – and now beyond – at the same time as the Mouvement Mondial des Mères/World Movement of Mothers. The MMM helps mothers fulfil all their responsibilities, particularly building peace, in the family and outside the home. Thanks to these two organisations this meeting developed ways in which a child’s fairytale future might come true... Anna KOVACOVA, MuDr, NATO Partner Co-Director
Prevention of violence to children and the protection of their rights is the duty of every adult. But most adults do not know how to offer appropriate support. This meeting, which brought together for the first time scientists and lay people with practical experience, looked not only at practical measures to engage and train concerned adults and adolescents, but also at changing the attitudes which lead to the abuse of children. As a Belgian, trying to come to terms with the discovery of a paedophile network in the heart our society, I feel very strongly the need for coordinated local, national and international initiatives and guidelines to prevent and remedy trauma to children. Mia VANDERHASSELT NATO Co-Director
vi
NATO Advanced Research Workshop Smolenice Castle, Slovak Republic March 4–6th 2004
Preface and Acknowledgments No longer are threats to security and their impact on individuals a matter for the authorities alone – a holistic view is now essential. From grass roots to policy level all of us must be involved, take responsibility, make informed decisions and undertake appropriate actions. This is particularly important if we are to succeed in redressing the potential negative impact of the psychosocial consequences of trauma in children and adolescents in countries in transition, emerging from conflict or victim of terrorist incidents. There are many more young people who need appropriate help to come to terms with what they are suffering than there are mental health professionals. Many people could learn the skills to ensure that today’s young people realise their full potential as wellbalanced adults, willing and able not only to commit themselves to social development and security for their own country but also to focus on respect and understanding to ensure international peace and security. This Workshop sought to establish long-term and sustainable strategies of practical activities which mothers, fathers, teachers – any concerned member of the community – can be trained to undertake in order to complement the work of mental-health professionals to prevent trauma and to deal with its consequences in children and adolescents as victims, witnesses and perpetrators of the violence of the new security threats. As a first step, the 40 participants from 19 countries developed a Consensus Strategy to deal with the responses to trauma shown by 12–15 year old Serbian children, identifying the training required by non-professionals working alongside mental health professionals. Preliminary work was undertaken to develop international guidelines for implementing effective measures to help young people regain their well-being and become future actors for respect, understanding and Peace. We thank each participant for their most active and constructive involvement in every aspect of the Workshop: they each brought to our meeting total commitment, generosity of spirit and open-mindedness to succeed in our appointed task. The setting of Smolenice Castle allowed us all to complement the intense work of the sessions with very fruitful informal discussions. We should like to express thanks on behalf of NATO and the MMM to Dr Anna Kovacova, Barbora Maronkova and the direction and staff of the Castle for their unstinting efforts to ensure our comfort. I should like to give my sincerest thanks to Lucie Bratinkova and Diana Morato for their dedication and hard work throughout the meeting, to Caroline Paskell for recording and transcribing the proceedings, to all those who helped to translate and edit the manuscript and to Celia Clarke for copy-editing and proof reading. This spirit of solidarity and human concern in many people throughout the world far outweighs the atrocities committed by the few – this brings hope that the future can truly be secure and peaceful. Jill DONNELLY President, MMM International
vii
List of Participants AKHMEDOVA, Khapta BELAROUCCI, Latéfa BENHABYLES, Saïda BOKUN, Tanja
BRATINKOVA, Lucie DESPOTOVIC, Tija DONNELLY, Jill GASIC PAVISIC, Slobodanka GMUR KARAPETIAN, Armine IGNATIEVA, Anna JISHKARIANI, Mariam JOVANIC DUNJIC, Ivanka KOVACOVA, Anna
LETH, Ingrid KUTS, Linna DE MALHERBE, Angela MALKA, Shimon
MARONKOVA, Barbora MORATO, Diana NEUHAUSER, Linda
OZACKY Lazar, Sara
Psychologist dealing with refugees, Grozny, Chechnya Clinical psychologist, specialist in victims of terrorism, Algeria President of the International Federation of Victims of Terrorism Algeria NGO “Srce”, Centre for Emotional Support and Prevention of Suicide Novi Sad, Serbia and Montenegro Research Fellow Defence Academy of the United Kingdom Shrivenham UK (Czech) Psychoanalytical psychotherapist, psychiatrist Belgrade, Serbia President, MMM International Paris France (British) Professor Faculty of Education and Foundation Together Belgrade Serbia Center For Psychological Services, Armenia Union of Committees of Soldiers’ Mothers of Russia Moscow Russian Federation Psycho-rehabilitation Center For Victims Of Torture Centre “Empathy”, Tblisi Georgia Psychiatrist/psychotherapist, Belgrade Serbia Paediatric psychiatrist, Klinika detskej psychiatrie Detskej fakultnej nemocnice, Bratislava Slovak Republic Professor of Psychology, University of Copenhagen Denmark President, Democratic Union of Many Children Families Chernigov Ukraine Centre d’Education Pluridisciplinaire de la Personnalité Neuilly-sur-Seine France The Jewish Arab Center for Peace, Co-director ‘All for Peace’ joint Palestinian/Israeli radio station and Co-editor ‘Crossing Borders’ joint Palestinian/ Israeli/Jordanian youth magazine Givat Haviva Israel Centre for European and North Atlantic Affairs Bratislava Slovak Republic Universidad Pontificia Comillas (ICADE), Madrid, Spain Clinical Professor School of Public Health, University of California Health Sciences Center Berkeley, California, USA Academic Director, The Jewish Arab Center for Peace Givat Haviva Israel
viii
OSOFSKY, Howard OSOFSKY, Joy PASKELL, Caroline PETERS, Lilian DE RAMBUTEAU, Isabelle SALEM-PICKARTZ, Josi SKODA’CEK, I. SPECKARD, Anne
TKACHENKO, Dmytro VANDERHASSELT, Mia VLACHOVA, Marie
VULEVIC, Gordana
WIENTJES, Cornelis
YULE, William ZIVULOVIC, Jasna
Head of the Department of Psychiatry Louisiana State University, New Orleans USA Professor of Pediatrics, Psychiatry, & Public Health LSU Health Sciences Center, New Orleans USA Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics UK Consultant International Coalition to Stop the Use of Children as Soldiers President, MMM France Paris France Clinical psychologist, Amman Jordan (German) Head of the Klinika detskej psychiatrie Detskej fakultnej nemocnice, Bratislava Slovak Republic Associate Professor in Psychiatry Georgetown University, Professor of Psychology Vesalius College Free University of Brussels Belgium Youth section DUMF Chernigov Ukraine Liga voor het Kind, Ghent Belgium Centre for the Democratic Control of Armed Forces Women and Children in an Insecure World Programme Geneva Switzerland (Czech) Psychologist-Psychopathologist Faculty of Philosophy, Department for Psychology of Youth and Adolescence Belgrade Serbia Military psychologist, NATO Security-Related Civil Science & Technology Programme Brussels Belgium (Dutch) Professor of Applied Child Psychology, University of London Institute of Psychiatry UK President MMM Serbia, Belgrade Serbia
ix
Contents Foreword Anna Kovacova and Mia Vanderhasselt
v
Preface and Acknowledgments Jill Donnelly
vi
List of Participants
vii
Introduction Introduction I. The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents in the Context of Conflict and Terrorist Incident Howard J. Osofsky Introduction II. Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats to National and International Stability Jill Donnelly
1
7
Part I 1. Specific Causes of Trauma in Children and Adolescents as Victims, Witnesses and Perpetrators of the Violence of Conflict and Terrorism, and Activities Proved to Prevent, Reduce or Remedy the Consequences to the Individual and to Society as a Whole 1. Education Under Continuous Violent Conflict Sara Ozacky-Lazar 2. Brutalisation of Young Conscripts in the Russian Federation and the Long-Term Effects Anna Ignatieva
15
19
3. Terrorism in Algeria – The Impact on Children and Adolescents Saïda Benhabyles
23
4. Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments Latéfa Belarouci
25
5. Group Therapy with Traumatized Children in the Chechen Refugees Camps Khapta Akhmedova
32
6. Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims and Problems of Rehabilitation in Georgia M. Jishkariani, V. Kenchadze and Z. Beria 7. Child Soldiers – Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration Lilian Peters
34 40
x
8. Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children in Serbia Slobodanka Gasic-Pavisic
53
9. Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism: Trauma and Bereavement as Psychological Vulnerabilities in Human Security – The Chechen Case Anne Speckhard and Khapta Akhmedova
59
2. A Comparative Study of Different Developmentally Grounded and Culturally Sensitive Mental Health Approaches Towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table William Yule, Howard J. Osofsky, Igor Skodacek, Armine Gmur Karapetian, Latéfa Belarouci and I. Leth
65
3. Collaboration Between Mental Health Professionals and Non-Professionals Introduction William Yule
75
I. The Role of Non-Mental-Health Professionals – The Professional Viewpoint The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages: Prevention and Intervention – Effective Collaboration with Police and Court Joy Osofsky The Role of Authoritative Parenting in Building Resilience Josi Salem-Pickartz II. The Role of Non-Mental-Health Professionals – The Non-Mental-Health Professional Viewpoint 1. Causes and Effects of Delinquent Behaviour and Social Exclusion Caroline Paskell
77 89
93
2. Dignity and Respect for Oneself and Others: A Practical Initiative with Adolescents Angela de Malherbe
107
3. Communication in the Family—A Means to Reduce Anti-Social Behaviour and Violence in the Community Isabelle de Rambuteau
110
4. Israel: Mechanisms to Help Youth Cope with the Current Situation and the Fear of Violence and Terror Shimon Malka
112
5. Working with Youth as Partners to Reduce the Effects of Trauma: Models from Belarus, Russia and the USA Linda Neuhauser
116
xi
Part II Identifying Scientifically-Grounded Specific Strategies to Deal with the Responses to Trauma Shown by 12–15 Year Old Serbian Children and the Training Required by Members of the Community, Working Alongside Mental-Health Professionals, to Implement Effective Measures to Ensure Well-Being and Well-Balanced Social Attitudes 1. Establishing the Context – The Impact of Post-Conflict Trauma on the Well-Being of Young People and the Future Development and Security of Fragile Societies: Bosnia, Kosovo, Serbia William Yule 2. Case Study: Specific Elements of the Post-Conflict Trauma of Serbian 12–15-Year-Old Children and Adolescents Tija Despotovic, Ivanka Jovanovic Dunjic, Gordana Vulevic and Jasna Zivulovic 3. Discussion 4. Effective Strategies Already in Place in Serbia 1. Psychosocial Programs for Teachers – A School-Based Model of Child Mental Health Protection Anica Mikuš Kos and Tatjana Bokun 2. Using Educational Institutions in Serbia for the Post-Conflict Recovery of Children Slobodanka Gasic Pavisic 5. “Serbia Maybe Could Forgive if NATO Apologised!” – NATO Response Cornelis Wientjes 6. Identifying the Obstacles and Local Resources for Implementation and the Training Required by Non-Professionals Working Alongside Mental Health Professionals to Implement Effective Measures to Ensure the Well-Being and Well-Balanced Social Attitudes of Young People in Serbia All Participants 7. Consensus Serbian Strategy. Action Plan Agreed by All Participants Part III Recognising Developmental Considerations and Cultural Sensitivities, First Steps in Developing a Strategy to be Applied Internationally for Preventing, Mitigating and Remedying Trauma in Children: Lessons Learned from the Development of the Strategy for Serbian Children – Relevance, Limitations and Opportunities Josi Salem-Pickartz, Jill Donnelly and Howard Osofsky
127
133
141
149
157
159
170 182
185
Unanimous Recommendations
198
Author Index
201
This page intentionally left blank
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
1
INTRODUCTION I The Essential Elements in dealing with trauma in children and adolescents in the context of conflict and terrorist incident. Howard J. OSOFSKY, M.D., PhD. NATO Country Co-Director Professor and Head Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center Department of Psychiatry New Orleans, USA The areas of relevance to the participants and the program objectives: First, how humans - children and their families - cope with ongoing threats, as well as the impact of long term threats, repeated exposure to trauma, and warfare and its aftermath. Second, the importance of cultural considerations and sensitivities related to the expression of symptoms, evaluation and treatment. Third, questions about whether there is a post warfare and terrorism mental syndrome. Fourth, issues of preparation/readiness including community preparedness, training of responders, development of family and school plans, and consideration of developmental needs. Fifth, response at the time of terrorist attacks and warfare including immediate needs, expectable reactions successful coping and worrisome reactions. Sixth, recovery including reduction, persistence or worsening of symptoms, as well as development of new symptoms. Seventh, when and how to carry out mental health evaluations and treatment taking into account developmental considerations, cultural values and resources. Eighth, resilience including the important components of successful coping and resilience, how resilience differs from resistance, and long term implications of resilience. Ninth, the needs of responders including respectful training of indigenous practitioners, compassionate reactions, counter transference and burnout, concerns about safety, family safety and family worries, and management of stress and personal difficulties. Tenth, issues of hope, altruism, spirituality and personal meaning with individual’s wishes to know where they are going - going forward to something - while knowing where they have been and integrating the traumas they have experienced.
Over the course of three days, key leaders, investigators, and clinicians from around the world focused on the needs of children, adolescents, and their families in the face of threats of violence, and ongoing current violence. The conference, a joint initiative of NATO and the World Movement of Mothers, represents the recognition of the importance of this topic not only for the European countries which will receive particular focus, but for the world at large. The World Movement of Mothers, representing millions of mothers and their concerns, plays a crucial role in emphasizing the key roles that parents, particularly mothers, play in fostering healthy development and in protecting their children, the young people and future of our society.
2
H.J. Osofsky / The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents
NATO is taking the leadership in helping to bring together the best available scientific knowledge and in formulating specific action plans that can help high risk children and adolescents in their development, allowing them to achieve their potential, and minimize the threat of future violence. In the workshop, we focused both on current and ongoing threats and together with our Serbian colleagues, gave specific attention to programmatic efforts that can be of maximal help to young people in Serbia. We are well aware that most humans cope with reasonable success to various types of traumatic exposure including the complex emergencies related to warfare and other acts of mass violence. We know less about the impact of long term concerns about potential terrorist attacks or armed conflict in how these may affect children and adolescents’ behaviours and perceptions of others. During the workshop, a number of us presented data and our thoughts on outcomes related to repeated exposure to trauma and the aftermath of warfare. Within these presentations and the subsequent discussion, emphasis was placed on: - Losses — of loved ones, homes and income - Refugees, resettlement, immigrant problems - Injuries, rapes, torture, mutilations - Family and community stability - Parental strengths, difficulties - Roles of and for children and adolescents Through these presentations, it was considered important to deal thoughtfully with cultural considerations and sensitivities. These are crucial from a number of perspectives. The meaning and expression of symptoms clearly have commonalities across cultures; however, there are specific components that are culturally related and that will influence interventions that are designed to be of help in coping and recovery. Our approaches to treatment and the roles of treaters must similarly take into account these cultural considerations. In many areas of the world, skilled mental health professionals are either not available or available in very limited numbers. Other service providers and indigenous health practioners will play crucial roles in the delivery of services. Further, key responder groups, including spiritual leaders, teachers, community and agency first responders, and parents and children themselves play key roles, and we considered how to maximize their benefits in a respectful and thoughtful manner. As we continued in our discussions, we focused on a number of areas, which in English begin with the letter “R”: x Readiness — Preparation 1. Community preparedness 2. Training of responders 3. Development of family and school plans 4. Consideration of developmental needs x Response — Here we focused on the needs that are paramount at the time of terrorists’ attacks and active warfare. 1. Safety 2. Well being and availability of family 3. Nutrition 4. Shelter 5. Medications currently being prescribed 6. Crisis intervention services as needed.
H.J. Osofsky / The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents
3
It was considered important to consider reactions that can be anticipated and expected at the time and shortly following terrorist attacks and those that occur during active warfare. As was noted throughout the workshop, as we address the needs of children and adolescents, we must give attention to such factors: x
Reactions 1. Age and developmentally related considerations for children and adolescents 2. Extent of Trauma 3. Proximity of Trauma 4. Losses 5. Prior experiences 6. Prior mental health symptoms 7. Family support 8. Community support This is obviously complex area for consideration. A number of key components include whether hostilities have ceased, the potential and real threats of future terrorism or renewal of hostilities, death, injury or torture of loved ones; economic loss, possible relocation and refugee status, perceived and real opportunities. Given the positive coping of most individuals, we can expect to observe a reduction of symptoms over time. However, we must be attuned to those who have a persistence of symptoms, a worsening of symptoms, or a development of new symptoms. Although specific mental syndromes have not been identified for these children and adolescents, rates of persistent mental health problems appear higher then those noted for non-traumatized community groups. Further, we must also be aware of and address behavioural and learning changes that are not traditionally associated with mental health diagnoses but that impact on school performance, peer relationships, and functioning within the family and community. For those of us who are involved in designing systems or clinically providing mental health evaluation and treatment, a number of key principles should receive focus “in our toolbox” or clinical approaches. These include: Identify Diagnose Treat Take into account developmental and age related considerations Be culturally attuned in diagnosing, communication, and prescribing Remember the importance of altruism, hope, cultural, and spiritual values Teach positive coping behaviours; reinforce reduction of risk behaviours x Resilience. It was considered very important for us to address the resilience of youth, how to promote their resilience, and how to allow it to serve them in developmentally appropriate and socially adaptive manners. Adolescents in particular should be included in the process and can be of help to their families, to younger children, and to the community during response and recovery. A number of participants at this workshop provided useful information concerning how resilience differs from resistance, factors that contribute to resilience, how we can support healthy resilience, and the long term implications of resilience.
4
H.J. Osofsky / The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents
x Responders. Given the needs of countries and availability of resources, consideration must be given to the roles of local service providers and indigenous practitioners. Within this training, we addressed age and developmentally informed treatment, cultural questions, roles that are most helpful especially during response and recovery, and the respect that is required for local service providers and indigenous practitioners in their roles. Local practitioners and indigenous practitioners may be more attuned than consulting professionals to societal and cultural sensitivities and needs, and each can compliment the other. Any consideration of responders must include their reactions and those of their families. Responders may be called to deal with members of their community, with family members, or with individuals who remind them of family members. They may have compassionate reactions, especially when traumatized individuals are children. We need to consider when these compassionate reactions can be of help and when they interfere with responder effectiveness. Counter transference issues may also impact on the therapeutic process. When the patients’ problems awaken uncomfortable feelings in the therapist (and in these circumstances the therapist is dealing with these same issues) or when patients have been extremely traumatized, the therapist may either wish to make things better more quickly than is possible or feel hopelessness given the extent of the traumas experienced by the patient; either of these may interfere with treatment. Emphasis was put on issues related to responder burnout. The factors considered include: x Intensity and difficulty at work x Needs for time off, away from work x Increases in burnout over time—i. e. during hostilities or in refugee camps x Needs for colleagues/sharing/supervision x Worries about themselves, their safety x Worries about their families and their safety x Families’ worries about them and their safety It is necessary that we help responders, including those who are highly motivated, to recognize and deal with their reactions including, if and when their occur, stress reactions, physical complaints, post traumatic stress and mood symptoms, substance abuse in themselves or their families, and domestic problems. In conclusion, I would like to reflect on a component of our work and those of our colleagues with individuals who have experienced extreme trauma, including aspects related to terrorism and warfare. As they cope with and recover from their traumatic experiences, these individuals frequently describe the importance of hope, altruism, and spirituality as they address issues of personal need. We have been impressed with their wishes to move forward, to know where they are going and that they are going forward to something with realistic hope and expectations. At the same time when active engagement is possible, they often express the desire for greater understanding, knowing where they have been and wishing to integrate the traumas they have experienced. It is our obligation to help by thinking and developing plans to deal with the trauma experienced by children and adolescents of countries in the NATO periphery. We can have much hope for the future of our youth and their ability to meet their potential. This in turn will contribute to the social stability necessary for post conflict recovery and reconstruction.
H.J. Osofsky / The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents
5
References Alexander, D. & Klein, S. (2001). Ambulance personnel and critical incidents. The British Journal of Psychiatry. 178, 76-81. Baker, A. & Shalhoub-Kevorkian (1999). Effects of political and military traumas on children: the Palestinian case. Clinical Psychology Review, 19(8), 935-950. Bell, C. (2001). Cultivating resiliency in youth. Journal of Adolescent Health, 29(5), 375381. Fazel, M., & Stein, A. (2002). The mental health of refugee children. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 87, 366-70. Gavrilovic, J., Lecic-Tosevski, D., Dimic, S., Pejovic-Milovancevic, M., Knezevic, G., & Priebe, S. (2003). Coping strategies in civilians during air attacks. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 38(3), 128-133. Larsen, J. (2003). Stress and resilience in South African firefighters. SAMJ, 93(4), 36-38 Lipton, H. and Everly, G. (2002). Mental health needs for providers of emergency medical services for children (EMSC). Prehospital Emergency Care, 6(1), 15-21. Masten, A., Hubbard, J., Gest, S., Tellegan, A., Garmezy, N., & Ramirez, M. (1999). Competence in the context of adversity: pathways to resilience and maladaptation from childhood to late adolescence. Developmental Psychopathology, 11(1), 143169. Mollica, R., Osofsky, H., Osofsky, J., & Balaban, V. (In press). The mitigation and recovery of mental health problems in children and adolescents affected by terrorism. JOURNAL Mollica, R., Cardozo, B., Osofsky, H., Raphael, B., Ager, A., Salama, P. (In press). Scientific overview of the role of mental health in complex humanitarian emergencies. The Lancet. Osofsky, H.J., Osofsky, J.D.. (2002) Children’s Exposure to Community Violence: Psychoanalytic Perspectives on Evaluation and Treatment in Violence and Transmission of Trauma: Analytically Informed Interventions in the Community. B. Sklarew, S. Wilkinson and S. Twemlow. Eds. Analytic Press, New York. In Press Osofsky, H.J., Osofsky, J.D.(2001). Violent and Aggressive Behaviors in Youth: A Mental Health and Prevention Perspective, Psychiatry: Interpersonal and Biological Processes. Vol. 64, p. 285-295 Pynoos, R., Armen, K., & Steinberg, A. (1998). A Public Mental Health Approach to the Postdisaster Treatment of Children and Adolescents. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America, 7(1), 195-210. Raphael, B., Sihgh, B., Bradbury, & Lambert, F. (1983). Who helps the helpers? The effects of a disaster on the rescue workers. OMEGA, 14(1), 9-20. Report of a Workshop of Institute of Medicine and National Research Council. The impact of war on child health in the countries of the former Yugoslavia. (March 27-30, 1994) Trieste, Italy. Salama, P., Spiegel, P., Van Dyke, M., Phelps, L., & Wilkinson, C. (2000). Mental health and nutritional status among the adult Serbian minority in Kosovo. Journal of the American Medical Association, 284(5), 578-584. Shaffer, D., Fisher, P., & Dulcan, M. (1996). The NIMH Diagnostic Interview Schedule for Children Version 2.3 (DISC-2.3): Description, Acceptability, Prevalence Rates, and
6
H.J. Osofsky / The Essential Elements in Dealing with Trauma in Children and Adolescents
Performance in the MECA Study. Journal of the American Academy of Child Adolescent Psychiatry 35 (7), 865-877. Walton, J., Nuttall, R., & Nuttall, E. (1997). The impact of war on the mental health of children: a Salvadoran study. Child Abuse and Neglect, 21(8), 737-749.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
7
INTRODUCTION II Working in the context of the new security environment and threats to national and international stability Jill DONNELLY, BA President of MMM International Mouvement Mondial des Mères – World Movement of Mothers Paris, France Today’s revolution - Impact of military activity on the fabric of social life leading to revolution - elements and causes of today’s revolution: social changes; shift in strategic focus; new threats to security - Why this is a personal problem and why we must respond - Why we are focusing on the well-being and needs of children and adolescents
Human history moves in cycles. Every 50 years or so there occurs a revolution in the way we think and react. Revolutions take time to happen. They differ from evolution in that the changes accumulate. Revolutions happen when several changes reach a high degree of intensity and simultaneity. The skill in negotiating a revolution is in recognising what will stay the same and what will change! In revolutions people are hurt because governments find they do not have the appropriate tools to deal with the new circumstances. I am speaking from a Western European perspective but this is – or probably soon will be – the experience of other parts of the world. The Impact of Military Activity on Social Life Military activity has a huge impact on the fabric of social life, and therefore, affects us all. Some examples from European history are x 1789-1815: the French Revolution to the battle of Waterloo saw the development of mass conscript armies. This meant the creation of a very large standing army, standardised and efficient. But it caused a social revolution in that now 20% of the active male population was exposed, not just to death in foreign lands, but to new ideas. This also caused the centralisation of states – France is a very good example. Napoleon was, therefore, able to enforce the legal system called the ‘Code Napoléon’ on every country of Europe he overran – and it is still in force today. x In the conflicts of the 1860´s came the rifle, rapid firing weapons, industrial mechanisation – but also the telegraph and the railways x The First World War, 1914 – 1918, saw the industrialisation of warfare and the fact it was a contributing factor to the revolution in Germany, Turkey and Russia and the
8
J. Donnelly / Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats
x
formation of the Soviet Union. The loss of so many young men caused a huge impact on social customs and traditions. The Second World War: Nuclear armaments, modern medicine, such as antibiotics and the involvement in every aspect of the nation’s activities of women! For example, in 1947 the MMM – the World Movement of Mothers - was founded to give women a voice. While the men were mobilised, women, particularly mothers had kept alive not only their family but the nation as a whole, but they had had no say in the decision to go to war which had so overturned their lives. As an NGO with Consultative Status at the United Nations, the MMM can make the two-way link between grassroots and policy level. We are part of the rapid development since the Second World War of civil society.
Right now, we are in a revolution as profound as any of these – but because we are in it, we do not see it – and are, therefore, very vulnerable indeed. If you think the world has not changed so very much - just think about communication – How long have we all been able to use mobile phones, Internet, emails – and how lost we are without them when they do not work! Here are just a few of the compounding elements of our revolution: I shall mention just a few of the rapid and profound social changes. Globalisation and Western market-driven culture is overriding and even destroying national traditions and customs, particularly in countries with little state infrastructure where the role of mothers and fathers, clearly defined, but complementary, is the major source of well-being, support and social cohesion. In developed countries, where this traditional role is taken over more and more by the state, we are witnessing break up of family as the foundation of society – marriage is becoming rarer, divorce more prevalent, parental authority is challenged. In developed nations governments are struggling to find social policies to deal with the demographic trend of a non-replacement birth rate, single-person households, an ageing population: there are several causes, such as women in the workplace, professional women waiting to fulfil career goals before having children – and then finding they have left it too late to give birth, conflict, social and employment uncertainty and concerns about security. We are seeing increasingly individuals focusing on their rights – not their responsibilities. All of these – and more – are challenging tradition and are destabilising societies and nations. There has been a shift in strategic focus on the world military scene. Throughout the Cold War, strategic focus was in Central Europe - the East-West standoff – with Germany as the focal point. We can still see this today – all the major roads run East-West throughout Europe and the former Soviet Union, all heading towards Germany. It was the concentration of armies and armaments and the confrontation between the two. Now strategic focus has shifted to an arc stretching from Mauritania to Pakistan – with Turkey as the interface New threats to security bring new threats to our way of life. I shall deal with these later, but I shall mention two elements now. Firstly, we need to note the impact of the fact that defence and security are no longer synonymous. By this I mean that in the Cold War period, the stronger a country’s defence, the more secure its population felt. However, this is no longer true – Israel’s defences have never been stronger, but never have Israelis felt so insecure.
J. Donnelly / Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats
9
The second, linked to the first, is terrorism. One contributory factor to the rise in terrorist activity is the fact that, during the Cold War, the great powers did not wage war in the conventional way in Europe and America, nothing showed the tension – the standoff – but the great powers were fighting their war using other actors – factions in fragile societies, such as those in the Middle East, Afghanistan, Africa. The aftermath is two-fold. There is legacy of resentment and discontent, particularly among young populations where their low economic opportunities and living standards make a stark contrast to the lifestyle images broadcast by the media and available on the Internet which give a false impression of life in developed countries. More insidious is the fact that there is in these countries a body of people trained in covert activities and agitational propaganda aimed at destabilisation.
What is this current revolution and why is it happening? There are many factors all intermeshed and interacting with one another, which bring great benefits but at the same time, truly terrifying vulnerabilities. We just need to look at two aspects of the growing gap between industrially developed – rich – nations and developing – poor – countries. Firstly economic: for example, exploitation, corruption, lack of capacity-building programmes for local administrators, absence of stable infrastructure and so on has led to slow economic growth-rates despite huge natural resources and inward investment. Secondly demographic: in industrially developed countries there is growth of the older population and very rapid decline in the birth rate. Despite wars, the AIDS pandemic, governmental mismanagement or corruption leading to the absence of the most basic needs of the population, epidemics and natural catastrophes, this is generally reversed in developing countries. Our lives have been changed by the rapid development and proliferation of technology military or otherwise – everything from thermal and satellite imaging, self-homing missiles, to robotic manufacturing, the internet and the mobile phone! This is linked to the information revolution. While we all think of the Internet and emails, we must not forget electronic banking. Many countries have reached a high level of sophistication but we are victims of our own efficiency – it leaves us very vulnerable. Almost all industrial enterprises - commercial or agricultural industries, hospitals, for example, now use the practice of “just in time delivery”, this keeps costs down, no stock is held in reserve. Whether it’s spare parts for your car factory in England or Japan, or fuel delivery for a hospital in Spain or Singapore, or feed for a chicken farm in Denmark, ‘just in time delivery’ is the system for economic efficiency. So why is this a potential problem? A breakdown of the delivery system could have truly a catastrophic effect on the socioeconomic cohesion of a country. And this system applies in electronic banking: no European country has enough cash in circulation to meet demand during peak times every week, particularly during Friday or Saturday. If the electronic system through which all transactions are channelled crashes on a Friday, in Britain, for example, by the following Thursday, farmers would have to start slaughtering cattle through lack of the delivery of fodder. And this all came to light, when in Britain two years ago, fuel delivery drivers went on strike to protest the tax on diesel fuel. If the strikes had continued for a further 36 hours,
10
J. Donnelly / Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats
Britain would have faced social and economic collapse. Just think of one example: no fuel, no electricity for hospitals…. And this was a group exercising their legal right to make a peaceful protest. They were not aware of the repercussions – and it took the Government a week to 10 days to understand the gravity of the situation. Another example from Britain: in the 1990s, the IRA placed a large bomb in a lorry outside Canary Wharf, in the City of London – the heart of the British commercial and banking world – if it had been placed 10 meters to one side, it would have destroyed 60% of the U.K telephone communications, and it would have closed down the City. We are just not prepared for this kind of attack – we have no alternative back-up. To quote an example from another part of the world, just think of the Japanese cult leader who caused Sarin to be released in the Tokyo underground. It caused 11 deaths and 5,000 injuries – if he had been more technically competent, these figures would have been reversed. The 5,000 injured had been present in the underground - but the other 12,000 who were hospitalised had been nowhere near the incident. Most of them had seen it on TV! This was a clear example of the impact of psychological trauma. How could hospitals cope with a really successful terrorist incident? Professor Ahmed Baker’s research in Palestine confirms how the fear of danger is a powerful factor in provoking trauma – studying the reactions of children in three areas: a zone where bombs were dropping – where children were seeing family, friends and neighbours killed, their homes destroyed; within a five-kilometre radius – still a certain degree of danger and the noise of the attacks was loud; within a 20-kilometre radius – no danger at all, but the planes could be heard flying over. It was in this outside area that the evidence of trauma was greatest – in the danger zone, children dealt with day-to-day survival. It is not yet known what the situation will be in the future when the danger is past. Dr Anika Mikus Kos, president of Foundation Together, Slovenia, ran psychological tests on a visiting group of Serbian children – and on the Slovenian host children. The latter showed a higher degree of trauma than those who had actually been in the war zone. Again showing that fear and uncertainty are very strong factors in provoking trauma – which could impact negatively on the capacity of the rescue services and hospitals to cope with a serious incident. Lastly we have to face the new threats to security.
What are these New Threats to Security? x x x x x x x
Bad governance – Incompetent, corrupt, self-seeking governments Corruption at all levels of activity - from the State leader to the border guards Organised crime and its involvement in human trafficking and terrorism Insecure borders - illegal migration, leading too often to human trafficking for cheap labour, sexual exploitation and organ removal Refugees - the destabilising effect – just think about the influx of Palestinian refugees into Lebanon which led to 16 years of vicious civil war Ethnic and religious strife. The manipulation of natural resources – we all immediately think of oil, but water is more likely to cause conflict in the near future or to cause irreversible ecological damage. Turkey controls the water for Iraq and Syria and could hold them to ransom. Ethiopia controls the waters of the Blue Nile. If they were withheld then Egypt could become the desert wasteland that was the Aral Sea.
J. Donnelly / Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats
x x
11
Proliferation of weapons, including weapons of mass destruction - the basic elements of which are available to the corrupt governments of the poorest countries, who could pose a serious threat to the major powers of the world. Terrorism. To repeat an earlier point, during the Cold War, the great powers did not wage war in the conventional way in Europe and America. Nothing showed the tension but the great powers were fighting their war using other actors – factions in fragile societies in the Middle East, Afghanistan and Africa. The aftermath is a legacy of resentment and discontent, particularly among young populations – and, particularly in those areas which came under the influence of the Soviet Union, groups of people well-trained and experienced in destabilising societies and nations by, for example, infiltration of national infrastructures. Many of these countries have a rapidly growing young population whose only chance of spiritual fulfilment, economic improvement for themselves or their family and enhanced self-image is offered by illicit income or membership of extreme groups. The fact that this is sustained and manipulated by corrupt governments and organised crime and that it facilitates terrorism and harms the social and economic fabric of nations is ignored by all concerned – including the beneficiaries in the so-called developed countries who benefit from cheap goods and labour. The situation is endangered further by the recruitment for suicide terrorism of well-educated young Muslims, often secondor third-generation, well-established in Western countries. A common factor is that they study or work in scientific or information technology fields and that they feel a lack in their life of spiritual values and purpose. This is a challenge for both the Western societies in which they live and for the Muslim communities of those countries.
Why is this a personal problem and why must we respond? Together with the foregoing factors, we must consider four more elements. They underline why we, as individuals working together, not the state, the “authorities” or whichever other actor we might like to be in charge, must take responsibility for and control of our present situation. The first is that in the past women and children were usually involved, injured or killed accidentally or incidentally in war. Today they are specifically targeted as a ‘normal’ feature and constitute 85% of the casualties in the conflicts of the last 10 years. The second is that no longer do massed armies face each other on a distant battlefield – now the conflict is close to our lives wherever we live - terrorism brings it into our workplace, our schools, our supermarket, our restaurants and our homes. Wherever we – and our children - are, we are now at risk. The third is more insidious - the power of the media – as uncontrollable – and potentially as dangerous - as the weather! It colours how we view current events and forms our attitude towards other people – particularly those from different backgrounds or cultures. The fourth returns to an earlier remark. In revolutions, states and international institutions do not have the right tools to tackle the new problems. The forces of law and order are almost powerless to stem the tide of illicit activity – because they act within the law and their adversaries act outside the law. Civil rights organisations persuade us that heightened security measures are an infringement of our privacy.
12
J. Donnelly / Working in the Context of the New Security Environment and Threats
What is more, the factional aspect of conflict is such that states and international organisations like NATO and the United Nations do not have the weapons to fight it – literally and metaphorically. Weapon procurement is a slow process – about 15 years from order to supply of new types of weaponry. Changing the mindset which still wants to spend the defence budget on new jet planes – at $220,000,000 each for a US F22 – and, no, I have not added a couple of extra zeros! - when we are facing a fast-moving ‘invisible’ enemy - is an equally slow process! Responsibility to act is now in the hand of individuals – and that is you and me! Whether we are mothers, fathers, teachers, concerned members of society – or mental health professionals - responsibility to act is ours. Few of the problems of our revolution are truly new – what is new is the immense scale, the vast numbers of people who have been hurt – or will be hurt physically and mentally. There are just not enough mental health professionals to deal with all of those who need help to recover. For this reason we were seeking to identify in this Workshop the necessary training and practical activities which, in collaboration with professionals, ordinary people can undertake. We found that certain activities have been proved to work to help children and adolescents cope with the consequences of the violence of conflict and terrorist incident activities such as discussion, art, music and theatre groups where traumatised children and adolescents can regain the trust and confidence necessary to begin the healing process – and where those who need individual help can be identified.
Why are we focusing on the well-being and needs of children and adolescents? Those children and adolescents who have suffered trauma – and those who, in this new security environment, run a real risk of suffering trauma in the near future - need our help. All of the clinicians and specialists at the Workshop from 19 different countries were united in a common concern for the well-being and happiness of children. A further dimension is that children represent the best investment for the future. The consequences for society of not helping them recover from the trauma caused by the violence of war and terrorism is all the greater because children are the future. The future safety of the world and the individual security of each one of us depend on children growing up into adults who are well-balanced, productive, committed to social development and nationhood - and who recognise diversity not as a threat to be eliminated, but as an enriching and shared human value. Our task in this Workshop was to develop measures to make this ideal a reality.
Part I 1. Specific Causes of Trauma in Children and Adolescents as Victims, Witnesses and Perpetrators of the Violence of Conflict and Terrorism, and Activities Proved to Prevent, Reduce or Remedy the Consequences to the Individual and to Society as a Whole The purpose of this session was to identify positive responses to traumatised children and adolescents - Speakers from several countries dealt with the kinds of extreme experiences which can cause their trauma – What are their symptoms? What is the impact on their community and on society as a whole?
Editors’ note: Issues raised in the discussion following the presentations have been incorporated into the texts
This page intentionally left blank
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
15
1. Education under Continuous Violent Conflict Sara OZACKY-LAZAR, PhD. Academic Director, The Jewish-Arab Center for Peace, Givat Haviva, Israel In Israel, the official school system hardly deals with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the way to cope with it. - Over the years, grassroots organizations and NGOs have developed various philosophies and methodologies to cope with the violent war-like reality. The oldest organization in this field is The Jewish-Arab Center for Peace at Givat Haviva, located at the heart of Wadi ‘Ara region. The area is characterized by its mosaic of population where Jews and Palestinians live side by side. - The Center integrates projects of instruction, education, research, and community involvement among diverse populations in Israel and Palestine. It helps design programs to different target groups and audiences. Its Department of Education runs programs for teachers, students, and trainers. Moreover, it develops creative techniques in an effort to highlight some key concepts: equality, tolerance, and acceptance of “the other.” Knowledge and information are essential, as well as creating a supportive environment for the children to talk and express their feelings.
In February 2003 Abigail, a 14-year-old girl and Adrian a 13 ½-year-old boy were killed – or murdered as I would say – in a suicide bombing of a bus on their way home from school. These two kids were part of one of our programmes for peace called ‘Children Teaching Children’. This is a project which we have been conducting at the Jewish Arab Center for Peace for the last 15 years. Their high school in Haifa was one of the first schools to try this programme. In Israel we have about 17% Palestinians who citizens of the state, they do not live under the Palestinian authorities or in the occupied territories; they are Arab, most of them Muslim, and some are Christian. One of their schools, paired with a school in Galilee, did not know what to do, how to react to the fact that their two Israeli friends had been killed in a suicide attack by a Palestinian, by someone of their nation, from their own people. A meeting had been planned for the week after the attack. The teachers got together to discuss if they should cancel the meeting. They did not know how the children would react. In the end they postponed it for one week. Two weeks after this traumatic happening, 50 kids got together, about half Jewish Israelis from the same class as Abigail and Adrian and half Palestinian kids. The teachers and the facilitators let go of the encounter. It was not structured – they just let the kids talk, express their feelings as they tried to overcome the trauma. It was very moving. We felt afterwards that this had been the right decision – to bring the kids together, let them mingle, talk together, crying on each others shoulders, drawing and writing letters for Abigail and Adrian – and they decided together to go ahead with the programme and not to stop the meetings, this alternative way of living as citizens in the same state.
16
S. Ozacky-Lazar / Education Under Continuous Violent Conflict
They wanted this new model: “We do not want to be like our fathers and the politicians” – “We want this new model which is Children Teaching Children. We are going to teach each other about ourselves about our culture, our religion, our life.” They invited each other to their homes. A year later in February 2004, Adrian’s father went to the Palestinian school for the first time and he met with the kids and teachers. He told the children how important the project was in the life of his 13-year-old son, and how he, his father, decided that his life’s mission now would be to follow his son’s footsteps and try to change the nature of the relationship between the two communities and the two peoples. This is just one story from many more – not all as tragic - from my personal experience in working in the Jewish Arab Center for Peace. This was the first NGO in Israel – it was in 1963 – to educate young people and adults for a better future, for mutual recognition, mutual respect and for future peace. In the course of 40 years you can imagine many, many changes have occurred – you could say there is never a dull moment in our country. You all see it in your headline news! Also, of course, there have been changes in the perception and the knowledge. But we have not changed one thing – I say “we” but I was not there 40 years ago, of course. The basics and the philosophy of the place can be defined in several ways: 1. Identity Self identity is very important. We try to strengthen and empower the identity of the kids and not just national identity. It is easy to understand the identity problems of Palestinian children in the Israeli state, but what are the identity problems of Israeli children? They are a majority in Israel, but a minority in the Arab world – so who are they? How are they able to cope with Palestinian children on an equal level when everything around them gives a different message? The question of identity is very complex. This is why the subject of identity is so significant and important in Israel, even among Israeli Jews – the religious, the secular, the settlers, the newcomers, different ethnic groups – Jews came from Europe, Eastern Europe, USA, North Africa, Yemen and other Muslim countries. What we try to do in the Jewish Arab Centre for Peace – and it was pioneering work in the 60s and 70s – is to give Palestinian Arabs the space to express themselves – What it is like to be a Palestinian citizen in a Jewish state. It is not a contradiction – Europe has its minority groups – and it will increasingly have to face problems because of the increasing power of Muslim groups. In Israel there is the additional element – the conflict. It is not just Palestinians inside the Jewish state, but outside, on the other side, the enemy – so we try and succeed in the framework of the Centre and this project - to give space and growth to the Palestinian kids to talk about themselves, to speak Arabic in front of their Jewish friends and show that different identities do not necessarily contradict, but is something that can bring moral value and moral richness to Israeli society. As for the identity of the Jewish kids – during these sessions they develop a sense of guilt towards the Palestinians because they find out things they did not know about: the state suppresses them, discriminates against them – so the first thing is they start defending themselves, going right back into Jewish history - and the Holocaust is everywhere in these discussions: ‘We were oppressed’. So they start arguing who is more victim. The victimisation of society is another topic. In both communities there is a deep sense of being a victim. The facilitators, by giving space, listening, respecting, can lead the kids towards what we think is right – they are equal citizens, despite the differences.
S. Ozacky-Lazar / Education Under Continuous Violent Conflict
17
2. The creation of equal conditions: A supportive environment for the kids is vital, especially when we talk about minority/majority relations of Israel. In Israel, of course, the Jews are the majority and the Arab Palestinians are the minority, but as we say, only half joking, “The Jews always feel as a minority”. Psychologically the Jews feel as though they are a minority and the Arabs psychologically feel they are the majority. This has to do with the historical and psychological background of the two communities but at the Center we try to create equal conditions, chairs in a circle and the children behaving together as equals. 3. Mutual respect: Respect for each others language is a very important thing in Israel, because the Arabs study Hebrew and speak Hebrew, but this is their second language. Most of the Jewish people do not study Arabic and they do not want to learn it – I am an Arabic teacher, so I know what I am talking about. They see it as the language of the enemy and even feel it is not legitimate to speak Arabic in public. People are afraid – if someone speaks Arabic behind you, immediately you think he is a terrorist. So we focus on legitimising the Arabic language. Of course they speak their language and practice their religion. The children teach each other about this. 4. Participation In this project and others, the children decide for themselves what they want to talk about, what they want to discuss, how they want to present their culture and background – not, as teachers, educators, facilitators tend to do, an imposed curriculum, their own methodology. I am not a psychologist; I do not see myself as someone who can treat an individual who has been through trauma. I would say the whole society in Israel is a traumatised society, as is the Palestinian society. There is recent research done in Israel, showing – which will be no news to you as mental health professionals - that sometimes trauma can be a trigger for empowerment and growth. This is in effect what we are trying to do. We take the situation, the reality as it is. We cannot change it right now. We try with the children to build ways of coping with this reality, to cope with the conflict and also give them the opportunity to express their ideas and their ways to resolve the conflict. Even if the conflict is not resolved – for the last 40 years, the conflict has not be resolved despite all sorts of efforts and initiatives – you know, every year there is a new peace initiative, which fails. So, even if the conflict is not resolved, we try to give the children the opportunity to grow despite the conflict and use the context of the conflict for their personal growth. For example, let them have hope and dreams, and also be engaged in an alternative project. Children Teaching Children is one project of several we have found to be effective in helping children cope with the trauma of living under continuous conflict. Face to Face is another project – meeting face to face with the enemy, so to speak, with the other side. Learning that the others side are human beings like themselves. They have the same dreams, eat the same food, wear the same clothes, like the same music and superstars. By experiencing this, they understand that the other side are like them and they have the opportunity to express themselves to the other side.
18
S. Ozacky-Lazar / Education Under Continuous Violent Conflict
From these two projects Children Teaching Children and Face to Face, we have developed another programme to empower the natural leaders amongst the children. We have in Israel what we call ‘Student Councils’, as in many other countries. These are made up of children elected by their friends to be the leaders of the school. So we have developed a special programme for these kids – for Israeli Jews and Palestinians to empower them, to train them and give them special skills as leaders and to work together. Another programme was developed 10 years ago. After working so many years with hundreds and thousands of kids, we decided to focus more on the teachers. Partly because of the budget and material problems and partly because of the mere fact one teacher meets in his or her career, thousands of kids. If we change the mentality of the teachers, hopefully we can change the kids’. So we have a programme called ‘Teachers Lounges’ – we work with the entire teaching staff of the schools: Arab schools paired with a Jewish school, to work together to develop methods, text books, techniques and projects for the kids. We have many projects, but to mention just two more - we have an Arts Centre where the kids create art together – There is a photography project, a beautiful project called ‘Through Others Eyes’, where kids form both communities are trained to be photographers and then they go and take pictures in each others houses and communities. Then they put together an exhibit. Sometimes we give the kids the task of first taking a picture of their own home, then invite the friend from the other community and let them take photos of it. It is interesting for them to see what he or she is focusing on. It is really interesting to compare what a kid thinks is important and worth photographing in his own home and what the guest from the other culture decides to photograph. Another successful initiative we did was a poem contest: ‘Children Write for Peace’. We did it with the local radio station and the kids were asked to write in Hebrew and in Arabic. There was a contest and the kids were invited to the radio studio to read their own poems. We put together a book in Arabic, English, German and Hebrew of selected poems. The two kids who won the contest were received by the President of the State and had a lot of media coverage. Good news for a change – not headline news, but it was very popular. In conclusion, I would like to read you one of the poems - it was very hard to choose – all the poems are very emotional and touching. A 13-year old girl, who is an Arab Druze wrote the poem in Arabic – here it is in English:
Peace: Yesterday I dreamed a dream That I was the queen of a great, broad land But in the morning when I woke, I was just a little girl Without a kingdom and a crown. Then I thought: Is peace just a dream Which can never be for real, for which we only hope, In which we must believe? Is it not possible To wake up one morning to a better world,
A world without war and hatred, Without enemies lying in wait around the corner? I really believe it can be so, That there is room for both Jews and Arabs, That both peoples move peacefully together, Like an king and a queen in their palace. Perhaps it’s only a small, foolish dream Of a girl not versed in worldly ways, But maybe from dreams like these We can build, not make believe real peace.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
19
2. Brutalisation of Young Conscripts in the Russian Federation and the Long-term Effects Anna IGNATIEVA Public Relations Officer and Information Technology Specialist Union of the Committees of Soldiers’ Mothers of Russia Moscow Russian Federation Brutal practices in the armed forces of the Russian Federation – suspension of human rights; poor living and working conditions, including deprivation of food and warmth; beatings; humiliations; torture; abuse – cause mental health damage to military personnel. Those most profoundly affected are the young conscripts, often straight from school who suffer this inhuman treatment for 2 years and then are released back into society with no vocational training, their sense of right and wrong destroyed and often suffering from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. The authorities offer them no help to recover and settle into civilian life. In their desperation and traumatised state, they too often turn to criminality, drug abuse, even suicide. The Union of the Committees of Soldiers’ Mothers of Russia is the only organisation seeking practical ways to make the authorities acknowledge this situation, demanding military reform and the abolition of enforced conscription. However, those in power, too, have been through the military system and themselves show symptoms of the same mental damage. Justice for those who have suffered this mistreatment is a powerful tool in helping conscripts recover and their parents cope with their son’s aberrant behaviour.
The Union of the Committees of Soldiers’ Mothers of Russia began its human rights work in 1989 in the time of the Soviet Union. Now it is the biggest female human rights organisation in Russia. One of our main focuses is human rights abuses connected with conscription – obligatory military service. 18-year-olds are deprived of their most basic human rights for two years. They are obliged to obey commands - or risk criminal charges. They cannot vote in elections. They cannot refuse to go to war or take part in the so-called ‘anti-terrorist’ action in Chechnya. There is the question “Are 18-year-old men children?” When our sons go into the military conscription they have just left school or university – we have brought them up too soft – they are not prepared for the reality of military service. So young lads at the age of 18 are children who need protection from the pressure – in military service they must obey every order otherwise they are punished; their human nature is broken; they cannot be a real human being when they grow up. Because of conscription, all men were damaged young by this military machine – and only women escaped the system and so want to help our men. Human rights’ organisations like the Soldiers’ Mothers have to protect their rights – this is a women’s organisation not protecting their own rights, but women protecting the rights of the men of our country! Every year the UCSMR office in Moscow registers approximately 4000 individual and 3000 written primary complaints. About 60 percent of complaints received by the UCSMR concern violations of human rights for life and human dignity. They include
20 A. Ignatieva / Brutalisation of Young Conscripts in the Russian Federation and the Long-Term Effects
beating, humiliations, tortures and other crimes. Around 20 percent of human rights violations’ complaints concern health and living conditions. Since 1989 every Monday the UCSMR holds Human Rights school for draftees and their parents. On average 200-300 people attend the courses in the school every week. In September 1998, the Committee called for the immediate abolition of involuntary conscription. The UCSMR demands military reform based on the establishing of professional military service From the start, the UCSMR was confronted with the problem of veterans returning from the Afghan War – these veterans, including those disabled in the conflict, were receiving no help from the authorities, neither vocational nor psychiatric. They were deprived of all their basic privileges. The Soldiers’ Mothers demanded that the State fulfil its responsibility towards these men, as was agreed and implemented after the Second World War. When we started our activities there was no connection between civil society and the authorities. Moreover, there was no civil society in Russia. The UCSMR has built up a system of mutual relations with authority and have forced the authorities to work with us in the legal field. We work with the President’s administration and regional authorities, with legislatures both on regional and at a federal level, military authorities, military justice, including military courts and Military Prosecutor. Currently every week the representative of the Military Prosecutor (whose duty is to observe the law) is on duty in our office to solve matters concerning Human Rights violations of draftees, soldiers and their parents. Achieving justice has a positive impact on the way they cope with their trauma. Now we are faced with a situation far worse than after the Afghan War. For 9 years our State has been waging war on its own territory, against our own citizens – the people of Chechnya. Our children – our young conscripts – are mutilated physically, morally and mentally in this war. They face death, injury, loss, brutal treatment, brainwashing and punishment outside the legal system. Young soldiers return home with this kind of experience. In the middle of the 1980s a new phenomenon was noticed in our country for the first time – organised criminal activity. The veterans of the Afghan war were the reason. Young men, conscripted at the age of 18, straight from school, suffer these two years of inhuman military service and then are released back into civilian society. It is very difficult for them to adapt. All they know is brutality and aggression. They have no experience of normal adult civilian life, no vocational training, working experience or profession. It is very difficult for them to find a job, because employers do not want to employ anyone who has been in the military and served in ‘hot’ places – they do not want to risk the problems, such as their spontaneous aggression and unpredictability – their mental state caused by their traumatic experiences and injuries, such as concussion, which have never received medical treatment. All this prevents them being accepted and reintegrated into normal society, which augments their trauma. There is no official programme for training and reinsertion into society after military service. There is no official recognition of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, neither its causes nor consequences. In 1995 the Association of American Veterans made a proposal to our government: the setting up of a special psychological service in Russia for former military personnel – it was refused.
A. Ignatieva / Brutalisation of Young Conscripts in the Russian Federation and the Long-Term Effects 21
At present in Russia there is no State institution to deal with the consequences for military personnel of the Chechen war – the so-called ‘anti-terrorist’ action, the authorities ignore those illegally interned, such as conscientious objectors and prisoners of war – in contravention of international law. For this reason the Soldiers’ Mothers’ organisation focuses on the consequences of the Chechen War, by seeking to enforce legislation in favour of these prisoners, and in providing medical, social and psychological support for soldiers. But we meet resistance – in the summer of 1999 the Soldiers’ Mothers wanted to open their own rehabilitation centre in Sochi on the Black Sea, but the local government refused to grant planning permission. Despite this we did open a camp for this work – but the local government requisitioned it for other activities. Even according to official data the human rights situation in the armed forces is getting worse, which makes it even more difficult for young conscripts and former soldiers to reintegrate into normal society. Soldiers are dying of hunger, disease, accidents and suicide – every year more than 3,000. But soldiers cannot protect their constitutional rights. Commanders will not report violations of human rights. The soldiers have no possibility of defending their rights in court. The existing system of investigation makes a criminal of tortured, humiliated soldiers, particularly those who have deserted to protect their life and human dignity. The Military Prosecutor’s Office does not carry out objective investigations, even if there is evidence of brutal treatment, which judges describe a merely “officers exceeding their official authority”. The military court gives unconditional punishment to the soldier, but the officer accused of the abuse is left in command of his unit. We have to remember that these officers themselves are victims of the trauma of serving in the Chechen War. The Soldiers’ Mothers’ organisation presented a proposal to the Chief medical Officer of the Ministry of Defence to conduct medical tests and to provide psychological support for these officers. What was his response? Offended and angry, he screamed that the officers are “healthy” – and he ran away. We see this behaviour as a symptom of PTSD – and I think this is proved by the fact that he is an Afghan veteran! Even apart from military action, the injuries sustained during military service can be unfavourably compared with those suffered by survivors of natural disasters, torture, and abuse. In our country every year 400,000 people are drafted into military service. Each one of them, to a greater or lesser extent, suffers the after-effects of the abuse by officers and fellow soldiers which I have described. I shall give you one specific example. A crime occurred in December 2003 – it was a crime, not an accident. More than 70 soldiers were frozen on the way to military service. They were made to stand in the open without warm clothing in 30 degrees of frost – several died and all the rest were badly injured. How did we discover that this had happened? Not through official sources, but because a nurse working in the hospital where the injured were taken called the parents of these young guys to tell them their son was in hospital. The parents of one of them called our Moscow office to ask for advice. We contacted journalists and TV stations – and the incident was publicised. The State authorities cover up this kind of incident.
22 A. Ignatieva / Brutalisation of Young Conscripts in the Russian Federation and the Long-Term Effects
So this is just one example of the brutal mistreatment of young conscripts. After two years they are ejected and forgotten. Once they are back home they fall into criminality and drug addiction, and often become tramps or commit suicide. In the Russian Federation the causes of this behaviour is not acknowledged and there are insufficient mental health professionals. The only organisation which works with military reform and which works on soldiers’ human rights in the armed forces is the Soldiers’ Mothers organisation – we are the only specialists in soldiers’ rights. This is the reality unfortunately – several organisations speculate on military reform, but they do not deal with the real situation – they announce a programme – all very academic – but they do not want to work with soldiers, they do not want to know the real situation and they do not want to work with us! This situation will get worse – the war in Chechnya continues. President Putin does not want to abolish conscription. Using the expansion of NATO as an excuse, conscription is being increased. This is leading to more and more young men – our children – suffering from PTSD and its consequences which diminish our society. What kind of society will we have in the future?
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
23
3. Terrorism in Algeria – The Impact on Children and Adolescents Senator Saïda BENHABYLES President of the International Federation of Victims of Terrorism Algeria
In Algeria, children and adolescents are surrounded by terrorism and are targets of terrorism. These children have witnessed and escaped collective massacres. Schoolgirls have been killed because they were not wearing the chador or headscarf. We have seen the assassination of their teachers who refused to accept the ‘diktats’ of the terrorists. The children are also victims of the Fatwa, the religious authorisation which allows the massacre of a section of the population. The terrorist Muslim extremists declare this Fatwa which permits and incites the murder of babies, children, and adolescents so that they will not grow up in a society which the fundamentalists judge impious. School massacres have become commonplace, and terrorists have even been known to throw babies into ovens. Females, from little girls to women, must suffer the worst form of terrorism: rape. Rape is also authorised by the Fatwa which defines rape as a ‘pure act,’ a ‘marriage of pleasure’. These collective rapes are just the start of the most terrible suffering. If the females’ throats are not slit, the women and adolescents may become pregnant and subsequently rejected by society. In addition to the moral and physical abuse they have suffered, their own family insults and rejects them, which causes them to fall prey to depression, drug abuse, prostitution, and suicide. Children of the terrorists are victims of their fathers’ behaviour. Brought up in this atmosphere of violence, these children are far from thinking there is anything wrong with their father’s actions; rather, the children accept the actions as commonplace, and take them as a models for the future. The government is attempting reconciliation within society, but leaves these bad fathers unpunished. This political behaviour is very psychologically damaging for a child who sees the man who killed his or her family swaggering about the streets escorted by an official bodyguard. Recently, I asked a plumber to deal with a water leak. After we talked for a while, he said: “I know you – You’re the woman who helps families who have been victims of terrorism. I’m 18 now, but when I was 14 my father was killed right in front of me. Today the killer walks free with an official bodyguard and lives in a home provided by the State – but I’ve got nowhere to lay my head.” There is, therefore, total incomprehension on the part of these young witnesses. Our association fears that they are starting to have feelings of revenge. There is concern that they, too, will be become violent in adulthood due to feelings of revenge and hatred. We are concerned less with the consequences than with the problem of the violence. That is why
24
S.S. Benhabyles / Terrorism in Algeria – The Impact on Children and Adolescents
our association’s policy consists of exerting pressure on the government so that they do not encourage a policy of impunity. Please forgive my frankness, but I do not understand why we never hear from Palestinian victims in international conferences on terrorism. I was invited to an official conference in Spain – and I was astonished to see Israeli victims of terrorism represented – but no Palestinians. . Our Israeli friend, Dr Ozacky, described in her presentation the meeting between an Israeli father, who had lost his son in a Palestinian suicide attack, and a Palestinian child who did not understand why his son, her friend, was dead. I would have liked to know what would have been the reaction of an Israeli child to the Palestinian boy who has just had his hand crushed by Israeli soldiers. Inclusion is vital – we must not continue to allow exclusion. As far as I am concerned, exclusion is a form of terrorism As to the question of the coping mechanisms needed when dealing with children who have been the witness or subject of violence, I understand that there are two levels of dealing with the subject of violence and trauma: 1. information – the intellectual level 2. feelings – the emotional level It touches the basic human subjects of destruction and creation. Children are exposed to extremes of violence which deny them their existence, their integrity, their respect for their existence. How can one maintain a positive outlook and productivity – the children, the parents and the professionals? In Algeria there are two camps: those who want to plunge Algeria back into medieval obscurantism through terrorism and the rest of the population who resist the fundamentalists. We cope by drawing on sheer will-power and our determination so that the positive is not obscured. Each time you leave home you do not know if you will ever return – this is a constant fear, but strength of will does overcome fear and help us remain positive, everyone in their own sphere – children, teachers, psychologists – we are all afraid. But here is a concrete example: In 1997 the fundamentalists decreed a ‘white year’ – no education at all, no schools, no universities. Armed Islamists condemned to death school children, students, teachers to enforce their no education policy. But even after the mass killings in schools, pupils returned. Despite hands cut off, 825 schools and universities burnt down, school children, students and teachers assassinated, they went back to school – this is the triumph of will over fear, the desire for democracy over the negative obscurantism of the terrorists. You must realize that the people opposing the terrorist are not just the intellectuals, the politically aware, people seeking democracy – but also illiterate peasant women, the unemployed, young lads – it is everyone with one aim – to struggle against terrorism. This strength, this will-power has overcome the negative and transformed it into something positive.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
25
4. Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments Latéfa BELAROUCI M.D., PhD. Sidi M’Hamed Health Department, Algeria; Algerian Red Crescent Terrorism in Algeria aims principally at the destruction of the individual. In effect, however, the atrocities that are being committed target the entire community, because through the individual, the whole population lives in terror. This climate of terror is exacerbated by the fact that the assassinations and massacres are collective. Thus we are seeing the destruction of community ties, because of the assassinations, the destruction of homes, and the destruction of schools – places that symbolically represent a community. Their destruction means the destruction of the reference points that allow an individual to situate himself or herself in society.
Terrorism: attack on ties and confidence Terrorism targets the very fabric of society, particularly through the rape of women and girls. In the Arabo-muslim culture, the honour of the family and the community is enshrined in a woman’s body. An attack on the integrity of her body leads to the destruction of the family’s honour and ties of belonging and affiliation to the community. The terrorism is an attack on the community whose identity is destroyed and which must now bear the shame. Due to the fact that terrorism targets social ties and structures, communities are at risk of being unable to fulfil their usual role: being adaptive and providing for its members support and comfort. In effect, the climate of terror engenders a loss of confidence in oneself, in others, in the institutions and in the representatives of the State. This leads to a loss of perspective for the future and a generalised mistrust which weakens society as a whole. The psychological trauma caused by this violence originates in a brutal confrontation not only with death, but also with things that are unthinkable. Psychological trauma is therefore a result of the breakdown of ties with the world. It stems from exposure to a traumatic event of which the person was a victim or in which the person feared he or she was going to die or be seriously wounded, or in which he or she saw other people killed or injured. This is why so many families are affected by the violence and insecurity in which we have been living for over ten years in Algeria. This goes on to weaken the integrity of social groupings, particularly children and adolescents. In effect it is society as a whole that is the target of terrorism, because its impact is psychological. Furthermore, terrorism in Algeria is deliberate and intentional in nature – and it has been repetitive and ongoing for many years. The prime aims of terrorism are to physically destroy and psychologically annihilate because terrorist activities are aimed less at the victims than at the survivors. Faced with an intentional traumatic incident, the individual is hurt not only in his or her biological and psychological being, but also in his sense of
26
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
belonging to a sociocultural grouping. Also, if the social body is attacked and the individual has experienced trauma, then the problem is both on an individual and community level. A June 1999 study by the National Institute of Public Health analyzed the 348 children who had survived a collective massacre in their village 18 months earlier. The results were revealing: 94.4% talk about this experience. Amongst the traumatic incidents experienced by these children, 84.5% talk about the massacre, and 83.9% talk about friends or neighbours who were assassinated. Clinical indicators noted include: 69.8% experience flashbacks, 66.7% nightmares, 57.5% sleeping disorders, 51.1% difficulties with concentration, 73.9% - are easily startled. All of these are danger signs. The majority of the children began experiencing these effects in the first 6 months after the traumatic events. It is worth noting that 53.2% of the children had the feeling that the aggressors would return. These few facts show very well the distress of these children a year and half after the massacre. Moreover, this region is well known for having suffered several assassinations well before the massacre and to some extent since. While it was hard for these children to talk about their problems, their drawings speak volumes about the horror they experienced. Through their drawings, the children let us see and hear the all the horror of terrorist violence. This set of drawings reveals to us the persistence of the traumatising experience: violence that has not been exorcised, negative images, mourning that never took place. Their artwork does not consist of static images. Instead, it is more like snapshots of their psyche, of their inner turmoil, through dramatic scenes, aggressive people, and use of the colour red. Everything points to the existence of definite anxiety. These pictures are in effect raw, brutal documents of a thought process that is not masked by perspective or dissembling. Violence is depicted as it is. No one would doubt that these children are traumatised – violence and death appear in vivid detail. These pictures tell us about destruction and death, pain and suffering, and about unanswered questions. The children are the silent witnesses to barbarity. They remind us forcefully of the murdering madness of adults.
The traumatic effects are issues of generation and identity We pay particular attention to children, as they are especially vulnerable to the excessive violence being perpetrated around us: pillage, rape, arson, collective assassinations, and the destruction of homes and schools. In this situation, a child loses all of his or her points of reference since he or she is confronted by the breakdown of all he or she holds dear. In the case of collective assassinations, where the child has had to face death, there is the breakdown of the community. This means social breakdown since all social ties are broken, breakdown of the integrity of the human body when the child sees physical injuries, and spatial breakdown when houses are destroyed. For these children, adults are either murderous or powerless. It is these adults who are responsible for their pain and suffering. The adult world in which they believed and the laws that regulate it have been found lacking - powerless to stop the massacre. Furthermore, it is adults who have committed the atrocities. The child is thus forced to revise and take a new look at adult behaviour and attitudes. A desire for revenge is not far away. Therefore, we see uncharacteristic aggressiveness, and destructive behaviour – or on the contrary, extreme inhibition. Because their most basic beliefs have been deeply shattered, these children display serious personality changes. As the child develops, we see not only its basic personality modified
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
27
by the trauma, but also, in the words of L. Bailly, “when the event implies an attack on law, a child’s socialisation is put at risk. They discover human barbarity - committed by adults who should be protecting them. This discovery is profoundly traumatising. Terrorist violence thus introduces a cleavage in affiliation ties. In effect, belief in strong, powerful parents is fundamental for a child so that it can have faith not only in itself and its own abilities, but also so that it can build trusting relationships with other people and thus feel safe.” How are these children to build their identity? With which parental role model can they identify? How can a child build his or her identity when the only models are either an aggressor acting outside the law or a parent who is a victim, overcome by the aggression and unable to defend himself or herself and his or her family? When it is a choice between a violent dominating person or a weak person who has lost his or her dignity? Parents are dispossessed of their ability to be protectors since they let the horror take place. What is the basic question these children ask? Which law applies? The law imposed for many long years by the fundamentalists – their law which has deprived the children of their most basic rights –the right to education, the right to life itself...? It is true that the fundamentalists are in power, that they are the strongest – but does that make them the most just? Or what about the other law? Which law? The one that was found lacking? The one that let the terrorists get them? The law that is giving an amnesty to the assassins? These questions affect not only those children who were victims of terrorism, but also those whose parents are terrorists – except that for the latter the problem is much more complicated, and they are in an ambiguous position, with the stain of shame and the risk of social exclusion.
Which mechanisms for adapting are they going to develop in order to find a place in society? Having been present at scenes of violence, above all if they are repeated and committed by adults, can lead to profound changes in a child’s perception of his or her own safety and the safety of his or her emotional relationships. Additionally, the children will have difficulty in confronting the concept of the future. They will not make plans for the future, unlike children who have not experienced traumatic events. But we do see some who, after treatment, choose a career which we could call reparative, such as medicine, psychology, engineering, or mechanics. That applies to children who were victims of terrorism. What about those others – the ones whose parents were terrorists? Often they have no choice but to bear the burden of the place assigned to them by the family group or by society. The problem is even more accentuated for the children of those who have disappeared because they cannot mourn. The disappearance leaves a gaping hole in their lives around which settles pain, suffering, and above all, silence, because the label ‘disappeared’ implies ‘terrorist’ – someone who is guilty. These children live in an environment where there is no choice but secrecy, silence, things unsaid, and unanswered questions. Members of the family are torn between pride and shame that one of theirs is involved. How are these children going to develop with this label? How are they going to find their identity? With which paternal role model will they identify? This father is simultaneously called a hero, a martyr, an assassin, and a murderer. What adaptive
28
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
mechanisms are the children to develop in order to find their a place in the community, a place in society? Where do they fit in? In such a context, a child loses all points of reference – inner and external. The consequences resulting are mistrust, a feeling of insecurity, a loss of self-esteem, a general feeling of confusion, and most of all, a deep problem of identity.
The quest for meaning Children do not ask who did the killing. They know and call them ‘the cut-throats’. On the other hand, they often ask us this question: Why did they do it? No matter how old they are, they are trying to find a meaning. Finding the meaning of a traumatic event is part of therapy, but how can we give meaning to something which has no sense? What meaning can a psychologist give when the authorities not only do not give a meaning to the situation, but also show they are in denial when they say terrorism is over while the massacres are continuing? When they claim that “the terrorists are fools, mercenaries, definitely not Muslims,” while at the same time the terrorists use Islam to justify their actions? There is no worse aggression than something that does not make sense. Furthermore, the authorities themselves are guilty of violence – rejection of the needs of others, denial, attempts to make people forget, and the amnesty for terrorists – these are all violations. In the same way, forgetting and not recognising the facts reinforce suffering, worsen turmoil, foster hatred and lead to a revenge mindset.
Trauma Management The different mental health programmes proposed in conflict and/or post-conflict situations have three characteristics: - Importance given to post-traumatic syndrome - Aim of the public health system to prevent trauma based on epidemiological facts - Predominance of the individual therapy approach, such as support, counselling, debriefing... In effect these classic approaches to trauma all rely on an individual therapeutic model – and because of that they are all sure to fail. Why? A traumatic experience linked to a conflict situation or terrorist violence includes the breakdown of family, community and social ties which occur alongside the psychological disturbance. When intentional, repeated and collective destruction reaches the intensity, the seriousness and complexity that it has in our country, bandaging the wounds is just not enough. We must, therefore, find other kinds of approaches to the psycho-trauma in order for a procedure to have any chance of success. The procedure that seems the most suitable to this type of situation is one which allows collective treatment. We have to consider the individual in the global context of his or her relationships with society. This procedure should allow one to confront the traumatic events collectively. It aims above all at removing each victim from the spiral of despair and the inescapable nature of the trauma. Using a community approach makes it possible to avoid victims being too deeply stigmatised, since other factors intervene after conflict. These factors include: - financial difficulties
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
29
- social break-up due to separations, disappearances... - material and emotional losses - danger to oneself and to others - displacement, emigration, exile.... - uncertainty about the future In effect, the community approach can restore ties, community spaces, and social functioning. To paraphrase J. M. Lemaire:” if we consider that direct attacks on cultural, national, political and family ties are the focus of intentional destruction, we should also envisage that it is precisely these ties which should become the place where therapy can work. In this perspective, treating should not be limited to mental health professionals. The background, the social environment of the child, and family influence the psychosocial response to psychological disorders and recovery. A network of community help is fundamental for protecting children and meeting their needs. The active support of parents, neighbours, friends, religious leaders, medical authorities, teachers, social workers – plays a dynamic role in psychosocial well-being and in the resolutions of trauma.” Therefore, we can say that the psychological effects of trauma are very complex problems where the dimensions of subjectivity and social ties must be taken into account. The only potentially successful approaches in restoring meaning to the life of traumatised children are psychosocial and socio-political. Managing trauma, particularly when it is linked to armed conflict and terrorism, requires official recognition of the facts. Recognition by the relevant authorities of the violence and injustice suffered is a fundamental part of psychological recovery. If the evil is named, if the aggressors are brought to justice, if the prejudices suffered are recognised for what they are, then this will allow the ”community to rebuild its psychosocial points of reference and will avoid the spirit of revenge which leads to the violence being repeated.” Therefore, first the social and legal aspects must be dealt with before we begin psychological treatment. But how can we reform the justice system to admit the transgression and reestablish the rule of law? Verbalising and recognising the collective trauma and working on a collective memory are ways of allowing people to mourn. Children know this and they have started working through their memories in their drawings, songs and writings. Furthermore, a problem that confronts us currently and with which we must deal urgently is domestic violence. It is becoming more prevalent – and the ones that suffer are the children. What can we do to stop the culture of hatred and exclusion so that our children can know peace? Our duty as adults is to ensure that ‘culture of peace’ and ‘tolerance’ are not empty words. The child victims of violence call to us through their pictures, their poems, and even through silence. We do not have the right to remain silent – we must answer their questions. We have to find the words to help them – if we do not, they will develop pathologies which will lead them to their deaths.
Limits of clinical procedures Being a therapist who continually works with those who have suffered traumatic events is difficult because we have to accept things that we find morally offensive, to imagine things that are impossible to imagine, and to run the risk of being traumatised ourselves.
30
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
Many therapists find it difficult to work with children of terrorists or with terrorists themselves. You develop defence mechanisms, such as, for example, not asking about the circumstances in which the parent or parents died. The biggest difficulty is that you are immediately and emotionally involved because you are living through the same conflict situation as your patients. What makes us responders, then? It is being a professional, in touch with one’s emotions, and capable of knowing oneself, so that one can recognise in oneself something of the other person and recognise the other person, having the desire to put things right, to support. Also the emotions which the therapists feel must not be rejected. On the contrary, the emotions are an actual part of the work, as long as they are experienced as a developmental part of the therapy. This is why the framework, the plan of action, and a third party are so important in thinking through the psychological care which is essential to the inter- and intrapersonal restoration. In the same way as his or her patients, the therapist also has the experiences of pain and solitude. Very often he or she is alone, confronting the suffering of others. This isolation is difficult to communicate. For that reason, the therapist is tempted to say nothing. At the same time, his or her position makes him or her a witness under obligation to his or her patients. Furthermore, his or her position is uncomfortable because he or she has not only to bandage psychological injuries, but at the same time he or she has to think of the impact of his or her actions and treatment on the victims. The first obstacle which confronts the therapist relies on continually proving objectivity and neutrality in a context where the victim wants him or her to be subjective, where there are gaping wounds, and where there are many unanswered questions. Understandably, it is not rare for those who treat traumatised children to be beset by feelings of revolt in the face of atrocity, injustice, and abandonment. All therapists want to do something, want to bring their help and support to alleviate suffering. It is just like Francis Scott Fitzgerald says, “One has to understand that things are hopeless, but nevertheless decide to change them.” Seemingly hopeless barriers are often components of extreme situations like terrorism. However, our aim as therapists is to bring about a meaningful change. This necessitates a great deal of time and patience. What makes our task more difficult lies in the fact that we are working with children – and working with children is hard work because it requires us to be very energetic and active.
Why think? As underscored by F. Maqueda, it is precisely because “it is thought which is attacked in these situations where violence is overflowing with a cruelty which targets before physical death, a symbolic and social death. Coping with this is a difficult task as the therapists themselves are victims of stress, tensions, uncertainty, the difficulty of thinking and thinking through their own role. In effect as a result of rubbing shoulders with horror, the therapists reach the point where they cannot face the horror of thinking, engage in physical activity to avoid thinking, or limit themselves to their own certainties, procedures and techniques.” This is where the therapist
L. Belarouci / Terrorist Violence: Attack on Community Attachments
31
must use to good account his or her knowledge of the processes of individual and social change in order to effect the emergence of changes which make sense. This is possible through listening to, talking to, and focusing on the other person in distress in order to help the victim find his or her own place. For all those therapists who deal with children I offer these few lines of poetry: You say that it’s tiring to be with children. You’re right. You add because you have to get down to their level, crouch down, Stoop, bend over, and make yourself small. Well you’re wrong. That’s not what tires you out most. It’s rather the fact of being obliged to raise yourself up to the heights of their feelings To strain upwards, reach up, stretch up on tip-toe To avoid hurting them. Janusz Korczak, 1942 References Aiguesvives C. Situations de crise : prévention en santé mentale infantile, quels modèles. Anzieu A. Barbey L., Bernard-Nez J. Daymas S. Le travil du dessin en psychothérapie. Ed. Dunod, Paris, 1996. Baqué S. Jours après nuit. Voyage dans le dessin des enfants rwandais rescapés du génocide. Fondation Tumrere. Bailly L. et coll. Conséquences pour les enfants des crises familiales graces ou des événements traumatiques. In Nouveau traité de psychiatrie de l’enfants et de l’adolescent. P.2793-2805 Dubois V et coll. Catastrophes causées par l’homme : importance des programmes de santé mentale communautaire. In Méd. Catastrophes Urg. Collectives, 1999,2,106-110 Jacquet F. Séminaire « Approche communautaire, santé mentale et prévention », novembre 2000 Maqueda F. Carnets d’un psy dans l’humanitaire. Paysage de l’autre. Collection des Travaux et de Jours. Ed. Eres
32
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
5. Group Therapy with Traumatized Children in the Chechen Refugees Camps Khapta AKHMEDOVA, M.D., PhD Institute of Psychology Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow Research Institute of Psychiatry, Russian Ministry of Health, Grozny, Chechnya
The tent camps for Chechen refugees in Ingoushetia were opened in 1999 and are now closing. During my four years of experience working with children’s and adolescents’ psychological well being in two of these camps, I had some interesting experiences. The first time, we carried out or work in the open groups. The open group included about 20-25 children. There was one group for children and another group for adolescents. Two psychologists worked with every group, which included many children who had been in active war zones immediately before their arrival at the camps. The children had acute stress reactions and needed help. Unfortunately, our team included only five psychologists and one psychiatrist, and we did not have the time for the individual investigation of every child. In the open group, we observed many children simultaneously and selected which children had symptoms of psychotrauma. Moreover, many children had tics and enuresis, signs of PTSD in children, and these symptoms first appeared during the course of the traumatic events. We also observed aggressive and elevated risk-taking behaviours in adolescents following traumatic exposure. We formed closed groups for those children and adolescents who had symptoms of PTSD and other disorders. In these groups, we used play therapy. The group therapeutic process included approximately sixteen meetings over two months. The traumatized children demonstrated repetitive, destructive, or interrupted playing. The playing showed that the children relived the trauma over and over because their styles of plays showed that the children could not surmount their feelings. When children seemed particularly frustrated, the psychologist would join the play and positively redirect it. Step by step, children learned to surmount their traumatic feelings not only in the play, but also in their everyday lives as well. We reached the positive changes of the children’s mental state in about 65% of children who completed the full two month schedule of meetings. The positive changes were somewhat dependent on several factors. First was the regular participation in the meetings. Second, family support, and particularly parental support, was also important. However, many troubled children’s families were also traumatized. When children left the group, they returned to their similarly troubled families, and it negatively influenced their progress. Therefore, we also began therapies for traumatized family members. One case with traumatized children involved a large family that included nine brothers, one sister, and two parents. They lived in a mountain village, but were separated most of the family came to the refugee camp, but the father remained at home. Over the
K. Akhmedova / Group Therapy with Traumatized Children in the Chechen Refugees Camps
33
first few days of the family’s life in the refugee camp, seven of the boys (from age 6 to age 14) made a security checkpoint near the aqueduct tap. The checkpoint was like an arms checkpoint in Chechnya, and they sat all day in the embankment they had dug. The brothers did not allow refugees to take water without paying for it, but many of the women who needed water did not want to pay. When the women did not comply, the boys began to stone them. When complaints reached the boys’ mother, she forbade her sons to continue their activities. The boys obeyed because she was a strong woman and they were afraid of her, but they soon built a similar checkpoint on the border of a neighbouring camp. The other children of the camps had nicknamed them pirates. We heard about these brothers and talked about them often. I visited their tent and talked with their mother about our centre and invited her sons to it. She did not even know what psychologists do. When I explained our profession to her, though, she agreed to tell her sons to come. The next day, seven brothers came to our tent, bringing two dogs with them. They were armed with sticks and stones, and asked who had invited them to the centre and why. I explained our groups to them, but they refused to be separated into groups by their ages. Instead, they wanted to stay together in one group with their siblings, the dogs, and the weapons. I negotiated with them for about half an hour. We agreed that all brothers could be included in an adolescents group if the dogs and equipment would be kept outside. It would have been inappropriate to separate them since they had been brought together by the trauma they had experienced, and they had to learn how to overcome the trauma together. In the group discussions, they discussed their experiences with war and how they had survived. They spoke of escaping soldiers’ gunfire as well as witnessing others being shot and killed. After our treatment, the boys’ behaviour changed. They did not demonstrate aggression, and actually began to make a business. The built a shop in front of their tent and sold food. They earned money and then constructed a video hall and play area that attracted many children who paid small fees for admission. Later, they bought a motorcycle for making food deliveries, and ultimately showed that they coped with trauma better than many of the adults in their community. In the process, the brothers became independent and each ran his own section of the business while still helping his siblings as well. After the group therapy, we observed their behaviour for two years, and they never repeated their previous negative behaviour. Sometimes, some of them even visited the centre and continued to speak about their feelings and their progress.
34
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
6. Traumatic Stress among Child War Victims and Problems of Rehabilitation in Georgia Dr. M. JISHKARIANI; Dr. V. KENCHADZE; Dr. Z. BERIA Psycho-Rehabilitation Center for Victims of Torture and Org. Violence "Empathy". M. Asatiani Research Institute of Psychiatry; Tbilisi State Med. University, Dep. Psychiatry and Med. Psychology;
In consequence of war conflicts on the territory of Georgia in 1992-1993, 1998 about 300,000 civilians become Internally Displaced Persons. The definition of IDP is widely used by the international organizations – UN etc, but from our opinion, that is question for suggestion: is this definition correct or not, because these persons, civilians are involuntary, forced displaced people. It is something different and is very important for appointment correct ways of rehabilitation. As well as there are amount 3 000 Chechen refugees in Georgia after the military conflicts in Chechnya (Russian federation). The several difficult problems have not only refugees or Internationally Displaced Persons, but the population living inside the military conflict zones, especially illegally repatriated IDPs in Abkhazia (Gali Region) and civilians that stay in this territory during and after military conflicts too. It must be indicated that unfortunately all their problems are unsettled up to now. In our opinion, investigation of the mental health and psycho – social problems in forced migrants is of special interest. In this case a number of etiological factors are involved in the development of post-stress disorders. A number of observations and study programmes were conducted in Georgia during the last 10 year period, among them in children population too. In this presentation we would like to represent some results and conclusions or questions for suggestion of several investigations that were provided in the dynamic. The analysis of the results of new, ongoing programme (by the financial support of the UNVFVT) of the Centre EMPATHY, including observations and medical and psycho – social rehabilitation for IDPs, Illegally repatriated IDPs in Military Conflict zone in Gali region and Refugees from Chechnya – Victims of Torture and their families have included in this presentation as well. First programme of investigation of the psycho – social problems of the children and as well as families involuntary migrants after the Abkhazian war conflict in Georgia was conducted in 1995 – 2 years after of migration. During this study program 400 children from 4 till 16 years old were investigated. The special prepared clinical questionnaire that include the several points (personal history, family psycho – social background, trauma history, character of the medical and psychological aid, psycho – social and physical condition in the dynamic, providing assistance and recommendations for rehabilitation have been included in this clinical card) was used for investigation, as well as the psychological tests: Lusher, PTSD, Hand test and Picture were used too for revealing the psychological problems of children involuntary migrants.
M. Jishkariani et al. / Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims
35
During the study period, we identified several groups of psycho-traumatic factors causing PTSD, having some peculiarities of clinical manifestation and clinical course. 1. War Traumatic Stress Events, being a trigger for the development of the PTSD (Table 1, Program OXFAM/UK/) Table 1. N War Traumatic Stress Events Number of % children 1. Death of family members or close relatives 81 20 2. Being witness of death 82 21 3. Being in the area of bombing or under fire 275 69 4. Being among dead or mutilated wounded people 113 28 5. Being in captivity or hostage 17 4 6. Torture, violence, or being witness of the above 39 10 7. Physical trauma with the CNS disturbances 8 2 8. Home attack or home loss 389 90 9. Being at the occupied territory 10 2 10. Serious problems during evacuation (e.g. crossing mountain 81 20 pass in Svaneti) 11. Evacuation without parents, being unaware of their location 31 8 12. Conflict between family members on the basis of ethnic 3 1 differences
As we can see from the percent ratio in Table 1 there was combination of several traumatic stress events, which indicates intensity of the stress influence. 2. Additional stressors of the war and pre-war period, causing decrease of reactivity and creating the basis for the development of psychosocial disturbances (Table 2). Table 2. a) Additional stressors of war period 1. Starvation and shortage drinking water 2. Deficit of electricity and energy 3. Cold 4. Lack of sleep, insomnia 5. Unemployment b)”Global Changes” of pre-war period
1. Radical political changes in the former Soviet Union 2. Social-economic crisis
Above-mentioned combinations of stress factors caused high incidence of the PTSD symptoms (in 284 out of 400 – 71%, Program OXFAM /UK/). In all sufferers of the PTSD we observed symptoms of “Intrusive/Repetitive Phase” group and “Avoidance/Denial Phase” group of different intensity, depending of the personality features and age of the studied person. Children aged 6 - 11 years were found to be more susceptible to the PTSD. Second point or question for this study was: Is it only PTSD or something combination disorders - TSD?
36
M. Jishkariani et al. / Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims
Symptoms of PTSD superimposed progressive asthenia (problems of the psycho – physical development) and other psychological or stress – related disturbances, caused by the prolongation and unsettlement of the stress situation and also by polymorphism of the etiological factors. Thus, we described stressors of the post-war period, which are decisive for the formation of some clinical features of the PTSD or TSD in children – war victims. These factors were defined as "Radical Social Changes" induced by the forced migration. Taking into consideration these peculiarities, we tried to single out following groups of disorders associated with the symptoms of the PTSD, according to the most typical structuraldynamic manifestations (as we defined Risk Groups for development of the behavioural or adjustment disorders) (Table 5). Table 5. Stress – Related Disorders among Children – War victims PTSD with somatization (with psychogenic enuresis) PTSD with neurotization 1. with teak disorders 2. with Obsessive - Phobic syndrome PTSD with behavioural disorders 1. Hyperkinetic disorders, children with hyperactive behaviour and with a lack of attention and concentration possibilities. 2. Opposite – Provocative brutal reactions Children with a tendency to chronic personality change after the traumatic stress event revealed in Social Grouping reactions PTSD with depressive disorders (prolonged grief reaction)
In 16 p. out of total 284 – 6%
1. In 12 p. out of total 284 – 4% 2. 36 ------------------------13 %
1. 15 – 5 % 2. 27 – 10 %
12 – 7 % (adolescents aged from 13 - 16)
8 – 3%
¾ In the first group (with enuresis) the main stress events were treated to be dead, to be in hostage, being in the captivity, torture, evacuation crossing Svanety Maintains. ¾ In the second group with neurotization the main stressors were the violence and torture of the family, to be under the bombing, death of the family members or parents etc. ¾ In the third group (with behavioural disturbances) were included the children mostly from 4 to 8 years older with severity trauma background in family, as well as secondary traumatized children, with hyper – control attitude from parents side. ¾ In the fourth group (with grouping reactions) were included mostly adolescents with hypo – control from parents side. ¾ Our special interest was fixed on the group with prolonged depression reaction. There were following groups of children included in this group: 1. "Children without mother" from the mix ethnic families. 2. Children those parents were dead during the military conflict (orphans). There were revealed severity problems of the psycho – social adaptation in these contingent that reveals in violation of the contacts, psychogenic autism and isolation, tendencies to be in friendship relations only with persons with same grief (life stress event), lack of interest outside to world, estrangement and feeling of abandonment etc. As well as it would be indicated that in accordance with our
M. Jishkariani et al. / Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims
37
observations the particular trauma, especially for small children, was to leave (deprivation) domestic animals (dogs, cats etc), lovely toys or close relatives – grandmother or grandfather, on the occupied territory during the evacuation. It was reason for sever feelings of guilt, obsessive memories and dreams. Prospective study during 10 years revealed progressive changes of the personality with formation of the "image of enemy", hostility attitude to world and state, aggressive and self – aggressive reactions that become most obvious after the passing of years of involuntary migration. In this aspect it would be indicated that main problem of adaptation reveals in interpersonal relationships, in the difficulties of integration into the new society, intolerance of the contacts. They have close relationships only with IDP population, social actions, celebrations etc they provide only inside this population. Our observations revealed the important role of the mutual induction with the traumatic experiences inside the family in the children's wellbeing. As well as it must be indicated that the phenomenon of the trauma transmission into the generation is very clear too. That's revealed in the generation who was not remembering the war traumas or among the generation who was born after the migration. The same adaptation mechanisms and as well as intolerance in the contacts, close, circle, only refugees' community relations are revealed too. The important negative factor for psycho – social wellbeing of the children is the Collective Living Condition in the refugee's living centres. That causes the fixation of the community members on the war traumatic events and dissemination of the negative memories or feelings among the community and families, created of the close system of relationships and contacts. That caused among children population limitation of the world philosophy and system of values, limitation of their roles in the world and society. Ethnic – cultural factors influence on the psycho – social condition of the children and whole families. We divided the post-war stressors into several groups of ethnic-cultural features: 1. Self-Ethnic-cultural features: age-old traditions – phenomenon of the family house – residence of many generations for centuries. Loss of family house induces Nostalgia Phenomenon, becoming increasingly accentuated while hopes for repatriation fail. Another basic ethnic-cultural aspect is the traditional concern for the welfare of the yang generation with appropriate rituals, which is disturbed as a result of the radical social changes in the life of these people. 2. Deprivation of the religious traditions, associated with the family house and family crypts, interfering with the rituals of burial and rituals of religious feasts. 3. Social-cultural aspects, associated with the loss of social role of personality, as well as with the violation of the social traditions, caused by the change of the natural and climate conditions and alteration of biological rhythm. Above-mentioned ethnic-cultural characteristics play an important role in the complex succession of the etiological factors and cause prolongation and recurrence of the clinical course of the PTSD, alongside with the other stress-related disorders, with predominance and aggravation of the depressive affect. Frequent recurrence, associated with religious and traditional dates is an important ethnic-cultural peculiarity of these disorders in the present area. Mutual induction of traumatic experiences in family members and also in places of migrant’s collective dwelling, incorrect attitude of the society, mass media, and sometimes government officials, toward them also contribute to the recurrent clinical course of the disorder. Lack of a large-scale psychosocial rehabilitation and management actions, poor living conditions, imperfection of the mechanisms of legal protection, as well as public unawareness of those, uncertainty of future, alongside with the above-mentioned stressors,
38
M. Jishkariani et al. / Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims
induce personality disadaptation, tendency to personality transformation and "Refugee" trauma transmission into the generation. Table 6. Stressors of the post-war period
I. a) b) c) d) e) f) g) h)
Radical social changes: Poor living conditions; Shortage of food; Deficit of electricity; Cold; Unemployment; Factor of mutual induction; Lack of medical assistance; Incorrect approach to the problem of refugees.
II. 1) a) b) c)
Ethnic-cultural factors: Ethnic-cultural factors proper: Loss of the traditional house; leaving relatives on the occupied territory; deprivation of the opportunity to concern for the welfare of the next generation; Change of social-cultural traditions; change of climate conditions; Violation of religious-cultural traditions: associated with burial ritual; associated with remembrance of the dead; associated with family house; associated with religious feasts.
2) 3) a) b) c) d) III. IV. V.
Uncertainty of future In case of the Chechnya Refugees language differences and problems of education. In case of uncontrolled military conflict zones civilian population (families) (example Gali region investigations) – Permanent fear and uncertainty waiting of torture and violence
Based on the above, we conclude that the complex combination of a number of etiological factors induce association of PTSD with the other stress-related disorders and result in chronic, recurrent clinical course of these disorders with marked affective liability – episodes of depression or euphoria /as a hyper-compensation/, deterioration of ability to estimate the real situation. Based on the above, we are dealing with a Complex Traumatic Stress Syndrome. Basic phenomenon of which is the affective liability, primary depression with a progressive asthenia and incorrect adaptation, circle "refugee and other world" relations that was increased by the incorrect system of the rehabilitation, especially for children IDP's and refugees population, such are: not having the state, comprehensive, national wide strategy of the children's rehabilitation after the war conflict, limited rehabilitation programs and
M. Jishkariani et al. / Traumatic Stress Among Child War Victims
39
educational yours centres only the refugee's communities, not having the plan of the repatriation of this contingent and protective strategy of their rights. For these reasons the main experiences are the fear of future, caused by its uncertainty, fear of threatening danger, destroy of the values systems and failure of the philosophy of life, the change of the attitude with: “I – another I”, “I – World”, “I – God”. It is important to note that behind these psycho - social manifestations is human being with his individual and collective existence philosophy. From this end the issues of interrelation of dramatic events and human’s mental equilibrium, being on crossroads of psychiatry, philosophy and human rights, become increasingly important. And that must be basis for creation of the correct strategy of the rehabilitation for families’ wellbeing and especially for psycho – social rehabilitation of the children after the war conflicts.
40
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
7. Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration Lilian PETERS, M.A. Middle East and North Africa NGO-network to Stop the Use of Children in Armed Conflict (affiliated to the International Coalition to Stop the Use of Children in Armed Conflict) Why children are recruited as soldiers; Reasons why children may become voluntary recruits; Who does the recruitment; Children who are vulnerable to recruitment; What can prevent underage recruitment; Key points for rehabilitation and reintegration of former child soldiers; A Framework for planning; The three stages of community involvement: Sensitisation Articulation and Reflection -Mobilisation of Resources; Initial steps for planning social reintegration of a former child soldier; Identifying factors which influence social re-integration Implementing programmes of rehabilitation within a therapeutic or medical framework - Issues affecting re-integration of child soldiers
Action for the Rights of Children (ARC) has worked extensively in the field of Child Soldiers and I am basing this paper on their work.1 Basic Principles 1. The factors that influence the participation of children in armed conflict are complex. No single model can either explain all the factors, or outline a uniform procedure that will prevent the recruitment of children, and enable procedures for their demobilization and social reintegration. 2. The recruitment and participation of under-age children in armed conflict constitute an abuse of their rights. 3. The rights perspective of the Convention on the Rights of the Child provides a framework for assessment of the impact of participation on children and informs a response to their situation. 4. Children, including adolescents, most at risk of recruitment in the particular situation, need to be specifically identified and planning needs to be undertaken to prevent their recruitment. 5. Responses to forced recruitment should be based on an understanding of the social, political and cultural factors which gave rise to the conflict. 6. Demobilization is the first step in the child’s return to a normal life and should be accompanied by initiatives to enable social reintegration. 7. Children and adolescents, their families and communities, need to be informed and empowered to enable them to resist recruitment, to effect demobilization and to participate fully in initiatives to secure the social reintegration of former child soldiers. 8. It is important to create an open and accepting environment and let children set the pace of their reintegration and rehabilitation, rather than focus on trauma and its consequences.
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
41
Overview and Definitions While many children fight in the frontline, others are used as spies, messengers, porters, servants and even sexual slaves; children are also often used to lay and clear landmines. The problem is most critical in Africa and Asia, though children are used as soldiers by governments and armed groups in many countries in the Americas, Europe and Middle East. While some children are recruited forcibly, others are driven into armed forces by poverty, alienation, patriotism and discrimination. Many children join armed groups because of their own experience of abuse at the hands of state authorities. The term child soldier has become widely adopted, and will, therefore, be used to cover any person less than 18 years of age who is part of any kind of regular or irregular armed force or armed group in any capacity other than purely as a family member. It does not, therefore, only refer to those carrying arms, but includes cooks, porters, messengers, and those accompanying such groups, including girls recruited as concubines or for forced marriage.1 Recruitment encompasses compulsory, forced and voluntary recruitment into any kind of regular or irregular armed force or armed group. Demobilization means the formal and controlled discharge of child soldiers from the army or from an armed group. The term psycho-social underlines the close relationship between the psychological and social effects of armed conflict, the one type of effect continually influencing the other.
Children who are vulnerable to recruitment It is important to recognize that certain children will be more vulnerable to underage recruitment, whether voluntary or forced. Research has shown that the overwhelming majority of child soldiers, in almost every conflict, are drawn from the poorest, least educated and most marginalized sections of society. Especially those separated from their families or with disrupted family backgrounds, are at risk. In general, children vulnerable to recruitment are: • Children from particular ethnic, racial or religious groups; • Children living in the conflict zones; • Children from unstable or disrupted backgrounds; • Children separated from their families and without the protection that the family can provide to prevent recruitment; • Unaccompanied children who initially became associated with an armed group for protective reasons, but who may progress to active participation; • Former child soldiers.
Why children are recruited Although children may be recruited predominantly because of shortages of adult soldiers, recent research suggests that they are often seen by commanders as having special qualities. Some of the main reasons why children are recruited, in addition to making up
42
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
numbers, have been identified as: easily used in battles; easily manipulated; adventurous; quick to learn fighting skills; no competition for the leadership role; less costly; pose a moral challenge for enemies. The longer a conflict continues the more likely it is that children will be recruited, and in increasing numbers.
How children are recruited, and by whom The manner in which children are recruited ranges from compulsory to voluntary recruitment, although in practice it is hard to ascertain the reality as they often merge into one another. The most distinct category is compulsory recruitment by conscription. This, by its nature, is a governmental prerogative. Many children, however, are conscripted under age. This may happen even where there is a legal minimum age of 18, because: • People are unaware of their rights; • Children lack documentation such as birth or identity records; • Voluntarily enlistment for compulsory conscription is sometimes a convenient loop-hole to mask conscription of children; • Children are caught up in “quota” enlistment which may be carried out by government agents, village headmen, local militias and others who are concerned to make up required numbers of conscripts; • The conscription system is flawed or outright ignored by the military particularly where there is a perceived need for an enlarged force, or the military is targeting certain groups. Forced recruitment is also practiced by armed opposition groups – sometimes justified as a requirement that all members of an ethnic group, for example to join the armed struggle. Armed groups may face shortfalls in numbers of recruits and therefore impose quotas on the populations in the areas under their control. The causes for voluntary recruitment are varied, and a number of factors may operate simultaneously to influence the child’s decision to volunteer. Some children make a positive choice to join, or are encouraged to volunteer by force of circumstance or because the family makes a choice on the child’s behalf.
Reasons for recruitment It is essential to understand how the problem is manifesting itself in a particular community, locality or country. This will include understanding of why and how children are recruited, forcibly or voluntarily, and enable steps to be taken which make such involvement less likely. Some responses require specific actions in the field, others longerterm programs as well as advocacy for changed laws and practices. In all cases, clear understanding is required of the social, cultural or economic reasons that may be contributing to recruitment, particularly when it is on a voluntary basis. However, the nature of how “voluntary” the decision may be depends a great deal on the circumstances. Some factors can be addressed through specific interventions; others require longer-term changes in society and in attitudes.
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
43
Cultural reasons: Participation in military or warlike activities is often glorified, and children are taught to revere military leaders. Value systems that endorse bearing arms as a mark of masculinity may draw or push youngsters into armed opposition groups. Some children may join as a result of peer pressure, particularly in urban areas or garrison towns, for the adventure or to escape boredom. Voluntary recruitment into armed opposition groups is significantly influenced by children's personal experiences of harassment by government armed forces, including torture, loss of home or family members, forced displacement or exile. Ideological Reasons: Some children volunteer for armed opposition groups because they believe in what they are fighting for: a holy war, religious freedom, ethnic or political liberty, a general desire for social justice. The children’s commitment to the opposition cause may have been instilled in them throughout their upbringing and be reinforced by the idealization of a culture of violence. Many may have witnessed abuses against their families or communities. Economic and Social Reasons: The motivation for volunteering may be to find a means of survival or support, particularly where the alternative is unemployment. Family may influence the child’s recruitment, because they need the income, as in some cases the child’s wages are paid to the family, or there are other incentives such as food or the provision of medicines. Economic motivation may be more than for pure survival, as the army may represent the only route to influence, or upward social mobility.
Demobilization and social reintegration The manner in which under-age recruits leave an army or armed group is varied, including: • They may escape from situations of abduction; • They may be spontaneously shed from armed factions and abandoned to their own resources; • They may be shed as such groups become aware of the disapproval that is associated with the practice, and political initiatives indicate that their aims and objectives in promoting the conflict may be reaching acceptance; • At the end of a conflict they may be grouped within a larger category of unaccompanied or separated children to avoid any acknowledgement of their participation, and thus be excluded from accessing any demobilization "benefits"; • They may return home with family members who occasioned their initial involvement; • They may be involved in organized procedures for demobilization of under-age recruits. Demobilization or release from an armed group should be considered as the first step in the normalization of the children's lives. Where possible, given the various circumstances, there should be a readiness to respond to children's needs immediately upon their release from the military, so that there is as smooth a progression as possible, and they are not left confused. Organizations concerned with the protection and welfare of children have an important role to play both in determining the criteria for child-oriented procedures of demobilization, and being involved in translating these into practice, so that children's needs and concerns are recognized and integrated into the process of demobilization. For some children, the prospects of life as a soldier, despite the hardships and dangers, may be more attractive than returning to one of oppression and destitution. Their
44
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
families may hold similar views and will influence the children accordingly. Demobilization and social reintegration programs should be rooted in this reality, and not digress into considerations of systems and procedures to “manage” the problem. There is a growing awareness not only of the particular needs of child soldiers, but of those of other children who are involved in fighting forces - children abducted or otherwise forcibly recruited not just as fighters but as “human shields”, porters and camp assistants, or for sexual purposes. One of the most challenging effects on children of such experiences is that they have spent a significant part of their childhood in a strictly hierarchical structure and have experienced a socialization process which serves the purposes of a military command. Clearly such experiences may make it difficult for children, upon release, to adjust and to re-learn new codes of behavior and how to develop relationships not based on power and fear. Children who have participated in violence and killing have probably been given messages about what such actions mean from the vantage point of armed forces. This may mean that children have to re-learn moral behavior and acquire the ability to make moral judgments appropriate to civilian life. Some children realize the terrible nature of their previous actions and may suffer greatly because of that realization and the guilt and shame associated with it. Some children - especially those who have had positions of responsibility in the fighting forces - may have particular difficulty in adjusting themselves to civilian life where their status is no longer recognized. Even young children may have taken on “adult” roles, responsibilities and authority: this may make it extremely difficult to return to the expectations associated with childhood - e.g. conforming to the norms and rules of school. Girls who have been on active duty may find particular difficulty in adjusting to expected ways of how girls should behave in their society, and this may affect marriage prospects as well as adjustment to the role of wife and mother. Girls are particularly at risk of rape and prolonged sexual abuse, and this may affect the normal development of ageadequate and culturally acceptable behavior: in turn this can pose a challenge for successful social integration. One aspect of life within fighting forces that is not always well recognised is that children may well have had some positive experiences, intermingled with many negative and brutalizing experiences. For example, they may have been part of a highly supportive group-living situation they may have had a strong sense of purpose, perhaps with in ideology which may have given a sense of meaning to their actions. They may also have had strong personal relationships with their commanders despite the potential for an exploitative and brutal aspect of this relationship. These more positive sides of their experience cannot always be replaced. Therefore, unless children do have opportunities for good adult and peer-group relationships, a sense of purpose and self-esteem, they are likely to experience difficulties in returning to more normal civilian life in the community. Integral to any concern to effect the demobilization and social reintegration of former child soldiers is the fact that all children in a community will to some degree have been affected by the conflict. Their circumstances and experiences have placed them also at special disadvantage. Under the provisions of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, they have the right to special protection and assistance. Families and communities who have experienced the various ways in which the conflict has impacted their daily existence, including the participation of some of their children, may be more concerned with establishing normal life and familiar routines. In other situations difficult and complex issues of “forgiveness" may have to be addressed
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
45
within the community as a whole because of serious acts of violence that have been perpetrated by the demobilized child soldiers. They may not initially be sympathetic to special initiatives on behalf of former child soldiers. The integration of vulnerable children such as child soldiers into overall programming for war-affected children will need to be carefully considered and monitored. Approaches which mobilise communities around key issues such as family impoverishment; education; skills training; health and disabilities; and reconciliation may be more likely to ease the return of the child soldiers. They entail a more sustainable, longterm perspective which also better meets the range of developmental needs experienced by former child soldiers. They can also be integrated into general programs of post-conflict reconstruction. The risk of marginalizing former child soldiers through the implementation of special programs should be balanced against such considerations. Special programs of rehabilitation and interim care may be necessary. At all stages children must be informed about their rights and details of the existing or planned programs. Dialogue, from the very earliest stages of any intervention, must allow the children to influence the demobilization and reintegration program and to determine a realistic "plan of action" for themselves. An essential aspect of rehabilitation is finding ways of promoting children’s selfesteem and a sense of hope and confidence in the future: this may be particularly difficult for children who have been recruited partly as a reflection of their own perceptions of the lack of opportunities available within their own community. Experience suggests that once these children reintegrate back into more normal life in the community, many struggle with poor self-esteem and a confused sense of who they are, and need long-term support from their families and community. It is not surprising that many remain vulnerable to rerecruitment.
Community involvement The process of community involvement can be summarized in three phases: • Sensitization - to educate and raise awareness in the community; • Articulation and Reflection - based on dialogue with community members to enable an understanding of the root causes of child militarization; • Mobilization of Resources – both human and material to contribute to project implementation. The care and protection of children, and their social reintegration, will ultimately rest with their families and communities. Going beyond addressing the needs of children in difficult circumstances, to protecting and securing their rights requires the participation of their families and communities in order to take due account of the importance of the traditions and cultural values of each person for the protection and harmonious development of the child. There are practical considerations which dictate the necessity of encouraging community initiatives, which are usually low cost and have greater impact when aimed at building up local capacity to resolve their own problems through programs based on and managed by the communities themselves. Taking due account of these principles will involve: • Determining the attitude of the community towards the child soldiers; • The community’s perception of their roles and responsibilities; • The resources and capacities, both human and material, that are available to meet the
46
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
children’s needs; • The community's circumstances and realistic and sustainable objectives. Community involvement should not be seen as a simple solution to the social reintegration of former child soldiers. Time is needed to engage people in a dialogue in order to understand the risk factors within the family and community that can result in children being militarized. Often, there is an understandable focus on the worst consequences of the children's participation in the conflict, such as substance abuse, the atrocities they have committed, and their aggressive and violent behaviour. This is the aspect of the children's involvement that people have experienced, and risks placing the emphasis on the need to “de-traumatize” the children and to teach them to be good and moral citizens. This often goes along with the conviction that they are best kept away from people until they are ‘cured’.
An integrated community development model implies a range of partners, like international organizations and NGOs, local agencies and local NGOs, all contributing different skills and expertise. Agreement is needed amongst the various partners on what is an appropriate approach within a given situation. All concerned must be clear about their own roles and responsibilities. It may be necessary, for example, to identify a lead agency with responsibility for ensuring a co-coordinated response from the various organizations. Following conflict, the capacity of governments to respond to children's issues may be limited, which contributes to the risk that the government's role and responsibility towards its children is pre-empted by others. However, the involvement of appropriate ministries in program planning and implementation is important, in order that social reintegration develops from a shared perspective, and is implemented in a manner that allows for continuity and sustainability. Also, incorporating local partners and government departments at an early stage will enable a more effective response. Capacity building aimed at developing and strengthening human resources will be an important aspect of developing a framework to normalize the lives of child soldiers. Activities directed at the normalization of the children's lives will require outreach to their communities. Local partners can play a crucial role in assessing the situation of the children's families and communities, and in identifying factors that influence their social reintegration.
Community awareness Frequently, people’s attitudes and opinions about child soldiers indicate little awareness or sympathy for the view that the children themselves have suffered. When children are seen as the perpetrators of violence, introducing any consideration of abuse of children's rights is not easy, and may be considered irrelevant. An emphasis on the consequences for children of their participation in military activities, like: the loss of family life and normal developmental experiences, missed educational opportunities, social marginalization and increased risk of exploitation - can be a means of raising awareness, and thereby informing the process of demobilization, rehabilitation and social reintegration. In this manner the implementation of the CRC is promoted in a natural manner, not as a remote instrument of international law, as different activities are targeted at the range of children's needs occasioned by conflict.
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
47
As a result of their own experiences, people can be engaged in discussing how the conflict has affected children, including the fact that it has resulted in their children becoming soldiers. Here discussion can focus on "what was done to children" rather than "this is what the children did". Discussions such as these can enable people to take a longer term perspective about issues that influence their children, including strategies to assist child soldiers in what will be for many a long and difficult process of social reintegration.
Demobilization and social reintegration There are issues that are common to the experience of all children who have participated in conflict and which require consideration if they are to reintegrate with their families and communities. These issues are: • Separation from the family; • Family poverty and vulnerability; • Education and vocational training; • Participation of children; • Health; • Children in need of special care. 1. Separation from the family and community Child soldiers may have been separated from their families and communities for prolonged periods of time. This separation in itself can create a risk for children, but their situation is compounded by the experiences and conditions of their time as soldiers. These children need to be able to establish and maintain stable emotional relationships. This is of particular concern for children who have been "recruited", often abducted, at an early age. It will be important to re-establish continuity of care, nurture and support and to normalize their daily lives. A process of mediation may be required before communities can even accept child soldiers including perhaps, acknowledgement of inappropriate behavior, public apology, forgiveness, religious rituals or traditional procedures. This will be difficult and complex in situations where they are perceived to have committed atrocities against others and for communities to accept the limits of their responsibility as the children may be difficult. Family reunification and re-attachment to family and community can be considered as the most significant determinants of effective social reintegration. In the immediate term it will be necessary to trace families, arrange for family reunification and consider interim care arrangements, including substitute families or small group care within the communities for children who cannot be reunited with their own families. Some children may be unable or unwilling to return to their families and it will thus be necessary, as soon as possible after demobilization (preferably beforehand if sufficient time is available for planning), to determine the numbers of children to be reunified immediately; numbers for whom interim care is required during tracing; and the numbers requiring longer-term alternative care. Where options such as substitute family care or small group care under the supervision of the community are considerations, it will be necessary to work with the communities to establish criteria to ensure the protection and well-being of the children. Institutionalization is unlikely to meet the needs of these children and should be considered a "last resort" to be implemented in exceptional circumstances.
48
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
Children who are unable to reunite with their own families, or who choose not to return home, are especially vulnerable. Not only will they have no emotional or social reference points, but they will have no-one to represent their interests and secure their care and protection. Procedures for determining legal responsibility or guardianship for these children should therefore be considered. In theory, the role and responsibility of governments in such cases is defined by the provisions of the CRC. Organizations concerned with the rights and well-being of children must therefore acknowledge and respond to this issue, in particular the requirement for training and capacity building of government personnel in appropriate ministries, and local NGOs, in both legal and child welfare issues as they relate to these children. Monitoring of former child soldiers who are not reunited with their families is an essential aspect of long-term protection that requires consideration. 2. Family poverty and vulnerability The overall context for the children’s return may often be characterized by impoverishment of their families. The situation of the child soldiers' families and communities is a crucial factor for their social reintegration. Criteria should be developed to identify vulnerable families and to determine appropriate assistance, ideally delivered at the community level, to enable the reintegration of their children. Communities emerging from conflict often stress the linkage between education, employment opportunities and the economic security of the children’s families as the factors that would determine not only successful social reintegration, but also prevent rerecruitment. The requirement of children, of whatever age, to contribute to the family economy may constitute the most important factor in their re-attachment to their families, thereby defining effective social reintegration. During this process they will be valued for their contribution to the productive work of the family, and relearn the values, practices, and norms that regulate and give reason to family and community life. This must, however, be balanced against the requirement to address the overall needs and rights of the children occasioned by their participation in conflict. It will thus be important to identify those factors which create vulnerability in certain families and to direct assistance to their situation in order to prevent renewed risk to the children. Of particular importance for these children will be the prevention of further separations or abandonment. In some instances, the circumstances of the family may mean that it is unable to satisfy the needs of the child, ending up to push the child onto the streets, either through the child’s own initiative or by encouragement or forced by the family to provide for him/herself and even for the family. Life as a street child may not be the only consequence of such situations. Children from vulnerable families can also be at risk of sexual abuse and exploitation and child labor, or may find themselves again involved in violence by joining armed gangs. 3. Education and Vocational Training One factor which appears common to all child soldiers is that prior to their recruitment they have had limited or no access to education. The right of these children to education is selfevident, but how this right becomes a reality will again be a function of the circumstances confronting the children following demobilization, including the extent to which educational facilities have been destroyed, a situation which affects all children, not only the former child combatants. Experience with child soldiers indicates their desire for education. This poses
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
49
problems for older children in particular, as they will have lost the opportunity for normal education. Children will also be returning to impoverished families, and the need to contribute to the family's economy may outweigh any concern for their education. Consideration should be given to approaches that are appropriate to local circumstances, like: • Literacy and numeracy courses in parallel with vocational/skills training; • Traditional apprenticeship schemes; • Formal vocational training; • Opportunities for self-employment; • Ensuring the appropriateness and sustainability of skills training. 4. The Participation of Children A Child Rights approach to the social reintegration of child soldiers must incorporate their participation in procedures to facilitate their return to civilian life. Participation in any process requires access to reliable information. This is important in itself, but it is also a means of building trust and confidence in young people who may feel anxious and confused about their future. Thus, if demobilization is seen as a stage in social reintegration, efforts should be made to reach the children beforehand and to inform them that demobilization is planned, and how it is envisaged that they will be included in the planning. Without information, children may be prey to rumors and false expectations. Older children will likely have ideas for their own personal plans or situation, and a structure should be available to discuss personal or confidential concerns, and to make informed and realistic decisions that are appropriate to their age and circumstances. Further, children's participation should be actively promoted through strategies that enable the children to develop a sense of personal control and self-worth through contributing to and participating in the process of their social reintegration. 5. Health Children's experiences as soldiers indicate that many of them will have significant health problems. The effects of poor diet, unsanitary living conditions, untended injuries, and physical abuse will be immediately apparent. Not so obvious will be that some will have been affected by sexually transmitted diseases, with the risk of an elevated numbers of children being HIV positive. Girl soldiers may face added health complications associated with self-administered or incompetent abortions, unwanted pregnancies and miscarriages. Experiences of sexual abuse, both for girls and boys, can have significant social and cultural implications. This can have a negative impact on family reunification or social reintegration and means that related problems are often neither acknowledged nor addressed. Therefore, these issues must form a key aspect of planning of reintegration of former child soldiers. 6. Children in need of special care All former child soldiers could be considered as belonging to this category, but, given the children’s experiences, there will be some whose needs are particularly pressing. We need to consider what constitutes an appropriate response to children with special needs, but also what capacities are available to implement this response. This is of particular concern if children are not included in formal demobilization procedures, and planning includes emergency interim care.
50
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
The category of children in need of special care includes: • Children with disabilities; • Girl soldiers, in particular those returning with children of their own; • Children who remain separated from their families, including those separated at the time of recruitment; • Children whose families cannot be found; • Children who refuse to return to their families and communities of origin; • Children suffering from alcohol or drug dependency; • Children with psychological problems caused by, or exacerbated by, their experiences.
A return to normal life – key points • The involvement of government departments and local partners in program planning and implementation is vital. • Capacity building activities directed at developing and strengthening human resources can help to facilitate a return to normal life. • It is essential to establish criteria for protection and well-being of children in care of the community. • Daily routines help to normalize life, give children opportunities to learn skills, and build confidence and self-esteem. • Active participation of children, by involving them in planning and decision making, enables them to take responsibility for their own actions and future development. • It is important to create an open and accepting environment, and let the child set the pace, rather than focus on ‘trauma’ and its consequences. Although each situation is unique, and no one model can direct program responses, there are some issues that are likely to be common to efforts to re-establish normal life. These issues are: • Assessing child care needs: determining the numbers of children who will be immediately reunified with their families, the numbers for whom interim care is required during tracing, and the numbers requiring longer-term alternative care; • Establishing criteria to identify vulnerable families and to determine appropriate assistance to enable the reintegration of their children; • Identifying networks of social support at the community level, like: churches, mosques, schools, women's organizations, youth and community structures; • Identifying children with special needs, and paying particular attention to the situation of girl soldiers.
Re-establishing social and emotional bonds As they return to normal life, the impact of the children's experiences as soldiers may affect the re-establishment and development of social and emotional relationships. 1. The re-establishment of trust Children who have been exposed to violence and other traumatic experiences may over time lose their trust in others, and may have difficulty in differentiating between people who wish them well and others who do not. Re-establishing trust in others is a crucial task, upon which the possibility of successful recovery depends.
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
51
2. The re-establishment of self-esteem Normal family and community life enables the development of self-esteem. For child soldiers this can be endangered by separation from their families and the fact that they may no longer be valued by the community because of the acts of violence in which they have been involved. 3. Self-control Child soldiers have been encouraged or forced to continually activate and utilize their aggressive impulses. It is important to note that the aggression has also been sanctioned by those in command of the children. This can result in problems of self-control of aggression following return to normal, civilian life. Child soldiers have also been victims of aggression and humiliation, and this may similarly affect their capacity to control their aggression. 4. The re-establishment of identity The concept of identity is connected to one’s self-perception: the knowledge of who one is and how one experiences and defines oneself in a cultural, social, historical and spiritual sense. Included in our sense of identity is our set of values, skills, beliefs, and our role in the family. The losses that child soldiers have suffered and their experience of militarization pose particular problems for them as they seek to re-establish a sense of who they are and how they can fit into civil society. 5. The recognition of resources and strengths When working with and relating to children who have in some way been defined as “different” and “difficult”, attention is often drawn to problematic behavior, symptoms and signs of emotional disturbance and developmental deviancies. However, in order to assist children in achieving developmental tasks, it is necessary to recognize and encourage the development of children’s personal strengths and resources. They may have much to contribute and should not be seen only as recipients of any particular form of intervention. 6. The re-establishment of attachment Attachment describes a very close bond between persons. Children need close emotional attachment to feel secure, and to develop fully their potential as human beings. Close attachment is related to trust, the building of feelings of competence, and eventually a stable identity. Young persons and adults need close intimate relationships with at least a few others. Thus a very important task will be to help child soldiers develop the capacity for good relationships with others. Assistance in finding lost parents or other family members is crucial as well as helping the children to build friendships again, and to develop behaviors which favor positive interaction with others is equally important.
Rehabilitation Whether children are able to reunite immediately with their families, or are cared for within some form of interim care program, the term rehabilitation is frequently used to describe program responses directed to their needs. It can have many different meanings, from educational projects to clinical approaches to deal with the consequences of traumatic events. Those engaged with the development of projects and activities to normalize the child soldiers' lives should use the term carefully. Consideration should be given to its meaning within the social and cultural reality of the lives of the children, their families and communities, and its appropriateness within this context. One common use of rehabilitation emphasizes the need to “rehabilitate” children
52
L. Peters / Child Soldiers - Recruitment, Demobilization, Rehabilitation, Reintegration
because of the behavioural consequences of their participation in conflict. These are understood as the psychological effects of the traumatic events the children have experienced. Specific programs of rehabilitation within a therapeutic or medical framework In the development of therapeutic rehabilitation programs, thought should be given to points like: • Is the concept appropriate to the experience and conditions of life of the children, and the families and communities to whom they will return? • Who will make the decision to implement a rehabilitation program, and who will be involved in the process of implementation? • Which children will benefit from the program, and what criteria will be used to select them? • What will be the aim of the program, and how will this be explained to the children and their families? • Has any consideration been given to alternative strategies, incorporating, for example, skills and knowledge from within the community? The children themselves will have many worries and concerns, some of a practical nature, both about their past experiences and what the future will hold in store for them. The setting in which they can express such concerns requires careful consideration. Counseling the children could wait until their environment has been normalized and they have been assessed and are ready to talk about their experiences. It might be necessary to “unpack” the term trauma and talk instead about issues of suffering, loss, loneliness, terror and anxiety. Also the term trauma counseling can stigmatize the children and more neutral words could be used which focus on issues that may be troubling the children. Community members could be trained to hold supportive conversations in order that the children feel their concerns are accepted, and that someone is available to listen and to help them resolve their problems. Enabling children to reflect on their experiences and their implications is important. This is best conducted, however, with some practical goal in mind. For example, a child may have a particular problem controlling aggression. Practical strategies can be discussed with the child, setting particular goals, perhaps on a daily or weekly basis. The idea is to help the child to gain gradual control of the problem, to accept personal responsibility and ultimately to experience a sense of achievement that they have mastered a problem through their own efforts. Children can assist each other in achieving these goals, and their participation in this process should be encouraged. Traditional ceremonies and practices to heal or cleanse children can be important components in this process, and should be incorporated where appropriate. References 1 ARC is developed by OHCHR, UNHCR, UNICEF and Save the Children. For more information, please contact David Nosworthy, ARC-Project coordinator,
[email protected], Phone: +41-22-919 2003 2 Cape Town Principles, 1997
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
53
8. Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children in Serbia Slobodanka GASIC-PAVISIC, PhD Faculty of Defectology, University of Belgrade, Beograd, Serbia
Yugoslavia was bombed by NATO during 1999. The bombing lasted permanently for 79 days. The flights of the warplanes were so frequent that the air emergency warning lasted for two or three days continuously, and emergency air warnings were repeated everyday. According to NATO official statements the bombing was directed just to the military targets, but many civil objects were struck (so called collateral damage) and actually the only safe places were the shelters. Since the parents had to work, day care for children was a particular problem. The preschools worked but some of them were damaged by bombing and moved to cellars and private houses. Through the help of humanitarian organisations, different kind of creative activities and psychological support was organised in order to help the children overcome the feeling of fear and uncertainty.1 Approximately 3,000,000 children lived under these traumatic circumstances. However, the consequences of the NATO bombing to the children’s mental health attracted only small attention from the experts and public. The bombing and its consequences are not a subject to talk about in Serbia. Is it all forgotten or just put away in the subconscious in order to save strength for the everyday hard life lasting for decades with a sombre perspective for the future? (“Is the memory bombed as well”, was the title of the comment published on the Internet in March 2005). However, it is possible that the silence has other causes besides the psychological.
Research – Findings on Level of Trauma in Children Looking for data about the posttraumatic effects of the NATO bombing on the children of Serbia I found only a few unconnected investigations, most of them not fully published. I will state here their main findings chronologically. N. Kapor-Stanulovic (Stanulovic, 2001) conducted research concerning the disturbance of the mental health of adolescents and adults during the bombing. By the end of last two weeks of bombing she had tested 368 subjects from the two cities in Vojvodina
54
S. Gasic-Pavisic / Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children
(Zrenjanin and Novi Sad in North of Serbia). The main finding was that more than 60% of subjects had expressed symptoms of posttraumatic stress, while the presence of depression and anxiety was significantly less observed. Marija Zotovic (Zotovic, 2001) investigated the frequency of PTSD symptoms in the children 2 months after bombing. The sample was 333 children from Novi Sad, 11, 14, and 15 years old. This research has shown as well that over 60% of subjects showed the signs of PTSD symptoms significantly present. One year after bombing, M. Zotovic (Zotovic, 2004) conducted research into details concerning the state connected with PTSD of male and female adolescents of 12, 15 and 18 years old (629 subjects in total). The object of the research was: (1) What is the level of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depressive symptoms in children and adolescents a year after the NATO bombing of Yugoslavia?; and (2) What factors correlate with PTSD and depression level, in a way that they present risk factors for development of higher levels of symptoms? The main findings of the research are: - A year after the bombing, significant extent of PTSD symptoms (moderate and severe levels of disorder) exists in almost 60% of children and adolescents (59.6%). This result shows that the consequences persisted a year after the bombing, and that they could not disappear easily and quickly. - The symptoms of depression were significantly less frequent. They were registered in 18.5% of subjects. - Girls had greater number of symptoms comparing to boys. - The highest level of PTSD symptoms was revealed in the youngest group of subjects (12 years old), while the oldest group of subject (18 years old) had the highest number of depressive symptoms. Questioned about what was the most terrible experience for them during bombing the majority of them answered that it was the first day (59%) and after followed: the worry for the family members or other close persons (48%): when some particular target was struck ( a bridge, TV tower etc): the sound of the explosion and the ground shaking (40%). The research also revealed risk factors for development of PTSD and depression.’’For the prediction of PTSD level, a usage of specific coping strategies seemed especially important. The best predictor for higher levels of PTSD was a tendency for using social coping strategies – the need to talk with other people, to share the company of other people. It is assumed that more anxious subjects used social coping strategies, and later developed higher levels of PTSD, as the result of the anxiety. Likewise, it is possible that the subjects who sought social support were not satisfied with a response from their social network (because everybody was distressed), and therefore suffered more and had more symptoms. In contrast to social, usage of avoidant coping style was the predictor of lower levels of PTSD symptoms. This finding is in accordance with the results of previous studies, as well as theoretical statements in the field (Lazarus & Folkman, 1984; Folkman et al., 1986). Among personal characteristics, higher neuroticism appeared to be a risk factor for developing higher levels of PTSD.’’(Zotoviü,2004). M. Zotovic warns that is difficult to measure the psychological effects of bombing since that is a complex and multidimensional experience.
S. Gasic-Pavisic / Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children
55
In another research study, R. Marusic-Gasic (Marusic-Gasic, 2000) investigated the PTSD in preschool children one year after bombing. The research carried out at the Department for child’s health at VMA in Belgrade during 2000 year. The sample consisted of the parents of 128 children. The children were about 6 years old by the time of bombing. Since their fathers were engaged in military service, most of the subjects (32%) were used to live without them during bombing and just the small number of subjects (12%)had had their fathers with them. That fact increased the effect of anxiety and the feeling of uncertainty since they were worried about their fathers. Mothers were mostly with their children (76%) but some of them had to work (24%) and there children had to stay with neighbours or their relatives. One boy, 12 years old, from Belgrade, wrote: “Every night I was woken up by the sounds of the warplanes and missiles. Since my father was a soldier, I was the only male at home. Yet, my heart was trembling with fear and I was crouched all the time in the doorway with my mother and sister where we were waiting, clinging to each other, for the sounds of warplanes and explosions to stop”. During the air emergency, most of the parents (48%) did not go with their children into the shelters, only 9% were regular in their going into a shelter and the rest only went occasionally (43%). This kind of behaviour certainly was not safe but psychologically it was less traumatic for children, since they were able to sleep in their own bed, to be fed more regularly, to play with their own playthings and to be surrounded with people they knew. According to the parents’ statements, the children’s reactions to the air emergency signal and the sounds and detonations of warplanes and missiles were the following: 5% of subjects did not answer to the question, 49% showed signs of fear and uneasiness, 46% requested explanations or just continued with their activity. The manner of the children’s reaction was determined by the parent’s behaviour at that moment, depending as well on the part of the city or on the kind of apartment where they were living ( uneasiness was greater for the children in multystorey buildings). The findings showed that a year after the bombing more than half of the examined children had at least one symptom of psychotrauma and for 46.37% of children the parents had not observed any of the mentioned symptoms. 15.7% of children showed 3 or more PT symptoms as a sign of their moderate or difficult state of mental health. Among the children’s psychotrauma symptoms, generated during the bombing and observed at preschool children one year after bombing, were: -
Enforced fear of the separation from the parents (the child does not want to stay alone in the room and prefers sleeping in the parents’ bed ) - 35.5% Disturbed biological cycle– sleeping, nutrition (scared to sleep, waking up in the night and crying, refusing to eat, eating too much) - 15.94% Fear and shaking at any strong sound - 10.86% Disturbed behaviour (aggressiveness, irritation) - 5.07% Regressive symptoms – enuresis, tics, baby talk - 3.62% Three or more symptoms together -10.86%.
56
S. Gasic-Pavisic / Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children
A year after the bombing 33.3% of children (129 examined) talk often about the bombing, have the need for questioning , talk and mention the events connected with bombing, which means that the event is intensively present in their memory. Also, about one third of the children (32.5%) have been playing war games and bombing games (‘’ the post-war games’’). Four year after bombing , 30 of these children were tested again (Bejatoviü, 2003) and 60% of them still have the same symptoms of psychotrauma. The number of children having the group of symptoms (increased feeling of fear, disturbance of sleeping and appetite, over-exciting, enuresis, disturbance in speaking, tics) has increased (23.3%).
Protective Factors The two most important protective factors concerning the trauma caused to the children during the bombing were: 1. Staying in their homes instead going to the shelter which psychologically gave them the illusion of safety and keeping their every day schedule undisturbed (sleeping, resting and nutrition) 2. Parent’s presence near the child, what was not possible in many cases since the parents had to work or do military service. The author of the research R. Marusic, stressed the needs for implementing psychosocial programmes for children’s mental health protection in Serbia, particularly giving care to vulnerable children. However, very few of these necessary programmes have been implemented. Some of the actions were directed to in-service training of teachers in order to prepare them for giving psychosocial help to traumatised children. One such very successful psychosocial programs for teachers is being organised and implemented in Serbia by Foundation “Together” from Ljubljana, Slovenia. The effects of the NATO bombing on handicapped children During the bombing, handicapped children and their parents were particularly affected. The effects of the NATO bombing on handicapped children were direct and indirect. The direct effects of the NATO bombing comprise slow and/or regressive psychomotor development of the children and some additional disorders like epilepsy, stammering, etc. not existing before the bombing. The indirect effects of the NATO bombing include the disturbed psychodynamics of children’s' family life, suddenly impoverished families, and worsening quality of the institutional care for rehabilitation of the population (Stosljeviü, 2000). The negative influences of bombing on these children are multifold and appeared very quickly, according to a study carried out by Stosljevic (Stosljevic, 2005) the effects of which were observed already after 20 days. Stosljevic began to observe 72 moderately mentally retarded children two years before the bombing. The objective of the research was to follow up the effects of their rehabilitation on their psychomotor development for a long period of time. We have been assessing their
S. Gasic-Pavisic / Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children
57
development every six months, the last being organized with 43 available subjects twenty days after the beginning of NATO's aggression on Yugoslavia. The obtained results showed that their psychomotor development index have constantly been increasing till the beginning of NATO's aggression when, only 20 days later, it has gone down to the value recorded in March 1998. There are at least two reasons for the results obtained: the negative psychological effect of the bombing on the handicapped children and the understandable break in their treatment. The second direct effect of the NATO bombing was the occurrence of new, repeated additional disorders of the subjects researched. In the last controlled measurement the following disorders can be singled out: the majority of disorders (99.47 %) were from the domain of the motor activity expressed through their motor unrest, their changed behaviour (83.80 %), neurosis (83.80 %) and their vigilant attention (66.64 %). However, more drastic disorders like enuresis (30.08 %), facial jerks (30.08 %), and epilepsy (28.56 %) are more alarming. The author points out that ‘’ Epilepsy was particularly great problem due to the shortage of antiepileptic and a dramatic clinical picture that upsets in an already upsetting environment. The problem is exceptionally difficult if the attack takes place in a bomb shelter, during the air-raid danger, or to the sound of air-raid sirens announcing the danger.... Disturbed psychodynamics of children’s' family life seems to be among the worst. When you dislocate handicapped children from their own social milieu and put them in a bomb shelter to the sound of air-raid sirens with rules to regulate the behavior there which the children do not understand, they are obligatorily traumatized. That indirectly affects their families and the people in bomb shelters.’’ (Ibidem). To end, I shall recount a personal memory: During the bombing, I was working as a professor at the Preschool Teachers’ College in Belgrade. One of my girl students had the oral part of her graduate exam. During the exam we heard the sound of the emergency signal. I asked her if she wished us to stop the examination and go to a shelter. She wanted to finish the examination and we proceeded in spite of the sounds of explosions. After the exam was finished, I approached her and we shook hands. Then, I noticed that her hand was icy cold and her face totally bloodless. I will never forget that.
Final comment In this comprehensive and certainly not completely encompassing overview of the researches accomplished about the consequences of NATO bombing to the mental health of children in Serbia, I wanted to present the facts which can be useful for developing the strategy for helping those children. Theoretical interpretation of the researches presented here was already given by the authors themselves, and interested readers can find it in the references. The common finding of all of those research studies is that the great number of children in Serbia had two or three of the symptoms of stress related to disorders as a consequence of the NATO bombing. This makes the children’s mental health susceptible to future disturbing life circumstances - and those are the conditions in which children live in Serbia nowadays. However, it has to be kept in mind that the psychotraumatic consequences are not the only ones which affected the children in Serbia and affect them further in connection with the NATO bombing. Since the child’s resistive mechanism was weakened by the
58
S. Gasic-Pavisic / Negative Effects of the NATO Bombing on the Mental Health of Children
stress during the bombing, children are exposed to the increasing risk of malignant disease whose number increased significantly in Serbia after the bombing (Stanimirovic 2005). Meanwhile all the authors mentioned showed that the consequences of the traumatic experience to the children are long-lasting and that is necessary to give to those children psychosocial help and support – but to date very little has been done in that field. I hope that the warm understanding, compassion and good will of the World Movement of Mothers will contribute to the fact that children all over the world stricken by war will more easily overcome their traumas. Note 1
For example, there were organized youth gatherings – birthday parties and amateur theatre performances in the shelters, professional theatres worked free of charge during the air strikes and every day in the city plazas were organized lunch-time concerts. There was a totally unrealistic - and unforgettable - sight of thousands of young people (and not only youth) in the plaza singing and dancing with the warplanes flying over their heads. The purpose of those concerts was certainly political but it was also one of the strategies for coping with stress and for relaxation.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
59
9. Editor’s Note: Dr. Speckard and Dr. Akhmedova’s work provides thought-provoking insight into some of the possible factors contributing to a traumatized adolescent’s descent into terrorism and martyrdom. Its narrative style encourages future examination of their findings in more detailed research studies.
Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism: Trauma and Bereavement as Psychological Vulnerabilities in Human Security - The Chechen Case Anne SPECKHARD, PhD. Adjunct Associate Professor of Psychiatry, Georgetown University Medical Center, Professor of Psychology, Vesalius College, Free University of Brussels and psychological consultant of Advances in Health & Khapta AKHMEDOVA, PhD. Institute of Psychology Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow Research Institute of Psychiatry, Russian Ministry of Health Since the dissolution of the Soviet Union, Chechnya has unsuccessfully sought independence from Russia in two wars on Chechen territory. The first occurred in 19941996, and the ongoing war started in 1999. Russian military forces currently occupy the area, with numerous and well-documented war atrocities and human rights violations by both sides. Indeed one Russian policy analyst commented privately that the Russian forces currently in Chechnya are poorly controlled, chaotically operating there, and attracting to their ranks the lowest level criminals who wish to operate in an arena of widespread impunity. Terrorism, particularly suicide terrorism, as a strategic tactic has been introduced into the Russian/Chechen conflict over the past decade, imported through Al Qaeda and other terrorist networks. The idea of tempered revenge has a strong foundation in Chechen culture. When a family member is harmed or killed it is the responsibility of the family members to seek out the evil-doer and make him or her pay accordingly. However, this ideology of revenge is strictly codified and does not normally spread beyond seeking out the harm’s originator and repaying his or her evil deed. With widespread war traumatization, bereavement, and the importation of a terrorist mentality, this mindset is changing. Rather than being limited, in the minds of many revenge is becoming generalized. Indeed, Akhmedova found in her
60
A. Speckhard and K. Akhmedova / Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism
study of over 600 clinical subjects who had undergone war traumas that those who had the highest levels of posttraumatic effects had undergone a transformation in this regard. They no longer regarded revenge as a duty to find and repay in kind the person who had harmed their families. Instead, the subjects broadened their desire for revenge to wishing to hold an ethnicity responsible for the actions of some of its members. Retribution against members of this ethnicity (i.e. the Russians military or civilians) was both sufficient and acceptable. 2 War-harmed youth appear the most vulnerable to the fusion of revenge and terrorist ideology spreading through the region. This paper draws on clinical case examples from the practice and research interviews of the authors, and examines the vulnerabilities in youth who are drawn to terrorist activities. The paper focuses on prospective suicide terrorists and makes recommendations regarding preventative actions. Trauma and Grief Traumatic loss is common during war. Nearly everyone in Chechnya has witnessed and been subjected to traumatic events. However when the trauma hits close to home, these events are riveting and life changing. Researcher Janof-Bulman posits that in normal times and given nurturing upbringings most individuals hold what she calls world assumptions. Three fundamental assumptions that according to Janof-Bulman3 generally go unquestioned and unchallenged are: benevolence, meaningfulness of the world, and a sense of self worth. The experience of psychological trauma (i.e. an inescapable, horrifying and terrifying experience which is life threatening or threatens serious injury, or in which a person witnesses or learns of the death or serious injury of another), however, often so challenges these assumptions that they are completely shattered, and unable to be rebuilt. Indeed reparative psychological work with trauma victims often involves rebuilding a cognitive frame capable of “holding” the emotional and cognitive aspects of the traumatic event. At age 23, S journeyed to Moscow as part of the Chechen terrorist group that overtook the Dubrovka theatre. The group held more than 800 people hostage for fiftyeight hours. S was in Grozny in 1995 during the onset of the second Russian offensive against the Chechens. Without money and transport to flee, he and his family hid in a cellar during the bombings. At some point during the onslaught, S’s mother left the shelter to retrieve water for her family. Though she was mortally wounded, she was able to return to the family’s shelter. At age 17, S sat powerless for four days, witnessing his mother’s death. Because of the ongoing violence, his family could not even bury their mother properly for some time after her death. Eventually, they dug a grave for her in the courtyard of their apartment block. S was deeply traumatized by the death of his mother. He began to isolate himself from the family. This only worsened when his father shockingly remarried in a rather short amount of time. Traumatic events are by definition individually defined, but they are overwhelmingly horrifying, terrifying, and fraught with death and/or the threat of death for the person experiencing them. When a person is severely traumatized, it is normal that he or she cannot take in the enormity of the experience he has undergone at once. His or her view of the world is dramatically altered; normalcy no longer exists. Frequently, his or her mind is unable to allow the full impact of the event into consciousness and the traumatic
A. Speckhard and K. Akhmedova / Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism
61
memory exists in a highly charged sensory state triggered in flashbacks, nightmares, and arousal states that occur with reminders of the original event. Part of healing from a traumatic event is finding a way to allow this highly charged memory to be processed into normal memory in a manner that creates new meanings, behaviours, and outlooks that are able to process the highly charged and painful emotions that were experienced. For some, healing occurs in fits and spurts as avoidance strategies are enacted to keep the traumatic memory at bay until little by little it is accepted into the conscious narrative of one’s life story. For others, an active seeking occurs, in which the individual searches for a new frame in which to place the traumatic memory in context of one’s life that gives it meaning which is acceptable versus overwhelming in grief, shame, fear and sorrow. For these seekers of a new cognitive frame, the terrorist recruiters are a grave danger. Seeking Meaning after Trauma Nearly every trauma survivor seeks to place his or her traumatic experience within the context of his or her past, present and future. For some, the shame, fear, guilt and danger that the event posed make this a very difficult thing to do. For instance, sexual abuse survivors are often so terrified by the sexual advances of adults toward them that they will construct a reality in which they blame themselves for having “seduced” their abuser. By placing this negative label upon themselves, they are able to gain a sense of control over what happened to them. For a survivor, it is often far more acceptable to believe that one was “evil” or “seductive” as a child than to believe that it can happen at random, unpredictably, outside of one’s willing or desire. It is always possible once reform this selfcognition or to block out these unacceptable sides of the self, but to accept a random, unpredictable, and terrifying world is a much worse alternative. The same is true with victims of war. When S’s mother returned mortally wounded, he was powerless to help her. He couldn’t even bury her without a shameful delay. Later, his father seemed to forget her, marrying again. S had to find some way to deal with his grief, guilt, anger, and shock over these events. He found himself drawn to a mosque espousing radical and violent ideologies. There he found other father figures who guided and taught him. He was drawn to Allah, the ultimate father figure, one who neither abandons nor forgets. S lived with the traumatic recollection that he could not save his mother and that his needs may have contributed to her death. However, he learned there was a way to come to peace with these painful emotions. He could avenge her death. At the mosque, he was taught jihad martyrdom was a way he could find to right the world and to regain a sense of control by enacting social justice. He could go to Moscow and do there what had been done to his family. He would have to give his life to achieve this goal, but it was a small price to pay for the peace it would give him. It is likely he found a way to rebuild his inner narrative, and in this life narrative, his mother and all the others beside her would not have died in vain. He would ensure it. Her death and his would be meaningful. He and the other suicide terrorists would take the death they experienced in Grozny to Moscow and make sure the Russians had a taste of it.4 Maybe then his people would be freed, and maybe then the Russians would withdraw their forces. If there were enough brave men and women, they could give their lives for their country and fight back for justice. In doing so, they would gain a sense of control and wash the shame of powerless witnessing off themselves. Even in their dependent states, they could
62
A. Speckhard and K. Akhmedova / Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism
do something that would make their lives honourable and meaningful. S had found a way out of the traumatic cellar where he had watched his mother die. The Tasks of Adolescence and Terrorism Recruitment The tasks of adolescence are difficult in normal times, and more so in times of war. During the stage when an adolescent is often still seeing things in formal operations versus abstract thinking, the experience of war can complicate things greatly. Traumatic events often engender a primitive thinking process in which perceptions are narrowed to a concentration on the threat and, if possible, fighting back or escaping it; all else often recedes from conscious awareness with a great enough threat. Likewise, teens typically go through a process of alternating between dependency on and rejection of their parents. While moving away from the family and toward independence, the young person typically begins to see the weaknesses of his or her parents and turn to peers and others in attempt to distance themselves. When war weakens, threatens, and renders parents powerless, these normative tasks are intensified in their difficulty for adolescents. When there is no clear path to adulthood and little to hope for in the future other than to avoid death, fears coupled with the need to achieve developmental tasks can be overwhelming. Terrorist recruiters typically understand this struggle and offer a powerful family for the confused and frightened adolescent. Bonds of loyalty are forged in the form of Muslim “brotherhood.” This often achieves the developmental task of leaving parents, although in a unfinished manner, as dependencies are transferred from one to the next “family”. Then, escalating tests of adulthood are offered, one of which might be placing a mine where Russian armoured trucks typically drive and exploding the mine. For those who successfully ascend the ladder of commitment and violence, the opportunity to go to a jihad training centre is offered next. In this case, the teen typically separates himself completely from his family of kin, and joins the family of “Muslim brotherhood”. He learns to carry out a terrorist act, and trains in the mission of martyrdom. He is shown pictures and films of atrocities toward children, women and elderly men. His anger and his longing to enact justice are kindled, while the “family” ties are cemented through singing about Jihad and training with other recruits. In many ways, this experience differs only slightly from typical military “boot camp” training in which military recruits are completely removed from their own families the brotherhood of the military is forged by group experiences, and the values of loyalty and self sacrifice are instilled. Many young U.S. military recruits will openly admit that the service functioned as a family for them when they left troubled homes and were in need of guidance to grow into responsible adults. Recruitment of Bereaved Children In Chechnya, militant madrassahs often recruited young children from families in which the father has been killed. A mother having trouble supporting her children is often quite grateful that her children can receive education and at first may not understand the price her child will pay to receive such an education. In this case, it is relatively simple to play upon the vulnerabilities of the mother and the child. Without a father, the child is
A. Speckhard and K. Akhmedova / Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism
63
eager for a father figure. Likewise, when sympathy is extended for their loss, strong bonds are forged. Then, it is relatively easy to steer the child beyond traditional views of the duty to avenge the death of one’s parents into generalized views of revenge, and from there into the tactics of terrorism. Terrorism Recruitment and Traumatic Stress Responses Victims of traumatic stress generally feel very alienated. Realizing that their experience is personally overwhelming and incomprehensible, they know not to expect others to be able to be able to listen, understand, or bear their pain with them. When surrounded by other trauma victims, they often learn that to speak of their own pain only triggers reactions of hyperarousal, flashbacks, anger, avoidance and fear in others similarly traumatized. In attempts to calm their flashbacks and hyperarousal, they will often avoid things that previously brought pleasure and isolate themselves from people and activities that may trigger negative emotional states. They are typically searching for meaning and means to weave the traumatic event into their life narratives. They search for a way to understand and accept what happened, and what it means about the world, the self, and one’s place in the future. Trauma victims often feel a sense of a foreshortened future. They no longer believe the world is benevolent or predictable, or that they deserve not to have chaotic evil events befall them. They know that, no matter how much self esteem they previously had, no matter how much control they thought they had, and no matter how good the world seemed, it can all come crashing down in a dreadful moment. Trauma victims often suffer survivor guilt. They cannot make meaning out of the idea that others died when they did not. They are pained by their powerlessness to keep their loved ones alive, by their inability to act in frozen terror, or the failure of their actions to make a positive effect. Some are depressed and welcome death. All are seeking ways to find an acceptable meaning to assign to their experiences that allows them to re-enter life in a way that makes it possible to live without a constant state of emotional pain. L is likely such a person. When L was 12, her father was killed in the war. Her teacher reports that L immediately went into mourning, withdrawing from the others. She seldom smiled and never laughed. In time, she was drawn to the Whabbit beliefs and began to dress modestly in the hijab. For three years this girl withdrew from her normal school girl life, dutifully but robotically performing her school tasks while searching for a way out of her pain. On her last day of life, she went to school and told her classmates and teachers goodbye. She came to her teacher and begged forgiveness for everything bad she had done, making it clear in retrospect that leaving this life cleansed of guilt was very important to her. That day she left with a terrorist peer – another girl – to drive a lorry into the courtyard of the local Russian commandant’s office, break through the concrete barriers, blow up the office, and martyr themselves. L appears to have been propelled by the terrorist organization to embrace what she came to see as a meaningful death, which to her was more acceptable than the pain of her traumatically bereaved adolescence. While her teachers had noticed her withdrawal, isolation and changed behaviours, they had not realized what was occurring in her foreshortened life.
64
A. Speckhard and K. Akhmedova / Mechanisms of Generating Suicide Terrorism
Combating Suicide Terrorism Recruitment in Vulnerable Populations Recognizing the general, trauma-related, and bereavement-related vulnerabilities in adolescents, treatment professionals can be equipped to make programs to combat the influence of individuals who prey upon adolescents to steer them toward terrorism. Indeed, it is possible to combat terrorism recruitment, but it requires outreach and support on the community level. Unfortunately, the militant mosques are currently superior to any governmental or nongovernmental group in terms of community connectedness. While war atrocities, human rights violations and suppressed struggles for independence are all very real stressors, terrorist jihadists who prey upon vulnerable populations can be deterred. Alternatives to turning to militant religious organizations to find meaning, solace, and community following traumatic bereavement should be offered. While religion is the means by which most individuals assess life and death, militant fundamentalism is not the only religious answer. Likewise, recognizing the normal profile of traumatic stress through community wide education, parents and peers can be taught to help identify those individuals unable to move through the normal posttraumatic phase of avoidance, isolation, and alienation. With this knowledge, they may be able to identify individuals vulnerable to terrorist recruitment. Schools and clinics can offer treatment to traumatized individuals to help them find meanings other than offering one’s life in martyrdom. In the after-effects of a war torn and conflict ridden environment, programs should be introduced into schools and medical clinics that funnel troubled traumatized youth into group and individual psychological treatment. Naturally the programs would be expensive, but so is doing nothing. As long as youth continue to be vulnerable to terrorist recruitment and terrorist organizations continue to desire to wage war, these youth will be drawn to and selected into martyrdom. They see it as the only current treatment available for them to overcome their traumatic bereavement experiences. Certainly we can do better than that. References I Akhmedova, K. (2004) Unpublished doctoral thesis. 2 Janoff-bulman, R(1992) Shattered Assumptions: Towards a New Psychology of Trauma. New York free Press 3 For various descriptions from the point of view of the hostages of the Chechen terrorist takeover of the Moscow Dubrovka theatre in which this individual participated, see: 4 Speckhard, A., Tarabrina, N., Krasnov, V. & Akhmedova, K. (2003) Observations of suicidal terrorists in action: The psychology of suicidal terrorism. Journal of Terrorism and Political Violence. (In press). 5 Speckhard, A., Tarabrina, N., Krasnov, V. & Mufel, N. (2003) Stockholm effects and psychological responses to captivity in hostages held by suicidal terrorists. Unpublished Manuscript 6 Speckhard, A., Tarabrina, N., Krasnov, V. & Mufel, N. (2003) Posttraumatic and acute stress responses in hostages held by suicidal terrorists in the takeover of a Moscow theatre. Journal of Traumatology (In press).
7 Speckhard, A. Soldiers for God: A Study of the Suicide Terrorists in the Moscow Hostage Taking Siege (2004) in Mcternan, O.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
65
2. A Comparative Study of Different Developmentally Grounded and Culturally Sensitive Mental Health Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents Roundtable Identifying and analysing the mental health indicators of trauma - including emotional, relationship, behavioural, somatic and cognitive components - Different approaches towards the professional treatment of trauma in children and adolescents
William YULE MD, PhD Professor of Applied Child Psychology University of London Institute of Psychiatry UK
My experience in refugee camps on the Pakistan border, leads me to make this point: - We need to differentiate between a single traumatic event occurring in a normal settled life, and incidences of multiple stresses. The latter given the context of terrorism and conflict is the subject of this Workshop. I stress this because the literature tends to relate to single traumas. The reactions of children, when they have been subjected to violence, are many and varied. These are the sort of thing children told me about in the camps. The problem is that these reactions do not fit into the diagnosis of PTSD – individual behaviours and emotions such as anxiety, depression. We know quite a lot about children over the age of 8, because they can fill in questionnaires and so on – it is quick and cheap to do. But it is a lot more work to observe and interview younger children. Methods of diagnosis tend to be adult-centric and can overlook key aspects of a child’s behaviour, avoidance. We need, therefore, much more research on how children react in these stressful situations. We must pay close attention to the role of parental stress. Children are very sensitive to their parents’ distress. If a child and parent are involved in the same incident and the child starts talking about it, the parent gets upset – this often enough to stop the child ever mentioning it again, because the child does not want to upset the parent. It is worth remembering this, because so many studies of child trauma use the parents and teachers as informants; they do not ask the children themselves about their reactions.
66
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
It is our job to listen to the children. A recent study on disasters concentrates on the mother’s distress – a lot in it did not make sense to me, but it took me a while to spot what the problem was: Avoid using the mother as a judge of her child’s state of mental health – it can distort the validity of the evaluation. Upset mothers saw their children more upset than they really were, got more upset, made the child more upset and so on – it just extends the impact of trauma. When we repeated this study in Bosnia only using the children, it was possible to be far more accurate. Direct exposure to the traumatic event is also a major factor. PTSD is not a temporary problem. This came out very recently in a study of people involved in the Aberfan disaster 33 years ago where a slag heap collapsed onto a school in Wales. 29% of those traumatized still met the criteria for PTSD – It is not a transient thing – which is why we must take it seriously. When I first worked in Bosnia 4 years ago we were told to gather information from parents etc. When doing our assessment we encountered a lot of resistance from people working with the children – How would we gather the information? What would happen to the information? Is it just for a PhD? There was a lot of suspicion. There were many hundreds of well-meaning NGOs working with groups of children, but they were not evaluating what was said to them at all. UNICEF said we had to have evaluation. We trained 20 teachers in a 2-day seminar. Each teacher worked with 60 kids. The plan was that over 10 years, 600 children could be assessed. What we still need is more information about how the children’s adjustment is changed by psychological intervention. Not everyone agrees that it is appropriate to make a diagnosis of what is after all a very human response. Not only one discipline is involved in describing very clearly what is happening, how children are behaving. When we consider crisis intervention, we have to consider it in the context of the large groups we work with - we hear very moving descriptions, but only two interventions have a reasonable evidence base: 1. Behaviour therapy, including prolonged exposure and 2. EMDR Observation and assessing. These two treatments can be offered to many people because non-mental-healthprofessionals can be trained for this treatment.
Howard J. OSOFSKY, MD., PhD Professor and Head Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center Department of Psychiatry New Orleans, USA I should like to raise other issues of treatment: Close studies at every step of the way are vital – sometimes what seems to make common sense often does not. When we look at the literature on critical stress de-briefing, which is a popular intervention, there are serious questions about the validity because despite seeming logical and being popular, people were not gaining significant benefit – some improved, but some worsened due to the intervention. So I would be suspicious about recommending EMDR.
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
67
We need to look more closely at the benefit derived from different methods and timing of intervention. After 9/11 it was not appropriate to go straight in after the traumatic event applying cognitive behaviour therapy – victims needed a more supportive, community approach in the therapy than when we were treating a more discreet group of symptoms. It is a question of symptoms v. the diagnosis. When we look at parents’ reactions, there is a tendency to find parents reporting fewer symptoms in their children than do the children themselves... How much of this is the normal parental reaction in wanting to see our children performing better in difficulties? How much is it children protecting the parents and identifying with the parents’ trauma and not wanting to add to it? Children being ‘brave soldiers’ and reporting fewer traumas to their parents. How much is the parents’ own anxiety or depression related to their own difficulties in how they view the children even as good parents? How much are other societal concerns in play? – Is it safe to talk to people? – This is one of the things that often comes up in conflict situations, such as in Afghanistan where there have been deaths and loss of limbs as reprisals. So there is concern that if you say something then something will happen to you, you are putting your family group or community at risk. People are wary of speaking to strangers. We as therapists must be aware of this as we come into complex situations. One of the other issues is the prior history: Not only people who have experience of prior trauma will be in some ways more protective and predisposed to a re-awakening of symptoms, but also those who have a prior history of mental health problems will be more prone to develop problems after a traumatic episode. Some of the other issues were brought up earlier: After hostilities are over, what is the state of the community? What is the issue of refugees and immigrants? What is the issue of trusty in the government? How is the leadership of the government functioning? Do people have confidence in what is going on in their community, in their personal world? Another issue came up in the thoughtful and profound presentation on child soldiers – how difficult it is in countries, such as Mozambique, where the children are taken as soldiers and forced to kill family members, then when they get older and rebellious they will be crippled or blinded before they go back into their communities – those who survive. How different it is from the countries where the children of a somewhat similar age are ideologically a close part of the movement. These are issues of which we must be aware in our work. I would stress also that there are age-specific reactions. In my work with close colleagues in Israel - and other developed countries – they say that the initial immediate response is good – they talk about the excellent hospital response, the mobilization of the people to get on with their lives, the hope, the courage, the altruism, but the response to the long-term symptoms is less good. Studies are being done on the long-term effects – one sees higher incidence of mood and anxiety symptoms in school-age children – which would be expected in people living in an on-going assault of incidents. I stress that because there are things that each of us within our own culture would not look at in the same way. Being mindful of protecting the population and the culture may not always give us a clinical picture of the variety of experiences. For this reason therapists must be aware of cultural considerations – for example, what may be expressed and what may not.
68
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
Finally there is the issue of medication in the cultural context – when medication is appropriate, how to make sure that the practioners have an adequate knowledge of the cultural base model of the use of medication which could relate to levels of dosage.
Igor SKODACEK Mudr, PhD Klinika detskej psychiatrie Detskej fakultnej nemocnice, Bratislava, Slovak Republic
The phenomenon of group violence has been presented throughout history and is an important aspect of the last century. Violent behaviour presents a risk phenomenon for the entire human society. The natural base of society is family life; for this reason, it is the most important element of education. Family relations are the first ones and contribute to individuals’ formation of basic manifestations, habits, language, and moral habitude. Hereby we can find a possibility for deformity of personality, the natural development of a child, his or her morality, conscience, and justice. The signs of hostility and animosity together with all forms of violence may occur within the family, from typical psychic tyrannical maltreatment up to lethal physical violence. Home violence is more often an issue than we suppose. If this violence occurs, it has the tendency to graduate. The relationship exists between trauma related factors in children experienced not only during domestic violence, but also during war and so called PTSD reactions. The current denomination posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) points to our belief in stress as a cause of mental disorders. PTSD is pervasive anxiety disorder that follows exposure to stressful events. PTSD has three cardinal sets of symptoms. First, those suffering from PTSD re-experience the trauma (including memories, nightmares and/or flashbacks). Second, they avoid internal or external cues associated with the trauma. Finally, they experience increased arousal (including insomnia, irritability, impaired concentration and hyper vigilance). The duration of disturbances must exceed 1 month, and it should be associated with significant distress or impairment. Recovery from PTSD regularly occurs during the first year. However, approximately 20-25% of the survivors of severe traumatic events may suffer from chronic PTSD. We can specify causes of PTSD that range in duration and intensity, from traffic accidents to war exposure or holocaust. In the Child Faculty Hospital in Bratislava sixty maltreated children were registered over a five year span. From seven outpatient pedopsychiatric departments, we received the questionnaires on CAN syndrome and we have identified 374 children with this syndrome in a ten-year period. However, forty-one casualty wards exist in Slovakia, meaning that the sample could predict 1770 affected children. Only one thirtieth of cases are pedopsychiatrically examined, suggesting that 53,100 of Slovakia’s 1.4 million children (or approximately 4 %) could be affected by CAN syndrome. Some biological features associate PTSD with other mental disorders. Comorbid panic disorder was found in 13 to 19% of PTSD patients. Anxiety, dissociation and flashbacks can be elicited in PTSD patients by experimental procedures (such as administering yohimbine or lactate) that provoke panic attacks in patients with panic disorder. For this reason, we can assume a role of the locus coeruleus-norepinephrine “alarm” system and predict a positive effect of anti-panic medication on PTSD symptoms. In many cases, major depression in PTSD patients is diagnosed. It resembles depressive symptoms listed in the DSM-IV as “diminished interest,” “restricted range of affect” or
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
69
“sense of foreshortened future.” We can apply similar treatment with antidepressants and MAO inhibitors. The specific view on PTSD is the “opioid” model, which is based on the recognition that opioid neuromodulation is responsible for phenomena such as stress-induced analgesia and amnesia. Traumatic remembrances (‘spomienky’) usually consist of sensory and emotional states. After stressful situations, we may find higher levels of corticosteroids on receptors of hippocampal neurocytes. They change normal functions of the hippocampus and coding of time and space. Traumatic remembrances are in the form of sensory events such as flashbacks (van der Kolk 1997). Here is the low correlation between the content of traumatic remembrances and reality of physical, psychic sexual experiences or punishment. In emotional memory, the acquisition of fear conditioning is mediated by the subcortical path. This includes the sensory thalamus and the lateral and central nuclei of the anmygdala and thalamocortical pathway. Emotional memories may be stored “forever” at subcortical levels of the brain. Successful treatment of PTSD may not involve an eradication of traumatic memories but rather an enhanced control over previously acquired fear responses. Also, repeated processing of distressful recollections decreases the threshold for neuronal transmission of similar signals up to an irreversible cycle of spontaneous repetitions with gene expression, new protein synthesis, and neuronal spreading. This leads to the irreversible modifications of synaptic conductivity. These neuronal changes may be later expressed as PTSD. It is the kindling theory of PTSD. Studies of the hypothalamuspituitary adrenal axis have shown a decreased epinephrine/cortisol ratio, elevated urinary catecholamines and increased dexamethasone suppression in PTSD. Findings of increased serotonin receptor affinity imply that serotonergic neurotransmission may play a role in PTSD. Therefore, the therapy with SSRI is effective to some extent. Studies on antidepressants suggest that these drugs sometimes improve intrusion and avoidance as well as depression, insomnia, and anxiety. No study has presented the full remission of PTSD symptoms yet. In PTSD the dopaminergic brain systems are also involved. Yehuda et al. (1992) found an elevated urinary excretion of dopamine in Vietnam veterans which correlated with PTSD symptom severity. In some cases, therapy with neuroleptics is also effective. Studies on benzodiazepines have produced different results. Several investigations described a specific effect of alprazolam on intrusion and avoidance, despite a modest effect on anxiety. Clonazepam and buspirone improved sleep and reduce nightmares, flashbacks and panic attacks. Open trials indicated that the mood stabilizers such as lithium, sodium valproate, and carbamazepine reduce irritability and improve impulse control. The pharmacological treatments require a prolonged period, approximately between four and eight weeks, to become effective. Pharmacotherapy alone is rarely sufficient to cure PTSD. Therefore, the psychotherapeutical approach is applied. The various psychotherapeutical advances in child psychiatry are in the form of play therapy. The core behavioral conceptualization of PTSD identifies classic conditioning as the mechanism linking the symptoms of PTSD to the precipitating trauma. Increased responses to cues reminiscent of the trauma are followed by operant conditioning. Perception of controllability and predictability and the subsequent attribution of threat are central to the development of the conditioned responses involved in PTSD. Such perceptions of trauma should be addressed in therapy along with desensitization (gradual re-exposure to the conditioned stimuli-cues or flooding what is massive re-exposure to the cues). Prolonged exposure to cues had greater efficacy in reducing PTSD symptoms. Maginal
70
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
desensitization was better in children; it was associated with reduction in nightmares, flashbacks, muscle tension and readmission rates. Also, brief dynamic therapy, hypnosis, produced measurable improvement. Desensitization of one traumatic incident does not extend to the other traumatic incidents from the same event. From the psychodynamic point of view, the therapy should include ego-supportive maneuvers, address vulnerability in character structure, and involve the therapist in the role of participants rather than neutral observer. Based on our experiences, empathy is crucial in the psychotherapy of children. This we can apply in group therapy and family therapy. PTSD patients often perceive their life experiences as fundamentally different from nonvictims. Alienation, isolation, helplessness and mistrust reduce PTSD patients´ interpersonal and social competence. Therefore group therapies have a major role in the comprehensive psychiatric treatment of PTSD. Expression of violence, fear, suspiciousness, or tension within families of PTSD patients may extend to future generations. Family members’ reactions may reciprocally exacerbate the patient’s condition. Hypnotic induction and other suggestive techniques are used especially in the treatment of combat stress reactions because they improve avoidance and distress. Hypnosis for adolescents must be used carefully due to possible development of severe dissociative states. In Slovakia, we prefer to hospitalize children with PTSD symptomatology, often in response to depression, substance dependence, suicidal behaviour and violence. We use a variety of interventions such as group and milieu therapy, individual therapy, counseling sociotherapy or pharmacotherapy. The length of hospitalization varies and is up to 2 months. After hospitalization, rehabilitation is necessary for concentration to work, to learn, or rehabilitate the sports skills, and so on. To draw conclusions, we can say that it is necessary to support the superior effectiveness of early treatment, whether pharmacotherapy or cognitive-behavioral therapy. Every treatment modality which has had success can often be of great significance for the patient. Evidence of synergetic effects of pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy has been reported in up to 70% of the patients (Bleich, Siegel 1986). Patients with PTSD can expect to receive substantial help from therapists but probably not a definite cure. This is also the problem for self-help, religious organizations, non-governmental institutions and municipal authorities.
Armine GMUR KARAPETIAN., PhD Center for Psychological Services, Yerevan, Armenia My experience with traumatized children dates from the devastating earthquake of 1988 in Armenia. 5,000 died, 500,000 were made homeless. The first psychological centres in Armenia date from that time – we did not have any psychological centres or hospitals. It was a very difficult period and it needed great courage to create psychological centres in Armenia at that time. The earthquake was a natural disaster, but only 18months – 2 years later Armenia was involved in war with Nagorni Karabakh. It was also the period when the Soviet Union collapsed – the whole system collapsed. ‘Big Brother’ Russia could not give any help because Armenia wanted to be independent. So, different socio-economic factors made the situation even more difficult.
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
71
The earthquake caused mass traumatisation. There was a general sense of insecurity and helplessness. There were several elements: 1. Feelings went back to the history of our nation, particularly the genocide – this came up in all the therapy sessions – “We are a punished nation”; “We are helpless”; “Worse will happen” – there was a real expectation of future incidents. From a cultural and political viewpoint it was difficult to help. There was little trust towards the foreign professionals who came to help – “How can they help us if we have such a traumatic history?” 2. The role of the child in the family – Armenians think families are child-centered, but the paradox was that adults were not sensitive enough to a child’s trauma. Adults were too occupied with problems and their own trauma – the children’s pain was ignored. They did not help inside families – it was usual to hear from mother, father, grandparents that if a child is showing certain symptoms, they were not identifying them as the symptoms of a traumatized child, but rather as the normal behaviour of a child whose mother has died and so on. It was rather sad, and made artificial difficulties to helping children. 3. The strong role of the mother – another paradox. In our culture, the mother’s role is strong, but in the family the father wields the power – so this created more difficulties. 4. Young children (under 7 years) were not told the truth about the death of their parents – “They have gone to Russia”; “They are working in Georgia” So two or three years after the earthquake, children were still living the nightmare – “Is it true? Is it not?” Children want to see the grave of their parents. Their need to live out their grief was denied them. 5. We still had the Soviet ideological heritage. We know very well that religious belief – in our case Christian – helps overcome the grief and losses, but at that time the Church was not exactly forgotten, but the values were absent. We were still in the old Soviet tradition. Armenia suffered the multi-traumatisation of earthquake, war and the collapse of the political, social and economic system. Psychologists who came there shortly afterwards noticed that the latter seemed to be creating a sense of depression and helplessness, particularly amongst the male population. We love our children very much, but it was significant that after the earthquake there was no respect for the feelings of children. The country was at war, and there was no respect for a child as a human being, a social, emotional human being. It was not considered that a child was part of life, experiencing everyday life’s influence on him.
Latéfa BELAROUCI., PhD Sidi M’Hamed Health Department, Algeria; Algerian Red Crescent Contrary to the compartmentalized Slovak approach, in Algeria we use a more global, psychodynamic approach to psychotrauma. When a traumatic event happens, whatever its cause, there is a breakdown of ties – the traumatic event causes a rupture. These might be community ties, where houses are destroyed, schools and mosques burnt – these are the reference points for an individual’s identity which have been attacked.
72
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
There is a rupture in family ties, when a parent or family member is killed or reported missing – there is the question “What happened to him?” “When will he come back?” When there are earthquakes, floods, mass murders lots of parents fled abandoning their children. The purpose of our approach is to the rebuild the ties – the tie of the child with its community, the ties of the child to its family. Identifying local resource people On the community level, the first step is to find resource people with whom we can work – whatever the profile of that person may be – mayor, teacher, social worker, imam from the mosque….We have put together a network, based on the principle that a psychologist or psychiatrist treating a traumatized child cannot work alone, because it is not the child alone who is affected – there is the effect on the individual, the family, the community. So, through this work in a network having key resource people. It is necessary to put in place an action plan involving all of them – because the way to approach psychotrauma is not just the work of mental health professionals. There also the social, religious, legal context, so we identify resource people on a local and regional level who can take part in this plan – all the possible therapists in a district or a region, establish links with these people, get ourselves known, because psychologists are not always well-thought-of! Then we start working towards our goal. Why group therapy works Here are some examples of work we have initiated in the different kind of traumatic events I have mentioned. The common factor is group therapy – why? The traumatic event, no matter what it was, was experienced by a group of people, if they are treated together and talk through the event together this helps them overcome the trauma – this is particularly true of children. For example, for traumatized children, we organize art workshops – this is not art therapy – pictures are used as a mediator in the relationship between the children and between the children and the therapists. Generally we work in a team of teachers and psychologists together. Why a group with children? A group has its own internal dynamics – it allows a child to speak out, and if one child starts talking others are stimulated to speak. Equally the group reduces the feeling of loneliness, because very often after a person has been very deeply traumatized, he has the feeling that he is alone in his distress – the fact of sharing it with his peers – children in the same group who have been through the same experience – can reduce the feeling of isolation. The final objective of the workshop is simple: it is to allow, through drawing as a medium for building relationships, to work on the traumatic event. This works well for young children. With adolescents, or older children who can verbalise, we organize discussion groups. I remember a group in a village where there had been a mass murder, one boy pointing to a classmate and telling me “His uncle killed my uncle”. You can imagine that my first reaction was panic – What would happen to the group now? Then I asked the boy “Who is he?” “He’s my friend”. So I asked “Who is he really?” “He’s my friend”. “What about his uncle?” “He is the uncle of my friend.” That is why I say that group therapy also can work with adolescents, giving the opportunity to talk through the traumatic event and put things into context – “He’s my friend”.
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
73
We also organize discussion groups with parents and children. I said earlier that very often in catastrophic or traumatic events, parents flee, leaving their children behind. Many children have told us this– I am thinking again of the village where there was the mass murder. Terrorists had held sway there for 5 years. The little girls were obliged to wear the headscarf, and those who did not were dragged through the streets by their hair. The fathers fearful of the consequences of disobedience would say to their daughters “Wear the headscarf”. So in relation to this parental image, we organized a discussion group between the parents and children, so that they could say what they wanted and be listened to. The children felt before that they could never say what they thought openly. It was the same for the parents – they could say “Wear the headscarf” or “Don’t go to school”, but did not dare explain that if they disobeyed, the parent would be killed, and maybe the child, too. This group helped to reweave the ties in the heart of the family. Using cultural practices to overcome trauma What we also have tried to do, taking into account our cultural practices is to use the mourning ritual. A concrete example: After the last earthquake, I went to the site of the disaster, to a village where a little girl had been killed by falling masonry. All the children I met – in fact all my information came direct from the children – did a certain kind of drawing. This helped me choose the best way to help them. The pictures depicted their neighbour, the little girl on roller skates or a bike, often her name, Naserine, appeared, and also the little girl dead. Shortly afterwards came the ‘40th Day’ which in our culture marks the end of mourning – in fact I do not know if it is cultural or religious. There is a ritual where the tomb of the dead person is built, a meal is offered, and imams read verses from the Koran. So with the agreement of the parents we organized the very active participation of the children in the ceremony. I thought the children’s pictures were wonderful, so we organized an exhibition. An artist friend did a portrait of Naserine which was put on show with the children’s pictures – so that we could get away from the idea of death, they had done some of the village after the earthquake. We invited to the exhibition the parents of the little girl, the local authorities who had helped us materially; flowers were placed at place she died with readings from the Koran, and then we accompanied the children to the cemetery where they could see where their little friend was buried. This was very effective in dealing with their trauma. This implies that the psychologist must agree to leave his usual workplace, waiting behind his safe desk for patients to come to him – but traumatized people often do not seek help. So it is up to the therapist to go out to meet them and make them part of their own healing.
Round the table comments from each participant and discussion following these presentations, underlined further issues: 1. 2. 3. 4.
The historical background is important Ideology and religion play an important role in how people deal with trauma There are pronounced similarities between different cultures However, there are surprising differences in approach concerning children
74
Different Approaches towards the Treatment of Trauma in Children and Adolescents – Round Table
5. On the subject of the benefit of group v. individual therapy - If the trauma was experienced as a group, then group therapy has been found to be very effective – the symbiotic effect is beneficial. Group therapy helps in identifying those who need individual therapy 6. Family and friends are powerful factors in overcoming trauma. Examples: During the bombing in Sarajevo, the most popular strategy to reduce stress was being together with family and friends. Young people were on the streets playing basket ball and dancing during the air-raid sirens. 7. The most important factor for helping children cope with trauma was staying in their own home despite danger during the bombing rather than going to the shelters – half of the people decided to risk staying at home. 8. It is essential to take care of the parents before you can start to take care of the children. 9. When there is a national disaster it is vital to raise awareness on a national level. 10. On the question of the evaluation of very young children, it was underlined that there are accurate ways of assessing very young children and treating them. Follow-up as children grow up and begin to verbalise confirms this. 11. Many European conferences are from the Western viewpoint and ignore the situation in countries like Ukraine, where there are not enough well-trained therapists, a great lack of any kind of information – not just for psychologists but for all the medical profession. There is a lack of modern information, up-to-date research, so the follow-up from this meeting, spreading information will be very welcome. 12. The therapy that has been the most studied is cognitive behavioural therapy. Others do not have the scientific basis, such as play therapy with children and child/parent therapy. CBT has been shown to be effective for some people. 13. Depending on the individual, a combination of therapy and medication may also help. 14. Use of medication in children can actually produce symptoms of PTSD. Therapists need to be made aware of this. 15. Even with professional treatment of many different therapies, people still have lingering symptoms of trauma. I LETH MD, PhD Professor of Psychology University of Copenhagen, Denmark Summing Up Mental health professionals from several countries have shown that there are very many different approaches and views on the treatment of traumatised children and adolescents. The following issues must be addressed by us all: Identifying children’s needs Identifying the assessment tools Being able to distinguish between the trauma of the child and the trauma of the parents Making a diagnosis Selecting appropriate treatment But we still need much more scientific research and information about who needs to be treated, by whom and with what kind of treatment.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
75
3. Collaboration between mental health professionals and non-professionals The aim of this session was to identify potential resources – people, places, infrastructures, agencies - by examining practical activities in the family and in the community to mitigate and deal with trauma in children and adolescents. Introduction – Trauma in Young children - Working with the police and judiciary – Building resilience in the family -
Introduction William YULE MD, PhD Professor of Applied Child Psychology University of London Institute of Psychiatry UK
When mental health professionals work with non-professionals there is a great need to raise awareness of the effect of conflict, terrorist incident and disasters on children. When I worked with UNICEF in Yugoslavia, a large part of the work was in raising awareness. We tried a meeting at which all the local politicians were present as well as the local TV cameras. While the cameras were on them they looked interested, but soon left – and we got on with the real work! Media coverage and political will are very important but are they truly interested? I was charged with collaboration within the community in Mostar to help build local capacity in a way that is sustainable. Group therapy can help to identify those individuals with whom it is necessary to do intensive individual work. The needs of the local infrastructure must be considered. The role of the school is important. In Mostar we spent a long time with the people who work with kids – teachers and officials, many of whom had been affected by the war. And we took account of that. The local people wanted training seminars for teachers and parents, so that they could work as counselors. We looked at the role of the schools. Then we identified a new syndrome – “Post-Training Stress Disorder” – people started recognizing their own symptoms! We also worked with specialist teachers already in the schools and gave them additional skills. We did a survey of refugee children in the UK – there was a high level of PTSD, so there is a role for trained members of the community in the destination countries as well as in the country of origin. A group of Western psychologists who had worked together and separately in Yugoslavia got together and said ”What have we learned there that could be used for large numbers of children in a future disaster or war?”
76
W. Yule / Introduction
- Training seminars for non-professionals work. - What is very clearly evidence-based is that there is a use for people, not necessarily trained therapists, but people who like children and could work with minimal supervision with a group of 20-30 kids. These measures are being used in the foundation we have set up in Norway: www.childrenatwar.org In the Greek earthquake this method was used and the children’s symptoms were reduced. So there is evidence that this technique is useful. It has since been used to good effect after the earthquakes in Turkey and India.
Developing Strategies to Deal with Trauma in Children J. Donnelly et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2005 © 2005 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
77
I. The role of non-mental-health professionals - the professional viewpoint The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages: Prevention and Intervention – effective collaboration with police and court Joy OSOFSKY, MD, PhD Professor of Pediatrics and Psychiatry, Louisiana State University Medical Center, New Orleans, Louisiana USA Children are traumatized by community and domestic violence exposure as victims and witnesses. Information on the effects of violence exposure on children will be presented including developmental implications, resultant behaviors, and the most extreme reaction, posttraumatic stress disorder. Parental and caregiver traumatization will also be discussed. Prevention and early intervention is very important both to reduce exposure to violence and to reach children shortly after exposure. Therefore, the role of the mental health professional as an interventionist with first responders such as law enforcement will be discussed as a way to reach traumatized children earlier. A model for mental health professionals to develop collaborations with judges and lawyers who work in juvenile court will be presented. The conclusion will describe ways to provide education and relevant information to police and the court on how to help traumatized children.
Violence exposure affects all children, even the very youngest infants who usually expect to be protected in their homes and communities. Children are impacted by their exposure to domestic and community violence as well as war, terrorism, and natural disasters. Yet many people have difficulty thinking about children, especially infants and toddlers, being affected as victims and or even witnesses to violence; many think they are too young to be impacted by the violence that they see, hear, or feel. The situation may be further complicated by the fact that often children, especially very young children, who are exposed to violence have no voice and have to depend on adults to take care of them and to speak for them. Young children are sometimes victimized by violence, and, if they are exposed to too much violence, there is a risk they may become immune and lose the ability to empathize with other victims. While young children may not always understand the experience of violence exposure, they do remember it. Therefore, it is important that we pay attention to their feelings and behaviours. Caregivers have a responsibility to help all children, particularly infants and young children, comprehend the meaning of violence,
78
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
especially since they do not have language to help them organize their experience and express their feelings. While we often cannot prevent infants and toddlers from being exposed to violence either in violent neighbourhoods or in their homes, we can certainly help protect them, nurture them, keep their hopes alive, and care for them. In this chapter, I will discuss what is known about the effects of violence exposure on young children and then discuss prevention, intervention and treatment strategies. The effects of violence exposure on young children Violence is defined as the use of physical force so as to damage or injure. (Webster’s Unabridged Dictionary). Trauma is an event out of the normal range of normal experience. Children are affected by violence exposure at all ages: however, less is known about the consequences of exposure at younger ages, especially about the long term effects of such exposure. Many people assume that very young children are not affected at all, erroneously believing that they are too young to know or remember what has happened. However, even in the earliest phases of infant and toddler development, clear associations have been found between exposure to violence and emotional and behaviour problems. Infants and toddlers who witness violence show increased irritability, immature behaviour, sleep disturbances, emotional distress, fears of being alone, and regression in toileting and language (Bell, l995; Drell et al., l993; Jaffe et al., l990; Osofsky, 2004; Osofsky & Fenichel, l996; Pynoos, 1993, Pynoos, et al, 1997). Exposure to trauma interferes with their normal development of trust and later exploratory behaviours (Osofsky & Fenichel, l994). Consistent reports have even noted the presence of symptoms in these young children very similar to post-traumatic stress disorder in adults, including repeated re-experiencing of the traumatic event, avoidance, numbing of responsiveness, and increased arousal (Drell et al., 1993; Osofsky, 2004; Osofsky & Fenichel, 1994). In addition to the trauma that young children may experience, it is also important to consider that their parents or caregivers may be numbed, frightened, and depressed when they are exposed to trauma. For the children, it is especially difficult when they cannot depend on the trust and security that comes from caregivers who are emotionally available; consequently, children at any age may withdraw and show disorganized behaviours. Older school age children often experience increases in anxiety and sleep disturbances with exposure to violence (Pynoos, l993). They have difficulty paying attention and concentrating since they frequently experience intrusive thoughts. They are likely to understand more about the intentionality of the violence and worry about what they could have done to prevent or stop it (Drell et al., 1993; Pynoos, 1993). In extreme cases, they may exhibit symptoms akin to post-traumatic stress disorder. Both school age children and preschoolers exposed to violence are less likely to explore and play freely, showing less motivation to master their environment. Studies related to clinical work with children and their families who have been traumatized, show that it is not unusual for the parents to be unaware of their children’s difficulty with concentration and school problems that frequently follow traumatization from violence exposure. Some studies (Bell, 1995; Bell & Jenkins, 1997) have reported that school-aged children who witness domestic violence often show a greater frequency of externalizing (aggressive, delinquent) and internalizing (withdrawn, anxious) behaviour problems in comparison to children from nonviolent families. Overall functioning, attitudes, social competence, and school performance are often affected negatively.
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
79
Much more is known and symptoms recognized in adolescents who have experienced violence exposure throughout their lives. They are more likely than non-exposed adolescents to show high levels of aggression and acting out, accompanied by anxiety, behaviour problems, school problems, truancy, and revenge seeking. Although some adolescents who witness community and domestic violence may be able to overcome the experience, many others suffer considerable scars. Some report giving up hope, expecting that they may not live through adolescence or early adulthood. Such chronically traumatized youth, often appear deadened to feelings and pain, with resultant constrictions in emotional development. Alternatively, they may attach themselves to peer groups and gangs as substitute family incorporating and accepting violence as a way of coping and dealing with frustration (Bell & Jenkins, 1997; Pynoos, 1993). Understanding the effects of violence exposure on children The impact of exposure to community and domestic violence on a child depends on many factors, including the age of the child, frequency and type of violence exposure, characteristics of the neighbourhood (including degree of community resources), amount and quality of support provided by caregivers and other significant adults, experience of previous trauma, proximity to the violent event, and familiarity with the victim or perpetrator (Pynoos, l993). How much a child perceives or remembers a violent experience affects the presence or absence of symptoms and the circumstances under which they are likely to occur (Drell, Siegel, & Gaensbauer, l993). Adolescent problems related to violence exposure have been most visible, both in the research and clinical literature and in the media. Less well-known are the problems that are frequently seen in younger children who may be exposed to violence as witnesses or victims. As mentioned above, a common assumption is that young children are too young to know or remember what has happened and that exposure violence has little impact on them. In fact, this assumption is far from the reality in that young children are impacted greatly even by hearing their parents or caregivers fighting through closed doors. The issue of the effects of exposure to violence on children is a topic that has been sorely neglected. Exposed children frequently show signs of posttraumatic stress disorder similar to those seen in war veterans who have been traumatized by violence. Although very young children may be partially protected from exposure to a traumatic incident because they do not fully appreciate the potential danger (Drell, et al, l993; Pynoos, l993), it is crucial to pay attention to their reactions to violence. Even the youngest of children are likely to show emotional distress, immature behaviour, somatic complaints, and regressions in toileting and language (Bell, 1995; Drell et al, l993; Jaffe, Wilson, & Wolfe, l990; Margolin, l998; Osofsky & Fenichel, l994; Osofsky, l995a; Pynoos, l993). As mentioned, in the most extreme cases, the presence of symptoms very similar to post-traumatic stress disorder in adults have been noted, including repeated re-experiencing of the traumatic event, avoidance, numbing of responsiveness, and increased arousal (Drell, et al, l993; Osofsky, 2004; Osofsky & Fenichel, l994). With exposure to violence at an early age, the child’s view of him or herself, the world and people in it will be impacted significantly. Because the child is so young, the rapid and complex changes that are part of normal development in the earliest years of life influence the infant or toddler’s perceptions, understanding, and experience of violence. The very young child’s capacity for perceiving and remembering the experience of violence will affect the
80
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
symptoms that result from exposure. If the victim or perpetrator is very close to the child, he or she may wonder whether relationships are trustworthy and dependable. If the child is exposed to violence repeatedly, the effects are likely to be more significant and/or severe as the child grows older. He or she will come to expect violence in everyday life, not be aware of other ways to respond, and, over time, may become immune and unfeeling about such exposure. It must be remembered that infants have very few ways of expressing their feelings and distress since they do not have language. Yet, the exposure to violence has special meaning for very young children. Thus, with violence exposure, frequent responses include difficulty sleeping, clingy behaviour, withdrawal, aggression, crying and irritability, eating problems, anxiety and fearfulness. Regression in both toileting and language is common. For toddlers, it is often possible to help them use words, play or drawings to express how they are feeling; however, the symptoms described above for infants are also seen commonly. Recent clinical data regarding interventions and treatment of young children exposed to violence indicate that early interventions can be quite effective in alleviating symptoms and that the symptom manifestations may be intensified if a child does not receive treatment shortly after experiencing the trauma. The impact of violence exposure on parents, other adults, and the relationship For some parents and children, the stress associated with violence exposure and the necessary coping with violence as an everyday event affect both the parent’s ability to parent and the child's capacity to form healthy attachment relationships (Osofsky & Fenichel, l994). Since early relationships form the basis for all later relationship experiences, such difficult early interactions may be problematic for the child's later development. Poverty, job and family instability, and violence in the environment add immeasurably to the inherent difficulties. Although systematic research has not yet been conducted concerning the effects of violence exposure on parenting and the caregiving environment, anecdotal reports indicate that parents who live with violence frequently describe a sense of helplessness and frustration about their inability to protect their children and keep them safe, even in their own neighbourhoods (Garbarino, Dubrow, Kostelny, & Pardo, l992; Osofsky & Fenichel, 1994; Richters, l993). While some parents will maintain their strength creatively finding ways to cope with violent environments, for others, the constant barrage of violence may lead adults to communicate helplessness and hopelessness to their children. Protecting children and facilitating their development is a family’s most basic function. Regardless of their composition, families are uniquely structured to provide the attention, nurturance, and safety that children need to grow and develop. An important psychological aspect of parenting an infant or toddler is being able to provide a “holding environment” (Winnicott, 1965) in which a parent can both protect a child and allow and encourage appropriate independence. Parents who are aware that they may not be able to protect their children from violence are likely to feel frustrated and helpless. In addition, when parents witness violence or are themselves victims of violence, they are likely to have difficulty being emotionally available, sensitive, and responsive to their children (Osofsky & Thompson, 2000; Osofsky, 2004). In trying to help children and parents who have been traumatized by violence exposure, it is important to offer support to the parents as they cope with their own trauma in order to help enable them to deal with their children’s needs. When parents live in constant fear, their children
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
81
often lack the sense of basic trust and security that is the foundation of healthy emotional development. Another burden, rather than support for parents may result from the traditional societal protectors of children, including schools, community centres, and churches, also being overwhelmed and unable to assure safe environments for their children. Several surveys done in urban cities in the United States designed to identify issues of trust and safety among a group of African American parents and children living a high rate of community violence according to police homicide statistics indicated that many parents believed their children were not safe in their neighbourhoods or walking to school. Thirty-five percent of the parents reported that they did not feel their children were safe walking to school and 54% did not feel they were safe playing in their neighbourhood. Only 17% of these parents felt that the children were very safe doing these activities. However, the majority (62%) felt that the children were very safe at home and 30% felt they were very safe at school (Fick, Osofsky, & Lewis, 1997). These data are consistent with the responses of their elementary school children, ages 8-12, from the same neighbourhoods, who reported that they felt much safer at home and in school than walking to school or playing in their neighbourhood. In clinical work with traumatized young children and their families, one of the first issues that must be dealt with before any treatment can begin is whether the child and the family feel safe. There is a dual problem, however, in dealing with community violence: 1) the continued physical reality of the violent environment; and 2) the continued post-traumatic reality for the young child and caregivers. Exposure to violence may interfere with normal developmental transitions for both parents and children. On the one hand, violence exposure may divert the child from his or her normal developmental trajectory. On the other hand, in violent neighbourhoods, parents may become overprotective, hardly allowing their children out of their sight. Yet, encouragement of autonomy is important for development and comes with trust in the safety of the environment (Erikson, l950). For families living with violence, children's growing independence and normal exploration may be anything but safe and, therefore, not allowed. Parents who are exposed to chronic violence may also become depressed and unable to provide for their young children’s needs. Even with heroic efforts, if the parent is sad and anxious, it will be more difficult for her to respond positively to the smiles and lively facial expressions of her young child. Depressed parents may be more irritable and may talk less often and with less intensity. All of these factors, although understandable, may influence young children to be less responsive themselves and feel that they may have done something “bad” to contribute to this state of affairs. Thus, supports outside of the family are very important for parents and children exposed to violence. Supporting strengths in young children exposed to violence An important, but little understood, area concerns the issue of invulnerability or resilience, that is, which children will experience fewer negative effects in response to exposure to community or other violence. Results from many studies of resilient infants, young children and youth consistently identify a small number of crucial protective factors for development (Masten, 1997; Masten, 2001; Masten, et al 1990; Rutter, 1993; Werner, et al, 1994). The most important protective resource is a strong relationship with a competent, caring, positive adult, most often a parent. The most important personal quality is average or above average intellectual development with good attention and interpersonal skills. While catastrophic stressors such as
82
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
premature birth, war, trauma, and loss can threaten the integrity of a child’s ability to think and solve problems, good parenting by either a parent or other significant adult that supports both cognitive ability and positive development and relationships will proceed positively even with adversity. For children living in high violence areas, having a protected place in the neighbourhood provides a "safe haven" from violence exposure. Additional protective factors include positive role models, feelings of self esteem and self efficacy, attractiveness to others in both personality and appearance, some individual talents, religious affiliations, socioeconomic advantage, opportunities for good schooling and employment, and ability to seek out people and environments that are positive for development. It is crucial to recognize that adult behaviour, especially “good enough” parenting plays a central role in a child’s risks, resources, opportunities, and, therefore, his/her resilience. Several studies have focused on resilience, a factor that has been emphasized which may improve conditions directly affecting a child’s coping ability is effective parenting. Werner’s (1984) landmark study on resilience describes this phenomenon as the ability to recover from or adjust easily to misfortune or sustained life stress. Resilience is often used to describe the following outcomes in children (Werner, 1994): 1) Good outcomes despite risk status; 2) sustained competence under stress; 3) recovery from trauma. Many studies, including those of Werner (1984) and Masten (2001) define a resilient child as one who is more likely to have an adaptable easy temperament and be more intelligent. A resilient child is also more likely to have a supportive person, often a parent or care giver, in his/her environment -- a person with whom the child has a trusting relationship. Werner (1984) found in her longitudinal study that resilient children who adapted successfully to adult life had the following protective factors: 1) An adaptable temperament that allowed them to elicit positive responses from caring adults; 2) skills and values that allowed for an assessment of the child’s abilities in order to develop realistic educational and vocational goals; 3) parents or care- givers who reflected competence and fostered self-esteem in their children or other supportive adults who fostered trust. Further, resilient children sought out environments that reinforced and rewarded their competencies and helped them successfully handle life’s transitions. Much can be learned from Werner’s remarkable longitudinal study. Regarding concerns about adaptive parenting, it is important to note that in her study of 698 babies born on the Hawaiian island of Kauai, resilient youth (about a third of the group) at the time of high school graduation had developed a positive self-concept and an internal locus of control. They displayed a more nurturant, responsible, and achievement oriented attitude toward life than did their high risk peers who had developed problems in their teens. These boys and girls had grown up in families where they had not experienced prolonged separations from their primary caregivers during the first year of life. All had the chance to establish a close bond with at least one caregiver from whom they received much positive attention when they were infants. Some of this nurturance came from substitute parents, such as grandparents or older siblings, or other members of their extended family. Both parents and substitute parents served as important role models for identification for the children. Masten and her colleagues (1997) research and studies of resilience were carried out as part of Project Competence, a careful longitudinal study following the pioneering work in this area by Garmezy. This study includes competent children growing up with little adversity, resilient children growing up with high levels of adversity, and maladaptive children who have
J. Osofsky / The Effects of Exposure to Violence on Children of Different Ages
83
not been able to successfully overcome adversity. Again, they found that the role of a good enough parent is crucial for positive outcomes in these children. Successful children whether low or high risk have a history of more resources than maladaptive children. Important factors for good outcomes appear to be better intellectual skills and good parenting. Resilience in children and youth is not created in a vacuum, even with good enough parenting. Promoting positive development depends on creating healthy systems for youth in addition to healthy individuals. Thus, parents need support from the broader society and environment for parenting, educating, and socializing their children. Further, study by Masten and colleagues (2001), suggest that future understanding of the impact of factors such as parenting on developmental outcomes could benefit from disaggregating global resources such as “parenting quality” into meaningful components such as dimensions like structure, warmth, and expectations that may relate to conduct, achievement and social functioning with peers under different conditions. The development of both resilience and protective factors begins in infancy and longitudinal studies have pointed consistently to factors in very young children that contribute to such strengths. Werner (1994) reported that 10 percent of their Asian and Polynesian cohort who had experienced four or more risk factors including perinatal complications, parental psychopathology, family instability, and chronic poverty before the age of 2 years developed into competent, confident, caring adults. These resilient young children were described by their caretakers as active, affectionate, cuddly, easy infants with few problematic early behaviours. Similar observations on resilient infants were part of the Coping Project carried out many years ago at the Menninger Foundation (Murphy and Moriarity, 1987). Clinical assessments of 32 Caucasian infants revealed an active, easy-going nature and few feeding and sleep problems. These babies were also notably responsive to people and objects in their environment. Resilient