Defending Against Statistical Steganalysis

"!# 465"798:5";< =>;&?"U7 < 79=>DW;AV3@C5"$&;YB3X"%(...

Author: Provos

11 downloads 751 Views 310KB Size Report

This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!

Report copyright / DMCA form

DOWNLOAD PDF

"!# 465"798:5";< =>;&?"U7 < 79=>DW;AV3@C5"$&;YB3X"%(8E'*DWDF8T),=>RZ+7H-=S<.0GI/2[\5K13JK/LMDFJK+ 7NLM=>D]O,P^=QB3P37 R?A798S5FP3;0B38TDF=>7 _ .Q/`13/+Kab*%]cY%EdfehgC%,bKiNdf'kjhe lmnko`p2q9r3o EESt>Fy"z|vv0FEvz|{0FyAS``TEz|v{2v0k¶2y"{>E{2` "vTkEEFv0vQy"wÑ:}2Fy"t2E2zv0±|vETv`20T{23Ev|wv0wxF ¶N2`Evv0Fv{}3Evv{Fvzfk{`"y"¥{¶{2k"E·"wxkvFv0yAy"}2E}2z|z|{2"t { s`ut2vx2EwxFvyA{z|{~Sv}2"2^F}3"kwEvw">{2z|0FyKvkFzfy"k{2{"hkFy"t2}2zft |vwz|*FNwt2zv`Evxt2`Et>2v zz|{*K· yk{2Tz|K"°±v{{>±yK{>Fy"2wEvkv |"TEv0yky"E{2v0"kEvFy"}2·"t2vzkÏT`ÒNTv0Evwxy">¡Ev|v0AyY"vµEt2`v0vSzf z|wx{yKFt2TvvwxF yKF>z|yY0CyA*yAyAF{>vy"fzf`{ E z|z|^Ewxz|2yYfv FEv0"yAvQyA{"T"F>yAEEvzFF"z|v000yA ky"T{2v0"{>wxEv0yA0 EsuvQt2:²zyA2yA||vfKF°FykSyAvQ{v0°±yYzfkEt2v0Fz|{\`EkyC}2w}3vv0`Fz|2w2 vSEvQ²:t>xy"Fwyk:v0F`vzFyz|TEEt>zyA0 |}3zfvQkEvz|{~Et>Evt>v&]ykT:E¡vkEt>yAw&v0t2`zz|22`wv0{¢suSkt>wv0Ewv&2`{2zEzyAEv0Ez|}>"yA{Z{Szz|¡v0t>yAv}2 t>yAyYEkz|v"{v0zv±{&²yAw· `zf{>`xzf¬>}2vQ|^yk SvkEv0u"®v0y"Ffz|t2{2">F"t>tyKE±t>Tv6vQSEFv0vSSuFvSS"w"w6{*E2v0{2{*zf z`±v¥{2v0AyK±²uv E}3t>vkEwxv0y"2zf{z²±}22t2Fz2}3`kv0Ev{¡"{hyKTEE>v0Ekvy"z{2±"Ekv0F"y"vQ}2yAt |v0"^ °±t2z²t }3v{2z|{2> E3suz|v0"t22{¦z£`z|}t2{2yAz|©2}3zfv{2ENª}2¨EwvQ§Tz|{2v0{>{*zfwvCF¤z|«wz|v wvSF}2wt2F`K`"`v0z¬3>EwyKv0FvSzfFk}2t2{>E`k2>IEyA©¥>"zfIF|zt2zfT{`vE¥z~kSEKwxv0"w6yAv0 ¸W {ÏCkz`vv{2{*v0FFzy"¥ (z|{2Ft2v´Fv0z|`{`2¥k{E2wxyA{*yKFzfk2{zfF¶t2zzf`{Zzf{>y~Z}2KF" vv0wFv02TFzf2y"Tw² wS`v0``vQz|2kw°±¤t2z®²t{>Ay"Eft>|Kv°wFt2vSvFt2v0`w¡3v0vw2`}2z|{2|K N}>Ev0`ESF"vQEE³¯F"FE²vQt2: Fkzf{2Ev ¬>Ó±vQvQZ`2°±{>zf2Ey"t2{*k&`2zf2Fv0¡TEyAFFKv*z|E{2t>kEFvt2v2zfz|F{*¶Ev0E"t>FyAz0yAA{F3t2vvwSK`"`v0z °±|zf·kt2vz|²zft´t2 >`z²AE~wv0zf`{>`zf¥`CvSFz|v0{:Fyµv0^°u¢yY¸W{ZEt>y"yA2¶2z`Fv0zfk{EvQuy"°IEv0v6Ey"t>{ v wEvSuv0`Az|2Fwt2hvsuFv0t22vu2v{>w23y"{kv0u>`2zfzf{>FIE}2F`t2SkvQ|EM>Et2yKv0Fy{¥EFv"|v0wÔSFy6hyEv0E2E`v Et2z`}2vFKw6 2z|2Fv zf}>}>f|v¡y">2TyKz|²2y|vT`vFv{2zz|yA{>zfE|t>zv¶k Ey"wvSK"v0wv0`z|2w Ewt>v0vFETy"v0f"vQvk:³EvQsu¶t2Fvv0T2E2v{>k2y"w{kv02>zfz2²wH±°±z|NzFtSFv0wyAvQEv0EF¶yAk v>Fvz²}>| ykSz|{2 Es¹yAt>}>vN}2}2fT FFvz|yA{2kEvz{*Fyµ¹z|0`yAv"*EF}2v0EESvQkE:z|}F"v0zf{6{2TF*zfvQEM²TyA"F{>yK`FTEz|¥t2T"vuEFzwSKy"k"EvF~v0Twy"F{´0vQK`°Iz|zfwx>vIw¡yA}2"F9vkv0I®EvTºFEF"vyAv Esuyt>t2]v y"zEwv}>|zfv0|yAS}3EvAz|"{}>}2}2FEvv0F`>EvS2{*vQA²E¯0F³y"{>su°N`t>"vwÕ{>¬>v²°H{ 2Nwwwv3vSEvEt2t>` "2&v0{2TFvv0²fvQyK:z|Fw²"¤²}2x¥EFK"Ö ×Akw Ø,v E}2zFTv0EEzvyA{>IvF"vNky"T{>EvyA*|`yAT{2zk "z|²yA}2{2t kfk{2µ"v6v0}>yAE2vQT|vv0{kEyA`{vE»v0S¼3½:¾]E¿At>½:v ¾ Ä£yyk`²zftZÁv}>FEvv{*>¶22Azf¯¡Fy"E{>v`|v0"SwÙEz|"{ {2ÚwEt23vµvTv0kfvvQ{2:v0Ez|F"yA{E"F¶t>EyKvQ¡T2fyAF¡TvQz|{ v03Tv¤Ez|t2wxz2yK`Fvv{Ez|{`Evt>Ev9vFzfwxwyAzf{>kvv9°±Et2t2vz|fy"v£wTE"z|2A{*v0zfA{>92yAyA2F|yvhEEt±yKwxy"zfy"{`{ E¥"t>vE¥t2vv6°Nvv0w6TµvQ²t2yA`{2z|{2k>v0suFZt>vEt>TvQv´SkS{>KkvwvSwEt>vQ `zf>>wÛTvQzv0E>FT"vQE Fy"y"zf{{¡À*¥F2v0z|À*²· 2|v0&{>S²¡t2 S*"T>v{ky"{zfy"wxEv0yAkv²zfyK{Fz|°±TEt2zz|²0t£suyt2wz±vQE°uFyYyA"k`v°NAv z|S{\kEFEvv0|Sv0ESz|{2Ez|´{2´`>`zv0²0ÝÆsusut2t2vµvµE°IvQT2fwvSz|Ft2k`E2vQyKEv0y"{¢Ü>v3 `vzf2>z|TzvQ vESyvQÁ"v0²z|S"Ev0z|¥"{µ"v0{2Ez|Fv0«t2Fvv±AÂ*y"hÃ£{"ÄI>3ÅÆvyAzft2}2wxz}>2y"E`"*v0vy"{~²¥t"EFyA`wx¥°NvyK|v"¶}2yAFs¹{v0Ev{*vvK yA}>|²|>y"yKyAzfF{Ez|TvEt2zEKt>y"° v Ewkv0"`vz|E2t2wv0 EÞwzf{2z|wzf«0v#w``zf¬yAEz|"{>CE¦Et2v\SK"v0 ßy"k{¢{2vS²Ft>t2y"v{2|v0"Fv0kEyAt2{ v~6TwFyA`E`zzfF¬z|00yKyAEz|"}2{F""}33vFEt2Evz|v0F&v0`A>{>F2t2yAv~{*¤SK2"zfv0F ">±{2v°¢wvEt2``v¥v0yAFNEt>vw w|zf·kv0v`|¡z|2wz|{y¶à2wkvQEvF `yAky"wvE}2t>fvkyA¹ kt{2y"v063yAv{>v0{«0v0v{>FSkF }`y"EEvQvx^vQÀ*á>yAK|°uf vykvFQEAkF{2t2vSF"v0F`F>v{>yK2EyAz|"{*{£E2KyA°uFyyA²32vMz|{2v0z6Ft2Evv09}2|«0ykvSFvQ6"wh"z|"{2t*vk£³t>Ä£yYwkv Ç ÈkÉ o`p2Ê±ËÌr3o2ÍTÊ É 3yKv0E2z|"`{Mz|{2 6Et2v v{SF*}2Ev0wvQEFyAkv°Nv0yA·kv{>¤Et>yAu"FEv ]Î y"FSvky"F{2t>"yKkFy"S}2"t w&w6z2{2Ezt>vyKFy"zfkT{Ïy"z{>²FyAS· z|zfv{>{>Zv}2Ay"ISt>vkz|Ð`z|{2¡t2Et>z| vv

z|yAw{t2HyAz|Efv0v±TfEy"v{6kt>Þy"y"2£w""vvQ¤²`FEzfyA>t>Fwv6v0*wyAzfwz|3{>wv0³2·*v0`2{>vQz|KyA°±Ev2fvQ|zfÆ`F0"FvIvEAt2kv0v6kyAT{2EC|z|f9²yAt`}2yAv}2{2EFvQkY:v0 F0 w``z¬3yKFzfk{ y²AO:yA}>kP }2}2f|t E{2*vy" ²vStv0EyAw,}>E"fRÖ Q)K|"K vØ¹z|{2}2F&Ft2"v{>}3"}2k{>FE`v"v>yAEfv0{v0Ew wz|{`z|¥"{2"±z|FTwxEEv0zyKx2FEzfFkvv{&|v0:FFFt2vzfkvkky"{E{2v"E¸W"z{ E"t>v0vFFz|MyAFw`2`2v³,Qy±Et2}2v¤Fvk}>EEz|`"Sz|{>vQy"EEAz|w{2v0`Fz|2v}w\z|{*z|MEF·* {>2K>°±S{vQF±²yAE{>t>`vIky"w` {2{2vQ"E 6kzf`{*FFy"zf{Ft2Fv&t2v6KE"²yAv{>6Tw¥"v0F`wz|2v0w~K"¸¯vEt>wv¡v0`yk`z|2"wv0FFyATt>Fv6y"y"{{ {2FyA""v&` vQ~`>"S>v¡Evz|{`F ¥"zf{2FwxµyK`Ezfz|Á3"v0{´Ev0yA{>3S"vQ`663EvSt2v¡°Nvvv0w6{FvQt22v`v0"Fzfkwzf{>vQy" yA°N{µ{>Et2v0Sv¶vQETFEyAv0"FSwk{>v02`zfzf2Ez|w"{>N¸W¥{kE2TvQwS2wxFyAvF"F¹v*Et2yAv0{2µk"E²2yA"}2kt v0/ TS T suFyAt2kvvEzv0±2E{2v±· {2·"Kv¶°±{&>TEvQ&FEt2xvvy"w6`kvvQ²&Ey"EEt2kv t2z2`v0{wvQ T wsut2v0v¨ 2zf2ykw` "v0FFyAFÛ2*vQÕ{2A · {2K° Ft2v¨SK"v0 ¸WE{ U}2S²v0y"MSEEzSvkS>Fv0FyAt2Ev0vNEvyS°NKk¶vS¹kw{>`vQ`zfEz|z|2"w{> °±yAzFFvt6vQyy"`Ezfzf|k&z²wyA`v0y" w¸¯ Evt>²yv""Fzfk*zf{>y"F|0yA {>{2zf{>t2"|z2yY¶}2z:F2Fv00yA{¡E¶`zFyA² {2áSvQ"KEh°N¡3vvuky"vyY{ZQY¤y"z|{kzfvkFyAEv>`{´f`vIE¥t2"Skv92S2"kz|t´wTE}>Ekt>yATFv¡Fzfz|kEk"{>E{Mz|"©0z|F{>t2®y"vuN{>vy"ww6f`vQE`vQz|zf¶2>`wÐAz|{2wwx}>zfy"kE{*t*" 2w{2`w`z`¬`v0zf6¬>v0zfwxCyAzfwxkv0y"³"v0y"6²·wxMyY¸`v0E{*v0E"zf¬v0y"yAIE²z|t>"{y"FAyk>:FFvt2Fv0z|ETv±Ez²t>yAE²t>y"yAS EyKv0ºFEvzThEzFt2vy"vfw6|K°vQu2>`±z|{2Fx}2}Fv0 T¥v0kFE³wÝEt>SyAk¤EF}2v0FSv0EEz|v{2F6"vIE²EyAt2{>vT¥`"vQFTwxz|E yA>fv²t>y"Fyk:Ev0EzTEz0 ²t2yAvQ²fE· "E{ 2wÝVÖ Q!Qz|{Øy"F`t2Ev6t2Fv0v0{*2E2z{>yK2Fy"v0x{ky"2{´zfFz| wxAyA£"v¡Et2 vCzfwxTEy"""Fv"z|{2suzft>Fv °±²yAt2>zfvQEzf|t²z · TyuEEz2}>w Ev0vw>z|2&3Av0`¯2Fz|Ty"2E{>zfF{2`z|2"`w#zfE{~vQ{*F>t2w2z{23zf}>v¥"y"F}kwvv0{2fv02FyAzKÁE"v"v0²QEsu t2~t2vv9²zf}2t2wxF yA"kk2Tv Ez|w{2kv0u`Eyz|t>2yAwTv0v0 EvQ`¥>kv0FNt2Ev&t>v}T{2v0v0>`v0AFE¯²y"yAE{>`²kt>w y"{2{ "2vQIw6Ev0E6t>kvvS{2Kv0"Fv0yA p p uÌÍTn Ío ¹nq É Ë q³o MË Ê¤p v{2®²">yKEFFv0y¢"6FÖ KEt>ØyKEvTzvQ|v0¡SEt2yCvF}>t2EEv&v0vS>>F`vSz²"6,·"²z|yAv0{~{F`y"t2"{>v¡wÙCK}"Kv0v0"ETw6v0¯6w`EFv0zfyA`«0Ev&z|z|2"wF{¢vwx"vyAá{2z|{ v wzfà2 k`z&`zTvS¬E `v0v0}k*yAST{>KvQ"^k"v^²uyAy¶}>wt*v0"`wz|F2}>wÑyAFFzv{2Twxkv{vQyA2z|{NvE2x°I{>v03`vvv{E·"vQv0:K}`E"vQv0^TuvQwSEFt>v0vSv`Qz|22¤{`w ¸¯ 2¸W²{ÏyA{>{>²k`t2kyAw{2kv0v0{ w^2`3w6Fv0t22vv02{¡¶zf{2Fk¢t2vv{2}2v0FEFv yA|v0Ev0":FF¶v06¡z|¶t22KEzfvQ°NFT±vv0"°±v0v0`z|0vQM3FvEt2vEt2¬}>v{>TFv0yA>wE`t>"vkv 3v0Tv0w3v022zf{2Ú±zf{y">`zFzfk{¤Ft2v2zf¶Tv0fvQ:Ez|"{`vS 2F;-6'6G!.E#"(H%;-$'8J&%I'K"%L+$)MNI(+*-,/./$'0#.(#!.1(#.325476'"%87"%&-9:.03(#;-<'874703'.=><9@?BA!(#CED }3v{>2"{&Et2vt2z2`v0{wvQEFyAkvTz|«vk

E§v0{2{*t2v¤¡z|f°uv6zyYT>FC²FtF}2v0y"F`{vkyASv}2v{*}2MFFt2`kvvykE²v0Tt¡z|S«E2vz|v0"S{AFv0"yk2Et>TvQFvNvkt2Ey"t2z2{2v6`"fkv0z|{Z·"Fy"v0}2fwz|t2t2v0z Fh`ESy"¡""{2Avk zEf`t>v"v6Ev0TS§FEyKz|2"Fz|{TE}>zzyA }3y"yA¹v}>TxE}2kFF}v0v0Ev0EvT2{*Ffzf²FvQ±z|y¶A{£{2`y&v0v0°¦SEKwvQky"vvSEFv0t2¡w`t2v02z`Ezf2z|{2w }2F v0y"E}>vyAFy""}2Sv }2su|t2 v£zf{2E²yAyk{>2T`¥"zfEFz|wx"{>My"S`kEE²FyAv0{SM¥wkEv0wxykT³2E²yAF>t2fv£v2Fvv0 `z|>yA{>E2z|"yA{>{*¹£z|2{yAEFt>y>v T`FvQyKSFFz|v0Ty"EzEz|±{2 0yAE>t2Ev±v0t2¶z` z|x{2Et20vyA}>v0wykS3zfv02`A3z|{2Et2v}2F`FvS"v0FNw°±v0z2Ft2zf2"w2 µ2yAvFy±2Fvt>FyKzfk9v¡y"y"{{\3»¶vIt>¼3z|½:2¾]¿A2½:v¾u{v0°±TEt>z|wzf|vNyATEEv&z| ¥*"3vz|E{2t>vyAy"2w|v¤"F2{*}>EAv °NwEvvv0F"FEvyAy"{x¥"FvÀ*v0À*22zy"²v{&· {f3S6vz|`t2Sv0"z{*2>E`{kzfv¥ {>z|Fy"wyKE¥y"v0v0"fkvQT9 FzfyA{Ez°±Ft2z|0z²tx®y}>yAyEEEzvQST>2|fy"0 zt2y~z|f"vµv0{2Ft2vvFz¡wv"E{>t2`v#}`xA6Ft>yKT&z|{2z|&y"22yK²`yµzfEz|¥""{FwyAyAE²yAzf{{>`T¥v"}3Fvwx{` ¥A`"Iv0F{kEwxQt2±vTFTFEyKvF}2kz|FT&v0EEzwvy"FvQ"`vzf}2>EFw¡t>"}3v6w vEE`z|vv0v¶}3z|fv|yA>{{>TE²"yKF{t2FvvFt2vEv6 `}3z|>v0TESyKz|zfF{2¬yx¥"F²FFyKy"wE{>zyATT EEzt>v0y"EuvuEEvQv0T²F9¥y"kEvu{2Et2"v£Â*y"Ã£}>ÄIyA2Å |vuzfwxAyA`kvSv¶Fv0¥:kFEzfwx{>yA02CyK²®yv0Fwt2"32v0k t E`SvQkvQ{*£E°±vEt>{*zfEQyAt6NIµ"`2 v£v0¤F§t22`vvS:{EÅ vQ`:2¤vv0wFFt2u"vÖ{ }2Ø`FFEFv0`yAEEvFv{vSwyvuKEA}°NvQvITSE}2zfv¬F*v0yAEF{2vFk{*y""9{>²yyA¥}2{>kt>Evw °z| ¥E"zThEzFt2yAv^Â*}>Ã£EkÄN}Åv0T¥F"zfvQFwxIy"yK{>9EtFyKt ¤>}2NF}2v0EEv0v"Fv0"{kvQ²MuFt2`v±vSFz|v0w:Fy"zf"kvk{ 9¥FT"FwyA TFyKFz|TEzy"EvQ²±>y"Ev0&"{&¥Fv0À*2v{S¶"2{*F0 |suFKyAt2°Fv ¥F"vÎ ±wxvQT:y"vQEzfSz|{>"22{ Fvv¡F"z|v{k*FyAEF`t2{2`zk"S²}>yAv0y"}2}t Fv0t2vxyAz|{>}2&Fv"`FFv0kz|FÀ*y"S2{2zzfET«0Ezfv0Ev0\vQuFy"{2vv0yK¥Fv0kv0T °NyA{6"FK·"v0z|{¡E zfz|wxv°yAkAv `FTt2Ev0vukvy"w{2"3kv0F>y"`}2zf{>t "M}2¸WF{ `SÎ vQvQE:³EyAz|"{>{¡×2zf{*`E°NF`v`k>zfkvv {2wv0v0°ÞFEy"w"vSvQFt2`®2ºEFv¡6z|Ewv0 }2zfFv0K°±"zfv6{2Et2Â*vxÃ£v0ÄNwÅÔ3v0v02{>`Sz|`{2`z|{2"Nz|t2{ z2Î `v0v0:{ EÎ z|vQ":{ Ez|>"{^°N2vN}2°NFvv0EEvt2{*K°ÆTFt>yAEKz°ÆFz|E0~yA³y"E}2vQ}2²|~zfE{ ²yAÎ {>vQT:¥E"z|F"wx{ 6`E6t>¸WyA{ }2 z|F2vv0k9v{*yA£{`yAvS{FyAv0|S EEz|"z¹{" 6Ft2TvuFyKEF²z|yATE{z¥y"k`EEwxvQ³²°I vuÎ >vQE:vNFzfEk { Sk E}>Fv0E"S z|`{ v0*Î zv0yK:FFzfkzfk{>{ 9z|{x Et>vÂkÃIÄIÅ#zfwxy""v±¥kEwxyKQ¹µv"{>f>2v

±E°Âkt>"zfvEt2~tZ{>ESyY"K{\yAyAz|wÕz|yA y"{>2E\|t>vyAÂ*Ty ESv0`>k`Ey"zF{2y v"{*k6FÖ "y"TØE}2v0t2yAkz{>yA&y"{>fE" A"«º²vµyA°u}>z|yAwt2Fz|v"y"6Z"FvQv0®¡²t2F{2Et2vQz"À*yK22Fkv0v0t E|`v0²zyYyAE"{>vµ¥FkN{2E"Ew Et2zvSv0{>y"yA2NE|2svFv2z|AT*³EvkEUTt2FvQSzfkTz|vv{>{*¡`F0zzfT¤{\E"Ft2EEt>Evz|vC"{`2z| FS{2FvS"Fv~¥2STkFEt2z|{2vv µTFyKv0FTz|TT¥Evz¦y"±y"yK{>T¦²y"²Ã¤·`¬2E«0yAwxky"yAzf{2{{HxVÖ SQ0k×KwØw`vQkE{´Ez|T3EvvC*yA {2z|Ek>"y"²yA}2y"t>{>z| E" ²kyA}>|0t2 z|suEvQt2²vt2¢{2z`Àkz|>FSv0xE²t>°uy"{2yY"`v¡¡E²t>yKyAEzTESz"yAwuw}2"F"{ }3vTEEvEz|*v0yA{2z|"{ E}>t>y"v6TFSz|K2k|vy"w}2vQF"`kzf>Fy"w¡wÆà2Et"yKvSv0 2wyAw3v0}22|v" 2EyAt>Fvyx¡z|v{KyAÂ*|Ã£>ÄIyKFÅ¦v"z|w6{>v EEyAt>t>kvv¶v00}2S´Fk"fs¹k"µ²yA`2wz|vSTYEEvQFFt2:z|2xv`t2Ez|>z"2E{~`vv0y"{uz|y"S{`{(¥Fkv0zfEwxTwxyAyKÖ kKFvØ,zf*k{C°±y"t2Ev0zFw² tzf3{2vQv02F`t2zfwxvQz2CyA`E v0v0{ z|`{`z¥"FEFz|wx2`yKEFz|zf"k{{ yA{>Skw}>yAFv0zfxy"ky"zf{>TEt2vk>Tv0Ekv0 su`vt2Ev v0SF:,EkvQ{2f£z9}>E}3kv"F²t>yAyAwx}h±EF t>yK`zvFw6SFzfwvQz|{>t>yKz|F2zf{22v{µ"z|{wEvQt>EFyAyA£kzfv 2¸W{zfF}>³y"°±TzfFEz|t22k`yAhQE0}2Ft2Fv0zyk`Fv0zf{>Th`E t>vQvMwÏ{2K"k³v`¹vy"EvQf*:F³v0E`t22v±{§2yA`{*²Åh22zvQ²E vw6vQ2`z|{2x}2F`Sv0F0*}>EvQTv0{kFv0&zf{ Î vQ:Fzfk{×> ¸W{ y"}>Î yAv0>SfEvz|""{ h2`Av°NEvQvN:E`z|vQ{2EEwz|3kvNEvy"{6E2v` *EF|vv{>2²t>v0y"{2":vQ,EIvQÄ¤³"Ev0t{yK9Tz| EEt>z|"v {w vEt23`A2Ft&u`Ft2v0"vv"|"Fz|}3"v0z|¶{>yAzf^{¶yAE{t2zuF}>t2y"v}vSv0 NEv0}>{>Ev0`"vQv {*u`,vSEFvQv0:Q

Ez|wz|y""{#}>{fv03y"wvµfkv0"yk{*FEzFv0"t2Zww°±wzy"F {>t2>"¡yK`E{2vQvZ°Ï²t>°±yAEzfv{>E|t\"v0z|S{2Ey´~z|"`{AzfFÁt2vFvFF&yAv{*E}>v0"yAz|Ez|v0`F¶v0{*0AEyAzf{¬E3t>yAvv EE v|Tv0E:v0Fwzfk{&¸W`{ ykvQI2`{>zfAE±z|"`{v3}3Fvt2{>v¡k"{wE}2t>`v²yKFkzfkTI{>yA"h¹zS`*v{*E"zf¥¤ Ezf{>t>v Et>vEvQ`2{>2y"{*u>z² EE§v0t>{2{*vvEEzyAvK³|yAv0f|:*z FEzfkk{xA £vF0z|v{`S}E¥kz|9"Eà2{wxkyKyA£Fkvzfy"k `zf{y"{wEt>}2yAEfvkt>kz|wy"{xz|E"vzft*wx}yAyA²kyKv6vEz|t2wx"v{´yY|}`z|¥2t>9}3yYkAz|{ v t2|yAv0FzF2v0yk`±fv0z|{¢·"Av09fz|{`t2¥z|""F¡tFwx3yK"vFwzf`k}2v{ZE|vSv0" `S¡EzfvQ¶^zf{¢6Ft>°±¸WyK{t2zk²2t#yA{wwv0z``F`t2`zvv0¬3 (yKt2EF"t2zfkv{>Ewv|"yAv0FFSvv E{2z|""³{~yYy"°ufyAkF"v9FzAF`t2Ew t>vTz|v0³v0kEz|k"{2z|{fMs¹Et2vFvFwv02vQ2`{>2Fy"t2{kzY2Fzft2FvIzyA`{>v0{kFz|z ¬su0t2yKvQETz|v¶"{yATTFEEvz|}2`ykF2v026±zf{>yKE2Ez|F0zfyK>E`v&EvQzNyEx2v0zyk²zt¶F| v0`²·k>v0{>2yAk{*±t22Kzf°0 `vEv0SFy"2fv²tyA{2kv0IEzfyAFv"

m MËËÍ É p>Êur/ ¹n*n suTFt2yKvFz|TTE}3zv0y"¤z¬3S~kEEF²v0yAS{Ez|"¥{>kEwx`v0}°Nv0{>vCµz|{*"E{µF`v`w>3SvCv0>E`\zf{>}v0wT¥vkEEt`w ``22¶{2EyAt>{*yA¡>`z²zFEz|su2`t2FzvµEyv0St2Ez|z|">{`vv{¢ }>w|y"vQzfE{>FyAkEt2vvK2"{>v0¶2vyAF|f z|E{2v {2TEv0v°¢*yAw{2kvS"Ft2²yA`}22t>uz|F¡vz|w6w}2vQF2K`"vz|{2"{¡}2zFQ` SvQEy"{>z|{*EF 2>SvQ µz|{v£y`z|*K"z`vv£uEwt2v0v92²zfy"2Ew ·"zf`{*vF6w3°Nv0>x`zfF{>v}>)t2S z2`v{zf{`¥kEwxyAEz|"{ yAE3z|"vC{wA`x`Fz¬v0`v0Ï>{>°±2yAzfE{*t>"`2zfF0` vSFv0Ó±:²vQyA`22|{>2y"`{*vS T ¸2`zfFv0µ{*Ezf¬y"{Ï kFyk`zf{>Ft2vSKkvuwv0`z|2w T wxsut2yKvFzfkEv{¡|v0E:t2Fkzfk2{|¡A3v>z}2²Iy"z|S{¶vQ^°± t>z|²t¶Et2v t2z2`v{&zf{2¥"E |Î Kv0°}>±yA²¥yK"F zf{2v0ykTE¡t>v±Fvv}2wy"3v0v>w`vzf{>{*0}>®ÞE`S`vQzfEÁ³vz|F{*vE{* 2°IyA Fy}>y"¥"T²F9wyAyAf

!#"$&%(')!#"+* ,*.-/01&2&'. !03"!54

¸WE{"2"²v0S{2vv`²yAv0},`v0z|{>22v{*E"zf¥{ zfF{2t2v6EEt2}vvQSFzfv0¬`>k{>`2EyA}2{*22¥zf"FFwxA9yKQyx2§yK{>²yv t>}3ykv{> ±E°±t>3vv{yYE°Nt>y"vEv6SKE"t>v0yAuwEt2vQ`vxz|2v0ww 3zv0±2°±2Fzf{2zEEv0yk{¡:Fk>`yA|fz|{t>Et>yAyA}2 ¥z|{>"FSwx|>yK`Qv "I}3"v²{ yK"Fv0zfFkE{>zfk£{|z ·"Ev&E"t2wv}2¬>F{v0yAF9Tz|2"yK{M²kyxyA{¥kEwxzIyK{>AwI{>zfkv0t*: Ev02t>Fy"Fv{kyA¤SFzfK>|"¡z²v0¤2IvS3wEvSv0vQ¥E"`wFzfvN>z|{2wHEzt2vFFz|v0y""À*: 2Fz|>EyAvQz|I{2z|· wF{2vz|"K«°±z|{2|wv0¡2v0w"2v zf 22Aw©Mz¬Fz0t2¤yKvSFFzfFkv0v0{>yA`E±2v0F{2 "à2yA{}3kv²vSyKE 2yYFy"zfkkwv0{>u}>Fft2vkz|{ 2v"EEkt>vQfvk`v02§{>`2:z|y"{¢Å {*2Sv0F2v0FzfyAFEÖ z| {2vØ³~{>E`F"t22Fvv{*wÑFkv`F}Ev0}2v0^T2 ¥¡kà2Ek"wxvE0y"t>Sfv Â*`Ã£zEÄIEÅ©vEvz|wxS*yATkz|v{2v ¥"EF²wxyA{>yKTQ¥"FFt2wÔzSw vz|U"t*zfv03{kv6²EÚ2t2Ev vv ÎÎ vQÒ :F"zfk¤{ Et>>v 2su`vzft2FE±vvF°±t>wt>z|2zfv{>2{¡z|vEEw {Zt2vz|zf{`{¬¥F"{>t2FyAvIwxyKk"F`{ zfEk"}>{v0`FKEz|kz|"±v{ F°±}2EvQEE`yKzfEFvQv0v0^F¤EQt2su°±vt2t2EzzuvQ²t`F2v0À*{>y"22{z|y"EyA{*vQf °uyyY}> Ev>2vIAv¯{>FEy"2{>F`v0"w { E2v0w6}2|ykv0Sz|{2"v0{2²yAv{>²yK2F""w# E}>tEyK`SvQzEEv0z|{2Mz°±Fz|zy"Ft ¬>z|«{>v0y"ES6k{*Et2kvv²FTyAz|"w{¡vTFFvyA}E v¥"IEt2vz`v{*Fz¬0yKFzfk{&yA{xEt>v EwxÒNz|"vSyK¥{FkzfEkTvE{v6F}Mt2 suvEt2t2zzv0`¶vz|{*{`yAF¥Fz"v¬>FvQwxy"{2yK{22E"z|zf"FF{yK¡Fv0yAzf{&FSv|°±>}>z`Fy"v0t¡FTykvQ|2´``²E·"zfE~vQz|"F{>t22y"vzf^F0zfE{2¤v¥|¾ "v0SE 2SvQzfFEM0AEt>yA{yA³6wxyyYt2 v>{2EAz³Fz|IvIFwt> yK92z`¬>vSvQFvFz|w{zfE{2t>vQv£hvt2w6K°CvQ2``vEz|{2vQ:F}>y"2E"|v ²t>y"{2"vQ£Fy2zwz|"t*3v" ® 2zzC|`²·"v0ª°±t>v{ÆFt2v\2zt>yk´y"fFv0yk`Þ3vv0{

76

98

;:=<>:

>°±Et2v0v0µ{¶Fw"Fy"vEFFt>yAt>{&z|2"2{2vv {wz|{`v0F¥"Ey"Fwx"vyKz|FNzfkt2{z2`suv0{&t2z|z|{Fy"t2{~v`SKS">v0 wv0`z|2w

+ %! "*

* -3 "!54

NÒyA{vS¥ÓkE>v¶Et2TEvFv0Ty"v0wÑfvQ:Fzfzf}>kt2{#vA6Ö KEØ³vQz`2z|{>{22zfEy"z{*yA|&zf«02v0zfF°±zfEy"t{#yx3>vkEvzf{E E²²yAt2{>*v`T{>v0k{wE T}`{ vQS92FwFvSt23vv·kt29vzkk2v`{2µv0v0{Fv6yAwE"v0TFvE]y"EÃIt2"Óv±vßyA·"{>v0Å x"¹v02¥kv³FzfFEkEt2vuvQvyAywÝE}>v|TSv0v0z|S}2>Et2`z|"v"{ ¥E}2"t>FFv`wxSt2v0yKvFF|Izf}xk¥{EAk3¥wÔFE"t>w¢vzQ¤}>EEt>suvv¤t2>t2v`z"22,`zf²FvyAu{{F`wt>"yKvQwÏEFyA{ yAF2kv w6v¤EyAv0F}2v0v¤|¤ykT"Sv0v0vQfvQ{2:vE°±²vQyKzfFE"t¡°±¤zzfF{`ykt ¥"| K° à³yzf²T"0{>¤0°NyKEv¶v0{>{2yKv0Fv0zfk{EAt>z|y `vQ!K× ¯2zf&²yKTFv0v&v02zfy"F0{>~Zsuy t2Q!vK¯2²yKz&Ev&zf{`z| EÒNv0C"v0KyAF" {*zf{>Fy"zf{>Ezft2{2v¶EEvt2vQv|vEt2{2v"EtµEv|Av0¤SEFz|t2"v{t2zy"2{`v¬>{µ{>wv0yFE3y""vSTvk EEv0t>v&vzw6`v{*vQF2z¬>`vQz|{2C>> zÎ²v~|v0SµEz|"v¡{2vS²EyAv0EEFwz|yA{2±v&EEt2t2vv3{2vvk *zf{>{22zf{>zfx A SyAk{w~}2y"`2E`z|{2z|{2µyFt>²yKyA6{>2A"Á^wÕTvAÁ^ETvEt2°±v¶zfEt22z|F{´Ev0y{k¬2> `zv0C}zf*{*TEzfv0EEz|"K{y" ²s¹yKyA{>F`t2"kvww {2}2v{ `°Ñ2Fvw62Ft2zfv0v6}Fk*y"v{>T{2zf`Ev0z|kF"wÔyA{EkAzxÁ^T`Evv0v0F}2F0S*y"F°NzfS3vQv v0C>°±Tv0v zfyAEFFtt2|zfvv0F0t2}> vTv0w>yK`vQ²"y FFv0yAE"2vF>zf{>yKFy>>zsu}3t2kz|EzF}2zfFk {>±v0Fy"{zzfvEvF²vyK}2FFv0v0~Ev× {*&Fv0E¶z|wykvQ sut>v ¥" Q °±t2v0ENv zyz|NFFy"t2{>v`"}wH*TzfAEÁ^z|"T{&vuAz|¹{¡Et2Et2v v,(z|F{*t&Ev0EEvK|yAv0S¤EVÖ v0Q &22Ø¯zf 02y"{> ²2®±yAzfº{>Fv`EMvkvQEwÝt2^v£{*T>suFwyAt2Ev3v¤vF2vyAwx"Fv0yuy"{2zft>{2vyk²z|{2yK&F"v0fvv0{{2z Av0FEwtvQ3TAv0v0v092`F`vQt2vQv^Q°±t2Ez|zft2>Etv£`v}>E{Tt2v0v w>`Q)vQ"A ²wxFyAyAyA"{>z|v6`{2kz|z|{2wÐx>{ E2v02yK²w6y2E v0Fy"&2y"yA}`FvF`t2Fv6yY°±z|{*{Ev0FE~KyAE³t2"v2yAw"£"2°±{*t2¶z²"tEEt>vv

1

1

!

`yAI>v0t2{xf vxkwFEv0vQz|{2`EFx>yA{>Ek2t>vyAv6T{*z|z|«{*vuE2vFzfFFK0yAy¶³wxµzf{yKvx `Ez|t2vSw `z }22w©°NyAz|yY{A¡zfE{ vQÎ FEvQz:":F²3zf±kF{t2Ft2v&v6yYK°±t>yAz|t z|f EFt>v0`z|62{z|62yA{2{*"2yzfFE±vkFz|zf"k>v0NFEt2vQvFETzv0:fFvQzf:kF{zfk{¡ß}>AE`6SvQTEz|u{2yky"EfvQIyKEEt>v0v "z|{ }>}Î kv0:TFF2zfk{2{xzf×2 ×2FM¸¯¬>N{>yAxTy kfvQ yY "vQhv0wv{23kv022"2tzf{22zfF*hyk¥¤k`hvQEEt2vEz|"vQE FTFv0yK:FFzfz|{>TEzF0F y"{>T¥"Fw E}2Fv0EvF"vI¥EvQÀk>v{>Sk2{*hy"Ev0 }3z|ÒN{2kv0F0TFyAz|t2>2vIE|vv ·kvEEk¶t2¹v¬>suÃI{>t2ÓvIßEEt2vQÅÞvSz|}2t2z±zfzv02·"{*`v0¹v"{z|vQ{2&zwF°±z|v0y"zfFfEz|Et«y"vQ"yxvFEt2°±v0vuzfEEÃ£t2v0Ók2`ß zfÅ·*z±{>°±K{2z°uF"t EFtvSEyKFz|vE"v0vIEEvt>6vNyAt>{z|22v>{TvQwvQFEt2Fv&yAkFv£yAw¥F"v¶w EvF|t2v0Sv±Ez|"Fv{~k}2Fw`Sv0v02Fzf2wF 33suvvt2vv {Tzf{*vQvFw6vFEYvQy"2F3`v0Ev0Ez|v«vQvEzuEt2²Ft>vt2yAv}>{>E"v²v0yKE`v6kA{2¯z|F|y"F{>vSyK`EºkFEz|v0wÑv£KyAF{ t222v|w6v²y"yKv0{>Ev "t>vy"{2yk{ v²yKF"±SkEFv0SE|"

'&

3 ($ %("+'(/ 4 11&" *)

*.- !,+.- /0/21

µwv0v`z|{22KwÏ°Ð0yAv{ }>3|vIy"zfF{ªv0`t2KS° v0w°±z`F`tzf¬Et20vuyKEEz|v"|{v0µ:FzfEk {EyAt>|"vZkESzfKEt2"v0w ¥F"wÔFt2v}2Fv zfk>±Ev0:Fzfk{ ¸W{ {2wEt>3vv9Tv0kfvvQ{2:v0Ez|F"yA{Ek}2³F0`yAS{vQE30v±FFv0t2Evxvv0·"2v0v0"v0µ°±zf}>EEtxvy`¥EAv0¯vFy"|{>`²t2k"w AEÄ£vIyk{zf²{>t´Q)2Av},}3>Tv0vz>{>``EvAv0vQ{*¯^²yA{>}¸W`T{v0k>w v`Á3AvQ{ ¯:²2QyAw>{>F3`t2vkv6w Ekv{ vvQ2{2w6v0FSyAFv0Ev0kyKFkv0Evv{2y|v0v0FS]yAyAFEwxkz|zfFfF0 Kz|{°±yx{`T2zÁvTFvv{*A¹{ F2v0w622{>v02y""{kh±>2z²zfF±0E£tsuyKt2vt>EyYvk|v v0SEEz|"3{>vuwFv0`E2`fz ¬>z£vQ2^z|³{2sukwt>vuzyA2,z|9TEsuFt2zf>v`}>Ez|E"k{>yAA2z|E t2zvu{ E2twyK 3xv9A" 3²t>2y"zfF{2I"°±vQz|f2zf3Fv ²t>y"{2"vQ¶z±y"N¥kf|K° 43

65< 798;:

>=

6

Q

<

A

6

5

8

<

°±Fv0t2`v02E{v 2yA{*z|±E2t2yKv²y}2Ft>"y"NyAF2xz|fzv²Et>ty"yK{2"yvQ^Tv0 fvQ:Fv0¡2zfzf{¡Et>v ®TEIFv0FyAt2w¨vt>z|zf2}22t>vv{Q2zfyK¡²yt>ykt>&ykIEt23vµvv0}2{¶Fv0"{>}3SvFE E}`z|v0E&vQA6 yCEFt2y"v{>Ó`">w TyAEkFvv0yA{ w2w T3v°IvA¤vS `²t>}yAvQ{>:N"v0Et>yA> z²°±z|f¹ yAv{S|Ekt>EyAvIEF t2vyYkvAE z|{kFvFKyA Fv&wxFyAvz|wx{2z|yA{2z|{2z|f{2v0{2AEFvQt`2A{>¹>wyAvQ{*E±FyA2kz²v Et>v2z²±z|{&Ft2vt2z2`v0{>yKFy> Esu>t>t2Tv~Ev¡vQ"T{2v0|fv#vQ":v0E`Ez|"zfÁ3{~v0v0Ezf}>kv0Et*{>`SSvvQ2Ez3²vSz|¡{2"{*suFt2zfE{ zt>2yAvQ°NyYEy"t2v~Ft2"z|`v{*FEt2fv0z|z{2E2KvQ`yAv0{yAz3wKy""vQ`vk E>Ã¤t>¶zv²· E|zfK{>°IEvQv0y`¶>Ev0v{>vvQZEt>"Fvt>yKE{ 6t22vµEw6v0}22Ez|v0{2vQ&T"v0w"{*zFyA2zE²t2`&zv&EF²t>Et>z|yA2yA¡`{2Ft>kzfyYv0kk{#v2yAEzf|FK°3yAv FyA"v z`zFEz|2`Fv0¡vkv{2|K"v0±yA|yYYy"zfyA>fv 2zfF0 w``z¬v0^Ú2Evvà³zfk2Fv Qk³¸¯±3v0"wv0ut>y"F2vIEx`vSFv0S #"

%$

3@?

6

6

B&

EyAt>|Fv v0y"w2``{>zf¬yKFyA2EFz|y""f{>|0`Fvy"}2IFwv0E"vF{*vFv0"6Ezf{t2vEt>t2v±z2E`vQv0`{¶2{>w2v0y"F{*F¤yA"2vz²z| F® 0v Evy&v02Fzfv0{2E2fE0t2vµwÃ£kEÓvß wÅ ``¥z"¬3&yKEFwxzfkyA{>|fv0¶y"t2{z23`vv0{#yY"wkz|v02Fv0FyA" vQ EtAy {¡¥"±2z|"kvu"{>v00 vzf¥{vQSy""EEt2>2v¡{kEFz|}2v{2FFv0"µ>Et2y"z|2v{zf|TEzfFt2yA v¶{2EvyAE|²v0t>CSyAEz|`"v0y{ z|TTyAv0EEfv0z|vQ"}:{CFyAv0|"fK>°²zt>y">t>{2y""vQEEµk2vzf3FEv w``z¬v0y"±Et2K°±{¡zf{à³zfk2Fv 2 à2yA>>fTvFt2EvFw¬{>"Fv"y"M{ µvw6KyAFvQ*2z|`{2z|¡{2Et>Fv¶t>yKTv0v0`µ v0Ft2v¶{2AyA|"t>kyYE"zfEv6t>wS"{2z| Ü>Ez|z}2:|²vµ°±>yKzfEFtyCfT`v²F·k&v0°±z2Ft2zfFzf0{\yCsut2zK"yAv¶|fKw°vQ`>z|2wE¡t2°±z|t22zv6²tZw62°Nv `zE>Fuzf{ Î vQ:Ez|"{×> 2 0.014

6

Binomial distribution Selection for different seeds

0.012

6

Probability

0.01

0.008

0.006

0.004

0.002

0

¥Eà³"z|zf"±k{2`F°±zfÁv zfvEQFt vS¡{*Ã¤uFE"v>vQ2*y"×u2z|SfzkyAwµ{> }2yAz|FTEv0Fxzf>F ` Ey6z|"2{z|{2A"w²tzyAyA^{2`kzv0~FEz|22zf`F }E2t>FvSv`ESvQ{*v0:>F²0wyA23z|suvfz ±t2Av¡9zT²v0t>yAfvQy":T{2&E"kvQ>6T`vQ2 zfvQFyk±>{2y&`"62yAzFy"ETµzfF{Ft2EvFt2v0vxK`">Ev0vF|vy"v0fS"E{>z|`"fvS{ E`vQv:E²v0yAS2Fy"z|f2z zf"|zf°±t2z|fv*{23v0vI"v0y">`y&v02zfFty±y""|"E¡yAAv2zwy"0`¹`®Cz¬v0t2^z|"t2zfv0F y"E}0SvQ2Szfw6¬2vyKw6EvQvQ22`zy"z|{2¶E°±vQ`zf|>S3vQv>Ft2TvQv^| z ·"v|z t2 Et>yA&Ft2z| zsut2"vz|"v0² {yA9{> >9 yA² v`{>vA EzzSyKvFzf kFt>{C°±yK±zAF tFt2yv2²z|yK{2E"Qz|wAzyA³±EÚ³t2`z|v{zFT"EF2z|y"2{>`20FyAzfy"k²E{ v z|`{&v0*Fzt2yKvFzft2kz{¶2`yAv0{{¡xwEt>vQvEFFyAÀ*k>vyAFFvvwxF yAAz|{>u±A"F{>t2TvF{ y"{k2Qw6 v0uAM2zfF 2100

2150

2200 2250 Changed bits in redundant data

6

2300

2350

6

A

6

6

6

,

,

B

,

B

6

1*

*&" *)

+

`z|{2t2xz|fvCy"±Ey6t2v´}2FT"v0>v0y"`2z|{2zf|ZzFyAz|| K}2°F`S>v0F0kFFZt2v zfÜ>v0vS°Õ `z|2Et2z|fvz ¶v0w"M3Ev0t> v EEÃ£¡vQÓ:yY²ßyA"2Å\kz|z|f]z y""y"w±fhz|µ 2zfv6Fz|{&"EEtv2|yKv0 SEy"}2z|E{2Fv6vkf>v`{*z²²·k£v0wzN`k{2`Az¬3ut>yAyYyK|kF°Nv6zfkyYy{`¤t>Av0zfhk{2Et"t>>k`"EvSt v 2t2zfzF2`v0zfN{µzfw°IvQEv0FEyAvk}3v6k°±FTzfEz|2t2|kv6`F`zfvQ{*EFFE`K` >z|{2¶v6zfv0FEF"²"{*Ez|{*v0E{*0">¸W{ AFv0F:t2²vyA2°N|v"" ²2¤y"fNz|{kFE``Sv0CvFEkF{2vvQEµ3v¡"E F°±Iv0`F:z`&Fvz|{2vÖFEkFt2FvAk Ø ECxE }>wxz|E{>yAK` zz|zw`yKv0F>IvIw6>y ¯u|*zf°±·kW`vzfE|zfzfwtt2 v0S{>``T`z|v0"`I{vQyAFSt>"`yK|z`{2z|{2v0y"y">³{& µ"2Evv Ay"h{¡|v{2""FEEt vQ: °±Iv0zfEEtF"á²0yA*w°±wt>vzf{>Fv 2z|TFy"{> Sv Q" Î ²ty 2v ¸WS{``"vv0z|{2{>vS²FyAv0,ykTvQEt>±vCEt>yAv}22}>yAfzFyyAEEz|t>"yA{ A°Nv6yA{>{ vv0v0EFE"¡E¯vw"F3Ev0vQ:Fzf{2® á2*¯yAK2F°Nzfyvkz>¶vyKQFyAAy&|°NFv02v±y"|`2¬>²²·£E°±v0k}2zf>|F9Ev0vEEFvQv"{*TvN>EvQEt>yAzf{y"I{>yAyA3{ "`2 I,v0>"¶z{>{2v±SA`t>`yAv{2fv02Av0|`E²t>F·v 3y">v¡`wzFzf`k`{>zfyA¬>^v0v0ENF"y"²{>I´zf{¡Ev0Et>"v{>S`9`Evt>yA2|`°I²·3v9suy"{´t >z|0{*`EzF ``>Sv Q t2v{kS|2`0`Yv0°IvI2vSyK `²}3yxv0F:¶³E3t>vv£F{ t22vxwE3y"vw³vA2y"w`¥"`zf¬Et2yAvEz|2"{2{>v0M{>¥"S`¹`Et>vQ v 2yAFy29ÄIÀkyKEz|"{ Q uy"{&3vEv0°±EzfTFv{y" Q °±wxt2yKz `²z|t¶wz2NwHvS 22y"z|STEF|y"{>ESt2vv EvÎ }>z|{2y""F|y"vS2F|"v {&k2{>Î x±S¥>``¬>vQ|v0ÖR&Q *Ø, y"f {2¥"EE2{>yAEv0fkEt2v k{2fÔ{>"{`,EFzf zyA¡2z|{>yAF Î S``vNz³Et2vuFv}3vSEzfEz|"{S``vÖ Q Ø,¹¸¯0 ³wy "9`²yY°u

3

3

3

ÒIzfF Ä9Î ²` yA}3{>v02Sy"EFv0 v z|v0yAykETz|">{ EvQ Ã¤F" yA 2z|fz Q!Q) Q' ` *× Q)>VQ "× Q × 2 ×Q Q × 2 Qk × VQ!"× > k× Q × "× A×>VQ'A× 2à³FyAzfzf¤"kv2t>Fy"zfv{¡9E2S zfF3 vvF²z|t>yA*yA{>z|{2{2¶kEv0Et2t2vv¥ET}2kFy"FwÏ"{>>2Fy"t2yA2²v¶z|fTz z|2« vv± "z|yA3FEyt>z|"yKt2±{ z2y `Tv0¥v0{"fuvQw:v0EvQw6vQ 32zfv0F20` z|{2z|{kF¡y¡Â*Ã£ÄIÅ¯z|wy""v°±zfEt Q0× EvQ`2{>2y"{*

* "+% 4 0"!,+ +

3

A

A

3

6

6

!

>zuyk>²·¡Tvz¥2Et2kv{2f¶(¥¥"k|EwxEv0yA}|v^Et2zfEz|z|>"`{v{"¤wEt>v0FvEy"2"yAvQFy> EFt>yKzf vE0§t>yk{>v&²t¡vFv0E``t2>`v¶{>v2>2yAyK|{* Fyx²·2zEyKt>²v0yAy2{>CS``§`vQ2{2^A³²°It2{>v"vzv0S0&v&yA{Fz|x²t2` vvEkvwEFv w``zf{>zf2¬>v0zv0² z|z|{{ vFSv0kw6E{`"Ü>|vQ"z2:v0²`¶±vQ °±xzwFEtvQt2EvyAF|yA2EkvQvSv"y"EA`vQy":x²{>yA|`2²yKz|f·"ºz EvQv0¶¶£"2yA³zf|F>²t>¥"y"E{`{2kÜ>"w zvQ:²y 9}2t>FyYvk vNz|"3>vEv0f{ }>vsuky"t2vEvQzfy">}2vT}2{>z|F{2kZ y"2²v0zft´{2EFE"tEEyKW2S""kF°NFv0vv0T:EFv0FyAzf{>·kCv*St2`v®`F{>vvQ`zv0t>FEy"T"z|w{\y"zfRÖ`yAQ:KØ¯CyA{*Eá²yAKE"°ut>vQv KS>"v0Ezf6µTy"z|{2ky"zf{>FTt26v0}>yAyA}>FykzfS~zfv{> ~ 2²zft2{2 k~Ezf{2vy0yAS{``FvxFykF`t>vyKTvz| {2"{>"f Î ³M>®z²2£`yAzfFEvuz|"f{>`y"²f·k|v0^°±k°±zfEtµt2vvFFv0Eykk³TEWt2SkvE}Fv0yASFEzz|{2v0{>S`S`` vQ z|{2f`²·`±yA| >z² %

6

A

-

+'.2

4#"4+

1&"+'&" " !

°N¹ssuvNt2v wvw6E`vQ``vQzf2¥{>>yFyAt2t2{*v±zN2F`v02`v0yA{2Fy{w2wv0yAFz|{*"E¤t*y"2"Nv±yKt>²z|yYy{k"FAv}2EEEt>t2kvv}Sv0KKTk"FzfvvvQ9h¤ww"¹v0v022yzfzf22TFwwyA E`zv0TFETzFyAy"{>{>yK|Fv02FFv°NAv|°±Ft2t>zyA²{#ty"°I{#vy"y"2Ev"v{2²F"yA&F"yY°uyA¸¯Fv"£Ft2kvv02w6{` 3SKv0k2v` z|{2wµv0}2`Fz|2 wv0MF6y&²wtyAk{2Evkv0· {2EKt2°±v|v0²`t>ky"v0FyAyk>:fEv6v0E"z>TEEzvF"v0"Ey"t>{ v {E2StkvQ{>yKSv0SF|°N>FyA`vFFvzfv|F²t2tv3yAv}2{2z|{2Fkv0µv0E^vyA{2S|vvAF9y}3t2"zz|2{k`v0E{wEt2v0v¡FETy"}3"v0v°±z¬3z¶Ft22"zf2F ¥vsu"kt2²vSvxQvQYµk°IEz|vNE"y"z|{>FFTyKv2Fk"wv0 y"v9¤AFNEt>t>EyKv¶t2³vEt2t>zT2vIE`v0k"v0{2{CfwS}2kv0Fw`v0z|w622z|wÕ20yK{2Ezwv£yAEzfkEt2z|tkvI"{"{2>KEáv°©FK"°u3v0v wFyAy"`"{¶`vQy"±z¬Fz|Sv0{kv0^FTx¹²yA¸¯E`z|t>{xEv6t2z|v££SKEEkvt>{vv`]vy"wSvQIv0`wFzft>>3yKw¡v0I2EMt2t2wvv2SfKy"Ekz|{}2v|¤zfv¤{>wt2fzvQ2```zfv6>v0{wÔy"{w°NvQzf{`yk E{2TtE`vyKSk>¶"E>wt> vv0F2wvµzf2v0zFwEy"M{2"y"vk{>AEF2t2|v0Fv{yYkFvz|t>{`2yK¥k{>Et>KwxyAkFyKvwF zfkv0"^{#{µt2EsuvQz2À*t>`2z|v0v0{ Tz0 zf0{\yA|y"|EfzfvQt>w v ¼ |» :¾ ¾]» ¾ ¾ K zft2®Ez|S2E`>Ev0y"2{f}2|"}3wM"vQEEEt2FFv&yAk}2`v¡v0yAF0>SyAFE{zfzf3>fv03v¶v2wvvw{2v0z²3yAt>v02y">z|{2 `zzTv0kwÕ^ yAyk|E"vQFEy"vxt2`v EtEz|yAfw{~`²}2"·kfz{>v0: v 2`zfv0 {xwyATvQEEFFz|2yA`kv0Ev6}>¥EEkv0w "v{*3²vuz|{2zf{`¥kKE"wxvFyA°±Ez|F"z{&EEv¥E{Mk wHAvF}3t2vv{>±2t>zfz|{2 E"}2t{FvyK Et2z|y6"v>EETvfz||µ«v0v¡S|E Az|"²±·k{&Fv0t2z|~Nv¡¥>kt2z2²z|>6{>`x0vyA{´F{t>wyK3vQv¡`EFE yAwxvQkIyAv0|{>0(³AµEt2¸WS{~v¡k{`Ffz|Ü>t>·"zyKv0:xf±z|t2°± ykzT`Fvkt vFF"E¯"FEvQ:Ez|{2 2v0y"{3vv0w}2fKkv0E¡zf{>EvQy"Ev

< #<

6

Et>vTv0fvQ:Ez|"{&Ü>v z|2z|fz "

"+&

14 4 '5) !

!5

" 14 * $

#"

E>y"f|"^yt>z|22v{wvQEFyAkvz|

Sw zf¬v0¶`z|2wwvQ`3z|E2t2wv6µt2z¸W2{`vF{v0y"wvQAEFyAEkvv|v0v0:wFy"zf{{>3v02v6y`vSvQE 2}3yAv0z|w{*SzfEz|¬{2&&v0y&SKTy"}3"{>v0vS y`z|S{2K"°±v0£zFwtv0w2zfzf2{2wHz|wx°±yA^zf|w`v`zfE¬v|v0yA:EFz|"v0{>0E t>yAuy"f|K°£v0w3v0 suFyAt2"zv9z|{*y"E{3vwy">²Ft2zfz|}2v|kvCv0K "vv0ww3v0v022z|`y>z|{2 ®±Et>ºFvNvt>F°Nz|2y"2Fv>{ wEvQt>v ESz|K"k{vu6z|w²vQt>`kz|2Evw { EtyKEvQT2fFz|{Ft2v¡¥v°Nv0Tw``zf¬yA ®`zfNÁ3v0vE v0}3{*v09SEvQK^"v0*¹Et2wvv0`2zz|yFE¥"z|2|f`KF°zfkh{yA2¹z|{2²t"yAw{2zkyAv02`z2zfFFENz|2z|`{FEzfkt>{ v Ezfwz| y"uEEt2vk{2vTt>K°±{&z|{ Î v0SEz|"{×2 ×2 Í q ²Ê¤p q³o }3vt2¤z|yAfv£FvNEt2zf{>vI2vvw6}3v{>vQ`2v0`{*z|{2¤A>wFvSt2Fv±t2`y"S2EM>wy"2v02{kyKFzf²ky{2¥v0kEwxz|{yKF9t2"z|¹>E}>t>yAv ES2zKyAkFy"vy¶hu}2¥w"EFkv0w}`v0yAz|2T)FwSzfvQÂk2ÃIvQy"ÄIµ²Å t&v>ÖVEQyKvQQSFØ,y6FE¥zká:EKwx"°NyK>v± kvt>y"Qyk{>uyAE|zz|`²w±Tzz|KyA°±F¡{²y&t>²yAyK"²Ev0y"zEST E"v0v0E{2zvTE²zyAMxz|`vQy"y{´Ay"¤|ESkE3Fv¡v0S¥E"z|{22x{C²yKz|{Fz|TAEEzt>y"v¹`¥v0"*FwxzyKFyKzfFk0{>´suTEt>z|fv ¥yA"}>F}2wxfz|v0 02`Fv0À*2z|Fv0`zfÁ3v0Ev0{kQyA}2}>Ek}2EzyKFvFFy"{>T E2su²|t2yA`v {²· ¥ÂkkÃIE"w ÄI£ÅÛFt2vxz|Nwxzfwxs yA¹y"""v#Fv¥Fzf"{*FFy"Ewx{>TyK¥´" FwÏTvQNT>s©0yÞSSvQ E`vEzUzfEkvSEz|vvE{*v ² S¯v0k}2y"Ezz| `²{2tMv0v z|suwt2y"v "v}2Nzfs¦ `vS v Uxzfv0{*:F> y"Ev"z|"v0:{&M ANy"{ 2|`²·A > 0

%

&

('

*)

$

- /.

,+

(32

10

+

-

/.

Q

3

54

4

: 8 .769

: 8

0

(32?

Q k Q) Q) °±t2v0Ev Q "Et2v0EQ °± z Ev" °±t2v{ yA{> v0À*>y" y"{> |®±Kº°±Fvzf{2F°Ny"kF}>v0hFyAEt2Ez|v "{S S vUzfv0{k²£y"EvÀ*>y"{kFzf«0v0 6Et2v±¥k ¸W{*Ev0"v²Ó±k2{> 4

S*

-)

$

-)

4

4

-) .

+,D

-

;

3.

;=<

#

@- A

><

2

@.#A

B

.

4

Q

-

FE

C.

+

G

-

/.

/.IH

Coefficient Frequency

15000

Coefficient Frequency

15000

` Fv0yAFTFvQv¤Ft2 vN6¥FEt2vQÀkvz|>Nvzf{>{>2zfvQz|Mv0"I2zfE{¶t2v±Et2v "|S""M|"z|{>£`Fzy"S2vQf³vkhv¸¯¥ "FvNy"y"{>{> FyKvºFyKvE9z|"Ft2{¡vzuv0wfz|·"3v0v0f2x`Fz|{2xt2F"v0E }3v0:Fzfkv|""Et2v0{Et2v±¥kf|K°±z|{2

10000 5000 0 −40

−30

−20

−10

0

10

20

30

10000 5000

Difference in percent

−30

−20

−10

0

10

20

30

0 −10 −30

−20

−10

0 DCT coefficents

G

-

10

20

30

3.

+

D

-

/.

`o q³o`ÍEnko`ÍErq@ Mnko2n Îzf¬>²v0yK¡EzT E&zTyAEAv0Ekv0yAT{>F¹""y"²yA{ }>Ft*vkk³v0y"suKt>z2v0yAEv{Ez|wxv0TyAF"v9`tvSFy"v^F3wvz|v0{2{vwzfh`y" { z|Î wkwy""vvkF¹v0T²FyKEy"zTEEvzz|yA{>*`}2v0F}"v0}3{>v`EvE{*z|v0¹"`¹vF t2zyKvE2v¤yA¥EFkyw¢¥kFEt2wxvNyK{2"y"F{>w >Twv0y"E2Fv Et2vv0{kFEk} xA³Et2vFv0`>{>2yA{*2yAFy2 °uFsuvyAt2Q²vx 2Ezfwk{2}2{2v"|z|v0"Tv®©²FEyAwv0 TkÎ EzvFyAEEF"z}2Fwt2z|0zvQyATEy"zE2s¹yKFv0Fvv0TµFt2¥"vk{2~vSkÓz|E FyAv{>2yKvF"|zzfw k{yAÒNE2"zf EÅ vt>{>yYv²kyKvEky6Ft> zfkÖ t2KvØ,¹±v0{kv¤FEvk `} }vQ:EMt>z|y"wx{&yAF"t2vQk^E°±vzf°±EtzFt2t2z"22`0v0 {2yK²y Eµz|wzTv0Ey"Tz"Tvk¥yAvNFµyKt2Ev£yAF{>y"v0²w·3Ã9v0ÖV¬2Q02×YF`«Ø¯z|wx{2yAsu{2"t2{`v0v"{>`kFE>f z|T{2}`v0vEFkv0yAv{2Et>yAzf{*yAFEyv0²E¥t>vQky"6F{2zfy{>"¡vQkzfTkEFt>vyA{ v t2zF"kFy"wÔA9S"|"N¥Fv0À*2v0{>Sz|v0uz|{y6}yAEEzS2yAu°uyY" ¸Wt2{K°ÞEt>v±z6¥"y"|}2fK}2°±|zfvQz|{2 EA°IFvt2v|y"ÂkEÃIzf¥ÄIÅÔFt2v¥"z|£Fwy"}2yA}20Fxk¸Wy"{µ²tEt>yAv{z|Et2ykKT°vk E2t>zfFv 6v0Awu3Ev0t>2v¶2Szf{2kxfk}>FE`z|{SvQEyAN{~²t>z|wxy"{2yA"kvQv"£Fsut2vt2v¶fvQy""T|"T²z|"{2yAzfF¬v¶0yAy"{*`

6

A0

40

A0

Ty¸W¸W"{{x"yAvE{*{t2vv0{>SM"°N|E" "²}`²2Fv00z 0FEwt2vQvI`v0>F¥EEvQy"v0Àk">vkv K{>«vFFkt22hv6zy"Áv0{>vwFv3"{>v0{22v£vQ293zf{2yAvS¡FvN°N}2vQvFÀ*v0`{6>SyAv0y"|F`f0 ¥2`Fzzfv0FÀ*F9E2"z|v2>{*`FFt2Ffv0xv±^t2Fµt>z2yAà2`{¡kv {Ft2wvv0AFFFt2yAv"±vN°u² t>yYyA{>EyA"t>Fv yA"62{w^v0F y"{>E t> yAwE"t>Fvv wx"sut2yKTvQv0³EFk¸WyA{vw`Fvzfv0Á3zy"Nv0EEv0AF{>2^SvwvQzf£v0{y"z|{&EF2t2EFvt2zf{>v yk¥TFEvv0t2À*"v 2¹SvFk{t2fSkv¤Â*A¥Ã£F¹v0ÄIEÀ*t2ÅÏ2v v{2SyKNz|²v0ys¢0"¥S"°N"Ev v Uzfv0{k² à³zfk2Fv×~`zT}2yY`Et>vt2zF""²yAwÐv¥"Fv yAy{ÂkÃIyAÄIºEÅ©vz|wxy¡yAt2"zvk26`v0su{t2wvvQt2EzTFEyA"kkv6Fy"t>w yk`zfv0Á3vv0{µEv0v{>w6SvQ vQ2y"E`vv0µ`zz|{ }2µyYv6"kvQ>Tz|v0{&EkFvt2vy&EE2vQ2`">²:yAF}>zfkt&{yKz|u{FEt2t>vv6¥"FTv0FÀ*"2wHv0{>"SMF`t2zfvÁ¬>vF"v>{>Evkv 3Sz|vSv{*°N vGv{&`MS ®v UTy"Sz|vv{*{*hwvQQyAyA{>{¹xFt>z²yKI³ykEt2Tyvu"S v{*v Ux zfNv0{*sZF³`*zv ÁUv "z|{x{>f¥EvQz|À*{x2Evt2{>v x|v0`y"zTÁNvEFz|v"{{2Szf¬v0y"yA{*{xI32vzf0k9>®\EvTFz|"wv0zfyA3IvSE°NvQ`v>v0:{¶FzfSk"{ v Uzfv0{k²F yA{>¡×2 µ°±t2v0vTETt2¥vv0EyAt>{vI¡SkÃ¤fk¬2^E«0¥Fwxv0À*yA2{2v{{>SEv`yz|TEFSz|2(F`v0ETz|±"{Ez|{`y"vE{vzfFwxwyAzf{>kvv wxvw6yK²²vQt22v0`z|{2y2t2z|zT2EF`zfv0>{`E2z|"yK{´²y2E¡t>¸WyA{EEt2t2vK°¥"|f`Kz°±Fz|"{2E>E¹z|"°I{~vx¥kF"`w T |ÒNzf{2v0v60yAE>t>Evvz|Ft2Fv0v¶TFv0¥T"Et2TvQv kN{2fsÏµSFt2 v¡v UTEv0zfv0"{k² wzfvQ{µ`y&z|2wÂ*Ã£¤ÄNEÅt>v vSS `kw}3v0}2S`Ev0EvQ´´`¥zEkFEw z|2`Et2Fzfvk{ z|wxyA "vk¥"6suEt2t2v vy":F,TE2v0wT}`Ft>zfy"k6{CE¥µkx3yv wyAF`v`Tzz|¬wv0zfZyAQz|wx yAkvv zFt>vyKFt2vy" TykNSs¢v0{kt2 zF"Nks Fy"w¡¥EvQ Àk°N>vv{>Et2zfv0vQ{ Fy"·"v Et>vyAFzFt2wvSEz wv0yA{M

Histogram difference 10

Eà³yAz{ zfSk¶vQ2yATF2FvI|yAvu×Ez°±S Ft2z|v0zfÁ3{yAv0FEt2v0"vu{>FSvEvQvQw³:3Ezfz|{v0">{E`t2zfv {>N}2EsC`t2v0zF³F"2"*²vQyAhwx{2¹AyA9Fwxv£yA{2·k"v °±t2v0Ev Nz±y A¯v|vwv0{kÀ*>y"{kFzf«QyKFzfk{Fy"2|v" suS t2v vUx|v0zfykv0{*EF¯0E¤z|"¥{2"zf¬°±y"t2{*z²t 2zfF¶AEt>kEvÀky"yA{>{*Ez|«vQ Q"NNyAFs v >FyAE"v0v zyk±vFw6v0`>vQ2{>`2v0yA{* 2z² zf{*E¶°±t2z|²tEt2vt2z2`v{wvQ

40

20

−20 −40

40

Modified image

0 −40

(

Original image

4

&

A

4A

9

!2

8

2

EyA*yA`z|v{>ETvIFwFt2zfv{>vI">Ft2EvvuFvS" `vQ}3¶v0`:FzTv0E6Fzf`2z|2TEEz|F"z|2{ `Ez|"{yA{Skw}>yAFv 2

2su`t2Fv zfk{>±zKuyA|"2z|"vv0¥{¡"ykFt2vx`zfÁ3v0Ev0{>Sv3vS°Nvv{Et>v`z|TEFzf 9

:

<

2

A 2

2

No data embedded (not visible) Data embedded

Probability of embedding in percent

0.5

(!51%!#"+*

¸¯S(zFxv0T}£*FEEz|2fvv¡wF~"FvSv TEv0v0{>{>EzFzfkv±vQEE¥v}yAEEyAzyA{>2z|Ã9TE¬2kFT«FwxzfkyA{>{>¤{z|{ }2yA`{Fz`Fzf`Ewxz|>2yAS`kv±Fv"y"zfk{k§¡`>h¸WE{>Evt2FF"vv0vFykyAFt>wyKAv ±zf{°NNS¶KFyAv0z|y"`2Evv0z|{*{2hE¡z|z{xEy"t2yA³{ v¶2Fz|T}>yAEwy"FzfT}2>h|`AvE3z|E"Ezft>{>«0vv yAyx{Sxk{>yAT}2F}2yA|{* zf{>FyAwEt2}2v|vEvQTz|I«vyAN>`y "Ef{>z`TFvy"F{*t2¤v}}3*kTzfEEzz|F"zf{k{*°N°±vt2>vEFvv Ez|wt>v¶y""Evky"w}2EfvQz|{2yAFFt2vv£Fvy" *·"Fvv{{>2Kv0kv Fv0ETt2³v¶°NvvI{*y"Ez|EEv£vxy"²2yA|{>v¤"Ev `AuvSFEv0t>Sv ">Tz|w}2fvv0w3v022zf{2}2F`SvQE0Ú2Tv0và¹z|">Ev > ¸W{NEs¦t2z¶S 0v y"UxEv"zfIv0E{*t2F0vFsuyAwt2v}2|EvvQEzf«0v²yAz|EFEvSyKx FEt>v× 73 vkzf{>"{2zf{>y"f A}3v²ESt2vvN{*z|hw¥"y"h"vkv0""yAv{>F Et2±vuy"}3}2k}2E|zz0FzfyKkE{z|"z{Mh¹zf{suSt2FzvhwvSv {*EEv0vQ{>`vQ F"v0{>Tv E`t> vv0uvw{>A3v0>Fv0`y"zf{>SuxEzfx{yAE{¡"w2v{2wyAF`v0`y"zfI¬>v0A³Ez|t>wxvyA"Fvkv`"2`z|wx`yAv"EvkvQ :F vSs¹Et2 `"}32v0¬S{>E´v00yAy">2{Ez|vITy"Ey}2Fzf}2{2>Fv0`"kE}2z|yK"FFz{zfyKkEv¤¥v¡kF±v0Ey"TE³t2wv6F}2v0vSfEv 2EfE0v0zf³{>«0v"`¸W{>IvQ °IFv0vyk:²,t2EAvQ 3kEyAv&Et>Sy"2yA{ y"yK ETyz|"{2Sxv0{*Ft2 v6k{2y"Ev0zf0Et>°IwvvEFzyA·kwvv0Ft2y"{vyAAF¤zFSt2 wv UvSEzzf6v0{kw²vQyAy"{{>¡A¤Et2°Nv0zf 2{2FvyKFv0¡S v Uzfv0{k²

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0

³àSKzfkkv2²F¤v × 7S®{"^vE *t2Fv v{>2Nv0s# S Sv(FUv0TSz|v°±{*²t2Iv0`EvvEvQvQy":F²£t~EFt>yAvwv0}2w6|v E3xv02y"`{¡z|{2>{2wz|{ F2t2z¬>vxvQw¡ zfwx2zyA¬>kvQv" z|wxyAkv"^2`2*vQ {2AFv0y"S °±3vt2xv0EAv y`AzfÁ3Fv9v0EEv0t2{kvN`0vyKkEEv0v0"v0k^E"z|v0 6¥Ezfv0{´v0`Ekt>w¡vQt2Fz|t>TyKEk³"z|0²QyAEwt2vIw{*zf>{ w6> ¥"EFv{>"Fv"w¨"v0¡F¸¯t2`vzwFvSyYE `~z|2}3`v03FSvzfEkv0{2{¡ vQES`xv0zFTvFE{yAFFTzf222FFv E~z|"Et>{T2yAwÙyA{>Et>#y"v F¥TyvFk"SyAw v0F{kv Fv0t2{2Kv~yA"|>2""2v0t FSy"v0k À*2Ty"2{*Sz|FEv0v {*z|&E{tyKv0yAy"Ev²vQtky""²tFzfyAvQSExv0k"2yA"{*FFv"z|´T±>kwEwvQvQyKvQEF¥vvuEEkt"yAyAvS{>{¡Ft2¥v"Ã9Q2u¬>QE£E«t>¸¯wxvhy"`°N{2vS{ "FvvQNA³¥Ev0v0`kwu{>vv0¶Ex3vFv0`>v0& "{2vk v0su`À*zt2>Fv´y"Ez|}22zE`NkF">zfkz|yA"{¡>v0zf{¥|2z {> :FEzft2k{vFt> SyKkwE}>t2fv0vCwv0°I{*#N"2z|TEEt2Fvzf>`2Ewz|"2{>yKFyAzfkFvv 0

10

20

30

80

90

100

&

40 50 60 70 Analysed position in image in percent

6

6

Q

A

#

7

:

°±t2v0Ev zNEt2vÄ£2fv0ÅyAwwx y6¥2{>:Fzfk{ suS>t2|vyAE}2z|{2F" >y"2¥kzf|zfy¡"FMyAwvw6}2|v6vQ2¥F`"z|wÝ{2Fz|t2uv `vENvFsÞwzfS{> v0vU zfv0{k0yA²f ¥su"t2±vuvQEy"y"²wt¡}2wfvQv0hy"E2²yAFvEhwyAv¹{*Fut2Evut>vv0E"y"z|w{2{2}>z|f{2vE"zf«0>v Ft2z±vuz|zf{>wxSyAFv0kykvITy"vQ{>^ ÒNyA|v0°u0yYyA > EvTFFyAt2Ev FEv0yAT±E>t2Evxv0N3yAv{¶kzfz|{2{>{>zfE{2vQy"E"zf{2£Et>Evxy"wzfwx}2fyAvkv"Ezf«0zfv y"`{>vS EEvQk:T²FIv0²t>Sky"{2{*E"z|vQ{*9>""{>>fEfz^¥EFkt2wZv¥EFt>v0v¤À*2v0v0{>"Sz|{2{2t2z|{2zF""kkFFy"t2w¦v¤z|wz£y"`"zvk ¸W`{*zEFv0"EwEEz|v0"2{>z|yAE0vyAy"{EvQy"yA£zfT{¶vE{2t2v0v kyKzfwxFzfky"v"vFv0FTt>yK±EvQ`T6>{2²AxuvSsu `t2t2zz|2z|zf E`t>zvF"0Ey"EEvQv^v0"à2v0{¶kzf¹Ft2Az|Ft2vF±v0y"y"EE"vQ{My"2IEzft>{&vEEt2vQvz|wx`yA "v0vyA{2FAv`fvQvSyAFv0FSf Et>vvw3v0>`zf{>x}2E`v0FN2v0FSFzf3v0¡z|{¶Ft2z|}>yA}3vQ 6

&

2

K®¢yyA|22"zfv{FEyA¥v0"F|uyAE°±Tz|vQ"t2yA{´z²²²t¶Etx~F"t2F{t2vvFvSt2 vSvE `v0E}3{>y"v0`wSvQE}> v0f#v:T`,z|z|«ETv0vETFz|z|N2`>` EEv0v0z|"N{Z{2E"62±v¬>FE{>zft2k&Kv0° y ¥F"wÆ2{>Ev0|yAEv0¡S v Uxzfv0{*F0

¤Ê p2p ¹r3o`Í É o`q³o`ÍEnko`ÍErq@ ÍTq¹o2ÍTÊ É n 3}2ßFv0"`2&S`v0yAz|F{2|¡yA"E|t>fKv6E°t2t2vz2{2E`vQv0`{w2{>"w2FvvQy"E{*FFt>yAkyA2{µv"z²t>&¸Wy"{y"NE]vykA:¤QFT^t2vQEvt2vxE°±vQEt2`v2v|{v0{>S2Ev0y"z|w6"{*{ 2zfFuFv>Ev0&¥k2yK²y2 ¸¯z|{26&°NvµTvQ·*{>KE°¡vS°± 2y"t>wyKz|{2· vzf{yAZ{Az|wxyAk²yKvE¥z"TEzwyA ``Fv0zf¬TFyAEyAz|"F{v3°NvSv TFy"yK{Fz|>TETvuzFy"t2kv±`v0F vwxz|yAEyAz|z|"{2{z|{2EtyKEvQM`F2t2{>vN>vyAw{*39v02>z`²9zf{>F}2SF" FFv0v0:FM¤y"E{*v yKFv0^ S§k2EFv¬>yK²FTzf k{¥{>Ey"6zfk"v {2v yAyA}2{>}>E*Ey"t2²vtv{*z|{>EFf">} 2v0wv0}2y"FEv02EvFv0F zf{2 &EEt>t>vv

>

Coefficient Frequency

15000

Coefficient Frequency

15000

¥"t2²2zy"2:`F|v0zfkk{´F{¶w"AMv0IFEkFvQyAv`{2"2vkv0{>F´y">fyA®z {*º"NEv>|xvSz² v0£wFt>3 yKv02¹2y"zf E{2v>£vT °NvQ xvFvS` `v}{2t>vQ"":ExvEEEt>t>t>vvv ¥"| K°±zf{2x²t>y"{2"vQNzf{¡¥Fv0À*2v{Sz|v0) S

10000 5000 0 −40

−30

−20

−10

0

10

20

30

40

0

Modified image

0

10000 5000

Difference in percent

0 −40

−30

−20

−10

0

10

20

30

40

20 Histogram difference 10

0 0

0

A

0 A 0

0 A

0

E¸W{2{t>v0v±v0"¡¥²EE`vQ¶À*v02vv6¥{>"fv6ºFt2"z|v~{2{*Fµ0 Fky"Tv{>{2F¥kkt>2EyK"w tE2Et2Z{2vw²3`tvC`yA{2zfy"¬>k2v0vfxvzf{E ZµvUS0kSyAEz|{vF{*v03SFv y" >Fv0^>zf{AFt2v±°N"²2IEt>vEv0|yAEz|"{ 0

0

0 −10 −20 −40

¥z|à³«Fzfv0v0kÀ*22FvvG{¸¯¶SxS¹z|suAht>z|wv±y" w{>TyyAkv0z|S`"v0zvyK{kFT FvyA|CENzvsZF z|0zS`yA v>v{*Ux"FFEzft>vQv0yK{k:Ex²z|N"F{Et2³v0zfyAvwx>vQy"EÀkvu"vEyAt>z|fv w``z¬v0^ ¥¥FF""y"wwH2Ekv0«0{2vFvE¡vQExEQÕ«0vy¡FÄI>"£{>EEv"®v³{*F°IEt2zvyA"|>F"E"t°±`EFt2t2v0²z{ t>y"yAyZ{2}>"}22vxEz*yy"²z|{2t&vQyA²t2tFv*yA|}>{2uk2v0Fzf }2SkFwvk}2vf{*vEv0vf{* E{2F"v} kfvQ:z|²{>SF²v0yKykFTz|vTEz|z{µEEt2t>vxyA¹Fv0``v>}3{>v2{yA{*"{2wxyAFy"y>ME"zf zFà³±Szf"kyx}>2`z|FvGz|T}2E`kFh"TsuF}3zfvkt2E{&v Ez|z|v0{&0NuEs´t2à2v "*v ENUt2s#vSz|Âkvt>ÃI{*z|TFÄIE kÅ G"²¥yAkwy"Ewx{> yAzf|0f2QFFt2yAFvFyAv±EFv0v0v¡Ek2vz|f{{ ¥S"|k Ev¹NEs\k"Sv Et2v Uv0¹SFz|t>v{*yA²{F z|{6à³y"{>z|"2×FvNyA×>F"v yA{>{v0yAFF|t2vNE¥t2EvQvÀkF>yAvw{>v"zf vQ E¸¯wxkyA"°Iz|²{*yAv~FwyA°uz|´{yA{*ykFt22v`EzfZE`z|z"yY{>FkEy""z|z2#`SFk`zfkEzTF{CEv0"SAEEEz|"z|"E{>t2{ v yAzf{\FNv©EsÆt>{2v v0S v0vFUNEy"sEzfÝv0{kt2²zF à2FyAk"~vvSw 2`yAw`zf}2¬>|v0v"NxFt2E2v }2"}3(kFt EvvNws 3v0S> `v Uzf{>Ïzfv0y¢{kQt>z|22v{© wS¤vQ¸¯ F*zfN°±z|f3vw``zf¬>vQxE Q"hµv "E F v0:Et>z|: ²Ft>t>y"yK{2±"zv& *µ¬>{`zf{>µy" {´y" Q"Ty`"y"S{>v0&{*²tS yA{2v Uxkzf{2zfv0{*zf E¬ zfv0 {k²±²¸¯ ¤F°Nt2vv6z|Skt2EzFTv0ES"kFvy" kwªvF¡°±zf²|t>y"3{2v"z|v`Fv0{*EFzt2yAv FNEst2vS "vS{>ºv A³Et>v"Fzfkzf{>y"zfwxyAkv" à2E°N>y"TF}>t2xvFKwyA|"2Fv0v"¶Ky·"v0v"}>FEvQy":Efz|{2¥±EvQFÀ*Fy"2{>v{>T¥"Fw¢"F2t>{*yK²h¶v0FSEkv{>{*TEFzyAyA{*|fQ suSkt 2>{*0F*{>°±6z|TfuFyK3Fvz|TEy"z±2|Fv¶t>yKFµuz`£v>EykvQ:TvQxy}222zFÁvv|Fv"{>{v&¥F3v0À*vS2°Nv0{>vv0S{ Et>v"Fzfkzf{>y"^yA{>¶Et2vTEv0"wv0`z|2w µSkv~2{*w y"·"y"vµEv0Et>TvFyA¥E"z|fFKz|°±0z|{2 MvS" >EvF3KvyKEy¶z|"¥{#Fv0¥À*"2v{¥FSv0À*2Skv0{>2S{* z|{Ft2vxt2zF""²yAwy"{> z²y" TykSv0{k"2{*0zfEt` −30

−20

−10

0 DCT coefficents

10

20

30

6

A

A

4 4

8

C0

Original image

3

;

4

3

8

0

0

;

4

40

Q

0

A

0)

0

A

w t2k| E°±suz|"t2t2{z|vfvF vTEAyKz|¤FfzfFkt>v0{6yY` 2z|z|{{2v22yA£v{*{2y"k{>2z"»u²t¼F½:>t>¾]z¿K²yK½:u¾2fvQvy"ºNF{zfwx¥k3NyKv6FEvu>t2E¥vv0"9SkF¥Et2"Fv±v0S¥2E²yKz|y"{2²Sy E²yA{¥kEwªFx°IkE/· S

0

0

0

E¥Å "z|F"wÆ²vt2{ °±kyz|Ef¹vt>z|yA2v{2y"vz|2wx{C|vyAwkFvxvQE¥}2FkyAF kv0Ev"°±v9t>F°N"z|²vv¡tE0t2EyAt2v{CvxkESz|kT"v&Ez|F{>v0EyAt2SEv¡z|¥{2Fv0v0TÀ*EF2z|Fwxv0y"{>yK{>SFTv AS`k³v02{´E{*vQ`wF02v0¹{>F¸W>F{*yAyAF"{*vv±Fv02`TEz ²z|v0{2u"E|t{2yK"vx{>zf"{>y"2{&kEtvQ3y"AvE¥v&>k¤E|v0zÂk&{2ÃIv0EÄIy"EÅ|t2kFt2¥|¶"v±E¥t2²z|wy"vSy"t>E"z|z|" vQ{ °±zfEtw"Fv Ns\S v USz|v{*²Ú2Evvà³zfk2Fv > wsut2vv{*FS) kS EFv0SEz|{26E²yA{>T¥"FwÔt>y"NFt2v¥"| K°±zf{2Fv0À*2z|Ev Q"±à>"yA{ }>yAEANEt2vz|wxyAkv"Ft2v`zFEz|2`Fzfk{A F2t2{>v w``Nzf¬>sÔvQ&S z|vwxUxyAkzfv"v0{*FTt2k2~vEzfwz| y"FEt>v `±sut2v~{ 2w6v0AxSkEFv0SEz|"{>¡{2vQSvQEFyAFE}>Ev EvF"v²yKFz|TEzy"^}2Ek}v0TFzfvQ±Tt>"2¶3vEwy"f, wx`Î >kyYw&zf{>vx3&TvFy"yA>>E{2`z· zFF{2z|zf0KkyA°±{>9yA{}2hEF`"z}3Fv"E^EEEz|Ev0z|x" {>°IA0Iv EEÎ t2F>v¶²tFN`}2zs¦TFEv""E v0Ev{*z|U"{Szf{*z|vF{*Ey""F{ EF3zv0vE£2"E9t>¥y"yAF26"`w©°NzfEv¶Sz|"k`{EFyAv0>· SwE{2z|K`"°Ô{>`zf³¬yAw3yAv0"Ey"2z|{k"0{>9IF¸¯Twx}2°IFy"v¶v0f,E"·"v°NFv"v0vvI}FEv0Et2t2`v>v¶²{*v±yK>EEw6t>zTv |zfy"·k^v|}2zft2F" }3`vEEAz|9v00¥>TFt2v`zF"EEz|{2xEt>vz|wy""vk TFyAEzFz

1

0.8

+

4

3

0.9

Fraction of redundant bits usable for data hiding

{*>w× 3v±A9S ^v Ú xzfv0{*Fuz|{¡z|wx:Ú yAkv"Ú "Ö (Ø ²Ö ,Ø CÖ Ú ,Ø¯Ú

U

! #" + ' , %$'& #")( * # .0/ * ! Q 1 $'& * 32 4< 6587 .9/ : / 5 1 /#;-. .9/ * 1 < >= Q ? 1 A@BCBCDEB >5F7 .9/ G ' : / 5 1 /#;-. .9/ 1 H 1 * @BCBCDEB >IJ >5F7 .0/ G : / 5 1 /#;-. .9/ * 1 1 LKNM !O 587 .9/ G : / 5 1 /#;-. .9/ * 1 .0/ * ! QPSRUT QP)VXW * Y 7 1 Z . [@BCBCDEB $ & * G ' KNM .9/ * Y .0/ * ,

?

3

4

0.6

fzx{¿ |A*¾ k}Ú "Ú Ö Ø `v0Ev0wv{* zf{|*k}Ö Ú ,Ø Ú zf{SFvwÖ v{* zf{W|Ø*k}Ö Ú Ö WØ,Ú WØ zf{SFvwv{* zf{|*k:}Ö Ú S»K¾ WØ,Ú

0.5

3

4

0.4

0.3

=

4

0.2

;

4

8

0.7

'

4

4

0.1

0

4

1

2

3

4

5 6 7 Number of DCT coefficients

8

9

³ày"zfk{23Fv v¶>S9Ev0sut2v¥k¥6Fyk2:yAEFz|"y{¡t2Az|2¹zfE{2t2µv ` Nv0s\{2SA vUzf{>Sz|EvvQ{*y"²ENvEt>|zf{`yA v0y"E|¥"zfwxyAkv0N°±zfEtw"Fv vUSz|v{*F0 Eà2yAvQk>:vTFFv0wt2v>F Tw¶"3FFt2vv"vN¥Fvzv *vFvAF{>v¤*2TyAv0F{2yAEkz":²Fz|yA,0E}2yAv0t TM0`3zz|yATxE|M"EE}>~Ey"z|F"Tv²{wx±uAyAhz|su{´Ft2t2>vv{>Fz|`v0w6vST ¬>E°±vQz|fF9t2z|`wvvy"E"v0"FSzfv¤k tzf{{>y"yA&³,yv0w3Nv0s2`Sz| {2v¡UzIzfv0v0y"{k²ht`z}>yAFEEz|2`"¤FzfEkt2{6vEzfww`z|`y"z E}2®t>`|v"FvkvEw6EzfEt2t>v vQw 2`Q¤Nz|{2ws¶v0¥vS}2EFvQFM`ÀkS>vQ"vEE{>Nt¬>Fv0{>t2À*z|Ez|2Tt2z|EFv0kv0"w±²¸WyAv{{*wÑFT0E¥Fv"¸¯} MwÑzQk>EFt2°N2vv{kSyAEkºz|Ew"vzf E{>wxt>y"yAEvQ{ zfTwxt2vky"F|"F¡v"²¥yAF{>v0z|À*{2FTv0t2E{>kvuSEz|t2vv0z|0zfTuEksuzf{"t2²yAvw Et>°NÎ EEvQvuv0Ty"}t2EkvI|°±`z|zfvS{>|F`zfv{2FzwyAFzfE{2vQvQFu"t2|EKvt>E° v wvyKUF>vN¥Fzf"v0zf}29{k|²y NzfT{>°±}3zv0FFt&t2z¬vIF t2kv>ENEv0sCFyA"|zfv0{>*v ¥UF]v0y"SÀ*Sz|E2vk{*v0 {>0³S Iz|¸¯v099³z|"9`t20Ev0yAt2{¶Sv 2Ft2yKvNFv0{*s>Sw6 " 3°Nvv¶wA¤``v0Ez¥F"²F±t2¥v¶k z|wxy¡yASk vv UEzf}2v0F{kv0 EvvSF 2"Svv0v0E2t> v¡zfFTFyAEEt>zEFvQz|T0t2k¥|k EtyKS v Uxzfv0{*0 yw"Î FzfvTy{>"}CvSv0×zf{*¬ E{>Ft>2¡v FEvt2 vxyA Fwv `}3`vzf{¬>`³v0µzfE{>t2C"v¶{>vzfv"{>FF2"vS¸W²{ ~xTA¥E"uv0&}Et>Ev&t>MvµS°N ykvxv UxTy`"vSzfFv0vv{*{*E E3St> vv&v FUxFSykk`zfEv0Fv0{*v0SEy"Ez|"kt{y"yKzfx{>¥"TTt2kFEt22t2vv¡~}S2v0v¡{>FE`Sv0z|k{*{2E¡Fv0S"NEFv0sÔEvQ:F*zf¸Wk{~v {UFASt>z|£yKvx{*zfF6yky"Ty"`vk{ Ty"v{*S v Uzfv0{kQ ¸¯{ 2wEt3yKv&£zA^{>vFAEkFF¹t2v¥k90y"EEt2v"v±S°N vvU²St2z|v0v²{*·´Q zf{¢ F v:} Ö zfEt>WØ,v Ky"yA{|23v"hv¸¯z|9{>yASF{2v"wEt2v0v0{kIFv0z|{>¶°±Ev0zwFt2v0"{*`uuzvSu 2}3kvv0FT2z|zf2{2|6v" z²°IIvEt2"Fv0{* EEt2z|{ "2 v

9

10 4

x 10

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

4

`v0Ev0wv{*Ö ,Ø :Ú Ö ,Ø¯Ú EA®zh|"y"`k¤zfÁ3E}2zfv0EFEt>"v0w }3{>vSEvQQ EuSz|v0zf{¡su"t2Et>uzvy"E{~¥²FyAv0ÂkÀ*{>ÃI2TÄI¥v0"{>ÅÔFSw &z|wxS}2"yAF>kv0Ev"{kv¶²Fu"¸¯v06v·"E°Ivt>v0v0v}>v {¡²E"yK²Fy"Ezfz²"T· z|S{>v0yAT²9yAyAz|{¶{Ft2TFEv0vEkt2&"w^vQ `Et>zf>vw¡¥EvQÀk¸¯£>vEt>{>v¶2SzÁkv2F{*v{>z|±v0 yk vS 2>TvEv0v0 y

4

4

4

3

±°SkzfEEFtv0SF±t2vEt2{2vvS S2FwFv`{*`zf¬w0`yK`Ez|z"¬3{MyKF§zfkF{t2vz|{F°±Ezt2Tv6vkzfwx°Nv6y""tv"yY"suvt>Fv ]E yAt>z|vKNhM SE v>Uk S°Iz|vvyA{*|"ky"E£zfEkKt2kwHvyAt2Fz|ut2vQy"vFv0EEt>yA}E{kvQ6{>Tt2Ez|zf{>k2||¡Ev vQyA¥y""{E±vI¶FF²t>t2yAyKv·kQvv0¤E0¸¯F³yA"FhEvt>¥kyAA zf|yAEvQ EE®±z|"ºF{v"hFwyAEvQ|kzf:kw t*`y"f`9zfv6¬Fv}wxyA*Ey"Ez|"Ezf{2z|{>2z|M{2fvkt>¡±yYv"áFv£EKk°NFv0v0v"{v0ß0v> `"zy"9w°NyAzf|v{2hvQEyA^t2FYvvx°IyASvI2k{2E|vFvv0vQFS SyAkFvEF{2v0SA¤w`vkETvQ£:FAy"^2F|t2v"v vFF"²"²tyA{2kv09z|{xEt>vt2zF"kFy"w suS t2v v Ux Lzfv0KN{*M 6 KyA| 2v ± y"fk"FzFyAt2{wHzy}3kvkFE&zFzfEkzfw{ }2|v"zf{CÅ Et2z|"v¡v0z|{w6y

4

4

4

3}yATFkkyAv"EEz³FFNzfz6kE{¡v0EFyAy"zf²vQ{>²¶t2z|F²{2t>y"¬>{2{2{>vQ"yAv IFzfNEt2t2v¶Fv6FSyAzf Fw±v Uxv¶yk Tyzf*"v0v {*UvI{*SF±z|t>vSyK{* ±6vUyKy">Sz|TyvvQ{*}2QF9Ezft>k¸¯v ® |z|wx{>wyA"`vQvS`Fzft2¬>`vQ §"× {2vSB Q I"FCFv× yK7 Ez|"{ Ky"× 2Ev0sM7AvQ×k × ¥3yAF|v"""wÙkz|E{2zf{2EEt>t2z|{2wHvxt2F"z&M2E`3t>vvv{#vzf wxwvQyAvQSkE`Fv"FyAv0 kIvyA "{>v ¶UE°Nt>zfv0"yA{kF&²·`Nt>yYEzft>kFyAv°N3t2yYv"&v{#E&>2ETyKvQt>²yv ßxI"" FFEEvQvQ::EEz|z|""{{ VQ Q CC×× ×Q 7AQ)×Q ¥su"t29v}>Ey"v0fk*"z|"FzF³t2wÔ"FzfE{vQ`:z|F0zfkyK{>Fv0h±yAEF>vNE· v0zfF}2u}3"v0u] yAz| 2 EvkKF M : ¸WwxyAk{>0v w I¥`"`±zf¬>°±vQt2 z²t"» × ¼½: ¾]¿K½:¾^Cv0T× E7z|Awx× yKFv t> " K2× 7 BQ I"FE vQ:Ez|"{ "× C× 7A× 7A×Q ; /-: 5 1 / S KNM 5 S à³wzfky"2"FvQv u °±S zFItk2wyK}²yyAFvz|Ew"3{v03>vS`v0°Nvv2{22°±{2wzFt2`"`2z¬v0²yKz|wxFz|TyAEkzv0y"0 | z = QkÚ Sk|>EFv0TSFEyAz|"Ez{>0Fkz|0y"yA{>xSk¬E{>FyAv0|SfEz|"z|{>wx0yA "vQ¤°±zfEt2yK²yv0w3v02`vQ Q $'& Q * 2 } 1 " ¿ 3¿ 2¿ "» W» OS ¿A½ ²¿K½:½ ,¾]¿ >» 3¿ 587 .9/ S Ú . 5 ; / 6

4

.9/ * .0/ * .5; /

><

4

4

1 O

I

<

<

7

<

&

@

&

&

@

&

&

<

6

6

$

@ ,

,

,

&

@

Bad Corrections No Corrections Good Corrections (not visible)

0.8

l É q@n ÍTn s¹2yAFvy~Ky"z|{*f>E yAEv C"2}2Nz|SSEk2EFFv0v0xSEFz|yA"·k{vyA{|"°±kEzfEzfEtZt>w¡y*à>°N vz v0w3v0-2Q'` vQ `Ezfz|«0"vzfF"y"£Et2y"vwz|v0wxFyyA"y"vQENkz|2 {> ®{2{ ®E}>3z" `Qv 0h®z|²t2ºEz|v0kuy"{Et2&vsuz|w6t>v F2yAv0kyKSv0kF v0w9°N}2FvEt2FvQvvEE`v0"K{ °±"°±{>v0zfFF*Ety"zfk`y{vQÀ*TE>¥v0y"F}xf"z wzf{FE]y"t2t2SvxvE"v0wuy"w"3@ v0v02F y>22zf9{2Esut2t2v0}2z|E±`°NEz|vv0w6FFv °±zfEt2k`y"SE>y"f|vw6vQ2`z|{2yA{ ¶>yKFy> à2S kv ±UxEt>zfz|v0{*TFvMEAt>9yA³zfwx°Ny"vI"0v0yA0{ Et>Tvv£yY¥""³v0Fwy"`"v`zf{*¬>0wyKE3z|"v{6z|"³ yA3"N2s 3KyAF zf{2&v°Iv0v{× A³Et>v0Ev"{*EFz|2`EvQu"{2vFv0`>{>2yA{*yA{2zf0 ÄIy"²t °NvzfE{2t2AkF`z|¤vvw6yxFvQE2k`{2z|{2SkyAE{ Fv2yKFyAzfFky {zf{FKF°Nt2y"v±FE2vQu`k2{2{>v">yA{*§9{2zyY²* v`²v0yA*kzyKv"Fzfkk×{& " A×¤yA |Ft2vv°I2zfv0Fv {yAz|Fwvy"T"vvQ°± zfEtyTFy"{>2yA² µEsuvt>vvw6á2vQ{*2E`z|{2v0"FMt2Evt>v¬>²Î T{>¶y"²Et>· yA6}`zfF{*vE"F t2vMvz|w°±zy" "vQNyA¤F®F"ºE|(v SQ k w- }2EvQE>Ezz|²"{ 0Et2vNt2z2`v0{wv0FEy""v¤ty"yTz|«vIA>yA3"2 &

8

&

1

4

#

0.9

&

< <

S»A¾ `½ ®²t>|y""{2kE"zfv Et>z±w FxSz²à¹y"z|{> Ty"Syv0{*E}3 v0SzfN¬s\ S NvsHUSSz|v {*v QUx zfv0{*y"{>

B&

4

4

&

B&

7

4

(A

4

Probability of embedding in percent

4

4

@

;@

6

+

4

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0

³à`z|zf{2k2F¥v kS£Fsut2vt2vz|wxv yAE"vv{`Et>v0yA&t>,ykEv0T{2`vE²vQyK:FFz|T±EzEt2y"vv0SwkE3Fv0v0 S Eáz|"K{°Nv¤k§vQ2^£yA{{µyAzfz|wx"vyASkkvEFFt>v0SyKEz|"F{v0z|v£z|"vkv0v{Et>wvx"}2FvEk`}vSv0Fv0:²²yAyK2Ez|v"T E2z{2wy" ``"zf¬>FEv0vQ¡:Fz|zfwxk{yA"0vkyA {Z{>A&3v`z|TEz|{2k2z|Et2vQ¥EkwÙy"{ E2à³t|zf`kyK²2·6Fkv E}zf &«0v0v±FEyAAt2E^Kvv°kz|"{2t*fE¤t22v"zf{FF0v0AFE2t2Ft2v¶²vFFv0¥v0`"E>2{>E¤2t>yA"v{*EEz|t2w2v }>yAFfvxy>yA¡T2FFyKvFhz|zfTEFEt´v0zTy ¥{2""EzySv0Fy"E2>|fvzf{²yASF{>v0`y"kEw vz|{Tkv2{*FEFv"} z ¥kVQ >z|wxyA"vQv¡uE"tyKTv0Et>kyYvkyv EE{2Kt>"°uvxyAzfEwx²vQ2SyA9vkz|k"v0{2vQvF2t>Tv0yKFSyAFEv0tzykyYFT"z|vQ0v9yA£{2v0"v"E{~zFSEv0vQSy":k2EEz||F""v0{MkSEE vQsu>9t2¥kváK°N"²FvyKEkFv0vz||TyAQEEAzz|¥"ky"{ E`yAt>kzv~v0F¹"2¥E"{2Ez|9w"°±{>`Mt>`z|Ez²¬t>t6v0v£\EKt2yAzfv|wx2»uv0y"h¼3"v0½:y"¾]0E¿Av¤½:k¾`Ä¤vv0FT 2 EyAz|wwf*yAzf{>TEv£vuzf{2Et2kE|k2t2{20vNfA2°NyKFvu²t2y±{2v~A¥FFz|"w6z|w v EyAt{yKuFEt2t2vv`zfwxzfÁyAvkFv0v{>Ev0t>NyAxvEvQ°ISv0vvz|"{¶vQCEt2v"2F{2EvQw:E`z|`"zf{¬>6v0&y"Ez|v¡wvy"k"vvQ{ EEvQw:y"fk|v2Q9suFt2v*v0yAEv{2kT"z|w²yA}2}2ft v"E vQ²±yAFvFt >N{2AyA>fvE`vS 0

10

20

30

40 50 60 70 Analysed position in image in percent

80

6

90

100

2tsuyAkzt2v0FvM"wEkt>Fky"yAEw¡³vut#z|{kyY"F¸¯vv£ FFv0°Nv0TvEvz|{2z|}2"|vQATFyKSFFkt2z|ETv FEv0z±SENzz|h"sÑ{>Et>0t2v0z°NTEvu"NyAksCFFv£y"¥w{2Fv0À*Af2kv0{2{>z|"w6Sv0 EyA`z|>v"Ef{Mv¡v0hSEFà³¹z|E"¬t>2{>v£Fv z|w {2y"AE"t2FvIz|K°±°v0yAz³F>t2Eft>v"v``9vSzf ÁSFkvvEF{>Fvv0`{>SvQEv0z|"{>z|M{´(yAFFv0{>t2T0v9Ft2`suvNzt2zfFv±wxEz|F2yAv0k`Tv S`kvEEFv0v0SSuEEvQt2v°±z|wzfEty"""v>¤Sk{>EyAFz|v0"SvuEv0wxvS¥F"t2`T^F*yK2Fz|`T£Ezzf¤y"z|^¤`2v{> yAzyK>Efz|vu"{F °±zfEt¡Et2vFFy"{>T¥"FwÆzf{®|"kEzfEt>w Q" suy">t2`vzFzfk"{>FEyAvQ9:E²z|t>{2y"¡{2"E²vQyA±{F¶¥kFEt2w v0EvQyA`>2Ev0{>2y"y"{*k`2 yAF y> sut>yKk× z| yAFyA}>"}2vkEµY `suz|wxt>v¡yKEyYv0fk v² yA"vx{ "2w6Et>v&v06Ezf"«0v¶`AzfÁ3v0EEt2v0v¡{>St2vQz2`Fvt>{CyKxwvQy"{ {2Fv0":Fzfkv{> "]FyAEz|hvQ:¥E"vQz|wxz yAQ k v0 ¥"°±9t>z|su²tt2vEt2wxvy »"¼3Fz½:¾]¿A½:"¾³³vQ"FEz wxEwyKy"Fv&f|vz|{>`Et>zy"yA{Ev0Et2vy"wx{>vyK `°Izfw6v2EFw ¶Fw¶v0vFFw6yA"v&vQ^Tz|«áv&KE°It>v0yA"xvQ°N>ykzf EE°Nt>t>vNvIv&|S yYk""E·v0FFv0ky"S{2"Efz|v{2{ ±yA29FwFzfy"wx3{>yAv6k¥kv0AE¹w ¥"`²hzft>Á3°±y"v0t2{2Ev0z"²{>vQt6SMvQE× t2Q v±EtvQyK Fzfwx0Q'yA£yK{F>vIz{2²t>"¹"6y"2{>3 v SkEFv0SEvQzG 7 ` E¸¯"t>kvNEzzfEt>"}3FwÏkEFvQTyA:z|kE2z|y"|{2vzf{EEh²yAw¥{>2 TE2¥E"t2z¥Fv0 w6z|{2Q` vQSS F2v0vzykUy"TEvSz|{2z|vE{*t>F²vt2¹²vN°±t>EzfyAEv{2t|v0kSy v0E t2z|"z|¥{"Ft2"yAwv0f ¥EFzf¬v0À*02yKEvz|{"S{ TEEt>vy"}¢{E¥Ft2"v0w zf³y"Î vQTy:kESz|v0"{k{ ³S×2 Qv Uy"S2z|2v{*&²Ft2³v~sut2yAv¤{2{2z`"vF{`yA E¥Fz|"v0À*{#2Evt>{yAS²St> yAv {2Ukv0zf¶v0{kE²2yAzfFFvv0"ykFTz|z|"vz|&{>yKEFzf{2`CvSF¥v0Ek:Qw¨ t2z|"Et2zf{>v0 E×"t>× v °N"²T N ¡Ev|y"v02:2FzfzkFzf{k*{>EyAt2£v²t"yAF{2EkvQv0:0Ez|&{2sut2E²vxyA{>3Tv0¥T"FwÔEv|v0yASEz|T"vQ{ Fz|wv0Ey"2"²vk¤A°Iz|{xv"E{2v|vNF×t>yK£ Tz|{2k× Et2²tzhyAF{2v0k²v0t20{2 zÀ*I2"v"w"E}>t2y"vEz|S{2"FFvQv0y":²Et z|{2FFy"{>T¥"FwÏyA{yY"kz|×Q Q ²t>y"{2"vQMz|{yYkv²yAkv" °Ns¹SkvEFvkv0wvSFE3zz|¥{2v0µNEEwt>²yAv¡vQ{>EFT"yA¥"FkFEv0wvQN:EA{>9µv0`Fv9zfÁ3{2v0"AEFv0v9E{kt2E t>v~TyAz|»¶«vQ¥¼3"½:MyA¾]w{>¿A½:vQ¾IEy"FvQ}2yAFk}2zfv9|wxTyAz|E«Et>vQv"v 3wvk|KT°¢v0FEt2F"v²vQ±F¸Wzfwx{SyAFEv0vy"EFz|t2{2vxFEFt>y"v{>w¥kv0EFwÑEy""zvyAE>z|«fv6vFy"¶KSkkvEFEv0t>Sv v0TEz|wxyKFvyATvQNy{2"EzSvQyA2|vzf{>EvQy"Evzf{vFF"² EsuyAt>>t2vfvvFvE`²zyATv{E"{>¥EkEEz|"wÆyA{Fv0y"z|yµ|{E6zfE{t2tvy"Ft2NvENz|wsÝwy"v"Sv vuv EFUxt2t>vyKzf¶v0F{*v0ETFt2E0KF\z|°SExà³z|"z|{2"{¶"2EEFzt>v SyAv zE|E{Zt>t2vKS°"¥ENwvQEÀk}>t2>y"vvE{>zt2Ez|"T{EkAE" ~²yAEFt2wÆt2v v`zfkÁNEvz|sÑ"Fvz|{>{>SyA ,vv UA9suSyz|t2vv{*w²``xzf`Á3yAzf¬>Fv0v¡EvQv0{>{>vSzfwx"vQ|yAz "kz|zf{ v 2t2|zv"2k`Ev0t {>>hyKFFt2y>v v *Fv{>2v0 S(Fv0TI` v0¤{2A¤z|{>`zyAEvy"{* 7

;

'&

0

9

Difference in percent

0.2

Bits 1 − 23946

0.1 0 −0.1 −0.2 −120

Difference in percent

9

Histogram difference

−100

−80

−60

−40

−20

0

20

0.2

40

60

80

Bits 23947 − 47892

0.1 0 −0.1 −0.2 −120

Difference in percent

−100

−80

−60

−40

−20

0

20

0.2

40

60

80

Bits 47893 − 71840

0.1 0 −0.1 −0.2

2tà³`zv0zfk*F2z"yKFkFv Fzfky"{>wZS¥¥Ä9"F"¹ 2w#}>yAyAwEEt2z|F{2v¤Mz|A>{2`{2Fwt2F t2v£2vµz|wxz¬>2yAvQz"ÁvIv"FTFvt2zf{>kKzf°{v0¡yA,{2z|{Zsu{2t2E"t>v9Ev z|Sy"vQEyAkN2v0T|s v `zfÁ3v0Ev0{>Svz±yAF">{> Ê É r EÌn ÍÊ É EEÄ¤t>t>kvvv{ }2">EEvQt>ETv"v0F2{>"kSv0tv0 ±"F³Evvy*{>yAt2E{2v0zk20">`²vTyAF{}2yKFt wz|±TvQEzEzFyAy"Ak¹ºFv"y"v {>{yA>|`{>T`zvS±Fv0y"SF{yA>Ev0fv¤"v0 y" µEv|v~v0:zfF{*zfkEF{``}2>F`v0S¢v0F0µ°Isut2{2v&v0° ¬>²wv>Et2Ev0`2yFEvvQzf`wv0C}2F}>K"Tv0vµ>E`t>"v ²wyA`{>``zk¬3w yKF{ zf2kw{>M3EvFkt2vvI{2v0KF"yAv0EkMwFv0`z|`2vSwFvhFwsut2z|{2vIvEv0Et>"v{>¥v°N>Ev0v0T vEvFF|v0":EF¯zf{>"FE2vQzf:FE¤z|{2°±zfESt>`"``vQNzf{>FEvQz|{>y"EEzf{>vQy"EEvt2vEt>{ v¶2w6Ü>v `v0zf£2z|" z~{>v0z|:{ v0>FEFv0yA¡FF¶²}2tFyAK{2 kz|v0`0vH}>|sMy"k>"Tvz|2Et2|v6v00`v0{2Et2zyAvQ2Tvµz|fz w¡vSEt>v6 v>w3v0yA>{\`zf{>3v w>Fzf}2|vt2z2`v0{¡wvQEFyAkv0Nzf{¡Ft2vSKkvuwv0`z|2w ®`vfEEv0t>S"2wkt``Et>zf¬v¡yAE"z|w"{>wu"¥{2F"|~w >EEt>v0v zfwS}2,FEKvQ"vQ¡z|6vw2{>3y"v02>|`v¶zf{>F E}2yAv0FF{>v0`yk`SNv0vQF zf¤{`}>vQy"(EFTv0²ETuz|¤3Av0E³ty"yKz|{&I{xzz|ENwxt2zyAyAIk}}>v"yAyA 2}3|vvQA"M°N2vvSE`vQvQ:EFzfE{2z|6vQw yA2{xz¬>vvQ s¹SkÑ2{*F"2|{*zf·kEv0v¡\Et2TFvyAEvSz FFvz|0{>yA`µvQ EvQ²:\,EvQ>y"QEIv0°N v¡"zf{{*EF¥`F`v0À*>2v0v0{>Sy ¥¥{2F"v0"F° wÞwªwE¥"t2vSNv FFt2vt2w6`vÞÂkvQÃIE2ÄI`z|Å¢S{2k¥E"F}2Fv0FwxS`SyKv0QFFht2£vZ®y"u{>²yyKyFFz|v0TEE"2zFf0Ey"vQ :{2F`"zf{2v{> vzyKF"FEMy"z|"E{>t>{Tv }2TEFvv0*EyAv{*{2EkvQ"²yA}2²yKt EkzTEzyAv2Ey"v0|TEF£}>yAEvQ{xTv0`{kvFEv0vQ:¤yAF{t2v»&}2F¼3v0½:E¾]v¿A{>½:¾uvuv0AT

−120

−100

−80

−60

−40

−20 0 DCT coefficients

20

40

60

&

80

E2z|yAwxFyyKFEv¶tyKFt>yK0yA{yA|fKv°t2z|>>`6vE{z|{2vSyAE{v0Ewz|wz|{2y""vvFt2°±vt2z|yA vw"F2zf|{*M3AvS z|Å {2z|"vyA{>fyv9Ft2z|>}2`Fvv0{xEvwF"v0v³F¥FFyAv0"À*vk2"v0°N{>vSy"S{xk2>{*TMv>Ey"t2Evv0vQTFFzfwxyAEyAzEFv±z|0F À*y"2{&z²·*3|v6v²w6t>**vQT2v`y"vQ{x¡zfFwxyK¥y"v0"fkv± z|{°±t2z²tyT}3v0z¬wvQEFyAkv suyA}>t2}2vfÑwSvSkFt2EF`v02SEz|{2E¦Fz|wFy"}2{>FTK¥""Fv´wE´t2vFÔvw6}2EvQvQT2v0`Ez|k{2v\ÏTyAF{yAEÏzFFz Å y"2£vQ}2E¤F"Ö }3Ø*v}2EEFz|"v0"²t>yAwyY"Sv¶°±t>v0z|²vt{zz|^w¥F}2vfv0v0fw vyY{*YEy"vQzfyA>z|{~fv9Ey"t2MvTk§2`FTv S``vyA l r É Ê ¹Ë É o2n ¸Iy"EEt>vy"¥2{2A·&FvÃh vz|Evv°áy""{>{2v0T 2wky""{vQFyAzf{>k{>Ã9QyAyK{>FEz²Ãh· vEv0MÅ y"`{2Ezfwxv0yA¥{>k{ ¥N"yA¶F²y¶v0zf¥{2kyv0y"kE| zfv0 `Ezt2Ev>}>Et2Evz|"²^{>#k¸{yAEvQE`>ESt>z|{2y"{2·´w®`{>`zf`¬FvyA° E¥2z|"M{"Fw±wEt2vvN{*FSuKkkv{vwFEv0k2TzfW2SwkEAFy"v0{>SE z|{2Î vQyAS{ ``IvQAÁ v ¥kMt2v0f}`

6

- p É r/ Mn )

!"$#&%'()*+%-,.%'0/,.123(4%-#5"$67"867(:9*29*;4+<=,.4" > %@?A(CBD23E29*F.GIHJ9*(4KL,.%+K.),MAONJ"QPORSOTUWV+XYR.U Z\[ X []:^_[`Ia T [ V.bdceUgfhRiji8SOUc ] V ^ ckRUl4mnkoJpq oLr.o.sLoLtO+l u ,4Nv4w+w+tO" xyz?AEz,D#{),O"L6|),;9*2=;4,<J}~%OO2323123<3239_N23%23K+29,.<+E$ E8{%23;y,.9*23%D"5}~%TR ][*[*` ceUObzR~Uy4RTiV ^ cRUc ` cUO ceTb ^ U ^_[ TUV ^ cRUV+XdR.T*.bR"$HOM)*23%K(:)()*<,.Kl u,4 N.+{%($yww+m" > '(y' +<=')*(:2=;AD"¢¡vR `J[ TU£f|T¤ ^ R*TVO¤.¥¦TRL§*V §:ckX ceb ^ c ] TRyR~bdV.U ` b [ S ` R TVU ` Ri8U [ bb*"¨HM)*23%K+(:) ()*<,.Kl yww+w" o.©(423<¦/"|++A%+%ª,.%'ªHO{A23<¦+,«~O'2=,"IHO9*(4K+,%,.<N23 G}_Ez,K(4¬)*(y,.9*(4'F23%KI{))*(:%O9HJ9*(4KL,.%K),MA23; H.G9~®,.)*(+"¯}_%°TR ][*[*` ceUObFRvUy:RTi$V ^ cRUCc ` cUO Z\[] RU ` U ^_[ TUWV ^ cR.UWV+X±RT.bR" HOM)*23%K(:)()*<,.Kl # M)*2=<²yww+tO" ³y(4<32 u " u ,{)*(:)y"´#@%23L()**,<&HO9,9*239*2=;4,<&?µ(49$G) ,.%'+E·¶29(4%(),.9*)*4"¸PORSOTUV+X5R´f|T¤ ^ R+X3R*¤.l ³nxpq twsy¹L³Jl|ywwLxO" m8" u J.)*(¦,%'5j" u ;,1W(+"U ^ TR ` S ]:^ ckRU ^ R ^ [ ¦TV ^ c ][ R Z^ V ^ ceb ^ c ] b*"\º»"+¼j"+/)*(4(4Ez,.%,%'+EM,%JNJlJ)' (y'29*23+% lD4w+ww" ryz¶2)*K+296²½9*¾4Ez,%%D"+}~%G)*Ez,9*2=%8¼2'23%K?µ(:)*E23%<=KNJ" }~%¿TR ][*[` ceUObRdUy4RTiV ^ cRU¨c ` ceUO 8 cTb ^ U ^_[ TUV ^ cRUV+Xj±RT.bR"|HM)*23%K+(:)h(:)*<=,Kl u ,4N+{%( yww+m"

t©23(4<3²6|)*.++4" > {9{(4µ\%23L(:)**,<HJ9*(4KL,.%+K.),MAON\" ÀJÁLÁ+Â²ÃÄLÄ.ÅLÅ+ÅhÆÇ.ÈJÁ+É+ÈOÊOËLËDÆÇÌLÉOÄ l7#&{K+{9yww+t" wH#Í,9,ªH(4;4{)*29~NJ"g?A(Î&oªÏh%;:)NM9*23+%Ð#&<=K )*29*AEdl u ,.)*;AywwLxJ" y¹z"¼j"&+,.%»B 2=%J9y"ÑU ^ TR ` S ]:^ ckRU ^ RCfhR ` ceUO»ÒD [ RT¤." HM)*2=%K+(:)h(:)*<=,KlWx%'(4'29*23+%DlDywwLxO" +¬j"º»"ºI,<3<=,;:(+"Ó?A(´L6hÏÔHO9*23<3<$6²2=;9*{)*(!+E$ M)*(423%´HO9,%',)' "IfhRiji8SOUc ] V ^ ckRUbzR~ ^ [$a fµ¡Îl onkoJpq +¹ysJo+ol #M)*2=<²yww" xy¬HO9*(4+(Îº,<9*+% "-}~%Ge.)*Ez,.9*23+%¿#{9*A(4%J9*23;y,9*2=%ÕGe.), H<323MMW(:)N©(:®0#K(+"ÖT4×ÖR+§y§:bPOR.STUWVX l¦x.¹nkoJpq34ts xmOlW#M)*23<²4w+w+³O" yz#%')*(y,.²º(49Ge(:<'8,%'8#%'O)*(y,h6|½9*¾4Ez,.%% "#99,;ØO +%HO9*(4K+,%K),.MA23;zHJN9*(4E4"8}_%TR ][*[` ceUJbzRU 4RTiV ^ ckRUÎc ` cUO ÒDOceT ` U ^_[ TUV ^ cRUV+XdR.T*.bR" HM)*2=%K+(:)&h(:)*<=,KlWHO(4M9*(4Ej1W(:)4w+w+wO" 4o.z"jÙ|+Ú <3<3%(:)ylz¼"/(y'()),.9*ADl8¼j"5Û<323Ez,%J9yl#5"56|½9*¾: Ez,%%Dl"6²2=.9),;AØL(lW#"º(:9Ge(4<=' lWj"º¨23;ØL(+l,%' j"Oº+<G_" u O'(4<3<323%K89*A(HO(4;4{)*29_NzG²HJ9*(4KL,.%K),MA23; HON9*(4E4"Ü}_% TR ][*[` ceUJb¨RªU44RTiV ^ ckRU°c ` cUO Z\[] RU ` U ^_[ TUWV ^ cR.UWV+X±RT.bR" HOM)*23%K(:)()*<,.Kl # M)*2=<²yww+tO"

Against Perfectionism: Defending Liberal Neutrality

Against Perfectionism: Defending Liberal Neutrality

Defending Your Digital Assets Against Hackers,Crackers,Spies,and Thieves

Defending Your Digital Assets Against Hackers,Crackers,Spies,and Thieves

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Space

Defending Space

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice

Defending Life: A Moral and Legal Case Against Abortion Choice

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Angels

Defending Angels

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Evil

Defending Devon

Defending Devon

Defending Jacob

Defending Jacob

Defending Serenity

Defending Serenity

Defending the Heiress

Defending the Heiress

Defending Jacob: A Novel

Defending Jacob: A Novel

Defending the Undefendable

Defending the Undefendable

Defending the Heiress

Defending the Heiress

Defending the Undefendable

Defending the Undefendable

Defending the Undefendable

Defending the Undefendable

Defending Common Sense

Defending Common Sense

Defending standardized testing

Defending standardized testing

Defending Hard Incompatibilism

Defending Hard Incompatibilism

Defending His Own

Defending His Own

Defending Rhyannon's Inheritance

Defending Rhyannon's Inheritance

Defending the Heiress

Defending the Heiress

Steganalysis of JPEG Images Breaking the F5 Algorithm

Steganalysis of JPEG Images Breaking the F5 Algorithm

Defending literature early mod england

Defending literature early mod england

Our partners will collect data and use cookies for ad personalization and measurement. Learn how we and our ad partner Google, collect and use data. Agree & close