Edited by G. Einsele and A. Seilacher
With 180 Figures
Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York 1982
DM G(;.OO
Professor Dr. GERHARD ErNSELE Professor Dr. ADOLF SEILACHER Institut fiir Geologie und PaHiontologie Universitiit Tiibingen SigwartstraBe I 0 D-7400 Tiibingen
ISBN 3-540-11373-8 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN 0-387-11373-8 Springer-Verlag New York Heidelberg Berlin This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, spedfical!y those of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, broadcasting, reproduction by photocopying machine or .similar means, and storage in data banks. Under §54 of the Gennan Copyright Law, where copies are made for other than private use, a fee is payable to "Verwertungsgesellschaft Wort", Munich, ©by Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 1982 Printed in Gennany The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Offsetprinting and bookbinding: Briihlsche Universitii.tsdruckerei, Giessen 2132/3130-543210
v
Preface
The problem of bedding, a basic feature of most sedimenta ry rocks, is as old as the science of geology itself. We use bedding in structural geology, regional correlation and for estimating the time involved in the stratigraphic record. Nevertheless we still are far from fully under standing the processes involved. This is particularly true for carbonate rocks, where primary phenomena are sometimes difficult to separate from the secondary diagenetic over print. After new interest in the subject had arisen from the International Deep Sea Drilling Project and from pa leoecological studies in our own research group (Sonder forschungsbereich 53 '1Pal6kologie11 ) , a Rundgesprach (work shop) was held in TUbingen on April 25th - 27th 1980. The present volume, which resulted from this symposium, con tains a variety of contributions, including some by col leagues that were unable to attend the meeting itself. Papers whose authors did not submit an elaborated manu s�ript, are represented by abstracts in the form presented fo'r the me�ting. Our own interest in the problem envolved from studies of 11Fossil-Bonanzas11, such as the Solnhofen lithographic lime stones or the bituminous Posidonia shales, in which the unusual kind and preservation of fossils indicated extre me environmental conditions. During these studies (see sununary ;reports in Zbl. Geol. PaUiont. II, 1976 and N. Jb. Geol. Palaont., 157, 1978) we realized that even in these cases· one single-ell vironmental model is usually insuffi cient to explain the conflicting evidences. This lack in our approach became still more evident, when we left the extreme end members to study Fossil-Lagerstatten such as shell beds, in more "normal" types of facies. The title of the symposium focuses on the key questions: to what extent does bedding reflect the gradual cyclic and periodic changes of _our tellu'ric system or rather rare and unpredictable events that occur in almost any sedimen tary regime? Or, more pragmatically: in what environments have telluric cycles a chance to leave a sedimentary re cord that does not become wiped out by bioturbation or obscured by the effects of catastrophic events? Because this inherent dilemma commonly splits researchers into a .''cyclist11 and a 11 catastrophist " camp, we felt it necessary to have both views adequately represented in this volume. The con tribu·tions cover a broad spectrum of rock and facies types and paleoecological as well as sedimentological and diagenetic criteria. The well-knoW n turbidites, although being the most prominent group of the event deposits, are, however, dealt with only by a few .examples in relation to coexisiting cyclic or black shale phenomena, or in order to demonstrate the role of carbonate diagenesis. The au-
VI thors of this volume range from amateurs and undergradu ate students to established experts. In spite of such in herent heterogeneities we hope that this collection of papers in some way does justice to the scope of the prob lem and meets the needs of geoscientists trying to under stand the meaning of bedded sequences. Our work at Ttibingen including the workshop mentioned above was sponsored by the German Research Society (Deut sche Forschungsgemeinschaft) which is gratefully acknow ledged. Particular thanks are due to Mrs. L. Hagel, E. Himmel, H. Jurczyk, A. Lupke, R. Stephani for typewrit ing the manuscripts camera-ready, to Mr. H. Vollmer for help in drafting, and to Mr. ��. Wetzel for photographic work including the reduction of roost of the figures and tables to meet the page size set by the publishers. All this work had to be accomplished besides the daily tasks at our institute. We are grateful to Springer Verlag for accepting our home-made product despite of technical shortcomings, for which the editors alone bear the re sponsibility. We hope that in spite of these deficiencies, this volume may _convey some of the spirit that united the participants during the symposium and help to free stratigraphy from the blemish of being a dry and purely descriptive science.
TUbingen, March 1932
G. EINSELE A. SEILACHER
·i� . •·
I
I
; 1 .,, ..
. .'·�·. '. .1": .
'i
.
. ..
VII
Contents
Part I.
Limestone-Marl Rhythms and Climate-controlled
Facies Changes General Remarks About the Nature, Occurrence, and Recognition of cyclic Sequences (Periodites) G. Einsele (With 1 Figure) . . . . . . • . . . . . . . • • • ....... .. .
3
Limestone-Marl Cycles (Periodites) : ficance, Causes - a Review G. Einsele (With 14 Figures) . • • . • . .
. . ..
8
Observations on Well-bedded Upper Jurassic Lime stones W.M. Bausch, J. Fatschel, and D. Hofmann (With 8 Figures) .....................................
54
Origin of Marl-Limestone Alternation {Oxford 2) in Southwest Germany W. Rieken and c. Hemleben (With 3 Figures) . • • . • • • • •
•
.
63
Limestone-Shale Bedding and Perturbations of the Earth1s Orbit w. Schwarzacher and A.G. Fischer (With 7 Figures)
.
•
72
Diagnosis, .
.
• •
.
. • .
.
. •
s·igni .
•
•
•
.
Rhythmic Sedimentation Documented in a Late Cretaceous Core (Abstract) L. Pr<:ttt.............................................
96
Ecology and Depositional Environments of Chalk-Marl and Limestone-Shale Rhythms in the Cretaceous of North America (Abstract) E.G. Kauffman........................................
97
Diagenetic Redistribution of Carbonate, a Process in Forming Limestone-Marl Alternations (Devonian and Carboniferous, Rheinisches Schiefergebirge, w. Germany) W., Eder (With 12 Figures) ............................
98
A Contribution to the Origin of Limestone-Shale Sequences 11. Walther {\Vith 2 Figures) • • . . . . • : . . . • • • . • • • . • .
•
.
.
.
•
11 3
Deep-Sea Stratigraphy: Cenozoic Climate Steps and the Search for Chemo-Climatic Feedback W.H. Berger (With 2 Figures) ·····�················ . • . 121
VIII Part IIA. Event Stratification.. Calcareous and Quartz-sandy Tempestites General Remarks About Event Deposits A. Seilacher (With 2 Figures) • . . . • . . .
.
.
.
•
.
.
.
.
•
.
.
.
.
•
Experiments on the Distinction of Wave and Current Influenced Shell Accumulations E. Futterer {With 2 Figures) . . . . . • . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . .
.
•
161 ':iJ '·
.
•
175
Calcareous Tempestites: Storm-dominated Stratification in Upper Muschelkalk Limestones (Middle Trias, SW-Gerrnany) T. Aigne.r (With 10 Figures) . . • . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . 180 Allochthonous Coquinas in . the Upper Muschelkalk Caused by Storm Events? (Abstract) H. Hagdorn, and R. Mundlos . • • • . . . • • • • . • . . • • . . • . . . .
.
199
The role of Storm Processes in Generating Shell Beds in Paleozoic Shelf Environments R.D. Kreisa _and R.K. Bambach (With 2 Figures) . . . . . . . •
200
.
•
-� ,';,
'
Rhythmic Bedding and Shell Bed Formation in the Upper Jurassic of East Greenland F.T. Flirsich (With 5 Figures) . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . • . . . . 208 Shell Beds in the Lower Lias of South Germany - Facies and Origin G. Bloos (With 7 Figures) . . . • . . . . • • . . . . • • . . . . • . • . • • . . 223 Storm Sedimentation in the Carboniferous Limestones Near Weston-Super-Mare (Dinantian, SW-England) D. Jef_fery and T. Aigner (With 1 Figure) . . . • . . . . • . . .
.
240
Event-Stratification in Nummulite Accumulations and in Shell Beds from the Eocene of Egypt T. Aigner (With 7 FigureS) . . . • • • . . . • • . . . . . • . . . . • . . . .
.
248
The !!Bank der kleinen Terebrateln u (Upper Muschelkalk, Triassic) Near Schwabisch Hall (SW-Germany} - a Tem pestite Condensation Horizon H. Hagdorn (With 13 Figures) . . . . . � • . . . • . • . . • . • . . . • . . . 263 Glauconitic Condensation Through High-Energy Events in the Albian Near Clars (Escragnolles, Var, SE-France) G. Gebhard (With 4 Figures) . • . . . • • . • . . • . . . . • • • . . • . . .
.
286
Muschelkalk/Keuper Bone-Beds (Middle Triassic, SW Germany) - Storm Condensation in a Regressive Cycle W.-E. Reif (With 11 Figures) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
299
Condensed Griotte Facies and Cephalopod Accumulations in the Upper Devonian of the Eastern Anti-Atlas, Morocco J. Wendt and T. Aigner (With 2 Figures) . . . . • . . . . . . . • . 326 Distinctive Features of Sandy Tempestites A. Seilacher (With 7 Figures) . . . • • . . • • • . . .
•
.
.
.
.
.
•
.
.
•
.
333
-�.
IX Multidirectional Paleocurrents as Indicators of Shelf Storm Beds D.I. Gr� y and M.J. Benton (With 2 Figures) . • . • . •
.
.
.
.
.
350
Scour and Fill: The Significance of Event Separation R. Goldring and T. Aigner (With 2 Figures) . . • . . . • . . • • 354 Storm-surge Sandstones and the Deposition of Inter bedded Limestone: Late Precambrian, Southern Norway M. Tucker (With 5 Figures) . . . • . • . . . • • . . . . . • • • • • • . . . .
.
363
Flat Pebble Conglomerates, Storm Deposits, and the Cambrian Bottom Fauna J.J. Sepkoski, Jr. (With 4 Figures) . . . . . . . . • . . . • . • . . . 371
Part IIB. Event Stratification - Other Event Deposits Jurassic Bedded Cherts from the North Apennines, Italy: Dyscyclic Sedimentation in the Deep Pelagic Realm T.J. Barrett (With 5 Figures) • . . . . . . . . . . . • . • • • . • . . .
.
.
389
Quartz-sandy Allodapic Limestones as a Result of Lime Mud-Raising Clastic Turbidites u. Maier-Harth (With 8 Figures and 2 Plates) . . . . .
.
.
•
404
Belemnites as Current Indicators in Shallow Marine Turbidites of the Santonian Bavnodde Gr¢nsand, Bornholm (Denmark) R. Schmidt (With 2 Figures) . . . . . • • • • • • . . • . • . . . . . . . .
•
•
419
Habits of Zircon as a Tool for Precise Tephra stratigraphic Correlation J. Winter (With 1 Figure) . . . . . • • . • . • • . • • . . . • . . .
.
.
•
.
.
.
•
423
.
.
•
.
.
.
431
Part III. Cyclicity and Event Stratification in Black Shales Cyclic and Dyscyclic Black Shale Formation A. Wetzel (With 5 Figures) . • • • • . • . . • • . • • . . .
.
.
.
.
Cyclicity and the Storage of Organic Matter in Middle Cretaceous Pelagic Sedime'nts P.L. deBoer (With 5 Figures) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . • • • • . . 456 Types of Stratification in the Kupferschiefer J. Paul (With 2 Figures) . . . . .. . . . . • . . • • . . • . • . • .
.
.
.
476
.
.
.
482
The Community Structure of "Shell Islands11 on Oxygen Depleted Substrates in Mesozoic Dark Shales and Laminated Carbonates (Abstract) E.G. Kauffman . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . •
502
.
.
.
.
Environmental Changes During Oil Shale Deposition as Deduced from Stable Isotope Ratios ·w. Klispert (With _5 Figures) . . . . . • . • . . . . • . . . • . . . . . .
X Ammonite shells as Habitats - Floats or Benthic Islands? (Abstract) A. Seilacher . • • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . • • . . . . • . • . .
.
•
.
.
.
504
Palynology of Upper Liassic Bituminous Shales (Abstract) W. Wille . . . • . . . • . . . . . • . . . . . . . • • . . . . . . • . . . . . . . •
.
.
.
•
.
505
.
.
The Bituminous Lower Toarcian at the True de Balduc . ement de la Lozere, S-France) Near Mende (DElpart W. Riegraf (With 2 Figures) . . . . . . • . • • • . . . • • . . . . • • . ... 506 Bedding Types of the ToarCian Black Shales in NW-Gree.ce J.P. Walzebuck (With 6 Figures) . . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . ...... 512 Stratinomy of the Lower Kimmeridge Clay (Dorset, England) (Abstract) T. Aigner; . • . . . • • . . . . . . • • . . . . . . . • • . . . . • . . . . . . . • .
.
.
.
•
.
526
The Formation of the Bituminous Layers of the Middle Triassic of Ticino (Switzerland) (Abstract) H. Rieber . . . • • . • . . . . . • • . . . . . . . • • . • . . . . • • • . . . • . . . . . . • . 527
*
s-ry Paleogeographic Significance of Tempestites and Periodites G. Einsele and A. Seilacher (With 2 Figures) • • . .•
• • . . .
531
XI
List of Contributors
1
*Aigner, T. 180, 240, 248 326' 354' 526 Bambach, R.K. 200 Barrett, T.J. 389 54 Bausch, W'.M. 350 Benton, M.J. Berger, W.H. 121 Blocs, G. 223 deBoer, P.L. 456 Eder, w. 98 *Einsele, G. 3, 8, 531, Fatschel, J. 54 Fischer, A.G. 72 Flirsich, F.T. 208 Futterer, E. 175 *Gebhard, G. 286 Goldring, R. 354 Gray, D. I. 350 Hagdorn, H. 199, 263 *Hemleben, C. 63 54 Hofmann, D. Jeffery, D. 240
Kauffman, E.G. 97, 502 Kreisa, R.D. 200 *Klispert, w. 482 *Maier-Harth, U. 404 Mundlos, R. 199 Paul, J. 476 Pratt, L. 96 *Reif, w.-E . 299 *Rieken, W. 63 Rieber, H. 527 *Riegraf, w. 506 *Schmidt, R. 419 Schwarzacher, w. 72 *Seilacher, A. 161, 333, 504' 531 Sepkoski, J.J. jr. 371 Tucker, M. 363 Walther, M. 113 *Walzebuck, J.P. 512 *Wendt, J. 326 *Wetzel, A. 431 *Wille, W. 505 Winter, J. 423
1A 11 authors marked with an' asterisk can be contacted under the following address: Geologisch-Palaontologisches Institut und Museum der Universitat SigwartstraEe 101 7400 TGbingen, FRG Please find the addresses of the remaining authors in the 11Address List11 (next pages)
XIII
Address List
Bambach,
R.K.,
Prof.
Virginia Polytechnic Institut.e and State University, Dept. of Geologi cal Sciences, 4044 Derring Hall, Blacksburg, Virginia 24061, USA
Barrett,
T.J.,
Dr.
University of TorontO, Dept. of Geology, Toronto, Ontario MSS 1A1, Canada
Bausch,
W.M.,
Prof.
Institut ftir Geologie u. Mineralo gie, Universitat Erlangen-Nlirnberg, SchloBgarten 5, 8520 Erlangen, FRG
Benton,
M.J.,
Dr.
Department of Geology University of Newcastle Upon Tyne, Newcastle, NE1 7RU, England
Berger,
W.H.,
Prof.
Scripps Institution of 09eanography University of California, San Diego La Jolla, California 92093, USA
�;
Blocs,
G.,
de Boer,
Eder,
W.,
Fatschel,
P.L.,
Dr.
State University of Utrecht, Insti tute of Earth Sciences, Budapest laan 4, P.O. Box 80.021, 3508 TA Utrecht, The Netherlands
Dr.
Geologisch-Palaontologisches Insti tut und Museum der Universitat, Goldschmidt-StraBe 3, 3400 GOttingen, FRG
J.
Institut ftir Geologie u. Mineralo gie, Universitat _Erlangen-Nlirnberg, SchloBgarten 5, 8520 Erlangen, FRG
Fischer,
A.G.,
Flirsich,
F.,
Futterer,
Staatliches Museum flir Naturkunde, Arsenalpla tz 3, 7140 Ludwigsburg, FRG
Dr.
E.,
Prof.
Dr.
Dr.
Princeton University, Dept. of Geological and Geophysical Sciences, Guyot Hall, Princeton, New Jersey 08544, USA Institut flir Palaontologie und Historische Geologie der Universitat, Richard-�agner-StraBe 10 II, 8000 Mlinchen 2, FRG Geologisch-Palaontologisches Institut der Universitat, Olshausen straBe 40/60, 2300 Kiel, FRG
XIV Goldring, R., Dr.
University of Reading, Dept. of Geology, Whiteknights, Reading Rg6 2AB1 England
Gray,
Department of Geology, University of Newcastle Upon Tyne, Newcastle, NE1 7RU, England
D.I.,
Dr.
Hagdorn, H. studienrat
Konsul-Uebele-StraBe 14, 7118 Ktinzelsau, FRG
Hofmann,
Institut flir Geologie u. Mineralo gie, Universitat Erlangen-Nlirnberg, SchloBgarten 5, 8520 Erlangen, FRG
D.
Jeffery, D.
Institute of Geological Sciences (Overseas Dept.) Keyworth, Nottingham, NG 12599, England
Kauffman,
Dept. of Geosciences, University of Colorado, Boulder, Colorado 80302, USA
E.G., Dr.
Kreisa, R.D.,
Dr.
Dept. of Geological Sciences, Ohio University, Athens, Ohio 45701, USA
Mundlos, R., Dr.
SchachtstraBe 6, richshall, FRG
Paul, J. , Dr.
Geologisch-Palaontologisches Insti tut urid Museum der Universitat, Goldschmidt-StraBe 3, 3400 GOttingen, FRG
Pratt, L.M.
Princeton University, Dept. of Geological and Geophysical Sciences, Guyot Hall, Princeton, New Jersey 08544, USA'
Rieber,
Palaontolog. Institut und Museum der ETH ZUrich, Klinstlergasse 16, 8006 ZUrich, Switzerland
H.1 Prof.
Schwarzacher, w., Prof.
Sepkoski, jr., Dr.
J. John,
Tucker, M.,
Dr.
J.,
University · of·Belfast1 Dept. Geology, Queen's University, Belfast - BT 71 NN1 Ireland
of
University of Chicago, Dept. of the Geophysical Sciences, 5734 s. Ellis Avenue, Chicago, Illinois 60637, USA Department of Geology, University of Newcastle Upon Tyne, Newcastle, NE1 7RU, England Geologisch-Palaontologisches Insti tut und Museum der Universitat, Goldschmidt-StraBe 3, 3400 GOttingen, FRG
Walther, M.
Winter,
7107 Bad Fried
Prof.
Geologisch-Palaontologisches Insti ·tut der Universi tat, Senckenberg Anlage 32-34, 6000 Frankfurt a.M., FRG
Part I. Limestone-Marl Rhythms and
Climate-controlled Facies Changes
I
I
I'
I
General Remarks About the Nature, Occurrence, and Recognition of Cyclic Sequences (Periodites) G.EINSELE
Abstract: Rhythmic sequences may be caused (1) by a succession of events or (2) by gradual periodic changes (minor cycles or per.iodites). Some characteristics of these principal me chanisms are demonstrated in sediment buildup-time curves for periodites, tempestites, turbidites, and black shales. The most prominent examples for periodites appear to be non turbiditic pelagic to hemipelagic limestone-marl rhythms. Under favorable conditions including diagenet�c enhancement of small primary alternations, they record a periodically changirig environment which is otherwise obscured or obliterated.
Cyclic or rhythmic sequences occur world-wide in presumably every stratigraphic system. Although such sequences have frequently _been dealt with in the past
1967; ELAM & CHUBER1
(e.g. MERRIAI1,
1972;
1964·; DUFF1
SCHWARZACHER,
1975) 1
HALLAM & WALTON1
many questions related
to this basic problem of stratigraphy are still unsolved.
Therefore
it is a challenge for earth scientists to do further research in this field in order to explain the striking phenomenon of cyclic sediments. Such an attempt seems particularly timely since new methods of inve. stigation have become available and our knowledge of Recent and Quater nary deposits in marine and lake environments has grown considerably. The term 11cyclic sediments" as used in the past comprises a wide varie ty of large-scale and small-scale phenomena of different nature and extremely diverse duration. In the p�esent context,
we cannot deal with
the whole spectrum of sedimentary seq�ences ranging from annual varves to lon�-period mega-cycles or cyclothems caused by lateral migration of a deltaic environment or by the rejuvenation of relief by endogenic
cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) ©Springer 1982
E..:.
4
.r ic se..... forces. The contributions to this volume focus on 1'1\0Xi.ne rhythr quences which DUFF et al
(1967 ) have described as "minor cycles". In a
first section we discuss cyclic sediments, which are controlled by factors not directly related to the mechanism of sediment transport and accumulation v,7ithin the sedimentary basin, outside of this area
but rather to processes
(allocyclic sediments).
1. Pure Type of Cyclic Sediments with a Certain Time Period
(Periodites) Some characteristics of these rhythms in comparison to event deposits are shown by Fiq. 1. The pure type of such rhythm.ic sequences consists of periodically alternating beds deposited in a pelaqic to hemipelag-ic environment below V.'ave bi:l:se. Sedimentation rate,
texture and fabri.c,
as well as composition of secUm.ents :rr.ay chang-e gJ:_"a.duai.ly within one period while features of omissio . n or erosion are atypical.
For that
reason, usually both alternating be·d types are affected by bioturbation anC no markeC change in the infauna can be observed. Base and top of sinqle beds show similar burrows;
breaks in the i.nfa.una occur only i:l:
oxygen depletion is involved near the sea floor.
Fig. 1 Simplified and idealized scheme of differences and interrelationships between periodites, tempestites, turbidites, and black·shale rhythms. Periodites are characterized by slow and periodic changes in sediment parame·ters, bioturbation, and sedimentation rates as well as by con tinuous vertical buildup with time (BT-curve). Change of primary com position includes texture and fabric; the curve for bioturbation re presents intensity of burrowing and also some changes in community. Tempestites and turbidites are the resul·t of erosional and dep_osi tional events, but sediment parameters, bioturbation, and sedimen tation rate of their background sediments may remain more or less unaffected. In the ideal case the material of tempestites is entirely autochthonous, whereas turbidites always contain sediment from distant sources (mixed with local material). In periodites as well as in the background sediments of tempestites and turbidites, the zone of bio turbation {B) is migrating solely upwards (Bupw), whereas the recolo nization of event deposits is starting at thelr surface and prograding . in a downward direction (B dw). Black shales may show both event strati fication (interval a) as well as periodic changes (interval b with periodites), but these are often superimposed by short-period changes generating thin !�ruinations as long as anoxic conditions are prevai ling. For further explanations see general remarks to part II (this vol.). Exp. = vertical exposure of sequence after diagenesis (compaction neg lected; 1, often lost by slow currentsi �, without lateral addition or loss of Sediment
5
TURBIDITES
PERIODITES
1 l
ALLOCHTH.
RATEOF SEDIM.
BIOTURBATtON
�
'
� 1
�
BACKGR. SED.
�
.
AN- l OXIC
l
l
l
l
\ MEAN COMP
EROSl
ON
�
BUt LD UP EXP
TEMPESTITES
I.'l''' [ ��;:H I ��L�� �· COARSE
I �
CHANGE I OF PRIM I I I I " COMPOS. F INE "'tl '·' 'v'
I �
°F
��bTM
BLACK SHALES
COMR A ( CaC03)
.
AL
I �EAN
.
COMP. 8 ("CLAY")
.t='-'>.
""lJlJJV
,
EROSION
-
��T�gn BUILD UP
bbft,k b fbik6�.
� ' :
t::e
6
As SCH1i17ARZACHER
(1975')
has pointed out,
there are cycles which carry
time information anC. others which do not. Many workers hold the opinion that rhythmic sequences as described above are induced or generated by some global mechanism with rr.ore or less constant time periods. If this is true,
such sequences can provide information about
stratigraphic a0e and accumulation rate as well as indications of �eneral qlobal processes. be termed
Therefore, sequences with this potential may
uPeriodites".
Mechanisms often quoted are the earth' s orbital cycles of precession, obliquity,
and eccentricity with·periods of approximately 21,000 y.,
41,000 y.,
and 100,000 years, respectively.
These periodic earth move
ments !l'lay affect the cliw.ate on the continents, the current systems of the Oceans, the elevation of the sea level and some physical and chemical prOperties of the sea water and thus al.so exert some in fluence on the sediments. The periodic change of on.e single sedimer..t parameter such as e.g. porosity rr.ay be sufficient to produce con spicuous rhythmic sequences,
particularly if it is enhanced by later
diagenesi-s. Marl-limestone rhythms are very sensitive to dia�enetic changes. Pro bably for that reason, these sequences have become the most prominent examples of periodites.
In view of the growing general interest in the
carbon cycle and the interchange of carbon dioxide between the atmos phere and hydrosphere, further studies on marl-limestone rhythms appear to be especially promising.
2.
Recognition and Modifications of Pure Periodites
Primary periodic alternations in sediments can be recognized only if they reflect substantial changes in sedQment parameters,
or if minor
variations are enhanced by secondary processes such as limestone dia genesis. Here,
the original symmetry of a sin�le bed can be lost due
to the uni-directional upward flow of pore water and its ability to dissolve and reprecipitate solid material. The recognition of perio dites may also be restricted to basins of a certain sedimentation rate. In areas of very slow deposition,
the sediments of alternating beds
can be completely mixed by bioturbation and thus the primary rhythm be obliterated. On the other hand,
high input of a sediment component not
implied in the periodic variations may dilute the alternating sediment components to such an extent that the · cycles become unrecognizeable. Periodic variations in a sedimentary sequence can also be obscured by aperiodic phenomena triggered by earth quakes,
storms and other events
Limestone-Marl Cycles (Periodites): Diagnosis, Significance, Causes - a Review G. EINSELE
Abstrac t : Pelagic to hemipelagic l imestone-marl rhythms are described as minor cycles with time information {periodite s ) They develop and can be recognized in the field only , if (a) the original sediment had a carbonate/clay ratio on the order of 4 and, under oxygenated ·conditions , if ( b ) the thicknes s of somewhat alternating beds was sufficient ( 5 to 10 em) to prevent complete mixing by bioturbation. Simple · models demonstrate the effect of fluctuating produc tivity and dissolution of (chiefly biogenic) carbonate as well as its dilution by 11clay11• Howeve r 1 small primary differences in carbonate content or texture - of alternating beds may be enhanced by diagenesis , including pressure solu tion, which strongly affect the final field aspect and the faunal content of the rhythmic sequence . Yet there are several criteria to prove the primary origin of such succession s . The exact correlation and timing of limestone-marl sequences is difficult in many case s , but it can hardly be doubted that the time periods of Quaternary and older carbonate cycles coincide in their order of magnitude ( 20 , 000 to 1 00 , 000 years) This i s also true for their sedimentation rate ( 0 . 5 to 3 cm/ 1 000 years) which is controlled by pelagic carbonate productio n . Limestone-marl rhythms reflect a depositional area below storm-wave base . In the case of continental margins or epicontinental seas , accumulation approximately balances subsidence , and alternating beds appear to be generated mainly by dilution. In the deep sea , cyclic carbonate de position is found on rises and plateaus , where it i s chiefly controlled b y dissolution i n conjunction wi·th a fluctuating CCD ·and/or changi ng bottom currents . _ Rhythms of this type occur wor�ide since Paleozoic time . They are probably caused by climatic variation s , but s imul taneous (generally small) sea level fluctuations may also play a part. During periods of widely extented and intensive plant grow·th on land, the .co2 content of surface waters may have been diminished for some time , whereas the river supply of dissolved old carbonate was increased. Both pro cesses tend to promote the production and preservation of carbonate in shallow and deeper water . •
•
Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
9
1 . Introduction
Rhythmic sediments with carbonate as a principal phase occur in diffe rent environment s , the most important of which are { FISCHER, 1 9 8 1 ) : { 1 ) Pelagic to hemipelagic marine sedimentary conditions , { 2 ) marine carbonate platforms , ( 3 ) lacust,rine settings . This paper only deals with the first group of environments . The purpose is not to add a further case study Of a' limestone-marl sequence t0 the already existing extensive l i terature , but rathe·r to make an attempt to review the " state of the art" on this problem and, if possible, to add,.a few points which have not been discussed very much. It also appears to be high time to use the great amount of new information from the study of young and older marine sediments in the - oceans and to apply this knowledge to ancient rock sequences on the continents . work on this promising task has s tarted only a few years ago . Further more , sedimentation and dis solution of marine carbonate i s an important process of the world-wide hydrospheric and· endogenic carbonate cycles . Since these cycles are interlocked with the exogenic organic carbon { including carbon dioxide) cycle of the hydrosphere, atmosphere , and biosphere on land { e . g . GOLUBI C et a l . , 1 9 79 ) , cyclic deposition of carbonate may reflect certain fluctuations in the exogenic carbon cy qle . Therefore , this interrelationship is also briefly discussed in this paper. For a theoretical and statistical approach to the problem, the reader may start with SCHWARZACHER1s { 1 9 7 5 ) book . In this paper only a few very s imple models are used to quantify the effect of di fferent oszillating processe s .
2 . Definition and .F ield . Aspect o f Limestone-Marl Rhythms
As already pointed out in an introductory chapter to Section I of this volume (EINSELE , this vol . ) limestone-marl rhythms are a simple case of a cyclic sediment with a comparatively long time period ( FUCHTBAUER, 1 9 70) . DUFF et a l . ( 1 9 6 7 ) have described such an ABAB sequence a·s "minor cycle'' displaying regular alternations of shale or marl and fine-grained argillaceous limes tone of the order of a few decimeters per cycle . SCHWARZACHER ( 1 9 7 5 ) describes cycJ..ic sediments as an ordered
10
sequence o f lithologies which i s repeated i n a predictable pattern , although the orderliness of the sequence i s never perfect . According to him , limestone-marl rhythms are 11short cycles n which probably carry a certain time information (type cycles ) . This is the case , if the al ternating sequence is due to a mechanism with a statistically .con stant time period . Then the rhythms may be termed periodites (i:IHSELE, this volume) . Many l imestone-dolomite cycles as well as some evaporite cycles belong to this group . Limstone-marl type 1 cycles have to be distinguished from other car bonate-shale or marl sequences (after SCHWARZACHER "type 2" sequences) which reflect aperiodic events ( carbonate tempestites and .turbidite s , see EINSELE, this vol . ; AIGNER , this vol . ) . There are cases, where this distinction i s more diffic�lt than anticipated ( see MAIER, this vol . ) , especially when the carbonate phase - also i s fine-grained ( e . g . mud turbidites) and primary sedimentary structures have been overprin ted by strong diagenetic effects ( e . g . nodular limestones) . Of course there may be cases where both types of alternating sequences exist in the same stratigraphic section, but field examples have been hardly reported ( e . g . DEAN et al . , 1 9 7 7 ) . Both types of alternating sequences have beds which are laterally uniform in thickness and can be traced over long distances . In the Kimmeridgian of Southern Germany ZIEGLER ( 1 9 5 8 ) was able to establish a bed-by-bed stratigraphy over a distance on the order of 200 km wh·i ch , according to GWINNER ( 1 9 7 6 ) , however , is not_ clear everywhere . Another good example of bed correlation has been reported from Berriasian marl-limestone sequenCes of the southwestern Alps (BEAUDQIN et al . , 1 9 74 ) . Both examples probably represent type cycles with time information . Further examples are reported by DUFF et a l . ( 1 9 6 7 ) , L011BARD ( 1 9 72 ) , SCHWARZACHER ( 1 9 7 5 ) , FISCHER ( 1 9 8 1 ) , and KAUFFMAN ( this vol . ) . A further means to distinguish between type 1 and 2 sequences may be the study of bed thicknes s .(BEAUDOIN et al . , 1 9 74 ; SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 7 5 ) . True cyclic sequences of type 1 should exhibit equal or subequal beds , whereas event deposits show a large variety of bed thicknesse s . This criterion i s , however , no� always valid, because already a_ slight shift in the composition of limestone-marl sequences can considerably alter the ratio of bed thicknesses of the l imestone and marl layers ( see below) . For that reason ,. type 1 cycles also contain certain marker horizons like the type 2 successions .
11
3 . Limits for the Recognition o f Limestone-Marl Rhythms A sedimentary sequence consisting of the two principal phases "clay" and fine grained carbonate may vary in its composition without showing any distinct lithologic change or bedding in field exposures and dril ling core s . In ancient rocks , an observable transition from marlstones to limestones us �ally takes place when the carbonate content surpasses a certain minimum value Beyond this limit the material becomes hard rock arid more or less resistent to weathering. H�hce a rhythmic se que �ce can be easily recogn ized in the field only , if the alternating beds have a carbonate content fluctuating around this boundary ( Fi g . 1 ) . . osZ illations in the carbonate content below or above this limit do not significantly change the f ield aspect of the material as marlstone or limestone, respectively . However, as SCHNEIDER ( 1 9 6 4 ) has demonstrated for Early Cretaceous marine deposits of NW-Germany , alternat·i ons of claystones poor and somewhat richer in carbonate (average 8 % ) can be recognized in the field as rhythmic succes sions . As SEIBOLD ( 1 9 5 2 , 1 9 6 2 ) , HEILER { 1 9 5 7 ) , and OVERBECK ( 1 980) have pointed o u t , i n Jurassic marl-limestone sequences of Southern .Germany, the minimum carbonate content for l imestone beds or nodules of liDestone in marl (often des cribed as shale) is approximately 70% or even higher. In the Upper Cretaceous of �orthern Germany, at least 75-85% Caco are necessary to 3 fc/rm a hard limestone bed (ABU-MAARUF , 1 9 7 5 ) . Certainly this value varies between different occurrences of limestone-marl sequences (Fig . 2 ) , because it depends on several factors , the nature of the car bonate as well as the grain size distribution and mineralogical compo sition of the "cla)r" -phase , but for the models discussed below it is taken as a constant value. Consequently, the mean a·c cumulation rate of detrital silicates in the depositional area must be considerably lower than the biogenic carbonate accumulation (possibly minus dissolution) in order to get a limestone-marl sequence . Hence, this type of rhythm is strongly related to the production rate resp. sedimentati�n rate of fine-grained carbonate in the pelagic to hemipelagic environmen t . According to MILLIMAN ( 1 9 7 4 ) , i n the Holocene this rate (related to solid limestone) is on the order of 0 . 3 to 0 . 6 cm/1 000 y . on shelves and slope s , 0 . 4 to 0 . 7 5 cm/ 1 000 y . in 2000 to 3000 rn water depth of the large oceans ( in greater depth less ! ) , and 0 . 7 to 1 . 9 cm/1 000 y . in enclosed marine basins . •
.
If the pelagic carbonate production is diluted by a clay supply too high for the mean composition necessary for the transition from marl to limestone , the total sedimentation rate becomes higher than the values found for typical limestone-marl successions . This actually is
'
i ,f
12 TIME
Fig. 1 Sequence with an oszillating, but slowly increasing carbo nate-clay ratio (The ampli tude of the clay oszillation is 1 : 3 and remains constant in the course of time) Only oszillations crossing the transition line between lime stones and marls (here assumed to correspond to 70% carbonate, 30% clay) generate an alternating marl limestone sequence which can be easily recognized in the field •
MARL-LIMESTONE
the case for the example of Early Cretaceous marly claystones mentioned above , where over long periods the sedimentation rate was 5 to 9 em/ 1000 y . { SCHNEIDER, 1 9 6 4 ) . On the other hand, if carbonate anQ clay supply, although in the correct ratio, drop below a certain limit, the al ·te �nating beds run the risk to be destroyed and completely mixed by burrowing organisms . It is - difficult to fix a certain minimum bed thickness necessary for the _ preservation of primary bedding, but accor ding to field observa ·tions and special studies by SARNTHE"IN ( 19 7 2 ) , -
�
Fig. 2 . carbonate content in different limestone-marl sequences of the Jurassic in SW-Germany ( after HEILER, 195 7 ) . Marl layers are indicated by oblique hatchures , but the boundary between marls "and l imestones genera_lly is. transi tiona! and depends to some extend on the state of weathering. Inspite of this uncertainly it can be clarly seen that the "field aspect as limestones" starts at different car bonate content s . Maximum carbonate contents are found in the center of the l imestones . 'l'he exposures of Essingen and Al tenstadt show the same sequence 26 km apart
13
em
m
ESSINGEN
I I
�
OXFORDIAN IMALM fll LIMESTONES
I
50
ALTENSTADT
I I I
KIMMERIDGIAN \MALMo\ WEISSENSTEIN
40 30
'
'
I I
I
8?
I.
I
I !
I
20
I 10
I I I
-�'·
I
-t.., I c,�. -t;....
�"J. !
..rf' I
110 100
'
90
I I I I I
60 10 "
I
OXFORDIAN I MALM [J\ LIMESTONES GENKINGEN
50 40 lO 20 10
MARL
/
"
' '
CALLOVIAN I DOGGER 1;1 MARLS L ENGETAL , I I I I I
50 40
PLIENSBACHIAN
I LIAS ¥) MARLS
30
MOSSINGEN
20 10 0 70
..
"
100
% Co C03
60
0 90
100
"
"
60
%
CoC03
90
100
14
BERGER and HEATH ( 1 9 6 8 ) , BERGER et al . ( 1 9 7 7 ) , and A . WETZEL (pers . communication) this limiting thickness of one of the alternating beds may be on the order of 5 to 1 0 em. In Quaternary sediments from the deep slope off west- A·f rica ( 4 720 m water depth) , WETZEL { 1 9 8 1 ) has worked out the burrow-induced mixing of a 30 em thick layer rich in carbonate alternating with clay beds . Fig . 3 shows that a zone of several em at bottom and top of the bed contains strongly varying carbonate contents of burrow-fillings as well as a transition zone of medium carbonate content for the total sediment . In thi·s case , an alternating succession of 5 em thick beds certainly would have been completely obliterated. In oxygen-depleted environmentS , mixirig of alternating layers i s , of course, strongly reduced or absen·t . From this brief discussion it is evident that limestone-marl rhythms are restricted to environments with a comparatively narrow range of sedi ment accumulation. This rate- often varies between 0 . 5 and 2 cm/1 000 y . A further problem i s the distinction of true alternations and secon dary bedding planes . The number of observable beds in the same sequence may vary in relation to the degree of weathering ( SCHWARZACHER , 1 9 7 5 ) , if this distinction is not possible by using other criteria. This is a seiious problem for the determination of the time period of the limestone-marl cycles { Chapter 5 . 2 . ) . An oszillating supply of carbonate or clay in the right ratio which is discussed below as a principal cause of limestone-marl couplets , be completely masked by the substantial contribution o f a third pha se, e . g . silt or sand to the total sedimen t . For that and other reasons , limestone-marl-rhythms cannot develop in shallow water above wave base .
4 . Direct Mechanisms Producing Limestone-Marl Rhythms The different mechanisms leading to limestone-marls rhythms have been described, in a more or less complete way, by several authors {recent ly e . g . by DEAN et al . , 1 9 7 8 ; FISCHER, 1 9 8 1 ; VOLAT et al . , ·1 980) . The existing views can be summarized as follows: There are (1 ) primary or synsedimentary processes generating limestone-marl couplets and { 2 ) diagenetic processes producing or at least enhancing the genera tion of alternating beds . In the fol lowing discussion we assume that the basic requirements for the formation and recognition of a rhythmic sequence are complied with.
15
4.
L
Primary' Rhythms
4 . 1 . 1 . Periodic Fl uctuations of Carbonate Production (Productivity Cycles ) Primarily, marls and limestones are mixtures of a detrital phase of different silicate ·minerals , in general within the clay and silt size fraction ( usually described as "clay" ) and a biogenic phase consisting of the skeletons of plantonic and benthic organisms ,;<. (carbonates) . Two phase bedding cycles (FISCHER, 198 1 ) occur as soon as the contribution o:t at least one of these phases starts to fluctuate in the course of time ,(Fig . 4 ) . A pure productivity cycle is characterized by fluctua ting carbonate supply during steady contribution of clay (Fig. 4A) . This graph presents , however , only the alternating composition of the growing sediment colu_m n, but not the varying thickness of alternating beds . The bed sequence resulting from this mechanism is shown quantita tively for a still more simplified case in Fig . S , where a homogeneous marly sediment column ( 60% carbonate and 40% '1clay11 ) is transformed into a sequence of alternating marl-limestone beds . In this example , the periodically increased carbonate production must be higher by a factor of at least 2 in compqrisOn with the original production rate ( production fac tor 2 ) in order to get a hard and · resistent l imestone lay � .r contairiing_ at least 70% carbonate as mentioried above . With increasing production factor the periodically generated limestone beds become thicker (Fig . S) . For a production factor of. 5 , in our example the ratio of the bed thicknesses of limestones and marls L/M is 3 . 4 , for a factor of 1 0 , it is 6 . 4 . Carbonate-
t
'"''�--w;th Zoophy�os Plan
I
iles
carbonate: toyer
Planolites. with •
A
high carbonate content low carbonate content
Fig . 3 I1ixing by bUrrowing at the upper and lower boundary of a layer riCh in carbonate alternating with clay bed s . Marine Quaternary a t the slope off west Africa (after NETZEL , 1 9 8 1 )
16
From this s imple test it can be seen that an already high original or 11background carbonate production" ( in our example contributing 60% of the total sediment) must be multiplied periodically by a factor of 1 0 to 20 to produce the common type of limestone-marl sequences with limestone beds alternating with thin marl layers . For that reason, e . g . SEIBOLD ( 1 952 , 1953 ) assumed a periodic inorganic precipitation of car bonate in order to explain Oxfordian limestone-marl sequences in southern Germany . Today we know ( HEMLEBEN, this volume) that these he mipelagic limestones as those of many other occurrences are composed mainly or entirely of biogenic materia+. The study of Quaternary marine sediments ( e . g . PRELL and HAYS, 1 9 7 6 ; RUDDI.MAN and t4ciNTYRE , 1976; PISIAS, 1 9 7 6 ) has reveaJ,ed that periodic changes in total biogenic carbonate production and in the faunal and mineralogical composition of the carbonate are indeed a wide-spread phenomenon for reasons some of which are discussed below. Whe·ther these fluctuations i.n carbonate production alone. are suff icient to produce the common type of rhythmic limestone-marl sequences as men tioned above i s , however , doubtful . It is difficult to assume that genic carbonate production is periodically multiplied by a factor of 1 0 or even 5 , if special envi�onmental conditions as upwelling are ruled out. For that reason cyclic productivity can be regarded only occasionally as the principal factor controlling limestone-marl rhythms . 4 . 1 . 2 . Periodic Increase of Detrital Sili cate Supply ( Dilution Cycles ) The pure type of this rhythm is generated when a steady production of biogenic carbonate is more or less diluted by fluctuating input of the detrital phase ('Fig . 4C) . If the cycles are symmetric , i . e . the half periods have the same length (duration) , the layers relat ively rich in "clay11 will become thicker than the alternating layers rich in carbo nate . The ratio L/M of bed thicknesses of l imestones and marls noW de pends on the mean composition of the sequence . If the mean carbonate/ clay ratio is just about at the transition from marls to l.imestones ( say 70% carbonate and 30% clay ) , the L/N-ratio will become < 1 . A higher mean carbonate content, however , enables the development of thicker l imestone beds altern·ating with thinner marl layers (Fig . 4C) A simplified quantitative study of these relationships is shown by Fig . 6 . Here a homogeneous sequence primarily consisting of 8 5 % carbo nate and 1 5 % clay ( s ame original composition as assumed by DEAN et al . , 1 97 8 ) is affected by periodic steplike increases of the clay input. •
[
BIB/\ 1061-HGi INHIIOVTO\ Qft<.\l!O�A�7KDM
. "-���. ��l�VHMm £?_fi�fi�
,CLAY" SUPPLY
CARBONATE SUPPLY
CARBONATE D I SSOLUTION RATE
@
S1+C2+D0
52+C3+DO (Sand C 180' out of phase)
52+C3 + 02
(Cand D 180' out of phase)
I
1®
�1 I
L
M
51
PURE.�LAY"
.
®
In this case doubling of the clay inPut (dilution factor 2 ) leads to a marly limestone with 2 6 % clay, and marl layers develop only when the dilution f_actor is greater than approximately 3. From this model and Fig . 4C one can clearly see that periodic high clay input into a car bonate-dominated environment probably is the most common mechanism to explain the occurrence of thin limestone layers alternating with thick
Ji�:L:._
I
. F�g . 4 . Model ""t:o ·-exp'l·a:t:n....,..,..the combined result o f steady ( 8 1 , C 1 , DO, D 1 ) or fluctuating silicate supply ( S , nclay11 ) , carbonate sup ply ( C ) , and dissolution ( D ) in the course of time . The resulting total rate of deposition as well as the varying composition of the sediment is shown by (A) through '(E): for vari ations of S and c , but without dissolution, ( D ) and {E ) : for fluctuat ing C and s , either in pha se ( D ) or 180° out of pha se ( E ) . ( F ) and ( G ) : With fluctuating dissolution in combination with ( F ) s teady S and C , or ( G ) with inpha se fluctuating s and 18oo out of phase fluctuating c . Much more combinations are feasible, especially if the amplitudes 6f the fluctu ations (here causing vari ations of rates by a factor of 3 ) and the periods of the three different pro cesses are varied or the cycles become asymmetri c . The percentage o f marl and limestone in the re sulting sediments s trongly depends on the ratio of S 1/ C 1 (here 3/10 resp . 2 3 % clay and 7 7 % carbonate )
.
18 (->
Fig. 5. Simplified model for the transition of a homogeneous marly sediment column (A) i-nto a lime stone-marl succession ( C ) by peri odically increased carbonate pro duction ( B , productivity cycles ) . Note the relation between the thickness of limestone layers ( L ) and the carbonate production fac tor. ML, marly limestone
RfSUt T OF (B)
A
B
VOLUME OF PORE�FREE SEDIMENT TIME
c
RESULT OF (B)
A
8
VOLUME Of PORE-FREE SEDIMENT TIME
Fig. 6 . Simplified model for the transition of a homogeneous clay bearing carbonate Sediment (A) in to a limestone-marl success ion ( C ) b y periodically increased clay in put (B , dilution cycles ) . Note the growing thickness of the marl lay ers with increasing dilution fac tor, whereas the thickness of the limestones remains constan t . ML = marly limestone
19
marl beds. · In the example of Fig. 4 , a dilution factor of 20 enables a L/M-ratio of 0 . 2 6 . In previous work on alternating limestone-marl beds dilution as a controlling factor has not been stressed very much. However, for Pleistocene sediments of the deep sea1 it is generally assumed that during glaciations more fine and coarse grained material was delivered into the oceans than during interglacial s . Already a regression of sea by eustatic sea level fluctuations can induce this mechanisfu'.. Further more , in basins not far from land areas with a climate fluctuating between desert and more humid condi�ion s , the input of air-borne and river-borne fine-grained detrital material is fluctuating ( e . g . SARNTHEIN, 1 9 78 ) . In the eastern Ivlediterranean Sea , Quaternary periods of stagnation are characterized by several horizons of black shale which also reflect a reduction of detrital input from the neighboring land areas ( DOMINIK and STOFFERS , 1 9 7 9 ) . Hence in certain environments , par example on marine shelves or in shallow adjacent seas , where cyclic productivity and dissolution are less probable, strong variations in "clay11 input may be the most plausible cause for an alternating bed sequence . 4 . 1 . 3 . Periodic Dissolution of Carbonate - ( Dissolution Cycles ) Dissolution of carbonate can take place within the water column or in the uppermost sediment layer·s at the sea ·floor ( FLUGEL and PENNINGER, 1 9 6 6 ; EDER, this Vol . ) . In Fig . 4F a steady supply of clay and carbonate is superimposed by fluctuating dissolution of carbonate . With the re latively low original carbonate/clay .. ratio ( 7 7 % carbonate and 2 3 % cl ay ) of this example, the result o f fluctuating dissolution is a sequence of alternating thick marl and thin l imestone beds. On the basis of the ratio L/11 of bed thicknesses , this sequence can hardly be distinguished from the sequence of Fig . 4 C generated by cyclic dilution . Starting with a higher carbonate/clay ratio (the same as DEAN et al . , 1 9 77; have studied) Fig . ? demonstrates again in a simplified way by applying steplike changes , the effect of increasing dissolution on a primarily homogeneous clay-bearing carbonate mud (pore volume neglected) •
As already DEAN et a l . ( 1 9 7 7 ) have pOinted out, in this case a disso lution of 50% carbonate (dissolution factor 2 ) is not sufficient to produce a marl layer, but the thickness of thiS bed is already distinct ly reduced . InCreasing dissolution leads to thinning marl layers bet ween limestone beds of more or less constant thickness . If periodically 95% of the original carbonate is dis solved (dissolution factor 20) the
20 A VOLUME Of PORE- FREE SEDIMENT TIME 100%
[
B
RESULT OF PERIODIC DISSOLUTION
PERIODIC DISSOLUTION OF ORIGINAL CARBONATE 100% 0 50
100% PORE.-fREE SfOIMENT
' '
'
"
-·
l
15
'
5
:;� a" "
M
l
-
7
Fig . 7 . Transition o f a homoge .neous carbonate sequence ( A , taining 85% CaC0 3 and 1 5 % clay) into a limestone-marl succession ( C ) by periodic dissolution of primary carbonate (B) , dissolu tion cycles ) . Note the decreas ing thickness of individual marl beds with increasing dis solution
6
37
5
l
-=-�
0
l
L/M-ratio becomes 5 . 2 . A value in this order of magnitude appears to be characteristic for many limestone-marl sequences . Recently , periodic dissolution of carbonate .has been quoted by several authors as the main factor controlling fluctuating carbonate contents . In their review of Pleistocene sediments in the deep sea, VOLAT et al. ( 1 980) were able to show that during glacial periods in the Pacific much less calcareous skeletons were dissolved than during the warm periods (Fig . 8 ) . Therefore, the total carbonate content of the sediment is higher by 5 to 1 0 % than that of the alternating muds . �his relatively small fluctuation of carbonate content between 80 and 90% is, however , not suff icient to produce a marl-limestone sequence , if it is not enhanced later by diagenesi s . Stronger fluctuations in the carbonate content of Quaterpary marine sediments have been found else where in the Equatorial Pacific (BERGER, 1 9 7 9a) or in the wester� equatorial Atlantic (BEet al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . In contrast to the Pacific , here sections rich in carbonate ( 60 to 80%) correlate with warm whereas the glacial sediments contain only 4 5- 5 5 % biogenic carbonate (Fig . 9 ) . The main cause for this alternating carbonate content also appears to be dissolution rather than variations in species or of the belts of maximum production toward the equator ( see also et al . , 1 980) . The non-contemporaneous dissolution peaks in the appear to be associated with the changing circulation of Antarctic bottom waters. The same mechanism is quoted to explain several disso-
21
CORE DESCRIP TION
DEPTH !N em
S te o/POB
SEDIMEN TAT ION RATE
SOLUTION INDEX
TOTAL CARBONATE
30
COLOR
TEXTURE COLOR
40%
CJ1�2-3 IIllilll' ITIIIIJs 1::·:-:Js c::J7
Fig . 8 . Carbonate fluctuations in a Pleistocene deep-sea core from the Pacific by periodic climatically-controlled carbonate dissolution (redrawn and somewhat simplified after VOLAT et a l . , 1 9 80) . High values of solution index signify increasing dissoluti<;m intens.ity . Stippled areas correspond with glacial periods according to oxygen isotope studies
22
v25-59
%coco,
60
TIME SCALE 0
>0 20 30
<0
50 • •
" 60 • • w > 70 • 0
• • w • w •
eo
90
>OO '"
>20 <30
• STADE 0 INTERSTADE Fig. 9 . Carbonate fluctuations in Pleistocene deep-sea se � iments of tbe western equatorial Atlantic (core V 25-5 9 , after BE et al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . carbonate peaks correlate with warm interstadial periods derived by MORNER { 1 9 7 2 ) for the region of the eastern Great Lakes, North America lution cycles found by KELLER ( 1 9 80) in Miocene deep sea sediments of (\ the North and Southeastern Pacific. A further well documented example of dissolution cycles has been re ported from the Eocene of the Sierra Leone Rise in the eastern Atlantid< ( DEAN et al . , 1 9 7 8 , 1 9 80) . Cores from the Deep Sea Drill ing Project, Site 3 6 6 , 2800 m water depth , have revealed an alternating sequence of clay or marl and chalk with carbonate contents f luctuating between lesS:; than 1 0 and 80 to 8 5 % (Fig . 1 0 ) . From careful examination of the bio genous components preserved it is evident that sections poor in car bonate reflect periods of strong and sel ected dissolution of nanno-
23 % CaC03 dl�$Oived
%clay added·dilution
I
r.
I'
I
li
DISSOLUTION ONLY l
DILUTION ONLY A
Fig . 1 0 . carbonate fluctuations (A) in Eocene sediments from DSDP Site 3 6 6 , Sierra 'Leone Rise, 2800 m water depth ( DEAN et al . , 1 9 78 and 1 980) . Ass�ming an initial pelagic sediment with 8 5 % caco 3 and 1 5 % clay, the observed composition ( A ) results either from carbonate dissolution ( B ) or from dilution by clay ( C )
fossils and foraminifera rather than dilution by clay . Periodic disso lution here is explained by a fluctuating depth of the carbonate compen sation · depth ( CCD) and the lysocline { see e . g . BERGER, 1 9 7 9 ) . At pre sent the Sierra Leone Rise lies well above the CCD , but during Eocene time, the CCD had reached just about the depth where the cyclic sedi ments were deposited ( DEAN et al . , 1 9 80) . An example demonstrating Quaternary dis sOlution cycles by a fluctuating lysocline is reported by BERGER and MAYER ( 1 9 7 8 ) from the Ontong-Java Plateau. A somewhat different model using cyclic disso � ution and reprecipitation of basin floor ca-rbonate to explain shelf carbonates al ternating with shales, particularly black shales, is proposed by DEGENS and STOFFERS ( 1 9 76 ) . For a further discuss ion of bedding phenomena in black shales see 1VETZEL ( this vel . ) .
24
4 . 1 . 4 . Combinations of Fluctuating Carbonate Production , Dilution, and Dissol-ution The three synsedimentary processes described above which generate limestone-marl couplets can be combined in several way s . Some of these combinations which have a certain probability in nature are presented in Fig . 4 . Oszillating carbonate production in combination with steady clay supply and cOnstant dissolution (factors S 1 + C2 + D 1 ) does not cause �uch change in comparison to the pure productivity cycle (81 + C2 + Do, Fig . 4B ) apart from a general shift to a sequence more rich in clay with thicker marl layers. A combination of oszillating carbo nate productivity ( C 2 ) and oszillating clay supply ( S 2 , both in phase) leads to a pure limestone sequence, although the total sedimentation rate is strongly fluctuating (Fig . 4D) . I f , however, dilution and pro ductivity fluctuate 1 80� out of phase ( S 2 + C3 + Do, Fig . 4E) , again a limestone-marl sequence is deposited. Finally, Fig . 4G demonstrates the result of three f luctuating processes ( S 2 + C3 + D 2 ) , where clay and dis solution are in phase , but productivity is 1 80° out of phase . In this case , pure 11clay" beds can be generated alternating with marls and limestones ( 3 bed cycle) The result would be similar , if only C3 and D2 are combined and clay supply is kept constant . •
.
In the fol lowing chapters , these combinations are not further dis cussed, because the existing case studies usually do not give enough information for an interpretation in this way. In general , one of the three factors discussed i s , beside diagenesis , held to be chiefly responsible for the rhythmicity . 4 . 1 . 5 . Other Primary Factors Causing Minor Cycles in Carbonates In or or of
,. i;
general , there are many other processes leading to alternating beds cyclic sequences ( see e . g . DUFF et al . , 1 9 6 7 ) . Dealing with pelagic hemipelagic carbonates , the number of alternatives or modifications the mechanisms described above i s , however, sma l l .
Instead o f a gradually changing lithology a t the transition from marls to l imestones and viceversa, a sharp boundary may be visible . If tur bidites and other depositional events ar_e excluded , such sharp bounda ries can be explained as omission planes or hardgrounds , or as a com bination of both phenomena. Lithification of lime mud at or slightly below the present sea floor has been reported from many localities in shal·low and deep water { summarized e . g . by r.nLLH1AN, 1 9 74 ) .
25
can be accomplished within a period on the order of 1 0 , 000 years , and it can occur periodica�ly 1 _par example on the I4id-At1antic . Ridge { RN1SAY , 1 9 74 ) . Also Plant growth {possibly algae) at the floor of flat1 widely extended submarine banks has been quoted to form rhythmic succ essions of hardgrounds , e . g . in the Upper Cretaceous of Normandy {JUIGNET and KENNEDY, 1 9 7 4 ) . If kept free of sediments for ' some time, firm and hardgrounds often are identified by post-depositional burro wing or boring organisms (see e . g . HATTIN, 1 9 7 1 ; FURSICH , 1 9 7 7 ) , which indica te that there were long periods of non-deposition. There may be sequences with regular repetitions of suCh beds possibly due to periodic sea level fluctuations . There may also be composite cycles, where two or more independent cyclic processes are superimposed (SCHWARZACHER� 1 9 7 5 ) . In Upper Jurass.ic/Berriasian l imestone-marl successions, BEAUDOIN ( 1 9 7 7 ) has found 3 different time periods for cyclic processes controlling some minor features of these succession s . Favorable conditions for such a development can be expected in semi enclosed basins similar to the Red Sea, where sea level f luctuations were assoc iated with variations of (high) salinity (1>1-ILLIMAN et al . , 1 9 6 9 ) . Studying successions which contain penecontemporaneous , recolo nized firm and hardgrounds , we run, however , the risk to get an in cor�ect number of rhythms , because part of the sedimentary record may be missing. The chances for the preservation o f a total cyclic record again improve , when in a subsiding area a tidal flat and lagoonal en vironment is established . Then carbonate cycles of the Loferite-type may develop (FISCHER, 1 9 6 4 ) .
4 . 2 . Diagenetic ProcesseS Diagenetic processes have been quoted by several authors to be the only cause ( e . g . SOJKOWSKI , 1 9 5 8 : rhythmic unmixing) or at least the main factor producing a lternating limestone bedS ( diagenetic overprint) . In the last 1 0 to 20 years an enormous number of publications on the diagenesis of carbonates , m�ny of them summarized by BATHURST ( 1 9 7 1 ) and MILLH1AN { 1 9 7 4 ) has shown the str:,ong and early influence of dia genesis on the lithif ication of carbonates . There can be no doubt that diagenesis also must play a great part in the formation of limestone marl rhythms .
26
4 . 2 . 1 . Rhythmic Unmixing In the Hettangian of England, KENT ( 1 9.3 6 ) described limestones as se condary features , and in Oxfordian limestone-marl sequences of Poland SOJKOWSKI ( 1 9 5 8 ) observed no difference in the organic and mineral composition of both bed types . The limestones , however, were characte rized by a great percentage of calcitic cement and a better preserva tion of the macro- and microfauna than the marl layers , where smaller remains or more delicate shells had disappeared. SUJXOiVSKI concluded that primarily there was no difference in carbonate content and in the nature of the carbonate between the two bed type s , but he admitted that the diagenetically produced rhythmic changes might be due to very inconspicuous, chiefly textural primary alternations in the sequence ( see also HALLAH , 1 9 6 4 ) . According to our present knowledge on the diagenesis of carbonates , a rhythmi� unmixing of a completely homogeneous sediment column appears to be very unlike l y . In this case the result of diagenesis probably would be a random distribution of limestone nodules within a marly matrix or a nodular limestone with thin and irregular lenses of marl . Recent work on nodular limestones (NOBLE and HOWELLS, 1 9 7 4 i GARRISON and KENNEDY , 1 9 7 7 ) envisages such a pure diagenetic unmixing. However, as soon as limestone nodules are restricted to certain horizons wi·thin the sediment, a primary chemical or textural deviation from the mean composition appears ·to be necessary. For that reason , a purely d iage netic origin of the marl-limestone rhythms is rejected.
4 . 2 . 2 . ·Early Diagenetic overprint The most far-reaching effect of a diagenetic overprint is that mentio ned· above . Primarily the sedimentary column is homogeneous in respect to the carbonate/clay ratio, but inhomogeneous concerning the nature of the carbonate and/or the texture of the total sedimen t . A simple model for the last case starting with a carbonate/clay ratio of 4 (clay content 20% ) is represented in Fig. 1 1 . This example is based on three assumptions : ( 1 ) Gravitational compaction has reduced the origi nal pore volume to SO% , before diagene sis starts ( see e . g . SCHLANGER and DOUGLAS , 1 9 74 ) , ( 2 ) no further gravitational compaction takes place, i . e . the following reduction of porosity versus zero is solely due to carbonate dissolution and reprecipitation in the pore space, ( 3 ) carbonate is dissolved only from the subsequent marl layers ,
27
B
A
0
( '%VOLUME so
100
Fig . 1 1 . !1odel of lime stone-marl couplets purely produced by dia genes i s . A , primary fluc tuations of texture , pore size , etc . , but B , without alternation of . pore volume or composition ( carbonate/ clay ratio 4 : 1 ) . Early state of compaction (pore volume 50% ) i arrows show the succeeding migration of carbonate from marl (M) to limestone (L) layers . C , final composition and D1 field aspect of lime stone-marl couplets (pore volume 0) Limstones ( L ) consist o f 4 0 % primary carbonate cement and 1 0 % clay, but are not further compacted since B •
DEPTH
whereas carbonate precipitation is restricted to the texturally diffe rent subsequent l imestone beds . The result of this admittedly very simplified model is a limestone.:..rnar l sequence with a bed thickness ratio 2.5, whereas the original bed thickness ratio (after mechanical L/M compaction) was approximately 0.6. The carbonate content of the lime stone member has been diagenetically increased to 90% , but 50% of the total sediment volume is taken by carbonate migrated from the subse quent marls and �e�recipitated as cement. The marls have lost 75% of their original carbonate to the limestones , but due to "chemica-l com paction" they still contain 50% carbonate in the form of the original , mainly biogenic components . In reality limestone-marl diagenesis is much more complicated, but in this paper only a few additional points can be mentioned .( for further details see e . g . RICKEN and HEMLEBEN, this vol . , or WALTHER , this vol . ) : =
( 1 ) Already during mechanical compaction some dissolution and re precipitation of carbonate may take place . Then the dissolved carbo nate can be transported by the upstreaming pore-water into higher levels ( e . g . EINSELE , 1 97 7 ) and, und�r slightly changed physico-chemi cal condition s , start to cement such layers which primarily are rich in carbonate (containing suff icient nuclei of the stable carbonate phase) and/or have larger or different pores as well as a better per meability than the material below and above . Once cementation has star ted, compaction ceases in this horizon , but is proceeding in the neigh-
28 borhood . As a resu'l t, the carbonate content may reach a maximum in a certain level and decrease towards the base and the top of the growing limestone bed (Fig . 2 ) . Therefore , from the carbonate content alone it cannot be decided, whether the original carbonate phase was fluctuating or not. ( 2 ) As long as advective transport is involved, the maximum carbo nate content is not necessarily found in the center of a l imestone layer. However , if carbonate is migrating solely by molecular diffu sion, its rate and distance of transport becomes equal in an upward and downward direction (Fig . 1 1 ) . This certainly is the most important process for limestone diagenesis , although it takes a very long time and can transport dis solved species only over relatively short distan ces (em to m} concerning. the low concentration gradients involved ( e . g . BERNER, 1 9 7 1 ; FREEZE and CHERRY , 1 9 7 9 ) . The best examples for this process are limestone concretions within marls or shales (EINSELE and MOSEBACH , 1 9 5 5 ; SEIBOLD , 1 9 6 2 ; RAISWELL , 1 9 7 1 ; HUDSON, 1 9 78}. : (3) Tiny skeletons of aragonite and Mg-calcite usually are dissolved first, whether they occur in subsequent marls or limestones . Therefore ,: these constituents are generally miss ing in either bed type. At greater ·.·;: burial depth , also calcitic · foraminifera and nannofossils start being corroded or dissolved, especially if pressure solution becomes impor tant . Simultaneously calcitic cement is precipitat e d in the free pore space. In their study on pelagic carbonates from the Shatsky Rise, Northwest Pacific , MATTER et al . ( 1 9 7 5 ) have estimated, that in 1 00 m burial depth the percentage of cement in relation to the total carbonate con tent is already 6 4 % , and in 240 m 7 6 % . In a sequence with primarily alternating beds, the carbonate cement will be precipitated chiefly in layers, the grain framework of which is already stabilized by cementation against further gravitational compaction. In contrast, layers still affected by gravitational compaction will loose most of their dissolved · carbonate , because they provide only very small pores for cementation. Many authors indeed hold the view that carbonates be come lithified . at much Shallower depth than clayey sediments . This is a further reason , why a primary diff erence between the ·two alternating bed types appears to be mandatory. The better preservation of calca reous fossils in the limestones in comparison to the marls , however , cannot b e used a s evidence, neither for purely primary o r purely secon� dary origin of the limestone-marl couplets .
29
( 4 ) Magnesium released by the dissolution of Mg-calcite may be used form small quantities of authigenic dolomite (e . g . WALTHER, this to vol . ) . The occurrence of alternating l imestone-dolomite sequences, par example in the Upper Muschelkalk (Triassic) of Southern Germany, how
ever, cannot be explained by this mechanism alone. 4 . 2 . 3 . Pressure Solution and Stylolites
Pressure solution and the formation of stylolites can start durlng an
early burial stage and comes to an end when the pore space of the
surrounding sediment is completely filled by recrystallized carbonate { P�RK and SCHOT, 1 968) . In order to allow the migration of dissolved carbonate by diffusion, the pores must be water-filled. This inter stittal water is more or less stagnant, for as soon as meteoric water starts to circulate, the dissolved carbonate, or at least part of it,
is transported far away . The result is beginning karstification, which
is not dealt with in this pape r .
The· effects of pressure solution are evident in many limestone-marl sequences, par example in the Oxfordian sequences of Southern Germany
quoted above (Fig. 1 2 ) . The transition from a limestone to a marl bed as well as the marl beds themselves are often marked by a network of interconnecting irregular, but essentially bed-parallel solution seams ahd stylolites {WEILER, 1 957 ; RICKEN and HEMLEBEN, this vol ; GARRISON and KENNEDY, 1 97 7 ) .
By this mechanism, primary sedimentary structures are commonly distur
bed and difficult to recognize . The occurrence of these stylolites con firms the hypothesis that a great part of the limestone cement is deri ved from the accompanying marl layers .
During the main phase of stylolitization, not only the limestone beds,
but also the marls may have become firm and .gained a stabil ized grain framework . Therefore, stylolitization can be regarded chiefly as the last phase of the diagenetic overprint.
Studies on the carbon isotopes of limestone cement ( e . g . HUDSON, 1 975, 1 9 7 7 ) confirm the importance of cementation and pressure solution du
ring burial diagenesis. The source- of the cement is' often more or less identical with the marine carbonate sediment, because an influence of
isotopically light near-surface bicarbonate is subordinate or missing { see also CAMPOS and HALLAM, 1 979) . Therefore HUDSON assumed that chiefly shale's are the " donor beds11 for the cementation of the adjacent
limestones .
30
Further investigation s , e . g . the study of trace elements such as Sr, and Mn ( e . g . VEIZER, 1 97 7 ) , the fossil-matrix isotopic contrasts ( e.g. HUDSON , 1 97 7 ) as well as the influence of bacterial activity on the carbon isotope composition ( I RWIN et al., 1 97 7 ) have shown the 1 i ty to distinguish between different stages of diagenesis and tion . Essentially , all this work has underlined the great importance of diagenesis for the formation of limestones .
5 . Diagnosis and Interpretation of Limestone-Marl-Rhythms
5 . 1 . Criteria for Primary Origin Most of the criteria to be mentioned here are s imple and well-known to the experienced geologist. Much can be taken £'rom th.e preceding dis cussions and earlier publications ( e . g . HALLAM , 1 964 ; DEAN et al., 1 978) . Nevertheles s , a brief summary may be useful :
( 1 ) Composition and texture of the alternating beds . If the carbonate phase is· excluded , a primary alternating sequence may show some differences in the detrital sil icate phase , bo.th in texture and
composition. However, such differences must be used with caution, be
cause of the possibility of crystal growth and the formation of authi genic silicate minerals.
( 2 ) Fauna and bioturbation. The use of carbonate skeletons of rent faunal groups as a means to identify primarily
( SUJKOWSKI , 1 958) appears to be equivocal. As mentioned above, also
l imestones may have lost part of .their orig.inal fauna by dissolution, although the loss of biogenic carboD;ate from the marls is much greater.· On thE: other hand, extraction of fossils from. marls by standard mE't�hods is easy and may, therefore , pretend a very goad fossil preservation in these beds . Unfortunately , in this environment siliceous fossils are
very sensitive to diagenetic proces ses , too, and hence more or less useless for our purpose . More promising are all those relicts which are resistent to diagenetic dissolution , e . g. chitinous tests or parti culate organic matter . A better means for the distinction of primarily alternating beds is bioturbation , if the rhythmic sequence is not com
pletely destroyed by intensive burrowing (Chapt.2 ) . Burrows in one type
31
of the alternating beds may be filled by sediment from the other type (HALLAM , 1 9 64 ) . Sometimes a gradual change in the nature and intensity
of burrowing can be obserVed (Fig. 1 2) . However, it has to be taken into account that the marls have undergone stronger gravitationa l compaction · and chemical . dis �olution than the l imestones .
( 3 ) Inorganic - sedimentary structures should be also used as criteria
with caution. Small-scale lenticular or flaser bedding of marls may be entirely due to pressure solution (WEILER, 1 957 ; RICKEN and HEMLEBEN , this vol.) . There are, however, cases where a primary dif ference bet
ween the sedimenta.ry structures of both bed types is evident (Fig .1 2) . Thi:·s is probably one of the best evidences we have for the primary origin of the rythms . ( 4 ) The interpretation of oxygen and carbon isotope f l uctuations raises different problems mainly because of the strong influence of
diagenesis and interactions between the solid phase and interstitial Water {see e . g . HUDSON , 1 977; SCHOLLE and ARTHUR, 1 980) . These diffi culties may be particularly serious , if relatively smallscale varia-
/.
tions are considered. Recently , WEISSERT et al ( 1 979) and de BOER ( 1 980 and this vol . ) , however , have shown 0 1 3 c fluctuations between alternating limestones and black shales of Cretaceous age in the Alps.
WEISSERT et al. used bulk samples rich in calcareous nannofossils for
tfieir isotope study , whereas de BOER pointed out that the carbOn iso tope composition of organic matter is more stable and thus a better
indicator of primary environmental conditions . In both example s , the present limestope beds are isotopically lighter than the shale s , but
de BOER argues that in this case the original situation was opposite , because subsequent bacterial fermentation of organic ma'tter has altered 13 the 6 c value of the shale s . Obviously more work is necessary in this field to get a reliable tool for the identif ication of the primary
environment and its variations.
5 . 2 . Correlation and Timing of Limestone-Marl Rhythms 5.2 . 1 . General Constraints The timing of ancient l imestone-marl rhythms , i . e. the determination of the period of one cycle , is dealt with in more detail by FISCHER . ( 1 981 ) and SCHWARZ ACHER and FISCHER {this vol.) . Therefore , here only a few points have to be mentioned.
32
D
1cm
1----1
c
1cm
F
33
(1) The best method to aCcomplish this aim is to date bottom and top of a very thick sequence which contains a great number of cycle s . Thus the error for the timing of one cycle becomes re·l atively sma l l .
Neverthele ss ,,-the timing o f such sequences b y biostratigraphic methods remains rather uncertain. If , par example , the period of one cycle is 50,000 y. and the sequence between two datable levels contains 1 00
cycles , the difference in a �e of the two reference levels is only 5 m . y . Such a short time lriterval usually cannot be me.asured prec.is�ly by biostratigraphic methods . Hence the period of the cycles may easily vary between 40, 000 and 60 , 000 y .
Better results can be achieved with radiometric methods using volcanic
ash layers (KAUFF!1AN , 1977) or glauconite (ERNST et al . , 1979) . The
best timing of cyclic sediments has been accomplished for Quaternary marine sediments with the radiocarbon and thorium metho d , stable iso tope studies and magnetostratigraphy ( see e .. g . CLINE and HAYS , 197 6 ; SHACKLETON and OPDYKE , 197 3 ; IMBRIE and H1BRI E , 1979) .
( 2 ) The second problem is the determination of the number of cycles between two reference levels . As was pointed out earlier (chapters 3 and 4 . 2 ) , the recognition of primary alternations depends on several factors , the most important being the carbonate/clay ratio , biogenic
mixing in combination with the sedimentation rate , diagenetic overprint ahd weathering. It should be added that the common processes of con densation , offiission, and winnowing at the sea floor may, if they are
overlooked in a thick succession of similarly-looking beds , falsify the number of cyc les . Most of these factors tend to reduce the real number of cycles .
( 3 ) The diffi·c ulties mentioned above are obvious when exposures of the same succession have to be correlated over la·rge-distances . Thanks
�
Fig . 12 . A and B , pressure solution at the transition from limestone member (white) to marl (dark) Numbers in A indicate Caco 3 content (after WEILER, 195 7 ) . c and D , completely bioturpated limestone and marl beds with gradual transition from one bed type to the other (drill ing cores from the Lower Oxfordian , Heil3jura alpha, Hausen) . E, thick bioturbated limestone bed� alternating with thin evenly lami nated black marl layers . This relatively rare occurrence indicates the primary origin of the limestone-marl couplets . •
F , dark marl layer with sharp boundary to the underlying limestone and indications Of small-scale lenticular bedding due to pressure solu tion ( ? ) . (E and F represent drilling cores from Oxfordian l imestone marl succes sion , Weil3jura beta, Strassberg , Southern Germany)
34
to distinct master horizons (Chapt . 3 ) , usually a very good correlation
of certain sections of the total succession is possible { e . g . 1 96 6 ) . A bed-by-bed correlation i s , however, sometimes difficult .
Fig . 2 demonstrates �n example of well studied exposures in Oxfordian limestones of Southern Germany mentioned above (WEILER, 1 95 7 ) .
exposures lie 2 6 km apart and have been selected, because they contain
excellent mas�r beds with a typical fauna. The Essingen-section was , howeve r , 50 years exposed to weathering instead of only 1 0 years in the case of Altenstadt. This may be one of the reasons why on the
of the weathering profile and the very carefully determined carbonate content, the number of visible primary cycles appears t� be somewhat
different at both localitie s . Even for one exposure this number quite clear, because the thickness of. both bed types as well as that of the couplets varies very much . Such unc·e rtainties are, of course ,
multiplied, i f instead o f a 6 m sequence a much thicker �imestone marl succession is investigated. VJell documented examples for these difficulties (points 2 and 3 of this discussion) also have been repor ted from the Upper Cretaceous of NE Germany (SEIBERTZ , 1 979) .
5 . 2 . 2 . Discussion of Some Results For all these reasons , an exact timing of the limestone-marl periods
is difficult and often problematic . F ISCHER ( 1 981 ) prepared a list of well exposed and carefully investigated Cretaceous and Paleocene lime stone-marl successions in Europe and the United States and found
periods in the range of 1 2 , 000 to 1 00, 000 y . A great part of this
variation is caused by uncertainties in the absolute age of the stage boundaries , particularly for sequences Cenomanian to Coniacian in age.
Nevertheless, most values can be attached to two groups , one with values around 20, 000 y , another , b ut less distinct , with periods around 40, 000 y .
Some other values for the time· period of limestone-marl rhythms al).d
argillaceous rhythms in ancient rocks are listed in Table 1 . Values
for Quaternary carbonate cycles as observed in deep-sea sediments can
be taken from Table 2 .
Although this data collection is far from being comple.t e, it allows to draw some conclusions : ( 1 ) The scatter of data for the time period of limestone-marl
rhythms as well as redox cycles is considerable and covers the range me ll tioned above (FISCHER, 1 98 1 ) . This is also true of the Quaternary
marine cycles, which vary bet_ween 1 5 , 000 and 1 00 , 000 years, if one
example of a major cycle is neglected.
{ 2 ) The periods of the older rhythms have the same order of magni tude as the Quaternary cycle s . This is a strong argument that both
periodicities were contrOlled cl imatical l y .
( 3 ) Some authors , partly bY using modern statistical methods such as spectral analysis ( e . g . HAYS et al . , 1 97 6 ; de BOER, this vol . ;
SCHWARZACHER & FISCHER, this vol . ) have been able to put forward evi ,dence for the existence of certain discrete time periods .related to the orbital cycles of precession, obliquity, and eccentricity { periods of aroUnd 2 1 , 000 y . , 4 1 , 000 y . , and 1 00 , 000 y . , after MILANKOVITCH, 1 930) .
Personally , I am in doubt whether this is feasible with the information we have as yet , at least for sedimentary cycles older than the Quater nary period . As we have seen , the error in timing is still great and difficult to overcome .
( 4 ) For these reasons , it is not yet proven that limestone-marl
rhythms and other minor type 1 cycles really have a constant time period . The Quaternary marine carbonate cycles {Figs . 8 and 9) also re
present cycles of different length . Probably it is more realistic to say that the time period of a l l these rhythms varies around a certain me�n value . This mean time period is expected to be constant .
The time interval of event deposits such as tempestites and turbidites certainly is not constant { see e . g . AIGNER, this vol . ; SEILACHER, this vol . ) . From Late Quaternary marine sediments we know that turbidites
occur in time intervals between 500 and 1 0 , 000 years ( RUPKE and STANLEY , 1 97 4 ) . Their frequency depends very much on the sediment supply in shallow water and the configuration of the depositional area (EINSE.LE
and KELTS , 1 981 ) . I n basins with low input of sediment, their average
frequency may wel l be on the same order as that of the l imestone-marl periods {DEAN et al . , 1 97 7 ) . Therefore , similarities in the appearence
and sedimentation rate of cyclic limestone-marl sequences and fine grained al lodapic l imestone successions alternating with marls or clays are to be expected ( see MAIER-HARTH , this vol . ) .
( 5 ) Quaternary and older carbonate cycles coincide not only in their
range of time periods, but also in their rate of sediment accumulation . For wet Quaternary deep-sea sediments this rate is 1 -3 cm/ 1 000 y . , whereas older, more or less consol idated and lithified l imestone-marl successions , show rates between 0 . 6 and 2 . 8 cm/1 000 y . , if an extreme
case with the contributiori of chert is excluded. As already mentioned earlier, this rate is dictated by the limiting factor of carbonate
g;
Table 1 . a Average Time Periods of Pelagic to Hemipelagic Limestone-Marl Rhythms - older than Pleistocene ( for further data see FISCHER , 1981 ; WETZEL , this vol . ) Age
Oligocene to Miocene Eocene
Locality
Sierra Leone Rise (DSDP Site 3 6 6 ) "
I>iethod of timing biostrat. and radiometric "
Late Cretaceo us
NW-Germany
biostrat. and radiometric
Mid-Cretaceo us
Western Interior Basin, USA
radiometric
Mid-Cretaceous
Southern Europe
Barremian to Tithenian
C ape Verde Basin (DSDP Site 3 6 7 )
Kinuneridge
Oxford
Sedimenta- Time tionrate a per.i9d ( crn/1000 y) x1000 y
Remarks
Author { s )
0 . 9- 1 . 6
44
chalk-marl cycles
Dean· et al. ( 1980)
1. 4 5.2
19 7
altern. of green and cherty chalk
"
2.8
30-40
l imestone-marl cycles
Ernst ( 1979)
24
limestone-marl cycles
Kauffman (pers. conununic . )
limest. alternating with black shales
de Boer
altern. bioturbated l imestone and laminated dark marl s
Dean et al . ( 19 77)
biostrat. b
o.6
37
S Germany
biostrat. b
ca. 2
15-20
mean of c a . 110 couplets in 3 5 m pr
Ziegler d ( 1958)
S Germany-
biostrat. b
c a . 15
mean of 4 6 0 couplets in 120 m profile
Seibold ( 1952) d
c a . 3 . 4c
Il
-
�-
-�
- ;
-
- -
I
-
Table 1 . !?_ Average Time Periods of some Argillaceous Rhythms Eocene Late C�etaceous to Paleocene Hauterivian to Albian
biostrat.b
Cap Verde Bas.in "
NW-Germany
"
biostrat.
o.6
ca.SO
0.6-0.8
ca.50
1 .1-9
25-33
altern. greenishgray and dark carbonaceous claystones
altern. blue-green and reddish-brownish silty claystones altern. claystones and marly clayst., mean of 7 4 5 couplets
Dean et al. ( 1 97 7 ) "
Schneider ( 1 96 4 )
Table 1 . � Average Time Periods of some Peritidal or Lagoonal Limestone-Dolomite Cycles Early Cretaceous
I stria ( Jugoslavia)
biostrat.b
Triassic (Dachsteinkalk)
Austria
biostra t .
Triassic. ( Wettersteinkalk)
Austria
biostra t .
b b
ca.6
1 0-20
mean of 300-400 cycles
Flichtbauer and Tislja:r: ( 1 975)
ca. 1 0
20- 1 00
approx. 200 cycles in ca . 1.5 m . y .
Fischer ( 1 96 4 )
ca.20
ca.40
: · mean of
>
1 00 cycles
Bechstadt ( 1 97 3 ) -
a , dry , solid or lithified sediment
b , poorly defined base and top of succession, or poor determination due to other causes c , high value due to a relatively high percentage of marls d , authors did not calculate sedimentation rate or time period of cycles
'i
85
Table 2 . Average Time Periods and Sedimentation Rates o f Quaternary Carbonate Fluctuations in the Deep Sea Locality
Method of timing
Atlantic { Colombia Basin) Core v 1 2 - 1 22 Core V 1 8 - 357
stable isotops and radiometric
W equat. Atlantic Core v 25 - 59 NE-Atlantic Panama Basin Core V 28 - 2 3 8 Pacific (Solomon Rise, Core V 28 - 2 3 9 W-Pacific Ontong-Juva-Plat. Pacific Core 04 - KS06 Indian Ocean Core IC - 5 Indian Ocean E-Mediterranean Sea
"
"
"
"
(+biostratigr.and tephra:chronology) "
oxygen isot. and magnetostratigr. acoustic records in comb. with isot. and radiom.
stable isotops, radiom. , and foram. stratigr. stable isotopes , radiometric , and magnetostrat. stable isotopes and radiometric
Sedimenta- Time Period X 1 000 y tion rate (cm/1000 y) 2.3 ( wet) 2.0 ( wet)
Remarks
2.8 (wet)
60 50 20 - 30 15
mean of 2 cycles mean of 3 , or mean of S-7 cycles mean of 8.5 cycles of different duration
2.3 ( wet)
83 - 8 8
mean of 7 cycles
0 . 6 (dry, solid) 1 .o ( wet) ca.2 (wet) 1 .0 (wet)
23 1 00 25 90
2 2 5 - 350 75
1 . 7 ( wet) 3.0 (v.Jet)
aThere are also shorter periods due to turbidites
1 00 42 23 4 0 - 6 0a
, Author ( s )
Prell and Hays ( 1 97 6 ) B e et al. ( 1 97 6 ) Ruddiman and Mcintyre ( 1 97 6 )
for 6 1 8 o and carbon. Pisias ( 1 97 6 ) for opal accum. mean of minor cycles Shackleton and ( carbonate dissol.) Opdyke ( 1 97 6 ) mean of 5 major cycles mean of up to 7 cycles
Berger and 11ayer ( 1 97 8 )
mean of 5 different mean of 3 different
Volat e t al. ( 1 980)
t
cycles of duration cycles of duration
t
dominant in a record of minor cycles 4 50.000 y mean of 5 - 8 redox cycles
Hays et al. ( 1 97 6 ) Kidd et al. ( 1 97 8 Dominik and Stoffers ( 1 979)
�
39
production and not by rhythmic diagenetic processes { e . g . HALLAM, 1 9 6 4 ) . peritidal or lagoonal limestone rhythms , however , usually have been deposited with higher sedimentation rates ( 6-20 cm/1 000 y . , Table 1 c ) . ( 6 ) Therefore, also the thickness of a l imestone-marl couplet generally varies between narrow limits (commonly 1 0 to 50 em) With growing supply pf ,·clay" , the sedimentation rate as well as the thick ness of individual couplets inCrease s . In Upper Jurassic sediments of southern German y , the couplets of predominantly marly sequences (mean •
carbonate content 7 5 % ) reach an average thickness of 6 3 em, whereas in the l imestone succes.s ion (mean carbonate content 9 0 % ) they are only 36 em thick (calculated after data from SEIBOLD, 1 9 5 2 and 1 9 5 3 ) . For predominantly clayey deposits ( example in Table 1b after SCHNEIDER , 1 9 6 4 ) there is theoretically no limit for the thickness of single rhythms and their sedimentation rate . 5 . 3 . Conclusions for Tectonic Setting and Paleoceanography of the Depositional Area 5 . 3 . 1 . Principal Requirements for the Realization of Limestone-Marl Succession s From the preceding chapters one might draw the conclusion that the ge nesi,.,s of pure limestone-marl successions is restricted to rather special environmental conditions , the most important ones are ( see also chap� ter 3 ) : ( 1 ) Deposition . below strom wave base ; no eros ion or non-deposition by bottom currents ; no interruptions by turbidites or other events; ( 2 ) Maintenance of a certain carbonate/clay ratio on the order of 3 to 4 (after possible synsedimentary dissolution) . Since carbonate production is limited, this implies a sedimentation rate of about 0 . 5 to 3 cm/1 000 y . ( 3 ) More or less steady state conditions over a period on the order of 5 m . y . , if a rhythmic sequence of 1 00 m thickness is deposited. Con sequently, in a comparatively shallow basin (with a sea floor somewhat deeper than storm wave base) subsidence should at least balance sedi ment accumulation ( see ( 2 ) ) . In spite of these constraints , l imstone-marl successions have been rea lized rather frequently throughout geologic history ' s ince Paleozoic time. The reason is that the three requirements mentioned above often match the situation in present and ancient ocean basins and therefore not seldom also coincide .
40 5 . 3 . 2 . Consequences for Deep Shelves and Epicontine ntal Seas Divergent continentql margins show a certain hi story of subsidence (WATTS and STECKLER , 1 9 7 9 ; von RAD and EINSELE , 1 9 80) . During and shortly after rifting , subsidence is very fast (on the order of 1 0 to 50 cm/1 000 y . , 'but later slows down more or less exponent ial l y . One can assume that SO to 1 20 m . y . after rifting a rate of subsidence is reached which is in the correct order for the formation of limestone marl sequences . -At the margins of the Atlantic ocean , this situation was realized since Mid-Cretaceous time. In the course of the Tertiary, subsidence became too low to maintain the steady state conditions mentioned above . The shelves became too shallow, �nd reworking and winnowing of sediments started. Of course , this development was imposed by other important processes such as great climatic changes sea level fluctuations which cannot be dealt with in this contex t . Below epic9ntinental seas the rate o f subsidence usually i s low, but may reach the order of magnitude necessary for the formation of lime stone-marl rhythms , especially if subsidence coincides with a global sea level rise ( VAIL and HITCHUN., 1 9 7 9 ) . For that reason , in several regions of Europe limestone-marl rhythms have been deposited on top of continental crust (Variscan fold belt) during Jurassic and Creta ceous time s . However , their development was always in danger to be di s·turbed or modified by ( 1 ) clay input too high (transit ion to marl s ) ( 2 ) clay input too low (transition to pure limestones) , ( 3 ) shallowing sea ( reworking, omission , wedging out and channelling , interfingering and replacement by reef s , transition to carbonate tidal flats , or tion and replacement by sandy materia1) . Many successions in the Jura ssic of Southern Germany or in the Cretaceous of Northwestern Germany show these tYpes of facies change ( e . g . ZIEGLER, 1 9 7 7 ; SEIBERT Z , 1 9 7 9 ) . A s a result , in" .these regions the ideal type o f a more or less constant l imestone-marl success ion is verified only for relatively short time intervals on the order of 1 to a few mill ion years. For both settings , continental margins and epicontinental seas , it can be as sumed that carbonate dissolution does not play a great part for the genesis of the rhythms . Hence , periodic dilution and, to a minor degree and only in some case s , varying redox conditions and/or carbo nate productivity are held to be responsible for the primary of alternating beds which later are strongly enhanced by diagenes i s . I f dissolution can b e neglected, these successions tend to have ·thicker l imestone-marl couplets which are deposited under a higher rate than those of the deep sea ( compare Tables 1 and 2) •
41
5 . 3 . 3 . Consequences for Rhythmic Deep-Sea Carbonates Periodicity in deep-sea carbonates appears to be chiefly caused by dissolution due to a fluctuating carbonate compensation depth . This is often combined with a changing circulation system including inter actions between two ocean basins such as assumed for the Quaternary between the Antarctic water masses and the Atlantic and Pacific Ocean ( e . g . VOLAT et al . , 1 980) . During times of unstable stratification of the oceanic water masse s , caused by a smaller temperature gradient beto ween low- and high-latitude areas , fluctuations of the CCD or the ly � ocline probably' have been larger than at present time {BERGER, 1 9 7 9 ) and may , therefore, have affected a wide depth range . Thus, the occurr ence of dissolution cycles in the ancient record presumably is not re stricted to deep submar-ine rises or plateaus where they have been found preferentially in Quaternary s ediments. If carbonate dissolution at the sea floor is a major factor , the initial carbonate/clay r.atio must be higher than the final one . In other words, regions with l imestone-marl successions due to per�odic dissolution have a lower clay input and a lower mean sedimentation rate than dilu tion cycles, provided biogenic carbonate production was tDe same in both areas . As mentioned above , the values of Tables 1 and 2 obviously s�pport this assumption . Of course we also know areas of increased cai'bonate produc.tion in com bination with coastal uPwelling or ocean current divergence ( e . g . STOWE , 1 9,7 9 ) . The typical l imestone-marl succession i s , however , not associated with upwelling and an exceptionally . high production of phyto- and zooplankton reflected by high contents of organic matter and opaline silica (chert) in the corresponding sediments .
6 . Global Control of Limestone-Marl Rhythms ? 6 . 1 . General Remarks After having described the differen·t direct mechanisms controlling limestone-marl rhythms (chapter 4) , now an attempt is made to define these cycles in terms of a more or less global phenomenon. Such an approach appears to be justified, because these rhythms occur since Paleozoic time in many regions of the world. For a discussion of the
42
ultimate cause of theSe and other cycles with a corresponding of time period see e . g . HAYS et a l . ( 1 9 7 6 ) , IMBRIE and IMBRIE F ISCHER ( 1 9 8 1), and SCHWARZACHER & FISCHER .(this vol . ) These papers deal- with the astronomically controlled orbital cycles of precession, •
obliquity, and eccentriticy of the earth , based on the theory of Milankovitch . Obviously , these orbital cycles induce climatic with periods around 2 1 , 000 years , 4 1 ,000 years, and 1 00 , 000 years . Apparently there are many deviations from the orbital cycles, partly due to a time lag between the response of the carbonate system of the oceans to the change in insolation evident in the Quaternary marine dissolution cycles ( see e . g . LUZ and SHACKLETON , 1 9 7 5 ) or, still due to inaccurate timing of ancient sedimentary the relati-vely good agreement of Quaternary and well as the consistent sedimentation rates of carbonate as strong evidence that c limatic control also must have in older sedimentary basins . In their general conclusions et a l �
qp
the origin of cyclic sediments, DUFF
( 1 9 6 7.) have discussed changes of climate and eustatic sea level
separately and indicated that minor eustatic oscillations may provide a satisfying explanation for limestone and shale cycles in the transi tional marine-continental environment. Using our increased knowledge of the Pleistocene, we should consider the combined effect of both factors , because they are changing simultaneously and may supplement each other . Par example in a basin near the continent a globally-con trolled shift from a warm and humid climate to a colder and partly semi-arid c limate can have the following consequences : ( 1 ) Reduction of carbonate productivity , ( 2 ) Increase of terrigeneous input due to loss of vegetation cover and regressive sea . In this case , both factors work into the· same direction and intensify the dilution of carbonate . In. contrast, rising sea level combined with an extension of vegetation cover tends to reduce the input of "clay" . In non-glacial times of the earth history, relatively short-period eustatic sea level fluctuations were, if they existed, owing to the growing and waning of mountain glaciers, only smal l . They therefore chiefly affected very shallow water or peritidal . sediments (FISCHER, 1 9 6 4 ; BECHSTADT, 1 9 7 3 ) . Consequently it can be expected that marine l imestone-marl rhythms , which are restricted to environments below storm-wave base, are predominantly control led by c l imatic variations { see e . g . BRUCKNER, 1 9 53 ; WEILER, 1 9 5 7 ; ZIEGLER, 1 9 5 8 i DEAN et a l .
43
1 9 7 7 ; de BOER, 1 9 80) . These variations may exert influence on different processes such as ( 1 ) Water circulation controlling production and dissolution of carbonate as well as redox conditions at the sea floor . ( 2 ) Vegetation cover on land controlling input of terrigeneous material and the ratio of suspension load to dissolved river load entering the sea ( see e . g . GARRELS et a l . , 1 9 7 5 ) , ( 3 ) Variations in the exogenic carbon cycle chiefly controlling ihput and production of carbonate within relatively shallow wate r . I n ge'nera l , these processes are interlocked and sometimes their com bined effect accelerates a certain trend (also see BERGER, this vol . ) , but in the following especially the influence of the carbon cycle i s stressed. 6 . 2 . Plant Life as Main Factor Contro lling the Exogenic Carbon Cycle From a _number of recent publications on the global carbon cycle ( e . g . SIEGENTHALER and OESCHGER, 1 9 7 8 ; BOLIN et. al . , 1 9 7 9 ; BROECKER e t al . , 1 9 7 9 ; DEGENS and KEMP E , 1 9 7 9 ; WOODWELL , 1 9 7 9 ) the principal evidence relevant to our problem may be listed as follows : � 1 ) For cyclic variations with a time period of 2 0 , 000 to 1 00 , 000 years , only the exogenic carbon cycle (comprising the atmospheric car bon cycle and the carbonate cycle of the hydrosphere) are of interes t . The endogenic carbon cycle, which i s controlled by subsidence and up_ lift of the earth'1 s crust, approximately maintains steady-state con ditions for the exogenic cycle ( GOLUBI C et a l . , 1 9 79 ) , and induces , if any , only long-termed variations in the amount of carbon in the exogenic cyc l e . ( 2 ) The carbon content i n the present biosphere is nearly equal to that in the atmosphere, and about 9 8 % of the living biomass is concen trated in the plant cover on land. As far as dissolved and particulate organic matter is concerned, about one half is found on land ( soil hu mus ) , the other half in the ocean s . ( 3 ) The res idence times of carbon in the atmosphere and biosphere are very short in comparison to that in the hydrosphere . According to HOLLAND ( 1 9 7 8 ) , 1 0% of the atmospheric co 2 is drawn yearly into the organic carbon cycle and again mineralized, mostly by microbial pro cesses {Fig. 1 3 ) . Within the carbonate cycle of the hydrosphere, however, much less carbon is exchanged by precipitation and dis solution of
caco
3
.
44
Fig. 1 3 . Simplified s cheme of the carbon reservoirs o f the exogenic carbon cycles , their storage { S ) , annual exchange rates ( E ) , annual river transport ( T ) and deposition in the sea ( D ) . All values in 1 Q 1 5 g units C02 , rounded (here only orders of magnitude are importan t ) . From different sources , e . g . MILLIMAN ( 1 9 74 ) , BOLIN ( 1 9 7 7 ) , BOLIN et a l . ( 1 9 7 9 ) , BROECKER e t a l . ( 1 9 7 9 ) , GOLUBIC et al . ( 1 9 79 ) , WOODWELL ( 1 9 79 ) . CCD, carbonate compensation dep·th
ATMOSPHERE s � 700
A
ATM. C02 f-)?
ATM. COt { + ) ?
TERR {+)
Fig . 1 4 . Gain ( G ) or loss (L) in storage of carbon in the plant bio mass and soil humus (maximum value 1 x 1 o 1 5 g per year, after BOLIN et al . , 1 9 7 9 ) as well as increase ( + ) or decrease ( - ) of the C02 -con tent of the atmosphere ( ? ) and surface water s , the river input of dis solved bicarbonate ·and suspension load . A , during periods of increasing, and B , decreasing vegetation cover on land. Stage A is promoting production and preservation of marine car bonate ( lowering of the CCD) , whereas stage B may lead to reduction dilution of carbonate production and even to more dissolution ( rise CCD)
Therefore, the rates of incorporation and exchange within the organic carbon cycle are about 200 times higher than those of the carbonate cycle . From these points, even if the quantitative data are still uncertain, one can conclude that plant life on land is the most important factor
45
controlling the carbon cycle . Therefore, plant life also affects the hydrospheric carbonate cycle, because this cycle is interlocked with the atmosphere . 6 . 3 . Climatic Variations . and Their I nfluence on the Carbonate Cycle of the Hydrosphere From the Plei$tocene we know that, on a global scale , the vegetation . . cover dqring the glacial stages was considerably reduced in comparison
"to the interglac ial s . The released co 2 was taken up by the buffer system of the oceans and later turned back via the atmosphere to the biospher e , wheh vegetation and soils started again to advance over barren land surfaces (Fig , 1 4A) . Between .the land surface , the atmosphere , and also the uppermost zone of the oceanic water mas s e s , this exchange of co 2 was accompli�hed without great time delay. However, the exchange of co 2 bet·ween surface waters and the deep ocean took much longer time
(on the order of several thousands of years, see e . g . GARRELS et a l . , 1 9 7 5 ; LUZ and SHAKLETON , 1 9 7 5 ) .
As a result, the surface waters tended to become richer or poorer in
co 2 for some time , before the deep ocean water masses had buffered the
surplus or deficit of co 2 in the atmosphere and in surface waters . Whether these processes really led to a substantial variation in the co � content of the surface waters i s , however , not yet clear ..
Another mechanism, which is also associated with the growing and waning plant cover of the globe or of individual drainage basins, may be more important in oui context . A wide-spread vegetation cover promotes chemi cal weathering and thus increases the river input of dissolved carbonate into the oceans ( see e . g . AHNERT, 1 9 7 0 ; GARRELS and !1ACKENZ IE , 1 9 7 5 ; HOLLAND, 1 9 7 8 i B6GLI , 1 9 7 8 ) . As e . g . SHACKLETON ( 1 9 7 7 ) has mentioned , a higher input o f terrestrial Ca-bicarbonate into shallow seas enables an increase in the production and preservation of carbonate .. SCLATER et a l . ( 1 9 7 9 ) have calculated that an increase of the river input of 1 0% can generate a depression of the CCD of 3 50 m. 6 . 4 . · consequences for Ancient Limestone-Marl Rhythms Let us turn again to non-glaciated times of the earth history and accept that, owing to the orbital cycles, cl imatic variations resulting in an alternating increase and decrease of the global vegetation cover were possible · The half-periods with reduced vegetation cover may have • .
been either cooler or warmer (more arid) than the other halves of the cycles .
46
I f we further as sume that during certain times ocean circulation was much less developed than at present time (see e . g . ARTHUR and NATLAND 1 9 7 9 ; BERGER , 1 9 7 9 ) and thus the exChange of co 2 between surface and
deep waters was reduced , we have a relatively simple mechanism to ex
plain l imestone-marl rhythms (Fig. 1 4 ) . tation cover , both phenomena, decrease waters and higher input of terrestrial duction and preservation of carbonate .
During periods of growing of dissolved co 2 in surface bicarbonate , promote the pro Thus , layers rich in carbonate
can be forme d . In contras t , periods with globally reduced vegetaion cover resulting from wide-spread semi-arid and arid or colder cl imate create a tendency into the opposite direction (Fig. 1 4B ) . Carbon re leased by the reduction of plant biomass and degradation of soils is concentrated as co2 in the atmosphere and in surface waters. Input of dissolved bicarbonate by rivers into shallow seas is diminished, as the transport of detrital material into the oceans, at least nally, is increased. Thus , less production and more dissolution bonate is feasible, and in addition , also more sediments by terrigenous material may take place. In such a way , rhythmic changes in carbonate content and texture of sediments may be generated which are accentuated later by diagene s i s . Some detailed studies on the carbon i sotopes o f caco 3 i n alternating beds of l imestone and black shale mentioned in chapter 5 . 1 . possibly support this hypothesi s . The low (negative) Q 1 3c values of the lime stones may be caused by increased input of dissolved inorganic carbon from the neighboring continent ( 6 1 3 c - 6 . 5 ) , whereas " normal" l imestones have values not f a r f rom 1 . 5 { see e . g . SCHOLLE and ARTHUR, =
1 980) . WEISSERT et a l . ( 1 9 7 9 ) and de BOER ( 1 9 80 ) , however, have a different explanation for this phenomenon . 6 . 5 . Redox Cycles Of course, a globally controlled mechanism may be superimposed by other phenomena of regional or local nature . Of particular interest for rhythmic bedding are variations in redox conditions at the sea floor or above the sedim�nt-water interfac e . Moderate reducing condi tions with oxygen still present in small quantities at the sea floor promote the decomposition of organic matter and thus ·the dissolution of carbonate (WEFER, 1 9 7 6 ; BERGE R , 1 9 7 9 ) . As a result, the correspon ding beds (marls ) are somewhat depleted in Caco 3 and less or ly bioturbated. than the alternating l imestone beds . Some couplets of the Jurassic in southern Germany show a tendency into this direction {Fig. 1 2 ) , but most of them are intensively bioturbated.
47
In euxinic basins, carbonate produced in oxygeneted surface waters is better preserved at the sea floor, because under anaerobic conditions the decomposition of organic matter and, therefore , the redissolution of carbonate is hampered (BERGER, 1 9 7 9 ; GOLUBIC and SCHNEIDER, 1 9 7 9 ) . Hence, periods of oxygen deficiency may generate layers richer in car bonate than periods of better oxygenated bottom wate r s . In this case, however , the members rich in c-arbonate should be devoid of burrows produced by some infauna . For fUrther information on alternating bed sequences in black shales see WETZEL ( this vol . ) . This last model certainly does not describe the· typical limestone--marl successions , but probably it can be also explained by climatic variations which periodically induce an overturn and aeration of deep water masses ( DEAN et al . , 1 9 7 7 ) ; WEISSERT et al . , 1 9 7 9 ; de BOER, 1 98 0 and this vol . ) . 7 . Final Remarks , work in the Future This paper certainly has riot covered all the information already avai lable on l imestone-marl succession s , and a number of geol? gical , bio logica l , oceanographic , physical , and chemical processes which may also play a part in the genesis of these cycles have not been discussed. As some other workers have pointed out earlier, this problem is indeed ve �y complex . Therefore, it appears to be necessary that future studies in this field are conducted in a more interdisciplinary way than up to now. Some of the queStions not answered satisfactorily are : ( 1 ) Persistence of the l imestone-marl-type cycles or periods through the total Phanerozoic time? ( 2 ) Recognition of this cyclicity in sediments other than those rich in carbonate ,
( 3 ) Importance of and differences in diagenetic overprint , ( 4 ) Length and consistency of the time period of the rhythms , { 5 ) Special features of l imestone-marl sUccessions indicating diffe rent depositional environments , ( 6 ) Better evidence for a globally-controlled mechanism (by a combi nation of different methods including isotope studies) , ( 7 ) Use of rhythmic sediments (periodites) for a ref inement of the biostratigraphic and absolute geological time scale { e . g .._ ERNST et al . , 1 9 7 9 ) and continent-to-continent correlation s .
48 Acknowledgements W . Rieken, w . Schwarzacher , and A . Seilacher critically read the cript and made helpful suggestion s . Referen.ces ABU-MAARUF , M. ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Feingliederung und Korrelation der Mergel kalk-Fazies des Unter-Campan von Misburg, HOver und Woltorf im ostniedersachsischen Becken . - Ber . Naturhist. Ges . 112 : 1 27-204 , --Hannove r . BE, A . W . H . 1 DAMUTH , J .E. 1 LOTT, L . , FREE, R . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Late Quaterna ry climatic record in western equatorial Atlantic sediment. I n : CLINE, R .M . , HAYS , J . D . ( eds . ) , Investigation of Late Quaternary paleoceanography and paleoclimatology . Geol . Soc . Amer . , Memoir H� : 1 6 s-2oo. . BEAUDOI N , B . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Methodes d ' analyse sedimentaire et reconstruc tion du bassin : le Jurassique terminal-Berriasien des chaines subalpines meridional es . - These , Univ. Caen, Sciences de la terre et de � ' amenagement regional , 3 3 9 + 1 3 6 p . BEAUDOIN, B . , BIE, J . , CONARD, M . , GUY, B . , LE DEUFF, D . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Essai d ' analyse des rythmes dans des formations marne-calcaires alternantes . � Bul l . Soc. geol . France ( 7 ) , Q¥J : 6 3 4 - 6 4 2 . BECHSTADT , T . ( 1 9 7 3 ) : Zyklotheme im h angenden Wettersteinkalk von Bleiberg-Kreuth (Karnten, �sterreich ) . Festschrift HEISSEL, Ver O f f . Univ. Innsbruck, Bd . �g : 25 -5 5 . BERGER, W . H . ( 1 9 79 a ) : Preservation o f foraminifera. I n : SEPM Short course No . 6 , Houston 1 9 7 9 (Foraminiferal Ecology and Paleocolo gy) , Soc. Econ . Paleontol . Mineralog . : 1 05 -1 5 5 . BERGER 1 W . H . ( 1 9 79 b ) : Impact of Deep-Sea Drilling on paleoceanogra phy. I n : TALWANI , M . , HAY , W . & RYAN , W . B . F . (Maurie Ewing Se ries 3 , Deep drilling results in the Atlantic Ocean: Continental , Am . Geophys . Union, margins and paleoenvironment , p . washington . BERGER 1 W . H . & HEATH , R . G . ( 1 9 6 8 ) : Vertical mixing in pelagic sedi ments . - J . Marine -Res . 1 �g: 1 3 4 - 1 4 3 . BERGER, W . H . , JOHNSON , R . F . & KILLINGLEY , J . S . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : "Unmixing 11 of the deep-sea record and the deglacial meltwater spike_.- Na ture , �g�, No . 5 6 3 0 : 6 6 1 -6 6 3 . BERGER , W . H . & MAYER , .C . A . ( 1 9 7 8) : Deep-sea carbonates : Acoustic reflectors and lysocline fluctuations . - Geology g : 1 1 - 1 5 . BERNER, R . A . ( 1 97 1 ) : Principles of Chemical Sedimentology . - McGraw Hill , New York, 240 p . BOER1 P . L . d e ( 1 9 80) : The paleo-environment of mid-Cretaceous black shale deposition as deduced from stable carbon isotopes . Compa rative Sedimentology Research Group, Institute of Earth Scien ces·, Utrecht, s e p . 4 2 , 1 9 p . , 8 Figs . ·
BOLIN, B . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Modeling the oceans and ocean sediments and their response to fossil fuel carbon dioxide emissions . I n : ANDERSEN, N . R . , MALAKOFF , A . ( eds . ) The fate of fossil fuel co 2 in the oceans . - P lenum Press, New York London , p . 8 1 - 9 5 . BOLIN, B . , DEGEN S 1 E . T . , KEMPE , S . , KETNER , P . (eds . ) ( 1 9 79 ) : The global carbon cycle . - SCOPE 1 3 , Wiley, Chichester - New York Brisbane - Toronto , 4 9 1 s .
49
BROECKER,. W . S . , TAKAHASHI , F . , SIMPSON, H . J . , PENG, T . -H . ( 1 9 79 ) : Fate of fossil fuel carbon dioxide and the global carbon budget . Science V . &Qg, No . 4 4 1 7 : 409-4·1-8 . BRUCKNER, W . D . ( 1 9 5 3 ) : Cyclic calcareous sedimentation as an index of climatic variations in the past . - J . Sediment. Petrol. �� : 2 3 5 -2 3 7 . CAMPOS , H . S . and HALLAM , A . ( 1 9 79 ) : Diagenesis o f English Lower Ju rassic limestones as inferred from oxygen and carbon isotope analys is . - Earth and Planetary Sc i . Lett. j; � : 2 3 -3 1 . CLINE, R . M . & HAYS , J . D . (eds . ) ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Investigation of Late Qua ternary Paleoceanography and Paleoclimatology . - Geol . -Soc. Am . , Memoir J,�� , 4,6 4 p . DEAN, W. E . , GARDNER� J .V. , JANSA, L . F . , CEPEK, P . & SEIBOLD, E . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Cyclic sedimentation along the continental margin of northwest Africa. I n : LANCELOT , Y . , SEIBOLD, E . et a l . , Ini tial Reports of Deep Sea Drilling Project, �1 : 9 6 5 - 9 9 0 , Washing-ton (U . S . Government Printing Office} . DEAN , W . E . , GARDNER, J . V . & CEPEK, P . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Tertiary carbonate dissolution cycles on the Sierra Leone Rise , eastern equatorial Atlantic Ocean . - Marine Geology v. �� ' 1 / 2 : 8 1 - 1 0 1 . DEGENS , E . T . , KEMPE , s . ( 1 9 79 ) : Heizen wir unsere Erde auf?- Bild der Wissenschaft , 1.6 Jg . , H. 8 : 52-58 . DEGENS , E . T . & STOFFERS , P , ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Stratified waters as a key to the pas t . - Nature �g�: 22-27 . DOMINIK, J . & STOFFERS , P . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : The influence of Late Quaternary stagnations on clay sedimentat·ion in the Eastern Mediterranean Sea . - Geol . Rundschau , g� : 302-3 1 7 , Stuttgart . DUFF , P . MeL. D . , HALLAM , A . , WALTON, E . K . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Cyclic s edimen t tation . - Developm . Sedimentology J,Q , Elsevier, Amsterdam, 280 p . EINSELE , G . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Range , velocity, and material flux o f compaction f low in growing sedimentary sequences . - S edimentology §� : 6 3 9 -6 5 5 . EINSELE, G . KELTS , K . { 1 9 8 1 ) : Significance , s edimentological and mass physical- properties , and early diagenesis of Pliocene/Qua ternary mud turbidites in the Gulf Of California. I n : CURRAY 1 J . R . , MOORE , D . G . et al . , Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Pro j ec t , v. 2� , Washington (U . S . Government Printing Office ) , in pres s . EINSELE, G . 1 MOSEBACH , R . ( 1 9 5 5 ) : Zur Petrographi e , Fossilerhaltung und �ntstehung der Gesteine des Posidonienschiefers im Schwabi schen Jura . - Neues Jb . Geo l . Palaont . , Abh . , JQJ, 3 : 3 1 9 - 4 3 0 , Stuttgart . ERNST , G . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Calibration o f s tratigraphic methods in the boreal Cretaceous of Germany . - 25th Internat . Geol . Congr . Sydney , Ab stracts , v . l : 2 6 7 - 2 6 8 . ERNST , G . , SCHMIDT , F . & KLISCHIES , G . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Multistratigraphi sche Untersuchungen in der Oberkreide des Raumes Braunschweig Hannover . I n : WIEDMANN, J . ( ed . ) ,- Aspekte der Kreide Europas . Interna t . Union Geol . Sciences , Series A , No . g : 1 1 - 4 6 , Stuttgart . FISCHER, A . G . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : The Lofer cyclothems of the Alpine Triassi c . I n : Symposium on Cyclic s edimentation . -Kansas Geo l . Survey Bul l . J,g� : 1 07 - 1 49 .•
50
FISCHER, A . G . ( 1 9 8 1 )' : The 2 1 . 000 year shale-limestone rhythm . - J . Geol . Soc . London (in press ) . FLtiGEL, H . , PENNINGER , A . ( 1 9 6 6 ) : Die Lithogenese der Oberalmer Schichten und der mikritischen Plassen-Kalke ( T'ithonium, NOrdli che Kalkalpen) . - N . Jb . Geol . PaUiont. Abh . l&J : 249-280. FREEZE, A . R . , CHERRY , J . A . { 1 9 7 9 ) : Groundwater . - Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs N . J . , 604 p . FREYBERG, B . von ( 1 9 6 6 ) : Der Faziesverband irn Unteren Malm Franken s . Ergebnisse der Stromatometrie . Erlanger Geolog. Abh . , H . 6 2 : 1 - 9 2 . FtiCHTBAU.E R, H . , MULLER, G . ( 1 970) : Sedimente und Sedirrientgesteine . (Sediment-Petrolog i e , Teil I I ) . Schweizerbart, Stuttgart, 7 2 6 S . FtiCHTBAUER, H . 1 TISLAR1 J . ( 1 97 5 ) : Peritidal cycles in the lower Cre taceous of Istria (Jugoslavia) . - Sediment. Geology J� : 2 1 9 -2 3 3 . FURSICH, F . T . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Corallian (Upper Jurassic) marine benthic asso� Ciations from England and Normandy . - Palaeontology &Q: 3 3 7-3 8 5 . GARREL S , R . M . , MACKENZ I E , F . T . & HUNT, C . ( 1 97 5 ) : Chemical cycles and . the global environment . - Kaufman n , Los Altos , 206 p . GARRISON, R . E . , KENNEDY , W . J . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Origin of solution seams and flaser structure in Upper Cretaceous chalks of southern Eng land . - Sediment . Geology J� : 1 07 - 1 3 7 . GOLUBIC , S . 1 KRUMBEIN, W. 1 SCHNEIDER, J . ( 1 9 79 ) : The carbon cycle. I n : TRUDINGER, P . A . , SWAINE , D . J . (eds . ) Studies in Environmen tal Science 3 : Biogeochemical cycling of mineral-forming ele ments . - Elsevier , Amsterdam, .p. 29- 4 5 . GOLUBIC , S . , SCHNEIDER, J . ( 1 9 79 ) : Carbonate dissolution. I n : TRUDINGER, P . A . , SWAINE , D ' J . {eds . ) Biogeochemical cycling of mineral-forming elements . - Studies in Environmental Science 3 , Elsevier, Amsterdam, p . 1 07- 1 29 . GWINNER, M . P . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Origin of the Upper Jurassic limes tones of the Swabian Alb (Southwestern Germany ) . - Contrib . - Sedimentology � : 1 -7 5 . HALLAM , A . { 1 9 6 4 ) : Origin of the limestone-shale rhythms in the Blue Lias of England : A compOsite theory . - J . Geology, Z§ : 1 57-1 6 8 . HATTIN, D . E . ( 1 9 7 1 ) : Widespread , synchronously deposited1 burrow mottled limestone beds in Greenhorn Limestone {.Upp . Cret . ) of Kansas and Southeastern Colorado . - Amer . Assoc. Petrol . Geol · . Bull . ��: 4 1 2- 4 3 1 . HAYS , Y . D . , IMBRIE, · J . & SHACKLETON , N . J . ( 1 9 7 6. ) : Variations of the easth ' s orb i t : Pacemaker of the ice ages . -- Science J.��: 1 1 2 1 -1 1 3 2 . HOLLAND , H . D . ( 1 97 8 ) : Chemistry of the Atmosphere and the .ocea�s . Wiley, New York, 3 5 1 p . HUDSON , J . D . ( 1 97 5 ) : Carbon isotopes and limestone cement . - Geology : 1 9 -2 2 . HUDSON, J . D . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Stable isotopes and limestone lithification . Geol . Soc . London Quart. J . , v . l�� : 6 3 7 - 6 6 0 . HUDSON , J . D . ( 1 9 78 ) : Concretions , isotopes , and the diagenetic hi story of the Oxford Clay (Jurassic) of central England . - Sedi mentology &� : 3 39 - 3 7 0 . IMBRIE, J . & IMBRIE , K . P . ( 1 9 79 ) : Ice Ages , solving the mys,tery . MacMillan , Londo n , 2 2 4 p .
i l
51
IRWIN , H , CURTIS., C . & COLEMAN , M . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Isotopic evidence for source of diagenetic carbonates ·formed during burial of organic rich sediments . - Nature �g� , No . 5 6 2 5 : 209-2 1 3 . • .
INIGNET , P . & KENNEDY , W . J . ( 1 9 7 4 ) " : Structures sedimentaires et mode d ' accumulation de la craie du Turonien superieur et du senonien du Pays de Caux . - Bul l . Bur . Rech. Geol . Min . {deux. serie) , sec t . 4 , 1 : 1 9 -47 . KAUFFMAN , E . G . ( 1 9 77 ) : Cretaceous facies, faunas, and paleoenviron ments across the Western Interior Basin . - The Mountain Geologist 1 4 : 7 5 -2 7 4 . ==
KELLER , G . ( 1 9 80 ) : Middle to Late Miocene planktonic foraminiferal datum levels and paleoceanography of the North and Southeastern Pacific Ocean . - Marine Mikropaleontology � : 249-28 1 . KENT�. P . E . ( .. 1 9 3 6 ) : The formation of the hydraulic limestones of the Lower Lias . - Geo l . Mag. z� : 4 7 6 -4 7 8 . KIDD, R . B . , CITA, M . B . , RYAN , W . B . F . ( 1 97 8 ) : Stratigraphy of Eastern Mediterranean sapropel sequences recoVered during DSDP Leg 42A and their pa leoenvironmental significance . In: HSU , · K . , MONTA DERT , L . et al . � Init . Reports Deep Sea Drilling Project, 4 2 , I , Washington ( U . S . Government Print. Off . ) . LOMBARD 1 A . ( 1 9 7 2 ) : Series sedimentaires . Genese - evolution . Masson, Paris , 4 2 5 p . LUZ , B . & SHACKLETON , N . J . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : CaCO � solution in the tropical East Pacific during the past 1 30 . 000 years . -Cushman Found. Fora miniferal Res . Spec . Pub l . , J4 : 1 42 - 1 50. MATTER, A . , DOUGLAS , R . G . & PERCH-NIELSEN , K. ( 1 97-5 ) : Fossil preser vation , geochemistry, and diagenesis of pelagic carbonates from Shatsky Rise, Northwest Pac i f i c . I n: LARSON , R . L . , MOBERLY , R . ' et a l . Initial Reports o f Deep Sea Drilling Project, v . J£: 89 1 -9 2 1 , Washington ( U . S . Governm. Print. Off . ) . MILLIMAN , J . D . , ROS S , D . A . & KU , T . H . { 1 9 69 ) : Precipitation and lithification of deep-sea carbonates in the Red Sea . - J . Sediment. Petrol. : 7 2 4 -7 3 6 . MILLIMAN , J . D . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Marine carbonates . - Springer : Berlin, 3 7 5 p . NOBLE , J . P . A . , HOWELLS , K . D .M . ( 1 97 4 ) : Early marine stratification of the nodular limestones in the Silurian of New Br.unswick . Sedimentology �l ' 5 9 7 - 609 . OVERBECK, R. ( 1 9 80 ) : Verwitterung von Mergelkalken durch Trocknungs Befeuchtungs-Wech se l . - Unpublish�d Rep . , Geolog. Ins t . Tlibingen, 8 p, 7 Figs . -
PARK , w . C . & SCHOT , E . H . ( 1 9 6 8 ) : Stylolites : their nature and origin. - J. Sediment. Petrology, v. 4� : 1 7 5- 1 9 1 . ' PISIAS , N . G . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Late Quaternary sediment of the Panama Basin: Sedimentation rates , periodicities, and controls of carbonate and opal accumulation . - Geo l . Soc . America, Memoir J,�� : 3 7 5- 39 1 . PRELL, W . L . , HAYS , J . D . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Late ,,Pleistocene faunal and tempe rature patterns of the Colombia Basin, Caribean Sea. I n : CLINE, R . M . , HAYS , J . D . (eds . ) Investigation of Late Quaternary Paleoce anography and Paleoclimatology . - Geo l . Soc . Amer . , Memoir l�� : 201 -220 .
52 u . v . , EINSELE, G . ( 1 980) : Mesozoic-Cainozoic subsidence hi story and palaeobathymetry of the northwest African continen tal margin (Aaiun Basin to D . S . D . P . Site 3 9 7 ) . - Pei l . Trans . R . Soc . London A �2� : 37-50. RAISWELL, R. ( 1 9 7 1 ) : The growth of Cambrian and Liassic concretions . Sedimentology 11: 1 4 7 - 1 7 1 .
RAD ,
RAMSAY , A . T . S . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : The distribution of calcium carbonate in deep sea sediments . - Soc. Econ. Paleont . Miner. Spec. Pub l . �Q: 5 3 -7 6 . RUDDIMAN, W . F . , MciNTYRE, A . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Northeast Atlant.ic paleoclimate changes over the past 600. 000 years . I n : CLINE, R . M . , HAYS , J . D . (eds . ) Investigati.on of Late Quaternary paleoceanography and pa leoclimatology . - Geol . Soc . Amer . , Memoir 2�� : 1 1 1 - 1 4 6 . RUPKE , N . A . & STANLEY , D . J . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Distinctive properties o f tur biditic and hemipelagic mud layers in the Algero-Balearic Basin, western Mediterranean Sea . - Smithsonian Contrib . Earth Sciences, No. l� , 40 p . , Washington . SARNTHEIN, M. ( 1 9 7 2 ) : Stratigraphic contamination by vertical biotur bation in Holocene shelf sediments . - 24th Internat. Geol . Con gres s , Montreal , Section 6 : 4 3 2 -4 3 6 . SARNTHEI N, M . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Sand deserts during glacial maximum and clima tic optimum . - Nature �Zl ( 56 4 8 ) : 43-4 6 . SCHNEIDER , F . K . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Erscheinungsbild und Entst.ehung der rhythmi schen Bankung der altkretazischen Tongesteine Nordwestfalens und der Braunschweiger Buch t . Ein Beitrag zur Absolutchronologie von Hauterive bis Alb . - Fortschr. Geol. Rheinl . West£. ] : 3 5 3 - 3 8 2 , Krefeld. SCHLANGER, S . O . , DOUGLAS , R . G . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : The pelagic ooze-chalk lime stone transition and its implications for marine stratigraphy . Spec. Pub l . Internat. Ass . Sediment v . J : 1 1 7 - 1 4 8 . SCHOLLE , P . A . & ARTHUR, M . A . ( 1 980) : Carbon isotope fluctuations in Cretaceous Pelagic limestones : potential stratigraphic and petro leum exploration too l . -Am. Assoc. Petrol-Geol . Bul l . v . Q� , 1 : 6 7-8 7 .
SCHWARZACHER, w . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Sedimentation models and quantitative g�aphy. Developm. Sedimentology ,1,2, ·1 Elsevier, Amsterdam, 3 8 2 p .
SCLATER, J . G . , HELLINGER, S. & TAPSCOTT , C. ( 1 9 7 7 ) : T he paleobathy metry of the Atlantic Ocean from the Jurassic to the present . J . Geol . �� : 509 -5 5 2 . SEIBERT Z , E . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Stratigraphisch-fazielle Entwicklung des Turon im stid6stlichen Mtinsterland (Oberkreide, NW-Deutschland ) . - Newsl . Stratigr . , � : 3-60, Berlin - Stuttgart . SEIBOLD , E . ( 1 9 5 2 ) : Chemische Untersuchungen zur Bankung im unteren Malm Schwabens . - N. Jb . Geol . , Abh . 2� : 3 3 7 - 3 70 , S tuttgar t . SEIBOLD , E & I . ( 1 9 5 3 ) : Foraminiferenfauna eines Profils i m gebank ten unteren Malm Schwabens . - . N . Jb . Geol. u. Palaontol . 1 Abh. ��� 1 : 28-8 6 , Stuttgar t . SEIBOLD , E . ( 1 9 6 2 ) : Kalk-Konkretionen und karbonatis·ch gebundenes Magnesium . - Geochimica et Cosmochimica Act a , v. �g: 8 9 9-909 . ..
53
SHACKLETON , N . J . , ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Carbon 1 3 . ,in Uvigerina : tropical rain forest history and the equatorial Pacific carbonate dissolu tion cycles. I n : ANDERSEN, N . R . & MALAKOFF , A. (eds . ) The fate of fossil fuel co2 in the ocean . - New York, Plenum Pres s : 4 0 1 - 4 2 7 . SHACKLETON, N . J . , OPDYKE , N . D . ( 1 9 7 3 ) : Oxygen isotope and paleomagne tic stratigraphy of equatorial Pacific core V 28-23 8 . - Quater nary Research , v. � : '3 9 - 5 5 . SHACKLETON , N . J . , OPDYKE , N . D . { 1 9 7 6 ) : Oxygen-isotope and magnetic stratigraphy of Pacific core V 28-239 late P liocene to latest Pleistocene. I n : CLINE , R . M . , HAYS , J . D . ( eds . ) Investigation of Late Quaternary paleoceanography and paleoclimatology . Geol. Soc . Am. Mem . l��: 4 4 9 -4 6 4 . S IEGENTHALER, U . , OESCHGER, H . ( 1 9 78 ) : Predicting future atmospheric carbon dioxide levels . - Science l��: 3 8 8 - 39 5 . STOWE 1 K . S . ( 1 9 79 ) : OceanScienc e . - Wiley, New York, 6 1 0 p . SUJKOWSKI , Z . L . ( 1 9 58 ) : Diagenesis . - Bul l . Am. Assoc . · Petro l . Geo logists, �� ' 2 6 9 2-2 7 1 7 . VAIL , P . R . , MITCHUM, R . M . j r ( 1 97 9 ) : Global cycles of relative chan ges of sea level from seismic stratigraph y . I n : WATKINS , J . S . , MONTADERT , L. , DICKERSON , P .W . (eds . ) Geological and geophysi cal investigations of continental margins . - Am. Assoc . Petrol. Geolog . , Memoir �2: 4 6 9 - 4 7 2 . VEIZER, J . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Geochemistry o f lithographic limestones and dark marls from the Jurassic of Southern Germany . - N . Jb . Geol . Palaont. Abh . : 1 29 - 1 4 6 , Stuttgart. VOLAT , J . L . , PASTOURET, L. & VERGNAUD-GRAZZINI , C . ( 1 9 80) : Disso lution and carbonate fluctuations in Pleistocene deep-sea cores : a review . - Marine Geology �� : 1 - 2 8 . WATTS , A . B . , STECKLER, M . S . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Subsicence and lustasy at the continental margin of eastern North America . I n : TALWANI , M . , HAY , w. , RYAN , W . B . F . (eds . ) Deep Drilling results in the At lantic Ocean: continental margins and paleoenvironment . - Mauri ce Ewing Series d : 2 1 8-2 3 4 . Am. Geophys . Union, Washington D . C . . . WEILER, H . ( 1 9 5 7 ) : Untersuchungen zur Frage der Kalk-Mergel-Sedimen tation im Jura Schwabens . - Dis s . Univ. Tlibingen, 58 s . ·
WEISSERT , H . , McKENZIE, J . & HOCHULI , P . ( 1 97 9 ) : Cyclic anoxic events in the early Cretaceous Tethys Ocean . - Geology z : 1 4 7 � 1 5 1 . WETZEL, A . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Okologische und stratigraphische Bedeutung bioge ner Geftige in quart�ren Sedimenten am NW-afrikanischen Konti�en talrand . - 11Meteor11 Forsch . -Ergebnis s e , Reihe c, d .1. : 1 - 4 7 , Berlin Stuttgar t . WOODWELL , G . M . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Das Kohlendioxid-Prob lem . - Spektrurn der Wis senschaft, Erst-Edition, Weinheim. Z IEGLER , B . ( 1 9 5 8 ) : Feinstratigraphische Untersuchungen im Oberjura Stidwestdeutschlands - ihre Bedeutung fUr Palaontologie und Pa laogeographie . - Eclogae Geol . Helv . , ��: 2 6 5-2 7 8 . ZIEGLER, B . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : The 11White" (Upper) Jurassic i n Southern Germany . Stuttgarter Beitrage Naturk . , Ser . B , Nr. �g : 1 - 7 9 .
Observations on Well-bedded Upper Jurassic Limestones W. M. BAUSCH, J. FATSCHEL, and D. HOFMANN
Abstract. Some studies of selected l imestone beds in the Oxfor dian of the northern and southern Franconian Alb again confirm the SEIBOLD-medel : A continuous de·p osition o f detrital clay is super imposed by a periodical changing calcium carbonate production . On this base1 fused (i . e . , doubled} l imestone beds are recognizeable . Fusion or splitting of beds depends on the clay . mineral associa tion: where kaolinite .is present , fusion occurs , and vice vers a . Ih the northern region investigated , thickness of sequences and carbonate(non-carbonate ratiO are positively correlated , in the southern area this correlation Ls negative . The lateral transition from a limestone/marl sequence into pure bedded limestones is a function of the thicknes s of individual limestone beds and their content of insoluble residue s . 1 . Introduction The Oxfordian of the swabian and Franconian Alb is developed as a regular intercalation of limestones' and marls (disregarding bio herms ) . In such a sequence , SEIBOLD ( 1 9 5 2 ) postulated that a con tinuous supply of "clay" was superimposed by a periodical precipi tation of carbonate . According to his mode l , each bed of limestone and each bed of marl represent approximate equal t�e spans . I f there i s appreciable precipitation o f carbonate , llmestone will be formed ; if ·not, the result is only mar l . I n the Swa.bian , and especially i n the Franconian Alb these sequen ces can be traced laterally over remarkably wide distances . V . FREY BERG and his co-workers established a most detailed system , accord ing to which sequences ·of beds and single beds may be identified over more than 100 km distance. Such a persistence of sedimentation rhythms is a strong argument for the concept of exact isochrony of these sequences . On the base of this " stromatometry" of v . FREYBERG (1 966 ) a group of 7 limestone and 9 marl beds from Malm B (planula�zone ) were
selected and studied in detail for S.edimentary parameters in 9 out crops in the northern and 6 quarries in the southern Franconian
Alb (Fig. 1 ) . Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
55
Fig. 1 . Map of ?ampling locations within the Franconian Alb (dashed)
Isolation of non-carbonatic residues was done by monochloric acetic acid , followed by separation into fractions
>
and
<
2'p by the
ATTERBERG-method . Finally the mineralogical composition was deter mined quantitativel y (with simplifications} by X-ray diffraction .
2 . Fusion and Splitting o f Limestone Beds In the northern Franconian Alb we observed fusion as well as splitting of limestone beds by the disappearance of bedding planes
or by additional joints , respectively (Fig . 2 ) , such occurring in
a distance of about 40 km. These phenomena are not two independent effects 1 but o�ly the two sides of one coin. This is so because of the arbitrary counting scheme of the bed s .
56
According to Fig. 2 , fus£on and splitting of beds clearly is not
dependent on bed thicknes s . Fusion occurs e .. g. in beds No . 108[109 , in relatively thick profiles ( 6 , 7 ) as well as in thin ones (9 , 3 ) .
Splitting takes place e . g . in bed No . 110 , without any visible relation to thickness variations , occurring in a group of profiles of medium thicknes s . In fact , the fusion-splitting phenomenon is dependent on the quality of clay minerals in the insoluble residue s . Sections with maximum fusions ( 3 ) have the highest contents o f kao linite (Fig. 3 ) , whereas profiles with: separation of all beds (and additional splitting) exhibi,.t very little or no kaolin'ite . The six outcrops of the southern Franconian Alb show analogous relationships . The lnterpretation of the relationship of fusion/splitting with kaolinite contents may be possible according to WHITEHOUSE 1 JEFF REY & DERBRECHT (1960 ) . They described differing settling velo
cities of clay minerals 1 with kaolinite settling quicke s t , such being possible even the
when
water turbulence is high. In this case
tendency for formation of j o ints is relatively low� In con
trastr lack of kaolinite indicates relatively quiet sedimentation, leadlng to a maximum of horizontal joints� 3 . Lateral Variation of Non-Carbonates Grain s i z e fractionation of non-.carbonates into
>
and < 2
p
frac
tions separates the bulk of quartz and feldspars from the bulk of clay minerals , though not completely · so , with feldspars occurring only in the coarse , smectite in the fine fraction . In the coarse fraction feldspar and quartz + kaoliriite vary in versely. ·In the northern FrancOnian Alb, kaolinite is coming from NW1 in the southern area from W. Relative maxima of feldspar are found in the SE and E region s .
In the fine fraction , kaolinite varies inversely with illite
+
smectite� The regional d istribution of kaolinite corresponds to that of the coarse fraction� One sampling location (No. 1 ) , mostly protected by �urrounding quiet water bioherms, exhibits the relatively highest amounts of smectite. This may be explained by the low settling velocity of this mineral (WHITEHOUSE et al . , 1 9 60 ) .
57
s "'"
.o N
2m
111
1n 1100
110a 110
110
1m
109a
1090
109
109
108
108 107 106a 10 5 5
'
7
Fig.
2.
107 106a 106
correlation of profiles of the northern sampling group. Distance from left ( N ) to right (S) : 40 km
proportional peak ratio
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Fraction < 2p
0 texturized
r---�----�---L--�r�a�ti�o-n���-tiu---�--�
100
Legend : M+J
6
a
:--o
:--o
K : --a M + JIQ : --o M + J/K : --o
7
9
bed nr, 1 1 0 , horizontal correlation
5
2 0
Fig. 3 . Contents of smectite + illite ( !1 + J) , quartz ( Q ) and kaolinite ( K ) . Given values are not percentages . Note the disappearance of kaolinite in sample locations 1 , 4 , 5, 2 , 8 . This diagram is only valid for bed No J 1 0 ; however , all other beds show very similar results
58
4 . Absolute Non-Carbonate Amounts and SEIBOLD-Medel Relative amounts of insolubles in the limestone beds range in the
�orthern Alb between 2 and 6 % , in the southern Alb between 1 and 3% For mar l s , it is of little use to refer to percent values, as their carbonate content may be altered secondarily in the surface out crops . Howev�r, for marls the absolute values of non-carbonates , given in "em thickness 11 , provide reliable values for comparisons . The amounts of non-carbonates ( in em) , are rather constant in limestones as also in marls , as is shown by Fig. 4 for the northern
Alb , by Fig. 5 for the southern Alb. This would substantiate the
SEIBOLD-medel ( vd . Introduction) . It is only the different amount of carbonate ( in em thickne s s ) which causes the difference between limestones and marls . It also determines the thickness of a lime stone (valid for the section studied ; in higher or lower parts of the Oxfordian sequence there also occur gradational changes in the absolute non-carbonate conten� ) . The SEIBOLD-medel , developed in· the Swabian Alb , is thus now confirmed in the northern and southern Franconian Alb. There are two reasons for assuming that the separation into lime stone beds and intercalated marls is a primary feature , and not caused by diagenetic effects : ( 1 ) the constancy of absolute non-carbonate amounts {in em) , ( 2 ) the identity of bedding rhythms over distances of more than 100 km. The observations of HEMLEBEN & RICKEN ( this Vol . ) indicate indeed diagenetic effects which may have been very remarkable but they cannot explain the facts given above . With the aid of the absolute amount of non-carbonates {in em). it is also possible to detect the fused character of a double bed, as
may be seen by comparison of Figs . 2 and 4 . 5 . Disappearance of Marls
Whereas in the northern area marls are intercalated .rather regular ly between the limestone s , this is not seen in the southern area marls , which are present in the west and di sappear towards east . This could perhaps be explained thus :
]
59 3
Sample locat\on
nr.
5, vertic at correlation
�
22 0 c 0 "'
81 I
c 0 z
-
106
- - - " ,.,.
105a total
_,. .-. �
-
107
7" - - - - - - - - -
108
109
--
-
II
'
'
'
109a
'
'
,
,
'
'
'
'
'
'
''
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
110
2!J
> 2{J
Fig. 4 . Absolute contents of non-car}:)onates in em . Note that values for l imestone beds ( normal numbers) show the same level as those for marls ( numbers with a-suffix ) . Bed No . 1 1 0 exhibi·ts twice the "normal " amount, and is in fact a double bed ( proven by splitting, compare Fig . 2 )
em
00 2 40
Location 1 5 •
'
n o n - carbonate
o carbonate
30 0
10 Bed- Nc
Fig. 5 . Absolute contents of non-carbonates in em, southern Franconian Alb . As in the northern part (Fig. 4 ) , amounts in limestones and marls are nearly identical
Let us suppos e the SEIBOLD-medel is valid regarding l imestone beds of about 10 em th.ickness wi.th. only 1 % insolubles .. Then correspond ing marls would contain only 1 rom non-carbonate thickness .. Also if some carbonate content is added , the marl would reach a thick ness of not more than around 3 rom. Obiously at this stage , the
marl degenerize to bedding j o ints . With the aid o f the SEIBOLD-medel , the change o f a limestone-marl succession into a mere limeston·e sequence can be described by the following limiting conditions : Marls disappea r , when thickness of limestones x percentage of 1 mm . insolubles =
The data for this rule are given only by the remaining limestones of the sequence . Actually , proceeding from W to E within the
60
southern Franconian Alb, the thickness of limestone beds decreases to 10 em, and the contents of non-carbonate grade to the range of 1%. 6 . Comparison Between Non-Carbonates of Limestones and Marls Qualitatively , there are no differences of lLmestones and �arls in the non-carbonates. As regarded quantitative aspects , the follow ing differences are recognizable : Marls contain relatively more quartz in the coarse fractLon than limestones, but less in the fine fraction . An explanation may be seen in the different diagenetic history: it is reasonable to assume that the percolation of pore fluids is higher in marls than in pure limestones , which usually are cemented rather early. There fore, qua�tz i s enabled to grow by preference in marls . Then it forms part of the coarse fraction and becomes rarer in the fine fraction . Careful check of this hypothesis by e l ectron scanning microscopy will be done .
7 . Relationship Between Thickness and Carbonate/Non-Carbonate Ratios Fig. 6 shows a pos·itive correlation between total thickness of the profiles studied and the carbonate/non-carbonate ratio for the northern Alb, and a negative correlation for the southern Alb. The limestones and mar l s st�di.ed can be regarde<:'l. as a two-component system, built up by carbonate and non-carbonate. Both components are able to vary independently; they may vary both together and with �ifferent intensity. Quite understandable are the two possib le extremes : variation of only one component , constancy of the other .. Variation of t h.e carbonate component only creat.es a posJ..tive correlation . I f thickness variations base on varying non-carbonate contents, then a negative correlatio� is resulting. Fig. 6 shows the contrary behaviour of northern and southern Alb; in these identical seq·..J.enoes both cases are realized . 8 . Relations Between Carbonate/Non-Carbonate and the Grain S i z e of the Residues
There exists a negative correlation between purity of limes.tones and thetr coarse/fi.ne residue fractions quotient . This is shown for
61 70
15 •
14 •
12 •
:8 60 e
•
13 •
0
§ 50
.0
8 I
40
c
,g
'-· • c
_g 30 Ci
20
14 130
•
11•
0 0
10
3 •
150
140
9 •
2
•
� 160
total
170
8 •
5
•
200
thickness (em)
ratio Fig. 6 . Negative correla tion between ca·rbonate/non-carbonate and total thicknes s for the southern Francon ian Alb ( squares ) , and slightly positive correla tion for the northern _Francon ian alb ( c ircles)
0
35
�
e
•
0
§ 30
.0
0 0 c
I
§c 25
@y � ®
�
'
2 0
·�
®
�
§ 20
.0 c 0 0
15
®
� ®
2,0
2,5
3,0
3.5
0
�
� @
4,0
"-® 4,5
2p
Fig . 7 . Negative correlation between carbonate/non-carbonate ratio and < /> 2 }A- ratio for one single bed (No . 1 1 1 , northern Franconian Alb)
62
one single bed by Fig� 7 ; there i s , however , a remarY�ble disper sity. Th.is implies that relative pure limestones exhibit coarser non-carbonates . This effect can also be shown fo� single beds (Fig. · a ) . We would also note that there seems to be a relation between the slope of the correlation lines wLth the thickness of the beds (one exception) . At this stage in the studies , we will not attempt to explain this effect. . � 35 2 �
0 c
� 30 8
I c 0 c
' �
25
0 c 0
-e 20 8
,5 51,4 38
15 2.0
2.5
3.0
3. 5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
<J, 2J.J
Fig . 8 . Correlation l.ines for the same relation as in Fig . ? , for single beds . Numbers : Average thickness of beds ( em) Acknowledgements
This study was supported by the German Research Foundation ( Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft) which is greatly acknowledged . References FATSCHEL , J . -11 . ( 19 79) : Variationen sedimentarer Parameter im t1alm der Feuerstein-Folge . Diplomarbeit , Universitat Erlangen .
B
FREYBERG, B . v . ( 1966) : Der Faziesverband im Unteren Malm Frankens . Ergebnisse der Stromatometrie . - Erlanger ge61 . Abh. &I, 112 p . HOFMANN, D . ( 198 1) : Laterale Variation sedimentarer Parameter im Oxford der slidlichen Frankenalb. Diplomarbeit, Univ. Erlangen ( in Bearbei tung) SCHMIDT-KALER , H . ( 196 2 ) : Zur Ammonitenfauna und Stratigraphie des Malm Al pha und Beta in der Slidlichen und Mittleren Frankenalb . Erlanger geo l . Abh. � ' 5 1 p . • .
SEIBOLD , E . ( 19 5 2 ) : Chemische Untersuchungen zur Bankung im Unteren Malm Schwabens . - N . Jb . Geol . Pa l . Abh. �' 3 3 7-370 . WHITEHOUSE , U . G . , JEFFREY, L . M . & DERBRECHT ,· J . D . ( 1960) : settling tendencies of clay minerals in saline waters . - Clays and Clay Min . l ·
n.-.m n
ofMarl-Limestone.Alternation (Oxford 2) in Southwest Germany W. RieKEN and C. HEMLEBEN
Abstract: A co'red Oxford 2 marl-limestone alternation shows diag.e netic overprint of primary marl-limestone rhythms . The clay con tent in the marl layers is enhanced due to pressure solution and the formation of marl seams . Well preserved and little compacted burrows throughout the limestone beds indicate early cementation. weathering emphasises the differences in prima_ry lithology .
1 . In traduction The Oxford 2 (20 m to 90 m thick) , exposed 200 krn along the bench land of· the Swab ian Alb {Fig. 1 ) , consists of two different facies :
( 1 ) Well bedded marl-limestorie rhythms interfingering with ( 2 ) the bioherm facies , which is composed of ( ? ) blue green algae and calci fied siliceous sponges and l-acks clear bedding 'in most cases . De tails of stratigraphy and facies distribution of the Swabian Alb have been summarized by GWINNER ( 1 9 7 6 ) and Z IEGLER ( 1 9 7 7 ) . rh the Oxford 2 only a few marl beds can be traced locally in both . facies , ind icating that the relief of the bioherm bod i es was low and flat. No real reef detritus has been· observed so far . Therefore,
all authors agree that the bioherms of the lOwer members of the Swa bian Upper Jurassic originated in relatively deep water, predominant ly below the storm wave base . Outcrop and facies distribution of the Oxford 2 are shown in Fig. 1 . Quarries and natural outcrops exhibit sharply alternating limestone beds { 1 0 to 30 em) and thin mar�y layers and marl j-oi nts (Fig. 2A) . The carbonate content in the limestones- ranges from 8 5 to 9 7 % while the intercalating marls contain 70 to 90 % cai'bonate (SEIBOLD1 1 9 5 2 ) . These data show that. a 5 % overlap exists between field determined marls and l imestones . This can be explained by weathering process e s . Furthermore , relict limestone particles within the marl beds cause an increase of the carbonate content . The noncarbonate part con 84 % clay {KNOBLAUCH, 1 9 6 3 ) . The distribution of carbonate Within an individUal limestone reaches its maximum in the middle of sists of
the bed {WEILER, 1 9 5 7 ) . Thick limestone beds are riche-r in carbonate Cyclic and Event Stratification ( e d . by Einsele/Seilacher) .0 Springer 1982
64
+
+ ,---, Crater C. ...)R ies \_...
+
+ site KB 6
• marl - l i mestone •
rhythm
algal-sponge facies
Fig. 1 . Outcrop and facies distribution of the Oxford 2 along the Swabian Alb after HILLER ( 1 96 4 ) . Thickness in m
than thin ones (.SEIBOLD , 1 9 5 3 ) . Quarries occasionally exhibit varia tions in thickness (Fig. 2B) . At the Eastern Alb WEILER ( 1 9 5 7 ) corre lated s.ingle be'ds over distances of more than 20 km by caco 3 analyses (EINSELE , Fig. 2 , this ·val . ) . However attempts of single bed corre lation have not been successful in all cases . Recently GWINNER ( 1 9 7 6 ) summarized correlations in the region of the Eastern Alb , which com prise a distance of ca. 70 km . He found that bed _by bed correlation seems to be problematic because of the .uniformity of the sequence and the lack of real marker beds . However, the increasing thickness of the Oxford 2 . from NE to SW (Fig. 1 ) suggests that the limestone marl rhythms started earlier or ended later towards SW; thus, not all lithological units can be traced over several tenth of km. In addition, the boundary between Oxford 1 and Oxford 2 is not well de fined by biostratigra�hy . Nearly all previous investigat'ions have been carried out on weathered material . Therefor e , we examined a drilling core, KB 6 , 7 em in dia meter from StraBberg { F i g . 1 ) . The initial core description { ETZOLD et al. , 1 9 7 5 ) shows the Oxford 2 to be 4 6 . 5 rn thick . Unfortunately the cored sequence is not entirely free of weathering. Particularly the lower 1 4 m above the underlying Oxford 1 marls show karst solution
65
and there.fore have not been used for any detailed studie s . Nevertheless , . prelimi riary results will be contributed herewith . 2 . observations and Interpretation The cored Oxford 2 (Fig. 3 ) exhibits alternations of marl and biomicri tic limestone containing mostly coccoliths . Some parts of the lime stone contain also debris of brachiopod s , echinoids , belemnites , ostracods and foraminifera (see also SEIBOLD & SEIBOLD, 1 9 5 3 ) . Some parts are rather r.ich ih Thoracosphaera, Pithonella and similar tests. 18 8 marl-limestone transitions were studied; 42 of which show only tranSitions in the rom-range . The relative amount of clay in Fig. 3 i s indicated by the descriptive weathering section. I n contrast t o out crops , the core shows intensive bioturbation . Planolites and Teichich nus structures occur quite often. Long burrows of ·2 to 4 em in diame ter and a maximum visible length of 4 5 . em ( ? athropod burrows) are re:Stricte4 to the middle and 'lower part of the cor e . The clay-rich upper part is predominantly bio"turbated by Chondrites - which are also common in the middle and the -lower part of the section. Here they are usually much smaller and arranged in · a nest-like pattern . In the limestones all burrows are well pres�rve d , because early cementation and negligible compaction took place . In contrast , burrows in the marl lay�rs are strongly compacted and thus badly preserved (Fig. 2 D) . Only 17% of the alternations show a rather distinct contact betwe�n marl and limestone (CD in Fig. 3 } as can be observed in outcrops (Fig. 2 F ) . In all other cases the transition between marl and lime stone is usually diffuse {CI in Fig. 3 ) and consists of bundles of single marl seams (MS in Fig . 3 } , causing a flaser-like structure (Fig. 2 c , D, E , G. H ) , which decreases towards the Kimmeridge 1 and disappears gradually. The bulk of the seams are fairly parallel to the stratification , although angles up to 4 5 ° occur producing nodular . features . In some cases marl seams are bound to small fissures (Fig. 2 E and at 6 3 . 7 m , 5 3 . 9 m , 4 1 . 8 m and 3 8 . 6 m in Fig . 3 ) . 22 % of the marls contain carbonate lenses {CL) often showing an internal flaser structure caused by marl seams (Fig. 2 H ; EINSELE Fig. 12 A , B , this vol . ) . As a rule , marl seams truncate t.he bioturbation structures indicating a diagenetic origin. Thu s , ' they cannot be interpreted as primary sedimen�ary structures . Thin sections and sometimes even rock specimens reveal the stylolytic nature of these marl seams . Marl seams in connection with fissures indicate that the marl seams were formed predominaritly after the initial cementation of the limestone beds at a late diagenetic stage . Competent components , for instance ,
67
belemnites or early diagenetic pyrite nodules , enable the reprecipi tation of carbonate , causing pressure shadow structures (PSS , Fig . 2 G , H ; SEILACHER et al , 197 6 ) . Marl seams caused :- by pressure solution are corrunon featur'e s in lime-· stones and even sometimeS in chalk {WEILER, 1 9 5 7 ; TRURNIT, 1 9 6 8 ; WANLESS, 1979 } . BARRET ( 1 9 6 4 ) described quite similar marl seams in oligocene _ calcarenites of New Zealand , which · are subparallel to the bedding. Diagenetic features , closely resembling the Oxford 2 marl seams , have recently been reported from the chalk of England ( GARRI SON & KENNEDY, 197.7 ) . These authors suggest that marl seams develop after the formation of early diagenetic nodules due to the overlying sediment of some 100 m . Evidence o f pressure solution can be observed not only within the marl sea�s but also in the marl beds where pressure shadow structures domi nate . Compared to adj acent limestone beds , marl beds seem to be · en riched in bioclastic detritus. Perhap s , this may be explained as the
Fig. 2 A, Oxford 2 limestones : Typical limestone-marl alternation. Scale : 1 m . Qudrry 3 km - southward o f Pfullingen , Swabian Alb. B, Upper part of OxfOrd 2 limestones : Branching of a limestone bed . Swelling and thinning of single bed is probably of concretionary origin. Sc'a le : 0 , 5 m. Road GOnningen-Genkingen , Swabian Alb. C , Bundles of single seams leading to nodular features . Scale: . lO em. Road G6nningen-Genkingen, Swabian Alb. D, Marl-limestone alternation exhibiting maximum carbonate content in the 'middle of the bed. Marl seams disseCt bioturbation structures . In th� marl layers , circular sections of burrows have been deformed to ellipses by compaction ( arrows ) . Scale: 1 em. KB 6 , 4 9 . 6 8 m - 4 9 . 8 1 m . E , Abundant marl seams i n the nodular part· of a limestone bed ( com pare 3 C ) . Marl seams developed at a small fissure ( arrow) , probably caused by different compaction around early lithified nodular struc ture . Scale: 1 em. KB 6 , 4 1 . 7 8 m - 4 1 . 9 3 m. F, Sharp marl-limestone boundaries . Upper cont-acts show stylolytic overprint. Marl seam is parallel to the bedding and continues into a joint, which is perpendicular to the bedding. Scale : 1 em. KB 6 , 53 . 7 5 m - 5 3 . 9 3 m . G, Marly limestone including a belemn ite shm.,ing "pressure shadow structurd '' . bcale: � em. KB 6 , 4 2 � 60 m - 4 2 . 7 3 m. H , Cross section of a thin limestone bed showincr compactional shearing and marl seam formation. All stages .of integration and formation of residual marl and limestone are developed . The originally limestones bed ( a ) -has been' converted into limestone lenses ( b , c ) . Belemnite shows small 11pressure shadow structures " . Scale: 1 em. KB 6 , 65 . 8 9 m - 6 6 . 0 1 m
68
co
w""·;t,
65
61
MSS
MS
co
CL CO PSS
66
MS
0
,-,:;;
j [l.i' ." ?
.:.;J·'' li i !.�� I
Cl MS
'N
MS PSS
MS PSS CL MSCI
co
62
MS co
MS PSS CO MSS MS
oo
�-�0
67
·'·'�
0 ,••
•
63 core loss
MS
ct MS
MS MS
MS
MSS
MS
MS
MSS
..:
69
50
64 MS
MS
MS C! MS
MS MS
68
MS
Cl
CL
MS MS
MS
48
CJ MS
Cl
MS MS
0
' �
MS
MS
MS
?
,,
Cl MS Cl MS
co
CD MS
_ ,... .... -
MS PSS " CL
co
MS
,,
. 'f -
MS
....,
"'
MS
· � r � · -QJ._
Fig . 3 . Marl-limestone alternation of core KB 6 , StraBberg , depth
51
69
boundary
oxford 21
CD HS
Cl Cl Cl
Cl
Cl Cl
"
Cl Cl
Cl
Cl Cl Cl Cl
�
Y1!:!1.
MS
detritus ., 5%
abbreviations marl seams
MSS ·mart seam -stylolitic ,rmacroscapicl
(I
CO PSS CL
� ammonite
fossUs blue-grey white·
contact marl/ limestone indistinct contact marl / limestone distinct
pressure shadow structure carbonate lenses
0
( s!ie/1
/
belemnite echinoderm fragme'nt
bioturbgtion-sttucfurf!s mainly Planolites
o=
#
�
Teichichnus -..,. Chondrites
r}jg{},enefic structures ;;::_....,.,. . marl seams
�limestone lenses -<e><S>pressure shadow structures o o
pyrite crystals
70
result of compaction and leaching of matrix Carbonate (EDER, this GARRI SON & KENNEDY , 1 9 7 7 ) , Sometimes the contact to the overlying and underlying limestones very distinct and certainly altered by pressure solution. On the hand , a certain primary sedimentary origin of these marl beds cannot be excluded . 3 . conclusions Pr�liminary results obtained mainly from macroscopic observation sug-; gest that the alternations of limestones and marls are· of primary origin. Mixing of sediment by burrowing organisms , as can be observed in modern sediments ( EKDALE & .BERGER, 1 9 7 8 ) , destroys most of the limestone-marl boundaries : Further destruction of primary pattern depends on the clay content and i s due to pressure solution, resulting .in macroscopically rather scattered transitions between marls -·and limeStones . On the other hand , ear.LY diagenetic cementation of the limestone facilitates pressure solution at the marl boundary. Thus , sharp marl-limestone contacts may be explained probably as a late stage of pressure solution. The final 11product" of these proces-. ses are th� well layered lim�$�nes in outcrops of the Oxford 2 of the Swabian Alb, where weathering attacks mainly the marl layer s . Acknowledgments : The writers are indebted to the Sonderforschungsbe reich 11Pal5kologie" for financial support of this study. Prof. and Prof. Luterbacher reviewed the manuscript. Technical ass istance was provided by W. Ries and w. Wetze l . References
_
BARRETT , . P . J . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Residual Seams and cementation in oligocene calcarenites , Te Kui ti Group . - J . Sedim. Petr . , vol . 1.1 , no . 3 : -524-5 3 1 . EKDALE , A . A . & BERGER, W . H . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Deep-sea ichnofacies : Modern organism traces on and in· pelagic carbonates of the western equatorial Pacific . - Palaeogeog . , Palaeoclimato l . , Palaeoeco l . , �4 : 26 3-27 8 . ETZOLD, A . , HAHN, W . & KOERNER, U . ('1 9 7 5 ) · : Keuper , Jura .- und TertHir in Bohrungen dcr P lanungsgcmcinschaft BN - Stollen zwischen Bode,nse� und Ncckar . - Jh. geol . Landcsamt Badcn-WUrttemb_erg , J.,Z : 8 9 - 2 5 5 . GARRISON, R . E . & KENNEDY , N . J . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Origin o f solution seams and flascr structure in Upper Cretaceous chalks of southern England . Sedim. Geology, l2 = 1 07- 1 3 7 . GNINNER , M . P . ( 1 97 6 ) : Origin of the Upper Jurassic limestones of the Swabian Alb ( Southwestern Germany ) . - Contr. Sedimentology , � : 1 -7 5 .
71
HILLER, K . ( 1 9 6 4 } : tiber die Bank- und Schwammfazies des WeiBen Jura der Schwabischcn Alb (Wlirttemberg) . - Arb . Geo l . Pal&ont. Inst . Technische Hochschule Stuttgart N . F . �Q: 1 -1"8 9 . KNOBLAUCH, G . ( 1 9 6 3 } : Scdimentpetrographischa und gcochcmischc Unter suchungen an WeiBj urakalkCn der gcschichteten Fazies im Gebict von urach und Neuffen . - Thesis Univcrsitat Tlibingen, 9 figs . , 1 06 p . SEIBOLD , · E . ( 1 9 5-Z ) : Chemische Untersuchungen zur Bankung im untcrcn Malm Schwabens . - N . Jb . Gcol . Palaont . , Abh . 2� ( 3 ) : 3 3 7 - 3 7 0 . SEIBOLD , E . & SEIBOLD, I . ( 1 9 5 3 ) : Foraminifcren und Kalkgehalt cines Profils im gebankten unteren Malm Schwabens . - N . Jb . Geol . Palaont. Abh . �!) ( 1 ) : 28-86 ., ' sEILACHER, A . ; ANDA:L I B , F . ; DIETEL, G . & GOCHT , H . ( 1 97 6 ) : Preser vational history of · comprEJssed JUrassic ammonites from Southern Germany . - N . Jb . Gcol . Palaont. Abh . l�� ( 3 ) : 307-3 56 . TRURNIT, P . ( 1 9 6 8 } : Analysis of pressure solution contacts and clasSi fication of pressure solution phenomena . - in: MULLER, G . ( cd . ) : Recent developments of carbonate sedimentology in Central Europe : 7 5-8 4 , Springer . WEILER, H . ( 1 9 5 7 ) : Untersuchungen zur Frage der Kalk-Mcrg£1-Scdimcnta tion im Jura Schwabcns . - Thesis Univcrsitat Tlibingen,. 57 p . ZIEGLER, B . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : The "Whithe" (Opper} Jurassic i n southern Gcrma:ny . Stuttgartcr · Beitr. Naturk . , Ser . B , �g : 1 -7 9 . •
Limestone-Shale Bedding and Perturbations of the Earth's Orbit W. SCHWARZACHER and A. G. FISCHER
Abstract: Stratigraphic sequences in carboniferous and Cretaceous limestones were measured with particular attention to strength and spacing of bedding planes . Spot sampling at regul·a r intervals transforms these data into numerically manageable form, replotted in smoothed Curves of sequential bed thickness . Beds are bundled into sets about 1 m thick. Power spectra of the Cretaceous data yield three frequency peaks , in the vicinity of 50 em, 1 m , and in the less-well defined low-frequency end. Depositional rates indicate that the bundles represent about 1 001 000 years , imply ing correlation with the Earth ' s 1.001000 year short cycle in eccentricity . That would match the 50 em peak with the orbital cycle in obliquitY and the low-frequency peak possibly with the long cycle in eccentricity . Sub-structure of the bundles , re"C vealed bY relative position of bedding planes , yields curves sho�ving three to four groupings of bedding planes per bundle. These are remarkably similar to insolation minima per eccentri city cycle, as calculated from BERGE R ' s algorithm, and suggest that the .main beds reflect the precessional cycle . It appears that limestone deposition, as well as Pleistocene ice volume , is a sensitive index to climate . It reflects the Earth ' s orbi tal perturbations at least through the latter half of Phanero zoic time. 1 . Introduction Although stratigraphy is basically defined as a science concerned with strata , most stratigraphers in fact pay scant attention to strata per s e , and to the bedding planes that bound .them. They are more concerned with packages of strata differentiated by compos i tion , sedimentary structures , or biotic character - the features that define the familiar formations and biostratigraphical zones . Most such units span episodes in the time range o f 1 05 to 1 07 m . y . This approach has sufficed for the normal applications o f strati graphy to problems of structural mapping, for recognition of epi sodes of Earth history, and for economic applications . Individual strata, however 1 may record events from this scale down to that of a year or less , and may offer clues to Earth behavior at much finer time scales . Classical along these lines are the stu dies of Holocene varve suites by de Geer and other workers . More recently, fine-scale studies of Pleistocene history have been made on Pleistocene deep sea cores, with or without reference to beds Cyclic and Event Stra·tification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
73
(e . g . HAYS et al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . These have confirmed the long-suspected tie of climates. to t�e Earth ' s orbital perturbations , and have 4 6 res olved patterns of ice behavior and climate in the 1 0 to 1 0 year range . We have been interested in sedimentary bedding and its origin during geologically earlier times (SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 5 4 , 1 9 5 8 , 1 9 6 4 , 1 9 7 5 , 1 9 8 1 ; FISCHER, 1 9 6 4 , 1 9 7 5 , 1 9 80 , 1 9 8 1 ) . Here we will describe techniques designed to convert field observa tions to. numerical data and methods of processing such data . Re-· suits are compared with astronomical data on orbital perturbations , and their effects on insolation (BERGER , 1 9 7 8 , 1 9 80) . Three sequences of limestones were treated in this manner. One is the Glencar Limestone , one of a series of Carboniferous shelf-edge sediments loca�ed in C . Sligo {NW Ireland ) , previously studied in some detail { S CHWARZACHER, 1 9 6 4 , 1 9 8 1 ) . The other two are in the pelagic Cretaceous section of central Italy {Umbria) , at Gubbio {ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ; ARTHUR, 1 9 7 7 1 1 9 7 9 ) . One is in the upper part of the Maiolica Limestone (Aptian) in the Bottaccione gorge at the town of Gubbio . The other deals with the Cenomanian part of the Scaglia Bianca, in the Valle de la Contessa, several ki lometers to the north of Gubbio . 2
·.-
Bedding in Limes tones
Bedding in these l imestones is defined by bedding planes , disconti nuities which are generally associated with a thin layer of shaly matter, largely o-f detrital origin. In the Glencar limes tone , some _ of these shaly or marly beds reach a considerable thickness . In the Maiolica and Scaglia Bianca limes tones , thin (rom-dimension) ra diolarian cherts or siliceous shales may define bedding planes . All locallities show a distinct grouping of beds into pakets or "bundles " , a feature which is readily seen in the field {Figs . 6 and 7 ) . A h ierarchy of alternatives may be considered for the origin of this bedding. Primary or Diagenetic?· The first of these alternatives centers on the question of wheth'er the bedding is original , or induced by a 11diagenetic unmixing " . SUJKOWSKI ( 1 9 5 8 ) and HALLAM ( 1 9 6 4 ) suggested that a rhythmic alternation of limestone with marly or shaly inter beds could be formed from a uniform primary ·sediment by diagenetic diffusion processes that removed carbonate from some zones and en riched it in oth-e rs . This suggestion appears to derive some
74
s trength from the following observations : ( 1 ) , lithified carbonate rocks such as the Maiolica generally show more sharply defined beds than do their poorly consolidated prototypes such as the chalk . ( 2 ) , many bedding planes show unmistakeable features o f dissolution . On the other hand, marl or shale beds in the examined sequences show features which can only be explained by primary sedimentation . For example, in the Scaglia limestone beds contain marl-filled burrows , and shale beds may contain carbonate-rich burrows , proving . that primary sediment varied from carbonate-rich to marly or shaly ( ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 97 7 ) . Ripple cross bedding defines some bed ding planes of the Glencar limestone as primary . Furthermore , sedi mentary layering, whatever its origin, is inevitably parallel to success ive positions of the sedimentwater interface. If due to un mixing, such unmixing had to be directed .either by a preexisting layering, or by the - immediate proxirnni ty of . the seafloor . In either case it records depositional history. Diagenesis has profoundly modified these consolidated sediments . Many beds are now stylolytic . What are now sharp bedding planes or thin shale seams may not have been that initially. But we reject the view that well-developed and continuous bedding planes are unre lated to depositional history. We can imagine their loss through bioturbation (ARTHUR , 1 9 79b ) , but not their addition by diagenesi s . We therefore feel justified i n treating bedding planes as expres sions of historical events developed in stratigraphical sequence � At the same time , the field observer may find it difficult to draw the line between true bedding and a family of other discontinuities , which in their more distinctive expression are discontinuous and cross-cutting, but which may masquerade as "weak" beds . Some of these are biogenically induced ( for example , spreite· burrows o f the Zoophycos typ e . Others are stylolytic or non-stylolitic solution surfaces unrelated to bedding. Yet others , in folded terranes such as these, are tectonically induced fractures . Combinations of such features are likely . These inevitably constitute a kind of noise in the bedding signal, which will be . further discussed below. Which Phase has Fluctuated? Let us assume that the bedded limestone sequences record the alternation of two primary phases of sediment. The dominant one is rich in biogenic carbonate and contains only a small admixture of detrital quartz and clay . The subsidiary phase is richer in detrital components , and may or may not have been en-
75
. -hanced in character by diagenetic export of carbonate·. I t is gene rallY assumed that such alternation result from sedimentary settings in which one phase is supplied at a steady rate, and the other phase at a variable rate. Presumably there are limestone sequences in which the carbonate component is the more invariant one and the clay supply peaked at intervals ; and others in which the reverse occurred. There is no reason to exclude the third possibility , that the supply of both fractions fluctuated , Th� amount of detrital matter deposited per unit time is largely related to the rate at which terrigenous matter is supplied . The amount' of carbonate deposited per unit time fluctuates in response to two variables : the carbonate productivity of the contributing biota1 and the rate of carbonate dissolution from the sea floor ( ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ; DEAN et a l , 1 9 7 8 , 1 9 8 1 ; ARTHUR, 1 9 7 9 a , 1 9 79b) . The latter factor is presumably not significant in shoalwa ter settings , but becomes dominant as the carbonate compensation depth is approached . For the Sligo Carboniferous , SCHWARZACHER ( 1 9 6 4 ) has suggested the terrigeneous matter may be the variable phase; for the Italian pe lagic sequences , ARTHUR and FISCHER ( 1 9 7 7 ) have suggested a steady influx of the detrital phase and variations in the carbonate phase 1 due e ither to fluctuations in productivity or to changes in rate of seafloor solution . Any of these factors are highly sensitive to climatic control , and limestones may be amongs t the most sensitive barometers of climatic fluctuations , as suggested by' GILBERT ( 1 89 5 1 1 900) •
3 . Field Observations
A s tudy of bedding necessarily implies concentrating attention on the features that bound beds , namely bedding planes . Field notes were designed t? record two features of these surfaces : their stratigraphic distance above a common reference point- the base of the measured sequence (Fig. 1 column a ) ; and a semiquantitative ranking of the intensity of the bedding plane 1 plotted in column b . This intensity ranking was considered important because o f the uncertain boundary between true bedding and other surfaces of dis continuity, and because of di fferences in the expression of bedding depending on the nature of the exposure and the degree of weathering .
76 a
46 44
b c 1 /
1 0
/
0
22
2
0
16
3
0
1
2
42 40
0 0
32
2
36
8
5
1
0
3
4 3
0
Fig. 1 . Stratigraphic field measure ments , with accompanying codes . ( a ) , stratigraphic elevation of bedding planes above base of sequence, in em. (b) 1 ran king of bedding plane, from ( O ) , contact which is not a bedding plane, to { 4 ) , master bedding plane . ( c ) , code for type of contact : ( 0 ) , lime stone-limestone ; ( 1 ) , lime stone-shale; ( 2 ) , shale-l ime s ·tone; ( 3 ) , limestone-chert � ( 4 ) , chert-limestone
The ranking scheme used was as follows ! 0 - discontin�ity that is not a bedding plane, e . g . a boundary between l imestone and a chert nodule . 1 - a weak surface , planar or stylolytic , developed only locally ( i . e . , in dm domain) 2 a very weak bedding plane , discontinuous at outcrop scale 3 a strong bedding plane , continuous through outcrop, may show a visible thin film of clay 4 a master bedding plane, generally associated with a definite . shaly (or cherty) interbed , showing topbgrap�ic expression in the outcrop surfaC e . -
-
-
A third column ( F i g . 1 c ) records changes in rock type . It too may be coded numerically , for example : 0 - no lithic change - limestone to shale 2 shale to limes tone -
3 - limestone to chert
4 - chert to limestone
1
I
i
77
_ Additional. columns may be used to plot other features observed in the field or obtained from subsequent s tudy .
4 . Analysis of Data The columns of Fig. 1 contain all of the information at hand . The next steps will be ·'to make this information more suitable for pro ce;s sing by computer, or for vizualization. This invariably results in a ).oss of in'formation . Various alternative methods will be used, each of which sacrifices some kinds of information in order to illu minate others . one such method is to construct simple - frequency diagrams of some of the data , for exampl e , of bedding thickness (Fig. 2 } . In this , the
30 20 10 20 10
0
30
40
om
50
om
60
MAIOUCA
Fi9:. 2 . Frequency distributions of bedding thickne s s , Maiolica and Scaglia limestones_ . Vertical scale: observed frequency
time-series aspect provided by s tratigraphic superposition is dis carded, bUt useful information for comparing s tratigraphic sequences emerges . Multimodal thicknesses of limestone beds may suggest either non-random fluctuations in the rates of carbonate depos ition, or a non-random variation in timing of interrupting events .
78
We turn now to plots in which the stratigraphic integrity of the data is preserved . In the case of varved sequences , e ach bedding couplet represents one year . In the tradition of varve analysis , the vertical axis of a stratigraphic plot i s inverted to a true time axis by assigning equal intervals to each couplet. Plotting the thickness of varves on the horizontal axis then depicts the fluctua tions in sedi�entation rates , fiom year to year. In most sediments , including those here considered , the length of time represented by beds or bed-couplets is not known , nor is it necessarily constant: there is no assurance that thin beds bounded by bedding planes of grade 1 or 2 represent as much time as does a thick bed delimited by planes of grade 3 . Nor can we be sure that a thick bed is not the result o f amalgamation of several thin ones , by temporary suppression of events that cause bedding planes , or by subsequent bioturbation . Thus we cannot treat ordinary bedded sequences in the manner of varves , and are constrained to retain the initial field measurements as our closest approximation to time . This time axis i s true in di rection . For most formations its dimension - the rate of sedimenta tion - is probably fairly constant when sets of beds are averaged1 but deviates at the level of beds and inter-bed events . Most methods in time-series analyses require data obtained at equal interval s . Since t ime is not known , data are collected at constant vertical intervals . Choice of interval will vary from case to case: It makes no sense to choose intervals smaller than the thinnest beds encountered with some frequency . In the case of the Umbrian Cretaceou s , in which 1 0 em beds are commo n , a 10 em interval was used; in the case of the more coarsely structured Glencar limestone , a 20 em interval gave good results . Bed thicknesses are recorded only at such predetermined measuring points . In the case of limestone beds separated by simple bedding planes . or by shale partings of rnm dimensions , the thickness of the shales can be ignored , and a shale parting counted as a bedding plane. In the case of thicker interbeds of marl or shale , the observer is faced by a choice : Whether to ignore the shale , no matter what its thick ness, treating it in the manner of a bedding plane ; or whether to deal With the section as a sequence of shale-limestone couplets , adding the thickness o f the shale to that of the succeeding lime stone bed . The two methods yield di f ferent results , and we have
79
chosen the second alternative in our treatment of the Glencar lime stone (below) . Data obtained in this manner may be smoothed by means of a running average of 3 with the weight 1 , 2 , 1 , and plotted on the strati graphic base as sequential bedding variation curves (Fig . 3 ) . In spection of thes·e curves shows a fairly regular alternation between thicker and thinner beds - the "bundling" of strata that is apparent 1
2
3
'
5
r;
?
8
9
:�' :� O
I
9
1l
Kl
2
3
n
n
12
12
l. ,
5
13
14
a
6
15
14
1
16
!5
16
•
I
15
16
17
18
19
20 21
22
23
2J.
25
17
2&
V
8
9
18
r1
n
I
28 29
18
� 12
"
30
13
31
14
32
=� 20
25
�
�
Fig. 3 . Sequential variation in thickness of beds . Vertical scale: thickness of beds in centimeters; horizontal scale in meters . A - Scaglia Lime stone , B - Jilaiolica. Limestone . Numbered arrows are master bedding planes noted in field, and used to define cycles to th.e eye in the field or in photographs (Figs .. 6 , 7) . They may be tested for periodicities by means of power spectra of the unsmoothed data (Fig. 4 ) . The three cycles thus revealed - one of which pro duces the bundles - will be considered below.
80
Fig, 4 . Power spectra of strati graphic variation in bed thick ness , for Maiolica and Scaglia limestones . Interpretation : So em peak: 4 3 , 000 year obliquity cyclei 1 m peak : 1 00 , 000 year cycle in eccentricity. Peak at left ? 4 1 3 ,000 year cycle in eccentricity
5
-
• 0 " •
•
MAJOLICA
>
4 � 0
(
"'
Jl
SCAGL I A
cyc1.;2ocm
om
.1
200
BlANCA .2
100
.3
6M
.4
60
.5
40
While this approach reveals the periodicities of higher order, it does not by itself define the s tructure of the bundles , in as much as the beds which form the bundles serve as the units of measurement . In order to study the s tructure o f the bundles , it is necessary to do two things : first1 to find some reference point within the cycle a distinctive bed or bedding plane - which serves to break the chain of stratigraphic events into equivalent segment s ; and secondly1 to devise a method of depicting and comparing the structure of these segments , individually or in an integrated manner . For our reference or segmentation point we chose the Master bedding planes (bedding planes of grade 4 ) observed in the field . Fig. 3 shows that these are generally well coirelated with the curve of bedding variation1 although not inevitably so: In a few cases 1 two bundles seem to lack a dividing master plane; in others a bundle may have been split . We have not .attempted to "correct" these cases with the benefit of hindsigh t 1 but have retained the initial field iden tification for the analysi s . The s tructure o f bundles has been s tudied b y counting the number of beds in them (SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 5 4 ; 1 9 75 ; FISCHER1 1 9 80 ) . This places much importance on which planes to count in terms of their intensity and spacing. counts from which the weaker bedding planes (grade 1 ) have been omitted are shown in Table 1 .
81
Table 1 . Number of major beds per cycle No. of beds per cycle 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 mean
MAIOLICA 32 cycles 0 6 4 8 12 1 1 4 . 03
SCAGLIA 1 7 cycles 0 0 4 2 5 4 2 4 . 88
As an alternative-- -we have used the relative position of bedding planes : The thickness of a given bundle is normalized to 1 , and the relative stra-tigraphic position of each bedding plane within that bundle is recorded. A histogram of their distribution de-emphasizes the number of bedding planes , and expresses the divison of the cycle into segments of relatively uninterrupted carbonate deposition1 separated by portions in which interruptions are concen-trated. Rather than dealing with individual cycleS , we here present the average structure of_ bundles for a given stratigraphic sequence (Fig. 5 ) . These various methods provide for a given s tratigraphic sequence a series of numerical data. These document visible features ( e . g . the bundli�g shown in Figs . 6 and 7 ) , reveal additional structure ( i . e . cyclicity below and above the levels of the bundles observed) , and present the information data in form that permits comparison , with other stratigraphic sequences as well as with non-stratigraphic da ta (such as the insolation curve in Fig. 5 ) . 5 . Examples The methods discussed above were applied, in part or in whole , to three sedimentary sequences : . ( 1 ) , the Maiolica Limestone ( Lower Cre taceous ) of central Italy ( Umbria) ; ( 2 ) , the Scaglia Limestone , Up per Cretaceous , of the same · area; and ( 3 ) .the Glencar Limestone, Lower Carboni ferous , of Ireland. Maiolica Limestone The Maiolica (Fig. 6 ) is a whitish, fine-grained limestone , somewhat cherty , of Tithonian-Aptian age. It is a li'thified coccolith ooze containing an admixture of larger protists ( calpionellids , globige-
82 MAIOUCA
G LEN CAR
SCAG LIA
I N S O LATI O N M I N .
Fig . 5 . Structure of bedding cycles in Glencar, Maiolica and Scaglia l ime stone s , as defined by relative position of bedding planes within them . Master bedding planes at positions 0 and 1 . 0 ( top and base) . The relative frequency of bedding plane positions is plotted from left to right. Various position maxima are indicated by shading. The position of insol�tion minima is shown for comparison ( see text) rinids , radiolaria) as well as some pelagiq crinoids and ammonite aptychi . It is thus an example of" the ''Aptychus limestone11 facies widespread in the Tethyan realm during the Tithonian-Neocomian in terval (GARRISON and FISCHER, 1 9 6 9 ; HSU , 1 9 76 ) . It was deposited above calcite compensation depth , but below the zone of aragonite compensation. Part of .the Umbrian pelagic sequence , succeeding Ju rassic . radiolarites and preceding the radiolarian-rich shales (Scisti a Fucoidi) of the Aptian-Albian 1 it was probably deposited at depths on the order of 1 km. The measured sequence comprises the top 36 . 4 5 m of the formation on the northwest side of the Bottaccione Gorge at Gubbio , Italy ( ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ) , exclusive of a slump zone at the very top of the 'uni t . No evidence was found in this sequence for carbo-
83
nate resedimentation in form of turbidite beds , a common feature of these rocks elsewhere ( GARRISON, 1 9 6 7 ; GARRISON and FISCHER, 1 96 9 ) . We believe the measured section to lie entirely within the Aptian (PREMOLI S ILVA et al . , 1 9 7 7 ) . Bedding Character . In the ·sequence measured, beds show an average thickness of 1 5 em, but the distribution (Fig. 2 ) shows one mode at 6 em and another at 2 1 em. Most bedding planes are sharp and in some cases s lightly sutured, with little or no cl.ay visible . Much s �·ron'ger bedding planes are developed at interva l s of about one meter , and these generally contain 1 to 5 em of dark shaly matter. These" are the "master bedding planes 11 which produce step-like slopes where gently dipping beds reach the surface, and define a 11bundling" of strata evident in outcrop . Not all of these master bedding planes contain shale, and shale may occur in the minor bedding planes near a master plane, so that presence or absence o f shale i s not a reliable objective criterion for defining cycle boundaries . Detailed petrographic and/or chemical studies have not been made . Lower ·in the format�on (Fig. 6 ) bedding is more massive, and bundling is even more striking. Aside from the bedding,· the chief varial:?le noticed iri the field is the distributiOn of chert . Chert layers , at least some of which are i"ich in radiol � ria, generally occur dir�?tly in the bedding pla nes ( in place of shale ) , or within five centimeters above or below a bedding plane. With reference to the cyclical bundles , 5'5 % of the chert beds occur �n the lower third of the bundle, 25% immediately below the master bedding plane, and the remaining 20% are dispersed along bedding planes in the upper 2 / 3 of the cycle . Cherts are not universally present in these bundles , but the number of chert bands ( 6 7 ) is about double the number of cycles ( 3 3 ) . Thus cheits cannot be used as a definitive objective criterion for recognition of cyc les . Sequential Bedding Thickness . In s tudying bedding thickness , as outlined above , spot samples taken at 1 0 em intervals served to construct the variation curve shown in Fig. 3 . The same diagram al so shows the position of master bedding planes identified in the field and numbered in ascending order. The cyclic nature o f the se diments emerges clearly from the graph, which may be regarded as ob jective proof of the cyclic s tructure of this sequence . There are, however, a few inconsistencies . No maximum in bedding thickness was found between master bedding planes 3 and 4 , while two maxima occur
84
Fig. 6 , Maiol�ca Limestone , old quarry, Valle della Centes sa, This lies lower in forma ·tion than the sequence described in text , bUt shows similar cycle . Scale bar 2 . 5 m
. between planes 4 and 5 . No maximum is found between planes 1 0 and 1 1 , 20 and 2 1 , 2 2 �nd 2 3 . Master bedding plane 2 8 falls directly onto the only peak between planes 27 and 29 . We may be justified in re . trospect in concluding that master bedding planes 20 and 2 8 , which occur rather too closely spaced to their neighbors as wel l , are pro bably spurious , and that one has been omitted between planes 4 and 5 . Yet , we have not revised the original data, preferring to treat these cases as unresolved.
85
Fig. 7 . Scaglia Bianca Limestone , road cuts , Valle della Contessa, Umbri a . A , lower part of section described; B, middle part. scale bar 2.5 m
The mean thickness of cycles thus recognized is 1 1 0 . 3 em. 'l'he ave rage thickness of cycles 1 - 1 9 is 1 2 5 . 3 cm1 that o f cycles 1 9 - 3 3 is 9 0 . 0 em, but this difference disappears if, as suggested above , the former set counts one cycle . too few and the latter two cycles too many . Power Spectrum. An objective estimate o f cyclicity can be obtained by calculating the power spectra of the thickness indices . Indices were calculated with a spacing of 20 em to obtain the maximum amount of information in the low frequency bands . The spectrum ( Fig . 4 ) shows a well developed peak in the frequencies corresponding to a wave length of 1 26 to 1 3 3 cm1 slightly longer than the cycle calculated by use of the master bedding planes . A second prominent peak lies at wave length 52 em. This peak is not attributable to any cyclicity recognized in the field .
86
Higher frequencies ' have very little significance in the spectrum, ' inasmuch as they approach the dimensions of the units used in measu ring the thickness indices . Experiments with much more closely spa c_ed thickness indices lead to power spectra .which have no obvious terpretation. I t is not possible to establish further subdivisions the 1 m cycle by such means . More informa�ion is contained in the low frequency part of the spectrum, which shows a peak at a wavelength of approximately 8 m . A power spectrum calculated with a smaller band-width, using 3 0 em intervals , suggests that this peak lies more properly between 6 . 5 and 7 . 5 m , but the resolution of wavelength in these low frequencies . is not very good in a 35 m sequence . Th is cycle is not obvious in the field, but finds expression in the bed-thickness variation curve (Fig. 3 ) , in which four episodes of high amplitudes , each containing 4-6 cycles.' are separated by shorter episodeS of low amplitude. It thus appears that the bedding cycles in the 1 m range are grouped into sets ·of �bout seven . Relative Position of Bedding Planes . The high-frequency end of the spectrum in the Maiolica section is examined next by means of rela- · tive position dia grams , using the master bedding planes as cycle boundaries , in the manner discussed above . The �esults are shown on Fig. 5 . The pattern of bedding plane spacing is highly symmetrical . Maximum concentrations at 0 . 2 and 0 . 8 repre sent bedding planes which lie near the master bedding plane . There is a wide and less well defined zone of bedding plane frequency in the middle of the cycle, having three subsidiary peaks between 0 . 3 and 0 . 6 . The cycle is thus shown to have a general s tructure of four major beds , of which the middle ,ones may in turn show subdivision. Bed coun ts . Counts ( Table 1 ) confirm the analysis by relative posi tion of bedding planes : Th€y show a total of 1 2 9 major beds in 33 cycles, yielding a mean of 4 beds per cycle, and a mode of 5 . Scaglia Bianca The Scaglia Bianca is a light-colored , somewhat cherty limestone which represents a lithified coccolith-globigerinid ooze (ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ) . It thus resembles the Maiolica Limestone , from which it is separated by the Aptian-Albian Scisti a Fucoidi . The Scaglia Bianca represents Cenomanian and part of Turonian time (PRE MDLI SILVA et al. , 1 9 7 7 )
•
87
The section was measured in the cuts along the highway passing through the Valle della Contessa , some kilometers to the northwest of Gubbio. It comprises the 1 9 . 7 meters of Scaglia Bianca immedia tely below the distinCtive black cherts and shales of· the "Bonarelli bed" ( ARTHUR and ·FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ) , and is strikingly rhythmic (Fig. 7 ) . As in the Maiolica, no evidence was found here of turbidite beds , although such beds are common in the Scaglia group in other parts of Italy (WEZEL, 1 9 79 ) . ,Bedding Characte r . Both the bedding and the lithologies are mOre com plicated than are those of the Maiolica. Continuous thin (rnm domain) layers of black and at least in part radiolarian chert 1 commonly associated with dark shale, occur commonly along the cycle boundaries . Light-colored chert i s more common within the limestone beds, and may occur either as nodules or in continuous layers . The 2 2 4 beds of Scaglia measured average 8 , 8 4 em thick, appreciably less than the beds in the Maio lica. A strong mode lies at 2 em, bey ond which there_ lies a second, diffuse multiple maximum ( F i g . 2 ) . The bed thickness distribution results from the following sequence, which occurs over and over again: (1 )
Strongly developed bedding plane , possibly shaly; (f) 2 em limestone; ( 3 ) weakly developed bedding plane; 1 0 to 1 5 em limestone ; (4) ( 5 ) weakly developed bedding plane; ( 6 ) 2 em l imeStone ; ( 7 ) s trongly developed bedding plane , possibly shaly etc. A complication factor is that the thinner beds may be s i liceous , and may turn into chert . The striking bundling of beds in this sequence (Fig. 7 ) is produced by the occurrence of more shale and associated or substituting black chert. Bundle boundaries were independently verified by SCHWARZACHER and FISCHER. 1 8 cycles were differentiated. Sequential bedding thickness . The cu.rve of sequential bed thicknes s·es (Fig. 3A) portrays these relationships graphically. As in the Maiolica , the pattern appears cyclic. Cycle boundaries as picked in the field are plottet on this curve , and as in the Maiolica, one could have second thoughts about the placement of a few of them : perhaps the cycle defined by planes 5 and 6 should have been spli t .
88 We were uncertain about the uppermost three cycles in the field , and this is reflected by the curve . Even so, we proceeded to pro cess the data without further revision. PoWer Spectrum. The average thickness of a cycle given by the field data and the bedding thickness plot is 1 07 em. This is well suppor ted by the spectral analysis of the unfiltered data (Fig. 4 ) . The high frequency peak at 5 1 em corresponds to one in the· Ma.lOlica spectrum, and its origin is revealed ln the bedding variation curve: various cycles - particularly those between planes 1 - 2 , 1 0- 1 1 , 1 1 1 2 and 1 3- 1 4 are split by a group of thin beds . Agai n , as in the Maiolica· , there is a peak in the low-frequency range, at a wave length of between 400 to 5 3 3 em. Structure of cycles. Relative position of bedding planes within the cycle is shown in Fig. 5 . The occurrence of numerous bedding planes in the middle portion of the cycle, responsibl� for the spectral peak at 0 . 5 1 m , is seen to be bimodal , falling on either side of a central bed. Two additional bedding plane maxima are seen in the lower part of the cycle , and near position 0 . 8 two peaks appear . Thus this Scaglia Bianca cycle contains more beds than the Maiolica cycle - an average of 4 . 9 major beds as shown on Table 1 - yet the overall structure is not too dissimilar . Glencar Limestone The Lower Carboniferous of County Sligo, Ireland, has been investi gated extensively by SCHWARZACHER ( 1 9 6 4 , 1 9 7 5 ) . Its basic sedimen tary cycle is probably seen best where a maximal compositional diffe rentiation occurs , in the Middle Glencar Limestone . A regular alter nation is found between 30 to 50 em layers of marly shales and 1 50-to 200 em units of bedded limestone . The individual limestone beds range in thickness from 5 to · about 30 em, with a mode at about 20 em, and are frequently ·separated by thin layers of marl. The bundles are thus approximately twice as thick as are those in the Maiolica and Scaglia limestones , and are distinguished by presence of a prominent basal shale bed . These cyclic packages of 2 to 2 . 5 m thickness are mappable units in the Middle Glencar Limestone , and their lateral variation can be studied. In the Sligo area the thickness of the marly shale beds decreases rapidly in SW direction, while the limestone gain thick ness in proportion. Thus the succession of. cycles in which the boundaries are defined by marly-shaly beds changes to one of lime-
89
stone in which the same boundaries are demarked by unusually well developed (master) bedding planes . From the paleogeographic set ting of the areas it is quite clear that this transition is connec ted with increasing distance from the land to the NE , that appears to have provided the clay· . Carbonate is largely of benthonic skele tal origin, with sponge spicules playing a large role . While some of it was produced in situ , some may have been excess supplied from carbonate banks and reef · knolls . The depth of the setting is estima t�d at about 1 40 m or less . Statistical Data. Bedding data on this sequence has · been provided elseWhere (SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 6 4 , 1 9 7 5 , 1 9 8 1 ) . While the actual num ber of limestone beds between marls or master bedding planes can be quite variable , the mean number arrived at by counting is 8 . 0 8 . Relative Position '9f Bedding Planes . For the present paper , the average structure of the cycles was computed by the relative po sition of bedding planes (see above ) . Fig . 5 shows essentially three main composite peaks in bedding plane position: at about 0 j , 0 . 4 and 0 . 8 . Thus the cycle is divided into four main segments , closely resembling �hat of the Maiolica. In bed-counts , this simi larity is obscured by the larger number of satellitic bedding pla nes in the Glencar Limestone . 6 . Discussion Communality of Pattern. In all three sequences investigated , l ime stone deposition "was interrupted by events which produced bedding planes and/or shale interbeds . This interruption occurred in a cyclic pattern. This is very similar for the Glencar and Maiolica lime stones , and slightly different for the Scaglia Bianca. Apparent similarities in timing will be discussed below . A s imple sedimen tation model which can explain these observations can be derived by superimposing two periodic functions having a frequency ratio of 1 : 5 . If this function is regarded as a probability measure for the formation of limestone beds , then profiles very similar to those observed can be generated (SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 8 1 ) . Sedimentology . At first glance, it may appear surprizing that such different sedimentary settings should respond to what appears to have been a similar cause . The Maiolica and Scaglia Bianca Limestones are pelagic deposits , probably formed near calcite compensation depth . In them, the
90
accumulation o f pelagic calcitic muds was interrupted periodically to allow the normally minor components of clay and biogenic silica to accumulate in pure form. Whether this signifies a drop in orga nic calcite production or an increase in rate of calcite dissolu tion on the sea floor remains uncertain, as does the question of whether the production of radiolarian biogenic silicy fluctuated . In the Glencar Limestone, periods dominated by calcareous matter, either of local biogenic origin or derived from near-by carbonate mounds and banks , alternated with episodes dominated by the terri genous component, possibly partly by an increase in supply of the latter. Thus bedding in each of these settings was controlled by local factors of different sorts . The communality of pattern suggests , however , that these local factors were driven in turn by some general rhythmic fluctuation in the state o f the outer Earth . Such fluctuations include eustatic oscillations and changes in climate . Change in sea leve l , possibly indirectly related to climate through fluctuations in the volume of ice , are according to FISCHER ( 1 9 6 4 ) probably the immediate cause o f some sedimentary cycle s . I t does not seem likely as a cause of cycles in pelagic depositS ·, such as the Maiolica and scaglia limestones . It might have played a role in the Glencar cycles, in which a drop in sea level would have increased the influx of terrigeneous debris while reducing the supply of carbonate from bank settings at times of emergenc e . Both the Italian Cretaceous and the Irish carboniferous settings might have responded to climatic factors , in other ways . Thus the supply of terrigeneous debris to the Glencar settings is likely to have been influenced by changes in the c limate of nearby/ lands, as well as by changes in wind-driven currents . Likewise , carbonate productivity of the carbonate banks presumably responded to changes in salinity temperature and wind-driven circulation·. Productivity of calcite-precipitating plankton in the Umbrian Cretaceous was presumably dependent upon supply of nutrients and thereby upon oceanic circulation , and rise and fall of the carbonate Compensa tion depth likewise must have mirrored changes in oceanic structure and circulation (FISCHER and ARTHUR, 1 9 7 7 ) ultimately responSive to climate. Thus climate appears to be the main conunon denominator o f the changes that induce interruptions o f carbonate depos ition . Indeed 1 limestone stratification may be one of the most sensitive recorders of climatic change , as suggested by GILBERT ( 1 89 5 ) . I
91
The Cenomanian sequence in Umbria is about 50 m thick (ARTHUR and FISCHER, 1 9 7 7 ) , and the duration of the stag� is calcula ted to lie between 2 . 5 and 8 m . y . ( OBRADOVICH and COBBAN , 1 9 7 5 ; VAN HINTE, 1 9 7 6 ) . Accordingly the mean depositional rate lies in the range of 6-20 m/m . y . ,- or 5 0 1 000 to 1 60 , 000 years per cyc le . Ess entially the same rate is indicated for the Maiolica . Similar considerations yield an estimate of 2 7 , 000 to 1 50 1 000 years for the cycles in the Glencar Limestone . These values are of the s ame order as those calculated for other bundled carbonate sequences (FISCHER, '!980) , and as the main climatic cycle recorded in Pleistocene ice flux, ( HAYS et al . , 1 9 76 ) . ==�
Link to Orbit. Regularity o f sedimentary cycles has led various authors ( among others CROLL , 1 8 7 5 ; BLYTT, 1 88 6 ; � ( GILBERT , 1 8 9 5 ; BRADLEY, 1 9 2 9 ; SANDER, 1 9 3 6 ; SCHWARZACHER, 1 9 5 4 ; VAN HOOTEN , 1 9 6 4 ; FISCHER, 1 9 80 ) to suggest that the sedimentary record is influenced by the perturbationS of the Earth ' s orbit . MILANKOVITCH was the first to calculate the variations in insolation caused by these perturba tions during the- :?leistocene . The recovery of continuous records of Pleistocene deposition in the deep sea , together with improved da ting , detailed paleontological studies and studies of oxygen _i sotope ratios have made it possible to compare the stratigraphic record of Pledstocene events - in particular the growth and shrinkage patterns of the ide sheets - with the orbital data and the insolation values calculated from them ( HAYS et al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . The patterns are remarkab ly similar, and leave little doubt that the orbital perturbations played a major role in the Pleistocene expansions and contractions of the cryosphere , and thereby on sedimentation . Such a precise comparison is not possible for the Carboniferous and Cretaceous sequences dealt with here because their timing is not well enough known . - Howeve r , the predominant cycle ·of sets of about five beds seems in each case to approximate 1 00 T OOO years � a factor of two. The spectral analyses of the marine record of Pleistocene glaciations also show their most prominent peak at this wavelength , which has been equated with the Earth 1 s short cycle in excentricity (HAYS et al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . If the sPectra are correlated on that basis , then the subdivisions of the bundle into approximately f. ive units ( the major beds) match the precessional cycle with frequency peaks at 1 9 1 000 and 2 3 , 000 years . The spectral peak at about 5 0 , 000 years then matches the ob-
92
liquity cycle, and the low-frequency peak would poS� ibly correspond to the long cycle in eccentricity noted by BLYTT ( 1 8 8 6 ) , calculated by BERGER at 4 1 3 1 000 years , and observed in the Pleistocene record by BRISKIN and BERGGREN ( 1 9 7 5 ) . A first-approach model may be formulated on the assumption that carbonate sedimentation is interrupted at times o f insolation extre ma, let us say minima . The following experiment was carried out to test this : Daily, insolation was calculated for the vernal equinoxes at the equator for the last 20 million years using the BERGER ( 1 9 7 8 ) algorithm. This shows a 2 0 , 000 year periodicity whose amplitude is modulated by a wave of approximately 1 00 , 000 years , which re sults in a series of 11minima of minima " . A program was written to find all o f the insolation miriima , and 11minima of minima11 which occur at roughly 1 00 , 000 year intervals . Assuming that the 11minima of minima'' find expression as master bedding planes, they were then used as points o f reference for establishing the relative positions of the minima (= normal bedding planes ) . The results , smoothed by a running average o f 3 with weight 1 , 2 , 1 , are shown in Fig. 5 . The pattern is that o f a five-fold cyc.le which may occasionally contain more beds , and is quite similar to the bedding plane position dia grams shown : especially to that of the Scaglia Bianca .
!i
We have already stated our hypothesis that cycles of the s ort ob served in the geological record are related in various ways to cli matic change . We do not wish to claim that insolation at the e'qua tor is directly responsible for turning carbonate deposition on and o f f , but view it as an index to general climatic · effects induced by orbital perturbations . Resemblance of the insolation curve to bed ding patterns is not proof of a causal relationship. It is consi stent, however , with the hypothesis that orbital perturbations in fluence climate , and climate in turn influences patterns of sedi mentation . Neither of these relations is likely to be simple and linear. 7 . Summary and Conclusions The Maiolica , Scaglia Bianca and Glencar limes tones show geome ·tri cally similar cycle s , seen in the field as a 11bundlii1g" of strata . These can be objectively described by converting the field data into diagrams of usequential variation in bed thickness " .
I·
Such di agrams do not resolve variations smaller than groups of beds . However, distinctive bedding planes or strata may be used to break
93
the depositional record into its cyclic segments , whose s tructure may then be compared . Bed counts offer the simplest approach , but statistical distribution of bedding planes , expressed in 11relative position11 diagrams , was found to be a better way of characterizing the structure of the cycles . Although the mechanism responsible for the cyclical interruptions of carbonate deposition are obscure and multiple, they are most like-· ly related to climate . This , in turn , is influenced by the Earth ' s orbital perturbations . Three and perhaps · four quasiperiodicities were found in the sedi mentary record, by means of spectral ·analysis of the sequential bedding curves and by the structure of the bundles . These have approximately the ratios to each other that characterize the quasi periodicities in the orbital perturbations . The actual period of the sedimentary cycles , while not accurately known, suggests 1 06., 000 years for the 11bundle " of beds , which would equate this with the short cycle of orbital eccentricity. This corre lates the main beds of the cyclic sequence with the Earth 1 s 1 9 1 0002 3 , 000 years precesSion. The power spectra further show what then appears as an expression of the 4 3 ,000 year cycle in obliquity, as wr ll as a low-frequency peak that may well correspond to the 4 1 3 , 000 year long Cycle of eccentricity . These results correspond to the patterns of Pleistocene climatic fluctuations a�d their effects on Pleistocene geochemistry arid faunas . We conclude that orbitally driven variations in climate were recorded in limestones arid perhaps in other sensitive sedimentary settings through the latter half of Phanerozoic time . As suggested by GILBERT { 1 900) the resulting cycles may indeed constitute a pulse which, once better understood, wi l l afford a basis for a re fined geochronology and for a better understanding of how the outer Earth functions . Acknowledgement The field s tudy of the Glencar limestone was made by SCHWARZACHER some years ago . The observations in Umbria were made jointly , with the additional help of Ms . Amanda PALMER , and under the sponsorship of National Science Foundation project EAR-77- 2 3 36 9 . Measurements and processing are by SCHWARZACHER, and for help in the field we are obliged to Pro f . Giovanni NAPOLEONE .
94
References ARTHUR, M . A . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Sedimentology of the Gubbio sequence and its bearing on Paleomagnetism . Mem. Soc . Geol . Ital . J�, 9-20 . ( 1 9 79 a ) : NOrth Atlantic Cretaceous black shales : the record at Site 398 and a brief comparison with other occurrences . In RYAN , W. B. F . , SIBUEJ, J . C . , et a l . , Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Project 4z, p t. 2 . •
( 1 979b) : Sedimentologic and geochemical studies of Cretaceous and Paleogene pelagic sedimentary rOcks : The Gubbio sequence . Dissertation, Princeton Univers ity , Part I , 1 74 pp . ARTHUR, M . A . and FISCHER, A . G . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Upper Cretaceous magnetic stratigraphy at Gubb i o , Italy: I , lithostratigraphy and sedimen tology . _Geol . Soc. A.rner . Bul l . �§: , p . 3 6 7-37 1 . BERGER , A . L . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : A simple algorithm to compute long-term ·varia tion of daily or monthly insolation. Universit8 Catolique de Louvain , Ins t . d ' Astronomie et de Geophysique George Lemaitre , Contrib . ;),§,, p . 1 - 1 7 . ( 1 9 86 ) : The Milankovitch astronomical theory o f paleoclimates : a modern r.e view . - Vistas in Astronomy , v . ,€4 , p . 1 03 - 1 2 2 . FISCHER, A . G . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : The Lofer cyclothems o f the Alpine Triass i c : i n MERRIAM, D . F . , ( ed . ) , Symposium on Cyclic SedimentatiOn , Kan sas State Geol . Surv. Bul l . Jg�, 1 , 1 0 7 - 1 5 0 . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : �idal deposits , Dachstein Limes.tone of the North-Alpine Trias s i c . In GINSBURG, R. N . , ( ed . ) ; Tidal Deposits : a casebook of Recent examples and fossil counterparts. Ch . �Z p . 2 35-2 4 1 . ·
( 1 9 80 ) : Gilbert - Bedding rhythms and geochronology . Geol . Soc. Amer . Spec. Paper j�� ' p . 9 3- 1 04 . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Climatic oscillations in the biosphere. In NITECKI , M . H . ( ed . ) , Biotic Crises i n Ecological and Evolutionary Time . Acade mic Press , p . ·1 0 3- 1 3 1 . and ARTHUR, M . A . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Secular variations in the pelagic realm. In COOK , H . E . , and ENOS, P . (eds . ) , Deep-water carbonate environ ments , Soc . Econ. Paleont. Mineral . Spec. Pub . g� , p . 1 9 -50. GARRISON-, R . E . ( 1 96 7 ) : Pelagic limestones of the Oberalm beds ( Upper Jurassic - -Lower Cretaceous ) , Austrian· Alps . Bul l . Canad . Petro l . Geol . v . ,1� , p . 2 1 -4 9 . and · FISCHER, A . G . ( 1 9.6 9 ) : Deep water limestones and radiolarites of the Alpine Juras s i c . Soc . Econ . Paleont. Mineral . Spec . Publ . :1,4 , p . 20-55 . GILBERT, G . K . ( 1 89 5 ) : Sedimentary measurement of geologic time . Jour. Geol . � � 1 2 1 - 1 2 7 . --- ( 1 900) : Rhythms and geologic time . Amer . Assoc. Adv . Sci . , Proc �� 1 - 1 9 .
• • •
'
HALLAM , A . ( 1 9 64 ) : Origin o f the limestone-shale rhythms in the Blue Lias of England: A composite theory . Jour . Geol � J:€. ' 1 57 - 1 69 . HAYS , J . D . , IMBRIE, J . and SHACKLETON, N . J . ( 1 9 76 ) : Variations in the earth ' s orbit : Pacemaker of the ice ages . Science 12� , 1 121-1 132. HSU, K . J . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Paleoceanog�aphy o f the Mesozoic Alpine Tethys . Geo l . Soc . America , Spec. Paper 1 701 4 4 pp .
95
- MILANKOVITCH, M. ( 1 9 4 1 ) : ' Kanon der Erdbestrahlung und seine Anwendung _ auf das Eiszeitenprohlem . E d . Spe c . Acad . Roy . Serbe , Belgrade , v . JJJ, 6 3 3 pp . English transl . U . S . Dept. Commerce . OBRADOVITCH, J . D . and COBBAN , W . A. ( 1 97 5 ) : A time scale for the Late Cretaceous of· the Western Interior of North America. In CALDWELL , W . G . E . {ed. ) , The cretaceous System in the Western Interior of North America. Geol . Assoc. Canada Spec. Paper 1J_, -p . 3 1 -5 4 . PREMOLI SILVA, I . , PAGGI , L. , and MONECHI , S . ( 1 9 7 7 ) ; Cretaceous thro"ugh Paleocene biostratigraphy of the pelagic sequence at Gubbio , Italy . Mem. Soc . Geo l . Italy v . l� ' p . 2 1 -3 2 . SANDER , B . ( 1 9 36 ) ; Beitrage zur Kenntnis der Anlagerungsgeflige. Mi neral . Petrogr. Mitt. v . �� , p . 2 7 - 1 39 . --- ( 1,_9 5 1 ) : Contribution to the s tudy of depositional fabrics . Amer . Assoc. Petro l . Geol . , Tulsa, Oklahoma . SCHWARZACHER, W . ( 1 9 5 4 ) : Die GroBrhythmik des Dachsteinkalkes von Lofer . Mineral . Petrogr . Mit t . v . � , p . 44- 5 4 . ( 1 9 5 8 ) : The stratification o f the Great Scar Limestone i n the Settle District of Yorkshire . Liverpool and Manchester Ge6 1 . Jour . , v . £ 1 p . 1 24 - 1 4 2 .
( 1 9 64 ) : An application o f statistical time-series analysis to a liffie stone-shale sequence . Jour. Geol . , v . z�, p . 1 9 5- 2 1 3 .
( 1 975 ) : Sedimentation Models and Quantitative Stratigraphy . De velopments in .Btratigraphy 1 v . J,� , Elsevier , 3 8 2 pp . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Quantitative correlation of a cyclic limestone-shale formation. Proc . Internat . Assoc . Mathema t . Geol . '· Symposium on Quantitative Con;elation, in press . SUJKGWSKI , Z . L . ( 1 9 5 8 ) : Diagenesis . Amer . Assoc. Petro l . Geo l . Bul l . , v . ii • p . 2 6 9 2 - 27 1 7 . VAN HINTE, J . E . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : A Cretaceous time scale . Amer . Assoc. Petrol . Geo l . Bull . , v . �Q , p . 4 9 8 -5 1 6 . VAN HOUTEN , F . B . L1 8 6 4 ) : Cyclic lacustrine sedimentation, Upper Triassic Lockatong Formation , New Jersey and adj acent Pennsylva n i a . Kansas Geo l . Surv. Bull . J,�� � p . 4 9 7-5 3 1 . WEZEL, F . C . { 1 9 7 9 ) : The Scaglia Rossa Formation of Central Italy : results and problems emerging from a regional study . Ateneo Parmens·e 1 Acta Nat . , v . J, � , p . 2 4 3 - 25 9 .
Rhythmic Sedimentation Documented in a Late Cretaceous Core (Abstract) L. PRAIT
Abstract : A continuous core taken through the Bridge Creek Limestone and Hartland Shale is the basis for a study of rhythmic in -l ate Cenomanian - early Turonian deposits in the Western Interior Basin of North America . The core has been cut in half , polished, and peeled, thus providing a detailed record of the large-scale bioturba tion rhythms , small-scale lamination rhythms , current events , and volcanic ash falls that occur in 30 meters of the section. Alterna ting beds of burrowed micritic limestone and laminated organic-rich marls characteristic of the Bridge Creek Limestone are well-suited to .the study of rhytmic stratal events and can be interpreted in terms of changing oceanographic conditions . The broad spectrum of sediment tYpes and sedimentation events documented in the peels indi cate that this Cretaceous sea oscillated between brackish and marine states, ·s tratified and well-mixed states, and between anaerobic and aerobic bottom conditions . The laminated marls consist of 8 major sediment types : 1 ) pelletal marl s , 2 ) pelletal and foraminiferal marls , 3 ) homogeneous ( bioturba ted) marls , 4 ) black b ituminous shale1 5 ) foraminiferal calcarenites, 6} calcarenites of foraminifera and inoceramid fragments , 7 } bone beds of fish debris , 8 ) volcanic ash bed s . Other features of sedimen- ,· tological importance i-n clude lumps of poorly sorted shell fragments and foraminifera that are probably coprolites produced by fishes and reptil e s , bedding-concordant and bedding-discordant inoceramid frag ment s , pyrite framboids , massive pyrite, and fish bone s .
..·,
�.. .
Diagenetic processes of 90mpaction, recrystallization, and neo formation have affected each microfacies differently. Foraminiferal chambers provide sites for many diagenetic reactions that can be studied with light and scanning electron microscopy , common fillings in the chambers being b locky calcite, dog-tooth calcite, clay crystals , and framboidal pyrite .
l. f I I
t�'
Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) c Springer 1982
Ecology and Depositional Environments of Chalk-Marl and Limestone-Shale Rhythms in the Cretaceous of North America (Abstract) E. G. KAUFFMAN
Abstract : Chalk-marl and limestone-shale couplets less than a meter ' ·thick widely characterize pelagic Cretaceous sediments of the Western rnterior and Gulf Coastal Plain, United States and northern Mexico. These rhythmic depOsits are best developed during transgressive (eu static) peaks between Late Aptian and earliest Campanian time . In dividual couplets can be traced for hundreds of k ilometers , and from offshore epicontinental and marginal continental platforms into basi nal facie s , where they broadly grade into clay shales . Shallow and deep water couplets are similar in many ways . The�r cyclicity ranges between 30 and 50, 000 year s . measured radiometrically , suggesting climatic cycles . Most have graded lower contacts between shale and carbonate, but sharply defined boundaries on top of · carbonate units ; in some cases these are eroded and/or partially cemented surfaces (firmgrounds) . In each couplet, clay content diminishes upward as mainly biogenic pelagic carbonate increases . Many lines of evidence suggest diminishing sedimentation rate , and decreasing water content of the sediment , from the bottom to the top of each cycle. Marine varves consisting mainly of alternating clay enriched and coccolith enriched bands a nun or .less thick are variably preserved in the rhythms , and best studied in offshore deep basinal facies . Ecblogically restr i cted benthic faunas characterize these rhythms , with abundance and diversity decreasing offshore and beilthic inverte b iates disappearing completely in certain basinal settings . Environ mental constraints on benthic colonization are substrate texture and fluidity, turbidity of benthic water s , temperature as a reflection of depth , and especially sediment and benthic 1-1ater chemistry (o , H 2 S ) and carbonate dissolution potential . The principal macro 2 zoobenthos were burrowing polychaete worm and arthropods , big epi faunal bivalves of the families Inoceramidae and Ostreidae, · small epi- and endobionts on these shells (worms , sponges , bivalves , bryozoans , barnacles , etc . ) , and saltating epibenthic ammonite s . Ecological giadients can b e established both spatially (onshore offshore depletion and change in community st�ucture} and temporally for each cyclothem . Onshore - offshore gradients seem to be mainly oxygen and temperature related , and involve , fi i s t , loss of more specialized epibenthic and infaunal mollusks and- echinoderms , follo wed by loss of shell epibionts and specialized burrowing invertebra tes , followed by loss of inoceramids and all burrowing arthropods , and finally by reduction and loss of detritus-feeding polychaetes . Temporal changes involve upward increase in density and diversity of burrowers with decreasing turbidity . and water content of the sediment, followed by w idespread colonization of the substrate surface by ino ceramids and their epi- and endob ionts, and terminating at the top of some cycles by development of firmgrounds and local hardgrounds with their characteristic encrusting and boring biota. Alternating cool/wet and warm/dry cl imatic cycles best account for temporal changes within chalk-marl and limestone-shale rhythms . Cyclic and Event Stratification {ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
Diagenetic Redistribution of Carbonate, a Process in Forming Limestone-Marl Alternations (Devonian and Carboniferous, Rheinisches Schiefergebirge, W W. EDER
Abstract: Rhythmically developed l imestone-shale alternations in the Devonian and Carboniferous of the northern part of the Rheinisches Schiefergebirge reveal certain features which cannot be explaned in terms of sedimentary transport alone . Three different paleozoic environments are interpreted as pro duced (Letmathe sequence) or at least modified ( Helle sequence , Edelburg sequence) by early diagenetic carbonate migration. Re distribution of carbonat e , specific to the local environment , Could develop differences in an originally homogenous body of marly sediment. . This process starts with carbonate solution ( probably initiated by bacterial activity) within the uppermost 1 0 em of sediment, and is followed by subsequent reprecipitation of the same material immediately below sea floor . The newly cemented sediment-layer remains largely unaffected during a latter phase of carbonate-solution because of its coarser grain size .
1 . Introduction This paper presents the interpretation of some selected Palaeozoic limestone-shale cycle'S of the northern part of the Rheinisches Schiefergebirge ( F i g . 1 ) . I t is not intended to give a comprehensi ve accOunt of the world-wide phenomenon of wel l-bedded limestone shale rhythms , though it contains some general suggestions . Rhythmically or cyclically developed , regularly bedded l.imestones , the s O-called Plattenkalke ? f the Rheinisches Schiefergebirge, in general are s ituated between the sites of major production of car bonate - represented by reefs - and the "deeper" water areas where
This work forms part of the research program of the . Sonderfor s chungsbereich 48 " Entwicklung , Bestand und Eigenschaften der Erd kruste , insbesondere der Geosynklinalraurne 11 , University of G6t tingen (Federal Republic of Germany ) . Funds for this work were provided by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (German Research Society) . Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
�0
99
r
Fig. 1 . Occurrence of Devonian carbonate complexes in the Rhein ische s Schie ferge birg e with loca tion of the investi gated sections Let mathe , Helle , and Edelburg
Fig. 2. Palaeogeographical and environmental reconst1:-uction of the investigated sections : ( 1 ) " Schleddenhof Beds" near Letm.ithe ; subtidal inter-reef l imestone sequence of Upper Givetian age ( 2 ) "Garbecker Kalk" near Helle/Balve ; near-reef l imestone turbidites of Upper Givetian age ( 3 ) " Kulm-Plattenka lk" of Edelburg-quarry near Herner ; basinal l imestone turbidites of Lower Carboniferous age
100
detrital carbonates ' accumulate. Often the s equences can be inter preted as limestone turbidites or allodapic limestones (MEISCHNER, 1 9 64 ) , but obviously various sedimentary and diagenetic �rocesses have played a part in their development .
Many of the coarse detrital calcareous turbidites show a fine-grained layer of microspar i te. This one to several centimeters thick layer is firmly attached to the overlying detrital b ed . MEISCHNER ( 1 9 6 4 ) called i·t "Nullphas e 11 , ''0-Phase 11 , or "Prephase " and suggested later (SEILACHER & MEISCHNER1 1 9 6 5 i MEISCHNER1 1 9 67 ) that diagenetic processes are responsible for the development of this layer . Studies of near-reef small-scale turbidites ( 11Garbecker Kalk11 , EDER, 1 9 70 , 1 9 7 1 ) confirm the view that the ''basal layeru ( equivalent to the "O-Phase" ) is a secondary product- of diagenetic redistribution of carbonate in solution. A common aspect of many shallow water sequences of Middle Devonian near-reef limestones i s that bedding is not alWays controlled by environmental changes . Conventionally , bedding planes are interpre ted as correlated to periods of non-depos ition or abrupt changes in the sedimentary delivery (CAMPBELL , 1 9 6 7 ) . But a cooperative project of the Sonderforschungsbereich 4 8 , comparing the sedimentological
and geochemical features ( S - , c - , and 0-isotope ratios , total car b onate- and Sr-content) of various limestone-marl rhythms , leads to . the suggestion that diagenetic processes play a part in forming re gularly bedded li�estone-marl successions .
2 . Geological Setting and Observations The area of study comprises the "Massenkalk" -region of the Remscheid Altena-Anticline ( F i g . 1 ) . Three examples of near-reef or off-reef depositional environments .( F i g . 2 ) , differing in their geological setting and age, have been investigated: "Sch leddenhof Beds " , "Garbecker Kalk " , and "Kulm-Plattenkalk u . 2 . 1 . 11S chleddenhof Beds11 of Letmathe ( Fig . 3 ) Geological setting: Northern and topmost part of the Hagen-Iserlohn Massenkalk (KREBS , 1 97 1 ) of Upper Givetian age; abandoned quarry east of Letmathe (Le , R 3 4 04 1 0 , H 5 6 9 3 20) , transition from reef-deposits to "deeper11 water environment.
101
bed thickne5s
Fig , 3. Idealized example of the l imestone-marl sequence near Letmathe : - Alternation of dm-thick , bedded autochthonous shallow water limestones and calcareous shales Biogenic constituents , vagile and sessile benthos , are enriched in the " shales" ( light band) - Total carbonat_e cont�nt : 90 - 9 9 % in limestones , 80 - 90% in " shales'1 Insoluble residue : quartz , illite , pyrite - Frequency distribution of bed-thickness
· - ·.
Fig. 4 . s - , c- , and 0-istotope ratios from selected beds of the Letmathe section. No sig ni ficant di fferences between limestone and "shale 11
Observations : Alternation of dm-thick, autochthonous shallow water limestone beds and calcareous shales . Total thickness ca. 30 m . Gradual transitions from limestone bed to calcareous shale. No erosional features , but thinning out of individual beds . Total carbonate content : 90 - 99 % i'n limestones , 80 - 90 % in 11 shales 11 • Insolub,le res idue : Quar t z , illite, pyrite. M.i crofacies : Float- and boundstone (or biomicrosparite) in l ime stones and calcareous shale s , dissolution of b iofragments in the 11ShaleS 11 parallel to bedding.
102
Biogenic constituents : Vagile and sessile benthos ( corals , stromato poroids , amphiporoids , brachiopods , gastropods , trilobites , sponges , bryozoa, algae, forams , and abundant crinoid ossicles ) , the fossils ar:e enriched in the "shale11 (up to 1 0 times ) . s-,
C-,
and 0-isotopes : no significant difference between lime
stone and 11Shale11 in bulk samples (Fig. 4 ) .
2 . 2 . ''Garbecker Kalk11 of Helle ( Fig. 5 ) Geological setting: SOuthern part of the Balve-Massenkalk (KREBS , 1 9 7 1 ) of Upper Givetian agei abandoned quarry .at. Helle/Balve ( H e , R 34 2 1 56 , H 56 89 7 2 ) , pelagic near-reef sedimentation influenced episodically by small-scale limestone turbidites (EDER, 1 9 7 0 , 1 9 7 1 ) . Observations : Alternation of dm-thick , richly fossiliferous detrital limestone beds and calcareous shales . Total thickness c a . 35 m . Switch from autochthonous t o allochthonouS sediment observable within single beds . 4 zones ( shale , basal layer , detritus , up per layer) distinguishab l e . Total carbonate content: 90 - 9 9 % in limestones , 7 0 - 83 % i n Sr/Ca-ratio x 1 000: 2 - 3 in the limestones , c a . 1 in 11shales" .
HELLE
GARBECKER K A L K , Givet
bed thickness
Fig . 5 . Idealized example of the limestone-marl sequence near Helle: - Alternation of dm-thick , bedded limstone turbidites with fine grained basal layer-beds and calcareous shales - Total carbonate content : 90 - 9 9 % in limestones , 70 - 8 3 % in - Sr/Ca-ratio x 1000: ca . 1 in "shales " , 2-3 iri limestones Frequency distribution of bed-thickness
103
Mic rofacies : Wacke- or floatstone (or ·biomicrospcirite) in the fine-grained limestone zones and. the "shales " , wacke- or pack stone (or biomicrosparite) in the detrital zone. s- ,
c-,
and 0-isotopes : Allochthonous detrital zone : isotopically
"heavy " , autochthonoUs zones ( shale , basal layer and upper layer ) : isotoP i cally " l ight11 (Fig. 6 ) .
upper layer
detritus basal layer
� @, ��
shale
Fig. 6 . S - , c- , and 0-isotope ratios and mean Sr-contents of a se lected bed o f the Helle. section : Autochthonous shale , the basal layer and the upper layer are " isotopically" light, al lochthonous detritus is isotopically "heavy11
2 . 3 . 11Kulm-Plat::t enkalk11 of Edelburg ( F i g . 7 ) Geological setting: Outer part (maximal to distal ) o f the Upper Vis E: an "Kulm-Plattenkalk" (MEISCHNER , 1 9 6 4 ) ; abandoned quarry Edelburg east of Herner (Ed, R 34· 1 6 50 , H 56 9 7 00) , basinal limestone turbidites . Observations : Alternation of em- to drn-thick calcareous turbidites with pelagic shales1 sharp trans ition from shale to limestone. Total carbonate content: 8 5 - 9 8 % in l imestones , 30 - 5 5 % in sha les . Microfacies : Wackestone (or biomi�rosparite) in the shale and "0-Phase " , pack- and floatstone (biomicrosparite) in the alloch thonous detrital zone. S- , C- , and 0-isotopes : Allochthonous detritus : isotopically "heavy u , autochthonous shale and 110-Phas e " : 11 l ight11 (Fig . 8 ) .
1 04
Fig . 7, Idealized example of the limestone-shale sequence of - Alternation of em to dm-thick, bedded limestone turbidites with 110-phase" (basal layer) and pelagic shales - Total carbonate conten t : 85 - 9 8 % in the turbidites and the basal layer , 30 - 5 5 % in shales - Frequency distribution of bed-thickness
8%o 345
� shale
detritus 0- [lhase 0'
basal Ia er shale
6 %0 13( O%Xl18Q
�
� @ Gb
--
& @ @b � @@
F i g . 8 . s - , c- , and tope ratios of a bed o f Edelburg : Au.toch·' thonous shale and basal l ayer are characterized relatively ratios , the de-tritus is "heavy11
3 . Discussion The sedimentological , paleoecological, and geochemical s tudy of the three sections has shown that , except for its total carbonate con tent, the l imestones of Letmathe , the "basal" and "upper" layer of Hel l e , and the 110-Phase11 of Ede lburg , have a wide range of features
105
in common with the interbedded marls or shales . Especially the iso topic composition of the calcareous shales and the autochthonous limestone beds of all three s equences are more or less identical . This leads to the assumption that the lithological differences bet ween s'hales and fine-grained limestones in the investigated sequen ces are produced or at least intens if.ied by an early diagenetic car bonate migration or redistribution. The analysis of total carbonate content and bed-thickness of the L7·tmathe sequence shows no recognizable correlation between bed thickness and carbonate content (Fig. 9 and 1 0 ) . Similar observa tions' have been made by FLUGEL et a l . ( 1 97 1 ) , who studied Lower Permian beds of the Carnic Alps . This contrasts to investigations of limestone-marl cycles of the Upper Jurassic in southern Germany where SEIBOLD { 1 9 5 2 ) and BAUSCH ( 1 9 80) have shown that the carbonate content of a limestone bed is proportional to its thickness . It was inferred {SEIBOLD , 1 95 2 ) that the cycles were produced by periodic variations of calcium carbonate precipitation during a constant "background 11 of C lay deposition. Another result of FLUG�L et a l . ( 1 9 7 1 ) i s that not all bedding planes of their investigated section are due to primary variations in fossil content or partical s i Z e . Some bedding planes in the '
limestone rhythm could not be correlated to periods of abrupt changes in sediment supply or to periods of non-deposition. The same i s generally true for the Letmathe section, where no sedi mento logical or pa leoecological changes can be detected at the limestone/marl interface . Primary pulsat.ions of the carbonate- or clay-supply do not seem to provide a plausible explanation for the l imestone-marl rhythms . Investigators of P lattenkalk-sequences often noted that the density of calcareous biogenic constituents per unit volume of matrix de clines with increasing carbonate content (SEIBOLD & SEIBOLD, 1 9 5 3 ; HALLAM , 1 9 6 0 ; NEUMANN & SCHUMANN , 1 9 7 4 ; this paper F ig . 3 } . The conventional explanation, a relatively enrichment of fossils due to a slower rate of sedimentation, is not confirmed by the results of our paleoecological and isotopic analysis , which suggest that sedi mentation and diagenesis of the shales and of the fine-grained l i mestones took place under the same or similar conditions . An alternative explanation may be that solution of micritic matrix in the marl took place and lead to a relative enrichment of bioge-
106
Le9 llcm
le 29 9cm
le 60/1 .15cm
Le 60/2
17cm
le 60/3 18cm
Le 60/4 14,5cm
Le 68/1
13cm
Le 68/2 16cm
Le 8
llcm
Fig. 9. Distribution of total carbonate content ( light) and insoluble residue ( stippled) of nine selected beds of the Letmathe section. Range of samples is indicated by black columns
107 30%
LET MATHE
100%
104 bod1
� 20
z 0 u
< z
£ � u
90
"
Bf0-THICKNf55
Fig . 1 0 . Frequency distribution of bed-thickness of the Letmathe section and range of total carbonate content of 1 2 selected beds (black lines ) . No correlation of bed-thickness and carbonate content nic constituents . Additionally , the marls might have undergone stronger compaction than the limestones ( HALLAM , 1 9 60 ) . A similar diagenetic interpretation for the genesis of nodular limestones is based upon data from recent marine s ediments . So for example · the theory of GRUNDEL & R6SLER ( 1 9 6 3 ) explaining the forma tion o f calcareous nodules i s mainly based on ideas of ILLIES ( 1 9 4 9 ) , who proposed that differences in pH- and Eh-values in the oxidation zone and lower reduction-zone within the sediment are responsible for carbonate solution (in the reduction-zone) and concentration ( in the oxidation-zone ) . The importance of the diagenetic migration of calcium carbonate ( s e� gregation) in forming regular cyclic alternations of shale and ar gillaceous limestones is also described by HALLAM ( 1 9 6 4 ) . The formation of recent . to subrecent carbonate hardgrounds or hard layers in nearly all marine environment.s has been summari z ed by BATHURST ( 1 9 7 6 ) . He argues that submarine diagenesis must be regar ded as important as meteoric diagenesis in the lithification of limestone s . Therefore w e propose a diagenetic . origin o f the described limestone marl sequence of Letmath e , and a diagenetic overprint of the calca reous turbidite-shale alternations of Helle and Edelburg .
108 4 . Genetic Model · of Limestone-Marl Alternation
It is supposed that diagenetic redistribution-processes , recognized . by MEISCHNER ( 1 9 6 7 ) in the deeper turbidite environment of the nisches Schiefergehirge, may also have been effective in shallower environment . Measurements on recent carbonaceous sediments indicate that the lo
west pH-values occur in the uppermost 5 em of the s ediment (SEIBOLD·, 1 9 6 2 ; PAUL , 1 9 70) . I t is suggested that a sort of chemical bedding within the sediment is responsible for two levels : A lower one with carbonate solution1 · probably initiated by bacterial activity (CHILINGAR et al . 1 9 6 7 ; HARTMANN & NIELSEN, 1 9 69 ; GOLUBI C & SCHNEI DER, 1 9 79 ) , and a higher one with carbonate reprecipitation imme
diately below the sea floor (Fig. 1 1 ) . Pore-water dissolving Ca- � Mg-, and Sr-carbonate migrates upwards , until saturation is achieved and carbonate i s reprecipitated as a calcite cemen t.
Fig . 1 1 . Model of diagenetic differen tiation in a carbonate mud : subsurface carbo'nate solution ( initiated probably by bacte rial activity) and carbonate reprecipitation within the uppermost 1 0 to 1 5 em of ' sediment Fig. 1 2 displays an idealized dynamic model for the origin of dia genetic bedding. While solution and reprecipitation takes place in the shallower subsurface , sedimentation is continued . The zone of solution, depleted of carbonate , undergoes stronger compaction. Solu tion and compaction lead to a relative enrichment of fossils and in solubles . As sedimentation goes on1 the front of bacterial activity (possible sulfate reduction) and concomitant carbonate solution migrates upwards in the column affecting newly deposited carbonate matter . The dissolut ion/reprecipitation cycle is repeated . Carbonate precipitated during earlier cycles ( now buried) remains largely un affected because of its coarser grain-s ize .
109
�··
Fig. 1 2 . Dynamic model : continuous sedimentation of carbonate mud, subsequently overprint.ed by carbonate solution and reprecipitation. Homogenous mud acquires regular diagenetic bedding . Density of stippling is inversely proportional to carbonate content
5 . Interpretatiqn of the Investigated Sections Letmathe : The carbonate sediment, primarily more or less homogeneous , acqui�ed bedded character as a result of migration or s egregation of carbonate during early diagenesi s . This process possibly is controlled by bacterial activity ( sulfate reduction) in a partly "open system" of the uppermost layer of the sediment (NIELSEN, 1 9 79 ) . Helle: The deposition of au.tochthonous marl was interrupted by episo dic influx of calcareous turbidites . Early diagenetic redistribution of carbonate differentiated the autochthonous marl into a calcareous shale and a basal layer . The segregation of carbonate possibly was controlled by bacterial activity. Solution and reprecipitation of carboncite took place under partly 11open system11 conditions (NIELSEN , 1 9 7 9 ) within the uppermost 1 0 em of the sediment. The overlaying turbidite (detrital zone) remains isotopically " heavy 11 , because cementation took place under 11closed system" conditions .
1 10
Edelburg : The primary alternations ( allochthonous detritus 1 nous shale) were overprinted and to some extent obscured by ry , diagenetic car�onate migration possibly controlled by bacteria l ac.tivity as suggested for the Helle-sequence .
·
6 . Conclusions The hypothesis proposed here suggests that regularly bedded lime stone-marl alternations., apparently cyclic or rhythmic , in many cases (deep and shallow water carbonate environments) may be due to .e arly diagenetic redistribution of carbonate rather than to va riations in the primary delivery of materi a l . The supposed diagenetic redistribution process may a l s o have been effective in the Muschelkalk (see AIGNER, this vel . ) or in the Ju rassic P lattenkalk sections (KEUPP, 1 9 7 7 ; RICKEN & HEMLEBEN, this vol . ) or in the paleozoic sequences of Ireland (see WALTHE R , this vol . ) or the Alps ( FLUGEL et a l . , 1 9 7 1 ) . The controlling parameters of the proposed redistribution process are thOught to be local rather than global . Ac;knowtedgemen ts I feel very indepted to Prof . Dr . D . MEISCHNE R , who initiated and s t imulated the study of sedimentary and diagenetic processes in the Rheinisches Schiefergebirge. I would like to express my thanks to my colleages and friends Dr . w. ENGEL and Dr . W. FRANKE, who were incorporated in the field and brain work 1 and Prof . Dr .. J . HOEF S 1 Dr . H . NIELSEN, Dr . A . SCHNEIDER and Prof . Dr . H . WEDEPOHL for the'i r generous help with the isot�pe studies . H . GRIMME and B .· RAUFEISEN carried out the drawings . Last not least I want to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG1 "German Research Society) , who financed the investigations of our group in the "SFB 4 8 - Erdkruste " . References BATHURST1 R . G . C . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Carbonate s ediments and their diagenesis , 2nd edn . , Elsevier1 Amsterdam Oxford New York . BAUSCH , W . M . ( 1 980) : Tonmineralprovinzen in Malmkalken . Erlanger Forsch . B , Naturwiss . u . Medizin � CAMPBELL, c . v . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Lamina , Laminaset and Bedset. Sedimentology 1! = 7-2 6 .
111
G . V . ,. BISSELL, H . J . , WOLF , K . H . ( 1 9 67 ) : Diagenesis of carbonate rocks . I n : LARSEN, G . , CHILINGAR , G . V . ( eds . ) , Diage nesis in Sediments . - Developm. Sedimentol . � : 1 79 - 3 2 2 · Elsevier.
EDER1 w . ( 1 9 70 ) : Genese Riff-naher Detritus-Kalke bei Balve im Rheinischen Schiefergebirge (Garbecker Kalk) . Verh. Geol. B . -Anst . , J�ZQ= 5 5 1 -56 9 , Wien.
EDER , w. ( 1 9 7 1 ) : Riff-nahe detritische Kalke bei Balve im Rheini schen Schiefergebirge (Mittel-Devon , Garbecker Kalk) . - GOttin ger Arb . Geol . Pal&ont . , JQ · FLtJGEL, E . , HOMANN , W . , TIETZ , G . F . ( 1 97 1 ) : Litho- und Biofazies eines Detailprofils in den Oberen Pseudoschwagerinen-Schichten (Unter-Perm) der Karnischen Alpen . - Verh. Geo l . B . -Anst . 1�11: - --10-42 , Wien. GOLUBIC , S . , SCHNEIDER, J . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Carbonate Dissolution. I n : TRUDINGER, P . A . , SWAINE , D . J . ( eds . ) , Biochemical cycling of mineral-forming elements. -Studies in Environffi. Science 1, Elsevier, Amsterdam Oxford New York : 1 07- 1 29 . GRUNDEL , J . , ROSLER, H . J . ( 1 9 6 3 ) : Zur Entstehung der oberdevonischen Kalkknollengesteine ThUringens. Geologie J� : 1 009 - 1 03 8 . HALLAM , A _. { 1 960} : A sedimentary and faunal study of the Blue Lias of Dorset and Glamorgan . - Phi l . Trans . Roy. Soc . London , Ser. B , 2 4 3 : 1 -4 4 . HALLAM , A . ( 1 9 6 4 ) .: Origin of the l imestone-shale rhythm in the Blue Lias of England: a composite theory . - J . Geo l . �� : 1 57 - 1 6 9 . ===
HARTMANN, M . , NIELSEN, H . ( 1 9 69 ) : Delta 3 4 S-Werte i n rezenten Meeres sedimenten und ihre Deutung am Beispiel einiger Sedimentprofile aus der westlichen Ostsee . - Geo l . Rundsc h . �� : 6 2 1 -6 5 5 . ILLIES , H . ( 1 9 49 ) : Die Lithogenese des Untereozans in Nordwestdeutsch i and._- Mitt.. Geo l . Staats ins t . Hamburg J,� : 7 - 4 6 . _ KEUPP , H . { 1 9 7 7 ) : Ultrafazies und Genese der Solnhofer P lattenkalke ( Oberer Malm, Slidliche Frankenalb) . - Abh . Naturhist. Ges . Nlirn berg, ��
KREBS , w. ( 1 9 7- 1 ) : ·Devonian Reef Limestones in the Eastern Rhenish Schiefergebirge . I n : MULLE R, G . ( ed . ) Sed imentology of parts of Central Europ e , VIII Int . Sed . Congr . 1 97 1 , Heidelberg, Guidebook to Excursions : 4 5 -8 1 . MEISCHNER, K . D . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Allodapische Kalke , Turbidite in Riff-nahen Sedimentations-Becken . I n : BOUMA , A . H . , BROUWER , A. (eds . ) Turbi dite s . - Developm. Sedimentol . � ' Elsevier: 1 5 6- 1 9 1 . MEISCHNER, D . { 1 9 6 7 ) : PalOkologische Untersuchungen an gebankten Kalken - Ein Diskuss ions-Beitrag . - Geol . FOren. StOckholm FOrh. Jl� : 465-469 . NEUMANN , N . , SCHUMANN , D . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Zur Foss·ilerhaltung1 besonders der Goniatiten in roten Knollenkalken vern "Arnmonitico Rosso11-Typ . · N . Jb . Geol . Palaont. Mh. J��� : 2 9 4-3 1 4 . NIELSEN, H . { 1 9 7 9 ) ! Sulfur I sotopes . I n : JAGER, E . , HUNZIKER, J . C . { eds . ) Lectures in Isotope Geology. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg: 2 8 3 -3 1 2 . PAUL , J . ( 1 970) : Sedimentgeologische Untersuchungen im Limskikanal und vor der istrischen Ktiste (nOrdliche Adria) . - GOttinger Arb- . Geol . Palaont. � SEIBOLD , E . ( 1 9 52 ) : Chemische Untersuchungen zur Bankung im unteren Malm Schwabens . N . Jb . Geol . Palaont. Abh . �g : 3 3 7 - 3 7 0 .
112
SEIBOLD , E . ( 1 96 2 ) : Untersuchungen zur Kalkfallung und KalklOsung am Westrand der Great Bahama Bank . - Sedimentol . J : 50- 7 4 . SEIBOLD , E . , SEIBOLD , I . ( 1 9 5 3 ) : Foraminiferenfauna und Kalkgehalt eines Profil im gebankten unteren Malm Schwabens . - N . Jb . Geol . Palaont. Abh . �� : 2 8 -8 6 . SEILACHER, A . , MEISCHNE R , D . ( 1 9 6 5 ) : Fazies-Analyse im Palaozoikum des Oslo-Gebietes . - Geol . Rdsch. �� ( ftir 1 9 6 4 ) : 596-6 1 9 .
A Contribution to the Origin of Limestone-Shale
Sequences
M. WALTI!ER
.
Abstract: Layered limes tones of the Sligo syncline in NW Ire land . indicate that the limestone-shale alternations are largely of diagenetic origin. The centre of limestone layers generally consists of largely pure calcium ca�bonate . This light-grey lime stone is often enveloped by chert. The oU ter parts of the layers are composed of dark-grey limestone with an increasing dolomite content towards the margins . Metastable components of modern lime muds are aragoni te , bioge nous silica, and Mg-calcite . In this order they are dissolved and precipitated in the pore space of the mud forming limestone layers with the internal structure described above .
. Introduction A 7PO-m section of Lower Carboniferous Limestone ( S 2 - D1 ) has been studied in coaStal ou-tcrops about 1 5 km
NW
of Sligo in NW Ireland .
The fossiliferous limestones were deposited in an open marine, shal low water environment . The sequence consists of more or less regu larly alternating nodular limestone layers (mostly micrite) separa ted by shale . A statistical time-serieS analYsis of parts of the section about 1 0 krn eastwards did not result in any definite me
chanism for the cha�ge between periods of limestone and shale depo sition ( S CHWARZACHER, 1 9 6 4 ) . Limestone-shale alternations are relatively common world-wide in any stratigraphic system. Most previous workers have related these
alternations to successive periods of limestone and shale depos � tion
~
which may have been controlled by various factors e . g . climatic cycles (BRUCKNE R , 1 9 5 1 , 1 9 5 3 ; BJ¢RLY�KE , 1 9 7 3 ) , permanent changes between shallow water and deep water environments (KREBS , 1 9 6 2 ) , turbidi�es (MEISCHNER, 1 9 6 4 ) , lateral facies migrations (B5GER,
1 9 6 6 ) , periodical C0 -increases ( FLUGEL & PENNINGER , 1 9 6 6 ) , or cycli 2 cal fluctuations of the microplancton productivity (GARRISON, 1 9 6' 7 ) . Cyclic and Event Stratification ( e d . by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
1 14 Others pointed out the role of secondary carbonate migration tuating primary inhomogeneities ( HALLAM, 1 9 6 4 ; SEILACHER & 1 9 6 4 ; MEISCHNER, 1 9 6 7 ; OLDESHAW & SCOFF I N , 1 9 6 7 ; EDER, 1 9 7 1 ; & AMSTUTZ , 1 9 7 9 ) or · the possibility of an origin of l imestone ers without any primary pattern within the sediment (KENT, 1 9 3 6 ; EDER, 1 9 7 5 ) . The _ carbonate i s mobilized by solution o f aragonite and pressure solution ( OLDERSHAW & SCOFFIN, 1 9 6 7 ) , a decrease of pH-value (EDER, 1 9 7 1 , 1 9 7 5 ) , or pressure solution ( TRURNIT & ARM STUTZ , 1 9 79 ) .
2 . Field Observations · within mqst limestone l ayerS there are three different main compo nents easily distinguished i f the. lime S tone is intensively light-grey _limestone, chert and dark-grey limestone. In parts section the layers consist of light-grey and dark-grey limestone only. Light-grey l imestone is generally situated in the center of the layers . It occurs in straight layers or nodules with all transitions_ bet;ween both . AccumUlations ·o f· fossils , shell layers or coarser intercalations are generally s ituated in the centre of the layers of light-grey limestone . Such layers thicken around large fos � ils ( e . g . coral colonies) o r often terminate where lenses of fossils or shell debris disappear as wel l . Nodular thickening o f subse quent layers is generally complementary , i . e . : if the l ight-grey limestone of one layer is thickening, it is thinning in the subse quent layer . There is no compaction observed within the light-grey l imestone . Chert generally envelopes the nodules or layers of light-grey
l imestone . These envelopes _are between a few mm and about 5 em thick and consist of vitreous or granular chert ( ROBERTSON, 1 9 7 7 ) . The transition between l imestone and chert can be abrupt or grada tiona l . Dark-grey l imestone i s generally situated a t the outer parts o f the layers . If there is no chert between the two types of limes tone_ , the vertical and horizontal transition between both is gradual . The dark-grey l imestone reveals a certain amount of compaction increa sing towards the margins of the layers . Delicate fossils are gene rally crushed, stable ones only show deformation i f s ituated clo sely to the margin of the layers .
1 15
The· shale beds between the l imestone layers are up to a few em thick. Fossils within the shale beds are s trongly deformed by compaction. If shale layers pass through thickets of l ithostrotionide coral s , the coralites are s trohgly leached, sometimes only relicts o f the wall survived the diagenes i s . Neither the l imestone nor the shale l ayers are continuous i ri all cases . Quite commonly are thin l imestone layers surrounded- by shale only a few em wide . O ri e thick limestone layer splits up completely i�to two thinner layers within 25 m laterall y . The two thin layers enclose a shale bed . - Each of them has got the internal structure of limestone layers as- described above . Quite· often are shale layers which are developed only for a few em between successive nodules of light-grey limestone. Beyond the area of pressure emanating from the nodules these shale layers can be traced into dark-grey limesto ne . Gastropods or cephalopods have never been observed outside the light-grey limestone exept as moulds or PY rite replacements .
3 . Laboratory Investigations . The Mgo and CaO content of a l imestone layer from Serpent Rock (Lower Glencar Limestone ) consisting of light-grey limes tone in the centre and dark-grey l imestone in the marginal parts was analysed titrimetrically according to HERRMANN ( 1 9 7 5 ) . The results were plotted in F i g . 1 as Mg, Ca ( C0 ) 2 and caco 3 , the insoluble residue 3 wqs calculated from these data . x-ray diffraction analysis shows that the insoluble residue is largely made up of quartz . . Fig.
shows that the calcite (Caco 3 ) content is high in the middle of the laye r , and decreases towards the margins . Insoluble residue is low in the centre , but increases towards the margins with two
distinct peaks in the outer centres . The dolomite content ( C a , Mg (co ) ) is generally negligible but increases at the margins of 3 2 the layer, so that roughly a threefold zonation of the layer can be established: An inner zone with high calcite content is surroun ded by .intermediate zones with distinct quartz peaks and outer zo nes with- relatively high dolomite concentrations . The inner zone appeared as l ight-grey limestone , the rest of the layer as dark grey l imestone .
1 16
Fig. 1 . MgO and CaO (plotted as ' Mg , Ca ( C0 3 ) 2 and CaC0 3 ) content of a l imestone layer ( Serpent Rock , Lower Glencar Limestone ) . Insoluble Residue ( I R ) calculat ed . Left side : s chematic sketch of the weathered limestone layer cons1sting of l ight-grey and dark-grey limestone
80 90 wt 0/o
4 . Diagene tic Model Modern lime muds have porosities of between 40 and 90% (PRAY
&
CHOQUE-TTE , 1 9 6 6 i CHILINGAR et al . , 1 9 6 7 ) . When deposited above the lysocline , they generally consist of various amounts of aragonite, Mg-calcite , calcite , biogenous silica , and clay minerals , depending on the . environment in which they ar·e deposited. The porosity of ancient limestones , consisting mainly o f calcite , quartz and clay mineral s , is reduced to about 2 or 3 % (BATHURST, 1 9 70) . When the high porosity of lime muds is reduced to about zero with Only minimal or without compaction a source problem for the large amounts of carbonate needed for cementation emerges (BATHURS T , 1 9 70 , 1 9 7 6 ) .
The l imestones described above are assumed to be lit� ified by an internal diagenetic process , i . e . they derived their cements from ' indigenous sources by soluti on at one site and reprecipitation at other sites . The site of precipitation is assumed to be the original pore system of the lime mud where the l imestone layers are now , with areas of
117
solution mainly being the shale beds which are considered to be a compacted residuum of the original lime mud deplete-d of the meta stable carbonates ( aragonite and Mg-calcite) and biogenous silica . .A.s described above , the sequence generally cons ists o f four dif·fe rent types of rock : chert and two types of l imestone within the layers , and phale between the limestone layers ( Fig'. 2 ) . The .diffe rent rat·e s of - compaction of the various parts of the sequence show that each part was lithified at i ts individual time : the inner �arts of the layers ( light-grey limestone) do not reveal significant compaction , therefore i t i s concluded that they were lithified re latively soon after deposition prior to accumulation of overburden. The outer parts of the layers ( dark-grey limestone) and the shale beds show an increasing degree of· compaction, therefore must have been cemented later. The composition of the solut�on which cemented the pore space of a lime mud to form a limestone layer consisting of three different types of rock had to change three times . At the beginning it had to be oversaturated with respect to largely pure calcium carbonate to form the l ight-greY limestone in the �iddle of the laye·r . It is assumed that this oversaturation was achieved b y solution of the aragonitic components of the l ime mud (Fig. 2 ) . Later the solution be dame oversaturated with :r::e spect to Sio2 by dissolution of bioge
nous s i lica to cover the l ight-grey limestone with chert, and at the end it was oversaturated with respect to calcium carbonate and dolo mite to form. the dark-grey l imestone which is the result of so lution of the Mg-calcite . The shale beds remain as a compacted re siduum ( l ime mud depleted of aragoni te , b iogenous silica, and Mg calcite ) . According to the ' maturatio? . hypothesis ' ( ERNST & CALVERT , 1 96 9 ; WISE & WEAVER, 1 9 7 4 ) the first form of s ilica to be precipitated
is disordered cristobalite . In calcareous environments this silica
is transformed to quartz within an average rate of between 30 and 50 million years ( v . RAD, 1 9 79 ) . Metastable components of the same material undergo d ifferent types of ' stabi l ization ' (BATHURS T , 1 9 6 4 ; LAND , 1 9 6 7 ) . I t largely depends on the s i te where components are s i tuated whether they are dissol ved or Whether they recrystallize in situ . Metastable components s ituated at the site of precipitation or within alreadY lithified parts of the l ime mud recrystall· ize. in situ, outside those sites of recrystallization they are generally dissolved ( Fi g . 2 ) . This
118 S o l u t i on
of
Shale S o l u t i on Solution Dark-grey
of
of b i og,
+ dolomite
s i l ica
a r a g on i t e
Chert
L i ght-grey M g- c a l c i t e
l imestone
Chert
Solution Dark-grey
of
Solut ion
limestone
of a r a g on I t e
2
b i og.
Shale
Formation Sequence
of
even t s :
I ight-grey limestone
s i f ica
Formation of chert l imestone
Fig . 2 . Schematic model displaying the formation of a limestone layer consisting of l ight-grey limestone, chert and dark-grey limestone . Disordered cristobalite as an intermediate form during silica diagenesis ( see text) i s not shown
can be proven by gastropods or cephalopods which consisted largely of aragonite ( HALLAM & O ' HARA , 1 9 6 2 ; MAJEWSKE , 1 9 7 4 : MILLIMAN , 1 9 7 4 ) . They can not ·be observed recrystallized outside the ligh.t-grey limestone. A few exeptions in which they are preserved as moulds or
replaced by pyrite prove that the restriction of these fossils to light-grey limestone i s not primary . Factors other than the site such as Mg-content, grain size , crystal shape, and abrasion induced strain also determine the solubility of components ( CHAVE & SCHMALZ ,
1 9 6 6 ; LAND , 1 9 6 7 : NEUGEBAUER , 1 9 74 ) , therefore recrystallized fos sils are sometimes observed in areas of solution.
1 19
The s ite of precipitation seemed to be determined by primary inho mogeneit ies within the l ime mud such as shell layers , accumulations of fos s i ls , coarser intercalations , or even single l arge fossils in to which the carbonate ions migrated: If these inhomogenei·ties are absent, the l ight-grey l imestone occurs in nodules and the layers become more or less nodular in appearance . All transitions between limes tone nodules and l imestone layers can be observed , therefore the formation of both , nodules · and layers , is attributed to the same ( concretionary ) origin. Acknowledgements The author is indebted to Prof . D . MEISCHNER for consistent advice , constructive criticism and support . The manuscript has been impro ved by the critical reading of Prof . B . ERDTMANN.
References BATHURST , R . G . C . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : The replacement of aragonite by calcite in the molluscan shell wal l . I n : IMBRIE , J . & NEWELL, N . · (eds . ) : Approaches to paleoecology , Wiley & Sons 1 . New York : 3 5 7 -3 7 6 .
BATHURST, R . G . C . ( 1 9 70 ) : Problems of lithification in carbonate muds ·. -Proc. Geo l . Ass . 8 1 : 4 2 9 - 4 4 0 . BATHURST, R .- G . C . _ ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Carbonate sediments and their -diagenes is . � Develop� Sedimentol . 1 2 : 2nd edn . , 6 5 8 pp . BJ�RLYKKE , K . ( 1 9 7 3 ) : Origin of limestone nodules in the Lower Pa laeozoic of the Oslo Region. -Norsk Geo l . Tidsskr . 5 3 : 4 1 9-4 3 1 . BUGE R , H . ( 1 96 6 ) : PalaoOkologische Untersuchungen an gebankten Kal ken . -Geo l . FOren. Stockholm FOrh . 8 8 : 307-3 2 6 . BRUCKNER , w . ( 1 9 5 1 ) : Lithologische Studien und zyklische Sedimenta tion in der Helvetischen Zone der Schweizeralpen . -Geo l . Rdsch. 39 : 1 9 6 -2 1 2 . BRUCKNER , W . D . ( 1 9 5·3 ) : Cyclic calcareous sedimentation .as an index of cl imatic variations i n the pas t .· -J . Sed . Petro l . 2 3 : 2 3 5 -2 3 7 . CHAVE , K . E . & SCHMALZ , R . F . ( 1 9 66 ) : Carbonate - seawater interactions . Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 3 0: 1 0 3 7 - 1 04 8 . CHILINGAR , G . V . , BI S SELL, H . J . & WOLF , K . H . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Diagenesis of carbonate rocks . -Developm. Sedimentol . 8 : 1 7 9 - 32 2 . EDER, F . W . ( 1 9 7 1 ) : Riff-nahe detritische Kalke bei Balve im Rheini schen Schiefergebirge (Mittel-Devon , . Garbecker Kalk) . - GOttinger Arb . Geo l . Palaont. 1 0 : 66 pp. •.
EDER, F,. W . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Riffe und Riff-detritogene Plattenkalke . - Ber. SFB 48 : Entwicklung , Bestand und Eigenschaften der Erdkrus te , insbesondere der Geosynklinalraume , Projektber. A : 1 1 7- 1 4 3 . ERNST, W . G . & CALVERT , S . E . ( 1 9 6 9 ) : An experimental s tudy o f the recrys talliza-tion of porcelanite and its bearing on the origin of some bedded cherts . - Am. J . Sc i . 2 6 7-A: 1 1 4 - 1 3 3 .
120 FLUGEL , H . & PENNINGE R, A. ( 1 9 6 6 ) : Die Lithogenese der Oberalmer Schichten und der mikritischen Platten--Kalke (Tithonium , NOrd liche Kalkalpen) . - N . Jb . Geol . Palaont . , Abh . 1 23 : 2 4 9 - 2 8 0 . FOLK , R . L . ( 1 96 5 ) : Some aspects of recrystallization i n ancient l imestones . -Soc . Econ. Paleontol . Mineral . , Spec. Pub l . 1 3 : 1 4- 48 . GARRISON, R . E . ( 1 96 7 ) : Pelagic l imestones of the Oberalm Beds (Upper Jurassic - Lower Cretaceous ) , Austrian Alps . -Bul l . Cana . dian Petro l . Geol . 1 5 : 2 1 -4 9 . HALLAM , A . ( 1 9 6 4 } : Origin o f l imestone - shale rhythm i n the Blue Lias ·of England: a d.omposite theory . - J . Geo l . 7 2 : 1 5 7 - 1 6 9 . HALLAM , A . & O ' HARA, M . J . ( 1 96 2 ) : Aragonitic fossils in the Lower Carboni ferous of Scotland . - Nature 1 9 5 : 2 7 3 -2 7 4 . HERRMANN , · A . G . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Praktikum der Gesteinsanalyse . - 204 pp . Springer; Berlin Heidelberg New York. KENT , P . E . (. 1 9 3 6 ) : The formation of the hydraulic l imestones in the Lower Lias . -Geo l . Mag. 7 3 : 4 76 - 4 7 8 . KREBS , w . ( 1 9 62 ) : Das Oberdevon der Prllmer Mulde/Eifel· unter Aus schluB der Dolomit-Fazies . - Notizbl . hess . L . -Amt Bodenforsch . 9 0 : 2 1 0- 2 3 2 . LAND, L . S . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Diagenesis of skeletal carbOnates . - J . -Sed . Pe trol . 3 7 : 9 1 4 -9 30 . MAJEWSKE , O . P . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Recognition of invertebrate fossil frag nents in rocks and thin sections . - 2nd edn . 1 0 1 p p . E . S . Bri l l ; Leiden. MEISCHNER, K . D . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Allodapische Ka�ke , Turbidite in riff-na hen Sedimentations-Becken . - Developm. Sedimentol . 3 : 1 56 - 1 9 1 . MEISCHNE R, D . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Pal&Okologische Untersuchungen an gebankten Kalken . Ein . Diskussions-Beitrag . -Geo l . FOren. Stockholm FOrh. 89 : 4 6 5 -4 6 9 . MILLIMAN , J . p . ( 1 9 74 ) : Marine carbonates . -3 7 5 pp . Springer; Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. NEUGEBAUER, J . ( 1' 9 74 ) : Some aspects of cementation in chalk ,.. Spec. Publs . int . Ass . Sediment . 1 : 1 49 - 1 7 6 . OLDERSHAW , A . E . & SCOFFI N , T . P . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : The source o f ferroan and non-ferroan calcite cements in the Halkin and Wenlock l imesto nes . - Geol . J . . 5 : 309-320. PRAY , L . C. & CHOQUETTE , P. W . ( 1 96 6 ) : Genesis of carbonate reservoir facies . - Am .' Assoc . Petroleum Geologists , Bul l . 5 0 : 6 3 2 . RAD , u . von ( 1 9 79 ) : SiO � -Diagenese in .Tiefseesedimenten . - Geol . Rdsch. 6 8 : 1 02 5- 1 036 . ROBERTSON , A . H . F . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : The origin and diagenesis of cherts from Cyprus . - Sedimentology 2 4 : 1 1 -3 0 . ·
SCHWARZACHER, w . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : An application of statistical time-series analysis of a l imestone-shale s equenc e . - J . Geo l . 7 2 : 1 9 5 -2 1 3 . SEILACHER , A . & MEISCHNER, D . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Fazies-Analyse iffi Palaozoikum des Oslo-Gebietes . - Geol . Rdsch . 5 4 : 5 9 6 -6 1 9 . TRURNIT , P . & AMSTUTZ , G . L . ( 1 9 79 ) : Die Bedeutung des Rlickstandes von Druck-LOsungsvorgangen flir stratigraphische Abfolgen, Wech sellagerung und Lagerstattenbildung . - Geo l . Rdsch . 6 8 : 1 1 1 7- 1 1 24 WIS E , s . w . & WEAVER, F . M . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Chertification o f oceanic sedi ments . - Spec. Publs . int . Ass . Sediment . 1 : 30 1 -3 2 6 .
.·
Deep-Sea Stratigraphy: Cenozoic Climate Steps and the Search for ChemocClimatic Feedback W. H. BERGER
Abstract : Results of paleoceanographic studies on cores recovered by Glomar Challenger suggest that the evolution of ocean circu1ati.on and climate is not gradual but is punctuated by periods of rapi.d change, or " steps " . These events may or may not be associated with the classical stratigraphic boundarie s , some apparently ar.e . There appear to be two extreme types of events : { 1 ) those which represent accelerations of a given trend, depending on positive feed back from hydrosphere and perhaps carbon sphere and ( 2 ) those which are independent of a trend and depend entirely on outsi.de forcing. Steps opposing the overall trend, but following on-trend steps , also exist. They are interpreted a s rebound events . The step-like transitions from one geochemical�climatologic setting to another are important as natural experiment s , · for the s tudy of response characteristics of the system, and for global high resolu tion s tratigraphy . Il nous restait ensuite a nous assurer' positivement si ces d:Lff€.rents terrains, ces diff6rents 6tage s , si tranch6s sur le sol de la Franc e , etaient l e r€.sultat des c:Lrconstances locale s , sp€.ci.ales a notre sol , ou s ' ils d€.pendaient de faits g€.n6raux qui se seraient produits sur tous les points du globe a la fois. , M . A . d ' Orbigny ( 1 8 5 1 )
1
•
In traduction
The question of whether or not there were times of rapid c limati.c change on a global scale can realistically be answered only by study ing continuous sequences in the deep · sea . We now have a reasonably complete (but by no means perfect) record of Tertiary ocean climate . Were there sudden changes? What can they teach us about the ocean atmosphere system in geologic time? The first question can now be answered in the affirmative; an updated list of events is given in Table 1 . The second question provides an opportunity for much speculation , because analysis of c l imate events in deep-sea stratigraphy is entirely in its infancy . The events usually considered include sudden large-scale increases in terrige nous component s , changes in sedimentation rates , hiatus development or cessation , drastic drops or rises of the carbonate compensation Cyclic and Event Stratification {ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
122 depth , and large changes in the proportion of organic matter (see .. reviews by Arthur, 1 9 7 9 and by Berger1 1 9 7 9 , 1 9 8 1 a ) .
, ·
Table 1 . Examples of fast c l imatic transitions in the Cenozoic ( for data sources see Arthur , 1 97 9 ;' Berger et a). . , 1 9 8 1 i Haq, 1981 ) ( 1 ) Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary Event ( rv 6 5 m. y . ) . Large-scale extinction of oceanic plankton and othe:t:' organism groups . Large c:l'imatic fluctuations probable. { 2 ) Paleocene-Eocene boundary ewent. Short l ived peak warmi:ng· . Expansion of tropical faunas and ( 3 ) Earl,.y-to-mid-Eocene cooling steps . Shift of climate zones toward equator . Cooling of deep water. Chert formation . ( 4 ) Eocene Termination Event ( tV 3 8 m . y . ) . Cooling in · high and low latitudes , expansion of polar highs ._ Significant changes in deep-sea benthic fauri.a . Rapi.d drop ot the carbonate compensation deP th . ( 5 ) Mid-to-Late Oligocene Oxyg-en Shift ( ? ) ( rv 30 m . y . ) . F· irst occurrence of rather heavy oxygen isotope values in deep sea benthic foramini fera , presumably due to polar bottom water formation. ( 6 ) Mid-Miocene " Oxygen Shi ft" ( .rv 1 5 m . y . ) . Oxygen isotope ratios shift to heavier value s , presumably due to Antarctic ice buildup. ( 7 ) 6-mil l i on-year 11Carbon Shift " . Isotope ratios o f the ocean ' s carbon shift to li.ghter values 1 presumably due to organic carbon input from regressi.on and pco -change ( ? ) . 2 ( 8 ) Messinian "Salinity Cri.s i s " ( rv 5 . 5 m . y . ) . Isolation of Mediterranean through regression, strong cooling. ( 9 ) 3-mill ion-year Event. Onset of Pleistocene-type climatic fluctuations . ( 1 0) 1 -mill ion-year Event . Onset of large climati·c fluctuations after peri.od of quiescence. ( 1 1 ) 11Terminations'1 of the late Pleistocene ( last 0 . 8 m . y . ) . Rapid deglaciations , warming of mid-latitudes . pco change . 2
In the short time since the evidence for climatic-related steps has been e;x:tracted from Tertiary sequences in the deep sea · (Berggren, 1 9 7 2 ; Kaneps , 1 9 73 ; van Andel and Moore , 1 9 7 4 ; Benson , t 9 7 5 ; Savin et al . , 1 9 7 5 ; Shackleton and Kennett, 1 97 5 ; Kennett and Shackleton, 1 9 7 6 ) a tradition has alrea�y developed which leans heavily on pre sumed changes in ocean circulation produced by continental drift and
123
sea floor spreading to explain the timing of events and their sedi men tologic manifestation (Berggren and Hollister, 1 9 7 4 , 1 9 7 7 ; Berger and Roth , 1 9 7 5 ; Kennett , 1 9 7 7 ; McGowran, 1 9 7 8 i Thie�stein an� Be�ge�, 1 9 7 8 � Arthur and Nat!Land , 1 9 79 ; Talwan.i. et a l .
1
1 9 7..9) .
There are good reasons for ascribing basinwide sy:n.cl:u::onous facies changes t6 changes in ocean circulation. Surface ci.:r:culati.on. domi nates biogeography and productivity patterns , and deep cix:cul.a tion ' govern s · chemical and mechanical, erosion and .redeposition processe s . Thf.' echange o f water masses betw$en ocean basins i s a cruci.ai factor in de �ermining the ultimate resting place of chemical deposi'ts , that
is, carbonate and s ilica . Changing opportunities for basin�basin ex� change result from the re·arrangement of geography by plate tecton ic s . Thus , the opening and closing of the gatew.ays o f circulation must profoundly influence facies patterns . Even more to the point, in the context of climatic change, ocean currents are involved in largescale heat transport . Hence a change of geography allowing {or forcing) increased poleward transport of tropical water masses ( or increased sinking of polar waters) should have important effects on the planet ' s temperature and precipitation patterns . The disappearance of the
Tethyan seaway , the or � gin of the Gulf Stream, and the evolution of the C ircumpolar Current are recurrent themes in such discussions . The approach l_eads_ to a search for critical gateways and barriers affecting surficial and deep circulation. As a rule, this type of event analysis leads to a reasonably exact statement about the strati graphic position
6£
a climate-related event , an assertion about con
temporaneity with a poorly dated geophysical-geographic event, and speculative suggestions about how the one was a result of the other -. Here I shall take a di fferent approach to the treatment of events. I shall argue , in essence , that many of the observed steps are produced by internal feedback , notably albedo feedback , and that they do not in principle depend on minor rearrangements of geography. Also, I draw attention to the intimate involvement of the carbon cycle in climate c5 1 3c
steps as manifested in changes in carbonate deposition and in
composition of foraminiferal shells . It appears unavoidable to me that ' such involvement must result in change s in the atmospheric co content. 2 The present essay summar izes facts and concepts put forward earlier (Berger, 1 9 7 7 ; Thierstein and Berger , 1 97 8 ; Vincent et a l . , 1 98 0 ;
�erger and Vincent, 1 9 8 1 ; Berger e t a l . , 1 98 1 ) , and further develops some of these concepts especially with regard to carbon feedback and to the implications of the c5 1 3c signal in foram stratigraphy.
124
Just also albedo gOverns how much of the sun ' s radiation is by the earth ' s surface , the co 2 helps determine at vh�t te�pe��tu he the energy is to be reradiated . We have , then , an interpl..Y bet�eep, the hydrosphere cycle an.d the ca.rbon shere cycle , an interplay that opens the possibility for re inforcement or cancellati.on of the two cycles in the course of climatic change . Phase shifts in the res�on� ses of the cycles could conceivably produce osci llati.o ns . A;f·ter a summary of the postulates needed to discuss the issues , I. shali present the evidence for climate steps in the deep sea , a.nd then attempt to extract those features which are common of steps. 2 . Basic Propositions on Climate Steps and on Feedback 2 . 1 . What Are Climate steps? A c limate step is a short period of transition of the ocean-atmosphe re system from one state to another. The d i fference of the states is commonly expressed i n terms of " cooling" o r "warming " . However , it be of a more subtle nature , such as a change from more stable to · stable climate. The requirement that there are two sets of variables ( "before" and "after" ) and a " short" transition, concept " c l imate step" as a statistical property of · a time- series . the number of such steps, in essence , depends on one 1 s criterion for creating subsets - from a set of climate-related variables and on the criterion for " short" . Some steps in Cenozoic deep-sea sediments are large enough so that no statistic-s are required to note them: these "major" steps are the ones here considered. The evidence for their existence is based on oxygen isotopes in the shells of planktonic and benthic foraminifera ( Figure 1 ) . 2 . 2 . Why " Steps " The term " step" is taken from the systems analysis concept " step function " . Step function analysis considers the · response of a -system to an instantaneous change in the ''input signal " . A conmi.on example in electrical engineering is a sudden change in voltage at the in-
put of an electric control system which pro� uces a change at the out put: the respons e . Such systems adjust their output by comparing it with the input signal and operating o n the difference ( = error ) .
Hence, they are characterized by " feedback " , that i s , information from the output signal helps control future Output. Feedback is "positive"
125
-2
'
CD 0 a.
0
"'
to
1\
DOUGLAS, SAVIN,
IIIll
1975, 1977
� =����� �� =��
PLANKTONIC FORAMS
- BENTHIC FORAMS SHACKLETON, KENNE TT, O
1975
AMS
R
0
20
40
60 m.y.b.p.
Fig. 1 . Oxygen isotope trends in Cenoz.oi.c foraminifera frox:n Pacifi.c deep-sea sediments . Data of Douglas and. Savin refer to cen tral Pacific (Douglas and Savin, 1 9 7 5 ; for Douglas and Savin , 1 9 7 7 see Douglas and Woodruff , 1 9 8 1 ) . Data of· Shackleton. and Kennett ( 1 9 7 5 ) refer to region south of E . Australi.a and New Zealand. Major steps are marked by arrows
when it i s in phase with the error, magnifying i t . I t is �'negative" if it is in opposing pha-s e , reducing the error. Positive feedback leads to instab i l ity , negative feedback stabilizes a system. The response to a step function describes the efficiency of a feed back system. A highly sensitive system responds very � apidly, thanks to lack of damping. However , such a system tends to go wel l beyond the new equil ibrium state and large overshoot is typical . As the overshoot builds up, the discrepancy between input signal and output signal rises and the feedback acts i n reverse . Again the system goes beyond the equilibrium point: i t oscillates. There are several ice age theories which make use of this property of systems with weak damping. Their s�ccess has been limited because they failed to account for the need of outside stimulation if the
126
oscillations are to C ontinue. This need has been fil led by the kovich mechanism {Hays et al . , 1 9 7 6 ; Pisias , 1 9 7 6 ; Imbrie and Imb �ie, 1 980) . As yet the typical time constant of the Pleis t'ocene climate system, its resonance peak, has not been found (or looked for in a systema·tic fashion) . Perhaps no such thing exists. With sufficient damping, overshoot -and hence osci llations- can be eliminated . A strongly damped system responds more slowly to a change in input, and reaches the new equilibrium after a much longer time . There seem to be , in the cOurse of the Cenozoic , times with strongly damped cl imate systems and · times with weak damping, characterized by large and frequent fluctuations . On the whole, instability appears to increase until it reaches its climax in the Pleistocene . The abundance of climate steps also increases. We have one step every 1 00 , 000 years or so for the last million years : the glacial-post glacial transitions known as " terminations" (Broecker and van Donk , 1 9 70) . I think it is unlikely that the terminations reflect strong damping, and I would , therefore, expect evidence for overshoot and oscillation. The fact that a very warm period (the AllerOd) was followed by a very cold one (Younger Dryas') near the end of the last termination supports the overshoot hypothesis (Berger, 1 98 1 b) . The resonance period, under this assumption, would be near 2000 years.
2 . 3 . Why S·tudy Climate Steps? A resonance period of 2000 years , if correct , would seem to hold little promise of being detected i_n older parts of the Cenozoic, un less extremely detailed studies are performed in various segments of the record . Neverthe l e s s , step analysis is very worthwhile because { 1 ) Times of rapid c limatic change are likely to be dominated by one or two causal factors whose influence may be obscured at other time s , when a multitude of .f actors has control . ( 2 ) If there is no clearly identifiable external cause forcing the change , one must then suspect the action of strong internal positive feedback , which needs to be identified; ( 3 ) the maximum rate of climat i c change . yields informa tion on damping, a most interesting property of the system; ( 4 ) a comparison of "before" and "after" should be very instructive the increase or decrease in stability ( " stabilizing11 versus "destabilizing" events ) . Last but not least , the record of
127 climate steps may produce an excellent means · f � r basin-shelf corre lation : it has done so a lready for basin-basin correlation (Haq et a l . , 1 980) . 2 . 4 . Albedo Feedback The c l imate machine is driven by the sun ' s energy . _ Of the radiation reaching the earth , a portion i s refl�cted into space before it can heat the surface: this i s the albedo. The planetary a lbedo is the
pJ:oportion of. radiat_ion refl � cted as measured from space. It is near 2 8 % overall and depends greatly on atmospheric conditions
regionally, especially on cloud cover. The surface albedo is the proportion of incident radiation reflected from ground or water sur face . It varies with the sun ' s angle. Surface albedo values for clear sky and high noon are listed in Table 2 . Table 2 .
Albedo-values o f ocean , and land surface s . (Reflectivity in percent o f incident light, during noon) ( Source: comp ilation of Humme l and Reck , 1 9 7 8 )
Annual global average :
Q£�gg
low latitudes : mid lat itudes : high latitudes:
Land
1 4 ( planetary albedo: 2 8 ) 4 to 7 4 to 1 9 6 to 50
min .
( surmne r ) :
6
max .
(winter) :
55
desert:
2 0 t o 30
grasslands, coni ferous & deciduous forests: wetlands :
15
10 tropical rain forests: 7 snow-covered land: 3 5 to 82
�rr��££��£-�2rr��rr�rr��1_f��-��E
pack ice in water:
as
40 to 5 5
The well-known features o f surface albedo distributions are readily seen : { 1 ) a dark ocean, especially in low latitudes where it is less ' fertile on the whole and , therefore , clear; ( 2 ) a great range of land
128
values , from dark foi'ests and wetlands to light deserts and bright snow fields; ( 3 ) the enormous contrast between ice and snow on the one hand and water surface on the other. Replacing water surface with snow fields , or vice v.e rsa , provides the greatest possible change in albedo. on the whole, the c limate history of the Cenozoic is marked by regression and ice buildup. Henc e , albedo has increased promoting cooling. The buildup of ice and snow was favored by the poleward movement of land masses ( Donn and Shaw, 1 97 7 ) and the thermal isolation o f Antarctica and the Arctic Ocean. Albedo changes contain positive feedback : cooling promotes snow cover , which increases albedo, and vice versa. There i s , however, also nega ·tive feedback: cooling decreases moisture in the air, hence cloud 9over, and hence planetary a lbedo decreases . Which of the effects will dominate presumably depends on the initial state: once snow and ice cover considerable areas , positive feedback must gain greatly in importance. The fol lowing feedback mechanisms apply:
( 1 } Warming
�
ice and snow cover reduction � a lbedo decreases
f'Urther warming ( 2 ) \Varming -7 ice mass reduction decreases � further warming
-7
sea level rises
-7
�
albedo
( 3 ) Warming � humidity rises � forest growth � albedo decrea ses � further warming ( 4 ) "(.�!arming --7 wirids decrease � upwelling decreases -7 albedo decreases � further warming Cooling engenders these steps in reverse . However, it must be kept in mind that when the sea level drop reaches the shelf edge there is much less feedback of type ( 2 ) . Cenozoic climate history is marked by an increase in the feedback mechanism ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) . The interaction of ice masses and sea level are crucial: the ice masses constitute large reservoirs of instability as it were. In this view, the onset of Pleistocene f luctuations is a matter of critical ice mass. 2 . 5 . Carbon Feedback The major climate steps are associated with changes in the carbon cycle. Both o 1 3 c signals and preservation-of-carbonate signals in dicate that this is so (Berger, 1 9 7 7 ; Shackleton, 1 9 7 7 ; Scholle and
129
Arthur, 1 98 0 ; Vincent et a l . ( 1_9 80) . Perhaps the most rema:r.-kab!Le phenomenon in this respect is the preservation spike wl1ich is. in variably associated with late Plei.stocene deglaciation steps (Berger and Vincent , 1 98 1 ) . we must now ask whether the role cf· the C?,;t:bop, cycle is entirely passive_ , or whethe;r i.t contributes to posi.ti.ve a:pd_ negative feedback surrounding climate steps. The idea that climatic variations are influenced by the a.tmospheri.c carbon dioxide content through the " greenhouse effect" is ove:r a
h,undred years old; it is associated with the writings of· J . Tynda;LJ..r
s . Arrhenius , and T . C . Chamberlin . Early in the century i.t exci.te<:;l considerable discussion ( see Dacque , 1 9 1 5 , p . 4 5 6 f f ) . Subsequep.tly
it fell into disfavor with _ many- textbook writers ( e . g . Wright, 1 93 7 ) but was then revived in connection with the present bui.!Ld.up o f co 2 in the atmosphere, from the burning of· fossil fuel ( P lass , 1 9 5 6 ) . Recent- calculations (see e . 9 . Hansen et aL , 1' 9 8 1' ) suggest that a doubling of the pco 2 will raise the average global surface tempera ° ture by about 2 C . Direct evidence for past changes in pco 2 now exi.st from the analysis of ice· cores (Berner et a l . , Delmas et al . 1 1' 980) . Such calculations , then , are indeed pertinent to the interpretation
of climate history. The deep-sea record shows that the intensity of volcanism cha.nged 1 through Cenozoic h i'story (Kennett and Thunell, 1 9 7 5 i Kari.g, 1: 9 7 5 ) a,nd so, presumably, did the supply of co 2 . Likewise, the intensity of weathering changed , as seen in deep ocean sedimentation rates (pavi.es et a l . , 1 9 7 7 ; Wotsley and Davi.e s , 1:979) 1 and thus the rate of· uptake
of co2 in the weathering process mus·t have changed. Fina1J.y 1 the accu mulation rate for organic carbon i.s not constant (Thi.erstei n, T 9 7 9 ) , implying that this maj or sink for co 2 varies .in eff'icien.cy·. F luctua.tions in the phosphorus cycle (Arthur and Jenkyns, 1 98 1' ) through i.ts in
fluence on the carbon cycle may be at least partly responsible (Broek ker, 1 9 7 3 ) . As concerns climate steps1 the possibility- of rapid additi.on of co 2 to the atmospher e , or extraction from i t , is of interest. The various carbon reservoirs which are in intimate contact with the atmosphere are listed in Table 3 . These reservoirs can change siz.e quickly enough to affect the pco 2 of the atmosphere on the time scale here considered. Several of these reservoirs are considerably greater than that ot: the atmosphere. Of central importance is the partitioning of the co 2 bet ween ocean and atmosphere . Obviously1 relatively small changes in this
130
5 Table 3 . Carbon reservoirs active on a 1 0 year scale {ACM pheric carbon mass ) . For data sources see Scholle and Arthur ( 1 980) and Vincent et al . ( 1 9 80) .
=
atmos
_Reservoir 6
Atmospheric co 2 Dissolved c in ocean (mainly HC03 l
350
58
0
1 00 5 50
1. 7 1 8
+ 1 ° /oo
·Accessible Organic Carbon Biosphere ( forests) Soil carbon ( 11humus " ) , peat, etc. Seafloor stirred layers
8 20 6
1 3 1
Stream flux, all carbon (per thousand years)
10
2
Accessible Carbonate Deep sea ( upper meter) Shelf (upper meter) Land ( 1 0 5 years ' leaching)
Volcanic co input (per thousand 2 years)
0. 5 - 2
- 25 °/oo
0. 2
partitioning and in the fluxes between the active carbon reservoirs can . Potentially have large effects on the atmospheric pco 2 . A cursory overview of potential feedback mechanisms in the carbon sphe re suggests a striking symmetry between carbonate and organi.c carbon (Table 4 ) . The processes which produce positive feedback in the carbo nate cycle, produce negati.ve feedback in the organic cycle, and vice versa. For example , when sea level rises , shelf carbonate i.s precipi _ tated which releases co 2 to the atmosphere , but also organi.c carbon accumulates - tying up co 2 . It is not clear to me which ef';E"ect wUJ., be stronger at any given time during a transgression. Presu�abl,y- the balance depends on the width of the tropical belt, the �orpho�ogy of the shelf, and the availabi-lity of· nutrients. Nutrient supp;Ly has opposing effects on carb
131
Table 4 .
Feedback mechanisms of the carbon sphere
Bas � c principle: pC?2 � n the atmosphere is linked to the . of reradJ..at1.on of energy to space, in the infra effJ..cJ..ency red spectrum. High pco 2 obstructs reradiation, hence atmos pheric temperature rises ( 11greenhouse " effect) .
Positive feedback Carbonate Sea level rise - shelf carbonate precipitation - CO release . warming - co 2 release - warming - further sea leve l rise ( i f ice present ) . Also: reduced co uptake by decreased land surface 2 in warm, humid climate) . { bu t : chemical weathering favored Sea level fal l : reverse of rise, but precipitation of deep-sea carbonates can proceed to balance shelf carbonate dissolution. Physical principle s : . lag of deep-sea carbonate dissolution behind shelf precipitation (not valid in reverse) , co 2 less soluble ln warm water than in cold, exposed land surface neutrallzes co 2 while submerged surface does not. Carbon
---
Sea level rise - decrease of erosion - fewer nutrients to sea reduction of fertility - less Cor produced - less uptake of co ? from atmosphere � warming _ �urther sea level rise ( i f ice present ) . Sea level fal l : reverse of rise . Physical principle: effect of ocean fertility on pCO ? ' through
photosynthetic carbon fixation.
Negative feedback Carbonate Sea level rise - decrease of erosion - fewer nutrients to sea decre-ase of carbonate precipitation - less co 2 released - cooling effect. Sea level fal l : reverse of rise, but effect may be more pronounced, since onset of new erosion can produce a nutrient spike. Physical principle: effect of ocean fertility on pco 2 , through rate of deep-sea carbonate accumulation. Carbon Sea level rise - drowned estuaries, marshes, lagoons collect orga nic-rich sediments - co 2 extracted from atmosphere - cooling. Also: increased precipitation on land (more sea surface, warming from albedo effect) builds up biosphere and associated " humus " , peat, etc . Sea level fal l : reverse of rise, but previously accumulated organic carbon is very accessible, hence onset of erosion can produce a carbon spike .
132
Table 4 {continued) Physical principle: effect of sea level change on forming or exposing traps of organic-rich sediments, and on precipitation patterns , influencing bio- and soil-carbon size . In addition to the overall tendency of carbOn and carbonate feedback mechansims to balance within _each cycle and between cycles, there also is a tendency for direct cancellation: release of co 2 , from organic carbon pools , is neutralized by dissolution of carbonate , and take-up of co 2 is similarly neutralized by carbonate precipita tion.
On the whole, the carbon sphere system lacks a simple and strong positive feedback mechanism of the albedo type. We should , there fore, see much less short-term high amplititude climatic variation in a world without ice. Nevertheles s , the buildup and subsequent
erosion of readily accessible reservoirs of organic carbon , and of nutrients, may provide opportunities for large-scale step changes
even in the Mesozoic .
2 . 6 . On Reading Proxy Signals In what follows we shall look more closely at oxygen istope and carbon isotope _records. The correct reading of these types of curves
is still a matter of research and discussion. The main points may be
briefly summarized as follows ( see also chapter on stable isotopes in
Lipps et a l . , 1 9 7 9 ) . Concerning oxygen isotopes, a change in the signal may indicate: ( 1 ) a rise or a drop in temperature, 4 to 5 ° c for 1 ° /oo chang e ; ( 2 ) a decrease or increase in the mass of conti 16 nental .ice (which enriches or depletes the ocean in o , the preferred
isotope in ice) ; · ( 3 ) a regional change in the composition of seawater,
due t'o changes in evaporation-precipitation pattern s. Lesser effects (vita l , seasonal , dissolution-related) also exist.
The choice of the effect or combination of effects to be credited with a change in oxygen is-otope values is generally qu�te arbitrary. Thus, the temperature scales given with or 1 80 records are not necessarily informative. I have left them off .
Concerning carbon isotopes , a change in the signal may indicate: ( 1 ) a rise or a fall in the degree to which 1 3 c is enriched in sur face waters with respect to deep waters , such enrichment being a function of both fertility and intensity of stratification; ( 2 ) a
133
change in the input or output ratios of carbonate a.n..d carb0n, to or from the . ocean-atmosphere system: such change wi_:u a.ffect the ratiO because of the low 0 1 3 c values of' organic carb0p_ (Table
regional change in the compos ition of
Hco;
1 3 c;1 2c 3) ; a
of deep waters , due to
changes in deep circulation.: old waters are enriched in 1 2c . Lesser effects {vital, seasonal, dissolution-related) also exi.s t, and. voi
canism also can inflUence
61 3c .
Related signals of the carbon cycle are carbonate preservation and
organic carbon preservation. A change in carbonate preservation. w.ay ' indicate one or more of these: ( 1 ) a change in the producti.vity of
the ocean ( increase in fertility decreases saturation} , ( 2 ) a change in the overall supply of calcium-carbonate to the deep ocean (bui.;I..d_
up or erosion of shelf carbonate , ridge crest volcanism) ,
(3)
regio
nal change from altered deep ci-rculation (within and between basin fractionation ) . Other effects also exist {Berger, t 9 'Z ? ) . The preser
vation of organic ca �bon in deep-sea sediments is a matter ot carbon and nutrient supply , of availability of calcium and magnesi.urn, and of oxygenation of the deep sea . The balance between eupelagi.c and hemi pelagic sedimentation is probably very important both for carbon. and carbonate signals in deep-sea sediments , as it is f.or silica depo
sition.
3.
Major Steps : the Evidence
3. 1 .
Abundance of Steps
As pointed out above , the abundance of c limate steps is a function
both of the variability of' the c limate and of the ( arbi.trary) stati.s
tical cut-off for "unusual " contrast between c limatic regimes follow ing one another. Traditionally , changes in fossil abundances , and changes in stable isOtope composition have been used to i.den.ti.fy periods of rapid change in the deep-sea record. On the whole, the abundance of events appears to increase throughout the Cenoz.oic
(Figure 1 ) . The probable reason has been mentioned : a general trend of increasing importance of albedo feedback and of ice-mass buildup in the Cenozoic . Only the major st.eps are considered here, obviating the n.eed for statistics to extract them from the available information.
134
3 . 2 . Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary The most signi ficant information on the Cret a.ceous-Tertiary boundary event has been provided by the pelagic record . It concerns the whole sale extinction of oceanic plankton within a few thousand years combined with an absence of extinctions in the deep benthonic realm. Se.veral papers on this topic were published in Rosenkrantz and
Brotzen (editors , 1 960 ) , by J . P . Beckmann , H . M . Bolli and M . B . Cita , and W . A . Berggren . Subsequently Luterb.acher and Silva ( 1 96 4 ) , in the Gubbio section, established the Globigerina eugubina Zone, which became the criterion for comple teness of the record . The deep-sea record fully supports the earlier suggestions of planktonic ex
tinctions including pelagic coccolithophores (Bramlette , 1 96 5 ; see
Thierstein and Okada , 1 9 79 } . Also it allows an estimate for the time it took to replace Cretaceous faunas and floras with Tertiary ones, in the pelagi'c realm. It is a matter of a few thousand year s , at
most (Thierstein, 1 980) . The debate about the end-of-Cretaceous ex tinctions is in full swing (Christensen and Birkelund, 1 97 9 ; Rus sel l , 1 97 9 ) ; the arguments for a n extraterrestrial cause seem t o hold sway
at this time (Alvarez et a l . , 1 980; Emiliani , 1 980; HsU , 1 980; Smit and Hertogen, 1 9 80) � - The evidence . for the catastrophic impact of an extraterrestrial body lies almost exclusively with the discovery of
high iridium values within the K-T boundary . . The geochemistry of iridium, however, is poorly understood . Recently, sanid�ne spherules have been proposed as additional evidence (Smit and Klaver, 1 98 1 ) . There is now little doubt that the event was both catastrophic and
independent of a trend , so that gradualist explanations (Bramlette , 1 9 6 5 ) become rather unattractive. Whether the K-T boundary event teaches us anything about the climatic workings of the ocean-atmosphe re system is as yet a moot question . As things stand, it i.s a re
minder that Earth (and life on i t ) are subject to cosmic bombardment (Urey, 1 -97 3 ) , and it provides an outstandi.ng example for plankton radiation.
3 . 3 . Tertiary Trends The climate events within the Tertiary appear most cle�rly as steps in the oxygen isotope record , although other signals also show them .
Such signals are found in various sediment properties : carbonate con tent and related preservation of calcareous fossils, silica content, clay mineral composition, hiatus abundance , organic matter content,
and carbon i sotopes within calcareous shells (see Arthur , 1 97 9 ) .
135
The available isotope data, largely produced by Douglas and Sa�in ( 1 97 5 ) and by Shackleton and, Kenn.ett ( 1 9 7 5 ) , show the well-known. fact that the Cenoz.oic on the whole i.s marked by a cooling tre-nd
(Figure 1 ) . It is not always appreciated that this cooling trend is chiefly a high-latitude phenomenon. The tropi.cs are not a;f';fected
very much . Immediately, this discrepancy suggests a clue to the trend: It is something that happens in high latitudes only. The most likely cause whi.ch offers itself i.s that the land areas in hi.gh latitudes
cover themselves with snow and ice, reflecting much of the incoming sUnlight. An overall regression provides more land areas (which by
itsel� increases albedo ) 1 and continental drift leads to therma.l isolation of the Arctic Ocean. and the Antarctic Continent, favoring
buildup of snow (Donn and Shaw, l 9 77 ) .
The trend has steps : the threshold events . It appears that these steps essentially reflect the phase transitions from water to i.ce t on va_ rious parts of the globe .
The importance of sea level in modulating the temperature evolution on the planet - and hence the e f· fect of Cenoz:oi.c regression on the overal l cooling trend · - has been variously demonstrated in a compa rison of sea level changes and - the stratigraphy o f· stable is-otopes and CCD-level fluctuations ( see Berger , 1 9 77. ; Fi.scher a.nd A..r thur, 1 97 7 ; van Andel et al . , 1 97 7 ) . lilhen. one considers the anornali.es of
the shaded trend shown in Figure 1 , they clearly tend. to parallel
the sea level variation s , indicating that transgressions result in a warming of the ocean and an expansion of the tropical belt (Berger,
1 97 7 ) . The low stand of s.ea level in the Oligocene and the concurrent cooling of the planetary surface is especially noteworthy . I believe that this is largely an effect of the increased planetary albedo due to increased exposu"re of ( light) land at the expense of (dark) ocean. Cool tropics in the Oli.gocene also would have favored drought, · further
increasing albedo on land (and incidentally accounting for the low Oligocene sedimentation rate s : see Davies et al . , 1 97 7 ) . 3 . 4 . Early Eocene Eyents
The first distinct steps visible in Figure 1 are in the early Eocene . They are remarkably large , almost 1 ° /oo each. By the es tablLshed rules (Section 2 . 6 ) the steps describe drops in temperature or in-
136
creases in salinity 'in the region south of New Z:ealand, or else i.ce buildup on Antarctica. At the time when the site (DSDP Si.te 2 77J re corded the change it was some 1'5° furth,Qr south than now. I.t a.lso was shallower. The diagram shows that these steps mark the begi.nnin_g of a divergence of oxygen isotope values for high southern regions from those for central regions of the Paci.fic . I'n f·act , the overlap of the values i n the early Eocene i s surprising. A temperature gradi.ent must have existed from subtropics to subpolar z:ones . Thus, the hi.gh-iati.tucle values are 11too low" when interpreted in terms of temperature alone .. They must reflect excess precipitation of 1 6o-rich rain : The bi.ght between Tasmania and Campbell Plateau (Antarctica and Australia being close together) must have been, on the whole, an estuari..n e ba.sin wi.th salinity strati.fi.cation, situated in a rain belt� If the rain · belt hypothesis i.s accept.ed, we can. then unQ.ers.tand either step, or both , as an event establishing more nearly normal salinity. Since Australia separated f-rom Antarctica at about this time , an increase in the inf-lux of water from the I.ndi.an Ocean. could be invoked That such an ad hoc gateway �xplanation i.s not the whole story is suggested by the evidence for large climatic excursions near the Paleocene-Eocene boundary and in the middle Eocene , in the North Atlantic (Haq et al . , 1 977 ) . Haq ( 1 98 1 ) cites ev'idence that ·the latest Paleocene-early Eocene represents the warmest period of the entire Cenozoic in the mari,fle realm. Thus , the steps would seem to represent cooling events which lead from thi.s warm peak to more " nor mal 11 Cenozoic conditions . .•
The cooling and the rain belt mechanisms are not mutually exclusive. On the contrary: the high temperatures in subpolar regions require large-scale heat import . Transport of moisture from low to high lati tudes i.s the most efficient of the heat transfer mechanisms. Cooling and an equatorward movement of a hi_g h-latitude rain belt are compa tible with the data. The fact that there are steps, presumably, in� dicates positive feedback from albedo changes on Antarctica from . drought or snow. 'Large excursions in the 6 1 3c signals are associated with these steps (see Shackleton and Kennett , 1 975, Fig. 4 ) . J?os.t-step time (mid- to late Eocene) is characterized by increasing di£ferences 1 in 6 3c values of planktoni.c and benthic forams . A likely interpre tation is lowered fertility due to an increase in thermocli_pe develop ment: another clue to cooling as the step-producing factor.
137
The second of the two events , which may be called the " 50 m . y . step " , marks _ a change in high latitude land floras (Kemp, 1 97 8 i Wolfe, 1 9 7 8 ) and the end of a majOr episode of laterization of Gondwana land frag ments (according to McGowran, 1 9 7 8 ) . In the deep sea, chert deposits are common within this period of change . One possible explanation: laterization produced free silica {Leclaire, 1 9 74 ) , which was partly stored in shelf seas where nutrients were trapped . The development of a thermocline produced silica-poor surface water (j ust as it produced 13 e-rich surface waters) and the recently trapped s i l ica could thus be leached off the shelves and transported to the deep sea . Upwel ling areap were as yet poorly developed : thus there were no highly locali zed sinks for s i l ica, but the deposits were spread out. Alternative hypotheses are considered by Steinberg ( 1 9 8 1 ) . •
.
3 . 5 . End o f Eocene The next large step occurs near the Eocene-Oligocene boundary (Figure 1 ) . Tt · markedly .incr.e ases the d i fference in 61 8 o values between low and high latitudes - the planetary temperature gradient sharpens sud denly. The simplest explanation for this step is that the deep ocean started to fill up with cold water produced in high latitudes (Savin 1 975' ; Kennett and Shackleton , 1 9 7 6 ) . The supporting evidence � � _ that this is so comes from benthi.c ostracods (Benson, 1 9 7 5 ) and also from benthic foraminifera (Dougla s , 1 97 3 ; Keigwin, 1 9 80) . However, the change of benthic foraminifera across the boundary is rather more ° gradual than what one might expec.t if the temperature drop from 1 0 C ° to 5 C postulated by Kennett and · Shackleton ( 1 9 7 6 ) is real (see Cor l i s s , 1 97 9 ) . A change in fauna does take 'place, but it apparently takes millions of years rather than a hundred thousand. The change proceeds from abyssal depths upward (Douglas and Woodruf f , 1 98 1 ) , in dicating new and growing influx of heavy abyssal water. Of course, we need not accept the suggestion of a 5 °C drop in tempe •. ,
I
I
I
•
rature . It is only the first of several possibilities: ( 1 ) a strong cooling of Antarcti.c coastal waters resulted in_ density increase, sinking and production of cOld bottom waters ; ( 2 ) alternatively or in add ition, cold bottom water could have been produced in a newly acces sible Arctic Ocean· ('Thi.e rstein and Berger, 1 9 7 8 ) ; ( 3 ) salinity (and therefore 1 8 o content) of the deep water could have increased , by moving a rainbelt off the Antarctic coast toward the tropics ( see Kemp, 1 9 7 8 ) ; when this belt moves away from the Antarcti.c shelf , the
138
shelf waters will become heavier , and w.i ll have a better chance of sinking, even without substantial cooling; ( 4 ) buildup of a large amount of ice on Antarctica would have extracted 1 6 o from the t0us increasing the 0 1 8o values as observed ( e . g . Matthews 1 9 80) . - This latter possibility appears unattractive because , of independent evidence for such a buildup of ice . Which of these possibilities applies and in what combination? is little doubt "that a considerable temperature drop in mid- and high latitudes was associated with this event. Paleobotanic evidence for North America (Wol fe, 1 9 7 8 ) and the oxygen record of shallow water molluscs in the North Atlantic (Burchardt, l 9 7 8 ) attest to fact, among other clues. The low silica values in Oli.gocene pelagi.c sediments in the central Pacific (Leinen, 1 97. 9 ) and elsewhere that a newly born Antarctic Current (Kennett , 1 9 7.7.) rerroved silica world ocean on a large-scale. Such a current would favor thermal isolation of Antarctica, and hence promote cooling of this albedo increase there and i_n the polar high, and migration of the rain large ice buildup involved? If so, we should see an increase stability in climate . On the whole , this does not seem to be judging from facies variability (carbonate scatter) in the central Pacific (Berger, 1 9 7.7. ) . In any case, the suddenness of the Eocene/Oligocene event is stri king. Strong positive feedback appears to be involved, perhaps both from albedo changes and through extraction of co 2 from the by a cooling ocean. There i s a rapid deepening of the Pacific carbo""' nate cOmpensation depth at the Eocene/Oligocene bOundary (Berger and Roth, 1 9 7 5 i van Andel , 1 9 7 5 ; von Andel et �. , 1 97. 5 ) . Thus , there no question that the carbon cycl e is involv�d in this event. 3 . 6 . 1 5 Million Year Event
The Oligocene,with its low di.versity planktonic fauna., i.t s cool tro pic s , low sedimentation rates , and high carbonate-to-silica ratios somewhat of a mystery as far as paleoceanography is concerned. The phenomenon of Braarudosphaera blooms (see van Andel et · al . , l97. 7 ) is striking and has defied explanation. A weak thermocline and sporadi.C open-ocean mixing is a possibility (see Berger, 1. 9 7 9 ) . A late Oligo cene cooling step may exist (Figure 1 ) but it has received little attention.
I' ,I
139
may be related to an ex·t;reme ;Low stand of sea. level in the La.te (see Vail et a l . , 1' 9 7 7 ) . The beginning of the Miocene is an increase in the temperature gradi.ent between tropi.ca.l
areas , by an increase of cold bottom water production and' an
increase in the overall ferti.lity of the ocean . Basi.c all-y, the tropics are darkened as a result of the Miocene transgression., an.d th,e whi.ten.,.. 18 ing of high latitude continues . In the Mid-Miocene , the 6 o values
of calcareous plankton and o f benthic ;foramini;fera increases sharply (Figure . 1 ) . This is generally interpreted as reflecting the bui.idup o'f a large ice cap in eastern Antarctica {Savin, Dougl,as , Stehl i ,
1 975 ;,. $hackleton and Kennett , 1 97 5 ; Savin, 1. 9 77) . This bui.;I.dup pre 16 feren tially extracts H 2 o from the ocean, thus enri.ching i.t with 1 8 o. The rapidity of the glaciation again suggests positive teedback
within the causal factors . Presumably the growth of· ice coincidin.g with a warming of the tropics strengthens the temperature gradi.ent and favors wind transport of moisture from the tropics into white
and hence cold polar areas. I.'t i s noteworthy that the maximum buildup apparently occurs during maximum transgression and maximum wari,ni.ng, of the tropic s , which is favorable for supplying moisture to the air.
A detailed study by Woodruff et · al. .
( 1 98 1 ) , based on the isotopi.c
analysis of benthic foraminifera from DSDP Site 2 8 9 in the western equatorial Paci fic , puts the mid-Miocene transition event at between 16 and 1 4 mil l ion Years B . P . with the greatest change occurring in the
latter part .of the interval (see. Fig. 2 ) . The transition itself· is marked by rapid o � cillations , which are reminis-cent o f Pl.eistocene.. type cycles : an indication of instability in the system . The source
of this instabi l i ty, presumably, is the ease with · which snowfields and even large continental glaciers may be built up and destroyed , so that minor fluctuations in �he forcing functions ( e . g . Milankovi.tch
mechanism) can be greatly ampl ified through drastic changes in albedo. The carbon i sotope signal given by Woodruff et a l .
( 1 98 1 ) has some
very intriguing properties vis-a-vis the oxygen isotope curve. From inspection, one can see that the two stable isotope signals show
positive correlation throughout the time period investig_a ted ( 20 to 6 m . y . bp) , on a scale of one million years or less . Thus, "warming" . 1 2 c , isotopes within the shells of results in a· higher proportion o f
the transition, however, the positive correlation is opposed by a negative one, on a scale of several m. y . On this scale, and within the crucial interval ( 1 8 m . y . bp to 1 3 m . y . bp) , "warming" results 1 3 c and vice versa . in enrichment of shells with
140
-0.5 m 0 0..
0 � uo
0 +0.5
II I
LATE MIOCENE Nl6 NI
I iI
• 1 .0 ' 1 .5
m
� p
MIDDLE MIOCENE EARLY MIOCENE Nl5 Nl4 Nl3 Nl2 I I 10 9 8 N7 N6 N 5
lj/I I I I I I I J I I I 1 1 1i l li i l l l l l li i 'r1 , i l ill / 1 1 1 l i l l l l l l i lj 111 1 1 1 1rliJ, 1 IJJ II I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 lu1
' 1 .0 + L5
(<) • 2 .0
11 1 1,1 1 111JI IIJJ1 1 1 J11l// lr / l l il l l lj,1 1 / J 11 1 1 II 11
jJI
WOODRUFF,$AVIN, DOUGLAS, 1981 •2.5 DSDP SITE 289 ( W.EQ.PACIFIC) . II CIBICIDES SPP. (BENTH.FORAM.) • 3 ·0 t:::;N 14;[1Ntl1ffi I7==;oN1J§: -z N�6I;�N�5d +3.0 3 N!II2�U [['f 16::J:�N[E15[[N[� 1 1:ffiiO[j}9�8[[]N[�]J • 2.5
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20 m.y.b.p.
Fig. 2 . Oxygen and carbon isotope trends in Miocene benthi_c fora minifera from DSDP Si.te 2 8 9 , western equatorial Pacific. Data from Woodruff , Savin, an.d Douglas ( 1_ 9 8 1 )
It is dif;ficult to conceive of any one cause which could produce the positive and the nega ti.ve co�rela_ti.o n . Thus r we :wust sea+:ch, t·or least two. Also , the positive correlation must reflect more rapid chemical processes than the negative one. Various ways to produce in the carbon isotope composition o f foraminiferal shells have been .. · · · proposed (see Berger and Vincent, 1 98 1 ) . Briefly, they are ( 'I ) or release of organic carbon from temporary reservoirs (especially superficial sediments and soi l ) , ( 2 ) changes in forest mas s , ( 3 ) changes in ocean stratification and fertility, and ( 4') chang·es in circulation and · oxygenation (see Section 2 . 6 ) . In the present case, for example , positive correlation might be produced by factors ( 3 ) and ( 4 ) , since warming presumably leads to greater aging o f deep waters , hence loss of oxygen , hence gain of 1 2c - rich .co . The long 2 term negative correlation would be mainly based on factor ( 1 ) : warming leads to a buildup o f organic carbon reservoirs on land, through increased supply of moisture and on the shel.f (transgression) .
141
2 such buildup extracts 1 c preferentially from the sy·stem ( somewha.t in analogy to the 1 60 extraction by the bui.ldup of glaci.ers) . Upon cool ing - and regression - the temporari.ly stored organic carbon i_s freed and adds 1 2c to the system {Table 5 ) .
Table 5 . Effects of change in c limate on stable isotope rati.os in calcareous deep sea fossils {hypothetical) , to explain pos� tive and negative correlatioris between 61 8o and ot3c si.gnals recorded in· benthic foraminifera {Figure 2 ) . Change in Climate
Effect on 61 8o Positive correla tion with & 1 80
warming
•remperature: tS 1 8o decrease
lee-melting
1 6o release : 61 80 decrease
Cooling
Temperature : 61 8o increase
Ice buildup
l6o extraction :
61 8o increase
Negati:ve corre lation wi.th &1'8c
Aging of deep C reservoirs water, co ·lncrease, ( org 2 land and sea) 6 1 3c decrease 2 buildup. : 1 c extraction, b1 3 c increase .
Younging of deep water, co decrease, 2
0 1 3c increase
c
. org reservo1.rs (land and sea) diminished: cS1 3c decrease
We have , then , according to this hypothe s i s , lorig-term reservoir effects and short-term circulation effects , which produce opposing correlations between !>1 8o and d1 3c sign.a l s . Presumably, therefore , mutual cancellation and reinforcement of climate feedback from hydro sphere and carbonsphere likewise are a matter of time scale. Following the 1 5 m. y. cooli.;pg step, there seems to be a rebound in the oxygen isotope signal, centered on 1 2 m . y . This rebound , if such i.t be, i.s preceded by a change in the b 1 3c signal suggesting release
142
of 1 2 c to the system. If we fol low t� e generally accepted argument of ice buildup near 1 5 m . y . , we must admit global regression and heightened erosion of carbon-rich superficial deposits in coastal lowlands and on shelves . Such erosion would tend to descrease b1 3 c · in the ocean ' s carbon content . It would also , presumably, increase dissolution of deep-sea carbonates , by titration of carbonic acid with carbonate. There is indeed evidence for enhanced di.ssolution at the end of the middle Miocene . Furthermore , the release of carbon to the system should increase the atmosphere ' s co 2 content : hence the warming and hence the rebound .
3 . 7 . 6 Million Year Event An excellent period for study, in order to test the type of specu lation about carbon sphere involvement that - I just put forward, i.s the time near 6 m . y . bp . This i.s the t ime of the " (Magneti.c) Epoch Carbon shiftn ( Savin, 1 9 7 9 ; Vincent et al . , 1 97 9 ) . :tts course and signi ficance has been dis-cussed by Bender and Keigwin ( 1 9 7 9 ) i ( 1 97 9 ) ; Keigwin and Shackleton ( 1 980) ; Vincent � a l . ( 1 980) ; Berger and Vincent ( 1 98 1 ) ; and Vincent and Berger ( 1 98 1 ) . The best record of the 6 m . y . Event is that of DSDP Site 2 3 8 , in the Ind.ian Ocean, for which detailed mul tichann.el signals exist in the form of stable i sOtopes for several planktonic and benthic species (Vincent � a l . , 1 980) . Haq et al ( 1 980) showed that the event can be used globally as a chronologie marker . The Indian Ocean record i s intriguing in that it clearly shows a covariance between planktonic and benthic signa l s , demonstrating deep and shallow water chemistries were equally involved . Hence the case for release of organic carbon to the system, to change the entire ocean ' s 1 3c; 1 2c ratio, is very strong (Vincent � al . , 1 980) . Evidence for a substantial peak in carbonate dis solution in the eastern equatorial Pacific, during the time of the ME-6 Carbon Shift (Saito et al . , 1 9 7 5 ; Dunn et al . , 1 9 8 1 ) s�ggests ti.trati.on of newly introduced organic carbon against carbonate , in conjunction with fer-tility increase and changes in deep circulation patterns ( cooling would favor development of a North Atlantic carbonate trap) . I t is significant that the various stable isotope signals of the several ;foraminiferal species. show much l.ess cOherence before the
143
' e.vent than after i t . Before the shif-t, several unideDti.fi.ed factors, ' none strong and dominant , appear involved in producing the record. ourin g and after the transition a dominant signa�-guiding factor appea rs to emerge . This factor may be linked to the repea.ted desi.cca tion of the Mediterranean Sea at the time, discover-ed d.uring Leg 1'3 (Ryan , Hsu et a l .· 1 1 9 7 3 ) . Climatic variations paralielin.g the desic cation cycles from albedo changes i n and around the M'editerranean , presumably were amplified by i.ce mass variation in. polar regi.on_s , . ,which i n turn affected s e a levei a.nd hence s i 11 depth at the M.edi. terranean: a class � c case of posi.tive internal feedback . The pulsating production of deep saline waters whiCh must have accompanied the restriction of the Mediterranean also enters the pi.cture , th;rough i.ts effect on heat budget and ferti�i.ty var-i.a tion.
3 . 8 . 3 Million Year Event Glaciation of the northern hemisphere commenced about 3 mi.:!J,i.on. years ago . The time since has been. characteriz:ed by fluctuations in th,e s ize of northern_ ice caps; i t i s the geologic setting we live in and are familiar with. The buildup of ice and associated climatic change appear to hi:lve been very sudden (Berggren, 1 97 2 ; Shackl.et0n and Op dyke , 1 97 7 ) . As in the previously discussed 6 m . y . Event , instabil,i.ty increases during the 3 m . y . transi tion and a fter ( S hackleton and Op dyke 1 1 97 7 ; Keigwin and Thunell., 1'97 9 ) . Presumably instability arises for similar reasons as before: heightened albedo sensitivity, and
transient reservoirs in hydros Phere and carbon sphere. In the eastern equatorial Pacific the 3 m . y . Event i s marked by pronoun.ced carbonate dissolution (Dis solution Pulse GU3 ; Hays et a l . , 1 9 6 9 ; Saito et al . 1 1 97 5 ) . Again , the relationship between regression., cooling, in.stabi.li ty, and di ssolution is renri niscent of the 6 m . y . Event. L.ar:ge-scale introduction of newly eroded organic carbon , and increased fertiiLty from fresh nutrient supply, may be indicated. I f organic ca.rbon. was indeed released by transient reservoirs , we should see a d 1 3c -shift at this time toward light values . Kaneps ( 1 9 7 3 ) shows the GU3 dis ° solution pulse at 1 80 m in DSDP Site 1 5 7 . A shift of 0 . 5 /oo in the b1 3 c signal for the benthic foraminifera Uvigerina occurs at thi.s leve l , in �he expec ted direction (Keigwin, 1 9 79 ) . Orbulina 1 the
planktonic foram, does not show the shift, howeve r .
The most striking effect of the northern glaciations on the deep-sea record is the greatly increased supply of terrigenous material to the
144
deep sea , and the · increasingly large cli�atic fluctuations in carbonate cycles (Arrhenius , 1 9 5 2 ) and in isotope cycles 1" 9 5 5 , 1 9 6 6 ) . On a cooling Earth it was unavoidable that the �oving and rising continents would eventually collect snow and ice. Nevertheless , we may ask why di4 it happen so suddenly , and why at that particular time. Several possibilities can be envisaged. On land, the ·rise of ranges during the Pl iocene could have reached a critical level. covered and tree-barren highlands would have increased the albedo the point where cooling and snow buildup reinforced each other . In the ocean, the closure of the Panama Straits about 3 mill ion years ago would have obstructed the westward f low of Caribbean surface waters (Keigwin , 1 9 7 8 ) . These waters , then, would have been for northward transport in the Gulf Stream System. The have been a sharp intensification of the Icelandic low region and an increase in atmospheric moisture in high to evaporation from the warm ocean current . In would have been available for building up ice. This type of has turned up in several ice age theorie s . 3 . 9 . Pleistocene Terminations The last mill ion years have been· . characterized by an entire closely spaced steps , whose signi ficance is as yet obscure. and van Donk ( 1 9 7 0 ) drew attention to the peculiar " sawtooth " o f the i sotopic curves of Emiliani ( 1 9 5 5 , 1 9 6 6 ) . A maximum always ending at the same level of intensity - is followed b y a rapid deglaciation culminating in a peak warm period . There follows an overall increase in ice cover . The trend toward increasing glaciation on the gentle side of each sawtooth , the gradual buildup, is readily explained by positive do feedback , that i s , by increasing amounts of reradiation from whitening Earth. The rapid deglaciation is more difficult to Hwo does the deglaciat ion get started? What feedback prOcesses it? Why is it so rapid? These questions are being addressed ing box cores from deep-sediments, containing the record of the deglaCiation . Detailed stratigraphic analysis of box core material suggests that the sought-for positive feedback for deglaciation may be contained
145
in the - buildup of a low salinity layer on top of the ocean, once deglaciation s tarts. (Berger et a l . , 1 9 77 ) . Once such a layer is establi shed, i t would greatly facilitate the transport of heat from the ·tropices to high latitudes . This would induce additional melting and thus maintain the low salinity layer - a typical case of positive feedback . The like-lihood of a low salinity layer establishing itself increases during the course of deglaciation. It is not particularly great at the beginning, a lthough even then deglaciation apparently proceeded quite quickly. The answer to this riddle may lie in a low �alinity Arctic whi�h freshened during its isolation from the glacial world ocean, when sea level was lowered {Vigdorchik, 1 98 0 ) . Thus , after a substantial period of isolation , when sea level first rose , low salinity water would be available to initiate the meltwater lid effect. There i s little question that the carbon cycle would be affected considerably by a buildup of a low salinity layer {Worthington, 1 9 6 8 ) . The apparent rise Of pco in the a tmosphere in the early Holocene 2 (Berner et a l . , 1'9 8 0 ) and especially the ev i dence for a fluctuating pco 2 during the glacial-Holocene transition ( see data of Delmas et a l . , 1 9 8 0 ) , must be considered with the possible effects of a transient meltw�ter lid in mind. There is no doubt that the carbon cycle was profoundly affec'ted by deglaciation: a preservation spike in forami nifera and pteropods occu·rs during the maximum rate of change of sea leve l , over wide regions of the ocean floor {Berge r , 1 97 7 ; Shackleton,
1 977) . 4 . General Features o f Climate Steps
4 . 1 . Surprise Events and Threshold Events Regarding climate events , we wish to know whether or not it is ex ternally caused and how much internal feedback is involved . Also, we wbuld like to know whether an event, in principle , could have been predicted before it occurred , and how accurately . I suggest that among the events discussed there is only one . unpre dictable one: the Cretaceous termination. It is truly a " surprise event " , because nothing in the preceding record suggests that doom is near. The view that there are no prophecies, right up to the point when catastrophe strikes , is not generally accepted , of course. There are
1 4�
those who po.ir}t to- a drop in sea level , to cha:n.ges in, ca;r;bonate position pattern s , or to declining d:i versity in various groups organisms in order to advance the idea that the event was the nation of a trend. (For review see Russell , one suspends justif iable doubts about the quality o f the ev£dence offered , there remains the impression that the postulated tal changes are merely part o:::- the background t:'l. uctuati.ons the late Cretaceous . Indications are th�t the external interference ' whether cosmic or tectoni.c . A certain · of environmental preconditioning, say , by a drop in sea �eve�, have exacerbated the calamitous impact of the disturbance, but not by itself produce the event . On thi s , if anything, the record is clear (Thierstein and Okada , 1 97 9 ) . All other events discussed appear to be predlctable , The major climate steps in the Tertiary lie on a coo�ing trend : constitute acceleration of this trend . The most llkely mechanism acceleration is albedo feedback , and the most efficient duci� g phenomenon is the 'changeover from water to snow , (Table 2 ) . Each step, in this interpretation , reflects the of a portion of the earth ' s . surface , at the point where t<•mper2
.
i
..
4 . 2 . Rebound Events What about the events which oppose the general cooling trend? less spectacular than the major steps listed they are abundant out the Tertiary (Figures 1 and 2 ) and are especially Plei.stocene , as deglaciation events or " ter:t:nination s " . On the of analogy with the Pleistocene terminations ( albeit at the prejudging the issue ) , I suggest that the reverse steps are events " which owe their existence to three ingredients: ( 1' ) side force ' or a negative feedback overshOot temporarily cooling trend , ( 2 ) a sufficient buildup of ice all.owing level rise upon melting, and ( 3 ) positive albedo feedpack se of sea level , the disappearance of snow cover, and the vegetation . There is one corollary of the 11reboundu hypothe s i s : the reverse steps should get larger and perhaps more common. as ice build. up proceeds throughout the Cenozoic . Statistics on thi.s point are not
BIB/\ 108H KH l01 Qi\tA"Oillklll! lllll 110Y l�l1 KM MtHllKfi� mv""� s ava, wo"� ' but the assertion appears reasonable that rb��;;:::,;.;� ps increasingly large and abundant in the late Cenoz·oi c' and especial
_ _ _. _
Pleistocene proper . In fact, it would seem that the ing trend has run its course , so that any additional cooling steps only take place after a rebound step has provided the opportunity new ice buildup. In this view, the c limate of the last mill ion years cons ists of a compressed sequence of cooling steps and rebounds . Maximum instability has been reached because the areas affected by rospheric albedo change were never larger , and because ice masses .hy? peak glaciation were never more voluminous . Thus , the main sources of positive feedback are greater than ever before in the Cenozo ic .
4 . 3 . Forcing Events Unless we assume that c l imate is inherently unstable and flips over from one state into another more or less by chance, each cl imate chan must have an identifiable "ultimate cause " . Such a "cause" should outside the feedback system, and should be able to start the change . A plethora of possible causes for c limatic change has been listed in the literature . They may be grouped under the headings geologic settin-g , orbital variations , solar phys ics , and ·cosmic effects. Causes related to geologic setting have been invoked for the general Cenozoic cooling trend: the drift of northern continents .away from the equator , the isolation of Antarctica and of the Arctic , mountain building and global regression (Hamilton, 1 96 8 ; Donn and Shaw, 1 9 77 ) . Orbital variations (Croll , 1 97 5 ; Milankovich , 1 9 3 0 ) demonStrably dominate Pleistocene c l imatic f luctuations (Hay� et al . , 1 9 7 6 ) . Little is known about possible variations in solar output and about cosmic effects if any. Volcanic activity, changes in sea level from changes in seafloor spreadinq rate s , and changes in salinity due to buildup or release of salt deposits are other themes which turn up in dis cussions about climatic change . There is one class of potential forcing events which are of special interest because they might produce steps by themselves , without the aid of feedback . These are inundation and des iccation events which are produced by the rapid filling or emty.ing of semi-isolated ocean bas ins . They produce essentially instantaneous global regressions or transgressions (Berger and Winterer , 1 9 74 ) . Salt depos its in the �editerranean , in the Gulf of Mexico , in the South Atlantic , and in
148 the North Atlantic , suggest that large evaporite basins were at various times after the breakup of the Pangaea . It should be possible to find evidence for the associated periods o f instabil ' of sea level in the shelf sediments of the last 2 0 0 million years 4 . 4 . Gateway Events as Triggers As mentioned in the introduct ion, the idea that changes _in the opening and closin� of straits and passages especially ocean circulation and hence climate has gained considerable favor and currency. There are good reasons for this developing (Berggren and Hollister, 1 9 7 4 , 1 9 7 7 ; Savin et a l . , 1 9 7 5 ; Kennet, 1 9 7 7 ; McGowran, 1 97 8 ; Lance lot, 1 98 0 ; Berger, 1 98 1 a ; Haq , 1 9 8 1 ) . is certainly striking that major circulation adjustments can be associated with just about every one of the major Tertiary steps . Quite commonly there is an embarrassment of riches : one a choice of several aateway events which are close enough to a climate step to qualify as trigger events (Berggren , 1' 9 8 1 ; Haq, I n the ear·l y Eocene, there i s the separation of Austral,ia from arctica , development of a passage between North Atlantic and ·the incipient collision of India and Asia, closing a east-west passage . At the end of the Eocene , there is a deepening the passage between North Atlantic and Arcti c , and the incipient collision of India and Asia , closing a tropical east-west pas sag-e . the end of the Eocene, there is a deepening of the passage between Antarctica and Australi a , and of that from Atlantic to Arct i c , and ther e is the closure of the central Tethys . In the mid-Miocene themes again appear : opening of the Drake Passage in the Southern Ocean , closure of Tethys , and access from the Atlantic to the Nor wegian Sea and to the Arctic Ocean (Thiede , 1 98 0 ; Eldholm and 1 98 0 ; voget et a l . , 1 98 1 ) . For the 6 m . y . Event we have the isolation of the Mediterranean, and. for the 3 m . y . Event the closure of the Panama Straits . For the Plei� stocene terminations , fi_nal l y , we can invoke an isolated Arctic (Vigdorchick1 1 9 8 0 ) , if we so desire. The arguments for the importance of gateway trigger events range from plausible ( thermal isolation of the Antarctic by development of the Circum-�ntarctic Current; Savin et al . , 1 9 7 5 ) to �xtended ( importance of " in j ection even·ts " ; Thierstein and Berger , 1 9 7 8 ) . They are not
149
< .c:ornp'"" """" , because ( 1 ) the assignment of gateway events to climate commonly arbitrary ( the opening of Drake Passage , for examp 'le , has been invoked for c limate steps both of Eocene and of Miocene age) , and { 2 ) they suffer from a lack even of e lementary heat budget incidental l y , is true for the present essay) . summary , gateway triggers are a good ide a , but they may not be steps ,
4 . 5 . Stability and COherence as Criteria for Event Type In several instances we saw that a c l imate step may result in altered clima te stability and coherence between climate-·r elated signals. During the course of the Cenozoic , albedo feedback and ice masses increase in importance . I take this to be responsible for an apparent overall decrease in stability and an increase in coherence of signals since the Oligocene . By this argument, each step which results in decreased stability supports the presumption of ice mass buildup . A special type of instability source is the semi-isolated ocean basin such as the · Mediterranean and the Arctic . Geographic isolation im plies a potential for ' bU ildup of large reservoirs o f hypersaline or of br acki�h water. Beyond the intriguing possibility of total dis connection .and sudden reconnection o f such basins (Gartner and Keany,
1 9 7 8 ; Thierstein and Berget , 1 97 8 ) they constitute an important element of deep ci.rculation. The Mediterranean Sea with its deep
saline outflow is an actualistic example . Its outflow apparently is linked to the production of North Atlantic Deep Water (see Reid, 1 9 7 9 ) , and thus the Mediterranean c limate may be closely l inked to
the heat budget of the Norwegian Sea , itself a climatic amplifier of great power ( Ruddirnan and Mcintyre, 1 98 1 ) . Ice mas ses , and isolated basins with their "odd" water masses are hydrospheric examples of "transient reservoirs" which can be called upon to introduce geochemical diseqUilibrium to the ocean-atmosphere system. Others (carbon , phosphorus , salt} can b� envisaged {Berger et a l . , 1 9 8 1 ) . St i l l , for the Cenozoiq and especially the late Ceno zoic there is probably no transient reservoir effect which exceeds that of the ice masses and thei.r enormous leverage through sea level change .
150
5 . Conclusion and Outlook I have proposed that ciin,ate steps are r ea l , an.d that they r-eflect the action of feedback mechanisms mainly from hydrospheric (albedo effect) but also from changes in the carbon cycle effeft) . On the whol e , the greenhouse feedback appears less and the checks and balances within it lead one to suspect that feedback has a moderating rather than an arnpli.fying role . I.f so, intriguing possibility arises that we are dealing with a system fluctuates because of imbalances between opposing feedback rne:ct\ar1i :3(lU3 ;: The fast-response albedo feedback would provide for overshoot in direction of change , whi le the lagging greenhouse effect would be responsible for reversing directions . There is some indication the la� t great climate step, deglacia tion , displays properties such an oscillating system (Berger, 1 9 8 1b ) . Examples in vari.ous of the geologic record, and on various tilne sqales, must be to establish the reality of this postulated phenomenon . The importance of transient geochemical reservoirs other than ice ( water, carbon , phosphorus1 metal nutrients, sulfate and sulfide ; salt) in abetting climate instability i.s worth considering. The ,,,
up of Pangaea and the subsequent development of isolated basins and long pass ive margins should have greatly favored the development of such reservoirs ( see Hay, 1 98 1 ) . The crucial factor in their activa tion is sea level fluctuation, which rema ins as the central problem in global stratigraphy (Vail et al . , 1 9 7 7 ) . References
,..: ,r..''
Alvarez. , L . , Alvarez , W . , Asaro, F . , Michel , H . V . ( 1 98.0 ) : Extra terrestrial cause for the Cretaceous-Tertiary extinction. Science 2 0 8 : 1 0 9 5 -1 1 08 . Arrhenius 1 G . ( 1 95 2 ) : Sediment cores from the East Pacifi_c . Rep. Swedish Deep-Sea Exped . 1 9 4 7 - 1 9 4 8 5 : t -22 8 . Arthur, M . A . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Paleoceanographic events - recogniti.o n , tion and reconsideration. Rev . Geophysics 7. : l 4 74-1:4 9 4 . Arthur , M . A . , Jenkyns , H . C . ( 1' 9 8 1· ) : Phosphorites and Oceanologica Acta, supplement to volume 4 , Proc . na l Geological Congr e s s , Geology o f Oceans Symposium, 83- 9 6 .
Arthur, M . A . , Natland , J . H . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Carbonaceous sediments i n the North and South Atlantic : the role of salinity in stable strati� fication of Early Cretaceous basin s . I n : Talwan i , M. , Hay, W . , Ryan , W . B . F . ( eds . ) : Deep Drilling Results in the Atlantic Ocean : Continental Margins and Paleo-environment . American Geophysical Union, washington , D . C . , 3 7 5- 4 0 1 .
151
sender, M . L . , Keigwin , L . D . , Jr. ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Speculations about the upper Miocene change in abyssal Pacific dissolved bicarbonate b1 3 c . Earth and Planetary Science Letters 4 5 : 383- 3 9 3 . Ben son , R . H . ( 1 97 5 ) : The origin o f the psychrosphere a s record'ed in changes of deep-sea ostracode assemblages . Lethaia 8 : 6 9-83 . · serger, W . H . { 1 97 7 ) : Carbon dioxide excursions and the deep sea record : aspects of the problem . I n : Andersen, N . R . and Malahoff , A . (eds . ) : The Fate of Fossil FU:el co 2 in the Oceans . Plenum· Press , New York, p . 5 0 5 - 542 . Berge r , W . H . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Impact o f deep-sea drilling on paleoceanography. In: Talwan i , M. , Hay , w . and Ryan , W . B . F . {eds . ) : Deep Drilling ' Results in the Atlantic Ocean: continental margins and paleoenvi ronmen t . American. Geophysical Union , Washington , D . C . , 297- 3 1 4 . Berger, W . H . ( 1 98 1 a) Paleoceanography : the deep..:sea record. I'n : Emiliani , c . (ed. ) : The Sea, Vol . 7 . Wiley-Interscienc e , New York, in pres s . Berge r , W . H . ( 1 98 1 b ) : C limate steps in ocean history: lessons from the Pleistocene . In : Crowel l , J . C . and Berger, W . H . { eds . ) Pre Pleistocene Climate . Studies in Geophysics. National Research Council (NAS ) , washington , D . C . , in press. ·
Berger , W . H . , Roth , P . H . ( 1 97 5 ) : Oceanic micropaleontology: progress and prospects . Reviews of Geophysics and Space Physics 1 3 : 5 6 1 5 8 5 and 6 24 - 6 3 5 .
Berger 1 W . H . , Vincent , E . ( 1 98 1 ) : Chemostratigraphy and biostratigra phic correlation: exercises in systemic stratigraphy. Proceedings 26th International Geological Congre s s , Geology. of Oceans Sympo sium, Paris 1 98 0 , Oceanological Acta Supplement to vol . 4 : 1 1 5127. Berger , W . H . , Winterer , E . L . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Plate strat i graphy and the fluctuating carbonate line. I n : HsU, K . J . and Jenkyns , H . (eds . ) Pelagic Sediments on Land and under the Sea. Sp�cial Publication International Association of Sedimentologists 1 : 1 1 -4 8 . .Berger , W . H . , Joh.nson, R. F . , Killingley, J . S . ( 1 9 7 7 ) "Unmixing" of the deep-sea record and the deglacial meltwater spike. Nature 2 6 9 : 661-663. Berger , W . H . , Vincent, E . , Thierstein, H . R . ( 1 98 1 ) : The deep-sea record: major steps in Cenozoic ocean evolution . Society Economic Paleontologists & Mineralogists , Special Publication: in pres s .
Berggren , W . A . ( 1 9 7 2 ) : Late Pliocene-Pleistocene glaciation. Initial Reports of the Deep Sea Dr i lling Project, 1 2 , u . s . Govern ment Printing Office, Washington , D . C . : 9 5 3 - 9 6 3 .
Berggren, W . A . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Role of ocean gateways �n climate changes . I n : Crowell , J . C . and Berger , W . H . (eds . ) Pre-Pleistocene Climate. Studies in Geophysics . National Research Counc il (NAS ) , Washing ton , D . C . , in pres s . Berggren, W . A . , Hollister, C . D . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Paleogeography , paleobio geography and the history of c i rcu'lation in the Atlantic Ocean. Society of Economic Paleontologists & Mineralogists Special Publi cation 2 0 , 1 2 6- 1 8 6 . Berggren, w . , Hollister, C . D . ( 1 97 7 ) : Plate tectonics and paleocir culation - commotion in the ocean . Tectonophysics 3 8 : 1 1 -4 8 . Berner , w ,. , Oeschge r , H . , Stauffer, B . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Information on the co 2 cycle from ice core studies . Radiocarbon 2 2 : 227 -2 3 5 .
152
Bramlette, N . N . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Mass ive extinctions in biota at the end Mesozoic time . Science 1 4 8 : 1 6 9 6- 1 6 9 9 . Broecker , w . S . ( 1 st7 3 ) : Factors controlling co 2 content in the and atmosphere . I n : Woodwel l , G . M. and Pecan, E . V . ( eds . ) �aroon and the Biosphere . AEC Symposium 3 0 : 3 2- 5 0 . Broecke r , W . S . 1 van Donk , J . ( 1 97 0 ) : Insolation changes, ice and the o 1 8 record in deep-sea cores . Reviews of Geophysics Space Physics 8 : 1 6 9 - 1 9 8 . Buchardt , B . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Oxygen isotope paleotemperatures from the Te,rtol•'� ry period in the North Sea area. Nature 2 7 5 : 2 1 2-2 2 3 . '
J .
Christensen, W . K . , Birkelund ,. T . (eds . ) ( 1 9 7 9 ) Cretaceous/Tertiary Boundary Events , vol . 2 . University of Copenhage n , Copenhagen, 2 5 0 pp. Corliss , B . H . { 1 9 7 9 ) : Response of deep-sea benthonic foraminifera the development of the psychrosphere near the Eocene/Ol igocene boundary. Nature 2 8 2 : 6 3 - 6 5 . Crol l , J . { 1 8 7 5 ) : Climate and Time. Daldy, Isbister & Co . , London, 5 7 7 pp . Dacqu€ , E . ( 1 9 1 5 ) : Grundlagen und Methoden der Palaogeographie. Gustav Fischer, Jena, 4 9 9 pp. Davies , T . A . , Hay, W . W . , Southam, J . R . , Worsley, T . R. { 1 9 7 7 ) : mates of Cenozoic oceanic sedimentation rates . Science 1 9 7 : Delma s , R . J . , Ascencio, J . -M . , Legrand , M . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Polar ice that atmospheric co2 2 0 , 0 0 0 yr BP was 5 0 % of present. Nature 1 55 c 1 5 7 . Donn , W . L . , Shaw , D . M . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Model o f c l imate evolution based continental drift and polar wandering . Geological Society of America Bulletin 8 8 : 3 9 0- 3 9 6 .
: �j �
d ' Orbigny, M . A . ( 1 8 5 1 ) : Cours €1€mentaire d e Pal€ontologie e t de Geologie Stratigraphiques , vol . 2 . Victor MaSson , Douglas , R . G . ( 1 9 7 3 ) : Benthonic foraminiferal bi� �: �'' � = ' � �i y ; central North Pacific, Leg 1 7 , Deep Sea Drilling Reports Deep Sea Drilling Project 1 7 , u . s . Gov . Print. washington , D . C . , 6 0 7- 6 7 1 . Douglas , R . G . , Savin, S . M . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Oxygen and Carbon isotope of Tertiary from Shatsky Rise and other sites in the North Ocean. Initial Reports DeeP Sea Drilling Project, vol . 3 2 . Government Printing Office , Washington , D . C . , 5 0 9 - 52 0 . Douglas , R . G . , woodruff, . F . ( 1 98 1 ) : Deep sea benthic foraminifera. Emiliani , C . ( ed . ) The Sea, vel. 7 . Wiley-Interscienc e , New vnrkco in press . Dunn , D . A . , Moore , T . C . , Keigwin, L . D . ( 1 98 1 ) : Atlantic-type carbo-. nate stratigraphy in the late Miocene Pacific. Nature 2 9 1 : 225227. Eldholm, 0 . , Thiede, J . ( 1 98 0 ) : Cenozoic continental separation bet.;. ween Europe and Greenland . Paleogeography , Pale0climatology , Paleoecology 3 0 : 2 4 3 - 25 9 . Emiliani, c . ( 1 9 5 5 ) : Pleistocene temperatures . Journal of Geology 6 3 : 538-578 . Emiliani , C . ( 1 9 6 6 ) : Paleotemperature analysis of Caribbean cores P 6 3 0 4 - 8 and P 6 3 0 4 -9 and a generalized temperature curve for the past 4 2 5 , 0 0 0 years . Journal of Geology 7 4 : 1 09 - 1 2 6 .
153
Emil iani, C . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Death and renovation at the end of the Mesozoic . EOS, Transaction of the American Geophysical Union 6 1 : 5 0 5 - 5 0 6 . Fischer, A . G . , Arthur , M . A . ( 1 97 7 ) : Secular variations in the pelagic realm. Society of Economic Paleontologists and Mineralogists , Special Publication 2 5 , 1 9 - 5 0 . Gartner, S . , Keany, J . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : The Terminal Cretaceous event. A geo logic problem. with an oceanographic solution. Geology 6 : 70 8- 7 1 2 . Hami lton, W . { 1 9 6 8 ) : Cenozoic climatic change and its cause. Meteoro logical Monographs vol . 8 : 1 28 - 1 3 3 . Hansen , J . , Johnson, D . , Lacis , A . , Lebede f f , S . , Lee, P . , Rind, D . , Russell , G . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Climate impact o f increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide. Science 2 1 3 : 9 5 7- 9 6 6 . Haq, B . U . ( 1 98 1 ) : Paleogene paleoceanography : early Cenozoic . oceans ·revisited. Oceanologica Acta , Supplement to vol. 4 , Proceedings 26th International Geological Congress , Geology of oceans sympo sium, Paris, 1 980: 7 1 - 8 2 . Haq, B . U . , Premoli-Silva, I . , Lohmann , G . P . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Calcareous plank ton paleobiogeographic evidence for major climatic fluctuations in the early Cenozoic Atlantic Ocean. Journal of Geophys ical Re search 8 2 : 3 8 6 1 - 38 7 6 . Haq, B . U . , Worsley, T . R . , Burckle, L . H . , Douglas , R . G . , Keigwi n , L . D . , Opdyke , N . D . , Savin, S . M . , Sommer , M . A . , Vincent, E . , Wood ruf f , F . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Late Miocene marine carbon-isotopic shift and synchroneity of some phyto-planktonic biostratigraphic events. Geology 8 : 4 2 7 -4 3 1 . Hay, w . w . ( 1 98 1 ) : Sedimentological and geochemical trends ·r esulting fr9m the breakup of Pangaea . Oceanolog�ca Acta, Supplement to vol. 4 , Proceedings 26th International Geological Congres s , Geology of oceans symposium, Paris , 1 9 8 0 : 1 3 5- 1 4 7 . · Hays , J . D . , Saito, T . , Opdyk e , N . D . , Burckle , L . H . ( 1 9 6 9 ) : Pliocene Pleistocene sediment.s of the equatorial Paci fic : their paleomag netic , biostratigraphic and c l imatic record. Geological Society of America Bulletin 8 0 : 1 48 1 " - 1 5 1 4 . 1
Hays , J . D . , Imbrie , J . , Shackleton, N . J . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Variations in the earth ' s orbit : Pacemaker of the ice age s . Science 2 9 4 : 1 1 2 1 - 1 1 3 2 . Hsli, K . J . { 1 9 8 0 ) : Terrestrial catastrophe caused by cometary impact at the end of Cretaceous . Nature 2 85 : 2 0 1 - 2 0 3 . Hummel , J . , Reck, R . A . { 1 97 8 ) : A global surface albedo model. General Motors Research Publication GMR 26.0 7 : 1 -4 7 .
Imbrie , J . , Imbr i e , J . Z . ( 1 98 0 ) : Modeling the climatic response to orbital variations . Science 2 0 7 : 9 4 3- 9 5 3 . Kaneps , A . ( 1 97 3 ) : Carbonate chronology for PlioCene deep-sea sedi ments . Initial Reports Deep Sea Dril ling Project 1 6 , u . s . Government Prin ting Office , Washington , D . C . : 873-88 1 . Karig, D . E . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Basin genesis in the Philippine Sea. Initial Reports Deep Sea Drilling Project 3 1 , U . s . Government Print·ing Office, washington, D . C . , p . 8 57-879 . Keigwin , L . D . , Jr . { 1 9 7 8 ) : Pliocene closing of the I sthmus of Panama, based on bios tratigraphic evidence from nearby Pacific Ocean and Caribbean Sea cores . Geology 6 : 6 3 0 - 6 3 4 .
154
Keigwin , L . D . , J r . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Late Cenozoic stable isotope and plaeoceanography of DSDP Sites from the east equatorial north central Pacific Ocean. Earth & Planetary Science Letters 361-382. Keig.w in, L . D . , J r . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Oxygen and carbon i sotope analyses from Eocene/Oligocene boundary at DSDP Site 2 7 7 . Nature 287 � 722-72 5 . Keigwin, L . D . , Jr . , Shackleton , N . J . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Uppermost Miocene isotope stratigra Phy of a piston core in the equatorial Pacific . Nature 2 8 4 : 6 1 3-6 1 4 . Keigwin , L . D . , Thunell , R . C . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Middle Pliocene climatic in the western Mediterranean from faunal and oxygen isotopic trends . Nature 2 8 2 : 294-29 6 . Kemp, E . M . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Tertiary climatic evolution and vegetation in the Southeast Indian Ocean region. matology , Paleoecology 2 4 : 1 6 9-208 . Kennett , J . P . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Cenozoic evolution of Antarctic glaciation , the C ircum-Antarctic Current and their impact on global pale oceanography . Journal of Geophysical Research 8 2 : 3 8 4 3 - 38 6 0 . Kennett, J . P . , Shackleton , N . J . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : oxygen isotopic evidence development of the psychrosphere 38 m . y . ago. Nature 2 6 0 : 5 1 3- 5 1 Kennett, J . P . , Thunel l , R . C . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Global increase i n Quaternary explosive volcanism. Science 1 8 7 : 4 9 7 - 5 0 3 . Lance lot , Y . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Environnements sedimentaires oceaniques : deve- . loppement de la pal€o-oc€anographie. Livre Jubilaire de la . soc. g€ol. de France, 1 8 3 0 - 1 9 8 0 . Mem. h . S€r . g9ol. de France, 1 98 0 , 1 0 , 3 5 1 -3 6 2 . Leclaire, L . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Hypothese sur l ' origine des silifications dans les grands bassins oceaniques . Le rOle des climats hydrolisants. Bull. . Soc . Geol . France 1 6 : 2 1 4 -2 2 4 . Leinen, M . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Biogenic silica accumulation in the Central Equa torial Pacific and its implications for Cenozoic paleoceanography Geological Society of America Bulletin 9 0 : 1 3 1 0- 1 3 1 6 . Lipps , J . H . , Berger, W . H . , Buzas , M . A . , Dougla s , R . G . , Ross, C . A . { 1 9 7 9 ) : Foraminiferal ecology and paleoecology . SEPM Short Course' No . 6 , Houston , Texas , 1 9 8 pp. Luterbacher, H . P . , Premoli-Silva, I . ( 1 9 6 4 ) : Biostratigrafia del limite Cretaceo-Terziario. Riv. I ta l . Paleont. 7 0 : 6 7- 1 2 8 . Matthews , R . K . , Poor e , R . Z . { 1 98 0 ) : Tertiary Q1 8o record and glacio� eustatic sea level fluctuations . Geology 8 : 5 0 1 - 5 0 4 . McGowran , B . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Stratigraphic record o f Early Tertiary oceanic and continental events in the Indian Ocean region . Marine 26: 1-39. Milankovic h , M . ( 1 93 0 ) : Mathematische K limalehre und astronomische Theorie der Kl imaschwankungen. Handbuch der Kl�matologie, vol . 1 A , Berlin, Gebr . Borntraeger , 1 7 6 pp. Pisias , N . G . { 1 9 7 6 ) : Late Quaternary variations in sedimentation rate in the Panama Basin and the identification o·f orbital fre quencies in carbonate and opal deposition rates. Geological Socie ty qf America Memoir 1 4 5 : 3 7 5- 3 9 1 . Plass , G . N . ( 1 9 5 6 ) : The carbon dioxide theory of climatic change. Tellus 8 : 1 4 0 - 1 5 4 . Reid, J . L . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : On the contribution of the Mediterranean sea out-
155 flow to the Norwegian-Greenland Sea . Deep-Sea Research 2 6A : 1 1 991 223. -: Rosen krantz , A . , Brotzen, F . {eds . ) : Report o f the twenty-first session Norden 1 96 0 Part V , The Cretaceous-Tertiary Boundary. Det Berlingske Bogtrykkeri , Copenhagen , 2 1 5 pp. Ruddiman , W . F . , Mcintyre, A. ( 1 98 1 ) : Oceanic mechanisms for amplifi cation of the 23 , 00 0-year ice-volume cycle. Science 2 1 2 : 6 1 7- 6 2 7 . ,Russell , D . A . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : The enigma o f the extinction of the dinosaurs. Annual Reviews of Earth & Planetary Science 7 : 1 6 3 - 1 8 2 .
Ryan , W . B . F . , Hsli , K . J . , Cita, M . B . , Dumitrica, P . , Lort, J . M . , Mayne·, w . , Nesteroff , W . D . , Pautot , G . , Stradner, H . , Wez e l , F . C . ( 1 9 7 3 ) : I,flitial Reports of the Deep Sea Drilling Proj ect, VOl . 1 3 , parts 1 and 2 , U . s . GOvernment Printing Office , washington, D . C . , 1 44 7 pp.
Saito , T . , Burckle, Hays , J . D . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Late Miocene to Plei stocene biostratigraphy of equatorial Pacific sediments . I n : "Late Neogene Epoch Boundaries", Micropaleonto logy Special Publication No. 1 , 226-244. Savin , S . M. { 1 97 7 ) : The history of the Earth ' s surface temperature during the last 1 00 mi llion years. Annual Reviews Earth & Plane tary Science 5 : 3 1 9 - 3 5 5 . savin, S . M . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Interocean stable isotopic correlations and Mio cene pa leoceanography . Annual Meeting Geological Society of Ameri ca , San Diego, California 1 9 7 9 , Abstracts with Programs , p. 5 1 0 . Savin, S . M. , Douglas , R . G . , Stehli , F . G . { 1 9 7 5 ) : Tertiary marine paleotemperatures· . Geological Society of America Bulletin 8 6 : 1 4 9 9- 1 5 1 0 . Scholle , P . A . , Arthur , M . A . ( 1 98 0 ) : Carbon isotopic fluctuations in pel�gic limestones : potential stratigraphic and petroleum explo ration too l . Ame'rican Association of Petroleum Geologis ts Bulletin 6 4 : 6 7 -8 7 . Shackleton , N . J . ( 1 97 7 ) : Carbon- 1 3 in Uvigerina: tropical rainforest history and the equatoria� Pacific carbonate dissolution cycles . In: Andersen, N . R. and Malahoff , A . (eds . ) : The Fate of Fossil Fuel co i n the. Oceans. Plenum Pub Corp. , New York, p. 4 0 1 - 4 2 7 . 2 Shackleton, N . J . , Kennett, J . P . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Paleotemperature history of the Ceno zoic and the initiation of Antarctic glaciation: oxygen and carbon isotope analyses in DSDP Sites 2 7 7 , 2 7 9 and 2 8 1 . Initial Reports Deep Sea Drilling Project, vol . 2 9 , u . s . Govern ment Printing Offic e , Washington, D . C . , 7 4 3 - 7 5 5 . Shackleton, N . J . , Opdyke , N . D . ( 1 97 7 ) : Oxygen isotope and paleomag· netic evidence for early northern hemisphere glaciation. Nature 2 7 0 : 2 1 6- 2 1 9 . Smi t , J . , Hertogen, J . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : An extraterrestrial event at the Cretaceous-Tertiary boundary . Nature 2 8 5 : 1 98 - 2 0'0 . Smit , J . , Klave r , G . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Sanidine spherules at the Cretaceous Tertiary boundary indicate a large impact event. Nature 2 9 2 : 47- 4 9 . Steinberg, M . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Biosiliceous sedimenta tion, radiolarite pe riods and s i lica budget fluctuations . Oceanologica Acta, Supple ment to Volume 4 , Proceedings 26th Internationa l Geological Con gress , Geology of Oceans symposium, Paris 1 9 8 0 , 1 4 9 -1 5 4 .
156
Talwani , M . , Hay, w . , Ryan, W . B . F . (eds . ) ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Deep drilling results in the Atlantic Ocean: continental margins and paleoen vironment. Maurice Ewing Series, vol . 3 , American Geophysical Union, Washington , D . C . Thiede, J . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Paleo-oceanography , margin s tratigraphy and paleophysiography of the Tertiary North Atlantic and Norwegian Greenland Sea . Philos . Transaction Royal Society, London A294 : 1 77-185. Thierste i n , H . R . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Paleoceanographic implications of organic ' carbon and carbonate distribution in Mesozoic deep-sea sediments. I n : Talwani , M . , Hay, W . , Ryan , W . B . F . ( eds . ) Deep Drilling Re sults in the Atlantic Ocean: continental margins and ment, Maurice Ewing Series 3 , American Geo Physical ton, D . C . 2 4 9 - 2 7 4 . Thierstein, H . R . ( 1 9 8 0 ) : Cretaceous oceanic catastrophism. Paleobio- , logy 6 : 2 4 4 - 24 7 . Thierstein, H . R . , Berger , W . H . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Inj ection events in ocean history. Nature 2 7 6 : 4 6 1 -4 6 6 . Thierstein , H . R . , Okada , H . ( 1 9 7 9 ) ! The Cretaceous/Tertiary boundary ·. event in the North Atlantic. Initial Reports Deep Sea Drilling Pro j ec t , vol . 4 3 , p . 6 0 1 -6 1 6 . Urey, H . ( 1 97 3 ) : cometary collision and geological period s . Nature 2 4 2 : 32-3 3 . Vail, P . R . , Mitchum, R . M . , Jr . , Thompson, s . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Seismic strati graphy and global changes of sea-level, Part 4 : Global cycles of relative changes of sea leve l . American Association of Petroleum Geologists Memoir, 2 6 : 83-97 . van Andel , Tj . H . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Mesozoic/Cenozoic calcite compensation and the global distribution of calcareous sediments . Earth and Planetary Science Letters 2 6 : ·1 8 7- 1 9 4 . van Ande l , Tj . H . , Moore , T . C . ( 1 9 7 4 ) : Cenozoic tribution and calcite compensation depth in Pacific. Geology 2 : 8 7 - 9 2 . van Andel , Tj . H . , Heath, G . R . , Moore , T . C . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Cenozoic sedimentation and paleoceanography of the central equatorial fie . Geological Society of America Memoir, v . 1 4 3 , 1 4 3 pp. van Andel , T j . H . , Thiede, J . , Sclater, J . G . , Hay, w . w . ( 1 9 7 7 ) : Depo"'7 siotional history of the South Atlantic Ocean during the last 1 2 5 m.i l lion years . Journal of eology 8 5 : 6 5 1 - 6 9 8 . Vigdorchik, M . E . { 1 9 8 0 ) : Arctic Pleistocene History and the rnent of Submarine Permafrost. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado, 2 8 6 pp. Vincent, E . , Berger, W . H . { 1 9 8 1 ) : Planktonic foramini fera and their use in paleoceanography . I n : EmilianL, C . ( ed . ) The Sea, vol . 7 . Wiley-Interscience , New York, in pres s . Vincent, E . , Killingley, J . S . , Berger, W . H . ( 1 97 9 ) : Late Miocene carbon shift in the Indian Ocean. Geological Society of America, Abstracts with Program 1 1 : 5 3 2 . Vincent, E . , Killingley, J . S . , Berger, W . H . ( 1 98 0 ) : The Magnetic 6 Carbon Shi f t : a change in the ocean ' s 1 3c ; 1 2 c ratio 6 . 2 mi.llion years ago. Marine Micropaleontology 5 : 1 85-2 0 3 .
1 57 Vogt, P . , Bernero , c . , Kovacs, L . , Taylor , P . ( 1 98 1 ) : Structure and plate tectonic evolutipn of the marine Arctic as revealed by aero'magnetics. Oceanologica Acta Supplement to volume 4 , Proceedings 26th International Congress , Geology of Oceans Symposium, Paris , 1 9 8 0 : 2 5-40 . woodruff , F . , Savin, S . M. , Douglas , R . G . ( 1 9 8 1 ) : Miocene stable isotope record : a detailed deep Pac i fic Ocean study and its paleoclimatic implications . Science 2 1 2 : 6 6 5-66 8 . .
Wors ley, T . , Davies , T . ( 1 97. 9 ) : Sea-level fluctuations and deep sea sedimentation rate s . Science 2 0 3 : 455-4 5 6 . worthington , L . V. ( 1 9 6 8 ) : Genesis and evolution o f water wasses. Meteorological Monograph 8 : 6 3 -67. . ' Wright, W . B . ( 1 9 37 ) : The Quaternary Ice Age. Macmillan, London, 4 6 5 pp.
.Part ITA. Event Stratification
Calcareous and Quartz-Sandy Tempestites
<"
General Remarks About Event Deposits A. SEILACHER
Abstract: Rare, but geologica·lly common events such as severe storms , floods , turbidity currents , seismic shocks and volcanic eruptions leave behind bed units with distinctive sedimentological and ecological features and succ.e ssions . Event stratigraphy has pOtential applications in correlation , basin analysis and evolutionary research. The present generation of earth scientists has become aware that the history of the biosphere is not only one of gradual and stately changes but that it is accentuated by events of various kinds and degrees , most of which are so rar.e that they refute a uniformitarian approach . In the context of the present work shop we have not dealt with the dramatic "very rare events " that may be responsible for global faunal changes arid not even with the more common sea level changes due to glaciations and changes in the rates of sea floor spreading . We rather focuss e"d on more local catastrophies that are common enough to appear in any section, bu t in terms of human life spans and experience still deserve to be called "rare events " . 1 . Ki�ds of Rare, Event Deposits Volcanic ashfalls (and dust from meteoric impac�s) are examples in which geochemical and crista llographic " fingerprints" may be used to distinguish fndividual beds over long distances ( "tephra stratigraph y " ; WINTER, 1 9 7 7 and in press) ; but apart from their mineralogic composition , such beds are little distinctive with respect to sedimentological or ecological features . Similarly , seismic shocks may alter the structure of the gradationally compacted upper sediment layers in a dist'inctive way ( " seismites " , SEILACHER, 1 9 6 9 ) . But. their sedimentological and ecological effects are negligeabl� except through mass flows and turbidity currents that they may trigger. In this case , however , the resulting beds can no more be distinguished from olistostromes or turbidites released by other kinds of events . Cyclic and Even t Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Sei.lacher) © Springer 1982
162
The effects of turbulence events are more complex , because they imply sedimentological as well as ecological successions within the depositional unit. Storm deposits (tempestites } , turbidity current deposits ( turbidites } and f lood deposits ( inundites) have in common ; { 1 ) that they reflect the onset, culmination and waning of water turbulence during the event by distinctive erosional and depositional structures .
'"
'
( 2 ) that they re-distribute the organic and inorganic sediment material along a vertical {bottom to top) and horizontal (shallow to deep) gradient . ( 3 ) that they change the ecological situation for benthic organisms by altering the consistency and/or the food content of the bottom for a biologically relevant period after the event . In the following paragraphs only the effects of turbulence events � with special emphasis on tempestites , will be further discussed . 2.
Sedimentologic Conse'quences of Turbulence Events
In the ideal case we can assume a symmetric succession of erosional phases during the increase, and of depos itional phases during the decrease , of the episodic turbulence (Fig . l a ) . Erosional Phases of different magnitude can be distinguished in the record as far as they reflec·t a compactional gradient within an otherwise uniform substrate . Depending on the strength of the event , increasingly consistent layers will be reached by the erosion . The result is a succession of erosional phenomena , of which only the · last generation will be preserved as casts on the sole of t�e overlying event deposit . The gradation of the depositional phases during the waning of the epi�odic turbulence is two-fold . Given a uniform sediment , bed forms will change according to the decreasing modes of flow regimes and particle transport . In most cases , however , the transported sediment is not uniform, but contains particles of varying s i z e , shape and specific weight, which will be deposited in a graded succession according to their settling velocity . In the case of a polymodal particle content , sedimentation can
163
become discontinuous , the phases being separated by intervals of non-sedimentation . The symmetrY between erosional and depositional level in the ideal cycle is most Closely approximated in tempestites , because the turbulence is wave-domina·ted and more or less stationary , i . e . lateral sediment transport i s subOrdinate . In turbidites and inundites , however , the turbulence peak shifts later.ally during the even t , so that the levels of the erosional and the depositional phases in any given place will rarely correspond (Fig . l b ) . The . same - i s true in rip currents that compensate for coastal water build-ups during storm s . Another complication results from the fact that most substrates are not homogenous . In many cases the substrate already contains the sedimentologic memories of previous events that may change the erosion behaviour from layer to layer . This memory is less consequential in sandy sediments , where only shelly or congl.o meratic layers block the erosion. I t is more important in muddy sediments , in which previous erosion surfaces become further compacted by intermittent overload . The memory becomes most . enhanced in carbonate mud s , because early diagenesis tends to selectively cement erosional mud s·u rfaces buried under calcarenitic or S helly event deposits , so that these surfaces Qecome more and more resistant reference horizons during repeated re-burial and re-exposure by subsequent events . The processes involved are not yet well und�rstood , but field evidence suggests that they are laigely responsible for the formation of hardgrounds and their common association with tempestitic condensation horizons (FURSICH , 1 9 7 1 ) in shallow marine sequences , particularly during regress ive phases caused by lowering of the sea level or reduced subsidence . In principle , condensation phenomena may occur in all kinds o f turbulence events , but due to the higher rates of net sedimentation and lateral transport in turbiditic and flood regimes , they are less prominent in these than in storm-dominated sequences . In shallow seas , most background sediments become deposited only temporari ly , because the next storm is likely to rework them and carry them further down towards the center of the basin. What we eventually see in the sedimentary record is the final
�,:---
--
- ----¥---
-4-*-•"'"'"'""·
,.., _,_ ,;:y-,:_,:,:,.:"-·-�:--
PROXIMALITY GRADIENTS SYM M E T R Y
'
,, .'
.
'
Substrate w. compaction-gradient : Event deposit · · ·
,.,
, , '"
;
.6 I I
Substrate memorizing previous events
-M
J
�
Fig. 1 . A) In the ideal case , levels of the erosional (a-c) and depositional regime {A-C) should cor respond at any point along the proximal-distal gradient of a turbulence event ( upper diagram) . In re ality ( lower diagram) , shoreward accumulation O f water masses (during a storm� , or gravity flows fol lowing the paleoslope , have commonly _ d1storted this syffimetry, so that lower levels of erosion are fol lowed by unproportionately high-level deposition. This effect is most pronounced in turbidites and flood deposi t s ; but i t may also occur in s torm deposits . As one consequence , firm ground representing high level erosion may be left without depositional cover in the proximal zone. B-H) These diagrams , with dramatically exaggerated vertical scale , visualize vertical and lateral modifications in a tempestite . Erosion is directly proportional to the energy level (decreasing from left to right) only in homogeneous substrate ( B ) . In gradationally compacted mud .(C-E ) it will decre ase at lower levels . In sediments strUctured by the sedimentary memories of previous events (F-H ) , erosion wil l follow ancient bedding planes and expose them over wide areas according to their ero sional resistivity . Deposition is continuous only if the available event sediment is uniform. Poly modal grain size distribution, usual in pre-sorted shallow marine sediments , introduces intervals o f non-sedimentation (black arrows ) , during which the exposed surfaces may b e modified by hydrodynamic (shell orientation; ripple reworking) or by biologic ( trace formation) processes
8l
166
result of countless erosional and depositiona! .episodes . Of these only the strongest can still be recognized , because this event tends to wipe out the traces of intermittent weaker events . The degree of cannibalism and event condensation is an important facies criterion , because it allows us to distinguish between proximal and distal zones in a lateral , and between times of faster or slower subsidence and deposition in a vertical, direction. 3 . Ecologic Consequences of Turbulence Events
From our human perspective we tend to overrate the immediate , destructive impacts of catastrophic events . In terms of geologic and evolutionary time , however , the less dramatic after-effects are the more important ones . Event erosion commonly disturbs and removes epibenthic and shallow infaunal populations over large areas , their dead remains becoming transported to other environments ( for instance to the beach) or incorporated in the overlying event deposits . Their fate will be discussed in the chapter on taphonomic consequences . Since only limited areas are affected by turbulence events , their. recolonization from unaffected regions in the neighbourhood is no problem . Neverthel�ss _the after-event community commonly differs in character and species content from the backgro�nd commuriity. This is readily understandable in proximal zones of asymmetrical event deposits , where the eroded surfaces have remained uncovered , or the sandy, shelly or gravelly sedimentation was not followed by a muddy tai l . The firmer or coarser substrates naturally attract a fauna different from the native background community (oysters , brachiopods , crinoids , stromatolites; firm ground burrowers of the Glossifungites association ) . Examples are firm- and hardground communities (FURS ICH , 1 9 7 1 ; see also contribution by AIGNER) and the attached communities or community successions of autochthonous coquinas (see contributio_n by HAGDORN & MUNDLOS ) . It should be
noted, howeve r , that event-condensation commonly produces "pseudo-successions" of communities separated by burial/reac � ivation intervals . Their regular sequence does not reflect biological interdependence , but the maturation of the substrate during subsequent events (Fig . 2 ) .
167
@ Soft ground continuously bioturbated by deposit feeders ( end of Maliere sedimentation)
Erosional firm ground burrowed by 1 s t . Tha l a s s inoides generation @ Reactivation of same horizon after burial & transfor mation into hard ground @ Below hard cavities are wa•sh.ed out along ancient burrows . . @ Encrus ters and borers set tle on exposed rock surfaces QD' cavities filled with soft mud ( Couche Verte) ® After reactivati on , compacted fills burrowed by 2nd
@ Buri
!Of!S 2'na' "'s s i n .
generation
oncoids · & encrusta tion by stromatoli tes after repeated reactivation ( Congl .����� de Bayeux ) .
G) Multiple reburial by
oolites with size-graded mixture of fossils from different zones (Calc . a OolitheS Ferrugineuses ) .
Fig. 2 . The already complex history of a mid-Jurassic condensed section (FURSICH 1 9 7 1 ) can be better Uriderstood if we add a number of burial/reactivation events ( arrows) that have left no direct sedimentary record except in the oolithe ( i ) . In this modified view the observed faunistic sequences represent not true ecological successions , but independent communities that did respond to diffe rent substrate conditions in a maturing reference horizon and were separated by long burial intervals
168
But post-event communities also tend to differ from the background fauna if the top of the event deposit is muddy and granulometrica lly undistinguishable from the background mud . The difference is most pro?ounced in the turbiditic flysch facies , where the pr�-turbidite background burrows (preserved as casts on the sole faces) are consistently different from the burroWs that are dug to different levels by the one-phase post-turbidite community. This difference mainly reflects food supply : While the pre-turbiditic background fauna subsists on an impoverished but continuous rain · of degraded organic material from the photic zone , the post-turbidite fauna makes use of the fact that detrital food, derived from local reworking or . event-imported from shelf areas , is concentrated in the top layers of the graded event deposit . Accordingly the post-event communities are more opportunistic, i . e . their species diversity is lower. and differs from bed to bed in spite of high densities . There is also a difference in trophic s trategies : Direct sedi�ent - feeding prevails in the post-turbidite communities , while the less compact but highly organized patterns of pre-tur bidite burrows suggest food extraction .with the help of exo symbiotically 11farmed " microbionts {SEILACHER , 1 9 7 7 ) .
\
,,,,
Similar, t�ough less pronounced differences between pre- and post-event mud burrowers can be expected in f lood and storm beds . Distinction of the two would be useful to pin-point the top of the event-deposited muds either directly or by way of the penetration level of the stratified burrow community that is recorded on the interface between the coarser and the einer part of the event deposit. 4 . 'f<;phonomic Consequences of Turbulence Events
In the paleontological record , the immediate victims of catastrophic events play a - subordinate - role. Notable exceptions are autochthonous brachiopod communities that became buried in life position in the lower few centimeters of shallow marine sandstone beds (SEILACHER , 1 9 6 8 ) , obviously without previous erosion or transport. Event-imported arthropods preserved at the end of their last track at the sole of Solnhofen lithographic limestone beds (GOLDRING & SEILACaER, 1 9 7 1 ) may be cited as another example .
169
r
I
More mobile organisms may start to work their way up trough the smothering sediment , leaving escapement tracks behind. This reaction , however , depends on the thickness and the kind of the overlying sediment. In modern experiments , NICHOLS et a l . ( 1 9 7 8 ) found that escapement was not attempted i f the overload exceeded about 30 em. Escapement was more difficult o'r impos sible if the
L
I
I I
I
smothering sediment was finer grained. The common occurrence of completely preserved echinoderms at the top of the coarser part of event deposits ( ROSENKRANZ , 1 9 7 1 ) possibly ref lects the fcital c loggi-ng of their ambulacral system by the fine mud that was d�posited during the final phase of the event� Most body fossils found in event-deposits , however , are reworke d . In par-autochthonous coquinas (see contributions by T . AIGNER and HAGDORN & · MUNDLOS) they largely represent the local epi- and infauna of the background mud s . Their faunal spectrum may in fact , be less distorted in the coquinas than in their native muddy sediment , where the aragonitic shells tend to become selectively dissolved during early diagenesis . Repeated reworking , such as occurs in "cannibalistic" storm beds ,
r·:
Ii
I
wi l l eventually change the faunal spectrum in the coquinas as wel l . Aragon i tic shells , diagenetically weakened during buria l , disaPpear first (although new ones may be added during each event) . Calcitic shells w i l l be next , probably followed by
echinoderm .remains 1 whose high-magnesium calcite becomes soon transformed into a rather resistant and eventually solid form of cal9ite. Most resistant are the apatitic skeletal remains , particularly teeth , because they also tend to gain, rather than loose , durability during burial in phosphorous-rich sediments . This is effiphasized by the fact that in the resulting bone beds
I
the originally soft coprolites , phospatized and brok �n during repeated burial and reworking 1 form a common element (see
I'
Thus all-shell coquinas , calcitic shell beds , crinoidal limestones and bone beds form a series of increasingly mature concentration
I
I
I
I
! j':
I
contribution by
w.
REIF ) .
deposits. Their. distribution in the stratigraphic co lumn reflects the degree of cannibalism and of regressi vi ty, wi t.h the bone
170
beds accentuating the final {or by renewed reworking the following initial) phase of a transgressive - regressive cycl e . A few deviations from this model should b e mentioned . 1.
Since new material becomes admixed during every eve:n,t , c annibalistic event deposits may always contain well preserved elements of low durability , though with a much lower percentage than in the original thanatocoenosi s .
2 . There are condensation horizons i n which 11ghost ?-nunonites" are
,. ·:.
as well preserved as the associated younger forms (FURSICH , 1 9 7 1 ; contribution by G . GEBHARD in this volume ) . Still their close association with manyphase hard grounds and i ncrustations below , plus the fact that the heterochronous ammonites are size-graded w�thin the condensed layer , strongly suggest repeated reworking. In these cases it is im�ortant to note that the host sediment largely consists of aragqnitic muds or oolites , by which the shells would be diagenetically protected , while the storm reworking .may have been too rare and too short to effectively abrade the fossils . 3 . It should also be remembered that the ecologic situation may
have changed considerably during the complex h istory of one bed . While the first tempestite cont�ined only reworked shells of · the soft-mud fauna � the basal surface may have subsequelltly. been colonized by firm- and eventually hard-bottom communities during later exposure s . Remains of all communities , plus current-imported allochthonous forms , will be incorporated i nto the final shell bed . 4 . Early diagenetic cementation is favoured not only below the
eroded mud surfaces . In addition, pressure shadow concretions may form in mudfilled shells , strongly increasing their duiability in subsequent cycles {contribution by GEBHARD ) These as well as ordinary concretions will increase the amount of reworkable diaclasts during success ive events . Multiple growth ( "hiatus concretions'' VOIGT1 1 9 6 8 and i-ncrustation or boring by sessile organisms {KENNEDY & GARRISON , 1 9 7 5 ) may reveal the complex histories of the individual clasts in such cases . · •
171
5 . Fields of Application
Because of the interrelationship of sedimentological and biologi cal processes , the concept of event-stratigraphy is relevant to dif ferent fields of research . 5 . 1 . Shelf Sedimentation apd Geomorphology
Taking a steady state ocean as a null-hypothes i s , we should expect the marginal sediment wedge to develope an equilibrium surface near the extreme s torm wave. base . Except in coastal �reas and aroUnd carbonate buildups , in which sediment pro duction and resistivity may far exceed rare storm erosion, extreme events would tend to winnow down excessive sediment accumulations to this equilibrium leve l , while the winnowed fines would gradually prograde the shelf edge basinwards . The sa·me basic model can be applied to epicontinental basins and lakes , but with a shallower shelf level corresponding to the reduced storm wave depth . . In this paradigm, negative changes in relative sea · level (caused . by tectoriic , e �s tatic or sedimentational processes ) will be
reflected by condensations of coarser and more durable sediments , 1 while a re·lative sea level rise Will favour more complete accu mulation of finer sediment s , on the shelf surface. In the case of a rapid rise i n sea leve l , however, the old shelf sbrface could become inactivated , forming a terrace below a new shelf prograding at a higher leve l . The imp lications o f this paradigm for the analysis o f lar ge-scale stratigraphic sequences and for the prospection of hydrocarbon and mineral deposits are obvious .
5 . 2 . Basin Analysis Just as turbidites , which have been used in the past to re _ · construct the geometry of flysch basins , storm and flood depo sits provide distality criteri� either individually or on a sta tistical basis (see contribution by AIGNER ) . Since s torm waves (and floods ) originate at sea level and reach deeper the stronger
172
they are , the number of tempestites between fingerprinted marker beds may be also used to contour the basin morphology (AIGNER, 1 9 79 ) , while their occurrence in general prov·ides . a paleobathymetric datum. 5 . 3 . High- resolution Stratigraphic Correlation Since the events here considered do last only for days , they potentially provide a measure stick for within-basin correlation that is many orders of magnitude more exact than the evolutionary change ·of index fossils . The usefulness of this measure stick in disparate outcrops depends on · our ability to identify individual beds by rhythmograms or 'by ecological or geochemical fingerprinting.
The success of seisrnostratigraphy (PAYTON 1 9 77 }/t�hich allows to trace physically distinct beds continuously , probably
rests to a large part on event stratification. 5 . 4 . Community Evolution Since turbulence events intermittently provide similar bottom conditions that allow the expansion of a specific post-event benthic fauna , . community structures · in subsequent colonisation episodes should provide an answer as to how random this structure actually is . Also there may be acci dental or evolutionary replacements if there is an upper limit to species diversity . 5 . 5 . Species Evolution In the discussion about a gradualist�c versus a punctuational mode of evolution , storm beds may also provide important evidence . I f our assumption is correct, population sizes of firm- and hardground dwellers became extremely expanded following erosional events and became reduced during the long intervals ,which in turn were the high time for the soft mud background fauna . Preliminary observations {Terebratula beds of the German Muschelkalk; Oyster and carolia beds in the Eocene of Egypt) suggest that there is a considerable change in form , size and behaviour from one autochthonous coquina to the next and that this change is not linear . I n comparison , the species of the background fauna seem to change con·siderably less ( SEILACHER , 1 9 8 1 ) .
173
In conclusion , we feel that the complexity of the processes involved and the variety of phenomena to be observed make· event deposits , in particular the tempestite s , an interesting field for integrated studies by sedimentologists , geochemists and paleontologists . References AIGNER, T . 1 9 7 9 : Schill-Tempestite im Oberen Muschelkalk , (Trias , SW-Deutschland) . - N . Jb . Geol.Palaont . ,Abh. ��z : 3 2 6 - 3 4 3 . F liRSICH, F . 1 9 71 : H�rtgrUnde und Kondensation im Dogger von Ca1vados . - N . Jb . Geol . PaUiont . , Abh.1 ,J.,4� : 3 1 3-342 . GOLDRING , R .
&
SE ILACHER , A . 1 9 7 1 : Limulid undertracks and their
sedimentological implications . - N . Jb . Geol .Palaont . , Abh .
,),;);( : 4 2 2- 4 4 2 . KENNEDY , W . J .
&
KLINGE R , H . C . 1 9 7 2 : Hiatus concretions and
&
GARRISON, R . E . 1 9 7 5 : Morphology and genes is of
hardground 'horizons in the Cretaceous of Zululand . Paleontology, J � : 5 3 9 - 5 4 9 . KENNEDY , W . J .
nodular phosphates in the Cenomanian Glauconitic Marl of South-east Eng��n d . - Lethaia , � : 3 3 9-360 . NICHOLS , J . A . ; ROWE , G . T . ; CLIFFORD , C . H . ; YOUNG, R . A . 1 9 7 8 : In situ experiments on the burial of marine invertebrates . J . Sed . Petr .1 �� : 4 1 9 - 4 2 5 . PAYTON , C . E . {ed .·) 1 9 7 7 : Seismic stratigraphy - Application to hydrocarbon exploration . - AAPG Mem . , �g . ROSENKRANZ , D . 1 9 7 1 : Zur Sedimentologie und 6kologie von Echinodermen-Lagerstatten . - N . Jb . Geol .Palaont . , Abh . 1 J,:j� : 2 2 1 -2 5 8 . SEILACHER, A . 1 9 6 8 : Origin and diagenesis of the Oriskany Sandstone ( Lower Devonian , Appalachians) as reflected in its shell fossi ls . - I n : Recent Developments in Carbonate Sedimentology in Central Europe , 1 7 5 - 1 8 5 , 7 Abb . , Heidel berg (Springer) 1 9 6 8 . SEILACHER, A . 1 9 6 9 : Fault-graded beds interpreted a s seismi tes . - Sedimentology , �� , 1 5 5 - 1 5 9 , Amsterdam.
174
SEILACHER, A. 1977 : P attern analysis of PaZeodietyon and related trace fossil s . - Trace fossils 2 (CRIMES & HARPER, Spec . Issue No . 9 : 2 8 9 - 33 4 , 1 5 figs ed. ) . Geol •
.
•
.
SEILACHER, A . 1 9 8 1 : Towards an evolutionary stratigraphy . In : Concept and Method in Paleontology ; Acta geo l . Hispan ica, lg: 39-44 . VOIGT , E . 1 9 6 8 : Uber Hiatus-Konkretionen (dargestellt an Bei spieleri aus dem Lias ) . - Geol . Rundsch .1 �� : 2 8 1 - 2 9 6 . WINTER, J . 1 977 : Stabile Spurenelemente als Leit-Indikatoren einer tephrostratigraphischen Korrelation (Grenzbereich Unte�-/Mitteldevon , Eifel-Belgian) . - News l . Stratigr . , g : 1 52 - 1 70 . WINTER, J . ( i n press ) : 11Exakte tephrostratigraphische Korre lation mit morphologisch differenzierten Z irkonpopulationen ( Grenzbereich Unter-/Mittel -Devon , Eifel-Ardenhen) . N . Jb . Geol . Palaont.
Experiments on the Distinction of Wave and Current ' Influenced Shell Accumulations E. FuTIERER
Abstrac t : Edgewise and stringer accumulations o f shells may b e formed by current as well as wave activity , but the results can be dis t�h guished by particular criteria. This distinction will be important for the recognition of wave-generated s torm coquinas . ExtenQing on earlier studies about current orientations of isolated shells , the occurrence of a 2nd stable position is referred to higher current velocities . Principles controlling the familiar orientation of biogenic par t:i cles ( stable positions use.d as current indicators) are valid mainly for isolated objects . This has been shown by many experi ments ( FUTTERER, N . Jb . Geol . Palaont . , Abh . l�g , 1 9 7 8 ) . In shell accumulations these stable positions are rare due to the reciprocal impediments exerted by neighbouring objects . Since the formation of shell accumulations is very complex, field observations must be supplement by experimental data , if we want to 11decode" the orig1..n and the hydrodynamic environment of fossil shell accumu lations .
1 . Edgewise Shell Accumulations
l
] ''
I
!
Edgewise coquinas are generally attributed to wave action (MI I , Res . Bull . , �g , 1 9 5 7 ; SCHAFER , Ecology and Palaeoecology o f Marine Envirortments , 1 9 7 2 ) in analog to flat pebbles placed vertically by wave action ( ROZANSKI , J . Geol . , �1 1 9 4 3 ; DIONNE , Canad . J . , Earth S c . , � � 1 9 7 1 ; SANDERSON & DONOVAN , J . Sediment. Petrol . , �� , 1 9 7 4 ) . Only few authors refer edgewise shell accumulations to --
current action (MULLER, lehrb . d . Palaozoologie ) . All edgewise shell accumulations have in common that they appear in shallow water and that the shells and pebbles involved are more or less flat . Flume studies with a sample of single valves of Mya arenaria demon
I
l l !.
strate that edgewis e shell accumulations form under wave as well as current conditions . Howeve r , the results can be distinguished in the two hydrodynamic regimes ( see Tab . 1 ) . Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed . by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
176
Tab . 1 .
. Distinction of wave and current generated edgewise shell accumulations waves
currents
direction of long
di fferent
shell axes
orientations
:': uniform, at right angles to the current
inclination
various
constant , generally
directions
upcurrent
stacks in various directions
imbrication in one direction ( down-current)
accumulations
In shal low water , waves and currents commonly occur in combination, The dominant for ce , however, determines the type of the resulting edgewise shell accumulations . 2.
Linear Shell Accumulations
Longitudinal shell accumulations .nstringers·" with more than 20 specimens have been recorded · from fossil c:eposi ts by several au thors ( HAUF."F , Paleontographica, §,£, 1 9 2 1 ; KLii.HN , Jb . vaterl . Ver . Naturkd . Wlirtt . , �g , 1 9 2 9 ; MOORS , Sed . Geo l . , � � 1 9 70 ; BRENNER , N . Jb . Geol . Palao n t . Abh . , l�J , 1 9 7 6 ) . The observed accumulations are mainly composed of ammonites . Shells of pelecypods , ostracods and graptolites , however , can also form such linear accumulations . I t is d�fficult to decide whether their formation is due to wave or current action. Some criteria allowing this distinction have f.'.f,
been found by field observations . in the Wealden shales of s . Eng land ( together with T . AIGNER) and by supplementary flume experi 2 ) . I t is important to stress that longitudinal shell bands formed by currents run parallel to the current direc tion, whereas linear shell accumulations caused by wave action are
ments ( see tab
•
.
parallel to the wave crests . In shallow water environments wave motion is generally combined with currents , the direction of which is more or less transversal to the wave crests . Linear shell accumulations occur mostly in argillaceous deposits ( e . g . graptolite shales , Lias epsilon b ituminous shales , Wealden shales ) , deposited under quiet water conditions . As flume experi ments show, the occurrence of shell bands is an unequivocable in dication that water movement (waves or currents) has at least epi sodically influences
the
sediment.
177
Tab. 2 .
Distinction between linear shell accumulations caused by wave and current action waves
distance between
uniform, corres
shell bands
ponding to ripple
currents
variable
dis tance frequenc y of
always numerous
shell bands shell position wi th.im the bands deposition of very small biogenic par
imbrication in long axis of shells parallel to the bands one direction on both s i d e s only on the lee ward side of the of the bands bands
ticles direction of gutter casts caused by
often isolated 1 rarely numerous
transversal to the bands
parallel to the bands
temporary currents
3 . Appendix - Additional Studies with Isolated Biogenic Particles 3 . 1 . Single Pelecypod Valves I
A number of observations with single shell valves have shown that a second stable position occurs during their transport ( FUTTERE R , N . Jb . Geol. Palaont . , Abh . , l�g, 1 9 7 8 ) . Subsequently , left v�lves of abOut 20 different pelecypod species have been se-
I
J I I
1
I
I
I
systematic transport•stability studies -- depending lected for on the position of their umboes -- in an unidirectional current. The valves were placed in the current with the convex sides up in four different· umbo positions - each displaced by 90° . Fig . 1 shows the following results for 3 variously formed types of pele cypods : ( a ) Circular pelecypods ( Gtycimeri s ) are most stable when their umboes point down-stream; (b) Elongated tri angular pelecypods with terminal umbo ( My t i Z u s ) are also most stable when their umboes point down-stream• { c ) Elliptical pelecypods with the umbo at one of the long sides (Pe trico Z a ) are roo st stable when the long axis is parallel
to the current and the posterior end of the valve points up stream.
0
178 "'
§ 60 '
270°
+ o•
90"
180°
o::>
)I
...··
· ·· ...- · ·· · ·
.... .
40 .-
20
0
become •
• •
Glycimeris
Myfi/us
glycimeris
edu/is
Petr icofa
pholadiformis
270°
0°
Position of umbo
The principles hitherto believed to govern shell orientation (MULLER, Abh. Dt .. Akad . Wiss . Berlin, Kl . Math . u . All g . Natur wiss . , � � 1 9 50) are supplemented but not contradicted by these results . The occurrence of pelecypod shells with the s econd stable position in fossil ' deposits , however , suggests stronger currents (critical velocity of transport more than 50 cmjs ) . 3 . 2 . Gastropod Shells Evaluation ( together with T. AIGNER) of plano-spiral and troche spiral gastropod shells (Planorbina sp . and G alha s p . respecti vely) from Oligocene freshwater deposits ( Bembridge limestone) in S . England ( Isle of Wight) confirmed the stable orientation found in flume studies ( FUTTERER , N. Jb . Geo l . Palaont. Abh . , J�g, 1 9 7 8 ) . As the orientation roses show ( F i g . 2 } , Planorbina shells have their stable position with the aperture downstream and the margin of the aperture parallel to the current. The high spired Galba shells lie in a stable position with the long axis · parallel to the curren t , but apart from the predomina�t maximum with the apex-stream (most stable position ) , there is a smaller submaximum with the apex down-stream. Experiments in the flume have shown taht troche-spiral shells ( e . g . Lymnae a ) tend to get anchored with the aperture lying flat on the bottom, whereby the apex may turn either against or with the current .
179
Fig. 2 . Orientation roses for Planorbina ( 2 1 readings) and Galba ( 1 3 1 readings) from the Bembri'dge limestone ( O ligocene , Isle of Wight, s . England)
Planorbina
121I
Golba
1 1 31 I
15% '
N
t
//
/
'
/
' '
References FUTTERER , E . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Untersuchungen tiber die Sink- und Transport geschwindigkeit biogener Hartteile . - N. Jb .. Geol . PaUion t . Abh . , d�� : 3 1 8- 3 5 9 . FUTTERER, E . ( 1 9 7 8 ) : Fossil-Lagerstatten Nr . 4 4 : Studien Uber die Einregelung , Anlagerung und E inbettung biogener Hartteile im StrOmungskanal . - N . Jb . Geol . Palaont . Abh . , J�g : 8 7 - 1 3 1 .
Calcareous Tempestites: Storm-dominated Stratification in Upper Muschelkalk Limestones (Middle Trias, SW-Germany) T. AIGNER Abstract : Storm-induced high energy events dominate stratifica tion phenomena in Upper Muschelkalk epicontinental carbonates . Within s torm beds ( tempestites) diagnostic sedimentological and paleoecological features show an orderly gradation from bottom to top and from proximal to dtstal facies . ThiS concept has implications for basin ana�ysis , stratigraphy, paleoecology and diagenesis .
1 . In traduction Stratification in carbonates is far from being fully understood . Apart from long-term allocyclic changes ( see section 1 of this vo lume ) , changes in 'energy level may be responsible for bedding and lamination in limestones { e . g . HARDIE
&
GINSBURG , 1 9 7 7 ) . In addition ,
diagenetic processes have commonly altered or enhanced the original picture. Studies in recent sediments demonstrate the importance of powerful storm event s , which may have significant effects in shelf morphology and sediment transport (reviews in KELLING & MULLIN 1 9 7 5 and in BRENCHLEY et ai . 1 9 79 ) . Although storm effects in ancient rocks cannot be proven with absolute certainty , the object of this paper is to demonstrate examples of event-stratification from the Upper Muschelkalk (Middle Trias , SW-Germany) , which are likely due to storms (AIGNER 1 9 77 , 1 9 7 9 ) and thus represent " tempestites 11 (AGER 1973) •
The Muschelkalk is a shallow marine epicontinental carbonate se quence , representing a marine ingression into the Germanic Basin separating_ the continental phases of the Lower and Upper Trias . Further SE , borehole data suggest a: belt of sandy, probably litto ral sediments along . the NE-SW trending shoreline (Fig. 1 ) . In an offshore direction , a zone of crinoidal or shelly , partly oolitic "shoals" is follOwed by the more open marine "Tonpla:tten " facies , whiqh comprises laterally persistent limestones interbedded with mar l s . It is in this facies that tempestites can be most clearly recognized (Fig. 2 ) . Cyclic and Event Stratification (ed. by Einsele/Seilacher) © Springer 1982
F 1 81
Fig. 1 .
Paleogeographical setting 1 i sopachs ·and overall facies cross-section of the Upper Muschelkalk basin (Modified after GEYER & GWINNER 1 9 6 8 , MUNDLOS 1 9 7 6 , and AIGNER & FUTTERER 1 9 7 8 )
2 . Descriptions 2 . 1 . Lithofacies Limest�nes vary between calcirudites , calcarenites and calcilutites . PackS tone depositional textures are most abundant , but mudstones ,
.:·. '
I
wackestones and even grainstones may also be found . Mol luscan , brachiopod (and occasiona l vertebrate ) bioclasts form the bulk of the components , while few smaller fossils can be recognised ·
in the calcilutites , except for Schizospha$re Z-la . Intraclasts (often traceable to subj acent layers) and extraclasts ( s i lt/fine sandstone and "Black Pebbles " ) are particularily common in thicker beds. Lithoclasts , usually subangular in shape, range in size from a few
mrn
up to 40 x 50 x. 5 ern ( in marginal areas )
•
Bed thickness ranges between a few ern and a few dm. Although the bedding is very regular , amalgamation of beds is conspicuous in many instances. A em-thick "1.!-nderbed" of microsparite firmly attached to the base of many tempestites , probably represents a diagenetic overprint (see 4 . 1 . ) .
182
Fig. 2 . Typical stratification sequences through , Muschelkalk tempestites : A } basal shell lag, followed by plane lamination and toppe d by wave-ripple lamination (Upper Muschel kalk , Kernmtihle ) . B ) parallel and low-angle lamination, followed by convolute bedding ( Upper Muschelkalk , Gottwolls hausen) C ) shell bed with platY interclasts showing imbrication. (Lower Muschelkalk , leg. R. RAUSCH) . •
D ) graded packstone (note mud-shelters below shells and imbricated f ibrics) , passing into slightly convoluted plane bed and into ripples (Upper Muschelkalk , Crailsheirn) 2 . 2 . succession Within Single Beds a) The base of an individual bed is always sharp and erosional . Sole marks include large scours (up to several m broad and 20 em deep ) , gutter casts and tool marks (Fig. 3d , e ) . Thes e , however , are commonly hidden by the encrusting underbed . b) Internally , limestone beds display three main types of succes sions :
(Fig. 2 )
( 1 } crudely graded bedding of litho- and bio
clast s , ( 2 ) couplet of a basal shell l�yer followed by laminated calcilutite and ( 3 ) laminated calcilutite alone . Bioclasts show all stages of disarticulation and shells may be imbricated,
183
edge-wise or convex-down , although orientations more or less pa rallel to the bedding plane predominate . Laminations include in this succession - plane lamination , low angle and hummocky cross-stratification , wave-ripple lamination . Rippledrift and convolute bedding also occur in some beds (Fig. 2 ) .
c ) Bed tops may be of four basic types : { 1 } gradational to the over lying marls , ( 2 ) with primary current lineation ( Fig . 3 c) , ( 3 ) as hardground ( 4 ) with wave-ripples (height ranging between 1 and 10 em, wavelenghths between 60-100 - .i n calcarenites/rudite s , Fig. 3 a , b - and 7 - 1 5 em - 'in calcilutite s ) . Wave ripples are bften slightly asymmetrical both in shape and internal structure , and their crests trend parallel or s lightly oblique to the suppo sed shoreline .
Fig. 3 . Some common top (a-c) and bottom features (d-e ) in calcareous tempestites . a) large-scale wave-ripples in cross-section with "spill over11 ( scale 2 5 em) . Troch i tenkalk, Kernmi.ihle . b ) wave-ripple field ( length of compass 1 1 em) . Upper Hauptmuschelkalk, Barenhaldenmlih l e . c ) pr1mary current lineation on bed top. d) scour with abundant rip up clasts . e ) tool marks at bottom surface of a distal tempe's tite
184
2 . 3 . Biofacies
a) The erosional bed bases may be burrowed by Glossifungites and Talassinoides Pebbles and larger reworked plates are commonly concentrated near the base and are often encrusted on both sides with several stages of colonisation (AIGNER 1 9 7 9 , Fig. 7 ) . b ) The shelly fauna within the coquinas may range between two types : ( 1 ) soft bottom association, dominated by shallow burrowing and epifauna·l bivalves , scaphopods and gastropods (Myophoria, Pseudoaorbula,
;·.::
Hoernesia,
Entolium, Enta l i s ,
Omphaloptyaha
etc. ) . In contrast ,, the deep-burrowing bivalve P l euromya is rare in the shell pave�ents while it is most abundant in the interstratified marls . ( 2 ) mixed faunas , containing epifaunal Terebratulids , Lima , Pecti nids ,. and epifaunal encrusters (Enantios treon_, Placunop s i s ) i n addition t o elements from ( 1 ) . c ) Three different biologic situations can be recognised at bed tops (Fi.g. 4 ) : ( 1 ) Topmost part o.f beds bioturbated and penetrated by spreite burrows (Rhizooora l lium_, Tei a h i a hnus ) , the degree of biOturbation significantly decreasing downward and commonly stopping at top of the lower coquinoidal part . ( 2 ) Epifaunal bivalves ( e . g . Lima_, Pectinids , partly in life attitude} and btachiopods colonising upper sur faces . { 3 ) Hardgrounds , perforated by borers and encrusted by Ena n t i o s treon and PZaaunopsi s .
Fig. 4 . Ecological variation in post-tempestite fauna. - softground, burrowed by Teiohiehnius (Upper Muschelkalk, Ummenhofen) - firmground, colonised by Lima and Pecten ( Lower Muschelkalk , leg . H . HAGDORN) hardground, encrusted by oysters (Upper Muschelkalk, Heldenmtihle) -
185 2 . 4 . Results
· ( 1 ) Stratification similar to the BOUMA-sequence suggests that many limestone beds formed under high-energy conditions in a waning flow regime . ( 2 ) Some of the beds , mainly the thinner and finer grained ones , were rapidly deposited as one-event beds . ( 3 ) Other beds , mainly the thicker and coarser ones , represent the accumulation of several erosive and depositional events , i . e . they are multiple-event beds . Mixed faunas and abundant extraclasts in these composite beds indicate a multiple pro venance or a complex series of truncation and colonisation episodes . IDEAL TEMPESTITE- SEQUENCE + HYDRODYNAMIC INTEPRETATION
1i•1@1#11;1·i1¥ I. ��== � � ��p��----L--=_O���� � = j I ! - � �� � - - - - t -
pelitic division w v
LAMINAR FLOW M
UPPER FLOW M -
graded bedding
redeposition of suspend ed detritus .
very low
--mOd;ra
-
w
high
I
I
1
-
-
-
-
-
very high
very low
Fig. 5 ,
The idealised tempestite sequence corresponds closely to the BOUMA-sequence , except for the wave-rippled top . Since plane lamination in most cases passes gradually into wave-ripple lamination , wave-ripples belong to the complete tempestite sequence and are not due to a subsequent phase of reworking
3 . Interpretation
3 . 1 . Processes a) Depositional Environment . The abundance of fine-grained shelf se diment suggests an environment below normal wave-base which was disturbed only episodically by storm waves . On the other h and , the f auna indicates a marine shelf platform.
186 Since many beds are laterally persistent for several kilometers , a relatively even topography with a low paleo-slope towards the basin center may be inferred . b) Frequency of Events . From Plaeunopsis growth rates , WAGNER ( 1 93 6 ) assumed 2 5 000 years for the deposition o f one meter of Muschelkalk sediment giving an average sedimentation rate of 4 cm/1000 y . Assu ming roughly 10 m . y . for the deposition of about 200 m sediment (re presenting the whole Muschelkalk) , sedimentation rate would be 2 cm/1000 y . Since 5 - 10 storm beds may be typically present in 1 m , a rough estimate suggests that each event took place every 2 500 . 5 000 years according to �AGNERs assumption and every 5000 - 10 000 years according to the second calculation . Comparable orders of magnitude (one event per 400 - 2 000 years) are given by GOLDRING & LANGENSTRASSEN ( 1 9 7 9 ) for Devonian sheet sandstones . In the Present , AGER ( 1 97 3 ) .reports a 9 5 % probability for a hurricane to occur once every '3 000 years at any one point of the Gulf of Mexico . For Ordo vician storm sandstones , BRENCHLEY et al . ( 1 9 7 9 ) assume a 10 000 1 5 000 year periodicity. Such frequencies are far too low compared to the 20 - 50 year fre quency of major storms in the North Sea ( REINECK et al . 1 9 68 ) . But it should be remembered that it is difficult to single out all the events condensed in composite beds or minor storms that have left little record of their passage . c ) Nature of Events Stratification similar to the BOUMA-sequence (Fig. 2 , 5 ) strongly suggests that many limestone beds were deposited by high-energy events . In shallow marine environments , storms are the most likely· initiating mechanism, but the variety of factors in .•
volved makes detailed int�rpretat!ons difficult. Two main categories of processes, occurring independently , or , more likely , in combina tion , have to be considered (KELLING & MULLIN 1 9 7 5 ) :
( 1 ) Waves : They are responsible for s'tirring-up and rewoiking bottom sediments in-situ and result in 11swell lags" ( BRENNER & DAVIES 19.7 3 ) . SPECHT & BRENNER ( 19 7 9 ) consider fabrics like geopetal voids and grain-sheltered patches as indicative for storm-wave winnowing. ( 2 ) Currents account for lateral transport and deposition of alloch thonous sediment . Various initiating factors (winddrift , back flow currents , storm surge tides) as well as various depositional mechanisms (suspension and bottom currents , see WALKER 1 9 7 9 , and rip currents) may be responsible.
187 Muschelkalk tempestites suggest that both categories were involved: Wave indicators (oscillation ripples , grain-shelters etc . ) are asso ciated with current featu"res (parting lineation , lateral shell transport etc. ) , but current-ripple lamination is conspicuously rare. HAMBLIN & WALKER ( 19 7 9 ) suggested that hummocky cross strati f i cation would be characteristic for density current deposition un der the influence of storm-wave surge below fair-weather wave base . Muschelkalk gutter casts are parallel to shore (AIGNER & FUTTERER 1 9 78 ) , while the oscillation ripples suggest on/Offshore winds and ' wave s ; internal tempestite features indicate offshore flow towards the NW, probably compensating for near-shore water build-up ( comp . HAYES 1 9 6 7 ) .
3 . 2 . Proximality a ) Concept. Storm effects decrease towards deeper, offshore bottoms . This obvious relationship has been demonstrated in modern environ ments (HAYES 1 9 6 7 , fig. 3 ; CURRAY 1 960 , fig. 6 ; POWERS & KINSMAN 1 9 5 3 ; REINECK & SINGH 1 9 7 5 , figs . 4 5 8 and 4 79 ) . The basinward de crease of both storm-waves and s torm-induced currents should be ref 1.ected in a lateral succession of bedforms; i . e . tempestite s , like turbidites , should range between proximal and distal end. types . Muschelkalk storm beds can be arranged within such a proximality framework: { 1 ) Proximal teffipestites are relatively thick-bedded , bioclast-dominated and coarse-grained calcirudite s , commonly for ming composite and amalgamated beds . ( 2 ) Distal equivalents are mud-dOminated and thinner one-event beds , mainly calcilutites (Fig. 6 ) . Detailed correlation of beds shows that massive coarse calCirudites actually do pass laterally into thin finerg�ained calcirudites , calcarenites and calcilutites (Fig. 7 ) . A tempestite-frequency map , computed from log-data of VOLLRATH ( 1 9 55 ; see AIGNER 1 9 7 9 , fig. 5 ) , shows a consistent relationship between the isopachs and 11iso-tempestites " , i . e . a gradual decrease in the number of h i s "SchalentrUmmerk�lke11 (roughly equivalent to proximal beds ) . from marginal to basinal localities in a time-equi valent part of the section. More detailed cross-sections (Fig. 8 ) , however, show that this relationship is probably too simpli fied , because one thick proximal bed may distally split up into several thinner ones (Fig. 7 ) . In any case , tempestite proximality de-
188
Fig . 6 . A ) Typical n proximal tempestite 11 • No'te overall grading, geopetal f i l l of voids , abundance of interclasts and extraclasts ( 11black pebbles11 and s i l tstone clasts . B , C). Typical 11distal tem pestite s 11 : dominance of fine-grained pelleted carbonate with fine bioclastic debri s . At base micro-scours and underbeds SSE
«p r o x i m a l»
pebbly calci rudite
« d i s t .a I»
NNW
3 km
rudite
F i g . 7 . Lateral change in tempestite s : a uproximal11 bed passing within about 3 km into several "distal11 beds . {Exposures Kernmi.ihle - Baren haldenmtihle near Crailsheim, right is basinwards) . This example emphasizes the composite nature of many proximal beds and indicates their potential function as source areas for distal beds
189
creases away from shore , as expressed by a decrease in bed thick ness , grain s i z e , bioclast content, and by a Change in sediment fabrics ( e . g . increase in abundance of mudstones , no grainstones
in basinal s-ection of Fig. 8 ) .
b) Control s . The distribution of proximal and distal tempestites i s likely . to be controlled by water depth and b y a variety of factors
other than depth. Thus , the general sedimentation model (Fig. 10)
of proximal (nearshore) and distal (offshore) beds will be modified
SE
marginal
b asinal
NW
fabrics
bed-0
bed-0
gram s1ze
gram s1ze
"L .,
" cu
. _
Fig. 8 .
.,;
_
� -
:::::
:
Change of tempestite facies in a section from marginal to basinal settings ( a Heldenmlihle , Unterohrn ) . Note the following trends : b =
=
- depositional fabrics : dominance of mudstones and no grainstones in basinal area. - bed-thickness : decrease towards basinal. - grain size: increasing abundance of calcilutites (black) in basinal , distal beds
190
by factors such as shelf morphology and by a number of factors in volving the nature of storms . Subsequent events may also be crucial in enhancing the 11proximal appearance" of a particular bed . Such secondary 11proximalisation11 will become most effective 1 ) in shallo wer near-shore zones , 2 ) in areas of s low rate of subsidence re lative to sedimentation, 3 ) in progradational/regressive s i tuations . Under each of these conditions , proximal tempestites should be more abundant and show evidence of repeated reworking or the amalgama tion of several events and ecologic communitie s .
3 . 3 . Results
·, .�
{ 1 ) Tempestites are deposited in shallow water bY sudden influx of sediment and rapid deposition caused by rare high-energy events , most likely storms and hurricanes. ( 2 ) The particular association of sedimentary str�ctures suggests the presence of both unidirectional and oscillatory currents . ( 3 ) Vertically , tempestite s equences are characteri sed by a) an upward gradient of sedimentary structures , and b) a downward countergradient it:t the degree of bioturbation. ( 4 ) Laterally , tempestites show a more or less pronounced proximality gradient, which may become exaggerated by subsequent ev.ents.
4 . Implications 4 . 1 . Diagenesis Many detrital tempestites show a em-thick layer of microsparite firmly attached to the erosive bas� of the shelly bed. Similar 11underbeds" have been described by MEISCHNER ( 1 9 6 7 ) and EDER ( 1 9 70 , 1 9 7 1 , 1 9 7 5 , t h i s volume) from calcareous turbidite s . EDER interprets this layer as a secondary e f fect of diageneti c carbonate redistribu tion. The following observations suggest an early diagenetic origin also for the Muschelkalk underbeds : ( 1 ) uncompressed preservation of Rhizocorallid spreite burrows in the underbeds indicat�s early ce mentation ; ( 2 ) gutter casts are commonly rimmed by a cementation aureole cutting across internal laminations ( Fi g . 9 a , b ) ; ( 3 ) intra clasts may be traced to subjacent underbeds ;
( 4 ) where penecontempo
raneous erosion has removed again the whole shell bed , the exhumed underbed could already act as a firm- or hardground for specific
191
burrowers , borers and encrusters , or even get broken up into large plates (AIGNER 1979 , Fig. 2 , 7 ) . Thus , " underbed s " may be regarded as a type of concretion controlled by the sudqen porosity change at the base of the tempestite .
Fig. 9 . Underbeds as diagenetic aureoles below event surface s . A ) Concretion-like pillow below small gutter cast (Upper Muschelkalk , Kernmlihle} B} Cementation aureole around a gutter cast below shell bed preserves even the lamination of a previous smaller-scale event ( Upper Muschelkalk , Garnberg) . C ) Underbed below crinoidal limestone preserves the strongly burrowed firmground s tage ( Lower Haupt muschelkalk, Neckarwestheim, leg. 0 . LINCK) . D ) Composite bed: underbed of first event ( lower part) probably remained covered with sediment , whereas underbed of second event ( upper part) became exposed and burrowed as a f irmground prior to final burial ( Upper Muschelkalk , Tiefenbach )
192
Since reworking plays a'n important role in shallow-marine sedimenta tion , the underbed mechanism may be important 1 } in enhancing the resistance of the underlying muds against sub sequent erosion and in hardground formation (LINDSTRtiM 1 9 79 ) . 2 ) as an indicator for composite beds : burrowed or bored and en
crusted firm- or hardgrounds record previous phases of event-de position and reexposure of the underbed (Fig. 9 c , d ) . 3 ) In acting as a local base ( "reference horizon" ) on which several subsequent events are only partly recorded due to 11cannibalistic" reworking and partial condensation .
4 . 2 . Paleoecology
a) General o As we have seen, erosional or depositional storm events alter substrate conditions on the sea floor and p�rticularly so in carbonate muds . The biologic response to such events will therefore be mainly· controlled by a change in substrate consistency . Principally , the establishment o f a post-tempestite fauna i s simi lar to that known from turbidites (SEILACHER I960) ' but it may be complicated ( a ) by subsequent phases of event reworking and ( b ) by interaction with early diagenetic processes ( in carbonates ) . As demonstrated above , recolonized surfaces on tempestite tops or ba ses may be softground s , firrngrounds or hardgrounds (Fig. 4 ) . Commu nity succession may involve all phases from soft- to firm and - in case of gradual lithification - to hardgrounds , or be unpredictably modified through subsequent events . b ) Distortion of Faunal Spectrum. KREISA & BAMBACH (this vel . ) show, that faunas o f Paleozoic storm-packstones closely correspond to those in the unreworked i X:t.e rstratified sediments . In the Upper Muschelkalk , 11rich" faunas in the tempestites do not in general correspond to the 11poor" faunas of the interlayered mud s . In the latter , shells were mainly aragonitic and are preseryed as inter nal molds , with the deep-burrowing bivalve Pleuromya predominating (mostly in life attitude ) . In contrast, Pteuromya is extremely rare in the shelly tempestite s , while epifauna and shallow burrowers are abundant . Faunistic reconstructions based on storm-reworked shell material should therefore consider possible distortions of the faunal spectrum caused by several factors :
193
1 . distortion by level of erosion: shallow levels of a stratified benthic community are more likely to be eroded , while deeper burrowers remain undisturbe d .
2 . Diagenetic distortion : non-reworked aragonitic shells may have eventually been dissolved· in the muds , whereas the. same shells . survived when reworked into the different diagenetic regime of a coquin a . Storm reworking thus increased the preservation poten tial of these s he l l s . 3 . 9omposite b e d distortion: due t o repeated phases of burial and re-exposure , shell beds may have served as substrates for epi and infaunal colonisation by different organisms , that led to an increase ip eventual diversity . 4 . transport distortion : a "miXed fauna11 including e lements from different habi tats , may also result from lateral and commonly selective , transport of shell material . REINECK et a l .
( 19 6 8 ) for
instance , have recorded living and dead Hydro b i a shells displaced from tidal flats into offshore storm layers.
4 . 3 . Basin Analysis a) Lateral Sequences . Although proximal or distal tempestites may dominate in di fferent parts o f a sequence , the relative abundance of the two types appears to show a significant variation across the basin ( see Fig . 8 ) . Proximal tempestites are more corrunon in a '1near -shore facies " , wh ich can be distinguished from an "open shelf fa cies " , dominated by distal tempestites ( Fi g . 10) . Further work should treat tempestites in a more quantitative way of analysis , an approach which has been successfully applied to deep turbidite basins ( WALKER 1 9 6 7 , 19 70; LOVELL 1970) . Eventual l y , tempes'tite features may b e transformed into contour-type map s , re vealing the geometry and facies-pattern of shallow storm-dominated basins . b) Vertical Sequences . Apart from two major shallowing cycles in the Upper Muschelkalk (Fig. 1 ) , smaller-scale cycles , a few meters thick, may also be present . For instance , distal type tempestites may pass upwards into proximal ones and eventually into massive shell accumulations (up to 2 m thick e . g . Spiriferina-Bank in Crailsheim area) , which are commonly cross-bedded . This may be in-
L
194
FACIES - MODEL offshore , •• ...
TEMPESTITES
«proximal»
facies
bioclast-dom.
paleocurrents base
J. to
shore
channelled
':N•••.
, ....�-�--
« distal .. mud-dominated
II to shore impacts
grain size intra-extracl. amalgamation
Fig. 10.
Tentative facies model accounting for the lateral change of tempestite facies in terms of proximality as shown in th·e Muschelkalk exampl'e (W wave base, storm wave base) . Paleocurrents in distal SW areas are mainly deduced from gutter casts =
=
terpreted as a shallowing sequence , probably due to the prograda tion of the source area . Simil ar cycles have been described from terrigenous clastic facies ( e . g . GOLDRING & BRIDGES 1 9 7 3 and HOBDAY & READING 1 9 7 2 ) .
4 . 4 . Stratigraphy Many Muschelkalk tempesti t_e s , in particular thicker shell beds 1 can
be traced for a few kilometers (see AIGNER 1 9 7 9 , fig . 4 ) , less fre quently for some lO ' s of kilometers. A few distinctive shell beds
with tempestite features (Spiriferina-beds of the Lower and Upper Muschelkalk 1 see SCHWARZ 1 9 7 5 , 1 9 7 7 and SCHKFER 1 9 7 3 ) can be traced nearly throughout the basin 1 except the very basin c enter. , Since storms form instantaneous and isochronic events , tempestites are potentially ideal for correlation on a regional and in certain cases probably even on a basin-wide scale ( BALL 1 9 7 1 ) . 11Event-stra tigraphy11 based on such horizons might refine biostratigraphic re solution by several orders of magni tude .
195
Basin-wide marker beds are rare because they require a particular combination of sedimentary factor s . Low shelf bottom relief and low rates of subsidence· and sedimentation (which favour the quantum like accumulation of many events over a long period and even the establishment of a new fauna) may be important . No. matter how many events are condensed in one bed, it will be the final large event that ultimately coins the overall aspect of the stratification. ,· 5 . Conclusions
Stol::m-induced high energy events are important processes in genera ting stratification within the Upper Muschelkalk : 1 . Storms control the development of various types of bedform se quences in tempestite s , which may be differentiated, as in turbi dite s , · between proximal and distal end members . 2 . These proximality gradientS help to understand vertical and la teral facies sequences in storm-dominated shelf environment s . 3 . Deposition o f calcareous tempestites (or o f calcareous turbidites) may cause early diagenetic cementation of underlying muds ( under beds ) , thus enhancing the formation of intraclast s , as well as firm- and hardground s , during subsequent events .
4 . Paleoecologically , storms i'nfluence the establishment and succes sion of particular communities mainly by changing the consistency of the substrate s . The overall faunal spectrum in an individual shelly tempe s ti t e , however , may be distorted by several factors . 5 . Since storms are instantaneous and i sochronic event s , storm beds and their ecologic impact are useful tools for high-resolution stratigraphy , at least on a regional scale . 6 . Tempestites With particular associations of sedimentary structures ( e . g . presence or absence of wave ripples) may also prove to be valuable as paleodepth indicators . Acknowledgements I am grateful to ·the following individuals and institutions who helped me in many ways to carry out these studies whil e I was an undergraduate student: Pro f . Dr. J . R . L . ALLEN , Prof . Dr. P � . ALLEN , Dr. R. GOLDRING (Sedi mentology Research Lab . , Univ. of Reading/Englan d ) , H. HAGDORN (Klinzelsau ) , Pro f . Dr . H . -E . REINECK ( Institute of Marine Geology and Biology , Wilhelmshaven) and Pro f . Dr. A . SEILACHER (Dept . of Geology and Paleontology , Ttibingen Univ . ) . He , Prof. Dr . G. EINSELE , Dr. R. GOLDRING and H . HAGDORN reviewed the manuscript. Mr: RIES and Mr. WETZEL (Ttibingen ) provided technical assistance . Specimens are deposited in the Institut� and Museum for Geology and Paleontology , Univ. of Tlibingen (No . 1 5 74 ) .
196
References AGER, D . V . ( 1 974 ) : Storm . deposits in· the Jurassic of the Maroccan High Atlas . - Pa.leogeogr . , Paleoclimat . , Paleoeco l . , J:� : 83-9 3 . AIGNER, T . ( 1 9 77 ) : Schalenpflaster i m Unteren Hauptmuschelkalk bei Crailsheirn (Wlirtt . , Trias , mol} - Stratinomie , Bkologie , Sedi mentologie . - N . Jb . Geol . Pal . , Abh . !��: 19 3-2 1 7 . - ( 1 9 7 9 ) .: Schill-Tempestite im Oberen Muschelkalk ( Trias , SW-Deutsch- · land ) . - N . Jb . Geol . Pal . , Abh . J�J: 3 2 6 - 34 3 . AIGNER, T .
&
FUTTERER, E . ( 1 9 78 ) : Kolk-T6pfe und -Rinnen (pot and
gutter casts) im Muschelkalk - Anzeiger fUr Wattenmeer ? - N . Jb . Geol .Pal . , Abh .
J�� : 2 8 5-304 .
BALL; S . M . ( 1 9 7 1 ) : The Westphalia Limestone of the northern Midcon tinent: a possible ancient storm deposit . - J . sedim. Petr . ,
�J : 2 1 7-2 3 2 .
BRENCHLEY , P . J . i NEWALL , G .
&
SANISTREE.T , J . G . ( 1 9 79 } : A storm s-urge
origin for sandstone beds in an epicontinental platform sequen c e , Ordovician, Norway . - Sedim. Geol . , �� : 1 8 5 -2 1 7 . BRENNER,- R . L . & DAVIES, D . K . ( 1 9 73 ) : Storm-generated coquinoid sandston e : genesis of h i gh-energy marine sediments from the Upper Jurassic of ·Wyoming and Montana . - Bul l . Geol . Soc . 1685-1697 . CURRAY , J . R.
Am.
, 84 : ==
( 1960) : Sediments and history of Holocene transgres
sion , northwestern Gulf of Mexico . - In : F . P . SHEPARD , F . B . PHLEGER & Tj . van ANDEL (Eds . ) , Recent Sediments , Northwest Gulf of Mexico . - Am . Ass . Petro l . Geol . : 22 1-26 6 . EDER, W .
( 19 70) : Genese riff-nahe'r Detritus-Kalke bei Balve im
Rheinischen Schiefergebirge ( Garbecker Kalk ) . - Verb. Geo l . B . -A . ,
!�Z�: 5 5 1 - 56 9 .
- ( 1 9 71 ) : Riff-nahe detritische Kalke bei Balve irn Rheinischen Schiefergebirge (Mittel-Devon , Garbecker Kalk) . - G6ttinger Arb . Geol . P a l . EDER, W.
�� , 66 pp.
( 19 75 ) : Riffe und Riff-detritogene Platte'n kalke . - Bericht
Sonderforschungsbereichs 4 8 , Projektber . A, GBttingen 1 9 7 5 , 1 17 - 1 4 3 . EDER, W . ( 19 8 2 ) : On the genesis o f limestone-marl alternation in the Rheinisches Schiefergebirge {this volume ) .
197 &
GEYER, O . F .
GWINNER, M . P . ( 19 6 8 ) : Einflihrung in die Geologie von
Baden-Wlirttemberg . - 2 . Aufl . , Schweizerbart . KELLIN G, G . & MULLIN , P . R . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Graded limestones and limestone quarzite couplets: possible ancient storm deposits from the Mo roccan . carboniferous . - .Sediment . Geol . J,J : 1 6 1 - 1 90 . KREISA, R .
&
BAMBACH , R . ( 1982) : The role o f storm processes in gene
rating shell beds in Paleozoic shelf environments . - (this volume ) . GOLDRING, R . & BRIDGE s , P . · ( 1 9 7 3 ) : Sublittoral sheet sandstones . J . Sedim. Petr . , 4� : 7 36-7 4 7 . GOLDRING , R . & LANGENSTRASSEN , F . ( 19 79 ) : Open shelf and near-shore clastic facies in the Devonian . - Spec . Pap. in Palaeont . g� � 8 1 -9 7 . &
HAMBLIN , A . P .
WALKER, R . G . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Storm-dominated shallow marihe
deposits : the Fernie-Kootenay (Jurassic) transition , southern Rocky Mountains . - Can . J . Earth Sci . �g: 1 6 7 3- 1690 .
HARDIE , L . A .
&
GINSBURG , · R . N .
( 19 77 ) : Layering : the origin and en
vironmental significance of lamination and thin bedding . - In : �IE , L . A . (Ed . ) : Sedimentation on the Modern Carbonate Tidal Flats of Northwest Andros Islan d , Bahamas . - Johns HopkiUs Univ.
Studies in Geology , No . ��· 1 HAYES", M. O . ( 1 9 6 7 ) : Hurricanes as geological agents , south Texas coast . - Bul l . Am. Assoc. Petro l . Geol . 5 1 : 9 37-9 4 2 . ==
HOBDAY , O . K .
&
READING , H . G .
( 1 9 7 2 } : Fair weather versus storm pro
cesses in shallow marine sand bar sequences in the Late Pre cambrian of Finnmark , North Norway . - J. sedim. Petrol . ��, 3 18-324 . LINDSTROM , M.
( 1 9 7 9 ) : Diagenesis of Lower Ordovician hardgrounds in
Sweden . - Geologica et Palaeont . ��: 9-30 . MEISCHNER, D . ·( 1 96 4 ) : Allodapische Kalke, Turbidite in riff-nahen Sedimentationsbecken . - In: Turbidite s , Developments in Sedi mentology , J: 1 56 - 1 9 1 .
MUNDLOS , R . ( 1 9 7 6 ) : Wunderwelt im Stein . Fossilfunde - Zeugen der Urzeit . - Bertelsmann Lexikon-Verlag . POWERS , M . C . & KINSMAN , B . ( 1 9 5 3 ) : Shell accumulations in underwater sediments and their relation to the thickness of the traction zone . - J . sediment . Petr . , �� : 229-2 34 .
198 REINECK , H . -E . ; D5RJE S, J . ; GADOW, S . & HERTWECK , G . ( 1 9 68 ) : Sedi mentologie , Faunenzonierung und Faziesabfolge vor der Ostktiste der inneren Deutschen Bucht . - Senckenb . Leth . , i�: 2 61-309 .
REINECK , H . -E .
&
SINGH , I . B . ( 19 75) : Depositional Sedimentary En
vironments . - Springer , Berlin-Heidelberg-New York . SCHKFER 1 K . A . ( 1 9 73 ) : Zur Fazies und Palaogeographie der Spiriferi na-Bank (Hauptmuschelkalk) im n6rdlichen Baden-Wtirttemberg . N . Jb . Geol . P a1 . , Abh . J4�: 5 6 - 1 1 0 . SCHWARZ , H . -u. ( 1 9 75 ) : Sedimentary structures and facies analysis of shallow marine carbonates (Lower Muschelkalk , Middle Triassic Southwestern Germany ) . - Contrib. Sediment.
�: 1-100 .
- ( 19 7 7 } : Sedirnentationszyklen und stratigraphisch-fazielle Probleme der Randfazies des Unteren Muschelkalks (Kernbohrung Mersch/Lu xemburg) - Geol . Rdsch . , .•
SEILACHER, A .
��: 34-6 1 .
( 1 9 6 2 ) : Paleontological studies on turbidite sedi
�entation and erosion . - J. Geol . , JQ: 22 7-2 34 .
SPECHT , R . W .
&
BRENNER, R . L .
( 1 9 79 ) : Storm-wave genesis of bio
cla� tic carbona�e s i n Upper Jurassic epicontinental mudstones ,
East-central Wyoming . - J . sedim. Petrol . , 4� : 1 30 7 - 1 32 2 .
VOLLRATH , A . ( 1 9 55 ) : Stratigraphie des Oberen Hauptmuschelkalks (Schichten zwischen Cycloides-Bank und Spiriferina-Bank) in
Baden-Wlirttember g . - J h . geol . L . -A . Bad. -Wtirtt . , J : 190-21 6 . - ( 19 5 5 ) : Zur Stratigraphie des Hauptmuschelkalks in Wlirttemberg . Jh . geol . L . -A . Bad. -Wlirtt . , J : 7 9 -1 6 8 ( 1 9 5 5b ) .
WAGNER , G .