Volume 3 ASIA AND PACIFIC
Crime and Punishment around the World
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Crime and Pun...
165 downloads
3919 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Volume 3 ASIA AND PACIFIC
Crime and Punishment around the World
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Crime and Punishment around the World ASIA AND PACIFIC
Volume 3
DORIS C. CHU, VOLUME EDITOR GRAEME R. NEWMAN, GENERAL EDITOR
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Copyright 2010 by Doris C. Chu, Volume Editor Graeme R. Newman, General Editor All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, except for the inclusion of brief quotations in a review, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Crime and punishment around the world. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-313-35133-4 (set : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-313-35134-1 (set ebook) — ISBN 978-0-313-35135-8 (vol. 1 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-313-35136-5 (vol. 1 ebook) — ISBN 978-0-313-35137-2 (vol. 2 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-313-35138-9 (vol. 2 ebook) — ISBN 978-0-313-35139-6 (vol. 3 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-313-35140-2 (vol. 3 ebook) — ISBN 978-0-313-35141-9 (vol. 4 : alk. paper) — ISBN 978-0-313-35142-6 (vol. 4 ebook) 1. Crime. 2. Punishment. 3. Criminal justice, Administration of. HV6025.C7115 2010 364—dc22 2010021159 ISBN (set): 978-0-313-35133-4 EISBN (set): 978-0-313-35134-1 14
13
12 11
10
1
2
3
4
5
This book is also available on the World Wide Web as an eBook. Visit www.abc-clio.com for details. ABC-CLIO, LLC 130 Cremona Drive, P.O. Box 1911 Santa Barbara, California 93116-1911 This book is printed on acid-free paper Manufactured in the United States of America © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
This volume set is dedicated to the memory of Ali Sabeeh of Omara, Iraq, who, while preparing the entry on Iraq, was kidnapped, tortured, and killed in October 2007 To Amma and Nannagaru
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Editorial Advisory Board
Adam Bouloukos, Director of Outreach and Partnerships, UNOPS, Copenhagen, Denmark Ronald V. Clarke, University Professor, Rutgers University Adam Graycar, Professor, Australian National University Martin Killias, Professor, University of Zurich Jeremy Travis, President, John Jay College of Criminal Justice
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Contents
Acknowledgments, xi
Georgia, 71
General Introduction by Graeme R. Newman, xiii
Hong Kong, 76
Maps, xxiv
India, 86
Map 1. Murder around the World, xxiv
Indonesia, 92
Map 2. Imprisonment around the World, xxv
Japan, 98
Map 3. Death Penalty around the World, xxvi
Kazakhstan, 110
Map 4. Corporal Punishment around the World, xxvii
Kyrgyzstan, 118 Laos (Lao People’s Democratic Republic), 125
Volume 3 Introduction by Doris C. Chu, xxix
Macao, 132
Maps, xxxiii
Malaysia, 141
Country Key to Asia and Pacific Maps, xxxiii
Maldives, 151
Map 5. Murder in Asia and Pacific, xxxiv
Mongolia, 158
Map 6. Imprisonment in Asia and Pacific, xxxv
Myanmar (Burma), 166
Map 7. Corporal Punishment in Asia and Pacific, xxxvi
North Korea (Democratic People’s Republic of Korea), 178
Map 8. Death Penalty in Asia and Pacific, xxxvii
Pakistan, 187
Nepal, 171
Philippines, 192 Singapore, 202
VOLUME 3
South Korea (Republic of Korea), 209 Asia, 1
Sri Lanka, 218
Afghanistan, 1
Taiwan (Republic of China), 222
Armenia, 13
Tajikistan, 232
Azerbaijan, 20
Thailand, 239
Bangladesh, 24
Timor-Leste, 251
Bhutan, 37
Turkey, 262
Brunei Darussalam, 47
Turkmenistan, 268
Cambodia, 52
Uzbekistan, 275
China (People’s Republic of China), 64
Vietnam, 286 ix
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
x
|
Contents
Pacific, 299
Republic of Kiribati, 325 Republic of Nauru, 326
Australia, 299 Melanesia, 305
New Zealand, 327
Micronesia, 315
Norfolk Island, 337
Republic of Belau (Palau), 316
Pitcairn Islands, 339
Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands (CNMI), 318
Polynesia, 344 Tonga, 350
Guam (Guahan), 319 Federated States of Micronesia (FSM), 321
General Bibliography, 359
Republic of the Marshall Islands, 323
Index, I-1
About the Editors and Contributors, 367
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Acknowledgments
The contribution made by the volume editors to this project has been inestimable. A project of this magnitude could not have been achieved without their unceasing efforts to find contributors for large and small countries alike, to manage their contributors’ contributions, and to edit them into the style and format required by a publication of this type. They helped overcome a number of crises we met along the way. For this and for their always being on the receiving end of my constant e-mails, I express my sincere appreciation. I thank especially Janet Stamatel for producing the world and regional maps from my sometimes less than adequate databases. Many authors have contributed to these volumes. Without them, of course, this project would not have been possible. The volume editors and I express our great admiration to our contributors and appreciation for their tolerance of our editorial demands, which oftentimes must have seemed unreasonable. We apologize if your chapter ended up a little shorter than you had wanted. We bear full responsibility for any misconceptions that may have occurred as a result of our at-times heavy editorial hand. Finally, we thank the Editorial Advisory Board members for being there when we needed them. —Graeme R. Newman Albany, NY December 31, 2009
xi © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
We humans are fascinated by the diversity of cultures, climates, landscapes, and peoples. It is part of our deep human heritage that we have never been able to stay at home. Since the beginning of human time, our haplogroups have migrated far and wide, stumbling on new fauna and evolving with them, adapting to cold, hot, wet, and dry seasons and climates. Along the way, we have constructed societies and civilizations that have come and gone, none reaching perfection; each having tried its own solutions to the problem of order; each constructing rules, laws, customs, and ways of dealing with those who, for whatever reason, have broken with the sacred commandments of order. Somewhere along the way, no matter what the civilization or society, the idea of justice emerged, perhaps independently of the need for order and, indeed, every now and again in opposition to order. But whatever order’s relationship to justice, one thing is certain: order is necessary for societies to survive. And embedded in this necessity is the inevitability that individuals will break laws, rules, and customs and will, as a matter of logic (and justice), be punished for it. So law (so-called if it is written) and custom (embodying law and rules that may not be written but that are “practiced” and conveyed orally) is universal in all known societies. They are part of the “civilizing” process, which seeks to hold in check the tendency of humans to devour each other. It is true that great thinkers, philosophers, and even scientists have insisted—in the face of the overwhelming evidence of history that stands against them—that humans, if only given a chance, can or could work together for their common good without being coerced to do so. But we know of no society anywhere in which this utopian (if it is utopian) conception of human nature has produced a society without laws or customs and their concomitant punishments. And surely humans have had plenty of chances to construct such utopian societies. Yet each time they try, order takes over, because we know that individuals only grudgingly curb their own desires. They do not like the imposition of order, but they know that they cannot survive without it and its accoutrements. Or at least, we may say that life is much more comfortable if one gives into almost any kind of order. This observation probably applies even to the worst of tyrannical orders, for it is easier to remain in submission than it is to rise up and overthrow a very powerful authority. The 18th-century enlightenment thinkers upon whose ideas much of the world’s criminal justice systems are based (whether civil or common) were clearly of the opinion that punishment was a necessary evil, a price paid for the xiii © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
xiv
|
General Introduction
comfort of living in an ordered society. Its universality certainly attests to the truth of this assertion. It should come as no surprise, therefore, that getting reliable information about such a touchy subject—essentially how a society, nation, or culture maintains order in the face of a populace that may secretly or even openly resent its imposition—is very difficult. Nations can be very secretive about their crime rates and their punishments, not to mention their procedures for finding guilt and their manner of interrogating suspects. Various organizations have set themselves up to monitor the most egregious violations of individuals in the name of order, such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, but there is a far larger part of the maintenance of order and the processing of lawbreakers by nations and regional governments that also needs constant scrutiny. Violations of human rights in the name of order may easily be hidden inside the bureaucratic inertia and practices of even the most “enlightened” societies. To admit to having a very high rate of murder or incarceration—perhaps one of the highest—of its citizens is not something of which a nation can be especially proud. Such statistics say something about that nation, though what that something is, unfortunately, can be easily misinterpreted. For example, some countries may be criticized for having very high imprisonment rates, but their retort may be that this is because they have very high crime rates, to which it may be asked, but why do you have such high crime rates? The reply may be, “Because we have strict laws that are strictly enforced, which is for the good of our citizens, who are kept safer than those in other countries whose administration of criminal justice is too lax.” Provided here is just a taste of the controversies and disagreements concerning the differing levels of crime and punishment in diverse countries, as well as the puzzling relationship or lack thereof between prison rates and crime rates. The riddle can be stated thus: more punishment should reduce crime, but more crime requires more punishment. One would think that the costs in public relations to a nation would be far too high to allow for the publication of crime and punishment statistics. So it is an amazing achievement that the United Nations World Crime Surveys, whose mission is to collect the official statistics on crime and justice from member nations, have shown steady and significant increases in the number of countries submitting their statistics since they were first collected in the 1970s. From a handful of countries in the beginning, the number providing crime and punishment statistics had grown to about 50 as of 2005. That is the positive spin. In fact, this is only 50 out of 190 member UN nations, and there are signs of decreasing reporting by countries in recent years, according to Jan Van Dijk, author of The World of Crime and former UN expert on international crime and justice. Although it is true that nations are reticent to make public their crime and punishment statistics for reasons of public image, there are many technical difficulties in making comparisons of officially collected crime and justice statistics across countries. Many of these difficulties are serious, and the reader is warned to use considerable caution in making such comparisons across countries. These technical difficulties include the following:
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
• Different legal definitions of offenses make it difficult to compare specific offenses across nations. • Different reporting and recording practices of the police who generally have first official contact with a crime make comparing statistics from one country to another unreliable without knowledge of these practices. • Different legal systems may affect the finding of guilt, recording and classification of offenses, and recording of arrests and convictions. • Inconsistent classifications of crime records and frequent changes over time make it difficult to compare trends in crime or punishment. • Different bureaucracies and government departments within each nation that collate and publish crime and punishment statistics may produce different statistics. For example, city- or state-level collection of crime rates or prison rates may differ from collection at the federal level, as in the United States. • Inadequate infrastructure for collecting and processing crime and justice reports, including information technology, may hinder the amount or accuracy of criminal justice data. • Lack of professionally trained crime analysts and statisticians may limit the reliability and depth of statistical data available. • Local events or conditions may inflate crime and punishment statistics, such as genocidal events that may or may not be recorded as murders. • Changing government policies about making crime and justice statistics public may affect trends and the amount and type of data made available. There have been instances where countries have revealed crime and justice statistics to the United Nations, but not to their own citizens. The reverse is also true. There was a time, for example, when the Soviet Union routinely collected crime statistics for its internal use but officially denied to the United Nations that there was any crime at all in the Soviet Union, because there could be no crime in a true communist society. • In large populous countries, there may be vast differences within those countries. For example, the levels of crime and punishment vary enormously throughout the United States; some states still retain the death penalty, and many do not. There may also be huge differences in amounts and kinds of crime between urban and rural regions. There may even be different legal systems operating within the same country, such as, for example, Quebec in Canada or the several customary, Islamic, and civil law systems operating in Timor-Leste. If one must make comparisons—and most people are unable to resist it—the best way to overcome these pitfalls is to make sure that one knows as much as possible about the historical and social context within which the statistics are collected. Crime and Punishment around the World provides just that context. This encyclopedia describes in detail the crime and punishment practices of each country and, in some instances, specific regions. The four volumes offer a glimpse of the ways in which all the nations around the world try to solve the basic problem
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xv
xvi
|
General Introduction
they all face: what to do with those who break the law? They have all enacted either customary or written criminal laws. They have all inherited their criminal laws from their ancestors near and far, not infrequently from other nations that either usurped them or overtook them through migration. They have all developed procedures for the finding of guilt of the accused, and all, of course, follow up the finding of guilt with legislated or customary punishments. These are all essentially the product of their legal systems.
World Legal Systems For more than 1,000 years, the Roman Empire encompassed just about all the region around the Mediterranean and stretched as far north as Great Britain. Law was probably its major weapon against the peoples it subdued, bringing with it order and a stable means of commerce. Its concepts would form much of the basis of canon law and eventually much of the civil law of Europe. Furthermore, much of the Islamic and customary law of the countries surrounding the south and east of the Mediterranean was deeply affected by Roman law because those peoples were also subjects of the Roman Empire at various times for over 1,000 years. Those countries of Europe that retained more of the Roman law and its procedures would later come to be known as “civil law” countries. Those European countries that managed to put aside Roman law came to be known as “common law” countries. And those of North Africa and the Far East retained Islamic and customary law systems. Civil law systems account for over 50 percent of the world’s legal systems, although many such systems are mixed with other legal systems because of local and historical circumstance. In fact, as a result of constant reforms, it is likely that there are no purely civil law systems left in the world. Most countries have incorporated various aspects of the adversarial system. The main characteristics of civil law systems are the following: 1. Systematically written legal codes are the prime source of authority in legal decisions and procedures. 2. Their procedures are often (though not entirely) based on what is sometimes called the “inquisitorial system”—reaching back to the days of the Roman Catholic Inquisition—in which the process of finding of guilt is conducted by a judge or magistrate who both investigates and conducts the final trial. These trials are usually, though not always, conducted before a magistrate or panel of magistrates. Probably the prime examples of European civil law systems are those of France and Germany and, to some extent, Italy, which has recently incorporated aspects of the adversarial system. Common law systems account for another 20 percent of the world’s legal systems. These are commonly referred to as “adversarial systems” because the finding of guilt is not conducted by the magistrate who decides and investigates the case as in civil law; rather, a prosecutor (or sometimes an investigating police officer) investigates the case and prepares the case for a trial by judge and jury © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
(although juries are not always required). The two significant features of common law systems are the following: 1. Cases are decided based on precedent, which views previous cases and decisions as a cumulative wisdom and authority. 2. Cases are a courtroom drama in which the prosecutor is pitted against the defense. It should be noted, however, that in modern legal systems of common law, there are legal codes that systematize the law, and these may or may not be based on the codification of past legal practice. In the United States, for example, every state, in addition to the federal system, has its own written code. Cases are decided, however, based not only on how well the offender’s acts match the written code but also on the cases that came before it—that is, precedent. One sees this tradition played out in the U.S. Supreme Court, which arduously scrutinizes past decisions to conclude whether a particular case was decided correctly or not, in accordance with the supreme law of the land, the U.S. Constitution. The popular view that contrasts these two legal traditions is that civil law is focused more on finding a probably guilty person guilty, whereas common law is focused more on defending a possibly innocent person from a guilty verdict. Both systems do, however, adhere to the presumption of innocence of the accused until proven guilty. The most typical examples of common law systems are those of the United Kingdom, the United States, and Australia. Islamic legal systems account for about 10 percent of the world’s legal systems, although there are probably no purely Islamic systems anywhere in the world. This is because of the early Roman influence on all countries surrounding the Mediterranean and because of the imperialism of the West during the 16th through 20th centuries. In its pure form, the Islamic system of law follows the exact law of God, as interpreted by experts (Mullahs), deriving from the Koran, the Bible, and other sacred texts. Islamic law is often called sharia—the path to follow. Perhaps the most contrasting feature of Islamic law is that it is more a way to live one’s life than a set of prohibitions laid down by a state authority as in Roman law and its progenitors. Thus, not only does it include prohibitions, some of which are set out in the Ten Commandments, but it also includes exhortations to lead a good life (e.g., love thy neighbor). No such positive exhortations are found in other Western legal traditions, whose defining principle is prohibition. The procedural rules of Islamic law are those of human reasoning and consensus. One of the problems that faces legal theorists in Islamic law is that there are many offenses that are not specifically covered in any of the sacred texts. For example, sodomy is not mentioned in the Koran or Sunna (another sacred text), but adultery is. So the judge may reason that the two offenses are similar and the punishments prescribed for one may apply to the other. In practice, however, many cases are decided also on custom and precedent, given that in many Islamic countries, tribal customs concerning redress of wrongs (e.g., feuding and vengeance) have developed alongside Islamic and other kinds of law. The majority of countries with Islamic legal systems therefore also have customary law as a major component, especially in dealing with day-to-day infractions. Finally, most Islamic law © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xvii
xviii
|
General Introduction
countries also have a considerable dose of civil law, especially in the field of commerce, though it has been necessary even there for such countries to develop ways to get around the Islamic prohibition of usury, defined rather broadly. Customary law is the law that has arisen through oral tradition among tribes and cultures where law is not written down but rather communicated across generations by tribal elders. Village or regional chieftains are usually, though not always, the main repositories of such legal wisdom, and the finding of guilt usually occurs within an informal meeting of interested parties. In many countries of Africa and southern Asia, these kinds of local meetings occur and settlements are reached based on the hearing of all sides of the complaints. Depending on the culture, shamans or others thought to hold special powers may be brought in as expert witnesses and sometimes as judges. However, the most important attribute of customary law is its specificity to the local region or village. These traditions can be very deep and resistant to change or imposition from outside influences. Perhaps a prime example in the 21st century is that of the tribal villages in the mountains of Pakistan and parts of Afghanistan that have defied state authority for hundreds of years. Instead, these tribal areas have their own chiefs and their own informal ways of settling infractions and disputes. Socialist legal systems are those that have arisen on top of civil law systems, for the most part. Certainly this was the case in the Soviet Union and continues to be the case in Cuba and other communist countries, although China is perhaps an exception. Yet even there, the customary legal system was usurped by Western powers in the 19th century and abolished by the revolution of 1949. However, the emergence in the 1980s of China as an industrial and trading nation required that it develop a legal system that would make commerce possible and more efficient. The result has been that its legal system is based essentially on civil law, with criminal law that codifies edicts of the State and procedures that are largely reflective of the inquisitorial system. Finally, although there are probably no countries that are purely of one or the other legal system, there are quite a number of countries whose legal systems are mixtures of some or all of the preceding. Many African and some South Asian countries are mixtures of customary, civil, common, and Islamic law. Such countries would include, for example, India, Afghanistan, and maybe Egypt.
How Does Your Country Measure Up? Although for the reasons recounted earlier, comparing the crime and punishment of countries to each other is a very difficult procedure, it is nevertheless important to get a rough idea of how one country compares to the rest of the world. It is probably one of the main reasons people refer to world encyclopedias of any kind, to get a sense of how one fits in the universe. To provide a very rough glimpse of how a country’s crime and punishment compare to the rest of the world, we have provided a snapshot of some major indicators of crime and punishment for each country at the start of each country essay. We have chosen these indicators because they are readily available and offer a reasonably approximate way of ranking countries along a continuum. Of © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
the crime indicators, murder is chosen as probably the most reliable for making comparisons because its definition is roughly similar across nations, and in most cases, the statistics have been adjusted to fit the UN standard definition of murder for countries reporting their murder rates. Nevertheless, many countries do not report their murder rates. Prison rates are also reasonably reliable for making comparisons, although they too involve great technical difficulties in measurement, considering that the counting of inmates may occur on different days of the year, and a simple accounting on a particular day does not give any indication of the flow of prisoners in and out of the prison over a given period of time. The snapshot indicators provided for each country or region when available are as follow: • • • • •
Type of Legal System Murder—murders per 100,000 people Burglary—those victimized by burglaries per thousand people Corruption—levels of perceived corruption Human Trafficking—how much the country is doing to control human trafficking • Prison—number of prisoners per 100,000 population • Death Penalty—whether the country has the death penalty • Corporal Punishment—whether corporal punishment is available to the criminal justice system
Legal System The types of legal system were compiled from the United Nations Global Report on Crime and Justice, supplemented by information from individual country Web sites and from the University of Ottawa Civil Law Section Web site on World Legal Systems at http://www.droitcivil.uottawa.ca/world-legal-systems/eng-tab leau.php.
Murder These are officially reported statistics on murder supplied by countries to the United Nations World Crime Surveys, supplemented where necessary by individual country information plus homicide statistics from the World Health Organization. Most of the statistics were taken from the revised listing supplied by Jan Van Dijk in his book The World of Crime, in which he reported the average murder rates for 1998–2002, supplemented by more recent United Nations surveys. Additional data from INTERPOL and individual country sources, where available, sometimes for a slightly different period of years, were also included. However, such small differences should not matter because we know that murder rates are fairly stable over time. The countries are ranked from highest to lowest murder rate (murders per 100,000 people) and then divided into quartiles, with the middle two quartiles classified as “Medium” and the two outer quartiles labeled “High” and “Low.” The world distribution of murder rates can be seen in Map 1, Murder around the World. © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xix
xx
|
General Introduction
Burglary Obtaining reliable rates of property crime, the most common of which is usually referred to as theft, is especially difficult when relying on officially recorded statistics because definitions and enforcement practices vary enormously across nations. We have therefore included measures of victimization of individuals by burglary. These measures are derived from the International Crime Victim Surveys (ICVS), which are interviews or questionnaires asking samples of a population whether they have been victims of particular offenses over a particular number of years (usually the past year). In this case, the samples were households, and the survey was conducted in many countries, although limited only to urban populations. Therefore, they do not, of course, represent the country or region as a whole, though they do, perhaps in the case of burglary, represent most of the population of a given country that there are, generally, many more households in urban settings than in rural settings. These data are taken from Van Dijk’s World of Crime. Countries were ranked according to their burglary rates (number of victimizations reported per 1,000 people) using quartiles, divided into High, Medium, and Low, with Medium defined by the two middle quartiles.
Corruption The ways in which crime and punishment are eventually perceived by the public and administered by the State are affected by the level of corruption in a particular country. We have therefore included a measure of corruption, a kind of crime that is neither a violent crime nor, strictly speaking, a property crime. Rather, it is a crime against justice itself. There is also the advantage that data on perceived corruption in countries are much more available, thanks to the source of our data, Transparency International at http://www.transparency.org/policy_re search/surveys_indices/cpi. This Corruption Perception Index (CPI) is based on the ranking of “180 countries by their perceived levels of corruption, as determined by expert assessments and opinion surveys” according to Transparency International. We have taken these rankings, added some additional countries in some cases where they were not included in the survey, and then divided them into Low, Medium, and High, using quartiles once again.
Human Trafficking This measure is taken from the U.S. Department of State three-tier listing of countries it classifies as making a strong effort to control human trafficking, making some effort, or making very little effort. The classifications are taken from the U.S. Department of State Trafficking in Persons Report 2008, found at http://www.state.gov/g/tip/rls/tiprpt/2008/index.htm. The classification scheme is derived from the U.S. Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000 (TVPA), which defines the minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking. It should be noted, however, that our ratings of “High” “Medium,” and “Low” in the rates of human trafficking are only very rough because they assume that countries that comply with the U.S. anti-trafficking standards of enforcement will therefore have low levels of human trafficking. This is not always true. The United States, © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
for example, is rated as low for human trafficking because it complies with the TVPA anti-trafficking act; however, we know that it is a major destination country for trafficked humans. The classifications are as follows: • Low Amount of Trafficking (Tier 1): Countries that fully comply with the U.S. Department of State standards for anti-trafficking enforcement. • Medium Amount of Trafficking (Tier 2): Countries that do not fully comply with the minimum standards but are making significant efforts to bring themselves into compliance. • Medium Amount of Trafficking (Watch List): Countries on Tier 2 requiring special scrutiny because of a high or significantly increasing number of victims, failure to provide evidence of increasing efforts to combat trafficking in persons, or an assessment as Medium based on commitments to take action over the next year. • High Amount of Trafficking (Tier 3): Countries that neither satisfy the minimum standards nor demonstrate a significant effort to come into compliance. Countries in this tier are subject to potential non-humanitarian and non-trade sanctions.
Prison The prison rate assessments are derived from the International Center for Prison Studies, King’s College, London, and found at http://www.kcl.ac.uk/schools/law/ research/icps. The rates are of prisoners per 100,000 population, and countries are ranked from high to low and divided into High, Medium, and Low using the quartile method described previously. These were the most up-to-date and thorough statistics available as of 2008. The world distribution of prison rates is depicted in Map 2: Imprisonment around the World.
Death Penalty About 65 percent of countries have abolished the death penalty either by legislation or in practice. A few have essentially abolished it while retaining it for especially heinous crimes, although it may not have been used for many years. These countries are classified as “maybe” in our assessment of whether the death penalty is available to countries. Thus, the classifications for whether countries have the death penalty as an available punishment are “Yes,” “Maybe,” and “No.” The information has been taken from the Web site Info Please at http://www.in foplease.com/ipa/A0777460.html, which in turn has taken its statistics from Amnesty International. The world death penalty distribution may be seen in Map 3: Death Penalty around the World.
Corporal Punishment The assessments as to whether countries have available to them the use of corporal punishment, either as a sentence for a crime or for use within the prison system for disciplinary purposes, is based on information provided by the Web site http://www.endcorporalpunishment.org/pages/frame.html, which assesses © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xxi
xxii
|
General Introduction
mainly the legislative steps that countries have taken to prohibit the use of corporal punishment. The Web site covers the use of corporal punishment in homes and schools as well as in the criminal justice system. Its assessments of countries are based almost entirely on whether legislation has been passed prohibiting corporal punishment either as a sentence in criminal justice or as a means of discipline in prisons. The legal situation is often ambiguous because, as with the death penalty, many countries retain the possibility of corporal punishment’s use either as a sentence or in prisons but rarely or never resort to it. Thus, there is a category of “maybe” for those countries. Perhaps surprisingly, less than 20 percent of the world’s countries have prohibited by legislation the use of corporal punishment either as a sentence for a crime or for use in prison discipline. Like the death penalty, our classification of the availability of corporal punishment is “Yes,” “No,” or “Maybe.” The world use of corporal punishment is presented in Map 4: Corporal Punishment around the World.
Regions of the Four Volumes The four volumes are broken up into the following regions: • • • •
Volume 1: Africa and the Middle East Volume 2: The Americas Volume 3: Asia and Pacific Volume 4: Europe
There are any number of ways to classify countries into regions of the world. We have mostly relied on a geographical classification based on the United Nations Statistics Division classification system (http://unstats.un.org/unsd/geoinfo/ default.htm). But this method is far from satisfactory. Although geography (relatively speaking) remains the same, the borders of countries do not, mostly as a result of political conflict and other factors such as migration. Furthermore, the definition of what makes a country a country is also very difficult because there are many instances where “principalities” (e.g., San Marino) and “independent nations” (e.g., the Navajo Nation in the United States) exist inside larger nations or countries. The complex histories of colonialism and migration have resulted in particular countries containing a vast variety of peoples, cultures, and social arrangements, such that calling them a “country” or even “nation” gives a misleading impression of a cohesive national system governed by one set of laws. Bosnia and Herzogovina are perhaps a prime recent example of this difficulty. Given the shifting boundaries and definitions of countries and the social, cultural, and political diversity contained in them, allocating such countries to broad regions of the world is obviously even less precise. The final allocation of countries that were hard to classify—Turkey, for example—was admittedly somewhat arbitrary. We finally placed Turkey, along with Georgia, in Asia, not Europe. And we located countries of the Middle East (itself a very difficult region to define in both geographical and political terms) along with Africa in Volume 1. A number of the countries classified in the Middle Eastern region could just © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
General Introduction
as easily be placed in Asia, and others are geographically located in North Africa. And the variety of countries found in the Asia and Pacific volume is also vast in terms of both geography and culture; New Zealand and Australia, for example, have much more in common with Europe, from a historical and cultural point of view, than they do with their near and distant neighbors in Asia (although this is probably changing). Thus, comparing regions on any number of crime and punishment factors is fraught with even greater difficulties than comparing individual countries. Some commonalities and patterns, however, do emerge when one peruses the world maps that are provided. It is likely, as editors to the respective volumes point out, that these patterns reflect the colonial past of these regions, although there are no doubt other explanations related to local culture, migration patterns, and political history.
About the Contributors We have drawn on a variety of authors to contribute to these four volumes. In some cases, these authors are professionals who work for their governments, but in other cases (the majority), these authors are independent scholars. The objectivity of reports written by those who work for governments may perhaps be questioned, but on the other hand, government officials have much greater access to information and statistics than do outsiders. With a couple of important exceptions, all governments, by and large, have a monopoly on crime and punishment information. The exceptions are the international crime-victim surveys described earlier that are conducted mostly apart from governments, because they do not necessarily depend on officially recorded statistics by criminal justice officials. However, more government departments are conducting their own victimization surveys because some governments in the past have been embarrassed by the findings. Various nongovernmental watch groups, such as Amnesty International and Transparency International, also collect crime and punishment information and it is part of their mission to apply value judgments and criticism to governments and their administrators. As editors, we have tried in these chapters, as far as possible, to avoid either advocacy on behalf of the government’s interest or criticism of governments, although in some cases the criminality and punitive practices of governments cannot be ignored. —Graeme R. Newman University at Albany
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xxiii
xxiv
Murder around the World © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Imprisonment around the World
xxv © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
xxvi
Death Penalty around the World © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Corporal Punishment around the World
xxvii © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
Asia and the Pacific comprise the largest region in the world, which is home to more than half of the world’s population. Three out of the four most populous countries in the world—China, India, and Indonesia—are located in Asia. Asia/ Pacific includes the largest number of countries in the world. The growing role of Asia/Pacific in the world makes documenting the criminal justice practices and philosophies within the region essential. Volume 3 of Crime and Punishment around the World contains individual chapters for each of the following countries (regions): Central Asia (Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan); Eastern Asia (China, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of China, Japan, Mongolia, Macao Special Administrative Region of China, Republic of Korea [South Korea], Democratic People’s Republic of Korea [North Korea], and Taiwan), Southern Asia (Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka), Southeastern Asia (Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao People’s Democratic Republic, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Timor-Leste, and Vietnam), Western Asia (Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Turkey), and Oceania (Australia, Melanesia, Micronesia, New Zealand, Norfolk Island, Polynesia, Pitcairn, and Tonga). The individual chapters for each of the subregions of Oceania—Melanesia, Micronesia, and Polynesia—encompass the following islands: • Melanesia: Fiji, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, and Vanuatu • Micronesia: Guam, Kiribati, Nauru, Northern Mariana Islands, Marshall Islands, Palau, and the Federated States of Micronesia • Polynesia: Cook Islands, French Polynesia, Niue, Samoa, Tokelau, Tuvalu, and Wallis and Futuna Islands, with separate chapters for Pitcairn and Tonga in Polynesia Some countries from Asia that may be classified as “Middle East” are included in Volume 1 of Crime and Punishment around the World, which covers Africa and the Middle East. Those countries include Iran, Iraq, Israel, Jordon, Kuwait, Lebanon, Oman, Palestine, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Syria, United Arab Emirates, and Yemen. In addition, Cyprus is included in Volume 4: Europe. With the rapid changes in communication, technology, and transportation, crime is no longer a problem limited by national borders of individual countries. Transnational crimes such as human and drug trafficking, money laundering, xxix © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
xxx
|
Introduction
credit card skimming, hijacking, terrorism, and acts of piracy pose challenges to the international community. To overcome these challenges, multinational collaboration has become an inevitable trend. The form of collaboration usually starts with neighboring or regional countries since the sharing of adjacent borders poses difficulties for individual countries in their attempts to prevent and control crime. This volume covers information regarding human trafficking, drug crimes, and the most challenging crimes (faced by states) for individual countries in the region. While this volume does not provide direct comparisons among countries, its in-depth information regarding crime and punishment covering almost all of the countries (or territories) in the region does provide a good opportunity for those interested in gaining a broad understanding of the region’s crime problems and criminal justice practices. The layout of the book starts with the section on history and context (legal system, criminal justice system, and role of police). Political and historical backgrounds are also included since they are related to the development of legal and criminal justice systems. Sections on crime (classification of crimes and crime statistics), criminal justice procedures (investigation, trial stages, and sentencing), and punishment follow. Some important themes discussed in the country essays are described below.
Legal Systems The legal systems in a number of Asian countries are linked to European colonialism. Civil and common law systems, the two predominant legal systems, were brought into Asia largely through European colonization. Countries colonized by the British, such as India, Malaysia, and Singapore, were largely influenced by common law traditions. On the other hand, civil law was introduced through such colonizers as the Dutch in Indonesia. Additionally, some countries in the region (e.g., Thailand and Japan) never had external legal systems imposed on them through colonization; they chose civil law tradition as the basis of their legal system. Some countries classified under one legal system can also borrow ideas from other systems. The imposed legal system through colonization can also co-exist with indigenous traditions. As a result, the legal classification of some countries can be described as integrated or combined systems. India is one of the examples with a combination of common, Islamic, and customary laws. There are great varieties of political, social, and historical backgrounds among nations in Asia/ Pacific; thus, the legal systems in the region tend to be versatile. Overgeneralization may miss some of the unique features.
Crime While crime statistics are included for each country (territory) if data were available, those statistics should be interpreted with caution. Some of the statistics were based on police records while some represent number of convictions. In addition, categories included in the total number of crimes may vary from nation to © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
nation. For example, since professional negligence in traffic accidents comprises a considerable amount of the crime in Japan, the inclusion of professional negligence in traffic accidents in statistics may distort crime trends in Japan. Thus, it is important to keep these caveats in mind while making interpretations of crime statistics. Although great variability exists (see the accompanying maps below), nations in the region share some commonalities in crime problems that they find challenging. Many countries in the region state drug crimes are a prominent challenge to them. A number of countries in Asia take rigid positions against drug-related offenses and adopt severe penalties. In some countries, such as China, India, Indonesia, Laos, Myanmar, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Taiwan, Thailand, and Vietnam, the harshest punishment for the most serious drug offenses includes the death penalty.
Death Penalty Correctional systems around the globe can be distinguished by whether the death penalty is used as an available punishment. Zimring and Johnson (2008) indicated that Asia has been the center of death penalty concerns. They claimed that those who study the death penalty must study Asia since Asia is the site of at least 85 percent of the world’s executions. Albeit there is a higher prevalence of death sentences and executions in Asia compared to other regions in the world, variability of death penalty policy and practices exists among nations. As indicated in this volume, a number of countries (territories) (e.g., Armenia, Australia, Bhutan, New Zealand, Hong Kong, and Macao) have by legislation abolished the death sentence for all types of crime. Some of the countries in the region were classified as having the death penalty as an available punishment but they had not carried out any executions for a long period of time. For example, in Brunei, the death penalty is allowed; however, in practice Brunei has not carried out any executions since 1957. Likewise, in Laos the death penalty is allowed but not carried out in practice. On the other hand, there are countries (e.g., China, India, Japan, Malaysia, Mongolia, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam) that retain the death sentence and also carry out executions in practice. To get more detailed information regarding distinctions between death penalty policies and recent practices among nations, readers are encouraged to refer to the section on punishment in the chapters. The map below also shows the distribution of the death penalty for each country in this region.
Prison While prison rate assessments are available in the snapshot as well as in the map on page xxxv, readers should be cautioned about making direct comparisons. The prison rates are computed based on number of prisoners per 100,000 population. While this measure is a popular way of making comparisons and is constantly employed by researchers, plain comparisons with relative incarceration rates may be inaccurate at times and can pose some problems. For example, in © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
|
xxxi
xxxii
|
Introduction
some countries, there is no distinction between jails and prisons. As indicated in the Bangladesh chapter in this volume, all penitentiary institutions are referred to as jails in that nation. Of its total population in jails, only about 29 percent were convicted prisoners and the remaining 71 percent were either awaiting trial or detained for investigation. Thus, more comprehensive information about the prison system in a given country may help to make more accurate interpretations of prison rates. More in-depth information about inmates and prisons is included in this volume, which can help readers to get a comprehensive picture.
Acknowledgments I am grateful to all the contributors. The preparation of this volume would not have been possible without their hard work and endless efforts. —Doris C. Chu Arkansas State University
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Country Key to Asia and Pacific Maps Afghanistan
AF
Nepal
NP
Armenia
AM
New Caledonia
NC
Australia
AU
New Zealand
NZ
Azerbaijan
AZ
Niue
NU
Bangladesh
BD
Norfolk Island
NF
Bhutan
BT
North Korea
KP
Brunei Darussalam
BN
Northern Mariana Islands
MP
Cambodia
KH
Pakistan
PK
China
CN
Palau (Pacific Islands)
PW
Cook Islands
CK
Papua New Guinea
PG
Federated States of Micronesia
FM
Philippines
PH
Fiji
FJ
Pitcairn Islands
PN
French Polynesia
PF
Samoa
WS
Georgia
GE
Singapore
SG
Guam
GU
Solomon Islands
SB
Hong Kong
HK
South Korea
KR
India
IN
Sri Lanka
LK
Indonesia
ID
Taiwan
TW
Japan
JP
Tajikistan
TJ
Kazakhstan
KZ
Thailand
TH
Kiribati
KI
Timor-Leste
TL
Kyrgyzstan
KG
Tokelau
TK
Laos
LA
Tonga
TO
Macao
MO
Turkey
TR
Malaysia
MY
Turkmenistan
TM
Maldives
MV
Tuvalu
TV
Marshall Islands
MH
Uzbekistan
UZ
Mongolia
MN
Vanuatu
VU
Myanmar (Burma)
MM
Vietnam
VN
Nauru
NR
Wallis and Futuna
WF
xxxiii © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Murder in Asia and Pacific
xxxiv © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Imprisonment in Asia and Pacific
xxxv © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Corporal Punishment in Asia and Pacific
xxxvi © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Death Penalty in Asia and Pacific
xxxvii © 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Asia Afghanistan Legal System: Islamic/Civil/Common/Customary Corruption: High Human Trafficking: Medium Prison Rate: Low Death Penalty: Yes Corporal Punishment: Yes
Background Afghanistan is a landlocked country bordered by China, Pakistan, Iran, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan. The population numbers approximately 28.7 million, with an estimated 2 million refugees in Pakistan and 800,000 in Iran. The biggest ethnic group is the Pashtun people followed by Tajik, Hazara, Uzbek, Aimak, Turkmen, and Baloch. The Afghan legal system undertook several reconstructions during the 20th and early 21st centuries. Several constitutions have been implemented to coincide with regime changes, while the formal justice system has been influenced at specific times by widely different ideological, theological, and legal schools of thought. During the early 20th century the Hanafi school of Islamic jurisprudence provided a foundation for the state criminal justice system, in parallel to customary dispute resolution mechanisms. The 1950s and 1960s were a time of great change as attempts were made to modernize the state, and a new constitution was adopted in 1964. This constitution elevated state law over Islamic law.
The codification of state law continued until 1978 and many laws, which still stand today, such as the Penal Code, were enacted during this time. In 1978, the president was assassinated in a coup d’état by the Afghan Communist Party. Soviet forces invaded in 1979 on the pretext of defending the Afghan Communist Government from Islamic rebels. The Communist regime enacted a Soviet-style judicial system along the lines of Marxist legal school of jurisprudence. Much of the progress made since the 1950s was quickly lost under Communist rule. In 1989, Soviet troops withdrew from the country and in 1992 the Soviet-backed president was overthrown by mujahideen and other rebel groups; Islamic law was reinstated as the primary source of law. By 1994, Afghanistan was in a state of anarchy characterized by general lawlessness and violent conflicts between various former warlord commanders and criminal organizations to exert influence over areas including the profits from illicit commerce. The emergence of the Taliban out of the conflicts offered the Afghan peoples, tired of fighting and exhausted by famine and drought, peace and a modicum of stability. A far right, patriarchal interpretation of Islamic law was the only source of law during the Taliban era and was enforced with brutality and a complete disregard for basic concepts of human rights. The Taliban were opposed, and eventually overthrown, in 2001, by an alliance of Afghan factions, supported financially and militarily by a coalition of foreign forces. A new constitution was adopted by the Loya Jirga in January 2004. In 2004 and 2005 presidential and parliamentary elections were held 1
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
2
| Afghanistan
Afghan National Police trainees listen to a speech by their instructor at the police academy in Kabul, Afghanistan, May 22, 2004. (AP Photo/Emilio Morenatti)
in accordance with democratic principles. With regard to the presidential election, 10.5 million Afghan peoples registered to vote and Hamid Karzai was elected from 18 candidates with a majority of 55 percent. Since then the slow process of redrafting the body of legislation and reforming the fractured institutions has been underway. The erratic journey of the Afghan national police force may be illustrative of the history of the criminal justice system in full. A national civilian force was built during the 1960s modernization drive. This force was based upon the European model and supported by West and East Germany. During the Soviet-backed Communist regime the Khedamate-Atlaat-e-Dawlati (KhaD), an Afghan alternative to the Soviet Union’s Komitjet Gosudarstvjennoj Bjezopasnosti (KGB), was created. The police and KhaD were used in the internal power politics of the Afghan Communist Party, which often resulted in violent armed clashes. The police force disintegrated as a civilian force. Reform was attempted again in 1989 with the support of Germany; however, this
was halted due to the conflicts between former warlord factions. The only criminal justice institution the Taliban administered was the despotic Vice and Virtue Ministry, which was mandated only to enforce the Taliban’s far right, patriarchal interpretations of Islamic law.
Current Status of the Criminal Justice System Years of conflict and regime changes left a confused and contradictory body of legislation; in 2001 there were 2,400 separate laws originating from different regimes, and therefore legal schools of thought, that overlapped and conflicted with one another. The post-2001 reforms, at first glance, are promising. The 2004 Constitution is a progressive document defending democracy, human rights, and the rule of law. A more critical view is that the status of Islam in the Constitution could be used by the farright Islamic factions operating within the state to repress the movement toward a greater realization
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Afghanistan
of civil and political rights. The Constitution provides in article 3 that Afghanistan’s religion is Islam and that no law can violate any Islamic principle. Articles 130 and 131 also state that if no law exists on a subject then the provisions of Hanafi or Shiite jurisprudence will be applied, which makes Islamic law a secondary source of law. However, the Penal Code gives Islamic law primacy in certain areas of criminal law such as the punishments of those guilty of murder, adultery, and theft. To many the punishments enacted through Islamic law are unjust and can be perceived as contrary to Afghanistan’s human rights commitments. One example is of a student who allegedly downloaded and distributed information on the role of women in Islamic culture. He was sentenced to death by a district court for apostasy; the decision is currently being appealed at the Kabul Appeals Court. However, in the Islamic faith, these punishments come from the Koran and sunna texts and are thus sacred. In sum, the conflict between Islamic law and codified law, coupled with overlapping and contradictory legal codes, makes Afghan law, at present, too complex and lacking in clarity and consistency. With regard to the institutional infrastructure, decades of violent conflict corroded an already weak criminal justice system, limiting not just the material resources but also the pool of professional and trained coercive, legal, and support personnel from which criminal justice systems are founded upon. At present, the judicial process is slow and open to corruption. The administrative infrastructure is poor with a lack of effective record keeping, inadequate storage facilities, and a lack of resources to effectively track the progress of cases. Many buildings are not fit for court, with inconsistent power supplies and no areas for attorneys and clients to privately converse. In many provinces, district courts are convened in rented houses or take place in an impromptu manner in provincial court buildings. Furthermore, the educational infrastructure to support the system is inadequate. With regard to the coercive arm of the state, the Afghan National Police (ANP) are employed by the Ministry of the Interior and comprise the Afghan Uniformed Police; the Afghan Border Police; the Afghan Civil Order Police
|
3
(a rapid reaction force intended to maintain civil order in Afghanistan’s largest cities, created in response to the ineffectiveness of the uniformed police to control riots in Kabul in 2006); Afghan Highway Police; and Counter-Narcotics Police of Afghanistan. There is also a separate Special Narcotics Force, an elite paramilitary force that reports directly to the president and carries out high-level interdiction raids. There is no agreement on the number of police officers operating in Afghanistan. Estimates range from 62,000 (of which 12,000 are border police) to 82,000. The real number could be half this estimate due to desertion, injury, “ghost names,” and the general ineptitude of many officers. In 2008, according to the International Crises Group, only 511 of these officers were female. The lower estimate of 50,000 is equal to 180 operational officers per 100,000, which is very low compared to other states in the region such as Jordan (600/100,000) and Kyrgyzstan (340/100,000), and Western states such as Germany (292/100,000). However, some Afghan experts maintain that even this low number is unsustainable without the financial support of the international community. An alternative to the unsustainability of the ANP was the creation of an Auxiliary Police Force in 2006 to patrol Southern and Eastern Provinces and support counterinsurgency operations. The force was 11,270 strong, recruited locally and came under the control of tribal Jirgas. It was perceived by many Afghans and ANP officers as unprofessional and ineffective, and by many as a policy by a Pashtun president to re-arm Pashtun militias. For these reasons the force was disbanded in 2008. Another major problem with the ANP is that of the blurring of the boundaries between its role as a civilian and military force. However, in a state such as Afghanistan, the lines between military and civilian are blurred; the cultivation of opium is within the civilian sphere, yet many farmers are protected by large, well-armed militia. The ANP is lacking many necessary resources and sufficient training. The 2006 Kabul riots are illustrative as the ANP was ineffective in quelling the civilian dispute; many ran from the scene. Furthermore, there appeared to be no prior intelligence or chain of command, while
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
4
| Afghanistan
the officers lacked necessary equipment such as protective gear, pepper spray, and water cannons. More troubling is that the force is perceived by many Afghans as inefficient and largely corrupt. Many have reported that the police steal from travelers on state highways. Furthermore, the ANP was accused of numerous human rights violations including torture, illegal detention, and arbitrary arrest in 2006. However, strategic reform was underway, at the time of writing, including placing two officers trained to monitor human rights violations in each province, while the respected Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission began providing training to officers. The continued inefficiencies and lack of consistency in the Afghan legal system may point to why, at present, it is estimated that between 80 and 90 percent of the peoples of Afghanistan choose to use informal dispute mechanisms, according to a report of the Istituto Superiore Internazionale di Scienze Criminali (ISISC). The most common of these are the customary conflict resolution mechanisms referred to as Jirgas (in Pashtun tribes) or Shuras (in non-Pashtun tribes); due to the similarities between the two mechanisms Jirga shall refer to both. The Jirga is a customary legal system in which interpretations of Islamic law and local customs are enacted to arbitrate and prevent conflict that has the potential to harm the community. The rules and procedures differ from tribe to tribe; however, all are centered on a belief in “restorative justice” that primarily seeks to restore peace to the community rather than seeking retribution for crimes. The central tenet is that the offender is shamed and then accepted back into society with the victim agreeing to a truce. However, one researcher, Verna Lieble, has also described how many Pashtuns choose to ignore the results of the Jirga, opting instead for personal vengeance. At present the Afghan criminal justice system as a whole is also perceived by many as corrupt, inefficient, expensive, and slow (many Afghans cannot afford the bribes to have cases referred to court). The lack of legal infrastructure means many rural people have to make long journeys on roads that are considered unsafe due to threat from insurgents,
bandits, and corrupt/criminalized police officers. When at court the process can be slow, due to frequent delays caused by administrative problems. Conversely, customary mechanisms are conducted by respected elders with reputations for fairness who reach decisions using “accepted” and established local traditions and values. Many Afghans are illiterate and unable to complete legal paperwork, and due to a lack of legal education, are ignorant of the formal law; yet they are aware of their rights and duties under their tribes’ customary laws. However, the negative aspects are that it is a patriarchal system where women are not allowed to witness the process that can, in many tribes, legitimately give them away as a form of dispute settlement or compensation; much customary law was constructed by men, for men. The UN Special Rapporteur on Women objects to the Pashtun Jirga tradition of arranging a marriage between a female member of the defendant’s family to a male member of their victim’s family. The rationale is that the marriage will bind the families and prevent further disturbance; in practice it reduces women to the property of men, a commodity to be traded. Furthermore, in many areas insurgents and former warlords violently take seats to increase their illegitimate authority.
Finding of Guilt Formal System Afghanistan’s formal court system is developing based on the Constitution, the 2005 Law on Organization and Jurisdiction of Courts of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, and the 2004 Interim Criminal Code for Courts. Afghanistan is also a signatory of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and commits, in the preamble of the Constitution, to observe the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Thus, Afghanistan is obliged to uphold the judicial rights contained within these international instruments. However, the practical application of law lags far behind the actual legislation.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Afghanistan
The Afghan Judiciary, mandated by the 2005 Law on Organization and Jurisdiction of Courts of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, is hierarchically structured, with the Supreme Court at the top. Each of Afghanistan’s 34 provinces has a provincial court that is required to have within its jurisdiction: a Central Provincial Primary Court, Juveniles Court, Commercial Primary Court, Family Issues Primary Court, and District Primary Court. District courts have jurisdiction over petty, misdemeanor, and felony crimes. Appeals are referred first to the provincial court and then to the Supreme Court. The 2005 Narcotics Law allows for the creation of special Narcotics Tribunals within the Kabul Provincial Court, which operate and are bound under the 2005 Law on Organization and Jurisdiction of Courts and the 2004 Criminal Code for Courts. The 2005 Juvenile Code article 3 mandates that a juvenile primary court must be held in the capital city of all of Afghanistan’s 34 provinces to protect and prosecute juveniles. An example of the conflicting nature of Afghan legislation is that Juvenile Code article 7 defines a child as a juvenile under 18 years old, while article 10 states that children below 12 are not criminally responsible. Penal Code articles 70 to 73 offer a different classification with minors being aged between 7 and 13, teenagers aged between 14 and 17, and children under 7 being exempt from prosecution. There currently exist 34 provincial courts and 408 primary courts, although only 81 percent of these are functioning. Juvenile courts are situated in the provincial capital as are some primary courts, due to a lack of resources. This makes them inaccessible to many rural people who may have to make long journeys on poor roads that are considered unsafe due to the insurgency, bandits, and/or criminalized police officers. Under the 2004 Criminal Code for Courts, all primary courts are assigned three judges, although it is possible for one judge to sit for security reasons or a lack of resources. Penal action for the prosecution of all crimes is introduced to the court by the primary Saranwal (prosecutor) who investigates whether a crime has been committed and who is responsible. At this stage the Saranwal can either
|
5
indict the suspect, or if there is not sufficient evidence, the case may be dismissed (a more senior Saranwal or the victim may file a complaint against this decision). A notification of the deeds must then be served to the suspect at least three days before the trial. If the suspect cannot be found, then the notification is issued to a police-appointed defense council who acts on the suspect’s behalf and the defendant is tried in absentia. The suspect and defense have the right to examine all documents collected in the Saranwal’s investigation. The accused has a right to remain silent during the process. The judge’s decision can be petitioned by the Saranwal, sentenced person, relative, or the defense council. The petition is evaluated by a committee headed by a Supreme Court judge and two appellate judges. Under the Constitution all citizens of Afghanistan have equal rights and duties before the law, and all are considered innocent until proven guilty (a right which, as shall be discussed shortly, is seldom adhered to with regard to rape); the basic right of due process is provided for under article 27. All are provided with the right to be immediately informed of the nature of the accusation upon arrest. Article 31 of the Constitution provides all with the right to appoint a defense attorney and those charged with a criminal act are entitled to defense from a state-appointed attorney. The right to confidentiality between attorney and client is also provided for in this article. Article 19 of the Criminal Code for Courts sets the eligibility for state assistance as the accused, or suspect, being “financially unable to appoint a defense attorney.” It further states that the defense council must be informed of any searches, confrontations, line-ups, expert examinations, or interrogations during the investigation so that they can be present. Unfortunately, there is a void between legislation and practice in Afghanistan. Legal representation is scarce to the point of being unavailable. There are just 250 lawyers registered with the Ministry of Justice to provide free legal aid to cover a population of 28.7 million. In many provinces there is no access to free legal aid at all. Legal aid in Kabul appears to have improved since 2001; however, few lawyers are present during interrogation and trial,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
6
| Afghanistan
contrary to the Constitution and the Criminal Code for Courts. Furthermore, many defense attorneys are contacted on the day of the trial, instead of the five days prescribed by the Criminal Code for Courts; this leaves them little time to produce an effective case. Under article 30 of the Constitution, statements or confessions obtained by means of compulsion are invalid; the confession must be voluntary and the confessor must be of sound mind. However, several women interviewed by a UN researcher in Pole-Charki Prison, Kabul, maintained that they were made to sign confessions at police stations without a defense attorney present. The women interviewed were illiterate and ignorant of their rights and duties before the law. Furthermore, many reported promises of release after signing; these confessions therefore should have been considered invalid under Afghan law. At present the Supreme Court employs 1,700 judges, while the Attorney General’s Office employs 2,500 Saranwals. The Law on Organization and Jurisdiction of Courts, article 58, states that to qualify as a judge an individual must hold a BA degree in law or Islamic law, or a diploma in religious studies from a recognized center and have completed the state practical judicial training course. In practice, the make-up of Afghan judges’ education does not conform to this provision: • 44 percent of judges hold degrees in Islamic law. • 21 percent have attained no higher than a high school education. • 16 percent have qualifications from nonuniversity programs. • 12 percent hold degrees in law. • 8 percent hold nonlaw degrees. With regard to Saranwals, in Kabul 37 percent have university law backgrounds, while in the provinces only 20 percent hold law or Islamic law degrees. Clearly, there is a huge void between the rights and procedures expressed under state law and the ability of the state to enforce them. Under these conditions it is little surprise that the majority of
Afghans prefer to use informal dispute resolution mechanisms.
Informal System Ali Wardak, an expert on Afghan customary law, notes that mediation tends to be split between spheres of authority within Afghan society. This starts with the family, where all “private” matters, such as domestic violence and divorce, tend to be resolved; the oldest male family member has the greatest influence. Conflicts outside of this private sphere are resolved in Jirgas at either the village or tribal level depending on the potential disruption the dispute may cause. For instance, disputes over land rights or murders, which may have the potential to disrupt the tribe, will be under the jurisdiction of the tribal Jirga. The Jirga is composed of the elite of village or tribal elders who are considered to embody certain qualities that make them good sources of judgment, including hospitality, belonging to a honorable family, a record of bravery in violent conflict, while they must be eloquent orators and have a proven record of fair and effective judgment at Jirgas. These men sit in an inner circle with a respected religious leader. An outer circle is formed in which all males of the tribe can observe the proceedings; this is thought to act as a transparency mechanism. The elders then pass judgment using their interpretations of the customary laws of their tribe. The laws tend to be a mixture of custom, practice, and interpretations of Islamic law. The laws and customs vary from tribe to tribe. The formal and customary systems do in some cases interact. In Kandahar Province criminal cases are forwarded to tribal Jirgas by the state and then returned to the prosecutor’s office if the case cannot be resolved.
Islamic Law If Islamic law is used as the source of law to decide a case, then all Hudud and Qissass offenses must be witnessed by two sane adult Muslim men, four in the case of Zena. It is argued that the harshness of the punishments deters offenders and that the
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Afghanistan
standard of proof is very high and must, according to the sunna, be proved beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, a lot depends on the honesty of the two/four male witnesses. Under Islamic law a child under seven years old is unpunishable, while from the ages of 7 to 15, the family or tribe is held responsible. After 15 the individual is criminally responsible. The individual can also use the defense of insanity and coercion into the crime.
Crime State Law Crime in Afghanistan is currently classified by the 1976 Penal Code, Book 2, under the following three levels of seriousness: • Felonies, which include embezzling public funds; counterfeiting; the torture of individuals by public officials; arson; murder; kidnapping, with coercion or fraud, of a teenager; kidnapping of an adult women; adultery; highway robbery. • Misdemeanors, which include bribery; the use of illicit narcotics or alcoholic drinks; illegal detention of an individual (extended to a felony if accompanied by torture, coercion, or if the individual is a state employee); kidnap of a minor; kidnapping of a male adult; crimes pertaining to the unlawful slaughtering and hurting of animals. • Obscenities, which include causing disturbance or inconvenience by blowing a horn “or producing uproar or hubbub”; releasing a lunatic “who terrifies people” on public roads; public nudity; and cruelty to domesticated pets. Rape is not clearly defined in the Penal Code; it is implied in various articles that refer to Zena (adultery or sex outside of marriage), including article 429(1) which states: “A person who, through violence, threat, or deceit, violates the chastity of another (whether male or female).” However, it is noted by a UN report that victims of rape are gen-
|
7
erally treated as committing the crime of Zena until able to prove their innocence. Under the Penal Code, article 61, individuals are protected from prosecution if murder is committed in defense of fear of death or serious injury; the act of, or fear of, adultery or homosexuality; human kidnapping; defense against larceny; or defense against unauthorized entry into a residential home at night. Article 62 does though limit the action in that if legal recourse was possible, then it reverts back to being classified an illegal act. It could be argued that this article implicitly makes homosexuality a prohibited act by its inclusion; however, we are unaware of any penalties formally set in the legislation. The use, production, trafficking, possession, and retailing of illicit narcotics is prohibited under the 2005 Counter-Narcotics Law. This law lists the substance prohibited under national law in the following four classification tables: 1. “Prohibited drugs of abuse with no medical use”—this includes heroin, opium poppy seeds and straw, MDMA (Ecstasy), and cannabis. 2. “Strictly controlled plants and substances with a medical use” (which are considered high-risk drugs of abuse)—this includes cocaine and opium. 3. “Controlled plants and substances with a medical use” (considered drugs with a risk of abuse)—this includes codeine and GBH. 4. “Substances frequently used in the manufacture of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances (precursor chemicals)”—this includes ethyl ether and ephedrine.
Islamic Law Article 1 of the Penal Code differentiates between crimes under the jurisdiction of the code and those to be administered according to Islamic law. The code covers Tazir crimes, ones that are considered less serious under Islamic law and can therefore be left to the discretion of nonreligious judgment. Crimes not covered are those that under Islamic law entail nonflexible punishments, once proved by a just trial. These crimes are classified as follows:
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
8
| Afghanistan
• Hudud (crimes that threaten the existence of Islam), which include Sariqah (theft); Hirabah (armed robbery or armed rebellion); Zina (adultery and sex outside of marriage); Qadhf (an unsupported accusation of Zina); Sharb alKhamr (intoxication); and Riddah (apostasy). • Qissass, which are intentional crimes committed against an individual’s person and could include murder, manslaughter, or bodily harm. If there is a lack of evidence to try the individual under Islamic law, then the case is reclassified as a Tazir crime and comes under the jurisdiction of the Penal Code.
rise in opium abuse; the highest levels of opium and heroin consumption in the world occur along the trafficking routes out of Afghanistan. The consumption of opiates in Afghanistan is above the global average. In 2005, it was estimated that within Afghanistan 150,000 people had consumed opium (0.6 percent of the population) while 50,000 (0.2 percent) had used heroin, 520,000 (2.2 percent) had used hashish, and 160,000 (0.7 percent) of the population had consumed alcohol (a prohibited intoxicant). In general, rural populations are more likely than urbanites to consume opium, heroin, and hashish, while alcohol is more widely used by urban populations.
Drugs
Corruption
The illicit narcotics trade, or more specifically the illicit opium trade, is one of the most high profile and damaging crimes in Afghanistan. It is also indicative of the deficiencies in the criminal justice system. Afghanistan is by far the world’s largest producer of illicit opium—it is estimated that of 8,870 metric tons of illicit opium produced globally in 2007, 8,200 was produced in Afghanistan: a 92 percent share of the market. The nearest rival is Burma, which was able to produce only 460 metric tons. This record-breaking output is cultivated over a 193,000-hectare area. During 2008, 98 percent of all opium was confined to the areas in the west and south, which are classified as high or extremely risky by the United Nations Department of Safety and Security (UNDSS). Most districts are inaccessible to UN and nongovernmental organizations and under the authority of insurgents and/or organized criminal networks, who have violently opposed eradication measures by the state in the past. The major growing areas of production levels include Helmand, Kandahar, Uruzgan, Farah, and Nimroz. According to the United Nations Office of Drug Control (UNODC), 2.4 million Afghans, or 9.8 percent of the population, were involved in the trade in 2008. The increased cultivation has had a direct effect on neighboring states, many of whom are used as trafficking routes and as a result have witnessed a
Corruption in Afghanistan facilitates the illicit narcotics trade. Police and local state officials are bribed to not eradicate opium crops, according to a UNODC report, while high-level offenders are immune from arrest and prosecution due to connections with the political and criminal justice elite. This is illustrated by the practice in some areas of posts for police chiefs in poppy-growing districts being auctioned off to the highest bidder. They can reach as much as US$100,000 for a six-month appointment: an appointment that legitimately pays approximately US$360 over the six months. Corruption in Afghanistan runs deeper than the involvement of drug trafficking networks. Afghanistan is an overall hugely corrupt nation; in the World Bank’s report, “World Governance Indicators,” Afghanistan is placed in the lowest 1 percentile: the only state considered less able to control corruption is Somalia. A consequence of ongoing violent conflict, the existence of former warlords (many of whom profited from the illicit opiate trade during their conflicts with Soviet and Taliban forces) in state institutions and their illegitimate authority in rural areas, the lack of state influence in many areas, and ineffective institutional constraints on corruption is that a culture of impunity has arisen in which criminal networks are protected by corrupt state employees at all levels.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Afghanistan
Connected to institutional corruption is the criminalization of the police, which appears to be a problem of epidemic proportions. There are reports of the police facilitating kidnapping and creating ad hoc, unofficial tollbooths on national roads. In 2007, 35 police officers were removed after a group of truckers went on strike over the payment of such tolls on the Herat-Delaram highway. The corruption and criminalization of state employees is arguably the most damaging crime in Afghanistan, for as long as it, and the impunity it offers, continues, the state will be unable to counter other high-level crimes such as the trade in illicit narcotics.
Insurgency Many prominent crimes in Afghanistan can be linked to the ongoing insurgency. The insurgency claimed 6,500 lives in 2007. A worrisome development is that civilian targets such as schoolteachers, religious leaders, and politicians who support human rights are increasingly being targeted. This strategy has resulted in the closure of 370 schools, which has prevented almost 220,000 individuals from receiving an education, and the death of many perceived progovernment religious leaders and state employees, including nearly 900 police officers and 140 teachers and students in 2007. Another insurgent-linked crime is kidnapping by the Taliban and other militia. In the second half of 2006, 190 kidnappings were reported for political or criminal purposes. The actual level is likely to be much higher, according to a U.S. State Department report. The United Nations reports that the number of insurgent-based security incidents increased significantly in 2008.
Human Trafficking The U.S. State Department notes that Afghanistan is a source, transit, and destination country for men, women, and children forced into sexual, military, and commercial servitude. Human trafficking, forced servitude, and prostitution can be linked to the illicit opium industry as opium seed is offered on a credit basis by criminal organizations. If a debt
|
9
cannot be repaid, for instance after a poor harvest, then it is not unknown for poor farmers to repay the debt with female members of the family.
Violence against Women Violence against women is a persistent problem. According to the U.S. State Department Human Rights Report, women suffer at the hands of their family members, police officials, and the general tolerance of violence in their communities. And, as noted above, women who report their rape risk being charged as adulterers, or Zina. The Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission documented 1,651 crimes against women in 2006; of these, 558 were in the form of “severe beatings,” 213 were forced marriages, 50 were murder cases, and 34 were cases of rape (though rape is not a codified crime). The true number is likely significantly higher. The Ministry of the Interior in 2006 reported 134 cases of rape against women and 103 against male children in 2006. An extension of this problem is that of former warlords and their militias raping male and female children and women; during 2005, 21 such cases were reported according to a U.S. State Department report. Again the true number is likely significantly higher. It is also reported that forced marriages and abductions are common crimes committed by former warlords and their militia.
Other A 2006 study by the Centre for Strategic International Studies interviewed 1,000 Afghans; the major conclusion was that the majority of all crimes are unreported. The results indicated increase in theft in both rural and urban areas and a rise in burglaries in Kabul. Kidnapping for ransom has also increased dramatically and is thought to be widespread.
Punishment State Law The Penal Code, articles 23 to 26, state that: • Felonies are punishable with the death sentence or continued (16–20 years) or long (5–15
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
10
| Afghanistan
years) imprisonment. The death penalty is defined as “the hanging of convicted person on gallows until death.” • Misdemeanors are punishable with a prison term from three months to no more than five years, or a cash fine of more than 3,000 afghanis. • Obscenities are punishable with a prison term of between 24 hours and three months, or a cash fine of up to 3,000 (US$63) afghanis. In October 2007, 15 Afghanis were executed, by firing squad (not hanging as called for in the Penal Code) at Pol-e-Charki Prison, Kabul. The offenses included murder, robbery, and looting. Prior to this, the last execution in Afghanistan was in April 2004, according to Amnesty International. A unique characteristic of the Penal Code is that Zena, if unpunishable by Islamic law, is considered an offense punishable with a long prison term. Many women who abscond from home are also tried for Zena. A UNODC study, which interviewed 56 women in Pol-e-Charki Prison in Kabul, found that 50 percent were detained for committing “moral crimes,” which appear to consist of a wide interpretation of what constitutes Zena; most puzzling is that one woman was charged with “attempted adultery.” The 2005 Narcotic Law, Chapter 4, sets forth penalties, primarily the following: • Trafficking; the punishment is reliant on the amount, and the substance, trafficked. A guideline is set at a maximum of life imprisonment and a fine of between 1,000,000 (US$21,022) and 10,000,000 (US$210,227) afghanis for trafficking heroin, cocaine, or morphine. The minimum sentence is up to three months’ imprisonment and a fine of between 5,000 (US$105) and 10,000 (US$210) afghanis for the trafficking of any other substance contained in the tables. Furthermore, employers or organizers of traffickers are set penalties three times as severe as the maximum penalty, not exceeding 20 years. • Drug laboratories, manufacturing and storage; an individual who allows his or her property
to be used for the purpose of manufacturing, cultivating, processing, storing, concealing, or distributing illicit narcotics can be sentenced to between 10 and 20 years’ imprisonment and fined between 50,000 (US$1,052) and 1,000,000 (US$21,022) afghanis. • Drug-related corruption and intimidation is punishable by 5 to 10 years and a fine of twice the amount of the bribe. • Cultivation; for the cultivating of one jerib (0.4 hectares) of opium or coca bush the penalty is between six months and one year of imprisonment and a fine of between 10,000 (US$210) and 50,000 (US$1,052) afghanis. This is increased by one month imprisonment and a 5,000 (US$105) afghani fine per 100 square meters in excess of one jerib. In addition the crops shall be destroyed without compensation. • Consumption of illegal drugs; the consumption or possession of heroin, morphine, or cocaine is punishable with six months to one year in prison and a fine of between 20,000 (US$420) and 50,000 (US$1,052) afghanis. All other substances are punishable with between three and six months’ imprisonment and a fine between 10,000 (US$210) and 25,000 (US$315) afghanis for opium or 5,000 (US$105) to 10,000 (US$210) afghanis for all other illicit substances. Possession of more than 1 gram of heroin, morphine, or cocaine and 10 grams of opium or hashish are punished as trafficking. The Penal Code also gives the court the power to: quarantine individuals into mental health hospitals or other relevant health institutions for a period of no less than six months; restrict individuals movement or residence to prevent repetition of the crime; delicense individuals from their trade or profession or from driving for a limited amount of time; and close properties used to commit a crime. Article 35(2) of the Narcotics Law also allows for the extradition of nationals in accordance with international and bilateral international agreements.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Afghanistan
Juvenile Punishment The Juvenile Code article 10(2) states that children between the ages of 7 and 12 can, instead of penal punishment, be given a warning, confined to a rehabilitation center, or be supervised by social service. Children between 12 and 18 can be punished with long, medium, and short imprisonment as long as it does not exceed one-third of the maximum term given to adults. The death penalty is prohibited, yet continued imprisonment is allowed if it does not exceed half the maximum applied to adults. If the imprisonment is less than three years, then it may take place in a rehabilitation center. One year probation can also be applied in exchange for imprisonment if the term would be less than three years.
Islamic Law The Penal Code does not offer punishments for Hudud or Qissass crimes, as under Islamic law these punishments are inflexible. The judge has no discretion once a crime is proved, as punishments are set by the Koran or sunna. Hudud punishments consist of the following: • Sariqah, which is punishable with the amputation of a hand. • Hirabah, which is punishable with death, crucifixion, cross-amputation (one hand and one foot), or banishment. • Zina, adultery is punishable with death by stoning, sex outside of marriage with 100 lashes. • Qadhf, which is punishable with 80 lashes • Sharb al-Khamr, which is punishable with 40 lashes. • Riddah, which is punishable with death. The central concept of Qissass is that of lex talionis (an “eye for an eye”). Under Islamic law the victim (or victim’s family) is entitled, under the supervision of the authorities, to inflict a proportional punishment of similar magnitude to the crime. However, this right may be waived, in which case the offender is pardoned by the wronged party in exchange for a Diat (fine).
|
11
There have been no recent reports of the official sanction of stoning or flogging (which would suggest minimal or unreported enforcement of Hudud punishments). Cases in state courts involving murder and rape have been reported in which the judges have allowed the victim to enforce the execution of the guilty party themselves, or receive a form of compensation (which would conform to Qissass). However, all capital punishment must be authorized by the president.
Informal Systems Punishments differ between tribes and regions, yet certain characteristics permeate all tribes, cultures, and regions, including the belief in restorative justice, with the apology of the perpetrator of the crime being central to this. According to the International Legal Foundation, punishments can include the following: • The penalty for murder in most regions ranges from the paying of a fine to the victim’s family, to the death sentence, or the binding of the families through the giving of a woman from the perpetrator’s family to marry a male from the victim’s family (a custom condemned by some tribes especially those in Nuristan Province). • The punishment for Zena between two married persons tends to be the death sentence for both parties. • In Pashtun tribes, if a man rapes a women, he is killed. • The punishment for theft tends to be centered on returning the goods. However, rules differ as to whether an extra punishment should be enacted. Hazaras pay no extra fine other than an apology, while in the Nuristan Province the extra fine can be anywhere between two and five times the worth of the object and a sheep must be slain at the house of the victim. • With regard to domestic violence, in the Pashtun regions if a husband beats a wife, the husband must pay the wife’s father a fine or in the case of murder, the father may kill the perpetrator.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
12
| Afghanistan
Furthermore, many rural areas of Afghanistan are controlled by former militia warlords and insurgents, including, but not exclusively, the Taliban. The illicit punishments handed out by such groups are largely undocumented. However, the punishments enforced by the Taliban during its rule may be reflective of its contemporary method of punishment. From 2000 to 2001 the Taliban officially banned the cultivation of the opium poppy. The punishments for disobeying this order included public humiliation; prison sentences of two years or more; and corporal punishment such as lashings, public beatings, and executions. In 2006, more than a dozen Afghan and foreign nationals were beheaded for “crimes” such as espionage and support of the Karzai Government.
Prison The 2005 Law on Prisons article 12 states that every province shall have a detention center (for holding accused individuals pretrial) and a prison (for holding those convicted of a crime). Each district must also have a detention center. Article 23 obliges all prisons and detention centers to be built in accordance with Islamic principles and the United Nations Standard Principles and Terms, while all remaining facilities must be adjusted. Articles 24 to 28 oblige the state to offer a minimum standard of living, including all individuals having a bed and bedding, adequate hygiene, healthy food, clean drinking water, and the opportunity to walk outdoors in the open air for a minimum of two hours a day; a free health service must also be provided. Well-equipped libraries are required to help detainees to study, worship, and for recreation. Prison administrators are required to operate educational and vocational training centers approved by the Ministry of Education. Prisoners are afforded the right to be remunerated for any work they carry out while incarcerated. Detainees and prisoners have the right to contact with their families; these meetings must be in places controlled by the prison or detention center staff. Article 37 also provides for up to 20 days home leave and up to seven days on compassionate grounds.
The formal prison population has significantly increased in recent years from approximately 600 in 2002 to more than 10,000 in 2007 (in addition to more than 500 juveniles), an increase of more than 1,600 percent in five years, according to the ISISC. As the other arms of the Afghan justice system become more efficient, then this number will likely increase. An alternative estimate by the International Center for Prison Studies for 2007 was 9,600. This estimate states that 2.8 percent of the population was female, 4 percent juveniles, and 0.9 percent foreign nationals. The current prison infrastructure is unable to cope with such numbers. The flagship prison is Pol-e-Charki, in Kabul, which has been described by a UN official as overcrowded, lacking sufficient power and clean water, with a security situation described as “shaky,” largely due to corruption and lack of prison staff. Yet for all these negatives the UN official maintains that “Pol-e-Charki is a great prison compared to the other prisons in the country. . . . Most are uninhabitable.” The Afghan Ministry of Justice has noted that of the 34 official prisons, 42 percent are in rented homes. The U.S. State Department reports that in some districts shipping containers are used to house convicts and that in many areas where no detention facilities exist, women are forced into slave labor for the families of village elders. Furthermore, it is noted with regard to juvenile offenders that in 12 provinces, as separate facilities did not exist, children were detained alongside adults. Due to this children are exposed to physical and sexual exploitation and abuse. James Windle and Graham Farrell Further Reading Conference on the Rule of Law in Afghanistan. (2007): http://www.rolafghanistan.esteri.it/ ConferenceRol. International Crises Group. (2008). Policing in Afghanistan: Still Searching for a Solution: http:// www.crisesgroup.org. Ruben, Barnet. (2006). Afghanistan’s Uncertain Transition from Turmoil to Uncertainty. New York: Council on Foreign Relations.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Armenia
United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime: http:// www.unodc.org/. Wardak, Ali. (2004). “Building a Post-War Justice System in Afghanistan.” Crime, Law and Social Change 41(4): 319–341.
Armenia Legal System: Civil Murder: Medium Corruption: Medium Human Trafficking: Medium Prison Rate: Medium Death Penalty: No Corporal Punishment: No
Background A former republic of the Soviet Union, Armenia is a landlocked mountainous country located in the southern Caucasus. One of the world’s oldest civilizations, Armenia was the first country to officially adopt Christianity as its religion in 301. However, the current republic was established in 1991 when the country declared its independence from the Soviet Union. The capital of Armenia is Yerevan. At present, Armenia is a unitary, multiparty, presidential representative democratic republic. Legislative power is entrusted to the Parliament of Armenia. Executive power is exercised by the government while judicial power by the courts. Armenia is very homogenous. According to the April 2006 data, the population of Armenia was 3,215, 800 with ethnic Armenians making up 97.9 percent of the population. The largest minority groups are the yezidis and Russians. Other minorities include Greeks, Kurds, Assyrians, and Georgians.
History of the Legal System The history of Armenian criminal law and legal system takes its origins from the first Armenian kingdoms, where judicial power was executed solely by
|
13
the kings. Later, in the 12th to 13th centuries Mkhitar Gosh’s “Codex” and Smbat Sparapet’s “Law Book” were introduced. These codified acts contained provisions regulating the age of criminal responsibility, the system of punishments, and evidence. After many centuries of living under the rule of conquerors and having no state system, in 1918, the First Armenian Republic was created. The government of the newly established country founded a Ministry of Interior and created a police force. A law on police was adopted on April 21, 1920, regulating its structure, jurisdiction, and responsibilities. According to the law, the Ministry of Interior was divided into units (“commissariats”) administered in provinces and districts, as well as in Yerevan. In the villages the responsibilities of the police were carried out by the Ministry of Interior officers (“commissars”). In the 1920s, the government of the First Armenian Republic developed the judicial system based on the transformation of the Russian Empire’s Court System into the Armenian legislation. The Prosecutor’s Service was attached to the Court System. On November 29, 1920, Armenia was declared a Soviet republic. In 1961, the Criminal Code and Criminal Procedure Code of the Armenian Soviet Republic were adopted, modeled on the Criminal Code of the Russian Soviet Republic. The structure of the Armenian Soviet Republic judiciary system was identical to that of the other Soviet republics. In general, the police and prosecutor’s office were responsible for fighting crimes and investigating the cases. Afterward, the cases were handled by the Courts of the First Instance (“national courts”). The Supreme Court of the Armenian Republic had the authority to review the cases solved by the First Instance courts. As to the jails, they were under the control of the Ministry of Justice. All these institutions were acting under the respective bodies of the USSR. After the collapse of the Soviet Union and the establishment of the new republic, Armenia was faced with the necessity to adopt new legislation and reconstruct the main administrative bodies. During the first years of independence, the legislation of the previous Soviet Union was in force. On July 5, 1995,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
14
| Armenia
the Constitution of Armenia was enacted upon the referendum. In 1998, the Parliament of Armenia (which is called National Assembly) approved the Criminal Procedure Code, while the Criminal Code of the newly established Armenia was adopted only on April 18, 2003. The Criminal Code set criminal responsibility for such new offenses as terrorism, money laundering, illegal banking, human trafficking, and so forth. One of the achievements of the code was the introduction of a system of alternative sanctions and abolition of the death penalty, which had been in the Soviet Criminal Code. Being a civil law country where the legal system is based entirely on written law, Armenia also adopted laws regulating the structure of the judiciary and law enforcement bodies. On November 8, 1996, the president of Armenia signed a decree entitled On Judiciary Reforms of the Republic of Armenia. In 1998, the Armenian Parliament passed laws on Formation of Courts, On the Status of Judges, On Prosecution, On the Solicitor Service, On Compulsory Implementation of Judiciary Acts, and On the Service Providing the Compulsory Implementation of Judiciary Acts. In correspondence with the new legislation, a three-staged judiciary system replaced the twostaged court system, which was inherited from Soviet times. The new judiciary system started to function consisting of the primary-level Courts of First Instance, followed by the Courts of Appeal and Court of Cassation (the supreme judicial body of the Republic of Armenia except for constitutional matters). As a part of judiciary reforms taking place in the country, on April 18, 2007, the Judicial Code of Armenia was introduced, which provided for the creation of specialized courts, in particular, the Criminal and Civil Courts (Northern, Southern, and Yerevan City). However, in 2008, these specialized criminal courts were abolished. All the reforms relating to the judiciary are carried out by the Ministry of Justice. The functions of the ministry include, but are not limited to, providing legal advice to the president, governmental bodies, or the legislative branch; providing assistance in developing the legislation of Armenia; administering punishments imposed by the courts; and
ensuring the compulsory enforcement of judicial acts of the courts of the Republic of Armenia. As a part of judiciary reforms and as a requirement for Armenia’s ascension into the Council of Europe, in 2001, the Penitentiary Service of the Republic of Armenia, which functioned under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, was transferred to the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Armenia. Radical reforms were carried out also in the prosecutor’s office and police. In the beginning of the 1999, according to the law On Prosecutor’s Office, the prosecution system was divided into the General Prosecutor’s Office, Prosecution Offices of the Provinces, of the Yerevan City, of the Yerevan City Districts, as well as into the Prosecutor’s Offices of the Military Units. The prosecutor’s office is authorized to initiate criminal prosecution, including criminal case, as prescribed by law; wield control over the legality of preliminary investigation and inquiry; support the prosecution on criminal cases in courts; present state interests protection suits to the court; appeal the acts, verdicts, sentences, or the decisions of the court; and supervise the implementation of punishment and other means of enforcement measures. In 2007, one of the functions of the prosecutor’s office, investigation of crimes, was taken from the unit and handed to the newly established Special Investigations Service. As to the police, one of the first changes encountered by this body in 1992 was the creation of internal police forces and the elimination of neighborhood police (the latter to be re-established in later years). Special units to combat organized crime and drug trafficking were created. In the same year, Armenia joined the International Criminal Police Organization (INTERPOL). This helped establish closer cooperation between the police officers of Armenia and foreign countries. In November 1996, the Ministries of Internal Affairs and State Security were combined into one. However, in 1999, they again were divided and continue to function independently. On April 16, 2001, the Armenian Parliament passed the law On Police and on June 30, 2002, the law On Police Service. According to the last
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Armenia
document, the Armenian police became a law enforcement body adjoined directly to the government of Armenia. The main responsibilities of the police include law enforcement, investigation of crimes, crime prevention, social control, and protection of the public. The activities of the police are directed by the chief of police appointed by the president of Armenia. The structure of the Armenian police is represented by the Central Body, Yerevan Police Department, 10 regional departments (one per each marz/region) and 54 police districts. It also includes the Police Force, Police Academy, and Police Training Center. The Central Body heads the police command staff and is composed of Headquarters, Combating Organized Crime Main Department (including the Trafficking in Drugs and Human Beings Division), Criminal Investigations Main Department, Investigative Main Department, Public Order Department, Personnel Department, Information Center, Public Relations and Press Department, Finances and Economic Affairs Department, Administration, Department of Road Inspection, Passports and Visas Department, State Protection Department, Criminal Forensics and Legal Affairs Department, as well as the National Central Bureau of INTERPOL.
Crime Detailed definitions of crimes are prescribed by the Criminal Code of Armenia. Therefore, a person cannot be accused as a criminal for the willful committal of a socially dangerous act, if the latter is not established as a crime by the Criminal Code. Crime in Armenia is multifold. Nowadays the most frequent types of offenses are corruption, tax evasion, assault, and theft. Due to the extremely high level of hidden corruption, crimes are not accurately reflected in official crime statistics. In the last two decades, corruption has become a particular challenge for Armenian society. However, the cases that receive international resonance are based on political motives. One of the offenses took place on October 27, 1999, when six armed men attacked the Armenian parliament and killed the Armenian
|
15
prime minister and seven other high-ranking officials. The leader of the group, Nairi Hunanyan, accused the government of being corrupt and leading Armenia into political and economic ruin. On October 28, the attackers surrendered and freed the hostages after they were allowed to speak on national television and were promised a fair trial. The court said the criminals had acted on their own and were not guided by outsiders. The criminals were sentenced to life imprisonment. However, many people believe that some political forces, which remained unrevealed and unpunished, were behind the 1999 Armenian parliament shooting.
Classification of Crimes The age of criminal responsibility in Armenia is 16. However, juveniles who reached the age of 14 before the committal of the crime are subject to criminal responsibility for several types of crimes: murder, rape, violent sexual acts, kidnapping, grave assault, theft, robbery, extortion, hooliganism, joyriding, theft or extortion of weapons, drugs, damaging transportation or communication systems, destruction or damage of property in aggravating circumstances. Article 19 of the Armenian Criminal Code classifies crimes into four categories: not very grave, medium gravity, grave, and particularly grave offenses. The gravity of the offense is evaluated based on the punishment provided for the particular crime by the Criminal Code of Armenia. Not very grave crimes such as libel, insult, forgery or use of forged documents, false crime reporting, and tax evasion are the least serious of the four offenses and are punished either with a punishment other than imprisonment or with imprisonment not exceeding two years. Medium-gravity intentional crimes such as joyriding or inducting a person into the use of drugs are punished by a term of imprisonment not exceeding five years. Crimes of negligence receive different levels of punishment but usually do not rise above medium gravity so that the categories of grave and very grave crimes include only intentional crimes. Theft, fraud, robbery, drug sale, production, trafficking, assault, and bribery usually are in the list of
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
16
| Armenia
grave crimes. The Criminal Code provides a maximum punishment not exceeding 10 years of imprisonment for grave crimes. Particularly grave crimes such as murder, money laundering, terrorism, and treason are the most serious crimes. The usual punishment for these crimes is imprisonment for more than 10 years or life imprisonment. Starting from 2008, no criminal responsibility is provided for the consumption of drugs in Armenia. Nevertheless, criminal responsibility and imprisonment for the term of three to seven years is set for the illegal cultivation, production, sale, supplying, possession, transportation, theft, or extortion of any type of drugs. The punishment can be increased to 15 years if there are aggravating factors. A person voluntarily submitting drugs to police is exempted from criminal responsibility for illegal production, sale, possession, supplying, and transportation of drugs. Special provisions are provided for abetting or involving a person in the use of drugs, as well as for the organization and maintaining of dens for the use of drugs.
Crime Statistics For many decades Armenia had an image of a country with extremely low crime. During the last several years, the rise of property and violent crimes, as well as drug-related and corruption offenses, has challenged this conception. According to Armenian police data, the crime rate peaked in 1992 at 473 offenses per 100,000 residents and then began a decline and reached 304 offenses per 100,000 population in 2006. In 2007, there were 8,428 criminal offenses in the country; 43.6 percent of offenses reported to the police were property offenses and 11.6 percent, violent crimes. In spite of the fact that, according to the Corruption Perception Index for 2007, Armenia was ranked 99 out of 179 countries, only seven cases of bribery were registered by the Armenian police. This figure is enough to make anybody think that official crime statistics are misrepresented. According to unpublished data from the Armenian police, the crimes recorded for 2007 were as follows: Homicide Assault
104 521
Rape Robbery Theft Joyriding Embezzlement Fraud Drug offenses Bribery Hooliganism Traffic offense Illegal turnover of weapons Money counterfeiting Other crimes Total
8 199 2,712 137 69 432 1,080 7 241 408 180 57 2,273 8,428
Though, according to official data, the trends of such crimes as theft, robbery, rape, and homicide have remained more or less steady over the last 10 years, an enormous change was registered in drug-offense rates. Mitigation of the control over the borders with Turkey and Iran, which used to be strictly closed during the Soviet era, in recent years has contributed to the increase in drug-related offenses. From 1999 through 2007, the drug-offense rate increased sharply, peaking in 2007 with 33.6 drug offenses per 100,000 population. The reported number and types of offenses vary within the country. In 2007, the highest crime rate was registered in Yerevan (the capital of Armenia) with a rate of 452.7 per 100,000 population, and the lowest rates were registered in Gegharkunik (208.3), Armavir (231.8), and Vayots Dzor (253.5) regions. This distribution has remained almost unchanged since the year 2000. Both violent and property crimes are relatively higher in urban areas. Thefts, robberies, and frauds are more frequent in metropolitan areas, while assaults are common in rustic areas. According to the unpublished data provided by Armenian police, the homicide rate is higher in Tavush (17.4 per 100,000 population), Syunik (16 per 100,000 population), Yerevan (8.8 per 100,000 population), and Lori (8.1 per 100,000 population). Syunik, Shirak, and Lori have relatively high assault rates, 7.9, 8.8, and 7.3 per 100,000 population, respectively. Thefts are more frequent in Yerevan (118 per 100,000 popu-
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Armenia
lation), Lori (112.6 per 100,000 population), and Tavush (111 per 100,000 population). Law enforcement officials and experts are increasingly concerned about juvenile involvement in crime. In 2002, 4.9 percent of the total crimes reported to police were committed by juveniles while in 2007 the percentage reached 6.7 percent. For the given years, the amount of the assaults committed by juveniles increased from 3.6 percent to 6.7 percent, and for thefts the data were 5.3 percent and 16 percent, respectively.
Finding of Guilt The Constitution and Criminal Procedure Code of Armenia endow the accused with many rights, which include, but are not limited to, protection against unreasonable search and seizure, protection against double jeopardy, protection against self-incrimination, the exclusionary rule, the right to be informed of the charges, the right to be presumed innocent, the right to a public and fair trial, protection against cruel punishments, the right to due process, equal protection under law, and the right to have assistance of counsel. Starting from the moment of arrest, the accused have the right to have a private or public defender. The latter one is expected to represent the client at every stage of the case proceedings. According to the Criminal Procedure Code of Armenia, the participation of the defender is mandatory in the following cases: the accused undergoes a speedy trial, the accused expressed a wish to have a defender, the accused has difficulties in exercising the right to defense due to physical or mental disorders, the accused does not have sufficient command of the Armenian language, the accused is a juvenile or a person drafted for military service, there are discrepancies in the interests of the accused, meanwhile one of them (the accused) has a defense attorney. The persons charged with committal of a crime can remain in a status of arrestee for no more than 72 hours. At this stage, the suspects are informed of the charges, have their constitutional criminalprocedural rights explained to them, and are given the opportunity to choose their defender. When
|
17
72 hours of an arrest are over, the suspect either has to be freed or must be detained based on the court’s decision. Usually, pretrial detention may be executed for a committal of a crime, for which the person can be imprisoned for more than a year. The detainment carried during pretrial proceedings shall not last longer than two months. However, the time of pretrial detention may be extended up to one year due to the complexity of the case. In Armenia, bail is an alternative to the pretrial detention for those who are accused of committing a crime categorized as not grave or medium gravity. As follows, suspects charged with serious offenses, such as murder, rape, robbery, aggravated theft, aggravated assault, kidnapping, and drug trafficking will be denied bail. The court also may deny the release of the accused in those cases where the identity of the accused is not established or when the accused does not have a permanent place of residence, and where the suspect has attempted to hide from the authority that carries out the criminal proceeding. In Armenia, there is no separate system for juveniles. Though Criminal and Criminal Procedure Codes of Armenia provide several privileges for juveniles, offenses committed by juveniles and adults are handled within the same justice system. Depending on the type of crime committed, the investigation of the case may be conducted by the police, Ministry of Defense, Tax or Customs Service, National Security Service, or Special Investigations Service. In general, police investigators are responsible for the investigation of the majority of crimes including homicide, theft, robbery, drug offenses, and so forth. When the investigation is over, the case either will be dropped or it may be brought before a court. In Armenia, any person charged with a crime may be found guilty only by the verdict of the court. As a rule, when a plea bargain takes place, the case undergoes a speedy trial. In that case, the sentence does not exceed two-thirds of the maximum punishment provided for the charged offense by the Armenian Criminal Code. The Armenian judicial system consists of three court levels: Universal Jurisdiction Courts of First Instance, Court of Appeals, and Court of Cassation. All the judges in Armenia are appointed by
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
18
| Armenia
the president of Armenia with the advice of the Justice Council. To become a judge, one has to earn at least a bachelor’s degree in law, work as an attorney at least for two years prior to nomination, and graduate from judicial school. There is no special term period during which a person can serve as a judge. However, judges’ powers must be terminated upon reaching retirement age. There are 16 Universal Jurisdiction Courts of First Instance in Armenia with 147 judges in total. Each court has a chairman and judges, who hear any type of civil or criminal case. The second level is the Court of Appeals. There are two courts of appeal in Armenia: the Criminal Appeal Court and the Civil Appeal Court. The Court of Appeals has the authority to review cases resolved by the Court of First Instance. It consists of 16 judges, including the chairman. Each case is reviewed at the Criminal Appeal Court in a panel of three judges. The highest level of the courts is the Court of Cassation. Based on a complaint in cases stipulated by law, the Cassation Court reviews judicial acts of the Court of Appeals. The Cassation Court has two chambers: the Civil Chamber and the Criminal Chamber. The latter consists of six judges, who must participate in any session of the Cassation Court.
Punishment Armenia’s Criminal Code provides the following penalties: a fine; a prohibition to hold certain posts or practice certain professions; public works service; deprivation of special titles or military ranks, categories, degrees, or qualification class; confiscation of property; arrest; service in a disciplinary battalion; imprisonment; or life sentence. These penalties fall into three categories: basic, supplementary, and mixed punishments. Public works, fine, arrest, service in disciplinary battalion, imprisonment, and life sentence are used only as basic punishments. Deprivation of special titles or military ranks, categories, degrees, or qualification class and confiscation of property are applied only as supplementary punishments. Prohibition to hold certain posts or practice certain professions is a mixed punishment
and is imposed both as basic and supplementary punishment. Only one basic punishment can be assigned for one crime. One or more supplementary punishments can be added to the basic punishment. Public punishment, banishment, and corporal punishment are not practiced in Armenia. The most commonly used sentencing option is incarceration followed by fines and parole. According to the statistical data provided by the Criminal–Executive Department of the Armenian Ministry of Justice, at the beginning of 2008, there were 2,922 individuals serving their term in prisons. The typical punishment for murder, rape, robbery, theft, and serious drug offenses is imprisonment. Life imprisonment is practiced for aggravated murder, international terrorism, and genocide, crimes against humanity. The death penalty is not imposed in Armenia. All convicts serving their term of imprisonment are eligible for parole. To be eligible, the convict must meet two main requirements: have a good record of conduct and actually serve the minimum sentence required by law. The latter one is one-third of the convict’s imprisonment term for a not grave or medium gravity offense, half of the punishment for a grave offense, and two-thirds for a particularly grave offense. For some offenses such as aggravated murder, aggravated rape, or aggravated robbery, the inmate has to serve three-fourths of the imprisonment term. The actual term of imprisonment served by a person cannot be less than three months. For juvenile convicts, the minimum sentence required by the law is set to one-fourth, one-third, and half of the imprisonment term for not grave and medium gravity, grave, and particularly grave offenses accordingly. People who were sentenced to life imprisonment can be freed on parole after serving 20 years of incarceration.
Prisons According to the Criminal–Executive Department of the Armenian Ministry of Justice, at the beginning of 2008, there were 12 correctional institutions in Armenia. In 2008, one more was established, and at present the number of correctional institutions has reached 13.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Armenia
Based on the level of isolation, the following types of correctional institutions are distinguished: “open,” “semiopen,” “semiclosed,” “closed,” and medical penitentiary institution. Assignment of the convicts is based on the seriousness of the offense committed, and, later, the behavior of the inmate. The inmates needing the minimum state of security serve their sentence at penitentiary institutions of the open type, while those sentenced to life imprisonment or imprisonment exceeding 10 years are at closed-type jails. The majority of the penitentiary institutions, except Kosh, Sevan, and Erebuni correctional institutes, provide sections for keeping pretrial detainees. On January 1, 2008, the total number of prisoners was 3,539 (3,278 in prison and 261 convicts in medical correctional institutions). The majority of the prison inmate population, 53 percent, consists of convicts under the age of 30. Only 4 percent of the prisoners are women, and 1.4 percent are juveniles. The largest correctional facilities in Armenia are Nubarashen, Kosh, and Erebuni penitentiary institutions. Nubarashen serves as the biggest pretrial detention center where inmates awaiting trial are kept (as of January 1, 2008, 407 of 770 prisoners kept at Nubarashen jail were pretrial detainees), while Kosh and Erebuni prisons’ population consists only of adjudicated convicts. Usually, several levels of isolation (divided by units) are housed in the same facility. Nubarashen jail provides all levels of security, while Kosh Prison serves as a correctional institution of open, semiopen, and semiclosed type. Kosh jail has day rooms, library, and telephones. There are televisions in the day rooms, but there is no access to cable networks. The convicts can make phone calls, but not in unlimited amounts. Inmates are allowed to have visitors. Attorneys can have an unlimited amount of visitation hours with their clients. The others (family, relatives, friends, etc.) can have a limited number of short-term or long-term visitations. The latter one is provided only for the family or close relatives of the prisoner. The duration of short-term visitation is four hours, and the longterm visitation lasts three days. Short-term visits are allowed during the daytime (from 10:00 a.m.
|
19
until 5:00 p.m.) in special rooms occupied for that purpose. The convict can have short-term visitation once per month, and long-term visitation is allowed once per two months. The number of visitations for those serving a life sentence in prison is reduced to three and one, correspondingly. The visiting rules in correctional institutions provide for a maximum of three adult persons at a time for short-term and two adults for long-term visitations. Juveniles under age 18 do not count as visitors. However, the list of juvenile visitors is restricted to the brothers, sisters, children, or grandchildren of the prison inmates. Criminals serving their term in prison may be granted a privilege to have extra short-term visits, receive extra parcels, or make additional phone calls for good behavior. Good conduct is required to be eligible for parole or to be transferred to a correctional center with a lower level of isolation. Shortterm furloughs usually not exceeding seven days are another form of privilege granted to prisoners and detainees. Though the correctional institution may require inmates to work, scarcity of jobs makes employment actually impossible. To provide jobs for the prison inmates, the Armenian government founded the fund Assist the Prisoner. In Yerevan in 2006, the market hall Prison Art was opened, which gave the prisoners the opportunity to have their handicrafts sold and the money transferred to their personal accounts. Upon their consent, the prisoners also can be engaged in voluntary works aimed at the maintenance of correctional institution facilities or territories. This occupation cannot exceed two hours per day. Penitentiary establishments take measures to provide necessary conditions for the education of both juvenile and adult inmates. Secondary and vocational education is offered by the correctional institutions free of charge, while higher education can be provided by correspondence at prisoners’ own expense. Prisoners who serve their punishment in Armenia and who have been charged in another country with any crime can be delivered there. The main requirement is the existence of signed multilateral or bilateral treaties between Armenia and the requesting state. At present, such treaties exist between
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
20
| Azerbaijan
Armenia and Russia and many countries of Europe, the Newly Independent States (NIS). No extradition agreement was signed with the United States. However, the transfer of the criminal from Armenia to the United States or any country having no signed agreement with Armenia can be done based on mutual goodwill. An example of prison inmates being transferred to another country is the case of two citizens of Kazakhstan charged with drug smuggling. Drug smugglers planned to take more than 700 grams of heroin to Greece from Tashkent, but the flight was interrupted in Armenia when one of the smugglers went into a coma as the result of the dissolving of the container of heroin he had swallowed. The criminals were sentenced to 10 years of imprisonment. However, in 2008, they were transferred to Kazakhstan upon their request. Anna Margaryan Further Reading Gabuzyan, Ara. (2007). Problemi prestupnosti v Respublike Armenia v perekhodniy period (The Problems of Criminality in the Republic of Armenia in the Transitional Period). Yerevan. Gabuzyan, Ara, and Anna Margaryan. (2004). Tendenzen der Kriminalität in Armenien in der Übergangszeit. Strafrecht and Kriminaltät Entwicklungen in Mittel-und Osteuropa (Trends of crime in Armenia during the transition. Criminal justice and crime at developments in Central and Eastern Europe). Bochum. Margaryan, Anna, and Ara Gabuzyan. (2009). “Armenia.” In Juvenile Delinquency in Europe and Beyond: Results of the Second International Self-Report Delinquency Study, edited by Josine Junger-Tas, Ineke Haen Marshall, Dirk Enzmann, Martin Killias, Majone Steketee, and Beata Gruszczynska. New York: Springer. Official Web site of the Judiciary of Armenia: http://www.court.am.
Azerbaijan Legal System: Civil Murder: Medium Burglary: Low Corruption: High Human Trafficking: Medium Prison Rate: Medium Death Penalty: No Corporal Punishment: No
Background On the eve of the Soviet Union’s dissolution, the Republic of Azerbaijan re-established its independence with passage of the Constitutional Act on Restoration of State Independence, October 18, 1991. With this act, Azerbaijan instituted a presidential republic with a separation of federal powers into legislative, executive, and judicial branches, governed by a system of civil law. The new constitution of 1995 called for political and individual rights as well as the independence of the judiciary. Since its signing of a memorandum of understanding with the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) on the July 17, 2000, Azerbaijan has been obligated to respect the rule of law and observe human rights standards as established in the Copenhagen, Moscow, and Budapest Documents of 1990, 1991, and 1994, respectively. Following its successful bid to join the Council of Europe (CoE), Azerbaijan since January 2001 has been obliged to amend its legislation to conform to CoE standards. After joining the CoE, Azerbaijan ratified in 2002 the European Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. As a party to the convention, violations can be brought to the European Court on Human Rights when all domestic avenues have been exhausted.
Official Web site of National Statistical Service of the Republic of Armenia: http://www.armstat.am.
Legal System
Official Web site of the Public Prosecutor Office of the Republic of Armenia: http://www.genproc.am.
Domestically, district and municipal courts principally serve as trial courts for criminal, civil, and
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Azerbaijan
juvenile cases, while the Supreme Court, the head of the judiciary, largely performs appellate reviews. The Supreme Court consists of 12 members appointed by the Chamber of Deputies to serve fiveyear terms. The court is divided into four chambers with three justices in each. Two chambers are charged with reviewing civil cases, a third chamber handles criminal cases, and a fourth reviews administrative, social, and mining cases. In addition to performing appellate reviews, the High Court has original jurisdiction on questions concerning charges against top officials or state contract disputes. Responding to indications that the Supreme Court is acquiescent to the authority of the president, the Council of Europe offered financial assistance to facilitate further reform of Azerbaijan’s judicial system toward a more democratic example. Although Azerbaijan’s Constitution presumes innocence in criminal cases, calls for public trials, and upholds a defendant’s right to legal counsel, reports continue that judges are subject to political influence and sometimes may take bribes, according to the Fund for Peace, 2009. Among the array of crimes addressed by the Penal Code of Azerbaijan, thefts and frauds are the most clearly defined. In the first six months of 2007, for example, 8,676 crimes were officially registered. Of these, approximately 18 percent were premeditated murders while robberies and muggings accounted for 15 percent; 6 percent were reportedly burglaries; 24 percent consisted of cattle theft; and car theft actually dropped by 11 percent during this period, according to a BBC report. Public prosecutors generally handle prosecutions and supervise investigations by common law enforcement agencies. To practice criminal law, defense attorneys must first obtain membership to the Collegium of Advocates, or the Azerbaijan Bar Association, a quasigovernmental entity that limits its enrollment. Membership is currently obtained through an unclear process that combines a Soviet legacy with an ill-formed mechanism for admitting new members. Further, the Collegium remains under the influence and power of the prosecutor’s office. Thus, despite almost 20 years of independence and ongoing attempts to move
|
21
the legal system further away from the influence of the previous Soviet system, prosecutors maintain an imbalance of power that can influence the outcome of cases. Although the 2004 Law on Advocates, a revision of the previous 1999 Law on Advocates and Advocate Activity (itself intended as a revision of the 1980 Provision on the Advokatura of the Azerbaijan Soviet Republic), in principle designed to restructure the Collegium’s monopoly control over which licensed lawyers can serve as criminal defense attorneys, in practice the Collegium has not been required to establish a clear and transparent mechanism for admitting new members. Consequently, the original 350 members admitted under the 1980 Provisions on the Advokatura, and another 150 subsequently admitted, preserve their monopoly control over criminal defense. Given the low number of criminal defense attorneys available to the public, approximately 500 for a population close to 8.5 million, it appears that Azerbaijan does not have sufficient criminal defense resources to serve its citizens. At the same time, the Collegium’s dependence on the prosecutor’s office leaves advocates susceptible to the influence of police, investigators, the prosecutor’s office, and political authorities. While legislatively Azerbaijan’s judiciary is independent of political control, in practice judges remain largely subject to the executive branch, leading to presumptions of likely corruption and influence peddling. Judges, acting on the instruction of executive branch officials, regularly sentence detainees to jail within hours of their arrest without providing access to a lawyer.
Crime Even as Azerbaijan’s oil-based economic development continues to expand, incidences of officially reported crimes have been increasing over previous years. According to official Ministry of Internal Affairs statistics for 2008, the total number of reported crimes, 21,692, was an increase of 16 percent over 2007 levels. More than 7,500 of these reported crimes involved personal injury, with close to 6,500 concerning theft and robbery and approximately
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
22
| Azerbaijan
6,000 committed against public security. While official statistics suggest that 816 crimes were committed against state authority, what constitutes such a crime is contested by a range of national and international commentators. Official statistics published in 2008 by Azerbaijan’s State Statistical Committee suggest that in 2007, there were 18,667 crimes with 17,734 convictions. Human trafficking violations reached 394 reported incidents in 2008, an increase of 111 since 2007. Reported drug possession, distribution, and selling charges reached 3,767, compared to 3,224 in 2007. The Border Control intercepted 350.5 pounds (159 kg) of illegal drugs while the Ministry of Internal Affairs confiscated 1,435 pounds (651 kg) within the country. On the other hand, 2008 also marked an apparent decline from 2007 in certain officially reported crimes, ranging from bribery (a reported decrease of 50%) and car theft (down 33%), to sexual assault (down 26%) and willful homicide (down 4.5%), as reported by the Ministry of Internal Affairs. While violence against women remains problematic throughout the country, and legislation provides for criminal prosecution of domestic violence and punishment for acts of rape (including spousal rape), comprehensive statistics concerning the scope of the problem are sketchy. Officially, there were 34 reported instances of rape and attempted rape in 2007, compared to a 12-year high reportedly set in 1995 of 70, according to an Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) 2009 report.
Finding of Guilt Four years after the Republic of Azerbaijan declared its independence, the Police Law was passed in 1995, formally instituting a centralized state police system. The country’s initial internal Special Forces unit, the Detachment of Police of Special Purposes (OPOR), played a significant role in early 1990s political and public life. However, after this military unit mutinied in the nation’s capital in 1993, its command was disbanded and subsequently Azerbaijan’s internal security forces were placed under the control of
the Ministry of Internal Affairs rather than the Department of Defense. Empowered to contain protests, processions, and unauthorized activities, these forces were called upon by the central government to keep a check on protests surrounding the results of the 2003 presidential elections. Police, the prosecutor’s office, and magistrates each can instigate identity checks and arrests; the prosecutor’s office and police can further order questioning of citizens. Police have the power to detain individuals for 48 hours but with a judge’s order can hold individuals in custody longer; police do not require a court order to conduct searches of persons and premises. With a court order, police are empowered to tap private telephone lines as well as bug public locations. Azerbaijan adheres to the presumption of innocence, a tenet ensured in principle by article 63 of the Constitution, the Criminal Code of Procedure, and the Code of Administrative Offences. In practice, according to a study commissioned by the Baku Office of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) in 2006, the Prosecutor General, the Minister of Internal Affairs, representatives of the Presidential Apparatus, and the heads of other administrative bodies frequently refer to suspects in high-profile cases as “criminals” without a final court decision and will discuss evidence publicly. After a decade or so of the media’s growth and diversification, since assuming the presidency following his father in 2003, the government of President Aliyev has been increasing its formal and informal restrictions on freedom of expression. Consequently, the largely government-controlled media has been complicit in its broadcast of unproven allegations and accusatory speeches with apparently little regard for fact checking, further complicating the constitutionally protected right to the presumption of innocence. The Constitution ensures that every citizen who has been detained, accused, or arrested for a crime has the right to legal representation at each stage of his or her legal proceeding. The Constitution’s article 61 guarantees the right of every citizen to have access to a lawyer from the moment of detention,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Azerbaijan
|
23
Police officers detain an opposition activist while dispersing an unsanctioned rally against President Ilham Aliev in downtown Baku, Azerbaijan, December 18, 2005. (AP Photo/Aida Sultanova)
accusation, or arrest for a crime, while article 67 directly provides that each accused, arrested, or detained individual will be advised of his or her rights immediately. The Law on Advocates and the Criminal Procedure Code each provide that an advocate and client will be given adequate time to meet in private. According to a study by ABA-CEELI (2005), however, for the most part neither jails, courthouses, nor police stations have or provide for private and separate meeting rooms. Further, consultations between client and advocate are commonly conducted either in the presence of law enforcement personnel or members of the court. While the Constitution provides the right of access to an advocate from the moment of arrest or detainment, individuals may be held for several days without access to a defense attorney, or until the accused has signed a confession.
Although the Constitution’s articles 57, 60, and 65 guarantee the general right of appeal, the appeal’s process in practice can be somewhat unclear, and the actual timeframe varies on a case-by-case basis.
Prison Azerbaijan’s prison system, administered by the Chief Department for the Execution of Court Decisions and overseen by the Ministry of Justice, consists of more than 50 penal institutions ranging from those for juveniles to maximum-security units. Like many other penal systems in Eurasia, Azerbaijan employs congregate rather than single-occupancy cells. Azerbaijan’s penal institutions are divided according to population. For example, certain facilities house juveniles while others are dedicated to
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
24
|
Bangladesh
former police officers and members of the civil service; one is reserved for women, and another for tuberculosis patients. The total prison population as of 2007 was 18,259 consisting of approximately 10 percent women, 4 percent repeat offenders, and almost 70 percent from the ranks of the unemployed. Of those convicted of a crime and serving time in 2007, sentences of two to five years were most common. There were 18 individuals sentenced to life imprisonment. The Parliament on June 24, 2008, voted to approve penitentiary legislation that called for the improvement of penal detention standards. These improvements included, among others, more family visits, allowance of food parcels brought in from the outside, and a reduction in the number of inmates per cell for those serving life imprisonment. Capital punishment was abolished in Azerbaijan in 1998, following a moratorium on executions applied in 1993. Jeremy Tasch
Further Reading ABA-CEELI. (2005). The Legal Profession Reform Index for Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan: American Bar Association and Central European and Eurasian Law Initiative. Abdullahzade, Cavid. (2007). “The Status of International Treaties in the Legal System of Azerbaijan.” Review of Central and East European Law 32: 233–256. “Human Rights Center of Azerbaijan Individual UPR submission—Azerbaijan, September 2008.” (2008): http://209.85.229.132/search?q= cache:aJYe60n5bCYJ:humanrightshouse.org/ noop/file.php%3Fid%3D10010+Human+Rights +Center+of+Azerbaijan+Individual+UPR+sub mission+-+Azerbaijan,+September+2008&cd= 1&hl=az&ct=clnk&gl=az&client=firefox-a. “Life Imprisonment and Conditions of Serving the Sentence in the South Caucasus Countries.” (2009). A Project of the Global Action to Abolish the Death Penalty, DDH/2006/119763: http://www.penalreform.
org/edith/South%20Caucasus%20Life%20 Term%20feb%2009.pdf. Ministry of Internal Affairs. (2009): http://www. mia.gov.az/?/en/content/29162/.
Bangladesh Legal System: Common/Islamic Murder: Medium Corruption: High Human Trafficking: Low Prison Rate: High Death Penalty: Yes Corporal Punishment: Yes
Background Bangladesh became an independent nation in 1971. It is located in South Asia and is nearly surrounded by Indian territory except for a small strip in the southeast, where it borders Myanmar. Formerly, Bangladesh was a part of British India and then of Pakistan from 1947 through 1971. The total land area is 147,570 square kilometers (56,977 square miles) and its population is 153,546,896 as of July 2008, which makes it the seventh most populous country in the world. The main religion in Bangladesh is Islam, and Bangla is the primary language. Muslims account for 88 percent of the total population, Hindus 10.5 percent, less than 1 percent Buddhist or Christian. Bangladesh has experienced an unstable political climate since its independence. This political instability has often resulted in emergency declarations of martial law, undermining the legal regime of personal liberty. The impact of such political regimes on the criminal justice system has been clearly demonstrated in the administration of courts and corrections (justice) in Bangladesh. For example, the increased use of preventive detention under the present emergency rule has caused unprecedented growth in prison population. Also, it produced an increasing number of convictions in special courts.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
The imposition of emergency on January 11, 2007, has significantly altered the political history of Bangladesh. Over the years enactment of special laws such as Special Powers Act, Anti-Terrorism Act, Public Safety Act, Speedy Trial Act, and more recently, Emergency Powers Ordinance 2007 and Anti-Terrorism Ordinance 2008 have greatly affected the administration of law and order as well as the protection of basic human rights in Bangladesh. At the same time, these legislative initiatives by the government have increased the punitiveness of the criminal justice system. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) 2002 report states that Bangladesh is facing a significant level of human insecurity with regard to access to justice, enforcement of laws, misuse of authority and abuse of power by some people. A study by Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee (BRAC) found that “the administration of justice is underfunded, painfully slow and inefficient which results in excessive delays.” At the same time, the justice system is not accessible to a great majority of the population due to costs and time associated with litigation, lack of legal awareness, and fear of interaction with the police. After assuming state power on January 11, 2007, the caretaker government worked to ensure a good governance and corruption-free society. To implement this political agenda the government had adopted more than 60 ordinances and policies on legal and institutional reforms during the tenure of the government. The major ordinances and policies that were adopted by the caretaker government include separation of the judiciary from the executive and formation of the Supreme Judicial Commission to ensure the appointment of neutral and competent judges, National Human Rights Commission, Anti-Terrorism Ordinance, and Bangladesh Attorney Service. Since corruption became a great concern for the government, it reconstituted the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) to fight corruption effectively. More than 70,000 cases were filed with the ACC during the last 18 months. As a part of crackdown on rampant corruption, the military-backed interim
|
25
government had detained immediate past prime minister Khaleda Zia and her two sons and another former prime minister, Sheikh Hasina. Both the prime ministers had to face charges of corruption and extortion. The ACC filed a large number of corruption cases against the top politicians. Accordingly, more than 160 political leaders, including former ministers and parliament members, had been detained, and many of them received jail sentences ranging from 3 to 13 years. Although the caretaker government made significant advances in its drive to bring corrupt politicians to justice, toward the end of its rule almost all the detained political leaders, including the two former prime ministers, had been released from the jail just to ensure the participation of the two major political parties in the national election held on December 29, 2008. It is important to mention that the caretaker government made reform in many constitutional bodies. For example, reform in the election system ensures that corrupt and convicted politicians could not take part in the election. And the government became more lenient toward corruptive and convicted politicians who were allowed to participate in the election. It appears that the caretaker government could not sustain the political pressure from the two major political parties, though many believed that the prosecution of corrupt politicians and other reform activities would bring a new political era. However, after the national election in which the Awami League came to state power with overwhelming victory, the newly elected government has already discarded many reform activities initiated by the caretaker government. Most importantly, some of the ordinances and bills were not even endorsed by the new Parliament. As a result, the political culture of Bangladesh remained largely unchanged due to unwillingness of the political parties.
Legal System Bangladesh inherited a colonial legal system from the British and Pakistani rule, thus the legal system is founded on English common law. Nevertheless,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
26
|
Bangladesh
most laws in Bangladesh are statutory laws passed by the legislature and interpreted by the higher courts. The procedural laws offer an adversarial system of proceedings in which prosecution has to prove the guilt of the accused and the accused is presumed innocent until found guilty after trial. On the other hand, in a civil case the burden is divided between the litigating parties. All laws of the country are subordinate laws made by the elected Parliament in compliance with the principles of the Constitution. The judicial system remained the same until the enactment of the Constitution of Bangladesh on December 16, 1972. The two levels in the court system include the subordinate courts and the Supreme Court. The subordinate courts are divided into two broad classes: civil courts and criminal courts. The civil courts are created under the Civil Courts Act of 1887. There are five tiers of civil courts, which have jurisdiction to try all suits of a civil nature. There are two classes of criminal courts, Courts of Session and Courts of Magistrate. There are four tiers of judicial magistrates: chief metropolitan magistrate in metropolitan area and chief judicial magistrate to other areas, magistrate of the first class, second class, and third class. The Supreme Court is divided into two sections: the High Court and the Appellate Court. The High Court hears original cases and assesses cases from the lower courts. The Appellate Court has jurisdiction to hear appeals of judgments, decrees, orders, or sentences of the High Court or any other body. Verdicts of the Appellate Court are binding on all other courts. The High Court may proclaim any law incompatible with the fundamental rights as null and void. The Supreme Court is not only autonomous, but also acts as the keeper of the Constitution. In addition to interpreting laws made by Parliament, the Supreme Court can also enforce fundamental rights of the citizens. In addition there are administrative tribunals to decide service disputes of public servants and some special courts and tribunals such as family court, Artha Rin Adalat (Money Loan Court) to decide money claims of the banks and other financial institutions, Nari-o-Shishu Nirjatan Daman Adalats
to decide cases of crimes committed against children and women. Parliament can enact laws, but that must be consistent with the provisions of the Constitution. It appears that almost all the substantive laws creating rights and obligations are those endorsed during the British period, and are still in action with alterations over time. For example, the existing Criminal Codes and Procedures in Bangladesh result from the period of British rule, as modified by Pakistan and Bangladesh. Likewise, the fundamental documents such as the Bangladesh Penal Code, first promulgated in 1860 as the Indian Penal Code; the Police Act of 1861; Bengal Jail Code of 1864; the Evidence Act of 1872; the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1898; the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1908; the Official Secrets Act of 1911; the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937, relating to Muslim family affairs, are still in operation in Bangladesh.
Politicization of Police The state exercises strong control over police agencies. As a consequence many policy decisions regarding police are instigated for political purposes. Evidence indicates that politicians even manipulate preparation of charge sheets and final reports; as a result the “fall out” rate of arrest is high. Most importantly, the investigations of sensational cases have been redirected according to the will of the ruling party. It may be noted that after assuming state power each successive government brought major changes in different tiers of the police administration, including the appointment of new police chiefs. For example, during the tenure of Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) government (October 2001–October 2006) a total of 65 senior (of them 6 additional inspector generals, 19 deputy inspector generals, and 4 additional deputy inspector generals) and 950 lower-ranking police officers were forced to retire, while 796 members of the police force were dismissed during the same period on political grounds. Similarly the new Awami League government also brought major changes in the police administration.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
In sum, the extent of politicization has been reflected in appointment, promotion, and academy training of the police officers. To improve the quality of police services in 2007, the caretaker government drafted a new police ordinance aiming at freeing police from extraneous influences and making them more accountable to the people. The ordinance entitled Bangladesh Police Ordinance, 2007 will replace the existing 148year-old Police Act. The goal of the new ordinance includes making police more service-oriented and people friendly and protecting human rights. Under the new ordinance any interference in police work will be treated as a criminal offense. Unfortunately, the caretaker government did not pass the draft ordinance and the new political government has yet to pass the ordinance as well.
Separation of Judiciary Although the Constitution grants an independent judiciary, the lower courts have remained a part of the executive branch since independence. In 1999, the Supreme Court gave a 12-points directive for separating the judiciary from the executive organ of the state. The directive came following a case— popularly known as the Masder Hossain case filed in 1995. Despite the repeated pledge, the successive political governments did not take any steps for separating the judiciary. Finally, on November 1, 2007, the interim government implemented the court’s directive for the separation of judiciary. Accordingly, all magistrates at subordinate courts started exercising their judicial functions under the authority of the Supreme Court that contributed to significant changes in the structure of criminal courts in Bangladesh. Moreover, the existing Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 has been revised. Truly, this is the major achievement of the past caretaker government.
Crime Control and Human Rights There have been allegations that two specific laws facilitate endemic human rights violations in Bangladesh: (1) the Special Powers Act, 1974 (SPA)
|
27
and (2) the Emergency Powers Rules of 2007. The SPA allows arbitrary detention for long periods of time without charge, and Section 54 of the Code of Criminal Procedure facilitates torture in police or army custody. The limited safeguards provided in the act allow the government to abuse it to control freedom of expression and to suppress political opposition. Political parties have repeatedly promised to repeal the law when in opposition, but the law has been maintained so far. Each year, thousands of people are capriciously in custody under SPA, which rebuffs them from resorting to judicial remedies. The legal experts argue that a number of provisions in the Emergency Powers Ordinance and Emergency Powers Rules (EPR) 2007, providing death penalty and life-term imprisonment for violating these provisions and also any rules with retrospective effect, are against the fundamental structure of the country’s Constitution. For example, Rule 10(2) states that “all crimes committed under this law shall be cognizable, non-compoundable and non-bailable.” Also, Section 6(1) of the Emergency Powers Ordinance 2007 provides blanket impunity for all actions to state actors. In sum, the Emergency Powers Rules (EPR), enforced by the government in January 2007, suspended many basic rights, including freedom of press, freedom of association, and the right to bail. There were widespread allegations that in the prosecution of anticorruption cases in the newly established Special Judges’ Courts instead of regular courts, the due process rights of the accused were not maintained properly. Meanwhile, the present government has withdrawn a large number of corruption cases against the leaders of the ruling political party, arguing that all the cases were politically motivated.
Police The police in Bangladesh are a centralized national force. The Ministry of Home Affairs controls its functions while the operational responsibilities are vested in Police Headquarters. The inspector general is the chief executive of the police departments.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
28
|
Bangladesh
Bangladesh police follow the British police system of the colonial era with some minor modifications. The Police Act of 1861 oversees the police administration, whereas operational parts are directed by the Police Regulation of Bengal (PRB), 1943. In addition, the Home Ministry has the authority to issue administrative regulations on personnel and police operations. The main branches in the police department include Traffic, Special, and Detective branches. In addition to that, there is the Central Investigation Department (CID), which deals with the high profile and serious cases, and Rapid Action Battalion (RAB). In recent years, Highway Police and Trafficking of Human Beings (THB) units have been introduced. Policing activities are carried out from a central office known as police station (Thana) in both urban and rural areas. There are presently 599 police stations in Bangladesh. The officer in charge (OC) of a police station is responsible for maintaining law and order and prevention and detection of crimes in his jurisdiction. The metropolitan police, a separate wing within the police department, are responsible for policing the major cities of the country. Police officers are classified as gazetted and nongazetted, roughly equivalent to commissioned and noncommissioned officers in the military services. The top four managerial positions are inspector general of police (IGP), additional inspector general, deputy inspector general (DIG), and superintendent of police (SP). The nongazetted category consists of inspector, sub-inspector (SI), and assistant sub-inspector (ASI). The superintendent (SP) of a district and officer in charge (OC) of a Thana are the two most powerful officers in the police administration. The lower echelons of the police are known as constables and constitute more than 70 percent of the police force. According to Police Headquarters, as of June 2008, the total manpower of Bangladesh police was 123,000.
Rapid Action Battalion (RAB): Policing by Military In the face of the rising crime problem, especially organized crime, the government has created a
specialized unit of police called the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) in June 2004, based on the Armed Police Battalions (Amendment) Act, 2003. It is a composite force drawing its personnel from the police, paramilitary forces, and the various branches of the armed forces. Presently, 12 battalions of RAB are working throughout the country. In comparison to the police, RAB staff are better trained, well paid, and well prepared. The main functions of RAB include crime fighting, elimination of illegal arms, arrest of wanted criminals, controlling organized crime (e.g., women and child trafficking), Islamic militancy, and money laundering. Since its inception, RAB has played a very effective role in improving the law and order situation in the country. Its success stories include apprehension of top leaders of Islamic militants like Jamatul Mujahidin of Bangladesh (JMB), Horkatul Jehad, and some most wanted gang leaders. Despite wider public acceptance, its involvement in “extra-judicial killings,” popularly known as “crossfire,” has generated wide controversy among politicians and members of civil society groups at home and abroad. The U.S.–based Human Rights Watch reports that over the past four years, RAB members have killed more than 540 people as of June 2008.
Crime Classification of Crimes The major categories of crimes and their punishments are listed in the Penal Code and Schedule II of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, the country’s most significant and comprehensive penal decree. Among the listed classifications of more serious crimes are activities called offenses against the state, offenses affecting life, such as murder. Among other categories of felonies are offenses against the public tranquility (meaning unlawful assembly), rioting, and public disturbances; offenses relating to religion; and offenses against property, such as theft, robbery, and dacoity (robbery by a group of five or more persons). The age of criminal responsibility in Bangladesh is 16 years.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
Crime Statistics Bangladesh experienced a sharp increase in crimes in the early 2000s. A study by Kashem for the Bangladesh Center for Criminological Research found that over the years, the patterns of murders have changed significantly in terms of premeditation and brutality. And the use of firearms in committing crimes, especially murder, has increased in the past decade. The data provided by the Police Headquarters indicate that between 2000 and 2007, the number of reported crimes has increased by 44 percent in Bangladesh. While, during the same period, violent crime such as murder has increased by 13.6 percent. According to crimes recorded by police in 2007, there were 157,200 reported crimes and an overall crime rate of 91.5 per 100,000 population. The most typical crimes recorded by police in rural areas are theft, robbery, cruelty to women for dowry, while in urban areas the most typical crimes are burglary, mugging on the city streets, drug-related crime, and extortion at the city markets and business establishments. Most recent crime statistics (2007) are as follows: Dacoity (gang robbery) Robbery Murder Seedy Trail Act Rioting Cruelty to women Child abuse Police assault Burglary Theft Arms Act Explosive Act Narcotics Smuggling Kidnapping Others
1,047 1,298 3,863 1,980 263 14,250 967 278 4,439 12,015 1,746 232 15,622 5,202 774 93,224
Controlling Muslim Militancy In recent years the rise of religious militancy is a big challenge for the law-enforcing agencies of Bangladesh. It appears that since 1999, attacks by Islamist
|
29
militants have been increasing. They have targeted opposition politicians, scholars, journalists, members of the judiciary, religious minorities, and so forth. Law-enforcement agencies have identified 29 Islamic organizations for suspected involvement in militancy. Of them only two major militant groups, namely, Jama’atul Mujahideen (JMB) and Harkatul Jihad-al-Islami (Huji), are active. Interviews of senior police officers suggest that controlling religious militancy is a difficult task, as the issue is linked to policy choice of the government. Most importantly, the law-enforcement agencies cannot get tough on them because of the religious issue. One leaflet of these organizations entitled “Islamer Prokrito Salah” (“Real Salah +9of Islam”) says that “jihad or military program or armed struggle is a must to establish the rule of Islam.” Using the verses of the holy Koran, it is reported that “if anyone leaves jihad or armed struggle, they shall not be accepted to Allah as a momen (devout/real Muslim).” Citing this example, one senior official of a law-enforcement agency observes: “As long as the government allows such campaigns or activities and does not prohibit such propaganda, we cannot consider it as an offence.” That is, existing laws are inadequate to fight against militancy. The government has so far banned four Islamist militant organizations. But police could not trace the many leaders of these militant groups because their activities are largely confined to mosques and madrassas (religion-based educational institutions).
Women and Child Trafficking Trafficking in human beings (THB) has been increasing in Bangladesh. The major factors behind the trafficking have been identified as poverty, illiteracy, landlessness, overpopulation, and low levels of income. There are no reliable statistics; however, according to United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) since 2004, between 10,000 and 29,000 children are used for the purpose of prostitution in Bangladesh. In fact, the actual number of THB cases is higher than the recorded ones by the police. According to a U.S. State Department report (2005), Bangladesh serves as both the source and
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
30
|
Bangladesh
transit country for men, women, and children. They are used “for the purpose of sexual exploitation, involuntary domestic servitude, child camel jockeying, and debt bondage.” The U.S. State Department Trafficking in Persons Report 2008 revealed that Bangladeshi women and children were engaged in forced labor and prostitution in India and Pakistan. While boys have been used as camel jockeys in the Middle Eastern countries such as United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia, most of them were trafficked to these countries through fraudulent job offers by some Bangladeshi recruitment agencies. In a country like Bangladesh, clearly, the social consequences of trafficking are extremely serious, especially for the women and girls who are sold for the purpose of sexual exploitation. According to police officials, the investigation of trafficking cases is complex and time-consuming. Additionally, the police and judicial departments do not have sufficient capacities in prosecuting trafficking cases, which is a major obstacle in controlling trafficking. Recently, within the police department, a specialized THB unit has been set up to strengthen the fight against different types of trafficking.
Cybercrime Although cybercrime is still not alarming in Bangladesh, the growing number of Internet users poses a great threat to the country. So, Bangladesh police are now improving their capacity to combat cybercrime. They have identified the following sites: (1) illegal prostitution promotion sites; (2) use of the Internet for transmitting false and malicious information; and (3) use of the Internet for women and child trafficking. Interviews with police officers suggest that due to a lack of resources, trained investigators, and equipment, presently it would be very difficult for the police to control cybercrime in Bangladesh. Furthermore, in the absence of digital forensic laboratories for investigation and detection of cybercrime, the investigative capability of the police is limited. In identifying the major obstacles to controlling cybercrime, police executives argue that cybercrime is not a cognizable offense. On the other hand, the lack of legislation to extradite the offender is one of the major obstacles in dealing with
this problem. The establishment of a Cyber Appellate Tribunal is essential. At the same time, the level of Information Communication Technology (ICT) knowledge of judges must be increased for successful prosecution of cybercrimes.
Finding of Guilt Jury trial does not exist in Bangladesh. In the subordinate courts a single judge hears all the cases while in the Supreme Court, a judicial panel comprising two to three judges conducts the majority of the trials. Trials conducted under the SPA and the Women and Children Repression Prevention Act are analogous to normal trials, but these are tried without the prolonged deferments as observed in other cases. Under the provisions of the Speedy Trial Act (STA) and the Women and Children Repression Prevention Act, special tribunals hear cases and issue judgments. Cases under these laws have to be investigated and tried within specific time restrictions. For example, the Women and Children Repression Act, 2000 (Nari O Shishu Nirjatan Daman Ain, 2000) specifies a speedy investigation (generally within 60 days; with permission of the Tribunal within 90 days to 120 days—Section 18) and trial (within 180 days—Section 20).
Rights of Accused and Legal Aid The rights of the accused include the right to be represented by counsel, to review accusatory material, to call witnesses, and to appeal verdicts. Statefunded defense attorneys are seldom afforded, and there are few legal aid programs to offer financial assistance to poor plaintiffs. There is no mandated provision of counsel for accused indigents, but the government does appoint lawyers to represent individuals tried in absentia. In rural areas, individuals frequently do not have legal representation. In urban areas, legal counsel usually is offered if individuals can find the funds. Nevertheless, there are accusations that sometimes detainees and suspects in police custody were denied right of legal counsel. Legal aid in many countries, for example, the United States, United Kingdom, and India, has
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
|
31
Prisoners look out from a prison van at the court premises in Dhaka, Bangladesh, August 4, 2009. Bangladesh launched a campaign to formally establish village courts in 500 rural administrative councils to settle small-scale disputes outside formal courts. (AP Photo/Pavel Rahman)
developed largely through private initiatives. The voluntary organizations such as legal aid societies, social service organizations, law school clinics, and bar associations have been playing an important role for the poor. In Bangladesh as well, some leading nongovernment organizations (NGOs) have come forward to provide legal aid, sometimes with the active assistance of different donor agencies. Among the most prominent organizations are Bangladesh Legal Aid and Service Trust (BLAST), Ain O Salish Kendro (ASK), Bangladesh National Women Lawyers’ Association (BNWLA), and Madaripur Legal Aid Association. Most of these NGOs render legal aid schemes to cover a particular area of the country, but some have been offering legal assistance all over the country. For example, BLAST has been providing legal assistance to the poor through legal aid clinics in the country. These organizations offer
training, mediation, legal awareness, and counseling schemes to help indigent people solve their legal problems. Besides that, since 1996, BLAST has been conducting a number of public interest litigations aimed at improving the legal empowerment of poor and marginal people. Under the Legal Aid Act of 2000, the government formed a National Legal Aid Organization to provide legal aid to poor litigants. Between 2001 and 2007, legal aid has been provided in 56,211 cases (civil and criminal) in 55 districts. Also, legal aid has been provided in 1,020 jail appeal cases.
Problems of the Court System A major problem of the court system is the devastating accumulation of cases, and prolonged trial process. Consequently, many accused persons are held
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
32
|
Bangladesh
in prison for many years. It is alleged that corruption occurs in the judicial process, prohibiting many persons from attaining a fair trial. A survey by the World Bank in 2005 found that the performance of judiciary was the worst among the participating countries in the survey. The average civil case in the district court in Bangladesh takes nearly five years to resolve, excluding the time taken for the appeals process. In some cases, especially land-related litigation, it is more than 15 to 20 years from filing in the trial court to decision by the appeal court. The data provided by the Supreme Court revealed that as of January 1, 2008, more than 1.6 million cases are pending in Bangladesh. Of them, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has 8,834, the High Court has 262,345, and the judicial magistracy has 602,173 cases. However, the disposal rate of cases has significantly increased since the separation of judiciary. Between November 2007 and April 2008, a total of 307,322 cases were disposed of. It appears that the rate of disposal of criminal cases in the courts of magistrates has increased by 51 percent in December 2007, as compared to the cases disposed of by the judicial magistrates in November 2007. Interviews suggest that the lengthy trial process and the shortage of judges in the court systems cause enormous delay in disposing of cases. To bring transparency to the judiciary, modern technology has been introduced in the management of court and cases in recent years.
Prosecution Bangladesh does not have an enduring prosecution service. The attorney general is the major law officer of the government. He or she is aided by the additional attorney general, deputy attorney generals, and assistant attorney generals. They stand for the state in the Supreme Court and conduct cases at courts on behalf of the state. Currently, there are 77 attorneys, including the attorney general for dealing with cases for the state. Additionally, at the subordinate courts, the prosecution division consists of public prosecutor (PP), government pleader (GP), and special public
prosecutor (SPP). Law officers are attended by assistants, whose numbers differ based on the number of courts in their jurisdiction, and the size and population of the district. They correspond to the state in the subordinate civil and criminal courts in the district and perform cases in these courts on behalf of the state. Law officers are appointed on the basis of their political affiliations. The recruitment process depends on the political selection of the ruling political party. Consequently, whenever a new party holds the power, all prosecutors are removed from their posts, and a new group substituted. Interviews with the court officials suggest that one of the major problems of this political appointment is that in many cases younger and lessexperienced lawyers are being appointed using their personal and political connections. It is noteworthy that a large number of these prosecutors often have insufficient knowledge of law and experience in legal practice. On the other hand, senior lawyers are unwilling to serve as prosecutors because of the lack of facilities and low payment. To improve the state of prosecutorial service, the past caretaker government has created the Government Attorney Department for dealing with cases in courts and performing other duties on behalf of the state. Under the new ordinance, the Attorney Department would directly recruit the law officers (prosecutors) through competitive examination with transparency, neutrality, and responsibility. But the new government did not endorse the ordinance in Parliament. As a result, the process of political recruitment remained unchanged. The use of police officers as prosecutors is another distinctive feature of government prosecution service. Under Sections 492(2) and 495 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the government allocates police to conduct the prosecution in the magistrates’ courts, which deal with approximately 70 percent of all cases in the country. Typically, a police officer at the rank of sub-inspector handles the prosecution of cases before the court, even if these officers do not have law degrees or sufficient training in prosecution. Interviews with police officers, however, suggest that since police investigate the cases, they
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
can plead the case better than the regular prosecutors to prove charges against the accused.
Investigation The most common preliminary step in the quest of justice is to file a complaint either with a police station or magistrates’ court in the jurisdiction where the offense allegedly happened. Complaints filed with police are classified as GR cases: those on the Government Register. Nevertheless, in many cases filing complaints with police stations is hard for the poor and politically weak, particularly if the complaints relate to wealthy and politically powerful persons. In such cases, the other selection is to file a complaint straight to a magistrates’ court. Such cases are categorized as CR cases: those on the Complaint Register. In either category of cases, police investigate, collect evidence, and take essential steps. It has been argued that successful prosecution of criminal cases requires a thorough and professional police investigation. A study by Kashem and Saadi reported at the Asian Association of Police Studies in 2007 found a “high fall out” rate. Between 2002 and 2006, the average conviction rate for the policesubmitted charge sheets was about 34 percent. The study also reported that political influence in police investigative work and improper use of the public prosecutors for personal benefit or some other reasons are largely responsible for this low conviction rate. The police chief (IGP) recently pointed out that police submit charge sheets in about 50 to 60 percent of the cases, while the rest end up in final reports (closing the inquiry without trial). The prosecutions of criminal cases in Bangladesh are heavily dependent on oral evidence and confession instead of physical evidences. Research on police investigations suggests that the amendments of various legal provisions in the Evidence Act of 1872 are essential to rectify the existing investigative practices of police. Specifically, changes in the rules regarding confessional and selfincriminating statements by the suspects before the police or magistrates are essential for efficient investigations of criminal cases. The lack of specially
|
33
trained evidence technicians for crime scene processing also affects the quality of police investigation in Bangladesh.
Alternatives to Trial ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION (ADR) Plea bargaining does not exist in the court system of Bangladesh. Thus, in the face of the judicial system’s million-case backlog, the government has been experimenting with the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). ADR is a process to settle disputes through a consensual method chosen voluntarily by the parties. Three main types of ADR consist of negotiation, mediation (including conciliation), and arbitration. The Ministry of Law in 2001 began a pilot program offering ADR in various civil cases through mediation or arbitration. Since then, ADR is becoming a popular mode of dispute resolution by the litigants of civil cases. The concept of alternative dispute resolution in the form of mediation in family disputes was first introduced in the Family Court Ordinance of 1985. Accordingly, exclusive family courts were established in June 2000. Also, the judicial mediation program in the districtlevel family courts has been implemented in some selected jurisdictions, for example, in Dhaka and Chittagong. It is known that in view of the time and costs associated with traditional lawsuits, many favor ADR. Most importantly, it provides an opportunity for community involvement or participation in the dispute resolution process. Based on government reports, extensive use of mediation in civil cases has accelerated the administration of justice. The report, however, also pointed out that the majority of the general public and many lawyers at subordinate courts are not aware of this alternative method of dispute resolution.
VILLAGE SALISH Salish is an informal justice institution through which the rural poor attempt to resolve their conflicts in Bangladesh. Widely practiced at the village level, salish involves the resolution of a conflict by a method other than traditional litigation. Built on
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
34
|
Bangladesh
traditional models of popular justice, the salish is conducted by religious leaders, or other community figures of the village. The outcome of village-based salish mediation includes shaming and fines. However, it appears that the existing process of shaming through salish in many cases is disintegrative rather than reintegrative.
Truth Commission: A New Version of Guilty Plea in Bangladesh In the wake of the massive load of corruption cases and prolonged legal processes and convictions by courts, in May 2008, the caretaker government established the Truth and Accountability Commission (TAC) as an alternative for dealing with high-profile corruption suspects. TAC provided an opportunity for a graft suspect to admit his or her culpability and to be instantly penalized monetarily instead of going through prolonged legal processes. In other words, any person who earned wealth through corruption could avoid jail (get clemency) by confessing crimes, disclosing his or her wealth statement, and depositing ill-gotten wealth to the commission voluntarily. Many government officials, politicians, and business persons applied for voluntary disclosure. The commission heard cases within 14 days of submission and delivered its verdict in 30 days. Failure to comply with TAC rulings will result in five years’ imprisonment. People convicted by TAC will be barred for five years from contesting in elections to any public office toward the end of the caretaker government.
Juvenile Justice System The administration of juvenile justice in Bangladesh is governed by two exclusive acts, the Children Act, 1974 and the Probation of Offenders Ordinance, 1960 (amended in 1964). The Children Act contains both procedural and substantive components. The procedural component entails establishment of a separate juvenile court for children, whereas the substantive component depicts offenses committed by children and prescribes penalties. That is, the Children Act handles the trial, custody, protection, punishment, and treatment of juvenile offenders.
Juveniles were required by child laws to be detained in juvenile correctional facilities such as juvenile development centers or safe homes and can only be tried in the juvenile courts or court duly empowered to try the juvenile cases. Accordingly, a number of separate juvenile courts and three child development centers have been established in the country. According to the Children Act, after arrest, a police officer can release the juveniles on bail or produce before the magistrates’ court to release the juveniles on probation. However, in most cases, police have been producing delinquent children before the court and the court is sending them to prison instead of safe homes or the juvenile development centers where these juveniles are incarcerated with adults. Though in some cases age determination is a major problem for the police officer to process the juvenile offenders, in many cases police deliberately or negligibly claim a higher age of the child and forward the child to adult courts to avoid extra work. A recent press report revealed that about 412 juveniles are detained in different prisons across the country for years, violating the Children Act. It should be noted that the court has the discretion to send the juvenile offenders to juvenile development centers directly.
Punishment Following the Western model of corrections, a number of Asian countries (such as India, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan) have introduced probation, parole, home leave, work release, and suspended sentences in recent years. Thus, it is evident that as compared to other Asian countries, the Bangladeshi correctional system is still lagging behind. The major causes may be attributed to nonavailability of funds for correctional programs, lack of political supports, and lack of research on corrections. Although the Jail Commission Report of 1978 recommended the establishment of the system of probation, parole, and work release in Bangladesh, these recommendations have yet to be implemented, which means imprisonment is the only sanction for offenders. The certainty of punishment, the likelihood that a criminal will be punished for a serious crime, and the amount of time a criminal is likely to spend in
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bangladesh
prison are higher today than they had been in the 1990s. This is primarily due to enactment of various anticrime laws over the years, and more recently, the emergency rule from January 11, 2007, to December 2008. The typical punishment for various types of offense as prescribed in the Penal Code and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (as amended up to October, 2007) are shown as follows: • Dacoity (gang robbery): transportation for life or rigorous imprisonment for 10 years, and fine. • Murder in dacoity: death, transportation for life or rigorous imprisonment for 10 years, and fine. • Robbery or dacoity, with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt: rigorous imprisonment for not less than seven years. • Robbery: rigorous imprisonment for 10 years, and fine. • Theft: imprisonment for three years or fine or both. • Rape: death or life imprisonment. • Offenses against the state: punishable by death or imprisonment for 20 years. • Violence against women (acid throwing): death or life imprisonment.
Death Penalty Article 35(5) of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh precisely states that no person shall be subjected to cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment. But the courts have been imposing the death penalty for various offenses. According to the data provided by the Prison’s Directorate, as of July 1, 2008, the total number of death row population in Bangladesh was 1,012. And between 2004 and 2008, Bangladesh executed a total of 31 prisoners.
Prison The nomenclature in Bangladesh makes no distinction between jails and prison. All institutions are referred to as jails in Bangladesh. The prison system of Bangladesh had its inception in the legislation of the Prison Act of 1894, which was basically
|
35
derived from the England Prison Act of 1877. The correctional system is administratively centralized. The jail is the only correctional institution in Bangladesh, which holds inmates who are awaiting trial, undergoing trial, and serving sentences. Jails are controlled by the Ministry of Home and their operational responsibilities vested in the Prisons’ Directorate. Bangladeshi jails are still administered under the century-old colonial Prison Act. Presently, there are 67 jails, which vary greatly in size, as well as many other characteristics. They are divided into two categories: central and district jail. They are generally distinguished by their degree of security that relates to perimeter control and internal gates and bars, and the types of population they hold. As of 2008, there were 12 central jails and 55 district jails. Imprisonment is of two types: rigorous and simple. Persons admitted under sentence of rigorous imprisonment are required to work, while persons serving simple imprisonment have no such liability.
Prison Population Since imprisonment is the only legal sanction, this conservative ideology of punishment is responsible for the present crisis in corrections in Bangladesh. In the absence of any population-reduction strategy, a substantial increase in prison populations has been observed in Bangladesh. Evidence suggests that the use of imprisonment as a sanction for crime has accelerated rapidly after the 1990s. Since then, the number of offenders incarcerated in jails has increased every year from about 39,530 in 1993 to more than 87,000 in 2008. The prisons are becoming no more than warehouses. It seems that part of the growing problem of prison crowding is attributable to the shift in sentencing policy over the 1990s; for example, enactment of the AntiTerrorism Act of 1993, Public Safety Act of 2000, and Speedy Trial Act of 2002, and more recently, the Emergency Powers Ordinance of 2007. According to the data provided by the Prison’s Directorate, the prison population increased by about 55 percent between 1993 and 2008, reaching 87,011 as of July 1, 2008, which is more than 300 percent of official prison capacity. Bangladesh
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
36
|
Bangladesh
has the capacity to accommodate 27,386 inmates in jails across the country. Of the total population, only 25,173 (about 29%) were convicted prisoners and the remaining were under-trial (70.7 percent) or detained for investigation. Almost all the institutions are housing far more inmates than the design capacity. The daily population of Dhaka Central Jail on July 1, 2008, was 10,424. It appears that overcrowding of the under-trial prisoner is the main problem for the prison systems. In most cases, cells were so packed that prisoners had to sleep in shifts. More than anything else, it is the war on corruption that has caused this dramatic increase in prison population, especially during the regime of the immediate past caretaker government (2007–2008). Additionally, the courts and legislatures did indeed get “tougher” on offenders during this period and is the reason for the stunning growth in prison populations. In the face of serious overcrowding in jails recently, the government has decided to release some selected nonviolent offenders who already served half of their prison terms of seven years or less.
Prison Programs The jails in Bangladesh are primarily custodial institutions. The goal of imprisonment is to incapacitate and punish the offenders. Jail conditions seem consistent with that goal. Thus, no aspects of imprisonment in Bangladesh seem to be linked to rehabilitating prisoners. The problem of overcrowding has seriously affected both the safe running of the prison system and the rehabilitation of individual offenders. Institutional treatment programs such as individual or group counseling is totally absent. Educational and vocational programs that exist in the jails suffer from inadequate funding and administration. As a result, the existing prison programs cannot serve as an important tool in gaining marketable skills for the prisoners in their postimprisonment life.
subject to censorship. Visits from approved family members are allowed at specified intervals. According to the Jail Code, the ordinary inmates can write one letter every month and the division prisoner can write twice a month. Prison authorities do sometimes grant a short furlough for few hours to the Division I prisoner for emergency occasions such as a death in the immediate family. There are no dayrooms or dining facilities for the inmates in jails. The concept of conjugal visits is unknown in Bangladesh. It is important to mention that political prisoners are a privileged class and immune from the harsher confinement conditions. Despite the limited resources of the prison system, this category of prisoners receives better treatment in terms of housing, food, visitation, and other facilities than the ordinary prisoners.
Alternative to Imprisonment The Bangladeshi penal system provides just one alternative measure—probation. Where a person is convicted of an offense punishable with imprisonment for not more than two years, the court may, after considering the age and character of the offender and the nature of the offense, make a probation order. The penal laws of Bangladesh do not provide the system of parole.
Exchange of Prisoners Prisoners can be exchanged to other countries such as Myanmar and India. In August 2006, Bangladesh and Myanmar signed an agreement to exchange prisoners from their respective countries. And very recently, Bangladesh and India agreed to exchange each other’s prisoners. Mohammed Bin Kashem
Visiting Policies and Privileges
Further Reading BLAST: Bangladesh Legal Aid and Services Trust: http://www.blast.org.bd.
Prisoners do not have access to telephones and law libraries. In general, prisoners are not entitled to have a newspaper, except division prisoners that are
Kashem, Mohammed B. (1996). “Jails in Bangladesh.” International Journal of Comparative and Applied Criminal Justice 20(1): 31–40.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bhutan
Kashem, Mohammed B. (2004). “The Social Organization of Police Corruption: The Case of Bangladesh.” In Police Corruption: An International Comparative Perspective, edited by Dilip K. Das and Rick Sarre, pp. 237–246. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books. Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs. Legal and Judicial Capacity Building Project: http://www.minlaw.gov.bd/ljcbp.htm. Strengthening Bangladesh Police. Police Reform Program: http://www.prp.org.bd.
Bhutan Legal System: Customary/Common Murder: Low-Medium Corruption: Low Death Penalty: No Corporal Punishment: Yes
Background Bhutan, meaning “Land of the Thunder Dragon,” is a small kingdom-state located in the eastern Himalaya Mountains of southern Asia. Landlocked between India to the south and the Tibetan region of China to the north, Bhutan has an area of 47,000 square kilometers (18,147 square miles), and its terrain is predominantly mountainous. Bhutan has been popularly described as the “last Shangri-la” or the only remaining Buddhist kingdom in the Himalayas. These narratives represent Bhutan as “a fairy-tale kingdom,” locked in ancient culture and tradition, untouched by modernization and globalization. Though these idyllic representations are exaggerated, indeed, Bhutan remained largely isolated from the rest of the world well into the early 1960s when Bhutan’s third monarch, King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck, began the process of cautious modernization. Since then, Bhutan opened its doors to regulated tourism in 1974, became a member of the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) in 1985, and lifted a nationwide ban on television and the Internet in 1999.
|
37
The rugged terrain of Bhutan makes transportation and communication between Bhutanese communities challenging. In fact, there were no telecommunications or roads in Bhutan until the 1960s. Though some roads and highways have since been constructed with the help of migrant workers from India, even today, a number of communities can only be reached by walking. Therefore, despite gradual modernization efforts, the Bhutanese people still remain largely isolated from one another and from the rest of the world. This seclusion is further enhanced by the government’s strict regulation of tourism and other forms of foreign influence to preserve the kingdom’s traditional culture. Today, Bhutan continues to be one of the poorest and most underdeveloped countries in the world. The vast majority of the Bhutanese people (more than 90%) live in rural communities and a large majority of the labor force (more than 60%) is employed in the agriculture or forestry industries. The government of Bhutan, however, has objected to assessment of the nation’s material wealth as a measure for overall quality of life. In 1998, the government abandoned Gross Domestic Product (GDP) as the primary measure of national prosperity and replaced it with Gross National Happiness (GNH), which prioritizes social, cultural, and spiritual well-being over material wealth. The Bhutanese government is very committed to preserving its national heritage and cultural traditions; however, Bhutan continues to take steps toward development and modernization. Bhutan is in the midst of social and political changes that have significant implications for the nation’s crime rates and the criminal justice system. Historically, Bhutan has reported very low crime rates; however, crime rates appear to be increasing in the last decade. Considering that the “first-ever crime wave” in the nation corresponds to the introduction of television, a number of Bhutanese officials have suggested a relationship between television and increasing crime, drug use, and the deterioration of traditional family values. As Bhutan has opened itself to foreign influence, it has also become particularly concerned about maintaining its cultural and religious traditions.
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
38
|
Bhutan
As a result, since the late 1970s, the government of Bhutan has instituted many policies to forge a unified Bhutanese identity. Some of these policies are considered restrictive and even repressive of minority groups within the country and have caused some human rights groups to accuse Bhutan of ethnic cleansing. According to critics, the long-standing repressive policies may have incited recent terrorist attacks across the country. At the same time, the nation has made significant strides toward more democratic governance, including the adoption of a new Civil and Criminal Procedural Code in 2001, a new Penal Code in 2004, and the codification of basic rights in a new Constitution in 2008.
Government During the 19th century, Bhutan was under decentralized rule by a number of independent principalities that were in continuous competition and civil war. After several years of conflict, between the years of 1882 and 1885, Ugyen Wangchuck of Trongsa was finally able to unify the many decentralized local governments across Bhutan and achieve a peaceful truce among the parties. On December 17, 1907, respected community leaders of Bhutan selected Ugyen Wangchuck to be the first hereditary king of Bhutan and, thereby, established the Kingdom of Bhutan as an absolute monarchy. Bhutan’s modern political history is unique from most other nations in that it is one of the few nations in which the movement for democracy has been largely from the top-down. Though the monarchy continues to be very popular among the people of Bhutan and the majority of the general public has not been enthusiastic about political transition, Bhutan’s last few monarchs have been eager to institute gradual democratization. King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck, Bhutan’s third monarch, started the democratization movement in 1953 when he established the nation’s first legislature, the National Assembly, to promote a more democratic and inclusive form of governance. The National Assembly, under the guidance of King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck, enacted the first
comprehensive codified law code in 1959. The law code, known as the Thrimzhung Chhenmo, or, the Supreme Law, codified the civil and criminal laws of Bhutan. Though many sections have been amended by subsequent legislation, the Thrimzhung Chhenmo is considered to be the foundation for Bhutan’s legal system. During his reign, King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck also created a Royal Advisory Council in 1965 and established a Council of Cabinet Ministers in 1968. In 1998, King Jigme Singye Wangchuck, Bhutan’s fourth monarch, introduced significant political reforms in the government and transferred many of his administrative powers to the Council of Cabinet Ministers. One of his most significant reforms is that King Jigme Singye Wangchuck established a procedure by which the National Assembly could impeach the monarch by a two-thirds majority vote. During King Jigme Singye Wangchuck’s rule, the National Assembly enacted the Civil and Criminal Court Procedure of Bhutan in 2001 and the Penal Code of Bhutan in 2004. These legal codes established the appropriate protocols for civil and criminal procedures and outlined the classification of crimes and punishment for civil and criminal offenses. The codification of the court procedure and penal code were significant reforms for Bhutan’s justice system. In 2006, King Jigme Singye Wangchuck abdicated the throne in favor of his son, King Dasho Jigme Khesar Namgyal Wangchuck, who became the fifth monarch of Bhutan. During King Dasho Jigme Khesar Namgyal Wangchuck’s reign, on March 24, 2008, the country’s first-ever national elections took place, and Bhutan finally made the anticipated transition from an absolute monarchy to a constitutional monarchy. A draft constitution that had been unveiled during his father’s rule in 2005 was adopted after the elections, and the Supreme Court of Bhutan was established as the highest court of the land with the chief justice at its head.
Cultural Context Bhutan’s government prefers to portray the nation as homogenous; however, Bhutan is actually a
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bhutan
multiethnic, multireligious society with three major ethno-linguistic groups: the Ngalung, the Sarchhop, and the Lhotshampa. The Ngalung, who migrated from Tibet in the 17th century and live predominantly in the northwestern region of the country, practice Drukpa Kagyu Buddhism and speak Dzongkha (an offshoot of Tibetan). The monarchy of Bhutan belongs to the Ngalung ethnic group. The Sarchhop, a native Bhutanese ethnic group, live predominantly in the eastern region of Bhutan, practice Nyingmapa Buddhism, and speak a native Bhutanese dialect. The Lhotshampa, an ethnic group of Nepalese descent, live predominantly in the southern region of Bhutan along the Indian border, practice Hinduism, and speak Nepali. The Bhutanese government, dominated by the Ngalung ethnic group, has instituted a policy of driglamnamja or “one nation, one people” and passed a number of laws in an effort to assimilate the Bhutanese population according to Ngalung cultural values and traditions. The government has been criticized for ethnic and religious discrimination against minority groups, particularly the Lhotshampa. The Bhutan Marriage Act of 1980, for example, restricted marriage with non-Bhutanese and denied Bhutanese citizens who married nonBhutanese state support such as land, loans, education, and health benefits. The act was discriminatorily applied to the Lhotshampa population to curb marriages with noncitizen Nepalis living in Bhutan. Furthermore, in 1985, the government passed a Citizenship Act that stipulated that Bhutanese citizens would be required to prove their residency in Bhutan for more than 10 years. Considering that members of the Lhotshampa ethnic group were more likely to include immigrants from Nepal, documentation of 10 years’ residency in Bhutan was more difficult for the Lhotshampa. The Citizenship Act also stipulated that citizens could lose their nationality if they left their farmland or broke the law. Again, these laws were targeted at the Lhotshampa, to limit their freedom of movement and political participation. In the 1990s, political tensions led the government of Bhutan to force more than 100,000 Lhotshampa
|
39
and ethnic Nepalis out of the country into refugee camps in Nepal. Those refugees are still living in refugee camps awaiting a resolution that will allow them to come home. The refugee crisis will be discussed in more detail later. The long-standing ethnic conflict may help explain the fact that demographic data about the Bhutanese people are inconsistent and controversial. According to the government census of 2005, Bhutan has an estimated population of approximately 672,425, but other reports, such as numbers from the United Nations and the CIA, indicate that the population may be as high as 2 million. The discrepancies in population estimates may be due to the ongoing refugee crisis involving the Lhotshampa, since some population estimates do not include the refugees or ethnic Lhotshampa still residing within Bhutanese borders whereas others do. Conflicting numbers indicate that approximately 47–85 percent of the population are either Ngalung or Sarchhop and follow the Buddhist tradition, and approximately 15–53 percent, the ethnic Nepalese, follow the Hindu tradition. The religious and cultural traditions of Bhutan, both Buddhist and Hindu, serve to reinforce the predominant social value that all forms of life are to be considered sacred. The people of Bhutan are generally known to be a peaceful people and the overall crime rates in Bhutan remain very low, though Bhutan has seen some escalation in crime over the last decade. Though crime does not seem to be a major problem, there is insufficient data to conduct a systematic review of the nature and extent of crime in Bhutan. Nevertheless, it is perhaps fair to say that Bhutan’s most long-standing “criminal justice” problem has to do with the ethnic conflict and refugee crisis that has plagued the nation for almost two decades.
Legal System Bhutan’s legal system is based largely on Buddhist tradition, English common law, and the Indian legal system. Lower courts exercise original jurisdiction on cases within their territorial jurisdiction and appellate courts review appeals cases from the
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
40
|
Bhutan
lower courts. The Supreme Court was established as the highest court of Bhutan with the adoption of the Constitution in March 2008 and will be presided over by the chief justice of Bhutan. Prior to 2008, the Bhutanese legal system had a three-tier court system. The High Court, established in 1968, was the highest court of Bhutan. The High Court is made up of three benches that each consist of a minimum of two judges. The Dzongkhag, or district courts, are the next level of courts. The first district court was established in 1961, and there are currently 20 across Bhutan. The Dungkhag, or local court, was established in 1978, and there are currently three local courts in Bhutan. The registrar general of the High Court heads the administrative division of the courts and is appointed by the chief justice for a period of three years. The registrar general serves at the pleasure of the chief justice for one term. Recent procedural reforms in the administration of the court system have reduced the cost of litigation in Bhutan, and the National Assembly has asked the High Court to develop guidelines to limit the fees of jabmis (counsel) to make litigation more affordable and accessible to all citizens. The time to disposition for the majority of all legal cases, and virtually all criminal cases, is within 108 days. The Bhutanese legal system is based on the adversarial principle, though there are some elements of the inquisitorial system as well. The courts are supposed to be impartial participants in the proceedings, and judges are responsible for ensuring procedural fairness during trial. Defendants may choose to defend themselves or may select a jabmi to represent them in front of the court. In cases in which the defendant is indigent and cannot afford to retain the services of a jabmi, the court can appoint legal counsel for the defendant. The litigants or their counsel may present relevant information to the court and answer questions posed by the judges. The courts are charged with deciding cases based on the facts submitted by the parties. Defendants are presumed to be innocent. For criminal cases, the prosecution has the burden of proof to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. For civil cases, the plaintiff has the burden to prove his or
her case by a fair preponderance of the credible evidence.
Police Bhutan’s security forces include a national militia, the Royal Bhutan Army, and the Royal Bhutan Police. The national militia was established in 1958, and shortly thereafter the Royal Bhutan Army was established in 1963. In 1965, the Royal Bhutan Police was established on September 1, and this date continues to be commemorated and celebrated annually as Police Day. The Royal Bhutan Police serves as the national police force and is organizationally inferior to the Royal Bhutan Army. The nation’s first police officers were a few hundred army personnel who were reassigned to the new police force. By the late 1970s the police force had expanded to more than 1,000 constables and officers, and by the mid-1990s the police force had grown to about 5,000. Police recruits, at a minimum, are required to have completed a sixth-grade education, and the Royal Bhutan Police is the only security force in Bhutan that recruits women. Until 1981, all new recruits were trained at the Police Training Centre in Zilnon Namgyeling, Thimphu District. In 1981, a new police training center opened in Jigmiling, Geylegphug District, and police officers are now trained at that location as well. The police training curriculum includes weapons training, tae kwon do, physical training with and without arms, legal training, simple investigation techniques, check-post duties, traffic control, and public relations. Some officers are chosen for advanced training in criminology, traffic control, and canine corps and are sent to India for those training programs. Police officers are required to perform a variety of functions that go beyond standard policing practices. Officers serve as border guards, corrections officers, firefighters, and first aid providers. Some critics have noted that there may be issues of conflict of interest in requiring police officers to participate in such a diverse set of functions; however, the government of Bhutan has not been particularly concerned with specializing these functions or
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bhutan
separating the police from these other service and enforcement functions. The Royal Bhutan Police has been cognizant of development and modernization programs and has made gradual adaptations to those changes. Construction of roads and the increasing number of motor vehicles in use has resulted in increasing numbers of traffic accidents. In response to the changing circumstances, the Royal Bhutan Police established a mobile traffic court staffed by police personnel and a judicial official to facilitate on-thespot legal decisions. In 2007, the Royal Bhutan Police established a new Women and Child Protection Unit in the capital, Thimpu. This new unit is one of the first steps in developing women and child friendly police and judicial procedures. The unit is run by women police officers in collaboration with the National Commission for Women and Children (NCWC) and provides a safe environment for female victims and witnesses to come forward. It is the first unit of its kind in the country and, based on support from the United Nations Development Program, will likely be replicated in other regions in the near future. A procedural code has also been established that stipulates that police officers may not arrest an individual without an arrest warrant or specific cause and that an arrestee must be brought before the court within 24 hours, not including travel time from the place of arrest. These reforms are relatively new, and, in practice, these legal protections are not systematically applied, primarily because of deficiencies in police training and some gaps in the procedural codes that will hopefully be addressed in the next few years.
Crime Classification of Crimes Bhutan’s Penal Code came into effect on August 11, 2004. The Penal Code consolidated and clarified existing legal codes on the culpability and punishment for criminal acts committed in Bhutan. According to the Penal Code, the age of criminal responsibility for adult offenders is 18. Juvenile offenders cannot be held responsible for any criminal acts committed
|
41
under the age of 10; however, juveniles between the ages of 10 and 18 may be held responsible for criminal acts and sentenced to appropriate punishment, though punishment is scaled lower for juveniles than adults. The Penal Code classifies criminal acts into four categories ordered by severity of offense: felony, misdemeanor, petty misdemeanor, and violation. Felony crimes are the most serious category of criminal offenses and are further classified into four degrees of severity. First-degree felonies are the most serious offenses and include such crimes as murder, treason, terrorism, defilement of national monuments, and the illegal manufacturing of weapons of mass destruction. Second-degree felonies include such crimes as the illegal transaction of a controlled substance, the rape of a child under the age of 12, and the trafficking of a minor for prostitution. Third-degree felonies include such crimes as gang rape, the trafficking of adult women for prostitution, torture that causes physical disability, extortion, and armed robbery. Fourth-degree felonies include such crimes as rape, the illegal sale or purchase of a firearm, the unauthorized opening of another person’s mail, trafficking of humans for labor, child molestation, torture that does not cause physical disability, the illegal sale of national or cultural heritage property, robbery, burglary, and arson. Misdemeanor crimes include such crimes as eavesdropping through unlawful wiretapping, patronizing a prostitute, assisting in suicide, sodomy, and abortion. Abortion is legal only under the following circumstances: the mother’s life will be put at risk to carry the unborn child to term, the child is the product of rape or incest, or the mother is of unsound mental condition. Otherwise, abortion is illegal and is treated as a misdemeanor crime, as are “unnatural” sex acts such as sodomy. Petty misdemeanor crimes include such crimes as battery, sexual harassment, pollution, illegal hunting and fishing, abandonment of a person in danger, failure to report a crime, and gambling. Violations include such crimes as disorderly conduct, assault, public intoxication, and the use of tobacco. Bhutan banned the use of tobacco in 2004 and is currently
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
42
|
Bhutan
the only nation to have completely banned smoking in public.
Human Rights Issues The government of Bhutan has passed a number of laws to give life to the “one nation, one people” policy and to preserve Bhutan’s traditional culture. For example, in 1989, a royal decree made it compulsory to wear the national dress at formal gatherings and government institutions, including schools, to preserve and promote Bhutanese culture. For men, they must wear the “gho” or a wrap-around, coatlike, knee-length garment with a narrow belt. For women, they must wear the “kira” or an anklelength dress made of a rectangular piece of cloth held at the shoulders with a clip and closed with a woven belt at the waist over a long-sleeved blouse. Failure to the wear the required dress results in fines of three days’ wages (approximately equivalent to US$10 to US$55) or up to a month in prison. The government has also established a language policy requiring use of the official language, Dzongkha, in schools and public offices, a policy that has marginalized the Nepali-speaking minority. Furthermore, religious freedom is minimal, and the law forbids religious conversions and penalizes those who attempt to convert others. The government has also enacted a number of laws pertaining to marriage and family life. The Marriage Act of 1980 legislated punitive measures against Bhutanese who marry non-Bhutanese nationals. From the day of such a marriage, the Bhutanese citizen is denied promotion in government services, is ineligible for employment in national defense, cannot run for election, and is deprived of many privileges, including land, loans, education, and medical treatment. In 1990, the government also imposed a policy of compulsory birth control. If a couple has more than two children, the government may compel one of the parents to undergo a sterilization operation. These drastic birth control measures, however, have been implemented discriminatorily against minorities, and, according to critics, violate human rights. Meanwhile, polygamy is legal in Bhutan on
the condition that the first wife gives permission to her husband to take a second wife. Divorce is also legal and fairly common in Bhutan, and the legal code favors women in matters of alimony and child custody.
Crime Statistics Bhutan has not reported any crime statistics to the United Nations and the official crime statistics are not available to the public. Most reports, including estimates from the U.S. Department of State and the Central Intelligence Agency, suggest that there is relatively little crime in Bhutan. Of crimes committed in Bhutan, the vast majority tends to be nonviolent crimes. Violent crime rates are estimated to be very low; however, there is not sufficient data for precision. Homicide rates for 2004 are estimated to be between 2.4 and 4.3 homicides per 100,000 population, according to the United Nations Office of Drug Control. Although Bhutan has not experienced a serious crime problem, according to news reports, crime has been gradually increasing in the last decade. Bhutan’s courts have made public the number of cases reviewed by the courts over the last 15 years. Based on the official data, there has been a general trend of rising numbers of cases filed in the courts over the last decade. For the years 1991 and 1992, the courts decided a total of 3,136 cases. These numbers grew to a total of 8,804 cases in 2002, 10,376 cases in 2006, and 11,501 cases in 2007. The numbers, however, do not indicate the type or severity of the cases, though some reports indicate that the majority of cases were related to loans, land disputes, and marital issues. The judiciary of Bhutan is working toward technological improvements to automate its record keeping so that it is able to generate better case tracking statistics and improve the overall judicial system. According to news reports, April 2002 was likely the “first-ever crime wave” in Bhutan. There were several incidents of fraud, violence, and even murder. Some residents of Bhutan blame increasing problems with crime, drugs, and alcohol on television. The government of Bhutan lifted the ban on
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bhutan
television in June 1999. Bhutan opened its first and only local television station shortly thereafter, and international television channels also became available for viewing via satellite dishes. There is significant concern in Bhutan that exposure to satellite television has resulted in harmful cultural changes, especially among the youth population. Based on qualitative research, an independent group of Bhutanese academics found a correlation between exposure to satellite television and cultural changes, including increased participation in crime, corruption, and less conventional romantic relationships. Some critics have even asserted that television can be blamed for increases in drug use and family break-ups. Whereas the Bhutanese people have traditionally shied away from killing even insects, now they are exposed to extreme violence as well as ultraliberal sexual mores on television. In addition, discos and nightclubs have recently opened and are considered to be threatening the traditional values and peaceful culture of Bhutan. There are no official statistics on drug use in Bhutan; however, the government recognizes it as a growing and potentially serious problem. Bhutan is an active participant in regional initiatives to combat drug trafficking and substance abuse and is a signatory on the SAARC Convention on Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (1990). Bhutan also joined International Criminal Police Organization (INTERPOL) in 2005. Bhutan has no pharmaceutical industry and relies on the import of licit drugs from India. Bhutan’s trade relationship with India allows for free and unregulated trade between the neighboring countries. The relatively open and insecure borders between Bhutan and India make Bhutan vulnerable to international drug trafficking across the border. Anecdotal data suggest increasing use of amphetamines smuggled in from India, and there are some estimates of approximately five to six deaths from morphine overdoses each year. Use of heroin and injecting drug use, however, is considered to be minimal. Before the introduction of television, cannabis plants, which grow freely in Bhutan, were used to feed pigs. In recent years, however, the police have arrested hundreds for smoking marijuana.
|
43
According to official sources, most drug users in Bhutan are young males under the age of 25. As a result, there is significant concern about young people’s propensity for drug use as well as their risk for HIV. As of 2005, there were 144 officially reported cases of HIV in Bhutan and some estimates indicating that there could be approximately 500 people living with the disease by the end of that year. Concerns about increasing levels of drug use and HIV prompted the National Assembly, in 2005, to pass the Prevention and Control of Drug Abuse Act and create a new Narcotics Control Agency. The National Assembly specifically called for joint efforts by the government and local communities to enhance preventive education measures and to collaborate for improvements in the quality and availability of effective treatment, rehabilitation, and social reintegration when prevention fails.
Violence against Women Bhutan ratified the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) in 1981 without any reservation and has drafted a National Plan of Action for Gender (NPAG) that was spearheaded by the National Commission for Women and Children and will be rolled out from 2007 to 2013. Though the actual extent of the problem is not known since most cases of family violence go unreported, anecdotal evidence suggests that domestic violence is a problem in Bhutan. In response to the problem of domestic violence and gender violence in general, Her Majesty Queen Ashi Sangay Choden Wangchuck started a nonprofit organization for women called Respect, Educate, Nurture and Empower Women (RENEW) in 2004. RENEW seeks to be the leading institution in shaping the role of women in Bhutanese society, and its mission is to empower disadvantaged girls and women to be independent and socially and economically productive members of society. According to RENEW, reported cases of assault against women and girls that were prosecuted in court grew from 56 in 2000 to 99 in 2003. Police reports indicate that of the 347 cases of assault
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
44
|
Bhutan
against women and girls that went to court from 2000 to 2004, 43 percent involved the woman’s intimate partner. The problem is exacerbated by the fact that there are currently no emergency shelter or support services available in Bhutan for women trying to escape from violent and abusive relationships or situations. Many women, especially those who are financially dependent on their husbands, have nowhere to go for counseling, therapy, or information on how to become independent. RENEW’s Web site also reports that although accurate statistics are not yet available in Bhutan, hospital staff and the police are seeing increasing incidence of sexual and physical abuse of women and girls. As the government has made public education more widely available and has encouraged the schooling of girls, more and more girls are sent to schools away from their families. A serious issue of concern is the sexual abuse of girls and young women who are sent away to schools. Many educators who responded to a limited confidential study on female students in their schools replied that sexual abuse of girls is a problem. The government of Bhutan is also concerned about the problem of human trafficking. Bhutan is known to be an origin and transit location for human trafficking. Bhutanese women are often trafficked to neighboring Nepal, and children are trafficked through Nepal and India to Pakistan.
Finding of Guilt The Civil and Criminal Code of Bhutan ensures equal justice under the law without discrimination on the basis of sex, race, religion, or any other reason. Citizens accused of crimes are to be tried by ordinary courts, not by any ad hoc tribunals. In criminal proceedings, the accused are afforded the right to a trial by judicial panel on the appropriate court’s current bench, and the trails are intended to be fair and public trials. In some circumstances, there may be exceptions made regarding public trials when there are concerns about public order, national security, or privacy of the parties. Defendants may plead their cases or defend themselves in person or may select a jabmi, legal counsel, for assistance.
Defendants may waive their right to have a jabmi if they do so competently and intelligently. While there is no separate court system for juveniles, juvenile offenders may have their parent or guardian present with them during trial proceedings and may have their privacy protected by the court. Only indigent defendants who cannot afford to secure their own legal counsel may be offered free legal services by the court. If a defendant is not satisfied with the decision of a court, he or she may file an appeal within 10 days of the initial judgment.
Punishment Types of Punishment The Penal Code’s stated objective is to reinstate dignity to victims of crime and increase the possibilities for rehabilitation of offenders. Those who are convicted of criminal offenses may be imprisoned, released on probation, made to pay fines to the state, made to pay compensation as restitution to victims or victims’ families, or a combination. Mutilation as punishment was abolished in 1965. Exile was once an official punishment; however, it is no longer used as a form of punishment. Furthermore, capital punishment was abolished by royal decree on March 20, 2004. The Penal Code is largely based on the rehabilitative ideal, though in recent years, some policy makers have advocated for harsher punishments, particularly for sexual crimes. Juveniles under the age of 10 are not held responsible for criminal conduct. Juveniles between the ages of 10 and 18 are held responsible for their acts and are liable to punishment, though juveniles receive punishment scaled lower than adults for similar offenses. In fact, juveniles are to receive a minimum of half the sentence that would otherwise be imposed if the offender had been an adult when committing the crime. In 1997, the Youth Development and Rehabilitation Center was established for juvenile offenders with the primary goal of rehabilitation. Nevertheless, in some cases in which a juvenile may face imprisonment, the court may choose to assign an alternative sentence. Children are a high priority in Bhutan, and the country was one of the first to ratify the Convention on the Rights
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Bhutan
of the Child in 1990 and has since been investing steadily in services to benefit children. Bhutan’s justice system tends to be more lenient toward juvenile offenders and is primarily concerned with rehabilitating them. Felony crimes are the most serious category of criminal offenses and are punishable with a minimum of three years of imprisonment to a maximum of life imprisonment. First-degree felonies are punishable with a minimum of 15 years of imprisonment to life imprisonment. Second-degree felonies are punishable with 9 to 15 years of imprisonment. Third-degree felonies are punishable with 5 to 15 years of imprisonment. Fourth-degree felonies are punishable with three to five years of imprisonment. Misdemeanor crimes are punishable with a minimum of one year of imprisonment to a maximum of three years. Petty misdemeanor crimes are punishable with a minimum of one month of imprisonment to a maximum of one year. Violations are punishable with fines for up to 90 days at the national minimum wage rate. Offenders convicted on a repeat offense are punishable with enhanced sentences. Typically, these offenders are sentenced as if they had committed a crime one degree higher than their actual offense. The Penal Code does allow the court to consider mitigating and aggravating circumstances. Mitigating circumstances include that the defendant has no criminal record, the defendant committed the crime under extreme mental or emotional distress, the crime was committed accidentally, the victim consented to the criminal conduct, the crime was conducted because the defendant believed there was reasonable justification for the act, the defendant was only an accomplice in a crime committed by someone else and his or her participation was minor, the defendant acted under duress, or, at the time of the offense the defendant’s capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of the conduct or to conform to the requirements of the law was impaired on account of mental disability or intoxication. Aggravating circumstances include that the defendant had previously been convicted of a crime, the defendant committed another crime at the same time as the current offense, the defendant knowingly
|
45
created a grave risk of death or serious bodily injury to another person, the defendant negligently caused bodily injury to another person with a deadly weapon, the crime was essentially heinous, atrocious, or cruel and represents exceptional depravity on behalf of the defendant. In some circumstances, and according to the court’s discretion, the court may make an order that the defendant pay a fine or perform community service in lieu of imprisonment. Typically, these considerations are afforded to nonfelony offenders provided that the offender is not a recidivist or habitual offender. According to the Penal Code, those who are found to be mentally insane may be sentenced to civil commitment in lieu of imprisonment. There are, however, no mental hospitals or community residential facilities in Bhutan, and forensic cases are typically kept in police custody. Residential facilities that are available include a 50-bed facility for juvenile delinquents, a 15-bed facility for drug detoxification and rehabilitation, and a 5-bed residential facility for the elderly. Furthermore, according to the Ministry of Health, a residential facility for victims of domestic violence and rape is currently under construction. For some felony cases, the court may order the defendant to pay compensatory damages to the victim or victim’s family in addition to imprisonment. For example, for some murder and rape cases, the court may order compensation to the victim or victim’s family for up to 10 years. Similarly, for most property or monetary crimes, such as bribery and fraud, the court punishes offenders based on valuebased sentencing and attempts to compensate the victim with comparably valued damages. The monarch retains the power to grant amnesty or commute any criminal sentences.
Prisons In Bhutan, prisons are under the jurisdiction of the police. Police officers administer the prisons and serve as correctional officers. Bhutan does not publish prison figures and according to the World Prison Population List (8th edition), there are currently no
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
46
|
Bhutan
reliable statistics available on the number of prisoners incarcerated in Bhutan’s prison system. In the 1990s prison conditions were widely known to be poor, with inadequate hygiene, unhealthy food, and prevalent overcrowding that allegedly resulted in the deaths of detainees. The government ended the use of shackles in 1992 as a result of pressure from Amnesty International. Representatives from the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) began visiting prisons in 1993, and, according to ICRC, prison conditions in Bhutan are now satisfactory. Furthermore, the opening of a new prison camp in Chemgang and a new prison in the capital city, Thimpu, in 1994 improved the conditions of detention. Medical treatment in prisons is provided by the Basic Health Unit (BHU). These units are normally staffed by a medical officer, health assistant, assistant nurse, and two nonmedical staff members. Health records of the individual prisoners are kept and minor illnesses of the prisoners are treated at the BHU. The medical officer visits the BHU on one occasion a week for custom check-ups of prisoners. In terms of mental health services, Bhutan’s prisons offer very little. According to the Bhutan Ministry of Health, less than 4 percent of prisoners suffer from psychosis or mental retardation. Therefore, the need for mental health services is not dire. Nevertheless, Bhutanese prisons have at least one prisoner per month in treatment contact with a mental health professional. As for training, some police officers (21%–50%) and a few (1%–20%) judges and lawyers have participated in educational activities on mental health in the last five years.
The Refugee Crisis Opposition to the government’s “one nation, one people” policy and the cultural protection laws resulted in mass demonstrations in September and October 1990. Up to 18,000 protesters participated in the demonstrations and the government moved decisively to suppress the movement. Demonstrators were labeled as “ngolops” (antinationals) and the National Security Act of 1992 made antinational activities into criminal offenses. From 1989
to 1992, police and army forces arrested thousands of ethnic Nepalese suspected of supporting a rebellious movement. Some were detained and others simply disappeared. The government has denied accountability for any disappearances; however, in the past several years, the government has freed from detention at least 1,666 ethnic Nepalese under official amnesties. According to local human rights groups, widespread human rights abuses were reported during 1989–1992 and were likely committed as part of an effort to drive out ethnic Nepalese. These policy initiatives suggest that the government tacitly condoned the abuse of ethnic Nepalese. Several thousand people were imprisoned for months in what some allege to have been substandard conditions. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees detailed 2,200 allegations of torture in the government prisons of Bhutan. Victims reported severe beating and kicking, exposure to extreme heat and cold for long periods, scalding, light depravation, electric shocks, chepwa (pressing the thighs between iron rods or logs), nails in the flesh, hanging people upside down, and rape of women. Military officers were stationed in the southern districts and allegedly forced village headmen and others to provide local teenagers for sexual favors. According to the Coalition against Trafficking in Women Factbook on Global Sexual Exploitation (1999), in 1991, an estimated 12,000 Bhutanese women refugees fled to western Nepal as a result of sexual violence perpetrated by the Bhutanese military. The Human Rights Organization of Bhutan (HUROB), the People’s Forum for Human Rights, Bhutan (PFHRB), and the South Asia Human Rights Documentation Center (SAHRDC) published dozens of sworn statements from victims of torment and rape who escaped to refugee camps in Nepal. Human Rights Watch alleges that children were forced to commit atrocities against their families and neighbors so as to ensure that they would be stigmatized and unable to return to their communities. Bhutan is, in fact, the source of more refugees fleeing their homeland to escape persecution than almost
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Brunei Darussalam
any other country in the world. Bhutanese refugees live in seven refugee camps in Nepal, and their numbers range from 100,000 to 130,000. Several nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) offer rehabilitation services to victims of torture for those refugees. Meanwhile, the Bhutanese government has instituted a resettlement program that brings people from other parts of the country and settles them on the land formerly owned and occupied by the refugees. In essence, the government policy is a deliberate attempt to make it more complicated and difficult for refugees to return to Bhutan. By 2003, 70 percent of the land of those in exile had been resettled. Those who resettled were given cash incentives for the move. About 13 percent of the population of Bhutan, or approximately 82,000, were considered to be nonnationals and were ineligible to vote in the historic 2008 elections. A few months before the elections, on January 20, 2008, coordinated bomb blasts in Thimpu and three other locations generated political shock in Bhutan. The police suspected Nepal-based exile groups, and the previously unknown United Revolutionary Front of Bhutan claimed responsibility for the attacks. The organization expressed the grievance that the move toward democratization should be inclusive of all Bhutanese. More bomb blasts occurred in February and March 2008. Certainly, if Bhutan wants to move into a new era of democratic governance, it will need to take steps to resolve the refugee crisis and the treatment of minorities within its borders. Julie Ahmad Siddique Further Reading Giri, B. R. (2004). “Bhutan: Ethnic Policies in the Dragon Kingdom.” Asian Affairs 35: 353–364. Lamsang, Tensing. (2008, April 12). “A Decade of Crime in Bhutan.” Kuensel: http://www.kuenselonline.com/modules.php?name=News&file=arti cle&sid=10194. National Portal of Bhutan: http://www.bhutan. gov.bt/government/index_new.php. Rizal, D. (2004). “The Unknown Refugee Crisis: Expulsion of the Ethnic Lhotsampa from Bhutan.” Asian Ethnicity 5: 151–177.
|
47
Brunei Darussalam Legal System: Islamic/Common/Customary Murder: Low Prison Rate: Medium Death Penalty: No Corporal Punishment: Yes
Background During the 14th and 16th centuries, Brunei was ruled by a powerful sultanate. In 1847, the sultan concluded a treaty with Great Britain and Brunei Darussalam officially became a British protectorate in 1888. In 1906, the Residential System was established, which allowed for a system of indirect British rule or protection for Malay states. A British resident was appointed to represent the British government. He advised the sultan in all matters, with the exception of Malay customs, traditions, and religion. However, the resident had no police or army support from Britain, and no specific set of guidelines to follow, so the sultans and followers resisted change for several centuries of traditional rule. The resident’s success or failure depended on his relationship with the sultans and his Malay chiefs. In 1959, Brunei Darussalam received its own constitution and self-governance. In 1967, Sultan Haji Sir Muda Omar Ali Saifuddien, gave up his throne and his son Penigran Muda Mankota Hassanal Bolkiah became the 29th ruler of Brunei Darussalam. After giving up his throne, Omar Saifuddien became the defense minister and Brunei received full internal independence, in 1971, with the exception of defense and external affairs. Then in 1984, Brunei Darussalam gained full independence. Subsequently, the sultan became known as the prime minister, finance minister, and home affairs minister. He presided over a cabinet of 6, and this cabinet increased to 11 members in 1986. His Majesty Sultan Haji Hassanal Bolkiah remains sultan today. Located in southeastern Asia, neighboring Malaysia, Brunei Darussalam is situated on the northwest island of Borneo. Brunei Darussalam is divided into four districts, Brunei/Muara, Tutong, Belait,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
48
|
Brunei Darussalam
and Temburong. Bandar Seri Begawan is the capital of Brunei. Brunei Darussalam has a total area of 5,765 square kilometers (2,226 square miles). As of July 2008, Brunei has a total population of 381, 371. Not long after Brunei received full independence, Brunei joined the Association for Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). Many of the citizens were resistant, first to the changes that came with independence and second on becoming a member of ASEAN. Brunei went back and forth between different powers for many years. Merging with a larger entity would have ensured Brunei’s political survival; however, political groups and the monarchy wanted to keep Brunei as a separate entity. This was primarily because Brunei had become oilrich, and Brunei officials, particularly the monarch, wanted to remain in power and continue to control its oil, and wealth. With the emergence of full independence, Brunei Darussalam became the center of media attention on its National Day of celebration not only because of its extravagance as one of the richest nations, but also the spectacle of the sultan’s 1,778-room palace, which was reported to have cost $300–$500 million. With the formation of the new government, governmental responsibilities were given to other members of the sultan’s family, revealing a clear commitment to remain a ruling monarchy. With this form of government, losing touch with the population and corruption were risks. Other government officials saw an opportunity, because for the leaders it was sometimes hard to distinguish between personal and governmental funds, thus providing opportunities for corruption.
Police Established in 1921, the Royal Brunei Police Force has several departments, each with its own function. For example, the Department of Administration and Finance’s function is the administration of personnel and preparation of the Royal Brunei Police Force’s annual budget. The total workforce consists of 3,594, plus 204 civilian employees, which include gardeners, cleaners, technicians, clerical staff, and confidential secretaries. Some of the other departments include the Department of
Operation, Department of Criminal Investigation and Intelligence, Department of Logistic, Department of Traffic Investigation and Control, and the Commissioner of Police Secretariat and Public Relations. Also, under the Department of Operation, are the Immigration Department, Royal Customs and Excise, Royal Guards, Airport Police, and the Narcotic Control Bureau. Not only does Brunei have a police force of its own, but it is also affiliated with two international police forces. Those two international police forces are the Association of South East Asian Nations Police (ASEANAPOL) and International Criminal Police Organization (INTERPOL). The reason for these memberships is to maintain good international relations.
Crime Since the Special Investigation Unit was formed in 1993, it has handled 32 cases, which include murder, suspicious death, armed robbery, and arson. Fourteen of the 32 cases have been solved while the others are still under investigation. In 1997, it solved five murder cases. Although there are no signs of terrorism, the government monitors terrorist groups to prevent terrorism. A Women and Child Abuse Unit has also been set up under the Investigation unit. Its responsibilities include investigating women and child abuse, rape cases, and to prevent and suppress prostitution.
Drug Offenses According to the United Nations report on Drugs and Crime in 2001, the number of drugs entering and leaving Brunei is minor; however, there has been an increase in the number of drug-related arrests. The types of drugs have also changed over the years. In the 1990s heroin, cannabis, and cough mixture were the most dominant drugs, while methamphetamines, also called Syabu, were minor drugs. In 1997, the amount of heroin seizures was calculated at 1.35 grams, which is less than 2 grams, and had decreased to 0.0011 grams by the year 2000. Syabu seizures in 1997 amounted to 122.82 grams and increased in 2000 to 1,649.73 grams. In 2000,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Brunei Darussalam
there were 54.39 grams of cannabis seized. Most drug users arrested in 2000 were between the ages of 21 and 30 years old. The Misuse of Drugs Act Chapter 27 is the principal legislation for drug trafficking and possession. For possession of drugs of a certain amount, the penalty could be the death penalty, although there have been no executions in Brunei since 1957. In 1996, the annual prevalence of abuse, among the population of 15- to 64-yearolds, for cannabis was 0.02 percent. In 1998, it was 0.01 percent for opiates, and in 2006, it was 0.3 percent for amphetamines. Amphetamines and cannabis, in 2006, were the primary drugs of abuse among those treated for drug problems. The number of people treated in Brunei for drug problems was 57; of those, 98.2 percent were treated for amphetamine abuse and 1.8 percent were treated for cannabis, according to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime’s “2008 World Drug Report.” There are two drug rehabilitation facilities, which assist approximately 250 voluntary and involuntary residents. The names of the facilities are the Al-Islah Rehabilitation Centre and the Al Islah Intoxicating Substances Rehabilitation Centre. These facilities are under the control of the Prisons Department and the Ministry of Home Affairs. There are three ways of admission, court order, minister’s order, and voluntary order. Detoxification treatment is for a period not exceeding 14 days. After conviction by the court and release from prison or rehabilitation, an individual must be enrolled in a supervision scheme.
Crime Statistics
|
49
these news reports, crime statistics released by the Royal Brunei Police Force in 2004 were the highest since 1996; however, in 2005 there was a drop in the number of crimes reported to police and another drop again in 2006, a drop of 170 cases was calculated for the two years. Brunei has an estimated population of 381,371 people as of July 2008, and the crime ratio was 593 crime cases to 100,000 people, based on crimes recorded by police. Miscellaneous crimes dropped 21 percent during 2005 and 2006, overall crime dropped 4 percent, the rate of apprehensions and arrests dropped 3.4 percent, and fraud cases decreased by 183 percent. The crimes that showed an increase were cases of house breakins and burglaries. There was an increase of 145 break-ins and burglaries. Most of the break-ins occurred in the Brunei Muara district. Car thefts also increased by 6 percent, and out of the 169 stolen vehicles (mainly Toyota brand), 106 were recovered. The number of arrests increased by 0.05 percent in 2006, and 10.5 percent of those arrested were below the age of 18 and generally involved in thefts and burglaries. The United Nations report on drug statistics for 2001 showed a 21 percent increase in drug-related arrests, an average increase of 46.5 arrests per month to 56.4 between 1999 and 2000. The majority of drug-related arrests were male, but the number of females has increased. In 2007’s statistics, 4,519 crimes were reported. The Royal Brunei Police Force handled 3,370 of those cases. In total, there were 1,136 arrests made and 1,046 criminal cases solved.
Finding of Guilt
Crime statistics for Brunei Darussalam are hard to find because not all of the official records of crime statistics are up to date or made available. As reported by http://www.bruneiresources.com. in 2003, the total number of criminal cases was 4,075; in 2004, the number was 4,796; and in 2005, it was 2,207. For the entire time period, by far the major portion of cases reported to police were for property crime, followed by crimes against the person and drug crimes. According to news reports, crime rates in Brunei have been decreasing for many years. According to
Criminal Prosecution There are two court systems in Brunei Darussalam, a national system that deals with laws in the Constitution, and another system that deals with Islamic law. The National System is composed of three courts, the Subordinate Court, the Intermediate Court, and the Supreme Court. Most cases appear in the subordinate court, which is also called the magistrates’ court. In the intermediate court, the more serious criminal and civil matters are seen. However, the intermediate court does not handle
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
50
|
Brunei Darussalam
capital offenses. The Supreme Court includes the High Court and the Court of Appeals. This court also tries cases that carry capital sentences. The other court system is the Syariah Courts. This court coincides with the Supreme Court and only handles matters of Islamic law. Criminal prosecutions and proceedings are under the direction and control of the attorney general, who is also the public prosecutor. Occasionally, His Majesty will appoint a deputy public prosecutor who is under the direction of the public prosecutor. The police conduct investigations, and they have the power of search and seizure; however, they must document what has been seized. The owner of the property, who must be present during the search, as well as the officer, must sign the document. The officer may also question witnesses, and witnesses then write and sign their statement. The officer then reads the statement to the witness, who then signs it. These statements can be submitted as evidence in a trial. When an officer interviews a potential defendant, the officer is required to read the defendant his or her rights. Silence is not a right in Brunei Darussalam since the courts may see this as a detrimental factor for the defendant. Once a suspect is arrested, he is either placed in remand or released on bail. If remanded by the magistrate, the defendant cannot be retained for more than 15 days. If the court ordered the arrest, there is no time limit. Preliminary inquiries are held for offenses against the state, in addition to murder or any offense that carries a death sentence. The magistrate at this stage determines if there is enough evidence to submit the case to the High Court; however, drug trafficking and rape cases go straight to the High Court, while other cases are tried summarily in the magistrate court. Charges against a defendant may be dropped any time before a judgment is made, and only the prosecution can withdraw the charge. Defendants have the right to counsel, if they cannot afford counsel the court does not provide one unless it is a capital case. In noncapital cases, defendants may act as their own counsel. Defendants also have the right to a speedy trial and the right to confront their accusers. The number of judges presiding over the trial varies; it can be either one judge or a panel of judges. At the trial, the defendant is read the
charge and asked to enter a plea of either guilty or not guilty. If the plea is guilty, it is recorded, and he or she may be convicted on that plea; however, the judge makes sure the defendant know the consequences of his or her plea. If the plea is not guilty, a trial will be held and witnesses and evidence will be seen before a judge. If the defendant is found not guilty, the court appoints an acquittal. If the defendant is found guilty or has pleaded guilty, the court then sentences the defendant. Defendants are allowed to appeal. However, the appeal will be heard in the High Court. If the defendant appeals the High Court’s decision, the Court of Appeal hears the appeal. The magistrate court handles civil court proceedings, and the cases viewed involve matters between people concerning breaches of contracts and compensation. These trials are heard in public; however, the magistrate may request that the hearing be in the presence of the parties alone. The High Court cases are initiated by writ, summons, motion, or petition. In these cases, if a defendant wants to avoid a hearing, he or she may pay the court the amount of money a plaintiff claims. If the plaintiff accepts the money, notice must be given to the defendant. In High Court cases, offers to settle and summary judgments may be made.
Juvenile Offenders Originally, the age of criminal responsibility was seven years old; however, after some controversy, the law was changed to 12 years of age. The courts have limited powers when dealing with juveniles. Under the Criminal Procedure Code, the court may impose several alternative sentencing options, instead of imposing fines or imprisonment on a youthful offender. Those alternative sentencing options include: (1) discharging after admonition, (2) delivering the offender to a guardian, nearest relative, or another person who is responsible for the juvenile for a period not exceeding 12 months, (3) ordering the offender to be released on probation of good conduct on the entering into a bond, and to appear and receive judgment if and when called upon by the court, and (4) in the case of the High Court, committing the offender to custody in the detention facility of Jerudong Prison, for one to
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Brunei Darussalam
five years. Other alternatives are to inflict a fine of $1,500 on the offender’s guardian should the court consider that the guardian has contributed to the misconduct through neglect of care or other reasons. Offenders under the age of 18 may not receive the death penalty.
Punishment Some of the most common punishments in Brunei Darussalam are expulsion from the country, caning (whipping), death penalty (no longer inflicted), life imprisonment, fines, and payment of compensation. In sentencing hearings, where the death penalty may be imposed, there must be two judges present, and they both must agree with the decision. Women who are pregnant are not sentenced to the death penalty; instead, they receive life imprisonment. Life imprisonment means the defendant will spend the rest of his or her life in prison. Besides life imprisonment, prison terms can carry long sentences. Caning has been in use since 1988, and is a mandatory punishment for 42 different criminal cases. An adult who is sentenced to caning or whipping usually receives a maximum number of 24 lashings. Defendants below the age of 18 receive a maximum number of 18 lashings. Women and men above 50 years old, and those sentenced to death, are exempt from caning. Canings must be conducted in the presence of a doctor, who for medical reasons can stop the caning at any time. Offenders prefer this method to long-term punishment. Fines are assessed according to the relevant law, and if there is no relevant law, the court may decide on the appropriate amount. In addition to the punishments imposed, the court can also order the defendant to pay compensation, if he or she can afford it. If a defendant can pay the compensation amount but defaults on the payment, the result is imprisonment or additional imprisonment. Caning is used as a punishment in nearly 80 percent of criminal convictions. Under Brunei’s penal code, murder is punishable by death. Those convicted of rape are sentenced up to 30 years in prison and shall be punished with caning, as well. Those who have sexual intercourse with a woman less than 14 years of age without her consent could receive
|
51
a prison term not less than 8 years but not more than 30 years, and shall be punished with caning not less than 12 strokes. For theft, a criminal could be punished with imprisonment for a term up to three years, with a fine, or with both. Other types of theft could see up to seven years in prison. Theft that causes harm, fear of harm, or death could see as much as 15 years in prison and receive a caning. Those who commit robbery could receive as much as 30 years in prison and, with whipping, no less than 12 strokes. There are very severe penalties for illegal drug offenses. For possession of certain amounts of narcotics, there is a “mandatory” death penalty. Possession of heroin, Ecstasy, and morphine derivatives of more than 15 grams; cocaine of more than 30 grams; cannabis of more than 500 grams; Syabu or methamphetamine of more than 50 grams; or opium of more than 1.2 kilograms carries the death penalty. Possession of lesser amounts is considered minor drug possession, and charges are known to carry a 21-year sentence and/or heavy fines. There is a presumption clause, which states that anyone in possession over a certain amount of controlled drug is assumed to be trafficking. Drug trafficking of other amounts of narcotics is punishable with a minimum of 1 to 30 years in prison, and 1 to 15 strokes of whipping. Prostitution is illegal, and women who move to Brunei solely for prostitution are deported. As noted above, in Brunei, the death penalty is allowed; however, Brunei can be considered abolitionist in practice because it has not executed anyone since 1957, and is believed to have a practice of not carrying out executions. Sharia law is only applied to Muslims. Sharia law punishes individuals who commit crimes against the Islamic law; however, it does not apply to nonMuslims. It provides punishment for moral crimes such as adultery, fornication, alcohol use, as well as many other crimes. These crimes are included in a group of punishment called “hudud” crimes. These crimes are considered crimes against Allah. Under the sharia law, robbery crimes are punishable by cutting off the hand of the thief, while fornication by unmarried persons and alcohol consumption are punishable by caning. Being stoned to death is the punishment for adultery. Other crimes, such
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
52
|
Cambodia
as murder and assault, are punished severely, with murder being punished by the death penalty, and assault being punished using the “eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth” principle. Through negotiation, in an Islamic court, an individual can escape such punishments by providing compensation.
Prison Until 1998, Brunei only had one prison. The Jerudong Prison was established in 1954. This prison was built to accommodate all categories of prisoners, ranging from those sentenced to one day of prison to life terms and death penalties. The purpose of the prison is to rehabilitate offenders into law-abiding citizens, as well as protect society by holding and guarding criminals. Rehabilitative programs were established to reintegrate offenders back into society. Religious and social counseling, physical training, and vocational courses are just a few of the opportunities provided by the programs. It is mandatory that prisoners work to build ethics and discipline. The rehabilitative process uses a Progressive Stage System, which has five stages. In the first stage, a prisoner is allowed to send and receive one letter every two months and get one 15-minute visit every two months. This is for prisoners serving less than six months. In the second stage, a prisoner is allowed to send and receive one letter every two months; however, this is for prisoners serving more than a six-month sentence. With good behavior, they can be promoted to the third stage. In the third stage, the prisoner is allowed to send and receive letters every three weeks. Prisoners are also allowed to receive earnings and can have 20-minute visits every six weeks. In the fourth stage, the prisoner is allowed to send and receive one letter every two weeks and have 30-minute visits every month, but only with good behavior. In stage five, called the Special Stage, prisoners are honored with a special blue uniform. Prisoners can send one letter every month and receive unlimited amounts of letters and have a 30-minute visit every two weeks. There are no reported cases of police misconduct with prisoners, and the prisons are said to meet the minimum international standards. In 1998, a new prison was
established to accommodate the increasing numbers of prisoners. Overcrowding is not a problem in the prisons. Prisoners are allowed visits from their family, and they are allowed to bring food into the prison. The number of inmates incarcerated during 2003 was 443 prisoners. In 2005, there were 492 prisoners. The percentage of female inmates was 7.5 percent. In 2007, the United Nations Development Program reported that the total number of prisoners was 529, with only eight female prisoners. Pamela Shultz Further Reading About ASEAN. ASEAN Secretariat. Association of Southeast Asian Nations: http://www.ase ansec.org. The Government of Brunei Darussalam Official Web site: http://www.brunei.gov.bn. Laws of Brunei. Chapter 22 Penal Code. Attorney General’s Champers Web site: http://www.agc. gov.bn/LOB/PDF/Cap22.pdf. Legal Procedure in Brunei Darussalam. Legal Systems in ASEAN. ASEAN Law Association Web site: http://www.aseanlawassociation.org. Sharp, A. M. (2006). “Brunei Darussalam.” In The World Police Encyclopedia, edited by D. K. Das and M. Palmiotto, pp. 131–134. New York: Routledge.
Cambodia Legal System: Civil Murder: High Burglary: High Corruption: High Human Trafficking: Medium Prison Rate: Low Death Penalty: No Corporal Punishment: No
Background Cambodia is a small Southeast Asia nation bordered by Laos in the north, Vietnam in the east,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Cambodia
Thailand in the west, and the Gulf of Thailand in the south. During the last quarter of the 20th century, Cambodians have suffered civil war, foreign aggression, and genocide. At peace since 1998, one of the characteristics of the population, which was about 13 million in 2005 and growing at a rate of 2.4 percent per year, is its youthfulness: 60 percent are under 25 and 40 percent are less than 15 years old. Cambodia comprises 24 provinces, 84 percent of the population reside in rural areas, many subsisting on less than US$1 a day. Close to 60 percent of the remaining 16 percent of urban dwellers reside in the capital Phnom Penh. The population is 95 percent Buddhist and ethnic Khmer. For centuries the Khmer were ruled by revered god kings; most famously, during the Angkorian period, in which cultural brilliance between the 9th and 13th centuries has not been surpassed. Cambodia suffered recurring territorial and political conflicts with its Vietnamese and Thai neighbors, until the modern period when Cambodia was engulfed in the imperialist pursuits of French colonialism. In 1863, Cambodia was established as a French Protectorate, which lasted until independence in November 1953. In 1954, Cambodia became a constitutional monarchy led alternatively as king or prime minister by Prince Norodom Sihanouk. In the 1960s, Cambodia was gradually enmeshed in the civil war in neighboring Vietnam. In 1970, Sihanouk was ousted by a U.S.-supported coup led by General Lon Nol. Cambodia was declared a republic and entered a period of civil war, which was rendered even more destructive by the heavy and illegal U.S. bombing targeting Vietcong supply routes inside the country. This conflict boosted the popularity and power base of groups opposed to the Lon Nol regime, among whom the dominant groups were royalists and a revolutionary movement known as the Khmer Rouge led by Pol Pot. In 1975, the Khmer Rouge (KR) defeated the republican army and entered Phnom Penh. Once in power, the KR emptied the cities, and established a Chinese-backed utopian regime of agrarian revolutionary terror, which killed (through starvation and murder) close to 3 million people and ended in 1979 with a military occupation by the Vietnamese. The
|
53
Vietnamese army of occupation installed a socialist regime called the People’s Republic of Kampuchea (PRK), led successively and briefly by a number of former KR defectors, and six years later by Hun Sen, himself a former KR defector. In 1989, when Vietnam withdrew its troops from Cambodia, the regime was renamed the State of Cambodia (SOC). In 1979, a second civil war (with strong nationalist anti-Vietnamese overtones) commenced. The combatants comprised PRK/SOC forces supported by Vietnam and the Soviet Union on one side, and KR and royalists forces supported by the United States and China on the other. In 1991, a United Nations intervention resulted in a peace settlement known as the Paris Accords and the establishment of the United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia (UNTAC). In 1993, UNTAC oversaw the adoption of the present constitution and implementation of the first free elections. The royalist party (FUNCIPEC) won a majority but, in the hope of preserving a fragile peace between former warring factions, was forced into an inherently unstable governmental alliance (a joint prime ministership) with the Cambodian People’s Party (CPP) led by Hun Sen. This precarious peace was indeed seriously threatened by armed clashes between the CPP and royalist forces in 1997, which led to a significant number of casualties and the end of the co-prime ministership with the defeat of the royalists’ military capability. After the second elections of 1998, the CPP/FUNCIPEC governmental alliance was eventually reinstated, but with a greatly weakened FUNCIPEC. However, this arrangement was accompanied by continued periods of political uncertainty and violence. Remaining pockets of KR resistance ended in 1998, which also coincided with the death of Pol Pot. Efforts to bring to justice the leaders of the KR responsible for the genocide and atrocities of the revolutionary period have been long delayed by a government reluctant to disturb pragmatic arrangements that encouraged defections from the KR. At the time of writing, a tribunal of Cambodian and international jurists is leading a trial against the few remaining aging leaders of the KR. After four rounds of national elections in 1993, 1998, 2003,
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
54
|
Cambodia
and 2008, the CPP has consolidated its dominance over government, and its leader, Prime Minister Hun Sen, has steadily increased his grip on power.
History of the Legal System Before the Protectorate, the Cambodian legal system was essentially a customary law system with widespread use of mediation and reparation to settle local disputes and crime. During the Protectorate, an official legal system patterned after the laws and courts of France was imposed (hence inquisitorial in relation to the criminal law). After the Protectorate and until 1975, the official legal system and informal practices in use during the Protectorate were maintained. The Khmer Rouge regime of terror (1975–1979) destroyed the legal system, judicial officials were murdered, and traditional informal mediation practices were undermined. During the PRK/SOC regime (1979–1991), a Soviet-style legal system was imported from Vietnam and staffed according to political allegiance rather than expertise in the field of law and criminal justice. Many police were trained in Vietnam and Russia and focused mostly on internal security and intelligence rather than on law and order and crime control. Regarded as a security agency of the government with minimal commitment to civilian peacekeeping, the police and the whole criminal justice system (CJS) had a very low standing in the community. Recourse to the formal justice system was rare as people continued to use traditional mediation and resolution to deal with crimes and conflicts at the commune and village level. While a court system, styled as People’s Revolutionary Courts, had been re-established in May 1980 and formalized by the enactment of the Constitution of June 1981, judges and prosecutors were generally unqualified, poorly educated, and subject to military control. There was no independent appellate body. Any review of verdicts and sentences pronounced by the courts was thus in the hands of the executive branch. Further developments, such as the enactment of the Law Concerning the Organization of the Courts and Prosecutors and the establishment of the Institute of Public Administration and Law (IPAL) in 1982, the People’s Supreme Court in
1985, or even the new SOC Constitution in 1989, did not bring any significant changes to the system and its standing in the community. Since the Paris Accords in 1991, the official system has remained inquisitorial and is primarily based on a civil law mixture of French-influenced codes from the period of UNTAC, royal decrees, and acts of the legislature, with influences of customary law and remnants of communist legal theory. However, most cases continue to be dealt with informally at the village or commune level. In addition to a new constitution, 2007 saw the passage of the Law on Criminal Procedure, which defines the roles and functions of the police, courts, and prisons. Agencies in the Cambodian CJS include the Ministry of Interior (MOI), the National Police Department, the Gendarmerie Militaire, and the Department of Prisons. The Ministry of Justice (MOJ) is responsible for the court system, and the Supreme Council of Magistracy for the management of judges and prosecutors. Some international donors such as the Australian government (AusAID) have focused their aid on rebuilding a legitimate Cambodian CJS. However, in spite of several years of ongoing assistance, many Cambodian people continue to regard the current CJS as having little legitimacy, because in the three branches of the system (police, judiciary, and corrections), regime capture (lack of independence) and corruption is endemic.
Role of Police The Cambodian Police comprises the Gendarmerie and the Cambodian National Police (CNP). The Gendarmerie is primarily a military police force and does not have the rural policing function that it generally plays in France and francophone countries. However, in its 2007 reports, the Cambodia Criminal Justice Assistance Project (CCJAP) noted the overlapping of functions between the CNP and the Gendarmerie: the latter has become increasingly visible deploying to district level in rural areas as well as in towns and cities, performing “national security” roles. The new Criminal Procedure Law provides the Gendarmerie with the same powers of arrest held by
© 2011 ABC-Clio. All Rights Reserved.
Cambodia
the judicial police, although such powers have long been exercised by them under the general provision for arrest in the UNTAC penal code. The structure of the Cambodian National Police includes a number of central departments such as Traffic, Training, Scientific and Technical, Human Trafficking and Child Protection, Public Order Police, Border Police, Security Police, and judicial police. In all provinces the CNP structure is replicated at the various administrative strata down to the commune level (Police Post). However, the provincial commissioners must comply with the national policies and procedures laid down by the MOI, which is responsible for salaries and operating expenses but takes direction from the deputy governor (who, in theory but rarely in practice, is responsible for infrastructure and other resources) about provincial policing priorities. The role of the judicial police and its Central Department of Criminal Police is similar to the role performed by traditional policing agencies in many other countries (i.e., mediation, complaint handling, investigation, and arrests). One of the functions of the Scientific and Technical Office, under the control of the judicial police, is to record and classify reported crimes as well as offenders and fingerprints. According to the law, the judicial police can also act as prosecutors and are often appointed to conduct investigations, but in this role they have limited powers of arrest and must seek authority from a prosecutor. As in most inquisitorial systems, the investigating judge appointed to the case can conduct further inquiries. However, CCJAP points out that poor training of the police force and the judiciary often prevents the proper application of and compliance with the laws of Cambodia. For instance, many police interrogations end up in confessions with little supporting evidence. As part of its regular monitoring of prison conditions in Cambodia, the Cambodian League for the Promotion and Defense of Human Rights (LICADHO) conducted interviews with prisoners in 18 prisons, and found that from 1999 to 2006 between 450 and 163 inmates had been tortured in police custody. However, it is worth noting that in 1999 reports of torture in police custody represented 13.7 percent of the population of the
|
55
surveyed prisons but that they have steadily fallen to represent only 1.8 percent by 2006. Other problems reported by CCJAP, affecting the CNP in general and the judicial police in particular, are poor management and supervision and lack of strategic planning and equipment: According to CCJAP, the creation of the Offices of Human Trafficking and Child Protection under the responsibility of the judicial police is a positive response, but its effectiveness is impaired by a “lack of proper definition of function, staffing requirements, training requirements, and a plan for how these Offices will actually function.” Decades of conflicts have resulted in an overstaffed National Police Department, which was used to absorb demobilized military personnel with little sense of their civilian mission and the provision of services to the community. This contributes to a widespread feeling of mistrust, reflected, for instance, in the very low reporting rates of criminal victimization to the police. Given the level of corruption in the police and in most other institutions, there is also cynicism about impartiality and fair treatment by such agencies. For instance, it is not rare for the judicial police to seek between 20–50 percent of the cost of a stolen motorbike up front before they begin an investigation. While streetlevel police corruption of this kind has generally decreased between 2000 and 2007, in many locations public cynicism about police corruption has grown despite reduc