Counterterrorist Detection Techniques
of Explosives
This page intentionally left blank
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques
of Explosives
Edited by
Jehuda Yinon Department of Environmental Science,
Weizmann Institute of Science,
Rehovot, Israel
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford • Paris
San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sydney • Tokyo
Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK First edition 2007 Copyright © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-444-52204-7 For information on all Elsevier publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com Printed and bound in The Netherlands 07 08 09 10 11
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Working together to grow libraries in developing countries www.elsevier.com | www.bookaid.org | www.sabre.org
To Bracha, the love of my life
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Introduction
ix
About the Editor
xi
Contributors
xiii
1 Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
1
Ana M. Jimenez and Maria J. Navas
2 Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
41
Jehuda Yinon
3 Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
61
Gary A. Eiceman, Hartwig Schmidt and Avi A. Cagan
4 Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
91
Joseph Wang
5 Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
109
Larry Senesac and Thomas Thundat
6 Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives
131
Richard C. Lanza
7 Nuclear Quadrupole Resonance Detection of Explosives
157
Joel B. Miller
8 X-ray Diffraction Imaging for Explosives Detection
199
Geoffrey Harding and Adrian Harding
9 Detection of Explosives by Millimeter-wave Imaging
237
David M. Sheen, Douglas L. McMakin and Thomas E. Hall
10 Laser-based Detection Methods of Explosives
279
Chase A. Munson, Jennifer L. Gottfried, Frank C. De Lucia, Jr., Kevin L. McNesby and Andrzej W. Miziolek
11 Detection of Explosives by Terahertz Imaging John F. Federici, Dale Gary, Robert Barat and Zoi-Heleni Michalopoulou vii
323
viii
Contents
12. Explosives Detection Personnel Portals
367
Kevin L. Linker
13. Biological Detection of Explosives
395
Ross J. Harper and Kenneth G. Furton
Index
433
Introduction
In the battle against terrorism, the detection of hidden explosives has become an issue of upmost importance. While terrorism is not new to the international community, terrorist attacks during the last years, such as the attack on the twin towers in New York on September 11, 2001, the Bali bombing in 2002, the train bombing in Madrid 2004, and the London subway and bus bombings in 2005, have brought the issue of detection of explosives to a high priority and have generated a great demand for rapid, sensitive, and reliable methods for detecting hidden explosives. In Israel, a series of suicide bombers’ attacks in buses, nightclubs, markets, and restaurants has shown the need for detecting explosives from a distance. However, several attempts, such as Richard Reid’s shoe bomb in 2001 and the London plot involving liquid explosives in 2006, were prevented. The various bombings as well as the bombing attempts show the ingenuity and versatility of the various terrorist organizations. These result in major challenges to the scientific community who has to design and apply security screening technologies including new sensors and detecting devices which will prevent the smuggling of bombs and explosives in airports, train and bus stations, federal buildings, mail storerooms, etc. The purpose of this book is to assemble in one volume a series of detection technolo gies of explosives, written by a group of scientists who are experts in each one of these technologies. It contains techniques that are already in use as well as techniques that are in advanced stages of development. Each technique is described in detail, including its principles of operation, as well as its applications in the detection of explosives. The book includes several chapters on vapor and trace detection: chemiluminescence, mass spectrometry, ion mobility spectrometry, electrochemical methods, and micro mechanical sensors, such as microcantilevers. Other chapters deal with bulk detection techniques: neutron techniques, nuclear quadrupole resonance, X-ray diffraction imag ing, millimeter-wave imaging, terahertz imaging, and laser techniques. Special chapters are devoted to personnel portals and to biological detection. The purpose of this book is to be a reference volume for scientists and engineers in universities, research institutes, and industry involved in research and development of explosives detection techniques, as well as a textbook for graduate students in the natural sciences and in engineering. ix
x
Introduction
Finally, I thank the contributing authors who have made the publication of this book possible. Many thanks are due to authors and publishers for permission to reproduce copyrighted material. Jehuda Yinon
About the Editor
Dr. Yinon received his B.Sc. and M.Sc. degrees in electrical engineering from the Technion, Israel Institute of Technology (Haifa, Israel) and his Ph.D. in chemistry from the Weizmann Institute of Science (Rehovot, Israel). Dr. Yinon conducted research, as a senior research fellow, at the Weizmann Institute of Science for over 35 years. He was a research associate (1971–1973) and a senior research associate (1976–1977) at Caltech’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory (Pasadena, California) and spent sabbatical leaves as a visiting scientist at the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (Research Triangle Park, North Carolina) (1980–1981), the EPA Envi ronmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory (Las Vegas, Nevada) (1988–1989), and the University of Florida (Gainesville, Florida) (1993–1994). His last appointment in the U.S., before returning to Israel, was as visiting professor and assistant director at UCF’s National Center for Forensic Science (Orlando, Florida) (2000–2003). Dr. Yinon’s main activities involve applications of novel analytical techniques for the detection and analysis of hidden explosives. Dr. Yinon has authored, co-authored, and edited nine books and published over 100 papers in the scientific literature. He is a member of the editorial boards of several scientific journals, is a member of the NATO Advisory Explosives Detection Working Group, and serves as chairman of the International Committee for Symposia on Analysis and Detection of Explosives. Dr. Yinon is currently an independent consultant on detection and analysis of explo sives. He lives in Rehovot, Israel, where his consulting office is located.
xi
This page intentionally left blank
Contributors
Robert Barat Otto York Department of Chemical Engineering New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, NJ 07102, USA
Dale Gary Department of Physics New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, NJ 07102, USA Jennifer L. Gottfried US Army Research Laboratory
AMSRD-ARL-WM-BD
Aberdeen Proving Ground,
MD 21005, USA
Avi A. Cagan Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry New Mexico State University Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA
Thomas E. Hall Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Richland, WA 99354, USA
Frank C. DeLucia, Jr. US Army Research Laboratory AMSRD-ARL-WM-BD Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005, USA
Geoffrey Harding GE Security Germany
D-22453 Hamburg, Germany
Gary A. Eiceman Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry New Mexico State University Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA
Ross J. Harper Nomadics Inc., ICx Nomadics Inc. Stillwater, OK 74074, USA Ana M. Jimenez Department of Analytical Chemistry Faculty of Pharmacy University of Seville 41012 Seville, Spain
John F. Federici Department of Physics New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, NJ 07102, USA Kenneth G. Furton Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry International Forensic Research Institute Florida International University Miami, FL 33199, USA
Richard C. Lanza Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, MA 02139, USA xiii
xiv
Kevin L. Linker Contraband Detection Technologies Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque, NM 87185, USA Douglas L. McMakin Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Richland, WA 99354, USA Kevin L. McNesby US Army Research Laboratory AMSRD-ARL-WM-BD Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005, USA Zoi-Heleni Michalopoulou Department of Mathematical Sciences New Jersey Institute of Technology Newark, NJ 07102, USA Joel B. Miller Chemistry Division, Code 6120 Naval Research Laboratory Washington, DC 20375, USA Andrzej W. Miziolek US Army Research Laboratory AMSRD-ARL-WM-BD Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005, USA Chase A. Munson US Army Research Laboratory AMSRD-ARL-WM-BD Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005, USA
Contributors
Maria J. Navas Department of Analytical Chemistry Faculty of Pharmacy University of Seville 41012 Seville, Spain Hartwig Schmidt Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry New Mexico State University Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA Larry Senesac Nanoscale Science and Devices Group Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge, TN 37831, USA David M. Sheen Pacific Northwest National Laboratory Richland, WA 99354, USA Thomas Thundat Nanoscale Science and Devices Group Oak Ridge National Laboratory Oak Ridge, TN 37831, USA Joseph Wang Biodesign Institute
Arizona State University
Tempe, AZ 85287, USA
Jehuda Yinon Department of Environmental Science Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot 76100, Israel
Chapter 1
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
Ana M. Jimenez and Maria J. Navas Department of Analytical Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Seville, 41012 Seville, Spain
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. 1
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
2. Chemiluminescence systems in explosive analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
8
3. Using chemiluminescence as detection technology in security . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
36
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37
2
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
3
1. Introduction The aim of this chapter is to explore the real and potential advantages of chemilu minescence (CL)-based trace detection systems for the detection of a broad group of explosives containing nitrogen. The literature reviewed covers about 25 years of research and advances in the use of CL for detecting explosives, from the 1980s to May 2006. Because the earliest papers in the 1970s and 1980s comprehensively describe how these techniques operate, we have used them to provide concepts and general information. The literature has been summarized to provide a contemporary understanding not only of the potential of CL systems but also of their implementation in many laboratories for the detection of trace explosives. The chapter has been structured into several sections: first, there is a brief introduction, including a description of the concept and general principles of CL and how it is used in the field of explosives. The second section describes CL applications in the field of explosives and focuses in particular on the thermal energy analyser (TEA) because of its important role in the trace detection of explosives. The recent applications of luminol CL and electrochemiluminescence (ECL) to explosive detection are also described. Finally, because much of the research into explosive detectors has been directed towards civilian safety, a third section describes how CL is used as a security measure to detect explosives.
1.1. Principles of chemiluminescence Energy can be transferred into (and out of) matter in many different ways, as heat and light or by chemical reactions. When energy is released by matter in the form of light, it is referred to as luminescence. An exception is usually made for matter that has such a high temperature that it simply glows; this is called incandescence. When energy in the form of light is released from matter because of a chemical reaction, the process is called CL [1]. CL is the generation of electromagnetic radiation (ultraviolet, visible or infrared) as light by the production of an electronically excited species from a number of reactants which goes on to release light in order to revert to its ground state energy. While the light can, in principle, be emitted in the ultraviolet, visible or infrared region, reactions emitting visible light are the most common. They are also the most interesting and useful. When the chemiluminogenic reaction occurs within living organisms, the phenomenon is named bioluminescence. CL in analytical chemistry has numerous advantages, such as superior sensitivity, safety, rapid and simple assay and controllable emission rate. However, it also has such disadvantages as poor reproducibility and long observation times. The CL process takes place at the rate of a chemical reaction, and the factors that affect emission intensity are in fact a combination of chemical reaction rate and luminescence considerations. A CL reagent may yield significant emission not just for one unique analyte, CL emission intensities are sensitive to a variety of environmental factors such as temperature, solvent, ionic strength, pH and other species present in the
4
Jimenez and Navas
system, and the emission intensity from a CL reaction varies with time [2]. Today, many chemiluminescent systems are known, both biological and non-biological. Numerous inorganic and organic chemical reactions produce light because one of the reaction products is formed in an electronically excited state and emits the radiation on falling to the ground state. A general description of the reactions is as follows: A + B � C∗ + D C∗ � C + light where ‘∗ ’ indicates an electronically excited state [3]. This would be a rather simple case and would be classified as direct CL. In many systems, the initially excited state molecule is used as a conduit of energy to excite a second or third molecule that is the actual emitting species. When energy is transferred to an effective fluorophore (F) added to the system, the luminescence intensity increases considerably. C∗ + F � C + F ∗ F∗ � F + light This would be classified as indirect, sensitized or energy transfer CL. Nowadays, CL methods are a real alternative in analytical fields, and the applications that determine a wide variety of compounds have been extensively discussed in the literature.
1.2. Using CL to reveal the presence of explosives Explosive detection techniques can be broadly classified into two main categories: bulk detection and trace detection. CL is commonly regarded as a trace detection technology. Trace detection involves the chemical detection of explosives by collecting and analysing tiny amounts of explosive vapour or particles (a microscopic amount of explosives) [4] and looking for residue or contamination from handling or being in proximity to explosive materials. Microscopic particles of solid explosive materials can adhere to a wide variety of surfaces (Teflon, glass, metal, plastic, etc.), and they can be detected by wiping the surface. Vapour detectors examine the vapour emanating from a liquid or a solid explosive, and because some explosives have a low vapour pressure, these detection techniques would be very sensitive. Nitrogen-explosive compounds usually analysed by CL may be classified under three structural categories: (i) nitroaromatic compounds, (ii) nitrate esters and (iii) nitramines. Examples of nitro-substituted hydrocarbons are nitromethane, trinitrobenzene (TNB), trinitrotoluene (TNT) and pentantiroaniline. Nitroglycerine (NG), ethylene glycol dini trate (EGDN) and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) are nitrate esters [5]. The nitroexplosive compounds that are the result of the presence of nitro and nitrate groups can
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
5
be detected by CL methods, as we shall describe below (Section 2). A list of the most widely used nitrogen-containing explosives commonly determined by CL is given in Table 1. As explosives are usually referred to with an abbreviation, the Table gives both the compound name and the abbreviation. Figure 1 gives the structures of nitroaromatic and nitramine explosives commonly determined by CL. Reviews and other papers (e.g. official reports or guides about instrumentation designed for explosive detection) describe CL as a reliable trace detection system for nitro explosives [4,6–13]. In a recent review, Moore [12] pointed out that vapour or particle detection systems are best suited for personnel monitoring. He has also stated how difficult it is to detect explosives, among other reasons, because of the low vapour pressure of most common explosives, vanishingly small in the case of the highest prior ity explosives, the attenuation of vapour by packaging or the thermal degradation of the material when the temperature is raised to achieve higher vapour pressure. Therefore, methods that relay on sampling of air spaces need to either sample very large volumes or have exceedingly small detection limits. Fine et al. [14] have pointed out that an ideal technique for ultra-trace analysis of explosives would be both simple and rapid, require minimal sample clean-up, be sensitive to as little as 1–10 pg quantities of all the compounds of interest and would work equally well both on complex samples from the real world and on high-grade laboratory standards made up in pure solvents. CL systems have many of the aforementioned qualities, and so it is one of the more commonly used techniques for detecting explosives [7]. Nevertheless, the use of CL for detecting explosives does have some drawbacks although some of them can be overlooked. First, it is limited to nitrogen-containing explosives. This does not reduce its usefulness too much because most major explosives are nitrogen compounds although it clearly makes it impossible to use CL to detect some types of explosives, such as peroxide explosives, that have become particularly important in forensic investigations because of the emergence of terrorist threats and crimes in which these explosives have been used [15]. The second disadvantage has to do with selectivity: CL per se is not capable of identifying what type of explosive molecule is present because several compounds, including those commonly used as taggants in plastic explosives, also contain NO2 groups. This lack of selectivity inherent to most CL methods can be overcome by coupling CL with separation techniques. CL explosive detection technologies are usually fitted with a front-end gas chromatograph column. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) or supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) has been less used. The use of separation methods is also recommended because explosive residues usually have to be determined in complex matrices. CL technology is a real alternative in trace explosive detection. It has excellent sensitivity and selectivity when combined with high-speed gas chromatography (GC). A wide range of explosives is detectable, including EGDN, NG, ammonium nitrate fuel oil (ANFO), TNT, dinitrotoluene (DNT), cyclotrimethylene trinitramine (RDX) and PETN. The detector does not require a radioactive source, and this can reduce both time and paperwork when transporting the system [16]. Commercial systems, easily hand-held or portable, are available and being used as security systems in different kinds
6
Table 1. List of common nitrogen-containing explosives analysed by chemiluminescence Abbreviation
Chemical formula
Class
CAS no.
Vapor pressure (High, moderate or low)
Cyclotrimethylene trinitramine Cyclotetramethylene tetranitramine 2-Nitrotoluene 3-Nitrotoluene 4-Nitrotoluene 2,3-Dinitrotoluene 2,4-Dinitrotoluene 2,5-Dinitrotoluene 2,6-Dinitrotoluene 2,4,6Trinitrotoluene Nitroglycerine
RDX
C3 H6 N6 O6
Nitramine
121-82-4
Low
HMX
C4 H8 N8 O8
Nitramine
2691-41-0
Low
2-NT 3-NT 4-NT 2,3-DNT 2,4-DNT 2,5-DNT 2,6-DNT TNT
C7 H7 NO2 C7 H7 NO2 C7 H7 NO2 C7 H6 N2 O4 C7 H6 N2 O4 C7 H6 N2 O4 C7 H6 N2 O4 C7 H5 N3 O6
Nitraromatic Nitraromatic Nitraromatic Nitroaromatic Nitroaromatic Nitroaromatic Nitroaromatic Nitroaromatic
88-72-2 99-08-1 99-99-0 602-01-7 121-14-2 619-15-8 606-20-2 118-96-7
High High High High High High Low Moderate–low
NG
C3 H5 N3 O9 / CH2 ONO2 -CH ONO2 -CH2 ONO2 C5 H8 N4 O12 / CCH2 ONO2 4 C2 H4 N2 O6 / NO2 -OCH2 CH2 O-NO2
Nitrate ester
55-63-0
High
Nitrate ester
78-11-5
Low
Nitrate ester
628-96-6
High
Pentaerythritol tetranitrate Ethylene glycol dinitrate
PETN EGDN
Jimenez and Navas
Compound name
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
7
CH3
CH3
CH3 NO2
NO2
NO2
3-NT
2-NT
4-NT CH3
CH3
CH3 NO2
NO2
NO2
NO2
O2N
NO2 2,3-DNT
2,5-DNT
2,4-DNT CH3
CH3
CH3
O2N
NO2
NO2
O2N
NO2 NO2
NO2
3,4-DNT
2,6-DNT
TNT NO2 O2N
O2N N
N
NO2
N N N
N NO2 RDX
N
NO2
NO2 HMX
Fig. 1. Structures of nitroaromatic and nitramine explosives commonly determined by chemiluminescence. DNT, dinitrotoluene; HMX, cyclotertamethylene tetranitramine; NT, nitrotoluene; RDX, cyclotrimethylene trinitramine; TNT, trinitrotoluene.
of installations, such as in airports or forensic laboratories. A considerable number of papers have reported the application of luminol CL, anyway ECL and immunoassay (IM) techniques for explosive detection. Nevertheless, most of these papers deal with the CL reaction of the nitrosyl (NO) radical with ozone and the use of the TEA manufactured by Thermo Electron Corporation (Waltham, MA, USA). Section 2 deals with NO–ozone
8
Jimenez and Navas
CL (TEA), luminol CL and ECL detection systems in their applications to the trace detection of explosives and briefly summarizes the reactions and mechanisms involved.
2. Chemiluminescence systems in explosive analysis 2.1. Thermal energy analyser Thermal energy analyser is a gas-phase CL detector that responds specifically to nitrogen compounds. Most common explosive materials contain nitrogen in the form of either nitro or nitrate groups that pyrolyse to produce NO or NOx, which is the main reason why CL can be applied. TEA was developed by Fine and coworkers [17,18], and at first, it was mainly used for the detection of N -nitrosamines in complex matrices or analytes of medical interest, such as vasodilators and their metabolites in human blood [19]. In these fields, the development of the CL-specific nitrogen detector during the 1970s was a major advance. Although the TEA detector can be used with both gas and HPLC in explosive detection, most applications couple TEA to GC, and the earliest references to it being used with explosives that appeared during the 1980s [20–24]. TEA is described [23] as a very useful chromatographic detector for the forensic trace analysis of explosives. Its high sensitivity and selectivity for nitro compounds allow the rapid screening of contaminated extracts for traces of explosives, the majority of which contain nitro groups, with the minimum likelihood of false-positive results. A detailed description of the detector and the physical principles of its operation can be found in the literature [25–27]. 2.1.1. Analytical considerations 2.1.1.1. The chemiluminescence reaction The fundamental operating principle of TEA is based on the CL reaction between nitric oxide and ozone, which can be schematized as follows [28]: NO + O3 → NO2 ∗ + O2 NO2 ∗ → NO2 + h The nitric oxide reacts with ozone to produce an electronically excited specie NO2 ∗ that decays back to its ground state emitting light in the infrared spectral region (600–2800 nm). 2.1.1.2. Mode of operation The earliest references above mentioned (Subsection 2.1) describe the fundamental oper ating principle of the TEA, which can be briefly summarized as follows: the components of interest eluting from the chromatograph are introduced into a catalytic pyrolyser where NO2 is released from organic nitro compounds and simultaneously converted into a
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
9
Vacuum pump
NO2,O2
Sample
Pyrolyser 300°C
NO.
O3 Ozone Light filter
Light detector and display Fig. 2. Simplified schematic of the thermal energy analyser. Reprinted from Fine et al. [25]. Copyright (1975), with permission from Elsevier.
NO radical by the catalytic surface. The gaseous pyrolysis products are swept by a carrier gas from the pyrolyser through a cold trap (−100 or −150 C) or a solid sorbent device where most contaminants are condensed, but NO radicals survive. The ozone reaction generally takes place at reduced pressure in a reaction chamber where the NO radical is oxidized by ozone to form the electronically excited species NO2 ∗ that is detected by an appropriate photomultiplier tube (PMT). This operating principle produces peaks only for substances containing nitro or nitroso groups. Because the intensity of light from the chemiluminescent reaction can be increased at reduced pressure, a vacuum pump is always used. A red cut-off filter is used to eliminate light emission resulting from potential interferences. A schematic diagram of the TEA is shown in Fig. 2. One nice feature of CL detectors is that they do not use a radioactive ionization source [29] and thus avoid some of the paperwork and regulatory oversight that may be associated with ion mobility spectrometer detectors. 2.1.1.3. Sampling and preparation of the samples The papers reviewed show that the general procedure for collecting organic explosive residues from surfaces includes cotton swabs or vacuum onto a filter. Owing to the complexity of the samples (debris from the scene of an explosion, contaminated soil, etc.) and/or the need for pre-concentration, samples often require pre-treatment, which eliminates possible interfering substances. So the literature reviewed also contains reports on such sampling methodologies as solid-phase extraction (SPE) or supercritical fluid extraction (SFE), which describe how they are used to isolate explosives in combination with chromatographic techniques. A common procedure for taking samples consists of using solvent-moistened cotton wool swabs. The same solvents are then often used to extract the explosive residues from
10
Jimenez and Navas
the soaked cotton swab. Acetone is one of the most commonly used solvents because explosive compounds dissolve easily in it; however, the drawback is that it also dissolves other non-desirable compounds. Douse used a dynamic headspace method to improve the clean-up of gunshot residues before detecting NG by capillary column GC–TEA [30]. Handswabs and vacuumed clothing samples were generated and placed in a luer lock glass syringe fitted. Syringes containing filters with residues were then inserted in a headspace apparatus. A column containing Amberlite XAD-7 beads was eluted in the following sequence: (i) pentane to elute nitrobenzene (NB) and 4-nitrotoluene (4-NT); (ii) pentane-methyl-tert-butyl ether (pentane-MTBE) to elute unwanted coextractives and (iii) ethyl acetate to elute NG and other explosives. The syringe containing residual material was clamped vertically, and MBTE was passed through it. The solution was passed through a glass column containing XAD-7 beads. Explosives were eluted with ethyl acetate, and this fraction was evaporated under a stream of nitrogen. NG and other explosives were detected by GC–TEA. Thompson et al. [31] compared the aqueous recovery and acetone extraction from cotton swabs of organic explosive residue, which was generated by mixing standards in motor oil on aluminium foil, by detonating four different bombs hidden inside suitcases filled with clothing and by handling plastic explosives. The explosives were isolated by SPE, using a poly-N -vinylpyrrolidone-divinyl-benzene sorbent. Samples were screened by liquid chromatography-ultraviolet (LC-UV), and the presence of explosives was confirmed by LC– or GC–mass spectrometry (MS) and fast GC–TEA (EGIS). The authors concluded that the water extraction/SPE procedure was an effective process for treating organic explosive residue on cotton swabs for subsequent analysis by LC. Kolla [32] used SPE and GC–TEA to prepare and analyse samples of explosives and found that SPE was the most useful way of reducing the contamination of the column by accompanying substances. The SPE columns were 500-mg RP18 (3 cm) columns. The original sample, whether dust or swabs, was extracted with acetone in a Soxhlet extractor. The acetone was then evaporated and the sample dissolved in acetone and diluted at 1:10 with water. After washing, the elution was performed with three volumes of methanol. After the methanol had been evaporated, the sample was dissolved in a small volume of acetone for GC–TEA. The effectiveness of using SFE coupled to GC with a thermal desorption modulator (TDM) interface and TEA detection to analyse explosives has been evaluated by Francis et al. [33] in soil samples and standards. 2.1.1.4. Pyrolyser In the analysis of nitroaromatic explosives, TEA is similar to the systems used for nitrosamines except for the fact that temperatures must be higher. Several papers have reported that the temperature of the TEA pyrolysis furnace can affect the selectivity of the detector. A study carried out by Douse [34] to detect traces of several explosives at the low nanogram level revealed that the chromatograms obtained by GC–TEA for both pure compounds and spiked handswabs clearly showed the superior selectivity of TEA in reducing the temperature from 800 to 700 C. Reduction from 700 to 550 C further
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
11
demonstrated the selectivity of TEA, but this was offset by a partial loss of response for all explosives. It was found, however, that the selectivity of TEA using a pyrolysis of 550 C was such that as much as 13% of the sample could be analysed with little effect on the background. On the contrary, from the literature reviewed, it can be seen that, for nitroaromatic compounds, the release of nitric oxide was maximum between 800 and 950 C (though even 1000 C has been reported) [21]. Lafleur and Mills [20] studied the pyrolytic release of nitric oxide (produced from a series of NTs) as a function of temperature. The response was maximum at temperatures above 800 C and decreased by almost three orders of magnitude at temperatures below 500 C. They finally selected a temperature of 900 C to ensure maximum thermal decomposition and thus maximum release of nitric oxide. The relative response was highly reproducible, and the release of nitric oxide was, therefore, also reproducible but not necessarily molar; that is, one nitro group did not necessarily yield one molecule of nitric oxide. Relative molar response ranged from 0.59 (2-NT) to 2.25 (2,4,6-TNT). A pyrolysis temperature of 950 C was chosen by Phillips et al. [35] to determine nitroaromatics, NB, 2,4-DNT and 2,6-DNT in biosludges by GC/TEA. Selavka et al. [36] have reported that for LC, a pyrolysis chamber temperature greater than 550 C gives rise to substantial baseline noise, which severely limits the detector’s sensitivity and selectivity. Thus, LC–TEA is always performed in the ‘nitroso mode’ (the pyrolyser is held at 550 C). 2.1.1.5. Selectivity The use of a selective detection system is of primordial importance in reducing or eliminating interference in the signal of the analytes of interest. In this respect, TEA coupled to chromatographic techniques is one of the most selective devices. When TEA is used, the analytical signal is not affected by compounds without nitro functional groups, which may be in the sample. Fine et al. [14,26] have suggested that four factors are responsible for TEA’s high degree of selectivity. First, only compounds that have NO2 or NO functional groups can give a response. Second, the reactive species must survive the −100 C cold trap. For highly contaminated samples, this temperature can even be −160 C. At these temperatures, the vapour pressure of the NO radical is greater than 1 atm, whereas the vapour pressure of almost all organic compounds is substantially less. Third, the reactive species must react with ozone to produce a chemiluminescent light in a narrow range between 600 and 800 nm. Fourth, the reaction with ozone must be sufficiently rapid to take place during the residence time of the species in the reaction chamber. Phillips et al. [35] have compared the TEA results with those of other selective GC detectors (thermionic specific, electron capture and Hall electrolytic conductivity) to analyse nitroaromatics in biosludges. The chromatograms obtained from spiked extracts with the other detectors all contained many interfering compounds that eluted at retention times close to the nitroaromatics, which made it necessary to modify the sample workup so that the samples were amenable to the different selective detectors. They found that the selectivity of the TEA made sample clean-up unnecessary and solved all the problems of the solvent effects.
12
Jimenez and Navas
The Guide for the Identification of Intact Explosives from The Technical Working Group on Fire and Explosion (TWGFEX) of the National Center of Forensic Science [37] classified the analytical techniques into four categories, and GC–TEA and LC–TEA were in the category that provides a high degree of selectivity. 2.1.1.6. Sensitivity Traces of explosives are commonly present in very low levels in samples that are analysed, so it is important to take sensitivity into account when designing detectors for explosive detection. As a rough ‘rule of thumb’, Nambayah and Quickenden [38] reported that a method suitable for direct explosive vapour detection should be able to detect explosive concentrations at less than 1 ng/L. They made an exhaustive study of the lowest experimental detection limits achieved with various analytical techniques reported in the literature on traces of explosive, and they informed that headspace GCelectron capture detector (ECD) followed by immunosensor techniques achieves the lowest detection limits (from 0.07 to 20 ng/L). The literature reviewed shows that GC/TEA methods can be extremely sensitive and respond to a few picograms of common explosives. Fine et al. [14] using GC/TEA (capillary columns) found that the minimum detectable level at a signal-to-noise ratio of 3:1 is estimated to be 4 pg for TNT and RDX; 5 pg for EGDN, NG and DNT; and 25 pg for tetryl when they determined explosives in ‘real world’ samples without previous clean-up. Although the reported sensitivity of TEA when it is used in combination with HPLC or packed column GC to analyse explosives is only in the low nanogram range, Douse [21] described a method that uses fused silica capillary column GC in conjunction with TEA detection for trace analysis of explosives in the low picogram range. He reported that silica capillary column GC can be used to overcome the problems of very polar explosives adsorbing on the packed columns used for GC analysis and in the transfer lines of the TEA. In this way, the detection limits were lowered. He also concluded that the minimum detectable levels (15,10 and <200 pg for NG, TNT and RDX, respectively) of the compounds studied were similar to those obtained when ECD was used. 2.1.2. Applications of TEA to the analysis of explosives For complex matrices, a separation technique used to be necessary to obtain a clean sample for explosive analysis. Also, because of the lack of selectivity of CL, explo sives are generally introduced into the TEA after separation. Chromatographic techniques coupled to sensitive detection systems are widely used to detect explosives. Most of the TEA methods for detecting and identifying nitrogen-containing explosives rely on GC separation techniques, as can be seen in most of the literature reviewed and in the commercial technologies available today. TEA in combination with certain chromato graphic techniques can exhibit detection limits in the low picogram range. Its selectivity is good, and it has become the method used for detection and confirmation by a con siderable number of laboratories. As far as we know, there has been little bibliography
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
13
on HPLC and SFC, but some earlier papers suggest that they may be able to be used for explosive analysis. The selective and sensitive detection of explosive compounds by coupling HPLC with TEA has been limited to nitrate esters and nitramines, because when nitroaromatic compounds have been investigated under the same conditions, the molar response is relatively poor [20,39]. 2.1.2.1. Gas Chromatography–thermal energy analyser In GC, a sample containing the compounds of interest, which may be gas or liquid, is pushed through a column by an inert carrier gas (the mobile phase). The sample moves through a packed or capillary column at different speeds. The sample’s components are separated and emerge at different ‘retention times’ because they are distributed differently between the mobile and the stationary phases. The detection system responds to the presence and concentration of the separated compounds, thus making it possible to identify and quantify them. The potential of GC, HPLC and ion chromatography (IC) coupled with sensitive detection techniques, including TEA, for the trace detection of explosives has been investigated by Kolla [40]. GC is preferred for organic compounds, which can be vapourized without decomposition. Most of the explosives that can be detected by TEA belong to this group. TEA with GC is presented as one way of solving some of the problems associated with MS (i.e. the identification of nitrate esters or RDX in complex matrices). Kolla has pointed out that GC is the method of choice in general analytical operations, but the usual GC systems have to be applied with slight modifications because not every explosive is stable at higher temperatures. In order to be able to analyse all explosives, a compromise has to be found for GC conditions. An injection port with an insert that traps the non-vapourizable substances should be used (a split-splitless injector with a fritted glass insert). The optimum injection temperature was 170 C. The column used was a 10-m DB-5 capillary column. The column temperature was initially 50 C and was increased gradually to 250 C 10 C/min. A polymethylphenyl (5%) siloxane (DB-5) was used to enhance the selectivity of the column for the nitro compounds. Despite the specificity for nitro and nitroso compounds, in some samples, in addition to the explosive constituents, many unidentified peaks appeared in the chromatogram. The author pointed out the need for confirmation with at least one different method that must have a similar sensitivity and should have also a selective detector. A simple column change to a stationary phase of different polarity (that is to say, a stationary phase with a higher phenyl content or with additional cyanopropyl groups in polymethylsiloxane) in the GC–TEA system may make this confirmation possible. The author also reported that the TEA detector can be coupled to HPLC, but the greatest disadvantage of this approach is the lower sensitivity that results from broad peak shape and poor resolution. Confirmation is also possible by GC–MS or electron capture detector. The first, though well suited to the determination of nitroaromatics, presents some of the problems already mentioned, and the second, because of its lower selectivity, is only recommended if the matrix is relatively clean. Another paper published by Kolla and Sprunkel [41] deals with the identification of dynamite explosives in post-explosion residues. In the post-blast
14
Jimenez and Navas
residues of dynamites that contain nitroaromatic compounds (i.e. European dynamites), the isomers of DNT and/or TNT can be detected, so it is possible to identify dynamite by determining the ratios of the nitroaromatic constituents. Six German dynamites were selected, and their compositions were analysed. The dynamites selected were detonated as free hanging charges, and the samples, taken from metal plates placed at different distances from the centre of the explosion, were analysed by GC–TEA. The effectiveness of coupling SFE/GC with TDM and TEA detection was evaluated by Francis et al. [33] as a system for analysing explosive compounds [1-nitropyrene (1 NP), 2-nitronaphthalene (2-NN), 2,4-DNT, 2,6-DNT, 1,3,5-TNB, TNT, PETN, RDX and NG] in soil samples and standards. The system can be used for screening small samples in short periods of time. Citing other investigators, the authors claim that the system has the following advantages: it allows the extraction process to be monitored in real time, it provides very small injection bands for sample introduction and it is compatible with narrow-bore capillary columns. This study used neat or modified carbon dioxide CO2 as mobile phase and capillary columns (50 mm ID) with methylpolysiloxane and pp -cyanobiphenylmethylpolysiloxane stationary phases. Nitroaromatic compounds were easily extracted and eluted, but nitrate esters (PETN and NG) decomposed during thermal desorption in the modulator (a direct correlation between the temperature of the TDM and the extent of the decomposition was observed), which is one of the limitations of the method. Organic modifiers (15% acetone) had to be used to improve the extraction of some explosives, such as TNB or 1-NP. Nitramine or RDX could not be extracted under these conditions, and the use of methanol as a modifier for their extraction led to plugging of the 5-mm ID restrictor. The analysis of 200 mg of soil samples containing 24 ppb of 2,4-DNT (data obtained by GC/MS and SFC/MS) was complete in less than 10 min, and the minimum detectable quantity for 2,4-DNT was found to be 2.6 ppb S/N = 3. The authors concluded that the proposed method can quickly analyse relatively volatile and thermally stable nitro compounds from solid matrices. Trace explosive detection is a typical activity of forensic laboratories, and several laboratories involved with explosive investigations have adopted GG–TEA for this purpose. In several publications, Douse (from The Metropolitan Police Forensic Science Laboratory, London, UK) has described the application of capillary column GC–TEA to the trace analysis of explosives. Some of his preliminary papers [21,34] have shown that this combination leads to very broad peaks that impair resolution and thus reduce the power of the method for identifying and discriminating peaks due to unknown explosives. Attempts at improving the peak shape by optimizing the chromatographic conditions were unsuccessful. So, subsequent studies describe modifications in the TEA detector to improve selectivity [22]. Samples were cleaned up using columns of Amberlite XAD-7 beads and mixture of methyl tert-butyl ether and n-pentane as eluting solvent when necessary. TEA operating conditions included TEA pyrolysis oven temperature between 550 and 800 C, an ozone flow rate of 1.3 mL/min and a reaction chamber pressure of 0.29 mm Hg at an oven temperature of 60 C. One modification consisted of replacing the standard amplifier by a different amplifier and noise filtration system that gave better
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
15
peak shape. Under the optimum conditions, 5 pg of NG, TNT and RDX were readily detectable. Moreover, selectivity was better when the pyrolyser catalyst tube normally fitted on the TEA detector was replaced with a length of silica capillary tubing. The selectivity of the system was such that vacuum extracts from clothing could be analysed for traces of organic firearms discharge residue without the need for sample clean-up. In addition, the cryogenic trap could be eliminated when TEA was used for trace analysis in contaminated extracts. Another advantage of the silica pyrolysis tubes reported by the author was the low price of replacement lengths of uncoated capillary, their long lifetime and the extreme ease of replacement of the pyrolysis column. As Douse has reported, these modifications considerably simplify routine operation and the maintenance of the TEA detector. Collins continued these studies [24] and in a subsequent paper identified the source of the peak broadening within the electronic circuitry. He also described a simple modification of the TEA [the original capacitor C2 047 F was first replaced with a 01-F component and later with a 0022-F capacitor], which results in much better capillary GC peak shape. Nevertheless, the above modifications resulted in more noise, which was obtrusive at higher sensitivities. To minimize this last problem, the author described the use of a supplementary electronic filter. Subsequently, Douse [30] used the GC/TEA system to detect NG in gunshot residues. With pure standards, it was possible to detect down to about 5 pg of NG, but such sensitivity cannot be achieved with extracts from handswabs or vacuumed samples from clothing, for such extracts were substantially contaminated with lipids and other materi als. The clean-up is adequate for many samples, but during experiments on clothing, it was frequently found that contamination was too great. This was studied, and a proce dure was developed that exploits the volatility of NG to provide a primary clean-up by trapping the NG vapour on to XAD-7 beads, followed by solvent elution and GC–TEA detection. The dynamic headspace procedure described effectively separates volatile explosives such as NG from involatile impurities that reduce the selectivity. By trapping the volatilized explosives on to XAD-7 beads and effecting additional clean-up, detec tion limits of sub-nanogram quantities per swab or filter can be achieved. The results confirmed that the GC/TEA system is a robust combination that provides both sensitivity and selectivity. Since 1989, GC–TEA has been used by the Forensic Explosive Laboratory (FEL; Kent, UK) as one of the techniques for explosive trace analysis. In this year, the FEL established a weekly quality assurance testing regime in its explosive trace analysis laboratory in an attempt to prevent the accumulation of explosives, which could result in contamination of samples and controls. GC–TEA was usually used for initial sample screening and identification. Confirmation was carried out when possible by GC–MS. The GC–TEA systems adopted were essentially as described in a previous paper by Douse [34]. Since 1989, several articles have described the results obtained by the FEL investigators during approximately a decade. The general procedures and conditions for organic explosives are summarized below. They use cotton wool swabs or vacuum onto a filter for sampling (with two different sampling solvents: a mixture of ethanol and water in equal volumes and methyl-tert-butyl ether), a standard TEA solution,
16
Jimenez and Navas
generally containing 11 high common explosives (EGDN, 2-NT, 3-NT, 4-NT, NG, 2,4 DNT, 2,6-DNT, 3,4-DNT, 2,4,6-TNT, PETN and RDX) at low concentrations (between 0.1 and 075 ng/L) analysed before and after the sample, three different types of columns – dimethylsiloxane (type BP1), 5% diphenyl-dimethylsiloxane (SGE type BP5) and 7% cyanopropyl-7% phenyl-1% vinyl-dimethylsiloxane (type CPSIL-19) – for GC and confirmation when possible by GC with MS. The markers that were commonly used to provide reference peaks in GC analyses were 2-fluoro-5-NT and the fragrance musk tibetine (2,6-dinitro-3,4,5-trimethyl-tert-butylbenzene). Hiley [42] used the GC– TEA system in these conditions to study chemical analysis methods for post-explosion investigation and in particular those methods developed by the FEL’s Chemical and Electronic Sector and applied to explosive incidents on the UK mainland. The paper focuses on the importance of promptly collecting, analysing and identifying samples of material that are not visible to the naked eye, if the investigation is to be satisfactory. He reports that the systems will detect at worst 50 pg per 08 L injection of the major explosives, which corresponds to about 6 ng in a 100-L sample. The presence of dinitrosopentamehylenetetramine (DNPMT), a potential interference in the detection of explosive traces, was revealed in samples taken from a soft suitcase using GC–TEA [43]. This compound is widely used as a chemical blowing agent in the manufacture of foamed polymers and, when analysed by GC–TEA, produces a strong response that might incorrectly be taken as indicative of the presence of PETN or RDX. For GC–TEA analysis, ‘UNICEL 100’ (DNPMT) was used and, for purposes of comparison, the mixed standard solution (TEA standard) containing a low concentration of the common high explosives was used. The pyrolysis furnace was held at 750 C and directly connected into the reaction chamber. In comparison with chromatogram of the TEA standard, the chromatograms of the DNPMT solution showed strong sharp peaks. The FEL standard method for explosive trace identification by GC/TEA required that the relative retention times of the suspect explosive peak and standard explosive peak agreed within ±05%. Under this criterion, DNPMT did not coincide sufficiently with PETN or RDX. Nevertheless, the author concluded that GC/TEA analysis with columns of a similar polarity to those used in the study would incorrectly consider DNPMT as indicative of the presence of PETN or RDX. In another FEL study, Crowson et al. [44] carried out a survey to determine the background level of explosive traces in public places. Samples were taken at various transport sites (buses, taxis, underground trains, passenger aircraft, etc.), and police sites were also sampled to assess how likely it is that a suspect could be contaminated. A pyrolysis oven temperature of 750 C, an interface oven temperature of 250 C and a reaction chamber pressure reading of 0.5–2 mm Hg were the instrument settings. Although the most common high explosives can be detected by the technique in question, the explosive cyclotertamethylene tetranitramine (HMX) and the propellant ingredient nitrocellulose are not sufficiently volatile to be detected. Limits of detection for the complete procedure were estimated for the explosives NG, TNT, PETN and RDX in both clean and dirty samples using the three columns mentioned above. In the case of the BP-5 column and clean samples, the limits of detection (ng) were 1.0, 1.1, 2.2 and 0.6.
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
17
The results of this survey led the authors to conclude that traces of high explosives were rare within the general public environment. In fact, no traces of NG, TNT or PETN were detected at any of the public sites sampled during this project. Only four low level traces of RDX were detected. Therefore, they concluded that it was unlikely that a member of the public would be innocently contaminated with a significant quantity of explosives. A second survey from FEL was presented in 2004 [45]. This study examined levels in four of the UK’s major cities: Birmingham, Cardiff, Glasgow and Manchester. Samples were collected from taxis, buses, trains, airports, hotels, privately owned vehicles, and clothing purchased from charity shops. The samples were analysed as described in the study by Crowson et al. [44] with the exception of a modification to the temperature programme of the gas chromatographs to allow screening for NB. Traces of the high explosives NG, TNT, PETN and RDX were rare within the general public environment. The results of the survey indicate that it is unlikely that persons visiting public areas could become significantly contaminated with explosives. Warren et al. [46] described a simple processing and analysis scheme for explosive trace swab samples which deals both with organic and inorganic materials. Swabs, wetted with ethanol or ethanol/water mixture, were extracted with ethanol/water mixture and applied directly through a simple column containing an acrylonitrile/styrene copolymer adsorbent. The adsorbent retained common organic explosives that were recovered with an efficiency of 30–50% and analysed using GC-CL or GC–MS detection. Figure 3 Swab, wetted with ethanol or ethanol/water Extract with ethanol/water Ethanol/water extract Pass down adsorbent tube
Adsorbent in tube
Ethanol/water fraction
1. Wash with MTBE/pentane 2. Elute with ethyl acetate
Ethyl acetate fraction
Analysis by IC and/or CE
Analysis by GC–TEA and/or GC–MS Fig. 3. Processing scheme. Reprinted with permission from Warren et al. [46]. Copyright (1999) Forensic Science Society. CE, capillary electrophoresis; GC, gas chromatography; TEA, thermal energy analyser; IC, ion chromatography.
18
Jimenez and Navas RDX MT
TNT EGDN
NG
PETN
FNT NB
2
4 Time (mins)
6
8
Fig. 4. Example of thermal energy analyser (TEA) standard analysis using CPSIL-19 column type. EGDN, Ethylene glycol dinitrate; FNT, 2-fluoro-5-nitrotoluene; MT, musk tibetine; NB, nitrobenzene; NG, nitro glycerine; PETN, pentaerythritol tetranitrate and RDX, cyclotrimethylene trinitramine; TNT, trinitrotoluene. Reprinted with permission from Warren et al. [46]. Copyright (1999) Forensic Science Society.
shows a processing scheme. For GC/TEA analysis, the three columns mentioned above are used with a pyrolysis furnace held at 750 C. Concentrations of explosives were estimated by comparing peak areas with those of explosives in the standard solutions and assuming a linear relationship between peak area and concentration. A typical TEA standard chromatogram obtained using a CPSIL-19 column is shown in Fig. 4. Mean recoveries of organic explosives ranged from ∼4% for the NTs to over 50% for PETN. The authors reported that recoveries were generally lower than those obtained using XAD7 clean-up and that higher recoveries can be obtained using clean-up tubes with lower sample flow rates. Twelve years after the weekly quality assurance testing regime had been implemented in FEL, Crowson et al. [47] summarized the results obtained in an attempt to determine the best methods for preventing contamination. They also provided information on the lessons learned and suggestions for improvement. Bowerbank et al. [48] have described a new separation technique, solvating GC (SGC), which uses packed capillary columns and neat CO2 as mobile phase coupled to TEA for the separation and selective identification of NG and other nitro-containing explosives (2,6-DNT, 2,4-DNT, 2,4,6-TNT and PETN). To identify NG, they used two soil samples obtained from an explosive training ground. Instrument requirements are similar to those of SFC, except that the SFC restrictor at the end of the column is removed, resulting in a pressure gradient along the column. The transfer line between the SGC column and the TEA pyrolyser unit consisted of a 50 cm length of large bore 530 m ID × 700 m OD fused silica tubing. This was made necessary by the fixed distance between the outlet of the SGC column and the inlet to the pyrolyser. In this
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
19
1
2 4
5
3
2
3
4
5
Fig. 5. Solvating gas chromatography (SGC) separation of a standard explosive mixture. Injected amounts: 033 g nitroglycerine (NG), 33 g all others. Peaks (1) nitroglycerine, (2) 2,6-dinitrotolene, (3) 2,4 dinitrotoluene, (4) 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene, (5) pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN). Reprinted from Bowerbank et al. [48]. Copyright (2000), with permission from Elsevier.
study, the authors pointed out the following benefits and advantages of coupling SGC to TEA: the CO2 mobile phase does not give rise to added background noise; it does not increase the limit of detection of the TEA due to the absence of nitro or nitroso functional groupsand the selective nature of the TEA makes it possible to use certain organic modifiers in the CO2 mobile phase to elute highly retentive compounds. Modifiers such as dichloromethane or methanol cannot be used with flame ionization detection (FID) because they significantly increase the baseline signal. The TEA calibration curve for NG showed linearity in the sub-micrograms per millilitre range. The authors reported an SGC separation of a standard mixture of nitroaromatic explosives in ∼4 min using neat CO2 and TEA as selective detector. Figure 5 shows a chromatogram obtained for nitroaromatic compounds (conditions: 65 cm ×320 m ID column packed with octadecylsilane (ODS) bonded porous particles, neat CO2 mobile phase, 250 atm, 130 C isothermal oven, 740 C pyrolyser, 250 C transfer line, 200 nL injection and 12:1 split ratio) in which peak tailing is attributed by the authors to the use of the fused silica transfer mentioned above. When the same packed column was placed in an SGC-FID, no peak tailing was observed. The results obtained in a standard NG sample containing 040 g/mL (0.2-L injection), which corresponded to ∼6 pg on-column after taking the split ratio (12:1) into account, were compared with those obtained with flame ionization detector (the most commonly used with SGC). As Fig. 6 shows, the TEA gives a strong NG peak, whereas FID failed to detect the compound (conditions as in Fig. 5). The authors concluded that SGC is capable of performing separations with half-height peak widths in the order of 200 ms, but a detector with greater sensitivity than FID (TEA or MS) is necessary for sensitive and selective detection of NG and nitroaromatics. Numerous terrorist activities as well as many serious criminal offensives involve firearms. When a firearm is discharged, a variety of materials is emitted by the muzzle (accompanying the projectile), including primer and gunpowder (propellant) residues
20
Jimenez and Navas NG
TEA FID
2
3
4
Fig. 6. Chromatograms of standard nitroglycerine (NG) obtained using thermal energy analyser (TEA) and FID (0.0004 mg/mL). Reprinted from Bowerbank et al. [48]. Copyright (2000), with permission from Elsevier.
from the projectile. Detection of gunpowder (propellant) residues on suspects or their clothing may link them to such an incident. Modern propellants for small arms ammu nition almost exclusively contain nitrocellulose, and other explosive ingredients may also be present, e.g., NG and nitroguanidine, stabilizers such as diphenylamine and flash inhibitors such as 2,4-DNT, 2,6-DNT and plasticizers. Thus, analytical methods for detecting propellant or their residues are similar to those used for analysing explo sives [49–51]. Numerous studies have been published on the analysis of propellant residues [49]. However, only a few have proposed operational methods for sampling, detecting and identifying these residues on shooters and/or their clothing. Zeichner et al. [50] have conducted experiments to collect gunpowder (propellant) residues from shooters’ clothing using a portable vacuum sampler and the Teflon filters supplied with the commercial IMS instrument. They analysed them by GC/TEA, IMS and GC/MS. The samples were centrifuged and/or filtered, concentrated by evaporation and analysed without any additional clean-up steps. The clothing is first sampled by double-side adhesive-coated aluminium stubs followed by vacuum collection for pro pellant residue examination. The detection limits (in ng) of the GC/TEA (15-m length column) are 0.2 for NG, 0.05 for 2,4-DNT and 0.05 for 2,6-DNT. The sensitivity of the system was lower when the authors used a 30-m long column in the GC/TEA (0.5–1.0 for NG, 0.1 for 2,4-DNT and 0.1 for 2,6-DNT) or IMS (0.3 for NG, 2,4-DNT and 2,6-DNT). The considerably lower sensitivity of GC/TEA for NG compared with DNT is due to the thermal decomposition of NG in GC columns, which is more pronounced when the 30-m column is used. With the 30-m column, the NG peak in most of the chro matograms was preceded by a smaller peak that could be identified as one of the possible thermal decomposition products of NG. The formation of two NG peaks in the GC/TEA chromatograms increases the probability of it being identified by this method. On the basis of this last study, Zeichner and Eldar [51,52] developed an efficient method for extracting and analysing gunpowder residues on double-side adhesive-coated stubs. The method should be applied after the primer residues have been examined. The major problem of achieving this goal is minimizing the co-extraction of adhesive
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
21
and skin debris components, which interfere in the analysis of propellant residues. The optimal procedure for the extraction consists of two stages: (i) extraction of the stubs with a mixture of 80% v/v aqueous solution of 0.1% w/v of sodium azide and 20% v/v of ethanol using sonication at 80 C for 15 min and (ii) further extraction of residues of the obtained extract with methylene chloride. The methylene chloride phase was concentrated by evaporation prior to analysis by GC/TEA and IMS. The optimal procedure was tested in extraction experiments of single gunpowder particles and of standard solutions of NG and 2,4-DNT deposited on stubs, as well as in additional shooting tests. The recovery of NG and DNT was quite variable and found to be in the range 30–90% for the adhesives tested. Neither the adhesives nor the skin was observed to interfere in any significant way in the analysis, but interferences were observed in the GC/TEA analysis of samples collected from hair. The applications of GC–TEA to explosive analysis are summarized in Table 2. 2.1.2.2. High-performance liquid chromatography–thermal energy analyser High-performance liquid chromatography is a type of LC in which a liquid or an appro priately dissolved solid sample is forced through a column by liquid at high pressure. HPLC with UV detection, specially reversed phase methods, has been extensively used for the analysis of explosives [53–55]. HPLC-UV is standardized in the US Environmen tal Protection Agency (EPA) Method 8330 [56] for monitoring nitroaromatic explosives in soils, ground water and sediments, which provides HPLC conditions for detecting ppb levels of certain explosive residues. In our review of the literature, we have not found many papers about HPLC with TEA detection in recent years. However, at the beginning of TEA, a number of papers, which must be mentioned here, show that it can be useful for explosive detection. So, Lafleur and Morriseau [39] carried out a very detailed study using HPLC with TEA to identify and determine explosives and other related compounds [EGDN, NG, PETN, Petrin (2-hydroxymethyl-2-nitroximethyl-1,3 propanediol-1,3-dinitrate), RDX, 1-nitroguanidine (NGu) and HMX (octahydro-1,3,5,7 tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine)] with thermally labile nitro or nitroxy groups. They used columns packed with Lichrosorb Si-60 or Lichrosorb NH2 , a pyrolyser temperature of 550 C and cold traps between −80 and −90 C. A mixture of isooctane and ethanol was used as mobile phase. Chromatographs obtained for the analysis of a mixture of four explosives (NG, PETN, RDX and HMX) showed increased retention times on the NH2 column compared with silica. This was particularly evident in the case of PETN, which elutes after NG on the NH2 column but before it on silica. According to the authors, this shift can be a valuable method for identifying components in certain mixtures of explosives. The HPLC–TEA analysis of an 80-ng sample of a standard dynamite with a nitrate ester composition of nine parts EGDN to one part NG showed that NG shifts to a longer retention time on an NH2 column whereas EGDN does not. The authors pointed out that this behaviour could be very useful for identifying dynamite compo sitions. Retention data for 62 HPLC–TEA analyses of eight different explosives were reported. All of the components were clearly resolved on the silica column, but the retention times of PETN and NG overlapped significantly on the NH2 column. Ancillary
22
Jimenez and Navas
Table 2. Applications of gas chromatography–thermal energy analyser (GC–TEA) to explo sive analysis Analyte
Observations
Pyrolysis temperature
Minimum working level
NB, 2,4-DNT and 2,6-DNT
A shakeoutcentrifugation procedure is used to isolate the nitroaromatics from the biosludges Silica capillary column GC Parallel GC– TEA/HPLC–TEA. No need for sample clean-up before analysis Handswab extracts using columns of Amberlite XAD-7 porous polymer beads
950 C
0.05 mg/L (LOD) NB was not detected (<005 mg/L wet weight)
[35]
1000 C
Low pg level
[21]
900 C
Low pg level. Sensitivity of 4–5 pg injected on-column
[14]
500–900 C
Low ng level
[34]
Sample clean-up using columns of Amberlite XAD-7 beads. Dynamic headspace sampling. Columns of Amberlite XAD-7
550–800 C
5 pg of NG, TNT and RDX
[22]
625 C NB, 4-NT and 2,4-DNT required 750 C
Sub-ng level
[30]
Sample pre-treatment: solid phase extraction
900 C
pg level
[32]
SFE/TDM/GC
800 C
MDQ for 2,4-DNT 2.6 ppb
[33]
NG, TNT and RDX NG, DNT, TNT, RDX, EGND and tetryl NG, EGND, TNT, RDX, tetryl BTT, NB, TNB and 2,4-DNT NG, TNT and RDX
NG, EGND, BTN, TEGDN, TNT, RDX, NB, 4-NT, 2,4-DNT and musk tibetine NG, EGND, TNT, DNT, PETN and RDX 2-NN, 2,4-DNT, 2,6-DNT, 1-NP, 1,3,5-TNB, NG, PETN, TNT and RDX
Reference
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
23
Table 2. (Continued) Analyte
Observations
Pyrolysis temperature
Minimum working level
DNPMT (chemical blowing agent) NG, TNT, PETN and RDX
Extraction in methyl-tert-butyl ether
750 C
–
[43]
Samples taken at various transport sites
750 C
[44]
SGC using packed capillary columns and neat carbon dioxide as mobile phase Gunpowder residues collected by a portable vacuum sampler
740 C
LOD (BP-1 column) and relatively dirty samples NG (ng), 3.1 TNT(ng), 2.9 PETN (ng), 4.0 RDX (ng), 2.3 Low pg range
LOD 0.2 ng (NG), 0.05 ng (2,4-DNT), and 0.05 ng (2,6-DNT) In the range of 0.1–1 ng
[50]
NG, 2,6-DNT, 2,4-DNT, 2,4,6-TNT and PETN NG, 2,4-DNT and 2,6-DNT
NG and 2,4-DNT
Extraction and analysis of gunpowder residues on double-side adhesive-coated stubs
850 C
850 C
Reference
[48]
[51,52]
BTT and BTN, butane-1,2,4-triol-trinitrate; DNT, dinitrotoluene; EGDN, ethylene glycol dinitrate; HPLC, high-performance liquid chromatography; LOD, limits of detection; MDQ, minimum detectable quantities; NB, nitrobenzene; NG, nitroglycerine; NN, nitronaphthalene; NT, nitrotoluene; PETN, pentaerythritol tetranitrate; RDX, cyclotrimethylene trinitramine; SFE, supercritical fluid extraction; SGC, solvating gas chromatography; TDM, thermal desorption modulator; TNB, trinitrobenzene and TNT, trinitrotoluene.
components such as plasticizers and stabilizers presented no interferences even when standard explosive preparations were not purified. The 90% confidence interval for the quantification of RDX was ±16% at the 4-ng level and 3.2% for PETN at the 6-ng level. The authors conclude that the method proposed is useful for identifying explosive compounds at trace levels and for analysing explosive compositions. Liquid chromatography with TEA detection or an ultraviolet HPLC detector has been evaluated as an analytical procedure that simultaneously determines EGDN and NG in air [57]. Samples were collected by drawing a known volume of air through large sampling tubes containing Tenax-GC resin. The samples were desorbed with methyl alcohol and analysed by LC with TEA or an UV HPLC detector. A Dupont Zorbax CN
24
Jimenez and Navas
46 mm × 25 cm column was used. Temperatures of 550 and −80 C were selected for the HPLC pyrolyser and the cold trap, respectively. The detection limit of the overall procedure was 186 ng/sample for EGDN and 280 ng/sample for NG. The equivalent air concentrations were 12 g/m3 (2.0 ppb) for EGDN and 19 g/m3 (2.0 ppb) for NG. These were considered to be reliable quantitation limits within the requirements of a recovery of at least 75%. The report mentions that one disadvantage is the high cost of the TEA detector. Interfacing the TEA to both a gas and a HPLC has been shown to be selective to nitrobased explosives (NG, PETN, EGDN, 2,4-DNT, TNT, RDX and HMX) determined in real world samples, such as pieces of explosives, post-blast debris, post-blast air samples, hand swabs and human blood, at picogram level sensitivity [14]. The minimum detectable amount for most explosives reported was 4–5 pg injected into column. A pyrolyser temperature of 550 C for HPLC–TEA and 900 C for GC/TEA was selected. As the authors pointed out, GC uses differences in vapour pressure and solubility in the liquid phase of the column to separate compounds, whereas in HPLC polarity, physical size and shape characteristics determine the chromatographic selectivity. So, the authors reported that the use of parallel HPLC–TEA and GC–TEA techniques provides a novel self-confirmatory capability, and because of the selectivity of the technique, there was no need for sample clean-up before analysis. The detector proved to be linear over six orders of magnitude. In the determination of explosives dissolved in acetone and diluted in methanol to obtain a 10-ppm (weight/volume) solution, the authors reported that no extraneous peaks were observed even when the samples were not previously cleaned up. Neither were they observed in the analysis of post-blast debris. Controlled experiments with handswabs spiked with known amounts of explosives indicated a lower detection limit of about 10 pg injected into column. Selavka et al. [36] have studied how the incorporation of on-line, post-column UV irradiation improves the HPLC–TEA detectability of mono-NT, DNT and TNT. This photolytically assisted TEA (PAT) detection approach included the use of an ultraviolet lamp and a knitted open tubular photochemical reactor design that significantly reduced the band broadening that resulted whenever long lengths of tubing (11.9 m long) were used to construct post-column reaction chamber. TEA was operated in the nitroso mode (pyrolyser temperature at 550 C). The mechanism was explored using batch irradia tion followed by LC–TEA and GC/MS and was postulated to involve photochemically induced isomerization leading to homolytic cleavage of the C–NO2 bond, followed by hydrogen abstraction. The authors concluded that PAT improved the TEA detectability of TNT and DNT by a factor of 30 and 16, respectively. LC–PAT has been used to confirm the presence of TNT in several bomb cases and makes the examination results more reliable. 2.1.2.3. Supercritical fluid chromatography–thermal energy analyser Supercritical fluids are produced by heating a gas above its critical temperature or compressing a liquid above its critical pressure. In SFC, the sample is carried through a separating column by a supercritical fluid (typically CO2 ) that is used as mobile
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
25
phase. The solvating powers of supercritical fluids can be similar to those of organic solvents. Their diffusivities are higher, however, and their viscosity and surface tension lower. To our knowledge, SFC has not been extensively applied to the detection of explosives: only two earlier references describe the coupling of SFC to TEA and its application to the detection of explosives. A representative group of compound explosives, including those compounds that are difficult to analyse by HPLC–TEA or GC–TEA because they are thermally unstable or non-volatile, have been satisfactorily analysed by capillary SFC with thermal energy analysis detection at the nanogram level [23]. Some of the explosives studied present the characteristics mentioned above: hexanitrobibenzyl, which has low vapour pressure, tetryl, which decomposes to N -methylpicramide, or PETN, which requires a clear GC system to prevent decomposition. Pure compounds were dissolved in ethyl acetate and analysed directly. The chromatographic column was 68 m × 005 mm ID SB Octyl 50 Superbond cross-linked flexible silica (Flexsil) capillary with a stationary phase film thickness of 025 m. The restrictor penetrated 11.5 cm into the TEA pyrolyser interface block, and the pyrolysis temperature was 625 C. The SFC density and temperature programmes operated simultaneously and were described for specific applications. The operating conditions described by the author made it possible to analyse many nitramine, nitrate ester and nitroaromatic explosives in pure standards and hand swab extracts. The author reported that the minimum detectable levels (in pure standards) ranged from 20 to 60 pg injected for a representative group of compounds (NG, 23 pg; PETN, 40 pg; tetryl, 60 pg and hexanitrobibenzyl, 55 pg). Moreover, compounds containing very polar groups (amino and hydroxyl groups) could not be analysed. The peak shape of HMX was poor, probably because of its low solubility in supercritical CO2 . The effect of dirty extracts on column stability was also investigated, and the results obtained allowed the author to conclude that capillary SFC–TEA is more resistant than capillary GC–TEA to contamination by extractives. Francis et al. [58] have reported the coupling of SFC with TEA for the analysis of such nitro- and nitroso-containing compounds as tobacco-specific nitrosamines and explosives (synthetic mixture: NG, 2,6-DNT, 2,4-DNT, PETN, 2,4,6-TNT, 1,3,5-TNB, tetryl, RDX and HMX). TEA was interfaced directly to the outlet restrictor of the SFC. Its potential use for thermally labile compounds and environmental samples has been evaluated by the authors. The sensitivity of TEA was good, and its linear dynamic range was broad; minimum detectable quantities (MDQ) were below 20 pg for PETN with a dynamic range of over four orders of magnitude. The analysis of HMX was accomplished by using modified CO2 with a corresponding MDQ of 67 pg. Owing to the superior selectivity of the cyanobiphenyl stationary phases (medium polarity) for a variety of compounds, the authors used mp-cyanobiphenyl and the p p-cianobiphenyl phases. The selectivity of TEA for nitro and nitroso compounds can be adjusted by changing the pyrolysis temperature. Nitroso compounds, O-nitro (nitrate ester) and N -nitro compounds (nitramine), are more easily pyrolysed than the C-nitro compounds. The mixture of standard nitrated compounds was run at 400 and 800 C (although at this last pyrolysis temperature there was no selectivity towards the different types of
26
Jimenez and Navas
nitrated groups). At 400 C only, the nitroso compounds, the nitrate esters and the nitramines were detected. The SFC/TEA system was used to study the environmental fate of propellant and explosive residues after military munitions had been disposed of. Air samples were obtained on quartz fibre filters when the compounds were burned or detonated in a ‘bang box’. The major nitrated compound was TNT, there were smaller amounts of TNB and there was also a peak that eluted at the same retention time of RDX. Independent SFC/MS analysis of the sample confirmed the identification of the peak as RDX (contamination from an earlier test).
2.2. Luminol Luminol is a relatively simple chemical containing only carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and hydrogen C8 H7 N3 O2 . It is widely used as a chemiluminescent reagent, and it has quite a few other names: 5-amino-2,3-dihydro-1,4-phthalazine-dione, o-aminophthalyl hydrazide, 3-aminophthathic hydrazide and o-aminophthaloyl hydrazide, among others. It was discovered in the late nineteenth century and later, in 1928, Albrecht [59] dis covered a specific chemical that, when placed in an aqueous alkaline solution, emitted a fairly intense blue-green light. This specific chemical was to be later called luminol. The chemiluminescent emitter is a ‘direct descendent’ of the oxidation of luminol by an oxidant in basic aqueous solution. Hydrogen peroxide is probably the most useful oxidant, however, other oxidants have been used. The presence of a catalyst is essential if this chemiluminescent method is to be used as an analytical tool. Many metal cations catalyse the reaction of luminol, H2 O2 and OH− in aqueous solution to increase light emission. The general CL reaction of luminol can be schematized as follows:
O C H2O2 + C NH2
O
O
O NH
C
OH–
NH Catalyst
C NH2
O
∗ O–
C
O–
C NH2
O– O–
+ Light
O
Analytical methods based on the CL reaction of luminol are famous for their inherent simplicity, speed, high sensitivity and wide dynamic range. A highly selective and sensitive detector for measuring organic nitrates in atmospheric air samples has been developed by Hao et al. [60]. They describe the development of a chromatographic detector based on post-column thermal decomposition of organic nitrates (and other nitrogen-containing compounds) in a quartz tube pyrolyser to yield NO2 , which is subsequently detected using a highly sensitive and selective CL-based
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
Flow sensor
27
Compressor
NO2 Luminol solution
Quartz tube
NO2 detector 350°C
Pyrolyzer
UV-Window Photodiode
Amplifier
N2 Wick 180°C
λ = 425 nm
ECD
Carrier gas out
RONO2
Waste
O2 Mass flow controller
GC NO2 Perm. source
Fig. 7. Schematic diagram of the organic nitrate-specific detector. Reprinted with permission from Hao et al. [60]. Copyright (1994) American Chemical Society.
NO2 detector, and luminol as the chemiluminescent reagent. Figure 7 shows a schematic diagram of the organic nitrate-specific detector. In the case of organic nitrate pyrolysis, the reaction proceeds by O–N bond homolysis as follows: RONO2
RO + NO2
The luminol detector is based on the sensitive chemiluminescent reaction between NO2 and luminol in solution. The luminol in alkaline solution reacts with NO2 to pro duce intensive CL centred on 425 nm. The detector cell itself is a 15 cm × 8 cm × 2 cm rectangular block, with inlets and outlets for the carrier gas and luminol flows. The reaction cell contains a fabric wick that is wetted with the luminol solution (1 × 10−4 M luminol, 02 M Na2 SO3 , 0.05 M NaOH, 15 × 10−4 ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid and 0.1% surfactant). The wick is viewed by a PMT through an acrylic win dow, which is transparent to the chemiluminescent light at 425 nm. When a NO2 peak enters the cell, a fraction of the NO2 dissolves in the solution on the surface of the wick, which then reacts with luminol to ultimately yield a strong CL. The results described indicate that this detector may be successfully used for the sensitive and selective detection of any nitrogen-containing species that may thermally decompose to yield NO2 , with a potential use for the detection of explosives (2,4-DNT and TNT).
28
Jimenez and Navas
Table 3. Relative response factors for aromatic nitro compounds and nitrosamine for the pyrolyser/luminol detector Compound
N -nitrosodimethylamine nitrobenzene o-Mononitrotoluene m-Mononitrotoluene p-Mononitrotoluene 1-Nitronaphthalene 2,4-Dinitrotoluene (2,4-DNT) 2,4,6-Trinitrotolene (2,4,6-TNT) a
Temperature of the quartz tube for pyrolysis ( C)
Relative responsea
350 650 650 650 650 650 800 800
051 053 048 051 044 099 074 090
Relative to 2-butyl nitrate, obtained at the same temperature as for the related species in the table. Reprinted with permission from Hao et al. [60]. Copyright (1994) American Chemical Society.
At sufficiently high temperatures, the detector also responds to a variety of nitroaro matics and to N -nitrosodimethylamine. NO2 yields of 0.70 and 0.90 were obtained for 2,4-DNT and TNT, respectively. The detection system exhibits a linear response for all nitrogen-containing compounds studied, and the detection limit for the determination of organic nitrates was found to be ∼005 pmol. The relative response factors for aromatic nitro compounds and nitrosamine for the pyrolyser/luminol detector are presented in Table 3. The reversed micellar-mediated CL (RMM-CL) reaction of luminol with AuCl4 − was applied to the indirect CL determination at trace level of p-toluidine, 2-methyl 5-nitroaniline and 2,4-dinitroaniline in aqueous samples by Mohammadzai et al. [61]. These compounds are related to the degradation products of TNT but are not active in the CL reaction. Incorporating reversed micelles into the CL detection system has sev eral advantages, including improved sensitivity and selectivity. In the reversed micellar solution, the surfactant molecules encompass tiny water droplets and are converted into homogeneously distributed micelles in the organic bulk. Acting as microreactors, the reverse micelles have unique properties, and it is believed that the RMM-CL reactions occur at water–surfactant interfaces of the reverse micelles. These microreactors have the ability to quantitatively transfer species of experimental interest into their water pools and to enhance sensitivity by several factors. The protonated analyte, HA + , forms an ion-pair with the AuCl4 − ion in aqueous acidic medium, which is extracted into the organic phase of dichloromethane. Using a membrane phase separator, the on-line separated extracts are successively introduced into the mixing cell situated in a CL detector. In the cell, the extract containing the analyte as an ion-pair, HA + AuCl4 − , is mixed with the reversed micellar luminescent reagent (luminol in 03 M Na2 CO3 ) pre pared from cetyltrimethylammonium chloride in CH2 Cl2 -cyclohexane, pumped through the other tubing, and the CL signal produced from luminol oxidation by AuCl4 −
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
29
is recorded. The detection limits S/N > 3 reported were as follows: p-toluidine, 10 × 10−4 M; 2-methyl-5-nitroaniline, 10 × 10−7 M and 2,4-dinitroaniline, 10 × 10−7 M. The calibration curves were linear between 10 × 10−4 and 10 × 10−2 M for all the com pounds. These data indicate that the proposed CL method could be a sensitive, fast and low-cost substitute for the existing procedures. With a simple experimental setup and low-cost instrumentation, the proposed method makes it possible to quantify p-toluidine, 2-methyl-5-nitroaniline and 2,4-dinitroaniline at trace levels in aqueous samples. The method has various advantages over the manual extraction procedure: simplicity, less human exposure to toxic reagents/solvents, throughput, sensitivity, precision, minimum risk of contamination, etc. The great interest in detecting traces of explosives has originated several patents. Nguyen et al. [62] have provided a method and system for detecting small quantities of explosives and other contraband substances located on the surfaces of objects. The technique uses a chemical reaction between NO2 gas and luminol in an aqueous, alkaline solution. Under suitable conditions, the vast majority of common types of explosives may be decomposed to produce NO2 gas that is detected using the apparatus presented by the authors. Light is detected to signal the presence of the contraband substance. The system rapidly provides quantitative indications of the amount and location of a critical substance. It is especially well suited for use in applications that require throughput and accuracy, such as security screening associated with airlines and other forms of public transportation. A portable advanced explosives detector (E 3500) based on luminol CL is manu factured by Scintrex Trace Corp. [63]. It offers both vapour and particulate sampling without the use of an external carrier gas or radioactive source. Vapours are sampled directly through the sampling nozzle. Particulates are sampled by swiping a suspected object with a cotton glove or other means and transferring any traces to the unit. This portable detector is capable of detecting plastic and high vapour pressure explosives rapidly, and it can detect minute traces (low nanogram level) of C-4, TNT, dynamite, PETN, semtex, EGDN, 2,3-dimethyl-2,3-dinitrobutane (DMNB), RDX, ANFO, ammo nium nitrate, urea nitrate, NG and triacetone triperoxide (TATP), with low false alarm levels and few interferents.
2.3. Electrochemiluminescence The application of ECL per se or in combination with enzyme IM to the detection of explosives has been reported and has extended the possibilities of CL in the field of explo sives. ECL can be defined as the luminescence generated by the relaxation of excited state molecules that are produced during an electrochemically initiated reaction [64]. A wide range of reagents is known to produce these luminescence processes (organic, organic-metal ions including compounds of ruthenium, osmium, rhenium or other ele ments, and other kinds of molecules), but only a few of them are of interest for analytical purposes. Ruthenium trisbipyridine Rubpy3 is probably the best known of the organic
30
Jimenez and Navas
metal ion coordination complex ECL molecules. ECL combines the advantages of CL with the ability to control the time of the light-emitting reaction and is therefore a sensitive method for the analysis of some chemical species. In explosive detection, Bruno and Cornette [65] have used ECL to determine several diaminotoluenes (DATs), degradation products of DNT. DNT is present in TNT, and DATs are related to other compounds that are TNT breakdown products. The determi nation is based on the low-level ECL reaction of these molecules with the group IB transition metals ions Au+ and Cu+2 . DAT isomers were screened for ECL against a battery of 32 metal ions, including Cu+2 , Eu+3 , Mg+2 , Ru+3 and Tb+3 associated with other known ECL complexes, at 1:3 added metal ion: ligand molar ratios. The 1:3 molar ratio presumed tris-bidentate octahedral metal coordination complex formation, which generally yielded optimal ECL intensity. An ORIGEN Analyzer (ECL sensor; IGEN Corp.) was used. DAT isomers (2,3-, 2,4-, 2,5-, 2,6- and 3,4-diaminotoluene), DNT isomers and 4-amino-3-NT were screened. Control solutions of metal ions without ligands, but with tripropylamine (TPA), an electron carrier, gave no detectable ECL, whereas some solitary DAT ligand solutions produced appreciable background ECL in the presence of TPA. The authors reported that the DNT and aminonitrotoluene metal ion data demonstrated that the presence of the nitro functional group disallowed or severely inhibited ECL (presumably because of steric hindrance), whereas amino functional groups appeared to interact with certain metal ions to produce noteworthy ECL reactions. Data from the preliminary screening showed that the most intense ECL response was obtained from Cu+2 for 3,4-DAT (light brown) and Au+1 for 2,4-DAT (dark brown). They suggested that the apparent specificity of Au+ for 2,4-DAT and Cu+2 for 3,4-DAT may be partly based on ionic size as Au+ has nearly twice the ionic diameter of Cu+2 and thus may form a coordination complex with the meta but not with the orto DAT. Other DAT isomers were screened and exhibited mildly enhanced ECL with various metal ions, but these enhancements were not statistically significant. An ECL intensity time dependence was observed in the Cu+2 -3,4-DAT system. A very linear ECL response of Cu+2 to 3,4-DAT from 1 to 200 ppm was obtained, and the detection limit was in the order of ≤1 ppm of 3,4-DAT. The Au+1 -2,4-DAT titration demonstrated no time dependence and did not appear to have a broad linear response range. Lower detection limits or sensitivities in the ppm range for both the metal ions and organic ligands involved can be achieved. Finally, the authors concluded that the ECL assays described are potentially useful for detecting and quantifying DATs or possibly triaminotoluenes as well as detection and quantitation of various transition metals in industrial wastewater streams and groundwater supplies. A patent based on ECL reactions has been presented by these authors [66]. The invention is directed to novel ECL reactions between diaminoaromatic ligands and soluble metals ions and in particular to reactions between aminoaromatic ligands, such as 2,4-DAT, 3,4-DAT and 2,3-diaminonaphthalene, and metal ions, such as Au(I), Cu(II), Cr(VI), Fe(III), Ru(III), Se(IV) and V(V). The ECL assays are considered useful for carrying out field and laboratory analysis to detect TNT breakdown products and toxic metals in wastewater streams, soil and ground water supplies.
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
31
2.4. Immunoassay, chemiluminescence and electrochemiluminescence Immunoassay makes use of the binding between an antigen and its homologous antibody to identify and quantify the specific antigen or antibody in a sample. IM methods cover quite an important field of analytical chemistry and are the method of choice for measuring analytes that are normally present at very low concentrations and which cannot be determined accurately by other less expensive tests. The sensitivity of any IM is a complex function of the underlying physicochemical basis of the technique and the size and source of ‘experimental’ errors [67]. Considerable effort has been made to improve the sensitivity (i.e. the introduction of time-resolved fluorescence IMs where femtomolar detection limits are achieved) but only at the cost of introducing more sophisticated and expensive equipment. High sensitivity can also be achieved by using chemiluminescent labels [68], which emit light when they are mixed with a chemical trigger. Although these labels produce a lower number of detectable events than fluorescent labels, there is no excitation source, and therefore the background emission is close to zero, and there is no interference due to scattering. Competitive immunoanalytical methods are based on the competitive binding that occurs between a labelled and an unlabelled ligand for highly specific receptor sites on antibodies. Analysis is carried out by measuring a physical or chemical property associated with the label and by constructing a standard curve that represents a mea sured physical signal as a function of the concentration of the unlabelled ligand. Analyte concentrations are extracted from this calibration curve [2]. CL IM is now established as one of the best alternatives to conventional IM for quantifying low concentrations of analyte in complex samples. In recent years, ECL has been used for the detec tion step in IMs. The technology has evolved into analytical procedures that perform much better than IMs based on the use of radioactive labels. Several reports show the potential of IM combined with CL or ECL detection in the field of trace explosive detection. Multianalyte detection (TNT, atrazine and fluorescein) with an affinity sensor array is presented by Schuetz et al. [69]. The normal assay procedure for an indirect enzymelinked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) is used, with horseradish peroxidase (HRP) labelled secondary antibodies in combination with a CL substrate. The authors have developed a parallel affinity sensor array (PASA) to overcome the most controversial disadvantage associated with ELISA: that is to say, cross reactivity. In the PASA system, parallelization is achieved by immobilizing different affinity molecules such as antibod ies or haptens in distinct areas of a plain glass surface. If several antibodies are used for one analyte, substances should be able to be identified by pattern recognition. Multian alyte detection is made possible by using different antibodies for different analytes. The system is based on peroxidase-catalysed CL with luminol/hydrogen peroxide substrates (Pierce Supersignal, Pierce Supersignal ULTRA and DuPont Renaissance). The CL light is collected with a high-performance charge coupled device (CCD)-camera that allows high spatial resolution and a high density of different haptens. A standard liquid autosam pler is used for standards and samples. The haptens were covalently coupled to a surface
32
Jimenez and Navas
by the N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS)-ester technique. Although results were best with the ‘Super Signal ULTRA’ substrate, the authors decided to use normal ‘Supersignal’ because the results were satisfactory, and it was cheaper than ‘Super Signal ULTRA’. For the analyte TNT, the detection limit was about 02 g/L. Ciumasu et al. [70] have developed a portable and power-supply autonomous field immunosensor for environmental pollutants using TNT as the key target. Other explo sives and pesticides (diuron and atrazine) have also been determined. Monoclonal anti bodies (mAbs) were immobilized through adsorption on a gold surface with numerous pyramidal structures. The recognition reaction was enhanced in three ways: (i) through the enzymatic reaction, (ii) through the pyramidal structure with the gold surface cover and (iii) through the detection of the CL of the product through a very sensitive PMT. Immunoreagents (enzyme tracer and antibody) together with the environmental sample were located in a single-use chip that was replaced after each measurement. This chip is the key to the versatility of the analytical system. In the final step, the competition between the enzyme tracer and the analyte for the antigen-binding sites of the antibodies yields a CL signal that is inversely proportional to the concentra tion of the analyte in the given range of detection. Reagents are transported with an automated, miniaturized flow-injection system. SuperSignal®ELISA Femto Maximun Sensitivity Substrate (Luminescence) and SuperFreeze™ Peroxidase conjugate Stabilizer were used. A battery of six enzyme tracers for nitroaromatic compounds was produced by hapten conjugation to HRP through N -hydroxysuccinimide active esters, and TNP– glycylglycine–HRP was established as the best enzyme tracer for mAb A1.1.1. After optimization on the microtiter plates, the ELISA procedure for each target analyte was adapted to the batch ELISA format, where the wells of the microtiter plate were replaced by the gold covered disk with numerous pyramid structures. The specific batch-ELISA conditions for TNT assays were as follows: the coating protein was protein A/G [alter natively, goat anti-mouse immunoglobulin G (IgG)] for mouse mAb A1.1.1, the coating concentration was 4 g/mL and the recognition antibody was anti-TNT mAb A1.1.1, 2 g/mL and 2 h at room temperature. After the blocking step, the TNT standard and the enzyme-tracer solution were incubated together on the structures for 10 min. When TNT was analysed with the optimized TNT-ELISA on microtiter plates, the goat anti-mouse IgG as coating antibody, mAb A1.1.1 and the mentioned enzyme tracer, the performance characteristics of the standard curve were as follows: detection limits (DL; IC20 ) between 0.1 and 02 g/L, linear dose–response region IC20 –IC80 from 0.1 to 10 g/L and test midpoint IC50 between 0.3 and 1 g/L. The pH range was from 4 to 10. The assay showed a high selectivity for TNT. The authors concluded that the sensitivities for all three analytes were very good, which was especially true for TNT. This platform had such important features as analytical flexibility for a wide range of analytes, sensitivity, automation, miniturization and low environmental hazardous waste. Investigators from the Department of Chemistry of the University of Liverpool tried using ECL with enzyme IM for trace explosive detection (TNT and PETN). The detection step uses ECL and triggers light emission by an electrochemical reaction. The ECL step
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
Gold electrodes
33
Piston with magnet Stepper motor
Reference electrode Solution out
Solution in
Magnet behind working electrode Fig. 8. Flow-cell with rare earth magnet positioned behind the working electrode. Reprinted from Wilson et al. [68]. Copyright (2003), with permission from Elsevier.
allows the time of the light-emitting reaction to be controlled, and so, the detection can be delayed until the antibody-binding reaction has taken place. The enzymes glucose oxidase (Gox) and HRP were used in these assays. The authors designed and constructed a computer-controlled flow-injection chemiluminometer. Full details of the instrumentation used to carry out these IMs are given in the study by Wilson et al. [68,71,72]. The flow-injection electrochemiluminometer consists of a Pentium III computer, a flow injection analyser, a potentiostat and an electrochemiluminometer. The electrochemiluminometer consists of two enclosures, one outside the other (Fig. 8) surrounding a flow cell where ECL reaction takes place and a PMT that detects the light emitted. The enclosures are designed to exclude light from the PMT when the electro chemiluminometer is in use but allows access to the flow cell for routine maintenance. The inner enclosure contains a flow cell designed to facilitate the flow of solutions through the working compartment and to ensure that gas bubbles do not become trapped. It is made of PTFE (Teflon) to minimize the adsorption of molecules such as labelled antibodies. The main design features reported by the authors are the hydrodynamic shape of the working compartment through which solutions are pumped from the bottom to the top of the flow cell; the increasing diameter in the direction of flow; connection between the working and reference electrode compartments angled upwards, in the direction of the flow; and working and counter electrodes polished flush with the Teflon. Wilson et al. [72] describe the ECL enzyme IM for TNT. The flow-injection elec trochemiluminometer incorporates a three-electrode arrangement consisting of 3-mm diameter gold disk working and counter electrodes and a miniature Ag/AgCl reference electrode. The deposition of a re-usable immunosorbent dextran surface anchored to a gold surface in the flow cell by chemiadsorbed thiol groups is described. Antibodies were labelled with the enzyme glucose oxidase and used in competitive IM. In the ECL IMs, the antibodies were mixed with TNT. After TNT had occupied a fraction of the
34
Jimenez and Navas
available antibody binding sites, the sample was pumped through the flow cell where unoccupied binding sites were bound to the immunsorbent surface. After washing away the unbound fraction, antibodies bound to the immunosorbent surface were detected by pumping a solution of glucose and luminol through the flow cell. The enzyme label oxidized the glucose and generated H2 O2 , which reacted chemiluminescently with electrochemically-oxidized luminol. A mixture of acetonitrile and urea was used to regenerate the immunosorbent surface. As the concentration of TNT was increased, the amount of the unbound antibody that bound to the immunosorbent surface decreased. Light intensity was inversely proportional to the concentration of TNT in the sample in the range 0–100 ppb. The limit of detection was 12 ppb. The authors reported that in comparison with the data obtained by Colorimetric ELISA, ECL is very fast: for example, colour takes 20 min to develop with Colorimetric ELISA, but the detection step in ECL takes only 100 s. However, the detection limit of ELISA was lower (2.3 ppb), and the authors mention that the limit of the proposed method must be improved for environmental analysis. Finally, they discuss the possibility of developing a portable instrument for use in the field. A paramagnetic bead-based enzyme ECL IM for TNT has been described by Wilson et al. [68]. The paramagnetic beads are coated with haptenylated dextrans prepared by substituting biotin and analogues of TNT into aminodextrans. The IM protocol reported is shown in Fig. 9. The IMs are carried out in three stages: in the first stage, TNT and haptenylated dextrans compete for a limited number of antibody-binding sites; in the second stage, antibodies bound to the dextran are concentrated on the surface of paramagnetic beads; and in the third stage, the beads are magnetically concentrated on the surface of an electrode. In the presence of glucose, the glucose oxidase label conjugated to the antibodies generates H2 O2 , which reacts chemiluminescently with electrochemically oxidized luminol. The concentration of TNT in the sample is determined from the light intensity with reference to a calibration curve. The light intensity reaches a maximum at around +600 mV and then decreases as the potential increases. The limit of detection for TNT was 31 ppb. The flow cell can be used for at least 3 months without being cleaned manually. The Gox system described also has many shortcomings: comparatively low turnover, incompatible ECL and enzyme pH optima, a high CL background and susceptibility to interference from non-specifically bound label. The authors also point out that the detection step in the ECL assays described took 80 s compared with the 20 min for colour to develop in colorimetric IMs with similar sensitivity. The authors reveal that of the existing detection systems, the combination of HRP with electrochemically generated H2 O2 comes closest to meeting the requirements, and so they carried out similar assays for TNT and PETN but based on HRP [71]. HRP catalyses the chemiluminescent oxidation of luminol in the presence of electrochemically generated H2 O2 . For enzyme IM, the haptens corresponding to the explosives were covalently attached to highaffinity dextra-coated paramagnetic beads, which were mixed with the corresponding Fab fragments and the sample. It is recommended to use Fab fragments rather than whole antibodies for maximum sensitivity. After adding a second HRP-labelled antispecies specific antibody, the mixture was pumped into an electrochemiluminometer where
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
(a)
35
(b) CO2
CO2 CO2
Streptavidin dynabead
CO2 CO2
CO2
CO2
CO2
PMT
Light
(c)
N
S
Fig. 9. Enzyme electrochemiluminescence (ECL) immunoassay protocol. (a) Trinitrotoluene (TNT) and dini trophenyl of haptenylated dextran compete for antibody-binding sites. (b) Antibodies attached to dextran bound to streptavidin-coated paramagnetic beads. (c) ECL detection of enzyme-labelled antibodies mag netically concentrated on electrode. Reprinted from Wilson et al. [68]. Copyright (2003), with permission from Elsevier.
beads were concentrated on the working electrode magnetically. The amount of analyte in the sample was determined by measuring light emission when H2 O2 was generated electrochemically in the presence of luminol and an enhancer, p-iodophenol. The HRP ECL detection system is schematized by the authors as follows: (i) reducing dissolved oxygen electrochemically generates H2 O2 , (ii) H2 O2 oxidizes HRP and (iii) HRP oxidizes p-iodophenol, which mediates the chemiluminescent oxidation of luminol. The limit of detection of TNT was 0.11 ppb. Nevertheless, the limit of detection was 68 ppb when IMs were carried out with whole antibodies. The EPA has proposed a lifetime health advisory level of 2 ppb for TNT in drinking water. The detection limit for PETN was 19.8 ppb. The authors observed the relation between the limit of detection and the Ka (affinity of the antibodies) of the antibodies. The Ka value of the anti-TNT antibodies used in this work was 58 × 105 , which corresponds to a maximum sensitivity of 0.03 ppb. Finally, the authors concluded that the simple protocol ensures that IMs for a previously undetected analyte can be up and running within a few weeks of the antibodies and corresponding haptens becoming available.
36
Jimenez and Navas
3. Using chemiluminescence as detection technology in security The prevalence of terrorist activity has led to major efforts to encourage research and improve explosive trace detection systems to be used for security inspections and monitoring explosive substances. Security technologies are now one of the main aims of researchers, government agencies, the military and manufacturers. The detection system must comply with certain requirements: a fast response time and high sensitivity are essential to prevent and detect terrorist attacks. Rouhi [73] has pointed out that the detection systems in aviation security must be sensitive enough to find small amounts hidden in complex matrices. They must also be specific, able to discriminate between threatening and benign materials and not generate too many false alarms. Likewise, they must do the job quickly. CL is commonly cited in explosives’ reports and guides as one of the technologies used for the security of civilians and the investigation of terrorist activities. Gross and Bruschini [74] have reported that artificial odour or vapour sensors currently in use in the chemical industry and airports (CL, MS, ion mobility spectrometry, biosensors and electron capture) would be a valid alternative for detecting antipersonnel mines though they have mentioned that these sensors have a too low sensibility, are too slow or too large to be used in field applications. In the congressional research service (CRS) report for the USA Congress (2005), Shea and Morgan [75] included chemical luminescence as one of the trace detection techniques for aviation security. They point out that bulk detection of explosives on airline passengers is of interest and that these systems detect only bulk quantities of explosives, so they would not raise ‘nuisance alarms’ on passengers who have recently handled explosives for innocuous reasons. They also mention that trace detection tech niques would also detect bulk quantities of explosives and may raise security concerns about passengers who have been in contact with explosives. Hallowell [76] cites a patent from Thermedics Inc. [77] based on a high-speed GC-CL detector, as being in the category of trace detection technologies and states that it is a nonintrusive way of screening people for the presence of clandestinely concealed explosives, weapons or drugs for aviation security. Hallowell comments that this patent includes the development of a ‘walk-in, walk-out’ booth, containing suction vents that horizontally draw in a ‘large volume’ of air from around a human subject who enters the booth. Gas chromatography–thermal energy analyser explosive detection systems (EGIS II and EGIS III systems manufactured by Thermo Electron Corporation) are now being used by several governments, institutions and laboratories, including the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF), the Royal Canadian Mounted Police forensic laboratories, US and German government aviation security agencies and the British Military (to be deployed in Northern Ireland in support of the anti-terrorism mission) [78]. The specifications reported for EGIS II® and EGIS III® include a false alarm rate below 0.2% for typical luggage screening and lower detectable limits of 300 and 100 pg, respectively. The reader interested in more details and specifications can consult the last reference from the Thermo Electron Corporation. These systems have become the trace detection standard throughout Europe for the
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
37
airport screening of bags. In 1995, the National Laboratory Center in Rockville, Maryland (from ATF’s laboratory system), started using EGIS Explosives Detectors to examine explosives residue in post-blast explosive scenes. The Explosion Investigation Section of the National Research Institute of Police Science of Japan [79] makes use of GC with a TEA and IC to analyse trace explosive residues from debris. An EGIS explosives detector was also used in the Oklahoma City bombing investigation [80]. In a collaborative police investigation involving the Indonesian National Police and the Australian Federal Police about the Bali bombings on 12 October 2002, which killed 202 people [81], the presence of the organic explosive TNT was detected using IMS, and it was confirmed by GC–TEA, among other systems.
References [1] T.G. Chasteen. Chemiluminescence Definitions and Primer. Available at http://www. shsu.edu/∼chm_tgc/chemilumdir/Define.html. [2] W.R.G. Baeyens, S.G. Schulman, A.C. Calokerinos, Y. Zhao, A.M.G. Campaña, K. Nakashima and D. De Keukeleire. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal., 17 (1998) 941. [3] A. Townshend. Analyst, 115 (1990) 495. [4] L. Theisen, D.W. Hannum, D.W. Murray and J.E. Parmeter. Survey of Commer cially Available Explosives Detection Technologies and Equipment 2004, Document No. 208861. Sandia National Laboratories, 2004. Available at http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/ nij/grants/208861.pdf. [5] Environmental Health and Safety. University of Wisconsin. River Falls. Environmental Safety Resources. Nitro explosive safety. Available at http://www.uwrf.edu/ehs/2nitroexplosivesafety.htm. [6] C.D. Bosco. Hand Held Explosives Sensor System, Report number 03306. University Transportation Center for Alabama (UTCA), Tuscaloosa, AL, 2003. Available at http://utca.eng.ua.edu/projects/final_reports/03306-Bosco-fin-rpt-16Sep03.pdf. [7] E.B. Byall. Explosives Report, Detection and Characterization of Explosives and Explo sive Residue: A Review, 1998–2001. 13th INTERPOL Forensic Science Symposium, Lyon, France, 16–19 October, 2001. Available at http://www.interpol.int/Public/Forensic/ IFSS/meeting13/Reviews/Explosives.pdf. [8] J.I. Steinfeld and J. Wormhoudt. Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem., 49 (1998) 203. [9] C. Bruschini. “Commercial Systems for the Direct Detection of Explosives (for Explosive Ordnance Disposal Tasks” ExploStudy, Final Report (2001). Available at http://www.eudem.vub.ac.be/publications/files/ExploStudy.pdf. [10] J. Yinon. Trac-trends. Anal. Chem., 21 (2002) 292. [11] S. Singh and M. Singh. Signal Processing, 83 (2003) 31. [12] D.S. Moore. Rev. Sci. Instrum., 75 (2004) 2499. [13] A.M. Jimenez and M.J. Navas. J. Hazard. Mater., 106A (2004) 1. [14] D.H. Fine, W.C. Yu, E.U. Goff, E.C. Bender and D.J. Reutter. J. Forensic Sci., 29 (1984) 732. [15] X. Xu, A.M. van de Craats, E.M. Kok and P.C.A.M. de Bruyn. J. Forensic Sci., 49 (2004) 1. [16] D.W. Hannum and J.E. Parmeter. Survey of Commercially Available Explosives Detection Technologies and Equipment, NCJ 171133. Sandia National Laboratories, 1998. Available at http://www.fortliberty.org/military-library/expsurvey.pdf. [17] D.H. Fine, F. Rufeh and B. Gunther. Analyt. Lett., 6 (1973) 731.
38
[18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27]
[28] [29]
[30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37]
[38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52]
[53] [54] [55]
Jimenez and Navas
D.H. Fine, F. Rufeh and D. Lieb. Nature, 247 (1974) 309. W.C. Yu and E.U. Goff. Anal. Chem., 55 (1983) 29. A.L. Lafleur and K.M. Mills. Anal. Chem., 53 (1981) 1202. J.M.F. Douse. J. Chromatogr., 256 (1983) 359. J.M.F. Douse. J. Chromatogr., 410 (1987) 181. J.M. Douse. J. Chromatogr., 445 (1988) 244. D.A. Collins. J. Chromatogr., 483 (1989) 379. D.H. Fine, D. Lieb and F. Rufeh. J. Chromatogr., 107 (1975) 351. D.H. Fine, F. Rufeh, D. Lieb and D.P. Rounbehler. Anal. Chem., 47 (1975) 1188. R.A. Scanlan. Chemilumnescence for measurements of N-nitrosamines in foods, in Anal ysis of Food Contaminants (Ed. by John Gilbert). Elsevier Applied Science Publishers, London, 321 (1984). U. Isacsson and G. Wetermark. Anal. Chim. Acta, 68 (1974) 339. C.L. Rhykerd, D.W. Hannum, D.W. Murray and J.E. Parmeter. Guides for the Selec tion of Commercial Explosives Detection Systems for Law Enforcement Applications, Guide 100-99. National Institute of Justice, Washington, DC, 1999, p. 18. Available at http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/178913-1.pdf. J.M.F. Douse. J. Chromatogr., 464 (1989) 178. R.Q. Thompson, D.D. Fetterolf, M.L. Miller and R.F. Mothershead II. J. Forensic Sci., 44 (1999) 795. P. Kolla. J. Forensic Sci., 36 (1991) 1342. E.S. Francis, M. Wu, P.B. Farnsworth and M.L. Lee. J. Microcolumn. Sep., 7 (1995) 23. J.M.F. Douse. J. Chromatogr., 328 (1985) 155. J.H. Phillips, R.J. Coraor and S.R. Prescott. Anal. Chem., 55 (1983) 889. C.M. Selavka, R.E. Tontarski Jr and R.A. Strobel. J. Forensic Sci., 32 (1987) 941. TWGFEX Laboratory Explosion Group and Standards & Protocols Committe. Rec ommended Guidelines for Forensic Identification of Intact Explosives. Available at http://www.ncfs.org/twgfex/docs/Guide%20for%20identification%20of%20intact%20 explosives.pdf. M. Nambayah and T.I. Quickenden. Talanta, 63 (2004) 461. A.L. Lafleur and B.D. Morriseau. Anal. Chem., 52 (1980) 1313. P. Kolla. J. Chromatogr. A, 674 (1994) 309. P. Kolla and A. Sprunkel. J. Forensic Sci., 40 (1995) 406. R.W. Hiley. J. Defence Sci., 1 (1996) 181. R.W. Hiley. J. Forensic Sci., 41 (1996) 975. A. Crowson, H.E. Cullum, R.W. Hiley and A.M. Lowe. J. Forensic Sci., 41 (1996) 980. H.E. Cullum, C. McGavigan, C.Z. Uttley, M.A.M. Stroud and D.C. Warren. J. Forensic Sci., 49 (2004) 1. D. Warren, R.W. Hiley, S.A. Phillips and K. Ritchie. Sci. Justice, 39 (1999) 11. A. Crowson, R.W. Hiley and C.C. Todd. J. Forensic Sci., 46 (2001) 53. C.R. Bowerbank, P.A. Smith, D.D. Fetterolf and M.L. Lee. J. Chromatogr. A, 902 (2000) 413. A. Zeichner. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 376 (2003) 1178. A. Zeichner, B. Eldar, B. Glattstein, A. Koffman, T. Tamiri and D. Muller. J. Forensic Sci., 48 (2003) 1. A. Zeichner and B. Eldar. J. Forensic Sci., 49 (2004) 1. A. Zeichner and B. Eldar. A novel method for extraction and analysis of gun powder residues on double-side adhersive coated stubs. The 8th Conference of the Israel Analytical Chemistry Society, 11–12 January 2005. T.F. Jenkins, D.C. Leggett, C.L. Grant and C.F. Bauer. Anal. Chem., 58 (1986) 170. R.L. Marple and W.R. LaCourse. Anal. Chem., 77 (2005) 6709. A.C. Schmidt, B. Niehus, F.M. Matysik and W. Engewald. Chromatographia, 63 (2006) 1.
Detection of Explosives by Chemiluminescence
39
[56] EPA Method 8330. Nitroaromatics and Nitramines by High Performance Liquid Chromatog raphy. Available at http://www.epa.gov/SW-846/pdfs/8330.pdf. [57] Ocupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA), US Department of Labor. Organic Methods Evaluation Branch OSHA Analytical Laboratory, Method no. 43. 1983. Available at http://www.osha.gov/dts/sltc/methods/organic/org043/org043.html. [58] E.S. Francis, D.J. Eatough and M.L. Lee. J. Microcolumn. Sep., 6 (1994) 395. [59] H.O. Albrecht. Z. Phys. Chem., 135 (1928) 321. [60] C. Hao, P.B. Shepson, J.W. Drummond and K. Muthuramu. Anal. Chem., 66 (1994) 3737. [61] I.U. Mohammadzai, T. Ashiuchi, S. Tsukahara, Y. Okamoto and T. Fujiwara. J. Chin. Chem. Soc., 52 (2005) 1037. [62] D.H. Nguyen, S. Berry, J.P. Geblewicz, G. Couture and P. Huynh. Chemiluminescent Detec tion of Explosives, Narcotics, and Other Chemical Substances, US patent no. 6 984 524. 2006. Available at http://www.freepatentsonline.com/6984524.html. [63] Scintrex Trace Corp. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Trace Detection Products and Systems for a Dangerous World. Available at http://www.scintrextrace.com/. [64] K.A. Fähnrich, M. Pravda and G.G. Guilbault. Talanta, 54 (2001) 531. [65] J.G. Bruno and J.C. Cornette. Microchem. J., 56 (1997) 305. [66] J.G. Bruno and J.C. Cornette. Electrochemiluminescence Assays Based on Interactions with Soluble Metal Ions and Diaminoaromatic Ligands, US patent no. 5 976 887. 1999. Available at http://www.freepatentsonline.com/5976887.html. [67] T.M. Jackson and R.P. Ekins. J. Immunol. Methods, 87 (1986) 13. [68] R. Wilson, C. Clavering and A. Hutchinson. J. Electroanal. Chem., 557 (2003) 109. [69] A.J. Schuetz, M. Winklmair, M.G. Weller and R. Niessner. Multianalyte detection with an affinity sensor array, Bioluminescence and Chemiluminescence – Perspectives for the 21st Century (Ed. by A. Roda, M. Pazzagli, L.J. Kricka and P.E. Stanley, pp. 67–70). Proc. 10th Intern. Symp., 1998, Bologna, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 1999. Available at http://www.ch.tum.de/ wasser/weller/BC99b.pdf. [70] I.M. Ciumasu, P.M. Krämer, C.M. Weber, G. Kolb, D. Tiemann, S. Windisch, I. Frese and A.A. Kettrup. Biosens. Bioelectron., 21 (2005) 354. [71] R. Wilson, C. Clavering and A. Hutchinson. Anal. Chem., 75 (2003) 4244. [72] R. Wilson, C. Clavering and A. Hutchinson. Analyst, 128 (2003) 480. [73] A.M. Rouhi. Chem. Eng. News, 73 (1995) 10. [74] B. Gross and C. Bruschini. Sensor technologies for the detection of antipersonnel mines. A survey of current research and system developments: Paper presented at the International Symposium on Measurement and Control in Robotics (ISMCR’96), Brussels, May 1996, 564–569. [75] D.A. Shea and D. Morgan. Detection of Explosives on Airline Passengers: Recom mendation of the 9/11 Commission and Related Issues. Updated on 7 February 2005. http://fas.org/sgp/crs/homesec/RS21920.pdf. [76] S.F. Hallowell. Talanta, 54 (2001) 447. [77] M.D. Arney, G. Zaccai, E.K. Achter, E.J. Burke, G. Miskolczy and A.A. Sonin. Airsampling Apparatus with Easy Walk-in Access, US patent no. 4896547. 1990. Availabele at http:/www.freepatentsonline.com/4896547.html. [78] Thermo Electron Corporation. A line of portable, bench-top explosives detection systems. EGIS II and EGIS III. Available at http://www.thermoramsey.de/EGIS-englisch.pdf. [79] National Research Institute of Police Science, Japan. Explosion Investigation Section. Avail able at http://www.nrips.go.jp/org/second/explosion/index-e.html. [80] http://www.atf.gov/explarson/forensics-laboratory-support.htm. [81] D. Royds, S.W. Lewis and A.M. Taylor. Talanta, 67 (2005) 262.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 2
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
Jehuda Yinon Department of Environmental Science, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Elsevier B.V.
All rights reserved.
41
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43
2. Mass spectrometry – principles of operation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43
3. Detection of explosives by mass spectrometry methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
48
4. Miniature and mobile mass spectrometers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
54
5. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
58
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58
42
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
43
1. Introduction The mass spectrometer meets the main performance requirements of an explosive detection system, which are sensitivity, selectivity, and speed of analysis. Additional requirements are mobility and cost. During the last 10 years, mass spectrometers have become smaller and mobile and less expensive. Various mass spectrometer configurations have been used for the detection of explo sives, such as ion traps, quadrupoles, and time-of-flight (TOF) analyzers and tandem mass spectrometer (MS/MS) combinations. Also, various modes of ionization have been employed, depending on the specific application in the detection of explosives.
2. Mass spectrometry – principles of operation Mass spectrometry is the field dealing with separation and analysis of substances accord ing to the masses of the atoms and molecules of which the substance is composed. The principle of mass analysis is that the parameters of time and space of the path of a charged particle in a force field in vacuum are dependent on the mass-to-charge (m/e) ratio. The methods of separation and analysis can be divided in two: (1) Methods based on time separation. (2) Methods based on geometric separation. The time separation method is based on the fact that ions having different m/e ratios have different times of flight and are thus collected one after the other. The TOF mass spectrometer is based on these principles of operation. In the geometric separation method, ions having different m/e ratios are separated according to their geometric position at the collecting spot. The magnetic mass analyzer, the quadrupole mass analyzer, and the ion trap are based on these principles of operation. The magnetic mass spectrometer will not be discussed in this chapter as it has not been used for the detection of explosives.
2.1. Quadrupole mass analyzer The quadrupole mass analyzer [1] consists of four parallel metal rods arranged as in Fig. 1. Two opposite rods are electrically connected and have an applied potential of U + V cos �t, and the other two rods, also electrically connected, have a potential of −�U + V cos �t�, where U is a DC voltage and V cos �t is an RF voltage, � being the angular frequency �� = 2�f�.
44
Yinon
Quadrupole rods
To detector
– +
+ Ions
Exit slit (to detector)
– Resonant ion (detected) Source slit
Non-resonance ion (not detected)
Fig. 1. Quadrupole mass analyzer. Reproduced from http://www.chm.bris.ac.uk/ms/images/quad-schematic. gif, with permission from Dr Paul Gates, School of Chemistry, University of Bristol, UK.
The motion of an ion injected into the field in the z direction can be described by the Mathieu differential equations: m
d2 x e + 2 2 �U + Vo cos �t� x = 0 dt2 ro
m
d2 y e − 2 2 �U + Vo cos �t� y = 0 dt2 ro
m
d2 z =0 dt2
where ro is the radius of the four-rod system, m is the mass of the ion, and e is its charge. The solution of these equations designate oscillations performed by an ion in the x and y directions, whereas the ion proceeds with constant velocity in the z direction. The applied voltages affect the trajectory of ions traveling down the flight path centered between the four rods. For given DC and RF voltages, only ions of a certain m/e ratio pass through the quadrupole analyzer until they hit the detector, whereas all other ions are thrown out of their original path and hit the walls. A mass spectrum is obtained by monitoring the ions passing through the quadrupole analyzer as the voltages on the rods are varied. There are two methods: varying the frequency � while holding U and V constant, or varying U and V but keeping U/V constant.
2.2. Ion trap mass analyzer The ion trap mass analyzer [2] (Fig. 2) consists of two end-cap electrodes, held at ground potential, and an interposed ring electrode, to which DC and RF voltages are applied. The ring electrode is a single surface formed by a hyperboloid of rotation. The end-caps are complementary hyperboloids having the same conical asymptotes: z is an axis of
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
Ring electrode
Spacer rings Exit lens
lnlet focusing
lons in
Trapped ions
Entrance end-cap electrode
45
lons out
Exit end-cap electrode
Fig. 2. Ion trap mass analyzer. Reproduced from http://www.chm.bris.ac.uk/ms/images/iontrap-schematic.gif, with permission from Dr Paul Gates, School of Chemistry, University of Bristol, UK.
cylindrical symmetry. These electrodes form a cavity in which it is possible to trap and analyze ions. Both end-cap electrodes have a small hole in their centers through which the ions can travel. The ring electrode is located halfway between the two end-cap electrodes. Ions produced in the source enter the trap through the inlet focusing system and the entrance end-cap electrode. As in the quadrupole mass analyzer, the motion of an ion in the trap having an m/e ratio can be described by the Mathieu differential equations: m
d2 r e + 2 2 �U + Vo cos �t�r = 0 dt2 ro
m
d2 z e
− 2 2 �U + Vo cos �t�z = 0 2 dt zo
where U is the DC voltage, Vo cos �t is the RF voltage, � is the angular frequency �� = 2�f�� ro is the radius of the cavity formed by the ring electrode (represents the trap size), zo is the distance from the center of the trap to the end cap, and m and e are the mass and charge of the ion, respectively. For an ideal quadrupole field, ro2 = 2zo 2 . Solution of these equations lead to two possibilities: r or z continues to increase with time giving unbounded and therefore unstable trajectories, and r and z are periodic with time, producing stable trajectories within the trap (assuming that the maximum distance of excursion from the center is less than ro and zo ). Mass analysis is based on mass selective instability. DC and RF voltages applied to the trap electrodes are such that ions over the entire m/e range of interest can be trapped within the field imposed by the electrodes. After this storage period, the parameters U and Vo are changed so that the trapped ions of consecutive values of m/e become
46
Yinon
successively unstable and are ejected through perforations in one of the electrodes and impinge on a detector. The detected ion current signal intensity, as a function of time, corresponds to a mass spectrum of ions that were initially trapped.
2.3. Time-of-flight mass analyzer The TOF analyzer [3] consists of an ion-accelerating region, a flight tube, and a detector. In theory, all ions experience the same potential difference during acceleration and thus have the same kinetic energy at the start of the flight tube, and thus different velocities depending upon their mass. Therefore, their arrival time at the detector is proportional to their mass, and they reach the detector in order of increasing mass. The m/e ratios of the ions relate to the flight times t by the following equations: � 2eV mv2 = eV v= 2 m � � � l m 1 m tf = = l =l v 2eV 2V e � m tf = k e where tf is the TOF, l is the length of the flight tube, v is the velocity of the ion of mass m and charge e, and V is the acceleration potential. The differences of flight times are, of course, the basis for resolving ions of different m/e ratios in the TOF analyzer, and the mass resolution depends on the flight time differences, which are proportional √ √ to l� m1 − m2 �. The major deficiency of a simple linear TOF instrument is its insufficient mass resolution, resulting from flight time variations of ions of the same m/e ratio. The ionization process adds a certain amount of initial kinetic energy to the molecules before acceleration. In addition, the different spatial positions in the source from where the ions are formed lead to varying values of l, and thus to flight time variations. As a result, modern TOF instruments commonly employ a technique called reflectron to enhance resolution. A reflectron TOF (RETOF) [4] (Fig. 3) is used to focus ions of the same
Reflectron off
Reflectron on
Source
Source Detector linear mode
Drift tube
Detector reflectron mode
•
•
•
•
Drift tube •
•
•
•
Detector reflectron mode
Fig. 3. Reflectron time-of-flight (TOF) mass analyzer.
Detector linear mode
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
47
m/e but of different kinetic energy. There are different designs of reflectrons, but often they consist of a series of rings or grids that act as an ion mirror. It is located after the drift tube, creating a retarding field that the ions penetrate. Depending upon their kinetic energy, they enter this field at different depths and then are reflected back into the flight tube, where they drift to the detector, which is placed close to the ion source. Consider the case of ions of the same m/e but significant energy spread, which would be detected as broad peaks in the linear TOF: the ion with a higher kinetic energy penetrates deeper and spends more time in the reflectron. The slow ion, on the other hand, returns to the flight tube faster, but with the same lower kinetic energy. The faster ion will catch up with the slow one at the detector, thereby improving mass resolution greatly.
2.4. Tandem mass spectrometer (MS/MS) Tandem mass spectrometry, or MS/MS, is used for structure determination of molecular ions or fragments [5]. In MS/MS, the ion of interest, the precursor ion, is selected with the first analyzer (MS-1), collided with an inert gas, such as argon or helium, in a collision cell, and the fragments generated by the collision are separated by a second analyzer (MS-2) and detected (Fig. 4). This configuration of having two mass spectrometers in series is called tandem in space. Several combinations have been used, the most common one being the triple quadrupole. In this configuration, the second quadrupole, to which only an RF voltage is connected, serves as the collision cell. In the ion trap, the experiments are carried out in one analyzer, and the various events are separated in time, not in space. This configuration is called tandem in time and is
Inlet system Sample introduction
Ion source Sample ionization
First mass analyzer Primary mass separation
Introduction of collision gas
Collision cell CID of selected ion
Second mass analyzer Daughter-ion mass analysis
Detector and data system Mass spectrum of daughter ions Fig. 4. Schematic MS/MS configuration.
48
Yinon
not limited to simple MS/MS experiments but can achieve multiple MS/MS/MS� � � /MS measurements under optimal conditions. The MS/MS mass spectrum provides a ‘fingerprint’ of the precursor ion and provides an additional dimension of selectivity and identification of the analyzed sample.
3. Detection of explosives by mass spectrometry methods 3.1. Explosive vapor and trace detection An explosive detection system based on an atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI) source with corona discharge ionization has been developed [6]. The direction of the sample gas flow introduced into the ion source is opposite to that of the ion flow produced by the ion source, a technique called ‘counter-flow introduction’ (CFI). In a conventional source, sample gas flows directly into the corona discharge region. Hence, the sample gas and primary ions produced by the corona discharge are moved toward the sampling aperture by the gas flow and by an electric field produced between the corona discharge electrode and the aperture electrode. In the present ion source, the sample gas flows in the opposite direction. The negative ions generated are extracted by the electric field in the direction opposite to the gas flow. The mass analyzer is an ion trap having a radius ro of 16 mm. The system, with a mass range of 300 amu, had a detection limit for trinitrotoluene (TNT) of 10–20 ppt. The detection limit was reduced to 0.3 ppt when using MS/MS. A commercial explosive trace detection system, Hitachi DS-120E, based on a quadrupole mass spectrometer was built [7]. Ionization is carried out by corona dis charge and APCI. Sampling is carried out by wiping surfaces on suspicious objects for traces of explosives. The ‘wipe sheet’ is inserted into the detection system, where it is heated in order to desorb the trace explosives into the ion source. Analysis time is 5–10 s. A new ion source has been developed for rapid, non-contact analysis of materials at ambient pressure and at ground potential [8,9]. The new source, termed ‘direct analysis in real time’ (DART), is based on the atmospheric pressure interactions of long-lived electronic excited-state atoms or vibronic excited-state molecules with the sample and atmospheric gases. Figure 5 shows a schematic diagram of the DART ion source. The source consists of a tube divided into several chambers through which a gas such as nitrogen or helium flows. The gas is introduced into a discharge chamber containing a cathode and an anode. A voltage of several kilovolts initiates an electrical discharge producing ions, electrons, and excited-state species in a plasma. It is believed that the electronic or vibronic excited-state species (metastable helium atoms or nitrogen molecules) are active reagents in the DART source. Several ionization mechanisms are possible, depending on the polarity and reaction gas, the proton affinity and ionization potential of the analyte, and the presence of additives or dopants. The simplest process
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
49
Needle electrode
Gas heater
Gas electrode Gas in
Perforated disk electrodes Gas out Insulator cap Fig. 5. Schematic diagram of direct analysis in real time (DART) ion source. Reproduced with permission from Cody et al. [9]. Copyright 2005 American Chemical Society.
is Penning ionization involving transfer of energy from the excited gas M∗ to an analyte S having an ionization potential lower than the energy of M∗ . This produces a radical molecular cation S+� and an electron. Penning ionization is a dominant reaction when nitrogen or neon is used in the DART source. Nitrogen or neon ions are effectively removed by electrostatic lenses and are not observed in the background mass spectrum. When helium is used, the dominant positiveion formation mechanism involves the formation of ionized water clusters followed by proton transfer reactions. Negative-ion formation occurs by production of electrons by Penning ionization or by surface Penning ionization: M∗ + surface → M + surface + e− These electrons, after being thermalized by collisions with atmospheric pressure gas, undergo electron capture by atmospheric oxygen to produce O2 − , which reacts with the analyte to produce anions. The DART source was installed on a high-resolution TOF mass spectrometer with a resolution of 6000. The system can directly detect compounds on surfaces without requiring sample preparation, such as wiping or solvent extraction. Negative molec ular ions are observed for TNT. For other explosives, such as cyclotrimethylene trinitramine (RDX), cyclotetramethylenetetranitrate (HMX), pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN), nitroglycerin (NG), and ethylene glycol dinitrate (EGDN), adduct ions like �M + Cl�− or [M + trifluoroacetate]− are observed, when a suitable additive is present.
50
Yinon
3.2. Detection of trace explosive residues on boarding passes A system for the detection of trace explosive residues on aircraft boarding passes has been developed [10]. This approach is based on the assumption that passengers involved with explosives are likely to become contaminated with detectable amounts of trace explosives. These residues are transferred by touch to the boarding pass and are detected by the system before the passenger boards the aircraft. The desorption of explosives from the passes was achieved by short wave infrared radiation. The vapors produced were drawn into a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer (MS/MS) and were monitored in the selected reaction monitoring (SRM). Ionization is carried out by corona discharge, followed by APCI. Ions formed from most explosives are M− � �M − H�− , and adduct ions. One of these ions is selected to pass into the collision cell, to react with molecules of nitrogen, as a result of which a series of product ions are formed. In the SRM mode, one precursor ion and one product ion are chosen for each compound. The first and third quadrupoles are adjusted in order to enable SRM transition between these two ions. When introducing an additive, such as dichloromethane, precursor adduct ions are observed for RDX, PETN, and NG. SRM transitions are as follows: for RDX, m/z 262 �M + 35 Cl�− → m/z 46 �NO2 �− ; for PETN, m/z 351 �M + 35 Cl�− → m/z 46 �NO2 �− ; and for TNT, m/z 227 �M�− → m/z 210 �M − OH�− . Limits of detection were less than 100 pg for TNT, NG, PETN, and RDX. The system could handle 1000 boarding passes per hour. A background study into the levels of explosive residues on used boarding passes was conducted by analyzing over 20 000 boarding passes from a number of airports in UK, USA, and Canada. Traces of explosives were detected on approximately 0.5% of passes analyzed. NG contributed to the majority of the positive signals observed, probably because of its use as a medication.
3.3. Personnel screening portal An explosive detection personnel portal is a walk-through system for rapidly screening personnel for trace amounts of explosives at sites such as airports or Federal buildings. Such a portal, the Syagen Guardian MS-ETD Portal, has been built, using a mass spectrometer detector [11,12]. The basic functions of the portal are as follows: sample collection and concentration, selective detection of targeted compounds, and accurate measurement of the targeted compounds. When a person enters the portal, he feels a flow of air that removes and collects any particles (e.g., explosive materials) from the person’s clothing and body. The air in the portal is filtered to collect particles and condensable vapors in a preconcentrator. Following this enrichment process, the collected sample is thermally desorbed in a glow discharge ion source coupled to a quadrupole ion trap TOF (QitTof) mass spectrometer system, having MS/MS capability.
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
51
Fig. 6. Schematic diagram of how a portal works. Reproduced from http://www.syagen.com/datasheet/ Syagen4pBroFin.pdf, with permission from Syagen Technology, Inc.
Explosives that were detectable included TNT, dinitrotoluene (DNT), RDX, HMX, PETN, EGDN, NG, Tetryl, ammonium nitrate fuel oil (ANFO), triacetone triperoxide (TATP), and hexamethylene triperoxide diamine (HMTD). Analysis time is less than 15 s. Figure 6 shows schematically how such a portal works: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
Front door opens and person enters the portal. Door closes and a puff of air dislodges trace materials from clothing. Portal air is concentrated to extract particles, residue, and condensable vapors. Enriched mixture is analyzed by mass spectrometer and results displayed. Rear door opens and person exits.
3.4. Laser photoionization mass spectrometry Single-photon ionization (SPI) in combination with mass-selective detection by TOF mass spectrometry has been used for the detection of explosives [13]. The laser system consists of a Continuum Powerlite Precision 9010 Nd:YAG with a 5-ns pulse width and a repetition rate of 10 Hz. The 118.2 nm light, equivalent to a photon energy of 10.49 eV, is produced by frequency tripling the third harmonic output (354.6 nm) of the Nd:YAG laser. To accomplish this, the 354.6 nm laser beam is focused into a stainless steel tripling cell filled with Xe or Xe/Ar mixtures, which is attached directly to the ion source of the mass spectrometer. Figure 7 shows a schematic diagram of the SPI–TOF-MS instrument. Ions produced by SPI are detected and mass analyzed by a reflectron TOF mass spectrometer having a resolution of m/�m = 1000. The sample is introduced into the
52
Yinon
Nd:YAG λ = 355 nm, Duration = 5 ns W1
L1 P Pump
L2
Xe/Ar Ion extraction optics Ion beam steering plates
Ion reflector
Time-of-flight mass spectrometer
Chevron channelplate detector
Sample inlet (shown rotated 90°)
100 μm id x 90 cm uncoated capillary
PC
Fig. 7. Schematic diagram of the single-photon ionization–time-of-flight (SPI–TOF)-MS instrument. Repro duced with permission from Mullen et al. [13]. Copyright 2006 American Chemical Society.
ion source through a short deactivated capillary gas chromatography (GC) column that can be heated to 200 C. The SPI–TOF mass spectrum of TNT consists of the molecular ion at m/z 227 and the �M − OH�− fragment ion at m/z 210. The SPI–TOF mass spectrum of TATP consists of a molecular ion at m/z 222 and a series of fragment ions at m/z 43 (acetyl ion), m/z 58 (acetone ion), m/z 59 �C3 H7 O�+ � m/z 75 �C3 H7 O2 �+ � m/z 106 �C3 H6 O4 �+ , and m/z 122 (diacetone diperoxide C3 H6 O6 + ). Limit of detection, measured for 2,4-DNT, was 40 ppb with a signal-to-noise ratio of S/N ≈ 2 � 1. The drawback of the 118.2-nm SPI method is its applicability to only those molecules with ionization energies below 10.49 eV.
3.5. Desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry Desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) uses an aqueous spray directed at an analyte deposited on an insulating surface (Fig. 8) [14,15]. The sample is in the solid form at atmospheric pressure. The spray of charged droplets is produced, as in electrospray ionization (ESI), by passing an aqueous solution (i.e., methanol–water, containing some
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
53
DESI source Solvent HV power supply V N2
lon transfer line to MS
Nebulizer capillary Spray capillary
Gas jet
Spray Sample
Desorbed ions Surface
Freely moving sample stage in air Fig. 8. Schematic diagram of the desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) source. Reproduced with permission from Cotte-Rodriguez et al. [14]. Copyright 2005 American Chemical Society.
additive) through a capillary held at high voltage. The impact of the charged microdroplets with neutral molecules present on the surface produces gas-phase ions of the analyte. These ions are then sampled with an ion trap mass spectrometer, producing mass spectra that are similar to normal ESI mass spectra. Addition of reagents in the spray solution formed characteristic adduct ions that improved selectivity and identification capability. The type of ions observed depends on the nature of the sample, substrate, and reagent. For example, RDX is observed as the chloride adduct �RDX + Cl�− when electrosprayed with a dilute HCl solution but is observed as the protonated molecule �RDX + H�+ when sprayed with pure water. Observed ions can be mass selected and examined by recording their MS/MS dissociation products mass spectrum. Analyzed explosives included TNT, RDX, HMX, PETN, TATP, and the plastic explosives C-4, Semtex-H, and Detasheet. Limits of detection were in subnanogram to subpicogram range. Figure 9(a) shows the negative ion DESI spectrum for a plastic explosive C-4 finger print on glass, using methanol–water–HCl (1:1:0.05%) as spray solvent. Identity of the ions was confirmed by MS/MS. Figure 9(b) shows the negative ion DESI spectrum of a C-4 fingerprint after five transfers onto a glass slide. The absolute abundance of the ion at m/z 257 �RDX + 35 Cl�− for the five transfers was more than one order of magnitude lower than the one of the original fingerprint. A DESI source was adapted to sample ions at a distance up to 3 m [16]. The mass spectrometer and the DESI source were connected by a long stainless steel flexible ion transport tube (1.8 mm ID, 3.18 mm OD), which allows the transport of ions through air to the mass spectrometer after they leave the surface. The transport tube allows movement of the DESI source across the checked surface, looking for explosives. Methanol–water (70:30) doped with 10 mM NaCl was used as spray solvent, resulting in typical chloride adduct ions.
54
Yinon
(a) [RDX + 35Cl]– 257
Relative abundance
100
479 [2RDX + 35Cl]–
50
259 [RDX + 37Cl]– 331 [HMX + 35Cl]–
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350 m/z
400
481 [2RDX + 37Cl]– 450
500
550
600
(b) [RDX + 35Cl]– 257
Relative abundance
100
259 [RDX + 37Cl]– 331 [HMX + 35Cl]–
50
479 [2RDX + 35Cl]– 481 [2RDX + 37Cl]– 0 50
100
150
200
250
300 350 m/z
400
450
500
550
600
Fig. 9. (a) Negative ion desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) spectrum for a plastic explosive C-4 fingerprint on glass, using methanol–water–HCl (1:1:0.05%) as spray solvent. (b) Negative ion DESI spectrum of a C-4 fingerprint after five transfers onto a glass slide. Reproduced with permission from Cotte-Rodriguez et al. [14]. Copyright 2005 American Chemical Society.
Limits of detection at 1 m distance for TNT, RDX, HMX, TATP, and C-4, on different surfaces, were 0.5–1 ng (for PETN, 10 ng). At 3 m distance, the limits of detection were 5–10 ng (for PETN, 20 ng).
4. Miniature and mobile mass spectrometers Mass spectrometers were always considered too complex, too large and heavy, and too power-consuming, in order to be used as mobile explosive detectors. However, during the last 10 years, several groups have developed miniature and mobile mass spectrometers. Although these instruments were built for environmental applications, detection of chemical and biological weapons, and space exploration, most of them can easily be converted to detection of explosives. Sections 4.1–4.5 describe some of these mass spectrometers.
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
55
4.1. Quadrupole ion trap TOF mass spectrometer A 30-lb field-portable quadrupole ion trap TOF (QitTof) mass spectrometer with an atmospheric photoionization source was constructed [17]. The photoionization source has the ability to choose a narrow-band ionization energy that is sufficiently high to ionize and detect most compounds of interest but low enough to avoid ionization of most common air constituents, such as N2 � O2 � H2 O� CO2 , CO, Ar, etc. Fragmentation is minimal because ionization occurs just above the ionization thresholds, with very little excess energy. The ion trap stores ions from a continuous ionization source followed by pulsed extraction into the TOF mass analyzer. The QitTof mass spectrometer has MSn capability. Its mass resolution, m/�m, for mass 181 amu, ranges from 100–200 for a 22-cm flight-path linear TOF analyzer to 400 for a 38-cm coaxial reflectron configuration. Detection limits of 10–100 ppb for phosphonates and aromatic compounds were obtained.
4.2. Compact ion trap mass spectrometer A compact ion trap �ro = 10 mm� mass spectrometer was developed for space-based applications [18]. The trap was made of titanium; its hyperboloid surfaces were machined to a tolerance of 0.02 mm. Electron ionization was used by generating electrons from a heated, spiral-wound tungsten wire and accelerated at 75 eV into the trap. The trap operates in an RF only mode without DC. No cooling gas, such as helium, is required. Mass range was 1–300 amu and resolution m/�m = 324. The sensitivity of the trap was determined for N2 and was found to be 2 × 1014 counts/torr.s.
4.3. Mass analyzer based on rectilinear geometry ion trap A mass analyzer based on rectilinear geometry ion trap (RIT) was built [19]. The ion trap consists of two pairs (x and y) of rectangular electrodes supplied with RF voltages and a pair of z electrodes to which only a DC voltage is applied (Fig. 10). The RF signal is applied between the x and y electrode pairs and forms an RF trapping field in the xy plane, whereas the z electrode DC voltage generates a DC trapping potential well along the z axis. Slits in the RF electrodes and apertures in the z electrodes allow the electrons to be injected into the trap and ions to be ejected from the trap. As in the Paul trap, a buffer gas is used to facilitate trapping of ions through collisions. The half-distance between the x pair of electrodes �xo � and y pair of electrodes �yo � was 5.0 mm. The distance between the two z electrodes was 43.2 mm. The overall dimensional tolerance was ∼0�1 mm. Mass range was up to 650 amu and resolution in excess of 1000. Capabilities of the rectilinear trap included MS/MS.
56
Yinon
(a) Ceramic holder RF electrode - y
RF electrode - x z electrode
(b) RF/DC
Vacuum manifold
y0
e–
Filaments
RIT Assembly
X0
Electron ion gate
Electron multiplier AC+ GND
RF/DC
AC– GND
Fig. 10. Rectilinear geometry ion trap (RIT) assembly (a) and instrumentation (b) Reproduced with permission from Ouyang et al. [19]. Copyright 2004 American Chemical Society.
A handheld miniaturized mass spectrometer based on the RIT geometry was built [20]. It size is 13.5 inches (length) × 8.5 inches (width) × 7.5 inches (height) and weighs 10 kg, with a power consumption of less than 75 W.
4.4. Mass spectrometer with APCI A miniaturized mass spectrometer with APCI was built [21]. The analyzer was a monopole with 54 mm rod length and 2 mm radius. A two-stage differentially pumping system and sampling nozzle of 80 �m enabled an inlet gas flow rate of 1 ml/s. The ion current generated by the corona discharge was 0�01–10 �A. With a voltage of 20 V, U/V = 0�12 and a frequency of 5 MHz, a resolution of one mass unit in the range of 12–200 amu was obtained. The dimensions of the mass spectrometer were 185 × 100 × 70 mm, with a weight of 20 kg. For phosphorous-containing substances, the limit of detection was in the ppt region.
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
57
4.5. Cylindrical ion trap mass spectrometer with APCI and ESI A miniature cylindrical ion trap mass spectrometer with APCI and ESI capabilities was developed [22]. The system includes a three-stage, differentially pumped vacuum system and can be interfaced to many types of atmospheric pressure ionization sources. The cylindrical ion trap, machined from stainless steel, has a radius �ro � of 2.5 mm and a center to end-cap distance �zo � of 2.7 mm. Planar end-cap electrodes allow for ion entrance and exit through 1-mm-radius apertures. The instrument measured ∼46 × 50 × 38 cm, with a weight of 38 kg and 210 W power consumption while in operation. Performance of the instrument was investigated by using a corona discharge source and an ESI source. A mass range of 450 amu with unit mass resolution was obtained. Limits of detection for trace analysis in air of methyl salicylate (1.24 ppb) and for nitrobenzene (629 ppt) were achieved. Isolation and collision-induced dissociation efficiencies in MS/MS experiments were greater than 50%. Desorption electrospray ionization was implemented on this portable mass spectrome ter [23]. DESI experiments were carried out at ambient capillary temperature, at a spray voltage of 3 kV and a nebulizing N2 gas flow of 80–120 psi. Detection of RDX from three different surfaces (paper, plastic, and metal) was demonstrated with this portable instrument in the positive-ion mode, with an analysis time of 5–10 s. The result obtained for 10 ng of RDX deposited on 1-cm2 paper is shown in Fig 11(a). Figure 11(b) shows
(a)
(b) 223
100 [M + H]+
RDX
100
10 ng
500 pg
Relative abundance
LOD
[M + H]+ 223
50
50
0 100
200 m/z
300
320
360
400
0 80
120
160
200
240 m/z
280
400
Fig. 11. Positive-ion desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) mass spectrum of (a) 10 ng of RDX and (b) 500 pg of RDX. Reproduced with permission from Mulligan et al. [23].
58
Yinon
the mass spectrum obtained for 500 pg of RDX deposited on 1-cm2 paper, with the actual area sampled by the nebulizing spray being significantly smaller.
5. Conclusions Because of its high sensitivity and selectivity, mass spectrometry has always shown great potential for vapor and trace detection of explosives. Issues of size, portability, and power requirements have been addressed during the last years, and miniature and mobile mass spectrometers have been developed, based on a variety of mass analyzers. Also, different ionization techniques, such as ESI and DESI, have been applied for the detection of explosives. Integration of mass spectrometry with other technologies, i.e., bulk detection systems, would greatly enhance the detection capabilities of such integrated systems.
References [1] P. H. Dawson, Principles of operation. In: P. H. Dawson, ed., Quadrupole Mass Spectrometry and its Applications, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1976, pp. 9–64. [2] R. E. March and J. F. J. Todd, eds., Practical Aspects of Ion Trap Mass Spectrometry, Vol I: Fundamentals of Ion Trap Mass Spectrometry, CRC Press, Inc., Boca Raton, 1995. [3] M. Guilhaus, J. Mass Spectrom., 30 (1995) 1519. [4] R. Cotter, Anal. Chem., 64 (1992) 1027A. [5] J. Yinon, Modern Methods and Applications in Analysis of Explosives, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester, 1993. [6] Y. Takada, H. Nagano, M. Suga, Y. Hashimoto, M. Yamada, M. Sakairi, K. Kusumoto, T. Ota and J. Nakamura, Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics, 27 (2002) 224. [7] Anon, Hitachi Review, 53 (2004) 88. [8] R. B. Cody, J. A. Laramee, J. M. Nilles and H. Dupont Durst, JEOL News, 40 (2005) 8. [9] R. B. Cody, J. A. Laramee and H. Dupont Durst, Anal. Chem., 77 (2005) 2297. [10] R. Sleeman, S. L. Richards, I. F. A. Burton, J. G. Luke, W. R. Stott and W. R. Davidson, Detection of explosives residues on aircraft boarding passes. In: M. Krausa and A. A. Reznev, eds, Vapour and Trace Detection of Explosives for Anti-Terrorism Purposes, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 2004. pp. 133–142. [11] J. A. Syage, 57th Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, Orlando, FL, March 12–17, 2006. Paper No. 203–3. [12] K. Hanold, 54th ASMS Conference on Mass Spectrometry and Allied Topics, Seattle, WA, May 2006. [13] C. Mullen, A. Irwin, B. V. Pond, D. L. Huestis, M. J. Coggiola and H. Oser, Anal. Chem., 78 (2006) 3807. [14] I. Cotte-Rodriguez, Z. Takats, N. Talaty, H. Chen and R. G. Cooks, Anal. Chem., 77 (2005) 6755. [15] R. G. Cooks, Z. Ouyang, Z. Takats and J. M. Wiseman, Science, 311 (2006) 1566. [16] I. Cotte-Rodriguez and R. G. Cooks, Chem. Commun., 2968 (2006). [17] J. A. Syage, M. A. Hanning-Lee and K. A. Hanold, Field Anal. Chem. Technol., 4 (2000) 204. [18] O. J. Orient and A. Chutjian, Rev. Sci. Instr., 73 (2002) 2157.
Detection of Explosives by Mass Spectrometry
59
[19] Z. Ouyang, G. Wu, Y. Song, H. Li, W. R. Plass and R. G. Cooks, Anal. Chem., 76 (2004) 4595. [20] Z. Ouyang, R. G. Cooks, L. Gao, S. Kothari and S. Qingyu, 57th Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, Orlando, FL, March 12–17, 2006. Paper No. 2260–8. [21] A. L. Makas, M. L. Troshkov, A. S. Kudryavtsev and V. M. Lunin, J. Chromatogr. B, 800 (2004) 63. [22] B. C. Laughlin, C. C. Mulligan and R. G. Cooks, Anal. Chem., 77 (2005) 2928. [23] C. C. Mulligan, N. Talaty and R. G. Cooks, Chem. Commun., 1709 (2006).
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
Gary A. Eiceman, Hartwig Schmidt and Avi A. Cagan Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM 88003, USA
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. 61
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
63
2. Background and principles of DMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
67
3. Technology of DMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73
4. Studies of explosives by field asymmetric IMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
76
5. Explosives determination with a micro-fabricated differential mobility spectrometer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
78
6. Fast GC with DMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
80
7. The EGIS Defender: a commercial high-speed GC–DMS analyzer . . . . . . . . . . .
85
8. Next developments in DMS and IMS determinations of explosives . . . . . . . . . .
85
9. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
88
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
62
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
63
1. Introduction Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) is an instrumental method where sample vapors are ionized and gaseous ions derived from a sample are characterized for speed of movement as a swarm in an electric field [1]. The steps for both ion formation and ion characterization occur in most analytical mobility spectrometers at ambient pressure in a purified air atmosphere, and one attraction of this method is the simplicity of instrumentation without vacuum systems as found in mass spectrometers. Another attraction with this method is the chemical information gleaned from an IMS measurement including quantitative information, often with low limits of detection [2–4], and structural information or classification by chemical family [5,6]. Much of the value with a mobility spectrometer is the selectivity of response that is associated with gas-phase chemical reactions in air at ambient pressure where substance can be preferentially ionized and detected while matrix interferences can be eliminated or suppressed. In 2004, over 20 000 IMS-based analyzers such as those shown in Fig. 1 are placed at airports and other sensitive locations worldwide as commercially available instruments for the determination of explosives at trace concentration [7]. In mobility spectrometers, including differential mobility spectrometers [8–10], ions are characterized for mobility as shown in Fig. 2, where an ion swarm or packet of ions develops a velocity in an electric field, established in a fixed distance between two potentials. This drift velocity vd , when normalized for field strength vd /E, is termed the mobility coefficient K, and common magnitudes of these are 1–4 m/s for drift velocity and 25–15 cm2 /V s for mobility coefficients. Commonly, the mobility coefficient is adjusted for temperature and pressure yielding a reduced mobility coefficient, Ko , referenced to 760 torr and 273 K. The measurement of drift velocity occurs inside a drift tube (Fig. 2) where a set of conducting rings is used to establish the electric field and maintain a level of homogeneity in the field [11,12]. In an IMS measurement, ions
Fig. 1. Two commercial ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) explosive detectors used at airports worldwide: the Itemiser3 (GE Ion Track, (GE Security, Wilmington, MA, USA)) and the IONSCAN (Smiths Detection (Mississauga, Ontario, Canada)).
64
Eiceman et al.
vd = length/drift time K = vd /E E
Shutter
Ion source
Drift region
0
Drift time (ms)
20
Fig. 2. Schematic representation of a mobility spectrometer. Ions created in the ion source are separated in the drift region based on their mobility. The ion swarms reach the detector where their drift times are recorded and plotted in the form of a mobility spectrum (Originally published in the article of Buryakov et al. [9]).
are introduced into the drift region using an ion shutter, which is commonly a set of parallelly interdigitated wires in a plane or as close to a plane as possible [12]. Electric fields are established between adjacent wires in the shutter so ion passage down the voltage gradient of the drift tube and through the shutter, which spans the cross-section of the drift tube, is stopped by ion annihilation on the wires. When the wires are brought to a common potential appropriate for the position of the wires in the voltage gradient, ions pass through the shutter; as the fields in the shutter are re-established, ion passage is again stopped forming an ion swarm or pulse of ions for mobility analysis,with width defined by the timing of the ion shutter. Pulse widths are commonly 50–300 s and occur on a 10–30 Hz basis. This highlights another advantage of IMS, comparatively fast determinations, where sample preparation and introduction into the drift tube are often the slowest or limiting steps in the analysis. When an ion swarm is injected into the drift region of the drift tube, spatial resolution of ions of differing mobility can be separated as differences in drift velocity as the ions move toward the detector, here at virtual ground. Separate packets or swarms of ions develop with the separation as shown in Fig. 2, where three ion swarms have been resolved in time and space. As ions collide with the detector, commonly a simple metal disc or Faraday plate, neutralization of ions is accompanied by electron flow in the detector plate; this is amplified and shown in the inset of Fig. 2. Thisplot of detector response(current or voltage) versus time (in ms) is called a mobility spectrum and is the
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
65
O2–(H2O)n(N2)x – –
–
K = vd /E
–
K = (3e /16N )(2π/μkTeff)1/2[(1 + α)/ΩD(Teff)] ΩD = O2–(H2O)n(N2)x Fig. 3. The mobility coefficient K describing the movement of an ion swarm in an electric field. The mobility coefficient depends on the cross-section (collision area) , the reduced mass , and the effective temperature Teff of the ion. Collision area D will depend on moisture, temperature, drift gas, and molecule.
source of drift time (hence drift velocity) and Ko values, quantitative response as peak height or area, and performance of the analyzer as peak width and shape. The basis for mobility is shown in Fig. 3, where a link is made between the structure of individual ions and the drift velocity of the ion swarm. These are joined effectively by ion cross-section of collision D , reduced mass , and effective temperature of the ion Teff . The relationship is directly suitable for ions in a supporting atmosphere where ions do not form associations [13] with molecules that are strongly polarizable or contain permanent dipoles [14,15]. In this instance, increased temperature of the gas atmosphere leads to diminished mobility through increases in ion drag with increased collision frequency from increased speed of gas molecules. By contrast, negative ions formed in an IMS ion source in air with even low ppm levels of moisture will form cluster ions where O2 − , the core ion at the center of a cluster, is surrounded by polar neutrals such as water as shown in Fig. 3. These associations occur through dipole charge or charge-induced dipole interactions, forming O2 − H2 On species, where n is controlled by temperature and moisture of the gas environment [16,17]. The interactions between water adducts and the core ion can be substantial leading to stable cluster identities; however, the addition or loss of adducts also can be highly dynamic increasing cluster size as association enthalpies decrease. Additionally, the buffer gas can be viewed as part of the cluster even though the associations may be very weak solely through the large number of collisions or high collision frequency. Clustered ions may be dissociated with heat, and the core ion of O2 − or Cl− could be regarded as thoroughly declustered with sufficient temperature or reduced moisture. The heat of association between H+ and H2 O is so large that the terminal ion at elevated temperature and reduced moisture in positive polarity in IMS will be H3 O+ . When an ion is declustered extensively with increases in gas temperature, a decrease in ion size (seen as D ) is observed, and mobility, as K or Ko , will be increased. This is apparently contradictory to the formula in Fig. 3, where K decreases with an increase in Teff . Karpas highlighted the balance between D and Teff where mobility with ions of mass >100–150 will be governed by Teff even in an air atmosphere and elevated temperature [18]. However, the collision cross-section
66
Eiceman et al.
D will be the controlling parameter with ions of mass <100–120 in an air atmosphere as ions cluster at low temperature and decluster at elevated temperature. This is not observed, as expected, in non-clustering atmospheres such as argon or helium, and in inert atmospheres, changes in temperature are described in the formula principally by Teff . Suchdiscoveries were seen as consistent [19] with the emerging technology of differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) and field-dependent behavior as described in this chapter. Attention to these parameters with control of temperature, moisture, and ion residence time in drift tubes for IMS presents requirements for reliable operation and the collection of valid data; failures to control the purity and consistency of the supporting gas atmosphere in the ionization and drift regions will make the method unreliable and unpredictable. The fine engineering, seen with instruments such as those shown in Fig. 1, illustrates that such control is possible and commercially viable and that IMS analyzers have been entrusted with the security of commercial aviation. Ion mobility spectrometry as a research tool and an analytical method has undergone a transformation since 1990 [1] and is today understood as a powerful supplement to mass spectrometry (MS) for biological studies [20] and as a robust, field instrument as a standalone analyzer.This transformation is due in large part to the successful utilization of IMS analyzers for explosives monitoring and for detection of chemical warfare agents [7]. Also, changes have occurred in understandings of the principles of IMS and the level of technology as illustrated in comparisons between the earliest summary of IMS (an edited monograph [21]) and the first integrated summary of IMS [22] and then the most recent edition of the same [1]. Although a progression of science and technology for IMS has occurred since 1970 when the first analytical IMS analyzer was described [23], there are still very few applications for IMS that eclipse military and security analyses and few prospects evident on the horizon of commercial activity. Still, no other advanced technology is used in such large numbers or in such mission-critical applications as mobility spectrometers. Recent reviews will provide a broadened perspective on these comments [24–27]. The first step in response in an IMS analyzer is the conversion of a sample neutral to a gas-phase ion through coulombic associations resembling displacement reactions as shown in Eqs 1 and 2 for positive and negative polarity, respectively. M
Sample neutral
M
Sample neutral
+ H+ H2 On → M H+ H2 On−x + xH2 O Positive reactant ion
− + O− 2 H2 On → M O2 H2 On−x + xH2 O Negative reactant ion
(1)
Positive product ion
(2)
Negative product ion
These occur simultaneously in the ion source, and heretofore, the user chooses the polarity for analysis.Because properties of ionization of substances including explosives can sometimes be favored in one polarity over the other, a restriction to measuring a single polarity is not a minor limitation or simply an inconvenience. One of the key limitations with all mobility spectrometers, until recently, has been the use of either positive or negative charge singly in the mobility measurement providing chemical information for one ion polarity only while that for the other is lost. In the early 1990s,
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
67
a solution to this was sought where two drift tubes shared a common ionization region and tubes were biased positive or negative with maximum potential at the detectors that were opto-isolated to an amplifier [28]. This design was termed the twin drift tube design, and a single sample, introduced to the analyzer, was simultaneously screened for positive and negative ions with two drift tubes of identical structure and a shared timing cycle for the ion shutters. This concept has now been commercialized in 2005, 15 years later, as the model IONSCAN 500DT from Smiths Detection [29]. Explosive analyzers based on IMS are popular as benchtop instruments that are transportable but not man-portable, and recent developments have been successful in making hand-held explosive analyzers [30]. Even so, these are still comparatively large and heavy due in large part to the size and mass of the drift tube and are expensive, though IMS analyzers are economical compared with mass spectrometers. In the late 1990s, efforts were made to create small drift tubes based on principles of mobility but unlike traditional drift tubes or methods. This new generation of analyzers was based on micro-fabrication techniques and was operated using field-dependent behavior of ions in gases. This was applied to the determination of explosives and has been extended from the early successes as described in this chapter.
2. Background and principles of DMS Early in the first part of the twentieth century, studies with ions in gases revealed mobility concepts as described in Section 1 and also showed that mobility coefficients could be changed by E/p, where p is the gas pressure inside theanalyzer [31–33]. This is shown in Fig. 4, where the mobility coefficients of alkali ions are plotted against E/p: mobility is constant for most ions up to certain values for E/p, after which the ion is linearly dependent in mobility upon E/p. Both the point where the curve breaks from a plateau to a slope and the slope of the plot are characteristic of an ion (in a given gas environment). In the instance of Cs+ , there is no level portion for the plot, and a positive slope exists from the lowest measured value for E/p. The cause for this is understood as the heating of ions through the electric field and declustering of ions, a decrease in D with increased Teff . Today, E/p has been replaced by E/N , where N is the number density for atoms in a gas, though interconversion between E/p and E/N is inconvenient [34]. In one obscure reference [35], a method for field-dependent ion characterization came very close to an analytical method though the subject of field dependence of ion mobility was apparently overlooked, forgotten, or ignored until the mid 1980s. In the early to mid 1980s, the characterization of ions with field dependence of mobility was treated theoretically [36] and was based on the following concept: if ions had the same mobility but differing dependence of mobility with E/N , then the characteristic differences in mobility could be a basis for ion separation. Thus, a complete expression of mobility is shown in Eq. 3, where the mobility coefficient contains a non-linear
68
Eiceman et al.
5.2
Li+
p
(WE )
4.4
+
NH3
Mobility
3.6 Na+ +
K Na+(NH3) 2.8
Rb+ Cs+
2.0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
E/p Fig. 4. Plots of mobility versus E/p for ions in helium (originally published in the article of Mitchell and Ridler [33]).
dependence on an electric field, and pressure (or E/N ) is derived from plots such as those shown in Fig. 5: KE = K0 1 + 2
E N
2 + 4
E N
4 +
E = K0 1 + N
(3)
where K(0) is the mobility coefficient for electric field below 1000 V/cm, i parameters are functions that describe the dependence of K on the electric field, N is neutral density of drift gas in molecules/cm3 , and the electric field strengths at ambient pressure can be as large as 30 000 V/cm. The alpha parameter can be understood as shown in Eq. 4, where an alpha parameter describes the changes in the mobility coefficient with E for a constant N :
KE − K0 KE E = = N K0 K0
(4)
Thus, alpha is associated with a difference in mobility of the ion may be positive or negative in sign, which discloses the direction of change in the coefficient of mobility (and compensation voltage) with E at constant N . In practice, ions are characterized by
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
69
6
Alpha *100
NT 4 DNT 2
TNT 0 0
40
80
120
160
E /N (Td) Fig. 5. Alpha functions of nitrotoluene (NT), dinitrotoluene (DNT), and trinitrotoluene (TNT).
repeatedly placing ions at high and low fields obtaining a differential mobility of K, seen in Fig. 5 as different mobilities with E/N . The practice of differential mobility determinations was demonstrated in 1993 by a team in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, who developed a method that was both practical and potentially scalable to miniaturized dimensions [8–10]. This approach is shown in Fig. 6, where ions are introduced with a gas flow between two plates separated by a distance from 0.5 mm to 0.1 cm. Ions entering the volume between the plates are exposed to an oscillating electric field shown in the inset of Fig. 6. This field, in the instance of small planar analyzers, is ∼14 MHz and generated by voltages of 1000–100 V (fields of 1–30 kV/cm). During the high-field portion of the waveform, the ions move, under the formula vd = KE/N × E, in the direction of the ground plate (the top electrode). During the low-field portion, the ion is restored toward the bottom plate, now negative, according to formula vd = KE/N × E, where K(E/N) and E differ from the high-field portion. The waveform is arranged so that ions moving, under the formula vd = KE/N × E, will have no net displacement from the center of the gap if K(E/N) is not dependent on E/N . However, if the coefficient of mobility is dependent on E/N as shown in Fig. 5, a net displacement toward a plate will occur, and eventually, the ion will collide with the plate. The estimated maximum number of oscillations is ∼103 for an ion spending ∼1 ms in the analyzer region. Ions with large differences in K(E/N) or high K will reach the wall after a lower number of oscillations compared with an ion with low K between two values of E/N . Ions with negative dependence of mobility on K(E/N), where the mobility decreases with increased field strength, will move in directions opposite to those with positive alpha. Without intervention, all ions apart from those with no dependence of mobility on field will strike a wall, be neutralized, and be swept as a neutral from the analyzer. However, a DC voltage (the compensation voltage) can be added to the bottom electrode and superimposed on the megahertz waveform (Fig. 6). As this potential is applied, ion
70
Eiceman et al.
Ground
Top electrode
α>0
t2
Gas flow from ion source
To detector
α=0 α<0
t1
Bottom electrode
Add DC here
E1t1
Field
Waveform generator
E2t 2
– +
Ground
U (V)
100 50 0 –50 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
Time (μs)
Fig. 6. Schematic of a differential mobility spectrometer showing the principles of ion separation in a differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) drift tube. Ion paths are governed by both the asymmetric electric field and field dependence of mobility for an ion. The inset displays the asymmetric waveform of separation electric field used in the DMS drift tube. The waveforms shown are theoretical (top part) and actual or experimental (bottom part) used in these experiments.
displacement between the plates can be affected and a certain potential may be found for each ion to be restored in displacement to the center of the channel. This DC voltage is also known as the compensation voltage, and a sweep of compensation voltage will, in increments, bring ions with characteristic dependences into the center of the gas flow and to the detector. Detectors are commonly Faraday plates, and a plot of detector current against compensation voltage yields a differential mobility spectrum. This is shown in Fig. 7, where the polarity of compensation voltage is associated with positive or negative dependences of K on E/N . The magnitude of compensation voltage is proportional to K as shown in Fig. 7. As ions formed from sample differ in mass and in K, in principle, each ion should have a characteristic compensation voltage for constant conditions or a unique plot of K versus E/N providing DMS with capabilities for ion separation. The principle for alpha dependence is rooted in ion behavior through collisions and associations with molecules of the supporting atmosphere, and a comprehensive treatment has been given. In summary, ions that exhibit a positive dependence of K on E/N can be understood to undergo clustering and declustering events as shown in Fig. 8. During a low-field portion of the waveform, ions are not electrically heated or are slightly over thermal energies, and associations with water and supporting atmosphere can occur with lifetimes proportional to the heats of association. These associations result in increases in D and decreases
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
Ion intensity (V)
4
71
Proton bound dimer
3
+ΔK
–ΔK
2 Protonated monomer 1 –20
–15
–10
–5
0
5
10
Compensation voltage (V) Fig. 7. Differential mobility spectra (intensity vs. compensation voltage plot). The relationship between K and the compensation voltage is shown for ions with positive and negative alpha functions.
–
–
Kh
Kh
–
– E1 t1
Kl
t2E2
Kl
Fig. 8. Model for positive alpha with increasing electric field. During the high-field part of the duty cycle E1 , ions are declustered, leading to an increase in mobility Kh due to a decrease in . During the low-field part of the duty cycle E2 , ions are re-clustered, leading to a decrease in mobility Kl Kh > Kl due to an increase in h < l . With this model, a positive K may be expected.
in K (Fig. 3). As an ion is exposed to the high-field portion of the waveform, the ion is no longer at or near thermal energies and the energy of the field causes an increase in Teff . Although this will cause a small decrease in K due to drag, the greater effect is declustering with a decrease in D and an increase in K. Consequently, the K and alpha function are positive. Ions that exhibit negative alpha and negative K will be those where clustering and declustering exert a negligible effect and where ion drag through increased collision frequency dominates ion behavior as Teff is increased. This is true of large ions and is seen principally for ions with masses over 150 amu, consistent with Karpas’ early observation on the balance between Teff and D in supporting atmospheres where clustering was possible [18]. The mechanism of clustering and declustering for ions with positive alphas was developed and supported by results from the study of the changes in alpha functions with moisture in the gas atmosphere in the DMS analyzer [37,38]. Gas-phase protonated
72
Eiceman et al.
monomers MH+ H2 On and proton-bound dimers M2 H+ H2 On of organophosphorus compounds were evaluated for alpha functions between 0 and 140 Td at ambient pressure in air with moisture between 0.1 and 15 000 ppm. The alpha function for MH+ H2 On at 140 Td was constant from 0.1 to 10 ppm moisture in air. However, at 50 ppm, a dependence of alpha with moisture was observed and alpha increased twofold from 100 to 1000 ppm regardless of E/N . At moisture values between 1000 and 10 000 ppm, an additional twofold increase in E was observed. In a model proposed here, field dependence for mobility through changes in collision cross-sections is governed by the degree of solvation of the protonated molecule by neutral molecules. The level of 50 ppm matched closely the need for a collision between the ion and a water molecule and the time available during the low-field portion of the RF separating field. Additionally, increases in temperature of the DMS analyzer suppress alpha plots illustrating that a declustered ion at high gas temperature will be weakly clustered, if any, during the lowfield cycle. Consequently, control of moisture in a DMS experiment is as important as that in an IMS measurement; however, the direction of degraded response is somewhat different – DMS separations are improved with increased moisture. In an IMS analyzer, increases in moisture tend to degrade peak shape. The first description of a differential mobility spectrometer is shown in Fig. 9 with a schematic from the 1993 article by Buryakov et al. [8–10]. Subsequently, the technology from this team was migrated to the USA [39] and then Canada [40] as field asymmetric ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) with a cylindrical design for the analyzer. The FAIMS analyzer was attached to a mass spectrometer [41], and a line of study on large instrumentation was begun where the FAIMS was an ion filter for the mass spectrometer in environmental and biological studies [42–44]. Refinements were made and a commercial inlet for mass spectrometers was introduced [45], but no determinations with
Voltage generator Compressor Ionization chamber Dosimeter
Inlet
‘+’
Ion separator
3 Ion collector
SI-source β-source
Amplifier
‘y’
‘x’ Recorder
Fig. 9. Experimental arrangement used in one of the first differential mobility spectrometers (originally published in the article of Buryakov et al. [9]).
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
73
Fig. 10. Planar micro-fabricated differential mobility spectrometer. The photograph shows the device in comparison to a quarter (adapted from the article of Miller et al. [47]); the inset shows the size of the drift region 4 mm × 12 mm and the size of the detectors 4 mm × 4 mm.
explosives were made by either team. However, a similar cylindrical design was refined or developed independently in Russia and applied for explosive detection (see pp. 76ff.). The development of a micro-fabricated analyzer employing field-dependent mobility or differential mobility methods [46,47] was developed for simple motivations of small size, high portability, and low cost. In this approach, a planar configuration for the region of ion characterization was employed (similar to the first DMS manuscript [9]) to permit micro-fabrication methods where analyzers could be produced using mass production techniques. A photograph of the original glass-based drift tube is shown in Fig. 10, and planar units built using ceramic from designs at New Mexico State University (NMSU) are shown in Fig. 10 (inset). Here, the inside surfaces of the analyzer are shown. The detector is a 4 mm × 4 mm square metal plate, and the region for ion separation is a rectangular metal plate with dimensions of 4 mm × 12 mm.
3. Technology of DMS Differential mobility spectrometers are attractive through the mechanical simplicity of an analyzer assembly without ion shutters, an aperture grid, or multiple components to establish a voltage gradient to move ions as found in conventional IMS drift
74
Eiceman et al.
tubes. Moreover, fabrication of DMS analyzers with planar designs is both uncomplicated and comparatively inexpensive with micro-fabricated production methods. Instead, requirements for sophistication are transferred to the technology or design of electronics to generate a ∼12 MHz asymmetric waveform with electric fields reaching 20 000– 30 000 V/cm.
3.1. Ion source The formation of ions from explosives in IMS and DMS, the first step in the instrumental response, has been reviewed [48] and commonly is based on the reactions between sample vapors and gas-phase ions from the supporting or internal atmosphere of the analyzer as shown in Eqs 1 and 2. The ion source used in most DMS experiments has been a metal foil containing a few millicuries of 63 Ni, and this source produces beta particles having a mean energy of 16 keV. The high-energy electrons collide with nitrogen and oxygen in air and through a series of ion-molecule reactions result in the formation of long-lived ions, or reactant ions, with comparatively high density of 1010 ion/cm3 [49]. Generally, the reactant ions in negative polarity are thermalized electrons in nitrogen or O2 − O2 − H2 O, and O2 − H2 O2 , or CO2 − and CO4 − , and their hydrates in air. Selectivity and sensitivity in response can be enhanced in IMS analyzers by the addition of a reagent gas into the gas atmosphere to form alternate reactant ions. The reagent gases, or dopant chemicals, are typically volatile organic compounds or substances that when heated release vapors. The reagent gases undergo reactions also in the ion source yielding alternate reactant ions such as Br − or Cl− . All response in an IMS or a DMS analyzer begins with the formation of an association between the substance and the reactant ion as shown in Eq. 2 for negative polarity. Subsequently, the product ion can undergo further reaction steps as shown for two possible pathways in Eqs 5 and 6 and summarized in whole in Fig. 11. Charge exchange: M Cl− H2 On−x → M− + Cl + n − xH2 O
(5)
Negative product ion
Proton abstraction: M Cl− H2 On−x → M − 1− + HCl + n − xH2 O
(6)
Negative product ion
All of these reactions occur in the ion source without user intervention or effort, an understood advantage of IMS and DMS technology. Although the chemistry in Fig. 11 is shown for a purified air atmosphere, the reagent gas and reactant ions (with O2 − replaced by Cl− ) assist in suppressing response to background interferences and in simplifying response by directing ion chemistry through only one or two paths of Fig. 11. Thus, ion sources for DMS and IMS will be equipped with a reservoir of chemical, which normally should be thermostated or controlled so that vapor levels of the reagent gas are
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
75
[M•O2–(H2O)n(N2)x]
[M– •(H2O)n(N2)x]
–
– [M•O2–(H2O)n(N2)x]*
– – – [NO2– •(H2O)n(N2)x] [M•Cl–(H2O)n(N2)x]*
[(M – 1)– •(H2O)n(N2)x]
Fig. 11. Overview of different reaction pathways that an ion [M • O2 − H2 On N2 x ]∗ can take.
constant and reproducible. Recently, Hill et al. demonstrated the value of electrospray ionization with controlling ion chemistry with explosives determination by IMS [50,51]. The benefits of this method are difficult to imagine for on-site use with routine screenings owing to the operation of an electrospray ionization (ESI) source with condensed phase, i.e., aqueous solution.
3.2. Analyzer The analyzer in Fig. 10 was the first micro-fabricated DMS analyzer and is shown independent of the housing, ion source, flow and power utilities, and data system. The plates of the units built at NMSU are held between two aluminum (Al) supports with Teflon cushions and insulators between the Al housing and the DMS plates and a 0.5-mm-thick gasket to separate plates and direct gas flow and ion through the analyzer.
3.3. Utilities Flows of purified gases, scrubbed over molecule sieves, are passed into the DMS analyzer at flows of 0.3–1.2 L/min usually with a mass flow controller. Pressure is near ambient; however, DMS analyzers can operate at reduced pressures with scaled values of E as expected with E/N . The electronics of the DMS analyzer are based on a fly back transformer to give the RF waveform.
3.4. Combination to gas chromatograph Because differential mobility spectrometers like IMS analyzers function at ambient pressure in air or nitrogen, combinations with gas chromatograph inlets are technically
76
Eiceman et al.
uncomplicated and are relevant only for proper flow dynamics and elimination of contamination. A major source of contamination with modern fused-silica capillary columns is the thin protective polymer, a polyimide, that if heated over 60 C will release vapors that become unintended reagent gases and alter the ion chemistry. Consequently, an Al-clad column is used as a bridge between the gas chromatography (GC) and the DMS flow system. Naturally, the interface region must be warmed to prevent condensation of low vapor pressure constituents including explosives. Early studies on GC–DMS configurations demonstrated that extra-column broadening between the DMS analyzer and a commercial flame ionization detector (FID) detector was nearly the same for a prototype design. Subsequently, GC–DMS configurations have been used in research and form the basis for the commercial DMS analyzer, the commercial GC–DMS analyzer, and the EGISTM Defender, as described in Section 4.
4. Studies of explosives by field asymmetric IMS Differential mobility spectrometry has been known by several names, including drift spectrometry and field asymmetric IMS, though the principles are shared in common with DMS and these other methods; various analyzers have common features though they differ in geometries and sizes. Unsurprisingly, explosives were examined by these other methods, and Buryakov et al. [52] found that ions for dinitrotoluene (DNT), trinitrotoluene (TNT), and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) could be separated (Fig. 12(c) and (d)) using a cylindrical configuration for the analyzer (Fig. 12(a)) in contrast to parallel plates [9]. The separation of negative ions was made in a supporting atmosphere of air with ∼4% relative humidity yielding baseline separation of peaks for ions formed at 120 C and passed through the characterization region with a gas temperature that was undisclosed but possibly nearly room temperature. The ions showed large dependence of Vc on Vrf and differences in dependence with separating fields up to ∼18 kV/cm and a frequency of 160 kHz. In this first study, the response of the analyzer with respect to separating field and temperature of the ion source was characterized and optimized. The effect of water concentration in the gas atmosphere on the response was also noted or observed without reference to the effects of moisture on the position of peaks (i.e., the compensation voltages). The level of moisture will be seen as critical in the operation of field-dependent mobility instruments. In a second report on FAIMS response to explosives [53], Buryakov extended the studies with a cylindrical tube to nitrobenzenes and nitrotoluenes, and plots of alpha versus E/N plots were determined (Fig. 12) and found that the alpha followed the relationship TNT < trinitrobenzene < DNT < dinitrobenzene < mononitrotoluene (MNT) < iodine. Ions for all these showed positive alpha coefficients for the negative ions (presumably M− M − 1− , or M∗ XH2 On − species) though the TNT began to exhibit a negative dependence at the highest separating fields. This was consistent with a condition where the effects from ion cluster–decluster were greater than the effects of ion drag on mobility. These plots would be confirmed with a micro-fabricated DMS analyzer though
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry (a)
77
(b) 1
1 11
4 5
10
2
2 3
9
6
7
8 9
I
τ
4
3
5
6
8
Uc
7
Ud
Ud P
10 Qt I, A
11
tR, s Uc, V
(c)
(d) 4 15
DNT
– DNT
10
TNT
2
– TNT
Uc, V
I, 10–13 A
3
– PETN 5
1
PETN
0
0 0
5
10
15
20
Uc, V
0
–1
–2
–3
–4
Ud, kV
Fig. 12. (a) Schematic diagram of the differential mobility spectrometer (top left): 1, laboratory air; 2, water; 3, explosive; 4, ionization chamber; 5, field inlet; 6, separation chamber; 7, dividing voltage generator; 8, compensating voltage generator; 9, electrometer; 10, ion collector; and 11, gas filter (originally published in the article of Buryakov et al. [52], translated from Zhurnal Analiticheskoi Khimii, 56(4) (2001) 381). (b) Flow chart of the gas chromatography–differential mobility spectrometry (GC–DMS) system (top right): 1, sample injector; 2, thermostat; 3, multi-capillary column; 4, ionization chamber; 5, 63 Ni source of beta radiation; 6, field inlet; 7, separation chamber; 8, electrodes; 9, drift voltage generator; 10, electrometer; and 11, compensation voltage source (originally published in the article of Buryakov and Kolomiets [54], translated from Zhurnal Analiticheskoi Khimii, 58(10) (2003) 1057). (c) Differential mobility spectrum of ambient air containing dinitrotoluene (DNT), trinitrotoluene (TNT), and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) vapors (bottom left). (d) Experimental plots of compensating voltage against the amplitude of separation voltage for DNT, TNT, and PETN (bottom right, both originally published in the article of Buryakov et al. [52], translated from Zhurnal Analiticheskoi Khimii, 56(4) (2001) 381; in the original reference, the instrument is termed ion drift non-linearity spectrometer).
the effects here were exaggerated owing to the high levels of moisture in the supporting atmosphere. In an article on drift tubes of comparatively large size and a cylindrical geometry [54], Buryakov and Kolomiets combined a multi-capillary column [55,56] with the analyzer to obtain measurements and quantitative response curves with a GC–DMS configuration.
78
Eiceman et al.
The gas chromatograph as inlet (Fig. 12(b)) permitted reliable delivery of amounts of explosives to the analyzer, and limits of detection were reported as <2 pg for TNT and <4 pg for PETN. The measurements were comparatively fast with most explosives eluted in times below several minutes, some as low as 9 s (for DNT) and none more than 4 min (for PETN). These early findings with field-dependent mobility instrumentation suggested that the favorable chemistry of IMS could be combined with the simple instrumentation of FAIMS or DMS and that the strong electric fields show no ill effect on gas-phase ions for explosives. The next step in development with field-dependent mobility instruments was a micro-fabricated DMS analyzer.
5. Explosives determination with a micro-fabricated differential mobility spectrometer The micro-fabricated DMS analyzer described in Section 2 and shown in Fig. 10 was used as a stand-alone analyzer to determine both quantitative response and spectral profiles for nitro-organic explosives [57]. Unlike the studies with the cylindrical drift tube with comparatively moist air atmosphere inside the analyzer as described in Section 4, peaks in differential mobility spectra with purified air at comparatively low moisture of ∼1 ppm were confined to a narrow range of compensation voltages from −1 to +3 V [fields of 20–60 V/cm with separating fields at E/N values up to 1200 V (24 kV/cm) or 120 Td]. All spectra exhibited one intense peak, and the absence of peaks between 5 and 20 V showed that fragmentation was a minor pathway in ionization though fragment ion was barely discernible for 1,2,3-propanetriol trinitrate (nitroglycerin, or NG) (at 14 V) and peaks of low intensity for PETN (also at 14 V). The ions with the product ions were identified with a DMS analyzer fitted to a mass spectrometer, and the product ions observed with a 63 Ni ion source at ambient pressure in purified air at 100 C were M− M∗ NO2 − , or M − 1− , as expected for these chemicals from previous decades of experience with IMS/MS investigations. Product ion peaks were concentration dependent, but ion identity and compensation voltages were independent of analyte concentration. The compression of peaks for explosives with the small planar DMS in dried air to a narrow band of compensation voltages was analytically limiting and was consistent with the model of cluster–decluster for ions with positive alphas. The level of moisture was too low to permit ion hydration during the low-field portion of the waveform; however, the alpha function was understood to be adjustable through the controlled addition of a polar or polarizable neutral into the supporting atmosphere. This had been seen earlier for organophosphorous compounds and could be associated quantitatively with collision frequencies between ions and water molecules to form water clusters during the 280-ns period of low electric field strength. During the high-field portion of the waveform, the ions would be desolvated providing a difference in mobility constant with decreased collision area. Various dopants affected compensation voltages for DNT, and methylene chloride was shown to favorably enhance alpha for all explosives tested as shown in Fig. 13, where alpha functions were increased to values of 0.08–0.24 (at 100 Td), from
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
79
(a)
Without modifier
With modifier
NG DNT DNB TNT PETN
0.20 0.15
NG DNT DNB TNT PETN
0.10 0.05 0.00 0
40
80
120 0
40
80
120
E /N (Td)
(b) NG
NG
DNB
0
10 CV
DNB
DNT
DNT
TNT
TNT
PETN
PETN
20
0
10
20
CV
Fig. 13. (a) Alpha functions [alpha vs. E (Td)] of the explosives ions in pure air (top left) and a 1000 ppm mixture of methylene chloride/air (top right) [57]. (b) Differential mobility spectra of the explosives in purified air (bottom left) and 1000 ppm of methylene chloride in air (bottom right). Explosives are from top: 1,2,3propanetriol trinitrate (NG); 1,3-dinitrobenzene (DNB); 2,6-dinitrotoluene (DNT); 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT); and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) [57].
80
Eiceman et al. 4 -
-
Mobility (a.u.)
3
2
1
0
50
100
E /N (Td) Fig. 14. Mobility versus E/N , showing the change of the mobility coefficient K as the ions are clustered through the addition of a dopant (e.g., methylene chloride). Under high-field conditions, K stays practically unaltered, whereas under low-field conditions, K is decreased, which leads to an increase in K.
the clean gas values of 0.0–0.01, through the addition of 1000 ppm of methylene chloride to the drift gas. This improved separation of ions as shown in differential mobility spectra of Fig. 13 was understood as a consequence of the formation of ion clusters between product ions and vapor neutrals of the modifying gas during the low-field portion of the separation field waveform. The core ion when heated and unclustered during the high-field portion of waveform was affected in mobility to a lesser degree increasing
K and compensation voltages. Consequently, the effect of the reagent is to wet or solvate the ion at low field as shown in Fig. 14. The addition of methylene chloride had the effect of improving the separation of peaks in the differential mobility spectrum without altering the identity of the core ion, M− M − 1− , or other. Quantitative response curves for the nitrobenzenes and nitrotoluenes were obtained for a continuous vapor stream of chemical in air and the plots extended from 0.1 to 100 ppb with an anticipated systematic error from surface adsorption at low vapor concentrations. At the high concentrations, the curves begin to flatten as seen with all IMS and DMS response owing to saturation of the ion source region, a complication in all uses of gas-phase ion chemistry with sources at ambient pressure. Detection limits from the micro-fabricated DMS analyzer were suggestive of suitable analytical performance for a trace explosives detector [57].
6. Fast GC with DMS Traditionally, the majority of explosives monitors rely on the detection exclusively of negative ions due to the strong Coulomb interactions with negative ions (expressed as high electron affinity) of many, but not all, of the target molecules and comparatively low associations of matrix interferences with the negative reactant ion. One of the benefits of
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
81
DMS, not previously developed for explosives detection, is the simultaneous detection of ions of both polarities. This is seen in Fig. 15(a)–(d) for triacetone triperoxide (TATP), hexamethylene triperoxide diamine (HMTD), 4-MNT, and TNT in which product ions can be seen for TATP and 4-MNT only in positive polarity and for TNT only in negative polarity. Thus, a DMS analyzer operated would see ions for each of these compounds. The changes in intensity for reactant ion peaks (RIPs), however, suggest that reactions may occur in both polarities, but the product ions are unstable on the time scale of observation. For example, the negative RIP for 4-MNT (Fig. 15(c)) is decreased by nearly 50% with exposure to chemical vapor suggesting that O2 − ions are attaching to the 4-MNT molecules. However, the absence of product ions suggests that the adduct M∗ O2 − is undergoing simple dissociation without proton abstraction or charge transfer. This can also be seen slightly with TNT (cf. Fig. 15(d)), where the positive RIP is depressed slightly with increased concentration, but no positive ions appear in the differential mobility spectrum. Thus, MH+ H2 On apparently was formed but did not survive until reaching the detector. Such observations have not been made previously. In some instances, a chemical will form stable product ions with positive and negative reactant ions, and these can be seen simultaneously in a planar DMS scan as shown for HMTD in Fig. 15(b). In this instance, a positive product ion can be seen at 5.5 V and a negative ion at 7.8 V. The selectivity of ionization and the benefit of detection of dual ions may not fully protect analytical response from interferences, and in a step to even more rugged response, pre-fractionation through chromatographic methods was applied. The analytical result from a GC–DMS analysis of a mixture of explosives is shown in Fig. 16, where seven explosives were separated and detected within 3 min. The results from the measurement are displayed as topographic plots of retention time (x-axis), compensation voltage (y-axis), and ion intensity (z-axis), and each substance exhibited specific retention times and compensation voltages with ions in one or the other polarity, occasionally both polarities. Thus, the gas chromatograph provided an additional dimension of information in the retention time, e.g., ∼15 s for HMTD, ∼ 25 s for ethylene glycol dinitrate (EGDN), or ∼25 min for TNT and ion separation in the DMS added to this. For example, isomers such as 2-MNT and 4-MNT can be distinguished using their slightly differing compensation voltages CV ≈ 05 V and different retention times tr ≈ 10 s. For the reliable detection of these substances, a concentration effect needs to be considered: both MNTs form two different ions of specific compensation voltages, and for both pairs a concentration-dependent intensity ratio can be explained by the formation of monomer and dimer ions. As the substance molecules elute from the GC column into the DMS analyzer in a chromatographic profile, the initially small analyte concentration favors the formation of monomer ions MH+ H2 On , detected at ∼ 2 V (Figs 15(c) and 16). At the center of the chromatographic profile, the analyte concentration may be high enough that dimer ions of the analyte, M2 H+ H2 On , can be formed and provide response at ∼ 0 V in the differential mobility spectra. At the end of the elution profile, the equilibrium returns to the preferred formation of monomer ions. Not surprisingly, at decreased sample amounts, only monomer ions are formed throughout the entire elution process. Because concentrations are often unknown, both compensation
82
Eiceman et al.
(a) TATP in air only H+(H2O)n(N2)x
4
Intensity (a.u.)
2 Positive ions
0 0 –1 –2 O2–(H2O)n(N2)x
Negative ions
–3 0
5
10
15
Compensation voltage (V)
(b) HMTD in air only 3
H+(sol)
Positive ions
H+(H2O)n(N2)x
2
Intensity (a.u.)
1 0 0 –1 –2 –3
Negative ions
0
O2–(H2O)n(N2)x 5 10 Compensation voltage (V)
15
Fig. 15. (a) Differential mobility spectra of triacetone triperoxide (TATP) in air at different concentrations. Product ions can only be detected in the positive mode, negative product ions cannot be observed. (b) Differential mobility spectra of hexamethylene triperoxide diamine (HMTD) in air at different concentrations. Product ions can be detected both in positive and negative polarity. The additional peak in the positive mode could be attributed to a co-eluting solvent, acetonitrile (ACN).
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
83
(c) 4-MNT in air only Positive ions
6
CH3
O2N
H+(H2O)n(N2)x
4
Intensity (a.u.)
2 0 0
–2 O2–(H2O)n(N2)x
Negative ions
0
5
10
15
Compensation voltage (V)
(d) 2,4,6-TNT in air only 4 NO2 O2N
Intensity (a.u.)
2
Positive ions
H+(H2O)n(N2)x
CH3 NO2
0 0
–2 Negative ions
0
O2–(H2O)n(N2)x 5 10 Compensation voltage (V)
15
Fig. 15. (Continued) (c) Differential mobility spectra of 4-mononitrotoluene (4-MNT) in air at different concentrations. Product ions can only be detected in the positive mode, negative product ions cannot be observed. (d) Differential mobility spectra of 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) in air at different concentrations. Product ions can only be detected in the negative mode, positive product ions cannot be observed. Source: A.A. Cagan, H. Schmidt, G.A. Eiceman, NMSU (unpublished results, 2006).
84
Eiceman et al. 15 0.1
12 0.2
6
0.4
3 1.3
0 5.0
–3 15
0.1
12
Signal (V)
Compensation voltage (V)
9
0.2
9 0.5
6 3
1.2
0 3.0
–3 0
1
2
3
Retention time (min)
GC–DMS of HMTD, EGDN, TATP, 2-MNT, 4-MNT, 2,4-DNT, TNT (100 ng in ACN) Fig. 16. Gas chromatography–differential mobility spectrometry (GC–(DMS) topographic plot [retention time (x-axis), compensation voltage (y-axis), intensity (z-axis)] of a mixture of seven explosives (100 ng in acetonitrile): hexamethylene triperoxide diamine (HMTD), ethylene glycol dinitrate (EGDN), triacetone triperoxide (TATP), 2-mononitrotoluene (2-MNT), 4-MNT, 2,4-dinitrotoluene (2,4-DNT), and 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT).
voltages should be monitored for the detection of MNTs. The findings in Fig. 16 amplify the condition that some explosives form stable product ions exclusively in the positive polarity (e.g., TATP and MNTs), some in the negative (EGDN and TNT), and some in both polarities (HMTD and DNT). Therefore, the presence of target substances can altogether be confirmed on basis of a combination of their characteristic compensation voltages, retention times, and the polarities in which a response can be detected. However, this GC pre-fractionation has an analytical benefit much greater than only retention time. The chemistry of ionization is simplified as substances are provided individually to the ionization source of the DMS analyzer. As shown earlier, reactant ions are created in the ionization region and subsequently form analyte ions with sample molecules. However, as the whole sample is presented to the reactant ions at the same time, the competition between sample molecules of different proton affinities in the positive mode, or electron affinities in the negative mode, to form analyte ions can result in the suppression of response of certain molecules of lower proton or electron affinities. This may lead to a false-negative response to some analytes. A chromatographic pre-separation can improve the reliability regarding both qualitative and quantitiative response compared with the presentation of a whole sample vapor to the DMS. One disadvantage of the use of a chromatographic column is the extended total analysis time, because a fast response is a critical requirement in explosives detection. This problem can be solved through the use of short high-speed columns in combination with very fast temperature
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
85
ramps as practiced with true high-speed GC. The results in Fig. 16 were collected using a conventional large benchtop gas chromatograph with no refinements or upgraded components needed to obtain good quality with high-speed GC. These limitations were ameliorated with the commercial GC–DMS analyzer as described in the next section.
7. The EGIS Defender: a commercial high-speed GC–DMS analyzer A commercial version of a GC–DMS instrument [58,59] has been produced for detecting explosives and is known as the EGIS Defender from Thermo Scientific Corporation (Fig. 17). Much of this instrument had technical heritage with the EGIS analyzers such as the Thermedics EGIS 3000, which was a high-speed gas chromatograph with a chemiluminescence detector. Sample is collected as with most trace detectors for explosives by wiping a surface with a specially designed filter. The filter is then placed into an inlet where explosives are thermally desorbed for an 18-s analysis to determine the types and levels of explosives in the sample. A box diagram for the architecture of this instrument is also shown in Fig. 17, where vapors desorbed from a sample are passed to a gas chromatograph and then a DMS analyzer (sensor assembly). The gas chromatograph is based on high-speed control of temperature, which was re-developed and released as the EZ Flash upgrade kit designed to improve the speed of a conventional gas chromatograph. In this gas chromatograph, column temperatures can be increased at a rate up to 1200 C/min with upper temperatures of 280–365 C, depending on the column length. The contours of the GC separation with the DMS analyzer as selective detector are visible in the graphic display of Fig. 17. The sample inlet is seen in the front of the analyzer at bottom right. A measure of the performance of the EGIS Defender is shown in Fig. 17 (bottom) where quantitative response is shown in part and illustrates that DMS and IMS analyzers are quantitative devices so long as sources are not saturated or overloaded. The analytical response of this unit is only partially disclosed here as response curves for two substances, TNT and EGDN. The plots are normal in appearance for IMS or DMS quantitative response, with a range, as shown here, in nanograms. As with all DMS and IMS instruments, response can become saturated at levels ×100 or more than these making this and other DMS analyzers trace detectors with quantitative and proportional response across a limited range.
8. Next developments in DMS and IMS determinations of explosives Although reliable and capable of operation by non-specialists with trace detection capabilities useful for explosives screening, IMS analyzers are comparatively low in resolution; although specificity of response is strong owing to the method of ionization of sample and the additional evaluation of product ions with mobility, increased specificity and expanded scope of response to an enlarged list of explosives is a reasonable
86
Air pumps Filters & dryers
Dopant reservoir
Sensor assembly Desorb inlet
Main oven
SE
Exhaust
Split exhaust
Eiceman et al.
8000
3000
TNT 20025 7000
2500
6000 5000
2000
4000
1500
EGDN 20025
3000 1000
2000 500
1000 0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Fig. 17. A commercial configuration of high-speed gas chromatography–differential mobility spectrometry (GC–DMS) is the Defender (flow schematic top left, instrument top right), which is a successor of the EGIS and EGIS II explosives analyzers. Calibration curve of trinitrotoluene (TNT) (bottom left) and ethylene glycol dinitrate (EGDN) (bottom right) (signal vs. mass in nanogram) from the EGIS Defender.
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
87
expectation for maturation of technology. In the moment, the low resolution found with IMS is offset or compensated with practical benefits of simplicity of instrumentation sans vacuum pumps, the very low levels of detection, and the simplicity of use and maintenance. The emergence of DMS and GC/DMS as described in Sections 2–7 will aid some of these concerns as will the twin drift tube of the IONSCAN 500DT. Nonetheless, specificity of response remains a factor in false alarms, positive or negative, and the use of a single technology with stable parameters for a more comprehensive list of explosives would be a welcome enhancement with trace detectors. The method of DMS–IMS2 is based on characterizing ions using differences in the mobility K followed by ion separation based on K in an IMS analyzer [60,61]. Whereas characterization of ions in IMS is based on cross-section of collision (as a first approximation), ions in DMS are characterized on the susceptibility of an ion to hydration or solvation and the mass of the ion. Although these concepts are not purely orthogonal, enough difference exists between ion characterizations by IMS and DMS so a combined or tandem analyzer of DMS–IMS is three to five times improved over either alone. When ions of both polarities are characterized simultaneously, two IMS drift tubes may be used to interrogate ions after DMS analysis. What is known for DMS determination of explosives and for IMS determination of explosives is neither lost nor compromised with the DMS–IMS2 characterization of explosives. Findings are shown in Fig. 18, where the response to different nitrotoluene isomers (2-MNT, 3-MNT, 2,4-DNT, 3,4-DNT, and 2,4,6-TNT) is shown in three-dimensional 10
10
9
9
8
8
7
5
6 5
2-Nitrotoluene
4
CV
CV
RIN
7
RIP
6
3-Nitrotoluene
3
4 3
2
2
1
1
2,4-DNT
0
3,4-DNT
0
3,4-DNT
–1
2,4-DNT
TNT
–1
–2
–2 1
2 3 Drift time (ms)
4
1
2 3 Drift time (ms)
4
Fig. 18. Overlay of plots from DMS–IMS2 response to several nitrotoluenes [2-mononitrotoluene (2-MNT), 3-MNT, 2,4-dinitrotoluene (2,4-DNT), 3,4-DNT, 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT)] in positive polarity (left). A reactant ion peak (RIP) is seen at 6.5 V and 1.9 ms, whereas protonated monomers are seen near 3 V and 2.2 ms, and proton-bound dimers are at 0 V and 3.5 ms. TNT does not show a response in positive polarity. Overlay of plots from DMS–IMS2 response to several nitrotoluenes (cf. list in positive polarity) in negative polarity (right). A RIN is seen at 7 V and 1.8 ms, whereas molecular adducts or charge-exchanged ions are seen at 0.5 V and 2.5 ms. MNTs do not show a response in negative polarity. Source: Neil D. Paz, NMSU (unpublished results, 2006).
88
Eiceman et al.
plots of compensation voltage (for the DMS) versus drift time (for the IMS) and ion intensity in both polarities. Emphasis should be given to the benefit of collecting positive and negative ion data simultaneously in the DMS–IMS2 analyzer design. Also, the drift region in the IMS analyzers here was the smallest drift tube ever built at NMSU (1 cm drift length) and constituted the smallest considered viable for measurements. Doubling this length or even 3 cm would enhance analytical performance seen in Fig. 18 (the DMS analyzer was of normal size with 15-mm-long analyzer path). Nonetheless, the plots show that response to nitrotoluene isomers will provide enhanced resolution in the DMS scale over IMS, and larger ions (such as DNT or TNT) exhibit enhanced resolution in the IMS scale. The combination provides response to both ion polarities simultaneously and resolution across a range of explosives.
9. Conclusions The benefits of characterizing ions in air at ambient pressure bring some compelling strengths for chemical measurements with explosives, and these have been expanded with the advancement toward micro-fabricated DMS analyzers. The principal advantage of small size and low cost with agreeable analytical performance can be enhanced with sample preparation through fast chromatography, as seen now in the EGIS Defender, and in additional ion evaluation with tandem DMS and IMS configurations with simultaneous characterization of ions of both polarities for mobility and differential mobility.
Acknowledgments We acknowledge with thanks the supporting information on the Defender provided by Dan Dussault, ThermoScientific Corporation, and Raanan Miller, Sionex Corporation. The development of the DMS–IMS2 analyzer was a joint effort with Hamilton Sundstrand Sensor Systems and Sionex Corporation [60], and the explosives data are unpublished courtesy of Neil D. Paz, NMSU, 2006.
References [1] G.A. Eiceman and Z. Karpas, Ion Mobility Spectrometry, 2nd edition, CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL (2005). [2] D.D. Fetterolf and T.D. Clark, J. Forensic Sci., 38 (1993) 28. [3] M.J. Cohen, R.F. Wernlund and R.M. Stimac, Nucl. Mater. Manage., 13 (1984) 220. [4] R.F. Wernlund, M.J. Cohen and R.C. Kindel, The ion mobility spectrometer as an explosive or taggant vapor detector. Proceedings of the New Concept Symposium and Workshop on Detection Identification of Explosives, Reston, VA, USA, October/November 1978, pp. 185–189.
Explosives Detection Using Differential Mobility Spectrometry
89
[5] S. Bell, E. Nazarov, Y.F. Wang, J.E. Rodriguez, and G.A. Eiceman, Anal. Chem., 72 (2000) 1192. [6] G.A. Eiceman, E.G. Nazarov and J.E. Rodriguez, Anal. Chem. Acta, 433 (2001) 53. [7] G.A. Eiceman and J.A. Stone, Anal. Chem., 76 (2004) 390A. [8] I.A. Buryakov, E.V. Krylov, A.L. Makas, E.G. Nazarov, V.V. Pervukhin and U.K. Rasulev, Pisma Zh. Tekh. Fiz., 17 (1991) 60. [9] I.A. Buryakov, E.V. Krylov, E.G. Nazarov and U.K. Rasulev, Int. J. Mass Spectrom. Ion Process., 128 (1993) 143. [10] I.A. Buryakov, E.V. Krylov, A.L. Makas, E.G. Nazarov, V.V. Pervukhin and U.K. Rasulev, J. Anal. Chem. USSR (Zhurnal Analiticheskoi Khimii), 48 (1993) 156. [11] G.A. Eiceman, V.J. Vandiver, T. Chen and G. Rico-Martinez, Anal. Instrum., 18 (1989) 227. [12] G.A. Eiceman, E.G. Nazarov, J.A. Stone and J.E. Rodriguez, Rev. Sci. Instrum., 72 (2001) 3610. [13] A.J. Midey and A.A. Viggiano, J. Chem. Phys., 114 (2001) 6072. [14] S.L. Gong and R.E. Jervis, J. Chem. Phys., 103 (1995) 7081. [15] M. Meot-Ner, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114 (1992) 3312. [16] J.D. Payzant and P. Kebarle, J. Chem. Phys., 56 (1972) 3482. [17] M. Arshadi and P. Kebarle, J. Phys. Chem., 74 (1970) 1483. [18] Z. Karpas, Z. Berant and O. Shahal, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 111 (1989) 6015. [19] Z. Karpas, G.A. Eiceman, E.V. Krylov and N. Krylova, Int. J. Ion Mobility Spectrom., 7(1) (2004) C8. [20] C.S. Creaser, J.R. Griffiths, C.J. Bramwell, S. Noreen, C.A. Hill and C.L.P. Thomas, Analyst, 129 (2004) 984. [21] T.W. Carr (ed.), Plasma Chromatography, Plenum, New York, 1984. [22] G.A. Eiceman and Z. Karpas, Ion Mobility Spectrometry, CRC Press Inc., Boca Raton, FL, (1993). [23] M.J. Cohen, Plasma Chromatography. A New Dimension for Gas Chromatography and Mass Spectrometry, presented at the Pittsburgh Conference on Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spectroscopy, March 1969. [24] J.I. Baumbach, Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 384 (2006) 1059. [25] D.C. Collins and M.L. Lee, Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 372 (2002) 66. [26] G.A. Eiceman, Trends Anal. Chem., 21 (2002) 259. [27] H. Borsdorf and G.A. Eiceman, Appl. Spectrosc. Rev., 41 (2006) 323. [28] United States Patent 5,227,628 Ion mobility detector, July 13, 1993 Turner; Brian R. (Chesham, GB) Assignee: Graseby Dynamics Limited (Cambridge, GB2) Appl. No.: 741,472 Filed: August 5, 1991PCT Filed: February 07, 1990 PCT NO: PCT/GB90/00182 371 Date: August 05, 1991 102(e) Date: August 05, 1991 PCT PUB.NO.: WO90/09583. [29] Smiths Detection, IONSCAN 500DT, Simultaneously Detect Explosives and Narcotics Using Dual IMS Detectors, available at http://trace.smithsdetection.com/products/ Default.asp?Product=55 (2006). [30] R. Wilson and A. Brittain, Explosives Detection by Ion Mobility Spectrometry, Special Publication - Royal Society of Chemistry 203 (Explosives in the Service of Man), Graseby Dynamics Ltd., Hertfordshire, p. 92 (1997). [31] R.J. Munson, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A172 (1939) 51. [32] A.M. Tyndall and C.F. Powell, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A134 (1931) 125. [33] J.H. Mitchell and K.E.W. Ridler, Proc. R. Soc. Lond., A146 (1934) 911. [34] L.G.H. Huxley, R.W. Crompton, and M.T. Elford, Br. J. Appl. Phys., 17 (1966) 1237. [35] I.I. Balog, Fizika, 74 (1944) 123. [36] M.P. Gorshkov, Analysis of Impurities in Gases, Inventor’s Certificate of USSR No 966583, G01N27/62 (1982).
90
Eiceman et al.
[37] E. Krylov, E.G. Nazarov, R.A. Miller, B. Tadjikov and G.A. Eiceman, J. Phys. Chem. A, 106 (2002) 5437. [38] N. Krylova, E. Krylov, J.A. Stone and G.A. Eiceman, J. Phys. Chem. A, 107 (2003) 3648. [39] B. Carnahan, S. Day, V. Kouznetsov and A. Tarassov, Development and Applications of a Transverse Field Compensation Ion Mobility Spectrometer, presented at the 4th International Workshop on Ion Mobility Spectrometry, Cambridge, UK, 6–9 August 1995. [40] R. Guevremont, Can. J. Anal. Sci. Spectrosc., 49 (2004) 105. [41] R.W. Purves, R. Guevremont, S. Day, C.W. Pipich and M.S. Matyjaszczyk, Rev. Sci. Instrum., 69 (1998) 4094. [42] R.W. Purves, D.A. Barnett and R. Guevremont, Int. J. Mass Spectrom., 197 (2000) 163. [43] R.W. Purves, D.A. Barnett, B. Ells and R. Guevremont, J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom., 11 (2000) 738. [44] D.A. Barnett, B. Ells, R. Guevremont and R.W. Purves, J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom., 13 (2002) 1282. [45] Thermo Scientific, FAIMS: The First Step in LC-MS Method Development Problem Solving, Waltham, MA (2007) available at http://www.thermo.com/com/cda/resources/ resources_detail/ 1,2166,112852,00.html. [46] R.A. Miller, G.A. Eiceman, E.G. Nazarov and A.T. King, Sens. Actuators B, 67 (2000) 300. [47] R.A. Miller, E.G. Nazarov, G.A. Eiceman and A.T. King, Sens. Actuators A, 91 (2001) 307. [48] R.E. Ewing, G.J. Ewing, D.A. Atkinson and G.A. Eiceman, Talanta, 54 (2001) 515. [49] M.W. Siegel, Atmospheric pressure ionization, in T.W. Carr (ed.), Plasma Chromatography, Plenum Press, New York, (1984). [50] G.R. Asbury, J. Klasmeier and H.H. Hill, Jr., Talanta, 50 (2000) 1291. [51] M. Tam and H.H. Hill, Jr., Anal. Chem., 76 (2004) 2741. [52] I.A. Buryakov, Yu.N. Kolomiets and B.V. Luppu, J. Anal. Chem., 56 (2001) 336. [53] I.A. Buryakov, Talanta, 61 (2003) 369. [54] I.A. Buryakov and Yu.N. Kolomiets, J. Anal. Chem., 58 (2003) 944. [55] V.P. Zhdanov, V.N. Sidelnikov and A.A. Vlasov, J. Chromatogr. A, 928 (2001) 201. [56] J.I. Baumbach, G.A. Eiceman, D. Klockow, S. Sielemann and A. von Irmer, Int. J. Environ. Anal. Chem., 66 (1997) 225. [57] G.A. Eiceman, E.V. Krylov, N.S. Krylova, E.G. Nazarov and R.A. Miller, Anal. Chem., 76 (2004) 4937. [58] Thermo Scientific Corporation, EGIS Defender - Explosive Detector, Waltham, MA, USA (2007) available at http://www.thermo.com/com/cda/product/detail/1,10119656,00.html. [59] Thermo Scientific Corporation, EGIS™ Defender, Portable Lightweight Desktop Explosives Trace Detection System, Waltham, MA, USA (2007), available at http://www.thermo.com/ eThermo/CMA/PDFs/Product/productPDF_30772.pdf. [60] C.R. White, Characterization of Tandem DMS-IMS2 and Determination of Orthogonality Between the Mobility Coefficient (K) and the Differential Mobility Coefficient ( K), MS Thesis, New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM, (2006). [61] G.A. Eiceman, H. Schmidt, J.E. Rodriguez, C.R. White, E.G. Nazarov, E.V. Krylov, R.A. Miller, M. Bowers, D. Burchfield, B. Niu, E. Smith and N. Leigh, Characterization of Positive and Negative Ions Simultaneously Through Measures of K and K by a Tandem DMS-IMS2 , presented at the 14th International Conference for Ion Mobility Spectrometry, Maffliers, France, 25 July 2005.
Chapter 4
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
Joseph Wang Biodesign Institute, Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287, USA
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Elsevier B.V.
All rights reserved.
91
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
93
2. Electrochemistry of explosive materials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
94
3. Easy-to-use disposable electrode strips for explosives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
95
4. Real-time electrochemical monitoring . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
96
5. Lab-on-a-chip electrochemical detection of explosives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
102
6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
106
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106
92
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
93
1. Introduction The detection of explosive compounds has received considerable attention for national security and environmental applications [1]. Such security and environmental needs have generated major demands for effective and innovative field-deployable devices for detecting organic explosives in a sensitive, fast, simple, reliable, and cost-effective manner. New devices and innovative protocols providing effective on-site or in situ real-time monitoring capability are particularly needed for addressing escalating threats of terrorist activity and related explosive detection challenges. This chapter highlights recent advances, primarily from our laboratory, aimed at developing electrochemical sensors and detectors for explosive compounds. Electrochemical sensors offer unique opportunities for addressing the need for on-site detection of various explosives. The advantages of electrochemical systems include high sensitivity and selectivity, a wide linear range, minimal space and power requirements, and low-cost instrumentation. Both the sensor and the controlled instrumentation can be readily miniaturized to yield hand-held meters. The coupling of modern electrochemical detection principles with recent advances in microelectronics and microfabrication has led to powerful, compact, and user-friendly analytical devices for decentralized (on-site) testing. Common examples are pocket-size glucose meters (based on amperometric enzyme electrodes) that are widely used for self-testing of diabetes. Electroanalytical techniques are concerned with the interplay between electricity and chemistry, namely, the measurements of electrical quantities, such as current, potential, or charge, and their relationship to chemical parameters [2]. Controlled-potential (potentiostatic) techniques deal with the study of charge transfer processes at the electrode/solution interface and are based on dynamic situations. Here, the electrode potential is being used to derive an electron transfer reaction, and the resulting current is measured. The role of the potential is analogous to that of the wave length in optical measurements. Such controllable parameter can be viewed as ‘elec tron pressure’, which forces the chemical species to gain or lose an electron (reduc tion or oxidation, respectively). In 1980s and 1990s have seen major advances in electroanalyticalchemistry, including the design of tailored interfaces, the development of ultramicroelectrodes, the coupling of biological components or nanoscale materials with electrical transducers, the microfabrication of molecular devices, and the introduc tion of ‘smart’ sensors and sensor arrays. The readers are referred to a recent book and a review for comprehensive information on electrochemical systems [2,3]. The inherent redox activity of nitroaromatic explosives [4], namely, the presence of easily reducible nitro groups, makes them ideal candidates for electrochemical (voltammetric) monitoring. Particularly suited for the rapid testing of military explosives is square-wave voltammetry (SWV), owing to its high sensitivity, fast scan rates, and compact low-power instrumentation [5]. SWV is a large-amplitude pulse-voltammetric technique in which a waveform composed of a symmetrical square wave superimposed on a base staircase potential (Fig. 1) is applied to the working electrode [2]. The current is sampled twice during each square-wave cycle, and the current difference offers
Wang
Potential
94
1 Esw
ΔE
τ
2
Td
Time Fig. 1. Waveform used in square-wave voltammetry (SWV) showing the amplitude, ESW ; step height, E; square-wave period, T ; delay time, Td ; and current measurement times, 1 and 2. Reproduced with permission from Wang [2].
a substantial increase in the ratio of the analytical to the background current. The resulting peak-shaped voltammogram is symmetrical, with the peak potential providing the quali tative identification and the peak current being proportional to the analyte concentration. Sections 3–5 will describe several recently developedpowerful electrical devices for on-site monitoring of explosive materials.
2. Electrochemistry of explosive materials The nitro group is an excellent electron acceptor. The reduction of polynitroaromatic compounds is complicated by multi-step processes. These usually occur in two steps to form an amine via a hydroxylamine. Such processes are strongly dependent on the pH, the number of nitro groups per molecule, their relative position on the ring, and the nature and position of other substituents present on the aromatic system [4]. In general, trinitroaromatic compounds, such as TNT or picric acid, are more easily reduced than dinitro- and mononitroaromatic compounds. Nitramines and polynitrate esters are more difficult to reduce, and their reduction peaks appear at more negative potentials. Such redox activity of TNT and RDX can be exploited not only for sensing applications (described in Sections 3–5) but also for electrochemical ‘cleanup’ in connection with flow-throughporous electrodes [6]. Detection tags with high vapor pressure, particularly 2,3-dimethyl-2,3-dinitrobutane (DMNB), are commonly added to commercial explosives to facilitate the vapor detection of explosives with relatively low vapor pressure such as plastic explosives. Evans group [7] investigated the mechanism of the DMNB reduction at mercury electrodes in a dimethylformamide (DMF) medium, whereas Wang’s team [8] recently
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
95
exploited the electroreduction of DMNB at the carbon-fiber surface for its fast and sensitive SWV detection.
3. Easy-to-use disposable electrode strips for explosives The performance of the voltammetric procedure is strongly influenced by the working electrode material. The working electrode is the one at which the reaction of interest occurs. The selection of the working electrode depends primarily on the redox behavior of the target explosive and the background current over the applied potential region. A range of materials have found application as working electrodes for reductive (cathodic) mea surements of nitroaromatic and nitramine explosive compounds, including mercury, car bon, or gold/amalgam. The deliberate modification of conventional electrodes can lead to an enhanced explosive detection. Modified electrodes based on carbon nanotube [9] or mesoporous SiO2 -MCM-41 [10] coatings have been recently shown to be useful for enhancing the sensitivity through adsorptive accumulation of the target explosive. Three-electrode cells are commonly used in controlled-potential experiments. The cell is usually a covered beaker of 5–20 ml volume and contains the three electrodes (working, reference, and auxiliary) that are immersed in the sample solution. To address the needs of field sensing of explosives, it is necessary to move away from such traditional electrodes and bulky cells. The exploitation of advanced microfabrication techniques allows the replacement of conventional ‘beaker-type’ electrochemical cells and electrodes with easy-to-use sensor strips. Both thick-film (screen-printing) and thin-film (lithographic) fabrication processes have thus been used for high-volume production of highly reproducible, effective, and inexpensive electrochemical sensor strips. Such strips rely on planar working, reference, and counter electrodes on a plastic, ceramic, or silicon substrate (Fig. 2). These strips can thus be considered as self-contained electrochemical cells onto which the sample droplet is placed. The thin-film fabrication route also facilitates the development ofcross-reactive electrode arrays [11], which are promising for multi-explosive electronic nose (e-nose)-type gas-phase detection (in con nection with advanced signal-processing algorithms).
Working electrode Counter electrode
Reference electrode
Fig. 2. A disposable thick-film voltammetric sensor for detecting organic explosives.
96
Wang
(b)
(a)
0
0
a
–0.5
–1.0
–1.5
b
–2.0 –2.5
c
–3.0 –3.5
Current (10–6 A)
–1.0
Current (10–6 A)
a
–0.5
–1.5
b
–2.0 –2.5
c
–3.0 –3.5
d
–4.0 –4.5
–4.0
d
–4.5 0
–0.10 –0.20 –0.30 –0.40 –0.50 –0.60 –0.70
Potential (V)
0
–0.10 –0.20 –0.30 –0.40 –0.50 –0.60 –0.70
Potential (V)
Fig. 3. Explosive detection at single-use screen-printed electrodes. Assays of river water (A) and groundwater (B) samples. Response to the sample (a) as well as for subsequent concentration increments of 3 ppm TNT (b–d). Reproduced with permission from Wang et al. [12].
It was demonstrated that a thick-film TNT sensor, based on the coupling of fast SWV and the screen-printing fabrication process [12]. Screen-printing is a well-established technology used for the mass production of low-cost, disposable electrochemical sen sors [2,13]. This process involves printing patterns of conductors and insulators on surfaces of planner substrates by ‘forcing’ the corresponding ink through the openings of a patterned stencil. The screen-printed TNT sensor developed in our laboratory offers an attractive analytical performance, including high sensitivity (down to a detection limit of 200 ppb TNT), a wide linear range, fast response, and high selectivity [12]. Such high sen sitivity and selectivity were demonstrated in connection with direct TNT measurements in ground and river water samples (Fig. 3). Hart’s group [14] demonstrated the utility of similar screen-printed carbon electrodes for stripping voltammetric measurements of trace 2,6-dinitrotoluene. Reproducible measurements down to 160 ppb were reported in connection with 100 l samples. Zen and coworkers [15] used the preanodization of screen-printed electrodes for obtaining sharper peaks for nitroaromaticcompounds. This allowed a useful approach to identifying substituents and facilitated single-run (internal standard) approach that obviated the need for standard additions. Applicability to vapor detection is anticipated in connection with the use of closely spaced planar electrodes covered with a conducting permeable film, for example, hydrogel (Section 4.5).
4. Real-time electrochemical monitoring The use of sensors and detectors to continuously measure important chemical properties has significant analytical advantages. By providing a fast return of analytical information in a timely, safe, and cost-effective fashion, such devices offer direct and reliable monitoring of explosive compounds while greatly reducing the huge analytical costs and
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
97
minimizing errors associated with the sampling process. Such real-time electrochemical monitoring of explosive compounds has been accomplished in our laboratory through on-line [16] and submersible [17] operations.
4.1. Flow analysis of TNT: toward on-line monitoring of explosives Electrochemical measurements can be readily adapted for on-line monitoring. An electrochemical detector uses the electrochemical properties of target analytes for their determination in a flowing stream. An electrochemical flow system, based on an SWV operation at a carbon-fiber-based detector, for use in the on-line continuous monitoring of trace TNT in marine environments was developed [16]. Such flow detector offers selective measurements of sub-part-per-million concentrations of TNT in untreated natu ral water samples with a detection limit of 25 ppb. It responds rapidly to sudden changes in the TNT concentration with no apparent carryover. About 600 runs can be made every hour with high reproducibility and stability (e.g., relative standard deviation RSD = 23% n = 40). The system lends itself to full automation and to possible deployment onto various stationary mobile platforms (e.g., buoys and underwater vehicles). An electrochemical flow detector, based on four working electrodes coated with different permselective film types, for use in flow-injection measurements of multiple nitroaromatic explosives was recently developed [18]. The resulting array response (Fig. 4) offers unique ‘fingerprints’ of such explosive compounds. Electrochemical devices are extremely attractive for designing such e-nose-type multi-electrode arrays that combine several partially selective electrodes and lead to a distinct response pattern (signature) for mixtures of organic vapors without prior separation [2].
Current (μA)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0 LP
NF
BR
PP
Sensor TNT
1,2-DNB
4-NT
2,6-DNT
Fig. 4. Amperometric array response to various nitroaromatic explosives at a flow detector with four electrodes coated with different films. LP, lipid; BR, bare; NF, Nafion; PP, polyphenol.
98
Wang
4.2. Remote monitoring of TNT Remotely deployable submersible sensors capable of monitoring contaminants both in time and in location have a variety of applications [19]. Such ability to perform in situ measurements of explosives is important for improving the efficiency of characterization and remediation of sites that are former military munitions manufacturing, storage, and demilitarized zones and are contaminated with high levels of explosive compounds. A submersible electrode assembly, connected to a 50-ft-long shielded cable via environmentally sealed rubber connectors, for the real-time in situ monitoring of the TNT explosive in natural water was developed [17]. As illustrated in Fig. 5, this sensor assembly consists of the carbon-fiber, silver, and platinum working, refer ence, and counter electrodes, respectively, and operates in the rapid SWV mode. This remote/submersible probe circumvents the need for solution pumping and offers greater simplification and miniaturization. The facile reduction of the nitro moiety allowed con venient and rapid SWV measurements of sub-part-per-million levels of TNT. Lower (ppb) concentrations have been detected using a background subtraction operation. Such high sensitivity has been coupled with good selectivity and stability and the absence of carryover effects. The latter reflects the absence of recognition/binding events. These capabilities were illustrated in various natural water environments. For example, Fig. 6 displays voltammograms for seawater samples containing increasing levels of TNT in 250-ppb steps. Prolonged direct operations of such in situ electrochemical sensors in organic-rich ocean environments may be complicated by surface fouling by co-existing substances (e.g., surfactants, suspended particulates, and bacterial fauna). Prevention of electrode deactivation due to such surfactant adsorption has been accomplished by covering the working electrode with a protective (anti-fouling) polyphenol coating [20].
Electrode connections Long shielded cable Quick disconnect environmentally sealed connector PVC type housing
Working electrode
Counter electrode
Reference electrode Fig. 5. A submersible electrochemical sensor for remote monitoring of explosive substances in natural water samples. Based on Wang [19].
99
Current
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
0.0
–0.2
–0.4
–0.6
–0.8
Potential (V) Fig. 6. Square-wave voltammograms recorded with remote/submersible electrochemical probe for seawater samples containing increasing levels of TNT in 250-ppb steps (scale: 1 MA per cm).
Such size-exclusion film is prepared by electropolymerizing polyphenol in the presence of the phenol monomer. A self-contained system, which integrated the remote carbon-fiber electrochemical sensor with a voltammetric analyzer and a wireless communication system, was described by Fu et al. [21]. The mobile remote underwater systems were applied for field meas urements of explosive residues in marine environments.
4.3. In situ electrochemical monitoring of TNT using underwater vehicle platforms The voltammetric sensor was integrated onto an unmanned underwater vehicle (UUV). This integration was a part of the Office Naval Research (ONR) Chemical Sensing in Marine Environments (CSME) Program, whose goal was to demonstrate the effectiveness of advanced sensor technology for detecting explosives (leaking out of mines) in coastal regions of the ocean. Such chemical detection of explosives in a marine environment is an extremely challenging problem, as the explosive chemical signature emanating from a source can rapidly disperse in the environment, diluting the signature to trace levels that are difficult to detect. Highly sensitive and rapid sensors are thus desired for detecting and prosecuting plumes containing trace amounts of explosives that leak into the seawater, and this detection is used for identifying and marking mines. The electrochemical TNT sensor was mounted onto the UUV as a separate module, and it serially sent data values to the REMUS UUV. The electrode assembly was mounted on the cone nose of the vehicle and connected to the internal microanalyzer (Fig. 7). Major attention was given to the optimization of variables of the square-wave waveform (including the frequency, amplitude, and potential step) essential for attaining high speed
100
Wang Electrode unit
PV with electronics
REMUS body
ADCP
Collar
Connector
Nose cone
Fig. 7. Electrochemical explosive sensor mounted on the autonomous underwater vehicle (AUV). The threeelectrode assembly (on the cone nose of the vehicle) is shown on the right side.
(1–4 s runs) without sacrificing the sensitivity. A computerized baseline subtraction was developed to compensate for the oxygen background contribution and hence to facilitate the detection of low part-per-billion levels of TNT (Fig. 8). The optimal device offered high sensitivity and selectivity, fast response, excellent precision and stability, and no matrix effect, hence meeting the demands of underwater sensing of TNT. A typical set of stability data involving 100 repetitive runs is displayed in Fig. 9. The UUV-deployed sen sor was tested in tracking TNT plumes in several field missions lasting between 2 and 3 h.
1.2
7.0
6.0 1.0 5.0
Current (10–6 A)
Current (10–5 A)
0.8
0.6
4.0
3.0
2.0
0.4 1.0 0.2 0
0
–1.0 0
–0.10 –0.20 –0.30 –0.40 –0.50 –0.60 –0.70
Potential (V)
0
–0.10 –0.20 –0.30 –0.40 –0.50 –0.60 –0.70 –0.80
Potential (V)
Fig. 8. Square-wave voltammograms for seawater samples containing increasing levels of TNT in 20-ppb steps (right and left, with and without background correction, respectively).
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
101
Current (μA)
2 μA
0.2
–0.2
–0.6
–1.0
Potential (V) Fig. 9. Stability of 100 repetitive measurements of 3 ppm TNT by the submersible carbon-fiber electrode assembly.
4.4. Diver-held TNT sensing unit The carbon-fiber-based voltammetric sensor was also integrated into a diver-held unit. This integration relied on the incorporation of a commercial compact (the PalmSense) hand-held voltammetric analyzer within a pressure vessel, with the electrode assembly sticking out of the vessel surface. This configuration allows the diver to observe in real time the corresponding voltammogram. Repetitive square-wave voltammograms are thus performed at 2–4 s intervals. Particular attention has been given to the adaptation of the PalmSense software to meet the requirements of continuous TNT detection. The new software was successfully tested, and the unit was deployed during a field test. Preliminary underwater testing has been very promising, with the current signal increasing and decreasing as the diver enters and departs from the explosive plume.
4.5. Gas-phase voltammetric detection Real-time reliable detection of explosive vapors is extremely important for practical applications ranging from roadside checkpoints to baggage screening. Commercial amperometric devices are widely used for real-time environmental emission monitoring of toxic gases such as CO SO2 NOx O3 CO, formaldehyde, or ethanol [2,22]. For amperometric gas sensors, the main challenge lies in the creation of a working electrode that is accessible for the sample gas while still being in contact with a liquid electrolyte solution (containing the reference and counter electrodes) [22]. Alternately, it is possible to use a solid polymer electrolyte membrane, such as Nafion, covering a planar microfabricated electrode arrangement, as solid-state sensors. Krausa and Schorb [23] described such a solid-state TNT gas sensor based on 25-m gold disk working electrode, surrounded by a gold ring reference/counter electrode,
102
Wang
Current (nA)
2 0 –2 –4 –6 –0.5
0.5 0 Potential (V) vs. Gold (Au)
1.0
Fig. 10. Gas-phase detection of TNT: cyclic voltammograms for TNT (solid line) and control (dotted line) placed 10 cm above the TNT sample. Scan rate, 400 mV/s. Reproduced with permission from Krausa and Schorb [23].
arranged in a single plane, and coated with a sulfuric acid film. Figure 10 (solid line) displays a cyclic voltammogram recorded by placing the probe 10 cm away from the solid TNT sample. The shape of this voltammogram, with the characteristic TNT reduction peak at−04 V, is identical with that recorded upon immersing the electrode in a TNT solution (not shown). The gas-phase reduction peak increased with the exposure time up to 20 s and leveled off for longer periods. Different configurations of gas-phase amperometric TNT sensors are currently being developed in several laboratories, including ours.
5. Lab-on-a-chip electrochemical detection of explosives Microfluidic analytical devices, which combine multiple sample-handling processes with the actual measurement step on a microchip platform, have received a considerable recent interest [24,25]. Complete assays, involving sample pretreatment (e.g., preconcen tration/extraction), chemical/biochemical derivatization reactions, electrophoretic sepa rations, and detection, can thus be accomplished on a single microchip platform. Because of this high degree of integration (of multiple functional elements and processes), these microfabricated devices are referred to as ‘lab-on-a-chip’ devices. These analytical microsystems rely on electrokinetic fluid ‘pumping’ and obviate the need for pumps or valves. Highly effective separations combined with short assay times have been achieved by combining long separation channels and high electric fields. Owing to their versatility, efficiency, speed, high degree of integration, miniaturization, and ability to handle nanoliter volumes, microchip platforms have proven themselves as attractive vehicles for ‘counter-terrorism’ assays, in general, and for fast and effective separation of explosive substances, in particular.
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
103
Electrochemistry offers great promise for such microsystems, with features that include high sensitivity (approaching that of fluorescence), inherent miniaturization and integration of both detector and control (potentiostatic) instrumentation, compatibility with advanced microfabrication and micromachining technologies, low power and cost requirements, and independence of optical path length or sample turbidity [26–28]. These properties make electrochemical detection extremely attractive for creating truly portable (and possibly disposable) standalone field-deployable microsystems. Various detector configurations, based on different capillary/working electrode arrangements and positions of the electrode relative to the flow direction, have been proposed to meet these requirements. The common characteristic of most of these configurations is the alignment of the detector at the exit of the separation channel. Electrochemical detection for microchip devices can work on different principles. Most commonly, it is performed by controlling the potential of the working electrode at a fixed value and monitoring the current as a function of time. Such fixed-potential amperometric measurements have the advantages of ease of operation and freedom of background current contributions. Negative potentials are particularly useful for monitoring reducible (nitro-containing) explosive compounds. Our group and Hilmi and Luong have developed several effective capillary electrophoresis (CE)/amperometric microchip protocols for detecting nitroaromatic explosives down to the part-per-billion level [29,30]. Such amperometric detection relies on the application of a fixed negative potential at the working electrode and on subsequently monitoring the reduction current as a function of time. The current response generated in this manner reflects the concentration profiles of these explosives as they pass over the detector. For example, Fig. 11 displays microchip-based electropherograms for mixtures containing increasing levels of TNT and DNB in 200-ppb steps. A surfactant, such as sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), is commonly added to the run buffer to facilitate the separation of the neutral nitroaromatic explosives. An end-channel thick-film carbon electrode detector was used for this task. Hilmi and Luong [29] employed a gold working electrode, formed by electroless deposition onto the chip capillary outlet, for highly sensitive amperometric detection of nitroaromatic explosives (with a detection limit of 24 ppb TNT). Analysis of a mixture of four explosives (TNT, 2,4-DNT, 2,6-DNT, and 2,3-DNT) was accomplished within 2 min through the use of a borate/SDS run buffer at a detection potential of −08 V. This microchip system was successfully applied for the analysis of explosive compounds in groundwater and soil samples [30]. Such microchip system is particularly useful for monitoring explosive contamination in military sites, explosives-producing plants, and ammunition factories. Convenient distinction between ‘total’ and ‘individual’ explosive compounds has been accomplished in connection with chip-based ‘flow-injection’ (fast screening) and ‘separation’ (fingerprint identification) operation modes [31]. The realization of this dual screening/identification mode protocol using a single microchannel chip manifold involved the rapid switching from a run buffer that did not contain SDS to an SDScontaining buffer (Fig. 12, right). As micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) separation of neutral (nitroaromatic) compounds requires the addition of a surfactant,
Wang
Current (nA)
104
a
6 4
b
5 nA
2 0
0
500
1000
a b
1500
c (ppb)
G
Current
F
E D C B A 0
50
100
150
Time (s) Fig. 11. Microchip electropherograms for mixtures containing increasing levels of DNB and TNT in 200-ppb steps, along with the resulting calibration plots. Thick-film amperometric carbon detector was held at −07 V; borate buffer (15 mM, pH 8.7) contained 25 mM sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS).
such as SDS, an operation without SDS leads to high-speed (‘flow-injection’) mea surements of the ‘total’ content of these hazardous compounds. As desired for various security scenarios, this allowed for the generation of repetitive fast screening assays of the ‘total’ content of explosive compounds and for a switch to detailed fingerprint identification once such substances were detected. Figure 12 (left) illustrates such ‘total’ and ‘individual’ measurements for a mixture of nitroaromatic organic explosives. In addition to their effectiveness in detecting high-energy organic explosives, microchip devices offer great promise for the separation and detection of ionic com ponents of low explosives [32]. A contactless-conductivity detection system has been particularly useful for this task. This detector can sense all ionic species with con ductivity values different from that of the background electrolyte. The low electro osmotic flow (EOF) of the poly(methylmethacrylate) (PMMA) chip material facilitated the rapid switching between analyses of explosive-related cations and anions using the same microchannel and run buffer; this led to rapid <1 min measurements of seven explosive-related cations and anions down to the low micromolar level. Addition of an 18-crown-6 ether modifier has been used to separate the peaks of co-migrating potas sium and ammonium ions. In addition to sequential injection of anionic and cationic
2-Am-4,6-DNT 4-Am-2,6-DNT
Current
10 nA
TNB DNB TNT 2,4-DNT
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
105
Individual
+2 kV
0
50
100
RB with SDS
150
RB without SDS
Current
Total
Sample
100 nA
0
50
100
150
+5 kV
Time (s) Fig. 12. ‘Total’ and ‘individual’ capillary electrophoresis (CE) microchip measurements of nitroaromatic organic explosives (based on rapid switching between flow-injection and separation modes, respectively). Reproduced with permission from Wang et al. [31].
residues, it is possible to use a special chip-based dual-end opposite injection protocol for simultaneous measurements of explosive-related cations and anions [33]. For this purpose, mixtures of cations and anions were injected simultaneously from both sides of the chip to the separation channel. The cations and anions thus migrated in oppo site directions and were detected in the center of the separation channel by a movable contactless-conductivity detector. Simultaneous measurements of explosive-related ions and nerve-agent degradation products were also demonstrated. Lab-on-a-chip devices have been used for a wide variety of explosive analyses. However, integrating on chip sampling into these explosive measurements is still in the preliminary stages. A new ‘macro-to-micro’ chip interface based on a sharp sample inlet that allowed rapid, convenient, and reproducible introduction of continuously flowing explosive sample stream into narrow chip microchannels was developed [34,35]. Such simple and yeteffective interface facilitates the use of hydrodynamically pumped largevolume samples without perturbing the CE separation and hence the realization of on-line chip-based explosive monitoring. For example, Fig. 13 displays the response for 80 alternate flow-injection measurements of 10 and 5 ppm TNT solutions at ahigh sample throughput of approximately 100 samples per hour. The power and utility of such microfluidic explosive assays will be greatly enhanced by integrating additional sample processing functions (e.g., preconcentration) into their pro tocol. On-going collaborative efforts by several laboratories (including ours) are aimed at developing a self-contained completely functional multi-channel ‘counter-terrorism’ field-portable (hand-held) microanalyzer for providing early and timely simultaneous detection of different classes of explosives and chemical warfare agents.
106
Wang
20 nA
Current
a
b
50 s
Time Fig. 13. Rapid capillary electrophoresis (CE) microchip measurements of TNT obtained by direct sample introduction into the separation channel: 80 alternate injections of (a) 10 and (b) 5 ppm TNT solutions. Reproduced with permission from Chen and Wang [34].
6. Conclusions This chapter has illustrated the power and versatility of modern electrochemical devices for detecting explosives. Electrochemical devices offer attractive opportunities for addressing the growing needs for sensing of explosives. Such devices would allow field testing for major explosives to be performed more rapidly, sensitively, inexpensively, and reliably and should greatly facilitate the realization of in situ detection of explosive compounds. The resulting real-time monitoring capability should thus have a major impact on the way explosive materials are monitored and on the prevention of terrorist activity. Although early efforts have focused on liquid-phase electrochemical measure ments of nitroaromatic explosive compounds, current activity focuses on vapor-phase explosive detection.
Acknowledgments The author thanks the coworkers and collaborators who have contributed to the research on electrochemical sensors, detectors, and microsystems. This work was supported by grants from the ONR, DHS, DOE, and EPA.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7]
J. Yinon, Trends Anal. Chem., 21 (2002) 292. J. Wang, Analytical Electrochemistry (3rd Ed.), John Wiley, New York, 2006. J. Wang, Acc. Chem. Res., 35 (2002) 811. K. Bratin, P. Kissinger, R. Briner, C. Bruntlett, Anal. Chim. Acta, 130 (1981) 295. J. Wang, E. Ouziel, C. Yarnitzky, M. Ariel, Anal. Chim. Acta, 102 (1978) 99. D.M. Gilbert, T.C. Gale, Environ. Sci. Technol., 39 (2005) 9270. W.J. Bowyer, D.H. Evans, J. Org. Chem., 53 (1978) 5234.
Electrochemical Sensing of Explosives
[8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35]
107
J. Wang, S. Thongngamdee, D. Lu, Electroanalysis, 18 (2006) 971. J. Wang, S.B. Hocevar, B. Ogorev, Electrochem. Commun., 6 (2004) 176. H. Zhang, A. Cao, J. Hu, L. Wan, S. Lee, Anal. Chem., 78 (2006) 1967. K. Albert, N.S. Lewis, C. Schaurer, G. Soltzing, S. Stitzel, T. Vaid, D.R. Walt, Chem. Rev., 100 (2000) 2595. J. Wang, F. Lu, D. MacDonald, J. Lu, M.E.S. Ozsoz, K.M. Rogers, Talanta, 46 (1998) 1405. S. Wring, J. Hart, Analyst, 117 (1992) 1281. K.C. Honeychurch, J.P. Hart, P.R. Pritchard, S.J. Hawkins, N.M. Ratcliffe, Biosens. Bioelec tron., 19 (2003) 305. J.C. Chen, J.L. Shih, C.H. Liu, M.Y. Kuo, J.M. Zen, Anal. Chem., 78 (2006) 3752. J. Wang, S. Thongngamdee, Anal. Chim. Acta, 485 (2003) 139. J. Wang, R.K. Bhada, J. Lu, D. MacDonald, Anal. Chim. Acta, 361 (1998) 85. J. Wang, S. Thongngamdee, J. Zima, in preparation. J. Wang, Trends Anal. Chem., 16 (1997) 84. J. Wang, S. Thongngamdee, A. Kumar, Electroanalysis, 16 (2004) 1232. X. Fu, R. Benson, J. Wang, D. Fries, Sens. Actuators B Chem, 106 (2005) 296. R. Knake, P. Jacquinot, A.W. Hodgson, P. Hauser, Anal. Chim. Acta, 549 (2005) 1. M. Krausa, K. Schorb, J. Electroanal. Chem., 461 (1999) 10. D.R. Reyes, D. Iossidis, P.A. Aurox, A. Manz, Anal. Chem., 74 (2002) 2623. P.A. Aurox, D.R. Reyes, D. Iossidis, A. Manz, Anal. Chem., 74 (2002) 2637. J. Wang, Talanta, 56 (2002) 223. J. Wang, Electroanalysis, 17 (2005) 1133. J. Wang, B. Tian, E. Sahlin, Anal. Chem., 71 (1999) 5436. A. Hilmi, J.H.T. Luong, Anal. Chem., 72 (2007) 4677. A. Hilmi, J.H.T. Luong, Environ. Sci. Technol., 34 (2000) 3046. J. Wang, M. Pumera, M.P. Chatrathi, A. Escarpa, M. Musameh, Anal. Chem., 74 (2002) 1187. J. Wang, M. Pumera, G.E. Collins, F. Opekar, I. Jelinek, Analyst, 127 (2002) 719. J. Wang, G. Chen, A. Muck Jr., G.E. Collins, Electrophoresis, 24 (2003) 3728. G. Chen, J. Wang, Analyst, 129 (2004) 507. J. Wang, W. Siangproh, S. Thongngamdee, O. Chailapakul, Analyst, 130 (2005) 1390.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 5
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
Larry Senesac and Thomas Thundat Nanoscale Science and Devices Group, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831, USA
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. 109
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
111
2. Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
112
3. Apparatus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
114
4. PARC for analyte identification. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
118
5. Results and discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
121
6. Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
128
Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 129
110
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
111
1. Introduction Explosive-based terrorism is an eminent threat to a civilized and free society. Accurate and cost-effective explosive sensors are, therefore, essential for combating the terrorist threat. Some of the main performance characteristics for explosive sensors include sensitivity, selectivity, and real-time fast operation. As the vapor pressures of commonly used explosives are extremely small, highly sensitive sensors are essential for detecting trace quantities of explosives. Moreover, the sensors should have high selectivity to have an acceptable rate of false positives. Also, these sensors should have the capability of mass deployment because of the breadth of terrorist threats involving explosives [1]. Finally, these sensors should have fast detection and regeneration time for fast operation. Currently available sensors are unable to satisfy these requirements. Silicon microcantilever sensors that can be mass-produced using currently available microfabrication techniques, however, have the potential to satisfy the conditions of sensitivity, miniature size, low power consumption, and real-time operation [2]. Microcantilevers are generally micromachined from silicon wafers using conventional techniques. Typical dimensions of a micromachined cantilever are 100 m in length, 40 m in width, and 1 m in thickness. The primary advantage of a cantilever beam originates from its ability to sensitively measure displacements with sub-nanometer precision. Sensitive detection of displacement leads to sensitive detection of forces and stresses. Microcantilever sensor technology has been demonstrated in sensitive detection of chemical, physical, and biological analytes [3,4]. Microcantilever sensors can be operated in dynamic mode where mass loading due to molecular adsorption is monitored as a variation in resonance frequency of the cantilever or in static mode where adsorptioninduced surface stress is monitored as bending of a cantilever. In the static mode, adsorption of molecules on one side of the cantilever makes the cantilever bend [5,6]. The bending mode of operation is unique to thin structures where adsorption-induced forces cause the cantilever to bend if the adsorption is confined to a single side. Differential adsorption on the surfaces results in differential stress. Low-frequency, low-springconstant cantilevers result in large bending due to adsorption-induced forces. In addition to bending, the resonance frequency of the cantilever varies sensitively as a function of mass loading. Resonance frequency mode is very similar to the operation of other gravimetric sensors, such as quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) and surface acoustic wave (SAW) transducers. The sensitivity of the dynamic mode of operation is directly related to the frequency of the cantilever; the higher the frequency, the higher the sensitivity. For the cantilevers used in our experiments, the bending mode sensitivity is much higher than that of the dynamic mode, and therefore, we will discuss only bending mode of operation of the cantilever in this chapter. Figure 1 shows a schematic diagram of cantilever bending due to differential molecular adsorption. Microcantilever-based sensing satisfies many requirements for an ideal explosive sensor. Microcantilever sensors have extremely high sensitivity and are compatible with array arrangement for simultaneous detection of multiple analytes. They have the advantages of low power consumption and miniature size. However, microcantilever
112
Senesac and Thundat
Vapor molecules
SAM
Gold coating Si-Nx
Surface adsorption
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of a cantilever bending due to differential adsorption of analyte molecules.
sensors lack chemical selectivity. Chemical selectivity is accomplished using selective layers based on receptor-based detection.
2. Theory 2.1. Cantilever bending The microcantilever is an ideal displacement sensor. The ability to detect the motion of a cantilever beam with nanometer precision makes the cantilever ideal for measuring bending. Cantilever bending can be related to adsorption/desorption of molecules through adsorption forces. As molecular reactions on a surface are ultimately driven by free energy reduction of the surface, the free energy reduction leads to a change in surface stress. Although they would produce no observable macroscopic change on the surface of a bulk solid, the adsorption-induced surface stresses are sufficient to bend a cantilever if the adsorption is confined to one surface. Adsorption-induced forces, however, should not be confused with bending due to dimensional changes such as swelling of thicker polymer films on cantilevers. The sensitivity of adsorption-induced stress sensors can be three orders of magnitude higher than those of frequency variation mass sensors (for resonance frequencies in the range of tens of kilohertz) [3]. Microcantilever deflection changes as a function of adsorbate coverage when adsorption is confined to a single side of a cantilever (or when there is differential adsorption
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
113
on opposite sides of a cantilever). As we do not know the absolute value of the initial surface stress, we can only measure its variation. A relation can be derived between cantilever bending and changes in surface stress from Stoney’s formula and equations that describe cantilever bending [7]. Specifically, a relation can be derived between the radius of curvature of the cantilever beam and the differential surface stress: 61 − 1 = s R Et2
(1)
where R is the radius of curvature of the cantilever, and E are Poisson’s ratio and Young’s modulus for the substrate, respectively, t is the thickness of the cantilever, and s = 1 − 2 is the differential surface stress. Surface stress, , and surface free energy, , can be related using the Shuttleworth equation [8]: = +
(2)
The surface strain, , is defined as the ratio of change in surface area, to original surface area = dA/A. As the bending of the cantilever is very small compared with the length of the cantilever, the strain contribution is only in the part-per-million 10−6 range. Therefore, one can possibly neglect the contribution from surface strain effects and equate the free energy change to surface stress variation [9]. Using Eq. 2, a relationship between the cantilever deflection, z, and the differential surface stress, s, is obtained as z=
3L2 1 − s Et2
(3)
where L is the cantilever length. Therefore, the deflection of the cantilever is directly proportional to the adsorption-induced differential surface stress. Surface stress has units of N/m or J/m2 . Equation 3 shows a linear relation between cantilever bending and differential surface stress. Adsorption-induced forces are applicable only to monolayer films and, as mentioned earlier, should not be confused with bending due to dimensional changes such as swelling of thicker polymer films. It should also not be confused with deflection due to the weight of the adsorbed molecules. The deflection due to weight is extremely small—for example, for a cantilever with a spring constant of 0.1 N/m, the bending due to weight of 1 ng of adsorbed material will be 0.1 nm. The minimum detectable signal for cantilever bending depends on the geometry and the material properties of the cantilever. For a silicon nitride cantilever that is 200 m long and 0 5 m thick, with E = 8 5 × 1010 N/m2 and = 0 27, a surface stress of 0 2 mJ/m2 will result in a deflection of 1 nm at the end. Because a cantilever deflection strongly depends on geometry, the surface stress change, which is directly related to molecular adsorption on the cantilever surface, is a more convenient quantity of the reactions for comparison of various measurements. Changes in free energy density in
114
Senesac and Thundat
biomolecular reactions are usually in the range of 1–50 mJ/m2 but can be as high as 900 mJ/m2 .
2.2. Thermal motions of a cantilever As the cantilevers are very small structures, they execute thermal (Brownian) motion. The longer the cantilever, the more sensitive it is for measuring surface stresses. However, increasing the length also increases the thermal vibrational noise of the cantilever, which from statistical physics is [10,11] n =
2kB TB
kf0 Q
(4)
Here, kB is the Boltzmann constant 1 38 × 10−23 J/K, T is the absolute temperature (300K at room temperature), B is the bandwidth of measurement (typically ∼1000 Hz for dc measurement), k is the cantilever spring constant, f0 is the resonant frequency of the cantilever, and Q is the quality factor of the resonance, which is related to damping. It is clear from Eq. 4 that lower spring stiffness produces higher thermal noise. Higher thermal noise leads to poor signal-to-noise ratio. This thermal motion, however, can be used as an excitation technique for resonance frequency mode operation.
3. Apparatus 3.1. Cantilevers Cantilevers are usually microfabricated from silicon by using conventional photomasking and etching techniques. Typical dimensions of a cantilever are 100 m (length), 40 m (width), and 1 m (thickness). Silicon and silicon nitride cantilevers and cantilever arrays that utilize optical beam deflection for signal transduction are commercially available. Piezoresistive cantilever arrays are also commercially available. Piezoresistive cantilevers are 120 m in length, 40 m in width, and 1 m in thickness.
3.2. Readout techniques There exist a number of readout techniques based on optical beam deflection, variation in capacitance, piezoresistance, and piezoelectricity. Piezoelectricity is more suited for a detection method based on resonance frequency than the method based on cantilever bending. The capacitive method is not suitable for liquid-based applications. The piezoresistive readout has many advantages, and it is ideally suited for handheld devices.
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
115
The piezoresistive readout method has been gaining attention recently. Doped silicon exhibits a strong piezoresistive effect. The resistance of a doped region on a cantilever can change reliably when the cantilever is stressed with deflection [12]. Boisen et al. [13] developed piezoresistive cantilever sensors with integrated differential readout. Each cantilever had a thin resistor element made of doped silicon [13]. The silicon is fully encapsulated in silicon nitride for electrical insulation. The thickness of silicon nitride coating on the doped silicon is adjusted in such a way that the doped silicon resistor is asymmetric with respect to the neutral axis of the cantilever. As the cantilever bends, the resistance of the doped silicon varies linearly because of its asymmetric location with respect to the neutral axis of the entire cantilever. Each sensor was composed of a measurement cantilever and a built-in reference cantilever, which enabled differential signal readout. The two cantilevers were connected in a Wheatstone bridge, and the surface stress change on the measurement cantilever was detected as the output voltage from the Wheatstone bridge. The typical signal-to-noise ratio of the resistance measurement was 26 during the experiments. For cantilevers that were 120 m long, 40 m wide, and 1 3 m thick, the sensor was determined to have a minimum detectable surface stress change of approximately 5 mJ/m2 . Figure 2 shows an array of piezoresistive cantilevers [14]. The piezoresistive readout technique has several advantages over commonly used optical beam deflection methods. For example, optical beam deflection probes the bending of the free end of the cantilever. It is assumed that the bending is uniform along the length of the cantilever. The piezoresistive method, however, measures the integrated bending of the cantilever. Piezoresistive cantilevers can be encapsulated in silicon nitride
Fig. 2. Scanning electron micrograph of a piezoresistive cantilever array.
116
Senesac and Thundat
for operation under solution, thus avoiding the long-standing problems associated with optical path lengths and variations in refractive index. In addition, because no external optical components are required, the electronic readout is more amenable to miniaturization and is ideal for portable devices. An electronic readout is compatible with array arrangements because both cantilevers and readout circuits can be fabricated simultaneously on the same chip. However, currently available piezoresistive cantilever sensors are an order of magnitude less sensitive than those using optical readout techniques. This discrepancy in sensitivity, however, is vanishing because of recent progress in piezoresistive cantilever development. 3.3. Vapor generators Producing highly calibrated, trace quantities of explosive vapor is a challenging task. As the vapor pressures of most explosives are extremely small at room temperature, their vapors are often produced by maintaining the sources at higher temperatures. This leads to the condensation of vapor at cold spots, which should be avoided to deliver highly calibrated quantities of explosive vapors to the cantilever sensor. We have used a custom-built vapor generator that can deliver precise concentrations of explosive vapors in these experiments. The explosive vapors were produced from the headspace vapors from granules of explosives deposited on thickly packed glass wool kept at a constant temperature. These explosive vapors were then mixed as needed with vapors of interferents such as water, alcohol, and acetone, prior to exposure to cantilevers. As the vapors were created at temperatures higher than room temperature, the delivery lines were heated to avoid condensation in these lines. We have also used a vapor generator developed at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) to generate the PETN, RDX, and TNT vapor streams. Flowing ambient air through a reservoir containing explosives (PETN, TNT, or RDX) kept at a constant temperature generated the vapor stream. The reservoirs of the vapor generators consisted of 0.1 g of explosives dissolved in acetone and deposited on glass wool contained in a stainless steel block. The temperature of the reservoir was controlled by two thermoelectric elements that cooled or heated the reservoir, generating a saturation vapor pressure within it. All the experiments were conducted at a constant flow rate of 100 standard cubic centimeters per minute (sccm) to eliminate the parasitic cantilever deflection that would have been induced by variations in flow. In some experiments involving RDX and PETN, the vapor generators were operated at 50 C to produce enough vapor to be delivered to the cantilever chamber. The vapor concentrations for PETN and RDX were 1.4 and 0.3 ppb, respectively, at 50 C [15].
3.4. Sensitivity and false positives The selectivity of the sensor is determined by the efficiency of the coating material. Developing selective coatings is an ongoing research area. Figure 3 shows a useful metric for sensor performance called the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve [16].
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
117
1.0
True positive rate (sensitivity)
Best
Better Good Poor
0.5
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
False positive rate (1 – specificity) Fig. 3. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.
The y-axis of the ROC curve shows the rate of true positives (related to sensitivity), whereas the x-axis shows the rate of false positives (1 – specificity). A poor sensor response will lie along the diagonal. An ideal sensor performance curve lies on the y-axis, that is, zero rate of false positives and high sensitivity. However, the performance of most current sensors lies between the y-axis and the y = x diagonal line as shown in Fig. 3. The key to achieving chemical selectivity lies in using coatings that can take the response curve away from the y = x line toward the y-axis. In the case of microcantilevers, the ability to functionalize one surface of the microcantilever with receptive molecules in such a way that the explosive molecules preferentially bind to the treated surface results in high selectivity. Choosing receptor molecules that can provide highest affinity, therefore, can control the selectivity of detection. Another important requirement for a sensor system is fast regeneration (recovery), so that the sensor can be used repetitively. Satisfying these two conditions requires developing coatings that interact with explosives with interaction energies that are close to the thermal energy, kB T , where kB is the Boltzmann constant and T is the room temperature. This condition, however, severely restricts the types of interactions that one can choose in designing specific coatings. This also results in high false positives as there exists a large number of interfering molecules that can interact with the coating materials. This problem may be solved by using cantilever arrays where each cantilever element produces a unique response due to the chemically specific coatings used. The higher the uniqueness of an individual cantilever, the higher the specificity and the lower the number of cantilevers needed in an array. The design goal for the array is to move away from the y = x diagonal in the ROC curve toward the y-axis.
118
Senesac and Thundat
3.5. Selective coatings A number of coatings can be used for chemical selectivity, such as self-assembled monolayers (SAMs), polymers, metal oxides, and single-stranded DNA. The choice of coatings must take into account the response amplitude, response time, and recovery time. We have chosen a condition of combined detection and recovery time less than 1 min. Often, the response time is faster than the recovery time. For our case, a response time of 10 and a recovery time of 50 s were used. One of the chemically selective coatings that have been used extensively in our study was a SAM of 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA; also known as thiosalicylic acid). SAMs of 4-MBA provide carboxyl end groups for acid–base reactions with explosive molecules [17]. It should be pointed out that the molecular adsorption-induced stress generation is extremely sensitive to the quality of the SAM. Ordered, well-formed SAMs produce higher responses than randomly distributed SAMs. Often, it is necessary to age the SAM by soaking the substrate for hours in SAM solution. For example, the formation of a 4-MBA SAM on the gold surface of the cantilever was achieved by immersing the cantilever into a 6 × 10−3 M solution of 4-MBA (97% from Aldrich Chemical Company) in absolute ethanol for 2 days. Prior to SAM immobilization, the cantilevers were thoroughly cleaned and coated on one side with 3 nm of titanium followed by 30 nm of gold. Upon removal from the solution, the cantilever was rinsed with ethanol and then dried before use in the experiments. The monolayer coating was shown to be quite stable for several months under normal operating conditions. We have also found that electrochemical deposition of SAMs reduces the aging time of the SAMs to minutes. The 4-MBA SAM on gold-coated cantilever has a pKa in the range of 5–7 and binds with strongly basic groups such as nitro-substituted molecules of explosive vapors. For the pattern recognition (PARC) approach, we have coated the piezoresistive cantilevers with different selective layers. Each piezoresistive cantilever had four cantilever elements. Two of these cantilevers were coated with gold, whereas the other two served as reference cantilevers. We have used four separated chips arranged into an array in a single vapor chamber. Each cantilever chip was coated with a different selective agent. The four coatings used in our study include 4-MBA, Au (evaporated), CH3 CH2 11 -SH, and a complex of -cyclodextrin and alkane.
4. PARC for analyte identification 4.1. Background Coatings that can identify explosive molecules with no interference do not exist at present time. This requires the use of partially selective coatings on arrays that can provide responses that are orthogonal or close to orthogonal. For each analyte vapor, an ideal detector array produces a unique chemical response signature. A catalog of these signatures may be produced for a large number of analytes of interest, and this
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
119
catalog may then be used for the identification of unknown vapors. For single-component analytes, this task is relatively straightforward, but for mixtures of several different analytes, a sophisticated computational algorithm is required. Initially, PARC algorithms for this purpose were based on linear system theory. Algorithms such as linear discriminant analysis (LDA), principle component analysis (PCA), and cluster analysis (CA) were used because the action of these linear algorithms on the data is easier to visualize and understand than for non-linear techniques. These linear algorithms map the response data from the individual analytes onto clusters of points in a multidimensional space, where each cluster corresponds to a different analyte. As the number of analytes increases, this invariably leads to an overlap of some of the clusters, resulting in a region where the mapping of a point no longer produces a unique classification. Similarly, as the concentration of the analytes decreases, more of the clusters overlap until at some low concentration they all overlap and no analyte identification is possible. Although algorithms based on these linear techniques have been successful at recognizing fairly large numbers of individual analytes and many binary mixtures [18], they have never been successful for the identification of mixtures of more than two components. For explosive detection, it will be necessary to identify not only single compounds such as TNT, PETN, and RDX individually but also when they are in the presence of associated compounds and common environmental interferents. For these multicomponent mixtures, an approach utilizing non-linear algorithms will be required. The latest PARC algorithms [19,20] include non-linear systems that mimic natural systems. Artificial neural networks (ANNs) were created to mimic the neuronal networks of the human brain. ANN algorithms [21] vary in structure, in learning methodology, and in their performance strengths and weaknesses. The most popular and versatile ANN is the multi-layer perceptron (MLP) with back-propagation error correction (BPEC), but others include probabilistic neural networks (PNNs), neuro-fuzzy systems (NFSs), learning vector quantization (LVQ), radial basis transfer function (RBF), and the newest algorithm, support vector machines (SVMs). Several reviews comparing the characteristics of the different PARC algorithms conclude that the best choice of algorithm is application specific and that hybrid approaches (algorithms combining two or more of the above techniques) show the greatest potential [18,22–24]. It is therefore necessary to develop a PARC algorithm that can meet the specific project goals.
4.2. Analyte signature pattern For the purpose of analyte identification, the response of the detector array to exposure to the analyte vapor must be recorded, and a unique pattern or chemical signature for each analyte must be extracted from the data. A good signature pattern highlights the characteristic features of the data that yield high differentiation between patterns and eliminates those features that provide little or no differentiation information.
120
Senesac and Thundat
This process of feature selection [20] begins by preprocessing the raw data to remove artifacts such as outliers and noise that do not reproduce from one data run to another, making the patterns inconsistent. An example of an outlier would be a typical data spike where one data point may be significantly outside the average data value. The most common noise in the data may come from the electronics used to read and record the data. For microcantilever sensors, the relevant response signal takes place over a period of a few seconds, where by contrast the noise has a relatively high-frequency characteristic. A Fourier high-frequency filter such as a Fourier–Gaussian convolution filter may be used to remove most or all of the noise from the data while causing little or no distortion of the underlying low-frequency response. As rapid changes in signal amplitude require higher frequency Fourier components, caution must be taken to reduce the unwanted noise without severely attenuating (or rounding off) sharp data transitions. An added bonus of this filtering is that the aforementioned outlier spikes in data are of very high frequency and are therefore severely attenuated from the signal. After preprocessing the data, the search begins to find the features in the data that show the largest differences between patterns. This process is very much dependent on the type of detectors in the detection system but may involve comparing the relative amplitudes of the different detectors in the array, the derivative of the response, or even mathematical transforms of the data to select which features show the most differentiation between the patterns of different analytes. For our examples described in Section 5.3., we chose to use 120-data point analyte signature patterns sampled from the entire shape of the signal from a detector array of four cantilevers with coatings described in Section 3.5.
4.3. PARC – linear algorithm – CA For the linear system approach to PARC, we will examine a simple form of CA [20]. We wish to plot the feature vectors of length N (our 120-data point patterns, N = 120) in an N -dimensional vector space. We started with three data sets (three signature patterns) for each of five known analytes. This plotting produces five clusters of three points each in the 120-dimensional vector space. The coordinates of the centers of the five clusters are calculated and stored in the CA algorithm. Once ‘trained’ in this manner, the CA algorithm can map new signature patterns in the 120-dimensional vector space and calculate each pattern’s of RMS distance from the five stored cluster points. If the new point falls within a predetermined distance from one of the five cluster points, the pattern is identified with that cluster point analyte. For this type of analysis, the amplitude of the pattern is important. For our array of four detectors, the response to changes in analyte vapor concentration is fairly linear, so the shape of the response for a given analyte is unchanged by differences in analyte concentration, but the amplitude of the response can vary considerably. If uncorrected, this would lead the CA algorithm to map these patterns at large distances from any of the known analyte clusters. Therefore, for this type of algorithm, all the patterns are normalized between 0 and 1 to yield uniform mapping of the analyte signatures regardless of analyte concentration.
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
121
Input Output Middle
Fig. 4. Simple three-layer artificial neural network (ANN).
4.4. PARC – non-linear algorithm – ANNs Our choice for the non-linear system approach to PARC is the ANN. The ANN is composed of many neurons configured in layers such that data pass from an input layer through any number of middle layers and finally exit the system through a final layer called the output layer. In Fig. 4 is shown a diagram of a simple three-layer ANN. The input layer is composed of numeric scalar data values, whereas the middle and output layers are composed of artificial neurons. These artificial neurons are essentially weighted transfer functions that convert their inputs into a single desired output. The individual layer components are referred to as nodes. Every input node is connected to every middle node, and every middle node is connected to every output node. The ANN is trained using special sets of data called training sets. Each training set consists of an input set of data for the ANN and an output target set. The target set is simply the desired output of the ANN in response to the input set. The goal of training is for the ANN output to match the target set. In our case, the input set is the analyte signature pattern described in Section 4.2, and the target is a set of five numbers corresponding to the five analytes we wish to identify. The training procedure is as follows: the input data set is placed into the input layer of the ANN and is fed forward through the ANN to its output layer. The output is then compared with the desired target set, and the error is calculated. The source of these errors is then backpropagated (traced back through the neurons), and the weight factors are corrected for every neuron connection. This training process is repeated until the ANN output for every training input set converges in agreement with the corresponding target set. An ANN that incorporates this learning technique is referred to as a feed-forward BP-EC ANN [21].
5. Results and discussion 5.1. Single coating To be used in an array, the coatings will have to be selected by testing out many different candidate coatings. We have tested each selective coating individually to characterize
122
Senesac and Thundat
its response to explosive vapors in terms of sensitivity and orthogonality. Here, we will describe the characterization results of 4-MBA coatings. Similar studies were carried out on many different possible coatings. To test the sensitivity of 4-MBA-coated cantilevers to PETN vapors, we carried out some preliminary experiments using the optical beam readout. In this case, we have used a commercially available silicon cantilever. Figure 5 shows the bending response of a SAM-coated cantilever when it was exposed to a PETN vapor stream. It is clear from Fig. 5 that the bending response of the cantilever to the PETN vapor exposure is extremely sensitive and fast. As the noise level of the bending response in these experiments is approximately 2 nm (3× standard deviation of the noise level), the detection resolution corresponding to Fig. 5 is approximately 0.1 ppb. Maximum bending of the cantilever is achieved within 20 s. The amount of PETN delivered by the generator in 20 s was approximately 700 pg. The adsorbed mass calculated from cantilever resonance frequency variation was approximately 100 pg. As the bending due to the weight of the adsorbed mass is around 4 pm, almost all of the bending is due to surface stress. The 200-nm deflection for 100 pg of adsorbed PETN corresponds to a limit of detection (LOD) of a few picograms [16]. Additionally, we carried out temporal response studies of the cantilever as a function of repeated exposure to PETN vapor. One of the important characteristics of a sensor,
50
Bending signal (nm)
0
–50
–100
–150
–200
–250 0
200
400 Time (s)
600
Fig. 5. The response of a 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA)-coated silicon cantilever to a PETN vapors of 1.4 ppb concentration in ambient air. This experiment was performed using the optical readout.
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
123
20
Bending signal (nm)
0
–20
–40
0
200
400 Time (s)
600
Fig. 6. Temporal response of a 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA)-coated cantilever as a function of repeated exposure to PETN vapor.
in addition to selectivity and sensitivity, is its ability for regeneration. For useful applications as an explosive sensor, the cantilever should be able to regenerate itself within seconds for continued operation. Therefore, techniques based on receptors should utilize weak bonding that can be broken at room temperature. Figure 6 shows the temporal response of the cantilever when exposed to a stream of PETN vapor. It is obvious from the Figure that the cantilever responds within 10 s to a stream of PETN vapor at a sub-part-per-billion vapor concentration. When the PETN vapor stream is turned off, the cantilever returns to the original position within 60 s. Figure 5 clearly shows that the cantilever can be operated repeatedly without losing its sensitivity. A test was also performed using a piezoresistive cantilever with the associated Wheatstone bridge readout. The cantilever was prepared with a coating of 4-MBA as described in Section 3.5. Figure 7 shows the bending response of the 4-MBA-coated piezoresistive cantilever as it was exposed to a 10 s pulse of PETN vapor. The Figure also shows the first 40 s of analyte desorption following the exposure. Again, we see the rapid response followed by a return of the cantilever to its original position. The mechanism for cantilever bending is assumed to be adsorption-induced stress. The adsorption decreases the surface free energy, and surface free energy density is surface stress. Hydrogen bonding between the nitro groups of the explosive molecules and the hydroxyl group of 4-MBA may be responsible for the easily reversible adsorption of explosive vapors on the SAM-coated top surface of the cantilever. This hydrogen
124
Senesac and Thundat 300
250
Response (mV)
200
150
100
50
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Time (s) Fig. 7. Response of a 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA)-coated piezoresistive cantilever as a function to the exposure to PETN vapor. The readout electronics were designed to produce a positive signal in response to cantilever bending.
bonding creates a differential surface stress because hydrogen bonding is confined to only one of the surfaces.
5.2. Four-coating array Using just a 4-MBA receptor layer for selective detection of explosives will bring many false-positive signals because the fundamental mechanism is an acid–base reaction. However, there are many other SAMs with different head groups that could be used to provide orthogonal signals. A group of coatings that can provide partially selective binding are metals and oxides of metals deposited on cantilever surfaces. Other coatings we have experimented with include CH3 CH2 11 -SH and a complex of -cyclodextrin and alkane. Once a number of these layers are identified, an array of cantilevers can be modified with different SAMs to create unique responses. The response from an orthogonal array can be analyzed with PARC techniques to identify the explosive molecules.
5.3. PARC: analyte signature patterns In Fig. 8 are shown the chemical signature patterns for five known analytes and one unknown analyte. The patterns were extracted from the response of an array of four coated microcantilevers to exposure to each analyte vapor. The four cantilever coatings
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
80
125
Lever-2/Coating-B – Response to acetone
Response (mV)
60
40
20
0 0
5
15
10
20
25
30
Time (s)
A
B
C
D Acetone
Ethanol
H2O
TNT
Toluene
Unknown vapor
Fig. 8. Analyte chemical signature patterns. The inset at the top of the Figure shows the temporal response of one of the four cantilevers in the detector array. The responses for all four detectors were recorded simultaneously, and the signature pattern for each analyte was created by combining the four responses sequentially.
126
Senesac and Thundat
were (A) 4-MBA, (B) Au (evaporated), (C) CH3 CH2 11 -SH, and (D) a complex of -cyclodextrin and alkane. The cantilevers are of the piezoresistive design described in Section 3.2 that changes electrical resistance in response to cantilever bending due to surface stress. The resistance changes were measured with a Wheatstone bridge circuit and recorded on a computer. For each analyte, the array of four cantilevers was exposed to a 10-s pulse of analyte vapor and the response from all four detectors was recorded simultaneously. The inset plot at the top of Fig. 8 shows the response of cantilever2/coating-B to acetone vapor. The plot shows 10 s of adsorption response followed by the first 20 s of the desorption response. The data were then preprocessed by Fourier Gaussian convolution filtering to remove high-frequency noise, and 30 points were sampled from the data at 1-s intervals. To produce the complete chemical signature pattern, the preprocessing was performed on all four cantilevers (A, B, C, and D, 30 points each) and the four individual patterns were placed end-to-end to produce a 120-point signature pattern for each analyte. These 120-data point values were then used as the input features for the PARC algorithms. The analytes used were acetone, ethanol, H2 O, TNT, and toluene. An unknown vapor signature was also produced artificially and is plotted at the bottom of Fig. 8. The purpose of the artificial unknown signature pattern was to test the ability of PARC algorithms to reject a pattern that is similar to the known patterns for which it was trained to recognize. For explosive detection, water vapor often causes problems. Notice that the signatures for TNT and H2 O look very similar, having similar relative amplitude patterns. A closer look reveals a very slight difference in desorption rates where the slope of the H2 O curve is steeper during desorption than in the TNT curve. More importantly, we see that for most of the start of the adsorption side of the curve, the slope of the H2 O curve starts out steeper and continually decreases toward the peak (negative curvature), whereas the slope of the TNT curve starts out more shallow and continually increases toward the peak (positive curvature).
5.4. PARC: CA Three new sets of data were taken for each of the five analytes (and three sets of the artificial ‘unknown vapor’ were created as described in Section 5.3), and their signature patterns were produced. The new signatures were then normalized and presented to the trained CA algorithm to determine their RMS distances from the known clusters. The results are summarized in Table 1. The leftmost column of the Table lists the analytes (three rows each for the three data sets) to be identified by the CA algorithm, and the other columns list the distances of the analyte from the known clusters. If we assign a value of between 6.0 and 7.0 to be the threshold between positive identification and negative identification, we see that the algorithm correctly identifies all the analytes (the shaded cells in the Table) with no false positives. Also note that the unknown analyte was rejected, not mapping close to any of the known clusters. For explosive detection,
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
127
Table 1. Pattern recognition of analytes by cluster analysis Analytes
Root mean square distance from center of each cluster Acetone
Ethanol
H2 O
TNT
Toluene
Acetone
5.79 5.70 1.32
21.44 12.17 17.13
16.53 15.93 15.60
14.15 7.32 10.35
12.06 12.31 10.78
Ethanol
18.83 14.48 17.34
3.77 3.45 2.30
20.50 16.09 18.67
11.85 7.09 9.75
19.89 15.27 17.98
H2 O
15.12 15.19 16.86
19.83 17.43 18.46
5.02 1.70 3.58
12.47 10.29 11.83
10.02 8.53 9.72
TNT
10.42 9.63 9.90
8.04 9.68 10.09
12.13 10.42 10.51
1.54 1.27 1.43
11.15 9.50 9.49
Toluene
13.01 11.45 8.78
17.90 17.63 17.93
8.80 8.62 10.35
10.95 10.30 10.23
3.22 1.73 4.34
Unknown
18.95 16.72 17.43
22.76 18.07 19.13
19.47 16.87 17.89
18.13 14.14 15.12
19.18 15.89 16.77
it is particularly interesting to note that the TNT and H2 O signatures do not map close to each other, making them easy to differentiate.
5.5. PARC: ANN For our ANN training, we used the same set of signature patterns used in training the CA algorithm above (three runs each for the five analytes of interest), and the patterns were preprocessed as described in Section 5.3. One important note here: whereas, in the case of the CA algorithm, it was necessary to normalize the signature patterns to prevent misidentification of analytes at different concentrations, ANNs can be trained to recognize both the species and the concentration of the analytes and have been used to recognize the species and the concentrations of analytes individually as well as the components of binary mixtures [25]. For consistency and comparability with the CA algorithm, we chose to normalize the data here as well. The target output of the ANN is a set of five numbers corresponding to the five analytes we wish to identify. For each analyte training pattern, the output target has a value of 1.0 in the position corresponding to the correct analyte and a value of 0.0 in the other four positions. The ANN is then
128
Senesac and Thundat
Table 2. Pattern recognition of analytes by artificial neural network (ANN) Analytes
Acetone Ethanol H2 O TNT Toluene Unknown
ANN recognition of analyte components Acetone
Ethanol
H2 O
TNT
Toluene
0.993 0 010 0 004 0 004 0 001 0 034
0 005 0.993 0 000 0 000 0 005 0 001
0 000 0 000 0.965 0 004 0 004 0 009
0 000 0 000 0 006 0.968 0 005 0 022
0.000 0.016 0.033 0.017 0.956 0.011
trained to produce a value near 1 for the output corresponding to the correct analyte and a value near 0 for incorrect analytes. The training for this ANN took less than 1 min on a desktop computer. A new set of data was taken for each of the five analytes (and one set of the artificial ‘unknown vapor’ was created), and their signature patterns were produced as described in Section 5.3. The new signatures were then normalized and presented to the trained ANN algorithm, and the results are summarized in Table 2. The leftmost column of the Table lists the analytes to be identified by the ANN, and the other columns list the five ANN output components. The output values can be thought of as representing the relative probability of detection for each of the five output analytes. The small differences of the outputs from the desired 0 or 1 probabilities are due to the fact that test set data are not identical to any of the training sets used to train the ANN. Allowing for these random fluctuations and assigning a threshold value of 5% for positive detection, the ANN correctly identifies all five analytes (the shaded cells in the Table) with no false positives. The ANN also rejects the ‘unknown’ signature pattern. For explosive detection and the discrimination between the TNT and H2 O signatures, we see that the output values show no significant recognition of TNT in the H2 O signature and no significant recognition of H2 O in the TNT signature.
6. Conclusions Adsorption-induced bending of microcantilevers in an array where each cantilever element is modified with different receptor layers can be used for the detection of explosive vapors. The detector response is fast, reversible, and repeatable. Receptive layers such as SAMs provide selectivity to cantilever sensing. As no chemically selective coatings are absolutely specific, arrays of cantilevers coated with partially selective coatings were used, and data were analyzed with PARC algorithms. Comparing the two PARC algorithms used here, we saw that both algorithms successfully identified the target analytes. A closer look at the CA output shows that the range of positive detection output is 1.27–5.79 and for negative detection is 7.09–22.76, giving a separation of 1.3 between
Explosive Vapor Detection Using Microcantilever Sensors
129
positive and negative ranges. Therefore, the separation between positive and negative detection is only 0.29 times the range of positive detection. By contrast, the ANN output shows that the range of positive detection output is 0.956–0.993 and for negative detection is 0.000–0.034, giving a separation of 0.922 between positive and negative ranges. This separation between positive and negative detection is 24.9 times the range of positive detection, giving the ANN algorithm almost two orders of magnitude greater separation between positive and negative detection than the CA algorithm. This makes the ANN much less likely to produce a false-positive analyte identification. The array of four microcantilever detectors proved adequate for differentiating the five individual analytes used here, but as we strive to distinguish hundreds or thousands of analytes and mixtures of analytes, larger arrays of detectors and coatings will be necessary to produce the orthogonal responses needed to produce response signature patterns that are unique to each analyte. Our current research involves using arrays of 32 cantilever sensors to detect explosives such as TNT, RDX, and PETN individually and in the presence of associated compounds and common environmental interferents. As the complexity of the mixtures increases, we find it necessary to modify and combine multiple PARC algorithms to properly detect and identify the mixture components.
Acknowledgments This work was supported by the Department of Homeland Security, Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms (ATF), and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). Initial experiments were carried out with help from E. Hawak, V. Boidjev, Lal Pinnaduwage, T. Ghel, and D. Hedden. ORNL is managed by UT-Battelle, LLC, for the U. S. Department of Energy under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725.
References [1] L.A. Pinnaduwage, Hai-Feng Ji, and T. Thundat, IEEE Sensors Journal, 5, 775 (2005). [2] T. Thundat, P.I. Oden, and R.J. Warmack, Microscale Thermophysical Engineering, 1, 185 (1997). [3] T. Thundat and A. Majumdar, Microcantilevers for physical, chemical, biological sensing, in Sensors and Sensing in Biology and Engineering, F.G. Barth, J.A.C. Humphry, and T.W. Secomb (eds.) pp 338–355, SpringerWein, New York (2003). [4] N.V. Larvick, M.J. Sepaniak, and P.G. Datskos, The Review of Scientific Instruments, 75, 2229 (2004). [5] T. Thundat, R.J. Warmack, and D.P. Allison, Applied Physics Letters, 77, 4061 (2000). [6] R. Berger, Ch. Berger, H.P. Lang, and J.K. Gimzewski, Science, 276, 2021 (1997). [7] G.G. Stoney, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B. Biological Sciences, 82, 172 (1909). [8] R. Shuttleworth, Proceedings of the Physical Society of London, 63, 444 (1950). [9] H.-J. Butt, Advances in Colloid and Interface Science, 180, 251 (1996). [10] D. Sarid, Scanning Force Microscopy, Oxford University Press, New York (1991).
130
Senesac and Thundat
[11] M.V. Salapaka, S. Bergh, J. Lai, A. Majumdar, and E. McFarland, Journal of Applied Physiology, 81, 2480 (1997). [12] M. Tortonese, R.C. Barrett, and C.F. Quate, Applied Physics Letters, 62, 834 (1993). [13] A. Boisen, J. Thaysen, H. Jensenius, and O. Hansen, Ultramicroscopy, 62, 834 (2000). [14] Available from Cantion Inc. A/S, c/o NanoNord A/S, Skjernvej 4A, DK9220 Aalborg 0, Denmark. www.cantion.com. [15] B.C. Dionne, D.P. Rounbehler, E.K. Achter, J.R. Hobbs, and D.H. Fine, Energetic Material, 4, 447 (1986). [16] S. Srinath, PhD Dissertation, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, CA (2006). [17] L.A. Pinnaduwage, V. Boiadjiev, J.E. Hawk, and T. Thundat, Applied Physics Letters, 83, 1471 (2003). [18] M. Hsieh, E.T. Zellers, Analytical Chemistry, 76, 1885 (2004). [19] R.O. Duda, P.E. Hart, and D.G. Stork, Pattern Classification – 2nd Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York (2001). [20] S. Theodoridis and K. Koutroumbas, Pattern Recognition – 3rd Edition, Academic Press, Amsterdam (2006). [21] M.T. Hagan, H.B. Demuth, and M. Beale, Neural Network Design, PWS Publications Co., Boston, MA (1995). [22] T.P. Vaid, M.C. Burl, and N.S. Lewis, Analytical Chemistry, 73, 321 (2001). [23] R.E. Shaffer, S.L. Rose-Pehrsson, and R.A. McGill, Analytica Chimica Acta, 384, 305 (1999). [24] P.C. Jurs, G.A. Bakken, and H.E. McClelland, Chemical Reviews, 100, 2649 (2000). [25] L.R. Senesac, P. Dutta, P.G. Datskos, and M.J. Sepaniak, Analytica Chimica Acta, 558, 94 (2006).
Chapter 6
Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives
Richard C. Lanza Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Counterterrorist Detection Techniques of Explosives Jehuda Yinon (Editor)
© 2007 Published by Elsevier B.V.
All rights reserved.
131
Contents
Page 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
133
2. Neutron techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
135
3. Practical issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
141
4. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
151
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153
132
Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives
133
1. Introduction The problem under consideration is the detection of explosive materials that may be made of a variety of materials and generally are hidden so as to make the detection of their presence difficult, especially to a casual inspection. The goal of any inspection technique is to non-intrusively determine the presence of such materials in a manner that is consistent with not interrupting the normal scheme of commerce and that, at the same time, exhibits a high probability of detection and a low probability of false alarms. A great deal of work has been reported in the literature on neutron-based techniques for the detection of explosives, with by far the largest impetus coming from the requirements of the commercial aviation industry for the inspection of lug gage and, to a lesser extent, cargo. There, the major alternative techniques are either X-ray based or chemical trace detection methods that look for small traces of explo sive residues. The limitations of the X-ray and trace methods are well known, but as of the date of this writing (2006), it is safe to say that despite extensive devel opment, no neutron- or nuclear-based technique is in use in aviation security on a routine basis. More recent events (September 11, 2001) have focused interest on other places for which surveillance is required, but unfortunately, these new places lack much of the control over inspected objects, which is characteristic of the aviation indus try; materials must of necessity pass through a defined location before being loaded on the aircraft. In light of these changes, it is now useful to re-examine neutron methodologies.
1.1. Characteristics of explosive materials Explosive materials vary widely in their chemical composition, and in some sense, one could argue that the common characteristic of these materials is that they explode. Although it is certainly true that many commercial and military explosives have high concentrations of nitrogen, recent experience has revealed a new set of non-nitrogenous explosives that are often fabricated by terrorists from readily available and fairly ordinary materials that may be purchased without arousing suspicion. It is essential that the designer of detection equipment recognize the vast variety of potential threats and thus understand clearly what the limitations of a particular technique may be. It should be emphasized here that the implications of the widespread use of these improvised explosives imply that the detection of nitrogen alone will often be inadequate, and indeed, the use of assumed elemental ratios for explosive composition may lead to difficulties in detection [1]. A list of potential explosives was summarized by Makky [2] and Gozani [3]. Data from Krauss are shown in Figs 1–3. Note that the Figures are summaries of explosives of concern that have high concentrations of nitrogen and oxygen, and in fact, these elements Figure prominently in most of the current literature.
134
Lanza
0.9
Innocuous materials Plastics and rubbers Military Commercial Liquids Black powder area Smokeless powder area Schultze powders Other propellants
0.8
Nitrogen weight fraction
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 –0.1 0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4 Density (g/cc)
1.6
1.8
2
2.2
Fig. 1. Density versus nitrogen weight fraction for representative explosives. Reproduced with permission from Makky [2], pp. 18–21.
20
Military 18
Commercial Liquid
Average atomic number (Z)
16
Innocuous materials Plastics and rubbers
14
12
10
8
6
4 0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4 Density (g/cc)
1.6
1.8
2
2.2
Fig. 2. Density versus average atomic number for representative explosives. Reproduced with permission from
Makky [2], pp. 18–21.
Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives 0.95
Innocuous materials Plastics and rubbers Military
Commercial
Liquids
Black powder and other propellants
Smokeless powders
Pure compounds
0.85 0.75 Oxygen weight fraction
135
0.65 0.55 0.45 0.35 0.25 0.15 0.05 –0.05 –0.05
0.05
0.15
0.25 0.35 Nitrogen weight fraction
0.45
0.55
0.65
Fig. 3. Nitrogen weight fraction versus oxygen weight fraction for representative explosives. Reproduced with permission from Makky [2], pp. 18–21.
2. Neutron techniques 2.1. Overview Neutron techniques are based on the detection of the nuclear properties of possible threats rather than their density or chemical properties. One may summarize the advantages of these techniques as follows: 1. Determine elemental composition not just density: This is the major advantage of nuclear techniques as compared with conventional X-ray scanners. Conventional X-ray techniques generally measure the apparent density and shape of objects. Using dual-energy X-rays, one also gets an approximation to the average atomic number (Z) of the material, and can it and spatial extent as a clue to the presence of an explo sive material. Neutron techniques offer the possibility of determining the elemental composition of a suspicious object. 2. Great penetration and potential for cargo inspection: The effective range of neutrons even in metals enables penetration of much greater thicknesses of materials than the usual low-energy (140 kV) X-ray scanner, although it should be noted that high-energy X-ray sources, such as from multi-MeV electron linacs, offer similar penetration. Of course, each technique has its limitations; neutrons are shielded by low-Z materials, particularly organics, and high-energy X-rays by high-Z metals.
136
Lanza
3. Difficult to shield contraband against probing radiation, usually neutrons or gammas: This is a corollary of the previous statement; however, in the interest of completeness, one should recognize that the presence of a large absorber in an object under inspection is in itself an indication of a potential threat and will also trigger a “shield alarm” in many X-ray imaging systems. 4. Detection of nuclear materials: This is a different aspect of the use of neutrons in that nuclear materials may be detected by their response to probing neutrons. In some cases, depending on the neutron energy and the material under inspection, this can be a very clear identifier of such materials. This subject constitutes a separate area of research and will not be discussed in this chapter. Although it is largely concerned with land mines, the review by Bruschini [4] out lines most of the nuclear techniques for explosive detection, which were commercially available at the time of its writing. Other useful reviews are those of Khan [5], Buffler [6], Nebbia and Juergen [7], and Schubert and Kuznetsov [8].
2.2. Neutrons in, gammas out This is one of the most common approaches using neutrons. One of the earliest approaches to the explosives problem was thermal neutron analysis used for aircraft luggage inspection [9,10]. A piece of luggage is bombarded by neutrons from either an isotopic �252 Cf� or an electronic source deuteron-tritium (DT). The neutrons are allowed to thermalize in the luggage, and nitrogen is detected through the reaction ∗ 14 N + n�thermal� → 15 N → 15 N + � (10.8 MeV). Detection of the 10.8 MeV gamma confirms the presence of nitrogen. Unfortunately, the lack of imaging and the general low sensitivity of the method led to its being abandoned for aircraft security, although there have been some attempts at using it for the detection of land mines. The more common approach which is now used relies on fast neutrons as probes that excite nuclear processes, generally leading to the production of characteristic gamma rays through inelastic processes of the form (n, n’�). The technique had its origins in the mining industry, where neutron probes were used to analyze the composition of coal and other materials. The cross-sections for these processes for elements of interest for explosive detection are shown in Fig. 4, along with the energies of the resultant gammas for materials such as nitrogen, carbon, oxygen and elements associated with many common explosives. Examples of spectra from coal analysis are shown in Figs 5 and 6. One of the most developed of these methods is the technique usually referred to as pulsed fast neutron analysis (PFNA) [3,11–13]. The operation is illustrated in Fig. 7 [11]. Neutrons in the range of ∼ 8 MeV are generated by an accelerator (not shown) by the reaction D(d,n)He. The accelerator is pulsed with a ∼1 ns pulse width to produce 1 ns pulses of neutrons with a repetition rate of ∼1 MHz. Gamma rays are detected in a series of scintillation detectors. The time difference between the accelerator pulse and the
Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives
137
0.5 Carbon 4.43 MeV
Cross-section (barn)
0.4 Oxygen 6.13 MeV Oxygen 6.92 MeV
0.3 Nitrogen 5.11 MeV
0.2 Nitrogen 1.64 MeV
0.1 Nitrogen 2.31 MeV
0
2.00
4.00
6.00 Neutron Energy (MeV)
8.00
10.00
O 6130 800
750
700
650
O 5620 (s)
Na 1633 Si, Al 1779 H 2223 600
850 550
Pb, Ge 6740 Fe 7130 (s), 7280 Pb, Ge 7360 Fe 7640 800
750
Si 4423 (s), C 4434 (s) S 4910 (s), Si 4934, C 4945 S 5420 CI 5600 (s), O 5620 (s) CI 6110, O 6130 650
350
300
250
700
O 6130
O 5620 (s)
C 4443 250
150
100
Counts
C 3932 (s)
Fig. 4. Cross-sections for inelastic neutron gamma production for various lines in nitrogen, oxygen and carbon.
Channel number
Fig. 5. Spectra from pulsed neutron analysis of coal.
gamma detected is used to determine the position along the beam where the interaction took place. By mechanically scanning the beamline so as to move the beam through the object, the gammas can be correlated with the position of interaction in three dimensions. The resulting gamma ray spectrum is used to determine relative elemental content for “voxels” in the object under inspection. For 8 MeV neutrons, the time-of-flight (ToF) measurement yields an accuracy of ∼5 cm in space. The physics for this particular system has been refined over a number of years. One should note that the choice of neutron energy, ∼8 MeV, means that scattered neutrons will generally lose enough energy so that
Fe 7640
Fe 7130 (s), 7280, Pb 7367
Cl 6110, O 6130
Cl 5600 (s), O 5620 (s)
S 5420
Pb 6736, 6856 (s)
Counts Error (sigma)
Si 4934, C 4945, S 4910 (s)
Lanza
Si 4423 (s), C 4434 (s)
138
3 0 –3 150
200
250 Channel number
300
350
Fig. 6. Details of spectrum of coal showing fitted results.
they fall below the threshold for gamma production, and thus do not contribute to spatial clutter. Another point to observe is that the detectors are conventional scintillators (NaI) rather than high-energy-resolution detectors such as High Purity Germanium (HPGe). The choice of detectors was made after both experimental observation and cost analysis. The NaI has considerably higher efficiency and count rate capability than, HPGe but has poorer energy resolution. This is overcome by the use of the entire spectrum rather than single peaks to determine elemental composition. In this approach, rather than fitting the data to individual peaks, the entire spectrum is fitted to a linear combination of whole spectra from each of the elements. This approach has long been used in areas such as well logging and online coal and mineral analysis [14–16]. In controlled tests in the United Kingdom, the system demonstrated the ability to achieve a high detection probability (98%) for cargo inspection with only one false alarm during the tests. Despite this, the system was not installed, mostly due to concerns over system complexity, unease about downtime, large space requirements, and, finally, cost [17]. Another major study of PFNA came to similar conclusions [18]. An alternative and less complex (and less powerful) approach to the use of probing with neutrons uses a sealed neutron generator based on the DT reaction. This approach is commercially used in fields such as coal analyzers among others, and there have
Neutron Techniques for Detection of Explosives
139
Gamma ray energy information
Gamma ray arrival time
Top detectors Image
Energy
ce
tan
Dis
Neutron departure
time
Reflection detectors
D
Transmission detectors
Scan angle
e)
y) (Tim
it Veloc
e=( istanc
Bottom detectors
Fig. 7. Pulsed fast neutron analysis system [11].
been a number of attempts at using this method land mine detection and explosive detection [45,46]. The most common implementations of this technique use high-energy neutrons, typi cally 14 MeV from a sealed DT tube [16]. The resulting gamma rays are then detected by a gamma detector, usually a scintillator, but sometimes a germanium solid-state detector. This approach has been well described in the literature and has led to several commer cial implementations as well as many research laboratory studies [7,19–24]. Figure 8 shows the results from probing an explosive shell and indicates the presence of explosive compounds. In a modification of this approach, usually referred to as associated particle interrogation (API) or “tagged” neutrons, the recoil alpha particle associated with a neutron from the target is detected and its direction and timing are used to improve the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) [21,22]. Despite the apparent simplicity of design obtained by the use of a sealed DT gener ator, practical considerations often lead to less than satisfactory results, and as a result, a considerable amount of ingenuity and skill must often be employed to build a prac tical unit. Because the use of 14-MeV sealed DT neutron generators, both tagged and untagged, is so common, the details of operation of such systems will be discussed in more detail later.
140
Lanza
100 000
Carbon (4