Computer Games as Educational and Management Tools: Uses and Approaches Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Vitor Hugo Costa Carvalho Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Paula Cristina Almeida Tavares Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal
Senior Editorial Director: Director of Book Publications: Editorial Director: Acquisitions Editor: Production Editor: Typesetters: Print Coordinator: Cover Design:
Kristin Klinger Julia Mosemann Lindsay Johnston Erika Carter Sean Woznicki Mike Brehm, Keith Glazewski, Natalie Pronio, Jennifer Romanchak, Milan Vracarich Jr. Jamie Snavely Nick Newcomer
Published in the United States of America by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 701 E. Chocolate Avenue Hershey PA 17033 Tel: 717-533-8845 Fax: 717-533-8661 E-mail:
[email protected] Web site: http://www.igi-global.com/reference Copyright © 2011 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher. Product or company names used in this set are for identification purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Computer games as educational and management tools: uses and approaches / Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha, Vitor Hugo Carvalho, and Paula Tavares, editors. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. Summary: “This book considers the many uses of games and simulations, focusing specifically on their use in organizational and educational settings and providing perspectives on gaming for distance learning, gaming for rehabilitation, business simulators, and motivational games, this publication explores new and emerging trends in this ever-evolving area of research”-Provided by publisher. ISBN 978-1-60960-569-8 (hardcover) -- ISBN 978-1-60960-570-4 (ebook) 1. Management games. 2. Management--Simulation methods. 3. Organization-Simulation methods. 4. Computer simulation. I. Cruz-Cunha, Maria Manuela, 1964- II. Carvalho, Vitor Hugo, 1979- III. Tavares, Paula, 1973HD30.26.C66 2011 658.3’124--dc22 2011012251
British Cataloguing in Publication Data A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All work contributed to this book is new, previously-unpublished material. The views expressed in this book are those of the authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.
Editorial Advisory Board Nelson Zagalo, Universidade do Minho, Portugal Rui Prada, Instituto Superior Técnico, Portugal Adamantios Koumpis, ALTEC Software S.A., Greece Pedro Mota Teixeira, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal António José Videira Tavares, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal
List of Reviewers Adamantios Koumpis, ALTEC Software S.A, Greece Agostino Poggi, Università degli Studi di Parma, Italy Ana Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Ana Castro Correia, TECField Sistemas de Informação e Multimédia, Lda, Portugal Anja Johansson, Linköping University, Sweden Antonio Manuel Valente de Andrade, Universidade Católica Portuguesa – Porto, Portugal Antonio Magalhaes, Universidade do Porto, Portugal Augusta Gaspar, ISCTE-IUL, Cis-IUL, Portugal Bernard Riera, Reims University, France Bruno Vigário, Real Games Lda, Portugal Clodis Boscarioli, Western Paraná State University, Brazil Corinne Grenier, Euromed Management, Marseille, France Daniel Thomas, Griffith University, Australia Danny Pannicke, Berlin Institute of Technology, Germany Eva Ferreira Oliveira, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Fernando Paulo Belfo, Polytechnic Institute of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal Giannis Milolidakis, Technological Education Institution of Crete, Greece & Euromed Management, Marseille, France Gyula Mester, University of Szeged, Hungary Heather O’Brien, University of British Columbia, Canada Heiko Duin, BIBA Bremer Institut für Produktion und Logistik GmbH, Germany Helena Coelho, Technical University of Lisbon, Portugal Henry Emurian, UMBC, USA Ines de Seixas Duarte, Universidade Católica Portuguesa – Porto, Portugal
Isidro De Pablo, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Jannicke Baalsrud Hauge, University of Bremen, Germany João Orvalho, Face In Motion, Portugal Johann Riedel, Nottingham University Business School, UK Jonas Repschlaeger, Berlin Institute of Technology, Germany Jorge Bidarra, Western Paraná State University, Brazil Jose Bidarra, Universidade Aberta, Portugal Juho Hamari, Helsinki Institute for Information Technology HIIT, Finland Julia Bullard, University of British Columbia, Canada Julio Angel Ortiz, Harvard University, USA Karla Munoz Esquivel, University of Ulster, UK Kostas Anagnostou, Ionian University, Greece Ljubo Vlacic, Griffith University, Australia Luis Neri, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico Mabel Okojie, Mississippi State University, USA Marcelo Fantinato, University of São Paulo, Brazil Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Mark G. Elwell, Hakusan International School, Japan Martin Heitmann, Technische Universität Berlin, Germany Michael Barlow, The University of New South Wales at the Australian Defence Academy, Australia Morgan Leigh Murillo Guimarães Carneiro, Federal University of Uberlândia, Brazil Nicholas Stegg Olga Albuquerque, Escola Secundária Dr Jaime Magalhães Lima, Portugal Patrícia Arriaga, ISCTE-IUL, Cis-IUL, Portugal Patricia Gonçalves, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Paula Cristina Almeida Tavares, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Pedro Campos, University of Madeira & Universitário da Penteada, Portugal Pedro Pina, ESTGOH - Polytechnic Institute of Coimbra, Portugal Peter J. Denning, Naval Postgraduate School, USA Peter Wasilko, The Institute for End User Computing, Inc., USA Petri Lankoski, Aalto University, Finland Pierangelo Dell’Acqua, Linköping University, Sweden Piroska Stanić Molcer, Subotica-Tech, Subotica, Serbia Ruediger Zarnekow, Berlin Institute of Technology, Germany Sarajane Marques Peres, University of São Paulo, Brazil Sofia Efraimidou, University of Thessaly, Greece Stephen Schafer, Digipen Institute of Technology, USA Tiago Gomes, University of Minho, Portugal Tim Serong Verónica Costa Orvalho, Universidade do Porto, Portugal Vítor Hugo Costa Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Vladimir Devyatkov, Bauman Moscow State Technical University, Russia Vlado Delić, University of Novi Sad, Serbia
Table of Contents
Preface . ................................................................................................................................................ xv Chapter 1 Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes........................................................... 1 Vitor Hugo Costa Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Celina Pinto Leão, University of Minho, Portugal Filomena Soares, University of Minho, Portugal Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Chapter 2 Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’......... 10 C. Karagiannidis, University of Thessaly, Greece S. Efraimidou, University of Thessaly, Greece A. Koumpis, ALTEC Software S.A, Greece Chapter 3 Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games................................ 23 Daniel I. Thomas, Griffith University, Australia Ljubo B. Vlacic, Griffith University, Australia Chapter 4 Computer Games and Libraries............................................................................................................. 52 Helena Coelho, Technical University of Lisbon, Portugal Chapter 5 Games and Simulations in Distance Learning: The AIDLET Model.................................................... 67 José Bidarra, Universidade Aberta, Portugal Meagan Rothschild, University of Wisconsin, USA Kurt Squire, University of Wisconsin, USA
Chapter 6 The Educational Value of Digital Games: Possibilities and Limitations of the Use of Digital Games as Educational Tools (The Spore Case)..................................................................................... 86 Ana Castro Correia, TECField Sistemas de Informação e Multimédia, Lda, Portugal Lia Raquel Oliveira, University of Minho, Portugal Chapter 7 The Pedagogical Potential of MMOG: An Exploratory Study Including Four Games and their Players......................................................................................................................................... 103 Tiago Gomes, University of Minho, Portugal Ana Amélia A. Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Chapter 8 Browser-Native Games That Use Real-World XML Data................................................................... 122 Jonathan Chetwynd, London, UK Chapter 9 A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to Designing Business Management Games..................................... 136 Pedro Campos, University of Madeira & INESC ID Lisbon, Portugal Chapter 10 Creating Computer Games for Class Instruction................................................................................. 151 Chien Yu, Mississippi State University, USA Anthony A. Olinzock, Mississippi State University, USA Chapter 11 RACEM Game for PC for Use as Rehabilitation Therapy for Children with Psychomotor Disability and Results of Its Application............................................................................................. 167 Brenda Flores Muro, Universidad Autónoma de Coahuila, Mexico Eduardo César Contreras Delgado, Universidad Autónoma de Coahuila, Mexico Chapter 12 When Control Education is the Name of the Game............................................................................. 185 António Pessoa de Magalhães, Universidade do Porto, Portugal Bernard Riera, Reims University, France Bruno Vigário, Real Games Lda, Portugal Chapter 13 Affective Educational Games and the Evolving Teaching Experience............................................... 206 Karla Muñoz, University of Ulster, UK Paul Mc Kevitt, University of Ulster, UK Tom Lunney, University of Ulster, UK Julieta Noguez, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico Luis Neri, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico
Chapter 14 Business Simulators for Business Education and Research: SIMBA Experience............................... 229 Fernando Borrajo, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Yolanda Bueno, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Fernando Fernández, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Javier García, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Isidro de Pablo, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Ismael Sagredo, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Begoña Santos, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Chapter 15 Educational Games.............................................................................................................................. 247 Gyula Mester, University of Szeged, Hungary Piroska Stanić Molcer, Subotica-Tech, Subotica, Serbia Vlado Delić, University of Novi Sad, Serbia Chapter 16 Evaluation of Simulation Games for Teaching Production (Engineering).......................................... 263 Johann C.K.H. Riedel, Nottingham University Business School, UK Jannicke Baalsrud Hauge, University of Bremen, Germany Chapter 17 Can Computer Games Motivate and Sustain Learning?...................................................................... 280 Mabel CPO Okojie, Mississippi State University, USA Compilation of References ............................................................................................................... 299 About the Contributors .................................................................................................................... 324 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 334
Detailed Table of Contents
Preface . ................................................................................................................................................ xv Chapter 1 Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes........................................................... 1 Vitor Hugo Costa Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal Celina Pinto Leão, University of Minho, Portugal Filomena Soares, University of Minho, Portugal Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha, Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal This chapter presents a research developed in collaboration by two higher education institutions. Nowadays, high education programs can only be successful with the use of new technologies in the teaching/ learning process, especially when there are special education requirements. Two experiments were carried out: (1) a set of billiard balls, for snooker game, simulated by using physics laws and, (2) aLJo 2009, a game whose aim is to achieve the correct sorting of a sequence to accomplish a common task. Both projects were developed by students with different background and from different engineering courses. The snooker game, an academic project, aims to demonstrate that, through a simple game, several areas of knowledge can be used. On the other hand, aLJo 2009 was developed considering a collaboration protocol between the university and the Parents and Friends Association of the Citizen with Mental Deficiency (APPCDM), to improve behavior and social skills in patients with mental impairments. Chapter 2 Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’......... 10 C. Karagiannidis, University of Thessaly, Greece S. Efraimidou, University of Thessaly, Greece A. Koumpis, ALTEC Software S.A, Greece In recent years the gap between educational theory and practice has been closing, but although there have been calls for ‘reflexivity’, there has been little critical examination of its meanings. Proposed reflexive methodologies still perpetuate many traditional hierarchies, and fail to consider the creative nature of the educational process as such. Much research work also takes place within the commercial sphere, and post-processual ideas cannot advance educational practice unless they can be implemented
in some type of an e-learning system. This chapter examines theoretical considerations of reflexivity, representation, subjectivity and experiential engagement to highlight their relevance to everyday educational practice, and their potential to undermine existing suboptimalities in the classroom. Chapter 3 Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games................................ 23 Daniel I. Thomas, Griffith University, Australia Ljubo B. Vlacic, Griffith University, Australia In this chapter, the authors envisage virtual beings engaging as equal partners with humans, providing richer emergent game play. In computer games, the development of artificial intelligence (AI) has been a very poor cousin to the investment in graphics and physics. AI in the most part is confined to path finding algorithms and simple state machines. Taking human and virtual beings beyond current applications of AI in computer games means that intelligent entities within the computer game cease to be “props” in a human-centric story line, but become equal participants themselves within the computer game world, engaging with humans towards achieving goals in more dynamic and realistic ways. Computer games provide a compelling environment to study and enable virtual beings to engage with humans as equals. The authors investigate the requirements, design and implementation of virtual beings that participate in computer games as humans would; playing the game and creating rich new collaborative game play experiences in areas of education, training and entertainment. Chapter 4 Computer Games and Libraries............................................................................................................. 52 Helena Coelho, Technical University of Lisbon, Portugal Information literacy is a crucial attribute in today’s knowledge society, because it makes independent lifelong learning possible. Faced with a digital world where new tools for information seeking and the spaces for information sharing are developing, academic librarians must respond to the changing learning landscape in order to help students acquire essential skills. Computer games, due to their cognitive potential and engagement capacity, can be used to promote and improve information literacy instruction. This chapter consists of a review of available literature on these topics. It addresses the role of computer games in the teaching and learning process and aims at discussing its possible use as training tools for promoting information literacy in libraries. Chapter 5 Games and Simulations in Distance Learning: The AIDLET Model.................................................... 67 José Bidarra, Universidade Aberta, Portugal Meagan Rothschild, University of Wisconsin, USA Kurt Squire, University of Wisconsin, USA This chapter discusses the selection and potential use of electronic games and simulations in distance learning supported by an operational model called AIDLET. The authors have developed a framework to facilitate the selection, repurposing, design and implementation of games and simulations, with focus on the practical aspects of the processes used in Open and Distance Learning (ODL). Whereas
traditional learning is based on knowledge memorization and the completion of carefully graded assignments, today, games, simulations and virtual environments turn out to be safe platforms for trial and error experimentation, i.e. learning by doing/playing. New instructional models may require that rich interactive processes of communication are supported, that assignments are structured as game-like projects, and that a culture of interaction, collaboration, and enablement drives learning and personal development. In this context, the AIDLET model was set out and verified against a taxonomy representing the main categories and genres of games to meet the requirements of distance education teachers, instructional designers and decision-makers.. Chapter 6 The Educational Value of Digital Games: Possibilities and Limitations of the Use of Digital Games as Educational Tools (The Spore Case)..................................................................................... 86 Ana Castro Correia, TECField Sistemas de Informação e Multimédia, Lda, Portugal Lia Raquel Oliveira, University of Minho, Portugal Today, digital games present themselves as one of the most common forms of entertainment, especially for children and teenagers, combining the playful factor with pedagogical advantages, promoting changes in terms of cognitive, behavioral and psychomotor skills in its users. The use of digital games in educational contexts encourages active, critical, autonomous and participated learning processes, overcoming some of the limitations presented in more ‘conventional’ methods, engaging players in non-passive forms of acquiring knowledge and skills. Aiming to demonstrate how digital games make the learning process possible by allowing the development of critical thinking, outlined during the act of playing, the authors will proceed to a critical analysis of Spore, a game created by Electronic Arts in 2008, demonstrating how the player places himself in an active learning situation which is self controlled and self regulated, facilitating the comprehension of phenomena that are not a part of formal teaching. Chapter 7 The Pedagogical Potential of MMOG: An Exploratory Study Including Four Games and their Players......................................................................................................................................... 103 Tiago Gomes, University of Minho, Portugal Ana Amélia A. Carvalho, University of Minho, Portugal The increasing complexity experienced by electronic games, began to demand a greater cognitive effort from their players. This has fostered some capacities in its players that could be used in teaching and learning. This chapter describes an exploratory study with two phases: the first one analyses four MMOG (Ikariam, OGame, Gladiatus and Metin2) and its pedagogical potential related to the development of problem solving skills, communication and interaction skills, and motivation to perform tasks. The second phase is a survey conducted to the players of these games about their motivation to play and their perceptions about its pedagogical potential. The results showed that all of the four analyzed games are motivating for the players, they have some pedagogical potential related to problem solving, and they improve communication and interaction skills. But the majority of the players felt some difficulties in accepting that they could transfer those developed skills to their scholar or professional life.
Chapter 8 Browser-Native Games That Use Real-World XML Data................................................................... 122 Jonathan Chetwynd, London, UK The rising tide of scientific data available on the web has the potential to help us consider the complex problems that concern us today, and simulation games can help us visualize, model and plan for alternative futures. However, the modularisation of knowledge has limited communication across subject domains, and copyright legislation and business practices may need to change, if the many new visualisation tools needed are to be interoperable and share common interfaces. A game standard and specification for the web, together with easy-to-use authoring tools for creating browser-native games that use real-world XML data; could enhance communication, and engage the public in the understanding of science, and its progress. Chapter 9 A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to Designing Business Management Games..................................... 136 Pedro Campos, University of Madeira & INESC ID Lisbon, Portugal Computer games have become an important part of the new digital economy, employing thousands of Information Technology professionals worldwide. Their role as a novel approach to reduce the distance between students and knowledge is also well documented. The chapter describes describe a multi-disciplinary approach to designing a particular class of educational games: business management games. Authors argue that through a better understanding of the relationship between work-domain based decisions and processes, professional game designers can achieve effective results. The design approach was based on intensive collaboration and co-design meetings with business management researchers and professors. The result was a game called “SimCompany”, aimed at teaching children about business management concepts, thus promoting an entrepreneurship culture in classroom settings. “SimCompany” proved effective as a teaching tool about business management concepts, and initial evaluation showed a positive increase in students’ rate of learning, when compared to traditional teaching methods. Chapter 10 Creating Computer Games for Class Instruction................................................................................. 151 Chien Yu, Mississippi State University, USA Anthony A. Olinzock, Mississippi State University, USA This chapter aims to provide the classroom teachers with the basic tools and fundamentals necessary to create instructional games targeted to specific courses and/or instructional objectives. By discussing the trends and issues related to today’s teaching and learning environment, the authors review the benefits of using educational games in classrooms, and provide some strategies and guidelines for creating computer games for classroom instruction. Along with discussing the fundamental issues and considerations, the authors discuss some of the challenges and impact of computer games in classrooms. Additional examples drawn from literature are also included to illustrate the use of games in education and the strategies of effective instruction.
Chapter 11 RACEM Game for PC for Use as Rehabilitation Therapy for Children with Psychomotor Disability and Results of Its Application............................................................................................. 167 Brenda Flores Muro, Universidad Autónoma de Coahuila, Mexico Eduardo César Contreras Delgado, Universidad Autónoma de Coahuila, Mexico This chapter introduces a PC simulation game to conduct a study with the main objective to train children with psychomotor disabilities (coordination, equilibrium and movements). The child interacts with simulated environments which contain the needed stimulus to develop the eye-hand coordination, the child responds to the game with mouse movements by means of audible orders. The main objective for the present work, is to enhance the child´s psychomotricity with more precise movements. Converting the game in a mean to children rehabilitation, this can be used in homes aided by child´s parents. Another purpose is to have a didactical tool for professors of special education. Chapter 12 When Control Education is the Name of the Game............................................................................. 185 António Pessoa de Magalhães, Universidade do Porto, Portugal Bernard Riera, Reims University, France Bruno Vigário, Real Games Lda, Portugal This chapter relates to a serious game named ITS PLC, an interactive simulation tool aimed at control systems education and training that includes the latest technologies from the video and computer games industry, namely, real-time 3D graphics, physics and sound. The goal of the game is to make five virtual industrial plants work correctly by using an external and real programmable logic controller (PLC) running the proper software, which the trainee must develop. The main purpose of the chapter is to testify the excellent properties of ITS PLC as an educational tool throughout a collection of three success stories: the first one shows how virtual scenarios can be used to investigate real problems; the usage of ITS PLC in an “edutainment” scenario is the theme of the second story; the third case testifies the benefits of ITS PLC in introductory automation programs. Chapter 13 Affective Educational Games and the Evolving Teaching Experience............................................... 206 Karla Muñoz, University of Ulster, UK Paul Mc Kevitt, University of Ulster, UK Tom Lunney, University of Ulster, UK Julieta Noguez, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico Luis Neri, Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico Computer game-based learning environments enable learning through experimentation and are inherently motivational. However, for identifying when learners achieve learning goals and providing suitable feedback, Intelligent Tutoring Systems must be used. Recognizing the learner’s affective state enables educational games to improve the learner’s experience or to distinguish relevant emotions. This chapter discusses the creation of an affective student model that infers the learner’s emotions from cognitive and motivational variables through observable behavior. The control-value theory of ‘achieve-
ment emotions’ provides a basis for this work. A Probabilistic Relational Models (PRMs) approach for affective student modeling, which is based on Dynamic Bayesian Networks, is discussed. The approach is tested through a prototyping study based on Wizard-of-Oz experiments and preliminary results are presented. The affective student model will be incorporated into PlayPhysics, an emotional game-based learning environment for teaching Physics. PRMs facilitate the design of student models with Bayesian Networks. The effectiveness of PlayPhysics will be evaluated by comparing the students’ learning gains and learning efficiencies. Chapter 14 Business Simulators for Business Education and Research: SIMBA Experience............................... 229 Fernando Borrajo, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Yolanda Bueno, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Fernando Fernández, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Javier García, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Isidro de Pablo, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Ismael Sagredo, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain Begoña Santos, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain Business Simulators provide a simulated environment where different scenarios and decisions can be tested without risk. They are also used for education where they can help students to understand the main concepts and theory involved in business administration. In addition, business simulators can be used to carry out research in different scientific areas, such as psychology, financial planning, risk evaluation, or intelligent business. This chapter introduces SIMBA, a new simulator for business education and research. SIMBA has two main goals: one is to serve as a web-based platform for business education, allowing students to connect the simulator from any point on the web, permitting both classroom education as well as distance education; SIMBA architecture permits not only the connection of human business managers, but also software agents; the second goal of SIMBA is to provide an environment in which to design and test a Multi-Agent platform for the creation, development and evaluation of Intelligent Agents that can manage companies in the same way as humans. Chapter 15 Educational Games.............................................................................................................................. 247 Gyula Mester, University of Szeged, Hungary Piroska Stanić Molcer, Subotica-Tech, Subotica, Serbia Vlado Delić, University of Novi Sad, Serbia The market favours the best-selling computer games regardless of their social and educational effects. This chapter discusses the present trends in educational games development, technologies related to them as well as their features, through representative examples of games used for education with respect to pedagogical, business, and social aspects. Benefits and limitations of introducing games in education are pointed out, and computer games for the disabled along with their pedagogical and social effects are presented. Recent research results on the implementation of video games in schools and educational game evaluation are also presented in the chapter, based on the experience in the development,
implementation, and evaluation of several interactive e-learning educational exercises, as well as in the development and validation of several innovative computer games for the visually impaired. Chapter 16 Evaluation of Simulation Games for Teaching Production (Engineering).......................................... 263 Johann C.K.H. Riedel, Nottingham University Business School, UK Jannicke Baalsrud Hauge, University of Bremen, Germany This chapter reports on the evaluation methods and findings from serious games for teaching production/ engineering. Two serious games are considered: Cosiga, a new product development simulation game and Beware, a risk management simulation game. These two games cover the front and middle parts of the engineering process – from design to manufacture to sale. For the Cosiga simulation evaluations of the communication, cognitive change and situational awareness were performed. For the Beware game evaluation of communication, risk awareness and improvement of risk management skills were performed. The findings from the evaluations showed that serious games deliver learning outcomes. However, there are drawbacks to their use that need to be taken into account. Principally the high cost of development and the need for expert facilitators for running game sessions. Chapter 17 Can Computer Games Motivate and Sustain Learning?...................................................................... 280 Mabel CPO Okojie, Mississippi State University, USA The chapter presents a critical examination of the use of computer games as motivation for learning, by reviewing evidence from the literature dealing with computer games as learning tools. Factors and difficulties associated with games as instructional strategies are discussed. Evidence from the literature indicates that current methods of applying computer games into instruction are not guided by pedagogical principles. It is recognized that the design of educational games be based on learning theories. The current practice of viewing educational games as separate entity from all other educative processes is detrimental to learning. Although, the results of scientific studies on game-based learning are inconclusive, nevertheless, the future of game-based learning is promising partly because games are generally engaging. The results of qualitative interviews reveal that the participants believe that computer games motivate them to have fun but not to learn. Thus, by implication may not sustain learning. Compilation of References ............................................................................................................... 299 About the Contributors .................................................................................................................... 324 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 334
xv
Preface
ABOUT THE SUBJECT Computer games is a multidisciplinary area that presents an exponentially growing impact on the economy, creating huge business opportunities generating large investments and large returns, new employment opportunities for professionals of several areas, from designers to programmers, from psychologists to mathematicians, from managers to politicians, from marketers to investors; increasing offer of graduation and post-graduation studies by universities worldwide. This domain claims for new professionals that are not yet enough at the labor market, but that higher education is already alert and preparing them. Simultaneously it is creating social impact on individuals and society, not always on a positive direction. Hence, opportunities and challenges must converge in order to take the maximum social, economical and educational profit of the emerging potential of this field. Computer Games as Educational and Management Tools: Uses and Approaches is a collection of the most recent developments and applications of computer games as management and educational tools in all embraced fields of knowledge or disciplines related. With the mission of discussing the main issues, challenges, opportunities and trends related to this explosive range of new developments and applications, in permanent evolution, the overall objectives achieved with the compilation of works at the readers’ hands are: to present the new technological developments related to the requirements of this industry; to discuss the impact of computer games as educational and management tools; to present practical solutions and state-of-the-art technologies; to discuss social and individual impact; to provide guidance for further research and development; and to build a bridge between research and practice. Throughout its 17 chapters, the book covers the following topics: • •
•
The technological dimension, addressing: supporting technologies and tools; computing developments and requirements; communication tools and human-computer interaction. The business or industry dimension, including: emerging businesses; business opportunities and applications; studies of opportunity and impact; critical success factors; legal aspects and copyright issues. The human and social dimension, comprising; psychological aspects; behavioral effects and social effects.
xvi
ORGANIZATION OF THE BOOK This book is a compilation of 17 contributions to the discussion of the applications and developments of computer games as educational and management tools. These 17 chapters are written by a group of 44 authors that include many internationally renowned and experienced researchers and specialists in several disciplines included and a set of younger authors, showing a promising potential for research and development. Contributions came from all over the world and integrate contributions from academe, research institutions, and industry, representing a good and comprehensive representation of the state-of-the-art approaches and developments that address the several dimensions of this fast evolutionary thematic. The first chapter, “Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes,” presents research developed in collaboration with two higher education institutions. Today, high education programs can only be successful with the use of new technologies in the teaching/learning process, especially when there are special education requirements. Two experiments were carried out: (1) a set of billiard balls, for snooker game, simulated by using physics laws and, (2) aLJo 2009, a game whose aim is to achieve the correct sorting of a sequence to accomplish a common task. Both projects were developed by students with different backgrounds and from different engineering courses. The snooker game, an academic project, aims to demonstrate that, through a simple game, several areas of knowledge can be used. On the other hand, aLJo 2009 was developed considering a collaboration protocol between the university and the Parents and Friends Association of the Citizen with Mental Deficiency (APPCDM), to improve behavior and social skills in patients with mental impairments. In recent years, the gap between educational theory and practice has been closing, but although there have been calls for ‘reflexivity,’ there has been little critical examination of its meaning. Proposed reflexive methodologies still perpetuate many traditional hierarchies, and fail to consider the creative nature of the educational process as such. Much research work also takes place within the commercial sphere, and post-processual ideas cannot advance educational practice unless they can be implemented in some type of an e-learning system. The second chapter, “Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’” examines theoretical considerations of reflexivity, representation, subjectivity and experiential engagement to highlight their relevance to everyday educational practice and their potential to undermine existing suboptimalities in the classroom. In Chapter 3, “Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games,” the authors envisage virtual beings engaging as equal partners with humans, providing richer emergent game play. In computer games, the development of artificial intelligence (AI) has been a very poor cousin to the investment in graphics and physics. For the most part, AI is confined to path finding algorithms and simple state machines. Taking human and virtual beings beyond current applications of AI in computer games means that intelligent entities within the computer game cease to be “props” in a human-centric story line, but become equal participants themselves within the computer game world, engaging with humans towards achieving goals in more dynamic and realistic ways. Computer games provide a compelling environment to study and enable virtual beings to engage with humans as equals. The authors investigate the requirements, design and implementation of virtual beings that participate in computer games as humans would; playing the game and creating rich new collaborative game play experiences in areas of education, training and entertainment. Information literacy is a crucial attribute in today’s knowledge society because it makes independent lifelong learning possible. Faced with a digital world where new tools for information seeking and the
xvii
spaces for information sharing are developing, academic librarians must respond to the changing learning landscape in order to help students acquire essential skills. Computer games, due to their cognitive potential and engagement capacity, can be used to promote and improve information literacy instruction. Chapter 4, “Computer Games and Libraries” consists of a review of available literature on these topics. It addresses the role of computer games in the teaching and learning process and aims at discussing its possible use as training tools for promoting information literacy in libraries. “Games and Simulations in Distance Learning: The AIDLET Model” discusses the selection and potential use of electronic games and simulations in distance learning supported by an operational model called AIDLET. The authors have developed a framework to facilitate the selection, repurposing, design and implementation of games and simulations, with focus on the practical aspects of the processes used in Open and Distance Learning (ODL). Whereas traditional learning is based on knowledge memorization and the completion of carefully graded assignments, today, games, simulations and virtual environments turn out to be safe platforms for trial and error experimentation (i.e., learning by doing/playing). New instructional models may require that rich interactive processes of communication are supported, that assignments are structured as game-like projects, and that a culture of interaction, collaboration, and enablement drives learning and personal development. In this context, the AIDLET model was set out and verified against a taxonomy representing the main categories and genres of games to meet the requirements of distance education teachers, instructional designers and decision-makers. Today, digital games present themselves as one of the most common forms of entertainment, especially for children and teenagers, combining the playful factor with pedagogical advantages, promoting changes in terms of cognitive, behavioral and psychomotor skills in its users. The use of digital games in educational contexts encourages active, critical, autonomous and participated learning processes, overcoming some of the limitations presented in more ‘conventional’ methods, engaging players in non-passive forms of acquiring knowledge and skills. Aiming to demonstrate how digital games make the learning process possible by allowing the development of critical thinking, outlined during the act of playing, the authors of “The Educational Value of Digital Games: Possibilities and Limitations of the Use of Digital Games as Educational Tools (The Spore Case)” will proceed to a critical analysis of Spore, a game created by Electronic Arts in 2008, demonstrating how the player places himself in an active learning situation which is self controlled and self regulated, facilitating the comprehension of phenomena that are not a part of formal teaching. The increasing complexity of by electronic games demands greater cognitive effort from their players. This has fostered some capacities in its players that could be used in teaching and learning. Chapter 7, “The Pedagogical Potential of MMOG: An Exploratory Study Including Four Games and Their Players” describes an exploratory study with two phases: the first one analyses four MMOG (Ikariam, OGame, Gladiatus and Metin2) and its pedagogical potential related to the development of problem solving skills, communication and interaction skills, and motivation to perform tasks. The second phase is a survey conducted to the players of these games about their motivation to play and their perceptions about its pedagogical potential. The results showed that all of the four analyzed games are motivating for the players, they have some pedagogical potential related to problem solving, and they improve communication and interaction skills. But the majority of the players felt some difficulties in accepting that they could transfer those developed skills to their scholar or professional life. As discussed in “Browser-Native Games That Use Real-World XML Data,” the rising tide of scientific data available on the web has the potential to help us consider the complex problems that concern us today, and simulation games can help us visualize, model and plan for alternative futures. However,
xviii
the modularisation of knowledge has limited communication across subject domains, and copyright legislation and business practices may need to change if the many new visualisation tools needed are to be interoperable and share common interfaces. A game standard and specification for the web, together with easy-to-use authoring tools for creating browser-native games that use real-world XML data could enhance communication and engage the public in the understanding of science and its progress. Computer games have become an important part of the new digital economy, employing thousands of Information Technology professionals worldwide. Their role as a novel approach to reduce the distance between students and knowledge is also well documented. Chapter 9, “A Multi-Disciplinary Approach to Designing Business Management Games” describes a multi-disciplinary approach to designing a particular class of educational games: business management games. Authors argue that through a better understanding of the relationship between work-domain based decisions and processes, professional game designers can achieve effective results. The design approach was based on intensive collaboration and co-design meetings with business management researchers and professors. The result was a game called “SimCompany,” aimed at teaching children about business management concepts, thus promoting an entrepreneurship culture in classroom settings. “SimCompany” proved effective as a teaching tool about business management concepts, and initial evaluation showed a positive increase in students’ rate of learning when compared to traditional teaching methods. Chapter 10, “Creating Computer Games for Class Instruction,” aims to provide classroom teachers with the basic tools and fundamentals necessary to create instructional games targeted to specific courses and/or instructional objectives. By discussing the trends and issues related to today’s teaching and learning environment, the authors review the benefits of using educational games in classrooms, and provide some strategies and guidelines for creating computer games for classroom instruction. Along with discussing the fundamental issues and considerations, the authors discuss some of the challenges and impact of computer games in classrooms. Additional examples drawn from literature are also included to illustrate the use of games in education and the strategies of effective instruction. Chapter 11, “RACEM Game for PC for Use as Rehabilitation Therapy for Children with Psychomotor Disability and Results of its Application” introduces a PC simulation game to conduct a study with the main objective to train children with psychomotor disabilities (coordination, equilibrium and movements). The child interacts with simulated environments which contain the needed stimulus to develop the eye-hand coordination, the child responds to the game with mouse movements by means of audible orders. The main objective of this work is to enhance the child´s psychomotricity with more precise movements. Converting the game to a means for chidren’s rehabilitation, this can be used in homes aided by parents. Another purpose is to have a didactical tool for professors of special education. Chapter 12, “When Control Education is the Name of the Game,” relates to a serious game named ITS PLC, an interactive simulation tool aimed at control systems education and training that includes the latest technologies from the video and computer games industry, namely, real-time 3D graphics, physics and sound. The goal of the game is to make five virtual industrial plants work correctly by using an external and real programmable logic controller (PLC) running the proper software, which the trainee must develop. The main purpose of the chapter is to testify the excellent properties of ITS PLC as an educational tool throughout a collection of three success stories: the first one shows how virtual scenarios can be used to investigate real problems; the usage of ITS PLC in an “edutainment” scenario is the theme of the second story; the third case testifies the benefits of ITS PLC in introductory automation programs.
xix
Computer game-based learning environments enable learning through experimentation and are inherently motivational. However, for identifying when learners achieve learning goals and providing suitable feedback, intelligent tutoring systems must be used. Recognizing the learner’s affective state enables educational games to improve the learner’s experience or to distinguish relevant emotions. Chapter 13, “Affective Educational Games and the Evolving Teaching Experience” discusses the creation of an affective student model that infers the learner’s emotions from cognitive and motivational variables through observable behavior. The control-value theory of ‘achievement emotions’ provides a basis for this work. A Probabilistic Relational Models (PRMs) approach for affective student modeling, which is based on Dynamic Bayesian Networks, is discussed. The approach is tested through a prototyping study based on Wizard-of-Oz experiments and preliminary results are presented. The affective student model will be incorporated into PlayPhysics, an emotional game-based learning environment for teaching Physics. PRMs facilitate the design of student models with Bayesian Networks. The effectiveness of PlayPhysics will be evaluated by comparing the students’ learning gains and learning efficiencies. Business Simulators provide a simulated environment where different scenarios and decisions can be tested without risk. They are also used for education where they can help students to understand the main concepts and theory involved in business administration. In addition, business simulators can be used to carry out research in different scientific areas, such as psychology, financial planning, risk evaluation, or intelligent business. Chapter 14, “Business Simulators for Business Education and Research: SIMBA Experience,” introduces SIMBA, a new simulator for business education and research. SIMBA has two main goals: one is to serve as a web-based platform for business education, allowing students to connect the simulator from any point on the web, permitting both classroom education as well as distance education; SIMBA architecture permits not only the connection of human business managers, but also software agents; the second goal of SIMBA is to provide an environment in which to design and test a multi-agent platform for the creation, development and evaluation of intelligent agents that can manage companies in the same way as humans. The market favours the best-selling computer games regardless of their social and educational effects. Chapter 15, “Educational Games,” discusses the present trends in educational games development, technologies related to them as well as their features, through representative examples of games used for education with respect to pedagogical, business, and social aspects. Benefits and limitations of introducing games in education are pointed out, and computer games for the disabled along with their pedagogical and social effects are presented. Recent research results on the implementation of video games in schools and educational game evaluation are also presented in the chapter, based on the experience in the development, implementation, and evaluation of several interactive e-learning educational exercises, as well as in the development and validation of several innovative computer games for the visually impaired. Chapter 16, “Evaluation of Simulation Games for Teaching Production (Engineering)”, reports on the evaluation methods and findings from serious games for teaching production/ engineering. Two serious games are considered: Cosiga, a new product development simulation game and Beware, a risk management simulation game. These two games cover the front and middle parts of the engineering process – from design to manufacture to sale. For the Cosiga simulation evaluations of the communication, cognitive change and situational awareness were performed. For the Beware game evaluation of communication, risk awareness and improvement of risk management skills were performed. The findings from the evaluations showed that serious games deliver learning outcomes. However, there are
xx
drawbacks to their use that need to be taken into account. Principally, the high cost of development and the need for expert facilitators for running game sessions. The last chapter, “Can Computer Games Motivate and Sustain Learning?” presents a critical examination of the use of computer games as motivation for learning by reviewing evidence from the literature dealing with computer games as learning tools. Factors and difficulties associated with games as instructional strategies are discussed. Evidence from the literature indicates that current methods of applying computer games into instruction are not guided by pedagogical principles. It is recognized that the design of educational games be based on learning theories. The current practice of viewing educational games as separate entity from all other educative processes is detrimental to learning. Although the results of scientific studies on game-based learning are inconclusive, the future of game-based learning is promising partly because games are generally engaging. The results of qualitative interviews reveal that the participants believe that computer games motivate them to have fun but not to learn.
EXPECTATIONS Throughout these 17 chapters, the reader is faced with the discussions and confirmation of the relevance and impact of this hot topic, providing professionals, researchers and scholars with some of the most advanced research developments, solutions and discussions of computer games as education and management tools: uses, trends, approaches, solutions and case studies. It is expected to support a professional audience of top managers and computer games professionals (developers and creative individuals) and also an academic audience (teachers, researchers and students, mainly of post-graduate studies). It can support disciplines of post-graduate studies on Information Systems and Technologies related with computer games development under the design, psychology and management approaches. The Editors, Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Vitor Hugo Costa Carvalho Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal Paula Cristina Almeida Tavares Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal
1
Chapter 1
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes Vitor Hugo Costa Carvalho University of Minho, Portugal Celina Pinto Leão University of Minho, Portugal Filomena Soares University of Minho, Portugal Maria Manuela Cruz-Cunha Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, Portugal
ABSTRACT This chapter presents a research developed in collaboration by two higher education institutions. Nowadays, high education programs can only be successful with the use of new technologies in the teaching/learning process, especially when there are special education requirements. Two experiments were carried out: (1) a set of billiard balls, for snooker game, simulated by using physics laws and, (2) aLJo 2009, a game whose aim is to achieve the correct sorting of a sequence to accomplish a common task. Both projects were developed by students from University of Minho (UM), with different background and from different engineering courses. The snooker game, an academic project, aims to demonstrate that, through a simple game, several areas of knowledge can be used. On the other hand, aLJo 2009 was developed considering a collaboration protocol between UM and the Parents and Friends Association of the Citizen with Mental Deficiency (APPCDM), to improve behavior and social skills in patients with mental impairments. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-569-8.ch001
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
INTRODUCTION Several definitions of game can be stated but, in general, a game considers a structured activity focused on pleasure, not discarding the educational purpose. The use of games and simulations as educational tools is well documented (Carpick, 2002; Mayo, 2007; Muñoz, Noguez, McKevitt, Neri, Robledo-Rella, & Lunney, 2009). For the authors, games are viewed as a strategy for getting students to, not only, understand but also to retain the concepts, helping them in soft skills as teamwork, strategy, competition, problem solving (Smith, 2008). Some others studies complement this idea evaluating games from an educational point of view, identifying that they increase the students’ level of engagement while interfacing with the game however, learning in a similar way (Muñoz et al., 2009; Annetta, Minogue, Holmes, & Cheng, 2009). Considering the teaching/learning process and how games can be employed in this process (if they really can), there is a difference between supplying information to the students and delivering learning. To give information simply is not enough for an efficient learning. Intuition, imagination, interactivity are considered as key parts in the learning process. The possibility to individually construct, manipulate, modify and control an experiment is a strong aspect for students. The paradigm ‘to learn by doing’ in a friendly and animated way is essential to form good professionals, in special in the different areas of engineering. Here, the use of games for pedagogical and educational purposes can play an important role. In this way, students acquire and develop their knowledge by challenging. Each student has his own way of learning: some learn by reading, others by listening and others by experiencing, by doing. With games, learning environments must include the elements to satisfy each student, no matter it is focused on high school learning outcomes or if it is dedicated to promote and develop social competences in disabled persons.
2
Regarding the use of games to gather engineering students perception of the application of physics laws there are lots of practical examples. Among them, the billiard tables appear as an adequate tool, from very simple examples (MathsIsFun.com, 2008) to more complex systems as in (Free Download Manager, n.d.). All of these billiards games share similar equipment - a long rectangular table, balls and a stick - but they differ from each other in their goals and styles of play (Mahoney & Davis, 2007). Nevertheless, in some areas there are not available commercial solutions, or at least solutions to ensure comfort, independence and enjoyment of the whole population. In particular, people who require special education are often “forgotten” by society, resulting in increased difficulty in performing simple tasks. The education system and the educational products on the market are normally targeted at the general population; there are few products with particular characteristics for special education. The existing games in this area have some categories that stand out, as are games of Logical Reasoning, Recognition of Facial expressions/feelings, Visual Perception, Concentration, Memory and also Game Sequences (do2learn, n.d.; GreyOlltwit Educational Software, n.d.).Typically, they respond very well to visual stimuli (as bright colors and multicolor images) and sound stimuli (for example, pieces of music and funny sounds). The aim of this work is, then, the development of an educational game for young people who require special education, in particular young people with mental disability. Students in special education have a set of characteristics that should be considered in order to enhance the development of certain capabilities. Usually, they have low attention, many of them cannot read or write, and have little autonomy in carrying out simple tasks from the daily routine (Filho, n.d.). The undemanding task “eating a yogurt” can be very complicated for disabled people, who do not know the correct sequence of actions. This work is part of a research project undertaken through
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
a collaboration protocol between University of Minho and APPACDM (in Portuguese Associação Portuguesa de Pais e Amigos do Cidadão com Deficiência Mental) from Braga. It was decided to develop a game aimed at students with mental disability, because there are several cases in this institution, and therefore therapists can assess the progress of students in the skills that the game intends to develop. Knowing that nowadays, projects tend to be multidisciplinary, the experience of a group of researcher of two higher education institutions: the University of Minho, UM (in his departments Industrial Electronics, DEI, and Production and Systems, DPS) and the Polytechnic Institute of Cávado and Ave, IPCA, is described. The major objective of this research project is the developing of new teaching/learning methodologies where the passive attitudes in the transmission of knowledge are changed. Not only can the high education programs be successful with the progress and the use of new technologies, as well as the special education requirements, especially the education of children with special needs, can be active in the use of these new tools. This chapter is divided in four sections, the first on which corresponded to this introduction. Section two presents the development of a set of billiard balls in a Snooker game, considering the physics law, the game rules and the user interface. aLJo2009 game is presented in the third section and the experimental results obtained in APPACDM as well as the feedback from students are analyzed. The last section presents the conclusions and future work perspectives.
SNOOKER GAME: DEVELOPMENT OF A SET OF BILLIARD BALLS Motivation and Objectives Several sports activities can be described by mathematical models. Using the laws of physics it is
possible to estimate the end results (outputs) of the application when under a set of initial parameters (inputs). For example, in a golf game, the golf club choice, the force applied in the golf ball, the wind direction, speed, friction between the ball and the ground, have direct and indirectly influence on the length and on the final position of the ball. In this work, the game chosen to illustrate this purpose was a snooker game that was designed, developed and implemented, in a friendly way. Firstly, a search on the laws of physics that can be used to simulate the balls’ behavior/movement when subjected to an external force was made. The rules of the game itself were also defined, as well as the inputs and outputs parameters. In this way, the simulation of the game can be performed.
Game Development The programming language used was the ANSI C with the library GLUT (OpenGL Utility Toolkit, Lighthouse 3D, n.d.), which is a simple interface for creating OpenGL (animation)(GLUT, n.d.). This library contains several predefined roles that help in drawing functions of the objects and the user interface. With this choice, the application will draw the objects frame by frame (frame rate varies from computer to computer), and every moment, if there is movement, determines the new positions of the balls. The tool used was the Microsoft Visual Studio 2005 since is a powerful tool for software development, with high levels of productivity. Although the programming language of choice was the ANSI C, the files were created in C++ due the compatibility with Microsoft Visual Studio 2005. It was not major attention to obtain special effects and nice virtual environmental, but using physical properties of body dynamics, simulate the game. In this way the group of students involved in the game development, learn mathematics and physics by using the theoretical aspects to develop the game beyond the programming skills enlargement.
3
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
In this subsection, the body dynamics considered for the game simulation will be summarized. It was considered that the billiard balls can be in three states: stopped (initial and final positions), sliding and running. The state sliding is assumed as the moment when the ball initialized its movement. This state will be short if the applied force into the ball is high. The state running will be the most common state when the ball is in motion. The set of equations used were easily obtained (Danby, 1997; Newmann, Stoy, & Thompson, 1994;The Physics Classroom (n.d.); The Math and Physics of Billiards, n.d.). The physical equations used describe the initial linear and angular velocities, describing the first balls movement when the cue touches the white cue ball. After that, the balls can take several and different movements and velocities. Knowing that, the velocity of a ball decreases until stopped due to the frictional force between the ball and green cloth (or felt) of the table, the variation of the linear and angular velocities must also be considered. Another aspect that was taken into account was the possibility of collision between the balls. It was considered two types of collisions: between two balls and/or between a ball and the walls of the table. To detect a collision between two balls, the distance between the two balls centers that can be at most equal to the sum of two times its radius, is estimated. The time to collide is also estimated and then the new directions and velocities. This new calculus took into account the normal and tangential velocity components for each ball, being the new direction the sum of these two components.
Game Input and Output Definition The input parameters considered were the balls positions before making the putt, the force applied to the white cue ball and its related direction. Thus, the player will be able to control these two parameters each time he makes a shot. Then, due to the various factors adjacent to the system and game conditions, the balls stops producing the final
4
result (output), i.e. the new positions of the balls on the table. The various factors adjacent to the system are the movement of the balls, the friction between the balls and the felt, the friction of the ball when hit the table walls, the collision type, the weight of the ball, the momentum of the cue ball, gravity, among others. The friction coefficient and the impetus time given by the cue to the ball were approximately estimated due to the complexity to determine exactly their values. Summarizing, (1) the input parameters: balls position before making the putt, force and direction applied to the white cue ball; (2) adjacent factors: balls movement kind, slide (friction coefficient with the felt=1), rotate (friction coefficient with the felt=0.05), ball hit the table walls (coefficient=0.1), ball weight and diameters (0.5Kg and 57.15cm, respectively), gravity (9.81m/s2), time of momentum between the ball and cue (0.005sec), collisions and linear and angular velocities; (3) output parameters: new balls positions on the table.
Application The application has a three dimensional representation, however, since the position of the camera, that allows the visualization of the game, is a way to visualize the top of the table, the application looks to have only two dimensions (Figure 1). The game has 16 balls placed at predetermined mark on the table (1 white, 1 black, 7 red and 7 yellow). Figure 1. Pool table and game balls just before the break off
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
Figure 2. Player interface
Figure 3. Player 2 white cue ball direction
Game Interface Development Rules The developed game supports two players, and first to play can choose the color. The game begins with seven red and seven yellow balls in the table. The number of balls will diminish as they are inserted or increasing (up to a maximum of seven) when a fault is committed. On each turn, it is determined if the player continues to play or changes. For this, a set of rules were defined, like the color of the first ball that contact the white cue ball, if it was inserted a ball of the other player, if the white cue ball did not touch any other ball in the table. The application of the rules must follow a certain order. To know: if the white cue ball does not touch any other ball or, after assigned a color to each player, a player hit a ball of different color, a new ball must be inserted in the table (maximum of seven for each of the two colors) and the player looses the turn. If the white cue ball hits the right player’ ball, but no ball enters or a different one enters, the player looses the turn. At this time if the white cue ball enters, a new ball must be inserted in the table, the player looses the turn and the white cue ball returns to the initial point. If the player chooses the right ball and inserts the right ball, he continues to play. All these conditions are tested through variables and then the rules applied.
For the user interface, functions were developed which interact with the computer accessories(mouse, keyboard). The interface indicates the state of the game every time (Figure 2). The mouse becomes an important peripheral to control the direction that the white cue ball will take (Figure 3). The two parallel lines represent the direction of the ball; the color indicates which player to play (player 1: blue line, player 2: red line) and the line within represents the force applied to the ball. It is also available to the players a summary of the keys and correspondent actions that can be taken. During the development of the game, several problems were solved with varying difficulty, however the problem related to the holes in the table. In the game, the boundary zones were considered straight and not round. To detect whether a ball was inserted into a hole, a function was defined and the help of a sphere to determines whether the ball has or not pass its limit. If the limits were passed through, indicates that the ball was inserted. In Figure 4 the function and the spheres were represented.
Tests and Results Analysis The students’ perspectives were reached. This work was very interesting in the student point of view, since it provides the possibility by a real
5
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
Figure 4. Control inclusion ball places
Figure 6. Task “Eating and Yogurt” from the Food theme
case (snooker game), and with some complexity in terms of laws of physics, to put in practice the theoretical aspects. Somehow, they consider that the model used characterize the reality, although missing some components, such same effects, namely that ones that depend on the point of contact between the ball and the cue. As future work, beyond the effects, the game graphics of and the areas ahead of the hole could be improved.
aLJo 2009 GAME DEVELOPMENT The game was developed using the Allegro game motor (allegro.cc, n.d.; Feldman, 2000; Hattan, 2009; Malik, 2008; Dawson, 2006; Harbour, 2002). This game motor is free distributed, which was a relevant factor in our choice. This motor also contains interesting functionalities, like the
6
Figure 5. List of Tasks
possibility of using the game in several operating systems, audio functions, among others. The game consists of the correct ordering of a sequence of steps necessary to perform a task, or letters, words or numbers ordering. The tasks available are simple execution tasks like, hands washing, to cross a street or buying a product. The chosen activities included in the game were daily tasks. When performed correctly by the players, they will increase hardly their autonomy and independence. The task list is presented on Figure 5. In Figure 6 it is possible to observe one of the tasks which is possible to work with, “Eating a Yogurt”. To control the game flux/task, it was implemented the chart presented in Figure 7. It is possible to verity that during the tasks execution it is given the player the possibility of help assistance. The help is given by a video which exemplifies how the task can be done. All over the task concretization are used voice messages indicating to the player if their options are or not correct. This feature was necessary because several players cannot read and so this procedure allows turning the game more friendlily to this kind of players. One of the innovations implemented was the game interface. Considering that some players present motor difficulties, which in some cases unable to use a mouse. To control the game flux it was decided to test the interface from the games console Wii
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
Figure 7. Game/task flux control
(Wiimote, n.d.).Through the wirst moviment it is possible to control the mouse direction. In this way it is possible to measure small orientations in the wrist direction, as well as not considering involuntary movements done by the players, like tremors. The implementation of this interface vises only to analyse its viability, not being assumed a better relatioship between the player/game with its use. At last, when a player concludes with success a task, the information associated with that task lke the execution time, number of faults, number of helps, is recorded. So, it is possible to analyse the player evolution and taking conclusions about the advantagesregarding the game to the player.
Results It were executed some preliminary tests with seven students with soft mental deficiency who promptly
Figure 8. Player 1, Task Ordering Letters
revealed high interest. Some students played with the help of the teacher who explained the game procedure, others played with more autonomy. Initially the graphical environment, the images, colors and music caused a high curiosity in the students. The incentive messages during the game worked as a motivating element. The scores were also observed as factors that cause the player evolution, as well as the competitiveness between the students. Although, some students could not read, the scores were also given by an intuitive way, as using bars with different sizes for different scores. The task “Eating and Yogurt” was concluded, in general, with high scores, but some students demonstrated more difficulties in the following tasks. The scores of each player had a positive evolution with the repetition of a task, which can be the result of individual evolution. The game was presented individually, being subsequently tested in classroom context, in which a student had the game control and the others could assist. In this last phase the students demonstrated group spirit as well as comparison of the activities with real situations of their daily life. Some students demonstrated high difficulty in controlling the game with the Wiimote, being easier in this case the control with the mouse. Figures 8 to 10 present the evolution of three different players, chosen randomly, to test several times a specific task of the game (in the ordinates it is presented the time required to perform the task and in the abscissas the number of the attempt). It is necessary to refer that these results are preliminary.
7
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
Figure 9. Player 2, Task Eating a Yogurt
Figure 10. Player 3, Task Eating a Yogurt
For the players 1 and 2 it is observed a clear evolution with the task repetition (reduction of the time necessary to execute the task). This scenario does not happen to player 3, Figure 10, in which the time to perform the task increases with the number of attempts, not showing apparently a better performance with the task repetition.
in reading simple words and ordering numbers. In preliminary tests carried out, the game had a remarkable acceptance in the youth at APPACDM and there are positive developments in its repeated use. The use of Wiimote to control the game was not successful as the Roll motion is complex for the target group, resulting in inadequate control of the game. The tests carried out allowed finding particular points to be improved in the game. These include, for example, changing the format of the classification, placing bars with different sizes instead of quantitative results; the menu buttons should be in different colors so that players, that cannot read, can associate colors with actions and as such it is easier to navigate in the game; allowing the modification and integration of new tasks by the educators; optimizing the implementation of the Wiimote.
CONCLUSION AND FUTURE WORK The authors believe that the paradigm “Learning by doing” implemented through the use of educational and pedagogical games fortify the learning process. In this way, students enlarge their knowledge on the particular subject they are studying as well as they develop their creativity, their planning capacity and the communication between the working groups. Also, it can be focus on two different target groups. By one hand it can help students in understanding several physical laws as well as it can gather and promote the attention of people with impairments to be familiar to daily routines and tasks. aLJo 2009 is an educational game dedicated to young people with special needs. The game consists of ordering a sequence of simple tasks of daily life, like eating a yogurt, crossing a road, washing the teeth, in order to enable these people to be more autonomous, reducing their dependence on their families and teachers. The game also performs tasks which aim to develop skills
8
REFERENCES allegro.cc. (n.d.).Game developing community network. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http:// www.allegro.cc/ Annetta, L. A., Minogue, J., Holmes, S. Y., & Cheng, M. T. (2009). Investigating the impact of video games on high school students’ engagement and learning about genetics. Computers & Education, 53, 74–85. doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2008.12.020
Games Development for Pedagogical and Educational Purposes
Carpick, R. W. (2002). Who Wants to be an Engineer? Or Better Teaching through Game Shows. In Proceedings of the 2002 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition (10 pp.). American Society for Engineering Education.
Mahoney, B., & Davis, M. (2007, March). Billiards: A Lifetime Sport (Pocket Billiards Curriculum Guide & Instructor’s Manual). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.billiardeducation.org/ index.php?Itemid=39&id=29 &option=com_ content&task=view
do2learn, Learning Games for Young People with Disabilities. (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.dotolearn.com/
Malik, D. S. (2008). C++ Programming: From Problem Analysis to Program Design (4th ed.). Boston, MA: Course Technology.
Danby, J. M. A. (1997). Computer Modeling: From Sports to Spaceflight…. Richmond, VA: From Order to Chaos.
MathsIsFun.com. (2008).Billiard Tables. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.mathsisfun.com/ games/billiard-tables.html
Dawson, M. (2006). Beginning C++ Through Game Programming, Course Technology (2nd ed.). Boston, MA: PTR.
Mayo, M. J. (2007). Games for Science and Engineering Education. Communications of the ACM, 50(7), 31–35. doi:10.1145/1272516.1272536
Feldman, A. (2000). Designing Arcade Computer Game Graphics. Plano: Wordware Publishing, Inc.
Muñoz, K., Noguez, J., McKevitt, P., Neri, L., Robledo-Rella, V., & Lunney, T. (2008). Adding Features of Educational Games for Teaching Physics. In Proceedings of the 39th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference (6 pp.). October 18-21, San Antonio, TX, USA.
Filho, T. A. G. (n.d.). Educação Especial e Novas Tecnologias: O Aluno Construindo Sua Autonomia. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www. profala.com/ arteducesp30.htm Free Download Manager. Play89 2.0. (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http:// www.freedownloadmanager.org /downloads / PLAY89_56936_p/ GLUT – The OpenGL Utility Toolkit. (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www. opengl.org/ resources/libraries/glut/ Grey Olltwit Educational Software. (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www. greyolltwit.com/ Harbour, J. S. (2002). Game Programming all in one, Muska&Lipman. Portland: Premier-Trade. Hattan, J. (2009). Beginning Game Programming: A GameDev.net Collection. Boston, MA: Course Technology PTR.
Neumann, P., Stoy, G., & Thompson, E. (1994). Groups and Geometry. Oxford. Smith, L. T. (2008, January).Games to Motivate Students to Learn, Society. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.associatedcontent.com / article/509779/ games_to_motivate_ students_ to_learn.html The Math and Physics of Billiards. (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://archive.ncsa.uiuc.edu/ Classes/MATH198/ townsend/math.html The Physics Classroom. (n.d.).Newton’s Laws. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.physicsclassroom.com/ Class/newtlaws/ Welcome to Lighthouse 3D (n.d.). Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://www.lighthouse3d.com/ Wiimote (n.d.). Wii, Satoshi Konno Library. Retrieved March 20, 2010 from http://pt.wii.com/
9
10
Chapter 2
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’ C. Karagiannidis University of Thessaly, Greece S. Efraimidou University of Thessaly, Greece A. Koumpis ALTEC Software S.A, Greece
ABSTRACT In recent years the gap between educational theory and practice has been closing, but although there have been calls for ‘reflexivity’, there has been little critical examination of its meanings. Proposed reflexive methodologies still perpetuate many traditional hierarchies, and fail to consider the creative nature of the educational process as such. Much research work also takes place within the commercial sphere, and post-processual ideas cannot advance educational practice unless they can be implemented in some type of an e-learning system. In our Chapter we examine theoretical considerations of reflexivity, representation, subjectivity and experiential engagement to highlight their relevance to everyday educational practice, and their potential to undermine existing suboptimalities in the classroom.
INTRODUCTION AND CONTEXT OF OUR IDEA With the emergence of what we shall call interpretative and reflexive approaches to education DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-569-8.ch002
through the reaction against the processual (or process-oriented) education of the 1970s and 1980s, the desire for the inclusion of other voices in the educational process is born. This was and still is a conscious step toward creating reflexivity within the educational profession, i.e. dissolving the rigorous praxis and constraints
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
of the interpretative process that followed the science-oriented approaches and realizing and accepting that interpretation occurs at all stages of the educational practice. Multivocality seems to become an “it-word” used for whenever other people besides professionals are incorporated into the interpretation of educational-related core assignments, whether through community of experts, internet forums etc, or when the role and voice of a particular professional as a person is emphasized. However, the concept of multivocality has up until now always focused on listening to different voices in the present. Various people have been consulted to discuss issues regarding a particular educational case or issue, from their point of view as professionals or experts today. But is it not possible to also allow voices from people that have been involved in the educational process in the (long or not so long) past to speak up regarding their own involvement within an educational process. This is where the concept of multivocality comes into play. It becomes a way of dealing with the educational profession and / or practice not only from the view-point of the currently involved actors but also from interpreting a case through the voices of other stakeholders besides the originally involved inter-actors. In our chapter we explore what we call the the ‘Collaboration game’ from two aspects namely the issue of multi-vocality and the issue of post-processualism and by means of adopting a service-based approach. Even if several educational services exist, these services are still un-configurable by the education expert and represent the professional (‘business’) logic view without considering the specific needs of the particular pupils. These services are designed in a silo manner and hardly, if not impossible, interconnected by the actual needs of the individual pupils. Though this reality is more or less widely adopted in the domain of general education, the needs for individualized interventions in the area of special education form rather the rule
Figure 1. Collaborative practices and interventions within and outside the classroom
than the exception. The implications of what we call ‘Collaboration as a game’ to the technical architecture of any plausible solution should take into account following the three dimensions that will be addressed in a use case we shall present in the chapter: 1. Inter-school unit dimension: It represents the overlap among processes and practices from a set of intra-organizational school units. This overlap is usually the result of necessary interaction between processes, which could be explicit or implicit. However, this interaction is not subject to a series of sequential activities but may occur between any of the entire set of activities running into the particular school organization. Indeed, all professional knowledge is not spread according to the activities predefined sequence. These interactions can exist between the same school unit, or two or more different school units. 2. Cross level-Intra- school unit dimension: It represents the common knowledge of members of the same school unit level but from different environments. This set is the federator of the community of participants
11
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
into the activities and processes of the school units involved. This knowledge is generally specific to the unit and related to its processes that lead to the difficulty to find it beyond its area of competencies. It represents the relay points between the various stages of collaboration implementation, enforcement or the establishment of one or more processes of the unit. This knowledge is often at a high level of granularity and is sometimes extracted directly from the environment of process enforcement. This high level of specialization infers their reduced interoperability with other units of the same school organization. Still that, this knowledge is compulsory for the functioning of processes within the unit and are usually transplanted into other environments under other forms. 3. Cross level-Inter unit dimension: Depending on the particular environment of the school organization, the distribution of its inherent processes can vary significantly in scheduling, operating or in prerequisites. Nevertheless, school units that contain these processes can be matched with other school units from a different environment in terms of needs, knowledge or skills. This knowledge can be a source of innovation and discovery. Indeed, a result of this knowledge is generally the use of a new form of knowledge completely different from the most common used one in this area. This makes this overlap very diverse, unstructured and thus hardly detectable compared to other levels of overlap. ‘Collaboration as a game’ can be considered a further stage of evolution that connects knowledge, represents meanings and knowledge about things so that education experts can work together, adding new levels of intelligence to the user interface of existing (operational) systems, social collaboration, applications, and the infrastructure of the Web.
12
ADDRESSING SOCIAL NETWORKING ASPECTS We all witness the enormous success of many social networking services which meet personal needs of friendship (Facebook), concise textbased communication (Twitter), professional networking (LinkedIn), bookmarking (Delicious), sharing videos (YouTube) and pictures (Flickr). The success of these services rests on the user/ client/consumer being able to actively participate in a manner which is of personal benefit, thereby creating value for himself/herself. Our aim is to follow up on the success of these services and create additional value for the teacher as the user of such an infrastructure and the wider community, in terms of facilitating the creation, mashing-up, publishing, tagging, using and rating services in a simple and user-friendly interface. Whereas Flickr concentrates on pictures and YouTube concentrates on videos, our idea is to concentrate on (web) services created for and by teachers within a social networking environment. In this respect, our aim is to provide a social networking platform for developing services which address the needs of the teachers (with an emphasis to the collaboration between general and special education staff) and enable them to create value. In our initial phase, we envisage two main types of users using the service platform: 1. Novice, inexperienced teachers without any technical knowledge or programming expertise. 2. Power, experienced users aiming to promote their own services. We aim to: •
Help education experts create services to meet their needs.
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
•
•
•
Dynamically integrate education experts’ (both from general and special education) multidimensional profiles Provide a roadmap for creating social networking services to support service provision Exploit the wisdom of the crowds (‘crowdsourcing’) in providing better services for professional users, while at the same time promoting open innovation and enhancements for service providers.
On the latter, we have reported extensively in (Karagiannidis et al, 2007) and (Karagiannidis et al, 2008). Versatility is a central attribute of the Framework, enabling the consumption of services which should address needs in a complex and highly distributed networked environment which can be seamlessly integrated with the current web. The objective for this Framework is to be a major driver for large scale exploitation, enabling users to create, share and configure services easily which address their and others’ needs, whether for entertainment, information, business or any other area, if possible, on a national scale covering the entire territory of Greece. More specifically, our idea is to define a Framework for service provision based on educators’ needs. This requires a well defined concept of service which we currently define as: “service is any item or action an education expert can offer which could meet the needs of that or another education expert either from the field of general education or from the field of special education”. The Framework is need-driven from the user aspect in order to provide ‘made-to-fit’ personalized services – rather than non- customised ‘one-size fits all’ solutions. The concept of the Framework is depicted in Figure 2, which shows that a person with a particular need can use a solution from a network of people and services. The evolution, expansion and healthy functioning of this network depend on
Figure 2. The proposed Social Networking Service Framework
the ability of individual experts or organizations, such as the local or regional Offices of General or Special Education, to add their services to the network. The functions are complemented by feedback and rating of the utilized services (ultimately promoting open innovation and enhancing service quality), as illustrated in figure 2. The Framework enables the implementation of social networking services which support both networking for their users (as does Facebook) and provide services by individuals or organizations. These services can also be networked and mashedup. Mashing-up services, i.e. combining data or functionality from two or more external sources to create a new service, in a social network fashion, can facilitate the selection and composition of services to address complex social and education needs. People are multidimensional and multifaceted and defining the range of these complex aspects would be necessary in order to enable to locate and use the appropriate service. Personal profiles and service tagging vary from short and simple to complex and detailed. We are specifically interested in the provision of a formalized structure for supporting service discovery, selection and composition (mashing-up),
13
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Figure 3. Need Examples
together with the relevant social networking functions (tagging, blogging, reviewing and rating). Research into the categorization of services is essential. This includes the division into the educator’s personal needs and the needs of the organization that he/she is part of. The idea of a Framework for networked services which is open to anyone in practice may seem too ambitious and easy to compromise, however the wisdom of the crowds in social networking services has helped to override such problems (e.g. in Wikipedia where false information is quickly corrected by others or a warning is provided regarding its reliability). Such approaches ensure the quality and monitoring of level of service. The Service Framework aims to become a roadmap for developing open service-provision services of the Web 2.0 genre, maintaining enough versatility to eventually address provision of needs in the upcoming Web 3.0, where semantic considerations are of importance. To this end, we develop an open architecture that allows incorporation of semantic functionalities where needed. In figure 3, we present a conceptualization of the areas that we concentrated for the evolutionary building of our framework, demonstrating the progress towards more soft aspects of the interaction and networking activity as such. It is interesting to recognise that the emergence of social networking principles is a spontaneous
14
and unplanned to a great extent. Over the last few years, the rise of social software and social networking has driven the transition from contentcentred to people-centred activities. ‘Reading’ and top down content production has dominated the first era of the Internet. Now a truly participatory bottom up or ‘read/write’ approach is emerging as a dominant trend. This shift of focus represents as much a cultural phenomenon as a technological one and has resulted in many commentators questioning its impact on our sense of identity, the meaning of community and the nature of this change (e.g. Hatzipanagos & Warburton, 2009). Web 2.0 has moved beyond the original meaning of the term defined by O’ Reilly (2005) to encompass a set of tendencies exhibited by virtual communities. According to O’ Reilly (in Musser, 2006), Web 2.0 is a set of economic, social and technology trends that are based on user participation, openness and network effects. It is beyond doubt that consumer-oriented concepts can easily grow in such an environment. For instance, the best-known success stories of Web 2.0 (e.g. Wikipedia, Facebook, YouTube, etc.) are based on the concept of user participation through social networking. The terms Web 2.0 and social software and social networking are often used together or synonymously, though Web 2.0 describes more the new ways in which the WWW is used, while social software and social networking, built on Web2.0 platforms and services, describes the universe of possible interactions between individuals and communities, where users are connected and collaborate with each other. The attitudes and behaviours of these communities or social groups have become as significant as the distributed technological platforms that are being exploited by increasing numbers of internet users. One of the major characteristics of these new practices has been a shift towards ‘user-generated content’ where:
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Figure 4. Framework to accommodate needs of the educators and the learners community
1. Collective and collaborative information is gathered, shared, modified and redistributed in creative acts; 2. Personal sites and content increasingly belong to the so called ‘me media’ category; 3. The user controls the choice of appropriate software, tools and services; 4. The ‘collective intelligence’ of users is harnessed through aggregation and large-scale cooperative activities (O’ Hear 2005). For example, social networking sites have become integrated into the daily practice of millions of users and Boyd and Ellison (2007) describe the key features of these services as allowing individuals to:
1. construct a public or semi public profile within a bounded system 2. articulate a list of other users with whom they share a connection, and 3. view and traverse their list of connections and those made by others within the system. In general what we identify are two important functions of these social networks: • •
Intelligence gathering, where people share and construct information online Meeting new people, where there are opportunities for one to one and one to many and many to many interactions.
15
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Participants in internet-based social networking are immersed in fragmented digital environments, and engage in acts of computer mediated communication (Hatzipanagos 2006) through e-mail, email-conferencing and mobile texting, podcasting, personal publishing via blogs and wikis, aggregation and mash-ups, voice, chat, instant messaging and videoconferencing. Social networking is productive of and exercised by virtual communities of people with common interests. Users have the opportunity to contribute to personal and informal or professionally oriented social networks and the goal can be employment, provision of a service or collaboration. The term community has been expanded to include interdependency and a set of relationships that connect people and groups. Citizens become Netizens, an identity that relates them to the entire world, and moves them outside their local life and work settings. For example, social networking, such as Facebook, MySpace, SecondLife and LinkedIn have changed forever the way people communicate in formal (professional) or informal spaces. In all these cases, instead of business-generated content, we see user-generated content; the users contribute directly or indirectly and collectively co-create content or experiences. The users are not only consumers, but also co-developers; they do not expect the passive fulfilment of their needs by business firms. Instead, they participate actively in the development of products and services that meet their needs. Their motives for participation are related to their needs to create products, services and websites that fulfil their personal interests, to tailor offers according to their preferences, to experiment, learn and gain experiences, to contribute to the community, to offer to their peers and to communicate and share with others.
16
THEORETICAL CONSIDERATIONS A Word on (Bypassing) Infinite Regress Activities related to both the preparatory actions needed for establishing a collaboration session of the extended ‘Collaboration game’ as well as for organising information management and processing during its course can make apparent the fact that there are plenty of infinite regress problems and that we need to disaggregate the concept of information before we can get a better understanding of the arguments. To use a quite widely known example (Smith, 1987), in short: •
•
it seems true that before we proceed to a collaboration act we have to make a decision on how much information to collect before proceeding to the particular act but, before we can make a collaboration decision on how much information to collect we also need to collect information about how much information we should collect to make that decision and so on. This is a problem in two ways:
• •
First, it produces an infinite regress. Second, it may be impossible to get reliable information even when one decides to spend time seeking the information.
We believe this is important because it demonstrates that rational choice theory has to be complemented by psychological theories in order to explain collaborative behaviour. The infinite regress problem makes it impossible to make a rational decision in some situations: if rational behaviour is logically impossible, then behaviour in those circumstances can not be explained as the outcome of rational choice (Elster, 1986).
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Figure 5. Domains – modules – formalisms
In the context of our research we considered at least three kinds of infinite regress problems: 1. First, we have to decide how to decide on the particular collaboration act we aim to proceed to (and this may lead to an infinite regress). Assuming we have decided how to decide, 2. we have to find the optimal level of information and deliberation before the decision rule can be used. Once again, it is possible that this leads to an infinite regress. 3. Finally, we might ask about the optimal use of a given set of information. Now, we should not need to provide evidence that these problems are separate. For instance, deciding how to decide requires us to collect information, and this leads to the second problem. We nevertheless tend to think that even if we could collect an optimal level of information, one might still have an infinite regress problem in deciding how to decide. Even if we assume that the optimal level of information is known at every stage, this does not automatically ensure that there is a final end-point. Collaboration theorists often note the infinite regress problem briefly, only to assume it away or decline to discuss it – however, it is something that has direct and practical implications. In this respect, that for Radner (Radner, 1996) it is convenient to classify the costly (resource-using) activities of such decision-making into four groups:
Figure 6. ‘Bad’ versus ‘good’ formalisms
1. observation, or the gathering of information, 2. memory, or the storage of information, 3. computation, or the manipulation of information, 4. communication, or the transmission of information.
A Note on Formalisms As shown in Figure 5, based on a domain conceptualisation, we aim to set a framework that will be expressed by a respective formalism that will support certain collaboration models. Now, the challenging point is whether the (universe of the) actually intended models will fall close to this of the (universe of the) actually supported ones or not. As shown in Figure 6, it is easy to identify and distinguish between a “bad” formalism and a (sufficiently) “good” enough in similar ways to one is using to assess the expressive power of a controlled language. Much work on controlled languages has been motivated by the ambition to find the right tradeoff between expressiveness and processability (Fuchs, 1996). An alternative suggested by several researchers related to bringing into play a “hierarchy of controlled languages”1, ordered by the degree to which they semantically approximate the target formalism. Continuing the analogy with controlled languages, in our research we aimed to design the
17
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
equivalent of a framework and its corresponding application for use by people who are education experts, teachers and teaching practitioners. Such a collaboration ‘language’ needs to be designed with at most minimal training requirement needs. In addition, the collaboration ‘language’ is intended to be used as part of a general system design and verification cycle (namely, this of assisting multi-party collaboration and collaborative decision-making activities. We want thus the collaboration framework to act as some type of a ‘controlled language’, which education experts and practitioners would find intuitive to use, without extensive learning, and which affords the same immediacy and interactivity as spoken language, i.e., which can be used without careful planning and redrafting of the input.
Decision-Making Assessment The decision-making assessment determines the benefit of a particular collaboration decision options by means of quantitative and qualitative assessments. In literature there are well-established scenario techniques which allow the impact analysis of different assumptions with regard to (any particular) value adding benefits. A result of this is the creation of preferential roadmaps. This part of the model has to describe the procedure of how to develop different scenarios and carry out an ‘environmental’ analysis according to the specific scope and needs of the particular education environment under consideration. What is to be taken for sure is that working in and with education networks together with the mastery of key processes enables change in the school environment through evolutionary processes of which an instance is this of our proposed ‘Collaboration Game’. In the current context, change should be regarded as an enabling factor for enabling adaptation of an education structure, so that the latter better responds to external conditions and the given context.
18
Actually, the idea of introducing change as the result of evolutionary processes is not new at all. Furthermore, it can be regarded as one of the most important consequences of game theory in that it can be used to determine situations where one behavior is more fit than all known alternatives, or alternately, a specific mix of behaviors where no one behavior is more fit than any other (Friedman, 1991). In both cases, the result is considered as an evolutionary stasis with respect to the behaviors being considered - there is no change in relative frequency of the employed strategies over time. These situations are named, according to the game theoretical terminology as Evolutionarily Stable Strategies (henceforth: ESSs). More specifically, in the literature of game theory we identify two types of ESS: •
•
“Pure” ESS is where one strategy totally out-competes all others. In our case, this should be read as follows: mastery of a key process by a specific education environment, or alternatively, by a specific education scheme, should out-compete any other scheme. That means that regardless of its frequency, it is always more fit than any known alternative. A strategy that is a pure ESSs is considered as immune to invasion by other known strategies. In the old paradigm of collaborating in a controlled environment, such a strategy might be sought and considered as ideal. “Mixed” ESS is where two strategies permanently coexist, thus increasing the complexity of the implementation, as in a real world application any actor should distribute its resources for achieving a certain / acceptable level of “mastery” in several key processes. From a computational perspective, in contexts where three or more strategies to play, it is possible to have a situation where there is no devisable ESS.
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
It is at this stage that ad hoc or heuristic approaches are employed that may either attempt to simplify the complexity of the given context, or alternate the actual problem to be addressed. A further implication of this is that all relations in an education environment (internal and external) actually and potentially may take the form of a co-operative game. Working groups (comprised either by intra- or inter-school personnel) seem to play an increasingly important role in collaborative education activities, both at the low ‘operational’ level and at the high ‘strategic’one. The importance of this phenomenon is reflected in the emergence of endogenous pedagogical policy models. The latter concentrate on the interaction between working groups of education experts while the school management tends to keep for itself the role of the policymaker (or the arbiter?). Of course, in the case of inter-school working groups, where education experts are involved in a crossschool collaboration game, representatives from the school management boards of the participating schools may also be included. These models are typically focussing on Nash equilibriae of a properly defined game with complete information, where the various working groups (paricipants of a collaboration session) and the school management are the (fully rational) players. These issues are of obvious empirical relevance, since neither the set of working groups (and of the respective collaboration sessions which they are populating) nor their cardinality appears to be constant over time. In fact, organisational maintenance and attracting of new members (or getting rid of old ones that show sub-performances) is a continuing concern for such groups. Moreover, the realism of assuming complete information and (any type of) sophisticated strategic behaviour can be seriously questioned given the complexity of the education environment being dealt with.
CONCLUSION Taking into account that game theory is, after all, the part of economic theory that focuses not merely on the strategic behavior of individuals in economic environments, but also on other issues that will be critical in the design of economic institutions, such as; •
• •
how information is distributed as approached by (Harsanyi, 1967, 1968a, 1968b), the influence of players’ expectations and beliefs and the tension between equilibrium and efficiency (Myerson, 1983).
In general, game theory has already achieved important insights into issues such as the design of business contracts and resource allocation mechanisms which take into account the sometimes counterintuitive ways in which individual incentives operate in complex environments having decision makers with different information and objectives. There have been two means for “confronting” game theory with evidence: in the laboratory and in the field. More specifically, in laboratory studies, expected utility theory, as originally formulated by von Neumann and Morgenstern (Neumann, 1944), was one of the first subjects to attract the sustained attention of experimenters. From the very beginning this effort has both provided indications of the extent to which the predictions of the theory are approximate guides to individual choice behavior, and identified particular situations in which a significant proportion of subjects consistently violate the predictions of the theory. Using procedures of this kind, experimental methods allow investigators to measure some of the parameters on which the predictions of a theory may depend, and which would be unobservable in non-experimental situations*.
19
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Experimental data can also provide insights into field data. More specifically, field studies, as opposed to laboratory studies, are what economists traditionally do, in terms of concentrating their research efforts in studying behaviour of existing (operational) systems or of ad hoc developed, in order to check the validity of assumptions and of any hypotheses made. Conclusively, we note that any interactions between members of a decision-making session, as these would be described in the accompanying model according to a generic process classification scheme, may build on the notion of a co-operative game and according to various modeling perspectives. In thinking about coalitions, these may be for instance formed between: •
•
20
A working group, which is considered as a single part of a decision-making session, and the school management for achieving a particular business objective. In this case, the basis for the formation of the coalition would be related to the achievement of a mutually wished management of school resources (e.g. improvement of a new teaching subject procedure, which would be combined with an increase in the acceptability or likeability rates for the pupils). Two working groups representing parts of two distinct decision-making sessions, both involved in the same decision-making process. In this case, the involved groups may identify a window of opportunity for forming a coalition for achieving their (perhaps common) goal. In any case, even when considering the case of two competitive working groups, formation of a coalition might be justified in terms of minimising the overall uncertainty that might exist when no communication and joint planning had existed, which would imply bigger operational costs.
REFERENCES Boyd, D., & Ellison, N. B. (2007). Social Network Sites: Definition. History, and Scholarship. Elster, J. (Ed.). (1986). Rational Choice. Cambridge University Press. Friedman, J. W. (1991). Game Theory with Applications to Economics. Oxford University Press. Fuchs, N. E., & Schwitter, R. (1996) ‘Attempto Controlled English (ACE)’. In Proceedings of the First International Workshop on Controlled Language Applications (pp. 124-136). Centre for Computational Linguistics. Fudenberg, D., & Tirole, J. (1991). Game Theory. MIT Press. Harsanyi, J. C. (1967-68). Games with Incomplete Information Played by ‘Bayesian’ Players. Management Science, 14. Harsanyi, J. C. (1967). Games with Incomplete Information Played by ‘Bayesian’ Players, I: The Basic Model. Management Science, 14(3), 159. doi:10.1287/mnsc.14.3.159 Harsanyi, J. C. (1968a). Games with Incomplete Information Played by ‘Bayesian’ Players, II: Bayesian Equilibrium Points. Management Science, 14(5), 320. doi:10.1287/mnsc.14.5.320 Harsanyi, J. C. (1968b). Games with Incomplete Information Played by ‘Bayesian’ Players, III: Basic Probability Distribution of the Game. Management Science, 14(7), 486. doi:10.1287/ mnsc.14.7.486 Harsanyi, J. C. (1973). Games with Randomly Disturbed Payoffs: A New Rationale for Mixed Strategy Equilibrium Points. International Journal of Game Theory, 2, 1–23. doi:10.1007/ BF01737554
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Hatzipanagos, S. (2006). HOT and Flaming Spirals: Learning and Empathic Interfaces in Textbased Discussion Forum Dialogues. European Journal of Open, Distance and e-Learning, 2006/I. Hatzipanagos, S., & Warburton, S. (Eds.). (2009). Social Software and Developing Community Ontologies. Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Karagiannidis, C., Efraimidou, S., Koumpis, A., & Molinari, F. (2007). A Collaborative Community Environment to Support Experiential Improvement of Processes and Practices in Special Education. Paper presented at 4th WSEAS / IASME International Conference on Engineering Education (EE’07), Agios Nikolaos, Crete Island, Greece, July 24-26, 2007 Karagiannidis, C., Efraimidou, S., Koumpis, A., & Molinari, F. (2008). Employing the Living Labs methodology to support experiential improvement of processes and practices in special education. Paper presented at 6th International Conference on Networked Learning 2008, 5 - 6 May 2008, Halkidiki, Greece Moulin, H. (1986). Game Theory for Social Sciences. New York, NY: NYU Press. Mueller, R. Haiduk. S., Heertsch. N., Lenz. H.-J., & Spiliopoulou, M. (2004). Studying Knowledge Trading with a Business Game. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Computer Science, Software Engineering, Information Technology, e-Business, and Applications (CSITeA’04), Cairo, Egypt. Mueller, R., Haiduk, S., Heertsch, N., Lenz, H. J., & Spiliopoulou, M. (2005b). Experimental Investigation of the Effects of different Market Mechanisms for Electronic Knowledge Markets. In Proc. of ECIS 2005.
Mueller, R., Spiliopoulou, M., & Lenz, H. J. (2002a). Electronic Marketplaces of Knowledge: Characteristics and Sharing of Knowledge Assets. In Proc. of the Int. Conf. on Advances in Infrastructure for e-Business, e-Education, e-Science, and e-Medicine on the Internet (SSGRR 2002w), L’Aquila, Italy, Jan. 2002. Mueller, R., Spiliopoulou, M., & Lenz, H.-J. (2002b). Expertenrat in e-marketplaces, (“Expert Advice in e-marketplaces”) HMD Praxis der Wirtschaftsinformatik, 223, dpunkt (pp. 38–48). Heidelberg: German. Mueller, R., Spiliopoulou, M., & Lenz, H. J. (2005a). The Influence of Incentives and Culture on Knowledge Sharing. In Proc. of 38th Hawaiian Int. Conf. on System Science (HICSS 2005), IEEE, Hawaii, Jan. 2005. Musser, J. (2006). O’Reilly Radar: Web 2.0 Principles and Best Practices. O’Reilly Media Inc. Myerson, R. B., & Satterthwaite, M. A. (1983). Efficient Mechanisms for Bilateral Trading. Journal of Economic Theory, 29, 265–281. doi:10.1016/0022-0531(83)90048-0 (1944). Neumann, J., & von and Morgenstern. O.: Theory of Games and Economic Behavior. Princeton University Press. O’Hear, S. (2006, June 20). Web’s second phase puts users in control. The Guardian Education. Retrieved November 21, 2008 from http://education. guardian.co.uk /elearning/story/ 0,1801086,00. html O’Reilly, T. (2005). What Is Web 2.0: Design Patterns and Business Models for the Next Generation of Software. Retrieved December 4, 2009 from http://www.oreillynet.com/ pub/a/oreilly/ tim/news/ 2005/09/30/ what-is-web- OrientedEconomy20.html
21
Multi-Vocality and Post-Processualism as Methodological Assets of the ‘Collaboration Game’
Radner, R. (1996). Bounded rationality, indeterminacy, and the theory of the firm. The Economic Journal, 106. Smith, H. (1987). Deciding how to decide: Is there a regress problem? In Bachrach, M., & Hurley, S. (Eds.), Foundations of decision theory. Oxford: Blackwell.
ENDNOTES *
22
For example, the classical game theoretic models of bargaining which date from the work of Nash were unusually resistant to tests with field data because their predictions depend on difficult to observe elements of
1
the bargainers’ preferences. But laboratory experimentation presents the opportunity to measure or control these factors, and thus permits bargaining to be observed in environments for which the predictions of these theories can be known, and therefore tested. And when examined in this way, the evidence supports some of the qualitative predictions of these models, for example concerning the effect of risk aversion on the outcome of bargaining, while contradicting others, concerning, for example, what constitutes complete information about a bargaining problem. With today’s language style cliché one would call it “ontologies of controlled languages”.
23
Chapter 3
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games Daniel I. Thomas Griffith University, Australia Ljubo B. Vlacic Griffith University, Australia
ABSTRACT For humans, collaboration is a natural and beneficial problem-solving attitude. In computer games, human players have worked together to achieve their objectives and many computer games today foster that collaboration with many social mechanisms. Non-human entities however, are used predominantly as props, plot devices and adversaries. Our vision is to see virtual beings engaging as equal partners with humans, providing richer emergent game play. In computer games, the development of artificial intelligence (AI) has been a very poor cousin to the investment in graphics and physics. AI in the most part is confined to path finding algorithms and simple state machines. Taking human and virtual beings beyond current applications of AI in computer games means that intelligent entities within the computer game cease to be “props” in a human-centric story line, but become equal participants themselves within the computer game world, engaging with humans towards achieving goals in more dynamic and realistic ways. Computer games provide a compelling environment to study and enable virtual beings to engage with humans as equals. In this chapter, we investigate the requirements, design and implementation of virtual beings that participate in computer games as humans would; playing the game and creating rich new collaborative game play experiences in areas of education, training and entertainment. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-569-8.ch003
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
INTRODUCTION Alan Turing once remarked that “We may hope that machines will eventually compete with men in all purely intellectual fields” (Turing, 1950). While may not be fully realized today, the integration of artificial beings into human organizations and society evoke powerful images of both positive and negative possibility. Despite the technology that surrounds us today, humans continue to use the imagery of science fiction to strive to create more intelligent machines capable of autonomous decision making. In this Chapter, we explore the possibility of artificial i.e. virtual beings emerging as partners to humans rather than tools used by humans in various collaborative situations. Unlike past revolutions of mechanical automation, the presence of virtual beings should not imply a redundancy for human partners, but rather a complimentary relationship. Group decision-making, including both humans and virtual beings as equals, increases the diversity of the knowledge pool (Dunbar, 1995), improving the likelihood of positive outcomes. Computer game development offers a compelling platform for such research and development. As each new computer game produced pushes the boundaries of technical possibility, it should come as no surprise that academia and the game industry have frequently cross-pollinated each other’s efforts. To this end, we explore a collaborative computer game called TeamMATE1. This environment facilitates the investigation of human and virtual computer game players engaged as fully equal partners. By investigating the nature of fully equal partners, concepts of collaboration and facilitating architecture, it is possible to address the following questions: 1. Can human and virtual beings, being heterogeneous agents, interact cooperatively as fully equal partners in the context of
24
computer games, where each entity is fully replaceable or substitutable with the other? 2. How can cooperation be obtained in heterogeneous agent situations, such as a boardroom, be designed to facilitate cooperation between biological and virtual beings? 3. Can a boardroom-like game scenario be appropriate for social and educational computer games? This book chapter explores these questions, and what is required in order to engage human and virtual players collaboratively in computer games. The principles presented here are delivered from our experience in designing, developing and implementing the TeamMATE© cooperative computer game.
FULLY EQUAL PARTNERS (FEPS) To engage human and virtual beings as equal partners in a computer game setting requires interaction beyond treating the virtual partners as sophisticated tools, but rather requires a degree of social acceptance and cohesion. In such a heterogeneous group of partners, virtual beings must be able to articulate their perspectives and opinions, while taking on board the knowledge and opinions of others. For social acceptance and societal influence to occur the virtual being needs to become acceptable within the social system: Society, organization or group (Kelman, 2006). In making the transition to societal acceptance of virtual beings, there are great challenges both technical and social. To better study virtual beings as collaborative partners, it is possible to focus on a smaller, group social setting, with an assumption of social acceptance (and therefore the capability to influence) collaborative group decision-making. For this reason, computer games provide an excellent environment for understanding how humans and virtual beings can
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
positively influence outcomes in a collaborative group situation. The nature of an independent virtual being participating alongside humans collaboratively in computer games is strongly influenced by the notion of intelligent autonomous agents in computer game theory. The concept of an intelligent autonomous agent as described by Jennings and Wooldridge (Jennings & Wooldridge, 1995) is appropriate for application to the characteristics of human and virtual beings that engage collaboratively as equal participants in computer games. An intelligent autonomous agent, being situated within a collaborative computer game enjoys the following abilities: 1. Is Autonomous; operating without the direct intervention of humans or other entities, having control over its internal state. 2. Situated in and aware of its environment (the game) and is able to interact with this environment through their sensors and effectors. 3. Have some kind of Social Ability; interacting with other human and virtual beings via the use of a communication language. 4. Is able to perceive changes within the (game) environment and React to these changes in a timely fashion. 5. Is Proactive; being able to exhibit goaldirected behavior (taking the initiative) and directly affecting the game and other entities in order to achieve these goals. There have been many instances in the past where virtual players have participated in computer games as a human would (Laird, 2001). In these instances, the virtual player has typically participated as an opponent. In addition, there are many games where simple virtual players have worked as part of a human player’s “team” where they interact with these entities through simple commands. Building upon these principles, we consider that if virtual players were able to participate
Figure 1. Humans and Virtual beings as collaborative fully equal partners
and collaborate within a computer game setting, while having their own internal goals (that is, the ability to play a game as a human would), then these games would have an increased perception of realism and “life” as the interactions between human and virtual beings is not static, scripted or based upon the scenario at hand, but rather changes as these beings interact and collaborate with each other over time to affect change upon the game world that they are situated within. To this end, human and virtual beings can be considered fully equal partners (FEPs) that collaborate to achieve a set of shared goals or outcomes (Figure 1). We consider this concept as complementary to other concepts that use autonomous agents as either opponents (Laird, 2001) or as interactive story characters (Magerko, Laird, Assanie, & Stokes, 2004). Unlike the FEPs, non-player virtual characters are typically able to interact with (or provide simple assistance to) the human players, but do not participate as intelligent collaborative entities, equal in ability to a human being. Humans and virtual beings interacting collaboratively in computer games as fully equal partners enjoy the following attributes:
25
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
1. Can work cooperatively with other fully equal partner s (human or otherwise); 2. “Play” the game as a human would; 3. Does not work to a defined script or take centralized behavioral direction from an agent “director” such as those described by Magerko et al. (Magerko, Laird, Assanie, & Stokes, 2004) and Riedl et al. (Riedl, Saretto, & Young, 2003) and; 4. Are not necessarily aware of the nature of other FEP beings (human or virtual in nature). Simply, a Fully Equal Partner (or FEP) is an intelligent entity that performs tasks cooperatively with other FEPs (human or virtual), but is also capable of being replaced one with another. These beings are not necessarily aware of the nature of their fellow partners.
CONCEPTS OF FEP COLLABORATION Humans and Virtual beings are vastly different entities in terms of their cognitive abilities and complex interactions. This poses a number of challenges when moving from virtual computer game characters as adversaries, tools, props and plot devices to engaged societal equals to humans. A framework is required to facilitate equal engagement in a collaborative computer game. The framework used in TeamMATE© is known as the Collaborative Process. The process itself treats all players as engaged equals (but not necessarily equals in cognitive capacity). This allows the execution of computer game play scenarios with varying proportions of human and virtual players, as well as allow for replaceability.
Collaborative Engagement Consider a group of fully equal partners P engaged in the collaborative process c. There will be a set of outcomes O met at the conclusion of the process.
26
The set is based upon the set of defined goals G defined at the beginning of the process and the ability of the partners to collaborate towards the desired outcomes. However there is not a 1:1 ratio of outcomes to goals, and the set of objectives may even be empty. O = c(P,G )
(1)
Each partner pk is either Human hi or Virtual aj. The collaborative group is the union of the Human and Virtual fully equal partners. P = {p1,.., pk } pk = {hi | a j } A = {a1,.., a j } H = {h1,.., hi } P = A∪H
(2)
During the collaborative process, any partner pl, where l ≠ k, may ask a question qm of any other partner pk in order to receive a response rm, where m = j+i rm = f (pk , qm )
where qm = g(pl ) rm = f (pk , g(pl ))
(3)
The response may contain facts or partial knowledge that can be collected and added to the collective knowledge obtained by the group. The collaborative process of the group in order to obtain a set of outcomes is then consensus based upon the interpretation of the group collective knowledge in order to identify whether the partners
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
have achieved (or partially achieved) the initial goals of the group. The set of Group Collective Knowledge K obtained by the group through the collaborative process is a subset of the responses obtained during the collaborative process.
the game. Typically, the goals that can be found in such a game are: individual goals, goals of the collective (group) scenario and goals of the play scenario.
K ÍR K Í {r1,.., rm } {k1,..kq } Í {r1,.., rm }
Roles are the ingredients of a linking mechanism between the cognitive layer and the physical layer. Within the collaborative FEP architecture, roles define specific functions or duties to be performed by FEPs fulfilling the role. A FEP’s role can also affect the sensors and effectors available to the being participating in the game. While our collaborative computer game concept has been designed to operate without the assistance of an overall agent “director”, as is the case with work in the field of interactive fiction games (Magerko, Laird, Assanie, & Stokes, 2004), we have developed an authority role - The Negotiator2. The Negotiator typically is responsible for the organization, initiation and conclusion of a play scenario or defined objective within a collaborative computer game. A Leader may have to organize a team for a single task or may have to organize groups of FEPs over the entire play time of the game. Depending on how the collaborative computer game has been designed, multiple roles can be defined. In keeping with the FEP concept, a human or virtual being is permitted to perform any role defined.
(4)
For simplicity, assume that all responses rm are components of group collective knowledge K = R. This means that all results contribute to the set of collective knowledge and that all partners are aware of this knowledge. K =R {k1,.., kq } = {r1,.., rm } i.e. q = m
(5)
Outcomes of the collaborative group are a result of the collaborative process between the group of fully equal partners and the goals of the collaborative process. O = c(P,G ) O = c(P,G ) O = {o1,.., on }
(6)
on = s(P, n(G, K P )) Where s is a function of all partners P applied to an interpretation function n of the set of goals G, the set of group collective knowledge across the entire set of partners KP, resulting in an outcome on.
Goals Understanding the various types of goals that can exist within a collaborative computer game is imperative to understanding the outcomes of
Roles
The Collaborative Process The Collaborative Process is used to facilitate a framework of interaction between computer game players acting collaboratively. The process is independent of implementation and underlying communication methods utilized between players (for example, non-verbal, audio or symbolic communication instead of text-based English phrases). Maintaining this level of abstraction allows the
27
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 2. The Collaborative Process as used by TeamMATE©
process to be applied to a variety of collaborative applications. Figure 2 defines the collaborative process employed within the cognitive processing of participating FEPs. Each element of the collaborative process encapsulates particular stages within the collaborative engagement.
Invitation Stage In a collaborative computer game, participation is by invitation to engage in a collaborative task. Invitations themselves may be controlled by a player or set of pre-requisite criteria, or by selfinvitation.
Attendance Stage Once a collaborative computer game has been initiated, participating FEPs are able to “join” the game. Attendance can also occur internally, as human and virtual beings already participating within the game may attend and participate in many play scenarios.
28
Initiation Stage At a point determined by the leader (typically when all participants are present, or the scheduled meeting time has been reached) they will declare the play scenario “started”. It is at this point that the play scenario can commence. Initiation of the play scenario is actually a special action (we describe actions in more detail later).
Definition of Goals Stage Before any meaningful collaboration can be achieved between the participating FEPs, it is necessary to define the goals of the current play scenario. This defines the framework for the conversations that will occur during the process. These goals can also be used to determine the success or failure of a particular play scenario (or whether additional game play is required).
Presentation Stage All communication and collaborative behavior within the computer game takes place in the
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
form of “Conversations”. Conversations involve the presentation of some instructions, positions, statements, or questions that require additional facts and opinions from the FEPs involved in the collaborative process.
Conversation Stage Collaborative behavior within the computer game takes place as the result of “Conversations” that engage two or more players. This involves the interpretation of the Truth/Facts revealed during the conversation process. Conversations between FEPs engaged in a collaborative process involve the transfer of information using different types of conversation elements. As the conversations occur, partners are able to collect truths as well as opinions/positions stated by the other partners. The resulting collection of information is recorded as collaborative group knowledge, which may be used to analyze, evaluate and act towards achieving the desired goals of the computer game.
Questions Questions are used to obtain truths, facts and perceptions. Questions in a collaborative computer game are any communications made by FEPs that result in an outcome (for simplicity, statements or instructions are also considered “questions”). When an agent proposes a question, there are three possible outcomes: A response (which may be itself another question), an Action or No Response.
Response A response is given when a FEP receives a directed question, or perceives (through their sensors) the necessity to respond to a question or action. As a response may happen through non-directed communication, but through the perception of other events within the collaborative computer game, a response may itself initiate a new conversation/negotiation. A special type of response that
requires the use of effectors not directly related to inter being communication is called an Action.
Actions Actions are special responses to questions that result in a transition of some item or process from one state to another. For example, if a FEP asked the question “I require a technician for Project X”, a possible resulting outcome may be that another participant in the play scenario may perform an action that results in the commencement of a recruitment process to hire a skilled technician for Project X. Actions tie the collaborative process to the defined physical layer as only those actions available within the physical layer may be enacted to change a defined entity’s state. Thus, the introduction of cognitive layer elements results in the ability to enact complex/abstract actions based on perceived physical layer effectors rather than a defined set of actions available for a defined role being enacted by a FEP.
No Response In some instances, a question may not require a response.
Negotiation Stage Negotiation involves the willingness of one or more parties involved in the conversation to accept a compromised position. Previously collected facts or collaborative group knowledge, are then used by players in the negotiation process in order to influence or determine outcomes aligned to the earlier stated goals of the collaborative process. The negotiation process involves the process of conversation that the partners engage in and allows the FEPs to discover a best fit outcome based upon the goals stated during the definition of goals phase.
29
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
In human to human interactions, we see many forces at play that influence one person to agree or take the side of another in a discussion. These influences need to be taken into account when collaborative work is undertaken. Even the size of a group (Fay et al, 2000) can change the way in which partners are influenced, and by whom. Collaborative FEPs may create an affinity with one or more entities and are more likely to accept their position during negotiation. Possible methods for obtaining an affinity with one or more FEPs include: 1. The degree to which one FEP’s responses convey a perception/opinion that matches that of another FEP. The more that a partner’s position matches that of another partner, it becomes more likely that the partner will “trust” the statements of that partner. 2. Some arbitrary/authoritative influence factor that has the partner tending towards the position of one or more other partners. An example in a business sense might be seniority and/or position within an organization. 3. Trade: changing a given position in order to influence another partner’s position on another item in the collaborative process. 4. A pre-existing relationship (for example a friendship) that exists beyond the scope of the collaborative process During the collaborative process, any partner pl, where l ≠ k, may ask a question qm of any other partner pk in order to receive a response rm, where m = j+i rm = f (pk , qm )
(7)
The set of Group Collective Knowledge K obtained by the group through the collaborative process is a subset of the responses obtained during the collaborative process.
30
K ÍR K Í {r1,.., rm } {k1,..kq } Í {r1,.., rm }
(8)
To influence group collective knowledge, resulting responses rm that contribute to K must be changed in some way. Assuming that all responses contribute to collective knowledge: K =R {k1,.., kq } = {r1,.., rm } i.e. q = m
(9)
During the negotiation phase, an influence function changes the response for a given partner’s initial decision based on the degree of influence the other partners have with the first partner. i(rpk ) =
∑
1−n ,n ≠i
pnf * (rpn − rpk )
(10)
where i(rpk ) is the influenced response which is the sum of all influence factors pnf multiplied by the response difference partner pn and the partner under influence pk. FEPs using this influence function cannot influence themselves.
Assessment Stage At the conclusion of the negotiation phase, the Leader provides a summary of the collaborative engagement. Based on the information obtained, each goal may be evaluated in terms of the resulting outcomes. The assessments are relayed to the participating partners.
Conclusion Stage At either a specified time, or when the objectives of the play scenario have been completed success-
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 3. The three layers of a collaborative FEP system architecture
fully, the leader is able to enact a special action that concludes the play scenario. Prior to the conclusion, the leader or another nominated partner is given the opportunity to summarize or present the outcomes of the scenario to the other participating human and virtual beings. Outcomes can include gauging the success/failure of the play scenario based on the goals defined at the beginning by the leader; can also result on actions required beyond the scope of the current play scenario and could also be the determination that additional play scenarios are required.
A LAYERED COLLABORATIVE ARCHITECTURE In our work with collaborative computer games, we see a collaborative computer game architecture consisting of three distinct layers (Figure 3). This layered approach allows us to formalize the necessary attributes required starting from atomic technical concepts through to abstract concepts of the cognitive layer. Since each layer creates an additional abstraction, built upon the previous layer, it is important to provide a firm
understanding of each layer’s function within a collaborative computer game. We refer to our approach to a layered collaborative computer game architecture for FEPs as the TeamMATE© Architecture (Thomas & Vlacic, 2005). Each layer of the TeamMATE© Architecture is described in the following sections, demonstrating how this layered approach to collaborative FEPs permits a socially driven environment to exist.
Communication Layer The communication layer is a very fundamental element of a collaborative computer game. This layer defines the technical protocols used to convey information from the game or other entities from or to the FEP beings situated within the computer game. The communication layer is effectively a low level transport layer used to pass information from one place to another for example: DirectPlay, TCP/IP, radio signal etc. These protocols, along with the format of the data being transmitted are then available to a FEP’s sensors. A FEP may also transmit using these communication protocols via their defined effectors.
31
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Physical Layer The physical layer within a collaborative computer game defines a FEP’s available sensors and effectors within the context of the game. The term “physical” is used to refer to this layer as it defines the characteristics of sensors, effectors and entities within the computer game. Before we are able to work with the more abstract cognitive layers of TeamMATE©, it is necessary to define a layer that: 1. Is able to define the physical objects of the collaborative computer game; 2. Provides a common pattern of sensor and effector abilities available to human and virtual beings situated within the game and; 3. Defines the possible actions that may be performed using the available sensors and effectors; Human and virtual partners must be able to work with the appropriate rules/constraints of the specific play scenario being undertaken. Physical rules for a given play scenario consist of information about objects in the computer game and how they may be used. Using or enacting some change upon an entity using the defined effectors is referred to as performing an Action. Take as an example, a simple play scenario that contains these physical layer rules (Table 1). When working with more complex games, and also collaborative games that may occur within the physical world, defining all objects and all actions is not feasible. However, it is possible to define the available sensors and effectors for a FEP, while the task of relating objects and actions becomes a function of the cognitive layer. While a collaborative computer game and the human and virtual beings that are situated within a given play scenario may share a common physical layer, it is not necessarily required that the manifestation of the physical layer will be the same. For example, in order for a human being to interact with the sensors and effectors provided
32
Table 1. Simplistic Physical Layer Rules Object
Available Actions
Chair
Sit, Stand, Move
Table
Place Item, Pick Item
Telephone
Call, Hang Up, Speakerphone, Listen
Stock
Buy, Sell, Report
Talk
Whisper, Tell All, Listen
by the physical layer, it would be necessary to provide a mechanism to interact with the sensors and effectors through a human user interface. Likewise, if a virtual FEP was to interact with other beings within a collaborative computer game, the physical layer would possibly be accessed as some form of software interface.
Cognitive Layer The Cognitive Layer describes the intelligent mechanisms within a human or virtual being that are capable of manipulating, communicating and collaborating intelligently using the defined sensors and effectors provided by the physical layer. The cognitive layer also defines the roles, goals and processes by which FEPs can collaborate within a computer game and provides methods for expressing this information in a meaningful manner in order for decision-making to occur. Human players engaged in computer games are assumed to have an innate cognitive ability, and that a human player engaged in a computer game does so through an interface that presents sensor and effector information in a meaningful way. This interface for human players is what they would simply perceive as the computer game’s user interface. Unlike a human player, a virtual being’s cognitive layer is designed to include decision-making processes as opposed to an innate ability to make intelligent decisions within a collaborative context (Figure 4). The following section describes how a virtual being’s cognitive layer may be constructed.
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 4. Human and Virtual beings utilizing a layered collaborative architecture
EMBODIMENT OF THE LAYERED ARCHITECTURE To facilitate collaboration amongst human and virtual FEPs a Layered architecture consisting of Communication, Physical and Cognitive layers was created. Each of these layers provides a level of abstraction from each other, allowing elements within each layer to be replaced and/or modified without affecting the others (Figure 3). From a practical perspective, the current implementations of this collaborative computer game architecture have been developed using Microsoft Visual Studio 2008 in Visual Basic. Some related technologies utilized in development include Windows Communication Foundation (WCF) as a data transport method; and SQL Server Compact Edition, a lightweight database for storing configuration, rules and domain related game data. Some examples of this abstraction include changing parts of the communication layer from utilizing Microsoft DirectPlay to Windows Com-
munication Foundation (WCF), The most important abstraction for engaging human and virtual partners is the cognitive layer. By providing this layer of abstraction, FEPs can interact with equal ability while their decision making processes are vastly different. This layered approach allows the resulting computer game to facilitate collaboration while supporting many desirable features of multi-agent environments such as exogenous events, causal structures (Hanks, Pollack, & Cohen, 1993), concepts of time (Vincent, Horling, & Lesser, 2000), experimental support as well as many practical features that allow the environment to be worked with effectively (Thomas & Vlacic, 2003). To satisfy these requirements and facilitate FEP collaboration, an embodiment of this architectural concept was developed around the notion of an Electronic Boardroom called TeamMATE©. This computer game provides a virtual “sandbox” within which it is possible to investigate various scenarios and elements of FEP collaboration.
33
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 5. Electronic Boardroom Computer Game Composition
Architectural Overview The game is decomposed into the primary software systems required to create a collaborative computer game. Each of these parts embodies the layered architecture elements in different ways depending on their function within the collaborative educational/training game. The Electronic Boardroom is designed to embody a layered architecture for collaborative computer games which facilitates the interaction and cooperation between FEPs. The collaborative computer game system is divided into three distinct parts (Figure 5): 1. An interfacing system that allows human beings to join (become situated in) and engage others within the computer game; 2. An interfacing system that allows virtual partners to do likewise and; 3. The game play environment which manages the “world” within which the partners are situated. Figure 6. Human Being Interface structure
34
These three elements form the basis of the technical architecture within which FEPs interact and collaborate. Each of the three software systems that combine to form a collaborative computer game must apply the principles of the layered collaborative architecture. The layered architectural approach is applied to each of the main structures of the TeamMATE© system including the computer game “world” and the human and artificial being interfaces
Human Being Interface The Human Being Interface (HBI) facilitates the interaction between human and all other beings situated within the collaborative computer game. It provides a Social Ability mechanism as well as a well-defined interface to permit interaction and cooperation within the bounds of the collaborative computer game (Figure 6). Bringing all these elements together is a central “core” infrastructure of the HBI. This manages the communication, user interface processing
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 7. A Human Being Interface for engaging with other partners
and the management of physical layers for game scenarios. The human being is considered the cognitive layer, and exists separately of the rest of the HBI. The HBI itself provides the other two layers.
HBI Communication Layer The communication layer within the human being interface corresponds to the low level signals transported to and from the electronic boardroom. These signals are then interpreted by the physical layer.
HBI Physical Layer It is necessary to provide a well-defined interface between the human being and the human being interface as well as between the same interface and the electronic boardroom. Humans are only able to interact with the game using the sensors and effectors provided by the HBI. Humans can be considered completely autonomous and are able to use the defined sensors and effectors provided
by the HBI in both reactive and proactive ways to achieve their goals.
HBI Cognitive Layer When working with the human being interface, it is apparent (Figure 6) that the intelligent, cognitive layer exists within the human being and separate of the HBI, which acts as the conduit between the human being’s cognitive abilities and the collaborative computer game.
Virtual Being Interface The Virtual Being Interface (VBI) is actually very similar to the HBI. The difference however, is that the cognitive abilities required to interact and collaborate with other FEPs are contained within the VBI as the cognitive layer (Figure 8). Unlike the HBI, which allows a human being (acting as the cognitive layer) to interact with the collaborative computer game, the VBI itself can be considered to encapsulate all layers of the fully equal partner. The VBI:
35
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 8. Virtual Being Interface structure
1. Contains features that allow the virtual being to be situated within the electronic boardroom game. 2. Is autonomous; Interaction with the computer game is through a well-defined interface. 3. Provides the necessary Social Ability elements such that the virtual being may interact and cooperate with other FEPs. 4. Is able to act reactively based on the information provided by sensors 5. Is able to act proactively in order to achieve its goals While the VBI can be considered as an autonomous entity from the viewpoint of the game “world”, it is not necessarily true that it cannot exist within the same runtime system as long as its interactions are via the interface sensors and effectors. As stated earlier, a number of networking technologies have been utilized by the collaborative computer game, and in some instances a virtual network protocol has also been used.
VBI Communication Layer As with the human being interface, the communication layer is the transport system utilized by all elements of the collaborative computer game.
VBI Physical Layer While the HBI operates as a conduit, providing an actual graphical user interface to the human
36
being, and representing the available sensors and effectors used within the collaborative computer game, the virtual being simply requires a software interface directly between the physical layer (of sensors & effectors) and the virtual being’s cognitive layer. In doing this, it can be demonstrated that the human and virtual FEPs have an equivalence in terms of their interaction with the computer game, while the implementation of this equivalence is quite different.
VBI Cognitive Layer The virtual being cognitive layer is responsible for providing the “Intelligence” required to collaborate within a computer game as a FEP. This is where the decision-making processes of the virtual being reside. This subsystem is able to take interpreted sensor information (provided by the physical layer) and perform reactive and proactive decision making processes. If decisions require action, these actions are interpreted in terms of the computer game’s physical layer attributes and passed as actions (via the communications layer) to the game. In order to adequately experiment with cooperative FEPs, the cognitive layer is designed (conceptualized) as an encapsulated software component. As a practical example, one of the decision-making processes utilized in the VBI cognitive layer uses T-Function (Yan, Ryan, & Power, 1994) fuzzy logic algorithms with a
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 9. A Virtual FEP
small-footprint database storing the linguistic terms and variables. Combining this decision-making process with a language interpreter allowed the virtual FEPs to interact with their human partners.
COGNITIVE LAYER The virtual being’s cognitive layer encapsulates the intelligent decision-making components required to engage in collaborative computer games. This layer comprises the perception, analysis, decisionmaking and action elements required to participate in intelligent collaborative tasks.
Cognitive Layer Design The cognitive layer interprets and evaluates sensor messages that are passed to it via the physical layer and then determines an appropriate response, be it another message, or an action. The response is then relayed to the physical layer effectors. Figure 10 depicts the process by which the cognitive layer receives information from the computer game that it is situated within. The physical layer receives stimulus from sensors (via the
communication layer) which is then transformed and passed to the cognitive layer. The cognitive layer then interprets this physical sensor stimulus, along with inter-partner messages and determines the appropriate response. Messages are conveyed to other game partners (either virtual or human beings), from the cognitive layer as physical layer items in order to interact with other partners and objects within the computer game. Virtual FEPs receiving information via their sensors have no control of the information relayed to the cognitive layer. This means that actions and messages sent to all participating FEPs are received by the virtual partner. From a collaborative point of view this is vital importance as this allows the virtual partner to collect data through the computer game engagement for later utilization in their decision making. At this point it is possible to breakdown the details of a virtual being’s cognitive processes. The cognitive layer can be divided into the following high-level subsystems (Figure 11). Each subsystem or element of the cognitive layer plays a part in taking input stimuli in the form of physical layer sensor information to produce outcomes in the form of physical actions,
37
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 10. The Cognitive and Physical layers and their interaction
messages to other partners or in some cases, no response at all. The operational elements within the cognitive layer fall into four broad categories of operation: Perception, Analysis, Decision-Making and Action. Supporting these functional elements is a cognitive data store which provides supporting information to the operational elements. Figure 11. High level elements of the Cognitive Layer
38
Perception The cognitive layer receives information from the virtual partner’s sensors and can communicate (an action or message) via its effectors. Perception of the computer game situation involves making sense of messages received from these sensors. To achieve this, the virtual partner requires a basic knowledge of the world in which it operates. This knowledge of the world is provided by a scenario Model which represents an instance (point in time) state of the scenario. To collaborate with other partners, the virtual partner’s cognitive layer must have a basic knowledge of the communication language being utilized. This communication language may take the form of a human language, symbols or some other agreed common language for communication. It would be presumptuous to suggest that the implementation of the perception elements of the cognitive layer presented here represent a nextgeneration Natural Language Processor, but there is however some rudimentary language processing that must take place in order to make sense of the messages communicated. Once the interpretation process is concluded, the messages received from the sensors have been transformed into a simple internal structure that represents the interpreted concepts. Once a mes-
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
sage can be transformed into a structured form of the original message, analysis can occur.
Enquiries and Directives
The Analysis subsystem supports the process of taking interpreted information from the Perception subsystem, analyzing the input and providing information for the Decision-Making subsystem to formulate a response based on the information available. The analysis phase can draw upon knowledge of previous events to help infer context. By the end of this process, the message structure has been associated with definitions and meanings that have been stored in the cognitive data. Consequently, this message shall also be recorded, as well as the resulting decision and action for future reference.
An Enquiry is a question directed to one or many partners with the expectation of some form of verbal response. A Directive is a request for some form of response by one or more partners. An Enquiry is a special type of directive where the expected response is specifically verbal in nature. An enquiry or directive is required in the case of insufficient information to address the current collaborative exchange. This is particularly important when various FEPs engaged in a collaborative process have access to different sets of knowledge. In order to achieve an outcome, information has to be requested and shared with the rest of the group. This process of knowledge sharing also grows each partner’s set of indirect test data for statement assessment.
Decision-Making
Actions
Once each type of message has been analyzed, a decision must be determined as to what response is to be taken. By this point, the sensed message has been classified as one of the following message types: A Statement, Enquiry, Directive or Action.
An Action is a non-verbal message enacted by an external party (another partner or the computer game itself) and sensed by the partner’s sensors. Actions are performed upon objects within the computer game environment. An action changes the state of an object from one form to another.
Analysis
Statements A Statement is a communication between one or more partners that expresses a perceived observation made by the originating partner. Statements therefore must be tested as part of the decisionmaking process. Statements may be directly or indirectly tested. Direct testing relies on the partner being able to perform tests upon the statement and recording the result. Indirect testing relies on secondary sources of information that the partner has collected from other partners.
Making a Decision The response to each type of message is the responsibility of the Decision-Making subsystem. The responses that are available include Statements, Enquiries, Directives, Actions or No Response at all. Decisions can be made using a wide variety of methods. In the context of the play scenarios presented here, the decision-making subsystems were able to incorporate a number of problem solving techniques.
39
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Influence In addition to decisions, there is an additional process contained in this subsystem known as the influence process. Influence can modify the decision of a collaborative partner so it is either in more agreement or less agreement with another partner. As the collaborative computer game scenario is executed (and executed many times), influences between the partners emerge. These influences form forces upon the decision made by the partner causing the decision to shift slightly based on the influencing forces.
Action The Action subsystem is the process of changing the response of the Decision-Making process into a form that may be conveyed to other collaborative FEPs via the Physical Layer effectors. This process is undertaken for all verbal and non-verbal messages. The decision-making process outputs the results in the same structured message format used within the cognitive layer. This process is essentially the opposite process to the Perception processes, changing the internal message structure into messages that can be transmitted by the physical layer’s effectors.
Cognitive Data Supporting these subsystems are the various data elements required in order for the cognitive layer to interpret, evaluate and act upon the information received via its sensors (including messages between partners): The game scenario instance or model is created from a game scenario definition, along with the information required to understand and manipulate the model. The cognitive data store also maintains lists of common concepts that are used to assist in perceiving and manipulating the game scenario model. Historical actions and the results of decisions made are also preserved for further use in cogni-
40
tive processing. When a statement is tested, the corresponding results and influences are updated for future reference.
Cognitive Layer Implementation Integration Process Integrating a problem solving technique into a collaborative computer game involves several steps. When integrating a new problem-solving technique into an already existing computer game, many of the following elements shall already be defined. Due to the nature of some techniques, it is important to ensure that each element is addressed to verify whether changes may be required as part of the integration process.
Integrating a Problem Solving Technique The cognitive layer is a set of inter-connected subsystems, each responsible for a particular function and partitioned from the other operations (Figure 11). Underpinning these subsystems is the Cognitive Data Subsystem (Figure 12). Each subsystem is designed to be modular and therefore replaceable (and replaceable separately of the other subsystems). The following sections detail how a new problem-solving technique may be integrated into a virtual being’s cognitive layer.
Internal Message Structure The internal message structure is used to pass sensor input information between each of the cognitive layer subsystems. In order to integrate a problem solving technique it is important to understand what information is produced by the Perception subsystem and contained in this structure. Given the modularity of the computer game layered collaborative architecture, this structure has had opportunity to undergo incremental
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 12. Composition of the Cognitive Data Subsystem
enhancement to facilitate the transfer of progressively richer and more sophisticated information.
Cognitive Data The Cognitive Data Subsystem is where information about a scenario, the current scenario state (as perceived by the player), common concepts and memory (recorded information made by the engaged players during the scenario) is saved
for use by all four cognitive layer processing subsystems. When integrating a new problem-solving technique, it is possible that some changes may be required to the scenario and its related entities.
Scenario Model A Scenario Model reflects the internal definitions and state of the computer game play scenario and
Figure 13. Technical data representation of a Structured Message
41
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 14. Perception subsystem process
is a main element of the cognitive data subsystem (Figure 12). It consists of two primary elements: The Scenario Definition and the Scenario Instance. The Scenario Definition defines the play scenario objectives and information about the types of objects that inhabit the computer game “world”. It provides a definition for the types of entities involved in the computer game, as well as the scenario objectives.
Rules The rules stored within the cognitive data subsystem consist of two information sources: The Scenario Rules and Common Concepts. Scenario Rules are defined as part of the scenario definition and as such are specific to each game play scenario. Common Concepts are rules which may be applied across all game play scenarios an example of such common concepts are the language rules that are to be applied by the Perception subsystem.
Memory When sensor inputs are processed by the cognitive layer, the state of entities within the game play scenario is updated within the scenario model (instance information). Outside of this, information supplied by other players during the collaborative process is stored in a memory within the cognitive data subsystem. This allows the cognitive layer to recall information they have received and use in later processing. Collectively, this memory
42
forms part of the group’s collective knowledge, which is discussed in more detail in (Thomas & Vlacic, 2008).
Loading a Game Play Scenario The Cognitive Data subsystem provides the scenario model, rules and memory which are used by the four processing subsystems of the cognitive layer. To engage in a specific game play scenario, a definition is loaded from a data source (e.g. XML files, Database, etc.). Once loaded into the Cognitive Data Subsystem, the data source is used to create the Scenario Definition and the initial Scenario Instance within the Scenario Model. From here, the Scenario Rules are also created, thus preparing the cognitive data necessary for the Cognitive Layer to engage in the collaborative computer game play scenario.
Perception While not necessarily involved in the integration of a problem-solving technique, the perception subsystem does create a structured representation of the input received from the defined sensors. As Figure 14 shows, the perception subsystem takes input from the physical layer sensors and creates an internal message structure which is processed by subsequent subsystems. Definition and state information stored in the Cognitive Data layer is used to identify and associate information contained in the input.
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 15. The Analysis subsystem provides additional related information to the message structure
Analysis The analysis process involves the association of related data and determining the context of the input message. From a technical perspective, context and related information is added to the message structure as additional related information.
Decision-Making Once an input obtained from the sensors is relayed to the decision making subsystem, the message structure contains information about the original message in a structured format. Inside the decision-making subsystem, an interface is provided that allows for the construction of an interfacing component which is used to transfer data between the decision-making module and the supporting elements of the subsystem.
While other parts of the integration process do not require a highly technical level of expertise, the integration and interface mapping process currently requires some programming skills to map the internal structured message to and from the required interface of the problem-solving technique. Software code is used to implement the interface, allowing the mapping of structured messages to the input requirements of the integrated problem-solving technique. In order to achieve this, a mapping must be determined between the information found in a structured message, and the specific input requirements of the technique’s software implementation. For example “Daniel, is this coffee affordable?” (see Table 2). Conversely, once results are received from the problem solving technique software, it must then be mapped back to the structured message so that
Figure 16. Integrating a problem solving technique into the decision making subsystem
43
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 17. High level diagram of integrating a problem solving technique
the results may be passed to the Action subsystem which sends instructions to the player’s effectors. To integrate a new problem solving technique, we must: 1. Look at the input requirements of the selected problem solving technique. 2. Cross reference these requirements with what is available as part of the message structure. 3. Items that are not available as part of the message structure need to be evaluated to determine if additional information may be retrieved from the cognitive data layer, or from another external source. If a particular technique requires additional external elements beyond the cognitive layer such as the manipulation of another item defined
within the computer game “world” (for example, an electronic mediator), we must define these items in the scenario definition.
Definition Changes Integrating a different problem-solving technique may change the way in which the scenario is defined. In particular, adding additional physical items to the play scenario.
Maintaining Specific Technique Data Some decision-making techniques shall rely upon an internal store of information. With the fuzzylogic example, this data includes all the rules necessary to evaluate input information.
Table 2. Mapping message structure elements to technique input requirements Structure
Data
Partner:
Daniel
Related Item:
Coffee, $10: (Analysis process assigns attribute price, $10)
Action:
Evaluate: Affordable
Message Type:
Enquiry
44
Technique Mapping Fuzzy process for: Coffee Linguistic variable: Affordable Crisp Value: 10.00
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 18. A Data Maintenance dashboard used to main scenario and technique data
Many software-based techniques provide tools to load and configure input data, or if none are provided, large volumes of import data can typically be loaded via an automated process. In a number of play scenarios using various fuzzy logic techniques, a maintenance dashboard was created to assist with maintaining the required data within the data store (Figure 18).
Action Once the message structure contains the results of the decision-making subsystem, the action subsystem converts the structured message into directives instructing the player’s effectors to perform some form of action. Once a structured message has been fully processed by the cognitive layer, it is recorded in memory for possible later use.
CASE STUDY So far, we have explored how human and virtual beings may engage in collaborative computer games as fully equal partners. We have discussed the architectural attributes that are desirable in a collaborative computer game as well as how FEPs engage within these games via the collaborative process. Added to this, we have explored the technical requirements of the communication, physical and cognitive layers with particular attention to the technical implementation of a virtual player’s cognitive layer. To demonstrate how these principles are dealt with in practice, a game play scenario is presented here to demonstrate how FEPs engage in collaborative problem-solving. Computer games of this nature can be applied across a number of computer game applications such as education, training and entertainment. A significant focus has been primarily placed upon educational computer game application however the play scenario presented is of the more familiar entertainment variety of com-
Figure 19. The Action subsystem converts structured messages into instructions for the player’s effectors
45
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
puter game. Other scenarios presented elsewhere belong to the education and training varieties of computer games (Thomas & Vlacic, 2005, 2008, 2009; Vlacic & Thomas, 2009; Vlacic, Thomas, & Amagasa, 2009). Each scenario engages players in scenarios that must be resolved collaboratively; with each play scenario exploring one or more attributes of FEPs engaged in collaborative computer games. The following four case studies explore and rely on the principles of player collaboration to achieve a positive outcome.
Hammurabi Those well versed in computer programming and in particular computer game history will be aware that Hammurabi is considered one of the oldest kingdom building style games and a forefather to many modern strategy and planning games (Egenfeldt-Nielsen, Smith, & Tosca, 2008). This particular game was chosen due to the simple game play, but intelligent decision-making required on behalf of the players. This combination allows us to focus on the details of the virtual partner’s cognitive layer in action. The original game itself is simple. A player acting as the ancient Sumerian king Hammurabi aims to survive a 10 year period (turns) in office by managing resources of grain to ensure their people were fed, and that there was enough land for cultivation. Each player starts with 100 people, 1000 acres of land and 2800 bushels of grain. Each year (turn) the player determines how many bushels of grain to feed to their people, buying or selling land and how much grain to cultivate in the fields. There are a number of basic rules that determine game play: 1. The game lasts up to ten years (turns) unless the player is impeached for poor performance. Impeachment occurs if the following conditions are met in any given turn:
46
2.
3. 4. 5. 6.
a. The number of population starved is greater than 33% b. Acres per person of population ratio is less than 7:1 Every person requires 20 bushels of grain to survive for a year. If a person does not receive 20 bushels of grain, they starve. Each acre of land requires 1 bushel of grain for cultivation Every year, a price to buy and sell land is determined Each person can cultivate up to 10 acres of land If a player lasts 10 turns, they are evaluated to determine how successful their term in office was
Each turn, a set of exogenous events occur that determine the resources available to the player for the next turn: 7. Each year, the population grows due to migration and natural growth 8. The price of land to buy or sell fluctuates between 17 and 26 bushels of grain per acre. 9. The crop yield for the turn ranges between 1 and 5 bushels per acre of cultivated land 10. There is a percentage chance each year that rats will eat a proportion of the harvested bushels of grain 11. There is a percentage chance that the kingdom shall suffer a plague which kills half the population
Scenario Hammurabi’s Boardroom is built upon the classic game Hammurabi, but expands the game to include multiple collaborative partners providing an additional mental challenge as they must collaboratively make decisions to achieve a successful outcome. The game consists of a group of up to four players. One player is Hammurabi who is responsible for commanding the Royal Steward
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Figure 20. Hammurabi’s Boardroom Game Cycle
to buy and sell land, feed the people from the granaries and order cultivation of the fields based on the council’s decision. While Hammurabi is the head of state and responsible for sending the decree to the Royal Steward; in this game a Council consisting of Hammurabi and three wise officials elected by the country has equal say in the decisions made. One the council has arrived at a collaborative decision, Hammurabi informs the Royal Steward of their commands. Once the Royal Steward receives the command to act from Hammurabi, the decision of the council is performed. Once the
commands enacted by the steward are performed, the turn “ends” (representing a year). The steward then receives a report on the performance of the country that is then brought before the council (Figure 20). Typically, each turn would result in a random assortment of exogenous events (in the form of crop yields, migrations, deaths, land price etc.). This particular game has been designed to allow specific turn results to be recorded and played back, allowing the scenario to be repeatable. Table 3 shows the factors that were applied to Hammurabi’s Boardroom for each turn cycle.
Table 3. Table of Game Factors used during experiment runs Turn
Population Increase Factor (1 – 10)
Plague Factor (-3 – 17)
Rat Population Factor (0 – 1)
Crop Yield (1 – 5)
Land Trading Price per Acre (17 – 27)
1
5
10
0.09
1
23
2
2
9
0.16
2
26
3
1
2
0.41
2
23
4
3
16
0.52
4
21
5
5
3
0.15
2
21
6
9
0
0.55
1
24
7
4
-2
0.69
2
18
8
2
-2
0.62
3
23
9
8
-2
0.62
4
18
10
4
-2
0.62
4
22
47
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
These factors were taken from the random values produced in an initial game run.
Decision-Making There are many methods by which decisionmaking can be achieved. As part of the architectural implementation, each process of the layered collaborative architecture is designed to allow replacement. Two techniques were applied to Hammurabi’s Boardroom: A fuzzy logic process and a second decision-making process based around levels of quality. Both of these approaches have been demonstrated individually in other work (Thomas & Vlacic, 2008; Vlacic & Thomas, 2009). The decision making process within each virtual partner results in a recommendation about how many people to feed, acres to trade and grain to store. This decision is then passed to the Action processor. In addition to the fuzzy approach, a second decision-making group was also implemented which instead made collaborative group decisions based on levels of quality (LOQ) that each partner brought to the decision making process. This approach is based around using a completely neutral process or mediator to deliver an outcome based upon the decisions of all partners. Each partner reviews a set of alternative decisions each turn (in the case of this computer game, the alternatives are evaluated and put forward by the partners themselves) and the group provides their decisions to the mediator based upon the levels of quality they have nominated. This electronic mediator then determines the outcome which satisfies the decisions of the collaborative group using an order-consistent achievement function (Vlacic, Wierzbicki, & Matic, 1986). The electronic mediator in the context of this computer game is the Royal Steward who enacts the outcomes of the council’s decisions.
48
Table 4. Results at the conclusion of the Game for each Partner/s Player/s
Population
Bushels
Acres
Human
57
3
45
Fuzzy Partners
22
697
502
LOQ Partners
20
16
771
Baseline Partner
16
3
261
Results The computer game was constructed as a set of loosely coupled functional modules and subsystems. The Hammurabi game module itself is responsible for creating exogenous game events and managing game play. To verify the correctness of the solution, a suite of unit tests was performed in order to ensure the validity of the computer game model. Verification requires benchmarks, testing and a consistent point of reference. A single reference implementation3 of the original Hammurabi was used to generate testing outcomes with which to verify the results generated by the game. Firstly, a Baseline Partner (BP) was used to determine a benchmark position for game play. This baseline partner used strict constraints to ensure the goal of zero population loss per turn. Two collaborative groups were also tested: A Fuzzy Logic based collaborative group and a group collaborating using levels of quality and an electronic mediator. Finally, a human partner was also included in testing to verify the solution approach. Table 4 shows the results at the end of each game. The underlined values represent the “winner” of each game attribute (population, bushels and acres). What can be seen in Table 4 is that each of the Human, FP and LOQ strategies in the game resulted in each achieving a significant benefit over the others for a particular attribute. Interestingly,
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Table 5. Individual virtual players game achievements Player/s
Population
Bushels
Acres
Hammurabi
18
0
390
Shullat
22
16
624
Hanish
23
0
692
Delondra
21
16
774
while the Baseline Partner achieved zero deaths due to starvation, it achieved a consistently lower result than any of the other game groups across all attributes. In addition, to demonstrate how the LOQ collaborative group achieved their outcomes Table 5 shows the individual virtual partners involved in the LOQ engagement after playing the game again as individuals. This illustrates how the quality levels nominated by each of the decisionmakers results in the overall collaborative decisions of the LOQ group.
SUMMARY This chapter has explored the principles of engaging human and virtual beings in intelligent collaborative computer games, the purpose being to provide engaging and effective methods by which collaborative outcomes may be achieved. Human and virtual beings can be considered fully equal partners (FEPs). That is, intelligent entities that performs tasks cooperatively with other FEPs (human or artificial), are replaceable, and not necessarily aware of the nature of their fellow players. To facilitate the engagement of FEPs in computer games, the collaborative process provides a structure within which players of different natures and levels of intelligence may collaborate effectively. The TeamMATE© system supports this process by implementing a layered collaborative architecture. The communication, physical and
cognitive layers are used to cohesively facilitate collaboration, with each layer having a level of abstraction beyond that of the previous layer. Humans are considered intelligent entities by nature, something which must be emulated or constructed for in virtual being. The virtual being is able to enact intelligent decisions via its cognitive layer subsystem. Contained within this cognitive layer are the abilities to perceive, analyze, make and then enact decisions. The results of which are conveyed to other players via sensors and effectors. The decision-making processes required within the cognitive layer are able to be replaced by other problem-solving techniques offering a flexible and extensible platform for intelligent decision-making. The Hammurabi game play scenario demonstrates an entertainment style game as well as the application of a number of different problemsolving techniques. This and other game play scenarios we have tested (Thomas & Vlacic, 2005, 2008, 2009; Vlacic & Thomas, 2009; Vlacic, Thomas, & Amagasa, 2009) demonstrate that human and artificial beings are able to interact cooperatively as fully equal partners in the context of computer games, and are capable of being substituted one with the other. It has also been shown that cooperation between FEPs can be achieved in computer games using the collaborative process and a layered collaborative architecture. Also, that TeamMATE© as an implementation of boardroom style collaborative computer games may be used in social and educational applications. The implication of effective collaboration between FEPs extends beyond computer games and the virtual environment, to physical real-world applications. In particular, the ability to engage humans and embodied virtual beings collaboratively provide many potential opportunities in the field of automated transportation systems. There may also be opportunities to apply FEP collaborative games in areas of behavioural studies as
49
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
a platform for clinical research and/or various defense force settings. Whatever the future holds for virtual beings, as FEPs they will no longer be props or plot devices in virtual worlds; but will be the players, teammates and co-workers of the future, working alongside their human counterparts.
Laird, J. E. (2001). Using a Computer Game to Develop Advanced AI. IEEE Computer, 34(7), 70–75.
REFERENCES
Riedl, M., Saretto, C. J., & Young, R. M. (2003). Managing interaction between users and agents in a multiagent storytelling environment. In Proceedings of the second international joint conference on Autonomous agents and multiagent systems (pp. 741-748). Melbourne, Australia: ACM.
Dunbar, K. (1995). How scientists really reason: Scientific reasoning in real-world laboratories. In Sternberg, R. J., & Davidson, J. (Eds.), Mechanisms of Insight (pp. 365–395). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Egenfeldt-Nielsen, S., Smith, H. J., & Tosca, S. P. (2008). Understanding Video Games: The Essential Introduction. Taylor & Francis. Fay, N., Garrod, S., & Carletta, J. (2000). Group Discussion as Interactive Dialogue or as Serial Monologue: The Influence of Group Size. Psychological Science, 11(6), 481–486. doi:10.1111/1467-9280.00292 Hanks, S., Pollack, M., & Cohen, P. (1993). Benchmarks, Testbeds, Controlled Experimentation, and the Design of Agent Architectures. AI Magazine, 14(4), 17–42. Jennings, N. R., & Wooldridge, M. (1995). Intelligent Agents: Theory and Practice. The Knowledge Engineering Review, 10, 115–152. doi:10.1017/ S0269888900008122 Kelman, H. C. (2006). Interests, relationships, identities: Three central issues for individuals and groups in negotiating their social environment. Annual Review of Psychology, 57, 1–26. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.57.102904.190156 Khan, Z. (1998). Attitudes towards intelligent service robots (Technical Report IPLab-154, TRITA-NA-P9821). Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm.
50
Magerko, B., Laird, J. E., Assanie, M., & Stokes, D. (2004). AI Characters and Directors for Interactive Computer Games. The 16th Innovative Applications of Artificial Intelligence Conference (pp. 877-883).
Thomas, D. I., & Vlacic, L. B. (2003). Selecting an Environment for Cooperative Autonomous Robot Research. In Hyungsuck Cho, J. K., & Lee, J. (Eds.), Intelligent Robots: Vision, Learning and Interaction (pp. 187–198). KAIST Press. Thomas, D. I., & Vlacic, L. B. (2005). TeamMATE: Computer Game Environment for Collaboration and Social Interaction. IEEE Workshop on Advanced Robotics and its Social Impacts - ARSO’05, (pp. 60-65). Nagoya. Thomas, D. I., & Vlacic, L. B. (2008). Collaborative Decision Making Amongst Human and Artificial Beings. In G. Phillips-Wren, N. Ichalkaranje, & L. Jain (Eds.), Intelligent Decision-Making: An AI Based Approach, 97-133. Thomas, D. I., & Vlacic, L. B. (2009). Toward Societal Acceptance of Artificial Beings. In Khosrow-Pour, M. (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology (2nd ed., Vol. 8). IGI Global. Turing, A. M. (1950). Computing Machinery and Intelligence. Mind, LIX, 433–460. doi:10.1093/ mind/LIX.236.433
Human and Virtual Beings as Equal Collaborative Partners in Computer Games
Vincent, R., Horling, B., & Lesser, V. (2000). Experiences in Simulating Multi-Agent Systems Using TAEMS. The Fourth International Conference on MultiAgent Systems (ICMAS 2000). AAAI.
Whittaker, B. (1999). What went wrong? Unsuccessful information technology projects. Information Management & Computer Technology, 7(1), 23–29.
Vlacic, L. B., & Thomas, D. I. (2009). Beyond Multiplayer Games: Engaging Cognitive Virtual Partners in Collaborative Decision-Making and Problem-Solving Situations. XXII International Symposium on Information, Communication and Automation Technologies – ICAT 2009. Sarajevo.
Wierzbicki, A. P. (1982). A Mathematical Basis for Satisficing Decision Making. Mathematical Modelling, 3, 391–405. doi:10.1016/02700255(82)90038-0
Vlacic, L. B., Thomas, D. I., & Amagasa, M. (2009). The Integration of Artificial Beings into Human Society in the Context of Collaborative Problem Solving. The Problem Solving Systems Symposium. Tokyo: Daito Bunka University. Vlacic, L. B., Wierzbicki, A., & Matic, B. (1986). Aggregation Procedures for Hierarchically Grouped Attributes With Application to Control Systems Performance Evaluation. In Jahn, J., & Krabs, J. (Eds.), Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems: Recent Advances and Historical Development of Vector Optimization (pp. 285–311).
Wierzbicki, A. P. (1985). Negotiation and Mediation in Conflicts, II: Plural Rationality and Interactive Decision Processes. In Grauer, M., Thompson, M., & Wierzbicki, A. P. (Eds.), Sopron 1984 (pp. 114–131). Springer Verlag. Yan, J., Ryan, M., & Power, J. (1994). Using Fuzzy Logic. Prentice Hall.
ENDNOTES 1
2
3
Copyright Intelligent Control Systems Laboratory, Griffith University, Australia Unlike a mediator, a negotiator has the right to participate in the collaborative process. Reference implementation used is available at http://www.hammurabigame.com/ hammurabi-game.php
51
52
Chapter 4
Computer Games and Libraries Helena Coelho Technical University of Lisbon, Portugal
ABSTRACT Information literacy is a crucial attribute in today’s knowledge society, because it makes independent lifelong learning possible. Faced with a digital world where new tools for information seeking and the spaces for information sharing are developing, academic librarians must respond to the changing learning landscape in order to help students acquire essential skills. Computer games, due to their cognitive potential and engagement capacity, can be used to promote and improve information literacy instruction. This text consists of a review of available literature on these topics. It addresses the role of computer games in the teaching and learning process and aims at discussing its possible use as training tools for promoting information literacy in libraries.
INTRODUCTION In today’s knowledge society, the creation of value depends on harnessing the power of information. Advanced skills and high qualifications are required to ensure organizational competitiveness. Given the expansion of knowledge-based economy and the exponential growth of information available, schools and universities should help train people to be able to search, find, evaluate and DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-569-8.ch004
use information whenever necessary. The skills and methodologies involved are transversal and allow graduates to learn throughout life, fostering their professional integration and evolution. This has consequences for the libraries of these institutions, whose professionals, due to their training in organization, retrieval and evaluation of information, are especially equipped for ensuring this aspect of preparing students for the future through a pedagogical attitude about the identification of sources of quality information and the efficient use of available resources.
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Computer Games and Libraries
In other words, libraries, while maintaining their traditional functions of building collections and providing information services, must teach its users a set of essential skills in terms of information literacy, considering not everybody is equally able to take full advantage of available resources. Fighting information illiteracy, which is a cause of social exclusion, might contribute to increase the importance of libraries as spaces for research and learning. One possible way for libraries to achieve this educational goal is to explore the potential of games in general or, more specifically, of computer games. Crawford (1997) noted that games have become an integral part of learning activities in many civilizations and are in fact “the most ancient and time-honored vehicle for education” (p. 15). Nevertheless, games have always evolved along with human culture, society, and technology. Considering that information literacy is not an easy subject to teach students, particularly given the increasing diversity and complexity of information sources, it seems natural to look for tools that take advantage of today’s digital culture and use computer games (Kirriemuir, 2008). Thus, librarians’ role as instructors would not be diminished, but updated through the use of teaching methods that employ media in which students are already engaged. As the world changes, the way people play changes too, but play’s importance remains constant. It not only help us to relax, but also prepares us for life’s challenges. The same technologies that influence our forms of entertainment and communication with other people can be used to foster knowledge construction and development of new skills. Therefore, the objectives of this chapter are to expose the need to train information literate citizens and to present arguments concerning the potential of computer games as educational tools to achieve this aim.
INFORMATION LITERACY FOR THE 21ST CENTURY Traditionally, the concept of literacy was associated to a linguistic code and defined as the ability to read, write and understand texts. However, with the rapid development of new communication technologies and the consequent proliferation of information, the nature of literacy has undergone a transformation in order to include the ability to learn, comprehend, and interact with technology in a meaningful way. Hence the advent of the expression information literacy, defined by the Chartered Institute of Library and Information Professionals (CILIP) as the ability to recognize when and why information is needed, where to find it and how to evaluate, use and communicate it in an ethical manner (Armstrong, Boden, Town, Woolley, Webber, & Abell, 2005). This term incorporates the traditional views of literacy as well as new forms of literacy associated to technological progress. Probably, its meaningfulness will increase due to the recent developments of the World Wide Web, notably the change of paradigm from Web 1.0 to Web 2.0 and the evolution towards the semantic Web, with its emerging methods of information extraction and semantic analysis of data. In Web 1.0, the flow of information was largely unidirectional, with the common cybernaut acting merely as a receptor. But the recent popularization of resources such as blogs, wikis, podcasts, and social tagging systems has led to the advent of the so called Web 2.0, where every person with a minimum of technological skills can be not only a consumer, but also a producer of information. For this reason, the concept of literacy will tend increasingly to include the skills and competencies involved in finding, selecting, analyzing, evaluating, and storing information, as well as in its treatment and use, independently of the associated codes or technologies. As Vieira (2008) states, from an historical perspective, literacy represents a pole of attraction for
53
Computer Games and Libraries
many aspirations of society regarding opportunities for learning, expression, creativity, and civic participation and has therefore been integrated into educational curricula, specially because it is considered one of the competencies required by an increasingly competitive labor market, that favors certain sectors of society over others (the info-excluded). In order to be successful in a knowledge-centered society, an individual must be able to determine what information is necessary, to find it efficiently and to critically evaluate its sources; that information shall be integrated in the individual’s knowledge base, so that his or hers objectives are achieved and the socioeconomic, legal and ethical variables that determine information’s use are understood. Libraries have an important role to perform as gateways to knowledge by promoting information literacy skills. As archives of knowledge and repositories of the achievements of the human spirit, they are an integral part of civilization (O’Connell, 2008). For eras, librarians have played a pivotal role, connecting people to information necessary for academic, professional, cultural or recreational purposes. School and university libraries, in particular, have the key roles of storing information and providing a place for learning and research activities. They are organizational and educational centers for students, teachers and researchers striving for academic success and trying to meet the demands of modern society. In fact, a link was demonstrated between library use and student achievement (International Association of School Librarianship, 2007).
COMPUTER GAMES IN EDUCATION According to Leach and Sugarman (2006), “a game can be defined as an activity that contains some or all of the following elements: rules, goals, challenges, fantasy, mystery, curiosity, competition, and skill” (p. 191). From observing the natural world, Crawford (1997) concluded games
54
have received the approval of natural selection as educational tools for every creature capable of learning. People commonly associate playing games with children because they recognize its fundamental utility in education. Hannikainen (1997) showed children reflect in their play many questions of existential nature while trying to master skills corresponding to their acquired knowledge. Perhaps that is the reason why teachers consider play as the most important activity for children development and learning (Azevedo, van der Kooij, Neto, 1997). Leite and Rodrigues (2001) also point out the importance of game playing for intellectual and social development in a context of education for citizenship through active pedagogies, which differ from traditional ones by focusing on ludic activities as sources of both amusement and learning. Nevertheless, it is possible to conceive educational games for all ages that aim to help players in achieving a specific learning outcome. Leach and Sugarman (2006) refer the use of games as instructional tools in a variety of disciplines, as well as an increase in knowledge retention by students using an educational game compared to those who received conventional instruction with lectures and paper-based materials. More recent studies (Tüzün, Yilmaz-Soylu, Karakus, Inal, & Kizilkaya, 2009; Huizenga, Admiraal, Akkerman, & ten Dam, 2008) also point out positive effects of game-based activities on learning. Smith (2007) showed information literacy skills can be taught through games. This author implemented simple gaming activities, such as crossword puzzles and word searches in a course on information research skills for academic credit. It was an effort to integrate active learning techniques to reduce student boredom and keep them engaged in information literacy classes. After one semester, 86% of students agreed the activities were engaging and 95% agreed the activities were preferable to a lecture-only format. But why should academic libraries feel compelled to take the initiative to teach information
Computer Games and Libraries
literacy skills to a population that seems at ease with technology and perfectly capable of satisfying its informational needs through the Web? Today’s students seem faster at processing information than the previous generations, acting sometimes as authorities in all areas involving technology. In fact, Prensky (2006) calls them digital natives, because they grew up in a world where computer games, e-mail correspondence, instant messaging and other digital tools are commonly used, and thus developed patterns of engagement different from those of earlier generations. However, familiarity with technology does not necessarily imply sophistication in its use. In spite of the popular belief that teenagers and young adults are technologically savvy, Valenza (2006) claims that today’s young information seekers lack advanced skills or knowledge necessary to explore complex information environments and to properly evaluate the information they find; students show a limited understanding of the way information is organized, tend to use natural language instead of promising keywords when searching databases and have a manifest difficulty in identifying information needs in systems that require specific terminology in search interfaces. Calhoun (2006) seems to have the same opinion, declaring students favor search engines with simple interfaces, like Google’s, instead of academic databases that might yield more satisfying results. Both this author and Valenza (2006) also describe students’ apparent lack of concern with the quality of their sources, noting they spend more time searching than analyzing their results on the computer screen. Besides, they accept as good enough materials that many information professionals would not deem satisfactory. Nevertheless, the lack of understanding of search environments and an incomplete knowledge about the potential and limitations of Web resources often leads to feelings of frustration with less than effective approaches. A recent report of findings from respondents to a survey carried out among college students in
the United States of America as part of Project Information Literacy (Head & Eisenberg, 2009) corroborated these findings and added that students seem to conceptualize information seeking as a competency learned by rote and fail to harness the wide range of resources available to them in the digital age. Educators must recognize that technological innovations brought significant social and cultural changes that manifest themselves in schools and universities. However, although grappling with technology has usually ludic aspects, is not enough to ensure certain aspects of student’s preparation for the future. Given that several studies point to the pervasiveness of computer games in today’s society (e.g., Lenhart, Kahne, Middaugh, Macgill, Evans, & Vitak, 2008; Kirriemuir, 2008; Kirriemuir & McFarlane, 2004), it makes sense to analyze their pedagogical potential and value as educational tools. Kirriemuir and McFarlane (2004) state that the terms computer game and video game used to refer to PC-based games and console-based games respectively, but are now used interchangeably. Generally, these authors define a digital game as one that “provides some visual digital information or substance to one or more players”, “takes some input from the players”, “processes the input according to a set of programmed game rules”, and “alters the digital information provided to the players” (p. 6). This definition includes games that operate on different platforms: personal computers, mobile devices, and hardware known as video game consoles. Although some educators may regard computer games as a waste of time, Gee (2003) considers this is a complex field whose potential is better perceived by gamers, so they must not be quickly judged. This author argues that playing computer games involves skills related to learning and game designers often use learning techniques identified and considered important by cognitive scientists. In fact, complex computer games require players to master a great deal of information in order to
55
Computer Games and Libraries
improve their results and achieve their goals; this information is often gathered by playing, so games employ a variety of techniques to encourage learning. These techniques include training players in subtle ways without giving them direct instructions and encouraging them to practice, persevere, try new things and take risks. But learning is not just about information gathering. Also according to Gee (2003), other aspects of learning, such as thinking patterns, are independent of content and can be developed through computer games. Besides, a great deal of knowledge is constructed through interaction with other players. This is of particular importance considering humans usually do not learn well from lots of overt information provided to them outside contexts in which it can be used. They tend to forget that information, especially when they are unable to imagine such contexts. These are the reasons why most games can be adjusted to a range of skills, allowing players to choose among various difficulty levels, leading them on a learning curve and providing rewards at appropriate times as capabilities are developed. In addition, many computer games present players with the opportunity to choose from different styles of play, such as stealth or overt aggression, and to solve problems in several ways (e.g., logic or trial and error), thus allowing them to customize the game to their learning style or to experiment with new styles. Computer games that are better at creating learning are more profitable in the marketplace, because there would be no demand if they were not challenging or if they proved too difficult to master (Gee, 2003). Prensky (2003), based on Gee’s work (2003), explained 36 ways players learn from computer games: 1) Doing and reflecting; 2) Appreciating good design; 3) Seeing interrelationships; 4) Mastering game language; 5) Relating the game world to other worlds; 6) Taking risks with reduced consequences; 7) Putting out effort because they care; 8) Combining multiple identities; 9) Watching their own behavior; 10) Getting more
56
out than what they put in; 11) Being rewarded for achievement; 12) Being encouraged to practice; 13) Having to master new skills at each level; 14) Tasks being neither too easy nor too hard; 15) Doing, thinking and strategizing; 16) Getting to do things their own way; 17) Discovering meaning; 18) Reading in context; 19) Relating information; 20) Meshing information from multiple media; 21) Understanding how knowledge is stored; 22) Thinking intuitively; 23) Practicing in a simplified setting; 24) Being led from easy problems to harder ones; 25) Mastering upfront things needed later; 26) Repeating basic skills in many games; 27) Receiving information just when it is needed; 28) Trying rather than following instructions; 29) Applying learning from problems to later ones; 30) Thinking about the game and the real world; 31) Thinking about the game and how they learn; 32) Thinking about the games and their culture; 33) Finding meaning in all parts of the game; 34) Sharing with other players; 35) Being part of the gaming world; and 36) Helping others and modifying games, in addition to just playing. Steinkuehler and Duncan (2008) mention that the intellectual activities that constitute successful game play include not only computer literacy, but also the construction of new identities, collaborative problem solving, literacy practices and systematic thinking. They provided empirical evidence about the potential of one particular genre of computer games, called massively multiplayer online games (MMOs) as tools that foster learning, especially informal science literacy. Massively multiplayer online games are 2- or 3-D graphical, simulated worlds played online that allow individuals to interact not only with the designed environment in which activities take place, but also with other individuals. Science literacy is relevant to the broader concept of information literacy because both involve similar processes of testing (scientific hypothesis or search queries), as well as a mindset to evaluate results critically. Those are also observed when a player explores a gamespace and learns its norms by following
Computer Games and Libraries
a process of trial and error. Usually, a player can improve his or her performance quantitatively (by, for example, making decisions faster) or qualitatively (by modifying playing strategies). Conceiving and testing strategies is often a fundamental aspect of game playing: As part of developing efficient and effective solutions, players are customarily expected to research various game strategies and tactics by consulting on- and offline manuals, databases, and discussions, as well as by using such knowledge as the basis for in-game action. (p. 531) Prensky (2003) considers there is great value in letting players, within the world of the game, try things, form beliefs, and test and revise them, employing the same procedure scientists use in the real world. Besides, Steinkuehler and Duncan (2008) also show individuals collaborate to solve complex problems within the virtual world. Markey et al. (2008) corroborates this idea regarding information literacy games, arguing that although students want to be in control during game play, they will collaborate with their peers when the collaboration makes their goal more easily achievable. The development of collaboration skills is also important for information literacy because, according to Valenza (2006), information seeking is often a social activity and peers may play a significant role as collaborators on that process. Students have greater success in their research when they can discuss their progress and their difficulties with others who can fill gaps in their knowledge. Many other simulation-based games allow players to interact with complex systems and test hypotheses. Squire and Jan (2007) provide one example through the use of an augmented reality game, that is, a game played in the real world with the support of digital devices (PDAs or cellphones) that create a fictional layer on top of the real world context. Although the project was specifically conceived to immerse students
in genuine scientific inquiry, the authors were also concerned with general information literacy, because they recognized scientific argumentation as a literacy skill. Among practices that constitute game play, they include collecting data in the world, creating instruments to collect data, using spreadsheets to analyze data and conceive models, arguing over data collection methods and developing assertions based on data. Games can engage players by establishing associations to the real world and to issues relevant to them, as well as by asking them to inhabit roles that allow them to see themselves as active participants in the game and encourage competition, collaboration and reflexion-in-action. Besides, to help games appeal to the imagination, a narrative is often employed. Given that knowledge is contextual and experience-based, narrative contexts can help students gain an experimental understanding of notions that might otherwise remain abstract. Thus, librarians who intend to use digital games as educational tools must pay attention to several aspects. When playing, students are actors in an activity instead of passive recipients of information, and if games are to be played in informal contexts, players will often control when and how much they play (whereas in library instruction classes students are expected to learn all at the same pace). Therefore, the narrative and the task must be challenging, drawing on themes that elicit engagement from students. The roles available shall invite them to explore the virtual world in new and interesting ways. Moreover, it is necessary to consider the social nature of game play, because games often elicit social interactions, as already mentioned above. Malone and Lepper (as cited in Schaller, 2006) composed a list of key characteristics a learning game should have: challenge, control, fantasy, and curiosity. Challenge is created by clear, fixed goals that are relevant to the learner. Whereas success in accomplishing activities should promote feelings of competence for the gamer, uncertain outcomes provide challenge by offering variable difficulty
57
Computer Games and Libraries
levels, hidden information, and randomness. Control is experienced as feelings of self-determination when the gamer is presented with the opportunity to make choices that produce a visible effect. Fantasies involve both the emotions and thinking process of the learner, so they can be employed to provide relevant metaphors or analogies linking the material covered to the emotional needs of learners. As for curiosity, the authors argue it exists in two different forms: sensory and cognitive. Audio and visual effects in computer games may enhance sensory curiosity, whereas puzzle elements arouse cognitive curiosity. Schaller (2006) extended this list by adding two other criteria for an effective learning game: iteration and reflection. Iteration is described as vital to learning, because “whether it consists of small iterations within the activity sequence, or replaying the entire game to attempt alternate strategies, iteration supports the learning process by encouraging experimentation, hypothesis testing, and synthesis” (p. 6). Reflection should happen during this whole process. Thus, games are better tools when they include an interactive element that is sufficiently engaging to encourage repeated usage with meaningful outcomes.
Library Games The presence of computer games in libraries is not something new and Levine (2008) presents several situations. Some libraries develop games collections and/or books about gaming, specially in institutions offering courses associated to computer games; others offer computer games as a recreational, educational and professional opportunities; and some use them to enrich and complement existing teaching methods. In fact, several academic libraries are already attempting to develop information literacy skills in students through computer games. For example, Carnegie Mellon Libraries created the “Library Arcade”, featuring two online games designed to help students develop research skills through
58
entertaining and easy-to-repeat activities. In one of them, entitled “I’ll Get It”, the player controls a student character who must help his peers to identify diverse research materials; the mouse is used to pick up their requests and the library catalog is available to look for helpful resources. Players are asked to do their best to help the colleague characters quickly in their research, or they will get annoyed and leave the library. In the other game, entitled “Within Range”, players are asked to shelve books in correct order to learn how information is organized and categorized using the Library of Congress Classification System (Carnegie Mellon Libraries, n.d.). The University of North Carolina at Greensboro also developed an interesting project for undergraduates: “The Information Literacy Game” is an online board game for up to four students with a question-and-answer format. Players take turns moving around the board answering questions and attempting to get one right in each of four categories: “Choose Your Resource”, “Searching/ Using Databases”, “Cite Your Sources/Avoid Plagiarism” and “Library Wild Card”. The game incorporates Web evaluation exercises, given that some squares on the board ask players to find specific information on a website or to compare websites based on criteria such as authority or currency. The educational objectives are for students to: 1) Understand that information can be found in a variety of sources; 2) Understand the function and use of information sources; 3) Identify useful information from the library’s catalog and online databases; 4) Understand the way collections of information are organized and accessed; 5) Determine when to cite a source and cite it properly using a specific citation style (Harris & Rice, 2007). The game files (including images, scripts, questions, sounds, and HTML documents) are freely available for download, along with instructions for other libraries to reconfigure it using their own contents. Another example is “Defense of Hidgeon”, a University of Michigan’s project born of the
Computer Games and Libraries
observation that librarians may be exemplary in terms of assisting students who want to acquire information literacy skills, but they only reach a few of those who need assistance (Markey et al., 2008). For that reason, a team was assembled to design, test, and evaluate a new method for teaching information literacy called storygaming. It consists in combining gaming with dramatic storytelling to maintain and build player involvement, to prevent game play from becoming tedious, and to appeal to a wide range of people. The storygame aimed specifically at teaching undergraduates the General-to-Specific Research Model for conducting research and finding information. According to this model, students are advised to start research with broad overview tools in order to develop a general understanding of their chosen topics, and subsequently replacing them for resources that provide more specific information. “Defense of Hidgeon” is a web-administered board game in which action takes place in 14th century Europe, at the height of the Black Death. Teams of four players land on each of the six different monastery libraries and must give correct answers at least three times to the questions that are posted there. Correct answers receive a scroll and give the team an opportunity to purchase an exclusive license to the library or challenge the owning team for its license. A roll of the electronic dice lands game pieces not only on the monastery library, but also on spaces that require different actions. To complete the game, it is necessary to collect all 18 scrolls and gather as much gold and property as possible. The goal is to become the fastest, richest, and most accurate research team in order to prove to Hidgeon’s ruler that one’s team can be trusted to use monastery collections responsibly and efficiently. Students started playing this game at the end of 2007 and cited some benefits: learning how to use the tools of research, doing research tasks connected with various online tools over and over again, and confronting and solving important problems during the research process.
Fletcher Library at Arizona State University created another computer game entitled “Quarantined: Axl Wise and the Information Outbreak” to teach library and information skills in first-year English classes. It was assumedly designed to meet the learning preferences of a generation of students that are comfortable with technology, appreciate collaboration, prefer immediate responses and think in non-linear terms (Gallegos & Allgood, 2009). After years of using a paper library tour exercise unpopular with students, a professional manifested the desire to “find an alternative instructional tool that would be online, engage students, and allow them to learn the same basic information as they built skills” (Levine, 2008, p. 29). The project started with educational gaming research and the creation of a board game with question cards called “Information Pursuit” as a prototype that was used for the first time in 2005. The trials were positive, with this game being successful and exceptionally popular, so in the spring of 2006, the team began developing the interactive online game that became “Quarantined”. “Quarantined: Axl Wise and the Information Outbreak” is described as an interactive single-player game that simulates the processes of selecting, using, evaluating and synthesizing multiple sources of information within a research environment. Players are faced with a deadly virus outbreak, so they must avoid contagious students and professors to remain virus free, as well as VOA (Virus Outbreak Agency) officers. In order to save the world, they are required to explore the college campus game world to discover the cause of and the cure for the virus, developing information literacy skills as they interact with characters and make decisions about the resources they encounter. A variety of information sources such as databases, the online catalog, the web, librarians, professors and peers can be useful to solve the mystery in this educational adventure game with puzzle and action elements. A computer game with similarities to the previous one, although less complex, is Bioactive, a
59
Computer Games and Libraries
web-based interactive adventure about bioterrorism developed by the University of Florida to teach library research skills. It aims at helping students to learn how to search in the library catalog, access an item in the online course reserve system, find a journal article and locating materials in the library by call number. The game files are available to download and modification by other institutions (University of Florida, n.d.). It is also possible for libraries to adapt existing games to meet their own goals. The University of Calgary is developing a project entitled “Benevolent Blue” by modifying the first person shooter “Half-Life 2” to test the effectiveness of first-person perspective action games to introduce players to information literacy skills. The player controls a virtual character in a three-dimensional world and perceives the digital environment through its eyes. The action genre was chosen because of its popularity, flexibility of challenges, progressive narrative and first-person point of view (University of Calgary, 2008). There are embedded elements (pre-generated narrative components such as video clips and scripted scenes) and emergent elements created as the player interacts with the game. In the dystopic game world, the player will find a totalitarian regime where culture, thought and choice are tightly controlled; the mission will be to discover the truth in the propaganda saturated media and to aid dissidents in revealing the forgotten memory of the nation. The player must achieve this by solving puzzles, defeating security forces, exploring an old institution of higher learning and completing tasks such as searching the library catalog, locating books, identifying citations and evaluating resources. Thus, using “Benevolent Blue”, key concepts of information literacy are presented through play, along with ideals of civic responsibility, intellectual freedom, critical thinking, access to information, copyright, privacy, diversity and preservation of resources.
60
The Need to Innovate For ages, academic librarians have acted like gatekeepers of access to information. However, recent technological developments that make information appear to be easily accessible seem to challenge this institutional role. Therefore, librarians should adapt to the current digital landscape, assuming new roles in promoting information literacy skills, such as the ability to recognize when information is needed and to locate, evaluate, and use it effectively. The projects here described can be considered good examples of innovation. Their outcomes should be shared and discussed by librarians, so that lessons for the future can be learned. The team responsible for “Defense of Hidgeon”, based on students’ and on its own evaluation of the game, issued some premises for guiding the development of information literacy games in general. They claim games must be useful to the coursework students are already doing, sending them positive and negative feedback to improve their performance, giving them the possibility to see other researchers at work so they can connect what they do to what others do, and fostering opportunities for them to reflect on their own research habits and on what they are learning. They also argue that students’ performance in gaming activities must count toward students’ grades. However, it is not clear that information literacy skills should be taught in mandatory classes with an impact on students’ grades. Smith (2007) argues that students can resent mandatory classes they do not perceive a real need for. It was also found that students ranked credit-courses as their least preferred means of getting library instruction, favoring individual assistance while actively seeking information (Davidson, 2001). Given the premise that students learn best when they feel a need to know, perhaps a balance can be found, both for mandatory and non-mandatory programs, through the use of games so much as motivational tools as an integral part of the
Computer Games and Libraries
teaching material available online. Games that are downloadable or browser-based can be played not only in the library, during instruction classes, but also on any computer connected to the Web, as informal educational tools. If games present challenges relevant to issues students face, the intrinsic motivation and the exploratory frame of mind gamers exhibit when playing can optimize the learning experience. The online availability of computer games is of particular relevance considering academic libraries are increasingly requested to transcend their physical space in order to bring their resources and services to every student, reaching all spaces where the learning process can take place. This require librarians to accept a transition from formal to informal learning spaces, a shift from classes to personalized learning opportunities, and a change from restrictive and constructed learning activities to creative and extended learning opportunities (O’Connell, 2008). Many librarians have a conservative perspective on literacy, associating it to reading and writing skills, so they fear that promoting computer games will drive students even further away from book reading and its cultural affordances. Perhaps those librarians do not possess yet for computer games a frame of reference equivalent to the one they already developed for the presence of other resources, like CDs and DVDs, in libraries. However, considering the development of complex and engaging storylines, together with the artistry behind computer games, Easterwood and Wesson (2009) propose their popularity can be explored, so that librarians connect gamers to books. Novels and plays provide narratives and plots that are culturally engaging, and in many ways digital games, due to their embedded storytelling, are a more recent form of fiction. By examining different genres of computer games and identifying their features and the kind of books their fans may respond to, librarians have a great opportunity to act as readers’advisors, matching gamers with books and promoting reading.
For example, fans of strategy games that require good problem-solving skills, mental engagement and creativity will probably enjoy reading mystery novels; people who prefer action games could be directed towards books with as much immediacy as possible, grippingly turbulent plots, and firstperson narration; those who favor role-playing games or adventure games that revolve around a quest and combine action with puzzle solving might like fantasy and science fiction books. Non-gamers may find difficult to apprehend all the nuances, but a basic knowledge of a few key genres like the ones mentioned above would be valuable in order to better communicate with gamers, learn what appeals to them and understand key elements in a game that allow its pairing with a book. Reading reviews, becoming acquainted with computer games, and analyzing them in terms of plot, characters and required skills could be a good start. Communication and collaboration between game designers and library professionals involved in teaching information literacy is also crucial. Although librarians might not possess the skills to create digital games themselves, they need to learn the fundamentals of contemporary game design in order to communicate effectively with designers and therefore safeguard the success of their initiatives.
CURRENT TRENDS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH Johnson (2006) suggests there are three factors that impact on libraries’ survival and opportunities to thrive: the growing digitalization and portability of information, the fundamental changes in the nature and sources of information, and the critical need for new skills for workers in a global economy. All these changes can be directly related to information literacy. This fact, together with a new understanding of the benefits of playing computer games, has led many academic librar-
61
Computer Games and Libraries
ies to ponder the expansion of their realm of possibilities for user instruction through gaming. One way to create games is to start by identifying real-world uses or applications of the knowledge to be taught, searching for situations that are narratively compelling and emotionally engaging, in which information is necessary to solve complex problems in simulated environments. It would also be advisable to add challenges to motivate the players, increase complexity to stimulate improvement, and provide adequate feedback by matching choice opportunities and consequences. It is possible to conceive role-playing games with pedagogical approaches such as goal-based scenarios and case-based learning, which cast students in roles where they solve complex problems. As for multiplayer games, an interesting design should foster collaboration among players in order to gather and share information. What is essential is to envision games that enable joy of use and work as both entertainment and learning experiences. The interactive and immersive character of computer games makes possible a high degree of involvedness, turning the player into an active operator instead of a passive recipient of experiences. Nevertheless, it would be interesting to know if certain game genres lead to better learning outcomes and, if so, to search for an eventual association to learning styles, as well as to information searching and processing habits. Librarians involved in this kind of initiatives should communicate and share experiences with their peers. Together, they can find innovative ways to integrate gaming on their services and instigate other professionals interested in exploring the potential of computer games to invest themselves, take risks and establish partnerships with other members of the academic community. Another valid line of research would be to study the attitudes of the academic community (including teachers, students, and other librarians) towards the use of computer games as learning tools. Obviously, it would also be of great relevance to investigate how students respond to these initia-
62
tives and understand if and how their information literacy skills evolve. Libraries must not create computer games merely to present themselves as modern and trendy, but rather to adapt to the interests and needs of one particular community they serve. This requires, in the first place, a good understanding of library’s real and potential users, and then careful consideration about the impact of gaming on teaching and learning, as well as on the acquisition and distribution of knowledge and information. The aspects of gaming to be included in information literacy programs should be significant to the community and reflect on services rendered by the library. The results of subsequent surveys should be used to evaluate those programs and readjust them when necessary. A trend that deserves attention is the customization of computer games. Gee (2003) approaches the phenomenon of game players becoming game designers, mentioning that many game companies take advantage of it to ensure, through creativity, their survival in a competitive market. Sometimes, the companies provide free software players can use (often working in groups over the Internet) to create something new. Myers (2008) supports this idea for educational purposes, mentioning that inventing and experimenting with materials, rather than simply interacting with them, provide the best learning experiences. The author adds that “by allowing kids to design their own computer games, educators can facilitate deeper learning and promote the acquisition of literacies that will be crucial to success in tomorrow’s professional and social environments” (p. 55). Librarians who plan on creating computer games should eventually decide whether or not they will accept library users as collaborators on the process of game development. The possibility of players becoming creators strongly resembles what happens in the Web 2.0 world, where the distinction between information producers and consumers is blurred. In fact, both game cultures and the Web 2.0 draw upon collective intelligence and require people to navigate through multiple
Computer Games and Libraries
information spaces that span different media and to evaluate the reliability of what they find. Similarly, academic libraries’ websites often assemble several information resources and librarians play an important role in helping students to evaluate the authenticity and applicability of material from the web. Given these parallels, it would also be interesting to see if there is an association between gaming and the correct use of Web 2.0 tools, which is nowadays an important aspect of information literacy.
CONCLUSION In today’s knowledge society, the tools for seeking information and the spaces to share it are rapidly changing. The Web offers multiple free alternatives to information seekers, but it is full of outdated, contradictory and inaccurate data, which confuses many users. Considering that the ability to find the right information, assess its value, and interpret it is essential for full citizenship, teaching organizations have the obligation to prepare students for a future in this extremely dynamic information age and help them to obtain skills that allow not only for success in academic work, but also for lifelong learning. School and academic librarians should contribute to their institutions’ teaching strategy by developing those abilities in students. These professionals have the opportunity to assume new roles that build on their traditional training but challenge them to go further in order to update the way how they teach information literacy skills. Oblinger and Hawkins (2006) state: “Historically, library collections have ensured quality control and have safeguarded the legitimacy of the material used by students. Beyond the quality of the collection itself, professional librarians have helped students hone their information searches and find information resources” (p. 12). Nevertheless, more must be done to help students learning how to navigate today’s complex digital landscape and
adapt to new situations. Although libraries no longer have a monopoly on information sources, they do offer value-added services and this is one of them. Games in general are powerful learning tools and one proactive approach libraries can follow to develop information literacy skills in students consists in conceiving games that require them to find, evaluate, and use information effectively to solve a particular problem or make a decision. Considering that computer games provide versatile tools for recreation, education and entertainment, librarians can harness the potential of information technology and engage digital natives by creating computer games with clear goals and instant feedback, challenging without being too hard, and both socially and intellectually appealing. Their pedagogical objectives must be established taking into account its desired impact and embedded in the gaming experience with the purpose of creating effective learning environments. Driven by authentic quests, computer games can incorporate multiple resources and guide learners through tasks into a way of thinking. Besides, in designing a computer game, it is necessary to consider motivational aspects that will make it enjoyable, attract diverse users and encourage them to continue playing. Unfortunately, most library instruction initiatives are based on the historic literacies of print and have not yet adapted to the literacies of interactive technology. Librarians, as educators, have a responsibility to better understand these relatively new technologies and draw implications regarding the paths they can follow in order to achieve their professional missions. Despite the fear that computer game playing would eventually replace more culturally valued activities like reading, empirical studies show some games encourage advanced manipulation of texts, along with other materials, for achieving particular ends, including the construction of complex models to compare the effectiveness of strategies. Reading, writing and data interpretation are prevalent in game
63
Computer Games and Libraries
forums where mastering information is a source of prestige. Besides, these forums are rich sites for social knowledge construction thanks to the debate and collaboration they foster. Moreover, many computer games require some form of research that makes the act of playing very similar to exploring a database. In both activities, there are goals achievable through a series of steps that must often be repeated and involve finding, evaluating, and using information, as well as establishing search strategies, articulating constructed knowledge, and reflecting on outcomes to refine procedures. Thus, it is possible to develop pedagogies that capitalize on these forms of literacy in order to prepare students for a future in the information age, when constant learning, as well as the creation and use of knowledge, are central elements of organizational strategies. Librarians can explore the contemporary affordances of computer games in order to play their instructional role in an innovative way, both in formal and informal situations. This requires them to keep up-to-date about technology and to understand students’ habits. In fact, if new tools are to be incorporated in the definition of strategies to promote information literacy among academic communities, it is essential to know these communities needs in the first place. Only then will it be possible to conceive interesting and engaging projects aimed at helping people to become competent information seekers and users. Librarians’ motivation to experiment digital game-based teaching approaches to develop and enhance information literacy in academic communities relies on two factors: one is the recognition that learning in general and the acquisition of information literacy skills in particular can be achieved by playing adequate games; and the other is a professional drive to seek new ways to serve both the explicit and the implicit information needs of one’s community. Obviously, all initiatives should be open to feedback, support
64
future innovation, and allow for the study of their impact. Careful design and constant evaluation are crucial to overcome eventual challenges and tap on the potential of computer games.
REFERENCES Armstrong, C., Boden, D., Town, S., Woolley, M., Webber, S., & Abell, A. (2005). CILIP defines information literacy for the UK [Electronic version]. Library and Information Update, 4(1), 22–25. Azevedo, N. R., van der Kooij, R., & Neto, C. A. (1997). Early childhood teachers opinions about play: An exploratory study. In International Council for Children’s Play (Ed.), Play and society (pp. 37-38). Lisbon: Faculty of Human Kinetics. Calhoun, K. (2006). The changing nature of the catalog and its integration with other discovery tools. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Library. Retrieved April 11, 2008, from http://www.loc. gov/catdir/ calhoun-report-final.pdf Carnegie Mellon Libraries. (n.d.). Library arcade. Retrieved November 22, 2009, from http://search. library.cmu.edu /rooms/documents/ libraries-andcollections/ Libraries/etc/index.html Crawford, C. (1997). The art of computer game design. Retrieved October 4, 2009, from http:// www.vancouver.wsu.edu /fac/peabody/gamebook/ Coverpage.html Davidson, J. R. (2001). Faculty and student attitudes toward credit course for library skills [Electronic version]. College & Research Libraries, 62, 155–163. Easterwood, L., & Wesson, L. P. (2009). Gamers are readers: Capitalize on the popularity of videogames. School Library Journal, 55(4), 24-25. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www. schoollibraryjournal.com /article/CA6647714. html
Computer Games and Libraries
Gallegos, B., & Allgood, T. (2007). Quarantined: Axl Wise and the Information Outbreak: Creating an online game to teach information skills. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://gaming. techsource.ala.org /index.php/Quarantined:_Axl_ Wise_and_the_Information_ Gee, J. P. (2003). What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. Hannikainen, M. (1997). Playful actions as part of children’s culture in day care centers. In International Council for Children’s Play (Ed.), Play and society (pp. 38-39). Lisbon: Faculty of Human Kinetics. Harris, S., & Rice, A. (2007). The Information Literacy Game. Retrieved November 22, 2009, from the University of North Carolina at Greensboro Web site: http://library.uncg.edu/game/ gamehandout.doc Head, A. J., & Eisenberg, M. B. (2009). Project Information Literacy progress report: Lessons learned: How college students seek information in the digital age. Retrieved December 5, 2009, from http://freerangelibrarian.com /2009/12/01/ must-read-project-information -literacy-report/ Huizenga, J., Admiraal, W., Akkerman, S., & ten Dam, G. (2008). Cognitive and affective effects of learning History by playing a mobile game. Retrieved March 30, 2010, from http://www.ilo. uva.nl/homepages /wilfried/docs/ ECGBL_2008_ Huizenga%20etal.pdf International Association of School Libraries. (2007). School libraries make a difference to student achievment. Retrieved November 13, 2009, from http://www.iasl-online.org /advocacy/ make-a-difference.html Johnson, D. (2006) Dangers and opportunities: Challenges for libraries in the digital age. Retrieved November 30, 2009, from http://www. doug-johnson.com/ storage/handouts/danger.pdf
Kirriemuir, J. (2008). Teaching information literacy through digital games. In Godwin, P., & Parker, J. (Eds.), Information literacy meets library 2.0 (pp. 153–164). London: Facet Publishing. Kirriemuir, J., & McFarlane, A. (2004). Literature review in games and learning. Bristol: Futurelab. Retrieved December 7, 2009, from http://www. nestafuturelab.org/ research/reviews/08_01.htm Leach, G. J., & Sugarman, T. S. (2006). Play to win! Using games in library instruction to enhance student learning [Electronic version]. Research Strategies, 20, 191–203. doi:10.1016/j. resstr.2006.05.002 Leite, C. M., & Rodrigues, M. L. (2001). Jogos e contos numa educação para a cidadania. Lisboa: Instituto de Inovação Educacional. Lenhart, A., Kahne, J., Middaugh, E., Macgill, A. R., Evans, C., & Vitak, J. (2008). Teens, video games, and civics. Washington: Pew Internet & American Life Project. Retrieved December 22, 2009, from http://www.civicsurvey.org Levine, J. (2008). Broadening gaming services in libraries [Electronic version]. Library Technology Reports, 44(3), 24–34. Markey, K., Swanson, F., Jenkins, A., Jennings, B., St. Jean, B., Rosenberg, V., et al. (2008). Engaging undergraduates in research through a storytelling and gaming strategy: Final report to the Delmas Foundation. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from University of Michigan Web site: http://deepblue. lib.umich.edu/ handle/2027.42/58630 Myers, B. (2008). Minds at play: Teens gain 21st-century literacy skills designing their own computer games [Electronic version]. American Libraries, 39(5), 54–57. O’Connell, J. (2008). School library 2.0: New skills, new knowledge, new futures. In Godwin, P., & Parker, J. (Eds.), Information literacy meets library 2.0 (pp. 51–62). London: Facet Publishing.
65
Computer Games and Libraries
Oblinger, D. G., & Hawkins, B. L. (2006). The myth about student competency: “Our students are technologically competent”. EDUCAUSE Review, 41(2), 12-13. Retrieved November 12, 2009, from http://www.educause.edu/ EDUCAUSE+Review/ EDUCAUSEReviewMagazine Volume41/ TheMythAboutStudentCompetency /158049 Outbreak:_Creating_an_Online_Game_to_ Teach_Information_Skills Prensky, M. (2003). Escape from planet Jar-Gon [Review of the book What video games have to teach us about learning and literacy]. Retrieved November 11, 2009, from http://www.marcprensky.com /writing/ Prensky, M. (2006). Listen to the natives. [from https://matua.wikispaces.com/Readings]. Educational Leadership, 63(4), 8–13. Retrieved November 16, 2008. Schaller, D. (2006). What makes a learning game? Retrieved November 28, 2009, from www.eduweb.com/ schaller-games.pdf Smith, F. (2007). Games for teaching information literacy skills. Library Philosophy and Practice. Retrieved November 10, 2009, from www.webpages.uidaho.edu/ %7Embolin/f-smith.pdf Squire, K. D., & Jan, M. (2007). Mad City Mystery: Developing scientific argumentation skills with a place-based augmented reality game on handheld computers [Electronic version]. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 16, 5–29. doi:10.1007/s10956-006-9037-z
66
Steinkuehler, C., & Duncan, S. (2008). Scientific habits of mind in virtual worlds [Electronic version]. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 17, 530–543. doi:10.1007/s10956008-9120-8 Tüzün, H., Yilmaz-Soylu, M., Karakus, T., Inal, Y., & Kizilkaya, G. (2009). The effects of computer games on primary school students’ achievement and motivation in geography learning [Electronic version]. Computers & Education, 52, 68–77. doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2008.06.008 University of Calgary. (2008). Benevolent Blue: An information literacy FPS. Retrieved November 22, 2009, from http://www.ucalgary.ca/ ~cthomas/ wilu08_handout.pdf University of Florida. (n.d.). Bioactive. Retrieved November 22, 2009, from http://www.uflib.ufl. edu/ games/bioactive Valenza, J. K. (2006, April). They might be gurus: Teen information-seeking behaviour. E-Voya, 1-4. Retrieved November 11, 2009, from http://pdfs. voya.com/ VO/YA2/VOYA 200604T9gTeamTech.pdf Vieira, N. (2008). As literacias e o uso responsável da Internet. Observatorio (OBS*), 2(2), 193-209. Retrieved October 17, 2009, from http://obs.obercom.pt /index.php/obs/article/view/112
67
Chapter 5
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning: The AIDLET Model José Bidarra Universidade Aberta, Portugal Meagan Rothschild University of Wisconsin, USA Kurt Squire University of Wisconsin, USA
ABSTRACT This chapter discusses the selection and potential use of electronic games and simulations in distance learning supported by an operational model called AIDLET. After analyzing the different approaches to the use of games and simulations in education, and discussing their benefits and shortcomings, a framework was developed to facilitate the selection, repurposing, design and implementation of games and simulations, with focus on the practical aspects of the processes used in Open and Distance Learning (ODL). Whereas traditional learning is based on knowledge memorization and the completion of carefully graded assignments, today, games, simulations and virtual environments turn out to be safe platforms for trial and error experimentation, i.e. learning by doing/playing. New instructional models may require that rich interactive processes of communication are supported, that assignments are structured as game-like projects, and that a culture of interaction, collaboration, and enablement drives learning and personal development. In this context, the AIDLET model was set out and verified against a taxonomy representing the main categories and genres of games to meet the requirements of distance education teachers, instructional designers and decision-makers.
INTRODUCTION The current model of pedagogy in conventional schools and universities is essentially teacher focused and one-way communication. It is set against DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-569-8.ch005
evidence that shows how students learn more by collaborating with their teacher and with each other in the context of educational narratives (Pachler & Daly, 2009). Furthermore, evidence indicates that a new model of education is emerging, one that is student-centered, networked, customized and col-
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
laborative, leading to the creation of mechanisms through which infusion experiences and other rich learning contexts may support activity in novel situations (Shaffer, 2004). In addition, it is now recognized that student emotional expressions are a part of the learning process and also an essential component of basic education, a fact that continues to be a minor concern in schools and higher education. There is a growing body of evidence from the neurosciences and the cognitive sciences that recognizes the importance of emotions in cognitive processes and memory operations. The Portuguese born neuroscientist António Damásio developed a theory of emotion that has evolved from his first book, Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain (1994), which explains how feelings are entangled in the cogitations of the brain and the circumstances of the body. In his second book, The Feeling of What Happens: Body and Emotion in the Making of Consciousness (1999), Damásio further explores the role of emotion. He attempts to connect the neurology of emotion to the neurology of consciousness and extends this to the existence of a sense of self. Essentially, Damásio states that mind and body are inseparable and integrated via mutually interactive biochemical and neural components, such as the endocrine, immune, and autonomic neural constituents, which produce chemical and electrical transmitters. As a rule, freedom of choice, challenge, participation, transparency, integrity, collaboration, fun, speed, and innovation must be a part of students’ learning experiences. Playing games may be an important part of learning as this generation’s game-playing experiences are more widespread than the game-playing experiences of previous generations. No doubt technology is transforming the ways we learn today but the most widely accepted theories and models behind learning are still valid. For instance, the pedagogical framework for implementing new software tools, games and simulations in the context of Open and Distance Learning (ODL) can be developed by drawing
68
on concepts from: constructivism (Bruner, 1966; Piaget, 1973), social constructivism (Vygotsky, 1978), situated cognition (Brown, Collins, & Duguid, 1989; Barab & Kirschner, 2001), and communities of practice (Wenger et al., 2002). Social constructivism in the Vygostkyan way provides a series of principles that may be accomplished during the development of educational activities. The Piagetan notion of constructivism is at the core and it basically means that students modify their current knowledge schemes to integrate new information and acquire new knowledge when in contact with teachers, peers and the surrounding environment. In addition, learning activities must be situated in authentic settings and in a context that is meaningful to each individual student, and may increase in effectiveness when students are part of community that shares values and contributes to a common objective. Constructivism, situated learning, and the establishment of communities of practice constitute a robust theoretical framework for knowledge acquisition based on the notion that learning occurs in the context of activities that typically involve a problem or task, other persons, and an environment or shared culture. A recent Educause Center for Applied Research (ECAR) survey of undergraduate technology used in the United States reports that 82.2% of undergraduates own a computer, with 80.5% owning a laptop. Web-enabled or smart phones are owned by 66.1% of undergraduate students, though not all use the features due to cost. Over 85% of students surveyed report using network resources for activities such as accessing social networking sites, playing online multiuser computer games, or accessing virtual worlds (Salaway & Caruso, 2008). Video game use has become a more diverse and popular form of entertainment than it was a decade ago. Games are not just for children, as nearly half (49%) of players are between the ages of 18 and 49. The gender divide in gamers has also greatly narrowed, with males making up 57% of online game players, and women at 43% (ESA, 2008). With the emergence of greater variety in
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
game style and genre, the market is embracing a diverse range of player motivations. The numbers found in the ESA surveys will continue to shift as the games industry evolves in inclusivity. The interest in gaming for educational purposes has also increased over the last decade, with researchers identifying key pedagogical features that make good video games inherently strong learning tools. What underlies the allure of games? As educational game researcher James Gee (2003) asks how do good game designers manage to get new players to learn their long, complex, and difficult games. A well-designed game entices players into the “reality” of the game world and keeps them there until the goals of the game have been met (Salen & Zimmerman, 2004). Gee points out that incorporating appropriate challenges that are “doable,” and other widely accepted effective learning principles that are supported by research in cognitive science, are in fact a large part of what makes good video games motivating and entertaining (Gee, 2004). James Gee (2007) has narrowed down the list of pedagogical strengths to thirteen principles that link good games to good learning, emphasizing the areas of learning empowerment, problem solving, and understanding. High-quality games cycle players through new content, encouraging the player to try different ways of learning and thinking (Gee, 2003). A well-designed game doesn’t distinguish between learning and playing, rather, players refine and add to their skill sets as the game progresses (Gee, 2004). When a player is successful in-game, the game expertise is linked to ‘expert’ behaviors such as self-monitoring, pattern recognition, high-level problem recognition and solving, principled decision-making, qualitative thinking, and superior use of both short and long term memory (VanDeventer & White, 2002). Popular video games like World of Warcraft emphasize cooperation and leadership rather than individual competition for the highest score (typical of arcade games, for example). These video games reward creative problem solving,
multitasking, collaboration, experimentation, and stimulate the creation of models (Steinkuehler, 2004). The instant feedback and risk-free environment invite exploration and experimentation, stimulating curiosity, discovery learning and perseverance (Kirriemuir, 2002). Learning how to learn becomes an essential skill and the speed and dexterity developed playing video games becomes an added-value. Social skills are also important: to be a guild master in a game like World of Warcraft, a player needs to be able to create a vision, recruit and inspire people, and organize the group’s strategy. And while the game industry has recognized and embraced such learning fundamentals, weaving them into design to increase value to the player, educational institutions have yet to fully recognize and integrate these models. From another standpoint, the methodology of Open and Distance Learning (ODL) is now widely based on the e-learning model, a technology-based model that has emerged as a serious contender to help support the learning needs of individuals in this day and age. According to Klopfer (2008), “e-learning itself can mean many things to many people and at its core simply means electronically supported learning, which can be online, on desktop PCs, or even on mobile devices (though the latter is sometimes referred to as m-learning). In practice e-learning often means delivery of information and content to learners through online hypertext, accompanied by images, audio, and video. But e-learning can mean much more, as evidenced by the recent surge of interest in using video games to teach everything from basic math skills for young learners to advanced communication skills for adults.“ (p. 8). For students, the major motivation for enrolling in distance education is not the technology or the network access capability, but the freedom that allows students to move through a course of studies at a time and pace of their choice (Anderson, 2008). Today, improvements in the processing power of mobile computers combined with networked media applications provide a tremendous opportunity for
69
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
novel approaches to online learning that go well beyond the use of Learning Management Systems (LMS). Relevant examples are Personal Learning Environments (PLE) that enable individuals to access, aggregate, configure and manipulate digital artifacts in the context of ongoing learning experiences. The power of these new virtual learning environments lies in creating (hyper)spaces that give users a sense of learning by doing, or, in the case of games, learning by playing. There is reason to believe that learner-driven demand and anticipated boost in effectiveness will facilitate an increasing uptake of serious games in the short term, even if simulations have a longer association of its use to support education and training – namely in applications for business, health, and military training. In any scenario, institutions and educators will need extra support when selecting, repurposing and using games or simulations in their practice, often trying to overcome factors such as time pressure, lack of experience, shortage of resources, etc. In many cases off-the-shelf games can be successfully introduced into educational processes, always a good decision as the creation of high quality educational games has a prohibitive cost. Therefore the access to tools and frameworks that may help in the process will benefit the stakeholders in any ODL organization. For instance, US military have considered the use of a framework for the use of Massive Multiplayer Online Gaming in Military Training and Education (Bonk & Dennen, 2005). In another case, a framework for evaluating games- and simulation-based education in general has been proposed by De Freitas & Oliver (2006) indicating the main pedagogical requirements. In a similar approach, a study by Moreno-Ger et al. (2008) proposes a set of educational game design guidelines, namely: choosing an appropriate genre, adding assessment and adaptation to the design and integration with an online environment. But we were not able to find yet a comprehensive framework for the selection, repurposing, design
70
and implementation of games and simulations in ODL courses, so this became our main goal. In the next section we start by analyzing the potential for the use of games and simulations in distance education, and by discussing their benefits and shortcomings in this context. Next we introduce the AIDLET framework for the selection, repurposing, design and implementation of games and simulations, concentrating on the practical aspects of the processes involved. Finally, we verify the AIDLET model against a taxonomy representing the main categories and genres of games, attempting to meet the requirements of distance education teachers, instructional designers and decision-makers.
THE POTENTIAL OF GAMES IN ODL It has been established that Open and Distance Learning (ODL) institutions hold great potential for the instruction of a broad and diversified range of learners. It has also been established that well-designed interactive media tools such as games, simulations, and virtual environments may provide learners with relevant and engaging paths to content mastery. The next step is to bring the two together. But overcoming the technology gap between learners and institutions is just one aspect of the problem. Traditional ODL pedagogy has to be reformulated, not just accommodating the latest technology but also enabling rich social interaction, enhancing group work and communication within educational settings. Many educational researchers today would define learning as a multidimensional construct of learning skills and cognitive learning results, for instance, procedural, normative and strategic knowledge, and attitude (Pivec & Dziabenko, 2004). Academic and life success require not just the accumulation of facts and conceptual understandings, but also attitudes, dispositions, and values that are aligned with those of science. Learning is, from this perspective, about building up knowledge, skills, beliefs
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
and attitudes that together, form an identity as someone who is a capable consumer, and perhaps even producer of scientific knowledge. Some have even speculated that this “identity-level” is a good way for educators to think about transfer. Perhaps if students experience the development of identities as competent performers in science, acquiring knowledge, skills, and beliefs congruent with those valued by various scientific communities, they will take on these practices outside of formal school contexts. So, in line with the use of new digital media, a current tendency in education acknowledges the emergence of new learning experiences that games may turn out and seeks to understand their consequences for how we think, act, play, and learn (Shaffer et al., 2005).
Convergence of Learning Modes In the last decade the classroom mode and the distance learning mode have been converging, in part due to the success of many e-learning experiences, based on the progress in information and communication technologies and their permeating all learning environments in most developed countries. Using computers and accessing the Web in schools and universities, taking advantage of quality learning products in digital format, linking institutions with broadband connections, using Web 2.0 networking applications, all create favorable conditions for increasing student autonomy and learning effectiveness (Moore & Anderson, 2003). But this also creates a shift in teacher’s profiles and roles: the ability to virtually experience events in shared spaces determines that they become mediators between students and the information provided by a variety of sources, rather than being the exclusive owners of knowledge to be transmitted. Globally, the implications of this re-conception of education, as a mobile and flexible exchange of ideas in a broad context, are profound. It goes beyond the traditional view of instruction as the transmission or construction of knowledge within
the constraints set by a curriculum, to replace it with an ongoing process of learning through continual exploration and negotiation. As Don Tapscott (2008) puts it: “Educators should take note. The current model of pedagogy is teacher focused, one-way, one size fits all. It isolates the student in the learning process. Many Net Geners learn more by collaborating—both with their teacher and with each other. They’ll respond to the new model of education that’s beginning to surface—student-focused and multiway, which is customized and collaborative.” (p. 108). We would just add that learning in this way is in fact pervasive or ubiquitous education. This means that education is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, anywhere, and anytime. Pervasive learning is also a social process that connects learners to communities of devices, people, and society so that students can construct relevant and meaningful learning experiences, author specific content (text, images, audio, video), in locations and at times that they find meaningful and relevant. So, for the most part, distance learning has become a way of life for students wherever they are. For the institutions this is good news, as for the first time in history we have educational technologies that cost nothing to governments and schools: smartphones and mobile computers (most students have one), networking software (freely available, e.g., Facebook, Twitter, Skype), learning applications (increasingly available, often for free e.g., Apple Store) and open educational resources (freely available, e.g., MIT – OCW, Stanford). On top of this, there are many other free tools available for personal learning environments, such as collaborative tools (e.g., blogs, wikis, authoring software), immersive environments (e.g., virtual worlds like Second Life), media production and distribution tools, and so on. There is an old adage of distance education research that states: ‘It is not technologies with inherent pedagogical qualities that are successful in distance education, but technologies that are generally available to citizens’ (Dias et al., 2008).
71
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
I this context we argue that the transformation of ODL curriculum and instruction processes must be based on the new digital media capabilities and its patterns of use by students, namely through interactive and rich content embedded in game-like learning experiences. For this to take place we also propose the integration of games and simulations with the existing e-learning standards and platforms used for online education. Ideally, these educational games should be able to coexist in environments that follow the learning objects model and have elevated pedagogical value (Moreno-Ger et al., 2008).
Learning Attributes of Games But what is the real potential for the integration of games and simulations in distance education? What are the expected benefits and shortcomings in this specific learning context? It may be important to note that not all games do all things. Certain game styles and formats may lend themselves better to different sorts of players and objectives. For example, there are different player experiences in single vs. multiplayer games, but no one is superior for learning per se. It depends on what the specific learning goals and player behaviors are. Also, much like other entertainment industries, games are experiencing genre shifts as developers take specific traits from multiple game styles to achieve desired systems and play experiences. It is for these reasons that the attributes and styles cannot be put nicely in “boxes”, or fit a precise matrix for that matter. There is considerable overlap. The goal of the AIDLET model is to provide a planning framework for development and inclusion of game environments for learning, taking into account familiar attributes of commonly referred to game subtypes. Let’s start first by identifying the broader categories of games referenced in educational game studies:
72
Edutainment Games These are games that usually combine education and entertainment in a package that highlights intended educational outcomes targeted at specific groups of learner, very often targeted as youth and children’s games. Most edutainment games currently in the market are not supported by empirical learning evidence and thus it’s difficult to integrate them in an effective educational program.
Serious Games These are games with many of the characteristics of entertainment games but with intended educational outcomes targeted at specific groups of learners. The “serious” adjective is generally applied to refer to products used by industries like defense, education, scientific exploration, health care, management, city planning, engineering, religion, and politics. Put simply, these are games with a serious purpose; the games may include First Person Shooters (FPS), Role-playing Games (RPG), Real Time Strategy (RTS) games, and Massively Multiplayer Online Games (also called MMOG or simply MMO). In most cases, these are the games that will better integrate with the ODL workflow.
Location Aware Games This rather new designation usually refers to virtual experiences played out in real world spaces. This last aspect makes the difference and identifies the genre more specifically. In general, contextualized clues can only be discovered via real world spaces with the aid of GPS devices that are becoming common amongst students these days. Unfortunately, even with the advantage of involving students in authentic real world tasks, participation in groups, and frequent interaction and feedback, these games are difficult to integrate in an ODL workflow because e-learning students are far away and dispersed geographically.
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
Global Reach Games Also a recent phenomenon, exampled by games such as World of Warcraft or Everquest. The term covers any video game capable of supporting hundreds or thousands of players simultaneously. These by inevitability are played on the Internet and feature at least one persistent world. In the case of Second Life, which is not a game per se, we can consider the existence of a virtual world with a game-like society of users. Many types of games can be set up in a virtual world and take full advantage of a 3D environment with its realistic interaction modes. In an effort to identify more distinctive learning attributes of games we must take a look at the design specificity and comparative merits of games’ categories and genres. In many cases they extend and overlap to create mixed categories/ genres. The potential for integration in a typical ODL workflow is discussed.
Traditional and Casual Games Chess, solitaire, and card games, whether traditional or game specific, are examples of such games. Other casual games are commonly deployed online, and offer movement in 2D or 3D space with obstacles to overcome. Timing is sometimes critical, with heavy reliance on motor skills, memory, and planning. Themes may vary from games that expand concepts, such as the food chain, set matching, etc. to card games aimed at teaching math, animal, and plant species. Other games in this genre have shown potential for involving math and physics, for example, games such as World of Goo and Crayon Physics. Because these games were not developed specifically for education, the behaviors are not mapped directly to learning objectives. However, the player behaviors do support the kinds of scientific thinking practices that educational game environments tend to foster. Potential in this genre exists for games that support systems
engineering and computing concepts. The Flash technology can be used to easily produce cards or other digital artifacts for ODL.
Shooting /Action These games can include First Person Shooters (FPS) or other fighting games. The game scenarios may exist within a broader narrative framework, and are presented from a first person perspective. In shooter games, players typically aim and fire at moving objects to destroy them. This involves the development of fast hand to eye coordination and may be important in training areas associated with the police or military. In most cases the player operates virtual mechanical devices and has to accomplish some objective (e. g. drive a vehicle, fire a weapon or use a tool). Shooter and fighting games may be played solo, or designed for team collaboration. Military strategy games in these genres may also include cultural learning objectives, using local cues to engage with others in-game to accomplish missions. These games can be used in ODL as a drill-and-practice component of a course, for example, in engineering, sports, or military training. Team development objectives can also be met through multi-player modes.
Adventure Games The adventures or quests offer a series of challenges usually within a detailed framework. Most adventure games do not rely on speed or “twitch” play for success. A classic example in this genre is the interactive fiction game Myst. The tasks in the game may be relevant to the curriculum and the learning process, often in terms of motivation, as in the case of Sid Meyer’s Civilization, a widely popular and researched game that involves geography, history, and politics (also falling within the strategy genre). There is definitely room for the deployment of this kind of games in distance education.
73
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
Role-Playing Games A Role-Playing Game (RPG) is a game in which the participants assume the roles of fictional characters. Drawing from original RPGs like Dungeons and Dragons, players inhabit a role with status and responsibility within a shared context, and in which the context is defined by a set of rules. The educational function of RPGs may be extensive. Players in educational RPGs may establish the actions of their characters (e.g., lawyers or politicians) based on their characterization, and the actions succeed or fail according to a formal system of rules and guidelines. This may be interesting for many ODL courses requiring students to learn those kinds of skills and the related tacit knowledge. This is also very useful for learners to practice behaviors in an environment that provides clear consequences based on the context and rules of the game world.
Strategy Games Sometimes called Real Time Strategy (RTS) games, this genre of video games emphasizes skillful thinking and planning to achieve a goal. They involve strategic, tactical, and sometimes logistical challenges. There are many good examples of this type of games, in the areas of history, economy, management, ecology, society, etc. Typically these games involve multiple challenges and are aimed at developing problem-based skills. Some very popular and successful titles are: Civilization and Age of Empires. These are very expensive games to design and produce but some of the themes and inherent characteristics of those commercially available may be interesting for specific ODL courses.
Simulation Games For a game to be considered a simulation game, as opposed to a pure simulation or a virtual world, a game system must exist in which the player has a
74
role and specific objectives. In simulation games, the player operates a model or simulation that behaves according to a programmed set of rules. Many simulation games focus on some element of realism, thus forcing players to understand and remember complex principles and relations and progress by trial-and-error. These often very expensive games can teach anything, from flying a plane up in the sky to steering a submarine deep in the ocean. Typical examples are Flight Simulator and Train Simulator. Another is SimCity, a popular mainstream title that has been used for educational purposes. Social simulation games are also a large component in the simulation genre, with Will Wright’s The Sims the most widely recognized title. Another recent (and free) simulation game for Business Project Management training is INNOV8, developed by IBM a few years ago and now reaching version 2 (IBM, 2009). These kinds of simulation games are often suitable for online cooperative work and thus very apt for integration in ODL.
Modeling Games Modeling is often a component of the game rather than the game in itself, and usually is tied with other types of games (action, strategy, simulation, programming, etc.). For example, some car racing titles involve creating a track or building the car before you can race it. This genre is also linked with programming games, as learners may create the models before they are able to program them. Examples include robots, cars, bikes, machines, factories, companies, electronic devices, etc.
Programming Games A programming game is basically a computer game where the player has no direct influence on the course of the game. Instead, a computer program or scripts are written in some domain-specific programming language in order to control the actions of the characters, often robots, tanks or
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
bacteria, which seek to destroy each other. Many programming games are considered environments full of digital organisms, related to artificial life simulations. Games that enable users to build microworlds have been created at the MIT MediaLab, and extensive research has been published on this (e.g., programming of Lego robots and Logo projects). The potential for use in ODL is great and technology is often freely available.
Massively Multiplayer Online Games A Massively Multiplayer Online Game (also called MMOG or simply MMO) is a game capable of supporting hundreds or thousands of players simultaneously. The most accomplished and famous MMO is World of Warcraft, with many millions of players all over the world, but in education this is a hard choice to make due to enormous technological demands (software, servers, technical support, etc.). Nevertheless, there are a few multiplayer games with educational intentions, in one example (MEGG - http://www.cybertrain.info/megg.html) there is capability to build an online multiplayer educational game on any theme, with menus, text, graphics and multiple choice quiz banks.
Virtual Worlds Virtual worlds are one of the newer developments on the Internet, with Second Life being the most well known. The unique qualities of 3D virtual worlds can provide opportunities for rich sensory immersive experiences, with authentic contexts and activities for experiential learning, simulation and role-play, including the creation of complex environments and scenarios. Hundreds of university systems around the world use the Second Life Grid™ as a lively part of their educational programs. Many of the previous types of games can be set up in a virtual world and take full advantage of a 3D environment and its realistic interaction modes. One recent example is SLOODLE Game
Show, an open source game for Second Life (http:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRVVrAp_64U)
Layered Reality Games These games are representative of a new set of experiences that consists of roughly three different categories of games: Augmented Reality Games, Hybrid Reality Games, and Alternate Reality Games, mostly involving active engagement, participation in groups, frequent interaction and feedback, and connections to real world contexts via GPS. This last aspect makes the difference and identifies the genre more specifically but implies that these games are more difficult to integrate in the ODL workflow. In general, research shows that learning through games is possible by immersing players in relevant experiences, by modeling expert problem solving, by providing guidelines to solve a problem, and by structuring problems so that the player builds on previous knowledge, which are all features of powerful and well designed learning environments (Bransford et al., 2000; Gee, 2003). On a less positive note, according to Huntington (2006), there are obvious barriers to the development or adoption of educational games in general. For instance: •
•
•
High development costs in an uncertain market makes investment in educational gaming innovations too risky for the commercial video game producers and even the educational materials industries. Change in institutions comes slowly in terms of adopting any new innovations and as do making the necessary organization and instructions changes that allow use of new learning technologies. There is unwillingness on the part of institutions to give up textbooks in order to purchase educational gaming products.
75
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
•
•
•
•
The specific educational values that are tied to established standards have not been proven through in-depth research. Some parents and teachers have very negative attitudes about the use of videogames in the classroom. Games are especially good at teaching higher order skills, which are not typically assessed in standard examinations. Access to computers is sometimes so low that it can’t play a mainstream role in student learning (the case of many developing countries).
But the application of games in education requires more than just their availability and adequacy, a new educational perspective is needed. Squire (2008) suggests the following scenario: envisage for a second that you are a teacher or instructional designer, charged with developing an advanced science course, covering a few hundred new terms, facts and concepts. How would you go about designing materials that handles these concepts? What kinds of experiences would you want learners to have? How would you pace them and how would you know if they truly mastered what you needed them to learn? These questions, which may seem traditionally the domain of instructional technologists, are also relevant for video game designers. As games get longer and more complex, designers devise ways to “teach the player” to see and act in particular ways. Whereas educational technologists ask if education can happen at a distance, gamers show you that it already does, as game designers and distributed game communities help them become better players. Part of what is interesting about contemporary video games is how experiences are ordered so that players are “taught” the game through the careful construction of levels, missions, and interactions. Few, if any, of the so called “serious games” or even research prototypes that have been made, to the best of our knowledge, take advantage of most of these design principles.
76
How is assessment defined? In games that are designed for learning play behaviors are mapped to the specific actions that relate to the learning goals. Other design considerations that promote attainment of educational goals include deciding how pass and fail states map to desired player performance. Games’ environments designed for specific learning goals may also include threshold points in-game, much like educational threshold concepts are gatekeepers for understanding future content, game threshold points can be designed to scaffold player skill and require player mastery of certain behaviors before progressing in the game world. Games also provide opportunities for learning from feedback loops. As players are evaluated on their performance, feedback loops help guide player behavior towards desired outcomes. In this way, the development of the game system will support player progress in both micro and macro objectives. Assessment instruments may include capture logs of player performance in situ, recordings of student performance, and discourse analyses of students’ work in game play. Other documents emerging from the game (including students’ writing, illustrations, or digital representations) can be analyzed to identify how their thinking is (and is not) affected by the game experience.
THE AIDLET MODEL In a more pragmatic way, considering the current educational context, to attain high quality learning results based on constantly connected, highly interactive, and fully mobile media environments, the right teachers, materials, methods, and games have to be found. But this may be a rather costly and challenging proposition for many ODL organizations as it involves: investment in new information and communication technology (mildly expensive), faculty and tutor re-training (time and capital intensive), development of engaging digital materials (games and simulations
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
may be expensive), review of internal processes (habits are difficult to change) and, last but not least, establishment of a credible and high quality brand name (as online learning is often regarded as a kind of lower-grade education, not to mention games-based learning). However, even with the adoption of new digital media, games and simulations, we must accept the fact that not all knowledge can be acquired through distance learning. In some cases it is not suitable for acquiring all the necessary skills, for example in: • • • •
health sciences, especially surgery and hospital practice; experimental sciences, which require laboratory practice; applied psychology, involving direct interpersonal experience; court training in law, about oratory and argumentation.
A way to overcome this difficulty is to separate theoretical content from the corresponding practical component. The former may be taught in distance learning mode, and, to a certain extent, practice may be supported by VR applications, simulations and games representing real situations (Bidarra & Cardoso, 2007). On that note, Starr (1994) argues that simulations – the process of setting up scenarios and exploring under what conditions they might work – are at the core of business, government and science. For many years researchers have studied the uses of simulations in education and established that well-designed simulations will develop in the student a profound, flexible, spontaneous, kinesthetic understanding of the subject matter (Gibson et al., 2007, Issenberg, 2006, Teodoro, 2004, Kezunovic et al., 2004). Squire & Giovanetto (2008) argue that when considering the higher education of gaming, a core intellectual feature of a twenty-first-century educational system should include inroads into participation in cultures of simulation. In fact, students who learn by means of simulations can
improvise better in real world contexts. They can handle unexpected situations with ease and knowledge learnt is not structured around a set of norms or processes but developed from intrinsic personal experience. This is the kind of knowledge students retain for a long time. Unquestionably, today video games are the individual’s primary exposure to this important way of thinking. And in the probable scenario that games/simulations may not be developed or cannot be applied, online learning can be made more game-like (Gee, 2003) in an attempt to change the inflexible and prescriptive models in use today.
Dealing with the Issues Based on our observations and on data collected we consolidated a clear-cut framework to assist ODL teachers, instructional designers and managers in making the right decisions about the adoption and use of educational games and simulations. But for a framework or toolkit to be effective, no matter how simple or practical it is, a particular learning context has to be defined. Previous research by De Freitas & Oliver (2006), on the kinds of questions facing tutors when thinking of introducing games- and simulation-based learning into their practice, relied on some interesting questions: Which game or simulation to select for the specific learning context? Which pedagogic approaches to use to support learning outcomes and activities? What is the validity of using the chosen game or simulation? So, trying to answer those questions, our research started by exploring real world practices and went on identifying the main concepts and activities that defined those practices, in the belief that a certain way of thinking and doing could be derived and applied to new situations. For instance, the traditional classroom environment, where an instructor can guide the activity of the
77
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
students, is very different from the online educational environment in which specific game genres have to be identified and suitable frameworks set (Moreno-Ger et al., 2008). So, in the case of ODL we were confronted with the existence of three main groups of requirements: the definition of an approach closely linked to educational content specifications, the repurposing of existing game/ simulation titles or the design and development of specific games/simulations, and the integration of games/simulations in the ODL workflow. The framework we propose builds on these requirements and is rooted in research previously conducted into conventional teaching/learning with games (Prensky, Gee, Gibson, Jenkins, Squire, etc.), all sharing essential features such as students, teachers, and resources; but in this model we had to go beyond that by explicitly addressing the requirements imposed by the typical context of Distance Education. A relation may be established with the ACTIONS model (Bates, 1995, 2000), a media selection and evaluation framework often used in ODL studies. ‘ACTIONS’ is the acronym for seven main criteria that Bates proposes for selecting a specific learning technology, namely: access, cost, teaching and learning implications, interaction, organizational issues, novelty and speed. In this model he uses a pragmatic approach to the effective costs of technologies, and relates these to other important features that are relevant for decision-makers. The fundamental principle is still valid today: educational technologies are not good or bad, it’s the way they are used that dictates the success or failure of a project. The same can be said of the application of games and simulations in ODL.
Applying the Model The chief benefit of using a conceptual model for instructional design is that common pitfalls can be avoided. So, our purpose is twofold: (1) to help distance education teachers and instructional designers in the implementation of game- and
78
simulation- based learning, and (2) to support ODL organizations and decision-makers in the process of choosing the right tools and methodologies. Of course, an overall educational strategy must be in place, indicating the materials and learning objectives (content), the ways to choose, validate, organize, and present content (curriculum & instruction), the individual attention offered to each student (tutoring), the grading and confirmation of a level of competency (assessment), and the creation of peer groups that both make learning more effective and engaging (learning community). The framework we propose tries to beat the shortcomings of other models, not specifically tailored for the use of games in distance education, by introducing a six-dimensional model with the acronym ‘AIDLET’, addressing issues related to availability and cost, interaction and communication capabilities, distance education workflow integration, learning design potential, engagement and ease of play, thematic value and adequacy (summarized in Table 1). The six steps provide main criteria for consideration, certainly not intended as prescriptive, allowing for practitioners to be more critical about how they implant games and simulations into their courses. With this basis, teachers, designers and decision-makers may develop their own metrics for introducing games and simulations in specific educational programs. The key-aspects of the model may be described as follows:
Availability and Cost The widespread use of games as entertainment is a known fact but it doesn’t mean that games in general are effective for learning purposes. Some games can be selected and used to assist the learning process and others have to be designed from scratch to support a specific course. The first decision is whether to consider the repurposing of an existing title or the development of a new one. There are basically three options: buy an “off-the-shelf” title, contract with a development
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
Table 1. The AIDLET Model for selection and implementation of games in ODL AIDLET Model
Questions
Availability and cost
Is there an adequate game for the organization and for the learners? What is the cost? If the available version is not suitable, can it be modified? The game or simulation has to be developed from scratch? At what cost? What is the unit cost per student?
Interaction and communication capabilities
The game is state-of-the art in terms of concept, interface and design? Is it Web 2.0 ready? The interaction and communication features are adequate for learning?
Distance education workflow integration
Does it integrate with ODL practice and workflow? What kinds of connections can be made to other ODL tools and media?
Learning design potential
What kinds of learning are supported? What instructional approaches are possible within the constraints of the game/simulation? What other technologies can be integrated in supporting teaching and learning?
Engagement and ease of play
Are the game characteristics engaging and user-friendy? Is it accessible to teachers and students less experienced in games? How long does it take to master the basics of the game?
Thematic value and adequacy
Can the game content be used without any side effects? Are the themes appropriate? What social skills does the game develop? Are these congruent with cultural, societal and organizational values?
firm or get in-house production. The costs are very different and tend to increase from the first to the latter. There is no stable and robust model to use here as it all depends on the instructional design to be used and the budget on hand. For instance, learning history with Sid Meyer’s Civilization is quite inexpensive, because the title is widely available at affordable prices, while developing a game for a new course on telecommunications surely has a prohibitive price.
Interaction and Communication Capabilities Games and simulations are by definition very interactive yet not all of them support useful educational interaction that leads to effective learning. Furthermore, the quantity of interaction that is possible with a system does not guarantee the quality of the interaction in terms of attaining learning goals. A sense of security and progress is important and depends on broad agreement both on the ends to be pursued and on the means to achieve them. The design of the interaction is vital to the success of the game/simulation as
these are initial requirements that make or break the deal. A poorly made design will never be used by students no matter the amount of research and development that was spent in the project. Also the essential Web 2.0 features of current applications are important to enable connection with other people and resources not only for support, as is usually the case to tackle technical problems, but to achieve a strong motivation and a multiplying effect that facilitates learning. The current boom in social networking is a solid indicator of this requirement.
Distance Education Workflow Integration Learning with the new digital tools really implies much more than just using intensively a given set of applications: it comprises all the human factors and qualified work involved in conceiving appropriate learning materials, devising a sound pedagogical strategy, providing each student with efficient support, assessing individual progress, grading students, and certifying their final results. So many questions arise: how games and simu-
79
Games and Simulations in Distance Learning
lations integrate with the usual ODL workflow? How do we monitor student’s activity? What if the students do not visit all the areas in the game/ simulation? What if they wander around wasting time? How much time and effort is necessary to accomplish all the tasks? How do we assess the students? Etc. Of course, there is no ready answer to these questions; the idea is to figure out the answers specific to each project before going any further.
Learning Design Potential The best way to see the instructional benefits of games and simulations is to evaluate how they are used in education. For example, evaluating the performance of titles in the so-called “Serious Games” genre, namely, investigating the kinds of learning that may be supported, the instructional strategies that are possible within each game constraints, the e-learning platforms and technologies that are compatible. Only when students feel comfortable with the online environment and the technology provided will they be able to study and contribute. On the other hand, excessive involvement with games and simulations may damage the interaction with other course content and the interaction with people, and this certainly needs to be monitored closely. Another pragmatic way is to consider typical game-based learning scenarios to be developed, where synchronous or asynchronous online communications may be used:
Synchronous Scenarios • • • • • • •
80
Training of dialogue and articulation Leading and conducting meetings Courtroom conferencing and interaction Business conferencing and interaction Collaborative design in architecture Health professional interaction practice Surgery and operation theater practice
Asynchronous Scenarios • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Dynamic learning activities (e.g., driving a vehicle, operating a machine) Active exploratory learning (e.g., archeology, history, CSI, detective work) Goal oriented brainstorming (e.g., advertising, marketing) Policy decision making (e.g., business, government, orgs) Business decision making (e.g., marketing, sales, operational) Process management (e.g., commerce, industry, communications) Strategic planning (e.g., business, government, orgs) Case study (e.g., business, sociology, health, ICT) Experiential activities (e.g., laboratory, field trip) Debating relevant issues (e.g., policy, business, academia) Science modeling (e.g., chemistry, engineering)