Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 1
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Related titles: Non-crimp fabric composites (ISBN 978-1-84569-762-4) Non-crimp fabric (NCF) composites are composites that are reinforced with woven mats of straight (non-crimped) fibres. Straight fibres deform much less under tension. NCF composites are being used in applications in the aerospace, automotive, civil engineering and wind turbine sector where strength is important. Non-crimp fabric composites reviews production, properties and applications of this important class of composites. Interface engineering of natural fibre composites for maximum performance (ISBN 978-1-84569-742-6) There is a growing trend towards the use of natural (sustainable) fibres as reinforcements in composites. One of the major mechanisms of failure in such composites is the breakdown of the bond or interface between the reinforcement fibres and the matrix. When this happens, the composite loses strength and fails. By engineering the interface between fibres and the matrix, the properties of the composite can be manipulated to give maximum performance. This book reviews both processing and surface treatments to improve interfacial adhesion in natural fibre composites as well as ways of testing their resulting properties. Polymer carbon nanotube composites (ISBN 978-1-84569-761-7) Polymer carbon nanotube composites reviews the use of carbon nanotubes as reinforcements in a polymer matrix, creating a new class of nanocomposites with useful properties and wide potential applications. Part I discusses preparation and processing techniques. Part II analyses key properties and ways of characterising polymer carbon nanotube composites. The final part of the book covers some of the important applications of this new group of materials. Details of these and other Woodhead Publishing materials books can be obtained by: ∑ visiting our web site at www.woodheadpublishing.com ∑ contacting Customer Services (e-mail:
[email protected]; fax: +44 (0) 1223 832819; tel.: +44 (0) 1223 499140 ext. 130; address: Woodhead Publishing Limited, 80 High Street, Sawston, Cambridge CB22 3HJ, UK) ∑ contacting our US office (e-mail:
[email protected]; tel. (215) 928 9112; address: Woodhead Publishing, 1518 Walnut Street, Suite 1100, Philadelphia, PA 19102-3406, USA) If you would like to receive information on forthcoming titles, please send your address details to: Francis Dodds (address, tel. and fax as above; e-mail: francis.
[email protected]). Please confirm which subject areas you are interested in.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 2
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance Edited by Philippe Boisse
Oxford
Cambridge
Philadelphia
New Delhi
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 3
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited, 80 High Street, Sawston, Cambridge CB22 3HJ, UK www.woodheadpublishing.com Woodhead Publishing, 1518 Walnut Street, Suite 1100, Philadelphia, PA 19102-3406, USA Woodhead Publishing India Private Limited, G-2, Vardaan House, 7/28 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi – 110002, India www.woodheadpublishingindia.com First published 2011, Woodhead Publishing Limited © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publisher, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited. The consent of Woodhead Publishing Limited does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing Limited for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Control Number: 2011935449 ISBN 978-1-84569-965-9 (print) ISBN 978-0-85709-371-4 (online) The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp which is processed using acid-free and elemental chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards. Typeset by Replika Press Pvt Ltd, India Printed by TJI Digital, Padstow, Cornwall, UK
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 4
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contents
Contributor contact details
Part I Materials for reinforcements in composites
xiii 1
1
Fibres for composite reinforcement: properties and microstructures
A. R. Bunsell, Mines ParisTech, France
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10
Introduction Fineness, units, flexibility and strength Comparison of materials Organic fibres Glass fibres Chemical vapour deposition (CVD) monofilaments Carbon fibres Small-diameter ceramic fibres Conclusions References
3 4 6 8 17 19 22 27 30 30
2
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
32
A. W. K. Ma, University of Connecticut, USA and F. Chinesta, Ecole Centrale de Nantes, France
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) Carbon nanotube (CNT) polymer composites Performance and applications References
32 36 46 47
3
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
51
J. Lamon, CNRS/National Institute of Applied Science (INSA Lyon), France
3.1 3.2
Introduction Ceramic fibers: general features
3
51 53
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 5
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
vi
Contents
3.3 3.4 3.5
Fracture strength: statistical features Mechanical behavior at high temperatures Fiber–matrix interfaces: influence on mechanical behavior Mechanical behavior of composites: influence of fibers and interfaces Conclusion References
3.6 3.7 3.8
57 64 73 74 81 82
Part II Structures for reinforcements in composites
87
4
Woven reinforcements for composites
89
D. Coupé, Snecma Propulsion Solide, France
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7
Introduction: from the beginning of wearing to technical applications Technology description Woven fabric definitions Applications for composite reinforcements Conclusion and future trends Acknowledgment Sources of further information and advice
89 90 100 113 114 115 115
5
Braided reinforcements for composites
116
A. Gessler, EADS Deutschland GmbH, Germany
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12
Introduction Fundamentals of braiding Braiding technologies for preforming Key parameters for using braiding machines Characteristics and properties of braided textiles Mandrel technologies Further processing Typical applications Limitations and drawbacks Future trends Sources of further information and advice Reference
116 116 120 134 136 144 149 151 154 155 155 156
6
Three-dimensional (3D) fibre reinforcements for composites
157
A. P. Mouritz, RMIT University, Australia
6.1 6.2
Introduction Manufacture of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites
157 160
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 6
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contents
6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.10 6.11
Microstructure of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Delamination fracture of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Impact damage resistance and tolerance of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Through-thickness stiffness and strength of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Through-thickness thermal properties of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites In-plane mechanical properties of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Joint properties of three-dimensional (3D) fibre composites Conclusions References
7
Modelling the geometry of textile reinforcements for composites: WiseTex
S. V. Lomov, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium
7.1 7.2
Introduction Generic data structure for description of internal geometry of textile reinforcement Geometrical description of specific types of reinforcements Geometrical model as a pre-processor for prediction of mechanical properties of the reinforcement Conclusion References
7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 8
Modelling the geometry of textile reinforcements for composites: TexGen
A. C. Long and L. P. Brown, University of Nottingham, UK
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7
Introduction: rationale and background to TexGen Implementation Modelling theory Rendering and export of model Applications Future trends References
vii
168 175 183 184 186 187 195 196 197 200 200 202 204 225 232 235 239 239 240 246 254 257 262 263
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 7
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
viii
Contents
Part III Properties of composite reinforcements
265
9
In-plane shear properties of woven fabric reinforced composites
J. Cao, Northwestern University, USA, J. Chen, University of Massachusetts at Lowell, USA and X. Q. Peng, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, P. R. China
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8 9.9
Introduction Fabric properties Experimental setups of the trellis-frame test Experimental results of the trellis-frame test Experimental setups of the bias extension test Experimental results of the bias extension test Conclusions Acknowledgments References
267 270 270 280 286 294 298 301 301
10
Biaxial tensile properties of reinforcements in composites
306
V. Carvelli, Politecnico di Milano, Italy
10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6
Introduction Experimental analysis Analytical model Numerical modelling Conclusions References
306 308 318 324 328 329
11
Transverse compression properties of composite reinforcements
333
P. A. Kelly, The University of Auckland, New Zealand
11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6
Introduction Transverse compression of composite reinforcements Inelastic response of fibrous materials Inelastic models of reinforcement compression Future trends References and further reading
333 334 344 351 359 360 367
12
Bending properties of reinforcements in composites
E. de Bilbao, Institut Universitaire de Technologie d’Orléans, France
12.1 12.2 12.3
Context Improved cantilever test Results and discussion
267
367 375 383
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 8
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contents
12.4 12.5 12.6
Conclusions Acknowledgement References
392 393 393 397
13
Friction properties of reinforcements in composites
J. L. Gorczyca, K. A. Fetfatsidis and J. A. Sherwood, University of Massachusetts at Lowell, USA
13.1 13.2 13.3
Introduction Theory Testing methodologies (static and dynamic friction coefficients) Experimental data Modeling of thermostamping Conclusion References
13.4 13.5 13.6 13.7 14
Permeability properties of reinforcements in composites
V. Michaud, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Switzerland
14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 14.6 14.7
Introduction The permeability tensor Saturated permeability modelling for fibre preforms Unsaturated permeability modelling Permeability measurement methods Conclusion and future trends References and further reading
Part IV Characterising and modelling reinforcements in composites 15
Microscopic approaches for understanding the mechanical behaviour of reinforcements in composites
D. Durville, Ecole Centrale Paris/CNRS UMR 8579, France
15.1 15.2 15.3
Introduction Interests and goals of the approach at microscopic scale Modelling approach to textile composites at microscopic scale Application examples Conclusions References
15.4 15.5 15.6
ix
397 401 411 418 422 428 428 431
431 432 436 444 445 451 451
459
461 461 463 465 477 482 485
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 9
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
x
Contents
16
Mesoscopic approaches for understanding the mechanical behaviour of reinforcements in composites
E. Vidal-Sallé, INSA Lyon, France and G. Hivet, Polytech Orléans, France
16.1 16.2 16.3 16.4 16.5 16.6 16.7 16.8
Introduction Mechanical behaviour of the reinforcement Mechanical behaviour of the yarn Geometric modelling Behaviour identification and finite element modelling Finite element simulations, use and results Conclusions and future trends References
486 488 498 503 511 519 522 523
17
Continuous models for analyzing the mechanical behavior of reinforcements in composites
529
X. Q. Peng, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, P. R.China and J. Cao, Northwestern University, USA
17.1 17.2 17.3 17.4 17.5 17.6 17.7
Introduction Continuum mechanics-based non-orthogonal model Non-orthogonal constitutive model for woven fabrics Specific application for a plain weave composite fabric Validation of the non-orthogonal model General fiber-reinforced hyperelastic model Specific fiber-reinforced hyperelastic model for woven composite fabrics 17.8 Conclusions 17.9 Acknowledgment 17.10 References 18
X-ray tomography analysis of the mechanical behaviour of reinforcements in composites
P. Badel, Ecole des Mines de Saint-Etienne, France and E. Maire, INSA-Lyon, France
18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4
Introduction X-ray tomography of composite reinforcements Analyses of the structure of a textile reinforcement Application of the mechanical behaviour of woven reinforcements to finite element simulations Conclusion References
18.5 18.6
486
529 533 535 537 552 556 558 562 563 563 565
565 566 571 578 585 586
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 10
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contents
xi
19
Flow modeling in composite reinforcements
E. Ruiz and F. Trochu, École Polytechnique de l’Université de Montréal, Canada
588
19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4 19.5 19.6 19.7
Introduction Governing flow equations Analytical solution Numerical solution Application examples Conclusions References
588 589 591 594 603 613 613
20
Modelling short fibre polymer reinforcements for composites
616
P. Laure, Université de Nice-Sophia Antipolis, France and L. Silva and M. Vincent, Mines ParisTech, France
20.1 20.2 20.3 20.4 20.5 20.6
Introduction Observations Models Computation of fibre orientation in injection moulding Conclusions References and further reading
616 617 622 631 645 647
21
Modelling composite reinforcement forming processes
651
P. Boisse and N. Hamila, Université de Lyon, France
21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 21.5 21.6 21.7
Introduction A mesoscopic approach Continuous approaches The semi-discrete approach Discussion and conclusion Acknowledgements References
651 653 656 661 668 668 669
Index
672
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 11
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 12
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contributor contact details
(* = main contact)
Editor
Chapter 2
P. Boisse Université de Lyon LaMCoS Insa Lyon France
A. W. K. Ma* Institute of Materials Science/ Chemicals Materials and Biomolecular Engineering University of Connecticut 97 North Eagleville Road Storrs, CT 06269–3136 USA
E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 1
E-mail:
[email protected]
A. R. Bunsell Mines ParisTech (formerly Ecole des Mines de Paris) Centre des Matériaux BP 87 91003 Evry Cedex France E-mail:
[email protected]
F. Chinesta UMR CNRS Ecole Centrale de Nantes 1 rue de la Noe BP 92101 44321 Nantes Cedex 3 France
Chapter 3 J. Lamon CNRS/National Institute of Applied Science (INSA Lyon) MATEIS Laboratory 21 Avenue Jean Capelle 69621 Villeurbanne Cedex France E-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 13
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
xiv
Contributor contact details
Chapter 4
Chapter 7
D. Coupé Safran Group Snecma Propulsion Solide France
S. V. Lomov Department MTM Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Kasteelpark Arenberg, 44 B-3001 Leuven Belgium
AEC 112 Airport Drive Rochester, NH 03867 USA E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 5 A. Gessler EADS Deutschland GmbH Innovation Works 81663 München Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 6 A. P. Mouritz School of Aerospace, Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering RMIT University GPO Box 2476 Melbourne Victoria Australia 3000 E-mail:
[email protected]
E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 8 A. C. Long* and L. P. Brown Faculty of Engineering University of Nottingham University Park Nottingham NG7 2RD UK E-mail: Andrew.Long@nottingham. ac.uk Louise.Brown@nottingham. ac.uk
Chapter 9 J. Cao* Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Northwestern University 2145 Sheridan Rd Evanston, IL 60208-3111 USA E-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 14
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contributor contact details
J. Chen Advanced Composite Materials and Textile Research Laboratory Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Massachusetts at Lowell One University Avenue Lowell, MA 01854 USA
Chapter 11
E-mail:
[email protected]
E-mail:
[email protected]
X. Q. Peng Department of Plasticity Shanghai Jiao Tong University 1954 Huashan Road Shanghai P. R. China 200030
Chapter 12
E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 10 V. Carvelli Department of Structural Engineering Politecnico di Milano Piazza Leonardo da Vinci 32 20133 Milano Italy E-mail:
[email protected]
xv
P. A. Kelly Department of Engineering Science Faculty of Engineering University of Auckland Private Bag 92019 Auckland Mail Centre Auckland 1142 New Zealand
E. de Bilbao Institut Universitaire de Technologie d’Orléans Département Génie Mécanique et Productique 16 rue d’Issoudun BP 16729 45067 Orléans Cedex 2 France E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 13 J. L. Gorczyca, K. A. Fetfatsidis and J. A. Sherwood* Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Massachusetts at Lowell One University Avenue Lowell, MA 01854 USA E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Konstantine_Fetfatsidis@ student.uml.edu
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 15
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
xvi
Contributor contact details
Chapter 14
Chapter 17
V. Michaud Laboratoire de Technologie des Composites et Polymères (LTC) Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL) CH 1015 Lausanne Switzerland,
X. Q. Peng* Xiongqi Peng Department of Plasticity Shanghai Jiao Tong University 1954 Huashan Road Shanghai P. R. China 200030
E-mail:
[email protected]
E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 15 D. Durville MSSMat Laboratory Ecole Centrale Paris/ CNRS UMR 8579 Grande Voie des Vignes 92290 Châtenay-Malabry France E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 16 E. Vidal-Sallé* INSA Lyon LAMCOS – Bâtiment Joseph Jacquard 20 avenue Albert Einstein 69621 Villeurbanne Cedex France E-mail:
[email protected]
G. Hivet Polytech Orléans 8 rue Léonard de Vinci 45072 Orléans Cedex 2 France
J. Cao Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Northwestern University 2145 Sheridan Rd Evanston, IL 60208-3111 USA E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 18 P. Badel * Center for Health Engineering LCG CNRS UMR5146 Ecole des Mines de Saint-Etienne 158, cours Fauriel 42023 Saint-Etienne Cedex 2 France E-mail:
[email protected]
E. Maire Université de Lyon, CNRS INSA-Lyon MATEIS UMR5510 69621 Villeurbanne Cedex France E-mail:
[email protected]
E-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 16
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
Contributor contact details
Chapter 19 E. Ruiz* and F. Trochu Research Center on High Performance Composites (CCHP) École Polytechnique de l’Université de Montréal C.P. 6079, succ. Centre-Ville Montréal Québec, H3C 3A7 Canada E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 20 P. Laure* Laboratoire J.-A. Dieudonné CNRS UMR 6621 Université de Nice-Sophia Antipolis Parc Valrose 06108 Nice Cedex 02 France
xvii
L. Silva and M. Vincent Cemef CNRS UMR 7635 Mines ParisTech BP 207 06904 Sophia Antipolis Cedex France E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 21 P. Boisse* and N. Hamila Université de Lyon LaMCoS Insa Lyon France E-mail:
[email protected]
E-mail:
[email protected]
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 17
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
CompRein-Boisse-Prelims.indd 18
9/6/11 4:42:11 PM
1
Fibres for composite reinforcement: properties and microstructures
A. R. B u n s e l l, Mines ParisTech, France
Abstract: There are many types of fibres that can be used as reinforcements. Their remarkable properties are exploited in many composite materials and structures, enabling applications which otherwise would be almost impossible. Their long fine forms allow original shapes to be made and their often extraordinary mechanical properties push back the limits of structural materials. Some fibres are familiar, as they are used in textiles, but fibres also find technical applications, such as in reinforcing tyres. Other fibres combine great stiffness and strength with light weight which traditional structural materials cannot rival. These properties depend on the atomic structures of the fibres and these are induced by the way they are made. This chapter relates how the manufacture of the fibres controls their properties and how these are determined by their microstructures. Key words: synthetic fibre reinforcements, manufacture, microstructure, mechanical characteristics.
1.1
Introduction
The form of a fibre explains much of the interest in them as reinforcements. They are fine filaments of matter with diameters often of the order of 10 microns and lengths that can range from centimetres to virtually continuous. Before they were used for composite materials it was their shape, long and fine, that made them ideal for use in textiles (Morton and Hearle, 2008). Fine filaments are extremely flexible and can be woven even if in tension they are very stiff. Many features of fibre-reinforced materials can be seen to be related to their textile uses. Like cloth, most fibre-reinforced composites are two-dimensional, although a woven structure can be seen to have an out-of-plane thickness on the fine scale. Of course there are thick cloths and three-dimensional weaving, but the basic nature of fibre-reinforced composites is two-dimensional. Other materials, such as metals, are made in bulk form and have to be either machined or deformed to be made into sheets, which are expensive operations. A woven cloth can be draped around a complex shape with curvatures in two orthogonal planes because of the way the fibres can move slightly with respect to one another but a metal plate has to be deformed plastically. For example, the bulkhead in an aircraft like the A380 makes use of the drapability of carbon fibre cloth 3 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 3
9/6/11 4:38:16 PM
4
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
in its manufacture, so this aspect of fibre characteristics is important in the manufacture of composites. Drapability is only one advantage, however, as matter in the form of a filament often possesses mechanical properties which cannot be achieved with the same material in bulk form. The strength of a body is related to the probability of finding a defect in it, and because of the very small volume per unit length of fibres they are often much stronger than the same material when in bulk form. If the structure of the fibre can be aligned parallel to the fibre axis, the stiffness of the material can also be increased, and some carbon fibres possess Young’s moduli which approach the theoretical maximum that nature can give. Alignment does mean that the structure becomes anisotropic, which can be either a drawback or a useful characteristic, depending on the application. Nature has evolved along the lines of fibre reinforcement because, unlike other, often fully crystalline materials, composite structures can possess a wide range of characteristics which can be optimized to best meet the needs of different parts of a structure. Wood, with its obvious grain, is a clear example of a natural composite, but all of nature, in both the animal and vegetable worlds, is based on structures which have inspired the development of man-made fibre-reinforced composites. Again, the form of the fibre is optimal for reinforcement. The aspect ratio, that is the ratio of the length to the diameter of a fibre, can be very great, and reinforcement theory shows that this long, fine form is ideal for effecting a transfer of loads from the composite matrix to the usually mechanically more robust fibres.
1.2
Fineness, units, flexibility and strength
The small diameters of most fibres present a difficulty not encountered with bulkier materials. Most materials are characterized by their failure stress, which is the force to produce failure divided by the cross-sectional area or stiffness, calculated as the ratio of stress to strain at the beginning of the deformation curve. This was not usually possible with fibres until the 1960s when the scanning electron microscope was developed and fibre cross-sections could be measured accurately. However, measuring the cross-section still remains a difficulty for characterizing fibres. As fibres have diameters of the order of 10 mm and many fibres, particularly natural fibres, do not have regular cross-sections, even the best optical microscopes are of little help. The resolution of a microscope is limited by the wavelength of light, which is around 0.6 mm, so that accurate measurement of the diameter of even a cylindrical fibre presents serious difficulties. For this reason the fibre industry developed units based on weight per unit length. The traditional unit was the ‘denier’, defined as the weight in grams of 9000 metres of the fibre. A typical textile fibre might be 15 denier. More recently the international unit
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 4
9/6/11 4:38:16 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
5
for fibres has been given the name ‘tex’ and is defined as one gram per 1000 metres. This means that the tex is less fine as a unit than the denier so that the decitex (dtx) is often used, as being one gram per 10,000 metres, very close to the denier. The strength of a fibre is given as the force to produce failure (gram force, for example) per textile unit (denier or tex). This can be seen to be related to traditional engineering units of strength, as it is equal to the force multiplied by the length and divided by the weight:
Force ¥ length/weight = force ¥ length/(volume ¥ density)
= force ¥ length/(length ¥ cross-section ¥ density) = force/(cross-section ¥ density) As force/cross-section is the engineering definition of stress, it can be seen that strengths given in textile units are related to engineering units through the density of the fibres. To understand the importance of the diameter in determining the flexibility of a fibre, it should be noted that the relationship governing its bending can be shown to be a function of Fl3/ED4, in which F is the applied force to produce bending, l is the fibre length, E is its initial modulus or stiffness and D its diameter (Bunsell, 2009). This relationship shows that the bending of a fibre is controlled by the reciprocal of the diameter to the fourth power. Reducing the diameter to half of its original value makes the fibre 16 times more flexible. This means that materials which are very stiff, that is, have a very high Young’s modulus, can still be flexible if they are made into fibres of small diameter. Strength is not an intrinsic property of a material as it depends on the presence of defects. Usually, the bigger the defect the weaker the material. This observation is described by Weibull statistics which reasons that a material is analogous to a chain, the strength of which depends on the weakest link amongst the n links making up the chain. If the probability of failure of a link, under an applied stress s, is P0, the probability of its survival is 1 – P0. The probability of survival of the chain is therefore
1 – Pn = (1 – P0)n
1.1
Pn = 1 – exp[n ln(1 – P0)]
1.2
or
Let’s consider a body of volume V to be divided into small volumes V0 analogous to links in a chain. In this case n is analogous to V/V0. If we consider that V0 is constant, which is like saying that all the links in a chain would have the same length, the value of ln(1 – P0) depends only on the stress, so that for the whole specimen the risk of failure is (from Eq. 1.1):
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 5
9/6/11 4:38:16 PM
6
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
È PV = 1 – exp Í– Î
ÚV
Ê ˆ˘ f Á s , 1 ˜ ˙ dV Ë V0 ¯ ˚
1.3
Weibull put f (s, 1/V0) equal to [(s – su)/s0]m, where s is the applied stress, su is the stress below which there is no probability of failure, and the two material parameters s0 and m are measures of the density and variability of the flaws in the material. It should be noted that s0 does not have the units of stress. In a straight tensile test on fibres the stress s is constant throughout, so that we can write: È Ês – s u ˆ m ˘ PV = 1 – exp Í– Á V˙ Ë s 0 ˜¯ ÎÍ ˚˙
1.4
The parameter m is known as the Weibull shape parameter or simply the Weibull modulus and it quantifies the scatter of the strengths in a population of fibres. The value of m is often low, around 6, similar to that of bulk ceramics, because there is usually a large scatter in strengths in a population of fibres. A material with less scatter would have a higher value for its Weibull modulus. The scatter in fibre strengths is an important characteristic and determines the kinetics of the failure of a fibre bundle and ultimately how many fibrereinforced composites fail. For a more detailed exposition of Weibull statistics see Bunsell and Renard (2005). A consequence of the form of a fibre, which is explained by Weibull statistics, is that fibres are generally much stronger than the same material in bulk form. Imagine a plate of glass with dimensions 100 mm ¥ 100 mm: it could be tested to failure and its failure stress determined. Now if the glass is converted into glass fibres, each fibre would be found to be much stronger than the original plate. Weibull explains that if 100 mm of fibre were tested, it would have a much smaller volume than the plate and therefore there would be a much lower probability of finding a significant defect in it. If all the fibres were assembled next to one another so as to reconstruct a plate and they were embedded in a matrix to make a composite, the new structure would be much stronger than the original glass plate even if the matrix were not very strong. This is because of the intrinsically higher strength of glass in fibre form and also because individual fibre breaks would be isolated by stress transfer to other fibres by shear of the matrix.
1.3
Comparison of materials
Composite materials are structural materials and as such compete with others which are more traditional. The densities and Young’s moduli of some of these materials are compared in Table 1.1. The values have been rounded
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 6
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
7
Table 1.1 Typical properties of some bulk materials compared to those of fibres and fibre-reinforced composites Material Specific gravity
Young’s modulus (GPa)
Specific modulus (GPa)
Bulk materials Steel Aluminium Titanium Beryllium Oak Copper Nickel Tungsten Concrete
7.9 2.7 4.5 1.8 0.6–0.9 8.9 8.8 19.6 2.4
200 76 116 289 11 110 21 400 30
25.3 28 25.7 161 12–18 12.4 2.4 20.4 12.5
1.38 1.15 1.4 1.53 1.45 1.56 0.96 2.5 1.8 2.16
15 5 12 65 135 280 117 72 295 830
10.8 3.3 8.5 43 93 180 122 27.6 164 384
11 45 83 143–179 500
12–18 16 58 87–109 270
Fibres Polyester PET fibre Nylon (PA66) fibre Spider silk fibre Flax fibre Kevlar fibre Zsylon fibre Dyneema polyethylene fibre Glass fibre Carbon (high strength – H.S.) fibre Carbon (ultra high modulus – H.M.) fibre Fibre composites Oak wood Glass fibre composites Kevlar fibre composite H.S. carbon fibre composite H.M. carbon fibre composite
0.6–0.9 2.08 1.43 1.64 1.85
off for ease of comparison, and where the materials are not perfectly elastic the initial slope of their stress–strain curves has been taken as their Young’s modulus. Stiffness is often a critical characteristic of a structure and so is its weight, so that the specific modulus, which is Young’s modulus divided by specific gravity, is an important characteristic. The driving force for the development of many composite materials has been the combination of high mechanical properties, particularly stiffness and low density. Table 1.1 shows that the common structural metals steel, aluminium and titanium have very similar specific moduli so that to maintain the same stiffness there is little to be gained by substituting one for another, if weight is important. Beryllium is a metal and the fourth element in the Periodic Table. It is used for some rather exotic applications such as for some structures in satellites but it is toxic, particularly its oxide, which makes it unsuitable for
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 7
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
8
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
most uses. It can be seen that some synthetic fibres possess specific moduli much higher than those of the traditional structural materials. Glass fibres do not have remarkable specific moduli but nevertheless find very wide use in composite materials. This is usually not to gain weight but for low cost, as glass fibres are much cheaper than many other reinforcements, and for ease of manufacture of complex parts, which is another characteristic of composite materials that makes them attractive. Fibres usually possess much higher strengths than the same material in bulk form, for the reasons explained above, and some have remarkable stiffness, usually due to the alignment of their atomic structures. These high-performance fibres can be seen to possess remarkable specific moduli, far exceeding the values of traditional materials. Carbon fibres can be made with a very wide range of Young’s moduli and the values given in Table 1.1 are some typical values. The properties given for the composites are those of unidirectional composites containing a volume fraction of fibres of 60% loaded in the fibre direction. The technical, synthetic fibres, which have been developed since the middle of the twentieth century and which have permitted fibre-reinforced composites to be produced, are the subject of this chapter.
1.4
Organic fibres
Several people unsuccessfully tried to produce artificial fibres before regenerated cellulose fibres were patented in 1884, in France by Count Hilaire de Chardonnay (Moncrieff, 1982). These first artificial fibres were made of cellulose nitrate and were very inflammable. Ten years later in 1894, Charles Frederick Cross and his collaborators Edward John Bevan and Clayton Beadle, in England, patented their process, which gave rise to viscose fibres. This was a fibre which could be used for textile purposes, and commercial production began in 1905 by the Courtauld’s company, in England. The fibres were made by extrusion of the cellulose solution into a bath of sulphuric acid. The goal of producing artificial fibres was to produce a cheaper and therefore more accessible silk. The viscose fibres did find uses in textile applications but also in reinforcing rubber, typically for the emerging tyre industry. These fibres represent the link between natural and synthetic fibres, as rayon fibres make use of the structure of cellulose molecules which occur naturally in all plants. The cellulose for making rayon fibres is usually obtained from wood.
1.4.1
Thermoplastic fibres
It was not until around 1938 that the first truly synthetic organic fibres were produced. These were polyamide 6.6 fibres, developed by the work of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 8
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
9
Carothers at DuPont in the USA, and almost simultaneously, polyamide 6 was produced by the German company I.G. Farben. Both types of polyamide fibres contain the amide group, consisting of a carbon atom linked to an oxygen atom and both linked to a nitrogen atom. This group lies within the backbone of the polyamide macromolecule. Polyamides are more generally known as nylons. The work that gave rise to polyamide 6.6 fibres came from a widerranging study of both polyamides and polyesters, the latter being based on the ester group, consisting of a carbon atom linked to an oxygen atom and both linked to another oxygen atom. This ester group lies in the backbone of any polyester polymer. Although the work on polyesters was initially abandoned, because of the instability of the molecular structure, it inspired work in England by J. R. Whinfield and J. T. Dickson of the Calico Printers Association. These two chemists found that by associating the ester group with an aromatic group, consisting of a cycle of six carbon atoms, poly(ester terephthalate) (PET) could be produced. This polymer overcame many of the limitations of other polyesters that had been produced as it resisted hydrolysis and possessed a melting point of 260°C. The polyester fibres that were developed from PET and commercially launched by ICI in the UK around 1947 have become the most widely produced fibres of all types. Both nylon and polyester (PET) fibres find wide technical uses, such as in reinforcing rubber in tyres, walkways, fan belts, hoses, flexible drives, moving walkways and other applications. The aromatic ring in the PET molecule can be seen in Table 1.2. It confers on the polymer improved thermal and chemical stability as well as interesting mechanical properties. The PET fibres have the same melting point as PA66 fibres but around three times the stiffness. This stiffness, however, is still low compared to that of most structural materials. Both nylon and polyester fibres are semi-crystalline thermoplastics and are drawn from the melt; however, stiffer organic fibres were later developed by using the technology of liquid crystals. The addition of the aromatic ring, seen in the PET molecule, defined the routes which chemists would take to produce ever more complex chemical structures, to produce organic fibres with higher tensile stiffness that are used in high-performance composites.
1.4.2
Aramid fibres
The aramid family of fibres is made up of aromatic polyamides, some of which possess remarkably high Young’s moduli more than 20 times that of conventional polyamide fibres. The term aramid comes from an abbreviation of aromatic polyamide and covers the range of wholly aromatic polyamides so as to distinguish them from the linear aliphatic polyamides. The aramids
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 9
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 10
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
Maximum elastic modulus (GPa)
Poly(p-phenylene benzobisoxazole), PBO [Zylon], Toyobo
Poly(p-phenylene terephthalamide) [Kevlar], DuPont
Poly(m- phenylenediamine- isophthalamide) [Nomex], DuPont
HN
O N
N
CO
O
NH
CO
O
H NH
C
O
N
CO
CH2
CO
CH2 n
280
135
17
15
650
550
360
260
CO
Polyethylene terephthalate [polyester], ICI
O
230
260
Melting or decomposition temperature °C
Polyamide 6 4 [Nylon 6], —NH—CH [ ]nˆ 2—CH2—CH2—CH2—CH2—CO— I.G. Farben
Polyamide 6/6 5 [Nylon 6.6], —NH—CH [ ]nˆ 2—CH2—CH2—CH2—CH2—CH2—NH—CO—CH2—CH2—CH2—CH2—CO— DuPont
Fibre type Repeat unit in the macromolecule
Table 1.2 Some molecules used to produce organic fibres
Fibres for composite reinforcement
11
consist of stiff molecules due to the aromatic rings which are not flexible. The result is a family of polymers which are more chemically resistant and thermally stable than aliphatic polyamides due to the greater degree of alignment of the molecular structure that is possible. Some of the aramids possess much higher strengths and tensile stiffness, the latter being due to the para- linkage of the aromatic rings, which means that they are joined parallel to the main molecular chain. This limits the compliance of the molecule. The properties of the most common classes of organic fibres are shown in Table 1.3, and it should be clear how those fibres based on cyclic molecular structures are much stiffer than the first thermoplastic fibres that were produced. An early type of aramid fibre which has found wide use is poly(metaphenylene isophthalamide). This fibre is sold by its makers, DuPont, under the name of Nomex. This polymer contains meta-oriented phenylene radicals, which means that stresses through the molecule are not supported by straight covalent bonds, resulting in a tensile stiffness which is still only about that of highly drawn PET. The fibre is, however, flame resistant and thermally stable to around 100°C over the melting point of the aliphatic polyamides and has good dielectric properties. As a consequence the fibre is used in apparel for which resistance to heat is required such as fire officers’ uniforms and racing drivers’ overalls. It is also used in chopped form to make a paper material that is widely used as a honeycomb in advanced composite structures. The low specific gravity of Nomex (1.38) compared to aluminium (2.7), which is also used for honeycomb structures, gives it an obvious advantage for applications for which weight saving is important, such as in aircraft. In order to obtain high strength and above all high stiffness, the aramid polymers should contain predominantly para-oriented aromatic units. This is the case in poly(para-phenylene terephthalamide) (PPTA) which is the polymer used to make the Kevlar fibre that has been available from DuPont since 1972. A similar fibre is the Twaron fibre, originally produced by Akzo, in the Netherlands and now produced there by the Japanese company Teijin (Pergoretti and Traina, 2009). Table 1.3 Typical properties of most commonly commercially available organic fibres Fibre Polymer Diameter Density (µm) (g/cm3)
Young’s modulus (GPa)
Strength (GPa)
Strain to failure (%)
Polyamide 66 Polyester Kevlar 49 Zylon Polyethylene (Dyneema)
<5 <18 135 280 117
1 0.8 3 5.8 3
20 15 4.5 2.5 3.5
PA66 PET PPTA PBO PE
20 15 12 12 38
1.2 1.38 1.45 1.56 0.96
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 11
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
12
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
PPTA is insoluble in most solvents, but a 10% solution of the polymer in concentrated (>98 wt%) sulphuric acid results in the production of a mesophase or liquid crystal solution. The rod-like PPTA molecules are randomly oriented in the solution but, beyond a critical concentration, locally the molecules are attracted together and adopt an ordered arrangement in small domains to achieve better packing. The domains are still randomly arranged with respect to one another and the solution retains the flow properties of a liquid, but in polarized light it can be seen to be locally oriented. When the solution is passed through the holes of a spinneret the induced shear forces orient the molecular structure so that a highly oriented fibre can be produced without drawing, as shown schematically in Fig. 1.1. The result is a highly oriented and well-organized molecular structure for these types of fibres. The molecules are oriented parallel to the fibre axis so that the covalent bonds in the structure support any applied load. However, the presence of the amide group, which is not straight, leads to less than
1.1 A schematic representation of a liquid crystal solution being extruded through a spinneret to form a highly oriented fibre.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 12
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
13
theoretical maximum stiffness for an organic fibre. Table 1.3 shows how the development of aramid fibres produced filaments which were around 30 times stiffer than nylon 66 fibres and had remarkable specific properties in tension. However, inevitably, in the plane normal to the fibre axis the secondary bonds, which are hydrogen and van der Waals’ bonds in PPTA fibres, make the fibres very anisotropic. The presence of hydrogen bonds means that these fibres absorb significant amounts of water. On a molecular scale, the fibres behave like a bundle of filaments, with each filament representing a PPTA molecule. A bundle is strong in tension but in all other directions, particularly compression, it is weak. For this reason these highly oriented organic fibres are not suitable for structures which are subjected to compressive loads. Figure 1.2 shows that Kevlar fibres deform plastically in compression, rather than break as brittle fibres do (Lafitte and Bunsell, 1985). When an aramid fibre is bent, the convex surface goes into compression and this relieves the tensile stress which is developed in the convex surface. It means that these fibres can be bent to a zero radius of curvature without breaking and this makes them both difficult to cut and useful for absorbing energy. A major application for composite materials reinforced with these highly oriented organic fibres is in impact absorption, whether in the case of explosions, for
1.2 This Kevlar fibre is bent around another fibre. Both have diameters of 12 mm and it can be seen that the concave side of the fibre has developed slip bands by the plastic deformation in shear of the polymer. In this way the fibre accommodates the compression rather than breaking (Lafitte and Bunsell, 1985).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 13
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
14
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
flak jackets or used with other elastic fibres so as to make a hybrid composite capable of resisting shocks. Another mechanism which absorbs energy is fibrillation, and these highly oriented organic fibres made by liquid crystal technology usually fail like a blade of grass, clearly revealing their fibrillar microstructure, as can be seen from Fig. 1.3 showing a broken Zylon fibre. The Zylon fibre, made by Toyobo in Japan, has been commercially available since 1998 and has the highest tensile stiffness of all commercially available organic fibres. This fibre is 40% stiffer than steel for a fifth of the density. The fibre is made from poly-p-phenylenebenzobisoxazole (PBO) (Pergoretti and Traina, 2009). This is one of the polybenzazoles containing aromatic heterocyclic rings, which were developed by the US Air Force as polymers that resist heat better than Kevlar. As the molecule is straight, the Zylon fibre, as shown in Tables 1.2 and 1.3, has a tensile stiffness twice as great as that of Kevlar. When Zylon fibres are first produced they absorb some water, around 2 wt%, because of porosity in the fibre structure due to solvent evaporation. Treatment of the fibre reduces this to around 0.2 wt%. Such a low water uptake is due to the transverse bonds being purely van der Waals but must increase anisotropy. Other organic fibres are in development, such as the M5 fibre made from polypyridobisimidazole (PIPD) which was produced by the researchers from the Dutch company Akzo Nobel and is now being developed by Magellan Systems International with suggestions that it will be commercially produced by DuPont. The PIPD molecule is related to PBO, and the Young’s modulus claimed for the fibre of 330 GPa is even higher. The producers claim that
1.3 A broken Zylon fibre, revealing its highly oriented fibrillar microstructure.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 14
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
15
there is a highly significant difference in the behaviour of the PIPD fibre as lateral cohesion is determined by hydrogen bonds. As mentioned above, the PBO fibre relies on van der Waals’ bonds for lateral cohesion which, however, are very weak. Hydrogen bonds are 10 times stronger, which means that the M5 fibre should have superior radial and compressive strengths. The presence of hydrogen bonds will probably mean that the fibre will absorb water, however.
1.4.3
High-modulus polyethylene fibres
The stiffness of fibres such as Kevlar or Zylon is a consequence of the alignment of the main molecular chains parallel to the fibre axis. This is achieved by the liquid crystal technology discussed above, but aligning the main molecular chains of even the simplest polymer parallel to the fibre axis would, theoretically, produce a tensile Young’s modulus greater than that of steel. The difficulty is how to do it. One of the simplest polymers is polyethylene, consisting of a backbone of carbon atoms to which are attached hydrogen atoms. The simplicity of the molecule has allowed the DSM company, in the Netherlands, to produce polyethylene fibres with an aligned molecular structure and so consequently produce a high-modulus fibre (Vlasblom and van Dingenen, 2009). High-modulus polyethylene fibres are produced using a dilute (<5%) sol-gel, in which the polymer is dissolved in a solvent and then spun. The low concentration of the polyethylene allows the macromolecules sufficient space to become disentangled and, by optimization of the process, to produce fibres with aligned molecular structures. The gel is extruded and the solvent evaporated to make the filaments. High-modulus polyethylene fibres produced in the Netherlands by DSM in collaboration with Toyobo in Japan under the name Dyneema and in the USA by Honeywell under the name Spectra have properties rivalling those of the aramid fibres with a lower specific gravity of 0.97. Unlike the fibres made by liquid crystal technology, these fibres do not contain thermally stable cycles of atoms, so that the fibres are more sensitive to temperature effects. These fibres are limited in temperature to a maximum of 120°C and suffer from creep. The melting point is around 146°C. The Dyneema fibres are therefore composed of aligned polyethylene molecules, which results in a high-modulus fibre when loaded in tension but also a highly anisotropic structure. The fibrillar nature of the fibre can be seen in Fig. 1.4. The anisotropy of the fibre means that, like the liquid crystal fibres, it is weak in compression. Figure 1.5 shows a kink band produced by a compression wave generated by the failure of the Dyneema fibre in tension. High-modulus polyethylene fibres are finding markets as high-strength
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 15
9/6/11 4:38:17 PM
16
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
1.4 The fibrillar nature of Dyneema high modulus polyethylene fibres is clearly seen in this micrograph.
1.5 A compression kink band in a Dyneema fibre following a tensile test.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 16
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
17
mooring ropes for large ships and oil platforms as well as for flak jackets and similar anti-ballistic structures.
1.5
Glass fibres
Glass filaments were probably made in antiquity. The beginning of an industrial process for producing fine glass filaments was demonstrated in Great Britain in the nineteenth century, and they were used as a substitute for asbestos in Germany during the First World War. However, the first commercial production dates from 1931 when two American firms, Owen Illinois Glass Co. and Corning Glass Works, developed a method of spinning glass filaments from the melt through spinnerets. The two firms combined in 1938 to form Owens Corning Fiberglas Corporation. Initially the glass fibres were destined for filters and textile uses, but the development of thermosetting resins opened up the possibility of fibre-reinforced composites, and in the years following the Second World War the fibre took a dominant role in this type of material. Today, glass fibres represent about 99% by weight of all fibre reinforcements used in composites, if rubber-based composites are not considered. Fibres of glass are produced by extruding molten glass, at a temperature around 1250°C, through holes with diameters of 1–2 mm in a spinneret and then drawing the filaments to produce fibres having diameters usually between 5 and 15 mm (Jones, 2009). The spinnerets usually contain several hundred holes so that a strand of glass fibres is produced. Several types of glass exist but all are based on silica (SiO2) which is combined with other elements to create speciality glasses. The compositions and properties of the most common types of glass fibres are shown in Table 1.4. The most widely used glass for fibre-reinforced composites is called E-glass, while glass fibres with superior mechanical properties are known as S-glass. E-glass is the most widely used glass in fibre production, type S is a glass with enhanced mechanical properties, and type C glass resists corrosion in an acid environment. Glass fibres are easily damaged by abrasion, either with other fibres or by coming into contact with machinery in the manufacturing process, so they are coated with a protective coating known as a size. The purpose of the size is both to protect the fibre and to hold the strand together. The size may be temporary, usually a starch–oil emulsion, to aid handling of the fibre, which is then removed and replaced with a finish to help fibre matrix adhesion in the composite. There are two main types of coupling agent used in composites. These are organometallic compounds, typically of cobalt, nickel, lead, titanium or chromium, or, more commonly, organosilanes. They are applied as an aqueous solution. An example of an organosilane is shown in Fig. 1.6. It reacts with the glass surface through hydrogen bonds. The
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 17
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
18
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Table 1.4 Compositions (wt%), density and mechanical properties of glasses used in fibre reinforcement production Glass type
E
S
C
SiO2 54 65 Al2O3 15 25 CaO 18 MgO 4 10 B2O3 8 F 0.3 Fe2O3 0.3 TiO2 Na2O K2O 0.4
65 4 14 3 5.5
Density Strength at 20°C (GPa) Elastic modulus at 20°C (GPa) Failure strain at 20°C (%)
2.49 2.8 70 4.0
2.54 3.5 73.5 4.5
R
R
Si
Si
O
O H
2.49 4.65 86.5 5.3
8 0.5
O p
O H
H
O
O
Si
Si
H
Glass surface
1.6 Glass fibres are always coated with a size, the most common of which is based on silane.
size usually has several additional functions which are to act as a coupling agent and lubricant and to eliminate electrostatic charges. Continuous glass fibres may be woven, as are textile fibres, made into a non-woven mat in which the fibres are arranged in a random fashion, used in filament winding or chopped into short fibres. In this latter case the fibres are chopped into lengths of up to 5 cm and lightly bonded together to form a mat, or chopped into shorter lengths of a few millimetres for inclusion in moulding resins. The structure is vitreous with no definite compounds being formed and no crystallization taking place. An open network results from the rapid cooling that takes place during fibre production with the glass cooling from about 1500°C to 200°C in 0.1–0.3 seconds. Despite this rapid rate of cooling
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 18
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
19
there appear to be no appreciable residual stresses within the fibre and the structure is isotropic. The result is that the Young’s moduli of glass fibres are very similar to that of bulk glass of the same type and the fibres are not anisotropic, like most other reinforcements. Glass is set to remain the most widely used reinforcement for general composites. Glass fibres are cheaper than most other relatively high-modulus fibres and because of their flexibility do not require very specialized machines or techniques to handle them. Their elastic modulus is, however, low when compared to many other fibres, and the specific gravity of glass, which for E-type glass is 2.54, is relatively high. The poor specific value of the mechanical properties of glass fibres means that they are not ideal for structures requiring light weight as well as high properties, although considerations such as their relatively low cost compared to other high-performance fibres and the ease of composite manufacture means that they are used in some such structures.
1.6
Chemical vapour deposition (CVD) monofilaments
The first fibre produced with a much increased Young’s modulus compared to glass fibres was the boron fibre made by a CVD technique onto a substrate which was a tungsten wire. Boron, the fifth element in the Periodic Table, is the lightest element with which it was found practical to make fibres. The first boron fibres were produced in the USA at the beginning of the 1960s. They had a Young’s modulus exceeding 400 GPa and quite extraordinary strength in compression. Silicon carbide fibres, produced by a similar technique to that used to make boron fibres, can be used as a reinforcement for metal matrix composites, including titanium and intermetallic matrix composites. Silicon carbide fibres, are based on materials which are readily available, and the substrate can be either tungsten wire or a carbon filament, which is cheaper (Wawner, 1988). The production of both boron and silicon carbide fibres by CVD takes place in a reactor which consists of a glass tube, which for commercial production is usually 1–2 metres in length and most often vertical. Schematic representations of the arrangements for the production of both types of fibres are shown in Fig. 1.7. The substrate can run continuously through the reactor by the use of mercury seals at each end. These ensure that the reactive gases are contained in the reactor and also allow the substrate to be heated by electric current over the deposition length. The choice of the substrate is governed by the need to use a material which maintains its strength to around 1100°C and is an electrical conductor. Heating the substrate, usually with a dc current, is a necessary part of the process which determines the deposition rate, which must be constant or irregularities in the fibre diameter
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 19
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
20
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance Supply reel
Mercury contact
Supply reel
W
W or C
BCl3 + H1
Boron deposition reactor
Mercury contact
Silane Hydrogen propane Argon Silane Hydrogen
HCl Silane Propane Argon Bw SiCw or SiCc Take-up reel
Take-up reel
1.7 Schematic views of the reactors for producing boron and silicon carbide fibres by CVD.
occur with a subsequent fall in strength. Tungsten wire was chosen for the production of boron fibres and can be used also for SiC fibres, although carbon substrates are an alternative. The tungsten wires have a diameter of around 12 mm but the carbon cores are usually around 30 mm. It is therefore evident that the fibres produced have much bigger diameters than most other reinforcements used for composite materials. As explained above, the large diameter leads to the production of fibres which are not very flexible and cannot be woven, which limits their use. Boron fibres are made by mixing boron trichloride with hydrogen, which results in boron being deposited according to the following reaction:
2BCl3(g) + 3H2(g) Æ 2B(s) + 6HCl(g)
Passage through the reactor takes 1–2 minutes and results in a fibre with a diameter of 140 mm. During the deposition process the small boron atoms diffuse into the tungsten core to produce complete boridization and the production of WB4 and W2B5. This leads to an increase in diameter to 16 mm
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 20
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
21
which induces considerable residual stresses, putting the core into compression and the neighbouring boron mantle into tension. A final annealing process puts the fibre surface into compression. The fibres were initially of interest for all types of composites destined for mainly aerospace structures, but their use in resin composites was curtailed by the development of cheaper, highperformance carbon fibres that became available in the late 1960s. Boron fibres were successfully used to reinforce aluminium, and the American space shuttle made extensive use of this type of composite in its structure. Silicon carbide fibres made by CVD are produced on both tungsten and carbon cores in similar reactors to those use for the production of boron fibres, except that multiple injection points are used for the introduction of the reactant gases. Various carbon-containing silanes have been used as reactants. In a typical process, with CH3SiCl3 as the reactant, SiC is deposited on the core as follows:
CH3SiCl3(g) Æ SiC(s) + 3HCl(g)
Figure 1.8 shows the cross-section of a SiC fibre made by CVD that has been used to reinforce titanium. Like the boron fibres, these SiC fibres usually have a diameter of 140 mm. The tungsten core can be seen in the centre and a protective layer can also be seen on the fibre surface. This layer is to protect the SiC from the highly reactive molten titanium during manufacture of the composite. Several types of protection are used; the best known is
1.8 A cross-section of a SiC fibre made by CVD, used to reinforce a metal matrix.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 21
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
22
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
produced during the later stages of fibre production and consists of a CVD layer, the composition of which varies from being rich in silicon to being rich in carbon before becoming rich again in silicon on the fibre surface. This SCS coating is typically 3 mm in thickness. The greatest interest for SiC fibres made by CVD is for the reinforcement of titanium for use in jet engines so as to reduce weight.
1.7
Carbon fibres
Carbon is the sixth lightest element and the carbon–carbon covalent bond is the strongest in nature (4000 kJ/mole); however, the arrangements of the bonds and the distances between the carbon atoms can vary, so giving many types of carbon, including graphite, diamond and amorphous forms.
1.7.1
Carbon fibres from cellulose
Many fibres can be converted into carbon fibres, the basic requirement being that the precursor fibre carbonizes rather than melts when heated. In 1901 Edison used bamboo fibres, which like all plants are made up of cellulose, and converted them into carbon filaments for his electric light bulbs. He therefore became the first person to patent a carbon fibre but they proved very brittle and after three years were replaced by tungsten. Interestingly, however, the carbon fibres developed in the USA in the 1950s and early 1960s used viscose fibres regenerated from cellulose (Bacon, 1973). This proved a slow process as the carbon yield from cellulose is only 24% and mechanical properties were not high; however, such fibres have low thermal conduction properties and are still used in carbon–carbon heat shields and brake pads.
1.7.2
Carbon fibres from polyacrylonitrile (PAN)
Most carbon fibres nowadays are made by a process developed and commercially produced first in Great Britain in the mid-1960s and then in Japan, where production began in 1970, based on the conversion of a modified form of polyacrylonitrile (PAN) fibre. PAN has a carbon yield of 67% by weight (Matsuhisa, and Bunsell, 2009). The PAN molecule has a backbone of carbon atoms and consists of long linear molecules. Heating in air around 275°C causes the fibre to turn black due to oxygen interacting with the PAN. This causes crosslinking, producing a three-dimensional infusible atomic network. The crosslinked fibre is then heated in nitrogen above 1000°C to produce a carbon fibre. This process is conducted with the fibre in tension, as the matter that is lost causes a reduction in volume and without the tensile load on the fibre would result in a fibre with poor
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 22
9/6/11 4:38:18 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
23
structural organization at the atomic level. The properties of carbon fibres made from PAN precursors depend on the temperature of pyrolysis. The different stages in carbon fibre production are shown in Fig. 1.9. Highest strength is achieved between 1500°C and 1600°C but the Young’s modulus continues to increase with increasing temperature. The reasons for this change in strength and modulus with pyrolysis temperature lie at the level of the atomic structure of this type of carbon fibre, which was closely studied by Oberlin and Guigon (1988). The structure which results from the pyrolysis of PAN is highly anisotropic, with the basic structural units, formed by small plates of the carbon atom groups, arranged in hexagons, aligned parallel to the fibre axis. They form imperfectly stacked layers called turbostatic layers with the interlayer spacing being greater than that of graphite. There is complete rotational disorder in the radial direction and the relatively poor stacking of the carbon atoms means that a graphite structure is never achieved. The structure contains pores which account for the density of the fibres being less than that of fully dense carbon. Table 1.5 shows some typical properties of carbon fibres; however, there exists a considerable range of properties for these fibres. Pyrolysis temperatures above 1600°C produce an increase in size of the basic structural units which evolve, becoming larger plates and more continuous ribbon-like structures. The structure tends towards that of graphite but never attains the close packing of this crystalline form of carbon.
Polymerization
AN Acrylonitrile
Wet or dry spinning
PAN
PAN fibre
Polyacrylonitrile
Oxidation 200–300°C 2–3 hours in air
Oxidized fibre
Precursor fibre
Carbonization
High temperature treatment
1000–1500°C 5 min in N2
2500–3000°C 1 min in N2 Surface treatment
Sizing
High strength
High modulus
1.9 Carbon fibres made from PAN can be processed at different temperatures in order to change their properties.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 23
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
24
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Table 1.5 Typical properties of PAN- and pitch-based carbon fibres Fibre type Diameter Density Strength Failure Young’s (µm) (g/cm3) (GPa) strain modulus (%) (GPa) Ex-PAN High strength (first generation) High strength (second generation) High modulus (first generation) High modulus (second generation) Ex-pitch Oil-derived pitch Oil-derived pitch (high modulus) Coal tar pitch Coal tar pitch (high modulus)
7 5 7 5
1.80 1.82 1.84 1.94
4.4 7.1 4.2 3.92
1.8 2.4 1.0 0.7
250 294 436 588
11 11 10 10
2.10 2.16 2.12 2.16
3.7 3.5 3.6 3.9
0.9 0.5 0.58 0.48
390 780 620 830
The carbon fibre surface consists of planar BSUs aligned parallel to the fibre surface and along the axis direction. There are no pendant bonds available so that carbon fibres are surface treated using an oxidation process or other methods to make the fibre surface more reactive, so as to improve adhesion between the fibre surface and matrix resin. After surface treatment, the carbon fibres are coated with a sizing agent to facilitate composite manufacture. PAN-based carbon fibres were originally produced with diameters of 7 mm and this first generation of fibres is still the most widely used; however, a second generation of carbon fibres is available with diameters of 5 mm. This change in diameter reduces the cross-section by a half and the result is that the strengths of these fibres are considerably improved when compared to the earlier fibres. The above discussion on Weibull statistics gives the explanation: that the smaller volume per unit length means that there are fewer defects to weaken the fibres. In addition the smaller diameter allows for greater regularity in the structure so that the modulus is increased. Figure 1.10 compares the appearances of the first-generation fibres (left) with the latest on the right. In addition to the smaller diameter, it can be seen that the later fibres have been produced with improved control over the spinning process so as to produce smoother fibres. This also improves the strengths of the fibres. Figure 1.11 shows the range of fibre properties available from PAN-based carbon fibres. Together with the improvement in tensile strength, the compressive strength of carbon fibre has also improved (Norita et al., 1988). Therefore the presence of defects is also an important factor for the compressive strength. Another important factor for the compressive strength of single filaments is crystallite size. Carbon fibres can be categorized into low modulus carbon fibres (<200 GPa), standard modulus carbon fibres (~230 GPa), intermediate modulus carbon fibres (~300 GPa) and high modulus carbon fibres (>350 GPa). Fibres
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 24
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
1.0 µm
25
1.0 µm
Tensile strength (GPa)
1.10 A comparison of a first-generation PAN-based carbon fibre (left) and a fibre of the most recent generation (right).
8
Ultra high strength
6
High modulus
4 Ultra high modulus 2 200
400 600 Young’s modulus (GPa)
800
1.11 The range of properties from commercially available PAN-based carbon fibres.
with higher moduli than 600 GPa are sometimes called ultra high modulus carbon fibres and are sometimes known as graphite fibres. The highest tensile modulus of PAN-based carbon fibres is 700 GPa. PAN-based carbon fibres are produced in a range of tows, the finest of which originally contained 1000 fibres. Such tows were used for the highest quality aerospace structures but with improved control, experience in manipulating the fibres and a drive to reduce costs, tows of 3000, 6000 and 12,000 filaments became standard. This trend has continued and tows of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 25
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
26
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
24,000 fibres are increasingly used, with tows of even 48,000 carbon fibres becoming to be seen as standard. Tows containing hundreds of thousands of carbon fibres seem to be the future for at least non-aerospace applications as fibre production cost is reduced in this way. The large tows then have to be split into tows with smaller numbers of fibres so that they can be used in composite manufacture.
1.7.3
Carbon fibres from pitch
Carbon fibres made from pitch, which is the residue of petroleum refining or coal tar distillation in the steel industry, were developed in the USA in the early 1970s and in Japan in the 1980s. The high carbon yield of pitch, which approaches 90%, makes it an attractive and potentially cheap source for making carbon fibre precursors (Lavin, 2000). Cost, however, is increased by the purification processes which are necessary for this naturally occurring material. Some carbon fibres are made from pitch with no attempt to align their structures, and the result is fibres with a low Young’s modulus of around 40 GPa. These fibres are used for their chemical inertness and low cost for the reinforcement of cement and concrete. The biggest producer of this type of isotropic pitch-based carbon fibre is Kureha in Japan. In the early 1970s, Union Carbide in the USA developed high performance carbon fibres from mesophase pitch (Volk, 1975). In this method the pitch is treated so that the molecular structure is ordered to give a nematic (onedimensional) liquid crystal structure. Mesophase pitch melts around 300°C and is then processed around 400°C. The polymerized pitch molecules are made up of chains of aromatic hexagonal units each consisting of six atoms of carbon. When the polymerization is sufficiently advanced the molecules form spheres which grow until a phase inversion occurs, at which point the previous situation with the discrete spheres being embedded in the isotropic medium reverses and the molecules become the medium consisting of a continuous nematic liquid crystalline phase, called a mesophase. The precursor pitch fibres are then spun from the melt. After production of the precursor fibres the production processes of pitch-based carbon fibres are fundamentally the same as those of PAN-based carbon fibres. The arrangement of the atomic structures of the carbon fibres produced from pitch can be more regular than that obtained from PAN precursors, with a graphite structure being achieved in some types of these fibres. As a consequence the results are higher moduli and lower production temperatures, with the result that ultra high modulus carbon fibres made from pitch are cheaper than those made from PAN. The maximum tensile modulus of a carbon fibre is limited to that of a graphite single crystal, which is 1050 GPa. Carbon fibres made from coal tar pitch are commercially available with moduli of 935 GPa. The regularity of the arrangements of the carbon atoms
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 26
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
27
means that the basic structural units of the carbon are larger than in PANbased fibres and this results in lower strengths, particularly in compression. As Table 1.5 shows, the tensile strength of pitch-based carbon fibre does not vary with pyrolysis temperature as is the case in producing carbon fibres from PAN.
1.8
Small-diameter ceramic fibres
There are two families of small-diameter ceramic fibres (Bunsell and Berger, 1999). Glass fibres are based on oxides, and shortly after their development discontinuous oxide fibres were produced as refractory insulation for furnaces and similar applications (Bansal, 2005). Fibres based on silicon carbide were produced much later, inspired by the production of carbon fibres from PAN.
1.8.1
Oxide fibres
Oxide fibres for reinforcement were first produced in the 1970s, primarily in the USA and Great Britain. Saffil fibres developed by ICI are short fibres with small diameters of around 3 mm. They are based on alumina (Al2O3) and around 3% silica (SiO2). They find use as reinforcement for aluminium. DuPont produced the first continuous a-alumina fibre but did not proceed to commercial exploitation. This was due to its brittle nature. Alpha-alumina is the most crystalline form of alumina and has a Young’s modulus of around 400 GPa. Other producers, notably 3M, have produced other fibres based on alumina, often combined with other oxides to limit phase transformation of the alumina into the most brittle alpha phase (Wilson, 2009). 3M produces a range of oxide fibres under the name of Nextel and they are successfully used at temperatures up to around 1000°C. However, the ionic bonds in oxides make them susceptible to creep at higher temperatures. The Nextel 720 fibre has a complex structure consisting of a-alumina and mullite phases. This means that the fibre has a complex crystallographic structure with no easy slip planes. It is the most advanced oxide fibre but is limited to temperatures below 1100°C because it is metastable in the presence of alkaline impurities (Deleglise et al., 2002). Table 1.6 shows some examples of oxide fibres together with some of their properties.
1.8.2
Silicon carbide fibres
Silicon carbide filaments can be used at temperatures above 1000°C. This is due to the structure of SiC containing covalent bonds, as in carbon. It is this similarity with carbon that encouraged the use of these fibres to replace
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 27
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 28
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
99% Al2O3, 0.2–0.3% SiO2, 0.4–0.7% Fe2O3
99.9% Al2O3 10–12
10
Alumina–silica Saffil Ltd Saffil 95% Al2O3, 5% SiO2 1–5 based fibres 15 Sumitomo Altex 85% Al2O3, 15% SiO2 Chemicals 3M Nextel 312 62% Al2O3, 24% SiO2, 14% B2O3 10–12 and 8–9 3M Nextel 440 70% Al2O3, 28% SiO2, 2% B2O3 10–12 3M Nextel 720 85% Al2O3, 15% SiO2 12
a-Al2O3 based Mitsui Almax fibres Mining 3M Nextel 610
2 1.8 1.7 2.1 2.1
3.2 2.7 3.05 3.4
1.9
1.02
3.2
3.75
3.6
1.12 1.11 0.81
0.8
0.67
0.5
0.3
152 190 260
210
300
370
344
Fibre type Manufacturer Trade Composition Diameter Density Strength Strain to Young’s mark (wt%) (mm) (g/cm3) (GPa) failure modulus (%) (GPa)
Table 1.6 Examples of oxide-based fibres
Fibres for composite reinforcement
29
carbon fibres in composites used for very high-temperature applications, such as rocket nozzles. Silicon carbide in bulk form can be used in air up to 1600°C whereas carbon oxidizes from 400°C. The commercial development of silicon carbide fibres in the early 1980s was the direct consequence of the work of Yajima and his colleagues in Japan (Yajima et al., 1976). Nippon Carbon made these fibres commercially available under the name of Nicalon. Later, Ube Industries began producing Tyranno fibres with similar properties but slightly different compositions. The early fibres were produced in an analogous fashion to that used to make carbon fibres from PAN. A polycarbosilane organic precursor was used. It not only contained the elements necessary for SiC but was structured in a way that was reminiscent of the b-crystalline form of the ceramic. The precursor fibres were made infusible by heating in air, then heating to a higher temperature in a controlled atmosphere produced the ceramic fibre. Unfortunately, unlike in carbon fibre manufacture, the oxygen that was used to crosslink the polymer remained in the structure. The early fibres did not have the properties of bulk SiC due to the small (<2 nm) SiC grains being embedded in an amorphous matrix phase created by the presence of oxygen. A second generation of fibre was produced by Nippon Carbon, called Hi-Nicalon, for which oxygen was replaced by electron irradiation of the precursor so as to induce crosslinking. This fibre had enhanced properties but still not those of fully crystalline SiC (Berger et al., 1995). A third generation of SiC fibres has emerged with almost fully sintered structures (Bunsell and Piant, 2006) and these fibres retain their properties up to 1400°C. The manufacturers of these latest SiC fibres are the Japanese companies Nippon Carbon and Ube Industries as well as the American company COI Ceramics. Table 1.7 gives some of the properties of the three generations of SiC-based fibres.
Table 1.7 Examples of the three generations of SiC-based fibres Trade mark Manufacturer Average Room diameter temperature (µm) strength (GPa)
Room temperature Young’s modulus (GPa)
First gen. Second gen. Third gen.
Nicalon 200 Hi-Nicalon
Nippon Carbon 14 Nippon Carbon 12
3 2.8
200 270
Tyranno SA3 Sylramic Sylramic iBN Hi-Nicalon Type-S
Ube Industries 7.5 COI Ceramics 10 COI Ceramics 10 Nippon Carbon 12
2.9 3.2 3.5 2.5
375 400 400 400
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 29
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
30
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
1.9
Conclusions
There exist fibres to reinforce all classes of materials – elastomers, polymers, metals and ceramics – so that composite materials cover the whole spectrum of structural materials. They are also found in some structures which experience extremes in temperature. The reinforcements often bring to the composites their remarkable properties which can be indispensible for certain types of applications. The properties of the fibres depend on the elements from which they are made and these are generally found at the beginning of the Periodic Table, which means that they are light in weight. Strength and stiffness are not linked to density so that the fibres allow lightweight composite structures to be made and this has been the most important characteristic sought for many applications. However, the fineness of the fibres also allows structures to be envisaged that otherwise would be difficult to produce, so that manufacturing considerations can be a reason for using fibre-reinforced materials. Fibres are extraordinary forms of reinforcement and their properties have allowed composites to be developed and have enabled a remarkable revolution in structural materials to occur.
1.10
References
Bacon R (1973) Chemistry and Physics of Carbon, Vol. 2, Marcel Dekker, New York. Bansal N P (2005) Oxide Fibers – Handbook of Ceramic Composites, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, MA. Berger M-H, Hochet N and Bunsell A R (1995) J. Microscopy, 177(3), 230–241. Bunsell A R, ed. (2009) Handbook of Tensile Properties of Textile and Technical Fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, and CRC Press, Washington, DC. Bunsell A R and Berger M-H (1999) Fine Ceramic Fibers, Marcel Dekker, New York. Bunsell A R and Piant A (2006) J. Mater. Sci. 41, 823–839. Bunsell A R and Renard J (2005) Fundamentals of Fibre Reinforced Composite Materials, CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group, London and Boca Raton, FL. Deleglise F, Berger M-H and Bunsell A R (2002) J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 22, 1501–1512. Jones F R (2009) ‘Structure and properties of glass fibres’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Handbook of Tensile Properties of textile and technical fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 529–573. Lafitte M H and Bunsell A R (1985) Polym. Eng. Sci., 25(3) 182–186. Lavin J G (2000) ‘Carbon fibres’ in Hearle J W S (ed.), High Performance Fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 156–190. Matsuhisa Y and Bunsell A R (2009) ‘Tensile failure of carbon fibers’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Handbook of Tensile Properties of textile and technical fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 574–602. Moncrieff R W (1982) Man-Made Fibres, 6th ed., Butterworth Scientific, London. Morton W E and Hearle J W S (2008) Physical Properties of textile fibres, 4th ed., Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 30
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
Fibres for composite reinforcement
31
Norita T, Kitano A and Noguchi K (1988) ‘Compressive strength of fiber reinforced composite materials – Effect of fiber properties’, 4th Japan–US Conference on Composite Materials, 548. Oberlin A and Guigon M (1988) ‘The structure of carbon fibres’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Fibre Reinforcements for Composite Materials, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 149–210. Pergoretti A and Traina M (2009) ‘Liquid crystalline organic fibres and their mechanical behaviour’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Handbook of tensile properties of textile and technical fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 354–436. Vlasblom M P and van Dingenen J L J (2009) ‘The manufacture, properties and applications of high strength, high modulus polyethylene fibers’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Handbook of tensile properties of textile and technical fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 437–485. Volk H F (1975) ‘High performance carbon fibers and cloth from pitch’ in Scala E et al. (eds), Proc. 1975 Conf. on Composite Materials, Vol. 1, 64–69. Wawner F E (1988) ‘Boron and silicon carbide fibers’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Fibre Reinforcements for Composite Materials, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 371–426. Wilson D (2009) ‘The structure and tensile properties of continuous oxide fibers’ in Bunsell A R (ed.), Handbook of Tensile Properties of Textile and Technical Fibres, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, UK, 626–650. Yajima S, Okamura K, Hayashi J and Omori M (1976) J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 59, 324– 327.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-01.indd 31
9/6/11 4:38:19 PM
2
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
A. W. K. M a, University of Connecticut, USA and F. C h i n e s t a, Ecole Centrale de Nantes, France
Abstract: Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) belong to a novel class of nanoscale fibers. Their high aspect ratio and superior physical properties make them an appealing candidate to be incorporated into polymeric materials for mechanical reinforcement and conductivity enhancement. This chapter provides an overview of the development of CNT polymer composites. We first discuss the structure and physical properties of CNTs as individual nanoscale entities. We then review different techniques available for processing them into composites and the challenges involved. Two different flow models are introduced, and we conclude this chapter by discussing the performance and potential applications of some CNT polymer composites. Key words: carbon nanotube, flow modeling, polymer composite, processing.
2.1
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs)
2.1.1
Structure and properties
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) are rolled cylinders of graphene sheets having one or multiple layers.1 Single-walled CNTs (SWNTs), with one layer of graphene, can be metallic or semi-conducting, depending on how the graphene sheet is rolled up into a cylinder2,3 (Fig. 2.1). All existing synthesis methods produce a mixture of SWNTs with different diameters and electronic properties. This poses one of the biggest hurdles in using CNTs for electronic applications.4–6 Producing large quantities, say grams, of a single electronic type of SWNTs, through growth7,8 or subsequent separation,9,10 remains an active research area. There is always a certain length and diameter distribution in a CNT sample, meaning that CNTs are ‘polydispersed’ in terms of both diameter and length. Diameter of SWNTs typically varies from 0.4 nm to 5 nm, whereas that of multi-walled CNTs (MWNTs) varies from 1.4 nm to >100 nm. As-produced SWNTs are found as bundles (Fig. 2.2), where the SWNTs are held together by van der Waals forces,11 making it difficult to obtain a uniform dispersion with ordinary solvents and mixing methods (see Section 2.2.2). Lengths of CNTs typically vary from hundreds of nanometers 32 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 32
9/6/11 4:42:30 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
33
2.1 Different types (zig-zag, chiral, and armchair) of single-walled CNTs (SWNTs) can be conceptualized as graphene sheets rolled up into a cylinder at different angles. Image produced by Michael Ströck.
to hundreds of microns, but millimeter12 and centimeter13 long CNTs have also been reported. Table 2.1 summarizes some of the physical properties of CNTs. Individual CNTs have high tensile strength (~37 GPa), high modulus (~1 TPa), and yet low density (~1.4 g/cm3). They are ballistic conductors, where no heat is dissipated during conduction. As a result, they can carry a current density of 109 A/cm2 or even higher, orders of magnitude larger than normal metals (~105 A/cm2). CNTs are semi-flexible filaments with a persistence length on the order of tens of microns,14 larger than that of rigid-rod polymers (p-phenylene terephthalamides (PPTA): 30 nm and poly(p-phenylene-2,6benzobisoxazole) (PBO): 60–120 nm), but can undergo reptation – snakelike slithering motion – in a confined environment.15 Recently, SWNT has been used as a model system to confirm the ‘reptation theory’ proposed by P. G. de Gennes for polymer. In many ways, CNTs behave like a rigid-rod
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 33
9/6/11 4:42:30 PM
34
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
2.2 TEM of a bundle of SWNTs produced using the high-pressure carbon monoxide disproportionation (HiPco) method. Reproduced with permission from Chemical Physics Letters, Elsevier. Table 2.1 Physical properties of CNTs
CNT
Density Tensile strength Young’s modulus Thermal conductivity Electrical resistivity Current-carrying capacity Persistence length
Refs 3
1.4 g/cm (for SWNT) 37 GPa 6, 25 1 TPa 25 1750–5800 W/m K 26 <10–4 W cm 27 >109 A/cm2 6 26–138 μm (depending on CNT diameter and number of walls) 14
polymer and have been referred to as the ‘ultimate polymer’ given their superior properties.16,17 Similar to rigid-rod polymers like PPTA and PBO or nanorods like tobacco mosaic virus, CNTs can phase transition to liquid crystals when dispersed at high concentration in liquids.18–22 From the liquid crystalline state with orientational order, CNTs can be further processed into ordered films23 and aligned fibers.21,24
2.1.2
Synthesis and costs
There are various ways of producing CNTs. CNTs can be produced by applying high voltage (known as the ‘electric arc discharge’ method25) or
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 34
9/6/11 4:42:30 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
35
striking a high-purity graphitic source with one or two laser beams (known as the ‘laser ablation method’26). Alternatively, CNTs can be produced from catalytic reactions of a wide range of hydrocarbons.11,13,27–29 Catalyst particles can be pre-patterned onto a substrate or produced in situ during the synthesis by introducing catalyst precursor as an aerosol. The latter is also known as the ‘floating catalyst’ method.29 Different methods give different yields and different levels of purity; the diameter and length distributions of CNTs also vary accordingly. Typical impurities are fullerenes, metal catalyst residues, amorphous carbon, and graphitic particles (in the case of laser ablation-produced CNTs). Combination of techniques such as filtration, centrifugation, thermal oxidation and acid digestion has been developed to remove impurities.30–33 Caution, however, should be taken because some of these purification techniques create defects, introduce chemical functional groups, and/or shorten CNTs.34–36 Current cost data for as-produced SWNTs and MWNTs from different sources are provided in Table 2.2. Although MWNTs are usually more defective than SWNTs, MWNTs have received more attention for composite applications, mainly because of their lower material costs.
2.2
Carbon nanotube (CNT) polymer composites
2.2.1
Early development
P. M. Ajayan (formerly Université Paris-Sud, now Rice University), H. D. Wagner (Weizmann Institute of Science, Israel), and their co-workers were among the first to study CNT composites. Ajayan et al.37 embedded CNTs in epoxy and realized that some of the CNTs can be aligned by cutting the CNT epoxy composite into thin slices (50–200 nm). A few years later, there were some studies on stress transfer in CNT composite.38–41 Like conventional carbon fiber composites, Raman spectroscopy has proven to be a powerful tool in understanding the stress transfer in CNT polymer composites. Wagner et al.38 measured the compression of CNT with Raman spectroscopy during the cooling of a CNT epoxy composite, and deduced the Young’s moduli for the embedded SWNT and MWNT. Schadler et al.39 noticed a difference in Young’s modulus under tension and under compression, and hypothesized Table 2.2 Current cost data for CNTs Manufacturer
Synthesis method
Price (US$/g)
Purity
Carbon Solutions SouthWest Nano Technologies (SweNT) Nanocyl
Electric arc discharge method CO disproportionation (with Co and Mo as catalyst) Catalytic carbon vapor deposition
$50/g (SWNT) 40–60% $750/g (SWNT); >90% $5/g (MWNT) $6–$485/g Varies (SWNT, MWNT)
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 35
9/6/11 4:42:31 PM
36
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
that only the outer layer of an MWNT is in tension and that the difference is due to poor stress transfer into inner layers. In 1999, Calvert published a review on early development work of CNT composite.42 As succinctly pointed out in the review, several pioneers soon realized the challenges involved in the development of CNT polymer composite, namely (1) to disperse CNT bundles and (2) to improve interfacial interaction between the matrix and the CNT. As shown in Fig. 2.3, the field of CNT polymer composite expanded rapidly after 2000 as CNTs become more readily available, thanks to advances in more efficient and larger-scale synthesis. To date, there is a wealth of literature data on blending CNTs with different types of thermosets and thermoplastics; a comprehensive list of various CNT-polymer systems can be found in a recent review paper by Bose et al.43
2.2.2
Processing techniques
The first step in processing CNT polymer composite usually involves mixing CNTs into a low-viscosity solvent or directly blending them into polymer melts using a twin-screw mixer44,45 (Fig. 2.4). Nevertheless, mechanical mixing does not always guarantee a uniform dispersion, given the tendency of CNTs to aggregate.46–48 There are some techniques to facilitate the 160 145 140
Number of publications
120
115
100
89
80
70
60
54 40
40
31
20 0
140
16 1
2
4
6
5
1994 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 Year
2.3 Number of journal article publications per year in CNT polymer composite from 1994 to 2010. A total of 723 article publications were obtained from Web of Knowledge using “Title= (nanotube or CNT) AND Topic= (composite and polymer)” as the search phrase.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 36
9/6/11 4:42:31 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
37
Carbon nanotube (Number of walls, diameter, length, polydispersity, chemistry)
Purification (Thermal oxidation, acid wash, etc.)
Polymer matrix (Chemical functionality, viscosity)
Dispersion (Sonication, high shear mixing, twin screw mixer, etc.)
Material forming (Solvent evaporation, photo/thermal curing, in-situ polymerizatin, extrusion, etc.)
Composite fibers, films (Level of dispersion, CNT alignment, physical properties)
2.4 Typical steps involved in producing CNT polymer composites.
dispersion of CNTs, namely sonication in surfactant solutions, high shear mixing, and chemical functionalization.35,49–51 Unfortunately, many of these techniques are ineffective in debundling CNTs and are destructive – they shorten the length of CNTs, disrupt the pristine sp2 hybridization, and impair their intrinsic properties. One unusual and yet effective way to disperse CNTs is to use strong acids.21,52,53 CNTs are found to be soluble in oleum (sulfuric acid saturated with SO3), chlorosulfonic acid, and their mixtures, and can be further spun into neat solid fibers.21,44,45,54 Interestingly, notable high-performance PPTA fibers (DuPont’s Kevlar® and Teijin’s Twaron® fibers) have been produced using a similar method – by spinning from highconcentration solutions of PPTA in oleum. The effectiveness of dispersion depends largely on the choice of polymer matrix (chemistry and viscosity), the chemical functionality of the CNTs, and the mixing method.39,44 Several research groups have been active in establishing the understanding of the flow behavior of CNT in a wide range of polymeric liquids or melts: Dr Petra Pötschke (Leibniz Institute), Erik Hobbie (formerly NIST, now North Dakota State University), Professor Malcolm Mackley (University of Cambridge), and Professor Matteo Pasquali (Rice University). The current understanding is that low simple shear flow induces aggregation of CNTs that are attractive in nature.46,55,56 An extreme example is the experimental observation of a highly anisotropic type of aggregates in confinement.57 High shear flow disentangles CNT aggregates
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 37
9/6/11 4:42:31 PM
38
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
and subsequently aligns CNTs in the shear direction,47,58,59 but compared to simple shear flow with a rotational component, extensional flows are more effective in aligning CNTs.60 One important question is how to assess the uniformity of dispersion.44 Light microscopy is useful for assessing dispersion quality at the micron scale. Although individual CNTs are nanoscale objects, they absorb light strongly,61,62 and poor CNT dispersions usually contain large aggregates that are optically resolvable.57 For assessing dispersion quality on a nanoscale, electron microscopy is needed,63,64 but a solid specimen is preferred and the results can be partial. For liquid samples, one interesting idea is to use rheology. It should be noted that judging the degree of mixing based merely on the value of the storage modulus from visoelasticity measurements can be misleading.44 The proper way to do this is to measure the (complex) viscosity as a function of mixing time.50 The minimum mixing time required for a certain mixing method is determined as the mixing time beyond which the viscosity reading becomes steady. It is best to use more than one technique to get an accurate picture of dispersion quality, given the limitations of each of them. After dispersion, a mixture of CNT and polymer melts can be extruded directly into fibers or films. For solvent-based mixing, the solvent is usually removed by evaporation, followed by an in situ polymerization process.65,66 For thermoset systems, the monomers are usually crosslinked using photoor thermal curing.47,63 It is interesting to note that CNTs absorb UV light strongly, and can increase the curing time significantly as a result.47,67 Nevertheless, like carbon black, the added CNTs can protect the composite against photo-degradation.58 There are several research groups capable of producing neat CNT fibers and films,54,68,69 and one can further impregnate these structures with polymer resin.
2.2.3
Flow modeling of functionalized and nonaggregating CNTs
Chemically functionalizing CNTs can prevent aggregation, and the flow model of a dilute or semi-dilute suspension of non-aggregating CNTs in a Newtonian matrix is similar to the one developed for short fiber suspensions.58 The momentum balance equation, neglecting the mass and inertia terms, reads: div s = 0 2.1 where s is the total stress tensor. The mass balance equation for an incompressible fluid gives:
div v = 0
2.2
where v is the velocity field. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 38
9/6/11 4:42:31 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
39
The constitutive equation for a dilute suspension with high-aspect-ratio (>1000) rigid CNTs can be written as s = –PI + 2hD + f = –PI +
2.3
where P denotes the pressure, I is the unit tensor, h is the matrix viscosity, D is the strain rate tensor (symmetric component of the velocity gradient tensor) and sf is the anisotropic viscous component of the stress tensor due to the presence of fibers. The suspension microstructure is defined by CNT orientation. It is assumed that the CNTs are ellipsoidal and rigid and that they are immersed in a Newtonian matrix whose kinematics is defined by its velocity field. If p denotes the unit vector aligned in the CNT axis direction, then its evolution will be given by the Jeffery equation:70 dp = W · p + k D · p – k (D :(p ƒ p))p dt
2.4
l 2 – 1, l is the CNT aspect ratio (length to diameter ratio), and where k = 2 l +1 Ω denotes the vorticity tensor. The tensor product ƒ of vectors a and b is defined as (a ƒ b)ij = aibj, and ‘:’ denotes the tensor product contracted twice (i.e. (a : b) = ∑∑aijbji). Although the Jeffery equation was first proposed for an isolated fiber immersed in a Newtonian fluid, it can be applied to a population of fibers or CNTs if the suspension is dilute and the interaction between CNTs is negligible. However, defining the fluid microstructure using the orientation of each CNT in the suspension is not helpful for the formulation of a mesoscale model. Instead, a more useful way of describing the microstructure is to use a kinetic theory approach which introduces an orientation distribution function y(x, p, t) such that y(x, p, t)db represents the probability of finding, at point x and time t, a CNT whose orientation is within the interval defined by p and p + dp. In this expression, the physical coordinates (x, t) (space and time) can be distinguished from the conformation coordinate, p, which describes the orientation defined on the unit surface S(0,1). This distribution function satisfies the normality condition:
ÚS(0,1) y (x, p, t ) dp = 1, "x, "t
2.5
The consideration of an orientation distribution function allows certain moments to be defined, namely the second-order moment, also known as the second-order orientation tensor: a(x, t ) =
ÚS(0,1) p ƒ p y (x, p, t ) dp
2.6
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 39
9/6/11 4:42:32 PM
40
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
and the fourth-order moment, also known as the fourth-order orientation tensor: A(x, t ) =
ÚS(0,1) p ƒ p ƒ p ƒ p y (x, p, t ) dp
2.7
The evolution of the orientation distribution function is governed by the Fokker–Planck equation: dy Ê ∂p ˆ Ê ∂y ˆ + ∂ y = ∂ d dt dpÁË dt ˜¯ ∂p ÁË r ∂p ˜¯
2.8
where the advection field dp/dt is given by the Jeffery equation (Eq. 2.4), and dy/dt is the material derivative, i.e. dy ∂y = + v · grad xy dt ∂t
2.9
∂y ∂x
2.10
where grad xy =
dr given in Eq. 2.8 is the rotary diffusion coefficient of the CNTs and is a key parameter to describe the balance between flow-induced alignment and orientation randomizing events such as thermal Brownian motion. For CNTs suspended within epoxy (10 Pa.s), dr was determined to be on the order of 0.005 s–1, consistent with theoretical predictions.71 Deriving a constitutive equation for non-aggregating CNT suspension involves the use of spatial homogenization and statistical averaging. Together with other simplifying hypotheses for high-aspect-ratio fibers, the stress tensor f due to the presence of CNTs is defined: Iˆ Ê t f = 2hN p (A : D) + b dr Á a – ˜ 3¯ Ë
2.11
where Np is a scalar parameter that depends on CNT concentration and aspect ratio whereas in dilute suspensions b is a parameter that depends on the number concentration of CNTs and viscous drag coefficient.72 The second term on the right-hand side of Eq. 2.11 essentially accounts for the effect of Brownian motion, but in general, other randomizing events such as CNT–CNT hydrodynamic interaction can be accounted for by replacing dr with an ‘effective diffusion term’. Neglecting the Brownian contribution gives a shear stress: 12 = hg· + 2hNpA1212g· 2.12 where A1212 is the 1.2–1.2 component of the fourth-order tensor A and we can define the apparent viscosity:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 40
9/6/11 4:42:32 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
ha =
t 12 = h(1 + 2N p A1212 ) g
41
2.13
This simple model is able to describe experimental findings as shown in Fig. 2.5. 1000
8 Dr = 0.005 s–1 Np
6 4 2
100 ha [Pa.s
Np = 7
0 0
Np = 4
0.2 Conc. [%]
0.4
10 Epoxy 0.05% CNT 0.2% CNT 0.33% CNT
Np = 0.5
1 0.01
0.1
1 · g R [s–1] (a)
10
100
100
ha [Pa.s
Np = 7 Dr = 0.01 s–1 Dr = 0.005 s–1
10 Dr = 0.0025 s–1 0.01
0.1
1 · g R [s–1] (b)
10
100
2.5 (a) Orientation model fitting of 0.05%, 0.2% and 0.33% functionalized non-aggregating CNTs suspended in epoxy resin. Np and Dr are the fitting parameters. (b) Sensitivity of the model to Dr given the experimental data of 0.33% treated CNT suspension and Np = 7. Reprinted with permission from Journal of Rheology 53(3), 547 (2009). Copyright 2009, The Society of Rheology.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 41
9/6/11 4:42:33 PM
42
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
2.2.4
Flow modeling of aggregating CNTs
The orientation model described in Section 2.2.3 fails to capture the experimentally observed shear-thinning characteristic for aggregating CNT suspensions. A different model named the Aggregation/Orientation (AO) model has been developed.48 The AO model considers a hierarchy of CNT aggregate structures within an untreated CNT suspension, where the shear viscosity is controlled by the state of aggregation and CNT orientation. The Fokker–Planck description is modified to incorporate aggregation/ disaggregation kinetics and a detailed derivation for the AO model is included in this section. The aggregation/orientation distribution function in the AO model is written as y(x, t, p, n), where n Œ [0,1] describes the state of aggregation (n = 0 corresponds to CNTs that are free from entanglement and n = 1 represents a CNT aggregate network). It is assumed that the flow is steady and homogeneous and that different populations (n) are present within the control volume considered in the balance equation. In more complex flow situations where spatial flow inhomogeneity is present, the material derivative in the Fokker–Planck equation contains the orientation distribution function gradient and it does not reduce to the temporal partial derivative. Such spatial dependence does not introduce great difficulties in numerical modeling and is commonly encountered in the simulation of forming processes involving flows in complex geometries. For an arbitrary population n (where n ≠ 0 nor 1), the population increases as a result of the aggregation of smaller aggregates (r < n) or the disaggregation of larger aggregates (r > n). On the other hand, the population n decreases because of the disaggregation of population n forming less entangled aggregates (r < n) or the aggregation of n forming more entangled aggregates (r > n). The aggregation kinetics involves an aggregation velocity (vc) as well as a disaggregation velocity (vd). The resulting balance equation related to the distribution function reads:
{
} {
}
Ï ∂ ∂y (p, n ) ¸ dp ∂ Ì– ∂p y (p, n ) dt + ∂p dr (n ) ∂p ˝ Ó ˛ Ïv r =n y (p, r )dr + v r =1 y (p, r )dr ¸ dÚ Ô c Úr =0 Ô r =n +Ì =0 r =n r =1 ˝ Ô– vdy (p, n ) Ú dr – vcy (p, n ) Ú d r Ô dr r =0 r =n ˛ Ó
2.14
The distribution function y(p, n) can be obtained by solving Eq. 2.14 and the fourth-order orientation tensor can be expressed as: A(n ) = Ú p ƒ p ƒ p ƒ p y (p, n ) dp
2.15
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 42
9/6/11 4:42:33 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
43
The stress contribution due to the presence of CNTs for a multi-population system can be obtained by generalizing Eq. 2.11:
t f = 2h
1
Ú0
N p (n )(A(n ) : D) dn
2.16
The rheological model described above provides a first approximation for describing a suspension with aggregating CNTs and contains four parameters: the concentration and aspect-ratio parameter Np, the rotary diffusion coefficient (dr) and the aggregation and disaggregation velocities (vc and vd). To simplify the analysis and minimize the degrees of freedom, the following assumptions are made, but other more complex models could be proposed: 1. Np varies linearly with the population variable n. If we assume that N pmin << N pmax and that N pmin ª 0, then Np(n) ª N pmaxn (see Eq. 2.17a below). (note: N pmin = Np (n = 0) and N pmax = Np (n = 1).) 2. In the modeling of associative polymers, a number of authors have assumed that chains within an aggregate network can undergo affine deformation and therefore dr(n = 1) ª 0. In the case of CNT suspensions, there is, however, experimental evidence showing that the opposite is true.57,61 CNT aggregates tend to rotate in simple shear flow, and CNTs within aggregate are more isotropically oriented compared with disentangled CNTs. The rotary diffusion coefficient is therefore assumed to increase linearly with the population n as given in Eq. 2.17b. 3. vd increases linearly with the shear rate and takes the form as given in Eq. 2.17c below, where g·max is a characteristic shear rate above which the suspension viscosity coincides with the matrix viscosity. At high shear rates, vd remains constant and vd = vdmax (2.17d). 4. vc decreases linearly with the shear rate and takes the form as given in Eq. 2.17e. For a shear rate higher than g·max, the aggregation velocity becomes zero (Eq. 2.17f). ÏN p (n ) = N pmax n + N pmin (1 – n) n ª N pmax n Ô max Ôdr (n ) = dr n Ô Ï Ô max Ê g ˆ if g ≤ g max Ôv (g ) = ÔÔ vd ÁË g max ˜¯ Ì Ôd Ì Ô v max if g > g max Ô ÓÔ d Ô Ï Ô max – g ˆ max Ê g max Ôv (g ) = ÔÌ vc ÁË g max ˜¯ if g ≤ g max Ôc Ô 0 if g > g max ÔÓ Ó
2.17a 2.17b 2.17c 2.17d 2.17e 2.17f
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 43
9/6/11 4:42:34 PM
44
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
The AO model has been tested against the experimental evolution of apparent steady shear viscosity for four different concentrations of untreated CNT suspensions (0.025%, 0.05%, 0.1%, and 0.25%), and reasonable fitting results have been obtained (Fig. 2.6).
2.2.5
Challenges and trends in modeling CNT composite systems
The models described in the previous sections (2.2.3 and 2.2.4) can capture the flow-induced microstructure evolution for CNTs suspended within a Newtonian matrix. Strictly speaking, such models should not be applied to suspensions with a viscoelastic matrix, even though one might still be able to fit the models to experimental data. For instance, it is well known in the context of short fiber suspensions that the Jeffery equation is only valid for Newtonian fluid flows. However, the equation has been practically applied to simulate processes involving thermoplastic which clearly exhibits viscoelastic behavior, and in some cases the predictions agree reasonably well with the experimental findings. Modeling the flow of CNTs through a porous medium is of high relevance to industrial forming processes such as injecting CNT/resin into preformed structures within a mold. There are two major difficulties, and they constitute an active area of research: (1) The flow induced orientation of CNT occurring on microscopic scale, within micro-channels with complex topologies, and (2) CNT concentration varies as a function of flow-path length as some of the CNTs are retained (‘filtered out’) by the micro-channels in preformed structures. Microscopic flow analysis is necessary if one is interested in evaluating the induced orientation, because the orientation distribution depends on the local flow kinematics. It is important to recall that in many applications CNTs enhance electrical conductivity, and in the case of composite laminates an out-of-plane CNTs orientation is required for obtaining the conduction in the transverse direction. Concerning the filtration of CNTs, different types of filtration kinetics have been proposed. It is commonly assumed that both the retention and the resuspension rates are proportional to the amount of CNTs passing through and retained respectively. By further assuming that resuspension of retained CNTs is insignificant, the retention will depend only on the velocity and concentration of CNTs in the flow. In addition to resin transfer molding, it is also possible to use infusion techniques with shorter flow path-lines, or direct incorporation of CNTs into pre-impregnated thermostable or thermoplastic sheets. It is important to understand and model complex CNT flows in these different forming processes to ensure a good dispersion and precise control over orientation distribution in the conformed parts.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 44
9/6/11 4:42:34 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
1 0.1
10
100
1 Shear rate (s–1] (a) 0.25% CNT
1 Shear rate (s–1] (c) 0.05% CNT
N pmax = 208 Drmax = 1 ¥ 10–4 s–1 b = 350
10 0.1
100
10
10
N pmax = 1339 Drmax = 5 ¥ 10–5 s–1 b = 182
1 Shear rate (s–1] (b) 0.1% CNT
10
10
N pmax = 556 Drmax = 3.58 ¥ 10–5 s–1 b = 222
1 Shear rate (s–1] (d) 0.025% CNT
N pmax = 23 Drmax = 0.0541 s–1 b = 907 1 0.1
10
100
10 0.1
100
1000
2.6 Aggregation/Orientation (AO) model fitting to experimental ha data at different CNT concentration levels: (a) 0.25%, (b) 0.1%, (c) 0.05% and (d) 0.025%. Experimental data are represented by unfilled circles () and the best-fit values of max max x Npmax , Drmax and b = v dma /v cmax were obtained from least-square fitting. (Npmax a and gmax in Eq. 2.17 were set to 0 and 100 –1 s respectively.) Reprinted with permission from Journal of Rheology 52(6) 1311 (2008). Copyright 2008, The Society of Rheology.
ha [Pa.s]
ha [Pa.s]
1000
ha [Pa.s] ha [Pa.s]
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 45
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
46
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
2.3
Performance and applications
One appealing attribute of CNTs is their high aspect ratio (>1000), and their capability of forming a percolating network at relatively low concentration (compared to carbon black and carbon fibers).6 Sandler et al.73 achieved a conductivity of 10–2 S/m at a loading of 0.1 vol%, whilst a conductivity of 10–6 S/m is sufficient for electrostatic dissipation applications. Another potential application is to introduce a small amount of CNTs into automotive composites to facilitate the electropainting process. The electrical conductivity of CNT composites depends on type of microstructure present, which in turns depends on the the chemical pre-treatment of CNTs43 and the application of external fields (flow, electric, and magnetic) during processing.44 Hightemperature annealing can improve electrical conductivity in processed CNT polymer composite by allowing CNTs to connect better.74 This observation is in line with an argument put forward by Zakri and Poulin75 that weakly attractive CNTs are more efficient in forming a percolating network. For mechanical reinforcement, in 1999 Andrews et al.76 created a composite from CNT and petroleum pitch and reported that incorporating 5 wt% CNT increased the tensile strength and Young’s modulus by 90% and 150% respectively. Their composite fibers had a tensile strength of ~830 MPa and a modulus of ~78 GPa. A year later, P. Poulin (Université Bordeaux, France) and co-workers reported the production of high-loading CNT composite fibers by first dispersing CNTs in a surfactant solution and then condensing the CNTs in a polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) solution.77 Their composite fibers had a tensile strength of 150 MPa and a Young’s modulus of 9–15 GPa. Attempts have also been made to combine CNT with rigid-rod polymers like PBO and PPTA. Kumar et al.78 published the result of PBO/SWNT composites, and reported a 50% increase in tensile strength for PBO fibers containing 10% of SWNT. More recently, Deng et al.79 observed that CNT only marginally improved the mechanical properties of the PPTA/SWNT (by ~15%) at a low fiber draw ratio. At higher draw ratios, the orientation of polymer decreased and the mechanical properties degraded. In general, CNTs can be used for applications where carbon fibers prevail. Additionally, CNT polymer composite can potentially be used for electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding,80 photo-degradation protection,67 fire retardation 81, sensing,82 and solar cell applications.83 Nevertheless, there are only a few examples of CNT polymer composite being currently used in commercial products, such as in sporting equipment and high-end yachts. Market penetration of CNT polymer composite is slow, mainly because of the high costs of CNTs compared with other traditional materials such as carbon fibers and carbon black. Even though a smaller amount of CNT is needed to achieve similar performance, CNT polymer composite may not pass the cost/benefit test. In the short term, lowering costs of CNT will definitely
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 46
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
47
expedite the commercial application of CNT polymer composites. For highend applications, the quality and precise control over CNT diameter, length, and electronic properties still remain a grand challenge. Like the development of carbon fiber composite, continuing efforts have been made to improve the interfacial interaction between CNT and the matrix through chemical functionalization.43,84 There is also a trend of combining CNT with other nanostructures (such as graphene and fullerene) to create novel, functional 3-D composite structures.85
2.4
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
7.
8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
References
S. Iijima, Nature 354 (6348), 56–58 (1991). M. S. Dresselhaus and P. Avouris, Carbon Nanotubes 80, 1–9 (2001). M. S. Dresselhaus, G. Dresselhaus and R. Saito, Carbon 33 (7), 883–891 (1995). C. Dekker, Physics Today 52 (5), 22–28 (1999). P. Avouris, Accounts of Chemical Research 35 (12), 1026–1034 (2002). R. H. Baughman, A. A. Zakhidov and W. A. de Heer, Science 297 (5582), 787–792 (2002). A. R. Harutyunyan, G. Chen, T. M. Paronyan, E. M. Pigos, O. A. Kuznetsov, K. Hewaparakrama, S. M. Kim, D. Zakharov, E. A. Stach and G. U. Sumanasekera, Science 326 (5949), 116–120 (2009). R. E. Smalley, Y. Li, V. C. Moore, B. K. Price, R. Colorado, H. K. Schmidt, R. H. Hauge, A. R. Barron and J. M. Tour, Journal of the American Chemical Society 128 (49), 15824–15829 (2006). R. Krupke, F. Hennrich, H. v. Lohneysen and M. M. Kappes, Science 301 (5631), 344–347 (2003). M. S. Arnold, A. A. Green, J. F. Hulvat, S. I. Stupp and M. C. Hersam, Nature Nanotechnology 1 (1), 60–65 (2006). P. Nikolaev, M. J. Bronikowski, R. K. Bradley, F. Rohmund, D. T. Colbert, K. A. Smith and R. E. Smalley, Chemical Physics Letters 313 (1–2), 91–97 (1999). S. M. Huang, X. Y. Cai and J. Liu, Journal of the American Chemical Society 125 (19), 5636–5637 (2003). H. W. Zhu, C. L. Xu, D. H. Wu, B. Q. Wei, R. Vajtai and P. M. Ajayan, Science 296 (5569), 884–886 (2002). N. Fakhri, D. A. Tsyboulski, L. Cognet, R. B. Weisman and M. Pasquali, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106 (34), 14219–14223 (2009). N. Fakhri, F. C. MacKintosh, B. Lounis, L. Cognet and M. Pasquali, Science 330 (6012), 1804–1807 (2010). M. S. P. Shaffer and A. H. Windle, Macromolecules 32 (20), 6864–6866 (1999). M. J. Green, N. Behabtu, M. Pasquali and W. W. Adams, Polymer 50 (21), 4979–4997 (2009). S. Badaire, C. Zakri, M. Maugey, A. Derre, J. N. Barisci, G. Wallace and P. Poulin, Advanced Materials 17 (13), 1673–1676 (2005). W. H. Song, I. A. Kinloch and A. H. Windle, Science 302 (5649), 1363–1363 (2003). S. E. Moulton, M. Maugey, P. Poulin and G. G. Wallace, Journal of the American Chemical Society 129 (30), 9452–9457 (2007).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 47
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
48
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
21. L. M. Ericson, H. Fan, H. Q. Peng, V. A. Davis, W. Zhou, J. Sulpizio, Y. H. Wang, R. Booker, J. Vavro, C. Guthy, A. N. G. Parra-Vasquez, M. J. Kim, S. Ramesh, R. K. Saini, C. Kittrell, G. Lavin, H. Schmidt, W. W. Adams, W. E. Billups, M. Pasquali, W. F. Hwang, R. H. Hauge, J. E. Fischer and R. E. Smalley, Science 305 (5689), 1447–1450 (2004). 22. V. A. Davis, L. M. Ericson, A. N. G. Parra-Vasquez, H. Fan, Y. H. Wang, V. Prieto, J. A. Longoria, S. Ramesh, R. K. Saini, C. Kittrell, W. E. Billups, W. W. Adams, R. H. Hauge, R. E. Smalley and M. Pasquali, Macromolecules 37 (1), 154–160 (2004). 23. H. Shimoda, S. J. Oh, H. Z. Geng, R. J. Walker, X. B. Zhang, L. E. McNeil and O. Zhou, Advanced Materials 14 (12), 899–901 (2002). 24. V. A. Davis, A. N. G. Parra-Vasquez, M. J. Green, P. K. Rai, N. Behabtu, V. Prieto, R. D. Booker, J. Schmidt, E. Kesselman, W. Zhou, H. Fan, W. W. Adams, R. H. Hauge, J. E. Fischer, Y. Cohen, Y. Talmon, R. E. Smalley and M. Pasquali, Nature Nanotechnology 4 (12), 830–834 (2009). 25. P. M. Ajayan, J. M. Lambert, P. Bernier, L. Barbedette, C. Colliex and J. M. Planeix, Chemical Physics Letters 215 (5), 509–517 (1993). 26. A. Thess, R. Lee, P. Nikolaev, H. Dai, P. Petit, J. Robert, C. Xu, Y. H. Lee, S. G. Kim, A. G. Rinzler, D. T. Colbert, G. E. Scuseria, D. Tomanek, J. E. Fischer and R. E. Smalley, Science 273 (5274), 483–487 (1996). 27. H. J. Dal, A. G. Rinzler, P. Nikolaev, A. Thess, D. T. Colbert and R. E. Smalley, Chemical Physics Letters 260 (3–4), 471–475 (1996). 28. Y. L. Li, L. H. Zhang, X. H. Zhong and A. H. Windle, Nanotechnology 18 (22), 225601–225606 (2007). 29. C. T. Kingston and B. Simard, Analytical Letters 36 (15), 3119–3145 (2003). 30. A. G. Rinzler, J. Liu, H. Dai, P. Nikolaev, C. B. Huffman, F. J. Rodriguez-Macias, P. J. Boul, A. H. Lu, D. Heymann, D. T. Colbert, R. S. Lee, J. E. Fischer, A. M. Rao, P. C. Eklund and R. E. Smalley, Applied Physics A – Materials Science & Processing 67 (1), 29–37 (1998). 31. J. Liu, A. G. Rinzler, H. Dai, J. H. Hafner, R. K. Bradley, P. J. Boul, A. Lu, T. Iverson, K. Shelimov, C. B. Huffman, F. Rodriguez-Macias, Y.-S. Shon, T. R. Lee, D. T. Colbert and R. E. Smalley, Science 280 (5367), 1253–1256 (1998). 32. S. Bandow, S. Asaka, X. Zhao and Y. Ando, Applied Physics A – Materials Science & Processing 67 (1), 23–27 (1998). 33. K. B. Shelimov, R. O. Esenaliev, A. G. Rinzler, C. B. Huffman and R. E. Smalley, Chemical Physics Letters 282 (5–6), 429–434 (1998). 34. A. Lucas, C. Zakri, M. Maugey, M. Pasquali, P. van der Schoot and P. Poulin, Journal of Physical Chemistry C 113 (48), 20599–20605 (2009). 35. I. A. Kinloch, S. A. Roberts and A. H. Windle, Polymer 43 (26), 7483–7491 (2002). 36. A. Garg and S. B. Sinnott, Chemical Physics Letters 295 (4), 273–278 (1998). 37. P. M. Ajayan, O. Stephan, C. Colliex and D. Trauth, Science 265 (5176), 1212–1214 (1994). 38. H. D. Wagner, O. Lourie, Y. Feldman and R. Tenne, Applied Physics Letters 72 (2), 188–190 (1998). 39. L. S. Schadler, S. C. Giannaris and P. M. Ajayan, Applied Physics Letters 73 (26), 3842–3844 (1998). 40. O. Lourie and H. D. Wagner, Journal of Materials Research 13 (9), 2418–2422 (1998).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 48
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
Carbon nanotube reinforcements for composites
49
41. C. Bower, R. Rosen, L. Jin, J. Han and O. Zhou, Applied Physics Letters 74 (22), 3317–3319 (1999). 42. P. Calvert, Nature 399 (6733), 210–211 (1999). 43. S. Bose, R. A. Khare and P. Moldenaers, Polymer 51 (5), 975–993 (2010). 44. A. W. K. Ma, K. M. Yearsley, F. Chinesta and M. R. Mackley, Proceedings of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers Part N: Journal of Nanoengineering and Nanosystems 222, 71–94 (2009). 45. P. Potschke, T. D. Fornes and D. R. Paul, Polymer 43 (11), 3247–3255 (2002). 46. S. Lin-Gibson, J. A. Pathak, E. A. Grulke, H. Wang and E. K. Hobbie, Physical Review Letters 92 (4), 048302 (2004). 47. A. W. K. Ma, M. R. Mackley and F. Chinesta, International Journal of Material Forming 1 (2), 75–81 (2008). 48. W. K. A. Ma, F. Chinesta, A. Ammar and M. R. Mackley, Journal of Rheology 52 (6), 1311–1330 (2008). 49. Y. Y. Huang and E. M. Terentjev, International Journal of Material Forming 2, 63–74 (2008). 50. Y. Y. Huang, S. V. Ahir and E. M. Terentjev, Physical Review B 73 (12), 125422 (2006). 51. D. Tasis, N. Tagmatarchis, V. Georgakilas and M. Prato, Chemistry – a European Journal 9 (17), 4001–4008 (2003). 52. S. Ramesh, L. M. Ericson, V. A. Davis, R. K. Saini, C. Kittrell, M. Pasquali, W. E. Billups, W. W. Adams, R. H. Hauge and R. E. Smalley, Journal of Physical Chemistry B 108 (26), 8794–8798 (2004). 53. W. Zhou, P. A. Heiney, H. Fan, R. E. Smalley and J. E. Fischer, Journal of the American Chemical Society 127 (6), 1640–1641 (2005). 54. V. A. Davis, PhD dissertation, Rice University, 2006. 55. E. K. Hobbie and D. J. Fry, Physical Review Letters 97 (3), 036101 (2006). 56. S. S. Rahatekar, K. K. K. Koziol, S. A. Butler, J. A. Elliott, M. S. P. Shaffer, M. R. Mackley and A. H. Windle, Journal of Rheology 50 (5), 599–610 (2006). 57. A. W. K. Ma, M. R. Mackley and S. S. Rahatekar, Rheologica Acta 46 (7), 979–987 (2007). 58. A. W. K. Ma, F. Chinesta and M. R. Mackley, Journal of Rheology 53 (3), 547–573 (2009). 59. A. W. K. Ma, F. Chinesta, M. R. Mackley and A. Ammar, International Journal of Material Forming 1 (2), 83–88 (2008). 60. A. W. K. Ma, F. Chinesta, T. Tuladhar and M. R. Mackley, Rheologica Acta 47 (4), 447–457 (2008). 61. S. Lin-Gibson, J. A. Pathak, E. A. Grulke, H. Wang and E. K. Hobbie, Physical Review Letters 92 (4) (2004). 62. Z. P. Yang, L. J. Ci, J. A. Bur, S. Y. Lin and P. M. Ajayan, Nano Letters 8 (2), 446–451 (2008). 63. Z. H. Fan and S. G. Advani, Polymer 46 (14), 5232–5240 (2005). 64. P. Pötschke, A. R. Bhattacharyya and A. Janke, European Polymer Journal 40 (1), 137–148 (2004). 65. Z. J. Jia, Z. Y. Wang, C. L. Xu, J. Liang, B. Q. Wei, D. H. Wu and S. W. Zhu, Materials Science and Engineering a – Structural Materials Properties Microstructure and Processing 271 (1–2), 395–400 (1999). 66. M. Moniruzzaman and K. I. Winey, Macromolecules 39 (16), 5194–5205 (2006). 67. A. W. K. Ma, PhD dissertation, University of Cambridge, 2009.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 49
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
50
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
68. Y. L. Li, I. A. Kinloch and A. H. Windle, Science 304 (5668), 276–278 (2004). 69. M. Zhang, K. R. Atkinson and R. H. Baughman, Science 306 (5700), 1358–1361 (2004). 70. G. B. Jeffery, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A – Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character 102 (715), 161–179 (1922). 71. M. Doi and S. S. Edwards, The Theory of Polymer dynamics (Clarendon, Oxford, 1986). 72. R. G. Larson, The Structure and Rheology of Complex fluids (Oxford University Press, New York and Oxford, 1999). 73. J. Sandler, M. S. P. Shaffer, T. Prasse, W. Bauhofer, K. Schulte and A. H. Windle, Polymer 40 (21), 5967–5971 (1999). 74. S. Abbasi, P. J. Carreau, A. Derdouri and M. Moan, Rheologica Acta 48 (9), 943–959 (2009). 75. C. Zakri and P. Poulin, Journal of Materials Chemistry 16 (42), 4095–4098 (2006). 76. R. Andrews, D. Jacques, A. M. Rao, T. Rantell, F. Derbyshire, Y. Chen, J. Chen and R. C. Haddon, Applied Physics Letters 75 (9), 1329–1331 (1999). 77. B. Vigolo, A. Penicaud, C. Coulon, C. Sauder, R. Pailler, C. Journet, P. Bernier and P. Poulin, Science 290 (5495), 1331–1334 (2000). 78. S. Kumar, T. D. Dang, F. E. Arnold, A. R. Bhattacharyya, B. G. Min, X. F. Zhang, R. A. Vaia, C. Park, W. W. Adams, R. H. Hauge, R. E. Smalley, S. Ramesh and P. A. Willis, Macromolecules 35 (24), 9039–9043 (2002). 79. L. Deng, R. J. Young, S. van der Zwaag and S. Picken, Polymer 51 (9), 2033–2039 (2010). 80. H. M. Kim, K. Kim, C. Y. Lee, J. Joo, S. J. Cho, H. S. Yoon, D. A. Pejakovic, J. W. Yoo and A. J. Epstein, Applied Physics Letters 84 (4), 589–591 (2004). 81. B. Schartel, P. Pötschke, U. Knoll and M. Abdel-Goad, European Polymer Journal 41 (5), 1061–1070 (2005). 82. C. Wei, L. Dai, A. Roy and T. B. Tolle, Journal of the American Chemical Society 128 (5), 1412–1413 (2006). 83. E. Kymakis, E. Koudoumas, I. Franghiadakis and G. A. J. Amaratunga, Journal of Physics D – Applied Physics 39 (6), 1058–1062 (2006). 84. P. M. Ajayan and J. M. Tour, Nature 447 (7148), 1066–1068 (2007). 85. N. Halonen, A. Rautio, A. R. Leino, T. Kyllonen, G. Toth, J. Lappalainen, K. Kordas, M. Huuhtanen, R. L. Keiski, A. Sapi, M. Szabo, A. Kukovecz, Z. Konya, I. Kiricsi, P. M. Ajayan and R. Vajtai, Acs Nano 4 (4), 2003–2008 (2010).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-02.indd 50
9/6/11 4:42:35 PM
3
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
J. L a m o n, CNRS/National Institute of Applied Science (INSA Lyon) France
Abstract: Ceramics need to be reinforced because of their inherent brittleness and lack of reliability. Only continuous fibers are able to arrest the cracks through deflection at fiber–matrix interfaces. Only those fibers that can withstand the high temperatures required by composite processing (>1000°C) without significant damage can be used. Efficiency of reinforcement depends strongly on interface/interphase characteristics. Features of the mechanical behavior, as well as the influence of reinforcement on composite mechanical behavior and properties, are also discussed. Key words: ceramic matrix composites, fibers, interfaces, mechanical behavior, toughness, reliability, fatigue, strength, fracture statistics.
3.1
Introduction
Ceramics need to be reinforced because of their inherent brittleness and lack of reliability. Ceramic matrix composites are built primarily for toughness. Ceramic materials exhibit favorable mechanical properties that are retained at high temperature, which make them candidates for structural use at high temperatures and in severe environmental conditions. The interesting properties are high tensile strength, very high compressive strength, high Young’s modulus and low density at temperatures up to 1500°C. Because of their low fracture toughness, currently less than 6 MPa √m, ceramics are very sensitive to microstructural flaws, which initiate cracks that propagate catastrophically. Proper reinforcement of ceramics is aimed at increasing the resistance to crack propagation by introducing elements that arrest the cracks. Only continuous fibers are able to arrest the cracks through deflection at fiber–matrix interfaces. Damage tolerance requires strong fibers and weak interfaces. Composite strength requires strong fibers and strong multifilament tows. Discrete elements like particles, whiskers and short fibers have been introduced into monolithic ceramics. They are unable to arrest the cracks that zigzag between the obstacles. Whiskers have been the most attractive discrete reinforcement, in the past. Incorporating whiskers into a ceramic matrix may improve resistance to crack growth, making the composite less sensitive to flaws. However, fracture toughness is not increased significantly 51 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 51
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
52
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
when compared to the ceramic matrix: once a crack initiates, its propagation is catastrophic. Although whisker strengthening and toughening are limited, they can be sufficient for certain applications like cutting tools: SiC-whiskerreinforced alumina or silicon nitride. At least one successful whisker-reinforced composite is already being marketed. An SiC-whisker-reinforced alumina cutting-tool material is being used to machine nickel-based superalloys. But, there is a major drawback as whiskers are dangerous for health. Continuous-fiber-reinforced ceramics do not fail catastrophically. After matrix failure, the fiber can still support a load. Reinforcement by continuous fibers provides fracture-toughness values that may be much larger than those for metals; they may approach infinity in certain composites like C/SiC or C/C. In CMCs, only those fibers that can withstand the high temperatures required by composite processing (above 1000°C) without significant damage can be used. Other high-temperature requirements to be met include long-term high-temperature stability, creep resistance and oxidation resistance. There is a wide spectrum of continuous-fiber-reinforced ceramic matrix composites (CMCs) depending on the chemical composition of the matrix and fibers. Non-oxide CMCs reinforced by non-oxide fibers have been the most studied, because carbon and silicon carbide fibers display the highest properties for use at high temperature. Second, for compatibility reasons, non-oxide fibers can be combined essentially to non-oxide matrices. However, carbon fibers degrade in oxidizing atmosphere at temperatures as low as 450°C, and they must be protected. SiC-based fibers are much more resistant to oxidation. Oxide fibers are inherently resistant to oxidation, but they have limited creep resistance and undergo grain growth at high temperatures, which causes strength degradation. Further, they display much higher densities than carbon fibers. Despite these drawbacks, alumina-based CMCs have been extensively studied. This chapter focuses on continuous reinforcement by ceramic fibers because they are more applicable to high-temperature use: SiC, carbon or oxide fibers are capable of withstanding high temperatures (to about 2500°C for carbon fibers). Diameter is about 7–20 mm. High-stiffness and large diameter SiC fibers that consist of a thick layer of silicon carbide which has been deposited on a thin fiber substrate of tungsten or carbon were developed initially to reinforce aluminum and titanium matrices. Although they have been used as reinforcement in silicon nitride, their use in CMCs is difficult since they cannot be woven, because of their high stiffness and large diameter. Diameter of the final product is about 140 mm. The basic requirement for a tough ceramic composite, whatever the chemistry, is that cracks that initiate in the matrix do not propagate into fibers, but bypass them by deflecting into fiber–matrix debonding cracks. This requires a tailored interface in the region between fiber and matrix. Fiber–matrix interfaces or interphases (interphase is a coating on fiber aimed
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 52
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
53
at controlling crack deflection) play an important role in fiber reinforcement. Thus, efficiency of reinforcement of fiber-reinforced ceramics depends strongly on interface/interphase characteristics. One cannot address reinforcement without discussing interface/interphase issues. In addition to developments in fibers, advances in controlling the interfacial bond between matrix and fibers have led to further mechanical property improvements of ceramic–ceramic composites. The interfacial bond must be optimized to promote favorable toughening mechanisms such as crack deflection and crack bridging. The interphase allows crack deflection to be tailored and mechanical behavior to be controlled. Without proper interface control, a brittle polyphase material results, rather than a toughened composite. Features of the mechanical behavior of CMCs, as well as the influence of reinforcement on mechanical behavior and properties, are also discussed in this chapter.
3.2
Ceramic fibers: general features
3.2.1
Oxide fibers
Oxide fibers that are commercially available are mostly based on alumina ceramics [1–4]. Table 3.1 lists the main properties of available oxide fibers. They display high values of tensile strength and Young’s modulus, and diameters as fine as 10–12 mm. As oxides they are resistant to oxidation at high temperature. However, they creep under load at temperatures above 1100°C. When subjected to high temperatures over long times, they are sensitive to grain growth. Nextel oxide fibers are the most widely used reinforcements for continuous fiber oxide–oxide composites [1–3]. Nextel 610 fiber has the highest strength and elastic modulus (3.1 GPa and 380 GPa respectively), but it is limited by creep to <1000°C. Nextel 720 fiber has lower room-temperature strength (2.1 GPa) but higher creep resistance which allows use at higher temperatures (up to 1200°C). Sapphire (single crystal Al2O3) fibers are also available. Their cost and diameter (>50 mm) limit their use in composites. Other oxide fiber types have been lightly investigated [1]. Current research activities are focused on the development of oxide fibers with enhanced creep properties and reduced grain growth rates. Oxide fibers are typically used in woven form. A limited amount of work has been completed on 3-D woven oxide–oxide composites.
3.2.2
Non-oxide fibers
Non-oxide fibers exhibit superior tensile strength and creep resistance to oxide fibers. They possess comparable Young’s modulus and diameter. Table 3.1 lists the main properties of SiC-based ceramic fibers. Non-oxide fibers are used in various 2-D or 3-D forms. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 53
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 54
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
SiC fibers Nicalon Hi-Nicalon Tyrano-S Tyranno-SA Sylramic Sylramic-iBN
C
25 28 27 <0.3 – 15 – 5 – Other
B 2O 3 B 2O 3 – Fe3O3 SrO2, Y2O3 – – – –
Other
Nippon Carbon 58 31 11%O Nippon Carbon 63.7 35.8 <1%O UBE Industries 50.4 29.7 17.9%O, 2%Ti UBE Industries 67.8 31.3 <1%O, <2%Al Dow Corning/COI 66.6 28.5 O, B, Ti, N COI/NASA
S
63 70 73 >99 89 85 100 95 100
3M 3M 3M 3M 3M 3M Mitsui Mining Sumitomo Chemical Saphikon Inc.
Oxide fibers Nextel 312 Nextel 440 Nextel 550 Nextel 610 Nextel 650 Nextel 720 Almax Altex Sapphire
SiO2
Composition Al2O3
Manufacturer
Fiber
Table 3.1 Fiber properties
3.0 2.8 3.3 2.8 3.2 3.2
1.7 2.0 2.0 3.1 2.6 2.1 1.0 1.8 3.0
192 269 170 380 400 400
2.55 2.74 2.35 3.10 3.0 3.0
150 2.7 190 3.1 193 3.0 380 3.9 358 4.1 260 3.4 320 210 435 3.8
Strength Modulus Density (GPa) (GPa) (g/cm3)
10–20 10–20 11 7.5–10 10 10
10–12 10–12 10–12 10–12 10–12 10–12 15 10–15 70–250
Diameter (µm)
3.5 3.1 4.5 5.4 5.4
8.8 –
3.0 5.3 5.3 8.0 8.0 6.0
CTE (ppm/°C)
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
55
Lower creep rates are observed at temperatures above 1200°C, even under high stresses, whereas oxide fibers can barely exceed 1000°C [5–12]. For example, Sylramic fibers show less than 1% creep strain after 1000 hours at 1350°C and 100 MPa stress, and Hi-Nicalon type S fibers show less than 0.5% after 60 hours at 1350°C and 850 MPa stress. Creep strain of 10–8/s is obtained at 1000°C and 100 MPa stress on the most creep-resistant oxide fiber (Nextel 720), at 1400°C and 300 MPa stress on Tyranno SA3, and at 1350°C and 850 MPa on Hi-Nicalon type S. Tyranno SA3 and Hi-Nicalon type S exhibit higher resistance to creep than Hi-Nicalon. The creep resistance is commensurate with low oxygen content, SiC grain size and the small amount of amorphous phase. It has been shown to be improved after high-temperature treatment under various atmospheres. Creep behavior of Hi-Nicalon can be improved by using high-temperature treatment that eliminates the amorphous phase and organizes a better carbon structure [10].
3.2.3
Carbon fibers
Carbon fibers degrade in an oxidizing atmosphere at temperatures as low as 450°C. They are stable in non-oxidizing environments up to 2800°C. There is a wide variety of carbon fibers. They can be classified in several categories, based on Young’s modulus and strength, precursor fiber material and final heat treatment [13]. Categories based on precursor fiber material are as follows: ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
PAN-based carbon fibers Pitch-based carbon fibers Mesophase pitch-based carbon fibers Isotropic pitch-based carbon fibers Rayon-based carbon fibers Gas-phase-grown carbon fibers.
In general, it is seen that the higher the tensile strength of the precursor the higher is the tenacity of the carbon fiber. The characterization of carbon fiber microstructure by X-ray scattering and electron microscopy techniques has shown that most carbon fibers consist of crystallites that are arranged around the longitudinal axis of the fiber [14–18]. Depending on the orientation of the layer planes with respect to the axis, Young’s modulus values span a wide range from a few GPa to more than 1000 GPa, and thermal conductivity from a few to several hundreds of Wm–1K–1 [14–19]. In high-modulus fibers, planes are highly oriented parallel to the axis. Young’s modulus decreases with increasing orientation angle. Based on Young’s modulus, carbon fibers are classified into five groups [13]:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 55
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
56
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
∑ Ultra-high-modulus, type UHM (modulus > 450 GPa) ∑ High-modulus, type HM (modulus 350–450 GPa) ∑ Intermediate-modulus, type IM (modulus 200–350 GPa) ∑ Low modulus and high-tensile, type HT (modulus < 100 GPa, tensile strength > 3.0 GPa) ∑ Super high-tensile, type SHT (tensile strength > 4.5 GPa). In PAN-based fibers, the linear chain structure is transformed to a planar structure during oxidative stabilization and subsequent carbonization. Basal planes oriented along the fiber axis are formed during the carbonization stage. Wide-angle X-ray data suggest an increase in stack height and orientation of basal planes with an increase in heat treatment temperature. A difference in structure between the sheath and the core was noticed in a fully stabilized fiber. The skin has a high axial preferred orientation and thick crystallite stacking. However, the core shows a lower preferred orientation and a lower crystallite height. Based on final treatment temperature, carbon fibers are classified into: ∑
Type I, high-heat-treatment carbon fibers (HTT), where final heat treatment temperature should be above 2000°C and can be associated with high-modulus type fiber. ∑ Type II, intermediate-heat-treatment carbon fibers (IHT), where final heat treatment temperature should be around or above 1500°C and can be associated with high-strength type fiber. ∑ Type III, low-heat-treatment carbon fibers, where final heat treatment temperatures are not greater than 1000°C. These are low-modulus and low-strength materials. Tensile strength and modulus are significantly improved by carbonization under strain when moderate stabilization is used. Overall, the strength of a carbon fiber depends on the type of precursor, the processing conditions, heat treatment temperature and the presence of flaws and defects. Carbon fibers exhibit elastic behavior at room temperature. Stiffening as the load increases has been observed on fibers with intermediate Young’s modulus (around 200 GPa), i.e. with an amount of crystallites than can align in the fiber axis direction [20]. PAN-based fibers typically buckle on compression and form kink bands at the innermost surface of the fiber. However, similar high-modulus type pitch-based fibers deform by a shear mechanism with kink bands formed at 45° to the fiber axis. Carbon fibers are very brittle. The layers in the fibers are formed by strong covalent bonds. The sheet-like aggregations allow easy crack propagation. On bending, the fiber fails at very low strain.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 56
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
3.3
Fracture strength: statistical features
3.3.1
Single fibers
57
As usual with brittle ceramics, fracture data of single filaments exhibit a significant scatter, since fracture is induced by flaws that have a random distribution. An important consequence is that the fracture stress is not an intrinsic characteristic. It is instead a statistical variable which depends on several factors, including the test method, the size of test specimens and the number of test specimens [21]. Therefore, a universal reference value of fiber fracture strength cannot be recommended. It is widely accepted that the Weibull model satisfactorily describes the statistical distribution of failure strengths of single filaments under tensile loads: P = 1 – exp{– ∫(s/s0)m dV/V0}
3.1
where P is the probability of failure, s is the stress, s0 is the scale factor, m is the Weibull modulus, V is the volume of the specimen and V0 is the reference volume (1 m3 is generally used); m reflects the scatter in data, and s0 is related to the mean value of strength. The strength for a given geometry and stress state can be determined using equation (3.1). However, m, s0 and V0 must be available. It is important to note that the estimate of s0 depends on V0 [21]. It is substantially different if V0 = 1 m3 or 1 mm3. This dependence is ignored in most papers. When V0 is not given, the estimate of s0 is meaningless. The strength cannot be determined safely. Unfortunately, reliable s0 values (characteristic strength in a few papers) cannot be recommended here, until the authors have completed their papers. The values of the Weibull modulus of most commercial carbon and ceramic fibers at room temperature are rather small (Table 3.2). They span a range from 4 to 12. Scatter in m is generally observed, inherent to the use of an estimator to construct the Weibull plot, and of limited sample size. For a single gauge length and uniform tensile stress, equation (3.1) reduces to m ÏÔ Ê ˆ ¸Ô P = 1 – exp Ì– V Á s ˜ ˝ ÔÓ V0 Ë s 0 ¯ Ô˛
3.2
The Weibull modulus, m, is determined as the slope of the ‘Weibull plot’ of ln(ln(1/1 – P)) vs. lns: ln(ln(1/1 – P)) = m ln s + k
3.3
where k is a constant. This can be done either graphically or using methods of curve fitting like linear regression analysis, the least-squares method or
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 57
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
58
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Table 3.2 Tensile properties at room temperature (gauge length = 50 mm): sr is the tow failure stress, ac is the critical fraction of individual fiber failures, mf and s0 are the statistical parameters of single filaments derived from tow tensile stress–strain curves
Mechanical characteristics
Fibers
sr(MPa)
Ef (GPa)
ac
Nicalon [49] 180 0.17 Hi-Nicalon [49] 1839 270 0.13 Hi-Nicalon S [49] 2776 420 0.14 Alumina Nextel 720 [45] Alumina Nextel 650 [45] Alumina Nextel 610 [45] Carbon PAN-based T300 [59] 2000 205 0.18 Carbon PAN-based HTA [59] 2900 220 0.05 Pitch-based carbon [59] 320 43 0.03 a
mf 4.6 6.8 7.1 7.6 6.8 10.1 4 9 12
s(MPa)a 8.4 61 99
85 120
V 0 = 1 m 3.
the maximum likelihood estimator [21]. For Weibull plots, P = (i – 0.5)/n is recommended to estimate fracture probability, where n is the number of fibers tested and i is the rank of strength for each fiber. Another method of determining the Weibull modulus is to measure fiber strength as a function of gauge length. With increasing gauge length, the chance of finding a large flaw increases, so fiber strength decreases. The effect of gauge length is given by the equation
ln s = (–1/m) lnL + k¢
3.4
where L is gauge length and k¢ is a constant. Thus, the slope of a log–log plot of strength vs. gauge length is –1/m.
3.3.2
Multifilament tows
Multifilament tows represent a fundamental entity in textile composites. They comprise several hundreds or thousands of single filaments. They progressively carry the load as the matrix is damaged, and they control ultimate failure [22]. Multifilament tows are elastic and damage tolerant, whereas single fibers are brittle. Two different types of bundle tensile behavior are observed depending upon loading conditions and fiber [23]: ∑ ∑
Either a non-linear force–strain relation associated with individual fiber breaks for carbon or certain SiC-based fiber tows under controlled deformation Or a two step non-linear force–strain relation (Fig. 3.1) for ceramic fibers under controlled deformation or load. The first step of stable failure
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 58
9/6/11 4:42:52 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
59
160 Hi-Nicalon
140
Simulation
Force (N)
120 100 NLM 202
80 60 40 20 0
0
0.5
1 Strain (%)
1.5
2
3.1 Tensile load–strain curves for SiC-based multifilament tows showing controlled behavior (simulation) and two-step behavior (experimental results) (Hi-Nicalon and NLM 202 Nicalon fibers).
involves individual failures of a fraction of the fibers. The second step of unstable failure results from the failure of those fibers that survived during the first step. The fraction of fiber fractures at maximum force in both types of tow response controls the failure of composites. It takes a critical value ac = Nc/N0, where N0 is the initial number of fibers, Nc is the number of broken fibers at maximum load, and ac is a constant (Table 3.2). The particular fiber that fails at maximum load is referred to as the ‘critical fiber’. It has rank Nc when strength data are ordered from smallest to largest. Relationships between tow tensile behavior and fiber properties have been modeled by several authors. Daniels [24] considered tows containing parallel and non-contacting fibers. He demonstrated that tow strengths are described by a normal distribution for large numbers of fibers. Coleman [25] proposed a relationship between tow and fiber strengths and evidenced a significant drop in tow strength when compared to mean fiber strength. Phoenix and Taylor [26, 27] introduced effects of non-uniform loading resulting from fiber misalignment and scatter in fiber lengths within tows. Calard and Lamon [23] introduced random load sharing. They predicted tow strength drops when compared with the Daniels model. The bundle model Bundle models are based upon the following hypotheses [24, 25]: the bundle contains Nt identical and parallel fibers (radius Rf, length l), and the © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 59
9/6/11 4:42:53 PM
60
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
statistical distribution of fiber strengths is described by the Weibull model (equation (3.2)). When a fiber fails, equal load sharing is assumed. This means that the load is carried equally by all the surviving fibers, whereas the broken fiber no longer carries any load. Under load-controlled conditions, the load that was carried by the broken fiber is shared equally by the surviving fibers which experience overloading by an increment Dsi: Ds i =
si N t – Ni
3.5
where i designates the fiber that failed, si is the stress that was operating on this fiber before failure, and Ni is the number of broken fibers. Ultimate failure occurs when Dsi > si+1 – si where si+1 is the strength of the fiber having rank i + 1, the strengths being in ascending order. at this stage, the surviving fibers are generally unable to withstand the load increment Dsi. Most of them fail catastrophically. Failure becomes unstable at maximum load. Under strain-controlled conditions, there is no overloading of surviving fibers when a fiber fails: Dsi = 0. As a consequence, failure is a stable phenomenon. The ratio a (s) of the number of broken fibers N to the total number of fibers Nt is approximately equal to the failure probability when Nt is large and when fiber failures are equally probable events:
a (s ) = N = P(s ) Nt
3.6
Consequently, the total force F(s) applied to the bundle is: m ÏÔ Ê ˆ ¸Ô F (s ) = N i(1 (1 – a (s )) ))sf s = N i sf exp Ì– V Á s ˜ ˝ ÔÓ V0 Ë s 0 ¯ Ô˛
3.7
with sf the fiber cross-sectional area. The maximum force Fmax is given by one of the following conditions, depending on the loading mode: dF = 0 (stable failure under deformation-controlled conditions) ds 3.8 a = ac (unstable failure under load-controlled conditions) 3.9 The first condition of stable failure (equation (3.8)) yields
s max
Ê ˆ = s0Ám V ˜ Ë V0 ¯
–1 m
3.10
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 60
9/6/11 4:42:54 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
Ê 1ˆ a (s max ) = 1 – exp Á – ˜ Ë m¯ Fmax
Ê Vˆ = F (s max max ) = N t sf s 0 Á m ˜ Ë V0 ¯
61
3.11 –1 m
Ê 1ˆ expÁ – ˜ Ë m¯
3.12
The second condition of unstable failure (equation (3.9) yields Fmax = F(ac) = NtsfsF(1 – ac)
3.13
where sF is the strength of the tow at instability. Fmax corresponds now to tow ultimate strength. It can be shown that ac is given by equation (3.11), which implies that sF = smax. As a consequence, Fmax is also given by equation (3.12) in the presence of unstable failure. The only difference between both tow behaviors under load- or strain-controlled conditions lies in the domain beyond Fmax. To estimate scattering of the maximum force Fmax, the binomial function b(Nt, a(smax)) (or ac respectively) can be considered [28], which is naturally equal to the critical number of broken fibers Nc (statistical definition): Nc = b(Nt, a(smax))
3.14 2
Thus, the expectation E( ) and the variance s ( ) of the critical number of broken fibers Nc are deduced from the expectation and the variance of the binomial function, which finally yields the expectation and the variance of the maximum force Fmax: E(Nc) = Nt(smax) fi E(Fmax) = Nt(1 – a(smax)) sfsmax
3.15
s2(Nc) = Nt(1 – a(smax)) a(smax) fi s2(Fmax) = (sfsmax)2 Nt(1 – a(smax)) a(smax)
3.16
This allows calculation of the coefficient of variation Cv, given by Daniels [24], McCartney and Smith [29] and Gurvich and Pipes [30]: Cv (Fmax ) =
s (Fma max x) = E (Fma max x)
a (s max max ) N t (1 – a (s m max ))
3.17
An important consequence of equation (3.17) is that the coefficient of variation is small when the total number of fibers Nt is high: Nt = 500 in this paper. Therefore, according to theory the maximum forces (tow strengths) should not be scattered at all. Experimental results are at variance with theory: an unpredicted scatter in tow strength is observed (Fig. 3.2). This scatter results essentially from imperfect local load sharing attributed to fiber interactions (such as friction) or dynamic effects. Local load sharing induces a drop in tow strengths (Fig. 3.3) and an enhanced scatter in data when
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 61
9/6/11 4:42:54 PM
62
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance 1
Probability of failure
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2 ac
Tows Single filaments
0 0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7 0.8 Strain (%)
0.9
1
1.1
1.2
3.2 Statistical distributions of strains-to-failure for SiC-based single filaments and multifilament tows. 120 100 0.00
Force (N)
80 0.10 60 0.25
40 20 0
0.40
0
0.5
1 Strain (%)
1.5
2
3.3 Influence of fiber interactions by random load sharing on the tensile load strain behavior of multifilament tows (modeling) [23].
compared to equal load-sharing conditions. Imperfect local load sharing in tows involves fewer fibers than local load sharing in composites does. Fiber stress redistribution depends on the degree of interaction of the broken fiber with its neighbors: random load sharing [23]. Although tow strength data are influenced by extrinsic factors, testing of tows is an interesting technique to determine fiber properties. Taking into
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 62
9/6/11 4:42:55 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
63
account random local load sharing allows sound predictions of tow strengths and associated scatter [23].
3.3.3
Filament–tow relations: tow-based testing methods for determination of single filament properties
It is worth pointing out that tow strength is determined by the critical number of fibers broken individually at maximum force:
s(Fmax) = s(a = ac)
3.18
whereas the average filament strength corresponds to the particular value a = 0.5: s– = s(a = 0.5) 3.19 Since a < a, s(F ) < s–. Both strengths can be determined using equation c
max
(3.20) provided that m, s0 and V0 are available; ac is derived from m using equation (3.11). When the theoretical ac is identical to the experimental value at Fmax, this indicates that there was no fiber interaction during the tests (equal load sharing). The failure characteristics of single filaments can be extracted from the tensile stress–strain curves determined on tows [31–33], or by using the standardized method described in [34] (Table 3.2). For this purpose, fiber strengths are derived from the force and the effective bundle section, taking into account the number of fibers broken individually. The number (j) of fibers broken at load Fj is derived from the compliance Cj:
Nj = N0(1 – C0/Cj)
3.20
where N0 is the initial number of intact fibers in the tow and C0 is the corresponding compliance. For the Weibull plot, P = Nj/N0 = 1 – C0/Cj can be used since the sample size is generally large, owing to the number of filaments present in a tow. Deformation instead of stress can be used (Fig. 3.2), provided an appropriate method of strain measurement is employed [33]. Using deformation presents an important advantage, since measurement of fiber sections is not required. Then, deriving stresses on fibers from strains is straightforward when Young’s modulus is available. The tow testing technique is interesting because of the significant sample size which can be obtained using a single test. However, artifacts may result from fiber misalignement. Specimen preparation and testing require much care. The degree of fiber interaction can be checked from the comparison of theoretical and experimental values of ac. Data for ac and statistical parameters are reported in Table 3.2. The
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 63
9/6/11 4:42:55 PM
64
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
database is not complete because authors are sometimes interested only in the Weibull modulus. Anyway, as pointed out above, available data may not be reliable. Therefore, it is recommended to determine the statistical parameters instead of using data from sources whose reliability has not been checked or established.
3.4
Mechanical behavior at high temperatures
At intermediate temperatures SiC-based fibers are sensitive to subcritical crack growth. Strength degradation of SiC single filaments starts at temperatures exceeding 1000°C [35, 36], and creep at temperatures over 1100°C [37]. It was also found that growth of a silica layer at the fiber surface and oxygen diffusion are enhanced under load [38]. Temperatures below 1000°C are referred to as intermediate. This temperature range has not been investigated on oxide fibers. Carbon fibers exhibit viscoelastic behavior at intermediate temperatures, and a viscoplastic behavior at high temperatures in inert environments [20]. The transition temperature between both regimes is commensurate with the degree of organization of carbon structure. It increases from 1200–1400°C for isotropic fibers to 2000–2200°C for highly organized fibers.
3.4.1
Strength degradation and oxidation at high temperature
Non-oxide fibers experience oxidation-related effects in the high-temperature range (above 900°C). However, this temperature may be lower for fibers that contain larger amounts of oxygen. Almost all the results found in the literature have been determined on single filaments. The authors were essentially interested in creep and strength retention after heat treatment or oxidation at high temperatures. The strength retention at room temperature generally decreases with increasing the heat treatment temperature [8, 39, 40] and the load [40]. At temperatures above 1000°C, the oxidation was found to cause the growth of SiC grains, a drop of resistivity and degradation of strength for Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon fibers [39]. At all temperatures, the formation of a uniform silicon oxide layer at the surface of fibers has been observed (Fig. 3.4). A very thin oxide film was formed at temperatures between 650 and 730°C [41]. Microstructure observations after heat treatment at 1300°C revealed that oxidation and loading accelerated new flaw nucleation and growth, resulting in stress corrosion cracks in Hi-Nicalon fibers [40]. Oxidation in air at 800–1000°C only slightly decreased the strength of Nicalon fibers, whereas a decrease of strength and no noticeable change of the Young’s modulus were reported for Tyranno fibers at lower temperatures (650–730°C) [41]. This strength decrease was related to flaw size increase after oxidation [41].
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 64
9/6/11 4:42:55 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
65
3.4 SEM micrograph showing evidence of slow crack growth and an oxide layer on the surface of a SiC-based Hi-Nicalon fiber, after static fatigue under 250 MPa at 1000°C during 13 days.
Strength retention (MPa)
2500 2000
1500
1000
500
Monofilament Hi-Nicalon Single filament Hi-Nicalon
0 0
500
1000 Temperature (°C)
1500
3.5 Strength retention for SiC-based Hi-Nicalon single filaments and multifilament tows at elevated temperatures.
Figure 3.5 shows that Hi-Nicalon single filaments retain more than 90% of their room temperature strength at 1300°C. By contrast, the strength data measured on multifilament strands show a steep decrease from 400°C. Yun and DiCarlo also reported strength data measured on Hi-Nicalon tows at high temperatures in air [42]. They found that tensile strength degradation started at 300°C. This phenomenon results from fiber bonding by a SiO2 oxide layer that grows at the surface of fibers. E. Lara-Curzio modeled the effect of oxidation on the stress-rupture time behavior of fiber bundles and composites [43, 44]. The delayed failure of
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 65
9/6/11 4:42:55 PM
66
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
fiber bundles was attributed to formation of a silica layer on the surface of fibers; the thickness of this layer was introduced in place of the critical flaw size in the linear fracture mechanics equation of strength, leading to a fiber bundle strength decrease with time as t–1/4 [43, 44], which corresponds to a fiber-independent stress exponent n = 4. Figure 3.6 compares the relative high-temperature multifilament strand or roving strength of all available oxide Nextel fibers. Since the number and diameter of the fibers is different for each type of fiber, the data are presented as a percentage of room temperature strength. All fibers retain more than 90% of their room-temperature strength at 800°C. Nextel 720 showed no degradation in strand up to 1100°C. Strength degradation is related to creep resistance. Nextel 720 comprises a majority of large 0.5 mm creep-resistant mullite grains; as a result, Nextel 720 fiber has 150–200°C higher temperature capability than other Nextel fibers [45]. With PAN-based carbon fibers, the strength increases up to a maximum at 1300°C and then gradually decreases in inert atmosphere, whereas the elastic modulus has been shown to increase with increasing temperature [20].
3.4.2
Static fatigue under constant load at intermediate temperatures: subcritical crack growth
Several researchers have demonstrated since the 1960s the sensitivity of refractory materials to slow (subcritical) crack growth [46, 47]. Slow crack
Strength retention (%)
100
80
60
40 610 650 720
20
Strain rate = 0.68 mm/min
0 0
200
400
600 800 1000 Test temperature (°C)
1200
1400
3.6 Comparison of relative tensile strength retention of multifilament strands of Nextel 312, 440, 550, 610, 650 and 720 fibers at elevated temperatures [45].
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 66
9/6/11 4:42:55 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
67
growth leads to failure, which implies that the strength is time dependent at high temperatures. Delayed failure is observed for SiC-based fibers under constant load at intermediate temperatures (Fig. 3.7) [48, 49]. It is indicated by long rupture times under stresses much lower than the strength at room temperature (Fig. 3.7). The data on single filaments exhibit a significant scatter, the rupture times seeming to decrease when the stresses are increased (Fig. 3.8). But the 10000000 Tows Single filaments
1000 100
100000 1 day
10
Hours
Rupture time (s)
1 month 1000000 1 week
10000 1
1h 1000
0.1 100 1 min
0.01
10 100
600
1100 Applied stress (MPa)
1600
2100
3.7 Stress–rupture time data determined on single SiC-based filaments (Hi-Nicalon) at 800°C. 10000000
1000
1000000
g = 1.05E+30x–0.45
10
10000
1
1000 100 10 1 100
100
0.1 Tow 500°C Two 800°C Single fiber 500°C Single fiber 800°C 300
500
Lifetime (h)
Lifetime (s)
100000
0.01 g = 3.36E+26x–0.34
0.001
700 900 1100 1300 1500 1700 1900 Applied stress (MPa)
3.8 Stress–rupture time diagrams for Hi-Nicalon single fibers and multifilament tows at 500°C (under 1500 MPa) and 800°C (under 1100 MPa).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 67
9/6/11 4:42:56 PM
68
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
trend is not as clear as with the tows. This statistical variability in rupture times is similar to that observed with bulk ceramic specimens, which results from the presence of different critical flaws within the fibers. The stress–rupture time data obtained for tows align on a curve that the following power law fits satisfactorily:
tsn = A
3.21
where t is the rupture time, s is the applied stress, and n and A are constants depending respectively on material and environment. The above power law often describes non-linear time-dependent responses such as that dictated by slow crack growth activated by the environment under low stresses in ceramics [50]. However, the response of tows must be regarded as a remarkable feature, since it is at variance with that observed for bulk ceramics and that of single fibers for which the experimental stress–rupture time data do not range in a single line, so that no monotonous trend is shown. The constant A depends on the initial flaw size. It takes the same value for those specimens which possess flaws with the same initial size [50]. The response of tows can be related to the critical fiber-dictated failure mode, as discussed above. When ac is a constant, the critical fibers correspond to identical initial flaw sizes. A and n are estimated from the stress–rupture time diagram using a regression technique (Table 3.3). The stress exponent n does not display temperature dependence. It seems to depend on fiber. A depends on temperature. Close values of n were estimated: 8.4 for the Hi-Nicalon tows and 7.2 for the HiNicalon S ones (Table 3.3); n was smaller (n = 2.8) and A was larger (A = 2 ¥ 1029 MPan s at 600°C) for Nicalon tows [51]. This indicates that the Hi-Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon S tows are less sensitive to slow crack growth than the Nicalon ones. The delayed failure of SiC-based fiber bundles at temperatures below 800°C results from the subcritical crack growth of the surface defects by the oxidation of the grain boundaries (free carbon) and the SiC nanograins or silicon oxycarbide at the crack tip [38]. Both phenomena may contribute simultaneously (Nicalon fibers) or sequentially (Hi-Nicalon S and SA3 fibers, Table 3.3 Subcritical crack growth constants for low oxygen content SiC-based Hi-Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon S fibers in ambient air at elevated temperatures T (°C)
Hi-Nicalon tows n
Hi-Nicalon S tows n
A (MPa s)
500 8.45 1.05 ¥ 1030 600 800 8.34 3.36 ¥ 1026
n
A (MPan s)
7.25 7.24
3.15 ¥1026 3.33 ¥ 1024
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 68
9/6/11 4:42:56 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
69
which contain a little free carbon not connected). Growth of a silica layer at the fiber surface is not responsible for fracture. In the presence of free carbon, the crack length increase is attributed to the consumption of free carbon by oxidation. In the presence of silicon carbide or silicon oxycarbide, the silicon oxide formed at the defect/crack tip causes a local volume increase (by a factor of 2.1 for SiC and by less for SiOxCy) which induces a tensile stress Ds. Considering the atomic concentrations of free carbon, those fibers with the largest fractions of free carbon are the less resistant to static fatigue:
Tyranno SA3 ª Hi-Nicalon S < Hi-Nicalon ª Nicalon
(ª2%)
(ª3%)
(ª17%)
(ª15%)
∑
Nicalon fiber contains large amounts of very reactive free carbon (≈15 at%), and very small b-SiC nanograins (~5 nm) embedded in silicon oxycarbide. These elements are very sensitive to oxidation due to their structure (free carbon) or their size (Valhas and Laanani demonstrated that the smaller the grains, the faster they oxidize [52]). In consequence both mechanisms can operate simultaneously and this is consistent with the small resistance to fatigue of this fiber. ∑ Hi-Nicalon fiber is essentially made of bigger b-SiC nanograins (~10 nm) and a free carbon network (the electrical conductivity is high: about 1 S/cm, compared to the Hi-Nicalon S and Nicalon fibers: 10–5 S/cm). The oxidation of this network from the surface defects should be the predominant mechanism of slow crack growth. As a consequence, longer rupture times would be expected when compared to Nicalon fibers. ∑ Hi-Nicalon S fiber contains much bigger b-SiC nanograins (~20 nm) without the silicon oxycarbide, and a little free carbon located at grain boundaries and not connected. The oxidation of the b-SiC nanograins would contribute to slow crack growth. The resistance to static fatigue is greater than that of Hi-Nicalon fiber because free carbon is not connected and the SiC grains are bigger. ∑ Tyranno SA3 fiber possesses the same amount of free carbon in the surface as the Hi Nicalon S fiber, but the difference lies in the SiC grain size: 50–100 nm versus 20 nm for the Hi-Nicalon S fiber. The longer rupture times exhibited by the SA3 fiber can be attributed to the presence of much bigger grains, which oxidize more slowly than the smaller ones present in the other SiC-based fibers [52]. In this case the oxidation rate of the SiC grains would determine slow crack growth. Both phenomena of oxidation of SiC grains and free carbon may contribute sequentially to slow crack growth in the Hi-Nicalon S and Tyranno SA3 fibers. Finally, the lifetime–microstructure relationships can be highlighted by comparing rankings of resistances to static fatigue, and microscopic features which control the reactivity of constitutive elements:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 69
9/6/11 4:42:56 PM
70
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Lifetime: Tyranno SA3 > Hi-Nicalon S > Hi-Nicalon > Nicalon
Free carbon: (ª2%)
Grain size: (ª50–100 nm) (ª20 nm)
(ª3%)
(ª17%)
(ª15%)
(ª10 nm)
(ª5 nm)
In order to improve the fatigue resistance of these SiC-based fibers in air at intermediate temperatures between 400 and 800°C, the manufacturers will have to reduce drastically the amounts of oxygen and free carbon near the fiber surface and also to eliminate the surface defects, in order to limit the oxidation.
3.4.3
Creep at high temperatures
Figure 3.9 compares the creep rate of oxide Nextel fibers at 1100°C [45]. Creep differed by a factor of 10–100 times between each type of fiber. The stress exponent for Nextel 720 and 610 is 1.8 less than for the other fibers. Nextel 720 fiber has the best creep resistance than any commercially available polycrystalline oxide fiber. This effect was attributed to the presence of creep-resistant mullite grains. However, further reductions in creep of oxide fibers are possible, as shown on YAG fibers. Typical creep curves that were obtained for near-stoichiometric SiCbased fibers are shown in Fig. 3.10 [12]. Steady-state creep was observed after a more or less long primary creep stage, depending on the fiber: after 0.00001
Test temperatures 1100°C
Strain rate (s–1)
0.000001
Nextel 610
1E-07
Nextel 650
1E-08
Nextel 720 (1200C)
1E-09
Nextel 720
1E-10 10
100 Load (MPa)
1000
3.9 Comparative creep rate of Nextel fibers at 1100°C as a function of stress [45].
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 70
9/6/11 4:42:56 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
71
3.5 3
Strain (%)
2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5
Experiment Prediction
0 0
48
96
144 192 Time (h) (a)
240
288
336
0.7 0.6
Strain (%)
0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
Experiment Prediction
0 0
12
24
Time (h) (b)
36
48
60
3.10 Creep curves obtained on (a) Hi-Nicalon and (b) Hi-Nicalon S SiC-based fibers at 1350°C, and under (a) 850 and (b) 500 MPa: comparison with prediction.
about 140 h for Hi-Nicalon fibers at 1200°C, about 72 hours for SA3 fibers at 1200°C, about 8 hours for SA3 fibers at 1250°C, and about 8 hours for Hi-Nicalon S at 1350°C. The creep results reported by most authors were obtained during much shorter tests (<48 hours). Thus, it may be anticipated
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 71
9/6/11 4:42:57 PM
72
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
that certain tests were not sufficiently long, so that a true secondary creep stage was probably not reached. Creep curves obtained under incremental temperature steps show evidence of tertiary creep at temperatures above 1600°C [12] (Fig. 3.11). Creep curves are described by the following well-accepted equations of deformations in the primary and secondary stages (Fig. 3.10):
ee = s E0
3.22
ep = sA[1 – exp(–pt)]
3.23
es = bsnt
3.24
e = ee + ep + es
3.25
where subscripts e, p and s refer respectively to elastic regime, primary and secondary creep, s is the stress on the fiber, E0 is the initial fiber Young’s modulus, t is time, and A, b, n and p are constants. Based on microstructure analysis, the fibers can be considered to be a mixture of wrinkled carbon-layer packets and SiC grains. Possible controlling creep mechanisms may involve grain boundary sliding, carbon diffusion, dewrinkling, deformation and sliding of carbon crystallites [37]. Primary creep can be attributed to viscoelastic deformation of carbon at grain boundaries. Secondary creep of low oxygen content fibers (n ≈ 2.5) may be attributed to grain boundary sliding, without grain elongation and a glassy phase (Rachinger mechanism), and diffusion of al, C or Si at grain 8 7
1700°C
6
Strain (%)
5 1650°C
4 1600°C 1550°C
3 1500°C 2
1450°C
1400°C
Test stop for SEM observation
1350°C
1 0 0
12
24
36
48 Time (h)
60
72
84
96
3.11 Creep of SiC-based SA3 fiber under a stress of 150 MPa and in the 1350–1700°C temperature range.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 72
9/6/11 4:42:57 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
73
boundaries in SA3 fiber and diffusion of carbon or silicon within grain in Hi-Nicalon S fiber. In polycrystalline ceramics, accommodation results from diffusion and fold formation at triple junctions [53]. In SiC fibers, it probably involves carbon deformation. Tertiary creep was shown to be due to an increase in stress as the load-bearing fiber area is reduced by volatilization of Si.
3.5
Fiber–matrix interfaces: influence on mechanical behavior
The fiber–matrix interfacial domain is a critical part of composites, because load transfers from the matrix to the fiber and vice versa occur through the interface. Interface characteristics depend on the fiber’s ability to be more or less strongly bonded to the matrix or to a coating. The interface must not be too strong in order to obtain crack deflection by fibers, although excessively weak interfaces are detrimental to composite strength. High strength requires efficient load transfers from fibers to the matrix. This is obtained with rather strong interfaces, provided deflection can occur (Fig. 3.12). Efforts have been directed towards optimization of interface characteristics with respect to composite behavior, through control of the fiber–matrix bond. In CVI SiC/SiC composites, fiber matrix interfaces consist of a thin Matrix crack
Fiber/matrix interphase Strong interface cohesive failure mode
Weak interface adhesive failure mode
Load transfers Limited debonding
Energy absorption Important debonding Fiber pullout Sliding friction
Multiple matrix cracking
Strengthening
Toughening
3.12 Schematic diagram summarizing relationships between degree of fiber–matrix bonding and composite strength and toughness.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 73
9/6/11 4:42:57 PM
74
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
coating layer (less than 1 mm thick) of one or several materials deposited on the fiber (interphase). Enhanced interfaces have been obtained using fibers that have been treated in order to increase the fiber–coating bond [54, 55]. The concept of enhanced interfaces has been established on CVI SiC/SiC composites with SiC-based fibers, and PyC or multilayered (PyC/SiC)n fiber coatings. Less interesting results have been achieved with BN interphases [56] or carbon fibers. In CVI SiC/SiC composites with PyC-based fiber coatings, the interfacial shear stress (which reflects the strength of the fiber–matrix bond) ranges between 10 and 20 MPa for the weak interfaces obtained with as-received fibers, and between 100 and 300 MPa for the strong interfaces obtained with treated fibers. In the presence of weak fiber–coating bonds, the matrix cracks generate a single long debond at the surface of fibers (adhesive failure type, Fig. 3.13). The associated interface shear stress is low, and load transfers through the debonded interfaces are poor. The matrix is subjected to low stresses and the volume of matrix that may experience further cracking is reduced by the presence of long debonds. Matrix cracking is not favored. The crack spacing distance at saturation as well as the pullout length tends to be rather long (>100 mm). Toughening results essentially from fiber–matrix sliding friction over the interface crack. However, as a result of matrix unloading, the fibers carry most of the load, which reduces the composite strength. The corresponding tensile stress–strain curve exhibits a narrow curved domain limited by a stress at matrix saturation which is smaller than ultimate strength (Fig. 3.14). In the presence of stronger fiber–coating bonds, the matrix cracks are deflected within the coating (cohesive failure type, Fig. 3.13) into short and branched multiple cracks. Short debonds as well as improved load transfers allow further cracking of the matrix. Sliding friction within the coating as well as multiple cracking of the matrix increases energy absorption, leading to toughening. Limited debonding and improved load transfers reduce the load carried by the fibers, leading to strengthening. The associated tensile stress–strain curve exhibits a wide non-linear domain and the stress at matrix cracking saturation is close to ultimate failure (Fig. 3.14).
3.6
Mechanical behavior of composites: influence of fibers and interfaces
Fibers deeply influence the mechanical behavior of ceramic matrix composites depending on various parameters: ∑
Elastic properties with respect to matrix properties. It is worth pointing out that there are a wide variety of fibers and matrices with elastic modulus ranging from low values (roughly, a few GPa) to very large ones (≈400
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 74
9/6/11 4:42:57 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 75
9/6/11 4:42:57 PM
I
I
Microcrack
M
(SiC/PyC)n interphase
F
I
Microcrack
Microcrack
M
PyC interphase
F
I
Microcrack
M
(SiC/PyC)n interphase
F
(b) Strong F/I bond
3.13 Schematic diagrams showing crack deflection (a) at the fiber surface with as-received fibers which generate rather weak interfaces, and (b) within the coating with treated fibers which are more strongly bonded to the coating.
(a) Weak F/I bond
Microcrack
M
PyC interphase
F
76
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance 400 (a)
Stress (MPa)
300 (b) IV 200
III
II
100
I 0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 Deformation (%)
1
1.2
3.14 Tensile stress–strain curves obtained with (a) treated fibers (enhanced interface) and (b) as-received fibes (weak interfaces) in SiC/SiC composites with a pyrocarbon coating on fibers.
GPa for SiC-based fibers or matrices, and ≈700 GPa for carbon fibers). This situation is quite different from that prevailing in organic matrix composites for which the matrix elastic modulus is always ≈5 GPa, whatever the matrix is. ∑ Ability to be more or less strongly bonded to the matrix as discussed in the previous section. ∑ Resistance to fracture, and statistical distribution of strength data.
3.6.1
Tensile stress–strain behavior
Damage-sensitive stress–strain behavior is obtained when the contribution of the matrix to load carrying is initially significant, as observed when the elastic modulus of fibers (Ef) is comparable to the matrix one (Em). Then, Em degrades as matrix damage proceeds. Damage consists of transverse cracks with respect to fibers oriented in the loading direction. Damage-sensitive behavior exhibits non-linear stress–strain relationships. Saturation of matrix damage is indicated by a point of inflection, at transition between domains II and III in Fig. 3.14. Then the ultimate portion of the curve reflects the deformation of fibers (domain IV in Fig. 3.14). Fiber failures may initiate prior to ultimate fracture. The influence of matrix elastic modulus is illustrated by the mixtures law, which provides satisfactory trends for continuous fiber-reinforced composites:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 76
9/6/11 4:42:58 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
E c = E mV m + E fV f
77
3.26
where Ec is the composite elastic modulus, Vm is the volume fraction of the matrix, and Vf is the volume fraction of fibers oriented in the loading direction in a two-dimensional woven composite. In two-dimensional (2D) SiC/SiC and C/SiC composites, the matrix is stiffer than the fibers: Em (~410 GPa) > Ef (200–400 GPa), Vm ~ Vf. It carries a significant part of the applied load. In C/C composites, the fibers are much stiffer than the matrix: Em (~30 GPa) < Ef (200–400 GPa), Vm ~ Vf. The fibers carry most of the load. The matrix is subject to low stresses. As shown by equation (3.27) derived from (3.26) for small Em, the behavior is dictated by fibers. The stress–strain curve is essentially linear, as it reflects a damage-insensitive behavior.
E c ~ E f V f
3.27
In those damage-sensitive unidirectional composites under on-axis tensile loads, the basic damage phenomena involve multiple microcracks or cracks that form in the matrix, perpendicular to the fiber direction, and that are arrested by the fibers at fiber–matrix interfaces. In composites reinforced with fabrics of fiber bundles, matrix damage is influenced by the multilength scale structure [22]. In 2D SiC/SiC and C/SiC composites, damage consists essentially of the formation of cracks between the longitudinal tows perpendicular to the fiber axis and their deflection by the tows and, in a second step, of matrix cracks within the longitudinal tows and their deflection by the filaments. In 2D C/SiC composites, the first step of damage initiates during cooling down from the processing temperature as a result of the large coefficient of thermal expansion of the carbon fiber compared to that of the SiC matrix. The major modulus loss (70% in 2D SiC/SiC) is caused by the first families of cracks located on the outside of the longitudinal tows (deformations < 0.2%). By contrast, the microcracks within the longitudinal tows are responsible for only a 10% loss. The substantial modulus drop reflects important changes in load sharing: the load becomes carried essentially by the matrix-coated longitudinal tows (tow reloading). During microcracking in the longitudinal tows, load sharing is affected further, and the load becomes carried essentially by the filaments (fiber reloading). The elastic modulus reaches a minimum described by the following equation:
1
Emin = 2 EfVf
3.28
where Vf is the volume fraction of fibers oriented in the loading direction. Equation (3.28) reflects the fact that the mechanical behavior is fully controlled by the fiber tows oriented in the direction of loading (Fig. 3.15).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 77
9/6/11 4:42:58 PM
78
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance Longitudinal tow Macropore
Transverse tow
Layer
0.5 mm
3.15 Micrograph showing the multiple length scales structure of 2D CVI SiC/SiC composite.
3.6.2
Damage tolerance and fracture toughness
Damage tolerance and resistance to crack propagation depend strongly on fibers, first through interfaces, and second through fiber strength. The density of matrix cracks is enhanced by rather strong interfaces: the crack spacing distance may be as small as 10–20 mm whereas the crack spacing distance is at least 10 times larger in the presence of rather weak interfaces. In the presence of a notch or a pre-existing main macroscopic crack, a process zone of matrix microcracks is generated at the tip of the notch or the crack. As indicated in a previous section, crack density is commensurate with interface strength. Extension of the main crack results from the random failures of the fiber bundles located within the process zone [54]. Matrix cracking is an alternative mechanism of energy dissipation. Strain energy release rate values ranging from 3 to 8 kJ/m2 have been determined on CVI SiC/SiC composites respectively with weak or strong interfaces [54]. The corresponding values of the J-integral ranged from 11 kJ/m2 (weak interfaces) to 29 kJ/m2 (strong interfaces). These values are quite high by at least two orders of magnitude when compared to the SiC matrix.
3.6.3
Fatigue behavior
During cyclic fatigue at room temperature, matrix damage appears during the first cycles. Fatigue resistance is governed by the damage of fibers and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 78
9/6/11 4:42:58 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
79
fiber–matrix bonds. Owing to fiber resistance, composites like 2D SiC/SiC are insensitive to fatigue at room temperature, and under low loads. At high temperatures or in aggressive environments, the fibers may be sensitive to strength degradation by corrosion or by subcritical crack growth. As a consequence, composite resistance to fatigue decreases.
3.6.4
Ultimate failure
Ultimate failure generally occurs after saturation of matrix cracking, when the load is carried by the longitudinal tows. The fibers break when the applied load is close to maximum. Matrix damage and ultimate failure are successive phenomena. Ultimate failure is controlled by the tows. The ultimate failure of a tow of parallel fibers involves two steps, as discussed above: ∑ ∑
a first step of stable failure a second step of unstable failure.
During the first step, the fibers fail individually if the load is increased. In the absence of fiber interactions, the load is carried by the surviving fibers only (equal load sharing). Fiber interactions cause tow weakening leading to premature failures. The ultimate failure of a tow (second step) occurs when the surviving fibers cannot tolerate the load increment resulting from a fiber failure. The ultimate failure of a longitudinal tow coated with matrix results from the same two-step mechanism and involves global load sharing when a fiber fails. In the presence of multiple cracks across the matrix and associated interface cracks, the load-carrying capacity of the matrix is tremendously reduced or annihilated. The matrix-coated tows behave like dry tows subject to the stress state generated by the presence of matrix cracks. The ultimate failure of a matrix-coated tow occurs when a critical number of fibers have failed. This mechanism operates in the tows within textile CVI SiC/SiC composites. The ultimate failure of a composite is caused by the failure of a critical number of broken tows (≥1), depending on the stress state: ~1 under uniaxial tension, >1 in bending. It is worth pointing out that such a failure mechanism differs from that observed in polymer matrix-impregnated tows, where the fibers fail first and then local load sharing prevails when a fiber fails.
3.6.5
Reliability
Fiber stochastic features influence ultimate failure of ceramic matrix composites. Figure 3.16 shows that strength magnitude and scatter decrease from single fibers to tows, then to infiltrated tows and finally to woven composites.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 79
9/6/11 4:42:58 PM
80
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance 0.012 Composites (2D)
Density (1/MPa)
0.01 0.008 0.006
Composites (1D)
0.004 Tows
0.002 0 0
Fibers 500
1000 1500 Stress (MPa)
2000
2500
3.16 Strength density functions for SiC fibers (NLM 202), SiC multifilament tows, SiC/SiC (1D) minicomposites and 2D SiC/SiC composites.
As a result of the previously mentioned two-step failure mechanism, the ultimate failure of an entity is dictated by the lowest extreme of the strength distribution pertinent to its constituent, i.e. tows versus filaments, infiltrated tows versus fibers, and 2D composites versus infiltrated tows. The lowest strength extremes correspond respectively to the critical number of individual fiber breaks (ac ~ 17% for SiC-based NicalonTM and Hi-NicalonTM fibers) and to the critical number of tow failures (≥1 depending on stress state). The gap between tows and SiC-infiltrated tows results from strength determination: tow strength corresponds to the number of fibers carrying the load (effective cross-sectional area) whereas the strengths of infiltrated tows and composites correspond to the total cross-sectional area of specimens. During the successive damage steps, the flaw populations are truncated, which leads to a homogeneous ultimate population of flaws in the longitudinal tows at ultimate failure [57]. This progressive elimination of flaws strongly influences ultimate failure characteristics. Composite strength data exhibit a limited scatter and an insignificant dependence on the stressed volume and loading conditions (Figs 3.17 and 3.18). Thus, the flexural strength is 1.15 times as large as the tensile strength [57, 58] when measured on specimens having comparable sizes. The Weibull model is not appropriate to describe the volume dependence of strength data [57], since the weakest link concept is violated due to the presence of the cumulative damage process. However, the Weibull modulus (m) can be extracted from the statistical distribution of strength data: m is in the range 20–29 for 2D woven SiC/SiC composite. This value provides an index of the scatter in strength data. It reflects a small scatter.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 80
9/6/11 4:42:58 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
81
1
Probability
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0 200
250 300 Ultimate stress (MPa)
350
3.17 Statistical distribution of strength data for 2D woven SiC/SiC composite. Influence of specimen dimensions on ultimate failure in tension: d 8 ¥ 30 mm2 s 160 ¥ 120 mm2 [57]. 1 Tensile tests
Failure probability
0.8
Three-point bending tests
0.6
Four-point bending tests
0.4
0.2
0 260
280
300 320 340 Maximum stress (MPa)
360
380
3.18 Strength distributions for 2D woven SiC/SiC composites tested under various loading conditions: tension, three-point bending and four-point bending [57].
3.7
Conclusion
Using continuous refractory fibers is the most efficient way to obtain strong and tough ceramic matrix composites. Owing to a wide variety of potential
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 81
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
82
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
matrix materials, the fibers must meet several requirements. They must withstand the high temperatures required by composite processing above 1000°C. Their thermoelastic and fracture characteristics must compare favorably with those of the matrix. The influence of fibers on the mechanical behavior and on the properties of a composite depend on the matrix properties. The thermoelastic properties influence the stress-strain behavior. When the matrix is stiffer than the fibers (as typified by SiC/SiC and C/SiC composites) the stress–strain behavior is non-linear and damage sensitive. The matrix is able to share the applied load with the fibers, so that load transfers from the fibers to the matrix have to be sought. Toughening and strengthening depend on load transfers through fiber–matrix interfaces, i.e. the degree of bonding of fiber to the matrix. When the matrix is less stiff than the fibers (certain C/C composites) the behavior is damage insensitive. Most of the load is carried by the fibers, as in organic matrix composites. Improvement of damage tolerance is not the primary requirement to be met with such damage-insensitive composites. The thermal expansion of the fiber must also be matched to that of the matrix, since ceramic matrix composites are made at high temperatures. Fiber resistance to fast or delayed fracture determines composite ultimate strength under monotonous or fatigue loading. Fiber strength may be affected by temperature and environment, as a result of various phenomena like subcritical crack growth, creep and oxidation. Fast fracture data exhibit a statistical distribution which follows satisfactorily the Weibull model. The scatter in strength data is tremendously reduced through a truncation process when using multifilament tows. The multifilament tows are a fundamental entity in textile composites. They control ultimate failure and determine scatter in composite strength. They exhibit damagetolerant behavior which depends on the statistical distribution of filament strengths. Tow characteristics can be tailored with respect to composite strength. In damage-sensitive composites, the bonding of fibers to the matrix is of primary importance for the deflection of matrix cracks and for subsequent load sharing. Fiber–matrix interface characteristics depend on the fiber used. By applying appropriate treatment to the fiber surface, fiber–matrix bonding can be enhanced, leading to stronger and tougher composites.
3.8
References
1. K. A. Keller, G. Jefferson, R. J. Kerans, ‘Progress in oxide composites’, Annales de Chimie Science des Matériaux, 30, 659–671 (2005). 2. B. Clauss, ‘Fibers for ceramic matrix composites’, in: Krenkel W. (ed.) Ceramic Matrix Composites: Fiber-reinforced Ceramics and their Applications, Chapter 1, pp. 1–19, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany, (2008).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 82
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
83
3. K. A. Keller, G. Jefferson, R. J. Kerans, ‘Oxide–oxide composites’, in: Bansal N. P. (ed.) Handbook of Ceramics and Glasses, Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York, pp. 377–421 (2005). 4. A. Bunsell, ‘Oxide fibers’, in: Bansal N. P. (ed.) Handbook of Ceramics and Glasses, Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York, pp. 3–31 (2005). 5. J. A. DiCarlo, H.-M. Yun, ‘Non-oxide (silicon carbide) fibers’, Bansal N. P. (ed.) Handbook of Ceramics and Glasses, Kluwer Academic Publishers, New York, pp. 32–53, 2005. 6. H.-M. Yun, J. C. Goldsby, J. A. DiCarlo, ‘Tensile creep and stress-rupture behavior of polymer derived SiC fibers’, in: Singh J. P. and Bansal N. P. (eds) Advances in Ceramic-Matrix Composites II, pp. 17–28, American Ceramic Society, Westerville, OH, (1995). 7. H.-M. Yun, J. A. DiCarlo. ‘Comparison of the tensile, creep, and rupture strength properties of stoichiometric SiC fibers’, report NASA/TM-1999–209284 (1999). 8. A. R. Bunsell, A. Piant, ‘A review of the development of three generations of small diameter silicon carbide fibers’, J. Mater. Sci., 41, 823–839 (2006). 9. R. Bodet, X. Bourrat, J. Lamon, R. Naslain, ‘Tensile creep behavior of a silicon carbide-based fiber with a low oxygen content’, J. Mater. Sci., 30, 661–677 (1995). 10. G. Chollon, R. Pailler, R. Naslain, P. Olry, ‘Correlation between microstructure and mechanical behaviour at high temperatures of a SiC fiber with a low oxygen content (Hi-Nicalon)’, J. Mater. Sci., 32, 1133–1147 (1997). 11. J. A. DiCarlo, H.-M. Yun, ‘Microstructural factors affecting creep-rupture failure of ceramic fibers and composites’, in: Sheppard L. (ed.) Ceramic Material systems with Composite structures, pp. 119–134, American Ceramic Society, Westerville, OH (1998). 12. C. Sauder, J. Lamon, ‘The tensile creep behavior of SiC-based fibers with low oxygen content’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 90(4), pp. 1146–1156 (2007). 13. R. R. Hegde, A. Dahiya, M. G. Kamath, ‘Carbon fibers’, MSE 554, Nonwovens Science and Technology II, Spring 2004, http://web.utk.edu/~mse/pages/textiles/ carbon%20fibers.htm. 14. A. Oberlin, J. Goma, J. N. Rouzaud, Chimie Physique, 81, 701–710 (1984). 15. D. J. Johnson, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 20(3), 287–291 (1987). 16. X. Bourrat, E. J. Roche, J. G. Lanvin, Carbon, 28(2/3), 435–446 (1990). 17. R. Bacon, W. A. Schalamon, J. Appl. Polym. Sci., Appl. Polym. Symp., 9, 285 (1969). 18. B. T. Kelly, Physics of graphite, Applied Science Publishers, London, pp. 196–222 (1981). 19. C. Sauder, J. Lamon, ‘Prediction of elastic properties of carbon fibers and CVI matrices’, Carbon, 43, 2044–2053 (2005). 20. C. Sauder, J. Lamon, R. Pailler, ‘The tensile behavior of carbon fibers at high temperatures up to 2400°C’, Carbon, 42, 715–725 (2004). 21. J. Lamon, Mechanics of brittle fracture and damage: Statistical probabilistic Approaches (in French, Mécanique de la rupture fragile et de l’endommagement: Approches Statistiques-Probabilistes), Editions Hermès-Lavoisier, Paris, 2007. 22. J. Lamon, ‘A micromechanics-based approach to the mechanical behavior of brittlematrix composites’, Comp. Sci. Technol., 61, 2259–2272 (2001). 23. V. Calard, J. Lamon, ‘Failure of fiber bundles’, Comp. Sci. Technol., 64, 701–710 (2004).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 83
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
84
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
24. H. E. Daniels, ‘The statistical theory of the strength of bundles of threads I’, Proc. R. Soc., A183, 405–435 (1945). 25. B. D. Coleman, ‘On the strength of classical fibers and fiber bundle’, J. Mech. Phys. Sol., 7, 60–70 (1958). 26. S. L. Phoenix, H. M. Taylor, ‘The asymptotic strength distribution of a general fiber bundle’, Adv. Appl. Prob., 5, 200–216 (1973). 27. S. L. Phoenix, ‘Probabilistic strength analysis of fiber bundle structures’, Fiber Sci. Technol., 7, 15–31 (1974). 28. D. Breysse, ‘A probabilistic model for damage of concrete structure’, Proc. 2nd Int. Symp. on Brittle Matrix Composite (BMC 2), Cedzyna, Poland, 20–22 September, pp. 237–247 (1988). 29. L. N. McCartney, R. L. Smith, ‘Statistical theory of the strength of fiber bundles’, ASME J. Appl. Mech., 105, 601–608 (1983). 30. M. Gurvich, R. Pipes, ‘Strength size effect of laminated composites’, Comp. Sci. Technol., 55, 93–105 (1995). 31. Z. Chi, T. Wei Chou, G. Shen, ‘Determination of single fiber strength distribution from fiber bundle testing’, J. Mater. Sci., 19, 3319–3324 (1984). 32. N. Lissart, J. Lamon, ‘Evaluation des propriétés de monofilaments à partir d’essais de traction sur mèches’, Comptes-rendus des 9° Journées Nationales sur les Composites (JNC9), edited by J.P. Favre and A. Vautrin, AMAC, 2, 589–598 (1994). 33. M. R’Mili, T. Bouchaour, P. Merle, ‘Estimation of Weibull parameters from loose bundle tests’, Comp. Sci. Technol., 56, 831–834 (1996). 34. ENV1007-5, ‘Advanced technical ceramic–ceramic composites ñ Methods of test for reinforcements – Part 5: Determination of distribution of tensile strength and tensile strain to failure of filaments within a multifilament tow at ambient temperature’, European Committee for Standardization, CEN TC 184 SC1, Brussels (1997). 35. M. Berger, N. Hochet, A. R. Bunsell, ‘Small diameter SiC-based fibers’, in: Bunsell A. R. and Berger M. H. (eds) Fine Ceramic Fibers, p. 265, Marcel Dekker, New York (1999). 36. H. M. Yun, J. A. DiCarlo, ‘Time/temperature-dependent tensile strength of SiC and Al2O3-based fibers’, in: Bansal N. P. and Singh J. P. (eds) Ceramic Transactions, Vol. 74, Advances in Ceramic-matrix Composites II, pp. 17–26, American Ceramic Society, Westerville, OH, 1996. 37. R. Bodet, X. Bourrat, J. Lamon, R. Naslain, ‘Tensile creep behaviour of a silicon carbide fiber with a low oxygen content’, J. Mater. Sci., 30, 661–677 (1995). 38. W. Gauthier, F. Pailler, J. Lamon, R. Pailler, ‘Oxidation of silicon carbide fibers during static fatigue in air at intermediate temperatures’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 92(9), 2067–2073 (2009). 39. T. Shimoo, K. Okamura, W. Mutoh, ‘Oxidation behavior and mechanical properties of low-oxygen SiC fibers prepared by vacuum heat-treatment of electron-beam-cured poly(carbosilane) precursor’, J. Mater. Sci., 38, 1653–1660 (2003). 40. J. J. Sha, J. S. Park, T. Hinoki, A. Kohyama, ‘Tensile properties and microstructure characterization of Hi-Nicalon SiC fibers after loading at high temperature’, Int. J. Fracture, 142, 1–8 (2006). 41. Y. Gogoti, M. Yoshima, ‘Oxidation and properties degradation of SiC fibers below 850°C’, J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 13, 680–683 (1994). 42. H. M. Yun, J. A. DiCarlo, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc., 4, 61–67 (1996). 43. E. Lara-Curzio, ‘Stress-rupture of Nicalon/SiC continuous fiber ceramic composites in air at 950°C’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 80(12), 3268–3272 (1997).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 84
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
Ceramic reinforcements for composites
85
44. E. Lara-Curzio, ‘Oxidation induced stress-rupture of fiber bundles’, J. Eng. Mater. Technol., 120, 105–109 (1998). 45. D. M. Wilson, L. R. Visser, ‘High performance oxide fibers for metal and ceramic composites’, Proc. Fibers and Composites Conf., Barga, Italy, 22, May (2000). 46. R. J. Charles, W. S. Hillig, Symposium on Mechanical Strength of Glass and Ways of Improving It, Florence, Italy, 1962. Union Scientifique Continentale du Verre, Charleroi, Belgium (1962). 47. S. M. Wiederhorn, ‘Sub-critical crack growth in ceramics’, in: Bradt R. C., Hasselman D. P. and Lange F. F. (eds) Fracture Mechanics of Ceramics, Vol. 2, pp. 613–646, Plenum Press, New York, 1974. 48. S. Bertrand, R. Pailler, J. Lamon, ‘Influence of strong fiber/coating interfaces on the mechanical behaviour and lifetime of Hi-Nicalon/(PyC/SiC)n/SiC minicomposites’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 84(4), 787–794 (2001). 49. W. Gauthier, J. Lamon, ‘Delayed failure of Hi-Nicalon and Hi-Nicalon S multifilament tows and single filaments at intermediate temperatures (500–800°C)’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 92(3), 702–709 (2009). 50. R. W. Davidge, J. R. McLaren, G. Tappin, ‘Strength–probability–time (SPT) relationships in ceramics’, J. Mater. Sci., 8, 1699–1705 (1973). 51. Ph. Forio, F. Lavaire, J. Lamon, ‘Delayed failure at intermediate temperatures (600°C–700°C) in air in silicon carbide multifilament tows’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 87(5), 888–893 (2004). 52. C. Valhas, F. Laanani, ‘Thermodynamic study of the thermal degradation of SiC- based fibers: influence of grain size’, J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 14(22), 1558–1561 (1995). 53. T. G. Langdon, ‘Grain boundary deformation process’, in: Bradt R. C. and Tressler R. E. (eds) Deformation of Ceramic Materials, pp. 101–125, Plenum Press, New York, (1974). 54. C. Droillard, J. Lamon, ‘Fracture toughness of 2D woven SiC/SiC CVI composites with multilayered interphases’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 79(4), 849–858 (1996). 55. R. Naslain, ‘Fiber–matrix interphases and interfaces in ceramic matrix composites processed by CVI’, Composite Interfaces, 1, 253–258 (1993). 56. F. Rebillat, J. Lamon, A. Guette, ‘The concept of a strong interface applied to SiC/ SiC composites with a BN interphase’, Acta Mater., 48, 4609–4618 (2000). 57. V. Calard, J. Lamon, ‘A probabilistic–statistical approach to the ultimate failure of ceramic-matrix composites – Part I: experimental investigation of 2D woven SiC/ SiC composites’, Compo. Sci. Technol., 62, 385–393 (2002). 58. J. C. McNulty, F. W. Zok, ‘Application of weakest-link fracture statistics to fiber-reinforced ceramic-matrix composites’, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 80, 1535–1543 (1997). 59. T. Laguionie, ‘Determination of carbon fiber strengths using multifilament tows’, unpublished work (2002).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 85
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
CompRein-Boisse-03.indd 86
9/6/11 4:42:59 PM
4
Woven reinforcements for composites
D. C o u p é, Snecma Propulsion Solide, France
Abstract: Weaving technology, well known for several millennia, is fundamental to composite reinforcements. This chapter gives an overview of processes for the manufacture of woven fabrics, from basic ones used in textile applications to recent developments in the field. Definitions and applications of bi-dimensional (2D) and tri-dimensional (3D) fabrics, and of special woven shapes, are discussed. A projection of the future of weaving technologies in composite applications is made. Key words: composite woven fabrics, 2D fabrics, 3D fabrics, composite reinforcements, woven preform.
4.1
Introduction: from the beginning of weaving to technical applications
A woven fabric is characterized by two distinct thread directions (usually at right angles), interlaced with a repetitive pattern. Threads that run lengthways make up the ‘warp’, while threads that run from side to side represent the ‘weft’ or ‘fill’. The origins of weaving are not precisely known, but it seems to have been first used in the prehistoric period. Some specialists think our ancestors could have been inspired by spiders’ webs or birds’ nests. Weaving was initially used for making the tools of everyday life, like wooden fishing nets, or shelter components such as floors and roofs. The first hand-woven clothes seem to have appeared in Mesopotamia and Turkey (8000 bc), followed by Egypt (5000 bc), where linen, cotton and wool fibers were used (perhaps most famously in their linen wrapping tapes for mummies). During the same period, cotton and wool were being woven on the South American continent. Following the remarkable invention of silk spinning technology around 2700 bc, China exported silk fabrics all over the world. Woven fabrics were made on hand looms for millennia. Mechanization only appeared in the eighteenth century, and was improved during the nineteenth century by the introduction of Jacquard technology. Further major developments occurred in the twentieth century, with perhaps the most significant being the replacement of shuttles with rapiers for the insertion of fill-direction fibers. Other fill-insertion technologies have since 89 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 89
9/6/11 4:43:44 PM
90
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
been developed (projectile, air jet, etc.), but these are for very specific fibers and fabrics. Technical fibers like glass, ceramic and carbon fiber were also developed and popularized during the last century. These fibers typically have a high modulus and a very short elongation factor (less than 2%), and are transformed into fabrics in a radically different way from natural or polymeric fibers. Weaving is the most popular method of fabric manufacture, but many developments were needed before it could be used successfully on structural composites. Fiber manufacturers and technical weavers faced significant challenges when first attempting to produce fabrics from these fibers. Each step of the technology had to be optimized: spinning, twisting, warp setup, shed opening, fill insertion, etc. The quality of the sizing is particularly important, because it must be compatible with the composite matrix, and able to protect the fiber during the transformation process. These problems were overcome, and weaving technology has been used on glass fibers for more than 50 years, and carbon fibers for 30 to 40 years.
4.2
Technology description
The main principle of weaving is based on the interlocking of warp and fill fibers. As shown in Fig. 4.1, each warp end (a single yarn or tow in the warp direction) goes through a heddle eye and through a reed. Some eyes are moved up and others are moved down to form a shed, the internal triangle between two warp webs where the fill is inserted. The sequence is as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4.
The The The The
shed is open. loom moves the warp forward one space. fill is inserted. reed beats up to place the fill in the right position.
Then a new shed is created, with a different warp end at the top and bottom, and the sequence is repeated. A schematic weaving machine or loom, as presented in Figs 4.1 and 4.2, is composed of different parts: ∑ The back of the machine is the warp presentation side. ∑ The central area is where interlacing between warp and weft occurs. ∑ The front of the loom is the weaver side, where the fabric is wound.
4.2.1
Warp presentation
There are two main ways to present the warp side on a loom: a creel or a beam. Depending on fiber presentation, fiber type, and the desired properties of the woven fabric, one of these two processed is used.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 90
9/6/11 4:43:44 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
91
Heddle warp
A Cloth
Warp
Harnesses
Cloth roll
B
Warp beam
4.1 Basic weaving loom (courtesy of Staübli). Reed
Frames
Shed
Warp ends
Fabric
4.2 Weaving loom schema (courtesy of Staübli).
Creel technology A creel is a bobbin support that allows each yarn to be pulled independently, as shown in Fig. 4.3. A rudimentary creel can be made by simply placing bobbins on a rack (like those used for glass roving), while very sophisticated creels have tension control on each bobbin.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 91
9/6/11 4:43:44 PM
92
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
4.3 Creel example.
The creel process has two main advantages: ∑ ∑
Bobbins can be used directly from the fiber manufacturer. Bobbins can run independently, which allows the loom to pull different lengths depending on the fabric pattern or shape.
Yarn tension may be less homogeneous than with beam technology, due to the positioning of the bobbins in the creel, and the yarn angle between creel and harness. An additional device between creel and harness, called an ‘eye board’, can be introduced in order to steer the warp straight through the harness from the back of the loom to the front. Beam technology A beam is a large cylinder onto which all warp ends can be wound, as shown in Fig. 4.4. Beam technology is very convenient for providing equal tension on each yarn, which is important in producing fabric with regular patterns. For technical fibers, like carbon or glass, the quality of the beam winding must be perfect. If the tension of some yarns is different from that of others, individual tows will have different lengths, and the fabric quality will be poor. For production, looms with warp beams are much more compact than looms with creels. However, an intermediary warping process is necessary, for winding yarn from the bobbins to the beam.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 92
9/6/11 4:43:44 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
93
Section beam warping
4.4 Beam example (courtesy of Staübli).
4.2.2
Crossing warp head
The central part of the loom consists of a head, which controls warp lift, shed, the reed, and the fill-insertion device. Two main technologies have been developed for the head on an automated loom: ∑ ∑
The earliest and simplest is the harness frame or dobby process, which uses several frames holding heddles that are lifted by different cams. The second is the Jacquard process, in which each warp end can be lifted individually by the head.
Harness frame process (cam or dobby) Harness frame technology, created in the eighteenth century, is a natural development of the hand loom, where the warp is separated into two yarn webs to form the shed and lifted by hand or by pedals. After fill insertion, each web is crossed to interlace the fill. Two webs are sufficient for plain weave, the simplest and most popular pattern (Fig. 4.1). With harness frames, each warp web passes through the heddles of the same frame, as shown in Fig. 4.5. To make more complex patterns, the number of frames can be increased. The maximum number of frames on the dobby of a regular loom is of the order of 28. For some very specific applications, customized looms have been developed that have a double dobby with 56 frames. However, increasing the number of frames requires a drastic increase in the lift of the rear frames, in order to keep a good shed for the fill insertion. This can be a problem because technical fibers are very sensitive to large variations in shed opening.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 93
9/6/11 4:43:44 PM
94
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance Heddles
Warp
4.5 Harness heddles (courtesy of Staübli).
Harness frame is the most convenient method for creating simple, regular fabrics like plain weave, twill and satin. Fabrics woven from composites are almost exclusively manufactured with this technology. Jacquard process Jacquard technology, invented by Joseph Marie Jacquard at the beginning of the nineteenth century, enables the manufacture of more complicated patterns. The Jacquard process is a mechanical technology that independently lifts each heddle of the harness (see Fig. 4.6). Originally, it was controlled by a device that read holes punched in pasteboard cards, where each hole corresponded to a warp lift. Although these mechanical heads are still used, it is increasingly common for Jacquard heads to be controlled by electronic systems. This technology is necessary for complex pattern definitions such as 3D weaving patterns, or complex net shape preforms for composite parts, which require a large degree of freedom for the interlacement of warp yarns.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 94
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
95
y
x
4.6 Jacquard process (courtesy of Staübli).
Although some technical weavers have used this technology for years, it is not yet a popular method for producing composite preforms.
4.2.3
Take-up systems
The ‘take-up system’ is the mechanism that pulls woven fabric out of the central part of the loom, and so controls weft count. For regular fabrics it is composed of a set of different mandrels (two or three), as shown in Figs 4.1 and 4.2. The first two are dedicated to advancing the fabric and controlling the weft count, while the last one is for winding the woven fabric with a uniform tension. For regular production, almost all woven fabrics are manufactured using this technology.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 95
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
96
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
In the manufacture of thick fabrics (more than ~3 to 5 mm), particularly 3D woven fabrics, the textile structure can be damaged by winding on a regular mandrel even if the diameter of the mandrel is increased. A special device with clamps to pull the preform straight out of the loom is therefore used. These systems are usually custom built.
4.2.4
Fill insertion
Different processes have been used to insert the weft across the width of the fabric: ∑
The earliest is the shuttle process, which was used for handmade fabrics and is still used today for applications like narrow fabrics for ribbons. ∑ The rapier process was born in the twentieth century and is now the most popular production approach. ∑ Other processes, such as projectile, needle, air jet and water jet, are used only for very specific purposes. Shuttle process This process uses a device called a shuttle to move yarn across the fabric width. A small bobbin of yarn is incorporated into the shuttle. The yarn is held at one side of the fabric, and unwinds from the bobbin as the shuttle is thrown through the shed opening to the other side. Originally, the shuttle was moved by hand as shown in Fig. 4.7. During the eighteenth century, John Key invented the flying shuttle. This shuttle, running on wheels, moved over the lower side of the warp web as shown in Fig. 4.8. Two wooden tenders connected by a small rope, which was pulled by hand, propelled the shuttle. A century later, it was improved by the addition of a multi-shuttle device, able to change the type of yarn in the weft direction. For technical applications, like weaving composites, this technology is used rarely and only for specific purposes such as narrow tapes (carbon or glass UD, for example), or to achieve a continuous fill at the edge without selvedge (to weave a cylindrical fabric, for example). The winding and unwinding inherent to this process can introduce some non-negligible additional twisting to the fill yarn. This may be unacceptable for some fragile yarns and some composite applications. Rapier process This process consists of inserting the fill with a clamping device, called a rapier, which takes the yarn from a fixed bobbin on one side of the loom and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 96
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
97
4.7 Hand loom.
4.8 Flying shuttle loom.
transfers it to the other side. The end of the fill is cut on the bobbin side after insertion. The technology was developed at the beginning of the twentieth century, and was popularized during the second half of that century. Different types of rapier are used (Fig. 4.9): ∑ ∑
Rigid ones that stay straight during weaving Flexible rapiers that are wound and unwound during weaving, allowing the use of more compact looms ∑ Double rapiers, with one placed on each side, and an exchange of the fill yarn from one to the other in the middle of the shed.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 97
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
98
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Solid
Shuttle
Rapier
Cripper
Air jet
Fluid
Air
Water
Water jet
4.9 Fill insertion technologies.
A rapier can be much slimmer than a shuttle, because it does not have to carry the bobbin. The shed opening can then be reduced, which means a smaller lift of the harness. This is important, because a smaller lift reduces the tension variation on the yarn, which is desirable for technical fibers with low elongation factors. This technology is extensively used for the production of woven fabrics in composite applications. Other processes Other fill insertion technologies exist, but are seldom used for technical woven fabrics. These technologies include: ∑
The projectile process, in which the fill yarn is transferred by clamping it to the back of a projectile, which is launched from one side of the loom to the other (see Fig. 4.9). ∑ Air jets. The fill yarn is pushed through the whole width of the fabric by an air nozzle or a series of air nozzles, without the use of any other device (i.e. without a shuttle or projectile) (see Fig. 4.9). ∑ Water jets. The same as air jets but the fluid power is provided by water instead of air (see Fig. 4.9). ∑ Needles. This technology replaces the shuttle or rapier in the production of narrow fabrics. Needle and yarn go through the shed to the other side of the loom. The yarn is maintained by a hook at the opposite side of the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 98
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
99
loom and the needle comes back with the yarn, which inserts a double fill into the same shed opening. Use of these technologies is mainly driven by the desire to increase loom productivity. They are applicable only for specific fibers, such as low-weight synthetic or cotton fibers.
4.2.5
Fabric width
Weaving looms have a large range of widths: ∑
Small looms are able to weave anything from a few millimeters to several centimeters. Mostly used for ribbons or tapes, they can use frame or Jacquard technologies for the harness and shuttle or rapier (or sometimes needle) for the fill insertion. For small widths, shuttle looms can have several heads in parallel, each weaving fabric with the same pass. ∑ Regular looms with a fabric width between 1 and 2.5 meters are able to use all the technologies explained previously. ∑ Large looms, which are more than 4 to 5 meters and sometimes up to 15 meters or more, are used for specific applications like carpets or paper machine clothing, and employ shuttle or projectile processes for fill insertion.
4.2.6
Other weaving technologies
Some marginal technologies have been developed that can be useful for specific applications. All are based on woven structure interlacements, but some have more directions and some have different fiber orientations. ∑
Circular weaving. A technology for weaving circular fabric exists, which produces very open fabrics for bags with synthetic fibers, but it is not used for technical fibers. With another technology, a tubular fabric can be woven on a shuttle loom by weaving two flat layers at the same time, and adjusting the weaving at the edge to keep the same pattern. The continuous fill provided by shuttle weaving eliminates discontinuities at the edges. Such fabric can be cut on a helix to obtain a ± 45° fabric. ∑ ±45° weaving technology. Some prototypes have been developed for manufacturing a woven ±45° fabric, but their use is limited. ∑ Tri-axial fabrics. There is a process for weaving in three directions, which produces a fabric with fiber with 0°/+60°/–60° orientation. This complex technology produces a very open fabric, but a single layer of this fabric is quasi-isotropic. ∑ Four-directional fabrics. Some prototypes have been developed to produce a 4 ¥ 45° woven fabric in 2D and even 3D. This technology is limited in width, and is not yet in production. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 99
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
100
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
4.3
Woven fabric definitions
Having provided an overview of existing technologies, we next have to define all the possible fabric styles that weaving technologies can produce. The following description progresses from the simplest to the most complicated.
4.3.1
2D patterns
Patterns for woven fabrics are defined by the smallest repeating unit cell, which describes the interlacing of the warp and weft. The term ‘2D (two-dimensional)’ is used to identify standard fabric with one layer of warp and one layer of fill. There are three main types of 2D pattern: plain weave, twill and satin. Plain weave definition Plain weave (PW) is the basic and simplest pattern. The unit cell (or weave repeat) of this pattern is made up of two warps and two wefts. As shown in Fig. 4.10, the first warp yarn goes over the first fill and under the second fill, while the second warp goes under the first fill and up the second. Plain weave was the most popular pattern amongst early weavers. The harness requires a minimum of two frames, with odd warp ends running through the heddle of the first frame to create the first warp web, and even warp ends going through the second frame to create the second. These two webs alternate between the top and bottom position for each fill insertion.
4.10 Plain weave pattern (Wisetex image).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 100
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
101
The surface of the fabric looks like a checkerboard (as Fig. 4.11) on both sides. Basket weave pattern is derived from PW. Two or more warp ends alternately interlace two or more fill ends, as can be seen in Fig. 4.12. Twill definition The weave repeat of a twill weave (TW) pattern has a minimum of three warps and three weft columns. It is generated by shifting a base pattern by one warp and one weft column, relative to the adjacent warp column. This shifting is constant across the width of the fabric and is always in the same direction. The surface of the fabric is characterized by diagonal stripes, and the two sides typically differ in appearance. The most simple twill pattern is the 2 ¥ 1 TW (see Fig. 4.13), called 2 ¥ 1 because each warp end goes over two fills and under one. The bottom side of the fabric will show two fills running over two warps, then under one. The term ‘warp face’ is used for the top side (because warp predominates), and the term ‘weft face’ or ‘fill face’ is for the bottom side.
Top
Bottom
4.11 Each side of PW.
Top
Bottom
4.12 Basket pattern (Wisetex image).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 101
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
102
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Top
Bottom
4.13 Twill pattern 2 ¥ 1 (Wisetex image).
TW 2 ¥ 2
TW 3 ¥ 1
4.14 Examples of TW (Wisetex image).
Looms need a minimum of three frames to create three different warp webs. These three webs alternate, sometimes with two webs at the top of the shed and one at the bottom, sometimes with one at the top and two at the bottom. See Fig. 4.14 for some examples of different variations of twill patterns. The 2 ¥ 2 TW is a balanced pattern because each side has the same number of warps interlacing up and down, which means the length of warp and fill will be the same on each side. Satin definition Satin is the third basic pattern family. It has a relatively small number of interlocking locations, which are scattered to avoid the diagonal appearance of twill patterns. The satin family is characterized by the same basic interlocking pattern for each warp, which is shifted several fill columns relative to the adjacent warp. In contrast to the twill pattern, the shift is not uniform for all warp columns in the repeats. The basic pattern of each warp is under one fill and over several. An ‘N’ harness satin (NHS) means that the warp goes under one and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 102
9/6/11 4:43:45 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
103
over (N – 1) fill ends. The weave repeat is N warp and N weft columns. This shifting is always more than 1 and less than (N – 1), and is constant overall. The amount of shift in the fill between two adjacent warps must not be a divisible factor of N. For example, for a 5HS the shift must be two or three, and for an 8HS it must be three or five (see fig. 4.15). The 4HS pattern is an exception to the usual rule for satin. It has an irregular shifting pattern because the rules defined above cannot be satisfied. For this special case, interlacing displacement between two adjacent warps alternates between two and one fill column shifts, as one can see in Fig. 4.16.
5HS
Top
Bottom
8HS
4.15 5HS and 8HS patterns (Wisetex image).
4.16 4HS pattern (Wisetex image).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 103
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
104
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
There is a significant difference between the appearance of the two sides of a satin fabric: one has a majority of visible warp and is called the ‘warp face’, and the other has a majority of visible weft and is called the ‘weft face’. Properties of the three basic 2D pattern families If the three types of 2D patterns are compared, several rules applicable to composite applications can be defined. ∑
Firmness and drapability. Because it has the highest level of interlacement, PW is the most stable pattern, which means it is the least formable. In contrast, HS patterns are definitively the most formable fabrics but can be more difficult to handle and to keep in their original geometry. For regular TW patterns, the formability is in between PW and HS. ∑ Weight and thickness. HS patterns are potentially the best choice for the heaviest and thickest fabrics. Greater thickness is made possible by the low level of interlocking. In contrast PW, the most interlaced pattern, is more appropriate for lightweight fabrics. ∑ Symmetry. The only patterns that create the same effect on both side are PW and N ¥ N TW. All the other patterns have a warp and fill face. ∑ Crimp (wave induce by yarn interlocking). Due to the interlacement at every fill, the PW pattern introduces more crimp into the fabric than TW or HS. For composite applications, mechanical properties in the x–y direction (i.e. in plane) can be significantly affected by a higher crimp level.
4.3.2
3D patterns
Compared with 2D patterns, which are far more common, 3D (threedimensional) fabrics only appeared in the composite field for R&D applications in the 1980s. However, such patterns have been used in the textile industry for more than 100 years. Three-dimensional woven fabrics are defined by an interlacement of several layers of warp and weft linked through the thickness. These patterns can be manufactured directly on a loom. Jacquard woven cloth, including furnishing fabrics, can be considered 3D woven fabrics but they do not have a regular pattern and have more crossing layers. These layers give particular color and design effects. This is also true for carpet fabrics, but when they are woven on a mechanical loom, two fabrics are woven at the same time. The woven pattern can be considered to be a 3D pattern, as can be seen in Fig. 4.17. It can be argued that the first technical application for 3D woven fabrics
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 104
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 105
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
12 13 14
15
11 20
10
7
5
6
2
3 b
2
20
1
a
2 14
b
2
20
1
a
20
2
3 b
2
20
1
a
20
a
2
3 b a b
2
20
20
2
1
20
2 13 2
20
1
7
12 13 14 9
15 2 6
b
4
8 10 5 11
1
222
4
221
223
231
226
232 232¢
4.17 Carpet fabric pattern (patent nos EP0919652A2 and EP1375714A1).
a
20
4
2 212/212¢
225
211
TP
22
14
23
21
220
106
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
involved their use as straps for carrying heavy loads. These patterns are simple enough to be woven on frame looms, and are very efficient. A combination of the properties of the yarn, the pattern, and the friction between filaments makes such straps robust. Another technical application for 3D woven patterns is in paper making clothing. These fabrics, usually woven from polyamide and polyester monofilaments, have a specific texture on one side to obtain the proper paper surface, and a specific porosity to extract water from the paper through the fabric. A classification into orthogonal, angle interlock and multilayer patterns is proposed for the different patterns used for 3D woven fabrics in composite applications. Orthogonal 3D patterns Yarns in orthogonal 3D patterns are orientated in the three principal orthogonal directions of volume (x, y, z), as shown in Fig. 4.18. Some warp yarns are straight in the x direction (warp ends), fill yarns are straight in the y direction (fill ends), and some warp ends (called ‘warp weavers’) interlace the other yarns and are, at times, orientated in the z direction (corresponding to the thickness of the fabric). This is the simplest 3D pattern, and it can be manufactured on frame harness looms if the number of layers is not too high (maximum ~20 layers). The structure of this pattern permits multi-rapier insertions during the same pass, which can be an efficient way to increase productivity. Angle interlock patterns Angle interlock patterns do not have warp weavers in the z direction (across the thickness of the fabric). Interlock patterns are defined by two criteria:
4.18 Orthogonal 3D pattern (Wisetex image).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 106
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
∑ ∑
107
Warps in the same warp column interlace several fill layers (to become a 3D fabric linked through the thickness). Every warp has the same path in the same warp column every fill layer.
We can define two families within angle interlock patterns: through-thethickness interlock and ply-to-ply interlock. Through-the-thickness interlock patterns, as shown in Fig. 4.19, have warp columns crossing all the weft layers of the fabric. In ply-to-ply interlock patterns, the warp is interlaced, and only goes through some weft layers as shown in Fig. 4.20. The EADS trademark 2.5D (Fig. 4.21) is a member of the ply-to-ply interlock family. Multilayer patterns Multilayer patterns look like several layers of regular 2D fabrics with some interlacement between the layers. For example, the pattern shown in Fig. 4.22 is a multi-PW pattern. The basic pattern of each layer is a PW, but
4.19 Through-the-thickness interlock pattern example (Wisetex image).
4.20 Ply-to-ply interlock pattern example (Wisetex image).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 107
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
108
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
4.21 2.5D pattern (Wisetex image).
4.22 Example of multilayer PW pattern (Wisetex image).
some warps are going from one layer into another to create links that make the 3D pattern. Multilayer patterns have certain benefits: the weave repeat can be quite simple and they can be made on a harness frame loom if only a few layers are needed (i.e. up to five or six). Another example of a multi-HS fabric is shown in Fig. 4.23. A loom with a Jacquard head is usually needed for this type of fabric if more than three layers are required. Properties of 3D patterns for composite applications Three-dimensional fabrics have some general properties, but these rules can be slightly modified, depending on the type of yarn and the warp/fill count for each layer.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 108
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
109
4.23 Example of multilayer 4HS pattern (Wisetex image).
Firmness Orthogonal 3D patterns produce very strong, hard preforms, and the geometry of these preforms is very difficult to modify. This characteristic can be explained by the yarn directions. The preform directly out of the loom can have a fiber content close to 50–55%, which is quite high. To increase it to 60–65%, the thickness has to be reduced by roughly 20%. It is practically impossible to do this with a thick preform without skewing the fiber alignment or damaging the fiber. Through-the-thickness interlocks are less firm than orthogonal 3D patterns, but they can be quite hard too, if there is a significant quantity of straight warp in the pattern. They are more compressible than orthogonal patterns because there is no fiber in the thickness direction. The most soft and compressible patterns that can be produced without damaging the yarn positioning are those without straight warp fibers. All the warps in the same column follow the same path, and are able to move together naturally without being fixed by another warp column with the same property. The multilayer patterns are not hard, and are easily compressed. More de-bulking is required for these patterns, especially when the interlacing goes through only one or two layers. Drapability The drapability of these 3D woven fabrics follows the same trend as firmness. An orthogonal 3D is not formable for complex shapes due to the structure
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 109
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
110
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
of the interlacement. Interlock patterns without straight warp and multilayer patterns are the only ones that produce nice formable fabric. Other parameters like tow size, warp/weft count and warp/weft ratio can be optimized to improve the formability of a preform. Mechanical properties The best properties in the z direction are obtained with orthogonal 3D patterns, and this can be easily explained by fiber directions. The lowest through-the-thickness properties are found in multilayer patterns that are close to 2D fabrics. Interlock patterns are in between. In the in-plane (x–y) direction, properties depend on warp and fill crimp. Using patterns with straight tows like orthogonal 3D or through-the-thickness interlock can be an advantage, but this depends on the quantity of warp weavers. For interlock patterns, depending on the specific pattern, the tow size and the warp and fill count, the crimp can be reduced to give x–y properties close to those of the other types of 3D fabrics. For multilayer patterns, the x–y properties are not significantly different from those of the basic equivalent 2D fabric.
4.3.3
Specific shapes
Most fabrics are flat and can be wound onto a roll as they are manufactured, but there are ways of producing other shapes. Contour woven fabrics These fabrics are woven with a special shape, which is created by a particular device on the loom. One example is shown in Fig. 4.24. The most popular use for such fabrics is in fan case containment for aircraft engines. Spiral fabrics By using another special device on the loom, weaving technology permits the manufacture of helical fabrics, as shown in Fig. 4.25. The two yarn directions in the fabric are radial for the weft and circumferential for the warp. Tubular or conical fabrics One way to produce a tubular fabric is to weave a flat double layer on a shuttle loom, with a special interlacement at the edge to keep the regular pattern. With the same technology but using a more complex design, the edge junction of the double layer fabric can follow a triangular shape. After © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 110
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites 40
44
111
50 39
42
38
39
41
54
53
52 51
4.24 Example of contour weaving (patent no. EP0302012A1).
4.25 Spiral woven fabric.
creating an opening between the two layers, the shape of the fabric is conical. This technology had been used for composite noses for military aircrafts. Double-wall fabric When manufacturing carpet or velvet, two woven fabrics are produced simultaneously (top and bottom) with interconnecting yarns. These yarns are cut in the middle to give the ‘fluffy’ texture on one side. If the interconnecting
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 111
9/6/11 4:43:46 PM
112
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
yarns are not cut, the same technology can be used to produce a double wall preform linked by vertical yarns. Complex shapes 3D patterns can be used to weave flat fabrics with several layers, and carefully positioned bifurcations can be made between layers to obtain preforms than can be unfolded to produce complex shapes. Figure 4.26 shows some examples of unfolded preforms for stiffeners, Pi preforms, and other complex shapes. A multitude of combinations are possible. Even if textile definition is more complicated than in regular fabric, creating complex woven shapes may ultimately simplify manufacturing of composite parts. For example, a complex part can be made with only one 3D woven preform, instead of using several plies, which sometimes require additional bonding technologies. 3D woven fabric can also produce a net shape preform directly on the loom by removing some layers and letting some warps end without interlacement. After weaving, extra floats can be trimmed to obtain the complex net shape preform. For example, an aircraft engine fan blade can be made from a 3D woven complex shape preform, as shown in Fig. 4.27
4.26 Examples of complex shapes.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 112
9/6/11 4:43:47 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
113
4.27 Snecma composite fan blade.
4.3.4
Woven fabric characterization
The different parameters of a woven fabric are given below: ∑
Definition of the yarn or tow, including type, linear weight, sizing and twist ∑ Warp and fill count, including the number of warp and fill ends per unit length ∑ Pattern ∑ Weight of the fabric ∑ Thickness under pressure ∑ Warp and fill crimp. This is the difference between the woven yarn length and the fabric length. It is expressed as the percentage of extra length that represents the additional length needed for the pattern interlacement. ∑ Selvedge. This is a specific pattern with a high level of special interlacement on each edge of the fabric. Its function is to fix the fill ends to avoid the risk of fraying. Usually selvedge is done with a different yarn type than is used in the rest of the fabric. ∑ Fabric width and piece length.
4.4
Applications for composite reinforcements
The following is an overview of applications that make significant use of woven fabrics for composite parts:
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 113
9/6/11 4:43:47 PM
114
∑
∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ ∑
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Civil and military aircraft: for the new generation of civil aircraft, composite parts represent around 50% of total weight. Woven fabrics have a large proportion of composite reinforcement for use in the fuselage, wings, engine nacelles, landing gears, and brakes. Helicopters need composites for the same parts as planes but at higher percentages. Space and defense: for missiles and launch vehicles with polymeric and thermostructural matrix composites, and for satellite applications. Wind energy: for blades with carbon and glass fibers, and even for masts. Sport and leisure: for jet skis, snowboards, wakeboards and canoes, frames and components for racing cycles, motorcycle accessories, fuel tanks, wheels and helmets, tennis racquets and golf clubs. Marine: for hulls, decking, spars and mast. Glass fibers are used most, but carbon fibers are sometimes used in racing boats. Industry: for robotics and high-speed automation, printed circuit boards and composite tooling. Automotive industry, particularly sports cars: specific applications include bodies, chassis, and front and rear wings. Ballistics: glass or aramid fabrics are used for helmets, body armor, vehicle armor, and secure door structures for buildings and aircraft.
Woven fabrics are not the only reinforcements used for all these applications. They are challenged by other technologies like UD tapes, fiber placement or NCF (non crimp fabric) products.
4.5
Conclusion and future trends
What will be the future of weaving in the composites business? 2D woven fabric was the first technology used for composite structural reinforcements, and is still the most popular. More recent technologies like NCF and fiber placement are challenging this technology and have replaced it in some applications. These new technologies can potentially be cheaper or offer better fiber orientations, and will continue to replace woven parts. However, they are not such mature technologies as weaving, and for many applications introducing them will take time. For example, in the aerospace businesses it will take several years to introduce these technologies, because new products must be certified. Meanwhile, technical weavers are continuing to improve 2D technologies in order to increase loom speed, and are working on spreading heavier and cheaper tows to produce fabrics with the same weight. 3D weaving and complex shapes have high potential for expansion. Combined with RTM processes, they can limit the number of steps from © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 114
9/6/11 4:43:47 PM
Woven reinforcements for composites
115
fiber to final part. There is only one preform to mold, and it is already close to the net shape, as opposed to several plies that must be cut, collated, and sometimes linked together. However, design offices will need to think differently if 3D weaving and complex shapes are to be introduced industrially on a large scale. There are important differences between them and the more familiar laminate composites. Perhaps most importantly, defining the right preform is more time consuming. 3D techniques are just beginning to find industrial applications, in the same way that 2D carbon woven fabrics were 40 years ago. Several years later these fabrics became industrial products – can we expect the same from complex shapes and 3D woven fabrics?
4.6
Acknowledgement
Many thanks to Jon Goering for correction of this chapter.
4.7
Sources of further information and advice
Some book references for weaving and textile technologies: ∑
Woven Textile Structure: Theory and Applications, B K Behera and P K Hari, Indian Institute of Technology, India Woodhead Publishing Series in Textiles, No. 115. ∑ 3-D Fibrous Assemblies: Properties, Applications and Modelling of Three-dimensional Textile Structures, J Hu, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong, Woodhead Publishing Series in Textiles, No. 74. ∑ Handbook of Technical Textiles, A. Richard Horrocks, Subhash Anand and S. Anand, Woodhead Publishing Series in Textiles, No. 12. Some website references for woven composite reinforcement manufacturers: http://ww3.albint.com/AEC http://www.ballyribbon.com/ http://www.cytec.com http://www.hexcel.com http://www.porcher-ind.com/ http://www.sigmatex.com/ http://www.3tex.com/ Some website references for weaving loom manufacturers: http://www.lindauerdornier.com http://www.mueller-frick.com/ http://www.staubli.com/en/textile/ © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-04.indd 115
9/6/11 4:43:47 PM
5
Braided reinforcements for composites
A. G e s s l e r, EADS Deutschland GmbH, Germany
Abstract: This chapter describes braiding technologies used for the production of net-shaped or near-net-shaped composite preforms. The advantages and limitations of the braiding process are explained with examples of practical applications. Because mandrels play an important role in braiding, various mandrel technologies and materials are described together with their different applications. Key words: braiding, unidirectional braiding, overbraiding of mandrels, robot-assisted braiding, 3D-braiding, braided textiles, braiding mandrels.
5.1
Introduction
For over 100 years, industrial braiding technology has been used in the manufacture of consumer goods as varied as shoe laces and power cords for flat-irons. Most braids, however, are highly specialized technical products with demanding requirements for durability, reliability and quality. Climbing ropes, marine ropes and metallic jackets for cables and high-pressure tubes are the best-known examples of these technical applications. Tubes made out of glass fibers were among the first braided products used for composites, mainly for sport and leisure applications. Fibers like carbon and aramid soon followed. In the early 1990s, braiding became more significant when preform-infusion technology developed in composite manufacturing. Braiding could be used in net-shaped fiber preforms for complex composite parts by overbraiding of contoured mandrels (the device around which the braid is formed). It soon it became clear that this technology was not only cost-effective and quick but also highly versatile. Many companies around the world started to research ways of mass-producing braided composites. Braided preforms are now well established in high-tech applications, e.g. crash absorbers in sports cars, aircraft propeller blades and even structural aircraft parts.
5.2
Fundamentals of braiding
Simple braids are textiles with interlocked fibers in two directions. At least three strands are needed to build a braid. Unlike in woven fabrics, where the warp runs along the textile and the weft is exactly perpendicular (90°), the 116 © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 116
9/6/11 4:44:12 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
117
basic characteristic of braiding is that the yarns are run at an angle from one rim of a braided ribbon to the other or like a helix around a tubular support. Figure 5.1 compares weave, flat braid and tubular braid. The yarn angles in a braid depend on the relative speed of the bobbins and the take-up. The faster the take-up, the smaller the angle. Angles between 10° and close to 90° can be achieved. It is important to achieve a closed braid with a 100% coverage to avoid resin-rich areas in the composite (see Fig. 5.2). The fiber angle, the total number of yarns and the circumference of the mandrel are in a direct relationship. This relationship is the key feature in the design of a braided preform and the most important limitation of braiding technology: with the exception of 3D braiding, the number of yarns is always fixed. No technical solutions to change the number of yarns in the braiding process have been found so far. In 1748 Thomas Wattford (Manchester, England) filed the first patent for a braiding machine. Industrial production of the so-called ‘Barmer Flechtmaschinen’ started in 1767 in Barmen, a part of Wuppertal (Germany). The basic principle (Fig. 5.3) has remained more or less unchanged. A braider consists of: ∑ ∑
The bobbins holding the yarns Bobbin carriers to keep the yarn under tension
Weave
Flat braid
Tubular braid
5.1 Comparison of weave, flat braid and tubular braid.
Open braid
Closed braid
5.2 Open braid (coverage about 80%) and closed braid (coverage 100%).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 117
9/6/11 4:44:14 PM
118
∑ ∑
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
A machine bed with an engraved groove to guide the bobbin carriers as they are pushed forward by the horn gears A take-up mechanism to pull the completed braid from the machine.
The variations of modern braiding machines are numerous. The machine size and the number of bobbin carriers depend on the type of braid required. Figure 5.4 shows some examples. The versatility of modern preforming machines depends on two basic features: ∑ ∑
Overbraiding of contoured mandrels The combination of the braider with an industrial robot to handle the mandrel.
The braider is fully controlled by the robot program. The machine speed can be continuously adapted to the mandrel diameter to produce a braid with the required yarn angle. The robot also allows smooth and rapid changes of
Clockwise running bobbins
Counter-clockwise running bobbins Take-up
Braid point
Braid
Carrier Horn gear Horn
Carrier foot track
5.3 Braiding machine principle and machine elements.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 118
9/6/11 4:44:14 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
119
5.4 Top to bottom: net yarn braiding machine, offshore rope braider, composite preform machine.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 119
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
120
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
the mandrel position and angle relative to the braiding machine, which is helpful in dealing with discontinuities in the preform. Additional machine adaptations have been made to deal with carbon fiber rovings. These started with special bobbin carriers and yarn guiding elements and ended up with the so-called ‘radial braider’ with bobbins running on the inside of the machine. Other fibers of technical interest, like glass or aramid rovings, have also benefited from these developments, though there is a drawback: the bobbin capacity on a radial braider is a lower (about 5–10% depending on the fiber type). As a result, production has to be stopped more often to load the braider with a new set of bobbins.
5.3
Braiding technologies for preforming
Although there is a huge number of different braider types, sizes and configurations for different technical applications, machines for production of preforms split into two basic types: the so-called ‘3D braider’ and – most important – the circular braider, as shown in Fig. 5.4. Machine size is defined by the yarn and preform size and is constrained by the need for 100% coverage. Braiders with 144 or 196 bobbin carriers are typical. Filament yarns like carbon rovings can be narrowed, but each yarn type has its specific maximum lay-up width. As a rough-and-ready rule, a 144 carrier braider is able to cover a mandrel with a circumference of about 300 mm at an angle of 45° with an 800 tex HT carbon roving. Machines need not be small, because it is possible to work with a reduced number of bobbins without serious effects on the braid quality, even when the bobbins are unevenly distributed on the machine.
5.3.1
Circular braiding
Conventional braiders This type of braider has its horn gears on the front of the machine. Due to the path of the bobbin, which follows a wavelike pattern (like a sine shape), the distance between the bobbin and machine center is never constant. To keep the yarns under tension, the bobbin carriers (Fig. 5.5) are equipped with a spring-loaded faller. This pulls a certain length of the yarn back into the bobbin carrier when it moves from the outside to the innermost position on the machine. These braiders are the standard machines for the production of tubes and ropes. For these applications, the machines are combined with a take-up mechanism and a braiding ring, located at a distance of about half of the machine diameter in front of or above the yarn outlet of the bobbins. Figure 5.6 shows a typical configuration. © Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 120
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
121
5.5 Bobbin carrier of a conventional braider.
The braiding ring defines the distance known as the ‘braiding point’, the point at which the yarns meet each other. It influences the angle of the braid as well as the angle at which the yarns leave the bobbin carriers. The maximum angle at the bobbin is defined by the stroke of the tensioner. In the extreme position, when the braiding ring is located in the plane of the yarn outlet, the tensioner must cover the whole amplitude of the bobbin path. This configuration is of special importance for mandrel overbraiding (see Section 5.3.2). It requires an advanced type of bobbin carrier (Fig. 5.7), able to deal with not only the amplitude of about 120 mm but also the fragility of the carbon rovings as well. On the average, each segment of the yarn is pulled back and forth over the rollers and guiding elements about 30 times until it finally leaves the bobbin carrier. There is a delicate balance between the low yarn tension required and the force to pull the roving back into the reservoir. As a result, these bobbin carriers require careful maintenance. The advanced bobbin carrier design has substantially reduced yarn damage and broken filaments. New radial braiding machines promise to reduce the problem even further. Radial braiders First introduced by Muratec in early 1990, the so-called ‘radial braiders’ or ‘tunnel braiders’ were further developed to the late 1990s by the German
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 121
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
122
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.6 Typical braiding machine configuration.
5.7 Advanced bobbin carrier used for overbraiding with carbon rovings.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 122
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
123
braiding machine manufacturer Herzog. The horn gears are no longer located on the front but inside the machine. The bobbin carriers point to the center of the machine, avoiding a 90° redirection of the yarns. Figure 5.8 illustrates a Herzog radial braider. The major benefit of a radial braider is the reduction of the relative movement between the yarn outlet and the braiding point to a few millimeters, because the bobbin path is now perpendicular to the machine base plane. Because yarn consumption now normally exceeds the change in length, there is no pullback of the yarns into the bobbin and no repetitive crinkling and straightening. As a result, the risk of yarn damage is drastically reduced compared to a conventional braider. The complexity of the bobbin carriers on a radial braider is similar to that on a conventional machine (see Fig. 5.5). The tensioner no longer needs to compensate for the amplitude of the bobbin path. The capacity of the faller now allows asymmetric positioning of the mandrel in the machine and reduces the risk of tangling the yarns when the direction of the mandrel is changed (Fig. 5.9). Another advance in reducing fiber damage is the use of a baffle, covering
5.8 Herzog radial braider.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 123
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
124
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.9 Radial braider bobbin carrier optimized for carbon roving processing.
about one-third of the spool. It reduces friction between the roving and the coil by reducing the take-up angle and the area affected when the yarn scrapes over the coil (Fig. 5.10). Radial braiders need a minimum machine size because of the angle between the horn gears. The first problem is to run the bobbin carriers smoothly around the machine. Noise and wear of machine parts increase in proportion with decreasing machine diameter. The second problem derives from the limited room for movement by the bobbin carriers. This reduces spool capacity, particularly for smaller machines. If there is a minimum size required, there is no theoretical limitation to the maximum size of machines. The design flexibility regarding the number and diameter of horn gears and bobbin capacity is constantly growing with machine size. One of the biggest radial braiders, with 288 bobbins and
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 124
9/6/11 4:44:15 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
125
5.10 Effect of the baffle (realized as an open cage for demonstration).
a diameter of about 4.6 meters, is located at the University of Dresden (Germany): see Fig. 5.11. Independent of machine size, radial braiders are comparatively slim and both face planes can be kept completely flat. Motors and feeding systems for 0° yarns can be located on the outside. Hence two or more machines can be positioned side by side to produce a multilayer textile.
5.3.2
Overbraiding of mandrels
Overbraiding can be regarded as the most flexible technology for net-shaped or near-net-shaped textile preforming. At a first glance the preform shape is solely defined by the shape of the mandrel. But this is not the complete
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 125
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
126
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.11 Radial braider at the University of Dresden.
picture. After removing the textile from the mandrel, other preforming methods like draping, folding or combination with other preforms can be used to create a huge variety of preforms. The technology of overbraiding needs a combination of a braider with a manipulation device for the mandrel. In some cases, a simple and lowcost linear track serves this purpose. However, as the preform becomes more complex, an industrial robot (see Fig. 5.4) can be regarded as the best option, particularly as the price is low enough to compete with most individual solutions. If the braider is connected to the robot control as an external axis, the complete production sequence can be automated by using the robot programming language. In 1991 Rosenbaum [1] described a machine configuration with a moving braider and a fixed mandrel. This is an optimized solution for very long mandrels for two reasons: first, the mandrel is supported on both sides, and, second, the required floor space is only about 10–20% longer than the mandrel, whereas it has to be more than twice the mandrel length if the braiding machine is fixed. Nowadays advanced braiding machines combine both a moving braider and an industrial robot. Two industrial robots, one on either side of the braider, can be coupled to one integrated unit if a doublesided support of the mandrel is required.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 126
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
127
The production of a preform is carried out by moving the mandrel in the braider back and forth. Each machine path creates a new layer. The stacking sequence depends on the type of braid (see below, Section 5.5.1). Wall thickness transitions (by two layers) can be achieved by changing the direction of motion, when only a part of the mandrel is covered. To create a neat edge on the inversion, the braid needs to be fixed. A ring of needles around the mandrel is a simple but unreliable solution. Clamping devices provide a better solution. They have sheet metal inside to form the edge and a stamp outside to ensure fixation when the sheet is removed. Figure 5.12 shows how wall thickness transitions can be achieved. The symmetrical construction of a radial braider is an optimized solution for overbraiding. This symmetry means that no deviations between forward and backward braiding limit the process and the flat shape of the yarn path in the machine maximizes the space for manipulating the mandrel (see Fig. 5.13). Compared to winding, overbraiding offers more freedom regarding part shape. Because of the self-supporting nature of braids, there is no limitation to fiber lay-up. Mandrels with more complex changes in curvature and circumference can be handled (Fig. 5.14 shows examples). Even undercuts can be handled by applying shaping devices. As shown in Fig. 5.15. The braid can be manufactured as a positive, and removing part of the mandrel before curing builds the undercut.
5.3.3
Three-dimensional (3D) braiding
The braiding technologies described above are limited to the production of textiles similar to woven fabrics. The preforms are built layer by layer
5.12 Realization of wall thickness transitions.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 127
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
128
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.13 Room for mandrel manipulation on different braider configurations.
with the mandrel as the shape-defining element. 3D braiding is completely different. The machine consists of a flat array of horn gears, connected by switches. The path of each individual bobbin can be freely chosen by altering the switches between two states. One state allows the bobbin to move from the actual horn gear to its neighbor; the other forces the bobbin to stay on the same horn gear and move in a new position 90° clockwise. On first-generation 3D braiders, all horn gears are turned simultaneously in one direction. Second-generation machines allow a horn gear to stay in position or to move either forwards or backwards. Figure 5.16 shows the design principle, and Fig. 5.17 shows a first-generation 3D braider with a 10 ¥ 10 horn gear array.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 128
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
129
5.14 Examples of overbraiding of extreme mandrel shapes.
This design means that the bobbins can move freely over the complete machine bed. The fiber architecture is no longer layer oriented. Defined by the programmable movement pattern, the yarns can now travel through the preform in three dimensions. On top of this the braid can be changed in shape, e.g. from a round to a rectangular cross-section, from solid to hollow, from a T to an L and H shape. The braid can even split up into two or more strands and then reconnect again later. Figure 5.18 shows an example for a 3D braid (T-profile), and Fig. 5.19 the machine setup. One basic method of operation is to reproduce the cross-section of the braid on the machine bed. A uniform 3D architecture can then be achieved by a standard moving pattern of the bobbins. More advanced 3D braids are much more complex. This was the reason for developing process simulation techniques at the same time as developing more advanced machines. Parameters to take into account include the moving pattern, the take-up speed and position, the dynamic forces influencing the yarns, yarn friction behavior, stiffness, etc. A basic problem of 3D braiding is the contradictory effects of increasing machine size. On the one hand, machines need to carry as many bobbins as possible. The total area of the product in cross-section is limited only
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 129
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
130
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
B
A
A
5.15 Realization of an undercut by draping: A: curing tools; B: auxiliary braiding mandrel.
Take-up direction Standing threads input channel
3D-braid
Bobbin
Bobbin path Horn gear
Switch point (cycle)
Switch point (transfer)
5.16 Design principle of a 3D braider.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 130
9/6/11 4:44:16 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
131
5.17 First-generation 3D braider with a 10 ¥ 10 horn gear array.
5.18 Example of a 3D braid (T-profile).
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 131
9/6/11 4:44:17 PM
132
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.19 Machine setup for the T-profile shown in Fig. 5.18.
by the sum of braiding and standing yarns working simultaneously. On the other hand, a wide machine bed needs an increased pull-back capacity of the bobbins, which causes potential problems. The most serious is the early tangling of fibers away from the braiding point in the outer areas of the machine bed (Fig. 5.20). Compared to circular or radial braiders, where the horn gears rotate with a speed of up to 200 rpm, the productivity of 3D braiders is quite low, because the process is not continuous. Every production step has two parts: all switches have first to be set in their new position and, after that, the bobbins are pushed into the next position by turning the horn gears by 90°. Modern 3D braiders can execute around one production step per second, which is about 4–6 times faster than the speed of a first-generation machine. Second-generation 3D braiders have a modular design based on units with 4 ¥ 4 horn gears. The arrangement of the units is flexible and can be adapted to particular production needs. The basic configuration is nine units in a horizontal 3 ¥ 3 arrangement. By removing the center unit, the machine can be used for overbraiding of long straight mandrels. Optimizing the number and position of the units, e.g. in a T or L shape, helps to increase productivity, since the spare units can be used for other production requirements. An example of the selective use of individual units is shown in Fig. 5.21.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 132
9/6/11 4:44:17 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
133
5.20 Tangled fibers on a 3D braider instead of a compact braid.
5.21 Second-generation 3D braider.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 133
9/6/11 4:44:17 PM
134
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.3.4
Other braiding technologies
Although not yet built, Georges Cahuzac has invented and patented a machine designed to produce an interlocked multilayer textile called ‘AEROTISS® 3.5 D fabric’ (Fig. 5.22). The textile is intended to overcome the impact damage sensitivity of CFRP materials with the help of rovings running between the layers to build multiple connection points. This type of textile requires a vertical braider consisting of multiple rows of bobbin tracks connected with self-shifting switches to manufacture a tube about 1 meter in circumference. It requires a machine with 5400 moving bobbins to build a 3 meter-wide 21-layer 3.5 textile with a thickness of about 3 mm. Production costs for the textile would be dominated by the cost of the machinery, including the bobbin carriers, and the time needed to change the bobbins.
5.4
Key parameters for using braiding machines
This section describes ways of obtaining an optimized setup of the braiding machine with respect to mandrel size and behavior of the braiding yarns. High-tech applications need smooth and flawless fiber architectures with a homogeneous fiber content of about 60%. Areas of neat resin in the laminate cannot be accepted. As a consequence, the coverage rate has to be as close to 100% as possible. Detailed investigations in recent years have shown that the so-called ‘UD-braids’ (see Section 5.5.1 below) offer superior material properties
5.22 Aerotiss 3.5D fabric.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 134
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
135
over standard biaxial and triaxial braids. Only UD-braids have been used for further development of braiding technology in EADS laboratories. For this reason, the formulas below are simplified for the use with UD-braids, where only one yarn angle and only a single layer thickness has to be considered. Formulas for biaxial and triaxial braids can be found in Rosenbaum [1], for example.
5.4.1
Braiding angle and coverage rate
The coverage rate depends on four determining factors: the mandrel circumference, the braiding angle, the number of braiding yarns and the width of the yarns after lay-up. Assuming a coverage rate of 100%, the number of yarns for the machine setup can be calculated like this:
N = (2pRM cos g)/wY
where RM = radius of mandrel, g = braiding angle, and wY = yarn lay-up width. Twist-free carbon rovings are the standard material used to produce highperformance composites. Most manufacturers deliver carbon rovings optimized for textile processes. These rovings also usually give the best results for braiding. The lay-up width can be easily reduced to produce a higher layer thickness. On braiding machines, where effective spreading devices cannot be used, the maximum width depends on the titer (linear density) of the yarn and on the type of sizing. Because the lay-up width is also influenced by the shape of the mandrel, experimental trials in the workshop are still the best option to find out the right roving width for the calculation of the braid. On mandrels with a changing circumference, the braid must be matched to the maximum circumference. If the braiding angle remains constant, the rovings are compressed in smaller mandrel areas and the layer thickness and areal weight increase. With a given fiber angle, the mandrel size is limited by the maximum number of bobbins the machine can carry. On the other hand, the machine setup can be adapted to smaller mandrels by leaving some bobbin positions empty or by choosing rovings of a lower titer for the complete setup or on just some of the bobbins. If possible, empty bobbins or those with different yarns should be distributed homogeneously on the machine.
5.4.2
Areal weight and layer thickness
The calculation of the areal weight of the braid is the second basic step in the preparation of a machine setup. Assuming a UD-braid, a fiber volume fraction of 60%, a coverage of 100% and HT fibers, layer areal weights in the
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 135
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
136
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
range of 280 g/m2, corresponding to a layer thickness of about 0.25 mm, can be regarded as standard. A formula for the calculation of areal weight is:
mA = (Nf/1000cos (g))/2pRM
where N = number of yarns, f = yarn fineness in tex, g = braiding angle, and RM = radius of mandrel. Lower areal weights (from 230 to 200 g/m2 or lower) will need further processing. The braid is first produced with gaps between the yarns (coverage rate < 100%). The rovings must then be spread on the mandrel, for example with the help of a laminating roller. Online spreading mechanisms on the bobbin outlet and on or after the braiding ring are under development.
5.5
Characteristics and properties of braided textiles
While there is a huge number of books on the manufacturing of braided ribbons and strands for fashion and household goods, they are of very little help in producing technical textiles for high-performance fiber reinforcements.
5.5.1
Textile variations on circular braiders
With the exception of 3D braiding, all commonly known preforming techniques are based on circular braids. Biaxial braids A biaxial braid is the standard textile on a circular braider. The kind of weave (Fig. 5.23) differs depending on the position of the bobbins on the horn gears. No practical difference can be recognized between the two machine setups, neither in lay-up behavior nor in material properties. Both textiles show a wavy surface texture (Fig. 5.24) in combination with the typical fiber undulation known in woven fabrics. The layer thickness is twice the yarn height on the crossing points and effectively zero on the meeting point of four intertwining yarns. As a result, biaxial braids have some significant disadvantages for high-performance applications: ∑ higher preform compressibility in the thickness direction ∑ lower stiffness and strength in tension and compression ∑ inhomogeneous fiber content and risk of resin accumulations ∑ difficulty in reaching fiber volume fractions higher than 50%. Nevertheless some applications may benefit from other features deriving from the rough structure of the textile. First, there is a better interlock between
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 136
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
(a)
137
(b)
5.23 Different weave types of biaxial braids: (a) standard setup leads to a 2 over 1 twill weave; (b) tandem setup leads to a 2 over 2 plain weave.
5.24 Typical surface quality of a biaxial braid.
the layers, leading to slightly higher interlaminar shear strength. Second, the gaps between the yarns and layers provide resin channels which allow faster infiltration or the use of resin systems with higher viscosity. The inherent symmetry of each biaxial braiding layer is a further advantage, especially for the production of flat preforms. After covering the mandrel with a series of braided layers, the mandrel can be removed and the preform flattened. The resulting layer sequence is always symmetrical.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 137
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
138
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Triaxial braids Most circular braiders are equipped with feeding units for ‘standing ends’ through the hollow axles of the horn gears. These yarns are oriented along the axis of the preform, evenly distributed around the mandrel. Being fixed in position in the middle of the braided layer, they offer a cost-effective way to add some additional stiffness in a longitudinal direction. Triaxial braids also offer the highest productivity in terms of lay-up rate. However, triaxial braids have some disadvantages. Problems of fiber undulation, preform compressibility, resin content and distribution are even worse than in biaxial braids. In addition: ∑ ∑
The ‘standing end’ yarns are not completely straight. The total number of the standing ends is limited to the number of horn gears. ∑ The standing ends cause additional fiber undulation and waviness in the textile. Figure 5.25 shows the typical surface quality of a triaxial braid. The low number of standing ends and the undulation of each fiber reduce their contribution to increased stiffness and strength. The total length of the ‘straight yarns’ is about 5–15% longer than the preform, as a series of laboratory tests has shown.
5.25 Typical surface quality of a triaxial braid.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 138
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
139
UD-braids UD-braiding has been developed to overcome the drawbacks of bi- and triaxial braids deriving from fiber crimp. By replacing the carbon rovings on one set of bobbins (running clockwise or counterclockwise) with a very thin and pliant yarn, the residual undulation in the rovings can be reduced to a minimum. This is because the undulation is completely taken up by these so-called ‘support yarns’. Figures 5.26 and 5.27 show the principle and the effect of UD-braiding. Such a UD-braided layer more resembles a unidirectional fiber tape or a layer of a non-crimp fabric than a conventional braided layer. Various comparisons of material properties confirm this impression (see Fig. 5.28). The selection of the support yarns depends on the application and especially on the applied resin system. Thermoplastic yarns with a low melting point, for example, can be used to stabilize the preform for later handling and post-processing after a short heat treatment to glue the layers together. The support yarn can also carry special agents for resin modification or it could completely dissolve in the resin. Although not very robust, the support yarns (and that is the reason for their name) hold the rovings in position during the braiding process. This allows higher flexibility for fiber lay-up compared to winding. Support yarns have some drawbacks: ∑
Only one single + or – layer is produced in one machine path, with the complementary layer formed when the mandrel is pulled backward. ∑ When the mandrel is removed and the preform flattened, the layer stacking is no longer symmetrical. ∑ Yarns fed as standing ends cannot be used.
Auxiliary yarn Reinforcement fiber Braiding ring Mandrel
5.26 Principle of UD-braiding.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 139
9/6/11 4:44:18 PM
140
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
Conventional braid
UD braid
5.27 Effect of UD-braiding. COM strength
800
COM modulus
80 70
600
60
500
50
400
40
300
30
200
20
100
10
Compression strength (GPa)
Compression strength (MPa)
700
0
0
NC-braid
Conventional braid
NCF
5.28 Comparison of compression properties (NCF, UD-braid, conventional braid).
As a result, the improvements in material quality are offset by a reduction in productivity of about 50%. Nevertheless UD-braiding is a serious candidate for weight-critical structural applications in aerospace engineering.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 140
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
5.5.2
141
Textile variants on 3D braiders
The possible fiber architectures of 3D braids are in principle unlimited, which means there are many possible ‘textile variants’. As mentioned in Section 5.3.3, the production of a complex three-dimensional preform depends very much on factors such as the distance of the braiding point from the machine bed, the friction behavior of the yarns, yarn tension (e.g. for different bobbin positions on the machine bed) and, of course, the braiding program itself. Whereas the production process on a circular braider can still be optimized by experiments in the workshop, this is not possible for a 3D braided preform. For this reason the simulation of the 3D braiding process was developed in parallel with the development of the technology (see Fig. 5.29). Early versions of the software do not allow the simulation of mandrel overbraiding. The interfaces of the various programs are now user-friendly enough to consider using them for the simulation of circular braids. Indeed, current simulation development has focused more on conventional braiding technologies because the number of applications is many times more than for 3D braids.
5.5.3
Auxiliary technologies
Because braiding, especially UD-braiding, is limited to the production of layers with + or – orientation, it has to be combined with technologies for the other yarn orientations and for local thickness variations. Winding of 90° layers Winding devices (Fig. 5.30) similar to those used in the cable industry are used to produce a yarn orientation of nearly 90°. A complete orientation of 90° is impossible due to the spiral nature of the lay-up. With common carbon rovings, a winder can typically carry two bobbins without disturbing the layer orientation.
5.29 Simulation of a 3D braided H-profile.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 141
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
142
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.30 Winding device.
5.31 Problem of slopes with wound 90° layers.
Problems with wound layers can be observed when the mandrel shape changes. Slopes are difficult to handle, because the fiber tends to slip down (Fig. 5.31). A more serious problem is fiber undulation which is caused when the stair-like winding pattern is corrugated by the next braiding layer. This problem can only be solved with a higher number of smaller rovings, but this drives up the price of the material significantly.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 142
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
143
Feeding devices for 0° fibers As described above, the standing ends of triaxial braids do not work properly for high-quality preforms. Feeding devices for 0° fiber tapes (see Fig. 5.32) can be a suitable replacement as long as the tape is of constant width and is applied on a flat surface without being bent in a lateral direction. Such feeders can be located directly in front of the braiding machine. In this configuration, the tape does not need additional fixation because it is clamped by the braiding yarns. There is also no need for an active movement of the tape. Pick and place units for local reinforcements Structural elements like beams or struts often need local increases in wall thickness for load-bearing points. The braiding process itself is not able to deal with these small local increases in thickness. They often do not even cover the whole circumference of the mandrel. For an optimized CFRP design, they should be interleaved into the layer stacking of the preform. The application of pre-manufactured patches (Fig. 5.33) using a thermoplastic binder provides a solution. Industrial robots equipped with suitable end-effectors (e.g. heated stamps with a vacuum system) may be considered as a universal device for the handling of these patches. It is relatively simple to achieve a synchronized continuous movement of stamp and mandrel during binder activation.
5.32 Tape feeder for 0° fibers.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 143
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
144
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.33 Local fiber patch on a beam preform.
Displacers One problem with braids is that they are not able to run smoothly around holes or inserts, because there is no force to close the fibers around the hole. Instead fibres congregate around holes, producing very uneven fiber distribution and misalignment of the fibers, which reduces the strength of the component. The use of displacers (Figs 5.34 and 5.35) does not provide a sufficient solution to this problem.
5.5.4
Hybrid braids
A braiding machine can be equipped with a combination of different fibers at the same time. Although a mix of carbon rovings and a low-performance fiber like glass is not particularly useful in improving performance, a mix of carbon and aramid fibers might be useful in crash scenarios where the tough aramid can prevent the part from total disintegration.
5.6
Mandrel technologies
Preform complexity is often limited by the problem of demolding. The design and the material of the mandrel can be even more challenging than the design of the part itself, especially when a high degree of automation has to be achieved.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 144
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
Braided reinforcements for composites
145
5.34 Displacers for small and big openings.
5.35 Part manufactured with the aid of displacers for in situ integration of inserts.
© Woodhead Publishing Limited, 2011
CompRein-Boisse-05.indd 145
9/6/11 4:44:19 PM
146
Composite reinforcements for optimum performance
5.6.1
Mandrel materials
There is a wide range of suitable mandrel materials. The selection depends on three main questions: ∑
Is the mechanical performance of the mandrel material sufficient to bear the load during the braiding operation? ∑ Is the material able to withstand the thermal loads of the following processes (preforming, curing)? ∑ How can the demolding be achieved?
5.6.2
Persistent mandrels
It is accepta