Springer New York Berlin Heidelberg Barcelona Budapest Hong Kong London Milan Paris Tokyo
Carlos A. Berenstein
Roger Gay
Complex Analysis and Special Topics in Harmonic Analysis With 29 Illustrations
,
Springer
Carlos A. Berenstein Mathematics Department and Institute for Systems Research University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742 USA
Roger Gay Centre de Recherche en Mathematiques Universite de Bordeaux I 351, Cours de la Liberation 33504 Talence (cedex) France
Mathematics Subject Classification (1991): 02.30.15, 02.30.25
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Berenstein, Carlos A. Complex analysis and special topics in harmonic analysis / Carlos A. Berenstein and Roger Gay. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-387-94411-7 1. Functions of complex variables. 2. Harmonic analysis. 1. Gay, R. (Roger), 1934. II. Title. QA331.7.B462 1995 515'.9--dc20 94-41894 Printed on acid-free paper.
:h; 1995 Springer-Verlag New York, Inc. All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Springer-Verlag New York, Inc., 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010, USA). except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use of general descriptive names, trade names, trademarks, etc., in this publication, even If the former are not especially identified, is not to be taken as a sign that such names, as understood by the Trade Marks and Merchandise Marks Act, may accordingly be used freely by anyone. Production coordinated by Brian Howe and managed by Francine McNeill; manufacturing supervised by Jeff Taub. Typeset by Laser Words, Madras, India. Printed and bound by R.R. Donnelley and Sons, Harrisonburg, VA. Printed in the United States of America. 9 8 7 654 321
ISBN 0-387-94411-7 Springer-Verlag New York Berlin Heidelberg
To our dear friends, Mischa Cotlar and Jean-Henri Davancens
Yaqui me despido yo Que he relatao a mi modo, Males que conocen todos Pero que naides conto. Martin Fierro
Jose Hernandez En la desierta sala el silencioso Libro viaja en el tiempo. Las auroras Quedan atras y las nocturnas horas Y mi vida, este suefio presuroso. Ariosto y los Arabes Jorge Luis Borges
Preface
The present volume is a companion to our Complex Analysis: An Introduction [BG], published in the Graduate Texts in Mathematics. In the previous volume our main objective was to present the theory of functions of one complex variable in a way that made clear to the student that one and several complex variables are not dissimilar subjects, as it is quite often assumed. This was accomplished by emphasizing the role that the inhomogeneous Cauchy-Riemann equation plays in modern complex analysis. In reality, in several complex variables one needs to solve the Cauchy-Riemann equation with restrictions on the growth of the solutions. As it turns out, the corresponding result in one variable is not too hard to prove and it allows us to consider in Chapter 2 interpolation problems and ideal theory in algebras of entire functions with growth conditions, which is one of the two main themes of this book. The other theme is that of periodicity and of functions that are close to being periodic, namely, mean-periodic. The link between these two themes is provided by classical integral transforms, like those of Fourier, Laplace, Mellin, and also by the less known but very useful G transform, which we study in Chapter 4. In [BG, Section 3.6] we introduced the student to the concept of boundary value of a holomorphic function in the sense of distributions. In Chapter 1 we return to this subject, first from a more classical point of view, where we give a short introduction to the theory of Hardy spaces H P in the unit disk (including the Corona Theorem), and then we go to the other extreme and discuss a very broad definition of boundary value of a holomorphic function, hyperfunctions. An interesting link between the two is a beautiful theorem of Helgason describing all the eigenfunctions of the Laplace-Beltrami operator in the unit disk, which is proved in the last section of the first chapter. Elsewhere the reader will find functional equations involving analytic continuation and boundary values of holomorphic functions related to the previously mentioned questions about periodicity. One of the oldest and most important class of convolution equations is the difference-differential equations. Indeed, it was Euler who, after having proved that every solution of a linear homogeneous ordinary differential
V111
Preface
equation with constant coefficients is basically a linear combination of exponentials, attempted to prove the same result for difference-differential equations. These equations are related to ideals generated by exponential polynomials; hence it becomes very important to study the sets of zeros of exponential polynomials. We provide a fairly comprehensive study of this subject in Chapter 3. The questions mentioned in this chapter are of interest both in analysis and in number theory. The next two chapters deal with some other subjects related to complex analysis and transcendental number theory. The unifying concept is that of the G transform introduced therein. Finally, Chapter 6 applies the previously developed theory to prove the tundamental theorem of L. Schwartz that any solution of a homogeneous convolution equation in the real line, that is, any mean-periodic function, has an expansion in terms of exponential solutions of the same equation. This is applied to several questions of harmonic analysis, like how to recover a continuous function from its averages over intervals of different lengths. This type of question has wide applications in engineering. This chapter can also be considered as an introduction to the treatise of Ehrenpreis, Fourier Analysis in Several Complex Variables, as well as the second volume of Hormander's The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators. The book is organized on the same principle as [BG]; that is, while we present a coherent picture of the whole subject, most chapters and even sections are fairly independent, allowing the teacher or student to choose and pick which subjects to consider. For instance, there is nothing wrong with just starting in the last chapter! We have also strived to develop all the material ab initio, except for a basic knowledge of complex variables and elementary real variables, as can be found, for example, in [BG, Chapters 2-3] or [Rudin]. For that purpose, in Section 1.4 we have provided a list of all the theorems from functional analysis that are used in the text. Many of the topics covered appear in book form for the first time, giving the reader an overview of current research and open problems. Moreover, some of the results presented correspond to questions that remain wide open in the case of harmonic and complex analysis in several variables, both in the Euclidean setting as well as in the setting of Lie groups and symmetric spaces, hopefully motivating the reader to study them. As the reader has already surmized, this volume reflects a significant portion of the authors' own research and interests. We feel it is our duty here to acknowledge our debt of gratitude to those who introduced us to this beautiful mathematics, especially Vazgain Avanissian, Leon Ehrenpreis, Jean-Pierre Ramis, and B. Alan Taylor. Finally, we would like to thank the National Science Foundation for its generous support, Ms. Stephanie Smith for her excellent typing of this manuscript under difficult conditions, and also to Thierry Pelle and Yvette Gay for their generous help with the proofreading. College Park, Maryland Talence, France
Carlos A. Berenstein Roger Gay
Contents
Preface
vii
CHAPTER 1
Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals 1.1. 1.2. 1.3. 1.4. 1.5. 1.6.
The Hardy Spaces in the Disk Hyperfunctions Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis Convolution of Analytic Functionals Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
1 2 35 51 77 85 94
CHAPTER 2
Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
109
2.1. 2.2. 2.3. 2.4. 2.5.
109
The Algebras Ap Interpolation with Growth Conditions Ideal Theory in Ap Dense Ideals in AiQ) Local Ideals and Conductor Ideals in Ap 2.6. The Algebra Ap of Entire Functions of Order at Most p
118 136 160 166 170
CHAPTER 3
Exponential Polynomials 3.1. The Ring of Exponential Polynomials 3.2. Distributions of Zeros of an Exponential Polynomial
198 198 217
CHAPTER 4
Integral Valued Entire Functions 4.1. The G-Transform 4.2. Integral Valued Entire Functions
260 260 278
ix
comems
x CHAPTER 5
Summation Methods
299
5.1. 5.2. 5.3. 5.4.
299 316 326 333
Borel and Mittag-LetHer Summation Methods The Lindelof Indicator Function The Fourier-Borel Transform of Order p of Analytic Functionals Analytic Functionals with Noncompact Carrier
CHAPTER 6
Harmonic Analysis 6.1. Convolution Equations in IR 6.2. Convolution Equations in C 6.3. The Equation J(z + 1) - J(z) = g(z) 6.4. Differential Operators of Infinite Order 6.5. Deconvolution
353 354 3115 405 419 458
References
471
Notation
479
Index
481
CHAPTER 1
Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
The Schwarz Reflection Principle leads naturally to the consideration of boundary values of holomorphic functions. Those boundary values can exist pointwise, almost everywhere, or in some generalized sense, for instance, in the sense of distributions, as in the Edge-of-the-Wedge Theorem (see [BG, Theorem 3.6.23], [Beur]). Let us make these concepts more precise. First, assume that 1 is a function holomorphic in a rectangle Q, Q = {z E C: a < Rez < b, 0 < Imz < c}. We say that 1 is of slow growth if for every 8 > 0 there are constants A > 0, N 2: 0 such that
II(z)1 ::; AI Imzl- N , whenever a + 8 ::; Re z ::; b - 8, 0 < 1m z ::; c - 8. The function 1 has a boundary value I(x + iO) in the sense of distributions if for every I{J E ego (]a, bD the limit lim
£-+0+
f
I(x
+ i£)I{J(x)dx
exists. This limit is denoted (f(x + iO), l{J(x)}, and I(x + iO) E V'(]a, b[), the Schwartz space of distributions in the interval ]a, b[. From [BG, Proposition 3.6.12] we have that 1 has a boundary value in the sense of distributions if and only if 1 is of slow growth. Moreover, 1 = 0 if and only if its boundary value I(x + iO) = 0 as a distribution. Furthermore, we have also shown in [BG, Theorem 3.6.19] that every distribution T E V'(]a, b[) can be obtained as T = I(x
+ iO) -
I(x - iO),
where f is a function holomorphic in the domain Q = ]a, b[ + ilR* and of slow growth in Q. (The meaning of f(x - iO) and of slow growth in the lower halfplane being entirely similar to the previously defined for the upper half-plane). If f has a continuous extension F to the semiclosed rectangle Q', Q' = {z E C: a < Re z < b, 0::; 1m z < c}, then the function F(x) coincides with the distribution f(x + iO) on la, b[. In fact, since F is continuous in Q' and I{J is compactly supported in ]a. b[, it is clear that lim
E--+O+
J
f(x
+ i£)I{J(x)dx =
J
F(x)l{J(x) dx.
2
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Moreover, it is clear that if the limit lim I(x
£-+0+
+ i€) =
I(x
+ ;0)
exists not only a.e. on la, bl, but with some kind of uniformity then I(x + iO) is still the boundary value of I in the sense of distributions. One instance of this statement occurs when the functions x 1--+ I (x + ;€) and I (x + ;0) belong to L'([a + 8, b - 8]. dx) and lim £-+0+
l
b- O
I/(x+ie)-/(x+;O)ldx=O.
a+o
This is the spirit that animates the first section of thi:, (;hapter on I I P spaces. The functions in these spaces are holomorphic in the upper half-plane and I(x + ie) E LP(lR, dx) for every e > O. It turns out to be easier to consider the case of holomorphic functions in the unit disk, which is what we do in Section 1. In the second section of this chapter we take an altogether different approach to the problem of existence of boundary values of holomorphic functions. Namely, we introduce a concept so general that every function has a limit! These limits are the hyperfunctions. That such a general concept would lead to interesting mathematics is really amazing, but in fact the school of Mikio Sato, Masaki Kashiwara, and Takahiro Kawai have made it one of the major tools of contemporary analysis. The following sections of the chapter will introduce analytic functionals, i.e., the linear continuous functionals on the space Jf(Q). We shall see that there are close relations between analytic functionals, hyperfunctions, and the H P spaces considered in § l.l.
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk This section is a short introduction to the Hardy spaces ~P(D), HP(D) in the unit disk D = 8(0. I). We refer to the excellent monographs [Dul, [Gal, [Hofj, IKo I 1 for a thorough treatment of this classical subject (see also [Rud2]). We refer also to [Rud2l for the background material in measure theory. and to [BG, Chapter 4] for the properties of harmonic and subharmonic functions we use. We include a proof of the celebrated Corona Theorem of Carleson, which allows us to show the importance of solving the Cauchy-Riemann equation with growth conditions. It is convenient throughout this section to denote by 'Jr the unit circle and da = dB /2n, the normalized measure on 'Jr. Given a function / defined in D and a number r, 0 ~ r < I, we introduce a function Ir defined on 'Jr by /r(e ifi ) := /(re ifi ).
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
3
If I is a hannonic function and 1 ~ P < and therefore the function r t-+
II I, lip
(i
=
00,
the function I/IP is subhannonic
1/,(eillW da) lip
is increasing for 0 ~ r < 1. In fact, 1I/,IIb is the average )..(I/IP, 0, r) of I/IP on the circle aB(O, r), (see [BG, Chapter 4]). The maximum principle implies that the function r
f-+
11/,1100 = max {I I, (e ill ) I: 0 ~ 8 ~ 21l'}
is also increasing. Let ~(D) be the space of hannonic functions in D. For 1 ~ P ~ 00 we consider
~P(D) := {I E ~(D):
IIfll p
:= sup
II/,II p
< oo}.
05'<1
Clearly the spaces ~P(D) are nonned spaces with the nonn II· lip. Note that the same symbol denotes the nonn in U(T, da). The reader can verify directly that these are actually Banach spaces. A proof of this fact will also be a consequence of the later discussion on the boundary values of the functions in ~P(D). We recall from [BG, §4.3] that the Poisson kernel of the unit disk is given by P(re ill , ei'P) = P,(
* l(e i 'P»)(8) =
r
27r
Jo
p,(e _
21l' Let IL be a Radon measure in T, i.e., IL E c' (T), the dual space of the Banach space of continuous functions on T. We can define its Poisson integral by
r P(z, e,lI)dlL(e).
P(IL)(z):= _1
21l' /]['
This defines a function hannonic in D, in fact, hannonic in C\ supp IL. When I de, I E U(T), 1 ~ p ~ 00, this coincides with the definition of the Poisson integral P(!) given in [BG, §4.3.5]. We let p,(f)(e ill ) = P(f)(re ill ) and obtain the following extension of Proposition 4.3.6 from [BG]:
dlL =
1.1.1. Proposition. Let 1 ~ P < U(1I'). Proof. Let e > O. There is g Use p < 00.) Hence
II P,(f)
- flip ~
Since Pr(f) - Pr(g)
E
00 and I
lim,_ J - P,(f) = I in
C(T) such that III - gllp < e. (It is here that we
II Pr(f)
- Pr(g) lip
= P,(
+ II Pr(g) -
gllp
g)(ei'P') and "Prill
IIPr (f) - Pr (g)lI p ~
whence
E U(T), then
II Pr IiI II! -
+ III -
gllp.
= I, we have
gllp ~ e,
2
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Moreover, it is clear that if the limit lim f(x
c-o+
+ ie) =
f(x
+ iO)
exists not only a.e. on ]a, b[, but with some kind of uniformity then f(x + iO) is still the boundary value of f in the sense of distributions. One instance of this statement occurs when the functions x ~ I(x + ie) and f(x + iO) belong to LI([a + 8, b - 8], dx) and lim
l
b- 8
c-O+ a+o
I/(x + ie) - f(x + iO)1 dx
= O.
This is the SpInt that animates the first section of thi!> (;hapter on I I P spaces. The functions in these spaces are holomorphic in the upper half-plane and f(x + ie) E LP(R, dx) for every e > O. It turns out to be easier to consider the case of holomorphic functions in the unit disk, which is what we do in Section 1. In the second section of this chapter we take an altogether different approach to the problem of existence of boundary values of holomorphic functions. Namely, we introduce a concept so general that every function has a limit! These limits are the hyperfunctions. That such a general concept would lead to interesting mathematics is really amazing, but in fact the school of Mikio Sato, Masaki Kashiwara, and Takahiro Kawai have made it one of the major tools of contemporary analysis. The following sections of the chapter will introduce analytic functionals, i.e., the linear continuous functionals on the space Jt'(Q). We shall see that there are close relations between analytic functionals, hyperfunctions, and the HP spaces considered in § 1.1.
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk This section is a short introduction to the Hardy spaces ~P(D), HP(D) in the unit disk D = 8(0, 1). We refer to the excellent monographs [Du], [Gal, [Hof], [Ko 1] for a thorough treatment of this classical subject (see also [Rud2]). We refer also to [Rud2] for the background material in measure theory. and to [BG, Chapter 4] for the properties of harmonic and subharmonic functions we use. We include a proof of the celebrated Corona Theorem of Carleson, which allows us to show the importance of solving the Cauchy-Riemann equation with growth conditions. It is convenient throughout this section to denote by 1I' the unit circle and da = dB /2JT, the normalized measure on 1I'. Given a function I defined in D and a number r, 0 ~ r < I. we introduce a function Ir defined on 1I' by [r(e ifJ ) := [(red!).
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
3
If I is a harmonic function and 1 :':: P < and therefore the function
00,
r~ 11/, lip (ll/,(e =
the function I/IP is subhannonic
i6W da)
lip
is increasing for 0:,:: r < 1. In fact, II/rll~ is the average A(I/IP, 0, r) of I/IP on the circle aB(O, r), (see [BG, Chapter 4]). The maximum principle implies that the function
r ~ IIlrlloo = maxlI/r(e i6 )I: 0:,::
e :':: 2rr}
is also increasing. Let ~(D) be the space of harmonic functions in D. For 1 :':: P :':: 00 we consider
~P(D) := { / E ~(D):
IIfll p := sup II/rllp < 0:9<1
oo}.
Clearly the spaces ~P(D) are nonned spaces with the nonn II· lip. Note that the same symbol denotes the nonn in U(T, da). The reader can verify directly that these are actually Banach spaces. A proof of this fact will also be a consequence of the later discussion on the boundary values of the functions in ~P(D). We recall from [BG, §4.3] that the Poisson kernel of the unit disk is given by P(re iiJ , ei",) = P,(rp - e), with Pr(a) = LnEZ rlnleina. For / E ~(D) n C(D), i.e., / is harmonic in D and continuous in D, we have l(re i6 )
= P(fIT)(re i6 ) = (Pr(rp) * I(ei"'»(e) =
r
27T
Jo
Pr(e _ rp)/(e i",) drp.
2rr
Let IL be a Radon measure in T, i.e., IL E C' (T), the dual space of the Banach space of continuous functions on T. We can define its Poisson integral by
r
P(IL)(z) := _1
P(z, e'6 )dlL«()).
2rr J./f This defines a function hannonic in D, in fact, hannonic in C\ supp IL. When dlL = I de, I E U(T), I :':: p :':: 00, this coincides with the definition of the Poisson integral p(n given in [BG, §4.3.5]. We let Pr (f)(e i6 ) = P(f)(re i6 ) and obtain the following extension of Proposition 4.3.6 from [BG]: 1.1.1. Proposition. Let I ~ P <
00
and I E U(T), then lim, ..... I - PAf) =
I
in
LP(T). Proof. Let e > O. There is g Use p < 00.) Hence
E
C(T) such that III - gllp < e. (It is here that we
IIP,(f) - flip :':: IIPr(f) - P,(g) lip
Since P,(f) - P,(g)
= P,(rp·) * (f -
g)(e i",.) and
IIPr (f) - P,(g)IIp :'::
whence
+ IIP,(g) -
II P, III III -
gllp
+ III -
gllp.
IIP,II1 = I, we have gllp :':: e,
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
4
On the other hand, peg) is the solution of the Dirichlet problem in D with boundary value 1? in 11', hence limr- 1- II Pr (g) - gil 00 O. It follows that
=
lim
r-+ 1-
II PrU) - flip
1.1.2. Proposition. Let 1 < P .::::: U(ll') such that 1 = PU*).
00
and
1E
o
= O. ~P(D).
There is a unique
f*
E
Proof. If 1 E ~P(D) then the family Ur)O
I(z)
E
= _1 27r
r P(z, e
If
i9 )f(rje i9 )d8.
U(ll'), we can take the limit and obtain
= lim
f(rjz)
= _1 27r
)-+00
IfrP(z, e
i9 )j*(e i9 )d8.
If 1 < P < 00 we have that Ir --+ f* in LP(ll') as r --+ 1- by the previous proposition, which proves the uniqueness of f*. Since L 00 (11') ~ LP (11') for any p < 00, this proves also the uniqueness in the case p = 00. 0
=
1 since 1.1.3. Remarks. (1) This proof cannot be adapted to the case p L 1 (11') is not the dual of any separable Banach space. Furthennore, there is a good reason for this. If f = PU*), f* E L 1(11'), then fr --+ f* in L'(ll'), hence pointwise a.e., but the Poisson kernel P(re i9 ) Pr «() is in ~'(D) and Pr --+ 0 a.e. In fact, the Dirac mass .5 at 8 = 0 is the only measure f..L such that P = P(f..L). (From the reader's knowledge up to this moment one can only say that Ir. --+ f* for a sequence rn --+ 1-, but the rest of the reasoning holds anyway.) (2) As we have pointed out during the proof, if 1 < p < 00 and 1 E ~P(D), then Ir = PrU*) --+ f* in U(11'). In the case p = 00, we proved that Ir --+ f* a.e. and in LP(11') for any p < 00.
=
For e i9 E 11' and 0 < .5 .: : : 27r, let us denote by ls(e i9 ) := {e il : It - 81 < .5} the open arc centered at ei9 and of length 28. 1.1.4. Lemma. Let (/j)l~j~M be afinitelamily olopen arcs in 11'. One can find a subfamily (lj,)l~k~N such that: (i) the I j• are pairwise disjoint;
(ii)
if Ij = IBI (~j)' then
U l~j~M
Ij
S;
U l~k~N
hBJt
(~j.);
5
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk and
~ 2 and the indices are such that ~j ~ Dj+l. Let jl 1. If Ij, intersects every Ij we let N 1. If not, let h be the smallest among the j such that Ij, n Ij = 0. Let us assume we have chosen it, ... , jt such that for 1 :::: I :::: k - 1 the arc Ij, does not intersect h+" but it intersects Ij for any jf < j < jf + 1. If Ij, intersects every Ij with j > k we set N k. If not, we let jk+l be the smallest index j > it such that Ij, n Ij 0. Clearly this process stops for some index N :::: M. If j < jN there is a k such that jt :::: j < jk+l and, since OJ :::: ~j, and Ij n Ijk =1= 0, we have Ij S; 138h (~j,). If j ::: jN, then ~j :::: OjN and Ij S; h8jN (~jN) since Ij n IjN =1= 0. This proves (i) and (ii). Finally,
Proof. We can assume that M
=
=
=
a (
U
Ij):::: a (
l~j~M
U
138j ,
l~k~N
(~j,»):::: L
a (h8;,
l~k~N
=
(~j,»)
We are ready now to define the Hardy-Littlewood maximal function of a Radon measure /-L on 1I'.
1.1.5. Definition. The maximal function M(/-L) of a Radon measure /-L on 1I' is the function M(/-L): 1I' ~ [0, +00] given by M( )( i9) _ /-L e -
O!~~lI'
1/-L1(fa(e
if!
»
a(la(ei9»
•
where I/-LI is the positive measure of total variation of /-L.
1.1.6. Remarks. It is clear that (i) M(/-L) = M(I/-LI); and (ii) M(/-L) is a lower semicontinuous (1. s.c.) function.
1.1.7. Proposition. For any Radon measure /-L on 1I' we have thatJor any t > 0 .f!
·9
311/-L1I t
a({e' : M(/-L)(e' ) > t)) :::: - - . where II/-LII = I/-L1 (1I').
Proof. Let K be any compact subset of the open set (e i9 : M(I1-)(e i9 ) > t}. Every point e ili E K is the center of an arc 18 such that 111-1(19) > ta(l9). Choose a
6
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
finite family lj = fIJI' I :::: j :::: M, which covers K. By the previous lemma we can find (h)l:".k:".N such that
a(K) :::: a (
U lj):::: 3 L I:".J:".M
a(/j{)::::
~ L IJ.LI(/j~)
l:".k:".N
l:::;k:".N
~ ~I~I C~N 110) "~II~II Finally, taking the supremum over all the possible compact subsets K, we obtain
o 1.1.8. Proposition. Let J.L be a Radon measure on T, letJ.Ls be its singular part with respect to a, and let E := {e ilJ E T: M(J.L)(e ilJ ) < oo}. Then lJ.Lsl(E) = O. In other words, J.Ls is concentrated on the set {e ilJ : M(J.L)(e ilJ ) = +oo}.
Proof. Let E, := {e ilJ : M(J.L)(e ilJ ) < t}, so that E = U,>o E,. It is enough to show that lJ.Lsl(Et) = 0 for every t > o. Therefore, we only need to prove that if K is any compact subset of Et such that a(K) = 0, then lJ.Lsl(K) = O. Let K be a compact subset of E, with a(K) = 0, and let e > 0 be arbitrary. There is an open subset Q of T such that K £; Q and a(Q) < 8. Let (/jh:".j:".M be a finite covering of K so that for each j, i j S Q and IJ.L I(lj) ::: t a (ij ), and let (ih)l:".k:".N be a collection obtained using Lemma 1.1.4. Then
U
= 3ta (
i jk )::: 3ta (n) ::: 3et.
l:".k:::;N
Hence IJ.LI(K) = 0 and, correspondingly, lJ.Lsl(E) =
o.
o
1.1.9. Proposition. Let f ELI (T) and denote by M (f) the maximal function of the measure J.L = fda. Then a({e ilJ
E
T: M(j)(e ilJ ) > t)) < 311 flll. -
t
o
Proof. It is a corollary of Proposition 1.1.7.
1.1.10. Proposition. Let f lim
~
8-0/)
1. 1,(e,8)
ELI (T),
then
If(ei
a a.e.
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
7
In particular.
Proof. Let 18
= 18(e iIJ ) and define
r
T(f)(e iIJ ) = limsup_lI/(e iIJ ) - l(ei
Let US fix t > O. £ > O. and g then it is clear that
E
Cnl') so that III -
gill
<
£.
Let h = I-g.
(i) T(f) :s T(g) + T(h); (ii) T (g) == O. since g is continuous; and (iii) T(h) :s Ihl + M(h).
Therefore T(f)
~
Ihl + M(h) and hence
t}
F,:= {e i9 : T(f)(e iIJ ) >
E, := {e iIJ : Ih(e i6 )1 >
We have
~} U {e i9 : M(h)(e i9 ) > ~} .
IIh lit
a(E,) < - - t/2
Since T(f)
£
~
311h lit + -t/2
> 0 was arbitrary it follows that a(Ft )
= O. a a.e.
8£
< -. - t
=0
for every t > O. Hence 0
This proves the proposition.
1.1.11. Definition. A value eilJo
E 11'
r
lim _1_ a (/8)
ila
is called a Lebesgue point of
I.
8-+0
such that. for h = h(e iIJO ).
I/(e i9 ) _ l(e ilJo )ld8 = 0
Hence. Proposition 1.1.1 0 states that for a function point of 11' is a Lebesgue point. 1.1.12. Proposition. Let If(e i9 )1 ~ M(f)(e iIJ ).
I
ELI (11') and let ei9 be
I
ELI (11').
almost every
a Lebesgue point
01 I.
then
Proof. We have l(e i9 ) = lim8-+0(l/a(/8» fl! l(eif{J)da(cp). Moreover. for
e > O. there is 8, > 0 such that _ 1
1_
a(l8)
r l(eif{J)dCPI ~ M(f)(ei9 )+£
i"
for all 0 < 8 < 8,. The conclusion is therefore clear.
o
8
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.1.13. Proposition. Let J1.s be a Radon measure on 11', singular with respect to a. Then, the limit ilJ V J.1s (eilJ) ;= I'1m J.1sU.(e» . ~-+O aU.(e di »
exists a a.e. and it is zero a a.e. Proof. We can assume J.1s 2: O. Fix t > 0 and B > O. There is a compact set K and a decomposition J1.s=J.11+J.12, where J1.1=J.1sIK, a(K) =0, and 1IJ.1211 ::: B. Let ilJ 1) J.1s (ilJ) e = I'Imsup J1.s (l~ (e. . 0-+0 a (I. (e,IJ»
»
Outside K we have 1)J.11 the notation. Therefore
= 0 and VJ.1s = VJ.12,
K U (e ilJ ; VJ.1s(e ilJ ) > t}
with the obvious meaning for
= K U (e ilJ ; VJ.12(e ilJ )
> t}
5; K U (e ilJ ; M(J1.2)(e ilJ ) > t}. Since a(K U (e ilJ ; M(J.12)(e ilJ ) > tD ::: 3e/t, and e > 0 is arbitrary, it follows that for every t > 0 the set (eill; V J.1s (e i8 ) > t} is contained in a Borel set of zero a-measure. Therefore, the same holds for (e iB ; VJ.1s(e ilJ ) > O} and we obtain that VJ1.s = 0, a a.e. This implies that the proposition is true. 0 1.1.14. Corollary. Let J1. be a Radon measure on 11' and let J.1 = fda + J.1s be its Lebesgue decomposition in absolutely continuous and singular parts. Then its derivative
exists a a.e. and
1.1.15. Definition. For e iB vertex ei9 is the region
E
11' and ex
> 1 a Stolz region of opening ex and
ra(e i9 ) ;= (z E B; Iz -
eiBI
< ex(l - Izl)}·
To simplify the notation in this section we shall write for ex - lim f(z);= :-+~
lim
:-+~ :er.(~)
~ E ']['
fez).
1.1.16. Proposition. For any ex > I, any Radon measure J.1, and any eilJ E '][' one
has sup
IP(J1.)(z)1 ~ 20aM(J1.)(e ilJ ).
:er.(t· 8 )
Proof. Since M(J1.) = M(iJ1.1) and W(J.1)i ~ P
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
Let ra(l) := ra.
9
Era. and r =
Z
Izi. Consider the value t =
Vo:= RET: 11 For k
E
a(l - r) and
~I < t}.
N*. let Vk
:= RET: 2k - 1t ~ 11 - ~I < 2k t}.
These sets are only interesting when 1 ~ k ~ ko. where 2kO-lt ~ 2 < 2ko t. Since M(JL)(l) = 1. we have
o = -.
JL(h(l» ~ (1(18(1»
]'(
hence
On the other hand. 1 2]'(
.
1 1 - r2 1 < --- 2]'( (1 - r)2 - ]'((1 - r)
-P(z e''I') < -
and -1
2]'(
For k ::: 1.
ei'l'
•
1
a
t 1 ]'(1-r
i
P(z.ef{)dJL~ - - - ~ -
Vo
E Vb
z E fa. we have
11 - ei'l'l ~ 2al e i 'l'
-
zl·
In fact.
11 - zl ::::: a(l-Izl) ~ all- e-i'l'zl. Hence
As a consequence _1 P(z. ei ",) = 1 -:- Izl2 < 4a 2 (l - ~2) < 4a 2 (1 - r) = 100. 2]'( 2]'( le'f{) - zl2 - 2]'( 11 - e'f{) 12 22k - 2t 2 22kt
Finally.
I -2
1·
P(z.e'''')dJL
100 ~ 2kt22k t
]'(Vt
= -100 k• 2
thus P(JL)(z) ::::: a
100
+ L 2k =
17a ::::: 20a.
o
k~1
1.1.17. Proposition. If JL is a positive measure on T and 'DJL(e i9 ) point ei9 E T. then a -
lim P(JL)(z)
z-+e,9
= O.
= 0 at some
10
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Proof. Let
E >
0 and 80 > 0, such that for 0 < 8 < 80,
JL(h(e ili » < w(l8(e iIJ ». Let Il-o = 1l-1 15o (e iIJ ) and let Il-I and Il-I is zero on 15o (e i9 ), hence
= Il- -
JLo. P(Il-I) is harmonic in C\SUPPIl-I
ex - lim P(ll-d(z) = O. :-+e IH
Moreover, M(ll-o)(e i9 ) ::: e. Since
P (Il-o)( z) ::: 20ex M (JLO (e i9 » ::: 20ex E,
sup :Ef.(ei ")
one has
ex -lim sup P(Il-)(Z) = ex - lim sup P(JLo)(Z) ::: 20exE. Given that e > 0 was arbitrary we obtain that the limit of the statement of the proposition vanishes. 0
1.1.18. Proposition. If f ELI (11') then ex - lim p(n(z) = f(e i9 ) :-+(,,9
at every Lebesgue point e ie of f.ln particular, this identity holds a a.e. Proof. Consider the measure Il- = If(ei'P) - [(eie)1 da(qJ). By hypothesis, VIl-(e ie ) O. Moreover
=
By the previous proposition, the limit of P(JL)(z) along the Stolz region r a(e ie ) is zero. Hence,
o
ex - lim p(n(z) = f(e i9 ). :-+e/ 9
1.1.19. Corollary. If Il- is a Radon measure on 11', then ex - : lim P(Il-)(z) = VIl-(eie), __ e,H
a a.e.
Proof. We write Il- = fda + JLs, f ELI (11'), and JLs singular with respect to a. Hence Ill-s I is also singular with respect to a and VI JLs I = 0, a a.e. On the other hand, the fact that IP(ll-s)1 ::: P(lll-si) together with Proposition 1.1.17 imply that a a.e. o ex - : lim P(1l-5)(Z) = 0. __ e,8
1.1.20. Corollary. If f
E ~P(D)for
some p, 1 :::: p ::::
ex - lim fez) = j*(e ie ), z-+e lfJ
00, we
a a.e.
have
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
II
Proof. The function f* defined by Lemma 3.1.2 belongs to LP('Jl') and we know that f = P(/*). Since LP('Jl') £ L'('Jl'), the result follows from Proposi-
tion 1.l.l8.
0
1.1.21. Proposition. The map P: C'('Jl') ~ ~'(D), which to every Radon measure on 'Jl' associates its Poisson integral, is a bijection such that the real valued measures correspond to the real valued harmonic functions in ~'(D) and the nonnegative measures correspond to the nonnegative harmonic functions.
Proof. It is clear that h
Ilhr IIi =
=
P(Jl-) is hannonic in D. Moreover, for 0 < r < 1,
21t Jor 2JrI (r21t Jo Pr (rp -
dO) . 1Jl-1 0) 2lT dlJl-1 (e'rp) = 2lT'
hence h E ~ 1(D). It is obvious that h is real valued if Jl- is real valued and h ::: 0 if Jl- ::: O. Let us show that P is injective. If P(Jl-) = 0, then for every f E C(T) we have
rf
r (_1 r21t Pr(rp - O)f(eirp)drp) dJl-(e ili ) Jo . (ll21t .) drp = O. - 1121r f(e'rp) P,.(rp - B) dJl-(e'li)
dJl- = lim_
Irr:
Irr: 217'
HI
= lim
2Jr
r_1-
0
2Jr
0
Hence Jl- = O. We only need to show that P is surjective. Let h A r (!):=
E ~ 1 (D).
For 0 < r < 1, let
121t h(reirp)f(eirp)drp,
which defines a linear functional on the space C('Jl'). Moreover,
IIArl1 =
sup IAr(/)I:::: 2lTllhr il i
::::
2lTllhll l .
11/1100:"1
It follows that we can find a sequence rn / ' I such that Ar. ~ Jl- E C' (T) weakly. For each n, Z 1--+ h(rnz) is harmonic in Izl < l/rn, hence, for each
zED, we have I
h(rnz) = 2lT
since eirp
1--+
21t .. = Jor P(z, e,rp)h(rne,rp)drp
Ar.
( 2lTI P(z, e'II') . )
,
P(z, eirp ) is in C('Jl'). Therefore h(z)
1 121t . . = n-oc lim h(rnz) = -2 P(z, e'II') dJl-(e 'rp ). 0 1'(
It is also clear that if h is real (resp. positive), Jl- is real (resp. ::: 0).
0
12
Valuc~
I. Boundary
of Holomorphlt: FunctIOns and Analytic FunctlOnah
1.1.22. Corollary. For every h E fJ I (D) there IS a umque Radon measure /1 such that It = P!ii) Gild there IS h' ELI (F) \/Ieh that
= 1t'(e,II).
lIm /t(:)
Ci -
a
a.e.
:-t""
Proof It IS enough to wnte Ii = h' da and apply Corollary 1.1.19.
+ /1,.
/1, singular With respect to da
0
We can now define the spaces HP( D) for I ::: p ::: HP(D)
ex)
by
= fJ"(D) n £(D).
I.e .. the functlOn~ m fJP (D) which are hoI om orphic. One can extend the range of p remarkmg that If h E £(D), then : f-+
liz(: lI".
0< p < x.
and
are subharmonic functions. Therefore we can define. for 0 < r < I.
1'"
Ilh, II p := ( - I 27T Ilh, lin := exp
IMre'
)I!P
0< p <
00.
0
(~ 27T
In(" log+ Ih(r("
which are mcreasing functions of rand mtroduce the following definitions.
1.1.23. Definitions. For 0 < p ::: HP(D) :=
{f
with the usual definition of given by N(D) :=
{f
00
we define the Hardy spaces H p (D) by
11/,11"
E £(D): II fll p := sup
< oo}.
0<1<1
11f, Ilx
and
E £(D): Ilf
11/11-.... 110
The Nevanlinna class N(D)
= sup
11f, 110
IS
< oo} .
0<1<1
It IS clear that the sup can be replaced by hm m the defimtlOns. The space" H P( D). 1 ::: p ::: 00, are also Banach space~ (see Propo~ltlon 1.1.24 below). For I ELI (F). real valued, one can prove the followmg mequalIty that generalizes the inequality that relates the geometnc and arithmetic means. Namely, exp ( - I 27T IS
()
de
::: - I
27T
exp(j ) de
0
called Jensen's inequality [Rud2). For any p > 0 we have exp(p(\og+
if
1'' ' I ) 1'' '
f
E [I'(F). Thl~
1/1»::: max(l.lfl"J::: 1+ Ifl"
shows immediately that HX(D)
for 0 < p <
00.
S
HP(D)
S
N(D)
E LI(]')
1.1. The Hardy
Space~ In
DI~k
the
1.1.24. Proposition. For I ::: p ::: 00, the spaces hI' ( D) and H" (D) are Banach spaces with the norms II fill' = limH I II f, II". 00. we have already ~hown that P: [I' (1I') ~ h" (D) is an IsomorphIsm of normed 5paces and the ~ame I~ true for p = I WIth P: C'(il) ---... hl(D). This show~ the spaces h"(D) are Banach spaces when 1 ::: P::: 00. Finally. the ~pace H"(D) IS clo~ed in h"(D) <;lOce the convergence in h"(D) implIes the UnIform convergence on the compact subsets of D by the Harnack inequalitIes (<;ee [BG. Propo<;IIIon 4.3.9]). 0
Proof. For I < P :::
1.1.25. Proposition. Let I < p :::
'X).
f
For erery
E
H" (D) there
/.1
{* E [I' (il)
slIch that (a)
lim ((:)
0' -
=
t *(e,H).
rr a.e ..
::--1"-
and morem·er. lim, _
I
f, = (* in
< P <
'X).
11/11"=111*11,,.
(b) (c) (d)
If I
[I' elI')
1(:)
I,
= -I
f*(:) --dt;
27[[ . 1(1=1 t; - :
n:1
< I).
f* for some I
The limctlllns cp E LI'(1r). wll/eh are of the lorm I < p :::: 'X). are charaeten:ed hy the conditions
HI'(D),
E
for el'en' n < O.
I;,
Proof. We only need to prove (c) and (d). For l* = lim,_Id& l() ~T f*(c,H )e-,"H -27f
£2T I (re'li )e-,"
= lIm I -
I
I' . ()
= lim - r"
when n < O. ThIS shows that (a) holds for
= 2~
d&
H_
27f
f(O --dt; =0
27f/. lCI=' (;11+1
,-I
P(re 'H , e")
we have
J*. On the other hand, for
L
r!I1le'IlIIl-1I
nEZ.
converges
10
L" (IT'). 1/ p
+ I/q = I.
= L (~ II":()
= -27fI
r
2T
Therefore. If:
= re'li
{*(e")e- 1I1l
dt):11
dt
1 = -. 27f1
27f.lo
1
2"
0
{*(e il )
.
I-e- Il :
1
E D,
j'*(>")
-'>-dt;.
1(1=1 ( - ;
I'
fixed,
14
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
In the second line we have used that we already know that (d) holds for 1*. Since P(I*)(z) = I(z), this proves (c). Moreover, this argument shows that if cP E U(1I') has cn(cp) = 0 for all n < 0, then P(cp)(z) = _1_. ( 21ft JI~I=I
i.e., P(cp)
E .1'f(D)
cp(~) d~, ~- z
o
n ~P(D).
1.1.26. Proposition.
II I
and 0 < r < I, we have
E HOC(D)
1 {21lIogl/(rei9)ldO:::: log!f(O)!:::: -2
1fk
Moreover,
if I ¢
0, then
1* =1= 0, u
~ {21lIogll*(ei9)ld8. L1fk
a.e.
Proof. We can assume that 11/1100:::: 1. Otherwise dividing I by 1111100 will not change the above inequalities. We know that the function r r+ (l/21f) fg1llog I/(re i9 )1 d8 is increasing and that limr-->I-Iog I/(re i9 )1 = log II*(e i9 )1. u a.e. Moreover, log I/(e i9 )1 :::: O. Hence we can apply Fatou's lemma {21lliminf {21lIogl/(rei9)ld8::::
Jo ' . . . 1- Jo
~ 21f
(21l log 1f*(e i9 )ld8.
Jo
This implies the required inequalities. = 0 occurs when The only difficulty in proving that u({e iO : l*(e iO ) = 1(0) = O. Let m be the order of z = 0 as zero of I. The function g(z) = I(z)/zm also belongs to HOO(D), Ig*1 11*1, everywhere and log Ig(O)1 > -00. Therefore 1 log 1f*(ei9 )1 d8 > -00,
On
=
12Jr
21f
which implies
f*(e iO )
=1=
0
0, u a.e. This concludes the proof.
o
The main building blocks offunctions in HP(D) are the Blaschke products.
1.1.27. Proposition. Let (an)n:::1 be a sequence in D\{O) such that L,,::: 1 (I - la,,\) < 00 and kEN. then the Blaschke product B(z) :=
Zk
II lanl an -= z an 1- anz n~l
defines a lunction in HX(D) whose zeros are exactly the an and has a zero at z = 0 01 multiplicity k. Proof. The general term of the series
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
15
satisfies
an -:: z ) 1= (1 -Ianl> I(an + lanl;) I:::: I + I~I (1 -Ianl). II - (~ an I-a"z (1-a nz)a 1-1_1 ll
Hence, the infinite product converges uniformly in every compact subset of D to a function B E JIf(D). Moreover, IB(z)1 :::: I since every factor has absolute value I on 11'. Therefore IIBlloo :::: 1. 0 This result shows that the condition LIl> 1(1 - lalll) < 00, often called Blaschke condition, is sufficient for the existence of a function I E Hoo(D) vanishing exactly at the an. In fact, we shall show below that this condition is necessary even for functions in N(D) to vanish on the sequence (onk:.l without vanishing identically. 1.1.28. Proposition. Let IE N(D), I =1= 0, and let (an)n:::l be the sequence 01 zeros 01 I in D\ {Ol, counted with multiplicity. Then the sequence (an)n:::l satisfies the Blaschke condition -Ianl> < 00.
LO n~l
Proof. We can assume I has infinitely many zeros and also that 1(0) =1= O. Otherwise, the function I(z)/zm is still in the Nevanlinna class and satisfies this additional restriction. Let v (r) be the counting function of the zeros of I in B(0, r). Fix k E N* and choose 0 < r < I such that k < vCr). By Jensen's formula (see [BG, 4.4.29]) we have
1/(0)1
IT
1:,,1:::: If(O)1
IT
l=on=ov(r)
1=0"=01.
I~~'I
Hence,
and, since r can be chosen as close to I as we want, we also have
I:::
IT l=on=ok
lanl:::
1/(0)1
> O.
c
To conclude the proof we need a small modification of a standard property of infinite products (see [BG, Proposition 4.6.12]). 0 1.1.29. Lemma. Let 0 :::: Un < 1lor every n, then Iln> 1 (1 - un) > 0 if and only
if Ln:::l Un
<
00.
-
Proof. It is well known that Ln> 1 U" < 00 implies that the infinite product is positive. To prove the converse, iet Pk = (1 - Ul)'" (1 - ud, then PI ::: P2 ~
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
16
... ~ p = ITn>l(1 - un) > O. As it is very easy to see (see [BG, Proposition 4.6.12]), we have p .::: PA .::: exp( -u 1 - u2 - ... - ud. Therefore Ln> 1Un < 00.
-
0
As a simple example of application of the above proposition we see there can be no bounded holomorphic function in D which is not identically zero and vanishes at all the points (n - I)/n. Indeed, no function f E N(D), f ¢ 0, can vanish at those points since
Let us consider now the behavior of the Blaschke products on T.
1.1.30. Proposition. If B is a Blaschke product and B* its corresponding boundary values on T, we have IB*(e i6 )1 = 1, a a.e. and 1 lim , ..... 1-2rr
127r log IB(re,o)1 . dO = O. 0
Proof. Let B(z)
=
z
k
II -Ian-I -an_- Z
n~
I
an 1 - anz
and
for N ~ I. We have that log IB / BN I is continuous in a neighborhood of T and that it has the value zero on T, therefore
~
I,
{27r log IB(re i6 )1 dO
.:::
By Proposition 1.1.26 we have, for any N 10gIBN(0)1.::: lim r-+I-
Now BN(O)
=
~ 2rr
rrn~N
Jo
lanl-- 1 as N -lim - 1 ' ..... 1-
2rr
1
2 "
00,
~ 2rr
(27r logIB*(re i6 )ldO
Jo
.:::0.
hence
. log IB(re,/I)1 dO = 0
0
and _1 27l'
{27r log(IB*(ei6)1 dO = O.
Jo
The last identity implies that IB*(ei/l)1 = 1, a a.e.
o
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
17
1.1.31. Proposition. Let f E N(D), f corresponding to the zeros of f. Let g besides, it satisfies:
¥= 0, and let B be the Blaschke product
= f / B. Then g has no zeros in
=
(i) g E N(D) and IIgllo Ilfllo; and (ii) iff E HP(D)for some 0 < p ~ 00, then g
HP(D) and Ilgll p
E
D and,
= IIfli p.
Proof. It is clear that If I ~ Igl, hence Ilfllo ~ Ilgllo. Moreover, 1 log+ Igi ~ log+ If I + log+ = log+ Ifl-log+ IBI·
TBI
Hence logllgllo ~ lim - 1 r-.I- 2rr
1
2 "
0
. log+ If(re,9)lde
1 2 "
- lim - 1 r-.I- 2rr
0
. log IB(re,9)1 de = log IIflio.
This inequality proves (i). Assume that f E HP(D) for some p > O. Let
BN(z) = z
k
IT
Ian I an - Z -_ an 1 - CXnZ N l~n.:5
and define gN = flB N. Since IBNI N -+ 00 then Ig N I/' Ig I. Therefore,
IIgrllp
= 1 on 1!' we have
= N-.oo lim IlgN.rllp
~
IlgNli p = IIfll p. When
IIfli p.
o
This implies that (ii) holds.
1.1.32. Proposition. Let f(z) = Ln>o anz n be a function in Jf(D). Then f E H2(D) if and only if Ln>O lan l2 < 00. Moreover, IIfll~ = Ln>o lan l2 • Furthermore, for any Junction g E HP(D), 0 < p < 00, there is a function h E H2(D) without zeros such that g
= Bh 2/
p,
where B is the Blaschke product associated to the zeros of g. Proof. For 0 < r < 1, we have fr(e i9 ) = Ln>o anrnein9, which coincides with the Fourier series expansion of fr. Parseval's Identity yields
= L lanl2r2n.
Ilfrll~
n:::O If f
E
H2(D), then lim IIfrll~ = lim'"' lanl2 r2n = Ilfll~ <
r---Jt-l-
Hence
r~l-
L
n'::O
L-t n~O
lan l2
= IIfll~.
00.
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
18
Conversely, if LII~o la n l2 <
00,
then
"""lan l2r211
lim
r-+I-L
=
n~O
n~O
and the above steps can be reversed. As to the second part, let 1= gj B = have Ihl 2 = IfIP, hence sup Ilhrll~
O~r<1
and g
=
"'la n l2 L
sup II/rll; O~r<1
e"',
cp E JIf(D), and h =
= 11/11; = Ilgll~ <
e(p/2)",.
We
00,
= Bh 2/ p •
o
1.1.33. Proposition. Let
I
E
a -
HI(D), then
lim I(z) = j*(e iO )
z-+e/fJ
exists
a.e. and limr-+ 1-
0
Ir = j*
in L I (1l'). Moreover, lor zED
I(z) = P(j*)(z)
1. f = -2 7ft
IU;) d
JI~I=I ~
-
z
s.
Proof. Since I E ~I(D), we already know the existence of a Radon measure J-L and j* ELI (1l') such that J-L = f* do + J.Ls, J-Ls singular with respect to 0, Ir - J.L in C'(1l'), I = P(J.L) and f*(e iO ) the limit of lover Stolz regions. What 0 and II' - I in is new here is that I, being holomorphic, implies that J.Ls L I (1l'). We can write 1= Bh 2 , h E H 2 (D), Ilhll~ = II/III. Let cP = Rh, then cp E H 2(D), IIcpll2 = Ilh112, and I = cph. Therefore, f* = cp*h*, 0 a.e. and
=
j* - Ir = cp*(h* - hr) + hr(CP* - CPr).
It follows that lim sup 11f* - Irlll ::: Ilcp*ll2lim Ilh* - hrll2 r~
1
r-+ I
+ IIhl121im IIcp* r-+ 1
- CPrl12 =
o.
=
This implies that II' - f* in L I (11') and II f* III II I III. Since L I (1l') can be considered as a closed subspace of C' (1l') and Ir - J.L in C' (1l'), it follows that J.Ls O. Hence 1= PU*) and, also, the Fourier coefficients cnU*) = 0 for n < O. As was shown in Proposition 1.1.25 this implies that the Cauchy integral 0 representation of f in tenns of f* is valid.
=
A Radon measure J.L on 1l' is called analytic if cn(J-L) = J::e- int dJ.L = 0 for all n < O.
1.1.34. Corollary (Theorem of the Brothers F. and M. Riesz). Every analytic measure on 1l' is absolutely continuous with respect to o. Proof. The hypotheses imply that P(J.L) E ~I (D) n Jt'(D). hence J.L = f* do, with f* ELI (1l') given by p'(e iO ) = limr-+ 1 P(J-L)(re i (/), 0 a.e. 0
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
19
We shall now prove some important factorization theorems for functions in HP(D).
1.1.35. Definitions. (i) An inner function f is a function that 11*1 = 1. a a.e. (ii) An outer function is a function in D of the form
= exp
f(z)
with rp 2:
°
(_I ior
21C
E
HOO(D) such
ell +z IOgrp(eil)dt) , ell - z
2iT
measurable and log rp
f
ELI (1I').
Clearly evt:ry Blaschke product is an inner functIOn. Another type of inner function is the following: 1.1.36. Proposition. Let f1.s be a positive Radon measure on 11', singular with respect to a. The function S(z) = exp (_ is an inner function. It
r io
21C
e'l
+ z df1.s(t»)
e" - z
is referred to as a singular inner function.
Proof. We have
log lSI = 2iTP(-f1.s)' Since f1.s 2: 0, it follows that lSI.::: l. Moreover, f1.s singular with respect to a implies aa.e. log IS*I = (log ISI)* = 0,
o
Therefore S is an inner function. The simplest example of a singular inner function is S(z) = exp (_ 1 + z) 1- z
corresponding to f1.s
= 8 = Dirac mass at e = o.
1.1.37. Proposition. The family of inner functions coincides with the products of the form cBS. where c E c. Icl = I. B is a Blaschke product. and S is a singular inner function.
Proof. It is clear that the product of two inner functions is another inner function, hence all products cBS are inner functions. Conversely. given an inner function f, let B be the Blaschke product of its zeros and g = fI B. We have that g has no zeros.llglloc = IIflloc = 1. and Ig*1 = I, aa.e. Therefore, -loglgl is a POsitive harmonic function and has a representation
1
2JT
-log Igl(z) = Re
o
eil + z -.-- dJ-l.(t) ell - z
20
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
for some measure /L ::: O. Hence /L = ('D/L) dO' + /Ls, and 'D/L = -(log Igj)* -log Ig*1 = O. It follows that /L is a positive singular measure. Let
=
log Ig(z)1 = Reh(z) for some h E .1t'(D). Then h(z) = -
211' eil +z 1 - . - - d/Ls(t), o ell - z
eh is a singular inner function and g = ce h for some c E
C, Icl
= 1.
0
1.1.38. Proposition. Let
e +z .) = exp ( -217r 1211' -.--logrp(e'l)dt 0 e'l - z it
I(z)
be an outer lunction. Then:
(i) log III = P(logrp); (ii) a - lim z..... ei8 I/(z)1 = rp(e iIJ ), 0' a.e., in particular, III" = rp; and (iii) IE HP(D), 0 < p =:: 00, if and only if rp E U(lI'). In this case, 1I/IIp Ilrpllp.
=
Proof The statement (i) is evident. Since logrp E Ll(lI') we have that log III E ~l(D), (log III)" = logcp, O'a.e., and 1/1* = rp, O'a.e. The rest of part (ii) is also clear. Note that we do not show that f* exists. Finally, if I E HP(D), 0 < p =:: 00, then f* exists 0' a.e. and 1If*lIp = II/l1p. Hence, rp E LP (11') and IIrpllp = II I lip. On the other hand, if rp E LP (11') for some o < p < 00, then I/(re i8 W
= exp 1
211'
o
P,«(} - t) 10g(rpP(e i'
dt I 1211' »=:: P,«() 27r 27r 0
t)rpP(e il ) dt,
by Jensen's inequality applied to the measure P,«() - t) (dt /27r). Integrating this inequality, one obtains
2~ 10211' II, (e i8 W d(} =:: 2~ 10211' (2~ 10 11' P,(O 2
= _1 f211' rpP(eil) dt
27r 10
t)cpP(e il ) dt) d()
= IIrpll;.
It follows that IE HP(D) and II/l1p ::: IIrplip. From the previous reasoning we have II/l1p = IIrplip' The only case left is that of rp E V"'(lI') and it is evident that f E HOO(D). 0
1.1.39. Proposition. Let f
E
HP(D), 1 ::: P::: 00,
f ofo O. Then:
(i) 10glf*1 E Ll(lI') andloglf(z)l::: P(loglf*l)(z)forz E D.
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
21
(ii) The outer function F(z)
eil + z .) = exp ( - I 12l!' -.--log 1/*(e")1 dt 2rr
is in HP(D). (iii) There is an inner function I (iv) The inequality
e" - z
0
= cBS such that
log 1/(0)1
::s
I 2rr
[2l!'
Jo
f
= IF.
logl/*(e i9 )ldB
becomes an equality if and only if I is a constant. f = cBSF is unique.
(v) The factorization
Proof. Consider first the case IE Hi(D). Let B be the Blaschke product of the zeros of I, g = II B. We know that g E Hi(D), 1/*1 = Ig·l, a a.e., and g has no zeros. Therefore, it is enough to prove the above items when B = 1. Since I has no zeros on D we can assume 1(0) 1. Hence log II I is harmonic and
=
0= log 1/(0)1 = _I 2rr Writing log III _I 2rr
2
log I/(re i9 )1 dB
l!'
for
0 < r < I.
= log+ If I -log- III we obtain
[2l!' log-
Jo
r
Jo
I/(reii:l) Ide =
r 2rr Jo
_1
2
l!'
log+ I/(re i9 )1 dO
::s 11/110 <
00.
By Fatou's lemma the two functions iog- 1/*1 and log+ 1/*1 belong to Li ('ll'), and log 1f*1 E Li('Jl'). This shows that F is well defined, and FE Hi(D). Moreover, IF·I = 1/*1 =1= 0, a a.e., since log 1/*1 E Li('Jl'). If we could prove that If(z)1
::s IF(z)1
for every
zED,
it will follow that cp = II F is an inner function without zeros, and hence that cp is a multiple of a singular inner function. Since log IFI = P(log 1/*1), we need to show that log If I ::s P(log I/*D· For 0 < r < I and zED we have log Ifr(z)1 = P(log+ I/rl)(z) - P(log-Ifrl)(z).
On the other hand, if u, v
E
1R+
Ilog+ u - log+ vi and limHI-
Ir = /*
::s lu -
vi,
in L i (1f). Hence lim P(log+ I/rD = P(iog+ I/*D.
r-+l-
Fatou 's lemma now implies that P(log-I/*D
::s lim inf P(log-Ifri> = r-+l-
P(iog+ 11*1) - log If I·
22
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Hence log III :s P(log 11*1)· Therefore, we have proved that the factorization I = I F holds, with I = cBS, and also the value at z = 0 of the inequality (*) shows that if (iv) becomes an equality, then II (0) I = IF (0) I. Hence II (0) I = 1 which can only occur if I is a constant of absolute value I. If 1< p:s 00 we only need to prove F E HP(D). But, if I E HP(D), then 11*1 E LP(1r) and hence FE HP(D) also. Finally, let us prove the uniqueness of the factorization. Assume I = cBS F = cIBISIFI. Clearly B = B I , since the other factors have no zeros. Moreover,
IF" I = IF; I = 11*1,
0'
a.e.
From Proposition 1.1.38(i) one can conclude that F = ot FI with ot E C, lot I = 1. Since F(O) > 0 and FI (0) > 0, it follows that ot = 1. From the fact that Icl = Icd = I, S(O) > 0, and SI(O) > 0, we obtain that c = CI, hence S = SI. D
1.1.40. Corollary. II I 0'
:s p :s 00, IE HP(D),
and / ¢ 0, then I*(eit)
I- 0,
a.e.
Proof. log 11* I ELI (11').
D
1.1.41. Corollary. II 1 :s p :s 00, /, g E HP(D), and 1* = g" on a set a/positive a-measure, then I = g. One can explicitly recover / E H P(D) flOm the data I*IE, where 0' (E) > 0 (see [Patl, [AC], [AiD. Having finished presenting the fundamental properties of the functions in HP(D), we shall now tum to the consideration of the maximal ideals in the algebra Hoo(D). The space HOC (D) is not only a Banach space, but a commutative Banach algebra with a unit element. In fact, the required extra properties, II/glloo :s II / II 00 I gil 00 and 1 . / = I, are evident. In this section we denote by M the family of all multiplicative functionals cP: H oo (D) ~ C, that is, for /1, 12 E W"'(D), AI, A2 E C, we have cp(AIil
+ A2h) = cp(fI!2)
AICP(fl)
+ A2CP(f2),
= CP(fl)CP(f2).
Obvious examples of elements in M are the evaluation functionals CPI;,
~ E
D,
CPI;(f) := I(~)· It is a very important fact that every element cP E M is automatically continuous. This is the Gelfand-Mazur theorem [Ga]. The proof consists in showing that kercp is a maximal ideal with the property Hoo(D)/ kercp = C, hence kercp is
23
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
closed and I{J is continuous. This argument works in any unitary Banach algebra. We will take the continuity of the elements I{J E M for granted. There are other elements in M besides the I{J~. One way to see this is as follows. For a point e j9 E 11' we define le,B
= {I
E
HOO(D):
lim
:---+-e'(/
I(z) =
o}.
This is a proper closed ideal in H 00 (D), hence there is a maximal ideal M, leiB S; M, and a corresponding I{J E M such that ker I{J = M. It is clear that this I{J =I rp~ for every ~ E D, since, for a given ~ E D, it is easy to find I E HOO(D) such that I(~) =I 0 and I E leiB, e.g., I(z) = z - e j9 • The set .'\'-1 is contained in the closed unit sphere of (H OO (8»', i.e., if rp E A1, then IIrpll = I. Namely, for I E HOO(D) and n E N* we have
Hence 11{J(f) I ::::
IIrplll/nllfll,
which implies Irp(f)1 :5 IIfII for every f E HOO(D). In other words, III{JIl :5 I. On the other hand, rp(l) = 1, which implies IIrpll ~ I. The set M is weakly closed: let 1/1 E M,w (weak-closure of M), then for any f, g E HOO(D) and any e > 0 there is rp E M such that 11/I(g) - rp(g)1 <
11/I(f) -1{J(f)1 < e,
e,
and
11/I(fg) - rp(fg) I <
e,
by the definition of the weak topology in (W'O(B»'. Since rp(fg) = rp(f)rp(g), we obtain 11/I(fg) -1/I(f)1/I(g)1 ::::
e(l + 11111 + IIgll),
which shows that 1/1 is multiplicative. As a consequence, we see that M is a weakly compact subset of (Hoo(D»,. In fact, it is well known that the unit sphere is already weakly compact. The space C(M) of continuous functions on the compact space M (M considered with the weak topology) is also a Banach algebra when we consider it with II . II ox: norm. To every element f E HOO(D) we can associate a function j E C(M), called the Gelfand transform of f. It is given by j(1{J) := rp(f)
for
rp
E
M.
The definition of the weak topology makes it evident that j is continuous on M. Moreover, the map I f-+ j is injective and is an isometry of HOO(D) onto a closed subalgebra of C(M): 0 for every ~ E D. (ii) We have li(l{J) I = IrpU)! :::: IIrpllll/ll"" ::s 11/1100, i.e., IIi",,,, ::s II til"",· On the other hand, I/(~)I = ,j(rp!;) I :::: lIilloo, so that IIhoo = 11/1100' (i) If j
= 0, then
j(rp!;)
= I{Jl;U) = 1(0 =
24
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Let us consider the identity function id(z) = z as an element of HOC(D). Then we have a map rr: M ~ Dgiven by rr(lP) := (idnlP) = rp(id).
It is clear that I(idnlP)I ~ II id 1100 = 1, hence rr(M) ~
D.
Moreover, let
6. := lIP>.: A ED}, then rr(6.) 5; D. Namely. rr(IPA)
= IPA(id) = ideA) = A.
1.1.42. Proposition. The map rr: M ~ Furthermore. rr-'(D)
iJ
is a continuous surjective map.
= 6. and rrl6. is a homeomorphism onto D.
Proof. The continuity of rr is obvious from the definition of the topology on M. It is clear that rr(M) ;2 Jr(!:l) D. Since M is compact, rr(M) is also compact, hence iJ ~ rr(M) ~ D. Therefore rr is surjective. Let A ED and let IP E M be such that rr(rp) = A. If IE HOO(D) vanishes at Z = A, then I(z) = (z - A)g(Z), with g E HOO(D). Hence
=
1P(f)
=lP(id -A)IP(g) = (rr(lP) -
AIP(1»IP(g)
= (rr(lP) -
A)g
= O.
Therefore, ker IP ;2 ker IP>. and, since ker IP and ker IP>. are maximal proper ideals, kerlP = kerlP>., that is, IP = IP>.. This shows that Jr-'(D) = 6.. hence 6. is open in M, and rrl6. is a continuous bijection to D. Moreover, the usual topology of D can also be interpreted as being the weak topology defined by functions in HOO(D). Namely, let Zo E D and 0 < 8 < I - Izol. Then B(zo, 8) = Iz E D: I/zo(z)1 < 8}, where Izo(z) = z - Zo E HOC (D). Since zED corresponds to IPz E 6. we have that B(zo, 8) = rr(11P E 6.: Ilzo(IP)1 < 8}). This shows that rr 16. is a homeomorphism onto D. 0 The set C := M\6. is called the corona (Le., crown). It is mapped onto T. For every ex E T, the set Ma rr-'(Iex}) is called the fiber over ex. Clearly C is compact and Ma is also compact.
=
1.1.43. Proposition. Let ex (An)n~1
E T and I E HOC(D) be such that there is a sequence 01 points in D such that limn""'"" An = ex and the limit
exists. Then there is IP E Ma such that IP(/)
= ~.
Proof. The set 1 = Ig E H'X(D): Iimn-+'X g(An) = O} is a closed proper ideal in HOO(D). Hence there is rp E M such that kerlP ;2 I. The functions id -ex and I - ~ belong to I, hence rr(lP) = ex and 1P(f) = ~. 0
1.1.44. Proposition. Let f E HOO(D) and ex E T. The/unction Ma if and only if f has a continuous extension to D U lex}.
f
is constant on
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
25
Proof. If f has a continuous extension to D U {a}, then there is ~ E C such that limn ..... "" f()..n) = ~ for any sequence (An)n;::1 in D with limit a. We want to show that l(lP) = ~ for every lP E Ma. It is enough to do it when ~ = O. Let h(z) := 4(1 + «Xz). One has Ih(z)1 < I for z E D\{a} and h(a) = I. Hence, (1 - hn) f converges uniformly to f on D, because f is continuous on D U {a} and f(a) = O. For any rp E Ma we have rp(h) = + a1l'(rp» = I. Therefore, rp((1 - hn)f) = 0, whence rp(f) = O. Conversely, let us assume is constant on Ma and ()"n)n;::1 is a sequence in D converging to a. Since I/CAn)1 ~ 1111100, let (f(An,)h;::1 be any convergent subsequence, say toward a value ~. Then there is lP E Ma such that (lP) = ~. Given that is constant on Ma. all these possible limits coincide, hence f extend~ conlinuou~ly to D U {a}. 0
40
I
I
I
1.1.45. Proposition. Let I
E HOC (D), a E 11'. If there is rp E Ma such that l(lP) = 0 one can find a sequence (An)n;::1 in D converging to a, such that limn-oo I()"n) = O.
Proof. Let us argue by contradiction. Assume there is a disk R(a, e) and d > 0 such that If(z)1 ~ d for every z E R(a, 6) n D. We can write f cRSF. The properties of the Blaschke product and the singular inner function S imply that no mass of the singular measure lies in R(a, e) n 11' and that no zeros of R lie in R(a, e) n D. Hence both of these functions are holomorphic in a neighborhood of '][' n R(a, e). We can also assume c = I without any loss of generality. The function log 1f*(eit)1 is bounded on '][' n R(a, e), since d ~ If I ~ 1111100 on R(a, e) n D. We define
=
( Ii
h(z):=exp --2 1l' Then h
E HOO(D)
1I'nB(a,e)
e it + z .) . -.--loglf*(elt)ldt e lt - z
and
f(z)h(z) = R(z)S(z) exp ( - I 21l'
1
2 "
0
eit__ + z k(e't. ) dt ) , _. elt - z
where k E LI(1I') and k == 0 on 11' n R(a, 8). Therefore fh is holomorphic in a neighborhood of '][' n R(a, e) and its absolute value is exactly I in this arc, Therefore, (fhf is constant on Ma and this constant has absolute value I. If lP E Ma we have Irp(h)llrp(f)1 = I. This contradicts the assumption that rp(f) = 0 for some rp E M
a,
0
1.1.46. Corollary. Let I E H""(D) and a E ,][" The set I(Ma) consists of all the limit points of the sequences (f(An»n;::1 lor every sequence (An)n;::I in D which converges to a, i,e" the cluster set 01 f at the point a, A question that remained open for a very long time was the corona problem: Is !:J. dense in M? In other words. does the corona C have empty interior? The
26
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
affirmative answer was first given by L. Carleson in 1962. His original proof was very hard. Since then several simpler proofs based on the idea of Tom Wolff to use the a-operator have appeared. We follow here [FiJ, the reader is referred to [Ni3], especially its appendices, for sharper bounds in the constructions of Theorem 1.1.48 as well as for constructive interpolation procedures. For multiply-connected plane domains one can also consider the corona problem, see [FiJ, [10]. We need first to translate the corona problem into another form.
1.1.47. Proposition. A necessary and sufficient condition for 6. to be dense in
M is the following: for every finite family fl' ... ,fn of functions in HOC(D) satisfying,for some 8 > 0, the condition Ift(z)1
+ ... + Ifn(z)1
::: 8 > 0
(z ED),
there are gl, ... ,gn E HOC(D) such that ftgl
+ ... +
fngn = I.
Proof. Let f/Jo E M\t.. By definition of the weak topology there exist fl,"" fn E HOC (D) and 8> 0 such that f/Jo(ft> = ... = f/Jo(fn) = 0 and {f/JEM; If/JC/j) I <8, I s.j sn}n6.=0.
Therefore, for any
~
E D we have If/J{ (jj) I ::: 8 for some j. As a consequence, n
n
j=1
j=1
L IIP{(jj)1 = L
Ijj(~)1 ::: 0
for every ~ ED. On the other hand, all fj E ker f/Jo, hence I is not in the ideal generated by the jj. In other words, there would be no gj E HOC(D) such that ftgl
+ ... + fngn
= I
if~#M.
Conversely, assume there are ft, ... , fn E HX,(D), 8 > 0, such that IfII + 1 does not belong to the ideal generated by the jj. In this case, this ideal is proper and there is IPo E M such that f/Jo(jj) = 0, j = 1. .... n. The neighborhood {f/J E M: Irp(f,)1 < 8/n, I S. j S. n} of f/Jo is clearly disjoint from 6.. If not, there would be ~ E D with IIP{(jj)1 < o/n, I s. j S. n, i.e.,
... + Ifn I ::: 0 and
Ift(~)1
+ ... +
o
Ifn(OI < n- = 8. n
0
1.1.48. Corona Theorem. One has M=~.
Proof. We shall show that, given fl>"" fn and 1ft!
+ ... + Ifni:::
0 > 0, there exist gj
HX(D) satisfying llfilloc :::: 1 HX(D) such that flgl + ... +
E
E
27
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
Ingn = I and, assuming
°
< 8 ::: I,
It is enough to prove the existence of gj satisfying the estimate (*) when satisfy the additional requirement of being holomorphic in 8(0, p) I for some p > 1. Namely, given the original functions II, ... , In E Hoo(D) with the condition 1/11 + ... + Ifni ::: 8, consider 1,.k(Z) = Idrz), r < 1. They are holomorphic in B(O, I/r) and assume we can find gr.k E HOC (D),
/I, ... , In and IfJ I :::
IIg"klloo::: 129n 2 /8 4 (independent of r!), such that
1"lg,.1
+ ". + I,.ng,.n
= 1.
r,
We can use Montel's theorem to find a sequence -+ I, g,).k -+ gk in Jff(D). Evidently IIgklloo::: 129n 2 /8 4 and Ilgl + ... + Ingn = 1. Let us now consider the auxiliary functions
hj ..=
n
1-,
I ::: j ::: n.
L::lhl2
k=1
These functions are Coo and satisfy 11hl +.,. + Inhn = I in B(O, p). The idea is to modify them to make them holomorphic while preserving the desired identity, Let Wj.k be Coo functions in 8(0, p) satisfying the equations
OWj.k _ h. ah k az - , oz '
I _<
j',
k _< n.
Let gj := hj
+ L (Wj.k - Wk.j)!k.
I:::j:::n.
l::::k::::n One has n
n
L Jjgj j=1
=L
n
Jjh j
+ L I::::j.k::::n
j=1
Jjlk(W,.k - Wk.j) = L Jjh j j=1
= 1,
and, moreover,
ag! = ah j
oz
frz
= ohof
+ ~ (0 wj.k ~ k=1
a:;;~
_
0Wka-!k .j ) . = Z
( 1- Lhdk n ) a +h j az k=1
ah j a=~
~ (h. ah~ _ h ah,) '.
+~ k=1
( Lhdk n )
'a:;;-
k
a= I..
Jk
= 0.
k=1
To conclude the proof we need to find W,.k with appropriate bounds on
II wj ,kllv"'clI')' Let
U
E COC(B(O, p», p > 1. We shall estimate
inf {IIWIIL"'('lI'):
W
E COC(B(O, p»,
~; = u}.
28
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Since every w in this set is of the fonn Wo + IP, IP E .1f(B(O, p», with ow%z u, Wo E COO (B(O, p», we need to estimate
=
J := inf {liwo + IPIIL"'(T): IP E .1f(B(O, p» for some p > I} .
In order to estimate this quantity we use an auxiliary result: the dual space to C(1r)/ A(D) is isometric to the space z Hi(D). Namely, (C(1l')/ A(D»' can be identified to (JL E C' (1l'): en (JL) = IT e- in8 dJL(e i9 ) = 0 for n ~ O}. By the theorem ofF. and M. Riesz, JL = f*da, with / E zHi(D). By the density of Jff(D) in A(D) we have J
= inf{lIwo + IPIILoo(1l"): IP E A(D)} = d(wo, A(D» = IIwoli = sup {2~ I J~ wordel:
/
E zHi(D),
11/111
~ I},
where Wo is the class of wol1l' in C(1r)/ A(D). The last identity is just the HahnBanach theorem. Moreover, by a density argument, it is enough to consider only / E Jff(B(O, p» for some p > I, and 1(0) = O. For such / we can apply Green's formula
( wol d()
iT
=(
tJ.(wof) log
=(
tJ.(wof) log
io
tJ.(wof)
27f(wo/)(0)
Izl
io
We have
J.. dm -
J.. dm . Izl
a ,au = 4 oz (uf) = 4u/ + 4/ a;'
Therefore, in order to obtain the desired bounds on II w j.k II 00, we need to estimate
Iio{ uf'
log
J.. dm + ( I :u log ..!.dm I Izl io Izl oZ
for IE zJff(B(O, p», p > I, and u = h/ohk/oz). We do this in several steps: (i) First we observe that if h E H 2 (D), then { Ih'(z)1 2 10g ..!.dm = ::2 io Izl
(lIhll~ - Ih(0)1 2 ) ~ ::lIhll~. 2
This is easily seen using the Taylor series development of h and integrating. (ii) If f E HOO(D) and g E H 2 (D), then
{ Igf'1 2 \og ..!.dm Izl
io
~ 21T IIgll~lIfII~.
Namely gf' = (gf)' - g' f
and
29
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
From (i) we obtain
1;l dm ~ 2 G'lIg/Il~ + ~1I1II~lIgIiO ~ 21TlIglI~IIIII~.
llgl' I2 10g (iii) If
I
E HI(D),
1(' h
E WXJ(D),
then
r "
1 Jo IIIII21 log~dm ~ 211111I1liIlloollhlloo.
To see this, use Proposition 1.1.32 to write I = glg2, gj E H 2(D), and IIgj II~ = II I III. Apply the inequality of Cauchy-Schwarz and (ii) to obtain the final estimate. (iv) If IE W"'(D) and F E HI (D), then
r IF'f'llog~dm ~ Izl
Jo We factorize F
= glg2, gj E H 2(D), and
,,1 1 IF I I log -dm D Izi
~
21T II FII III 11100'
IIgjll~
= IIFIII
1 1 Ig l, g2/,Ilog -dm D Izl
as done earlier. Then
, ,I log 1 + 1Igigz/ -dm. Izl
D
The first term can be estimated by
r Ig;g2/'llog ~dm ~ ( rig; 12 log ~dm) 1/2 ( r Igd'I21og ~dm) Izl JD Izl Jo Izl
Jo
1/2
~ ~lIgIlI2v'2rrllg211211 11100 = 1T IIFIII 1111100' The same estimate holds for the second term. We can now conclude the proof of the theorem. To simplify the notation we set cp := (2::J=1 Ijj 12)-1, hence hk = cp k We have ahk
= cpl; -
az
cp 2 Ik-
""
~
Ik!;·
l:5k:5n
Therefore
As a consequence,
au az
=
- -2cp 3 Ij/;
" " ~
hi; - cp3 hh
l:5k:5n
" " ~
" 1!/e12 + 3cp4hhl " ~
l:5k:5n
ftl;1 2 ,
l:5k:5n
We return now to the estimation of J, We use that II I III ~ 1 and and apply the inequality (iv) to the integral
11 ul' o
1
I
2rr
log -dm < - 2 Izl - 8
2rr + -n 3
8
21T(n
+ 1)
< ----",..-83 '
-
cp
~ 1/8
30
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Apply the same estimates and inequality (iii) to the integral log ~dm I :::: IJD( I au az Izl These two inequalities show that we can find
Ilwj.kIlLOO('f) ::::
2:
6n.
0
wj.k
satisfying
64n
84'
Replacing the estimates in the formula for gj we obtain IIgjlloo:::: IIhjll oo
L
+
I
128n 2
129n 2
+ IIWk)loo):::: '8 + ~:::: ~.
(lIwj.klloo
1 -sk=sn
o
This concludes the proof of Carleson's Corona Theorem.
It is clear that the Corona Theorem provides the exact conditions under which the ideal 1 generated by fI, ... , In in HOO(D) coincides with the whole algebra. A variation of this question is the following: how can we decide if a function g E W'O(D) belongs to /? (Clearly this is only interesting if 1 is a proper ideal.) We obtain a necessary condition in the same way as it was done in Proposition 1.1.47. If gEl there are hI, ... ,hn E HOO(D) such that g = hI/I
+ ... +hnln,
so that for every sED
Ig(s)1 :::: C
L
Ijj(s)l,
l=:;j:5n
with C = max {lIh j 1100: I :::: j :::: n}. It turns out that this condition is not sufficient for gEl, we can only prove that g E ..[1, the radical of the ideal I. More precisely, g3 E 1 (see [Gam]). A strengthening of this statement is the following theorem of Cegrell [Cell: if there is e > 0 and C > 0 such that
(s
E D)
then gEl. The proof follows the same general lines of Theorem 1.1.48. There are several natural ways of defining the spaces HP(Q), for Q a planar domain [Fi]. Since we are interested in considering boundary values on IR of holomorphic functions in the upper half-plane, the domain to consider is Q = {z E CC: 1m z > OJ. In this case, we would like to define HP(Q) so that for IE HP(Q) the boundary value rex) = I(x + iO) belongs to LP(IR, dx). It turns out that the correct definition is the following. For 0 < p < 00, we say
\. \. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
that
I
E Jf'(Q)
31
belongs to HP(Q) if
(1
00
II/lI p := sup
-00
O
For p
= 00, we say I
I/(x + iy)IP dx
E HOO(Q)
)I/P
< 00.
if
11/1100 = sup I/(z)1 < 00. :eO
The theory of these spaces in the upper half-plane is entirely similar to that of HP(D) (see [Hof]. [Du], [Fi], [Kol]). This would seem entirely obvious using
the Moebius transformation .~
+I
~
- I
({J:~~l-
of D onto Q. In fact, for p i= 00, this map does not provide an isomorphism of HP(Q) onto HP(D), as one would expect that
f
~ ({J*
1= f
0
({J
should do. The reason is that the measures dx on IR and dO on 1I' do not correspond to each other, their exact relation is given by
I
I
1
-dO = - - - d x . 21T 1T I + x 2 The precise correspondence between these spaces is given by ({J* HP(Q)
= (1 -
~}2IP HP(D),
where the right-hand side denotes the space of functions of the form
g
E HP(D}
(~E
D).
Moreover, «((J-I)* HP(D) = (z
+ i)2/p HP(Q).
(See [Hof, pp. 129-130] for a detailed discussion.) As a final remark on the choice of the definition of the H P spaces of the upper half-plane, let us point out that the classical Paley-Wiener theorem (see [PW], [Du]) states that H 2(Q) is isomorphic to the space L2(1- 00,0[, dt) via the Fouriertransform. Namely, if F E L2(] - 00, O[dt), its Fourier transform F, F(z) =
fO
i-x
F(t)e- i : , dt,
is holomorphic in Q, in fact, F E H2(Q). Moreover, every function in H2(Q) is Obtained this way. Denoting also by F the boundary value of F on the real axis one has _1_ 21T
roc F(x)e
i-oo
iX1
dx
= {F(t) 0
for t < Oa.e., for t > Oa.e.,
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
32
and
1 - 2 2 2rr /lFIIz = IIFIIL'
EXERCISES 1.1. We keep the notation D = B(O, 1) and
I. Show that if
I
=e
n=
{z E IC: 1m z > OJ used in this section.
g E Jff(D), then
8,
sup - I O
211"
1 2 "
log I/(re i9 )1 d8 <
00.
0
Use this observation to show that the Nevanlinna condition sup - I O
1 2 "
log+ I/(re i9 )ld8 <
00
0
is strictly stronger than the condition (*) in the proof of Proposition 1.1.39.
2. Show that the function I/(l - z) E HP(D) for any p < 1, and that it does not belong to HI (D). Conclude that HP(D) =1= Hq(D) if q =1= p. 3. Show that if I E Jff(D) and I(D) ~ {w E IC: al < arg z < a2}, ~
0< a2 - al
I
4. Let
211", then
E HP(D),
rp
I
E HP(D) for p < 1I"/(a2 - al)'
E Aut(D).
Is
I
orp
E HP(D)?
*5. Assume I E H I (D) is such that the set of all products of the form pi, p a polynomial, is dense in HI(D). Show that I is an outer function.
6. Let I
E HI(D),
7. (a) Let
IIFrllp, 0 < (b) Let
I,
F,
W
= Ln~oanZn. Show that Iimn~ooan = O. E Jff(D). Assume Iw(z)1 ~ Izl and I = F ow. Show that IIlrilp I(z)
p ~ 00.
I
E Jff(D), Re
I
> 0 and
1(0) = I. Let
I(z) - 1
w(z)
~
= 1(:) + 1
and
F(z)
1+z = --. 1- z
Show that F E HP(D), 0 < p < 1, 1= F ow. Conclude that ("
IIlrll: ~ io U
d8 Ilm/(e i9 W 211" < 00,
0 < r < I.
*(c) For u harmonic we say that u E I)P(D), 0 < p < 1, if sUPO
p < I. (Hint: Use that the boundary values of positive Radon measures on T.)
8. Let
I
E H I (D)
g. Show that
and assume
10r 2
Conclude that
f
E A(D).
"
U
can be written as a difference of twO
r coincides a a.e. with a function of bounded variation
e- in9 dg(8) = 0,
n < O.
1.1. The Hardy Spaces in the Disk
33
9. Let I E HI(D). (a) Show that if II! E HI(D), then I is an outer function. (b) Show that if Re I > 0, then I is an outer function. (c) Show that if I is an inner function, then I + f is an outer function. 10. Verify the following two statements used in the proof of Proposition 1.l.45: (a) Let B be a Blaschke product with zeros (an)n?:1 in D. Denote by A the set of accumulation points of the set {an: n ~ 1), A ~ 11', and f3n = I/a n • Show that B E ;f(C\(A U {f3n: n ~ I)). (b) Let S be a singular inner function defined by a measure /-L, ~ 0 in ']['. Let K = supp /-L,. Show that S E .1f'(C\K). 11. (a) Let I E HOO(D) and 1111100 ~ 1. Show that the Blaschke product, if and only if lim
r-+ 1-
I
= cB, where
Icl = 1 and
B is
1211: log I/(re i9 )ldO = O. 0
*(b) (Frostman's Theorem). Let I be an inner function neither constant nor a finite Blaschke product. Show that the lunctions fez) - a ga(Z) := 1 - al(z)
are inner functions lor any a E D. Moreover, with the exception 01 a E E ~ D, with capacity C(E) = 0, every ga is an infinite Blaschke product (up to a multiplicative constant 01 absolute value 1). (Hint: If C(E) > 0, we can assume E that is a compact subset of D, let v
E
peE) be
the equilibrium measure, and consider u(z)
=
1
log 11
E
-
~z Idv(~).
Z-(
=
Jo
Show it is bounded, continuous near 11', and u Oon 11'. Computelimr-I- 21r u(f(re i9 ))dO to arrive at a contradiction.) (c) If I is as in (b), then C(D\/(D» = O. (d) Show that any function as in (b) is the limit of a sequence of Blaschke products. *12. (i) Let LO!!On!!ON Xnein9.
1/1
E LOO([O, 271']) and let (cn)neZ be its Fourier coefficients. Let p(O) Show that
dO L Cj+kXjXkl = i2~ 1211:(p(0»21/1(0) IO:5.J.k:5.N 0
i
~ 1I1/111oot1Xk1 k=O
Conclude that for any Xk. Yk E C, 0 ~ k ~ N, then
IO!!o~N cj+kxml ~ 1I1/111~ (~Ixd) (~IYd) 1/2
1/2
(USe the polarization of bilinear forms). (ti) Choose 1/1(0) = ie- i9 (7I' - 9) to obtain
IO!!o~N j :J:~ 11 ~ 71' (~IXkI2 y/2 (~IYkI2 y/2
2.
=
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
34
1/1 E LX ([0. 2rr]) be such that its Fourier coefficients HI(D). 1(:) = Ln~oanzn. Show that
(iii) Let
Let
IE
Cn
2: 0 whenever n 2: O.
Lenlatll ~ II 1/111"" IlfIII·
I = gh. g. h Ln>O Yn: n, and use (i).)
(Hint: Factorize
E H 2 (D).
II fill =
IIgll~ = IIh II~, g(z) = Ln>O xnz n, h(z) = -
(lv) (Hardy's Inequality). Let I E HI(D), I(z)
= Ln~oanzn. Show that
"~ lanl - ~ rrll/ili. n~O n + I *13. Recall that if IE A(D). the space of functions continuous in D and holomorphic in D, then (~ E 1[': 1(0 = OJ is a closed set of zero O'-measure. This exercise shows that any closed subset £ of 1I' with 0'(£) = 0 is the set of zeros of a function I in A(D). (i) Show that there is a function u: 1['\£ -+ IR of class C l , u 2: I, U E L I (1I'), and u(z) -+ 00 as z tends to any point in £. (ii) Let 2" eil +z . cp(z) := - I -.--u(e")dt, zED.
2rr
1 0
e" - z
Show that cp E .if(D) and has a continuous extension to D\£. Show that Re cp(z) -+ +00 if Z E D\£ tends to a point in £. Show that Recp(z) 2: I in D\£. (iii) Show that I(z) := IN(z) is holomorphic in D. has a continuous extension to D, vanishing on £, and Re I(z) > 0 on D\£. *14. (i) Let I E Ck(D) n J1f(D), k 2: I. Assume I(z) '" 0 in D. Let £ be the set of zeros of I. Write 1I'\£ as a disjoint union of open intervals of endpoints e ian and eibn , bn - an = In > 0, n 2: I. Let M be a constant such that I/(e i8 ) - l(ei~)1 ~ MIO - cpl. Show that -00 <
1
2n
ibn log[M(6 - an)ld6.
log I/(eiO)1 dO ~ L
o
1I~1
a"
Conclude that Ln>1 In log In > -00. (ii) Let £ be a -closed set in 1I', 0'(£) = 0, 1['\£ is the union of arcs with endpoints eian , eihn , bn - an = In > O. Assume Ln>l/n login> -00. Fix k E N*. Let KEN and consider the function u defined in 1I'\ £ by
u(t) Show that u
= log[(bn -
ELI (T)
t)(t - an)lK.
and that. if K
I(z) := exp
»
t Elan. bnL
n 2: I.
1. the function
(_--.!....
r
2rr 10
2
;r
e"
+ Z U(t)dt)
e" - z
is holomorphic in D, continuous in D. its boundary values are of class C' on 1I'\£, and I vanishes exactly on £. Furthermore. for ei& E 1I'\£. one has l(e i8 ) = e-U(OI. Use this to show that for e'Oo E £ one has lim I()l(:)
= O.
O:s j
~
k.
:_1"80
:eD'E
Hence £ is the set of common zeros in b of f. f' . .... to these last two problems and generalizations.)
pkJ.
(See [Cho!] for references
1.2. Hyperfunctions
35
15. Let (z.)."" be a sequence of distinct points in the upper half-plane all n ~ I. Assume that Imz.
L 1+ Iz 12
- - - <00 n
n::=.l
Show that for m
~
0
i)
zb(z) = ( - z+i
m
n:::)
is a function in H""(Q), Ib(x)1 = I a.e. on 16. Let cp(z) be a Moebius map in ad - be = I. Show that the map
n
Q,
~.
i for
.
Iz; + II z - z"
----Z2 + I z - :n n
(These are the Blaschke products in Q).
cp(z)
= (az + b)/(ez + d),
1
(Tf)(z)
Q, Zn '"
= ez+df(CP(z»
a, b, e, d
E ~,
(z E Q)
is an isomorphism of H2(Q) onto itself such that IITfl12 = IIfII2 (i.e., it is a unitary map). Is there a corresponding statement for HP(Q), 0 < p < oo? What about H2(D)? 17. Let f E HP(Q) for some' p, 0 < p ~ 00. Assume there is a rational function g such that f(x + iO) g(x - iO) a.e. on some open nonempty segment of the real axis. What can you say about the location and multiplicity of the poles of g? What can you say about the number of zeros of g? Does the answer depend on p? What happens when Q is replaced by D?
=
18. (a) Let G E Jf(D) n L' (D, dm), g E C(,][,), be related to G by the fact that for every fJ E COO(IC) one has
{Ga~dz/\dz=l
JD
az
aD
gfJdz.
Show that G is continuous in iJ and GI'][' = g. (Hint: Consider the restriction G, of G to the circles aD" D, = Iz: Izl ~ r). 0 < r < I, and prove the measures G,d9 converge weakly to the measure gd9. Use the Banach-Steinhaus theorem to conclude that G E H'(D). Finally, show that this implies G E C(iJ) and Gil = g. (Note, an alternative way is to compute the Fourier series of g and apply the theorems of this section.) (b) Show that the hypothesis G E Jf(D) is not necessary. Obtain the same conclusion.
1.2. Hyperfunctions Let n be an open nonernpty subset of the real line R We are going to introduce a complex vector space B(n) containing as a subspace the space V' (n) of distributions in n. This space B(n) will be called the space of hyperfunctions in n. As we have shown in [BO, §3.61, every distribution in n can be obtained as the boundary values of a pair of functions holomorphic above and below the real axis, respectively. These holomorphic functions have to satisfy precise growth conditions. What we are going to do is to generalize the concept of boundary values to any pair of holornorphic functions, without any growth conditions whatsoever. In a certain sense, the space B(n) is the largest conceivable space
36
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
where the usual operations of the differential calculus make sense. Some references for this section and further developments of the theory of hyperfunctions are [Schap], [Mor 3], [Kan]. In the rest of this section, Q will always denote a nonempty open subset of JR, JR is identified as usual to the real axis of C. We denote C# := C\JR and
Q=C#UQ. Q is an open subset of C such that Q = Q n JR. Let us denote by U(Q) the family of all open sets V in C such that V n IR = Q. Note that Q is necessarily closed in every V E U(Q). Finally, if VI. V2 are open subsets of C such that VI £ V2, we denote by R V!.v2 the restriction map Je(V2) ~ Je(Vd. 1.2.1. Definition. The complex vector space defined as the quotient B(Q) := Je(C#)/ RC',fl(Je(Q))
is called the space of hyperfunctions in Q. A hyperfunction in Q is an element of B(Q). 1.2.2. Proposition. For every V E U(Q), the natural map iv
B(Q) ~Je(V\Q)/ RV\n.v(Je(V)),
which assigns to the class T E B(Q) of the element f E Je(C#), the class TI of fl(v n C#) in the quotient space Je(V\Q)/ Rv\n.v(Je(V)), is an isomorphism of complex spaces. Proof. The map i v is well defined since it is induced by the restriction map Rvnc',co, which is compatible with the equivalence relations. In fact, if fl' hE Je(C#) and h - h = gIC#, with g E Je(Q), then (fdV n C#) - (f21V n C#) = (glV)1V n C# and glV E Je(V). It is clear that iv is a linear map. The map iv is injective: Let T E B(Q) be the class of f E Je(C#) and satisfy i v (T) = O. This means that f IV n C# admits an analytic continuation to the whole of V, i.e., across Q. It is clear that this implies the f admits an analytic continuation to Q, hence T = O. The map iv is surjective. Let g E Je(V\Q). Since V\Q = C II n V, by the Mittag-Leffler theorem (see [BG, § 1.2.2]), there are functions f E Je(C#) and h E Je (V) such that
g = (fICII n V) - (hle# n V). This implies that the class of flC# n V in Je(V\Q)/ Rv\n, v(Je(V» is the same 0 as the class of g. By the preceding proposition for any V E U(Q) and any g E Je(V\Q), the image under l of the class of gin Je(V\Q)/ Rnn.v(Je(V» is a hyperfunction in Q called the hyperfunction associated to g. Moreover, every hyperfunction in Q is associated to a unique g E Je(V\Q). We say g represents this hyperfunction.
iv
1.2. Hyperfunctions
37
1.2.3. Proposition. For VI, V2 E U(Q), the hyperfunctions associated to and g2 E Jt"(V2 \Q) coincide if and only if the function (gil VI n V2 n C#) - (g21 VI n V2 n C#) has an analytic continuation across Q. In particular, if T E B(Q) is the class of f E Jt"(C#) and V E U(Q), then g E Jt"(V\Q) represents T if and only if there is h E Jt"(V) such that flY n C# = (gjV n C#) + (hjV n c#).
gl E Jt"(VI \Q)
Proof. By Proposition 1.2.2, there are that
iI, 12 E Jt"(C#)
and h j
E
Jt"(Vj
)
such
and
12 =
g2
+ h2
The condition is necessary. If there is we obtain
on V7\Q.
h E Jt"(Q)
such that
fl
= 12 + h on C#,
and the function h2 - hi + Ii E Jt"(VI n V2). The condition is sufficient. If (fl - h) - (h I - h 2 ) admits an analytic continuation to VI n V2 , then fl - 12 also admits an analytic continuation to VI n V2 • hence to Q. D
1.2.4. Examples. (I) Let C+ = {z E C: Imz > OJ, C- = {z E C: Imz < OJ, we denote by I~ and lil the hyperfunctions in Q associated, respectively. to the characteristic functions Xc+ and Xc. One has I~ = -lil. In fact, Xc+ + Xc- = Xc" represents I~ plus In. but, by Proposition 1.2.3, the class of Xc" is zero. (2) If T E B(Q) is represented by f E Jt"(V\Q), we denote by I the hyper{z: Z E V}. function in Q which is associated to z t-+ - fez) E Jt"(V\Q), V We say that I is the conjugate of T. It is clear that T = T, and that for any scalars AI, A2 and hyperfunctions TJ, T2 we have
=
AI TI
+ A2T2 =)..1 II + )..2 T2.
=
One says that T is a real hyperfunction if T T. The real part of T is Re T := !(T + T) and the imaginary part is 1m T: (1/2i)(T - t). It is easy to see that Re T and 1m T are real hyperfunctions. A hyperfunction is real if and only if there is f E Jt"(C#) representing it such that fez) = - f(Z) for every z E C#. (3) For every T E B(Q) represented by f E ~(V\Q), V E U(Q), we can decompose T as T = T+ + T-, where T+ is associated to f+ = Xc+nv . f, and T- is associated to fXc -nv . f·
=
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionab
38
Note that when h E Jf"(V), V E U(Q), and T E B(Q), it makes sense to multiply T by h, namely, if f E Jf"(V\Q) represents T, then hT = Th is associated to hf. Since h E Jf"(V), this is well defined. In particular, for h E Jf"(V), the hyperfunction I~ . h makes sense, this is precisely the hyperfunction associated to the function Xc.nvh E Jf"(V\Q). Similarly, h makes sense and
In .
I~.h=-I;.h
by Example (1). It is also clear that if h), hiT + h2T.
1.2.5. Proposition. For a hyperfunction T
E
h2 E
Jf"(V), then (hi
+ h 2 )T =
B(Q) the following conditions are
eC{ui vulenl:
(i) There are V E U(Q) and f E Jf"(V) such that T = I~ . f. (ii) There are V E U(Q) and g E Jf"(V) such that T = I; . g. (iii) There are VI, V2 E U(Q), fl E Jf"(VI), and h E Jf"(V2) such that
T = I~ . fl
+ I; . h. Proof. (i) =9 (iii) Take VI = V2 = V, fl = f. h = O. (iii) ::::} (i) Take V = VI n V2 , f = (fJlV) - (hlV). I~ . (f11V) and I; . h = I; . (hlV). Thus T = I~. (fdV)
+ I; . (hlV) = [I~. (fJlV)]
Then clearly I~. fl =
- [I~.
by the previous Example 1.2.4(3). (ii) <=> (i) Just take f = -g.
(hlV)]
= I~ . f, o
1.2.6. Definition. A hyperfunction satisfying one of the equivalent conditions of Proposition 1.2.5 is called a hoiomorphic hyperfunction. For the following proposition we need to recall that for any complex-valued real analytic function ~ in Q there is an open set V E U(Q) and a holomorphic function E Jf"(V) such that IQ = ~. In fact, to say that ~ is real analytic means that for every Xo E Q one can represent ~ by its Taylor series in an open interval Ixo containing Xo, 1"0 <; Q, x
!p(x)
1 dj
= L.. ~ -:- -. !p(xo)(x J! dX1
. XO)l.
j=O
That is, this series has a positive radius of convergence bigger or equal to r(xo), where (xo - r(xo), Xo + r(xa» = 1'0' The series ~ ~(j)(xo) . -'----(z - XO)l
L.. 1=0
j!
clearly represents a holomorphic function in 8(xo. r(xo» whose restriction to Ixo coincides with rp. This way we can define a holomorphic function in
1.2. Hyperfunctions
v=
39
=
UxoEnB(Xo, r(xo» such that IQ rp and V E U(Q). We say is an extension of rp. We denote by A(Q) the space of complex-valued real analytic
functions in
Q.
1.2.7. Proposition. There is a canonical injection in: A(r.!) --+ B(r.!), which allows us to consider B(Q) as an A(Q)-module. The image of in is the family of holomorphic hyperfunctions. If rp E A(Q), then in(rp) is represented by Xc+nn . <1>, where is a holomorphicfunction extending rp to V E U(r.!). Ifrp E A(Q) and T E B(Q) is represented by f E Je(V\Q), where V E U(Q) is an open set for which there is an extension E Je(V) of cp, then rpT is the hyperfunction associated to (fl(V\Q». Proof. In part this was done in Example 1.2.4(3).
=
It is easy to verify that in is well defined. In fact. in(rp) 1~ . <1>. If in(rp) it means that Xc+nn . admits an analytic continuation across Q. Hence and rp = O.
= O. =0
Assume T is represented by h E Je(V;\Q), rp has extensions j E Je(V;), and VI, V2 E U(Q). We can suppose that VI = V2 = V and that it is connected, in order to show that the hyperfunctions associated to ( tI (VI \Q»ft and (21(V2\Q»h coincide. It follows that <1>1 = <1>2 in V, hence we can suppress the indices. By hypothesis, there is h E Je(V) such that h is the analytic continuation across r.! of fl - h Therefore, we have (I(V\Q»ft (I(V\Q»h = (I(V\Q»(f1 - h) which can be analytically continued to h across Q. This proves that the product is well defined. The fact that, with this definition of the product, B(Q) is an A(Q)-module is immediate. 0 Let us now see how to differentiate hyperfunctions.
1.2.S. Definition. Let T E B(Q) be represented by f E Je(V\Q) and V E U(Q). We define the pth derivative of T to be the hyperfunction DPT = rep) E B(Q) associated to the function f(p) = d P f (dz P E Je(V\Q). One can verify without difficulty that T(P) is independent of the representative taken. The maps DP: B(Q) --+ B(Q) are linear and they leave A(Q) invariant. Furthermore, for rp E A(Q), DPrp is the usual derivative.
1.2.9. Definition. A differential operator of order m in r.! is a linear operator L: B(Q) -+ B(r.!) of the form
40
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.2.10. Remarks. (1) One has that for cp E A(Q) and T E B(Q), DP(cpT) =
L
O~i~p
(~) Dicp. DP-iT. J
(The proof is left as an exercise to the reader.) (2) Let Q be an open interval of R A hyperfunction T E B(Q) is holomorphic and defined by a polynomial of degree ~ p if and only if DP+I T = O. The condition is clearly necessary. Conversely, if DP+ IT = 0, there is I E .1f(C#) such that I represents T and I(p+ll represents 0 in B(Q). Since n is simply connected and f(p+l) has an analytic continuation to there is a function g E .1f(n) such that g(p+l) = l(p+l) in e#. Hence (j _ g)(P-t-i) = o in C#, which implies there are polynomials P+, P_ of degree ~ p such P+ in C+ and 1- g P_ in e-. So that T P+I~ + P_In that I - g (P+ - P_)l~. It is clear that the polynomial P+ - P_ represents T, hence T is holomorphic and represented by a polynomial of degree ~ p. (3) A pth order primitive of T E B(Q) is a hyperfunction S E B(Q) such that SIP) = T. If Q is an interval, every hyperfunction admits primitives of all orders and two pth order primitives differ by a hyperfunction represented by a polynomial of degree ~ p - 1. In fact, if I E .1f(C#) represents T, then I admits pth order primitives in e+ and C- since both are simply-connected domains.
n,
=
=
=
=
We are now going to construct the sheaf of hyperfunctions in lit it will be a flabby sheaf. (The reader may consult [Bre] for questions in sheaf theory.) 1.2.11. Definition. Let Q I ~ Q2 be two nonempty subsets of R Let T E B(Q2) be represented by IE .1f(V2 \Qz), where V2 E U(Qz). The restriction of T to QI, denoted Rn,.n,(T) or TIQI, is the hyperfunction in B(Qd associated to fl«VI n V2 )\Q), for any VI E U(Qz). One can easily verify that TIQ I does not depend on the choice of VZ, VI. It is also clear that Rn,.n, is a linear map: B(Qz) ~ B(Qd. We set B(fjJ) 0 and R~.n 0 for every Q.
=
I,
or
=
1.2.12. Proposition. Let QJ, Qz be two nonempty open subsets olR Then: (1) Rn,.n, is surjecth·e. (2) I~,IQI = I~, and In,IQI = In,. (3) The map R n , n, commutes with conjugation, with taking real or imaginary parts, with multiplication by real analytic functions, and with differentiation operators. The map RQ,.n, preserves the class of holomorphic hyper/unctions. (4) IfQI £ f2z £ f23, then
1.2. Hyperfunctions
41
Proof. We only show that RflIofl2 is surjective leaving the rest of the proof as an exercise. Every T E B(nd has a representative f E Jt"(C#). to which one can associate S E B(n2). Clearly
R fllofl2
(S) = T.
D
The family 8(n). for n open subset of JR. and the maps RQIoQ 2 determine a presheaf on JR. this presheaf BJR is called the (pre )sheaf of hyperfunctions.
1.2.13. Proposition. The presheaf BJR is a flabby sheaf. Proof. Let
n
be a nonempty open subset of JR and let (nj)jeJ be an open covering of n. Let T E B(n) be such that TIOj = 0 for every j. We want to show that T = O. Let f E Jt"(C#) be a representative of T. The hypothesis TIOj = 0 means that there exists hj E Jt"(C# U OJ) such that hj is the analytic continuation of f across nj . Clearly f has an analytic continuation to C# U 0, i.e., T = O. Let us now show that BJR satisfies the second axiom of sheaves, which in this case means that hyperfunctions can be defined locally.
1.2.14. Lemma. Let (OJ )jeJ be an open covering of a nonempty open set n 5; JR. Let 1j E B(nj ), j E J, be a collection of hyper/unctions such that for every i, j with 0; n nj i= 0 we have Tiln;
Then there is a unique T
E
Proof. For every j let jj
n nj =
1]10;
n nj .
8(n) such that TIOj = 1] for every j
E
J.
Jt"(C#) be a function representing 1j. Recall that C# U j . For every i, j such that 0; n OJ i= 10 we have that g;j f; Ii admits an analytic continuation to a function, still denoted g;j, which is holomorphic in C# U (0; n nj ) 0.; n If n n i= 0, it is clear that gij + gjk + gk; = 0 in C#, hence in n n since all three functions are holomorphic in that intersection. By the Mittag-Leffler Theorem [BG, Theorem l.2.23] there are gj E 8(nj ). j E J. such that
o.j =
E
n
=
=
o.j. n; o.j nk
n; nj nko
Hence all the functions f; + gi coincide with a single function f E 8(C#). This function f determines aTE B(n) such that TIOj is represented by jj. since gj is holomorphic in j • That is, Tlnj = 1j. The uniqueness of T follows D from the reasoning at the beginning of the proof of Proposition 1.2.13.
n
This concludes the proof of the proposition, since we already know that the restriction operators are surjective, which is the last point we need to verify that Sa is a flabby sheaf. D
In the same way that we can talk about the support of a distribution. we can define the support of a hyperfunction.
42
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.2.15. Proposition. Let T E B(Q) and let (Q i )iEI be a family of open subsets ofQ such that TIQ i = 0, then TI(Ui Q;) = O.
Proof. Let Q' = Ui Qi, T' = TIQ'. Then (f2;)iEI is an open covering of Q' and T'lQ i = 0, by the previous proposition T' = O. 0 1.2.16. Definition. Let T E B(Q), then the support of T in Q, sUPPn T, or simply supp T, is the complement in Q of the largest open set U S; Q such that TIU =0.
For F a closed subset of Q, one denotes by BF(Q) the family of all hyperfunctions T in Q with supp T S;; F. The previous proposition shows that this is a well-defined concept. The following properties of the support of a hyperfunction are easy to verify:
L A/Fj) S;; U supp 1) (1) E B(Q), Aj E C, I:::: j :::: n). I:«;j:«;n I:«;j:«;n (2) sUPPn, (TIQd = (SUPPQ2 T) n Q) (T E B(Q2), Q I S;; Q2). (3) If Q is an interval in IR and T E B(Q) is zero in a neighborhood of Xo E Q, then, for every p E N*, there is a unique pth primitive of T in B(Q) that vanishes in a neighborhood of Xo.
(1) supp(
1.2.17. Proposition. Let Q be a nonempty open subset oflR and let (Fj)j?:,1 be a locally finite sequence of nonempty relatively closed subsets of Q such that Uj?:,1 Fj = Q. Let T be a hyperfunction in Q. Then there is a sequence (1)j?:,1 of elements of B(Q) such that supp 1j S; Fj for every j and, such that for every Q' open, Q' cc Q, there is an integer n = n(Q') so that
T IQ' =
L
(1j IQ').
I:«;j:«;n Proof. Let f
E
JIt"(C#) be a representative of T. Set Fl.l Flj = Fj\F I
= FI
and, for j ~ 2,
n Q.
The sequence (Flj)j?:,1 is a locally finite family of relatively closed subsets of Q and f is a holomorphic function in the intersection of the two open sets VI = Q\Fl.l' and V{ = Q\(Uj ?:,2 Flj ). Namely, in C#. By the Mittag-Leffler Theorem, there exist fl E Jt'(vd and gl E JIt"(V() such that
f = fl
+ gl
in C#.
Let TI be the hyperfunction in Q associated to ftlC#. Then supp TI S; Fl. To define the 1j we proceed by induction. Let k E N*, assume we have already found a locally finite family of relatively closed subsets Fi . j of Q, 1 ::'S i ::'S k, j ~ i, and functions Ii E JIt"(Vi), gi E JIt"(V/), with Vi = Q\Fu, V/ = Q\
1= fl + ... + h + gj in C#.
1.2. Hyperfunctions
43
Furthennore, Fj • j 5; Fj • We let Tj E B(Q) be the hyperfunction associated to fjlC'. Now, let and
j
~
k + 2.
Clearly, the sets Fk+l.j(J ~ k + I) fonn a locally finite family of relatively but as closed subsets of Q. Furthermore, the function gk is holomorphic in
V;,
= Vk+1 n V{+I' and Vk+1 = Q\(Uj;::k+1 Fk+l.j ) are open subsets of V{
where Vk+1 = Q\Fk+l.k+1 C, we can apply again the Mittag-Leffler Theorem and obtain
gk = fk+1 Hence
f = fl
+ gk+1
in Vr
+ ... + fk+1 + gk+!
in C'.
If Tk+1 is the hyperfunction in Q associated to fk+dC', it is clear that supp Tk+! 5; Fk+!.k+1 = Fk+I. If Q' is a relatively compact open subset of Q, then there is a positive integer n = n(Q') such that Fj n Q' = 0 whenever j ~ n(Q'). Therefore, gn is holomorphic in C' U Q' and so
TIQ' =
L
o
(TjIQ').
I;";j;";n 1.2.1S. Proposition. Let Q be a nonempty open subset ofR and let (Fj)j;::1 be a locally finite covering ofQ by nonempty relatively closed sets. Let Tj E B(Q) be such that supp Tj 5; Fj for every j. Then, there exists a hyperfunction T E B(Q) such that for every relatively compact open subset Q' of Q there is an integer n n(Q') satisfying TIQ' = (TjIQ') l:5j:5n . and TjIQ' = 0 for every j > n.
=
L
Proof. We can write Q = Uj;::1 Ij , where the Ij are pairwise disjoint open intervals in R Construct an increasing exhaustion (Kn)n;::1 of Q by compact sets as fOllows:
(.~" {x Eli' d(x.lj)
?:
n)
n [-no n).
Let and for I
~
2, E/ := {n E N°: Fn
n K/
-::f:: 0}\(EI U· .. U E/-d.
The sets E/, l ~ 1, are finite by the hypotheses.
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
44
Let V = {z E C: Re Z E Q} = Q important and elementary lemma:
+ iJR., the strip of base Q. We need the very
1.2.19. Lemma. Let Q be a nonempty open subset 01 JR., let F be a nonempty relatively closed subset 01 Q, V E U(Q), and let T be a hyper/unction in Q with suppT ~ F. Then, every holomorphiclunction I E ~(V\Q) representing T has an analytic continuation to V\F. Proof. Since TI(Q\F) = 0, there is also a function h E ~(V\F) representing T, therefore I - h E ~(V), which shows that I has an analytic continuation 0 to V\F. From the lemma we conclude that if In E ~(V\Q) represents the hyperfunction Tn, then In has an analytic continuation j" to V\Fn . We define a sequence of holomorphic functions in V\Q as follows: (i)
gl
:=
2:nEEI
(ii) g2 := 2:nEE2
j"
E
~(V\Q).
in E ~(V\Q).
(iii) For I :::: 3, the function 2:nEE, j" belongs to ~«V\Q) U KI _ I ). Applying Runge's Theorem [BG, Theorem 3.1.1] to V and the compact subset K; = KI-2 + i [-I, I], we find a function hi E ~(V) such that
ma~
IL
zEK, nEE,
Let now gl
:=
in(z) - hl(Z)1
(L in) -
hi E
~ 2-
1•
~«V\Q) U KI_
I ).
nEE,
It is easy to see that the series
converges uniformly in every compact subset of V\Q, hence g E Jt"(V\Q). Let T be the hyperfunction in Q associated to g. If Q' is a relatively compact open subset of Q, there is an integer no = no(Q') such that Fn n Q' = elfor all n > no. Th~refore Q' ~ UI <;;j <;;n Fj • Let n I = n 1 (Q') be smallest integer:::: 3 such that Q' ~ Kn, and {l, ... , no} ~ EI U··· U En, =
En, .
In V\Q we have the identity g -
L
Ik
=
L
gl -
L
hi
+
L
.h.
I~k~no
The first term is holomorphic in (V\Q) U in (V\Q) U Q'. From this it follows that
TIQ'
=
L l~k:::no
KnJ' the second in (TkI Q ').
V, and the third
1.2. Hyperfunctions
45
Furthennore. by the choice of no. TA IQ' proof of Proposition 1.2.18.
= 0 for any k > no. This concludes the 0
In [BG. Lemma §3.6.18] it has been shown that any T E t"(lR) (Le .• a distribution T with compact support) can be obtained from the boundary values of its Cauchy transform T. T = I/Jrz * T. Namely. T
I
= - 2i [T(x + iO) A
A
T(x - iO)].
We are now going to obtain similar results for hyperfunctions with compact support. 1.2.20. Definition. Let T E B(Q) be a hyperfunction with compact support. If V EU(Q) and f E Jf(V\suppT) represents T. and if y is a cycle. which is the union of disjoint Jordan curves in V \ supp T, oriented so that the index of y with respect to every point in supp T is 1. we denote by T(x) dx. the integral of T. the value of the integral
In
In
It is easy to verify the independence of T(x)dx from the choice of V. f. and y. If V is connected we can take y to be a Jordan curve. 1.2.21. Proposition. Let Q be a nonempty open subset of lR and let T have compact support. The function T defined in C# by A
T(z)
= -I
Jr
E
B(Q)
1
T(x) --dx.
nZ-X
is h%morphic in C# and has an analytic continuation to C\ supp T. Moreover. T(oo) = lim z --+ oo T(z) = 0 and T represents -2iT. It is the only representative of -2iT with these properties.
Proof. Let f
E
Jt'(Q\ supp(T» be such that flC# represents T. For every z
E
C' we have t
~
f(t) E Jt'(C'\{z)). t - z
and this function is a representative of the hyperfunction T: := (1/(f - z»T. the product of T by the real analytic function t ~ (t - Z)-I. For z E C\ supp T, the function T(z) =
2.
r TCt) dt = _2. r T:(t)dt = 2.1yt-z f(t) dt
Jr}nz-t
Jrk
Jr
makes sense and it does not depend on the choice of the cycle y in Q\ supp T of index I with respect to every point in supp T and index 0 with respect to z. It is easy to verify that T is holomorphic in C\ supp T and has the value 0 at 00.
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
46
t
Let us show that IC# represents - 2i T. It is enough to show that the function -(l/2iJT - f has an analytic continuation across supp T. Then -(l/2iJT - f would be entire and represent the zero hyperfunction. Let y be a cycle in Q\ supp T with index 1 with respect to every point of supp T. Let Int(y) denote the union of Int(y}) for the components of y. We claim that for any; E Int(y) n C# one has -~i(:) - fez) = __1_. f(t) dt.
21
2m
If the claim were true, then - (I /2i) t - f to the Int(y). To verify the claim, let YI YI S; Int(y), and such that the index of YI respect to ; is zero. By Cauchy's formula
fez)
= _1_. 2m = _1_.
27r 1
r
lY-YI
f(t) dt t- Z
= _1_. 27r1
r
1Y t -
;
would have an analytic continuation be another cycle in Q\ supp T with with respect to supp T is 1 and with we have
r
f(t) dt __1_. z 2m
ly t -
r
lYI
f(t) dt t- z
r f(t) dt _ ~t(z). 21
1
y
t - Z
t
which proves the claim. As a consequence, has an analytic continuation to C\ supp T. If there were another g E Jt"(C\ supp T), g(oo) = 0, and such that g IC# represents T, then g - (1 /2i) t can be continued across supp T, hence it is entire and vanishes at 00. Liouville's theorem shows now that g = -(1/2i)t.
o Let Q be a nonempty open subset of Ilt V E U (Q), and W = V n C*. Recall from [BO, §3.6.l11 that a function f E Jt"(W) is said to be of slow growth (or tempered) if for every compact K S; Q there are constants A, B, C > 0 such that for all ;: E W such that Re;: E K, 0 < 11m zl < A, one has
If(:)1 ~ BI 1m zl-c. For such a function
f
the limits
exist in the sense of distributions in V' (Q) and one can define its boundary value h(/) h_(/) - b_(/). Conversely, any element T E 1)'(Q) is of the form T = b(n for some holomorphic function of slow growth in Q (i.e., of slow growth in some open set W as above) (see [BO, Theorem 3.6.19]). These theorems can be translated in the language hyperfunctions into the following proposition:
=
1.2.22. Proposition. For eve,}' non empty open subset n S; IR, there is a canonical injection of the space V'(n) of distributions in n into B(n). The image of V'(n) under this injection is the subspace of B(n) of classes of holomorphic functions of slow growth at the points of n. This injection commutes with restrictions.
1.2. Hyperfunctions
47
Proof. Choose a partition of the unity (an>n:::l in Q, all E D(Q). Let T E V'(Q). Then for every n ::: I, the function (anT) , (z)
= -1TI
\
all(t») ft,-Z -
t
is holomorphic in C\ supp(anT) and zero at 00. The function (i /2) (all TnC# determines a hyperfunction Sn in Q with compact support, supp S" S; supp(anT) S; suppan • By Proposition 1.2.18 there is a hyperfunction S E B(Q) such that for every open set Q', relatively compact in Q, there exists an integer n n(Q') E N* for which we have
=
SIQ' = ~ (S; IQ') l:oj:on
and if
j > n.
Note that in view of the second condition, we might as well have written S IQ' = Lj2:1 (Sj IQ')· We want to see that S is independent of the choice of partition of unity. Let ({3n)n2:1 be another Coo partition of unity in Q. The same procedure allows us to construct a hyperfunction S in Q. To prove that S = S, it is enough to show that for every Q' open and relatively compact subset of Q, we have SIQ' = SIQ'. We know there is n 1 E N* such that SIQ' =
L
(SjIQ'),
l:sJ:::n I
SIQ
=
L
(SjIQ'),
l=5j::51l1
and SjIQ' = SjIQ' = 0 for all j > nl. The Sj are the hyperfunctions in Q associated to (i /2)({3j Tr. We can also assume that Q' n supp aj = Q' n supp {3j = 0 ifj>nl. The distribution L,I:Oj:on, (aj T - f3j T) has compact support contained in Q\Q'. Hence, its Cauchy transform LI::5j::5nl «aj Tf - (f3j Tn is holomorphic in C# U Q'. This proves that SIQ' = SIQ'. Therefore, the map T t-+ S is a welldefined map from D' (Q) into B(Q). The linearity now follows immediately from the above construction. To prove the injectivity it is enough to show that supp T S; supp S. In fact, if Q' is a relatively compact open subset of Q\ supp T, there is a ex Partition of unity (a n )n2:1 in Q such that al == I in a neighborhood of Q' and al == 0 in a neighborhood of supp T. The first condition on al implies that SIQ' is the hyperfunction associated to the holomorphic function _1_. / ft, al(l»). 2m \ t -;;
;; E C#.
But this function is entire (and. in fact. identically zero) by the second condition SIQ' = O. It follows that supp T S; supp S. Finally, we want to show that the map T t-+ S from distributions to hyperfunctions commutes with restrictions. Let 0' ~ 0 be two open subsets of IR
on al. Hence
48
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
and T E V'(Q). Let S be the hyperfunction in Q corresponding to T obtained previously, and let S' be the hyperfunction in Q/ obtained from TIQ' E V'(Q'). We need to prove that SIQ' =S'. It is enough to show that for every Q" open and relatively compact subset of Q' one has SIQ" = (SIQ')IQ" = S'IQ". For that purpose, let (a~h:::1 be a Coo partition of unity in Q' such that a; == 1 in a neighborhood of QII, and let (ak)k:::1 be a Coo partition of unity in Q such that al = c.r;. Then Sin' is represented hy the function O/27ri)(Tt ,al(t)/(t - z)}, which is holomorphic in C#\ supp a I. On the other hand, S'I Q" is represented by (l/2rri)(Tt IQ', al(t)/(t - z)}, which coincides with the previous one because suppa! cc Q'. Since the definition of the map T ~ S is independent of the 0 choice of partition of unity, this argument proves the restriction property. The only thing left to prove in Proposition 1.2.22 is the fact that the image of V'(Q) can be identified to the classes of holomorphic functions of slow growth. This is the statement of the following Proposition 1.2.23:
1.2.23. Proposition. Let Q be a nonempty open subset of JR, T E V' (Q). Then there is f E .1t"(C#) of slow growth in Q such that b(f) = T, that is,for every q; E V(Q) one has (T, q;)
= (b(f), q;} = E-+O}n lim {(f(x + ie) -
f(x - ie»q;(x)dx.
Furthermore, V/(Q) can be identified to .1t"b.n(C#)/.1f(Q), where .1t"b.n(C#) is the space of all functions f E Jf(C#) of slow growth in Q. Proof. This is an easy generalization of Theorems 3.6.19 and 3.6.24 in [BG]. All one does is replace in [BG, Theorem 3.6.19] the intervals [an, bn ], n :::: 1, by an exhaustion (Kn)n:::1 of Q by compact sets. 0
1.2.24. Examples. (1) Given a E JR, the function -1/[2rri(z - a»), holomorphic in C\{a}, repre{a}. This hyperfunction sents a hyperfunction in B(lR.) denoted 80' supp8a coincides with the image of the Dirac measure at a in B(JR) under the map of Proposition 1.2.22. For n :::: 1, 8~nJ is represented by the function obtained differentiating this function n times. i.e., (-l)n+l n !/[2rri(z - a)n+I). (2) Let T E B(Q), then for every n E N* and a E R there is an S E B(Q) such that (x - a)n S = T. In fact, if a ¢ Q, the solution S is unique and determined by mUltiplying T by the real analytic function (x - a)-n, or, what amounts to the same thing, if g E .1t"(C*) represents T, then S is associated to the function g(z)/(z - a)n E .1t"(C#). If a E Q, let SI be the hyperfunction in Q associated to g (z) / (z - a)n. This hyperfunction satisfies (x - a)n S I = T, but it is not the
=
49
1.2. Hyperfunctions
unique solution. The general solution is given by S = S I + Lo:,:j :,:n-I Cj 8~j), Cj arbitrary complex numbers. Before showing this, let us first give a second proof that if a ¢ n, then the solution of the equation is unique. Let I(z) := g(z)(z - a)-n E -*,(C#) to simplify the notation. If S E .8(n) is another solution and l E Jt'(C#) is a representative of S, then (z - atU(z) -l(z» = h(z),
n.
where h is a function holomorphic in Hence, (z - a)-nh(z) is also holomorphic in (because a ¢ n), showing that S = S. If a E n, we see that if S and SI are solutions of the equation, then S2 = S - Sl is a solution of the equation (x - a)n S2 = O. Now, we first observe that any linear combination Lj':ci cj8~j) satisfies this equation, since
n
n
L
(z - a)
Cj
(_l)j+lj! )j+l lTt Z - a
2'(
O:':j:,:n-l
E
-*,(C).
On the other hand, if S2 E 8(n) is an arbitrary solution of (x - aYS2 = 0, and h E Jt'(C#) is a representative of S2, then (z - a)nh(z) admits an analytic Therefore, h admits an analytic continuation to a function holomorphic in as a meromorphic function ii with at most a pole of order continuation to n at the point a. Let bn/(z - a)n + ... + b,/(z - a) be the principal part of the Laurent expansion of ii at z = a. It is clear that for a convenient choice of Co, Cl, ••. , Cn-I E C, we have that
n.
n
-
L
h(z) -
(-I)i+1j! Cj
O:,:j:,:n-'
is holomorphic in
. I
(z - a)1+
n, That is, S2 is the hyperfunction S2
=
L
c/i!j)
O:':j:,:n-'
in 8(n). (3) Let us recall that Arg z is the principal value of the argument of the complex number z in C\(] - 00,0]), its values lie in ] - Jr, IT[. The function -1
F(z) = - . (Log 2lTl
Iz I + i Arg( -z» = -
i
2Jr
Log ( -z),
Z E
C#.
detennines a hyperfunction Y E .8(lR), which coincides with the usual HeaviSide function, that is, the function X[o.oc[' In fact, note that Y must correspond a distribution since F has slow growth. Furthermore, as Log Izl is locally ?ttegrable on the real axis and continuous except for z = 0, and Arg z has a JUmp of 2Jr across the negative real axis, one obtains immediately that
!O
b(F)
= Y = X[o.oo[.
50
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Moreover. since F'(z)
= 1/2rriz. we conclude that y' =8.
EXERCISES 1.2. 1. Show that for any fixed c > 0 and n E N one has c5(n)(±cx)
2. Define for fixed a
E
= (±I)nc-n-I,s(n)(x).
IC\IE the hyperfunction a.X+ .-
b
2. -1 .
«-z) a ),
Sln7ra where one is USIng the principal blanch of the power function. [0, oo[ and the hyperfunction coincides with the function (a) Prove that supp(x~) x a on its support. To study this hyperfunction for a E IE, consider the auxiliary function I
=
rp(z;a):=(-z)a
r= e'(-t)-a-1dt, J-oo
which is holomorphic in IC\[O, oo[ for any a. (b) Show that for a < 0 one has 1
= r(-a)(-z)a + L --.~. 00
rp(z; a)
j=O
j
a - J J.
Conclude that for a ¢ IE 7r rca + l)cp(z; a) = -.--( _z)a SInHa It follows that for a ¢ IE
xa
r(a: 1)
mod Jf'(IC).
1
= 27ri b(rp(z; a».
Show that this last fonnula defines a hyperfunction even for a E Z. (c) Show that for n E N
x~
rea + 1)
I
= ,s(n)(x).
a=-n-I
What is the value of the right-hand side in the last formula for a
= n?
3. Is the function expO/z) of slow growth? What is the support of the corresponding hyperfunction? 4. Solve the differential equation
x 2 DT+T =0 in the space S(lR). 5. (a) Show that the space of hyperfunctions with support at the point 0 E lR is isomorphic to the space Jf'(1C) of entire functions. (Include the zero hyperfunction in this space. Hint: Identify T E S(R), supp T <; {OJ, with FO/z), F E Jf'(IC).) (b) Prove that if F(z) = Ln~oanZn is an entire function. then the function ~an
f(z):= ~ ,zn rt:?;O
n.
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
51
is also an entire function that satisfies the additional property that for every e > 0 there is a positive constant C, such that (z E iC).
Prove also the converse. The function I is said to be of infraexponential type or exponential type zero (see [BO, Chapter 4], [Lev]). (c) Let 0 0 be the space of functions holomorphic in a neighborhood of zero. Show that it can be identified to n,>o Jf'(B(O, the intersection of the spaces of holomorphic functions in the disk B(O, e) of center zero and radius e. Let L: 0 0 --+ IC be a linear Prove functional which is continuous when restricted to every Fn!chet space Jf'(B(O, that there is a unique sequence (an)n~o of complex numbers such that if rp E 0 0 then
e»,
e».
(L. I{!}
= L a.cpln) (0). n~O
Furthermore, prove that the function
L anz n
I(z) :=
n~O
e»
is an entire function of infraexponential type. (Recall that JIi?(B(O, is a Frechet space with the usual topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of B(O, e).) (d) Show that every entire function of infraexponential type can be obtained by the procedure from part (c). Using the previous parts of this exercise, show that the space of continuous linear functionals in 0 0 (i.e., those L described in (c» is isomorphic to the space of hyperfunctions with support contained in {O}. 6. Let n be an open interval of JR, supp(fT) = supp T.
I
E
A(n)\{O), and T
E
B(n). Show that
7. Let n be an open interval of JR, show that A(fl) consists of those I E c(n) such that for any closed and bounded subinterval K £; n there are constants C > 0, 8 > 0, so that for every positive integer n max I/ln)(x)1 .:::: Cn! 8n • xeK
8. Show that the function oc
I(x) =
L:>-n cosn x 2
n=O
is COO in IR but its Taylor series diverges (i.e., it has radius of convergence zero) at every point except x = O. Construct now g E c(JR) such that its Taylor series diverges at every point.
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type 1.3.1. Definition. An analytic functional T on an open set Q of C, T: JIi? (Q)
C, is a continuous linear functional on the Fn!chet space action of T on an element h E JIi?(Q) by (T, h).
--+
JIi?(Q). We denote the
52
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
The family of all these analytic functionals is the topological dual Jt"'(Q) of the space Jt"(Q). Since Jt"(Q) is a closed subspace of the FTt!chet spaces C(Q) (of continuous functions in Q) and f(Q) (of Coo functions in Q). Every analytic functional can be represented, in an essentially nonunique way, either by a measure with compact support in Q or by a distribution with compact support in Q. For instance, let a E Q, then the analytic functional
I
~
I(a),
usually denoted 80 , can be represented by the Dirac measure 80 as well as by the complex valued measure I dz -2.X8S(0.r)(z)--, 1Tl
Z -
a
whenever the closed disk B(a, r) ~ Q. Let us recall that, since the sequence 0-+ Jt"(Q) ~ f(Q)
~ f(Q)
-+ 0
is an exact sequence of Frechet-Schwartz spaces (see [BG, §3.6]), one can identify Jt"'(Q) with the quotient space £'(Q)/«a/az)(f'(Q»). In fact, this vector space isomorphism is also an isomorphism of topological vector spaces. We define the multiplication 'PT of T E Jt"'(Q) by'P E Jt"(Q) by ('PT, h) := (T, 'Ph)
for every
It is clear that 'PT E Jt'" (Q). The derivative DT of an analytic functional T formula
h E Jt"(Q). E Jt"'(Q)
is defined by the
(DT, h) := -(T, h'),
where h' is the derivative of the holomorphic function h. If we represent T by a distribution 11, then DT is represented by (a/az)l1. Therefore, we also write (a/az)T instead of DT. Hence, the action of the differential operator P(z, D) := LO~j~n aj(z)Dj (aj E Jt"(Q», on the space Jt"'(Q) is given by (P(z, D)T, h) = (T, P*(z, D)h),
where P*(z, D)
= LO~j~n(-l)jDJaj as an operator, i.e., P*(z, D)h = L (-l)j Dj(ajh). O~j~n
In at least one respect, the analytic functionals do not behave like distributions, they do not possess a well-defined support since the space .Jt'(Q) clearly does not have partitions of unity. The corresponding notion is that of carrier. 1.3.2. Definition. Let T E Jt'" (n), a carrier of T is any compact set K, K S n, such that for every neighborhood w of K, w CC Q, there is a constant Cw ~ 0
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
53
with the property that
I(T.h)l:s Cwsuplh(z)l. =Ew
for every h E Jt"(Q). The existence of representations of the analytic functional T by measures with compact support in Q shows that T has at least one carrier. There is no uniqueness, because any compact set L on Q which contains a carrier K is also a carrier. In particular, if T is carried by K, then T is also carried by Kn , the holomorphically convex hull of K in Q (see [BO, §3.1.3]). As we shall see, the existence of a smallest carrier in the sense of inclusion is a delicate question. For instance, let Q C* and T E .1f'(Q) be defined by
=
(T, h)
= _1_.j 2rrl
y,
h(z)dz,
where Y, = aB(D, r). The circle is holomorphically convex but T also has carriers Y']' Y'2' rl i= r2, which are not ordered by inclusion. We will be able to prove the existence of a smallest carrier when Q is holomorphically convex in C, i.e., when Jf"(C) is dense in Jf"(Q). Let us recall from [Ho3], [BG, Example 3.1.4] that we have the following characterization:
1.3.3. Proposition. Let Q I £ Q2 be two open subsets o/C. The/ollowing condi· tions are equivalent: (1) Every function in Jf"(QI) can be uniformly approximated by functions in Jf"(Q2) over any compact subset of QI. In other words, Jf"(Q 2) is dense in Jf"(Q I ) in the usual Frechet topology.
(2) For every compact K S; Q I, one has (3) For every compact K S; QIo one has
Kn
2
=
Kn] .
Kn2 n Q I = Kn]. S; QI, the set Kn, n Q I is compact.
(4) For every compact K (5) If Q2\Q I = L U F with L compact. F 'is a relatively closed subset of Q2, and L n F = 0, then L = 0.
In case these equivalent conditions are satisfied we say that the open set Q I is holomorphically convex in Q2.
ProO/o/Proposition 1.3.3. It is dear that (I) => (3) => (4). Let K'
= Kn, n Qi.
It follows from (4) that K' and K" are two disjoint compact sets whose union is a holomorphically convex subset of Q2, namely Kn ,. For any f E Jt"(QI) We can consider the function F = f on K' and 1 on Kif and, by the theorem ?f Runge [BO, Theorem 3.1.1], this function can be unifonnly approximated 10 K' UK" by functions in Jt"(Q2). In particular, Jf"(Q2) is dense in Jf"(QI). !herefore (4) => (I). If we choose f = D, the fact that K S; K' and the values ~ K" of a holomorphic function in Q2 can be estimated by its values in K', unplies that Kif = 0. Hence (2) also holds. Since (2) => (3) is clear, we have the equivalence of the first four conditions.
54
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
To show that (5) => (2), consider a component V of Q 2 \K which is relatively compact in Q2. Since av = K ~ Q" the set L =
U n (Q 2\Q 1) =
un (Q2\Qd
is a compact set in U and, since V C n (Q 2 \Qd is closed in Q2, condition (5) implies that L = 0. Hence, V ~ Q 1 and, from the theorem of Runge, it follows that K02 ~ Ko ,. The opposite inclusion being evident, condition (2) holds. To prove that (2) => (5), we choose an open set w ~ L such that n F = o and wee Q2. Since aw n (Q2\Qd = aw n (L U F) = 0 and aw ~ Q2. it follows that aw ~ QI. From the maximum principle one concludes that
w
-
aW02
;2 w;2
Since (2) implies that 8u) Q z = 8u)0, ~ as we wanted to show.
QJ,
L.
we have L ~
QI.
Therefore L
= 0, 0
1.3.4. Definition. An open subset in C is such that .}f(C) is dense in .}f(Q) is called a Runge open set.
In other words, Q is a Runge open set if Q is holomorphically convex in Co Proposition 1.3.3 includes the classical characterization of Runge sets. Namely, Q is a Runge set if and only if C\Q does not have any compact connected components. Clearly, if Q is a Runge open set then the polynomials are dense in .}f(Q). We have now the following result about carriers:
1.3.5. Theorem. Let Q bea Runge open set and let T E .}f/(Q). Then thefollowing properties hold: (1) Let K be a carrier ofT and let w be an arbitrary, holomorphically convex, compact neighborhood of K. Moreover, let {.lw be a measure with support in OJ representing T and let ~ '- -1 d{.lw(O {.lw(z) .--.
1
7T
OJ
z-~
The function [J.w is holomorphic in w C and zero at infinity. When w runs over all the compact holomorphically convex neighborhoods of holomorphically com'ex carriers ofT in Q, the family [J.w defines, by analytic continuation, a holomorphic function
1( 1)
~ := T(z)
7T
T~,--
=-~
in the open set V(T), which is the union of the complement of these carriers. (2) The set K(T) := C\V(T), the intersection of all the holomorphically convex carriers of T, is the smallest holomorphically convex carrier of T in Q. (3) Let V be an open neighborhood of K(T) and let 8 be a cycle in V\K(Tl with integral coefficients, 8 E ZI (V\K(T), Z), homologous in V(T) to the cycle
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
defined by the loop YR: t in U, then
55
Re 2lri / (R > 0 sufficiently large). If his holomorphic
t-+
(T. h) =
11
-"7
~
21
T(z)h(z) dz. A
(4) Conversely, if K is a holomorphically convex compact subset ofn, and .:r is a holomorphic function in C\K, which is zero at infinity, then .:r determines an analytic functional T.7 E Jt'" (n), carried by K, and such that f; = .:r. This analytic functional is defined by (T.7. h)
=~
r
21 J~
.1(z)h(z)dz
(h E
Jt"(n».
where 8 E Zl(n\K. Z) is any cycle homologous in C\K to a loop YR.
The function
i
is called the Cauchy transform of the analytic functional T.
Proof. We need to establish first the following lemma of independent interest:
1.3.6. Lemma. Let K be a holomorphically convex compact subset of an open set n. Then K has a fundamental system of compact neighborhoods that are holomorphically convex in Q. Proof of Lemma 1.3.6. We need to show that for any compact neighborhood w in n of the holomorphically convex compact subset K, there is a compact neighborhood V of K, V ~ w, such that V is holomorphically convex in n. i.e., V = Vn. For simplicity. we write V := Vn in this lemma. In fact, for any z E n\K there is f: E Jt"(Q) such that If,(z)1 > 1 = max~EK Ifz(~)1 because K = Kn. Define U z := {
~ E n: Ifz(~)1
>
If=(Z~1 + 1 }
and
We clearly have inf
~EU,
Let W :=
Ifz(~)1
:::: sup ~E\',
If:(nl.
wn, then wVv ~ rl\K, and we can cover w\lv with a finite number of
Zl •••• , Zn E w\w. Let V := nl::::j::::n V:" a compact neighborhood of K contained in n. ~e show that V = V by verifying successively that V is disjoint from n\w, w\w, and w\ V. First, V £ w implies V ~ W. Second, if Z E w\w. there is a j such that Z E UZj ' Hence,
~n sets ofthe form U:, .... , U:., with It IS A
58
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
We are now going to consider the case which occurs most often in practice: Q is an open convex subset of C. We shaH see that for any T E .1'f' (Q), there is
a smaHest compact convex carrier in Q. It is clear that when Q is convex, there are convex carriers for T. Namely, for any carrier K of Tin Q, the convex hull cv(K) is a convex compact subset of Q, which still carries T. If T E .1'fl(Q) is carried by the compact convex subset K of Q, the function T is holomorphic in K C and we have by the previous Theorem 1.3.4 that, for every h E .1'f(Q) (T, h)
= -211- :-
1
T(z)h(z) dz, A
y
here y is a loop in Q\K of imlt:J\. 1 with respect to every point of K. Evidently, if Kh K2 are compact convex carriers of T and T '1= 0, it follows from the proof of Definition 1.3.4 that KJ n K2 '1= 0 and it is also a compact convex carrier of T. One can conclude that the intersection K(T) of all compact convex carriers of T in Q is also a carrier K(T), K(T) '1= 0 if T '1= O. We will say that K(T) is the convex carrier of T or, sometimes, the convex support of T. When n is a convex open subset of C, let Jfo(QC) be the vector space of all germs of holomorphic functions in a neighborhood of C\Q which are zero at infinity. In case Q is unbounded, we additionally assume that the functions are holomorphic in a neighborhood of z = 00. Let C: .1'f' (n) ~ .1'fo(nC) be the map that assigns to T E .1'f' (n) the function C(T) := 7fT, C(T)(z)
= / T" \
_1_)
z- ~
(z ¢
K(T».
C is a linear isomorphism by Theorem 1.3.5 and Remark 1.3.7. Note that with this notation we have (T, h)
= _1_. 27f1
(C(T)(z)h(z) dz.
}y
We can consider the elements h E .1'fo(QC) as being defined outside a convex compact subset of n. Evidently, in the case of an arbitrary Runge open set Q, one could introduce the analogous space, still denoted .1'fo(QC), whose elements are holomorphic functions, defined in the complement of some compact holomorphically convex subset of Q and that vanish at 00. Since there is a smallest holomorphically convex carrier, the Cauchy transform will also provide an isomorphism between .1'f'(Q) and .1'fo(QC). 1.3.8. Definition. Let Q be an open subset of C. The Fourier-Borel transform of an analytic functional T E .1'f'(Q) is the function ~(T)(z) := (TI;. el;:).
1.3.9. Proposition. The function
~(T)
is an entire holomorphic function.
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
59
Proof. To see this, represent T by a measure of compact support and either differentiate under the integral sign or, what is easier, use Morera's theorem 0 [BG, Theorem 2.1.8].
1.3.10. Proposition. Let n be a convex open set and let T
E Je'(n) have as convex support the set K, then for every e > 0 there is a constant CE > 0 such that (z E C),
where HK(Z):= SUp~EK(RezO. In particular, ;jeT) is an entire function of exponential type. Proof. Let V(K,e) = l~ E ([: d(~, K) < e} and let y be a rectifiable Jordan curve in V(K, e)\K containing K in its interior. By Theorem 1.3.5(3) one can write
One has clearly sup(Re~z) ~ sup(Re~z) ~Ey
+ elzl =
HK(Z)
+ elZI.
~EK
e denote the length of y. We have 1;j(T)(z)1 :::: Me exp(HK(Z) + elzl}.
Let M = maX~EY It(~)1 and let
o
This proposition has a converse.
1.3.11. Theorem. Let K be a compact convex subset of a convex open set n. Let f be an entire function of exponential type such that for every e > 0 there is a constant CE > 0 so that f satisfies everywhere the estimate
If (z) I ::::
CEeHKlZ)+Elzl.
Then. there is a unique analytic functional T E Je' (n) such that ;jeT) = f. Proof. If fez)
= Ln~oanzn, let S(w):=
L n!an n~O
--I. w n+
This series defines a function B holomorphic in a neighborhood of 00 such that ~ vanishes at w = 00. More precisely, the hypothesis on f implies that there IS an R > 0 such that for some constant C > 0 (z E C).
(It is enough to choose R > 0 so that K S; B(O, R). If Ro is the smallest radius such that K S; B(O, Ro), we can choose e > 0 with Ro + 6 < R. CE = C. and USe Hdz) :::: HB(o.Ro)(z) = Rolzl.)
60
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
We claim that 5 is holomorphic in C\8(O, R). In fact, from the Cauchy inequalities we have
Moreover, Stirling's formula states that n!
= nn e-nJ271'n(1
+ s(n)),
s(n) ~ 0 as n ~ 00. Hence
n!lanl ~ CR nJ271'n(l
+ s(n»,
and limsup(n!lanD l / n ~ R. n-+oo
This implies that the series defining 5 converges whenever Iwi> R as we had claimed. Besides the purely formal way we have used to introduce the function 5, we observe that 5 coincides, in the half-plane Re w > R, with the Laplace transform of the function f. In fact,
where the term-by-term integration is justified by the estimate
l°OL,an,tne-I(Rew)dt = Ln!lanl(Rew)-n+l < o n:::O n:::O
00,
valid when Re w > R. For u E C·, let Lu be the ray starting at the origin with direction u, that is, Lu := {su: s ::: OJ. We also need to define the open half-plane
Pu := (z
E
C: Rezu > HK(u)}.
One has Hdu) = sUP:EK(Rezu) = sUP:EK(zlu), where (,1·) represents the usual Euclidean scalar product in C. Therefore, the half-plane Pu depends only on the ray Lit of direction u and not on u, in other words, by homogeneity, on u/lul. To simplify, we shall henceforth assume that lui = l. The value HK(u) represents the (signed) distance to the origin of the boundary line of Pu , this line intersects K and K is entirely contained in P~. The sign is positive if 0 is also in P~, negative otherwise (see Figure 1.1, where the origin was placed in K for convenience). The boundary of Pu is also called a supporting line of the convex set K. If Z E Pu we have for every e > 0 and every t = su E L u , If(t)e-zll:::: C.. eHK(I)+e1tl-Rezt.
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
61
Figure 1.1
Since z E Pu, there is a> 0 such that Rezu :::: HK(u) + a. In fact, the same inequality is valid in a half-plane strictly contained in Pu. Hence HKCt)
+ eltl -
Rezt = S(HK(U)
If we choose 0 < e < a, for instance, e
+e -
Rezu) :::: S(e - a).
= a12, we have
I/(t)e-:tl :::: Ce-(a/2)l sl,
with C = Ca / 2 and
S
= Itl. This shows that the integral
CPu(z):= { /(t)e-: t dt
iL.
converges uniformly in the half-planes {z E HK (u) + a), for every a > O. Therefore CPu is a holomorphic function in Pu. Let us now consider two distinct values U2, lu II = IU21 = 1, 0 < Arg(u2Iu,) < 7r. For p > 0, let YP be the loop in
u"
lim { /(t)e- I : dt = 0, p-+xir p when z E p. I n PU2 ' For that purpose we need to estimate If (t) I exp( - Re t z), when t E r p' The main idea is to use both that Yp surrounds a convex region and that HK is a convex function. Namely, if t E r P' then the endpoints of this segment are precisely pu, and PU2, hence, t = p(AU,
+ (l
- A)U2)
+ (1- A)U2), but )..)U2) == sup(Re~(Au, + (1 - )..)U2»
for some).. E [0, 1]. Then, Hdt) = pHK(AU, HK()..u,
+ (l
-
~eK
62
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Figure 1.2
= sup(A(Re~ul) + (1 -
A)(Re~u2»
~EK
which proves the convexity of HK • On the other hand, some ex > 0 we have ReZUl
Z
E PU1 n PU 2' hence for
= (zlu[) ~ Hdul) +a,
Rezu2 = (ZIU2) ~ H K (U2)
+ ex,
and therefore, Retz = P(Z!AUI
+
2: p[AHK(Ul)
Summarizing, for t !!(t)!
E
(1 - A)U2) = P[A(zIUl)
+ (1
- A)Hdu2)
+
u
(1 - A)(zl 2)]
+ ex].
Pp as above,
exp(-Retz) ::: C e exp(HK(t)
+ e!l!
- Retz) ::: C e exp«e
If we take e = a/2. C£ = C, we have lip !(t)e- t , dtl ::: Crrpe-(a/2)p -+ 0
as
p -+
00.
- ex)p).
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
63
By Cauchy's theorem, f 1(t)e- 1Z dt = 0, hence ~u, (z) = ~U2(Z) when z E YP Pu , n Pu2 • This shows that the functions ~u detennine a single-valued holomorphic function in the union of all the half-planes Pu , lu I = I, in other words, in K C • When we took u = I we observed that, for Re z > R, the Laplace transfonn C(f) of 1 coincides with 13; thus, we see that the function we have just obtained is precisely the analytic continuation of 13 from B(O, R)e into K C • We will also denote by 13 this extension. There is a unique T E JeI(Q) carried by K such that C(T) = B. Namely, let y be a Jordan curve in Q\K of index I with respect to K, then for h E Je(Q) we can define T by (T. h) :=
-1-.1 B(~)h(n 21f1
dr.
Y
hen
Let us compute J"(T)(z) for this analytic functional T. We set = ezl; in the definition of T and we see that we can replace y by the circle of center 0 and radius p > R because h is an entire function. We find J"(T)(z)
= _1_. 2m
r B(~)e/;z d~ = _1_. Jr (2: n~:~) el;z d;
Jy
I = '""' n!an . ~ 21f1
21f1
1
n~O
e/;Z --1
y
;n+
y
n?:O;
d; = '""' anz n = I(z). ~ n?:O
The third identity is valid by the unifonn convergence of the series representing 13 on y. Finally, the equation J"(Td = ;J(T2) for Tl, T2 E Je' (Q) implies that (T" ~n) = (h ~n) for every n :::: O. Namely, for z E C fixed, the series el;z = En?:o(zn~n In!) converges in JeI(Q), hence for T E JeI(Q) we have J"(T)(z) =
2:
n?: O
(T,
~n) zn.
n!
This shows that ;J(T) detennines {T, ;n} for all n :::: O. The density of Je(C) in Je(Q) implies that T1 = Tz. This concludes the proof of the theorem. 0
1.3.12. Definitions. (1) The function 13 introduced in the proof of Theorem 1.3.11 is called the
Borel transform of the function 1 and the Cauchy transform of the analytic functional T. (2) The representation of 1 = ;J(T) in the fonn
I(z) =
-1-.1 21f1
13(t)e IZ dt
y
is called the P61ya representation of f. (3) The function C(T) = 1fT is called the C-transform of T. (4) Let n be a convex open subset of
64
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
convex subset K of Q such that for every that f satisfies the estimate
£
> 0 there is a constant C" > 0 so
We can summarize the results of the previous theorem as follows. For Q an open convex set, the Fourier- Borel transform establishes a linear isomorphism
J:
Jf"(Q) ~ Exp(Q),
T t--+J(T).
The Borel transform is an isomorphism
B: Exp(Q)
f
~Jf'o(~n,
t--+B(f).
Finally, the C-transform is also an isomorphism
C: Jt'" (Q)
~Jf' o(QC),
T t--+C(T) =
'!rt.
The diagram below commutes
/ExP(Q) Jf"(Q)
B
~""O(Q')
and the map B- 1 is the P61ya representation. The functions HK appear naturally in the previous statements, we shall use the opportunity here to recall a few elementary properties of these functions. 1.3.13. Definition. If K is a nonempty compact set in C, the function H K defined by HK(u) = sup(Rezu) (u E C) :eK
is called the support function of the set K. If u = eirp , 0::: q; ::: 2rr, HK(u) is the maximum value in K of Re(zei'l') = (zle- irp ) = x cos q; - y sin q;, which is the projection of z on the ray Lu directed by it = e- irp • We have already used this fact above. It is an immediate consequence of the above definition that HK = Hcv(KJ' where, a usual, cv(K) is the convex hull of K. For that reason we will assume K is a convex compact set in what follows:
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
6S
1.3.14. Proposition. (1) If KI and K2 are two nonempty convex compact sets, then
where KI + K2 = K, K2 Eland
(2) If KI
= {z + w: Z E K1,w E K2} is also a convex compact set. = B(O, e), then KI + K2 = V(K, e) = {z E C: d(z, K) :5 HV(K.e)(Z)
= Hdz) + elzl.
(3) For any K, the function HK is a convex and homogeneous function of degree 1. That is,
HK()...u) = AHK(u) HK()...U (4) If K
+ (l -
)...)v) :5 )"'Hdu)
+ (1 -
for A> 0, A)HK(V)
for 0 < A < 1.
= {zo} = {xo + iyo} is a singleton, then HK(U) = HK(lulei'P) = lulexocosrp - Yo sinrp).
Hence,
if K
= {zo} + L, L convex compact and nonempty, Hdu) = Hdu)
+ lul(xocosrp -
Yosinrp).
= [-a, a] + i{O}, a> 0 (i.e., K is a symmetric segment of the real axis), then HK(u) = HK(lulei'P) = alul cosrp.
(5) If K
(6)
If K
= {OJ + i[ -a, a], a > 0, then HKCu) = HK(lulei'P) = alul sinrp.
(7) If K = B(O, R), then
HKCu) = Rlul. (8) If K = cv(KI U K 2 ), then
HK = max(HK!, HK2 ). Proof. Left as an exercise to the reader.
o
1.3.15. Definition. The (Lindelof) indicator function of an entire function of exponential type is the function
f
· log If(rz)1 hf () z = I Imsup r~x
r
(z E
C*).
The regularized indicator function hi is the function hi(z) = limsuphf(~)
(z E C).
{ ..... z
We do not define hf (0) directly due to the possibility that
f (0)
= O.
66
I.
Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and AnalytIc Functionals
1.3.16. Proposition. (I)
Let f1'
h be two entire functions of exponential type, then h/ll2 :::: h/l + hl2' h/l +12 :::: max(h I" hl2),
(2) If fez) = e(a+ib):, a, b
E
JR, then
hf(z) = Izl(acos
If f is an entire function of exponential type, then hrCtz) for every z
E
= thr(z)
and
hj(tz) = th'f(z)
C*, t > O. Moreover, hj(O) = O.
o
Proof. Left as an exercise to the reader.
1.3.17. Proposition. Let f be an entire function of exponential type, which is not identically zero. The function hI, defined at z = 0 by h f (0) = 0, is subharmonic and continuous in Co In particular, hf = hj.
Proof. It is clear that if f == 0, then hf(z) == -00. Let us show first that hj is subharmonic in the extended sense (i.e., it might be a priori == -(0). Since there are constants A, B > 0 such that log If(z)1 ::: Bizi + A, we have the right to apply the following Fatou's Lemma 1.3.18 to the family of subharmonic functions I
g,(z) = -log If(r(w + z»I, r r > 0, WECo From the inequality I -log If(rw)1 ::: r
- I2 7r P
h
I -log If(r(w
B(O,p) r
+ u»1 dm(u),
one obtains . I hf(w) = lim sup -log If(rw)1 r_oc r :::: - I2
7rp
= ::::
h .
I lim sup -log If(r(w
Beo.p) r-oc
r
r
hl(W
+ u) dm(u)
~ ~
hj(w
+ u) dm(u).
~ 7r P
j B
7rp Jaeo.PI
+ u»1 dm(u)
The above steps are justified applying twice the following variant of Fatou's lemma:
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
67
1.3.18. Lemma. If (X, r, /-L) is a measure space with a a-finite measure /-L ::: 0, (gr )rE[O.+oo[ is a family of integrable functions uniformly bounded above, then limsup { grd/-L S { (lim supgr) d/-L.
r~oo
Jx
Jx
r--+oo
Proof of Lemma 1.3.18. It is a consequence of the usual Fatou's lemma [Rud2] once one observes that if r E [n, n + 1[, then
sup fs S sup fs S sup fs, s:::n
s:::II+1
hence
o Now we use that for each w E C we have hi (w) = lim SUpj ..... oo h f (w + f;j) for a sequence f;j ~ 0, which depends on w. Then, from the inequality preceding Lemma 1.3.18, we have hj(w)
= lim sup hf(w + {j) S oo j .....
h .
lim sup ~ ~ hj(w j ..... co rrp JiJ(o.P)
+ {j + u)dm(u)
1 S-2 _ hmsuphj(w+f;j+u)dm(u) rrp B(O.p) j ..... oo
S
~ ~
rrp iB(o.p)
hj(w
+ u)dm(u).
The last inequality is due to the upper semicontinuity of hj. It follows that hi is subharmonic in the extended sense. Now we shall try to prove that hf 1= - 00 and that it is a continuous function in C*. It will follow that hf = hi in C*, hence hf will be subharmonic in C*. Since both functions are homogeneous it is enough to consider hf restricted to the unit circle. 1.3.19. Lemma. Let 8 1, 82 be two real numbers such that 0 < 82 - 81 < rr. Assume hf(e ifil ) S hi and hf(ei~) S h2 and let g(8) :=
+ h2 sin(8 - 81) . sin(82 - 8 1)
hi sin(82 - 8)
Then
Since g is the only function of the form a cos 8 - b sin 8 which takes the values hj at 8j , this lemma says that there is a unique exponential fo(z) = exp«a + ib)z) such that hfo(e ifi,) = h j and hf(e ifi ) S hfo(e ifi ) for 81 S 8 S 8 1• Proof of Lemma 1.3.19. Let 8 > 0 and g8 (8) = a8 cos 8 - b6 sin 8 be the unique sinusoidal of the form a cos 0 - b sin 8 taking the values hj + 8 at OJ. Let h(z)
= f(z)e-(a,+ib,)z.
68
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and AnalytIc FunctlOnals
=
Then Ih(z)1 = I/(z)le-R,(O)IZI, z Izle io , is bounded in the rays LJ, L2, where iOj L j = {se : s :::: OJ. Since 0 < (h - 8, < Jr, we conclude from the PhragmenLindeiofprinciple (see [BO, §4.9.37]) that 1161 is bounded by a positive constant M in the sector 8, :s 8 :s 82. Therefore, I/(z)1 :s M exp(go(8)lzl) and hf(e iO ) :s go(8). Passing to the limit ~ .... 0 we obtain the lemma. 0
=
Let us remark that if hf(e i61 ) = -00 and hf(e ifh ) -00, the above lemma implies that hf(e i !!) = -00 for 8, :s 8 :s 82. It is enough to take h, = h2 = -M, for some large M > 0, and let M .... 00.
1.3.20. Lemma. Let 8\ :s e2 :s 83 be such that 0 < 83 - 8\ < Jr. Let g(8) = acos8-bsin8 be such thai hf(eie:)~g(€h) uncl hf(ei~)?::.g(02)' then hf(e i03 ) :::: g(03).
Proof of Lemma 1.3.20. Let us assume there is ~ > 0 such that
hf(e i63 )
:s
g(83) - 8. Define the auxiliary sinusoidal go (e)
=
sin(8 - 0\) II )' sm 03 - 0\
g(O) - 8 . (ll
=
Then go(O\) g(8d, go(02) < g(e2), and go(e3) theses and Lemma 1.3.19 we conclude that '0
hf(e' 2)
= g(e3) -
8. From the hypo-
:s go«(h) < g(e2),
which is impossible. Therefore h f (e i !!3) :::: g«(h). The same proof shows that if we had hf(ei~) :::: g(02) and hf(e i !!3) the conclusion would be hf(e iO, ) :::: g(8d.
:s g(03), 0
We are now ready to conclude the proof of Proposition 1.3.17. First, we observe that the proof of Lemma 1.3.19 shows that if hf == -00, then I is bounded, hence a constant function, and since hf == -00, 1==0. Therefore, we have h f ¢ -00. In this case, Lemma 1.3.20 shows that hf(e i !!) is never -00. In fact, choose any value O2 such that hf(ei~) '# -00. Choose an angle e\ arbitrarily close to e2 , 0\ < O2 • Then, for any (h such that 83 < 0, + Jr we have h f (e i !!3) > -00, since we can find a sinusoidal g with g(82) = hf(ei~) and g(e,):::: hf(ei!!,), even if hf(ei!!,) = -00. This procedure covers an interval of length almost equal to Jr. Repeating it twice, we see that hf(e i !!) > -oc everywhere. Now that we know that hf(e i !!) is never -00, we can prove it is a continuous function. Let us do it for the argument 0 = e2. Choose any two values e\, e3 such that 8\ < 82 < 83, 83 - 8, < Jr. Define the two auxiliary sinusoidals g'2 and g23 by the conditions g'2(B,)
and
= hf(ei!!,),
g'2(B2)
= hf(eifh ),
69
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
Consider ()
E
]82 , 8J [, we have '0
gd8) ::: hf(e' ) ::: g2J«(}).
The first inequality is a consequence of Lemma 1.3.20, the second of Lemma 1.3.19. Since the sinusoidals are continuous and gI2(82) = gn(82) = hf(e ilh ) we obtain In the interval ]81, 82 [ we have '0
g23«(}) ::: hf(e' ) ::: gI2«(})·
The second inequality is a consequence of Lemma 1.3.20, the first is a consequence of the remark after the proof of Lemma 1.3.20. The continuity of hf (e iO ) and hence of hj(z), Z E C* is now clear. As pointed out above, this implies that hf coincides with hj, hence it is subharrnonic in C*. The upper semicontinuity of hj at Z = 0, and the homogeneity, now let us conclude that hj(O) = 0. We define hf(O) to keep it subharrnonic, continuous, and homogeneous of degree 1 everywhere. 0
=
°
The following provides a different, more geometric, proof of Proposition 1.3.17:
=
~(T) be an entire function of exponential type which is the F ourier-Borel transform of an analytic functional T whose convex support is the compact convex set K. We have then
1.3.21. Theorem. Let f
Hde iB ) = hf(e iO ),
8::: () ::: 2rr.
°
In particular, it follows that iff =I- (and hence T =I- 0) hf is continuous and subharmonic since it is a convex function.
Proof. Let B be the Borel transform of f. It is convergent in each half-plane of the form Re(ze iO ) > h f (e iO ), since the integral B(z) =
1
f(t)e-': dt
is absolutely and uniformly convergent for Re(ze iO ) ~ hf(eiB ) + e, e > 0, where L {se iB : s ~ OJ. Since the convex support of T is the smallest compact convex region on whose complement B is holomorphic, it follows that Hde ifJ ) ::: hf(e iO ). On the other hand, let e > 0 and use the P6lya representation
=
f(z) =
-1-.1 2rrl
B(t)e': dr,
y
with y a rectifiable Jordan curve such that K ~ int y ~ V(K, e). Then 1 e(y) (max IB(t)I) exp (max r Re(teiIJ If(reifJ)1 ::: -2 rr lEy lEy
»)
68
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Then IIo(z)1 = If(z)le- K6 (8)I ZI, z = Izle iO , is bounded in the rays L I, L 2, where L j = {seil!;: s :::: OJ. Since 0 < (}2 - (}I < Jr, we conclude from the PhragmenLindelof principle (see [BG, §4.9.37]) that 110 I is bounded by a positive constant M in the sector (}I ~ () ~ (}2. Therefore, If(z)1 ~ M exp(g~«(})lzl) and hf (e i8 ) ~ g6 (0). Passing to the limit ~ ~ 0 we obtain the lemma. 0
=
=
Let us remark that if hf(e i81 ) -00 and hf(e i82 ) -00, the above lemma iO -00 for (}I ~ () ~ (}2. It is enough to take hi = h2 = - M, implies that hf (e ) for some large M > 0, and let M ~ 00.
=
1.3.20. Lemma. Let (}I ~ (}2 ~ (}3 be such that 0 < (}3 - (}I < Jr. Let g(O) = acos&-bsine be such that hf(eie:):::g{fJd and hf(ei~)~g(B2)' then hf(e i03 ) :::: g«(}3).
Proof of Lemma 1.3.20. Let us assume there is ~ > 0 such that hf (e i03 ) ~ g«(}3) - D. Define the auxiliary sinusoidal
sin«(} - (}I)
g&«(}) = g«(}) - ~ .
sm
«()3 - () I ) .
Then g&«(}d = g«(}d, g6«(}2) < g«(}2), and g8«(}3) = g«(}3) - D. From the hypotheses and Lemma 1.3.19 we conclude that hf(e ilh ) ~ g8«(}2) < g«(}2),
which is impossible. Therefore hf(e i03 ) :::: g«(}3). The same proof shows that if we had hf(e ilh ) ::=: g«(}2) and h f (e i03 ) ~ g«(}3), the conclusion would be hf(e iOI ) :::: g(OI). 0 We are now ready to conclude the proof of Proposition 1.3.17. First, we observe that the proof of Lemma 1.3.19 shows that if hf == -00, then f is bounded, hence a constant function, and since hf == -00, f == O. Therefore, we have hf ¢ -00. In this case, Lemma 1.3.20 shows that hf(e iO ) is never -00. In fact, choose any value (}2 such that hf(e ifh ) :f. -00. Choose an angle (}) arbitrarily close to fh, (}I < (}2. Then, for any 03 such that 03 < 01 + Jr we have h r (e i83 ) > -00, since we can find a sinusoidal g with g«(}2) hr(e i02 ) and g«(}I)::=: hf(e iO, ), even if hf(e iOI ) = -00. This procedure covers an interval of length almost equal to Jr. Repeating it twice, we see that hf(ei(i) > -oc everywhere. Now that we know that hj(e iB ) is never -00, we can prove it is a continuous function. Let us do it for the argument () = O2 . Choose any two values ()], (}3 such that ()) < (}2 < (}3, (}3 - (}I < Jr. Define the two auxiliary sinusoidals gl2 and g23 by the conditions
=
and
69
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
Consider () E ](}2, (}3[, we have '0
gl2«(}) ::: hr(e' ) ::: 823 «(}).
The first inequality is a consequence of Lemma 1.3.20, the second of Lemma 1.3.19. Since the sinusoidals are continuous and gI2«(}2) = 823«(}2) = hr(e ilh ) we obtain In the interval
WI, (}z [
we have '0
g23«(}) ::: hr(e' ) ::: 812«(}).
The second inequality is a consequence of Lemma 1.3.20, the first is a consequence of the remark after the proof of Lemma 1.3.20. The continuity of hf (e i8 ) and hence of hj(z), Z E C* is now clear. As pointed out above, this implies that hj coincides with hj, hence it is subharmonic in C*. The upper semicontinuity of hj at z = 0, and the homogeneity, now let us conclude that hj(O) = O. We define hr (0) = 0 to keep it subharmonic, continuous, and homogeneous of degree 1 everywhere. 0 The following provides a different. more geometric. proof of Proposition 1.3.17: 1.3.21. Theorem. Let f = ~(T) be an entire function of exponential type which is the Fourier-Borel transform of an analytic functional T whose convex support is the compact convex set K. We have then
Hde i9 ) = hr(e i8 ),
() ::: () :::
In particular, it follows that if f =1= 0 (and hence T subharmonic since it is a convex function.
2Jl'.
=1=
0) hj is continuous and
Proof. Let B be the Borel transform of f. It is convergent in each half-plane of the form Re(ze i8 ) > hr (e i8 ), since the integral B(z) =
1
f(t)e-': dt
is absolutely and uniformly convergent for Re(zei9) ~ hr (e i9 ) + e, e > 0, where L = {se i9 : s ~ OJ. Since the convex support of T is the smallest compact convex region on whose complement B is holomorphic, it follows that HK(e iIJ ) ::: h,(ei8 ). On the other hand, let e > 0 and use the P61ya representation f(z) =
-1-.1 2Jl'1
B(t)e': dt,
y
with y a rectifiable Jordan curve such that K ~ int y ~ V(K, e). Then 1 l(y) (max1B(t)I) exp (maxrRe(te i9 If(re i9 )1::: -2 Jl'
lEy
lEy
»)
70
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functional,
This clearly implies hl(e ifJ )::: HK(e ifJ ) +e,
and since e > 0 was arbitrary, we have HK(e ill )
= hI (e ill ).
o
We are now going to show that any function h subharmonic in C and homogeneous of degree I is, in fact, the Lindelof indicator function of some entire function f of exponential type, that is, h = hi' It is clear that such f is not unique. Theorem 1.3.21 shows that we need the following lemma if we are going to succeed in proving LhaL It = hi for some f:
1.3.22. Lemma. Any function in C which is subharmonic and homogeneous of degree 1 is a convex function. Proof. Convexity is a local property and hence, up to a possible rotation, we can restrict ourselves to a neighborhood of the positive real axis. The convexity in a neighborhood of z = 0 will follow by the homogeneity, as well as the fact that h(O) = O. Let now 0 < ex < n12, -ex < 8, < 83 < ex, g(8) = acos8 - bsin8 be a sinusoidal function such that h(e ifJ, )::: g(8,) and h(ei!h) ::: g(83). Suppose there is a value 80 E ]/9I. 83[ such that g(80) < h(e iIlO ). Let g~ be the sinusoidal defined by g~(8,) = g(8,) + 8, g~(82) = g(82) + 8. Let 80 = inf{8 > 0: h(e i8 ) g8(8) ::: 0 whenever 8, ::: 8 ::: 83}. The existence of 80 as above shows that 80 > 0 and the infimum is achieved. On the other hand, the upper semicontinuity of h implies that the set I := {8 E [8,,83], h(e ill ) = g 80(8)} is not empty. Again by the upper semicontinuity of h, 82 := inf{8: 8 E /} E ]/9" 83 [ and h(ei~) = goo (82 ). Let A E C be such that if G(z) = Az then Re G(re ill ) = rg Oo (8). Choose o < p < I, sufficiently small so that iJ (eil!,., p) lies in the angular region 8, ::: Arg z ::: 83. The homogeneity of h implies that h(z) ::: Re G(z),
We also have h(ei~) = ReG(e iIl2 ) and h(z) < Re G(z), when z E 8B(e i8" p), 81 ::: Arg z < 82. This contradicts the mean-value property for the subharmonic function h - Re G. Therefore, we can conclude that
We claim that this inequality shows that h is convex. First, we observe that Lemma \.3.20 and its consequences can now be applied to h in place of hi, hence h(e ill ) > -00 everywhere. Now let g be a sinusoidal chosen so that g(8,) = h(e ifJ, ) and g(83) = h(e ill ,). Let z" =3 be any two points with arg z, = OI. arg Z3 = 03 and z = AZ, + (l - A)z3. 0 < A < 1. Then 0 = argz E [0,,831and h(z) = Izlh(e ill )::: Izlg(O) = Izl(acosO -bsin8)
71
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
= Re«a + ib)z) = ARe«a + ib)z,) + (1 = AlzIlg(Od + (1 - A)l z3Ig(03) = AlzIlh(e i61 ) = )'h(z,)
+ (l
A) Re«a
+ ib)z3)
+ (1- A)l z3Ih(e ill,) - )')h(Z3).
o
This concludes the proof of Lemma 1.3.22.
1.3.23. Proposition. Let h be a subharmonic function in C which is homogeneous of degree 1. There is an entire function f of exponential type such that hf =
f·
Proof. Let K = {w E C: Re z w ::::: h (z) for every z E q. Since h is convex by Lemma 1.3.22, we conclude that K is a compact convex set such that HK = h. The set S2\K is biholomorphic to the unit disk, this allows us to find a function B holomorphic in C\K, 8(00) = 0, and such that every point of aK is a singular point of 8. If we choose f to be the Borel transform of 8, then we 0 have hf = H K = h.
Let us consider a few special cases of compact convex carriers K. The first special case occurs when K = {OJ.
1.3.24. Definition. A nonzero entire function f is said to be of exponential type zero (or infraexponential type) if f is a function of exponential type and hf =0. If f is an entire function of infraexponential type and T E Jf' (C) is the analytic functional such that f = ~(T), then T is carried by K = {OJ. Therefore, T is a continuous linear functional on any of the spaces Jf(Q) for Q an open subset of C containing zero. Recall that the space 0 of germs of holomorphic functions at the origin can be described as 0= nJf(Q), OEn
and Q an open subset of C, 0 E Q. The natural topology of 0 is that of a projective limit of the Frechet spaces Jf(Q) (see [Hor], [Schae]). The dual space is then precisely the collection of analytic functionals carried by K = (OJ. Given cp E 0,
cp(~) =
L an~n = L n2:0
cpt: ~O) sn ,
n2:0
then (T,cp) = Lan(T,sn). n?;O
72
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
On the other hand, as we have seen earlier,
so that
(T, l;n) = Inn!. Hence
(T,rp)
= Ln! n;::O
rp(n) (0) In-,n.
= Llnrp(n)(o). n;::O
That is, we can associate to T the infinite-order differentilll operator
I(m = L
d
D=dz'
InDn,
n;::O
where
I(D)rp(l;) := L
In Dnrp(l;)
n::;:O
will define a holomorphic function in Q if rp
(T, rp)
E Jf(Q).
In this notation
= I(D)rp(O).
Consider now the case where K = [a, b], -00 < a < b < 00, is an interval of the real axis. Any analytic functional T carried by K will have as a Fourier- Borel transform I = ~(T) an entire function of exponential type such that hi = h K" for some KI = [a" bd, a ~ al ~ b l ~ b. That is, hi (e ilJ ) = max{al cos e, b l cos e}.
Moreover, the function -(lj2i)T is holomorphic in C\K and represents a hyperfunction S with compact support, supp S ~ K. Proposition 1.2.21 indicates that S should be identified to the analytic functional T, in fact, we have already done so in Proposition 1.2.22, when the analytic functional T is induced by a distribution with compact support in K. Note that supp T in the sense of hyperfunctions coincides exactly with the smallest holomorphically convex carrier K(T) of T. This follows from Theorem 1.3.5 and the observation that any compact subset of R is holomorphically convex. In other words, let K be the compact subset of R and let the space Jf(K) of functions holomorphic in a neighborhood of K be considered with the projective limit topology induced by the identity Jf(K) =
n
Jf(Q).
K<;n
where 1'2 runs over all open sets (or all Runge open sets) containing K. Then any element T E Jf'(K) is an analytic functional which is carried by K and it can be represented. in the sense of hyperfunctions. as boundary values of a
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
73
function holomorphic in 1(:*, more precisely in C\K. Namely,
I T = - 2ib(T). A
The reader should also observe that when K £ JR, JIf(K) coincides with the space A(K) of real analytic functions in a real neighborhood of K and we recall from the previous section that the hyperfunctions with support in K are a module over A(K). This is clear, since if T E JIf'(K), f{J E JIf(K), f{JT makes sense in JIf'(K). Later in this chapter we will discuss a similar situation for analytic functionals on the unit circle. It is clear that we need some precision about the properties of projective limits, inductive limits, and their duals. In particular, to be able to study the topological properties of Exp(Q), JIf'(Q), Jlfij(QC), etc. For this reason the following section will be an overview of the functional analysis tools we use in the remainder of the book. ExERCISES
l. Let a E 8~n)
1.3. Q
and let Q be an open set in C. Show that the distribution T
= L:=I cn8~n),
= (an /ozn)8a can be represented by a measure when considered as an analytic func-
tional in n. Give examples of non trivial measures that represent the zero analytic functional. 2. Show that if T is an analytic functional so that there is A ~ 0 with the property that = O(exp(AI Re zl + elzl», then T is carried by a compact subset of IJt Find a function F holomorphic in C\([-A. A] + itO)) such that T = b(F) in the sense of hyperfunctions.
if(T)(z)
3. Verify that C
= B . if as stated after Definition
1.3.12.
4. Find the analytic functional T whose Fourier-Borel transform is fez) How about S such that if(S)(z) = f(JZ).
= (sinhz)/z.
5. Let T be an analytic functional with smallest holomorphically convex carrier K and let n be a Runge open set, KEn, f E JIf(n). Define a function g by g(z) :=
(T~.
fez
+ ~»).
Show that g is a holomorphic function in a neighborhood of the origin. Let {z E C: z + K £; n}, show that Q' is open and g E JIf(Q'). 6. Let K be a compact convex subset of C, the following property: 3C > 0
if and only if there is h
k # 0. Show that
T
E
n' =
JIf'(K) satisfies
such that VIE JIf(C): I(T. f)1 ~ CllfIIL2IK)' E
(T. f)
L 2(K) so that
=
l
f(z)h(z)dm(z)
(f E JIf(K».
. 7. Let P(D) = LO,,;},,;n ajD} be a differential operator with constant coefficients and Its symbol P'(~) = LO";j,,;n(-l)Jaj~J, a nonzero polynomial of degree n. Show that if
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
74
T is an analytic functional then ~(P(D)T)(l;)
r(~ )~(T)(~).
=
Conclude that P(D): ;t"'(C) --. ;t"'(C) in injective. 8. Let T be an analytic functional in C, show that the Fourier-Borel transform of the product zT is given by
~(zT)(n = ~(~(T)(~» = D~(T)(n d~
Use this to show that the kernel of the multiplication map ;t"'(C) --. ;t"'(C) given by T ~ zT is the vector space c8 0, c E C. 9. Let T E ;t"'(C). Show that the following four conditions are equivalent: (i) T can be represented by a distribution S E V' (C) with support in a finite number of points aI, ... ,an E C of the form S = Lk.l Ak.l8~) (the sum is necessarily finite).
(ii)
t
is a rational function, zero at infinity, and with poles contained in the set
{al,'" ,an}
(iii)
~(T)
is an exponential polynomial of the form
L
~(T)(O;;:::
Pk(Oeat~,
1::J~n
Pk polynomials. (iv) There is a nonzero polynomial P
E C[~]
such that the product P . T
= O.
10. In this exercise, for P E C[z] we shall denote by P* the polynomial p*(z) := P(Z). For two nonzero polynomials P, Q we shall study the bijectivity of the operator Q(D)P: ;t"(C) --. ;t"(C) given by Q(D)P(f) := Q(D)(Pf), PI being the ordinary multiplication of functions, 1m P denotes the image of the multiplication operator. to}. (a) Show that Q(D)P is injective if and only if 1m P n ker Q(D) (b) Show that Q(D)P is surjective if and only if ;t"(C) = 1m P + ker Q(D). (Hint: Recall Q(D) is surjective.) (c) Show that the condition deg P deg Q is necessary for the operator Q(D)P to be bijective. Is the converse true? (d) Consider the Fock space Az(C) of all functions
=
=
IE ;t"(C)
so that for
I,
g
E A 2 (C)
n
Z
I{1 2
dm) ,
we have
(fIg)
=..!.. 7r
r I(~ )g(~)e-I{12 dm(~).
lc
Show that if IE A2 (C) and P*(D)P(f) (r(D)P/lf)
;e-
L (C,
= 1IP/li z =..!.. 7r
E
A2 (C) also, then
rIP(D)I(~)lze-d
lc
dm(O-
Conclude that r(D)p is injective in Az(C). "(e) Show that P"(D)P is bijective in Jf'(C), if and only if Exp(C)
=r
Exp(C)
e (ker P(D) n Exp(C».
1.3. Analytic Functionals and Entire Functions of Exponential Type
75
(This part of the exercise requires the use of duality and some properties that appear in the next section.) The bijectivity of P'(D)P in Jt'(IC) is called the Fischer problem, it can be shown to be true. The corresponding problem in two or more variables has not yet been solved (see [NS1, [MerSl, [MerYl). '11. (a) Let T E Jt" (IC) be carried by 8(0, R), and define T. E Jt" (IC) by
T.:=
L (-l)j (T,.~j) ~(j),
~
J.
O:sj:s.
= ~o, n:::: O.
Show that T. -+ T weakly in JIt"(8(O, R». That is, for every lim (Tn. f)
n-oo
I
E Jt'(8(O, R», one has
= (T, f).
In what follows. K = K(T) and S is an analytic functional carried by L ~ aB(O, R). (b) Show that if K ~ B(O. R)\L, then ST is a well-defined analytic functional carried by K. Define <1>: Jt"(8(0. R» -+ Jt"(IC) as follows. Let Tn be defined as In part (a), then Dom((T) := Iimn -+ oo ST. if T E Dom(': JIt'(IC) -+ Jt'(B(O, R», by Dom(t) := (h E Jt'(IC): T 1-+ (T)(h) is continuous on Dom((T)(h). Show <1>' is well defined. (0 If Dom(t) =f. {OJ, show that for any h E Dom(')\{O} one has (T. '(h) - Sh)
= 0,
"IT
E
Jt"(B(O, R».
Conclude that S = '(h)/h in a neighborhood of B(O. R). Show that S is a rational function vanishing at infinity. (g) Conversely, show that if S is a rational function vanishing at 00, then Dom(t) =f. (O). (h) Show that Dom(t) =f. (O). if and only if ~(S) is an exponential polynomial with frequencies in L, i.e .•
~(S)(~)
=
L
Pk(~)ea.{,
I~j~m
12. Let I be holomorphic in the first quadrant, n = (z: Re z > 0 and 1m z > 0), COntinuous in the closure and of exponential type. I/(z)1 :::: BoeB, 1:1 for ZEn. Assume further that for some constants c :::: 0, M :::: 0, A :::: 0 one has I/(iy)1 :::: Ae C ) I/(x)1 :::: M
(for y :::: 0). (for
x:::: 0).
Show that
I/(x + iy)1 :::: max(A, M)e'·', for all x :::: 0, y :::: O. (Consider the auxiliary function g(z) := f(z)e i" , and use the Phragmen - Lindelof principle.)
76
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Funcllonals
in
13. Let I be holomorphic in H (z: 1m z > OJ, continuous in fl. of exponential type fl. and such that: (i) hf < 00; and (ii) I/(x)1 s M for all x E lIt Show that
=
II(x
+ iy)1
~
M exp(hf(i)y),
for all x E JR, y ::: O.
n.
14. Let Q be the first quadrant as in Exercise 12, I of exponential type in I E n C(n), and such that: (i) hf(i) < 00; and (ii) K := IimsuPH+OC I/(x)1 < 00. Prove that lim sup I/(x + iy)1 ~ K exp(hf(i)y),
Je(Q)
for 0 < y < 00. (Start by showing that for every e > 0 there is At > 0 such that At exp«hf(i) + ely). For 8 > 0, Xo I, and A> 0, consider
»
II
(z) I ~
+ A)l/(z + xo) exp(i(hf(i) + e)z), where 8> 0 and Xo » I are chosen so that I/(x)1 ~ K + 8 for x::: Xo. First, prove that limY_Hex:> I(xo + iy) exp(i(hf(i) + c)(iy» = 0 and show that for A conveniently chosen one has Ig(iy)1 ~ K + 8. Hence, I/(z + xo)1 ~ [Iz + ).lllzl](K + 8)e(h/(i)+ t1 v. for x ~ 0, g(z) := [zl(z
y ::: 0.) 15. Use the previous exercise to show that in the case K lim I(x
x_+x
= O. then
+ iy) = 0
uniformly for y in any compact subset of ]0, 00[. (Use Montel's theorem.) *16. The object of this exercise is the following. Let Q be a domain in C, h E Je(Q)\{O). We want to characterize those R E Je'(Q) such that the product hR O. (a) Recall E(C) is the Frechet space of COO functions in the plane. We let (r, (J) represent the usual polar coordinates about z O. Let E be the subspace of those I E E(C) such that 1(0) (aJ/ar)(O) O. Show that E is closed. (b) Show that the map E(C) -+ E given by I ~ r2 I is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces. Fix a radial function X E 'D(C) such that X == 1 in a neighborhood of the origin. Show that every I E f(C) can be written in a unique way as
=
=
=
=
1= r2g + (1(0) +
~~ (o)r) x,
f ~ g continuous. (c) Show that for any S E f'(C), the equation r2T = S has a solution T E E'(C). (d) For S E E'(C), the equation zT = S has a solution T in E'(C). (e) Show that parts (c) and (d) hold when E'(C) is replaced by 'D'(C) throughout. (f) Let Q be a domain in C. h E Je(r2)\{O}. Show that the equation hT S has a solution T E E'(n). Prove the same statement in 'D'(n). (g) Prove that the sequence g
E f(C), and
=
i
a/a,
0-+ Je(r2) -+ Em) ---+ E(n) -+ 0 and its transpose
0-+ E'(n) ~ E'en)":' -'f'(n) -+ 0
are exact. (Here i is the canonical injection and r the restriction map. See [BG. §3.6].) (h) Let R E Je'(Q) be such that hR = 0, with h as in part (t). Choose T E E'(n) such that reT) = Rand S E E'(n) such that as/ai = hT. Further, choose SI E E'(Q) such
1.4. Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis
77
that hS I = S. Prove that S2 := T - asi/az has compact support contained in the set of zeros of h and. moreover. I'(S2) = R. (i) Show that for the analytic functional R from part (h). its Cauchy transform R is a rational function. What can you say about R?
1.4. Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis In this section we group together some basic results from functional analysis concerning Frechet spaces and their duals, which we will use throughout this book. We illustrate them by some elementary applications to topological vector spaces of holomorphic functions. The reader will find the proofs and additional material in [Hor], [Ja], [Schae]. An LF-space is a strict inductive limit of an increasing sequence (Enk:1 of Frechet spaces, such that the topology of En is that induced by En+ l • An £3'-space is an inductive limit of a sequence of Frechet spaces. An ultrabornological space is an inductive limit of a family of Frechet spaces (not necessarily countable).
1.4.1. Proposition. Let E and F be two Hausdorff locally convex topological vector spaces (Hausdorff LCTVS).lf the topology of E is weaker than a topology of space £3' and if F is ultrabornological. then every continuous surjective linear map of E onto F is open. 1.4.2. Proposition. Let E and F be two Hausdorff LCTVS. If E is ultrabornological and the topology of F is weaker than a topology of space £3', then the necessary and sufficient condition for a linear map E ~ F to be continuous is to have a closed graph.
1.4.3. Proposition. Let E be a complex vector space of complex valuedfunctions on a set X. There is at most one topology on E of space £3' which is stronger than the topology of pointwise convergence. Given a complex vector space E and a seminonn p on E we denote by the Banach space which is the completion of the quotient E /ker p, ker p = (x E E: p(x) = OJ, ker p its closure. If U is a convex balanced neighborhood of 0 in a LCTVS E, we denote by Pu the gauge of U. If U and V are two such neighborhoods of 0 such that V s.; U (hence p u :::: p v, ker p v s.; ker p u ) one can consider the linear map EPI ~ EPc defined by passing to the quotients the identity map.
Ep
1.4.4. Definitions. (I) A Hausdorff LCTVS E is said to be a Schwartz space if for every convex balanced neighborhood U of 0, there is another convex balanced neighborhood V of 0 such that V s.; U and the map Epv ~ Epu is compact.
78
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
(2) An FS space is a Fn!chet space which is also a Schwartz space. (3) A DFS space is a LCTVS, which is the strong dual of an FS space.
One can prove that any FS or DFS space is reflexive, and that the strong dual of a DFS space is an FS space. In particular, a DFS space is an CJ space.
1.4.5. Proposition. (I) If E is a Schwartz space and F is a closed subspace of E, then F and E / F
are Schwart: spaces. (2) A product oj Schwan: spaces is a Schwartz space. (3) A countable inductive limit of Schwartz spaces is a Schwartz space.
1.4.6. Definition. A continuous linear map u: E ~ F between LCTVS is said to be a homomorphism if the continuous linear map ii: E / ker u ~ 1m u is an isomorphism of LCTVS. A weak homomorphism means that the spaces are endowed with the weak topology induced by their duals. We now state a very useful proposition.
1.4.7. Proposition. Let E and F be two Frichet spaces, u: E linear map. The following properties are equivalent:
~
F a continuous
(1) u is a homomorphism.
(2) u is a weak homomorphism. (3) u has a closed image. (4) u has weakly closed image.
(5) The transpose IU has a weakly closed image. (6) tu is a weak homomorphism.
[fin addition we assume E is reflexive. these six statements are equivalent to: (7) tu has a strongly closed image. If we also assume that E and Fare FS spaces. then the seven preceding statements are equivalent to: (8) tu is a strong homomorphism.
1.4.8. Proposition. (I) (2)
Let Un: En~! ~ E" be a sequence of compact linear maps between Frechet spaces. The projective limit of the sequence (En)n"!! is an FS space. Let U,,: En ~ En-t-! be a sequence of compact linear maps between Frechet spaces. The inductive limit of the sequence (En)n"!! is a DFS space.
1.4.9. Proposition. The strong dual of a complete Schwartz space is ultraborn%gic.
1.4. Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis
79
1.4.10. Proposition. Let E be an FS space or a DFS space and let F be a closed subspace of E. (a) E'I FJ., equipped with the quotient topology of the strong topology of E, is isomorphic to the strong dual of F. (b) Flo, equipped with the strong topology f3(FJ., ElF) is the strong dual of EI F with the quotient topology. (f3(FJ., EI F) topologogy induced by f3(E', E).)
=
The following two propositions constitute the duality principle that underlies the relation between Hannonic Analysis and Complex Analysis: 1.4.11. Proposition. If E and F are two Frechet spaces and u: E ~ F is a continuous linear map, then the following three properties are equivalent: (1) u is surjective.
(2)
IU
is injective with weakly closed image.
(3) Im(u) is a set o/the second category of Baire.
If, moreover,
IU
is surjective, then u is injective.
1.4.12. Proposition. Let E and F be two FS spaces or two DFS spaces. In order that a continuous linear map u: E ~ F be an isomorphism of E onto 1m u, it is necessary and sufficient that IU: F' ~ E' be surjective. The map tu is surjective if and only if u is injective and has a closed image. To verify that 1m u is closed it is enough to show it is sequentially closed.
It is clear that the following result must be well-known but we have been unable to find an explicit proof for it. The proof below was kindly provided by Marcel Grange (Univ. Borde~ux I). 1.4.13. Proposition. Let E
= lim En
be an inductive limit of a sequence of
-->
Banach spaces En defined by the continuous linear maps u,,: En ~ E n+ l • For every subspace F of E, its closure coincides with its sequential closure.
Proof. Let us denote by Vn the canonical maps Vn: En ~ E. Let F be a subspace of E. Denote by FI the set of elements x E E such that there is an integer n I ::: I and a sequence (Xj)j::1 in En, with vnl(Xj) E F, (Xj)j ::: 1 converging in En, to a point x such that vn , (x) = x. Clearly FI S; F. That is, FI is precisely the set of sequential limits of F. Let us assume there is an x E F\ Fl' If we consider the set (F - x) I defined in a similar way with respect to the affine subspace F - x. we have (F - .r) I = FI - x and 0 ¢ (F - x) I. Let P = E\(F - x). We claim that P is bornivorous, i.e., for every n ::: 1 there is a An > 0 such that if y E En has norm less or equal to 1 in Ell' then vn(y) E AnP.
80
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
If the claim were not true, there would be no ::: I and a sequence (Ym)m~l of points in the unit ball of En" such that vnu (Ym 1m) f/. P. This means that vn,,(Ymlm) E F - x. Hence, there are fm E F such that fm = x + v",,(Ymlm). Let nl ::: no and i E En, be such that vn, (i) = x. If we let Xm = i + Vn,-lo" 'ovno(Ymlm) E En,. then Xm ~ i in En, and vn,(xm) fm E F. Since x f/. Fl. we have a contradiction. therefore P is bornivorous. The definition of bornivorous ensures that V;; I (P) is a neighborhood of 0 in En for any n ::: l. (In fact. it contains the ball of radius I I An.) This means that P is a neighborhood of 0 in the inductive limit E. Since x E F. we must have F n (x + P) =1= 0. Let Y E F n (x + P). then Y - x E F - x. and also Y - x E P. This is a clear contradiction with the definition of P. It follows that F Fl. which is what we wanted to prove ail along. o
=
=
We proceed to apply some of these concepts to the spaces of holomorphic functions.
1.4.14. Proposition. Let Q be an open subset of C. The space Jt"(Q) of all holomorphic functions in Q. considered with the topology of uniform convergence on compact subsets of Q. is a Frechet-Schwartz space. Proof. Let no be a sufficiently large integer. If Q = C. let Kn = 8(0. n) and. if Q =1= C, let Kn = {z E Q: d(z. QC) 2: lin} n 8(0, n). The sequence (Kn)n~no is an exhaustive sequence of compact subsets of Q. The topology of Jt"(Q) is defined by the seminorms (Pn)n~no:
Pn(f) = max If(z)l· :EK,
For every n ::: no, the natural map (Jt"(Q»p"., ~ (Jt"(Q»p, is compact: it is enough to see that if (hkh~l is a sequence in Jt"(Q) bounded for the seminorm Pn+J, i.e., uniformly bounded on Kn+h one can extract a subsequence converging uniformly on Kn. This is the content of Montel's theorem (see [BG. Theorem 2.2.8]). We repeat here the proof for the benefit of the reader. It is enough to show the equicontinuity of (hkh>1 on Kn. then apply the theorem of Arzela-Ascoli. We can construct a cycle -8 in Kn+1 \Kn such that for every h E Jt"(Q) and z E Kn we have
he:) =
-1-.1 2m
6
her) dt.
t- :
Therefore, if z and l; are in Kn we have
with M any number bigger than
(
SUP
k>1
IhdWH)
weKn_1
This proves the proposition.
( sup - 1 :.l;EK,2JT
1
Idrl ) 6Ir-zllr-l;1
o
1.4. Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis
81
Let Q be a convex open subset of Co According to Definition 1.3.12, the space Exp(Q) is the space of entire functions / of exponential type for which there is a compact convex subset K of Q (depending on f) such that
II/11K
:= supe-HK<:)I/(z)1 <
00.
zeC
Let us denote by Exp K (Q) the space of those entire functions / such that < 00. It is easy to show that EXPK(Q), considered with the norm II . 11K, is a Banach space. The convergence in this norm clearly implies the uniform convergence on every compact subset of Co We have
II/11K
Exp(Q)
= U EXPK(Q)· Kf;n
For any exhaustive sequence (Kn)n~l of compact convex subsets of Q, we can endow Exp(Q) with the topology of inductive limit of the Banach spaces EXPK. (Q). This topology is finer than the topology of pointwise convergence. It follows from Proposition 1.4.3 that this topology is independent of the sequence of compact convex sets (Kn)n~l. The space Jt'''(Q) is a DFS space. The Fourier-Borel transform~: JrI(Q) ~ Exp(Q) is an isomorphism of vector spaces. Hence one can transport the DFS topology of JeI(Q) to Exp(Q). This provides us with another £~ topology on Exp(Q) which is finer than the topology of pointwise convergence: If (Ta) is a filter of linear functionals in Jr' (Q) which converges to zero, then for any ~ E C, ~Ta(~) converges to zero, since (Ta) clearly converges weakly to zero. Therefore, this transported topology and the inductive limit topology introduced before, coincide, and ~: Je'(Q) ~ Exp(Q) is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces when Jf'1(Q) is considered with the strong dual topology and Exp(Q) with the inductive limit topology. Similarly, one can considerthe space Jf'o(QC), defined in § 1.3, as the inductive limit of the FS spaces Jeo(K C ), where K is a compact convex subset of Q and ~o(KC) is the space of functions holomorphic in K C vanishing at 00. (It is a closed subspace of Jff(KC).) The C-transform C: Je'(Q) ~ Jf'o(QC) is also bijective and the topology that induces on Jeo(QC) is finer than the £~ topology of Jeo(Q C) as shown by the representation formula of the analytic functional by elements of Jeo(QC): (T,h)
1 .1C(T)(Z)h(Z)dz. = -2 7r1 y
(Recall C(T) = 7fT.) Therefore, C is a topological isomorphism between JeI(Q) with the strong topology, and Jeo(QC) is the inductive limit of FS spaces. By composition, the Borel transform B: Exp(Q) ~ Jeo(QC) is also a topological isomorphism. Another interesting space is the space Jff(K), K a compact subset of C, which is by definition the inductive limit of the FS spaces Jff(w), w an open neighborhood of K. It is in fact a DFS space, since we can limit ourselves to open neighborhoods of the form V(K, lin) = (z E C: d(z, K) < lin}, and
82
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
the restriction maps from Jr(V(K, lin» into Jr(V(K, l/(n + 1))), which are compact. It is easy to verify that, when K is compact and convex, the FS space Jr/(K) is isomorphic, via the Fourier-Borel transform, to the Frechet space Exp(K) = {f E Exp(C): Ve > 0, 3Ce > 0 such that If(z)1 :::
CeeHK<:l+EI:1
for all z E C).
with the norms %(f) =
~~g (exp ( -HK(z) -
1:1) If(Z)I)
Using the Cauchy transform, .1f1 (K) is isomorphic to the projective limit of the Frechet spaces Jt"o(al), w an open neighborhood of K. This isomorphism does not require the compact K to be convex. We conclude this section by proving the Paley-Wiener-Schwartz theorem that characterizes the space F£/(JR) of Fourier transforms of distributions of compact support as the space of entire functions satisfying certain growth conditions. We will also prove the theorem of Ehrenpreis describing the topology of £' (lR) in terms of the topology of that space of entire functions. As we observed earlier any distribution J.l- E £' (JR) can be considered as an analytic functional T carried by a compact subset of an interval] - a, a[ of the real line, in fact, by supp(T) cc ] - a, a[. Since /.l has finite order N it can be represented as J.l- = 2:f=1 /.ly>, /.lj Radon measures, supp(/.lj) cc ] - a. a[ and so the /.l is completely determined by its action on the space Jt"([-a, a]), thus J.l- ~ T is an injective map. By definition F/.l(~)
= (/.lx. e-iX{) = ~T(-iO.
so that FJ.l- is an entire function and /.l previous remark
~
F/.l is injective. Moreover, from the
N
F/.l(~)
= L(-i~)j (/.lj. e- ix {) j=l
so that
Let us denote by PW the space of entire functions of the form
f satisfying an estimate
for some constants A, N, B ::: O. Clearly PW is an algebra under multiplication. Recall that £/(lR) is also an algebra under convolution of distributions [Schw2]. 1.4.15. Theorem (Paley-Wiener-Schwartz). The Fourier transform is a linear isomorphism F: £'(JR) - PW.
104. Vade Mecum of Functional Analysis
83
Moreover, if we consider £' (lR) as convolution algebra then :F is an algebra isomorphism.
proof. We have already shown that F is linear and injective. The fact that F(J.L * v) = FJ.L . Fv is well known. We need to recall that if 8b is the Dirac mass at the point b E IR then ~8bU;)
= e-il;b,
which implies that F8 = I, where 8 = 80 = Dirac mass at 0 is the unit of £'(IR) under convolution. Moreover, (F(..L(j»)(n
= ((..L(j) , e-ixl;) . dj \(..Lx, dx j e-
./
= (_i)l
=
r)
IX ,
(i~)j (J.Lx, e-iXI;)
= (i~)j F(..L(~). More generally, if P is a polynomial then
(F (p
(:x) (..L)) (~)
=
p(inF(..L(~).
Now we are ready to prove the surjectivity of the Fourier transfonn. Let so that
f
E
PW
If f has no zero then we must have f(~)
= Ceal;
for some C, a E Co The previous estimate implies that a must be a pure imaginary number, say a = -ib, bE JR, Ibl s B. Thus f = F(C8 b ). If f has only finitely many zeros, then there is a polynomial q and an entire function g without zeros such that f =qg.
Let q have leading coefficient qo and degree n, then for some R > 0 sufficiently large we have if This clearly implies that g
E
I~I ~
R.
PW. in fact.
Ig(nl
s
A'(l
+ 1~i)N eB11ml;l.
From the previous remarks we conclude that f = FJ-l, J-l = Cq«(1/i)(dldx»8b. s B. Therefore, to conclude the proof we can assume f has infinitely many zeros. lIence we can find a polynomial q of degree n = N + 2 dividing f. That is,
C E C. b E JR, Ibl
84
f
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
= qg, and from (*) and (**) we get Ig(~)1 ::: A'(l
(* * *)
+ 1~1)-2eBllm{l.
We are going to prove the existence of a continuous function rp, supp(rp) S; [-B, BJ such that g Frp. It will then follow that f FJ-L, J-L the distribution q((l/i)(d/dx»rp, supp(J-L) S; supp(rp). But the function g restricted to the real axis belongs to L I (lR) n L 2(lR), so that if we use the classical theory of the Fourier transfonn we can choose
=
=
rp(t) := - I 2rr
1
00
g(nei~1 d~,
-00
=
so that rp is continuous, bounded, and in L2(lR). In the L2-sense Frp g on R We claim that supp«(jI) S; [-B, Bl. Let t > B, using the Cauchy theorem and the estimate (* * *) we see that for any 7J > 0 I !oo+i~
=-
(jI(t)
2rr
so that
Im(t)1 ."
g(~)ei{1 d~,
-oo+i"
l
OO i A' + '1 Id~1 < _e(B-/)'1 - 2rr -oo+i'1 (1 + R1)2'
Letting 7J -+ +00 we see that (jI(t) = O. Similarly, for t < -B. As supp(rp) S; [-B, Bl, Fep is an entire function in PW which coincides almost everywhere with g on the real axis. Thus Fep g everywhere. This concludes the proof. 0
=
Let us remark that we have also shown in this proof that when f satisfies (*) then f = FJ-L, supp(J-L) S; [-B, BJ. We can introduce in the space PW the topology of the inductive limit of the Banach spaces PWn, n E N*. PWn :=
{f
E
.1t'(C):
II
f IIn:= sup(lf(~)le-nllm{l(l + I~I)-n) seC
<
oo}.
On the other hand, the space e(lR) is an FS space so that it is reflexive and e'(R) is DFS. As a consequence of Proposition 1.4.12 we now obtain the following result: 1.4.16. Theorem (Paley- Wiener-Schwartz-Ehrenpreis). The Fourier transform F is a topological isomorphism between e'(lR) and PW. A similar proof shows that F(V(R» = (f E .1t'(C): 3A > 0, "IN> 0: sup(l
+ IzI)Ne-A1lm:1If(z)1
< oc).
The description of a topology in F(V(R» that makes the Fourier transform an isomorphism is a bit more complicated than that of PW. It can be found in [Eh5].
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals
85
In the following chapter we will introduce the spaces Ap(C) of entire functions. For the choice p(~) = 1Im~1 + logO + 1';-1) we have Ap(C) = PW. including coincidence of topologies.
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals In this section we define the convolution of two analytic functionals and study the elementary properties of this operation.
1.5.1. Definition. Let Q Ix: it I,;unvex upen set and let T be an analytic functional whose convex support is the compact convex set K. For any I holomorphic in the convex open set Q + K, the function T * I is defined by
* /)(z) =
(T
is called the convolution of
I
(T~, I(~
+ z)}(z E
Q)
and T.
1.5.2. Proposition. The lunction T
*I
is holomorphic in
Proof. If
Q.
Q:f:. C, e > 0, let Q_ E := {z E Q: d(z, QC) > e}, if Q = C, then let fLE := Co For any e > 0 we can show that T I is holomorphic in ~Le, just simply represent T by a measure J.L with compact support contained in V(K,e) = {z E C: d(z. K) < e} and apply Morera's theorem to the function
*
(T
r
* /)(z) =
I(z
+~) dJ.L(~).
}V(K.E)
which is defined in
o
Q-e.
1.5.3. Proposition. The map T*: Je(Q linear and continuous.
+
K) ~ Je(Q) given by
I
~ T
*I
is
Proof. If L is a compact convex subset of Q and e > 0 is chosen sufficiently small so that L 5; Q-e, we represent T by a measure J.L of compact support in V(K, e), then sup IT
* l(z)1 :s (
:eL
I/(W)I)
sup weL+V(K.e)
(rJ~'(K.e)
dlJ.Ll) .
From this proposition we conclude that the transpose I(T*): Je'(Q)
is also continuous. For S
E Jel(n).
--+
Je'(Q
I(T*)(S)
+ K)
E Je'(Q
(I(T*)(S), f) = (S. T
* f)
+ K)
is defined by
0
86
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
on functions
f
E Je(Q
+ K).
It is standard to denote it by T * S so that
T
* S := I(T*)(S),
and call it the convolution of T and S. The question that arises immediately is whether T * S is well defined for any two analytic functionals, independent of the choice of the open convex set Q for which the convex support K(S) S n. Since Q + K is convex, Jel(Q + K) can be considered as a subset of Je'(C), i.e., the analytic functionaI1(T*)(S) is therefore completely determined by its value on entire functions f. In that case, T * f is entire, and the value (S, T * f) is then independent of Q. 1.5.4. Definition. The convolution T * S of any two analytic functional!. T and S is defined by (T * S, f) := (S, T * f) for all f E Je(C).
Since the Fourier-Borel transform is injective, this proposition can also be proved using the following one, which also helps to clarify the relation between '(T*)(S) and I(S*)(T). 1.5.5. Proposition. For any two functionals Sand T. we have ~(T)~(S). In particular, h:F(T*s) :::: h:F(T)
+ h:F(s),
~(T
* S) =
Proof. By definition F(T
* S)(S) = (T * S):, eZ~) = (S:, (Tw * eW~)(z») =(Sz, (Tw, e(Z+w)~))
=(S:. eZ~ (Tw , eW~)) = (S:, ~(T)(~ )e={) = ~(T)(~)(Sz, e Z {) = ~(T)(~) . ~(S)(~).
The second statement follows from log I~(T
* S)I =
log I~(T)(~)I
+ log 1~(S)(s)I.
o
We note that it follows from this proposition that for T =1= 0 the map T*: Jel(e) ~ Jel(e) is injective. Other properties are summarized in the following statement: 1.5.6. Corollary. The convolution of analytic functionals is commutative and associative. Moreover, Je'(C) is a unitary ring with unit the Dirac delta at the origin, and without zero divisors.
Proof It is left to the reader. 1.5.7. Proposition. If S is carried by the compact convex set Land K(T) = K. then T * S is carried by K + L. In particular, the convex support C of T * S i5 contained in K + K (, where K I is the convex support of S.
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals
87
Proof. It is an immediate corollary of Proposition 1.3.5 and Theorem 1.3.2. Namely,
We recall from § 1.3 that an analytic functional T =f. 0 is a differential operator of infinite order if and only if k (Tj = {OJ. (More precisely, T can be identified to such an operator.) In this case
k(T
* S) =
k(s)
for any analytic functional S. An important property of the convolution is the following:
1.S.S. Proposition. For any nonzero analytic functional T. the map T*: ;f(C) -+ ;f(C) is surjective. Proof. From Propositions 1.4.7 and 1.4.12 we know that the present statement is equivalent to the two properties that T *: ;f' (C) -+ ;f' (C) is injective and has a sequentially closed image. The first condition follows from Corollary 1.5.6 to prove the second condition, we use the fact mentioned in 1.4, that the Fourier-Borel transform is a topological isomorphism between ;f'(C) and Exp(C). Suppose that we have a sequence of analytic functionals (Sj)j, and an analytic functional S such that T * Sj -+ S. Then ;j(T);j(Sj) -+ ;j(S) in Exp(C) and in particular, uniformly over compact sets. Therefore, the entire function ;j(S) vanishes at all the zeros of ;jeT), with at least the same multiplicity. Hence, f := ;j(S)/;j(T) is an entire function. Lindelof's theorem [BG, §4.S.7] ensures that f is of exponential type. We conclude that there is an analytic functional R such that ;j(R) = f and, hence, ;j(R);j(T) = ;j(S),
in other words, S
= T * R.
o
It is not generally true that if Q is a convex open set, K = k (T) =f. 0, then T*: ;f(Q + K) -+ ;f(Q) is surjective. It depends on more subtle properties of the function ;jeT). 1.5.9. Definitions. (1) A measurable subset E ~ [0. oo[ is said to be of relative zero measure
if .
hm r~x
ml(E
n [0, r]) r
=0,
where m I denotes the Lebesgue measure on the real line JR. (2) Let ¢ be a function, defined on ]0,00[. for which there is a set E of relative zero measure such that the limiting value of ¢(r), when r -+ 00 while r fi E. exists. We denote this value by lim;~oo ¢(r). (Note that this value is independent of the exceptional set E.)
88
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
(3) Let 1 be an entire function of exponential type. We say f has a completely regular growth if there is a set E of relative zero measure such that for each 8,0:::8 <2rr, ;9 ;9 . • log If(re )1 hf(e ) = hm ,~oo
r
and, furthermore, these limits are uniform in 8. We refer the reader to [Lev, Chapter 3] for the properties functions of completely regular growth.
1.5.10. Proposition. If f has completely regular growth and g is an arbitrary emire June/iurl uJ e.Apuli13iltial type, then
Proof. It is left to the reader.
D
1.5.11. Corollary. If g is ofcompletely regular growth and f is an entire function
01 exponential type such that 1/ g is entire, then hf/g
= hf
- hg.
Proof. It follows from the fact that fig is an entire function of exponential type. D
1.5.12. Proposition. Let T be an analytic functional whose convex support is K and such that ;yeT) has completely regular growth. Then, for every convex open set n, the map 1 ~ T * 1 from )f(n + K) into )fen) is surjective. Moreover, every solution f 01 the equation T 1 = 0, f E )f(n + K), is the limit of a sequence of exponential polynomials of the lorm
*
L
pj(z)e ajZ ,
I::;j::;m
where each Uj is a zero of ;yeT) of multiplicity mj and Pj is a polynomial of degree::: mj - 1. Each term 01 this sum is an element olker(T*). Proof. It is easy to see that for ~ E C fixed and u E C· the functions z (e(/;+U): - e/;:)/u converge in )fCC) to z ~ ze/;: as u ~ O. Therefore,
~;Y(T)(~) d~
= lim ;Y(T)(~ + u) u-o
;Y(T)(~)
u
. ( e(/;+U): - e/;: ) = hm T.. - - - - -
u-o·
More generally,
U
~
89
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals
Hence, if a is a zero of multiplicity m of
~(T)
we have
O::::j::::m-l.
* (zj eaz) vanish identically when 0 :::: j
We claim that the entire functions T m - l. In fact, (Tz , (z
L
+ ~)j ea(z+'l) =
G)
::::
(Tz • zkeaz}~j-kea,.
O:5.k:<:)
and the coefficients of the last sum vanish identically when 0 :::: j :::: m - 1. This shows that all the exponential polynomials appearing in the statement of this proposition lie in the kernel of T *. Let us denote V := (f E Jt'(Q + K): T
*f
= O}.
the kernel of T* as a map from Jf(Q + K) into Jf(Q), and N := span{zjeaz : ~(T)(a) = 0,0:::: j :::: m - I. m = multiplicity of a}.
Then N ~ V, and we want to show that when N denotes the closure of N in Jf(Q + K), then N = V. By the Hahn-Banach theorem it is enough to show that if Jl E Jf'(Q + K) vanishes on N, then it vanishes on V. From the above considerations we know that Jl vanishing on N implies that ~(Jl) vanishes at every zero a of ~(T) with at least the same multiplicity as ~(T) does. Therefore, ~(Jl)
= ~(T)g,
where g is an entire function of exponential type. Since regular growth we have that hg
=
h'lj(/l-) -
~(T)
has completely
h'lj(T).
Any compact subset of Q + K is contained in a set of the form K some compact convex subset L of Q. If Jl is carried by K + L, then
+ L,
for
hg :::: HK+L - HK = H L,
which shows that g = ~(R). R E Jf'(Q), R carried by L and Jl = T IffEV,then
* R.
Hence N = V. To show the surjectivity of T* onto Jf(Q), we have to show that I(T*): Jf'(Q) _ Jf'(Q) is injective and has a closed image. The injectivity is part of Corollary 1.5.6. since t(T*)(Jl) = T * Jl. Furthermore, the preceding computations show that Im('(T*» = NJ.., which proves that Im('(T*» is closed in Jt"(Q + K). 0 As examples of analytic functionals satisfying the preceding conditions we
have:
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
90
=
=
P(8) LO~j~n(-I)jaj8(j) is a linear differential operator with constant coefficients of order n. P
(i) First. T
* f = anf(n) + ... + aof. if P(z) = L}~Oa}zj is an entire function T
(ii) More generally. type zero, then
of exponential
T = P(8) = L(-I)jaj 8(j) j~O
operates on any ;f(Q). Q an convex open set in C. by T
*f
=
L
a;/(j) .
}~O
Here we have P = J(T). T has convex support to}. and h p == O. It follows from [Lev, Chapter 3] that P has completely regular growth. We shall see in Chapter 3 that all the exponential polynomials have completely regular growth. hence Proposition 1.5.12 applies to any T that is a linear combination of the derivatives of Dirac point masses. Let us remark that the last part of the proof of Proposition 1.5.12 can be easily modified to obtain the following result.
1.5.13. Proposition. Let T be a nonzero analytic functional. then the linear combinations of the functions zk eaz • where Oi is a zero of J(T) of multiplicity m and 0 ::: k ::: m - 1. are dense in the space of all the entire solutions f of the equation T * f = o. EXERCISES
1.5.
I. Prove in detail Corollary 1.5.6. In particular. discuss the meaning of the identity = '(T*)(S). when a priori '(S*). t(T*) depend on an open convex set n and the convex supports K and L of S and T. respectively.
'(S*)(T)
2. Prove Corollary 1.5.10. 3. Show that if P(z) is a nonzero polynomial. a E C. T E ;f'(C). then T * == 0 implies that ;J(T)(~) vanishes at ~ = a. with multiplicity ~ deg P. More generally. show that if I is an exponential polynomial with frequencies ai • I(z) = LI:<:j~n Pj(z)e a". and T * I == O. then v(;J(T). al) ~ deg Pj • I ~ j ~ n. where v(;J(T). a,) is the order of aj as zero of ;J(T). Prove Proposition 1.5.13. (P(z)e a :)
4. Prove that if n is a convex open subset of IC and P(D) is a nonzero infinite order differential operator with constant coefficients. then P(D): ;fen) -+ ;fen) is an open map. '5. (Theorem of Cramer-P6Iya.) Let I be a function holomorphic in an open set that contains the half-plane Iz: Rez > a). Let us assume that in that half-plane the function I is represented by a Dirichlet series
n
I(z) = Lane-An; n?;:O
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals
91
with abscissa of convergence U c ::; a (see [BG. §5.2.12]). Let T be an analytic functional carried by a convex compact set K. b sup{lzl: z E K}. and let g ;J(T). Show that of the Dirichlet series the abscissa of convergence
=
u:
rp(z) :=
=
2: ang(An)e-i.·: n~O
satisfies U c ::; a + b. Moreover. the function rp has an analytic continuation to the unbounded component U of (K + oey. (Hint: Show that Z E U 1-+ (T~. I(z is holomorphic.)
n)
6. (a) Let 0 = B(O. J2). and let a(z) := sinz/z, fJ(z) := sinhz/z. Show that a, Exp(O), a, 13 have not common zeros, and afJ II Exp(O). (b) For II E N°, let f. be the contour in Figure 1.3 below. Show that the function In defined by
In(z) :=
1
e""
r. a(w)fJ(w)
is entire. (c) Show that the sequence (J.).?I converges in
I(z) :=
1
dw
~(O)
e:W
r a(w)fJ(w)
where f is the infinite contour of Figure 1.4.
Figure 1.3
13
dw,
to the function
f given by
E
92
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
r
Figure 1.4
(d) Let T and S be the analytic functionals such that :F(T) = a and :F(S)(i;) a(i;)/(I; - n). Show that S E Jf'/(Q) and (S, f)
Conclude that I '" O. (e) Prove that for n
~
=
r (S"
ir
e'W)
a(w)lI(w)
=
2:rri
dw
= 1I(:rr)·
I (T
* I.)(n =
1 e'W
-dw,
r. (3(w)
and deduce from this formula that for Ii; I < ~ one has (T
* f)(i;) =
lim (T
..... x
* I.)(i;) = o.
Conclude that T * I = O. (f) Prove that if R is the analytic functional such that F(R)
= II, then R * I
= O.
7. Let v E C, Re v > -~, and let T. be the analytic functional defined by the measure X., of suppon [- 1, 1] S; JR, for
- 1~ t
~
I.
1.5. Convolution of Analytic Functionals
93
Compute explicitly r(Tv) and show these functions are of completely regular growth. by applying directly the definition given in the text. (Hint: Look up the definition of the Bessel function in a table. for example. in [GRJ.)
=
8. Let T LI + L; + 81 + 8;. compute F(T) and show directly it is a function of completely regular growth. 9. Show that if E 5; [0, oo[ has finite Lebesgue measure then it has zero relative measure.
10. Prove that a function f E Exp(l[) is an exponential polynomial if and only if its Borel transform B(!) is a rational function. Show that the coefficients of this exponential polynomial are constant if and only if the poles of B(f) are simple. What do these characterizations mean in terms of the analytic functional T and of its Cauchy transform where f = F(T).
t.
r»
11. Let g = F(T) and h = F(S), T E .If'(B(O, B(h), and B(f) be the Borel transforms of g. h. and B(f)(w) = _I. { 27r1
for any w such that Iwl > r
JI~I=T+E
and S E .If'(B(O.
0'». Let B(g).
f := gh. Show that. for any E
> 0,
B(g)(~)B(h)(w - ~)d~,
+ 0' + e.
12. Assume that f is an exponential polynomial. g is an exponential sum (i.e .• exponential polynomial with constant coefficients). and that h = fig is an entire function. (a) Show that h is an entire function of exponential type such that if B(g) has poles at /31 •..• , /3m. then B(f)(w) = bjB(h)(w - /3j).
L
I~j::m
for Iwl sufficiently large, where bj := Res(B(g), /3j)' (b) We assume from now on that B(h) is holomorphic for Iwl > R > O. and that it has at least one singularity on Iwl R. We assume also that RI is such that B(h) is meromorphic for Iwl > RI and there is a singularity on Iwl = RI . Up to a change of variables. we can assume this singularity occurs for w = R I . Let us enumerate the poles /3j in a decreasing order for the lexicographic order. (That is, Z -< ZI is equivalent to either Re z < Re ZI or. if Re Z = Re Zlo then 1m Z < 1m ZI.) Show that RI -< RI + (/31 - M and that RI + (/31 - 13;) is exterior to B(O. Rd for j 2, ... , n. Conclude that
=
=
M a neighborhood of R + 131. w ~ B(h)(w -
is meromorphic in
(i
= 2, ... , m)
(c) Show that bIB(h)(w - fJd = B(f)(w) - (w),
where is meromorphic in a neighborhood of RI
+ fJl.
Hence, w = RI is at most a
POlar singularity for B(h). (d) Conclude that there is R2 < R such that B(h) is meromorphic in Iwl > R2 • (e) Conclude that B(h) is a rational function and that h is an exponential polynomial. (This is a generalization of a theorem of Rin that can be found in [ShiJ. see also Chapter 3 below.)
94
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle In this section we denote by D the disk B (0, I) = {z E C: Iz I < I}, and by l' = aD the unit circle. Recall that we denote V(1l') , the space of infinitely differentiable functions on T, i.e., Coo functions of a single real variable, which are 2rr -periodic. The Fourier coefficients of the functions f in 1'(11') are characterized by their fast decrease. I If I 1211' -int (n E Z), Cn = cn(f) = f(t)e dt 21l' 0 then, for every integer k
E
N* we have
as Inl
~ 00.
The dual V'(T) of the space 1'(1l') is the space of distributions on the circle 1l'. Recall that Je"(1l'), the space of holomorphic functions on 1', is the inductive limit Je"(T) = lim Je"(Q),
n2i over all open subsets Q of C containing 1'. This space is considered with the corresponding inductive limit topology and is an r:~ space. One can verify that Je"(1') ~ V(1') and is dense. The elements T of Je"'(1') will be called analytic functionals on 1l' or hyperfunctions on 1l'. (An older terminology is hyperdistributions on 1l'.) As was the case for the hyperfunctions on R this generalization of the distributions on 1l' will allow us to attribute to an arbitrary holomorphic function in D a boundary value, something that could only have been done for functions of moderate growth if we would have wanted the boundary values to lie in 1"(1'). As an application we will give the characterization of all the eigenfunctions of the hyperbolic Laplacian (or Laplace-Beltrami operator) in D as integrals of powers of the Poisson kernel multiplied by hyperfunctions on 1'. There are just not enough distributions on l' to solve this problem. We start by characterizing the elements of Jt'(1'). 1.6.1. Proposition. Let f be a continuous function on l' and let cn = _1_ 2rr
r 10 2
11'
f(eiIJ)e-inIJ dB,
n EN, be the sequence of its Fourier coefficients. The following properties are equivalent:
I
(i) f E Je"(1') (i.e., f is the restriction to l' of a holomorphic function defined in some annulus r2 < Izl < rio 0 ::: r2 < I < r) ::: (0). (ii) f is the sum of the restrictions to 'lI' of two functions E JIf(D) and E Je"o(C\D).
.A
12
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
95
(iii) There is 0 S a < I such that Icnl = O(a 1nl ). (iv) I E D(1l') and there is an M > 0 such that
11/112.M where II· (v)
I
E D(1l')
I II/(k)112
= sup Mk -k-'. k~O
< 00,
112 denotes the norm in
L2(1l', d(}). and there is an L > 0 such that
11/1100.L where!! . !!x
dennte.~
1 IljCk)lIoo
= sup Lk k~O
k'
•
<
00,
the norm in LooOf'. d8).
Furthermore, if I satisfies these conditions, thelunctions II and h ol(ii) are unique and given by
- 1 1 = -. 1 II(z)
h(z)
I = -.
-I(w) -dw
2rr I
YI W -
I 2rrl
1'2
Z
I(w) -dw w- Z
n = '"' L...,CnZ ,
Izi
s
I,
n = '"' L...,CnZ ,
Izi 2:
I,
n~O
n
where Yh Y2 are two positively oriented circles centered at the origin olradii PI. P2 such that r2 < P2 < I < PI < rl·
Proof. (I) The equivalence of (i) and (ii), and the fonnulas for 11 and
h
follow immediately from the properties of the Laurent development of I. The uniqueness of hand can be seen as follows: If II + = gl + g2 on 1l', with k gl E JIf(D), g2 E Jlfo(C\D), then the function II - gl = g2 - h on '][' is the restriction of an entire function which vanishes at 00. Hence it is identically zero by Liouville's theorem. (2) The equivalence of (i) and (iii) follows from Hadamard's fonnula for the radii of convergence of the two series
h 12,
12
and (The second one is a series in 1/Z .) (3) Let us show that (iii) implies (iv). First, if the sequence Cn tends to zero when n -- ±oo as a geometric series of ratio a, 0 S a < 1, then, a lortiori, it is of fast decrease and hence I E D(1f'). Furthennore, the derivatives with respect to () are given by l(k)(e ifJ ) = L(in)kcneinfJ. nel. Therefore II/(k)lI~ S L Inl2klcn l2 S CLn 2k a 2n nel. n~O
96
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
s
C L(n
+ 2k)(n + 2k -
l) ... (n
+ IH( 2 )n
n?:O
(2k)!
s
"~ Icn(g)1 = Ico(g)1 + "~ -In-IIcn(g')1 nEZ'
nEZ
:0 :"
s
It I+ (~ :' ) ." (~I,"(g')I') ." g(B) dB
A 1
for some constant AI > 0 independent of g. If g yields Ilf(k)lloo < A (1If(k)112 k! - 2 k!
S
= f(k), then the above estimate
11f(k+I)II2)
+ k! A 3 (M k + (k + l)Mk+I)
S A4(2Ml,
for some A4 > O. (5) Let us show that (v) implies (i). Assume Ilflloo.L < 00. Consider the Taylor development of f} f-+ f(e iB ) near a point f}o E [0, 2;rr]. The Lagrange formula for the remainder of order k shows that this remainder is majorized by
I(}
I
(l k+ I
(:+ol)! If(k+l)(~)1
s
C(If) -(}oIL/+ 1 ,
which tends to zero if If) - f}ol < 1/ L. This shows that f has a Taylor series expansion near each point of 11'. This proves that it is the restriction to 11' of a function holomorphic in a neighborhood of 11'. The proposition has been therefore proved. G 1.6.2. Definition. The pair (ft, h) Fantappie transform of f E J'f(1I').
E J'f(D)
x J'fo(C\D)
is called the
We can now show that the topology of J'f(1l') can be characterized in different ways.
97
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
1.6.3. Proposition. On Jt"(T) the following topologies coincide: (i) The topology of the inductive limit of spaces Jt"(U), U an open subset ofC
containing T. (ii) The topology whose images by the Fantappie transform f 1-+ i2) is the product topology of Jt"(D) x Jfo(C\D), each of the factors considered with its natural CF topology. (iii) The topology whose image, by the Fourier transform f 1-+ (cn(f»neZ onto the space if of sequences (cn)nezfor which there is an a E [0, 1[ such that sUPnez(lcn I/a lnl ) < 00, is the inductive limit of the Banach spaces
(il.
(iv) The topology of the inductive limit on the index M > 0 of the Banach spaces H2.MCIf) := (f
E
Jf(T): Ilfll2.M < oo}.
(v) The topology of the inductive limit on the index L > 0 of the Banach spaces
Hoo.d1f) := (f
E
Jf(1I'): Ilflloo.L < oo}.
Proof. All these are CF topologies, which are stronger than the topology of pointwise convergence on 1I', hence, Proposition 1.4.3 can be used to obtain the desired result. 0 1.6.4. Proposition. The space Jt"(T) is a subspace dense of V(1I').
Proof. The trigonometric polynomials I:ljl:::n ajz j are elements of Jt"(1I') and 0 they are already dense in V(1I'). 1.6.S. Proposition. The Fourier series I:nez cn(f)zn converges to f in Jf(T).
Proof. Namely, let 0 < a < 1 be such that c a < {3 < 1. We have Icn(f)1 = Icn(f)1 {3lnl a lnl
(~)Inl {3
< c -
= sUPn
(~)N {3
if
Inl::: N.
Therefore, the remainder gN of order N of the Fourier series of f: gN(Z)
= fez) -
L
cn(f)zn
(Z E T)
Inl:::N tends to zero in
H{3
as N ~
00.
o
1.6.6. Remark. Jt"(1I') is an algebra under multiplication. As a consequence one can show that if f E Jt"(1I') and g is holomorphic on the range of t, i.e., g E Jt"(f(1I'», then gof E Jt"(1I'). (It can also be proved directly.)
98
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.6.7. Example. The Poisson kernel as an element of Jt"(1I'). Let re ilP E D be fixed. The Poisson kernel is the function of b = ei9 E 11' given by P(re
irp
,b) =
1 - r2
1 - r2
.
Ib - re'lPl
It is an analytic function of b
E
2
=--~~----------
I
+ r2 -
2r cos(e - rp) .
11'. In fact, it is the restriction to 11' of the product
1 - r2
z
z - re ilP
1 - zre- ilP '
and these two functions are holornorphic in r < Izl < I/r. Using the partial fraction decomposition of this product, one finds the Fantappie transform (i51, P2) of P:
(Izl on
> r),
Izl = 1.
Hence, the Fourier series of P is given by P(re irp , ei9 ) = Lrlnle-inrpein9. nEZ
Now let I-t E C be a fixed value, and keep re ilP E D also fixed. Since P(reilP,b) > 0 for bE 11', the function w ~ wI-L which takes the value I at
w = I is well defined on the range of P. By Remark 1.6.6, we have that b ~ (P(re ilP , b»I-L is also in Jt"(1I'). We denote pI-L(z, b) := (P(z, b»I-L. The computation of the explicit Fourier series development of pI-L can be
found in [Er]: pI-L(re ilP , ei9 )
= Lan(r)e-inlPein9, nEZ
with an(r) = (1 - r 2)I-L r lnl
f(1-t
+ In!)
f(1-t)f(lnl
+ 1)
F(I-t,1-t
where f(c)
F(a, b; c; z)
= f(b)f(a)
' " f(a
~ n~O
+ Inl; 1 + Inl; r 2 ),
+ n)r(b + n) zn f(c + n) n!
is the hypergeometric function [Er]. We are going now to study the analytic functionals on 11'. Since ~(11') is dense in V(1I') and has a stronger topology, every distribution on 11' can be identified
99
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
to an analytic functional, i.e., V'(]') £ Jf"(]'). For instance, if hE L I (],), then
(Th, f)
I = -.
i
2m r
h(b)f(b) db
= -11211" hee'"(] )f(e''(] )e''(] d8 2Jl'
0
defines an analytic functional Th. For every n E Z and z Ii]' the functions b ~ bn and b ~ I/(b - z) are elements of Je(],). Hence the following definition makes sense: 1.6.S. Definition. Let T
For every n
E
cn(T) = (T, b- n -
I)
E Je'(],).
Z the number
is called the nth Fourier coefficient of the analytic functional T. The formal series
is called the Fourier series of T. Note that if T = Th , h E LI('Jf, d8), then this definition coincides with the usual one. 1.6.9. Definition. For T (Tt, T2) defined by
E Je'(]'),
TI(z):= / \
the Fantappie transform of T is the pair
T _1_) b,
b- z
T2(Z) := ( Tb, z
~ b)
(izi <
(Izl
I),
> I).
Thus, Tt = -Jl'T = -C(T), inside D, and T2 = Jl'T = C(T), outside D. If T = Tf , with f E Je(],) we recover the previously defined Fantappie transform h). (We have used the notation Tb to indicate that T acts on the variable b.)
(II,
1.6.10. Proposition. (1) The map T ~ (TI , T2 ) is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces between Je'(]') and Je(D) x Jeo(C\D). Furthermore,
TI (z) = (Tb' b
~ z) =
L:>n(T)zn
(izi
< I),
n~O
(izi
> I).
(2) The map T ~ (cn(T)neZ is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces between .w"(1l') and the space if' of sequences (an)nez such that for every r E [0, 1[ the series l:nez Ian Irlnl converges (i.e., the dual of if).
100
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
(3) Let T E Jt"'(1I') and f E Jt"(1I'), we have (T, f)
= I,>-(n+I)(T)cn(f) nEZ
11- -
= -2·
n
1r1
T2 (z)fl(z)dz
11--
+ -2· 1r1
~
TI (z)h(z) dz,
where Y2 (resp. YI) is a circle of center 0, radius> I (resp. < I) of index I with respect to 0, contained in the domain of holomorphy of il (resp. h). Proof. Even though these statements can be deduced from the general case of spaces Jt"(K) given earlier, we are going to give here a direct proof for this particular case. We leave it to the reader to verify the topological part of the statements. Let f E Jt"(1I'), its Fourier series L,nEZ cn(f)bn converges to f in Jt"(1I'). Hence, if T E Jt'" (11') we have (T. f)
=L
cn(f}(T, b n )
nEZ
= LCn(f)c-
which proves the first part of statement (3). If Izl < I is fixed, we have I/(b - z) = L,n>O znb- n- I• the series is convergent in Jt"o(C\D) and hence in Jt"(1I'). Similarly~if Izl > I, we have I/(z - b) = L,n>O z-n b n- I , this series is convergent in Jt"(D). hence also in Jt"(1I'). Therefore, if Iz I < I we have TI(z)
= (T. b ~
z) =
Lzn(T, b- n- I ) n~O
= Lcn(T)zn n~O
and, if Izl > I. one has T2 (z) = (T, z
~ b) = 1::>-n(T, b n- I ) = Lcn(T)z-n. n>O
n>O
This shows the proposed expansions for T I , T2 are correct and that (T I , T2) belongs to Jt"(D) x Jt"o(C\D). Moreover, these series have a radius of convergence ~ 1, hence for any r E [0. 1[ one has L
Icn(T)lr 1nl <
00.
nEZ
Since (bn)nEZ is a total set in Jt"(1I') , the map T ~ (Cn(T»nEZ is injective. Hence. also the map T ~ (TI • T2 ) is injective. The main thing left to prove is the surjecti vity in (l). Let (S I. S2) be an element of Jt"(D) x Jt"o(C\D). The map f ~
1 -2. 1f1
1 n
S2(z)/.(z)dz
1 + -. 21ft
1 -
S. (z)h(z) dz
YI
101
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
is well defined, and represents an analytic functional T E Jf"CJr). Its Fantappie transform is given by
- \ 1)z 11y, f _1_) -1-.1 S2(W)~ \ z-
TI(z) =
Th ,
2(z) = / Th ,
--
b-
dw = SI(Z) SI(W)--
= -. 27rl
b
W -
Z
Z -
W
=
27rl
y:!
= S2(Z)
if
Izl < 1,
if
Izl> 1,
these computations are justified using the uniqueness of the Fantappie pair associated to b H> l/(h - z), Izl < I and Izi > I,.respectively, and the Cauchy representation formula. Hence, ~ = Sj, j = 1, 2, which proves both the surjectivity in (1) as well as the relation in (3). The surjectivity in (2) follows from 0 the relations between the two transforms. 1.6.11. Definition. Let T E Jf"(1[') and (1'1,1'2) be its Fantappie transform. The Fantappie decomposition of T is the pair (T1 , T2) of elements in Jf"(1I') defined by the fact that the Fantappie transform of TI is (1'1,0) and that of T2 is (0, 1'2). We say that TI is the boundary value of the holomorphic function 1'1 E Jf'(D) and that T2 is the boundary value of the holomorphic function 1'2 E Jf'o(c\D).
Since T = Tl + T2, the Fantappie decomposition induces the direct sum decomposition Jf" (11') = Jf"1 (1[') $ Jf'; (1['), where Jf"1 (11') is the space of boundary values of functions holomorphic in D, and where Jf';(1I') is the space of boundary values of functions holomorphic in C\D that vanish at 00. One can, in fact, develop a theory of hyperfunctions on 'lI' entirely parallel to the theory of hyperfunctions on IR and construct a flabby sheaf over the real analytic manifold 1[' called the sheaf of hyperfunctions. The global sections of this sheaf are precisely the analytic functionals on T. In particular, an analytic functional on 1[' has a support, which is exactly the complement of the open subset of 1[' where the two holomorphic functions 1'1 and - 1'2 are the analytic continuation of each other. We use this obvious point without further justification. Similarly, we admit without proof those properties, used below, about boundary values of holomorphic functions in Jf'(D) and Jf'o(C\D), which are entirely analogous to the case of hyperfunctions on lR as boundary values of holomorphic functions in C\R Detailed proofs of these facts can be found in [Kan), [Mo3]. 1.6.12. Definition. Let T E Jf" (11') and let cTl, 1'2) be its Fantappie transform. For every 0 < r < 1, the function z H> 1'1 (rz) belongs to Jf'(D) and the function z H> T2(zlr) belongs to Jf'o(C\D), and there is a function Tr E Jf'(1I') whose Fantappie transform is precisely (TI(rz), T2(zlr». The functions Tr are called the r-approximations of T. 1.6.13. Proposition. The family (Tr)O
1, in the
102
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
Proof. This proposition follows from the fact that Tl (rz) converges to Tl (z) in JIt'(D) and T2(z/r) converges to T2(z) in Jlt'o(C\D), plus the topological isomorphism between )f"'(1I') and JIt'(D) x Jlt'o(C\D) given by the Fantappie transform. 0 The following proposition will be accepted without proof:
1.6.14. Proposition. Let T
E
$'(1I').
(1) The following properties are equivalent: (1) T E V(1I').
(2) The sequence (Cn(T»nEZ has a fast decrease (i.e., cn(T) = O(lnl-k)for
every k
E
N*).
(3) The functions Tl and T2 are bounded, together with all their derivatives in D (resp. qD).
(II) The following are equivalent properties: (1) T E V'(1I'). (2) The sequence (Cn(T»nEZ has slow (or tempered) growth (i.e., there is
».
N* such that cn(T) = O(lnl k Tl and T2 have slow (or tempered) growth near 1I' (i.e., there are k > 0, M > 0, such that
k
E
(3) The functions
11}(z)1 ~ M(dist(z, 1I'»-k,
j
=
1,2).
We are going to apply the theory of analytic functionals on 1I' to the study of the Laplace-Beltrami operator of the hyperbolic disk D. There are other applications, for instance, to harmonic analysis and to signal processing. The objective is to show that all the eigenfunctions in D of the operator ~ = (1- (x 2
fl.
+ l»2fl.,
= 8 2 / 8x 2 + 82 /8 y2, corresponding to the eigenvalue A E
C, are the functions
F/1-(z) = (Tb. pl1(z, b»),
where 4/-L(/-L - 1) = A, Re /-L :::: ~ and T E $' (1I') is arbitrary. The operator ~ is the Laplace-Beltrami operator in D for the hyperbolic metric. Recall the hyperbolic metric has arc length dx 2 +dy 2 ds 2 = ----;;:--;:--;:(1 - (x 2 + y2»2
and its isometries are precisely the Moebius transformations. The equation ~f -Af =0
is equivalent to the elliptic equation (r2 = x 2 + y2) A fl.f - (1 _ r2)2f = 0,
:
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
103
with real analytic coefficients in D, so that every distribution eigenfunction of 'A is actually a real analytic function in D. Let us start by verifying that the functions FJl are eigenfunctions of Li. We first need a little lemma.
1.6.15. Lemma. Let A be an open interval in R For every A E A let b feb, A) be afunction in Jf(1['). Assume that:
1-+
(i) There is a closed annulus U containing 1[' in its interior such that for every A E A, the function b 1-+ feb, A) is the restriction to 1[' of afunction few, A)
holomorphic for w E U. (ii) The derivative (8fI8A)(w, A) exists and is continuous in A x U. Then,for every A E A, b 1-+ (aflaA)(b, A) is an element of Jf(1[') and,for every T E Jf' (1['), one has
Proof. Let AD E A,
U. 1
W
E
U.
Whence, AD - h, AD
+ hEll.
for 0 < h small,
wE
Therefore,
few, AD
+ h) h
few, AD) _ af (w A )1 = 1af (w A + (}h) - af (w A )1 aA , 0 aA' 0 aA' 0
for some 0 < (J < 1. The last expression tends to zero as h ~ 0, uniformly for w E U by (ii). Hence, the difference quotient (f(w, AO + h) - few, Ao»1 h tends to (afla)..)(w, AO) in the topology of Jf(1['). This proves the lemma. 0
1.6.16. Corollary. For T
E Jf' (1['), J-L E
C, Re tL ~
!, the function
(Izl <
1)
is an eigenfunction of Li with eigenvalue 4tL(tL - I).
Proof. By an elementary explicit computation one verifies that, for every b
E
1['
fixed, one has
One uses afterward the previous lemma to guarantee that we can differentiate twice under the bracket ( , ), with respect to x = Re z and y = 1m z. Let zo = Xo + iyo E D fixed, ro = (x5 + yJ) 1/2 < 1. Fix r, p, ro < r < p < 1. We allow z to vary only in the disk Izl < r. Set U = {w E C: P':::: Iwi .:::: lip}. Apply the lemma to f = PJl, f = apJllax, f = apJllay, successively with A = x or A y. The proposition follows. 0
=
To prove the converse, we are going first to find those eigenfunctions of Li such that, after a rotation, they become new eigenfunctions proportional to the original ones.
104
1. Boundary Values of Holornorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
1.6.17. Proposition. Let A E C, f..L E C, such that 4f..L(f..L - 1) = A, Re f..L ~ ~,and let n E Z. II f E C 2(D)\{0} is such that for any e E lR, ZED,
l(eiOz)
= einO f(z),
the fol/owing two properties are equivalent: (i) /;.f = Af· (ii) f is proportional to the function qJn defined by '0
z = re'
= (1 -
~
1
qJn(z, f..L) := 21l'
r2)llrlnlein8 nlnl
Jor
2Jr
"
p/l(z. e'OI)e-,na da
+ f..L) F(f..L
r(f..L)(lnl!)·
f..L
+ Inl'
,
Inl
+ 1 r2)
.•
where F is the hypergeometric function.
=
Proof. It is clear that ({In(e i9 z, f..L) ein°qJn(z, f..L), as well that /;.qJn = 4f..L(f..L - l)qJn. The identity in (ii) has already been remarked above as giving the Fourier coefficients of pll(Z. eia ) for zED, f..L fixed (see [Er, vol. I, p. 81 (10))). We have to show that (i) implies (ii). The function I is real analytic and,
in polar coordinates, the equation (i) together with the transformation properties of I lead to the equation 2 d2 I r dr2
df
+ r dr
=
(2n +
Ar2)
(1 _ r2)2
I
for f = fer). 0 ::: r < 1, i.e., f restricted to the real positive axis. Hence I(r) is a real analytic function of r, f (r) = Lk>O akrk , and replacing into the differential equation we obtain two systems of equations for the coefficients ak:
n2ao = 0, (4 - n2)a2 = Aao. (I)
(II)
One sees immediately that if k does not have the parity of n, then air = O. Also, if k < Inl, then at = O. The ak are uniquely determined once alnl is given. If
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
105
one changes alnl by a factor, they all change by the same factor. Since ({In was 0 a solution, it must be that I is proportional to ({In. We are finally ready to prove the main theorem, due to Helgason [He]. Let us point out that the proof in [He] of the preceding lemma is more closely tied to the underlying semisimple Lie group SU(l, I), hence intrinsically more general than ours.
1.6.18. Theorem. Let D be the disk {lzi < I},
Li =
1['
= aD. Let
(1 -ld)2~,
the Laplace-Beltrami operator for the hyperbolic metric. Let P(z, b) =
1 -lzl 2 Ib-zl 2
(z E D, bE 1[')
be the Poisson kernel. Let A, /1 E C such that 4/1(/1- I) = A, Re/1 :::: eigenfunctions 01 Li with eigenvalue A are exactly the lunctions
where T
E
!. The
Jt'" (']').
Proof. Let I be a function D satisfying Lil = AI. Since I is real analytic, for ZED fixed, the function () 1-+ l(e i8 z) is infinitely differentiable and has an expansion in an absolute convergent Fourier series l(e i9 z) = Lln(z)e inll , nE:/:
I,,(z) = _1 21r
r
27r
Jo
l(ei9z)e-in9 d().
It is clear that I" (e i9 z) = ei"e I" (z). Furthermore, differentiating under the inteLi is invariant under rotations.) Therefore, there is a constant b" such that gral sign one finds Lifn = Aln. (This is simply a consequence that
I,,(z) = bn({ln(z, /1).
Taking
e = 0 in the above Fourier expansion we obtain that for every zED fez) = Lbn(jin(z, /1)
and nE:/:
We want to show there is T E Jt"'('][') such that the expansion of I will become fez) = (Tb • pJJ.(z, b».
C-n-l
(T) = bn . In that case
106
I. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
since the ifin(Z, J.L) are the Fourier coefficients of pl1-(z, b) (see Proposition 1.6.10(3». Hence, we have reduced the problem to show that for every r E [0, 1[ we have
To show this we need to use the asymptotic behavior of the functions lifin(z, as Izi ~ 1. In the formula for lifin I the term that multiplies r lnl is
10 -
r2)IL II F(J.L, Inl
J.L)I
+ J.L, Inl + I; r2)1 Ir(lnl+J.L)1 r(J.L)(lnl!) .
We want to see that for fixed r, 0 < r < 1, its presence or not does not affect the convergence of the series. First, we simplify this expression using the transformation law [Er]:
(a,
F(a, b, c; z) = (1 - z)-a F
c - b, c;
_Z_) . Z -
1
This leads us to consider IF(J.L, 1 - J.L, n
+ 1; y)1
as a function of the integer n ~ 00, where y = r2/ (r2 - 1) is a fixed negative number. Following [Er, vol. 1, p. 76], the Taylor series expansion of the hypergeometric series is
+ k)r(1 - J.L + k)r(n + I) yk r(ll)r(1 _ J.L)r(n + 1+ k) k! + Pm+l
m r(J.L
F(J.L, 1 - J.L, n
+ 1; y)
=
f;
~
= 1 + L.., (n k=O
Ak
k
+ 1) ... (n + k) Y + Pm+l
where IPm+Ii ::: amlylm+l(n
+ 1)2(Re IL )-m-3,
am a constant independent of Y and n. Chose first m so large that 2(Re J.L) m - 3 < 0, hence Pm+l ~ 0 as n ~ 00. This shows that for y fixed (i.e., for r < 1 fixed)
lim F(J.L, 1 - J.L, n
n->oo
Therefore, for n
~
+ 1; y)
= 1.
no, we have IF(J.L, 1- J.L,n
+ 1; y)1
~!.
The other factor that varies with n in lifin I is the quotient of r -factors. By Stirling's formula _r~(J.L_+_n_)_e-("'-l)IOg(n+l) ~ 1 r(J.L)f(n
+
1)
(as n
~
00).
1.6. Analytic Functionals on the Unit Circle
107
Since Re JL ~ ~, we have for some positive constant A and for n ~ n 1 ~ no that
+ n) I A Ir(JL r(JL)n! ~ (n + 1)1/2' Thus, for some constant B > 0 and r fixed in [0, I [, we have rllli
L IbllllcplI(z,JL)I~B Inl:::n, L Ibll l (lnl+I)I/2' 1111:::111 Since the left-hand side is convergent, we obtain that the power series
Ibnl + Ib_nl rn
"
L..J (n+l)I/2 n:::O
has radius of convergence 1. Since the derivative will have the same radius of convergence, it follows that
0
for any r E [0, 1[. This concludes the proof of Helgason's theorem.
We recommend the reader to consult [He] for a deeper understanding of the material in this section. EXERCISES
1.6.
1. Prove in detail that slow growth.
7)' (1[')
can be characterized as the space of Fourier series of
2. Verify that the topology of Jf(1[') is, in fact,
.c:!=". Show that it is a DFS space.
3. (a) Verify that. for fixed zED, the Fantappi~ decomposition of f: b ~ l/(b - z), is (0. h), with h(w) = l/(w - z). (b) Verify that if Z E C\D. then the Fantappi~ decomposition of the function f: b ~ l/(b - z) is (1..0) with f.. (w) = l/(w - z). Is there any contradiction between the two answers? 4. Show that the Poisson kernel b ~ P(re i6 • b) is the restriction to 'Jl' of the function z~
(1 - r2) z ---'---7:" Z - re i9 I - zre- i9
and verify that the Fantappi~ decomposition of P given in Example 1.6.7 is correct. S. Let h
E
Jf(1[')\{Oj. Characterize the solutions R
E JfI(1[')
of the equation hR
(Hint: See Exercise 1.3.16.)
6. A weight w in Z is a function w: Z ~ [1. oo[ such that w(m
+ n) :5 w(n)w(m)
for any
m. n E Z.
Let us denote Jf.. (1[') = (f E C('Jl'): If I.. := L:nez Icn(f)lw(n) < ooj. (a) Show that Jf.. ('lI') is a Banach algebra for the ordinary product of functions.
= O.
108
1. Boundary Values of Holomorphic Functions and Analytic Functionals
(b) Define H",('f)
= {T
E Jt"'('f):
IIITIII", := sup Icn(T)1 < nEZ
w( -n)
Do} .
Show that H",(1f) is isomorphic to (Jt"w('f»' under the identification
(T, f)
= LCn(f)c_(n+l)(T). neZ
(c) Show that (T, f)
1 . r f(l;)[C(T)(l;/r) = ,-+1lim -2 lrl 1'1:
C(T)(rl;)]dl;.
7. Let G E L1(D,dm) and let g E C('f) be such that for every fJ E COC(iC) one has Show that G E Jt"(D) n C(D) and GI'f g. (Hint: Consider the Fantappil~ transform (GJ, G 2 ) of g and, choosing conveniently /3, show that G2 = O. Use the fact that the Cauchy transform of g inside D coincides with the Poisson transform to conclude that G 2 G and it is continuous to the boundary). Compare with Exercise 1.1.18.
ID G(fJf3/fJz) dz /\ dz = 1'1' f3g dz. =
=
CHAPTER 2
Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
In the first chapter, we have seen how the Leitmotiv of the boundary values of holomorphic functions lead us naturally to introduce several transforms, in particular, the Fourier-Borel and Fourier transforms, and found out that many questions can be posed in equivalent terms in the algebras of entire functions with growth conditions, Exp(Q) and F(£'(R», specially problems relating to convolution equations. In the case of distributions, this relation will be come more evident in Chapter 6. The aim of this chapter is to study a more general class of algebras, the Hormander algebras, Ap(Q). We shall see that the ideal theory of these algebras is intimately related to the study of interpolation varieties. In the previous volume [BG, Chapter 3], we have shown that to be the case for the algebras of holomorphic functions Jf'(Q), and we found out that one could study interpolation questions with the help of the inhomogeneous Cauchy-Riemann equation. The same will be the case here. This time, though, we shall be obliged to consider the problem of solving the Cauchy-Riemann equation with growth constraints. The algebras Ap were used by Hormander in [H03], [H04], who proved they were the correct context in which to study the Cauchy-Riemann equations in en. Throughout this chapter we use this work, as well as that of [KTl], [KT2]. [Gull. [Ski], [Sk2]. [BTl], and [BT3].
2.1. The Algebras Ap In this section we consider the Hormander algebras Ap(Q) of holomorphic functions with growth conditions.
2.1.1. Definition. Let Q be an open subset of
lIO
2. Interpolation and the Algebras Ap
We denote by Wp(Q) the space of all measurable functions g in Q for which there is a constant C ::: 0 such that
i
Ig(z)lze-Cp(Z) dm(z) < 00.
lt is clear that Ap(Q) and Wp(Q) are algebras under the ordinary product of functions.
We will be interested especially in the case Q two additional conditions:
= ([; and we impose on p the
(i) p(z) ::: 0 and log(l + Iz12) = O(p(z». (ii) There are constants Co, Do > 0, such that whenever
I~
- zl ::::: 1, then
+ Do·
pes) ::::: Cop(z)
We will say that p is a weight. A weight p will be called radial if p(z) = p(lz!) (with the obvious abuse of language). These two conditions are useful since they imply the following properties: (a) The space Ap(:C) contains all polynomials: ([;[z] ~ Ap(e). In fact, log(l + Iz12) ::::: Mp(z) for some constant M > O. If Q E C[z] has degree d, then there is a constant C > 0 such that IQ(z)1 ::::: CO + IZI2)d/2. Therefore IQ(z)l::::: Cexp
(d7 P(Z»).
(b) The space Ap(C) is stable under differentiation: If 1 E Ap(e), then l' E Ap(e). Namely, let II(z)1 ::::: AeBp(t) for all z E C, then if Is - zl ::::: I, we have Since f'(z) = _1
r
1(0
(s - z)2
2ni JR-z1=1
ds.
then (c) We have Wp(C) n '*"(C) = Ap(C). If I E Ap(C),II(z)1 ::::: AeBp(z), and 10g(1 that C ::: 28 + 2M. Then
II(z)1 2 e-CP(:)
+ Iz12)
::::: A 1e(2B-C)p(z) ::::: A2 e - 2Mp (z)
::::: A2exp(-210g(l + Iz12» Therefore
I
::::: Mp(z), choose C such
E Wp(C).
= (1 +AI:12)2
E L1(C,dm).
2.1. The Algebras Ap
Conversely, if
I
111 E Wp(C)
k
n Jt"(C), let
I/(z)1 2e- Cp (Z) dm(z) = MI < 00.
Recall that A(I/I, z, r) denotes the area average of III over the disk B(z, r). Then I/(z)1 :::: A(I/I. z, 1)
:: - r I (
It
= ~It } r I/(~)I dm(~) B(z.l)
1/(~)12e-CP(~) dm(~) )
1/2 (
} B(z.l)
r
eCp(~) dm(~) )
1/2
} B(z.l)
:::: (M/lteCDo)I/2exp
(C~o P(Z»)
= AleB1P(z).
This shows that I E Ap(C). For particular choices of p we find some spaces already considered: If If If If
p(z) p(z)
= Izl, we have Ap(C) = Exp(C).
= 10g(1 + IzI 2 ), we have Ap(C) = C[z]. p(z) = I Imzl + log(l + IzI 2 ), we have Ap(C) =
.r(E'(R».
0 =1= C, the analogous technical conditions to introduce are the following (see [H04]). In the cases considered here they will always be satisfied: (i)' log(l + Iz12) = O(p(z». (ii)' There are constants C I , C 2 , C3, C4 > 0 such that if z E 0 and Iz - ~ I :::: exp( -C I p(z) - C 2 ), then ~ E 0 and pel;) :::: C 3P(z) + C 4 •
Note the condition p ~ 0 introduced in (i) above is only for simplicity, it does not affect any of the properties (a), (b), or (c). These three properties will hold for Ap(O) when (i)' and (ii)' are satisfied. Even condition (i)' is only introduced to guarantee that Ap(O) contains the polynomials, which in some cases needs not be assumed. Let Ap.B(O)
= {f E Jt"(O):
IIfIIB
= sup I/(z)1 exp(-Bp(z»
< oo}.
ZEQ
This is a Banach space for the nonn II . liB' Choosing a sequence (Bn)n~j, 0< Bn , strictly increasing to 00, we can introduce an C:J topology on Ap(O)
as the inductive limit Ap(O)
--
= lim Ap.Bn(n). n-->oo
Since it is stronger than the topology of pointwise convergence, this topology ~s independent of the sequence (Bn)n~:' In this topology, a sequence (fJ)j~1 m Ap(O) converges to I in Ap(n), if and only if there is an n such that /j e Ap.Bn (0) for all j, I E AP.Bn (n) and II fJ - I II Bn --+ 0 as j --+ 00. For subspaces, the closure coincides with the sequential closure. In order to follow the methods of L. Honnander to study the spaces Ap. which is based on the solvability of the inhomogeneous Cauchy-Riemann equation
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
112
in the spaces Wp(Q), we need to establish the following a priori inequality (see [BTl)).
2.1.2. Proposition (A Priori Inequality for ajaz). Let Q be an open subset ofe and P a subharmonic lunction in Q. For every I E 1'(Q) we have the inequality
In
I/(z)1 2e P (zJ dm(z)
:s !
In I~~
(Z)( (1
+ IzI2)2e P (zJ dm(z).
Proof. Let PI be any function of class C 2 in Q, then a direct verification shows the following identity holds:
IdZ + I aPl12 + eP1 1/12 8 P: az az az 2
(*) eP1 al
= a_ [e P1 (jal +lfI2aPI)] az az az
_~ (ep'jaf) +ePla~aj. az
az
dZ dZ
Since f has compact support in Q, the integrals of the first two terms on the right hand side of the last identity will vanish. Namely, for any ip E CJ(Q), then 0= ( d(ipdz) = { aip dz /\dz = -2i {
In
In
arp dm,
In az
az
and similarly,
d~ dm.
0= ( d(rpdz) = 2i (
In
In az
Therefore, integrating the identity (*) we obtain
{la~12ePldm=
In
dZ
{1/12a2P:eP'dm+ {Idl +fdPl12ePldm dZ az In az az
In
~ (lfI2a2P~eP'dm.
In
az az
If now P is a C 2 function which is subharmonic in 21og(1 + IzI2). Then
a2pl az dZ
a2p dZ dZ
-- = --
+
2 (1
eP1(Z) =
eP(zJ(1
set PI (z) = p(z)
+
2
+ Iz12)2
and
Q,
> ---;:--;:- (1 + Iz12)2
+ IZI2)2.
Hence, the previous inequality becomes,
in :~ 1
12 (1
+ IzI2)2e P(zJ dm(z)
~ 2 in 1/12e P dm
This is precisely the statement of the proposition. If P is subharmonic but not C 2 , let us regularize p by convolution, Pp:= p *ap, ap(z) = Ojp2)a(lzljp), where a E 1'(B(O, 1»,0 :s a, and Ja dm = 1. The function Pp is subharmonic
2.1. The Algebras A p in Q p supp f
113
= (z E Q: d(z, QC) > ~ Qp •
hi :~ Letting p
~
p}, but for 0 < p sufficiently small we also have
Therefore,
12 (l + Iz12)2 exp(pp(z» dm(z)
~ 2hlfI2exP(pp)dm. o
0 we obtain the proposition.
We are now ready to prove the existence theorem due to L. Hormander [H03].
2.1.3. Theorem. Let Q be an open subset of C, p a subharmonic function in Q, and v a measurable function in Q so that M:=
llvfe- P dm
<
00.
There is then a function u E Lloc(Q) such that au/ai = v, in the sense of distributions, and ( lu(z)1 2 e-p(z) dm(z) < M.
irl.
Furthermore,
if v
E
(1
+ Iz12)2
Coo then
U E
-
2
Coo.
=
L2(Q, eP dm) and HI = L2(Q, (1 + IZI2)2e P dm). The dual H~ of the Hilbert space Ho can be identified to L2(Q, e- P dm) thanks to the pairing
Proof. Let Ho
(g, f}o:=
l
fgdm.
Similarly, the dual H{ of HI can be identified to L 2(Q, e-p(z) /[0 (by the same pairing)
(g, f}1 :=
l
+ Iz12)2] dm)
fgdm.
We denote by II'II) and III·III} the norms in H} and Hj, respectively, j = 0, 1. Since p is subhannonic, the function e P is locally bounded, hence in Lloc(Q)· Therefore, D(Q) ~ Ho. Clearly, this space is dense in Ho, since if g E L2(Q, e- P dm) is such that Iri. 'Pg dm = 0 for every 'P E V(Q) one has g 0 a.e. For the same reason D(Q) is dense in H J • Note also that, because p is locally bounded above, Hj ~ Lloc(Q), j = 0, l. Let us consider the unbounded operator T: Ho ~ H], with domain dom(T) = D(Q), defined by
=
T(f)
af
= - az'
This operator has a well-defined adjoint IT (since dom(T) is dense), IT: H{ ~ Ho. Recall that the domain of I T is dom(tT) = {u
If U
E
E
H{: f
1-+
(u, T(f)}J is continuous on dom(T)}.
domcrT), then the linear map
f
1-+
(u, T(f»)) extends to Ho in a unique Ho such
way as a continuous linear fonn, that is, it determines an element v E
114
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A f'
that for every IE D(n)
(v, /)0
=f
In
vI dm
= (u, T(f)}) = - f u (J~ dm. In (Jz
From the definition of the adjoint, IT(u) = v. This means that ouj8z = v. in the sense of distributions. In other words. the first statement of Theorem 2.1.3 can be paraphrased by saying that IT must be surjective. Let us prove this. Let v E H6 = L2(n, e- P dm). and consider the linear functional L defined on the range of T. Im(T) £: HJ, by (L. T(f»)) = (v.
f)o
(f E dom(T».
The operator T is injective since. if T (f) = 0, then I is holomorphic and with compact support. Hence L is well defined by this formula. Let us apply Schwarz's inequality and Proposition 2.1.2. then I(L. T(f)}d 2 =
110 vI dml2 ~ (10 1/1 e dm ) (10 Ivl e2 P
~ ! (in I~~ 12 (1 + IzI
e
2 )2 P(z)
2
dm )
p
dm)
IIlvlll~ = !IIlvl"~"T(f)"i·
This shows that L is continuous on the subspace Im(T) of HI. By the Hahn-Banach theorem we know there is an extension of L to HI represented by a function u E HI = L 2 (n, e-P(l + IzI2)-2 dm) such that
IIlulili ~ 1111vlll~ Therefore. for
I
E
M
= 2'
dom(T) we have (v,
no = (L. T(f))) = (u, T(f»)).
which means. as we said earlier. (Juj(Jz = v in the sense of distributions. The integral estimate of u is precisely IIlulll! ~ M12. Finally. the proof of the regularity of the solution u when v E COC(n). follows from [BG. §3.2.1 and §3.6.5). (See also Exercise 2.1.1.) 0 Remark. The Hormander Theorem 2.1.3 involves only L 2 estimates. In relation to the attempts to prove the HOC corona theorem in the case of several variables. there has been a number of recent works on the corresponding LP estimates for in domains n of C. On this subject we refer the reader to [Am). [Bernd). [FS). and the references therein.
a
One of the main results we present in this chapter is an interpolation theorem for the Ap spaces. An intermediary step is a semilocal interpolation theorem. which uses the preceding existence theorem for the Cauchy-Riemann operator
a/oz.
2.1. The Algebras A"
115
If fI, ... , fm E Ap(Q) we set IfI 2 := Ifl12 C > 0, we introduce the open sets
+ ... + Ifml 2
and for E > 0,
S(lfl, E, C) := (z E 0: If(z)1 < Ee-Cp(z)} (0 will be left implicit in the notation.)
2.1.4. Theorem (Semilocal Interpolation Theorem). Let p be a subharmonic weight function in C, fl,"" fm E Ap(
holds for some constants A > 0, B > O. Then there are: (1) ).. E Ap(IC); (2) strictly positive constants E', C', A', B',O < E' < E, C' > C; (3) holomorphic functions ai, ... , am in S(lf!. E', C'); and such thatfor every z E SClfl, E', C'):
)..(z)=X(z)+
(a)
I:
a,(z)fj(z);
I:::J:::.i
and (b) (Zk)k~1 is the family of common zeros to all the fj, j = I, ... , m, and if their multiplicities (as a common zero) are denoted by mk, one concludes from (a) that>..(j) (Zk) = X(j)(zd for 0:::: j :::: mk - 1 and every k 2: 1. Therefore, given a sequence (ak,i h,i of complex numbers the problem of finding).. E Ap(C) such that
Remark. If
k 2: 1,
0 :::: j :::: mk - 1,
can be reduced to the same problem for a function i in S(lfl. E, C). This explains the reason of the terminology "semilocal" applied to Theorem 2.1.4.
Proof of Theorem 2.1.4. Let us first show that there are 0 < EI < s, C I > C, AI > 0, and BI > 0, such that, for z E S(lfl, EI, C I ), the distance from z to as(lfl, E, C) is at least exp( -AIP(z) - Bd.1t is enough to find those constants for those z E IC such that d(z, as(lfl, E, C» :::: 1 (if this set is nonempty). Let z' E aSCI!I. E, C) be such that Iz - z'l = dist(z. as(I!I. E. C» :::: 1. For t E [0, 1], let rp(t) = If(z + t(z' - z»12. There are A2 > O. B2 > such that Irp'(t) I :::: A21z - z'l exp(B 2 P(z». (Here we use not only that jj E Ap(
°
We have E 2 exp(-2Cp(z'»
= 1!(z')1 2 = ep(l):s rp(O)
+ tEIO,I] max lep'(!)1
: : Sf exp( -2C t p(z» + A21z -
z'l exp(B2P(Z».
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
116
when z E SOfl, et. Cd. Since p(z') :::: Cop(z) 1e2e-2CDo then we get
+ Do,
if C I ~ 2CCo and er <
e2
Iz - z'l ~ 2A2 e- 2CDo exp(-(2CCo + B2 )p(z», which allows us to detennine eI. Ct. AI. BI > 0 as required. A corollary of this result is the following lemma: 2.1.5. Lemma. There is a function X of class COO in C, 0 :::: X :::: 1, such that: (a) supp X (b) X (c)
~
S(lfl, e, C);
== 1 on SOfl, el, C I );
there are two positive constants A3, B3 such that (z E C).
Proof of Lemma 2.1.5. The fact that for z E SOtl, el, CI) we have the inequality d(z, as(lfl, e, C» ~ exp(-AIP(z) - B I ), allows us to apply Whitney's partition of the unity lemma (see [BO, §1.3.5]). 0 We continue with the proof of the theorem. The function XX, extended to be zero outside SOfl, e, C), is a Coo function in C. Let us introduce
h a -
j = l .... ,m.
Vj := -1/1 2 8z (XA),
These functions are also Coo and there are constants A 4 ,
B4
> 0 such that
IVj(z)1 :::: A4 e B4P (z). In fact. in SOfl, el, C I ) we have Vj ef exp( -2C I P(z», hence
= O.
IVj(z)1 :::: A: Ijj(z)le(2C 1+B3)P(Z)IX(z)1 e1
In the complement, If(z)1 2 ::::
(z E S(lfl. E,
and the required inequality follows. Theorem 2.1.3 ensures there are functions A
Uj E
C)\S(I/I. el. CI »
Wp(C)
n £(C) such that
= xX + UJ/l + ... + urnfm.
It is clearly in Wp(C) and
81.. _ 8(X I ) 8z 8z
+
f ~ I
8z
+
...
I"
+ Jrn
8u rn _ 8(X I )
8z -
8z
_ ""
hh 8(xl) = o. a-Z
~ Ifl2
l;5j;5m
Therefore, A E Wp(C) n Jt"(C) = Ap(C). Since Vj = 0 in S(lfl. 81. Cl). the functions aj defined by the restrictions Uj ISO/I. 81, Cl ) are holomorphic, and part (a) of the theorem holds.
2.1. The Algebras Ap
117
°
Let us choose now < 62 < 81, C 2 > C h E > 0, F > 0, such that if z E S(lfl, 82, C 2 ), then dist(z, S(lfl, 81, C1n > exp( -Ep(z) - F). This is possible by the reasoning at the very beginning of the proof. We also know we can find K > 0, M > 0, such that for every j:
k
IUj 12 e- Kp dm .::: M <
00.
Therefore, for z E S(lfl, 82, C2) we have laj(z)1 2 .::: A(!ajI2, z, exp(-Ep(z) - F»
= (
r
JB(z.exp(-Ep(z)-F»
I
.::: - exp«KCo rr
x
~
M rr
. exp(2Ep(z) rr
+ 2F)
+ 2E)p(z) + K Do + 2F)
JB(z.exp(-Ep(z)-F»
.::: _eKDo+2F
IUj(~)12 dm(~»)
IUj(OI2 e-Kp(O
exp«KCo
dm(~)
+ 2E)p(z».
This proves all the estimates required in the theorem.
o
EXERCISES 2.1.
1. The purpose of this exercise is to give two slightly different proofs that if au/ai = v in the sense of distributions and v E C""(Q), then u E C""(Q), as stated in Theorem 2.1.3. (a) [BG, Theorem 3.2.1] states that alai: COO(Q) -+ COO(Q) is surjective, and [BG, Proposition 3.6.5] states that if WE V'(Q) and aw/ai = 0, then W E Jt"(Q). Use these two statements to conclude that the function u E HI found in the proof of Theorem 2.1.3 belongs to COO(Q) if v E COO(Q). (b) (Direct proof.) Let E = 1/1rz and recall that (a/ai)E = (, in the sense of distributions. Let now u E V'(Q), v E C""(Q), and au/az = v. Let Q' be an arbitrary open subset of Q, Q' cc Q, and choose rp E V(Q) so that rp :; I on a neighborhood of Q'. (i) Show that (o/ai)(rpu) = v + w, W E E'(Q), supP(w) ~ (Q'Y. (ii) Show that if 1/1 E V(Q), 1/1 == I on a neighborhood of supp(rp), then
a
az'rpu)
= 1/Iv + Wit
WI E E'(Q),
SUPP(WI) ~ (Q')c.
(iii) Conclude that
rpu
(iv) Let B. E V(B(O, 0<8« I so that
6»
= E * (l/rv) + E * WI.
be such that B, =< 1 on 8(0,8/2). Show that you can choose supp«9E E)
(v) Writing E
= (I -
* WI) n Q' = 0.
+ BEE, show that in Q' one has the identity u = E * (l/rv) + «1 - BE)E) * WI.
9E)E
Why does this identity imply that u is a Coo function in Q'? O'his proof and that of [BG, Proposition 3.6.5] are originally due to A. Grothendieck.)
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A I'
118
2. The aim of this exercise is to show that Theorem 2.1.3 can be used to prove that %z: COO(O) --* COO CO) is surjective for any open set 0 in C. Ci) Let (Xn)n~1 be a strictly increasing sequence of numbers Xn > 0 such that limn .... 00 Xn = 00, and (Vn)n~h another sequence with Vn 2: O. Show that there exists a strictly increasing convex function 0, and let d n = d(Kn, OC). Show there is a convex, strictly increasing function
0'»
satisfies the inequalities p (z) :::: log IAn ,
=
for all z E k n \Kn - I , n 2: 1. (Define Ko ¢.) Why is p a subharmonic function in O? (iii) For 0 C, (rn)n~I' a strictly increasing sequence of positive numbers, convergent to 00, and (IAn).;,::h a sequence of strictly positive numbers, show there is a subharmonic function p in C such that p(z) 2: log IAn,
=
for all Z E 8(0, rn)\B(O, rn-I), n :::: I. (Define ro = -1.) (iv) Let f E &(0), show that there is a subharmonic function p in 0 such that
i
If1 2 e- P dm <
00.
=
Conclude that there is a locally integrable function g in 0 such that og/oi f in the sense of distributions. Use Exercise 2.1.1 (d) to conclude, without appeal to the results in [8G, §3.2.1], that
o oi: COO(n>
--*
C""(O)
is surjective.
3. Let p be a subharmonic function in an open set 0
t= C satisfying (a) log (1 + Iz12) =
O(p(z», ZEn, and (b) there exist constants C" C 2 , C 3 , C4 > 0 such that if ZEn, ~ E C, and Iz - ~I ~ exp(-C1P(z) - C 2 ), then ~ En and ~ C3 P(z) + C4 • Show that Wp(O) nJe'(O) = Ap(O).
pen
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions In [BG, §3.5] we have introduced the concept of a multiplicity variety V. Let us recall that it consists of a collection of pairs (Zk> mk), Zk distinct points of C, mk E N*, called the multiplicities of the points Zko and either the collection is finite or IZk I --+ 00. We shall assume throughout that we are in the latter case. We say that 1; E V to indicate that 1; is one of the points Zk. Given two multiplicity varieties, V = (Zko mdk~l, V' = (z;, mj)j~l' we say that V' C; V when (z;)j~1 is a subsequence of (zkh~l and, for the corresponding indices, we have mj ~ mk. For f an entire function, f ¢ 0, V (f) is the collection of zeros of f, with their respective multiplicities. More generally, we recall that for a collection of functions (h )jeJ. V «h )jeJ) denotes the multiplicity variety of their common zeros (Zdk~l and common multiplicities mk = inf{m(fj. Zk) :
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
119
j E Jl. The Weierstrass theorem [BG, §3.3.l] asserts that for every multiplicity variety V, there is I E Jt"(C) such that V = V (f). Given a multiplicity variety V, we also defined the space A(V) of holomorphic functions on V, i.e., doubly indexed sequences of complex numbers (ak,l )k,[, 0 .::s [ < mk. The reason for this notation is that there is a natural restriction map p: Jt"(C) -+ A(V) given by
g(I)(Zk») peg) = ( - [ - I•
. k,1
Given a sequence a E A(V) we say that the entire function g interpolates it, if peg) = a. The interpolation theorem [BG, §3.4.1] states that p is always surjective. The proof uses in an essential manner that variety V satisfies V = V(f) for some IE Jt"(C)\{Oj. In this section we discuss the corresponding interpolation problem for the space Ap (C). We shall assume throughout that the multiplicity variety V satisfies the non triviality condition V S; V(f)
for some I E Ap(C)\{Oj. We follow [BT 1] and we refer the reader to the references therein for other approaches to the interpolation problem. We start first by defining a space of holomorphic functions with growth conditions on a multiplicity variety. This space must be a good candidate to be the image of Ap(C) by the restriction map p: Jt"(C) -+ A(V). It turns out that there are several natural candidates. The first one is given in the following definition: 2.2.1. Definition. Let V = (Zk> mdk;::l be a multiplicity variety. We denote by Ap(V) the space of sequences (ak,{ h,l E A(V) such that there are constants A, B ~ 0 for which
L
lak'!l.::s
A exp(Bp(Zk»
(k ~
1).
O::;:i<m,
2.2.2. Proposition. For any I that
LI
1(I)(z)
- - I-
1;::0
I.
E Ap(C)
there are constants A ~ 0, B ~ 0, such
I .::s Aexp(Bp(z»
(z E C).
In particular, p(Ap(C» S; Ap(V).
Proof, Assume that I/(t)1 .::s A1eB1p(t) for every t E C. Let z E C be fixed. For any t E B(z. 2) there is { E B(z. 1) such that It - {I .::s 1, hence pet)
.::s
Cop(l;)
+ Do .::s cJp(z) + (Co + l)Do.
Taking these inequalities into account, the Cauchy inequalities 1(/)(z)
I-1-'• -
I
1
:::; 21 II-zl::::2 max 1/(t)1
2. Interpolation and the Algebras A p
120
yield the following estimate:
~ If(l)(z) I:5 2 ~ where A
I!
max If(t)1 :5 2 max AleB'P(t) :5 AeBp(z) , II-zl:S2
II-zl!:2
= 2Ale(Co+I)Do, B = BleB.
o
In general, as we shall see in some examples below, Ap(V) #- p(Ap(C». The reason is that the definition of Ap(V) was done basically taking only into account local conditions. In order to facilitate the appearance of global conditions we proceed as follows: Let r > 0 and z E C, define p(z, r) := maxp(z 1'1:5'
+ ~).
The same argument as that in Proposition 2.2.2 leads to the existence of A > 0, B > 0, such that f(l)(z) I L r' :5 A exp(Bp(z, r», I t~O I. - - I-
for any
z E IC
and
r > O.
This inequality leads naturally to a different candidate for a space of holomorphic functions with growth conditions on a multiplicity variety.
2.2.3. Definition. Let V = (Zko mdk~1 be a multiplicity variety, denote by Ap,oo(V) the space of sequences (ak,th" E A(V) for which there are constants A > 0, B > 0, such that for every r > 0 and every k E N*
L
lak,dr':5 A exp(B(p(Zko r».
O:sl<mk
The following result is immediate:
2.2.4. Proposition. The following inclusions hold: p(Ap(C»
S Ap,oo(V) S Ap(V).
We are now ready to state the interpolation problems of interest to us.
2.2.5. Definition. Let V = (Zko mkh~l be a multiplicity variety. We say that V is an interpolation variety for Ap(C) if p(Ap(C) = Ap(V). If p(Ap(C» = Ap,oo(V) we say that V is a weak interpolation variety. These are only two, the simplest two, definitions of interpolation variety. We shall only study the problem of deciding when V is an interpolation variety, and relegate the similar study for weak interpolation varieties to the exercises.
2.2.6. Lemma. Let V = (Zk, mk)k~l be an interpolation variety for Ap(IC). There are two constants, Clo C2 > 0, and functions hk E Ap(C) such that for every k 2: 1:
2.2. Interpolation with Growth Conditions
(i) Ihk(z)1 :::: CI exp(c2P(Z» (z E C); (ii) for every j ::f. k, one has hj/)(zd
(iii) hfl (Zk) = 0 for all 0 :::: I :::: (iv) him.-1)(Zk) = (mk - I)!.
121
= 0 for 0:::: I :::: mk -
I;
2;
mk -
In other words, (p(hk»j,1
= 8j ,k 81,m.-I,
where 8a ,b is the Kronecker delta symbol.
Proof. We leave it as an exercise for the reader to give a simple proof based on the open mapping theorem. We give here a proof using a minimum of functional analysis. For that purpose, let S := {(ak,/)
L
E Ap(V):
laul:::: I for every
k
~ I}.
O:sl<m.
Consider on S the distance induced by the norm
III (ak,/) II I := sup
L
lak,/l.
k:::I O:;:l<m.
It is easy to verify that S is a complete metric space. For n E N°, let Sn := {p(/): f E Ap(C), If(z)1 :::: n exp(np(z», Vz E
q n s.
We claim that Sn is a closed subset of S. Let (gj)j:::1 be a sequence in Ap(