Commun. Math. Phys. 286, 1–38 (2009) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0676-1
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP, with Applications to Random Matrix Theory Mark Adler1, , Pierre van Moerbeke1,2,, , Pol Vanhaecke3, 1 Department of Mathematics, Brandeis University, Waltham,
Mass 02454, USA. E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Département de Mathématiques, Université Catholique de Louvain,
1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium. E-mail:
[email protected]
3 Laboratoire de Mathématiques et Applications, UMR 6086 du CNRS,
Université de Poitiers, Poitiers Cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 21 June 2007 / Accepted: 22 August 2008 Published online: 21 November 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: Questions on random matrices and non-intersecting Brownian motions have led to the study of moment matrices with regard to several weights. The main result of this paper is to show that the determinants of such moment matrices satisfy, upon adding one set of “time” deformations for each weight, the multi-component KP-hierarchy: these determinants are thus “tau-functions” for these integrable hierarchies. The tau-functions, so obtained, with appropriate shifts of the time-parameters (forward and backwards) will be expressed in terms of multiple orthogonal polynomials for these weights and their Cauchy transforms. The main result is a vast generalization of a known fact about infinitesimal deformations of orthogonal polynomials: it concerns an identity between the orthogonality of polynomials on the real line, the bilinear identity in KP theory and a generating functional for the full KP theory. An additional fact not discussed in this paper is that these τ -functions satisfy Virasoro constraints with respect to these time parameters. As one of the many examples worked out in this paper, we consider N non-intersecting Brownian motions in R leaving from the origin, pwith n i particles forced to reach p distinct target points bi at time t = 1; of course, i=1 n i = N . We give a PDE, in terms of the boundary points of the interval E, for the probability that the Brownian particles all pass through an interval E at time 0 < t < 1. It is given by the determinant of a ( p + 1) × ( p + 1) matrix, which is nearly a wronskian. This theory is also applied to biorthogonal polynomials and orthogonal polynomials on the circle.
The support of a National Science Foundation grant # DMS-07-04271 is gratefully acknowledged.
The support of a National Science Foundation grant # DMS-07-04271, a European Science Foundation
grant (MISGAM), a Marie Curie Grant (ENIGMA), a FNRS grant and a “Interuniversity Attraction Pole” grant is gratefully acknowledged. The support of a European Science Foundation grant (MISGAM), a Marie Curie Grant (ENIGMA) and a ANR grant (GIMP) is gratefully acknowledged.
2
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
Contents 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Tau Functions and Mixed Multiple Orthogonal Polynomials . . . . . . . . . Cauchy Transforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Duality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Riemann-Hilbert Matrix and the Bilinear Identity . . . . . . . . . . . . Consequences of the Bilinear Identities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1 Biorthogonal polynomials ( p = q = 1) and orthogonal polynomials . . 7.2 Orthogonal polynomials on the circle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Non-intersecting Brownian motions and the p +q-component KP hierarchy 7.4 Non-intersecting Brownian motions leaving from one point, forced to p target points and a PDE for the transition probability . . . . . . . . . .
2 9 12 17 18 21 26 26 29 30 32
1. Introduction Random matrix theory has led to the discovery of novel matrix models and novel statistical distributions, which are defined by means of Fredholm determinants (e.g., [28,32,34]) and which, in many cases, satisfy nonlinear ordinary or partial differential equations. A crucial observation is that these matrix integrals, upon appropriate deformation by means of exponentials containing one or several series of time parameters, satisfy (i) integrable equations and (ii) Virasoro constraints with respect to these time parameters [5,8–11]. Most of the time, such matrix integrals can be written — by expressing the integrand in “polar coordinates” — as a multiple integral, which then can be expressed in terms of the determinant of a moment matrix; this may be a moment matrix with regard to one or several weights. The extra time parameters are added in such a way that each weight has its own exponential time deformation. It turns out that the determinant of such moment matrices satisfies (i) and (ii). These features turn out to be extremely robust! The purpose of the present paper is to show point (i) in great generality: the determinant of moment matrices associated with one or several weights and defined on various different domains satisfies the multi-component KP hierarchy with regard to the additional time parameters. The multi-component KP hierarchy is a very general class of integrable equations, to be discussed later [15,21,23, 25,29,36,39]. The combination of the multi-component KP and the Virasoro constraints leads to PDE’s for the transition probabilities for non-intersecting Brownian motions, as will be illustrated in the very last section. This in turn leads to PDE’s for universal scaling limits of the Brownian motions, like the Airy, Pearcey processes and others [3,10,11,13,17–19,34,35]. This determinant will turn out to be the τ -function of this integrable hierarchy. But much more is true, this τ -function with appropriate shifts of the deformation variables will be expressed in terms of the “orthogonal polynomials” defined by the weights and their Cauchy transform. In general, it is known that the determinants of bi-moment matrices (sometimes Hänkel and Toeplitz matrices) serve as τ -functions for the Toda [5,7,16,26,31], 2d-Toda [6,10,36], Toeplitz lattice [8,9] and Ablowitz-Ladik hierarchies [1,2], to name but a few examples [6,7,16]. We list below a number of such examples having their origin in Hermitian random matrix theory, in random matrices coupled in a chain, in random permutations and in Dyson Brownian motions (non-intersecting Brownian motions) on R leaving from the origin, where some paths are forced to end up
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
3
at one point and others at another point, etc. These examples will be discussed in detail in Sect. 7, along with suitable references and will be deduced from the main theorems of this paper1 . • Hermitian random matrix models: classical orthogonal polynomials, with a Hänkel moment matrix, satisfying the standard Toda lattice in the tk ’s: n ∞ ∞ 1 2 tk z k i+ j tk z k k=1 k=1 (z) e ρ(z )dz = det z e ρ(z)dz . n! E n n R 0≤i, j≤n−1 =1
• Coupled random matrices / Dyson Brownian motions: bi-orthogonal polynomials with moment matrices satisfying the 2d-Toda lattice in the tk and sk ’s [6,10]: n ∞ k k 1 n (x)n (y) e k=1 (tk x −sk y ) ρ(x , y )d x dy n! E n =1 ∞ k k = det x i y j e k=1 (tk x −sk y ) ρ(x, y)d xd y . E
0≤i, j≤n−1
• Longest increasing subsequences in random permutations: orthogonal polynomials on the circle S 1 , with Toeplitz moment matrices satisfying the Toeplitz lattice2 in the tk and sk ’s [8,9]: n ∞ −k k 1 dz e k=1 (tk z −sk z ) √ |n (z)|2 n! (S 1 )n 2π −1z =1 ∞ dz k −k = det z i− j e k=1 (tk z −sk z ) . √ S 1 2π −1z 0≤i, j≤n−1 • N = n 1 + . . . + n p non-intersecting Brownian motions on R leaving from 0 with n i paths forced to end up at p distinct points: multiple orthogonal polynomials on R, with a p block moment matrix, satisfying the p + 1-KP hierarchy in t := (t1 , . . . ), () s () := (s1 , . . .), with 1 ≤ ≤ p, [4,20] n ∞ p () 1 t (x )i τn 1 ,...,n p (t; s (1) , . . . , s ( p) ) = p N (x (1) , . . . , x ( p) ) e i=1 i j N 1 n ! E =1 j=1 ⎛ ⎞ n p 2 () 1 − x +b x () +β x ()2 −∞ s () x ()i () j j i=1 i j dx ⎝n (x () ) ⎠ × e 2 j j =1
j=1
⎛
⎞
(1) (µ )0≤i≤n 1 −1, 0≤ j≤N −1 ⎟ ⎜ ij
⎟ ⎜. = det ⎜ .. ⎟, ⎠ ⎝ ( p) (µi j )0≤i≤n p −1, 0≤ j≤N −1
with () µi() j (t, s , β ) =
E˜
x i+ j e−
x2 2 2 +b x+β x
e
∞ 1
()
(tk −sk )x k
d x.
1 Throughout the paper, (z) denotes the Vandermonde determinant of its components z , . . . , z . n n 1 2 Whenever t = s , the Toeplitz lattice [8] reduces to the Ablowitz-Ladik system [1,2]. k k
4
•
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
q
p = β=1 n β non-intersecting Brownian motions on R, with m α paths starting at aα ∈ R and n β paths forced to end up at bβ : mixed multiple orthogonal polynomials (mixed mops) on R, with a moment matrix consisting of pq blocks, satisfying the p + q KP-hierarchy. [20] α=1 m α
Orthogonal polynomials and the KP-hierarchy. The main result of this paper is a vast generalization of a known fact for orthogonal polynomials (see e.g. [7] and references within). Given a weight ρ(z) on R decaying fast enough at infinity, a formal deformation ∞ k by means of an exponential ρ(x) → ρt (x) := ρ(x)e 1 tk x , and a symmetric inner product between functions f and g, R f (x)g(x)ρt (x) d x, denote by τn (t) the determinant of the following (Hänkel) moment matrix depending on t = (t1 , t2 , . . .), ∞ k τn (t) := det z i+ j e 1 tk z ρ(z)dz . R
0≤i, j≤n−1
Then, the monic orthogonal polynomials pn (x) := pn (t; x) with regard to this weight ρt (x) and their Cauchy transform are given in terms of the determinant τn (t) by means of backwards and forward shifts3 involving z ∈ R; in other terms, shifting t backwards by [z −1 ] in the function τ (t) yields a polynomial in z and forward the Cauchy transform of that polynomial, −1 −1 pn (x) n τn (t − [z ]) −n−1 τn+1 (t + [z ]) = pn (z) and = ρt (x)d x. (1) z z τn (t) τn (t) z R −x Moreover, the integral below can be computed in two different ways: on the one hand, it is automatically zero, because pn (z) is perpendicular to any polynomial of lower degree; on the other hand, for t and t close to each other, the integral can also be developed in a Taylor series in t − t = 2y, passing via a so-called bilinear identity, yielding the following identities4 for arbitrary t, t ∈ C∞ , 0 = τn (t)τn (t ) pn (t; z) pn−1 (t ; z)ρt (z)dz 1 = 2πi =
∞ 3
τn (t − [z
−1
])τn (t + [z
−1
])e
∞ 1
(ti −ti )z i
z=∞
yk
t →t−y t →t+y
R
∂2 ∂t1 ∂tk
dz t →t−y
t →t+y
τn ◦ τn + O(y 2 ), − 2Sk+1 ∂˜t
(2)
2 showing that τn (t) satisfies the family of non-linear PDE’s, ∂t∂1 ∂tk − 2Sk+1 ∂˜t τn ◦ τn = 0, k = 3, 4, . . . , which describes the KP hierarchy [21]. Thus, orthogonality yields the so-called KP bilinear identity for tau-functions τn (t) and by a residue calculation PDE’s for τn (t) [21]. The point of this paper is to show the robustness of this point 3 Introduce the notation [α] := (α, α 2 , α 3 , . . .) for α ∈ C. 2 3 4 For a given polynomial p(t , t , . . . ), the Hirota symbol between functions f = f (t , t , . . .) and 1 2 1 2 g = g(t1 , t2 , . . .) is defined by: p( ∂t∂ , ∂t∂ , . . . ) f ◦ g := p( ∂∂y , ∂∂y , . . . ) f (t + y)g(t − y) y=0 . We also 1 2 2 ∞ k1 need the elementary Schur polynomials S , defined by e 1 tk z := k≥0 Sk (t)z k for ≥ 0 and S (t) = 0 for < 0; moreover, set S (∂˜t ) := S ( ∂t∂ , 21 ∂t∂ , 13 ∂t∂ , . . .). 1 2 3
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
5
of view: namely all this can appropriately be generalized to moment matrices for several weights. A moment matrix for several weights. Define two sets of weights ψ1 (x), . . . , ψq (x) and ϕ1 (y), . . . , ϕ p (y), with x, y ∈ R, and deformed weights depending on time parameters sα = (sα1 , sα2 , . . .) (1 ≤ α ≤ q) and tβ = (tβ1 , tβ2 , . . .) (1 ≤ β ≤ p), denoted by ψα−s (x) := ψα (x)e−
∞
k=1 sαk x
k
and
ϕβt (y) := ϕβ (y)e
∞
k=1 tβk y
k
.
That is, each weight goes with its own set of times. For each set of positive integers5 m = (m 1 , . . . , m q ), n = (n 1 , . . . , n p ) with |m| = |n|, consider the determinant of a ij moment matrix Tmn of size |m| = |n|, composed of pq blocks Tmn of sizes (m i , n j ); the moments are taken with regard to a (not necessarily symmetric) inner product · | ·, ⎛
⎞ 11 . . . T 1 p Tmn mn ⎜ . . ⎟ τmn (s1 , . . . , sq ; t1 , . . . , t p ) := det Tmn := det ⎜ (3) . ⎟ ⎝ .. . ⎠ q1 qp Tmn . . . Tmn ⎞ ⎛ j t −s i x ψ1 (x)y ϕ1 (y) 0≤i<m 1 . . . x i ψ1−s (x) y j ϕ tp (y) 0≤i<m 1 ⎜ 0≤ j
0≤ j
A typical inner product to keep in mind is f (x) | g(y) = R2 f (x)g(y) dµ(x, y), where µ = µ(x, y) is a fixed measure on R2 , perhaps having support on a line or curve. From moment matrices to polynomials and their Cauchy transforms. As in (1), one introduces backward and forward shifts (by [z −1 ]) of the arguments in the expressions τmn (s1 , . . . , sq ; t1 , . . . , t p ), but also shifts by ±1 of the indices m = (m 1 , . . . , m q ), n = (n 1 , . . . , n p ); the expressions obtained will turn out to be orthogonal polynomials, in some generalized sense, and their Cauchy transforms. I. Then, for 1 ≤ β, β ≤ p, the following expressions are polynomials (with coefficients depending on s and t)6 −1 ) n β τmn (tβ − z nβ z := Q (β,β) + ..., mn (z) = z τmn −1 (4) τ (t − z ) ) of degree < n β n β −1 m,n+eβ −eβ β (β,β εββ (n)z := Q mn (z), for β = β, τmn satisfying, for each β, the following orthogonality conditions: p 1≤α≤q i −s (β,β ) t Q mn (y)ϕβ (y) = 0 for x ψα (x) 0 ≤ i ≤ m α − 1. β =1
(5)
p 5 |m| = q α=1 m α and |n| = β=1 n β . 6 Remember the notation [α] := (α, α 2 , α 3 , . . .) for α ∈ C. Only shifted times will be made explicit in the 2 3 τ -functions; i.e., τmn (t − z −1 ) means that τmn still depends on all time parameters, but the variable t only gets shifted. Moreover, here and below all the expressions εαβ (n), αβ (n, m), etc. . . all equal ±1 and will be given later. Throughout the paper, we use the standard notation e1 = (1, 0, 0, . . .), e2 = (0, 1, 0, . . .), . . .
6
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
II. In the same way, the following expressions are polynomials (depending on s and t):
βα (n, m) z m α −1
τm−eα ,n−eβ (sα + [z −1 ]) τmn
∗(β,α) = Pnm (z) of degree < m α ,
(6)
satisfying, for each β, the orthogonality relations ⎧ q ⎪ 1 ≤ β ≤ p, 0 ≤ j ≤ n β − 1 ⎪ ∗(β,α) −s j t ⎪ y P (x)ψ (x) ϕ = 0 for (y) ⎪ nm α β ⎪ except β = β, j = n β − 1 ⎪ ⎨ α=1 (7) q ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ∗(β,α) ⎪ Pnm (x)ψα−s (x) y n β −1 ϕβt (y) = 1. ⎪ ⎩ α=1
III. The following expressions are Cauchy transforms of the polynomials obtained in II: t q −1 ϕ (y) ) β −n β τmn (tβ + z ∗(β,α) −s = Pnm (x)ψα (x) z , z−y τmn α=1 t q (8) ϕ (y) τ (t + z −1 ) β −n β −1 m,n+eβ −eβ β ∗(β,α) −s = Pnm (x)ψα (x) . εββ (n)z z−y τmn α=1
IV. Similarly, the following expressions are Cauchy transforms of the polynomials obtained in I: p −1 ]) −s (x) τ (s − [z ψ m+e ,n+e α α β α −m α −1 (β,β ) t
αβ (m, n) z = Q mn (y)ϕβ (y) . (9) τmn z − x β =1
The statements I, II, III and IV summarize Sects. 1, 2 and 3. As will appear in Sect. 2, the polynomials appearing in (I) are called Type II | t mixed multiple orthogoϕβ
nal polynomials, whereas those appearing in (II) Type I | t mixed multiple orthogonal ψα polynomials. These were introduced by E. Daems and A. Kuijlaars [20], in the context of non-intersecting Brownian motions; they are a generalization of multiple orthogonal polynomials, where instead of one set of weights, there are two sets (the classical orthogonal polynomials correspond to one set with one element). The multiple orthogonal polynomials themselves were introduced and studied by Aptekarev, Bleher, Geronimo, Kuijlaars, Van Assche [14,17,37,38]. Around the same time, they were introduced by Adler-van Moerbeke in the context of band matrices and vertex operator solutions to the KP hierarchy [7]. In [17,18], they were used in the context of non-intersecting Brownian motions and random matrices with external source. The ( p + q)-KP hierarchy and the Riemann-Hilbert matrix. Define two matrices Wmn (z) ∗ (z) of size p + q, whose entries are given by ratios of determinants τ and Wmn mn of moment matrices as above, but with appropriately shifted t and s parameters. They turn out to be the wave and dual wave matrices for the ( p + q)-KP hierarchy. This multicomponent KP hierarchy is a natural generalization of the KP-hierarchy involving Lax equations, wave operators, and τ -functions.
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
7
The KP-hierarchy, from the point of view of τ -function theory, has been extensively discussed by Date-Jimbo-Miwa-Kashiwara [21] and Zabrodin [39] and multi-component KP by Ueno-Takesaki [36] and then further by Bergvelt-ten Kroode [15], Kac-van de Leur [29], Dickey [23] and others. It is remarkable that, upon setting all t and s parameters equal to zero, the matrix Wmn (z) below is precisely the Riemann-Hilbert matrix characterizing the mixed multiple ∗ (z) at t = s = 0 satisfies the Riemann-Hilbert orthogonal polynomials! Similarly Wmn problem characterizing alternately the “dual” multiple orthogonal polynomials or the inverse transpose matrix of Wmn (z) at t = s = 0. The Riemann-Hilbert matrix for the multiple-orthogonal polynomials has been defined in Daems-Kuijlaars [20], which is a far generalization of the Riemann-Hilbert matrix of Fokas-Its-Kitaev [24] and DeiftZhou [22]. Using identities as in I to IV, the two left blocks of Wmn and the two right ∗ are mixed multiple orthogonal polynomials, and the remaining blocks blocks of Wmn are Cauchy transforms of such polynomials; for explicit expressions, see Sect. 5. The matrix Wmn (z) is defined by ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ k k k k Wmn (z) diag e− 1 t1k z , . . . , e− 1 t pk z , e− 1 s1k z , . . . , e− 1 sqk z ⎛⎛
τm,n+e −e (tβ −[z −1 ]) n +δ β β
⎞ −1
τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα −[z −1 ])
⎞
! −m −1
ββ ⎠ z α z β
αβ (m,n) ⎜⎝εββ (n) τmn τmn 1≤β≤ p ⎟ 1≤β≤ p ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ≤ p 1≤α≤q ⎟ 1≤β ⎟, ! ! := ⎜ −1 ⎟ ⎜ −1 τm+eα −e ,n (sα −[z ]) δ ⎟ ⎜ (m,n) τm−eα ,n−eβ (tβ −[z ]) z n β −1 −1−m α α αα (m) z ε ⎠ ⎝ αβ τmn τmn αα 1≤α≤q 1≤α ≤q 1≤β≤ p
1≤α≤q
(10) with inverse transpose matrix given by ∞ ∞ ∞ k k k k ∗ (z) diag e ∞ 1 t1k z , . . . , e 1 t pk z , e 1 s1k z , . . . , e 1 sqk z Wmn = ⎛⎛ ⎜⎝εβ β (n)
⎞ τm,n+e −e (tβ +[z −1 ]) δ β β β β −1−n β⎠ z τmn 1≤β ≤ p
⎜ ⎜ 1≤β≤ p ⎜ ! ⎜ −1 ⎜ − (n,m) τm+eα ,n+eβ (tβ +[z ]) z −n β −1 βα ⎝ τmn 1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p
!
⎞
τm−eα ,n−e (sα +[z −1 ]) β z m α −1 τmn 1≤β≤ p ⎟ ⎟ 1≤α≤q ⎟ ⎟. ! ⎟ τm+eα −e ,n (sα +[z −1 ]) δ ⎟ −1+m α α z αα εαα (m) ⎠ τmn 1≤α≤q 1≤α ≤q
− βα (n,m)
(11) The matrices Wmn (z) and Wm∗ ∗ n ∗ (z) satisfy the bilinear identities, which characterize the τ -function of the ( p + q)-KP hierarchy, ∞
Wmn (z; s, t)Wm∗ ∗ n ∗ (z; s ∗ , t ∗ ) dz = 0,
(12)
for all m, n, m ∗ , n ∗ such that |m| = |n|, |m ∗ | = |n ∗ | and all s, t, s ∗ , t ∗ ∈ C∞ . The integral above is taken along a small circle about z = ∞. This turns out to be, via the two Cauchy transforms (8) and (9), merely four identities, each expressing the fact that the inner-product between one pair of multiple orthogonal polynomials equals the inner product between a different pair.
8
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
Writing out the identity (12) above componentwise and using the expressions (10) and (11) for W and W ∗ , the bilinear identity (12) is equivalent to the single identity p
=
β=1 ∞ q α=1 ∞
(−1)
σβ (n)
τm,n−eβ (tβ −[z −1 ])τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ (tβ∗ +[z −1 ])e
∞ ∗ k ∗ 1 (tβk −tβk )z z n β −n β −2 dz
(−1)σα (m) τm+eα ,n (sα −[z −1 ])τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ (sα∗ +[z −1 ])e
∞ ∗ k 1 (sαk −sαk )z
∗
z m α −m α −2 dz,
where |m ∗ | = |n ∗ |+1 and |m| = |n|−1 and σα (m) = αα =1 (m α − m ∗α ) and σβ (n) = β ∗ β =1 (n β − n β ). It remains an open problem to have a clear understanding of why the Wmn (z; s, t)-matrix above, evaluated at t = s = 0, coincides with the Riemann-Hilbert matrix for the mixed multiple orthogonal polynomials. PDE’s for the determinant of moment matrices. Upon actually computing the residues in the contour integrals above, the functions τmn , with |m| = |n|, satisfy the following PDE’s expressed in terms of the Hirota symbol (remembering footnote 4): 2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = S+2δββ ∂˜tβ τm,n+eβ −eβ ◦ τm,n+eβ −eβ , ∂tβ,+1 ∂tβ ,1
2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = S+2δαα (∂˜sα )τm+eα −eα ,n ◦ τm+eα −eα ,n , ∂sα,+1 ∂sα ,1
2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = −S (∂˜tβ )τm+eα ,n+eβ ◦ τm−eα ,n−eβ , ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,+1
2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = −S (∂˜sα )τm−eα ,n−eβ ◦ τm+eα ,n+eβ . ∂tβ,1 ∂sα,+1
(13)
Whereas the formulae above have in their right hand side different τmn ’s, one can combine these relations to yield PDE’s in a single τmn ; so, these are PDE’s # the determinant of " for PDE’s, which play the moment matrix (3). In particular, one finds the following p+q 2 a fundamental role in chains of random matrices and in the transition probabilities for critical infinite-dimensional diffusions: ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ∂2 ∂2 ∂ ⎝ ∂tβ,2 ∂tβ ,1 ln τmn ⎠ ∂ ⎝ ∂tβ ,2 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn ⎠ + = 0, ∂2 ∂2 ∂tβ ,1 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn ln τmn ⎛ ∂ ⎝ ∂sα ,1
∂tβ,1 ∂tβ ,1
∂2 ∂sα,2 ∂sα ,1
ln τmn
∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂sα ,1
ln τmn
⎞ ⎠+
⎛ ∂ ⎝ ∂sα,1
∂tβ ,1 ∂tβ,1
∂2 ∂sα ,2 ∂sα,1
ln τmn
∂2 ∂sα ,1 ∂sα,1
ln τmn
⎞ ⎠ = 0,
⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ∂2 ∂2 ∂ ⎝ ∂sα,2 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn ⎠ ∂ ⎝ ∂tβ,2 ∂sα,1 ln τmn ⎠ + = 0. ∂2 ∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1 ∂tβ,1 ∂sα,1 ln τmn ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn These PDE’s turn out to be very useful in deriving PDE’s for transition probabilities for various random matrix processes; see e.g. [10,11].
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
9
2. Tau Functions and Mixed Multiple Orthogonal Polynomials Following [20] we introduce the notion of mixed multiple orthogonal polynomials $ % $ % (mixed mops), with regard to two sets of weights ϕ1 , ϕ2 , . . . , ϕ p and ψ1 , ψ2 , . . . , ψq : Definition 2.1. Let A1 , A2 , . . . , A p be p polynomials in y and set Q(y) := A1 (y)ϕ1 (y) + A2 (y)ϕ2 (y) + · · · + A p (y)ϕ p (y). Type I. For α ∈ {1, 2, . . . , q} the polynomials A1 , A2 , . . . , A p are said to be Type I normalized with respect to ψα , denoted Type I |ψα , if deg(Aβ ) < n β for β = 1, . . . , p and Q satisfies the following orthogonality conditions: (14) x i ψα (x) | Q(y) = δαα δi,m α −1 , i = 0, . . . , m α − 1, 1 ≤ α ≤ q. Type II. For β ∈ {1, . . . , p} the polynomials A1 , A2 , . . . , A p are said to be Type II normalized with respect to ϕβ , denoted Type II |ϕ , if Aβ is monic of degree n β and β
deg(Aβ ) < n β for 1 ≤ β ≤ p, with β = β, and Q satisfies the following orthogonality conditions: x i ψα (x) | Q(y) = 0, i = 0, . . . , m α − 1, 1 ≤ α ≤ q. (15) In both cases, the polynomials A1 , . . . , A p are called multiple orthogonal polynomials of mixed type, or mixed mops for brevity. Proposition 2.2. For β = 1, . . . , p, let (β, p)
(β,1) t t Q (β) mn (y) := Q mn (y)ϕ1 (y) + · · · + Q mn (y)ϕ p (y), (β,β )
, with 1 ≤ β, β ≤ p, are the polynomials, defined by −1 ) (β,β) n β τmn (tβ − z , Q mn (z) := z τmn −1 − z ) τ (t m,n+e −e β β β (β,β ) Q mn (z) := εββ (n)z n β −1 , β = β, τmn
where Q mn
and
εββ (n) = (β,1)
(−1)n β +1 +n β +2 +···+n β +1 if β > β , if β < β . (−1)n β+1 +n β+2 +···+n β
(β, p)
Then Q mn (y), . . . , Q mn (y) are Type II |
t ϕβ
(16)
(17)
mixed mops.
Proof. For j = 0, 1, 2, . . . and β = 1, 2, . . . , p we define the columns (of size |m|) of the matrix in (3) by ⎛ ⎞ x i1 ψ1−s (x) y j ϕβt (y) 0≤i <m 1 1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜. ⎟ β C j := ⎜ .. (18) ⎟, ⎝ ⎠ t i −s j x q ψq (x) y ϕβ (y) 0≤i q <m q
10
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
p p and so τmn = det C01 , . . . , Cn11 −1 , C02 , . . . Cn22 −1 , . . . , C0 , . . . , Cn p −1 . To insist β
on its size (see the proof of Proposition 2.3), we write C j (m) for (18). For future use, notice the following dependence of τmn on the t variables: p p τmn (t1 ) = det C01 (t1 ), . . . , Cn11 −1 (t1 ), C02 , . . . Cn22 −1 , . . . , C0 , . . . , Cn p −1 , .. .
(19) p p 1 1 2 2 τmn (tn p ) = det C0 , . . . , Cn 1 −1 , C0 , . . . Cn 2 −1 , . . . , C0 (tn p ), . . . , Cn p −1 (tn p ) . Since Q (β) mn (y) =
p
(β,β )
Q mn
β =1
(y)ϕβt (y) =
p
⎛ ⎝δββ y n β +
β =1
n β −1
⎞ Aββ y j ⎠ ϕβt (y), (20) j
j=0 (β)
the orthogonality conditions (15) for Q = Q mn can be written as the linear system p n β −1 j j β β j=0 Aββ C j = −C n β , of |m| equations, in the |n| (= |m|) unknowns Aββ , β =1
n 1 −1 , where 1 ≤ β ≤ p and 0 ≤ j < n β −1 . Ordering these unknowns as A0β1 , A1β1 , . . . , Aβ1 n −1
A0β2 , A1β2 , . . . , Aβpp , the determinant of this linear system is τmn . Since τmn = 0, generically, we have by Cramer’s rule, j
Aββ =
p β β β det C01 , C11 , . . . , C j−1 , −Cn β , C j+1 , . . . , Cn p −1 τmn
Substituted in (20) this yields an explicit expression for the Type II | (β,1)
(β, p)
.
t ϕβ
(21) mixed mops
Q mn (y), . . . , Q mn (y). In order to connect these polynomials with the tau functions τmn we first expand β τmn (tβ − z −1 ) using (19). Thus, we need to compute C j (tβ − z −1 ), which we claim to be given by β β β β β C j (tβ − z −1 ) = C j (tβ ) − z −1 C j+1 (tβ ) = C j − z −1 C j+1 ,
(22)
where the last equality is the notational simplification agreed upon. To prove the first equality in (22), which is an equality of formal series in z −1 , write a typical entry of the β i −s column vector C j (tβ ) with its explicit time-dependence on tβ , x ψα (x) y j ϕβt (y) = ∞ k x i ψα−s (x) y j ϕβ (y)e k=1 tβk y , where 1 ≤ α ≤ q and 0 ≤ i < m α . The following ∞
xi
trivial identity will be used over and over again in this paper: e− 1 i = 1 − x. In view # β" of the latter, the same entry of C j tβ − z −1 (as above) is given by & x
i
ψα−s (x)
' j t y ϕ (y) 1 − y = x i ψ −s (x) y j ϕ t (y) − 1 x i ψ −s (x) y j+1 ϕ t (y) α α β β β z z
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
11
which proves (22). Using the fact that the determinant is a skew-symmetric multilinear function of its columns, which vanishes when two columns are equal, it follows from (19), (22) and (21) that p β−1 β β β β β+1 z n β τmn tβ − z −1 , zC0 − C1 , . . . , zCn −1 − Cn β , C0 , . . . , Cn −1 ) = det(C01 , . . . , Cn p β β−1 −1 nβ (∗) j p β β β β+1 = z det(C01 , C11 , . . . , C j−1 , −C j+1 , . . . , −Cn β , C0 , . . . , Cn −1 ) p j=0 n
=
β
(β,β)
j
z j Aββ τmn = τmn Q mn (z).
j=0
β
β
In (∗) it is understood that all the columns between −C j+1 and −Cn β come with negative signs and no others; this notation shall be used freely in the sequel, without further mention. (β,β ) For Q mn with β = β we also need to keep track of signs and of shifts in the first index of the tau function, as is seen in the following computation, where we suppose that β < β : z n β −1 τm,n+eβ −eβ (tβ − z −1 ) β
β
β
β
= det(C01 , . . . , Cn β −1 , Cnββ , . . . , zC0 − C1 , . . . , zCn β +1
C0
β
− Cn
β −1
,
p
, . . . , Cn p −1 )
n β −1
=
β −2
β
β
β +1
z j det(C01 , . . . , Cnββ , . . . , C j−1 , −C j+1 , . . . , −Cnββ −1 , C0
p
, . . . , Cn p −1 )
j=0 n β −1
= εββ (n)
(β,β ) z j Aββ τmn = εββ (n) τmn Q mn (z). j
j=0 β
The sign εββ (n) which we introduced when moving the column Cn β to the right is given β
by (−1)n β+1 +···+n β , in agreement with (17). When β > β the column Cn β is moved to the left, which yields a sign εββ (n) = −(−1)n β +1 +···+n β , as is easily checked. The tau functions τmn also lead to Type I normalized mixed mops, as given in the following proposition: Proposition 2.3. For α = 1, . . . , q, let (α, p)
(α) (α,1) Pmn (y) := Pmn (y)ϕ1t (y) + · · · + Pmn (y)ϕ tp (y), (α,β)
where Pmn
(23)
are the polynomials, defined by (α,β) Pmn (z)
:= αβ (m, n)z
τ (t n β −1 m−eα ,n−eβ β τmn
− z −1 )
,
(24)
12
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke (α,1)
with leading sign αβ (m, n) = (−1)m 1 +···+m α (−1)n 1 +···+n β . Then Pmn (y), . . . , (α, p) Pmn (y) are Type I | −s mixed mops. ψα
Proof.
Letting (α) Pmn (y) =
p β=1
(α,β) Pmn (y)ϕβt (y) =
p n β −1 β=1 j=0
j
Bαβ y j ϕβt (y),
(25)
(α)
the orthogonality conditions (14) for Q = Pmn can be written as the linear system p m β −1 j β α α β=1 j=0 Bαβ C j = E m α , where E m α denotes the column vector of size |m| with a 1 at position m 1 + m 2 + · · · + m α , and zeros elsewhere. Cramer’s rule now yields j Bαβ
= αβ (m, n)(−1)
j+1−n β
(β p β β det(D01 , D11 , . . . , D j−1 , D j , D j+1 , . . . , Dn p −1 ) τmn
,
upon expanding the determinants along the E mα α column, where αβ (m, n) is given in γ γ Proposition 2.3 and where Dk is the column vector Ck with its (m 1 + · · · + m α )th entry γ γ removed, i.e., Dk := Ck (m − eα ). This yields explicit expressions for the Type I | −s ψα
mixed mops. To connect them with tau functions, we notice on the one hand that the γ columns Dk appear in the matrices which define the tau functions τm−eα , , and on the γ other hand that these columns behave in the same way (22) as Ck under shifts. Therefore, (α,β) as before, z n β −1 τm−eα ,n−eβ (tβ − z −1 ) = αβ (m, n) Pmn (z) τmn . 3. Cauchy Transforms We now show that certain shifts of the tau function, appearing in the Riemann-Hilbert matrix of [20], are (formal) Cauchy transforms. For a function F and a weight ψ, define its Cauchy transform as ' ∞ 1 i ψ(x) | G(y) = Cψ G(z) := x ψ(x) G(y) , z−x z i+1 &
(26)
i=0
i.e., our Cauchy transforms will be formal in the sense that we always think of z as being large, and this is precisely how it will be used. The first type of Cauchy transforms which we are interested in are given in the following proposition. Proposition 3.1. For α = 1, . . . , q and β = 1, . . . , p, the Cauchy transforms of (β, p)
(β,1) t t Q (β) mn (y) = Q mn (y)ϕ1 (y) + · · · + Q mn (y)ϕ p (y),
with respect to ψα−s can be expressed in terms of tau functions as follows: τ (s − z −1 ) (β) −m α −1 m+eα ,n+eβ α Cψα−s Q mn (z) = αβ (m, n) z . τmn
(27)
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
13
Proof. The proof is based on an investigation of the moment matrix row by row. Therefore we define, for α = 1, . . . , q and for i = 0, 1, 2, . . . the row Rαi of size |n| by ") *# x i ψα−s (x) y j1 ϕ1t (y) 0≤ j
0≤ j p
1
When its size is important we write Rαi (n) for Rαi . The moment matrix Tmn can now be expressed in terms of the rows Rαi , and so ⎞ ⎛ R10 ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ m 1 −1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜R 1 ⎟ τmn = det ⎜ ⎜ R0 ⎟ . 2 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎝ . ⎠ m −1
Rq q
The tau function which we need to compute is τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα − z −1 ); so throughout the proof, Rαi stands for Rαi (n + eβ ) for all 1 ≤ α ≤ q and i = 0, 1, 2, . . . . Notice that the only rows which depend on the time variables sα = (sα1 , sα2 , . . . ) are the rows ∞ i −s −s − sαk x k , k=1 Rα . Recall the dependence of ψα on sα as follows: ψα (x) = ψα (x)e −1 −s −s so that, when sα gets replaced by sα − z , then ψα (x) gets replaced by ψα (x) 1+
x z
+
x2 z2
+ · · · . It follows that
& x x2 Rαi sα − z −1 = x i ψα−s (x) 1 + + 2 + · · · z z
' j t y β ϕ (y) β 1≤β < p
,
0≤ jβ
where we introduce the convenient abbreviation n β := n β + δββ = (n + eβ )β . Notice that Rαi (sα − z −1 ) = Rαi (sα )+ 1z Rαi+1 (sα − z −1 ), for 0 ≤ i ≤ m α −1; we stop at m α −1 because the highest index i for which Rαi appears in Tm+eα ,n+eβ is i = m α . By recursively applying this formula we get that Rαi (sα − z −1 ) = Rαi (sα ) + lin. comb. of lower rows, for 0 ≤ i ≤ m α − 1. This leads to the first equality in ⎛ ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ R10 R10 ⎜ . ⎟ .. ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ . ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ R m α −1 ⎟ m −1 ⎜ Rα α ⎟ ⎜ α ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ˜ ⎟ mα −1 ⎟ Rα (z) ⎟ . z −m α −1 τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα − z −1 ) = z −m α −1 det ⎜ ⎜Rα (sα 0− z )⎟ = det ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎟ ⎜ Rα+1 ⎜ Rα+1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ .. .. ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ . ⎝ . ⎠ m q −1 m q −1 Rq Rq (28) For the second equality, in which we have put −s −s ψα (x) j1 t ψα (x) j p t y y ϕ (y) · · · ϕ (y) R˜ α (z) := p 1 z−x z−x 0≤ j1
0≤ j p
, (29)
14
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
" # it suffices to show that Rαm α sα − z −1 = z m α +1 R˜ α (z)+ lin. comb. of higher rows Rαi . " # To do this, compare a typical entry of Rαm α sα − z −1 , to wit &
' x x2 x m α ψα−s (x) 1 + + 2 + · · · y j ϕβt (y) z z & m α ' x x x2 = zmα ψα−s (x) 1 + + 2 + · · · y j ϕβt (y) z z z ! m α m α +1 x x j t mα −s + + · · · y ϕβ (y) =z ψα (x) z z
with the corresponding typical entry of z m α +1 R˜ α (z), to wit ! & −s 2 ' ψ x (x) x z m α +1 α + · · · y j ϕβt (y) . y j ϕβt (y) = z m α ψα−s (x) 1 + + z−x z z # m α −1 m −i i " It leads to Rαm α sα − z −1 + i=0 z α Rα (sα ) = z m α +1 R˜ α (z), and hence to the proof of the second equality in (28). In order to make the connection with mixed mops, β we introduce for β = 1, . . . , p the row Sβ (z) of size |n + eβ | = |n| + 1 which has zeroes " j# β 7 everywhere, except in its β -th block, namely Sβ (y) = 0 . . . 0 y 0≤ j
˜ ˜ Notice that with this notation, definition (29) of Rα (z) can be rewritten as Rα (z) = p β t Cψα−s β =1 Sβ (z)ϕβ (z) . It suggests the introduction of the following polynomials (in y): ⎞ ⎛ R10 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ R m α −1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ α ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ β β Sαβ (y) := det ⎜ Sβ (y) ⎟ . ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ Rα+1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ m q −1 Rq Expanding this determinant along its (m 1 + · · · + m α + 1)th row, which is the (unique) β row that contains y, it is clear that if β = β, then deg Sαβ (y) < n β = n β . In view of β
the definition of τmn we also have 8 Sαβ (y) = αβ (m, n) τmn y n β + O(y n β −1 ). Moreover, for any α = 1, . . . , q and i = 0, . . . , m α − 1, we have by linearity of the determinant 7 Recall that n = n + δ . β ββ β 8 See Proposition 2.3 for the definition of
αβ (m, n).
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
15
⎛ ⎞ R10 ⎜ ⎟ .. ⎜ ⎟ . ⎜ ⎟ m α −1 ⎜ ⎟ Rα ⎜ ⎟ p ⎜ ⎟ p ⎜ ⎟ β t β t i −s ⎜ ⎟ S (y)ϕ (y) det (30) (x) S (y)ϕ (y) = x ψ (x) x i ψα−s β β αβ β ⎜ ⎟ α ⎜ β =1 ⎟ β =1 ⎜ ⎟ 0 ⎜ ⎟ Rα+1 ⎜ ⎟ .. ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ ⎠ . m q −1 Rq ⎛ ⎞ 0 R1 ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ R10 .. ⎜ ⎟ . ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ m α −1 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ R α ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ R m α −1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ j t ⎜ ⎟ α ⎜ x i ψα−s ⎟ (x) y ϕβ (y) ⎟ 1≤β < p ⎟ = det ⎜ Rαi ⎟ , = det ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 0≤ j
αβ (m,n) 1
αβ (m,n) p τmn Sαβ (y), . . . , τmn Sαβ (y) are type II mixed mops, normalized with respect β
(β,β )
to ϕβt . It follows from Proposition 2.2 that Sαβ (y) = αβ (m, n) τmn Q mn α = 1, . . . , q. Since
(β) Q mn (y)
=
(β,1) Q mn (y)ϕ1t (y) + · · · +
τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα − z −1 )
z −m α −1
finishing the proof.
τmn
=
1 τmn
(β, p) Q mn (y)ϕ tp (y),
⎛
Cψα−s ⎝
p β =1
(y), for any9
it follows that ⎞
β
Sαβ (z)ϕβt (z)⎠
= αβ (m, n) Cψα−s Q (β) mn (z),
(31)
(β)
Incidentally, our proof shows, as a byproduct, that each Q mn (y) is expressible naturally as a determinant, like in the classical case, namely ⎞ ⎛ R10 ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎜ m α −1 ⎟ ⎜ R α ⎟ ⎜ p ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜
(m, n) β t αβ ⎜ S (y)ϕ (y) ⎟ . (32) Q (β) (y) = det β β mn ⎟ ⎜ τmn ⎟ ⎜ β =1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ Rα+1 ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ ⎠ ⎝ . m −1
Rq q
9 The formulas for the different values of α are all the same, up to a sign, as they amount to changing the location of a row in the evaluation of a determinant.
16
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
We now get to the second type of Cauchy transforms which correspond to the Type I (α) mops Pmn (y). (α )
(α ,1)
Proposition 3.2. For 1 ≤ α, α ≤ q the Cauchy transforms of Pmn (y) = Pmn (y) (α , p) ϕ1t (y) + · · · + Pmn (y)ϕ tp (y) with respect to ψα−s can be expressed in terms of tau functions as follows: τmn (sα − z −1 ) =z , τmn −1 τ (s − z ) m+e −e ,n α α α (α ) −1−m α Cψα−s Pmn (z) = εα α (m) z , τmn (α) Cψα−s Pmn (z)
−m α
(33) α = α.
(34)
Proof. Up to a relabeling of the indices, the shifted tau functions in question were already expressed as polynomials in the previous proof. Let us show how this leads to a quick proof of (33). Shifting the m α and n β indices down by 1, it follows from (28) that ⎛
⎞
R10
⎟ ⎜ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ m α −2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ Rα ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ˜ α (z) ⎟ , R z −m α τmn (sα − z −1 ) = det ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ R ⎜ α+1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ .. ⎟ ⎜ . ⎟ ⎠ ⎝ m −1
Rq q while the orthogonality relations (30) become
p β x i ψα−s Sαβ (y)ϕβt (y) = δαα δi,m α −1 τmn . (x) β =1
(35)
β
1 1 Since deg Sαβ < n β for β = 1, . . . , p this means that the polynomials τmn Sαβ (y) , . . . , p 1 −s , so they coinS (y) are type I mixed mops, normalized with respect to ψ α τmn αβ (α,1)
(α, p)
cide according to Proposition 2.3 with the polynomials Pmn (y), . . . , Pmn (y). We conclude, as in (31), that z −m α
⎞ ⎛ p τmn (sα − z −1 ) 1 β (α) = C −s ⎝ Sαβ (z)ϕβt (z)⎠ = Cψα−s Pmn (z). τmn τmn ψα β =1
Similarly, one obtains (34) from (27) by shifting m α and n β down by 1; the sign in this case is determined (for α < α) from the right hand side of (35) now taking the form
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
⎛
R10 .. .
⎛
⎞
R10 .. .
17
⎞
⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ m −2 ⎟ ⎜ m −2 ⎟ ⎜R α ⎟ ⎜R α ⎟ ⎜ α ⎜ α ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ R0 ⎜ Ri ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ α +1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ 0α ⎟ ⎟ .. ⎜ ⎜ Rα +1 ⎟ ⎟ . ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ = εα α (n) δα α δi,m −1 τmn . det ⎜ .. ⎜ m α −1 ⎟ = εα α (m) det ⎜ ⎟ α . ⎜ Rα ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ Rαi ⎟ ⎜ Rαm α −1 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ Rα+1 ⎟ ⎜ Rα+1 ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ .. .. ⎜ ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ ⎝ ⎝ ⎠ ⎠ . . m q −1 m q −1 Rq Rq 4. Duality By interchanging the rôles of the weights ψαt with the weights ϕβ−s we obtain Type I | mixed mops and Type II |
ψα−s
t ϕβ
mixed mops, expressed in terms of tau functions, leading
to a duality. As a general rule, in order to dualize a formula one does the following exchanges: q ↔ p, m ↔ n, ψ ↔ ϕ, s ↔ −t, x ↔ y.
(36)
At the level of the indices, duality amounts to α ↔ β, i ↔ j. As for the mixed mops which we have constructed, they will correspond to new mixed mops for which ∗(β) (α,β) (α) ↔ we will use the same letter, but adding a star. Thus, Pmn ↔ Pnm , Pmn ∗(β,α) (β) (β,β ) ∗(α) ∗(α,α ) Pnm , Q mn ↔ Q nm , Q mn ↔ Q nm . What happens tothe tau functions τmn ? To see this, pick a typical shifted tau function τm+eα −eα ,n (sα − z −1 ) and make its depen dence on the weights and on all times explicit, writing τm+eα −eα ,n (s − z −1 eα , t; ψ, ϕ). −1 According to the above rule it becomes τn+eβ −eβ ,m (−t − z eβ , −s; ϕ, ψ) which is −1 equal to τm,n+eβ −eβ (s, t + z eβ ; ψ, ϕ), since transposing the moment matrix has no effect on the determinant, while it permutes the indices in the tau function, it permutes the time-dependence (with signs) and it permutes the weights. Thus, τmn ↔ τmn and τmn (tβ − z −1 ) ↔ τmn (sα + z −1 ), τm−eα ,n−eβ (tβ − z −1 ) ↔ τm−eα ,n−eβ (sα + z −1 ), τm+eα −eα ,n (sα − z −1 ) ↔ τm,n+eβ −eβ (tβ + z −1 ), and so on. Dualizing Propositions 2.2 and 2.3 yields the following proposition. Proposition 4.1. For α = 1, . . . , q and β = 1, . . . , p, let ∗(β,q)
∗(β) ∗(β,1) Pnm (x) := Pnm (x)ψ1−s (x) + · · · + Pnm
(x)ψq−s (x),
∗(α,q)
−s ∗(α,1) Q ∗(α) nm (x) := Q nm (x)ψ1 (x) + · · · + Q nm
(x)ψq−s (x),
(37)
18
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke ∗(β,α)
where Pnm
∗(α,α )
and Q nm
∗(β,α) Pnm (z)
are the polynomials, defined by
:= βα (n, m)z
τ (s m α −1 m−eα ,n−eβ α
+ z −1 )
τmn
,
(38)
and Q ∗(α,α) (z) nm
:= z
m α τmn (sα
+ z −1 )
τmn
∗(α,α ) Q nm (z) := εαα (m)z m α −1 ∗(β,1)
Then Pnm ∗(α,q)
Q nm
∗(β,q)
(x), . . . , Pnm
(x) are Type II |
ψα−s
,
τm+eα −eα ,n (sα + z −1 ) , τmn
(x) are Type I |
(39) α = α. ∗(α1)
t ϕβ
mixed mops, while Q nm (x), . . . ,
mixed mops.
Dualizing Definition (26) we get the following definition for the dual Cauchy transform: for any function F and a weight ϕ we put & ' ϕ(y) ϕ(y) ∗ F(x)dµ(x, y) = F(x) . (40) Cϕ F(z) := z−y R2 z − y Dualizing now Propositions 3.1 and 3.2 yields the next proposition. Proposition 4.2. For α = 1, . . . , q and β, β = 1, . . . , p, the Cauchy transforms of ∗(β ) ∗(α) Pnm (x) with respect to ϕβt , and of Q nm (x) with respect to ϕβt can be expressed in terms of tau functions as follows: −1 ) ∗ ∗(β) −n β τmn (tβ + z , Cϕ t Pnm (z) = z β τmn −1 τ (t + z ) m,n+e −e β β β ∗(β ) Cϕ∗t Pnm (z) = εβ β (n) z −1−n β , β = β, β τmn and Cϕ∗t Q ∗(α) nm (z) β
= βα (n, m) z
−n β −1
τm+eα ,n+eβ (tβ + z −1 ) τmn
.
5. The Riemann-Hilbert Matrix and the Bilinear Identity Orthogonal polynomials were shown to be characterized by a Riemann-Hilbert problem in [24] and [22]. This was generalized by Daems and Kuijlaars to the case of mixed mops. According to [20]10 the corresponding Riemann-Hilbert matrix is given by the ( p + q) × ( p + q) matrix 10 Up to a factor diag(I , −2π p
√ −1Iq ) which we suppress.
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory ⎛
(β,β )
Q mn
⎜ ⎜ Ymn (z) := ⎜ ⎜ (α,β) ⎝ Pmn 1≤α≤q
1≤β≤ p 1≤β ≤ p
⎞ (β) Cψ −s Q mn 1≤β≤ p α ⎟ ⎟ 1≤α≤q ⎟ ⎟= (α ) Cψ −s Pmn 1≤α ≤q ⎠ α
1≤β≤ p
⎛⎛
19
⎞ τm,n+e −e tβ − z −1 n β +δββ −1 ⎟ β β ⎜ z ⎠ ⎜⎝εββ (n) τmn
1≤α≤q
αβ (m,n)
⎞
! τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα − z −1 ) −m α −1 z τmn 1≤β≤ p
⎜ 1≤β≤ p ⎜ 1≤α≤q ⎜⎛ 1≤β ≤ p ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ −1 −1 ⎜ τ t − z ) δ τm+eα −e ,n (sα − z n −1 −1−m α⎠ ⎜⎝ αβ (m,n) m−eα ,n−eβ β α ⎝ε (m) z β ⎠ z αα τmn τmn αα ⎝ 1≤α≤q 1≤α ≤q 1≤β≤ p
⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
1≤α≤q
whose inverse transpose matrix is given by ⎛
∗(β ) ∗(β,α) C ∗t Pnm −Pnm 1≤β≤ p ⎜ 1≤β ≤ p ϕβ ⎜ 1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p ⎜ ∗ Ymn (z) = ⎜ ) ⎜ ∗(α) ∗(α,α Q nm ⎝ −C ∗t Q nm 1≤α≤q ϕβ
⎛⎛
1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p
⎞ τm,n+e −e (tβ + z −1 ) δ β β β −1−n β ⎟ ⎜ β z ⎠ ⎜⎝εβ β (n) τmn
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟= ⎟ ⎠
1≤α ≤q ⎛
⎝− βα (n,m)
⎞ τm−eα ,n−e (sα + z −1 ) β m −1 α ⎠ z τmn
⎞
⎜ 1≤β≤ p 1≤β ≤ p ⎜ 1≤α≤q ⎜ 1≤β≤ p ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ ! −1 ⎜ τm+eα −e ,n (sα + z −1 ) δ −1+m ⎜ − βα (n,m) τm+eα ,n+eβ (tβ + z ) z −n β −1 α ⎝ε (m) α⎠ z αα τmn τmn αα ⎝ 1≤α≤q 1≤α≤q
⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
1≤α ≤q
1≤β≤ p
We will obtain bilinear identities for these tau functions from an identity which is satisfied by the Riemann-Hilbert matrix and its adjoint. We define the wave matrix Wmn (z) by Ymn (z)(z), where (z) is the diagonal matrix11 (z) := diag(eξ (t1 ,z) , . . . , eξ (t p ,z) , eξ (s1 ,z) , eξ (sq ,z) ), ∗ (z)−1 (z). In order to make the dependence on the time with adjoint wave matrix Ymn ∗ (z; s, t) for W ∗ (z). variables (s, t) explicit, we will write Wmn (z; s, t) for W (z) and Wmn mn
Theorem 5.1. The tau functions τmn satisfy the following bilinear identities which characterize the tau functions of the ( p + q)-KP hierarchy (see [36]): Wmn (z; s, t)Wm∗ ∗ n ∗ (z; s ∗ , t ∗ ) dz = 0, ∞
which is equivalent to the single identity p ∗ ∗ (−1)σβ (n) τm,n−eβ tβ − z −1 τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ (tβ∗ + z −1 )eξ (tβ −tβ ,z) z n β −n β −2 dz =
β=1 ∞ q α=1 ∞
∗ ∗ (−1)σα (m) τm+eα ,n (sα − z −1 )τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ (sα∗ + z −1 )eξ (sα −sα ,z) z m α −m α −2 dz,
where σα (m) = |m| = |n| − 1.
α
α =1 (m α
− m ∗α ), σβ (n) =
11 Throughout this section, we set ξ(t, z) := ∞ t z k . 1 k
β
β =1 (n β
(41)
− n ∗β ), |m ∗ | = |n ∗ | + 1 and
20
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
For the entry (β , β ) of the product
Proof.
∗
∗
∗
∗
Y (Y ∗ −1 ) = Y diag(eξ (t1 −t1 ,z) , . . . , eξ (t p −t p ,z) , eξ (s1 −s1 ,z) , . . . , eξ (sq −sq ,z) )Y ∗ , we need to prove that p
β=1 ∞ q
=
∗(β )
∗
ξ (tβ −tβ ,z) ,β) ∗ Q (β dz mn (z) C t ∗ Pn ∗ m ∗ (z) e
α=1 ∞
ϕβ
∗(β ,α)
) Cψα−s Q (β mn (z)Pn ∗ m ∗
∗
(z) eξ (sα −sα ,z) dz,
(42)
where it is understood that all polynomials P ∗ go with starred times s ∗ and t ∗ . Also, the integral stands for (minus) the residue at infinity, ∞ and i can be computed using the following formal residue identities, with f (z) = i=0 ai z : 1 f (z) Cψ g(z) dz = f (x)ψ(x) | g(y) , √ 2π −1 ∞ 1 Cϕ∗ f (z) g(z) dz = f (x) | ϕ(y)g(y) , (43) √ 2π −1 ∞ whose proof we defer until the end. Using this, and Definition (37) of the functions √ ∗(β) Pnm (x), the left-hand side in (42) becomes (up to a factor 2π −1) p β=1
p ,β) ∗(β ) ∗(β ) ξ (tβ −tβ∗ ,y) t∗ Pn ∗ m ∗ (x) Q (β = Pn ∗ m ∗ (x) (y) ϕ (y) e mn β β=1
(β ,β) Q mn (y) ϕβt (y)
) ∗(β ) (y) . = Pn ∗ m ∗ (x) Q (β mn
√ Similarly, the right hand side in (42) becomes (up to a factor 2π −1) q
∗(β ,α)
Pn ∗ m ∗
α=1
∗ ) (β ) ∗(β ) Q (x) ψα−s (x) eξ (sα −sα ,x) Q (β (y) = P (x) (y) . ∗ ∗ mn mn n m
The three other identities are obtained in the same way. In terms of tau functions, it means that we have shown that for any m, n, m ∗ , n ∗ , β and β , with |m| = |n| and |m ∗ | = |n ∗ | the following bilinear identities hold: p β=1 ∞ q
∗ ♣ τm,n+eβ −eβ (tβ − z −1 )τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ −eβ (tβ∗ + z −1 )eξ (tβ −tβ ,z) dz =
α=1 ∞
∗ ♠ τm+eα ,n+eβ (sα − z −1 )τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ −eβ (sα∗ + z −1 )eξ (sα −sα ,z) dz, ∗
where ♣ = εβ β (n)εβ β (n ∗ )z n β −n β −2+δββ +δββ , and ♠ = αβ (m, n) β α (n ∗ , m ∗ ) ∗ z m α −m α −2 . For different values of β and β this yields the same identity, up to a relabeling of n and n ∗ . Namely, replace in the bilinear identity n + eβ by n and n ∗ − eβ by n ∗
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
21
n ∗ +···+n ∗
β to find the following symmetric expression and multiply by (−1)n 1 +···+n β (−1) 1 for the identity, that is independent of β and β :
p β=1 ∞ q
∗ ∗ (−1)σβ (n) τm,n−eβ (tβ − z −1 )τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ (tβ∗ + z −1 )eξ (tβ −tβ ,z) z n β −n β −2 dz =
α=1 ∞
∗ ∗ (−1)σα (m) τm+eα ,n (sα − z −1 )τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ (sα∗ + z −1 )eξ (sα −sα ,z) z m α −m α −2 dz.
Notice that, due to the shift, one must have in this symmetric form that |m| = |n| − 1 and |m ∗ | = |n ∗ | + 1. The other three identities also yield the above identity, up to relabeling. Finally, to prove the first equation in (43), compute ' & ∞ ∞ 1 1 j 1 ψ(x) | g(y) dz = √ | x f (z) ai z i ψ(x) g(y) √ z−x z j+1 2π −1 ∞ 2π −1 ∞ i=0 j=0 ∞ ∞ i i ai x ψ(x) | g(y) = ai x ψ(x) | g(y) = f (x)ψ(x) | g(y) , = i=0
i=0
and similarly for the second equation in (43), completing the proof. 6. Consequences of the Bilinear Identities In this section we will derive from the bilinear identities (41) a series of PDE’s for the tau functions τmn . In order to keep the formulas transparent, we will use the following simplification in the notation. Recall that we have time variables sα = (sα1 , sα2 , . . . ) and tβ = (tβ1 , tβ2 , . . . ), where α = 1, . . . , q and β = 1, . . . , p. In the bilinear identities (41) we consider in each term a shift in tα , for a single α, or in sβ , for a single β; we will denote this tα or sβ by v (so v is an infinite vector v = (v1 , v2 , . . . ) and we assemble all the other r := p + q − 1 series of time variables in w = (w1 , w2 , . . . , wr ), where w1 = (w11 , w12 , . . . ) and so on. Moreover, precisely like in the bilinear identities we will want to consider an independent collection of all these variables, in fact we will consider here (v , w ) and (v , w ) besides (v, w). We use the Hirota symbol, which takes in our case the following form: P(∂v , ∂w ) F ◦ G = P(∂v , ∂w ) F(v + v , w + w ) G(v − v , w − w )
v =w =0
.
(44)
We also use the standard notation ∂˜v = ∂v∂ 1 , 21 ∂v∂ 2 , 13 ∂v∂ 3 , . . . . We first give an identity which will allow us to compute the formal residues which appear in (41) in terms of derivatives of the tau function. Lemma 6.1. For any n ∈ Z we have the following formal residue identity: ∞ dz F(v + z −1 , w ) G(v − z −1 , w ) e =0 (v −v )z z n √ 2π −1 ∞ =
j≥0
S j−1−n (−2a) S j (∂˜v ) e
∞
=1
a ∂v∂ + rγ =1 bγ ∂w∂
γ
(45) F(v, w) ◦ G(v, w),
22
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
where v = v − a, v = v + a, wi = wi − bi , wi = wi + bi , and a = (a1 , a2 , a3 , . . . ), bi = (bi1 , bi2 , bi3 , . . . ), for 1 ≤ i ≤ r . Proof. The proof is an immediate, but tricky consequence of the definition of the Schur functions and of the following two properties of the Hirota symbol: ∞ F v + z −1 , w G v − z −1 , w = z − j S j (∂˜v ) F ◦ G, j=0
F(v + a, w + b) G(v − a, w − b) = e
∞
r ∂ ∂ =0 (a ∂v + γ =1 bγ ∂wγ )
F ◦ G.
Proposition 6.2. The bilinear equations imply, upon specialization, that the tau functions τmn , with |m| = |n| satisfy the following PDE’s expressed in terms of the Hirota symbol: 2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = S+2δββ (∂˜tβ )τm,n+eβ −eβ ◦ τm,n+eβ −eβ , ∂tβ,+1 ∂tβ ,1
(46)
2 τmn
∂2 ln τmn = S+2δαα (∂˜sα )τm+eα −eα ,n ◦ τm+eα −eα ,n , ∂sα,+1 ∂sα ,1
(47)
∂2 ln τmn = S (∂˜tβ )τm+eα ,n+eβ ◦ τm−eα ,n−eβ , ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,+1
(48)
∂2 ln τmn . = S (∂˜sα )τm−eα ,n−eβ ◦ τm+eα ,n+eβ . ∂tβ,1 ∂sα,+1
(49)
2 −τmn
2 −τmn
Equations (46) resp. (47) for β = β (resp. for α = α) yield a solution to the KP hierarchy in tβ (resp. in sα ), while for β = β and α = α, (46) — (49) yields
τm,n+eβ −e τm,n+e −eβ ∂2 β β ln τmn = , 2 τmn ∂tβ,1 ∂tβ ,1 τm+e −eα ,n τm+eα −e ,n ∂2 α α ln τmn = , 2 τmn ∂sα,1 ∂sα ,1
∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1
ln τmn = −
It leads to the following of them,
τm+eα ,n+eβ τm−eα ,n−eβ 2 τmn
" p+q # 2
,
τm,n+eβ −eβ ∂ ln = ∂tβ,1 τm,n+eβ −eβ
∂2 ∂tβ,2 ∂tβ ,1
ln τmn
∂2 ∂tβ,1 ∂tβ ,1
ln τmn
τm−eα +eα ,n ∂ ln = ∂sα,1 τm−eα +eα ,n
∂2 ∂sα,2 ∂sα ,1 ln τmn ∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂tα ,1 ln τmn ∂2 ∂tβ,2 ∂sα,1 ln τmn ∂2 ∂tβ,1 ∂sα,1 ln τmn ∂2 ∂sα,2 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn ∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn
τm+eα ,n+eβ ∂ ln = ∂tβ,1 τm−eα ,n−eβ τm−eα ,n−eβ ∂ ln = ∂sα,1 τm+eα ,n+eβ
, ,
, .
(50) PDE’s for ln τmn involving not just one sα or tβ , but a few
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
⎛
⎛ ∂2 ∂tβ ,2 ∂tβ,1 ∂ ⎝ ⎠+ ⎝ ∂2 ∂2 ∂tβ ,1 ∂tβ,1 ∂tβ,1 ∂tβ ,1 ln τmn ∂tβ ,1 ∂tβ,1 ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ∂2 ∂2 ln τ mn ∂sα ,2 ∂sα,1 ∂ ⎝ ∂sα,2 ∂sα ,1 ∂ ⎠+ ⎝ ∂2 ∂2 ∂sα ,1 ∂sα,1 ln τ mn ∂sα,1 ∂sα ,1 ∂sα ,1 ∂sα,1 ⎛ ⎞ ⎛ ∂2 ∂2 ∂ ⎝ ∂sα,2 ∂tβ,1 ∂ ⎝ ∂tβ,2 ∂sα,1 ln τmn ⎠ + ∂2 ∂2 ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1 ln τmn ∂
∂2 ∂tβ,2 ∂tβ ,1
ln τmn
⎞
∂tβ,1 ∂sα,1
∂sα,1 ∂tβ,1
ln τmn ln τmn ln τmn ln τmn ln τmn ln τmn
23
⎞ ⎠ = 0,
(51)
⎞ ⎠ = 0,
(52)
⎞ ⎠ = 0.
(53)
Remark. These PDE’s will play a crucial role in finding the PDE’s for transition probabilities in the Dyson processes. Proof. For a = (a1 , . . . , aq ) and b = (b1 , . . . , bq ), define the differential operator (a, b), ⎛ ⎞ q p ∞ ∂ ∂ ⎝ ⎠. (a, b) := aα + bβ (54) ∂sα ∂tβ =1
α =1
β =1
Using Lemma (6.1), rewrite the bilinear identity12 (41): p
∞
(−1)σβ (n)
β=1
−
Sn ∗β −n β +1+k (−2bβ )Sk (∂˜tβ )e(a,b) τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ
k=0 q
(−1)
σα (m)
α=1
∞
(55) Sm α −m ∗α +1+k (−2aα )Sk (∂˜sα )e
(a,b)
τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ ◦ τm+eα ,n = 0.
k=0
Note that all infinite vectors aα and bβ can be chosen completely arbitrary. We set all components of a and b equal to zero, except bβ,+1 = B = 0 (for some fixed β and ), and we set m ∗ = m and n ∗ − n = −2eβ (for some fixed β ). Then only the first term in (55) survives, the signs σβ (n) are all 1 and, since the leading term of S (v) is vl , the identity (55) becomes 0=
p ∞ β =1 k=0
∂
B S1+k−2δβ β (−2bβ )Sk (∂˜tβ )e ∂tβ,+1 τm,n+eβ −2eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ
= B −2S+2δββ (∂˜tβ )τm,n+eβ −2eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ +
∂2 τm,n−eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ ∂tβ ,1 ∂tβ,+1
+O(B 2 ). Expressing that the coefficient of B in this expression must vanish we get (46), upon relabeling n − eβ → n and upon using the following property of the Hirota symbol, valid for f depending on (time-) variables s and t: ∂2 ∂2 F ◦ F = 2F 2 ln F. ∂t∂s ∂t∂s 12 Recall that in this form of the bilinear identity |m ∗ | = |n ∗ | + 1 and |m| = |n| − 1.
(56)
24
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
Equation (47) follows from (46) by duality, using P(−∂s ) F ◦ G = P(∂s ) G ◦ F. In order to obtain (48) we consider again (55), with bβ,+1 = B = 0 and all other components of a and b equal to zero, but we set now n ∗ = n and m − m ∗ = −2eα . Then (55) becomes 0=
∞
∂
B Sk+1 (−2bβ )Sk (∂˜β ) e ∂tβ,+1 τm+2eα ,n+eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ
k=0 ∞
−
∂
B Sk−1 (0)Sk (∂˜sα ) e ∂tβ,+1 τm+eα ,n ◦ τm+eα ,n
k=0
= −B 2S (∂˜tβ )τm+2eα ,n+eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ +
∂2 τm+eα ,n ◦ τm+eα ,n + O(B 2 ). ∂sα,1 ∂tβ,+1
The nullity of the coefficient of B in this expression, rewritten by using (56), leads at once to (48), upon doing the relabeling m + eα → m. From it, (49) follows by duality. The first column in (50) follows from (46) — (48) by setting β = β, α = α and = 0. The second column follows from (46) — (49) by setting β = β, α = α and forming in each equation the ratio of the cases = 0 and = 1, and using the following property of the Hirota symbol, valid for F and G depending on a (time-) variable t: ∂ ∂ F F ◦ G = FG ln . ∂t ∂t G Equations (51) — (53) are just the compatibility equations between the equations in the second column in (50). The corollary below generalizes identity (2) for orthogonal polynomials and identity (59) for bi-orthogonal polynomials to multiple orthogonal polynomials. Identities I and II below are the exact analogue of (2), worked out for multiple orthogonal polynomials, namely relating inner-products to a Taylor series in the bi-vectors13 b and a. It is also saying that a generating function for the identities (46), (47), (48) and (49) is given by an inner-product of two multiple orthogonal polynomials. Identities III and IV are the exact analogue of identity (59) in Sect. 7.1, valid for bi-orthogonal polynomials, but extended to multiple-orthogonal polynomials. It is important to notice that precisely these four τ -function identities will be used in the application to Brownian motion problems discussed in Sects. 7.3 and 7.4. ∗(β )
∗(β )
Corollary 6.3. The tau functions τmn and the polynomials Pn ∗ m ∗ (x) = Pn ∗ m ∗ (x, s ∗ , t ∗ ), (β )
(β )
Q mn (y) = Q mn (y, s, t) appearing in Y ∗ and Y respectively, satisfy the following four n +n +···+n β +n ∗1 +n ∗2 +···+n ∗β formal series identities, with δβ β (n, n ∗ ) = (−1) 1 2 : Identity I. The following orthogonality between polynomials (shifting t) has the following Taylor series: 0 = δβ β (n, n ∗ )τmn (s, t − b)τmn ∗ (s, t + b) ) (β ) Pn ∗ ,m (x, s, t + b) Q (β (y, s, t − b) n → n − eβ + e ˆ mn β
⎞ ∂2 ln τmn ⎟ 2 ∂tβ,1 =2 bβ,+1 ⎝ ˆ ∂tβ,+1 ⎠ (s, t) + O(b ). β=1 =0 −S+2δβ βˆ (∂˜tβ )τm,n+eβ −eβˆ ◦ τm,n−eβ +eβˆ p ∞
⎛
n ∗ → n + eβ − eβˆ
2 ⎜ τmn
13 b = (b ) and b = (b ). β β β,
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
25
Identity II. The following orthogonality between polynomials (shifting s) has the following Taylor series: 0 = δβ β (n, n ∗ )τmn (s − a, t)τm ∗ n ∗ (s + a, t) ) ∗(β ) Pn ∗ m ∗ (x, s + a, t) Q (β mn (y, s − a, t) m → m − eαˆ ⎛
∗ m → m + eαˆ n → n − eβ ∗ n → n + e β
⎞ ∂2 2 ln τ −τ mn ⎠ (s, t) + O(a 2 ). =2 aα,+1 ⎝ mn ∂sα,1 ˆ ∂sα,+1 α=1 =0 S+δααˆ (∂˜sα )τm+eαˆ −eα ,n ◦ τm−eαˆ +eα ,n q ∞
Identity III. The following inner product between polynomials (shifting t) has two different Taylor series: δβ β (n, n ∗ )τmn (s, t − b)τm ∗ n ∗ (s, t + b) ) ∗(β ) Pn ∗ m ∗ (x, s, t + b) Q (β mn (y, s, t − b) m → m − eαˆ
∗ m → m + eαˆ n → n − eβ ∗ n → n + e β
= −2 =2
p ∞
β=1 =0 p ∞
bβ,+1 S (∂˜tβ )τm+eαˆ ,n+eβ ◦ τm−eαˆ ,n−eβ (s, t) + O(b2 )
2 bβ,+1 τmn
β=1 =0
∂2 ln τmn (s, t) + O(b2 ). ∂sα,1 ∂t β,+1 ˆ
Identity IV. This last inner product between polynomials (shifting s) has two different Taylor series: δβ β (n, n ∗ )τmn (s − a, t)τmn ∗ (s + a, t) ) (β ) Pn ∗ ,m (x, s + a, t) Q (β mn (y, s − a, t) n → n − eβ + eβˆ
∗ n → n + eβ − eβˆ
= −2
q ∞ α=1 =0
=2
q ∞ α=1 =0
aα,+1 S (∂˜sα )τm−eα ,n−eβˆ ◦ τm+eα ,n+eβ (s, t) + O(a 2 )
2 aα,+1 τmn
∂2 ln τmn + O(a 2 ). ∂tβ,1 ˆ ∂sα,+1
Proof. From the proof of Theorem 5.1 and (45) the following two equalities follow: ) ∗(β ) δβ β (n, n ∗ )τmn (s, t)τm ∗ n ∗ (s ∗ , t ∗ ) Pn ∗ m ∗ (x) Q (β mn (y) n → n−eβ , n ∗ → n ∗ + eβ ∗ sα → sα −aα , sα → sα + aα tβ → tβ −bβ , t ∗ → tβ + bβ β
26
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
= =
p
(−1)σβ (n)
∞
β=1 q
k=0
α=1
k=0
(−1)σα (m)
∞
Sn ∗β −n β +1+k (−2bβ )Sk (∂˜tβ )e(a,b) τm ∗ ,n ∗ +eβ ◦ τm,n−eβ Sm α −m ∗α +1+k (−2aα )Sk (∂˜sα )e(a,b) τm ∗ −eα ,n ∗ ◦ τm+eα ,n ,
and so if we just follow the four specializations leading to (46) – (49), in that order, we find the four equations of the corollary, in their given order. 7. Examples 7.1. Biorthogonal polynomials ( p = q = 1) and orthogonal polynomials. This section explains in a simple way, namely for biorthogonal polynomials, what is being done and serves as a simple model for the results of this paper. The facts presented here are at the origin of the crucial arguments (Theorem 5.1) in this paper and are inspired by facts about the (semi-infinite) 2d-Toda lattice. It has been known for quite a while that biorthogonal polynomials and the 2d-Toda lattice are intimately related; in this respect, see Ueno-Takesaki [36], Gerasimov-Marshakov-Mironov-Morozov-Orlov [25], Adlervan Moerbeke [6], just to name a few references. Given the (not necessarily symmetric) inner product with regard to the weight ρ(x, y) on R2 ,
f (x) | g(y) := f (x)g(y)ρ(x, y) d x d y, R2
∞
and the deformed weight ρt,s (x, y) = e 1 (tk y −sk x ) ρ(x, y). Setting p = q = 1, m = m 1 , n = n 1 , with m = n, implies that the indices m, n in τmn can be replaced by one single index; namely, set τn := τmn , where ∞ ∞ k k . τn (t, s) = det x i e− 1 sk x y j e 1 tk y k
k
0≤i, j≤n−1
Moreover, set ψ1 = ϕ1 = 1 and define the monic polynomials pn(1) (y) := pn(1) (t, s; y) (2) (2) ∗(1,1) and pn (x) := pn (t, s; x) (with h −1 (x)) by n−1 the leading coefficient of Pnm (1,1) (2) ∗(1,1) n−1 + · · · pn(1) (y) := Q mn (y) = y n + · · · and h −1 (x) = h −1 n−1 pn−1 (x) := Pnm n−1 x The orthogonality conditions (5) and (7) imply ∞ ∞ k k x i e− 1 sk x pn(1) (y)e 1 tk y = 0 for 0 ≤ i ≤ n − 1,
(2) − h −1 n pn (x)e
∞ 1
sk x k
k j ∞ y e 1 tk y = δ j,n for 0 ≤ j ≤ n,
for all n ≥ 0, from which the bi-orthogonality can be deduced14 (1) pn(2) (x) pm (y)ρt,s (x, y)d xd y = δnm h n . R2
14 It turns out that h = τ n n+1 (t, s)/τn (t, s).
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
27
From (4), (6), (8) and (9) and from h n = τn+1 /τn , it follows that τn (t − [z −1 ], s) τn (t, s + [z −1 ]) = pn(1) (z), z n = pn(2) (z) τn (t, s) τn (t, s) −1 pn(2) (x) −n−1 τn+1 (t + [z ], s) z = ρt,s (x, y)d xd y τn (t, s) R2 z − y τn+1 (t, s − [z −1 ]) pn(1) (y) z −n−1 = ρt,s (x, y)d xd y, τn (t, s) R2 z − x zn
and from (41), the bilinear identity becomes ∞ i τn−1 (t − [z −1 ], s) τm+1 (t + [z −1 ], s ) e 1 (ti −ti )z z n−m−2 dz z=∞ ∞ i τn (t, s − [z −1 ]) τm (t , s + [z −1 ]) e 1 (si −si )z z m−n dz, =
(57)
(58)
z=∞
which characterizes the τ -functions for the 2-component KP hierarchy. Equations (57) and the bilinear identity were obtained in [6]. Indicating the explicit dependence on t, s in the polynomials, one notices that the inner product below vanishes if t = t and s = s, since pn+1 (t, s; x) isperpendicular to any polynomial of strictly lower degree, ∞ k k with regard to the weight e 1 (tk y −sk x ) ρ(x,y)d xd y. Therefore, setting s = s, one develops the inner product for small t j − t j , which, according to Corollary 6.3, can be computed in two different ways. On the one hand, replace on the left hand side of the bilinear relation (58) above, (1) τn−1 (t − [z −1 ], s) by the polynomial pn−1 (z) and τm+1 (t + [z −1 ], s ) by the Cauchy (2)
transform of pm (z), both given by formulae (57) and set n → n + 1 and m = n + 1. This yields the inner-product (59) below using an argument similar to one appearing at the end of the proof of Theorem 5.1. Thus the inner-product below equals the left hand side of the bilinear identity (58) with n → n + 1 and m = n + 1 and can thus be expanded in t − t, setting s = s. This yields the first series in a. On the other hand, the τ -functions on the right hand side of (58) can again be replaced by a polynomial and a Cauchy transform, according to formulae (57), and setting n → n + 1 and m = n + 1, this leads to the same inner-product below. Therefore the inner-product below equals the right hand side of (58), with n → n + 1 and m = n + 1 and can thus also be expanded in a series in t − t , yielding the second series below. Thus, the following holds: ∞ k k (2) (1) (tk y −sk x ) 1 τn (t,s)τn+1 (t ,s ) d xd y pn+1 (t , s ; x) pn (t, s; y)e ρ(x,y) t → t − a R2 t → t + a s = s ⎞ ⎛ ∞ −2a j+1 S j (∂˜t )τn+2 ◦ τn + O(a 2 )⎠ =⎝ j=0
=
∞ k=1
! ∂2 2 ak τn+1 ◦ τn+1 + O(a ) . ∂tk ∂s1
(59)
28
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
Identifying the coefficients of a j+1 in both expressions and shifting n → n − 1 yield a first identity; then redoing the calculation above for s → s − b, s → s + b and t = t leads to a second one. All in all we find S j (∂˜t )τn+1 ◦ τn−1 = −τn2
∂2 ∂2 ln τn , and S j (∂˜s )τn−1 ◦ τn+1 = −τn2 ln τn . ∂s1 ∂t j+1 ∂t1 ∂s j+1 (60)
Specializing the identity (53) leads to one, expressible as a sum of two Wronskians15 , involving a single tau function:
∂ 2 ln τn ∂ 2 ln τn , ∂t1 ∂s2 ∂t1 ∂s1
+
t1
∂ 2 ln τn ∂ 2 ln τn + , ∂s1 ∂t2 ∂t1 ∂s1
+ = 0.
(61)
s1
Note that these equations, combined with Virasoro constraints (not presented in this paper), are used in the computation of the PDE for the transition probability of Dyson’s non-intersecting Brownian motions; this equation then leads in some scaling limit to a PDE for the transition probability of the infinite-dimensional diffusions, like the Airy and Sine processes [10]. This will briefly be outlined in Sect. 7.3. The orthogonal polynomial case, presented in the introduction, is obtained by specializing the above to the inner-product
f (x) | g(x) =
f (x)g(x)ρt (x) d x,
R
∞
k
for the formal deformation ρt (x) := ρ(x)e 1 tk z . It turns out the deformations only depend on t −s, which can then be replaced by t. As a consequence of (57), the functions τn (t), become Hänkel determinants τn (t) := det
R
z
i+ j
e
∞ 1
tk z k
ρ(z)dz 0≤i, j≤n−1
and are related to the monic orthogonal polynomials pn (t; z) by means of the formulae (1), leading to the equality (2) between the inner-product and the bilinear identity and thus to the fact that τn (t) satisfies the KP-hierarchy,
∂2 τn ◦ τn = 0, k = 3, 4, . . . . − 2Sk+1 ∂˜t ∂t1 ∂tk
Bi-orthogonal polynomials are to the 2d-Toda lattice what orthogonal polynomials are to the standard Toda lattice. It is well known that the semi-infinite symmetric tridiagonal # " 2 1/2 is a matrix with diagonal entries ∂t∂1 log ττi+1 and off-diagonal entries τi τi+2 /τi+1 i solution of the standard Toda lattice. References on this relationship abound, like Moser [31], Bessis-Itzykson-Zuber [16], Adler-van Moerbeke [5], and others. 15 in terms of the Wronskian { f, g} = ∂ f g − f ∂g . t ∂t ∂t
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
29
7.2. Orthogonal polynomials on the circle. In [8] it was shown that running the 2d-Toda lattice with a Toeplitz determinant as initial condition leads to the so-called Toeplitz lattice, of which a subsystem is the Ablowitz-Ladik system ([1,2]). The starting point here is the inner product on the circle between analytic functions on S 1 , dz
f (z) | g(z) = f (z −1 )g(z), √ S 1 2π −1z and the determinant of the corresponding (Toeplitz) moment matrices ∞ i ∞ i τn (t, s) := det z k e− 1 si z z e 1 ti z 0≤k,≤n−1 ∞ dz −k+ (ti z i −si z −i ) 1 = det e . z √ S 1 2π −1z 0≤k,≤n−1 Then it follows that τn (t − [z −1 ], s) τn (t, s + [z −1 ]) = pn(1) (z), z n = pn(2) (z), τn (t, s) τn (t, s) (2) −1 du pn (u −1 ) ∞ (ti u i −si u −i ) −n−1 τn+1 (t + [z ], s) z = e 1 , √ τn (t, s) z−u S 1 2π −1u (1) τn+1 (t, s − [z −1 ]) du pn (u) ∞ (ti u i −si u −i ) = z −n−1 e 1 , √ −1 τn (t, s) S 1 2π −1u z − u zn
(1)
(2)
with pn (z) and pm (z) monic orthogonal polynomials on the circle: dz τn+1 (2) −1 pn(1) (z) pm (z ) = δnm h n , with h n = . √ 1 τn S 2π −1z The nature of the inner product implies some extra-relations of Szegö type [33] between the orthogonal polynomials (see [27]) (1) (1) (2) (2) (z)−zpn(1) (z) = pn+1 (0)z n pn(2) (z −1 ) and pn+1 (z)−zpn(2) (z) = pn+1 (0)z n pn(1) (z −1 ), pn+1
leading to the following relation, according to [8], (in the Hirota notation of footnote 4)
hn h m+1
2 h n+1 h m+1 1 ˜t )τm+2 ◦ τn 1− 1− = 2 S ( ∂ n−m hn hm τm+2 τn2 × Sn−m (−∂˜s )τm+2 ◦ τn .
In particular, for m = n − 1, h n+1 hn ∂ ∂ 1− 1− =− ln h n ln h n , hn h n−1 ∂t1 ∂s1
(62)
(63)
which is true, in addition to formulae (59), (60), (61). Then, according to [8], the functions xn (t, s) := pn(1) (t, s; 0) and yn (t, s) := pn(2) (t, s; 0),
30
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
with initial condition xn (0, 0) = yn (0, 0) = 0 for n ≥ 1 and boundary condition x0 (t, s) = y0 (t, s) = 1, satisfy the Toeplitz lattice (1)
∂H ∂ yn = −(1 − xn yn ) i , ∂ti ∂ xn
(2)
∂H ∂ yn = −(1 − xn yn ) i , ∂si ∂ xn
∂H ∂ xn = (1 − xn yn ) i , ∂ti ∂ yn ∂H ∂ xn = (1 − xn yn ) i , ∂si ∂ yn
(1)
(2)
for the traces 1 = − Trace L ik , i = 1, 2, 3, . . . , k = 1, 2 i
(k)
Hi
of the “ nearly rank 2” semi-infinite matrices16 ⎛ 0 −x1 y0 1 − x1 y1 1 − x2 y2 ⎜ −x2 y0 −x2 y1 L 1 := ⎜ −x3 y2 ⎝ −x3 y0 −x3 y1 ⎛
−x0 y1 ⎜ 1 − x1 y1 L 2 := ⎜ ⎝ 0
−x0 y2 −x1 y2 1 − x2 y2
−x0 y3 −x1 y3 −x2 y3
⎞
..
..
⎟ ⎟ and ⎠ .
⎞ ⎟ ⎟. ⎠
.
The fact that τn (t, s) satisfies the PDE (61) and identities (62), (63), combined with Virasoro constraints, leads to Painlevé equations [8] and discrete Painlevé equations [9] for generating functions of combinatorics. 7.3. Non-intersecting Brownian motions and the p +q-component KP hierarchy. Consider N non-intersecting Brownian motions x1 (t), . . . , x N (t) in R, leaving from distinct points α1 < · · · < α N and forced to end up at distinct points β1 < · · · < β N . From the Karlin-McGregor formula (see [30]), the probability that all xi (t) belong to E ⊂ R √ 2 can be expressed in terms of the Gaussian p(t, x, y) = e−(x−y) /t / π t, as follows, (0 < t < 1) β β Pα (all xi (t) ∈ E) := Pα
=
(x1 (0), . . . , x N (0)) = (α1 , . . . , α N ) all xi (t) ∈ E (x (1), . . . , x (1)) = (β , . . . , β ) 1 1 N N
1 ZN
1 = ZN
EN
det[ p(t, αi , x j )]1≤i, j≤N det[ p(1 − t, xi , β j )]1≤i, j≤N , 2α x N xi2 i j − t (1−t) e d xi det e t
E N i=1
, det 1≤i, j≤N
2βi x j e 1−t
-
N
d xi
i=1
. 1≤i, j≤N
(64) For the connection of non-intersecting Brownian motions with matrix-type integrals, see e.g., Johansson [28], Aptekarev-Bleher-Daems-Kuijlaars [13,17,20], OkounkovReshetikhin [32], Tracy-Widom [34], Adler-van Moerbeke [11]. 16 Notice that, in particular, the functions (x (t, t), y (t, t)) satisfy the Ablowitz-Ladik system [1,2]. n n
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
31
The limiting case where several points α and β coincide has been the object of many interesting studies. It is obtained by taking appropriate limits of the formulae above. Just to fix the notation, consider m1
m2
mq
n1
n2
np
. /0 1 . /0 1 . /0 1 (α1 , . . . , α N ) = (a1 , a1 , . . . , a1 , a2 , a2 , . . . , a2 , . . . , aq , aq , . . . , aq ), . /0 1 . /0 1 . /0 1 (β1 , . . . , β N ) = (b1 , b1 , . . . , b1 , b2 , b2 , . . . , b2 , . . . , b p , b p , . . . , b p ), q p where α=1 aα = bβ = 0 and a1 < a2 < · · · < aq , b1 < b2 < · · · < q pβ=1 bp, α=1 m α = β=1 n β = N . Then, take the limit of (64), make a change of variables in the second equality, use the standard matrix identity in the third equality # " det ai,σ ( j) b j,σ ( j) 1≤i, j≤n = det (aik )1≤i,k≤n det (bik )1≤i,k≤n , σ ∈Sn
and distribute the integral and the Gaussian over the different columns; this yields β
Pα (all xi (t) ∈ E) =
1 ZN
2
N x − i e t (1−t) d xi
E N i=1
⎛
x ij e
2a1 x j t
⎜ 0 ≤ i < m1 ⎜ 1≤ j ≤N ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜. × det ⎜ .. ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ 2aq x ⎝ xi e t j j
=
1 Z N
0 ≤ i < mq 1≤ j ≤N
2b1 x j
!
⎞
i ⎜ x j e 1−t ⎜ ⎟ 0 ≤ i < n1 ⎜ ⎟ 1≤ j ≤N ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜. ⎟ ⎟ · det ⎜ .. ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ! ⎜ ⎟ 2b p x j ⎜ i 1−t ⎠ ⎝ xje
0 ≤ i < np 1≤ j ≤N
⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎠
N yi2 e− 2 dyi
E˜ N i=1
⎛
y i ea˜ 1 y j 0 ≤ i < m 1 ⎜ j 1≤ j ≤N ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎜. × det ⎜ .. ⎜ ⎜ ⎜ ⎝ i a˜ q y j yje 0 ≤ i < mq 1≤ j ≤N
⎛ =
⎛
⎞
N! ⎜ det ⎝ Z N
E˜
dy
y2 e− 2
⎛ ˜ y i eb1 y j 0 ≤ i < n 1 ⎜ j ⎟ 1≤ j ≤N ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜. ⎟ ⎟ · det ⎜ .. ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ i b˜ p y j ⎠ yje 0 ≤ i < np ⎞
1≤ j ≤N
˜
y i+ j e(a˜ α +bβ )y
⎞
! 0 ≤ i < mα 0 ≤ j < nβ
⎞ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ ⎟ 2 ⎟ 2 ⎠ E˜ = E t (1−t) 2 a˜ i = 2(1−t) ai 2 t 2t b b˜i = 1−t i
⎟ ⎠
.
(65)
1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p
The numerator of this probability has exactly the form (3) evaluated at sα = tβ = 0, with the inner product given by a special instance of the typical inner product, given right after (3), y2 ˜ x i ψα (x) y j ϕβ (y) = dy e− 2 y i+ j e(a˜ α +bβ )y , E˜
32
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke ˜
upon setting ψα (x) = ea˜ α x , ϕβ (y) = ebβ y and dµ(x, y) = δ(x − y)e−y ˜ e bβ y
ea˜ α y
e−
∞
χ E˜ (y) d x. ∞
k
1 and by and e 1 tβ,k y By multiplying each of the exponentials respectively, it follows that both the numerator and the denominator of the probability above, namely
⎛ ⎜ τmn (t1 , . . . , t p ; s1 , . . . , sq ) = det ⎝
= det
E˜
dy
y2 e− 2
˜ y i+ j e(a˜ α +bβ )y+
sα,k
2 /2
yk
⎞
!
∞
1 (tβ,k −sα,k
)y k 0 ≤ i < mα 0 ≤ j < nβ
x i ψα−s (x) y j ϕβt (y) 0 ≤ i < m α
!
⎟ ⎠ 1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p
1≤α≤q 1≤β≤ p
0 ≤ j < nβ
and the same expression for E = R, satisfy the bilinear identity for the p + q-component KP hierarchy and, in particular, all the general relations and identities, mentioned in this paper, namely (13) and (51), (52), (53). Note the equations are all independent of the set E.
7.4. Non-intersecting Brownian motions leaving from one point, forced to p target points and a PDE for the transition probability. As a concrete application of the theory developed in this paper, we give a PDE for the transition probability of N non-intersecting Brownian motions in R leaving from the origin, p with n i particles forced to reach the p distinct target points bi at time t = 1, with i=1 n i = N . Applying formula (65) yields the following expression, after some manipulations, 1 P (all xi (t) ∈ E) = Zn ×
E˜ N
n
e
N (x
(1)
,...,x
)
p
n (x () )
=1
()2 () − 12 x j +b˜ x j
j=1
( p)
() 2 dx j . 2 E˜ = E t (1−t) 2 2t b b˜ = 1−t
Therefore, consider the following probability, which differs from the Brownian motion transition probability by a simple time and space change, as indicated above, (setting n := (n 1 , n 2 , . . . , n p )) 1 Pn (E; b1 , . . . , b p ) = Zn
EN
N (x (1) , . . . , x ( p) )
p =1
n (x () )
n
1 ()2
e− 2 x j
()
+b x j
()
dx j .
j=1
(66) The target points bi must be viewed as variables, just as the boundary points of the set E. However it is crucial the target points p to impose one non-trivial linear relation between p b1 , . . . , b p ; e.g., 1 ci bi = 0 with constants c1 , . . . , c p , where 1 ci = 1; without loss of generality, one may assume c p = 0. Theorem 7.2 at the end of this section gives the PDE satisfied by the integral above, with this linear dependence; it is given by the determinant of a ( p + 1) × ( p + 1) matrix. This section contains merely an outline of the proof; the details will appear in [4].
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
33
()
As before, adjoin extra-variables β , ti and si ’s for 1 ≤ ≤ p to the integral (66) p above, with the same linear dependence between the βi ’s as the bi ’s, namely 1 ci βi = 0. So, define the integral, also expressible as a determinant of a moment matrix, as shown in the previous section, τn (E) := τn 1 ,...,n p (E; b1 , . . . , b p−1 ; t; s (1) , . . . , s ( p) , β1 , . . . , β p−1 ) p n () i ∞ 1 N (x (1) , . . . , x ( p) ) e i=1 ti (x j ) = p N 1 n! E =1 j=1 ⎛ ⎞ p n () ()2 ∞ () ()i 1 ()2 () ⎝n (x () ) e− 2 x j +b x j +β x j − i=1 si x j d x j ⎠ 1p ci bi =0 j=1 =1
p 1 ci βi =0
⎞
⎛
)0≤i≤n 1 −1, 0≤ j≤N −1 (µi(1) ⎟ ⎜. j ⎟, = det ⎜ ⎠ ⎝ .. ( p) (µi j )0≤i≤n p −1, 0≤ j≤N −1
(67)
x2
where F1 (x) := e− 2 in the inner-product below and where one only indicates the dependency on the auxiliary variables, () k x2 2 ∞ () µi j (t − s () , β ) = x i+ j e− 2 +b x+β x e 1 (tk −sk )x d x E˜ ∞ ∞ () k 2 i = x i e− 1 sk x eb x+β x x j e 1 tk x , 1 f (x)g(x)F1 (x)d x. for f | g 1 = E˜
Since the matrix (67) consists of p blocks, arranged vertically, the function τn satisfies the p + 1-component KP hierarchy, according to Proposition 6.2, and thus we have the p equations for τn , 3 4 4 3 ∂ 2 ln τn ∂ 2 ln τn ∂ 2 ln τn ∂ 2 ln τn , () − , () = 0, for 1 ≤ ≤ p. (68) () () ∂s2 ∂t1 ∂s1 ∂t1 t1 ∂s1 ∂t2 ∂s1 ∂t1 s () 1
Using the Virasoro constraints, it happens that all (t, s)-derivatives in Eq. (68) can be expressed purely in terms of derivatives in the endpoints of the set E and the bi ’s, upon setting t, s () , β equal to zero; e.g., the cross derivative in s1() and t1 can be expressed as second derivatives with regard to the endpoints of the set E and the bi ’s, −
∂ 2 ln τn ()
∂s1 ∂t1
= (∂(b) + c ∂)∂ ln τn + n =: F , 1 ≤ ≤ p,
where τn is the integral (66) above and with17 17 For instance, for the interval E = (x, y), the Euler operator reads x ∂ + y ∂ . ∂x ∂y
34
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
∂ := ε :=
sum of partials in the boundary points of E Euler operator in the boundary points of E
+ + −
p−1 1
and ∂ bi ∂b i
⎧ p−1 ∂ (b) ⎪ ⎨ ∂ := − ∂b∂ (1 − δp ) + c 1 ∂bi , ⎪ ⎩ implying p
(b) =1 ∂ = 0.
(69) (b)
Note that ∂ bk = c − δk . So, setting all auxiliary parameters t, s () , β equal to zero, one ultimately shows that the p equations (68) can be transformed into p equations, purely in terms of the boundary points of E and the final points bi , also taking into account the value18 τn (R) of the integral (67) over the full range R, since Pn (E) = τn (E)/τn (R) for t = s = β = 0. The only remaining undesirable partials, to be eliminated, are the partials with regard to the β ’s, which appear on the right hand side of the final equation for Pn , 5 6 6 6 5 5 (β) (1) (2) ∂ ∂ ln Pn , F = H , F − H , F (b) , 1 ≤ ≤ p. (70) ∂
∂
∂
(i)
Here the F ’s are the same as above, but with τn replaced by Pn , as in (66), and the H (i) are given below, with the C being explicit rational functions of the target points19 bi , (b) (2) (b) F := ∂ + c ∂ ∂ ln Pn + n , H := (1 − ε + 2b ∂) ∂ + c ∂ ln Pn , H(1) := −c ∂ε + ((ε − 1)c + 2)(∂(b) + c ∂) ln Pn + C . (71) Using the short-hand notation, 6 5 6 5 (β) X = ∂ ∂ ln Pn, H := H(1), F − H(2), F ∂
Eqs. (70) become (taking into account {X , F } = H ,
(b)
∂
p
(β) =1 ∂
, f := ∂ ln Pn and := ∂, (72)
= 0)
1 ≤ ≤ p, with
p
X = 0.
1
Proposition 7.1. Given functions H and F , the system of ode’s {X , F } = H ,
1≤≤ p
18 where 1 p n b2 1 i i
τn (R)|t=s=β=0 = K n, p e− 2
(bi − b j )n i n j , for some constant K n, p .
1≤i< j≤ p
nj 19 The value of the constant in the formula below equals C = −2n (1 − c )b + j = b −b j
.
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
subjected to the condition
p 1
35
X = 0, has the following solution ↓
⎛
F1 ⎜ F1 F ⎜ det ⎜ .. X = ⎝. D ( p) F1
F2 F2 .. . ( p) F2
⎞ F3 . . . −G 1 . . . F p F3 . . . −G 2 . . . F p ⎟ ⎟ ⎟, .. .. .. ⎠ . . . ( p) ( p) F3 . . . −G p . . . F p
(73)
where D is the wronskian of the functions F1 , . . . , F p , ⎛ ⎞ F1 F2 F3 . . . F p ⎜ F1 F2 F3 . . . F p ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ D = det ⎜ .. ⎟, .. .. .. ⎝. ⎠ . . . ( p) ( p) ( p) ( p) F1 F2 F3 . . . F p and where the G i ’s are defined inductively as G i+1 = G i +
p (i) H F
F2
=1
Moreover
⎛
F1 ⎜ F1 ⎜ ⎜F det ⎜ 1 ⎜ .. ⎝. ( p) F1
F2 F2 F2 .. . ( p) F2
, G 0 = 0, G 1 =
p H . F
(74)
1
F3 F3 F3 .. . ( p) F3
. . . Fp . . . F p . . . F p .. . ( p) . . . Fp
⎞ G0 G1 ⎟ ⎟ G2 ⎟ ⎟ = 0. .. ⎟ . ⎠ Gp
(75)
Proof. : Any equation of the form {X , F } = H has a solution whose derivatives are given by (i) X
(i)
= G ,i
F + X , F
(76)
where the G i are defined inductively as, (i)
G 0 = 0, G 1 =
H F H , . . . , G ,i+1 = G i + . F F2
Indeed, starting with (76) and using X = (i+1)
X
= G i + X
(i)
1 F (H
(i+1)
F F + X F F
+ X F ), one computes inductively (i)
− X
F F F2
= (G i +
(i)
H F F2
= G ,i+1 + X
(i+1)
) + X (i+1)
F , F
F F
36
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
establishing (76). Summing up (76) from 1 to p, one finds 0 = Gi +
p
(i)
F , where G i := G ,i . F
X
=1
p
=1
Then solving this linear system pfor the X ’s, one finds the ratio (73) above. Then using that solution and expressing 1 X = 0 establishes (75) and thus Proposition 7.1. This enables us to make the following statement, remembering the partials ∂ = , ε, p with 1 ∂(b) = 0 as defined in (69):
∂(b) ,
Theorem 7.2. [4] The probability Pn (E; b1 , . . . , b p ) as in (66), with the linear constraint p p 1 ci bi = 0, with 1 ci = 1, satisfies a non-linear PDE in the boundary points of the interval E and in the target points bi , given by the determinant of a ( p + 1) × ( p + 1) matrix ⎞ ⎛ F1 F2 F3 . . . F p G 0 ⎜ F1 F2 F3 . . . F p G 1 ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜F F2 F3 . . . F p G 2 ⎟ (77) det ⎜ 1 ⎟ = 0, .. .. .. .. ⎟ ⎜ .. ⎝. . . . . ⎠ ( p)
F1
( p)
F2
( p)
F3
( p)
. . . Fp
Gp
where the F and G are given by (for C see footnote 18) (b) F := ∂ + c ∂ ∂ ln Pn + n , G +1 :=
G
+
p
(1)
(∂ F j ) ∂
Hj
j=1
Fj
(b) − ∂j
(2) !
Hj
Fj
,
G 0 = 0,
(b) := −c ∂ε + ((ε − 1)c + 2)(∂ + c ∂) ln Pn + C , H(2) := (1 − ε + 2b ∂) ∂(b) + c ∂ ln Pn . 6 5 6 5 (1) (2) Example. Setting H := H , F − H , F (b) , one has the following equations: (1)
H
p = 1 ⇒ det
F1 0 F1 HF11 ⎛
∂
∂
= H1 = 0,
F1 F2 ⎜ F F p = 2 ⇒ F1 F2 det ⎝ 1 2 F1 F2
H1 F1 H1 F1
0 + +
⎞ H2 F2 H2 F2
⎟ ⎠
= (H1 F2 + H2 F1 ){F1 , F2 } − (H1 F2 + H2 F1 ){F1 , F2 } = 0. Upon taking appropriate scaling limits on these PDE’s, one finds new PDE’s for the transition probabilities of the critical infinite-dimensional diffusions, like the Airy process, the Pearcey process, the Airy process with k outliers, and others; see e.g., [3,10,11]. We have for instance, letting N → ∞: p = 1 ⇒ p = 2 ⇒
b1 = 0 ⇒ Airy process, b1 = −a, b2 = a ⇒ Pearcey process b1 = 0, b2 > 0 ⇒ Airy process with k outliers.
Moment Matrices and Multi-Component KP- Applications to Random Matrix Theory
37
References 1. Ablowitz, M.J., Ladik, J.F.: On the solution of a class of nonlinear partial difference equations. Studies in Appl. Math. 57, 1–12 (1976) 2. Ablowitz, M.J., Ladik, J.F.: Non-linear differential-difference equations and Fourier analysis. J. Math. Phys. 17, 1011–1018 (1976) 3. Adler, M., Delépine, J., van Moerbeke, P., Vanhaecke, P.: Dyson’s non-intersecting Brownian motions with a few outliers. To appear Comm Pure Appl Math, doi:10.1002/cpa.2064, available at http://arxiv. org/abs/:math.PR/0707.0442, 2008, vi[math], 2007 4. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P., Vanhaecke, P.: Non-intersecting Brownian motions from one to many points. To appear, 2008 5. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: Matrix integrals, Toda symmetries, Virasoro constraints, and orthogonal polynomials. Duke Math. J. 80, 863–911 (1995) 6. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: String-orthogonal polynomials, string equations and 2-Toda symmetries. Comm. Pure & Appl. Math. 50, 241–290 (1997) 7. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: Generalized orthogonal polynomials, discrete KP and Riemann-Hilbert problems. Commun. Math. Phys. 207, 589–620 (1999) 8. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: Integrals over classical groups, random permutations Toda and Toeplitz lattices. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 54(2), 153–205 (2001) 9. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: Recursion relations for Unitary integrals of Combinatorial nature and the Toeplitz lattice. Commun. Math. Phys. 237, 397–440 (2003) 10. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: PDEs for the joint distributions of the Dyson, Airy and sine processes. Ann. Probab. 33(4), 1326–1361 (2005) 11. Adler, M., van Moerbeke, P.: PDE’s for the Gaussian ensemble with external source and the Pearcey distribution. Comm. Pure and Appl. Math. 60, 1–32 (2007) 12. Aptekarev, A.: Multiple orthogonal polynomials. J. Comp. Appl. Math. 99, 423–447 (1998) 13. Aptekarev, A., Bleher, P., Kuijlaars, A.: Large n limit of Gaussian random matrices with external source. II. Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 367–389 (2005) 14. Aptekarev, A., Branquinho, A., Van Assche, W.: Multiple orthogonal polynomials for classical weights. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 355, 3887–3914 (2003) 15. Bergvelt, M.J., ten Kroode Bergvelt, A.P.E.: Vertex operator constructions and multi-component KP equations. Pacific J. Math. 171, 23–88 (1995) 16. Bessis, D., Itzykson, Cl., Zuber, J.-B.: Quantum field theory techniques in graphical enumeration. Adv. Appl. Math. 1, 109–157 (1980) 17. Bleher, P., Kuijlaars, A.: Random matrices with external source and multiple orthogonal polynomials. Int. Math. Res. Not. 3, 109–129 (2004) 18. Bleher, P., Kuijlaars, A.: Large n limit of Gaussian random matrices with external source, Part I. Commun. Math. Phys. 252, 43–76 (2004) 19. Bleher, P., Kuijlaars, A.: Random matrices with external source and multiple orthogonal polynomials. Int. Math. Res. Not. 3, 109–129 (2004) 20. Daems, E., Kuijlaars, A.B.J.: Multiple orthogonal polynomials of mixed type and non-intersecting Brownian motions. J. Approx. Theory 146, 91–114 (2007) 21. Date, E., Jimbo, M., Kashiwara, M., Miwa T.: Transformation groups for soliton equations, In: Proc. RIMS Symp. Nonlinear integrable systems — Classical and quantum theory (Kyoto 1981), Singapore: World Scientific, 1983, pp. 39–119 22. Deift, P., Zhou, X.: A steepest descent method for oscillatory Riemann-Hilbert problems. Ann. of Math. 137, 295–368 (1993) 23. Dickey, L.A.: Soliton equations and integrable systems. Singapore: World Scientific, 1991 24. Fokas, A.S., Its, A.R., Kitaev, A.V.: The isomonodromy approach to matrix models in 2D quantum gravity. Commun. Math. Phys. 147(2), 395–430 (1992) 25. Gerasimov, A., Marshakov, A., Mironov, A., Morozov, A., Orlov, A.: Matrix models of two-dimensional gravity and Toda theory. Nucl. Phys. B 357, 565–618 (1991) 26. Geronimo, J.S., Case, K.M.: Scattering theory and polynomials orthogonal on the real line. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 258, 467–494 (1980) 27. Hisakado, M.: Unitary matrix models and Painlevé III. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 11, 3001–3010 (1996) 28. Johansson, K.: Universality of the Local Spacing distribution in certain ensembles of Hermitian Wigner Matrices. Commun. Math. Phys. 215, 683–705 (2001) 29. Kac, V.G., van de Leur, J.W.: The n-component KP hierarchy and representation theory, Integrability, topological solitons and beyond. J. Math. Phys. 44, 3245–3293 (2003) 30. Karlin, S., McGregor, J.: Coincidence probabilities. Pacific J. Math. 9, 1141–1164 (1959)
38
M. Adler, P. van Moerbeke, P. Vanhaecke
31. Moser, J.: Finitely many mass points on the line under the influence of an exponential potential–an integrable system. In: Dynamical systems, theory and applications (Rencontres, BattelleRes. Inst., Seattle, Wash., 1974), Lecture Notes in Phys., vol. 38, Berlin: Springer, 1975, pp. 467–497 32. Okounkov, A., Reshetikhin, N.: Random skew plane partitions and the Pearcey process. Commun. Math. Phys. 269(3), 571–609 (2007) 33. Szegö, G.: Orthogonal polynomials. Fourth edition, American Mathematical Society, Colloquium Publications, vol. XXIII. Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1975, xiii+432 pp. 34. Tracy, C.A., Widom, H.: Differential equations for Dyson processes. Commun. Math. Phys. 252, 7–41 (2004) 35. Tracy, C.A., Widom, H.: The Pearcey Process. Commun. Math. Phys. 263(2), 381–400 (2006) 36. Ueno, K., Takasaki, K.: Toda lattice hierarchy. In Group representations and systems of differential equations (Tokyo, 1982), vol. 4 of Adv. Stud. Pure Math., Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1984, pp. 1–95 37. Van Assche, W., Coussement, E.: Some classical multiple orthogonal polynomials. J. Comp. Appl. Math. 127, 317–347 (2001) 38. Van Assche, W., Geronimo, J.S., Kuijlaars, A.: Riemann-Hilbert problems for multiple orthogonal polynomials. In: Special functions 2000: Current Perspectives and Future directions, Bustoz J. et al., eds., Dordrecht: Kluwer, 2001, pp. 23–59 39. Wiegmann, P.B., Zabrodin, A.: Conformal maps and integrable hierarchies. Commun. Math. Phys. 213, 523–538 (2000) Communicated by P. Sarnak
Commun. Math. Phys. 286, 39–79 (2009) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0685-0
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations Yvan Martel1 , Frank Merle2 1 Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines, Mathématiques,
UMR 8100, 45, av. des Etats-Unis, 78035 Versailles cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Université de Cergy-Pontoise, IHES and CNRS, Mathématiques,
2, av. Adolphe Chauvin, 95302 Cergy-Pontoise cedex, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 22 October 2007 / Accepted: 5 September 2008 Published online: 21 November 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: We continue our study of the collision of two solitons for the subcritical generalized KdV equations ∂t u + ∂x (∂x2 u + f (u)) = 0.
(0.1)
Solitons are solutions of the type u(t, x) = Q c0 (x − x0 − c0 t) where c0 > 0. In [21], mainly devoted to the case f (u) = u 4 , we have introduced a new framework to understand the collision of two solitons Q c1 , Q c2 for (0.1) in the case c2 c1 (or equivalently, Q c2 H 1 Q c1 H 1 ). In this paper, we consider the case of a general nonlinearity f (u) for which Q c1 , Q c2 are nonlinearly stable. In particular, since f is general and c1 can be large, the results are not perturbations of the ones for the power case in [21]. First, we prove that the two solitons survive the collision up to a shift in their trajectory and up to a small perturbation term whose size is explicitly controlled from above: after the collision, u(t) ∼ Q c1+ + Q c2+ , where c+j is close to c j ( j = 1, 2). Then, we exhibit new exceptional solutions similar to multi-soliton solutions: for all c1 , c2 > 0, c2 c1 , there exists a solution ϕ(t) such that ϕ(t, x) = Q c1 (x−ρ1 (t)) + Q c2 (x−ρ2 (t)) + η(t, x), for t −1, ϕ(t, x) = Q c1 (x−ρ1 (t)) + Q c2 (x−ρ2 (t)) + η(t, x), for t 1, where ρ j (t) → c j ( j = 1, 2) and η(t) converges to 0 in a neighborhood of the solitons as t → ±∞. The analysis is split in two distinct parts. For the interaction region, we extend the algebraic tools developed in [21] for the power case, by expanding f (u) as a sum of powers plus a perturbation term. To study the solutions in large time, we rely on previous tools on asymptotic stability in [17,22] and [18], refined in [19,20]. This research was supported in part by the Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR ONDENONLIN).
40
Y. Martel, F. Merle
1. Introduction We consider the generalized Korteweg-de Vries (gKdV) equations: ∂t u + ∂x (∂x2 u + f (u)) = 0, (t, x) ∈ R+ × R, u(0) = u 0 ∈ H 1 (R),
(1.1)
for general C s nonlinearity f for which small solitons are stable. We assume that for p = 2, 3 or 4, f 1 (u) p p+4 (1.2) and lim p = 0. f (u) = u + f 1 (u) where f 1 is C u→0 u Remark that if the nonlinearity is of the form f (u) = au p + f 1 (u), a > 0, then we may 1
assume a = 1 by considering u (t, x) = a p−1 u(t, x) instead of u(t, x) and changing f 1 accordingly. We only consider the case where p = 2, 3 or 4 in (1.2) since otherwise solitons with small speed would not be stable, which is necessary in this paper. Denote s F(s) = 0 f (s )ds . The Cauchy problem for Eq. (1.1) is locally well-posed in H 1 (R) (see Kenig, Ponce and Vega [12]). All solutions considered in this paper are global in time. For H 1 solutions, the following quantities are conserved: u 2 (t, x)d x = u 20 (x)d x, 1 2 E(u(t)) = (1.3) (∂x u) (t, x)d x − F(u(t, x))d x 2 1 = (∂x u 0 )2 (x)d x − F(u 0 (x))d x. 2 Recall that Eq. (1.1) has soliton solutions, i.e. of the form u(t, x) = Q c (x − x0 − c t), where c > 0, x0 ∈ R and Q c + f (Q c ) = c Q c ,
Qc ∈ H 1.
(1.4)
Note that, for all c > 0, if p = 2, 4 then there is at most one solution of (1.4) (up to translations), which is positive, whereas for p = 3, a positive and a negative solution of (1.4) might exist. For all c > 0, if a solution Q c > 0 of (1.4) exists then it can be chosen even on R and decreasing on R+ (and similarly if Q c < 0). We refer to Sect. 6 of Berestycki and Lions [1] for these properties and a necessary and sufficient condition for existence. In this paper, we consider only nonlinearly stable solitons in the sense of Weinstein [29], i.e. such that d (1.5) Q 2c (x)d x c =c > 0. dc Note that since p = 2, 3 or 4 in (1.2), this condition is satisfied for c > 0 small enough. We recall the following stability result. Stability result [29]. Let c > 0 be such that (1.5) holds. Then, there exist K , α0 > 0 such that for any u 0 ∈ H 1 , if u 0 − Q c H 1 ≤ α0 , then the solution u(t) of (1.1) is global and, for all t ∈ R, inf y∈R u(t, . + y) − Q c H 1 ≤ K α0 .
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
41
From [1] and (1.2), it follows that there exists c∗ ( f ) > 0 (possibly +∞) defined by c∗ ( f ) = sup{c > 0 such that ∀c ∈ (0, c), ∃Q c positive solution of (1.4)}. In [19], we have proved that 0 < c < c∗ ( f ) and (1.5) are sufficient conditions of asymptotic stability in the energy space H 1 around the soliton Q c . Combining the stability result and the asymptotic stability result, we obtain the following. Asymptotic stability [17,19]. Let 0 < c < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds. There exists α0 > 0 such that for any u 0 ∈ H 1 , if u 0 − Q c H 1 ≤ α0 , then the solution u(t) of (1.1) is global and there exist c+ ∈ (0, c∗ ( f )), t → ρ(t) ∈ R such that for all A > 0, c t as t → +∞. (1.6) u(t) − Q c+ (. − ρ(t)) → 0 in H 1 x > 10 We also recall from [15] the following result of existence and uniqueness of asymptotic N -soliton-like solutions (see Theorem 1 and Remark 2 in [15]). Asymptotic N -soliton-like solution [15]. Let N ≥ 1 and x1 , . . . , x N ∈ R. Let 0 < c N < · · · < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds for all c j , j = 1, . . . , N . Then, there exists a unique H 1 solution u(t) of (1.1) such that N Q c j (. − x j − c j t) lim u(t) − = 0. t→−∞ 1 j=1 H
Recall also that this behavior is in some sense stable in the energy space, see Martel, Merle and Tsai [22]. We are concerned with the problem of collision of two solitons. This is a classical problem in nonlinear wave propagation which we briefly review (see also the introduction of [21] and to the references therein). First, Fermi, Pasta and Ulam [6] and Zabusky and Kruskal [30] have exhibited from the numerical point of view remarkable phenomena related to soliton collision. Next, Lax [13] has developed a mathematical framework to study these problems, known now as complete integrability. The inverse scattering transform (for a review on this theory, we refer for example to Miura [23]) then provided explicit formulas for N -soliton solutions (Hirota [8]): let f (u) = u 2 or f (u) = u 3 , and let c1 > · · · > c N > 0, δ1 , . . . , δ N ∈ R. There exists an explicit solution U (t, x) of (1.1) which satisfies N U (t, x) − Q c j (. − c j t − δ j ) −→ 0, t→−∞ 1 j=1 H N U (t, x) − Q c j (. − c j t − δ j ) −→ 0, 1 t→+∞ j=1 H
δ j
δ j
such that the shifts j = − δ j depend on the (ck ). For example, the for some following function U1,c , is a 2-soliton solution of (1.1) with p = 2, (0 < c < 1):
√ √ ∂2 with U1,c (t, x) = 6 2 log 1 + e x−t + e c(x−ct) + αe x−t e c(x−ct) ∂x √ 2 1− c . α= √ 1+ c
(1.7)
42
Y. Martel, F. Merle
As pointed out in [21], the problem of describing the collision of two traveling waves is a general problem for nonlinear PDEs, which is completely open, except in the integrable case described above. This kind of problems has been studied since the 60’s from both experimental and numerical points of view. We recall some numerical works for equations of gKdV type. Bona et al. [2], and Kalisch and Bona [11], studied numerically the problem of collision of two solitary waves for the Benjamin and the BBM equations. Shih [26] studied the case of the gKdV equation (1.1) with some half-integer values of p. Li and Sattinger [14] investigated the collision problem for the Ion Acoustic Plasma equation, and Craig et al. [5] report on numerics for the Euler equation with free surface. In all these works, the numerics match the experiments and show that for these models, unlike for the pure solitons of the integrable case, the collision of two solitary waves fails to be elastic by a very small but non zero dispersion. Finally, the multi-soliton solutions of the NLS (nonlinear Schrödinger) model, with special nonlinearity and under spectral assumptions (ruling out the existence of small solitary waves) have been studied by Perelman [24] and Rodnianski, Schlag and Soffer [25] (in a special case where the collision has a negligible effect on the solitary waves due to a very small time of interaction). See also Cao and Malomed [3], Holmer, Marzuola and Zworski [10], and Holmer and Zworski [9] for the case of the collision of a soliton of the NLS equation with a Dirac potential. In [21], we present a complete rigorous description of the collision of two solitons of (1.1) for the nonlinearity f (u) = u 4 in the case where one soliton is small with respect to the other. First, we prove that the collision is not completely elastic in this case, i.e. there does not exist a pure 2-soliton solution (Theorem 1.1 in [21]). Note that this is the first rigorous result related to an inelastic (but close to an elastic) collision, and that a precise measurement of the defect follows from the analysis (see Theorems 1.1 and 1.2 in [21]). We also prove that for any solution behaving as t → −∞ approximately as the sum of two solitons of different sizes, the two solitons are preserved after the collision, with a residual term very small compared to the sizes of the two solitons. Moreover, we give a detailed description of the collision such as explicit formulas for the main orders of the shifts on the trajectories of the solitons (see Theorems 1.2 and 1.3 in [21]). In this paper, we consider the same questions as in [21] for (1.1) with a general nonlinearity f (u) satisfying (1.2). The results will apply in particular to f (u) = u 2 + λu q or f (u) = u 3 + λu q , for q > 2, λ ∈ R. We consider two solitons Q c1 , Q c2 , with 0 < c2 c1 < c∗ ( f ). Note that the condition on c1 , i.e. 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) is not a smallness condition. Indeed, for many nonlinearities c∗ ( f ) = +∞. Thus, we do not simply perturb the power case. Our first result describes the collision for the asymptotic 2-soliton like solutions. Theorem 1.1 (Behavior after collision of the asymptotic 2-soliton-like solution). Let p = 2, 3 or 4. Assume that f satisfies (1.2). Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that the positive solution Q c1 of (1.4) with c = c1 satisfies (1.5). There exist c0 = c0 (c1 ) ∈ (0, c1 ) and K = K (c1 ) > 0 such that for any 0 < c2 < c0 , if Q c2 is a solution of (1.4) with c = c2 , then the following holds. Let u(t) be the solution of (1.1) satisfying lim u(t) − Q c1 (. − c1 t) − Q c2 (. − c2 t) H 1 = 0.
t→−∞
Then, there exist ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t), c1+ > c2+ > 0 and K > 0 such that w + (t, x) = u(t, x) − Q c1+ (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (x − ρ2 (t))
(1.8)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
43
1
satisfies supt∈R w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1 and 2
lim w + (t) H 1 (x> 1 c2 t) = 0, lim sup w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
t→+∞
10
1 − 14 − 100
t→+∞
lim |ρ1 (t) − c1+ | + |ρ2 (t) − c2+ | = 0.
.
(1.9) (1.10)
t→+∞
Moreover, limt→+∞ E(w + (t)) = E + and limt→+∞ (w + )2 (t) = M + exist and 1 lim sup ((wx+ )2 + c2 (w + )2 )(t) ≤ 2E + + c2 M + 2 t→+∞ ≤ lim inf ((wx+ )2 + 2c2 (w + )2 )(t), (1.11) t→+∞
c+ 1 (2E + + c2 M + ) ≤ 1 − 1 ≤ K (2E + + c2 M + ), K c1 2 1 2 −1 c+ 1 p−1 − 2 c2 (2E + + c1 M + ) ≤ 1 − 2 ≤ K c2p−1 2 (2E + + c1 M + ). K c2
(1.12) (1.13)
By time and space translation invariances, the conclusions of Theorem 1.1 hold for any asymptotic 2−soliton solution. If p = 2 or 4, Q c2 is necessarily a positive solution. If p = 3, Q c2 can be positive or negative. By considering − f (−u) instead of f (u) one can also consider the case Q c1 < 0 for p = 3. Remark 1. 1. Note that there exists K > 0 such that for c small, ∀x ∈ R,
√ √ 1 1 1 p−1 c e− c|x| ≤ |Q c (x)| ≤ K c p−1 e− c|x| , K
(1.14)
so that, for c small, 1
Q c H 1 ∼ K 1 c p−1
− 14
1
, Q c L ∞ ∼ K 2 c p−1 .
(1.15)
The main information provided by Theorem 1.1 is that the 2-soliton structure is preserved for all time at the main order. Indeed, we observe that for p = 2, 3 or 4, 2 1 1 1 p−1 − 4 − 100 < p−1 , thus from (1.9) and (1.15), the two soliton structure is recov1
ered asymptotically in large time. Moreover, since supt∈R w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1 Q c2 H 1 , the 2 soliton structure is preserved also during the collision. Note that this 1
estimate is optimal, the perturbation due to the collision being exactly of size c2p−1 in H 1 during the collision region. Theorems 1.2 and 1.3 below give other illustrations of the stability of the two soliton dynamics through the collision. 2. Estimate (1.12) means that the speed of the soliton Q c1 can only increase through the interaction, and that if c1+ = c1 then u(t) is a pure 2-soliton solution both at +∞ and −∞. Similarly, c2 can only decrease. Remarkably, for p = 3, the property does not depend on the sign of Q c2 . Note that it is well-known for the case f (u) = u 2 or u 3 that the solution u(t) considered in Theorem 1.1 is pure at ±∞ (u(t) is explicit in the integrable cases). In contrast, in the case f (u) = u 4 it was proved in Theorem 1.1 of [21] that there exists no pure
44
Y. Martel, F. Merle
2-soliton solution at both +∞ and −∞. In the general case f (u), whether or not the collision is elastic is an open question. A natural question related to Theorem 1.1 is thus to try to understand, in the case of a general nonlinearity f (u) in which situation the collision is elastic or inelastic, and what is the size of the defect. Our second result is related to the construction of an object similar to the 2-soliton solutions with a perturbation term, such that the speeds as t → ±∞ are the same. We also obtain an explicit formula for the first order of the resulting shift on the first soliton. The formula is related to the functions c → Q c and c → Q 2c for c close to c1 . Theorem 1.2 (Existence of 2-soliton like solutions). Let p = 2, 3 or 4. Assume that f satisfies (1.2). Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that the positive solution Q c1 of (1.4) with c = c1 satisfies (1.5). There exist c0 = c0 (c1 ) ∈ (0, c1 ) and K = K (c1 ) > 0 such that if 0 < c2 < c0 , and Q c2 is a solution of (1.4) with c = c2 , then there exist a global H 1 solution ϕ(t) = ϕc1 ,c2 (t) of (1.1) and 1 , 2 ∈ R, ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t) satisfying, for all t, x ∈ R, ϕ(−t, −x) = ϕ(t, x),
(1.16)
and such that the following holds for w± (t) where w − (t, x) = ϕ(t, x) − Q c1 (x + ρ1 (−t)) − Q c2 (x + ρ2 (−t)), w + (t, x) = ϕ(t, x) − Q c1 (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2 (x − ρ2 (t)). 1. Asymptotic behavior at ±∞: lim w − (t) H 1 (x< c2 t ) = 0,
t→−∞
10
lim w + (t) H 1 (x> c2 t ) = 0,
t→+∞
(1.17)
10
lim |ρ1 (t) − c1 | + |ρ2 (t) − c2 | = 0.
(1.18)
t→+∞
2. Distance to the sum of two solitons: there exists t0 > 0 such that 2
w − (−t) H 1 + w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
1 − 14 − 100
, for all t > t0 . 3
3. Shift property: there exist δ1 (c1 ), δ2 (c1 ) ∈ R such that for Tc1 ,c2 = c12 2
|ρ1 (Tc1 ,c2 ) − (c1 Tc1 ,c2 + 21 1 )| ≤ K c2p−1
− 21
(1.19)
− 1 − c2 c1
2
1 100
,
,
1 12
|ρ2 (Tc1 ,c2 ) − (c2 Tc1 ,c2 + 21 2 )| ≤ K c2 , 1 −1 2 1 −1 c2 p−1 2 δ1 (c1 ) ≤ K c2p−1 2 , |2 − δ2 (c1 )| ≤ K c212 . 1 − c1
(1.20) (1.21)
Moreover, δ1 (c1 ) = 2 sgn(Q c2 (0))
d Q c |c=c1 Q c1 dc . d 2 Q c |c=c dc
(1.22)
1
Remark 2. 1. By (1.2), assuming c1 small is sufficient to ensure the assumptions of Theorem 1.2. However, Theorem 1.2 holds for any (c1 , c2 ) such that 0 < c1 < c∗ , 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ) and (1.5) holds for c1 .
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations 1
45
−1
2. Recall that Q c2 L 2 ∼ K c2p−1 4 . This is to be compared with the size of w ± (t) in 1 has no particular meaning. By the technique (1.19). Note that in estimate (1.19), 100 2
− 1 − 0
of the present paper, one can get w+ (t) H 1 ≤ K ( 0 )c2p−1 4 , for any 0 > 0, which is sharp, see a lower bound on w+ (t) for the case f (u) = u 4 , in Theorem 1.2 in [21]. 3. If there exists a Viriel property for f (u) and Q c1 , as it is the case for f (u) = u p ( p = 2, 3, 4, see [20,21]), then ρ j (t) − c j t → x +j as t → +∞, for some x +j ( j = 1, 2). In particular, it is the case if c1 is small since then the problem is a pertubation of f (u) = u p and the Viriel argument still works for f (u). Note also that at t = Tc1 ,c2 , the two solitons are already decoupled, by exponential decay. Thus, (1.20) means that through the collision, the two solitons are shifted by 1 , respectively, 2 at the first order. In (1.21), we see that the main part of 1 (if δ1 = 0) is the product of a power of cc21 (depending only on p) by δ(c1 ) which depends on Q c1 and thus on the nonlinearity f (s) on the interval s ∈ [0, Q c1 (0)]. By the stability assumption, 2 d d Q c |c=c > 0, but the other term in (1.22) dc Q c |c=c may have any sign we have dc 1 1 p (for example, for f (u) = u , p = 2, 3 and 4, this term is respectively positive, zero and negative, see [21]). Note that the shift on Q c1 depends on the sign of Q c2 . Similarly, we observe that δ2 (c1 ) depends only on c1 . Thus, if δ2 = 0, it follows that the main order of the shift on Q c2 is independent of c2 . In [21], we have computed δ2 for f (u) = u 4 and there are well-known formulas for the case p = 2, 3 (see e.g. Miura [23]). Theorem 1.3 (Stability of the 2-soliton structure). Let ϕ(t) = ϕc1 ,c2 (t) be the solution constructed in Theorem 1.2, under the same assumptions. There exists c0 = c0 (c1 ) ∈ (0, c1 ) and K = K (c1 ) > 0 such that if 0 < c2 < c0 then the following holds. Assume that 1
u 0 − ϕ(0) H 1 ≤ c2p−1
+ 21
,
(1.23)
and let u(t) be the H 1 solution of (1.1). Then, there exist ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t) ∈ R and c1± , c2± > 0 such that 1. Global in time stability: w(t, x) = u(t, x) − Q c1 (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2 (x − ρ2 (t)) satisfies 1
w(t) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1 , for all t ∈ R.
(1.24)
2. Asymptotic stability: lim u(t) − Q c− (. − ρ1 (t)) − Q c− (. − ρ2 (t)) H 1 (x< c2 t ) = 0,
t→−∞
1
2
10
lim u(t) − Q c1+ (. − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (. − ρ2 (t)) H 1 (x> c2 t ) = 0, t→+∞ 10 c± c± 1 1 1 + 1 − 1 ≤ K c2p−1 2 , 2 − 1 ≤ K c24 . c1 c2
46
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Theorem 1.3 is the analogue of Theorem 1.3 in [21]. Note that since Q c2 H 1 ∼ 1
−1
K c2p−1 4 , (1.24) means that the two solitons (even the smaller one) are preserved through the collision. The loss of a power 21 in c between (1.23) and (1.24) is due to the difference of sizes of Q c1 and Q c2 . Our approach is the same as in [21], the main tool being the construction of an approximate solution in the collision region. The large time behavior is controlled by asymptotic arguments, from [17,18,22] later refined in [16,19] and [20]. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, we construct an approximate solution of (1.1) in a large time region including the collision. This section contains the main new arguments. In Sect. 3, we recall preliminary results for the asymptotics of the 2-soliton structure in large time. In Sect. 4, we prove Theorems 1.1, 1.2 and 1.3. 2. Construction of an Approximate 2-Soliton Solution For the sake of simplicity, we can first assume by scaling that c∗ ( f ) > 1 and c1 = 1 and c2 = c < c0 , where c0 > 0 is to be chosen small enough. We denote Q 1 = Q > 0 and we suppose that (1.5) holds for Q. Moreover, in what follows, we assume Q c2 > 0, the case Q c2 < 0 (and thus p = 3) is treated similarly. We construct an approximate solution of Eq. (1.1) close to the sum of two soliton solutions related to Q and Q c on a large time interval containing the collision time. (The general case will follow by a scaling argument, see Corollary 2.1 in Sect. 2.5.) Let 1
1
Tc = c− 2 − 100 .
(2.1)
1 (The power 100 in the definition of Tc above can be replaced by any small number, giving a justification of Remark 2 following Theorem 1.2.)
Proposition 2.1 (Construction of an approximate solution of the gKdV Eq.). There exist c0 ( f ) > 0 and K 0 ( f ) > 0 such that for any 0 < c < c0 ( f ), there exists a function v = v1,c such that the following hold: 1. Approximate solution on [−Tc , Tc ]: for j = 0, 1, 2, S(t, x) = ∂t v + ∂x (∂x2 v − v + f (v)) satisfies ∀t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ],
j ∂x S(t) L 2 (R)
≤ K0c
2 3 p−1 + 4
(2.2) .
(2.3)
2. Closeness to the sum of two solitons for t = ±Tc : there exist , c such that 2
v(Tc ) − Q(. − 21 ) − Q c (. + (1 − c)Tc − 21 c ) H 1 ≤ K 0 c p−1 v(−Tc ) − Q(. + 21 ) − Q c (. − (1 − c)Tc + 21 c ) H 1 ≤ K 0 c where
1 2 1 −1 −1 − c p−1 2 δ ≤ K 0 c p−1 2 , |c − δc | ≤ K 0 c 12 , d Q d c | c=1 c Q δ = 2 d 2 . Qc |c=1 d c
+ 14
,
2 1 p−1 + 4
,
(2.4)
(2.5) (2.6)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
47
3. Closeness to the sum of two solitons: for all t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], there exists y(t) such that 1
v(t) − Q(. − y(t)) − Q c (. + (1 − c)t) H 1 ≤ K 0 c p−1 .
(2.7)
To prove Proposition 2.1, we follow the same strategy as in [21], Sects. 2 and 3. Here, we recall the main steps and only mention the parts which have to be adapted. We refer to [21] for more details. Remark. It follows from the proof of Proposition 2.1 that the constants c0 ( f ), K 0 ( f ) depend continuously on f ∈ C p+4 . Notation. For k, k , , ∈ N, we denote (k , ) ≺ (k, ) if k < k and ≤ or if k ≤ k and < . We denote by Y the set of functions g ∈ C ∞ (R) such that ∀ j ∈ N, ∃K j , r j > 0, ∀x ∈ R, |g ( j) (x)| ≤ K j (1 + |x|)r j e−|x| . Note that Y is stable by sum, multiplication and differentiation. 2.1. Choice of a decomposition for v. We look for v(t, x) with a specific structure as in [19]. Let k0 ≥ 1, 0 ≥ 0, and 0 = {(k, ), 1 ≤ k ≤ k0 , 0 ≤ ≤ 0 }. We set yc = x + (1 − c)t and Rc (t, x) = Q c (yc ), y = x − α(yc ) and R(t, x) = Q(y), where for (ak, )(k,)∈ 0 ,
s
α(s) =
β(s )ds , β(s) =
0
ak, c Q kc (s).
(2.8)
(k,)∈ 0
The form of v(t, x) is v(t, x) = Q(y) + Q c (yc ) + W (t, x),
W (t, x) = c Q kc (yc )Ak, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )Bk, (y) ,
(2.9) (2.10)
(k,)∈ 0
where ak, , Ak, , Bk, are to be determined. The motivation in [21] for choosing W of the form (2.10) is the stability of the family of functions
c Q kc , c (Q kc ) , k ≥ 1, ≥ 0 (2.11) by multiplication and differentiation due to the power nonlinearity in the equation (see Lemma 2.1 in [21]). In the case of Eq. (1.1), for a general nonlinearity this structure is preserved up to a lower order term (see Lemma 2.1). Let S(t, x) = ∂t v + ∂x (∂x2 v − v + v p ).
(2.12)
48
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Proposition 2.2 (Decomposition of S(t, x)). Assume that f is of class C k0 +3 . Let Lw = −∂x2 w + w − f (Q)w.
(2.13)
Then, S(t, x) =
c Q kc (yc ) ak, (−3Q + 2 f (Q)) (y) − (LAk, ) (y)
(k,)∈ 0
+
c (Q kc ) (yc ) ak, (−3Q )(y) + 3Ak, + f (Q)Ak, (y)
(k,)∈ 0
+
−(LBk, ) (y)
c Q kc (yc )Fk, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )G k, (y) + E(t, x),
(k,)∈ 0
where Fk, , G k, and E satisfy, for any (k, ) ∈ 0 , (i) Dependence property of Fk, and G k, : The expressions of Fk, and G k, depend only on (ak , ), (Ak , ), (Bk , ) for (k , ) ≺ (k, ). (ii) Parity property of Fk, and G k, : Assume that for any (k , ) such that (k , ) ≺ (k, ) Ak , is even and Bk , is odd, then Fk, is odd and G k, is even. Moreover, F1,0 = ( f (Q)) and G 1,0 = f (Q). (iii) Estimate on E: there exists κ(y) > 0 (depending on (ak, ) and (Ak, ), (Bk, )) such that ∀ j = 0, 1, 2, ∀(t, x) ∈ [−Tc , Tc ] × R, |∂x E(t, x)| ≤ κ(y)(Q kc0 (yc ) + c0 )Q c (yc ). j
(2.14)
Remark. Estimate (2.14) is only a first rough estimate on the rest term, which can not be used without further information on κ(y). In Proposition 2.5, for the functions (Ak, ), j (Bk, ) to be chosen in this paper, we estimate precisely the size of ∂x E in L 2 . Before proving the above proposition, we recall the following properties of Q c , proved in Appendix A. k ∈ {1, . . . , k0 }, Lemma 2.1 (Properties of Q c ). For 0 < c ≤ 1, ∀k, √ √ √ 1 1 1 1 p−1 +1 c e− c|x| ≤ Q c (x) ≤ K c p−1 e− c|x| , |Q c (x)| ≤ K c p−1 2 e− c|x| , K k k Q k+ k k σk1 Q ck+k+k1 −2 + O(Q kc0 +1 ), (Q kc ) (Q kc ) = ck c +
(2.15) (2.16)
p+1≤k1 ≤k0 −k− k+2
(Q kc ) = ck 2 Q kc +
k+ p−1≤k1 ≤k0
(Q kc )(3)
= ck
2
(Q kc )
σkk∗ Q kc1 + O(Q kc0 +1 ), 1
+
k+ p−1≤k1 ≤k0
(Q kc )(4) = c2 k 4 Q kc + c
k+ p−1≤k1 ≤k0
+O(Q kc0 +1 ),
(2.17)
σkk∗ (Q kc1 ) + O(Q kc0 +1 ), 1 σkk∗∗ Q kc1 + 1
k+2 p−2≤k1 ≤k0
(2.18) σkk∗∗∗ Q kc1 1 (2.19)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
49
where σk1 , σkk∗ , σkk∗∗ and σkk∗∗∗ are independent of c, and where O(Q kc ) is a function E 1 1 1 j
satisfying for j = 0, 1, 2, |∂x E(t, x)| ≤ K Q kc (yc ), where K is independent of c. Proof of Proposition 2.2. Inserting v = R + Rc +W in the expression of S(t, x) in (2.12), and using the equations of R and Rc , we obtain the following decomposition (see also [21], Proof of Prop. 2.2) S(t, x) = I + II + III + IV,
(2.20)
where I = ∂t R + ∂x (∂x2 R − R + f (R)), II = ∂x ( f (R + Rc ) − f (R) − f (Rc )), III = ∂t W − ∂x (LW ), where LW = −∂x2 w + w − f (R)w, IV = ∂x ( f (R + Rc + W ) − f (R + Rc ) − f (R)W ). Now, we follow exactly the same steps as in Sect. 2 of [21], replacing Lemma 2.1 in [21] by Lemma 2.1 and using Taylor expansions. For example, by (1.2) for k0 ≤ p, we have the following Taylor expansion of f and F:
f (s) = s p + f 1 (s) = s p +
p+1≤k1 ≤k0
F(s) =
1 p+1 s + p+1
p+2≤k1 ≤k0
1 k1 (k1 ) s f 1 (0) + s k0 +1 O(1), k1 !
1 k1 (k1 −1) s f1 (0) + s k0 +1 O(1). k1 !
(2.21)
Decomposition of I. As in the proof of Lemma A.1 in [21], we claim I = β(yc )(−3Q + 2 f (Q)) (y) + β (yc )(−3Q )(y) + cβ(yc )Q (y) + β (yc )(−Q )(y) + β 2 (yc )(3Q (3) )(y) + β (yc )β(yc )(3Q )(y) + β 3 (yc )(−Q (3) )(y) = I1 + I 2 + I 3 + I 4 + I 5 + I 6 + I 7 . Using Claim A.1 (Appendix), we deduce that I has the following decomposition:
c Q kc (yc )ak, (−3Q +2 f (Q)) (y)+(Q kc ) (yc )ak, (−3Q )(y) (2.22) I= (k,)∈ 0
+
I c Q kc (yc )Fk, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )G Ik, (y) + O(Q kc0 +1 ),
(2.23)
(k,)∈ 0 I , G I satisfy (i)-(ii) where the main terms, i.e. (2.22) are coming from I1 and I2 and Fk, k, of Proposition 2.1. Decomposition of II. For this term, we use the Taylor decomposition of f both at 0 and at R, i.e. 1 k1 f (R + Rc ) − f (R) − f (Rc ) = Q (yc ) f (k1 ) (Q(y)) k1 ! c 1≤k1 ≤ p−1
+
p≤k1 ≤k0
1 k1 Q (yc )( f (k1 ) (Q(y)) − f (k1 ) (0)) k1 ! c
+ O(Q kc0 +1 ).
50
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Then, by ∂x (g(y)) = (1 − β(yc ))g (y),
(2.24)
applied to g(y, yc ) = f (Q(y) + Q c (yc )) − f (Q(y)) − f (Q c (yc )), we obtain:
II k0 +1 II = c Q kc (yc )Fk, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )G II ), (2.25) k, (y) + O(Q c (k,)∈ 0 II , G II satisfy (i)-(ii). Note that F II = ( f (Q)) and G II = f (Q). where Fk, 1,0 1,0 k, Q k (y )A (y) + (Q k ) (y ) c Decomposition of III. Since W (t, x) = c k, c c c (k,)∈ 0 Bk, (y) , we are reduced to compute ∂t w − ∂x (Lw) for terms of the type w(t, x) = Q kc (yc )A(y) and w(t, x) = (Q kc ) (yc )B(y). We recall (see Claim A.3 in [21]), for A(x) ∈ C 3 ,
∂t (Q kc (yc )A(y)) − ∂x (L(Q kc (yc )A(y))) = Q kc (yc )(−LA) (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )(3A + f (Q)A − c A)(y) + Q kc (yc )β(yc )(−3A − f (Q c )A + c A) (y) + Q kc (yc )β (yc )(−3A )(y) + Q kc (yc )β (yc )(−A )(y) + Q kc (yc )β 2 (yc )(3A(3) )(y) + Q kc (yc )β (yc )β(yc )(3A )(y) + Q kc (yc )β 3 (yc )(−A(3) )(y) + (Q kc ) (yc )β(yc )(−6A )(y) + (Q kc ) (yc )β (yc )(−3A )(y) + (Q kc ) (yc )β 2 (yc )(3A )(y) + (Q kc ) (yc )(3A )(y) + (Q kc ) (yc )β(yc )(−3A )(y) + (Q kc )(3) (yc )A(y). Note that a similar formula holds for w(t, x) = (Q kc ) (yc )B(y) (see Claim A.4 in [21]). Then, from Lemma 2.1 and the decompositions of β(yc ), β (yc ), β 2 (yc ), β (yc )β(yc ) and β 3 (yc ) (see Claim A.1), we obtain the following decomposition for III:
c Q kc (yc )(−LAk, ) (y) + (Q kc ) (yc ) 3Ak, + f (Q)Ak, −(LBk, ) (y) III = (k,)∈ 0
+
c
III Q kc (yc )Fk, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )G III k, (y)
(2.26) + EIII (t, x),
(2.27)
(k,)∈ 0 III , G III satisfy (i)-(ii) and E (t, x) satisfies (iii). where Fk, III k, Decomposition of IV. Let N = f (R + Rc + W ) − f (R + Rc ) − f (R)W . Using Taylor formula and (2.24), we obtain k0 1 ((Rc + W )k − Rck ) f (k) (R) + EN (t, x), k! k=2
IV c Q kc (yc )Fk, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )G IV (y) + EIV (t, x), IV = k,
N=
2≤k≤k0 0≤≤0 IV and G IV satisfy (i)-(ii) and E (t, x) satisfies (iii). where Fk, IV k,
(2.28)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
51
2.2. Resolution of the systems (k, ). Proposition 2.2 leads to the following decomposition of S(t, x): S(t, x) = − c Q kc (yc ) (LAk, ) + ak, (3Q − 2 f (Q)) − Fk, (y) (k,)∈ 0
−
c (Q kc ) (yc ) (LBk, ) + ak, (3Q )
(k,)∈ 0
− 3Ak, + f (Q)Ak, − G k, (y) + E(t, x). Therefore, we want to solve by induction on (k, ) the following systems: (LAk, ) + ak, (3Q − 2 f (Q)) = Fk, (k, ) (LBk, ) + ak, (3Q ) − 3Ak, − f (Q)Ak, = G k, . The first step is to establish a general existence result for the model system: (LA) + a(3Q − 2 f (Q)) = F () (LB) + a(3Q ) − 3A − f (Q)A = G. We introduce some notation and we recall well-known results concerning the operator L.
(x) is odd and satisfies: Claim 2.1. The function ϕ(x) = − QQ(x)
(i) lim x→−∞ ϕ(x) = −1; lim x→+∞ ϕ(x) = 1; (ii) ∀x ∈ R, |ϕ (x)| + |ϕ (x)| + |ϕ (3) (x)| ≤ Ce−|x| ; (iii) ϕ ∈ Y, (1 − ϕ 2 ) ∈ Y. Proof of Claim 2.1. By (A.1), we have ϕ 2 = of (1.2). Next, ϕ = Q12 ((Q )2 − Q Q) = from (1.2) and the decay of Q.
Q 2 Q2
= 1 − 2F(Q) , thus (i) is a consequence Q2
1 (Q f (Q) − 2F(Q)), Q2
and (ii), (iii) follow
Lemma 2.2 (Properties of L). The operator L defined in L 2 (R) by (2.13) is self-adjoint and satisfies the following properties: (i) There exist a unique λ0 > 0, χ0 ∈ H 1 (R), χ0 > 0 such that Lχ0 = −λ0 χ0 . d (ii) The kernel of L is {λQ , λ ∈ R}. Let Q = dc Q c |c=1 , then L(Q) = −Q. 2 (iii) For all h ∈ L (R) such that h Q = 0, there exists a unique h ∈ H 2 (R) such that h Q = 0 and L h = h; moreover, if h is even (respectively, odd), then h is even (respectively, odd). (iv) For h ∈ H 2 (R), Lh ∈ Y implies h ∈ Y. d 2 (v) If d c | c Q c=c > 0 then there exists λc > 0 such that 2 2 2 (wx + cw − f (Q c )w ) ≥ λc w 2 . w Qc = w Qc = 0 ⇒ Proof of Lemma 2.2. See Weinstein [28] and proof of Lemma 2.2 in [21]. We claim the following general existence result for () (similar to Prop. 2.3 in [21]):
52
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Proposition 2.3 (Existence for the model problem ()). Let F, G : R → R such that + ϕ(x) F(x), F(x) = F(x) + F(x) G(x) = G(x) + G(x) + ϕ(x)G(x); • F, G ∈ Y; F is odd and G is even; and G are odd polynomial functions; F and G are even polynomial functions. • F Then, there exist a ∈ R and two functions A(x), B(x) satisfying () and such that + ϕ(x) A(x), A(x) = A(x) + A(x) B(x) = B(x) + B(x) + ϕ(x) B(x); • A, B ∈ Y; A is even and B is odd; and and • A B are even polynomial functions; A B are odd polynomial functions. Moreover, = 0 (respectively, F = 0) then A = 0 (respectively, A = 0); if F (2.29) if A = 0 and G = 0 then B = 0; if A = 0 and G = 0 then deg B = 0. (2.30) Remark. In Proposition 2.3, we find one solution of system (). This solution is not unique but this does not play a role in this paper. See Corollary 3.1 in [21] for the uniqueness question. = G = 0. Note that as a consequence of (2.30), it could be that B = b ∈ R while A This has the consequence to possibly develop polynomial growths in the functions Ak, , Bk, . In the rest of this paper, it will be sufficient to consider indices (k, ) for which Bk, A = 0, is a constant and the other polynomials A, B = 0 are zero, see Proposition 2.4. However, if one wants to solve the systems (k, ) for large k, , polynomial growths appear in general, see [21]. Sketch of the proof of Proposition 2.3. As in the proof of Proposition 2.3 in [21], we first reduce the proof to the case where the second members do not contain polynomials and thus are in Y. Step 1. Following Step 1 of the proof of Proposition 2.3 in [21], considering x x (x) + A(x) = = (x) + A(x) −A F(z)dz, −A F(z)dz, B(x) = − B (x) +
0 x
0
(z) dz, −( G(z)+3 A B ∗ ) (x)+ B ∗ (x) =
0
B∗
x
(z) dz, G(z)+3 A
0
where B= + b, and using the exponential decay of we reduce ourselves to solving the following system in (a, b, A, B): (LA) + a(3Q − 2 f (Q)) = F (LB) + a(3Q ) − 3A − f (Q)A = G + b(Lϕ) , f (Q),
where F ∈ Y is odd, G ∈ Y is even and F, G do not depend on the parameters a and b. See [21] for more details. x Step 2. Existence of a solution to the reduced system. Set H(x) = −∞ F(z)dz. Since F is odd, R F = 0 and so H ∈ Y is even. To find a solution (a, b, A, B) of (), it is sufficient to solve LA + a(3Q − 2 f (Q)) = H () (LB) + a(3Q ) − 3A − f (Q)A = G + b(Lϕ) .
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
53
Since HQ = 0 (by parity) and H ∈ Y, it follows from Lemma 2.2 (iii)-(iv) that there exists H ∈ Y, even, such that LH = H.
(2.31)
By Lemma 2.2, there also exists V0 ∈ Y, even, such that LV0 = 3Q − 2 f (Q).
(2.32)
It follows that, for all a, A = H − aV0
(2.33)
is solution of LA + a(3Q − 2 f (Q)) = H, moreover, A is even and A ∈ Y. Note that at this point (a, b) are still free; they will be used to solve the second equation. Indeed, replacing A by H − aV0 in this equation, solving () is equivalent to finding (a, b, B) such that (LB) = −a Z 0 + D + b(Lϕ) ,
(2.34)
where
D = 3H + f (Q)H + G,
Z 0 = 3Q + 3V0 + f (Q)V0 .
It follows from the properties of Q, V0 , G and H that D and Z 0 are even and satisfy Z 0 , D ∈ Y. To solve (2.34), it suffices to find B ∈ Y such that x LB = E where E = (D − a Z 0 )(z)dz + bLϕ. (2.35) 0
We now choose (a, b) such that the function E is orthogonal to Q and has decay at ∞. First, we claim a nondegeneracy condition on Z 0 , related to the strict stability of the soliton Q (i.e. assumption (1.5)). This is a nontrivial extension of Claim 2.3 in [21], which means that the solvability of () is related to the noncriticality of Q. Claim 2.2 (Nondegeneracy condition). 1 d Z0 Q = − Q 2c c=1 = − Q Q = 0. 2 dc Assuming Claim 2.2, we finish the proof of Proposition 2.3. Let +∞ DQ and b = − (D − a Z 0 )(z)dz. a= Z0 Q 0
(2.36)
(2.37)
Then, E defined by (2.35) satisfies E ∈ Y,
E is odd,
E Q = 0.
(2.38)
Indeed, by integration by parts, and decay properties of Q, we have E Q = − (D − a Z 0 )Q + b (Lϕ)Q = − D Q + a Z 0 Q + b ϕ(LQ ) = 0,
54
Y. Martel, F. Merle
by (2.37) and LQ = 0. By Claim 2.1 and (2.37), we have +∞ lim E = (D − a Z 0 ) dz + b lim(Lϕ) = 0 and so E ∈ Y. +∞
+∞
0
For (a, b) fixed as in (2.37), from (2.38) and Lemma 2.2, it follows that there exists B ∈ Y such that LB = E. Setting + A, A= A+ A
B=B+ B+ B,
we have constructed a solution of system ().
Proof of Claim 2.2. Let Q be defined in Lemma 2.2; recall that L(Q) = −Q. Note also that L(x Q ) = −2Q (since LQ = 0). Thus, V0 defined by (2.32) is V0 = −Q − x Q . Therefore, Z 0 Q = 3 Q Q + (3v0 + f (Q)V0 )Q = 3 Q Q + V0 (3Q + Q f (Q)) 2 = −3 (Q ) − (Q + x Q )(3Q + Q f (Q)). First, −
x Q (3Q + Q f (Q)) = − x Q (4Q − Q + f (Q) + Q f (Q)) 1 = 2 (Q )2 − Q 2 + Q f (Q). 2
Since LQ = −Q + Q − Q f (Q), we also have L(Q + Q + x Q ) = −3Q − Q f (Q) and thus − Q(3Q + Q f (Q)) = QL(Q + Q + x Q ) = − Q(Q + Q + x Q ) 1 2 =− Q − Q Q. 2 Thus, we obtain by (Q )2 + Q 2 = Q f (Q), Z 0 Q = − (Q )2 − Q 2 + Q f (Q) − Q Q = − Q Q. Proposition 2.3 allows us to solve the systems (k, ) for all (k, ) ∈ 0 , for any k0 ≥ 1, 0 ≥ 0 (as in [21]). In the present paper, for the sake of simplicity, we work for the minimal set of indices so that we are able to prove Theorems 1 and 2. Indeed, let us define p = {(k, ) | = 0, 1 ≤ k ≤ p, or = 1, k = 1}.
(2.39)
Using Propositions 2.2 and 2.3, we solve the systems (k, ) by induction on (k, ) ∈ p , following [21].
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
55
Proposition 2.4 (Resolution of (k, ) for (k, ) ∈ p ). For all (k, ) ∈ p , there exists (ak, , Ak, , Bk, ) of the form Ak, (x) = Ak, (x) ∈ Y, Bk, (x) = B k, (x) + ϕ(x)bk, (x), bk,0 ∈ R, B k, ∈ Y, Ak, is even and Bk, is odd, satisfying
(k, )
(2.40)
(LAk, ) + ak, (3Q − 2 f (Q)) = Fk, (LBk, ) + ak, (3Q ) − 3Ak, − f (Q)Ak, = G k, ,
where Fk, , G k, are defined in Proposition 2.2. As a consequence of Proposition 2.4, we see that by restricting the sum defining v(t, x) to the set of indices p , all the functions Ak, belong to Y and the functions Bk, are bounded with derivatives in Y. This will simplify the proof of the estimates in Proposition 2.5 with respect to the general estimates proved in [21]. Proof of Proposition 2.4. 1. Case k = 1, = 0. Recall that from Proposition 2.2, the functions F1,0 , G 1,0 ∈ Y are explicit. Thus, from Proposition 2.3 (2.29)-(2.30), the system (1,0 ) has a solution (a1,0 , A1,0 , B1,0 ) such that 1,0 = 1,0 = A B1,0 = 0 and B1,0 = b1,0 , b1,0 ∈ R. A 2. Case 2 ≤ k ≤ p, = 0. In this case, by induction on 1 ≤ k ≤ p, we solve (k,0 ), and we prove k,0 = A k,0 = A Bk,0 = 0 and Bk,0 = bk,0 , bk,0 ∈ R.
(2.41)
The argument consists in proving that if property (2.41) is satisfied for all 1 ≤ k < k, then Fk,0 , G k,0 ∈ Y, and thus by Proposition 2.3, (2.41) holds for k as well. This has been checked in detail in [21], see Claim 2.4 and Lemma B1 (except for the case k = p). I,II First, it is quite clear that I and II (see Proposition 2.2) contribute terms Fk,0 , G I,II k,0 ∈ Y, see also proof of Lemma B.1 in [21]. For the term III in the decomposition of S(t, x), which is linear in W , the proof is exactly the same as in Claim 2.4 of [21]. Now, we give some details concerning the term IV. Recall first that IV = ∂x N, where N = f (R + Rc + W ) − f (R + Rc ) − f (R)W . In the Taylor expansion (2.28), for 2 ≤ k1 ≤ p − 1, the term f (k−1) (R(x)) decays as e−|x| , by (1.2), thus the contribution of these terms to Fk , , G k , are in Y. For k = p, the term f (k−1) (R(x)) is bounded p and the term of lower order in ((Rc + W ) p − Rc ) which is not in Y comes from B1,0 = B 1,0 + b1,0 ϕ. Thus, the lowest order term not localized in the y variable is p−1
pb1,0 (Q c
Q c ϕ)x = pb1,0 (Q c
p−1
Q c + ( p − 1)Q c
p−2
(Q c )2 ) + pb1,0 Q c
p−1
Q c ϕ .
Using Lemma 2.1, this term does not give a contribution for = 0, k = p. It follows that Fk,0 , G k,0 ∈ Y, and thus by Proposition 2.3, we obtain a solution satisfying (2.41). 3. Case k = 1, = 1. This case is handled in the same way, we notice that F1,1 , G 1,1 ∈ Y, and conclude that 1,1 = 1,1 = A B1,1 = 0 and B1,1 = b1,1 , b1,1 ∈ R. A
(2.42)
56
Y. Martel, F. Merle
2.3. Definition of v(t) and estimates on S(t, x). We define the function v(t, x) as follows. For (k, ) ∈ p , we consider (ak, , Ak, , Bk, ) defined in Proposition 2.4, and v(t, x) defined by
v(t, x) = Q(y) + Q c (yc ) + c Q kc (yc )Ak, (y) + (Q kc ) (yc )Bk, (y) , (2.43) (k,)∈ p
where yc = x + (1 − c)t, y = x − α(yc ) and s β(s )ds , β(s) = α(s) = 0
ak, c Q kc (s).
(2.44)
(k,)∈ p
For this choice of function v(t, x) and for S(t, x) defined by (2.2), we claim the following estimates. Proposition 2.5 (Estimates on V and S). For any 0 < c < 1, for any t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], W (t), S(t) belong to H s (R) for all s ≥ 1 and satisfy 1
W (t) H 1 = v(t) − R(t) − Rc (t) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 ,
(2.45)
inf v(t) − Q(. − y1 ) − Q c (. + (1 − c)t) H 1 ≤ K c
1 p−1
y1 ∈R
( j)
2
j = 0, 1, 2, ∂x S(t) L 2 ≤ K j c p−1
+ 34
,
.
(2.46) (2.47)
Proof of Proposition 2.5. The proof of Proposition 2.5 is based on explicit estimates on |α | and on all terms of v(t, x) and S(t, x). Recall from Proposition 2.4 that since v(t, x) is defined only with (k, ) ∈ p , we have Ak, ∈ Y and Bk, ∈ L ∞ , with derivatives in Y. First, we claim 1
∀s ∈ R, |α(s)| ≤ K c p−1 Indeed, for c small, ak, c |α(s)| ≤ (k,)∈ p
s
0
− 21
1
, |β(s)| = |α (s)| ≤ K c p−1 .
Q kc (s )ds ≤ max |ak, | × (k,)∈ p
(2.48)
Q kc ≤ K
Qc.
(k,)∈ p
1 1 √ −1 Since Q c (s ) ≤ K c p−1 exp(− c|s |), α L ∞ ≤ K Q c ≤ K c p−1 2 . Similarly, 1
α L ∞ ≤ K c p−1 . Proof of (2.45). For all (k, ) ∈ p , since Ak, ∈ Y and Bk, ∈ L ∞ , we have 1
c Q kc (yc )Ak, (y) L 2 ≤ K c Q kc L ∞ ≤ K c p−1 , 1
c (Q kc ) (yc )Bk, (y) L 2 ≤ K c (Q kc ) L 2 ≤ K c p−1
+ 14
.
The same is true for ∂x W (t, x) using (2.48). Proof of (2.46). Since Rc (t) = Q c (x + (1 − c)t), we only have to prove that, for all t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], 1
inf R(t) − Q(. − y) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 .
y∈R
(2.49)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
57
By (2.48), taking c small enough so that |α (t)| < 21 , for all t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], there exists a unique y(t) such that y(t) − α(y(t) + (1 − c)t) = 0. Then, R(t) − Q(. − y(t)) H 1 = Q(. − (α(x + y(t) + (1 − c)t) − y(t))) − Q H 1 = Q(. − (α(x + y(t) + (1 − c)t) − α(y(t) + (1 − c)t))) − Q H 1 . 1
By (2.48), we have |α(x + y(t) + (1 − c)t) − α(y(t) + (1 − c)t)| ≤ K c p−1 |x|. Thus, we obtain (2.49). Proof of (2.47). By the decomposition of S(t, x) in the proof of Proposition 2.2, and the choice of Ak, , Bk, in Proposition 2.4, we obtain S(t, x) = E(t, x) as defined in Proposition 2.2. Thus, we only have to estimate E(t). Since for any (k, ) ∈ p , Ak, , Bk, ∈ L ∞ (with derivatives in Y), it follows from the decomposition of S(t, x) (see proof of Proposition 2.2) that all functions of the y variable in the expression of S(t, x) are bounded. Thus, we have p+1
|S(t, x)| ≤ K (|Q c
(yc )| + c|Q 2c (yc )|), p+1
where K > 0 is independent of y and c. Since Q c Kc
2 3 p−1 + 4
(yc ) L 2 + cQ 2c (yc ) L 2 ≤
, we obtain 2
E(t) L 2 ≤ K c p−1
+ 34
.
The estimates on the derivatives of S are obtained in the same way. 2.4. Proof of Proposition 2.1. In what follows, we will see that the first order of the shift on Q is a1,0 Q c . We first derive an explicit formula for a1,0 in order to prove Proposition 2.1. Lemma 2.3 (Computation of the first order of the shift on Q). d Qc |c=1 d c a1,0 = 2 d 2 . Qc |c=1 d c Proof of Lemma 2.3. From Proposition 2.2 and Proposition 2.4, the system (1,0 ) writes, for p = 2, 3 and 4: LA1,0 + a1,0 (3Q − 2 f (Q)) = f (Q) (1,0 ) (LB1,0 ) + a1,0 (3Q ) − 3A1,0 − f (Q)A1,0 = f (Q). Recall from Claim 2.2 that V0 = −Q − x Q solves LV0 = 3Q −2 f (Q). Let V1 be the even H 1 solution of LV1 = f (Q). Then, the function A1,0 = V1 − a1,0 V0 solves the first line of (1,0 ), independently of the value of a1,0 . By replacing A1,0 in the second line of the system (1,0 ), we obtain (LB1,0 ) + a1,0 Z 0 = Z 1 , where Z 0 = 3Q + 3V0 + f (Q)V0 ,
Z 1 = 3V1 + p Q p−1 V1 + f (Q).
(2.50)
58
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Since LQ = 0, we have (LB1,0 ) Q = 0 and so a1,0 Z 0 Q = Z 1 Q. In Claim 2.2, we have obtained 1 d Q2c |c=1 . Z 0 Q = − Q Q = − 2 d c Now, we compute Z 1 Q similarly as in Claim 2.2, Z1 Q = Q(3V1 + f (Q)V1 + f (Q)) = V1 (3Q + Q f (Q)) + Q f (Q) = − LV1 (Q + Q + x Q ) + Q f (Q) = − f (Q)Q + f (Q). Now, since L(Q) = −Q, we have Q = − Q + Q f (Q) and since −Q + d Q = f (Q), we have Q = f (Q). Thus, Z 1 Q = − Q = − dc Q c |c=1 , which completes the proof. Proof of Proposition 2.1. From what precedes (in particular Proposition 2.5), we only need to recompose the function v(t, x) at time ±Tc , combining the first terms of the decomposition of v(t, x). By symmetry, we consider only t = Tc . This proof follows closely the proof of Proposition 3.1 in [21]. 1. First, we claim 2
v(Tc ) − Q(y) − Q c (yc ) − b1,0 Q c (yc ) H 1 ≤ K c p−1
+ 14
.
(2.51)
Indeed, from the definition of v(t, x), and the fact for (k, ) ∈ p , Ak, ∈ Y, Bk, ∈ L ∞ , we have: |y| |v(Tc ) − Q(y) − Q c (yc ) − b1,0 Q c (yc )| ≤ K Q c (yc )e− 2 + |(Q 2c ) (yc )| + c|Q c (yc )|) . |y| √ By (2.15), for all t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], Q c (yc )e− 2 H 1 ≤ K exp(− 21 ct), and thus at t = Tc , for c small enough, |y|
1
Q c (yc )e− 2 H 1 ≤ K exp(− 21 c− 100 ) ≤ K c10 . 2
+1
By (2.15), (Q 2c ) (yc ) H 1 + cQ c (yc ) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 4 , and thus the estimate is proved for the L 2 norm. We proceed similarly for the estimate on ∂x (v(Tc ) − Q(y) − Q c (yc ) − b1,0 Q c (yc )). 2. Position of the soliton Q at t = Tc . Let = ak, c Q kc . (k,)∈ p
We claim 1 1 − 100
for x ≥ −Tc /2 and t = Tc , |α(yc ) − 21 | ≤ K e− 4 c for t = Tc , Q(y) − Q(. − 21 ) H 1 ≤ K e
1 − 21 c− 100
.
,
(2.52) (2.53)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
59
Proof of (2.52). For any k ≥ 1, for any yc > 0, we have, by (2.15), ∞ √ ∞ √ 1 1 −1 k p−1 Q c (s)ds ≤ K c e− c s ds = K c p−1 2 e− c yc , 0≤ yc
yc
we obtain √ 1 1 α(yc ) − 1 ≤ K c p−1 − 2 e− c yc . 2
For x ≥ −Tc /2 and t = Tc , we have yc = x + (1 − c)Tc ≥ ( 21 − c)Tc , thus 1 1 − 100 2c
√
c yc ≥
− 1, and so 1 1 − 100
|α(yc ) − 21 | ≤ K c−1/6 e− 2 c
1 1 − 100
≤ K e− 4 c
. 1
Proof of (2.53). For x ≥ −Tc /2, by (2.52), we have |α(yc )− 21 | ≤ K c p−1 and so 1 1 − 100
Q(y) − Q(. − 21 ) H 1 (x>−Tc /2) ≤ K ce− 4 c 1
For x < −Tc /2, since y = x − α(yc ), and |α(yc )| ≤ K c p−1 Thus,
− 21
1
− 12 − 1 c− 100 2
e
,
.
, we have y < −Tc /4.
Q(y) − Q(. − 21 ) H 1 (x<−Tc /2) 1 1 − 100
≤ Q(y) H 1 (x<−Tc /2) + Q(. − 21 ) H 1 (x<−Tc /2) ≤ K e− 2 c
.
3. Position of the soliton Q c at t = Tc . We claim 1
Q c (yc ) − b1,0 Q c (yc ) − Q c (. + (1 − c)Tc − b1,0 ) H 1 ≤ K c p−1
+ 34
.
(2.54)
Indeed, for the L 2 -norm, we have by a scaling argument √ √ Q − c b1,0 Q − Q(. − c b1,0 ) L 2 1 1 −1 √ +3 ≤ K c p−1 4 ( c b1,0 )2 = K c p−1 4 , 1
Q c − b1,0 Q c − Q c (. − b1,0 ) L 2 = c p−1
− 14
and similarly for the estimate on the x derivative. Thus Proposition 2.1 is proved. 2.5. Extension of Proposition 2.1 by scaling. Let −3
− 23
Tc1 ,c2 = c1 2 Tc = c1
c2 c1
− 1 − 2
1 100
.
By a scaling argument, we have from Proposition 2.1 the following Theorem 2.1. Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds. There exist c0 (c1 ) and K 0 (c1 ) > 0, continuous in c1 such that for any 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ), there exists a function v = vc1 ,c2 satisfying v(0, x) = v(0, −x) and such that the following hold:
60
Y. Martel, F. Merle
1. Approximate solution on [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ]: for j = 0, 1, 2, 2
j
∀t ∈ [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ], ∂x S(t) L 2 (R) ≤ K 0 c2p−1
+ 34
.
(2.55)
2. Closeness to the sum of two solitons for t = ±Tc1 ,c2 : there exist 1 , 2 such that 2
v(Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. − 21 1 ) − Q c2 (. + (c1 − c2 )Tc1 ,c2 − 21 2 ) H 1 ≤ K 0 c2p−1
+ 14
,
2 1 p−1 + 4
v(−Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. + 21 1 ) − Q c2 (. − (c1 − c2 )Tc1 ,c2 + 21 2 ) H 1 ≤ K 0 c2 where
1 − 1 d 2 1 Q c1 dc Q c |c=c1 c2 p−1 2 p−1 − 2 δ1 ≤ K c2 , δ1 = 2 d . 1 − c1 Q 2c |c=c dc
, (2.56)
(2.57)
1
3. Closeness to the sum of two solitons: for all t ∈ [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ], there exists y1 (t) such that 1
v(t, x) − Q c1 (. − y1 (t)) − Q c2 (. − (c2 − c1 )t) H 1 ≤ K 0 c p−1 .
(2.58)
Proof of Theorem 2.1. Fix a nonlinearity f satisfying (1.2). Fix 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) such that (1.5) holds. Let p − p−1
f ( u) = up + f 1 ( u ) where f 1 ( u ) = c1
1
f 1 (c1p−1 u ).
Then u(t) is a solution of (1.1) if and only if 1 − p−1
u (t, x) = c1
3
1
− − u(c1 2 t, c1 2 x) is solution of ∂t u + ∂x (∂x2 u+ f ( u )) = 0. (2.59)
First, we observe that f satisfies assumption (1.2). Second, for any 0 < c < c∗ ( f ), c = cc1 < c∗c(1f ) , let Q c be the positive even solution of (1.4). For 0 < 1 − p−1
c (x) = c Q 1
1
− c + c ) = c . Q c (c1 2 x) solves Q f (Q cQ
(2.60)
Thus, c∗ ( f ) ≥ c∗c(1f ) > 1 (in fact, c∗ ( f ) = c∗c(1f ) ). Moreover, for any 0 < c < c∗ ( f ), we have 2 1 −1 −1 2c , c , Q c = c1p−1 2 Q Q Q 2c = c1p−1 2 c1 c1 2 1 2 − −3 d d d 2c c2 = c1p−1 2 = c1p−1 2 , (2.61) Q 2c Q Q c1 dc dc d c |c=c1 | c=1 |c=c1 1 1 1 3 d p−1 − 2 d p−1 − 2 d c c = c1 = c1 . Qc Qc Q 1 dc dc d c |c=c1 | c=1 |c=c1 In particular,
d dc
Q 2c c=c > 0 is equivalent to 1
d d c
2 Q > 0. c c=1
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
61
Let c0 = 41 c0 ( f ), K 0 = K 0 ( f ), where c0 ( f ), K 0 ( f ) are defined in Proposition 2.1 (these constants thus depend continuously upon c1 , see the Remark after Proposition 2.1). Let 0 < c2 < c0 , and let c = cc21 . We consider v = v1,c as defined in Proposition 2.1 for v + ∂x (∂x2 v − v+ f ( v )). From Proposition 2.1, we have the nonlinearity f and S = ∂t 2
∀t ∈ [−Tc , Tc ], ∂x S(t) L 2 (R) ≤ K 0 c p−1 j
+ 34
,
(2.62)
1 − 1 v (Tc ) − Q(. 2 ) − Q c (. + (1 − c)Tc − 2 c ) H 1 ≤ K 0 c d Q c Q 1 2 | c=1 d c − 21 − 21 p−1 p−1 δ ≤ K c , δ = 2 d 2 . − c Qc |c=1 d c
2 1 p−1 + 4
,
(2.63) (2.64)
Then, we set 1
S(t, x) = ∂t v
(2.66)
Since ∂x S(t, x) = c1 2 2
1
(2.65)
3+ j
j
3
v(t, x) = vc1 ,c2 (t, x) = c1p−1 v (c12 t, c12 x), 1 + p−1
+3
+ ∂x (∂x2 v
− v + f (v)).
j j ∂x S, estimate (2.62) gives j = 0, 1, 2, ∂x S(t) L 2 (R) ≤
K c2p−1 4 . From (2.63) 1
2
1
− ) − Q c2 (. + (c1 − c2 )Tc1 ,c2 − 1 c− 2 c ) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 v(Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. − 21 c1 2 2 2 1 1
+ 14
.
1
− and 2 = c− 2 c , by (2.64) and (2.61), we have Setting 1 = c1 2 1 1 − 1 2 −1 c2 p−1 2 δ1 ≤ K c2p−1 2 , 1 − c1 d d c Q c1 dc Q Q c |c=c1 − 12 − 21 | c=1 d c Q δ1 = c1 δ = 2 c1 = 2 d . 2 d 2 Q Q c |c=c c | d c dc c=1 1
Estimate (2.58) follows from (2.7). 3. Preliminary Results for Stability of the 2-Soliton Structure This section is similar to Sect. 4 in [21]. 3.1. Dynamic stability in the interaction region. Proposition 3.1 (Exact solution close to the approximate solution v). Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds. There exist c0 (c1 ) and K 0 (c1 ) > 0, continuous in c1 such that for any 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ), the following holds. Let v = vc1 ,c2 be defined in 1 , for some T0 ∈ [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ], Theorem 2.1. Suppose that for some θ > p−1 u(T0 ) − v(T0 ) H 1 (R) ≤ c2θ ,
(3.1)
62
Y. Martel, F. Merle
where u(t) is an H 1 solution of (1.1). Then, u(t) is global and there exists ρ(t) such that, for all t ∈ [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ], 2 1 1 p−1 + 4 − 100 θ u(t) − v(t, . − ρ(t)) H 1 + |ρ (t) − c1 | ≤ K 0 c2 + c2 . (3.2) The fact that u(t) is global follows from the stability of Q c1 . Sketch of the proof of Proposition 3.1. The proof is similar to the one of Proposition 4.1 in [21]. For the sake of simplicity, we give a sketch of the proof in the special case c1 = 1 and c2 = c small, i.e. we work in the context of Proposition 2.1. The general case follows by the same scaling argument as in Sect. 2.5. In view of (3.2), we may assume that θ≤
2 1 1 + − . p − 1 4 100
(3.3)
We prove the result on [T0 , Tc ]. By using the transformation x → −x, t → −t, the proof is the same on [−Tc , T0 ]. Let K ∗ > 1 be a constant to be fixed later. Since u(T0 ) − v(T0 ) H 1 ≤ cθ , by continuity in time in H 1 (R), there exists T0 < T ∗ ≤ Tc such that T ∗ = sup T ∈ [T0 , Tc ] s.t. ∀t ∈ [T0 , T ], ∃r (t) ∈ R with u(t)−v(t, .−r (t)) H 1 ≤ K ∗ cθ . The objective is to prove that T ∗ = Tc for K ∗ large. For this, we argue by contradiction, assuming that T ∗ < Tc and reaching a contradiction with the definition of T ∗ by proving independent estimates on u(t) − v(t, . − r ) H 1 on [T0 , T ∗ ]. We claim (see Lemma 4.1 in [21]). Claim 3.1. Assume that 0 < c < c(K ∗ ) small enough. There exists a unique C 1 function ρ(t) such that, for all t ∈ [T0 , T ∗ ], (3.4) z(t, x) = u(t, x + ρ(t)) − v(t, x) satisfies z(t, x)Q (y)d x = 0. Moreover, we have, for all t ∈ [T0 , T ∗ ], |ρ(T0 )| + z(T0 ) H 1 ≤ K cθ , z(t) H 1 ≤ 2K ∗ cθ ,
(3.5)
∂t z − z + f (z + v) − f (v)) = −S(t) + (ρ (t) − c1 )∂x (v + z), |ρ (t) − 1| ≤ K z(t) H 1 + K S(t) H 1 . + ∂x (∂x2 z
(3.6) (3.7)
Recall that the existence, uniqueness and regularity of ρ(t) is obtained by a standard use of the Implicit Function Theorem applied to u(t) at each fixed time t. Estimate (3.7) is obtained by Eq. (3.6). Step 1. Energy estimates on z(t). We extend to the case of the general power nonlineartity the definition given in [21] of the energy functional for z(t):
1 F(t) = (∂x z)2 + (1 + α (yc ))z 2 − (F(v + z) − F(v) − f (v)z). 2 Lemma 3.1 (Properties of F). Assume that 0 < c < c(K ∗ ) small enough. There exists K > 0 (independent of K ∗ and c) such that
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
63
(i) Coercivity of F under orthogonality conditions: ∗
z(t)2H 1
∀t ∈ [T0 , T ],
2 ≤ K F(t) + K z(t)Q(y) .
(3.8)
(ii) Control of the direction Q: 1 −1 ∗ ∀t ∈ [T0 , T ], z(t)Q(y) ≤ K cθ + K c p−1 4 z(t) L 2 + K z(t)2L 2 . (iii) Control of the variation of the energy functional:
1 −1 F(T ∗ ) − F(T0 ) ≤ K c2θ (K ∗ )2 (1 + K ∗ )c 2( p−1) 8 + K ∗ .
(3.9)
(3.10)
Proof of Lemma 3.1. (i) For this property, see the proof of Claim 4.2 in Appendix D of [21]. Recall that the proof of such property is related to assumption (1.5) (nonlinear stability of Q) and to the choice of ρ(t) in Claim 3.1. (ii) This estimate follows from the conservation of u 2 (t) and a similar approximate 2 d conservation for v(t). Indeed, we have | 21 dt v | = | S(t, x)v(t, x)d x| ≤ K S(t) L 2 from the equation of v(t). Thus, ∗ 2 2 ∀t ∈ [T0 , T ], v (t) − v (T0 ) ≤ K Tc sup S(t) H 1 ≤ K cθ . (3.11) t∈[−Tc ,Tc ]
Since u(t) is a solution of the (gKdV) equation, we have 2 2 2 u (t) = (v(t) + z(t)) = u (T0 ) = (v(T0 ) + z(T0 ))2 .
(3.12)
By expanding (3.12) and using (3.11) and (3.5), we obtain: 2 v(t)z(t) ≤ K cθ + 2 v(T0 )z(T0 ) + z(T0 )2L 2 + z(t)2L 2 ≤ K cθ + z(t)2L 2 . 1
−1
Using this and v(t) − Q(y) L 2 ≤ K c p−1 4 , we obtain: 1 1 z(t)Q(y) ≤ z(t)v + z(t)(v − Q(y)) ≤ K cθ + K c p−1 − 4 z(t) L 2 + z(t)2L 2 . (iii) The computations of the proof of Lemma 4.3 in [21] are extended as follows: F (t) = F1 + F2 + F3 , where
∂t z α (yc )z, 1 F3 = (1 − c)α (yc )z 2 − ∂t v f (v + z) − f (v) − z f (v) . 2
2 1 Let m 0 = min p−1 , p−1 + 21 . We claim the following estimates. F1 =
∂t z(−∂x2 z
+ z − ( f (v + z) − f (v))), F2 =
64
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Claim 3.2. 1 1 F1 + (ρ (t)−1) α (yc )Q (y)z ≤ K c p−1 + 4 z(t)2 2 L + K z(t) L 2 (∂x2 S(t) L 2 +S(t) L 2 ),
(3.13)
F2 − (ρ (t) − 1) α (yc )Q (y)z + 1 α (yc )Q (y) f (Q(y))z 2 2 (3.14)
1 ≤ K z(t)2H 1 cm 0 + c p−1 z(t) H 1 + K z(t) H 1 (∂x2 S(t) L 2 + S(t) L 2 ), 1 F3 − 1 α (yc )Q (y) f (Q(y))z 2 ≤ K cm 0 z(t)2 1 + K c p−1 z(t)3 1 . H H 2
(3.15)
Estimates (3.13)–(3.15) are obtained exactly as in [21]. For the reader’s convenience, we reproduce the computations in Appendix B. Now, we conclude the proof of Lemma 3.1. From the cancellations of the main terms of F1 , F2 and F3 , and then from (3.5) and Theorem 2.1, (2.55), we get 1 1
1 + |F (t)| ≤ K z(t)2H 1 c p−1 4 + c p−1 z(t) H 1 +K z(t) H 1 ∂x2 S(t) L 2 +S(t) L 2 1 1 2 +1 +θ + 3 −θ . ≤ K c2θ (K ∗ )2 (c p−1 4 + K ∗ c p−1 ) + K ∗ c p−1 4 1
1
Integrating on the time interval [T0 , T ∗ ], since T ∗ − T0 ≤ 2Tc = 2c 2 + 100 , and 1 θ > p−1 > 41 , we obtain 1 2 −1− 1 + 1 − 1 −θ |F(T ∗ ) − F(T0 )| ≤ K c2θ (K ∗ )2 (1 + K ∗ )c p−1 4 100 + K ∗ c p−1 4 100 . Note that by (3.3), we have
2 1 1 p−1 + 4 − 100 −θ
≥ 0 and
1 1 1 p−1 − 4 − 100
≥
1 1 2( p−1) − 8
> 0,
≥ ≥ + Thus, Lemma 3.1 is proved. since Step 2. Conclusion of the proof. By (3.9), we have 1 1 z(T ∗ )Q(y) ≤ K cθ + K c p−1 − 4 z(T ∗ ) L 2 + z(T ∗ )2 2 , L 1 2( p−1)
1 6
1 8
1 100 .
and thus by (3.8), 1
z(T ∗ )2H 1 ≤ K F(T ∗ ) + K (cθ + c p−1 Since
1 p−1
−
1 4
− 14
z(T ∗ ) L 2 + z(T ∗ )2L 2 )2 .
> 0, it follows that for c small enough, z(T ∗ )2H 1 ≤ (K + 1)F(T ∗ ) + K c2θ .
Next, by (3.10) and |F(T0 )| ≤ K c2θ , we obtain
1 −1 z(T ∗ )2H 1 ≤ (K +1)(F(T ∗ )−F(T0 ))+ K c2θ ≤ K 1 c2θ (K ∗ )2 (1+ K ∗ )c 2( p−1) 8 + K ∗ +1 ,
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
65
where K 1 is independent of c and K ∗ . Choose c∗ = c∗ (K ∗ ) such that 1
(K ∗ )2 (1 + K ∗ )c∗2( p−1) Then, for 0 < c < c∗ ,
− 18
< 1.
z(T ∗ )2H 1 ≤ K 1 c2θ 2 + K ∗ .
Next, fix K ∗ such that K 1 (2 + K ∗ ) < 21 (K ∗ )2 . Then z(T ∗ )2H 1 ≤
1 ∗ 2 2θ (K ) c . 2
This contradicts the definition of T ∗ , thus proving that T ∗ = Tc . Thus estimate (3.2) is proved on [T0 , Tc ]. 3.2. Stability and asymptotic stability for large time. In this section, we consider the stability of the 2-soliton structure after the collision. This question has been considered in [19,20]. See also [16,17,22]. We recall the following. Proposition 3.2 (Stability and asymptotic stability [19,20]). Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds. There exist c0 (c1 ) and K 0 (c1 ) > 0, continuous in c1 such that for any 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ) and for any ω > 0, the following hold. Let u(t) be an H 1 solution of (1.1) such that for some t1 ∈ R and 21 Tc1 ,c2 ≤ X 0 ≤ 23 Tc1 ,c2 , 1 ω+ p−1 + 14
u(t1 ) − Q c1 − Q c2 (. + X 0 ) H 1 ≤ c2
.
(3.16)
Then, there exist C 1 functions ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t) defined on [t1 , +∞) such that 1. Stability. sup u(t) − Q c1 (. − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2 (. − ρ2 (t)) H 1 ≤ K c
1 ω+ p−1 − 14
t≥t1
∀t ≥ t1 ,
1 2 c1
,
≤ (ρ1 − ρ2 ) (t) ≤ 23 c1 , 1 ω+ p−1 + 14
|ρ1 (t1 )| ≤ K c2
(3.17)
(3.18)
, |ρ2 (t1 ) − X 0 | ≤ K c2ω .
2. Convergence of u(t). There exist c1+ , c2+ > 0 such that lim u(t) − Q c1+ (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (x − ρ2 (t)) H 1 (x> c2 t ) = 0. (3.19) 10 + 1 1 c ω+ p−1 + 4 , 2 − 1 ≤ K cω . (3.20) c − 1 ≤ K c c2 1
t→+∞ + c1
The proof of Proposition 3.2 is based on energy arguments, monotonicity results on local energy quantities, and a Virial argument on the linearized problem around solitons. The loss of 21 in the exponent between (3.16) and (3.17) is due to the fact that the 1
natural norm to study the stability of Q c2 is not . H 1 but ∂x (.) L 2 + c 2 . L 2 .
66
Y. Martel, F. Merle
3.3. Monotonicity results. Recall a more precise decomposition of u(t) used in the proof of Proposition 3.2 in [19,20]. Claim 3.3 (Decomposition of the solution). Under the assumptions of Proposition 3.2, there exist C 1 functions ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t), c1 (t), c2 (t), defined on [t1 , +∞), such that the function η(t) defined by η(t, x) = u(t, x) − R1 (t, x) − R2 (t, x), where for j = 1, 2, R j (t, x) = Q c j (t) (x − ρ j (t)), satisfies for all t ≥ t1 , R j (t)η(t) = (x − ρ j (t))R j (t)η(t) = 0, j = 1, 2, 1 1 c1 (t) ω+ 1 − 1 p−1 − 4 c2 (t) ≤ K c p−1 4 . η(t) H 1 + − 1 + c2 − 1 2 c c1 2
(3.21) (3.22)
Now, we recall some monotonicity results for two localized quantities defined in η(t). Define ψ(x) =
2
π
arctan(exp(− 41 x)),
g j (t) =
(η2x + c j η2 )(t, x)e
(3.23)
√ − 14 c j |x−ρ j (t)|
j = 1, 2.
d x,
(3.24)
For 0 ≤ t0 ≤ t, x0 ≥ 0, j = 1, 2, let M j (t) = η2 ψ j , 1 2 ηx − (F(R1 +R2 +η)−( f (R1 ) + f (R2 ))η−F(R1 +R2 )) ψ j , E j (t) = 2 √ where ψ1 (x) = ψ( c1 x1 ), x1 = x − ρ1 (t) + x0 + c21 (t − t0 ), √ ψ2 (x) = ψ( c2 x2 ), x2 = x − ρ2 (t) + x0 + c22 (t − t0 ). Claim 3.4 (Monotonicity results in η(t)). Let x0 > 0, t0 > 0. For all t ≥ t0 , √ √ c1 1 d 2 Q c1 (t) + M1 (t) ≤ K e− 16 (c1 (t−t0 )+x0 ) g1 (t) + K e− 32 c1 c2 (t+Tc1 ,c2 ) , dt d c1 2 2E(Q c1 (t) ) + 2E1 (t) + Q c1 (t) + M1 (t) dt 100 1
√
1
√
≤ K e− 16 c1 (c1 (t−t0 )+x0 ) g1 (t) + K e− 32 c1 c2 (t+Tc1 ,c2 ) . √ √ c2 c2 c2 √ d 2 2 Q c1 (t) + Q c2 (t) + M2 (t) ≤ K e− 16 (t−t0 ) e− 16 x0 c2 g2 (t) dt 1
√
+ K e− 32 c1 c2 (t+Tc1 ,c2 ) , d c2 2E(Q c1 (t) )+2E(Q c2 (t) ) + 2E2 (t) + Q 2c1 (t) + Q 2c2 (t) + M2 (t) dt 100 ≤ K e−
√ c2 c2 16 (t−t0 )
c2
3
1
e− 16 x0 c22 g2 (t) + K e− 32 c1
√
c2 (t+Tc1 ,c2 )
.
Claim 3.4 is proved in [20] for the power case. The proof is exactly the same for a nonlinearity f (u) satisfying (1.2).
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
67
4. Proof of the Main Theorems 4.1. Proof of Theorem 1.1. Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) such that (1.5) holds and c2 > 0 small enough. Let u(t) be the unique solution of (1.1) such that (see Theorem 1 and Remark 2 in [15]) lim u(t) − Q c1 (. − c1 t) − Q c2 (. − c2 t) H 1 = 0.
t→−∞
1. Behavior at −Tc1 ,c2 . We claim that ∀t < −
1√ 1 Tc1 ,c2 , u(t) − Q c1 (. − c1 t) − Q c2 (. − c2 t) H 1 ≤ K e 4 c2 (c1 −c2 )t . 32
(4.1)
This is a consequence of the proof of existence of u(t) in [15]. See Proposition 5.1 in [21] for a proof in the power case. Now, let 1 , 2 be defined in Theorem 2.1 and Tc−1 ,c2 = Tc1 ,c2 +
1 1 − 2 1 , a = 1 − Tc−1 ,c2 . 2 c1 − c2 2
1
1 Since |1 | ≤ K c− 6 and 2 is independent of c, we have −Tc−1 ,c2 ≤ − 32 Tc1 ,c2 , and thus, for c2 small enough:
u(−Tc−1 ,c2 , . + a) − Q c1 (. + ≤ Ke
√ − 14 c2 (c1 −c2 )Tc−,c
1 2
1 2 )−
Q c2 (. − (c1 − c2 )Tc1 ,c2 +
2 2 ) H 1
≤ K c210 .
u (t, x) is also solution of (1.1) and Let u (t, x) = u(t + Tc1 ,c2 − Tc−1 ,c2 , x − a). Then satisfies u (−Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. +
1 2 )−
Q c2 (. − (c1 − c2 )Tc1 ,c2 +
2 2 ) H 1
≤ K c210 .
(4.2)
In what follows, we work with u (t) satisfying (4.2) and we denote u by u. 2. Behavior at +Tc1 ,c2 . Now, consider v = vc1 ,c2 constructed in Theorem 2.1 (possibly taking a smaller c2 ). By (2.56) and (4.2), we have 2
u(−Tc1 ,c2 ) − v(−Tc1 ,c2 ) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
+ 14
.
Applying Proposition 3.1 with T0 = −Tc1 ,c2 , θ =
1 2 + , p−1 4
it follows that there exists a function ρ(t) such that 2
∀t ∈ [−Tc1 ,c2 , Tc1 ,c2 ], u(t) − v(t, . − ρ(t)) H 1 ≤ K c p−1
1 + 14 − 100
.
In particular, by (2.56), for some a− , b− such that 21 Tc1 ,c2 < a− − b− < 2Tc1 ,c2 , 2
u(Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. − a− ) − Q c2 (. − b− ) H 1 ≤ K c p−1
1 + 14 − 100
.
(4.3)
68
Y. Martel, F. Merle
3. Behavior as t → +∞. From (4.3), it follows that we can apply Proposition 3.2 to u(t) for t ≥ Tc1 ,c2 , with ω=
1 1 − . p − 1 100
It follows that there exist ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t), c1+ , c2+ so that w + (t, x) = u(t, x) − Q c1+ (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (x − ρ2 (t)) satisfies 2 1 1 p−1 − 4 − 100
sup w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c2
,
t≥Tc1 ,c2
2
|c1+ − c1 | ≤ K c2p−1
1 + 14 − 100
lim w + (t) H 1 (x> c2 t) = 0,
t→+∞
10
1 1 1+ p−1 − 100
, |c2+ − c2 | ≤ K c2
.
(4.4) (4.5) (4.6)
4. Estimates on c1+ − c1 and c2+ − c2 . By (4.1) and conservation of the L 2 norm, we have 2 2 Q c1 + Q 2c2 . M0 = u (t) = By the definition of w + (t), we have 2 2 + 2 + Q c+ + Q c+ + (w ) (t) + 2 w (t)(Q c1+ + Q c2+ ) + 2 Q c1+ Q c2+ . ∀t, M0 = 1
2
Thus, by (4.5), passing to the limit as t → +∞, we obtain M + = limt→+∞ (w + )2 (t) exists and + 2 2 2 M = Q c1 + Q c2 − Q c+ − Q 2c+ , Ê. (4.7) 1
2
Similarly, using the conservation of energy, E + = limt→+∞ E(w + (t)) exists and E + = E(Q c1 ) + E(Q c2 ) − E(Q c1+ ) − E(Q c2+ ). p−1
p−1
(4.8)
9
By (4.5), we have w+ (t) L ∞ ≤ K w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c28 , for t large enough. Thus, 1 1 p−1 E(w + (t)) = (wx+ )2 (t) − F(w + (t)) ≥ (wx+ )2 (t) − K w + (t) L ∞ (w + )2 (t) 2 2 1 1 p−1 + 2 + + 2 ≥ (w ) (t) ≥ (wx ) (t) − K w (t) L ∞ (wx+ )2 (t) 2 2 9 − K c28 (w + )2 (t). Passing to the limit t → +∞, we obtain (1.11). If lim supt→+∞ wx+ (t) L 2 + w + (t) L 2 = 0, then w + (t) → 0 in H 1 as t → +∞, and u(t) is a pure two soliton solution at +∞, c1+ = c1 and c2+ = c2 so that (1.12)–(1.13) hold. Assume now that lim supt→+∞ wx+ (t) L 2 +w + (t) L 2 > 0, so that E + + 21 c2 M + > 0. Recall that ([28]) by assumption (1.5), d 1 d E(Q c ) = − c (4.9) Q 2c < 0, for c = c1 and c = c2 . dc 2 dc
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
Let c¯2 be such that c¯2
Q 2c2 −
Q 2c+
69
= 2(E(Q c2 ) − E(Q c2 )). Then, by (4.6) and
2
(4.9) on c2 we have | cc¯22 − 1| ≤ 41 . Multiplying (4.7) by c¯2 and summing (4.8), we find: +
E +
c¯2 2
M = E(Q c1 ) − E(Q c1+ ) + +
c¯2 2
Q 2c1
−
.
Q 2c+ 1
Using (4.6) and (4.9) on c1 , we find c+ 1 (2E + + c2 M + ) ≤ 1 − 1 ≤ K (2E + + c2 M + ). K c1 Let c¯1 be such that c¯1
Q 2c1 −
Q 2c+ = 2(E(Q c1 ) − E(Q c1 )). Arguing similarly, we
have |c¯1 − c1 | ≤ 41 c1 and +
E +
c¯1 2
(4.10)
1
M = E(Q c2 ) − E(Q c2+ ) + +
By (1.2), since c2 is small, we have
d dc
c¯1 2
Q 2c2
−
Q 2c+ 2 2
2 Q 2c |c=c2 ∼ ( p−1 − 21 )c2p−1
− 23
. , and thus
2 2 − 21 −1 c+ 1 p−1 c2 (2E + + c1 M + ) ≤ 1 − 2 ≤ K c2p−1 2 (2E + + c1 M + ). K c2
(4.11)
This concludes the proof of Theorem 1.1. 4.2. Proof of existence. Theorem 1.2. For 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) such that (1.5) holds and c2 > 0 small enough, we denote by u c1 ,c2 (t) the global solution of ∂t u + ∂x (∂x2 u + f (u)) = 0, u(0, x) = vc1 ,c2 (0, x),
(4.12)
where vc1 ,c2 (t) is the approximate solution constructed in Theorem 2.1 (note that u c1 ,c2 (t) is global by stability of Q c1 ). By the parity property of x → vc1 ,c2 (0, x) and since Eq. (1.1) is invariant under the transformation x → −x, t → −t, the solution u c1 ,c2 (t) has the following symmetry: u c1 ,c2 (t, x) = u c1 ,c2 (−t, −x).
(4.13)
Thus, we shall only study u c1 ,c2 (t) for t ≥ 0. We claim the following concerning u c1 ,c2 (t). Proposition 4.1. Let 0 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) be such that (1.5) holds. There exist c0 (c1 ) > 0 and K 0 (c1 ) > 0, continuous in c1 such that for any 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ), there exist 0 < c2+ (c1 , c2 ) < c1+ (c1 , c2 ) < c∗ ( f ), and ρ1 (t; c1 , c2 ), ρ2+ (t; c1 , c2 ) ∈ R, such that the following hold for wc+1 ,c2 (t, x) = u c1 ,c2 (t, x) − Q c1+ (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (x − ρ2 (t)).
70
Y. Martel, F. Merle
1. Asymptotic behavior: lim wc+1 ,c2 (t) H 1 (x>c2 t/10) = 0,
(4.14)
t→+∞
2
+1−
1
for t large, wc+1 ,c2 (t) H 1 ≤ K 0 c2p−1 4 100 , + + 2 1 c1 +1− 1 − 1 − 1 ≤ K 0 c p−1 4 100 , c2 − 1 ≤ K 0 c p−1 100 , 2 2 c c 1
(4.15) (4.16)
2
2
|ρ1 (Tc1 ,c2 )−(c1 Tc1 ,c2 + 21 1 )| ≤ K c2p−1
− 21
1 1 p−1 − 100
|ρ2 (T )−(c2 Tc1 ,c2 + 21 2 )| ≤ K c2
, ,
(4.17)
where 1 and 2 are defined in Theorem 2.1. 2. The map (c1 , c2 ) → (c1+ (c1 , c2 ), c2+ (c1 , c2 )) is continuous. Proof of Theorem 1.2 assuming Proposition 4.1. Fix 0 < c¯1 < c∗ ( f ) and 0 < 0 < c∗ ( f ) c¯1 − 1 small enough so that Q c1 satisfies (1.5) for all c1 ∈ [c¯1 (1 − 0 ), c¯1 (1 + 0 )]. Let c¯0 =
min
c1 ∈[c¯1 (1− 0 ),c¯1 (1+ 0 ])
c0 (c1 ),
K¯ 0 = 2
max
c1 ∈[c¯1 (1− 0 ),c¯1 (1+ 0 )]
where c0 (c1 ) and K 0 (c1 ) are defined in Proposition 4.1.
K 0 (c1 ),
1
1
Fix an arbitrary 0 < c¯2 < min(c¯0 , 012 ). We define = [1 − c¯212 , 1 + c¯212 ]2 , and the continuous map + c1 (λ1 c¯1 , λ2 c¯2 ) c2+ (λ1 c¯1 , λ2 c¯2 ) . , : (λ1 , λ2 ) ∈ → c¯1 c¯2 By (4.16), we have + c (λ1 c¯1 , λ2 c¯2 ) 1 j for j = 1, 2, − λ j ≤ K¯ 0 c¯23 . c¯ j This means that 1
− Id ≤ K¯ 0 c¯23 .
(4.18)
Moreover, by possibly taking a smaller 0 , 1
1
dist((1, 1), (∂)) ≥ c¯212 − K¯ 0 c¯23 ≥
1 121 c¯ > − Id. 2 2
(4.19)
From (4.18) and (4.19), we have deg(, , (1, 1)) = deg(Id, , (1, 1)) = 1. Therefore, from degree theory there exist (λ¯ 1 , λ¯ 2 ) ∈ such that (λ¯ 1 , λ¯ 2 ) = (1, 1) (see for example Theorems 2.3 and 2.1, p30 of [7].) Now, for j = 1, 2, we set c j = λ¯ j c¯ j , and we check that the function u c1 ,c2 (t) has the property announced in Theorem 1.2. Indeed, since (λ¯ 1 , λ¯ 2 ) = (1, 1), we have c+j (c1 , c2 ) = c¯ j for j = 1, 2. Moreover, (4.14) and (4.15) imply (1.17) and (1.19). Finally, (1.21) and (1.22) follow from (4.17) and (2.57).
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
71
Proof of Proposition 4.1. Let c1 , c2 be as in the statement of Proposition 4.1 for 0 < c2 < c0 (c1 ) small enough. Let u(t, x) = u c1 ,c2 (t, x) be the solution of (4.12). Denote for simplicity T = Tc1 ,c2 (defined in (2.65)). Step 1. Control of the modulation parameters of u(t) for t ≥ T . From Proposition 3.1 2 applied with T0 = 0 and θ = p−1 + 41 , since u(0) − vc1 ,c2 (0) = 0, we obtain, for some ρ(t), 2
∀t ∈ [0, T ], u(t) − v(t, . − ρ(t)) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1 2
where |ρ (t) − c1 | ≤ K c2p−1
1 + 14 − 100
1 + 14 − 100
,
(4.20)
, ρ(0) = 0 and so 2
|ρ(T ) − c1 T | ≤ K c2p−1
1 − 14 − 50
.
(4.21)
By (2.56) and (4.20), we have 2
u(T ) − Q c1 (. − a) − Q c2 (. − b) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
1 + 14 − 100
,
(4.22)
for a = 21 1 + ρ(T ), b = (c1 − c2 )T + 21 2 + ρ(T ), so that 1 c1 T ≤ a − b ≤ 2c1 T. 2 1 1 − 100 . Then, by Therefore, we can apply Proposition 3.2 (1) to u(t) with ω = p−1 Claim 3.3 we have the decomposition of u(t) in terms of η(t), c j (t), ρ j (t) ( j = 1, 2) defined for all t ≥ T :
η(t, x) = u(t, x) − Q c1 (t) (x − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2 (t) (x − ρ2 (t)),
(4.23)
with for all t ≥ T , 2
∀t ≥ T, η(t) H 1 ≤ K c p−1
1 − 14 − 100
.
(4.24)
Now, we claim 2
|ρ1 (T ) − c1 T − 21 1 | ≤ K c2p−1
− 21
1
, |ρ2 (T ) − c2 T − 21 2 | ≤ K c2p−1
1 − 100
.
(4.25)
Proof of (4.25). From (4.20), (4.21) and v(T ) H 2 ≤ K , we have 2
u(T ) − v(T, . − c1 T ) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
1 − 14 − 50
.
(4.26)
Remark that for a small, 1 K |a|
≤ Q c1 − Q c1 (. − a) L 2 ≤ K |a|,
1 K |a|
1 − p−1 + 14
≤ c2
Q c2 − Q c2 (. − a) L 2 ≤ K |a|.
(4.27)
By (2.56) we have 2
v(T ) − Q c1 (. − 21 1 ) − Q c2 (. + (c1 − c2 )T − 21 2 )) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 Thus by (4.23), (4.26) and (4.27), we deduce (4.25).
+ 14
.
72
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Step 2. Asymptotic stability. From (4.24), we can apply Proposition 3.2 (2) to u(. + T ) 1 1 with ω = p−1 − 100 . We deduce that there exist c1+ , c2+ > 0, such that c j (t) → c+j , ρ j (t) → c+j , as t → +∞, j = 1, 2, lim w (t) H 1 (x>c2 t/10) = 0, +
t→+∞
(4.28) (4.29)
where w+ (t, x) = u(t, x) − Q c1+ (x + c1 2 1 1 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 + 4 − 100 , c 1
− ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (x − ρ2 (t)), + c2 1 1 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 − 100 . c
(4.30)
From (4.28), η(t) − w + (t) H 1 → 0 as t → +∞ and thus, from (4.24), we obtain 2
−1−
1
w + (t) H 1 ≤ K c p−1 4 100 for t large. This concludes the proof of the first part of Proposition 4.1. Step 3. Continuity of c1+ (c1 , c2 ) and c2+ (c1 , c2 ). The proof is the same as in [21]. Let us give a sketch. Let c¯1 < c∗ ( f ) such that (1.5) holds for c¯1 and 0 < c¯2 < c0 small enough. First, we prove that the map (c1 , c2 ) → c1+ (c1 , c2 ) defined in a neighboorhood of (c¯1 , c¯2 ) is continuous. Denote by ηc1 ,c2 (t), cc1 ,c2 , j (t), c+j (c1 , c2 ), the parameters in the decomposition of u c1 ,c2 (t). We claim an estimate on |c1+ (c1 , c2 ) − cc1 ,c2 ,1 (t)| which is related to the quantities M1 (t), E1 (t) defined in Sect. 3.3. Claim 4.1. For all t ≥ Tc , |c1+ (c1 , c2 )−cc1 ,c2 ,1 (t)|
≤ K0
((ηc1 ,c2 )2x +ηc21 ,c2 )(t, x)ψ(x−ρ1 (t)+c1 4t )d x 1
+ K 0 e− 64 c1
√
c2 t
.
(4.31)
Assuming this claim, let us complete the proof of continuity of c1+ (c1 , c2 ). Since ηc¯1 ,c¯2 (t) H 1 (x> c¯2 t ) → 0 as t → +∞, for ε > 0, there exists Tε > 0 such that 10 √ 1 K 0 ((ηc¯1 ,c¯2 )2x + ηc2¯1 ,c¯2 )(Tε , x)ψ(x − ρ1 (Tε ) + c1 T4ε )d x + K 0 e− 64 c1 c2 Tε ≤ ε. We fix Tε > 0 to such value. Then, by continuous dependence in H 1 of u c1 ,c2 (t) solution of (1.1) upon the initial data on [0, Tε ] (see [12]) and of its decomposition in Claim 3.3, and the fact that u c1 ,c2 (0) = vc1 ,c2 (0) is continuous upon the parameters (c1 , c2 ) (see proofs of Proposition 2.1 and Theorem 2.1), there exists δ(ε) > 0 such that if |(c1 , c2 ) − (c¯1 , c¯2 )| ≤ δ, then √ 1 K 0 ((ηc1 ,c2 )2x + ηc21 ,c2 )(Tε , x)ψ(x − ρ1 (Tε ) + c1 T4ε )d x + K 0 e− 64 c1 c2 Tε ≤ 2ε, |cc¯1 ,c¯2 ,1 (Tε ) − cc1 ,c2 ,1 (Tε )| ≤ ε. From Claim 4.1, applied to ηc1 ,c2 , ηc¯1 ,c¯2 , we have |c1+ (c1 , c2 ) − cc1 ,c2 ,1 (Tε )| ≤ 2ε and |c1+ (c¯1 , c¯2 ) − cc¯1 ,c¯2 ,1 (Tε )| ≤ ε. Therefore, |c1+ (c¯1 , c¯2 ) − c1+ (c1 , c2 )| ≤ 4ε. Thus, (c1 , c2 ) → c1+ (c1 , c2 ) is continuous. We argue similarly for (c1 , c2 ) → c2+ (c1 , c2 ). This concludes the proofs of Proposition 4.1 and of Theorem 1.2.
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
73
Proof of Claim 4.1. For T ≤ t0 ≤ t, let M1 (t) and E1 (t) be defined in Sect. 3.3, with x0 = c1 t40 . From Claim 3.4 integrated on [t0 , t], we obtain √ 1 Q 2c1 (t) − Q 2c1 (t0 ) ≤ (M1 (t0 ) − M1 (t)) + K e− 64 c1 c2 t0 , c1+ 2 2 −E(Q c1 (t) ) + E(Q c1 (t0 ) ) − Q c1 (t) − Q c1 (t0 ) 100 √ 1 1 (M1 (t) − M1 (t0 )) − K e− 64 c1 c2 t0 . ≥ 2E1 (t) − 2E1 (t0 ) + 100 3 t 1 √ 1 √ 1 2 Note in particular that t0 e− 16 c1 (c1 (t−t0 )+x0 ) g1 (t)dt ≤ K e− 16 c1 x0 ≤ K e− 64 c1 t0 . Letting t → +∞, by the asymptotic stability, this gives 1 √ 2 Q c+ − Q 2c1 (t0 ) ≤ M1 (t0 ) + K e− 64 c2 t0 , 1 √ c1+ c+ 1 2 2 + E(Q c1 )−E(Q c1 (t0 ) )+ Q c+ − Q c1 (t0 ) ≤ 2E1 (t0 )+ 1 M1 (t0 )+K e− 64 c1 c2 t0 . 1 100 100
By (4.9), we obtain: |c1+ − c1 (t0 )| ≤ K
(η2x + η2 )(t0 , x)ψ(x − ρ1 (t0 ) +
t0 4 )d x
1
+ K e− 64 c1
√
c 2 t0
,
which concludes the proof of Claim 4.1. 4.3. Proof of stability. Theorem 1.3. Theorem 1.3 follows directly from Proposition 3.1, Proposition 3.2 and the proof of Theorem 1.2. Let 0 < c¯1 < c∗ ( f ) such that (1.5) holds for c¯1 . Let 0 < c¯2 < c0 (c¯1 ) small enough. We assume 1
u(0) − ϕ(0) H 1 ≤ K c¯2p−1
+ 21
,
(4.32)
where ϕ = ϕc¯1 ,c¯2 is the solution constructed in Theorem 1.2. From the proof of Theorem 1.2, there exist (c1 , c2 ) close to (c¯1 , c¯2 ) in the following sense (see (4.16)): 2 1 c¯1 +1− 1 − 1 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 4 100 , c¯2 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 100 , (4.33) 2 2 c c 1 2 so that ϕ(0) = vc1 ,c2 . The assumption (4.32) on u(0) is thus equivalent to 1
u(0) − vc1 ,c2 (0) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
+ 21
.
(4.34)
By invariance of (1.1) by the transformation x → −x, t → −t, it is enough to prove the result for t ≥ 0. (i) Estimates on [0, Tc1 ,c2 ]. 1 + 21 ) we obtain, for By (4.34) and Proposition 3.1 (applied with T0 = 0 and θ = p−1 all t ∈ [0, Tc1 ,c2 ], for some ρ(t), 1
u(t) − v(t, x − ρ(t)) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
+ 21
2
+ K c p−1
1 + 14 − 100
for c2 small. From (2.58), we obtain (1.24) on [0, Tc1 ,c2 ].
1
≤ K c2p−1
+ 12
,
74
Y. Martel, F. Merle
From Theorem 2.1, we deduce, for some a, b, with a − b ≥ 21 Tc1 ,c2 , 1
u(Tc1 ,c2 ) − Q c1 (. − a) − Q c2 (. − b) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1
+ 21
.
(4.35)
(ii) Estimates on [Tc1 ,c2 , +∞). By (4.35) and Proposition 3.2 (applied with ω = 41 ) for all t ∈ [Tc1 ,c2 , +∞), there exist ρ1 (t), ρ2 (t) and c1+ , c2+ , such that 1
u(t) − Q c1+ (. − ρ1 (t)) − Q c2+ (. − ρ2 (t)) H 1 ≤ K c2p−1 , + + 1 c1 +1 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 2 , c2 − 1 ≤ K c 41 . 2 c c 1 2 (iii) Combining (4.33) and (4.36), we obtain + 1 c1 +1 − 1 ≤ K c p−1 2 , 2 c¯ 1
(4.36)
+ c2 − 1 ≤ K c 41 . c¯ 2
4.4. Open problem and monotonicity of speeds. The main question following Theorem 1 concerns the case where c2 is not small with respect to c1 . In this case, we expect the following: Open problem. Assume that f satisfies (1.2) with p = 4 and assume that for all c ∈ (0, c∗ ( f )) the positive solution Q c of (1.4) satisfies (1.5). Let 0 < c2 < c1 < c∗ ( f ) and let u(t) be the solution of (1.1) such that lim u(t) − [Q c1 (. − c1 t) + Q c2 (. − c2 t)] H 1 = 0.
(4.37)
t→−∞
There exist 0 < c2+ < c1+ < c∗ ( f ), v0 ∈ H 1 , such that lim u(t) − Q c1+ (. − c1+ t) + Q c2+ (. − c2+ t) + W (t)v0 t→+∞
H1
= 0,
(4.38)
where W (t)v0 is the solution of the linear Airy equation vt + vx x x = 0 with v(0) = v0 . Note that for p = 4, a scattering estimate such as (4.38) is suggested by results of Tao [27]. For p = 2 or 3, we cannot expect scattering to be true, and we can replace + + (4.38) by a weaker result on η(t) = u(t) − Q c1+ (. − c1 t) + Q c2+ (. − c2 t) : lim η(t) H 1 (x>0) = 0,
t→+∞
lim E(η(t)) = E + ≥ 0.
t→+∞
(4.39)
This means that the nonlinear term in E(η) is controlled by 21 η2x for large positive time. In the framework of this open problem, we claim the following monotonicity principle on the velocities c j , c+j : Claim 4.2 (Monotonicity principle). Let u(t) be a solution of (1.1) satisfying (4.37)– (4.38). Then c2+ ≤ c2 ≤ c1 ≤ c1+ .
(4.40)
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
75
2 Proof. We prove (4.40) by conservation a2convexity+argument. By L norm and energy it follows that limt→+∞ η (t) = M and limt→+∞ ÊE(η(t)) = E + ≥ 0 exist and satisfy Q 2c1 + Q 2c2 = Q 2c+ + Q 2c+ + M + ≥ Q 2c+ + Q 2c+ , (4.41) 1
2
1
2
E(Q c1 ) + E(Q c2 ) = E(Q c1+ ) + E(Q c2+ ) + E ≥ E(Q c1+ ) + E(Q c2+ ). +
Recall that we assume d 1 d E(Q c ) = c − dc 2 dc
(4.42)
Q 2c > 0 for c ∈ (0, c∗ ).
(4.43)
We consider the following two cases: • c1+ ≥ c1 . Then it follows from (4.41) and (4.43) that c2+ ≤ c2 , and the result holds in this case. • c1+ < c1 . Similarly, using (4.42) and (4.43), this implies c2+ > c2 and thus c2 < c2+ < c1+ < c1 . We claim that this implies a contradiction. Indeed, set E(Q c1 ) − E(Q c1+ ) E(Q c+ ) − E(Q c2 ) 2 , α2 = − 22 α1 = − 2 . Q c1 − Q c + Q c+ − Q 2c2 1
2
On the one hand, by (4.43), we have c1 1 c1 d 1 d − (E(Q c1 ) − E(Q c1+ )) = Q 2c )dc ≥ c1+ Q 2c )dc c( dc ( dc 2 c1+ 2 c1+ 1 ≥ c1+ ( Q 2c1 − Q 2c+ ), 1 2 which means that α1 ≥ 21 c1+ . Similarly, we have α2 ≤ 21 c2+ . On the other hand, by (4.41), (4.42), we have E(Q c1 ) − E(Q c1+ ) E(Q c+ ) − E(Q c2 ) 2 α1 = − 2 ≤ − 22 = α2 . Q c1 − Q c + Q c+ − Q 2c2 1
(4.44)
2
Thus, we obtain 21 c1+ ≤ α1 ≤ α2 ≤ 21 c2+ , which is a contradiction. A. Proof of Lemma 2.1. Proof of (2.15). It follows from the equation of Q c , (1.2) and standard arguments. Note that for any 0 < c < c∗ ; from (1.4) multiplying by Q c and integrating, we get (Q c )2 + 2F(Q c ) = c Q 2c . Using the Taylor decomposition of F(Q c ) (see (2.21)), we obtain (Q c )2 = cQ 2c + σk1 Q kc1 + O(Q kc0 +1 ), p+1≤k1 ≤k0
k−2 . and (2.16) follows from (Q kc ) (Q kc ) = k k(Q c )2 Q k+ c
(A.1)
76
Y. Martel, F. Merle
Proof of (2.17)–(2.19). We prove (2.17) and (2.19); (2.18) is obtained in a similar way. Note that from (1.4) and (2.21), we get (2.17) for k = 1. For k ≥ 1, we have from direct calculations: (Q kc ) = k(k − 1)(Q c )2 Q k−2 + k Q c Q k−1 c c = k(k − 1)cQ kc − 2k(k − 1)Q k−2 F(Q c ) + ck Q kc − k f (Q c )Q k−1 c c = k 2 cQ kc − 2k(k − 1)Q k−2 F(Q c ) − k f (Q c )Q k−1 c c ,
(A.2)
and we get (2.17) by using (2.21) for f and F. Now, we prove (2.19), from (A.2), F(Q c )) − k( f (Q c )Q k−1 (Q kc )(4) = ((Q kc ) ) = ck 2 (Q kc ) − 2k(k − 1)(Q k−2 c c ) . For the first term, we use (2.17). Now, we consider the term ( f (Q c )Q k−1 c ) , the term k−2 (Q c F(Q c )) is similar. We have k−1 2 k−2 ( f (Q c )Q k−1 c ) = (Q c ) f (Q c ) + (Q c ) Q c (2(k − 1) f (Q c ) + Q c f (Q c ))
f (Q c ) + Q c Q k−1 c = c (k − 1)2 Q k−1 f (Q c ) + Q kc (2(k − 1) f (Q c ) c + Q c f (Q c )) + Q kc f (Q c ) − 2F(Q c )Q k−2 c (2(k − 1) f (Q c ) + Q c f (Q c ))
f (Q c ). − f (Q c )Q k−1 c Now, using Taylor expansions for f (i.e. (2.21)) and for f and f , we get (2.19). Thus Lemma 2.1 is proved. Claim A.1.
(i) For any integer r > 0, Q rc (yc )β(yc ) =
c Q kc (yc )ak−r, .
1+r ≤k≤k0 +r 0≤≤0
(ii) Decomposition of β , β 2 , β β and β 3 : 1∗ β (yc ) = c Q kc (yc )ak, + O(Q kc0 +1 ), 1≤k≤k0 + p−1 0≤≤0 +1
β 2 (yc ) =
2∗ c Q kc (yc )ak, ,
2≤k≤2k0 0≤≤20
β (yc )β(yc ) =
2≤k≤2k0 0≤≤20
3∗ c (Q kc ) (yc )ak, , β 3 (yc ) =
4∗ c Q kc (yc )ak, ,
3≤k≤3k0 0≤≤30
1∗ , a 2∗ , a 3∗ and a 4∗ depend on where for any k ≥ 1, ≥ 0, the coefficients ak, k, k, k, some (ak , ) for (k , ) ≺ (k, ).
See proof of Claim A.1 in [21].
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
77
B. Proof of Claim 3.2 First, we claim the following estimates: Claim B.1. 1
∂t v(t) L ∞ + v p−2 − Q p−2 (y) L ∞ + ∂x v − Q (y) L 2 ≤ K c p−1 ,
(B.1)
1 1 p−1 + 4
∂t v(t)+α (yc )Q (y) L 2 ≤ K c , ∂t v(t)+α (yc )Q (y) L ∞ ≤ K cm 0 , 1 1 + 1 α (yc ) L ∞ + α (4) (yc ) L ∞ ≤ K c 2 p−1 , c
2 1 , p−1 + 21 . where m 0 = min p−1
(B.2) (B.3)
The proof of Claim B.1 is omitted, it is a direct consequence of the definition of v and the expression of Q c . See also proof of Claim 4.1 in [21]. Proof of (3.13). We replace ∂t z by its expression:
F1 = − S(t) −∂x2 z + z − ( f (v + z) − f (v))
+ (ρ (t) − 1) ∂x (v + z) −∂x2 z + z − ( f (v + z) − f (v)) = g1 + g2 . By integration by parts, the Cauchy-Schwarz’ inequality, we have
|g1 | ≤ K z(t) L 2 ∂x2 S(t) L 2 + S(t) L 2 . Since ∂x (v + z) f (v + z) = 0, and by the definition of S(t), g2 = (ρ (t) − 1) ∂x (v + z)(−∂x2 z + z + f (v)) = (ρ (t) − 1) (∂x v(−∂x2 z + z) + ∂x z f (v)) = (ρ (t) − 1) z∂x (−∂x2 v + v − f (v)) = (ρ (t) − 1) z(∂t v − S(t)). By (3.5), Claim B.1 and the definition of v, we obtain: g2 + (ρ (t) − 1) α (yc )Q (y)z ≤ K |ρ (t) − 1|z(t) L 2 (∂t v + α (yc )Q (y) L 2 + S(t) L 2
1
≤ K z(t) L 2 (z(t) H 1 + S(t) L 2 )(c p−1 + S(t) L 2 ).
+ 14
Proof of (3.14). The term F2 was introduced in the expression of F to cancel the main terms in F1 and F3 , F2 = α (yc )z∂x (−∂x2 z + z − ( f (z + v) − f (v))) − α (yc )zS(t) + (ρ (t) − 1) α (yc )∂x (v + z)z = g3 + g4 .
78
Y. Martel, F. Merle
First, g4 = −
α (yc )zS(t) + (ρ (t) − 1)
1 α (yc )∂x v z − (ρ (t) − 1) 2
z 2 α (yc ).
By (3.5) and the definition of v, we have g4 − (ρ (t) − 1) α (yc )Q (y)z ≤ K cm 0 z(t) H 1 (z(t) H 1 + S(t) H 1 ). Second, for the term g3 , we integrate by parts, to obtain: g3 = −
−
α (yc )( 23 (∂x z)2 + 21 z 2 ) +
α (4) ( 21 z 2 )
α (yc )z∂x ( f (z + v) − f (v)).
(B.4)
Estimating the terms α (yc ) and α (4) (yc ) from Claim B.1 we obtain 1 1 − α (yc )( 3 (∂x z)2 + 1 z 2 ) + α (4) ( 1 z 2 ) ≤ K c p−1 + 2 z(t)2 1 . 2 2 2 H 1
In the last term of (B.4), cubic and higher order terms are controlled by K c p−1 z(t)3H 1 . The quadratic term is
α (yc )z∂x (− f (v)z) = 1
As before, |g5 | ≤ K c 2
1 + p−1
1 2
α (yc )z 2 f (v) −
1 2
α (yc )z 2 ∂x ( f (v)) = g5 + g6 .
z(t)2H 1 . Finally, by Claim B.1,
2 g6 + 1 α (yc )z 2 Q (y) f (Q(y)) ≤ K c p−1 z(t)2 1 . H 2 1 + 1 Proof of (3.15). First note 21 (1 − c) α (yc )z 2 ≤ K c 2 p−1 z(t)2L 2 . We now estimate −
∂t v f (v + z) − f (v) − f (v)z − 1
1 2
1 f (v)z 2 − ∂t v f (v)z 2 = g7 + g8 . 2 1
We have |g7 | ≤ K c p−1 z(t)3H 1 and by |α (yc )| ≤ K c p−1 , g8 − 1 α (yc )Q (y) f (Q)z 2 ≤ K cm 0 z2 1 . H 2
Stability of Two Soliton Collision for Nonintegrable gKdV Equations
79
References 1. Berestycki, H., Lions, P.-L.: Nonlinear scalar field equations. I. Existence of a ground state. Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 82, 313–345 (1983) 2. Bona, J.L., Pritchard, W.G., Scott, L.R.: Solitary-wave interaction. Phys. Fluids 23, 438–441 (1980) 3. Cao, X.D., Malomed, B.A.: Soliton-defect collisions in the nonlinear Schrödinger equation. Phys. Lett. A 206, 177–182 (1995) 4. Cazenave, T., Lions, P.L.: Orbital stability of standing waves for some nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 85, 549–561 (1982) 5. Craig, W., Guyenne, P., Hammack, J., Henderson, D., Sulem, C.: Solitary water wave interactions. Phys. Fluids 18, 057106 (2006) 6. Fermi, E., Pasta, J., Ulam, S.: Studies of nonlinear problems I. Los Alamos Report LA1940 (1955); reproduced in Nonlinear Wave Motion, A.C. Newell, ed., Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 1974, pp. 143–156 7. Fonseca, I., Gangbo, W.: Degree theory in analysis and applications, Oxford Lectures Series in Mathematics and its Applications, 2, Oxford Univ. Press, 1995 8. Hirota, R.: Exact solution of the Korteweg-de Vries equation for multiple collisions of solitons. Phys. Rev. Lett. 27, 1192–1194 (1971) 9. Holmer, J., Zworski, M.: Slow soliton interaction with delta impurities. J. Mod. Dyn. 1, 689–718 (2007) 10. Holmer, J., Marzuola, J., Zworski, M.: Fast soliton scattering by delta impurities. Commun. Math. Phys. 274, 187–216 (2007) 11. Kalisch, H., Bona, J.L.: Models for internal waves in deep water. Disc. Cont. Dyn. Sys. 6, 1–20 (2000) 12. Kenig, C.E., Ponce, G., Vega, L.: Well-posedness and scattering results for the generalized Korteweg–de Vries equation via the contraction principle. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 46, 527–620 (1993) 13. Lax, P.D.: Integrals of nonlinear equations of evolution and solitary waves. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 21, 467–490 (1968) 14. Li, Y., Sattinger, D.H.: Soliton collisions in the ion acoustic plasma equations. J. Math. Fluid Mech. 1, 117–130 (1999) 15. Martel, Y.: Asymptotic N –soliton–like solutions of the subcritical and critical generalized Korteweg–de Vries equations. Amer. J. Math. 127, 1103–1140 (2005) 16. Martel, Y.: Linear problems related to asymptotic stability of solitons of the generalized KdV equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 38, 759–781 (2006) 17. Martel, Y., Merle, F.: Asymptotic stability of solitons for subcritical generalized KdV equations. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 157, 219–254 (2001) 18. Martel, Y., Merle, F.: Asymptotic stability of solitons of the subcritical gKdV equations revisited. Nonlinearity 18, 55–80 (2005) 19. Martel, Y., Merle, F.: Asymptotic stability of solitons of the gKdV equations with general nonlinearity. Math. Ann. 341(2), 391–427 (2008) 20. Martel, Y., Merle, F.: Refined asymptotics around solitons for gKdV equations. Disc. Cont. Dyn. Sys. 20(2), 177–218 (2008) 21. Martel, Y., Merle, F.: Description of two soliton collision for the quartic gKdV equations. http://arxiv. org/abs/0709.2672v1[math.AP], 2007 22. Martel, Y., Merle, F., Tsai, T.-P.: Stability and asymptotic stability in the energy space of the sum of N solitons for the subcritical gKdV equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 231, 347–373 (2002) 23. Miura, R.M.: The Korteweg–de Vries equation: a survey of results. SIAM Review 18, 412–459 (1976) 24. Perelman, G.S.: Asymptotic stability of multi-soliton solutions for nonlinear Schrödinger equations. Comm. Part. Diff. Eqs. 29, 1051–1095 (2004) 25. Rodnianski, I., Schlag, W., Soffer, A.D.: Asymptotic stability of N -soliton states of NLS. To appear in Comm. Pure. Appl. Math. 26. Shih, L.Y.: Soliton–like interaction governed by the generalized Korteweg-de Vries equation. Wave Motion 2, 197–206 (1980) 27. Tao, T.: Scattering for the quartic generalised Korteweg-de Vries equation. J. Diff. Eqs. 232, 623–651 (2007) 28. Weinstein, M.I.: Modulational stability of ground states of nonlinear Schrödinger equations. SIAM J. Math. Anal. 16, 472–491 (1985) 29. Weinstein, M.I.: Lyapunov stability of ground states of nonlinear dispersive evolution equations. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 39, 51–68 (1986) 30. Zabusky, N.J., Kruskal, M.D.: Interaction of “solitons” in a collisionless plasma and recurrence of initial states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 15, 240–243 (1965) Communicated by H.-T. Yau
Commun. Math. Phys. 286, 81–110 (2009) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0597-z
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
The Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness David Gérard-Varet DMA/CNRS, Ecole Normale Supérieure, 45 rue d’Ulm, 75005 Paris, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 22 November 2007 / Accepted: 2 March 2008 Published online: 9 September 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: We consider the Navier-Stokes equation in a domain with irregular boundaries. The irregularity is modeled by a spatially homogeneous random process, with typical size ε 1. In the parent paper [8], we derived a homogenized boundary condition of Navier type as ε → 0. We show here that for a large class of boundaries, this Navier condition provides a O(ε3/2 | ln ε|1/2 ) approximation in L 2 , instead of O(ε3/2 ) for periodic irregularities. Our result relies on the study of an auxiliary boundary layer system. Decay properties of this boundary layer are deduced from a central limit theorem for dependent variables.
1. Introduction The concern of this paper is the effect of a rough boundary on a viscous fluid. In most situations of physical relevance, such an effect can not be described in detail: either the precise shape of the roughness is unknown, or its spatial variations are too small for computational grids. Therefore, one may only hope to account for the averaged effect of the irregularities. This is the purpose of wall laws: the irregular boundary is replaced by an artificial smoothed one, and an artificial boundary condition (a wall law) is prescribed there that should reflect the mean impact of the roughness. This paper is a mathematical study of wall laws, in the following simple setting: we consider a two-dimensional rough channel ε = ∪ ∪ R ε , where = R × (0, 1) is the smooth part, R ε is the rough part, and = R × {0} their interface. We assume that the rough part has typical size ε, that is x 1 R ε = x, 0 > x2 > εω ε
82
D. Gérard-Varet
Ω
Σ R
ε
Fig. 1. The rough domain ε
for a K −Lipschitz function ω : R → (−1, 0), K > 0. More will be assumed on the boundary function ω hereafter (see the figure for an example of such a rough domain). We assume that in this channel domain, the viscous fluid obeys the stationary incompressible Navier-Stokes equations: ⎧ − u + u · ∇u + ∇ p = 0, x ∈ ε , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ u = 0, x ∈ ε , ⎨ div (1.1) ⎪ u 1 = φ, ⎪ ⎪ ε ⎪ σ ⎪ ⎩ u|∂ = 0, where σ ε denotes any vertical cross-section of ε and φ > 0. The third equation in (1.1) expresses that a flux φ is imposed across the channel. Note that this flux does not depend on the cross-section, due to the incompressibility and no-slip condition at the boundary. We also stress that, up to minor changes, we could apply our analysis to many variants of this problem, notably to elliptic type systems or to unstationary Navier-Stokes. In this simple setting, the search for wall laws returns to the following problem: to find a boundary operator B ε (x, Dx ), regular in ε, acting at the artificial boundary , such that the solution of ⎧ − u + u · ∇u + ∇ p = 0, x ∈ , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ u = 0, x ∈ , ⎨ div (1.2) ⎪ u 1 = φ, u|x2 =1 = 0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ σ ⎪ ⎩ ε B (x, Dx )u| = 0 approximates well the solution u ε of (1.1) in . This type of homogenization problems has been considered in many mathematical works. On wall laws for scalar elliptic equations, we refer to [2]. On wall laws for fluid flows, see [1,3,4,19,20,11]. See also [21] on porous boundaries. These works go along with more formal computations, grounded by empirical arguments (cf. for instance [9,23]). We finally mention [15,10] for the study of roughness-induced effects on geophysical systems. All these studies have been carried under two assumptions: • compact domains, for instance bounded channels or periodic in the variable x1 . • periodic irregularities, meaning that the boundary function ω is periodic.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
83
The first restriction is just a small mathematical convenience that gives direct compactness properties through Rellich type theorems. The second assumption is of course a big simplification, both from the point of view of mathematics and physics. These assumptions were considerably relaxed in the recent article [8] by A. Basson and the author. As the present note extends this article, we now describe briefly its main results and underlying difficulties. In all papers on wall laws, the starting point is a formal expansion of u ε : u ε (x) ∼ u 0 (x) + 6φεv(x/ε) + . . . . Formally, the leading term u 0 satisfies (1.2) with the simple no-slip condition B ε (x, Dx)u := u = 0 at .
(1.3)
The solution of this approximate system is the famous Poiseuille flow : u 0 (x) = (U (x2 ), 0) , U (x2 ) = 6φx2 (1 − x2 ). Note that u 0 is defined in all R2 . This zeroth order asymptotics can be mathematically justified, at least for small fluxes φ: we prove in article [8], Theorem 1. There exists φ0 , ε0 > 0, such that for all φ < φ0 , ε < ε0 , system (1.1) has 1 (ε ). Moreover, a unique solution u ε in Huloc √ u ε − u 0 H 1 (ε ) ≤ C ε, u ε − u 0 L 2 () ≤ C ε. uloc
uloc
We stress that these estimates hold without further assumption on the boundary: we only assume that ω has values in (−1, 0) and is K −Lip. A look at the proof shows that the constants C and C are only increasing functions of K . Theorem 1 expresses that the wall law (1.3) provides a O(ε) approximation of u ε in 2 L uloc (). See also [19] for a similar result in a bounded channel. However, this wall law does not account for the behaviour of u ε near the boundary, and can therefore be refined. Indeed, as the Poiseuille flow u 0 does not vanish at the lower part of ∂ε , a boundary layer corrector εφv(x/ε) must be added to the expansion. The (normalized) boundary layer v = v(y) is defined on the rescaled infinite domain bl = {y, y2 > ω(y1 )} and formally satisfies the following Stokes problem: ⎧ bl ⎪ ⎨ − v + ∇q = 0, x ∈ , div v = 0, x ∈ bl , ⎪ ⎩ v(y1 , ω(y1 )) = −(ω(y1 ), 0).
(1.4)
Note the inhomogeneous Dirichlet condition, that cancels the trace of u 0 . Although linear, the boundary layer system (1.4) is quite challenging. First, the wellposedness is not clear. As the boundary function ω is not decreasing at infinity, one can expect only local integrability of the solution v in variable y1 . The derivation of local bounds is not obvious: the Stokes operator being vectorial, one can not use scalar tools such as the maximum principle or Harnack inequality. Moreover, as bl is unbounded 1 in all directions, the Poincaré inequality (which allows to get Huloc estimates in the
84
D. Gérard-Varet
channel) is not available. Besides the well-posedness issue, the qualitative properties of v seem also out of reach without further hypothesis. Under an assumption of periodic irregularities, the analysis of (1.4) becomes straightforward. If ω is say L periodic in y1 , it is easy to show well-posedness in the space
L +∞ 1 v ∈ Hloc (bl ), v L − periodic in y1 , |∇v|2 dy2 dy1 < +∞ . 0
ω(y1 )
Moreover, a simple Fourier transform in y1 shows that v(y) − v ∞ ≤ C e−δy2 /L , v ∞ = (α, 0), α =
1 L
L
v1 (s)ds, δ > 0,
0
that is exponential convergence to a constant field v ∞ = (α, 0) at infinity. The constant α at infinity is then responsible for a O(ε) tangential slip. Namely, chosing as a wall law the Navier-slip condition B ε (x, Dx )v = (v1 − εα∂2 v1 , v2 ) = 0 at ,
(1.5)
it can be shown (in this periodic framework) that the solution of (1.2) provides a O(ε3/2 ) approximation of u ε in L 2 . We refer to [19] for all necessary details. The error estimate ε3/2 comes from the fact that the boundary layer term satisfies ε(v(x/ε)−(α, 0)) L 2 = O(ε3/2 ). The periodicity hypothesis is a stringent one, and one may wonder if the use of Navier slip condition can be justified in more general configurations. This issue has been addressed rigorously in the recent article [8]. Inspired by the probabilistic modeling of heterogeneous media (see for instance [22]), we considered irregularities that are not distributed periodically, but randomly, following a stationary stochastic process. Namely, the rough boundary is seen as a realization of a stationary spatial process. Following the well-known construction of Kolmogorov, this amounts to consider the space P = {ω : R → (−1, 0), ω K − Lip} of all possible rough boundaries, together with the cylindrical σ − field C (that is generated by the coordinates ω → ω(t)) and with a stationary measure π . Stationary means that π is invariant by the group of translation τh : P → P, ω → ω(· + h). As a consequence of this modeling, the domains ε , bl , as well as the velocity fields u ε or v depend on the parameter ω. As discussed earlier, the existence result and estimates of Theorem 1 are uniform on P. Moreover, it was shown in article [8] that the function ω → u ε (ω, ·) (extended by 0 outside ε (ω)) is measurable as a function from P to 1 (R2 ). Hloc Using this probabilistic structure, we have been able to extend partially the results of the periodic case. Key elements of our analysis are: • the well-posedness of the boundary layer system, obtained in functional spaces encoding the relation v(τh (ω), y1 , y2 ) = v(ω, y1 + h, y2 ),
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
85
• the convergence of v(ω, y) to (α(ω), 0) as y2 → +∞, both in L 2 (P) and almost surely, locally uniformly in y1 . Such convergence is deduced from the ergodic theorem. More on the boundary layer system will be provided in the next sections. As regards the Navier wall law (1.5), the main result of [8] is summarized: Theorem 2. There exists α = α(ω) ∈ L 2 (P) such that the solution u N of (1.2), (1.5) satisfies u ε − u N L 2
uloc (P×)
= o(ε).
1/2 We recall that w L 2 (P×) := supx P B(x,1)∩ |w|2 d xd P . uloc Theorem 2 shows that a slip condition of Navier type improves the approximation of u ε . As in the periodic case, the random variable α in (1.5) comes from the convergence of the boundary layer v. If the measure π is ergodic, α does not depend on ω, as pointed out in [8]. A natural concern about this result is the o(ε) bound, which is only a slight improvement of the O(ε) in Theorem 1. A look at article [8] shows that this poor bound is due to the lack of information on the way v converges at infinity. Contrary to the periodic case, where convergence at an exponential rate is established, the simple use of the ergodic theorem does not yield any speed rate. The present paper aims at clarifying this point. Loosely, we will show that for a large class of boundaries, the Navier wall law provides a O(ε3/2 | ln(ε)|1/2 ) approximation of the real solution. Namely, we will make the two following assumptions on our random roughness: (H1) The measure π is supported by
Pν = ω : R → (−1, 0), ωC 2,ν ≤ K ν for some ν > 0 and some K ν > 0. (H2) The random boundary has no correlation at large distances, that is the σ -fields σ (s → ω(s), s ≤ a) and σ (s → ω(s), s ≥ b) are independent for b − a ≥ κ, for some κ > 0. Under these assumptions, the main theorem of the paper reads: Theorem 3. For small enough φ and under (H1)-(H2), the following refined estimate holds: u ε − u N L 2
uloc (P×)
= O(ε3/2 | ln(ε)|1/2 ).
Before entering the proof of this theorem, let us give a few hints. Theorem 3 is deduced from a central limit theorem for the quantity v(ω, y) − (α, 0). Broadly, this theorem comes from good properties of the random variables n+1 X n (ω) = v(ω, y1 , 0) dy1 . n
Due to the elliptic nature of the Stokes operator, such random variables are not independent. However, under assumption (H2), we are able to prove that the correlations between
86
D. Gérard-Varet
X 0 and X n decay fast enough as n → ∞. As a result, one can prove a central limit theorem on X n , and then a similar one on v − (α, 0). We point out that such type of results for dependent variables with strong decay of correlations is quite classical and has been used in various fields. We refer to [7] for a review paper related to dynamical systems, and to recent articles [24,12] for applications in a PDE context. As a consequence of this central limit theorem, we show that the boundary layer −1/2 converges to a constant as |y2 |. Note that this is in sharp contrast with the periodic case, where exponential convergence holds (we stress that periodic boundaries are highly correlated, thus far from satisfying (H2)).This speed of convergence is responsible for the ε3/2 | ln(ε)|1/2 in the Navier wall law. The main difficulty is to obtain the decay of correlations of variables like X n . The proof relies on precise estimates of the Green function for the Stokes operator above a non-flat boundary. Such estimates follow from sharp elliptic regularity results, where one must pay attention to the oscillation of the boundary. This is achieved under the regularity assumption (H1), using ideas of Avellaneda and Lin for homogenization of elliptic systems [5,6]. 2. Boundary Layer Decay and Navier Approximation In this section, we explain how Theorem 2 follows from estimates on the solution v of (1.4). Such estimates will be established in the following sections. At first, we recall the main features of v, as stated in article [8]. 2.1. The boundary layer system. As emphasized in the introduction, to solve (1.4) in a deterministic way, that is for each possible boundary ω, is still unclear. Hence, one must take advantage of the probabilistic setting. First, notice that a reasonable solution v should satisfy: v(τh (ω), y1 , y2 ) = v(ω, y1 + h, y2 ).
(2.1)
Together with the stationarity assumption, this relation sort of substitutes to the identity v(y1 + L , y2 ) = v(y1 , y2 ) used in the treatment of L−periodic roughness. It allows to extend the well-posedness result, through an appropriate variational formulation. This formulation has been described in article [8]. First, one introduces the new unknown w(y) := v(y) + (y2 , 0) 1{y2 <0} (y), and replace system (1.4) by ⎧ − w + ∇q = 0, x ∈ bl \ {y2 = 0}, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ div w = 0, x ∈ bl , ⎪ w|∂bl = 0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ [w]| y2 =0 = 0, [∂2 w − (0, q)]| y2 =0 = (−1, 0),
(2.2)
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
87
where [·]| y2 =0 denotes the jump at y2 = 0. Then, one multiplies formally the Stokes equation by a test function w = w (ω, y) that satisfies div w = 0, w |∂bl = 0. Integrating by parts over bl ∩ {|y1 < 1} yields ∇w · ∇w = w1 + (∂n w − qn) w . bl ∩{|y1 <1}
{|y1 |<1, y2 =0}
bl ∩{|y1 |=1}
w
Finally, if w, satisfy relation (2.1), one can integrate with respect to ω, and thanks to the stationarity of π , get rid of the annoying boundary term at the r.h.s: ∇w · ∇w = E w1 . E bl ∩{|y1 <1}
{|y1 <1, y2 =0}
Afterwards, this formal variational formulation can be rigorously defined and solved: in short, one can apply the Riesz theorem in a functional space of Sobolev type, made of functions w such that E |∇w|2 < +∞, bl ∩{|y1 <1}
and satisfying almost surely (2.1), together with div w = 0, w|bl = 0. We refer to [8] for all details. Note that stationarity implies: 1 |∇w|2 = E |∇w|2 < +∞. supt,R E bl R bl ∩{|y1 −t|
0, v(ω, y) = G(t, y2 ) v(ω, y1 − t, 0) dt R 1 t = − t ∂t G(y2 ) v(ω, y1 − s, 0) ds dt, t 0 R where G is the Poisson type kernel for the Stokes operator over a half space. Then, the ergodic theorem and a few calculations yield: 1 t v(ω, y1 − s, 0) ds → v ∞ (ω) = (α(ω), 0), t → ±∞, t 0
88
D. Gérard-Varet
where the convergence holds almost surely (locally uniformly in y1 ), as well as in L 2 (P) (uniformly in y1 ). In the case where the stationary measure π is ergodic, the constant α does not depend on ω. Finally, back to the integral representation, and with similar treatment for derivatives of v: 2 2|β| ∀β ∈ N2 , |β| ≥ 1, E |v(·, 0, , y2 ) − α(·)|2 + y2 E ∂ yβ v(·, 0, y2 ) −−−−−→ 0. y2 →+∞
(2.3) We refer to [8, Proposition 13] for all details.
2.2. Refined estimate for Navier wall law. Most of the analysis of the present paper will be devoted to a refined asymptotic estimate of the boundary layer: Theorem 4. Under assumptions (H1), (H2), for all β ∈ N2 , 2|β|+1
y2
2 E ∂ β (v(·, 0, y2 ) − α(·)) −−−−−→ σβ ≥ 0. y2 →+∞
(2.4)
It is of course a much sharper convergence result than (2.3). Before tackling its proof, we explain how it implies Theorem 3. Arguments are a direct adaptation from Section 5 in [8]. On the basis of the boundary layer analysis, one can build an approximation of u ε of boundary layer type. Namely, we introduce x ε + 6 φ ε u 1 (ω, x) + 6 φ ε r ε (ω, x). u app (ω, x) = u 0 (x) + 6 φ ε v ω, ε In this approximation, u 0 is the Poiseuille flow and v(ω, ·) is the boundary layer solution of (1.4). As v does not converge to zero at infinity, we add a large scale corrector u 1 satisfying: ⎧ 0 u · ∇u 1 + u 1 · ∇u 0 − u 1 + ∇ p = 0, x ∈ , ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ div u = 0, x ∈ , 1 (2.5) ⎪ u 1 · e1 d x2 = −α, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 0 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 1 u | y2 =0 = 0, u 1 | y2 =1 = −(α, 0). It is just a combination of a Couette and a Poiseuille flow: u 1 = αx2 (3x2 − 4) e1 . Still, this approximation does not vanish at the boundary, which explains the addition of another term r ε (ω, x). It must satisfy ⎧ ε r (x1 , 0) = 0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ x1 1 ε − (α, 0), (2.6) r (x1 , 1) = v , ⎪ ε ε ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ div r ε = 0, x ∈ . This remainder can be taken small, thanks to
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
89
Proposition 5. This problem possesses a (non unique) solution r ε such that sup E r ε 2H 2 (B(x,1)∩) = O(ε| ln ε|). x
Note that this estimate is “optimal”, in the sense that · 1 2 sup Er ε 2H 2 (B(x,1)∩) ≥ C sup Ev H 3/2 (B(x,1)∩{x =1}) = O(ε| ln ε|) by (2.4). , 2 ε ε x x Proof. The proof of this result mimics the one of Proposition 14 in [8]. The corrector r ε can be chosen in the form r ε = ∇ ⊥ ψ, ψ = a(x1 )x23 + b(x1 )x22 + c(x1 )x2 + d(x1 ). The streamfunction ψ is determined up to a constant and polynomial in x2 . Its coefficients have explicit dependence on v − (α, 0). Hence, the H 2 estimate on r ε follows from the control of various terms involving v − (α, 0). For instance, one must bound the L 2 (P × (−1, 1)) norm of x1 /ε x1 t 1 1 dt = ε dy1 v2 ω, , v2 ω, y1 , ε ε ε 0 0 1/ε x 1 =ε (v1 − α) ω, , y2 dy2 ε ω(x1 /ε) 1/ε −ε (v1 − α)(ω, 0, y2 ) dy2 := I ε (ω, x1 ) − I ε (ω, 0), ω(0)
where the last equality comes from the Stokes formula. Using stationarity of π , we get 2 x1 t 1 E x1 → dt v2 ·, , ≤ 4E|I ε (·, 0)|2 . 2 ε ε 0 L (−1,1) Thanks to the refined estimate (2.4), we finally obtain 1 ε 2 2 2 |(v1 −α)(·, 0, y2 )| dy2 + ε E|I (·, 0)| ≤ C ε E ω(0)
≤ C ε2 + C ε
1
1/ε
E |(v1 −α)(·, 0, y2 )| dy2 2
1 1/ε
y2−1 dy2 = O(ε| ln ε|).
All other terms involve similar computations. These are straightforwardly adapted from the proof of proposition 14 in [8], using (2.4) instead of (2.3). ε Once the approximate solution u app is built, one can obtain by energy estimates the following bounds, for φ small enough: ε u ε − u app L 2 (P×) = O ε3/2 | ln(ε)|1/2 , uloc ε N u app − u L 2 (P×) = O ε3/2 | ln(ε)|1/2 , uloc
which of course imply Theorem 3. As the proof is very similar to what was done in paper [8], we do not expand more and refer to it for all details.
90
D. Gérard-Varet
3. A Central Limit Theorem Up to the end of the paper, we will assume (H1)-(H2), and focus on Theorem 4. It is classical that (H2) implies ergodicity of π , so that the constant α does not depend on ω. We start again from an integral representation β β ∂ y (v(ω, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0)) = ∂t 1 ∂ yβ22 G(t, y2 ) (v(ω, −t, 0) − (α, 0)) dt R (3.1) t β1 +1 β2 = − ∂t ∂ y2 G(t, y2 ) (v(ω, −s, 0) − (α, 0))) ds dt, R
0
where the matrix kernel G is given by G(y) = We introduce
2y2 2 π(y1 + y22 )2
V (ω, t) :=
t
y12 y1 y2 . y1 y2 y22
(v(ω, −s, 0) − (α, 0)) ds.
0
A simple change of variable leads to |β|+1/2 β ∂y y2
(v(ω, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0)) =
β +1
R
−1/2
∂t 1 ∂ yβ22 G(u, 1) y2
V (ω, y2 u) du.
(3.2)
Our first goal is to show that the l.h.s. converges in law to a gaussian distribution, for all β. We will focus on the case |β| = 0, the other cases being handled in the exact same way. We state Proposition 6. The function V satisfies the following properties: i) E |V (·, t)|2 ≤ C|t|. −1/2 ii) The random process y2 V (ω, y2 u) converges weakly to a gaussian process B(ω, u) as y2 goes to infinity. iii) The covariance matrices also converge, that is for all indices i, j and for all s, t, E y2−1 Vi (·, y2 s) V j (·, y2 t) −−−−−→ EBi (·, s)B j (·, t). y2 →+∞
We recall that the process X n (ω, t) with values in R2 converges weakly to X (ω, t) if, for all T > 0 and all continuous bounded function F : C [−T, T ], R2 → R, EF(X n ) −−−−→ EF(X ). n→+∞
Theorem 4 is then a direct consequence of 1/2
Corollary 1. The random process y2 gaussian vector with zero average. Moreover, for all i, j,
(v(ω, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0)) converges in law to a
y2 E (vi (·, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0)i ) v j (·, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0) j −−−−−→ σi j , y2 →+∞
where σ is the covariance matrix of this gaussian vector.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
91
Proof of the Corollary. To prove convergence in law to a gaussian vector Nσ of covariance matrix σ , we need to show that for any F ∈ Cc∞ (R), −1/2 ∂t G(t, 1) y2 V (·, y2 t) dt −−−−−→ E F (Nσ ) . EF y2 →+∞
R
Unsurprisingly, we take
Nσ :=
R
∂t G(t, 1)B(ω, t) dt.
We decompose, for any T > 0, −1/2 EF ∂t G(t, 1) y2 V (·, y2 t) dt − E F (Nσ ) R
=EF
T
−T
∂t G(t, 1)
+EF
R
−1/2 y2 −1/2
∂t G(t, 1) y2
V (·, y2 t) dt − E F V (·, y2 t) dt − E F
+EF
R
∂t G(t, 1) B(·, t) dt − E F
:= J1 + J2 + J3 .
−T T
−T
T −T
T
∂t G(t, 1) B(·, t) dt −1/2
∂t G(t, 1) y2
V (·, y2 t) dt
∂t G(t, 1) B(·, t) dt
We now show that expressions J1 , J2 , converge to zero (J3 is similar to J2 and simpler). Let δ > 0. We have −1/2 |∂t G(t, 1)| y2 |J2 | ≤ max |F | E V (ω, y2 t) dt |t|>T
≤ max |F | ×
|t|>T
|t|>T
1/2 |∂t G(t, 1)| dt
1/2 |∂t G(t, 1)| E y2−1 |V (ω, y2 t)|2 dt 1/2
≤ C
|t|>T
|∂t G(t, 1)| dt
1/2 |t|>T
|∂t G(t, 1)| t dt
,
where the last line comes from point i) of Proposition 6. Thus, for T large enough, independently of y2 , |J2 | ≤ δ/2. Such T being fixed, for y2 large enough, we get |J1 | ≤ δ/2 by point ii) of Proposition 6. This yields convergence in law. The convergence of the covariance matrix y2 E (vi (·, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0)i ) v j (·, 0, y2 ) − (α, 0) j −1/2 −1/2 ∂t G(t, 1)y2 V (·, y2 t) ds dt E ∂t G(s, 1)y2 V (·, y2 s) = R R
i
j
follows from the dominated convergence theorem, using i) and iii) of Proposition 6. We get σi j = E (∂t G(s, 1)B(·, s))i (∂t G(t, 1)B(·, t)) j ds dt. R R
This concludes the proof of the corollary.
92
D. Gérard-Varet
It remains to prove Theorem 6. Note that point ii) is essentially a central limit theorem for the sequence of random variables 1 X n (ω) = F ◦ τn (ω), F(ω) = (v(ω, t, 0) − (α(ω), 0)) dt. 0
The problem is that these random variables are not independent, due to “propagation of information at infinite speed” in the Stokes system. To establish a central limit theorem for such type of sequences is a classical question. The basic idea is that one can extend the central limit theorem to non-independent sequences that feature a good decay of correlations as n goes to infinity. We now illustrate this general principle on our problem, using assumption (H2). We follow the presentation of article [24], in which a similar question arises for a semilinear heat equation with random source. Let C n the σ -algebra generated by the applications y1 → ω(y1 ), |y1 | < n.We state the following lemma: Lemma 7. Suppose that v n := E (v(·, 0, 0) | C n ) satisfies 2 E v n − v(·, 0, 0) ≤ C n −β for some β > 1. Then, Proposition 6 holds. Proof of the Lemma. We write the decomposition v(·, 0, 0) − (α, 0) = v 1 − (α, 0) +
+∞ j j−1 v2 − v2 j=1
with the sum converging in V =
+∞
L 2 (P).
The corresponding sum for V is t j j−1 v2 − v2 ◦ τs (ω) ds, V j , V j (ω, t) = 0
j=0
where v 1/2 := (α, 0). Then, we have: V (·, t) L 2 (P) ≤
+∞
j=0 V
j (·, t)
. By the 2 j L (P) j 2 assumption of independence at large distances, the correlations E v ◦ τt (ω) v 2 ◦ j j−1 τt+s (ω) and E v 2 ◦ τt (ω) v 2 ◦ τt+s (ω) vanish for |s| ≥ κ + 2 j+1 . We introduce n := |t|/(κ + 2 j+1 ) . If n = 0, we just write
2 j j−1 2 E V j (·, t) ≤ |t|2 E v 2 − v 2 .
If n ≥ 1, we decompose
n−1 2 (k+1)t/n j 2 j 2 2 j−1 v ◦ τs − v ◦ τs ds E V (·, t) = E k=0 kt/n n−1 t/n 2 2j 2 j−1 v ◦ τs+kt/n − v ≤ E ◦ τs+kt/n ds 0 k=0
≤ 2 κ + 2 j+1
n−1 |t|/n 0
k=0
j j−1 2 E v 2 − v 2 .
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
93
Using the bound on the conditional expectations, we end up with V j (·, t)2L 2 (P) ≤ C |t| min(|t|, 2 j ) 2− jβ
(3.3)
for some constant C = C(κ). We thus get i). To prove ii), we just write the decomposition v(·, 0, 0) − (α, 0) =
+∞ j j−1 v2 − v2 ,
−1/2
y2
−1/2
V (ω, t y2 ) = y2
j=0
+∞
V j (ω, t y2 ).
j=0
It is well-known that each finite sum satisfies a central limit theorem, that is ∀k,
−1/2
y2
k
V j (ω, t y2 ) −−−−−→ B k (ω, t) y2 →+∞
j=0
in the sense of weak convergence, to some gaussian process B k (ω, t). Moreover, the covariance matrix also converges, that is y2−1 E
k
j
Vl (·, sy2 )
j=0
k
j
Vm (·, t y2 ) −−−−−→ EBlk (ω, s) Bmk (ω, t). y2 →+∞
j=0
In short, it is due to the fact that the random variables 1 j j−1 v2 − v2 ◦ τt (ω) dt, n ∈ Z, X n, j (ω) = F j ◦ τn (ω), F j (ω) = 0
have zero correlations at large distances: see [13, Theorem (7.11) p. 424] for a similar result and detailed proof. Moreover, thanks to estimate (3.3), the remainder R (ω, t, y2 ) = k
+∞
−1/2
y2
V j (ω, t y2 )
j=k
converges to zero as k → +∞, locally uniformly in t, uniformly in y2 . Hence, points (ii) and (iii) of Proposition 6 hold, which ends the proof of the lemma. We still have to estimate the variance of v n − v(·, 0, 0). Following [24], we can turn this question into a question of domain of dependence for solutions of (1.4). Precisely, starting from the measure π on P, we define a new measure π n on the product space P n = {(ω1 , ω2 ) ∈ P × P, ω1 (t) = ω2 (t), |t| ≤ n} , endowed with its cylindrical σ −field. Namely, π n is defined in the following way: 1. π n (A × A) := π(A), ∀A ∈ C n , which determines π n over the sub σ −field Dn generated by the applications t → (ω1 (t), ω2 (t)), |t| ≤ n. 2. For all k ≥ 1, for all t 1 , . . . , t k with |t j | > n, for all borelian subsets B11 , . . . , B1k , B21 , . . . , B2k of R, and j
A1 := ∩kj=1 {ω1 , ω1 (t j ) ∈ B1 },
j
A2 := ∩kj=1 {ω2 , ω2 (t j ) ∈ B2 },
π n (A1 × A2 | Dn )(ω1 , ω2 ) := π(A1 | C n )(ω1 ) π(A2 | C n )(ω2 ), which determines π n conditionally to Dn .
94
D. Gérard-Varet
It is then easy to derive the following identity, see [24]: 2 1 |v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0)|2 dπn . E v n − v(·, 0, 0) = 2 Pn Thus, if bl (ω1 ) and bl (ω2 ) are two boundary layer domains with boundaries that coincide over [−n, n], we need to estimate the difference of the corresponding boundary layer solutions v(ω1 , 0, 0) and v(ω2 , 0, 0). This is the purpose of the next section. 4. Decay of Correlations Throughout the rest of the paper, we will assume (H1). The main difficuly is to prove the following Proposition 8. Under assumption (H1), for all 0 < τ < 1, for almost every ω1 , ω2 ∈ P, |v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0)| ≤
C n 2τ −1
,
(4.1)
where C does not depend on ω1 , ω2 . Together with the results of the preceding section, this proposition concludes the proof of Theorem 4 (take τ > 3/4), and therefore the proof of the main Theorem 2. In fact, the sharper bound |v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0)| ≤
C , n
that is with τ = 1, would still be true. We will discuss this briefly in the last section of the paper. For the sake of brevity, we only prove here the weaker form (4.1). The main difficulty is that the boundary layer solutions v(ω1 , y) and v(ω2 , y) of (1.4) are not defined on the same domain, so that estimates on the difference are not directly available. If the Poisson equation rather than the Stokes system was considered, representation of the solution in terms of Brownian motion would allow to conclude quite easily. Again, this will be explained in the last section of the paper. In the case of system (1.4), we are not aware of such a representation, and the bound (4.1) will come from an accurate description of the (matrix) Green function of the Stokes operator above a humped boundary. We consider for all ω ∈ C 2,ν , and for all z ∈ bl (ω) = {y2 > ω(y1 )}, the system: ⎧ bl ⎪ ⎨ −G ω (z, ·) + ∇ Pω (z, ·) = δz I2 in (ω), (4.2) div G ω (z, ·) = 0 in bl (ω), ⎪ ⎩ bl G ω (z, ·) = 0 on ∂ (ω). where δz is the Dirac mass at z, and I2 is the 2 × 2 identity matrix. Let us recall how to build the matrix Green function (G ω , Pω ). Up to a vertical translation of the domain, we can first assume that z 2 > 0. We then introduce the Green function (G 0 , P0 ) for the Stokes operator in the upper-half plane, see [14]. Extending G 0 (z, ·), P0 (z, ·) by 0 for y2 < 0, the functions H (z, ·) := G ω (z, ·) − G 0 (z, ·),
Q(z, ·) := Pω (z, ·) − P0 (z, ·)
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
95
satisfy formally ⎧ −H (z, ·) + ∇ Q(z, ·) = 0 in bl (ω), ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ div H (z, ·) = 0 in bl (ω), ⎪ ⎪ Hω (z, ·) = 0 on ∂bl (ω), ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ [H (z, ·)] = 0, ∂2 H (z, ·) − Q(z, ·) ⊗ e2 = − [∂2 G 0 (z, ·) − P0 (z, ·) ⊗ e2 ] ,
where [ · ] is the jump along {y2 = 0} ∩ bl (ω). The jump on the derivative is explicit, as ∂2 G 0 (z, (y1 , 0+ )) − P0 (z, (y1 , 0+ )) ⊗ e2 2z 2 (z 1 − y1 )2 (z 1 − y1 )y2 . = y22 π((z 1 − y1 )2 + z 22 )2 (z 1 − y1 )y2 Standard variational formulation yields existence and uniqueness of a solution H (z, ·) with ∇ H (z, ·) in L 2 . In turn, this provides a unique solution G ω (z, ·) to (4.2). The corresponding pressure field Pω (z, ·) is determined up to the addition of a constant matrix. Note that uniqueness yields the relation G τh (ω) (z, y) = G ω ((z 1 + h, z 2 ), (y1 + h, y2 )).
(4.3)
Our key estimate is provided by Lemma 9. For all 0 < τ < 1, for all z, y ∈ bl (ω) satisfying |z − y| ≥ 1, we have
|∂ yβ G ω (z, y)| + |∇ y Pω (z, y)| ≤ C
|β|≤2
δ(z)τ (1 + δ(y))τ , |z − y|2τ
(4.4)
where δ(·) denotes the distance to the boundary ∂bl (ω), and C is a constant depending only on τ and on ωC 2,ν . Note that by symmetry of G, we also have |β|≤2
|∂zβ G ω (z, y)| ≤ C
(1 + δ(z))τ (1 + δ(y))τ . |z − y|2τ
(4.5)
Moreover, in the course of the proof of Lemma 9, we will show that for all y, z ∈ bl (ω), (4.6) |G ω (z, y)| ≤ C ln |z − y| + 1 . Let us show Proposition 8, postponing the proof of lemma 9 to the next section. We first need to connect the solution v(ω, ·) of (1.4) to the Green function G ω . For this purpose, we rather consider w(ω, y) = v(ω, y) + y2 1{y2 <0} (y), which satisfies (2.2). Note that v and w coincide at y = 0. Formally, w should be equal to w(ω, ˜ z) = G ω (z, y) e1 dy. (4.7) {y2 =0}
96
D. Gérard-Varet
Using estimates (4.4), (4.6), it is standard to show that w˜ is a solution of (2.2) in 1 ( ). Using bound (4.5), one has even Hloc bl |∇ w| ˜ 2 ≤ C < +∞, bl ∩{|z 1 |<1}
for all ω ∈ Pν . Extending w(ω, ˜ ·) by 0 outside bl (ω), one can show that ω → w(ω, ˜ ·) is measur1 able from Pν to Hloc (R2 ) (see the Appendix for details). Moreover, thanks to (4.3), w˜ satisfies the stationarity relation w(τ ˜ h (ω), y) = w(ω, ˜ (y1 + h, y2 )). Finally, using that w and w˜ both satisfy (2.2), a simple energy estimate on the difference leads to |∇ (w˜ − w)|2 = 0 E bl ∩{|z 1 |<1}
which shows that w = w˜ almost surely. It remains to estimate the difference v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0) = G ω1 ((0, 0), y) − G ω2 ((0, 0), y) e1 , {y2 =0}
for every ω1 , ω2 in Pν which coincide over [−n, n]. This integral is bounded by G ω − G ω ((0, 0), y) dy I1 + I2 := 1 2 y2 =0,|y1 |>n G ω − G ω ((0, 0), y) dy. + 1 2 y2 =0,|y1 |≤n
The use of (4.4) gives I1 ≤ C
y2 =0,|y1 |>n
1 C dy1 ≤ 2τ −1 , |y1 |2τ n
where C, which depends a priori on ωi C 2,ν , can be chosen uniformly over Pν , as all C 2,ν norms are bounded by K ν . To bound the second term, we first assume that ω2 > ω1 for |y1 | > n, which is always possible up to introducing an intermediate third boundary. Hence, bl (ω2 ) ⊂ bl (ω1 ). To lighten notations, we introduce bl bl bl bl bl 1,2 := (ω1 ) \ (ω2 ), 1,2 := ∂ (ω2 ) \ ∂ (ω1 ),
as well as ˜ P(y) := Pω2 (0, 0), (y1 , ω2 (y1 )) ,
y ∈ bl 1,2 ,
which defines a continuous extension of Pω2 ((0, 0), ·) outside bl (ω2 ). Finally, we define the vector fields U (y) := G ω1 − G ω2 ((0, 0), y), Q(y) := Pω1 − Pω2 ((0, 0), y), y ∈ bl (ω2 ), ˜ Q(y) := Pω1 ((0, 0), y) − P(y), y ∈ bl U (y) := G ω1 ((0, 0), y), 1,2 .
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
They satisfy ⎧ ⎪ −U + ∇ Q ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ −U + ∇ Q div U ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ U ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ [U ] |1,2
97
= 0,
y ∈ bl (ω2 ), ˜ y ∈ bl = −∇ P, 1,2 ,
= 0,
y ∈ bl (ω1 ),
(4.8)
= 0, y ∈ ∂ (ω1 ), = 0, [∂n U − Q ⊗ n] |1,2 = −∂n G ω2 ((0, 0), y)|1,2 . bl
A direct energy estimate yields 2 |∇U | ≤ |∂n G ω2 ((0, 0), y)| |U | + bl (ω1 )
≤
≤ C
1,2
1,2
|∂n G ω2 ((0, 0), y)|2
1,2
1/2
|∂n G ω2 ((0, 0), y)|2
1,2
1/2
+
|U |2
bl 1,2
1/2
bl 1,2
˜ |U | |∇ P|
+
˜ 2 |∇ P|
bl 1,2
˜ 2 |∇ P|
1/2
1/2 bl 1,2
bl 1,2
|∂ y2 U |2
|U |2
1/2
1/2
.
Note that all y in both 1,2 and bl 1,2 satisfy |y1 | > n. Using (4.4), we end up with bl (ω1 )
Back to I2 , we obtain √ |I2 | ≤ 2n
|y1 |≤n,y2 =0
|∇U |2 ≤ C n 1−4τ .
1/2 |U |2
≤C
√ n
1/2
bl (ω1 )
|∂ y2 U |2
≤
C n 2τ −1
.
This ends the proof of Proposition (8). 5. Green Function Estimates This section is devoted to the proof of Lemma 9, that is sharp estimates on the Green function (G ω , Pω ) for the Stokes operator above the humped boundary y2 = ω(y1 ), where ω belongs to C 2,ν . A fundamental remark is that the Green function satisfies the scaling ∀ε > 0, G ωε (εz, εy) = G ω (z, y), ωε (x1 ) = εω(x1 /ε).
(5.1)
We want estimates (4.4) to hold for |z − y| large, that is for ε := |z − y|−1 small. By relation (5.1), to establish such estimates amounts to get local estimates for the Green function G ωε . Thus, this is again a homogenization problem: more precisely, we must show that the oscillations of the boundary at frequency ε−1 do not affect too much the estimates on G ωε , so that it behaves as the Green function for a half-plane. A very close problem has been considered in papers [5,6] by Avellaneda and Lin, namely the derivation of local estimates for elliptic systems div (A(x/ε)∇ · ), in which A is a positive definite matrix with periodic coefficients. Our reasoning follows these papers.
98
D. Gérard-Varet
For all x such that x2 > ωε (x1 ) and all r > 0, we will denote D(x, r ) the disk of center x and radius r , and D ε (x, r ) := D(x, r ) ∩ {x2 > ωε (x1 )}, ε (x, r ) := D(x, r ) ∩ {x2 = ωε (x1 )}. An important property is that for all 0 < r < 1, for all x with x2 > ωε (x1 ), |D ε (x, r )| ≥ η r 2 ,
(5.2)
for some η > 0 independent of ε. More precisely, η only involves the Lipschitz norm of ωε , which is bounded uniformly in ε. This will be used implicitly throughout the sequel. The core of the proof is to derive elliptic estimates uniform with respect to ε on the following Stokes problem: ⎧ ε ⎨ −u + ∇ p = div f, x ∈ D (x0 , 1), div u = 0, x ∈ D ε (x0 , 1), (5.3) ⎩ u = 0, x ∈ ε (x0 , 1), where x0 ∈ {x2 > ωε (x1 )}. More precisely, there are two steps in the proof: 1. We show a ε-uniform Hölder estimate on u: for all f ∈ L q , q > 2 and for µ = 1 − 2/q, (5.4) uC 0,µ (D ε (x0 ,1/2)) ≤ C f L q (D ε (x0 ,1)) + u L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1)) , where C depends only on ωC 1,ν . 2. Thanks to this Hölder estimate, we prove (4.4). The two next paragraphs correspond to these steps. 5.1. Hölder estimate. To obtain a Hölder regularity result, a classical approach is to use a characterization of Hölder spaces due to Campanato (see [16]): for an open connected bounded set, v ∈ C 0,µ () iff v ∈ L 2 () and 1 |v − v x,r |2 < ∞, (x, r ) := ∩ D(x, r ), sup 2+2µ x∈,r >0 r (x,r ) 1 v x,r := v. |(x, r )| (x,r ) One then tries to control such local integrals through energy estimates. This approach has been successful in the study of elliptic systems, see the work of Giaquinta and coauthors [16]. It extends to the Stokes type equations, cf. article [17]. For us, it amounts to controlling 1 1 ε I x,r := 2+2µ |u − u x,r |2 < ∞, u x,r := u, r |D ε (x, r )| D ε (x,r ) D ε (x,r ) where u is solution of (5.3). Note that, thanks to (5.2) (see [16]), for all x0 ∈ {x2 > ωε (x1 )}, uC 0,µ (D ε (x0 ,1/2)) ≤ C u L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1/2)) +
sup
x∈D ε (x
0 ,1/2),r >0
I ε (x, r ) ,
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
99
where C depends only on the Lipschitz norm of ω. In our case, the main problem is to ε on ε. It involves a discussion of the way ε relates keep track of the dependence of I x,r to r . Broadly speaking, the idea is the following: if r is large compared to ε, then the oscillations have small enough amplitude to apply the regularity results of the flat case. On the contrary, when r gets as small or even smaller than ε, one can rescale everything by a factor ε, so that oscillations of the boundary have frequency O(1), and are no longer annoying. Implementation of this idea is a bit technical, and follows closely the work of Avellaneda and Lin. We first recall a few elements of regularity theory for Stokes type systems. Let be an open connected bounded set, with Lipschitz boundary. Then, for any ϕ ∈ L 2 () satisfying ϕ = 0, the problem div w = ϕ, w|∂ = 0 has one solution w satisfying w H 1 ≤ C ϕ L 2 () , where C can be taken as an increas0 ing function of || and of the Lipschitz constant K of the boundary, see [14]. Thanks to this result, one has quite easily, p − p L 2 () ≤ C u + f H −1 () , (5.5)
where (u, p) ∈ H 1 () × L 2 () satisfies (in the distributional sense) − u + ∇ p = f, div u = 0, x ∈ .
(5.6)
Again, the constant C in (5.5) depends only on || and the Lipschitz constant of the boundary. We now state the famous Cacciopoli inequality: Lemma 10. For all 0 < r < 1, any solution u ∈ H 1 () of (5.3) satisfies ∇u L 2 (D ε (x,r )) ≤ C r −1 u L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) + r µ f L q (D ε (x,2r )) .
(5.7)
Sketch of proof: We recall the main elements of proof. Let η be a smooth function with compact support in D(x, 2r ), with η = 1 on D(x, r ). Note that |∇η| ≤ Cr −1 . Multiplying (5.3) by the test function η2 u, and integrating by parts, one has easily 2 2 2 −2 2 |∇u| ≤ η |∇u| ≤ C r |u| + C | f |2 D ε (x,r )
D ε (x,2r )
D ε (x,2r )
D ε (x,2r )
+ p − p x,2r L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) div (ηu) L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) . Using (5.5), we get p − p x,2r L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) ≤ C u + div f H −1 (D ε (x,2r )) = Cv H 1 (D ε (x,2r )) , where v ∈ H01 (D ε (x, 2r )) is the solution of −v + ∇ p = u + div f, div v = 0, v|∂ D ε (x,2r ) = 0. Note that the previous bound is uniform in ε, as it only involves the Lipschitz constant of ωε which is uniformly bounded. A simple energy estimate on v gives ∇v L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) ≤ C ∇u L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) + f L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) .
100
D. Gérard-Varet
As div (ηu) = ∇η · u, and using Hölder inequality on f , we end up with 2 2 2 −2 |∇u| ≤ η |∇u| ≤ C r |u|2 + Cδ r 2µ f 2L q (D ε (x,2r )) D ε (x,r )
D ε (x,2r )
D ε (x,2r ) 2 +δ∇u L 2 (D ε (x,2r )) ,
where δ > 0 is arbitrary small. We conclude as in [17, Theorem 1.1, p. 180]. Inequality of type (5.7) has been used by Giaquinta and Modica in the study of elliptic regularity. In the context of Stokes type system, they obtain a local estimate, see [17]: Theorem 11. Let of class C 1 , and (u, p, f ) ∈ H 1 () × L 2 () × L q (), q > 2, satisfying −u + ∇ p = div f, div u = 0, x ∈ (x0 , 1), u|∂∩D(x0 ,1) = 0. Then, u ∈ C 0,µ ((x0 , 1/2)) for µ = 1 − 2/q, and uC 0,µ ((x0 ,1/2)) ≤ C u L 2 ((x0 ,1)) + f L q ((x0 ,1)) .
(5.8)
Unfortunately, we cannot use this theorem as such. Indeed, the constant C in the last regularity estimate involves the modulus of continuity of ∇γ , where x2 = γ (x1 ) describes the boundary. In our case γ = ωε , such modulus of continuity is not uniformly bounded ε . Note that Thein ε. We must proceed in several steps to control the local integrals I x,r orem 11 implies estimate (5.4) when D ε (x0 , 1) is far from the boundary. Thus, we can restrict ourselves to a case in which x0 is close to the oscillating boundary, for instance belongs to the axis x2 = 0. Lemma 12. For all θ small enough, there exists ε0 > 0 such that for all ε < ε0 , and for all solutions of (5.3) satisfying u ε L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) ≤ 1, f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) ≤ ε0 , one has u ε L 2 (D ε (x0 ,θ)) ≤ θ µ+1 . Proof of the Lemma. Suppose that the result does not hold. Then one can find θ arbitrary small, and sequences u ε j , f j satisfying u ε j L 2 (D ε j (x0 ,1/4)) ≤ 1, f j L 2 (D ε j (x0 ,1/4)) −−−−→ 0, u ε j L 2 (D ε j (x0 ,θ)) > θ µ+1 . j→+∞
One can extend all the u εj , f j by 0 outside D ε j (x0 , 1/4) so that all these functions are defined on the fixed domain D(x0 , 1/4). From the L 2 bound on u ε j , up to extracting a subsequence, we get u ε j converges weakly to some u in L 2 (D(x0 , 1/4)), and by the Cacciopoli inequality (5.7), u ε j converges weakly to u in H 1 (D(x0 , 1/8)), and strongly in L 2 (D(x0 , 1/8)). One can then take the limit in (5.3), which yields −u + ∇ p = 0, div u = 0, in D(x0 , 1/8) ∩ {x2 > 0}, u| D(x0 ,1/8)∩{x2 =0} = 0.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
101
As the upper half plane is a regular domain, we can apply Theorem 11, so that for all µ˜ > µ, for all θ , ˜ u L 2 (D(x0 ,θ)∩{x2 >0}) ≤ 2π uC 0,µ˜ (D(x0 ,θ)∩{x2 >0}) θ µ+1 ˜ ˜ ≤ C u L 2 (D(x0 ,1/8)∩{x2 >0}) θ µ+1 ≤ C θ µ+1 .
For θ small enough, it contradicts the lower bound on u ε j L 2 (D ε j (x0 ,θ)) . We fix θ , ε0 as in Lemma 12. We then state Lemma 13. For all ε, k satisfying ε/θ k ≤ ε0 (k ≥ 1), 2 1 ε 2 2kµ+2 ε u L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) + |u | ≤ θ f L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . ε0 D ε (x0 ,θ k )
(5.9)
Proof of the Lemma. The lemma is deduced from an induction argument on k. For k = 1, the bound (5.9) is given by lemma 12. Assume now that this bound holds for k ≥ 1. Up to a horizontal translation, we can assume that x0 = 0. Then, we set M := u ε L 2 (D ε (0,1/4)) +
1 f L 2 (D ε (0,1/4)) , ε0
and introduce the rescaled functions v := θ −kµ M −1 u(θ k x), g = θ k−kµ M −1 f (θ k x). They satisfy −v + ∇q = div g, div v = 0, x ∈ D ε (0, θ −k /4), v| ε (0,θ −k /4) . Moreover, one has f L q (D ε (0,1/4)) ≤ ε0 , and by the induction assumption v L 2 (D ε (0,1/4)) ≤ 1. Applying Lemma 12 to v and g yields the result. We can now finish the proof of estimate (5.4). Let x ∈ D ε (x0 , 1/2). We need to bound I ε (x, r ), for r > 0. There are two cases to handle: • The distance between x and the boundary {x2 = ωε (x1 )} satisfies δ ε (x) ≥
ε ε0 .
Up to take a smaller ε0 , we can suppose that εε0 > ε, which implies that there exists x0 on the axis {x2 = 0} with |x − x0 | ≤ δ ε (x). By Lemma 13, for all ε/ε0 ≤ r ≤ 1/12, 2 |u ε |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . (5.10) D ε (x0 ,3r )
0
If r > δ ε (x)/2, D ε (x, r ) ⊂ D ε (x0 , 3r ), and the previous line implies 2 |u ε |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . D ε (x,r )
0
On the contrary, if r ≤ δ ε (x)/2, then D ε (x, r ) = D(x, r ) (it does not intersect the boundary). A simple rescaling of (5.8) yields uC 0,µ (D(x,δ ε (x)/2)) ≤ C δ ε (x)−1−µ u ε L 2 (D(x,δ ε (x))) + f L q (D(x,δ ε (x))) .
102
D. Gérard-Varet
Thus, D ε (x,r )
2 |u ε |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 δ ε (x)−1−µ u ε L 2 (D(x,δ ε (x))) + f L q (D(x,δ ε (x))) .
Now, by Lemma 13, as δ ε (x) ≥ ε/ε0 , u ε L 2 (D(x,δ ε (x))) ≤ u ε L 2 (D(x ,2δ ε (x))) 0 ε µ+1 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . ≤ C δ (x) 0
Using the two last inequalities, we end up again with 2 |u ε |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) , 0
D ε (x,r )
which in turn clearly implies 2 |u ε − u ε x,r |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . 0
D ε (x,r )
As D ε (x0 , 1/4)) ⊂ D ε (x0 , 1), this gives the required estimate. • The distance between x and the boundary {x2 = ωε (x1 )} satisfies δ ε (x) <
ε ε0 .
This time, there exists x0 on the axis {x2 = 0} such that |x − x0 | ≤ δ ε (x) + ε ≤ 2ε/ε0 . Again, for all ε/ε0 ≤ r ≤ 1/12, D(x, r ) ⊂ D(x0 , 3r ) and (5.10) implies 2 |u ε |2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 u ε L 2 (D ε (x ,1/4)) + f L q (D ε (x0 ,1/4)) . 0
D ε (x,r )
It remains to handle the case r < ε/ε0 . Up to a horizontal translation, we can assume that x0 = 0. We introduce the rescaled functions v=
ε ε0
−µ
uε
1−µ ε ε ε x , g= f x . ε0 ε0 ε0
They satisfy in particular − v + ∇q = div g, div v = 0, x ∈ D ε0 (0, 1), v| ε0 (0,1) = 0.
(5.11)
It is a Stokes type system set in a domain independent of the small parameter ε. Hence, we can apply Theorem 11, which yields: for all r < 1, |v − v x,r |2 ≤ C vC 0,µ (D ε0 (x,r )) r 2µ+2 D ε0 (x,r )
2 ≤ C r 2µ+2 v L 2 (D ε0 (0,2)) + g L 2 (D ε0 (0,2)) .
ε for r ≤ ε/ε . This Back to the original unknowns u ε , f , we obtain the control of I x,r 0 ends the proof.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
103
5.2. Bounds on the Green function. From the above Hölder estimate, we can deduce the estimate (4.4). The arguments are again adapted from article [5, pp. 819, 829–831]. For the sake of completeness, we describe the ideas at play. The first step is to establish the following bound: for all x, x in {x2 > ωε (x1 )}, (5.12) |G ωε (x, x )| ≤ C ln |x − x | + 1 , where C only involves ωC 1,ν . Note that it implies (4.6). To lighten the notations, we drop the suffix ω, denoting G ε , G instead of G ωε , G ω . Let us introduce the Green function G˜ ε (x, t, x , t ) for the Stokes operator over {x2 > ωε (x1 )} × T. Namely, it satisfies for all (x, t) ∈ {x2 > ωε (x1 )} × T, ⎧ ε ˜ε ˜ε ⎪ ⎨ −G (x, t, ·) + ∇ P (x, t, ·) = δx,t I3 in {x2 > ω (x1 )} × T, (5.13) div G˜ ε (x, t, ·) = 0 in {x2 > ωε (x1 )} × T, ⎪ ⎩ G˜ ε (x, t, ·) = 0 on {x2 = ωε (x1 )} × T. One has easily that G ε (x, x ) =
T
G˜ ε1 (x, 0, x , t ), G˜ ε2 (x, 0, x , t ) dt .
The point is to show that |G˜ ε (x, t, x , t )| ≤ C
1 |x −
x | + |t
− t |
.
The estimate (5.12) is then obtained by integration with respect to t , at t = 0. Such bound on G˜ ε will be deduced from repeated use of the Hölder estimate (5.4). Note that this estimate extends without difficulty to similar Stokes problems in dimension n ≥ 2, with q > n and µ = 1 − n/q. In particular, it holds when the domain is {x2 > ωε (x1 )} × T. Namely, let x˜ := (x, t) and x˜ := (x , t ). Let r := |x− ˜ x˜ |, and f ∈ Cc∞ (D ε (x˜ , r/3)). We consider the quantity u ε (x) ˜ = ˜ z˜ ) f (˜z ) d z˜ . G˜ ε (x, D ε (x˜ ,r/3)
The field u ε satisfies a Stokes equation with a source term f over {x2 > ωε (x1 )}×T, with a Dirichlet boundary condition. We therefore apply the estimate (5.4) to u ε . Properly rescaled, it yields 1/2 ˜ ≤ C r −3 |u ε |2 , |u ε (x)| D ε (x,r/3) ˜
where we used the fact that f vanishes over D ε (x, ˜ r/3). Thus, we get 1/2 ε 2 ≤ C r −3 ˜ ε (x, ˜ z ˜ ) f (˜ z ) d z ˜ |u | G D ε (x˜ ,r/3)
≤ C r −3 ≤ C r −1/2
D ε (x,r/3) ˜
|u ε |6
1/6
{x2 >ωε (x1 )}×T
D ε (x,r/3) ˜
≤ C r −1/2
|∇u ε |2
1/2
D ε (x,r/3) ˜
|u ε |6
≤ C r 1/2 f L 2 , 1/2
1/6
104
D. Gérard-Varet
where the last two inequalities come respectively from the Sobolev imbedding theorem (note that u ε is zero at the boundary so that the imbedding does not involve lower order terms), and from the standard energy estimate on the Stokes system: |∇u ε |2 ≤ f L 2 (D(x˜ ,r/3)) u L 2 (D(x˜ ,r/3)) ≤ r ∇u L 2 (D(x˜ ,r/3)) . {x2 >ωε (x1 )}×T
By duality, we infer that r −3
D ε (x˜ ,r/3)
|G˜ ε (x, ˜ z˜ )|2 d z˜
1/2
≤ C r −1 .
˜ ·) satisfies a homogenenous Stokes system over D(x˜ , r/3), one more Using that G˜ ε (x, application of (5.4) leads to 1/2 ε −3 ε 2 ˜ ˜ ˜ y˜ ) ≤ C r |G (x, ˜ z˜ )| d z˜ ≤ C r −1 . G (x, D ε (x˜ ,r/3)
The inequality (5.12) at hand, we can derive the final estimate on G. Let x, x ∈ {x2 > ωε (x1 )}. Set this time r := |x − x |. For all x¯ such that |x¯ − x| < 2r , (5.12) implies ε G (x, ¯ x ) ≤ C ln |x¯ − x | + 1 ≤ C ln |x − x | + 1 . Applying (5.4) to the function G ε (·, x ), we get for any τ ∈ (0, 1), ε G (x, x ) ≤ δ ε (x)τ G ε (·, x )C 0,τ (D(x,r/3)) ≤ Cτ δ ε (x)τ r −1−τ G ε (·, x ) L 2 (D(x,2r/3)) that leads to ε ε τ G (x, x ) ≤ Cτ ln |x − x | + 1 δ (x) . |x − x |τ Now reversing the roles of x and x , we obtain δ ε (x)τ δ ε (x )τ |G ε (x, x )| ≤ Cτ ln |x − x | + 1 . |x − x |2τ Using the scaling relation (5.1), we get for all y, z ∈ {y2 > ω(y1 )}, for ε := |y − z|−1 , δ ε (εz)τ δ ε (εy)τ δ(z)τ δ(y)τ = Cτ . G(z, y) = G ε (εz, εy) ≤ Cτ ln (ε|z − y|) + 1 2τ |ε(y − z)| |y − z|2τ Using classical local regularity results for the Stokes equation in a C 2,ν domain (see [17, Theorem 1.3, pp. 198], which extends Theorem 11): for |z − y| ≥ 1, |∂ yβ G(z, y)| + |∇ y P(z, y)| ≤ C G(z, ·) L 2 (D(y,1/2)) |β|≤2
≤C that is exactly estimate (4.4).
δ(z)τ (1 + δ(y))τ , |z − y|2τ
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
105
6. Comments 6.1. Well-posedness of the boundary layer system. As mentioned several times in this paper, the well-posedness of system (1.4) is still not known without a structural assumption on ω, like periodicity or stationarity. We stress however that thanks to our estimates on the Green function G ω , the representation formula (4.7) defines a solution of (1.4) for any C 2,ν boundary, cf. the fourth section. Hence, the open issue is rather to find the appropriate functional space for uniqueness. Such difficulty does not arise when the Stokes operator is replaced by the Laplacian, or more generally by a scalar elliptic operator. Hence, one can show well-posedness in L ∞ of − v = 0 in bl , v(y) = ω(y1 ) on ∂bl
(6.1)
if the function ω is bounded and Lipschitz. For the existence part, one may consider, for all n ≥ 1, the solution v n of −v n = 0 in bl ∩ D(0, n), v n (y) = ω(y1 ) on ∂ bl ∩ D(0, n) . By the maximum principle, v n L ∞ ≤ ω L ∞ , so that up to a subsequence it converges to some v in L ∞ weak*. Straightforwardly, v satisfies (6.1). For the uniqueness part, let v ∈ L ∞ , satisfying −v = 0 in bl , v(y) = 0 on ∂bl . Let us show that v = 0. As we do not know the behavior of v at infinity, it does not follow directly from the maximum principle. In the case of a Lipschitz boundary ω, we can conclude the uniqueness in the following way. By the change of variables y := (y1 , y2 − ω(y1 )), the previous equation becomes div (A(y)∇v) = 0, y2 > 0, v| y2 =0 = 0, for some elliptic matrix A = (ai j ) with bounded coefficients. We extend A and v to {y2 < 0} by the formulas, v(y1 , y2 ) := −v(y1 , −y2 ), ain (y1 , y2 ) := −ain (y1 , −y2 ), an j (y1 , y2 ) := −an j (y1 , −y2 ), i, j = n, ai j (y1 , y2 ) := ai j (y1 , −y2 ) otherwise. In this way, we get div (A(y)∇v) = 0 on all R2 . Harnack’s inequality for elliptic equations (see [18]) leads to sup (M + v) ≤ C inf (M + v)
|y|
|y|
for any R > 0 and M such that M + u ≥ 0. With M = max(0, − inf v) and R going to infinity, we obtain that v = 0.
106
D. Gérard-Varet
6.2. Decay of correlations. A key element in the paper is the estimate (4.4) on the Green function for the Stokes operator above an oscillating boundary. This estimate relies itself on the Hölder regularity result (5.4). In fact, with some more calculations in the same spirit, one could show a refined bound: for a C 1,ν boundary ω and a source term f ∈ C 0,µ (D ε (0, 1)) (ν, µ > 0), the solution u ε of (5.3) satisfies ∇u ε L ∞ (D ε (x0 ,1/2)) ≤ C u L 2 (D ε (x0 ,1)) + f C 0,µ (D ε (x0 ,1)) , with C independent of ε. This yields an optimal bound on the Green function, that is
|∂ yβ G ω (z, y)| + |∇ y Pω (z, y)| ≤ C
|β|≤2
δ(z) (1 + δ(y)) . |z − y|2
(6.2)
Estimate (4.1) can in turn be improved as |v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0)| ≤ C n −1 . Such bound is far easier to prove when (1.4) is replaced by the scalar system (6.1). In this case, one may use a representation in terms of the standard two-dimensional Brownian motion B(m, t) = (B1 (m, t), B2 (m, t)). If we denote (M, M, µ) the probability space on which this Brownian motion is defined, v(ω, 0, 0) = (−ω, 0) B1 (m, τ (m)) dµ, M
where τ is the exit time from bl (ω) (see [25]). We now want to bound ω1 B1 (m, τ1 (m)) − ω2 B1 (m, τ2 (m)) dµ, v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0) = M
where τi is the exit time from bl (ωi ). We recall that ω1 = ω2 over [−n, n], so the exit times are the same for brownian particles leaving in the region y1 ∈ [−n, n]. Hence, |v(ω1 , 0, 0) − v(ω2 , 0, 0)| ≤ 2 max ωi L ∞ µ (|B1 (·, τi )| ≥ n) i=1,2 ≤ 2 µ (T−n ≤ T−1 ) + µ (Tn ≤ T−1 ) , where we denote by T±n the first time for which B1 = ±n/2, and T−1 the first time for which B2 = −1. It is well-known that the distributions of these hitting times are 2 −n −1 n 1 1t>0 dt, dT−1 (µ) = √ 1t>0 dt. exp exp dT±n (µ) = √ 8t 2t 4 2π t 3 2π t 3 A straightforward calculation provides µ (T±n ≤ T−1 ) = dT±n (µ) (t1 ) dT−1 (µ) (t2 ) ≤ C(n 2 + 1)−1/2 , 0≤t1 ≤t2
which gives the result.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
107
6.3. Optimality of the decay rate. Theorem 4 shows that the boundary layer solution −1/2 v converges at least as y2 . One may wonder if this result is optimal, that is if we can find roughness distributions for which the speed of convergence is exactly given by −1/2 y2 . In other words, is the constant σ(0,0) of the theorem positive for some random distribution of roughness? We have not so far been able to show optimality in this setting, but it can be established for the easier Dirichlet problem
u = 0, y2 > 0, u = ω, y2 = 0, where ω is a given boundary data. Although simpler, this system shares many features with the original system (1.4): • If ω = ω(y1 ) is say L-periodic, the solution u(y) converges exponentially fast to the L constant α := L −1 0 ω(y1 )dy1 , as y2 goes to infinity. • If ω belongs as before to the probability space (P, C, π ), one can show under assumption (H2) that y2 E|u(ω, 0, y2 ) − α|2 −−−−−→ σ 2 ≥ 0, α := E(ω → ω(0)). y2 →+∞
Along the lines of [24, pp. 21–22], we will exhibit a stationary measure π for which σ > 0. Of course, π is the law of the random process ϕ(ω, y1 ) := ω(y1 ), so that we just need to characterize the random boundary data. Let G(ω, y1 ) be a gaussian random process, of zero mean and covariance ρ(z 1 − y1 ), where ρ ≥ 0 is a smooth even function with compact support. Note that such process exists: take ρ = f ∗ f , with f ≥ 0 an even smooth function with compact support. Then, its Fourier transform satisfies ρˆ = | fˆ|2 ≥ 0, which ensures the required positivity property c(z 1 ) c(y1 )ρ(z 1 − y1 ) = : | c(z 1 )eiξ z 1 |2 ρ(ξ ˆ ) dξ ≥ 0 R
z 1 ,y1
z1
for any family c with compact support. Note moreover that this process defines almost surely smooth functions of y1 : indeed, a simple calculation yields E |∂ yk1 X (·, y1 )|2 dy1 = 2R (−1)k ρ (2k) (0) < ∞ [−R,R]
k (R) and therefore smooth. Finally, we so that X (ω, ·) is almost surely in the space Hloc introduce
ϕ(ω, y1 ) = F(X (ω, y1 )) for a smooth increasing function F with values in (0, 1). We stress that ϕ satisfies (H2) as ρ has compact support. We will show that the corresponding σ is positive. Suppose a contrario that σ = 0. For y2 ≥ 1, we introduce the measure π y2 associated to the gaussian process with variance ρ(z 1 − y1 ) but mean m(z 1 , y2 ) = ρ(z 1 − y1 )g(y1 , y2 ) dy1 , where g will be given later. Note that π y2 is associated to the random boundary data ϕ y2 (ω, y1 ) := F(X (ω, y1 ) + m(y1 , y2 )).
108
D. Gérard-Varet
Standard computation yields R(ω, y2 ) :=
dπ y2 (ω) = exp g(y1 , y2 )ϕ(ω, y1 )dy1 dπ 1 − ρ(z 1 − y1 )g(z 1 , y2 ) g(y1 , y2 )dz 1 dy1 , 2
and |R(ω, y2 )|2 dπ = e H (y2 ) ,
H (y2 ) :=
ρ(z 1 − y1 )g(z 1 , y2 ) g(y1 , y2 )dz 1 dy1 .
If σ = 0, then a simple Cauchy-Schwartz inequality 1 √ y2 |u(ω, 0, y2 ) − α|dπ y2 ≤ e 2 H (y2 ) y2 |u(ω, 0, y2 ) − α|2 dπ and goes to zero as y2 → +∞ if H is bounded from above. Let u and v be solutions associated to the initial data ϕ(ω, y1 ) and ϕ y2 (ω, y1 ). As m ≥ 0, by monotonicity, v ≥ u. We can express u and v in terms of the Poisson kernel, so that y2 y2 2 (v − u)(ω, 0, y2 ) = ϕ (ω, y1 ) − ϕ(ω, y1 ) dy1 . 2 2 π R y1 + y2 Now, we define for y2 ≥ 1, 1 g(y1 , y2 ) = √ G y2
y1 y2
,
where G ≥ 0 has compact support, G = 1 over (−1, 1). On one hand, with this definition of g, one can check that y1 z1 −1 sup H (y2 ) = sup y2 G dz 1 dy1 < +∞. ρ(z 1 − y1 )G y2 y2 y2 ≥1 y2 ≥1 On the other hand, one has √ y2 (v − u)(ω, 0, y2 )dπ ≥ C F (X (ω, 0))dπ ≥ C
R
F (X (ω, 0))dπ
× ≥ C
inf
inf
y2 ≥1 |y1 |≤y2
ρ(y1 − s)G
R
R
s y2
ds
y2 −y2
y2 √ y2 m(y1 , y2 ) dy1 y12 + y22
y2 dy1 y12 + y22
ρ(s)ds > 0.
This implies that the quantity to a contradiction.
√
y2 (v(ω, 0, y2 ) − α) dπ does not go to zero, leading
Acknowledgements. The author warmly thanks S.R.S Varadhan for pointing out reference [24], as well as Luis Silvestre and Thierry Levy for fruitful discussions.
Navier Wall Law at a Boundary with Random Roughness
109
˜ Appendix: Measurability of w We want to show here that w(ω, ˜ z) := G ω (z, y) e1 dy, z in bl (ω), w(ω, ˜ z) := 0 y2 =0
otherwise
1 (R2 ). Let 0 ≤ ϕ ≤ 1 be a sequence of defines a measurable function from P to Hloc n smooth functions with compact support, ϕn |(−n,n) = 1. We define wn := G ω (z, y) (ϕn e1 ) dy, z in bl (ω), wn (ω, z) := 0 otherwise. y2 =0
Note that wn is the (unique) solution of ⎧ − wn + ∇qn = 0, x ∈ bl \ {y2 = 0}, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ div wn = 0, x ∈ bl , (6.3) ⎪ wn |∂bl = 0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ [wn ]| y2 =0 = 0, [∂2 wn − (0, qn )]| y2 =0 = (−ϕn , 0), satisfying bl (ω) |∇wn |2 < +∞. By the dominated convergence theorem applied to 2 . By the Cacciopoli inequality, the the integral formula, we get that wn → w˜ in L loc 1 convergence is also true in Hloc . Thus, we just have to show measurability of wn . Let us define
V := v ∈ H˙ 1 (R2 ), div v = 0 , Vω := v ∈ V, v|R2 \bl (ω) = 0 . Following the lines of [8, pp. 15–16] it can be shown that the application ω → π(ω), where π(ω) ∈ L(V, V ) is the orthogonal projection from V to Vω , is measurable. Now, wn is the unique fixed point of the contraction w →
1 π(ω) (w − vn ) , 2
where vn is the unique function of H 1 (R2 ) satisfying ∇vn · ∇φ = 6 ϕn φ1 . R2
y2 =0
The measurability of wn follows. References 1. Achdou, Y., Le Tallec, P., Valentin, F., Pironneau, O.: Constructing wall laws with domain decomposition or asymptotic expansion techniques. In: Symposium on Advances in Computational Mechanics, Vol. 3 (Austin, TX, 1997) Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Engrg. 151, 1–2, 215–232 (1998) 2. Achdou, Y., Mohammadi, B., Pironneau, O., Valentin, F.: Domain decomposition & wall laws. In: Recent developments in domain decomposition methods and flow problems (Kyoto, 1996; Anacapri, 1996), Vol. 11 of GAKUTO Internat. Ser. Math. Sci. Appl. Tokyo: Gakk¯otosho 1998, pp. 1–14 3. Achdou, Y., Pironneau, O., Valentin, F.: Effective boundary conditions for laminar flows over periodic rough boundaries. J. Comput. Phys. 147(1), 187–218 (1998)
110
D. Gérard-Varet
4. Amirat, Y., Bresch, D., Lemoine, J., Simon, J.: Effect of rugosity on a flow governed by stationary Navier-Stokes equations. Quart. Appl. Math. 59(4), 769–785 (2001) 5. Avellaneda, M., Lin, F.-H.: Compactness methods in the theory of homogenization. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 40(6), 803–847 (1987) 6. Avellaneda, M., Lin, F.-H.: L p bounds on singular integrals in homogenization. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 44(8–9), 897–910 (1991) 7. Baladi, V.: Decay of correlations. In: Smooth ergodic theory and its applications (Seattle, WA, 1999), Vol. 69 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. 2001, pp. 297–325 8. Basson, A., Gérard-Varet, D.: Wall laws for fluid flows at a boundary with random roughness. Comm. Pure Applied Math. 61(7), 941–987 (2008) 9. Bechert, D., Bartenwerfer, M.: The viscous flow on surfaces with longitudinal ribs. J. Fluid Mech. 206(1), 105–129 (1989) 10. Bresch, D., Gérard-Varet, D.: Roughness-induced effects on the quasi-geostrophic model. Comm. Math. Phys. 253(1), 81–119 (2005) 11. Bresch, D., Milisic, V.: Higher order boundary layer correctors and wall laws derivation: a unified approach. http://arXiv.org./list/math/0611083, 2006 12. De Bouard, A., Craig, W., Daz-Espinosa, O., Guyenne, P., Sulem, C.: Long wave expansions for water waves over random topography. http://arXiv.org./list/math/07100389, 2007 13. Durrett, R.: Probability: theory and examples. Second ed. Belmont, CA: Duxbury Press, 1996 14. Galdi, G.P.: An introduction to the mathematical theory of the Navier-Stokes equations. Vol. I, Vol. 38 of Springer Tracts in Natural Philosophy. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1994 15. Gérard-Varet, D.: Highly rotating fluids in rough domains. J. Math. Pures Appl. (9) 82, 11, 1453–1498 (2003) 16. Giaquinta, M.: Multiple integrals in the calculus of variations and nonlinear elliptic systems, vol. 105 of Annals of Mathematics Studies. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1983 17. Giaquinta, M., Modica, G.: Nonlinear systems of the type of the stationary Navier-Stokes system. J. Reine Angew. Math. 330, 173–214 (1982) 18. Gilbarg, D., Trudinger, N.S.: Elliptic partial differential equations of second order. Classics in Mathematics. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 2001 (Reprint of the 1998 edition) 19. Jäger, W., Mikeli´c, A.: On the roughness-induced effective boundary conditions for an incompressible viscous flow. J. Differ. Eq. 170(1), 96–122 (2001) 20. Jäger, W., Mikeli´c, A.: Couette flows over a rough boundary and drag reduction. Comm. Math. Phys. 232(3), 429–455 (2003) 21. Jäger, W., Mikeli´c, A., Neuss, N.: Asymptotic analysis of the laminar viscous flow over a porous bed. SIAM J. Sci. Comput. 22, 6, 2006–2028 (2000) (electronic) 22. Jikov, V.V., Kozlov, S.M., Ole˘ınik, O.A.: Homogenization of differential operators and integral functionals. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1994. (Translated from the Russian by G. A. Yosifian [G. A. Iosif yan]) 23. Luchini, P.: Asymptotic analysis of laminar boundary-layer flow over finely grooved surfaces. European J. Mech. B Fluids 14(2), 169–195 (1995) 24. Varadhan, S., Zygouras, N.: Behavior of the solution of a random semilinear heat equation. Comm. Pure Applied Math. 61(9), 1298–1329 (2008) 25. Varadhan, S.R.S.: Stochastic processes. Notes based on a course given at New York University during the year 1967/68. New York: Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences New York University, 1968 Communicated by P. Constantin
Commun. Math. Phys. 286, 111–124 (2009) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-008-0585-3
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation with Supercritical Dissipation Dong Li1 , Jose Rodrigo2 1 Institute For Advanced Studies, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA. E-mail: [email protected] 2 Warwick University, Coventry CV4 7AL, United Kingdom. E-mail: [email protected]
Received: 4 December 2007 / Accepted: 31 March 2008 Published online: 22 July 2008 – © Springer-Verlag 2008
Abstract: We prove the existence of singularities for the generalized surface quasigeostrophic (GSQG) equation with supercritical dissipation. Analogous results are obtained for the family of equations interpolating between GSQG and 2D Euler. 1. Introduction and Main Results In this article we consider a family of generalized active scalar equations arising from fluid mechanics. Of particular interest is the generalized surface quasi-geostrophic (GSQG) equation θt + u · ∇θ + κγ θ = 0 (x, t) ∈ R2 × (0, ∞), (1) θ (x, 0) = θ0 (x) x ∈ R2 , where κ ≥ 0, γ ∈ (0, 2] are fixed parameters. The dissipative term is given by a fractional Laplacian, γ , that is defined by means of the Fourier transform; we have γ f (ξ ) = |ξ |γ fˆ(ξ ).
To complete the system, the velocity u is related to the scalar θ by: u = −Q β (−)−1/2 ∇θ, with
(2)
cos β − sin β . Qβ = sin β cos β
Here β ∈ [0, 2π ) is also a fixed parameter. When β = π2 or 3π 2 , we recover the usual 2D surface quasi-geostrophic equation (SQG). In this sense we regard the system (1)–(2) as a generalization of the usual SQG. We remark that the usual SQG equation,
112
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
β = π2 , 3π 2 , is an incompressible model, while for all other β it is easy to check that the divergence of u is not 0. The other systems we will consider arise as a generalization of the family of interpolating models between SQG and 2D Euler. More precisely, the evolution of the active scalar θ is still given by Eq. (1) but now the velocity is given by α
u = −Q β (−)−(1− 2 ) ∇θ,
(3)
for 0 < α < 1. Notice that the endpoint case α = 1 corresponds to the previously described generalized surface quasi-geostrophic equation while the case α = 0 and β = π2 , 3π 2 produces the classical 2D Euler. We will not review here in detail the known results for the standard surface quasigeostrophic equation. We refer the reader to [2–5,7,10,13,14,16,17] and [18] for more details both from the theoretical and numerical point of view. We briefly recall some recent results for the generalized problems. For GSQG (α = 1) without dissipation (κ = 0), Dong and Li (see [11]) obtained the blow up of smooth radial solutions, while Balodis and Córdoba (see [1]) proved the existence of singularities for the equation ∂t θ + (−Rθ )∇θ = 0,
(4)
which corresponds to α = 1, β = 0 or π . Here R stands for the Riesz transform. In [1], they obtained some new bilinear estimates for the Riesz transform and used them to show the existence of singularities for general (smooth) initial data (not necessarily radial, and without any restrictions on the sign of θ ). Both results ([1] and [11]) are inspired by the work of A. Córdoba, D. Córdoba and M. Fontelos (see [8]) for the following one dimensional model for the surface quasigeostrophic equation: ∂t f − (H f ) f x = −κγ f,
(5)
where H is the Hilbert transform. In an elegant way they obtained some new bilinear estimates for the Hilbert transform and as a result proved the ill-posedness of the equation without the dissipative term (i.e. κ = 0). We refer the reader to [8] and [9] for more details. In [15] the authors were able to extend their result to include the dissipative term for γ < 21 . The results we present here are the first ones to answer the question of the global well posedness for the supercritical case for any of the two dimensional models mentioned before. We will restrict our attention to radial solutions of constant sign (determined by β). We will concentrate on the GSQG model, presenting the required modifications for the other equations at the end of the paper. For GSQG we will prove the following Theorem 1 (GSQG). Let θ0 ∈ C ∞ (R) be a smooth, bounded, even function. Assume θ0 L ∞ = M. Let 0 ≤ γ < 1/2 and 0 < δ < 1 − 2γ be arbitrary but fixed. Let β in (2) be different from π2 , 3π 2 , but otherwise arbitrary. Then there exists a constant C = C(γ , δ, β, M) > 0 such that if θ0 satisfies ∞ θ0 (y) − θ0 (0) dy > C, y 1+δ 0 then the solution to (1)–(2) , with initial data θ0 (|x|), blows up in finite time.
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
113
Remark 1. In the course of the proof of the above theorem we will actually prove that the blow up happens at the level of ∇θ L ∞ . Remark 2. For the GSQG equation, γ = 1 is the critical exponent. Our argument only provides blow up for γ < 21 , but we believe that this restriction is just a limitation of our approach, and conjecture that singularities exist for all the supercritical range (0 < γ < 1). For the interpolating models we have a similar result for α ≥ 21 . We have Theorem 2 (Interpolating Models). Let θ0 ∈ C ∞ (R) be a smooth, bounded, even function. Assume θ0 L ∞ = M. Let α ≥ 21 , 0 ≤ γ < α2 and 0 < δ < α − 2γ be arbitrary but fixed. Let β in (3) be different from π2 , 3π 2 , but otherwise arbitrary. Then there exists a constant C = C(γ , δ, β, M) > 0 such that if θ0 satisfies ∞ θ0 (y) − θ0 (0) dy > C, y 1+δ 0 then the solution to (1),(3) , with initial data θ0 (|x|), blows up in finite time. 2. Reduction to a One Dimensional Model Following [8] and [15] the main strategy in the proof of Theorem 1 is to establish the blow up of ∞ ∞ θ (x1 , x2 , t) − θ (0, 0, t) d x1 d x2 (6) 2+δ 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 for some positive δ. By restricting our attention to radial solutions we will be able to reduce the study of (6) to a 1 dimensional problem. To obtain an evolution equation for (6) we observe that ∂t θ (x1 , x2 , t) + u · ∇θ (x1 , x2 , t) = −κγ θ (x1 , x2 , t), ∂t θ (0, 0, t)+ = −κγ θ (0, 0, t),
(7)
since the velocity at the origin is 0 for radial solutions ∇θ (y1 , y2 , t) dy1 dy2 u(0, 0, t) = −Q β |(y1 , y2 )| ∞ 2π ¯ t)(cos µ, sin µ)dµdr = (0, 0). = −Q β ∂r θ(r, 0
0
And so using (7) we obtain an equation for (6), namely ∞ ∞ d θ (x1 , x2 , t) − θ (0, 0, t) d x1 d x2 (8) 2+δ dt 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ γ u ·∇θ θ (x1 , x2 , t)−γ θ (0, 0, t) =− d x d x − d x1 d x2 . 1 2 2+δ 2+δ 0 0 (x 2 + x 2 ) 2 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 1 2
114
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
¯ Since we are only considering radial functions we have θ (x1 , x2 , t) = θ(|x|, t) for some function θ¯ and so ∞ ∞ ∞ ¯ θ (r, t) − θ¯ (0, t) d θ (x1 , x2 , t) − θ (0, 0, t) d d x1 d x2 = 2π dr. 2+δ dt 0 dt 0 r 1+δ 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 In order to handle the dissipative term we will prove the following Lemma 1. Let δ and γ satisfy the conditions of Theorem 1. Given f (x1 , x2 ) = f¯(|x|) a positive, smooth (bounded) radial function, we have ∞ ∞ γ ∞ ¯ f (x1 , x2 ) − γ f (0, 0) f (r ) − f¯(0) d x d x = 2π dr 1 2 2+δ r 1+δ+γ 0 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 ∞ ¯ ( f (r ) − f¯(0))2 c ≤ dr + + c f L ∞ (9) 2+δ r 0 for any positive . Proof. First, using the representation of a fractional derivative as an integral, and the fact that γ (β f ) = γ +β f , we have ∞ ∞ γ ∞ ∞ f (x1 , x2 )−γ f (0, 0) f (x1 , x2 )− f (0, 0) d x d x = d x1 d x2 1 2 2+δ 2+δ+γ 0 0 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 (x12 + x22 ) 2 ∞ ¯ 1 ¯ f (r ) − f¯(0) f (r ) − f¯(0) = 2π dr ≤ 2π dr + c f L ∞ (10) 1+δ+γ r r 1+δ+γ 0 0 1 ¯ f (r ) − f¯(0) 1 dr + c f L ∞ ≤ 2π δ δ 0 r 1+ 2 r 2 +γ ∞ ¯ ( f (r ) − f¯(0))2 c ≤ dr + + c f L ∞ , 2+δ r 0 where we have used the fact that δ + 2γ < 1 for the range of γ and δ we are considering. Remark 3. The need for the inequality δ + 2γ < 1 in the above calculation (to make δ r − 2 −γ be in L 2 [(0, 1)]) is the only reason why we need to restrict to γ < 21 . This restriction on γ seems rather unnatural since the critial exponent is γ = 1 and it just seems to be a limitation of the techniques involved in the proof. In order to analyze the nonlinear term we will establish the following Lemma 2. Given θ and u as above we have ∞ ∞ ∞ u · ∇θ T (θ¯ )(r, t) ∂1 θ¯ (r, t) d x d x = −2π dr, 1 2 2+δ r 1+δ 0 0 0 (x12 + x22 ) 2 where
∞
T f (x) = cos β
f (r )g(
0
and
2π
g(x) = 0
|x| )dr r
cos µ x2
+ 1 − 2x cos µ
dµ
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
115
Proof. Since we are only considering the radial case it is sufficient to compute u · ∇θ at (|x|, 0, t). We have 1
u · ∇θ (|x|, 0, t) = −Q β (−)− 2 ∇θ (|x|, 0, t) · ∇θ (|x|, 0, t) (∂1 θ (y1 , y2 , t), ∂2 θ (y1 , y2 , t)) dy1 dy2 ·∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t)(1, 0) = −Q β |x| y1 0 − y2 ∞ 2π ¯ ∂1 θ (r, t)(cos µ, sin µ) = −Q β r dr dµ · ∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t)(1, 0) |x|2 +r 2 −2|x|r cos µ 0 0 ∞ 2π cos β cos µ − sin β sin µ ¯ =− ∂1 θ (r, t) dµdr ∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t) 0
0
∞
= − cos β
¯ t)g ∂1 θ(r,
0
|x| r
2
+ 1 − 2 |x| r cos µ
|x| dr ∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t) r
= −T (θ¯ )(|x|, t) ∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t), where we have used that 0
And so we have ∞ ∞ − 0
0
(x 2
1
+ 1 − 2x cos µ) 2
u · ∇θ (x12 + x22 )
sin µ
2π
2+δ 2
d x1 d x2 =
∞ ∞
0
0
∞
= 2π 0
dµ = 0.
T (θ¯ )(|x|, t) ∂1 θ¯ (|x|, t) d x1 d x2 |x|2+δ
T (θ¯ )(r, t) ∂1 θ¯ (r, t) dr. r 1+δ
Remark 4. The presence of the factor cos β in the expression for T in the above operator means that the nonlinear term is not present for the cases β = π2 or 3π 2 , making our approach inapplicable for the standard surface quasi geostrophic equation. Using Lemma 1 and 2 we have reduced the problem to the one-dimensional equation d dt
∞ 0
∞ ∞ ¯ ¯ t) − θ¯ (0, t) ¯ t) T (θ¯ )(r, t) ∂1 θ(r, θ(r, θ (r, t)−θ¯ (0, t) dr = dr − dr. r 1+δ r 1+δ r 1+δ+γ 0 0 (11)
To simplify the presentation we have taken κ = 1. It is clear that this has no effect in ¯ )) contains the factor cos β, whose sign depends on β. the result. We remark that T ((θ We will assume without loss of generality that cos β is positive, since otherwise one can consider the equation for −θ . When cos β > 0 we consider positive solutions. ∞¯ θ (r, t) − θ¯ (0, t) We want to prove that dr blows up infinite time. We will use r 1+δ 0 the following theorem to estimate the nonlinear term.
116
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
Theorem 3. Let f ≥ 0 be a smooth, bounded function in [0, ∞). Let β = π2 , 3π 2 , but otherwise arbitrary. Then for every δ in [0, 1), there exists a constant cδ,β , independent of f , such that
∞ 0
T f (x) f (x) d x ≥ cδ,β x 1+δ
∞
( f (x) − f (0))2 d x, x 2+δ
0
(12)
where
∞
T f (x) = cos β 0
|x| dr f (r )g r
and
2π
g(x) =
0
cos µ x2
+ 1 − 2x cos µ
dµ.
Proof. Without loss of generality we will assume that f (0) = 0. Using the Parseval identity for the Mellin Transform we have
∞
0
T f (x) f (x) 1 dx = 1+δ x 2π
∞
−∞
M1 (λ)M2 (λ)dλ,
where
∞
M1 (λ) = M2 (λ) =
0 ∞
1
δ
3
δ
x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x, x iλ− 2 − 2 T f (x)d x.
0
Integrating by parts we obtain ∞ 3 δ 1 δ M1 (λ) = − iλ − − x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x. 2 2 0 As for M2
∞
M2 (λ) =
x 0
= cos β
iλ− 32 − 2δ
∞
∞
cos β ∞
0 ∞ 0 ∞
0 3
δ
3
δ
x iλ− 2 − 2
f (r )g
x
dr d x r x d xdr f (r )g r 3
δ
r iλ− 2 − 2 y iλ− 2 − 2 f (r )g(y)r d ydr 0 0 ∞
∞ 3 δ 3 δ 1 δ y iλ− 2 − 2 g(y)dy − iλ − − r iλ− 2 − 2 f (r )dr . = cos β 2 2 0 0 = cos β
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
117
And so
1 2π
∞
1 M1 (λ)M2 (λ)dλ = 2π −∞
∞
×
3
δ
y −iλ− 2 − 2 g(y)dy
0
1 δ 1 δ iλ − − iλ − − cos β 2 2 2 2 ∞
∞
−∞ 0
∞
3 δ cos β 2 (λ + a 2 ) y −iλ− 2 − 2 g(y)dy 2π 0 ∞ 3 δ x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x dλ, ×
=
3
δ
∞
x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x
∞
3
δ
x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x dλ
0 ∞
−∞ 0
3
δ
x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x
0
where we have defined a = 21 + 2δ . We will prove the following result in the next section above. Then for every λ ∈ R we have (λ2 + a 2 )Re
∞
0
cos µ
2π
Lemma 3 (Main Lemma). Let g(x) =
1
(x 2 + 1 − 2x cos µ) 2
0
3
dµ and a and δ as
δ
y −iλ− 2 − 2 g(y) dy > cδ (1 + |λ|),
where cδ > 0 depends only on δ. We postpone the proof until the next section. Using this result we have ∞ ∞ ∞ T f (x) f (x) 3 δ iλ− 32 − 2δ d x ≥ cδ,β x f (x)d x x iλ− 2 − 2 f (x)d x dλ 1+δ x 0 −∞ 0 0 ∞ ∞ ∞ 1 δ 1 δ eiλx− 2 − 2 x f (e x )d x eiλx− 2 − 2 x f (e x )d xdλ = cδ,β
∞
= cδ,β
−∞ −∞ ∞ −∞
e
− 21 x− 2δ x
−∞
f (e )e x
− 21 x− 2δ x
f (e )d x = cδ,β
∞
x
0
f 2 (y) dy. y 2+δ
Using Lemma 1 and Theorem 3 we have the following estimates for the one dimensional equation (11) d dt
0
∞
∞ ¯ ¯ t) θ¯ (r, t) − θ(0, (θ(r, t) − θ¯ (0, t))2 dr ≥ c dr δ r 1+δ r 2+δ 0 ∞ ¯ (θ (r, t) − θ¯ (0, t))2 c − dr − cθ L ∞ − , 2+δ r 0
118
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
and so choosing = d dt
∞ 0
cδ we have 2
¯ t) − θ¯ (0, t) θ(r, cδ ∞ (θ¯ (r, t) − θ¯ (0, t))2 c dr ≥ dr − cθ L ∞ − 1+δ 2+δ r 2 0 r
∞ 2 ¯ ¯ θ (r, t) − θ (0, t) cδ c ≥ dr − c θ0 L ∞ − , 1+δ 2 r 0
where we have used the fact that since GSQG is an advection-difusion equation we have θ L ∞ ≤ θ0 L ∞ . If we denote by
θ¯ (r, t) − θ¯ (0, t) dr, r 1+δ
∞
J (t) := 0
we have established d J (t) ≥ c1 J (t)2 − c2 (1 + θ0 L ∞ ), dt
(13)
It is obvious that if we choose θ0 ∈ C ∞ (R+ ) with θ0 L ∞ = 1, and ∞ θ0 (x) − θ0 (0) J (0) = dx x 1+δ 0 to be sufficiently large, then J (t) in (13) will blow up in some finite T < ∞, i.e., J (t) → ∞ as t ↑ T . To conclude the proof of the main Theorem 3 we notice that ∞ 1 |θ (r, t) − θ (0, t)| 2 J (t) ≤ sup · + dr 1+δ r 1−δ r 0
2π
g(x) =
0
then for every λ,
λ + 2
1+δ 2
2
Re 0
cos µ x 2 + 1 − 2x cos µ
∞
3
δ
dµ,
y −iλ− 2 − 2 g(y)dy > cδ (1 + |λ|).
(14)
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
119
Proof. Notice that since the expression is even with respect to λ, it is enough to deal with λ > 0. Denote by M(λ) the left hand side of (14) and let a = 1+δ 2 . We will prove ∞ −iλ− 3 − δ 2 2 g(y)dy is always positive, (14) in two stages. We will first prove that Re 0 y and then that it is of order λ1 for large λ. The main tool in the proof is to transform the expression for M(λ) into the cosine transform of some function, and use a general result about positive cosine transforms to prove the lemma. We have M(λ) = (λ + a )Re 2 2 = (λ + a )2 2
2
∞
−∞ ∞
eiλx e−ax g(e x )d x
cos(λy) e−ay g(e y ) + eay g(e−y ) dy.
0
In order to prove the lemma we will use the following sufficient condition for a cosine transform to be positive Theorem 4 (Pólya). Let f : R+ → R be a convex function ( f > 0). Then its cosine transform is always positive. More precisely, for every λ,
∞
f (x) cos(λ x)d x > 0.
(15)
0
Using Pólya’s theorem it is sufficient to prove that W (y) = e−a y g(e y ) + ea y g(e−y )
(16)
is convex for y > 0, since W is trivially strictly positive. A simple calculation yields W (y) = a 2 e−ay g(eay ) + (1 − 2a)e(1−a)y g (e y ) + e(2−a)y g (e y ) +a 2 eay g(e−ay ) + (1 − 2a)e(−1+a)y g (e−y ) + e(2−a)y g (e−y ).
(17)
Since e y is increasing, it is sufficient to prove that a 2 x −a g(x) + (1 − 2a)x 1−a g (x) + x 2−a g (x) 1 1 1 + (1 − 2a)x −1+a g + x −2+a g >0 +a 2 x a g x x x
(18)
for all x > 1 In order to prove the above inequality we will need a deeper analysis of the function g, in particular a representation in terms of hypergeometric functions. Definition 1. We will denote by (Gauss) Hypergeometric Function (F(a, b; c; z)) the solution of the equation
120
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
z(1 − z)F + (c − (a + b + 1)z)F − ab F = 0
(19)
with initial condition F(a, b; c; 0) = 1. The function F has a representation as a power series given by F(a, b; c; z) =
∞ (a)n (b)n z n , (c)n n!
(20)
n=0
where the symbol (a)n is the rising factorial (or Pochhammer symbol) given by a(a + 1) (a + 2) · · · (a + n − 1). Using simple identities it is elementary to obtain the following expression for g: g(x) =
πx 3
(1 + x 2 ) 2
F
3 5 4x 2 , ; 2; 4 4 (1 + x 2 )2
.
(21)
The hypergeometric function involved in the expression of g, that we will denote by F(z), satisfies the equation z(1 − z)F (z) + (2 − 3z)F (z) −
15 F(z) = 0, 16
(22)
4x 2 . (1 + x 2 )2 We will prove (18) by showing that
where z(x) =
a 2 x −a g(x) + (1 − 2a)x 1−a g (x) + x 2−a g (x) > 0
(23)
and a2 x a g
1 1 1 + (1 − 2a)x −1+a g + x −2+a g >0 x x x
(24)
for x > 1. Due to the structure of the expressions involved it is sufficient to prove that (23) is positive for x > 0, x = 1 (notice that g is not defined at 1). We only sketch the result, leaving the details to the interested reader. A simple calculation yields g(x) = g (x) =
x 3
(1 + x 2 ) 2 1 − 2x 2
F, x
F z, (25) 3 (1 + x 2 ) 2 2 x x −9x + 6x 3 2 − 4x F+ z +z F , F + (z )2 g (x) = 7 3 3 5 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 (1 + x ) (1 + x ) (1 + x ) (1 + x ) (1 + x 2 )
5 2
F+
Blow Up for the Generalized Surface Quasi-Geostrophic Equation
121 3
and so (23) becomes (after multiplying both sides by (1 + x 2 ) 2 x a−1
1 − 2x 2 −9x + 6x 3 2 0 < F a + (1 − 2a) +x 1 + x2 (1 + x 2 )2 +F
(26)
2 − 4x 2 2 (1 − 2a)x z + z x + z x + F (z )2 x 2 . 1 + x2
Using (22) we have F=
16 z(1 − z)F + (2 − 3z)F 15
and so (27) becomes 0 < F I + F I I,
(27)
where I := (1 − 2a)x z + z x
2 − 4x 2 + z x 2 1 + x2
16 1 − 2x 2 −9x + 6x 3 + x (2 − 3z) a 2 + (1 − 2a) 15 1 + x2 (1 + x 2 )2
16 1 − 2x 2 −9x + 6x 3 2 2 2 . I I := (z ) x + z(1 − z) a + (1 − 2a) +x 15 1 + x2 (1 + x 2 )2 +
In order to complete the proof, we make two simple observations. First I I ≥ 0, and second (1 − z)F > F > 0. The first one is just a simple calculation, using the fact that 1 2 ≤ a < 1, while the second can be easily verified using the power series expansion for F. Then (27) becomes 0 < F [I (1 − z) + I I ],
(28)
and a simple calculation yields I (1 − z) + I I > 0, for x > 0, x = 0, completing the argument. In order to complete the argument we note that ∞ 3 δ 1 . Re y −iλ− 2 − 2 g(y)dy = O λ 0 The reason for this is that g is not smooth, and actually has a (mild) singularity at 1. The contribution outside a neighborhood of 1 is O(λ−l ) for any positive l (this can be proved by using a smooth cut-off function and a localization argument). We analyze the contribution of an interval around 1. It is easy to see that near 1, g(x) ≈ −2Log(|1 − x|). We also have
3 2 1 cos(λ x)2Log(|1 − x|)d x = O 1 λ 2
for large λ. We leave the details of the calculation to the reader.
122
D. Li, J. Rodrigo
4. Generalized Interpolating Models We sketch the modification to the arguments in the previous sections in order to handle the generalized interpolation models. Recall that the main difference is the fact that the velocity is now given by α
u = −Q β (−)−(1− 2 ) ∇θ, Proceeding as above we obtain Eq. (8) Since there have been no changes in the dissipation term, we will obtain an estimate by Lemma 1. For the nonlinear term we have a new version of Lemma 2. We have Lemma 5. −
∞ ∞ 0
0
u · ∇θ (x12
+
2+δ x22 ) 2
d x1 d x2 = −2π 0