Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 1–23 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0204-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations in General Relativity Adrian Butscher Department of Mathematics, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M1C 1A4, Canada. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 26 June 2003 / Accepted: 4 October 2006 Published online: 7 March 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: The extended constraint equations arise as a special case of the conformal constraint equations that are satisfied by an initial data hypersurface Z in an asymptotically simple space-time satisfying the vacuum conformal Einstein equations developed by H. Friedrich. The extended constraint equations consist of a quasi-linear system of partial differential equations for the induced metric, the second fundamental form and two other tensorial quantities defined on Z, and are equivalent to the usual constraint equations that Z satisfies as a space-like hypersurface in a space-time satisfying Einstein’s vacuum equation. This article develops a method for finding perturbative, asymptotically flat solutions of the extended constraint equations in a neighbourhood of the flat solution on Euclidean space. This method is fundamentally different from the ‘classical’ method of Lichnerowicz and York that is used to solve the usual constraint equations.
1. Introduction The notion of an asymptotically simple space-time was first proposed by Penrose in the 1960s as a means for studying the asymptotic properties of isolated solutions of Einstein’s equations in General Relativity [15]. The central idea is to define a class of space-times which are conformally diffeomorphic to the interior of a Lorentz manifold with boundary, called the unphysical space-time, where the boundary is identified in a certain way with points at infinity in the original space-time. Einstein’s vacuum equations can be rephrased in terms of this construction and can be used to describe the metric and conformal boundary of the conformally rescaled space-time. However, this description is rather awkward in some respects because of the following phenomenon. The metric g of the unphysical space-time is related to the metric g˜ of the original spacetime by g˜ = −2 g, where the conformal factor vanishes at the boundary (thereby encoding the fact that the boundary is at infinite distance). Consequently, Einstein’s
2
A. Butscher
equation in the unphysical space-time is Ric(−2 g) = 0, which degenerates at the boundary. Helmut Friedrich has developed a new approach for the mathematical description of the unphysical space-time, known as the conformal Einstein equations, which avoids this difficulty. The reader is asked to consult [9–11] for a review of these ideas. Essentially, Friedrich has discovered equations which are equivalent to Einstein’s equations in the unphysical space-time but which do not degenerate at the boundary. Using these equations, Friedrich has made significant steps in the development of the Penrose model of asymptotic simplicity; in particular, he has been able to prove the first semi-global existence and stability results for the Cauchy problem of evolving such space-times from initial data. Semi-global in this context means that, starting with so-called asymptotically hyperbolic initial data, it is possible to generate the entire future development of the data under Cauchy evolution, all the way up to time-like infinity. Recently, thanks to work of Corvino [8] and Chru´sciel and Delay [7], this result has been extended to a global existence result, in which a large class of asymptotically simple space-times can be constructed by Cauchy evolution from asymptotically flat initial data. As is well known, the Cauchy problem near a space-like hypersurface Z consists of splitting Einstein’s equations into constraint equations satisfied by initial data on Z and evolution equations that describe how the initial data evolve in time to produce a space-time neighbourhood around Z. The conformal Einstein equations also admit such a Cauchy problem. Indeed, given a space-like hypersurface Z in the unphysical spacetime, one can deduce a system of constraint equations and evolution equations for initial data on Z. The constraint equations on Z that arise in this way are called the conformal constraint equations. The conformal constraint equations are far more complex than the ‘usual’ constraint equations satisfied by the hypersurface Z when it is seen as an infinitely extended, spacelike hypersurface of the original space-time. The reason is that the conformal constraint equations combine two sub-structures — namely ‘geometric’ constraints (i.e. resulting from the Gauss-Codazzi equations) and a boundary value problem at the boundary of Z — in a highly coupled and non-linear way. Although general techniques do not yet exist for analyzing these equations, there is one approach which may be fruitful: to tackle these two sub-structures individually and in isolation from one another by considering special cases. The hope is that the knowledge gained in this way can be re-assembled in order to develop an understanding of the equations in more general cases. Just such an approach has been commenced by the author in [3] and is extended in this article. The Extended Constraint Equations. In the author’s previous paper [3], the Ansatz ≡ 1 is used to eliminate the boundary value problem for and bring the ‘geometric’ constraint problem to the forefront. This happens because the Ansatz ≡ 1 essentially assumes that the conformal rescaling is trivial so that Z is a boundaryless space-like hypersurface in the original space-time. The system of equations which results from this Ansatz reduces the conformal constraint equations considerably. The only remaining unknowns are the induced metric g and the second fundamental form χ of Z, as well as the so-called electric part S and the magnetic part S¯ of the Weyl tensor W of the space-time relative to the 3 + 1 splitting induced by Z. (That is, Sab = Wa00b is the electric part of W and S¯ab = εast Wb0st is the magnetic part of W , where εabc is the fully antisymmetric permutation symbol associated to the metric g.) Note that both S and S¯ are trace-free and symmetric. Explicitly, the conformal constraint equations reduce to the following system under the ≡ 1 Ansatz, called the extended constraint equations:
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
3
e ¯ ∇c χab − ∇b χac = εbc Sae , a¯ bc a ∇ Sae = εe χ Rac , b
Rab = Sab − χcc χab + χac χcb , ∇ a Sab = −χ ac εe S¯ae ,
(1)
bc
where ∇ is the covariant derivative of the metric g and Rab (g) is its Ricci curvature. (Actually, (1) is a slightly different yet equivalent formulation of the extended constraint equations found in [3].) As equations involving the metric g and the second fundamental form χ of the space-like hypersurface Z in the original space-time, one expects the extended constraint equations to be related in some way to the ‘usual’ constraint equations satisfied by g and χ . In fact, the following lemma shows that the extended constraint equations are fully equivalent to the usual constraint equations. Lemma 1. Let Z be a space-like hypersurface in the original space-time having induced metric g and second fundamental form χ . Then g and χ satisfy the usual constraint equations on Z if and only if g and χ , along with two tensors S and S¯ defined via Sab ≡ Rab (g) + χcc χab − χac χcb and S¯ae ≡ εebc ∇c χab satisfy the extended constraint equations. ¯ satisfy (1). Then by taking traces in the first and Proof. Suppose first that (g, χ , S, S) third equations, one obtains the usual constraint equations, namely that R = χbc χcb − (χcc )2 and 0 = ∇ c χcb − ∇b χcc . Next suppose that g and χ satisfy the usual constraint equations. Let S and S¯ be defined as in the hypotheses of the lemma, in which case the desired symmetries of S and S¯ follow from the constraint equations and the first and third equations of (1) follow automatically. Some simple calculations are now needed to show that the second and fourth equations also hold. First, the Bianchi identity for the Ricci curvature states ∇ a Rab − 21 ∇b R = 0. Substitute for Rab and R using the definition of S to derive 1 0 = ∇ a Sab − χ cc χ ab + χ ac χ cb − ∇b − (χ cc )2 + χ ac χ ac 2 = ∇ a Sab − χ cc δba − χ ab h uv S¯uav + χ ac S¯abc ,
(2)
where S¯abc is the dual of the tensor S¯ae defined by S¯abc ≡ ∇c χab − ∇b χac . By symmetry, the middle term in (2) vanishes, leaving 0 = ∇ a Sab + χ ac S¯abc , which is exactly the fourth equation of (1) when written in terms of this dual. ¯ That is, Next, consider the commutator of the second covariant derivatives of S. εebc ∇e S¯abc = 2εebc ∇e ∇c χ ab = εebc ∇e ∇c χ ab − ∇c ∇e χ ab s χ = εebc Reca sb
(3)
using the symmetries of Rabcd . Substitute in (3) the well-known decomposition s Reca = gea Rcs − δes Rca + δcs Rea − gca Res −
1 R gea δcs − δes gca , 2
4
A. Butscher
of the curvature tensor in three dimensions to obtain εebc ∇e S¯abc = 2εabc χ sb Rcs .
(4)
The second equation of (1) is now a consequence of (4) after invoking the symmetries of S¯ once again. The proof of Lemma 1 reveals an important feature of the extended constraint equations that will be exploited in a crucial way in the proof of the Main Theorem of this paper. Indeed, the calculations above show that the extended constraint equations break up into two pairs of equations, each consisting of a primary ‘geometric’ equation along with its integrability condition, i.e. an equation derived from the primary one by commuting covariant derivatives. This is explicitly true of the second equation of (1) but it is also true of the fourth equation since the Bianchi identity is the integrability condition for the Riemann curvature tensor. Remark. Another way of thinking about this system of equations, given that S and S¯ are the electric and magnetic parts of the Weyl tensor, is that (1) is equivalent to the vanishing of the full four-dimensional Ricci tensor along Z. The Statement of the Main Theorem. The extended constraint equations given in (1) are still too complicated to solve for general initial data on general non-compact, boundaryless space-like hypersurfaces in an infinitely extended space-time. An appropriate simplification is to consider perturbative solutions near a given known solution. An obvious known solution of the equations is the trivial solution in which Z = R3 and g = δ (the Euclidean metric) along with χ = S = S¯ = 0. This paper will therefore investigate the nature of a certain class of perturbative solutions of the extended constraint equations decaying asymptotically to this trivial solution and ‘near’ it in some appropriate sense. In [3], an approach for producing such solutions was developed under the further simplifying assumption of vanishing second fundamental form (the so-called time-symmetric case). The present paper will extend the approach used there to the full, non-time-symmetric case. (Note: perturbations near general asymptotically flat metrics on more general asymptotically flat manifolds will not be considered here.) The Main Theorem to be proved in this paper is the following. Main Theorem. There exists an infinite-dimensional Banach space B of so-called free data consisting of triples (T, T¯ , φ), where T , T¯ are symmetric, δ-trace-free and δ-divergence-free two-tensors on R3 and φ is a function on R3 , which parametrizes solutions of the extended constraint equations near the trivial solution as follows. 1. For every triple (T, T¯ , φ) whose norm is sufficiently small, there is a unique solu¯ of the extended constraint equations that is an asymptotically flat tion (g, χ , S, S) perturbation of the trivial solution g = δ and χ = S = S¯ = 0 (in a sense to be defined later in this paper). 2. The point (0, 0, 0) ∈ B corresponds to the trivial solution. 3. The association of triples (T, T¯ , φ) to solutions maps onto a neighbourhood of the trivial solution.
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
5
Furthermore, the map taking (T, T¯ , φ) to the solution of the extended constraint equations is smooth in the sense of Banach spaces. Sketch of Proof. The Main Theorem will be proved by applying the Implicit Function Theorem to the extended constraint equations in a suitable way. But because these equations are not fully-determined elliptic equations, it is not possible to apply this theorem in a simple-minded way. Rather, a two-step approach must be used. The first step, called Theorem A in this paper, consists of deriving and solving a related system of equations which is fully-determined elliptic. This system will be called the secondary system, and it will be shown that it determines the quantities g, χ , S and S¯ uniquely in terms of certain free data in a Banach space B provided the norm of the free data is sufficiently small. These solutions are of course not a priori solutions of the extended constraint equations and thus it is still necessary to prove that a solution found in Theorem A is also a solution of the extended constraint equations. This second step of the proof is called Theorem B in this paper; it asserts that solutions of Theorem A are solutions of the extended constraint equations. A surprising technical difficulty arises in the proof of Theorem A. In order to prove the existence of solutions via the Implicit Function Theorem, one must study the linearization of the secondary system at the trivial solution and show that it is bijective. However, the fact of the matter is that this operator is injective but not surjective. Consequently, it is possible only to solve the secondary system up to an error term belonging to the co-kernel of the linearization (which is finite-dimensional by Fredholm theory). This error term may be non-zero, and its presence complicates the proof of Theorem B. However, the lack of surjectivity is really an artifact of the two-step method of the proof of the Main Theorem, since the integrability conditions are exploited in a subtle way in Theorem B to prove that the potential error terms produced in Theorem A must in fact be zero at the same time that the solution found in Theorem A does indeed satisfy the extended constraint equations. The nature of the free data of the Main Theorem can be characterized as follows. Recall first that the extended constraints are equivalent to the usual Einstein constraint equations, so that the method outlined above for solving the extended constraints can be interpreted as a completely new method, different from the ‘classical’ LichnerowiczYork method, for solving the usual constraint equations. In the classical method (under the assumption of constant mean curvature), one freely prescribes a metric g0 (without loss of generality whose components have unit determinant) and a symmetric tensor χ0 , divergence free with respect to g0 , on R3 . The number of ‘freely prescribable’ functions for data defined in this way is thus seven, or four if one first makes a specific choice of coordinates. Then, one considers the conformally rescaled metric g = u 4 g0 , where u : R3 → R is an unknown function, and reduces the constraint equations to a semi-linear elliptic equation for u. Once this equation is solved, a further rescaling of χ0 yields a tensor χ which is trace-free and divergence-free with respect to g. The Lichnerowicz-York method thus produces a solution (g, χ ) in terms of the four degrees of freedom represented by g0 and χ0 . In contrast, the present method treats the metric g and certain components of χ , S and S¯ as the unknowns and leads to a quasi-linear elliptic system for these quantities that will be solved in terms of totally different free data. In the derivation of the secondary system in Sect. 2.4, it will be shown that the free data consists of certain components of the curvature of g, amounting to four degrees of freedom, along with a single degree of freedom corresponding to the trace of the second fundamental form (which is absent in the Lichnerowicz-York solution since the mean curvature is kept constant there).
6
A. Butscher
2. Preliminaries 2.1. Spaces of tensors and tensor operators. For the sake of convenience, it is worthwhile to assign names to the various tensors spaces and tensor operators that appear in (1) and elsewhere in this paper. Suppose M is any Riemannian manifold with metric g. Let S(M) denote the space of symmetric two-tensors over M and let Sg (M) denote the symmetric two-tensors of M that are in addition trace-free with respect to g. Additionally, let 1 (M) denote the oneforms of M. Finally, let J (M) denote those three-tensors which possess the symmetries Jabc + Jcab + Jbca = 0 and Jabc + Jacb = 0. Such tensors will make an appearance at one point in this paper. Next, define the following operators: • divg : S 2 (M) → 1 (M), given in local coordinates by [divg (S)]b = ∇ a Sab ; • Ric : S 2 (M) → S 2 (M), given in local coordinates by [Ric(g)]ab = Rab (g). This is naturally only defined on the non-degenerate symmetric tensors. These operators appear in the system (1). The following additional operators will play an important role in the sequel. First, there are the operators • Dg : S 2 (M) → J (M), given in local coordinates by [Dg (χ )]abc = ∇c χab −∇b χac ; • Qg : J (M) → 1 (M) defined in local coordinates by [Qg (J )]a = εebc ∇e Jabc , which will be used in exploiting the integrability conditions built into the extended constraint equations. Second, there are the formal adjoints (up to numerical factors) of the operators Dg and divg , given by: • Dg∗ : J (M) → Sg (M), given by [Dg∗ (J )]ac = ∇ b Jabc + ∇ b Jcba − 23 ∇ b Jubv g uv gac . Note that the adjoint of the restriction of the operator Dg to the space Sg (M) is being given here. • div∗g : 1 (M) → Sg (M), given by [div∗g (X )]ac = ∇a X c + ∇c X a − 23 ∇ b X b gac . Note that this operator is also known as the conformal Killing operator. It is a simple matter of calculating these adjoints by means of the integration by parts formula for covariant derivatives and so this will not be carried out here. 2.2. Weighted Sobolev spaces. In order to proceed with the solution of the extended constraint equations, it is first necessary to specify in what Banach spaces the various unknown quantities lie. The notion of asymptotic flatness in R3 should be encoded rigorously into these spaces by requiring that the relevant objects belong to a space of tensors with built-in control at infinity. Furthermore, the spaces should be chosen to exploit the Fredholm properties of the operators above. Both these ends will be served by weighted Sobolev spaces, whose definition and some of whose properties will be given in this section as a reminder to the reader (details can be found in such works as [2, 4–6, 12, 13]). The actual choice of Banach spaces in which the solutions of the Main Theorem will be found will then be given in the next section. Let T be any tensor on R3 . (This tensor may be of any order — the norm · appearing in the following definition is then simply the norm on such tensors that is induced from the Euclidean metric of R3 . Note that the following definitions can also be made for general metrics on R3 but this will not be necessary in this paper.) The H k,β Sobolev norm of T is the quantity k 1/2 l 2 −2(β−l)−3 T H k,β = D T σ , l=0
R3
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
7
where σ (x) = (1 + r 2 )1/2 is the weight function and r 2 = (x 1 )2 + (x 2 )2 + (x 3 )2 is the squared distance to the origin. Note that Bartnik’s convention [2] for the power of σ in the definition of the weighted spaces is being used (the reason for this is psychological: if f ∈ H k,β and f is smooth enough to invoke the Sobolev Embedding Theorem (again, see [2]), then f (x) = o(r β ) as r → ∞, which is easy to remember). The space of H k,β functions of R3 will be denoted by H k,β (R3 ) and the space of k,β H sections of a tensor bundle B over R3 will be denoted by H k,β (B). As an abbreviation, or where the context makes the bundle clear, such a space may be indicated simply by H k,β . Note also that the following convention for integration will be used in the rest of this paper. An integral of the form R3 f , as in the definition above, denotes an integral of f with respect to the standard Euclidean volume form. Integrals of quantities with respect to the volume form of a different metric will be indicated explicitly, as, for example, R3 f dVolg . Constant-coefficient elliptic partial differential operators acting on spaces of H k,β tensors satisfy several important analytic properties, and two of these will be used in a crucial way in the sequel. The first property is a characterization of the kernels and co-kernels of such operators that will be used in Theorem A. The second property concerns the stability of the co-kernels of these operators that will be used in Theorem B. Proposition 2 (Kernel/Co-Kernel). Let B be a tensor bundle over R3 and let Q : H k,β (B) → H k−2,β−2 (B) any linear, second order, homogeneous, elliptic partial differential operator with constant coefficients, where β ∈ Z, and k ≥ 2. Denote by Ker(Q : β) the kernel of Q acting on H k,β . Then the following is true: 1. Q is Fredholm; 2. Q is injective if β < 0 and surjective if β > −1; 3. If β > 0, then Ker(Q : β) consists of polynomials of degree equal to the integer part of β and has non-zero, finite dimension. 4. If β < −1, then the image of Q is the space Im(Q) = y ∈ H k−2,β−2 (B) : y, z = 0 ∀ z ∈ K er (Q ∗ : −β − 1) , R3
where Q ∗ is the formal adjoint of Q. The image thus has non-zero finite codimension. Proof. The fact that the operator Q is Fredholm and has finite dimensional kernel and co-kernel is a classical result that can be found in [12, 14]. Standard Schauder theory then asserts that any solution of the equation Q(u) = 0 is smooth, and if it has polynomial growth or decay at infinity, then it is a polynomial or is zero, respectively. The characterization of the image of Q as the orthogonal complement of the kernel of the adjoint Q ∗ is elementary functional analysis. An excellent source for understanding the motivation behind this theorem can be found in [13] in which the behaviour of the Laplace operator on Rn is explained. Proposition 3 (Stability). Let B be any tensor bundle over R3 and let Q ε : H k,β (B) → H k−2,β−2 (B), ε ∈ [0, 1], be a continuous family of linear, elliptic operators. Furthermore, suppose that Q ε is uniformly injective; i. e. there is a constant C independent of ε so that Q ε (y) H k−2,β−2 ≥ Cy H k,β . Finally, suppose C is a finite-dimensional linear subspace of H k−2,β−2 (B). If C ∩ Im(Q 0 ) = {0}, then there exists ε0 > 0 so that C ∩ Im(Q ε ) = {0} for all ε < ε0 .
8
A. Butscher
Proof. Suppose that this proposition is false; that is, for every ε > 0, let z ε be a non-zero element of C ∩ Im(Q ε ) and without loss of generality, it is possible to take z ε H k−2,β−2 = 1. Since z ε ∈ C for every ε, the finite-dimensionality of C implies that there is a subsequence ε j → 0 and z ε j ≡ z j that converges in the H k−2,β−2 norm to a non-zero element z ∈ C, with z H k−2,β−2 = 1. Furthermore, since z j ∈ Im(Q j ), there is an element y j ∈ H k,β (B) so that Q j (y j ) = z j . Claim. There is y ∈ H k,β (B) so that y j → y and Q 0 (y) = z. First, by the uniform injectivity of Q j , y j H k,β ≤ Cz j H k−2,β−2 = C,
(5)
so that the sequence y j is uniformly bounded in H k,β . Next, by the injectivity of the operator Q 0 , yi − y j H k,β ≤ CQ 0 (yi − y j ) H k−2,β−2 ≤ C (Q 0 − Q i )(yi ) H k−2,β−2 + Q i (yi ) − Q j (y j ) H k−2,β−2 + (Q 0 − Q j )(y j ) H k−2,β−2 ≤ C Q 0 − Q i op + z i − z j H k−2,β−2 + Q j − Q 0 op
(6)
by (5), where · op denotes the operator norm in the space of linear operators on H k−2,β−2 (B). Now the first and last terms in (6) go to zero with sufficiently large i and j because the family Q ε is continuous, while the middle term goes to zero by construction. Hence the sequence y j is Cauchy in H k,β and thus converges to an element y ∈ H k,β (B). By similar estimates as above, it is straightforward to show that z − Q 0 (y) H k−2,β−2 is zero. Thus z = Q 0 (y). But z is a non-zero element in C ∩ Im(Q 0 ). This contradicts the hypotheses of the theorem. 2.3. Choosing the Banach spaces. Solutions of the extended constraint equations will be found in the following Banach spaces. Pick any β ∈ (−1, 0) and any k ≥ 4. Then choose: • metrics δ + h so that h ∈ H k,β S 2 (R3 ) ; • tensors χ in H k−1,β−1 S 2 (R3 ) ; • tensors S and S¯ in H k−2,β−2 Sg2 (R3 ) . The preceding choice of Banach spaces is necessitated by the following two considerations. First, in order to ensure that the metric δ + h is asymptotically flat, h must decay as r → ∞, and this holds by the Sobolev Embedding Theorem when β < 0. Next, a non-trivial, asymptotically flat metric satisfying the constraint equations must satisfy the Positive Mass Theorem [16] and consequently must have non-zero ADM mass. Thus the r −1 term in the asymptotic expansion of h must be allowed to be non-zero, which imposes the further requirement that β > −1. Then, as a consequence of the choice made for h, the χ , S and S¯ quantities must be chosen as above because of the differing numbers of derivatives taken on these quantities in the equations (1): since the equations are meant to define maps between weighted Sobolev spaces, the weightings on χ and S and S¯ must match together properly and match the weighting on the metric δ + h. (For example, the Ricci curvature operator is of degree two and sends a metric δ + h with
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
9
h ∈ H k,β to a tensor in H k−2,β−2 . Thus S must lie in H k−2,β−2 to match Ric(δ + h).) Finally, k ≥ 4 is required in order to apply the Sobolev Embedding Theorem at one stage of the proof of the Main Theorem. Remark. One issue has been glossed over in the previous paragraph, and this is the effect of the non-linear terms. Because of this, for example, it is not immediately obvious that Ric(δ + h) is in H k−2,β−2 when h ∈ H k,β because this expression involves products of the metric and its first and second derivatives. However, the Multiplication Theorem for weighted Sobolev spaces [5] implies that the choice for β and k made above ensures that the various Banach spaces are in fact Banach algebras, and so this is not a problem.
2.4. The secondary system to be used in Theorem A. The first step of the proof of the Main Theorem is to derive and solve a secondary system of equations that is related to the extended constraint equations in a clever way. The key modification is that the secondary system is fully-determined and elliptic. The secondary system will be given immediately to streamline the presentation. The objects that will appear in the definition of the secondary system are these. 1. Let ST T (R3 ) denote the space of symmetric, δ-trace-free and δ-divergence-free two-tensors and define the map σ : H k−1,β−1 1 (R3 ) × H k−2,β−2 ST2 T (R3 ) → H k−2,β−2 Sg2 (R3 )
(7)
by σ (V, W ) = div∗g (V ) + W − 13 Tr g (W )g. Then put S(X, T ) = σ (X, T ) and ¯ X¯ , T¯ ) = σ ( X¯ , T¯ ). S( 2. Define the map χ : H k−1,β−1 Sδ2 (R3 ) × H k−1,β−1 (R3 ) → H k−1,β−1 S 2 (R3 ) via χ (K , φ) = K + 13 φδ. 3. Let Ric H (g) denote the formal expression of the Ricci curvature of a metric g in harmonic coordinates. In local coordinates, this is given by 1 H Rab = Rab + ( a;b + b;a ), 2
(8)
a and a are the Christoffel symbols of g. where a = g st st st
The secondary system can now be defined as follows. ¯ X¯ , T¯ ) and Definition 4. Let g = δ + h be the metric of R3 and let S = S(X, T ), S¯ = S( χ = χ (K , φ) be as above. Then the secondary system is:
Dg∗ Dg (χ ) − S¯ = 0, ab
st u ¯ − εa χs Rut (g) = 0, divg ( S) (9)
a Ric H (δ + h) − Sab + χss χab − χas χbs = 0, ab
u ¯ divg (S) a + χ st εat Ssu = 0, e . where S¯ denotes the tensor given in local coordinates by S¯ae εbc
10
A. Butscher
Motivation for the secondary system. Each equation of (1) has a corresponding equation in (9) and the motivation behind each of these equations will be given in turn. Begin by considering the first equation of (1). In [3], it was found that the symbol of this equation has a one dimensional kernel consisting of symmetric, pure-trace tensors. The symbol is thus injective when restricted to the space of symmetric, trace-free tensors and thus the equation is over-determined elliptic when so restricted. A related fully-determined elliptic equation can thus be derived as follows. First, one decomposes χ into its trace and trace-free parts (with respect to the metric δ) as χ = K + 13 φg and substitutes this into the first equation of (1). One then composes both sides of this equation with the adjoint of the operator Dg , so that the resulting equation contains the operator Dg∗ ◦ Dg , which is elliptic on K (the injectivity of the symbol of Dg implies the bijectivity of the symbol of Dg∗ ◦ Dg by straightforward algebra). Therefore K should be viewed as the unknown quantity in this equation and φ should be viewed as a free datum. Note that the correspondence between pairs (K , φ) and tensors χ is bijective. Now consider the second and fourth equations of (1). Again, in [3], both these equations contain the operator divg which has surjective symbol, making it under-determined elliptic. One should thus imagine that each of these equations determines only ¯ say in some direct sum decomposition, while part of the unknown tensors S and S, leaving the other part free. This idea is implemented by using a modified version of the well-known York decomposition of trace-free, symmetric tensors in the form of the mapping σ . This is needed to guarantee the uniqueness of the solutions of the extended constraint equations. (The modification is that traces and divergences are being taken with respect to the fixed metric δ rather than the solution metric g whenever the tensors in question correspond to free data.) One can easily check that σ is a bijection. Substituting this decomposition into the second and fourth equations of (1) yields the second and fourth equations of the secondary system, and the operators divg ◦ div∗g (X ) and divg ◦ div∗g ( X¯ ) appearing there are elliptic on X and X¯ (again, the surjectivity of the symbol of divg implies the bijectivity of the symbol of divg ◦ div∗g ). Therefore X and X¯ should once again be viewed as the unknowns in these equations and T and ¯ and (X, X¯ , T, T¯ ) is T¯ can be treated as free data. The correspondence between (S, S) bijective. Finally, consider the third and remaining equation of (1). As pointed out in [3], it is a well-known fact that the Ricci operator is not elliptic on h because of its gauge invariance. Again as in [3], the standard trick of using harmonic coordinates will be employed to break the gauge invariance. Recall that such coordinates x a are defined by the requirement that g x a = 0 for each a, making the x a harmonic functions. Under this coordinate condition, the Ricci operator can be written as in (8) with a = 0 and that
1 H Rab = − gr s gab,r s + q(Dg), 2
(10)
where q(Dg) denotes a term that is quadratic in the first derivatives of the components of g. The operator Ric H is clearly elliptic when acting on g. The third and remaining equation of the secondary system, then, is obtained simply by replacing the Ricci operator in (1) by its formal expression in harmonic coordinates.
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
11
3. Statement and Proof of Theorem A 3.1. The statement. The Implicit Function Theorem will be used to solve the secondary system near the trivial solution and so it is restated here for ease of reference. For an excellent discussion and proof of this theorem, see [1]. Implicit Function Theorem. Let : X × B → Y be a smooth map between Banach spaces and suppose that (0; 0) = 0. If the restricted linearized operator D (0; 0)X ×{0} : X → Y is an isomorphism, then there exists an open set U ⊂ B contain ing 0 and a smooth function ψ : U → X with ψ(0) = 0 so that ψ(b), b = 0. The Implicit Function Theorem allows solutions of the equation (x, b) = 0, with (x, b) sufficiently close to (0; 0) in the Banach space norm of X × B to be parametrized over the Banach space B of free data. To apply this theorem to the secondary system, identify the three Banach spaces X , B and Y with the space of unknown quantities (h, K , X, X¯ ) appearing in the secondary system (9), the space of free data (T, T¯ , φ) appearing there, and the space corresponding to the range of the secondary system, respectively. That is, define X = H k,β S 2 (R3 ) × H k−1,β−1 Sδ2 (R3 ) ×H k−1,β−1 1 (R3 ) × H k−1,β−1 1 (R3 ) , B = H k−2,β−2 ST2 T (R3 ) × H k−2,β−2 ST2 T (R3 ) × H k−1,β−1 (R3 ), Y = H k−2,β−2 Sg2 (R3 ) × H k−3,β−3 1 (R3 ) × H k−2,β−2 S 2 (R3 ) ×H k−3,β−3 1 (R3 ) . Now use the secondary system to define a map : X × B → Y by
⎛ ⎞ Dg∗ Dg (χ ) − S¯ ab
⎜ ⎟ ¯ ⎜ ⎟ divg ( S) − εast χsu Rut (g) (h, K , X, X¯ ; T, T¯ , φ) = ⎜ a ⎟, ⎝ Ric H (δ + h) − Sab + χss χab − χas χbs ⎠ ab
u S¯ . divg (S) a + χ st εat su
(11)
¯ X¯ , T¯ ) and χ (K , φ) are as in Definition 4. where g = δ + h and S(X, T ), S( The map is a well-defined map of Banach spaces by the considerations of Sect. 2.3 (and the remark made there about non-linear terms) and is clearly smooth. Since the flat solution g = δ and χ = S = S¯ = 0 satisfies the extended constraint equations, (0; 0) = 0, and any other asymptotically flat solution of the secondary system satisfies (h, K , X, X¯ ; T, T¯ , φ) = 0. The first theorem to be proved in this paper is the following. Theorem A. Let : X × B → Y be the map of Banach manifolds corresponding to the secondary system given above. Then there is a neighbourhood U of zero in B and a smooth map of Banach manifolds ψ : U → X with ψ(0) = 0 so that for each b ∈ U, the point (ψ(b), b) solves the secondary system up to a finite dimensional error. In other words, there is a finite-dimensional linear subspace C ⊆ Y such that (ψ(b), b) ∈ C. Furthermore, the map ψ is injective. 3.2. The proof. Analysis of the linearization The first step of the proof is to show that the linearization of in the X directions at the origin is Fredholm and to find its kernel and co-kernel. This begins with a lemma.
12
A. Butscher
Lemma 5. The operator divδ ◦ div∗δ : H k−1,β−1 1 (R3 ) → H k−3,β−3 1 (R3 ) is Fredholm and injective with image equal to the codimension-3 space 1 3 a k−3,β−3 I1 = X = X a dx ∈ H Xa = 0 ∀ a . (R ) : R3
2 3 Sδ (R ) → H k−3,β−3 Sδ2 (R3 ) is ◦ Dδ : Furthermore, the operator Fredholm and injective with image equal to the codimension-5 space I2 = T = Ti j dx i ⊕ dx j ∈ H k−3,β−3 Sδ2 (R3 ) : Ti j = 0 ∀ i, j . Dδ∗
H k−1,β−1
R3
Here, x i are the standard coordinate functions on R3 . Proof. This lemma follows from Proposition 2 on the mapping properties of the linear, homogeneous elliptic operators with constant coefficients, since divδ ◦ div∗δ and Dδ∗ ◦ Dδ are such operators. It is necessary only to identify the kernels of these operators and the kernels of their adjoints. Note that this task is simplified somewhat, since these operators are formally self-adjoint. Let P be any constant-coefficient elliptic operator on R3 . By Proposition 2 the components of a solution of Pu = 0 with growth or decay at infinity are polynomials of degrees less than or equal to the growth rate, or zero, respectively. The operators considered by the lemma are thus injective since β ∈ (−1, 0). Furthermore, β ∈ (−1, 0) implies that −β − 1 ∈ (0, 1) and so the tensors in the kernels of the adjoints of these operators have components that are polynomials of degree zero. That is, these components must all be constants. Consequently, the images of the operators considered in the lemma are tensors orthogonal to the constant 1-forms λi dx i (λi ∈ R for all i) and the constant trace-free symmetric tensors µi j dx i ⊕ dx j (µi j ∈ R for each i, j and δ i j µi j = 0), respectively. The dimension of each of these spaces is obviously 3 and 5, respectively. Proposition 6. The linearized operator P ≡ D (0; 0)X ×{0} in the X directions is given by ⎛ ∗ ⎞ Dδ Dδ (K ) − div∗δ ( X¯ ) ⎟ ⎜ divδ ◦ div∗δ ( X¯ ) ⎟ (12) P(h, K , X, X¯ ) = ⎜ ⎝ − 1 δ h − div∗ (X ) ⎠ , δ 2 divδ ◦ div∗δ (X ) where δ is the Laplacian corresponding to the Euclidean metric. The principal symbol of P is bijective, making P an elliptic operator of Banach spaces. Furthermore, P is Fredholm and injective with image equal to the codimension-11 space Im(P) = I2 × I1 × H k−2,β−2 S 2 (R3 ) × I1 , where I1 and I2 are the spaces defined in Lemma 5. Proof. One can break up the calculation of the linearization into two pieces: P(h, K , X, X¯ ) = D (0; 0)(h, 0, 0, 0; 0) + D (0; 0)(0, K , X, X¯ ; 0). First,
⎞ Dδ∗ Dδ (K ) − div∗δ ( X¯ ) ⎟ ⎜ divδ ◦ div∗δ ( X¯ ) ⎟ D (0; 0)(0, K , X, X¯ ; 0) = ⎜ ∗ ⎠ ⎝ −divδ (X ) divδ ◦ div∗δ (X ) ⎛
(13)
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
13
since (0, K , X, X¯ ; 0) consists of a sum of differential operators that are linear in K , X and X¯ with terms which are quadratic in K , X and X¯ . Second, ⎞ ⎞ ⎛ 0 0 d ⎜ 0 ⎟ ⎜ 0 ⎟ D (0; 0)(h, 0, 0, 0; 0) = =⎝ 1 ⎝ Ric H (δ + sh) ⎠ − 2 δ h ⎠ ds 0 0 s=0 ⎛
(14)
by definition of the reduced Ricci operator and using the fact that the terms in appearing there are quadratic. Since the operator P is upper-triangular and the operators appearing on the diagonal are all elliptic, P is itself elliptic. Furthermore, Proposition 2 shows that P is Fredholm; and by the choice of β ∈ (−1, 0) made in Sect. 2.3, both β and β − 1 are less than 0, so that each of the operators appearing on the diagonal are injective on their respective domains. The operator P is thus itself injective. To find the image of P, one must attempt to solve the equations ⎛ ∗ ⎞ ⎛ ⎞ Dδ Dδ (K ) − div∗δ ( X¯ ) f1 ∗( X ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ f2 ⎟ ¯) ◦ div div δ ⎜ ⎟ δ (15) ⎝ − 1 δ h − div∗ (X ) ⎠ = ⎝ f 3 ⎠ δ 2 f4 divδ ◦ div∗δ (X ) with ( f 1 , f 2 , f 3 , f 4 ) ∈ Y. According to Lemma 5, the second and fourth equations can be solved if and only if f 2 and f 4 are in I1 . The third equation can now be solved since δ is an isomorphism according to Proposition 2. The remaining equation of (15) can be solved if and only if [ f 1 ]i j + [Dδ∗ div∗δ ( X¯ )]i j = 0 R3
for every i and j. But this is true if and only if f 1 ∈ I2 by the definition of the adjoint and the fact are in the kernel of Dδ . Thus ( f 1 , f 2 , f 3 , f 4 ) ∈ I2 × I1 × that constants H k−2,β−2 S 2 (R3 ) × I1 , which is of codimension 11 in Y. Existence of solutions in Theorem A. The conclusion to be drawn from Proposition 6 is that solutions of equation (x; b) = 0 can not be found using the Implicit Function Theorem for x = (h, K , X, X¯ ) near 0 in terms of b = (T, T¯ , φ). The non-trivial co-kernel of the linearization P is the essential obstruction. However, the existence of solutions up to an error term transverse to the image of P can be proved using the following technique. Since P is Fredholm with 11-dimensional co-kernel, the image of P is closed and one can find (in many different ways) an 11-dimensional subspace C so that Y = Im(P) ⊕ C. If η : R3 → R denotes a smooth, positive function on R3 with compact support satisfying R3 η = 1, then one such choice is given by C = ηµi j dx i ⊗ dx j : µi j ∈ R × ηλ¯ i dx i : λ¯ i ∈ R × {0} × ηλi dx i : λi ∈ R .
14
A. Butscher
If π : Y → Im(P) denotes the projection operator corresponding to this decomposition, namely the operator given by ⎞ [ f 1 ]i j dxi ⊗ dx j f 1 − η R3 ⎟ ⎜ f 2 − η R3 [ f 2 ]i dx i ⎟, π( f 1 , f 2 , f 3 , f 4 ) = ⎜ ⎠ ⎝ f i 3 f 4 − η R3 [ f 4 ]i dx ⎛
then the operator π ◦ : X × B → Im(P) has linearization in the X direction equal to π ◦ P, which is injective (proved as in Proposition 6) and is surjective since the composition with π forces it to map onto its image. Consequently, the Implicit Function Theorem can be applied to the equation π ◦ (x, b) = 0. The result is as follows. There is a neighbourhood U of 0 in B and a smooth function ψ : B → X such that ¯ (b) , then ψ(b), b ∈ X × B if b = (T, T¯ , φ) ∈ U and ψ(b) ≡ h(b), K (b), X (b), X satisfies the equation π ◦ ψ(b), b = 0. This is equivalent to the statement that the tensors g = δ + h, χ = K + 13 φg, S = div∗g X + T − 13 T r g (T )g, S¯ = div∗g X¯ + T¯ − 13 T r g (T¯ )g satisfy the equations
⎞ ⎛ ⎞ Dg∗ Dg (χ ) − S¯ µab ab
⎜ ⎟ st u ¯ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ λ¯ ⎟ ut (g) ⎜ H divg ( S) a − εa χs R ⎟ = η ⎝ a ⎠ ∈ C, 0 ⎝ Ric (δ + h) − Sab + χss χab − χas χbs ⎠ ab λ st u a divg (S) + χ εat S¯su ⎛
(16)
a
where µab = λ¯ a = λa =
R
3
R
3
R3
Dg∗ Dg (χ ) − S¯ , ab
¯ − εast χsu Rut (g) , divg ( S) a
u ¯ divg (S) a − χ st εat Ssu ,
in the standard coordinates of R3 , provided that the free data (T, T¯ , φ) is chosen sufficiently small in the norm of the Banach space B. Uniqueness of solutions in Theorem A. It remains to show that the mapping from (T, T¯ , φ) to the solution (h, K , X, X¯ ) is injective. This will follow from the Implicit Function Theorem if it can be shown that the linearization of in the direction of the
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
15
free data, namely D(π ◦ (0; 0)){0}×B , is injective. But a calculation similar to that in Proposition 6 gives D π ◦ (0; 0) {0}×B (T, T¯ , φ) d = π ◦ (0, 0, 0, 0; sT, s T¯ , sφ) ds s=0 ⎞ ⎛ ∗ 1 Dδ Dδ 3 φδ − T¯ − 13 T rδ (T¯ )δ ab ⎟ ⎜ d divδ T¯ − 13 T rδ (T¯ )δ a ⎟ ⎜
s = 1 ⎠ ⎝ −T + T r (T )δ ds s=0 δ 3 ab 1 divδ T − T rδ (T )δ a ⎞ ⎛ ∗ 1 3 ¯ 1 δ (T¯ )δ η D δ Dδ 3 φδ − T − 3 T r R3 ab ⎟ ⎜ d η R3 divδ T¯ − 13 T rδ (T¯ )δ a ⎟ ⎜ − s⎝ ⎠ 0 ds s=0 1 η R3 divδ T − 3 T rδ (T )δ a ⎛ ⎞ eb eb ¯ ¯ ∇a ∇b φ − εc ∇bebTae − εc ∇bebTce ⎜ −η R3 ∇a ∇b φ − εc ∇b Tae − εc ∇b Tce ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ =⎜ (17) ⎟, 0 ⎝ ⎠ −Tab 0 using the fact that T and T¯ were chosen to be transverse-traceless with respect to δ. Suppose now that D(π ◦ ){0}×B (0; 0)(T, T¯ , φ) = (0, 0, 0, 0). Then clearly T = 0. Taking the trace of what remains of the first equation in (17) yields δ φ − η δ φ = δ φ = 0 R3
by the divergence theorem (valid because of the decay property of φ). But now, one can invoke the injectivity of on the space H k−1,β−1 (R3 ) to conclude that φ = 0. Finally, e T¯ + ε e T¯ + ε e T¯ = 0 and the fact that T¯ is divergence free at use the identity εbc ae ca be ab ce the Euclidean metric to conclude that the remaining equation for T¯ reads eb ¯ εa ∇b Tce − η εaeb ∇b T¯ce = 0. R3
The integrand above is an exact vector-valued differential. Thus by using Stokes’ Theorem (valid because of the decay property of T¯ ), one can eliminate the integral above and end up with εaeb ∇b T¯ce = 0. This equation shows that the vector-valued one-form T¯ab dx b is closed and hence exact, so that T¯ab = ∇b T¯a for some vector-valued zero form T¯a . The divergence-free condition on T¯ab then shows that δ T¯b = 0 and so T¯b = 0 by the injectivity of δ on the space of H k−2,β−2 tensors over R3 . These calculations show that the operator D(π ◦ ){0}×B (0; 0) is injective, thereby proving the uniqueness claim contained in Theorem A and concluding the proof of Theorem A.
16
A. Butscher
4. Statement and Proof of Theorem B 4.1. The statement. In order to complete the proof of the Main Theorem, it remains to show that the solution (16) of the secondary system constructed in the previous section actually satisfies the extended constraint equations. The second theorem to be proved in this paper establishes this fact. Theorem B. If (ψ(b), b) is a solution of the equation π ◦ (ψ(b), b) = 0 as in Theorem A, with b = (T, T¯ , φ) sufficiently small in the norm of the Banach space B and ψ(b) = (h(b), K (b), X (b), X¯ (b)), then the quantities g = δ + h(b), χ = K (b) + 13 φδ, S = div∗g X (b) + T − 13 T r g (T )g, S¯ = div∗g X¯ (b) + T¯ − 13 T r g (T¯ )g, satisfy the extended constraint equations (1). Strategy of proof. Theorem A has produced g ∈ H k,β (S 2 (R3 )), χ ∈ H k−1,β−1 (S 2 (R3 )), S ∈ H k−2,β−2 (Sg2 (R3 )), S¯ ∈ H k−2,β−2 (J (R3 )), and error terms λa , λ¯ a and µab in R that satisfy Eq. (16). Let J ∈ H k−2,β−2 (J (R3 )) be ¯ Then (g, χ , S, S) ¯ satisfies the extended constraint equations the tensor J ≡ Dg (χ )− S. (1) if and only if Jabc = 0, a = 0, (18) error terms = 0, a where is the quantity arising from the harmonic gauge choice as explained in Sect. 2.2. Here is a schematic of how it will be shown that (18) holds. Let z ε = (J, ) represent a solution of the secondary system, where the norm of the free data is represented by the small parameter ε, and let ε represent an error term lying in a fixed, finitedimensional subspace C. Then the integrability conditions contained within the extended constraint equations will be used to show that z ε satisfies a system of equations of the form Pε (z ε ) = ε , where Pε is a family of linear, elliptic operators with coefficients depending smoothly on ε. These equations will be called the auxiliary equations. Then, it will be shown that the operator Pε is (1) injective and uniformly elliptic, and thus uniformly injective, all for sufficiently small ε, and (2) that the finite-dimensional subspace C is transverse to the image of P0 . Consequently, the stability of co-kernels of linear elliptic operators proved in Proposition 3 shows that C remains transverse to the image of Pε for sufficiently small ε. Since ε ∈ C ∩ Im(Pε ), therefore ε = 0. But now the uniform injectivity can be invoked yet again to show that z ε = 0.
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
17
4.2. The proof. The auxiliary equations The first step in the proof of Theorem B is to derive the auxiliary equations satisfied by J and which are a consequence of the integrability conditions in the conformal constraint equations. Proposition 7. The quantities J , and the real numbers µab , λa , λ¯ a satisfy the equations 1 g b − Rba a = −ηλb − χ st Jsbt + Aa χab − χss gab , 2 where Ab = g ac Jabc , and
∗ Dg (J ) ab = ηµab ,
Qg (J ) a = 2ηλ¯ a ,
(19)
(20)
where Qg is the operator defined at the beginning of Sect. 2.1. Proof. The equation satisfied by will be deduced from the Bianchi identity ∇ a Rab − 1 2 ∇b R = 0. In fact, substitute the reduced Ricci operator into this identity to obtain 1 1 H 0 = ∇ a Rab − ∇b R H + g b + ∇ a ∇b a − ∇b ∇ a a 2 2 1 1 a a s = ∇ Sab − ∇ (χs χab ) + ∇ a (χas χsb ) + ∇b (χss )2 − χ st χst + g b + Rba a 2 2 1 st e ¯ a = ηλb − χ εbt Sse + g b + Rb a 2 − ∇ s χsa − ∇ a χss gab χss − χab − ∇b χst − ∇s χb χ st . (21) Now let Ab = g ac Jabc . According to the definition of J made above, Ab = ∇ a χab − ∇b χaa . Substituting this into (21) leads to 1 g b + Rba a = −ηλb − χ st Jsbt + Aa χab − χss gab , 2 which is the desired equation for a . Next, the first equation of (20) holds for J by definition. For the second equation, consider
Qg (J ) a = εebc ∇e Jabc s ¯ = εebc ∇e (∇c χab − ∇b χac ) − εbc Sas . At this stage, one must commute the second derivatives, bringing in curvature terms. Thus,
s ∇e S¯as Qg (J ) a = Recas χbs + Recbs χas εebc − εebc εbc = 2Recas χbs εecb − 2∇ s S¯as
(22)
by the algebraic Bianchi identity satisfied by the curvature tensor. Substitute the second equation of (16) into (22) to obtain
Qg (J ) a = 2Recas χbs εecb − 2εast χsu Rut + 2ηλ¯ a .
18
A. Butscher
The fact that only curvature terms remain is a manifestation of the integrability conditions. Finally, use the decomposition Recas = Rea gcs − Res gca + Rcs gea − Rca ges − 1 s ecb = ε st χ u R and thus that a s ut 2 R (gea gcs − ges gca ) to find that Recas χb ε
Qg (J ) a = 2ηλ¯ a , which is the second equation of (20).
Notation. Denote the pair of operators appearing in (20) by Pε (J ) = Dg∗ (J ), Qg (J ) . Thus Pε is an operator from H k−2,β−2 J (R3 ) to H k−3,β−3 Sg2 (R3 ) × 1 (R3 ) . Uniform injectivity and ellipticity. The operators appearing on the left-hand sides of Eqs. (19) and (20) should be viewed as linear, elliptic operators for J and whose coefficients depend on the solution g, χ , S and S¯ of Theorem A and thus on the free data (T, T¯ , φ). The uniform injectivity and ellipticity of these operators will be established one at a time using the following lemma. Lemma 8. Let g = δ + h be an asymptotically flat metric on R3 with h ∈ H k,β S 2 (R3 ) and let R(x) be a quantity that is quadratic in the argument x with coefficients proportional to the curvature of g. For any l ≥ 1 and γ < −1, there exists a number ε > 0 so that if h H k,β ≤ ε, then the only function u ∈ H l,γ (R3 ) satisfying the inequality ∇u2 dVolg + C R(u)dVolg (23) 0≤− R3
R3
for some constant C, is the zero function. Remark. This lemma is the generalization of a result from [3]. Proof. Because h ∈ H k,β with k ≥ 4 > 23 and β < 0, the Sobolev Embedding Theorem [2] guarantees that |h|C 2 ≤ Ch H k,β . Consequently, the coefficients of R are bounded in C 0 by h H k,β and it follows that R(u)dVolg ≤ R |u|2 dVolg R3 R3 ≤ Ch H k,β |u|2 σ −2 dVolg R3 ≤ Ch H k,β ∇u2 dVolg (24) R3
by the Poincaré inequality for weighted Sobolev norms proved in [2]. (Actually, [2] proves this only for the metric g = δ, but the result is also valid for the metric g = δ + h with sufficiently small h H k,β because the norms with the metric g are uniformly equivalent to the norms with the metric h and no Christoffel symbols appear.) Using (24) in inequality (23) leads to 0 ≤ Ch H k,β − 1 ∇u2 , R3
so if h H k,β is sufficiently small, the right hand side above becomes negative. Avoiding this contradiction requires ∇u = 0. But since u decays at infinity when γ < −1, it must be true that u = 0.
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
19
It is now straightforward to deduce the uniform injectivity and ellipticity for the operator g − Ric appearing in (19). In fact, all that is needed is to show the injectivity of this operator, since uniform ellipticity is clear. To see this, contract the equation g a − Rab b = 0 with a to obtain 0 = 2 − ∇ − 2Ric( , ). Then integrate over R3 and apply the divergence theorem as well as the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to produce an expression of the form considered in Lemma 8. The injectivity of g − Ric follows. The analogous result for the operator Pε appearing in (20) is not quite so straightforward. Another lemma is needed; then a lengthy calculation will transform the injectivity equation for Pε into a form suitable for the application of Lemma 8. Lemma 9. Let M be any Riemannian manifold. Then J (M) is isomorphic to Sg2 (M) × 1 (M). In local coordinates, this isomorphism is given by Jabc = e 1 2 εbc Fae + Ab gac − Ac gab , where εabc is the fully antisymmetric permutation symbol associated to the metric of M. Proof. Given any tensor J ∈ J (M), one can define a 2-tensor T by the prescription J (X, Y, Z ) = T X, (Y ∧ Z ) , for any three vectors X , Y , and Z , which is well-defined and unique because of the antisymmetry in the last two slots of J . Here, and are the raising and lowering operators associated to the metric of M and is its Hodge star operator. Moreover, one can check that the trace of T vanishes by virtue of the symmetries of J . The tensor T can now be decomposed into its symmetric part F and its antisymmetric part written in terms of a 1-form A by means of Hodge duality. It is easy to see that this association is bijective and yields the local coordinate expression of the lemma. Proposition 10. The family of operators Pε is injective provided that ε ≤ ε0 is sufficiently small. e F + A g − A g ) into the expression for P to obtain Proof. Substitute Jabc = 21 (εbc ae b ac c ab ε after some straightforward calculation ⎞ ⎛ 2 e e εcb ∇ c Fae + εca ∇ c Fbe − ∇a Ab − ∇b Aa + ∇ c Ac gab ⎠ 3 Pε (F, A) = ⎝ (25) b bc ∇ Fab + εa ∇b Ac for F and A. Now suppose that (F, A) ∈ H k−2,β−2 Sg2 (R3 ) × 1 (R3 ) and that Pε (F, A) = (0, 0). The key to showing (F, A) = (0, 0) is to find an inequality satisfied by F and A of the type needed to invoke Lemma 8. Begin with the identity e F + εe F + εe F εbc ae ca be = 0 that F satisfies by virtue of being trace-free. Then ab ce take its divergence with respect to ∇ c and substitute from the second equation of Pε (F, A) = (0, 0) to find e e e st εca ∇ c Fbe = εcb ∇ c Fae + εab εe ∇s At e c = εcb ∇ Fae + ∇a Ab − ∇b Aa .
(26)
20
A. Butscher
b Next, substitute (26) into the first equation of Pε (F, A) = (0, 0) and contract with εuv to get
1 b e b 0 = εuv εcb ∇ c Fae − εuv ∇b Aa + ∇ s As εauv 3 1 b = ∇v Fau − ∇u Fav − εuv ∇b Aa + ∇ s As εauv . 3
(27)
Now contract (27) with ∇ v : 1 b ∇ v ∇b Aa + ∇ v ∇ s As εauv 0 = g Fau − ∇ v ∇u Fav − εuv 3 1 b vs 1 vs = g Fau − ∇u ∇ v Fav − εuv Rba As + ∇ v ∇ s As εauv − Rus Fas − Rua Fsv 2 3 1 1 b vs pq vs = g Fau + εa ∇u ∇ p Aq + ∇ v ∇ s As εauv − εuv Rba As − Rus Fas − Rua Fsv (28) 3 2 after using the second equation of Pε (F, A) = (0, 0) once again. The advantage of this expression is that the only derivatives of F appearing here are in the Fau term. A similar expression can be obtained for A by computing the antisymmetric part of (28) and contracting with εtau . That is, 1 1 pq b vs vs Rba As − εtau Rus Fas − εtau Rua Fsv 0 = εtau εa ∇u ∇ p Aq + ∇ v ∇ s As εauv εtau − εtau εuv 3 2 2 = g At − ∇ u ∇t Au + ∇t ∇ b Ab − Rus Fas εtau − Rts As 3 1 s = g At − ∇t ∇ As − Rus Fas εtau . (29) 3 Since F ∈ H k−2,β−2 , the integral of F au g Fau over R3 is well-defined and can be integrated by parts. In what follows, R denotes a curvature quantity as in Lemma 8. Now, 0=
R3
F au g Fau dVolg +
R3
pq
εa ∇u ∇ p Aq F au dVolg +
1 g F2 dVolg − ∇ F2 dVolg 3 2 R3 R pq au + εa ∇u ∇ p Aq F dVolg + R(A, F)dVolg 3 R3 R pq =− ∇ F2 dVolg + εa ∇u ∇ p Aq F au dVolg +
R3
R(A, F)dVolg
=
R3
R3
R3
R(A, F)dVolg , (30)
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
21
since R3 g udVolg = 0 for any u ∈ H k−2,β−2 (R3 ). But now, pq pq εa ∇u ∇ p Aq F au dVolg = − εa ∇ p Aq ∇u F au dVolg R3 R3 pq = εa ∇ p Aq εr sa ∇r As dVolg 3 R = ∇ A2 dVolg − ∇ s Ar ∇r As 3 3 R R 2 = ∇ A dVolg + (∇ s As )2 dVolg + R3
R3
R3
R(A)dVolg , (31)
using ∇u F au = −εr sa ∇r As and repeated use of integration by parts. Substituting (31) into (30) yields 2 2 s 2 0=− ∇ F dVolg + ∇ A dVolg − (∇ As ) dVolg + R(A, F)dVolg . R3
R3
R3
R3
Similar calculations involving Eq. (29) for g At yield the identity 1 2 s 2 0=− ∇ A dVolg + (∇ As ) dVolg + R(A)dVolg . 3 R3 R3 R3
(32)
(33)
Adding one third of Eq. (32) to Eq. (33) allows the divergence term to cancel and leads to the identity 1 2 0=− ∇ F2 + ∇ A2 dVolg + R(A, F)dVolg . (34) 3 R3 3 R3 Now R(A, F) ≤ CR(F2 + A2 ), where R denotes the supremum norm of curvature coefficients and C is a general numerical constant. Consequently, one obtains the estimate ∇ F2 + ∇ A2 dVolg + C 0=− R A2 + F2 dVolg . (35) R3
R3
Lemma 8 along with the simple estimate ∇T 2 ≤ C∇T 2 (by Cauchy-Schwarz) can now be applied to conclude that (F, A) = (0, 0) when h H k,β is sufficiently small. But since h depends smoothly on (T, T¯ , φ), and vanishes when these quantities are zero, the operator Pε is injective when ε is sufficiently small. Proposition 11. For every 0 ≤ ε ≤ ε0 , the operator Pε is elliptic. Proof. The symbol of Pε , rewritten in terms of the isomorphism of Lemma 9 is given by ⎛ ⎞ 2 c e c e c ε ξ Fae + εca ξ Fbe − ξa Ab − ξb Aa + ξ Ac gab ⎠ 3 (F, A) → ⎝ cb b bc ξ Fab + εa ξb Ac
22
A. Butscher
for any non-zero ξ ∈ R3 . If one follows the same algebraic steps as were used in the previous proposition, one ends up with the two equations 1 b v 0 = ξ 2 Fau − ξ v ξu Fav − εuv ξ ξb Aa + ξ v ξ s As εauv , 3 1 s 2 0 = ξ − ξt ξ As . 3 (These are the analogs of Eqs. (28) and (29), where curvature terms do not appear since commuting derivatives reduces to commuting multiplication by ξ at the level of the symbol.) Contracting the second equation against ξ t yields 23 ξ 2 ξ t At = 0 or ξ t At = 0. If this is substituted back into the first equation, one has ξ 2 At = 0, or simply At = 0. In a similar manner, one then concludes that Fau = 0. The symbol of Pε is thus injective. But since it is a map from one 8-dimensional space of tensors to another, it must be surjective as well. Consequently, Pε is elliptic. Corollary 12. The family of operators Pε is uniformly injective, provided ε is sufficiently small. Proof. The injectivity of Pε together with the elliptic estimate yields an estimate of the form u ≤ CPε u in the appropriate norms. Since the coefficients of Pε depend smoothly on ε and P0 is not degenerate, the constant C can be made independent of ε. But this is the uniform injectivity of the operators Pε . Transversality and completion of the proof. The equation for J in (20) is schematically of the form Pε (J ) = ε , where ε depends on ε is the error term. However, for each ε ≤ ε0 , ε belongs to the fixed, finite dimensional subspace C = ηµi j dx i ⊗ dx j : µi j ∈ R × ηλ¯ i dx i : λ¯ i ∈ R , of H k−3,β−3 Sg2 (R3 ) × 1 (R3 ) . But the following transversality result makes this impossible unless ε = 0. Proposition 13. The family of operators Pε satisfies C ∩ Im(Pε ) = {(0, 0)} provided ε is sufficiently small. Proof. Apply the divergence theorem to the equation P0 (J ) = η(µ, λ¯ ). Integrating over R3 gives zero on the left-hand side, while by construction, integrating the right-hand side yields (µab , λ¯ a ). Thus the conclusion of the theorem holds for P0 . Consequently, by Proposition 3 and the uniform injectivity of Pε , the image of Pε remains transverse to C for sufficiently small ε. Equation (20) states that η(µ, λ¯ ) ∈ C ∩ Im(Pε ). Thus (λ, µ) must vanish, and J must satisfy Pε (J ) = (0, 0). Thus one can invoke the uniform injectivity of Pε once again to conclude that J itself must of vanishing J , λ¯ and µ vanish. The consequence is that the equation for reads 21 g b + Rba a = −ηλb . The vanishing of both and λ can now be shown in the same way as above. That is, since −ηλ belongs to the fixed, finite-dimensional subspace C ≡ {ηλi dx i : λi ∈ R} and g + Ric is uniformly injective and elliptic, all that is needed is the transversality of δ to C by Proposition 3. But this is again a simple consequence of the divergence theorem. Consequently, λ = 0 and so = 0 by uniform injectivity.
Perturbative Solutions of the Extended Constraint Equations
23
This completes the proof of Theorem B. In combination with Theorem A, this yields a construction of perturbative solutions of the extended constraint equations and concludes the proof of the Main Theorem. Acknowledgements. The research and most of the writing for this paper was carried out while I was a postdoctoral fellow at the Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics in Golm, Germany. I would like to thank Helmut Friedrich of this institute for suggesting the topic of the extended constraint equations as well as for suggesting the two-step approach for its solution. I would also like to thank him for providing guidance and support during and after the course of the research. Furthermore, I would like to thank Piotr Chru´sciel, Justin Corvino, Jörg Frauendiener and Gerhard Huisken for their helpful suggestions and comments. Erratum. Note that [3] contains an error in the section pertaining to that paper’s analogue of Theorem B. The Stability Lemma in Sect. 10.3.6 of [3] is mis-stated and its proof is incorrect. It is then applied to the associated equations in the way the correctly-stated version should have been applied. The result in [3] is thus still correct. In any case, the results of this paper subsume and generalize those of [3].
References 1. Abraham, R., Marsden, J.E., Ratiu, T.: Manifolds, Tensor Analysis, and Applications. Second edition New York: Springer-Verlag, 1988 2. Bartnik, R.: The mass of an asymptotically flat manifold. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 39, 661–693 (1986) 3. Butscher, A.: Exploring the conformal constraint equations. In: Proc. of the Int’l Workshop on the Conformal Structure of Spacetime (Tubinger, Germany, April 2001), in Lect. Notes in Phys. 604, Berlin Heidelberg-New York: Springer, 2002, pp. 195–222 4. Cantor, M.: Elliptic operators and the decomposition of tensor fields. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 5(3), 235– 262 (1981) 5. Choquet-Brouhat, Y., Christodoulou, D.: Elliptic systems in Hs,δ spaces on manifolds which are Euclidean at infinity. Acta Math. 146, 129–150 (1981) 6. Christodoulou, D., O’Murchadha, N.: The boost problem in general relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 80, 271–300 (1981) 7. Chru´sciel, P., Delay, E.: Existence of non-trivial, vacuum, asymptotically simple space-times. Class. Quant. Grav. 19 (2002) 8. Corvino, J.: Scalar curvature deformation and a gluing construction for the einstein constraint equations. Commun. Math. Phys. 214, 137–189 (2000) 9. Frauendiener, J.: Conformal infinity. Living Rev. Relativity 3 (2000), no. 4, Online Article: http://relativity.livingreviews.org/Articles/Irr-2004-/, 2004 10. Friedrich, H.: Asymptotic structure of space time. In: Recent Advances in General Relativity, A. Janis, J. Porter, eds., Einstein Studies, Vol. 4, Basel-Boston: Birkäuser, 1992 11. Friedrich, H.: Einstein’s equations and conformal structure. In: The Geometric Universe. Science, Geometry and the work of Roger Penrose S. Huggett, L. Mason, K.P. Tod, S. Tsou, N.M.J. Woodhouse, eds., Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998 12. Lockhart, R.: Fredholm properties of a class of elliptic operators on non-compact manifolds. Duke Math. J. 48, 289–312 (1981) 13. McOwen, R.C.: The behavior of the Laplacian on weighted Sobolev spaces. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 32, 783–795 (1979) 14. McOwen, R.C.: On elliptic operators in Rn . Comm. Part. Differ. Eqs. 5, 913–933 (1980) 15. Penrose, R.: Asymptotic properties of fields and spacetimes. Phys. Rev. Lett. 10, 66–68 (1963) 16. Schoen, R., Yau, S.-T.: On the proof of the positive mass conjecture in general relativity. Commun. Math. Phys. 65, 45–76 (1979) Communicated by G.W. Gibbons
Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 25–52 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0190-x
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Convergence of the Wick Star Product Svea Beiser, Hartmann Römer, Stefan Waldmann Fakultät für Mathematik und Physik, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Physikalisches Institut, Hermann Herder Straße 3, D 79104 Freiburg, Germany. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 14 July 2005 / Accepted: 27 September 2006 Published online: 7 March 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We construct a Fréchet space as a subspace of C ω (Cn ) where the Wick star product converges and is continuous. The resulting Fréchet algebra A is studied in detail including a ∗ -representation of A in the Bargmann-Fock space and a discussion of star exponentials and coherent states. 1. Introduction Deformation quantization usually comes in two flavours: formal and strict deformations: In formal deformation quantization as introduced by [2], see also [20, 25] for recent reviews, one considers the Poisson algebra of smooth complex-valued functions C ∞ (M) on a Poisson manifold as observable algebra in classical mechanics. A formal star product is a C[[λ]]-bilinear associative product for C ∞ (M)[[λ]] such that in zeroth order f g is the pointwise product and in first order of λ the -commutator gives i times the Poisson bracket. Usually one requires the higher orders to be given by bidifferential operators. The algebra C ∞ (M)[[λ]] then serves as a model for the quantum mechanical observables corresponding to the classical system described by M. In particular, the formal parameter λ corresponds to Planck’s constant and should be replaced by whenever one can establish convergence of the formal series. On the other hand, in strict deformation quantization as introduced in [44], see also [35], one works on the framework of C ∗ -algebras where the dependence of the deformed product on the deformation parameter is now required to be continuous. This is made precise using the notion of continuous fields of C ∗ -algebras. While in the first approach one has very strong existence [18,22–24,34,41] and classification results [3, 17, 26, 34, 38, 39, 47], the formal character of Planck’s constant is, of course, physically not acceptable. Here the second approach is much more appealing as it directly uses the analytical framework suitable for quantum mechanics. On the other hand, however, a general construction and reasonable classification of strict quantizations seems still to be missing.
26
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Many examples like the global symbol calculus on cotangent bundles [6–8], Berezin-Toeplitz quantization on Kähler manifolds [5,13–16,33] as well as [4] suggest that the formal star products should be seen as asymptotic expansions for → 0 of their convergent counterparts in strict quantization. On the other hand, many formal star products allow for large subalgebras, where the formal series actually converge, whence in some sense the asymptotics can be used again to recover the strict result, a heuristic statement for which a general theorem unfortunately is still missing. The above examples also suggest that there is a framework in between formal and C ∗ -algebraic, namely one can try to construct deformations of C ∞ (M) (or suitable subalgebras of it) in the framework of Fréchet or more generally locally convex algebras. Early results in this direction have been obtained in [27,30,36], see also [40]. Moreover, a general set-up of smooth deformations has been established and exemplified in [21]; in [43] holomorphic deformations were studied. The example we are going to discuss will provide an entire holomorphic deformation of a Fréchet subalgebra of C ω (M). More specifically, we consider the most simple phase space M = Cn with its canonical Poisson structure {z k , z } = 2i δ k and the formal Wick star product ∞ (2λ)r ∂r f ∂r g , (1.1) f Wick g = r! ∂z i1 · · · ∂z ir ∂z i1 · · · ∂z ir r =0
i 1 ,...,ir
where z 1 , . . . , z n are the canonical, global, holomorphic coordinates on Cn . Our convergence scheme to construct the ‘convergent’ subalgebra A is then based on the crucial observation that the Wick star product enjoys a very strong positivity property [10–12]: every δ-functional is a positive C[[λ]]-linear functional in the sense of formal power series. After choosing a point p ∈ Cn and > 0 this will allow us to construct recursively a system of seminorms for which the Wick star product is continuous, thereby defining our algebra A p,. Moreover, we shall construct, via the GNS construction corresponding to the positive functional δ p , a faithful ∗ -representation of A p, on a dense subspace of the Bargmann-Fock space giving an interpretation of the δ-functionals as coherent states with respect to the Heisenberg group Hn acting on Cn . We treat this example in quite some detail as we believe that it may serve as a good starting point for geometric generalizations to Wick star products on Kähler manifolds [9,31] suitable for a bottom-up approach to [5, 13–16, 33]. Moreover, in a future project we shall discuss the field-theoretic generalization for infinitely many degrees of freedom. The paper is organized as follows: In Sect. 2 we briefly recall some basic properties of Wick , the formal GNS construction for δ-functionals and the Bargmann-Fock space. Section 3 is devoted to the construction of the seminorms, depending on p ∈ Cn and > 0. This gives the space A p, which is shown to be a subspace of C ω (Cn ) with a Fréchet topology. In Sect. 4 we show that A p, is a subalgebra of C ω (Cn ) such that the pointwise product as well as the Poisson bracket are continuous, i.e. A p, becomes a Fréchet-Poisson algebra. Moreover, we show that the formula (1.1) for Wick actually converges on A p, in the Fréchet topology resulting in a continuous product. This way, A p, becomes a holomorphic deformation. In Sect. 5 we discuss the dependence on the a priori chosen point p and on the value > 0 of Planck’s constant. It turns out that the translation group acts on A p, by inner ∗ -automorphisms whence A p, = A does not depend on the choice of p. As a side remark we show that the star exponential, see [2], of linear functions converges in the topology of A. Moreover, for all values > 0 the algebras A are isomorphic in a canonical way. Finally, in Sect. 6 we show how the GNS construction yields a ∗ -representation of A in the sense of [45] in the Bargmann-Fock
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
27
space. The action of the Heisenberg group by inner ∗ -automorphisms gives easily the coherent states. 2. Preliminary Results In this section we shall collect some well-known results on the Wick star product which we shall use in the sequel, see e.g. [9, 10]. On the classical phase space R2n ∼ = Cn with standard symplectic form ω = 2i d z k ∧ k d z one defines the formal Wick star product by f Wick g =
∞ (2λ)r r =0
r!
i 1 ,...,ir
∂z i1
∂r f ∂r g , i i · · · ∂z r ∂z 1 · · · ∂z ir
(2.1)
where f, g ∈ C ∞ (Cn )[[λ]], the formal parameter λ corresponds to Planck’s constant without any further prefactors and z, z denote the usual global holomorphic/antiholomorphic coordinates on Cn . Then Wick is known to be an associative star product quantizing the canonical Poisson bracket corresponding to ω. It has the separation of variable property in the sense of Karabegov [31, 32] and is in fact the name-giving example of a star product of Wick type in the sense of [9]. Moreover, Wick is Hermitian f Wick g = g Wick f ,
(2.2)
where according to our interpretation of λ the formal parameter is defined to be real λ = λ. We shall also frequently make use of multiindex notation: Let R = (r1 , . . . , rn ) ∈ Nn be a multiindex, then one defines |R| = r1 + · · · + rn , R! = r1 ! · · · rn ! as well as z R = (z1 )r1 · · · (z n )rn etc. Moreover, we define R ≤ L if ri ≤ i for all i = 1, . . . , n R! and set RL = L!(R−L)! for R ≥ L. The Wick star product can equivalently be written as f Wick g =
∞ (2λ)|R| ∂ |R| f ∂ |R| g . R! ∂z R ∂z R R=0
(2.3)
The Wick star product enjoys a very strong positivity property which e.g. the WeylMoyal star product does not share: If δ p : C ∞ (Cn )[[λ]] −→ C[[λ]] denotes the evaluation functional at p ∈ Cn then we have δ p ( f Wick f ) =
∞ (2λ)|R| R!
R=0
|R| 2 ∂ f ≥ 0, ( p) ∂z R
(2.4)
where the positivity is understood in the sense of the canonical ring ordering of R[[λ]], see [10,46] for a detailed discussion on the physical relevance of this notion of positivity. This very strong positivity property is not true for general Hermitian star products: instead one has to add ‘quantum corrections’ to a given classically positive functional (here δ p ) in order to obtain a positive functional with respect to the star product. Since positive functionals play the role of states, the above simple observation implies that for the Wick star product any classical state defines a quantum state without any quantum correction, see [46] for a detailed discussion on the general situation. In fact, the Wick star product is used in an essential way for proving that for an arbitrary Hermitian star product one can always construct quantum corrections for a classical state, see [11,12].
28
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Since δ p is a positive functional for Wick we have a corresponding GNS representation of the Wick star product algebra C ∞ (Cn )[[λ]]. In fact, this example was one of the first examples of GNS constructions in deformation quantization. Since we need the construction in the following, we briefly review the results from [10]. The Gel’fand ideal J p of δ p is given by ∂ |R| f ( p) = 0 for all R . (2.5) J p = f δ p ( f Wick f ) = 0 = f ∂z R The GNS pre-Hilbert space H p = C ∞ (Cn )[[λ]] J p can canonically be identified with HBF = C[[y 1 , . . . , y n ]][[λ]]
(2.6)
with the C[[λ]]-valued positive definite inner product φ, ψ =
∞ (2λ)|R| ∂ |R| φ ∂ |R| ψ (0) (0), R! ∂yR ∂yR R=0
(2.7)
where the identification of a class ψ f ∈ H p is given by its formal anti-holomorphic Taylor expansion, i.e. H p ψ f →
∞ 1 ∂ |R| f ( p) y R , R! ∂z R R=0
(2.8)
where ψ f denotes the equivalence class of the function f in H p . Then the GNS representation on H p defined by π p ( f )ψg = ψ f Wick g is translated into
p( f ) =
∞ |R| (2λ)|R| ∂ |R+S| f S ∂ ( p) y , R!S! ∂z R ∂z S ∂yR R,S=0
(2.9)
via the unitary map (2.8). In particular, for p = 0 we see that this gives the formal analog of the usual Bargmann-Fock space and the Bargmann-Fock representation: indeed, recall that the Bargmann-Fock space is the Hilbert space
zz 1 n 2 − 2 HBF = f ∈ O(C ) e d z d z < ∞ (2.10) | f (z)| (2π )n of anti-holomorphic functions which are square-integrable with respect to the Gaussian measure, see [1]. Then it is well-known that HBF is actually a closed subspace of the L 2 -space for this measure and hence a Hilbert space itself. Moreover, the L 2 -inner product can be evaluated by the same formula (2.7) if one replaces λ by , where the series now converges absolutely. A Hilbert basis for HBF is given by the monomials 1 zR. e R (z) = |R| (2) R!
(2.11)
From (2.7) we see that the Hilbert space HBF can be interpreted as the space of those antiholomorphic functions whose Taylor coefficients at 0 form a sequence in a (weighted) 2 -space.
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
29
3. Construction of the Fréchet Space A p, The motivation for our convergence scheme is rather simple: we fix > 0 and we fix a point p ∈ Cn . Then we are looking for a subalgebra of C ∞ (Cn )[[λ]] such that δ p ( f ) converges for λ = . Though this looks rather innocent at the beginning, we obtain a hierarchy of conditions: For f, g in our algebra we want f Wick g to be in the algebra as well whence δ p ( f Wick g) has to converge for λ = as well. The idea is now to esti mate the convergence of δ p ( f Wick g) λ= by δ p ( f Wick f )λ= and δ p (g Wick g)λ= using the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for the positive δ-functional. Indeed, if one of the functions f or g is a polynomial, then f Wick g is only polynomial in λ whence we can easily set λ = . We use the notation Wick for the Wick star product where λ has been replaced by . Under this hypothesis we have the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality finite 2 2 (2)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g ( p) ( p) f Wick g ( p) = N N! ∂z N ∂z N =0 ⎛ ⎞ |N | 2 ∞ ∞ 2 |N | (2)|N | ∂ |N | f ⎠ (2) ∂ g ⎝ ≤ ( p) ( p) N N N! ∂z N! ∂z N =0 N =0 p,
p,
= h 0,0,0,0 ( f ) h 0,0,0,0 (g) . p,
(3.1)
p,
Here the quantities h 0,0,0,0 ( f ) and h 0,0,0,0 (g) are defined by the two factors on the right-hand side. An iteration of this procedure will lead to countably many unary conditions for a function f to belong to our algebra, which we shall interpret as seminorms determining the algebra. To motivate the quite involved combinatorics we first note that on the right-hand side of (3.1) we have to estimate derivatives of f and g as well. Thus we start directly with a formulation using all possible derivatives. The next iteration p, will lead to the following estimate for h 0,0,0,0 f Wick g , where again we assume that at least one function is a polynomial only, to make f Wick g well-defined as a smooth function. Then we have |R+S| ∂ |R+S| p, h 0,0,0,0 f Wick g (2) ∂z R ∂z S ∞ 2 (2)|N +R+S| ∂ |N +R+S| = ∂z N +S ∂z R f Wick g ( p) N! N =0
∞ (2)|N +R+S| = N! N =0
∞ (2)|N +R+S| N!
≤
N =0 ∞ (3.1)
≤
N =0
⎛ ×⎝
2 R N +S |I +J | f ∂ |N +S−J +R−I | g R N +S ∂ Wick ( p) I J ∂z I ∂z J ∂z R−I ∂z N +S−J I =0 J =0 2 R N +S R N +S ∂ |I +J | f ∂ |N +S−J +R−I | g I J Wick R−I N +S−J ( p) I J ∂z ∂z ∂z ∂z I =0 J =0
(2)|N +R+S| N!
R N +S R N +S I I =0 J =0
J
p, h 0,0,0,0
∂ |I +J | f ∂z I ∂z J
p, h 0,0,0,0
⎞ 2 ∂ |N +S−J +R−I | g ⎠ ∂z R−I ∂z N +S−J
30
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
R N +S |I +J | ∞ ∂ 1 R N +S f |I +J | p, ≤ h 0,0,0,0 I J (2) I J N! ∂z ∂z N =0 I =0 J =0 R N +S |I +J | R N +S ∂ g |I +J | p, h 0,0,0,0 × I J (2) J I ∂z ∂z I =0 J =0 R N +S |I +J | 2 R N +S ∞ 1 ∂ f p, (2)|I +J | h 0,0,0,0 ≤ I J I N! ∂z ∂z J N =0 I =0 J =0 R N +S |I +J | 2 R N +S ∞ 1 ∂ g p, |I +J | (2) × h 0,0,0,0 I J J N! ∂z ∂z I N =0 I =0 J =0 p, p, = h 1,1,R,S ( f ) h 1,0,R,S (g), p,
(3.2)
p,
where the quantities h 1,1,R,S ( f ) and h 1,0,R,S (g) are defined by the corresponding factors. In the first step we have used that the partial derivatives are still derivations with respect to the Wick star product. Moreover, we have added the power (2)|R+S| to make things more homogeneous. Note that the functions f and g enter in an asymmetric way: the multiindices I and J correspond to z and z-variables for f and vice versa for g. We use this first step of the iteration as motivation for the following definition of the seminorms. Definition 3.1. Let R, S ∈ Nn be multiindices, m ∈ N and = 0, . . . , 2m − 1. Then we define recursively for f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ), |R+S| f ∂ |R+S| f p, |R+S| ∂ h 0,0,R,S ( f ) = (2) ( p) Wick ∂z S ∂z R ∂z S ∂z R λ= |R+S+N | 2 ∞ |R+S+N | (2) f ∂ = (3.3) ∂z R ∂z N +S ( p) N! N =0 and
⎧ 2 R N +S ∞ ⎪ ⎪ 1 R N +S p, ⎪ ⎪ even ⎪ I J h m−1,/2,I,J ( f ) ⎨ N! p, N =0 I =0 J =0 (3.4) h m,,R,S ( f ) = 2 R N +S ∞ ⎪ R N +S p, ⎪ 1 ⎪ ⎪ odd. ⎪ ⎩ I J h m−1,(−1)/2,J,I ( f ) N! N =0
I =0 J =0
p,
Thanks to the positivity (2.4) of the δ-functional it is clear that h 0,0,R,S ( f ) either converges absolutely or diverges absolutely to +∞, as it is a series consisting of non-negative p, terms only. By induction, the same is true for all other h m,,R,S ( f ). Hence we have p,
h m,,R,S ( f ) ∈ [0, +∞],
(3.5)
where ‘convergence’ is always absolute and does not depend on the order of summation.
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
31
Definition 3.2. For f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) we define 2m+1 p, p,
f m,,R,S = h m,,R,S ( f )
∈ [0, +∞].
Moreover, we define p, = f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) f p, A m,,R,S < ∞ for all m, , R, S .
(3.6)
(3.7)
p, is a vector space and that the · p, The first step is now to show that A m,,R,S are seminorms on A p,. This will be a consequence of the following proposition: p,
Proposition 3.3. The maps · m,,R,S : C ∞ (Cn ) −→ [0, +∞] enjoy the following properties: p,
p,
1. α f m,,R,S = |α| f m,,R,S for α ∈ C. p,
p,
p,
2. f + g m,,R,S ≤ f m,,R,S + g m,,R,S . p,
p,
p,
p,
3. f m−1,,R,S ≤ f m,2,R,S and f m−1,,R,S ≤ f m,2+1,R,S . √ m+2 p, p, S! f m+1,2,0,0 . 4. f m,,0,S ≤ 2 √ m+2 p, p, R! f m+1,2+1,0,0 . 5. f m,,R,0 ≤ 2 √ √ m+3 m+2 p, p, R! 2 S! f m+2,4+1,0,0 . 6. f m,,R,S ≤ 2 Proof. The first part is clear by a simple induction. For the second part the case m = 0 follows directly from Minkowski’s inequality. Then m > 0 is shown inductively by using again Minkowski’s inequality, for both cases of odd and even . The remaining p, inequalities between the f m,,R,S for different values of the parameters are simply obtained by omitting all but one term for a specific N in the defining summations of (3.4). For example, in the third part one considers N = 0 and I = R, J = S only, while for the fourth and fifth one uses N = S = J and N = R = I . p, p,, give indeed seminorms. Moreover, the Thus the maps · m,,R,S , restricted to A labels R, S play only a minor role thanks to the estimates in the last part of the proposition. This motivates the following definitions. For f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) we define p,
p,
f m, = f m,,0,0 , p, p,
f m, .
f m = maxm 0≤≤2 −1
(3.8) (3.9)
Then we have the following simple corollary: p, ⊆ C ∞ (Cn ) is a subvector space and the · p, Corollary 3.4. The set A m,,R,S are p, p, seminorms on A p,. Moreover, the seminorms · m, as well as the seminorms · m p,. determine the same locally convex topology on A p, always with this locally convex topology In the following, we shall equip A p, induced by the seminorms · m,,R,S . However, this topology has one unpleasant feature: it is non-Hausdorff as a function f whose Taylor expansion at p vanishes identically
32
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann p,
has clearly f m,,R,S = 0 for all parameters m, , R, S. On the other hand, as one sees p,
already from the seminorm · 1 the functions with vanishing ∞-jet j∞ p f at p are the only functions with this property. Thus we identify them to be zero in order to have a Hausdorff topology: Definition 3.5. We define p, A p, = A
f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) j∞ f = 0 , p
(3.10)
and equip A p, with the induced locally convex topology determined by the seminorms p, p,
· m,,R,S (or equivalently, by the seminorms · m ). Clearly, A p, is now a Hausdorff locally convex topological vector space. The following theorem shows that the abstract quotient can be viewed as a certain subspace of the real-analytic functions on Cn : Theorem 3.6. Let > 0 and p ∈ Cn . 1. A p, is a Hausdorff locally convex topological vector space. 2. Every class [ f ] ∈ A p, has a unique real-analytic representative f ∈ C ω (Cn ). Therefore, we identify A p, with the corresponding subspace of C ω (Cn ) from now on. 3. Every function f ∈ A p, has a unique extension to a function fˆ ∈ O×O(Cn × Cn ), i.e. holomorphic in the first and anti-holomorphic in the second argument, such that f = ∗ fˆ,
(3.11)
where : Cn z → (z, z) ∈ Cn × Cn is the diagonal. 4. Any f ∈ C ω (Cn ) such that there exist constants a, b, c > 0 with |R+S| ∂ f |R| |S| ∂z R ∂z S ( p) ≤ ca b
(3.12)
belongs to A p,. In particular C[z, z] ⊆ A p,. Proof. The first part is clear. For the second, we consider p,
f 1,1,0,0 ≥
1 (2)2|R+S| p, ( f 0,0,R,0 )2 ≥ R! R!(S!)2
|R+S| 4 ∂ f ( p) ∂z R ∂z S
for all R, S. Thus we obtain √ √ |R+S| 4 ∂ f R! S! p, . ∂z R ∂z S ( p) ≤ f 1,1,0,0 (2)|R+S| But this implies that the series fˆ(z, w) =
∞ R,S=0
1 ∂ |R+S| f ( p)(z − p) R (w − p) S R!S! ∂z R ∂z S
(3.13)
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
33
converges for all z, w ∈ Cn . Thus fˆ ∈ O×O(Cn × Cn ) and clearly ∗ fˆ is in the same equivalence class as f . This shows the second and third part. Now assume f ∈ C ω (Cn ) satisfies (3.12). Then p,
h 0,0,R,S ( f ) ≤ c2 e2b n (2a 2 )|R| (2b2 )|S| , 2
whence there are constants c0,0 = c2 e2b n , a0,0 = 2a 2 and b0,0 = 2b such that 2
p,
|R|
|S|
h 0,0,R,S ( f ) ≤ c0,0 a0,0 b0,0 . We claim that for all m, there are constants am, , bm, and cm, such that p,
|R|
|S|
h m,,R,S ( f ) ≤ cm, am, bm, . Indeed, a recursive argument shows that 2 cm, = cm−1,/2 en(1+bm−1,/2 ) , am, = (1 + am−1,/2 )2 , bm, = (1 + bm−1,/2 )2 2
for even and 2 cm, = cm−1,(−1)/2 en(1+am−1,(−1)/2 ) , am, = (1 + bm−1,(−1)/2 )2 , 2
bm, = (1 + am−1,(−1)/2 )2 for odd will do the job. But then all seminorms of f are finite. Since the polynomials are in A p, we shall make intense use of them. The next proposition gives a first hint on the continuity of the Wick product. Proposition 3.7. Let f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) and let g ∈ C[z, z] be a polynomial. 1. 2.
f Wick g is a finite sum and thus a well-defined smooth function. f Wick g
p, m,,R,S
p,
p,
≤ f m+1,2m +,R,S g m+1,,R,S .
Proof. The first part is clear from the explicit form of Wick . For the second part we note that the computation in (3.2) is precisely the case m = 0. Note the necessity that one function (we have chosen g) is polynomial since otherwise the ‘function’ f Wick g is a priori not defined as a smooth function. The general case is now obtained by a straightforward induction on m only using the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. Corollary 3.8. The pointwise complex conjugation A p, −→ A p, is a continuous map. We have p, p, p, f m,,R,S ≤ 1 m+1,,R,S f m+1,2m +,R,S . (3.14) Note however that the seminorms themselves are not invariant under complex conjugation f ↔ f , though the complex conjugation is continuous. We also note that the second part of the proposition already shows some nice continuity properties of the Wick star product, at least if one function is a polynomial. Note however, that the above argument will not extend to arbitrary f, g whence we shall need another route.
34
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Theorem 3.9. The polynomials C[z, z] ⊆ A p, are dense. More specifically, the Taylor expansion ∞ 1 ∂ |I +J | f f (z, z) = ( p)(z − p) I (z − p) J (3.15) I !J ! ∂z I ∂z J I,J =0
of f ∈ A p, ⊆ C ω (Cn ) converges unconditionally to f with respect to the topology of A p,. In particular, the truncated Taylor polynomials f (N ,M) (z, z) =
N M 1 ∂ |I +J | f ( p)(z − p) I (z − p) J I !J ! ∂z I ∂z J
(3.16)
I =0 J =0
converge unconditionally to f in the topology of A p,. Proof. First recall that in infinite dimensional locally convex vector spaces, unconditional convergence of a series, i.e. independence of the order, is in general a strictly p, weaker statement than absolute convergence. First we rewrite the seminorms · m,,R,S in the following ‘measure-theoretic’ way ∞
p,
h m,,R,S ( f ) =
I1 ,J1 ,...,Is ,Js =0
|I +J | 2 |I +J | 2 ∂ 1 1 f s s f · · · ∂ , µm,,R,S, ( p) ( p) I1 ,···Is ,J1 ,···Js J J I I s 1 ∂z 1 ∂z ∂z s ∂z
m where µm,,R,S, I1 ,···Is ,J1 ,··· ,Js ≥ 0 are numerical constants not depending on p, and s = 2 . This
can be seen by induction easily. The concrete form of the coefficients µm,,R,S, I1 ,··· ,Is ,J1 ,··· ,Js ∞ is not important for the following argument. Now we define for f ∈ C (Cn ) a non-negative function φ p ( f ) : N2sn −→ [0, ∞) by
|I +J | 2 |Is +Js | 2 ∂ 1 1 f ∂ f ( p) · · · ( p) . φ p ( f )(I1 , . . . , Is , J1 , . . . , Js ) = J1 Js I I s 1 ∂z ∂z ∂z ∂z p,
Then we can interpret h m,,R,S ( f ) as the ‘integral’ of φ p ( f ) over N2sn with respect to the
weighted counting measure d µm,,R,S, determined by the coefficients µm,,R,S, I1 ,··· ,Is ,J1 ,··· ,Js , i.e.
p, φ p ( f ) d µm,,R,S,. h m,,R,S ( f ) = N2sn
Now let K, L ⊆ Nn be finite subsets and define the polynomial f (K,L) (z, z) =
1 ∂ |I +J | f ( p)(z − p) I (z − p) J . I !J ! ∂z I ∂z J I ∈K J ∈J
Then we clearly have φp
f − f
(K,L)
!
(I1 ,...,Is ,J1 ,...,Js )
=
0 if I1 , . . . , Is ∈ K, J1 , . . . , Js ∈ L φ p ( f ) otherwise. (3.17)
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
35
Thus when K, L exhaust Nn , the function φ p ( f − f (K,L) ) converges pointwise and monotonically to zero, i.e. for K ⊆ K and L ⊆ L we have φ p f − f (K,L) ≥ φ p f − f (K ,L ) , and for all I1 , . . . , Is , J1 , . . . , Js , lim φ p f − f (K,L) (I1 , . . . , Is , J1 , . . . , Js ) = 0 K,L→Nn
in the sense of net convergence for the net of finite subsets of Nn . Now an order of summation in (3.15) corresponds to a strictly increasing sequence Ki × Li ⊆ Nn × Nn which exhausts Nn × Nn . Then
p, lim h m,,R,S f − f (Ki ,Li ) = lim φ p f − f (Ki ,Li ) d µm,,R,S, = 0 i→∞
i→∞
by dominated convergence. But this is equivalent to the unconditional convergence of (3.15), see also [29, Sect. 14.6, Thm. 1]. We now come to the main result of this section: Theorem 3.10. The locally convex topology of A p, is complete, i.e. A p, is a Fréchet space. Proof. Since the topology is determined by countably many seminorms we only have to consider Cauchy sequences and not Cauchy nets. Thus let f i ∈ A p, be a Cauchy p, sequence, i.e. for all seminorms · m,,R,S and all > 0 we find a K (m, , R, S, ) such that for i, j ≥ K we have fi − f j
p, m,,R,S
< .
We first evaluate this for m = 1, = 1, R, S = 0. Let f i (z, z) =
∞ I,J =0
1 (i) a (z − p) I (z − p) J I !J ! I J (i)
be the Taylor expansion of f i then from (3.13) we see that the Taylor coefficients a I J form a Cauchy sequence for each I, J . Denote their limit by a I J = lim a (i) IJ i→∞
(∗)
and define f (z, z) =
∞ I,J =0
1 a I J (z − p) I (z − p) J . I !J !
(∗∗)
Then we want to show f ∈ A p, and f i → f . To this end we first choose a smooth function f˜ ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) with Taylor coefficients at p given by (∗), which is possible p, thanks to the Borel Lemma. Since f i is a Cauchy sequence with respect to · m,,R,S
36
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann p,
the sequence of seminorms f i m,,R,S stays bounded as i → 0. Thus we can again use the measure-theoretic point of view and write with the notation from the previous proof
p, h m,,R,S f˜ = φ( f˜) d µm,,R,S, 2sn N
= lim φ( f i ) d µm,,R,S, N2sn i→∞
= lim inf φ( f i ) d µm,,R,S, N2sn i ≤ lim inf φ( f i ) d µm,,R,S, N2sn m+1 p, sup( f i m,,R,S )2 i i
≤
< ∞,
p, and hence f as in (∗∗) is the unique real-analytic by Fatou’s Lemma. Thus f˜ ∈ A representative in A p,. Next we compute using (3.16), p,
f − f i m,,R,S ≤ ( f − f i ) − ( f − f i )(N ,M) +
(N ,M) fj
−
m,,R,S
(N ,M) p,
+ f (N ,M) − f j
m,,R,S
(N ,M) p, fi m,,R,S
≤ ( f − f i ) − ( f − f i )(N ,M) + fj −
p,
p, f i m,,R,S
p, m,,R,S
(N ,M) p,
+ f (N ,M) − f j
m,,R,S
.
Now we fix > 0 and K such that the last term is smaller than /3 for i, j > K . For such an i we fix N , M such that the first term is smaller than /3 thanks to Theorem 3.9. Finally, for this choice of N , M we can find j large enough that the second term is smaller than /3 since we have two polynomials of fixed degree (N , M) whose p, coefficients converge. This finally proves f i → f with respect to · m,,R,S . 4. The Continuity of Wick From Proposition 3.7 we know that on the subspace C[z, z] ⊆ A p, the Wick star product Wick is well-defined and continuous with respect to the topology of A p,. Since on the other hand C[z, z] is a dense subspace by Theorem 3.9 the Wick star product extends uniquely to a continuous product on A p, which thereby becomes a Fréchet algebra. However, from this abstract extension we cannot yet conclude whether the formula (2.3) with λ being replaced by is still true. Thus we need an additional argument. Let ∈ {0, . . . , 2m − 1} be written as = m−1 2m−1 + · · · + 1 2 + 0 with m−1 , . . . , 0 ∈ {0, 1}. Then we define = (−1)m−1 +···+0 . With this notation we can prove the following continuity property of the partial derivatives: Proposition 4.1. Let f ∈ C ∞ (Cn ) then we have ! p, p, ∂ |I +J | f
f m,,R+I,S+J for = +1 |I +J | (2) ≤ p,
f m,,R+J,S+I for = −1. ∂z I ∂z J m,,R,S
(4.1)
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
37
Proof. Clearly, for m = 0 (and hence = 0) we even have the equality ∂ |I +J | f (2)|I +J | ∂z I ∂z J
p, 0,0,R,S
p,
= f 0,0,R+I,S+J
p, by the very definition of · 0,0,R,S . Thus we prove the claim by induction on m. Let first be even and = +1. Then /2 = +1 as well and we have by induction
∂ |I +J | f |I +J | (2) ∂z I ∂z J 2 ∞ R N +S 1 R N +S p, ≤ K L h m−1,/2,K +I,L+J ( f ) N! N =0 K =0 L=0 2 R+I N +S+J ∞ 1 R N +S p, = K −I L−J h m−1,/2,K ,L ( f ) N! N =0 K =I L=J 2 R+I N +S+J ∞ 1 R+I N +S+J p, h m−1,/2,K ,L ( f ) ≤ K L N!
p, h m,,R,S
≤
N =0 K =I L=J p, h m,,R+I,S+J ( f ) . p,
For = /2 = −1 we get h m,,R+J,S+I ( f ) instead and the two cases with odd are analogous. From Theorem 3.9 we see that the polynomials ζ pI J (z, z) = (z − p) I (z − p) J
(4.2)
form a countable unconditional topological basis for A p,. The proposition now implies that we even have a Schauder basis: Corollary 4.2. The polynomials {ζ pI J } I,J ∈Nn form an unconditional Schauder basis for A p,. Proof. By Theorem 3.9 we have the unconditional convergence f =
∞ I,J =0
1 IJ δ ( f )ζ pI J , I !J ! p
and the (I, J )th derivative δ pI J of the δ-functionals are continuous linear functionals on A p, by Proposition 4.1. This implies the result, see e.g. [29, Sect. 14.2] for a definition of a Schauder basis. The next proposition shows that the pointwise product is continuous in the topology of A p,: Proposition 4.3. Let f, g ∈ C ∞ (Cn ). Then we have p,
p,
p,
f g m,,R,S ≤ f m+1,,R,S g m+1,,R,S , whence A p, is a Fréchet ∗ -algebra with respect to the pointwise product.
(4.3)
38
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Proof. First recall that from the explicit form of the Wick star product we obtain |I +J | 2 f p, |I +J | ∂ (2) ∂z I ∂z J ( p) ≤ h 0,0,I,J ( f ) .
(∗)
Now we first consider the case m = 0. Here we have by the Leibniz rule p,
h 0,0,R,S ( f g)
2 R N +S |I +J | f ∂ |R−I +N +S−J | g R N +S ∂ ( p) I J I ∂z J ∂z R−I ∂z N +S−J ∂z N =0 I =0 J =0 R N +S |R−I +N +S−J | 2 ∞ ∂ (2)|N +R+S| R N +S ∂ |I +J | f g ≤ ∂z I ∂z J ( p) ∂z R−I ∂z N +S−J ( p) I J N! N =0 I =0 J =0 2 R N +S ∞ R N +S p, (∗) 1 p, ≤ h 0,0,I,J ( f ) h 0,0,R−I,N +S−J (g) I J N! N =0 I =0 J =0 R N +S R N +S ∞ R N +S p, 1 R N +S p, ≤ I J h 0,0,I,J ( f ) I J h 0,0,I,J (g) N! N =0 I =0 J =0 I =0 J =0 2 R N +S R N +S p, ∞ 1 ≤ I J h 0,0,I,J ( f ) N! N =0 I =0 J =0 2 R N +S R N +S p, ∞ 1 × I J h 0,0,I,J (g) N! N =0 I =0 J =0 p, p, = h 1,0,R,S ( f ) h 1,0,R,S (g), ∞ (2)|N +R+S| = N!
using twice the Cauchy Schwarz inequality in the last steps. For m ≥ 1 we proceed by a straightforward induction for the two cases of even and odd separately. Corollary 4.4. A p, is a Fréchet-Poisson ∗ -algebra. Proof. Clearly, the canonical Poisson bracket is continuous as { f, g} is the sum of pointwise products of partial derivatives of f and g. Combining the last two propositions we can finally show the continuity of the Wick star product: we even show that the series (2.3) converges in the topology of A p, if we replace λ by any complex number α: Theorem 4.5. The Wick star product f αWick g =
∞ (2α)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g N! ∂z N ∂z N N =0
(4.4)
converges absolutely in the topology of A p, for all α ∈ C and gives a continuous associative product. If α = > 0 then A p, becomes a Fréchet ∗ -algebra with respect ∗ to Wick as the product and the complex conjugation as the -involution.
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
39
Proof. Let f, g ∈ A p, then we have for even and = +1, ∞ (2α)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g N! ∂z N ∂z N N =0
m,,0,0
∞ |2α||N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g N! ∂z N ∂z N N =0
≤ Prop. 4.3
≤
p,
∞ |2α||N | ∂ |N | f N! ∂z N
N =0 ∞ Prop. 4.1 | α ||N |
≤
N =0
N!
p, m,,0,0
p,
∂ |N | g
m+1,,0,0
p,
∂z N
p, m+1,,0,0
p,
f m+1,,N ,0 g m+1,,0,N
∞ α |N | ∞ α |N | 2 2 | | | | p, p,
f m+1,,N ,0
g m+1,,0,N ≤ N! N! N =0 N =0 ∞ 2 √ Prop. 3.3 | α ||N | 2m+3 p, ≤ N ! f m+2,2+1,0,0 N! N =0 ∞ α |N | 2 √ | | 2m+3 p, × N ! g m+2,2,0,0 N! N =0 ∞ | α ||N | 2m+2 √ p, p, = N ! f m+2,2+1,0,0 g m+2,2,0,0 . N! N =0 " #$ % =cm ( α )
Since cm ( α ) converges for all α ∈ C we have shown the convergence of (4.4) with p,
respect to · m,,0,0 for even and = +1. The other three cases are shown analop,
gously. As the topology of A p, is already determined by the seminorms · m,,0,0 the absolute convergence in the topology of A p, follows. From the above estimate (and the analogous ones for odd , etc.) one also obtains the continuity of αWick . If α = is real, then the complex conjugation is a ∗ -involution showing the last statement. Corollary 4.6. The Wick star product αWick is a holomorphic deformation of the pointwise product in the sense of [43]. Corollary 4.7. For f, g ∈ A p, we have f Wick g
p, m,,R,S
p,
p,
≤ f m+1,2m +,R,S g m+1,,R,S .
(4.5)
Proof. This follows from Proposition 3.7, the density of C[z, z] in A p, and the continuity of Wick .
40
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Though A p, becomes a Fréchet ∗ -algebra, the topology is not locally m-convex in the sense of [37], see also [43, App. A]. Recall that a locally convex algebra is called locally m-convex if there exists a set of seminorms · i defining the topology such that ab i ≤ a i b i . Such locally m-convex algebras always have a holomorphic calculus. Recall that a entire holomorphic calculus means that for any algebra element a and any entire holomorphic function f (a) is well-defined as convergent series. This property fails for A p,: Example 4.8. We consider the entire function f ∈ O(C) defined by f (z) =
∞ zr . √ 4 r! r =0
(4.6)
Then it is easy to see that f Wick f evaluated at z = 0 converges only for = 0. Since clearly the δ-functional δ p : A p, −→ C is continuous we conclude that f ∈ A0,. This shows that A0, does not allow a holomorphic functional calculus, as z ∈ A0, and the Wick -Taylor expansion of f would again coincide with f since the Wick -power of z coincides with the corresponding pointwise powers. Analogous arguments apply also for p = 0 and higher dimensions n ≥ 1. Corollary 4.9. The topology of A p, is not locally m-convex with respect to the Wick star product αWick for all α and there is no general holomorphic calculus for A p,. In the following we shall equip A p, always with the Wick star product Wick . Remark 4.10. At this point it would be interesting to compare our algebra to the construction obtained in [40]: Here the authors consider the Weyl-Moyal star product, which on the formal level is known to be equivalent to the Wick star product, and establish a convergence scheme to obtain a certain Fréchet algebra as the completion of the polynomials. However, their construction is rather different from ours whence it seems difficult to investigate whether the usual formal equivalence transformation survives the convergence conditions. 5. Translations and Rescalings We shall now discuss the dependence of A p, on the point p ∈ Cn and on the value > 0. We start with the dependence on the point p. Let α ∈ Cn then for f ∈ A p, we define
and
(τα f )(z, z) = fˆ(z + α, z)
(5.1)
(τ α f )(z, z) = fˆ(z, z + α),
(5.2)
which is well-defined according to Theorem 3.6, Part iii). Moreover, we consider the functions eα,β (z, z) = eαβ eαz+βz , (5.3) which are elements in A p, according to Theorem 3.6, Part iv). The following lemma is a simple computation, the results of which are well-known in the case of the formal Wick star product:
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
41
Lemma 5.1. Let α, β, γ , δ ∈ Cn . Then we have for all f ∈ A p,: (αδ−βγ ) e 1. eα,β α+γ ,β+δ . Wick eγ ,δ = e 2. eα,β Wick f = eα,β τ 2α f . 3. f Wick eα,β = eα,β τ2β f . 4. The maps τα and τ α are continuous linear bijections
τα , τ α : A p, −→ A p,.
(5.4)
Proof. The only non-trivial point here is that for f ∈ A p, we have τα f =
∞ α N ∂ |N | f , N ! ∂z N
N =0
and analogously for τ α since f has a extension to fˆ ∈ O×O(Cn × Cn ). Then the computations for the first three parts are folklore. The last part follows from α τα f = e0,− 2
α f Wick e0, 2
(∗)
and the continuity of the pointwise multiplication as well as of the continuity of Wick . The same argument applies for τ α . From (∗) one can easily work out explicit estimates p, p, for τα f m,,R,S and τ α f m,,R,S using Proposition 4.3 and Corollary 4.7. Corollary 5.2. Let α, β ∈ Cn . 1. eα,β ∈ A p, is invertible with respect to Wick with inverse given by e−α,−β . 2. eα,β is unitary iff α = −β since in general eα,β = eβ,α . We introduce now the following notation. For w ∈ Cn we denote the translation by w by Tw (z) = z + w whence we have the corresponding pull-back on functions (Tw∗ f )(z) = f (z + w). Moreover, we set uw = e
1 1 2 w,− 2 w
∈ A p,,
(5.5)
which is a unitary element of A p, according to Corollary 5.2. Proposition 5.3. The translation group Cn acts via pull-backs by continuous inner ∗ automorphisms Tw∗ = AdWick (u w ) (5.6) on A p,. Proof. This is a simple consequence of Lemma 5.1 and the fact that u w is unitary. Remark 5.4. We remark that on a heuristic level (or on polynomial functions only) the statement of this proposition is folklore. Note that it is clear that for the formal Wick star product the statement is wrong: the translations are only outer automorphisms as the elements u w are not well-defined as formal series in λ. In fact, it was one of our main motivations to find a reasonably large algebra where the statement of the proposition is still true, extending the polynomials.
42
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
The fact that the translations act by inner automorphisms will immediately imply the following result: Theorem 5.5. Let p, p ∈ Cn . Then A p, = A p ,
(5.7)
as Fréchet ∗ -algebras. Proof. Let f ∈ A p, be given and w = p − p. Then we have on one hand p ,
f m,,R,S = Tw∗ f
p, m,,R,S
<∞
since ∂ |I +J | f
∂ |I +J | (Tw∗ f )
∂z I ∂z
∂z I ∂z J
( p ) = J
( p),
p,
and in the definition of · m,,R,S only the Taylor coefficients of f at p are used while the combinatorial coefficients in the construction are the same for all points p , p. This shows f ∈ A p , whence by symmetry the equality (5.7) as vector spaces follows. On the other hand we have p ,
f m,,R,S = u w Wick f Wick u −w
≤
p,
m,,R,S p, p,
u w m+1,2m +,R,S f m+2,2m+1 +,R,S
p,
u w m+2,,R,S .
p ,
This shows that the seminorms · m,,R,S can be estimated against the seminorms p,
· m,,R,S whence the topology of A p , is coarser than the one of A p,. By symmetry p ↔ p we see that they actually coincide. The algebraic structures are the same anyway whence the theorem is shown. Thus we see a posteriori that the construction of the Fréchet algebra A p, does not depend on our choice p ∈ Cn . Hence we can simply write A = A p, from now on. p, Note however, that the system of seminorms · m,,R,S depends on the choice of p, only the induced topology is independent of p. As in the formal case, all δ-functionals are positive: Corollary 5.6. All δ-functionals δ p : A −→ C
(5.8)
are continuous positive linear functionals. Proof. The positivity is clear from (4.4) with α = > 0 and the continuity follows p, from the theorem as |δ p ( f )| ≤ f 0,0,0,0 . Corollary 5.7. The Fréchet topology of A is finer than the topology of pointwise convergence.
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
43
In the next step we want to analyze the continuity properties of the group representation w → Tw∗ further. To this end we consider the dependence of the elements u w on w. Since i − 2 Im(wv) u w u w+v , (5.9) Wick u v = e i
the map w → u w is not a group morphism. Since e− 2 Im(wv) is even a non-trivial group cocycle we need to pass to the central extension of the translation group Cn by this cocycle, i.e. to the Heisenberg group Hn . Here we use the convention that Hn = Cn × R with multiplication law (w, c) · (w , c ) = (w + w , c + c + Im(ww )).
(5.10)
Then it follows that i
Hn (w, c) → u (w,c) = e− 2 c u w ∈ U(A)
(5.11) i
is a group morphism from Hn into the group of unitaries U(A) in A. Since e− 2 c is central, (5.11) factors to the group morphism w → Tw∗ , i.e. we have AdWick (u (w,c) ) = AdWick (u w ) = Tw∗
(5.12)
for all (w, c) ∈ Hn . The Lie algebra hn of Hn can be identified with Hn via the exponential map. Then the Lie bracket is given by [(w, c), (w , c )] = (0, 2 Im(ww )). The next theorem shows that the group morphism Hn −→ U(A) is analytic and induces a Lie algebra morphism hn −→ A: Theorem 5.8. 1. The map hn ∼ = Hn (w, c) → u (w,c) is analytic with respect to the topology of A. 2. The generator J(w,c) of the one-parameter group t → u (tw,tc) is given by 1 d i (wz − wz), J(w,c) (z, z) = u (tw,tc) = − c + (5.13) d t t=0 2 2 and hn (w, c) → J(w,c) ∈ A is a Lie algebra morphism where A is equipped with the Wick -commutator as Lie bracket. 3. We have for all k, dk u (tw,tc) = J(w,c) · · · J(w,c) , (5.14) "Wick #$ Wick% d t k t=0 k times
and explicitly for c = 0, k/2 dk k! ww wz − wz k−2 − u (tw,0) = . d t k t=0 !(k − 2)! 4 2
(5.15)
=0
i
ww
1
i
ww
Proof. We have u (w,c) (z, z) = e− 2 c− 4 + 2 (wz−wz) . The first factors e− 2 c and e− 2 are clearly analytic as they are analytic functions times a fixed element (the identity) in A. For the remaining factor we see that the (z, z)-Taylor expansion, which converges unconditionally in the topology of A coincides up to numerical factors with the (w, w)Taylor expansion of this function. Thus the (w, w)-Taylor expansion converges also in A unconditionally which shows the first part. The second part is a trivial computation.
44
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
For the third part, the contribution of c is not essential whence we discuss the case c = 0 only. A straightforward computation of the Taylor expansion in t gives immediately (5.15). On the other hand, the kth power of the linear function Jw = J(w,0) satisfies the recursion formula Jwk = Jw Jw(k−1) + (k − 1)
ww (k−2) J , 2 w
which follows easily from the fact that partial derivatives are derivations of Wick and ∂ ww w ∂z Jw = 2 is central. In a last step one shows that also the right-hand side of (5.15) satisfies this recursion with the same initial conditions for k = 0, 1. Corollary 5.9. Let w ∈ Cn then the Wick -exponential function Exp (t Jw ) =
∞ k t k=0
k!
Jw · · · Jw = u tw "Wick #$ Wick%
(5.16)
k times
converges unconditionally in the topology of A for all t ∈ R. Remark 5.10. Again, the importance of this corollary is not the explicit computation of the star exponential which is folklore. Instead, we have found a well-defined analytic framework where the formula actually converges inside an algebra of functions. Note also that in general we cannot expect such a convergence as A does not allow a holomorphic functional calculus in general. Let us now discuss the dependence on the parameter . From a simple dimensional analysis we see that with our convention for the Poisson bracket {z k , z } = 2i δ k the 1
coordinates have to have the physical dimension [action] 2 . Thus a rescaling of , which physically is of course absurd, has to be reinterpreted as a rescaling of the coordinates (z, z): we are not changing the value but the unit system. On the other hand, from a purely mathematical point of view we cannot distinguish these two interpretations. As we do not have any additional absolute scale in our approach, the corresponding algebras A and A should be isomorphic in order to be physically reasonable. The following theorem will show that this is indeed the case. We define for α > 0 the diffeomorphism Rα : Cn −→ Cn , Rα (z) =
√ αz,
(5.17)
whose inverse is R 1 . α
Theorem 5.11. The pull-back Rα∗ induces an isomorphism of Fréchet ∗ -algebras Rα∗ : Aα −→ A.
(5.18)
In particular, we have for all f ∈ Aα , Rα∗ f
0, m,,R,S
= f 0,α m,,R,S .
(5.19)
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
45
Proof. Let f ∈ Aα be given. Then we have ∂ |I +J | (Rα∗ f ) ∂z I ∂z J
=
√
α
|I +J |
Rα∗
∂ |I +J | f ∂z I ∂z J
,
and thus Rα∗ f
0, 0,0,R,S
∞ (2)|N +R+S| N!
=
N =0 ∞
=
N =0
|N +R+S| ∗ 2 ∂ (Rα f ) (0) ∂z R ∂z N +S
(2α)|N +R+S| N!
|N +R+S| 2 ∂ f (0) ∂z R ∂z N +S
= f 0,α 0,0,R,S .
Since the higher seminorms are constructed in a purely combinatorial way out of ∗
· 0, 0,0,R,S , we can conclude (5.19). This shows that Rα : Aα −→ A is an isomorphism of Fréchet spaces as we can exchange the role of and α by passing from α to α1 . Then it is easy to see that Rα∗ is an algebra morphism: we use the convergence of (4.4) and the continuity of Rα∗ to obtain ∞ (2α)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g Rα∗ ( f αWick g) = Rα∗ N! ∂z N ∂z N N =0
∞ (2)|N | ∂ |N | (Rα∗ f ) ∂ |N | (Rα∗ g) = N! ∂z N ∂z N
=
N =0 Rα∗ f
∗ Wick Rα g.
The compatibility with the complex conjugation Rα∗ f = Rα∗ f is obvious. Remark 5.12. Of course we can also directly compare the seminorms for different values of . Clearly, one has 0,
f 0, (5.20) 0,0,R,S ≤ f 0,0,R,S for ≤ whence by induction
0,
f 0, m,,R,S ≤ f m,,R,S
(5.21)
as well. For ≤ this gives the inclusion A ⊆ A.
(5.22)
6. The GNS Construction and Coherent States We shall now discuss the GNS construction corresponding to the positive δ-functionals δ p : A −→ C, now in the convergent situation.
(6.1)
46
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Proposition 6.1. Let p ∈ Cn . Then the Gel’fand ideal of δ p is given by ∂ |I | f ( p) = 0 , (6.2) J p = f ∈ A ∀I : ∂z I and the GNS pre-Hilbert space D p = A J p is a Fréchet space in the natural way, where the topology of D p is determined by the seminorms p, p,
[ f ] m,,R,S = inf f + g m,,R,S g ∈ J p . (6.3) Proof. The statement (6.2) is obvious. Since δ p is continuous, the Gel’fand ideal is a closed subspace of A. Thus the quotient D p is again a Fréchet space by general arguments, see e.g. [29, Sect. 4.4, Prop. 1]. Since the translation group acts by inner ∗ -automorphisms we can safely specialize to the case p = 0 in a first step. Then we can describe the quotient D0 more explicitly: Theorem 6.2. Let f, g ∈ A. 1. The z-Taylor expansion : A −→ A defined by ∞ 1 ∂ |I | f I (0)z : f → z → f (z) = I ! ∂z I
(6.4)
I =0
is a continuous projection with ker = J0 . In fact, f
0, m,,R,S
(6.5)
≤ f 0, m,,R,S ,
(6.6)
where equality holds if and only if f is anti-holomorphic. 2. The quotient D0 is canonically isomorphic as a Fréchet space to the image D = im of via D0 [ f ] → f ∈ D. (6.7) In particular,
[ f ] 0, m,,R,S = f
0, m,,R,S
.
(6.8)
3. The space D is a dense subspace of the Bargmann-Fock Hilbert space HBF . The map (6.7) is an isometry of pre-Hilbert spaces and the Fréchet topology of D is finer than the topology induced from the Hilbert space HBF . 4. The GNS representation on D0 induces via (6.7) the Bargmann-Fock representation of A on D, explicitly given by ∞ ∞ |I | (2)|I | 1 ∂ |I +J | f J ∂ g (0)z , (6.9) π( f )g = J I! J ! ∂z I ∂z ∂z I I =0
J =0
where both series converge in the topology of D. 5. The bilinear map A × D ( f, g ) → π( f )g ∈ D is continuous with respect to the Fréchet topologies of A and D, respectively.
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
47
Proof. For the first part we have f (z) = fˆ(0, z) whence f is indeed a well-defined anti-holomorphic function. Moreover, (6.6) is clear from our consideration in the proof of Theorem 3.9 since in the seminorm of f simply less Taylor coefficients contribute compared to the corresponding seminorm of f . Thus f ∈ A and is continuous. From the explicit form of the equality (6.5) and 2 = are obvious. For the second part we first notice that (6.7) is well-defined and bijective since f − f ∈ ker = J0 , using the fact that is a projection. Moreover, (6.8) follows directly from (6.6) since 0, obviously [ f ] 0, m,,R,S ≤ f m,,R,S . Since the inverse of (6.7) is simply given by the well-defined and continuous map f → [ f ], we see that (6.7) is indeed an isomorphism of Fréchet spaces. For the third part we compute explicitly the GNS inner product on D0 , [ f ], [g] D0 = δ0 ( f Wick g) =
∞ (2)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g (0) (0) N N! ∂z N ∂z N =0
∞ ∂ |N | g (2)|N | ∂ |N | f (0) (0) N N! ∂z ∂z N N =0 & ' = f , g BF ,
=
whence (6.7) is isometric. In particular D ⊆ HBF follows, as &
f,f
'
0, 2 = ( f Wick f )(0) = ( f 0,0,0,0 ) < ∞.
BF
(∗)
Since C[z] ⊆ D ⊆ HBF , the subspace D is dense in HBF . Moreover, since f 0, 0,0,0,0 = 0,
f 0,0,0,0 the estimate (∗) implies that the Fréchet topology of D is finer than the topology induced from HBF . This shows the third part. For the fourth part recall that the GNS representation is defined by ( f )[g] = [ f Wick g] which translates via (6.7) into π( f )g = f
Wick g
= (∞
N =0
(a)
=
(2)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g N! ∂z N ∂z N
∞ (2)|N | ∂ |N | f N! ∂z N
N =0 ∞
∂ |N | g ∂z N
(2)|N | ∂ |N | f ∂ |N | g N! ∂z N ∂z N N =0 ∞ ∞ |N | (2)|N | 1 ∂ |N +M| f g M ∂ = (0) z , N N! M! ∂z N ∂z M ∂z (b)
=
N =0
M=0
where (a) holds since is continuous and (b) holds since obviously is a homomorphism of the pointwise product. Finally, in the last step we have used that commutes with derivatives in the z-direction. This shows the fourth part and the last part follows immediately from π( f )g = f g = f g and the continuity of and Wick . Wick Wick
48
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Corollary 6.3. The Bargmann-Fock representation of A is injective. The following corollary is remarkable in so far as closed subspaces of Fréchet spaces usually do not have complementary closed subspaces: Corollary 6.4. The algebra A decomposes into two complementary closed subspaces A = D ⊕ J0 . Remark 6.5. Since the Bargmann-Fock representation is injective and since π(z i ) = 2
∂ ∂z i
= ai ,
π(z i ) = z i = ai†
(6.10) (6.11)
are the annihilation and creation operators we find another interpretation of the algebra A: it is a (rather large) completion of the polynomials in the creation and annihilation operators in a certain Fréchet topology. In particular, this completion contains the usual unitary generators of the Weyl algebra, i.e. the exponential functions of ai and ai† . They are given by π(eα,β ) for suitable α, β ∈ Cn . Remark 6.6. Since the Bargmann-Fock representation is a ∗ -representation of the ∗ -algebra A by (in general) unbounded operators with common domain D, one can investigate the resulting O ∗ -algebra of unbounded operators by techniques as developed in e.g. [45]. In particular, it would be interesting to find more concrete characterizations of the Fréchet topologies of D and A. We now discuss the action of the translation group Cn and its central extension Hn . The following statement is obvious, the representation itself being well-known: Lemma 6.7. The map Hn (w, c) → U(w,c) = π(u (w,c) ) ∈ U(HBF )
(6.12)
is a strongly continuous unitary representation of the Heisenberg group. Explicitly, i
ww
wz
(U(w,c) ψ)(z) = e− 2 c− 2 e− 2 ψ(z + w)
(6.13)
for ψ ∈ HBF . It factors to a projective representation Uw = U(w,0) of the translation group Cn . Proof. Since π is a ∗ -representation it follows that π(u (w,c) ) is a unitary operator defined on the dense domain D. Thus it extends to a unitary operator on HBF . The group representation property is obvious from (5.11). The explicit formula is a simple consequence of (6.9). The fact that (6.12) is strongly continuous is well-known& but can also' be shown within our approach directly: let φ, ψ ∈ D, then g(w, c) = ψ, U(w,c) φ BF is realanalytic since ·, · BF and π are continuous with respect to the Fréchet topology and (w, c) → u (w,c) is real-analytic according to Theorem 5.8. Since g(0, 0) = ψ, φ BF we see that on the dense domain D the representation (6.12) is weakly continuous at the identity. But this implies that it is strongly continuous on the whole group Hn and on the whole Hilbert space HBF . Since the contribution of c is only an overall phase, the representation clearly factors to a projective representation of Cn .
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
49
Since we have a group action of Hn we can formulate now the following covariance property of the Bargmann-Fock representation which is an obvious consequence of the fact that the ∗ -automorphisms are inner. Theorem 6.8. The Bargmann-Fock representation is Hn -covariant with respect to the action by ∗ -automorphisms on A and the action by unitaries on HBF , i.e. we have ∗ = Uw π( f )Uw∗ π(AdWick (u (w,c) ) f ) = U(w,c) π( f )U(w,c)
(6.14)
for all (w, c) ∈ Hn and f ∈ A. Since the GNS representation is cyclic with cyclic vector 1 = 1 we obtain coherent states with respect to the representation of Hn . We define the coherent state vector ψ(w,c) ∈ HBF by −1 ψ(w,c) = U(w,c) ψ1 (6.15) explicitly given by i
ww
wz
ψ(w,c) (z) = e 2 c+ 4 e 2 .
(6.16)
From the covariance property (6.14) we immediately have the following characterization of the δ-functionals at arbitrary points in Cn : Corollary 6.9. The coherent state vectors give the δ p -functionals as expectation value functionals, i.e. we have & ' (6.17) δw ( f ) = ψ(w,c) , π( f )ψ(w,c) BF for all f ∈ A and (w, c) ∈ Hn . In particular, the group action of Hn on the coherent state vectors factors through to a group action of the translation group Cn on the coherent states δw : A −→ C. Remark 6.10. This corollary gives finally the justification to view the δ-functionals of the Wick star product algebra as coherent states with respect to the translation group. Though the explicit formula (6.16) is folklore (it is just the Bergmann kernel) we would like to emphasize that in our approach the coherent states emerge out of properties of the observable algebra instead of more conventional approaches based on group actions on the state vectors in some Hilbert space, see e.g. [42, 48] for more references. In this sense our approach supports the idea that the observable algebra is the more fundamental object in both quantum and classical mechanics. Remark 6.11. We also note that the statement of Theorem 6.8 as well as the Corollary 6.9 are not possible for the formal Bargmann-Fock representation. Again, this was one of our main motivations to consider a suitable convergence scheme for the Wick star product. The result of Theorem 6.8 and Corollary 6.9 suggest the following general definition of coherent states with respect to some symmetry based on the observable algebra: Definition 6.12. Let A be a ∗ -algebra with unit 1 and let G be a group acting on A by g : A −→ A. Let ω be a state of A such that the GNS representation is G-covariant, i.e. there exists a unitary (or more general: projectively unitary) representation U of G on the GNS pre-Hilbert space Hω . Then the states ωg with ' & (6.18) ωg (a) = (ω ◦ g )(a) = ψg , π(a)ψg ,
∗ -automorphisms
where ψg = Ug∗ ψ1 ∈ Hω are called coherent with respect to G.
50
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
Clearly, in case of a projective representation only the coherent states ωg are welldefined, while for a unitary representation also the coherent state vectors ψg are welldefined. With the Heisenberg group acting on A and the δ-functional we are in this situation: if the action is realized by inner ∗ -automorphisms then the representation is always covariant for a (in general only projective) representation on the GNS pre-Hilbert space. Note also, that for an invariant state ω the GNS representation is trivially covariant. In this case ψg = ψ1 coincides with the vacuum vector for all g ∈ G. Thus the interesting coherent states arise from non-invariant vacua such that the GNS representation is nevertheless covariant. For a survey on covariant ∗ -representation theory for ∗ -algebras over ordered rings we refer to [28]. Let us now come to a further property of the subspace D ⊆ HBF . We have already seen that the action of Hn leaves D invariant. Theorem 6.13. The vectors in D are analytic with respect to the unitary representation U of Hn . Proof. Let ψ ∈ D be fixed, then we have to show that Hn (w, c) → U(w,c) ψ is analytic with respect to the topology of HBF . But this is simple since U(w,c) ψ = π(u (w,c) )ψ and (w, c) → u (w,c) is analytic in the topology of A. Moreover, the bilinear map ( f, ψ) → π( f )ψ is continuous in the topologies of A and D. Thus the map (w, c) → U(w,c) ψ is analytic with respect to the topology of D. Since by Theorem 6.2 this topology is finer than the one of HBF , the proof is complete. Thus it would be interesting to know whether D coincides with the space of all analytic vectors. A positive answer would help to understand the (still rather complicated) Fréchet topology of D and hence the one of A. Using the convergence of the star exponential (5.16) we even can specify the analyticity of the vectors in D further. Since π is continuous with respect to the topologies of A and D, we have ∞ r 1 π J(w,c) ψ U(w,c) ψ = π(u (w,c) )ψ = π Exp(J(w,c) ) ψ = r!
(6.19)
r =0
with respect to the topology of D. Again, since the topology of D is finer than the one of HBF , the series converges unconditionally also in the Hilbert space sense. As usual, the contribution of c is not essential. Corollary 6.14. Let ψ ∈ D and w ∈ Cn . Then the series r n ∞ 1 1 r i i † w ai − w ai ψ Uw ψ = r ! 2 r =0
(6.20)
i=1
converges unconditionally in the Hilbert space topology. Of course we can also rewrite this in terms of the position and momentum operators 1 1 (ak + ak† ) = π(z k + z k ) 2 2
(6.21)
1 1 (ak − ak† ) = π(z k − z k ), 2i 2i
(6.22)
Qk = and Pk =
Convergence of the Wick Star Product
51
defined as unbounded symmetric operators on D. Then (6.19) shows that for ψ ∈ D we have the unconditionally convergent series ∞ i p· Q 1 ip · Q r e ψ= ψ (6.23) r! r =0
and e
iq· P
∞ 1 iq · P r ψ= ψ r!
(6.24)
r =0
in the Hilbert space topology, for all q, p ∈ Rn , substituting w suitably. Of course, this also follows by ‘Hilbert space techniques’ from the strong continuity of the representation U and Theorem 6.13. Note however, that the above argument using the convergence of the star exponential is independent. Acknowledgement. We would like to thank Pierre Bieliavsky, Martin Bordemann, Nico Giulini, Simone Gutt, Nikolai Neumaier, Konrad Schmüdgen, Martin Schlichenmaier and Rainer Verch for valuable discussions on this example. Moreover, S. W. thanks the ULB for hospitality while part of this work was being done.
References 1. Bargmann, V.: On a Hilbert Space of Analytic Functions and an Associated Integral Transform, Part I. Comm. Pure Appl. Math 14, 187–214 (1961) 2. Bayen, F., Flato, M., Frønsdal, C., Lichnerowicz, A., Sternheimer, D.: Deformation Theory and Quantization. Ann. Phys. 111, 61–151 (1978) 3. Bertelson, M., Cahen, M., Gutt, S.: Equivalence of Star Products. Class. Quant. Grav. 14, A93– A107 (1997) 4. Bieliavsky, P.: Strict Quantization of Solvable Symmetric Spaces. J. of Symp. Geom. 1.2, 269–320 (2002) 5. Bordemann, M., Meinrenken, E., Schlichenmaier, M.: Toeplitz quantization of Kähler manifolds and gl(N ), N → ∞ limit. Commun. Math. Phys. 165, 281–296 (1994) 6. Bordemann, M., Neumaier, N., Pflaum, M.J. Waldmann S.: On representations of star product algebras over cotangent spaces on Hermitian line bundles. J. Funct. Anal. 199, 1–47 (2003) 7. Bordemann, M., Neumaier, N., Waldmann, S.: Homogeneous Fedosov Star Products on Cotangent Bundles I: Weyl and Standard Ordering with Differential Operator Representation. Commun. Math. Phys. 198, 363–396 (1998) 8. Bordemann, M., Neumaier, N., Waldmann, S.: Homogeneous Fedosov star products on cotangent bundles II: GNS representations, the WKB expansion, traces, and applications. J. Geom. Phys. 29, 199–234 (1999) 9. Bordemann, M., Waldmann, S.: A Fedosov Star Product of Wick Type for Kähler Manifolds. Lett. Math. Phys. 41, 243–253 (1997) 10. Bordemann, M., Waldmann, S.: Formal GNS Construction and States in Deformation Quantization. Commun. Math. Phys. 195, 549–583 (1998) 11. Bursztyn, H., Waldmann, S.: On Positive Deformations of ∗ -Algebras. In: Dito, G., Sternheimer, D. (eds.): Conférence Moshé Flato 1999. Quantization, Deformations, and Symmetries. Math. Phys. Studies no. 22, Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Acad. Pub., 2000 12. Bursztyn, H., Waldmann, S.: Hermitian star products are completely positive deformations. Lett. Math. Phys. 72, 143–152 (2005) 13. Cahen, M., Gutt, S., Rawnsley, J.: Quantization of Kähler Manifolds I: Geometric Interpretation of Berezin’s Quantization. J. Geom. Phys. 7, 45–62 (1990) 14. Cahen, M., Gutt, S., Rawnsley, J.: Quantization of Kähler Manifolds. II. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 337.1, 73–98 (1993) 15. Cahen, M., Gutt, S., Rawnsley, J.: Quantization of Kähler Manifolds. III. Lett. Math. Phys. 30, 291– 305 (1994) 16. Cahen, M., Gutt, S., Rawnsley, J.: Quantization of Kähler Manifolds. IV. Lett. Math. Phys. 34, 159– 168 (1995) 17. Deligne, P.: Déformations de l’Algèbre des Fonctions d’une Variété Symplectique: Comparaison entre Fedosov et DeWilde, Lecomte. Sel. Math. New Series 1.4, 667–697 (1995) 18. DeWilde, M., Lecomte, P.B.A.: Existence of Star-Products and of Formal Deformations of the Poisson Lie Algebra of Arbitrary Symplectic Manifolds. Lett. Math. Phys. 7, 487–496 (1983)
52
S. Beiser, H. Römer, S. Waldmann
19. Dito, G., Sternheimer, D. (eds.): Conférence Moshé Flato 1999. Quantization, Deformations, and Symmetries. Mathematical Physics Studies no. 22. Dordrecht-Boston-London Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000 20. Dito, G., Sternheimer, D.: Deformation quantization: genesis, developments and metamorphoses. In: Halbout, G. (eds.): Deformation quantization, Vol. 1 in IRMA Lectures in Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, Berlin, New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2002, pp. 9–54 21. Dubois-Violette, M., Kriegl, A., Maeda, Y., Michor, P.: Smooth ∗-Algebras. In: Maeda, Y., Watamura, S. (eds.): Noncommutative Geometry and String Theory, Vol. 144 in Prog. Theo. Phys. Suppl., (Yukawa Institute for Theoretical Physics, March 2001. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Noncommutative Geometry and String Theory), pp. 54–78 22. Fedosov, B.V.: Quantization and the Index. Sov. Phys. Dokl. 31.11, 877–878 (1986) 23. Fedosov, B.V.: Index Theorem in the Algebra of Quantum Observables. Sov. Phys. Dokl. 34.4, 319–321 (1989) 24. Fedosov, B.V.: Deformation Quantization and Index Theory. Berlin: Akademie Verlag 1996 25. Gutt, S.: Variations on deformation quantization. In: Dito, G., Sternheimer, D. (eds.): Conférence Moshé Flato 1999. Quantization, Deformations, and Symmetries, Mathematical Physics Studies no. 21, Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000, pp. 217–254 26. Gutt, S., Rawnsley, J.: Equivalence of star products on a symplectic manifold; an introduction to Deligne’s ˇ Cech cohomology classes. J. Geom. Phys. 29, 347–392 (1999) 27. Hansen F.: Quantum Mechanics in Phase Space. Rep. Math. Phys. 19, 361–381 (1984) 28. Jansen, S., Waldmann, S.: The H -covariant strong Picard groupoid. J. Pure Appl. Alg. 205, 542– 598 (2006) 29. Jarchow, H.: Locally Convex Spaces. Stutt: B. G. Teubner, 1981 30. Kammerer, J.B.: Analysis of the Moyal product in a flat space. J. Math. Phys. 27, 529–535 (1986) 31. Karabegov, A.V.: Deformation Quantization with Separation of Variables on a Kähler Manifold. Commun. Math. Phys. 180, 745–755 (1996) 32. Karabegov, A.V.: On Fedosov’s approach to Deformation Quantization with Separation of Variables. In: Dito, G., Sternheimer, D. (eds.): Conférence Moshé Flato 1999. Quantization, Deformations, and Symmetries. Math. Phys. Studies no. 22, Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Acad. Pub., 2000 33. Karabegov, A.V., Schlichenmaier, M.: Identification of Berezin-Toeplitz deformation quantization. J. Reine Angew. Math. 540, 49–76 (2001) 34. Kontsevich, M.: Deformation Quantization of Poisson manifolds. Lett. Math. Phys. 66, 157–216 (2003) 35. Landsman, N.P.: Mathematical Topics between Classical and Quantum Mechanics. Springer Monographs in Mathematics. Berlin, Heidelberg, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1998 36. Maillard, J.-M.: On the twisted convolution product and the Weyl transformation of tempered distributions. J. Geom. Phys. 3.2, 230–261 (1986) 37. Michael, E.A.: Locally multiplicatively-convex topological algebras. Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. no. 11. Providence, RI: AMS, 1952 38. Nest, R., Tsygan, B.: Algebraic Index Theorem. Commun. Math. Phys. 172, 223–262 (1995) 39. Nest, R., Tsygan, B.: Algebraic Index Theorem for Families. Adv. Math. 113, 151–205 (1995) 40. Omori, H., Maeda, Y., Miyazaki, N., Yoshioka, A.: Deformation quantization of Fréchet-Poisson algebras: convergence of the Moyal product. In: Dito, G., Sternheimer, D. (eds.): Conférence Moshé Flato 1999. Quantization, Deformations, and Symmetries. Math. Phys. Studies no. 22, Dordrecht-Boston-London: Kluwer Acad. Pub., 2000, pp. 233–245 41. Omori, H., Maeda, Y., Yoshioka, A.: Weyl Manifolds and Deformation Quantization. Adv. Math. 85, 224– 255 (1991) 42. Perelomov, A.: Generalized coherent states and their applications. Texts and Monographs in Physics. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1986 43. Pflaum, M.J., Schottenloher, M.: Holomorphic deformation of Hopf algebras and applications to quantum groups. J. Geom. Phys. 28, 31–44 (1998) 44. Rieffel, M.A.: Deformation Quantization of Heisenberg Manifolds. Commun. Math. Phys. 122, 531– 562 (1989) 45. Schmüdgen, K.: Unbounded Operator Algebras and Representation Theory, Vol. 37 in Operator Theory: Advances and Applications. Basel, Boston, Berlin: Birkhäuser Verlag, 1990 46. Waldmann, S.: States and Representation Theory in Deformation Quantization. Rev. Math. Phys. 17, 15– 75 (2005) 47. Weinstein, A., Xu, P.: Hochschild cohomology and characteristic classes for star-products. In: Khovanskij, A., Varchenko, A., Vassiliev, V. (eds.), Geometry of differential equations. Dedicated to V. I. Arnold on the occasion of his 60th birthday, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. 1998 pp. 177–194 48. Yaffe, L.G.: Large N limits as classical mechanics. Rev. Mod. Phys. 54.2, 407–435 (1982) Communicated by A. Connes
Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 53–74 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0192-8
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata Torbjørn Helvik1 , Kristian Lindgren2 , Mats G. Nordahl3 1 Department of Mathematical Sciences, Norwegian University of Science and Technology,
NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway. E-mail:
[email protected]
2 Department of Physical Resource Theory, Chalmers University of Technology and Göteborg University,
SE-41296 Göteborg, Sweden
3 Department of Applied Information Technology, Chalmers University of Technology and Göteborg
University, SE-41756 Göteborg, Sweden Received: 21 July 2005 / Accepted: 4 September 2006 Published online: 2 March 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: We introduce a local version of the Shannon entropy in order to describe information transport in spatially extended dynamical systems, and to explore to what extent information can be viewed as a local quantity. Using an appropriately defined information current, this quantity is shown to obey a local conservation law in the case of one-dimensional reversible cellular automata with arbitrary initial measures. The result is also shown to apply to one-dimensional surjective cellular automata in the case of shift-invariant measures. Bounds on the information flow are also shown. 1. Introduction A number of authors have suggested that information should be viewed as a fundamental physical quantity, starting with the vision of “It from Bit” of Wheeler [27] and the fundamental work on the thermodynamics of computation by Landauer [14] and Bennett [1]. Information theory also has a close relation to the foundations of statistical mechanics, e.g., through the information theoretic formulation introduced by Jaynes [11], where entropy is viewed as a measure of the ignorance of the actual microstate of the system. Information theory and computation theory can also be used to define an entropy for individual microstates in spatially extended systems [17, 28]. In a microscopic view, information or entropy quantified in terms of the Gibbs H-function is a globally conserved quantity due to Liouville’s theorem. A natural question to consider is to what extent this statement has a local analogue in spatially extended dynamical systems. This article explores this question for one-dimensional reversible or surjective cellular automata. Precise statements of the notion of conservation of information, and possible extensions of this formalism to other systems, could provide a more solid foundation for the use of information based concepts in different physical systems. We first introduce a local version of the Shannon entropy. In a one-dimensional system, the local information is defined in terms of the conditional probability of a local
54
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
state given its left or right infinite context. Information can only be completely localized in a system without correlations. Thus, the measure we introduce is localized to the extent that correlations allow, and reduces to a completely local quantity when correlations vanish. However, even with correlations present, this quantity does obey a local continuity equation with an appropriately defined information current. For cellular automata, local conservation of information was first proposed by Toffoli [23], who derived a continuity equation for information transport in the case of small perturbations around the uncorrelated equlibrium states of particle conserving reversible cellular automata, such as lattice gases. Here we investigate how these concepts can be applied to a wider class of dynamical systems and to arbitrary measures, and how they can be given a rigorous formulation. We only consider one-dimensional systems; generalizations to systems in higher dimensions will be addressed in future work. We first consider reversible cellular automata, where the cellular automaton mapping has an inverse. Reversible cellular automata have been used to simulate physical systems, e.g., for microcanonical simulations of spin systems (e.g., [25]), and simulations of fluid dynamics [4, 7], and chemical reactions [2]. They have also been used as illustrative examples of fundamental issues in statistical mechanics [21, 22]. For one-dimensional reversible cellular automata, we show local conservation of information for any initial measure, including measures without shift-invariance. We also consider the more complicated case of surjective cellular automata, where the global mapping is finite-to-one [8]. In this case, local conservation of information is shown for all shift-invariant measures. For the simple case of permutative rules, we are able to describe the information flow in more detail. The aim of the article is to explore exactly to what extent information can be viewed as a local quantity in spatially extended systems. The main results show that important aspects of locality remain also in systems with correlations. We also give examples which illustrate the limits of locality in the formalism. The rest of this article is organized as follows. Section 2 contains background material on shift spaces and cellular automata. In Sect. 3 we introduce a local measure of information and show that it is well-defined. Section 4 contains the main results of the paper. We first define the information current, and prove that information is locally conserved for one-dimensional reversible cellular automata. We then extend this result to surjective cellular automata. In Sect. 5, we give an information theoretic interpretation of the current, and provide bounds on the information flow. We also characterize the information flow in permutative cellular automata, and study some examples illustrating the limits of locality. Section 6 contains conclusions and a discussion. 2. Preliminaries 2.1. The shift space. We study dynamical systems on the space AZ of all bi-infinite symbol sequences over a finite set A. For x ∈ AZ we write x = (xi )i∈Z . The length j j − i + 1 block (xi , xi+1 , . . . , x j ) of symbols from A will be written as xi . Likewise, i x−∞ = (. . . , xi−1 , xi ). The shift map σ is defined on AZ by σ (x)i = xi+1 . A probability measure µ on (AZ , B), where B is the Borel σ -algebra, is defined by assigning a probability µ(Cyl(aii+n )) to each cylinder set Cyl(aii+n ) = {x ∈ AZ : xii+n = aii+n } in a consistent way, see [26, §0.2]. We will usually write this probability µ(aii+n ), thus letting aii+n represent both the symbol block of length n +1 and the cylinder set. It is often convenient to consider the measure µ as defining a discrete, stochastic
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
55
process (X n )∞ n=−∞ , X n ∈ A, with joint distributions given by Prob(X i = ai ) = µ(ai ). A measure is said to be Bernoulli if the coordinate random variables X i are all indepenj
−1 )= dent and identically distributed. The conditional probability µ(a0 |a−n −1 X −n
−1 a−n .
j
0 ) µ(a−n −1 µ(a−n )
j
is the
= probability that X 0 = a0 given that The measure µ is shift-invariant if it satisfies µ(σ −1 (B)) = µ(B) for all cylinder sets B. When µ is shift-invariant, the expectation E[ f ] of any measurable function f on AZ satisfies E[ f ] = E[ f ◦ σ ]. The Shannon entropy h(µ) of a shift-invariant measure µ can be written as h(µ) = − lim
n→∞
−1 0 µ(a−n ) log µ(a0 |a−n ).
(1)
0 ∈An+1 a−n
2.2. Cellular automata. One-dimensional cellular automata (CA) are discrete dynamical systems on AZ that commute with the shift σ . Definition 1. A cellular automaton F : AZ → AZ is a dynamical system that can be defined by non-negative integers l, r and a map f : Al+r +1 → A, such that (F x)i = f (xi−l , xi−l+1 , . . . , xi+r ) ∀ i ∈ Z.
(2)
The left and right radii of F are the smallest such integers l and r for which there is a block map f (CA rule) that generates F. Example 1. Let A = {0, 1}, and denote by F1 the simple CA on AZ defined by the radii l = 0 and r = 1 and the block map f : A2 → A given by f (x0 , x1 ) = x0 + x1 (mod 2). The global map F1 can be written as F1 (x) = x + σ (x), where addition is coordinate-wise and modulo 2. For any n ≥ 1, the block map f can be extended in a natural way to a map f n : Al+r +n+1 → An+1 by putting r +n r r +1 r +n f n (x−l ) = ( f (x−l ), f (x−l+1 ), . . . , f (xn−l )).
(3)
We will omit the subscript n and write f for the block map applied to a block of any length. For reversible CA, F has an inverse map, so that each bi-infinite sequence y ∈ AZ has exactly one preimage under F. The inverse map of a reversible CA is always itself a CA [20], but the inverse CA does not necessarily have the same radii as F (see, e.g., [24]). Example 2. Denote by F2 the reversible CA on {0, 1, 2}Z having radii l = 0, r = 1 and block map given by f (10) = f (11) = f (12) = 0, f (01) = f (20) = f (22) = 1 and f (00) = f (02) = f (21) = 2. The preimage x of a given y ∈ AZ is found by the following procedure. If yi = 0 we must have xi = 1. If yi = 1 then xi = 2 unless yi+1 = 0, in which case xi = 0. Finally, if yi = 2 then xi = 0 unless yi+1 = 0, in which case xi = 2. The inverse CA F˜2 also has l = 0 and r = 1, but a different block map f˜.
56
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
A more general class of CA are the surjective ones, where all y ∈ AZ have at least one preimage. The class of surjective CA includes all linear CA [10] and other permutative CA [8]. It is well known that a one-dimensional CA F is surjective if and only if all finite blocks have the same number of pre-images under f [8]. That is, if for all n ≥ 1 and n+r ∈ Al+r +n that satisfy f (z n+r ) = y n . y1n ∈ An there are exactly |A|l+r blocks z 1−l 1 1−l Furthermore, there is a constant M(F) ≤ |A|l+r such that each bi-transitive x ∈ AZ has exactly M(F) preimages. For surjective CA one can define Welch coefficients. Let x1n ∈ An with n ≥ l + r . A compatible right extension of x1n of length m is a collection B ⊂ Am such that for each z 1m ∈ B, the (n+m−l−r )-block f (x1n z 1m ) is the same. Define the integer R(F) as the maximal number of elements in any compatible right extension of any length m and of any block x1n . Define compatible left extensions and L(F) in the same way. The coefficients L(F) and R(F) are finite, and satisfy the relation L(F) · M(F) · R(F) = |A|l+r [8, Th. 14.9]. 3. Local Information The intent of introducing a local information quantity is to measure how much information that is located at each position of an infinite symbol sequence generated by some stochastic process. However, the correlations in such symbol sequences can in general be arbitrarily long, and it is impossible for information to be completely localized. The natural approach is therefore to define the local information as a limit which converges to a local analogue of the Shannon entropy as more and more distant neighbours are taken into account. While the Shannon entropy is limited to shift-invariant measures, we can define left local information for any measure. Definition 2. Let µ be a measure on AZ . The left local information at coordinate i of x ∈ AZ with respect to µ is given by i−1 SL (x; i; µ) = − lim log µ(xi |xi−n ). n→∞
(4)
i−1 The quantity − log µ(xi |xi−n ) is the information gained from the symbol at position i when only knowledge of the n left symbols is assumed. If, and only if, µ is Markov there i−1 is a fixed n such that SL (x; i; µ) = − log µ(xi |xi−n ). We will often use the intuitive i−1 notation − log µ(xi |x−∞ ) for SL (x; i; µ). The following theorem ensures that the left local information with respect to µ is a well-defined function on the probability space (AZ , B, µ). i−1 ) converges µ-almost everywhere and in Theorem 1. For each i ∈ Z, − log µ(xi |xi−n L 1 (µ). Consequently, for each fixed measure µ, SL (x; i; µ) ∈ L 1 (µ).
The validity of the theorem follows from the martingale convergence theorem, see, e.g., [12, Th. 3.1.10]. Note that from L 1 -convergence and (1) it follows that E[SL (x; i; µ)] = h(µ) for all i in the shift-invariant case. The local information SL (x; i; µ) depends on the measure µ. However, for a shiftinvariant measure µ the left local information at position i of x can be recovered with i probability one from x−∞ only by considering the empirical measure νx obtained from i , the frequencies of finite blocks in x−∞
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
νx (a1n ) = lim
N →∞
N −1 1 1Cyl(a1n ) (σ i−n−k x). N
57
(5)
k=0
If µ is ergodic, then νx = µ a.e. However, even when µ is only shift-invariant it suffices to look at the local information with respect to νx . Theorem 2. Let µ be a shift-invariant measure on AZ and νx the empirical measure i generated by x−∞ . Then SL (x; i; µ) = SL (x; i; νx ) µ-a.e. Proof. The result follows since the infinite history determines with probability one which ergodic component of µ x is generated by, see Lemma 8.6.2. in [6].
We can also define the right local information at coordinate i of x with respect to µ as i+n SR (x; i; µ) = − lim log µ(xi |xi+1 ). n→∞
(6)
All results we show for the left information will have corresponding results for the right information. However, although the left and right information have the same expectation for all shift-invariant measures, they are not equal nor do they in general have the same probability distribution. This is exemplified by the Markov measure on {0, 1, 2}Z defined by the following non-zero transition probabilities: p(0|0) = p(1|0) = 21 ; p(0|1) = p(2|1) = 21 ; p(0|2) = p(1|2) = 21 . 4. Information Transport In this section we investigate the transport of local information in the time-evolution of a one-dimensional surjective cellular automaton. We show that the left local information satisfies a continuity equation involving an information current JL , and supply an expression for this current. Let µ0 be a measure on AZ . The measure F(µ0 ) = µ0 ◦ F −1 gives the joint disi+r ) when (X ) tributions of the stochastic process (Yi )i∈Z with Yi = f (X i−l i i∈Z has joint 0 0 −1 1 distributions given by µ . Denote µ ◦ F by µ and, more generally, set µt = µ0 ◦ F −t . The block probabilities of µ1 can be calculated from n+r µ0 (z −l ). (7) µ1 (y0n ) = n+r ∈ f −1 (y n ) z −l 0
It is well known that h(µ1 ) = h(µ0 ) whenever F is surjective and µ0 is shiftinvariant (if F is non-surjective, this relation is replaced by h(µ1 ) ≤ h(µ0 )), see, e.g., [16]. Our goal is to prove the much stronger result that the local information obeys a local continuity equation under the time evolution of the CA. This is an equation of the form t SL + i JL = 0,
(8)
where JL (x; i; µ) is the information current. The operator is the forward difference operator, so that t SL (x; i; µt ) = SL (F(x); i; µt+1 ) − SL (x; i; µt ), i JL (x; i; µt ) = JL (x; i + 1; µt ) − JL (x; i; µt ).
(9)
58
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
x
τ
i-1
i
Z
y i+r −1 i+r −1 Fig. 1. An illustration of Z = Z (x−∞ ) and τ = τ (x−∞ ). In this case r = 2, |Z | = 4 and τ = i − 4. The circles represent symbols in A. These are connected by lines to semi-infinite sequences which all map to the i−1 same y−∞ and coincide with x at all j ≤ τ .
With these definitions, JL (x; i; µt ) can be interpreted as the information flow from position i − 1 to position i generated by applying the CA. Note that the local information of F(x) is taken with respect to a different measure than x, unless µt happens to be invariant for the CA. i i For a semi-infinite sequence x−∞ , define Z (x−∞ ) as the set of all semi-infinite i (see Fig. 1): sequences that have the same image and the same tail as x−∞ i Definition 3. For x ∈ AZ and a surjective CA F, define the sets Z (x−∞ ) as j
j
i i i i Z (x−∞ ) = {z −∞ : f (z −∞ ) = f (x−∞ ) and ∃ j ≤ i such that z −∞ = x−∞ }. i Note that |Z (x−∞ )| ≤ R(F) for all x by the definition of the Welch coefficient R(F). i i ) Define τ (x−∞ ) as the largest index less than i − r for which all sequences in Z (x−∞ coincide (recall that r is the right radius of F): i Definition 4. For x ∈ AZ , define τ (x−∞ ) ∈ Z as j
j
i i i τ (x−∞ ) = max{ j : j < i − r, and z −∞ = x−∞ ∀ z −∞ ∈ Z (x−∞ )}. j
We are now ready to define the information current. Definition 5. Let F be a surjective one-dimensional CA with right radius r , and µ a i+r −1 i+r −1 ) and τ = τ (x−∞ ). Define the left information measure on AZ . Put Z = Z (x−∞ current at coordinate i of x with respect to µ and F as −1 τ τ JL (x; i; µ) = − log µ(xτi−1 µ(z τi+r (10) +1 |x −∞ ) + log +1 |x −∞ ). Z i−1 τ τ The quantities µ(z τi−1 +1 |x −∞ ) are defined as lim n→∞ µ(z τ +1 |x τ −n ). Since JL is constructed entirely from conditional probabilities of this type, an analogue to Theorem 2 yields
JL (x; i; µ) = JL (x; i; νx ) µ-a.e. i ) τ (x−∞
(11)
< i − r included in Def. 4. In the Note that τ < i − 1, by the requirement that case of a reversible CA, the existence of an inverse CA ensures that τ is bounded below. Let r˜ be the right radius of the inverse CA. Then τ ≥ i − 1 − r˜ unless r˜ = 0, in which case τ = i − 2. For non-reversible CA, τ is in general unbounded but always finite. It remains to show that JL (x; i; µ) is well defined as a function on (X, B, µ). This is ascertained by the following lemma, whose proof follows from the martingale convergence theorem.
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
59
Lemma 1. For any measure µ on AZ , −1 −k−1 −1 |x−n ) exists for all k ≥ 0 and all a−k ∈ Ak }) = 1. µ({x : lim µ(a−k n→∞
It is furthermore the case that JL (x; i; µ) ∈ L 1 (µ), see Theorem 5 in Sect. 5.3. We now proceed to present Theorems 3 and 4, which are the main results of the paper. The first theorem states that for reversible CA the continuity equation is valid for all initial measures. Theorem 3. Let F be a reversible one-dimensional CA, and µ a measure on AZ . Then t SL (x; i; µ) + i JL (x; i; µ) = 0 for all i ∈ Z µ-a.e. For a general surjective CA, the requirement of µ being shift-invariant is necessary to ensure the validity of the continuity equation. Theorem 4. Let F be a surjective one-dimensional CA, and µ a shift-invariant measure on AZ . Then t SL (x; i; µ) + i JL (x; i; µ) = 0 for all i ∈ Z µ-a.e. Example 3 in Sect. 5 shows that the continuity equation as defined above can fail to be valid if µ is not shift-invariant and F is surjective without being reversible. Note that if one of the theorems is valid for a CA F together with an initial measure µ0 , then the continuity equation will be satisfied at all time steps of the iteration by F. Proof (of Theorem 3). We first show that it is sufficient to consider the case r = 0. Here, and in the rest of the proof, we look at the initial measure µ0 and its image µ1 . Assume that Theorem 3 is valid for CA with r = 0, and let F have right radius r . There exist a CA G with r = 0 such that F = σ r ◦ G. We have SL (F x; i; µ1 ) = i+r −1 i+r ), ), τ2 = τ (x−∞ SL (Gx; i + r ; µ1 ), since F(µ0 ) = G(µ0 ) = µ1 . Write τ1 = τ (x−∞ i+r −1 i+r Z 1 = Z (x−∞ ) and Z 2 = Z (x−∞ ). Using the formula for JL , we obtain i+r −1 SL (Gx; i + r ; µ1 ) = − log µ0 (xi+r |x−∞ ) −1 τ1 − log µ0 (xτi+r |x−∞ ) + log 1 +1
−1 τ1 µ0 (z τi+r |x−∞ ) 1 +1
Z1
+ log µ
0
(xτi+r |x τ2 ) − log 2 +1 −∞
µ0 (z τi+r |x τ2 ). 2 +1 −∞
(12)
Z2
Since τ1 ≤ i − 2 and τ2 ≤ i − 1 by definition, we can write τ2 i+r i |x τ2 ) = log µ0 (xτi 2 +1 |x−∞ ) + log µ0 (xi+1 |x−∞ ), log µ0 (xτi+r 2 +1 −∞
and
(13)
60
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl i+r −1 −1 τ1 − log µ0 (xi+r |x−∞ ) − log µ0 (xτi+r |x−∞ ) 1 +1
i−1 i+r i = − log µ0 (xτi−1 |x τ1 ) − log µ0 (xi |x−∞ ) − log µ0 (xi+1 |x−∞ ). 1 +1 −∞
(14)
Substituting (13) and (14) into (12) gives the correct continuity equation for F. For the rest of the proof we assume that F has right radius r = 0, and left radius l ≥ 0. We look only at coordinate i = 0. This leads to no loss of generality. Call the ˜ and let F˜ have left radius l˜ and right radius r˜ . Sequences at time t = 0 inverse CA F, are denoted by x or z and sequences at time t = 1 by y. We first define the joint measure ν of two consecutive time steps. Let ν be the measure on (A × A)Z defined by the block probabilities j
j
j
j
j
ν(xi , yi ) = µ0 ({z i−l ∈ A j−i+l+1 |z i = xi
and
j
j
f (z i−l ) = yi }).
(15)
It is easy to show that ν actually is a measure and that ν is shift-invariant if µ0 is shiftj j invariant. By summing over all possible yi or xi we obtain from the definition that j j j j ν(xi ) = µ0 (xi ) and ν(yi ) = µ1 (yi ). We will need the following lemma, which follows from the martingale convergence theorem. Z Lemma 2. Let ν be a measure on AZ 1 × A2 , where each Ai is a finite set. Let (x, y) ∈ Z Z 1 A1 × A2 . Then there is a g ∈ L (ν) such that for any k ∈ Z, −1 −1 , y−n ) = g ν-a.e. lim ν(x0 , y0 |x−n−k
(16)
n→∞
Let y = F(x). From the definition of local information we have −1 SL (x; 0; µ0 ) = − lim log µ0 (x0 |x−n ) n→∞ −1 −1 , y−n+l ) ν(x0 , y0 |x−n −1 −1 = lim log − log ν(x0 , y0 |x−n , y−n+l ) −1 n→∞ µ0 (x0 |x−n )
= lim log n→∞
0 0 ) ν(y−n+l |x−n
−1 −1 ν(y−n+l |x−n )
(17)
−1 −1 − lim log ν(x0 , y0 |x−n , y−n+l ) n→∞
−1 −1 , y−∞ ) = − log ν(x0 , y0 |x−∞ 0 0 ) = ν(y −1 |x −1 ) = 1 for all n > l, |x−n by virtue of Lemma 2 and the fact that ν(y−n+l −n+l −n 0 0 through the local map f and since y−n+l in this case is uniquely determined by x−n −1 −1 likewise for y−n+l and x−n . A similar treatment of SL (y; 0; µ1 ) yields
SL (y; 0; µ1 ) = lim log n→∞
|y 0 ) −n+l˜ −n −1 ν(x −1 ˜|y−n ) −n+l ν(x 0
−1 −1 − log ν(x0 , y0 |x−∞ , y−∞ ).
(18)
When taking the difference t SL , the last term is canceled out, so −1 0 |y 0 ) − lim log ν(x −1 ˜|y−n ). t SL (x; 0; µ0 ) = lim log ν(x−n+ l˜ −n n→∞
n→∞
−n+l
To conclude the proof, we show that −1 ) = JL (x; 0; µ0 ) − lim log ν(x −1 ˜|y−n n→∞
−n+l
(19)
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
61
through a sequence of transformations. Firstly, −1 −1 −1 −˜r −1 −1 log ν(x −1 ˜|y−n ) = log ν(x −˜r −1˜ |y−n ) + log ν(x−˜ r |x ˜ , y−n ). −n+l
−n+l
−n+l
(20)
−1 The first term on the right hand side is zero, since x −˜r −1˜ is uniquely determined by y−n −n+l through the local map f˜ of the inverse CA. For the second term, a generalization of Lemma 2 gives −1 −˜r −1 −1 −1 −˜r −1 −1 lim log ν(x−˜ ˜ , y−n ) = lim log ν(x −˜r |x −n−l , y−n ). r |x
n→∞
−n+l
n→∞
(21)
Furthermore, for any events A, B and C in a probability space it is true that ν(A|BC) = ν(C|AB)ν(A|B) −1 −˜r −1 −1 . Let A = x−˜ ν(C|B) r , B = x −n−l and C = y−n . Then ν(C|AB) = 1. Thus, −1 −˜r −1 −1 −1 −˜r −1 0 −1 −˜r −1 log ν(x−˜ r |x −n−l , y−n ) = log µ (x −˜r |x −n−l ) − log ν(y−n |x −n−l ).
By the definition of ν, the last term can be written as −1 −˜r −1 −1 −˜r −1 |x−n−l ) = − log µ0 (z −˜ − log ν(y−n r |x −n−l ).
(22)
(23)
−1 Z (x−∞ )
Substituting (23) into (22) and taking the limit n → ∞ we arrive at the equation for JL (x; 0; µ0 ) presented in Def. 5.
For general surjective CA, there is no inverse CA and in general several possible preimages. As a consequence, the proof of Theorem 4 requires a different approach. Proof (of Theorem 4). By the same argument as in the proof of Theorem 3 it suffices to consider right radius r = 0. As before, we only look at coordinate i = 0 and consider the initial measure µ0 and its image µ1 . Let y = F(x), and define q(x) = SL (y; 0; µ1 ) − SL (x; 0; µ0 ) + JL (x; 1; µ0 ) − JL (x; 0; µ0 ).
(24)
Our goal is to prove that q(x) = 0 µ0 -a.e, or equivalently that E[|q|] = 0. To prove this we will introduce a sequence qk of approximations to q which are measurable with respect to finite parts of the history. First, define the following equivalence relation on Al+n+1 for n ≥ 0: n n n n x−l ∼ z −l iff f (x−l ) = f (z −l )
and
−1 −1 x−l = z −l .
(25)
That is, two blocks in Al+n+1 are equivalent if they have the same image under f and n by [z n ]. agree on the first l coordinates. Denote the equivalence class containing z −l −l −1 Z For an x ∈ A we will in particular look at the equivalence classes [x−k−l ] for k ≥ 1. For each k ≥ 1 we have the inclusion −1 −l−k−1 −1 −1 −1 Z (x−∞ ) ⊇ {x−∞ z −l−k : z −l−k ∈ [x−l−k ]}.
(26)
−1 −1 ) is largest index such that all sequences in Z (x−∞ ) agree on and to Recall that τ (x−∞ −1 −1 the left of τ (x−∞ ). Therefore, for all k ≥ −τ (x−∞ ) − 1 Eq. (26) is an equality.
62
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
−1 Define τ k (x) for k ≥ 1 as the analogue of τ obtained when considering [x−k−l ] −1 rather than Z (x−∞ ), −1 −1 ∈ [x−k−l ] ⇒ z −k−l = x−k−l }. τ k (x) = max{ j ≤ −2, and z −k−l j
j
j
(27)
−1 −1 ) iff k ≥ −τ (x−∞ ) − 1. Note that τ k (x) = τ (x−∞ We now define finite versions of the current JL (x; 0; µ0 ) and of q(x). Write τ k for τ k (x) and put for k ≥ 1, τk τk JLk (x) = − log µ0 (xτ−1 µ0 (z τ−1 (28) k +1 |x −k−l ) + log k +1 |x −k−l ), −1 −1 z −k−l ∈[x−k−l ]
and −1 −1 ) + log µ0 (x0 |x−k−l ) + JLk+1 (σ x) − JLk (x). qk (x) = − log µ1 (y0 |y−k
(29)
−1 ] It is straightforward to check that qk (x) → q(x) a.e. by using the properties of [x−k−l and τ k discussed above. Proceeding, we can write |q|dµ0 ≤ |qk |dµ0 + |q − qk |dµ0 . (30)
The theorem will follow if we can prove that both integrals on the right-hand side converge to zero. In order to do this we investigate the stochastic process (gn )n≥0 on AZ defined by gn (x) = n ]) means Here, µ0 ([x−l relationship
µ1 (y0n ) n ]) , µ0 ([x−l
0 n ). n ∈[x n ] µ (z z −l −l −l
n where y0n = f (x−l ).
(31)
The interest in this process is due to the
log gn−1 (x) − log gn (x) = qn (σ n x).
(32)
We will prove that the process (gn )n≥0 is a supermartingale with respect to a filtration that we now will describe. Let P n be the partition of AZ defined by the equivalence relation (25) on Al+n+1 . n ∈ [u]} for all equivalence classes That is, the elements of P n are the sets P[u] = {x : x−l [u] of Al+n+1 . Let Fn = σ (P n ). Then, Fn is the σ -algebra generated by gn . We have to show that Fn ⊆ Fn+1 for all n. This follows if we can show that the partition P n+1 is a n ] of P n . We claim that refinement of P n . Consider a general element P[w−l n ] = n a] P[w−l P[z −l . (33) n ∈[w n ] z −l −l
a∈A
n ] , then P n+1 clearly is a member of the double union. Conversely, if x is If x ∈ P[w−l [x ] −l
−1 −1 −1 n n n n a] in the union, then x in some P[z −l −l = z −l = w−l and f (x −l ) = f (z −l ) = f (w−l ). n ] . The claim follows, and (Fn : n ≥ 0) is a filtration. Thus, x ∈ P[w−l
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
63
To prove that gn is a supermartingale with respect to this filtration we show that E[g |F ] ≤ g . Since each sub-σ -algebra F is finite it suffices to show gn+1 dµ0 ≤ n+1 n n n 0 n gn dµ over any P[u] ∈ P . We find that gn dµ0 = P[u]
n µ0 (x−l )
n ∈[u] x−l
µ1 (y0n ) 1 n n ]) = µ (y0 ). µ0 ([x−l
(34)
For gn+1 , we split the integral into cylinder sets where gn+1 is constant: gn+1 dµ0 = gn+1 (x)dµ0 P[u]
n ∈[u] a∈A x−l
=
n ∈[u] a∈A x−l
=
n a) Cyl(x−l
n µ0 (x−l a)
n a)) µ1 (y0n f (xn−l+1 n a]) µ0 ([x−l
(35)
ψb · µ1 (y0n b),
b∈A
where ψb =
n a) µ0 (x−l n ∈[u] a∈A x−l
n a]) µ0 ([x−l
n · 1{ f (xn−l+1 a)=b} (x).
(36)
We claim that for each b, the quantity ψb is equal either to 0 or to 1. Fix a b. First n a in the double sum in (36) that satisfy f (x n note that all blocks x−l n−l+1 a) = b must n a] = [v]. Conversely, each block z n+1 ∈ [v] generate the same equivalence class [x−l −l n ∈ [x n ] = [u]. Consequently, is an element of the double sum, since it will satisfy z −l −l ψb = 1 by summation of the fractions and cancelation. The exception is the case where n ∈ [u] can be extended with one symbol to the right such that the new block maps no x−l n to y0 b under f . For such b, ψb = 0. We can conclude that gn+1 dµ ≤ 0
P[u]
b∈A
µ
1
(y0n b)
=µ
1
(y0n )
=
gn dµ0 .
(37)
P[u]
Finally, it is easy to prove that E[|g0 |] ≤ |A|l+1 < ∞. This finalizes the proof that gn is a supermartingale, so by the martingale convergence theorem gn converges a.e. to a g ∈ L 1 (µ0 ). We now proceed to show L 1 -convergence of log gn . A family ( f n )n≥0 of measurable functions is uniformly integrable if ([5, Sect. 1.14]) lim sup (| f n | − M)+ dµ = 0. (38) M→∞ n
We claim that (log gn )n≥0 is an uniformly integrable family. Note first that n ]) < 2−t · µ1 (y0n ). log gn (x) > t ⇔ µ0 ([x−l
(39)
64
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
n : µ0 ([x n ]) < 2−t · µ1 ( f (x n ))}. We obtain Define An,t ⊂ Al+n+1 as An,t = {x−l −l −l
µ0 ({log gn > t}) =
n µ0 (x−l )≤
An,t
n 2−t µ1 ( f (x−l ))
An,t
≤
n 2−t µ1 ( f (x−l )) = 2−t · |A|l ,
(40)
Al+n+1
for all n. A simple application of Fubini’s theorem yields ∞ µ0 ({log gn > t}) dt sup (| log gn | − M)+ dµ0 = sup n
n
M
∞
≤ |A|l
2−t dt = 2−M ·
M
|A|l . ln 2
(41)
Thus, uniform integrability is satisfied and limn→∞ E[| log g − log gn |] = 0. From (32) and shift-invariance, lim E[|qn |] = lim E[|qn | ◦ σ n ] = lim E[| log gn−1 − log gn |] = 0.
n→∞
n→∞
n→∞
(42)
Hence, the first integral on the right-hand side in (30) converges to zero. Regarding the second integral on the right-hand side, we know that limn→∞ qn = q a.e. Thus, if we can prove that (qn )n≥0 is itself a uniformly integrable family then we are done. From (32) and the fact that log gn ≥ 0 for all n it follows that {|qn | ◦ σ n > M} ⊆ {log gn−1 > M}
{log gn > M}.
We can conclude that |A|l + 0 , sup (|qn | − M) dµ = sup (|qn ◦ σ n | − M)+ dµ0 ≤ 2−M+1 · ln 2 n n and the result follows.
(43)
(44)
A corresponding continuity equation can also be written for right local information. The right variants of the set Z and variable τ are defined by ∞ Z (xi∞ ) = {z i∞ : f (z i∞ ) = f (xi∞ ) and ∃ j ≥ i such that z ∞ j = x j }, ∞ ∞ ∞ τ (xi∞ ) = min{ j : j > i − l, and z ∞ j = x j ∀ z i ∈ Z (x i )}. j
∞ ) and τ = τ (x ∞ ), and define the right information current at coordinate Put Z = Z (xi−l i−l i of x with respect to µ and F by
JR (x; i; µ) = log µ(xiτ −1 |xτ∞ ) − log
τ −1 ∞ µ(z i−l |xτ ).
(45)
Z
Then, JR (x; i; µ) satisfies the continuity equation t SR (x; i; µ) + i JR (x; i; µ) = 0 at all i ∈ Zµ-a.e., under the same conditions as in Theorem 3 or Theorem 4.
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
65
5. Further Aspects of Information Transport 5.1. Information Theoretic Interpretation. We now describe a way of decomposing JL (x; i) into JL (x; i) = JL+ (x; i) − JL− (x; i),
(46)
with JL+ , JL− ≥ 0, such that JL+ has a natural interpretation in terms of information flowing to the right between coordinates i − 1 and i, and JL− in terms of information flowing to the left. Here, and in the rest of the section, we omit µ from the notation in JL and SL when considering some fixed measure µ. i First recall the definition of Z (x−∞ ) and define i−r i−r i i i . (47) Z 0 (x−∞ ) = z −∞ ∈ Z (x−∞ ) : z −∞ = x−∞ i+r −1 We will consider the set Z 0 (x−∞ ), which consists of the semi-infinite sequences which i+r −1 i+r −1 up to index i − 1. Define JL+ have the same image as x−∞ and coincide with x−∞ − r −1 r −1 r −1 and JL at coordinate i = 0, with τ = τ (x−∞ ), Z = Z (x−∞ ) and Z 0 = Z 0 (x−∞ ), as −1 JL− (x; 0) = − log µ(z r0−1 |x−∞ ), (48) Z0
Z0
JL+ (x; 0) = − log
Z
τ µ(z rτ −1 +1 |x −∞ )
τ µ(z rτ −1 +1 |x −∞ )
.
(49)
It is straightforward to confirm that JL− (x; 0) and JL+ (x; 0) are non-negative and satisfy (46). We first examine JL− . Using the joint measure ν defined in (15) we can write JL− (x; 0) = − lim log
−1 −1 , y−r ) ν(x−n
n→∞
−1 ν(x−n )
−1 −1 = − log ν(y−r |x−∞ ).
(50)
−1 when The equation states that JL− (x; 0) is the information gained by observing y−r −1 −1 having knowledge of x−∞ . This is what one should expect. Indeed, since x−∞ is known, −r −1 is uniquely determined by the CA map. Hence, all the semi-infinite sequence y−∞ −1 −1 , and this uncertainty comes from lack of uncertainty about y−∞ is with respect to y−r −1 −1 −1 ∞ . The quantity − log ν(y−r |x−∞ ) is thus knowledge about the continuation x0 of x−∞ −1 −1 ∞ . This the further information about the continuation x0 found in y−∞ but not in x−∞ ∞ information has been transported from x0 , and adds a negative contribution JL− to the information current. Considering JL+ , we can write
JL+ (x; 0)
Z0
= − lim log n→∞
= − lim log n→∞
−1 µ(z r−n )
r −1 Z µ(z −n ) −1 −1 ν(x−n , y−n+l ) τ , y −1 ) ν(x−n −n+l
−1 τ = − log ν(xτ−1 +1 |x −∞ , y−∞ ).
(51)
66
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
−1 τ Thus, JL+ (x; 0) is the information gained from observing xτ−1 +1 when x −∞ as well as y−∞ −1 r −1 r −1 is determined up to the set Z (x is known. Since y−∞ is known, the preimage x∞ −∞ ). r −1 This is illustrated by Fig. 1, where xτ +1 must be one of the “branches” to the right, but −1 r −1 r −1 which one. However, which member of Z (x−∞ ) that x−∞ it is not decidable from y−∞ −1 actually is will, with probability one, be determined by the continuation y0∞ of y−∞ . −1 τ −1 Therefore, the information − log ν(xτ +1 |x−∞ , y−∞ ) flows to the right and is found to the right of coordinate −1 in y.
5.2. Permutative Cellular Automata. For the class of permutative CA the information dynamics has a particularly simple form. A CA F is called right permutative if R(F) = 1 i or, equivalently, if |Z (x−∞ )| = 1 for all pairs x and i. Thus, for right permutative CA − i−1 ) and (49) gives JL+ ≡ 0. This gives the (48) gives JL (x; i; µ) = − log µ(xii+r −1 |x−∞ following corollary to Theorem 4. Corollary 1. Let µ be any shift-invariant measure on AZ and F : AZ → AZ a right permutative CA with right radius r . Then, µ-almost everywhere, SL (F x; i; µ ◦ F −1 ) = SL (x; i + r ; µ).
(52)
In particular, if r = 0, then SL (F t x; i; µt ) = SL (x; i; µ0 ) for all t ≥ 0 so that the local information is locally constant. As a result of Corollary 1, the distribution of local information will also remain unchanged. Corollary 2. Let µ0 be any ergodic measure on AZ and F : AZ → AZ a right permutative CA. Then, for all measures ν being a weighted sum of the measures µt , t ≥ 0, the random variables SL (x; i; ν) have the same distribution. Note that even though the behaviour of the local information is very simple in the case of permutative CA, the sequence µt of measures generated by a linear CA under iteration is quite complicated. Block probabilities and the structure of correlations in the system varies widely with t [16]. On the other hand, for many bipermutative CA large classes of initial measures weak∗ converge in Cesàro mean to the uniform Bernoulli measure. That is, n−1 1 t k 1 lim µ (a1 ) = n→∞ n |A|k
(53)
t=0
for all k ≥ 1 and finite blocks a1k ∈Ak . This was first proved for the linear CA F = σ +σ −1 on {0, 1}Z with µ0 a Bernoulli measure by Lind [15]. It has later been extended to a larger subclass of the permutative CA and classes of measures [3, 9, 18, 19]. For the uniform Bernoulli measure µ¯ the local information has a uniform distribution, i.e., SL (x; i; µ) ¯ = log |A| for all x and i. We can use the result on Cesàro convergence to demonstrate that convergence of a sequence (µn )n≥0 of measures to a limit measure µ in the weak∗ -topology does not, in any sense, mean that SL (x; i; µn ) converges to SL (x; i; µ). Indeed, let F and µ0 be any combination of a CA and an ergodic measure t such that (53) is valid, and put µn = n1 n−1 t=0 µ . Then µn converges to the uniform Bernoulli measure, but by Corollary 2 all SL (x; 0; µn ) have the same non-uniform probability distribution on R. The reason that the distribution of SL (x; i; µn ) can remain unchanged even though µn → µ, ¯ with µ¯ uniform Bernoulli, is that local information
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
67
takes all correlations in the system into account while the weak∗ topology only considers finite blocks. In this sense local information yields a different, more microscopic, view of the system than the weak∗ topology does. We now use Corollary 1 to demonstrate the necessity of the shift invariance condition on the measure in Theorem 4. Example 3. Let F be the CA σ −1 ◦ F1 , with F1 from Example 1. Let µ0 be the uniform Bernoulli measure on {0, 1}Z , except that x0 always is zero. Then, for all x ∈ AZ we have SL (x; i, µ0 ) = 1 for i = 0 and SL (x; 0, µ0 ) = 0. However, we claim that SL (y; i, µ1 ) = 1 for all i. Each sequence y ∈ AZ has two preimages under f , call them z and w. These have the property that z i and wi always are different, z i = 1 − wi . Assume that z 0 = 0. We obtain
2 j−k 0 if j ≤ 0 ≤ k if j ≤ 0 ≤ k 0 k 0 k , µ (w j ) = . (54) µ (z j ) = j−k−1 j−k−1 2 otherwise otherwise 2 The local information SL (y; i, µ1 ) is the limit n → ∞ of i−1 ) = − log − log µ1 (yi |yi−n
i i µ0 (z i−n−1 ) + µ0 (wi−n−1 ) i−1 i−1 µ0 (z i−n−1 ) + µ0 (wi−n−1 )
.
(55)
In all three cases: i < 0, i = 0 and i > 0, inserting the probabilities from (54) gives i−1 − log µ1 (yi |yi−n ) = 1 for all n. Now assume that t SL + i JL = 0 at all iµ0 -a.e. Since F is right permutative and has r = 0, Corollary 1 states that JL = 0 µ0 -a.e. However, this makes SL (y; 0, µ1 ) = 0, which is not satisfied for the image of any x ∈ AZ . An alternative way to appreciate that SL (y; 0, µ1 ) = 1 for the system in the example −1 does not give any information about x−1 . Therefore, even though is to realize that y−∞ −1 ) = 21 . Note that once y0 is observed, we will have x0 = 0 with certainty, µ1 (y0 |y−∞ −1 perfect knowledge of x−∞ . Thus, information about the preimage that is not contained in the tail of y is made available at some position in the sequence. In similar constructs the information need not appear at a single position as it did in Example 3. A case illustrating this would be to let µ0 (X i = 1) = 41 for all i ≥ 0 and µ0 (X i = 1) = 21 for i ≤ 0. Then the correct preimage will be learnt gradually from observing y0 , y1 , y2 , . . . , since the fraction of 1’s in the preimage block x0n will converge either to 41 or 43 . In this case, the continuity equation will in general not be satisfied at any i ≥ 0, but will be an increasingly better approximation as i increases. Finally in this section, we use a left and right permutative CA to illustrate the difference between SL and SR , and the effect of the choice of a frame of reference on the distribution of information in the system. We consider the CA on {0, 1}Z defined by the radii l = r = 1 and local rule f (x−1 , x0 , x1 ) = x−1 + x0 + x1
(mod 2).
(56)
Let the initial measure µ0 be Bernoulli with a very small probability for a 1, say µ(1) = 2−10 . Assume that i = 0 is the only coordinate in the interval −100 ≤ i ≤ 100 initially having xi = 1. Figure 2 shows the configurations of the interval −50 ≤ i ≤ 50 for all iteration up to time t = 50. Coordinate i = 0 initially has 10 bits of left and right
68
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl 0 White: 0 Black: 1
Time t
10 20 30 40 50 0
50
Coordinate i
Fig. 2. The evolution of the symbol sequence with a single 1 located at i = 0 under the CA rule defined in (56). The left local information from the initial 1 is located at the left boundary of the expanding pattern while the right local information is located at the right boundary.
local information, SL (x; 0; µ0 ) = SR (x; 0; µ0 ) = 10. Let y = F t (x). An observer which knows the left history will by observing y−t = 1 learn that x0 = 1 and gain 10 bits of information. However, from each of the subsequent symbols the observer will gain only − log(1−2−10 ) bits of information. This is in agreement with Corollary 1. On the other hand, an observer knowing the right history will gain the 10 bits of information by observing that yt = 1. Thus, the question about where in the pattern the information generated by the unlikely event {x0 = 1} is located at time t cannot be answered without also taking into account which frame of reference an observer has.
5.3. Bounds on the Current. We first consider bounds for the local information flow. i+r −1 Let τ = τ (x−∞ ). Then, from (46), (48), and monotonicity of log x, −
i+r −1 k=i
SL (x; k) ≤ JL (x; i) ≤
i−1
SL (x; k).
(57)
k=τ +1
Thus, the amount of information that flows from coordinate i − 1 to i is limited by the amount of information available in the intervals [τ + 1, i − 1] and [i, i + r − 1]. The appearance of τ + 1 rather than i − l in the first interval warrants a closer examination, because a perturbation of one symbol in the initial configuration only can propagate a distance l per time step. For reversible CA the existence of an inverse CA ensures that τ + 1 ≥ i − r˜ , where r˜ is the right radius of the inverse CA. Therefore, the distance over which information can flow in a single iteration is uniformly bounded for a given reversible CA. For surjective non-reversible CA, τ is in general unbounded. In the following discussion, assume that r = 0, since this case gives the maximal flow of left local information to the right. We look at coordinate i = 0. The appearance of τ + 1 in (57) is related to the −1 interpretation of JL+ as the information gained by observing xτ−1 +1 when the image y−∞ as τ well as the history x−∞ is known. The second inequality in (57) is an equality if and only −1 leads to no reduction in information gain compared if the additional knowledge of y−∞ τ τ to knowledge of only x−∞ . From (49) this is equivalent to having Z µ(z τ−1 +1 |x −∞ ) = 1. However, since |Z | ≤ R(F) the sum is rarely close to this magnitude, particularly when
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
(a) x
0 1 2 2
1 1
1
0 0 2 2
69
(b) x
0 0 2
0 2 2 0 1 2 n
n
y
2 2 0
0 0 n-1
y
0 1 2
2 2 0 n-1
−1 1 ) for the CA in Example 4 when x −1 = 22 . . . 2 Fig. 3. An illustration of the sets (a) Z (x−∞ ) and (b) Z (x−∞ −n and x−n−2 = x−n−1 = x0 = x1 = 0.
|τ | is large. A further argument that large information flows are improbable is the obser −1 −1 τ τ −s vation that JL (x; i; µ) > s requires µ(xτ−1 Z µ(z τ +1 |x −∞ ) < 2 , so x τ +1 +1 |x −∞ )/ τ must be a very unlikely continuation of x−∞ to generate a large current s. We illustrate these considerations with the following example. Example 4. Let the surjective CA F on {0, 1, 2}Z be defined by the radii l = 1, r = 0 and local function f given by f (10) = f (11) = f (22) = 0, f (12) = f (20) = f (21) = 1 and f (00) = f (01) = f (02) = 2. Unlikely events in this system can generate information flows over large distances in a single iteration. Let µ be Bernoulli with a low probability p = µ(2) for the symbol 2 occurring, and q = µ(0) = µ(1) = 1−2 p . Although p is small, long blocks of successive 2’s will occur −1 −n−2 at some points. Assume that x−n = 22 . . . 2 while x−n−1 = 00 and x03 = 0000. The set −1 Z (x−∞ ) is illustrated to the left in Fig. 3 using the representation introduced in Fig. 1. −1 τ τ For p small, the quantity Z µ(z τ−1 +1 |x −∞ ) is much larger than µ(x τ +1 |x −∞ ), since the −1 ) consist entirely of 0’s and 1’s. It follows from (49) that two other elements in Z (x−∞ + JL is large and an increasing function of the number n of 2’s. Equation (10) yields for 1 ≤ k ≤ n, k q q . (58) JL (x; −n + k; µ) = log 1 + 2 ≈ 1 + k log p p Only approximately − log q bits of information remain at each coordinate −n ≤ i ≤ −1, while the surplus information is transported to the right of i = −1, see Fig. 4. Most of the information is accumulated at position i = 1. The reason is that observing the value 0 y1 = 2 while knowing y−∞ establishes that the actual preimage was the one containing the large block of 2’s, see the right part of Fig. 3. This preimage was highly improbable, and a high local information results. Finally, note that since F is left permutative, the transport of right local information is simply given by JR (x; i; µ) = SL (x; i − 1; µ). i−1 i−l−1 |x−∞ ) can be better appreciated by The possibility that JL (x; i) > − log µ(xi−l recalling that local information SL is defined with respect to an infinite frame of reference. Therefore, a permutation arbitrary far to the left of i can alter the conditional i−1 probability µ(xi |x−∞ ) and hence SL (x; i). Contrary to this, the propagation of a perturbation in the initial configuration consists of the symbols at an increasing number of coordinates deviating from some reference symbols. Clearly, no frame of reference is needed to detect these deviations. We can compare the results above to a situation that involves communication between 0 two parts of the lattice. Consider an observer A who knows the initial configuration x−∞
70
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl 20 Local Information, t=0 Local Information, t=1 Information Current
[bit]
15 10 5 0 −9
−8
−7
−6
−5
−4
−3
−2
−1
0
1
2
3
Position i
Fig. 4. The distribution of local information SL and the corresponding information currents JL (x; i; µ) for the situation in Example 4 with n = 7 and p = 0.1. The information is accumulated at coordinates i = 0 and i = 1 at time t = 1.
of the negative part of the lattice. How much information about the continuation x1∞ can A gain by observing the configurations (F k x)0−∞ for 0 < k ≤ t? This question can be answered by using the concept of relative entropy, or Kullback Liebler distance [13]. The relative entropy of a posterior measure µ with respect to a prior measure µ0 satisfying µ µ0 is defined as D(µ||µ0 ) =
log X
dµ dµ, dµ0
(59)
dµ where dµ is the Radon-Nikodym derivative. The quantity D(µ||µ0 ) is interpreted as 0 the Shannon information gained by going to the posterior. The posterior is in our case expressed in terms of the joint measure ν t of all times 0 ≤ k ≤ t obtained as a straightforward generalization of ν defined in (15). For x ∈ AZ , define the measure µtx on σ (X i : i > 0) as 0 µtx (z 1n ) = ν t (z 1n |x−∞ , (F x)0−∞ , . . . , (F t x)0−∞ ), n ≥ 1.
(60)
The information the observer A gains by time t is given by the relative entropy D(µtx ||µ0x ). The following relations are valid Proposition 1. The measures defined in Eq. (60) satisfy
D(µtx ||µ0x ) ≤ D(µ1x ||µ0x ) =
rt
SL (x; i; µ), i=1 JL− (x; 1; µ).
(61) (62)
This means that A during the first t iterations of F cannot gain more information about 0 than the left local information initially located within the interval [1, r t]. Similarly, x−∞ if B is an observer knowing x0∞ and observing the symbols at i ≥ 0 for times 1 ≤ k ≤ t, −1 −1 his information gain about x−∞ would be bounded by i=−lt SR (x; i; µ0 ).
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
71
0 z kr ) = f (x kr ) for 1 ≤ k ≤ t}. Both Proof. Define Bx ⊆ Ar t as Bx = {z r1t : f k (x−kr 1 −kr results follow from
D(µtx ||µ0x ) = lim
n→∞
= lim
n→∞
µtx (z 1n ) log
z 1n
µtx (z 1n ) µ0x (z 1n )
0 µ(z 1n |x−∞ , z r1t ∈ Bx ) log
0 , zr t ∈ B ) µ(z 1n |x−∞ x 1
z 1n
0 ) µ(z 1n |x−∞
0 0 = − log µ({z r1t ∈ Bx }|x−∞ ) ≤ − log µ(x1r t |x−∞ ).
We now move on to determine bounds on the average information flow generated by a surjective one-dimensional CA. Theorem 5. Let JL (x; i; µ) be the information current with respect to a surjective CA F and a measure µ. Then, for each i ∈ Z, JL (x; i; µ) ∈ L 1 (µ). Furthermore, if µ is shift-invariant, then E[JL ] satisfies the relationship −r h(µ) ≤E[JL ] ≤ log R(F) − r h(µ).
(63)
The term log R(F) on the right hand-side in (63) is related to the interpretation of JL+ as r −1 r −1 r −1 ) that x−∞ is. Since |Z (x−∞ )| ≤ R(F), the information about which member of Z (x−∞ the average of this information cannot exceed log R(F). The term −r h(µ) is related to JL− . Proof. We look at coordinate i = 0. The current can be written as µ(x r −1 |x τ ) −1 JL (x; 0; µ) = − log τ +1r −1−∞τ + log µ(x0r −1 |x−∞ ), µ(x |x ) Z τ +1 −∞
(64)
where the first term is non-negative and the second term is non-positive. To bound the r −1 integral of the first term we divide AZ into the sets Tk = {x : τ (x−∞ ) = k} for k ≤ −2. Furthermore, we wish to subdivide each Tk through an equivalence relation similar to that defined in (25). Define the following relation on A|k|+2r +l−1 : r −1 −1 −1 −1 k k ∼ z rk+1−l−r iff f (rk+1−l−r ) = f (rk+1−l−r ) and xk+1−l−r = z k+1−l−r . xk+1−l−r
Then, transfer the equivalence relation to Tk through r −1 −1 ∼ z rk+1−l−r . x ∼ z iff xk+1−l−r
We denote the equivalence classes of Tk by Pk, j with j in some finite index set. Furthermore, for each Pk, j denote the corresponding equivalence class of A|k|+2r +l−1 by P¯k, j . Each P¯k, j has at most R(F) members. k−l−r For each j there is a set Pk,−j ∈ σ (X i : i ≤ k − l − r ) of histories x−∞ such that Pk, j = Pk,−j
P¯k, j
k Cyl(z k+1−l−r ).
(65)
72
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
If | P¯k, j | = R(F) then Pk,−j = AZ , but otherwise Pk,−j can be a subset of AZ . For instance,
−1 let F be the CA from Example 4 and x have xi = 1 for all i. Then τ (x−∞ ) = −2, − | P¯−2, j | = 2, and P−2, j = {z : z i = 0 for i ≤ −3}. Using the subdivision, we can write µ(x r −1 |x τ ) − dµ log τ +1r −1−∞τ AZ Z µ(x τ +1 |x −∞ ) ⎛ ⎞ −2 k−l−r ⎜ −1 k−l−r ⎟ k−l−r = k, j (x−∞ )⎝ µ(z rk+1−l−r |x−∞ )⎠ dµ(x−∞ ), (66) k=−∞ Pk, j ∈Tk
− Pk, j
P¯k, j
where k−l−r k, j (x−∞ )=−
P¯k, j
−1 k µ(z rk+1 |x−∞ ) P¯k, j
−1 k µ(z rk+1 |x−∞ )
log
−1 k µ(z rk+1 |x−∞ ) P¯k, j
−1 k µ(z rk+1 |x−∞ )
.
(67)
k−l−r k−l−r The function k, j (x−∞ ) is for each x−∞ the entropy of a discrete random variτ −l−r ) ≤ log R(F). By using this able with at most R(F) outcomes. Therefore, k, j (x−∞ inequality, we obtain from (66) that
−
−2 µ(x r −1 |x τ ) dµ ≤ log R(F) log τ +1r −1−∞τ µ(Pk, j ) = log R(F). (68) AZ Z µ(x τ +1 |x −∞ ) k=−∞ T k
Considering the second term in (64), −1 log µ(x0r −1 |x−∞ )dµ ≥ −r log |A|. AZ
Therefore, E[|JL (x; 0; µ)|] ≤ r log |A| + log R(F) < ∞, so JL (x; 0; µ) ∈ L 1 (µ). The second statement follows since for µ shift-invariant, −1 log µ(x0r −1 |x−∞ )dµ = −r h(µ). AZ
From Theorem 5 it follows that for any surjective CA and any measure µ, the following uniform bound is valid: |E[JL (x; i; µ)]| ≤ 1. (l + r ) log |A|
(69)
When µ is the uniform Bernoulli measure µ, ¯ the inequality is sharp for all CA with r = 0 and maximal R. We close this section by looking briefly at information transport for µ, ¯ which is invariant for all surjective CA. With µ¯ there are no correlations in the system, so SL (x; i; µ) ¯ ≡ SR (x; i; µ) ¯ ≡ log |A|. The information currents JL and JR are consequently also constant, but these
Continuity of Information Transport in Surjective Cellular Automata
73
depend on the radii and the Welch coefficients L(F), M(F) and R(F). Using (10) and (45) we obtain JL (x; i; µ) ¯ ≡ log R − r log |A|, JR (x; i; µ) ¯ ≡ − log L + l log |A|.
(70) (71)
By using the relation L · M · R = |A|l+r , we obtain JR − JL ≡ log M.
(72)
Thus, the sum of the velocity of left information to the left and right information to the right only depends on M(F), the number of preimages that almost all bi-infinite sequences possess. The higher M is, the higher the potential for information transport. The choice of radii decides how the potential is allocated to transport of information to the right and to the left. 6. Conclusions and Discussion The main concern of the paper has been to investigate transport of local information in the time evolution of a cellular automaton F. In particular, we have introduced an information current JL (x; i; µ) such that the continuity equation t SL +i JL = 0 holds under very general conditions. This is expressed in our main results, Theorems 3 and 4 in Sect. 4. We have also given an information theoretic interpretation of the current, and shown bounds for the information flow. The fact that the local information is a locally conserved quantity for all measures under iteration of any reversible CA is a clear indication that the function SL is an appropriate local information measure in a spatially extended system. However, we still need to consider the fact that information is not a strictly local quantity when correlations are present, and that it depends on the choice of context. In one dimension, this is illustrated by the fact that both the left and right local information are locally conserved, and in general different (as seen, e.g., for bipermutative CA). We have also given other examples which illustrate the limits of locality when correlations are present. We are currently investigating how the continuity equation can be extended to other classes of cellular automata. In particular this includes non-surjective and probabilistic CA in dimension one as well as CA in dimension two and higher. For non-surjective or non-deterministic systems a continuity equation must take loss and production of information into account. One can also look at local information and transport of local information for other types of spatially extended dynamical systems, in particular coupled map lattices. Extensions of the formalism to other systems will also bring us closer to addressing fundamental issues relating to information transport and conservation in physical systems. The continuity equation is a fundamental property of information transport in reversible systems. But we expect local information in cellular automata to have further interesting properties. In particular, a continuity equation is a constraint, rather than an equation that determines the dynamics of the system. One may expect information flow to have different dynamic characteristics in different cellular automata. In particular it should be investigated whether some systems allow a description of the dynamics of information separate from the underlying dynamical system, which would provide an additional argument for viewing information as a fundamental physical quantity.
74
T. Helvik, K. Lindgren, M. G. Nordahl
Acknowledgements. Helvik acknowledges support from by the Research Council of Norway. Lindgren acknowledges support from PACE (Programmable Artificial Cell Evolution), a European Integrated Project in the EU FP6-IST-FET Complex Systems Initiative, and from EMBIO (Emergent Organisation in Complex Biomolecular Systems) under EU FP6.
References 1. Bennett, C.H.: Logical reversibility of computation. IBM J. Res. Develop. 17(6), 525–532 (1973) 2. Dab, D., Lawniczak, A., Boon, J.P., Kapral, R.: Cellular-automaton model for reactive systems. Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2462–2465 (1990) 3. Ferrari, P., Maass, A., Martínez, S., Ney, P.: Cesàro mean distribution of group automata starting from measures with summable decay. Ergodic Theory Dynam. Systems. 20(6), 1657–1670 (2000) 4. Frisch, U., Hasslacher, B., Pomeau, Y.: Lattice-gas automata for the Navier-Stokes equation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 1505–1508 (1986) 5. Gänssler, P., Stute, W.: Wahrscheinlichkeitstheorie. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer Verlag 1977 6. Gray, R.M.: Probability, random processes, and ergodic properties. New York: Springer-Verlag 1988 7. Hardy, J., Pomeau, Y., de Pazzis, O.: Time evolution of two-dimensional model system. I. invariant states and time correlation functions. J. Math. Phys. 14, 1746–1759 (1973) 8. Hedlund, G.A.: Endomorphisms and automorphisms of the shift dynamical system. Math. Syst. Theory. 3, 320–375 (1969) 9. Host, B., Maass, A., Martínez, S.: Uniform Bernoulli measure in dynamics of permutative cellular automata with algebraic local rules. Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. 9(6), 1423–1446 (2003) 10. Ito, M., Osato, N., Nasu, M.: Linear cellular automata over Z m . J. Comput. System Sci. 27(2), 125– 140 (1983) 11. Jaynes, E.T.: Information theory and statistical mechanics. Phys. Rev. 106, 620–630 (1957) 12. Keller, G.: Equilibrium states in ergodic theory, Volume 42 of London Mathematical Society Student Texts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1998 13. Kullback, S., Leibler, R.A.: On information and sufficiency. Ann. Math. Stat. 22, 79–86 (1951) 14. Landauer, R.: Irreversibility and heat generation in the computing process. IBM J. Res. Develop. 5(3), 183–191 (1961) 15. Lind, D.A.: Applications of ergodic theory and sofic systems to cellular automata. Physica D. 10, 36–44 (1984) 16. Lindgren, K.: Correlations and random information in cellular automata. Complex Systems. 1, 529–543 (1987) 17. Lindgren, K.: Microscopic and macroscopic entropy. Phys. Rev. A. 38, 4794–4798 (1988) 18. Pivato, M., Yassawi, R.: Limit measures for affine cellular automata. Ergodic Theory Dynam. Systems. 22(4), 1269–1287 (2002) 19. Pivato, M., Yassawi, R.: Limit measures for affine cellular automata II. Ergodic Theory Dynam. Systems. 24(6), 1961–1980 (2004) 20. Richardson, D.: Tesselations with local transformations. J. Comput. System Sci. 5, 373–388 (1972) 21. Takesue, S.: Reversible cellular automata and statistical mechanics. Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 2499–2502 (1987) 22. Takesue, S.: Fourier’s law and the Green-Kubo formula in a cellular-automaton model. Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 252–255 (1990) 23. Toffoli, T.: Information transport obeying the continuity equation. IBM J. Res. Develop. 32(1), 29–36 (1988) 24. Toffoli, T., Margolus, N.H.: Invertible cellular automata: a review. Physica D. 45(1–3), 229–253 (1990) 25. Vichniac, G.: Simulating physics with cellular automata. Physica D. 10, 96–115 (1984) 26. Walters, P.: An Introduction to Ergodic Theory. Number 79 in Graduate Texts in Mathematics. Berlin Heidelberg New York: Springer 1982 27. Wheeler, J.A.: Information, physics, quantum: The search for links. In: Zurek, WH (ed.): Complexity, Entropy and the Physics of Information. Redwood City, CA: Addison-Wesley 1989 28. Zurek, W.H.: Algorithmic randomness and physical entropy. Phys. Rev. A. 40, 4731–4751 (1989) Communicated by G. Gallavotti
Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 75–84 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0197-3
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
A Liouville-type Theorem for Schrödinger Operators Yehuda Pinchover Department of Mathematics, Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 19 December 2005 / Accepted: 12 June 2006 Published online: 2 March 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Abstract: In this paper we prove a sufficient condition, in terms of the behavior of a ground state of a symmetric critical operator P1 , such that a nonzero subsolution of a symmetric nonnegative operator P0 is a ground state. Particularly, if P j := − + V j , for j = 0, 1, are two nonnegative Schrödinger operators defined on ⊆ Rd such that P1 is critical in with a ground state ϕ, the function ψ 0 is a subsolution of the equation P0 u = 0 in and satisfies ψ+ ≤ Cϕ in , then P0 is critical in and ψ is its ground state. In particular, ψ is (up to a multiplicative constant) the unique positive supersolution of the equation P0 u = 0 in . Similar results hold for general symmetric operators, and also on Riemannian manifolds. 1. Introduction 2
Let ⊂ Rd be a domain. We assume that A : → Rd is a measurable symmetric matrix valued function such that for every compact set K ⊂ there exists µ K > 1 such that ∀x ∈ K , (1.1) µ−1 K Id ≤ A(x) ≤ µ K Id where Id is the d-dimensional identity matrix, and the matrix inequality A ≤ B means p that B − A is a nonnegative matrix on Rd . Let V ∈ L loc (; R), where p > d/2. We consider the quadratic form a A,V [u] := A∇u · ∇u + V |u|2 dx (1.2)
on
C0∞ ()
associated with the Schrödinger equation Pu := (−∇ · (A∇) + V )u = 0
in .
We say that a A,V is nonnegative on C0∞ (), if a A,V [u] ≥ 0 for all u ∈ C0∞ ().
(1.3)
76
Y. Pinchover
1 () is a (weak)sol ut i on of (1.3) if for every Definition 1.1. We say that v ∈ Hloc ∞ ϕ ∈ C0 (), (A∇v · ∇ϕ + V vϕ) dx = 0. (1.4)
1 () is a subsol ut i on of (1.3) if for every nonnegative ϕ ∈ C ∞ (), We say that v ∈ Hloc 0 (A∇v · ∇ϕ + V vϕ) dx ≤ 0. (1.5)
v∈
1 () Hloc
is a super sol ut i on of (1.3) if −v is a subsolution of (1.3).
Let C P () be the cone of all positive solutions of the equation Pu = 0 in , and let λ0 (P, ) := sup{λ ∈ R | C P−λ () = ∅}
(1.6)
be the generalized principal eigenvalue of the operator P in . By the AllegrettoPiepenbrink theory (see for example, [1, 21]), the form a A,V is nonnegative on C0∞ () if and only if λ0 (P, ) ≥ 0. Let K (i.e. K is relatively compact in ). Recall [1, 21] that u ∈ C P ( \ K ) is said to be a positive solution of the operator P of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in , if for any K K 1 , with a smooth boundary, and any v ∈ C P ( \ K 1 ) ∩ C(( \ K 1 ) ∪ ∂ K 1 ), the inequality u ≤ v on ∂ K 1 implies that u ≤ v in \ K 1 . A positive solution u ∈ C P () which has minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in is called a ground state of P in . The operator P is said to be critical in , if P admits a ground state in . The operator P is called subcritical in , if C P () = ∅, but P is not critical in . If C P () = ∅, then P is supercritical in . It is known that the operator P is critical in if and only if the equation Pu = 0 in admits (up to a multiplicative constant) a unique positive supersolution. In particular, in the critical case we have dim C P () = 1 (see for example [18, 21] and the references therein). On the other hand, P is subcritical in , if and only if P admits a positive minimal Green function G P (x, y) in . For each y ∈ , the function G P (·, y) is a positive solution of the equation Pu = 0 in \ {y} that has minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in and has a (suitably normalized) nonremovable singularity at y (see for example [18, 21] and the references therein). The following basic example will be used several times throughout the paper. Example 1.2. Let P = − and = Rd . It is well known that λ0 (−, Rd ) = 0. In addition, the positive Liouville theorem asserts that C− (Rd ) = {c1 | c > 0}, where 1 is the constant function taking at any point the value 1. Moreover, − is critical in Rd if and only if d ≤ 2. Recently, Berestycki, Hamel, and Roques [6] have introduced the following definition which arises naturally in the study of some semilinear equations. Definition 1.3. λ0 (P, ) := inf{λ ∈ R | ∃φ ∈ C 2 () ∩ W 2,∞ (), φ > 0, (P − λ)φ ≤ 0 in , φ = 0 on ∂, if ∂ = ∅}.
A Liouville-type Theorem for Schrödinger Operators
77
Before formulating our results, we present four basic problems (Problems 1–4) concerning the particular case = Rd , which have been solved in the past few years. It turns out that (almost) all these previous special results can be recovered directly from our general result (Theorem 1.7). Problem 1 ([23, 24]). Let V ∈ L 2loc (Rd ). Does the existence of a positive bounded solution to the equation HV u := (− + V )u = 0
on Rd
(1.7)
imply that HV is critical in Rd ? Problem 2 ([5]). Suppose that V is smooth and bounded. Does the existence of a signchanging bounded solution to Eq. (1.7) imply that λ0 (HV , Rd ) < 0? Problem 3 ([5, 14]). Let σ be a strictly positive C 2 -function on Rd , and consider the divergence form operator L = −∇ · (σ 2 ∇) on Rd . Suppose that the equation Lψ = 0 in Rd admits a nonzero solution ψ such that ψσ is bounded. Is ψ necessarily the constant function? Problem 4 ([7, Conjecture 4.6]). Suppose that P = −∇ · (A∇) + V is a uniformly elliptic operator with smooth bounded coefficients on Rd . Does the inequality λ0 (P, Rd ) ≤ λ0 (P, Rd ) hold true in any dimension d? The answers to the above four problems for the free Laplacian in Rd are well known. Nevertheless, the above problems are not of perturbational nature since there is no assumption on the asymptotic behavior of the coefficients of the given operator near infinity. Problem 1 was posed by B. Simon in [23, 24]. Clearly, the answer to Problem 1 is ‘no’ for d ≥ 3. Partial results concerning Problem 1 for d ≤ 2 were obtained under the assumption that V is a short-range potential (see for example, [12, 13, 16, 18]). On the other hand, Gesztesy, and Zhao showed in [12, Example 4.6] that there is a critical Schrödinger operator on R with ‘almost’ short-range potential such that its ground state behaves logarithmically at infinity. In a recent article Damanik, Killip, and Simon proved a result which reveals a complete answer to Problem 1. Theorem 1.4 (cf. [10, Theorem 5]). The answer to Problem 1 is “yes” if and only if d = 1, 2. Indeed, for d = 1, 2, it is shown in [10] that if the equation HV u = 0 admits a positive bounded solution, then any W ∈ L 2loc (Rd ) satisfying HV ±W ≥ 0 is necessarily the zero potential. But this property holds if and only if HV is critical (see [18]). Let us turn to Problem 2 which was raised by Berestycki, Caffarelli, and Nirenberg [5]. This problem is closely related to De Giorgi’s conjecture [11] (see [3–5, 14]). In [14], Ghoussoub and Gui showed a connection between Problem 2 and Problem 3 which concerns the Liouville property for operators in divergence form (see also the proof of Theorem 1.7 in [5]). In fact, the following result is proved in [5, 14, 3]. Theorem 1.5. The answers to Problems 2 and 3 are “yes” if and only if d = 1, 2.
78
Y. Pinchover
Note that Ghoussoub and Gui [14] used this Liouville-type theorem for d = 2 [5], to prove De Giorgi’s Conjecture in R2 . Problem 3 was posed by Berestycki and Rossi [7] who also solved it for d ≤ 3: Theorem 1.6 ([7, Theorem 4.1]). Suppose that P = −∇ · (A∇) + V is a uniformly elliptic operator with smooth bounded coefficients on Rd . If d ≤ 3, then λ0 (P, Rd ) ≤ λ0 (P, Rd ). The purpose of the present article is to (partially) generalize Theorems 1.4, 1.5, and 1.6 to general symmetric operators which are defined on an arbitrary domain ⊆ Rd , or on a noncompact Riemannian manifold. Our main result is as follows. Theorem 1.7. Let be a domain in Rd , d ≥ 1. Consider two Schrödinger operators defined on of the form P j := −∇ · (A j ∇) + V j
j = 0, 1,
(1.8)
p
such that V j ∈ L loc (; R) for some p > d/2, and A j satisfy (1.1). Assume that the following assumptions hold true. (i) The operator P1 is critical in . Denote by ϕ ∈ C P1 () its ground state. 1 () such that ψ = 0, (ii) λ0 (P0 , ) ≥ 0, and there exists a real function ψ ∈ Hloc + and P0 ψ ≤ 0 in , where u + (x) := max{0, u(x)}. (iii) The following matrix inequality holds: (ψ+ )2 (x)A0 (x) ≤ Cϕ 2 (x)A1 (x)
a. e. in ,
(1.9)
where C > 0 is a positive constant. Then the operator P0 is critical in , and ψ is its ground state. In particular, dim C P0 () = 1 and λ0 (P0 , ) = 0. Corollary 1.8. Suppose that all the assumptions of Theorem 1.7 are satisfied except possibly the assumption that λ0 (P0 , ) ≥ 0. Assume further that either ψ changes its sign in , or ψ is not a solution of the equation P0 u = 0 in . Then λ0 (P0 , ) < 0. Theorem 1.7 and Corollary 1.8 imply in particular the sufficiency parts of Theorem 1.4 and Theorem 1.5, and also Theorem 1.6 for d = 1, 2. We point out that Theorem 1.6 holds also for d = 3, and this case is not covered by our result. Note that in contrast to the assumptions of Theorem 1.5 and 1.6, in Theorem 1.7 we assume neither that the functions V j are bounded and smooth, nor that the matrix valued functions A j are smooth. The outline of the paper is as follows. In Sect. 2, we present some results from [19] that will be used in the proof of Theorem 1.7. Sect. 3 is devoted to the proof of Theorem 1.7 and its consequences. We conclude the paper in Sect. 4, where we pose two open problems suggested by the results of the present paper.
A Liouville-type Theorem for Schrödinger Operators
79
2. Preliminary Results Definition 2.1. We say that a sequence {u k } ⊂ C0∞ () is a null sequence for the quadratic form a A,V if there exists an open set B such that nonnegative 2 B |u k | dx = 1, and lim a A,V [u k ] = 0. (2.1) k→∞
We say that a positive function ϕ is a null st at e for the nonnegative quadratic form a A,V , if there exists a null sequence {u k } for the form a A,V such that u k → ϕ in L 2loc (). Remark 2.2. The requirement that u k ⊂ C0∞ (), can clearly be weakened by assuming only that {u k } ⊂ H01 (). Also, the requirement that B |u k |2 dx = 1 can be replaced by 2 B |u k | dx 1, where f k gk means that there exists a positive constant C such that −1 C gk ≤ f k ≤ Cgk for all k ∈ N. The following auxiliary lemma is well known (see, e.g. [9, 17, 19]). 1 () be a nonnegative subsolution of the equation Pψ = 0 in Lemma 2.3. Let ψ ∈ Hloc . Then for any nonnegative v ∈ C0∞ () we have a A,V [ψv] ≤ (ψ)2 A∇v · ∇v dx. (2.2)
Moreover, if ψ is a (real valued) solution of the equation Pψ = 0 in , then for any v ∈ C0∞ () we have a A,V [ψv] = (ψ)2 A∇v · ∇v dx. (2.3)
Proof. Follows from the definition of a weak (sub)solution and elementary calculation. The following theorem was recently proved by K. Tintarev and the author [19] (see also [20]). Theorem 2.4. Suppose that a A,V ≥ 0 on C0∞ (). Then a A,V has a null sequence if and only if the corresponding operator P = −∇ · (A∇) + V is critical in . In this case, any null sequence converges in L 2loc () to cϕ, where ϕ is a ground state of the operator P and c is a nonzero constant. Moreover, there exists a null sequence {u k } of nonnegative functions that converges to ϕ locally uniformly in \ {x0 }, where x0 is some point in . 3. Proof of Theorem 1.7 In this section we prove Theorem 1.7 and some consequences. Proof of Theorem 1.7. Since ψ satisfy P0 ψ ≤ 0 in , it follows that P0 ψ+ ≤ 0 in (see for example [1, Lemma 2.7]). By Theorem 2.4 and our assumptions, there exists a null sequence {u k } for the quadratic form a A1 ,V1 of nonnegative functions which converges locally uniformly in \{x0 } and in L 2loc () to the ground state ϕ of the operator P1 , and satisfies B (u k )2 dx = 1 for some open set B \ {x0 } and all k ∈ N.
80
Y. Pinchover
Denote wk := u k /ϕ. Since wk → constant locally uniformly in \{x0 } and ψ+ = 0, it follows that B1 (ψ+ wk )2 dx 1 for some open set B1 and every k ≥ k0 . Moreover, by Lemma 2.3 and our assumptions, we have a A0 ,V0 [ψ+ wk ] ≤ (ψ+ )2 A0 ∇wk · ∇wk dx ≤
C
ϕ 2 A1 ∇wk · ∇wk dx = Ca A1 ,V1 [ϕwk ] = Ca A1 ,V1 [u k ] → 0. (3.1)
Therefore, {ψ+ wk } is a null sequence for P0 . By Theorem 2.4, P0 is critical in and ψ+ is its ground state. In particular, ψ+ is strictly positive, and hence ψ− = 0, and ψ = ψ+ is the ground state of P0 . Remark 3.1. Suppose that all the assumptions of Theorem 1.7 are satisfied except possibly the assumption that λ0 (P0 , ) ≥ 0. One can show directly that λ0 (P0 , ) ≤ 0. Indeed, using the notations of the proof of Theorem 1.7, we have that for some C1 > 0, (ψ+ wk )2 dx ≥ (ψ+ wk )2 dx ≥ C1 = C1 (u k )2 dx ∀k ≥ k0 .
B1
B
Moreover, by Lemma 2.3 and our assumptions, we have 2 a A0 ,V0 [ψ+ wk ] + ) A0 ∇wk · ∇wk dx (ψ ≤ ≤ 2 2 (ψ+ wk ) dx B1 (ψ+ wk ) dx C˜
ϕ
1 ∇wk · ∇wk 2 B (u k ) dx
2A
dx
˜ A1 ,V1 [ϕwk ] = Ca ˜ A1 ,V1 [u k ] → 0. = Ca (3.2)
In light of the Rayleigh-Ritz variational formula and the Allegretto-Piepen-brink theorem, estimate (3.2) implies that λ0 (P0 , ) ≤ 0. It follows that λ0 (P0 , ) ≤ inf { λ ∈ R | ∃ ψ 0, (P0 − λ)ψ ≤ 0 in s.t. ψ+2 (x)A0 (x) ≤ Cϕ 2 (x)A1 (x) in for some critical operator P1 with a ground state ϕ } . In particular, if P = −∇ · (A∇) + V is an elliptic operator on Rd , d ≤ 2, with a bounded matrix A, then λ0 (P, Rd ) ≤ λ0 (P, Rd ) (cf. Theorem 1.6). Recall that if P := −∇ · (A∇) + V is Zd -periodic on Rd , then P − λ0 admits a (unique) periodic positive solution (see for example [15, 21]). On the other hand, − is critical in Rd if and only if d ≤ 2 (see Example 1.2). Therefore, Theorem 1.7 implies the following result of R. Pinsky (who proved it for general second-order elliptic Zd -periodic operators). Corollary 3.2 ([22]). Assume that the coefficients of the elliptic operator P := −∇ · (A∇) + V are Zd -periodic on Rd . Then the operator P − λ0 is critical in Rd if and only if d ≤ 2.
A Liouville-type Theorem for Schrödinger Operators
81
Remark 3.3. Suppose that P j are two nonnegative symmetric operators which are defined on a noncompact Riemannian manifold M of dimension d, where j = 0, 1. Since Lemma 2.3 holds true also in this case (see [17]), it follows that Theorem 2.4 is valid on Riemannian manifolds, which in turn implies that Theorem 1.7 holds true also in this case. Recall that a Riemannian manifold M is called recurrent if the Laplace-Beltrami operator on M is critical (see [21]). Therefore, we have in particular, the following generalization of Theorem 1.4 and Theorem 1.5. Theorem 3.4. Let M be a recurrent Riemannian noncompact manifold of dimension d. Let V ∈ L 2loc (M). Suppose that HV := − + V ≥ 0 on C0∞ (M), and that the equation HV u = 0 in M admits a nonzero bounded subsolution ψ such that ψ+ = 0. Then HV is critical in M and ψ is a ground state of HV in M. In particular, λ0 (HV ) = 0, the space of all bounded solutions of the equation HV u = 0 in M is one-dimensional, and dim C HV (M) = 1 . In addition, one can use the results in [15] and [8, Theorem 5.2.11] to extend Corollary 3.2 to the case of equivariant Schrödinger operators on cocompact nilpotent coverings. Corollary 3.5. Let M be a noncompact nilpotent covering of a compact Riemannian manifold of dimension d. Suppose that P := − + V is an equivariant operator on M with respect to the (nilpotent) deck group G. Then P − λ0 is critical in M if and only if G has a normal subgroup of finite index isomorphic to Zn for n ≤ 2. Theorem 1.7 might be called a Liouville comparison theorem and can be considered as a sufficient condition for the removability of singularity at infinity in or as a Phragmén-Lindelöf type principle. A positive solution of (1.3) in \ K , where K , is called singular at infinity if it does not have minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in . Accordingly, Theorem 1.7 implies that the behavior of a positive solution of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in of an equation of the form (1.8), dictates some ‘growth’ on all positive singular at infinity solutions of any equation of the form (1.8). More precisely, we have the following result. Corollary 3.6. Suppose that for j = 0, 1 the operators P j are of the form (1.8), and A j satisfy (1.1). Let u 1 be a positive solution of the equation P1 u = 0 of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in , and let u 0 be a positive solution of the equation P0 u = 0 in \ K , where K . If (u 0 )2 A0 ≤ C(u 1 )2 A1 in \ K , then u 0 is nonsingular at infinity, i.e., u 0 is a positive solution of the equation P0 u = 0 of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in . 1 () be positive functions which are defined Proof of Corollary 3.6. Let u0 , u1 ∈ Hloc in such that uj |\K 1 = u j , and uj | K 1 are sufficiently smooth, where K 1 , and j = 0, 1. Then for j = 0, 1, uj ∈ C P j (), where the operators P j are of the form (1.8) and satisfy P j |\K 2 = P j for some K 2 . Since u 1 (and hence also u1 ) is a positive solu1 u = 0 of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in , it tion of the equation P 1 in . Therefore, Theorem 1.7 follows that u1 is a ground state of the critical operator P 0 in . Hence, u 0 is a positive implies that u0 is a ground state of the critical operator P solution of the equation P0 u = 0 of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in .
82
Y. Pinchover p
Example 3.7. Let d ≥ 2, and V ∈ L loc (Rd ), where p > d/2. Suppose that HV := − + V ≥ 0 on C0∞ (Rd ), and the equation HV u = 0 on Rd has a subsolution ψ 0 satisfying ψ+ (x) = O(|x| Since ϕ(x) := |x|
2−d 2
2−d 2
)
as |x| → ∞.
(3.3)
is a positive solution of the Hardy-type equation d −2 2 u −u − =0 2 |x|2
of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in Rd , it follows from Corollary 3.6 that HV is critical in Rd and ψ is its ground state (cf. Theorem 1.7 in [5]). p
Example 3.8. Let d = 1, and V ∈ L loc (R), where p > 1. Suppose that HV := −d2 /dx 2 + V ≥ 0 on C0∞ (R), and the equation HV u = 0 on R has a subsolution ψ 0 satisfying ψ+ (x) = O(log |x|) as |x| → ∞. (3.4) It follows from [12, Example 4.6] and Corollary 3.6 that HV is critical in R and ψ is its ground state. 4. Open Problems We conclude the paper with two open problems suggested by the above results which are left for future investigation. Problem 5. Generalize Theorem 1.7 to the class of nonsymmetric second-order linear elliptic operators with real coefficients which have the same (or even comparable) principal parts, or at least to the subclass of operators which differ only by their zero-order terms. Remark 4.1. 1. Clearly, the condition (1.9) which involves the squares of the corresponding solutions of the symmetric operators P j , for j = 0, 1, should be replaced in the nonsymmetric case by a condition which involves products of the form u j u ∗j , where u j (resp. u ∗j ) are the corresponding solutions of the operators P j (resp. of the formal adjoint operators PJ∗ ) for j = 0, 1. 2. Let u be a positive solution of an equation of the form (1.3) of minimal growth in a neighborhood of infinity in , then Corollary 3.6 implies that any positive solution v of another equation of the form (1.3) (with a comparable principal part) in a neighborhood of infinity in which is singular at infinity satisfies lim inf x→∞
u(x) =0 v(x)
in the one-point compactification of (∞ denotes the point at infinity in ). Ancona proved [2] that a subcritical symmetric (or even quasi-symmetric) operator P in always admits v ∈ C P (), such that lim
x→∞
G P (x, x 0 ) = 0. v(x)
A Liouville-type Theorem for Schrödinger Operators
83
Moreover, it is shown in [2] that such a positive solution does not always exist for general nonsymmetric operators. This result indicates that the answer to Problem 5 in the nonsymmetric case might be more involved. The second problem that we pose deals with Liouville-comparison theorems for the p-Laplacian with a potential term. Let be a domain in Rd , d ≥ 2, and 1 < p < ∞. Fix V ∈ L ∞ loc (). Recently the criticality theory for linear equations was extended in [20] to quasilinear equations of the form −∇ · (|∇u| p−2 ∇u) + V |u| p−2 u = 0
in .
(4.1)
In particular, Theorem 2.4 was proved also for such equations. Therefore, it is natural to pose the following problem. Problem 6. Assume that 1 < p ≤ d. Generalize Theorem 1.7 to positive solutions of quasilinear equations of the form (4.1). Remark 4.2. An answer to Problem 6 (for 1 < p < ∞) was obtained after the present paper was submitted, and will appear elsewhere. Acknowledgements. The author wishes to thank H. Brezis, F. Gesztesy, and M. Marcus for valuable discussions and N. Schwartz for the musical inspiration. The author is also grateful to the anonymous referee for his careful reading and useful comments. This work was partially supported by the RTN network “Nonlinear Partial Differential Equations Describing Front Propagation and Other Singular Phenomena”, HPRN-CT2002-00274, the Israel Science Foundation (grant No. 1136/04) founded by the Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities, and the Fund for the Promotion of Research at the Technion.
References 1. Agmon, S.: On positivity and decay of solutions of second order elliptic equations on Riemannian manifolds. In: “Methods of Functional Analysis and Theory of Elliptic Equations” (Naples, 1982), Naples: Liguori, 1983, pp. 19–52 2. Ancona, A.: Some results and examples about the behavior of harmonic functions and Green’s functions with respect to second order elliptic operators. Nagoya Math. J. 165, 123–158 (2002) 3. Barlow, M.T.: On the Liouville property for divergence form operators. Canad. J. Math. 50, 487–496 (1998) 4. Barlow, M.T., Bass, R.F., Gui, C.: The Liouville property and a conjecture of De Giorgi. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 53, 1007–1038 (2000) 5. Berestycki, H., Caffarelli, L., Nirenberg, L.: Further qualitative properties for elliptic equations in unbounded domains. Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 25, 69–94 (1997) 6. Berestycki, H., Hamel, F., Roques, L.: Analysis of the periodically fragmented environment model: I - Influence of periodic heterogeneous environment on species persistence. J. Math. Biology 51, 75– 113 (2005) 7. Berestycki, H., Rossi, L.: On the principal eigenvalue of elliptic operators in R N and applications. J. Europ. Math. Soc. (2006), in press 8. Davies E.B.: “Heat Kernels and Spectral Theory”. Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, 92, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989 9. Davies, E.B., Simon, B.: Ultracontractivity and the heat kernel for Schrödinger operators and Dirichlet Laplacians. J. Funct. Anal. 59, 335–395 (1984) 10. Damanik, D., Killip, R., Simon, B.: Schrödinger operators with few bound states. Commun. Math. Phys. 258, 741–750 (2005) 11. De Giorgi, E.: Convergence problems for functionals and operators. In: “Proceedings of the International Meeting on Recent Methods in Nonlinear Analysis” (Rome, 1978), Bologna: Pitagora Ed., 1979, pp. 131–188 12. Gesztesy, F., Zhao, Z.: On critical and subcritical Sturm-Liouville operators. J. Funct. Anal. 98, 311– 345 (1991) 13. Gesztesy, F., Zhao, Z.: On positive solutions of critical Schrödinger operators in two dimensions. J. Funct. Anal. 127, 235–256 (1995)
84
Y. Pinchover
14. Ghoussoub, N., Gui, C.: On a conjecture of De Giorgi and some related problems. Math. Ann. 311, 481–491 (1998) 15. Lin, V., Pinchover, Y.: “Manifolds with Group Actions and Elliptic Operators”. Memoirs AMS, no. 540, 1994 16. Murata, M.: Positive solutions and large time behaviors of Schrödinger semigroups, Simon’s problem. J. Funct. Anal. 56, 300–310 (1984) 17. Murata, M.: Martin boundaries of elliptic skew products, semismall perturbations, and fundamental solutions of parabolic equations. J. Funct. Anal. 194, 53–141 (2002) 18. Pinchover Y.: Topics in the theory of positive solutions of second-order elliptic and parabolic partial differential equations. In: “Spectral Theory and Mathematical Physics: A Festschrift in Honor of Barry Simon’s 60th Birthday”, Proceedings of Symposia in Pure Mathematics, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. to appear 19. Pinchover, Y., Tintarev, K.: Ground state alternative for singular Schrödinger operators. J. Funct. Anal. 230, 65–77 (2006) 20. Pinchover, Y., Tintarev, K.: Ground state alternative for p-Laplacian with potential term, to appear in Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations, http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/math/pdf/0511/0511039.pdf 21. Pinsky, R.G.: “Positive Harmonic Functions and Diffusion”. Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics 45, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995 22. Pinsky, R.G.: Second order elliptic operators with periodic coefficients: criticality theory, perturbations, and positive harmonic functions. J. Funct. Anal. 129, 80–107 (1995) 23. Simon, B.: Large time behavior of the L p norm of Schrödinger semigroups. J. Funct. Anal. 40, 66– 83 (1981) 24. Simon, B.: Schrödinger semigroups. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 7, 447–526 (1982) Communicated by B. Simon
Commun. Math. Phys. 272, 85–118 (2007) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-007-0208-4
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Anti-self-dual Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures Maciej Dunajski, Simon West Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge CB3 0WA, UK. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 27 January 2006 / Accepted: 4 October 2006 Published online: 2 March 2007 – © Springer-Verlag 2007
Dedicated to the memory of Jerzy Pleba´nski Abstract: Using twistor methods, we explicitly construct all local forms of four–dimensional real analytic neutral signature anti–self–dual conformal structures (M, [g]) with a null conformal Killing vector. We show that M is foliated by antiself-dual null surfaces, and the two-dimensional leaf space inherits a natural projective structure. The twistor space of this projective structure is the quotient of the twistor space of (M, [g]) by the group action induced by the conformal Killing vector. We obtain a local classification which branches according to whether or not the conformal Killing vector is hyper-surface orthogonal in (M, [g]). We give examples of conformal classes which contain Ricci–flat metrics on compact complex surfaces and discuss other conformal classes with no Ricci–flat metrics.
1. Introduction The anti–self–duality (ASD) condition in four dimensions seems to underlie the concept of integrability of ordinary and partial differential equations [29]. Many lower dimensional integrable models (KdV, NlS, Sine–Gordon, ...) arise as symmetry reductions of the ASD Yang–Mills equations on a flat background, and various solution generation techniques are reductions of the twistor correspondence [19]. Other integrable models (dispersionless Kadomtsev–Petviashvili, SU (∞) Toda, ...) are reductions of the ASD conformal equations which say that the self–dual Weyl tensor of a conformal class of metrics vanishes [30, 7]. Generalisations to ASD Yang–Mills on ASD conformal background are also possible [27, 4]. In all cases the main interest is in conformal structures of signature + + −− which are called neutral, as the reductions can lead to interesting hyperbolic and parabolic equations. There are no non–trivial ASD structures in the Lorentzian signature + + +−, and the reductions from Riemannian manifolds can only yield elliptic equations thus ruling out interesting soliton dynamics.
86
M. Dunajski, S. West
The main gap in the programme to classify the reductions of ASD neutral conformal structures was understanding the reductions by a null conformal Killing vector. We embarked on this project hoping to incorporate more integrable systems into the framework of anti–self–duality, but we have found (Theorem 2) that the resulting geometry is a completely solvable system. Let (M, [g]) be a four dimensional real analytic neutral ASD conformal structure. We say that K is a null conformal Killing vector if it satisfies L K g = ηg,
g(K , K ) = 0,
(1.1)
for some g ∈ [g], where η is a function on M, and L is the Lie-derivative. When studying conformal structures with non-null conformal Killing vectors, it is natural to look at the space of Killing vector trajectories, since this will inherit a nondegenerate conformal structure. In the case of a null conformal Killing vector, the situation is different. The space of trajectories inherits a degenerate conformal structure. We find that it is necessary to go down one dimension more, and consider a two dimensional space U of anti-self-dual totally null surfaces in M, called β–surfaces, containing K , which exist as a consequence of the conformal Killing equation. It turns out that there is a naturally defined projective structure [] on U . Moreover, we show that the twistor spaces of (M, [g]) and (U, []) are related by dimensional reduction. Specifically, the twistor space Z of (U, []) is the space of trajectories of a vector field on the twistor space PT of (M, [g]) corresponding to K . Projective structures are just equivalence classes of torsion-free connections, which do not need to satisfy any equations; this underlies the complete solvability of null reductions, and contrasts with the non-null case where one obtains Einstein-Weyl structures [13], and associated integrable systems [30, 7, 6, 4]. In Sect. 2 we derive some elementary properties of null conformal Killing vectors. Section 3 is an introduction to projective structures. In Sect. 4 we prove the following: Theorem 1. Let (M, [g]) be a four dimensional real analytic neutral ASD conformal structure with a null conformal Killing vector K . Let U be the two dimensional space of β-surfaces containing K . Then there is a naturally defined projective structure on U , induced on PT by whose twistor space is the space of trajectories of a distribution K the action of K on M. In Sect. 5 we investigate the local form of ASD conformal structures with null Killing vectors. This is expressed in the following theorem: Theorem 2. Let (M, [g], K ) be a smooth neutral signature ASD conformal structure with null conformal Killing vector. Then there exist local coordinates (t, x, y, z) and g ∈ [g] such that K = ∂t and g has one of the following two forms, according to whether the twist K ∧ dK vanishes or not (K := g(K , .)): 1. K ∧ dK = 0. g = (dt + (z A3 − Q)dy)(dy − βd x) − (dz − (z(−β y + A1 + β A2 + β 2 A3 ))d x −(z(A2 + 2β A3 ) + P)dy)d x, (1.2) where A1 , A2 , A3 , β, Q, P are arbitrary functions of (x, y). 2. K ∧ dK = 0. g = (dt + A3 ∂z Gdy + (A2 ∂z G + 2 A3 (z∂z G − G) − ∂z ∂ y G)d x)(dy − zd x) −∂z2 Gd x(dz − (A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )d x),
(1.3)
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
87
where A0 , A1 , A2 , A3 are arbitrary functions of (x, y), and G is a function of (x, y, z) satisfying the following PDE: (∂x + z∂ y + (A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )∂z )∂z2 G = 0.
(1.4)
The functions Aα (x, y) in the metrics (1.2) and (1.3) determine projective structures on the two dimensional space U in the following way. A general projective structure corresponds to a second-order ODE, dy 3 dy 2 dy d2 y + A0 (x, y). = A (x, y) + A (x, y) + A (x, y) 3 2 1 dx2 dx dx dx
(1.5)
In (1.3) all the Aα , α = 0, 1, 2, 3 functions occur explicitly in the metric. In (1.2) the function A0 does not explicitly occur. It is determined by the following equation: A0 = βx + ββ y − β A1 − β 2 A2 − β 3 A3 ,
(1.6)
as is shown in the proof of the theorem. If one interprets z as a fibre coordinate on the projective tangent bundle of the (x, y) space, then (1.4) says that ∂z2 G is constant along the projective structure spray (compare formula 3.4). Note that in both cases the Killing vector is ∂t and is pure Killing (this comes from choosing a suitable g ∈ [g]). The non-twisting case (1.2) is a natural conformal generalisation of Ricci–flat pp waves. The twisting case (1.3) is a neutral analog of the Fefferman conformal class [10]. As special cases of (1.3) we recover some examples of [20], where neutral metrics were related to second order ODEs. The aim of Sect. 6 is to put our results into a broader context. We examine some examples found by different means in the light of our results. We find necessary and sufficient conditions on the underlying projective structure in order for there to exist (pseudo) hyper–complex metrics with triholomorphic K within a conformal class. A special case of the metric (1.2) yields a compact example of a Ricci–flat metric on a Kodaira surface of a special type. We consider how to construct conformal structure twistor spaces from projective structure twistor spaces in Sect. 7. The more involved spinor calculations are moved to the Appendix. 2. Null Conformal Killing Vectors 2.1. Spinors in neutral signature. We will denote by (M, [g]) a local patch of R4 endowed with a neutral signature conformal structure [g]. That is, [g] is an equivalence class of neutral signature metrics with the equivalence relation g ∼ ec g for some function c on M. Any neutral metric g on M can be put in the following form:
g = 2(θ 00 θ 11 − θ 01 θ 10 ) = AB A B θ A A ⊗ θ B B ,
(2.1)
where AB , A B are antisymmetric matrices with 01 = 0 1 = 1. The four (real) basis one-forms θ A A for A = 0, 1, A = 0, 1 are called a tetrad. The algebraic dual vector basis is denoted e A A , and is defined by θ A A (e B B ) = δ BA δ BA . Any vector V at a point can be written V A A e A A , and this exhibits an isomorpism TM ∼ = S ⊗ S,
(2.2)
88
M. Dunajski, S. West
where S, S are two-dimensional real vector bundles known as the unprimed spin bundle and the primed spin bundle respectively. For a general manifold M there is a topological obstruction to (2.2) but we are working locally so it always holds. Using a particular choice of tetrad, a section µ of S is denoted µ A , A = 0, 1. Simi larly ν A is a section of S ∗ , κ A a section of S and τ A a section of S ∗ , where ∗ denotes the dual of a bundle. The natural pairing S × S ∗ → R is given by µ A ν A , using the summation convention, and similarly for primed spinors. We sometimes use the notation µ A ν A = µ.ν. This product is not commutative; we have µ.ν = −ν.µ. It follows from (2.1) that g(V, V ) = det V A A . If V is null, then this gives V A A = µ A κ A . Abstractly, if V is null then V = µ ⊗ κ under the isomorphism (2.2), where µ and κ are sections of S and S respectively. The relation (2.1) can be written abstractly as g = ⊗ under the isomorphism (2.2). and are symplectic structures on S and S . These give isomorphisms S ∼ = S ∗ and S ∼ = S ∗ by µ → (µ, .), for µ a section of S, and similarly for S . Given a choice of tetrad, the spinors and are written AB and A B , where we drop the prime on the latter because no confusion can arise due to the indices. Note these are anti-symmetric in AB and A B . Then the isomorphism S ∼ = S ∗ is given in the A B trivialization by µ → µ B A := µ A and similarly for primed spinors. There are useful isomorphisms 2+ ∼ = Sym(S ∗ ⊗ S ∗ ), 2− ∼ = Sym(S ∗ ⊗ S ∗ ),
(2.3)
where + , − are the bundles of self-dual and anti-self-dual two-forms, using an appropriate choice of volume form for the Hodge-∗ operator. In the local trivialization, the isomorphisms (2.3) are expressed by the following formula for a two-form F in spinors: Fab = FA A B B = φ A B AB + ψ AB A B , where φ A B , ψ AB are symmetric. The φ A B term is the self-dual component of F and the ψ AB is the anti-self-dual component. The vector bundles S, S and their duals inherit connections from the Levi-Civita connection of T M (see Appendix A). These are the unique torsion-free connections defined so that the sections and are covariantly constant. Then covariant differentiation on either side of (2.2) is consistent. A primed spinor κ A at a point corresponds to a totally null self-dual two-plane spanned by κ A e A A , A = 1, 2, whilst an unprimed spinor corresponds to an anti-selfdual two-plane in a similar way. In twistor theory, these two-planes are called α-planes and β-planes respectively. 2.2. Null conformal Killing vectors in neutral signature. Suppose g is a neutral metric with a conformal Killing vector K . Then L K (ec g) = (K (ec ) + ec η)g, so K is a conformal Killing vector for the conformally rescaled metric, and we can refer to K as a conformal Killing vector for the conformal structure [g]. Now suppose g has a null conformal Killing vector K . We shall show (Lemma 1) that M is foliated in two different ways, by self-dual and anti-self-dual surfaces, whose leaves intersect tangent to K . This is a property of the conformal structure [g], since the Hodge-∗ acting on 2-forms is conformally invariant.
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
89
The spinor form of the conformal Killing equation is: 1 ∇a K b = φ A B AB + ψ AB A B + η AB A B , 2
(2.4)
where φ A B , ψ AB are the self-dual and anti-self dual parts of the 2-form ∇[a K b] , and η is a function on M. Since K is null, we have K = ι ⊗ o, where ι is a section of S and o a section of S . Choosing a null tetrad, and a trivialization of S and S , we have K A A = ι A o A . These spinors are defined up to multiplication by a non-zero function α, since K A A = ι A o A = (αι A )(o A /α).
Lemma 1. Let K = ι A o A e A A be a null conformal Killing vector. Then 1. The following algebraic identities hold: ι A ι B ψ AB = 0,
(2.5)
o o φ A B = 0.
(2.6)
A B
2. ι A and o A satisfy A
ι A ι B ∇ B B ι A = 0, B
o o ∇
B B
o
A
= 0.
(2.7) (2.8)
Remark. Equations (2.7), (2.8) are equivalent to the statement that the distributions spanned by ι A e A A and o A e A A are Frobenius integrable (see the Appendix). Equations of this type are often called ‘geodesic shear free’ equations, since in the Lorentzian case they result in shear-free congruences of null geodesics. Proof. Using K A A = ι A o A , the Killing equation (2.4) becomes 1 o A ∇ B B ι A + ι A ∇ B B o A = φ A B AB + ψ AB A B + η AB A B . 2
(2.9)
Contracting both sides with ι A o A gives 1 0 = o A ι B φ A B + ι A o B ψ AB + ηι B o B . 2
Multiplying by ι B and o B respectively leads to (2.5) and (2.6). To get (2.7) and (2.8),
multiply (2.9) by ι A ι B and o A o B . We have found that M is foliated in two different ways by totally null surfaces. Those determined by o A are self-dual and are called α-surfaces, and those determined by ι A are anti-self-dual and are called β-surfaces. It is clear that the α-surfaces and β-surfaces of Lemma 1 intersect on integral curves of K . Denote the β-surface distribution by Dβ ; this will be used later. It is appropriate here to recall the Petrov-Penrose classification [22] of the algebraic type of a Weyl tensor. In split signature this applies separately to C ABC D and C A B C D . In our case C A B C D = 0 and we are concerned with the algebraic type of C ABC D . When we refer to the algebraic type we will be referring to the algebraic type of C ABC D . One can form a real polynomial of fourth order P(x) by defining µ A = (1, x) and setting
90
M. Dunajski, S. West
P(x) = µ A µ B µC µ D C ABC D . The Petrov-Penrose classification refers to the position of roots of this polynomial, for example if there are four repeated roots then we say C ABC D is type N. If there is a repeated root the metric is called algebraically special. There are additional complications in the split signature case [16] arising from the fact that real polynomials may not have real roots. The split signature version of the Goldberg-Sachs theorem together with (2.7) implies that any Ricci-flat ASD space with null conformal Killing vector is algebraically special. In fact the vacuum condition can be removed if K is non-twisting; we will discuss this further in Sect. 6.5. It also follows from the Killing equations and the fact that K is null that K b ∇b K a =
1 ηK a . 2
Thus K is automatically geodesic, and if it is pure then its trajectories are parameterized by an affine parameter. 3. Projective Structures Let (U, []) be a local two dimensional real projective structure. That is, U is a local patch of R2 , and [] is an equivalence class of torsion-free connections whose unparameterized geodesics are the same. Then in a local trivialization, equivalent torsion-free connections are related in the following way: ˜ ijk − ijk = a j δki + ak δ ij ,
(3.1)
for functions ai on U , and i, j, k = 1, 2. Note that this is a tensor equation since the difference between two connections is a tensor. The ai on the RHS are the components of a one-form. The geodesics satisfy the following ODE: j k d 2si ds i i ds ds = v , + jk dt 2 dt dt dt
where s i are local coordinates of U , and t is a parameter, which is called affine if v = 0. One can associate a second-order ODE to a projective structure by picking a connection in the equivalence class, choosing local coordinates s i = (x, y) say, and eliminating the parameter from the geodesic equations. The resulting equation determines the geodesics in terms of the local coordinates, without the parameter. The equation is as follows: dy 3 dy 2 d2 y y y dy y x x − x x . = + (2 − ) + (xx x − 2x y ) yy yy xy 2 dx dx dx dx
(3.2)
A general projective structure is therefore defined by a second-order ODE (1.5). In fact, two of the four functions A0 , A1 , A2 , A3 can be eliminated by a coordinate transformation (x, y) → (x(x, ˆ y), yˆ (x, y)) which introduces two arbitrary functions. On T U , the horizontal lifts of ∂/∂s i are defined by Si =
∂ ∂ j − ik v k j , ∂s i ∂v
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
91
where v i , i = 1, 2 are the fibre coordinates of T U . The geodesics on U lift to integral curves of the following spray on T U : = v i Si = v i
∂ ∂ − ijk v j v k i . i ∂s ∂v
(3.3)
Now is homogeneous of degree 1 in the v i , so it projects to a section of a one dimensional distribution on P T U . P T U is the quotient of T U − {0-section} by the vector field v i ∂v∂ i . If λ is a standard coordinate on one patch of the RP1 factor,1 then the spray has the form = ∂x + λ∂ y + (A0 (x, y) + λA1 (x, y) + λ2 A2 (x, y) + λ3 A3 (x, y))∂λ .
(3.4)
There is a unique curve in any direction through a point in U , which is why the curves can be lifted to a foliation of the projective tangent bundle U × RP1 . ˜ is the spray corresponding to a different To obtain (3.1) we argue as follows. If ˜ ˜ ˜ push down to connection , then and are in the same projective class if and the same spray on P T U . This gives ∂ , ∂v i from which (3.1) follows, using the fact that the connections are torsion-free (i.e. symmetric in their lower indices). ˜ ∝ vi −
3.1. The twistor space of a projective structure. Now suppose we have a holomorphic projective structure on a local patch of C2 , which we still denote U . All of the above is still valid, with real coordinates replaced by complex ones. The functions ijk are now required to be holomorphic functions of the coordinates. Given a real-analytic projective structure, one can complexify by analytic continuation to obtain a holomorphic projective structure that will come equipped with a reality structure (see below). ∂ The space P T U is obtained from T U on quotienting by µi ∂µ i , which defines a tautological line bundle O(−1) over P T U . As the Si are weight zero in the µi coordinates, they push down to vector fields on P T U , giving a two-dimensional distribution S. Since is weight one in the µi , one must divide by a homogeneous polynomial of degree one in the µi to get something that pushes down to a vector field on P T U . The resulting vector field will have a singularity at a single point on each fibre, where the degree one polynomial vanishes. Different choices of polynomial will result in different vector fields on P T U , but they will always be in the same direction. In other words, defines a one dimensional distribution which we shall call D . Restricting to a CP1 fibre, D defines a line bundle over CP1 . A section of this line bundle corresponds to a vector field in D , i.e. a choice of polynomial as described above, and has a pole at a single point. Therefore by the classification of holomorphic line bundles over CP1 , it must be O(−1).2 1 By standard coordinates λ, λ ˜ on RP1 or CP1 , we mean the usual coordinates v 1 /v 0 and v 0 /v 1 , where v 0 , v 1 are homogeneous coordinates. 2 Coordinatize CP1 using two patches, U with coordinate λ ∈ C, and U with coordinate η ∈ C, and 0 1 transition function λ = 1/η. The holomorphic line bundle O(n) over CP1 is defined by the transition function a = λn b, where a ∈ C is the fibre coordinate over U0 and b(η) ∈ C is the fibre coordinate over U1 . The Birkhoff-Grothendieck theorem states that any holomorphic line bundle over CP1 is O(n) for some n. A global section of O(n) has |n| zeroes or poles, for n positive or negative respectively.
92
M. Dunajski, S. West
Restricting to a CP1 fibre, one obtains the following exact sequence of vector bundles over CP1 : 0 → O(−1) → O ⊕ O → S/D → 0,
(3.5)
where the first bundle is D , the second is S, and the last is the quotient. In fact, the quotient is O(1), for the following reason. Consider for instance the push down of S0 to P T U . This defines a subbundle of S that is different to everywhere except at a single point, the image of µ1 = 0. Hence it determines a section of S/ which vanishes at a single point. Therefore, again using the classification of holomorphic line bundles over CP1 , we have S/D ∼ = O(1). The twistor space Z is the two dimensional quotient of P T U by D . A point u ∈ U corresponds to a twistor line uˆ ⊂ Z corresponding to all the geodesics through u. The normal bundle of an embedded uˆ = CP1 ⊂ Z is given by the quotient bundle in the above sequence, i.e. O(1). This is summarized by a double fibration picture: U
U × CP1
Z
The left arrow denotes projection to U , and the right arrow denotes the quotient by D . The converse is also valid: Theorem 3 [11, 17]. There is a 1-1 correspondence between local two dimensional holomorphic projective structures and complex surfaces containing an embedded CP1 with normal bundle O(1). A vector V ∈ Tu U corresponds to a global section of the normal bundle O(1) of u. ˆ Such a section vanishes at a single point p ∈ Z . The geodesic of the projective structure through this direction is given by points in U corresponding to twistor lines in Z that intersect uˆ at p. That there is a one-parameter family of such lines can be shown by blowing up Z at the vanishing point and using Kodaira theory, see [11].
3.2. Flatness of projective structures. A projective structure is said to be flat if the corresponding second order ODE (1.5) can be transformed to the trivial ODE d2 y =0 dx2
(3.6)
by coordinate transformation (x, y) → (x(x, ˆ y), yˆ (x, y)). The terminology comes from the fact that given any second order ODE one can construct a Cartan connection on a certain G-structure [2], and when this connection is flat the equation can be transformed to the trivial ODE (3.6). It turns out that a second order ODE must be of the form (1.5) to be flat, and in addition the functions A0 , A1 , A2 , A3 must satisfy some PDEs. Defining F(x, y, λ) = A0 (x, y) + λA1 (x, y) + λ2 A2 (x, y) + λ3 A3 (x, y), the following must hold [2]: d d2 d F11 − 4 F01 − F1 F11 + 4F1 F01 − 3F0 F11 + 6F00 = 0, dx 2 dx dx
(3.7)
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
93
where F0 =
∂F , ∂y
F1 =
∂F , ∂λ
d ∂ ∂ ∂ = +λ +F . dx ∂x ∂y ∂λ
This is a set of PDEs for the functions A0 , A1 , A2 , A3 .
3.3. Reality conditions for projective structures. A reality structure for Z is an antiholomorphic involution that leaves invariant a two real parameter family of twistor lines, and fixes an equator of each line. Given a line in this real family, all the sections pointing to nearby lines in the real family have a zero at some point, and the union of these points gives an equator of the line; this equator must be fixed by the reality structure. The real family of twistor lines then corresponds to a real manifold U with a projective structure. In this paper all holomorphic projective structures have reality structures since they occur as complexifications of real projective structures.
4. Null Killing Vectors and Twistor Space 4.1. The twistor space of an ASD conformal structure. In the following and for the rest of the paper, e˜ A A denote the horizontal lifts of e A A to S , or their push-down to P S . Abstractly, the integral curves of these horizontal lifts define parallelly transported primed spinors using the connection on S (see Appendix A). We can abstractly define the two-dimensional twistor distribution on S as follows. A point s ∈ S is determined by a primed spinor π at a point x ∈ M. The null vectors π ⊗ µ for all unprimed spinors µ span an α-plane at x. Define the twistor distribution at s to be the subspace of horizontal vectors at s whose push-down to the base lies in this α-plane. Concretely, the twistor distribution is spanned by vectors L A (A = 0, 1) on S , defined with a choice of tetrad by ∂ L A = π A e˜ A A = π A e A A − A A BC π B , ∂π C
(4.1)
where π A are the local coordinates on the fibres of S . In the Appendix it is shown that the twistor distribution is integrable for ASD conformal structures, which is a seminal result of Penrose [21]. In other words, given a neutral ASD conformal structure [g], each self-dual two plane at a point is tangent to a unique α-surface through that point, which is the push down of a leaf of the twistor distribution. In the holomorphic case, the space of leaves of the twistor distribution (locally, over a suitably convex region of the base), is a three dimensional complex manifold PT called the twistor space [21, 11]. The double fibration picture is very similar to the projective structure case discussed in Sect. 3.1. The projective primed spin bundle P S is the quotient of S by the vector field π A ∂ A . P S is fundamental in the fibration picture, as each α-surface in M has a ∂π unique lift, in the same way that each geodesic of a projective structure has a unique lift to the projective tangent bundle. The horizontal vectors e˜ A A are weight zero in the π A coordinates, so push down to vector fields on P S , giving a four-dimensional distribution on P S . The L A vectors (4.1) are weight one, so together define a two dimensional
94
M. Dunajski, S. West
subdistribution L of , which restricts to O(−1) ⊕ O(−1) on a CP1 fibre; we also refer to this as the twistor distribution. Over a CP1 fibre, there is an exact sequence 0 → O(−1) ⊕ O(−1) → O ⊗ C4 → /L → 0.
(4.2)
The first term is L, the second is . As in the projective structure case, one can show that /L is O(1) ⊕ O(1). The twistor space PT is the quotient of P S by L. The image of a CP1 fibre over x ∈ M is an embedded CP1 ∈ PT , and has normal bundle O(1) ⊕ O(1), the quotient bundle in (4.2). It corresponds to all the α-surfaces through x. The twistor correspondence is summarized by the double fibration: M
P S
PT
Here the left arrow denotes projection to M, and the right arrow denotes the quotient by L. Again, there is a converse: Theorem (Penrose [21]). There is a 1-1 correspondence between local four dimensional holomorphic ASD conformal structures (M, [g]) and three dimensional complex manifolds PT with an embedded CP1 ⊂ PT , with normal bundle O(1) ⊕ O(1). The essential fact is that an embedded CP1 with the above normal bundle belongs to a family of embedded CP1 s parameterized by a complex 4-manifold M. Vectors at x ∈ M correspond to sections of the normal bundle of x, ˆ and null vectors are given by sections with a zero. This defines a conformal structure, because a global section of O(1) ⊕ O(1) is given by (aλ + b, cλ + d) for affine coordinate λ ∈ C, (a, b, c, d) ∈ C4 , and this can only be (0, 0) when ad − bc = 0, which is a quadratic condition. In this case there is a zero at a single point. The conformal structure is anti-self-dual, with α-surfaces defined by families of twistor lines through a fixed point in PT . In this picture, the α-surfaces are obtained as follows. Let xˆ ⊂ PT be the twistor line corresponding to a point x ∈ M. Let V ∈ Tx M be a null vector. We want to show that V lies in a unique α-surface through x. The corresponding section of the normal bundle of xˆ has a zero at some point p ∈ PT because V is null. The α-surface corresponds to all the twistor lines that intersect xˆ at p. There is a two-parameter family of such lines. It is easy to see that there is a two-parameter family of sections that vanish at p. To show that these are tangent to a two-parameter family of lines one must blow-up PT at p and use Kodaira theory; see [11] for details. 4.1.1. Reality conditions for split signature. In order to obtain a real split signature metric from a twistor space, we must be able to distinguish a four real parameter family of twistor lines, whose parameter space will be the four real dimensional manifold. In addition we require that given a line in this real family, the sections of the normal bundle that point to others in the family inherit a split signature conformal structure. As described above, a section of O(1) ⊕ O(1) is defined by four complex numbers (a, b, c, d), with a quadratic form defined by ad − bc. If we restrict (a, b, c, d) to be real we obtain a real split signature conformal structure. The sections tangent to the real family are of this type. The zero of such sections occurs for real λ, that is, on an equator of CP1 . The conformal structure is thus invariant under an anti-holomorphic involution of the CP1 that
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
95
has the equator fixed. A split signature real structure on PT is an anti-holomorphic involution that leaves invariant a four real parameter family of twistor lines, and when restricted to one of these fixes an equator. Not all holomorphic metrics have real structures, but all the holomorphic metrics in this paper have obvious real ‘slices’ because they are complexifications of real metrics, obtained by letting the real coordinates be complex. 4.2. Lift of K to P S . Now given a null conformal Killing vector for an ASD conformal structure, the fact that M is foliated by α-surfaces (Lemma 1) is not very illuminating, since they must already exist by anti-self-duality. The foliation by β-surfaces is more interesting, since these do not exist generically. In this section we will prove that in the analytic case, the space of β-surfaces inherits a natural projective structure. We then explain how this arises geometrically, due to the presence of α-surfaces ensured by anti-self-duality. Let K be a null conformal Killing vector for (M, [g]). We assume K is without fixed points, which can always be arranged by restricting M to a suitable open set. Since K preserves the conformal structure, the corresponding diffeomorphism maps α-surfaces to α-surfaces, and hence it induces a vector field K on PT . We now translate this fact into a statement on the projective primed spin bundle P S . Each α-surface has a unique lift and these lifts foliate P S . The following proposition shows how to lift K to P S , giving a vector field that is Lie-derived along the lifts of the α-surfaces.
Proposition 1. Let K = K A A e A A be a conformal Killing vector for an ASD metric g. Define a vector field K˜ on S by ∂ 1 A ∂ ηπ K˜ := K A A e˜ A A + π A φ A B + . 2 ∂π B ∂π A
(4.3)
∂ 3 [ K˜ , L A ] = (K B B B B AD − ψ A D )L D + (e AB η)π B π C . 4 ∂π C
(4.4)
Then this satisfies
Proof. See the Appendix.
Remark. Since K˜ is weight zero in the π A coordinates, it defines a vector field on P S , which we will also refer to as K˜ by abuse of notation. The last term on the right-hand side of (4.4) is proportional to the Euler vector field, so does not contribute to K˜ on P S . Hence (4.4) shows that K˜ commutes with the twistor distribution L on P S . The vector field K on PT is the push-forward of K˜ to PT , which is well defined because K˜ is Lie-derived along L. 4.3. Projective structure from a quotient. In this section we assume that [g] is analytic, so we can complexify by analytic continuation. Thus we are now working on a local patch of C4 , with a holomorphic conformal structure. We assume that we have restricted to a suitable open set on the base so that all the spaces of leaves involved are non-singular complex manifolds. As in Sect. 2, write K = ι A o A e A A , where now e A A is a holomorphic tetrad and ι A , o A are complex spinor fields that vary holomorphically.
96
M. Dunajski, S. West
When K is null, it is easy to see that K, the induced vector field on twistor space PT , will vanish on a hypersurface H in PT , because K fixes a two-parameter family of α-surfaces, which are those to which it is tangent. These are the ‘special’ α-surfaces of Lemma 1. We now explain how this is seen from the lift K˜ to P S . On S , K˜ from Proposition 1 is given by: ∂ 1 A ∂ K˜ = ι A o A e˜ A A + π A φ A B ηπ + . B 2 ∂π ∂π A
Now when π A ∝ o A , one has π A φ A B ∝ o B from (2.5), so the second term on the RHS is proportional to the Euler vector field ϒ = π A ∂ A . The last term is everywhere ∂π proportional to the Euler vector field. To go from S to P S one quotients S −{0-section} by the integral curves of ϒ. So we have shown that on the section [π A ] = [o A ] of P S , K˜ is the push down of ι A o A e˜ A A only. But this is in L, so K˜ pushes down to the zero vector under the quotient of P S by L. So there is a (complex) hypersurface in P S , defined by the section [π A ] = [o A ], on which K˜ lies in the twistor distribution. One can also define this hypersurface as the image in P S of the hypersurface π.o = 0 in S , under the quotient by ϒ. We will refer to this hypersurface as H . It is easy to see by pushing down to the base that K˜ is linearly independent of the twistor distribution everywhere else on P S . Define a vector field
V = ι A L A = ι A π A e˜ A A
on S . This is weight one in the π A coordinates, so gives a one dimensional distribution on P S which restricts to O(−1) on fibres. Together with span{ K˜ }, we get a two dimensional distribution on P S − H . On H , the distribution drops its rank from two to one. The two dimensional distribution defined by {V, K˜ } on P S − H pushes down to the β-plane distribution Dβ on the base. Lemma 2. The two dimensional distribution on P S − H determined by {V, K˜ } is integrable. Proof. We work on S for convenience, and push down to P S at the end. The distri bution span{ K˜ , V } on S is two dimensional on S when π A o A = 0. Multiples of the Euler field ϒ are therefore irrelevant: [V, K˜ ] = [ K˜ , ιC L C ] = ιC [ K˜ , L C ] + K˜ (ι B )L B
∂ 3 = ιC ((K B B B B CD − ψC D )L D + (eC B η)π B π C ) 4 ∂π C +K B B e B B (ιC )L C
= (K B B ∇ B B ιC − ι D ψ DC )L C + #ϒ
= (ι B o B ∇ B B ιC − ι D ψ DC )L C + #ϒ.
From (2.5) we have ι D ψ DC ∝ ιC , and from (2.7) we have ι B o B ∇ B B ιC ∝ ιC . Hence the RHS is proportional to V , ignoring the irrelevant Euler vector field part.
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
97
Next we will show that it is possible to continue this distribution over the hypersurface H so it is rank two on the whole of P S , and that the resulting distribution commutes on the hypersurface. It will then be possible to quotient P S by the leaves of this distribution. Lemma 3. There is a two-dimensional integrable distribution D over P S , which on P S − H is determined by { K˜ , V }. Let be the projection P S → M. Then for every p ∈ P S , we have ∗ (D | p ) = Dβ . Remark. Intuitively one can think of D as a lift of the β-surfaces to P S , where each β-surface has a CP1 of lifts.
Proof. Choose a spinor ι A satisfying o A ι A = 1. Define the following (singular) vector field on S : W =
1 (V − (π D ι D ) K˜ ). π C oC
(4.5)
This is weight zero in the π A , so defines a vector field on P S by push-forward, which we shall also call W . We will now show that W is well defined even over H ⊂ P S , despite the 1/(π C oC ) factor in (4.5). Without loss of generality, choose a tetrad such that
K = ι A o A e A A = e00 .
That is, ι A = (1, 0), o A = (1, 0). Define λ = π 1 /π 0 to be the coordinate on the π 0 = 0 patch of CP1 , and extend this to a patch of P S ; we call the patch U. Then H lies entirely within U at λ = 0. We have the following expression for K˜ , obtained by ‘projectivizing’ (4.3): ∂ K˜ = e˜ 00 + (φ01 + λ(φ11 − φ00 ) + λ2 φ10 ) ∂λ ∂ 1 0 2 0 = e˜ 00 + (λ(φ1 − φ0 ) + λ φ1 ) , ∂λ
where φ01 = 0 due to (2.6). In the above conventions, we have V = π A e˜ 0 A . On U ⊂ P S , the push forward of 1 V is C π
oC
1 e˜ 00 + e˜ 01 , λ
which is singular at H , corresponding to λ = 0. Choosing ι A = (0, −1), we then obtain the following expression for W on U: W =
1 1 ∂ e˜ 00 + e˜ 01 − K˜ = e˜ 01 − ((φ11 − φ00 ) + λφ10 )) . λ λ ∂λ
This is a non-singular vector field on U. By construction, away from H this lies in span{ K˜ , V˜ }. Define D on U to be span{ K˜ , W }. This is clearly non-degenerate everywhere on U. Note that W is also well defined over the other patch (i.e. at λ = ∞) so we can define D as span{ K˜ , W } over the whole of P S .
98
M. Dunajski, S. West
We now want to show that D is integrable over H . We know (Lemma 2) that D is integrable away from H . Therefore on U we have [ K˜ , W ] = f K˜ + gW + Y, where f, g are holomorphic functions on U and Y is a holomorphic vector field vanishing on U − H . But such a vector field must vanish, otherwise it is not even continuous, so is certainly not holomorphic. The last part of the lemma is obvious, just from inspecting the coordinate expressions of K˜ , W .
We now have a three dimensional integrable distribution L+D. It is three dimensional because at each point L and D have a direction in common, which is the one-dimensional distribution defined on P S by the push-forward of V on S . From Lemma 3, D is an integrable subdistribution. Note that D consists of a CP1 of lifts of each β-surface in the base. If we pick a suitably convex set on the base so that the space of β-surfaces U intersecting it is a Hausdorff complex manifold, then the quotient P S /D will also be a Hausdorff complex manifold. A point in this quotient is a point in U together with a choice of lift. In fact we can canonically identify P S /D with P T U , the projective tangent bundle of U , as follows. Using the conventions of Lemma 3, the tangent planes to the β-surfaces in the base are spanned at each point by e00 , e01 . Now L 1 has the form e10 + λe11 + (. . .)∂λ , so at each point in the fibre above a point x ∈ M, L 1 pushes down to a different null direction transverse to the β-plane at x. Now suppose we take a lift of a β-surface , i.e. a leaf of D that projects down to . Push down L 1 at each point over this lift. This will give a vector field = e10 + λe11 over , where λ is now a function on the M. We want to show that this determines a projective vector at the point s ∈ U corresponding to S. This means we require [e00 , ] ∝ mod{e00 , e01 }, [e01 , ] ∝ mod{e00 , e01 }. But it is easy to show that this is satisfied, using the fact that the distribution spanned by K˜ , W, L 1 commutes. Hence to determine the projective vector corresponding to a leaf of D, just choose a point on the leaf and push down L 1 . Because of the above considerations, this direction will be independent of the choice of point on the leaf. Proof of Theorem 1. Define Z as the quotient of P S by L ∪ D. Equivalently, this is the quotient of PT by a one-dimensional distribution which on PT − H is span{K}. The image of a CP1 fibre of P S under the quotient is a twistor line in Z . On a CP1 fibre, the horizontal part of D defines a subbundle O ⊗ C2 of the horizontal distribution = O ⊗ C4 , corresponding to the horizontal parts of the vectors K˜ and W . Choosing a spinor o A such that ι A o A = 1, we can form the vector field o A L A on S , which pushes down to a horizontal distribution on P S that is always linearly independent of D. Since the L A are weight one, this is O(−1) when restricted to a CP1 fibre. Because L ∪ D is integrable (Lemma 3), this distribution determines a one dimensional distribution D on P T U = P S /D. The spray of a projective structure is a section of D ⊗ O(1) where here O(1) is dual to the tautological line bundle over P T U . The situation is described by the following commuting diagram: 0 → O(−1) ⊕ O(−1) → O ⊗ C4 → O(1) ⊕ O(1) → 0 ↓V ↓D ↓ 0→ O(−1) → O ⊗ C2 → O(1) →0
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
99
PS’ L D
M Dβ
PT PTU
DΘ
U
K
Z Fig. 1. Relationship between foliation spaces
where these are bundles over a CP1 fibre of P S . The vector field o A L A on S constructed above corresponds to the O(−1) in the bottom row after quotienting by V , and gives the projective structure spray. The bottom row is the sequence (3.5) on P T U = P S /D, where U is the space of β-surfaces in M. Thus there is a projective structure on U .
Remark. The real space of β-surfaces has a system of curves that comes from the quotienting operations described above but with real spaces instead of complex. These real curves are described by the holomorphic projective structure with a reality structure. Figure 1 illustrates the situation. Here p and q are the obvious projections. Dβ repre labelling the map from PT to Z requires sents the β-surface distribution on M. The K ˜ some explanation. The vector field K over P S commutes with the twistor distribution (Lemma 1), so determines a vector field K on PT . This vector field vanishes on a hypersurface H ⊂ PT , corresponding to the α-surfaces to which K is tangent; these are the α-surfaces appearing in Lemma 1. Now K on PT only depends on K˜ modulo L. Lemma 3 shows that we can multiply K˜ modulo L by a meromorphic function (1/λ) and obtain a vector field W commuting with the twistor distribution. This means that over the whole of PT that never degenerates, there is a one-dimensional distribution K and which agrees with span {K} on PT − H. The quotient of PT by this distribution gives Z , as illustrated in the diagram. One can rephrase this in terms of divisor line bundles. That is, there is a holomorphic line bundle E over PT defined by the property that it has a meromorphic section ζ with a pole of order one on H. Then ζ ⊗ K defines a non-vanishing section of E ⊗ T PT . over PT described above. To This is equivalent to the one dimensional distribution K obtain the distribution one simply finds trivializations of E and T PT over a patch, and expresses ζ in this trivialization. Its direction will be independent of the trivialization of E, and defines the distribution over the patch. 4.4. Relationship of the twistor spaces. Here we discuss the relationship between the twistor spaces without the foliation space picture. Incidence relation between various objects in M and PT is represented by Fig. 2. First one must understand what a β-surface corresponds to in PT . The answer is a two-parameter family of twistor lines, each of which intersects any other at a single point. This is because all points on a β-surface are null separated. However, unlike the case of an α-surface, there is not just a single point of intersection of the whole family. To construct the family, pick a point on the β-surface, say x. Then xˆ is a twistor line in PT . Now K determines a section of the normal bundle with a zero. Twistor lines intersecting
100
M. Dunajski, S. West
PT M
p1 β p3 p2 K
β
p2
α
p3 p1
α
Fig. 2. The α and β surfaces in M intersect along a trajectory of K which is a null geodesic. This corresponds to a point α lying on a surface β in PT . Points p1 , p2 , p3 in M correspond to projective lines in PT
xˆ at this zero are on the β-surface, and correspond to those along the trajectory of K through x. In fact this is a null geodesic, since null Killing vector fields have geodesic integral curves. Now pick another section of the normal bundle with a zero at a different point, such that all linear combinations of this with the section determined by K also have a zero. The resulting two dimensional distribution in M at x is a β-plane. Doing this for each x ∈ M gives a β-plane distribution which is integrable. The diagram (Fig. 3) illustrates the situation. In M, a one parameter family of β-surface is shown, each of which intersects a one parameter family of α-surfaces, also shown. The β-surfaces correspond to a projective structure geodesic in U , shown at the bottom left. The β-surfaces in M correspond to surfaces in PT , as discussed above. These surfaces intersect at the dotted line, which corresponds to the one parameter family of
Fig. 3. Relationship between M, U , PT and Z
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
101
α-surfaces in M. When we quotient PT by K to get Z , the surfaces become twistor lines in Z , and the dotted line becomes a point at which the twistor lines intersect; this is shown on the bottom right. This family of twistor lines intersecting at a point corresponds to the geodesic of the projective structure. 5. Local Classification The second theorem stated in the Introduction gives a local expression for any smooth neutral signature ASD conformal structure. We now prove this theorem. In the proof we continue to work in the holomorphic category for continuity, but all the arguments work when the variables are real rather than complex, CP1 is replaced by RP1 , and functions are smooth rather than holomorphic. The smooth generalization of Theorem 1 could perhaps be established using techniques introduced in [18]. In the proof we will often use the following shorthand for coordinate transformations: t → F(t, x, y, z) means define a new coordinate t˜ = F(t, x, y, z) and then relabel it t again. This avoids having to introduce new symbols for new coordinates. We will denote partial derivatives by subscripts, for example Fz := ∂z F. Proof of Theorem 2. In what follows, we will use coordinates (x, y) for the twodimensional space of β-surfaces U . We will always work on a single patch of P S , with λ a standard coordinate on one patch of the CP1 fibre. The projectivization of (4.1) is L 0 = e00 + λe01 + ( f 0 + λ f 1 + λ2 f 2 + λ3 f 3 )∂λ , L 1 = e01 + λe11 + (A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 )∂λ ,
(5.1) (5.2)
where the f α and Aα are functions on M derived from primed connection coefficients. We can trivialize P T U by first choosing a two dimensional surface in M, transverse to the β-surfaces, and trivializing P S over this, using the standard two patch coordinates for CP1 . Then define a trivialization over the rest of P S by requiring constant coordinate on each leaf of D (this will be a base dependent Möbius transformation of any other trivialization of P S using a standard two patch trivialization of CP1 , since any two standard trivializations of CP1 are related by a Möbius transformation). This gives a trivialization P T U ∼ = U × CP1 . The special feature of this particular trivialization is ˜ that K and W will have no vertical terms, because it was defined by saying that the fibre coordinate is constant along them. We will use the conventions of Lemma 3, that is we choose a tetrad with K = e00 , and the tangent planes to the β-surfaces are spanned by K and e01 . Now choose a coordinate system (t, x, y, z) such that K = ∂t , and a conformal factor so that K is pure Killing. Any tetrad can then be written in these coordinates without any t dependence. Then [e00 , e01 ] = 0 and we can in addition choose the z coordinate such that e01 = ∂z . Then we have K˜ = ∂t , L 0 = ∂t + λ∂z + f (x, y, z, λ)∂λ . Note that f does not depend on t because it is composed from connection coefficients, which do not depend on t since it does not occur in the metric. Also note that K˜ = ∂t because L 0 , L 1 do not contain functions of t so it commutes with both. As vector fields on the base, ∂x and ∂ y are transverse to the β-surfaces, and so are coordinates on U .
102
M. Dunajski, S. West
Now we will alter the λ coordinate, using a trivialization as described above, so that L 0 has no ∂λ terms. This is achieved by a Möbius transformation, λ → (β + δλ)/(α + γ λ), where α, β, γ , δ are functions on M. Now the new λ coordinate satisfies K˜ (λ) = L 0 (λ) = 0. Therefore α, . . . , δ do not depend on t, from the first of these. This gives the following general form: K˜ = ∂t , L 0 = α ∂t + β ∂z + λ(γ ∂t + δ ∂z ).
(5.3) (5.4)
Now from Theorem 1, we know that L 1 must define a projective structure on U , the space of β-surfaces. In fact this can be seen directly using our coordinate choices. Clearly U has coordinates (x, y), since the β-surfaces are spanned by (∂t , ∂z ). Also, λ is a fibre coordinate on P T U , since D is defined by constant λ. Since {L 0 , L 1 } is an integrable distribution, one can find a non-zero function f on P S such that [L 0 , f L 1 ] ∝ L 0 . We may therefore assume we have chosen an L 1 such that [L 0 , L 1 ] ∝ L 0 . It follows from (5.4) that the coefficients in front of the ∂x , ∂ y , ∂λ terms in L 1 do not depend on z. Therefore L 1 must have the following form: L 1 := J0 (x, y)∂x + J1 (x, y)∂ y + λ(J2 (x, y)∂x + J3 (x, y)∂ y ) +(A0 (x, y) + λA1 (x, y) + λ2 A2 (x, y) + λ3 A3 (x, y))∂λ +(C(x, y, z) + λD(x, y, z))∂t + (E(x, y, z) + λF(x, y, z))∂z ,
(5.5)
where J0 J3 − J1 J2 = 0. One now observes that the ∂x , ∂ y , ∂λ terms precisely correspond to a projective structure spray on P T U . Since D is spanned by ∂t , ∂z , the quotient of L 1 by D gives a projective structure. To put the projective structure spray occurring in (5.5) into the more standard form (3.4) (i.e. J0 = J3 = 1, J1 = J2 = 0) it is necessary to perform a Möbius transformation of λ depending on (x, y). Since this does not depend on t or z, the general form (5.4) of L 0 is unchanged by this, and we can assume that the projective structure spray in L 1 is of the form (3.4), which we shall do from now on. We have found a general form that any { K˜ , L A } can be put into. For it to give an ASD conformal structure, the L A must commute modulo L A . Imposing this gives equations for the unknown functions, which will lead us to the metrics appearing in Theorem 2. First, it is convenient to change coordinates yet again, because together with conformal rescaling we can elimate three of the four functions in L 0 . We may assume δ = 0 (if δ = 0 then β = 0, in which case perform the coordinate change λ → 1/λ). Now change coordinates by (t, x, y, z) → (t + j (x, y, z), x, y, k(x, y, z)), where k z = 0. A suitable choice of j and k, and conformal rescaling, simplifies L 0 so that finally K˜ = ∂t , L 0 = ∂t − β(x, y, z)∂z + λ∂z ,
(5.6) (5.7)
L 1 = ∂x + λ∂ y + (A0 (x, y) + λA1 (x, y) + λ2 A2 (x, y) + λ3 A3 (x, y))∂λ +(C(x, y, z) + λD(x, y, z))∂t + (E(x, y, z) + λF(x, y, z))∂z .
(5.8)
One can read off a metric g ∈ [g] corresponding to the twistor distribution given by (5.7) and (5.8) by comparing with (5.1) and (5.2) and reading off a null tetrad. One finds that K ∧ dK = βz d x ∧ dy ∧ dz, where K = g(∂t , .). Thus the twist of the Killing vector ∂t vanishes iff β does not depend on z. Since existence of twist is a conformally
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
103
invariant property, the cases βz = 0 and βz = 0 are genuinely distinct, not an artefact of our coordinate choices. We now analyse each in turn. Twist-free case. βz = 0. Calculating the commutator of L 0 and L 1 we obtain [L 0 , L 1 ] = (−β + λ)(C z + λDz )∂t + (βx + λβ y − β E z − λβ Fz + λE z + λ2 Fz −(A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 ))∂z .
(5.9)
Since we require {L 0 , L 1 } to be integrable, this must be a multiple of L 0 . We deduce that 3 [L 0 , L 1 ] = (−β + λ)(C z + λDz )L 0 .
(5.10)
Now comparing the ∂z coefficients of (5.9) and (5.10) we get four equations, one for each power of λ. We can solve three of them, and use L 1 → L 1 − C L 0 which does not change the conformal structure. This yields L 1 = ∂x + λ∂ y + (A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 )∂λ +λ(−z A3 + Q)∂t + (z(−β y + A1 + β A2 + β 2 A3 ) + λ(z(A2 + 2β A3 ) + P))∂z , (5.11) where P and Q are arbitrary functions of (x, y) and we have eliminated one arbitrary function by translating the z coordinate. There is one remaining equation to solve, corresponding to the λ0 coefficient of ∂z . This equation is as follows: βx + ββ y − A0 − β A1 − β 2 A2 − β 3 A3 = 0.
(5.12)
The metric (1.2) in Theorem 2 corresponds to the twistor distribution given by L 0 , with βz = 0, and (5.11). If β(x, y) is regarded as defining a section of P T U , then (5.12) says that this section is tangent to lifted geodesics of the projective structure. In terms of the base, a solution is given by a congruence of geodesics. Twisting case. βz = 0. We may perform a coordinate transformation z → β(x, y, z). This does not affect the general form (5.8) of L 1 . Performing the coordinate change and dividing by βz gives the following form for L 0 : L 0 = H (x, y, z)∂t − z∂z + λ∂z ,
(5.13)
where H is a non-zero arbitrary function. Calculating the commutator gives [L 0 , L 1 ] = ((−z + λ)(C z + λDz ) − (E + λF)Hz )∂t +((−z + λ)(E z + λFz ) − (E + λF) − (A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 ))∂z . We require [L 0 , L 1 ] = αL 0 for some function α(x, y, z, λ), which is at most quadratic in λ, since otherwise αL 0 will contain powers of λ greater than three, and such terms do not occur in the commutator above. We make a replacement L 1 → L 1 − F L 0 , and analyze equations obtained from comparing coefficients of ∂z , ∂t . This puts L 1 in the form L 1 = ∂x + λ∂ y + (A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 )∂λ +(C + λD)∂t + (A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )∂z , 3 In [3] the resulting equations are interpreted as a special case of a gauge theory defined on a projective surface. A solution is called a projective Higgs pair. This also applies to the twisting case.
104
M. Dunajski, S. West
where C(x, y, z), D(x, y, z), H (x, y, z) satisfy C z − 2z Dz = −H A2 + Hy , Dz = −H A3 ,
(5.14) (5.15)
(∂x + z∂ y + (A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )∂z )H = 0.
(5.16)
and
The only things remaining now are to find expressions for C and D and construct the metric. In order to integrate Eqs. (5.14) it is convenient to express H (x, y, z) as the second derivative of another function G(x, y, z), i.e. we set H (x, y, z) =
∂2G (x, y, z). ∂z 2
Then Eqs. (5.14) integrate to give C = −G z A2 − 2 A3 (zG z − G) + G zy + ρ(x, y), D = −G z A3 + σ (x, y), where ρ and σ are arbitrary functions. Notice that G has a ‘gauge freedom’ G → G + zγ (x, y) + δ(x, y), since (1.4) will still be satisfied. Using this and a coordinate change t → t +ξ(x, y), one can set the functions ρ and σ to zero. The twistor distribution {L 0 , L 1 } is now fully determined: L 0 = G zz ∂t − z∂z + λ∂z , L 1 = ∂x + λ∂ y + (A0 + λA1 + λ2 A2 + λ3 A3 )∂λ +(−G z A2 − 2 A3 (zG z − G) + G zy ) − λ(G z A3 ))∂t +(A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )∂z . The distribution is integrable iff G satisfies (1.4). Calculating the corresponding null tetrad gives the conformal structure (1.3) in Theorem 2.
6. Examples 6.1. Neutral Fefferman conformal metrics. If G zz is simply a constant, then (1.4) is satisfied. So given any projective structure and setting G zz = 1 we obtain a family of conformal structures with twist which reduce to the given projective structure. Solving for G gives G=
z2 + zγ (x, y) + δ(x, y). 2
The corresponding metric takes the form z2 − δ) − γ y + ρ)d x)(dy − zd x) 2 (6.17) −(dz − (A0 + z A1 + z 2 A2 + z 3 A3 )d x)d x,
(dt + ((z + γ )A3 + σ )dy + ((z + γ )A2 + 2 A3 (
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
105
where we have chosen not to eliminate σ and ρ. By direct calculation one can show that the ASD Weyl tensor has Petrov-Penrose type III or N, and it is type N precisely when the following hold: 1 A2 , 3 2 γ A2 − 2 A3 δ − γ y + ρ = A1 . 3 One can always choose ρ, σ, γ , δ so that these are satisfied. In this case, the metric is the same as (31) in [20], with their Q cubic in p. These are neutral signature analogues of Fefferman metrics. γ A3 + σ =
6.2. ASD pp-waves. Notice that the metric (1.2) does not explicitly contain the function A0 (x, y) of the projective structure. The metric is always ASD for any choice of β, A1 , A2 , A3 ; one can regard (5.12) as giving A0 (x, y) in terms of these functions. On the other hand, if one wants to specify A0 , then one must choose a solution of (5.12) for β. In the special case A0 = 0, we have the solution β = 0. One then obtains the following metric: g = (dt + (P + z A2 )d x + (Q + z A3 dy))dy − (dz + z A1 d x)d x.
(6.18)
Different choices of function β(x, y) in (1.2) can give rise to different metrics. Suppose we choose the flat projective structure. Then β(x, y) must satisfy Eq. (1.6) with Aα = 0. By direct calculation one can show that the metric (1.2) is type III iff β yy = 0, otherwise it is type N. So the conformal structures with β yy = 0 and β yy = 0 are genuinely distinct. 6.3. Pseudo-hyper-Kähler metrics. We will find some examples of neutral ASD metrics with null conformal Killing vectors by independent means, and interpret them using our results. We will use Pleba´nski’s method [23] adapted to neutral signature, which converts the problem of finding Ricci-flat ASD neutral metrics, or pseudo-hyper-Kähler, to the problem of solving a non-linear second order PDE. He showed that such metrics are locally of the form g = dY (dT − X X dY − T X d Z ) − d Z (d X + T T d Z + T X dY ),
(6.19)
where (T, X, Y, Z ) satisfies the ‘second Heavenly Equation’: Y T − Z X + T T X X − 2X T = 0.
(6.20)
The primed connection coefficients vanish when using the tetrad indicated in (6.19), so there is a basis of covariantly constant primed spinors o A = (1, 0), ι A = (0, −1). There is therefore also a basis A B of covariantly constant null self-dual two forms, written in spinors as follows:
1 ι A ι B AB θ A A ∧ θ B B , 2 1 = o(A ι B ) AB θ A A ∧ θ B B , 2 1 = o A o B AB θ A A ∧ θ B B . 2
0 0 =
0 1 = 1 0
1 1
(6.21) (6.22) (6.23)
106
M. Dunajski, S. West
Using the identification between two-forms and endomorphisms given by g, we can write
R = 0 0 − 1 1 , I = 0 0 + 1 1, S = 0 1 . As endomorphisms, these satisfy −I 2 = R 2 = S 2 = Id, I RS = Id,
(6.24)
which is easy to check using their spinor forms. There is a hyperboloid’s worth of almost complex structures, a I + b R + cS, where a 2 − b2 − c2 = 1, which are parallel and hence integrable. This is a pseudo-hyper-Kähler structure. Now writing (A.2) using spinors by means of (2.4) and (A.1) gives 1 ι A o A C ABC D A B C D = ∇ B B (φC D C D + ψC D C D + ηC D C D ), 2 where we have used Ricci flatness and anti-self-duality. For a pure Killing vector or a homothety (η constant), it follows that ∇ A A φ B C = 0.
(6.25)
Therefore φ B C is actually constant in the basis shown in (6.19). Now let us suppose we have a null Killing vector which preserves the α–plane distribution spanned by o A e A A . Then K = ι A o A e A A , for some ι A and using (2.6) and (6.25) we get φ B C = a1 o B oC + a2 o(B ιC ) , for constant a1 , a2 . Consider the three distinct cases: φ B C vanishing (a1 = a2 = 0), non-vanishing but degenerate (a1 = 0, a2 = 0), and non-degenerate (a1 = 0, a2 = 0). For K = ∂T we get the first case, K = Y ∂ X + Z ∂T the second, and T ∂T + X ∂ X the third, and with some effort it can be shown that these choices are canonical (the first two cases were analysed in [8]). In order for any of these to be Killing, an equation for coming from the Killing equation must be satisfied. In fact we were only able to fully solve for the first two cases. • K = ∂T Since ∂T has no twist we expect this to be of the form (1.2). It is a neutral signature version of a tri-holomorphic Killing vector; i.e. it Lie-derives I, R, S. Solving the Killing equations in conjunction with (6.20) results in the following metric: g = dY dT − d Z d X − Q(X, Y )dY 2 ,
(6.26)
where Q is an arbitrary function. This is simply the split-signature pp-wave metric, and is a special case of (6.18). Here K is a self-dual Killing vector in the sense of Gibbons et al. [1]. The local expression (6.26) in this example corresponds to a class of global neutral metrics on compact four–manifolds. To see this we compactify the flat projective space R2 to the two–dimensional torus U = T 2 with the projective structure coming from the flat metric. Both T and Z in (6.26) are taken to be periodic, thus leading
ASD Conformal Structures with Null Killing Vectors from Projective Structures
107
to πˆ : M −→ U , the holomorphic toric fibration over a torus. Assume the suitable periodicity on the function Q : U −→ R. This leads to a commutative diagram M T 2 ↓ πˆ ∗ Q Q
U −→ R. This example can be put into the framework of [15] and [9], where M is regarded as a primary Kodaira surface C2 /G and G is the fundamental group of M represented injectively in the group of complex affine transformations of C2 . In this framework the Kähler structure on M is given by f lat + i∂∂(πˆ ∗ Q), where (∂, f lat ) is the flat Kähler structure on the Kodaira surface induced from C2 . • K = Y ∂ X + Z ∂T Again, this is twist-free and we expect the metric to be of the form (1.2). Solving the Killing equations in conjunction with (6.20) results in the following metric: g = dY dT − d Z d X −
Y Z H ( Y T −Z X , Y T −Z X )
(Y T − Z X )3
(Y d Z − Z dY )2 ,
(6.27)
where H is an arbitrary analytic function of two variables. This is a generalization of the Sparling-Tod metric [24]. It is easy to show that the arguments of H are in fact constant on the special β-surfaces, so serve as coordinates on U . Using the following coordinate transformation: t=−
1 X T , + 2 Y Z 1
z = (Y Z )− 2 , YT − XZ , x= 1 (Y Z ) 2 Z , y = log Y the metric (6.27) takes the following form: g=
1 (dydt − dzd x + z A3 (x, y)dy 2 ), z2
where now the Killing vector is ∂t . Multiplying by the conformal factor z 2 , we get a special case of (6.18). The projective structure is non-trivial, unlike for the pp-wave above. The projective structure is special in that it depends on only one arbitrary function. • T ∂T + X ∂ X In this case we were not able to fully solve the Killing equations in conjunction with (6.20). This Killing vector is twisting, so the answer must be of the form (1.3). 6.4. Pseudo-hyper-hermitian conformal structures. This is a generalization of the pseudo-hyper-Kähler case discussed in the last section. We will refer to a neutral metric g as pseudo-hyper-hermitian (also called hyper-para—hermitian [12]) when there exist endomorphisms I, R, S satisfying the algebra (6.24), such that any complex structure
108
M. Dunajski, S. West
J(a,b,c) = a I + b R + cS is integrable for a 2 − b2 − c2 = 1, and g is hermitian with respect to any of these complex structures. For g to be hermitian with respect to a complex structure J means g(J X, J Y ) = g(X, Y ). Note that for pseudo-hyper-Kähler, the endomorphisms I, R, S must also be covariantly constant with respect to the Levi-Civita connection of g. In [5], it is shown that one can always find a tetrad for a pseudo-hyper-hermitian metric such that the twistor distribution has no ∂λ terms. Equivalently, the twistor space fibres over CP1 . Now let us suppose that we have a null conformal Killing that is tri-holomorphic, i.e. it preserves I , R and S and so it preserves the holomorphic fibration PT → CP1 . All such cases are classified by the following Proposition 2. All pseudo-hyper-hermitian ASD metrics with triholomorphic null conformal Killing vectors are of the form (1.2) or (1.3) up to a conformal factor, where the corresponding ODE (1.5) is point equivalent to a derivative of a first order ODE. Proof. Let g be a pseudo-hyper-hermitian ASD metric, and K be a triholomorphic conformal Killing vector. Since g is ASD, it follows from Theorem 2 that there are coordinates such that, up to a conformal factor, g is of the form (1.2) or (1.3). From [5], it is possible to find a tetrad such that the twistor distribution has no ∂λ terms. Now a change in tetrad corresponds to a Möbius transformation of λ. Since K is triholomorphic, its lift will have no ∂λ terms in the tetrad where the twistor distribution has no ∂λ terms. Therefore the Möbius transform does not depend on t, otherwise ∂t will no longer Lie-derive the twistor distribution (one would have to add ∂λ terms). Furthermore, the Möbius transformation does not depend on z, otherwise ∂λ terms will be introduced into L 0 . Hence there is a Möbius transformation of λ, depending only on (x, y), such that the ∂λ terms in L 1 are eliminated. Aft