Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 1–44 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1387-5
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem in Multiply-Connected Domains I. Krichever1,2,3 , A. Marshakov3,4,5 , A. Zabrodin3,6 1 2 3 4 5 6
Department of Mathematics, Columbia University, New York, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Landau Institute, Moscow, Russia ITEP, Moscow, Russia Max Planck Institute of Mathematics, Bonn, Germany Lebedev Physics Institute, Moscow, Russia Institute of Biochemical Physics, Moscow, Russia
Received: 21 September 2003 / Accepted: 3 February 2004 Published online: 8 July 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: We study the integrable structure of the Dirichlet boundary problem in two dimensions and extend the approach to the case of planar multiply-connected domains. The solution to the Dirichlet boundary problem in the multiply-connected case is given through a quasiclassical tau-function, which generalizes the tau-function of the dispersionless Toda hierarchy. It is shown to obey an infinite hierarchy of Hirota-like equations which directly follow from properties of the Dirichlet Green function and from the Fay identities. The relation to multi-support solutions of matrix models is briefly discussed. 1. Introduction The Dirichlet boundary problem [1] is to reconstruct a harmonic function in a bounded domain from its values on the boundary. Remarkably, this standard problem of complex analysis, related however to string theory and matrix models, possesses a hidden integrable structure [2], which we clarify further in this paper. It turns out that variation of a solution to the Dirichlet problem under variation of the domain is described by an infinite hierarchy of non-linear partial differential equations known (in the simply-connected case) as dispersionless Toda hierarchy. It is a particular example of the universal hierarchy of Whitham equations introduced in [3, 4]. The quasiclassical tau-function or, more precisely, its logarithm F , is the main new object associated with a family of domains in the plane. Any domain in the complex plane with sufficiently smooth boundary can be parameterized by its moments with respect to a basis of harmonic functions. The F -function is a function of the full infinite set of the moments. The first order derivatives of F are then moments of the complementary domain. This gives a formal solution to the inverse potential problem, considered for the simply-connected case in [5, 6]. The second order derivatives are coefficients of the Taylor expansion of the Dirichlet Green function and therefore they solve the Dirichlet boundary problem. These coefficients are constrained by an infinite number of universal (i.e. domain-independent) relations which, unified in a generating form, just constitute
2
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
the dispersionless Hirota equations. For the third order derivatives (their role in problems of complex analysis is not yet quite clear) there is a nice “residue formula” which allows one to prove [7] that F obeys the WDVV equations. Below we are going to demonstrate that for planar multiply-connected domains the solution to the Dirichlet boundary problem can be performed in a similar way. Specifically, we consider domains which are obtained by cutting several “holes” in the complex plane. Boundaries of the holes are assumed to be smooth simple non-intersecting curves. In this case, the complete set of independent variables can be again identified with the set of harmonic moments. However, a choice of the proper basis of harmonic functions in a multiply-connected domain becomes crucial for our approach. It turns out that the Laurent polynomials which were used in the simply-connected case should be replaced by the basis analogous to the one introduced in [8] – a “global” generalization of the Laurent basis for algebraic curves of arbitrary genus. The basis has to be also enlarged to include harmonic functions with multi-valued analytic part. This results in an additional finite set of extra variables. We construct the F -function and prove that its second derivatives satisfy non-linear relations, which generalize the Hirota equations of the dispersionless Toda hierarchy. These relations are derived from the Fay identities [9] for the Riemann theta functions on the Jacobian of Riemann surface obtained as the Schottky double of the plane with given holes. We note that extra variables, specific for the multiply-connected case, can be chosen in different ways and possess different geometric interpretations, depending on the choice of basis of homologically non-trivial cycles on the Schottky double. The corresponding F -functions are shown to be connected by a duality transformation – a (partial) Legendre transform, with the generalized Hirota relations being the same. Now let us give a bit more expanded description of the Dirichlet problem in planar domains. Let Dc be a domain in the complex plane bounded by one or several non-intersecting smooth curves. It will be convenient to realize Dc as a complement to another domain D, having one or more connected components, and to consider the Dirichlet problem in Dc : to find a harmonic function u(z) in Dc such that it is continuous up to the boundary, ∂Dc , and equals a given function u0 (ξ ) on the boundary. The problem has a unique solution written in terms of the Dirichlet Green function G(z, ξ ): 1 u(z) = − u0 (ξ )∂n G(z, ξ )|dξ | , (1.1) 2π ∂Dc where ∂n is the normal derivative on the boundary with respect to the second variable, the normal vector n is directed inward Dc , and |dξ | := dl(ξ ) is an infinitesimal element of the length of the boundary ∂Dc . The main object to study is, therefore, the Dirichlet Green function. It is uniquely determined by the following properties [1]: (G1) The function G(z, z ) is symmetric and harmonic everywhere in Dc (including ∞ if Dc ∞) in both arguments except z = z , where G(z, z ) = log |z − z | + · · · as z → z ; (G2) G(z, z ) = 0 if any one of the variables z, z belongs to the boundary ∂Dc . Note that the definition implies that G(z, z ) < 0 inside Dc . In particular, ∂n G(z, ξ ) is strictly negative for all ξ ∈ ∂Dc . If Dc is simply-connected (note that we assume ∞ ∈ Dc ), i.e., the boundary has only one component, the Dirichlet problem is equivalent to finding a bijective conformal map from Dc onto the complement to unit disk or any other reference domain for which the
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
3
Green function is known explicitly. Such a bijective conformal map w(z) exists by virtue of the Riemann mapping theorem, then w(z) − w(z ) , G(z, z ) = log (1.2) w(z)w(z ) − 1 where bar means complex conjugation. It connects the Green function at two points with the conformal map normalized at some third point (say at z = ∞: w(∞) = ∞). It is this formula which allows one to derive the Hirota equations for the tau-function of the Dirichlet problem in the most economic and transparent way [2] (see also Sect. 2 below). For multiply-connected domains, formulas of this type based on conformal maps do not really exist. In general, there is no canonical choice of the reference domain, moreover, the shape of a reference domain depends on Dc itself. In fact, as we demonstrate in the paper, the correct extension of (1.2) needed for derivation of the generalized Hirota equations follows from a different direction which is no longer explicitly related to bijective conformal maps. Namely, logarithm of the conformal map log w(z) should be replaced now by the Abel map from the Schottky double of Dc to the Jacobi variety of this Riemann surface, and the rational function under the logarithm in (1.2) is substituted by ratio of the prime forms or Riemann theta-functions. We show that the Green function of multiply-connected domains admits a representation through the logarithm of the tau-function of the form 1 1 1 (1.3) G(z, z ) = log − + ∇(z)∇(z )F . z z 2 Here ∇(z) is a certain vector field on the moduli space of boundary curves, therefore it can be represented as a (first-order) differential operator w.r.t. harmonic moments with constant (in moduli) coefficients depending, however, on the point z as a parameter. In this paper we also obtain similar formulas for the harmonic measures of the boundary components and for the Abel map. A combination of these formulas with the Fay identities yields the generalized Hirota-like equations for the tau-function F . Our main tool is the Hadamard variational formula [10] which gives the variation of the Dirichlet Green function under small deformations of the domain in terms of the Green function itself: 1 δG(z, z ) = ∂n G(z, ξ )∂n G(z , ξ )δn(ξ )|dξ |. (1.4) 2π ∂Dc Here δn(ξ ) is the normal displacement (with sign!) of the boundary under the deformation, counted along the normal vector at the boundary point ξ . It was shown in [2] that this remarkable formula is a key to all integrable properties of the Dirichlet problem. An extremely simple “pictorial” derivation of the formula (1.4) is presented in Fig. 1. We start with a brief recollection of the results for the simply-connected case in Sect. 2. However, instead of “bump” deformations used in [2] we work here with their rigorously defined versions – a family of infinitesimal deformations which we call elementary ones. This approach is basically motivated by the theory of interface dynamics in viscous fluids, which is known to be closely connected with the formalism developed in [2] and in the present paper (see [5] for details). In Sect. 3 we introduce local coordinates in the space of planar multiply-connected domains and express the elementary deformations in these coordinates. Using the Hadamard formula, we then observe remarkable symmetry or “zero-curvature” relations
4
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin z δn ξ
Fig. 1. A “pictorial” derivation of the Hadamard formula. We consider a small deformation of the domain, with the new boundary being depicted by the dashed line. According to (G2) the Dirichlet Green function vanishes, G(z, ξ ) = 0, if ξ belongs to the old boundary. Then the variation δG(z, ξ ) is simply equal to the new value, i.e. in the leading order δG(z, ξ ) = −δn(ξ )∂n G(z, ξ ). Now notice that δG(z, ξ ) is a harmonic function (the logarithmic singularity cancels since it is the same for both old and new functions) with the boundary value −δn(ξ )∂n G(z, ξ ). Applying (1.1) one obtains (1.4). The argument is the same for both simply-connected and multiply-connected domains
which connect elementary deformations of the Green function and harmonic measures. The existence of the tau-function and the formula (1.3) for the Green function directly follow from these relations. In Sect. 4 we make a Legendre transform to another set of local coordinates in the space of algebraic multiply-connected domains, which is in a sense dual to the original one. In these coordinates, Eq. (1.3) gives another version of the Green function which solves the so-called modified Dirichlet problem. We also discuss the relation to multi-support solutions of matrix models in the planar large N limit. In Sect. 5 we combine the results outlined above with the representation of the Green function in terms of the prime form on the Schottky double. This allows us to obtain an infinite system of partial differential equations on the tau-function which generalize the dispersionless Hirota equations. 2. The Dirichlet Problem for Simply-Connected Domains and Dispersionless Hirota Equations In this section we rederive the results from [2] for the simply-connected case in a slightly different manner, more suitable for further generalizations. At the same time we show that the results of [2] obtained for analytic curves can be easily extended to the smooth case. Let D be a connected domain in the complex plane bounded by a simple smooth curve. We consider the exterior Dirichlet problem in Dc = C \ D which is the complement of D in the whole (extended) complex plane. Without loss of generality, we assume that D is compact and contains the point z = 0. Then Dc is a simply-connected domain on the Riemann sphere containing ∞. 2.1. Harmonic moments and deformations of the boundary. Let tk be moments of the domain Dc = C \ D defined with respect to the harmonic functions {z−k /k}, k > 0: 1 tk = − z−k d 2 z , k = 1, 2, . . . , (2.1) πk Dc
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
5
1 and {t¯k } be the complex conjugate moments, i.e. t¯k = − πk formula represents the harmonic moments as contour integrals
tk =
1 2πik
Dc
z−k z¯ dz
d 2 z¯z−k . The Stokes
(2.2)
∂D
providing, in particular, a regularization of possibly divergent integrals (2.1). Besides, we denote by t0 the area (divided by π) of the domain D: 1 t0 = π
d 2z .
(2.3)
D
The harmonic moments of Dc are coefficients of the Taylor expansion of the potential (z) = −
2 π
log |z − z |d 2 z
(2.4)
D
induced by the domain D filled by two-dimensional Coulomb charges with the uniform density ρ = −1. Clearly, ∂z ∂z¯ (z) = −1 if z ∈ D and vanishes otherwise, so around the origin (recall that D 0) the potential equals to −|z|2 plus a harmonic function, i.e. (z) − (0) = −|z|2 +
tk zk + t¯k z¯ k ,
(2.5)
k≥1
and one can verify that tk are just given by (2.1). For analytic boundary curves, one may introduce the Schwarz function associated with the curve. The function ∂z (z) = −
1 π
D
d 2 z z − z
is continuous across the boundary and holomorphic for z ∈ Dc while for z ∈ D the function ∂z + z¯ is holomorphic. If the boundary is an analytic curve, both these functions can be analytically continued outside the regions where they were originally defined, and, therefore, there exists a function, S(z), analytic in some strip-like neighborhood of the boundary contour, such that S(z) = z¯ on the contour. In other words, S(z) is the analytic continuation of z¯ away from the boundary contour, this function completely determines the shape of the boundary and is called the Schwarz function [11]. In general we are going to work with smooth curves, not necessarily analytic, when the Schwarz function does not exist as an analytic function. Nevertheless, it appears to be useful below to define the class of boundary contours with nice algebro-geometric properties. The basic fact of the theory of deformations of closed smooth curves is that the (in general complex) moments {tk , t¯k } ≡ {t±k } supplemented by the real variable t0 form a set of local coordinates in the “moduli space” of smooth closed curves [12] (see also [13]).
6
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
Important remark . This means that: (a) under any small deformation of the domain the set t = {t0 , t±k } is subject to a small change; (b) on the space of smooth closed curves there exist vector fields ∂tk such that ∂tk tn = δkn , which are represented in terms of infinitesimal normal displacements of the boundary that change xk = Re tk or yk = Im tk keeping all the other moments fixed; (c) the corresponding infinitesimal displacements can be locally integrated. The latter means that for each domain Dc with moments {t0 , t±k } and for an arbitrary integer N there exist constants m , |m| ≤ N , such that for } with |t − t | < , m ≤ N, t = t , |m| > N , in the neighborhood any set {t0 , t±k m m m m m }. We adopt this restricted c of D there is a unique domain with the moments {t0 , t±k notion of the local coordinates throughout the paper. It would be very interesting to find conditions on the infinite sets k for the corresponding rectangles to form an open set in an infinite-dimensional variety of smooth curves. We plan to address this problem elsewhere. Let us present a proof of this statement which later will be easily adjusted to the case of multiply-connected domains. At the same time this proof allows one to derive a deformation of the domain with respect to the variables tk . Suppose there is a one-parametric deformation D(t) (with some real parameter t) of D = D(0) such that all tk are preserved: ∂t tk = 0, k ≥ 0. Let us prove that such a deformation is trivial. The proof is based on two key observations: • The difference of the boundary values ∂t C ± (ζ )dζ of the derivative of the Cauchy integral C(z)dz =
dz 2πi
∂D
ζ¯ dζ ζ −z
(2.6)
is a purely imaginary differential on the boundary of D. Indeed, let ζ (σ, t) be a parameterization of the curve ∂D(t). Denote the value of the differential (2.6) by C − (z)dz for z ∈ Dc and by C + (z)dz for z ∈ D. Taking the t-derivative of (2.6) and integrating by parts one gets
ζ¯t ζσ + ζ¯ ζt, σ ζ¯ ζσ ζt − ζ −z (ζ − z)2 ∂D ¯ dz ζt ζσ − ζ¯σ ζt = dσ . 2πi ∂D ζ −z
dz ∂t C(z)dz = 2πi
dσ (2.7)
Hence,
∂t C + (ζ ) − ∂t C − (ζ ) dζ = ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ = 2iIm ∂t ζ¯ dζ
is indeed purely imaginary. • If a t-deformation preserves all the moments tk , k ≥ 0, the differential ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ extends to a holomorphic differential in Dc . If |z| < |ζ | for all ζ ∈ ∂D, then we can expand: ∂ ∂t C (z)dz = ∂t +
∞ dz k z ζ −k−1 ζ¯ dζ 2πi ∂D k=0
=
∞ k=1
k (∂t tk ) zk−1 dz = 0
(2.8)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
7
and, since C + is analytic in D, we conclude that ∂t C + ≡ 0. The expression ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ is the boundary value of the differential −∂t C − (z)dz which has at most simple pole at the infinity and holomorphic everywhere else in Dc . The equality 1 (∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ ) = 0 ∂t t 0 = 2πi ∂D then implies that the residue at z = ∞ vanishes, therefore ∂t C − (z)dz is holomorphic. Any holomorphic differential which is purely imaginary along the boundary of a simply-connected domain must be zero in this domain. Indeed, the real part of the harmonic continuation of the integral of this differential is a harmonic function with a constant boundary value. Such a function must be constant by virtue of the uniqueness of the solution to the Dirichlet problem. Another proof relies on the Schwarz symmetry principle and the standard Schottky double construction (see the next section for details). Consider the compact Riemann surface obtained by attaching to Dc its complex conjugated copy along the boundary. Since ∂t C − dz is imaginary along the boundary, we conclude, from the Schwarz symmetry principle, that ∂t C − dz extends to a globally defined holomorphic differential on this compact Riemann surface, which has genus zero. Therefore, such a differential is equal to zero. Hence we conclude that ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ = 0. This means that the vector ∂t ζ is tangent to the boundary. Without loss of generality we can always assume that a parameterization of ∂D(t) is chosen so that ∂t ζ (σ, t) is normal to the boundary. Thus, the t-deformation of the boundary preserving all harmonic moments is trivial. The fact that the set of harmonic moments is not overcomplete follows from the explicit construction of vector fields in the space of domains that changes any harmonic moment keeping all the others fixed (see below). 2.2. Elementary deformations and the operator ∇(z). Fix a point z ∈ Dc and consider a special infinitesimal deformation of the domain such that the normal displacement of the boundary is proportional to the gradient of the Green function G(z, ξ ) at the boundary point (Fig. 2): δn(ξ ) = − ∂n G(z, ξ ) . 2
(2.9)
For any sufficiently smooth initial boundary this deformation is well-defined as → 0. We call infinitesimal deformations from this family, parametrized by z ∈ Dc , the elementary deformations. The point z is referred to as the base point of the deformation. Note that since ∂n G < 0 (see the remark after the definition of the Green function in the Introduction), δn for the elementary deformations is either strictly positive or strictly negative depending of the sign of . Let δz be a variation of any quantity under the elementary deformation with the base point z. It is easy to see that δz t0 = , δz tk = z−k /k. Indeed, 1 δn(ξ )|dξ | = − ∂n G(z, ξ )|dξ | = , δz t0 = π 2π (2.10) 1 −k −k −k δz tk = ξ δn(ξ )|dξ | = − ξ ∂n G(z, ξ )|dξ | = z πk 2πk k
8
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
z
Fig. 2. The elementary deformation with the base point z
by virtue of the Dirichlet formula (1.1). Note that the elementary deformation with the base point at ∞ keeps all moments except t0 fixed. Therefore, the deformation which changes only t0 is given by δn(ξ ) = − 2 ∂n G(∞, ξ ). Now we can explicitly define the deformations that change only either xk = Re tk or yk = Im tk keeping all other moments fixed. As is clear from (2.10), the corresponding δn(ξ ) is given by the real or imaginary part of normal derivative of the function 1 Hk (ξ ) = zk ∂z G(z, ξ )dz (2.11) 2πi ∞ at the boundary. Here the contour integral goes around infinity. Namely, the normal displacements δn(ξ ) = Re (∂n Hk (ξ )) and δn(ξ ) = Im (∂n Hk (ξ )) change the real and imaginary part of tk by ± respectively keeping all other moments fixed. These deformations allow one to introduce the vector fields ∂ , ∂t0
∂ , ∂xk
∂ ∂yk
in the space of domains which are locally well-defined. Existence of such vector fields means that the variables tk are independent. For k > 0 it is more convenient to use their linear combinations ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ 1 ∂ 1 ∂ , = −i = +i ∂tk 2 ∂xk ∂yk ∂ t¯k 2 ∂xk ∂yk which span the complexified tangent space to the space of simply-connected domains (with fixed area t0 ). If X is any functional of our domain locally representable as a function of harmonic moments, X = X(t), the vector fields ∂t0 , ∂tk , ∂t¯k can be understood as partial derivatives acting to the function X(t). Consider the variation δz X of a functional X = X(t) under the elementary deformation with the base point z. In the leading order in we have: δz X =
∂X k
∂tk
δz tk = ∇(z)X
(2.12)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
where the differential operator ∇(z) is given by z−k z¯ −k ∇(z) = ∂t0 + ∂tk + ∂t¯k . k k
9
(2.13)
k≥1
The right-hand side suggests that for functionals X such that the series ∇(z)X converges everywhere in Dc up to the boundary, δz X is a harmonic function of the base point z. Note that in [2] we have used the “bump” deformation and continued it harmonically into Dc . In fact, it was the elementary deformation (2.10) δz ∝ |dξ |∂n G(z, ξ )δ bump (ξ ) that was really used. The “bump” deformation should be understood as a (carefully taken) limit of δz when the point z tends to the boundary ∂Dc . 2.3. The Hadamard formula as integrability condition. Variation of the Green function under small deformations of the domain is known due to Hadamard, see Eq. (1.4). To find how the Green function changes under small variations of the harmonic moments, we fix three points a, b, c ∈ C \ D and compute δc G(a, b) by means of the Hadamard formula (1.4). Using (2.12), one can identify the result with the action of the vector field ∇(c) on the Green function: 1 ∇(c)G(a, b) = − ∂n G(a, ξ )∂n G(b, ξ )∂n G(c, ξ )|dξ | . (2.14) 4π ∂D Remarkably, the r.h.s. of (2.14) is symmetric in all three arguments, i.e. ∇(a)G(b, c) = ∇(b)G(c, a) = ∇(c)G(a, b) .
(2.15)
This is the key relation which allows one to represent the Dirichlet problem as an integrable hierarchy of non-linear differential equations [2], (2.15) being the integrability condition of the hierarchy. It follows from (2.15) (see [2] for details) that there exists a function F = F (t) such that 1 1 1 G(z, z ) = log − + ∇(z)∇(z )F . (2.16) z z 2 We note that existence of such a representation of the Green function was first conjectured by Takhtajan. For the simply-connected case, this formula was obtained in [14] (see also [13] for a detailed proof and discussion). The function F is (logarithm of) the tau-function of the integrable hierarchy. In [14] it was called the tau-function of the (real analytic) curves – the boundary contours ∂D or ∂Dc . 2.4. Dispersionless Hirota equations. Combining (2.16) and (1.2), we obtain the relation w(z) − w(z ) 2 1 1 2 log = log − + ∇(z)∇(z )F (2.17) z z w(z)w(z ) − 1 which implies an infinite hierarchy of differential equations on the function F . It is convenient to normalize the conformal map w(z) by the conditions that w(∞) = ∞ and ∂z w(∞) is real, so that z (2.18) w(z) = + O(1) as z → ∞ , r
10
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
where the real number r = limz→∞ dz/dw(z) is called the (external) conformal radius of the domain D (equivalently, it can be defined through the Green function as log r = limz→∞ (G(z, ∞) + log |z|), see [15]). Then, tending z → ∞ in (2.17), one gets log |w(z)|2 = log |z|2 − ∂t0 ∇(z)F .
(2.19)
The limit z → ∞ of this equality yields a simple formula for the conformal radius: log r 2 = ∂t20 F .
(2.20)
Let us now separate holomorphic and antiholomorphic parts of these equations, introducing the holomorphic and antiholomorphic parts of the operator ∇(z) (2.13): D(z) =
z−k k≥1
k
∂tk ,
¯ z) = D(¯
z¯ −k k≥1
k
∂t¯k .
(2.21)
Rewrite (2.17) in the form w(z) − w(z ) 1 1 1 log − − ∂t + D(z) ∇(z )F − log z z 2 0 w(z)w(z ) − 1
1 w(z) − w(z ) 1 1 ¯ = − log + log − + ∂t + D(¯z) ∇(z )F . z¯ z¯ 2 0 w(z )w(z) − 1 The l.h.s. is a holomorphic function of z while the r.h.s. is antiholomorphic. Therefore, both are equal to a z-independent term which can be found from the limit z → ∞. As a result, we obtain the equation w(z) − w(z ) z log = log 1 − (2.22) + D(z)∇(z )F z w(z) − (w(z ))−1 which, as z → ∞, turns into the formula for the conformal map w(z): 1 log w(z) = log z − ∂t20 F − ∂t0 D(z)F 2
(2.23)
(here we also used (2.20)). Proceeding in a similar way, one can rearrange (2.22) in order to write it separately for holomorphic and antiholomorphic parts in z : log
w(z) − w(z ) 1 = − ∂t20 F + D(z)D(z )F , z − z 2
− log 1 −
1 w(z)w(z )
¯ z )F . = D(z)D(¯
(2.24)
(2.25)
Writing down Eqs. (2.24) for the pairs of points (a, b), (b, c) and (c, a) and summing up the exponentials of both sides of each equation one arrives at the relation (a − b)eD(a)D(b)F + (b − c)eD(b)D(c)F + (c − a)eD(c)D(a)F = 0
(2.26)
which is the dispersionless Hirota equation (for the KP part of the two-dimensional Toda lattice hierarchy) written in the symmetric form. This equation can be regarded as
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
11
a very degenerate case of the trisecant Fay identity [9]. It encodes the algebraic relations between the second order derivatives of the function F . As c → ∞, we get these relations in a more explicit but less symmetric form: 1 − eD(a)D(b)F =
D(a) − D(b) ∂t1 F a−b
(2.27)
which makes it clear that the totality of second derivatives Fij := ∂ti ∂tj F are expressed through the derivatives with one of the indices put equal to unity. More general equations of the dispersionless Toda hierarchy obtained in a similar way by combining Eqs. (2.23), (2.24) and (2.25) include derivatives w.r.t. t0 and t¯k : (a − b)eD(a)D(b)F = ae−∂t0 D(a)F − be−∂t0 D(b)F , ¯
1 − e−D(z)D(¯z)F =
1 ∂t ∇(z)F . e 0 z¯z
(2.28) (2.29)
These equations allow one to express the second derivatives ∂tm ∂tn F , ∂tm ∂t¯n F with m, n ≥ 1 through the derivatives ∂t0 ∂tk F , ∂t0 ∂t¯k F . In particular, the dispersionless Toda equation, 2
∂t1 ∂t¯1 F = e∂t0 F
(2.30)
which follows from (2.29) as z → ∞, expresses ∂t1 ∂t¯1 F through ∂t20 F . For a comprehensive exposition of Hirota equations for dispersionless KP and Toda hierarchies we refer the reader to [16, 17]. 2.5. Integral representation of the tau-function. Equation (2.16) allows one to obtain a ˜ representation of the tau-function as a double integral over the domain D. Set (z) := ∇(z)F . One is able to determine this function via its variation under the elementary deformation: ˜ δa (z) (2.31) = −2 log a −1 − z−1 + 2G(a, z) ˜ with the which is read from Eq. (2.16) by virtue of (2.12). This allows one to identify ˜ “modified potential” (z) = (z) − (0) + t0 log |z|2 , where is given by (2.4). Thus we can write vk 2 ˜ ∇(z)F = (z) = − z−k . (2.32) log |z−1 − ζ −1 |d 2 ζ = v0 + 2Re π D k k>0
The last equality is to be understood as the Taylor expansion around infinity. The coefficients vk are moments of the interior domain (the “dual” harmonic moments) defined as 1 2 vk = zk d 2 z (k > 0) , v0 = −(0) = log |z|d 2 z . (2.33) π D π D From (2.32) it is clear that vk = ∂tk F ,
k ≥ 0,
(2.34)
12
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
i.e., the moments of the complementary domain D (the “dual” moments) are completely determined by the function F of harmonic moments of Dc . In a similar manner, one arrives at the integral representation of the tau-function. Comparing (2.32) with (2.31) one can easily notice that the meaning of the elementary deformation δξ or the operator ∇(ξ ) formally applied at the boundary point ξ ∈ ∂D (where G(z, ξ ) = 0) is attaching a “small piece” to the integral over the domain D (the “bump” operator from [2]). Using this fact and interpreting (2.32) as a variation δz F we arrive at the double-integral representation of the tau-function 1 F =− 2 log |z−1 − ζ −1 |d 2 zd 2 ζ (2.35) π D D or F =
1 2π
D
2 ˜ (z)d z=
1 2π
((z) − 2(0)) d 2 z .
(2.36)
D
As we see below, the main formulas from this paragraph remain intact in the multiplyconnected case. 3. The Dirichlet Problem and the Tau-Function in the Multiply-Connected Case Let now Dα , α = 0, 1, . . . , g, be a collection of g + 1 non-intersecting bounded cong nected domains in the complex plane with smooth boundaries ∂Dα . Set D = ∪α=0 Dα , c so that the complement D = C \ D becomes a multiply-connected unbounded domain in the complex plane (see Fig. 3). Let bα be the boundary curves. They are assumed to g be positively oriented as boundaries of Dc , so that ∪α=0 bα = ∂Dc while bα = −∂Dα has the clockwise orientation. Comparing to the simply-connected case, nothing is changed in posing the standard Dirichlet problem. The definition of the Green function and the formula (1.1) for the solution of the Dirichlet problem through the Green function remain to be the same. A difference is in the nature of harmonic functions. Any harmonic function is still the real part of an analytic function but in the multiply-connected case these analytic functions are not necessarily single-valued (only their real parts have to be single-valued). In other words, the harmonic functions may have non-zero “periods” over non-trivial cycles1 . In our case, the non-trivial cycles are the boundary curves bα . In general, the Green function has non-zero “periods” over all boundary contours. Hence it is natural to introduce new objects, specific to the multiply-connected case, which are defined as “periods” of the Green function. First, the harmonic measure ωα (z) of the boundary component bα is the harmonic function in Dc such that it is equal to unity on bα and vanishes on the other boundary curves. Thus the harmonic measure is the solution to the particular Dirichlet problem. From the general formula (1.1) we conclude that 1 ωα (z) = − ∂n G(z, ζ )|dζ |, α = 1, . . . , g (3.1) 2π bα so the harmonic measure is the period of the Green function w.r.t. one of its arguments. From the maximum principle for harmonic functions it follows that 0 < ωα (z) < 1 1
Here and below by “periods” of a harmonic function f we mean the integrals trivial cycles.
∂n f dl over non-
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
13
D2 b2
z2
D0 z1 b1
z =0 0
b0
D1
z
3
C\D b3
D3
Fig. 3. A multiply-connected domain Dc = C \ D for g = 3. The domain D = 3α=0 Dα consists of g + 1 = 4 disconnected parts Dα with the boundaries bα . To define the complete set of harmonic moments, we also need the auxiliary points zα ∈ Dα which should be always located inside the corresponding domains
g in internal points. Obviously, α=0 ωα (z) = 1. In what follows we consider the linear independent functions ωα (z) with α = 1, . . . , g. Further, taking “periods” in the remaining variable, we define 1 αβ = − ∂n ωα (ζ )|dζ |, α, β = 1, . . . , g . (3.2) 2π bβ The matrix αβ is known to be symmetric, non-degenerate and positively-definite. It will be clear below that the matrix Tαβ = iπ αβ can be identified with the matrix of periods of holomorphic differentials on the Schottky double of the domain Dc (see formula (3.5)). For brevity, we refer to both Tαβ and αβ as period matrices. For the harmonic measure and the period matrix there are variational formulas similar to the Hadamard formula (1.4). They can be derived either by a direct variation of (3.1) and (3.2) using the Hadamard formula or (much easier) by a “pictorial” argument like in Fig. 1. The formulas are: 1 δωα (z) = ∂n G(z, ξ ) ∂n ωα (ξ ) δn(ξ ) |dξ | , (3.3) 2π ∂D δ αβ
1 = 2π
∂n ωα (ξ ) ∂n ωβ (ξ ) δn(ξ ) |dξ | .
(3.4)
∂D
3.1. The Schottky double. It is customary to associate with a planar multiply-connected domain its Schottky double (see, e.g., [18], Ch. 2.2), a compact Riemann surface without
14
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
D0
ξ0 aα ξ
b
α
α
c
D =C\D
Dα
Fig. 4. The domain Dc with the aα -cycle, going one way along the “upper sheet” and back along the “lower sheet” of the Schottky double of Dc . For such a choice one clearly gets the intersection form aα ◦ bβ = δαβ for α, β = 1, . . . , g.
boundary endowed with antiholomorpic involution, the boundary of the initial domain being the set of the fixed points of the involution. The Schottky double of the multiply-connected domain Dc can be thought of as two copies of Dc (“upper” and “lower” g sheets of the double) glued along the boundaries ∪α=0 bα = ∂Dc , with points at infin¯ In this set-up the holomorphic coordinate on the upper sheet is ity added (∞ and ∞). z inherited from Dc , while the holomorphic coordinate2 on the other sheet is z¯ . The Schottky double of Dc with two infinities added is a compact Riemann surface of genus g = #{Dα } − 1. A meromorphic function on the double is a pair of meromorphic functions f, f˜ on Dc such that f (z) = f˜(¯z) on the boundary. Similarly, a meromorphic differential on the double is a pair of meromorphic differentials f (z)dz and f˜(¯z)d z¯ such that f (z)dz = f˜(¯z)d z¯ along the boundary curves. On the double, one may choose a canonical basis of cycles. We fix the b-cycles to be just the boundaries of the holes bα for α = 1, . . . , g. Note that regarded as the oriented boundaries of Dc (not D) they have the clockwise orientation. The aα -cycle connects the α th hole with the 0th one. To be more precise, fix points ξα on the boundaries, then the aα cycle starts from ξ0 , goes to ξα on the “upper” (holomorphic) sheet of the double and goes back the same way on the “lower” sheet, where the holomorphic coordinate is z¯ , see Fig. 4. Being harmonic, ωα can be represented as the real part of a holomorphic function: ωα (z) = Wα (z) + Wα (z) , where Wα (z) are holomorphic multivalued functions in Dc . The differentials dWα are holomorphic in Dc and purely imaginary on all boundary contours. So they can be 2 More precisely, the proper coordinates should be 1/z (and 1/¯z), which have first order zeros instead ¯ of poles at z = ∞ (and z¯ = ∞).
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
15
extended holomorphically to the lower sheet as −dWα (z). In fact this is the canonically normalized basis of holomorphic differentials on the double: according to the definitions,
aα
ξα
dWβ =
dWβ (z) +
ξ0
−dWβ (z) = 2Re
ξ0 ξα
ξα
dWβ (z)
ξ0
= ωβ (ξα )−ωβ (ξ0 ) = δαβ . Then the matrix of b-periods of these differentials reads
Tαβ
i = dWβ = − 2 bα
∂n ωβ dl = iπ αβ ,
(3.5)
bα
i.e. the period matrix Tαβ of the Schottky double is a purely imaginary non-degenerate matrix with positively definite imaginary part π αβ (3.2).
3.2. Harmonic moments of multiply-connected domains. One may still use harmonic moments to characterize the shape of a multiply-connected domain. However, the set of harmonic functions should be extended by adding functions with poles in any hole (not only in D0 as before) and functions whose holomorphic parts are not single-valued. To specify them, let us mark points zα ∈ Dα , one in each hole (see Fig. 3). Without loss of generality, it is convenient to put z0 = 0. Then one may consider single-valued 2 analytic functions in Dc of the form (z − zα )−k and harmonic functions log 1 − zzα with multi-valued analytic part. The arguments almost identical to the ones used in the simply-connected case show that the parameters t0 , Mn,α , φα , where as in (2.3) t0 = Area(D)/π , Mn, α = −
1 π
Dc
(z − zα )−n d 2 z,
α = 0, 1, . . . , g, n ≥ 1
(3.6)
together with their complex conjugate, and 1 φα = − π
zα 2 2 log 1 − d z, z Dc
α = 1, . . . , g
(3.7)
uniquely define Dc , i.e. any deformation preserving these parameters is trivial. Note that the extra moments φα are essentially the values of the potential (2.4) at the points zα , φα = (0) − (zα ) − |zα |2 .
(3.8)
A crucial step for what follows is the change of variables from Mn,α to the variables τk which are finite linear combinations of the Mn,α ’s. They can be directly defined as moments with respect to new basis of functions: τ0 = t0 , τk =
1 2πi
Ak (z)¯zdz = − ∂D
1 π
Dc
d 2 zAk (z), k > 0 .
(3.9)
16
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
The functions Ak (z) are analogous to the Laurent-Fourier type basis on Riemann surfaces introduced in [8]. They are explicitly defined by the following formulas (here the indices α and β are understood modulo g + 1): Am(g+1)+α = R −m (z)
α−1
(z − zβ )−1 ,
β=0
R(z) =
g
(z − zβ ) .
(3.10)
β=0
In a neighbourhood of infinity Ak (z) = z−k + O(z−k−1 ). Any analytic function in Dc vanishing at infinity can be represented as a linear combination of Ak which is convergent in domains such that |R(z)| > const. In the case of one hole (g = 0) the formulas (3.10) give the basis used in the previous section: Ak = z−k . Note that A0 = 1, A1 = 1/z, therefore τ0 = t0 and τ1 = M1,0 = t1 . 3.3. Local coordinates in the space of multiply-connected domains. Now we are going to prove that the parameters τk , φα can be treated as local coordinates in the space of multiply-connected domains. (Here we use the same restricted notion of the local coordinates, as in the simply connected case (see the remark in Sect.2)). It is instructive and simpler first to prove this for another choice of parameters. Instead of φα one may use the areas of the holes 1 Area(Dα ) 1 = d 2z = z¯ dz , α = 1, . . . , g . (3.11) sα = π π Dα 2πi ∂Dα In order to prove that any deformation that preserves τk and sα is trivial, we introduce the basis of differentials dBk which satisfy the defining “orthonormality” relations 1 Ak dBk = δk,k (3.12) 2πi ∂D for all integer k, k . It is easy to see that explicitly they are given by: dBm(g+1)+α =
α−1 dzR m (z) (z − zβ−1 ) , z − zg
(3.13)
β=0
where we identify z−1 ≡ zg . The existence of a well-defined “dual” basis of differentials obeying the orthonormality relation is the key feature of the basis functions Ak , which makes τk good local coordinates comparing to the Mn,α . For the functions (z − zα )−n one cannot define the dual basis. The summation formulas ∞
dzdζ = dζ An (ζ )dBn (z), |R(z)| < |R(ζ )| , ζ −z n=1 ∞
dzdζ dζ A−n (ζ )dB−n (z), |R(z)| > |R(ζ )| , =− ζ −z n=0
(3.14)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
17
which can be checked directly, allow us to repeat arguments of Sect. 2. Indeed, the Cauchy integral (2.6), dz C(z)dz = 2πi
ζ¯ dζ , ζ −z
∂D
(3.15)
where the integration now goes along all boundary components, defines in each of the holes Dα analytic differentials C α (z)dz (analogs of C + (z)dz in the simply-connected case). In the complementary domain Dc the Cauchy integral still defines the differential C − (z)dz holomorphic everywhere in Dc except for infinity where it has a simple pole. The difference of the boundary values of the Cauchy integral is equal to z¯ : C α (z) − C − (z) = z¯ ,
z ∈ ∂Dα .
From Eq. (2.7), which can be written separately for each contour, it follows that • The difference of the boundary values
∂t C α (ζ ) − ∂t C − (ζ ) dζ of the derivative of the Cauchy integral (3.15) is, for all α, a purely imaginary differential on the boundary bα . The expansion (3.14) of the Cauchy kernel implies that • If a t-deformation preserves all the moments τk , k ≥ 0, then ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ extends to a holomorphic differential in Dc . Indeed, since |R(z)| is small for z close enough to any of the points zα , one can expand ∂t C α (z) for any α as ∂t C α (z)dz =
∞ ∞ 1 dBk ∂t Ak (ζ )ζ¯ dζ = ∂t τk dBk (z) , 2πi ∂D k=1
(3.16)
k=1
and conclude that it is identically zero provided ∂t τk = 0. Hence −∂t C − (z)dz is the desired extension of ∂t ζ¯ dζ −∂t ζ d ζ¯ . It has no pole at infinity due to the equation ∂t τ0 = 0. Using the Schwarz symmetry principle we obtain that ∂t C − (z)dz extends to a holomorphic differential on the Schottky double. If the variables sα are also preserved under the t-deformation, then this holomorphic differential has zero periods along all the cycles bα . Therefore, it is identically zero. This completes the proof of the statement that any deformation of the domain preserving τk and sα is trivial. In this proof the variables sα were used only at the last moment in order to show that the extension of ∂t C − (z)dz as a holomorphic differential on the Schottky double is trivial. The variables φα can be used in a similar way. Namely, let us show that if they are preserved under t-deformation then aα -periods of the extension of ∂t C − (z)dz are trivial, and therefore this extension is identically zero. Indeed, the variable φα (3.7) can be represented in the form 2 φα = − Re π
zα
dz 0
Dc
d 2ζ . z−ζ
(3.17)
18
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
d2ζ α The differential dz z + C − (z))dz for π Dc z−ζ is equal to C (z)dz for z ∈ Dα and (¯ c z ∈ D . Let ξ0 , ξα be the points where the integration path from 0 to zα intersects the boundary contours b0 , bα . Then ξ0 zα ξα C 0 (z)dz + C α (z)dz + (¯z + C − (z))dz . (3.18) φα = −2 Re 0
ξα
ξ0
It is shown above that if a t-deformation preserves the variables τk then all ∂t C α (z)dz = 0. Thus vanishing of the t-derivative ∂t φα = 0 implies ξα ∂t C − (z)dz . (3.19) 0 = −∂t φα = 2 Re ξ0
The r.h.s. of this equation is just the aα -period of the holomorphic extension of the differential ∂t C − (z)dz. φ φ Let us construct the deformations ∂xk and ∂yk of the boundary that change the real or imaginary parts of the variable τk = xk + iyk , k ≥ 1, keeping all the other moments φ φ φ and the variables φα fixed. It is convenient to set ∂τk = 21 (∂xk − i∂yk ). The argument is similar to the proof of the fact that any deformation that preserves all the variables is trivial. φ φ φ φ • Suppose that the deformations ∂xk and ∂yk exist. Then the differential ∂τk ζ¯ dζ −∂τk ζ d ζ¯ c extends from ∂D to the Schottky double . Its extension is a meromorphic differential φ d k with the only pole at the infinity point ∞ on the upper sheet. In a neighborhood of ∞ it has the form
d k (z) = dBk (z) + O(z−2 )dz . φ
(3.20)
φ
The a-periods of d k are equal to φ d k = aα
zα
(3.21)
dBk .
0 φ
First of all, it is clear that the meromorphic differential d k on is uniquely defined by its asymptotics at ∞ and by the normalization (3.21) of its a-periods. To deduce these properties, we notice, using (3.16), that ∂xk C α (z)dz = dBk (z). Therefore, the φ φ differential ∂xk ζ¯ dζ − ∂xk ζ d ζ¯ extends to Dc as d φxk = −∂xk C − (z)dz + dBk .
(3.22)
Using the Schwarz symmetry principle we conclude that it extends to the Schottky douφ ble as a meromorphic differential. Around the two infinities it has the form d xk =
z→∞
dBk + O(z−2 )dz and d xk φ
−d B¯ k + O(¯z−2 )d z¯ . In the same way one gets that
=
¯ z¯ →∞
φ φ the differential ∂yn ζ¯ dζ − ∂yn ζ d ζ¯ extends to the double as a meromorphic differenφ φ tial d yk , which at the two infinities has the form d yk = idBk + O(z−2 )dz and φ d yk
=
¯ z¯ →∞
id B¯ k + O(¯z−2 )d z¯ respectively. Since φ
2d k = d φxk − id φyk ,
z→∞
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
19
φ
the first statement is proven. From ∂xk φα = 0 and (3.17), (3.22) it follows that ξ0 zα ξα
φ 0 = Re −d xk + dBk + dBk + dBk . 0
Hence
ξ0
aα
In the same way one gets
ξα
d φxk = 2Re
aα
zα
dBk . 0
d φyk
= −2Im
zα
dBk . 0
The last two equations are equivalent to (3.21). Normal displacement of the boundary that accomplishes the deformations can be explicitly found using the following elementary proposition: • Let D(t) be a deformation with real parameter t such that the differential d = ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ extends to a meromorphic differential d globally defined on the Schottky double . Then the corresponding z normal displacement of the boundary is proportional to normal derivative of Re d at the boundary point ξ : ξ 1 δn(ξ ) = δt ∂n Re d . (3.23) 2 Conversely, if δn(ξ ) = 21 δt ∂n H (ξ ), where H is a real-valued function such that dH = 0 along the boundary contours and ∂z H is meromorphic in Dc then the differential ∂t ζ¯ dζ − ∂t ζ d ζ¯ is meromorphically extendable to the Schottky double as 2∂z H dz on the upper sheet and −2∂z¯ H d z¯ on the lower sheet. In our case normal displacements of the boundary that change xk or yk keeping all the other moments and the variables φα fixed are thus given by ξ ξ 1 1 δn(ξ ) = δxk ∂n Re (3.24) d φxk , δn(ξ ) = δyk ∂n Re d φyk 2 2 respectively. Note that since the differentials d xk (z), d yk (z) (but not d k (z)!) are purely imaginary on the boundaries, d Re xk (z) = d Re yk (z) = 0 along each component of the boundary. With formulas (3.24) at hand, one can directly verify that these deformations indeed change xk or yk only and keep fixed all other moments. We leave this to the reader. φ In terms of the differential d k formulas (3.24) acquire the form ξ ξ φ φ δn(ξ ) = δxk ∂n Re (3.25) d k , δn(ξ ) = −δyk ∂n Im d k (cf. (2.11) for the simply-connected case). Indeed, taking the real part of 2 k (ξ ) = xk (ξ ) − i yk (ξ ), we get 2 Re k (ξ ) = Re xk (ξ ) + Im yk (ξ ). But the normal derivative of Im yk (ξ ) vanishes since, by virtue of the Cauchy-Riemann identities, it is equal
20
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
to the tangential derivative of the conjugate harmonic function Re yk (ξ ). This proves the first formula in (3.25). The second one is proven in a similar way by taking imaginary part of 2 k (ξ ). φ φ The construction of the vector fields ∂τ0 (which changes τ0 only) and ∂α (which changes φα only) is quite similar and even simpler since the derivative (3.16) vanishes. So, we present the results without going into details. φ
• The deformation ∂τ0 corresponds to the normal displacement 1 δn(ξ ) = − δτ0 ∂n G(∞, ξ ) . 2 φ φ The differential −(∂τ0 ζ¯ dζ − ∂τ0 ζ d ζ¯ ) extends from ∂Dc to the Schottky double . Its extension is a meromorphic third-kind Abelian differential d 0 which has simple poles at the infinities on the two sheets of the Schottky double (with residues ±1) and vanishing a-periods. φ • The deformation ∂α corresponds to the normal displacement
δn(ξ ) =
1 δφα ∂n ωα (ξ ) , 4
where ωα is the harmonic measure of the boundary component bα (see (3.1)). The φ φ differential ∂α ζ¯ dζ − ∂α ζ d ζ¯ holomorphically extends from ∂Dc to the Schottky double . Its extension is the canonically normalized holomorphic differential dWα = ∂z ωα (z)dz on the upper sheet (and dWα = −∂z¯ ωα (z)d z¯ on the lower sheet). φ
φ
φ
φ
So we see that ∂xk , ∂yk , ∂τ0 and ∂α are well-defined vector fields on the space of multiply-connected domains. This fact allows us to treat φα , τk as local coordinates on this space. At this stage it becomes clear why we prefer to use the moments τk rather than Mk,α . Although the latter are finite linear combinations of the former, they can not be treated as local coordinates because the vector fields ∂/∂Mk,α , being in general infinite φ linear combinations of the ∂τk , are not well-defined. 3.4. -variables. Up to now the roles of the variables sα and φα have been in some sense dual to each other. It is necessary to emphasize that this duality does not go beyond the framework of our proof of the statement that the first or the second sets together with the variables τk are local coordinates in the space of multiply-connected domains. For analytic boundary curves one can define the Schwarz function, which is a unique function analytic in some strip-like neighborhoods of all boundaries such that S(z) = z¯
on the boundary curves .
(3.26)
Then the variables sα are b-periods of the differential S(z)dz. At the same time, the variables φα in general can not be identified with periods of this differential (or its extension) over any cycles on the Schottky double. Now we are going to introduce new variables, α , which can be called virtual a-periods of the differential S(z)dz on the Schottky double, since in all the cases when the Schwarz function has a meromorphic extension to the double they indeed coincide with the a-periods of the corresponding differential (see below in this section).
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
Let us consider the differential φ
d k = d k −
21
Bk (zα )dWα
(k ≥ 1) ,
(3.27)
α
where
z
Bk (z) =
dBk
(3.28)
0
is a polynomial of degree k. It is a meromorphic differential on with the only pole at ∞ on the upper sheet, where it has the form d k (z) = dBk (z) + O(z−2 )dz. From (3.21) it is clear that the differential d k has vanishing a-periods d k = 0 ,
(3.29)
(3.30)
aα
i.e. it is a canonically normalized meromorphic differential. The normal displacements of the boundary given by real and imaginary parts of the normal derivative ∂n k define a complex tangent vector field Bk (zα )∂αφ (3.31) ∂τk = ∂τφk − α
to the space of multiply-connected domains. These vector fields keep fixed the formal variable Bk (zα )τk . (3.32) α = φα + 2Re k
In a general situation this variable is only a formal one because the sum generally does not converge. Thus, we call α the virtual a-period of the Schwarz differential S(z)dz, since in the case when the Schwarz function has a meromorphic extension to the double , the sum does converge and the corresponding quantity does coincide with the aα -period of the extension of the Schwarz differential. 3.5. Elementary deformations and the operator ∇(z). Like in Sect. 2, we introduce the elementary deformations δa δ (α)
with δn(ξ ) = − ∂n G(a, ξ ) , a ∈ Dc , 2 with δn(ξ ) = − ∂n ωα (ξ ) α = 1, . . . , g , 2
(3.33)
where ωα (z) is the harmonic measure of the boundary component bα (see (3.1)). The deformations δ (α) were considered in [19] in connection with the so-called quadrature domains [19, 20]. In complete analogy with Sect. 2 one can derive the following formulas for variations of the local coordinates under elementary deformations: zα 2 δa τk = Ak (a), δa φα = log 1− , δ (α) τk = 0, δ (α) φβ = −2δαβ . (3.34) a
22
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
The first two formulas are particular cases of 2 h(ζ )d ζ = h(ζ )∂n G(a, ζ )|dζ | = −π h(a) δa 2 ∂Dc Dc which is valid for any harmonic function h in Dc (the last equality is just the formula for solution of the Dirichlet problem). Similarly, (α) 2 δ h(ζ )d ζ = h∂n ωα |dζ | = ∂n h |dζ | = −i ∂ζ h dζ 2 ∂Dc 2 bα Dc ∂Dα (the Green formula was used), and the last two formulas in (3.34) correspond to the particular choices of h(z). Variations of the variables α (in the case when they are well-defined) then read: δz α = 0,
δ (α) β = −2δαβ .
(3.35)
Therefore, for any functional X on the space of the multiply-connected domains the following equations hold: δz X = ∇(z)X ,
(3.36)
δ (α) X = −2∂αφ X = −2∂α X .
(3.37)
The differential operator ∇(z) in the multiply-connected case is defined by the formula Ak (z)∂τk + Ak (z)∂τ (3.38) ∇(z) = ∂τ0 + ¯k . k≥1
The functional X can be regarded as a function X = Xφ (φα , τk ) on the space of the local coordinates φα , τk , or as a function X = X (α , τk ) on the space of the local coordinates α , τk . We would like to stress once again, that although in the latter case the variables α are formal their variations under elementary deformations and the vector-fields ∂τk , which keep them fixed, are well-defined. For completeness, let us characterize elementary deformations δa in terms of meromorphic differentials on the Schottky double (as we have already seen, deformations δ (α) correspond to holomorphic differentials). • Let ∂t (a) be the vector field in the space of multiply-connected domains corresponding to the elementary deformation δa . Then the differential −(∂t (a) ζ¯ dζ −∂t (a) ζ d ζ¯ ) extends from ∂Dc to the Schottky double . Its extension is a meromorphic third-kind Abelian ¯ which has simple poles at the points a and a differential d (a,a) ¯ on the two sheets of the Schottky double (with residues ±1) and vanishing a-periods. In terms of the Green function we have: 2∂z G(a, z)dz on the upper sheet (a,a) ¯ d = −2∂z¯ G(a, z)dz on the lower sheet (cf. (3.23) and (3.33)). Note that the differential d 0 introduced before coincides with ¯ . d (∞,∞)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
23
Let K(z, ζ )dζ be a unique meromorphic Abelian differential of the third kind on with simple poles at z and ∞ on the upper sheet with residues ±1 normalized to zero a-periods. (Note that as a function of the variable z it is multi-valued on .) Then 2∂ζ G(z, ζ )dζ − 2∂ζ G(∞, ζ )dζ = K(z, ζ )dζ + K(¯z, ζ )dζ and the differential d k (ζ ) can be represented in the form dζ d k (ζ ) = K(u, ζ )dBk (u) , 2πi ∞
(3.39)
(3.40)
where the u-integration goes along a big circle around infinity. Using (3.14) we obtain that K(u, ζ )du dζ Ak (z)d k (ζ ) = − = K(z, ζ )dζ . (3.41) 2πi ∞ u − z k≥1
Therefore, the following expansion of the derivative of the Green function holds: ¯ k (ζ ) . 2∂ζ G(z, ζ )dζ = d 0 (ζ ) − (3.42) Ak (z)d k (ζ ) + Ak (z)d k≥1
¯ k is a unique meromorphic differential on with the only pole at infinity on Here d the lower sheet with the principal part −dBk (z) and vanishing a-periods. This formula generalizes Eq. (3.8) from [2] to the multiply-connected case.
3.6. The F -function. Applying the variational formulas (1.4), (3.3), (3.4), we can find variations of the Green function, harmonic measure and period matrix under the elementary deformations. In this way we obtain a number of important relations which connect elementary deformations of these objects: δa G(b, c) = δb G(c, a) = δc G(a, b) , δa ωα (b) = δ (α) G(a, b) = δb ωα (a) , δ (α) ωβ (z) = δ (β) ωα (z) , δz αβ = δ (α) ωβ (z) , δ (α) βγ = δ (β) γ α = δ (γ ) αβ .
(3.43)
From (3.36), (3.37) it follows that the formulas (3.43) can be rewritten in terms of the differential operators ∇(z) and ∂α := ∂/∂φα = ∂/∂α : ∇(a)G(b, c) = ∇(b)G(c, a) = ∇(c)G(a, b) , ∇(a)ωα (b) = −2∂α G(a, b) , ∂α ωβ (z) = ∂β ωα (z) , ∇(z) αβ = −2∂α ωβ (z) , ∂α βγ = ∂β γ α = ∂γ αβ .
(3.44)
These integrability relations generalize formulas (2.15) to the multiply-connected case. The first line just coincides with (2.15) while the other ones extend the symmetry of the derivatives to the harmonic measure and the period matrix.
24
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
Again, (3.44) can be regarded as a set of compatibility conditions of an infinite hierarchy of differential equations. They imply that there exists a function F = F (α , τ ) such that 1 G(a, b) = log a −1 − b−1 + ∇(a)∇(b)F , (3.45) 2 ωα (z) = − ∂α ∇(z)F ,
(3.46)
Tαβ = iπ αβ = 2πi ∂α ∂β F .
(3.47)
The function F is the (logarithm of the) tau-function of multiply-connected domains.
3.7. Dual moments and integral representation of the tau-function. To obtain the integral representation of the function F , we proceed exactly in the same manner as in Sect. 2 (see also [2] for more details). ˜ ˜ Again, set (z) = ∇(z)F . Equations (3.45) and (3.46) determine the function (z) for z ∈ Dc via its variations under the elementary deformations: ˜ δa (z) = −2 log a −1 − z−1 + 2G(a, z) , (3.48) ˜ δ (α) (z) = 2ωα (z) . It is easy to verify that the function 2 ˜ (z) =− log |z−1 − ζ −1 |d 2 ζ = (z) − (0) + τ0 log |z|2 π D
(3.49)
satisfies (3.48). Indeed, using (3.33), variation of (3.49) reads 2 −1 −1 2 δa − log |z − ζ |d ζ = |dξ |∂n G(a, ξ ) log |z−1 − ξ −1 | π D π ∂Dc = |dξ |∂n G(a, ξ ) log |z−1 − ξ −1 | − G(z, ξ ) π ∂Dc = −2 log a −1 − z−1 + 2G(a, z) , where we have used properties of the Dirichlet Green function and the fact that the Dirichlet formula restores harmonic function from its value at the boundary. Similarly, for z ∈ Dc we obtain: 2 (α) −1 −1 2 δ − log |z − ζ |d ζ = |dξ |∂n ωα (ξ ) log |z−1 − ξ −1 | π D π ∂Dc = |dξ |∂n ωα (ξ ) log |z−1 − ξ −1 | − G(z, ξ ) π ∂Dc = |dξ |∂n log |z−1 − ξ −1 | − G(z, ξ ) π bα = 2ωα (z) .
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
The same calculation for z ∈ D yields 0 (α) ˜ δ (z) = 2δαβ
25
if z ∈ D0 . if z ∈ Dβ , β = 1, . . . , g
(3.50)
˜ given by (2.32), where D is We see that the expression in (3.49) coincides with ˜ at infinity now understood as the union of all Dα ’s. The coefficients of an expansion of define the dual moments νk : 2 ˜ ∇(z)F = (z) =− log |z−1 − ζ −1 |d 2 ζ = v0 + 2Re νk Ak (z) . (3.51) π D k>0
The coefficients in the r.h.s. of (3.51) are moments of the union of the interior domains with respect to the dual basis 1 νk = Bk (z)d 2 z . (3.52) π D From Eq. (3.51) it follows that νk = ∂τk F .
(3.53)
The same arguments show that the derivatives sα := − ∂α F
(3.54)
are just areas of the holes (3.11). Indeed, Eqs. (3.46), (3.47) determine these quantities via their variations: δa sα = ωα (a), δ (β) sα = αβ . A direct check, using (3.33), shows that 1 1 2 2 Area(Dα ) ∇(z)F = − log − d ζ , ∂α F = − . (3.55) π D z ζ π For example, 1 (α) 2 ˜ (z)d δ z 2π D 1 ˜ ˜ ) d 2ζ . =− |dξ |∂n ωα (ξ )(ξ ) + δ (α) (ζ 4π ∂Dc 2π D
δ (α) F =
In the last term we use (3.50) and obtain the result: ˜ )+ ˜ d 2 ζ + sα = 2sα δ (α) F = − |dξ |∂n (ξ d 2ζ = − 4π bα π Dα 4π Dα (here = 4∂z ∂z¯ is the Laplace operator). The integral representation of F is found in the same way through its variations which are read from (3.55). The result is given by the same formulas (2.35) and (2.36) as in g the simply-connected case with the understanding that D = ∪α=0 Dα is now the union of all Dα ’s.
26
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
3.8. Algebraic domains. In what follows we restrict our analysis by the class of algebraic domains. In the simply-connected case dealt with in the previous section the algebraic domains are simply images of the exterior of the unit disk under one-to-one conformal maps given by rational functions whose singularities are all in the other “half” of the plane, i.e. inside the unit circle. Note that the boundary of the unit circle is the set of fixed points of the inversion w → 1/w¯ which is the antiholomorphic involution of the w-plane compactified by a point at infinity (the Riemann sphere). Planar multiply-connected algebraic domains can be defined as the domains for which the Schwartz function has a meromorphic extension to a higher genus Riemann surface (a complex algebraic curve) with antiholomorphic involution. More precisely, let be a real Riemann surface by which we mean a complex algebraic curve of genus g with an antiholomorphic involution such that the set of fixed points consists of exactly g + 1 closed contours (such curves are sometimes called M-curves). Then can be naturally divided in two “halves” (say upper and lower sheets) which are interchanged by the involution. Algebraic domains with g holes in the plane can be defined as images of the upper half of the real Riemann surface under bijective conformal maps given by rational (meromorphic) functions on (see, e.g. [21]). For the purpose of this paper, it is convenient to use another, more direct characterization of algebraic domains. The domain Dc is algebraic if and only if the Cauchy integrals (3.15) 1 ζ¯ dζ α C (z) = for z ∈ Dα 2πi ∂D ζ − z are extendable to a rational (meromorphic) function J (z) on the whole complex plane with a marked point at infinity (see [21]). It is important to stress that this function is required to be the same for all α. The equality S(z) = J (z) − C − (z) valid by definition for z ∈ ∂Dc can be used for analytic extension of the Schwarz function. The function C − (z) is analytic in Dc . Therefore, J (z) and S(z) have the same singular parts at their poles in Dc . One may treat S(z) as a function on the Schottky double extending it to the lower sheet as z¯ . It is also convenient to introduce z J (z)dz (3.56) V (z) = 0
which is multi-valued if J (z) has simple poles (to fix a single-valued branch, we make cuts from ∞ to all simple poles of J (z)). In fact we need only the real part of V (z). In neighborhoods of the points zα one has J (z)dz = τk dBk (z), V (z) = τk Bk (z) . (3.57) k≥1
k≥1
The formula (3.32) α = φα + 2 Re V (zα ),
zα ∈ Dα
(3.58)
shows that for the algebraic domains the variables α , introduced in the general case as formal quantities, are well-defined. It is easy to show that they are equal to the a-periods of the differential S(z)dz on the Schottky double . Indeed, using the fact that C 0 (z)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
27
and C α (z) represent restrictions of the same function J (z), one can rewrite (3.18) in the form zα ξα φα = −2 Re J (z)dz + (¯z + C − (z) − J (z))dz . 0
ξ0
Under the second integral we recognize the Schwarz function. Combining this equality with the definition of α (3.32), we obtain: ξα ξα α = 2 Re (S(z) − z¯ )dz = S(z)dz . (3.59) S(z)dz − z¯ dS(z) = ξ0
aα
ξ0
As an example of algebraic domains, it is instructive to consider the case when only a finite-number of the moments τk are non-zero. Let AN be the space of multiply-connected domains such that τk = 0,
(3.60)
k>N.
Then the arguments similar to the ones used above show that • S(z) extends to a meromorphic function on with a pole of order N − 1 at ∞ and a ¯ simple pole at ∞. The function z extended to the lower sheet of the Schottky double as S(z) has a simple ¯ For a domain Dc ∈ AN the moments with pole at ∞ and a pole of order N − 1 at ∞. respect to the Laurent basis (cf. (2.1)) 1 tk = − z−k d 2 z (3.61) πk Dc coincide with the coefficients of the expansion of the Schwarz function near ∞: S(z) =
N
ktk zk−1 + O(z−1 ),
z → ∞.
(3.62)
k=1
The normal displacement of the bondary of an algebraic domain, which changes the variable tk keeping all zthe other moments (and α ) fixed is defined by normal derivative ˜ k . Here d ˜ k is a unique normalized meromorphic differential d of the function 2 Re on with the only pole at ∞ of the form k = d(zk + O(z−1 )), k = 0 . d d (3.63) aα
k is well-defined for a generic, not necessarily algebraic Note that the differential d z ˜ k defines a tangent d domain. Therefore, the normal derivative of the function 2 Re vector field ∂t on the whole space of multiply-connected domains. k The space AN is a particular case of algebraic orbits of the universal Whitham hierarchy. In this case the general formula (7.42) from [4] for the τ -function of the Whitham hierarchy, after proper change of the notation, acquires the form 1 1 2F = − τ02 + τ0 v0 + (2 − k)(τk νk + τ¯k ν¯ k ) − α sα 2 2 g
k≥1
α=1
(3.64)
28
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
which is a quasi-homogeneity condition obeyed by F (compare with formula (5.11) from [2]). Let d 0 be a unique normalized meromorphic differential on with simple poles ¯ Its Abelian integral at the infinities ∞ and ∞. z log w(z) = d 0 (3.65) ξ0
defines in the neighborhood of ∞ a function w(z) which has a simple pole at infinity. The dependence of the inverse function z(w) on the variables tk is described by the Whitham equations for the two-dimensional Toda lattice hierarchy. These equations have the form k (w), z(w)} := ∂t z(w) = { k
k (w) d dz k (w) ∂t0 z(w) − ∂t0 . d log w d log w
(3.66)
Algebraic domains of a more general form correspond to the universal Whitham hierarchy. Let AN1 ,... ,Nl be the space of domains such that the extension of the Schwarz function S(z) to Dc has poles of orders Nj − 1 at some points zj (which possibly ¯ Then, according to [4], the variables include ∞ and ∞). zj 1 t0,j = S(z)dz, tk,j = reszj (z − zj )k−1 S(z)dz, k = 1, . . . , Nj − 1 (3.67) k ξ0 together with the variables sα (or α ) provide a set of local Whitham coordinates on the space AN1 ,... ,Nl . Note that the definition of the algebraic orbits of the universal Whitham hierarchy is a bit more general than the definition of algebraic domains given above. It corresponds to the case when the differential dS of the Schwarz function is extendable to Dc as a meromorphic differential (in [21] such domains are called Abelian domains). (1) For example, let AN be the space of multiply-connected domains such that (1) Tk
=
Ak dS =
∂D
S (z)Ak dz = − ∂D
∂D
Ak S(z)dz = 0,
k > N . (3.68)
This space is characterized by the following property: there are constants Kα such that S(z) + Kα extends to a meromorphic function on Dc with a pole of order N at ∞. The variables 1 Kα , sα , tk = z−k z¯ dz, k ≥ 1, (3.69) 2πik ∂D (1)
are local coordinates on AN . The two cases when S(z) or its derivative S (z) have a meromorphic extension to c D are particular examples of the whole hierarchy of integrable domains, which can be defined in a similar way by the condition that the mth order derivative of the Schwarz function S(z) admits a meromorphic extension to the Schottky double . For example, (2) let AN be the space of multiply-connected domains such that (2)
Tk
= ∂D
S (z)Ak dz = −
∂D
Ak S(z)dz = 0, k > N .
(3.70)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
29
This space is characterized by the following property: there are linear functions kα (z) = Kα0 + Kα1 z such that S(z) + kα (z) extends to a meromorphic function on Dc with a pole of order N + 1 at ∞. The variables 1 Kα (z), sα , tk = z−k z¯ dz, k ≥ 1, (3.71) 2πik ∂D (2)
(m)
are local coordinates on AN . The other spaces AN with m > 2 can be defined in a similar way. 4. The Duality Transformation The independent variables α (3.59) or φα used in the previous section are not as transparent as the dual variables sα (3.11), which are simply areas of the holes Dα . In this section we show how to pass to the set of independent variables s1 , . . . , sg (3.11) (together with the infinite set of τk ’s). This transformation is similar to the passing from “external” to “internal” moments in the simply-connected case (see Sect. 5 of [2]). The difference is that only a finite number of times are subject to the transformation while the infinite set of τk ’s remains the same. The change to the variables sα can be done in the general case of domains with smooth boundaries. However, it is the change α → sα rather than φα → sα that leads to a transparent duality. Since α ’s are only defined as formal (“virtual”) variables for domains with smooth boundaries, we shall restrict our consideration to the class of algebraic domains discussed at the end of the previous section. In this case the variables α are well defined. 4.1. The Legendre transform. Passing from α to sα is a particular duality transformation which is equivalent to the interchanging of the a and b cycles on the Schottky double . This is achieved by the (partial) Legendre transform F (α , τ ) −→ F˜ (sα , τ ), where F˜ = F +
g
(4.1)
α sα .
α=1
The function F˜ is the “dual” tau-function. Below in this section, it is shown that F˜ solves the modified Dirichlet problem and can be identified with the free energy of a matrix model in the planar large N limit in the case when the support of eigenvalues consists of a few disconnected domains (a so-called multi-support solution, see [22] and references therein). The main properties of F˜follow from those of F . According to (2.34), (3.55) we have dF = − α sα dα + k νk dτk (for brevity, k is assumed to run over all integer values, τ−k ≡ τ¯k , etc.), so d F˜ = α α dsα + k νk dτk . This gives the first order derivatives: ∂ F˜ ∂ F˜ α = , νk = . (4.2) ∂sα ∂τk The second order derivatives are transformed as follows (see e.g. [23]). Set Fαβ =
∂ 2F , ∂α ∂β
Fαk =
∂ 2F , ∂α ∂τk
Fik =
∂ 2F ∂τi ∂τk
30
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
and similarly for F˜ . Then Fαβ = −(F˜ −1 )αβ , g (F˜ −1 )αγ F˜γ k , Fαk = γ =1
Fik = F˜ik −
(4.3) g
F˜iγ (F˜ −1 )γ γ F˜γ k .
γ ,γ =1
Here (F˜ −1 )αβ means the matrix element of the matrix inverse to the g × g matrix F˜αβ . Using these formulas, it is easy to see that the main properties (3.45), (3.46) and (3.47) of the tau-function are translated to the dual tau-function as follows: 1 ˜ G(a, b) = log |a −1 − b−1 | + ∇(a)∇(b)F˜ , 2
(4.4)
2πi ω˜ α (z) = − ∂sα∇(z)F˜ ,
(4.5)
∂ 2 F˜ 2πi T˜αβ = , ∂sα ∂sβ
(4.6)
where τk -derivatives in ∇(z) are taken at fixed sα . The objects in the left-hand sides of these relations are: ˜ G(a, b) = G(a, b) + iπ
g
ωα (a)T˜αβ ωβ (b) ,
(4.7)
α,β=1
ω˜ α (z) =
g
T˜αβ ωβ (z) ,
(4.8)
β=1
i T˜ = −T −1 = −1 . π
(4.9)
˜ is the Green function of the modified Dirichlet problem to be discussed The function G below. The matrix T˜ is the matrix of a-periods of the holomorphic differentials d W˜ α on the double (so that ω˜ α (z) = W˜ α (z) + W˜ α (z)), normalized with respect to the b-cycles − d W˜ β = δαβ , d W˜ β = T˜αβ , bα
aα
i.e. more precisely, the change of cycles is aα → bα , bα → −aα . An important remark is in order. By a simple rescaling of the independent variables one is able to write the group of relations (4.4)–(4.6) for the function F˜ in exactly the same form as the ones for the function F (3.45)–(3.47), so that they differ merely by the notation. We use this fact in Sect. 5.
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
31
4.2. The modified Dirichlet problem. The modified Green function (4.7) solves the modified Dirichlet problem which can be formulated in the following way. One may eliminate all except for one of the periods of the Green function G, thus making it similar, in this respect, to the Green function of a simply-connected domain (recall that the latter has the non-zero period 2π over the only boundary curve b0 ). This leads to the following modified Dirichlet problem (see e.g. [24]): given a function u0 (z) on the boundary, to find a harmonic function u(z) in Dc such that it is continuous up to the boundary and equals u0 (z) + Cα on the α’s boundary component. Here, Cα ’s are some constants. It is important to stress that they are not given a priori but have to be determined from the condition that the solution u(z) has vanishing periods over the boundaries b1 , . . . , bg . One of these constants can be put equal to zero. We set C0 = 0. This problem also has a unique solution. It is given by the same formula (1.1) in terms ˜ of the modified Green function G(z, ζ ). The definition of the latter is similar to that of the G(z, ζ ) but differs in two respects: ˜ ˜ (G1) G(z, ζ ) is required to have zero periods over the boundaries b1 , . . . , bg ; ˜ ˜ ˜ (G2) The derivative of G(z, ζ ) along the boundary (not G(z, ζ ) itself!) vanishes on the boundary. ˜ Under the condition that G(z, ζ ) = 0 on b0 such a function is unique. The function given by (4.7) just meets these requirements. We conclude that the modified Green function is expressed through the dual tau-function F˜ . Note that variations of the modified Green function under small deformations of the domain are described by the same Hadamard formula (1.4), where each Green function ˜ This follows, after some algebra, from the formula for G ˜ in terms of is replaced by G. G, ωα and αβ . Therefore, all the arguments of Sect. 3 could be repeated in a completely parallel way starting from the modified Dirichlet problem. One may also say that ˜ differ merely by a preferred basis of cycles on the double: the the functions G and G ˜ has vanishing differential ∂z Gdz has vanishing periods over the a-cycles while ∂z Gdz periods over the b-cycles. ˜ The function wa (z) such that G(z, a) = − log |wa (z)| maps Dc onto the exterior of the unit circle which is slit along g concentric circular arcs (see Fig. 5). Since the periods
˜ Fig. 5. The image of a triply-connected domain under the conformal map wa (z) such that G(z, a) = − log |wa (z)|. The function wa maps the domain onto the exterior of the unit (dashed) circle with g = 3 concentric circular cuts. Positions and lengths of the arcs depend on the shape of Dc in Fig. 3 and depend also on the normalization point z = a which is mapped to ∞
32
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
˜ vanish, the function wa is single-valued. Positions of the arcs depend of the function G on the shape of Dc as well as on the point a which is mapped to ∞. The radii of the arcs, Rα , are expressed through the dual tau-function as log Rα2 = ∂sα∇(a)F˜ .
(4.10)
In particular, for a = ∞ we have log Rα2 = ∂sα∂τ0 F˜ (cf. Eq. (2.20) for the conformal radius).
4.3. Relation to multi-support solutions of matrix models. The partition function of the model3 , written as an integral over eigenvalues, reads: N N N 1 1 ZN = exp log |zi − zj |2 + U (zi ) d 2 zj . (4.11) N! i<j
i=1
j =1
The matrix model potential U is usually chosen to be of the form U (z) = −z¯z + V (z) + V (z) ,
(4.12)
where V (z) is at the moment some polynomial; however, we will see immediately that the coincidence of the notation with (3.57) is not accidental. The parameter , in the large N limit, tends to zero simultaneously with N → ∞ in such a way that t0 = N is kept finite and fixed. In the leading order, one can apply the saddle point method. The saddle point condition is
N j =1,=i
1 + ∂zi U (zi ) = 0 . zi − z j
The density of eigenvalues is a sum of two-dimensional delta-functions: ρ(z) = π δ (2) (z − zi ) . i
In the large N limit, one treats it as a continuous function normalized as t0 . In terms of the continuous density the saddle point equation reads 1 π
ρ(ζ )d 2 ζ + ∂z U (z) = 0 . z−ζ
1 π
ρ(z)d 2 z =
(4.13)
The solution is well known and easy to obtain: the extremal density ρ0 (z) is constant in some domain D (the support of eigenvalues which can be a union of disconnected domains Dα ) and zero otherwise. More precisely, 1 z∈D ρ0 (z) = . 0 z ∈ C \ D ≡ Dc 3
One may have in mind the model of all complex or mutually hermitian conjugated or normal matrices.
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
33
Note that the saddle point condition is imposed only for z inside the support of eigenvalues. Writing (cf. (3.57)) V (z) =
p
τk Bk (z) ,
k=1
multiplying Eq. (4.13) by Ak (z) and integrating it over the boundary of the support of eigenvalues, one finds that the domain D is such that the coefficients τk are moments of its complement with respect to the basis functions Ak and the higher moments (with numbers greater than p) vanish. As is proven in Sect. 3, these conditions, together with the normalization condition for the density, locally determine the shape of the support of p eigenvalues. Equivalently, one might parametrize the polynomial as V (z) = k=1 tk zk , −k then tk are moments of the C \ D with respect to the functions z . An interesting problem is to obtain, for a given value of t0 , necessary and sufficient conditions on the polynomial V for the support of eigenvalues to be a union of g + 1 disconnected domains (”droplets”) with non-zero filling. One may approach this problem from a “classical” limit of very small (point-like) droplets. Clearly, for our choice of the signs in (4.11) and (4.12), the stable point-like droplets are located at minima of −U (z), or equivalently at maxima of U (z). As soon as we use the basis which explicitly depends on the marked points zα ∈ Dα , it is natural to consider the germ configuration with point-like eigenvalue droplets at the points zα . It is easy to see that the sufficient conditions for the potential (4.12) to have maxima at the points zα are z¯ α = V (zα ),
|V (zα )| < 1
for all α .
(4.14)
The first one means that there is an extremum of the potential U (z) at the point zα . The second one ensures that eigenvalues of the matrix of second derivatives of the potential at the extremum are both negative, i.e. the extremum is actually a maximum of U (z). The first condition literally coincides with the one used in [22] for the completely degenerate curve (point-like droplets) while the second one requires that not all extrema are filled, so that the “smooth” genus g is always less than the maximal possible genus (p−1)2 −1. Let now V0 (z) be a minimal degree polynomial that obeys these conditions. Then perturbed polynomials of the form V (z) = V0 (z) + τk Bk (z) k≥g+2
obey the same conditions for sufficiently small τk , and this is the advantage of using the basis (3.10), (3.13) from the perspective of matrix models. The saddle point equation (4.13) just means that the “effective potential” π1 D log |z− ζ |2 d 2 ζ + U (z) is constant in each Dα , i.e. for z ∈ Dα it holds: 2 log |z − ζ |d 2 ζ + U (z) = v0 + α , (4.15) π D where v0 = π2 D log |z|d 2 z, and so in our normalization 0 = 0. Let Nα be the number of eigenvalues in Dα , then limN→∞ Nα = sα . First we find the free energy with some fixed sα : 1 lim 2 log ZN ρ0 (z) log |z − ζ |ρ0 (ζ )d 2 zd 2 ζ = 2 N→∞ π sα fixed 1 + ρ0 (z)U (z)d 2 z, π
34
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
where one should substitute (4.15). The result is g 1 lim 2 log ZN =− 2 log |z−1 − ζ −1 |d 2 zd 2 ζ + α sα N→∞ π D D sα fixed α=1
= F˜ (sα , τ ) .
(4.16)
This quantity depends on sα ’s. It is given by the value of the integrand in (4.11) at the saddle point with fixed sα . If one wants to take into account the “tunneling” of eigenvalues between different components of the support, sα are no longer free parameters, and the free energy F (0) of the “planar limit” of the matrix model should be obtained by extremizing F˜ with respect to sα (with fixed t0 ). It follows from the above that ∂sα F˜ = α and so the extremum is at α = 0. Therefore, F (0) = F , (4.17) α =0
where F is given by (2.35). The results of Sect. 3 imply that the growth of the support of eigenvalues, when N → N + δN and the tunneling is taken into account, is given by the normal displacement of the boundary proportional to the normal derivative of the Green function with the minus sign, like in (2.9). Since this quantity is always non-negative, we conclude that if a point belongs to the support of eigenvalues, it does so as t0 increases. In particular, if one starts with point-like droplets at the points zα , as is discussed above, then these points always remain inside the droplets. Let us note that different aspects of multi-support solutions of the 2-matrix model and matrix models with complex eigenvalues were discussed in [22, 26, 25]. For matrix models one usually restricts oneself to the algebraic case of a finite amount of nonvanishing moments playing the role of the coefficients of the matrix model potential (4.12). In such a case the corresponding complex curve can be described by an algebraic equation [22], which can be thought of as an auxiliary constraint to the second derivatives of F . These auxiliary constraints look similar to the reduction conditions in the case of Landau-Ginzburg topological theories (see, for example, discussion of such conditions in the context of dispersionless Hirota equations and WDVV equations in [7]). Their meaning is that the derivatives w.r.t. the times {τk } for k > g + 1 (where g is the genus of the corresponding algebraic complex curve) can be expressed through the derivatives restricted to k ≤ g + 1. 5. Green Function on the Schottky Double and Generalized Hirota Equations Let us now turn to the generalization of the dispersionless Hirota equations to the multiply-connected case. For a unified treatment of the two “dual” representations of the Dirichlet problem discussed in the two previous sections, we make a simple change of variables. Namely, let us introduce the generic “period” variables Xα which are identified either with α or 2πi sα depending on the choice of the set of cycles, and the function F(Xα , τ ) Xα equal to F (Xα , τ ) or F˜ ( 2πi , τ ) respectively. Then the main relations (3.45)–(3.47) and (4.4)–(4.6) acquire the form 1 G(a, b) = log |a −1 − b−1 | + ∇(a)∇(b)F , 2
(5.1)
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
35
ωα (z) = − ∂α ∇(z)F ,
(5.2)
Tαβ = 2πi ∂α ∂β F ,
(5.3)
where ∂α := ∂Xα and G, ω and T stand for the corresponding objects with or without tilde, depending on the chosen basis of cycles. We will see below that, in analogy to the simply-conected case, any second order derivative of the function F w.r.t. τk (and τ¯k ), Fik , will be expressed through the derivatives {Fαβ }, where α, β = 0, . . . , g together with {Fατi } and their complex conjugated. To be more precise, one can consider all second derivatives as functions of {Fαβ , Fαk } modulo certain relations on the latter, like the relation (5.14) to be discussed below. Sometimes on this “small phase space” more extra constraints arise, which can be written in the form similar to the Hirota or WDVV equations [27]; we are not going to discuss this issue here, restricting ourselves to the generic situation. 5.1. The Abel map. To derive equations for the function F = F in Sect. 2, we used the representation (2.23) for the conformal map w(z) in terms of F and Eq. (1.2) relating the conformal map to the Green function which, in its turn, is expressed through the second order derivatives of F. In the multiply-connected case, our strategy is basically the same, with the suitable analog of the conformal map w(z) (or rather of log w(z)) being the embedding of Dc into the g-dimensional complex torus Jac, the Jacobi variety of the Schottky double. This embedding is given, up to an overall shift in Jac, by the Abel map z → W(z) := (W1 (z), . . . , Wg (z)), where z dWα (5.4) Wα (z) = ξ0
is the holomorphic part of the harmonic measure ωα . By virtue of (5.2), the Abel map is represented through the second order derivatives of the function F: z dWα = −∂α D(z)F , (5.5) Wα (z) − Wα (∞) = ∞
2 Re Wα (∞) = ωα (∞) = −∂τ0 ∂α F .
(5.6)
The last formula immediately follows from (5.2).
5.2. The Green function and the prime form. The Green function of the Dirichlet boundary problem, appearing in (5.1), can be written in terms of the prime form (A.4) on the Schottky double (cf. (1.2)): E(z, ζ ) . G(z, ζ ) = log (5.7) E(z, ζ¯ ) Here by ζ¯ we mean the (holomorphic) coordinate of the “mirror” point on the Schottky double, i.e. the “mirror” of ζ under the antiholomorphic involution. The pairs of such mirror points satisfy the condition Wα (ζ ) + Wα (ζ¯ ) = 0 in the Jacobian (i.e., the sum
36
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
should be zero modulo the lattice of periods). The prime form4 is written through the Riemann theta functions and the Abel map as follows: E(z, ζ ) =
θ∗ (W(z) − W(ζ )) h(z) h(ζ )
(5.8)
when the both points are on the upper sheet and E(z, ζ¯ ) =
θ∗ (W(z) + W(ζ ))
(5.9)
ih(z) h(ζ )
when z is on the upper sheet and ζ¯ is on the lower one (for other cases we define E(¯z, ζ¯ ) = E(z, ζ ), E(¯z, ζ ) = E(z, ζ¯ )). Here θ∗ (W) ≡ θδ ∗ (W|T ) is the Riemann theta function (A.2) with the period matrix Tαβ = 2πi ∂α ∂β F and any odd characteristics δ ∗ , and h2 (z) = −z2
g
θ∗,α (0)∂z Wα (z) = z2
α=1
g
θ∗,α (0)
α=1
Ak (z)∂α ∂τk F .
(5.10)
k≥1
Note that in the l.h.s. of (5.9) the bar means the reflection in the double while in the r.h.s. the bar means complex conjugation. The notation is consistent since the local coordinate in the lower sheet is just the complex conjugate one. However, one should remember that E(z, ζ¯ ) is not obtained from (5.8) by a simple substitution of the complex conjugated argument. On different sheets so defined prime “form” E is represented by different functions. In our normalization (5.9) iE(z, z¯ ) is real (see also Appendix B) and lim
E(z, ζ ) = 1. − ζ −1
ζ →z z−1
In particular, limz→∞ zE(z, ∞) = 1. 5.3. The prime form and the tau-function. In (5.7), the h-functions in the prime forms cancel, so the analog of (2.17) reads 2 θ∗ (W(z) − W(ζ )) 2 = log 1 − 1 + ∇(z)∇(ζ )F . log (5.11) z ζ θ∗ (W(z) + W(ζ )) This equation already explains the claim made in the beginning of this section. Indeed, the r.h.s. is the generating function for the derivatives Fik while the l.h.s. is expressed through derivatives of the form Fαk and Fαβ only. The expansion in powers of z, ζ allows one to express the former through the latter. The analogs of Eqs. (2.19), (2.20) are, respectively: θ∗ (W(z) − W(∞)) 2 = − log |z|2 + ∂τ ∇(z)F , log (5.12) 0 θ∗ (W(z) + W(∞)) Given a Riemann surface with local coordinates 1/z and 1/¯z we trivialize the bundle of − 21 -differentials and “redefine” the prime form E(z, ζ ) → E(z, ζ )(dz)1/2 (dζ )1/2 so that it becomes a function. However for different coordinate patches (the “upper” and “lower” sheets of the Schottky double) one gets different functions, see, for example, formulas (5.8) and (5.9) below. 4
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
37
2 h (∞) 2 = ∂2 F . log τ0 θ (ω(∞)) ∗
(5.13)
Here ω(z) ≡ 2 Re W(z) = (ω1 (z), . . . , ωg (z)) and h2 (∞) = lim z θ∗ z→∞
z ∞
g dW = − θ∗,α (0)∂α ∂τ1 F . α=1
¯ A simple check shows that the l.h.s. of (5.13) can be written as −2 log(iE(∞, ∞)). ¯ + O(z−1 ) as As is seen from the expansion G(z, ∞) = − log |z| − log(iE(∞, ∞)) ¯ −1 is a natural analog of the conformal radius, and (5.13) indeed z → ∞, (iE(∞, ∞)) turns to (2.20) in the simply-connected case (see Appendix B for an explicit illustrative example). However, now it provides a nontrivial relation on Fαβ ’s and Fαi ’s:
2 θ∗,α ∂α ∂τ1 F θ∗,β ∂β ∂τ¯1 F = θ∗2 (ω(∞))e∂τ0 F (5.14) α
β
so that the “small phase space” contains the derivatives modulo this relation. The next steps are exactly the same as in Sect. 2: we are going to decompose these equalities into holomorphic and antiholomorphic parts. The results are conveniently written in terms of the prime form. The counterpart of (2.22) is E(ζ, z)E(∞, ζ¯ ) ζ log + D(z)∇(ζ )F . (5.15) = log 1 − z E(ζ, ∞)E(z, ζ¯ ) Tending ζ → ∞, we get: log
¯ E(z, ∞) ¯ − ∂τ0 D(z)F . = log z + log E(∞, ∞) E(z, ∞)
(5.16)
Separating holomorphic and antiholomorphic parts of (5.15) in ζ , we get analogs of (2.24) and (2.25): log
E(z, ζ ) = log(z − ζ ) + D(z)D(ζ )F E(z, ∞)E(∞, ζ ) − log
¯ E(z, ζ¯ )E(∞, ∞) ¯ ζ¯ )F . = D(z)D( ¯ E(z, ∞)E(∞, ζ¯ )
(5.17)
(5.18)
Combining these equalities (with merging points z → ζ in particular), one is able to obtain the following representations of the prime form itself: 1 2 E(z, ζ ) = (z−1 − ζ −1 )e− 2 (D(z)−D(ζ )) F ,
(5.19)
1 ¯ ¯ 2 iE(z, ζ¯ ) = e− 2 (∂τ0 +D(z)+D(ζ )) F .
(5.20)
Note also the nice formula 1
iE(z, z¯ ) = e− 2 ∇
2 (z)F
.
(5.21)
38
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
5.4. Generalized Hirota relations. For higher genus Riemann surfaces there are no simple universal relations connecting values of prime forms at different points, which, via (5.19), (5.20), could be used to generate equations on F. The best available relation [9] is the celebrated Fay identity (A.5). Although it contains not only prime forms but Riemann theta functions themselves, it is really a source of closed equations on F, since all the ingredients are in fact representable in terms of second order derivatives of F in different variables. An analog of the KP version of the Hirota equation (2.26) for the function F can be obtained by plugging Eqs. (5.5) and (5.19) into the Fay identity (A.5). As a result, one obtains a closed equation which contains second order derivatives of the F only (recall that the period matrix in the theta-functions is essentially the matrix of the derivatives Fαβ ). A few equivalent forms of this equation are available. First, shifting Z → Z − W3 + W4 in (A.5) and putting z4 = ∞, one gets the relation a c b D(a)D(b)F (a − b)e θ dW + dW − Z θ dW − Z ∞
+ (b − c)eD(b)D(c)F θ
+ (c − a)eD(c)D(a)F θ
∞
b ∞ c
∞
dW +
∞ a
dW +
∞
c
∞
dW − Z θ dW − Z θ
a ∞ b
∞
dW − Z
dW − Z
= 0 . (5.22)
The vector Z is arbitrary (in particular, zero). We see that (2.26) gets “dressed” by the theta-factors. Each theta-factor is expressed through F only. For example, z 2 dW = exp −2π 2 nα nβ ∂αβ F − 2π i nα ∂α D(z)F . θ ∞
nα ∈Z
α
αβ
Another form of this equation, obtained from (5.22) for a particular choice of Z, reads a −1 21 (D(a)+D(b))2 F h(c)θ∗ dW (a − b)c e +
b
∞
∞
dW + [cyclic per-s of a, b, c] = 0 .
(5.23)
Taking the limit c → ∞ in (5.22), one gets an analog of (2.27): a b θ ( ∞ dW + ∞ dW − Z) θ (Z) D(a)D(b)F 1− e a b θ ( ∞ dW − Z) θ( ∞ dW − Z) a g θ ( ∞ dW − Z) D(a) − D(b) 1 ∂ ∂τ1 F + = log b ∂α ∂τ1 F , (5.24) a−b a−b ∂Zα θ( W − Z) α=1
∞
which also follows from another Fay identity (A.6). Equations on F with τ¯k -derivatives follow from the general Fay identity (A.5) with some points on the lower sheet. Besides, many other equations can be derived as various combinations and specializations of the ones mentioned above. Altogether, they form an infinite hierarchy of consistent differential equations of a very complicated structure which deserves further investigation. The functions F corresponding to different choices of independent variables (i.e., to different bases in homology cycles on the Schottky double) provide different solutions to this hierarchy.
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
39
5.5. Higher genus analogs of the dispersionless Toda equation. Let us show how the simplest equation of the hierarchy, the dispersionless Toda equation (2.30), is modified in the multiply-connected case. Applying ∂z ∂ζ¯ to both sides of (5.18) and setting ζ = z, we get: ¯ z))F = −∂z ∂z¯ log E(z, z¯ ) . (∂D(z))(∂¯ D(¯
Here ∂D(z) is the z-derivative of the operator D(z): ∂D(z) = k Ak (z)∂τk . To transform the r.h.s., we use the identity (A.8) (Appendix A) and specialize it to the particular local parameters on the two sheets: θ (ω(z) + Z)θ (ω(z) − Z) θ 2 (Z)E 2 (z, z¯ ) +|z|4 (log θ (Z)), αβ ∂z Wα (z)∂z¯ Wβ (z) .
|z|4 ∂z ∂z¯ log E(z, z¯ ) =
α,β
Tending z to ∞, we obtain a family of equations (parametrized by an arbitrary vector Z) which generalize the dispersionless Toda equation for the tau-function: ∂τ1 ∂τ¯1 F =
θ (ω(∞)+Z)θ (ω(∞)−Z) ∂τ2 F e 0 θ 2 (Z) g − (log θ (Z)), αβ (∂α ∂τ1 F)(∂β ∂τ¯1 F).
(5.25)
α,β=1
(Here we used the z → ∞ limits of (5.5) and (5.21).) The following two equations correspond to special choices of the vector Z: ∂τ1 ∂τ¯1 F +
g
(log θ (0)), αβ (∂α ∂τ1 F)(∂β ∂τ¯1 F) =
α,β=1
∂τ1 ∂τ¯1 F = −
g
log θ∗ (ω(∞))
,αβ
θ 2 (ω(∞)) ∂τ2 F e 0 , θ 2 (0)
(∂α ∂τ1 F)(∂β ∂τ¯1 F) .
(5.26)
(5.27)
α,β=1
Finally, let us specify Eq. (5.25) for the genus g = 1 case. In this case there is only one extra variable X := X1 (1 or 2πis1 ). The is
Riemann theta-function
θ(ω(∞) + Z) then replaced by the Jacobi theta-function ϑ ∂X ∂τ0 F − Z T ≡ ϑ3 ∂X ∂τ0 F − Z T , where the elliptic modular parameter is T = 2πi ∂X2 F, and the vector Z ≡ Z has only one component. The equation has the form:
ϑ3 ∂X ∂τ0 F +Z 2πi ∂X2 F ϑ3 ∂X ∂τ0 F −Z 2π i ∂X2 F ∂τ2 F
∂τ1 ∂τ¯1 F = e 0 ϑ32 Z| 2πi ∂X2 F (5.28) − ∂Z2 log ϑ3 Z| 2πi ∂X2 F (∂X ∂τ1 F)(∂X ∂τ¯1 F) . Note also that Eq. (5.14) acquires the form
2 2 ϑ1 ∂X ∂τ0 F 2π i ∂X2 F
(∂X ∂τ1 F)(∂X ∂τ¯1 F) = e ∂τ 0 F , 2 ϑ1 0| 2πi ∂X F
(5.29)
40
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
where ϑ∗ ≡ ϑ1 is the only odd Jacobi theta-function. Combining (5.28) and (5.29) one may also write the equation
ϑ3 ∂X ∂τ0 F +Z 2πi ∂X2 F ϑ3 ∂X ∂τ0 F −Z 2π i ∂X2 F
∂τ1 ∂τ¯1 F = ϑ32 Z| 2πi ∂X2 F
2 2 ϑ1 ∂X ∂τ0 F 2πi ∂X2 F
∂Z2 log ϑ3 Z| 2π i ∂X2 F e∂τ0 F (5.30) − 2 ϑ1 0| 2πi ∂X F whose form is close to (2.30) but differs by the nontrivial “coefficient” in the square brackets. In the limit T → i∞ the theta-function ϑ3 tends to unity, and we obtain the dispersionless Toda equation (2.30). 6. Conclusions In this paper we have considered the Dirichlet boundary problem in planar multiplyconnected domains. A planar multiply-connected domain Dc is the complex plane with several holes. We study how the solution of the Dirichlet problem depends on small deformations of boundaries of the holes. General properties of such deformations allow us to introduce the quasiclassical tau-function associated to the variety of planar multiply-connected domains. By the tau-function, we actually mean its logarithm, which only makes sense for the quasiclassical or Whitham-type integrable hierarchies. Namely, the key properties are the specific “exchange” relations (3.43) which follow from the Hadamard variational formula for the Green function and the harmonic measure. They have the form of integrability conditions and thus ensure the existence of the tau-function. The tau-function corresponds to a particular solution of the universal Whitham hierarchy [4] and generalizes the dispersionless tau-function which describes deformations of simply-connected domains. The algebro-geometric data associated with the multiply-connected geometry include a Riemann surface with antiholomorphic involution, the Schottky double of the domain Dc = C\D endowed with particular holomorphic coordinates z and z¯ on the two sheets of the double, respecting the involution. This Riemann surface has genus g = #{holes} − 1. The (logarithm of) tau-function, F, describes small deformations of these data as functions of an infinite set of independent deformation parameters which are basically harmonic moments of the domain. These variables can be equivalently redefined as periods of the generating one-form S(z)dz over non-trivial cycles on the double and the residues of the one-forms Ak (z)S(z)dz, where Ak (z) z−k is some proper global basis (3.10) z→∞
of harmonic functions. We have obtained simple expressions for the period matrix, the Abel map and the prime form on the Schottky double in terms of the function F. Specifically, all these objects are expressed through second order derivatives of the F in its independent variables. The generalized dispersionless Hirota equations on F for the multiply-connected case (equivalent to the Whitham hierarchy) are obtained by incorporating the above mentioned expressions into the Fay identities. As a result, one comes to a series of quite non-trivial equations for (second derivatives of) the function F , which have not been written before (except for certain relations for the second derivatives of the Seiberg-Witten prepotential [28]). When the Riemann surface degenerates to the Riemann
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
41
sphere with two marked points, they turn into Hirota equations of the dispersionless Toda hierarchy. Algebraic orbits of the universal Whitham hierarchy describe the class of domains which can be obtained as conformal images of a “half” of a complex algebraic curve with the antiholomorphic involution under conformal maps given by rational functions on the curve. In particular, all domains having only a finite amount of non-vanishing harmonic moments, are in this class. In this case one can define the curve by a polynomial equation written explicitly in [22]. This situation is an analog of the (Laurent) polynomial conformal maps in the simply-connected case and literally corresponds to multi-support solutions of matrix models with polynomial potentials. The definition of the tau-function for multiply-connected domains proposed above holds in a broader set-up of general algebraic domains. It does not rely on the finiteness of the amount of non-vanishing moments. In general any effective way to describe the complex curve associated to a multiply-connected domain by a system of polynomial or algebraic equations is not known. The curve may be thought of as a spectral curve corresponding to a generic finite-gap solution to the Toda lattice hierarchy. Acknowledgement. We are indebted to V.Kazakov, M.Mineev-Weinstein, S.Natanzon, L.Takhtajan and P.Wiegmann for illuminating discussions and especially to A.Levin for very important comments on Sect. 5. We are also grateful to the referee for a very careful reading of the manuscript and valuable remarks. The work was also partially supported by NSF grant DMS-01-04621 (I.K.), RFBR under the grant 01-01-00539 (A.M. and A.Z.), by INTAS under the grants 00-00561 (A.M.), 99-0590 (A.Z.) and by the Program of support of scientific schools under the grants 1578.2003.2 (A.M.), 1999.2003.2 (A.Z.). The work of A.Z. was also partially supported by the NATO grant PST.CLG.978817. A.M. is grateful for the hospitality to the Max Planck Institute of Mathematics in Bonn, where an essential part of this work has been done.
Appendix A. Theta Functions and Fay Identities Here we present some definitions and useful formulas from [9]. The Riemann theta function θ (W) ≡ θ (W|T ) is defined as θ (W) = eiπn·T ·n + 2πin·W . (A.1) n∈Zg
The theta function with (half-integer) characteristics δ = (δ 1 , δ 2 ), where δα = Tαβ δ1,β + δ2,α and δ 1 , δ 2 ∈ 21 Zg is θδ (W) = eiπ δ 1 ·T ·δ 1 +2πi δ 1 ·(W+δ 2 ) θ(W + δ) = eiπ(n+δ 1 )·T ·(n+δ 1 )+2πi(n+δ 1 )·(W+δ 2 ) .
(A.2)
n∈Zg
Under shifts by a period of the lattice, it transforms according to θδ (W + eα ) = e2πiδ1,α θδ (W) ,
θδ (W + Tαβ eβ ) = e−2πiδ2,α −iπTαα −2πiWα θδ (W) .
(A.3)
The prime form E(z, ζ ) is defined as θ∗ (W(z) − W(ζ )) , α θ∗,α dWα (z) β θ∗,β dWβ (ζ )
E(z, ζ ) =
(A.4)
42
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
where θ∗ is any odd theta function, i.e., the theta function with any odd characteristic δ ∗ (the characteristics is odd if 4δ ∗1 · δ ∗2 = odd). The prime form does not depend on the particular choice of the odd characteristics. In the denominator, ∂θ∗ (W) θ∗,α = θ∗,α (0) = ∂Wα W=0 is the set of θ-constants. The data we use in the main text contain also distinguished coordinates on a Riemann surface: the holomorphic co-ordinates z and z¯ on two different sheets, and we do not distinguish, unless it is necessary between the prime form (A.4) and a function E(z, ζ ) ≡ E(z, ζ )(dz)1/2 (dζ )1/2 “normalized” onto the differentials of a distinguished co-ordinate. Let us now list the Fay identities [9] used in the paper. The basic one is Fay’s trisecant formula (Eq. (45) from p. 34 of [9]) θ (W1 − W3 − Z) θ(W2 − W4 − Z) E(z1 , z4 )E(z3 , z2 ) + θ (W1 − W4 − Z) θ(W2 − W3 − Z) E(z1 , z3 )E(z2 , z4 ) = θ (W1 + W2 − W3 − W4 − Z) θ(Z) E(z1 , z2 )E(z3 , z4 ) .
(A.5)
Here Wi ≡ W(zi ). This identity holds for any four points z1 , . . . , z4 on a Riemann surface and any vector Z ∈ Jac. In the limit z3 → z4 ≡ ∞ one gets (formula (38) from p. 25 of [9]) z z θ ( ∞1 dW + ∞2 dW − Z) θ(Z) E(z1 , z2 ) z1 z2 θ ( ∞ dW − Z) θ( ∞ dW − Z) E(z1 , ∞)E(z2 , ∞) z g θ( ∞1 dW − Z) (z1 ,z2 ) = d (∞) + dWα (∞) ∂Zα log z2 , (A.6) θ( ∞ dW − Z) α=1 where d (z1 ,z2 ) (∞) = dz log
E(z, z1 ) E(z, z2 )
(A.7)
is the normalized Abelian differential of the third kind with simple poles at z1 and z2 and residues ±1. Another relation from [9] we use (see e.g. (29) on p.20 and (39) on p.26) is θ (W1 − W2 − Z)θ (W1 − W2 + Z) θ 2 (Z)E 2 (z1 , z2 ) g = ω(z1 , z2 ) + (log θ (Z)),αβ dWα (z1 )dWβ (z2 ),
(A.8)
α,β=1
where (log θ (Z)), αβ =
∂ 2 log θ (Z) ∂Zα ∂Zβ
and ω(z1 , z2 ) = dz1 dz2 log E(z1 , z2 )
(A.9)
is the canonical bi-differential of the second kind with the double pole at z1 = z2 .
Integrable Structure of the Dirichlet Boundary Problem
43
Appendix B. Degenerate Schottky Double For an illustrative purpose we would like to adopt some of the above formulas to the simplest possible case, which is the Riemann sphere realized as the Schottky double of the complement to the disk of radius r. In this case dW =
dz d z¯ = idϕ = − z z¯
(B.1)
is purely imaginary on the circle and obviously satisfies the condition dW (z)+dW (¯z) = 0. Further, (cf. (3.65)) z z z W (z) = dW = dW = log (B.2) r ξ0 r and z (B.3) r which is nothing but the conformal map of the exterior of the circle |z| ≥ r onto the exterior of the unit circle |w| ≥ 1. Note that on the “lower” sheet of the double z¯ r dW = log , (B.4) W (¯z) = z¯ r w(z) = eW (z) =
and instead of (B.3) one gets w(¯z) =
r z¯
(B.5)
which is the conformal map of the exterior of the disk |¯z| ≥ r on the lower sheet onto the interior of the unit circle |w| ≤ 1. The prime form on the genus zero Riemann surface is (cf. (A.4)) w1 − w2 E(z1 , z2 ) = √ , √ dw1 dw2
(B.6)
¯ which is understood in the main text, where wi ≡ w(zi ). Let us compute E(∞, ∞), as “normalized” on the values of the local coordinates z∞ = 1/z and z¯ ∞ = 1/¯z in the ¯ on two sheets of the double. One gets (cf. (5.9)) points ∞ and ∞ ¯ =− E 2 (∞, ∞)
¯ 2 (w(∞) − w(∞)) . ¯ (dw(∞)/dz∞ )(dw(∞)/dz ¯ ) ∞
(B.7)
Substituting into (B.7) the formulas (B.3), (B.5) and dz z2 = − lim dz∞ , z→∞ r z→∞ r ¯ = r dz∞ dw(∞) ¯ ,
dw(∞) = lim
(B.8)
one finally gets 1 z2 /r 2 = 2, z→∞ (z2 /r)r r
¯ 2 = lim E(∞, ∞)
and this demonstrates that (5.14) indeed turns into (2.20) in the limit.
(B.9)
44
I. Krichever, A. Marshakov, A. Zabrodin
References 1. Hurwitz, A., Courant, R.: Vorlesungen u¨ ber allgemeine Funktionentheorie und elliptische Funktionen. Herausgegeben und erg¨anzt durch einen Abschnitt u¨ ber geometrische Funktionentheorie. Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1964 (Russian translation, adapted by M.A. Evgrafov: Theory of functions, Moscow: Nauka, 1968) 2. Marshakov, A., Wiegmann, P., Zabrodin, A.: Commun. Math. Phys. 227, 131 (2002) 3. Krichever, I.M.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 22, 200–213 (1989) 4. Krichever, I.M.: Commun. Pure. Appl. Math. 47, 437 (1994) 5. Mineev-Weinstein, M., Wiegmann, P.B., Zabrodin, A.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5106 (2000) 6. Wiegmann, P.B., Zabrodin, A.: Commun. Math. Phys. 213, 523 (2000) 7. Boyarsky, A., Marshakov, A., Ruchayskiy, O., Wiegmann, P., Zabrodin, A.: Phys. Lett. B515, 483– 492 (2001) 8. Krichever, I., Novikov, S.: Funct. Anal. Appl. 21, No 2, 46–63 (1987) 9. Fay, J.D.:“Theta Functions on Riemann Surfaces”. Lect. Notes in Mathematics 352, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1973 10. Hadamard, J.: M´em. pr´esent´es par divers savants a` l’Acad. sci., 33, (1908) 11. Davis, P.J.: The Schwarz function and its applications. The Carus Mathematical Monographs, No. 17, Buffalo, N.Y.: The Math. Association of America, 1974 12. Krichever, I.: 2000, unpublished 13. Takhtajan, L.: Lett. Math. Phys. 56, 181–228 (2001) 14. Kostov, I.K., Krichever, I.M., Mineev-Weinstein, M., Wiegmann, P.B., Zabrodin, A.: τ -function for analytic curves. In: Random matrices and their applications, MSRI publications, 40, Cambridge: Cambridge Academic Press, 2001 15. Hille, E.: Analytic function theory. V.II, Oxford: Ginn and Company, 1962 16. Gibbons, J., Kodama, Y.: Proceedings of NATO ASI “Singular Limits of Dispersive Waves”. ed. N. Ercolani, London – New York: Plenum, 1994; Carroll, R., Kodama, Y.: J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. A28, 6373 (1995) 17. Takasaki, K., Takebe, T.: Rev. Math. Phys. 7, 743–808 (1995) 18. Schiffer, M., Spencer, D.C.: Functionals of finite Riemann surfaces. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1954 19. Gustafsson, B.: Acta Applicandae Mathematicae 1, 209–240 (1983) 20. Aharonov, D., Shapiro, H.: J. Anal. Math. 30, 39–73 (1976); Shapiro, H.: The Schwarz function and its generalization to higher dimensions. University of Arkansas Lecture Notes in the Mathematical Sciences, Volume 9, W.H. Summers, Series Editor, New York: A Wiley-Interscience Publication, John Wiley and Sons, 1992 21. Etingof, P., Varchenko, A.: Why does the boundary of a round drop becomes a curve of order four? University Lecture Series. 3, Providence, RI: American Mathematical Society, 1992 22. Kazakov, V., Marshakov, A.: J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 36, 3107–3136 (2003) 23. De Wit, B., Marshakov, A.: Theor. Math. Phys. 129, 1504 (2001) [Teor. Mat. Fiz. 129, 230 (2001)] 24. Gakhov, F.: The boundary value problems. Moscow: Nauka, 1977 (in Russian) 25. Eynard, B.: Large N expansion of the 2-matrix model, multicut case. http://arxiv:org/list/mathph/0307052, 2003 26. Bertola, M.: Free energy of the two-matrix model/dToda tau-function. Nucl. Phys. B669, 435–461 (2003) 27. Marshakov, A., Mironov, A., Morozov, A.: Phys. Lett. B389, 43–52 (1996); Braden, H., Marshakov, A.: Phys. Lett. B541, 376–383 (2002) 28. Gorsky, A., Marshakov, A., Mironov, A., Morozov, A.: Nucl. Phys. B527, 690–716 (1998) Communicated by L. Takhtajan
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 45–69 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1378-6
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy Paul S. Aspinwall1 , R. Paul Horja2 , Robert L. Karp1 1
Center for Geometry and Theoretical Physics, Box 90318, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708-0318, USA 2 Department of Mathematics, University of Michigan, East Hall, 525 E University Avenue, Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1109, USA Received: 15 December 2003 / Accepted: 17 February 2004 Published online: 14 June 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: We analyze the link between the occurrence of massless B-type D-branes for specific values of moduli and monodromy around such points in the moduli space. This allows us to propose a classification of all massless B-type D-branes at any point in the moduli space of Calabi–Yau’s. This classification then justifies a previous conjecture due to Horja for the general form of monodromy. Our analysis is based on using monodromies around points in moduli space where a single D-brane becomes massless to generate monodromies around points where an infinite number become massless. We discuss the various possibilities within the classification.
1. Introduction The derived category approach to B-type D-Branes [1–5] appears to be extremely powerful. It allows one to go beyond the picture of D-branes as vector bundles over submanifolds so that α -corrections can be correctly understood. For example, the fact that B-type D-branes must undergo monodromy as one moves about the moduli space of complexified K¨ahler forms can be expressed in the derived category language [6–8]. The main purpose of this paper is to try to classify which D-branes can become massless at a given point in the moduli space. Again the language of derived categories will be invaluable. In order for an object in the bounded derived category of coherent sheaves to represent a D-brane it must be “-stable”. Criteria for -stability have been discussed in [9–12] although it is not clear that we yet have a mathematically rigorous algorithm for determining stability. Despite this, in simple examples such as in the above references and [13] one can compute stability with a fair degree of confidence. In particular if you have reason to believe that a certain set of a D-branes is stable at a given point in the moduli space then one can move along a path in moduli space and see how the spectrum of stable states changes. There is considerable evidence [12] that such changes
46
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
in -stability depend only on the homotopy class of the path in the moduli space of conformal field theories. The fact that changes in -stability do depend on the homotopy class of such paths was used in [12] to “derive” Kontsevich’s picture of monodromy at least in the case of the quintic Calabi–Yau threefold. The moduli space of conformal field theories may be compactified by including the “discriminant locus” consisting of badly-behaved worldsheet theories. Typically one expects such theories to be bad because some D-brane has become massless [14]. Indeed, the monodromy seen in [2, 13] around parts of this discriminant locus was intimately associated to massless D-branes. It is this link between massless D-branes and monodromy that we wish to study more deeply in this paper. In simple cases as one approaches a point in the discriminant locus, a single D-brane becomes massless. Of more interest to us is the case where an infinite number become massless. In [7,8] one of the authors studied components of the discriminant locus corresponding to what was called “EZ-transformations”. Namely if one has a Calabi–Yau threefold X with some complex subspace E, there may be a point in K¨ahler moduli space where E collapses to a complex subspace Z of lower dimension than E. We will see that it is then the derived category of Z that describes the massless D-branes associated to this transformation. A particular autoequivalence was naturally associated to a particular EZ-transformation and it was conjectured in [7,8] that such an autoequivalence resulted from the associated monodromy. We will call this conjecture the “EZ-monodromy conjecture”. One purpose of this paper is to justify this conjecture. Because of the nature of our understanding of D-branes and string theory it will not be possible to rigorously prove any hard theorems about D-branes. Instead we will have to play with a number of conjectures whose interdependence leads to considerable evidence of the validity of the overall story. In particular, on the one hand we have the EZ-monodromy conjecture and, on the other hand, we have our conjecture concerning which D-branes become massless. These two conjectures are interlinked by -stability as we discuss in Sect. 2. In particular, in Sect. 2.1 we discuss an older conjecture concerning single massless D-branes. In Sect. 2.2 we then review a framework for the more general case which is linked to the simpler case in Sect. 2.3 for a particular example. The physical interpretation of the general case is then given in Sect. 2.4. The link discussed in Sect. 2.3 between the simple case of a single D-brane becoming massless and an infinite number becoming massless depends upon a mathematical result which is derived in Sect. 3. This section is more technical than the other sections and may be omitted by the reader if need be. That said, it shows how the sophisticated methods of derived categories are directly relevant to the physics of D-branes. In Sect. 4 we discuss a natural hierarchy of cases. The familiar “conifold”-like situation arises where Z is a point and only one soliton becomes massless. If Z has dimension one then the derived category of Z has more structure. This case corresponds to the Seiberg–Witten theory of some nonabelian gauge group. We study an explicit example of this elsewhere [15]. The case where Z has complex dimension two is more complicated as the derived category now has a rich structure. We show that it appears to be similar to the spectrum of massless D-branes one gets from a decompactification. We also see that it demonstrates how 2-branes wrapped around a 2-torus can become massless. At first sight this appears to contradict T-duality but we will see that this is not actually the case. Finally, for completeness, in Sect. 4.4 we discuss the case of an exoflop which is awkward to fit into our general classification but still yields a simple result.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
47
2. Monodromy and Massless D-Branes 2.1. A single massless D-brane. B-type D-branes on X correspond to objects in the bounded derived category of coherent sheaves on X [1–5]. A given object A is represented by a complex. We may then construct another object A[n] by shifting this complex n places to the left. Such a shift or “translation” is a global symmetry of physics if it is applied simultaneously to all objects [2]. Relative shifts are significant — an open string stretched between A and B is not equivalent to an open string stretched between A[n] and B if n = 0. We would like to consider the case of moving to a point in moduli space where a single physical D-brane A becomes massless. Because of the global shift symmetry all of its translates A[n] are equally massless. Thus an infinite number of objects in D(X) are becoming massless even though only one D-brane counts towards any physical effects of this masslessness as it would be computed by Strominger [14] for example. The analysis of -stability in [12, 13] showed that monodromy is intimately associated to massless D-branes. This should not be surprising since monodromy can only occur around the discriminant and the discriminant is associated with singularities in the conformal field theory associated with massless solitons [14]. Consider an oriented open string f stretched between two D-branes in a Calabi–Yau threefold X. In the derived category language this is written as a morphism between two objects in D(X), f : A → B.
(1)
These two objects may or may not form a bound state according to the mass of the open string f . If f is tachyonic then we have a bound state a` la Sen [16]. (As we emphasize shortly A is really an anti-brane in such a bound state.) A real number1 (dubbed a “grade” in [2]) ϕ is associated to each stable D-brane. We assume ϕ varies continuously over the moduli space and is defined mod 2 by the central charge Z: ϕ=−
1 arg(Z) π
(mod 2).
(2)
The precise definition of ϕ is discussed at length in [12]. In [2] it was argued that the mass squared of the open string in (1) is then proportional to ϕ(B) − ϕ(A) − 1 allowing the stability of this bound state to be determined. One of the key features of the derived category which makes it so useful for the study of solitons is the way that bound states are described using distinguished triangles. The open string f between A and B is best represented in the context of a distinguished triangle
A
[1]
C _@ @@ @@ @@ f / B.
(3)
1 It has been suggested that ϕ is defined modulo some integer such as 6 [2, 17]. Periodicity can also appear, if desired, in Floer cohomology (see [18, 19] for example) which is supposedly mirror to the structure we are considering. For simplicity we ignore such a possibility. To take such an effect into account one should probably quotient the derived category by such translations.
48
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
The “[1]” represents the fact that one must shift one place left when performing the corresponding map. The object C, which is equivalent to the “mapping cone” Cone(f : A → B), is then potentially a bound state of A[1] and B. As explained in [2], A[odd] should be thought of as an anti-A. The triangle also tells us that B is potentially a bound state of A and C. Equally A is a bound state of B and C[−1]. The “[1]” could be interpreted as keeping track of which brane should be treated as an anti-brane. The fact that D(X) copes so well with anti-branes demonstrates its power to analyze D-branes. The other approach, namely K-theory, should be considered the derived category’s weaker cousin since it only knows about D-brane charge! Now suppose that A is stable and becomes massless at a particular point P in the moduli space. Furthermore, let us assume that the only massless D-branes at P are of the form A[m] for any m. Let us take a generic complex plane with polar coordinates (r, θ ) passing through P at the origin and assume that Z(A) behaves as cr exp(−iθ ) near P for c some real and positive constant. That is, we assume that Z(A) has a simple zero at P . Suppose B does not have vanishing mass. It follows that Z(B) and Z(C) are equal at P and nonzero. In particular if we circle the point P by varying θ , these central charges will be constant close to P . Furthermore, if C can be a marginally bound state of anti-A and B near P , then, according to the rules of [12], we have ϕ(B) = ϕ(C) near P . This allows us to rewrite (3) including the differences in the ϕ’s for the open strings (i.e., sides of the triangle) to give 1+a−b+ πθ [1]
A
C _@ @@ @@0 @@ f / B,
(4)
b−a− πθ
where ϕ(B) = b and ϕ(A) = a at θ = 0. The stability of a given vertex of this triangle depends upon the number on the opposite side being less than 1. By “stability” we mean relative to this triangle only. A given D-brane may decay by other channels. It follows that C becomes stable for θ > π(b − a − 1) while B becomes unstable for θ > π(b − a). Note that A is always stable near P consistent with our assumptions. Based on this idea that we “gain” C and “lose” B as θ increases, we can try to formulate a picture for monodromy around P . The meaning of monodromy is that after traversing this loop in the moduli space we should be able to relabel the D-branes in such a way as to restore the physics we had before we traversed the loop. It is important to note that monodromy is not really the statement that a certain D-brane manifestly “becomes” another D-brane explicitly as we move through the moduli space. It is much more accurately described as a relabeling process. Since stability is a physical quality, we are forced to relabel B since it has decayed. The obvious candidate in the above case is to call it C. Thus monodromy would transform B into C. Life can be more complicated than this however. If we have an open string f : A → C, then, since ϕ(B) = ϕ(C) when B decays to C + A[1], C will immediately decay further to D = Cone(f : A → C) plus another A[1]. Suppose A is “spherical” in the sense of [20] which means Hom(A, A[m]) = C for m = 0 or 3, and Hom(A, A[m]) = 0 otherwise. This condition is always satisfied in the context of this subsection — i.e., only A and its translates become massless. A long exact sequence associated to (3) then implies dim Hom(A, C) = dim Hom(A, B) − 1.
(5)
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
49
It follows that this second decay will occur if dim Hom(A, B) > 1. Iterating this process one sees that B will decay splitting off an A[1] a total of dim Hom(A, B) times. Finally we should also worry about homomorphisms between B and A[m] for other values of m. We refer to the example in Sect. 4 of [13] for a detailed example of exactly how this happens in a fairly nontrivial example. All said, allowing for all these decays, C becomes a number of A’s (probably shifted) together with Cone . . . ⊕ Ab0 ⊕ A[−1]b1 ⊕ A[−2]b2 ⊕ . . . → B , (6) where bn = dim Hom(A[−n], B) = dim Extn (A, B).
(7)
The cone (6) may be written more compactly as KA (B) = Cone(hom(A, B) ⊗ A → B),
(8)
where hom(A, B) is the complex of C-vector spaces 0
0
0
0
. . . → Ext0 (A, B) → Ext1 (A, B) → Ext2 (A, B) → . . . .
(9)
We refer to [20] for further explanation of the notation.2 We can also write more heuristically KA (B) = Cone
As much massless stuff that can bind to B as possible.
→ B .
(10)
Interpreted na¨ıvely, we have shown that, upon increasing θ from −∞ to +∞, an object B will decay and a canonically associated object KA (B) will become stable and appear as one of the decay products of B. What is desired however is monodromy once around P , i.e., θ should only increase by 2π. We will indeed claim that monodromy once around P replaces B by KA (B). For some objects, increasing θ by only 2π (at the appropriate starting point) will cause the complete decay of B into KA (B). Thanks to its rather simple cohomology, this always happens for Ox , the structure sheaf of a point x ∈ X. Therefore the relabeling process under monodromy should replace B by KA (B). There are undoubtedly many other objects B under which this increase in θ by only 2π would not induce the entire decay to KA (B ). This doesn’t matter however, we can still leave physics invariant by relabeling B by KA (B ). For example in an extreme case, both B and KA (B ) may be stable with respect to the above triangle both before and after increasing θ by 2π . It is therefore harmless to relabel one of these states as the other. Well, it is fine saying that it is harmless to relabel B by KA (B ), but why are we forced to relabel like this? The reason is that we know that physics must be completely invariant under monodromy which implies that the relabeling must amount to an autoequivalence 2 Note that since “left-derived” L’s or “right-derived” R’s should be added to every functor in this paper, we may consistently omit them without introducing any ambiguities!
50
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
of D(X). One can indeed show that KA defines an autoequivalence3 of D(X) so long as A is spherical [8, 20]. What’s more, as argued in [12, 21], it is pretty well the only autoequivalence that works. To be more precise, once we have argued that the specific objects Ox undergo monodromy given by KA then all other objects must undergo the same monodromy up to some possible multiplication by some fixed line bundle L. Note that the central charge Z is also a physical quantity. Insisting that monodromy acts correctly in this case amounts to insisting that the D-brane “charges” ch(B) transform under monodromy. This is precisely the same monodromy on H even (X, Z) that one deduces from mirror symmetry as in [22]. This determines that the above line bundle L is trivial (in a considerably overdetermined way!). It is known (see [7] for example) that KA then induces the correct transformation on these charges — indeed this was the reason why KA was conjectured as the monodromy action in the first place [6]! It is worth noting that in some special cases the transformation KA has nothing to do with decay. Consider how the spherical object A itself transforms: Cone(hom(A, A) ⊗ A → A) = Cone((C → 0 → 0 → C) ⊗ A → A) = Cone((A → 0 → 0 → A) → A) ∼ =0→0→A = A[−2],
(11)
where we use the convention of [4] by underlining the zero position when necessary. Such a transformation cannot be argued from -stability however. Clearly an open string between A and itself (perhaps translated) cannot have a mass that depends upon some angle as we orbit the conifold point as clearly the mass is constant. Instead one could argue that the transform (11) occurs simply because Z(A) has a simple zero at the conifold point and thus ϕ(A) shifts by −2 as we loop around the conifold point. Then we can apply the rule ϕ(A[n]) = ϕ(A) + n from [12].4 We must therefore view (8) as being motivated by -stability for most but not all of the objects in D(X). Note that the fact that the obvious physical requirement that monodromy be an autoequivalence of D(X) can force (8) to be the required transform for all the objects in D(X) once -stability has established it for a few elements. This was the basis of the proof in the case of the quintic in [12]. Anyway, all said we have motivated the following conjecture (which, in perhaps a slightly different form, is due to Kontsevich [6], Horja [7] and Morrison [23]): Conjecture 1. If we loop around a component of the discriminant locus associated with a single D-brane A (and thus its translates) becoming massless then this results in a relabeling of D-branes given by an autoequivalence of the derived category in which B becomes Cone(hom(A, B) ⊗ A → B). This transformation was also motivated by its relation to mirror symmetry and studied at length by Seidel and Thomas [20]. 3 Pedants will object that the cone construction is only defined up to a non-canonical isomorphism making the transformation on morphisms badly-defined. Fortunately, as is well-known and we discuss at length in Sect. 3, this transformation can be written as a Fourier–Mukai transform removing this objection. 4 In [17] it was suggested that the monodromy action on the derived category should be translated by 2 to undo this action on A. Since monodromy is a relabeling process, one is free to do this, but it looks unnatural from the perspective of associating monodromy with -stability.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
51
2.2. General monodromies. It is then natural to ask what happens more generally, i.e., if more than just a single D-brane A becomes massless. In order to answer this we need to set up a general description of how one might analyze monodromy in a multi-dimensional moduli space. There are two paradigms for monodromy — both of which are useful: 1. The discriminant locus decomposes into a sum of irreducible divisors. Pick some base point in the moduli space and loop around a component of the discriminant “close” to the base point. 2. Restrict attention to a special rational curve C in the moduli space. This rational curve contains two “phase limit points”, in a sense to be described below, and a single point in the discriminant. The loop in question is around this unique discriminant point. In the case of the one parameter models, such as the quintic, these two paradigms coincide. The moduli space is C ∼ = P1 and the discriminant locus is a single point. If a component of the discriminant intersects C transversely then we can again have agreement between these two pictures of monodromy. In general the discriminant need not intersect C transversely — a fact we use to our advantage in Sect. 2.3. We now recall the relationship between the discriminant locus and phases as analyzed in [24, 25]. The following is a very rapid review. Please refer to the references for more details. To make the discussion easier we suffer a little loss of generality and assume we are in the “Batyrev-like” [26] case X being a hypersurface in a toric variety. The data for X is then presented in the form of a point set A which is the intersection of some convex polytope with some lattice N . See [27], for example, for more details of this standard construction. The conformal field theory associated to this data then has a phase structure where each “phase” is associated to a regular triangulation of A [28, 29]. The real vector space in which the K¨ahler form lives is naturally divided into a “secondary fan” of all possible phases. One cone of this fan is the K¨ahler cone for X where we have the “Calabi–Yau” phase. Mirror to X, Y is described as the zero-set of a polynomial W in many variables. The points in A are associated one-to-one with each monomial in W . Thus the data A is associated to deformations of complex structure of Y via the monomial-divisor mirror map [30]. If we model the moduli space of complex structures on Y by the space of coefficients in W , then the discriminant locus can be computed by the failure of W to be transversal. This can be mapped back to the space of complexified K¨ahler forms on X. The result is that part of the discriminant asymptotically lives in each wall dividing adjacent phases in the space of K¨ahler forms. That is to say, if we tune the B-field suitably we can always hit a bad conformal field theory as we pass from one phase to another. Thus we may associate singular conformal field theories with phase transitions. The discriminant itself is generically reducible. The combinatorial structure of this reduction has been studied in detail in [31]. In particular, any time an m-dimensional face of the convex hull of the set A contains more than m + 1 points, the resulting linear relationship between these points yields a component of . One may then follow an algorithm presented in [25] to compute the explicit form of each component. The general picture then is of a discriminant with many components with each component having “fingers” which separate the phases from each other. Each phase transition is associated with fingers from one or more component of . Torically each maximal cone in the secondary fan is associated to a point in the moduli space which gives the limit point in the “deep interior” of the associated phase.
52
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
The real codimension-one wall between two maximal cones corresponds to a rational curve C passing through two such limit points. The rational curve C will intersect the discriminant locus in one point as promised earlier in this section. One component of is distinguished — it corresponds to the case of viewing the full convex hull as a face of itself. This is called the “primary” component of . Closely tied in with Conjecture 1 (and at least partially attributed to the same authors) is the following conjecture: Conjecture 2. At any point on the primary component of (reached by a suitable path from a suitable basepoint) the 6-brane associated with the structure sheaf OX and its translates become massless. At a generic point no other D-branes become massless. This idea was perhaps first discussed in [32]. It is certainly a very natural conjecture — the primary component of the discriminant is a universal feature for any Calabi–Yau manifold and so must be associated with the masslessness of a very basic D-brane. The fact that it works for the quintic was explicitly computed in [12], and presumably it is possible to verify the conjecture in a much larger class of examples. We will assume this conjecture to be true. The K¨ahler cone is a particular maximal cone in the secondary fan corresponding to the “Calabi–Yau” phase. Let us concentrate on the walls of the K¨ahler cone. A typical situation as we approach the wall of the K¨ahler cone is that an exceptional set E collapses to some space Z. We depict this as
E
i
/X
(12)
q
Z
where i is an inclusion (which may well be the identity) and q is a fibration with a strict inequality dim(E) > dim(Z). Associated with such a wall in the secondary fan we have a rational curve C in the moduli space connecting the large radius limit point with some other limit point. We wish to consider the monodromy associated to circling the point in the discriminant in C. The resulting autoequivalence on the derived category has been studied in [8] where it was dubbed an “EZ-transformation”. The simplest example would be the case of the quintic Calabi–Yau threefold which has only one deformation of the K¨ahler form. This single component of the K¨ahler form gives the overall size of the manifold. Thus the “wall” (i.e., the origin) corresponds to X collapsing to a point. In this case i is the identity map and Z is a point. This is the case discussed above in Sect. 2.1. Indeed, it appears that in all cases where Z is a point, the resulting monodromy amounts to a transform of the type studied in Sect. 2.1. It is precisely when Z is more than just a point the case of interest to us. 2.3. New monodromies from old. The precise form of the “EZ-monodromy conjecture” which associates an autoequivalence of D(X) with a given EZ-transform was given in [8]. Rather than appealing this conjecture, let us derive the simplest example of a more general case, by assuming the conjectures above, dealing with the case of a single massless D-brane.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
53
We will look at the well-known example [33], where X is a degree 8 hypersurface in the resolution of a weighted projective space P4{2,2,2,1,1} . The mirror Y is then a quotient of the same hypersurface with defining equation a0 z1 z2 z3 z4 z5 + a1 z14 + a2 z24 + a3 z34 + a4 z48 + a5 z58 + a6 z44 z44 .
(13)
The “algebraic” coordinates on the moduli space are then given by a 4 a5 . a62
(14)
0 = (1 − 28 x)2 − 218 x 2 y.
(15)
x=
a1 a2 a3 a6 , a04
y=
The primary component of can be computed as
The edge of the convex hull containing the points labeled by a4 , a5 , a6 leads to another component 1 = 1 − 4y,
(16)
with = 0 1 . X can be viewed as a K3-fibration π : X → P1 . In this case the component of the 1 K¨ahler form given asymptotically (for x, y 1) by 2πi log(x) controls the size of the 1 K3 fibre. The component of the K¨ahler form given asymptotically by 2πi log(y) gives the size of the P1 base. The base P1 is made very large by setting y → 0. In this case, we hit the primary component 0 of the discriminant when x = 2−8 . Let us refer to this point as P1 . Increasing x beyond this value moves one out of the Calabi–Yau phase into the hybrid “P1 -phase” where the model is best viewed as a fibration with base P1 and a Landau– Ginzburg orbifold as fibre [29]. Fixing y = 0 and varying x spans a rational curve C in the moduli space shown in Fig. 1. We would like to analyze the monodromy around the singularity P1 in Fig. 1. Clearly the transition associated with this monodromy consists of collapsing X onto the P1 base. In the language of (12), E = X, i.e., the inclusion map i is the identity, and Z ∼ = P1 . The map q is given by the fibration map π. In a way, we have constructed the simplest possible example where Z is more than just a point.
Large Radius Limit ( x = 0)
Calabi-Yau Singularity P1 ( x = 1/256) Hybrid P
1
H x=∞
Fig. 1. Moduli Space for y = 0
54
Hybrid Limit
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
L
P1
C
Large Radius Limit
H ∆0
K
Fig. 2. Full Moduli Space around P1
Now the useful trick is that the monodromy around the singularity in Fig. 1 can be written in terms of other monodromies that we already understand. This was originally described in [33], while this feature was also exploited in [7, 34]. The full moduli space near P1 is shown in Fig. 2 (with complex dimensions shown as real). The rational curve C given by y = 0 corresponds to an infinite radius limit and as such we understand the monodromy around it (see for example [7, 34]). (We will follow closely the notation and analysis of [34]). Let L refer to the autoequivalence of D(X) we apply upon looping this curve. It follows that L(B) = B ⊗ OX (S),
(17)
where S is the divisor class of a K3 fibre in X. Meanwhile let K refer to the autoequivalence of D(X) we apply upon looping the primary component 0 = 0 (i.e., denote KOX of Sect. 2.1 by K). Then from Conjectures 1 and 2 we know that K(B) = Cone(hom(OX , B) ⊗ OX → B).
(18)
It follows (see, for example Sect. 5.1 of [34] for an essentially identical computation) that the autoequivalence for the desired loop shown in Fig. 1 around P1 is given by L−1 KLK.
(19)
The desired goal therefore is to find the autoequivalence of D(X) obtained by combining the transforms in the above form. The result is that L−1 KLK = H,
(20)
where H is an autoequivalence that acts on D(X) by H(B) = Cone(π ∗ π∗ B → B).
(21)
Section 3 is devoted to the proof of this statement. Let us review briefly what is exactly meant by the rather concise notation of (21). Given the map π : X → Z and a sheaf E on X we may construct the “push-forward” sheaf π∗ E on Z by associating π∗ E (U ) with E (π −1 U ) for any open set U ⊂ Z. The π∗ appearing in (21) is the right-derived functor of this push-forward map. This π∗ “knows” about the cohomology of the fibre of π (see, for example, Chapter III of [35]). The pull-back map π ∗ is defined for sheaves of OZ -modules, and in particular for locally free sheaves, and thus for vector bundles.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
55
The map π ∗ appearing in (21) is the corresponding left-derived functor. It is a central result of the theory of derived categories [36] that π ∗ is the left-adjoint of π∗ : HomX (π ∗ E, F) ∼ = HomZ (E, π∗ F),
(22)
for any E ∈ D(Z) and F ∈ D(X). It follows that HomX (π ∗ π∗ B, B) ∼ = HomZ (π∗ B, π∗ B).
(23)
Thus the most natural morphism that would appear in (21) is the image of the identity on the right-hand side of Eq. (23) under this natural isomorphism. One can show that this is indeed the case. 2.4. Interpretation of monodromy. Let us interpret (21) in light of our discussion of monodromy from -stability in Sect. 2.1. To aid our discussion consider how one might rewrite the monodromy result (18) for the primary component of the discriminant. Let c : X → x be the constant map of X to a single point. One can then show, using the fact that sheaf cohomology is equivalent to c∗ , which, in turn, is also given by the global section functor Hom(OX , −) [35], that (18) is equivalent to K(B) = Cone(c∗ c∗ B → B).
(24)
Now, the only D-brane (up to translation in D(X)) which becomes massless in this case is OX , which is equal to c∗ C, where we denote the trivial (very trivial!) line bundle on the point x as C. That is, massless D-branes for the primary component of the discriminant are given by c∗ (something). The c∗ in (24) then gives a natural map to form a cone as required. The expression (10) immediately dictates that we may interpret Cone(π ∗ π∗ B → B) in a similar way. The D-branes becoming massless at the point P1 in the moduli space correspond to π ∗ z for some z ∈ D(Z). The push-forward map π∗ can be viewed as the natural ingredient required to form the cone from (23). There is one technical subtlety here which needs to be mentioned. The set of objects of the form π ∗ z for any z ∈ D(Z) is not closed under composition by the cone construction. If we write C = Cone(f : π ∗ a → π ∗ b),
(25)
for two objects a, b ∈ D(Z), then we may only write C = π ∗ Cone(f : a → b),
(26)
when there is a relationship between the morphisms f = π ∗ f . Unfortunately such an f need not exist for arbitrary f . Thus we might more properly say that the set of massless D-branes are generated by objects of the form π ∗ z, where we allow for composing such states. Flushed with success at interpreting the autoequivalence given by this example we now write down the most obvious generalization for the more general EZ-transform (12). First of all, we expect q ∗ (something) to be a massless D-brane on E. E is mapped into X by the inclusion map i. The push-forward map i∗ is then “extension by zero” of a sheaf which is the obvious way of mapping D-branes on E into D-branes on X. Our next conjecture is then
56
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
Conjecture 3. Any D-Brane which becomes massless at a point on a component of the discriminant associated with an EZ-transform is generated by objects of the form i∗ q ∗ z for z ∈ D(Z). This implies a corresponding autoequivalence for the monodromy from -stability: B → Cone(i∗ q ∗ ζ B → B),
(27)
for some “natural” map ζ : D(X) → D(Z). To compute ζ we use the same trick as (23). Introduce the functor “i ! ” as the right-adjoint of i∗ : HomX (i∗ E, F) ∼ = HomE (E, i ! F),
(28)
for any E ∈ D(E) and F ∈ D(X). The existence of i ! is one of the most important features of the derived category in algebraic geometry [36] and (28) may be regarded as a generalization of Serre Duality. Now we have HomX (i∗ i ! B, B) ∼ = HomE (i ! B, i ! B).
(29)
This leads to a natural map i∗ q ∗ q∗ i ! B → i∗ i ! B → B. This implies Conjecture 4. The monodromy around the discriminant in the wall associated to a phase transition given by an EZ-transform leads to the following autoequivalence on D(X): B → Cone(i∗ q ∗ q∗ i ! B → B).
(30)
This is equivalent to the EZ-monodromy conjecture of [8]. In particular, it was proven there that this is indeed an autoequivalence of D(X). We should perhaps emphasize that we have not proven Conjectures 3 and 4. Rather we have used the known connection between -stability and monodromy and generalized the example we considered in the simplest and most obvious way. Note that we may derive Conjecture 1 from Conjectures 3 and 4 as follows. Suppose Z is a point, then i∗ q ∗ z can only be one thing, so we have a single massless D-brane. Furthermore, q∗ now becomes the cohomology functor giving i∗ q ∗ q∗ i ! B = i∗ (homE (OE , i ! B) ⊗ OE ) = homX (i∗ OE , B) ⊗ i∗ OE .
(31)
This also shows that the massless D-brane is i∗ OE — i.e., the D-brane wrapping around E as observed in [2, 10, 37]. For completeness we should also obtain the monodromy as one circles the discriminant in the opposite direction. Going back to the triangle (4) we see that decreasing θ would result in C being replaced by B = Cone(C → A[1])[−1]. This implies we modify the above monodromy arguments to consider the transformation under which C → Cone(C → i∗ q ∗ ηC)[−1],
(32)
for some “natural” map η : D(X) → D(Z). That is, the massless objects bind “to the right” of C in the mapping cone rather than to the left. The “[−1]” is needed because of the asymmetrical definition of the mapping cone — we need to keep C in its original position.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
57
The only nontrivial step in copying the above argument is that to construct η we need a left-adjoint functor for q ∗ . Given that q ! F = q ∗ F ⊗ q ! OZ we can construct such a functor from HomE (E, q ∗ F) = HomE (E ⊗ q ! OZ , q ! F) = HomZ (q∗ (E ⊗ q ! OZ ), F). Thus our desired transform is given by C → Cone C → i∗ q ∗ q∗ (i ∗ C ⊗ q ! OZ ) [−1].
(33)
(34)
It was shown in [8] that this is indeed the inverse of the transformation given in Conjecture 4. 3. Composing Transforms In this section we will prove (20). For completeness, we choose to adopt a more general point of view and work with the class of Calabi–Yau fibrations over projective spaces. Thus we cover examples such as elliptic fibrations over P2 as discussed in Sect. 4.3, as well as the case of K3 fibrations over P1 as desired in Sect. 2.3. Readers not familiar with manipulations in the derived category may well wish to accept the result and skip this section. Having said that, some of the methods used in this section are very powerful and may have many other applications to D-brane physics. For the sake of brevity we use the formalism of kernels to describe the Fourier-Mukai transforms. For the convenience of the reader we review some of the key notions involved. The notations follow those of [8]. For X a non-singular projective variety, an object G ∈ D(X × X) determines an exact functor of triangulated categories G : D(X) → D(X) by the formula G (−) := p2∗ (G ⊗ p1∗ (−)),
(35)
where p1 : X × X → X is projection on the first factor, while p2 is projection on the second factor. The object G ∈ D(X × X) is called the kernel. The convenience in using kernels comes about because of the following natural isomorphism of functors: G G ∼ = G ◦ G . The composition of the kernels G , G ∈ D(X × X) is defined as ∗ ∗ G G := p13∗ p23 (G ) ⊗ p12 (G) ,
(36)
(37)
where pij is the obvious projection from X×X×X to the relevant two factors. There is an identity element for the composition of kernels: (X )∗ (OX ), where X : X → X × X is the diagonal morphism. In this section X is assumed to be a smooth Calabi–Yau fibration of dimension n over Z ∼ = Pd , with π : X → Z the fibration map. For us, the Calabi–Yau fibration structure simply means that π : X → Z is a flat morphism (see Sect. III.9 of [35]) with the generic fibre a Calabi–Yau variety of dimension n − d. Further assumptions on the Calabi–Yau fibration will be added shortly.
58
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
In order to set the functors L, K and H of the previous section on firm mathematical footing and to define them in the more general context of this section, we need to describe the kernels that induce them as exact functors according to formula (35). The following commutative diagram contains most of the maps that we use in the sequel: X _
(38)
j
p2 /X X×X E E z EE z EE π zz π1 zz EE 2 z π π π×π EE z z EE z z E z E" |zz / Z. Z × Z Zo s1 s2 Xo
p1
The maps are mostly projections, that are obvious from the context, except for j := X : X → X × X the diagonal of X and π : X → Z the fibration map. We now define the Fourier–Mukai functor L to be the autoequivalence of D(X) induced by the kernel L = j∗ (π ∗ OZ (1)). This functor acts on D(X) by (compare to (17)) L(B) = B ⊗ π ∗ OZ (1).
(39)
Note that the use of the notation L for this functor is consistent with the one used in the previous section, since in the case when X is a K3 fibration over Z ∼ = P1 we have ∗ OX (S) = π OZ (1). We also define the exact functor K induced by the kernel K = Cone(OX×X → O ), with O := j∗ OX and OX×X → O the natural restriction map. We can quote for example Lemma 3.2 of [20] to conclude that the action of this functor on D(X) is indeed given by (18). We make the assumption that the sheaf OX is spherical (as defined in Sect. 2.1). This ensures that the functor K is an autoequivalence of D(X). Finally, we define the exact functor H to be the so-called fibrewise Fourier– Mukai transform associated to the Calabi–Yau fibration π : X → Z (see, for example, [20, 38, 39]). The functor H is induced by the kernel H = Cone(OX×Z X → O ), with OX×Z X viewed as a sheaf on X × X (extension by zero), and OX×Z X → O the restriction map. To ensure that the functor H is indeed an autoequivalence (Fourier–Mukai functor), we assume that the sheaf OX is EZ–spherical. In the language of [8], this means that there exists a distinguished triangle in D(Z) (Z ∼ = Pd ) of the form5 OZ → π∗ OX → OZ (−d − 1)[−n + d] → OZ [1].
(40)
Note that the sphericity and EZ-sphericity conditions are both satisfied in the specific example of a K3 fibration over P1 analyzed in the previous section of this paper. We now justify the use of the notation H to denote the fibrewise Fourier–Mukai functor by showing that its action on D(X) is indeed, even in the higher dimensional situation, given by the formula (21) of the previous section. 5
Lemma 3.12 in [20], as well as Example 3.3 of [8] provide sufficient conditions for (40) to hold.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
59
The fibre product X ×Z X fits in the fibre square diagram X×Z X
q1
q2
X
/X
(41)
π
π
/ Z,
and let k : X ×Z X → X × X denote the canonical embedding. Since π is of finite type and flat, we can apply “cohomology commutes with the base change” (Prop. III 9.3 of [35] or for a more general form Prop. II 5.12 of [36]): π ∗ π∗ B ∼ = q2∗ q1∗ B,
(42)
for some B in D(X). On the other hand, q1 = p1 ◦ k, and q2 = p2 ◦ k, so we can write π ∗ π∗ B ∼ = q2∗ q1∗ B ∼ = p2∗ k∗ k ∗ p1∗ B ∼ = p2∗ (k∗ OX×Z X ⊗ p1∗ B).
(43)
Note that the last line in the previous formula represents the action on D(X) of the exact functor OX×Z X induced as in (35) by the kernel OX×Z X (shorthand for k∗ OX×Z X ). This shows that H(B) = Cone( OX×Z X (B) → B) = Cone(π ∗ π∗ B → B) as desired. We are now ready to start discussing the main goal of this section which is to prove the following relation between the defined Fourier–Mukai functors: (L−d KLd ) . . . (L−1 KL)K ∼ = H.
(44)
Equivalently, the same formula can be expressed using kernels as (L−d K Ld ) . . . (L−1 K L) K ∼ = H,
(45)
where, for any integer i, Li = j∗ (π ∗ OZ (i)). Of course, the case d = 1 (Z ∼ = P1 ) of (44) is precisely formula (20) of the previous section. Before we move on with the technicalities of the proof, a few remarks are in order. Note that the parentheses in the two formulae are simply decorative: the composition of functors, as well as the composition of kernels are associative (but, of course, not commutative!). For a fixed object G in D(X × X), the functors G − and − G from D(X × X) to D(X × X) are exact functors between triangulated categories (i.e. they preserve the distinguished triangles). Therefore, for any integer i, we can start with the distinguished triangle defining the kernel K, OX×X → O → K → OX×X [1],
(46)
and apply to it the operations L−i − and − Li from the left, and right, respectively. But L−i OX×X Li ∼ = (π × π )∗ (OZ (−i) OZ (i)), = π2∗ OZ (−i) ⊗ π1∗ OZ (i) ∼
(47)
and L−i O Li ∼ = O .
(48)
60
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
The notation OZ (−i) OZ (i) (the exterior tensor product) will be used quite often in what follows and simply designates s2∗ OZ (−i) ⊗ s1∗ OZ (i). As a shorthand for later convenience we introduce the following objects in D(X×X) : Ti := (π × π)∗ (OZ (−i) OZ (i)) ∼ = π2∗ OZ (−i) ⊗ π1∗ OZ (i)
(49)
Ci := L−i K Li ∼ = Cone(Ti → O ),
(50)
and
for i ∈ Z. To justify the definition of the kernel Ci , we need to explain how to define the morphism Ti → O . We start with the canonical pairing map on Z × Z, OZ (−i) OZ (i) → OZ ,
(51)
(π × π)∗ (OZ (−i) OZ (i)) → (π × π )∗ (OZ ).
(52)
(π × π)∗ (OZ ) ∼ = OX×Z X .
(53)
and lift it to X × X ,
We claim that
Indeed, for the fibre square X ×Z X _
t
/Z
π×π
/ Z×Z
Z
k
X×X
(54)
with t : X ×Z X → Z the “diagonal map” of the fibre square (41), and π × π flat, we can apply again “cohomology commutes with the base change” to obtain (π × π )∗ (Z )∗ OZ = k∗ t ∗ OZ . Since t ∗ OZ = OX×Z X , the previous formula can be written as (π × π )∗ (Z )∗ OZ = OX×Z X , which is exactly (53). The morphism Ti → O is then defined as the composition Ti ∼ = OX×Z X → O . = (π × π )∗ (OZ (−i) OZ (i)) → (π × π)∗ (OZ ) ∼
(55)
Note that C0 ∼ = K. Therefore we have to show that Cd . . . C1 C0 ∼ = H.
(56)
Note that the case d = 0 is immediate since in that case Z reduces to a point, and the Fourier–Mukai transforms H and K coincide. An important rˆole in what follows will be played by Beilinson’s resolution of the diagonal in Z × Z ∼ = Pd × Pd [40], 0 → OZ (−d) dZ (d) → . . . → OZ (−1) 1Z (1) → OZ×Z → OZ → 0, (57) where iZ is the sheaf of holomorphic i-forms on Pd .
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
61
For any integer i, 0 ≤ i ≤ d, we define the complexes Si on Z ×Z to be the following truncated versions of Beilinson’s resolution 0 → OZ (−i) iZ (i) → . . . → OZ (−1) 1Z (1) → OZ×Z → 0,
(58)
arranged such that the sheaf OZ×Z is located at the 0th position. Define Si := (π × π)∗ (Si ).
(59)
We claim that there exists a natural map 6 Si → O ,
(60)
that can be defined at the level of complexes, where, as usual, O denotes the complex on X × X with the only non-zero component located at the 0th position. To see this, we first make the remark that there exists a map of complexes Si → OZ . Such a map of complexes is well defined, since the complex Si is a piece of Beilinson’s resolution. We can now proceed as in (55) and define the desired morphism in D(X × X) as the composition Si = (π × π)∗ (Si ) → (π × π)∗ (OZ ) ∼ = OX×Z X → O .
(61)
The key result to be proved in this section is the following: Claim. For any integer i, 0 ≤ i ≤ d, Ci . . . C1 C0 ∼ = Cone(Si → O ).
(62)
Before proving it, let us convince ourselves that the claim implies (56). The complex Sd is quasi-isomorphic to the sheaf OZ (more precisely, to the complex on Z × Z having the sheaf OZ at the 0th position). Therefore, the i = d case of the claim states that Cd . . . C1 C0 ∼ = Cone((π × π)∗ (OZ ) → O ).
(63)
Since by (53) (π × π)∗ (OZ ) ∼ = OX×Z X , we see that the kernel Cd . . . C1 C0 is indeed isomorphic to H. We now proceed with the inductive proof of the claim. The induction is performed with respect to i. The case i = 0 is clear, since S0 = OZ×Z and S0 = (π ×π )∗ (OZ×Z ) = OX×X . To prove the inductive step i ⇒ (i + 1), we start with the natural maps Si → O and Ti+1 → O . Applying the functors − Si and Ti+1 − we get two more maps, and we can form the commutative square Ti+1 Si
/ Si
Ti+1
/ O .
(64)
6 In fact, by assuming that the sheaf O is EZ–spherical, it can be shown that Hom ∼ X X×X (Si , O ) = C. Therefore, the described nonzero morphism from Si to O is essentially unique.
62
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
There is a nice result due to Verdier, guaranteeing that a commuting square X
/ Y
X
/Y
(65)
extends to a “9–diagram” of the form X
/ Y
/ Z
/ X [1]
X
/Y
/Z
/ X[1]
X
/ Y
/ Z
/ X [1]
X [1]
/ Y [1]
/ Z [1]
/ X [2] ,
(66)
where all the rows and columns are distinguished triangles, every square commutes, except for the last one (containing the shift operator [2]), which anticommutes (for more details see p. 24 in [41]). Applying Verdier’s “9–diagram” construction to (64) yields Ti+1 Si
/ Si
/ Ci+1 Si
/ Ti+1 Si [1]
/ O
/ Ci+1
/ Ti+1 [1]
/ Ci . . . C0
/ Ci+1 (Ci . . . C0 )
/ Ti+1 (Ci . . . C0 )[1]
/ Si [1]
/ Ci+1 Si [1]
/ Ti+1 Si [2] .
Ti+1 Ti+1 (Ci . . . C0 ) Ti+1 Si [1]
(67)
We are interested in the term Ci+1 Ci . . . C0 . To compute it, return for a moment to the commutative diagram (66), and consider the “diagonal” map Y → Z . The axioms of a triangulated category guarantee that the morphism Y → Z can be included in a distinguished triangle of the form A → Y → Z → A[1].
(68)
A crucial piece of the proof of Verdier’s “9–diagram” (p. 24 in [41]) provides another distinguished triangle that involves A, namely A → X → Y [1] → A[1] .
(69)
Returning to diagram (67), we obtain the distinguished triangles X → O → Ci+1 Ci . . . C0 → X [1] ,
(70)
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
63
and X → Ti+1 Ci . . . C0 → Si [1] → X [1] ,
(71)
for some element X in D(X × X). We plan on using the latter triangle to compute the object X , but for that we need to first understand the term Ti+1 Ci . . . C0 . The leftmost column of diagram (67) shows that Ti+1 Ci . . . C0 ∼ = Cone(Ti+1 Si → Ti+1 ).
(72)
∗ T ∗ By definition Ti+1 Si = p13∗ (p23 i+1 ⊗ p12 Si ). After inspecting the definitions of the kernels Ti+1 and Si , it is not hard to see that computing Ti+1 Si requires the calculation of kernels of the type j ∗ ∗ (π3∗ OZ (−i − 1) ⊗ π2∗ OZ (i + 1)) ⊗ p12 (π2∗ OZ (−j ) ⊗ π1∗ Z (j ))) ∼ p13∗ (p23 = j ∗ ∗ ∼ (73) = (π × π ) OZ (−i − 1) (j ) ⊗ ( X )∗ (π OZ (i + 1 − j )) , Z
with 0 ≤ j ≤ i, and X : X → {pt} the projection to a point. But ( X )∗ (π ∗ OZ (i + 1 − j )) ∼ = ( Z )∗ (π∗ OX ⊗ OZ (i + 1 − j )). Since OX is EZ– spherical, the long exact cohomology sequence induced by the distinguished triangle (40) implies that ( Z )∗ (π∗ OX ⊗ OZ (i + 1 − j )) ∼ = HomZ (OZ , OZ (i + 1 − j )).
(74)
Summing up our work, we can conclude that Cone(Ti+1 Si → Ti+1 ) ∼ = (π × π)∗ (OZ (−i − 1) Ui ),
(75)
where Ui is the following complex in D(Z) : 0 → iZ (i) ⊗ HomZ (OZ , OZ (i + 1 − i)) j
→ . . . → Z (j ) ⊗ HomZ (OZ , OZ (i + 1 − j )) → . . . → 1Z (1) ⊗ HomZ (OZ , OZ (i + 1 − 1)) → OZ ⊗ HomZ (OZ , OZ (i + 1)) → OZ (i + 1) → 0,
(76)
arranged such that the sheaf OZ (i + 1) is located at the 0th position. But what is the complex Ui after all? Again the answer can be obtained by employing Beilinson’s resolution. Consider the following two quasi-isomorphic complexes obtained by truncating (57) at the appropriate place: 0 → dZ (d) OZ (−d) → . . . → i+1 Z (i + 1) OZ (−i − 1) → 0, 0 → iZ (i) OZ (−i) → . . . → OZ×Z → OZ → 0,
(77)
arranged such that the sheaf OZ in the second complex is located at the 0th position th (and, as a result, the sheaf i+1 Z (i + 1) OZ (−i − 1) is located at the (−i − 1) position in the first complex). Call these complexes Ai and Bi , respectively.
64
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
On one hand, the well known properties of the cohomology groups of the projective space Z ∼ = Pd , give that s2∗ (Bi ⊗ s1∗ OZ (i + 1)) ∼ = Ui .
(78)
On the other hand, the same cohomology properties give that s2∗ (Ai ⊗ s1∗ OZ (i + 1)) ∼ = i+1 Z (i + 1)[i + 1].
(79)
But Bi and Ai are quasi-isomorphic (i.e. isomorphic in D(Z × Z)), hence Ui ∼ = i+1 Z (i + 1)[i + 1],
(80)
and Ti+1 Ci . . . C0 ∼ = Cone(Ti+1 Si → Ti+1 ) ∗ ∼ = (π × π) (OZ (−i − 1) i+1 (i + 1))[i + 1] . Z
(81)
The distinguished triangle (71) and the definition (59) of the complexes Si show that in fact our unknown complex X is nothing else but Si+1 . The proof by induction of the main claim of this section is then finished by invoking the distinguished triangle (70). 4. Applications 4.1. Z is a point. It was discussed above that the case of Z being a point amounts to a single D-brane becoming massless. This is the case originally studied by Strominger in [14] and yielding monodromy of the form studied in detail by Seidel and Thomas [20]. There are three possibilities: 1. E = X in which case we are looking at the primary component of the discriminant. The quintic was studied at length in [12]. 2. E is a complex surface of codimension one in X. This could arise from the blow-up of an isolated quotient singularity. This was studied for example in [37]. 3. E is a rational curve. This is the flop case and was studied in [13]. 4.2. Z is a curve. Now we have an infinite number of massless D-branes arising from the derived category of an algebraic curve. There are two possibilities: 1. E = X in which case X is a K3-fibration and Z ∼ = P1 . This is the case we studied in Sect. 2. 2. E is a ruled surface arising from blowing up a curve of quotient singularities in X. In either case we are essentially looking at nonperturbatively enhanced gauge symmetry [42, 43]. Putting z = Op for some point p ∈ Z we obtain a soliton q ∗ z = OF which is the structure sheaf of a single fibre F of the map q. These correspond to the charged vector bosons responsible for the enhanced gauge symmetry. Clearly these bosons classically have a moduli space given by Z since p may vary in Z. Upon including quantum effects this leads to a number of massless hypermultiplets in the theory given by the genus of Z [43, 44].
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
65
Putting z = OZ we obtain q ∗ z = OX which corresponds to one of the massless monopoles. In fact we may analyze the complete spectrum of solitons in Seiberg–Witten theory [45] by using the “geometric engineering” approach of [46] to “zoom in” on the point in the moduli space where the nonabelian gauge symmetry appears. We will explain exactly what happens in detail in [15]. It is worth speculating that such analysis of Seiberg–Witten theory may shed some light on the “local mirror symmetry” story of papers such as [47]. The massless B-type D-branes associated with the derived category of Z may be related to the A-type D-brane story of [48] by some kind of local homological mirror symmetry. 4.3. Z is a surface. There is only one possibility, namely X = E is an elliptic fibration over Z. We will denote this fibration π : X → S. Let z ∈ D(S) correspond to the skyscraper sheaf of a point s ∈ S. Then π ∗ z ∈ D(X) corresponds to the structure sheaf of an elliptic fibre e ⊂ X over s. Let us consider the case where the size of S becomes infinite. According to our rules then, the 2-brane wrapping e should become massless when we hit the discriminant moving from the large radius phase to the phase where the elliptic fibres such as e have collapsed. At first sight this looks peculiar. One does not usually expect a 2-brane wrapped around a 2-torus to become massless for a particular radius of the torus! Actually we will argue that this indeed happens and that it is when the 2-torus is zero sized that the 2-brane becomes massless. Why T-duality doesn’t interfere with this will become apparent.7 As a specific example let X be given by the following equation in P4{9,6,1,1,1} : x12 + x23 + x318 + x418 + x518 .
(82)
This has a quotient singularity which may be resolved with an exceptional divisor P2 . One may regard [x3 , x4 , x5 ] as homogeneous coordinates on this S ∼ = P2 . Fixing a point 2 on S one then has an elliptic fibre e given by a sextic in P{3,2,1} . See, for example, [49] for more details about such fibrations. The moduli space of interest to us regards the area of e. This area is infinite for the Calabi–Yau limit point and shrinks down as we approach the other limit point. For a more precise statement let us consider the mirror e˜ of e given by the following equation in P2{3,2,1} : 1
x12 + x23 + x36 + 432 6 ψx1 x2 x3 .
(83)
Varying the size of e is then mirror to varying the complex structure of e˜ by varying ψ. Going through the usual story of solving the Picard–Fuchs equation and using the mirror map to map back to the B + iJ plane for e we obtain the shaded region in Fig. 3. The result is that for the Calabi–Yau limit point we √ have ψ → ∞ and thus J → ∞ as expected. For the other limit point ψ = 0 and J = 3/2. The discriminant is given by ψ = 1 and corresponds to J = 0, i.e., e has zero area. This is where the 2-branes wrapping e (and all the other D-branes given by π ∗ z for z ∈ D(S)) become massless. So what about T-duality for e? Note that the moduli space in Fig. 3 corresponds to two fundamental regions for the action of SL(2, Z) on the upper-half plane. T-duality 7
We are grateful to R. Plesser for an invaluable discussion on this point.
66
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
ψ
∞
ψ =0 ψ =1 Fig. 3. Moduli Space for Elliptic Curve
should map the point at ψ = 1 to the point at ψ = ∞. It is important to remember however that T-duality does not act only upon e — one must also shift the string dilaton by an amount related to the resulting change in the area of the torus. As such, the point at ψ = 1 is related to ψ = ∞ only with the string coupling shifted off to infinity, implying again that the D-brane mass is zero. Therefore if we fix the dilaton to be a finite value we cannot use T-duality to relate ψ = 1 to any large radius torus. This explains why we really do have a massless 2-brane appearing wrapped around a zero-sized torus. Note also that if we allow the base S ∼ = P2 to have finite size then the T-duality group ceases to exist anyway as in [50]. The fact that there is a T-duality relating ψ = ∞ to ψ = 1 shows that their physics must be similar. In particular ψ = 1 must be an infinite distance away in the moduli space. Indeed, in many respects the spectrum of stable D-branes at ψ = 1, coming from the derived category of P2 , must be similar to the spectrum one would see upon going to a large radius limit. It would be interesting to investigate this in more detail and generality. 4.4. The Exoflop. Finally let us note that not all the walls of the K¨ahler cone correspond directly to some subspace E collapsing to Z. Even so, it appears that we can still fit many, if not all examples into the general EZ language. We illustrate this with an “exoflop”. Let X be the degree 12 hypersurface in P4{3,3,3,2,1} . Its mirror, Y , then has defining equation a0 z1 z2 z3 z4 z5 + a1 z14 + a2 z24 + a3 z34 + a4 z46 + a5 z512 + a6 z42 z58 + a7 z44 z54 ,
(84)
and we may use the following algebraic coordinates on the moduli space of complex structures of Y : x=
a1 a2 a3 a62 a04 a5
,
y=
a 4 a6 , a72
z=
a 5 a7 . a62
(85)
We have chosen coordinates so that the K¨ahler cone of X appears naturally as a positive octant in the secondary fan. In particular this means that the 3 rational curves
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
67
in the moduli space connecting the large radius limit to each of the three neighbouring phase limit points are given by setting x = y = 0, x = z = 0 or y = z = 0 respectively. The discriminant has two components given by 0 = −1 − 64x + 768xz + 32768x 2 z − 196608x 2 z2 − 4194304x 3 z2 + 294912x 2 yz2 +16777216x 3 (yz2 + z3 ) − 75497472x 3 yz3 + 113246208x 3 y 2 z4 (86) and 1 = −1 + 4y + 4z − 18yz + 27y 2 z2 .
(87)
The phase transition of interest occurs for the rational curve C for which y = z = 0. For small x we are in the Calabi–Yau phase. For large x the Calabi–Yau X undergoes an “exoflop” [51]. That is X becomes reducible with one component consisting of a threefold with a singularity. The other component consists of a fibration of a Landau– Ginzburg orbifold theory over a P1 . These components intersect at a point which is the singularity in the threefold component. This then is not an EZ transformation. Note however that the discriminant 0 inter1 sects C transversely at (x, y, z) = (− 64 , 0, 0) and so the monodromy within C is exactly given by monodromy around the primary component of the discriminant. Therefore exactly one D-brane becomes massless at the transition point — the D6-brane wrapping X. This exoflop transition is equivalent, as far as monodromy is concerned, to an EZ transformation with X = E and Z given by a point. This is not entirely surprising given the following. Classically one would describe the exoflop wall of the K¨ahler cone as a wall where X J 3 = 0. Thus the classical volume of X is going to zero, even though the volume of some surfaces and curves within X, as measured by the K¨ahler form, do not vanish. Since the volume of X vanishes, one should expect the D6-brane to have vanishing mass. The fact that no other D-branes become massless is not obvious. It would be interesting to show that all phase transitions give rise to monodromies that can be associated with EZ transformations. Acknowledgements. It is a pleasure to thank J. Distler, D. Morrison and R. Plesser for useful conversations. P.S.A. is supported in part by NSF grant DMS-0074072 and by a research fellowship from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. R.L.K. was partly supported by NSF grants DMS-9983320 and DMS-0074072.
References 1. Kontsevich, M.: Homological Algebra of Mirror Symmetry. In: “Proceedings of the International Congress of Mathematicians”, Basel-Boston: Birkh¨auser, 1995, pp. 120–139 2. Douglas, M. R.: D-Branes, Categories and N=1 Supersymmetry. J. Math. Phys. 42, 2818–2843 (2001) 3. Lazaroiu, C. I.: Unitarity, D-Brane Dynamics and D-brane Categories. JHEP 12, 031 (2001) 4. Aspinwall, P. S., Lawrence, A. E.: Derived Categories and Zero-Brane Stability. JHEP 08, 004 (2001) 5. Diaconescu, D.-E.: Enhanced D-brane Categories from String Field Theory. JHEP 06, 016 (2001) 6. Kontsevich, M.: 1996, Rutgers Lecture, unpublished 7. Horja, R. P.: Hypergeometric Functions and Mirror Symmetry in Toric Varieties. http://arxic.org/list/math.AG/9912109, 1999 8. Horja, R. P.: Derived Category Automorphisms from Mirror Symmetry. Duke Math. J. 127, 1–34 (2005) 9. Douglas, M. R., Fiol, B., R¨omelsberger, C.: Stability and BPS Branes. http://arxiv.org/list/hepth/0002037, 2000 10. Douglas, M. R., Fiol, B., Romelsberger, C.: The Spectrum of BPS Branes on a Noncompact CalabiYau. http://arxiv.org/list/hep-th/0003263, 2000
68
P.S. Aspinwall, R.P. Horja, R.L. Karp
11. 12. 13. 14.
Douglas, M. R.: Topics in D-geometry. Class. Quant. Grav. 17, 1057–1070 (2000) Aspinwall, P. S., Douglas, M. R.: D-Brane Stability and Monodromy. JHEP 05, 031 (2002) Aspinwall, P. S.: A Point’s Point of View of Stringy Geometry. JHEP 01, 002 (2003) Strominger, A.: Massless Black Holes and Conifolds in String Theory. Nucl. Phys. B451, 96–108 (1995) Aspinwall, P. S., Karp, R. L.: Solitons in Seiberg–Witten Theory and D-Branes in the Derived Category. JHEP 04, 049 (2003) Sen, A.: Tachyon Condensation on the Brane Antibrane System. JHEP 08, 012 (1998) Distler, J., Jockers, H., Park, H.: D-Brane Monodromies, Derived Categories and Boundary Linear Sigma Models. http://arxiv.org/list/hep-th/0206242, 2002 Fukaya, K.: Floer Homology and Mirror Symmetry I. AMS/IP Stud. in Adv. Math. 23, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 2001, pp. 15–43 Seidel, P.: Graded Lagrangian Submanifolds. Bull. Soc. Math. France 128, 103–149 (2000) Seidel, P., Thomas, R. P.: Braid Groups Actions on Derived Categories of Coherent Sheaves. Duke Math. J. 108, 37–108 (2001) Bridgeland, T., Maciocia, A.: Fourier-Mukai transforms for Quotient Varieties. http://arxiv.org/list/math.AG/9811101, 1998 Candelas, P., de la Ossa, X. C., Green, P. S., Parkes, L.: A Pair of Calabi–Yau Manifolds as an Exactly Soluble Superconformal Theory. Nucl. Phys. B359, 21–74 (1991) Morrison, D. R.: Geometric Aspects of Mirror Symmetry. In: Enquist, B., Schmid, W. (eds.), “Mathematics Unlimited – 2001 and Beyond”, Berlin-Heidelberg-NewYork: Springer-Verlag, 2001, pp. 899–918 Aspinwall, P. S., Greene, B. R., Morrison, D. R.: Measuring Small Distances in N = 2 Sigma Models. Nucl. Phys. B420, 184–242 (1994) Morrison, D. R., Plesser, M. R.: Summing the Instantons: Quantum Cohomology and Mirror Symmetry in Toric Varieties. Nucl. Phys. B440, 279–354 (1995) Batyrev, V. V.: Dual Polyhedra and Mirror Symmetry for Calabi–Yau Hypersurfaces in Toric Varieties. J. Alg. Geom. 3, 493–535 (1994) Aspinwall, P. S., Greene, B. R.: On the Geometric Interpretation of N = 2 Superconformal Theories. Nucl. Phys. B437, 205–230 (1995) Witten, E.: Phases of N = 2 Theories in Two Dimensions. Nucl. Phys. B403, 159–222 (1993) Aspinwall, P. S., Greene, B. R., Morrison, D. R.: Multiple Mirror Manifolds and Topology Change in String Theory. Phys. Lett. 303B, 249–259 (1993) Aspinwall, P. S., Greene, B. R., Morrison, D. R.: The Monomial-Divisor Mirror Map. Internat. Math. Res. Notices, 1993, pp. 319–338 Gelfand, I. M., Kapranov, M. M., Zelevinski, A. V.: Discriminants, Resultants and Multidimensional Determinants. Basel-Boston: Birkh¨auser, 1994 Greene, B. R., Kanter,Y.: Small Volumes in Compactified String Theory. Nucl. Phys. B497, 127–145 (1997) Candelas, P. et al.: Mirror Symmetry for Two Parameter Models — I. Nucl. Phys. B416, 481–562 (1994) Aspinwall, P. S.: Some Navigation Rules for D-brane Monodromy. J. Math. Phys. 42, 5534–5552 (2001) Hartshorne, R.: Algebraic Geometry. Graduate Texts in Mathematics 52, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer-Verlag, 1977 Hartshorne, R.: Residues and Duality. Lecture Notes in Math. 20, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Spinger-Verlag, 1966 Diaconescu, D.-E., Gomis, J.: Fractional Branes and Boundary States in Orbifold Theories. JHEP 10, 001 (2000) Bridgeland, T., Maciocia, A.: Fourier-Mukai Transforms for K3 and Elliptic Fibrations. http://arxiv.org/list/math.AG/9908022, 1999 Andreas, B., Curio, G., Hernandez Ruiperez, D., Yau, S.-T.: Fourier–Mukai Transforms and Mirror Symmetry for D-Branes on Elliptic Calabi–Yau. http://arxiv.org/list/math.AG/0012196, 2000 Beilinson, A. A.: Coherent Sheaves on Pn and Problems in Linear Algebra. Funct. Anal. Appl. 12, 214–216 (1978) Beilinson, A. A., Bernstein, J. N., Deligne, P.: Faisceaux pervers. Ast´erisque 100, (1982) Aspinwall, P. S.: Enhanced Gauge Symmetries and Calabi–Yau Threefolds. Phys. Lett. B371, 231– 237 (1996) Katz, S., Morrison, D. R., Plesser, M. R.: Enhanced Gauge Symmetry in Type II String Theory. Nucl. Phys. B477, 105–140 (1996) Witten, E.: Phase Transitions in M-Theory and F-Theory. Nucl. Phys. B471, 195–216 (1996)
15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44.
Massless D-Branes on Calabi–Yau Threefolds and Monodromy
69
45. Seiberg, N., Witten, E.: Electric - Magnetic Duality, Monopole Condensation, and Confinement in N=2 Supersymmetric Yang-Mills Theory. Nucl. Phys. B426, 19–52 (1994) (erratum-ibid. B430, 485–486 (1994)) 46. Kachru, S. et al.: Nonperturbative Results on the Point Particle Limit of N=2 Heterotic String Compactifications. Nucl. Phys. B459, 537–558 (1996) 47. Katz, S., Mayr, P., Vafa, C.: Mirror Symmetry and Exact Solution of 4D N = 2 Gauge Theories. I. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 1, 53–114 (1998) 48. Klemm, A. et al.: Self-Dual Strings and N=2 Supersymmetric Field Theory. Nucl. Phys. B477, 746–766 (1996) 49. Vafa, C., Witten, E.: Dual String Pairs With N = 1 and N = 2 Supersymmetry in Four Dimensions. In: “S-Duality and Mirror Symmetry”, Nucl. Phys. (Proc. Suppl.) B46, 225–247 (1996) 50. Aspinwall, P. S., Plesser, M. R.: T-Duality Can Fail. J. High Energy Phys. 08, 001 (1999) 51. Aspinwall, P. S., Greene, B. R., Morrison, D. R.: Calabi–Yau Moduli Space, Mirror Manifolds and Spacetime Topology Change in String Theory. Nucl. Phys. B416, 414–480 (1994) Communicated by N.A. Nekrasov
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 71–78 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1391-9
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
The First Eigenvalue of the Dirac Operator on Compact Spin Symmetric Spaces Jean-Louis Milhorat Laboratoire Jean Leray, UMR CNRS 6629, D´epartement de Math´ematiques, Universit´e de Nantes, 2, rue de la Houssini`ere, BP 92208, 44322 Nantes Cedex 03, France. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 12 February 2004 / Accepted: 21 March 2005 Published online: 8 July 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: We give a formula for the first eigenvalue of the Dirac operator acting on spinor fields of a spin compact irreducible symmetric space G/K. 1. Introduction It is well-known that symmetric spaces provide examples where detailed information on the spectrum of Laplace or Dirac operators can be obtained. Indeed, for those manifolds, the computation of the spectrum can be (theoretically) done using group theoretical methods. However the explicit computation is far from being simple in general and only a few examples are known. On the other hand, many results require some information about the first (nonzero) eigenvalue, so it seems interesting to get this eigenvalue without computing all the spectrum. In that direction, the aim of this paper is to prove the following formula for the first eigenvalue of the Dirac operator: Theorem 1. Let G/K be a compact, simply-connected, n-dimensional irreducible symmetric space with G compact and simply-connected, endowed with the metric induced by the Killing form of G sign-changed. Assume that G and K have the same rank and that G/K has a spin structure. Let βk , k = 1, . . . , p, be the K-dominant weights occurring in the decomposition into irreducible components of the spin representation under the action of K. Then the square of the first eigenvalue of the Dirac operator is 2 min βk 2 + n/8 , 1≤k≤p
(1)
where · is the norm associated to the scalar product < , > induced by the Killing form of G sign-changed. Remark 1. The proof uses a lemma of R. Parthasarathy in [Par71], which allows to express (1) in the following way. Let T be a fixed common maximal torus of G and K. Let be the set of non-zero roots of G with respect to T . Let δG , (resp. δK ) be
72
J.-L. Milhorat
the half-sum of the positive roots of G, (resp. K), with respect to a fixed lexicographic ordering in . Then the square of the first eigenvalue of the Dirac operator is given by 2 δG 2 + 2 δK 2 − 4 max < w · δG , δK > +n/8 , w∈W
(2)
where W is a certain (well-defined) subset of the Weyl group of G.
2. The Dirac Operator on a Spin Compact Symmetric Space We first review some results about the Dirac operator on a spin symmetric space, cf. for instance [CFG89] or [B¨ar91]. A detailed survey on the subject may be found, among other topics, in the reference [BHMM]. Let G/K be a spin compact symmetric space. We assume that G/K is simply connected, so G may be chosen to be compact and simply connected and K is the connected subgroup formed by the fixed elements of an involution σ of G, cf. [Hel78]. This involution induces the Cartan decomposition of the Lie algebra G of G into G = K ⊕ P, where K is the Lie algebra of K and P is the vector space {X ∈ G ; σ∗ · X = −X}. This space P is canonically identified with the tangent space to G/K at the point o, o being the class of the neutral element of G. We also assume that the symmetric space G/K is irreducible, so all the G-invariant scalar products on P, hence all the G-invariant Riemannian metrics on G/K are proportional. We consider the metric induced by the Killing form of G sign-changed. With this metric, G/K is an Einstein space with scalar curvature Scal = n/2, (cf. for instance Theorem 7.73 in [Bes87]). The spin condition implies that the homomorphism α : K → SO(P) SOn , k → AdG (k)|P lifts to a homomorphism α : K → Spinn , cf. [CG88]. Let ρ : Spinn → HomC (, ) be the spin representation. The composition ρ ◦ α defines a “spin” representation of K which is denoted ρK . The spinor bundle is then isomorphic to the vector bundle := G ×ρK . Spinor fields on G/K are then viewed as K-equivariant functions G → , i.e. functions: :G→
s.t.
∀g ∈ G , ∀k ∈ K , (gk) = ρK (k −1 ) · (g) .
Let L2K (G, ) be the Hilbert space of L2 K-equivariant functions G → . The Dirac operator D extends to a self-adjoint operator on L2K (G, ). Since it is an elliptic operator, it has a (real) discrete spectrum. Now if the spinor field is an eigenvector of D for the eigenvalue λ, then the spinor field σ ∗ · is an eigenvector for the eigenvalue −λ, hence the spectrum of the Dirac operator is symmetric with respect to the origin. Thus the spectrum of D may be deduced from the spectrum of its square D2 . By the PeterWeyl theorem, the natural unitary representation of G on the Hilbert space L2K (G, ) decomposes into the Hilbert sum ⊕ Vγ ⊗ HomK (Vγ , ) ,
γ ∈G
The First Eigenvalue of the Dirac Operator on Compact Spin Symmetric Spaces
73
is the set of equivalence classes of irreducible unitary complex representations where G and HomK (Vγ , ) is the vector space of of G, (ργ , Vγ ) represents an element γ ∈ G K-equivariant homomorphisms Vγ → , i.e. HomK (Vγ , ) = {A ∈ Hom(Vγ , ) s.t. ∀k ∈ K , A ◦ ργ (k) = ρK (k) ◦ A} . The injection Vγ ⊗ HomK (Vγ , ) → L2K (G, ) is given by v ⊗ A → g → (A ◦ ργ (g −1 ) ) · v . Note that Vγ ⊗ HomK (Vγ , ) consists of C ∞ spinor fields to which the Dirac operator can be applied. The restriction of D2 to the space Vγ ⊗ HomK (Vγ , ) is given by the Parthasaraty formula, [Par71]: Scal v ⊗ A, (3) 8 where Cγ is the Casimir operator of the representation (ργ , Vγ ). Now since the representation is irreducible, the Casimir operator is a scalar multiple of identity, Cγ = cγ id, Hence if HomK (Vγ , ) = {0}, where the eigenvalue cγ only depends on γ ∈ G. 2 cγ + n/16 belongs to the spectrum of D . Let ρK = ⊕ρK,k be the decomposition of the spin representation K → into irreducible components. Denote by m(ργ |K , ρK,k ) the multiplicity of the irreducible K-representation ρK,k in the representation ργ restricted to K. Then dim HomK (Vγ , ) = m(ργ |K , ρK,k ) . D2 (v ⊗ A) = v ⊗ (A ◦ Cγ ) +
k
So the spectrum of the square of the Dirac operator is s.t. ∃k s.t. m(ργ , ρK,k ) = 0} . Spec(D2 ) = {cγ + n/16 ; γ ∈ G |K
(4)
3. Proof of the Result We assume that G and K have the same rank. Let T be a fixed common maximal torus. Let be the set of non-zero roots of the group G with respect to T . According to a classical terminology, a root θ is called compact if the corresponding root space is contained in KC (that is, θ is a root of K with respect to T ) and noncompact if the root + space is contained in PC . Let + G be the set of positive roots of G, K be the set of + positive roots of K, and n be the set of positive noncompact roots with respect to a fixed lexicographic ordering in . The half-sums of the positive roots of G and K are respectively denoted δG and δK and the half-sum of noncompact positive roots is denoted by δn . The Weyl group of G is denoted WG . The space of weights is endowed with the WG -invariant scalar product < , > induced by the Killing form of G sign-changed. Let + W := {w ∈ WG ; w · + G ⊃ K } .
(5)
By a result of R. Parthasaraty, cf. Lemma 2.2 in [Par71], the spin representation ρK of K decomposes into the irreducible sum ρK,w , (6) ρK = w∈W
74
J.-L. Milhorat
where ρK,w has for dominant weight βw := w · δG − δK .
(7)
βw0 2 = min βw 2 ,
(8)
if ∃w1 = w0 ∈ W such that βw1 2 = min βw 2 , then βw1 ≺ βw0 ,
(9)
Now define w0 ∈ W such that w∈W
and w∈W
where ≺ is the usual ordering on weights. Lemma 1. The weight βwG0 := w0−1 · βw0 = δG − w0−1 · δK , is G-dominant. Proof. Let G = {θ1 , . . . , θr } ⊂ + G be the set of simple roots. It is sufficient to prove <β G ,θi >
that 2 <θwi0,θi > is a non-negative integer for any simple root θi . Since T is a maximal common torus of G and K, βw0 , which is an integral weight for K is also an integral weight for G. Now since the Weyl group WG permutes the weights, βwG0 = w0−1 · βw0 <β G ,θi >
is also a integral weight for G, hence 2 <θwi0,θi > is an integer for any simple root θi . So we only have to prove that this integer is non-negative. G ,θi > Let θi be a simple root. Since 2 <δ <θi ,θi > = 1, (see for instance § 10.2 in [Hum72]) and since the scalar product < ·, · > is WG -invariant, one gets 2
< βwG0 , θi > < θi , θi >
=1−2
< δK , w0 · θi > . < θi , θi >
(10)
Suppose first that w0 · θi ∈ K . If w0 · θi is positive then w0 · θi is necessarily a Ksimple root. Indeed let K = {θ1 , . . . , θl } ⊂ + K be the set of K-simple roots. One has w0 · θi = lj =1 bij θj , where the bij are non-negative integers. But since w0 ∈ W , there are l positive roots α1 , . . . , αl in + G such that w0 · αj = θj , j = 1, . . . , l. So l r θi = j =1 bij αj . Now each αj is a sum of simple roots k=1 aj k θk , where the aj k are non-negative integers. So θi = j,k bij aj k θk . By the linear independence of simple roots, one gets j bij aj k = 0 if k = i, and j bij aj i = 1. Hence there exists a j0 such that bij0 = aj0 i = 1, the other coefficients being zero. So w0 · θi = θj0 is a K-simple <δK ,w0 ·θi > K ,w0 ·θi > root. Now since 2 <δ<θ = 2 <w = 1, one gets 2 0 ·θi ,w0 ·θi > i ,θi >
2
G ,θ > <βw 0 i <θi ,θi >
G ,θ > <βw 0 i <θi ,θi >
= 0, hence
≥ 0. Now, the same conclusion holds if w0 · θi is a negative root of K, since <β G ,θi >
0 ·θi > K ,w0 ·θi > 2 <δ<θ = −2 <δK<θ,−w = −1, hence 2 <θwi0,θi > = 2. i ,θi > i ,θi > Suppose now that w0 · θi ∈ / K , that is w0 · θi is a noncompact root. This implies that w0 σi , where σi is the reflection across the hyperplane θi⊥ , is an element of W . Let α1 , . . . , αm be the positive roots in + G such that w0 · αj = αj , where the αj ,
The First Eigenvalue of the Dirac Operator on Compact Spin Symmetric Spaces
75
j = 1, . . . , m are the positive roots of K. Since σi permutes the positive roots other than θi , (cf. for instance Lemma B, § 10.2 in [Hum72]), and since θi can not be one of the roots α1 , . . . , αm (otherwise w0 · θi ∈ + K ), each root σi · αj is positive. So w0 σi ∈ W since w0 σi · (σi · αj ) = αj , j = 1, . . . , m. We now claim that 2 impossible. Suppose that
G ,θ > <βw 0 i <θi ,θi >
2
< δK , w0 · θi > > 1. < θi , θi >
Since δK can be expressed as δK = a K-simple root
θj
such that <
K ,w0 ·θi > < 0, which is equivalent to 2 <δ<θ > 1, is i ,θi >
l
i=1 ci θi , where the ci
θj , w0
· θi > 0, and since 2
(11) are nonnegative, there exists <θj ,w0 ·θi > <θj ,θj >
is an integer, this
implies that 2
< θj , w0 · θi > < θj , θj >
≥ 1.
(12)
So θj − w0 · θi is a root (cf. for instance § 9.4 in [Hum72]). Moreover, from the bracket relation [K, P] ⊂ P, it is a noncompact root. Now ±(θj − w0 · θi ) is a positive noncompact root, so by the description of the weights of the spin representation ρK , (they are of the form: δn −(a sum of distinct positive noncompact roots), cf. §2 in [Par71]), (w0 · δG − δK ) ± (θj − w0 · θi ) is a weight of ρK . Now, (w0 · δG − δK ) + (θj − w0 · θi ) can not be a weight of ρK . Otherwise since σi · δG = δG − θi , (w0 σi · δG − δK ) + θj is a weight of ρK . But since w0 σi ∈ W , µ := w0 σi · δG − δK is a dominant weight of ρK . So µ is a dominant weight but not the highest weight of an irreducible component of ρK . Hence there exists an irreducible representation of ρK with dominant weight λ = w · δG − δK , w ∈ W , whose set of weights
contains µ. Furthermore µ ≺ λ. Now since µ ∈ , µ + δK 2 ≤ λ + δK 2 , with equality only if µ = λ, (cf. for instance Lemma C, §13.4 in [Hum72]). But µ + δK 2 = δG 2 = λ + δK 2 , so µ = λ, contradicting the fact that µ ≺ λ. Thus only µ0 := (w0 · δG − δK ) − (θj − w0 · θi ) ,
(13)
can be a weight of ρK . Now one has µ0 2 = w0 · δG − δK + w0 · θi 2 −2 < w0 · δG − δK + w0 · θi , θj > +θj 2 . Since w0 · δG − δK is a dominant weight, < w0 · δG − δK , θj >≥ 0, and from (12), 2 < w0 · θi , θj > −θj 2 ≥ 0, so µ0 2 ≤ (w0 · δG − δK ) + w0 · θi 2 .
76
J.-L. Milhorat
Now (w0 · δG − δK ) + w0 · θi 2 = w0 · δG − δK 2 +2 < δG − w0−1 · δK , θi > +θi 2 . But, as we supposed 2 2 <
δG − w0−1
G ,θ > <βw 0 i <θi ,θi >
· δK , θi > +θi
< 0, one has 2
≤ 0, hence
2 <δG −w0−1 ·δK ,θi > θi 2
≤ −1, so
(w0 · δG − δK ) + w0 · θi 2 ≤ w0 · δG − δK 2 , so µ0 2 ≤ w0 · δG − δK 2 . Now, being a weight of ρK , µ0 is conjugate under the Weyl group of K to a dominant weight of ρK , say w1 · δG − δK , with w1 ∈ W . Note that w1 = w0 , otherwise since µ0 ≺ w1 · δG − δK , (cf. Lemma A, § 13.2 in [Hum72]), the noncompact root θj − w0 · θi should be a linear combination with integral coefficients of compact simple roots. But, by the bracket relation [K, K] ⊂ K, that is impossible. Thus, by the definition of w0 , cf. (8), w0 · δG − δK 2 ≤ w1 · δG − δK 2 = µ0 2 , so µ0 2 = w1 · δG − δK 2 = w0 · δG − δK 2 . But by the condition (9), the last equality is impossible, otherwise since µ0 ≺ w1 ·δG −δK and w1 · δG − δK ≺ w0 · δG − δK , the noncompact root θj − w0 · θi should be a linear combination with integral coefficients of compact simple roots. Hence 2 also if w0 · θi ∈ / K .
G ,θ > <βw 0 i <θi ,θi >
≥0
Now let (ρ0 , V0 ) be an irreducible representation of G with dominant weight βwG0 . The fact that βw0 = w0 · βwG0 is a weight of ρ0 is an indication that ρ0 |K may contain the irreducible representation ρK,w0 . This is actually true: Lemma 2. With the notations above, m(ρ0 |K , ρK,w0 ) ≥ 1 . Proof. Let v0 be the maximal vector in V0 , (it is unique up to a nonzero scalar multiple). Let g0 ∈ T be a representative of w0 . Then g0 · v0 is a weight vector for the weight βw0 , since for any X in the Lie algebra T of T : d d = dt (exp(tX) g0 ) · v0 g0 g0−1 exp(tX) g0 · v0 X · (g0 · v0 ) = dt |t=0 |t=0 = g0 · Ad(g0−1 ) · X · v0 = βwG0 (w0−1 · X) (g0 · v0 ) = (w0 · βwG0 )(X) (g0 · v0 )
= βw0 (X) (g0 · v0 ) .
In order to prove the result, we only have to prove that g0 · v0 is a maximal vector (for the action K), hence is killed by root-vectors corresponding to simple roots of K. So let θi be a simple root of K and Ei be a root-vector corresponding to that simple root.
The First Eigenvalue of the Dirac Operator on Compact Spin Symmetric Spaces
77
Since w0 ∈ W , there exists a positive root αi ∈ + G such that w0 · αi = θi . Then −1 Ei := Ad(g0 )(Ei ) is a root-vector corresponding to the root αi since for any X in T = Ad(g0−1 ) · [Ad(g [X, Ei ] = [X, Ad(g0−1 )(Ei )] 0 )(X), Ei ] −1 −1 −1 = Ad(g0 ) · [w0 · X, Ei ] = (w0 · θi )(X) Ad(g0 ) · Ei = αi (X) Ei .
But since v0 is killed by the action of the root-vectors corresponding to positive roots in + G , one gets d g0 g0−1 exp(t Ei )g0 · v0 Ei · (g0 · v0 ) = dt |t=0 d = dt g0 exp t Ad(g0−1 ) · Ei · v0 |t=0 = g0 · E i · v 0 = 0.
Hence the result.
From the result (4), we may then conclude: Lemma 3. 2 βw0 2 + n/8 , is an eigenvalue of the square of the Dirac operator. Proof. By the Freudenthal formula, the Casimir eigenvalue cγ0 of the representation (ρ0 , V0 ) is given by βwG0 + δG 2 − δG 2 = 3 δG 2 + δK 2 − 4 < w0 · δG , δK > . On the other hand βw0 2 = δG 2 + δK 2 − 2 < w0 · δG , δK > . Hence cγ0 = 2 βw0 2 + δG 2 − δK 2 . Now, the Casimir operator of K acts on the spin representation ρK as scalar multiplication by δG 2 − δK 2 , (cf. Lemma 2.2 in [Par71]). Indeed, each dominant weight of ρK being of the form w · δG − δK , w ∈ W , the eigenvalue of the Casimir operator on each irreducible component is given by: (w · δG − δK ) + δK 2 − δK 2 = w · δG 2 − δK 2 = δG 2 − δK 2 . On the other hand, the proof of the formula (3) shows that the Casimir operator of K acts on the spin representation ρK as scalar multiplication by Scal 8 = n/16 (cf. [Sul79]), hence δG 2 − δK 2 = n/16 . So cγ0 + n/16 = 2 βw0 2 + n/8 . Hence the result.
(14)
78
J.-L. Milhorat
In order to conclude, we have to prove that Lemma 4. 2 βw0 2 + n/8 , is the lowest eigenvalue of the square of the Dirac operator. be such that there exists w ∈ W such that m(ργ , ρK,w ) ≥ 1. Let Proof. Let γ ∈ G |K βγ be the dominant weight of ργ . First, since the Weyl group permutes the weights of ργ , w −1 · βw = δG − w −1 · δK is a weight of ργ . Hence βγ + δG 2 ≥ w −1 · βw + δG 2 , (cf. for instance Lemma C, §13.4 in [Hum72]). So, from the Freudenthal formula, cγ = βγ + δG 2 − δG 2 ≥ w −1 · βw + δG 2 − δG 2 . But, using (14) w−1 · βw + δG 2 − δG 2 = 2 βw 2 + δG 2 − δK 2 = 2 βw 2 + n/16 . Hence by the definition of βw0 , cγ ≥ 2 βw 2 + n/16 ≥ 2 βw0 2 + n/16 . Hence the result.
References [B¨ar91]
B¨ar, C.: Das Spektrum von Dirac-Operatoren. Dissertation, Universit¨at Bonn, 1991, Bonner Mathematische Schriften 217. [Bes87] Besse, A.: Einstein Manifolds. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1987 [BHMM] Bourguignon, J.P., Hijazi, O., Milhorat, J.-L., Moroianu, A.: A Spinorial Approach to Riemannian and Conformal Geometry. Monograph (in preparation) [CFG89] Cahen, M., Franc, A., Gutt, S.: Spectrum of the Dirac Operator on Complex Projective Space P2q−1 (C). Lett. Math. Phys. 18, 165–176 (1989) [CG88] Cahen, M., Gutt, S.: Spin Structures on Compact Simply Connected Riemannian Symmetric Spaces. Simon Stevin 62, 209–242 (1988) [Hel78] Helgason, S.: Differential Geometry, Lie Groups and Symmetric Spaces, Pure and Applied mathematics, Vol. 80. San Diego: Academic Press, 1978 [Hum72] Humphreys, J.E.: Introduction to Lie Algebras and Representation Theory. Berlin-Heidelberg New York: Springer-Verlag, 1972 [Par71] Parthasarathy, R.: Dirac operator and the discrete series. Ann. Math. 96, 1–30 (1971) [Sul79] Sulanke, S.: Die Berechnung des Spektrums des Quadrates des Dirac-Operators auf der Sph¨are. Doktorarbeit, Humboldt-Universit¨at, Berlin, 1979 Communicated by P. Sarnak
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 79–102 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1396-4
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons Petar Ivanov, Stefan Ivanov University of Sofia “St. Kl. Ohridski”, Faculty of Mathematics and Informatics, Blvd. James Bourchier 5, 1164 Sofia, Bulgaria. E-mail:
[email protected] (P. Ivanov);
[email protected] (S. Ivanov) Received: 4 May 2004 / Accepted: 25 February 2005 Published online: 8 July 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: Necessary and sufficient conditions to the existence of a hermitian connection with totally skew-symmetric torsion and holonomy contained in SU (3) are given. A formula for the Riemannian scalar curvature is obtained. Non-compact solution to the supergravity-type I equations of motion with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton is found in dimension 6. Non-conformally flat non-compact solutions to the supergravity-type I equations of motion with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton are found in dimensions 7 and 8. A Riemannian metric with holonomy contained in G2 arises from our considerations and Hitchin’s flow equations, which seems to be new. Compact examples of SU (3), G2 and Spin(7) instanton satisfying the anomaly cancellation conditions are presented. Contents 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. General Properties of SU (3), G2 and Spin(7)-Structures . . . . . . . 2.1 SU(3)-structures in d = 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 G2 -structures in d = 7 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Spin(7)-structures in d = 8 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. The Supersymmetry Equations in Dimensions 6, 7 and 8 . . . . . . . 4. Non-Compact G2 -Solution Induced from a SU (3)-Instanton . . . . . 5. Non-Compact Spin(7)-Solution Induced from a G2 -Instanton . . . . 6. Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1 (SU (3), G2 , Spin(7))-instanton and conformally flat non-compact solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 (SU (3), G2 , Spin(7))-instanton and non-conformally flat non-compact solution . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. Almost Contact Metric Structures and Non-Compact SU (3)-Solutions in Dimension 6 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1 Non-conformally flat local SU (3)-solutions on S 5 × S 1 . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
80 83 83 84 85 86 88 91 92
. . .
93
. . .
95
. . . . . .
97 99
80
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
1. Introduction Supersymmetric backgrounds of string/M theory with non-vanishing fluxes are currently an active area of study for at least two reasons. Firstly they provide a framework of searching for new models with realistic phenomenology and secondly, they appear in generalizations of the AdS/CFT correspondence. The supersymmetric geometries of the common NS-NS sector of type IIA, IIB and heterotic/type I supergravity are analyzed in [42]. The bosonic geometry is of the form R1,9−p × Mp , where the Riemannian metric g, the dilaton function φ and the three form H are non-trivial only on Mp but all R-R fields and fermions are set to zero in type II theories. The type I/heterotic geometries, which is the main object of interest in the present note, allow in addition non-trivial gauge field A with field strength F A . We recall the basic notations [73, 54, 52, 41, 42]. We search for solutions to lowest nontrivial order in α of the equations of motion that follow from the bosonic action 2 1 2 1 10 √ −2φ g g 2 Scal + 4(∇ φ) − H − α T r F A S = 2 d x −ge 2k 12 which also preserves at least one supersymmetry. The three form H satisfies a modified Bianchi identity dH = 2α T r(F A ∧ F A ). The so-called Bianchi identity reads ˜ ˜ dH = 2α T r F A ∧ F A − T r R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ,
(1.1)
(1.2)
˜ ˜ where R ∇ is the curvature of the metric connection ∇˜ with torsion T ∇ = −H related 1 g g to the Levi-Civita connection ∇ by ∇˜ = ∇ − 2 H . The second term on the right-hand side of (1.2) is the leading string correction to the supergravity expression arising from the anomaly cancellation but for the consistency of the theory, a modification to the action should be included [10] (see also [22, 45]). In terms of characteristic classes (1.2) means that dH is proportional to the difference ˜ of the connections A, ∇, ˜ respectively. of the first Pontrjagin 4-forms (p1 (A) − p1 (∇)) A heterotic/type I geometry will preserve supersymmetry if and only if, in 10 dimensions, there exists at least one Majorana-Weyl spinor such that the supersymmetry variations of the fermionic fields vanish, i.e. 1 g δλ = ∇m = ∇m + Hmnp np = 0, 8 1 δ = m ∂m φ + Hmnp mnp = 0, (1.3) 12 A mn δξ = Fmn = 0,
where λ, , ξ are the gravitino, the dilatino and the gaugino, fields, respectively. The equations of motion corresponding to the action S are presented explicitly in [42]. It is known [25, 41] that the equation of motions of type I supergravity are automatically satisfied if one imposes, in addition to the preserving supersymmetry equations (1.3), the modified Bianchi identity (1.1).
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
81
According to no-go (vanishing) theorems (a consequence of the equations of motion [31, 25]; a consequence of the supersymmetry [58] for SU(n)-case and [42] for the general case) there are no compact solutions with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton satisfying the supersymmetry equations (1.3) and the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) simultaneously. In dimensions 7 and 8 the only known heterotic/type I solutions to the equations of motion preserving at least one supersymmetry, i.e. satisfying (1.3) and (1.1), are those constructed in [27, 37, 54] in dimension 8 and those presented in [52] in dimension 7. All these solutions are conformal to a flat space. In dimension 6, the possibility of the existence of a non-conformally flat solution on the complex Iwasawa manifold was discussed in [73, 21, 42, 63]. In the present note we concentrate our attention to find non-compact solutions to the supergravity equations (1.3) including the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) as well as the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2). In dimensions 7 and 8 we find non-locally-conformally flat non-compact solutions to the gravitino, gaugino and dilatino equations with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton which obey the Bianchi identities (1.1) and (1.2) and therefore satisfy the equations of motion, due to the result in [41]. In dimension 6, we present a (non-conformally-flat) non-compact solution to the equations of motion showing that it obeys (1.3),(1.1),(1.2). All these non-compact solutions seem to be new. We present a non conformally flat (resp. conformally flat) SU (3), G2 and Spin(7)instantons which satisfy the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2) as well as the modified Bianchi identity (1.1). We obtain compact 6,7 and 8-manifolds which solve the gravitino and gaugino equations and satisfy the compatibility conditions (1.2) and (1.1) but do not solve the dilatino equation which is consistent with the no-go theorems. Geometrically, the vanishing of the gravitino variation is equivalent to the existence of a non-trivial spinor parallel with respect to a metric connection ∇ with totally skew symmetric torsion T = H which is related to the Levi-Civita connection ∇ g by 1 ∇ = ∇ g + H. 2 The presence of a ∇-parallel spinor leads to restriction of the holonomy group H ol(∇) of the torsion connection ∇. Namely, H ol(∇) has to be contained in SU (3), d = 6 [73, 59, 58, 51, 21, 6, 7], the exceptional group G2 , d = 7 [32, 40, 34], the Lie group Spin(7), d = 8 [40, 57]. A detailed analysis of the possible geometries is carried out in [42]. Complex Non-K¨ahler geometries appear in string compactifications and are studied intensively [73, 46, 42, 40, 41, 46, 45, 6, 7]. Some types of non-complex 6-manifold have been also invented recently in the string theory due to the mirror symmetry and T-duality [63, 50, 49, 11, 21, 22]. Another special dimension turns out to be dimension 5. The existence of a ∇-parallel spinor in dimension 5 determines an almost contact metric structure whose properties as well as solutions to gravitino and dilatino equations are investigated in [32, 33]. We use these considerations in our construction in Sect. 6 of a new SU (3)-instanton and non-compact solution to the equations of motion in dimension 6. Almost Hermitian manifolds with totally skew-symmetric Nijenhuis tensor arise as target spaces of a class of (2,0)-supersymmetric two-dimensional sigma models [69]. For the consistency of the theory, the Nijenhuis tensor has to be parallel with respect to the torsion connection with holonomy contained in SU (n). The known models are those on group manifolds. We present a 6-dimensional nil-manifold as an example which is not a group manifold.
82
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
Starting with a SU (3)-structure in dimension 6 we analyze the five classes discovered recently by Chiossi and Salamon [23] from the point of the existence of a SU (3)connection having totally skew-symmetric torsion. We obtain necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of a connection solving the gravitino equation in dimension 6, i.e. the existence of a linear connection preserving the almost hermitian structure with torsion 3-form and holonomy contained in SU (3), in terms of the given SU (3)structure and present a formula for the Riemannian scalar curvature (Theorem 4.1). It turns out that the corresponding almost complex structure may not be integrable. In case that the almost complex structure is integrable, we derive that the SU (3)-structure is holomorphic if and only if the corresponding hermitian structure is balanced, i.e. has co-closed fundamental form (Corollary 4.3). On the other hand, any SU (3)-weak holonomy manifold (Nearly K¨ahler manifold) automatically solves both the gravitino and gaugino equations. It turns out that the Nearly K¨ahler 6-sphere S 6 satisfies in addition the compatibility conditions (1.2), (1.1). We present a six dimensional non-conformally flat nil-manifold Nil 6 = G/ , i.e. a compact quotient of a nilpotent Lie group G with a discrete subgroup , which solves both the gravitino and gaugino equations and satisfies the compatibility conditions (1.2), (1.1) but it is neither complex nor Nearly K¨ahler. Consequently, it does not solve the dilatino equation [73]. However, the SU (3)-structure on G is half-flat and therefore it determines a Riemannian metric with holonomy contained in G2 on G × R ∼ = R7 according to the procedure discovered by Hitchin [55], which seems to be a new one. We propose a simple way to lift a 6-dimensional solution to the gravitino and gaugino equations, i.e. a SU (3)-instanton solving the gravitino equation and satisfying the conditions (1.1) (resp. (1.2)), to a G2 -instanton on the product with the real line which solves the three supersymmetry equations (1.3) as well as the compatibility condition (1.1) (resp. (1.2)). We show that N il 6 ×R, (resp. S 6 ×R) is a non-compact solution to the equations of motion in dimension 7 with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton which preserves at least one supersymmetry and is not locally conformally flat (resp. locally conformally flat). Consequently, the compact spaces N il 6 × S 1 , S 6 × S 1 admit a G2 instanton structure satisfying all the Eqs. (1.3), (1.2), (1.1) except the dilatino equation. It turns out that any G2 -weak holonomy manifold (Nearly-parallel manifold) automatically solves both the gravitino and gaugino equations. We show that the Nearly parallel 7-sphere satisfies in addition the compatibility conditions (1.2), (1.1). The same lifting procedure is applicable to the Spin(7) case. Namely, any G2 -instanton solving the gravitino equation and satisfying the conditions (1.1) (resp. (1.2)) can be lifted to a Spin(7)-instanton on the product with the real line which solves the three supersymmetry equations (1.3) as well as the compatibility condition (1.1) (resp. (1.2)). We show that N il 6 × R × R, (resp. S 6 × R × R, S 7 × R) is a non-compact solution to the equations of motion in dimension 8 with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton which preserves at least one supersymmetry and is not locally conformally flat (resp. locally conformally flat). Consequently, the compact spaces Nil 6 ×S 1 ×S 1 , S 6 ×S 1 ×S 1 , S 7 ×S 1 admit a Spin(7)-instanton structure satisfying all Eqs. (1.3), (1.2), (1.1) except the dilatino equation. Starting with a Tanno deformed Einstein Sasaki structure in dimension 5, we lift it to a SU (3)-instanton on the product with the real line which satisfies all the supersymmetry equations (1.3) in dimension 6. In this way we obtain local solutions to the equations of motion in dimension 6. Consider S 5 as a Sasakian space form, i.e. a Tanno deformation of the standard Einstein-Sasaki structure, we show that S 5 ×R is a non-compact solution to the equations of motion in dimension 6 with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
83
which preserves at least one supersymmetry. Consequently, the compact space S 5 × S 1 admits a SU (3)-instanton structure satisfying all the Eqs. (1.3), (1.2), (1.1). 2. General Properties of SU (3), G2 and Spin(7)-Structures In this section we recall necessary properties of SU (3), G2 and Spin(7) structures. 2.1. SU(3)-structures in d = 6. Let (M 6 , g, J ) be an almost Hermitian 6-manifold with Riemannian metric g and an almost complex structure J , i.e. (g, J ) define an U (3)-structure. The Nijenhuis tensor N , the K¨ahler form F and the Lee form θ 6 are defined by N = [J., J.] − [., .] − J [J., .] − [., J.],
F = g(., J.),
θ 6 (.) = δF (J.), (2.4)
respectively. A SU √(3)-structure is determined by an additional non-degenerate (3,0)-form = + + −1 − , or equivalently by a non-trivial spinor. To be more explicit, we may choose a local orthonormal frame e1 , . . . , e6 , identifying it with the dual basis via the metric. Write ei1 i2 ...ip for the monomial ei1 ∧ei2 ∧· · ·∧eip . A SU (3)-structure is described locally by √ √ √ = −(e1 + −1e2 ) ∧ (e3 + −1e4 ) ∧ (e5 + −1e6 ), F = −e12 − e34 − e56 , (2.5) + = −e135 + e236 + e146 + e245 , − = −e136 − e145 − e235 + e246 . The subgroup of SO(6) fixing the forms F and simultaneously is SU (3). The two forms F and determine the metric completely. The Lie algebra of SU (3) is denoted su(3). The failure of the holonomy group of the Levi-Civita connection to reduce to SU (3) can be measured by the intrinsic torsion τ , which is identified with ∇ g F or ∇ g J and can be decomposed into five classes [23], τ ∈ W1 ⊕ · · · ⊕ W5 . The intrinsic torsion of an U (n)- structure belongs to the first four components described by Gray-Hervella [48]. The five components of a SU (3)-structure are first described by Chiossi-Salamon [23] (for interpretation in physics see [21, 50, 49]) and are determined by dF, d + , d − as well as by dF and N. We describe those of them which we will use later. τ ∈ W1 : The class of Nearly K¨ahler (weak holonomy) manifold defined by dF to be (3,0)+(0,3)-form. τ ∈ W2 : The class of almost K¨ahler manifolds, dF = 0. τ ∈ W3 : The class of balanced hermitian manifold determined by the conditions N = θ 6 = 0, i.e these are complex manifolds with vanishing Lee form. These spaces are investigated in [39, 68, 2]. τ ∈ W4 : The class of locally conformally K¨ahler spaces characterized by dF = θ 6 ∧ F . τ ∈ W1 ⊕ W3 ⊕ W4 : The class called by Gray-Hervella G1 -manifolds determined by the condition that the Nijenhuis tensor is totally skew-symmetric. This is the precise class which we are interested in. The class of a half-flat SU(3)-manifold [23] may be characterized by the conditions d + = 0, θ 6 = 0. The half-flat structures can be lifted to a G2 -holonomy metric on
84
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
the product with the real line and vice versa due to the Hitchin theorem [55]. In fact, many new G2 -holonomy metrics are obtained in this way [43, 14]. We recall [23] that the fifth component W5 and the two scalar components of W1 are determined by the expressions ∗d + ∧ + , d + ∧ F = W1+ vol., d − ∧ F = W1− vol., respectively. If all five components are zero then we have a Ricci-flat K¨ahler (Calabi-Yau) 3-fold. 2.2. G2 -structures in d = 7. Endow R7 with its standard orientation and inner product. Let e1 , . . . , e7 be an oriented orthonormal basis. Consider the three-form ω on R7 given by ω = e127 − e236 + e347 + e567 − e146 − e245 + e135 .
(2.6)
The subgroup of GL(7) fixing ω is the exceptional Lie group G2 . It is a compact, connected, simply-connected, simple Lie subgroup of SO(7) of dimension 14 [16]. The Lie algebra is denoted by g2 and it is isomorphic to the two forms satisfying 7 linear equations, namely g2 ∼ = {α ∈ 2 (M)|∗(α ∧ ω) = −α}. The 3-form ω corresponds to a real spinor and therefore, G2 can be identified as the isotropy group of a non-trivial real spinor. The Hodge star operator supplies the 4-form ∗ω given by ∗ω = e3456 + e1457 + e1256 + e1234 + e2357 + e1367 − e2467 .
(2.7)
A 7-dimensional Riemannian manifold is called a G2 -manifold if its structure group reduces to the exceptional Lie group G2 . The existence of a G2 -structure is equivalent to the existence of a global non-degenerate three-form which can be locally written as (2.6). The 3-form ω is called the fundamental form of the G2 -manifold [15]. From the purely topological point of view, a 7-dimensional paracompact manifold is a G2 -manifold if and only if it is an oriented spin manifold [66]. We will say that the pair (M, ω) is a G2 -manifold with G2 -structure (determined by) ω. The fundamental form of a G2 -manifold determines a Riemannian metric implicitly through gij = 16 kl ωikl ωj kl [47]. This is referred to as the metric induced by ω. We write ∇ g for the associated Levi-Civita connection. In [29], Fernandez and Gray divide G2 -manifolds into 16 classes according to how the covariant derivative of the fundamental three-form behaves with respect to its decomposition into G2 irreducible components (see also [23, 40]). If the fundamental form is parallel with respect to the Levi-Civita connection, ∇ g ω = 0, then the Riemannian holonomy group is contained in G2 . In this case the induced metric on the G2 -manifold is Ricci-flat, a fact first observed by Bonan [15]. It was shown by Gray [47] (see also [16, 71]) that a G2 -manifold is parallel precisely when the fundamental form is harmonic, i.e. dω = d ∗ ω = 0. The first examples of complete parallel G2 -manifolds were constructed by Bryant and Salamon [17, 44]. Compact examples of parallel G2 -manifolds were obtained first by Joyce [60–62] and recently by Kovalev [65]. The Lee form θ 7 is defined by [19] 1 θ 7 = − ∗(∗dω ∧ ω). 3
(2.8)
If the Lee form vanishes, θ 7 = 0, then the G2 -structure is said to be balanced. If the Lee form is closed, dθ 7 = 0, then the G2 -structure is locally conformally equivalent to a balanced one [34]. If the G2 -structure satisfies the condition d ∗ω = θ 7 ∧ ω then it is called integrable and an analog of the Dolbeault cohomology is investigated in [30].
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
85
2.3. Spin(7)-structures in d = 8. Now, let us consider R8 endowed with an orientation and its standard inner product. Let {e0 , ..., e7 } be an oriented orthonormal basis. Consider the 4-form on R8 given by = e0127 − e0236 + e0347 + e0567 − e0146 − e0245 + e0135 +e3456 + e1457 + e1256 + e1234 + e2357 + e1367 − e2467 .
(2.9)
The 4-form is self-dual ∗ = and the 8-form ∧ coincides with the volume form of R8 . The subgroup of GL(8, R) which fixes is isomorphic to the double covering Spin(7) of SO(7) [53]. Moreover, Spin(7) is a compact simply-connected Lie group of dimension 21 [16]. The Lie algebra of Spin(7) is denoted by spin(7) and it is isomorphic to the two forms satisfying 7 linear equations, namely spin(7) ∼ = {α ∈
2 (M)| ∗ (α ∧ ) = −α}. The 4-form corresponds to a real spinor φ and therefore, Spin(7) can be identified as the isotropy group of a non-trivial real spinor. A Spin(7)-structure on an 8-manifold M is by definition a reduction of the structure group of the tangent bundle to Spin(7); we shall also say that M is a Spin(7) manifold. This can be described geometrically by saying that there exists a nowhere vanishing global differential 4-form on M which can be locally written as (2.9). The 4-form is called the fundamental form of the Spin(7) manifold M [15]. The fundamental form of a Spin(7)-manifold determines a Riemannian metric implic1 itly through gij = 24 klm iklm j klm [47]. This is referred to as the metric induced by . In general, not every 8-dimensional Riemannian spin manifold M 8 admits a Spin(7)structure. We explain the precise condition [66]. Denote by p1 (M), p2 (M), X(M), X(S± ) the first and the second Pontrjagin classes, the Euler characteristic of M and the Euler characteristic of the positive and the negative spinor bundles, respectively. It is well known [66] that a spin 8-manifold admits a Spin(7) structure if and only if X(S+ ) = 0 or X(S− ) = 0. The latter conditions are equivalent to p12 (M) − 4p2 (M) + 8X(M) = 0, for an appropriate choice of the orientation [66]. Let us recall that a Spin(7) manifold (M, g, ) is said to be parallel (torsion-free [61]) if the holonomy of the metric H ol(g) is a subgroup of Spin(7). This is equivalent to saying that the fundamental form is parallel with respect to the Levi-Civita connection ∇ g of the metric g. Moreover, H ol(g) ⊂ Spin(7) if and only if d = 0 [16] (see also [71]) and any parallel Spin(7) manifold is Ricci flat [15]. The first known explicit example of complete parallel Spin(7) manifold with H ol(g) = Spin(7) was constructed by Bryant and Salamon [17, 44]. The first compact examples of parallel Spin(7) manifolds with H ol(g) = Spin(7) were constructed by Joyce [60, 61]. There are 4-classes of Spin(7) manifolds according to the Fernandez classification [28] obtained as irreducible representations of Spin(7) of the space ∇ g . The Lee form θ 8 is defined by [18] 1 θ 8 = − ∗ (∗d ∧ ) = 1/7 ∗ (δ ∧ ). 7
(2.10)
The 4 classes of Fernandez classification can be described in terms of the Lee form as follows [18]: W0 : d = 0; W1 : θ 8 = 0; W2 : d = θ 8 ∧ ; W : W = W1 ⊕ W2 . A Spin(7)-structure of the class W1 (i.e. Spin(7)-structure with zero Lee form) is called a balanced Spin(7)-structure. If the Lee form is closed, dθ 8 = 0 then the Spin(7)-structure is locally conformally equivalent to a balanced one [57]. It is shown in [18] that the Lee form of a Spin(7) structure in the class W2 is closed and therefore
86
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
such a manifold is locally conformally equivalent to a parallel Spin(7) manifold. The compact spaces with closed but not exact Lee form (i.e. the structure is not globally conformally parallel) have very different topology than the parallel ones [57]. Coeffective cohomology and coeffective numbers of Riemannian manifolds with Spin(7)-structure are studied in [74]. 3. The Supersymmetry Equations in Dimensions 6, 7 and 8 Dimension d=6 . Necessary conditions to have a solution to the system of dilatino and gravitino equations in dimension 6 were derived by Strominger in [73] and then studied by many authors [40–42, 21, 22, 6–8, 45] Necessary conditions to solve the gravitino equation are given in [32]. The presence of a parallel spinor in dimension 6 leads firstly to the reduction to U (3), i.e. the existence of an almost hermitian structure, secondly to the existence of a linear connection preserving the almost hermitian structure with torsion 3-form, and thirdly to the reduction of the holonomy group of the torsion connection to SU(3). It is shown in [32] that there exists a unique linear connection preserving an almost hermitian structure having totally skew-symmetric torsion if and only if the Nijenhuis tensor is a 3-form, i.e. the intrinsic torsion τ ∈ W1 ⊕ W3 ⊕ W4 . The torsion connection ∇ is determined by 1 ∇ = ∇g + T , 2 1 T = J dF + N = −dF (J., J., J.) + N = −dF + (J., J., J.) + N, 4
(3.11)
where dF + denotes the (1,2)+(2,1)-part of dF . The (3,0)+(0,3)-part dF − is determined completely by the Nijenhuis tensor [38]. If N is a three form then (see e.g. [32]) 3 dF − = − J N. 4
(3.12)
In addition, the dilatino equation forces the almost complex structure to be integrable and the Lee form to be closed (for applications in physics the Lee form has to be exact) determined by the dilaton due to θ 6 = 2dφ [73]. When the almost complex structure is integrable, N = 0, the torsion connection is also known as the Bismut connection and was used by Bismut to prove the local index theorem for the Dolbeault operator on the Hermitian non-K¨ahler manifold [12]. This formula was recently applied in string theory [7]. Vanishing theorems for the Dolbeault cohomology on the compact Hermitian non-K¨ahler manifold were found in terms of the Bismut connection [4, 58, 59]. Dimension d=7 . The precise conditions to have a solution to the gravitino equation in dimension 7 are found in [32]. Namely, there exists a non-trivial parallel spinor with respect to a G2 -connection with torsion 3-form T if and only if there exists a G2 -structure (ω, g) satisfying the equations d ∗ω = θ 7 ∧ ∗ω.
(3.13)
In this case the torsion connection ∇ is unique, the torsion 3-form T is given by 1 ∇ = ∇g + T , 2
H =T =
1 (dω, ∗ω)ω − ∗dω + ∗(θ 7 ∧ ω), 6
(3.14)
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
87
and the Riemannian scalar curvature has the following expression [34] sg =
1 1 (dω, ∗ω) + 2||θ 7 ||2 − ||T ||2 + 3δθ 7 . 18 12
(3.15)
The necessary conditions to have a solution to the system of dilatino and gravitino equations were derived in [40, 32, 34] and sufficiency was proved in [32, 34]. The general existence result [32, 34] states that there exists a (local) non-trivial solution to both dilatino and gravitino equations in dimension 7 if and only if there exists a G2 -structure (ω, g) satisfying the equations d ∗ω = θ 7 ∧ ∗ω,
dω ∧ ω = 0,
θ 7 = 2dφ.
(3.16)
The torsion 3-form (the flux H ) is given by 1 ∇ = ∇g + T , 2
H = T = −∗dω + 2∗(dφ ∧ ω).
The Riemannian scalar curvature satisfies s g = 8||dφ||2 −
1 2 12 ||T ||
(3.17)
+ 6δdφ.
Dimension d=8. It is shown in [57] that the gravitino equation always has a solution in dimension 8. Namely, any Spin(7)-structure admits a unique Spin(7)-connection with totally skew-symmetric torsion T = ∗d − ∗(θ 8 ∧ ). The necessary conditions to have a solution to the system of dilatino and gravitino equations were derived in [40, 57] and sufficiency was proved in [57]. The general existence result [57] states that there exists a (local) non-trivial solution to both dilatino and gravitino equations in dimension 8 if and only if there there exists a Spin(7)-structure (, g) with closed Lee form, dθ 8 = 0, which is equivalent to the statement that the Spin(7)-structure is locally conformally balanced. The torsion 3-form (the flux H ) and the Lee form are given by 1 ∇ = ∇g + T , 2
H = T = ∗d − 2∗(dφ ∧ ),
θ8 =
12 dφ. 7
(3.18)
1 ||T ||2 + 6δdφ. The Riemannian scalar curvature satisfies s g = 8||dφ||2 − 12 In addition to these equations, the vanishing of the gaugino variation requires the 2-form F A to be of instanton type: ([24, 73, 54, 70, 26, 42])
Case d=6 A Donaldson-Uhlenbeck-Yau SU (3)-instanton, i.e. the gauge field A is a SU (3)-connection with curvature 2-form F A ∈ su(3). The SU(3)-instanton condition can be written in local holomorphic coordinates in the form [24, 73] ¯
A = Fα¯Aβ¯ = 0, FαAβ¯ F α β = 0. Fαβ
(3.19)
Case d=7 A G2 -instanton, i.e. the gauge field A is a G2 -connection and its curvature 2-form F A ∈ g2 . The latter can be expressed in any of the following two equivalent ways A mn Fmn ω p=0
A ⇔ Fmn =
1 A F (∗ω)pq mn . 2 pq
(3.20)
88
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
Case d=8 A Spin(7)-instanton, i.e. the gauge field A is a Spin(7)-connection and its curvature 2-form F A ∈ spin(7). The latter is equivalent to A = Fmn
1 A pq F mn . 2 pq
(3.21)
4. Non-Compact G2 -Solution Induced from a SU (3)-Instanton In this section we show how to construct a local solution to the equations of motion in dimension 7 if we have a solution to the gravitino and gaugino equations satisfying the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) in dimension 6. We first investigate a necessary and sufficient condition to have a solution to the gravitino equation in dimension 6, i.e. to have a ∇-parallel spinors. We prove the following Theorem 4.1. Let (M 6 , g, J, ) be a 6-dimensional smooth manifold with a SU (3)structure (g, J, ) or equivalently, the almost hermitian manifold (M 6 , g, J ) has topologically trivial canonical bundle trivialized by a (3,0)-form . The next two conditions are equivalent a) There exists a unique SU (3)-connection with torsion 3-form, i.e. a linear connection with torsion 3-form which preserves the almost hermitian structure whose holonomy is contained in SU(3). b) The Nijenhuis tensor N is totally-skew symmetric and the following conditions hold 1 d + = θ 6 ∧ + − (N, + )∗F, 4
1 d − = θ 6 ∧ − − (N, − )∗F. (4.22) 4
The torsion is given by 1 1 T = −∗dF + ∗(θ 6 ∧ F ) + (N, + ) + + (N, − ) − . 4 4
(4.23)
The Riemannian scalar curvature is expressed in the following way sg =
1 1 1 (N, + )2 + (N, − )2 + 2||θ 6 ||2 − ||T ||2 + 3δθ 6 . 8 8 12
(4.24)
In particular, if the structure is complex and balanced then the Riemannian scalar curvature is non-positive. Proof. Suppose condition a) holds. Then the Nijenhuis tensor N is a three form due to Theorem 10.1 in [32]. The conditions ∇ = ∇ + = ∇ − = 0 imply the constraints (4.22) on the exterior derivative of the form . This can be checked directly using (3.11) and (3.12). To prove the converse we consider the product M 7 = M 6 × R with the G2 -structure ω defined by [55, 23] ω = −F ∧ e7 − + ,
(4.25)
where e7 is the standard 1-form on R. We adopt the convention to indicate the object on the product by a superscript 7, 7 i.e. ∗7 , T 7 , θ 7 , ∇ 7 , R ∇ are the Hodge star operator, the torsion 3-form, the Lee form,
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
89
the torsion connection and its curvature, respectively. The same objects on M 6 have superscript 6. Our idea is to check that the G2 -structure on the product M 7 = M 6 × R satisfies the conditions (3.13) and to apply the Friedrich-Ivanov result from [32] assuring the existence of G2 -connection ∇ 7 with torsion 3-form T 7 . We show that the torsion satisfies the condition T (e7 , ., .) = 0 and therefore ∇ 7 e7 = 0. Hence, the connection ∇ 7 descends on M 6 to a connection ∇ 6 which preserves the SU (3)-structure and has totally skew-symmetric torsion. We get from (4.25) applying (3.12) and (4.22) the following sequence of equalities 1 θ 7 = − ∗7 (∗7 dω ∧ ω) 3 1 6 6 = −∗ (∗ dF ∧ F ) + ∗6 (∗6 dF ∧ + )e7 − ∗6 ∗6 d + ∧ + 3 1 = θ 6 + (N, − )e7 , (4.26) 4 where we used the identities ∗6 (∗6 d + ∧ + ) = ∗6 (∗6 (θ ∧ + ) ∧ + ) = −2θ, ∗7 dω = ∗6 dF − ∗6 d + ∧ e7 , θ = −∗6 dF ∧ dF, 3 ∗6 (∗6 dF ∧ + ) = −( + , dF ) = − ( − , N ). 4
(4.27)
Applying the equalities d ∗6 F = −∗6 J θ 6 = θ 6 ∧ ∗6 F and the conditions (4.22) we obtain (3.13). Hence, there exists a G2 -connection ∇ 7 with torsion 3-form T 7 given by (3.14) on the product M 7 = M 6 × R. To compute T 7 we use (3.12) and (4.26). We have 3 (dω, ∗7 ω) = ∗7 (dω ∧ ω) = 2∗7 (dF ∧ + ) = − (N, + ), 2 (4.28) 1 6 6 6 6 + 7 7 ∗ (θ ∧ ω) = ∗ (θ ∧ F ) − ∗ (θ ∧ )e7 + (N, − ) − . 4 Now, the formula (3.14) and (4.22) give the desired expression (4.23) which implies that the torsion T 7 does not depend on e7 and therefore the connection ∇ 7 descends to M 6 . Substituting (4.28) and (4.26) into (3.15) we get (4.24) for the Riemannian scalar curvature on the product which clearly coincides with the scalar curvature on (M 6 , g 6 ). Corollary 4.2. In dimension 6 the following conditions are equivalent: a) There exists a non-trivial solution to the system of gravitino and dilatino equations with non-zero flux H and non-constant dilaton φ. b) There exists a SU (3)-structure (F, ) satisfying the conditions d + = 2dφ ∧ + ,
d − = 2dφ ∧ − .
The flux H is given by H = T = −∗dF + 2∗(dφ ∧ F ).
(4.29)
The Riemannian scalar curvature of the solution has the expression s g = 8||dφ||2 −
1 ||T ||2 + 6δdφ. 12
(4.30)
90
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
A part of the necessary conditions we presented are known [73, 42, 40, 41, 21]. The formula (4.29) was discovered in [40], the first formula in (4.27) has already appeared in [21]. Corollary 4.3. A closed SU (3)-structure (d + = d − =0) admits a SU (3)-connection with torsion 3-form if and only if the corresponding almost Hermitian structure is a balanced Hermitian structure, (N = θ 6 = 0). In particular, a holomorphic SU (3)-structure on a complex manifold supports a linear connection with torsion 3-form and holonomy contained in SU (3) if and only if it is balanced. In the latter case the Riemannian scalar curvature is non-positive. Consequently, such a structure is half-flat and therefore it determines a Riemannian metric with holonomy contained in G2 on the product with the real line . Remark 4.4. We note the coincidence of the formulas for the Riemannian scalar curvature of solutions to the gravitino and dilatino equations in dimensions 6, 7, and 8. Actually, it is proved in [59] (see also [45]) that the SU(n)-geometry arising from any solution to the gravitino and dilatino equations satisfies the identity Ricg (X, Y ) −
1 H (X, ei , ej )H (Y, ei , ej ) + 2∇ g X ∇ g Y φ 4 i,j
1 + dH (X, J Y, ei , J ei ) = 0, 4
(4.31)
i
which is consistent with the first equation of motion. The trace in (4.31) gives (4.30) due to the identity 1 1 dH (X, J Y, ei , J ei ) = 8||dφ||2 + 4δdφ − ||H ||2 4 3 i
shown in [4] (see also (3.24) in [59]). Remark 4.5. We note that the Riemannian scalar curvature for a half-flat SU (3)-structure is computed in [50]. On the other hand, not every half-flat structure admits an SU (3)connection with torsion 3-form since it may have a nonzero W2 component. For example, the SU (3)-structure on the nilpotent Lie algebras described in [23], Example 2 and 3, are half-flat but do not admit an SU (3) connection with torsion 3-form since d − = f F ∧F . Another consequence of Theorem 4.1 is the following Theorem 4.6. Let (M 6 , g, J, F, ) be a smooth almost complex 6-manifold with totally skew-symmetric Nijenhuis tensor equipped with a SU (3)-structure solving the gravitino equation, i.e. the conditions (4.22) hold. Assume also the conditions dθ 6 = 0,
(N, + ) = 0,
(N, − ) = const. = 0.
(4.32)
i) Then the G2 -structure ω = −F ∧ e7 − + defined on the product M 7 = M 6 × R solves both the gravitino and dilatino equations with non-constant dilaton. ii) If in addition the torsion connection ∇ 6 is a SU (3)-instanton then the corresponding torsion connection ∇ 7 is a G2 -instanton.
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
91
iii) Suppose moreover that the torsion connection ∇ 6 satisfies the modified Bianchi 6 identity (1.1), (resp. (1.2)) with F A = R ∇ . Then ∇ 7 also obeys (1.1), (resp. (1.2)) 7 with F A = R ∇ and therefore solves the equations of motion with non zero flux and non-constant dilaton provided θ 6 is exact. Proof. Equations (4.26) and (4.28) imply (3.16) due to the conditions of the theorem. 7 6 ˜7 ˜6 We know from Theorem 4.1 that T 7 = T 6 , R ∇ = R ∇ , R ∇ = R ∇ and conse7 7 6 6 7 7 ˜ ˜ ˜6 ˜6 quently, T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ), T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ). A 7 glance at the structure of Lie algebras su(3) and g2 implies that R ∇ satisfies the G2 6 instanton equations (3.20) provided R ∇ obeys the SU (3)-instanton equations (3.19) 5. Non-Compact Spin(7)-Solution Induced from a G2 -Instanton In this section we shall show that a G2 -instanton on (N 7 , ω) induces a Spin(7)-instanton on the product N 8 = N 7 × R. We denote the Hodge star operator on N 7 by ∗7 . On the product N 8 = N 7 × R there exists a Spin(7)-structure defined by = e0 ∧ ω + ∗7 ω,
(5.33)
where e0 = dt is the standard 1-form on R. We indicate the object on the product by a 8 superscript 8, i.e. ∗8 , T 8 , θ 8 , ∇ 8 , R ∇ are the Hodge star operator, the torsion 3-form, the Lee form, the torsion connection and its curvature, respectively. The same objects on N 7 have superscript 7. Theorem 5.1. Suppose (N 7 , ω7 , g 7 , ∇ 7 , T 7 ) is a smooth G2 -manifold which solves the gravitino equation, i.e. (3.13) holds. Then the Spin(7)-structure on the product N 7 ×R determined with (5.33) has the properties 6 7 1 θ + (dω, ∗7 ω)e0 , T 8 = T 7 , 7 7 8 8 7 7 T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ).
θ8 =
R∇ = R∇ , 8
7
Assume in addition the conditions dθ 7 = 0,
(dω, ∗7 ω) = const. = 0.
i) Then the Spin(7)-structure defined on the product N 8 = N 7 × R solves both the gravitino and dilatino equations with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton. ii) If in addition the torsion connection ∇ 7 is a G2 -instanton then the corresponding torsion connection ∇ 8 is a Spin(7)-instanton. iii) Suppose moreover that the torsion connection ∇ 7 satisfies the modified Bianchi 7 identity (1.1), (resp. (1.2)) with F A = R ∇ . Then ∇ 8 also obeys (1.1), (resp. (1.2)) 8 with F A = R ∇ and therefore solves the equations of motion with non-zero flux and non-constant dilaton provided θ 7 is exact.
92
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
Proof. Take the exterior derivative in (5.33) and use (3.16) to get the identity d = −e0 ∧ dω + θ 7 ∧ ∗7 ω. The latter yields (5.34) ∗8 d = −∗7 dω − e0 ∧ ∗7 (θ 7 ∧ ∗7 ω), 8 7 7 7 7 7 7 ∗ (θ ∧ ) = −∗ (θ ∧ ω) − e0 ∧ ∗ (θ ∧ ∗ ω), (5.35) 1 θ 8 = − ∗8 ∗8 d ∧ = (5.36) 7 1 − ∗8 e0 ∧ ∗7 dω ∧ ω − e0 ∧ ∗7 θ 7 ∧ ∗7 ω ∧ ∗7 ω 7
−∗8 (∗7 dω ∧ ∗7 ω) = 1 − ∗7 ∗7 dω ∧ ω − ∗7 ∗7 θ 7 ∧ ∗7 ω ∧ ∗7 ω 7 6 1 −(dω, ∗7 ω)e0 = θ 7 + (dω, ∗7 ω)e0 , 7 7
where we used the conditions (3.16), (2.8) and the general identity ∗7 (∗7 γ ∧ ∗7 ω ∧ ∗7 ω) = 3γ valid for any 1-form γ on (M 7 , ω). Substitute (5.34), (5.35) and (5.36) into the formula (3.18) and compare the result with (3.17) to get T 8 = T 7 . The vector field e0 is parallel with respect to the Levi-Civita connection of g 8 and satis8 7 ˜8 fies T 8 (e0 , ., .) = T 7 (e0 , ., .) = 0. Therefore ∇ 8 e0 = 0 yielding R ∇ = R ∇ , R ∇ = ˜7 R ∇ . Consequently, 7 0
∇ Rmnkl mn ij = 8
7
∇ Rmnkl (∗7 ω)mn ij = 2Rij∇ kl = 2Rij∇ kl , 7
7
8
1
since R ∇ is a G2 -instanton. Clearly, the modified Bianchi identity (1.1), (resp. (1.2)) is 8 satisfied for F A = R ∇ . 7
The reverse procedure to find types of SU (3)-structures on a 6-manifold induced by different types of G2 -structures on 7-manifold is discussed recently in [8, 11, 50, 49]. 6. Examples Theorem 4.6 and Theorem 5.1 allow us to produce a number of examples of G2 and Spin(7)-instantons and solutions to the equations of motion with gauge connection A = ∇ starting from certain types of almost complex 6-manifolds or certain types of G2 manifolds. We recall the well known curvature identity 1 ˜ R ∇ (X, Y, Z, V ) = R ∇ (Z, V , X, Y ) + dT (X, Y, Z, V ). 2
(6.37)
It helps us to handle the Bianchi identity (1.2) with F A = R ∇ provided the next equality holds R ∇ (X, Y, Z, V ) = R ∇ (Z, V , X, Y ).
(6.38)
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
93
Combine (6.37) and (6.38) to get 1 ˜ R ∇ = R ∇ + dT . 2 In view of (6.39), the Bianchi identity (1.2) with A = ∇ takes the form 1 dT = α T r(R ∇ ∧ dT ) − T r(dT ∧ dT ) . 2
(6.39)
Clearly, the condition (6.38) is a sufficient SU (3) (resp. G2 , Spin(7)) -connection to satisfy the SU (3) (resp. G2 , Spin(7)) -instanton condition (3.19) (resp. (3.20),(3.21)). The symmetry (6.38) of the curvature of a metric connection ∇ with torsion 3-form T holds exactly when ∇T is a 4-form which is equivalent to the condition ∇ g T = 41 dT [56]. In particular, if the torsion is ∇-parallel, ∇T = 0, then we have the additional relations 1 1 1 g Rij∇ kl = Rij∇ kl − Tij m Tkl m − Tj km Til m − Tkim Tj l m ; (6.40) 2 4 4
m m m dTij kl = 2 Tij m Tkl + Tj km Til + Tkim Tj l . 6.1. (SU (3), G2 , Spin(7))-instanton and conformally flat non-compact solution. Any Nearly-K¨ahler 6-manifold is an SU (3)-instanton since the torsion T = 41 N = J ∇ g J is ∇- parallel [64], (see also [9, 32]) and therefore the curvature R ∇ satisfies (6.38). Take + = dF ; we obtain a SU (3)-instanton solving the gravitino and gaugino equations according to Theorem 4.6 which, however, does not solve the dilatino equation since the almost complex structure is not integrable [73]. There are known only four compact Nearly K¨ahler 6-manifolds, namely S 6 , S 3 × S 3 , CP 3 and the flag F = U (3)/(U (1) × U (1) × U (1)) [55, 72]. We consider the six-sphere (S 6 , J, g) endowed with the standard nearly K¨ahler structure (g, J ) inherited from the imaginary octonions in R7 [47]. We claim that (S 6 , g, J, ∇, A = ∇) satisfies both the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) and the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2). It is well known that any 6-dimensional Nearly K¨ahler manifold is Einstein and of constant type. Consequently, the following identities hold [32]: 1 Tij m Tkl m = a 2 (gik gj l − gj k gil − Fik Fj l + Fj k Fil ), dT = a 2 F ∧ F = −2a 2 ∗F, 2 where a 2 is a non-zero constant which can be identified with the Riemannian scalar curvature s g , 15a 2 = s g . Applying the fact that (S 6 , g) is a space of constant sectional g curvature, i.e. Rij∇ kl = 21 a 2 (gj k gil − gik gj l ) and (6.39), we calculate the Pontrjagin forms 3a 2 ∇ ab 16π 2 p1 (∇) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = Rij∇ ab Rkl dT ; dx i ∧ dx j ∧ dx k ∧ dx l = − 4 2 ˜ = T r(R ∇˜ ∧ R ∇˜ ) = 9a dT . 16π 2 p1 (∇) 4 Remark 6.1. Observe that if we rescale the metric homothetically by a constant c, g¯ = e2c g, then the new torsion T¯ = e2c T in the case of SU (3)-structure and T¯ = e4c T in the case of G2 or Spin(7)-structure while the Pontrjagin 4-forms remain unchanged, ¯
¯
T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ),
¯˜
¯˜
˜
˜
T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) (see [22] for more
94
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
precise discussion of this phenomena). Hence, if dT is proportional to the difference of the Pontrjagin 4-forms with a constant then we can always rescale the structure by a suitable constant in order to get the formulas (1.1) and (1.2). Keeping Remark 6.1 in mind we obtain Theorem 6.2. The Nearly K¨ahler 6-sphere solves the gravitino equation, the gaugino equation with F A = R ∇ and satisfies the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) and (1.2) with negative α . Consequently: a) The product (S 6 × R, ω, A = ∇ 7 ) with the G2 -structure described in Sect. 4 solves all the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 7. The product (S 6 × S 1 , ω, A = ∇ 7 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 7. b) The product (S 6 ×R×R, , A = ∇ 8 ) with the Spin(7)-structure described in Sect. 5 solves the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 8. The product (S 6 × S 1 × S 1 , , A = ∇ 8 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 8. Similarly to the SU(3)-case, any G2 -weak holonomy manifold (nearly-parallel G2 manifold) is a G2 -instanton. Indeed, it is well known that any 7-dimensional nearly-parallel G2 manifold is Einstein and the following identities hold dω = −λ∗ω,
(dω, ∗ω) = −λ,
(6.41)
8 g where λ2 = 21 s is a non-zero constant. The torsion T = − 16 λω is ∇-parallel [32]. Hence, any nearly-parallel G2 -manifold is a G2 -instanton which solves the gravitino equation and the gaugino equation with A = ∇ 7 but does not solve the dilatino equation according to the result in [34]. There are many known examples of compact nearly parallel G2 -manifolds: S 7 , SO(5)/SO(3) [17, 71], the Aloff-Wallach spaces N (g, l) = SU (3)/U (1)gl [20], any Einstein-Sasakian and any 3-Sasakian 7-manifold [35, 36]. We consider the seven sphere (S 7 , ω, g) endowed with the standard nearly-parallel G2 -structure induced by the octonions in R8 , namely, consider the seven sphere as a totally umbilical hypersurface in R8 [29]. Clearly (S 7 , ω, g, ∇, A = ∇) is a G2 -instanton. We claim that it satisfies the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) and the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2). Indeed, we easily calculate from (6.40) applying (6.41), (6.39), the fact that (S 7 , g) is a space of constant sectional curvature and some G2 -algebra, that ∇ ab 16π 2 p1 (∇) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = Rij∇ ab Rkl dx i ∧ dx j ∧ dx k ∧ dx l =
−
λ4 λ2 ∗ω = − dT ; 8.27 36
˜ = T r(R ∇˜ ∧ R ∇˜ ) = 1 λ4 ∗ω = 1 λ2 dT . 16π 2 p1 (∇) 54 9 We obtain using Remark 6.1 the following
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
95
Theorem 6.3. The nearly-parallel 7-sphere solves the gravitino equation, the gaugino equation with F A = R ∇ and satisfies the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) and (1.2) with negative α . Consequently, the product (S 7 ×R, , A = ∇ 8 ) with the Spin(7)-structure described in Sect. 5 solves the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 8. The product (S 7 × S 1 , , A = ∇ 8 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 8. We note that these sphere-solutions are (locally) conformally flat. 6.2. (SU (3), G2 , Spin(7))-instanton and non-conformally flat non-compact solution. In this section we present a non-locally-conformally flat solution starting with a nilpotent 6-dimensional Lie group. Let G be the six-dimensional connected simply connected and nilpotent Lie group, determined by the left invariant 1-forms {e1 , . . . , e6 } such that de2 = de3 = de6 = 0, de1 = e3 ∧ e6 , de4 = e2 ∧ e6 ,
(6.42) de5 = e2 ∧ e3 .
In terms of the standard coordinates x1 , . . . , x6 on R6 the left invariant forms {e1 , . . . , e6 } are described by the expressions e2 = dx2 , e3 = dx3 , e6 = dx6 , e1 = dx1 − x6 dx3 , e4 = dx4 − x6 dx2 , e5 = dx5 + x2 dx3 . 6 Consider the metric on G ∼ = R6 defined by g = i=1 ei2 , or equivalently
(6.43)
ds 2 = dx12 + (1 + x62 )dx22 + (1 + x22 + x62 )dx32 + dx42 + dx52 + dx62 −x6 (dx1 dx3 + dx2 dx4 ) + x2 dx3 dx5 . (6.44) Let (F, ) be the SU (3)-structure on G given by (2.5). Then(G, F, ) is an almost complex manifold with a SU (3)-structure. We show below that this space is a new non-conformally flat SU (3)-instanton solving both the gravitino and gaugino equations satisfying the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) as well as the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2) but not solving the dilatino equation. We compute the Riemannian curvature R g . The general Koszul formula 2g(∇ g X Y, Z) = Xg(Y, Z) + Y g(X, Z) − Zg(X, Y ) +g([XY ], Z) − g([Y, Z], X) − g([X, Z], Y )
(6.45)
gives the following essential non-zero terms 2∇ g e6 e3 = e1 , 2∇ g e2 e3 = −e5 , 2∇ g e3 e6 = −e1 , 2∇ g e3 e2 = e5 , 2∇ g e1 e6 = −e3 , 2∇ g e5 e2 = e3 ,
2∇ g e6 e2 = e4 , 2∇ g e2 e6 = −e4 , 2∇ g e4 e6 = −e2 .
(6.46)
Then we obtain R g (e5 , e6 , e2 , e1 ) = − 41 = 0. Hence, the metric is not locally conformally flat since the Weyl tensor W g (e5 , e6 , e2 , e1 ) = R g (e5 , e6 , e2 , e1 ) = − 41 = 0.
96
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
It is easy to verify using (2.4) and (6.42) that dF = −3e236 , N = − − , θ 6 = d + = (N, + ) = 0.
d − = ∗F,
(N, − ) = −4, (6.47)
Hence, (G, , g, J ) is neither complex nor Nearly K¨ahler manifold but it fulfills the conditions (4.22) of Theorem 4.1 and therefore there exists a SU (3)-holonomy connection with torsion 3-form on (G, , g, J ). The expression (4.23) and (6.47) give T = −2e145 + e136 + e235 − e246 ,
dT = −2(e1256 + e3456 + e1234 ) = 2∗F. (6.48)
Plug (6.46) and (6.48) into (3.11) to get that the nonzero essential terms of the torsion connection are ∇e1 e6 = −e3 ,
∇e5 e2 = e3 ,
∇e4 e5 = −e1 ,
∇e5 e1 = −e4 ,
∇e4 e6 = −e2 , ∇e1 e4 = −e5 .
(6.49)
It follows from (6.49) and (6.48) that the torsion tensor T as well as the Nijenhuis tensor N are parallel with respect to the connection ∇. Hence, ∇ defines an SU (3)-instanton. To verify the Bianchi identities for H we calculate the curvature R ∇ by means of (6.49). We obtain the following non-zero terms R ∇ (e6 , e2 , e6 , e2 ) = R ∇ (e6 , e3 , e6 , e3 ) = R ∇ (e2 , e3 , e2 , e3 ) = 1, R ∇ (e4 , e5 , e4 , e5 ) = R ∇ (e4 , e1 , e4 , e1 ) = R ∇ (e5 , e1 , e5 , e1 ) = 1, R ∇ (e2 , e6 , e5 , e1 ) = R ∇ (e3 , e6 , e4 , e5 ) = R ∇ (e2 , e3 , e1 , e4 ) = −1.
(6.50)
Applying (6.50), (6.48) and (6.39) it is straightforward to compute the first Pontrjagin ˜ Compare the result with the second equality in (6.48) to get 4-forms p1 (∇) and p1 (∇). dT =
1 ˜ ˜ T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = −T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ). 2
(6.51)
The coefficient of the structure equations of the Lie algebra given by (6.42) are integers. Therefore, the well-known theorem of Malcev [67] states that the group G has a uniform discrete subgroup such that N il 6 = G/ is a compact 6-dimensional nilmanifold. The SU (3)-structure, described above, descends to N il 6 and therefore we obtain a compact SU (3)-instanton. With the help of Remark 6.1 and (6.51) we derive from Theorem 4.6 and Theorem 5.1 the following Theorem 6.4. The non conformally flat almost hermitian 6-manifold (G, g, F, , A = ∇) solves the gravitino and gaugino equations and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) with positive α . Consequently, a) The product (G × R, ω, A = ∇ 7 ) with the G2 -structure described in Sect. 4 solves all the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 7. The product (N il 6 × S 1 , ω, A = ∇ 7 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1) and (1.2) in dimension 7;
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
97
b) The product (N il 6 × R × R, , A = ∇ 8 ) with the Spin(7)-structure described in Sect. 5 solves the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 8. The product (N il 6 × S 1 × S 1 , , A = ∇ 8 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 8. The G2 -analog of the Dolbeault cohomology on G2 -manifold was studied on N il 6 × S 1 in [30]. Remark 6.5. The space (G, g, J ) is an example of an almost complex 6-manifold with totally skew-symmetric Nijenhuis tensor N and zero Lee form θ 6 which is neither complex nor Nearly K¨ahler but it is half-flat and therefore it determines a Riemannian metric with holonomy contained in G2 on G × R ∼ = R7 [55] which seems to be new. The explicit expression of this metric can be found solving the Hitchin flow equations dF =
∂( + ) , ∂t
d − = −F ∧
∂(F ) , ∂t
where the SU (3)-structure depends on a real parameter t ∈ R [55]. G2 -holonomy metrics arising from types of Hermitian 6-manifolds are studied recently in [5]. Remark 6.6. The torsion tensor T as well as the Nijenhuis tensor N of (N il 6 , g, J ) are parallel with respect to the torsion connection ∇ but ∇R ∇ = 0 since the space is not naturally reductive due to the inequality −1 = g([e3 , e6 ], e1 ) = −g([e3 , e1 ], e6 ) = 0. Hence, (N il 6 , g, J ) is an example of a compact non-naturally reductive almost Hermitian 6-manifold with totally skew-symmetric Nijenhuis tensor which is neither complex nor Nearly K¨ahler. The torsion as well as the Nijenhuis tensor are parallel with respect to the torsion connection. Remark 6.7. Spaces for which the covariant derivative of the torsion is a four form (in particular zero) become automatically of ‘instanton type’. Spaces with parallel torsion are studied in [1] in connection with the string model; almost Hermitian 6-manifolds with parallel torsion are investigated very recently (after the first version of the present article was posted to the arXiv) in [3]. Remark 6.8. In general, on any almost hermitian manifold the Nijenhuis tensor N is the (3,0)+(0,3)-part of the torsion of any linear connection ∇ compatible with the almost hermitian structure (see e.g. [38]). Therefore, the condition ∇T = 0 always implies ∇N = 0 because ∇ preserves the type decomposition induced from the almost complex structure.
7. Almost Contact Metric Structures and Non-Compact SU (3)-Solutions in Dimension 6 We construct in this section a new non-compact solution to the type I-supergravity equations of motion in dimension 6. We derive our solution from Sasakian structures in dimension 5. Solutions to the gravitino and dilatino equations in dimension 5 are investigated in [32, 33]. In dimension five any solution to the gravitino equation, i.e. any parallel spinor
98
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
with respect to a metric connection with torsion 3-form defines an almost contact metric structure (g, ξ, η, ψ), which is preserved by the torsion connection [32, 33]. It is shown in [33] that solutions to both gravitino and dilatino equations are connected with a special type ‘conformal’ transformations of the almost contact structure introduced in [33]. We recall that an almost contact metric structure consists of an odd dimensional manifold M 2k+1 equipped with a Riemannian metric g, vector field ξ of length one, its dual 1-form η as well as an endomorphism ψ of the tangent bundle such that ψ(ξ ) = 0,
ψ 2 = −id + η ⊗ ξ,
g(ψ., ψ.) = g(., .) − η ⊗ η.
The Nijenhuis tensor N and the fundamental form F of an almost contact metric structure are defined by F (., .) = g(., ψ.),
N = [ψ, ψ] + dη ⊗ ξ.
There are many special types of almost contact metric structures. We introduce those which are relevant to our considerations: – – – –
normal almost contact structures determined by the condition N = 0; contact metric structures characterized by dη = 2F ; quasi-Sasaki structures, N = 0, dF = 0. Consequently, ξ is a Killing vector [13]; Sasaki structures, N = 0, dη = 2F . Consequently, ξ is a Killing vector [13].
An almost contact metric structure admits a linear connection ∇ with torsion 3-form preserving the structure, i.e. ∇g = ∇ξ = ∇ψ = 0, if and only if the Nijenhuis tensor is totally skew-symmetric and the vector field ξ is a Killing vector field [32]. In this case the torsion connection is unique. The torsion T of ∇ on a Sasakian manifold is expressed by T = η ∧ dη = 2η ∧ F and the torsion T is ∇-parallel, ∇T = 0 [32]. We restrict our attention to the Sasakian manifold in dimension five. The spinor bundle of a 5-dimensional contact metric spin manifold decomposes under the action of the fundamental 2-form F 5 into the sum = 0 ⊕ 1 ⊕ 2 , dim 0 = dim 2 = 1, dim 1 = 2. Spinors of type 1 parallel with respect to the torsion connection on quasi-Sasakian 5-manifold are studied in [33]. We are interested in ∇ 5 -parallel spinors of type 0 or 2 on Sasakian 5-manifold. We recall ([32], Theorem 9.2) that a 5-dimensional simply connected Sasakian manifold admits a ∇ 5 -parallel spinor of type 0 or 2 if and only if the Riemannian Ricci tensor Ricg has the form Ricg = 6g − 2η ⊗ η.
(7.52)
The Tanno deformation of a Sasakian structure satisfying (7.52), defined by the formulas ψ = ψ,
ξ =
3 ξ, 4
η =
4 η, 3
g =
4 4 g + η ⊗ η, 3 9
yields an Einstein-Sasakian structure with Ricci tensor Ricg = 4g and vice versa. We may choose locally an orthonormal basis e1 , e2 , e3 , e4 , e5 = ξ such that F 5 = e1 ∧ e 2 + e 3 ∧ e 4 ,
dη = de5 = 2F 5 ,
T 5 = 2η ∧ F 5 = 2e5 ∧ (e1 ∧ e2 + e3 ∧ e4 ).
(7.53)
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
99
Let M 6 = M 5 × R. We indicate the objects on M 6 with a superscript 6. Consider the product Riemannian manifold M 6 = M 5 ×R with the product metric and the compatible almost complex structure J determined by the fundamental form F 6 = F 5 + e 5 ∧ e6 ,
(7.54)
where e6 = dt is the standard 1-form on R. The identity (7.54) yields dF 6 = 2F 5 ∧ e6 = 2e6 ∧ F 6 . This equality tell us that the almost hermitian manifold (M 6 , g 6 , F 6 ) is locally conformally K¨ahler. In particular, the almost complex structure is integrable and the Lee form θ 6 = 2e6 = 2dt is a closed 1-form on R. It is easy to check that the torsion T 6 of the corresponding Bismut connection ∇ 6 is determined by the equality T 6 = T 5 . Consequently, ∇ 6 T 6 = 0. The Bismut connection defines an SU (3)-instanton on M 5 × R which solves the three supersymmetry equations (1.3) provided M 5 is a Sasakian 5-manifold whose Riemannian Ricci tensor satisfies (7.52). 7.1. Non-conformally flat local SU (3)-solutions on S 5 × S 1 . Let S 5 be the five-sphere with the standard Einstein Sasakian structure induced on S 5 by the usual complex structure on C3 considering S 5 as a totally umbilic hypersurface in the complex space C3 . We consider (S 5 , g, ψ, η, ξ ) as a Sasakian space form, i.e. a Tanno deformation of the standard Einstein-Sasakian structure on S 5 . We may assume that the Riemannian curvature is given by (see e.g. [13]) 1
4
g Rij kl = gj k gil − gik gj l + Fkj Fli − Fki Flj + 2Fij Flk 3 3 1
+ ηi ηk gj l − ηj ηk gil + ηj ηl gik − ηi ηl gj k . (7.55) 3 Consider the locally conformally K¨ahler structure on S 5 × R determined by (7.54). We claim that the corresponding Bismut connection satisfies the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) as well as the anomaly cancellation condition (1.2). Indeed, Eq. (7.53) yields dT 6 = dT 5 = dη ∧ dη = 4F 5 ∧ F 5 . Use (6.40), apply (7.53) and (7.55), to get 1 4
6 Rij∇ kl = gj k gil − gik gj l + ηi ηk gj l − ηj ηk gil + ηj ηl gik − ηi ηl gj k + dTij6 kl . 3 6 The latter equality as well as (6.39) help to calculate the Pontrjagin forms 8 6 6 16π 2 p1 (∇ 6 ) = T r(R ∇ ∧ R ∇ ) = − dT 6 , 3 Keeping Remark 6.1 in mind we obtain
16π 2 p1 (∇˜ 6 ) =
16 6 dT . 3
Theorem 7.1. The Sasakian space form (S 5 , g 5 , ψ, η, ξ ) solves the gravitino equation 5 and satisfies the modified Bianchi identity (1.1) and (1.2) for F A = R ∇ with negative α . Consequently: a) The product (S 5 × R, g 6 , F 6 , ∇ 6 , A = ∇ 6 ) solves all the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 6. The product (S 5 × S 1 , g 6 , F 6 , A = ∇ 6 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 6.
100
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
b) The product (S 5 × R × R, ω, A = ∇ 7 ) with the G2 -structure described in Sect. 4 solves all the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 7. The product (S 5 × S 1 × S 1 , ω, A = ∇ 7 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 7. c) The product (S 5 × R × R × R, , A = ∇ 8 ) with the Spin(7)-structure described in Sect. 5 solves the supersymmetry equations (1.3) with non-zero flux, non-constant dilaton and satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2). Therefore it solves the equations of motion in dimension 8. The product (S 5 × S 1 × S 1 × S 1 , , A = ∇ 8 ) is a compact space solving locally the supersymmetry equations (1.3) which satisfies the Bianchi identity (1.1), (1.2) in dimension 8. Remark 7.2. Note that all compact examples we have presented in Sects. 6 and 6 solve the supersymmetry equations only locally since the closed Lee form θ is actually a closed 1-form on a circle and therefore it can not be exact. This is consistent with the vanishing results claiming that there are no compact solutions with globally defined non-constant dilaton and non-zero flux in type II and type I supergravities. Acknowledgments. The research was done during the visit of S.I. at the Abdus Salam International Centre for Theoretical Physics, Trieste, Italy. S.I. thanks the Abdus Salam ICTP for providing support and an excellent research environment. S.I. is a member of the EDGE, Research Training Network HPRN-CT2000-00101, supported by the European Human Potential Programme. The research is partially supported by Contract MM 809/1998 with the Ministry of Science and Education of Bulgaria, Contract 586/2002 with the University of Sofia “St. Kl. Ohridski”. We thank Tony Pantev for his interest in this work, for the useful suggestions and stimulating discussions. We are also grateful to Jerome Gauntlett for his helpful comments and remarks. We would like to thank the referee for his valuable comments and suggestions on clarifying the phenomenological background, especially the form of the Bianchi identity including string corrections.
References 1. Agricola, I.: Connections on naturally reductive spaces, their Dirac operator and homogeneous models in string theory. Commun. Math. Phys. 232, 536–563 (2003) 2. Alessandrini, L., Bassanelli, G.: Metric properties of manifolds bimeromorphic to compact K¨ahler manifolds. J. Diff. Geom. 37, 95–121 (1993) 3. Alexandrov, B., Friedrich, Th., Schoemann, N.: Almost Hermitian 6-manifolds Revisited. J. Geom. Phys. 53, 1–30 (2005) 4. Alexandrov, B., Ivanov, S.: Vanishing theorems on Hermitian manifolds. Diff. Geom. Appl. 14(3), 251–265 (2001) 5. Apostolov, V., Salamon, S.: Kaehler reduction of metrics with holonomy G2 . Commun. Math. Phys. 246, 43–61 (2004) 6. Becker, K., Becker, M., Dasgupta, K., Green, P.S.: Compactifications of Heterotic Theory on NonKahler Complex Manifolds: I. JHEP 0304, 007 (2003) 7. Becker, K., Becker, M., Dasgupta, K., Green, P.S., Sharpe, E.: Compactifications of Heterotic Strings on Non-Kahler Complex Manifolds: II. Nucl. Phys. B678, 19–100 (2004) 8. Behrndt, K., Jeschek, C.: Fluxes in M-theory on 7-manifolds: G-structures and Superpotential. Nucl. Phys. B694, 99–114 (2004) 9. Belgun, F., Moroianu, A.: Nearly K¨ahler 6-manifolds with reduced holonomy. Ann. Global Anal. Geom. 19(4), 307–319 (2001) 10. Bergshoeff, E.A., de Roo, M.: The quartic effective action of the heterotic string and supersymmetry. Nucl. Phys. B328, 439 (1989) 11. Bilal, A., Derendinger, J.-P., Sfetsos, K.: (Weak) G2 Holonomy from Self-duality, Flux and Supersymmetry. Nucl.Phys. B628, 112–132 (2002)
SU (3)-Instantons and G2 , Spin(7)-Heterotic String Solitons
101
12. Bismut, J.-M.: A local index theorem for non-K¨ahler manifolds. Math. Ann. 284(4), 681–699 (1989) 13. Blair, D.: Contact manifolds in Riemannian geometry. Lect. Notes Math. Vol. 509, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York: Springer Verlag, 1976 14. Brandhuber, A., Gomis, J., Gubser, S., Gukov, S.: Gauge Theory at Large N and New G2 Holonomy Metrics. Nucl. Phys. B611, 179–204 (2001) 15. Bonan, E.: Sur le vari´et´es riemanniennes a groupe d’holonomie G2 ou Spin(7). C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris 262, 127–129 (1966) 16. Bryant, R.: Metrics with exeptional holonomy. Ann. Math. 126, 525–576 (1987) 17. Bryant, R., Salamon, S.: On the construction of some complete metrics with exceptional holonomy. Duke Math. J. 58, 829–850 (1989) 18. Cabrera, F.: On Riemannian manifolds with Spin(7)-structure. Publ. Math. Debrecen 46(3–4), 271– 283 (1995) 19. Cabrera, F.: On Riemannian manifolds with G2 -structure. Bolletino UMI A 10(7), 98–112 (1996) 20. Cabrera, F., Monar, M., Swann, A.: Classification of G2 -structures. J. Lond. Math. Soc. 53, 407–416 (1996) 21. Cardoso, G.L., Curio, G., Dall’Agata, G., Lust, D., Manousselis, P., Zoupanos, G.: Non-Kaehler String Backgrounds and their Five Torsion Classes. Nucl.Phys. B652, 5–34 (2003) 22. Cardoso, G.L., Curio, G., Dall’Agata, G., Lust, D.: BPS Action and Superpotential for Heterotic String Compactifications with Fluxes. JHEP 0310, 004 (2003) 23. Chiossi, S., Salamon, S.: The intrinsic torsion of SU(3) and G2 -structures. In: Differential Geometry, Valencia 2001, Singapore World Sci. Publishing, 2002, pp. 115–133 24. Corrigan, E., Devchand, C., Fairlie, D.B., Nuyts, J.: First-order equations for gauge fields in spaces of dimension greater than four. Nucl. Phys. B 214(3), 452–464 (1983) 25. de Wit, B., Smit, D.J., Hari Dass, N.D.: Residual Supersimmetry Of Compactified D=10 Supergravity. Nucl. Phys. B 283, 165 (1987) 26. Donaldson, S.K., Thomas, R.P.: Gauge theory in higher dimensions. In: The geometric universe (Oxford, 1996), Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press, 1998, pp 31–47 27. Fairlie, D.B., Nuyts, J.: Spherically symmetric solutions of gauge theories in eight dimensions. J. Phys. A17, 2867 (1984) 28. Fernandez, M.: A classification of Riemannian manifolds with structure group Spin(7). Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. 143, 101–122 (1982) 29. Fernandez, M., Gray, A.: Riemannian manifolds with structure group G2 . Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. 32(4), 19–45 (1982) 30. Fern´andez, M., Ugarte, L.: Dolbeault cohomology for G2 -manifolds. Geom. Dedicata 70(1), 57–86 (1998) 31. Freedman, D.Z., Gibbons, G.W., West, P.C.: Ten Into Four Won’t Go. Phys. Lett. B 124, 491 (1983) 32. Friedrich, Th., Ivanov, S.: Parallel spinors and connections with skew-symmetric torsion in string theory. Asian J. Math. 6, 3003–3036 (2002) 33. Friedrich, Th., Ivanov, S.: Almost contact manifolds, connections with torsion, parallel spinors. J. Reine Angew. Math. 559, 217–236 (2003) 34. Friedrich, Th., Ivanov, S.: Killing spinor equations in dimension 7 and geometry of integrable G2 manifolds. J. Geom. Phys 48, 1–11 (2003) 35. Friedrich, Th., Kath, I.: 7-dimensional compact Riemannian manifolds with Killing spinors. Commun. Math. Phys. 133(3), 543–561 (1990) 36. Friedrich, Th., Kath, I., Moroianu, A., Semmelmann, U.: On nearly parallel G2 -structures. J. Geom. Phys. 23(3-4), 259–286 (1997) 37. Fubini, S., Nikolai, H.: The octonionic instanton. Phys. Let. B 155, 369 (1985) 38. Gauduchon, P.: Hermitian connections and Dirac operators. Boll. Un. Mat. Ital. B (7) 11(2), Suppl., 257–288 (1997) 39. Gauduchon, P.: Fibr´es hermitiens a` endomorphisme de Ricci non n´egatif. Bull. Soc. Math. France 105(2), 113–140 (1977) 40. Gauntlett, J., Kim, N., Martelli, D., Waldram, D.: Fivebranes wrapped on SLAG three-cycles and related geometry. JHEP 0111, 018 (2001) 41. Gauntlett, J.P., Martelli, D., Pakis, S., Waldram, D.: G-Structures and Wrapped NS5-Branes. Commun. Math. Phys. 247, 421–445 (2004) 42. Gauntlett, J., Martelli, D., Waldram, D.: Superstrings with Intrinsic torsion. Phys. Rev. D69, 086002 (2004) 43. Gibbons, G.W., Lu, H., Pope, C.N., Stelle, K.S.: Supersymmetric Domain Walls from Metrics of Special Holonomy. Nucl. Phys. B623, 3–46 (2002) 44. Gibbons, G.W., Page, D.N., Pope, C.N.: Einstein metrics on S 3 , R3 , and R4 bundles. Commun. Math. Phys. 127, 529–553 (1990) 45. Gillard, J., Papadopoulos, G., Tsimpis, D.: Anomaly, Fluxes and (2,0) Heterotic-String Compactifications. JHEP 0306, 035 (2003)
102
P. Ivanov, S. Ivanov
46. Goldstein, E., Prokushkin, S.: Geometric Model for Complex Non-Kaehler Manifolds with SU(3) Structure. Commun. Math. Phys. 251, 65–78 (2004) 47. Gray, A.: Vector cross product on manifolds. Trans. Am. Math. Soc. 141, 463–504 (1969) Correction 148, 625 (1970) 48. Gray, A., Hervella, L.: The sixteen classes of almost Hermitian manifolds and their linear invariants. Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. 123(4), 35–58 (1980) 49. Gurrieri, S., Micu, A.: Type IIB Theory on Half-flat Manifolds. Class.Quant.Grav. 20, 2181–2192 (2003) 50. Gurrieri, S., Louis, J., Micu, A., Waldram, D.: Mirror Symmetry in Generalized Calabi-Yau Compactifications. Nucl.Phys. B654, 61–113 (2003) 51. Gutowski, J., Ivanov, S., Papadopoulos, G.: Deformations of generalized calibrations and compact non-Kahler manifolds with vanishing first Chern class. Asian J. Math. 7, 39–80 (2003) 52. G¨unaydin, M., Nikolai, H.: Seven-dimensional octonionic Yang-Mills instanton and its extension to an heterotic string soliton. Phys. Lett. B 353, 169 (1991) 53. Harvey, R., Lawson, H.B.: Calibrated geometries. Acta Math. 148, 47–157 (1982) 54. Harvey, J.A., Strominger, A.: Octonionic superstring solitons. Phys. Review Let. 66(5), 549 (1991) 55. Hitchin, N.: Stable forms and special metrics. In: Global differential geometry: the mathematical legacy of Alfred Gray (Bilbao, 2000), Contemp. Math. 288, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc., 2001 pp. 70–89 56. Ivanov, S.: Geometry of quaternionic K¨ahler connections with torsion. J. Geom. Phys. 41(3), 235– 257 (2002) 57. Ivanov, S.: Connection with torsion, parallel spinors and geometry of Spin(7) manifolds. Math. Res. Lett. 11(2–3), 171–186 (2004) 58. Ivanov, S., Papadopoulos, G.: A no-go theorem for string warped compactifications. Phys.Lett. B497, 309–316 (2001) 59. Ivanov, S., Papadopoulos, G.: Vanishing Theorems and String Backgrounds. Class.Quant.Grav. 18, 1089–1110 (2001) 60. Joyce, D.: Compact Riemannian 7-manifolds with holonomy G2 . I. J.Diff. Geom. 43, 291–328 (1996) 61. Joyce, D.: Compact Riemannian 7-manifolds with holonomy G2 . II. J.Diff. Geom. 43, 329–375 (1996) 62. Joyce, D.: Compact Riemannian manifolds with special holonomy, Oxford Oxford University Press, 2000 63. Kachru, S., Schulz, M.B., Tripathy, P.K., Trivedi, S.P.: New Supersymmetric String Compactifications. JHEP 0303, 061 (2003) 64. Kirichenko, V.: K-spaces of maximal rank. Mat. Zam. 22, 465–476 (1977) (In Russian) 65. Kovalev, A.: Twisted connected sums and special Riemannian holonomy. J. Reine Angew. Math. 565, 125–160 (2003) 66. Lawson, B., Michelsohn, M.-L.: Spin Geometry. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1989 67. Malcev, A.I.: On a class of homogeneous spaces. Reprinted in Amer. Math. Soc. Trans. Series 1, 9, 276–307 (1962) 68. Michelsohn, M.L.: On the existence of special metrics in complex geometry. Acta Math. 149(3–4), 261–295 (1982) 69. Papadopoulos, G.: (2,0)-supersymmetric sigma models and almost complex structures. Nucl.Phys. B448, 199–219 (1995) 70. Reyes Carrin, R.: A generalization of the notion of instanton. Diff. Geom. Appl. 8(1), 1–20 (1998) 71. Salamon, S.: Riemannian geometry and holonomy groups. Pitman Res. Notes Math. Ser. 201, London: Pitman 1989 72. Salamon, S.: Almost parallel structures. In: Global differential geometry: the mathematical legacy of Alfred Gray (Bilbao, 2000), Contemp. Math. 288, Providence, RI: Amer. Math. Soc. 2001 pp 162–181 73. Strominger, A.: Superstrings with torsion. Nucl. Phys. B 274, 253 (1986) 74. Ugarte, L.: Coeffective Numbers of Riemannian 8-manifold with Holonomy in Spin(7). Ann. Glob. Anal. Geom. 19, 35–53 (2001) Communicated by G. W. Gibbons
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 103–128 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1297-6
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives. Global Analysis and Cohomology 1
Giovanni Giachetta , Luigi Mangiarotti1 , Gennadi Sardanashvily2 1 2
Department of Mathematics and Informatics, University of Camerino, 62032 Camerino (MC), Italy Department of Theoretical Physics, Physics Faculty, Moscow State University, 117234 Moscow, Russia
Received: 28 May 2004 / Accepted: 20 July 2004 Published online: 18 February 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: Lagrangian contact supersymmetries (depending on derivatives of arbitrary order) are treated in a very general setting. The cohomology of the variational bicomplex on an arbitrary graded manifold and the iterated cohomology of a generic nilpotent contact supersymmetry are computed. In particular, the first variational formula and conservation laws for Lagrangian systems on graded manifolds using contact supersymmetries are obtained. 1. Introduction At present, BRST transformations in the BV formalism [7, 24] provide the most interesting example of Lagrangian contact supersymmetries, depending on derivatives and preserving the contact ideal of graded exterior forms. Much that is already known regarding Lagrangian BRST theory (including the short variational complex, BRST cohomology [4, 5, 8], Noether’s conservation laws [5, 16, 19]) has been formulated in terms of jet manifolds of vector bundles (see [5] for a survey) since the jet manifold formalism provides the algebraic description of Lagrangian and Hamiltonian systems of both even and odd variables. In spite of this formulation, most authors however assume the base manifold X of these bundles to be contractible because, e.g., the relative (local in the terminology of [4, 5]) cohomology are not trivial even when X = Rn . Stimulated by the BRST theory, we consider Lagrangian systems of odd variables and contact supersymmetries in a very general setting. For this purpose, one usually calls into play fiber bundles over supermanifolds [12, 13, 17, 34]. We describe odd variables and their jets on an arbitrary smooth manifold X as generating elements of the structure ring of a graded manifold whose body is X [32, 38, 39]. This definition differs from that of jets of a graded fiber bundle [27], but reproduces the heuristic notion of jets of ghosts in the field-antifield BRST theory on Rn [5, 9]. Our goal is the following. Firstly, we construct the Z2 -graded variational bicomplex on a graded manifold with an arbitrary body X, and obtain the cohomology of its short
104
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
variational subcomplex and the complex of one-contact graded forms (Theorem 4.1). In particular, the first variational formula and conservation laws for Lagrangian systems on graded manifolds using contact supersymmetries are obtained (formulae (5.4) – (5.5)). Secondly, the iterated cohomology of a generic nilpotent contact supersymmetry is computed (Theorems 6.2, 6.4 and 6.5). In the most interesting case of the form degree n = dim X, it coincides with the above mentioned relative cohomology. Therefore, we extend the results of [5] and our recent work [21] to an arbitrary nilpotent contact supersymmetry. As is well-known, generalized (depending on derivatives) symmetries of differential equations have been intensively investigated [3, 11, 29, 30, 35]. Generalized symmetries of Lagrangian systems on a local coordinate domain have been described in detail [11, 35]. The variational bicomplex constructed in the framework of the infinite order jet formalism enables one to provide the global analysis of Lagrangian systems on a fiber bundle and their symmetries [2, 22, 32, 42]. Sketched in Sect. 2 of our work, this analysis is extended to Lagrangian systems on graded manifolds (Sect. 3). Recall that an r-order Lagrangian on a fiber bundle Y → X is defined as a horizontal n
density L : J r Y → ∧ T ∗ X, n = dim X, on the r-order jet manifold J r Y of sections of Y → X. With the inverse system of finite order jet manifolds r πr−1
π01
π
X ←− Y ←− J 1 Y ←− · · · J r−1 Y ←− J r Y ←− · · · ,
(1.1)
we have the direct system π∗
r ∗ πr−1
π01 ∗
∗ O∗ (X) −→ O∗ (Y ) −→ O1∗ −→ · · · Or−1 −→ Or∗ −→ · · ·
(1.2)
of graded differential algebras (henceforth GDAs) of exterior forms on jet manifolds r ∗ . Its direct limit is the GDA O ∗ with respect to the pull-back monomorphisms πr−1 ∞ consisting of all the exterior forms on finite order jet manifolds modulo the pull-back ∗ is decomposed into the sum d = d + d identification. The exterior differential on O∞ H V ∗ into a bicomplex. of the total and the vertical differentials. These differentials split O∞ Introducing the projector (2.3) and the variational operator δ, one obtains the var∗ . Its d - and δ-cohomology (Theorem 2.1) has been iational bicomplex (2.4) of O∞ H obtained in several steps [1, 2, 22, 35, 41–43]. In order to define the variational bicomplex on graded manifolds (Sect. 3), let us recall that, by virtue of Batchelor’s theorem [6], any graded manifold (A, X) with a body X is isomorphic to the one whose structure sheaf AQ is formed by germs of sections of the exterior product 2
∧Q∗ = R ⊕ Q∗ ⊕ ∧ Q∗ ⊕ · · · , X
X
(1.3)
X
where Q∗ is the dual of some real vector bundle Q → X. In field models, a vector bundle Q is usually given from the beginning. Therefore, we consider graded manifolds (X, AQ ) where Batchelor’s isomorphism holds. We agree to call (X, AQ ) the simple graded manifold constructed from Q. Accordingly, r-order jets of odd fields are defined as generating elements of the structure ring of the simple graded manifold (X, AJ r Q ) constructed from the jet bundle J r Q → X of Q which is also a vector bundle [32, 39]. Let CJ∗ r Q be the bigraded differential algebra (henceforth BGDA) of Z2 -graded (or, simply, graded) exterior forms on the graded manifold (X, AJ r Q ). A linear bundle r : J r Q → J r−1 Q yields the corresponding monomorphism of BGDAs morphism πr−1 ∗ ∗ CJ r−1 Q → CJ r Q [6, 32]. Hence, there is the direct system of BGDAs
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives π01∗
105
r ∗ πr−1
∗ CQ −→ CJ∗ 1 Q · · · −→ CJ∗ r Q −→ · · · ,
(1.4)
∗ consists of graded exterior forms on graded manifolds (X, A r ), whose direct limit C∞ J Q r ∈ N, modulo the pull-back identification. This definition of odd jets enables one to describe odd and even variables (e.g., fields, ghosts and antifields in BRST theory) on the same footing. Namely, let Y → X be an ∗ ⊂ O ∗ the C ∞ (X)-subalgebra of exterior forms whose coeffiaffine bundle and P∞ ∞ cients are polynomial in the fiber coordinates on jet bundles J r Y → X. This notion is ∗ is an exterior form on some finite order jet manifold intrinsic since any element of O∞ ∗ of graded and all jet bundles J r Y → X are affine. Let us consider the product S∞ ∗ ∗ ∗ algebras C∞ and P∞ over their common subalgebra O (X) of exterior forms on X. It is a BGDA which is split into the Z2 -graded variational bicomplex, analogous to that of ∗ . O∞ In Sect. 4, we obtain cohomology of some subcomplexes of the variational bicom∗ when X is an arbitrary manifold (Theorem 4.1). They are the short variational plex S∞ complex (4.1) of horizontal (local in the terminology of [5, 8]) graded exterior forms and the complex (4.2) of one-contact graded forms. For this purpose, one however must: (i) ∗ to the BGDA (S∗ ) of graded exterior forms of locally finite jet enlarge the BGDA S∞ ∞ order, (ii) compute the cohomology of the corresponding complexes of (S∗∞ ), and (iii) ∗ . Following this proceprove that this cohomology of (S∗∞ ) coincides with that of S∞ dure, we show that cohomology of the complex (4.1) equals the de Rham cohomology of X, while the complex (4.2) is globally exact. Note that the exactness of the short variational complex (4.1) on X = Rn has been repeatedly proved [5, 8, 14]. One has also considered its subcomplex of graded exterior forms whose coefficients are constant on Rn . Its dH -cohomology is not trivial [5]. The exactness of the complex (4.2) enables us to generalize the first variational formula and Lagrangian conservation laws in the calculus of variations on fiber bundles to graded Lagrangians and contact supersymmetries of arbitrary order (Sect. 5). Cohomology of the short variational complex (4.1) and its modification (6.2) is the main ingredient in a computation of the iterated cohomology of nilpotent contact supersymmetries. By analogy with a contact symmetry (Proposition 2.3), an infinitesimal contact supertransformation or, simply, a contact supersymmetry υ is defined as a graded derivation 0 such that the Lie derivative L preserves the contact ideal of the BGDA of the R-ring S∞ υ ∗ . The BRST transformation υ (5.7) in gauge theory on principal bundles exemplifies S∞ a first order contact supersymmetry such that the Lie derivative Lυ of horizontal graded exterior forms is nilpotent. This fact motivates us to study nilpotent contact supersymmetries in a general setting. The key point is that the Lie derivative Lυ along a contact supersymmetry and the total differential dH mutually commute. When Lυ is nilpotent (Lemma 5.3), we suppose 0,∗ that the dH -complex S∞ of horizontal graded exterior forms is split into the bicomplex k,m {S } with respect to the nilpotent operator
sυ φ = (−1)|φ| Lυ φ,
0,∗ φ ∈ S∞ ,
(1.5)
and the total differential dH . In the case of the above mentioned BRST transformation υ (5.7), sυ (1.5) is the BRST operator. One usually studies the relative cohomology H ∗,∗ (sυ /dH ) of sυ with respect to the total differential dH (see [15] for the BRST cohomology modulo the exterior differential d). This cohomology is not trivial even when X = Rn , but it can be related to the total (sυ + dH )-cohomology only in the form
106
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
degree n = dim X. We consider the iterated cohomology H ∗,∗ (sυ |dH ) of the bicomplex {S k,m } (Sect. 6). In the most interesting case of form degree n = dim X, relative and iterated cohomology groups coincide. They naturally characterize graded Lagrangians 0,∗ L ∈ S ∗,n , for which υ is a variational symmetry, modulo Lie derivatives Lυ ξ , ξ ∈ S∞ , and dH -exact graded exterior forms. Using the fact that dH -cocycles are represented by exterior forms on X and that any exterior form on X is sυ -closed, we obtain the iterated cohomology H ∗,m
y λ+ = i
∂x µ
i d y , λ µ ∂x
0 ≤ | |,
(2.1)
of J ∞ Y , where = (λk ...λ1 ) is a symmetric multi-index, λ + = (λλk ...λ1 ), and dλ = ∂λ +
| |≥0
d = dλr ◦ · · · ◦ dλ1 ,
i yλ+ ∂i ,
= (λr ...λ1 ),
(2.2)
are the total derivatives. Hereafter, we fix an atlas of Y and, consequently, that of J ∞ Y ∗ containing a finite number of charts [26]. Restricted to the chart (2.1), the GDA O∞ λ can be written in a coordinate form; horizontal forms {dx } and contact one-forms i = dy i − y i λ 0 ∗ {θ λ+ dx } make up a local basis for the O∞ -algebra O∞ .
∗ = ⊕O k,m of O ∗ into O 0 -modules O k,m There is the canonical decomposition O∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ of k-contact and m-horizontal forms together with the corresponding projections hk : ∗ → O k,∗ and hm : O ∗ → O ∗,m . Accordingly, the exterior differential on O ∗ is O∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ split into the sum d = dH + dV of the total and vertical differentials
dH ◦ hk = hk ◦ d ◦ hk , dV ◦ hm = hm ◦ d ◦ hm ,
dH ◦ h0 = h0 ◦ d, dH (φ) = dx λ ∧ dλ (φ), i ∗ dV (φ) = θ ∧ ∂i φ, φ ∈ O∞ .
One also introduces the R-module projector =
1 k>0
k
◦ hk ◦ hn ,
(φ) =
| |≥0
(−1)| | θ i ∧ [d (∂i φ)],
>0,n φ ∈ O∞ ,
(2.3)
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
107
∗ such that ◦ d = 0 and the nilpotent variational operator δ = ◦ d on O ∗,n . of O∞ H V ∞ k,n ∗ is split into the variational bicomplex Put Ek = (O∞ ). Then the GDA O∞
dV
0 →
1,0 O∞ dV
0 → R →
−→ dH
0,1 O∞
π ∞∗ d
dV dH
−→ · · ·
6
−→
6 0
1,1 O∞
dV
O 0 (X) −→
6
6
dV dH
6
0 O∞ π ∞∗
0 → R →
6
dV dH
−→ · · ·
6
6 1,m O∞
π ∞∗ d
6
dV dH
−→ · · ·
6
0,m O∞
1,n O∞
dH
−→ · · ·
6
0,n O∞ π ∞∗
6
6
−δ
6
−→
E1 → 0
≡
6
0,n O∞
(2.4)
d
O m (X) −→ · · ·
O n (X) −→ 0
6
0
−δ
6
dV
d
O 1 (X) −→ · · ·
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
6
0
0
Its cohomology has been obtained in several steps (see the outline of proof of Theorem 2.1 in Appendix A). Theorem 2.1. (i) The second row from the bottom and the last column of this bicomplex make up the variational complex dH
dH
δ
δ
0 0,1 0,n 0 → R → O∞ −→ O∞ · · · −→ O∞ −→ E1 −→ E2 −→ · · · .
(2.5)
Its cohomology is isomorphic to the de Rham cohomology of the fiber bundle Y . (ii) The rows of contact forms of the bicomplex (2.4) are exact sequences. One can think of the elements 0,n L = Lω ∈ O∞ , δL = (−1)| | d (∂i L)θ i ∧ ω ∈ E1 ,
ω = dx 1 ∧ · · · ∧ dx n ,
| |≥0
of the variational complex (2.5) as being a finite order Lagrangian and its Euler–Lagrange operator, respectively. Corollary 2.2. The exactness of the row of one-contact forms of the variational bicom1,n plex (2.4) at the term O∞ relative to the projector provides the R-module decomposition 1,n 1,n−1 O∞ = E1 ⊕ dH (O∞ ) 0,n , the corresponding decomposition and, given a Lagrangian L ∈ O∞
dL = δL − dH .
(2.6)
The form in the decomposition (2.6) is not uniquely defined. It reads λν ...ν
= Fi s 1 θνis ...ν1 ∧ ωλ , Fiνk ...ν1 = ∂iνk ...ν1 L − dλ Fiλνk ...ν1 +hνi k ...ν1 , ωλ = ∂λ ω, s=0 (ν ν
)...ν
1 0 obey the relations hν = 0, h k k−1 = 0. It follows where local functions h ∈ O∞ i i that L = + L is a Lepagean equivalent of a finite order Lagrangian L [25]. The decomposition (2.6) leads to the first variational formula (2.15) and the Lagrangian conservation law (2.16) as follows.
108
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
0 of the R-ring O 0 such that the Lie derivative L preserves A derivation υ ∈ dO∞ υ ∞ ∗ (i.e., the Lie derivative L of a contact form is a contact the contact ideal of the GDA O∞ υ form) is called an infinitesimal contact transformation or, simply, a contact symmetry (by analogy with C-transformations in [30] though υ need not come from a morphism of J ∞ Y ). Proposition 2.3 below shows that, restricted to a coordinate chart (2.1) and a GDA Or∗ of finite jet order, any contact symmetry υ is the jet prolongation of a generalized vector field in [35]. 0 is isomorphic to the O 0 -dual (O 1 )∗ Proposition 2.3. (i) The derivation module dO∞ ∞ ∞ 1 0 is of the module of one-forms O∞ . (ii) Relative to an atlas (2.1), a derivation υ ∈ dO∞ given by the expression i υ = υ λ ∂λ + υ i ∂i + υ ∂i , (2.7) | |>0
i are local smooth functions of finite jet order obeying the transformation where υ λ , υ i , υ law
υ = λ
∂x λ µ υ , ∂x µ
υ = i
∂y i j ∂y i µ υ + µυ , ∂y j ∂x
υ = i
∂y i ||≤| |
j
∂y
j
υ +
∂y i µ υ . ∂x µ (2.8)
(iii) A derivation υ (2.7) is a contact symmetry iff i i υ = d (υ i − yµi υ µ ) + yµ+ υ µ,
0 < | |.
(2.9)
∗ is generated by elements df , f ∈ O 0 . It suffices Proof. (i) At first, let us show that O∞ ∞ 1 0 -linear combination of elements df , to justify that any element of O∞ is a finite O∞ 0 . Indeed, every φ ∈ O 1 is an exterior form on some finite order jet manifold f ∈ O∞ ∞ r J Y . By virtue of the Serre–Swan theorem extended to non-compact manifolds [36, 40], the C ∞ (J r Y )-module Or∗ of one-forms on J r Y is a projective module of finite rank, i.e., φ is represented by a finite C ∞ (J r Y )-linear combination of elements df , 0 . Any element ∈ (O 1 )∗ yields a derivation υ (f ) = (df ) f ∈ C ∞ (J r Y ) ⊂ O∞ ∞ 0 1 is generated by elements df , f ∈ O 0 , different of the R-ring O∞ . Since the module O∞ ∞ 1 )∗ provide different derivations of O 0 , i.e., there is a monomorphism elements of (O∞ ∞ 1 )∗ → dO 0 . By the same formula, any derivation υ ∈ dO 0 sends df → υ(f ) (O∞ ∞ ∞ 0 is generated by elements df , it defines a morphism : O 1 → O 0 . and, since O∞ υ ∞ ∞ Moreover, different derivations υ provide different morphisms υ . Thus, we have a 0 → (O 1 )∗ . monomorphism and, consequently, an isomorphism dO∞ ∞ 1 0 -module generated by the (ii) Restricted to a coordinate chart (2.1), O∞ is a free O∞ i . Then dO 0 = (O 1 )∗ restricted to this chart consists of eleexterior forms dx λ , θ ∞ ∞ i . The transformation rule (2.8) results ments (2.7), where ∂λ , ∂i are the duals of dx λ , θ from the transition functions (2.1). The interior product υ φ and the Lie derivative Lυ φ, ∗ , obey the standard formulae. Restricted to a coordinate chart, the Lie derivative φ ∈ O∞ Lυ sends each finite jet order GDA Or∗ to another finite jet order GDA Os∗ . Since the ∗ . atlas (2.1) is finite, Lυ φ preserves O∞ (iii) The expression (2.9) results from a direct computation similar to that of the first part of B¨acklund’s theorem [29]. One can then justify that local functions (2.9) satisfy the transformation law (2.8).
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
109
Any contact symmetry admits the horizontal splitting υ = υH + υV = υ λ dλ + (ϑ i ∂i +
| |>0
ϑ i = υ i − yµi υ µ , (2.10)
d ϑ i ∂i ),
0 [32]. relative to the canonical connection ∇ = dx λ ⊗ dλ on the C ∞ (X)-ring O∞
Lemma 2.4. Any vertical contact symmetry υ = υV obeys the relations υ dH φ = −dH (υ φ), Lυ (dH φ) = dH (Lυ φ),
∗ φ ∈ O∞ .
(2.11) (2.12)
Proof. It is easily justified that, if φ and φ satisfy the relation (2.11), then φ ∧ φ does i . The well. Then it suffices to prove the relation (2.11) when φ is a function and φ = θ result follows from the equalities i i υ θ = υ ,
i i dH (υ ) = υλ+ dx λ ,
i dH θλi = dx λ ∧ θλ+ , (2.13)
i i ∂i = v ∂i ◦ dλ . dλ ◦ v
The relation (2.12) is a corollary of the equality (2.11).
(2.14)
0,n Proposition 2.5. Given a Lagrangian L = Lω ∈ O∞ , its Lie derivative Lυ L along a contact symmetry υ (2.10) fulfills the first variational formula
Lυ L = υV δL + dH (h0 (υ
L )) + LdV (υH ω),
(2.15)
where L is a Lepagean equivalent, e.g., a Poincar´e–Cartan form of L. Proof. The formula (2.15) comes from the splitting (2.6) and the relation (2.11) as follows: Lυ L = υ dL + d(υ L) = [υV dL − dV L ∧ υH ω] + [dH (υH L) + dV (LυH ω)] = υV dL + dH (υH L) + LdV (υH ω) = υV δL − υV dH + dH (υH L) + LdV (υH ω) = υV δL + dH (υV
+ υH L) + LdV (υH ω), where υV
= h0 (υ
) since is a one-contact form, υH L = h0 (υ L), and L =
+ L. Let υ be a variational symmetry of L (in the terminology of [35]), i.e., Lυ L = dH σ , 0,n−1 σ ∈ O∞ . By virtue of the expression (2.15), this condition implies that υ is projected onto X. Then the first variational formula (2.15) restricted to Ker δL leads to the weak conservation law 0 ≈ dH (h0 (υ
L ) − σ ).
(2.16)
110
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
3. Z2 -Graded Variational Bicomplex Let (X, AQ ) be the simple graded manifold constructed from a vector bundle Q → X of fiber dimension m. Its structure ring AQ of sections of AQ consists of sections of the exterior bundle (1.3) called graded functions. Given bundle coordinates (x λ , q a ) on Q with transition functions q a = ρba q b , let {ca } be the corresponding fiber bases for Q∗ → X, together with transition functions c a = ρba cb . Then (x λ , ca ) is called the local basis for the graded manifold (X, AQ ) [6, 32]. With respect to this basis, graded functions read f =
m 1 fa ...a ca1 · · · cak , k! 1 k k=0
where fa1 ···ak are local smooth real functions on X. Given a graded manifold (X, AQ ), by the sheaf dAQ of graded derivations of AQ is meant a subsheaf of endomorphisms of the structure sheaf AQ such that any section u of dAQ over an open subset U ⊂ X is a Z2 -graded derivation of the Z2 -graded ring AQ (U ) of graded functions on U , i.e., u(ff ) = u(f )f + (−1)[u][f ] f u(f ),
f, f ∈ AQ (U ),
where [.] denotes the Grassmann parity. One can show that sections of dAQ over U exhaust all Z2 -graded derivations of the ring AQ (U ) [6]. Let dAQ be the Lie superalgebra of Z2 -graded derivations of the R-ring AQ . Its elements are called Z2 -graded (or, simply, graded) vector fields on (X, AQ ). Due to the canonical splitting V Q = Q × Q, the vertical tangent bundle V Q → Q of Q → X can be provided with the fiber bases {∂a } which is the dual of {ca }. Then a graded vector field takes the local form u = uλ ∂λ + ua ∂a , where uλ , ua are local graded functions. It acts on AQ by the rule u(fa...b ca · · · cb ) = uλ ∂λ (fa...b )ca · · · cb + ud fa...b ∂d (ca · · · cb ).
(3.1)
This rule implies the corresponding transformation law u = uλ , λ
u = ρja uj + uλ ∂λ (ρja )cj . a
Then one can show [32, 38] that graded vector fields on a simple graded manifold can be represented by sections of the vector bundle VQ → X which is locally isomorphic to the vector bundle ∧Q∗ ⊗X (Q ⊕X T X), and is equipped with the bundle coordinates (x˙aλ1 ...ak , vbi 1 ...bk ), k = 0, . . . , m, together with the transition functions x˙ i1 ...ik = ρ −1 ia11 · · · ρ −1 iakk x˙aλ1 ...ak , j i −1 b1 −1 bk v j1 ...jk = ρ j1 · · · ρ jk ρji vb1 ...bk + λ
k! λ i ∂λ ρbk . x˙ (k − 1)! b1 ...bk−1
Using this fact, we can introduce graded exterior forms on the simple graded mani∗ , where V ∗ → X is the pointwise fold (X, AQ ) as sections of the exterior bundle ∧ VQ Q ∧Q∗ -dual of VQ . Relative to the dual bases {dx λ } for T ∗ X and {dcb } for Q∗ , graded one-forms read φ = φλ dx λ + φa dca ,
φa = ρ −1ba φb ,
φλ = φλ + ρ −1ba ∂λ (ρja )φb cj .
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
111
The duality morphism is given by the interior product u φ = uλ φλ + (−1)[φa ] ua φa . ∗ with respect to the bigraded exterior Graded exterior forms constitute the BGDA CQ product ∧ and the exterior differential d. The standard formulae of a BGDA hold. Since the jet bundle J r Q → X of a vector bundle Q → X is a vector bundle, let us consider the simple graded manifold (X, AJ r Q ) constructed from J r Q → X. Its local a }, 0 ≤ | | ≤ r, together with the transition functions basis is {x λ , c a j a c λ+ = dλ (ρja c ), dλ = ∂λ + cλ+ ∂a , (3.2) | |
a. where ∂a are the duals of c ∗ Let CJ r Q be the BGDA of graded exterior forms on the graded manifold (X, AJ r Q ). ∗ of the direct system (1.4) inherits the BGDA operations intertwined The direct limit C∞ r ∗ . It is locally a free C ∞ (X)-algebra countably generated by the monomorphisms πr−1 a a = dca − ca λ by the elements (1, c , dx λ , θ λ+ dx ), 0 ≤ | |. It should be emphasized ∗ ∗ that, in contrast with the GDA O∞ , the BGDA C∞ consists of sections of sheaves over X. In order to regard these algebras on the same footing, let Y → X hereafter be an affine ∗ is an algebra of sections of some sheaf bundle. Then one can show that the GDA O∞ over X (see Appendix B). Let us consider the above mentioned polynomial subalgebra ∗ of O ∗ and the product C ∗ ∧ P ∗ of graded algebras C ∗ and P ∗ over their common P∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ graded subalgebra O∗ (X) of exterior forms on X. It consists of the elements ∗ ∗ ψi ⊗ φ i , φi ⊗ ψ i , ψ ∈ C∞ , φ ∈ P∞ , i
i ∗ C∞
∗ P∞
∗ ⊗ C ∗ of the C ∞ (X)-modules C ∗ and P ∗ of the tensor products ⊗ and P∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ which are subject to the commutation relations ∗ ψ ⊗ φ = (−1)|ψ||φ| φ ⊗ ψ, ψ ∈ C∞ , ∗ (ψ ∧ σ ) ⊗ φ = ψ ⊗ (σ ∧ φ), σ ∈ O (X),
∗ φ ∈ P∞ ,
(3.3)
and the multiplication
(ψ ⊗ φ) ∧ (ψ ⊗ φ ) := (−1)|ψ ||φ| (ψ ∧ ψ ) ⊗ (φ ∧ φ ).
(3.4)
Elements ψ ⊗φ are endowed with the total form degree |ψ|+|φ| and the total Grassmann parity [ψ]. Then the multiplication (3.4) obeys the relation
ϕ ∧ ϕ = (−1)|ϕ||ϕ |+[ϕ][ϕ ] ϕ ∧ ϕ,
∗ ϕ, ϕ ∈ S∞ ,
∗ ∧ P ∗ into a bigraded C ∞ (X)-algebra S ∗ , where the asterisk means the and makes C∞ ∞ ∞ total form degree. Due to the algebra monomorphisms ∗ ∗ C∞ ψ → ψ ⊗ 1 = 1 ⊗ ψ ∈ S∞ ,
∗ ∗ P∞ φ → φ ⊗ 1 = 1 ⊗ φ ∈ S∞ ,
∗ as being an algebra generated by elements of C ∗ and P ∗ . For one can think of S∞ ∞ ∞ 0 are polynomials of ca and y i with coefficients in instance, elements of the ring S∞ C ∞ (X).
112
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily ∗ with the exterior differential Let us provide S∞
d(ψ ⊗ φ) := (dC ψ) ⊗ φ + (−1)|ψ| ψ ⊗ (dP φ),
∗ ψ ∈ C∞ ,
∗ φ ∈ P∞ , (3.5)
∗ and P ∗ , where dC and dP are exterior differentials on the differential algebras C∞ ∞ respectively. We obtain at once from the relation (3.3) that
d(φ ⊗ ψ) = (dP φ) ⊗ ψ + (−1)|φ| φ ⊗ (dC ψ),
∗ ψ ∈ C∞ ,
∗ φ ∈ P∞ .
The exterior differential d (3.5) is nilpotent. It obeys the equalities d(ϕ ∧ ϕ ) = dϕ ∧ ϕ + (−1)|ϕ| ϕ ∧ dϕ ,
∗ ϕ, ϕ ∈ S∞ ,
∗ into a BGDA, which is locally generated by the elements and makes S∞ a i a a a i i i (1, c , y , dx λ , θ = dc − cλ+ dx λ , θ = dy − yλ+ dx λ ),
| | ≥ 0.
A and θ A stand both for even and odd generatHereafter, let the collective symbols s a i a i ∞ ∗ which, thus, is locally generated ing elements c , y , θ , θ of the C (X)-algebra S∞ A A λ ∗ the graded exterior forms by (1, s , dx , θ ), | | ≥ 0. We agree to call elements of S∞ on X. ∗ , the BGDA S ∗ is decomposed into S 0 -modules S k,r of k-contact Similarly to O∞ ∞ ∞ ∞ and r-horizontal graded forms together with the corresponding projections hk and hr . ∗ is split into the sum d = d + d Accordingly, the exterior differential d (3.5) on S∞ H V of the total and vertical differentials
dH (φ) = dx λ ∧ dλ (φ),
∗ φ ∈ S∞ .
A dV (φ) = θ ∧ ∂A φ,
∗ is given by the expression The projection endomorphism of S∞ 1 = ◦ h k ◦ hn , (φ) = (−1)| | θ A ∧ [d (∂A φ)], k | |≥0
k>0
>0,n φ ∈ S∞ ,
similar to (2.3). The graded variational operator δ = ◦d is introduced. Then the BGDA ∗ is split into the Z -graded variational bicomplex S∞ 2 ∗,∗ k,n (O∗ (X), S∞ , Ek = (S∞ ); d, dH , dV , , δ),
(3.6)
analogous to the variational bicomplex (2.4). 4. Cohomology of Z2 -Graded Complexes We aim to study the cohomology of the short variational complex dH
dH
δ
0 0,1 0,n 0 −→ R −→ S∞ −→ S∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ E1
(4.1)
and the complex of one-contact graded forms dH
dH
1,0 1,1 1,n 0 → S∞ −→ S∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ E1 → 0
(4.2)
∗ . One can think of the elements of the BGDA S∞ 0,n L = Lω ∈ S∞ , δ(L) = (−1)| | θ A ∧ d (∂A L) ∈ E1 | |≥0
of the complexes (4.1) – (4.2) as being a graded Lagrangian and its Euler–Lagrange operator, respectively.
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
113
Theorem 4.1. The cohomology of the complex (4.1) equals the de Rham cohomology H ∗ (X) of X. The complex (4.2) is exact. The proof of Theorem 4.1 follows the scheme of the proof of Theorem 2.1, but all sheaves are sheaves over X. The proof falls into the three steps. (i) We start by showing that the complexes (4.1) – (4.2) are locally exact. Lemma 4.2. The complex (4.1) on X = Rn is exact. Referring to [5], Theorems 4.1 – 4.2, for the proof, we summarize a few formulae 0,∗ quoted in the sequel. Any horizontal graded form φ ∈ S∞ admits the decomposition , φ = φ0 + φ
= φ
1 0
dλ A s ∂A φ, λ
(4.3)
| |≥0
0,m
D
+ν
1
φ= 0
dλ ν α1 α µ ...µ µ A A (x , λs kδ(µ1 δµ2 · · · δµk−1 λs(α ∂ 1 kφ , dx µ ). (4.4) 1 ...αk−1 ) A k) λ k≥0
holds, and leads to the desired expression = δµν φ The relation [D +ν , dµ ]φ ξ=
(n − m − 1)! k=0
(n − m + k)!
, D +ν Pk ∂ν φ
P0 = 1,
Pk = dν1 · · · dνk D +ν1 · · · D +νk . (4.5)
0,m
∗ are polynomials in s A , the sum in the expression (4.5) Remark 4.1. Since elements of S∞ is finite. However, the expression (4.5) contains a dH -exact summand which prevents its ∗ . In this respect, we also quote the homotopy operator (5.107) in [35] extension to O∞ which leads to the expression
1 ξ =
A I (φ)(x µ , λs , dx µ ) 0
I (φ) =
| |≥0 µ
dλ , λ
(4.7)
µ + 1 (µ + + )! A µ+ + s d ∂ A (−1) (∂µ φ)], d [ (µ + )! ! n−m + | |+1 | |≥0
(4.8) where ! = µ1 ! · · · µn ! and µ denotes the number of occurrences of the index µ in . The graded forms (4.6) and (4.7) differ in a dH -exact graded form.
114
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
Lemma 4.3. The complex (4.2) on X = Rn is exact. 1,m
whose coefficients are linear in the variables s A , and vice versa. Let us consider the modified total differential d H = dH + dx λ ∧ sA λ+ ∂ A , | |>0
acting on graded forms (4.10), where ∂ A is the dual of ds A . Comparing the equality λsA = dx and the last equality (2.13), one can easily justify that dH φ = d H φ. dH sA λ+ Let a graded (1, m)-form φ (4.9) be dH -closed. Then the associated horizontal graded m-form φ (4.10) is d H -closed and, by virtue of Lemma 4.2, it is d H -exact, i.e., φ = d H ξ , where ξ is a horizontal graded (m − 1)-form given by the expression (4.5) depending on additional variables s A A glance at this expression shows that, since φ is linear in . A. , so is ξ = ξA s A ξA ∧ θ the variables s A . It follows that φ = dH ξ , where ξ = It remains to prove the exactness of the complex (4.2) at the last term E1 . If (σ ) = (−1)| | θ A ∧ [d (∂A σ )] | |≥0
=
| |≥0
(−1)| | θ A ∧ [d σA ]ω = 0,
1,n σ ∈ S∞ ,
a direct computation gives σ = dH ξ,
ξ =−
| |≥0 + =
(−1)|| θ A ∧ d σA
µ+
ωµ .
(4.11)
Remark 4.2. The proof of Lemma 4.3 fails to be extended to complexes of higher contact A ∧ θ B and s A s B obey different commutation rules. forms because the products θ (ii) Let us associate to each open subset U ⊂ X the BGDA SU∗ of elements of the ∗ whose coefficients are restricted to U . These algebras make up a S∞ presheaf over X. Let S∗∞ be the sheaf of germs of this presheaf and (S∗∞ ) its structure module of sections. One can show that S∗∞ inherits the variational bicomplex operations, and (S∗∞ ) does so (see Appendix C). For short, we say that (S∗∞ ) consists of C ∞ (X)-algebra
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
115
a , ds a of locally bounded jet order | |. There is the monomorphism polynomials in s ∗ ∗ S∞ → (S∞ ). Let us consider the complexes of sheaves dH
dH
δ
0,n 0 −→ R −→ S0∞ −→ S0,1 ∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ E1 , dH
dH
E1 = (S1,n ∞ ), (4.12)
1,1 1,n 0 → S1,0 ∞ −→ S∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ E1 → 0
(4.13)
over X and the complexes of their structure modules dH
dH
δ
0,n 0 −→ R −→ (S0∞ ) −→ (S0,1 ∞ ) · · · −→ (S∞ ) −→ (E1 ), dH
dH
1,1 1,n 0 → (S1,0 ∞ ) −→ (S∞ ) · · · −→ (S∞ ) −→ (E1 ) → 0.
(4.14) (4.15)
By virtue of Lemmas 4.2 – 4.3 and Theorem 8.3, the complexes of sheaves (4.12) – (4.13) ∞ are exact. The terms S∗,∗ ∞ of the complexes (4.12) – (4.13) are sheaves of C (X)-modules. Therefore, they are fine and, consequently, acyclic. By virtue of Theorem 8.4 (see Appendix D), the cohomology of the complex (4.14) equals the cohomology of X with coefficients in the constant sheaf R, i.e., the de Rham cohomology H ∗ (X) of X, whereas the complex (4.15) is globally exact. (iii) It remains to prove the following. Proposition 4.4. Cohomology of the complexes (4.1) – (4.2) equals that of the complexes (4.14) – (4.15). Let the common symbol D stand for the operators dH , δ and in the complexes ∗ denote the terms of these complexes. Since cohomology (4.14) – (4.15), and let ∞ groups of these complexes are either trivial or equal to the de Rham cohomology of X, ∗ takes the form one can say that any D-closed element φ ∈ ∞ φ = ψ + Dξ,
∗ ξ ∈ ∞ ,
(4.16)
where ψ is a closed exterior form on X which is not necessarily exact. Since all D-closed ∗ of finite jet order are also of form (4.16), it suffices to show that, if an elements of ∞ ∗ is D-exact in the module ∗ (i.e., φ = Dξ , ξ ∈ ∗ ), then it is also element φ ∈ S∞ ∞ ∞ ∗ ∗ ). in S∞ (i.e., φ = Dϕ, ϕ ∈ S∞ ∗ be D-exact in ∗ . Let X be a (contractible) domain, and let an element φ ∈ S∞ ∞ ∗ in accordance with Lemmas 4.2 and 4.3. Then, being D-closed, it is D-exact in S∞ Moreover, a glance at the expressions (4.5), (4.6) and (4.8) shows that the maximal jet order [ϕ] of ϕ is bounded by an integer N ([φ]) which depends only on the maximal jet order [φ] of φ. It follows that, if φ = Dϕ is an arbitrary D-exact form of the jet order less than k, then the jet order of ϕ does not exceed N (k). We agree to call this fact the finite exactness of an operator D. Let X be an arbitrary manifold and U a domain of X. By virtue of Lemmas 4.2 and ∗ | (or, roughly speaking, the operator D on 4.3, the restriction of the operator D to ∞ U U ) has the finite exactness property. Let us state the following. Lemma 4.5. Given a family {Uα } of disjoint open subsets of X, let us suppose that the finite exactness of the operator D takes place on each subset Uα separately. Then D on the union ∪ Uα also has the finite exactness property. α
∗ be a D-exact graded form on X. The finite exactness on ∪U holds Proof. Let φ ∈ S∞ α since φ = Dϕα on every Uα and all [ϕα ] < N ([φ]).
116
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
Lemma 4.6. Suppose that the finite exactness of an operator D takes place on open subsets U , V of X and their non-empty overlap U ∩ V . Then it is also true on U ∪ V . ∗ be a D-exact graded form on X. By assumption, it can be Proof. Let φ = Dϕ ∈ S∞ brought into the form DϕU on U and DϕV on V , where ϕU and ϕV are graded forms of bounded jet order. Due to the decomposition (4.16), one can choose the forms ϕU , ϕV such that ϕ − ϕU on U and ϕ − ϕV on V are D-exact. Let us consider the difference ϕU − ϕV on U ∩ V . It is a D-exact graded form of bounded jet order which, by assumption, can be written as ϕU − ϕV = Dσ , where σ is also of bounded jet order. Lemma 4.7 below shows that σ = σU + σV , where σU and σV are graded forms of bounded jet order on U and V , respectively. Then, putting
ϕU = ϕU − DσU ,
ϕV = ϕV + DσV ,
we have the graded form φ, equal to DϕU on U and DϕV on V , respectively. Since the difference ϕU − ϕV on U ∩ V vanishes, we obtain φ = Dϕ on U ∪ V , where def ϕ |U = ϕU ϕ = ϕ |V = ϕV is of bounded jet order.
Lemma 4.7. Let U and V be open subsets of X and σ a graded form of bounded jet order on U ∩ V . Then σ splits into the sum σU + σV of graded exterior forms σU on U and σV on V of bounded jet order. Proof. By taking a smooth partition of unity on U ∪ V subordinate to its cover {U, V } and passing to the function with support in V , we get a smooth real function f on U ∪ V which is 0 on a neighborhood UU −V of U − V and 1 on a neighborhood UV −U of V − U in U ∪ V . The graded form f σ vanishes on UU −V ∩ (U ∩ V ) and, therefore, can be extended by 0 to U . Let us denote it σU . Accordingly, the graded form (1 − f )σ has an extension σV by 0 to V . Then σ = σU + σV is a desired decomposition because σU and σV are of finite jet order which does not exceed that of σ . Lemma 9.5 in [10], Chapter V, states that, if some property holds on a domain and obeys the conditions of Lemmas 4.5 and 4.6, it holds on any open subset of Rn . Hence, the operator D has the jet exactness property on any open subset of Rn and, consequently, on any chart of the fiber bundle Q×X Y → X. Since the latter admits a finite bundle atlas with the transition functions (2.1) and (3.2) preserving the jet order, the finite exactness of D takes place on the whole manifold X in accordance with Lemma 4.6. This proves Proposition 4.4 and, consequently, Theorem 4.1. Remark 4.3. Let us consider the complex d
d
0 1 k 0 → R −→ S∞ −→ S∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ · · · ,
(4.17)
∗ , d) is the differential calculus which we agree to call the de Rham complex because (S∞ 0 n over the R-ring S∞ . If X = R , it is exact ([14], Theorem 3.1). Similarly to the proof of Theorem 4.1, one can show that the cohomology of the de Rham complex (4.17) equals the de Rham cohomology of X.
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
117
0,m
φ = ψ + dH ξ,
0,m−1 ξ ∈ S∞ ,
(4.18)
where ψ is a closed m-form on X. Every δ-closed graded Lagrangian L ∈ sum φ = ψ + dH ξ,
0,n−1 ξ ∈ S∞ ,
0,n S∞
is the (4.19)
where ψ is a non-exact n-form on X. 1,n The global exactness of the complex (4.2) at the term S∞ results in the following.
Proposition 4.9. Given a graded Lagrangian L = Lω, there is the decomposition 1,n−1 dL = δL − dH ,
∈ S∞ , (4.20) νk ...ν1 νk ...ν1 λνk ...ν1 νk ...ν1 λνs ...ν1 A
= θνs ...ν1 ∧ FA ωλ , FA = ∂A L − d λ FA + hA ,(4.21) s=0 (ν νk−1 )...ν1
where local graded functions h obey the relations hνa = 0, ha k
= 0.
Proof. The decomposition (4.20) is a straightforward consequence of the exactness of 1,n the complex (4.2) at the term S∞ and the fact that is a projector. The coordinate expression (4.21) results from a direct computation −dH = −dH [θ A FAλ + θνA FAλν + · · · + θνAs ...ν1 FAλνs ...ν1 λνs+1 νs ...ν1
+θνAs+1 νs ...ν1 ∧ FA = = =
+ · · · ] ∧ ωλ
[θ + θνA (FAν + dλ FAλν ) ν ν ...ν λν ν ...ν + · · · + θνAs+1 νs ...ν1 (FAs+1 s 1 + dλ FA s+1 s 1 ) + · · · ] ∧ ω ν ν ...ν [θ A dλ FAλ + θνA (∂Aν L) + · · · + θνAs+1 νs ...ν1 (∂As+1 s 1 L) + · · · ] ∧ ω θ A (dλ FAλ − ∂A L) ∧ ω + dL = −δL + dL. A
dλ FAλ
Proposition 4.9 states the existence of a global finite order Lepagean equivalent
L = + L of any graded Lagrangian L. Locally, one can always choose (4.21) where all functions h vanish. 5. Contact Supersymmetries 0 of the R-ring S 0 is said to be an infinitesimal contact A graded derivation υ ∈ dS∞ ∞ supertransformation or, simply, a contact supersymmetry if the Lie derivative Lυ pre∗ (i.e., the Lie derivative L of serves the ideal of contact graded forms of the BGDA S∞ υ a graded contact form is a graded contact form). A , dx λ , θ A ) for the BGDA S ∗ , Proposition 5.1. With respect to the local basis (x λ , s ∞ any contact supersymmetry takes the form υ = υH + υV = υ λ dλ + (υ A ∂A + d υ A ∂A ), (5.1) | |>0
where
υ λ,
υA
are local graded functions.
118
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
∗ can be identified as sections of a Proof. The key point is that, since elements of C∞ ∗ . finite-dimensional vector bundle over X, so can elements of the C ∞ (X)-algebra S∞ 0 Moreover, any graded form is a finite composition of df , f ∈ S∞ . Therefore, the proof follows that of Proposition 2.3. ∗ are defined by the The interior product υ φ and the Lie derivative Lυ φ, φ ∈ S∞ same formulae
υ φ = υ λ φλ + (−1)[φA ] υ A φA ,
1 φ ∈ S∞ ,
υ (φ ∧ σ ) = (υ φ) ∧ σ + (−1)|φ|+[φ][υ] φ ∧ (υ σ ), Lυ φ = υ dφ + d(υ φ),
∗ φ, σ ∈ S∞ ,
Lυ (φ ∧ σ ) = Lυ (φ) ∧ σ + (−1)[υ][φ] φ ∧ Lυ (σ ),
as those on a graded manifold. Following the proof of Lemma 2.4, one can justify that any vertical contact supersymmetry υ (5.1) satisfies the relations υ dH φ = −dH (υ φ), Lυ (dH φ) = dH (Lυ φ),
φ∈
∗ S∞ .
(5.2) (5.3)
0,n , its Lie derivative Lυ L along a Proposition 5.2. Given a graded Lagrangian L ∈ S∞ contact supersymmetry υ (5.1) fulfills the first variational formula
Lυ L = υV δL + dH (h0 (υ
L )) + dV (υH ω)L,
(5.4)
where L = + L is a Lepagean equivalent of L given by the coordinate expression (4.21). Proof. The proof follows that of Proposition 2.5 and results from the decomposition (4.20) and the relation (5.2). In particular, let υ be a variational symmetry of a graded Lagrangian L, i.e., Lυ L = 0,n−1 dH σ , σ ∈ S∞ . Then the first variational formula (5.4) restricted to Ker δL leads to the weak conservation law 0 ≈ dH (h0 (υ
L ) − σ ).
(5.5)
Remark 5.1. Let us consider the gauge theory of principal connections on a principal bundle P → X with a structure Lie group G. These connections are represented by sections of the quotient C = J 1 P /G → X [32]. This is an affine bundle coordinated by (x λ , aλr ) such that, given a section A of C → X, its components Arλ = aλr ◦ A are coefficients of the familiar local connection form (i.e., gauge potentials). Let J ∞ C be r ), 0 ≤ | |, and let the infinite order jet manifold of C → X coordinated by (x λ , aλ, ∗ ∗ P∞ (C) be the polynomial subalgebra of the GDA O∞ (C). Infinitesimal generators of one-parameter groups of vertical automorphisms (gauge transformations) of a principal bundle P are G-invariant vertical vector fields on P → X. They are associated to sections of the vector bundle VG P = V P /G → X of right Lie algebras of the group G. Let us consider the simple graded manifold (X, AVG Y ) constructed from this vector bundle. Its local basis is (x λ , C r ). Let CJ∗ r VG Y be the BGDA of graded exterior forms on ∗ (V P ) the direct limit of the direct system the graded manifold (X, AJ r VG P ), and C∞ G (1.4) of these algebras. Then the graded product ∗ ∗ ∗ S∞ (VG , C) = C∞ (VG P ) ∧ P∞ (C)
(5.6)
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
119
describes gauge potentials, odd ghosts and their jets in the BRST theory. With respect to ∗ (V , C) (5.6), the BRST symmetry is given a local basis (x λ , aλr , C r ) for the BGDA S∞ G by the contact supersymmetry (d υλr ∂r ,λ + d υ r ∂r ), (5.7) υ = υλr ∂rλ + υ r ∂r + | |>0
υλr =
p r Cλr + cpq aλ C q ,
1 r p q υ r = − cpq C C , 2
r are structure constants of the Lie algebra of G and ∂ λ , ∂ , ∂ ,λ ∂ are the where cpq r r r r r r , respectively. A remarkable peculiarity of this contact duals of daλr , dC r , da ,λ and dC supersymmetry is that the Lie derivative Lυ along υ (5.7) is nilpotent on the module 0,∗ S∞ of horizontal graded forms.
In a general setting, a vertical contact supersymmetry υ (5.1) is said to be nilpotent if Lυ (Lυ φ) =
||≥0,| |≥0
B A (υ ∂B (υ )∂A + (−1)[s
B ][υ A ]
B A υ υ ∂B ∂A )φ = 0
(5.8)
0,∗ for any horizontal graded form φ ∈ S∞ .
Lemma 5.3. A contact supersymmetry υ is nilpotent iff it is odd and the equality B A Lυ (υ A ) = υ ∂B (υ ) = 0 ||≥0
holds for all υ A . Proof. There is the relation i λ i λ ∂i = v ∂i ◦ dλ , dλ ◦ v
(5.9)
similar to (2.14). Then the lemma follows from the equality (5.8) where one puts φ = s A AsB . and φ = s Remark 5.2. A useful example of a nilpotent contact supersymmetry is the supersymmetry υ = υ A (x)∂A + ∂ υ A ∂A , (5.10) | |>0
A , but all s A are odd. where all υ A are smooth real functions on X, ∂A are the duals of ds
6. Cohomology of Nilpotent Contact Supersymmetries Let υ be a nilpotent contact supersymmetry. Since the Lie derivative Lυ obeys the rela0,∗ tion (5.3), let us assume that the R-module S∞ of graded horizontal forms is split into a bicomplex {S k,m } with respect to the nilpotent operator sυ (1.5) and the total differential dH which obey the relation
120
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
sυ ◦ dH + dH ◦ sυ = 0.
(6.1)
This bicomplex dH : S k,m → S k,m+1 ,
sυ : S k,m → S k+1,m
is graded by the form degree 0 ≤ m ≤ n and an integer k ∈ Z, though it may happen that S k,∗ = 0 starting from some number k. For the sake of brevity, let us call k the charge number. 0,∗ For instance, the BRST bicomplex S∞ (C, VG P ) is graded by the charge number r . In this case, s k which is the polynomial degree of its elements in odd variables C υ r (1.5) is the BRST operator. Since the ghosts C are characterized by the ghost number 1, k ∈ N, is the ghost number. The bicomplex defined by the contact supersymmetry (5.10) has the similar gradation, but taken with the sign minus (i.e., k = 0, −1, . . . ) because the nilpotent operator sυ decreases the odd polynomial degree. Let us consider the relative and iterated cohomology of the nilpotent operator sυ (1.5) with respect to the total differential dH . Recall that a horizontal graded form φ ∈ S ∗,∗ is said to be a relative closed form, i.e., (sυ /dH )-closed form if sυ φ is a dH -exact form. This form is called exact if it is a sum of an sυ -exact form and a dH -exact form. Accordingly, we have the relative cohomology H ∗,∗ (sυ /dH ). If a (sυ /dH )-closed form φ is also dH -closed, it is called an iterated (sυ |dH )-closed form. This form φ is said to be exact if φ = sυ ξ + dH σ , where ξ is a dH -closed form. Thus, we obtain the iterated cohomology H ∗,∗ (sυ |dH ) of the (sυ , dH )-bicomplex S ∗,∗ . It is the term E2∗,∗ of the spectral sequence of this bicomplex [31]. There is an obvious isomorphism H ∗,n (sυ /dH ) = H ∗,n (sυ |dH ) of relative and iterated cohomology groups on horizontal graded densities. Forthcoming Theorems 6.2 and 6.5 extend our results on iterated cohomology in [21] to an arbitrary nilpotent contact supersymmetry. Proposition 6.1. Let us consider the complex dH
dH
dH
0 0,1 0,n 0 −→ R −→ S∞ −→ S∞ · · · −→ S∞ −→ 0.
(6.2)
Its cohomology groups H m
(6.3)
Proof. The complex (6.2) differs from the short variational complex (4.1) in the last term. Therefore its cohomology H m
(6.4)
of the de Rham cohomology H m (X) of X of form degree less than n onto the iterated cohomology H ∗,m
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
121
Proof. Since a nilpotent contact supersymmetry υ is vertical, all exterior forms φ on X are sυ -closed. It follows that d-cocycles on X are (sυ |dH )-closed. Since any dH -exact horizontal graded form is also (sυ |dH )-exact, we have a morphism ζ (6.4). By virtue of Corollary 4.8 (and, equivalently, Proposition 6.1), any dH -closed horizontal graded (m < n)-form φ is split into the sum φ = ϕ + dH ξ (4.18) of a closed m-form ϕ on X and a dH -exact graded form. Therefore, any (sυ |dH )-cocycle is the sum of a closed exterior form on X and a dH -exact graded form. It follows that the morphism ζ (6.4) is an epimorphism. The kernel of the morphism ζ (6.4) consists of elements whose representatives are sυ -exact closed exterior forms on X. In particular, if X = Rn , the iterated cohomology H ∗,0<m
(6.5)
of the de Rham cohomology H
Theorem 6.5. Put H = H ∗ ( sυ )/Im γ , where the asterisk means the total charge. There is an isomorphism ∗
H ∗,n (sυ |dH )/H = Ker γ .
(6.6)
122
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
Proof. The proof falls into the following three steps. (i) First, we show the existence of a morphism η : H ∗,n (sυ |dH ) → Ker γ
(6.7)
from the iterated cohomology group H ∗,n (sυ |dH ) to Ker γ . Consider a horizontal graded n-form φn which is (sυ |dH )-closed. Then, by definition, sυ φn is dH -exact, i.e., sυ φn + dH φn−1 = 0.
(6.8)
Acting on this equality by sυ , we observe that sυ φn−1 is a dH -closed graded form, i.e., sυ φn−1 + dH φn−2 = ϕn−1 ,
(6.9)
where ϕn−1 is a closed (n − 1)-form on X in accordance with Corollary 4.8. Since sυ ϕn−1 = 0, an action of sυ on Eq. (6.9) shows that sυ φn−2 is a dH -closed graded form, i.e., sυ φn−2 + dH φn−3 = ϕn−2 , where ϕn−2 is a closed (n − 2)-form on X. Iterating the arguments, one comes to the system of equations sυ φn−k + dH φn−k−1 = ϕn−k ,
0 ≤ k < n,
sυ φ0 = ϕ0 = const, (6.10)
which can be assembled into descent equations = ϕ, sυ φ = φn + φn−1 + · · · + φ0 , φ
ϕ = ϕn−1 + · · · + ϕ0 .
(6.11) (6.12)
Thus, any (sυ |dH )-closed horizontal graded form defines descent equations (6.11) whose right-hand sides ϕ are closed exterior forms on X such that their de Rham classes belong to the kernel Ker γ of the morphism (6.5). For the sake of brevity, let us denote these (6.12) descent equations by ϕ . Accordingly, we say that a horizontal graded form φ is a solution of descent equations ϕ (6.12). Descent equations defined by a (sυ |dH ) be another solution of another closed horizontal graded form φn are not unique. Let φ set of descent equations ϕ such that φn = φn . Let us denote φk = φk − φk and ϕk = ϕk − ϕk . Then the equations (6.8) lead to the equation dH (φn−1 ) = 0. It follows from Corollary 4.8 that φn−1 = dH ξn−2 + αn−1 ,
(6.13)
where αn−1 is a closed (n − 1)-form on X. Accordingly, Eq. (6.10) leads to the equation sυ (φn−1 ) + dH (φn−2 ) = ϕn−1 . Substituting the equality (6.13) into this equation and bearing in mind the relation (6.1), we obtain the equality dH (−sυ ξn−2 + φn−2 ) = ϕn−1 . It follows that φn−2 = sυ ξn−2 + dH ξn−3 + αn−2 ,
ϕn−1 = dαn−2 ,
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
123
where αn−2 is an exterior form on X. Iterating the arguments, one comes to the relations φn−k = sυ ξn−k + dH ξn−k−1 + αn−k ,
ϕn−k = dαn−k−1 ,
1 < k < n, (6.14)
where αn−k−1 are exterior forms on X and, finally, to the equalities φ0 = 0, ϕ0 = 0. Then it is easily justified that − φ = sυ σ + α, σ = ξn−2 + · · · ξ1 , φ ϕ− ϕ = d α, α = αn−1 + · · · + α1 .
(6.15) (6.16)
It follows that right-hand sides of any two descent equations defined by a (sυ |dH )-closed horizontal graded form φn differ from each other in an exact form on X. Moreover, let φn and φn be representatives of the same iterated cohomology class in H ∗,n (sυ |dH ), of i.e., φn = φn + sυ ψ + dH β, where ψ is dH -closed. Let φn provide a solution φ = φ + a descent equation ϕ . Then φn defines a solution φ sυ (ψ + β) of the same descent equation. Thus, the assignment φn → ϕ yields the desired morphism η (6.7). (ii) Let us show that the morphism η (6.7) is an epimorphism. Let ϕ be a closed exterior form on X whose de Rham cohomology class belongs to Ker γ . Let ϕ = ϕn−1 +· · ·+ϕ0 be its decomposition in k-forms ϕk , k = 1, . . . , n − 1. Then the family of exterior forms (ϕk ) yields a system of the equations (6.10) which can be assembled into the descent exists because equations ϕ (6.11). Its solution φ ϕ ∈ Ker γ . Let ϕ differ from ϕ in of the equation an exact form, i.e., let the relation (6.16) hold. Then any solution φ ϕ = φ − yields a solution φ α (6.15) of the equation ϕ such that φn = φn . It follows that the morphism η (6.7) is an epimorphism. (iii) The kernel of the morphism η (6.7) is represented by (sυ |dH )-closed horizontal graded forms φn which yield homogeneous descent equations = 0. sυ φ
(6.17)
sυ ) onto Ker η. For this purLet us define an epimorphism of the total cohomology H ∗ ( its higher term φn . The latter defines homopose, let us associate to each sυ -cocycle φ , i.e., φn ∈ Ker η. Let φ = geneous descent equations (6.17) whose solution is φ sυ ψ be a sυ -coboundary. Its higher term φn takes the form φn = sυ ψn + dH ψn−1 , i.e., it → φn provides the desired is an iterated coboundary. It follows that the assignment φ ∗ epimorphism τ : H ( sυ ) → Ker η. The kernel of this epimorphism is represented by of the descent equation (6.17) whose higher term vanishes. Following item solutions φ = (i), one can easily show that these solutions take the form φ sυ σ + α , where α is a closed exterior form on X of form degree < n. Cohomology classes of these solutions exhaust the image of the morphism γ (6.5), i.e., Im γ = Ker τ . In particular, if the morphism γ (6.5) is a monomorphism (i.e., no non-exact closed exterior form on X is sυ -exact), the isomorphism (6.6) gives the isomorphism sυ )/H
124
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
7. Conclusion In the present work, we follow the algebraic topological approach to describing Lagrangian field theories in terms of the variational bicomplex. This enables us to extend the cohomology analysis of Lagrangian BRST theory on Rn to a generic contact supersymmetry on an arbitrary manifold X. Since only vector and affine bundles over X are involved, the corresponding cohomology characteristic is represented by the de Rham cohomology of X. In a general case of nilpotent contact supersymmetry sυ , its contribution however is not trivial because exterior forms on X are sυ -closed, but need not be sυ -exact. For instance, this contribution is given by the kernel of the morphism γ (6.5) in Theorem 6.5. Our analysis seems important for BV quantization of field systems with non-contractible topologies, e.g., gravitation theory and topological field models. We also bear in mind the extension of BV quantization to field systems where parameters of gauge transformations may depend on field variables and their derivatives [18]. For instance, this is the case of spinor fields in gauge gravitation theory [37]. 8. Appendixes Appendix A. Since Y is a strong deformation retract of any finite order jet manifold ∗ is easily proved to equal the de Rham J r Y , the de Rham cohomology of the GDA O∞ ∗ cohomology H (Y ) of Y in accordance with Theorem 8.3 [2]. However, we must enlarge ∗ in order to find its d - and δ-cohomology. O∞ H Outline of proof of Theorem 2.1. One starts from the algebraic Poincar´e lemma [35, 43]. Lemma 8.1. If Y is a contractible bundle Rn+p → Rn , the variational bicomplex (2.4) is exact. For instance, the homotopy operators for dV , dH , δ and are given by the formulae (5.72), (5.109), (5.84) in [35] and (4.5) in [43], respectively. Let O∗r be the sheaf of germs of exterior forms on the r-order jet manifold J r Y , and ∗ let Or be its canonical presheaf. There is the direct system of presheaves ∗
π∗
1∗ ∗ π0
∗
r ∗ πr−1
∗
OX −→ O0 −→ O1 · · · −→ Or −→ · · · . ∗
Its direct limit O∞ is a presheaf of GDAs on the infinite order jet manifold J ∞ Y . Let T∗∞ ∗ be the sheaf of GDAs on J ∞ Y constructed from the presheaf O∞ , i.e., T∗∞ is the sheaf ∗ of germs of O∞ (we follow the terminology of [28]). The structure module (T∗∞ ) of ∗ sections of T∞ is a GDA such that, given an element φ ∈ (T∗∞ ) and a point z ∈ J ∞ Y , there exist an open neighbourhood U of z and an exterior form φ (k) on some finite order jet manifold J k Y so that φ|U = πk∞∗ φ (k) |U . In particular, there is the monomorphism ∗ → (T∗ ). The fact that the paracompact space J ∞ Y admits a partition of unity O∞ ∞ by elements of the ring (T0∞ ) [42], enables one to obtain dH - and δ-cohomology of (T∗∞ ) as follows [1, 2, 41, 42]. The sheaf T∗∞ is split into the bicomplex T∗,∗ ∞ . Let us consider its variational subcomplex and the complexes of sheaves of contact forms dH
dH
δ
δ
0,n 0 → R → T0∞ −→ T0,1 ∞ · · · −→ T∞ −→ E1 −→ E2 −→ · · · , dH
dH
k,1 k,n 0 → Tk,0 ∞ −→ T∞ · · · −→ T∞ −→ Ek → 0,
Ek = (Tk,n ∞ ), (8.1) (8.2)
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
125
together with complexes of their structure modules dH
dH
δ
δ
0,n 0 → R → (T0∞ ) −→ (T0,1 ∞ ) · · · −→ (T∞ ) −→ (E1 ) −→ (E2 ) −→ · · · , (8.3) dH
dH
k,1 k,n 0 → (Tk,0 ∞ ) −→ (T∞ ) · · · −→ (T∞ ) −→ (Ek ) → 0.
(8.4)
By virtue of Lemma 8.1 and Theorem 8.3, the complexes (8.1) – (8.2) are exact. Since 0 T∗,∗ ∞ are sheaves of (T∞ )-modules, they are fine. The sheaves Ek are also proved to be fine [21, 41]. Consequently, all sheaves, except R, in the complexes (8.1) – (8.2) are acyclic. Therefore, these complexes are the resolutions of the constant sheaf R and the zero sheaf over J ∞ Y , respectively. In accordance with the abstract de Rham theorem ([28], Theorem 2.12.1), cohomology of the complex (8.3) equals the cohomology of J ∞ Y with coefficients in R, while the complex (8.4) is exact. Since Y is a strong deformation retract of J ∞ Y [2, 22], cohomology of the complex (8.3) is isomorphic to the de Rham cohomology of Y . Note that, in order to prove the exactness of the complex (8.4), one can use a minor generalization of the above mentioned abstract de Rham theorem (see Appendix D), and need not justify the acyclicity of the sheaves Ek [42]. ∗ ⊂ (T∗ ) is proved to have the same d - and δ-cohoFinally, the subalgebra O∞ H ∞ k,n ∗ mology as (T∞ ) [21, 41]. Similarly, one can show that, restricted to O∞ , the operator remains exact. The following is a corollary of item (i) of Theorem 2.1 (cf. Corollary 4.8). Corollary 8.2. Every dH -closed form φ ∈ O0,m
0,m−1 ξ ∈ O∞ ,
where ψ is a closed m-form on Y . Every δ-closed Lagrangian L ∈ L = h0 ψ + dH ξ,
ξ∈
0,n−1 O∞ ,
(8.5) 0,n O∞
is the sum (8.6)
where ψ is a closed n-form on Y . Note that the formulae (8.5) – (8.6) were obtained in [1] by computing cohomology of the fixed order variational sequence, but the proof of the local exactness of this sequence requires rather sophisticated ad hoc techniques. Appendix B. Let us consider the open surjection π ∞ : J ∞ Y → X and the direct image ∗ T∗ on X of the sheaf T∗ of exterior forms on J ∞ Y . Its stalk at a point x ∈ X conπ∞ ∞ ∞ sists of the equivalence classes of sections of the sheaf T∗∞ which coincide on the inverse images (π ∞ )−1 (Ux ) of open neighbourhoods Ux of X. Since (π ∞ )−1 (Ux ) is the infinite order jet manifold of sections of the fiber bundle π −1 (Ux ) → X, every point x ∈ X has a base of open neighbourhoods {Ux } such that the sheaves T∗,∗ ∞ and Ek in the proof of Theorem 2.1 are acyclic on the inverse images (π ∞ )−1 (Ux ) of these neighbourhoods. Then, in accordance with the Leray theorem [23], cohomology of J ∞ Y with coefficients in the sheaves T∗,∗ ∞ and Ek is isomorphic to that of X with coefficients in their direct ∗ T∗,∗ and π ∗ E , i.e., the sheaves π ∗ T∗,∗ and π ∗ E over X are acyclic. Let images π∞ ∞ ∞ k ∞ ∞ ∞ k Y → X be an affine bundle. Then X is a strong deformation retract of J ∞ Y . In this case, the inverse images (π ∞ )−1 (Ux ) of contractible neighbourhoods Ux are contractible and π∗∞ R = R. Then, by virtue of Lemma 8.1, the variational bicomplex T∗∞ of sheaves over (π ∞ )−1 (Ux ) is exact, and the variational bicomplex π∗∞ T∗∞ of sheaves over X is so. There is an R-algebra isomorphism of the GDA of sections of the sheaf π∗∞ T∗∞ over ∗ can be regarded X to the GDA (T∗∞ ). Thus, the GDA (T∗∞ ) and its subalgebra O∞ as algebras of sections of a sheaf over X.
126
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
Appendix C. Let us associate to each open subset U ⊂ X the bigraded algebra SU∗ ∗ whose coefficients are restricted to U . These of elements of the C ∞ (X)-algebra S∞ algebras make up a presheaf
SU∗ , rVU | rVU : SU∗ → SV∗
(8.7)
over X. Let S∗∞ be the sheaf constructed from this presheaf. Its stalk S∗x at a point x ∈ X is the direct limit of the direct system of R-modules {SU∗ , rVU }, indexed by the directed ∗ set of open neighbourhoods U of x. This stalk consists of the germs of elements of S∞ at x, i.e., elements of the presheaf (8.7) are identified if their restrictions (namely, the restrictions of their coefficients) to some open neighbourhood of x coincide with each ∗ on X = Rn which consists of elements other. Let Sc∗ be the subalgebra of the BGDA S∞ with constant coefficients. Then S∗x is the stalk of germs of Sc∗ -valued functions on X. It is a bigraded algebra isomorphic to the tensor product Cx∞ ⊗R Sc∗ of the R-algebra Cx∞ of the germs of smooth real functions on X at x and the R-algebra Sc∗ . This stalk is naturally decomposed into Cx∞ -modules Sk,m of the germs of graded (k, m)-forms on x X. Let the common symbol stand for all the operators (d,dH , dV , and δ) on the ∗ . It is an R-module morphism whose restrictions to S ∗ intertwined by BGDA S∞ U U the restriction morphisms rVU (8.7) constitute the direct system of morphisms
U , rVU | rVU ◦ U = V ◦ rVU ,
(8.8)
indexed by the directed set of open neighbourhoods U of x. Its direct limit x is an R-module morphism of the stalk S∗x . The properties of the direct limit of morphisms are summarized by the following theorem [33]. Theorem 8.3. The direct limit of a direct system of complexes {Ci∗ , i ∈ I } is a complex whose cohomology is the direct limit of that of the complexes Ci∗ . It follows that the stalk S∗x is a BGDA which contains the complexes correspond∗ . Since, ing to the subcomplexes of the variational bicomplex (3.6) of the BGDA S∞ dx = dH x + dV x and the operators dx , dH x , dV x are nilpotent, we have a bicomplex ∗ ∞ ∗ S∗,∗ x . Moreover, the vertical differential dV x on Sx = Cx ⊗R Sc comes from the oper∗ ator dV on Sc . Therefore, δx = x ◦ dV x and the subcomplexes of S∗x can be assembled into the variational bicomplex. Accordingly, the sheaf S∗∞ of germs of graded exterior forms on X constitutes the variational bicomplex ∗ k,n (OX , S∗,∗ ∞ , Ek = (S∞ ); d, dH , dV , , δ),
(8.9)
where the operators on S∗∞ are denoted by the same symbols as those on the BGDA ∗ . S∞ Let (S∗∞ ) be the bigraded algebra of sections of the sheaf S∗∞ . Given an arbitrary section s of (S∗∞ ), there exists an open neighbourhood U of each point x ∈ X such that s|U is an element of the presheaf (8.7). It follows that (S∗∞ ) can be provided with the ∗ which make it into the Z -graded same operators d, dH , dV , and δ as the BGDA S∞ 2 ∗ . The homomorphism S ∗ → (S∗ ) is variational bicomplex, analogous to that of S∞ ∞ ∞ a monomorphism.
Lagrangian Supersymmetries Depending on Derivatives
127
Appendix D. We quote the following minor generalization of the abstract de Rham theorem ([28], Theorem 2.12.1) [20, 22, 42]. Let h
h0
h1
hp−1
hp
0 → S −→ S0 −→ S1 −→ · · · −→ Sp −→ Sp+1 ,
p > 1,
be an exact sequence of sheaves of abelian groups over a paracompact topological space Z, where the sheaves Sq , 0 ≤ q < p, are acyclic, and let h∗
h0∗
h1∗
p−1
h∗
p
h∗
0 → (Z, S) −→ (Z, S0 ) −→ (Z, S1 ) −→ · · · −→ (Z, Sp ) −→ (Z, Sp+1 ) (8.10) be the corresponding cochain complex of structure groups of these sheaves. Theorem 8.4. The q-cohomology groups of the cochain complex (8.10) for 0 ≤ q ≤ p are isomorphic to the cohomology groups H q (Z, S) of Z with coefficients in the sheaf S. Acknowledgement. The authors would like to thank a referee for carefully reading the manuscript and numerous suggestions.
References 1. Anderson, I., Duchamp, T.: On the existence of global variational principles. Am. J. Math. 102, 781–868 (1980) 2. Anderson, I.: Introduction to the variational bicomplex. Contemp. Math. 132, 51–73 (1992) 3. Anderson, I., Kamran, N., Olver, P: Internal, external and generalized symmetries. Adv. Math. 100, 53–100 (1993) 4. Barnich, G., Brandt, F., Henneaux, M.: Local BRST cohomology in the antifield formalism. 1. General theorems. Commun. Math. Phys. 174, 57–91 (1995) 5. Barnich, G., Brandt, F., Henneaux, M.: Local BRST cohomology in gauge theories. Phys. Rep. 338, 439–569 (2000) 6. Bartocci, C., Bruzzo, U., Hern´andez Ruip´erez, D.: The Geometry of Supermanifolds. Dordrecht: Kluwer, 1991 7. Batalin, I., Vilkoviski, G.: Closure of the gauge algebra, generalized Lie algebra equations and Feynman rules. Nucl. Phys. B234, 106–124 (1984) 8. Brandt, F.: Local BRST cohomology and covariance. Commun. Math. Phys. 190, 459–489 (1997) 9. Brandt, F.: Jet coordinates for local BRST cohomology. Lett. Math. Phys. 55, 149–159 (2001) 10. Bredon, G.: Topology and Geometry. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1993 11. Bryant, R., Griffiths, P., Grossman, D.: Exterior Differential Systems and Euler–Lagrange Partial Differential Equations. Chicago, IL: Univ. of Chicago Press, 2003 12. Cari˜nena, J., Figueroa, H.: Hamiltonian versus Lagrangian formulations of supermechanics. J. Phys. A 30, 2705–2724 (1997) 13. Cianci, R., Francaviglia, M. Volovich, I.: Variational calculus and Poincar´e–Cartan formalism in supermanifolds. J. Phys. A. 28, 723–734 (1995) 14. Dragon, N.: BRS symmetry and cohomology. http://arxiv.org/list/hep-th/9602163, 1996 15. Dubois-Violette, M., Henneaux, M., Talon, M., Vialett, C.-M.: General solution of the consistence equation. Phys. Lett. B 289, 361–367 (1992) 16. Fatibene, L., Ferraris, M., Francaviglia, M., McLenaghan, R.: Generalized symmetries in mechanics and field theories. J. Math. Phys. 43, 3147–3161 (2002) 17. Franco, D., Polito, C.: Supersymmetric field-theoretic models on a supermanifold. J. Math. Phys. 45, 1447–1473 (2004) 18. Fulp, R., Lada, T., Stasheff, J.: Sh-Lie algebras induced by gauge transformations. Comm. Math. Phys. 231, 25–43 (2002) 19. Fulp, R., Lada, T., Stasheff, J.: Noether variational Theorem II and the BV formalism. Rend. Circ. Mat. Palermo (2) Suppl. (71), 115–126 (2003) 20. Giachetta, G., Mangiarotti, L., Sardanashvily, G.: Cohomology of the variational complex. http://arxiv.org/list/math-ph/0005010, 2000
128
G. Giachetta, L. Mangiarotti, G. Sardanashvily
21. Giachetta, G., Mangiarotti, L., Sardanashvily, G.: Iterated BRST cohomology. Lett. Math. Phys. 53, 143–156 (2000) 22. Giachetta, G., Mangiarotti, L., Sardanashvily, G.: Cohomology of the infinite-order jet space and the inverse problem. J. Math. Phys. 42, 4272–4282 (2001) 23. Godement, R.: Th´eorie des Faisceaux. Paris: Hermann, 1964. 24. Gomis, J., Par´ıs, J., Samuel, S.: Antibracket, antifields and gauge theory quantization. Phys. Rep 295, 1–145 (1995) 25. Gotay, M.: A multisymplectic framework for classical field theory and the calculus of variations. In: Mechanics, Analysis and Geometry: 200 Years after Lagrange. Amsterdam: North Holland, 1991, pp. 203–235 26. Greub, W., Halperin, S., Vanstone, R.: Connections, Curvature, and Cohomology, Vol. 1. NewYork: Academic Press, 1972 27. Hern´andez Ruip´erez, D., Mu˜noz Masqu´e, J.: Global variational calculus on graded manifolds. J. Math. Pures Appl. 63, 283–309 (1984) 28. Hirzebruch, F.: Topological Methods in Algebraic Geometry. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1966 29. Ibragimov, N.: Transformation Groups Applied to Mathematical Physics. Boston: Riedel, 1985 30. Krasil’shchik, I., Lychagin, V., Vinogradov, A.: Geometry of Jet Spaces and Nonlinear Partial Differential Equations. New York: Gordon and Breach, 1985 31. Mac Lane, S.: Homology. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1967 32. Mangiarotti, L., Sardanashvily, G.: Connections in Classical and Quantum Field Theory. Singapore: World Scientific, 2000 33. Massey, W.: Homology and Cohomology Theory. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1978 34. Monterde, J., Vallejo, J.: The symplectic structure of Euler–Lagrange superequations and Batalin– Vilkoviski formalism. J. Phys. A 36, 4993–5009 (2003) 35. Olver, P.: Applications of Lie Groups to Differential Equations. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1986 36. Rennie, A.: Smoothness and locality for nonunital spectral triples. K-Theory 28, 127–165 (2003) 37. Sardanashvily, G.: Covariant spin structure. J. Math. Phys. 39, 2714–2729 (1998) 38. Sardanashvily, G.: SUSY-extended field theory. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 15, 3095–3112 (2000) 39. Sardanashvily, G.: Cohomology of the variational complex in field-antifield BRST theory. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 16, 1531–1541 (2001) 40. Sardanashvily, G.: Remark on the Serre–Swan theorem for non-compact manifolds. http://arxiv.org/list/math-ph/0102016, 2001 41. Sardanashvily, G.: Cohomology of the variational complex in the class of exterior forms of finite jet order. Int. J. Math. and Math. Sci. 30, 39–48 (2002) 42. Takens, F.: A global version of the inverse problem of the calculus of variations. J. Diff. Geom. 14, 543–562 (1979) 43. Tulczyiew, W.: The Euler–Lagrange resolution. In: Differential Geometric Methods in Mathematical Physics (Proc. Conf., Aix-en-Provence/Salamanca, 1979), Lecture Notes in Math. 836. Berlin: Springer, 1980, pp. 22–48 Communicated by N.A. Nekrasov
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 129–138 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1361-2
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
A New Inequality for the von Neumann Entropy Noah Linden, Andreas Winter Department of Mathematics, University of Bristol, University Walk, Bristol BS8 1TW, U.K. E-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected] Received: 2 July 2004 / Accepted: 13 December 2004 Published online: 19 May 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: Strong subadditivity of von Neumann entropy, proved in 1973 by Lieb and Ruskai, is a cornerstone of quantum coding theory. All other known inequalities for entropies of quantum systems may be derived from it. Here we prove a new inequality for the von Neumann entropy which we prove is independent of strong subadditivity: it is an inequality which is true for any four party quantum state, provided that it satisfies three linear relations (constraints) on the entropies of certain reduced states. 1. Introduction Entropy is a key concept both in classical and in quantum information theory: Shannon’s source and channel coding and half a century of work [11] have exhibited a vast range of operational coding problems whose solution can be expressed most naturally by (Shannon-Gibbs-Boltzmann) entropies of random variables: H (X) = − Pr{X = x} log2 Pr{X = x}. x
Quantum information theory [3] allows a wealth of new information processing possibilities, with the von Neumann (quantum) entropy playing a role analogous to Shannon’s (classical) entropy in classical information theory: for a density operator ρ, the von Neumann entropy is S(ρ) = −Trρ log2 ρ. Although the two entropy functionals exhibit similarities, they have many decidedly different properties. These properties however, because of the intimate relation of the entropy to operational properties of (classical and quantum) information, ultimately express statements about the “nature of information”. Furthermore, they are indispensable technical tools in proving the information theoretic optimality of constructions:
130
N. Linden, A. Winter
most importantly, there are inequalities governing the relative magnitude of entropies, conditional entropies and mutual information. In the quantum case, there is essentially only one known inequality (all others being derivable from it): strong subadditivity. Proved by Lieb and Ruskai [6] in 1973, it is the key result on which virtually every nontrivial quantum coding theorem relies. We prove here a new inequality for the von Neumann entropy, which we show cannot be derived from the known ones: it is a constrained inequality in that it is not true in general but only for states satisfying three particular linear constraints on their entropies. One starting point for our work was the desire to understand properties of quantum entropy. We were also motivated by investigations of multi-party entanglement in [7]: namely, the entropies of any set of parties of a multi-party pure states are invariants under asymptotically reversible (multi-copy) state transformations. In [7], “entropy” values were found which are allowed by strong subadditivity but for which the authors could not find quantum states. This led to the conjecture that it is impossible to realise those values by a quantum state, which we indeed prove here. The structure of our paper is as follows: the next section reviews the well-established convexity framework for (linear) information inequalities. In Sect. 3 we state and prove our result, while in Sect. 4 we explain why it does not follow from the standard inequalities. In Sect. 5 we present a number of alternative forms of our inequality. We close in Sect. 6 with a discussion and a conjectured unconstrained inequality. 2. Linear Inequalities Pippenger [8] initiated the programme of determining all (linear) inequalities satisfied by the classical entropy functional H . This question was based on the realisation of two facts (see Yeung’s work [12]): first, that in information theoretic applications, the properties one uses about the entropy to bound information quantities seem always to be 1. 2. 3. 4.
Nonnegativity of entropy H (X). Nonnegativity of conditional entropy H (X|Y ) = H (XY ) − H (Y ). Nonnegativity of mutual information I (X; Y ) = H (X) + H (Y ) − H (XY ). Nonnegativity of conditional mutual information I (X; Z|Y ) = H (XY ) + H (Y Z) − H (XY Z) − H (Y ),
for random variables X, Y, Z, the so-called basic inequalities. n Second, that for every number n of random variables, the points in R2 −1 given by the entropies of all possible subsets of the random variables, (H (XS ))∅=S⊂{1,... ,n} : X1 , . . . , Xn random variables (where all random variables are assumed to be discrete and indeed finite range) form “almost” a convex cone (i.e., closed under nonnegative linear combinations) in the ∗ positive orthant: one only needs to go to the topological closure, denoted n , and called the (classical) entropy cone. Surprisingly, the classical entropy cone can be strictly smaller than the cone cut out by the basic inequalities for all subsets of random variables (which we will call “Shannon cone” n ): while the two cones coincide for n ≤ 3, they differ for n = 4. Indeed, as Yeung and Zhang have shown, there are further inequalities satisfied by the entropy
A New Inequality for von Neumann Entropy
131
cone which are not dependent on the basic inequalities; i.e., they are violated by points in the Shannon cone. Pippenger [9] observed that a similar situation occurs in the quantum case: with an underlying multipartite state ρ, denote the entropy of its restriction to subsystems A, . . . , or groups of subsystems AB, . . . , by S(A), S(AB), etc. Then, there is a “von Neumann” cone n , defined by the basic inequalities 1. Nonnegativity of entropy S(A). 2. Nonnegativity of the quantity S(A|B) + S(A) = S(AB) − S(B) + S(A) (this is known as the triangle inequality [2] of Araki and Lieb). 3. Nonnegativity of S(C|A)+S(C|B) = S(CA)+S(CB)−S(A)−S(B) (this replaces nonnegativity of the conditional entropy, and is called “weak monotonicity”). 4. Nonnegativity of quantum mutual information I (A; B) = S(A) + S(B) − S(AB). 5. Nonnegativity of quantum conditional mutual information I (A; C|B) = S(AB) + S(BC) − S(ABC) − S(B). (Note that the names of the quantities are given based on straightforward analogy, with no operational significance implied at this point.) The latter two are simply subadditivity and strong subadditivity [6] of the quantum entropy. The properties 2) [and 3)] above, can actually be derived from 4) [and 5)] (and vice versa) by viewing the state as the restriction of a pure state on the given parties plus one, and the fact that for a pure state, the entropy of a subset of the parties equals the entropy of the complementary set; the first equivalence was observed in [2], the second in [6]. They are actually a consequence of a linear algebra fact, namely the Schmidt decomposition of bipartite pure states, whose coefficients are the eigenvalues of both reduced states (for a more detailed discussion, see [10]). Note also that choosing trivial B (i.e., with Hilbert space C) reduces weak monotonicity to the triangle inequality, and conditional mutual information to mutual information (compare the classical case). Thus all non-trivial inequalities may be derived from strong subadditivity. We are particularly interested in the values of entropies which are actually realised by quantum states. Given a quantum state on the tensor product of n finite quantum systems, there is the 2n − 1-dimensional vector of the entropies of the 2n − 1 nontrivial ∗ marginals. Hence there is the cone of quantum entropies n : the closure of the set of all vectors realised by entropies of quantum states on finite quantum systems. That it is indeed a cone is proved in the same way as for the classical case [9], and we briefly sketch the argument. We leave it to the reader to convince him/herself that it is enough to show the following. a) For any entropy vectors v, w ∈ n∗ , also v + w ∈ n∗ ; this is proved by considering the tensor product of states representing v and w. b) For any > 0 there is δ > 0 such that for all 0 ≤ λ ≤ δ and v ∈ n∗ , there is u ∈ n∗ such that λv − u ≤ ; for this, consider the state λρ + (1 − λ)|0 . . . 0 0 . . . 0|, where ρ represents v and |0 . . . 0 0 . . . 0| is some n-party product (pure) state. The faces of the cone n are given by certain entropies being zero (which means that the corresponding subsystem is in a pure state), certain mutual information being zero (which means that certain pairs of subsystems are in a product state), certain conditional mutual information being zero, etc. The latter is fully analogous to the classical case of a Markov chain, where A and C are independent conditional on B (which we call the “pivot” of the chain), as explained in [4]. All this raises the following natural question: are there any further linear inequal∗ ities for the quantum entropy than those above? More precisely: is n n , and if ∗ so, can we find a hyperplane intersecting the interior of n but having n entirely in
132
N. Linden, A. Winter
one halfspace? It should not be too surprising that the question for inqualities beyond strong subadditivity, or for strengthenings of it, has been asked before: one of the earliest discussions of this problem seems to be by Lieb [5]. In our case, an additional incentive was provided by the two extremal rays of 4 mentioned in the introduction and given in Sect. 4 below, which in [7] were studied, but without being able to find a matching state. Since our main result proves that such states do in fact not exist, one arrives at the conjecture that any face of 4 which contains one of these rays is not entirely contained in 4∗ — indeed, this would be a consequence of our conjecture 6 below. 3. The New Inequality Our main result is the following theorem, which gives an answer to the question at the end of Sect. 2 in its first form, and provides evidence for a positive answer to the second. Theorem 1. Let ρ ABCD be a state of a quadripartite quantum system, such that strong subadditivity is saturated for the three triples ABC, CAB and ADB (pivot always in the middle). Then, I (C; D) ≥ I (C; AB). Proof. The proof relies heavily on the recent characterisation of states which saturate strong subadditivity [4], which is stated below as Proposition 2. First of all, since we have strong subadditivity saturated for CAB, Ca L aR B ρ CAB = pi ρ i i ⊗ ρ i i , i
by Proposition 2. To this we apply Proposition 2 once more, for the triple ABC: there exists the recovery map RB→C (we duplicate C, and attach a prime, to distinguish the
two incarnations of C) mapping ρ AB to ρ ABC . It maps the above ρ CAB to a R bL bR C
Ca L ρ CABC = pi pj |i ρi i ⊗ ρiji j ⊗ ρj j . ij
C
A
B
D Fig. 1. The angles in the figure represent the strong subadditivity constraints which are saturated in the conditions of Theorem 1 (i.e. strong subadditivity is saturated for the triples ABC, CAB, ADB; pivot always in the middle). Theorem 1 then states that under these conditions, the correlation between C and D is not smaller than that between C and AB
A New Inequality for von Neumann Entropy
133
(Notice that the states on the far right, by the structure of RB→C can only depend on j , the Hilbert space sector measured by the map, as described in Proposition 2 below.) But the two states obtained by tracing out C and C , respectively (and identifying C with C again), must coincide: ρ CAB = ρ ABC =
CaiL
a R bjL
⊗ ρiji
ij
pij ρi
ij
pij ρi i ⊗ ρiji
a R bjL
aL
bR
⊗ ρj j , bR C
⊗ ρj j .
Comparing these two, for a given sector labelled ij , with pij > 0, we obtain that both CaiL
ρi
bR C
and ρj j
are actually product states: CaiL
ρi
bR C
ρj j
aL
= ρjC ⊗ ρi i , bR
= ρj j ⊗ ρiC .
(1)
That the right-hand sides contain both i and j (whereas the left hand sides mention only i and only j , respectively) is no error, but in fact the main point: it means that for actually occurring ij , i.e., pij > 0, the state of C belonging to this sector depends only on i and only on j — in other words, it must be a common function of i and j : ρkC , with k = f (i) = g(j ), with certain (deterministic) functions f and g. We note that if all the pij are strictly positive, then the only way for ρkC to be consistent with Eq. (1) is for it to be constant, i.e. independent of i and j . Situations in which ρkC can vary with i and j are only possible when some of the pij are zero. As an illustration, consider a state ρ ABC which has i, j = 1, 2, 3, and p11 > 0, p22 > 0, p23 > 0, p32 > 0 and p33 > 0, but pij = 0 otherwise; then the non-constant possibility ρkC = ρ1 for i = j = 1 and ρkC = ρ2 = ρ1 for (i, j ) = (2, 2), (2, 3), (3, 2), (3, 3) (i.e. f (1) = g(1) = 1, f (2) = f (3) = g(2) = g(3) = 2) is consistent with Eq. (1). Returning to the general situation, with k as described in the previous paragraph but one, we can rewrite ρ ABC again, ρ ABC =
a R bjL
aL
pij ρi i ⊗ ρiji
bR
⊗ ρj j ⊗ ρkC .
ij
In fact, let us introduce quantum registers KA and KB holding k explicitly (of course, by our observation, they will be perfectly correlated) — and note that their content can be extracted locally at A and B, respectively, without disturbing the state ρ ABC , by a measurement of the orthogonal subspace sector i and j , respectively: ρ KA ABKB C =
aL
a R bjL
pij |k k|KA ⊗ ρi i ⊗ ρiji
bR
⊗ ρj j ⊗ |k k|KB ⊗ ρkC .
ij
We shall use the following convention: some of the registers are classical (such as KA and KB ) in as much as they come with a distinguished basis, and the global state is written as a mixture of states which have the classical registers in one of their distinguished basis states. These classical registers we identify with random variables, by the same name, for example KA with distribution
134
N. Linden, A. Winter
Pr{KA = k} = pk =
pi .
i:f (i)=k
This will allow us to speak about the state in quantum theoretical language, and interchangeably about its classical properties in random variable language. For example, as random variables, KA = KB with probability 1, by our earlier observation. The proof will now be completed by showing two things: first, that I (C; AB) equals the Holevo quantity of the ensemble of the ρkC , which is I (KA ; C); second, that k is also “known at D” by which we mean that there is a measurement on D extracting a random variable KD perfectly correlated with KA = KB . First, the first claim: the system AB, by our above characterisation, falls into orthog(AB)k onal sectors (AB)k , labelled by k, and the state in this sector is some σk ⊗ ρkC , a R bL
aL
bR
because it is a convex combination of states ρi i ⊗ ρiji j ⊗ ρj j ⊗ ρkC , with ij consistent with k, so they all have the same state ρkC on C. Hence, there is a quantum operation extracting KA from AB (a coarse-graining of the disturbance-free measurement of i (AB)k and j ), as well as a reverse, creating σk in AB from KA . By monotonicity of the quantum mutual information, I (C; AB) = I (KA ; C). The second claim is seen as follows: using the third constraint, I (A; B|D) = 0, with the monotonicity of the quantum conditional mutual information under the local maps extracting KA (from A) and KB (from B), gives I (KA ; KB |D) = 0. Proposition 2 guarantees the existence of a measurement (whose outcome we think of being stored in a classical register KD ) such that conditional on each measurement outcome, KA and KB are in a product state. It is straightforward to check that then I (KA ; KB |KD ) = 0, and because KA and KB are perfectly correlated, they must also be perfectly correlated with KD : KA = KB = KD with probability 1, as random variables. These two facts, by monotonicity of the quantum mutual information under quantum operations, finally yield I (C; AB) = I (KA ; C) = I (KD ; C) ≤ I (C; D). Proposition 2 (Hayden, Jozsa, Petz and Winter [4]). A state ρ ABC saturating strong subadditivity at pivot B, i.e., satisfying S(AB) + S(BC) = S(ABC) + S(B), must have the following form. There exists an orthogonal decomposition of B’s Hilbert space HB into subspaces HBj , each of which has a natural presentation as tensor product of two Hilbert spaces: HB = HbL ⊗ HbR , j
j AbjL
such that (with states ρj
j
bR C
on HA ⊗ HbL and ρj j j
ρ ABC =
AbjL
pj ρ j
on HbR ⊗ HC ) j
bR C
⊗ ρj j .
j
This can be operationally rephrased as follows: there is a quantum operation RB→C from B to BC such that ρ ABC = (idA ⊗ RB→C )ρ AB , which has the following form: 1. Perform a projective measurement associated with an orthogonal decomposition of B into sectors Bj .
A New Inequality for von Neumann Entropy
135
2. Each sector has a tensor product structure Bj = bjL bjR ; having measured j in step bR C
1, the map discards the state on bjR and replaces it by ρj j bjR C.
on the composite system
Remark 3. One can easily construct states where our inequality is strict, and others where it is tight: a state of the form ρ ABCD = qj ρjA ⊗ σjB ⊗ ϕjCD , j
with ϕjCD being arbitrary and having the marginal states τj and ζj on C and D, respectively, will generically have I (C; D) > I (C; AB). If however ϕjCD = τjC ⊗ ζjD , with mutually orthogonal τjC , we have equality. Also, it is easy to see that no proper subset of our three constraints can imply I (C; D) ≥ I (C; AB): 1. Saturation of strong subadditivity for ABC and CAB: consider ρ ABCD =
ABC 1 |000 000| + |111 111| ⊗ |0 0|D . 2
It satisfies these two constraints (and many more), but has I (C; D) = 0 and, however, I (C; AB) = 1. 2. Saturation of strong subadditivity for ABC and ADB: consider ρ ABCD =
BC 1 ⊗ |00 00|AD . |00 00| + |11 11| 2
It satisfies these two constraints (and many more), but has I (C; D) = 0 and, however, I (C; AB) = 1. Remark 4. It is worth pointing out that not every application of Proposition 2 along the lines of our proof of Theorem 1 yields a nontrivial result, even though it may seem so at first sight: for example, consider a tripartite state ρ ABC which saturates strong subadditivity for ABC. Then, the characterisation of such states implies that ρ AC is separable, which is well-known to imply S(AC) ≥ S(C). Since this inequality is false for general states, have we found a new constrained inequality? Actually no: it can be checked immediately that in generality, 2S(A|C) + I (A; C|B) = S(A|B) + S(A|C) + I (A; B|C) ≥ 0, by the basic inequalities (weak monotonicity and strong subadditivity): hence, if I (A; C|B) = 0, then necessarily S(A|C) ≥ 0. 4. Why the Constrained Inequality is New In the introduction we have explained already why for three parties there cannot be an ∗ information inequality independent of the basic ones, as 3 = 3 [9, 7]. Indeed, as
136
N. Linden, A. Winter
one can see from these papers there cannot even be a constrained inequality, since on each of the 8 extremal rays of 3 there are (nonzero) entropy vectors realised by certain states. We re-iterate here that if we speak of an inequality being “dependent” on others, we mean it in the sense of convex geometry: that it is a positive linear combination of these other inequalities. In particular, the equivalence between, say, subadditivity and triangle inequality, is not of this type. The four party case is studied in [7] with particular interest in the insights to be gained about multi-party entanglement. There it is shown that 4 has 76 extremal rays, which fall naturally into 8 symmetry classes under permutation of the parties. For 6 of them [7] gives states realising entropy vectors on the rays. The two remaining classes are represented by the rays spanned by the following vectors (the first row gives the combinations of subsystems in lexicographic order; below are their “entropies”): I II
A B C D AB AC AD BC BD CD ABC ABD ACD BCD ABCD 3 3 2 2 4 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 4 4 4 4 4 6 5 5 5 5 2
Clearly, if one could find states realising these vectors (or nonzero multiples), this would ∗ prove 4 = 4 . However, it is readily verified that both these rays satisfy the condition of Theorem 1, but not the conclusion: both vectors given above have I (C; D) = S(C) + S(D) − S(CD) = 0 but I (C; AB) = S(C) + S(AB) − S(ABC) = 2 > 0. Corollary 5. There are no quantum states of finite systems realising entropy vectors on the rays I and II above (except for the origin). In fact, in the face of the cone 4 described by the three constraint equations of Theorem 1, the new inequality I (C; D) ≥ I (C; AB) cuts off a slice, which contains the rays I and II. In other words, the two entropy vectors satisfy all the basic inequalities, but by Theorem 1 there can be no non-trivial quantum state with entropy vector in these rays. Thus, Theorem 1 cannot be derived from the constraints in its statement using only the basic inequalities and positive linear combinations, and so the new inequality is indeed independent of all previously known inequalities. We hasten to add, however, that this does not exclude the possibility of a proof of it using other, “non-linear”, means, like the purification trick relating some of the basic inequalities. 5. Alternative Forms of the Inequality We have presented the new inequality in Theorem 1 in a form which reflects our way of proving it. Writing out the mutual information in terms of entropies, one notices that some terms cancel, and we arrive at the following reformulation of our result: Theorem 1 . Let ρ ABCD be a state of a quadripartite quantum system such that S(AB) + S(BC) − S(B) − S(ABC) = 0, S(CA) + S(AB) − S(A) − S(CAB) = 0, S(AD) + S(DB) − S(D) − S(ADB) = 0. Then, S(ABC) + S(D) ≥ S(AB) + S(CD), i.e., I (ABC; D) ≥ I (AB; CD).
A New Inequality for von Neumann Entropy
137
We present this reformulation mainly because it may help understanding and applying the result. There is another one, however, which is less trivial: we can apply the purification trick that is used to relate strong subadditivity and weak monotonicity (see Sect. 2). In detail, we construct a purification ABCDE of the given state ρ ABCD and can apply Theorem 1 or 1 to three situations: strong subadditivity saturated for the triples ABC, CAB and AEB; second, for AEC, CAE and ADE; third, for ABE, EAB and ADB. If we then systematically eliminate all entropies involving E by substituting the complementary group, we get the following statements: Theorem 1
. Let ρ ABCD be a state of a quadripartite quantum system. Consider the following three properties this state could have: I (A; C|B) = I (B; C|A) = I (A; B|CD) = 0, S(C|A) + S(C|BD) = I (A; C|BD) = S(A|D) + S(A|BC) = 0, S(B|A) + S(B|CD) = S(A|B) + S(A|CD) = I (A; B|D) = 0.
(1) (2) (3)
Then, (1) ⇒ S(C|AB) + S(C|ABD) ≥ 0, (2) ⇒ S(C|D) + S(C|BD) ≤ 0, (3) ⇒ S(D) + S(CD) ≥ S(AB) + S(ABC).
6. Discussion Although we believe that the discovery of a new constrained information inequality is ∗ interesting in itself, our Theorem 1 is not enough to conclude 4 4 because it may be that there are states realising entropy vectors arbitrarily close to the points I and II in the previous section. Such a possibility could be ruled out by finding an unconstrained inequality satisfied by 4∗ but violated by points on the rays I and II. Note that indeed for n = 3, in both the quantum and classical version of the question, the set of entropic ∗ ∗ vectors is not closed, so is not identical to the entropy cone 3 , 3 . On the other hand, it is still the case that the extremal rays are indeed populated by distributions/states. We may remark that in the classical variant of the question, Yeung and Zhang also at first only found a constrained inequality [13], and only somewhat later their unconstrained inequality in [14], whose proof indeed uses ideas from constrained inequalities. We think, however, that our result provides some evidence towards the existence of such an inequality for the quantum entropy cone; in fact, we believe that it way well be possible to prove an inequality ruling out the approximability of I and II, based on the following: in [4], it is conjectured that there is a robust version of that paper’s main theorem — characterising the states that come close to saturating strong subadditivity. It seems likely that with such a theorem one could perform an approximation version of the proof of Theorem 1, and conclude a new “constrained” inequality if the three constraint equations of Theorem 1 are only almost satisfied. In other words, there would be a trade-off between the degree by which I (A; C|B), I (C; B|A), I (A; B|D) are nonzero, and the negativity of I (C; D) − I (C; AB). This rationalises the following conjecture, with which we close the paper:
138
N. Linden, A. Winter
Conjecture 6. There exist positive constants κ1 , κ2 and κ3 , such that for all quadripartite states, κ1 I (A; C|B) + κ2 I (C; B|A) + κ3 I (A; B|D) + I (C; D) − I (C; AB) ≥ 0. Acknowledgements. We thank E. Maneva, S. Massar, S. Popescu, D. Roberts, B. Schumacher, J. A. Smolin and A. V. Thapliyal, for illuminating discussions on the subjects of this paper over many years and for allowing us to use their results prior to publication. We also thank M. Christandl and T. Osborne for helpful remarks. Both authors received support from the EU under European Commission project RESQ (contract IST-2001-37559).
References 1. Accardi, L., Frigerio, A.: Markovian cocycles. Proc. Roy. Irish Acad. 83A(2), 251–263 (1983) 2. Araki, H., Lieb, E.H.: Entropy inequalities. Commun. Math. Phys. 18, 160–170 (1970) 3. Bennett, C.H., Shor, P.W.: Quantum information theory. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 44(6), 2724–2742 (1998) 4. Hayden, P., Jozsa, R., Petz, D., Winter, A.: Structure of states which satisfy strong subadditivity of quantum entropy with equality. Commun. Math. Phys. 246(2), 359–374 (2004) 5. Lieb, E.H.: Some Convexity and Subadditivity Properties of Entropy. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 81, 1–13 (1975) 6. Lieb, E.H., Ruskai, M.B.: Proof of the strong subadditivity of quantum-mechanical entropy. J. Math. Phys. 14, 1938–1941 (1973) 7. Linden, N., Maneva, E., Massar, S., Popescu, S., Roberts, D., Schumacher, B., Smolin, J.A., Thapliyal, A.V.: In preparation 8. Pippenger, N.: What are the laws of information theory? 1986 Special Problems in Communication and Computation Conference, Palo Alto, CA, 3–5 September 1986 9. Pippenger, N.: The inequalities of quantum information theory. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 49(4), 773–789 (2003) 10. Ruskai, M.B.: Inequalities for quantum entropy: A review with conditions for equality. J. Math. Phys. 43(9), 4358–4375 (2002) 11. Shannon, C.E.: A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell System Tech. J. 27, 379–423 and 623–656 (1948) Shannon Theory demi-centennial issue of IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory: 44(6), (1998) 12. Yeung, R.W.: A Framework for Linear Information Inequalities. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 43(6), 11924–1934 (1997) 13. Zhang, Z., Yeung, R.W.: A Non-Shannon Type Conditional Inequality of Information Quantities. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 43(6), 1982–1985 (1997) 14. Yeung, R.W., Zhang, Z.: On Characterization of Entropy Function via Information Inequalities. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 44(4), 1440–1452 (1998) Communicated by M.B. Ruskai
Commun. Math. Phys. 259, 139–183 (2005) Digital Object Identifier (DOI) 10.1007/s00220-005-1347-0
Communications in
Mathematical Physics
Instability Zones of a Periodic 1D Dirac Operator and Smoothness of its Potential Plamen Djakov1, , Boris Mityagin2 1
Department of Mathematics, Sofia University, 1164 Sofia, Bulgaria. E-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Mathematics, The Ohio State University, 231 West 18th Ave, Columbus, OH 43210, USA. E-mail:
[email protected] Received: 26 August 2004 / Accepted: 8 November 2004 Published online: 15 April 2005 – © Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract: Let L be the differential operator 0 P (x) 1 0 dy + y, Ly = i Q(x) 0 0 −1 dx
y y= 1 , y2
where P (x), Q(x) are 1-periodic functions such that Q(x) = P (x). The operator L, considered on [0, 1] with periodic (y(0) = y(1)), or antiperiodic (y(0) = −y(1)) boundary conditions, is self-adjoint, and moreover, for large |n| it has, close to nπ, a pair of periodic − (if n is even), or antiperiodic (if n is odd) eigenvalues λ+ n , λn . We study the relationship − between the decay rate of the instability zone sequence γn = λ+ n − λn , n → ±∞, and the smoothness of the potential function P (x). 1. Introduction 1. The operator
0 P (x) 1 0 dy Ly = i y, + 0 −1 dx P (x) 0
y y= 1 , y2
(1.1)
with a periodic function P (x) of period 1, P ∈ L2 ([0, 1]), is a self-adjoint operator on the real line R. Its spectrum σ (L) is absolutely continuous and has “a band structure”, i.e., + σ (L) = R \ ∪n∈Z (λ− n , λn ), The first author acknowledges the hospitality of The Mathematics Department of The Ohio State University during academic year 2003/2004. His research is partially supported by Grant MM–1401/04 of the Bulgarian Ministry of Education and Science.
140
P. Djakov, B. Mityagin
where − + + · · · < λ− n ≤ λn < λn+1 ≤ λn+1 < · · · , + and λ− n , λn is a pair of eigenvalues of the same differential operator L, but considered on the interval [0, 1], respectively with periodic (for even n), and antiperiodic (for odd n) boundary conditions (bc):
P er + : y(0) = y(1),
P er − : y(0) = −y(1).
See basic facts and further references on 1-D Dirac operators in [21, 23, 25, 29]. After Zakharov-Shabat [32–34] the operators (1.1) or (2.4), with Q = −P , and their spectra are closely related to analysis of the complete integrability of a dynamic system NLS, the nonlinear (cubic) Schr¨odinger equation. See [1, 31, 12] and references there. − 2. Let γn = λ+ n − λn , n ∈ Z, be the lengths of spectral gaps, or instability zones, + − (λn , λn ). What is the relationship between the decay rate of γn , n → ±∞, and the smoothness of a potential P ? In the case of Schr¨odinger (Hill) operators this question has a long history. Let us recall a few results and steps in the understanding of this relation. H. Hochstadt [17] proved that if a real-valued L2 -potential v of the Schr¨odinger operator My = −y + v(x)y, C ∞ -function
is a that is
v(x + 1) = v(x), x ∈ R,
then the gap sequence (γn )∞ 1 decays faster than any power of 1/n, (γn ) ∈ a = {(xn ) :
∞
|xn |2 (1 + n2 )a < ∞}
(1.2)
n=1
for every a > 0. He proved also [18] by using the trace formula [13] that a finite-zone potential (i.e., γn = 0 for all but finitely many n) is a C ∞ -function. For H. Hochstadt, this was an important step in analysis of finite-zone potentials; as soon as one knew that such potential is a C ∞ - function, it was possible [14, 17, 18] to use derivatives and derive polynomial identities involving v, v , v , . . . to determine v. Further analysis of finite-zone potentials [10, 28] led to the Dubrovin equations (see [11]). H. McKean and E. Trubowitz [24] used the trace formula in general setting to prove that (1.2) implies v ∈ C ∞ . E. Trubowitz [30] extended the analysis of [24], complemented by Dubrovin equations [10], to show that a real-valued L2 -potential v(x) is analytic if and only if the gap sequence (γn ) decays exponentially fast, that is ∃a > 0, C > 0 :
γn ≤ C exp(−an) ∀n ≥ 0.
In terms of the weighted sequence spaces 2 = {(xn ) : |xn |2 2 (n) < ∞}, Sobolev or analytic functions v, v(x) =
vk exp(2πikx),
can be characterized as having their Fourier-coefficient sequences in 2 , where = (1 + n2 )a/2 , or = exp(an), a > 0, respectively. T. Kappeler and B. Mityagin [19, 20] raised the general question about the relationship between the two conditions v ∈ H () and (γn ) ∈ 2 , where
1D Dirac Operators
141
H () = {v : (vk ) ∈ 2 },
(1.3)
for general (submultiplicative) weights. They showed that v ∈ H () ⇒ (γn ) ∈ 2 .
(1.4)
(γn ) ∈ 2 ⇒ v ∈ H ()
(1.5)
The opposite implication
required a delicate analysis of special non-linear equations in sequence spaces and a priori estimates of the Sobolev norms of their solutions. This has been done in [3–5] for, roughly speaking, each submultiplicative weight sequence of subexponential growth, i.e., lim (log n ) /n = 0. This is not just a technical restriction. For with superexponential growth like exp(|n|b ), b > 1, the implications (1.4) and (1.5) are not valid, but the proper adjustment can be made, and this is presented in [6]. Analysis of non-self-adjoint Hill operators, i.e., the case of complex-valued potentials, is done in [7]; see further references there. 3. Let us return to Dirac operators. Surprisingly enough, we could not find in the literature even a Hochstadt–McKean–Trubowitz [17, 18, 24] type statement in this case. Still, after [19, 20] the approach developed there for the Schr¨odinger-Hill case has been used in the Dirac case in [15, 16] to get claims about the decay rate of spectral gaps: γn2 2n < ∞ (1.6) P ∈ H () ⇒ n∈Z
under some rigid and (as we will see) unnecessary restrictions on . The main goal of the present paper is to show that for subexponential weights the H ()-smoothness of a potential P , i.e., the condition P ∈ H (), follows from 2 -decay of the two-sided sequence (γn ), i.e., (1.7) γn2 2n < ∞ ⇒ P ∈ H () (see Theorem 11, Sect. 4, for accurate formulation). This result has been announced in [8], Thm 2(i). Maybe, it’s worth mentioning that there is an analogue of this implication (and equivalence) in the non-self-adjoint case (see [8], Thm 2(ii); this result will be given with detailed proofs in [9]). In particular, (1.6) and (1.7) tell us the following. (A) (γn ) decays faster than any power of 1/n if and only if P ∈ C ∞ (compare to [17, 24]). (B) (γn ) decays faster than exp(−an) for some a > 0 if and only if P is analytic in a strip around the real axis (compare to [30]). (C) (γn ) decays faster than exp(−anβ ), β ∈ (0, 1), for some a > 0 if and only if the Fourier coefficients (pk ) of P decay faster than exp(−A|k|β ), for some A > 0 (compare to [5]). The statements (A), (B) and (C) are given in a precise form in Sect. 5.1. In the case of Schr¨odinger - Hill operators we have proven similar statements in [5] and [7]. The general scheme of the present paper is close to the scheme of our paper [5]. However, the technical details and difficulties are quite different, because
142
P. Djakov, B. Mityagin
(i) the Dirac operator is not semibounded; (ii) its resolvent is not a trace class operator. We are going to make this point explicit and specific in our proofs and comments below. The structure of our paper is as follows. Abstract Introduction Basic equation and formulae for gaps Weights; Carleman sequences Basic results: estimates on the smoothness of the potential in terms of the decay rate of spectral gaps 5. Conclusions and comments References 1. 2. 3. 4.
2. Basic Equation and Formulae for Spectral Gaps 1. The Dirac operator
L0 y = i
1 0 dy , 0 −1 dx
y=
y1 , y2
(2.1)
considered on the interval [0, 1] with periodic (y(0) = y(1)) or antiperiodic (y(0) = −y(1)) boundary conditions, has a discrete spectrum {2kπ, k ∈ Z} or {(2k+1)π, k ∈ Z}, respectively. Each eigenvalue nπ, both for periodic (if n is even), or antiperiodic (if n is odd) boundary conditions has multiplicity 2, and 1 −inπx 0 inπx 1 2 en (x) = e , en (x) = e (2.2) 0 1 are eigenfunctions corresponding to the eigenvalue nπ. Moreover, if the Hilbert space H = L2 [0, 1] × L2 [0, 1] is equipped with the scalar product 1 g f1 , 1 = (2.3) f1 (x)g1 (x) + f2 (x)g2 (x) dx, f2 g2 0 1 , e2 , k ∈ Z} and {e1 2 then each of the systems {e2k 2k 2k+1 , e2k+1 , k ∈ Z} is an orthonormal basis in H. The operator 0 P (x) 0 L = L + V, V = , (2.4) Q(x) 0
where P and Q are 1-periodic functions, may be considered as a perturbation of L0 . Further we always assume that P , Q ∈ L2 [0, 1]; then the operator L, considered with periodic or antiperiodic boundary conditions, has also a discrete spectrum. The following statement is known (see, for example [22, 23, 25, 26], in particular, [27], Thm. 4.1 and Prop. 4.3). Lemma 1. There exists N0 = N0 (P , Q) such that for each |n| ≥ N0 the open disc with center π n and radius π/2 contains exactly two (counted with multiplicity) periodic (if + n is even), or antiperiodic (if n is odd) eigenvalues {λ− n , λn } of L, i.e., |λ± n − πn| < π/2,
|n| ≥ N0 .
(2.5)
1D Dirac Operators
143
2. Suppose that λ = nπ + z, |n| ≥ N0 , is a periodic (or antiperiodic) eigenvalue of L with |z| < π/2 and y = 0 is a corresponding eigenvector. Let En0 = [en1 , en2 ] be the eigenspace of L0 that corresponds to nπ, and let H(n) be its orthogonal complement. We denote by Pn0 and Q0n , respectively, the orthogonal projectors on En0 and H(n). Then the equation (nπ + z − L)y = 0 is equivalent to the following system of two equations: Q0n (nπ + z − L0 − V )Q0n y + Q0n (nπ + z − L0 − V )Pn0 y = 0,
(2.6)
Pn0 (nπ + z − L0 − V )Q0n y + Pn0 (nπ + z − L0 − V )Pn0 y = 0.
(2.7)
Taking into account that Pn0 Q0n = Q0n Pn0 = 0 and Pn0 L0 Q0n = Q0n L0 Pn0 = 0 we obtain that (2.6) and (2.7) can be written as Q0n (nπ + z − L0 − V )Q0n y − Q0n V Pn0 y = 0,
(2.8)
−Pn0 V Q0n y − Pn0 V Pn0 y + zPn0 y = 0.
(2.9)
A = A(n, z) := Q0n (nπ + z − L0 − V )Q0n : H(n) → H(n)
(2.10)
The operator
is invertible for large |n| (see below (2.18), (2.26) and (2.27)). Thus, solving (2.8) for Q0n y, we obtain Q0n y = A−1 Q0n V Pn0 y, where Pn0 y = 0 (otherwise Q0n y = 0 which implies y = Pn0 y + Q0n y = 0). Now (2.9) implies (after plugging the above expression for Q0n y into (2.9)) that (S − z)Pn0 y = 0, where the operator S is given by S := Pn0 V A−1 Q0n V Pn0 + Pn0 V Pn0 : En0 → En0 .
(2.11)
12
S 11 S be the matrix representation of the two-dimensional operator S with S 21 S 22 respect to the basis en1 , en2 ; then Let
S 11 = en1 , Sen1 ,
S 22 = en2 , Sen2 ,
S 12 = en1 , Sen2 ,
S 21 = en2 , Sen1 . (2.12)
Hence we obtain (since Pn0 y = 0) 11 S − z S 12 = 0. det S 21 S 22 − z
(2.13)
In the self-adjoint case (Q(x) = P (x)), if λ is a double eigenvalue, then there exists another eigenvector y˜ (corresponding to λ), such that y and y˜ are linearly independent. Then Pn0 y and Pn0 y˜ are linearly independent also. Indeed, if Pn0 y = cPn0 y˜ then ˜ Q0n y = A−1 Q0n V Pn0 y = cA−1 Q0n V Pn0 y˜ = cQ0n y, which leads to a contradiction:
y = Pn0 y + Q0n y = c Pn0 y˜ + Q0n y˜ = cy. ˜
144
P. Djakov, B. Mityagin
Thus S ≡ 0, i.e., if λ = πn + z is a double eigenvalue of a self-adjoint Dirac operator L, then (for large enough n) S 11 − z = 0,
S 12 = 0,
S 21 = 0,
S 22 − z = 0.
(2.14)
1 , m ∈ Z} and 3. Let H1 and H2 be the subspaces of H generated, respectively, by {em 2 1 2 {em , m ∈ Z}, and let H (n) and H (n) be, respectively, the intersections of these spaces with H(n). Then H = H1 ⊕ H2 , so each operator B : H → H may be identified with a 2 × 2 operator matrix (B ij ), where B ij : Hj → Hi , i, j = 1, 2. If we consider the 1 , e2 , k ∈ Z} (or {e1 2 matrix representation of B in the basis {e2k 2k 2k+1 , e2k+1 , k ∈ Z}) ij then this matrix itself combines the matrix representations of B . Of course, a similar remark holds for operators acting in H(n). Further we always work with one of the bases (2.2) (respectively, using the first basis in the case of periodic boundary conditions, and the second one in the case of antiperiodic boundary conditions). However, we don’t specify below which basis is used because the formulas for the matrix representations in these bases are formally the same (with running indices even in the first case and odd in the second case). Let P (x) = p(m)eimπx and Q(x) = q(m)eimπx , (2.15) m∈Z
m∈Z
where p(m) = q(m) = 0 for odd m, be the Fourier expansions of the functions P and Q. It is easy to see that the operator V has the following matrix representation 0 V 12 12 21 = p(−k − m), Vkm = q(k + m). (2.16) V = , Vkm V 21 0 The diagonal operator Q0n (nπ + z − L0 )Q0n : H(n) → H(n) is invertible in H(n) for any z with |z| ≤ π/2. Let Dn denote its inverse operator; then the matrix representation of Dn is 11 δkm Dn 0 11 22 , D . (2.17) = D = Dn = 22 n n 0 Dn km km π(n − k) + z The operator A defined in (2.10) can be written as A = Q0n (nπ + z − L0 )Q0n (1 − Tn Q0n ),
(2.18)
Tn = Dn Q0n V : H → H(n).
(2.19)
where
Thus A = A(n, z) is invertible if and only if 1 − Tn Q0n is invertible in H(n). By (2.16) and (2.17) one can easily see that the operator (2.19) has a matrix representation 0 Tn12 , (2.20) Tn = Tn21 0 where (Tn12 )km =
p(−k − m) , π(n − k) + z
(Tn21 )km =
q(k + m) , π(n − k) + z
k, m ∈ Z, k = n. (2.21)
1D Dirac Operators
145
We need also to know the matrix representation of its square Tn2 . From (2.20) and (2.21) it follows that 12 21 T T 0