Closer to Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
PRAEGER
CLOSER TO TRUTH
CLOSER TO TRUTH Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Lawrence Kuhn
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kuhn, Robert Lawrence. Closer to truth : science, meaning, and the future / Robert Lawrence Kuhn. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-275-99389-2 (alk. paper) 1. Research—Philosophy. 2. Scientists—Psychology. 3. Critical thinking. 4. Science— History. I. Title. Q175.3.K84 2007 500—dc22 2006038657 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright © 2007 by Robert Lawrence Kuhn All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2006038657 ISBN–13: 978-0-275-99389-4 ISBN–10: 0-275-99389-2 First published in 2007 Praeger Publishers, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.praeger.com Printed in the United States of America
The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48–1984). 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments
vii
Foreword: No End for Science Exploration Dr. Song Jian
ix
Introduction: What is Closer To Truth? Chapter 1: Is Science Fiction Science?
xvii 1
Chapter 2: Why is Music So Significant?
21
Chapter 3: Is Consciousness an Illusion?
33
Chapter 4: How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
47
Chapter 5: Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
65
Chapter 6: Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
77
Chapter 7: Microbes — Friend or Foe?
91
Chapter 8: Testing New Drugs — Are People Guinea Pigs?
107
Chapter 9: How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
123
Chapter 10: How Weird is the Cosmos?
137
Chapter 11: Is the Universe Full of Life?
155
Chapter 12: Will Computers Take a Quantum Leap?
169
Chapter 13: How Does Basic Science Support National Security?
185
Chapter 14: Can Religion Withstand Technology?
201
Chapter 15: Can We Believe in Both Science and Religion?
217
Why Ultimate Reality Works for Us: Toward a Taxonomy of Possible Explanations
235
vi
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Glossary of Key Terms
259
About the Author and Contributors
279
Index
299
Acknowledgments
Closer To Truth, based on the pubic television/PBS television series of the same name, brings together leading scientists, scholars, artists, and thinkers to explore fundamental issues of life, sentience, universe, and meaning. We seek to make state-of-the-art ideas in science, philosophy, and human understanding accessible, intriguing, and absorbing to intelligent audiences. There are many people to thank for supporting my lifelong process of imagining, creating, planning, producing, writing, editing, thinking about, talking about, wondering about, and worrying about Closer To Truth— the ideas, the television series, and the book. They are my friends, family, mentors, and associates. I particularly acknowledge Mel Rogers, president of KOCE-TV, the PBS station in Huntington Beach (Orange County), California, for taking a chance on the series and for helping with the name; Jack Martin, for offering the encouragement and providing the platform to produce the pilot; and Dr. Shigehisa Okawara, for being my first mentor when he encouraged a 16-year-old college freshman to work in his neurosurgical laboratory. I am pleased to recognize those who worked on the Closer To Truth television series on which this book is based: Linda Fefferman, for directing and producing the specific shows; Bruce Murray, professor emeritus of planetary science and geology at Caltech, for his ideas and advice; Sharon (‘‘Bunny’’) Taveras for distributing and marketing the television series; and Pamela McFadden, for her competence and commitment in all manner of assistance. I thank my wife Dora and now-grown children Aaron, Adam, and Daniella for their long-standing support, and my parents, Lee and Louis Kuhn, for appreciating (if not always understanding) my sometimes unorthodox activities. In an interesting turn of events, this book was published in China prior to its being published in English, and for this I thank my business partner (and friend) in China, Adam Zhu. Closer To Truth, its ideas and energy, are the product of a passion to comprehend in a lifetime of wonder. I do not deny a continuing search for meaning or purpose while I do affirm that a personal predisposition to challenge current belief demands high standards of analytical rigor and critical thinking. This is the mission of Closer To Truth, which, when it works, may help explore the human condition and spotlight, if not decipher, ultimate issues.
Foreword
No End for Science Exploration
Since the Renaissance human beings have gradually shaken off the mentally constricting shackles of irrational ideas and have walked up the rational road of the experimental sciences. In the subsequent 400 years, humans drove the advancement of modern science and technology, thus enhancing their abilities to understand and deal with nature, and penetrated the profound depths of the physical world. Francis Bacon’s motto ‘‘Knowledge is power’’ has become common wisdom. Before the twentieth century, motivations for scientific study were often personal curiosities, but much has changed in the past 100 years. Since science has become the fundamental driving force for the prosperity of nations, the growth of economies, and the welfare of peoples, each government sets up scientific research systems, guides the cause of research endeavors, implements ‘‘Big Science’’ projects, conducts scientific education, and encourages applications. All these undertakings have generated rapid advances in science and technology, and thereby enabled human society to stride forward into the era of a knowledge-based, high-tech economy in which everyone can enjoy the fruits. The emergence of modern human thinking took place no more than 10,000 years ago, a mere instant of time compared with the three billion years of life on earth. Furthermore, only 400 years have elapsed since modern science first appeared. Humans are still young in their quest for knowledge about Mother Nature. It is as if modern science and technology were born just last night. However much knowledge we seem to have accumulated, our understanding about nature is still limited. Pluto, formerly one of the nine planets of our solar system, has only made one and half orbits around the Sun since
x
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
Copernicus published ‘‘On the Revolution of the Heavenly Orbs’’ (1543). The first mammals, the remote ancestors of human beings, appeared less than 200 million years ago, a duration not even sufficiently long for the Sun to complete a single rotation around the center of Milky Way. Some scientific theories, classical or modern, are often recognized to be at best stunning improvisation. For example, the Big Bang Theory, the standard model of the origin of the universe as we know it today, a theory that is consistent with most laws of physics and astronomic observations, is still unable to explain the origin of the singularity from which the Big Bang sprung forth. Many scientists are not convinced that such a singular point could be the origin of the entire mass-energy of the universe. Some physicists claim there was nothing at all before the origin, and would, in their joking manner, ‘‘consign to Hell those who asked such ‘stupid’ questions.’’ Commencing in the latter part of the twentieth century, space technology offered the opportunity for human observation of the universe from outside the earth. Before then, all we knew about nature was gleaned from the surface of the earth. Manned and unmanned space observations have confirmed that, as far as we can see, most of the physical laws are as effective elsewhere in the universe as they are here on earth. But these observations have also challenged some old science paradigms. To my recollection, 50 years ago few people believed that life could exist in extrasolar systems. Although there still is no evidence for extraterrestrial life, mainstream science now recognizes the value of the new discipline of astrobiology. The sun is only one among 100 billion stars in our own Milky Way galaxy. The earth, too, does not seem so special, nothing more than a fortunate planet. In spite of how magnificent modern science and technology seem, and how grand our science mansion looks, the underlying foundation of virtually all we know comes from living on the surface of the earth. We are bound by earth and solar system, and even reaching the nearest exostar, Proxima Centauri (as we call it), seems virtually impossible. To realize the long dream of mankind to travel into extrasolar space we need new ideas, concepts, theories, technologies, and mechanisms far beyond current frameworks. Nothing short of a revolution similar to what quantum mechanics did to Newtonian mechanics would be necessary to make such vast journeys possible. There is much evidence in palaeoanthropology that our human ancestors diverged from Hylobatidae and Pongidae, the fellow families of Hominoidea, many millions of years ago. As Homo sapiens became the first species capable of rational thinking, we are appreciative and justifiably proud of this remarkable increase in mind power. However, we should not be overly arrogant, because we can never disconnect ourselves from our humble biological origins; most of our behaviors and activities have seldom broken free from the instinctive, competitive rules of the animal kingdom. Even after two centuries of arduous campaigning for democracy around the world, there is little change in the Law of the Jungle.
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
xi
In the history of science, we often observe the same strictures and rigidities appearing in diverse forms. For millennia human beings considered themselves to be the core and center of all purpose and principle. Before Copernicus even the most enlightened thinkers assumed without question that our sun and all other stars had to circle around the earth, and that the existence of all living things were here solely for the benefit of Adam’s and Eve’s offspring. The masses had to submit to the Son of Heaven, just as monkeys have to obey their king. An elegant postulate in science is called the ‘‘anthropic principle,’’ which means that all scientific laws and processes of Nature, the entire flow of universal history, must somehow exist to favor (or at least be compatible with) the emergence and sustained existence of human beings. Yet human history itself is rife with the absence of such harmony. We witness daily the gross violations of ethics and morality. Science itself has a long history of being resisted or attacked by politics, religion, and common customs. Bruno was burned; Galileo was persecuted for much of his long life; Martin Luther was assassinated; and Ma Yinchu was animadverted1. Does all this, too, come from the ‘‘anthropic principle?’’ Fortunately, from the beginning of the twentieth century, general conditions for intellectuals, at least for scientists, began changing for the better. Physicists who discerned the mechanism of nuclear fusion and predicted the inevitable death of all stars, including our Sun, went free of punishment and won Nobel Prizes even though they were, in essence, the ultimate doomsayers. Their theoretical calculations proved that all life on earth including human beings will become unavoidably extinct along with the death of our Sun some billions of years from now, if we Homo sapiens are not able to find innovative solutions to change our destined fate. Such annihilative forecasts, of course, are terribly discordant with mankind’s long-range, fundamental interest. The fact that such a certain cataclysm could be accepted calmly by society would suggest that in some sense the impact of the ‘‘anthropic principle’’ is weakening. If human beings can evolve up into a higher state of being, perhaps we could penetrate deeper into the still-dark mysteries of scientific truth. However, human beings, dubbed Naked Apes by some anthropologists, are still biological members of the animal kingdom. Hence it would take a great period of time to divest ourselves of inherited habits. Or rather, we can never break away from our animal natures. Throughout the entire history of mankind, a traditional culture of hierarchies dominated societies: young follow elders; son obeys father; populace submits to emperor; all yield to Heaven. Notwithstanding the magnificent social and psychological benefits of such hierarchies for maintaining order and stability, the rigidity of such structures work to suppress the talent of those few human beings who, for the sake of breakthrough scientific inquiry, are able to challenge current belief and change the status quo. Scientific
xii
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
development, with its need for creativity, innovation, and for defying the accepted order, is often disadvantaged if children must always submit to their parents, if students must always believe what their teachers impart. When textbooks are sacrosanct, when sermons are as if from God, when authority is absolute, when it is forbidden to modify existing scientific theories or to buck authority, reject parts of standard answers, and find new solutions, true science can only be constrained. All these archaic ways of thinking, though they have their social graces, are incompatible with the modern scientific spirit. The one and only correct way to develop frontier and beyond-the-frontier science and technology is to encourage young people to contribute new ideas without fear or favor, to experiment over and over and again and again, to observe from diverse points, to try to discover new phenomena, to put forward hypotheses no matter how strange, and to devise new theories no matter how different, odd, or unaccustomed. All of our current scientific knowledge, theories, and laws, whatever we have believed and believe with good reason, must be deemed to be correct only relatively and conditionally. We should always be prepared for change. And we should never forget that our view and observations are largely gained from the surface of one planet. Such a perspective, no matter how impressed we are with what our contemporary science has achieved, is far too narrow, and our scientific experiences, measured in scant thousands of years, are far too brief. We know little about the deep ocean, the inner earth, the Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud, the Milky Way Galaxy, and the multiple billions of galaxies breathtakingly far away in space and time. It is not exceedingly rare that there may be different hypotheses to account for the same phenomena of nature, and it is only by repeated experiments and continued theoretical substantiation that one hypothesis will come to be favored over the others. For example, between the end of the nineteenth century and the first half of the twentieth, there emerged three kinds of atomic models, each derived from a different perspective (with different extrapolations), that seemed to account for the atomic nucleus: liquid-drop model, shell model, and collective model, each one overlapping, interacting with, and complementing the other two. We continue to use each of these models today. However, even if our current understanding of scientific theories, models, or laws seem perfect, they still may not ultimately hold up intact, because in many areas of human understanding the ultimate truth remains far, perhaps forever far, in the distance. All we humans should expect is to move ‘‘closer to truth,’’ asymptotically closer and closer to our goal of ultimate knowledge, though never knowing for sure if we will ever arrive at the final destination of absolute, last Truth. The age of the earth is proven to be 4.6 billion years, and if we are fortunate enough to escape devastation by impacting asteroids, human beings and our science could last another few billion years before our sun grows
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
xiii
old and begins to expand to swallow the earth in its fiery gases. Yet before that day of our inevitable obliteration, science and technology should be able to find ways for human beings to move to other oases in our vast universe, other habitable planets in our galaxy, so that the torch of human intelligence will continue to shine. Although science is unable to forecast accurately so far into the future, it is obliged to identify likely roads and suggest reliable directions. Passion for science has become good fashion in almost all human cultures, and it is a particular virtue of oriental culture to respect and esteem forefather scientists. However, science belongs not to any one generation but to all human history. Individual human lifetimes are short and new generations will continue to rise and fall. This is the order of nature: as years pass, the young replace the old. Elder scientists, versed with vast knowledge in their fields, should not be too strict with younger scientists. It is an admirable virtue that elders care for their progeny; as the old saying goes, ‘‘life is short, but caring is long.’’ But such care must include the tolerance and respect for deeper annotation and interpretation about conventional wisdom, common understanding, and assumed truth. History has taught us repeatedly that what elders believe is not always correct, and what elders deny is not always wrong. For the long-term interest of human civilization, it is good for elders to create wider spaces for young scientists to explore, and, if they can, to also keep their own minds open. The history of science also indicates that when a major scientific breakthrough occurs, people tend to regard it as an Ultimate Truth. During the twentieth century, quantum mechanics and particle physics made such remarkable advances so that by the 1980s some declared that ‘‘science had ended’’ and that Ultimate Truth—which could explain anything, a ‘‘Theory of Everything’’—was within our grasp. However, in less than 20 years, new mysteries emerged. Evidences of accelerating cosmic expansion, long believed to be impossible due to the inevitable and dominating power of gravity, were found by the satellite observations of COBE (Cosmic Background Explorer, 1989) and WAMP (Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe, 2001). In 1998, leading cosmologists and astronomers declared that there was some kind of ‘‘dark energy’’ existent throughout the universe, a kind of hidden power source which propels all matter in the universe to expand against the inward pull of gravitational attraction, and that such dark energy would have to account for an astounding 73 percent of the total mass-energy of the universe. Physicists suddenly had no choice other than to realize that something heretofore no one knew existed now constitutes most of everything that exists. Moreover, the observational data indicated that only about four percent of all the energy-matter in the universe is ordinary matter, so that the remaining 23 percent of matter must be ‘‘dark.’’ It is a dark matter that reveals its presence by gravity, such as in the higher rotational speeds of stars
xiv
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
in galaxies, but it cannot be seen at all. Up to now, our best science cannot describe what dark energy and dark matter really are nor explain how they are generated. No wonder this latest astounding discovery silenced those advocates who were announcing the ‘‘end of science.’’ Modern science in China started in the twentieth century, 200 years later than it did in Europe, and in recent decades has begun to flourish. It took China a whole century to make up for its somnolence and end its long hiatus from the frontiers of contemporary science. Most science and technology China learned from the West. Yet at the beginning of the twenty-first century it has become apparent that China’s science cannot follow the old paradigm of simply continuing to be a follower of the West. They must create a new paradigm so that not only does China come to rely on its indigenous intellectual strengths but also make original contributions to enrich all humanity and thereby benefit the entire world. Scientists commonly accept the proposition that students may and must be as good as their teachers, standing on their shoulders, as it were, to reach higher into the knowledge firmament. Young generations must be encouraged to be innovative, creative, and imaginative in all sectors of society, especially in science and technology. I am pleased that my friend, Dr. Robert Lawrence Kuhn, decided to publish Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future, which brings together leading scientists, scholars, and artists to debate the fundamental issues of our times, including brain and mind, creativity and thinking, life and health, technology and society, and universe and meaning. The book aims at encouraging young people to create, innovate, and contribute to scientific progress for all humankind. Dr. Kuhn and I often speak on the importance of science and the scientific way of thinking as crucial for the peace and prosperity of all countries and of all humankind. Entrusted by Dr. Kuhn, I am pleased to write this foreword. These are subjects I am thinking about these days, and it seemed to be a good opportunity, in the context of his book on the meaning and implications of frontier science, to communicate with fellow readers with similar interests. My hope is that such thinking might help catalyze a more flexible and innovative academic environment in China and throughout the world, and thus inspire greater progress in science and technology during the twenty-first century. Such is the origin of the above narration. Dr. Song Jian Chairman, Beijing Institute for Frontier Science Past Chairman, State Science and Technology Commission Past Chairman, Chinese Academy of Engineering Beijing, People’s Republic of China March 2006
Foreword: No End for Scientific Exploration
xv
Note 1. Ma Yinchu (1882-1982) , the president of Beijing University (who had earned a master’s degree in economics from Yale and a Ph.D. from Columbia), opposed the assertions that unchecked population growth was no longer a problem under socialism.
Introduction
What is Closer To Truth?
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future is a unique series of discussions about fundamental issues that explores the latest scientific research, philosophical thinking, and expressions of human creativity. Critical to the process, Closer To Truth tests conventional wisdom, seeks truth wherever it may change, sees the humor as well as the import of tradition-breaking ideas, and discerns what it means to be human in the twenty-first century with our continuing search for collective purpose and individual meaning. We confront the mysteries of mind, matter, and meaning, bringing together prominent thinkers to discuss what is happening at the leading edge of science and its broad implications for human understanding. Some of the world’s most esteemed experts, including Nobel laureates, best-selling authors, and renowned scholars, engage in a series of spontaneous and intimate conversations that combine leading-edge science and informed intuition. Closer To Truth is an inside opportunity to witness how the pioneers in humanity’s quest for knowledge chart their expeditions into the unknown, journeys that are marked by a rigorous pursuit of truth, a readiness to challenge current belief, a willingness to overturn dogma, an openminded exploration of inferences and implications, and a tough-minded reliance on critical thinking. I seek multi-faceted perspectives on some of the most exciting and controversial ‘‘big issues’’ of our time. Areas of inquiry are brain and mind, cosmos and astrobiology, biology and medicine, science and religion, and science and our world. What organizing theme brings together such topics? My own personal, perhaps idiosyncratic take on the human condition. Whenever and wherever
xviii
Introduction: What is Closer To Truth?
new knowledge challenges accepted principles, I find topics. I sometimes use three ‘‘C words’’ to mark Closer To Truth—consciousness, cosmology, creativity. My bet is that what I like, you like. The contributors to this book—participants in the Closer To Truth public television series—are among the leaders in their fields; these informal, unrehearsed discussions, derived from the show’s transcripts, give a good sense of state-of-the-art thinking at our intellectual frontiers. We can’t talk about science’s role in our lives without including its effect on morality, philosophy, religion, and human ingenuity. This is why religious scholars, philosophers, and science fiction authors as well as psychologists, molecular biologists, and astronomers participate in the dialogues. Closer To Truth is feel and flavor more than fact and logic, experience and emotion more than reason and analysis. It’s not the Truth, not even Closest to Truth. It’s more process than conclusion; the discussions reflect educated opinion but no certainty, no smugness. There is a welcome measure of ambiguity, complexity, and even occasional confusion. Topics do not develop linearly; arguments do not flow smoothly. The books our contributors have written are linear and smooth, but these conversations are not. The dialogues in Closer To Truth complement our participant’s more canonical works, which I commend to you for further reading. In each chapter, we follow two to four experts from diverse fields or perspectives as they engage one another in the competitive marketplace of ideas. The transcripts are presented essentially raw, except for verbal clean-ups, to preserve the head-to-head spontaneity and the tang of the original discourse. It is fascinating how the group dynamics move these leading thinkers to express themselves in ways dissimilar from their carefully polished writings, revealing strong passions and subtle nuances not commonly heard. What emerges is personality; it’s fun to meet the people who are challenging truth, changing truth, making truth—to watch them navigating with less control than they normally have when they speak in symposia or craft their elegant books. My role as host of the Closer To Truth television programs was broadbrush—picking the topics, selecting the guests, moving the talk along. My introductions and conclusions to each of the chapters in the Closer To Truth book are more personal mini-essays than analytical outlines; they position or summarize the topic and reflect my particular, perhaps peculiar, orientation. I have fun, and so do the participants, taking the topics seriously but (we hope) not ourselves. Closer To Truth is work in progress, with no artificial deadline. Forget canned surety or cosmetic harmony. Though the book proceeds linearly, the reader need not. Enter and exit at any point. Select by personal interest, not numerical order. Each chapter stands more or less on its own, presenting the take of its diverse contributors. Comments do not fit together neatly as if pieces in a puzzle. Closer To Truth may mean pieces too few or pieces too
Introduction: What is Closer To Truth?
xix
many; chapters are not manicured or neat, but reflect the real-time thinking of real-world thinkers. Look for greater dimension and deeper grain; see subjects from various viewpoints; watch for twists and curves. A primary characteristic of the modern world is science and technology. Knowledge-related changes have a profound effect on our daily lives and on how we perceive ourselves as individuals. Understanding state-of-theart science can help us to make more informed decisions about the choices the world presents to us. The biggest challenge facing scientists, scholars and artists today is to get the public to come to new knowledge with an open mind, to acknowledge that many of the advances brought about by scientific research have changed our lives beyond imagination and ultimately, if we are wise, for the better. We invite readers to visit our two websites—www.pbs.org/closertotruth and www.closertotruth.com—where we provide further resources for exploring these topics, including personal information from our guest experts. We also recommend www.scitechdaily.com, a daily resource for intelligent, informed science and technology coverage and analysis. I hope Closer To Truth encourages readers to become more informed and more passionate about the fundamental issues of human existence. Closer To Truth seeks to become the resource of record for the meaning and implications of scientific discovery and for critical thinking about who we are, why we are here, and where we are going. Closer To Truth will return.1 Robert Lawrence Kuhn Pasadena, California New York, New York October 27, 2006
Note 1. As we go to press, we have begun production of our new season of Closer To Truth, which will focus on cosmology and fundamental physics, the philosophy of cosmology, the philosophy of religion, and philosophical theology.
Chapter 1
Is Science Fiction Science?
Is science fiction scientific? How about diseases from distant galaxies; wormholes in space; fractures and travels in time; black holes with bad attitudes; weird life forms of every variety; telepaths creating superhumans; minds uploaded into silicon chips; souls downloaded from disposable slaves; ‘‘carbon copies’’ of yourself to expand your experiences in multiple lives; and baby universes created on desktops? Those are some of the ideas conjured up by our expert participants and their science fiction colleagues. But science fiction can be conceived as an artistic look at human history, society, and even human nature. In this chapter, three distinguished authors of popular science fiction spar over exactly how science fiction is constrained by known science and then question the value of science fiction. The authors describe the way in which science fiction can inspire scientific research and at the same time serve as a warning against our potential misuse of the awesome power of science (citing the novels Soylent Green and On the Beach). They also good-naturedly point out its limitations—e.g., no science fiction author predicted the personal computer—and wonder why its appeal is not as strong in some countries as in others. Scenario forecasting has been a military tool for thousands of years but only in science fiction is the limit the writer’s imagination. Can science fiction predict the future? Or prevent it? Writer/physicist David Brin argues that George Orwell prevented the 1984 scenario by making people aware of it. But best-selling author Michael Crichton questions why the omnipresence of cameras in society in anyone’s hands is ‘‘a good thing?’’ MacArthur Fellow Octavia Butler thinks we have more pressing things to worry about: ‘‘Global warming, for one.’’
2
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Although the history of science fiction writing has always reflected the science of the times, it is perhaps most telling that although the times and worlds change, the behavior of people—and aliens—across each fictional society has remained constant. This chapter is a virtual salon with celebrated inventors of alternative futures.
Expert Participants David Brin Author, Kiln People, The Postman, Earth; Ph.D. Space Science
Octavia Butler Author, Survivor, Parable of the Sower, Parable of the Talents (Nebula Award); MacArthur Fellow
Michael Crichton Author, Jurassic Park, The Lost World, Sphere, The Andromeda Strain; creator, ER Television series; medical doctor.
Robert Kuhn:
How is science fiction constrained by known science?
Michael Crichton: Robert Kuhn:
It’s fiction; it’s not constrained.
Should it be?
Michael Crichton: No, I don’t think so. Science fiction should make sense; it should be internally consistent; it should relate to contemporary reality in some fashion that’s recognizable—these are more important than whether or not every bit of the physics really works right. I’m very troubled if something really can’t possibly occur. I don’t mind if there’s theoretical running room, but if it’s very clear that something really can’t happen, can never happen, and is never going to happen, then that’s a problem for me. In general, I try and avoid that. Octavia Butler: fiction.
If there are no constraints, I think it’s fantasy, not science
Robert Kuhn: How would you differentiate science fiction from fantasy? It seems that science fiction describes how the world or the universe might look one day, for better or worse, and technology, real or fanciful, plays an important part. Fantasy, on the other hand, takes place in an alternative world, often in an era that has similarities to the Middle Ages where magic is often an important ingredient and technology is seldom very much developed.
Is Science Fiction Science?
3
Octavia Butler: I think the only requirement for fantasy is that it be internally consistent. As for science fiction, if you’re going to use science, you should make some effort to use it intelligently, not necessarily correctly, but intelligently. This means that if you want to do something odd, you are at least aware of it and justifying it. Robert Kuhn: Take mental telepathy, mind reading. Most scientists would say it doesn’t exist, can’t exist. How do you deal with that? Octavia Butler I had a series of books in which people were communicating telepathically. I didn’t care whether it was real or not, possible or not. What I was looking at was how that kind of communication, how a deeper form of communication, would affect people and their relationships. They get involved in war because they understand each other far too well. So, with me, I wasn’t using telepathy as science; I was simply using it as a tool to take a fresh look at the human condition. Robert Kuhn: Do you ever feel the compulsion to push science, to prod science or to predict science? David Brin: Sure, all of the above. Maybe I feel a little bit more liberated because I write hardcore science fiction, about physics and stuff like that some of the time, so I feel at liberty to press the envelope in any direction I choose. Even if my science is implausible, even if it’s impossible. But I feel a compact with the reader to make it clear which kind of science fiction I’m presenting. If we’re taking a vacation from reality in this short story, I try to make it obvious. If in one novel I’m going to try to play with scientific reality, what I write will fit within the plausible range of human science. Of all science fiction authors, only a small minority was trained scientifically, but almost all science fiction authors have enjoyed reading history while growing up. And so, perhaps an alternative name for science fiction should be ‘‘speculative history’’ (including future histories) because we deal with different pasts, alternative presents, and extensions of the human drama into the future. Octavia Butler: I have a problem with alternative histories. So many of them seem to figure out how to lead us to where we are now, in one way or another, instead of going anyplace else. Maybe different people are in charge, but the same basic things are happening I have an ambition to write an alternative history in which things truly do turn out as they haven’t. Robert Kuhn: Can science fiction, though, enable us to deal with alternative futures in a rational way? ‘‘Jurassic Park’’ in a sense is an alternative future, something that may happen. Is this a vehicle for dealing with alternative futures?
4
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Michael Crichton: There’s no question that the kinds of things that we’re doing, broadly speaking, are alternative scenarios and that the value of alternative scenarios is to explore futures in a way that’s safe and to say something about what they might mean. Robert Kuhn:
When you say ‘‘safe,’’ you mean in a fictional world.
David Brin: Einstein used the word gedanken experiment, thought experiment, a term he coined. He said that just sitting on a streetcar in Bern, leaving the clock tower and imagining he was riding on a beam of light, was 50% of the creative work that led to his Theory of Relativity. And we all do these kinds of thought experiments with these little nubs of brain above our eyes called the prefrontal lobes, which the Bible refers to as lamps on the brow, to look into the future, to do these kinds of thought experiments. We imagine, ‘‘What might happen if. . .?’’ But, our failures are obvious: no science fiction author predicted the home computer. Murray Leinster and John Brunner came close, but backed away at the last moment because each thought, ‘‘computers in the home, it seems logical, it’s heading that way, but people will laugh at me.’’ Octavia Butler: home?
Or, what possibly could we do with computers in the
Robert Kuhn: ‘‘Jurassic Park’’ is great entertainment, but is it more? You’re probably the wrong person to ask, but I’ll ask anyway. Michael Crichton: I’ll give you an anecdote. The book came out, and I was at a resort in Hawai with a lot of physicians from my old alma mater. One of these guys, who was also a bioengineer, read it, slapped it down and said, ‘‘It can be done!’’ And I thought, this is exactly the opposite of what I’m trying to accomplish here. Robert Kuhn:
What was your motivation for writing the book?
Michael Crichton: At that time, I was concerned about two things, which remain concerns: the first is that, in my lifetime, one of the biggest changes that has occurred in science is that it has become commercialized. When I was a student, the majority of scientists worked in academic settings or they worked in places where research was freely available unless you were in a classified, military situation. Now, more and more that’s not the case, more and more science is private, more and more of it is secret for financial reasons, and more and more of it is rushed. The problem with biotechnology in particular is, unlike nuclear technology, you don’t need a tremendous amount of money, you don’t need an Oak Ridge Processing Plant, you can get a little kit and start doing it yourself. Robert Kuhn:
So ‘‘Jurassic Park’’ is a warning?
Is Science Fiction Science?
Michael Crichton:
5
Yes. A warning about incautious research.
Octavia Butler: Do you think you seduced a lot of young people into thinking about paleontology? Michael Crichton: I think it’s great if kids become interested in science as a result. Robert Kuhn: So science fiction writers are stimulating more scientists who can work for more of those secret companies to do more of these dangerous biotechnology things. David Brin: If you take my sunny attitude, my sunny interpretation is that the more educated and enthusiastic a public we have, then the harder it is going to be for a small conspiracy to keep things secret. Octavia Butler: I don’t think that a conspiracy is the real problem. There is a serious problem with people knowing, for instance, what is science? Creationism in the science classroom, that kind of thing. Michael Crichton: Most people don’t have any idea about what constitutes scientific information. 15 years ago, many people I know (particularly from San Francisco) were having experts walk around their house with these little meters to check the electromagnetic fields because of the health hazard [of radon]. Today, those people are now buying, at great expense, magnet devices that they stick in their back and on their arms because they now think that these provide a health benefit. So, in 15 years we’ve gone from a health hazard to a health benefit. Robert Kuhn: Jurassic Park probably taught more people about DNA than most colleges. Is that a way science fiction can influence society? Michael Crichton: There has been much criticism that Jurassic Park is anti-science. The reason is that it took a critical posture to a new technology. At one point, a congressman was going to introduce legislation to ban dinosaur-creating research. I wish it had come to the floor, but someone apparently whispered in his ear that this was not likely to happen. Octavia Butler: People tend to believe the movies because they see it. I remember having an argument with somebody who was insisting that a tornado was the greatest storm the world could ever know, and there was nothing I could say that would convince her otherwise. David Brin: Let’s beware of our anecdotes, because if there’s anything that we need to watch out for as writers, it is cliche´s—and the biggest cliche´ in our civilization is that everybody else is stupid. I don’t know anybody who calls himself a member of the masses.
6
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Octavia Butler: Not that everybody else is stupid, but that it’s terribly easy to fool people. We’ve all been fooled. Daivd Brin: As authors, there are some very serious issues we have to think about. Our job is to keep a character, or several characters (with whom the reader or the viewer identifies closely) in peril or in jeopardy for 90 minutes of film or 400 pages of a book. The easiest way to do that is to simply posit that they’re not members of a civilization filled with skilled professionals who will help them if they’re in trouble. Or to have a really plausible excuse for why your heroes must remain in jeopardy. This is one of the things I liked in Jurassic Park in that the characters were very isolated, they had taken precautions, but somebody had deliberately destroyed the precautions. So you have the ridiculous situation of people running away from dinosaurs who should be properly penned up, really having been fairly well explicated how you can have 90 heart-thumping minutes, even though help should be on the way; well, it is on the way, but it’s going to arrive too late. Robert Kuhn: Do you desire to use future fiction to deal with the lack of scientific knowledge in society? Michael Crichton: I don’t know in what way we can help people to understand, when they see a number, how that number is arrived at, unless you’ve been doing some experiments yourself. David Brin: My wife is a science teacher and she finds it appalling that so much of the testing going on focuses on memorization. The latest big fad is attempting to emulate what foreign kids do to enable them to test well on standardized exams. So we are stressing memorization, when the font of our success, the reason why 90 out of the 100 best universities on the planet are in the United States, is not our memorization of past facts but our creativity and innovation to pioneer new thinking. But that’s not what our kids are now being taught. This emphasis on memorizing facts from lists, from worksheets, undermines the entire basis of science. Where my wife enjoys her best teaching is in conducting experiments and getting her students to draw conclusions and then criticize each other’s conclusions and come up with new experiments to settle the matter between them. Robert Kuhn: Are there issues in the world that you would like to see handled in a science fiction kind of model? David Brin: I think the most powerful science fiction stories are not those that accurately predict the future, but, rather, those that have prevented futures, the self-preventing prophecy that came across so chilling, and so many people read it and were so moved, that the very scenario that might have plausibly happened didn’t happen. The best two examples that really prevented the terrible futures they described are 1984 by George Orwell and Das Kapital by Karl Marx, who was probably the greatest science
Is Science Fiction Science?
7
fiction author who ever lived. Both books utterly and thankfully prevented the scenario that they described. Michael Crichton: I actually think that 1984 came to pass. Orwell was writing about a totalitarian state, but even though that part isn’t the case, the notion that you might live in a society that rather rigorously limits your available behavior, and that watches you to make sure that you do what is desired, is the case. I think we are increasingly seeing behavioral control, but it’s not Big Brother doing it to us, we’re doing it to ourselves. David Brin: But that’s a major distinction. We are not falling into Orwell’s failure mode of allowing the cameras to just look one way in a pyramidal social structure, which is what he feared, the ancient elites lording it over those languishing below. My point is that we’ve gotten our freedom from elites. Instead, most of the cameras are now in the hands of private people. Governments can install cameras but private people will have many more of them. Michael Crichton:
Why is that a good thing?
David Brin: What we’re talking about is evading Orwell’s failure mode of the elites staring at us and us not staring back. Michael Crichton: The notion that every single thing we do is recorded, that every purchase, even every mouse click, can be tracked in every way, that there is no part of our lives where we can truly be alone and where we can say that what we are doing is not available for observation—except maybe going to the bathroom and that’s soon to change (how about intelligent toilets that test your excreted fluids and solids). I think the notion that we’re all on camera now is going to cause a subtle shift in our natural behaviors. If we were having a conversation before the camera started, we experience some subtle but genuine difference now that the cameras are rolling. I’m on the air, I’m being broadcast, and I’m not being my normal self. I’m concerned that there isn’t going to be any part of my life where I can be my normal self. Robert Kuhn: Isn’t science fiction a vehicle for sharpening our perspective of contemporary problems, the technique being to move those problems to a radically different environment so that by stripping away the trappings of normal society, those problems become dissected out and exposed in all their purity? David Brin: One hopes that this is so, but the problem is this: Orwell warned us about the State looking at us without us looking back at the State, so we’re working on a society that might prevent such a situation. Where is science fiction’s warning about the kind of society Michael was just describing, a society in which everybody has the cameras—all right, so now we’re
8
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
free from spying elites, but we all spy on one another incessantly and nobody has any privacy. Michael Crichton: Let me tell you a story. A friend of mine’s husband works in the State Department and since he was about to retire they wanted to have a farewell party for this person. So this friend of mine, she cooks the dinner herself, she has her son serve it, and she has her son’s school friend also serve it, because she knows that if she brings in an outside person, a catering person, that no one at the table will talk. And I said to her, ‘‘This is a travesty: how is this different from living in the old Soviet Union?’’ David Brin: In all of history, no government ever knew as much about its people, as does ours. And in all of history, I contend, no people have ever been quite as free as ours. And both are still true after 9/11. Michael Crichton:
I’m not sure of this at all.
David Brin: We can argue about this, but you find me the historical counter-examples. Michael Crichton: Just to start, I can give you an easy one. When Bork was nominated for the Supreme Court and it appeared that it was going to be difficult to knock him down on intellectual content alone, one of the mechanisms that was suggested was that they might introduce his videotape rentals. David Brin:
And there’s a law that resulted from that.
Michael Crichton:
But, the fact is it’s recorded!
Octavia Butler: I have a feeling that some of the things that we’re doing environmentally, for instance, are going to hurt us a lot worse than the fact that we’ve got cameras trained on each other. Robert Kuhn:
Have you dealt with that in your fiction?
Octavia Butler: Yes, particularly global warming. In my books Parable of the Sower and Parable of the Talents global warming is a character. It’s there doing things while people are trying to live their lives. And it’s not a very popular notion. Global warming is something that people can still forget about, ignore, and, no matter how many novels come out, it’s just not that important to most people right now. Robert Kuhn: David, in your latest book, Kiln People, do you look beyond pure entertainment? Do you see an alternative future? Do you seek to push science? David Brin: Kiln People is one of my less plausible ideas. Most science fiction has fallen into the cliche´ of extending human life by extending it serially, tacking on more years at the end. In contrast, Kiln People is founded
Is Science Fiction Science?
9
on the notion that instead of extending human life serially, how about doing it in parallel, having more life, multiple lives, at the same time—when you are young, when you could really use it. Every morning you lie down on a fanciful ‘‘home copier,’’ which then turns out five or six clay copies of yourself (Golems) with your memory, your motivation, your personality, so that you can be in multiple places at once. You then collect the memories at the end of the day and integrate them together in your psyche. The next day, another five places at once—you can work out the enormous permutations. It’s a real science fiction novel in the sense that it works out what such a society might be like. Octavia Butler: enough?
Do you really think that five or six parallel lives would be
David Brin: People will never have enough, but I believe that human sanity is based, to some degree, on satiability: if you get what you want, assuming that you’re fairly sane, it should at least make you a little bit happier. And it should shift your ambitions from what they were to something else. Octavia Butler: I think one of the worst things that could happen to you is you get what you want. Then you’re finished, you might as well cut your throat now, your life is done. David Brin: Humans are monkeys; that’s not going to happen. People complain that 30% of Americans watch 40, 50 hours a week of television; 100 years ago, that same 30% of Americans watched the fire burning in their fireplace for 40 hours a week. Michael Crichton:
They had better programming back then.
Octavia Butler: When I was a kid, I got to live a nineteenth century existence for a little while. My grandmother had a chicken ranch and there was no electricity, we used a well for water. We told stories. I think they enjoyed scaring the heck out of me. Some of them were true, some of them weren’t. Robert Kuhn: Octavia Butler:
It enriched your life. It did. For one thing, I developed a real love for stories.
Robert Kuhn: Why has science fiction become more mainstream now? What’s happened? Michael Crichton: I think that technology is phenomenally important in our lives. And it’s developing at a much more rapid rate. I was born in 1942, so I spent 10 years without television, in the way that Octavia is talking about, and then the arrival of television made an enormously different world. And, a few years after that, the arrival of jet aircraft made an enormously different world. And, by the time you get to personal computers
10
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
and the internet, life has become very, very different. Talking about an early book I wrote, The Andromeda Strain, today’s kids say to me, ‘‘Well, why did you write it that way?’’ meaning that old way with all those old things. They can’t conceive of the world just 35 years ago, it’s such a totally different world today. Robert Kuhn: Some people say that The Andromeda Strain helped prepare us for bio-terrorism, how we would react to an anthrax attack. Michael Crichton: Robert Kuhn: character?
I always thought it was a remake of War of the Worlds.
Does science fiction in other cultures have a different
David Brin: Japanese science fiction, Brazilian science fiction are very different than American science fiction. There was very different, and very interesting, science fiction literature that arose out of the old Soviet Union, written by enthusiastic socialists. But if you travel around the world as a science fiction author, you know the difference between those countries in which science fiction is popular and those in which it isn’t. In Japan, people pick me up at the airport; in India they don’t. Octavia Butler: I remember a conference in New York for ‘‘African Women of the Diaspora,’’ called The Yari Yari Conference, actually, The Future of the Future. There were a lot of people from third world countries where it wasn’t as much a matter of press freedom so much as finding the necessities for publishing, such as a printing press, paying for paper, figuring out how to distribute your book, and often all by yourself. David Brin: But there is another essential point why science fiction is an American literature to some degree, and that is because most of the propaganda coming out of the American experience promote suspicion of authority and, to some degree, tolerance. As Octavia was saying, there are a lot of cultures in which authority is a much more revered thing, or much more of a problematical thing in day-to-day life. Octavia Butler: being met.
Or cultures where there are a lot more needs that aren’t
Robert Kuhn: If we had somebody here from China or India or Africa, how do you think they would react to our discussion about science fiction? Octavia Butler: I think they probably would want us to focus on topics that were more important to them. Take the writer Arundhati Roy who has been arrested in India because she went beyond her writing fiction and criticized something that her government was doing which was very worthy of criticism. People in third world countries would want us to pay more attention to what’s really going on in their countries and what shouldn’t be.
Is Science Fiction Science?
11
Robert Kuhn: Theoretically though, all of your fiction is non-culturally based, if you’re in a different era, a different galaxy, a different dimension . . . Octavia Butler:
But, really, it’s all culturally based, of course.
Robert Kuhn: Though the environment may be different superficially, the characters think and act as if they are in the current culture of the author. Because most science fiction is generated in the United States, does the genre reflect a cultural bias? Michael Crichton: Or building into our stories a bias that has to do with the level and nature of technological sophistication—which is not worldwide—but it’s a technology bias as opposed to a social one. Octavia Butler: I don’t think you can have this level of technology without it affecting the social, and therefore the bias is social as well. Robert Kuhn: What are some of the issues you’d like to see discussed in the science fiction in the future? Octavia Butler: We don’t have a focus now that was like, for instance, the Cold War or the space race; we don’t have anything that grabs everybody. And since we don’t have such an overriding cause, what we write probably seems more scattered than we intend it to be. The future of science fiction is not what we thought it would be years ago. David Brin: This is especially true since the best science fiction is about the human response to change. And since change is a salient feature of our civilization, I think that science fiction has, logically speaking, philosophically speaking, an important role to play. The issue is whether or not it’s playing that role well. Michael Crichton: To do these kinds of scenarios in our science fiction is valuable, but it is not the same as holding a newborn child, it is not the same as holding a parent while they die in your arms. How you explain that feeling is orders of magnitude more important than what we do.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: It doesn’t matter whether science fiction is really scientific; here are three reasons why it can be important. First, science fiction can break free from the scientific method: if your imagination doesn’t have to worry about verification, just maybe you’ll discover something truly original. Second, science fiction can explore contemporary issues in different environments, so that when all normal trappings of society are stripped away, just maybe real problems will be exposed.
12
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Third, science fiction can examine a vast number of alternative futures, which just maybe can prepare humanity for all eventualities, like, say, marauding asteroids or malevolent aliens. Only theology claims greater reach, and I’ll let you decide how science fiction, religion, and science can each explain the world, predict the future, and bring us Closer To Truth.
Interviews with Expert Participants Michael Crichton Why did you become a science fiction writer? Because when I was a kid I loved the Arthur Conan Doyle stories of Sherlock Holmes. And one of the things that really impressed me about them was the sense of how real they were, how true to life they were. People go to London and look for Holmes’s famous address, 221B Baker Street. I always aspired to have that quality of realism in my writings, trying to make people think it was true. What’s changed in your field since you were a kid? Storytelling has enormously changed in my lifetime as a result of two new kinds of storytelling which have emerged. The first is commercials and the second is cartoons. And they have produced an enormous change: in commercials in terms of pace and rapid change; and in cartoons in terms of the kind of exaggeration in storytelling that people have come to expect. Does the general public appreciate science? In the last survey that I saw people were asked what scientific instrument or what technological device they appreciated most in their house, and the overwhelming majority named the microwave. Any advice for young people? It’s my strong belief that people who are engaged in any kind of technology should not fall too much in love with it. Do not lose your human characteristics. How would you like to be remembered? I would like to be remembered by the people that knew me as a good person who made a difference in their lives.
Is Science Fiction Science?
13
Has your audience surprised you? When I wrote the first novel that was successful, The Andromeda Strain, I was really writing about technology that was already at that time 20 years old. And it was, ‘‘Oh wow, this is so hip and slick and up to date.’’ And I thought, ‘‘Really? Okay. Well, I’ll write something that really is up to date.’’ And the next book was ‘‘The Terminal Man,’’ which was about psychosurgery and atomic pacemakers and stuff like that. And it was based on real patients; it was all happening. And people said, ’’This is ridiculous! Who could possibly believe this?’’ It’s very hard to persuade your audience about what’s happening right now. They’re living in the past, so you have to write a little bit that way. What do you think the biggest threat to life is today? The greatest hazard now comes from biotechnology. Even in the worst years of the Cold War and the nuclear standoff, a nuclear war never conceived of totally wiping out the species. I think it is absolutely conceivable that somebody could do something in biotechnology that could wipe us out. Is technology irreversible? I’m actually not persuaded that technology cannot be turned back. In most of my lifetime, what powered adolescence was the desire for the freedom as exemplified by the mobility of the automobile. That was a peculiarly American dream, an early 20th Century dream; and now we have the entire world sitting in traffic jams. Today, the most forward thinking people are dreaming of a world without cars. And I think we’ll eventually have that. I think we’re going to eventually have to begin to crank this one technology, autos, backwards. Talk about the technology in fiction. To me, all fiction of the past seems simplistic, except for James Joyce. Certainly anything that’s technical, you look at it and just think, ‘‘Oh well, that’s just like child’s play.’’ I’m sure that 100 years from now people will look at the problems that we find overwhelming and say, ‘‘What was the big deal? That was nothing.’’ This progressive attitude is characteristic of technology. You write books about serious science; do you think entertainment can educate? Tom Wolfe once said, ‘‘Movies are great, but cannot explain anything.’’ And what people need now in terms of science and technology is that they need explanations. They need to understand what are the risks of this
14
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
technology? What are the benefits of that technology? What are the issues involved? What are the tradeoffs? Because there are always tradeoffs. Most people don’t understand the notion of tradeoffs; nor do they understand the notion of risk. You can say to them, ’’Do you want arsenic in the drink you ordered?’’ And they go, ‘‘No, not me.’’ But if you say, ‘‘Would you be willing to spend this amount of money on cleaning up the water, but this would mean that you couldn’t buy a new car,’’ they go, ‘‘Oh, wait a minute.’’ Most people can’t weigh tradeoffs, especially regarding societal issues.
David Brin Why did you become a scientist? I wanted to become a scientist because it seemed like this was an honest way to see the world. Every civilization has had artists—art flows from our pores. All the fine scientists I know have artistic hobbies. Most of my neighbors have artistic hobbies. The idea that art is rare is a myth foisted on us by artists. All civilizations have had art, and I was born to be an artist, I was scribbling from an early age. But science—only one civilization has ever had science—training millions of people to actually be honest in how they saw things, and to doubt themselves and to try to find out what’s true whether they like it or not. I wanted to be part of that and I struggled. I wasn’t very good at it. I got my union card—my Ph.D. You know what? Science is hard. ‘‘Lying’’ is easy. This civilization is willing to pay me a lot more to fib about people who can’t sue me because they are all fictitious, and who am I to argue with civilization? Ever had any close encounters? If you go to the Encounters Restaurant at the center of Los Angeles airport (LAX), you enter this little brushed aluminum elevator and all of sudden as soon as the door closes Star Trekkie music comes on, ‘‘Ooh-e-o-ooh.’’ You have all the waitresses wearing Star Trek miniskirts and there are lava lamps everywhere. Will technology outpace civil control? It seems likely that the biologists and the biochemists will do to their big, huge, building-size laboratories what the cyberneticists did to the computer. And not only make them smaller, but cheaper. In biotechnology, this miniaturization is happening at a curve that’s even faster than Moore’s Law. Within 10 to 15 years you will see the MolecuMac in which any teenager in America will be able to fabricate—on his desktop—any known or unknown organic compound. There are all sorts of possibilities. Science fiction is supposed to look ahead a little ways and see these possibilities: I see
Is Science Fiction Science?
15
the MolecuMac. Under circumstances like those, if we remain so stupid, civilization cannot hold together. Do you think the impoverished are doomed to exploitation? I like to use a ‘‘social diamond’’ as an economic metaphor of society and in which the well-off, empowered, and comfortable middle class far outnumber the poor. This contrasts with the typical ‘‘social pyramid’’ on which those at the top are extremely few. The social diamond shows how huge and obvious genuine progress has been, at least in the West, under our Modernist Agenda. No image demonstrates more clearly how this society is different from all predecessors, how much we ALL have benefited from science and accountability. . .and how much we have to lose if we return to the traditional human social pyramid. The chief argument among Republicans and Democrats is how to keep the diamond rising faster so that the poor live better lives than kings did in the past. In this respect, the absolute fundamental moral minimum is that no child born into poverty should automatically remain in poverty—Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians all agree that this would be a bad thing. Some may respond that the social diamond rests on the back of a social pyramid and that Americans stand at the top of the pyramid and exploit those beneath us. I agree, but not in the sense that the American economy and globalization makes poor people of the Third World poorer. That’s easily disproved. The more a foreign economy is enmeshed with the American economy, the richer the people are in that foreign economy. It’s those countries whose economies are least attached to the American economy that are the poorest, so that argument is easily disposed. So what is this pyramid on which we are on top and those beneath us we exploit? They are called machines. And here the science fiction writer comes in because in a few years will the machines be the latest slave population demanding their share of the diamond? It could happen. Is mankind exploiting the earth? Another perspective is that the pyramid is the earth and we’re extracting resources from it—we’re taking away the resources that our children will need. A science fiction author feels this very deeply because, of course, it’s going to take a great deal of surplus for us to be rich enough to colonize space, to plant colonies on Mars, to venture out to the stars. Only very rich, human, earth-wide civilizations will have the surplus that it takes to go and do these bold things. We are in a window of time during which we have enough surplus that we can spend some of it on trying to help raise up the poor while at the same time investing in making our children better than us, while at the same time putting enough aside for research so that the whole pie gets bigger. The resource-intensive approach to getting wealthier
16
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
cannot be sustained, but in the long run, it’s going to be human creativity that’s going to be the ultimate resource. Talk about anti-globalization—is it a democratic movement? Karl Marx was the greatest of all science fiction authors because in the East, where he was taken seriously and followed as if he were a prophet, his effects were actually fairly ineffective at changing humanity in positive directions. It was in the West, where his work was read as a plausible scenario for a failure mode, that something happened that he never imagined could happen because he felt contempt for the masses. He never imagined that the masses would read his work and then say, ‘‘Ah, interesting, let’s reform this scenario right away.’’ And he never imagined that elites like Franklin Delano Roosevelt would say the same thing. That’s the point. The young antiglobalization men and women are assuming that international law will be controlled by these elites, but their own countries are counterexamples. They should be out there in the streets demanding a place at the table, demanding institutions, doing what the Jeffersonians did when Madison and Monroe were writing ‘‘The Federalist Papers,’’ acting as the counterbalance, demanding that the people have a say. This is a good role they could be playing. But they are not doing it. What’s going to be our failure mode, if we have one? Failure modes are a fascinating topic. Of course, they attract a lot of science fiction because if you can expose a failure mode very vividly as in On the Beach, Fail-Safe, Dr. Strangelove, Soylent Green, 1984, and Das Kapital, then you can create the greatest of all science fiction stories, the selfpreventing prophecy, the prophecy that does not come true because people actually paid attention to you because people were smarter than you had expected. So we’re all looking for that next danger. Let me put this in perspective. Barring UFO fantasies, the obvious fact is that the Earth has never been visited by aliens for two billion years because if they had flushed their toilets in our primitive ecosystem, it would have changed the history of life on Earth. This virtually proves that there is a lot of empty loneliness out there in the universe. Now I believe that there are aliens—that alien life is out there—I worked on that both as an astronomer and as a science fiction author, but alien life seems to be extremely sparse. Why? One possibility is that some set of failure modes is always encountered by intelligent life forms before they reach the stars. Carl Sagan came up with this when he discussed nuclear winter, that this might be how civilizations destroy themselves. If that’s true, we’ve proved that it’s at least possible to get past the nuclear crises. We’ve proved that self destruction is not automatic, but what about resource depletion and environmental degradation? What about
Is Science Fiction Science?
17
bioengineering of diseases? I don’t know. It could be that human beings are anomalously smart. If that’s true, it’s a scary universe. How do you think we can insure survival of the species? I don’t think we’re even going to have colonies on Mars, let alone in the asteroids, let alone on other planets and other solar systems unless we do something that is very rarely portrayed in science fiction—actually grow up a bit. Gene Roddenberry is one of the only creators of science fiction who ever posited the possibility that our grandchildren might be better than us. And when you think about it, what’s the point in having kids if they won’t be? If we raise a generation of boys who are three times as responsible and girls who are three times as confident, all the rest is petty details and the next generation will be smarter than we are. We don’t have to preach to them what ideology they should have. They’ll be smarter than us. That’s our hope. Has science fiction served us well? Why have so few science fiction writes portray futures in which people are better than they are today? Gene Roddenberry, Ray Bradbury, and me are the few. Why? Because of the need to use ‘‘idiot plots.’’ Because your main job in a novel or in a movie is to keep your hero or heroine in jeopardy for 90 minutes of the film or 400 pages of a novel. And it’s hard to do, hard to keep your heroes in heart-pounding jeopardy, hard to keep the reader turning pages or the viewer glued to the screen if what is told is a story of a better society. So I think the ‘‘idiot plot’’ requirement has had a deleterious effect on us, because we tend to absorb through our books and through our movies the assumption that we live in this horrible civilization filled with idiots. Yes, it’s comforting to think, ‘‘I got my opinions because of rational analysis of the evidence, but everyone else got their opinions because of flaws in their character.’’ One hundred percent of us do that. But it’s time to wake up and smell the roses. Sorry folks, you actually live in a pretty decent civilization that’s getting better every day.
Octavia Butler Why did you become a writer? I came to be a writer by accident. I discovered I liked it; I was writing when I was 10 years old. I was writing to get away from my boring life, so fantasy was a natural. And a couple of years later, I saw a bad movie called Devil Girl from Mars, and watching it on television, I sat there and said, ‘‘Jeez, I could write a better story than that. Anybody can write a better story than that.’’ And finally it hit me that someone had been paid for writing that bad story, so I grabbed my notebook and began to write. I didn’t see the
18
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
end of that movie until many years later, when a Texas fan actually gave me a copy of it and I watched it, and I kind of admired my good taste as a 12 year-old. Whom do you admire most, and why? I began trying to sell stories when I was 13. If I found somebody I liked, I would read everything I could find that they had written. And that’s how I discovered John Bruner and Marion Zimmer Bradley and Harlan Ellison and J.T. McIntosh and a number of other old-time writers, people who were writing a lot when I was a kid. Because it was nice to find somebody dependable. I could just go back and find everything that they had written that was at the library or the Salvation Army bookstore. What advice do you have for young people A bit of the Hippocratic Oath: ‘‘Do no harm,’’ but also a bit of my own philosophy, ‘‘Do the thing that you love and do it as well as you possibly can and be persistent about doing it.’’ It’s really important to find a way to earn a living doing what you care about and trying to do as much good as you can in the world. Did you major in science in school? I don’t have a science background, but I do know where the library is, and that’s pretty much what I’ve leaned on throughout my career. Do you stress science research? For the most part, I don’t write hard science fiction. My Xenogenesis Trilogy is as close as I’ve gotten to hard science fiction and it’s biological science fiction. So far, I haven’t been writing about the scientist busily doing science. I’m more likely to be writing about the people who are affected by the science. I always wondered when I watched movies or television what was going on with the ordinary people because so often you would see the leaders and the scientists and the generals, and I was much more interested in how all this was affecting Joe Blow and Jane Doe. Why science fiction and not just fiction? I began writing because life was incredibly boring, and I began with fantasy. And when I went to science fiction it was mainly because of Devil Girl. It was supposedly science fiction, and if I was going to compete with it, which I was at first, then I should write science fiction. And I went off and got a little book on astronomy and read it. I was very disappointed in Mars, but I wrote anyway and tried to just see what I could do. It was fun. I got to learn
Is Science Fiction Science?
19
things that I had not known before. I really enjoy having an excuse to stick my nose into all sorts of things. I think most writers are just ‘‘natural liars,’’ but that’s not really the word I want. We eavesdrop. We do all sorts of things that get us into everyone else’s business, and we’re also into a little bit of everything. If you’re talking to a writer about almost anything, you can at least have a brief conversation that isn’t stupid. Were you surprised when the MacArthur Foundation called and you had been selected as a Fellow? When a total stranger with a very nice voice called me and said, ‘‘You’ve been chosen for the MacArthur Fellowship,’’ my immediate reaction was, ‘‘What is this? When is she going to ask me for my credit card number so I can hang up?’’ I couldn’t believe it. And I didn’t really know very much about it. I’ve heard of it vaguely. And it took me a while to begin to believe it. They asked me not to tell anyone for a while, and I thought, ‘‘That will be my choice.’’ I want to see what’s going to happen here before I run out and tell people and then later look really bad. How do you think you will be remembered? People will say that I’m a black science fiction writer, or I’m a feminist scientist fiction writer, something like that. People have to affix these labels because it’s shorthand and because it’s an excuse for failing to think. You don’t have to read my stuff if you already know what I am. How would you like to be remembered? I would like to be read and remembered for what I’ve written, and really that’s kind of up to the person who reads me. Now, if they read my books and don’t like them – and I’ve had some people tell me so – well, there’s nothing I can do about that. On the other hand, if they read my books and get something from them, well, that’s very good.
Chapter 2
Why is Music So Significant?
Music is a fundamental defining factor of the human mind; from brain development to cultural progression, music pervades the human psyche. Virtually every known human culture has some form of musical expression, and the neurobiology of music—how the brain appreciates and processes music—is an exploration of what it means to be human. Although there are specific parts of the brain dedicated to the sense of sound, vast areas of the brain (particularly the cerebral cortex) must work together to process the complex process we call music, including areas of working memory, forethought, movement, and emotion. Music has a special relationship to various kinds of brain patterns—melody, harmony, rhythm, timbre, pitch, and style of sound each have their unique representations. Music’s nonverbal character expresses a different way of thinking than do other kinds of human cognition and thus may have broader impact on the body, such as lowering blood pressure and easing pain. Like theories of a universal grammar hardwired into our brains to enable language, there may be a universal set of rules that governs how patterns of sounds can become music and how a limited number of sounds can be combined in an infinite number of ways. Two streams of research come together, one anatomical, one psychological. First, the plasticity of the brain, active during infancy and early childhood and perhaps into adulthood and old age, may be activated by music in diverse ways, thus stimulating richer, healthier, better functioning brains. Recent data goes further, contradicting long-standing maxims that no new brain cells—called neurons—can form in the adult brain, growth that may be enhanced by music. Second, there is anecdotal evidence that children and even adults who are exposed to music, especially complex forms, do
22
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
better in other areas of development. This seems true in infants and young children and may also be true in adults and even the elderly. Can music aid mental development? Running on treadmills increases brain size and function in young rats. Can listening to music do the same in young humans? Three musicians—a neuroscientist, a dean of a fine arts college program, and an education innovator—discuss music’s universal appeal and its importance to the development of human society. One panelist asserts that music could have easily predated human language, and all concur that music’s inherent symmetry and organizational principles tap into a deep human need to order, or manage, our environment. They investigate how music may affect brain development, whether or not listening to classical music can make us smarter, and music’s possible role in the development of cooperative action.
Expert Participants Jeanne Bamberger Professor of Music and Urban Education, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; pianist.
Robert Freeman Dean, College of Fine Arts, University of Texas at Austin; past director, Eastman School of Music; past president, New England Conservatory of Music
Mark Jude Tramo Director, The Institute for Music and Brain Science, Massachusetts General Hospital; neurologist and neuroscientist, Harvard Medical School; musician, songwriter
Robert Freeman: I grew up with music all over my house and I had a music teacher who shared with everyone the huge excitement that I have always gotten out of music. What I don’t know is whether music is part of my genetic background or part of the fact that it was the first language I really learned. I also still don’t know how best to teach music to other human beings. Mark Tramo: I would argue that music in the form of song predated our ability to speak. We were communicating emotions and ideas with grunts and groans and chants and hums well before we were enunciating complex ideas like the ones we are sharing right now.
Why is Music So Significant?
23
Jeanne Bamberger: Out of the grunts and groans has grown the complexity of the music that has been created since those early human days, because music embodies a lot of the organizing principles that we find in almost every other domain, such as symmetry and periodicity. Mark Tramo: And that symmetry relates to our natural affinity for music, the degree to which children, for example, naturally gravitate to music. It seems that as humans we have a compulsion to order, organize, control the environment around us. And music relates to our acoustic environment; we’re surrounded routinely by a cacophony of sounds coming from all around us, and we take all of those sounds and organize them with respect to their frequencies, with respect to when those combinations of frequencies are occurring in time, and with this beautiful regularity, beautiful structure —and that’s how we experience sound. Jeanne Bamberger: On the basis of my research, it turns out that what everybody knows how to do by the time they are five or six years old in this culture, they know how to hear beginnings and endings and they know how to hear what is usually called functions; for example, they can hear when musical passages do not have proper resolutions in their endings. Furthermore, I’ve seen a little girl, three years old, sitting on the floor, listening to a performance of The Magic Flute. When she got bored, she stood up and began walking: she walked one direction and at the ends of the phrases she turned around and walked in the other direction, and she kept that up for the whole tune. So what people can hear are beginnings and endings, and they can hear finished and unfinished, stability and instability, so one of the problems is that when we traditionally begin music education, we start with notes. We teach kids how to read music, which captures features that are very different from what we’re paying attention to when we listen. Robert Freeman: Of course, I don’t know what you hear when you hear music and you don’t know what I hear. Jeanne Bamberger: No, I don’t; that’s right. But I tried to find that out by asking kids to invent ways of putting down on paper something they had clapped, for example. And what they capture is different in very specific ways from what’s captured in the standard music notation. But it’s also very much inherent in what we do when people see our gestures, or movement from and to, but they don’t measure either time or pitch, which is exactly what music notation captures. Kids use squiggles on paper, say that show a whole little figure. Robert Kuhn:
What are some examples?
Jeanne Bamberger: Take mechanical gears. We have kids playing with great big cardboard gears of different sizes that they had made of different numbers of teeth, and the question was, when you turned them around,
24
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
which one went faster? Well, one little girl said, ‘‘It depends on what kind of ‘fastness’ you mean. Because if you’re talking about the number of times around, then the little one is going faster. But if you’re talking about those things (i.e., gears) that connect to each other, then they’re going the same.’’ She was nine, and she was failing in school because the way she thought about things was so much more complex, so much more integrated, and using so many different sensory modalities and modes of representation that nobody, not the other kids and not the teacher, could understand her. Robert Kuhn:
How did she relate to the gears?
Jeanne Bamberger: There were eight teeth on the little gear and it went around four times when the big one went around once, and the question was, how many teeth does the big one have? And the other kids said, ‘‘You better count them.’’ And she said, ‘‘You don’t need to count them, it’s 32!’’ Because eight times four is 32. Then I said, ‘‘Can you clap this relationship?’’ And we hit the table with one hand four times for every time we hit the table with the other hand one time. Then we went to the computer and I said, ‘‘Can you get the computer synthesizer to play that rhythm using numbers?’’ And at that point they had to get into ratio and proportion, because the slower gear had to have a number of teeth that was four times bigger than the faster one, so they could use something like 12 and three, this could be a 12-er, as they called it, and this could be a three-er. So at that moment they had gone across all these different sensory modalities, modes of representation, including their own body action and different kinds of materials. I think there are many things that meet in different domains and function actively in music. Robert Freeman: Though we don’t normally teach music as though that were the case—and we should. Robert Kuhn: When all this is happening there are vast areas of the brain that are involved, it’s not just the auditory part. Mark Tramo: The concept that there is a single, solitary music center in the brain is surely not correct. The auditory system is what allows us to decode the music, makes sense of the music. To derive the meaning or to evoke the emotions of music, one has to develop some expectations about where the music is going. So if I’m expecting a pianist to end on a particular note, I can tell you that the anterior frontal cortex of the brain is what is most active, trying to discern what’s coming next—it is not the auditory cortex in the superior temporal lobe. Robert Freeman:
What are the brain structures measuring?
Mark Tramo: The structures in the brain’s auditory system are measuring the frequency, the duration, and the timing of the events as we listen to them, and their complex combinations.
Why is Music So Significant?
Robert Freeman:
25
Patterns.
Mark Tramo: Yes, patterns. The anterior frontal cortex is expecting those patterns to resolve or not resolve in some way. You’re going to associate them with events that happened in your past life by recalling them in the medial temporal lobe. Robert Kuhn:
It shows the power and pervasiveness of music.
Mark Tramo: Music taps into so much of what makes us human. On the one hand it seems so simple: sing Happy Birthday, the simplest thing. But when you put it altogether, it is so meaningful and it involves so much of the brain, it’s astonishing. Jeanne Bamberger: Music recruits so much of our mental and emotional lives; why music has this capacity is a mystery. Mark Tramo: The amazing thing is that we think of music as being sound, acoustical energy, but it no longer exists as acoustical energy once it gets past the ear. It exists entirely in the activity of tens of millions of nerve cells throughout the auditory system. Robert Kuhn:
It starts out mechanical in the ear.
Mark Tramo: It starts out mechanical but there’s no sound in the brain; all we have are minuscule brain cells, called neurons, firing short, fast electrical impulses (called ‘‘action potentials’’) and communicating with one another. The electrical activity is one neuron splashing a chemical onto another neuron and causing it to fire sparks. How many sparks it fires, when it fires those sparks, that’s the code that the brain uses to say ‘‘Oh, Professor Bamberger is playing this particular piece,’’ or ‘‘she is climaxing the piece in just the right way to evoke the emotion.’’ The neurons themselves experience no sound per se; there’s no acoustical energy in the brain. The pitches that we hear that characterize individual notes can only exist within a particular range of the audible spectrum. We don’t have instruments that play tones above 20,000 Hz because we couldn’t hear them. So the physiology of our auditory system has to constrain the pitches that we use. When one plays different combinations of notes, we can actually see differences in the way that neurons fire. For certain types of sounds, there’s more regularity in terms of the neural firing, something Galileo wrote about when he was under house arrest for his work on astronomy. He pointed out that the timing of fluctuations and air vibrations, and therefore the fluctuations in the ear drum (which we know result in fluctuations in the sparking of neurons) is much more regular for certain musical structures like an octave. Robert Kuhn: Does music affect brain development? In other words, does brain development just enable us to hear different tones, or do those tones in fact impose themselves on the brain and influence brain development?
26
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Mark Tramo: Here is the way I think about it: we come into the world and we are primed to extract regularities in the acoustic environment and in the visual environment. For example, we’re primed to recognize faces. Our nervous system gives us that capacity. Robert Kuhn: So are music principles built into the brain, hard wired from birth? Or are they only out in the external world and we learn to recognize them? Mark Tramo: Both, in a way. They are certainly out in the external world, and we come into that world with a predisposition to apprehend it. It’s the old differentiation between nature and nurture. There’s a continual interaction between what we’re born with and what exists in the world. It is part of our nature to change with the environment, but brain and environment are inextricably linked. Robert Kuhn:
It’s the plasticity of the brain.
Mark Tramo: What’s new and exciting is that we’re not just talking about plasticity in three year olds, we’re talking about that the plasticity of the brain lasting throughout life, though to a lesser degree. Brain plasticity continues on into adulthood; the brain is changing well into our seventh and eighth decades of life. Robert Freeman: For any piece of music to make sense—whatever culture it’s in, whether it’s high art or pop art—there has to be some kind of regularity or repetition. If I play the beginning of Beethoven’s First Sonata, then two measures of Beethoven’s Second Sonata, then two measures of Beethoven’s Third Sonata, even though all of which are a part of Opus II, you would get something which makes no sense. Jeanne Bamberger: Robert Kuhn: hold?
Without repetition, there would be no coherence.
Suppose we go to a different culture, do the same principles
Jeanne Bamberger: If I listen to Chinese music, because I do not know it, I have the feeling that it goes on and on and on. If you can’t tell where the stops and starts are, then it’s like listening to a foreign language that you don’t understand. In learning a foreign language, one must learn where the stops and starts are. In other words, ‘‘how to chunk it,’’ what generates boundaries, what generates edges. Robert Freeman: I like comparing music to baseball, which is my avocational passion. You cannot understand a baseball game if you don’t know something about its basic rules or structure. Baseball can seem endless in much the same way. That’s what I get out of cricket—a feeling of endlessness—because I don’t know what the rules and objectives are.
Why is Music So Significant?
27
Robert Kuhn: Doesn’t this mean that music is more culturally based than genetically determined? Mark Tramo: There are some data of cross cultural studies that have compared how Stanford undergraduates, and how Balinese villagers who have never seen a pair of headphones, perform on tasks. So if I were to play a sequence on the piano and you had to decide how well that last note completes the sequence, then you would have some opinions about how well the last note worked. Now, a reasonable proportion of these Balinese villagers will rate how well that final tone completes that sequence very similarly to the way the Stanford undergraduates rated the tone in the goodness of the fit. Robert Kuhn: This would means that although the Balinese villages had no prior cultural exposure to this kind of music, the similarity of response indicates a universality of how music is perceived. This is turn would suggest that there are some basic structures of the brain that are innate and common to all human beings and generate similar cognitive experiences irrespective of cultural experience. Jeanne Bamberger: That study has come under a lot of criticism since what they use as stimuli are not related to the music that people in the culture know. So while it may demonstrate something, I don’t think it demonstrates how we make sense of real music. Mark Tramo: But isn’t that part of the power of the result, that although the Balinese villagers didn’t know anything about this music, yet they perceived the music in the same way that Stanford undergraduates perceived the music? Robert Kuhn:
Let’s talk about consonance and dissonance.
Jeanne Bamberger: I don’t know whether that’s cross-cultural or not. I doubt it because actually in Yugoslavia they sing in a way we might think it dissonant. We used to sing it that way in the twelfth or thirteenth century. And that’s not considered dissonant at all. Mark Tramo: There’s a whole semantics around the use of the terms consonance and dissonance. Robert Kuhn:
Is that culturally determined?
Mark Tramo: Although consonance and dissonance is culturally determined, there are universals. There is context here. Let’s say we’re watching a movie together and we hear crashing noises, it’s not a happy point in the film. The emotion that we associate with that crashing noise is very much learned, but even four month old children can tell the difference noise and music.
28
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: Let’s talk about the impact of music on children, something that many people know as the ‘‘Mozart Effect,’’ which supposedly will make you smarter—do better on tests—by listening to certain music. Robert Freeman: As a music school director, that’s something I would love to see proven. Mark Tramo: Let’s see how that experiment worked, by illustrating an example with our host that will illustrate the particular studies that came out of the University of California at Irvine, which are referred to as the Mozart Effect. We’ll imagine that there are three Robert Kuhn’s: one of them was in Dressing Room 1 listening to 10 minutes of Mozart’s Sonata For Two Pianos in D Major; there was another Robert Kuhn who was isolated in complete silence; and there was a third Robert Kuhn listening to relaxation music or maybe a modern composer like Phillip Glass. And then after ten minutes we ask all three Robert Kuhn’s to come and join us and what we did was to take several pieces of paper, folded them up, cut them in various ways, and then ask you to imagine that if we unfold the papers which papers will match. So, Robert, please choose! Robert Kuhn: The obvious answer would be this one, but I think you’re trying to fool me, so I will choose that one. Mark Tramo: You are correct, although you thought the obvious answer was actually the wrong one. Now that’s the particular task that the experiments used in ‘‘proving’’ the so-called Mozart Effect, and they determined that people would do better on this task, if just prior to the task, they had listed to Mozart for 10 or 15 minutes. Now that’s promising in the sense of showing some effect, but it’s very short lived and it can be explained by non-cognitive mechanisms that have to do with arousal and positive mood induction. Explaining the results in terms of the underlying brain mechanisms is difficult to sort out. Robert Kuhn: This focuses public attention on the fact that music may be important for the intellectual development of children. Jeanne Bamberger: But we don’t know why! Even the people who did the experiments can’t account for it. Mark Tramo: We need more data. What’s exciting about the Mozart Effect was that the experiment was in the right spirit. Music taps into so many different aspects of cognitive as well as emotional processing that it would be hard to believe that it wouldn’t have some sort of a positive effect. If we’re talking about phonological processing and language, and learning how to read, listening to music forces you to be able to decode very complex sequences, so that may confer a positive effect. There’s some evidence that music may be useful in the treatment for dyslexia. If we think of music in
Why is Music So Significant?
29
terms of proportions and ratios and symmetry, that would suggest a relationship with mathematical ability. Robert Kuhn: suspected.
The relationship between math and music has long been
Jeanne Bamberger: It only goes in one direction: there are very few musicians who are interested in math. Mark Tramo: If you put first graders into an intensive arts program that includes music training emphasizing sequencing, by the end of the year, they go ahead of the rest of the class in math. These kinds of longer term training programs are more important than what might happen in ten minutes. We need to know what happens when children begin to study piano at the age of four to nine years old. We need to collect the data. Perhaps we should institute a national effort. If one is trying to draw children into an activity that will exercise the brain, help to develop mental strategies and cognitive structures, do something that’s fun. Don’t drill the children on rote questions and canned answers. Music encompasses so many things that have to do with cognition, perception and motor function, that if the individual, apriori, likes music, gravitates to music naturally—it’s not for everybody—take advantage of it. Robert Freeman: I have a dream of a musical society in America that, just as with athletics, all kids are involved when they’re 5 to 7 years old. It’s not about becoming a professional musician—we don’t need more professional musicians. What we need is a whole army of avocational musicians, people who take great pleasure in being involved with music from an early age. Music is truly one of God’s great gifts to humanity. Mark Tramo: Music is one of the things that help bring us together. As humans we never would have survived, we would have been eaten up and killed by animals, if we hadn’t bonded together and form civilizations, so that we could fight our predators. We needed to develop social bonds, cement the collective identity, and music has been a part of virtually every collective ritual. Robert Freeman: A number of female art students at the University of Texas (Austin) decided when they were freshmen that Mozart and Beethoven were for everybody, and that they would invite non-art students on this vast campus of 51,000 people to accompany them on dates to go to artistic events. They started a whole cottage industry.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: This much we know about music: Every known culture has it, vast areas of the brain are involved, emotions are quickly recruited, and there are
30
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
cognitive connections with other aspect of the intellect. There may be a universal set of rules that governs how patterns of tones and rhythms can become music. Its nonverbal essence may enable physical, mental and emotional benefits beyond listening enjoyment, because the plasticity of the brain, active during infancy and early childhood and even into adulthood and old age, may be stimulated by music, yielding richer, healthier, betterfunctioning brains. While the so-called ‘‘Mozart Effect’’ may have some minor validity—kids seem to do better at a task for 10 minutes after hearing Mozart,but longer lasting effects are not evident—neurobiologists suspect that someday we’ll understand how music positively enhances brain processes, intelligence, and social interaction. Can music literally mold the plasticity of the brain? When I listen to the symphonies of Gustav Mahler, or the songs of Judy Collins . . .it doesn’t much matter. There is something special about music that reaches deep into our psyches and helps define us as human beings.
Interviews with Expert Participants Mark Tramo Why did you become a scientist? I grew up playing music and at a fairly early age starting writing songs in the pop rock genre. When I was in college at Yale, I studied drama and music even while I was a biology major and very interested in understanding brain mechanisms of behavior. Then, when I learned that there in fact was a science trying to understand music perception and cognition, I seized the opportunity to really pursue this new field and combine them in my career. Ultimately, I trained in neurology and became a neurologist at New York Hospital, and now at Massachusetts General Hospital. I find many very interesting questions in trying to understand the brain mechanisms responsible for something that comes so naturally to all of us as being able to apprehend the emotion and meaning in music. Is the appreciation of music innate or learned? Music appreciation as you and I experience it in everyday life is learned. What we’ve been exposed to, the associations that we have with music, what our personalities are, where we’re coming from—all these heavily influence the kind of music that we like to hear. All of us are born with the capacity to apprehend the emotion and meaning in music. There have been a considerable number of experiments done in infants that show that with a minimal
Why is Music So Significant?
31
amount, if any, exposure to music they showed sensitivities to some of the same musical structures that we experience as adults. We can’t forget the natural affinity for music that we all have at a very early age—even before we develop our tastes, and even before we identify with different subcultures and peer groups that lead us to like one music over another. There’s something basic about the ability to extract pitch and melody and harmony and rhythm that we all experience very early in our lives.
Jeanne Bamberger Why do you think music is a universally shared human experience? Music encompasses all aspects of our life. Everything from athletic to pure sensory experience to all kinds of higher level organizing abilities that we all have. I just keep being more and more impressed that the whole brain and the whole body is involved in music—it’s one holistic activity. Music is certainly an activity in which our whole humanness cooperates and participates.
Robert Freeman What are the key developments in your field? The program that we’re working on right now is the use of CAT scanning and positron emission tomography to better understand how music is created, how music is performed, and how music is perceived. I want to make sure that in the work of a brilliant young neurobiologist like Mark Tramo, the right questions are being asked and that his research is going down a positive track. Because I believe if we understood better how the human brain works, it would not only be better for musical instruction throughout the world, but that contribution would also help us understand how human function occurs generally. For example, I think that playing the piano or the organ or the violin at a very high level of technical accomplishment is about as complex a neurobiological function as the human body has mastered. Hitting fastballs in baseball is something that you do in a batting cage several times a minute, but once you start the last movement of the Brahms B-flat major concerto with an orchestra, there is no stopping and you are playing hundreds of notes every minute. Should public money be used to support the arts? There has been some nagging doubt about whether it’s a good idea to put any public money behind the arts in the United States. While there is always a possibility of misusing practically anything, there’s so much good that can be done through the arts. America has a public relations problem in certain
32
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
parts of the world in that many people think that America stands for sex and violence and consumerism and egocentrism. A reinvigorated program promoting all the arts, not only in America but throughout the world, would help counter this negative image and portray what a wonderful and compassionate and generous country this is.
Chapter 3
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
Is consciousness an illusion? You see; you feel; you act. You think you’re conscious. Some say you’re not. Modern neuroscience—the chemistry and physiology of the brain—has made remarkable progress. But is there something of the mind that is not in the brain? Philosophers have debated the ‘‘mind-body problem’’ and the existence of ‘‘free will’’ for thousands of years. What do we mean when we say ‘‘consciousness’’? Are our ‘‘minds’’ just the artificial integration of multiple brain systems? Are our feelings of self, that unique personal sense of mental ‘‘qualia’’—does the color ‘‘red’’ look the same to you as it does to me?—anything other an ‘‘epiphenomenon,’’ seemingly real but in reality an illusion? Furthermore, are non-human organisms ‘‘conscious’’? And, what about non-biological intelligences like advanced computers? Consciousness is a fundamental fact of human existence, and the nature or essence of consciousness is a core issue of human inquiry. It all comes down to one compound question: is there anything beyond current laws of physics that is needed to cause consciousness? If something new is needed, do we extend our notion of the physical? Or is consciousness somehow an independent, non-reducible, fundamental factor of existence? And if nothing new is needed, how do firings of neurons, or ultimately motions of atoms or vibrations of strings, emerge up into human self awareness? There are more radical theories about consciousness today, from religion and parapsychology to philosophy and quantum physics, than ever before. Four renowned brain scientists tackle the conundrum of how to define and study consciousness. One problem is that there are too many definitions! And getting these four guests to agree on what consciousness is and what causes it is an engaging but hopeless task that is revelatory at the same time.
34
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Their differences are immediately apparent as they attempt to describe consciousness and determine why it should include our sensory inputs, our experiences and our inner lives. They introduce the concept of ‘‘zombie’’ consciousness—where a patient is capable of performing certain tasks while remaining unaware of the surrounding environment—as one pathway to understanding. They all agree that other productive areas of study focus on how exactly the brain reacts to anesthesia or how it enables the process of making choices. The chapter concludes with a lively exchange of ideas about the meaning and measure of nerve cell activity—if it involves quantum mechanics or simply chemical reactions, or if molecular biology has advanced to a level that can make this kind of study feasible.
Expert Participants Joseph Bogen Clinical Professor of Neurosurgery, University of Southern California; adjunct professor in Psychology, University of California at Los Angeles; former consultant in neurosurgery (split brain), California Institute of Technology
Leslie Brothers Psychiatrist, neuroscientist; author, Friday’s Footprint: How Society Shapes the Human Mind
Stuart Hameroff Professor, Departments of Anesthesiology and Psychology; Associate Director, Center for Consciousness Studies, University of Arizona
Christof Koch Professor of Cognitive & Behavioral Biology & Executive Officer for Computation and Neural Systems, California Institute of Technology; author, The Quest for Consciousness: A Scientific Approach
Robert Kuhn:
Why do we call consciousness a ‘‘hard problem’’?
Joe Bogen: Consciousness is like the wind: you don’t see it; what you see are the effects of it. Stuart Hameroff: Proto-consciousness, something from which consciousness is derived, is fundamental and irreducible; it’s something like spin, or charge. Leslie Brothers: I think we have to be careful not to toss this term ‘‘consciousness’’ around too readily, as though somehow it’s a given that there
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
35
is such an entity as consciousness just because we have that word and we use it. It could be that just like we have the word ‘‘aliveness,’’ we have a concept, but that doesn’t mean that there is a single thing called consciousness. There may be many processes, many ways that we engage with the world with our own sensations and with the sensations that we get from the outside world, but to say that that means there’s some overarching entity called consciousness may be a mistake. Stuart Hameroff: We have a semantics problem here—consciousness is used incorrectly to group of all kinds of things. But I have to disagree with what you said, Leslie, because I think that consciousness, when used properly, is something very specific—it’s experience, it’s awareness that biological systems have, and as far as we know, only biological systems have. Joe Bogen: So far. Stuart Hameroff So far, and it’s just a matter of figuring out exactly what consciousness is or means. Joe Bogen If we’re going to find a scientific explanation for something, we have to be a little bit restrictive about what we’re trying to explain. Because if we try to explain all of those things that different people mean, in all of the different ways they use the word ‘‘consciousness,’’ we’re not going to be able to find any explanation. We have to focus on what we’re really after, which is closer to the idea of qualia. Stuart Hameroff: I agree. Sensations are qualia, our internal experience, the sense of our inner life that distinguishes us from computers, which do not have sensations, flavors, emotions, feelings, what philosophers call qualia, which do not have consciousness. Leslie Brothers: Christof and Francis Crick have said, let’s look at visual awareness as sort of a paradigmatic case. And see if we can find the neural correlates of consciousness beginning with one aspect of consciousness— vision. My question would still be, are the results going to be able to be generalized in some way, or is all we are going to find the neural correlates of visual awareness in a specific experimental setting? Christof Koch: It’s an experimental program. The hope is that you uncover any one aspect of consciousness: sensual consciousness, visual consciousness, pain, self consciousness, whatever, then the other aspects of consciousness are probably closely related in kind. The same principles held when scientists tried to study heredity in the origin of life. The belief was that studying that aspect of heredity and how the genetic information was transmitted in this very simple case probably would illuminate the way humans pass on genetic information to their children.
36
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: One of the theories would be that each of the different aspects of consciousness—the visual, the auditory, each separate sensory and motor system, memories—somehow gets integrated together and collectively give an illusion of consciousness. We call such an illusion an ‘‘epiphenomenon,’’ something that seems fundamentally real but it is not. Joe Bogen: I disagree with that theory: I don’t think that integrating all this stuff together is what’s crucial about consciousness. Robert Kuhn:
What’s important in your view?
Joe Bogen: What’s important about consciousness is the experience. Christof Koch: When you have a toothache, when you have tooth pain, it might override everything else because it can hurt so bad. But why does it hurt? Why is it that the release of some ions sloshing around in your brain, some calcium and potassium ions, gives rise to this really bad feeling? Leslie Brothers:
That’s the hard problem.
Christof Koch: That is a hard problem. In this case there is very little information integration going on, it’s all that one tooth that hurts. Consciousness does not have to be integration, it can be just the sensation. Here’s the critical question: how can a physical system—how can any physical system, a human, a fly, a robot—have subjective states? Robert Kuhn: We do many things that we’re not conscious of. We use the term ‘‘zombies’’ in consciousness. What’s a zombie? Christof Koch: A ‘‘zombie’’ is a set of sensory-motor systems that can do very complicated behaviors in the absence of awareness or consciousness. Leslie Brothers: A concept like ‘‘zombie’’ is a creative game that we play with our everyday notions of people; it’s the body without the mind. Christof Koch: For example, when I talk to you and I drink from a glass at the same time—this is a very complicated move. We have great difficulty getting robots to do this, to judge the distance to my mouth, to tilt it at just the right angle. This is a really difficult problem for robotics, yet I do it all the time effortlessly. Now there are some brain-damaged patients who cannot see the glass, who can’t tell how big it is, yet if you ask them just to grab it and drink it, they can do that. So here you have a beautiful dissociation: you have part of the visual system that mediates a zombie behavior that’s intact, yet another part of this visual system that mediates the conscious sensation that enables one to actually see this glass of water is destroyed. Robert Kuhn:
If you ask them, ‘‘Do you see a glass?’’ they say ‘‘No’’?
Christof Koch: Correct, they cannot see it, yet they can still do certain highly trained behaviors, like taking the glass and drinking from it.
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
37
Robert Kuhn: Your point is that the zombie part of the brain is not conscious but is still able to do sophisticated behaviors. Christof Koch: That’s correct, and there’s a whole range of these unconscious systems that move your eyes, adjust your gait, that come into play unconsciously when, for example, you shake somebody’s hand. Leslie Brothers: Zombies do all the things that bodies do but without the subjective locus of experience. For example, when I look at what’s on this table I believe that I am having my experience; I don’t think I’m having Christof’s experience. Robert Kuhn consciousness?
Does the concept of zombie help us understand
Christof Koch: Yes, because if you look at the brain basis of zombie behaviors, if you can identify what part of the brain or what brain systems are responsible for mediating unconscious behavior—zombie behaviors, call it whatever you like—and compare that with those parts of the brain that are responsible for mediating conscious behaviors, you want to ask, where is the difference? Is there a special type of neuron involved? Special parts of the brain? What is the brain difference between conscious and unconscious behaviors? Leslie Brothers: It is an assumption that conscious and unconscious behaviors are two kinds of separate categories. It may be that visual awareness, being awake as opposed to asleep, being in a light state of anesthesia as opposed to being fully awake, feeling toothache pain, these may not be unified in any overarching way. Christof Koch: But the history of biology in the last 150 years has shown that for every specific function that you can identify, there’s always one or more specific systems, specific cells, specific molecules, specific molecular machineries, that carry out this function. That’s how biology works. Leslie Brothers: Sure; each function may have its own specific systems. The question is whether there is some overarching system. Joe Bogen: You bet you there is! Stuart Hameroff: You have to be careful about not confusing ‘‘attention’’ with ‘‘consciousness’’ because it could be that our sensory inputs give us states of mind that are really not conscious until other systems like the cholinerrgic system come along and select for attention, for conscious attention. Robert Kuhn: Stuart, you are an anesthesiologist; you’re in the operating room; you literally have your hands on consciousness; you see it fade and disappear, and then you bring it back. What can you tell us?
38
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Stuart Hameroff: Consciousness is an amazing thing; even though I do it daily, I still wonder, well, where my patients go? But then it makes me wonder why are they conscious in the first place? It’s interesting that the anesthesia gasses that go into the lungs and into the blood and the brain don’t form any chemical bonds at all; they actually form very weak quantum mechanical forces. This implies that quantum mechanical interactions are generators of consciousness. Robert Kuhn: It wouldn’t have to be quantum mechanical; it could still be chemical. Or put another way, it is quantum mechanical only because everything, ultimately, is quantum mechanical. Leslie Brothers: If a mechanism is not known, one has to be careful to claim that it must be quantum mechanical, because they are both black boxes. Stuart Hameroff: The confluence of mystery theory. But what I’m saying is that proteins change their shape depending on quantum mechanical forces inside the proteins. Anesthetics get in there, form their own quantum mechanic reactions and prevent the protein from working. Robert Kuhn:
Suppose that’s true, so what? What follows?
Stuart Hameroff: It implies that there’s a quantum coherent state among these proteins throughout given nerves and given systems. Robert Kuhn: Let’s talk a little bit about the social brain because, as individuals, we only know what we are ourselves are thinking. I don’t know what you’re thinking. So what is it about the social relationship among people that helps define who we are? Leslie Brothers: You can think of it like language. Language is a system that is outside of us essentially, but we all participate in it, and our brains seemed to be well adapted to use it. And I think that’s the same thing with the social system that I’m talking about. Call it ‘‘the person system,’’ where I am a person with a mind, you are a person with a mind, and our brains are well adapted to perceive both ourselves and other people as persons, that is, bodies with minds. In a sense what gives us the feeling of unity is that each of us has a source of perception, feeling, awareness that resides in us. I call it an illusion. The sense that my experience somehow emanates from me or belongs to me, I believe that that’s an illusion. The reality, I suggest, is that we participate socially as we do in language. Joe Bogen: There’s some things that we really need to say here. Number one is that consciousness is real. Leslie, you some reservations about that, but you’re kind of willing to go along. Leslie Brothers:
I’ll play the game.
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
39
Joe Bogen: Number two is where does consciousness come from? Most of us believe that brains produce consciousness. Number three is at what level in the brain is consciousness produced? We can look at the subcellular level, at the cytoskeleton, the microtubules. We could look at the cellular level: some people think that there are some cells that are conscious (or have the capacity for it) and other cells that are not conscious. You can look at the level of brain circuits, which is where I happen to look. I believe that consciousness emerges at the circuit level. Or you could postulate that you need great, massive systems before you have consciousness. And then some people think that only whole brains can be conscious. Robert Kuhn: Yes, and there are other some people who believe that you need more than the brain to have true human consciousness. Joe Bogen: Yes, some people (like Leslie) don’t want to use the word consciousness unless you have a brain interacting with other brains. I’m not very happy with that opinion because I think that a totally isolated human being, or a cat or dog that never saw another cat or dog can experience pain and hunger and thirst. Robert Kuhn: Don’t we find it absolutely fascinating that first-rate brain scientists differ so substantially even as to the gross level in the brain that is the primary generator of consciousness—from the subcellular, to cellular, to systems of neurons, to neural circuits, to brain systems, to whole brains, to beyond. Is that the state of play today? Stuart Hameroff: You started too high, or too large. To find the real locus of consciousness—call it ‘‘proto-consciousness,’’ something from which consciousness is derived, something so fundamental and irreducible that it is a component of the universe that has been there all along, something like spin or charge or mass—it’s probably down there at the quantum mechanical level, at the most fundamental level of space-time geometry, and it has probably been there since the Big Bang. Christof Koch: Stuart Hameroff: is testable.
That’s a mystical statement. It is totally untestable. Christof, nothing you’ve said so far about consciousness
Christof Koch: No, there are lots of experiments you can do in mice, in monkeys, you in humans that involve consciousness. That’s what progress is. Progress is not at fundamental levels of space-time geometry. Experiments that brain scientists are doing today avoid all these philosophical arguments, because otherwise we would be sitting here 100 years from now having the same arguments. We progress by focusing on where in the brain are the correlates for sensations and emotions.
40
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Stuart Hameroff: Correlates! So you’re going to give up on consciousness and just worry about correlates. Christof Koch: Yes, for the foreseeable future, because we have not made any progress on pure consciousness; neither philosophers and nor scientists. Stuart Hameroff: That’s because you have tunnel vision, and you’re looking just in one direction—you’re looking under the lamp post for the keys because that’s where the light is. Christof Koch: That’s possible, but the way we will undoubtedly make progress in studying consciousness is the way scientists have made spectacular progress in molecular science and neuroscience. So we’ll focus for, say, the next 10 or 20 years, on the experimental approach, finding the location of the correlates of specific sensations, perceptions, acts and memories. And that’s where the funding is and that’s where the experiments are. Joe Bogen: If you think that consciousness is produced by a brain, then you say to yourself, which parts of that brain are more important in producing consciousness than other parts? How do you decide? You see which parts of brain you can take away and the cat or whatever animal is still conscious. And which parts of the brain do you need to remain intact or unimpaired for the creature to be conscious. (In animals we do surgical experiments to extirpate specific brain parts. In humans we see the results of traumatic accidents that destroy brain parts.) Robert Kuhn: And in fact an animal or a human can lose large parts of its brain and remain conscious. Joe Bogen: In certain parts of the brain you can take out great cupfuls of tissue without destroying consciousness, and then there are two places where you can make extremely teeny destructions, the size of a head of a kitchen match, and the human or animal is going to be totally unresponsive. Stuart Hameroff: But unresponsiveness doesn’t mean they’re not conscious, because the problem could be the brain’s attention mechanism. Joe Bogen: Now wait a minute: when we’re trying to decide if somebody is conscious, we never see consciousness—consciousness is like the wind, you don’t see it—what we see are the effects of it. . . Stuart Hameroff:
You can’t measure consciousness.
Joe Bogen: No, you’re trying to determine the level of consciousness. Christof Koch: Most biologists would assume that aspects of consciousness are expressed by animals: a rat and a cat have some sensation; they might not know who they are, they might not know about death, but they certainly have pain and pleasure and sensation—you can see that. And so if
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
41
animals do have these expressions of consciousness, many experiments of the type that Joe was suggesting can help, where you eliminate certain brain areas—either with a surgeon’s knife, or today using molecular techniques, such as genetic knockout or knock-in techniques—where you can manipulate the brain.1 The kinds of questions we ask are: Is this mouse still capable of doing certain things that in humans requires conscious behaviors? Joe Bogen: You can make, if you’re lucky, a zombie mouse. Leslie Brothers:
Zombie mice!
Christof Koch: Zombie mice, that’s exactly the point. If we can create mice that are unable to do certain things then we can learn about those things. Leslie Brothers:
How can I tell a zombie mouse from a non-zombie mouse?
Christof Koch: Because the zombie mouse is not able to do certain types of planning, it doesn’t have access to long-term memory. Leslie Brothers: out planning.
That’s just a mouse without a memory and a mouse with-
Christof Koch: You do exactly what you do in studying disease. Let’s say you’re trying to study a mouse model for autism or a mouse model for schizophrenia, you start by establishing a few characteristics that can distinguish humans who have autism from normal humans who do not—and you try to replicate the same phenomenology in mice. To study consciousness, you do the same thing. Leslie Brothers: You have to be careful. You might end up with some beautiful mice that won’t be able to remember or won’t be able to plan, but their existence doesn’t mean that you can then generalize from them to human consciousness. Christof Koch: I agree, you have to be careful, but 50 years history has shown that molecular biology works. Robert Kuhn: What can we learn about brain systems that can help us make progress? Christof Koch: One popular technique involves studying visual illusions; for example, where in the same image you sometimes see a vase or sometimes you see two people looking at each other. Here your consciousness switches constantly, you either see the vase or the people. Where are the neurons that are involved in this switching? If they are the ones that generate my consciousness, then they should show the same switching dynamic as my conscious perception. Robert Kuhn: consciousness.
At least we would know the neurons involved in
42
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Christof Koch: Robert Kuhn:
Exactly. How does consciousness impact our sense of humanness?
Stuart Hameroff: I think it depends on how you look at consciousness, if it’s an epiphenomenon, artificial, it doesn’t mean much. But if it’s causal, if consciousness is something kind of unique and has a fundamental role in the universe, then we’re not merely helpless spectators in the universe but we actually have something like free will and causal efficacy in this world. Christof Koch: Whoa! Wait! We’ve now we jumped several levels. Consciousness and volition are separate subjects, and they might or might not relate. I don’t see that they have to relate: consciousness can perfectly well exist, and free will might perfectly well be an illusion. Stuart Hameroff:
I don’t think so.
Joe Bogen: Usually consciousness has two aspects that are usually together, one is awareness, the sensory side, what we call qualia. The other is volition, that we do some things consciously rather than automatically. Robert Kuhn:
And both are intrinsic to our humanness.
Joe Bogen: Well, yes, but they are also intrinsic to cats and dogs. What makes humans special is not being conscious. Stuart Hameroff: Christof Koch:
It depends whether or not you believe in free will.
Cats and dogs can also have free will. . .
Joe Bogen: Cats do things deliberately; dogs make up their minds. Stuart Hameroff: Let me talk about volition because choice is very important, and the best way that I understand it is through a quantum paradigm. Quantum computing is coming at us like a freight train; I think it’s going to revolutionize information technology. Quantum computing utilizes the property of quantum superposition in which things can be in multiple states at the same time, so whereas in classical computation we have bits of one or zero, in quantum computation we have qubits of one and zero which superpose and sort of communicate. So let’s say we’re making a choice, we’re going to decide what to have for lunch: spaghetti, meat, sushi, whatever. One possibility is we have a quantum superposition of all these possibilities that then the quantum waveforms collapse to the specific choice—I’ll have sushi. Christof Koch: This is what Gell-Mann described as quantum mysticism— you’re using these words, there’s no brain involved.
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
43
Joe Bogen: Let me get back to the question of free will. Some things you take responsibility for; you say, ‘‘I did that.’’ Other things, like dropping something on the floor, for example, or stumbling, you don’t take responsibility for. And there are certain conditions where human beings have brain damage and they do some things that they don’t feel that they did. So what we’re talking about is the conviction of volition, the personal feeling that you did it. And you can have exactly the same outwardly observable behavior, say, a knee jerk, or turning one’s head to look at something, sometimes it is volitional and sometimes it is not. And what makes it volitional is the person saying, ‘‘I did that; I am responsible for the knee jerking or for the head turning.’’ Volition is that feeling on the part of the individual that he or she did it, and this feeling must have some physiological correlate in the brain, and that’s what you want to go looking for. So when you have a situation where you can do an act either volitionally or automatically, what you want to know is what’s the difference in nerve cell activity that characterizes that conviction of volition. Robert Kuhn: I want to ask a final question, If we are here 100 years from now discussing the same subject, what would we be saying? Leslie Brothers: We’ll have discovered that we had to leave behind the notion that we could discover anything about the human feeling of being aware. We’ll have discovered that the level of the subcellular, the cellular, the neuronal, were all too low. Ultimately we’ll understand that the highest and most complex kinds of cognition comes from the interaction of brain and brain—i.e., social systems. Joe Bogen: I think it’s going to take 100 years for people to accept what I already believe.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: These four leading brain scientists couldn’t even agree on at what level a simple ‘‘memory’’ was stored, whether as a gross ‘‘brain circuit,’’ at the synapse between nerve cells, or in the microstructure of the nerve cells as some sort of quantum effect. But why should it be any different now? Philosophers have debated the ‘‘mind-body problem’’ and the existence of ‘‘free will’’ for thousands of years. However, never before have we been in a position to examine the brain with such precision. Even as we begin to understand the deep science that underlies our cognitive processes, there is no letup in arguments whether we are anything other than automata, just reacting to stimuli—vastly more complex than a bacterium to be sure—but fundamentally little different. Although this spirited and highly qualified group manages to disagree on just about everything, in the midst, they transmit good information about the key issues involving the understanding of consciousness today.
44
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Psychiatrist/author Leslie Brothers firmly believes that there is something of the mind that is not in the brain, but it is not spirit or soul. To her, the seat of consciousness resides in the social interaction of living things between brain and brain in society. Says Brothers, without others to reflect ourselves off of, there would be no consciousness. You see; you feel; you act. You think that by yourself you’re conscious. But are you really?
Interviews with Expert Participants Leslie Brothers Talk about your book, Friday’s Footprint: How Society Shapes the Human Mind. I think we might be at the beginning of a paradigm shift, away from understanding the mind and the brain as a sort of isolated, unto itself entity, and understanding that most mental phenomena really arise from social processes. And so we’ll be looking to see what the social processing functions of the brain are, and then also how that leads to collective social processes that then circle back and affect the brain. How does brain physiology fit into this view? I think our personal experience arises from the material building blocks—the proteins, the neurons, how they fire together in patterns and all of that—but most important are the complex ways that these patterns are organized, and those have a reality of their own. For example, how it is that you feel yourself to be a person? It is sort of a subjective locus of experience, which is built up from these lower level building blocks, but its fundamental reality is on a higher level, which is derived from its patterns of complexity. Who influenced your ideas about society and the brain? I most admire the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein because he penetrated through a lot of the confusions that beset us in our analytical thinking and said that we have to look at the language that we use. We have to look at our social forms of life and our linguistic forms, and that if we don’t look at these, we’re going to be confused. And so Wittgenstein brought us back to the level of our everyday social practices, which is why he is one of my big heroes.
Is Consciousness an Illusion?
45
Joseph E. Bogen Are animals conscious? When we examine the brains of animals, we see a certain organization. And whether the animal is a monkey or a cat or a dog, the organization is very similar. I’m reasonably confident that mammals are conscious, any mammal; I think it’s part of being a mammal because being conscious helps you learn things faster. Consciousness helps you acquire learning that you either wouldn’t get at all or wouldn’t get as quickly or wouldn’t get as well. But this only applies to mammals. I don’t believe spiders are conscious, for example. They don’t learn much; they can do crazy, wonderful things, but not learn much. Why did you become a scientist? The real question is why didn’t I? My mother was a doctor. My uncle was a doctor. My cousins were doctors. So the real question is why is it that I went all through college as an economics major—and why is it that it wasn’t until several years later that I decided I to go to medical school? The answer undoubtedly involves deep psychoanalytic problems. Whom do you most admire, and why? Historically, Descartes. A good teacher used to say, ‘‘You could tell how big somebody was by how long he held up progress.’’ And Descartes has held up progress on the mind-body problem for about 400 years. That’s world class blockage! What is your outlook on human civilization? There were more baths and more houses with interior heating in England in the year 50 A.D. than there were in the year 1900. The reason was the Pax Romana. If you have peace, you can build all kinds of great stuff. And if you’re going to have war all the time, you’re not going to be able to build much at all. That’s our biggest single problem. What advice do you have for young people? The first thing you have to do is find out what your natural abilities are. And then you must determine how best to cultivate them. Young people have to find out are what they’re good at. Now, the trouble is that society rewards some talents much more than other talents. That’s a fact. So if you’re anxious to get a shiny sports car, which almost any teenager is, you’re not going to encourage your natural talents. You’re going to do whatever it takes to get the shiny sports car.
46
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Chrisof Koch You’re a nuts-and-bolts scientist. You like to knock out a neuron, then see what’s stopped working. But you’re also a theoretician. That’s unusual. Unusual, probably, from a scientific point of view. The person I collaborated with was Francis Crick, one of the few people I know that one might legitimately call a ‘‘genius.’’ The thing I admire most is the fact that he’s willing to question everything that he’s said, everything he’s done, everything we’ve talked about over the last 15 years. He has this ability to have very little emotional investment in his own ideas. To Crick, his own ideas were just another source of ideas, but they could also be rejected as much as anybody else’s idea could be rejected. In that sense, he was totally fearless. And of course, Crick had an amazing ability to combine facts and ideas, to have flashes of insights about things that I could be looking at but not see. He could bring two elements together that I never thought about, but once he said it, I’d say to myself, well, that was obvious. What are you finding out about animals and consciousness these days? An important development is our scientific capacity to record and differentiate, in the laboratory, hundreds of individual neurons in a behaving animal, like in a monkey. So while the monkey does a particular task—for example, looks at a colorful painting—I can now discriminate among the activity of hundreds of individual neurons. And that, more than anything else, has helped us and will continue to help us decipher the brain. We really need to look at the individual elements, the individual neurons.
Note 1. ‘‘Knockout’’ means suppressing some genes so the animal doesn’t express a certain structure or function, and then observing the losses to behavior.
Chapter 4
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
How does the brain really work? It’s all in your head, but it’s still a great mystery. Funny how the brain is often compared to a current technology— first a telephone exchange, then a computer. Now neuroscience has fascinating new theories of brain function. You’ll marvel at what’s crammed into your cranium.
Expert Participants Eric Courchesne Professor of Neuroscience, University of California at San Diego.
Portia Iversen Founder, Cure Autism Now
Soma Mukhopadhyay Teacher of autistic children; Tito’s mother
Tito Mukhopadhyay Autistic adolescent; author, Beyond the Silence
Erin Schuman Executive Officer for Neurobiology, Associate Professor of Biology, California Institute of Technology
Terrance Sejnowski Professor, The Salk Institute for Biological Studies; co-author, The Computational Brain.
48
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: Tito, we appreciate having you here. We’d like to talk about how people study other people. How do you feel when scientists ask you questions and want to see how your brain works? Tito writes on pad Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote): Robert Kuhn:
I get flattered.
What are the primary characteristics of autism?
Eric Courchesne: Poor speech and language, particularly in very young affected children, two years old; sometimes an absence of speech and language altogether. Poor social communication skills; a disinterest in interacting with other people, the willingness to just stand up and walk away when people are talking with you; ritualistic and repetitive behavior. Autistic patients may exhibit body mannerisms like flapping the hands or twiddling the fingers, or rocking and twiddling strings. Or they may have obsessive interests, interests in maps, for instance—just looking at maps continuously for no particular reasons. Portia Iversen: Tito, would you mind telling people why you flap your hands and rock back and forth, and how you experience your body? Tito writes Portia Iversen (reading what Tito wrote): I just need to find my position in space. Terry Sejnowski: Robert Kuhn: Tito?
Interesting, exploring space.
How does rocking help you find your position in space,
Tito writes on pad Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote): body and it reminds me that I have one.
I forget that I have a
Terry Sejnowski: Our brain is built to actively explore the world, and I think that what may be happening here—this is speculating—is that if you don’t have that anchor in your body, you have to continually remind yourself, ‘‘I’m here, I’m here,’’ and by moving back and forth, you can do that. Robert Kuhn: Our kinesthetic sense tells us where our arms and legs are at all times; we can close our eyes and we still know where our hands and legs are. But Tito may not know any of these kinds of things.
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
49
Eric Courchesne: It’s as if each of the senses are coming into the brain separately and never connect up with one another. Portia Iversen:
That’s what he’s describing.
Eric Courchesne: That must mean that he experiences a great deal of sensory noise, a lot of variability, and he has no way of keeping consciously focused. Erin Schuman: So he increases his sensory sample rate by moving through the environment to increase the amount of sampling information that he gets. Eric Courchesne: above the noise.
To make at least one stimulus stronger and thus emerge
Robert Kuhn: Tito, everybody at this table is a writer. Each of us has written different kinds of things. You write poetry. I do not. Tito continues writing Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote):
I write my experience.
Soma Mukhopadhyay: I do not have to wait long to see what Tito says, because he writes immediately, he doesn’t sit and think. It is as if his words have already been precomposed; he just gets up in the morning and then he just writes them as speech. Terry Sejnowski: That’s remarkable, almost as if it was composed while he was asleep. Soma Mukhopadhyay:
It’s just pre-thought.
Terry Sejnowski: His poems seem to occur to him in the morning. Now, why is that? This is something that I think all of us have experienced: we are struggling with a problem and we can’t get the answer, we go to sleep, wake up in the morning, and suddenly it’s a lot clearer. We either have the answer or we know how to get to the answer. Maybe there’s something going on during the period of sleep; we know a lot of activity is occurring in the brain during sleep; it’s quite different from the activity that occurs when we are awake, but maybe this is the period during which not only memories are consolidated but new ways of integrating together information you have are developed. Robert Kuhn:
Does Tito read?
Soma Mukhopadhyay: Yes; he never used to read, but I found that he can pinpoint words on a newspaper, but that I did not call reading. I do the reading with him, line by line. Robert Kuhn:
So you read to him.
50
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Soma Mukhopadhyay: Erin Schuman:
Do you read poetry to him?
Soma Mukhopadhyay: Robert Kuhn:
I usually read.
A lot.
Have you done that since Tito was a small child?
Soma Mukhopadhyay:
Every day.
Robert Kuhn: Do you see any correspondence between the poetry you’ve read over the years and what he writes, whether thematically or style? Soma Mukhopadhyay: Some things affect him, like while he was reading the book called Alchemist. It was after he had heard the whole book that he wrote his book, The Mind Tree. He gets inspiration like that. The style has a parallel feel; it’s just like his poem ‘‘This And That’’: ‘‘. . .there was a little desire and a little hopelessness; a little looking ahead and a little looking back; a little sunshine and a little shade; a little of this and a little of that.’’ Everything goes like ‘‘with a little of this and a little of that.’’ Every time he may have a new focus; for example, one day he wrote everything about orange, he got so obsessed with orange. He wrote: ‘‘On a hidden back with orange sparks on little dust grains, orange on this and that. Orange on hidden wild flower behind a hidden rock, gathering time with ages to stay, green with gathering moss. Orange on a peeping beam, through the canopy green.’’ Erin Schuman: So he is able to see orange, along with all these different things, so he is able to sort of synthesize things in a way in his poetry. Soma Mukhopadhyay:
Orange and blues and blacks.
Portia Iversen: If you read Tito’s poetry you’ll actually notice that there’s surprisingly little imagery. Normally in poetry, you often see a lot of visual descriptions. By the way, Tito has a mentor, Stephen Berke, the poet; Stephen lives in Philadelphia and they correspond by email. Stephen has been advising Tito to try to incorporate more visual components into his poetry, which for Tito is very hard. Robert Kuhn: write?
How does Tito commit word to paper, does he actually
Soma Mukhopadhyay: sometimes edits it. Robert Kuhn:
Yes, he usually writes it and then he types it. He
On the computer?
Soma Mukhopadhyay:
Yes.
Terry Sejnowski: How did he start using the computer? Was that something natural for him?
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
51
Soma Mukhopadhyay: No. I gave him a computer a year before last. He is pretty fast in picking things up: he corrects himself, using backspace and delete functions; he opens and closes his files. Portia Iversen: In his book, Tito has some very interesting descriptions about early sensory experience. He does one description where he says that he’s looking out the window at a cloud, and somebody says a word like, say, ‘‘banana,’’ and then forever after cloud and banana go together. Tito can listen and not look, or look and not listen. It seems like these sensory systems diverged, kind of came apart, instead of further integrating as they would for the average developing kid. Eric Courchesne: Sensory instances, the cloud and the banana collide, interact, and become formed as a single memory; that’s really common in autism. And a major question is, why does that happen? One possibility is that in autism there was a proliferation of connectivity in the cerebral cortex early on in the patient’s early development where these connections were abnormally arranged almost randomly, allowing interconnections that ordinarily wouldn’t be there or meaningful. Portia Iversen: Dr. Mike Merzenich speculates that autism results from a kind of early overselectivity coming on too early in a child’s development. Normal people must make sensory selections because you can’t make sense of your universe if everything is going at once; normal people use their selective attention system to focus on one sense modality in order to just simply know things like, ‘‘this is a glass; this isn’t banana glass.’’ Perhaps in autism, brain circuits are laid in very early, too early, and as these circuits become the underpinnings of other learned behaviors, confusion arises. Erin Schuman: I think it is interesting that Tito forms immediate associations, banana and cloud. Not only does this reveal that he can form associations, but that he does it so quickly is revealing. Normal people would need many trials to make an association between cloud and banana, so Tito, as our window on autism, seems to have a hypersensitive ability to make associations. Robert Kuhn:
Tito, how do you see the door?
Tito writes Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote): The shapes come first. . . Robert Kuhn:
The shapes come first, and what next?
Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote):
The color.
Terry Sejnowski: Sensory inputs come in over time, you have to put the pieces together, and normal people do that without ever knowing that they are doing it; that’s something that we take for granted.
52
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Eric Courchesne: So, Tito, you’re saying that the larger an object is, the more difficult it is for you to perceive it. And you perceive it in parts or fragments, shape and then color. Tito writes on pad Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote): I see the room only after I see the door. Terry Sejnowski: That’s almost poetical. It illustrates something that we’re beginning to understand about our own perception, which is that normally you see the whole before you see the parts. For Tito, it looks like it’s the opposite. Tito has a problem with putting the world together. Normally we don’t think about the fact that we can see someone and listen to them and touch things and it all comes together in our brain almost automatically. But, in some conditions, and apparently this is the case with Tito, those sensory inputs are disconnected and so it is not at all easy to put them together. To the autistic mind, the world must be a very frightening place when things are coming at you unexpectedly and things don’t connect. When we see malfunctions or brain breakdowns like autism, I think we can learn a great deal about how the brain works normally, things that aren’t apparent to us because our normal brains work so well. We don’t understand how difficult that is to put together all the different pieces of the world and make it a unified whole. Erin Schuman: Tito’s case is interesting, and rather hopeful, because it’s clear that working together with his mother and his team, Tito communicates his experiences. Tito has a great deal of first-person information that normal people would have noway of knowing or of getting it out. Using the computer and voice synthesizer it’s clear that Tito knows a lot more than would have been recognized if only conventional methods of probing what an individual knows were used. This suggests the possibility that there may be other cases like Tito where there is a lot of information locked up and a lot of synthesis going on internally, but where there is no output. Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading what Tito wrote): become bigger than the door, just a point.
I can see a point. . .It can
Soma Mukhopadhyay: Tito can just concentrate on that point and the other things get unnoticed. Portia Iversen: One day, Tito and I were looking at a door and (as he described it here) he said, ‘‘I see the shape, I see the color, I see the position.’’ I said, ‘‘What if I close it,’’ and he said, ‘‘I may have to start all over again.’’ In our average everyday world we’re confronted by thousands of kinds of images in any given second of time, some moving, some stationary, each with its own complex set of characteristics. When I ask Tito, ‘‘How do you see all this?’’ He answers all these things, ‘‘one by one.’’
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
53
Eric Courchesne: It’s almost like autistic people can only focus in like a spotlight on just one solitary piece of the world around them, and in order to put it together, to make any sense of their environment, they have to shift around and around to slowly piece it all together. The separate strands of sensory input take over his consciousness. Terry Sejnowski: Maybe that indicates an overactive form of attention. Normally we can tune out other, irrelevant sights and sounds, and focus on the one critical object, but usually we’re continuing to be aware of the rest of the world. If you can focus on one object extremely well, you can imagine that there’s nothing else out there except that object and it becomes your whole world. Eric Courchesne: Not just overactive but almost active in a way that’s out of his control. This would mean that Tito is not able to easily and smoothly adjust his scope of attention to take in the whole scene, let alone a part of a scene. He would be reduced to just a single feature of a scene. Robert Kuhn: What are some of the modern theories on how attention works and how we bind things together? Terry Sejnowski: It’s really all taking place in the prefrontal cortex of the brain, the part in the front of the brain that allows your mind to selectively attend to particular senses and particular features, and in fact switches between different objects. That is a mental function that we take for granted; we don’t think twice about switching very rapidly between discussions with different people, but for Tito this is very difficult. Eric Courchesne: The centers for attention in the brain are located not only in brain stem structures but also in the frontal and parietal cortex structures, as well as certain parts of the cerebellum. All these structures are involved in the dynamic regulation of attention and allow the rapid, smooth, and effective shifting of attention from one sensory percept, for instance ‘‘color,’’ to another, for instance ‘‘shape.’’ Or the sensory shift can be between sensory modalities, say between vision and audition. What we and others have found is that autistic individuals have a great deal of trouble doing this shifting, and they tend to get stuck on one thing as if their attention got locked in or became frozen, and this situation was out of the person’s control. So apparently systems that allow for the smooth modulation of sensory inputs are not effective. Robert Kuhn:
Let’s talk about memory. How does memory work?
Erin Schuman: How does an organism store information about its environment? That’s essentially what a memory is. What we know is that memories are stored at the interconnection between neurons (nerve cells), called the synapse, and it is likely that memories are mediated by changes in the
54
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
strength of communication between the neurons, which is how one cell can have impact on other cells. Robert Kuhn: That’s done through chemicals, called neurotransmitters, which pass from one neuron to another neuron across the synapse, the presynaptic part of the first neuron influencing the post-synaptic part of the second neuron by these chemicals. Erin Schuman: Right. The first neuron releases a neurotransmitter that the second neuron detects, and the latter changes that chemical signal into an electrical signal. So, information can be stored by changing the strength of that electrical signal. And then, once you get past the synapse you get to the cell, and the cell has to integrate the information that it’s receiving from all of the cells that are talking to it, which could be hundreds or even thousands of other cells. Robert Kuhn: As for brain structures, the hippocampus is critical in forming memories. Erin Schuman: The brain has two halves, so each person has two hippocampi, one in each hemisphere. In the hippocampus, a huge number of those synapses come into a single cell. In the 1950s, one patient, called H.M., had both of his hippocampi removed due to extreme epilepsy, and what was noticed in H.M. was that he had profound amnesia following the surgery and was incapable of forming new memories. That was one of the first clues that the hippocampus is important for memory formation. Since then, animal studies have basically borne that out: for certain kinds of memories, animals that lack a hippocampus cannot form those memories. Robert Kuhn:
How about long-term memory?
Terry Sejnowski: We think that semantic memory, memory that is knowledge about the world, resides in the cerebral cortex, but there is an initial period during which you need to have a dialogue between the hippocampus and the cerebral cortex, back and forth, for that memory to be consolidated in the cortex. Portia Iversen: Tito is telling us that, ‘‘I have that better,’’ meaning that he has better memory than average. Terry Sejnowski: That could well be. If you can really focus your attention on something, you can really encode that in a way that it will remain there for a long time. Attention is clearly directed by these neuromodulatory systems, like those that use choline and serotonin as neurotransmitters. If you could really focus the way Tito does, you could make a very strong association. Portia Iversen: Tito says, ‘‘I have that better,’’ meaning long term memory, but he then adds, ‘‘but I forgot my breakfast menu,’’ and he really means it.
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
55
If I were to ask Tito, ‘‘give me examples of breakfast food,’’ he’d probably give a longer list than we would, but if I said, ‘‘what did you have for breakfast,’’ he may absolutely not be able to tell us because of the way the information is stored in his brain. He needs a handle on memory or information to access and use it, he needs to get a hold of a tag, like a computer would. Tito’s mind works, I think, something akin to artificial intelligence. You couldn’t ask a computer, ‘‘what is this,’’ or ‘‘what did you do an hour ago’’; rather, you must give it some commands, and that’s similar to how Tito’s brain works. Robert Kuhn: On what level can autism be occurring at? We know that the brain works on multiple levels, from the neurons, the synapse between those neurons, to neural networks which are associations of neurons, to brain structures (like the hippocampus), and whole brain systems. Terry Sejnowski:
Why not all of them?
Erin Schuman: To the extent that autism has an underlying genetic or biological mechanism, it can be a quite fundamental mutation. One of the things that’s perhaps not intuitive is that the underlying biological mechanisms for these very complicated behavioral disorders can be something very simple, such as the way a synapse works. Robert Kuhn: In brain malfunctions, everything can be affected. But with autism, can we discern a primary cause? Eric Courchesne: Genetic factors must be very significant in autism because identical twins have a 60 percent likelihood that if one has it the second will also; whereas fraternal twins, in which the siblings are not genetically identical to each other, the likelihood is only three to six percent. So this disparity between the concordance of autism in the identical twin pair versus the discordance for autism in fraternal twin pair speak strongly to genetics. Most people believe that there’s probably two to four or five different genes that are involved in this disorder. Terry Sejnowski: But now here’s a challenge: identical twins have a concordance of 60 percent for autism, which means that if one of them has autism, there is a likelihood of 60 percent that the other one twin will also have autism. But it also means there’s a 40 percent probability that the other will not have autism; so what is missing here, in other words, is why is it that with precisely the same genes at birth, one identical twin can develop autism and the other doesn’t? That’s a mystery. Eric Courchesne: One or two genes do not make a person. We have tens of thousands of genes that are the blueprint for the biology of our bodies. And so it’s probably some complex interaction among other genes that may show slight variability even in identical twins.
56
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Terry Sejnowski:
What about the environment?
Erin Schuman: Genes have a whimsical nature, which we have seen in knockout studies where a single gene is mutated in a mouse. In some cases in a litter, you’ll find 30 percent of the mice lack a kidney, and since they are all genetically identical, there must be a whimsical or probabilistic nature to the way genes play out their program in the development of the organism that isn’t as hard wired as we would like to think. Terry Sejnowski: Some of that whimsy occurs in the womb. It turns out that the environment in which the fetus develops has a major impact on how the brain develops. Robert Kuhn: Let’s talk about the search for a cure for autism, not just alleviating symptoms, but a real cure. How is science progressing? Eric Courchesne: Science progresses by exploring possible biological mechanisms that lead to the phenomena of autism, both its behavioral and its brain phenomena. And some of these clues are going to lead us to possible biological interventions that can be very effective. The most remarkable story of this sort is a disorder called PKU, which, if not treated, will cause the child to become mentally retarded. From birth, the child’s chemistry is no longer protected by mother’s body and in those children who have the PKU disorder, the child’s chemistry is not able to control the use of an amino acid—phenylalanine, which is commonly available in foods—and as a result, toxic levels of this amino acid build up and produce brain damage. But knowing that allows a very simple and effective treatment: for a child that has the gene mutation, PAH, that prevents the normal metabolism of this amino acid, such a child is put on a diet that has low quantities of this amino acid. And almost magically, normal brain development follows. Something similar might be occuring with other developmental disorders. Portia Iversen: There’s a subset of children with PKU who have autisticlike symptoms. To demonstrate that a simple missing enzyme can cause a huge spectrum of complicated behavioral symptoms is remarkable. Terry Sejnowski: The key here is having knowledge that there’s a particular amino acid and a particular gene that’s gone wrong. If we knew what genes were involved, we might be able to catch them really early, before they even start manifesting themselves. Eric Courchesne: In autism there are two very interesting facts that may have something to do with each other and may eventually lead to this kind of intervention. One is the finding that, at birth, the brain of the autistic individual is normal in size, but by two years of age, it will have grown to be far larger than normal. So the question is, what’s causing the abnormal growth? It turns out that, at birth, there are elevated brain growth factors in children
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
57
who later become autistic; apparently in autism these brain growth regulators are in too great abundance. The interesting point is that, for the first time, molecular factors that may influence brain outcome have been identified at birth and blood samples from autistic individuals. This gives hope that the pathways that lead into and out of that point may be investigated and perhaps modified, producing a far better outcome. Robert Kuhn: Do you have concerns about brain research in terms of how information we’re learning might in the future be misapplied? Terry Sejnowski: Tough question. There is danger. The knowledge that we’re going to have very soon with the techniques that we have developed for imaging and seeing into people’s brain could be used someday, perhaps in a society different from ours, to control human beings. Eric Courchesne: Sadly, just about every human technological development at some point or another has been used by someone for ill. Erin Schuman: Science at its core has a sort of blind, knowledge-is-good attitude. The conventional scientific ethic says that doing the experiment shouldn’t be questioned because it’s the sort of blind search for the truth. Eric Courchesne: There is no doubt that knowledge gleaned from brain science will be extraordinarily powerful, with much opportunity for malevolence. But at the same time technology has brought tremendous good for people. So the results of better technology is a balance between the two. Soma Mukhopadhyay (reading from Tito): better kinds of treatment.
I think that it will lead to the
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: Call the brain the most complex organization of matter in the cosmos. Just three-pounds of wet flesh can discern how the universe began while enjoying the music of Bach. Although we focused on the abnormal brains of the autistic, we learned a good deal about what it means to be ‘‘normal.’’ ‘‘Normal’’ brain function ‘‘feels’’ integrated and unified, but it’s the complex combination of deep process and systems working seamlessly together. It’s the architecture of brain structure, and the timing of brain function. It’s the signaling of numerous nerve cells, exotic fluxes of electrical fields, and flowing streams of countless chemicals. The microscopic choreography is a multi-level dance of exquisite intricacies and purposeful outputs. So what does all this mean? Understanding how the brain works explains what human beings are. . .and foretells what human beings may become.
58
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Interviews with Expert Participants Tito Mukhopadhyay Fourteen-year-old Tito Mukhopadhyay struggles daily with the challenges of severe autism. Though nearly non-verbal, Tito can communicate independently and is a prolific, talented, and published writer. For more information and writing samples, visit http://www.cureautismnow.org/tito/.
Terry Sejnowski What contact have you had with Tito? My encounter with Tito on Closer To Truth was the first time I had met him, and it really had an impact on my view of autism. Because although he had a very difficult time communicating with the world, and in staying fixed and focused, it was clear that through the work that his mother had done with him he had found a channel of communication that other autistic children do not have. And what made me change my mind about autism is the fact that I saw there may be locked behind this socially impenetrable wall a mind that is every bit the same as ours except that it just can’t get through. It can’t communicate, it has trouble focusing, it has trouble holding onto things. I’ve thought a good deal about what it was that Tito’s mother did for him, and how that impacted his brain so that he became as communicative as he is. Have you spoken with any colleagues about Tito? Recently, I had a conversation with Dr. Mike Merzenich from the University of California at San Francisco, and Mike has some very interesting ideas having to do with coherent activity in different parts of the brain and how plasticity—how changes in the organization of the brain—may be the underlying cause of conditions like autism. He’s also working on a way for these kids to interact with a computer in order for them to react to timing signals. He thinks it might be possible for these autistic children to create or improve their communications channels, starting first with the computer and then broadening that out to people. How do we represent information in the brain? Information can be represented in the brain in many different ways. For example, if a neuron fires several spikes of electrical activity, the information could be represented by the number of spikes within a period of time, but it also could be represented by the specific time at which each of the spikes actually occur. There is evidence that the timing might be important for
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
59
things like attention and it may be the ability to pay attention and to focus on a single sensory stimulus that is really at the heart of autism. And if we understood more about the temporal coding part of the brain we might be able to perhaps come up with a cure for autism. In your opinion, is temporal coding the main way the brain works? It’s very unlikely that temporal encoding is the main way that the brain works because of the fact that we know that sometimes it is present and sometimes it isn’t. Temporal coding seems to vary with your mood. It depends on what you’re focusing on. So to the extent that temporal coding is important, it’s going to be important for the higher level of processing rather than the basics like recognizing an object or being able to throw a baseball. Those basic things are probably based on rate coding. But things that have to do with your ability to think, for example, and be able to focus your attention, might be related to the time that the spike occurs—not just how many spikes that occur. Describe further ‘‘the binding problem.’’ There’s a controversy having to do with how information that belongs together stays together. For example, if you have a red cup, how do the redness of the cup and the shape of the cup become bound together? That’s called the binding problem. And there have been different solutions that have been suggested for it. In my view, I don’t think it’s a real problem. I think that the brain is quite capable of representing those properties by different groups of neurons firing at roughly the same time, but they may not necessarily have to fire their spikes at exactly the same time. Binding the information together is needed, but equally important may be enhancing or amplifying the information. What kind of brain imaging techniques are available? Functional magnetic resonance imaging has really opened up a whole new era in the study of human brains. For the first time, it is possible to study— non-invasively—activity occurring in different parts of the brain during unique human mental activities like language that cannot be studied in any other animal because we are the only animal that has the ability to communicate with language. What are the key developments in the field right now? My field of integrating theoretical ideas and computational models to study the brain is one of the newest areas of neuroscience.
60
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Portia Iversen Portia, your son Dov is autistic, and you and your husband, Jon Shestack, first brought Tito and Soma to the U.S. What have you learned from them? Many families and autism professionals have written asking about Tito, his mother Soma, our son Dov, and the new teaching method Soma has pioneered. This method is called the Rapid Prompting Method (RPM). We are working with Soma to produce a teaching manual for parents, teachers and professionals, which describes step-by-step how to implement this teaching method. And we very much agree with the basic assumption that how an autistic person acts on the outside is not necessarily a reflection of who they are and how they think on the inside. We would rather assume competence. The teaching method, which has met with some early success, and through which we now communicate with our son Dov, is not a cure for autism. That will require much more medical research, and we are working hard on that front every day. How can others learn Soma’s techniques? As parents we understand the sense of urgency that many of you feel in getting this method to your own child. Soma is working hard on getting a first draft of the RPM manual written, and we hope to have it available soon. See the Cure Autism Now (CAN) website for the latest information—http:// www.cureautismnow.org/index.jsp. Can this method be taught to teachers and used in classrooms? Yes. Do you think this could work for other autistic children? It is probable that many could learn to communicate better with this method. Can Soma work with my child? Not at this time, but the manual will help you get started. Are there any workshops available? Not yet, but there will be in the future. What kind of letter board does Soma use? She uses either an ABC or QWERTY (keyboard) configuration, depending on whether the child knows the alphabet or not. The letters are typed or
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
61
written on a piece of paper or cardboard. Eventually, she trains the child to work on a portable keyboard such as the Alphasmart. My child can talk—could this method still help him? There are many people with autism who are verbal, but tend to use language more as a ‘‘stimulant’’ than for communication. Soma is testing the method with verbal children whose speech is of limited use for communication. More will be known about this in the next year. Is there any scientific research on RPM? The study of this method is part of CAN’s larger Neuroplasticity Initiative, which is being led by Dr. Michael Merzenich. Dr. Merzenich is an international authority in the field of neuroplasticity and has pioneered important technology to help people with dyslexia, including the computer teaching method Fast ForWord. As we search for effective biological treatments and a cure for autism, CAN is also always looking for ideas that can make an impact for people with autism today. Our goal is to bring the cutting edge of technology to bear upon the communication problems with autism. This initiative is actively creating a new hybrid field, bringing together the wizards of technology and neuroscience along with experts on autism, therapists and people with autism themselves. What are the recent key developments in finding a cure for autism? The most exciting news in neuroscience in the last five years is the idea of neuroplasticity—the concept that the brain continues to grow and change throughout life. There have been amazing breakthroughs in the treatment of stroke and dyslexia through neural retraining. Using specialized education techniques, the brain is able to rewire around damaged or undeveloped areas and re-regulate the way it deals with sensory input. CAN’s Neuroplasticity Initiative would compile an integrated team of scientific leaders to focus on bringing these techniques to bear on autism to find ways to retrain the brains of people with autism—from the very young to adults and even to those most affected who in many instances are not able to speak at all. What type of research does CAN fund? Cure Autism Now funds genetics, environmental co-factors in autism, neuroplasticity and a large portfolio of basic biological research in autism. CAN also works to increase federal funding of autism research and was responsible for the recent funding of eight centers of excellence in autism research by the National Institute of Mental Health.
62
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Where are CAN chapters located? Cure Autism Now has volunteer chapters in Los Angeles and Orange County, California, Northern California, New Jersey, Baltimore/Washington D.C., Seattle, Philadelphia, and Chicago. Please check the CAN website—http://www.cureautismnow.org/index.jsp—for information on local activities. Can Soma and Tito travel and give presentations? Through the CAN website, we can give Soma your request. It is difficult for Tito to fly, and therefore, he travels infrequently. We are helping Soma create a video of Tito and some the children she has taught, so that she may give presentations herself. She will respond to your request as soon as possible. You, Tito, and Mike Merzenich, Ph.D., were on ’’60 Minutes 2’’ and ‘‘Good Morning America’’ in February, 2003. Any way to see that? Tapes can be ordered from CBS News. Please visit www.cbsnews.com and click on ’’60 Minutes 2.’’ In the Closer To Truth program, ‘‘How Does the Autistic Brain Work?’’ Tito’s descriptions are disturbing. Have other autistics described the experience? Tito’s descriptions of sensory stimulation match those of other people with autism. Gail Gillingham Wylie, M.Sc., an autism consultant and workshop presenter, and her husband Clay Wylie, have made the effort to collect these descriptions from a variety of sources and used them to create an ’’autistic perception’’ experience for people to try out. You can contact them at
[email protected]
Eric Courchesne What causes autism? There’s a wide range of speculations regarding what causes autism. But the huge difference between identical twins and fraternal twins in the likelihood that if one has autism so does the other—60 percent versus three to six percent— suggests a very strong influence of genetics. It also may well be that the genes that are involved in autism somehow place that individual at greater risk or more vulnerable to environmental events, like exposure to viruses or toxins. That’s a possibility that autism may be caused by a reaction to a virus or toxin.
How Does the Autistic Brain Work?
63
What developments would help us understand the causes of autism? Autism is a disorder in which children live a long, natural life. They don’t die, so you can’t look at the brain after they die. So how do you study it? More effective methods for neuroimaging are required, methods that allow imaging down to describing details of cortical areas and structure. That would be a key way to study the features in their brains when they are most flagrant—at the time the child is two or three. Whom do you most admire and why? Actually, right now the person I most admire is Terry Sejnowski. The reason is that he has a very positive, very proactive and energetic approach to science, his interests are wide-ranging, and he understands the excitement of many different areas of neuroscience. And it’s that emotional and psychological attitude, as well as that intellectual attitude, which allows him to integrate ideas across many domains; and that’s what’s needed when you study a developmental disorder like autism because developmental disorders are very complex.
Erin Schuman As someone who studies the brain in detail, what do you think, does the soul exist? I think differently from most of my scientific colleagues in that I save a place for the soul along with all things spiritual. So for me personally, not everything has to be explained by a molecule or an atom, and so I put the soul in the category of those mystical things that touch us in life that I do not think we have a molecular explanation for.
Chapter 5
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
The battle lines in modern psychiatry are drawn: Will biology replace psychology? Mental health is a significant international issue—increasing numbers of people have mental problems—yet psychiatry remains suspect as a science. On one side is the psychological approach: traditional psychiatrists and psychologists who use psychoanalysis, behavioral and cognitive therapies. On the other side is the biological approach: high-tech medical scientists, also called biomedical psychiatrists, who use mood-altering drugs, brain imaging, genetic testing. Psychiatry is said to have a ‘‘split personality.’’ But who defines mental illness? When and why do such definitions change? The treatment of mental illness has a long and unpleasant history, including looking for demons and relying on exorcisms, and the chaining and torturing of the mentally ill. Note psychiatry’s controversial history: beginning with hypnosis and Freud’s study of the unconscious, the development of psychoanalysis, and the various behavioral and cognitive therapies founded on psychological theories and confirmed by statistical data as well as anecdotal stories. Recently, psychiatry has become more integrated into the medical sciences, with the design and controlled studies of psychoactive drugs, CAT and PET imaging of brain diseases and abnormalities, and genetic studies of mental illness. Do these techniques take psychiatry out of the realm of philosophy and put it into the realm of science? And does this mean that traditional psychiatry will become progressively less important?
66
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Some approaches to psychiatry are clearly scientific, such as brain imaging and mood-improving drugs, and can be subjected to the scientific method of verification as are traditional medical procedures. Other approaches, such as behavioral and cognitive therapies, and even psychoanalysis, though less verifiable by the scientific method, seem essential in curing or ameliorating many mental problems. With cases of depression skyrocketing today in addition to the steady state of the more severe mental illnesses, both approaches seem critical for effective treatment. Nonetheless, from the standpoint of the scientific method, psychodynamic methods still require a higher standard of proof. In this chapter, a prominent biological psychiatrist and two psychologists debate the extent to which psychoanalysis, or ‘‘talk therapy,’’ has been supplanted by pharmaceutical solutions in treating most psychiatric problems, including depression and anxiety. All express concern about ignoring the benefits of talk therapy, especially at a time when depression is on the rise and has a 10 percent suicide rate. They also highlight the causes for this trend, from HMOs’ desire to keep treatment costs down to the pharmaceutical industry’s need to generate profits. The outlook is hopeful that new brain imaging techniques will lead to a greater understanding of mental illnesses, thus yielding more comprehensive, sophisticated, and effective therapies. Psychology Today’s Robert Epstein fears that treatments will descend into mere pill popping. Neuropsychiatrist/MacArthur fellow Dr. Nancy Andreasen, whose work centers around these new techniques (and whose seminal work on schizophrenia has redefined the field), is also one of the staunchest champions of traditional talk psychotherapy. ‘‘Young psychiatrists don’t learn how to interview and that is a real loss.’’ She recognizes that disorders of the human mind are not like diseases of the human kidney. Subtle physical variations—far below our detection capacity—can combine with intense psychological experiences to induce debilitating mental illnesses that can benefit from the insights and interventions of skilled clinicians as well as from drugs. And Peter Loewenberg, dean of the Southern California Psychoanalytic Institute, argues that Freudian-type analysis, updated, continues to provide insights obtainable in no other way.
Expert Participants Nancy Andreasen Professor of Psychiatry, University of Iowa College of Medicine; editor-inchief, American Journal of Psychiatry; author, The Broken Brain, Brave New Brain; National Medal of Science
Robert Epstein Former editor-in-chief, now West Coast editor, Psychology Today magazine; University Research Professor, Alliant International University
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
67
Peter Loewenberg Dean, Southern California Psychoanalytic Institute; Professor of History, University of California at Los Angeles
Nancy Andreasen: If we go back in history, people like Hippocrates conceptualized mental illnesses as physical in origin. The psychodynamic way of thinking is an add-on that only really began in the late 19th and early 20th century. Robert Kuhn: Let’s use, as a specific example, depression, a mental problem that affects millions. Peter Loewenberg: There isn’t a split today: the two approaches interact. Everyone knows what depression’s like: there are emotional causes and physical causes, and that big split, mind from body, originating 2,000 years ago with Plato, has now been closed. Robert Epstein: I don’t agree. You’re talking theory, but when it comes to treatment, there’s very definitely a split. For a while in America, after Freud, when psychologists and psychiatrists were the people you went to for depression, what you got was mainly talk. Now, for the same syndromes, you go to your HMO (Health Maintenance Organization) and you get a drug—no one talks to you. So, the psychological side of depression is very often ignored and, in fact, what you could call the biomedical side is all most professionals seem to care about. Nancy Andreasen: The picture is not as bad as you’re portraying it. For sure, people received psychological treatments before good drugs were available (beginning in the 1950s). In my training, I was taught to use psychotherapy for the more psychological or reactive depressions, and to use drugs for those more biologically based. Robert Kuhn: depression?
How could you distinguish a biological-based cause for
Nancy Andreasen: There are classic signs and symptoms that are more biologically based: loss of appetite, severe insomnia, variations in diurnal rhythm—in other words, fluctuations in mood according to time of day, which suggests that there’s something in the physical apparatus that isn’t working quite right, that is causing the mental problems. These kinds of depressions are the ones that tend to respond best to medications. Robert Epstein: I will insist that what people really have now is very limited benefits through an HMO, which might give them 10 psychotherapy
68
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
sessions a year, with each lasting perhaps 15 minutes. With a mental health professional, there’s a bookkeeper somewhere in the background who says, ‘‘No, this person needs to be on Prozac.’’ The are about a 135 million Americans who now get their mental health services through HMOs. Nancy Andreasen: You’re talking about economics—that’s not what psychiatry is and that’s not what psychiatrists would like to do to take care of their patients. Robert Epstein: ideal.
You’re not talking about reality; you’re talking about the
Peter Loewenberg: You’re also right about the training. About 50% of psychiatry residency programs do not train in psychotherapy anymore. Nancy Andreasen: I don’t think the statistic is that high. You can’t get Board Certified in psychiatry without having demonstrated that you’ve had training in psychotherapy. Peter Loewenberg: Young psychiatrists do not know how to talk to people; one cynical psychiatrist calls it ‘‘cocktail mixing’’—you put in a little of something this week and, if it doesn’t work, you change the cocktail next week and put in a little of something else. When you talk depression, and people have had a loss—a bereavement, a martial breakup, or a defeat at work—they need someone to talk to, they need a human relationship to work out what’s going on, what they contributed to it, and how they’re going to cope with it and adapt to it and do better next time. Nancy Andreasen: This is ironic for me because I’m a psychiatrist who was actually involved in the criteria for defining mental illnesses that are now being used to train people. And when you say that young psychiatrists don’t learn how to interview, I’m afraid that I often agree with that. The diagnostic and statistical manual lays out a set of criteria for every mental illness and, when we put them down, we thought, well, this will help standardize things, clarify, create reliability, but what’s in fact happened is that they’ve become canonized over the course of the last 20 years, so that psychiatrists think these are absolutes handed down from God. And young psychiatrists, being tested by the Board Certification systems, are expected to have memorized all these silly criteria. The result is that, increasingly, their interviews are limited to asking about the signs and symptoms in those criteria, and they don’t ask about the people. Every very time I start interviewing a patient I always ask them as human beings—where did you grow up, what did you study in school, what do you enjoy, and so on, and then I go on and talk about signs and symptoms. But most of our young psychiatrists aren’t trained this way, which is a real loss.
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
69
Robert Kuhn: When do mental problems pass from a quirk that all of us have to one degree or another to something that is a medical condition? Nancy Andreasen: When it gets to the place where the person has become extremely dysfunctional or is experiencing pain beyond what you would expect given the social setting, then it begins to move into a medical condition. And then we can move on to extreme examples, to severe psychotic depressions during which mothers, tragically, can kill their own children— one of the most horrible things one can imagine, a heartbreaking situation. Robert Kuhn: Is depression different when it is biologically based, such as a deficit in the brain’s chemical system, and when it is induced by some event, like the loss of a loved one or a problem at work? Robert Epstein: There are depressions we tend to call reactive depressions, which are clearly initiated by some incidents in one’s life. There are others that seem to come from nowhere; the latter are probably caused by something gone wrong in the brain. Robert Kuhn:
How widespread is depression today?
Robert Epstein: There are probably 20 million Americans who are clinically depressed. But only a small portion of these people are getting appropriate treatment; for men the situation is even worse because men tend not to seek treatment and tend to use destructive means for dealing with their depression. Nancy Andreasen: Even more frightening is that depression rates are increasing. If you track the rates of depression in younger people versus older people over time, the curves for people in the baby boom generation are going up so steeply that if you extrapolate them to the end, it looks as if everyone in that group is going to have a depression at some time in his or her life. It’s also important to realize that people think mental illnesses are not lethal, but, in fact, depression has a 10 percent suicide rate. Peter Loewenberg:
Adolescents are especially at risk for suicides.
Robert Kuhn: Why do we think that the baby boomer generation and younger people today have a greater incidence of depression? Nancy Andreasen: There are multiple explanations. For one, this group is not going to be able to achieve at the same level as their parents. There were so many of them that opportunities were limited. You get a Ph.D. and you won’t get a job because there are all those people who went before you who already filled all the jobs. Things are easing up now because the parent-level people have retired. Robert Kuhn: Tell us about the biomedical approach to depression, diagnostics, and treatment.
70
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Nancy Andreasen: If you’re just a very narrowly trained biomedical psychiatrist, often functioning within the context of an HMO, you won’t even get paid if you don’t prescribe a medication, and so the patient will be denied the right to psychological treatment. After a half-hour interview, the person is diagnosed with depression and a prescription is written. The patient might not be seen again for three weeks. That’s the bad parody of the biomedical model. Robert Epstein: I don’t think we should hide the fact that there are trends in mental health which are very dangerous. Take New Mexico, which became the first state in the country to give prescription privileges to psychologists who are not M.D.s. This is a trend that’s going to continue: in five to 10 years, psychologists are going to have prescription privileges, probably nationwide. Robert Kuhn: How do the numbers of psychologists in the United States compare with the number of psychiatrists? Robert Epstein: There are 150,000 psychologists, more than three times the number of psychiatrists (about 40,000). What’s happening is that drug companies are trying to expand their markets and they’re finding big ways to do it. We’re moving farther and farther away from social support and talking therapies, the people side of mental health, and more toward just giving someone a pill and hoping it will work. Robert Kuhn:
Should psychologists be allowed to prescribe drugs?
Peter Loewenberg: It depends how well trained they are, and do they know what they’re doing. Nancy Andreasen: I don’t agree. To prescribe drugs, a doctor must know much biochemistry, neuroanatomy, physiology, general medicine—so that it’s very risky for somebody who doesn’t have that extensive training to prescribe a drug that could interact with some other drug or that could affect some other illness that the person has. I train neuropsychologists and they don’t know biochemistry or pharmacology. Robert Epstein: The reality is that nothing is going to stop this trend. And that’s because of powerful economic forces, namely these multibillion dollar drug companies. Nancy Andreasen: There’s another force behind it, which is the pharmacists. The reason that bill passed in New Mexico was that the pharmacists got behind it. Robert Kuhn: Are we headed to a brave new world where everybody will be on drugs and perpetually euphoric?
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
71
Nancy Andreasen: That’s a huge concern. I see us drifting away from the kind of world in which I grew up where the most important thing was values, relationships with other people, seeking some higher purpose. Robert Epstein:
And obligations to the community.
Peter Loewenberg:
And responsibility.
Robert Epstein: There is a myth that has been sold to us that a faulty brain is behind our problems and, therefore, if we can just go in and fix the brain, we’ll be fine. Robert Kuhn:
They used to blame your mother.
Robert Epstein: Exactly, it used to be your mother; now they blame the brain. I think it’s nonsense and I think it’s wrong. Nancy Andreasen: I teach a course on, specifically, brain/mind relationships and, well, you’re exhibiting dualism. We have a lot of terminology that assumes the brain and the mind are different things, when, in fact, I don’t think they are. The brain and the mind are the same thing; they are different words for the same thing. We are our brains, I am my brain, my brain is a composite of the experience I’ve had my entire life. My brain is different from your brain because I’ve had different experiences, as well as a different genetic endowment. Robert Kuhn: I don’t think you need to believe in dualism to agree with Dr. Epstein that ‘‘blaming the brain’’ in terms of physiological or biochemical rationale for every problem that we have is reductionistic, overly simplistic, and philosophically naive. Robert Epstein: The public can misinterpret the science and assume that ‘‘my problem is actually my brain’s problem.’’ Nancy Andreasen: That’s a very simpleminded way to think because you’re the carrier of your brain. Robert Epstein: I understand; what you’re saying is very reasonable, but it’s also sophisticated, and the fact is that’s not the message the public is getting, that’s not the way everyday people are looking at this, and it’s not the message that’s being sold by certain large industries. The message that is being sold, if you are depressed or you are anxious, is that there is something wrong with your brain and we will fix it by selling you some drugs. Nancy Andreasen: You’re saying that experience affects the brain and I totally agree. On the other hand, it’s the brain that experience effects and the brain interacts with the world. Now, if you want to complain that many people are either being taught to think in a simple-minded way or are doing it naturally, I would agree with that, too. We shouldn’t be saying that you
72
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
have obsessive-compulsive disorder just because of a seratonin imbalance, or you have depression because of a norephinephrine imbalance. Robert Epstein: But that is the message that’s being sold! And people love that message because, and now we get to cultural values, in our culture, we want a quick fix, we want to pop a pill and we’re fine. I think this is wrong. I think we’re moving in the wrong direction when it comes to mental health. I was at the first-ever White House Conference on Mental Health, and during the entire conference only on one occasion did one speaker mention psychotherapy. The rest of it was all brain and drugs. The fact is that everything that happens to you changes your brain, including if you go through a year of psychotherapy. Robert Kuhn: Have there been any long-term studies comparing psychoanalytical, cognitive, or behavioral treatments to drug treatments? Robert Epstein: Some of the early studies seemed to indicate that various kinds of psychotherapy were not that effective, then we started finding some studies showing that psychotherapy is effective. We’re not very good yet at matching up particular clients or patients with particular therapists. If we could match better, we’d probably do much better in outcomes. Nancy Andreasen New studies using neuroimaging techniques show that placebos (inactive treatments that the patient thinks are real) have effects on the brain similar to those that are produced by real treatments such as drugs. Robert Kuhn: Placebos must trigger some kind of reaction that causes the brain, perhaps the hypothalamus, to secrete chemicals that are similar to those kinds of drugs. Nancy Andreasen: Most people would say placebos are inert substances, and so they will not have an effect on the brain. Placebos are inert substances, but because people have expectations as to what they’re going to do, their brains respond the same way as they would if they got an active substance. The fact that people are already doing those imaging studies of placebo effects shows that they’re thinking about the interactions between non-biological and biological interventions. Scientists are fascinated by this placebo reaction, and perhaps this means there is hope for getting more people to think in more sophisticated ways. Robert Kuhn: Could there come a time when sophisticated neuroimaging techniques would allow doctors to identify certain kinds of brains that would be more susceptible to different types of psychotherapeutic approaches? For example, if you had an obsessive-compulsive anxiety disorder, might advanced neuroimaging ever be able to suggest, say, cognitive therapy or behavioral therapy?
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
73
Nancy Andreasen: It’s definitely possible, but farther down the road. It’s like working with cancer or heart disease: first these technologies study the most serious mental illnesses, like Alzheimer’s disease or schizophrenia, and then manic-depressive illness, and then they move on down to the less serious illnesses. And the emphasis is on what are the mechanisms of this illness so that we can produce better treatments and prevention, so it’s really a matter of priorities in the use of these imaging tools. If I wanted to design a study looking at the effects of psychotherapy on the brain, I could probably finish it in two or three years and probably show something fairly conclusive. The wonderful thing about imaging research is that it lets you ask all kinds of questions. I have a friend who is studying what happens in the brain during forgiveness. We have done neuroimaging studies of the effects of medication on the brain and how that relates to the change of symptoms. Neuroimaging isn’t a treatment, it’s a way of understanding how the brain works that then can help us understand how treatments work. My goal in life relates to the one disease I’ve worked on most of my life, schizophrenia —not just to understand mechanisms for better treatment, but to ultimately figure out how to prevent it, because schizophrenia is a disease of adolescence, and it’s the most tragic disease because it strikes young people and takes away their creativity and thoughtfulness. I want to figure out what the developmental mechanisms were in the brain that caused that illness and figure out how to intervene so it doesn’t happen. Peter Loewenberg: The Boston studies on schizophrenia show that when there’s a job, family, home, social support, there’s a 44 to 68 percent improvement. Nancy Andreasen: I can’t say anything except I agree. Good treatment should not be subdivided into psychological and biological domains, they should very much be integrated. Robert Kuhn: two domains?
What are some of the ideological disruptions between the
Nancy Andreasen: On the one side, some neurological biologists are simple-minded reductionists who don’t understand the human spirit, and on the other side, those psychoanalysts who make up a bunch of theories that can’t be tested and waste an awful lot of time talking to people who could be treated much more quickly and effectively with drugs.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: Psychiatry does have a split personality, but psychiatry is not the problem. The problem is the human mind. Some mental illnesses are clearly biological: genetic testing can mark abnormalities, imaging can reveal brain lesions, and drugs can rebalance brain chemicals.
74
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
But disorders of the human mind are not like diseases of the human kidney. Subtle physical variations—far below our detection capacity—can combine with intense psychological experiences to induce debilitating mental illnesses. Psychology and biology are both needed, each targeting its own kind of mental problems or, for some diseases, working together in synergy. The deep secret anguish of mental illness can often benefit from insights and interventions of trained clinicians (even if these therapies are not as verifiable as traditional medicine), and from the latest technologies such as brain imaging and tailored drugs. Ideally, biomedical and psychodynamic methods can combine to yield optimum benefits. Psychiatry remains an Art as it becomes a Science.
Interviews with Expert Participants Nancy C. Andreasen What are key developments in your field? As I look at things right now, there are two levels of knowledge that are building very rapidly. The first level, in which I primarily work, is the application of technology of imaging tools to map the brain and thus observe the mind in action. How does the human mind focus its attention? How does it remember? How does it experience emotions and so on? The second is at the level of the cell or the molecule, advances in our understanding that are coming from genetics, genomics, and proteomics. These two levels are happening at the same time, usually by people who don’t interact with one another. They are two quite different disciplines with different training and methods, but it’s evident that the power of combining these levels—the very fine cellular or molecular level with the brain systems level—is going to break open tremendous knowledge. We have an exciting century ahead of us. Why did you become a scientist? I began my career as an English professor. I have Ph.D. in English Literature and became pregnant and developed a disease. I was on intravenous antibiotics for a week before returning to teaching, and that pivotal experience changed my life. Because having the Renaissance as my field in English Literature, I knew if this had happened to me 100 years earlier, I probably would have been dead. I spent the next summer contemplating, had my first book on John Donne accepted for publication, but instead of feeling elated, I felt
Does Psychiatry Have a Split Personality?
75
discouraged. And I said to myself, if I had taken the same amount of effort that I put into writing that book, and applied it a field like medicine, I might actually produce something that could benefit many people. So I decided to go to medical school and to have a career in research. And when I saw my first psychiatric patient, somebody with schizophrenia, the questions raised by what that person was experiencing were so intriguing that I was just hooked. What advice do you have for young people? Find something that you think is really important, that you care about passionately, and pursue that vigorously. It’s important to recognize that you’re going to have a lot of failures, and if you’re a gifted person you’re going to receive a lot of criticism. So you have to be willing to accept rejection over and over and to pick yourself up and persist even if people doubt you or turn down your papers. Persist and work hard.
Robert Epstein What are your feelings about drugs and mental illness? There is a lot of important research being done on the brain and on drugs, and that’s where a lot of the research money is going. But I am very concerned that what we’re learning in those areas is being misinterpreted and misapplied. The mental health field is moving in a very dangerous direction. How well do psychologists and psychiatrists work together? I don’t think there is unification. I don’t think that psychologists and psychotherapists—the non-medical mental health professionals—are working together well with the more medically-oriented psychiatrists. In fact, what I see is a slow but inexorable process of domination by the medical doctors over the more traditional mental health professionals. This is a very dangerous trend; it’s wrong, it’s hurting people, and it’s going to get worse.
Chapter 6
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
Health care is a vexing issue of public policy, and a serious matter of personal concern. Costs are rising; quality of care is falling. Modern medicine has become a silted sea of specialists, endless tests, government regulations, and, worst of all, insurance forms. The major killers—like heart disease and cancer—demand complex medical procedures, which are often painful, debilitating, humiliating, expensive, and uncertain. Throughout history, human beings have sought to prevent disease, cure illness, reduce pain, and relieve suffering. In recent times, science has made medicine more predictable—increasing success rates and identifying side effects, bringing sense and order to the chaotic practices of the past. But now some challenge scientific medicine with ‘‘alternative medicine.’’ Certainly, alternative medicine makes remarkable claims. Certainly, billions of dollars are being spent in America alone. Certainly, millions of people are believers, and utilization of alternative medicine is growing. When we investigate, what do we find? Visionary horizons of healing? Or continuing approval of quackery? Some say that traditional scientific medicine has now become the new dogma, and the medical establishment has become the new priesthood. Do medical authorities deny different kinds of treatment to maintain their own control? Do high-cost, orthodox doctors thwart low-cost, innovative competitors? Are there alternative, non-traditional methods of curing and healing? On the other hand, is alternative medicine a colossal con game, a world of weirdos, charlatans, and quacks, out to separate us from our money, while providing little but false hope?
78
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
How to define Alternative Medicine? Therapies, treatments, practices, and procedures which share three common features: 1) they have not been demonstrated within the United States that they are safe and effective against specific diseases and conditions; 2) they are not taught in medical schools; and 3) they are generally not reimbursable by insurance. The challenges to scientific medicine have accelerated in the past 30 years, and in this chapter, the challenged (the traditional medical doctors) give the challengers (the alternative medicine providers) one tough time. As two advocates for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) square off with two defending traditionally trained medical doctors, their stronglyfelt disagreements center on a question of proof: how do you tell what works and what does not? All bemoan the disturbing number of bogus therapies being peddled on the Internet to desperate people, the lack of safe manufacturing for many alternative medicines, and the instances where certain natural approaches cause real harm. Yet the two sides argue fiercely about the efficacy and dangers of CAM and remain adamantly opposed over whether or not CAM can ever do any good; even the issue of licensing for CAM practitioners becomes a point of contention as they debate what guidelines should be used to determine who would qualify. For CAM’s critics, most alternative medicine is at best ‘‘self-delusion’’ foisted on a gullible public with misleading advertising and misguided legislation by Congress. Three of the guests can see both sides of the issue to various degrees. Only retired physician Wallace Sampson, editor in chief, The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine, sees the field in black and white—‘‘What we’re dealing with in most of alternative medicine is self-delusion.’’ His points are cogent: how can standardization occur when naturopathic remedies are effected by such things as growing conditions, time of harvest, and length of storage? Dan Labriola, a naturopathic physician who specializes in cancer and heart diseases actually concurs: what CAM company has ever publicized the proven fact that certain antioxidants prevent chemotherapy from killing tumor cells? For its advocates, CAM holds the key to a better understanding of the ‘‘mind-body continuum’’ and more effective treatment for a wide range of disorders. As alternative practitioner Hyla Cass—an M.D. who practices integrative medicine, which she calls the ‘‘best of both worlds’’—says, ‘‘12 medical schools, including Duke, Columbia, and Harvard, have incorporated CAM programs, and I want to see more of that.’’
Expert Participants Hyla Cass Psychiatrist; assistant clinical professor of psychiatry, UCLA School of Medicine; author, Natural Highs, Kava, St. John’s Wort, All About Herbs
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
79
William Jarvis Professor of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, School of Medicine, Loma Linda University; past president, National Council Against Health Fraud; leading critic of alternative medicine; author, Reader’s Guide to ‘‘Alternative’’ Health Methods
Dan Labriola Naturopathic physician and researcher; author,Complementary Cancer Therapies. Combining Traditional and Alternative Approaches
Wallace Sampson Clinical professor of medicine (retired), Stanford University School of Medicine; editor in chief, The Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine; Leading critic of alternative medicine
Robert Kuhn: Let’s begin with definition: what is alternative and complementary medicine? Dan Labriola: This is a subject of some debate, and there are a number of definitions. The one that seems to be accepted defines alternative medicine as everything that is not traditionally taught in conventional medical schools—which is, in my opinion, a very unfair definition because it includes well-trained, well regulated people like myself, naturopathic physicians in good regulatory districts like the state of Washington, and it also includes the people on the Internet who are making outrageous claims and doing a great deal of harm. Wallace Sampson: We use a different definition: Alternative medicine are methods and materials that do not work, methods and materials that are not likely to work, and methods and materials that already have been investigated and found to be debatable. William Jarvis: I go along with the NIH (National Institutes of Health) definition, which basically says everything outside of standard medicine— treatments, drugs, procedures that have not been shown to be safe and efficacious by modern medical standards. Hyla Cass: I’m rather surprised to hear your definition as everything that is not taught in medical school and is unproved. Wallace Sampson: No, I didn’t say not taught in medical schools; I said methods that are unproved or disproved. Hyla Cass: So are you saying that acupuncture would not be considered a complementary and alternative medicine?
80
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Wallace Sampson: disproved.
Acupuncture is unproved, and it probably is already
Hyla Cass: You are wrong. There is a very good body of research showing that acupuncture, homeopathy, and many other mind/body modalities have been shown to be very successful. Wallace Sampson: Well, we’re right into the heart of the argument then. What physicians do is that we take out appendices, we repair fractures, we cure some cancers. Naturopathy cannot do that. For instance in many people you can’t heal strep throat without treatment; what a physician can do is prescribe penicillin and keep nephritis and rheumatic fever from occurring. Now that’s what we do. Hyla Cass: I went to medical school, got my M.D. degree, and then spent four years in a psychiatric residency. I did a rotating internship where I delivered babies, did surgery, and did regular medicine. I was well prepared to look at the whole mind/body continuum. I practice integrative medicine; I use the best of both. If I have to write a prescription, I’ll write a prescription, no problem. But I’d much rather use something that, first of all, does no harm, that’s as natural as possible, and that it actually addresses the basic problem at the root of the superficial symptom. If the root of the problem is low blood sugar, let’s treat that; if it’s a B12 deficiency, let’s treat that. William Jarvis: I quibble with the definition of integrative medicine that Andrew Weil has put forth. He calls it the best from standard medicine and the best from alternative medicine. Well, how do you know what’s best until you have tested it, until you have put it through the rigor of science— then and only then do you know if it’s best or not. As a matter of fact, the, the product base from which alternative medical products come has poor manufacturing standards; half the time you don’t know what you’re even getting. So you find yourself in a situation, even if it is a product like acupuncture that has some real scientific progress, you really don’t know what it is—so how can you call it medicine? Hyla Cass: It’s very important to have standards, to have good manufacturing practices, and the industry is certainly trying to enforce that. The Natural Nutritional Food Association is trying to set up good manufacturing practices such as getting a certificate of analysis from every batch. William Jarvis: Dan Labriola:
They’ve been working on it for ten years! It’s a failure in government to protect the public interest.
Wallace Sampson: In science, such as physics and chemistry, if a particular method can’t be reproduced uniformly, then chances are that any positive results in experiments are wrong, because once something is shown to work
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
81
in one laboratory, one of the hallmarks of science is that any laboratory should be able to reproduce that. Dan Labriola: Looking at my profession, naturopathic medicine, especially in the jurisdictions where we are not licensed, there is literally no governing body that is responsible for what is being done in alternative and complementary medicine. Any fool walking along the street can, for 65 dollars, call himself a naturopath and begin practicing on the public. The only public protection that occurs is when someone like Dr. Jarvis here says, wait a minute, maybe you shouldn’t be doing that, maybe that treatment is going to hurt you. We’ve had patients die in Washington State who were treated incorrectly with natural medicine. The failure is really in government for not doing what it should be doing. As Hyla said, the National Nutritional Food Association has worked very hard to put in some analysis criteria, so that what’s on the label is really in the bottle, and that the claims that are being made are fair and reasonable claims. We can debate these claims, but at least there’s some rationality going into it. Robert Kuhn:
What is integrative medicine?
Hyla Cass: By integrative medicine, I do good clinical medicine, and I look for actual physiological or chemical imbalances in people, based on their diet or lifestyle, for which I found that I could do some very simple interventions by using alternative medical techniques. What is important is the patient, and I know you can say that our success is anecdotal, but many of us practicing what I say is good integrative medicine have such success with our patients. Robert Kuhn:
What kind of patients are we talking about?
Hyla Cass: Some cases of Alzheimer’s are in fact people who are low in vitamin B12. I give them a simple blood test and find they have what is called macrocytic anemia, and I give them a B-12 shot along with folic acid because they are not absorbing B-12 properly, and their so-called Alzheimer’s or degenerative disease suddenly disappears. Robert Kuhn: Do we really know they really had Alzheimer’s, or just symptoms that seemed like Alzheimer’s? Hyla Cass:
Exactly; this is what I’m saying—mistaken diagnosis.
Wallace Sampson: What this comes down to is this: what is the definition of what you are talking about? In the first place, these people do not have Alzheimer’s disease; they have degenerative brain disease, combined with B12 deficiency. But this was discovered not by alternative medicine but by hematologists and neurologists doing appropriate research. This was discovered 30 or 40 years ago through scientific medicine; this is not alternative medicine.
82
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Hyla Cass:
It’s integrative medicine; that’s exactly what I’m telling you.
Wallace Sampson: If you’re going to call integrative medicine just using things that work like oil of cloves on your gum, or ear, or Peppermint, or whatever else that we’ve used for thousands of years, that’s fine. Hyla Cass:
We are not in disagreement.
Wallace Sampson: Oh yes we are! We are surely in disagreement because you have taken something that is scientific medicine and called it alternative medicine. Hyla Cass: Excuse me! I said I am practicing integrative medicine while I am practicing plain old good scientific medicine. Wallace Sampson: Integrative medicine implies that you’ve taken something from some other place and integrated it with scientific medicine, and I’m telling you that that is not what is going on. Dan Labriola: I think the problem is that Wallace has a unique definition of alternative medicine. In his view, if a treatment doesn’t work, it’s alternative medicine, but as soon as we discover that it does work, it’s his kind of medicine. The presumption is that everything that we do in complementary and alternative medicine doesn’t work; that’s the presumption of his definition. Wallace Sampson:
That is the correct definition.
Hyla Cass: If a six-year-old child comes to see me with ADD (Attention Deficit Disorder) and he is already on Ritalin, Prozac, and other drugs, that’s terrible. I want to see what that child is eating, does he have any food allergies, does he have a high level of mercury or lead in his blood, and I do tests to make those assessments. Is that scientific? I’d say so. Did the regular doctors test for that? No, they didn’t. So I check for those heavy metals, and if present, I will use certain treatments, very safe treatments for getting rid of those heavy metals. I’ll put the child on a diet: instead of eating sugary sweets and soda pop, he is going to get a good diet that supplies enough protein and complex carbohydrates with fruits and vegetables and some vitamins to help reverse the ADD. William Jarvis: That’s right. When you get the mother to start preparing better foods, to start organizing better diets for the child, the mother stops blaming the child for everything it does and blames the previous bad diet, then there’s a whole release of tension between the mother and the child, there’s a whole new set of behaviors that take place in the home, and all of these build towards a more positive experience. Robert Kuhn:
That sounds good to me.
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
83
William Jarvis: That’s right, it is a good thing. But when scientists want to tease out what are the factors that produce the positive results, they have to be careful in making claims since there are so many factors running loose here. Hyla Cass: I’ve had very good results with such children. Occasionally I will continue to use a low dose of the drugs along with the dietary changes, a much lower dose of the medication. So I am grateful to have medication when I need it. But what I do have a problem with is doctors prescribing drugs aggressively. This is a problem with medical education, it’s a problem with post-medical school education where the doctors are basically being manipulated by the pharmaceutical industry. The research is paid for by the pharmaceutical industry; the journals are supported by the pharmaceutical industry. There have been some problems with authors of papers not fully disclosing their financial connections with the pharmaceutical companies, that they were being paid a lot of money to write a particular research paper. A negative paper doesn’t get published, so if a researcher wants to get published, they better get positive results. Robert Kuhn: It’s an industry with economic power that’s highly politicized, affecting all aspects of health care. William Jarvis: But it also has a lot of popular support, and that’s ultimately what it comes down. When the 1994 Dietary Supplements Health & Education Act passed, which was a terrible setback for consumer protection, every United States senator voted for it; there was not one single dissenting vote. Robert Kuhn: People get very emotional about alternative medicine, because it’s your body. William Jarvis: This is where there’s a very powerful sort of self-care factor among the mass public, and the politicians have a hard time confronting that. Everyone wants labels to be accurate, advertising to be truthful, products to be safe and effective. All people will answer yes to those issues, but you can sell a cancer patient anything if they think it’s going to help. For example, there’s been tremendous promotion in the marketplace for antioxidants, and Dan was one of the first guys to point out that all these antioxidant supplements that people are buying may not be the best thing for certain cancer patients. Dan Labriola: I published a scientific paper in Oncology, which is a prestigious journal, where my co-author, Dr. Robert Livingston from the University of Washington, and I looked carefully at the existing human studies and determined that there is a very good possibility that if you combine antioxidants—Vitamin A, B6, C, E, zinc, selenium—with certain categories of chemotherapy, what you can do is actually prevent the chemotherapy from
84
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
killing tumor cells. That doesn’t mean there isn’t a time and place for antioxidants. Bill Jarvis is right: there is a whole cottage industry out there saying, ‘‘use all these antioxidants during chemotherapy, you’ll have less side effects.’’ It’s true, you will feel better, because you are actually reducing the dosage of the drug, you are reducing the effectiveness of the chemotherapy in stopping the cancer. And so even though you may feel better, you may have a remarkably worse result and you’d never know it. Robert Kuhn: medicine? William Jarvis: Robert Kuhn:
How much money is estimated to be spent on alternative Tens of billions of dollars every year. This is a gigantic industry.
Wallace Sampson: In the United States, 60,000 chiropractors each make several hundred thousand dollars a year. Do the multiplication! William Jarvis: Congress has given the alternative medicine pill makers a license to steal, and now the pharmaceutical companies have joined them; they have their own supplement subdivisions—they are all in on the party making a fortune. We must force alternative medicine to meet the same standards that every other medication has to meet, get back to truth in advertising that doesn’t allow wild claims. Wallace Sampson: The problem is that alternative medicines are unpredictable; their quality depends on the time of harvest, the growing conditions, the length of storage, and so forth. These are uncontrollable, and almost every study that’s been done, except on purified materials such as glucosamine, have shown such wide variations of concentrations, you don’t know what you’re giving. William Jarvis: And every marketing survey shows that although there is a small cadre of people who are very health conscious (almost to the point of neurosis), 80 percent of the market out is purely pragmatic—they buy alternative medicines because they hear about it. It’s strictly a trial and error thing driven by the market claims that are usually exaggerated or outright wrong. Dan Labriola: There was a group of homeopaths who promoted the use of homeopathic immunization as opposed to conventional immunizations for childhood diseases and other things. I’m the principal author of the law in the State of Washington to bar such practices, because every study that’s ever been done has shown that homeopathic immunization simply don’t work. Robert Kuhn: But when any kind of vaccines, especially ‘‘alternative’’ ones, don’t work, we have an affirmative responsibility as a society to protect those children whose parents may think it works.
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
85
Dan Labriola:
Precisely.
Robert Kuhn:
Dan, what are some other specific treatments that you do?
Dan Labriola: My practice is mainly cancer, heart disease, and neurological diseases. For cancer patients I have found that acupuncture is often useful for the control of nausea and vomiting resulting from chemotherapy. I think we need to look carefully at the criteria for repeatability that Dr. Sampson was talking about, but there’s a factor that we didn’t talk about, namely, who is doing the test? Oftentimes you have researchers who are investigating some of these treatments who really don’t know anything about them, and as a result some of the negative studies may be the result of poor investigational design. It’s interesting that Bastyr University just got a $1.1 million grant from the National Institutes of Health to train scientists in how to do rational investigations of complementary and alternative medicine therapies. William Jarvis: When I read the Chinese medicine literature, every study seems to come out positive. Could this be because these treatments are the only modality that they offer? I don’t think that acupuncture qualifies as alternative medicine because it is now found in so many pain control centers around the country. At Loma Linda, which is a very conservative Christian medical university, we’ve had acupuncture in our pain control clinic since the early 1970s. Robert Kuhn:
Do you agree with that?
William Jarvis: Sure. Even though I am a skeptic about alternative medicine in general, I think that in the control of pain, which is very subjective, very individualistic, what works should be used. If the pain control is a result of, say, operant conditioning in that person, or part of their belief system, as long as it works for them, it is fine. In a pain control setting, your goal as a physician is to help each individual patient; your goals are not scientific, your goals are clinical, so you do whatever works. Hyla Cass: When they do acupuncture on horses, it also works, and, in horses, I don’t think operant conditioning is the reason. If you take a horse that’s lame, put the needle in the right spot, that horse can begin to walk and run and do what horses do. Placebos don’t work in horses. William Jarvis: I have never seen a horse immediately able to run after such treatments. What I have seen is that human beings evaluate whether the horse is feeling better or not. And so the result may be in the observer not in the horse. There is a great deal of subjectivity going on when it comes to the evaluations of the outcomes of veterinary acupuncture. Wallace Sampson: This is a place where really honest disagreement can occur. I’m not two-sided about this because I don’t think there is a role for
86
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
acupuncture in a medical clinic, although, frankly, at one time I did. I thought that acupuncture was in sort of a transition zone between scientific medicine, on the one hand and human subjectivity on the other, and that acupuncture might have some role. But now I don’t think that acupuncture works because there is so much myth about it, that even physicians, when they use it, misinform themselves about what they’re doing, and this is where I think the danger is. I don’t mind using placebos in some instances, but the physician must know that it’s a placebo and should not fool himself about what he is doing. Robert Kuhn:
Of course that would make it a better placebo!
Wallace Sampson: You are right, it would make it a better placebo, but the point I’m trying to make here is that there is danger when physicians and administrators in hospitals are so misinformed that they don’t know what they are doing, because medicine is built on objective results. Robert Kuhn: This brings up is the whole issue of what is scientific rigor in medicine? What are the standards by which new products or procedures are accepted into the medical community? Putting aside all definitions, if some alternative procedure to treat, say, prostate cancer can be proven to work, Wallace would be the first to accept that. If other research shows that antioxidants will diminish the effect of chemotherapy and therefore be detrimental, Wallace will also applaud that. So, how do we get everyone to work together in a scientific procedure, so that 20 years from today, we will have made progress? Dan Labriola: I think the first and most important thing is to provide licensing procedures for alternative medicine practitioners who are professionally trained in the use of these substances, like naturopathic physicians. William Jarvis: I’m concerned about the standards of conduct. Now I know Dan well and I trust Dan because he was a scientist before he was a naturopath. But I know a lot of naturopaths who are not scientists and never will be because they are ideologists: naturopathy is their religion, and Dan is not representative. Robert Kuhn:
Health can quickly become a religion.
Wallace Sampson: I have a simple answer for you. For the past 20 years, nothing has happened. And the reason is, as Bill Jarvis says, we are human beings, we’re faulty, we make mistakes, we believe in things that aren’t true, we fool ourselves, and each generation is going to do the same thing. And all I hope is that people can apply critical thinking in evaluating alternative medicine so that we can catch our own mistakes, our own errors, our own faulty way of thinking.
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
87
Dan Labriola: If we want to look at bringing more of these alternative therapies to the forefront, I think the way to do it is, rather than saying, okay let’s just find medical doctors and we’ll give them a few more months of training and let them loose on the public, why not concentrate on the providers who are already trained to prescribe alternative medicine properly? If there’s something you don’t like about the way they’re regulated or trained, deal with it, there’s a whole process to deal with it, but do not just outlaw it. Wallace Sampson: fooling yourself. Hyla Cass:
Alternative medicine ‘‘works’’ only because you are
So are all of us idiots?
Wallace Sampson: Error is error. Delusion is delusion. And what we’re dealing with in alternative medicine is self-delusion, because an observer on the outside looking at what these people are doing can only conclude that it is error dominated. Hyla Cass: I am very proud to say, as a physician, that 12 medical schools, including Duke, Columbia, and Harvard, have incorporated complementary and alternative medicine programs, and I want to see more of it.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: What’s the verdict on alternative medicine? Is alternative medicine science? It’s easy to ridicule alternative medicine . . .until you’re really sick. These unorthodox methods of treating disease carry astonishing claims of healing and prevention. But beware: weak science and big business make a treacherous combination. Many alternative medical practices are ineffective at best, dangerous at worst. Many, but not all. Some alternative methods may be effective and safe—e.g. stress management techniques, some dietary supplements, and acupuncture for certain problems. How to sift the wheat from the chaff ? I don’t like compromise, but with alternative medicine I’m conflicted. Anecdotal cases are intriguing, but only by conducting rigorous, doubleblind clinical trials—only by playing by the tough rules of scientific skepticism—can we discern truth. My advice? Don’t be an uncontrolled experiment. Never test the bizarre on your own body. The best cure is prevention—eat well, exercise, rest, be serene. What’s your report card? Here’s mine: good on the food, excellent on the exercise, mediocre on the rest. . .but lousy on the serenity—there’s lots of stress writing this book at night while being an investment banker during the day!
88
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Interviews With Expert Participants William Jarvis What does a consumer health specialist do? Health education is my specialty and we basically deal with health behavior: why people do what they do, and particularly, why people believe in things that science can’t verify. I look at consumer health from the viewpoint of the marketplace because, after all, most of our health behavior can be expressed by what we buy and what we don’t buy. Would you like to see standard and alternative medicine peacefully co-exist? Obviously, scientific, evidence-based medicine is the core of our modern healthcare system. The question is, should we also allow for traditional medicines like Chinese acupuncture, Ayurvedic cures, maybe American Indian medicine—something that has a long tradition of use, which people do because it’s part of their culture even though there is no science behind it. I say, ‘‘No!’’ but what we really should have, because we can do it, is the science of the possible. There ought to be a standard for evaluating new products and services. If something from alternative medicine can be proven safe and effective for a special purpose, it becomes part of standard medicine. I don’t think we really have room for pluralism in medicine like we have pluralism in religion and in politics. Religion and politics are arenas for opinions; medicine and healthcare are not. Claims of alternative medicine must be evaluated by the scientific method. To fail to do this is to fail to live up to the best human standards.
Wallace Sampson What’s your definition of alternative medicine? At Stanford, we’ve had a definition of alternative medicine for 20 years. We define alternative medicine as: 1) methods that are not likely to work; 2) methods that do not work; and 3) methods that are yet to be proved to work (methods that might work but we don’t yet know if they ever will). What’s the future of alternative medicine? I don’t use the term ‘‘alternative medicine’’ (unless I am answering a question) because these are collections of what I call ‘‘sectarian systems,’’ which are methods that are not scientific but have ideological or cultural bases. All so-called ‘‘alternative medicine’’ has not been proven to work or has already been proven not to work or is not likely to work. The future for these
Who Gets to Validate Alternative Medicine?
89
sectarian systems and anomalous methods is that most will eventually disappear, which will be a good thing for the public good. Alternative medicine consists of diverse and anomalous methods that people think up and invent for themselves and then try to impose on the public. Eventually most of them will be disproven, but many will still have a following because different kinds of people like to believe in different kinds of things.
Dan Labriola What are the key developments in your field? We are now giving more attention to the natural and traditional kinds of treatments that are available and have been known to work for many years, but they have never been given the opportunity to be tested under rigorous scientific criteria. That is a big change. And that’s how we discovered penicillin. Most of the major drugs that have been successfully developed over the last century were discovered as a result of anecdotal use that was repeated by providers who were competent and reliable. Does the public understand anecdotal methods of care? No, the public does not understand it at all. The definitions of what is scientific and what is not scientific are often mixed. Information on, and evidence of, treatment effectiveness is terribly variable and not presented properly to the public. We do not need to have an exhaustive scientific study to know that something works, but we do need to have accurate information and reliable evidence.
Chapter 7
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
Will we ever beat the microbes? Many people think we already have. They couldn’t be more wrong. But the dangers of infectious disease may be more widespread than ever imagined. And the supposed ‘‘cures’’ may actually make the problems worse. Many bacteria become resistant to our antibiotics. Viruses evolve with blinding speed. Prions may lurk in our meat. Anthrax is put into our mail. Healthcare today is better today than any time in history. We’ve had great successes; significantly against the smallpox virus, partially against the AIDS virus. But as diverse diseases (like tuberculosis) evolve resistance to treatment, as new diseases migrate out of the third-world countries and spread rapidly, and as terrorists begin biowarfare, we have to ask: will our precious health last? And what about the third world, where the scourge of disease exacts a terrible human toll? What’s the best way of fighting communicable disease in the long run? Will genetic engineering play a part? Are there any technological breakthroughs ahead? And can supposed ‘‘cures’’ actually can make the problem worse? Stranger yet, could microbes be causing other illnesses, like various cancers? We discuss radical ideas about microorganisms and human health. Disease-causing microbes are a serious issue, surely for human wellbeing and perhaps for our literal survival. There are dangers of inadvertently stimulating drug-resistant microbes and there are suspicions that microbes may cause a broader range of diseases. We should pay increased attention to microbiology and support an intense program of mapping and analyzing microbial genomes. In this chapter, four distinguished biologists examine the multitude of unseen bacteria and viruses that inhabit every part of the globe, as well as
92
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
the distinct and fascinating differences between ‘‘good’’ and ‘‘bad’’ microbes. On one hand, microbes are essential to life—a crucial element of our digestive system—and in the future may be utilized to treat many diseases. On the other hand, the deadly power of microbes is made all too real with the frightening threat of biowarfare and, worse, bioterrorism. Our experts emphasize that the key to understanding microbes is their amazing evolutionary potential, which is expressed in their capacity to change properties quickly, particularly their building up immunities to antibiotics. Our expert biologists also describe how microbes can cause certain kinds of cancer and may even be the culprits behind a wide range of human afflictions from Alzheimer’s Disease to neurological disorders.
Expert Participants Agnes Day Professor, Department of Microbiology and Immunology, College of Medicine, Howard University
Paul Ewald Professor of Evolutionary Biology, University of Louisville; author, Evolution of Infectious Disease and Plague Time
Alice Huang Senior Councilor for External Relations, Associate in Biology, California Institute of Technology; former Dean of Science, New York University
Lucy Shapiro Professor of Developmental Biology and Genetics; Director, Beckman Center for Molecular and Genetic Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine
Lucy Shapiro: After World War II, when we built up our whole arsenal of incredible antibiotics, we also built up a sense of security that we were able to deal with all manner of infectious bacteria that were, heretofore, killing off lots of people. Suddenly, it seemed, we had a way of dealing with disease, and it was remarkable. And we didn’t pay attention to the fact that, even as early as the 1950s, antibiotic resistance was building and building and building, because we didn’t have the ability to understand how clever these bugs are. And now we’re in full trouble. There isn’t a single antibiotic now that some bug isn’t resistant to. Agnes Day: We’ve gotten our wake-up call: indiscriminate use of antibiotics has led to this situation.
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
Robert Kuhn:
93
How come these bugs are so ‘‘smart’’?
Paul Ewald: They have a great evolutionary potential, they have very short generation time, they have high mutation rates, but most important is the vast number of these microbes. So, when you use an antibiotic you can knock down the microbe population by 99.99%. If you just have one in 10,000 or one in 100,000 microbes that’s a bit resistant, that becomes the microbe of the future. Agnes Day: Microbes reproduce in about 22 minutes, if you’re talking about E. coli. Microbe resistance is the recapitulation of Darwin’s theory of survival of the fittest. If you have the capacity to be resistant, then you are going to be the population that survives, while all the sensitive ones die off. If you look at a single-celled microbe and its environment changes, it figuratively ‘‘knows’’ that it has 22 minutes to change or die. In a sense it’s a form of collective intelligence that they can mutate or change to protect the species and survive by giving rise to a whole new species. Robert Kuhn It sounds like we’ve gotten into an arms race that we cannot possibly get out of. Alice Huang: We are always discovering new antibiotics. Every time we go into the soil and isolate new bacteria that we haven’t seen before, we find that they make antibiotics against other bacteria. Lucy Shapiro: Through genetic engineering we can actually take these cells apart as though we are systems engineers, and we can design double-headed antibiotics, that not only knock out the target but knock out the mechanism for drug resistance. The additional knowledge we have now is allowing us to design things in such a way to keep up with the way these bugs can evolve and change. Alice Huang: Newer antibiotics, the peptide antibiotics, can drill through the membrane of the bacteria—this is a whole new class that offers us some hope. Paul Ewald: A more general way of approaching this problem is to change the environment so that you favor the milder organisms. You can make vaccines in ways that favor the mild organisms, by selectively knocking out the harmful organisms Robert Kuhn:
You’re artificially selecting for the less virulent strain.
Paul Ewald: Well, if you favor milder strains of organisms, let’s say, an organism like the one that causes cholera, this means that instead of having half or three-quarters of the people showing severe infection, you may have only one percent, of the people who are infected showing symptoms of disease.
94
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Lucy Shapiro: But anyone in the world can get on a plane and be in Chicago in 17 hours. And they can travel asymptomatically. When you’re taking pathogens and putting them in completely different environments than they’re used to, and then they very rapidly evolve, there is great potential for deadly trouble. Paul Ewald: Take a look at what happens when we get these nasty strains, for example, diarrheal diseases, imported in the United States. The studies suggest that, when these nasty strains get in the United States where we have protection against waterborne transmission, they can’t make it, they die out. So, for example, a horrible outbreak of dysentery occurred in the early 1970s in Latin America, killing thousands, but when it got into Los Angeles, where the water supplies were protected, the number of new infections was about one-half, which means it just died out on its own, even without any controlled measures. Even though we live in a global village, if we adjust the infrastructure so that we disfavor the harmful strains, that’s an extra layer of protection. Lucy Shapiro: But what happens with antibiotic resistance when we all get panicked, like what happened with the mailed anthrax attacks after 9/11? The worst outcome of this particular anthrax attack, which killed a very few people, was the enormous collateral damage. It disrupted our entire way of living and thinking; we had 24/7 barrage on TV. But the real villain was the indiscriminate use of the antibiotic drug Cipro, which caused an increase in resistance to the drug. Several years ago, there was a big chicken flu scare, and so much Cipro was used in zillions of chickens, that although it managed to bring down the chicken infection epidemic, the resistance to Cipro went from almost nothing to about 15%. We’re going to make Cipro useless, and that was the big danger of this very mild attack with anthrax. Agnes Day: Cipro is not only active against anthrax, but also about 30 or 40 different bacteria. Once you give Cipro prophylactically to people who may have been exposed to anthrax, you’re also killing off those friendly microbes and other microbes that are living in your gut that you wanted to keep. It’s called microbial antagonism, where you want to keep the good guys and the bad guys sort of equal. Lucy Shapiro: The same things that have to be done to protect our populations from infectious disease are going to help us understand how to deal with bioterrorist threats. It’s tremendously important that we understand how bacteria can evolve and change and, at the same time, the knowledge that we acquire can be applied to how to deal very rapidly with both natural infectious disease and bioterrorism. Alice Huang: When we study bacteria in the laboratory, we often look at them as single-cell animals, whereas in nature they actually exist in
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
95
communities, in very complex communities. And there are rules in that community, so that no one organism takes over. In fact, they need each other; sometimes some bacteria will provide food for another organism and vice versa. As we understand these situations, we also begin to realize that there are many microbes that are very good, microbes that we actually need that are very useful. In our own gut, we find that there’s a nice mixture of microbes and generally, if we disturb them, if that balance is not correct, all sorts of terrible things happen. If you live on a farm, you know that cows are known to pass gas a great deal, and the reason that they do so is because they have a methane creating bacteria which does this. Now, one third of the human population has the same bacteria, predominantly in their gut. And so those are the friends that you sort of want to avoid. But two-thirds of humans have a different kind of bacteria, so each of our guts are actually quite different from the other. Lucy Shapiro: There’s an incredible story about a good bacterium that lives inside what’s called an eyespot on a squid that lives in very shallow waters off Hawaii, and this bacterium radiates photons, so it causes light to be generated. It radiates at night, and what it does is to protect this squid from predators because when there’s a full moon shining and you’ve got this squid in shallow water, the light turns on and obliterates the shadow, and so the squid becomes invisible to predators. And then in the morning, this particular population of light-generating bacteria goes away, and then it comes back again in the evening, cyclically. There are many examples of bacteria living symbiotically with other living organisms and providing critical functions. Robert Kuhn: How do different microbial strains work together, say beneficial ones versus harmful ones? Agnes Day: One way that microbial strains work together is by bringing about drug resistance in the sharing of extrachromosomal material that will carry the genes’ encoding for drug resistance. In the past, we thought that only like species could exchange this DNA (through conjugation where the cells come in contact with each other). Now scientists have discovered something called ‘‘promiscuous plasmids,’’ which will also affect other species. There are pieces of DNA called integrons that have sometimes up to six genes that are encoding for enzymes that will destroy six different drugs. With the rise of these types of resistance mechanisms in the bacteria, drug discovery is going to have to be more focused and more clever. Robert Kuhn: We’re going to go to our next topic—whether microbes can cause diseases beyond the traditional categories of infectious diseases. Most people don’t even realize that some cancers can be caused by external, infectious microbes.
96
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Paul Ewald: About 15% to 20% of all human cancers are known to be caused by infection, which is an astonishing number. If in 1975 you were to ask scientists what proportion of all human cancer is caused by infection, they would say perhaps one tenth of one percent. What has happened over the last 25 to 30 years is that every five years or so we’ve been discovering more and more cancers being caused by infection. Robert Kuhn: Is this a discovery of what always was and never known before or an increase due to changes in the human condition? Paul Ewald: A discovery of what always was. 25 years ago virtually 100% of cancers had causes that we didn’t understand well. Now we understand some of those causes better, enough to know, for example, that cervical cancer and liver cancers are caused by infectious agents. Agnes Day: And then there is the Helicobacter pylori bacteria, which has a strong association with gastric cancer. Paul Ewald: There is a great deal of interesting data that seems to show that stomach cancers can be cured with antibiotics that knock out Helicobacter. In a study from Japan, in which experimental and control groups were followed longitudinally in the population, there were 33 cases of stomach cancer in the control group, but in the experimental group, which had the Helicobacter bacteria knocked out, there were zero. Lucy Shapiro: To think critically here, the operational word is triggering ‘‘something’’ in the host. I do not think this is a simple chain of events that cancer is caused directly by a bacterial or viral infection. In most instances, a tissue in a person is attacked by an infection which then elicits a whole series of biochemical reactions that result in the cancer—everything in the cell is disrupted, especially in tissues that turn over rapidly. So it is not that the bug itself is causing the cancer; it is that our bodies are over-responding to the infection (especially in cells that keep recycling), trying to get rid of the infection, and as an unintended consequence of all the biochemical activity, you get mutations and when these mutations build up, you get an oncogenic response resulting in cancer. Paul Ewald: Sometimes yes; sometimes no. In other words, there are two ways in which infections can cause cancer: first is a sort of the irritation mechanism, which is what Lucy just described. But there is a second mechanism in which the pathogen directly causes the cancer by encoding a compound that knocks out one of the cancer-prevention genes or enzymes or proteins in the cells. So, for example, Human Papilloma viruses produce E6 protein, which knocks out p53, which is one of our barriers against cancer. The virus is doing this, evolutionary speaking, because it enables the virus to reproduce better by causing the host cell in which it is living to live a little bit more, and that enables the virus to avoid destruction by the
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
97
immune system. But in the process of extending its reproduction time, the virus pushes the cell one step closer to cancer. Robert Kuhn: What is the percentage of cancers that are caused, in some way, by infection? Paul Ewald: Let me answer that question in reverse: In less than 5% of human cancers can we exclude a role for infection. For about 15 to 20% of human cancers, we say infections are playing a triggering or primary role. And in the other approximately 75–80% of human cancers we don’t know yet. Lucy Shapiro: The impact of infectious disease goes beyond cancers. These infectious agents can come in and cause some effect in the host and then our immune system overreacts, causing auto-immune diseases. Many of our modern diseases are auto-immune diseases that are triggered initially by either a viral or a bacterial infection. Alice Huang: A great example of this is when the Helicobacter pylori bacteria was discovered to be causing ulcers, which, prior to this discovery, everyone thought was caused by stress. (For discovering that bacteria caused ulcers, Dr. Barry Marshall and Dr. Robin Warren won the 2005 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine.) On the other hand, for the inflammatory bowel diseases, doctors assume it must be caused by a bacteria, but when treatment with antibiotics didn’t work, we realized it was really the inflammatory response of the host. Lucy Shapiro: Good point. Antibiotics can be not only useless but also dangerous. Take E. coli 0157, in which you have the genes for a toxin that came from another kind of bacterium (called Shigella), and that Shigella is sitting within a piece of DNA that came from a bacteriophage (a bacterial virus). And so any treatment that a doctor gives a patient that affects E. coli 0157, which is harboring this latent virus in its chromosome, can cause the viral genes to turn on the toxin gene and then the toxin makes the patient very ill or even causes death. In this situation, if antibiotics are administered, you stimulate the production of the virus that turns on the genes for the toxin. So you can’t give antibiotics in this case. Robert Kuhn: Now to the good microbes. What is probiotics? Can microbes be utilized to make us better? Paul Ewald: One kind of research that has been going on since the 1960s (and perhaps the late 1950s) studies the possibility that if you have a nasty infection, let’s say staphylococcus, perhaps you could be given a milder staphylococcus so that the less toxic bacteria could interfere with the more toxic one.
98
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Agnes Day: The poster child for probiotics would be the lactobacillus or the active yogurt cultures that you see now in grocery stores, such as the Lactaid Milk for people who are lactose intolerant. This bacterium will break down the milk sugar so that you don’t get the stomach cramping. Paul Ewald: Vaccinations are probiotics in that they introduce into the human body milder strains of the disease so that the immune system is stimulated to develop antibodies that can fight the more virulent strains of the same disease. Thus the vaccines knock out the harmful strains and leaves the mild strains. The diphtheria vaccination program, which is the second most successful vaccination program in history (second only to the smallpox vaccination program), has used just this strategy (without really knowing it). Alice Huang: There is current research—probably least familiar to the general public—which puts anaerobic bacteria into tumors with the objective of destroying the inside of the tumor. That the bacteria are anaerobic is important, since once the bacteria gets into an oxygenated environment, it can no longer spread and grow uncontrollably. Dealing with bacteria is complex. Earlier we spoke about the water supply somewhat simplistically: if we seek to get rid of all the bad microbes just by cleaning up the water supply, we could cause other problems. Very often, when you treat one population of microbes and get the desired result, it doesn’t mean that other populations of microbes don’t change as well. In fact, the same treatment that eliminates one kind of bad microbe might cause good microbes to change into bad ones! So even though we all agree that having clean water is a good thing, in some instances where we have become more hygienic, we have become more susceptible as host to certain other agents. For example, the polio virus, which has been around since Egyptian days, became an epidemic because we developed much better water supplies. Paul Ewald: That’s right. We know that the success associated with cleaning up water supplies dwarfs most other success stories in medicine, but yet there can be potential problems in doing so. With polio, we had to come back with a good vaccine program and knock out this straggler virus that sort of got in the back door because it had some characteristics that made it unusual compared to other waterborne pathogens. We must take into account the whole balance sheet. The same kind of argument has been made for peptic ulcers. If we knock out Helicobacter pylori, we have this tremendously positive effect in reducing the frequencies of peptic ulcers and the frequencies of some stomach cancers. However, some people argue that it looks like this treatment might be associated with an increase in esophageal cancer—this may or may not be true; we have to look at those data. But even if true, the positive effect associated with knocking out Helicobacter pylori is so great that it dwarfs the potential negative effect.
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
Robert Kuhn: consequences.
99
We always have to be on the lookout for unintended
Agnes Day: Wouldn’t the cleaning up of water supplies with antibiotic chemicals generate a type of selective pressure so that the one percent of the bacteria that do survive might be even more detrimental? Paul Ewald: Let’s say the use of chlorine was going to be selecting for chlorine resistant organisms, which could mean trouble. Luckily, it turns out that there are only a very few organisms that can generate resistance to chlorine. Lucy Shapiro: That we know about. Paul Ewald: That we know about. But we do have some good evidence on this because we can observe whether we get infections caused by dangerous organisms in water supplies that are chlorinated. But the point is well taken: we have other methods for cleaning up water supplies, such as filtration. Lucy Shapiro: We have to continually remind ourselves that the water supply is just one way for epidemics to spread. There is also a great history of epidemics being spread just through the air. My feeling about bioterrorist attacks is that it would likely not be through the water, but through the air, with aerosols. Paul Ewald: Waterborne pathogens are lousy terrorist weapons. Lucy Shapiro: The bad news is that we can now genetically manipulate organisms to change their host range, to make them resistant to drugs, to make them into an aerosol, to make them more able to be transmitted from person to person. Robert Kuhn:
‘‘Weaponize,’’ as they say.
Lucy Shapiro: Weaponize. On the other hand, the good news is that we have learned so much about these bugs that now we can design detectors. We can now design ways of saying we know what that bug is and we know how to stop it now. Agnes Day: But there are also some bioweapons that utilize the toxins from the organism. And if terrorists acquire the gene sequence for these toxins, they can put these genes into bacteria that we would normally identify as being benign or nonpathogenic, and when that toxin gene is turned on, they have their warfare agent. Lucy Shapiro: Genetic engineering has pluses and minuses. Robert Kuhn: Bad human beings can use genetic engineering to create bioweapons and good human beings can use genetic engineering to design agents to stop them.
100
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn End Commentary: Bugs are not all bad, and although we’ve won some battles against toxic microbes, vanquishing many diseases, the threats are very real and we are in danger of losing the war. We can lose by Evolution: Antibiotic drugs can spawn species of superbugs, when natural mutations select for resistance to overused drugs. We can lose by Surprise: Bacteria and viruses may cause a broad range of diseases, including some cancers, cardiovascular illnesses, and dementias. We can lose by Insanity: Biowarfare can deliberately spread lethal microorganisms that infect human beings and destroy human life. We have no choice: Science must continue the microscopic arms race, mapping microbial genomes, designing highly specific new drugs, and maintaining a microbial balance of power. It is not surprising that there is a common fallacy in our society: ‘‘we must beat the microbes!’’ Yet maintaining a microbial balance of power is the key to a sustainable world: without microbes in the soil there would be no agriculture; without microbes in our cells processing oxygen, we would not be able to breathe. And just as microbes naturally evolve to combat others, we can now engineer beneficial microbes to evolve to combat dangerous microbes. Furthermore, surprising strategies including the use of probiotics —the opposite of antibiotics—might shift the balance of power in our favor, plus dramatically improve health in third-world countries.
Interviews with Expert Participants Paul Ewald Can infectious agents trigger genetic diseases? Autism does have indications of being caused by infectious agents. We should be looking really hard to see what agents might be infecting the growing fetus during pregnancy. What are key developments in your field? The final synthesis of evolution with the health sciences is going to affect daily life in dramatic ways. I think that a lot of the diseases that we have had difficulty to control are because the microorganisms that cause them are so evolutionarily versatile. This means that when we try to use antibiotics against them, they evolve resistance to these antibiotics. What we need to do is recognize that this evolutionary versatility is their characteristic power,
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
101
and we have to use this characteristic to our advantage as opposed to theirs. In other words, if a microorganism has strong evolutionary potential, we need to use that evolutionary potential to get the organism to evolve to become more benign.
Alice S. Huang Is cleanliness overly emphasized in modern society? Obviously it is important to be clean, but being too clean is not the very best thing either. Recent studies have shown that certain socioeconomic groups in which the children are playing on the streets in mud and with animals seem to be pretty well protected against certain diseases, and that it is the wealthier children who are ‘‘cleaner’’ who become infected with these diseases. Will we ever outgrow antibiotics? I don’t think so because we’re so dependent on them. Not many of us recognize what it was like in the pre-antibiotic days when so many women died in childbirth. We don’t see that very often now because of the widespread use of antibiotics. Why did you become a scientist? Ever since I was about seven years old, I’ve always wanted to be a physician. I think this is because my father, who was a bishop of the Anglican Episcopal Church in China, had often mused to himself that he would have perhaps preferred to have saved bodies rather than to have saved souls. When I got into medical school, I realized that saving bodies and preventing people from dying was only one aspect of medicine, and that there was so much more to it. I discovered that I loved doing research, which was fortunate because it turned out that I wasn’t very good at looking at sick bodies. The first time I saw a very elderly, very sick man in bed with lots of bedsores, I got pretty ill. After that I decided that perhaps practicing clinical medicine wasn’t the right goal for me. So research became my answer. Whom do you most admire, and why? As I get older, I realize that the person who has had the most impact on me professionally and whom I admire tremendously is Polly Bunting. She was a microbiologist who received her Ph.D. when she had two little children, and was very soon thereafter widowed. In her time, although times were difficult for female professionals, she had to go out and work and she became the president of Radcliffe College. She has given me tremendous advice over
102
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
my career. She said to me early on, ‘‘Keep your eye on your goals. Don’t get sidetracked, don’t get on too many committees, and don’t get too involved in all these gender studies.’’ And then she said what was probably most important: ‘‘Get to a position where you can really do some good. As a young assistant professor, you’re not going to be able to have much power to do anything. But as you become a professor, you will be much better able to help people.’’ But, she continued, ‘‘Remember that when you get to that position of power, you are still a woman.’’ And I thought she was very wise because she realized that in order for me to succeed, it was very likely that I would have adapted myself to the assumptions and the behavior patterns that the people around me had, which would be mostly men. And that when I became a professor, I might really have forgotten that I was still a woman. What are the key developments in your field? It’s really been fun to be part of a discovery process that I now can see has major impact. In the 1970s, we were just beginning to purify viruses and discover that they contained genetic information of all different kinds. At that time we had all been taught that DNA contained genetic information in all of our cells and in living organisms. But with these viruses, we found that some of them had other kinds of nucleic acids and therefore we worked out how information was transferred between these different nucleic acids. Now we find that we can use what we know about the genetic information of viruses to incorporate other genes into them, and this gives us the technological capacity to enable these viruses to become carriers for inserting new information into cells. This remarkable technology is right now at the forefront of the development of antivirals, the possibility that we will be able to insert new genes into cells that would help change a diseased cell or reverse a cancerous cell. What advice do you have for young people? I think getting into research is one of the most exciting careers that one can have. It opens up so many doors. You not only have the possibility of discovering something that would really help mankind, but you also have the pleasure of interacting with young people, teaching them, and passing on to them new information. How would you like to be remembered? I don’t ever try to really guess how history is going to look to different individuals. I hope that those who are alive will remember me with love.
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
103
Agnes Day How do disinfectants impact microbes? Interesting question. We’ve talked about antibiotic resistance, but there’s another corollary topic that needs to be discussed: resistance to the antiseptics and disinfectants that we use to keep hospitals and operating rooms sterile, and to clean our homes. There are many products on the shelves of grocery stores that say, ‘‘Antibacterial Action,’’ ‘‘Kills 99.9 percent of the germs.’’ And so I had a little seventh grader who did a science project testing these compounds. The directions said to dilute two capfuls in a gallon of water. When she tested these ‘‘antibacterial’’ cleaning compounds against bacteria that she had isolated from her own bathroom, she found that in two out of three cases, the disinfectant had to be used full strength in order to kill the bacteria, that once you diluted it in water as instructed on the bottle, it had absolutely no efficacy against home microorganisms! (One did work well when diluted one to ten.) Should we regulate disinfectants? I think the truth has to be told. If you’re buying an antibacterial solution, the directions should say, ‘‘Best when used undiluted.’’ Companies must tell the truth in advertisement. But of course it’s not only a health factor, it’s also an economic factor. If you think that the antibacterial cleanser is going to work if you dilute it one to one hundred (1:100), of course you’re going to dilute it to save money. Give some examples of successful gene therapy. They’ve made the greatest advances in gene therapy in the dental field. One example is for people with HIV. Usually their death certificates state that they died from candidiasis, which is a fungal disease caused by yeast that babies or women have in their urogenital tracts. But in an immunocompromised person (with HIV), this fungal disease will grow from the mouth all the way through the digestive system so that the people cannot absorb nutrients. And so what scientists have come up with is taking the cells that produce saliva, and taking a gene that encodes a peptide that they isolated that can kill these bacteria, and by putting that gene inside those saliva cells and then putting those cells back into the mouth, when the saliva cells replicate, you have these cells producing an antifungal agent (peptide) that the patient swallows along with his saliva, so that the antifungal agent is killing the organisms that are lining the gastrointestinal tract. This technique is not yet in wide use because there are some drawbacks of putting foreign DNA into human cells, but it shows great promise for alleviating some of the pain and suffering of people with immuno-compromised systems.
104
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Can microbes cause hereditary diseases? One example is the presence of chlamydial pneumonia, which are small, intracellular bacteria that cause upper respiratory tract infections. Scientists have now found this organism in the plaques of arteries. And so they’re looking at the cause and effect of chlamydial infections leading to arteriosclerosis. In the past, one thought that cardiovascular disease of this nature was not necessarily heritable, but it did run in families. Now they have shown that in this case there is a direct correlation between the presence of this organism and the causation of this disease early in life and with the later development of arteriosclerosis. So I believe that the more we look into this phenomenon, the more we’re going to find out that there are more diseases which are the direct results of bacterial and viral infections than we currently know about. What are human pathogens? Some viruses infect plants, others infect insect cells, and still others are strictly human pathogens. Many human pathogens have been found to be associated, with or to actually induce, certain types of cancer. We’ve found instances where viruses have exchanged genetic material with human cells and left a little surprise package behind – a protein that could enhance the carcinogenic activity of, say, an environmental insult to the body, thereby leading to cancer. These are called proto-oncogenes, and if these protooncogenes are turned on, they can bring about a cancerous state in the body. What are ‘‘promiscuous plasmids?’’ When we talk about promiscuous plasmids, we’re talking about the ‘host range’ of the plasmid. Some plasmids, like E. coli, have a very restrictive host range—they can only infect cells of their own kind. Promiscuous plasmids, on the other hand, can transfer their resistant genes not only to their own kind but also to other kinds of organisms—they don’t care who they infect, they’re going to infect whoever happens to be handy. So they can really cause a lot of trouble. Why did you become a scientist? I would always hang out with my older brother; he was actually was the youngest of six brothers, but he was older than I was. We would always go exploring together and catch various insects and animals in the woods; and I would ask him what were these critters were, and he would take me to the library and we’d figure out what was what. So at an early age I started asking ‘‘why’’ questions. And my interests developed to the point where when I was introduced to the hard sciences in high school and college, they were right up my alley. They brought back fond memories of walking through the woods and finding out things on my own.
Microbes—Friend or Foe?
105
Whom do you most admire, and why? It is hard to pick one person, but one of the people who served as an excellent mentor was my third grade teacher, the Reverend Mrs. Rosemarie Bryant, who, as she put it, saw something in me that needed to be developed. I was the youngest of 13 children, and so she asked my mother if I could come and live with her, and she in turn would give me the opportunities that I wouldn’t normally have growing up in the housing projects of Daytona. She always pushed me to do the best that I could. She brought me up in a very Christian atmosphere, so I think I’m basically a good person. And she taught me a love of learning by her being my third grade teacher. So Mrs. Bryant is the role model that most comes to mind when I think of the one person who put me on the path of achieving and becoming more than I ever dreamed I could be. Does the general public properly appreciate science? The general public takes science for granted. Once they leave school, most people cease to think about science at all. But every discovery, every cloning, every creation of a new chemical or compound is going to in some way affect their lives. The public really notices when the new discovery is marketed, but not necessarily when it’s discovered. The expectations of the public are high. They expect, ‘‘Well, if you’re a scientist, then you should know this.’’ But they have to realize that just as when they go to a doctor and say they’re not feeling well, they need to have some basic understanding of what is wrong with them in order to work along with the doctor to get better. The same is true with scientists. You don’t see scientists like you see doctors, but they are behind the scenes making the discoveries that are then translated into improved health care, improving people’s lives. And so the public has to make sure that they keep abreast of new developments and actually ask questions, be aware, know what is going on, and know how new discoveries are going to impact them. Most of the research that’s being done in the United States and abroad is being supported with taxpayers’ money, and so everyone has a personal investment in scientific discoveries. The general public should really know how such discoveries are going to benefit you or hurt you. What advice do you have for young people? Be aware. Be aware of what is going on, not only in your local community, but also in the global community. You must keep abreast of current discoveries and where they are going to lead because it’s your future at stake. By keeping abreast, you can also determine what career choices you might have, and you can also have information that could help your parents and friends, so you have to be aware of what is going on. It’s not a ‘‘me generation’’ now. It’s a global generation.
106
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
What advice do you have for young women? For young women who want to go into science, I say ‘‘Go for it.’’ Go for it with all of your heart. You can have a family life, you can have a social life, and you can still be a leading scientist. What you must get, though, is a role model, a mentor, who can help you—not by getting you a job, but by teaching you both the science of your job and the politics of your job. How would you like to be remembered? I would like to be remembered as a facilitator. I like to help people to get things done. I was raised with the idea that everyone has a responsibility to teach someone else. Today, most fields of science—such as microbiology, my field—have become so crowded in that one does not get that one-onone interaction and mentoring that we used to get. So now I’ve modified my theory so that each person must teach multiple people. So as a teacher, I’m doing the greatest good by bringing more young people into the disciplines of microbiology, molecular biology, and cancer research.
Chapter 8
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
When my father was diagnosed with terminal lymphoma, he was declared not eligible for a new class of drugs that target these life-ending tumors. How does society balance the need to do good science with the compassion to help sick people? What are the ethics of clinical trials? Instituted in the 1960s, clinical trials of new drugs, devices and procedures have become a vast and expensive enterprise in which drug companies can spend over $100 million to bring a new molecule to market. FDA procedures are complex and elaborate, as they should be to do good science and to protect the public from a drug’s potentially dangerous side effects. But how does the government balance statistical accuracy with the desire of all patients to get the best treatment as rapidly as possible? There is a natural and proper tension here. How is success defined for clinical trials? How are costs and benefits assessed? What are appropriate levels or toxicity of side effects that can be tolerated for given levels of cure, remissionn or alleviation of symptoms? And what about those not allowed to participate in the clinical trials of a needed drug, device, or procedure? How long must sick people wait to have a chance to be cured? What can be done about bringing new drugs to market quickly to help people in need? Once you delve into it, the entire arena of clinical drug trials is a tangle of hidden moral, ethical, legal, and philosophical complications. Say you want to enroll your seven year-old for an experimental HIV drug but the kid doesn’t know he or she has HIV and you don’t want to tell him or her because kids blab. If they talk about it, your family may be ostracized or
108
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
thrown out of their neighborhood. What about the altruistic man in Philadelphia who had a non-life-threatening genetic disease, volunteered for a genetic therapy drug trial, was a borderline case for admission, and then died because of the treatment? Then there are the sensitive, awkward ethical issues of drug testing in third world countries. Are we exploiting the people by using them in trials, or are we helping them by bringing medical care they would never have had access to and then giving them training, organization, buildings, and equipment? In this chapter, experts wrestle with the ethics of clinical trials: a doctor specializing in HIV medicine, a distinguished lawyer and bioethicist, and an official from the Food & Drug Administration outline the complex issues surrounding the development and testing of new drugs. They explain the standards now in place for conducting clinical trials and the exceptionally difficult task of conducting placebo control trials that are fair to all the participants. The guests touch on the role of drug companies, consent issues, and the need for a rigorous accreditation program for institutions conducting the trials. There is also a spirited call for more scrutiny of drug testing in the less-developed world, and they suggest that drug companies have an obligation to educate local medical professionals about western practices and to leave behind a solid infrastructure of medical facilities and equipment.
Expert Participants Alexander Capron University Professor of Law, University of Southern California; Director, Pacific Center for Health Policy and Ethics; former chairman, Biomedical Ethics Advisory Committee, U.S. Congress
Andrea Kovacs Associate Professor of Pediatrics and Pathology; Director, HIV Family Clinic, Keck School of Medicine, University of Southern California
Robert Temple Associate Director for Medical Policy; Chair, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
Alexander Capron: One thing we have to recognize in this country is that many people sign up for clinical trials because it is the only way they can get effective treatment of any kind. Clinical trials are now often run through private doctor’s offices on contract to drug companies, and many people who do not have the money to go into that doctor’s office and get the highest
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
109
standard of care may see an ad in the paper saying, ‘‘If you have xyz disease, come in, we’ll treat you,’’ and so they go into that doctor’s office and do not comprehend that what they are doing is signing up as a guinea pig in a clinical trial. Robert Temple: We have clinical control trials largely because Congress, in its wisdom in 1962, said controlled trials are the only basis for proving a drug. So the drug industry, which are bottom-line oriented, complied. Within ten years, every new medicine, device, or procedure had become a clinical trial. Robert Kuhn:
What is ‘‘compassionate use’’?
Robert Temple: Compassionate use refers to use of a drug specifically directed at treatment of an individual person, not to learn something. Alexander Capron: use.
This would be a drug that isn’t yet approved for that
Robert Temple: Usually it involves a drug early in its clinical trials, before it has been approved for general use. The individuals who are permitted ‘‘compassionate use’’ appear to have exhausted available therapy. Used this way, you often know very little about the drug and you can be surprised by its toxicity. Andrea Kovacs: You could have the wrong dose, and with a disease like HIV, the wrong dose could be disastrous. Robert Temple: We had an advisory committee meeting on this very matter relating to cancer drugs, and many members of the patient advocacy community came to sound a note of caution. They said that it is not always a favor to people to use an untested drug. I was very impressed by the perspicacity and wisdom they brought to the whole discussion. Robert Kuhn: Andrea, tell us about your work on AIDS, and the issues that you have with clinical trials. Andrea Kovacs: I’m the director of the Maternal, Child, and Adolescent Program at the University of Southern California (USC), and we are following at the present time over 600 women, children, and adolescents, including about 20 or 30 pregnant women. Over the last 10 years, we have seen tremendous progress in terms of actual successes. When I started about one third of the babies born to HIV-infected women were born infected. Now the number is zero! We can actually prevent transmission of HIV to a fetus. This success is a direct result of clinical trials. Our children were dying and now, through clinical trials, we’ve been able to determine the optimal therapies so that no child in our clinic has died in three or four years. Robert Kuhn:
What are the issues with which you are now wrestling?
110
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Andrea Kovacs: How to enroll children in HIV clinical trials, children who are between the age of seven and 13, who basically do not know their own diagnosis, but whose parents want them in clinical trials because they cannot get the drugs through compassionate use. How do you enroll such children, who have to sign a written assent that has the HIV diagnosis stated in the assent. Robert Kuhn:
The children do not know that they have HIV.
Andrea Kovacs: The children do not know that they have HIV. We’ve had families thrown out of their neighborhoods, kids getting punched in the face, because their HIV diagnosis was disclosed. It’s a complicated moral dilemma because, given the kind of discrimination that surrounds HIV, disclosure is such a huge issue. Robert Kuhn:
What is the difference between consent and assent?
Alexander Capron: The assent was conceived as a recognition that for people who have not yet reached the age of consent—they are under 18—they still ought not to be involved in a clinical trial unless they agree, and this below-age-of-consent agreement has been labeled with the term ‘‘assent.’’ Robert Kuhn: Is it realistic to ask a seven-year-old to give an ‘‘assent’’ to participate in a clinical trial? Robert Temple: There are no absolute rules about this; people draw lines where they think they can, but I think that seven years old is an age where people believe that the child can make a reasonable decision. Younger than seven, they probably cannot. Alexander Capron: If my child says, I don’t want to have this or that procedure, and the doctor and I have concluded that the procedure is the right thing, I will try to persuade the child, be as comforting as I can, but in the end, I will say, ‘‘This is the treatment we’re going to do.’’ But if I am ‘‘volunteering my child,’’ as opposed to volunteering myself, to participate in research for the benefit of science, I will not do that without some level of the child affirming, ‘‘I’m willing to play this role, and I understand that it’s a role that goes beyond my own benefit.’’ Robert Temple: This is the easiest ethical principle for me to understand: people who volunteer to participate in research trials are supposed to know and appreciate what they are getting into. Well, it’s not easy for a physician to convey to non-medical people the complexities of a study. You have to tell them what the alternatives are, you have to tell them what the risks are, you have to take care not to over-promise on the benefits side, and you not only have to give a written document with all appropriate language, but you also have to be available for questions. The whole process is very hard to do, but you have to do your best.
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
111
Alexander Capron: There is a real risk that people go into clinical trials thinking that they are going to benefit from participation, and physicians need to explain that what they are doing is research. You hear constantly from physicians in these situations that they explain to prospective participants that the process is randomized—they explain randomization, they explain that this is a trial—and then the physician will ask the prospect, ‘‘Are you comfortable?’’ and the person will answer, ‘‘Yes I am; I’ll sign,’’ but then they immediately say to the doctor, ‘‘But I know you’re going to give me the treatment that’s right for me.’’ Robert Kuhn: The situation is so unnatural: this is the person who is your doctor and he or she is in essence saying to you, ‘‘I don’t know if I’m giving you an inert substance or this drug that we hope will help make you better.’’ Alexander Capron: It’s cognitive dissonance. Prospects have told their doctors: ‘‘But you must be doing it for my good because you’re my doctor.’’ Robert Kuhn: Andrea, how do you handle clinical trials with adolescents, especially young people who have not the highest education? Andrea Kovacs: Young adults 13 to 18 years old who get HIV are not your routine 13- to 18-year-olds. Frequently they’re on the streets; frequently they come from broken homes. Since they are not legally emancipated, how do you enroll a 13- to 18-year-old pregnant adolescent? How do you enroll someone who is in and out of juvenile courts? These are complicated issues and a major challenge. Alexander Capron: I assume that in this group there is no question that they would all know that they have the HIV condition. Andrea Kovacs: Yes, of course; they all know their diagnosis, but I still cannot enroll the adolescent without a parent’s consent. Robert Kuhn: What is the governing rule here? Can you enroll these young people who desperately need to be in these trials without parental consent? It would seem that in some cases you would have difficulty in getting parental consent. Robert Temple:
A legal guardian can give consent.
Andrea Kovacs:
But you have to go to court.
Robert Temple:
I agree, and you have to find a legal guardian.
Andrea Kovacs: Right. So once we start doing these huge studies, which are going to be Phase III at some point, how do we do this? Robert Kuhn:
Let’s describe the key characteristics of clinical trials.
112
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Temple: The simplest kind of clinical trial is to give the treatment being tested, say, the drug you are interested in, to one randomized group, and a placebo (an inert substance that looks the same) to a similarly randomized group. Alexander Capron: The usual design of research involves what we call ‘‘blinded’’ tests, which means that the subjects and the investigators do not know which participants are getting the active treatment and which are getting the placebo. The identity of the treatment is sufficiently disguised so that no one knows what they are really getting. Robert Kuhn: It is called ‘‘single blind’’ if only the patients do not know but the investigators do know whether they are getting the active treatment or the placebo, and ‘‘double blind’’ if neither the participants nor the investigators know. The gold standard for clinical trials is to conduct them ‘‘double blind.’’ Robert Kuhn:
What are the phases of clinical trials?
Robert Temple: Phase I trials are the first introduction of a drug into humans; these drugs have been studied in animals and shown to have some efficacy. Now you give it to a small number of people, sometimes normal people, sometimes people with the disease; you generally push the dose up until someone develops a side effect, gets nauseated or dizzy or something like that—this provides some idea of what doses will be tolerated. Phase II trials are the first control trials of the drug, which are usually conducted in a fairly narrow, well-described population. Here the investigators are looking to determine whether the drug really does what they hope it to do; for example, in an HIV trial the investigators might compare one regimen of drugs with another (different drug combinations, dosages, and/or timeframes) to compare the effects on the HIV virus by monitoring the number of viral particles per unit of blood. Phase III trials are more extensive control trials to better define the dose, look at the drug in various severities of the disease, look at different subsets of the population (e.g., men and women, black and white, old and young) and to generally get much more exposure so you can uncover the rarer side effects. After all, in a Phase II trial of say 200 people, you won’t find an occurrence that happens once in 500, but when you get into Phase III where you might have several thousand people enrolled, you have at least a chance of finding side effects that occur at the rate of one in 1000. Alexander Capron: This is where you get into the sticky issue of using a placebo (inert) control versus what they call the active control, which is the current standard of care. For example, if you’re developing an acne medicine or a hair-loss medicine or something cosmetic, you would of course include a placebo control (in addition to the active control) because by using a
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
113
placebo control as part of the experimental design you are going to get results that are both more reliable and more rapid, and the fact that someone is going without any treatment for acne or hair loss for a brief period of time is not going to raise major problems. Robert Kuhn: However, in situations where the participants have serious medical conditions, which might be life threatening, how can you ethically allocate any of them to a placebo (no active treatment) group? Robert Temple: The basic rule is you cannot deny people a therapy that is available to them if harm might come to them by not having the therapy. ‘‘Harm’’ is usually defined to mean something that is irreversible: death is irreversible, a stroke is irreversible; everyone agrees that in these cases you cannot conduct a placebo control trial anymore. However, it is often not so clear cut. Consider depression: there are many new drugs for depression; they have already made a big difference in therapy and scientists are excited about their therapeutic potential. But it is a fact that only about half of the clinical trials of Prozac for depression can distinguish the drug from the placebo. Now, if you know this experimental fact, and you now do a clinical trial comparing a new drug with Prozac and the trial does not show any difference between them, well, what have you learned? Maybe this trial was one of those trials that couldn’t distinguish Prozac from placebo! And if you don’t have a placebo group running in parallel, there is no way to tell. So, in these cases, we ask for a placebo control trials. Now, some people are nervous about this kind of experimental design. After all, depression is not a benign illness, a few people commit suicide. Fortunately, in this case, there are several large assemblages of data, called meta-analyses, which have looked to see whether people in the placebo group are more likely to commit suicide, and since the clinical trials that have been conducted for depression were short term studies, four to six weeks, the placebo group was not more likely to commit suicide. So, as a result, we can comfortably say it is ethically permitted to conduct placebo control trials with properly informed patients, and it is essential to have the placebo group or we would be approving drugs that did not work and not approving drugs that did. Robert Kuhn:
Do you agree with that, Alex?
Alexander Capron: I don’t agree or disagree, because I think that there are certain things left out of that description. What is the type of depression? What are the circumstances of the subjects? We need to understand the participants’ personal capacity to consent so that we could build in appropriate safeguards. For example, if you are dealing with a relatively mild depression, where the likelihood of suicide or other harm is very small, it’s one thing; in more severe cases, the patients would have to be in circumstances both where their consent was very reliable and where they were going to be given protection of medical care. Only then would the investigators be ethically
114
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
protected if the situation arose where a treatment that would be available to a certain group was not offered to them, whereas other people were getting it and it proved to be effective. Even so, I have to say that I would be bothered by the quality of the consent here. Robert Temple: We don’t disagree at all. Those are important issues. But the reality is that if we don’t have a placebo control trial for a new antidepressant, we are not going to be able to know whether it works, and if we don’t, we can’t approve it. Now, there are alternatives. If the new antidepressant is shown to be better than the available antidepressants in a direct comparison (without the placebo controls), then you can approve the new drug. That works when the new drug has clear superiority, but it will not discern drugs that work at lower levels of efficacy. Alexander Capron: The direct comparison to available treatment is called a ‘‘superiority trial,’’ as opposed to an ‘‘equivalency trial,’’ which has this ambiguity that Dr. Temple points out. Robert Kuhn: baseline.
Because there’s no placebo to provide a standardized
Robert Temple: The trouble is that in the hundreds of trials that have been conducted comparing one antidepressant with another, one has never been shown to be clearly superior. They are all more or less equally effective. This means that without a placebo control as part of the methodology of the trials, our capacity to judge effectiveness is substantially weakened. Robert Kuhn: Let’s look at the stakeholders in clinical trials. Who has interests here? Obviously, the patients who have the syndrome or the disease that is being investigated. Obviously, the government which is responsible for safety and efficacy. But the big elephants in this room are the drug companies; they invest an enormous amount of money in creating these new drugs. What’s the attitude and impact of the drug companies in the ethics of clinical trials? Robert Temple: Obviously, the drug companies have their own views on everything, but they come to us and they come to experts in the medical community for advice about how to do their trials. There are numerous important questions, of which the control group is only one. Another is defining what the endpoint of the study should be. We approve drugs because they lower cholesterol, but what we really want to know is whether they save lives. Finally, after many years, we now have several cholesterollowering drugs that save lives. Alexander Capron: A bigger issue is the so-called me-too drugs, where there are effective treatments already. And the next treatment coming along is not being offered because it is cheaper or even because it has fewer side
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
115
effects, but simply because one drug company wants to have a drug on the market to compete with its rivals. There is no great benefit to the consumer. Robert Temple: However, the desire to find the place for your own proprietary product has been beneficial on some occasions. The most striking case was with what are called statins, the lipid-lowering drugs, where multiple drug companies competed to show the special effectiveness or comparative advantage of their own drug. One company did a large trial in Scandinavia showing that the drugs are good for people who had a heart attack and whose cholesterol is over 260. Then another company did a trial in Scotland showing that even if people didn’t have a heart attack and their cholesterol was over 260, the drug helped. To some extent, competition in this case did what it’s supposed to do. Alexander Capron: Competition developed more information than we would have had if we only had the first study. Robert Temple: In this case, we acquired unbelievably valuable information. Now many lipid-lowering drugs are known to save lives and there is general agreement that they are used too infrequently. So the multiple drugs doing the same thing encourages more people to take these drugs, which in general seems to be a good thing for the community. Robert Kuhn: Why is there so much criticism in the press about clinical trials and the government role in regulating them? Alexander Capron: There have been some trials which went very badly. One example was the death of an 18-year-old young man in a gene therapy trial at the University of Pennsylvania in 1999. The young man had a very rare liver disease (which mostly strikes very young children) and the procedure—placing healthy genes in his liver—was deemed to have minimal risk, so that even though the young man did not actually meet the enrollment criteria, he was enrolled. Within four days, he became very sick and died. His father said that the young man had volunteered for the study to help other sufferers. Robert Kuhn: Making the case more troublesome was the fact that the young man’s condition was mild, well under control, and certainly not life threatening. Alexander Capron: Correct; he had the version that was not as severe. Now, here is the underlying debate: would it have been better to conduct this research in people who were critically ill, namely the little babies who couldn’t, obviously, give their assent to participate, but where ethical tension would be balanced by the notion that they are already very sick, and if this worked, it would be a great benefit to them personally? Whereas the young man who volunteered for the procedure really wasn’t very sick and
116
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
wasn’t going to benefit from it; he was doing it altruistically. The other issue in this case is the extent to which the researchers and, indeed, the entire research enterprise, was tied into an entrepreneurial interest in which the researcher and the university had invested in the development of that technique. Robert Kuhn: So the university and the researcher had a financial interest in the procedure? That could turn an unhappy situation into an ugly one. Alexander Capron: The investigator was a principal owner of the company that was sponsoring the research and the university had a financial interest in the procedure. If the research had been successful, both would have been in a position to benefit financially. Robert Temple: Who supports most clinical trials? Drug companies, obviously; they are interested parties. Yet it’s not always clear what their interest is. I think they really do want to find out whether a drug hurts people, because they wouldn’t want to market a drug with terrible side effects, which would be a disaster for them, so it is not in their interest to suppress bad news. Still, drug company motivation is complicated. The ordinary way trials are done is that a drug company, obviously an interested party, pays an independent investigator to conduct the trial. The axiomatic assumption is that investigator is really independent, which means that he or she has no stake in the outcome of the trial and that he or she will conduct it with high quality, monitoring the trials rigorously to make sure everything is done appropriately to the highest standards. That’s the usual model. Alexander Capron: I think that if we looked in detail at research done anywhere, we could find problems. We are coming to the point in this country where we recognize that we need a better system than we have now for knowing, on an ongoing basis, how well institutions that carry out clinical research are doing. I think the government is preparing to assert that clinical trial programs should be accredited. (This was a recommendation of the National Bioethics Advisory Commission, on which I serve.) Such an accreditation procedure would start off as a voluntary activity, but it would mean that not just when a problem arises, but on a periodic basis, people familiar with the way research should be conducted would be coming in and taking an in-depth look at the procedures, at the consent process, at the reviews, and particularly at how good a job the universities were doing in monitoring the trials after they start. Robert Kuhn: Another area of ethical concern is clinical trials conducted by first-world drug companies in third-world countries. Cross-cultural sensitivities become especially acute when the specific clinical trial would not, at that point, have been allowed in the United States.
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
117
Alexander Capron: At one extreme would be a drug or medical device company wanting to develop a product for the U.S. market but it doesn’t think it can do the trial here because there is an existing treatment that is already effective and established. And so they think, well, we could go to a country where no one gets any treatment for the particular problem and we could compare our new treatment to a placebo. And the incentive for people in the third-world country could be either that they are confused about what they are getting themselves into, or that the officials in the country have been offered something or paid something under the table. Robert Kuhn: However, the third-world people with the medical condition may well be better off than they would have been without the clinical trials, certainly those getting the active treatment. Alexander Capron: Yes, of course. But the people may think that they will be better off because of this treatment, yet the reality is that the research intervention is likely to be very limited in numbers and in time, and the product being developed is not for them and even if it were they couldn’t afford it. One feels compelled to argue that drug companies should not be allowed to conduct such research, that it is ethically wrong, and that the FDA shouldn’t even accept such data. At the other extreme is a country faced with a serious disease requiring first-world treatment that is much too expensive, and their response is to empower their own scientists to work with scientists from elsewhere to develop an alternative, costing, say, a tenth or a hundredth as much. The third-world officials know from the beginning that the cheaper treatment will not be as effective as the much more expensive treatment, but since they have nothing else to offer, the cheaper treatment would be extremely valuable and extremely appreciated. Andrea Kovacs: A classic case was the clinical trials of a drug regimen to prevent the perinatal transmission of HIV in South Africa and Thailand where there was a huge uproar over the fact that we have a standard in the United States—AZT to the mother during pregnancy and to the newborn for six weeks—that due to its cost cannot be applied anywhere in subSahara Africa and in many parts of the world. A trial was done testing a low dose of AZT given to the mother and to the baby versus a placebo control. Robert Kuhn: Here is the ethical dilemma. For this condition you know that there is a proven drug that can reduce the HIV transmission rate by two-thirds, and yet you are testing, in another part of the world, a modified version of that proven drug that you know from the start is going to be inferior. Andrea Kovacs: But they cannot afford the first-world treatment and they do not have the infrastructure and the systems to implement it.
118
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: Here is the ethical conundrum: Do you knowingly administer a lower standard of care because it is the only one that can be afforded and implemented? And do you use a placebo control study which by its nature will deny to needy, infected babies the medicine they need to survive? Andrea Kovacs:
Absolutely.
Robert Temple: The basic rule is you cannot deny people a therapy that is available to them. In this specific case, you could not do a placebo control trial anymore. The critics said that the only acceptable trial here would be to compare the low-dose AZT experimental regimen with the sophisticated U.S. standard of care regimen. Robert Kuhn: Which is expensive and complicated and could not be implemented in those third-world countries. Robert Temple: The question these countries needed answered was not whether the low-dose, short-course AZT treatment was as effective as the larger-dose, long course U.S. standard of care, but whether the low-dose, short course AZT treatment was effective at all. It didn’t have to be as good as the U.S. standard, it could be half as good, but if it worked at all, those countries needed to know it rapidly because such a treatment was doable and could make a huge difference. Alexander Capron: The presumption here is that the first-world drug is not going to become available, that the drug you are testing could be available, and that there is some commitment to making it available. I think that the drug company conducting the trials would have an affirmative obligation to contribute to building the scientific and ethical review capability of the country, so that they leave something positive behind to the third-world country, beyond just having used their population as subjects in the experiment. If you don’t have some kind of ethical presumptions and prescriptions in these cases, with substantial and concrete requirements, then you open to the door to ethical misbehaviors that really would be very bad. Robert Kuhn:
Such as?
Alexander Capron: Poor people who would sign up to do anything; motivated by either the therapeutic misconception or the desire for a little money or both, they would literally become guinea pigs. I don’t think this is something that most American companies would want to do, but the temptation is there. Substantial scientific and ethical reviews should be required both in the first-world country where the drug company is domiciled and in the third-world host country where the clinical trial is being conducted. Robert Temple: Many drug companies are now carrying out trials of antidepressants, antihistamines, and the like just like the trials they carried out in the U.S. These trials are being conducted in Eastern Europe and in South
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
119
America. The companies may want to market their drugs sometime in those countries, but they will probably not be doing it any time soon because the countries would use a generic version of the same drug; they wouldn’t spend money on the original. Robert Kuhn:
Poorer people as guinea pigs?
Robert Temple: We use U.S. citizens in the same way, as guinea pigs. The antidepressant trials are conducted in America and Western Europe as well as in Eastern Europe and in Latin America. Robert Kuhn: Here is the difference, though. If a clinical trial is conducted in the United States, if the treatment works, at least the same population that participated in the clinical trials will benefit from its general usage. That is decidedly not the case when the clinical trial is carried out, say, in Africa. Robert Temple: Perhaps true. It is worth knowing, however, that as a consequence of doing trials in these poorer parts of the world, the drug companies leave behind an infrastructure that is capable of doing trials and they may also leave behind buildings suited for healthcare. The host counties get access to diagnostic and other methods, tools, and facilities that they would not have gotten otherwise. Robert Kuhn: So here is the summary question: are the first-world drug companies taking advantage of these third-world countries or are they providing something beneficial that these poor people would never have received in any other way? Alexander Capron: You can argue it in both directions, but does receiving something valuable for allowing clinical trials in their country constitute inappropriate inducement, or is it a just tradeoff that recognizes the cold imbalances in the world? Andrea Kovacs: I think it very important for the foreign, first-world pharmaceutical and healthcare companies to participate (by any means) in the healthcare systems of third-world countries, thus elevating the society locally. Robert Temple: resources.
The drug companies have the appropriate skills and
Andrea Kovacs: and then leave.
As long as the doctors don’t just go in, exploit the people,
Alexander Capron:
That is certainly the worst thing.
Andrea Kovacs: You educate the people; you train the local groups; you bring in resources; and then you teach them how to do the studies.
120
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Alexander Capron: But sometimes the people whom you are training and are benefiting are already the elite in the country; they are the scientists and the physicians and the people who are going to have access to the fancy equipment and buildings that you leave behind. And, yes, you may be indirectly helping the population by making them better off, but their agreement to participate personally in the clinical trial itself, with all the attendant risks, is not necessarily recompensed by donations to the country’s elite. On the other hand, there are things that a drug company can do beneficially for the entire community. Andrea Kovacs: I think we are making a real contribution to the treatment of HIV in the third world. Now we are going to start studying other diseases such as tuberculosis and malaria—we’re going to study the environment, the water, everything—and we’re going to have an incredible, positive impact on these societies ravaged by these terrible diseases. Robert Temple: Critics have complained with justification that commercial interests haven’t been as eager to study those diseases in the developing world as they should have been. Alexander Capron:
Because they weren’t diseases of our country.
Robert Temple: Right, and because there weren’t large amounts of money to be made from it. So I believe that when major drug companies get into those developing countries to do clinical trials the overall effect is usually beneficial.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary The ethics of clinical trials reflect the humanness of human beings. We seek the good of the group, but we respect the rights of the individual. We do take risks to discover new cures, but we do not dehumanize subjects to accelerate them. The ethical ideal, the parallel prescription, combines informed consent of patients and active monitoring of the data by investigators. When human lives are at stake, we can make compromises of compassion—clinical trials need not run their course, optimum statistics need not be achieved. How can we humanely accelerate the process of bringing valuable drugs to market? Most promising is ‘‘dry testing’’ of drugs by supercomputer simulations, a new field called computational biology. There are no ethical problems when messing around with silicon.
Testing New Drugs—Are People Guinea Pigs?
121
Interviews with Expert Participants Alexander Capron From the point of view of a bioethicist, where are we heading in this century? I haven’t seen many indications of major developments in ethics. There are obviously enormous developments in science. Right now we’re debating what to do about stem cells, adult stem cells and embryonic stem cells; I think they hold enormous promise. There are complex issues about the use of the somatic nuclear transfer techniques—cloning—both to produce stem cells and, more radically, to produce people or parts of people. This technology, which is coming, will have a totally transformative effect—probably not for the good, potentially remaking the relationship of generations in ways for which we really have no analogies. Do you think humans need to be the subjects for drug tests? Anything that can reduce the use of living human beings as subjects, anything that offers the prospect of learning more about drugs with less human risk, will of course be advantageous. (For example, more sophisticated experiments that use animals which have been genetically engineered with functioning human genes that express the diseased condition being assessed.) However, for quite a while, maybe forever, scientists are going to conclude that the only experimental animal on which human beings can ultimately rely is human beings. We will still be required, in the end, to test drugs or the biologics with human subjects. But with computational biology, the use of embryonic stem cells, and other tissue-culture methods—as we learn more about these, they will offer great prospects for doing drug assessments with less risk to human beings.
Robert Temple How did you come to work at the FDA? I came to the agency in 1972. I had been at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) for a few years, and having actually thought of myself as a consumer advocate, I wanted to go to where the decisions about medicines are made. In those days, no one went to the FDA knowing what working there was going to be like, but it turned out to be just fascinating. I have been pleased with our work and have stayed ever since. My particular specialty has been how to design trials that give you the answers you want. There are many issues involved and these constitute most of my writings. Recently, I have become involved in some ethical issues that have arisen relating to the use of placebos in clinical trials, which is intimately connected with what
122
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
kind of experimental design of clinical trials gives the optimum answers we need to introduce new, save, effective drugs.
Andrea Kovacs Your specialty is pediatric AIDS. Talk about your successes. The most significant development in the last five years in HIV, the human immunodeficiency virus, is the prevention of perinatel transmission of HIV —meaning the passing of HIV from mother to baby during pregnancy or at time of birth. When I started in this field, about 28 percent of babies were infected. And through large-scale clinical trials we were able to demonstrate that we could prevent transmission from mother to baby almost completely. We are moving to transfer these techniques internationally, so that we can, hopefully, effect similar success around the world in eliminating HIV transmission to babies. Do you think the general public understands what’s going on in HIV these days? The general public is now beginning to understand the impact of research. Going back 10 years, up-to-date, unemotional information was that not accessible in the media. But we have made significant progress in presenting accurate information about current research, how it is conducted, and how it has really benefited the public. How would you like to be remembered? I have two kids and a husband. I would like to be remembered both as a good mother and a good wife, and as a good doctor and a good scientist. I would especially like to be remembered as someone who helped patients locally in our community.
Chapter 9
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
Galaxies, stars, planets, molecules, living things, intelligence—how did all this develop from the simple soup of primordial particles swimming in the early universe? The answer may be Complexity and Emergence—just watch what these two powerful principles can do. The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that all closed systems tend towards disorder. Nonetheless, highly ordered pockets of matter and energy arise—just look at human beings and all that we encompass. How can order and structure develop spontaneously? By what mechanisms can seemingly random events lead to highly developed entities? How can simple rules governing the interaction between particles give rise to life and awareness? Theories of Complexity and Emergence are two of the most powerful principles that purport to explain just how billions of years of random history have produced ever more order and structure in the universe and in life. What is Complexity, and how has it generated the world around us? What is Emergence, and how does it explain the unpredictable properties of things from molecules to brains? This episode explores one of the greatest challenges facing science at the beginning of the twenty-first century: how do we account for the evolution of the universe, an evolution that includes the appearance of life on earth, even though we know that the universe relentlessly moves towards a state of disorder? Both guests, each a Nobel laureate, contend that with so much knowledge being uncovered today, we should be prepared to develop a new way to explore this crucial question. They suggest we unify the sciences through the creation of a new set of trans-disciplinary skills. A potential positive outcome of this integration could lead, they posit, to more practical problem solving, such as the search for a cure for AIDS.
124
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
The second half of the twentieth century saw the explanatory explosion of molecular biology, the technique of studying the component parts of cells and biologically active molecules in order to discern their mechanisms. Yet the study of Complexity recognizes that only by studying the interactions between these elements and their environment can the true behavior of the system be seen, understood, and predicted. David Baltimore takes his prodigious knowledge of biology and details how the DNA molecule’s complexity is integral to producing and maintaining an ordered living organism. Murray Gell-Mann, whose distinguished career includes the theory of elementary particles and the discovery of the quark (both of which form the bedrock of fundamental physics), discusses Emergence with all the joy of a scientist making his first original discovery. ‘‘The wonderful thing about emergence,’’ Gell-Mann says with sparkle, ‘‘is you don’t need something new to get something new!’’ Get enough things interacting with each other and something new naturally emerges.
Expert Participants David Baltimore Nobel Laureate in Physiology/Medicine; President, Professor of Biology, California Institute of Technology; Chairman, AIDS Vaccine Research Committee, NIH; founding director, Whitehead Institute for Biological Research, MIT.
Murray Gell-Mann Nobel Laureate in Physics; Distinguished Fellow and Co-Chairman of the Science Board, Santa Fe Institute; Emeritus Professor of Physics, California Institute of Technology; Author, The Quark and the Jaguar: Adventures in the Simple and the Complex.
Robert Kuhn: The normal direction of explanation is to explain biology in terms of physics, but can we go in reverse? Can we discern principles of how the universe is structured by examining the principles of biology and then applying them to physics? David Baltimore: Scientists had hoped that there would be things in biology that were so surprising, so different than we had ever seen before that it would inform us about new laws. But the evidence does not support this. Murray Gell-Mann: There is a sense though in which something like that is happening: people sometimes say that the twentieth century was the century of physical science and the twenty-first century will be the century of life
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
125
sciences. The progress in the life sciences is fantastically impressive and very important, both intellectually and practically. I think the next few decades would better be characterized as the decades of the unity of the sciences. Restoration of the unity of the sciences, that’s what’s really happening. At the Santa Fe Institute (in New Mexico), the research is now transdiciplinary, with mathematicians and physicists and computer scientists together with neurobiologists, evolutionary biologists, ecologists, and paleontologists, all working together without any regard at all for disciplinary boundaries. David Baltimore: When I characterize the human genome it is not a ‘‘result’’; it is just a series of questions—what does this do? What does that do? What does that other piece do? But, instead of having what we had before, which was 20 questions, we now have 30 or 40 thousand questions [the number of genes]. In fact, in a sense, we have three billion questions, which is the number of all the nucleotides in the genome. And to deal with this level of complication requires new techniques, new ways of handling data, new ways of gathering data, new ways of analyzing data, and biologists are not good at any of that. We’ve never had to deal with problems like that. But, astrophysicists have had to deal with these amounts of data, and computer scientists have, and so we’re bringing them in. The intellectual strength of all of these other areas of the physical and mathematical now becomes absolutely central to the progress of biology. Murray Gell-Mann: Until a few years ago, Harold Varmus was the Director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), operating out of Washington, and of course that’s the part of the scientific establishment for which it is easiest to get money from Congress because every person in the House or the Senate either has an illness or has a relative or a friend who has an illness. But Harold went around making speeches saying, don’t give me all the money allocated for science; sciences are a unity, they are all interdependent, and they all need support. I thought that was wonderful. David Baltimore: For biology to progress it is important that chemistry and physics and all of the other sciences also progress, particularly engineering, because they provide the new tools, the new ways of doing things. And that’s what’s happening; that’s where the unity extends from the ‘‘hard sciences’’ of physics and chemistry to the biological and social sciences. Murray Gell-Mann: Most real issues that we encounter in life involve all of these areas of knowledge. In any real situation, all come together, and yet the tendency is to divide things up between the humanities, say, and the sciences. David Baltimore: Of course, most science, historically, has not dealt with real issues and hasn’t even wanted to. Traditionally, science has concerned itself with artificial issues because they’re complicated enough, they’re hard
126
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
enough to solve, never mind solving a real problem. I’ve been involved with the HIV virus now for some long time, and one is faced with a real problem like this, there’s no hiding from it—there is a virus and this virus is killing people, it’s spreading across the world, and you must deal with this realworld problem. I have gained tremendous respect for the difficulty of solving a practical problem. Whereas, historically, I was brought up in science to say the tough problems are the theoretical problems or the conceptual problems in science. And I still think they are tough but I’ve learned to have a lot of respect for practical problems. Robert Kuhn: The early universe swarmed with simple, chaotic particles, yet today we have complicated, orderly things like DNA molecules. How did that all happen? Murray Gell-Mann: There are several things that you have to talk about to illuminate that issue. One is the initial condition of the universe, and another is the way that complexity has arisen thereafter. Order in the early universe is the governing circumstance. And it’s that order that has been responsible for the gradually increasing average disorder. Robert Kuhn:
That sounds like a paradox.
Murray Gell-Mann: I think we can throw some light on it. The key principle is called the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which has been understood now for more than a century and states that in a closed system, such as the universe, the average disorder keeps increasing. David Baltimore: Life is a little bit of aggregated order in the midst of a continuing tendency to disorder. Our perception is of increasing order, because you look back not too long ago and there was no intelligent life on Earth. And so we’ve seen this highly ordered thing, the brain, evolve over a relatively short period of time to do remarkable things, and so our perception is of increasing order and yet, underlying it, there has to be, by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, decreasing order. Murray Gell-Mann: But even though the average disorder in the universe has been increasing ever since its beginning, this increasing disorder is not occurring at every particular place in the universe. You can have local order created in certain locations at the expense of greater disorder somewhere else. Take your refrigerator as an example. You have ice cubes in the freezer that are certainly a manifestation of a great deal of order, but if you go around to the back of the refrigerator there’s a lot of hot air coming out indicating that the ‘‘cost’’ of the order of ice cubes is paid by a greater amount of disorder somewhere else. So that’s the way the creation of local order is perfectly compatible with the Second Law of Thermodynamics, but there’s another process at work as well—we have to distinguish ‘‘complexity’’ from ‘‘order,’’ they’re not exactly the same thing.
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
Robert Kuhn:
127
Let’s define complexity, which is an important concept.
Murray Gell-Mann: Right. I work with something that I call ‘‘effective complexity,’’ which I think best captures what we mean by complexity when we talk about it in ordinary conversation or even in most scientific discourse. In popular terms, the idea is that ‘‘effective complexity’’ is the length of a very compressed, very concise description of the regularities of something, not the random aspects that are treated as random or incidental. In most circumstances, to determine effective complexity requires judgment of what’s important and what’s not important, but there has to be some test that discriminates the important from the not important. To take a practical example, the U.S. Tax Code is complex, it has lots and lots and lots and lots of rules, of regularities and it’s very complex. And every rule is a regularity. Even the exceptions are rules, too. Everything in there is a regularity, and it’s very complex. The classic case is signal and noise. In the 1930s scientists at Bell Laboratories in New Jersey, were asked to study where static came from, and they found that it came from particular places in the sky, and that gave rise to radio astronomy. The static contained elements of regularity, but they also had to recognize that the static had this regularity. So you have to attribute anything that you see to a combination of regularity and randomness. Robert Kuhn: We all have the impression that in so many domains of experience, we’re seeing things of increasing complexity arising—it’s true of living things, it’s true of our daily lives, it’s true of computers, it’s true of all kinds of things. What’s the reason for that? Murray Gell-Mann: One can’t say, of course, that each individual thing has a tendency to get more complex. This isn’t true: people die, civilizations die, they become less complex. But what does seem to be true in a lot of places is that more and more complex things come into existence. And to seek the deep reason for why more complex things come into existence is to get into another very important property of the world, namely, the fundamental laws, which we believe to be very simple. The most important source of order is in the two fundamental laws of physics: the first is the Law of the Elementary Particles that describes how matter behaves, and the second is the initial condition of the universe, some 14 billion years ago. But these two fundamental laws, both of which we think may be simple, don’t determine the history of the universe. The fundamental laws are probabilistic. All they do is define probabilities for alternative possible histories of the universe, and then everything else that follows depends on an inconceivably long sequence of accidents, or chance events, that could go in any one of various ways, with the alternative histories of the universe forming a branching tree, with probabilities growing at all the branchings. The actual history of the universe, then, is codetermined by the fundamental law of the
128
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
elementary particles and the initial condition of the universe as developed by this fantastically long sequence of probabilities. And this long sequence of probabilities of chance events means that the result is hugely dependent on those accidents. Most of the information content of the universe lies in those accidents. Robert Kuhn:
You’ve called them ‘‘frozen accidents.’’
Murray Gell-Mann: They give rise to very significant regularities. For example, our galaxy was probably formed by some tiny, little random fluctuation in the early universe, not of great cosmic importance, but to anything in this galaxy, like us, it’s pretty important that our galaxy came into existence. And that little fluctuation in the early universe is a very important regularity for all of us that are in this galaxy. Robert Kuhn:
With very long term consequences.
Murray Gell-Mann:
With very long term consequences, right.
Robert Kuhn: Then we go from complexity to ‘‘complex adaptive systems.’’ How do we make that transition? Murray Gell-Mann: They are two slightly different definitions of complex adaptive system—mine and my friend John Holland’s. Robert Kuhn:
We’ll take yours.
Murray Gell-Mann: The fact that we have different definitions just illustrates the famous principle that a scientist would rather use someone else’s toothbrush than someone else’s nomenclature. Robert Kuhn:
Define complex adaptive systems.
Murray Gell-Mann: For me, it’s a system that takes in certain kinds of information and finds certain kinds of regularities in that information, and then condenses or compresses the description of those regularities into what I call a ‘‘schema,’’ and in that schema, then, you have the possibility for the system to describe certain aspects of reality, including itself, and to predict certain things that will happen in the real world and to prescribe behavior for the system in the real world. And then the circumstances in the real world exert selection pressures back on that schema, to which the schema reacts and changes or adapts. This means that an individual organism is a complex adaptive system, and biological evolution as a whole is also a complex adaptive system. Robert Kuhn:
Is the brain an example of a complex adaptive system?
Murray Gell-Mann: David Baltimore:
Yes.
The immune system is a complex adaptive system.
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
129
Murray Gell-Mann: The Santa Fe Institute, together with Los Alamos, is responsible for big advances in theoretical immunology. You’ve heard of the wonderful work of Dr. David Ho, for example; the theory was done in Santa Fe and Los Alamos David Baltimore: These principles are at work in virology. In HIV what happens in a single infected person is a whole evolutionary process that can be described using exactly the same principles that we use to describe the evolution of species. Robert Kuhn: Thus we need to integrates multiple disciplines, from fundamental to evolutionary levels in order to understand one disease, here HIV. David Baltimore: Right. HIV has actually spawned a tremendous amount of very interesting science. Unfortunately, we haven’t yet gotten what we need to gain control over the disease. Murray Gell-Mann: In the sciences of complexity, and in the study of chaos and related phenomena in nonlinear systems dynamics, we’re often looking at all sorts of actual situations intermediate in scale between the cosmology of the universe and the subatomic world of elementary particles: for example, the growth of real cities or the spread of real pediatric AIDS, the things with which we come into contact as human beings. Here, again, we find interesting regularities that transcend the disciplines. Robert Kuhn:
Is the DNA molecule a complex adaptive system?
Murray Gell-Mann: The DNA molecule is an examples of the schema type that I’m talking about. It reflects a huge amount of experience condensed into a very, very compressed description. David Baltimore: The DNA molecule is able to direct the development of a living organism: there’s information about where to make the proteins, how to make the proteins, how to modify the protein, the timing of events, the whole timing of development so that you start with a fertilized egg and end up with a human being or a frog or a plant. So the DNA molecule is enormously more complex in its representation of information than is usually appreciated. Basically, the universe evolved just like organisms evolved. Murray Gell-Mann: I don’t think so, because the whole point about biological evolution is that it is a complex adaptive system, and there’s a schema, and the schema compresses a lot of information about the outside world and about the system itself. And then that schema, together with a lot of other information, is used to predict or to prescribe behavior in the real world, and the outside world exerts selection pressures that favor certain schemas over others—and this is the way you get biological evolution. The same process is at work in cultural evolution. But in the physical universe, we don’t know that there is such a thing.
130
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
David Baltimore: At the heart of selection is variation, because you can’t select unless you have variation. The variation, to a first approximation, is random. So, you have exactly the same sort of development of history within living organisms that you have in the universe. There could be any kind of organisms in the world. There is nothing about the laws of biology or physics, and nothing in the laws of biology, that require of necessity for us to be here today. We could be very different than we are. Murray Gell-Mann:
Yes.
David Baltimore: This means that the outcome is the same sort of question. How many different outcomes of life could there have been? If we could observe the evolution of life on another planet, we would see an entirely different outcome of this process of variation and selection. Evolution would generate something that looks so different that you probably couldn’t recognize it as life. Murray Gell-Mann: You are absolutely right, but my point is a slightly different one: not all types of evolution can be described in terms of a schema that evolves by variation and selection. For life, yes, of course, but for galactic evolution or for the evolution of a star or a planet, we don’t have any evidence that these same kind of things happens. We have no evidence that they occur as a complex adaptive system. Robert Kuhn: Let’s talk about the concept of emergence. Is the living cell an example of emergence? David Baltimore: As a living, independent entity, the cell depends on all sorts of complex interactions within itself so that the cell can build up and form many cells and ultimately form an organism and differentiate itself to form something as complex as human beings. And we call this process ‘‘emergence,’’ because it is something so new that it is entirely different than the sum of all of its little constituent parts. Murray Gell-Mann: The whole point of emergence is you don’t need something new to get something new. It is so much nicer to study each science at its own level and find the regularities that jump to your eye at that level. That’s what emergence is all about. Robert Kuhn: What will twenty-first century science be about? How do you see the next two decades? David Baltimore: I think it might not be a bad idea to develop secret antibiotics that we have in our arsenal which nobody except a select group knows how they work. In this way, terrorists can’t design resistance to them. Unfortunately we have to be thinking this way.
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
131
Murray Gell-Mann: I think it’s not impossible that progress in fundamental physics will discern the basic laws and discover the unified theory of all the particles and all the interactions, including the initial condition of the universe. Robert Kuhn:
What about the ultimate stability of matter?
Murray Gell-Mann: That’s very exciting. Most of us theorists believe that the proton will eventually be found to decay, and at a level not very far from the existing limit. Robert Kuhn:
Is that bad news for us?
Murray Gell-Mann: It is bad news because it means that all the regularities regarding the existence of atoms and molecules, including our existence, will disappear. In addition, well before this ultimate disintegration, it may well be that the envelope of complexity will start shrinking instead of expanding. David Baltimore: Which will destroy us first, the second law of thermodynamics or proton decay? Murray Gell-Mann: In any case, the good news is that it will take something like 1035 years. So it’s not our most urgent problem. Robert Kuhn:
But it’s fundamentally, theoretically, important.
Murray Gell-Mann:
Yes.
Robert Kuhn: Let’s go back to the brain, which I call the most complex organization of matter in the universe. David Baltimore: The brain offers us a great many problems that we don’t know how to approach today but for which theory plays an important role. Murray Gell-Mann: The binding problem is an example of that. Take visual sensations: color, the direction of motion, the shape and so forth are all processed differently by different parts of the brain, and yet, somehow, we get the sensory impression that there is a unified thing there that has a certain color, is moving in a certain direction at a certain speed, has a certain shape and so forth. So that all these separate kinds of information, which are processed differently, are brought together and bound together. How is that done? David Baltimore: To make the problem even more complicated, and more fascinating, the different sensory modalities take different amounts of time to produce their images. I hit something and you hear the sound and you see it at exactly the same time, but they were processed over different periods of time in your brain and then bound together. So the binding problem is not just about different modalities, it’s actually taking different perceptions from different times and fitting them together so that they make cognitive unity.
132
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn:
What questions do you think about at night?
David Baltimore: As a scientist, you are often thinking about very dull and mundane questions that come together to form something which you hope is larger than you expect. When I was an experimentalist in the laboratory, I’d go to sleep thinking about why the experiment that I did today didn’t work. Did I use the wrong reagent, perhaps even the wrong glassware? Was I using the wrong analytic method, or was I thinking about the problem in the wrong way? You never know at what level a problem exists, and so you’re thinking about all possible explanations at once, trying to figure out which one you can vary in the lab the next day to determine what is really happening in your experiment. You are always trying to find out whether you on are to something trivial or important. Murray Gell-Mann: It’s the same with theory. You worry about why your theory doesn’t seem to be working, doesn’t seem to be agreeing with the real world; you worry about which aspect of the theory you have to change. Sometimes, the critical breakthrough comes by finding some accepted principle that simply isn’t so, to go ‘‘outside the box’’ of traditional thinking, to go outside of regularly approved ideas in order to find that variant that will work. But you better make sure that there isn’t some very good reason for that box of traditional thinking. Mostly when you’re outside the traditional box of science, you’re doing ‘‘crank science,’’ but every once in a while you find that there is an accepted limitation that is not a real limitation. Einstein, for example, found that absolute space and absolute time were a nuisance and there was no reason to have them. When I thought of ‘‘quarks,’’1 they had fractional charge—well, scientists didn’t like fractional charge very much, but I figured that these fractionally charged quarks would be stuck permanently inside of the neutron and proton. At first it was not a popular idea, but I realized that there was no real reason for the accepted dogma. David Baltimore: I had to accept the reversal of the flow of information in biological systems in order to explain how viruses were able to integrate into cells. The central dogma of the time was that biological information flows from DNA to RNA to proteins, and what we showed was that it could go in reverse direction, back from RNA to DNA. That was revolutionary. But when you think about it, it was sort of trivial chemistry to imagine that that could occur. There was nothing particularly revolutionary about what I discovered except for the fact that nobody was thinking that way. They were not even thinking about whether or not it was possible. Murray Gell-Mann: Robert Kuhn: science.
It was like a superstition.
But such reversals of common wisdom is very rare in
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
133
Murray Gell-Mann: You have to be careful: most of the time there are very good reasons why scientists don’t assume or consider certain things. But every once in a while, you come across an accepted idea that you mustn’t think about in a conventional way. It is just wrong, and when you look closely, you realize there’s no reason for it—and this is that rare kind of event that can be an opportunity to explain something that nobody could explain before.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary It seems like getting something for nothing, a free lunch. How can random movements, operating over time, yield highly developed things, like, say, planets and peanuts? We have looked at physics and biology together, and found two powerful principles that explain a good deal about how our world works. One is Complexity, which says that certain systems, as seemingly different as animal brains and stock markets, can never be understood by studying their individual elements in isolation—in this case, brain cells and stock traders. Only interactions can describe the entire system. The other is Emergence, which signifies an abrupt, unexpected change in the characteristics of systems, again like brains and markets, which are so startlingly different from the workings of their constituent elements, the innumerable brain cells and stock traders. Complexity and Emergence are overarching principles of how the world works, and although they can’t be classified in traditional areas of science, they engender what we call progress, whether in biological organisms or human culture. Why is there order in the universe? Complexity and Emergence, which 20 years ago sat on the periphery of scientific explanations, may now be the only way to explain the universe and all that is in it. Who knows what’s next: a new ice age? new mental capacities? a new stock market boom? As we understand more, maybe we can predict better.
Interviews with Expert Participants David Baltimore What’s going on in your field today? There is so much going on in biology today that is going to impact our future that I hardly know where to start. The development of drugs, the
134
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
development of prosthetic devices, the development of new forms of imaging, the ability to diagnose disease at very early stages—all these are going to have a huge impact on health care. Over the next few decades, a combination of new diagnostic methods and new treatment methods will revolutionize our approach to cancer. We will not recognize the lives of people—say, 30 years from now—in terms of how they worry about diseases, because there will be therapies for diseases that are today scourges. What do you think will be the next big discovery? The big discovery that I see coming down the track is the unraveling of the brain and its mechanisms—the ability to understand what kinds of information are coursing around in the brain, how they are encoded, and how to tap into them. I believe that we will figure out how to listen to the brain. This, I think, will be transformational. Can the brain imprint information into DNA? The brain consists of neurons. Neurons are cells. Every cell in the body, no matter what kind of cell it is, has a nucleus and the nucleus has chromosomes. And the chromosomes encode all of the information that enables the organism and the cell to grow, divide and specialize. So the brain, like every other part of the body, is determined by DNA. And the issue that we still don’t have closure on is whether any of what we call the information in the brain—our knowledge of our past, our capacity to solve problems, our awareness of self—is encoded in DNA. Now when I started working in this business, I assumed that the knowledge in the brain was at least partly, maybe very largely, encoded in DNA. And the model that I worked on, and I wasn’t alone in this, was the immune system. This was because the knowledge that the immune system has of the outside world is encoded in DNA. So we had one system, a Darwinian system in fact, in which DNA encoded the answer. Our thinking was that if DNA information encoding can work in immunology, why couldn’t it also work in the brain? Yet, everything that has happened in modern brain research has denied that solution. All the evidence point to the synapse as the locus of memory. Now do I believe that that is going to be the last word on the subject? No, I don’t. I think that the synapse does hold memory and we’re going to have to understand how that happens. We’re just beginning to understand that today. But I still believe that sooner or later the DNA in the neuron is going to play a role. I do not believe that memory will ever be as simple as one level of organization of synapse. It will be many levels of organization that work together.
How Does Order Arise in the Universe?
135
Will humans evolve into an unrecognizable species? If you read human history, to the extent that we have knowledge that goes back a few millennia, you understand exactly what people were saying in ancient Greece. In fact, the myths of ancient Greece are the myths of today. The plays of ancient Greece are performed today. People haven’t changed that much, even though we have seen many transformational technologies develop since the days of ancient Greece that have been truly monumental. None of this, as far as I’m concerned, has transformed human beings at all. We work faster now, we work more efficiently now, we move around more, we do all sorts of things better. But we are essentially still the same people we always were, flaws and all. Will we ever understand the basic laws of biology? The basic laws and rules of biology are, I think, relatively simple. First of all, they are the laws of chemistry. One can make the argument that they are almost entirely the laws of chemistry. And so to the extent that we can understand how molecules interact with each other, how chemical reactions occur, we understand most of how life works. But there are other levels, particularly of interaction of different systems in living organisms, that require a different kind of analysis—they are not just one by one analysis, they are analysis of the activity of multiple inputs. So we need to layer on top of our chemistry an understanding of how systems work together, a kind of systems organizations. But I don’t think there is anything terribly profound in any of that. The remarkable thing about the structure of DNA is that it is simple chemistry. When Watson and Crick discovered the structure of DNA, what they discovered was the structure of a chemical. And it was in a sense no different than the structure of any other chemical. It became vital only because it was the one molecule which evolution honed to play the central role in heredity. So what we learn when we go into biological systems is how powerful evolution is, how the inevitable generation of small variations and the natural selection of certain of those variations can lead to great tailoring of molecular behavior, to a particular end. But when you get down to analyzing how it works, it is never all that complex. Talk about heredity vs. environment. We know that no organism is born as a clean slate. All organisms have predispositions. But we also know that we learn a lot over our lifetimes, and that learning modifies the behavior of systems that we inherently have. In fact, the more we learn about how we visually process information, the more we realize that we are not simply looking at an image out in the world. We are taking all sorts of pieces, reconstructing the image, very much using our prior knowledge as a way of constructing the image that we are looking at. This means that prior knowledge, which we get from experience in our
136
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
environment, is actually feeding into structure the way we deal with something as simple vision (it’s not simple, of course). We are learning more and more about these cognitive interactions, between the way the system is wired and built, and what it knows intrinsically, and what it learns. And there will be debate for a long time about what percentage is intrinsic (‘‘nature’’) and what percentage is acquired (‘‘nurture’’). A debate about simple numbers is probably not a meaningful one, because the nature of the issue doesn’t lend itself to simple numbers. But there’s no question that we have enormous capabilities built into us. They come, hardwired, out of our genes. Why did you become a scientist? I became a scientist because I discovered when I was a young kid that I did science well. And I was smart enough to figure out that the way to enjoy at least some success in life is take the easiest route, that is, to do what you do well and take advantage of whatever endowments you have.
Murray Gell-Mann Why did you become a scientist? I became a scientist out of curiosity about regularities in the world. What are the key developments in your field? I think the most important developments in science today, both for the future of applications to specific questions in science and for the future of science itself, have to do with the reunification of the sciences. Many centuries ago, science or natural philosophy was in a sense a unified enterprise. It hadn’t yet become so specialized that you needed very different people to work on its very different aspects. Today, of course, specialization has gone a very long way and overall that’s a good thing. There is so much information, so much knowledge, so much understanding available that it has to be parceled out into fields and subfields, but along with that specialization there has to be some scientific activity that is integrative. And such efforts at unification, of cross and trans-disciplinary thinking, is occurring more and more. Scientists are recognizing the interdependence of all the sciences and the need for some scientific activity, especially theoretical activity, which is integrative. We try to meet that need at the Santa Fe Institute, and I think that this partial reunification of the sciences is perhaps the most important phenomenon in science today.
Note 1. Fundamental components of atomic particles for which discovery Murray GellMann won the Nobel Prize.
Chapter 10
How Weird is the Cosmos?
Why is the cosmos shocking? Dark matter fills the universe, controlling gravitation forces. Dark energy confounds gravity, causing the expansion of the universe to accelerate. And the laws of physics may not be forever. In recent years, waves of astonishing new discoveries have inundated cosmologists: a universe whose expansion is speeding up, not slowing down, contradicting all accepted theory; gravitational lenses revealing distant galaxies forming near the beginning of time; galactic jets shooting out thousands of light years; black holes with the mass of a billion suns lurking at the center of galaxies, swallowing entire stars in a single gravitational bite; a universe made more of dark matter than visible matter; dark matter candidates, strange and even stranger; dark energy, emerging from nothingness, controlling the destiny of the universe. And finally, even fundamental constants of nature, long thought stable, could possibly be changing. Cosmologists have been surprised by recent data. What does it all mean? Cosmology’s remarkable discoveries are revealing the deepest, most astonishing secrets of a luminous universe. The cosmos is indeed weirder that we think, even astronomers can hardly believe it! It’s so weird that four experts can only sit around and laugh as they outdo each other in trading stories about amazing findings and discoveries. Our group of distinguished physicists and astrophysicists outline the latest discoveries of how our universe began and continues to function, and marvel at how quickly the exotic and unusual can become commonplace. Not so long ago black holes were fantasy; now they are a given. They debate what could be behind the accelerating expansion of the universe: is there a new kind of energy, dubbed ‘‘dark energy,’’ that permeates empty space? They also explain current methods for measuring that expansion. The guests
138
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
finish their discussion by contemplating how a new generation of powerful telescopes and a digitized mapping of the universe could potentially alter our theories about the universe’s fundamental laws and transform the future of cosmic exploration in surprising ways.
Expert Participants Roger Blandford Professor of Theoretical Astrophysics, Stanford University (formerly at the California Institute of Technology); interests: black holes, gravitation, high-energy bursts.
David Goodstein Vice Provost, Professor of Physics and Applied Physics, and Distinguished Teaching and Service Professor, California Institute of Technology.
Alan Guth Professor of Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; discoverer, inflation theory in cosmology; author, The Inflationary Universe.
Neil deGrasse Tyson Director, Hayden Planetarium; member, Department of Astrophysics, American Museum of Natural History; visiting research scientist, Department of Astrophysics, Princeton University.
Robert Kuhn: Every few months, it seems, some new discovery or revelation in astrophysics and cosmology shocks me. Are you guys, the top professionals, shocked? David Goodstein: It’s the most amazing thing that, just a few years ago, black holes were considered a mathematical fantasy; there was no proof that any such thing existed. Now it is generally accepted every galaxy is condensed on a black hole the way every rain drop is condensed on a particle of dust. This has become so ordinary that we don’t even mention or discuss it in any way. Neil deGrasse Tyson: I agree 100 percent. The new discoveries came on quickly; scientists were rightly skeptical, but as the observations kept rolling in, there was no doubt about it. Roger Blandford: Another big surprise that we’ve discovered is very high energy cosmic rays, which are subatomic particles that have the energy of a well hit baseball!
How Weird is the Cosmos?
139
Alan Guth: I was genuinely surprised with the results that came out a few years ago that the expansion of the universe appears to be accelerating. Robert Kuhn: expansion.
The universe is not just expanding but accelerating in its
Alan Guth: The expansion of the universe is speeding up, and the best candidate for driving it—really the only sensible explanation that is currently on the table—is an energy that permeates empty space. This is exactly the kind of energy that causes acceleration, and the amount of acceleration that it would cause is exactly what’s seen in supernova observations—and when I use this word ‘‘exact,’’ I mean to an accuracy of about 10 percent. David Goodstein: An accuracy of 10 percent is a big improvement in astrophysics. I can remember when they used to tell us that the most important equation in astrophysics is one is approximately equal to 10. Neil deGrasse Tyson: One of our biggest challenges in astrophysics is that, since we can’t take a tape measure and measure distances to stars and we can’t travel there and read our odometers, we need to be much more clever about measuring distances in the universe. One of the most successful ways that astronomers have developed is to look around the galaxy and find a stellar event, which every time it happens, every time you see it, it’s the same, whether it occurs in our galaxy or in another galaxy. Since you know the one up close very well, then you can judge how far away the other one is by how much dimmer it appears to be (compared with the one you know). Robert Kuhn: If their absolute level is the same, the event, a gigantic supernova explosion, would be what is called a ‘‘standard candle.’’ Neil deGrasse Tyson: Exactly. Assume that we know that the supernova in our galaxy gives off the light of a 100-watt light bulb; then if I were to find a similar 100-watt light bulb in another galaxy and I see how much dimmer it is, I know how far away it has to be to be that dim. Robert Kuhn: Supernovas are rather brighter than 100-watt light bulbs; in fact they are brighter, for a few moments, than the entire galaxy in which they explode. Neil deGrasse Tyson: This enables supernovas to become our best known standard candles, which can enable us to calculate accurate distances to the most distant galaxies. And by doing this, we can measure the expansion of the universe, and based on that model, my standard candle equations tell me how bright each supernova ought to be. Robert Kuhn: In recent years, some of the most distant supernovas were turning out to be dimmer than predicted by the standard models of universal expansion.
140
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Neil deGrasse Tyson: The only way you can fit your curve through these dimmer standard candles is to be forced to the conclusion that we live in a universe whose expansion rate is accelerating. Alan Guth: This data is incredibly shocking, because from the point of view of fundamental physics, we just have no explanation of what this ‘‘dark energy,’’ the stuff that is causing the acceleration, might actually be. Robert Kuhn: Recent evidence suggests that dark energy makes up approximately 70 percent of the universe and dark matter makes up approximately 25 percent. This means that only about 4–5 percent of the universe is made of ordinary matter and energy, which includes all the atoms and radiations that comprise everything we see and know. Alan Guth: Dark energy is clearly the primary dominant component of the universe and we have no idea what it is. We don’t even understand ‘‘dark matter,’’ which is the second most dominant component. All we know things about is the third and smallest category of universal stuff—ordinary matter and energy. So there is a tremendous amount of mystery here. Roger Blandford: In cosmology, there’s a thrill a minute: we’re getting new discoveries all the time. We’re fortunate to be living at a time when these discoveries are being made at such a tremendous rate. This is a golden age of discovery in astronomy, driven largely driven by new technology being applied to observation. Neil deGrasse Tyson: The cosmos comes to us through telescopes and through particle accelerators, opening up vast new vistas of the universe that, prior to these instruments, our senses had no access to. For example, we discovered neutron stars and pulsars, which have the density equivalent of a herd of 50 million elephants crammed into a thimble. 50 million elephants are a thimble’s worth of neutron star. These are the kinds of ideas we have to contend with all the time. We have come to expect wild and crazy ideas emanating out of the cosmos; the threshold for what is ridiculous has to be quite high in the community of astrophysicists. Just look at how often we have been baffled and had to sort of grow out of our bafflement in order to get ready for the next set of discoveries. Robert Kuhn: All of the things we’re discussing regarding the expansion of the universe are building on a theory that Alan Guth came up with in the early 1980s and which revolutionized everyone’s understanding about how the universe began. Alan, please give us a brief summary of the ‘‘inflationary universe.’’ Alan Guth: The inflationary universe theory addresses the question that the conventional form of the Big Bang theory really just left out, which is the question of what caused the Bang, what started this enormous
How Weird is the Cosmos?
141
expansion. Inflation proposes that there would be a form of matter which would actually turn gravity on its head and make it repulsive, which is exactly what you need to start the universe expanding. Robert Kuhn:
When did inflation start and when did it end?
Alan Guth: Inflation lasted probably about 10-30 seconds, a number we’re not very certain about. 10-30, of course, is an almost infinitesimally small number, a decimal point and 29 zeros before you get to a one. Neil deGrasse Tyson: If you can’t imagine it, don’t worry, there’s nothing wrong with you; you’re still an okay person. Robert Kuhn: During that fleetingly brief moment, space expanded faster than the speed of light. Alan Guth: That’s right. The speed of light is an absolute barrier for a race. If any object has a race with a light beam, the light beam always wins, which means that nothing can travel faster than light. Nonetheless, if you imagine space as a plastic medium that’s stretching, general relativity places no limit whatever to how fast space can stretch, so this stretching does occur far faster than light. During this brief time of inflation the region of the entire vast universe that we now observe, everything that we can see with our most powerful telescopes, expands from a size smaller than that of a single proton at the start of that time to about the size of a marble at the end of that time. After this period of inflation (10-30 seconds in duration) ends, the universe continues to expand in its normal, currently observed manner until the present day. Robert Kuhn: What is it about human beings that we can look back 13, 14 billion years and describe events that are a billionth the size of a proton and 10-30 the duration of a second? David Goodstein: We have a deep faith in physics. Roger Blandford: It’s a long, historical pattern of people asking these questions. In ancient Greece, there were analogous questions being asked and in some sense analogous tools being employed, albeit in an extremely primitive manner, to try and discern the answers to these questions. It’s something perhaps deep in the human spirit to make these enquiries. Neil is right in that we’re forever being shocked by the universe and what it throws in our faces, but we shouldn’t forget that when we’re thinking about theoretical speculation, we’re still doing science. And the hard test of these theories is always observational predictions that become confirmed with observational data. Robert Kuhn: Let’s look at dark matter. Of all the matter in the universe, 90 percent is now said to be ‘‘dark.’’ Tell me what that means.
142
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Neil deGrasse Tyson: I’d rather word that slightly differently. To even assert that it is matter assumes that you know something about what it really is, and we don’t. Robert Kuhn: To be more precise, 90 percent of the gravity that we see at work in the universe—for example, in the rotational speed of stars around the centers of galaxies or the clustering of galaxies themselves—cannot be explained by aggregating all the normal matter that we can locate. Neil deGrasse Tyson: It is the case of ‘‘The Missing Matter’’—how do you know what’s missing if it’s not there? It’s a simple analysis, actually: there are two classic measurements that give rise to the missing matter. First, you measure how fast these galaxies are moving and that tells you how much mass is holding them together, because if there’s not enough mass, those speeds would have caused the galaxies to fly apart long ago. This means that you can calculate how much mass there must be from the speeds. Second, you just count up all the mass in the galaxies, stars and gasses, everything. Then you compare the two numbers: (i) the amount of mass that you calculated had to be there in order to keep the galaxies from flying apart, and (ii) the amount of mass that you can see. And what you find when you compare these two numbers is that the former, the amount of mass that is needed, is about a hundred times the size of the latter, the amount of mass that we can see. The only conclusion is that there is extra matter there that we can’t account for. This ‘‘dark matter’’ is not protons, neutrons, electrons—none of these classic particles you learn about in chemistry class. Alan Guth: Another important piece of evidence is from measurements of the non-uniformities in the cosmic background radiation, which we believe to be the afterglow of the heat of the original big bang by which the universe began. We can measure these non-uniformities at the level of one part in a hundred thousand, and because these have evolved as the universe has evolved, they have embedded in them many clues about the evolution and history of the universe. Neil deGrasse Tyson: The satellite Microwave Anisotropy Probe will map this cosmic microwave background with such precision that it’ll enable you to compare the pattern in one part of the sky with the pattern in another part. There is so much that we don’t know. For example, whether space is sort of ordinary, just continuing on, or whether it has multiple connections and folds to it, because if it is the latter, then the pattern over here will be exactly the pattern over there, which will tells us that the universe curves back in some loop, some donut or some sort of three dimensional Mo¨bius strip. This is the fanciful side of what that analysis might bring Alan Guth:
How about a pretzel universe.
Neil deGrasse Tyson:
It’s just strange. And we like strange things.
How Weird is the Cosmos?
143
David Goodstein: Not stranger than any of the other things we’ve been discovering in the past decade. Neil deGrasse Tyson: I keep trying to think what discovery could ever be as astounding to us as the Hubble telescope’s discovery that we live in a universe whose expansion is accelerating. That was extraordinary, astonishing. David Goodstein: Just think of what happened. In 1916 Albert Einstein works a theory and equations, all by himself, which have a natural prediction that the universe is expanding. But he doesn’t believe it, because none of the observational data in astronomy suggested such a wild idea. So Einstein adds to his theory and equations an artificial term, something he called the cosmological constant, which was supposed to prevent the universe from expanding. Then the great astronomer Edwin Hubble discovered from his photographic plates, taken by his giant new telescope, that the universe was, in fact, expanding. So Einstein calls his cosmological constant the biggest mistake of his scientific career. And now we’ve got it back again to explain this acceleration of the expansion of the universe. Neil deGrasse Tyson: So Einstein’s biggest blunder was saying that it was his biggest blunder. Robert Kuhn: Clearly everything we’re talking about requires the set of fundamental laws of physics. Recent data seems to suggest that some of these fundamental laws, some of these constants of nature, may be changing over time? Roger Blandford: There have been reports that one of the famous constants of nature, which is called the fine structure constant, may be changing slightly over time. Robert Kuhn:
What is the fine structure constant?
Roger Blandford: It’s a combination of the speed of light and the charge on the electron; it’s a famous constant that every physicist knows. David Goodstein: If the fine structure constant is changing, it means that the charge on the electron is not constant, and then that means that chemistry is changing all the time. We tend to think that the laws of physics are eternal, and such stunning news would indicate that not even the laws of chemistry are eternal. What a shock that would be! Robert Kuhn:
What would be the implications?
David Goodstein: There has to be a fine balance among the constants of nature for lots of things, including for planets and people to even exist. If the fine structure constant were to change by very much, we would probably become impossible. And, of course, we would prefer that not to be the case.
144
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Neil deGrasse Tyson: There’s an important point here. We’re talking about a difference in the fine structure constant from long ago. Whatever it is today, we’re here, so, we’re okay with its current value. If it had a different value back then, that would fly in the face of our expectations, but there’s nothing in principle that would prevent us from modeling the way in which it has changed over time and then reinterpret the statements we’ve made about the early universe. Just to put that in historical perspective, it’s important to realize science advances not by throwing a successful theory out the window, it advances by recognizing that successful theories are a subset of a larger, deeper understanding. People often erroneously refer to Einstein as he who threw Newton out the window so that now we have a new way of thinking about the universe. That imagery doesn’t quite capture the reality. If you look at Einstein’s equations of motion and of gravity, in low gravity and at low speeds, all of his equations look exactly like those of Newton. It is only under conditions of very high gravity and very high speeds that the differences surface. David Goodstein: That’s a very good point regarding both relativity and quantum mechanics—both are more fundamental descriptions of the universe that cover wider ranges of conditions. It’s not true that Einstein showed that Newton was wrong, instead it showed why he was right: Einstein showed that Newton’s laws arise out of even more fundamental laws that cover a wider range of experience. Robert Kuhn: Let’s look forward. We’ve been looking back to the beginning of the universe, some 13 or 14 billion years ago. How far can we look ahead? What are the kinds of predictions we can say about the future of the universe and, indeed, the end of the universe? Neil deGrasse Tyson: First on our horizon is the colossal merger of our Milky Way galaxy with the Andromeda Galaxy; that will happen in five or six billion years. Watching that happen will be fun for our far-future ancestors (if they will exist), seeing the galaxies get closer and closer. What a collisional ballet that will be. After that the acceleration of the universe will increase to the point where all nearby galaxies that are currently undergoing the accelerating expansion will have disappeared beyond our visual horizon. At that point we will be sitting in a small collection of stars, or whatever they are at that time, and we’ll see nothing else in the universe, because everything else would have been accelerated beyond our horizon. And I wonder if that time were this time, how would those simple observational facts have influenced our theories of the universe. There would be no other galaxies; there would be nothing else to see other than our local system. Robert Kuhn: How do we know that in some sense such a circumstance hasn’t already happened? Perhaps many things that exist in vastness of all reality have already passed beyond our capacity to see or discern them
How Weird is the Cosmos?
145
Neil deGrasse Tyson: This is the scary part; this is the scary part. Perhaps the state we are in now is the consequence of some other catastrophic phenomenon that occurred long before we were around to see it. Alan Guth: Let me answer that wild question by also taking a jump of maybe 10 billion light years off to the side. One of the curious things about inflation is that once this inflationary process starts, it never really stops. There is this peculiar material or force or field that’s driving the universe’s exponential expansion, as a result of the repulsive gravity that it creates. What happens is the material that’s driving the expansion is unstable so in some places it decays and forms normal matter, and these regions become normal universes. But it decays like a radioactive substance with a half-life, so if you wait the half-life of this material, half of it will have decayed, in a sense it will become normal matter. But unlike normal radioactive material, this strange material is exponentially expanding at the same time, so in the same half-life, the half that remains (that did not decay into ordinary matter) grows to be much larger than what was there in the first place. The expanding material goes on literally producing new universes forever. So although our universe will very likely have the fate of ultimate emptiness, this emptiness will be only for our region of the universe, because meanwhile, elsewhere, in virtually an infinite number of places, new, young universes are sprouting up and developing. Robert Kuhn: You made a jump and I missed how you did it. We had inflation going—I followed that—then we had a myriad of new universes coming out of that. I was listening carefully but I missed how that happened. Alan Guth: During inflation, the universe is undergoing exponential expansion, which every so often is doubling. It just so happens that the doubling time is about 10-37 seconds or some ridiculously minuscule time like that. So, every 10-37 seconds, the universe doubles in size. Then, in a slightly longer time scale, 10-34, a piece of the universe breaks off and becomes a new universe while the rest of the old universe goes on exponentially expanding, and then another piece breaks off and becomes a new universe, and on and on. And because the universe continues to double and redouble, even though pieces of it are constantly breaking off, it continues to get bigger and bigger. This would be the very history of our universe during the inflationary period. Robert Kuhn: moment?
Is that happening now or only during the early inflationary
Alan Guth: Our universe is one of these pieces that split off; when it split off it was probably a large region, but, within that, there was something the size of a marble that became everything that we observe today. Once it splits off, it’s been expanding ever since, even if slowed after that by ordinary gravity.
146
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: We’re the original stuff that had this inflation; we’re the marble came out of it. Alan Guth:
Exactly right.
Neil deGrasse Tyson: This multiplicity of universes allows us to reemphasize the Copernican principle for our own existence. If you’re spawning universes like they are rabbits, most universes would be inhospitable to life, because carbon life as we know it could not exist; under different laws and conditions, chemistry would be completely different. So you can have a multitude of cosmoses, of universes, perhaps only one of which is suitable for life, which is the one we happen to be in. Robert Kuhn: This is not as surprising as it first may seem, since only in a universe where we do exist are we around to analyze the universe. (This is one formulation of what is called the Anthropic Principle.) David Goodstein: There may be life in many kinds of universes, based on different chemistries. There is no reason why life couldn’t be based, say, on silicon rather than on carbon. Alan Guth: It is likely that only a very small fraction of the universes would become suitable for life, but since there are an infinite number of universes, whatever that fraction is yields a very large number. Neil deGrasse Tyson: Every time we play around with the fundamental constants, we get something that we know wouldn’t reproduce life as we know it. Alan Guth:
It always bothers me tacking on that phrase ‘‘As We Know It.’’
Neil deGrasse Tyson:
Why does that bother you?
Alan Guth: Because if we’re trying to ask why is the universe the way it is, some people say it has to be the way it is or else life, as we know it, would not exist. But if life of a different form existed—life as we don’t know it— that can still be part of a perfectly plausible universe. Roger Blandford: We’ve already demonstrated that, as far as inanimate things are concerned, our imagination has been rather limited, so there’s no reason why we shouldn’t be equally limited as far as animate things are concerned. Alan Guth: We have a strong tendency to define the word ‘‘universe’’ to mean anything that looks like everything else that we see. But the theory of cosmological inflation strongly suggests that everything we see and know is just a minuscule, fleetingly tiny fraction of everything that really exists. Robert Kuhn: How do you see the next 10 years in this time of dramatic new observations and new data in astronomy?
How Weird is the Cosmos?
147
Roger Blandford: There is still a tremendous amount of discovery to be made in astronomy and cosmology. One of the opportunities is in gravitational radiation. These are, if you like, waves, rather like light or radio waves, but they’re waves of gravity that have ripples in space and time. Gravity waves interact very weakly with matter but they can be detected by extremely delicate lasers and mirrors. At this moment, there are telescopes under construction on the ground and plans for putting similar telescopes in space, which we hope will soon measure this gravitational radiation. After that, perhaps a second or third generation gravitational telescope will be able to see gravitational radiation produced from the very earliest times of the big bang, perhaps even going back to the time of inflation. Neil deGrasse Tyson:
50 years, 100 years?
Roger Blandford: I wouldn’t dare put a date on it. It could be a lot sooner than that if we can find innovative new ways to look at these microwave background fluctuations from when the universe was about half a million years old, perhaps looking at them in a way that you might look at the sun through Polaroid sunglasses. This microwave radiation cold turn out to be a messenger from the very early universe, too. And if the right sort of patterns are seen in that polarization, that could also be confirmatory evidence for the stories that are told about the very early universe. Alan Guth: In terms of observations, there are two other exciting things going on now. One is the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, which is a much more massive survey of galaxies and their positions than ever before available; this data will allow us to do a lot of statistical tests in terms of the distribution of matter in the universe. This distribution data is also a tool for finding exotic objects, which can be a lot of fun. For example, one type of exotic occurrence that they’re looking for is the presence of two quasars very nearby each other. If we find them, then what they allow you to do is to observe the light coming along the line of sight from these quasars and you can measure the absorption of light by atoms in between. And these observations give you not only the description of the matter everywhere along each line of sight, but they also allow you to see left to right; for example, if there’s a cloud of a certain type that you’re seeing in one beam, is it also seen in the other beam? And, statistically, then you can learn, in this example, how big these clouds are, which in turn allows you to discern a lot about where the clouds are. Furthermore, the apparent size of the clouds can give clues about the geometry of the universe as a whole. This is really very exciting stuff! Neil deGrasse Tyson: I liken the Sloan Digital Sky Survey to the old days of the classical explorers, when the Renaissance explorers were mapping the Earth’s surface, coming to some understanding of the nature of our home and backyard. I see this enterprise, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, and those that came before it that were smaller in scope, as the inevitable extension
148
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
of this mapping efforts. First we were mapping our own Earth; now we are mapping the cosmos. David Goodstein: With all of the astonishing things that we’ve talked about today, this is not the biggest revolution in the history of cosmology. There was a time when we believed that we were the center of the universe, that the universe existed entirely for us. And we had a set of laws of physics that made sense, but it only made sense so long as that our centrality in the universe was true. And then Copernicus came along and ripped us out of the center of the universe, destroying everything we understood. Suddenly, there was no basis for any physics of any kind. And in a very short period of time, about 150 years, which is only five or six generations of scientists, we had put it all back together again. But we were no longer the center of the universe; we were living on a speck of dust in an undistinguished galaxy somewhere in some corner of one of the inestimable and unfathomable number of universes. Neil deGrasse Tyson: There might be some theory yet to emerge that will give us an understanding of dark matter, dark energy, Alan Guth’s ‘‘rabbit’’ universes, some theory that might come forth that connects all of this together. We will then be looking back on these times, laughing at how quaint our ignorance was. Robert Kuhn: Don’t we yet feel grand by being able to exalt in our understanding? Even though we’re not in the center, we are part of such enormity. Neil deGrasse Tyson: I feel grand. I do because I don’t feel smaller, I feel bigger, because it’s the collective minds of all of us, the human species, that figured this stuff out, and that’s extraordinary. For me, the unheralded discovery of the twentieth century, which I carry with me every waking moment, is the recognition that the very chemistry of our bodies were forged in the centers of supernovae, stars that exploded, that gave their lives to the enrichment of the galaxy, out of which formed new stars and planets and people. So, it’s not so much that we’re in the universe, the universe is in us.
Robert Kuhn End Commentary Dark matter, dark energy, black holes, an expanding universe that’s accelerating—these are astounding discoveries of a radically new reality. But I’m intrigued by something more: Human beings, though limited by a modest home planet and barely 500 years of serious science, have crafted an elegant timeline of the cosmos, exploring back billions of years with startling detail and forecasting ahead trillions of years with breath-taking perspective. Einstein said, ‘‘The eternal mystery about the world is its comprehensibility.’’ As the prescient biologist J.B.S. Haldane remarked, ’’The universe is
How Weird is the Cosmos?
149
not only queerer than we imagine, it is queerer than we can imagine.’’ As a species, human beings have achieved scientific critical mass, and who knows where this knowledge explosion will take us?
Interviews with Expert Participants Alan Guth Talk about the advances in your field. Cosmology has made tremendous progress in the past 15 years. People don’t have the opportunity to appreciate the level of detail that cosmologists think they have in understanding the universe and the ways we have of testing our theories. For example, we have the Big Bang theory, which says the universe started as a hot, expanding ball. That means much more to theoretical physicists who can actually calculate how fast the universe was expanding at any time, what the temperature would have been at any given time, what the density of matter would have been at any time. It’s a really quantitative theory. And we physicists know enough about nuclear physics to actually calculate what the rates of the different reactions would have been under the conditions we’ve calculated for the early universe. With all those independent strands of knowledge put together, we can accurately predict the abundances of about four or five of the lightest chemical elements around today, and our prediction agrees with what the astronomers predict, even though the calculations we do are based on nuclear physics experiments and theirs are based on astronomical measurements. But the theory and the measurements nonetheless agree! I find that astounding and I think it really means that we two groups are on to something here.
Neil deGrasse Tyson Will we ever look back to the Big Bang? We’re getting closer and closer to understanding what was going on right at the Big Bang. We have laws of physics that get us pretty close to the beginning, but not all the way to the beginning, and certainly not before the beginning. There are frontiers right now that offer tantalizing clues that perhaps we live in just one cosmic bubble of an infinite number of bubbles. We’re coming close to being able to ask and answer those questions theoretically and observationally, and I look forward to defining conclusions the next 20 to 50 years, as the string theorists come forth with more clever statements
150
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
about what went on right at the first singularity, right at that first moment of the big bang. When we find gravity waves, what will they tell us? The Big Bang is currently our most verified and supported theory for the origin of the cosmos, but there are several barriers to looking all the way back to the start of the clock. One of them is an optical barrier, and that’s seen in the famous cosmic microwave background. Right now, there is a wall of microwaves that emanates from everywhere in the cosmos that’s a leftover light signal from the original explosion. But that light hails from about 300,000 years after the moment of the initial explosion, so using ordinary telescopes we have no hope of seeing any earlier than that. There is no way we can penetrate that wall anymore than you have any hope of looking through a smoked, opaque glass and describing details happening on the other side. The optical boundary is impassable, but all hope is not lost. There are other kinds of telescopes; for example, one that detects neutrinos. Neutrinos don’t have that wall problem. They emanate from an early time in the cosmos, so if we perfect neutrino detectors, we in principle will be able to see much farther back in time than this optical wall created so soon after the Big Bang (a mere 300,000 years after). There is also something else that comes from the early universe and these are gravity waves, ripples in the fabric of space and time predicted by Einstein but still not observed. We’ve got good people working on the problem; they’re in the process of building sensitive enough telescopes to detect them. I have no doubt that we’ll detect them, and when we do, then we’ll be able to see even farther back—back to the earliest moments where the actual fabric of space and time sprung from what might have been this cosmic meta-soup, which we think gave birth to universes left and right! Now a lot of that is fantasy at this point, but it’s not complete fantasy, it’s consistent with modern thinking of what the behavior of quantum mechanics would be under those circumstances. Quantum mechanics is the study of matter on its smallest scale, whereas Einstein’s general relativity is the behavior of matter on its largest scale. Once you have the Big Bang and you have all that matter compressed down into a tiny volume, these two theories, Relativity and Quantum Mechanics, have to come together somehow . But they don’t, or we don’t yet see how they marry each other. We think we need a third thing to harmonize them, something more fundamental, something that gives rise to both. Herein is the limit of our theoretical understanding of the cosmos. Once that’s formulated, then we may be able to describe what kind of gravitational signature we think was made from the actual Big Bang explosion itself, and tune our gravity wave telescopes to see that.
How Weird is the Cosmos?
151
Whom do you most admire, and why? This sounds like a cliche´, but it is true: the people I most admire are my parents. Right now, they’re celebrating their 50th wedding anniversary. I admire them for many reasons, but foremost is for the way in which they guided me through my interests. They didn’t lead me, because if you’re led by someone you might think that you’re being taken somewhere that is not genuine expression of what’s within your own heart. How many people do we all know who became doctors because their parents were doctors? Neither of my parents were scientists, but they saw my interest in the universe from very early, and saw that it was something to be nurtured, and it was through their initiative that I took as many trips to the Hayden Planetarium as I did as a child. By the way, I didn’t only go to places of science. We also went to art museums and the like. I believe that if my interests were in art, I’d be making this same testimonial in their honor as people who have nurtured my interest in art. So my parents are the people whom I admire the most, and that hasn’t changed since my earliest memories. Does the general public properly appreciate science? The public has a love/hate relationship with the progress of science. Not a week goes by where you don’t find people complaining that there’s some genetically engineered food that they might be eating, or that technology has made their lives harder instead of easier, or they have less free time then they once did. What we have to consider is the very people who are making those statements, if they had lived 100 years ago, might have died in child birth because medicine wasn’t advanced enough to have kept them alive. They might have died of tuberculosis or polio or smallpox, so what a luxury it is to sit here in modern times and say you don’t want to eat the bell pepper because it might have been genetically engineered. So, yes, I don’t mind if people take technology for granted, but at the end of the day, sit back and ask yourself, how has technology enhanced your life, in fact, made you healthier, made you dream about what the next wave of technology might bring your way. What advice do you have for young people? In order to make informed decisions, decisions that can affect your life, your health, your wealth, your well-being, it’s important to be scientifically literate. That being said, beyond that it doesn’t matter what you major in in college. Go follow your heart, just don’t do so without knowing how this world works. Science literacy is empowering. However challenging it is to do well or to read through some of the material, the fact is technology drives our modern society, and it’s possible to move backwards just by standing still. It’s important to stay current, to stay up-to-date on things. So my advice is I’d love it if everybody majored in science, but that would be a boring
152
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
world because I want artists out there as well. But whatever you do, keep an eye on the science pages of the newspaper. How would you like to be remembered? If I’m remembered for anything, I want to be remembered for having brought down to earth the cosmos for all people to enjoy in the way others had brought the cosmos down to earth for me.
Roger Blandford What’s the current thinking about gamma ray bursts? The story about gamma ray bursts is that they were thought to be very powerful explosions that created lots of intense gamma rays from distant sources. What now seems to be the case is that they’re not quite as powerful as we once thought. We’re not absolutely sure, but it looks like they’re only as powerful as a typical supernova explosion—not as powerful as a 100 or 1,000 supernova explosions, as we were thinking. The way that we have come to this conclusion is that there is now fairly good evidence that the bursts themselves are not spherical explosions, radiating energy in all directions, but in fact almost one-dimensional explosions, like jets. And if that’s true, we only see the gamma ray bursts when the jets are pointed directly in our direction. And so if the energy is only focused in this beam, then we can say that it’s only about one percent or so of what we originally thought it might be. In addition, there is pretty good evidence now that although we aren’t sure what the cause of the gamma ray burst is, it does appear to be associated with young and massive stars, which is evidence that points the finger at supernovae. We’re not absolutely sure, but it’s looking like a stronger and stronger possibility. What’s the cosmological constant? The cosmological constant is essentially a mathematical term that Albert Einstein introduced into his general theory of relativity. It’s the possibility that there was something in addition to regular gravity that holds the systems of galaxies and stars and planets together. Dark energy in some sense is a more modern version of the cosmological constant. It’s basically the same idea, and there is now observational evidence—which of course there wasn’t for Einstein—that it really is present in the universe. Why did you become a scientist? I was very fortunate to go to a challenging high school, and had very good teachers. And I found science the most interesting subject, which kept my interesting going.
How Weird is the Cosmos?
153
Does the general public properly appreciate science? One of the ways of improving everybody’s life is for people to have an understanding not just of how to work your VCR, but to actually understand more of the principles that led to that VCR being designed and constructed in the first place, and to understand the connection that has to the fundamental ideas of condensed matter theory, electromagnetic theory, and so on. More people should appreciate without necessarily understanding the details that there is a very large world of science and technology that is very strongly interconnected—this is one of the lessons that we should be trying to give to the next generation. How would you like to be remembered? I’d like to be remembered as someone who was interested and fortunate to participate at some minor level in a lot of exciting scientific discovery. And I would like to be remembered through my students.
Chapter 11
Is the Universe Full of Life?
Will we find life elsewhere in the universe? As a child, I was scared that aliens might invade my nighttime bedroom. As an adult, I almost wish they would. Humans have long wondered whether life exists beyond our home planet. There have been endless speculations, including a good deal of science fiction writing. Finally, the search gets scientific. In recent years, a host of new technologies are turning speculation into science. We now have the ability to discern increasing numbers of earth-like planets circling faraway suns and even investigate the composition of their atmospheres; and we have discovered life in environments on Earth so extreme it’s not unreasonable to imagine that microbes—or more—may flourish elsewhere in the universe. Over the last decade, biologists have discovered microbial life in a dazzling array of hostile environments—mineral-rich hydrothermal vents at the bottom of oceans, buried thousands of meters beneath the Earth’s surface in solid bedrock, encased deep within the Antarctic ice sheet, and even in the cooling water of nuclear reactors! These organisms are called ‘‘extremeophiles’’—lovers of extreme environments. Given the ingenuity of life here on Earth, is it so unreasonable to imagine that microbes might flourish elsewhere in the universe? Or perhaps even elsewhere in our own solar system? Might they be able to survive an accidental journey through space on an asteroid, and thus even colonize new worlds on which they did not originally arise? A new hybrid field is now emerging; it is called astrobiology, a combination of astronomy and biology, and we will explore it. We will also ponder its potential meaning: what will be the philosophical and theological implications of astrobiology? Two planetary scientists and an astrophysicist make the case that the search for life in other parts of our universe has been made all the more valid
156
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
by two recent discoveries, one taking place at the bottom of our oceans and the other in the stars surrounding our galaxy. As it turns out, life thrives without benefit of any sunlight along mid-ocean ridges, one of earth’s most inhospitable places. And, improvements in telescope technology have revealed the presence of innumerable new planets circling stars similar to our own sun. The discussion then turns to the feasibility and value of finding proof that extraterrestrial life exists. All predict our inherent inquisitiveness and daring will lead to such expeditions into space. Batter up in the new game of astrobiology. Mars, then Europa. Astronomer/ planetary geologist Bruce Murray has worked on missions to Mars even before his tenure as head of Caltech’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory. If anyone wants to get our instruments to Mars, it’s Murray. But as for drilling for life on Mars, he knows the difficulty. Astrophysicist and director of New York’s Hayden Planetarium Neil deGrasse Tyson says he doesn’t care how big our shovel will have to be to find it, if that’s what we need technology to do, we’ll invent it. Shri Kulkarni, who observed and correctly assessed what turned out to be the first known pulsar, has what may be the key piece of data: ‘‘we now know that star formation is accompanied by planet formation.’’ ‘‘Are the stars out tonight?’’ Now we know that not only are they there, so are their planets. Multiply the stars times the planets they have all formed and your number is unimaginably gigantic. Astronomy is divided into those who say, just on statistics alone, there has to be life beyond Earth, and those who refute it by saying that those statistics don’t include a myriad of factors inhibiting the development of life, and that life on Earth and human-like intelligence in particular are chance accidents of the most remote kind.
Expert Participants Shri Kulkarni Professor of Astronomy and Planetary Science, California Institute of Technology; leader in the search for extra-solar planets
Bruce Murray Professor Emeritus, Planetary Science and Geology, California Institute of Technology; former director, NASA/Caltech Jet Propulsion Laboratory; co-founder (with Carl Sagan) and chairman, The Planetary Society
Neil deGrasse Tyson Director, Hayden Planetarium; member, Department of Astrophysics, American Museum of Natural History; visiting research scientist, Department of Astrophysics, Princeton University
Is the Universe Full of Life?
157
Robert Kuhn: The universe is a pretty unfriendly place for life. What about all the catastrophes, the giant stellar explosions emitting jets of severe radiation, comets and asteroids flying all around all the time? Talk about a hostile environment! Neil deGrasse Tyson: Before we wax poetic about how bad the universe is, consider that the last major extinction, the one that took out the dinosaurs, enabled the tree shrew to evolve to something more ambitious than a rodent so that we were enabled to become what we are today. So these impacts are givers as well as takers away to the diversity of life. Robert Kuhn:
Much of the radiation is intensely destructive.
Shri Kulkarni: Some stars die benignly like our own sun, so in another 5 billion years. . . Robert Kuhn:
Not benign to us.
Shri Kulkarni: That’s true, which goes to show my orientation as an astronomer. The sun will just expand very gently. Neil deGrasse Tyson: surface.
We’ll be a cinder orbiting deep within the sun’s
Shri Kulkarni: But that will be over 5 billion years from now so we shouldn’t be too worried. But other stars, the more massive stars, do die catastrophically as supernovae, which is not uncommon. At some point, they run out of fuel and, no longer able to counterbalance the inexorable force of gravity, undergo sudden and violent collapse because gravity is the ultimate winner in this game. The collapse process itself releases what we call gravitational binding energy, some of which now comes off in a flash and in gas hurtling out at very high speeds. And these supernovae are not uncommon—there is one superova in our own galaxy every hundred years or so. So if you’re close to one when it erupts, that could be pretty bad. Robert Kuhn:
What do you call ‘‘close’’?
Shri Kulkarni: Certainly a thousand light years would ‘‘close’’ by anyone’s theory of what a supernova would do. Even more exotic, more catastrophic things are lurking out in the universe, such as gamma ray bursts. Gamma ray bursts are rare, but their sphere of influence is tremendous Robert Kuhn: Gamma ray bursts are the most powerful explosive energy in the universe. Shri Kulkarni: Yes, they are the most powerful directed explosive energy in the universe. They are shot forth as basically beams of light and radiation, and although we don’t understand them very well, we do know that their sphere of death reaches out many, many thousands of light years.
158
Closer To Truth: Science, Meaning, and the Future
Robert Kuhn: Why is now such an exciting time in the search for life elsewhere in the universe? Bruce Murray: One reason is discoveries here on earth, in mid ocean ridges, in groundwater very deep, of living systems, organisms, microorganisms, that survive in environments we never believed possible. Neil deGrasse Tyson: Why didn’t we know about these ‘‘extremeophiles’’ before? They are just on the bottom of the ocean, why not 50 years ago? Bruce Murray: The bottom of the ocean is not easily accessible. Such organisms weren’t on the radar screen, so no one thought about the possibility or looked for them. Robert Kuhn: To have life at the bottom of the ocean means that you have life without need of sunlight as a direct source of its energy. Bruce Murray: Incredibly, these extremeophiles use chemical processes for energy, they don’t need photosynthesis, they don’t need sunlight to live. This is why I am optimistic, or at least less pessimistic, about finding life on Mars or finding it in another planet around another star. Neil deGrasse Tyson: Once you remove the sun as a requirement, it allows you to think of other ways you might generate energy to sustain life. When you teach Introductory Astronomy you talk about a ‘‘habitable zone’’ around a star. Let’s take our own sun. Life as we know it requires liquid water. If there is a planet a little too close to the host star, the water would evaporate, like on Venus; a little too far away, it’s frozen (like on Mars and beyond), so there is this sort of Goldilocks interval, a relatively small band where you can have liquid water (like on Earth). For quite a long time this concept dominated our thinking about how and where we might look for life in another star system. Robert Kuhn:
What are some of the conditions for life beyond Earth?
Shri Kulkarni: You need energy, that’s the ultimate requirement to get life going; it can be tidal, it can be solar, and so on. Robert Kuhn:
What about extreme cold?
Bruce Murray: That’s interesting because the satellite of Jupiter called Europa has an icy crust, probably not terribly thin, but below that is probably saltwater, perhaps like the Arctic or Antarctic Oceans. We can now detected organisms that really do seem to be able to live in the ice. It’s -20 degrees Centigrade, way below the freezing point of water, but the organisms not only survive, but they prosper. Neil deGrasse Tyson: But the fluid within these organisms is still liquid, so they’re not in a frozen state, not like a brick of ice.
Is the Universe Full of Life?
159
Bruce Murray: It’s tougher than that because it’s hard to determine if something is alive or not. The usual test is to assess its metabolism and reproductive capabilities. But in extreme environments, how do you culture those organisms? It’s not that simple; for example, how do you know the organisms weren’t a contaminant from the collection or storage equipment from the lab, or hadn’t floated in from the air? Neil deGrasse Tyson: So now because of these extremophiles, when we think about life elsewhere in the galaxy, we no longer restrict ourselves to this Goldilocks habitable zone—they have broadened our thinking. Robert Kuhn: Why is now such an exciting time in the search for life elsewhere in the universe? Shri Kulkarni: There are two reasons: one is the new technologies that for the first time enable us to address meaningfully the question of planets elsewhere, and perhaps even say something about the existence of large-scale life, by which I mean organisms and trees and so on. The second reason is just as important and a bit more subtle: astronomers can now say, more or less with confidence, that every time a star has formed, then planet formation is a necessary byproduct. So we know through observations that star formation is accompanied by planet formation, and we know that we have the technology to actually go look for them. So this is pretty much the start of a golden era in the search for life in the universe. Neil deGrasse Tyson: I agree, especially in the last 10 years, ever since the first discovery of a planet around a star other than the sun. I remember distinctly the day that that planetary count outside our solar system exceeded the number of planets in our solar system. So today’s children will only know a time when we have in our log books far more planets outside of our solar system than within. Bruce Murray: Ask somebody who is 30 or older, how many planets there are and they all say, ‘‘nine.’’ Say, no, I’m sorry, it’s now more than 200 (and growing, it seems, almost every week). Robert Kuhn:
How can we confirm the existence of extra-solar planets?
Shri Kulkarni: There are basically three techniques, each in various phases of sophistication. The simplest one is where the light from the host or central star communicates information Robert Kuhn: As the planet revolves around the star, the gravitational field of the planet causes a small but perceptible wobble in the star.