Challenges to Global Security: Geopolitics and Power in an Age of Transition
Edited by Hussein Solomon
I.B. Tauris
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page i
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
prelims.qxp
10/11/2007
2:59 PM
Page ii
Toda Institute Book Series on Global Peace and Policy Series Editor: Majid Tehranian Published and forthcoming: 1. Global Obligations for the Right to Food Edited by George Kent 2. Challenges to Global Security: Geopolitics and Power in an Age of Transition Edited by Hussein Solomon 3. Music and Conflict Transformation: Harmonies and Dissonances in Geopolitics Edited by Olivier Urbain 4. Peace Journalism: The State of the Art Edited by Dov Shinar and Wilhelm Kempf 5. Anti-racism as International Communication Edited by Mark D. Alleyne 6. Worlds Apart: Human Security and Global Governance Edited by Majid Tehranian 7. Asian Peace: Security and Governance in the Asia-Pacific Region Edited by Majid Tehranian 8. Nuclear Disarmament: Obstacles to Banishing the Bomb Edited by Josef Goldblat 9. Dialogue of Civilizations: A New Peace Agenda for the New Millennium Edited by Majid Tehranian and David W. Chappell 10. Managing the Global: Globalization, Employment, and Quality of Life Edited by Donald Lamberton 11. Worlds on the Move: Globalization, Migration, and Cultural Security Edited by Jonathan Friedman and Shalini Randeria 12. Bridging a Gulf: Peacebuilding in West Asia Edited by Majid Tehranian 13. Not By Bread Alone: Food Security and Governance in Africa Edited by Adelane Ogunrinade, Ruth Oniang’o, and Julian May 14. Reimagining the Future: Towards Democratic Governance by Joseph A. Camilleri, Kamal Malhotra, Majid Tehranian, et al. 15. Democratizing Global Governance Edited by Joseph Camilleri and Esref Aksu 16. Passion for Peace: Exercising Power Creatively by Stuart Rees 17. Eurasia: A New Peace Agenda Edited by Michael Intriligator, Alexander Nikitin, and Majid Tehranian, forthcoming 18. Beyond Reconstruction in Afghanistan: Lessons from Development Experience Edited by John D. Montgomery and Dennis A. Rondinelli
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page iii
Challenges to Global Security Geopolitics and Power in an Age of Transition
Edited by
Hussein Solomon
in association with The Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research
prelims.qxp
10/11/2007
2:59 PM
Page iv
Published in 2008 by I.B.Tauris & Co Ltd 6 Salem Road, London W2 4BU 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 www.ibtauris.com In association with the Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research In the United States and Canada distributed by Palgrave Macmillan a division of St Martin’s Press 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 Copyright © Hussein Solomon 2008 All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in a review, this book, or any part thereof, may not be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. ISBN: 978 1 84511 527 2 A full CIP record for this book is available from the British Library A full CIP record for this book is available from the Library of Congress Library of Congress Catalog Card: available Typeset by Jayvee, Trivandrum, India Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International, Padstow, Cornwall
prelims.qxp
10/11/2007
2:59 PM
Page v
Contents
Notes on Contributors
vii
Preface Majid Tehranian
xi
1 Introduction Hussein Solomon
1
PART I FROM NATIONAL TO REGIONAL AND GLOBAL SECURITY 2 The Competition for Power and Legitimacy in an Age of Transition Joseph A. Camilleri
27
PART II REGIONAL SECURITY PROBLEMS 3 US Nuclear Policies Michael D. Intriligator
55
4 Regional Security in Latin America Benedicte Bull
66
5 Regional Security in South Asia B.M. Jain
90
6 Regional Security in Southeast Asia Joseph Y.S. Cheng
112
7 Regional Security in the European Union Hripsime Nalbandyan
147
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
vi
1:55 PM
Page vi
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
8 Regional Security in Russia and the Near Abroad Olga A. Vorkunova
166
9 Regional Security in the Middle East Mohammad El-Sayed Selim
188
10 Africa’s Shaky Security Architecture: Perspectives from SADC and the AU Hussein Solomon 11 Prospects for an Asian Union Beni Prasad Agarwal
222 246
PART III CONCLUSION 12 On the Road to Global Security? Hussein Solomon
271
Index
279
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page vii
Notes on Contributors
Beni Prasad Agarwal is a former Ambassador of India to Somalia, Lebanon, and five West African countries. He served in Moscow as Press Secretary (1962–3), Bonn Minister in the Embassy (1978–81), and Consul in New York (1968–71). He was Adjunct Professor of Political Science at the American University in Bulgaria (1994). He is President of the Forum for Confederation in the Sub-Continent and co-founded the Association for Asian Union. Benedicte Bull is a Senior Researcher at the Centre for Development and the Environment (SUM), University of Oslo. She has written extensively about regionalization, development theory, multilateral institutions and the politics of Latin American market reforms. Her latest book (with Desmond McNeill) is Development Issues in Global Governance: Public-Private Partnerships and Market Multilateralism (2007). Joseph A. Camilleri, Professor of International Relations at La Trobe University, Melbourne, has been actively involved on issues of security, disarmament and human rights. He has given evidence to several government inquiries, and chairs the Editorial Committee of the scholarly journal Global Change, Peace and Security. He is also the President of Pax Christi Australia. His publications include: Civilization in Crisis: Human Prospects in a Changing World (1975), The End of Sovereignty? Politics in a Shrinking and Fragmenting World (1992), and States, Markets and Civil Society in Asia Pacific (2000). He recently co-edited Democratising Global Governance (2002). Joseph Y. S. Cheng joined the City University of Hong Kong in July 1992 as Professor of Political Science. Before that, he taught at the Chinese University of Hong Kong (1977–89) and the Opening Learning Institute of Hong Kong. He was a full-time member of the Central Policy Unit, Government of Hong Kong (1991–2). He received his undergraduate and postgraduate degrees at the University of Hong Kong, Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
viii
1:55 PM
Page viii
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
and the Flinders University of South Australia. He is the founding editor of the Hong Kong Journal of Social Sciences and The Journal of Comparative Asian Development. His recent publications include: China’s ASEAN Policy in the 1990s: Pushing for Regional Multipolarity (1999), Political Changes Since the Establishment of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (1999), and Guangdong’s Challenges: Organizational Streamlining, Economic Restructuring and Anticorruption (2000). Michael D. Intriligator is a Professor of Economics, Political Science, and Policy Studies in the School of Public Affairs, and Co-Director of the Jacob Marschak Interdisciplinary Colloquium on Mathematics in the Behavioral Sciences, all at UCLA. He is also a Senior Fellow of the Milken Institute in Santa Monica and has been a member of the UCLA faculty (since 1963) teaching courses in economic theory, econometrics mathematical economics, international relations, and health economics. Intriligator received his undergraduate S.B. degree in Economics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) (1959), his M.A. at Yale University (1960), where he was the recipient of the Woodrow Wilson Fellowship, and his Ph.D. in Economics at MIT (1963). He has authored over 200 journal articles and other publications in the areas of economic theory and mathematical economics, econometrics, health economics, reform of the Russian economy, and strategy and arms control – his principal research fields. Intriligator is Vice Chair and a member of the Board of Directors of Economists for Peace and Security and was President of the Peace Science Society (International) (1993). He serves on the Editorial Boards of Economic Directions, Defence and Peace Economics and Conflict Management and Peace Science. He is a Fellow of the Econometric Society, an elected member of the Council on Foreign Relations (New York) and the International Institute for Strategic Studies (London). He was elected as a foreign member of the Russian Academy of Sciences (1999) and as an AAAS Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (2001). B.M. Jain is a Professor and Research Scientist at the South Asia Studies Centre, University of Rajasthan, Jaipur in India. Jain is an honorary Academician and Research Professor at the International Noble Academy, Toronto, Canada. He is deeply engaged in Global Peace, Security and Conflict Studies research including international relations and in South Asia and has authored and edited numerous books, published over six dozen research articles in reputed journals in India and internationally, contributed ten articles to Encyclopedia on Modern Asia (2002), participated in more than three dozen international conferences and seminars, and lectured at universities and research
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page ix
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
ix
institutes in the US, Europe and Asia. Jain was a Visiting Scholar at the University of Hong Kong (2002), Visiting Fellow at the University of Pennsylvania (2001), and Visiting Scholar at the Henry L. Stimson Centre in Washington D.C. (1998), involving Gerald Ford (Michigan) and Charles Wallace Trust Grantee (London). He is also the Editor-in-Chief of the Indian Journal of Asian Affairs. Hripsime Nalbandyan is a Ph.D. student specializing in International Political Relations at Jan Masaryk Centre of International Studies, University of Economics, Prague. She graduated from the Faculty of International Relations at the University of Economics in Prague, Czech Republic. She received her B.A. in International Trade, her M.A. in International Politics and Diplomacy, and her second M.A. in European Economic Integration. Her current postgraduate study focuses on the ‘Role of the International Community in Handling the Conflict in Nagorno Karabakh.’ Mohammad El-Sayed Selim is Professor of Political Science at the Faculty of Economics and Political Science of Cairo University, and the director of the Center for Asian Studies of Cairo University. He graduated in 1979 from Carleton University in Canada, and taught at the American University in Cairo, King Saud University, the United Arab Emirates University, and Kuwait University. He is a member of the advisory boards of a number of international journals and has published numerous books and articles in Arabic and English. In 2003, his latest co-edited and co-authored book on Environmental Security will be published in Europe. He is an active member in the Toda Institute GRAD research team. Hussein Solomon is an Associate Professor in the Department of Political Sciences and Director of the Centre for International Political Studies at the University of Pretoria, South Africa. He is also a Visiting Fellow of the Mackinder Centre for the Study of Long-Wave Events at the London School of Economics. His latest book was co-authored with Nikki Funke and is entitled Exploring Islamic Fundamentalist Ideologies in Africa (2006). Majid Tehranian, a graduate of Dartmouth and Harvard, is currently Professor of international communication at the University of Hawai`i at Manoa, and Director of the Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research. His publications include 20 books and over 100 articles. His work has been translated into ten languages. He also edits Peace & Policy as well as the
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
x
1:55 PM
Page x
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Toda Institute Book Series. A global nomad, Tehranian has been banished to paradise where he surfs the Pacific and the Net at <
[email protected]>. His website at <www2.hawaii.edu/~majid> tells you more about him than you probably wish to know. Olga A. Vorkunova is currently Director of the Center for Development and Peace Studies FORUM. She received her Ph.D. from the Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences, and is Co-Director of TRANSCEND: a Peace and Development Network for Conflict Transformation by Peaceful Means. She is a member of Expert Group of the Cultural Policy and Action Department of the Council of Europe, ISSC/CEWS Steering Committee, International Peace Research Association, International Studies Association, and is an editor of the journal Forum Stability Studies.
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page xi
Preface Majid Tehranian
S
ince 11 September 2001, the concept of security has gone through sea changes. The changes may not have yet registered in the radar of traditional nation-states. But security analysts represented in this volume are focusing on their meanings. Such changes may be summarized by a few propositions: 1. Throughout history, international relations have been governed by one or a combination of the following models of power politics: (a) unipolarity, (b) bipolarity, (c) multipolarity, (d) fragmentation, and (e) a global governance regime for enduring peace and justice. The latter is a model setting goals for the distant future. 2. The present international dis/order is making a transition from bipolarity to unipolarity, multipolarity, and possible fragmentation. 3. Terrorism as a guerrilla struggle of the marginalized against the dominant state system will probably continue for the rest of this century unless its social sources of support in marginalization are reduced. 4. In an increasingly interdependent world, state security can no longer be confined to the defense of the national borders. 5. The current global conflict seems to be what Samuel Huntington has ideologically called the ‘clash of civilizations’. However, more realistically, the clashes appear to be between those with and those without access to world resources and patterns of consumption. 6. The world is currently fragmented among five socio-technical modes of civilization, including nomadic, agrarian, commercial, industrial, and digital. Increasing direct contact among the five modes, as in Afghanistan and Iraq, demonstrates that no single power, even if a superpower, can manage the ensuing problems. 7. Institutions of global governance commensurate with the complexity of ensuing problems are currently missing. The League of Nations and the United Nations were both state-centric organizations designed to respond to the problems of a state-centric world.
prelims.qxd
9/4/2007
xii
1:55 PM
Page xii
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
8. Although inter-state conflicts persist, a guerrilla war has been inaugurated by the marginalized groups against the forces of the states. The new revolutionary forces have gained access to the advanced technologies of transportation and telecommunication. 9. In the meantime, apart from the states, other international players have emerged on the scene with little representation in global governance. Transnational corporations (TNCs), transnational media corporations (TMCs), intergovernmental organizations (IGOs), non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and transnational ciriminal organizations (TCOs) are among them. The states mostly run the political system, the TNCs largely manage the market system, and the NGOs try to manage the civil societies. The TCOs manage an underworld of drug, currency, womenand children-trafficking. 10. To pre-empt a tragedy as large as World War I or II, the world needs to focus on the construction of a new global governance system that can (a) narrow the gaps between the five modes of civilization, (b) empower the major players to perform their own unique roles in global security, and (c) achieve unity in the diversity of the human family. Each of the above propositions calls for a separate volume. But fortunately, this volume covers every major world region in chapters written by knowledgeable experts, while the editor and a few collaborating scholars concentrate on the world as a whole. Global security affects the lives of millions of people. This volume is timely, prophetic, and accessible for scholars and students alike. Majid Tehranian Newport Coast, CA
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 1
Chapter 1: Introduction Hussein Solomon
T
he Chinese curse: ‘May you live in interesting times’ clearly seems to be borne out in the twenty-first century. We are living in a time of great upheaval where change is the only constant. Three of the most important forces driving such change are globalization, regionalization and democratization. Globalization, Regionalization and Democratization: Exploring the Interface
The concept of globalization has become ubiquitous in the languages of the world. In Italian there is talk of globalizzazione, in Chinese of Quan Qui Hua, in French of mondialisation, in German of Globalisierung, and in Korean of Gukje Hwa.1 Despite the worldwide use of the concept, there is no clear definition of what globalization means. Whilst Scholte2 defines globalization simply as the ‘process whereby the world is becoming a smaller place’, he does go on to note that, ‘Discourses of globalization have become a prime site of struggle between, broadly speaking, conservatives who deny such a trend, liberals who celebrate its presumed fruits, and critics who decry its alleged disempowering effects.’3 How could one concept elicit such strongly diverse perspectives? Perhaps part of the answer lay in the comment by Gillian Youngs4 that ‘the most obvious quality of discourses of globalization is their all-encompassing intention or nature, their orientation towards descriptions, explanations or theorizations of the whole, the global.’ Such totalizing discourses on the part of supporters and critics of globalization tend to ignore the nuanced complexity of processes of globalization; that globalization can be both positive and negative; empowering and disempowering; emancipatory and oppressive. Within the African context, discourses on globalization invariably focus on the negative. Giles Mohan5 for instance notes how pervasive the influence of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank is on African countries,
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
2
1:55 PM
Page 2
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
pointing out that 38 out of 43 sub-Saharan African countries are undergoing structural adjustment programmes. Similarly Grugel and Hout6 argue that globalization is an uneven process and that ‘weak states’ have fewer means to hold globalization at bay. Implicit in such an argument is that globalization is essentially a negative process. However, such arguments also ignore the positive in relation to Africa: globalization has resulted in the strengthening of a global democratic ethos, seen so vividly in the international human rights regime. Thus Kwame Ninsin7 argues that globalization ‘makes African governments vulnerable to democratize because of their dependence on foreign capital’. Thus whilst dependence on foreign capital is not a good thing, it is a positive development when international actors take this dependence and use it as leverage to pressurize those authoritarian governments to democratize. The fact that globalization is undermining the power of states, bypassing sovereignty and creating precedents for external intervention in defence of human security is not a bad thing within the African context. How this has come about is briefly examined in our discussions of the historiography of the concepts of security and sovereignty below. The historical evolution of the concept ‘security’ Traditionally, security was almost exclusively understood to refer to the security of states and military security.8 In this way, security came to mean national security and was synonymous with defence. This Clausewitzian conceptualization of security is clearly evident in the following definition of security by Bellamy: ‘Security itself is relative freedom from war, coupled with a relatively high expectation that defeat will not be a consequence of any war that should occur.’9 Bellamy’s rather narrow view of security is further echoed by another parochial perception of security by Giacomo Luciani who commented that ‘[n]ational security may be defined as the ability to withstand aggression from abroad.’10 As such, the study of security in the post-1945 period was dominated by such concepts as ‘containment’, ‘deterrence’, ‘flexible response’, ‘massive retaliation’, ‘balance of power’, ‘mutually assured destruction’ (MAD) and an overarching concern with nuclear strategy.11 This was clearly evident during Reagan’s presidency when the world had to familiarize itself with the Strategic Defence Initiative (SDI), more commonly known as the ‘Star Wars’ programme. This is not to say that there were no alternative voices to be heard challenging this dominant security-centred paradigm which, it could be argued, has dominated strategic discourse from the time of Sun Tzu, almost two thousand five hundred years ago! As early as 1705, the German philosopher Leibniz
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 3
INTRODUCTION
3
spoke of the need for the state to provide common security (la securité commune) to its citizens, and the French philosopher Montesquieu noted that true political freedom could only occur when people are secure.12 What is interesting is that both these philosophers were concerned with the security of individuals and not primarily concerned with the security of states. In 1950, the political scientist Lasswell argued for a broader conceptualization of security: . . . all measures which are proposed in the name of national security do not necessarily contribute to the avowed end . . . Our greatest security lies in the best balance of all instruments of foreign policy, and hence in the co-ordinated handling of arms, diplomacy, information, and economics; and in the proper correlation of all measures of foreign and domestic policy.13
Lasswell’s views were reinforced by McNamara, the former United States Secretary of State, who pleaded for a less military-political focus on security in 1968. This was later echoed by Galtung’s reference to ‘four highly credible, but also totally avoidable threats to our existence on earth – war, hunger, repression and eco-disaster.’14 Despite these dissident voices, the juggernaut of military-centred security studies continued to hold sway. How does one explain this effective marginalization of voices appealing for a more holistic understanding of security? One answer could possibly be that the fear of nuclear annihilation was so overwhelming that all else paled into insignificance. This is a view certainly subscribed to by United States President Eisenhower when he declared: . . . with both sections of this divided world in possession of unbelievably destructive weapons, mankind approaches a state where mutual annihilation becomes a possibility. No other fact of today’s world equals this in importance – it colours everything we say, plan and do.15
This dominance of the traditional paradigm was not to last, however. Changes in the strategic environment in the 1970s necessitated a rethinking of conventional understandings of security. According to Carim,16 five factors laid the foundations for a ‘devaluation of the military’s currency’ in the 1970s: • the beginnings of détente between the superpowers in the early 1970s as exemplified by the signing of the Strategic Arms Limitation Treaty (SALT 1) in 1972; • the American experience in Vietnam which exposed the limits of imposing military solutions to certain types of conflict;
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
4
1:55 PM
Page 4
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
• the financial costs of this campaign in conjunction with a world economic recession which fuelled a deleterious inflationary spiral; • America’s economic decline relative to Japan and the European Economic Community which were competing more successfully in international markets; and • the quadrupling of oil prices by the Organisation of Oil Exporting Countries (OPEC) in the 1970s that sent shock waves throughout global economies and exposed the West’s external dependence on strategic resources. These tectonic shifts in the global security landscape shook the very edifice of the dominant paradigm as Americans were forced to concede that threats to their national security also stemmed from a flagging economy. This new concern regarding the economic dimensions of security is perhaps best captured in the definition of security by Blair, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Public Affairs, who told the US Congress in 1972 that ‘[o]ur national security today depends on things like balance of payments, economic affairs, foreign assistance . . .’17 The mere acceptance of the economic dimensions of security by the establishment served to bolster those marginalized voices calling for a widening of the security agenda. Thus, the events of the 1970s effectively opened the sluice gates for further criticism of the dominant paradigm. One of the first of those to take advantage of these changing circumstances was what has been termed the ‘alternative security school’. The thrust of this approach was informed objectively by Reagan’s categorization of the Soviet Union as an ‘Evil Empire’ and by the arms race that it engendered. Proponents convincingly argued that more arms did not mean more security – more nuclear weapons did not result in a safer planet. In this, their work was inspired by the intellectual tradition of Herz who, in the early 1950s, introduced the idea of the security dilemma: ‘. . . a structural notion in which the self-help attempts of states to look after their security needs tend, regardless of intentions, to lead to rising insecurity for others as each interprets its own measures as defensive, and the measures of others as potentially threatening.’18
Herz’s theoretical insights found practical expression in the work of the alternative security school that introduced the radical notion of ‘security interdependence’ to the strategic discourse. According to this notion, Western security was intimately related to that of the Soviet Union and vice versa; modern weaponry had created objective security interdependence. This meant that it was necessary for the West, for example, to recognize the fact that
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 5
INTRODUCTION
5
increases in Soviet weaponry did not necessarily improve Western security. The reverse was also true.19 This rather abstract notion was given concrete expression in concepts such as ‘arms control’ and ‘non-offensive defence’. The notion of security interdependence rapidly gained support under the banner of common security. For example, the 1982 Palme Commission provided political support for the idea of common security, arguing that ‘states can no longer obtain security at each other’s expense, but only through co-operative efforts.’20 The ideas of security interdependence of the 1980s were further developed in the 1990s by scholars like Kennedy, Breytenbach, Tehranian, Obi, Nathan, Cottey, Krasna, Van De Veer and Dabelko, and Lizee and Peou who argued that the emergence of transnational security threats such as drought, narcotrafficking and pollution necessitated transnational or collective responses.21 Thus, Kennedy notes that ‘[i]n this larger and more integrated sense, ‘national’ security becomes increasingly inseparable from ‘international’ security.’22 These notions of common or collective security, of course, built on the earlier scholarship of ‘complex interdependence’ scholars such as Keohane and Nye.23 It would be wrong to assume, however, that these debates in the security discourse were only confined to the West. Ideas of common security had already entered the discourse of the Politburo of the Soviet Union. This was motivated in large part by Gorbachev’s understanding that the Soviet economy could not sustain a new arms race and that this meant that the superpower stand-off needed to be addressed decisively. Carim24 puts it this way: In conjunction with his domestic policies of glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring) which aimed to revive the Soviet political and economic system, Gorbachev galvanised the process of détente by proceeding with unilateral Soviet disarmament and by urging a series of arms control agreements.
Thus, the 1990s witnessed the rapid demilitarization of superpower relations. One aspect of this demilitarization was the knock-on effect it had on international relations scholars such as Barry Buzan and Ken Booth. Such soulsearching questions as ‘what is security, whose security, and security from what threats?’, were now being asked.25 In answering the question of whose security needs to be addressed, Booth argued that the problem with traditional security perspectives was that it equated security exclusively with state security.26 The problem with this perspective, as Buzan rightly argued, was that state security was often purchased at the expense of human security, specifically in the dictatorships of the third world; consider here Duvalier of Haiti, Bokassa in the Central African Republic, Pol Pot in Cambodia,27 Amin in Uganda and Mobutu in Zaïre (now
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
6
1:55 PM
Page 6
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
the Democratic Republic of Congo). In practice, this meant that people became the primary referent of security as opposed to the state. New security thinking therefore increasingly focused on what has been termed ‘human security’, as opposed to traditional state-centric security. According to the Bonn Declaration of 1991, human security is ‘the absence of threat to human life, lifestyle and culture through the fulfilment of basic needs’.28 This definition, in turn, has been greatly guided by feminist contributions to new security thinking. Feminists strongly argue that there is a need for ‘care’ to be incorporated into any security discourse. This seeks to place the security concerns of the ordinary man and woman on the street at the very core of any security strategy.29 One of the practical consequences of considering human security as opposed to state security, or making people the primary referent of security, is that it becomes possible to identify threats to human security at subnational, national and transnational levels.30 Thus, human security necessitated the broadening of the security agenda to include non-military threats. According to Buzan,31 the security of human collectivities is affected by threats emanating from five sectors: military, political, economic, social and environmental. These insights have resulted in a radical revision of traditional definitions of security. Today, most definitions are wider and tend to complement the definition of human security given above. For instance, Ullman’s32 definition of security provides a more adequate conceptual ‘fit’ to contemporary reality than do most traditional ones: . . . a threat to national security is an action or sequence of events that (1) threatens drastically and over a brief time span to degrade the quality of life for the inhabitants of a state, or (2) threatens significantly to narrow the range of policy choices available to the government of a state or to private nongovernmental entities (persons, groups, corporations).
To be sure, the new security agenda did not go unchallenged by those who sought to retain security’s traditionally narrow military and state-centric approach. These critics argued that the broader the concept of security, the fuller and potentially more unmanageable the threat agenda would become.33 But Booth levels several counterarguments against this criticism. It is sensible to quote his response in some detail: First, it must be conceded that broadening the concept does greatly widen the agenda. So what? This is what the political process is all about: making choices between competing demands. Bureaucratically, the implementation of security does not have to be dealt with by the same ministry, just as ‘defence’ has a land, sea and air component and ‘foreign policy’ has diplomatic, strategic and
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 7
INTRODUCTION
7
commercial aspects. So, while the security agenda should be broadened, it need not become unmanageable. Second, to leave the agenda narrowly defined by military considerations will leave security advice narrowly dominated by military specialists. There will be times when this is justifiable, since there will be times when the military threat deserves special consideration and there is a particular urgency to military threats. Ever since the time of Thomas Hobbes – but in reality earlier – security has been the primary obligation of governments. To place an item on the security agenda is therefore to raise its profile. If we are serious about human rights, economic development, the lot of women and so on . . . then we must simply accept the problems of an expanded agenda and of the need to settle the question of priorities in the political process. To control the agenda up to a point is to control policy. Yes, an expanded agenda is by definition potentially more unmanageable: but one needs to ask why somebody wants certain issues such as human rights off that agenda? And why do they want to privilege [military] threats? 34
Despite these criticisms, the proponents of the new security agenda seem to have weathered the storm and have come to dominate current security discourse. This is perhaps best illustrated by the manner in which new security thinking has revolutionized the discipline of Strategic Studies. Commenting on the relationship between security and Strategic Studies, Carim notes that ‘the concept of security is central to Strategic Studies in much the same way that power is central to Politics and wealth is central to Economics; that is, they are inextricably linked, but conceptually distinct.’35 Traditionally, Strategic Studies has been dominated by a military understanding of security. Evans and Newnham36 define classical Strategic Studies as: . . . the field of inquiry that is concerned to examine the ways in which actors use their military capabilities to achieve political goals, in particular, with the way in which the threat and use of force has served these ends. It is sometimes referred to as the Clausewitzian tradition after the nineteenth century Prussian strategist who did so much to advance the symbiosis between war and state policy . . . Strategic studies has been primarily concerned with military power as the key attribute which has to be converted into usable instruments.
Strategic Studies’ lopsided emphasis on military prowess at the expense of non-military security threats has opened it to criticism from those who have argued that its substance needs to be informed by the debates around the widening of the concept of security. Chipman, the Director of the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) argued that: Strategic Studies has been dominated by perversion and has resulted in a blinkered perspective which is unable to foresee, explain or even understand sources of threat other than those emanating from military confrontation.37
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
8
1:55 PM
Page 8
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
The dominance of new security thinking is also illustrated by the fact that members of the IISS were called upon to change a key text of their Constitution at an extraordinary general meeting in 1992. They had to approve the following: The object for which the Institute is established is to promote on a non-party basis the study and discussion of an exchange of information upon any major security issues including without limitation those of a political, strategic, economic, social or ecological nature.
The original version read: The object for which the Institute is established is to promote on a non-party basis the study and discussion of and the exchange of information upon the influence of modern and nuclear weapons of warfare upon the problems of strategy, defence disarmament and international relations.38
This has resulted in a radical change in the substance or stuff of Strategic Studies to include small-arms proliferation, narco-trafficking and organized crime, mass migrations, economic insecurity, ethnicity, religious fundamentalism and regional power clientelism.39 The real difference between this and earlier approaches to Strategic Studies was the emphasis on the security of individual human beings. While aspects of Strategic Studies, for instance counter-insurgency warfare, did appreciate threats to security emanating from non-military problems, it viewed these in the light of national security considerations of the state. The above discussion on the IISS is not meant to create the impression that the substance of Strategic Studies was to be defined and decided by them. Rather, it is used as an illustrative example of how new security thinking has moved from the margins to the very core of Strategic Studies. Similarly, in 1996 the Institute for Defence Policy changed its name to the Institute for Security Studies. Accompanying this name change was a change in the Institute’s mission statement from enhancing stability on the African continent to enhancing human security in Africa. But the impact of new security thinking was not confined to theoretical discourse: it has had a tremendous influence on policymakers. In addressing a conference in Tanzania, the Organisation of African Unity (OAU) Secretary General Salim Ahmed Salim dwelt on the changes in Southern Africa from the 1980s to the present as it related to the Frontline States: In security terms, the objective was to defend against colonial aggression and apartheid destabilisation. Now that circumstances have so radically changed, the first task must be to rethink security, to redefine the security needs
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 9
INTRODUCTION
9
and to elaborate a new defence doctrine. While in the past, the views and efforts of the Frontline States found common ground in the task of liberation, we should now find a new basis for common security moving from confrontation to co-operation in Southern Africa. This common security must be one in which all find relevance and which is holistic in scope, embracing the non-traditional areas such as social and economic domains.40
These ideas of common security and a widening security agenda have also found practical expression in the five main sub-regional organizations on the African continent: • • • • •
the Inter-Governmental Authority on Development (IGAD) in the east; the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) in the west; the Maghreb Union (UMA) in the north; the Southern African Development Community (SADC) in the south; and the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) representing Central Africa.41
What is interesting about each of the subregional groupings is that they began as development organizations, slowly taking on security functions. This underscores the reality of the intimate relationship between security and development. After all, in cases where there is civil unrest, it is difficult to attract foreign investor capital. This, in turn, has negative implications for development. Consider here the cases of ECOWAS troops attempting to keep the peace in Liberia, or IGAD attempting to pursue a peaceful settlement of the continuing Somali crisis. This complements the role of other sub-regional, largely development-oriented organizations in the third world that are compelled to undertake a security function. Both Latin America and Asia bear this out. In Latin America, MERCOSUR (the Southern Market) was compelled to intervene in the border war between Ecuador and Peru in February 1995. The Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) was also forced to engage in a peacekeeping function during the Cambodian civil war. This widening of the security agenda has also impacted on the role of the armed forces in the changing global security landscape. Consider, in this regard, the various tasks the military has performed more recently. In Austria, the army is used for the construction of anti-avalanche breaks, the stabilizing of ski ropes and the development of alternative energy sources (solar and water). In Bulgaria and Cuba, soldiers are used to plant trees and to create national parks and nature reserves in their military localities. A similar situation exists in Finland where commanders of each military district are responsible
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
10
1:55 PM
Page 10
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
for the environmental welfare. In South Africa, the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) is used to support police operations against crime and to curb the influx of illegal immigrants into the country. In France, the Navy is used to minimize pollution at sea. In Italy, the army has set up the Geographical Military Institute for the study of seismic cartography of the soil, tectonic (rock) modifications, movement of the earth’s crust and subsidence. In Jordan, the army is used to combat locust invasions.42 The underlying point of the above discussion is that the concept of security has undergone a radical transformation from one meaning state security to one meaning human security. In the process, it also confirms the process of democratization – the process whereby ordinary people are empowered. These trends also find resonance in the manner in which sovereignty has developed over the years. Reconstructing sovereignty in an era of human security and intervention Often, one hears of tyrants engaging in the internal repression of their citizens decrying any form of sanctions or intervention, arguing that this violates their state’s sovereign integrity. In this, the Saddam Husseins and Slobodan Milosevics of the world are drawing upon a particular philosophical tradition which views sovereignty as ‘. . . protection against external influence in a state’s affairs’.43 Sovereignty, as a legal and political construct, arose in Europe at a time when medieval feudal states slowly gave way to absolutist nation-states.44 Commenting on this Deng et al.45 note that sovereignty developed ‘as an instrument of feudal princes in the construction of territorial states. It was believed that instability and disorder, seen as obstacles to stable society, would only be overcome by viable governments capable of establishing firm and effective control over territory and population’. As the old social order decayed and crumbled, absolute monarchs were installed all over Europe; and each of these had their own praise singers and sycophants justifying the ‘New World Order’. In England, this saw Hobbes translating the social contract as people surrendering all their rights to the Ruler.46 In this way, the Ruler was sovereign. Jean Bodin also endorsed this view and this philosophical tradition contributed to the rise of the absolutist monarchy and the nation-state in Europe.47 This did not mean that the philosophical tradition, which was soon transformed into an established orthodoxy, did not go unchallenged. A rich and varied alternative discourse could still be heard above the cacophony of the sycophants. Other social contract theorists such as John Locke and
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 11
INTRODUCTION
11
Jean-Jacques Rousseau stridently argued against the notion that at the time of the social contract, the people transferred all rights to the Sovereign Ruler. From this emerged the idea of limited and popular sovereignty–that the Ruler had a clear but limited mandate from the people and that its violation by the Ruler could justify popular resistance to the Ruler.48 Of course, Locke’s and Rousseau’s ideas were not entirely unique and drew upon the earlier works of Althusius. This German Calvinist, who drew inspiration from ancient theories of popular rights, argued in 1603 for the ‘revolutionary right of active resistance to rulers who violated their contract’.49 This view was later endorsed by Suarez, who argued that ‘the Ruler always remained limited by positive law and the permanent rights of the People’.50 Similarly, the German philosopher Wolff, argued that the people were free to choose how much power to devolve upon government and how much to retain.51 By the 1780s the fierce debates between supporters of absolute monarchy and the proponents of popular sovereignty took a new twist with Kant arguing that the state, as opposed to an absolute monarch, was the agent and representative of popular sovereignty or as Rousseau put it, the ‘general will’. As in Hobbes’ sovereign, Kant’s state ‘absorbed all popular rights including the right to rebel or disobey’.52 Fuelled by the American War of Independence, the French Revolution and the Industrial Revolution which heralded a new class structure in Europe and North America, Kant’s notion of a sovereign state supreme in its domestic jurisdiction and free from external influence became the norm. The sovereign nation-state also became the norm in Africa following the 1885 Berlin Conference, which carved up Africa into European colonial territories. In the first decade of the twenty-first century, it is increasingly clear that the myth of sovereignty meaning national governments being supreme in their territorially defined jurisdictions, is cracking. The Angolas and the Afghanistans, the Somalias and the Yugoslavias clearly illustrate the inadequacy of the concept in these troubled times. It is also clear that ‘even as the traditional concept of sovereignty erodes there is no presumptive, let alone adequate replacement for the state. The locus of responsibility for promoting citizens’ welfare and liberty, for organizing co-operation and managing conflict . . . remains with the state’.53 For academics, then, the challenge is to rethink the notion of sovereignty in an era of interdependence that has witnessed profound global change. Highlighting the enormity of this challenge, former United Nations SecretaryGeneral Boutros Boutros-Ghali stated: A major intellectual requirement of our time is to rethink the question of sovereignty not to weaken its essence which is crucial to international security and
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
12
1:55 PM
Page 12
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
co-operation, but to recognise that it may take more than one form and perform more than one function. This perception would help solve problems both within and among states.54
Supporting this shift in intellectual discourse have been developments that contributed to a radical change in the global strategic landscape, which enabled key policymakers to be receptive to these new ideas. The first of these movements is the process of democratization that has been gathering tremendous momentum from the nineteenth century. This has increasingly challenged Kant’s notion of the state as the embodiment of all popular rights. In an era where a democratic ethos prevails and where violations of human rights are quickly beamed via satellite into people’s homes, a popular consciousness has developed that state security (read sovereignty) is often purchased at the expense of human security. It has also led to the notion that in the final instance, the people are sovereign and that the state, as Kant had argued, acts as the agent of that popular sovereignty. Unlike Kant, however, it argued against the notion of a state that absorbs all popular rights, including the right to rebel. Moreover, it also emphasizes that for the power of the state to be recognized as legitimate, it must be exercised responsibly and within the mandate given to it. Sovereignty constructed in this way means that the state uses its resources to enhance the human condition of its citizens – at the very least providing for the basic needs of its people.55 Given the enormity of power the state has at its disposal vis-à-vis the individual citizen, it is equally clear that state power needs to be constrained. Here, new social contracts have evolved – the Constitution, a Bill of Rights, etc. – clearly limiting the power of the state. These, together with an elected Parliament and an independent judiciary, are supposed to make governments accountable to the people and reinforce the idea that the state is an agent of popular sovereignty. The existence of several tyrannical regimes, however, clearly illustrates the limits of such domestic accountability. In such a situation, it is becoming obvious that agents (states) who violate the trust of their people are increasingly being held accountable to the international community, effectively, to other states. But this raises another question: why should states pursuing their own national self-interest (in the classical realist genre) care about human rights violations/atrocities committed in other states? The answer to this question relates to the second movement taking place in the world today. The myth of an independent sovereign state impervious to outside influence has been recognized by states as problematic for centuries. Since this myth, however, was crucial for the construction of nation-states from disparate
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 13
INTRODUCTION
13
peoples, states found it useful to perpetuate the myth. States realized that just as no two people can live in total freedom without encroaching on the freedom of others and therefore need the regulatory mechanism of the state, so too states need some regulatory framework, no matter how primitive, to guide the relations between states. Thus Evan Luard56 notes that: Already during the Middle Ages, conventions had emerged about some aspects of states’ conduct: for example, the treatment of heralds, declarations of war, diplomatic practice and similar matters. The rules of chivalry established a code governing the behaviour which knights should adopt towards each other in the battlefield . . . Canon law established rules about the conduct of war and other aspects of state conduct. In particular the doctrine of ‘just war’ laid down for what purpose war was justifiable and rules about the ways which wars should be conducted.
From the nineteenth century onwards, there emerged the idea among some states that war was not a rational way to achieve their foreign policy objectives: that war was detrimental to both their political alliances and commercial ventures. Thus from the Congress of Vienna in 1815 after the Napoleonic wars to the Hague conferences of 1899 and 1907, states sought to create mechanisms which they hoped would prevent the occurrence of war and would regulate its conduct, should it occur. At the end of the First World War in 1918, this went a step further when states ‘accepted the discipline of compulsory conciliation of their disputes by signing the Covenant of the League of Nations’.57 At the end of the Second World War, and with the establishment of the United Nations’ Organisation in 1945, states were once more willing to surrender a part of their sovereignty for the promise of international peace offered by the new organization. Under the new United Nations system, the international behaviour of states was subjected to the political authority of a Security Council that was more powerful than the Council of the League of Nations.58 As time wore on, it became increasingly clear to states that their relations with other states was not the only thing which needed regulation. It has become obvious that how states (agents) relate to their domestic constituencies can also serve to undermine international peace and security and hence endanger the national interests of other states. How does this come about? Samuel Makinda59 notes that ‘[j]uridical sovereignty without popular sovereignty can result in human insecurity.’ Indeed, social exclusion of a particular group from economic or political power, ethnic cleansing and the like, has resulted in more than 20 million refugees and 30 million internally displaced people.60 These then become a source of regional insecurity as they
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
14
1:55 PM
Page 14
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
flee into neighbouring states. In the process, the international order is itself threatened. The politics of exclusion pursued by some states that deliberately undermine the human security of their citizens also adversely affect international stability in other ways. In some cases those affected populations bearing the brunt of state repression choose to fight back. The Kosovar Liberation Army (KLA) is an example of this. But this only serves to intensify the domestic conflict whilst at the same time regionalizing it, as the KLA needs neighbouring countries from which to stage assaults against the hostile government of Slobodan Milosevic. The example of the Democratic Republic of the Congo is currently the archetypal example of how a civil war threatens to involve an entire continent, as Angola, Namibia, Zimbabwe, Rwanda, Uganda, Burundi, Chad and Sudan all have become involved in the politics of this Central African behemoth. Recognizing that insecurity anywhere is a threat to security everywhere, states have decided to band together for the cause of international security. For instance, acknowledging that an intrinsic relationship exists between agents (states) not acting responsibly towards their citizens and a failare to achieve international peace, states have in various international fora begun to regulate this domestic realm to ensure that states are in the final instance accountable to the international community for their actions. This resulted in the development of a normative code by which a state’s actions could be held up for scrutiny. The 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the 1966 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the 1966 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights as well as a vast array of other human rights instruments became a part of these global norms by which state actions could be monitored.61 The flip side to this, of course, is that those states which do not adhere to these global norms open themselves up for international intervention by the global community. In this regard Kalypso Nicolaidis62 notes that state sovereignty can be effectively bypassed when ‘a state stops fulfilling the basic responsibilities and functions that go along with sovereignty’. This was a point made abundantly clear to the South African apartheid regime in 1974. In that year the international community questioned Pretoria’s right to sovereignty (read non-interference) on the basis that it exercised power illegitimately, irresponsibly and to the detriment of regional peace and security. This resulted in the South African government being ousted from the UN General Assembly and replaced by the African National Congress and the Pan-Africanist Congress on the basis that these liberation movements were perceived to be
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 15
INTRODUCTION
15
more representative of the majority of South African citizens. Sanctions and an arms embargo were soon to follow. Despite the development of these global norms and the case of South Africa listed above, the truth is that during much of the Cold War, dictators such as Pinochet, Mobutu and Suharto held sway – nurtured and assisted by superpowers who displayed scant regard for the precepts of popular sovereignty or human rights. With the demise of global bipolarity and the beginnings of a new international consensus regarding sovereignty as responsibility, the way has become clear for the further development of international law to ensure accountability – that states act as responsible agents of popular sovereignty. One of the earliest examples of this new consensus occurred in 1991 with UN Security Council Resolution 688. This demanded an end to Iraqi aggression against the Kurds in northern Iraq and authorized a military operation to establish safe havens on Iraqi territory. In this way international humanitarian organizations were guaranteed access to the Kurds for the purposes of providing both protection and humanitarian relief. At the time, the United States’ Ambassador to the United Nations remarked that ‘this was the first time a significant number of governments denied the states’ right to the sovereign exercise of butchery.’63 Since then the UN Security Council has authorized forcible intervention in Somalia in 1992, Haiti in 1994, as well as in Yugoslavia. The advent of forcible intervention in the affairs of a state represents a watershed in our theoretical understandings of sovereignty in the current international system. Dan Smith64 puts it this way: The most familiar social science definition of the state is that it is the entity with the monopoly of the legitimate means of force within a given territory. Humanitarian intervention – especially forcible – breaks the states’ monopoly of force and rejects its legitimacy. It thus contradicts our understanding of the most basic function of sovereign statehood.
In this way forcible intervention reinforces the notion that sovereignty equals responsibility and that states who violate the trust of their citizens will be held accountable for their actions (or inaction) to the international community. Of course, developments in international law are not simply confined to the question of forcible intervention but also to what John Dugard65 refers to as the ‘internationalisation of criminal law’. This is most clearly seen in the Pinochet case and in Tripoli’s handing over of the two Libyans to the Netherlands for trial under Scottish law for the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie in 1989. It has also resulted in the establishment of an International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia in The Hague.66
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
16
1:55 PM
Page 16
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda in Arusha and the 120 states that signed an agreement in Rome in July 1998 to establish an International Criminal Court also serve to consolidate the trend.67 These are momentous developments and support the view that international law . . . appears to be moving away from being premised on a system of sovereign states towards the development of a common law for a world community of individuals. In the past states were the sole legal persons; in the twentieth century this hard shell has been breached and international law now concerns itself not just with states but also with individuals.68
What is even more revealing is that in the cases listed above, the defendants have not sought to challenge the authority or jurisdiction of the courts. For instance, Jean Kambanda, who was the Rwandan Prime Minister at the time of the genocide in 1994, pleaded guilty to all charges in the indictment against him including those of genocide, complicity in genocide and crimes against humanity. Consequently he was sentenced to life imprisonment on 4 September 1998.69 The case of General Augusto Pinochet, former military dictator of Chile, holds special importance to our subject at hand and deserves closer scrutiny. On 16 October 1998, as the former dictator lay in a London hospital bed recuperating from back surgery he was arrested by the British police. This followed a Spanish magistrate issuing of warrants for Pinochet’s arrest and extradition in connection with 94 murders and disappearances. Following his arrest, Pinochet was found by a three-judge panel of the High Court to be immune from prosecution for any crimes he might have committed whilst he was head of state from 1973 to 1990. When the case went to the House of Lords on appeal, however, three of the five Law Lords ruled against Pinochet. Whilst the High Court restricted itself to English law which has no exceptions to state immunity, the Law Lords argued that under international law, Pinochet’s crimes against humanity do not enjoy immunity. In a landmark judgment, Lord Nicholls noted: International law has made plain that certain types of conduct, including torture and hostage-taking, are not acceptable conduct on the part of anyone. This applies as much to heads of state, or even more so, as it does to everyone else, the contrary case would make a mockery of international law.70
As in the case of Jean Kambanda, what is interesting about the General’s defence counsel is that it did not challenge the legality or the jurisdiction of the court. Rather the defence counsel argued that Pinochet was suffering from chronic depression which had resulted in his being mentally unfit to stand trial for extradition.71
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 17
INTRODUCTION
17
The twentieth century will certainly go down as one of the bloodiest centuries in the history of humanity. From the bloody plains of Armenia to the trench warfare of the First World War, the gas chambers of Auschwitz and Dachau, the killing fields of East Timor, Cambodia, Sudan; Yugoslavia and now Angola and the DRC, the twentieth century has taken man’s inhumanity to man to new heights. Altogether 160 million people lost their lives in the century as a result of war, genocide and state killings.72 With the dawning of the twenty-first century there is a millennium feeling that such grave crimes committed by the Mengistus and Pinochets are not simply crimes against the victims but an affront to our collective humanity and dignity and as such should not go unpunished. Reconstructing sovereignty as responsibility, remodelling states as agents of popular sovereignty whose purpose it is to enhance the human condition of their citizens, and who are accountable not only to their domestic constituencies but to the international community as well, might go some way to resolve the historic tensions between state and human security in favour of the latter. In the final instance, it is only in the creation of vibrant democracies that the historic tensions between state and human security can be resolved. Regionalization: new and old Having discussed the relationship between globalization and democratization whilst alluding to regionalization, it is important at this point to turn to the question of how regionalization fits into this triadic structure. Before proceeding with our discussion on regionalization, it may be useful for us to examine the concept of region first. The primary, common-sense usage of the term ‘region’ connotes physical contiguity, but as Evans and Newnham illustrate, proximity is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for physical stipulation of region: Between state actors, contiguity as a variable in delineating regions produces mixed results. For example, there is a core area within the concept of ‘Western Europe’ which includes the founding six of the European Community. At the periphery, things become more confused. Iceland and Ireland presumably mark the Western fringes but where is the eastern fringe? Similarly, with the region of the Middle East. A core area can be identified but is Libya part of it, or of North Africa? Is Turkey part of Europe or part of the Middle East? . . . Clearly, more is needed than proximity to confidently stipulate the meaning of region.73
Obviously, other criteria are needed to define a region. One of the criteria, which Evans and Newnham74 have defined, is homogeneity at the social,
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
18
1:55 PM
Page 18
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
economic and political levels. Unlike old ‘regionalism’ efforts of the 1950s and 1960s with its overwhelming stress on functional integration driven by political and economic aspirations, regionalization efforts from the 1990s stressed the multidimensional aspects of regional integration building on a common value system.75 Ultimately, as one cannot integrate apples and oranges, regional integration would need to be an integration of like-minded entities. This would also make the cohesion between national interests and regional collective interests that much easier. National entities subscribing to a common value system would also greatly facilitate the formation of common policies at the regional level. Thus, it may be argued that what is driving new regionalization efforts is a common value system. It would also stand to reason that those regional structures which are driven by a democratic value system, and where human security is paramount, are fundamentally different from those which subscribe to a less democratic ethos where state (read elite) security is paramount. This is not all. Grugel and Hout76 note that, in the developing world, regionalization is often a response to fears of globalization. Among state elites in the south, there is an assumption that in banding together they could reduce the hegemony of the West, which they see as driving globalization. That the situation is more nuanced is obvious, but this view is a myth which state elites encourage as it deflects from their own failures.
Toda and the GRAD Project In an effort to come to better understand how these forces of globalization, regionalization and democratization impact on our world and are, in turn, impacted upon by world events, the Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research under the Directorship of Professor Majid Tehranian launched a three-year research project called GRAD or the Globalization, Regionalization and Democratization consortium. Researchers from all corners of the globe participated in this project under the aegis of Toda. These researchers were then organized into research clusters or themes. Each groups of researchers, however, had to examine their theme through the prism of globalization, regionalization and democratization. The chapters in this book reflect the collective efforts of one such research cluster – that of security. At the first meeting at Magdalen College, Oxford University, the project was formally launched and researchers organized themselves into research clusters. Within those clusters responsibility for specific papers was given to particular individuals. In
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 19
INTRODUCTION
19
2003, researchers reconvened at the Dialogue Institute at Simon Frasier University in Vancouver, Canada where first drafts of papers were presented. On the basis of comments and criticism of papers, these were revised and second drafts were presented in 2004 at the International Business School in Budapest, Hungary. Once again, presentations were made and criticism delivered. Authors once again revised the papers and updated them. These then constituted the final versions that are contained in this volume. The first part of the volume examines security from the national to the regional and on to the global. In the opening chapter, Joseph Camilleri provides an important overarching framework in order to contextualize the myriad contradictory developments at national, regional and international levels. Camilleri begins his analysis by identifying the limits of the Modern Age and how these impact on international relations generally and global security, in particular. He then situates the geopolitical landscape of the post-Cold War period, and especially the declining fortunes of the imperial project within this larger era of transition. Camilleri concludes on a positive note by referring to an alternative discourse – perspectives associated with the ‘dialogue of civilizations’ – that point to a more promising co-operative future. The second part of the volume focuses on regional security problems and begins with Michael Intriligator’s incisive chapter on the new US nuclear weapons policy – the so-called Bush Doctrine. Intriligator notes how past policies based on co-operative approaches to international security have been replaced by unilateral US policies and actions. Equally worrisome, he notes that despite this constituting a sea-change in the policy arena, very little debate has occurred around this. He concludes by arguing that it is perhaps time to consider an alternative approach – that of global security – to deal with the vexing issues of our time. Benedicte Bull’s chapter on Latin America illustrates how a fragile consensus on security issues broke down following diverse regional responses to the increasingly unilateral policies of the US in the region in the post 9/11 world. She points out that given the division between those Latin American countries that support an aggressive US security policy and those who do not, a collaborative regional security framework will be difficult to reach. The following two chapters deal with Asia. In his chapter focusing on the US and South Asia, B.M. Jain attempts to answer the question of what the main ingredients for sustainable peace are in the region. Key to this he also discusses the issue of whether the US has a ‘specific roadmap’ to encourage democratic forces in the region as well as to amelioriate tensions between nuclear rivals – India and Pakistan. In his analysis of South-East Asia, Joseph Cheng notes that countries viewed regional economic co-operation and market liberalization as
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
20
1:55 PM
Page 20
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
an important means to maintain a peaceful external environment and to promote economic growth. However this confidence was shattered with the Asian financial crisis. The impact of 9/11 has also raised concerns of threats of terrorism given the fact that terrorism in the region is largely rooted in domestic ethnic and socio-economic contradictions. In the search for more security, many are turning to the promise encapsulated in democracy to provide the region with greater stability. Our focus then moves to Europe where Hripsime Nalbandyan examines the conundrum that is the European Union – an economic giant but a military dwarf. In her chapter she examines European security past, present and possible future. In assessing the future of European security, Nalbandyan gives special attention to transatlantic relations between the US and Europe. In her penetrating chapter, Olga Vorkunova notes that the multifaceted regionalization process in Europe’s peripheries is affected by the Russian Federation in all matters pertaining to the eastwards enlargement of the EU. As such, the position of Moscow may well define the limits and constraints of a Wider Europe. Next, Mohammad Selim reviews the competing security arrangements in the Middle East and analyses their experience in responding to the plethora of security challenges posed. From these lessons learned, the factors that lead to successful regional co-operation in the security realm are extrapolated. The focus then shifts to southern Africa. Hussein Solomon argues that current forms of regionalization in the Southern African Development Community is elite-driven, and that state security is purchased at the expense of the human security of ordinary citizens. In the final instance, it is a regionalization that opposes the globalizing democratic ethos. In the final chapter, Beni Prasad Agarwal examines the prospects for an Asian Union. He starts his paper by noting how centuries of war in Europe ended with the establishment of a Coal and Steel Community, which developed into the European Union. Such functional co-operation contributed to growing interdependence that minimized prospects of war. He then reflects the extent to which this may be possible in Asia. He eloquently argues that such a Union must consist of all the major powers of Asia and that these need to reflect on how such a Union might assist in the securing their individual national interests. Notes 1. J.A. Scholte, ‘Beyond the Buzzword: Towards a Critical Theory of Globalization’, in E. Kofman and G. Youngs (eds), Globalization: Theory and Practice, New York: Pinter, 1996, p. 45.
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 21
INTRODUCTION
21
2. Ibid., p. 43. 3. Ibid., p. 43. 4. G. Youngs, ‘Dangers of Discourse: The Case of Globalization’, in E. Kofman and G. Youngs, p. 60. 5. G. Mohan, ‘Globalization and Governance: The Paradox of Structural Adjustment in Sub-Saharan Africa’, in E. Kofman and G. Youngs, pp. 292–95. 6. J. Grugel and W. Hout, ‘Regions, Regionalism and the South’, in J. Grugel and W. Hout (eds), Regionalism Across the North–South Divide: State Strategies and Globalization, London: Routledge, 1999, p. 5. 7. K. Ninsin, ‘The Quest for Democracy’, Africa Insight, 30(3), December 2000, p. 11. 8. K. Booth, ‘A Security Regime in Southern Africa: Theoretical Considerations’, Southern African Perspectives: A Working Paper Series, 30, Bellville: Centre for Southern African Studies, University of the Western Cape, 1994, p. 3. 9. B. Buzan, People, States and Fear: An Agenda for International Security Studies in the PostCold War Era, New York: Harvester-Wheatsheaf (2nd ed.), 1991, p. 16. 10. Ibid., p. 16. 11. J. Baylis and N.J. Rengger, ‘Introduction: Theories, Methods, and Dilemmas in World Politics’, in J. Baylis and N.J. Rengger (eds), Dilemmas of World Politics: International Issues in a Changing World, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992, p. 9. 12. E. Rothchild, ‘What is Security?’, in M. Singh (ed.), Redefining Security in Southern Africa: Workshop Proceedings, Common Security Forum, Centre for History and Economics, King’s College, University of Cambridge, 1995, p. 16. 13. J.J. Romm, Defining National Security: The Non-Military Aspect, New York: Council on Foreign Relations Press, 1993, p. 3. 14. M. van Aardt, ‘In Search of a More Adequate Conceptualisation of Security for Southern Africa: Do We Need a Feminist Touch?’, Politikon, 20(1), 1993, p. 55. 15. Quoted in X. Carim, ‘Strategic Perspectives for Southern Africa in the 1990s: Theoretical and Practical Considerations’, Southern African Perspectives: A Working Paper Series, 23, Bellville: Centre for Southern African Studies, University of the Western Cape, 1993, p. 4. 16. Ibid., p. 9. 17. Romm, p. 5. 18. Buzan, p. 4. 19. N.J. Wheeler and K. Booth, ‘The Security Dilemma’, in J. Baylis and N.J. Rengger (eds), Dilemmas of World Politics: International Issues in a Changing World, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992, p. 45. 20. Ibid., p. 45. 21. P. Kennedy, Preparing for the Twenty-First Century, London: Fontana Press, 1993, pp. 129–30; F.A. Magno, ‘Environmental Security and the South China Sea’, Security Dialogue, 28(1), 1997, pp. 97–112; E. Ottone, ‘Overcoming Poverty and Exclusion as Causes of Insecurity in Latin America’, Security Dialogue, 28(1), 1997,
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
22
22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28.
29.
30. 31.
1:55 PM
Page 22
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
7–16; W. Breytenbach, ‘Conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa: From the Frontline States to Collective Security’, The Arusha Papers: A Working Series on Southern African Security, 2, Cape Town: Centre for Southern African Studies, University of the Western Cape and Dar es Salaam: Centre for Foreign Relations, 1995, p. 3; P. Lizee and S. Peou, ‘Co-operative Security and the Emerging Security Agenda in Southeast Asia: The Challenges and Opportunities of Peace in Cambodia’, York Centre for International and Strategic Studies (YCISS) Occasional Paper, 21, Toronto, Canada: Centre for International and Strategic Studies, York University, 1993, p. 1; C.Y. Obi, ‘Environmental Conflict in Africa’, African Journal of Political Science, 4(1), June 1999, pp. 40–62; L. Nathan, ‘Good Governance, Security and Disarmament’, African Journal of Political Science, 3(2), December 1998, pp. 69–79; A. Cottey, ‘Central Europe Transformed: Security and Co-operation on NATO’s New Frontiers’, Contemporary Security Policy, 20(2), August 1999, pp. 1–30; J.S. Krasna, ‘Testing the Transnational Issues for International Security’, Contemporary Security Policy, 20(1), April 1999, pp. 57–64; S.D. van De Veer and G.D. Dabelko, ‘Redefining Security Around the Baltic: Environmental Issues in a Regional Context’, Global Government: A Review of Multilateral and International Organizations, 5(2), April–June 1999, pp. 221–50; Majid Tehranian and David Chappell (eds), Dialogue of Civilizations: A New Peace Agenda for a New Millennium, I.B.Tauris and Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research, London, 2002; Majid Tehranian (ed.), Bridging a Gulf: Peacebuilding in West Asia, I.B.Tauris and Toda Institute for Global Peace and Policy Research, London, 2003. Kennedy, p. 130. R.O. Keohane and J.S. Nye, Power and Interdependence: World Politics in Transition, Boston: Scott Foresman and Company, 2nd edition, 1989. Carim, p. 9. Booth Ibid., p. 5. Buzan, p. 43. A.H. Omari, ‘Regional Security: One View from the Frontline States’, The Arusha Papers: A Working Paper Series on Southern African security, 5, Cape Town: Centre for Southern African Studies, University of the Western Cape and Dar es Salaam: Centre for Foreign Relations, 1995, p. 4. K. Krause, ‘Critical Theory and Security Studies’, YCISS Occasional Paper, 33, Toronto: Centre for International and Strategic Studies, York University, 1996; Van Aardt, pp. 55–9; J.B. Elshtain, ‘Feminist Themes and International Relations’, in J. Der Derian (ed.), International Theory: Critical Investigations, London: Macmillan Press, 1995; J.A. Tickner, ‘Hans Morgenthau’s Principles of Political Realism: A Feminist Reformulation’, in J. Der Derian (ed.), International Theory: Critical Investigations, London: Macmillan Press, 1995. Booth, pp. 3–4; Solomon and Cilliers, p. 6. Buzan, p. 19.
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
1:55 PM
Page 23
INTRODUCTION
32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40.
41.
42.
43.
44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58.
23
Quoted in Romm, p. 4. Ibid., p. 6. Booth, p. 6. Carim, p. 7. G. Evans and J. Newnham, The Dictionary of World Politics, London: HarvesterWheatsheaf, 1990, p. 379. J. Chipman, ‘The Future of Strategic Studies: Beyond even Grand Strategy’, The Roundtable, 322, 1992, p. 135. P. Vale, ‘Can International Relations Survive?’, International Affairs Bulletin, 16(3), 1992, p. 100. S. Bearman (ed.), Strategic Survey 1990–1991, London: Brasseys for IISS, 1991, pp. 18–21. S.A. Salim, ‘The Frontline State: A New Alliance for Peace and Development in Southern Africa’, Keynote address by Dr Salim Ahmed Salim, Secretary General of the OAU, to the meeting of the Ministers of Defence and Security of the Frontline States, Arusha, Tanzania, 10 November 1994, pp. 4–5. J. Cilliers, ‘The Evolving Security Architecture in Southern Africa’, African Security Review, 4(5), 1995, p. 37; G. Cawthra, ‘Sub-Regional Security: The Southern African Development Community’, Security Dialogue, 28(2), 1997, pp. 207–9. M. Harbottle, ‘New Roles for the Military: Humanitarian and Environmental Security’, Conflict Studies, 285, London: Research Institute for the Study of Conflict and Terrorism, 1995, pp. 16–19. F.M. Deng, S. Kimaro, T. Lyons, D. Rotchild, and I.W. Zartman, Sovereignty as Responsibility: Conflict Management in Africa, Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution, 1996, p. vii. F.H. Hinsley, Sovereignty, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986, p. 62. Deng, et al., p. 2. Hinsley, p. 145. S. Makinda, ‘Sovereignty and Global Security’, Security Dialogue, 29(3), 1998, p. 282. Deng, et al., p. xx. Hinsley, p. 132. Ibid., p. 135. Ibid., p. 152. Ibid., p. 156. Deng, et al., p. 6. B. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, ‘Empowering the United Nations’, Foreign Affairs, 71, 1993, p. 99. Deng, et al., p. xvii. E. Luard, Basic Texts in International Relations, London: Macmillan. 1992, p. 143. Hinsley, p. 227. Ibid., p. 227.
ch1.qxp
9/4/2007
24
1:55 PM
Page 24
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
59. Makinda, p. 286. 60. Deng, et al., p. xiii. 61. B. de Villiers, D.J. van Vuuren and M. Wiechers, Human Rights Documents that Paved the Way, Pretoria: Human Sciences Research Council, 1992. 62. Quoted in D. Smith, ‘Sovereignty in the Age of Interventions’, in A. McDermott (ed.) Sovereign Intervention, Oslo: International Peace Research Institute, p. 16. 63. Ibid., p. 15. 64. Ibid., p. 14. 65. J. Dugard, ‘Lockerbie is a Triumph of Good Sense over Tradition’, The Sunday Times, Johannesburg, 25 April 1999. 66. P. Ahavan, ‘Justice in The Hague, Peace in the Former Yugoslavia? A Critical Commentary on the United Nations War Crimes Tribunal’, Human Rights Quarterly 20(4), 1999, pp. 737–816. 67. G. Robertson, ‘A Question of Sovereignty’, Newsweek International, 7 December 1998. 68. G. Evans and J. Newnham, The Dictionary of World Politics: A Reference Guide to Concepts, Ideas and Institutions, New York: Harvester-Wheatsheaf, 1992, p. 151. 69. United Nations General Assembly, Fifty-third session, Agenda item 50, Report of the International Criminal Tribunal ofr the Prosecution of Persons Responsible for Genocide and Other Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law Committed in the Territory of Rwanda and Rwandan Citizens Responsible for Genocide and Other such Violations Committed in the Territory of Neighbouring States between 1 January 1994 and 31 December 1994 A/53/429 – S/1998/857, United Nations, New York, 1998, p. 3. 70. Robertson, op. cit. 71. Ibid. 72. Ibid. 73. Evans and Newnham, p. 281. 74. Ibid., p. 281. 75. S.K.B. Asante, ‘Regionalism and Africa’s Development: Expectations’, Reality and Challenges, New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1997, p. 7. 76. Grugel and Hout, p. 4.
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 25
PART I From National to Regional and Global Security
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 26
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 27
Chapter 2: The Competition for Power and Legitimacy in an Age of Transition* Joseph A. Camilleri
T
here is now a good deal of evidence which suggests that we have entered over the last several decades a period of profound gestation, that is, a period of transition. Representatives of diverse intellectual traditions, usually writing in the aftermath of one or other of the great upheavals of the twentieth century, notably the two world wars and the Cold War, have repeatedly pointed to the limits of the Modern Age.1 Though starting from quite different premises and often reaching sharply contrasting conclusions, they have developed a strangely similar line of argument, which in one way or another foreshadows the end of an era. Over the last six decades on diverse labels have appeared, each attempting to capture something of the emerging epoch: atomic age, space age, electronic age, information age, global age The frequent use of the prefix ‘post’ as in postwar, post-modern, post-industrial, post-Cold War, post-Westphalian and post-colonial is itself indicative of the widespread sense that we have entered a period of transition,2 but also of the uncertainties that bedevil any serious attempt at interpretation. It is as if observers of the new landscape have a clearer sense of what is disappearing than what is replacing it. The purpose of this chapter is threefold: first, to identify, however briefly, the limits of the Modern Age and how these are impacting on international relations generally and global security in particular; secondly, to situate the evolving geopolitical landscape of the post-Cold War period and especially the declining fortunes of the imperial project within this longer era of transition; and thirdly, to point to the ensuing competition of ideas, and to a promising set of perspectives, which we associate with the ‘dialogue of civilisations’. More specifically, the aim is to explore the insights which dialogical discourse brings to the reading of the contemporary human predicament and the responses it proposes to the limits of imperial power and boundary-maintaining
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
28
1:52 PM
Page 28
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
conceptions of power and authority, two distinguishing characteristics of the modern era.
Limits of the Modern Age The contention of this chapter is that a new epoch is gradually emerging, which announces the slow but irreversible breakdown of the grand narrative that sustained the modern project. By virtue of the acceleration of change, the global age signifies a different temporal construction of reality and shifting attitudes to time.3 By virtue of the centrality of technological change, it suggests the ever-widening role of technique, and society’s increasing dependence on expertise. Above all, by virtue of the transportation and communications revolutions, the ‘global age’ points to the growing interconnectedness of human actions and destinies. The movement of goods and services, capital, technology, people, information, ideas and images may now be said to be global in two distinct yet closely related senses of the word. These flows are global in their origins – they are the result of global strategies and practices that cut across geopolitical and geocultural boundaries. Equally, they are global in their consequences – they directly and indirectly influence the material and psychosocial conditions of people’s lives and increasingly connect what were once the relatively disparate environments insulated by seemingly impenetrable physical and political boundaries.4 The emphasis on the global is both necessary and instructive, yet it is our contention that the new epoch which is emerging is far too complex to be reduced to ‘globalisation’ or even to the ‘global’ age. The globalising tendencies of an earlier period continue to gather pace and momentum, but in the process, functions and modalities of economic, social and political life acquire a new and distinctive profile. What we are witnessing is the interplay of two powerful forces at work: the unifying and homogenising impact of financial, commercial, information, demographic and ecological flows on the one hand, and the divisive and polarising effect of the revitalisation of cultural, religious, linguistic and civilisational identities and allegiances on the other. This interplay of integrative and disintegrative tendencies suggests that the capacity of the modernist project to impose its logic on the global pattern of human affairs has reached its limits. These limits and the multi-faceted responses to them continue to shape the transitional period that has been gradually unfolding since the end of the Second World War. While the notion of limits and their far-reaching practical
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 29
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
29
implications have not yet been fully or universally internalised, the two world wars, the great depression, the Holocaust and the advent of nuclear weapons – a remarkable sequence of events compressed into a mere three decades – produced shock waves whose impact is still being felt today. They helped to instil a sharper sense of the fragility of the human condition, effectively providing the first and to date most telling indication of the reality of these limits. For purposes of analytical convenience, we briefly categorise these limits under four separate headings. • Limits to empire: These are the most far-reaching limits for they go to the heart of the modernist project, which has in large measure centred on the application of science, technology and rationality to the politics of colonisation and control. By the middle of the twentieth century imperial domination was irrevocably weakened by imperial rivalry on the one hand and the revolt of the colonised on the other. It is not surprising therefore that the Second World War should have coincided with the steady rise of independence or national liberation movements, resulting in the eventual dissolution of all the European empires. It is true that the end of the war saw the establishment of two new centres of imperial power, whose geopolitical – and to a lesser extent ideological – rivalry became the pivot of international conflict. But both empires would soon be subjected to powerful centrifugal and centripetal pressures. The end of Cold War saw the disintegration of the Soviet empire, but not necessarily as some have argued, the consolidation of the American empire.5 Contrary to conventional wisdom, this chapter is at pains to show that events since 1989 have reinforced the limits of imperial power, foreshadowed three decades earlier by America’s humiliating defeat in Vietnam. • Limits to sovereignty: The concept of sovereignty was elaborated to fit the unique circumstances of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Europe. Designed to explain and legitimise the rise of the centralised and absolutist state, the sovereignty principle bestowed on the exercise of authority three defining characteristics: absoluteness, permanence and indivisibility. Several of these European states had already embarked on imperial expansion, or would soon do so. However, when placed in the international setting of the Late Modern period, the principle would give rise to several mutually reinforcing contradictions. In time, the sovereignty principle had to contend with the effects of the scientific and industrial revolution, especially in transportation and communications, the net effect of which was
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
30
1:52 PM
Page 30
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
the increasing porosity of state boundaries. At the same time, the principle of sovereignty – itself the legal expression of an abstract spatial relationship – conferred on all states a theoretical equality which was at odds with the actual geopolitical inequalities associated with colonialism, domination, empire, intervention and war. With the collapse of the European empires (and later of the Soviet empire) the sovereignty principle was extended to a much larger number of states – UN membership increased from 51 in 1945 to 117 in 1965 and 185 in 1995. This meant that the burden of wearing the mantle of state sovereignty was extended to a great many polities that lacked the institutional infrastructure available to their counterparts in the industrialised western world. It is hardly surprising that many of these polities would soon be classed as ‘fragile’, ‘failed’, ‘collapsing’ or at best ‘quasi’ states. Regardless of the theoretical entitlements inherent in the sovereignty principle, these states – and many others too – could not in practice screen the undesired consequences of internal conflict or outside military and economic pressure. Not surprisingly, statecraft and the operation of the system of states have over the last sixty years followed a trajectory that significantly diverges from the strictures espoused by the classical theories of state sovereignty.6 • Limits to legitimacy: The mutually reinforcing impact of the limits already described could not but call into question the legitimacy of the existing order. The legitimacy deficit may be pervasive but not necessarily uniform, its complexion varying considerably with time, place and cultural setting. Expressed at the most general level, the deficit refers to the state’s growing separation from civil society. This distancing of state and citizen stems in large measure from the actual or imagined gap between the promise and performance of the state, that is, from the perceived remoteness of the state to the satisfaction of material and psychosocial needs – to put it crudely, from the perceived incapacity of the state to deliver on such key desiderata as security, economic well-being or identity. To pre-empt the dangerous possibility of internal division or disaffection, the state can turn to any number of strategies, using the very considerable levers at its disposal. An attractive option, one which has often yielded positive results, at least in the short to medium term, is the appeal to primordial ties, whether based on race, religion or nationality, or some combination of these. The state project – the particular version to be adopted will be a function of such variables as stage of economic development, socio-cultural mix and political traditions – is to establish and cement a unifying political
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 31
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
31
culture, that is a value consensus based on an official interpretation of the community’s past history and future destiny.7 The politics of bureaucratic nationalism can be quite effective in times of war or crisis when the identification of external threats is used to uphold the unity of the state and the legitimacy of its actions. But success is neither total nor permanent. To begin with, many states represent an amalgam of several nations or ‘ethnies’ (e.g. Belgium, Canada, the former Soviet Union, the former Yugoslavia, Nigeria, India, the Sudan), and many nations or ‘ethnies’ are divided among the jurisdictions of several states (e.g. Kurds, Serbs, Macedonians, Irish). The increasing evidence of ethnic dissent is but one manifestation of the widening gap between state and civil society. Even in western parliamentary democracies, where ethnic disaffection may not be a source of acute polarisation, there is nevertheless a widely observed estrangement between formal political processes and the reality of everyday life. Electoral abstention, sudden shifts in voting behaviour, rapidly declining membership of political parties, and mounting public cynicism towards legislatures as well as political parties, leaders and messages point to a rising mood of cultural uncertainty and political detachment, to the decline of reflective political discourse and of the public sphere more generally. • Limits to Growth: These refer to the unsustainable relationship that has developed between economic practices and the natural environment. We now have a much clearer understanding of these limits than when the concept was first popularised by the Club of Rome in the early 1970s.8 Serious questions no doubt remain as to whether any number of resources (e.g. uranium, copper, bauxite, mercury) will be able to keep pace with projected rates of economic growth. The limitations of readily accessible reserves are most strikingly evident in the case of energy resources, in particular oil and natural gas, which have become the lifeline of both industrialised and newly industrialising economies. The more serious limitation, however, arises not from resource scarcity but from the disruption of the delicate equilibrium established over a long evolutionary timescale between the human species and its biological and physical environment. The introduction of pollutants into the earth’s ecosystems, whether it is through the use of pesticides or herbicides, industrial wastes or greenhouse gas emissions, represents a major and perhaps lasting hazard to life. The disturbance of the natural mechanisms helping to preserve the ecological balance has been compounded, at least until recently, by two interacting and limiting processes: the relatively unplanned or unregulated growth of technology on the one
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
32
1:52 PM
Page 32
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
hand, and the uncontrolled increase of the human population. Understood in this sense, the cumulative effect of ‘economic growth’ has been to place a heavy and ultimately unsustainable burden on the earth’s ecological and institutional infrastructure. The cumulative impact of these distinct but closely related limits has produced over time a remarkable though still inchoate shift in intellectual orientation, cultural ethos and organisational practice.9 It has created the context and impetus for change in the development of laws and institutions – both regionally and globally, and more fundamentally in the way authority is understood and exercised. Not surprisingly, the process is mirrored and reinforced by the steady but uneven growth of a new transnational social consciousness.
Geopolitics after the Cold War The powerful political, economic and cultural undercurrents deriving from the limits we have just identified gained added momentum with the end of the Cold War. This is not to say that the trend associated with this new phase of the transitional era is unilinear or amenable to simple explanation. The events of 9/11, Afghanistan, Iraq, the ‘war on terror’ and much that has happened in the last several years – indeed throughout the post-Cold War era (a label remarkable for what it fails to tell us about the world) – all point to a significant moment of transition. However, as we reflect on this moment, we are soon struck by the ambiguity of what we see, an almost palpable tension born of uncertainty and contradiction, for what we see is not one but several realities. Much of our initial exploration will focus on the so-called unipolar moment, that is, on imperial America, or what some have referred to as the ‘imperial tense’.10 However, the emphasis on the role of US power is simply by way of gaining a foothold on the slippery slope that is the current transitional moment, which, one should hasten to add, has still to run its full course. This is precisely what Thierry de Montbrial’s phrase ‘from Berlin to Baghdad’ helps to convey.11 What is at stake is partly a contest for power, between those intent on consolidating the supremacy of the United States and those equally determined to challenge it. But equally important, and not unconnected with it, is the contest of ideas and worldviews – different ways of interpreting the world and laying the foundations of a future world order, a theme to which we later return. As a point of departure it may be useful to revisit the assessment offered soon after the fall of the Berlin Wall of the likely course of events in the
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 33
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
33
aftermath of the Cold War.12 The aim was to characterise the new phase of international relations by drawing attention to four possible scenarios or security models, each with its distinctive configuration of power and approach to international security: • Unipolarity: a system resting primarily on the capacity of one state (the United States) to project military power on a global scale, to maintain alliances and build coalitions as the need arose, which the imperial power would use as the basis for the articulation of a ‘new world order’. • Balance of power: a system in which alliances, to the extent that they survived, would not necessarily reflect the dictates of the imperial power, and coalitions might not fulfil their promise – such a system of competing centres of power might be better described as competitive multipolarity. • Concert of powers: a system in which the great powers would co-operate on issues of global security – a tendency which the euphoria of the immediate post-Cold War period, coupled with a healthy dose of self-interest, seemed to reinforce – such a system might be labelled co-operative multipolarity. • Universal system of security: a system in which notions of collective and common security would have pride of place, in which the UN system generally, and the Security Council in particular, would be able to function with the efficacy which had proved so elusive during the Cold War years. The UN’s greater willingness and capacity to undertake peacekeeping operations and the proposals contained in the UN Secretary-General’s report (An Agenda for Peace)13 were perhaps indicative of a universal commitment to multilateral security. Could any one of these be said to constitute the essential dynamic or inherent logic of the emerging international system? The validity, however partial or qualified, of each of these four models suggested that each captured only one slice of a complex and rapidly evolving reality. It made therefore better sense to represent the international system as a mosaic in which all four models uneasily coexisted and interacted. Unipolarity was but the most striking component of this mosaic, but one whose salience would diminish over time at the expense of multipolarity, of both the competitive and co-operative variety. This interpretation in any case dovetailed with an international political economy perspective developed over the preceding fifteen years, that is, well before the end of the Cold War, which depicted the world system in terms of three competing but interacting tendencies (hegemony, imperial rivalry and imperial collusion).14 Put simply, the world system
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
34
1:52 PM
Page 34
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
was one in which the United States exercised ‘residual hegemony’ but in the context of ‘competitive interdependence’.15 In concluding this introductory note, it may be helpful to refer, at least parenthetically, to the competing perspectives of Chinese scholars and other experts – a debate that has gone largely unnoticed in western writing on the subject. Since the mid-1980s, Chinese analysts have pointed to three distinguishing features of the new transitional era (thought likely to last several decades): increasing prominence of great power rivalries, higher incidence of local wars, and redivision of spheres of influence. Two distinct interpretations have nevertheless emerged: the orthodox view which we associate with Huang Zhengji,16 and the dissenting view to which Yang Dazhou17 has been one of the main contributors. The conventional view, which underpins much of official Chinese discourse, has emphasised multipolarity as the dominant trend in international relations. This period of transition is associated with increasing competition on the world stage and the gradual decline of America’s imperial position. A new era of turbulence, to which the rise of the Third World has significantly contributed, is said to serve as a constraint on US power and to lower the probability of a major nuclear exchange. By contrast, in the eyes of the dissenting voices, the dominant trend is not towards multipolarity but towards a pluralistic world system in which the United States maintains its superpower status and its major alliances. It interacts with four other important centres of power, but it is the only ‘pole’, the only power capable of deciding key issues in any region. Over time a more sophisticated or hybrid position has emerged, which divides the transitional period into three stages: stage one (1989–91) marked by the fall of the Soviet Union; stage two (1991–2000) during which the international system has one superpower, two major military powers and three main centres of economic power; stage three (early part of the twenty-first century) which sees the formation of major centres of political power and the institutionalisation of a multipolar structure.18 The trend towards multipolarity is associated with the rise of a number of conflict zones, for example in Central Asia, new sources of tension with traditional conflicts that had been simmering during the Cold War now coming to the boil, and great power rivalries, most evident in the scramble for energy and other natural resources. Faced with such turbulence, the United States feels obliged to defend its dominant position by frequent recourse to the deployment and use of military power, an arena in which it enjoys unchallenged technological superiority, and by polarising international conflicts as a means of reinforcing its claims to leadership. These analyses, notwithstanding their limitations, capture two distinct but closely
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 35
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
35
related features of this historical moment: geoeconomic and geopolitical fluidity, and the limits to US power.
US Dominance and the Ambiguities of Emerging Plurality There is no denying that the emerging post-Cold War international landscape made for a good deal of ambiguity and not a little confusion, all of which may have served to mask the extent of US decline. Several features readily come to mind: the abrupt disintegration of the Soviet empire, the survival of US alliances, indeed the apparent consolidation of security relationships in Asia Pacific and the enlargement of NATO, the revival of the US economy during the 1990s, Europe’s inability to develop a strategy conflict management, let alone conflict resolution, for following the disintegration of the former Yugoslavia, China’s preoccupation with economic modernisation, the technological sophistication of US military capabilities displayed in the first Gulf War and in Kosovo. The net effect was to feed the seemingly reasonable but nonetheless misleading notion of the United States as a hyperpower. The technological, military and economic resources at the disposal of the American state were not in question, but the capacity to use these resources in ways capable of producing intended consequences and preventing unintended ones was very much open to question. Compounding the ambiguity were a number of developments in US policy, some intentional, others accidental, that appeared to enhance effectiveness of the Bush Sr. and Clinton presidencies. The relative success of Desert Storm, the Dayton Agreements and subsequent measures taken to enforce them, Clinton’s prosecution of the Kosovo war, the Framework agreement with North Korea, all these pointed to limited objectives pursued with sufficient support – from allies, friends and the wider international community – and sufficient success to mask numerous failures elsewhere. Humiliation in Somalia was followed by disengagement in Rwanda; severe frictions and instabilities continued to afflict the international trading and financial systems notwithstanding the establishment of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and the weathering of several financial crises; lack of clarity as to NATO’s future purpose reflected deep-seated internal differences; stemming the tide of horizontal nuclear proliferation remained a high but elusive priority for both administrations. US actions and pronouncements radiated power, yet this was abstracted power, one might say a kind of ‘virtual’ power that was not, perhaps could not
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
36
1:52 PM
Page 36
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
be, clearly or systematically reflected in the concrete. To put it crudely, the power of the American state was more fragile than appeared to the naked eye. Ironically, this fragility would not come into full view until an American president succumbed to the unilateralist temptation, that is, until he and his closest circle of advisers became convinced that the United States was at the peak of its power and could wield undisputed authority in international decision-making. Not that unilateral intervention was an entirely Bush innovation. The Reagan presidency practised its own brand of cautious and limited unilateralism, and Clinton’s Secretary of State, Madeleine Albright, was not reticent to describe the United States as ‘the indispensable nation’. The flaws of the unilateral option would be forcefully exposed when 9/11 struck its devastating blow on the twin symbols of US power. The symbolic significance of the terrorist attacks was widely acknowledged but little understood. They dramatised the ominous but not entirely new reality that the United States had no monopoly on unilateralism. George Bush Jr., possibly the most unilateralist American President since the Second World War, was met by the arch unilateralist of our time, Osama bin Laden. In the immediate aftermath, US policy-makers, intelligence organisations and think-tanks were spurred to action driven by scenarios which, though apocalyptic in the minds of many, were not entirely bereft of credibility. Vociferous opposition to US interests was rapidly gaining ground in many parts of Latin America; Russia was, however slowly, regaining something of its former economic and military poise; China was on the rise; unprecedented militancy had exploded in much of the Islamic world; the chronic US trade deficit had reached staggering proportions; and much of Western Europe (governments, intellectual elites and public opinion) was more sceptical of and resistant to US leadership than at any time since the Pershing and Cruise missile crisis of late 1970s, some might say since the creation of the Atlantic alliance. In this deeper sense, 9/11 and what was to follow offered the most revealing glimpse yet of the enormity of the US predicament. We would also see more clearly than ever before key features of the emerging international landscape, in which cultural and psychosocial currents would prove just as important as economic and geopolitical fault lines.
A Word on Terrorism and the ‘War on Terror’ In responding to the terrorist attacks on US interests and launching a ‘war on terror’, the Bush administration laid bare the weakness of its position, namely
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 37
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
37
the inability to articulate to its own (let alone any else’s) satisfaction answers to three closely inter-related questions. Whose war was this to be? Waged against whom? And with what specific objectives? The obvious answer to the first question was the ‘coalition of the willing’. But even those who seemed willing at first soon became much less willing (witness the steady exodus of coalition partners in the Iraq war). And even those who remained made it clear that they would remain as far away from the main theatre of conflict as they could manage. The willing proved to be less than willing. Indeed, it soon emerged that many of those who initially paraded their support for the US-led war on terror had agendas of their own (at times hidden, often not hidden at all). In return for their willingness, they would each exact a heavy price, whether in the form of economic assistance, military aid, trade concessions, or diplomatic favours. In the case of Russia and China, Washington felt obliged to turn a blind eye to gross human rights violations in Chechnya and Xinjiang respectively. The difficulties besetting the hegemon, or to be more accurate quasi-hegemon, should not be underestimated. The American state, it should be remembered, has had to carry its own public – a task, which despite the result of the 2004 presidential election, is by no means assured of success. In the face of the immense and still escalating human, financial and diplomatic costs, support for the Iraq war has sharply diminished. Securing and maintaining the support of governments (in Europe, the Arab world, Pakistan, Japan and elsewhere) has proven just as taxing and often unrewarding. The argument bears stressing: the means at the disposal of the imperial power are awesome, but so are the obstacles in its path. The Bush presidency has had to contend not only with reluctant or half-hearted allies, but with duplicitous friends, rogue states and an assortment of national and transnational movements, organisations and networks that refuse to be intimidated. To this was now added the frightening possibility (real or imaginary) of terrorist groups combining with rogue states, suicide bombers with weapons of mass destruction. The policy of regime change, ostensibly in the interests of democratic transformation, is by no means guaranteed to bring to power regimes more sympathetically disposed to US interests. Ambiguity and uncertainty, now integral to the use of force in international relations, have translated into imperial vulnerability. Indeed, ambiguity is at the heart of terrorism itself. What exactly does this phenomenon represent? Who or what are terrorists? What are their objectives and future plans? As for weapons of mass destruction, the questions are many but the answers stubbornly elusive. Who has them? Who might have them? Who could have them? Who wants to have them? In this potentially paralysing circumstance, Donald
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
38
1:52 PM
Page 38
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Rumsfeld’s comment at a Department of Defense briefing assumes a significance that few have fully appreciated: . . . there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns – the ones we don’t know we don’t know.19
Rumsfeld did know something: uncertainty. He knew that he, his department and the administration as a whole were in the throes of uncertainty. Preemptive action and the use of force were driven above all by fear of the unknown, the desire to control uncertainty, a desperate attempt to reaffirm the absoluteness of imperial authority. But the very attempt to do this, and do it unilaterally, could not but accentuate the legitimacy deficit, which is rapidly emerging as the Achilles heel of US power.
The Changing Grammar of International Relations The 9/11 incident and contemporary terrorism more generally – the Islamic dimension of the phenomenon gave the image added sharpness – mirrored and reinforced the unexpectedly and strangely turbulent seas in which US power now had to navigate. The United States had to contend with what Bertrand Badie has called the ‘changing grammar of conflict’.20 Conflict was now waged by different means, or with the same means but at the service of different ends, or in the pursuit of different strategies. What after all is the meaning of Somalia, Bosnia, Iraq, Iran and North Korea, not to mention 9/11, Bali and Madrid? Here we see the violence of the weak exposing the weakness of the violence of the strong. In the case of the American state, its strength, as we have already seen, has been subjected to many constraints. Perhaps the most debilitating has been the inner contradiction which, though embryonically present in the latter part of the bipolar era, has become steadily more acute with the passage of time. This is the contradiction between the ‘new world order’ triumphantly proclaimed by Bush Sr. in 1990 and the unwillingness or inability of the United States to establish the norms, rules and institutions implicit in the promised order. In most conflicts, Washington has not been able to perform the kind of regulatory or co-ordinating role that nurtures legitimacy. Over the last fifteen years, and most conspicuously in the last four, it has played the part of claimant rather than judge.
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 39
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
39
The weight of sentiment in much of Europe, East Asia and the Third World generally is that the United States has sought to maximise narrowly conceived self-interest, whether it be at the United Nations, in NATO or the WTO, around issues of international trade, nuclear proliferation, climate change or international criminal justice. To many, especially in the Arab and Muslim worlds, it appeared to lose any semblance of neutrality or even-handedness. In the words of Badie, it is as if its role has shifted from would-be ‘regulator’ to unconcealed ‘gladiator’.21 There is, of course, more to the constraints on US power than internal contradictions. Imperial conduct is not purely the product of internal motivations. External pressures inevitably influence and at times even shape policy outcomes. In this transitional moment, the spatial and temporal dimensions of international life are undergoing profound and rapid change. Traditionally the state has based much of its power and authority on the control of physical distance. However, with the transportation and communications revolutions and the ensuing exponential growth of transnational processes, relationships and organisations, the national state has seen the virtual monopoly it once exercised over space slowly but steadily dissipate. The far-reaching reorganisation of political space has had several consequences. First, agency is increasingly exercised by old entities in new ways and by new entities in ways both old and new. The telling blows inflicted on the United States by Al Qaeda and their supporters through their use of the airwaves (courtesy not just of Aljazeera, but also of western media outlets) are a case in point. Transnational flows, in line with unstable social dynamics and the variable geometry of communication, commerce, industry and migration, cut across territories, evade borders and restructure space. Territory still offers the state important modes of control, but in relation to fewer goods and often with diminishing returns. Secondly, territory has been severely destabilised by the reinvention of tradition. Partly in response to the crisis of institutions and the illusion of their regulatory efficacy, identity fever can take hold wherever states no longer make sense. The return to ‘nature’, to community, to the sacred, or simply to ethnie shatters the functioning of the territorial state as traditionally conceived. Present-day terrorism may be understood as a product of this dual movement of transnationalism and communitarianism. A third element of change merits attention. With the end of bipolarity and the melting of the Soviet glacier came the disorganisation of space in the former Soviet Union, the former Yugoslavia, now the Caucasus, and with it increasing contestation over borders, uprooted populations and new conflicts.
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
40
1:52 PM
Page 40
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
We may legitimately speak of spatial chaos which the imperial power is scarcely able to comprehend, let alone resolve. Far from establishing a new normative consensus on the meaning and functioning of territory, globalisation spawns at best ambiguous and at worst contradictory conceptions of space. Nowhere is this ambiguity more conspicuous than in the Muslim world. Here passionate micro-communities vie for a place in the sun with fiefdoms, struggling states, regional formations and religious movements. Is this not the meaning of post-invasion Afghanistan and Iraq, where the imperial power is struggling to regulate territory by administering a concoction of military coercion and rhetorical democracy? The evolution of the international system would seem to have reached a critical threshold that underscores the reasonably obvious yet often overlooked characteristic of societal organisation, namely the cultural and historical relativity of all spatial constructions on which such organisation is predicated. The present threshold is once again pointing to new ways of imagining and organising space, new forms of political geography. What after all is the meaning of the extraordinary rearticulation of German and Russian space that we have witnessed over a period spanning two world wars and the Cold War? This trend and its multiple ramifications have yet to run their full course. We need only bring to mind the fall of the Berlin Wall and its aftermath, and the accelerating reorganisation of European space. Indeed, we may be entering a period of even greater spatial reconstruction, if the growth of the new regionalism in its diverse manifestations and the hesitant steps towards global governance are any guide. If it is the case that the emerging world system is one where both the grammar of conflict and the organisation of space are undergoing change, it follows that the function and modus operandi of all states will be affected, albeit some more than others. But, contrary to conventional wisdom, the impact may be especially pronounced in the case of the world’s most powerful state. For, notwithstanding the potent levers it can use to shield itself from unwelcome intrusions into its domain, the vastness of the territorial space over which it is obliged to exercise a degree of imperial control makes it especially vulnerable to changes in the logic of conflict and articulation of space. It is precisely this vulnerability that terrorist violence aimed at US interests has sought to exploit. The great irony is that terrorism has turned the globalisation of insecurity and the deregulation of the market of violence into weapons which it has used with devastating impact against the arch apostles of globalisation and market deregulation. What is true of space is equally true of time. At first sight the compression of time scales – in other words speed – not least in the storage, retrieval and
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 41
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
41
dissemination of information, should work clearly in favour of the high-tech hyperpower. Paul Virilio, the pre-eminent student of speed, has made much of America’s capacity to wage ‘virtual’ or mediatised war. In the first Gulf War, he was struck by America’s capacity to transform local war into worldwide war, though the artifice of television and the controlled release of information. The result, he argued, was that ‘real time prevailed over real space’.22 The hyperstate, equipped with cyber-optic vision, was capable of global telesurveillance. The ‘virtual bubble’ of the single world market was now followed by the ‘visual bubble’ of electronic optics, with images and information able to travel at the speed of light. The US Air Force Chief of Staff in fact claimed that in first third of the twenty-first century the Pentagon would be able to find, track and target in almost real time any significant object on the surface of the earth. Even Virilio, this unusually perceptive French analyst, could not but be struck by this emerging revolution in military affairs. Was not Kosovo but the first full-fledged example of info-war in which US technology could rightly expect to reign supreme? Was it not this capacity that had allowed the United States to evade the United Nations, and might in time enable it to evade NATO itself? Confronted like the rest of the world by the ‘shock and awe’ quality of the US invasion of Iraq, Virilio managed nevertheless to put events in perspective. He described the Pentagon’s use of its awesome technical power as an ‘act of panic’. To return to our earlier theme, the United States had to contend with two weighty unknowns. On the eve of the invasion Saddam Hussein almost certainly did not possess weapons of mass destruction, but could the United States be sure that he lacked the intention and capacity to acquire them in the future? Pre-emptive war was waged as a response to this first unknown. But no sooner had war been launched, then a second unknown came to the fore: how much resistance would Washington encounter, what form might it take, and most importantly, how long would it last? For Virilio, the hyperpower had been rendered powerless by strategic innovation or, to use his expression, by the ‘metropolitics of terror’.23 What is it that in Virilio’s perspective has somehow overtaken America’s technological supremacy, its seemingly exclusive monopoly over speed and precision? The answer, as one might expect, is to be found in the psychology of the new situation. Virilio’s exposition is illuminating and merits careful reading: With terrorism we have entered the era of war without end, in both senses of the word. Henceforth, a state of emergency is able to spread without the constraint of time or space . . . We must now be in a permanent state of alert for an accident
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
42
1:52 PM
Page 42
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
that is always possible, always announced, always reported. We have entered a situation which is without historical precedent. It is a situation of hysteria. Hence, the use of the word panic. The ministry of Fear is gradually replacing the ministry of War and the ministry of Defence.24 (author’s translation)
The unknowns or ambiguities inherent in the dynamic of nuclear proliferation and terrorism have, it seems, combined to haunt the psyche of the world’s only superpower. To complete this all too brief explication of the psychological underpinnings of the American predicament, we turn to Baudrillard who turns the spotlight on the American nation, as distinct from the American state.25 What were, he asks, the most visible elements of the response to 9/11? Star-spangled banners, commemorative messages, prayer services and the cult of victims and of post-modern heroes – fire-fighters and the police. Struck by an unimagined and unimaginable evil, the American nation presents itself as the victim that wants to be left ‘alone with God’. The evil, Baudrillard tells us, which had hitherto existed merely in the American unconscious, has suddenly materialised by courtesy of ‘Islamic’ terrorism. Baudrillard wants to take us one step further, where perhaps many would prefer not to go. He wants to argue that what is unimaginable in the American consciousness is not just ‘Evil’ but also the ‘Other’. It is this refusal, or inability, to conceive of the other, be it friend or enemy, in its radical otherness, in its irreconcilable foreignness, that ultimately transforms the objective hyperpower into subjective victim. Though we need not regard Baudrillard as having uttered the last word on the subject, his analysis of the American psyche and in particular his emphasis on the concepts of victimhood and ‘otherness’ provide a useful backdrop to the road we have travelled from Berlin to Baghdad, and lead neatly to a discussion of larger intellectual and cultural currents.
Discursive Competition Events since the fall of the Berlin Wall are indicative of the attempts we have made to reorganise human affairs in the context of intensifying economic globalisation and the end of the Cold War system. Critical to this journey has been the task – to which many, not least US policy-makers, have devoted much energy – of identifying the principles which might sustain a new international order. Put simply, the question has been: What might be the international discourse that can legitimate the exercise of power and authority in the new dispensation?26
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 43
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
43
For those who interpreted the end of the Cold War as the triumph of the United States and of capitalism more generally, the moment for a ‘new world order’ had arrived. We are all reasonably familiar with Fukuyama’s rendition of this theme.27 After the defeat of Communism, world history was said to have reached the end of its dialectical process. Economic and political liberalism was now the only game in town. It seemed to offer the only rational, indeed available model of economic and political organisation. Globalisation, understood as the globalisation of liberalism, was hastening the interconnection of human destinies, and in this sense pointed to the ‘final’ consolidation of human history. The victory of liberalism had exorcised, or at least substantially mitigated the two most troublesome features of international society, anarchy and war. We had come to the ‘end of history’ as the world had known it. Beguiling though it was, the theme was unsustainable. Though in different ways and to different degrees both the Bush Sr. and Clinton administrations dabbled with this theme, in so far as it lent weight to US primacy in world affairs, it did not seem to serve the necessary legitimising function. Too many remained unconvinced; too many conflicts and divisions persisted; and no one seemed able and willing to deliver the promised new order. The discourse centring on the triumph of the free market and democracy would soon be complemented if not overtaken by notions of rogueness, military pre-emption, and the pursuit of narrowly defined self-interest. By the early 1990s an alternative discursive map would emerge. Huntington’s ‘Clash of civilizations’28 became the best known exposition of this worldview, although the term itself was probably first coined by Bernard Lewis.29 Conflict, threats and insecurity were seen again as abiding features of the international system, but with culture and religion as key categories defining geopolitical fault lines. In official discourse, even in the case of the present Bush administration, the prospect of a civilisational clash was not explicitly articulated. Nonetheless many pronouncements emanating from Washington, including presidential speeches and policy statements did proclaim a new political and ideological, not to say cultural, struggle pitting freedom and democracy against terrorism and Islamic fanaticism. US policymakers had found a new way of depicting the struggle between good and evil and of bifurcating the world, in part as a way of preserving and legitimising imperial authority.30 As we have seen, this second discursive strategy has been no more successful than the first. Tied to unilateralist inclinations, it has disturbed friends and allies, whose perceptions and priorities were already at variance with those of the United States. It has sharpened and probably strengthened Arab
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
44
1:52 PM
Page 44
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
and Muslim militancy, provided terrorism with a new lease of life, and in all likelihood given added impetus to the dynamic of nuclear proliferation. Not surprisingly, even before the events of 11 September 2001 – some would say in fearful anticipation of them – several voices could be heard beginning to articulate a third discourse, sharply divergent in tone and inspiration from the two previously outlined. I am referring to the ‘dialogue of civilisations’. Though it has a longer history than many realise, the discourse as developed over the last ten years is still at an embryonic stage. Here I simply single out three voices – each of different origin, inspiration and language, but all three remarkably similar in their diagnostic and prescriptive implications.
The Dialogical Frame of Reference We begin with a voice which perhaps better than any other symbolises the fall of the Berlin Wall, Vaclav Havel. An intellectual and playwright who in the 1960s came to epitomise the strong regenerative tendencies prevailing in Czech culture and Czech society in the 1960s, he eventually led the velvet revolution against Soviet-style authoritarianism, and in December 1989 was elected President of Czechoslovakia and later on of the Czech Republic. His intellectual contribution to civilisational dialogue is best encapsulated in the powerful metaphor of the ‘room’, evocatively suggested by the sharing of a prison cell, which is artistically developed in several of his plays. Our contemporary civilisation is compared to the common room in which we are doomed to live together, though each of us remains a different being: Parallel to the process of global unification in today’s civilization, there is an opposite development unfolding simultaneously: nations and whole regions are re-awakening and asserting anew, often quite aggressively, their own ways of life, their unique identity, their traditions, their history, their deities, their habits, their cultures.31
For Havel the only possible answer to the contemporary human predicament is a new ethos of co-existence or, to put it a little differently, a new normative structure of international society, which would transcend the Eurocentric Westphalian system. Such a structure, he made it clear, could not ‘rest on the set of imperatives, principles and rules produced by the Euro-American world’.32 Different cultures and civilisations would need to play a part in identifying common ground. As if to emphasise the point, Havel, though faithful to the Atlantic partnership and grateful to the American role in the emancipation
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 45
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
45
of his country from communist rule, nonetheless insisted that ‘the artificial world order of past decades ha(d) collapsed’, and that the central political task now was the creation of a new model of co-existence among the various cultures, peoples, races and religious spheres within a single interconnected civilisation. That he should have chosen to develop this theme in a landmark speech delivered on American Independence Day in the Independence Hall of Philadelphia where he was to be received with pomp and ceremony as one of the heroes of the post-Cold War period, is indicative of the importance he attached to the symbolic link between his message, the occasion and his audience. I now turn to a figure no less significant and just as controversial in his country and internationally, who perhaps more than any other has been instrumental in placing the dialogue of civilisations on the intellectual and political map. Hojjatoleslam Seyyed Mohammad Khatami, the fifth president of the Islamic Republic of Iran, is a religious scholar steeped in the study of philosophy. He headed the Hamburg Islamic Centre in 1979, is fluent in English, German and Arabic in addition to Persian, and has written several books and articles, little of which has been published in the English-speaking world. He successfully proposed the idea of the dialogue of civilisations to the Organisation of the Islamic Conference in 1997, and then gained the unanimous acceptance of the idea at the 1998 UN General Assembly, which went on to declare 2001 as the Year of Dialogue among Civilisations and to adopt the Global Agenda for Dialogue Among Civilizations. Numerous international governmental and non-governmental organisations have since adopted the principle and organised forums, colloquia and conferences, although declarations of principle have yet to be matched by sustained practice. Significant as the organisational impetus he has given to the concept might be, his more notable contribution lies in the intellectual domain, and especially in his characterisation of the dialogical process. Dialogue, which for him is the common search for truth, is not meant to obscure or evade the differences that separate its participants, which is why for him the act is one in which listening is at least as important as speaking. Dialogue, then, is the encounter across cultural, religious, philosophical, ethical, civilisational boundaries, in which each participant listens to the other, becomes open, even vulnerable to the other. In this sense, dialogue engages the participant in a journey of self-discovery: It is only through immersion in another existential dimension that we could attain mediated and acquired knowledge of ourselves in addition to the immediate and direct knowledge of ourselves that we commonly possess. Through
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
46
1:52 PM
Page 46
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
seeing others we attain a hitherto impossible knowledge of ourselves. Dialogue among cultures and civilizations, rests upon rational and ethically normative commitment of parties to the dialogue . . . [It] is a bi-lateral or even multi-lateral process in which the end result is not manifest from the beginning.33
What, then, are dialogue’s normative foundations? The recurring themes in Khatami’s numerous speeches on the subject suggest the following key elements: (a) the dignity of human being – made possible only through will to empathy and compassion – as the measure of world order; (b) the refusal of politics without morality; (c) the notion that ideas and values, embedded in cultures and civilisations, are an important determinant of political behaviour; (d) the sense that intellectuals, poets, artists, scientists and mystics, precisely because they have the capacity and authority to articulate the large questions of human existence, have a unique role in civilisation dialogue. Many questions remain unanswered: Who participates in this dialogue? What are the modalities of dialogue? Are states participants or mere spectators? There is nevertheless atleast one particular idea, central to Khatami’s conception of dialogue, which merits attention. In his celebrated 1999 speech at the University of Florence, he offered the following juxtaposition of East and West: Orient, which even in an etymological sense signifies the process of imparting direction and order to things, can beckon Europe and America to equilibrium, serenity and reflection in the context of an historical dialogue . . . If deeply understood in their Eastern connotations, equilibrium and serenity lie beyond both the Dionysian and Apollonian extremes of western culture. The age of reason is an Apollonian age while romanticism is the opposite pull on the swing of the same pendulum.34
Khatami’s exposition takes us back to the question of what is to be the discursive framework that guides the post-Cold War era. For Khatami dialogue among civilisations is designed specifically to address the fault line that separates Orient and Occident, a fault line that has a long history, of which the present difficulties between Islam and the West are but the most recent, perhaps geopolitically most troublesome manifestation As the third influential voice I have chosen Tu Weiming, perhaps the foremost Confucian thinker of our time. Born in February 1940 in Kunming, China, he grew up and was educated in Taiwan and is now Professor of Chinese History and Philosophy and of Confucian Studies at Harvard University. He holds honorary professorships from Zhejing and Renming Universities and the Shanghai Academy of Social Sciences, and advisory
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 47
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
47
positions in Singapore and Malaysia, with the UN and the World Economic Forum at Davos. A five-volume collection of his works as published in China in 2001.35 A recurring theme of Tu Weiming’s intellectual contribution is the modern transformation of Confucian humanism. Confucian values, he argues, remain highly relevant to modernity and are evident in contemporary social practices, at least as principles of societal organisation. These include: (a) the role of the state in the management of the market; (b) social civility as the key to civilised mode of conduct (law is useful but not enough); (c) the family as the foundation stone of social civility; (d) civil society as the indispensable nexus between family and state; (e) education as the key to civil society; (f) self-cultivation understood as both goal and process. Confucian societies retain many of these values even as they embrace the fierce competitiveness of the West. The reason is not hard to fathom: modernisation and modernity are shaped by cultural forms rooted in tradition: Traditions in Modernity are not merely historical sedimentation passively deposited in modern consciousness. Nor are they simply inhibiting features to be undermined by the unilinear trajectory of development – on the contrary they are both constraining and enabling forces capable of shaping the particular contour of modernity in any given society.36
For Tu Weiming, these traditions constitute the critical elements of sustainable dialogue. What can Confucianism bring to such a dialogue? Here is where Tu Weiming is at his most illuminating. He draws attention to what he calls the ‘ecological turn’ of neo-Confucian thought, and in particular to the contribution of three modern Confucian thinkers, Qian Mu (1895–1990), Tang Junyi (1909–78) and Feng Youlan (1895–1990) based in Hong Kong, Taiwan and China respectively.37 In their critique of the enlightenment and the discourse of modernity, they take us, he contends, beyond aggressive anthropocentrism and instrumental rationality, and pave the way for an inclusive cosmological and humanist vision that transcends the either/or mode of thinking in favour of a nondualistic understanding of the continuity of heaven, earth and humanity. The theme is a highly instructive one, for it offers another path to East–West dialogue. Placed in this context, it is not hard to see why Tu Weiming sees the long-term stability of the Sino-American relationship as likely to depend on
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
48
1:52 PM
Page 48
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
China widening the frame of reference offered by its indigenous traditions. For him, it is these traditions that hold the key to its own spiritual self-definition. The United States which has hitherto functioned principally as a teaching civilisation may have to acquire more of the qualities of a learning culture. Put simply but not inaccurately, Tu Weiming suggests that we may be entering a ‘second axial period’ in which all the major religious and ethical traditions that arose during the ‘first axial period’ are undergoing their own distinctive transformations in response to the multiple challenges of modernity. It is possible that such reassessment will make possible, through a process of mutual learning an ‘anthropocosmic’ worldview where the human is embedded in the cosmic order. This period of transition is the ‘dialogical moment’, the beginning of a new history that is simultaneously global and plural. Such a moment, Tu Weiming tells us, can flourish when ‘the politics of domination is being replaced by the politics of communication, networking, negotiation, interaction, interfacing and collaboration’.38 This brief excursion into civilisation dialogue was not meant to cover what is now a large and rapidly expanding field of philosophical and cultural inquiry. Rather it was meant to suggest that, despite the vastly different cultural and ideological backgrounds from which they spring, influential voices have emerged calling for a distinctive approach to world order, sharply at variance with the one that appears to have informed the vision and practice of empire. This discourse lends itself to the following propositions: (a) Dialogue, that is encounter with the other, is the path to self-discovery and is therefore a profoundly transformative process; (b) Dialogue can proceed only with the renewal of tradition against the backdrop of modernity; (c) The dialogue of civilisations proposes first and foremost the dialogical encounter between East and West; (d) Such encounter will involve a new synthesis constituted of both differences and commonalities; (e) The dialogue of civilisations offers the most promising cultural underpinning for the rapidly evolving multilateral edifice, and for new conceptions of governance, not least regionally and globally. What emerges from this review of civilisation dialogue is that several discourses are presently competing in the international arena for the attention of theorists and practitioners alike. The end of the Cold War, 9/11 and its aftermath, not least the responses of the imperial power and in particular the war in
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 49
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
49
Iraq, have added weight and urgency to this discursive competition. What is at stake is not simply or even primarily the future configuration of global geopolitics, but the norms that will guide the organisation of a still globalising yet fragmenting world. The evidence of the last fifteen years suggests that neither western triumphalism nor the clash of civilisations is likely to provide an acceptable let alone effective basis of world order. The journey from Berlin to Baghdad appears to have opened up a third possibility of a world that is simultaneously singular and plural. In this unfolding transitional moment, the journey between occident and orient has some way to go.
Notes * This chapter is based in part on the keynote address delivered to the HUGGII International Conference Alliance of Civilizations for Global Peace: Human Security, Regional Conflict, and Global Governance, Vancouver, Canada, 25–27 June 2006, an earlier version of which was given at the Philippines-Australia Studies Network Inaugural Week Lectures (see Joseph A. Camilleri et al., Australian Perspectives on Southeast Asia, the United States and the World, Manila: Ateneo de Manila University, 2005, pp. 13–38). 1. The reference here is not simply or even primarily to the body of thought generally referred to as ‘postmodernism’ that has exerted such a profound influence on philosophy, art, critical theory, literature, architecture, interpretation of history and culture in the late twentieth century. An earlier trend is evident in the works of Spengler (Oswald Spengler, The Decline of the West, authorised translation with notes by Charles Francis Atkinson, London: G. Allen & Unwin, 1926–28), and José Ortega y Gasett, The Modern Theme, translated from the Spanish by James Cleugh, New York: Harper, 1961. 2. Worthy of mention in this context is the contribution of Daniel Bell to the notion of post-industrialism, in particular The End of Ideology (New York: Free Press of Glencoe, 1960), The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism (New York: Basic Books, 1976) and The Coming of Post-Industrial Society (London: Heinemann Educational, 1974); and that of Edward Said to post-colonial theory (Culture and Imperialism London: Chatto & Windus, 1993). 3. See Martin Albrow, The Global Age: State and Society beyond Modernity, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1997. 4. See Joseph A. Camilleri, ‘State, Civil Society and Economy’, in Joseph A. Camilleri, Anthony P. Jarvis, Albert J. Paolini (eds), The State in Transition: Reimagining Political Space, Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner 1995, pp. 209–28. 5. See Eliot A. Cohen, ‘History and the Hyperpower’, Foreign Affairs, 83n(4), July/August 2004.
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
50
1:52 PM
Page 50
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
6. See Joseph A. Camilleri and Jim Falk, The End of Sovereignty: Politics in a Shrinking and Fragmenting World, Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar, 1992. 7. A.D. Smith refers to this project as ‘bureaucratic nationalism’. See A.D. Smith, Nations and Nationalism in a Global Era, Cambridge: Polity Press, 1995. 8. The Limits to Growth, a report for the Club of Rome’s Project on the Predicament of Mankind by Donnella H. Meadows, Dennis L. Meadows, Jorgen Randers, William W. Behrens, London: Earth Island, 1972. 9. There is now a rich literature covering most aspects of this evolving landscape. Particularly useful in this regard are: Aseem Prakash and Jeffrey Hart (eds), Globalization and Governance (London: Routledge, 1999); Kenneth Pomerantz and Stephen Topic, The World that Created: Society, Culture and the World Economy, 1400 to the Present (Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe, 1999); Pierre Jacquet et Frédérique Sachwald, ‘Mondialisation: la vraie rupture du XX siècle’, Politique étrangère 3–4/2000: 597–612; John Urry, Global Complexity (Cambridge: Polity Press 2003). 10. Andrew J. Bacevich (ed.), The Imperial Tense: Prospects and Problems of American Empire, Chicago: Ivan R. Dee, 2003. 11. Thierry de Montbrial, Quinze ans qui bouleversèrent le monde: De Berlin à Bagdad, Paris: Dunod, 2003. 12. Joseph A. Camilleri, ‘Alliances and Emerging Post-Cold War Security System’, in Richard Leaver and James L. Richardson (eds), Charting the Post-Cold War Order, Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1993, pp. 81–94. 13. Boutros Boutros-Ghali, An Agenda for Peace: 1995 (2nd edn with new supplement and related documents), New York: United Nations, 1995. 14. Joseph A. Camilleri, ‘The Advanced Capitalist State and the Contemporary World Crisis’, Science and Society, 45 (2), Summer, 1981, pp. 130–58. 15. The idea is further developed in Joseph A. Camilleri, States, Markets and Civil Society in Asia Pacific, The Political Economy of Asia Pacific Vol. I, Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar, 2000, pp. 148–52. As the title of the book indicates, a political economy perspective requires an integrated approach that focuses on the interconnectedness of state, market and civil society. This is highly relevant to any discussion of empire, for here, and especially in the context of the American empire, we are dealing with the American state certainly, but also and of necessity with the American economy, hence the role of US capital, and with American civil society. In what follows, I emphasise the functioning of the state, but by situating it explicitly or implicitly in the context of this triangular relationship. 16. See Huang Zhengji, ‘Volatile World Situation’, International Strategic Studies (published by the China Institute of International Strategic Studies), 24(2), June 1992, pp. 1–5. 17. Yang Dazhou’s position is outlined in Michael Pillsbury, China Debates the Future Security Environment, Washington, DC: National Defense University Press, January 2000 (sighted at http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/china/doctrine/ pills2/part01.htm on 28 June 2004).
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 51
COMPETITION FOR POWER AND LEGITIMACY
51
18. See Chen Qimao, ‘The Transitional Era: Roots of Turbulence and Features of International Affairs’, Shanghai Institute for International Studies Journal 1(2), 1994, pp. 15–32; also Chen, Qimao, ‘New Approaches in China’s Foreign Policy: The Post-Cold War Era,’ Asian Survey, 33(3), March 1993, pp. 237–51. 19. United States Department of Defense, News Transcript, 12 February 2002 (sighted at http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/2002/t02122002_t212sdv2.html on 25 June 2004. 20. See Bertrand Badie, Marie-Claude Smouts (dir.), L’International sans territoire, Paris: L’Harmattan, 1996 (Cultures & Conflits). 21. Bertrand Badie, ‘La puissance américaine condamnée à la modestie’, interview with Jean-Luc Allouche et Jean-Dominique Merchet, Liberation, 15–16 septembre 2001 (sighted at http://xtream.online.fr/china/references/www.liberation.com_quotidien_semaine_20010915samzc.html on 20 May 2004). 22. Paul Virilio, ‘Télésurveillance globale’, Le Monde Diplomatique, August 1999, p. 4. 23. Paul Virilio, ‘L’état d’urgence permanent’, Le Nouvel Observateur, 2051, 26 February 2004 (sighted at http://www.nouvelobs.com/articles/p2051/a233909.html, 20 June 2004). 24. Paul Virilio, ‘Télésurveillance globale’, p. 5. 25. Jean Baudrillard, The Spirit of Terrorism and Other Essays, translated by Chris Turner, London: Verso, 2003. 26. I am deeply indebted here to Fabio Petito’s characterisation of the competing intellectual currents of the post-Cold War period, although it is probably more useful and accurate to think in terms of currents or discourses than theories. See Fabio Petito, ‘The Dialogue of Civilisations as International Political theory: Khatami and Havel, paper presented at the workshop on ‘Political Science and Dialogue of Civilizations’, International Centre for Dialogue Among Civilizations, Tehran, 15–21 May 2003. 27. Francis Fukuyama, The End of History and the Last Man, London: H. Hamilton, 1992. 28. Samuel P. Huntington, ‘The Clash of Civilizations’, Foreign Affairs, 72(3), Summer 1993, pp. 22–8. This much discussed article was subsequently developed into a full length study The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, New York: Simon and Schuster, 1997. 29. Bernard Lewis, ‘Roots of Muslin Rage’, The Atlantic Monthly, September 1990 (sighted at http://www.travelbrochuregraphics.com/extra/roots_of_muslim_ rage.htm on 20 June 2004. 30. See Joseph Camilleri, ‘Terrorism, Anti-Terrorism and the Globalization of Insecurity’, Arena Journal, no. 19, 2002, pp. 7–19. 31. Vaclav Havel, speech delivered at the Latin American Parliament, São Paolo, 19 September 1996 (sighted at http://old.hrad.cz/president/Havel/speeches/ index_uk.html on 22 May 2004). 32. Vaclav Havel, ‘The Need for Transcendence in the Postmodern World’, speech
ch2.qxd
9/4/2007
52
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
1:52 PM
Page 52
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
delivered in Independence Hall, Philadelphia, 4 July 1994 (sighted at http://www.worldtrans.org/whole/havelspeech.htmlon 15 April 2004). Address by H.E. Seyyed Mohammad Khatami, President of the Islamic Republic of Iran at the Dialogue Among Civilizations Conference at the United Nations, 5 September 2005 (sighted at http://www.un.int/iran/dialogue/2000/articles/ 1.html on 12 May 2004). Speech at the European University Institute, Florence, 10 March 1999 (sighted at http://www.dialoguecentre.org/PDF/Florence%20Speech.pdf on 15 June 2004) Some of Tu Weiming’s more important works in English include: Confucian Thought: Selfhood as Creative Transformation, Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1985; The Way, Learning and Politics in Classical Confucian Humanism, Singapore: Institute of East Asian Philosophies, 1985; Confucianism in a Historical Perspective, Singapore: Institute of East Asian Philosophies, 1989; Confucian Traditions in East Asian Modernity: Exploring Moral Education and Economic Culture in Japan and the Four Mini-Dragons (editor), Harvard University Press, 1996. Tu Weiming, lecture delivered at Colorado College, 5 February 1999, sighted at http://www.coloradocollege.edu/academics/anniversary/participants/Tu.htm on 23 April 2004. Tu Weiming, ‘The Ecological Turn in New Confucian Humanism: Implications for China and the World’ (sighted at http://www.tc.columbia.edu/centers/coce/ pdf_files/s8.pdf on 23 April 2004). See Tu Weiming’s presentation to the seminar organised by the Danish Foreign Ministry, Copenhagen, June 1001 (proceedings edited by Jacques Baudot, Building A World Community: Globalisation and the Common Good, Copenhagen: Royal Danish Ministry of Foreign Affairs in association with University of Washington Press, Seattle, 2001).
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 53
PART II Regional Security Problems
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 54
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 55
Chapter 3: US Nuclear Policies* Michael D. Intriligator
Introduction and Purpose
T
here have been remarkable recent changes in US nuclear weapons policy under the current administration of President George W. Bush that were announced in 2002 in three official documents but are neither widely known nor adequately discussed and critiqued. They constitute a new doctrine, the Bush doctrine, ending the security system and nuclear weapons policies of the Cold War period. They thus represent a discontinuous sea change in the international security system that calls for discussion, debate, and analysis, which have not occurred. The earlier bipolar world has been replaced by a proposed unipolar world with the US under President Bush seeing itself as the dominant power or sole superpower. The mutual deterrence system that was part of the Cold War has been replaced by US unilateral actions against possible rivals, including ‘regime change’. Cooperative approaches to national and international security and alliance systems that had existed in the earlier epoch have been replaced by unilateral US policies and actions. Arms control has been replaced by unilateral US arms initiatives. The purposes of this chapter are to present these new concepts related to US nuclear weapons doctrine; to evaluate them; and to consider an alternative approach, that of global security. The new concepts as well as alternatives, such as global security, call for a wide-ranging debate both nationally and internationally. Unfortunately, this has not happened, possibly due to the concern over the US wars in Afghanistan and Iraq that were, ironically, examples of these new policies put into action. Both the new policies and their underlying goals should be subjects of intense scrutiny.
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
56
1:52 PM
Page 56
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Background to the New Bush Policy The background to these new nuclear weapons doctrines includes the end of the Cold War in 1989; the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991; the Project for a New American Century (PNAC) established in 1997 ‘to promote American global leadership’; the advent of the new Bush Administration in January 2001, which included many of the PNAC individuals in major leadership positions; the 11 September 2001 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon; and the ensuing declaration by the Bush administration of a ‘War on Terrorism’. Following on the adoption of these new policies were the invasion and occupation of Afghanistan and Iraq. Changes in Policy Announced in Three Major Policy Documents in 2002 The changes in US nuclear weapons policy were announced in three official documents that were released by the administration in 2002. The first of these documents is the US Nuclear Posture Review (NPR) that was delivered to the US Congress by the US Department of Defense in January 2002. It is a classified document that is mandated by Congress and produced periodically, the last one having been that of the Clinton administration in 1994. The Los Angeles Times leaked the latest version in March 2002. According to the NPR, ‘A combination of offensive and defensive, and nuclear and non-nuclear capabilities is essential to meet the deterrence requirements of the 21st century.’ It is a wide-ranging analysis of the requirements for deterrence in the twenty-first century. It states that it does not provide operational guidance on nuclear targeting or planning. Rather, it states that the Department of Defense continues to plan for a broad range of contingencies and unforeseen threats to the US and its allies in order to deter such attacks in the first place. It does, however, refer to the ‘possible use of nuclear weapons in an Arab–Israeli conflict, in a war between China and Taiwan, or in an attack from North Korea on the South’. It also refers to the possible use of nuclear weapons against targets able to withstand non-nuclear attack, in retaliation for attacks by nuclear, biological, or chemical weapons, or ‘in the event of surprising military developments’. Thus, it calls for contingency plans for the use of nuclear weapons in various contingencies, including against non-nuclear weapons states and in response to conventional weapons. It also states that the administration is fashioning a more diverse set of options for deterring the threat of weapons of mass destruction (WMD), which emerged as the last of these three policy documents in December 2002.
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 57
US NUCLEAR POLICIES
57
Overall, according to the NPR, nuclear weapons play a critical role in the defense capabilities of the United States, its allies and friends. They provide credible military options to deter a wide range of threats, including WMD and large-scale conventional military force. The NPR states that these ‘nuclear capabilities possess unique properties that give the United States options to hold at risk classes of targets [that are] important strategic and political objectives’. This document calls for the integration of nuclear weapons into conventional strike options, thus diminishing the firewall separating nuclear and conventional weapons and the development of new nuclear weapons to provide a wider range of options to defeat hardened and deeply buried targets. It also calls for a reduced reliance on nuclear weapons via missile defense and non-nuclear strike forces, including precision conventional forces, but, at the same time an indefinite retention of nuclear weapons under the 2002 Strategic Offensive Reduction Treaty (SORT) – the Moscow Treaty. The second of these documents is the National Security Strategy of the United States of America (NSS) that was issued by the Office of the National Security Advisor to the President in September 2002. It is an unclassified and open public document that is available on the White House website. According to the NSS, there are plans to ensure that no nation could rival US military strength. The emphasis is on defeating rogue states and global terrorists, noting that deterrence will not work against such enemies. It proclaims the doctrine of US preemption, where it states that the US ‘cannot let our enemies strike first’ and gives arguments for preemption. (Some have noted, correctly, that this is not a doctrine of preemption but rather one of preventive war.) For example, it notes that, ‘For centuries, international law recognized that nations need not suffer an attack before they can lawfully take action to defend themselves against forces that present an imminent danger of attack.’ It further states that ‘The US has long maintained the option of preemptive actions to counter a sufficient threat to our national security.’ It should be noted, however, that the US did not preempt in most of the recent wars it has fought, including the two World Wars, Korea, Vietnam, and the Gulf War, while its attempt at preemption in the Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba was a total failure. Far from there being historical precedents, this new policy represents a fundamental shift from a US policy of reaction to a new policy of initiation. It is too early to say that this policy of preemption in the Iraq War was a success or failure, but the costs in terms of both casualties and dollar spending have been immense and much larger than expected. Indeed, this war is being seen more and more as a quagmire and likened to the Vietnam War. The NSS notes that ‘To forestall or prevent such hostile acts by our adversaries, the United States will, if necessary act preemptively.’ Such a policy of
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
58
1:52 PM
Page 58
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
preemption is, however, a violation of the UN system that was set up in large part to prevent precisely such preemption, as in Hitler’s invasion of Poland or Japan’s invasion of China. The UN Charter forbids a member state from taking military action against another member state unless it has itself been attacked or it has the authorization of the Security Council. The US acted preemptively in the current Iraq War, which represented the first application of the NSS policy, but, at the same time, also represented a violation of the UN Charter. In terms of international law, the US was as much an outlaw in its attack on Iraq as Saddam Hussein was in his attack on Kuwait. President Bush’s West Point Commencement Speech of June 2002 articulates many of the points in the NPR and the NSS. In fact, this speech set the stage for the NSS, which quotes at length from it. The third of these documents is the National Strategy to Combat Weapons of Mass Destruction (NSWMD) that was issued by the White House in December 2002. As in the case of NSS, NSWMD is an unclassified and open public document that is available on the White House website. It notes that WMD, including nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons in the possession of states hostile to the US or terrorists represents one of the greatest security challenges facing the US. It states that an effective strategy for countering WMD, including their use and further proliferation, is an integral component of the National Security Strategy of the US. It states that, as in the war on terrorism, the strategy for homeland security, and the new concept of deterrence, this new approach to WMD represents a fundamental change from the past. It affirms that the highest priority is accorded to protection of the US and its allies from the threat of WMD. The three pillars it announces are counterproliferation to combat WMD use, strengthened nonproliferation to combat WMD proliferation, and consequence management to respond to WMD use. It discusses such policies as interdiction of WMD, new methods of deterrence with threats of overwhelming force, and defense mitigation, including the destruction of an adversary’s WMD before their use, on a first-strike attack as in the preemptive policy enunciated in NSS, as well as traditional nonproliferation approaches. It does not exclude the use of nuclear weapons to destroy facilities that could produce nuclear weapons. The policies set out in NSWMD were further elaborated by President George W. Bush in his February 11, 2004 speech at the National Defense University, in which he developed a seven-point agenda, including international cooperation against proliferation, requiring all states to criminalize proliferation, an expansion of the Nunn-Lugar Cooperative Threat Reduction program, the required renunciation of reprocessing and enrichment for
ch3.qxd
10/11/2007
3:03 PM
Page 59
US NUCLEAR POLICIES
59
non-nuclear weapons state parties to the NPT, a required additional protocol for states to import equipment for civilian nuclear reactors, the formation of a special committee of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Board to focus on safeguards and verification, and a requirement that states under investigation for violations of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT) not be allowed to serve on the IAEA Board of Governors.
Targets for Nuclear Weapons According to the NPR the US reserves the right to use nuclear weapons, thereby possibly breaking the taboo against their use that has existed since their first and only use – by the US against Japan in August 1945. According to this statement of US policy they are treated like any other weapon, with no sharp distinction from non-nuclear weapons, unlike traditional doctrine that sees them as weapons of last resort. Nuclear targeting discussions have been a part of US military strategy for some time, but the leak of the NPR provides for the first time an official ‘hit list’ of targets for nuclear weapons. The NPR lists seven nations as possible targets for US nuclear weapons. First are the two ‘old’ enemies of Russia and China. Second are the three countries listed as members of the ‘Axis of Evil’ in President Bush’s 2002 State of the Union speech, namely Iran, Iraq, and North Korea. Third are two countries that are listed by the US as terrorist states: Syria and Libya. Of these seven nations that could be targets of US nuclear weapons, three are non-nuclear weapons states that are parties to the Treaty on the NonProliferation of Nuclear Weapons, the NPT, namely Iran, Syria, and Libya (‘regime change’ has occurred in Iraq as a result of the US invasion, while North Korea has withdrawn from the NPT). The US along with other nuclear weapons states that are parties to the NPT, however, gave so-called ‘negative security assurances’ to non-nuclear weapons state parties to the NPT in 1978, pledging that it would not use nuclear weapons against such non-nuclear states unless they were allied with nuclear powers. The most recent such pledge was given on April 5, 1995 during the Clinton administration by Secretary of State Warren Christopher, who stated: The United States reaffirms that it will not use nuclear weapons against nonnuclear-weapon States Parties to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons except in the case of an invasion or any other attack on the United States, its territories, its armed forces or other troops, its allies, or on a
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
60
1:52 PM
Page 60
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
State toward which it has a security commitment, carried out or sustained by such a non-nuclear-weapon States in association or alliance with a nuclearweapon State.
This pledge was reiterated by the US State Department spokesman Richard Boucher on February 11, 2002 but undermined by his saying that if WMD were used against the US the Administration would not rule out any specific type of military response. Thus, targeting any of these three nations with nuclear weapons would be a violation of these US negative assurances that provided an inducement for these states to join the NPT and that were reiterated at the time of the NPT Review and Extension Conference in 1995. The NPR also calls for lesser reliance on the massive stockpiles of nuclear weapons as a deterrent to attack, with greater reliance on precision-guided weapons to deter attacks. It states that because of improvements in precisionguided weaponry, as demonstrated in the war in Afghanistan, the US military can now rely more on powerful, highly accurate conventional bombs and missiles. A New Triad According to the NPR there is a new triad. The old triad consisted of three different basing modes for nuclear weapons: long-range bombers, land-based missiles, and submarine-launched ballistic missiles. By contrast, the NPR refers to a new triad with three component parts of the US strategic system. First are offensive strike weapons, both nuclear and nonnuclear, including all three components of the old triad. Second are defenses, both active and passive, including the new national missile defense system that is currently under construction. Third is a revitalized defense infrastructure that could ‘design, develop, manufacture, and certify new warheads in response to new national requirements and maintain readiness to resume underground testing [at the Nevada Test Site] if required’. The Bush administration has obtained agreement from Congress to lift its ban on the design of new nuclear warheads, and there are plans to develop two such weapons. One is a low-yield weapon, a ‘mini-nuke’, that could potentially be used as a weapon in regional conflicts, thus possibly changing the role of nuclear weapons from that of deterring war to that of an instrument of war. The other is the Robust Nuclear Earth Penetrator, a ‘bunker buster’, that can destroy underground facilities, including missile silos in Russia, China, and
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 61
US NUCLEAR POLICIES
61
elsewhere. The administration has already started to construct a missile defense system at Fort Greeley, Alaska, and the Secretary of Defense has asked his Science Board to look into the possibility that the new system might use nuclear-tipped interceptors. Such interceptors would be much more effective in destroying incoming missiles than the more conventional hit-to-kill interceptors that are being tested now, and they could even neutralize a Russian second-strike deterrent. Thus, the NPR is a strategy for indefinite reliance on nuclear weapons with plans to improve the capabilities of the existing arsenal and to revitalize the infrastructure for improving US nuclear forces in the future. It promotes a nuclear strategy of maximum flexibility as opposed to measures for irreversible nuclear disarmament as agreed to at the 2000 NPT Review Conference in the form of ‘13 Practical Steps’ related to Article VI of the NPT Treaty that calls for the elimination of nuclear weapons. The US and the other nuclear weapons states that are parties to the treaty agreed to these steps. They included ‘an unequivocal undertaking to accomplish the total elimination of their nuclear arsenals’; an early ratification of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty; and a diminishing role for nuclear weapons in security policies, including irreversible and verifiable reductions of both strategic and tactical nuclear weapons. According to NSWMD and the other 2002 documents, however, the US has no intention of giving up its nuclear weapons but rather sees them as playing an even more important role in its security strategy and as part of a continuum of weapons, with no clear breaks or taboos against their use.
Preemption and Its Dangers The NSS places major emphasis on preemption (more properly, as already noted, a preventive war) and calls for preemption rather than deterrence as the fundamental basis of national security. The Iraq War is the initial case of such preemption, with the US retaining its right to preempt in defending its vital interests. (The Afghanistan War is more properly interpreted as a retaliatory strike for the 11 September 2001 attacks on the US) Such a policy of preemption requires massive defense spending, and the US now spends more than $400 billion annually on defense, more than most of the rest of the world combined. In addition to its costs, there are significant dangers associated with preemption. First, it creates antagonism toward the US and the possibility of further terrorist attacks. Second, it sends a message to the rest of the world, that they should not attempt to fight the US with
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
62
1:52 PM
Page 62
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
conventional weapons, leading to the proliferation of nuclear weapons and other weapons of mass destruction. Third, this policy sets a precedent for other nations to also engage in similar preemption, including China in Taiwan and India in Pakistan. Fourth, there are dangers stemming from US hubris after its quick defeat of Saddam Hussein’s forces in Iraq, with the next step possibly being an invasion of the other nations on President Bush’s ‘Axis of Evil’ list: Iran and North Korea, or possibly others on the NPR nuclear hit list, such as Syria or Libya, or yet others, such as Sudan or Cuba. These nations will see such a possibility as looming and try to protect themselves, possibly by building their own nuclear weapons, as has already happened in North Korea. According to the New York Times editorial of March 12, 2002: If another country were planning to develop a new nuclear weapon and contemplating pre-emptive strikes against a list of non-nuclear powers, Washington would rightly label that nation a dangerous rogue state. Yet, such is the course recommended to President Bush by a new Pentagon planning paper . . . Nuclear weapons are not just another part of the military arsenal. They are different, and lowering the threshold for their use is reckless folly.
A New Non-Proliferation Agenda The new non-proliferation agenda included ‘old approaches’ such as controls on materials and technology and ‘new approaches’ such as reserving the right to destroy facilities used to make WMD. A precedent for the latter was the Israeli destruction of the Osirak reactor near Baghdad in 1981 before it could be used to make nuclear weapons. Many nations criticized Israel for this action that was in violation of international law, including the UN Charter, given that the Security Council did not authorize it. Similar criticisms could be directed at the US if it were to engage in such acts. Furthermore, if the US claims a right to such acts then other nations could also make such a claim, creating very dangerous situations. For example, India might claim the right to destroy Pakistani nuclear facilities using the same logic or China could claim a right to destroy the nuclear infrastructure of Taiwan or Japan. Such policies and actions would make the world a much more dangerous place. One could also argue that the ‘old’ problem of proliferation was that of nations acquiring nuclear weapons, while the ‘new’ problem is one of terrorist groups acquiring such weapons. More should be done on a cooperative international basis to deny such weapons to terrorist organizations or subnational groups in general. This should be done under the auspices of the UN as a truly
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 63
US NUCLEAR POLICIES
63
international cooperative effort. As to the old problem, involving such nations as Iran and North Korea, a case could be made that their acquiring such weapons could, in fact, be stabilizing rather than destabilizing if the effect is to deter the US from using its weapons against these nations seeking further ‘regime change.’ The world has noted that the US invaded and occupied two non-nuclear nations, Afghanistan and Iraq, but that it did not invade North Korea or Iran, nations that were on President Bush’s ‘Axis of Evil’ in his January 2002 State of the Union address, possibly since the former already has nuclear weapons while the latter could possibly acquire them in the near future. Indeed, the US 2002 documents on nuclear policy create powerful incentives for states to proliferate to deter a US preemptive strike.
An Alternative Approach: Global Security There is an alternative to the policies that are enunciated in the NPR, the NSS, and the NSWMD, namely global security. The concept refers to security for the planet as a whole to replace the concept of national security, which is outmoded. National security, which is defined up to certain well-defined borders, makes little sense given the globalization that has occurred. The goal of global security would be that of protecting the planet as a whole from threats to its vital interests. This approach recognizes the value of global cooperation, in particular, the value of cooperative efforts among the current great powers of the US, the EU, Japan, Russia, China, India, Indonesia, Brazil, Argentina, South Africa, and others. The concept of global security recognizes the need to create a new global system comparable to the creation of a new world system after World War II, one that would encompass not only security but also economics, politics, and other issue areas. This new global system would treat problems of security, both military and non-military, through strengthening existing international institutions or creating new global institutions. These new institutions could be built, in part, on the UN system and its components. They would involve supranational decision-making and authority, with enforcement capabilities, transparency, and accountability and with global perspectives and responses. Participation in the global decision-making process would be through close international cooperation. There would be a prohibition against preemption by any one nation, no matter how powerful, in favor of collective action. Such a system of global security should be preferred to the current system of the US as a hegemonic global power.
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
64
1:52 PM
Page 64
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Among the specific steps that might be taken in an agenda to foster such a system of global security are reducing world stockpiles of nuclear weapons and other WMD, especially the enormous stockpile of chemical weapons in Russia; a ratification of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty; taking nuclear weapons off hair-trigger alert and generally dealerting WMD; a reaffirmation of the moratorium against nuclear testing; international cooperation to prevent nuclear proliferation; implementation of the 13 steps program under the NPT with specific timetables for each of these steps, including an abandonment of all plans to develop new nuclear weapons; a sharing of Permissive Action Link (PAL) technology with all nuclear weapons states to reduce the chance of accidental nuclear war; a US renunciation of its policy of preemption and its reaffirmation of the UN Charter; and cooperative efforts against terrorism, especially the acquisition of WMD by terrorist groups. Notes * A Presentation to the GRAD Conference on ‘Regional Cooperation and Global Security’ International Business School, Budapest, 30 June–4 July 2004.
Bibliography Allison, Graham (2004) Nuclear Terrorism: The Ultimate Preventable Catastrophe, New York: Times Books. Arkin, William M. (2002) ‘Secret Plan Outlines the Unthinkable,’ Los Angeles Times, March 10. Cushman, John H., Jr. (2002) ‘Rattling New Sabers,’ The New York Times, March 10. Gaddis, John Lewis (2003) ‘A Grand Strategy of Transformation,’ Foreign Policy 133: 50–7. Gordon, Michael R. (2002) ‘US Nuclear Plan Sees New Weapons and New Targets,’ The New York Times, March 10. —— (2002) ‘Nuclear Arms for Deterrence or Fighting?’ The New York Times, March 11. Gould, Robert M. and Patrice Sutton (2002) ‘Global Security: Beyond Gated Communities and Bunker Vision,’ Social Justice 29(3): 1. Guoliang, Gu (2003) ‘Redefine Cooperative Security, Not Preemption,’ The Washington Quarterly 26(2): 135. Heisbourg, François (2003) ‘A Work in Progress: The Bush Doctrine and Its Consequences,’ The Washington Quarterly 26(2): 75. Hoffman, Stanley (2003) ‘The High and the Mighty: Bush’s National Security Strategy and the New American Hubris,’ The American Prospect 13(24): 28.
ch3.qxd
9/4/2007
1:52 PM
Page 65
US NUCLEAR POLICIES
65
Intriligator, Michael D. (1994) ‘Global Security After the End of the Cold War,’ Presidential Address, Peace Science Society (International), Conflict Management and Peace Science 13(2): 1–11. Levi, Michael A. (2003) ‘The Case Against New Nuclear Weapons: New Tactical Bombs Would Have Little Military Value and Would Undercut US Nonproliferation Efforts,’ Issues in Science and Technology (March). McGwire, Michael (2002) ‘Shifting the Paradigm (Western Ideology of the Cold War),’ International Affairs 78(1): 1. O’Hanlon, Michael E. (2002) ‘The New National Security Strategy and Preemption,’ Brookings Institution. US Department of Defense (2002) Nuclear Posture Review, The Pentagon ( January). Excerpts available at http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/policy/ dod/npr.htm US Office of the National Security Advisor (2002) The National Security Strategy of the United States of America, The White House (September). http://www.whitehouse.gov/nsc/nss.html US Office of the President (2002) National Strategy to Combat Weapons of Mass Destruction, The White House (December). http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/ 2002/12/WMDStrategy.pdf
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 66
Chapter 4: Regional Security in Latin America Benedicte Bull
Introduction
R
egionalism in Latin America has traditionally revolved around two competing visions: the Latin American-led regionalism originating in Simón Bolívar’s Pan-American visions, and US visions of a cooperating Latin America originating in the Monroe Doctrine (Hurrel 1995; Kirby 2003). Currently regional integration initiatives abound; both those that represent a continuation of the visions of Bolívar, and those that emerge from US aspirations of hemispheric leadership. The main focus of current integration processes – including Mercosur and the negotiations for a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) – has been economic issues, primarily trade and investments. However, the wave of new regionalism also encompasses security issues. In the 1990s, a fragile consensus about specific values upon which security cooperation should be founded was established. However, this consensus broke down with the increasingly unilateral policies of the US after 2000, and the interpretation of Latin American security issues within the frames of the War on Terror. This has led to a division between those Latin American countries that support an aggressive US security policy, and those countries that are more skeptical towards it. This division adds to the already diverse security calculations among the Latin American countries, and makes it unlikely that a more committing security framework than the one already in place will emerge in the near future. This chapter analyzes security co-operation in Latin America with a special emphasis on the role played by the US The chapter is structured chronologically; it starts by discussing the Cold War period, moves on to the human security interlude of the 1990s, and ends with the period of the Bush administration. The main argument that I make is that security issues in Latin America are complex and essentially contested. What are considered solutions
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 67
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
67
to security problems by some are considered threats by others. However, the US presence in the region has contributed to the tendency to subsume complex threats within simplified concepts of the enemy in accordance with US geo-strategic interests and shifting policies. With the exception of Cuba, the enemy in Latin America has never been identified as a specific country; rather the threat has been of a changing transnational nature. In the Cold War era it was communism, in the 1990s it was drug-trafficking, and in the post-2001 period it has been terrorism. This simplification of the security agenda has contributed to the continued irrelevance of the institutions of the hemispheric security system, and to the lack of successful cooperation efforts regarding many of the most pressing security issues.
Regional Security and Contested Security Concepts Recently, some significant literature has added to our understanding of the regional security dynamics of Latin America and its relationship to the global order. The starting point of these contributions is that we are currently not facing a single global order, but rather a variety of new regional orders. However, different authors utilize different concepts of security, and have different views with regards to the extent to which regional orders are viewed as independent of global orders. This chapter applies a constructivist concept of security, based on Buzan et al.’s (1998) definition. The intention of its formulation was a desire to move beyond both the traditional notion of security focusing on military threats against states, but also avoid the pitfalls of a wider notion of security including non-military threats against a variety of referent objects. The critique of both concepts is now well-known.1 Among main shortcomings of the traditional concept is that it fails to account for the fact that the most pressing threats against the lives of the populations is the very state, whereas the wider concept runs the risk of diluting the concept of security. To make up for this, Buzan et al. argue that to qualify as a security threat it has to be ‘staged as an existential threat to a referent object by a securitizing actor who thereby generates endorsement of emergency measures beyond rules that would otherwise bind’ (1998: 5). Whereas this concept is also vulnerable to critique for essentially being able to encompass just about any threat to human existence (dependent on the existence of successful securitizing actors), it allows us to study the crucial phase in which a security threat is constructed. However, this can never be the only purpose of security analysis (and the authors certainly are not ready to
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
68
1:50 PM
Page 68
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
limit their analysis to that). Thus, at the core of a security analysis must also be an understanding of what is the real threats against the lives of citizens. This is the double concept underlying the approach to regional security by Hentz and Bøås (2003) who in spite of warning against the pitfalls of a widening agenda attempts to include a wide range of threats, regionalizing and securitizing actors and referent objects in their analysis. What is sacrificed of theoretical parsimony is attempted made up for by empirical relevance. The underlying security concept of this analysis will mainly be a constructivist concept, but with the qualification that the issues that are securitized are not necessarily the only existing threats to people’s survival. The second issue is what is a regional order and how does it relate to the global order? Lake and Morgan (1997) argue that regional orders are open systems and thus linked to global orders. Nevertheless, their desire to understand regional orders is founded on a desire ‘to identify when and how great powers, like the United States, can best contribute to regional stability in the years ahead’ (Lake and Morgan 1997: 6). This implies that regional orders may exist prior to and can be analyzed independent of the activities of great powers, in spite of their assertion that regional and global orders are interlinked. This, I will argue in the following, is not unproblematic. A second major contribution to the field of regional security (Buzan and Wæver 2003) argue explicitly that regional security complexes (defined as ‘a set of units whose major processes of securitization, desecuritization, or both are so interlinked that their security problems cannot reasonably be analysed or resolved apart from one another’, ibid.: 44) are mutually exclusive, and that they should be analyzed as a ‘closed’ subsystem. An outside power may also penetrate the region and pose significant threats to it. Moreover, in extreme cases outside powers may have what they call ‘overlay’, defined as a situation in which great power interests transcend mere penetration, and come to dominate a region so heavily that the local pattern of security relations virtually ceases to operate (Buzan and Wæver 2003: 61). Nevertheless, this does in their view not take away from the fact that the close interlinkage of securitization processes within a region distinguishes it from outside forces. The argument above is important, and perhaps also necessary for the project of Buzan and Wæver to re-focus security studies on territoriality, without limiting the analysis to one specific state. However, the possibility of analyzing regional dynamics separate from the global superpower is based on an emphasis on material forces and an equal de-emphasis on ideational power. I will argue that the United States have played a significant role in the securitization of specific issues in the Latin American region and the desecuritization of
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 69
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
69
others. Its role goes beyond being an external threat or penetrating the region, also in cases that do not fit the description of ‘overlay’ (which primarily relates to classical imperialism), by influencing the very ideas of what is to be considered a security issue. Buzan and Wæver argue for example that ‘South America is close to creating a security community based on securitizing primarily an external economic threat, and from this deriving the necessity of regional pacification’ (Buzan and Wæver 2003: 57). I will argue that this misses the point that the very process of securitization is deeply influenced by the United States, in matters not related directly to it being a threat or a guarantor against other threats. The key role of the US in the definition of regional security issues, or regional securitization, also calls into question the neat dividing line between the North American and the South American regional security complexes that Buzan and Wæver operates with. In other words, they do not adopt the term ‘Latin America’, but argue that securitization processes in Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean are interlinked with the securitization of the United States, whereas the Southern Cone and the Andean region make up a separate security complex. It is true that the securitization processes of northern, central and southern Latin America differ significantly, and also that they differ from the processes in the Caribbean. However, it is also true that the very process through which the United States securitizes threats emerging from its southern neighbors the American continent, contributes to the construction of them as one single region – or alternatively several sub-regions (Central America, the Caribbean, the Andean region, the Southern Cone) – not two. The fact that the United States tries to construct Latin America as one region in security terms does of course not mean that any analyst should do the same. However, as I will discuss below page 74, the US policy and regionalizing strategies do impact on the region in a way that further interlinks the process of securitization. In sum, this analysis owes a lot to the ones cited above. However, it differs by including the United States as an important regionalizing actor that attempts actively to impact on the processes of securitization in Latin America. Although their own security calculations are more dependent on those of the northern part of Latin America than the southern part, their regionalizing strategies crucially impact on both. This chapter also differs from the approaches discussed above by looking directly at the possibility for regional security cooperation and how that is linked to the question of securitization and the strategies of regionalizing actors.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
70
1:50 PM
Page 70
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Security in the Cold War Latin America A review of different concepts of security that have dominated the political agendas in Latin America over the last fifty years reveals that security has always been a contested concept. The Cold War era was dominated by the so called ‘traditional agenda’ and intra-state security issues, either discussed as having their roots in the deep-rooted inequality of the social structures, or in global communism. Security concepts in the Cold War era In Latin American security debates it is common to refer to a series of interstate conflicts, many of which have their roots back to colonial times, as the ‘traditional agenda’. In the Southern Cone, Brazil and Argentina have long competed for the hegemony of the Southern Atlantic Ocean, and there have been frequent border confrontations between Chile and Argentina (with a climax in 1978). Chile has a further border dispute with Bolivia. At the Pacific coast, Peru and Ecuador experienced a series of confrontations throughout the twentieth century. Moreover, Peru never attempted to hide that it prepared for a conflict with Chile in the 1980s, whereas Venezuela and Colombia have competed for control over the Golfo de Maracaibo. Further north, tensions between Honduras and El Salvador resulted in the so-called ‘soccer war’ in 1969. Both countries compete with Nicaragua for the control over resources in the Golfo de Fonseca. Colombia and Nicaragua have conflicts over the maritime delimitation of certain Caribbean islands, Nicaragua and Costa Rica have confrontations over Rio San Juan, and Guatemala still disputes the sovereignty of Belize (Tapia 2003). The ‘traditional agenda’ is not entirely a Cold War phenomenon, nor is it of purely historical interest, as many of these inter-state disputes still linger.2 In total, there are sixteen unresolved inter-state disagreements in Latin America and during the 1990s, military forces were utilized between Latin American states seventeen times, although only at one occasion did it result in a war-like situation (the conflict between Ecuador and Peru in 1995) (Rojas Aravena 2004). There are also ‘new’ tensions between Latin American states that may threaten to escalate into conflicts. These include the current relationship between Venezuela and Colombia, resulting partly from the spill-over from the Colombia conflict into Venezuela (as will be discussed below page 83) and partly from the differences between Colombian right-wing president Alvaro Uríbe and the left-wing populist president of Venezuela, Hugo Chávez.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 71
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
71
Nevertheless, it is generally acknowledged that inter-state conflicts in Latin America increasingly are dealt with in diplomatic forums, and that there currently is no major threat of a fully fledged inter-state war in Latin America. However, this does not mean that all the security problems from the past are solved. Indeed, the ‘traditional agenda’ has never constituted the most serious threat to people’s lives in Latin America. It is civil wars rather than inter-state wars that have constituted the most serious threat to people’s lives in Latin America. For example, the soccer war between El Salvador and Honduras lasted for 100 hours and killed approximately 2,000. In contrast, during the course of the twelve-year civil war in El Salvador, an estimated 75,000 people were killed. The same mismatch can be reported in Guatemala, where the 36-year long civil war left some 150,000 dead. This contrasts with the Guatemala–Belize border issue that never has resulted in outright military confrontation, in spite of repeated threats. Although the states of South America did not match the Central American ones in terms of killing of their citizens, also here internal conflicts demanded more lives than inter-state conflicts. The war between Ecuador and Peru in 1995 caused a few hundred victims and lasted for two days, whereas the internal confrontation between Sendero Luminoso and the government lasted for twelve years and caused an estimated 12,000 victims (Tapia 2003). Similarly, the numbers of casualties of the Falkland war between Argentina and Great Britain are dwarfed by the number of deaths in the ‘dirty war’ of the Argentine state. Historians and other scholars with in-depth knowledge of Latin America point to a complex set of issues that contributed to the outbreak of civil wars in Central America and the rise of authoritarian and violent regimes further South. The non-inclusive nature of the national states, the domination of small oligarchies, the skewed distribution of land and feudal organization of labor in the countryside, the vulnerability of the elites leading to the necessity of violent ‘protection racket states’ (Stanley 1996) are all elements in the explanation of the insurgencies in Nicaragua, El Salvador and Guatemala, and the rise of authoritarian regimes in South America. However, as is well known, that was not the explanation offered by the United States. The US connected the different insurgent movement invariably to the global communist threat. That not only resulted in the well-known support for anti-communist governments and counter-insurgencies, but also gave the impetus to hemispheric security ‘cooperation’.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
72
1:50 PM
Page 72
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Security cooperation in the Cold War era The US concern with the communist threat led to the creation of a series of multilateral organizations. On the one hand, it spurred interest in the creation of organizations for economic development as a means to curb the spread of communism in the region. This was the main backdrop of the Alliance for Progress initiated by the Kennedy administration in 1960. The communist threat and Latin American resentment against the US was also the main reason why the US changed its attitude towards the Latin American proposal for a regional development bank. Vice-president Richard Nixon’s tour in Latin America early 1958 was a wake-up call regarding the risks that development in the region posed to the US, and consequently, the US endorsed the plans for the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), which was created the year after (Dell 1972). On the other hand, US concern with communism overshadowed the agendas of already existing organizations for security cooperation. The InterAmerican Defense Board (IADB) was established in 1942 originally to deal with the fascist threat by coordinating an inter-American defense and political response to it. However, its main tasks were soon to be support of anti-communist work. The Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance (IATRA) (the Rio Treaty), signed in 1947, was designed to provide the region with a flexible collective security arrangement. It was initiated by the United States, and Latin American countries always viewed it with a great deal of skepticism. Over the course of the post-war period, their skepticism was strengthened by a series of developments. IATRA was converted dramatically into an anticommunist alliance in the 1960s, making the US priorities of the Cold War the main purpose of the alliance. Furthermore, it repeatedly served US rather than Latin American interest when they were in conflict. One example was its stance in the Falkland conflict. Due to US pressure IATRA supported the United Kingdom to the dismay of many regional governments (Tapia 2003). The fact that IATRA was absent from the multilateral efforts to resolve the ‘traditional conflicts’ (see below page 79) further diminished its relevance. Finally, the Charter of the Organization of the American States (OAS), established in 1948, is itself a statement of collective security and defense cooperation through its chapters V and VI. The American Treaty for Peaceful Resolutions was signed simultaneously with the creation of the OAS, and since then a series of other agreements have been added to it.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 73
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
73
However, OAS has also been subdued due to controversies between the Latin American countries and the United States for most of its existence. Whereas the Latin American countries have viewed it as a shield against US intervention, the US has perceived it as a vehicle for its foreign policy interests (Gosselin and Thérien 1999). The OAS’s debut was the support of the USbacked ouster of social reformist president Jacobo Arbenz in Guatemala in 1954. This left an impression of the organization as little more than a tool in the hands of the United States, an image it was stuck with until the ‘interlude of human and democratic security’ in the 1990s gave it increased powers to play a role in resolution of conflicts (see page 74). Nevertheless, even in the Cold War era, Latin American countries managed to create ‘pockets’ of autonomy for Latin American initiatives. A series of adhoc coalitions created to resolve specific issues have been among the most efficient initiatives in the region. These were sub-regional initiatives that were not initiated by the United States, nor did they involve the inter-American organizations to any significant extent. In fact, the presence of the United Nations in the groups that contributed to the resolution of conflicts in the region has been more significant than the presence of the inter-American organizations. There are four major examples of regional multilateral conflict resolution. These are, first, the Grupo Contadora (Colombia, Mexico, Panama and Venezuela) established in 1983 with the main purpose of solving the political conflicts in Central America, second, Grupo del Rio that emerged out of the Grupo Contadora and (consisting of all the countries in Central and South America, Mexico, the Dominican Republic and one representative of the anglophone Caribbean), that has met annually since 1987 to discuss security issues in the region. In addition to these two groups, there were formed two groups of Friends of Latin American and non-regional countries, to resolve the conflicts in El Salvador and Guatemala respectively. In addition to these, some more limited treaties between the Latin American countries have also had great success. That includes the Treaty of Tlateloco (1967), which has contributed to making Latin America and the Caribbean the first zone free of nuclear weapons in the world (Figoli 2003). In conclusion, during the Cold War era, the successful examples of security cooperation between Latin American states were those that were initiated by Latin American countries themselves, with minor US involvement, and with clearly defined tasks. General hemispheric organizations, on the other hand, tended to erode into US-led anti-communist clubs and generally contribute more to the insecurity of people than to the resolution of the region’s problems. This situation changed by the end of the Cold War.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
74
1:50 PM
Page 74
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Security in the Latin America of the 1990s It has often been argued that the Cold War ended in Latin America before the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. However, one may also say that it ended later. What marked the end of the Cold War was the fall of right-wing dictators in the Southern Cone starting in the mid-1980s, and the end of the civil wars in Central America (Nicaragua 1990, El Salvador 1992 and Guatemala 1996). Both processes were, of course, partly related to the diminishing US support for authoritarian regimes and for right-wing insurgents (Contras in Nicaragua). In the early to mid-1990s, there was a renewed interest in a broader security concept than the traditional one. However, over the course of the 1990s it was again overshadowed by the US interpretation of the ‘new threats’ focusing primarily on drugs and increasingly centered on Colombia. Thus, again the US contributed to narrowing the security agenda in the region, but this time revolving around different US concerns than during the Cold War. The 1990s was characterized by the end of the three bloody civil wars in Central America and the return to democracy in the countries of the Southern Cone. Therefore, the 1990s was often deemed the decade of the ‘double transition’; from authoritarianism to democracy and from state-led development towards market-oriented policies. Thus, a purported consensus emerged regarding the desired political system and economic policies. This led to a periodic opening for a broad security agenda in Latin America in line with trends in the rest of the world. This new agenda was reflected both in the renewal of the OAS as an expression of hemispheric regionalism, and in the revival of Latin American regional security cooperation. The first step in this direction was the adoption by the OAS of the Protocol of Cartagena in 1985. In this charter amendment, the OAS’s commitment toward the promotion and strengthening of representative democracy was articulated more explicitly than ever before, and the need to uphold the sacrosanct principle of nonintervention was reaffirmed. It also established the link between democracy and human rights. In 1990, a new Unit for the Promotion of Democracy (UPD) was created within the OAS, and in the wake of its establishment, the OAS General Assembly adopted the Santiago Commitment to Democracy and the Renewal of the Inter-American System reaffirming their ‘inescapable commitment to’ the defense and promotion of democracy and human rights in the Western Hemisphere (Gosselin and Thérien 1999). The development of the 1990s did not only involve adoption of declarations, but also testified to the growth of the OAS’s capacity to defend democracy
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 75
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
75
collectively. In the early to mid-1990s, OAS contributed to restoring democracy on four occasions: the September 1991 military coup in Haiti, the autogolpes (self-coups – attempt to set aside the national legislature) in Peru (1992) and Guatemala (1993), and the Paraguayan political crisis of 1996. Here, OAS proved itself to be an efficient multilateral mechanism in defense of democracy (Cameron 1998). The new ‘democratic’ interventions also signified a new willingness by the United States to support missions restoring democracy. When President Bill Clinton sent 20,000 American troops to Haiti to restore JeanBertrand Aristide to the presidency, it seemed to herald a new day in the postCold War when American invasions were not automatically synonymous with supporting some Latin American caudillo (Hallinan 2004). In 1994, the first in a series of hemispheric summits (including the leaders of all the countries in the Western Hemisphere except Fidel Castro) took place in Miami. This was an important event in many ways. Here President Bill Clinton re-launched the idea of a Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA)3 to tie together the hemisphere from Alaska to Tierra del Fuego in one single free trade area. Clinton further prodded the defense ministers to join the regional integration process by committing themselves to the peaceful resolution of border disputes, multilateral cooperation in peacekeeping missions, and the maintenance of constitutional governance (Barry 2003). The human security agenda was also influential at the sub-regional level in the early to mid-1990s. This was perhaps most evident in Central America where a process towards a broader definition of security and regional threats was initiated within the framework of the Central American Integration System (SICA). In 1995, the Framework Agreement for Democratic Security in Central America (Tratado Marco de Seguridad Democrática en Centroamérica (TMSDCA)) was adopted. It elaborated the concept of Democratic Security to involve a wider range of threats to human beings, and although it failed to include civil society participation in its preparation, it raised expectation that security policy-making was to become more democratic in the future (Jácome 2003). However, already at the summit at which the TMSDCA was adopted, it was clear that the ability of the Central American states to jointly pursue such a broad agenda was limited, and that the US security demands were still powerful in the region. This was reflected in the final declaration which perceived no other joint action than a joint framework to fight car-theft (implying primarily the theft of cars in the US for sale in Central America) (Bull 1999). A new aspect of the security agenda in the 1990s was that it involved also the organizations set up to deal with economic development in Latin America. In
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
76
1:50 PM
Page 76
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
the mid-1990s statistics revealed disturbing facts about crime rates in Latin America. Only South Africa had higher homicide rates than El Salvador and Colombia. In El Salvador, 6,000 people were killed annually between 1994 and 1996, signifying that El Salvador had a murder rate 20 times higher than the global average in 1996, and surpassed even Colombia (Call 2000). The revelation that more people were killed by violence in El Salvador in 1996 than the average during the civil war put traditional security concepts into perspective. As a consequence, US police cooperation was increased through the International Criminal Investigative Training Assistance Program (ICITAP), and organizations such as the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) got involved in public security issues. Yet, the new agenda of the 1990s was not as free of tension as it was often portrayed. The US proved itself to be deeply committed both to democracy and human rights, and to policies that could put those values in jeopardy. Towards the end of the 1990s, it became increasingly clear that the consensus on the new security issues was not as deep as purported. First, it was based on a strong belief in the virtues of market-oriented policies and democracy without recognizing that the general support for the former was much stronger than the latter. Towards the end of the decade, it became increasingly evident that the market-oriented policies failed to reduce poverty levels, and worsened the difference between rich and poor, which already was the worst in the world. Moreover, as noted by one commentator: . . . even in these best of times, there were deep contradictions in Washington’s argument for a policy of increased integration and hemispheric cooperation shaped largely by US corporate interests. [. . .] Official rhetoric about the confluence of economic liberalization and the transition to democratic peace was undercut by the self-serving mercantile policy of improving US exports to the region through the free flow of arms, attack helicopters, and fighter planes (Barry 2003: 4)
Second, the US came to increasingly identify the ‘new security agenda’ with drugs, migration, and to some extent money-laundering and contraband activities. Thus, as a result, economic strategies were increasingly designed to halt these undesired flows to the United States. The Miami summit in 1994 adopted the so-called ‘Williamsburg agenda’, in which it was argued that the end of the bipolar confrontation should be followed by a redefinition of security concepts, orienting them towards aspects such as the defense and promotion of democracy and human rights, but also the struggle against drug-trafficking, joint action against terrorism and participation in peace missions.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 77
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
77
In the shadow of the evolving priorities of the US, the new institutions established to develop a joint policy against new and diverse threats faced increasing problems. The Commission for Hemispheric Security, established in 1992, was given the mandate to ‘identify the forms to revitalize and strengthen the institutions of the inter-American system related to various aspects of hemispheric security’, in order to make them relevant for the challenges of the new millennium at the Presidential Summit in Santiago, Chile in 1998 (Delgado 2003: 153). However, during the special meeting of the Commission for Hemispheric Security to confront the ‘New Focuses of Hemispheric Security’ it became evident that the organization was not an effective forum for establishing concrete politics and decide upon actions (Covacevich 2003). A centerpiece of the US strategy and a main cause of concern was Colombia. In the 1990s, the Colombian conflict evolved from being a domestic problem to a major regional security issue. Atrocities committed by governmental militaries, paramilitaries and guerilla forces resulted in massive internal displacement and refugee flows into Panama, Venezuela and Ecuador. Moreover, despite having its historical roots in the concentration of resources in the hands of Colombia’s powerful political and economic elite, the drug trade was increasingly fuelling the warring parties, involving surrounding countries as transit areas, in money-laundering etc. Although the US had provided significant military support to Colombia since the 1960s, justified by the fight against communism, from the early 1990s support was given in the name of fighting drugs. Although legal attempts were made in the US Congress to distinguish between anti-drug and anti-guerilla operations, the dividing lines were increasingly blurred. From the 1980s the term narco-guerillas was increasingly used to denote the Ejército de Liberación Nacional (ELN) and the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (FARC) (Miller 2001). As a result of the focus on drugs, the Clinton administration increased significantly its aid to Colombia. In July 2000, Clinton signed a US$1.3 billion emergency counter-drug package, earmarking roughly $860 million in aid for Colombia. This special package, together with already appropriate funds, meant that the Clinton administration authorized an extraordinary US$1.2 billion in counter-narcotics aid to Colombia during 2000 and 2001. Roughly 80 percent of this was designated for military equipment and training (Miller 2001). Also at the sub-regional level, the broad human security agenda was replaced by US concerns on drug-trafficking. In Central America, various regional institutions were established in the aftermath of the adoption of the TMSDCA. However, they reflect to a larger extent military concerns in the
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
78
1:50 PM
Page 78
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
region than the broad human security agenda that was attempted adopted in 1995. As such, it is symptomatic for the development over the course of the 1990s, when ‘new threats’ increasingly were associated with US concerns about the consequences of drug-trafficking. With the onset of the Bush administration in 2000, the priorities changed again.
The Security Agenda of the Bush Era The entering of the Bush administration in the US in 2000 was initially met with high expectations among Latin American governments. During his first months in the White House, president Bush repeatedly promised that he would work to make this the ‘Century of the Americas’. He developed a close relationship with newly elected Mexican president Vicente Fox, and he achieved significant support among the many Latino migrants in the US To the pleasure of many state leaders in Latin America, Bush promised to put the negotiations for the FTAA back on track after they had stalled due to Clinton’s failure to achieve a Fast Track Authority from Congress. Moreover, Bush’s personality matched well with the Latin American leadership style: ‘Many Latin Americans accepted the political persona that the novice Bush created for himself – a rancher who conducts the affairs of the nation with a smile and a handshake, a fellow uncomfortable with the pretentious rhetoric of foreign policy elites but drawn to commonsense solutions that served US national interests’ (Barry 2003: 2). However, Bush soon disappointed many of the Latin Americans that had supported him. His policy towards the region combined the two elements that many Latin leaders feared most: right-wing conservative ideology and a lack of attention to Latin American affairs. The two elements were reflected by his appointment – and lack of such – of people responsible for hemispheric affairs. Over the strong objections of the Latin American diplomatic community and despite bipartisan dissent, Bush appointed Otto Reich, a person famous for his rabid anti-Castroism and public support for the Nicaraguan Contras as the Assistant State Secretary for the Western Hemisphere, the State Department’s chief regional officer. However, the Senate failed to endorse the appointment and therefore Reich continued in a interim position until 2003, when he was replaced by Roger Noriega, a former chief aid to Senator Jesse Helms, and favorite of the militant Cuban American lobby for his activism in support of the Contras and against Castro. Among the other appointments questioned by Latin Americans was the decision to appoint John Negroponte
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 79
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
79
as the US ambassador to the UN Negroponte was the ambassador to Honduras during the Cold War and oversaw from his position there the operation of Contras in Nicaragua. Bush also demonstrated the low priority Latin American affairs had by sending low ranking officials to events of great importance to Latin America. The most famous example of that came later, in 2002, when he sent trade negotiator Robert Zoellick instead of secretary of state Colin Powell to the inauguration of Brazilian president Luis Ignácio Lula da Silva. Moreover, it was soon evident that ‘whereas the Clinton administration ensured freedom through the diffusion of free trade and democratic ideas, the Bush administration made it conditional on the promotion of free trade and other topics on a security agenda’ (Fuentes Saavedra 2003: 2). This was, for example, evident in the Puebla-Panama Plan, launched by Mexican president Vicente Fox in 2000, but strongly backed by the US administration. The plan intends to integrate the economies of the eight impoverished South Eastern Mexican states (including Chiapas) with the Central American countries, through a series of infrastructure projects. The plan currently encompasses many different policies and a series of political agendas. However, its core idea has been to exploit the possibilities opened through free trade agreements, particularly through establishing assembly industries in the region, simultaneously curbing migration towards the north and improve the control of the problematic border areas that serve as transit regions for various kinds of illicit trade (Bull 2004). 9/11 and its aftermath There is little agreement about the impact of the events of 11 September 2001 in Latin America. Some analysts argue that it ‘changed everything’ whereas others argue that the security situation in Latin America did not really change at all. What certainly did change were US priorities in the region. The immediate impact of 9/11 on hemispheric security politics was the revival of OAS and IATRA and an odd diplomatic defeat of Mexico. On 7 September 2001, Mexican President Vicente Fox announced that Mexico would withdraw from IATRA due to its irrelevance and inefficiency. Although Fox thereby voiced the feelings of many Latin American state leaders, the announcement came as a surprise. However, within a few hours of the terrorist attacks of 11 September, Brazil proposed to convoke IATRA in order to discuss Latin American responses and show the countries’ support for the US.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
80
1:50 PM
Page 80
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Shortly after, the OAS issued an immediate condemnation of the attack and on terrorism in general, and on 21 September the OAS issued a statement saying that the member countries considered the attack to be directed against all members of OAS. Following these resolutions, the OAS assigned the InterAmerican Committee against Terrorism (CICTE) (that had been established in 1996) to design a specific program to enhance multilateral actions against terrorism in the hemisphere. Thus, in the immediate aftermath of 11 September, the Latin American countries united behind Washington (Youngers 2003). However, the unity would not last long. The development of US security policies in general and towards the region in particular caused great concern among the Latin American countries, and also a split between the different countries. One may distinguish between the effects of four different aspects of US policy post-9/11; the strategy of preventive war, including the war in Iraq, the increasing disrespect for democracy and human rights in its war against terror, the tendency to interpret various security issues within the framework of the war against terror, and finally the increasing tendency to put Latin America policy on the back-burner. The impact of the strategy of preventive war and the Iraq invasion The hemispheric consensus that many countries were eager to emphasize following the events of 11 September, broke down during the build-up to the Iraq war. In the division that followed the interlinkages between free trade and security became most evident. Dependence on trade or aid from the United States turned to be an almost perfect predictor of attitude towards the Iraq war. The Central American countries (with the exception of Costa Rica) that were eager to finalize the negotiations for the Central American Free Trade Area (CAFTA) all supported the US war in Iraq. Honduras, Nicaragua and El Salvador together sent 1,300 troops to Iraq, costing the impoverished countries US$30 million. Also the Dominican Republic, which is equally dependent on the US economically, backed the Iraq action. Colombia also proved a staunch ally of the US as the main recipient of US aid in the region. The exception was Chile that, in spite of being in the process of signing a free trade agreement with the United States, did not support the US policy.4 However, the willingness to cooperate with the US must also be understood against the background of the historical experiences with US intervention among the small and vulnerable states in Central American and the Caribbean. US direct interventions have been a returning feature of US policy in the region, and got renewed actuality after the launch of Bush’s security strategy.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 81
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
81
Among the rest of the countries, there was widespread resentment against US policy in Iraq. For Mexico and Chile with non-permanent seats in the Security Council their positions against the Iraqi war had severe consequences for bilateral talks on migration and trade issues. With regards to Chile it kept congressional endorsement of the Chile–US Free Trade Agreement in limbo for several months, whereas Bush cut off the process to negotiate a bilateral solution to the problem of illegal migration with Mexico. This split between different Latin American countries had both negative and positive consequences for Latin American unity. Whereas it moved Central America even further into the orbit of US influence, and reaffirmed Colombia’s close relationship with the US, it also strengthened the unity among the remaining Latin American countries, where anti-US sentiments experienced a boost. Disrespect for human rights and democracy The second main aspect of the policy that has affected Latin America was its increasing disrespect for human rights and democracy. Thus, one may argue that the consensus about the virtues of free market and democracy received two setbacks; whereas both civil society and governments of the region challenged market oriented policies, the US de facto challenged democracy and human rights in the name of the war on terror. There are several examples of that. The US has lately been unusually blunt in its opposition against some electoral candidates and support for others. It has intervened directly in electoral campaigns in Nicaragua, Bolivia, Brazil and El Salvador in order to prevent left-wing candidates from taking position. However, the main ‘enemies’ of the region that Bush has publicly announced to be part of the axis of evil are Fidel Castro and Venezuelan president, Hugo Chávez. In Venezuela, the US propped up the opposition against Chávez through the National Endowment for Democracy, the Center for Strategic Studies and right-wing think tanks. When the US finally embraced the government that was installed after Chávez had been forcefully ousted from office on April 12, 2002, it provoked severe criticism from across the region. However, the US did (albeit reluctantly) endorse the results of the August 2004 referendum on Chávez’s future, in which a solid majority of the population rejected the proposal to oust him from office before the end of his term. The US handling of the crisis in Haiti in 2004, during which democratically elected President Jean-Bertrand Aristide claimed he had been kidnapped by US forces and forced out of the country, did not provoke the same reactions.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
82
1:50 PM
Page 82
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Indeed the United States managed to put together a multilateral force, including troops from Canada, France, Chile and later Argentina to maintain stability in Haiti after the US-sponsored change of government. Thus, the US was not alone in its setting aside the principle of sovereignty and respect for a democratically elected leader. Nevertheless, the increasing interference with democratic processes in the region over the last years, ‘sends the very clear message that Washington supports electoral democracy – as long as its candidate wins’ (Youngers 2003: 3). There is also a very real fear that the policies of the US in the region will strengthen the military’s domination of security policy, and discontinue the unfinished process of establishing civilian control over the military forces (Diamint 2004). Without a stronger commitment to democratic, civilian governance in security matters, the ability to implement the various treaties of regional cooperation is also weakened, as these are not sufficiently embedded in the domestic polities but ‘managed by a small group of officers’ (Diamint 2004: 56). The reframing of security The focus on terrorist organizations in US foreign policy in Latin America precedes the terrorist attacks of 2002. The tri-border area of Argentina, Brazil and Paraguay has long been considered a ‘hotbed of Arab radicalism’. This area allegedly hosts a training camp for groups associated with Hizbollah that were made responsible for the attack on the Asociación de Mutuales Israelitas Argentinas (AMIA) in Buenos Aires in 1992 (Urzúa Lira 2003). The term narco-terrorist was also used about the Colombian guerilla forces long before 11 September. Furthermore, as a result of the perceived terrorist threat from Latin America, a special commission was set up under the framework of OAS, the CICTE, early as 1996. Moreover, the day before the terrorist attacks in New York, the US government announced that the paramilitary groups in Colombia (Autodefensas Unidas de Colombia, AUC) as well as the guerillas (ELN and FARC) had been put on the list of international terrorist organizations.5 However, the new security framework changed the rhetoric of the US that increasingly framed old conflicts in terms of terrorism. Thus, ‘old enemies’ were again subsumed under the rhetoric of a new security agenda. This was most evident with regards to Colombia, a state in which the boundaries between guerilla movements and terrorist movement were viewed as increasingly blurred (Gaitán Pavía 2003). This is a move that has been supported by hard-line
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 83
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
83
Colombian president Alvaro Uribe. Immediately after the 11 September attacks, he offered his public support for President Bush, and repeatedly emphasized to the international community that Colombia, too had a terrorist problem.6 At the same time, the US drug policy in Colombia has contributed to the regionalization of the problem. The eradication of coca cultivation in Colombia conducted under the US-supported Plan Colombia resulted in the reduction of approximately 50,000 hectares of coca plants in 1999–2002. However, the reduction in Colombia was equivalent to the increase in Bolivia and Peru. Moreover, the surrounding countries experience an increasing militarization attempting to create a ‘cordon’ around Colombia (Gaitán Pavía 2003). Thus, the arms and ammunition trade, money-laundering, smuggling of goods and the trade in illegal chemicals not only refuel the conflict in Colombia, but significantly challenge the sovereignty of the neighboring countries Colombia a matter which in particular has increased concerns that the conflict will spill over into Venezuela. Thus, initially viewed as a ‘problem country’ by the US administration, it increasingly came to be considered as a ‘serious threat’ and as a regional destabilizing factor with the potential of compromising peace and security for the hemisphere. As a result, the Bush administration has increasingly taken a regional approach to the conflict. One example of that is the Regional Andean Initiative, which has channeled US$800 billion in counter-narcotics support to the region. The regionalization of the Andean conflict is increasingly understood in Washington in the intersection between drugs and terror. This has resulted in a continuous increase in military aid, showing only a short setback immediately following the events of 11 September 2001. Currently the total military aid to the region is approximately US$900 million annually, of which the aid to Colombia accounts for two-thirds (Rojas Aravena 2004). The US Colombia policy has also lead to a further split between Laitn American and the US Although almost all the countries in the region (except Cuba and Venezuela) share the idea of attempting to find multilateral solutions to the Colombian crisis because of its external impact, the US and the Colombian government favor military solutions whereas the rest of the governments prefer political and diplomatic solutions (Manaut 2003). In sum, it contributes to making the prospect of hemispheric security cooperation bleaker. The issues that are ignored A final consequence of the new security framework is that it accentuates an old dilemma for Latin American policy-makers: namely that while their economic
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
84
1:50 PM
Page 84
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
and political dependence on the US makes them dependent on attention from the big brother in the north, this simultaneously implies that they are subject to the changing policy priorities and geopolitical strategies of the US. The War on Terror has not only framed security debates, it has also moved pressing issues facing Latin America far down on the list of priorities in the US. One issue that has received less attention than before is migration. Mexico and the US were at the point of signing an agreement resolving the issue of the flows of illegal immigrants to the US immediately before September 2001, but after that the issue was put on the back-burner. In February 2004 an agreement was finally signed, but this was focused on strengthening the border controls and repatriating detained migrants, and not on improving the lives of the thousands of migrants that already had crossed the border.7 More fundamentally, the issues that mostly concern Latin Americans, including poverty, inequality, unemployment and daily violence, are kept off the agenda. According to one analyst: . . . keeping in mind the travails of neo-liberalism, the persistence of poverty and inequality, the heavy weight of joblessness, the shadow of daily violence, and the diverse grievances and preoccupations of civil society, would lead us to think that a truly democratic discussion about what issues should be ‘securitized’ in Latin America and the Caribbean would produce a very different agenda from the current one, with ‘traditional’ security issues receding quickly into the past. (Stark 2003: 71)
Moreover, because of the daily insecurity experienced by Latin Americans, polls show that support for democracy is decreasing in many countries, being as low as 35 percent in Guatemala (Latinobarómetro 2004) and although there is still no majority for the return to authoritarianism, the calls for a strong hand (‘mano dura’) may not be very far away. With the increasing US support for authoritarian actions, this leads to fears of a return to the past in Latin America. Thus, it should be remembered that among many Latin Americans, the term ‘security’ itself is still is connected to the ‘national security state’ and primarily invokes an image of a threat. Although somewhat eroded by now, the aversion towards the use of the term itself that derives from the unhappy experiences of the authoritarian regimes is not entirely forgotten (Stark 2003). Conclusion: The Future of Sub-regional Co-operation Although the tendency to subsume hemispheric security issues under simplistic agendas such as the current war against narco-terrorists represent is clear, it
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 85
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
85
does not obstruct every regional initiative. Although it has been argued that the current successes of regional economic integration are not matched when it comes to security (Grabendorff 2003: 3), as in the past, there are examples of more efficient sub-regional projects. In the Southern Cone, the creation of Mercosur in 1990 (Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay, with Chile and Bolivia as associated members) promised not only to provide an alternative to the US led, free market-oriented North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA) but also to spur a deeper political integration, including security integration. In 2000 Mercosur established a ‘peacezone’ and established a so-called ‘democratic clause’ that implies a regional commitment to peace and democracy in the region.8 It is in the Mercosur area that the highest degree of confidence has evolved over the last years, and that includes at least Chile in addition to the ‘core’ Mercosur countries. Today, the Argentine marines train in Brazilian aircraft carriers and Argentine warships are repaired in Chilean shipyards. Chilean and Argentine defense authorities meet regularly in the Permanent Security Committee Chile-Argentina (COMPERSEG). Thus, in spite of the fact that Brazil’s hegemonic pretensions are increasingly evident, with its aircraft carriers, active defense industry and participation in the global arms trade, the Southern Cone increasingly resembles a security community. Central America, on the other hand, has increasingly aligned its policies to those of the United States. The Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) has been an important goal of the Central American countries for the last years. The group of countries has also signed agreements with the US for joint patrols for control of terrorists, illegal migration towards the US and drug-trafficking in the maritime corridors. The US has signed institutional agreements with El Salvador, Nicaragua, Guatemala and Honduras for training and institutional strengthening with the pursuit of combating terrorism. There has also been talk about the creation of a regional army coordinated by the United States (Castro 2003). In conclusion, security cooperation in the Western Hemisphere is, and has always been, deeply affected by US policy priorities and strategic considerations. They have for most of the history contributed to a narrowing of the security agenda and subsumed complex issues within often rather uni-dimensional agendas. Although there have been clear exceptions to this rule, it has deeply affected the ability of hemispheric security organizations to address the issues of most concern to Latin American peoples and governments. Nevertheless, several sub-regional initiatives have proved to be efficient mechanisms for peaceful conflict resolution. Today, there are several examples of this.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
86
1:50 PM
Page 86
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
A new aspect of inter-American relations today is the increasing division of the hemisphere into a US sphere of influence, and a Brazilian one. There is a tendency for Central America to line up with the US both when it comes to political issues and economic policies, whereas the countries of the Southern Cone (led by Argentina and Brazil) challenge both the neo-liberal hegemony and US trading strategies in the region, and the US security policies. However, the outcome of this challenge remains to be seen. Thus, it may be that we see the contours of a divided Latin America and that the Americas are about to be divided into two regional security complexes. If so, the hemispheric security institutions that were established in the period after the Second World War will be more obsolete than ever. However, so far the role of the US is still too prevalent in affecting processes of securitization also in South America for the two parts of the Americas to be analyzed completely separately.
Notes 1. See for example Krause and Williams (1996) and Haftendoorn (1991) and Hentz (2003) for a critique of the traditional concept. For a critique of the widened security concept, see Gray (1994) and Walt (1991). 2. That includes the conflicts between Guatemala and Belize, El Salvador–Honduras–Nicaragua, Nicaragua and Colombia, Venezuela and Guyana, Trinidad and Venezuela, Haiti and the Dominican Republic, Colombia and Venezuela, and Bolivia and Chile. 3. It was originally proposed by George Bush, Sr. in 1990. 4. Other Latin American countries saw this as an inconsistency in the Chilean relations to the United States. However, Juan Gabriel Valdés; who was Chile’s Permanent Representative to the United Nations at the time, argues that Chiles support for free trade agreements and rejection of the US failure to recognize the authority of the United Nations and international law, rests on the same foreign policy goal, namely the creation of a world with stable and recognized rules in which collective action, subject to majority consensus, takes precedence over unilateral action. This desire, he argues is based both on the needs of a small country, and on the Chilean’s traditional support for strong institutions (Valdés 2004). 5. http://www.cnnenespanol.com, 10 September 2001. 6. E.g., http://www.bbcmundo.com, ‘No queremos mas terrorismo’, 8 April 2002. 7. EE.UU./México: devolverán migrantes, http://www.bbcmunco.com, 21 February 2004.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 87
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
87
8. This has happened through the Declaration of Mercosur as a Zone of Peace as well as the Political Declaration of MERCOSUR of 24 July 1998, and the Common Declaration of Buenos Aires of 30 July 2000.
References Barry, Tom (2003) ‘Our Backyard Pax Americana’, Americas Program Discussion Paper, Silver City: New Mexico: Inter-hemispheric Resources Center, February 17. Bull, Benedicte (1999) ‘“New Regionalism” in Central America’, Third World Quarterly, 20(5): 957–70. Bull, Benedicte (2004) ‘Between Bush and Bolívar: Change and Continuity in the Remaking of Mesoamerica’, in Morten Bøås, Marianne Marchand and Tim Shaw (eds), New Regionalisms at the New Millennium, London: Palgrave. Buzan, Barry, Ole Wæver and Jaap de Wilde (1998) Security: A New Framework for Analysis, Boulder and London: Lynne Rienner Publishers. Buzan, Barry and Ole Wæver (2003) Regions and Powers: The Structure of International Security, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Call, Charles (2000) Sustainable Development in Central America: The Challenges of Violence, Injustice and Insecurity, CA 2020: Working Paper #8, Hamburg: Institut Für IberoAmerika Kunde. Cameron, Maxwell A. (1998) ‘Latin American Autogolpes: Dangerous Undertows in the Third Wave of Democratization’, Third World Quarterly, 19(2): 219–39. Castro, Gustavo (2003) ‘Petromilitarización del continente y de la América en medio’, Paper presented to the Conferencia Internacional: Paz, crisis regional, y política exterior de Estados Unidos, FLACSO-CHILE, Santiago, 28–29 de agosto 2003. Covacevich, Gerardo (2003) ‘Mecanismos de la seguridad subregional y las nuevas amenazas’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 138–48. Delgado, Pedro Villagra (2003) ‘Conferencia de Ministros de Defensa de las Américas:Tópicos sobre defensa y seguridad en el hemisferio’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena y Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 149–62. Dell, Sidney (1972) The Inter-American Development Bank. A Study in Development Financing, New York: Praeger Publishing. Diamint, Rut (2004) ‘Security challenges in Latin America’, Bulletin of Latin American Research, 23(1): 43–62. Figoli, Herbert (2003) ‘Mecanismos y estructuras institucionales para enfrentar las nuevas amenazas’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 127–38.
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
88
1:50 PM
Page 88
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
Fuentes Saavedra, Claudio (2003) ‘Tres Dilemas en el Sistema Internacional. Terrorismo, Soberanía Nacional y Unipolarismo’, Paper presented to the Conferencia Internacional: Paz, crisis regional, y política exterior de Estados Unidos, FLACSO-CHILE, Santiago, 28–29 de agosto 2003. Gaitán Pavía, Pilar (2003) ‘La Reconstrucción del Estado y el papel de la Sociedad civil frente al Conflicto interno en Colombia’, Paper presented to the Conferencia Internacional: Paz, crisis regional, y política exterior de Estados Unidos, FLACSOCHILE, Santiago, 28–29 de agosto 2003. Gosselin, Guy and Jean-Philippe Thérien (1999) ‘The Organization of American States and Hemispheric regionalism’, in Gordon Mace, Louis Bélanger and contributors, The Americas in Transition: The Contours of Regionalism, Boulder and London: Lynne Rinenner Publishers, pp. 175–92. Grabendorff, Wolf (ed.) (2003) La seguridad regional en las Américas: enfoques críticos y conceptos alternativos, Bogota: Fescol/Cerec. Gray, Colin S. (1994) Villains, Victims and Sheriffs: Strategic Studies and Security for an InterWar Period, Hull: University of Hull Press. Green, Rosario (2003) ‘Un nuevo regionalismo latinoamericano para un orden multilateral alterado’, Paper presented to the Conferencia Internacional: Paz, crisis regional, y política exterior de Estados Unidos, FLACSO-CHILE, Santiago, 28–29 de agosto 2003. Haftendoorn, Helga (1991) ‘The Security Puzzle: Theory-Building and Disciplinebuilding in Internacional Security, International Studies Quarterly, 35(1): 3–17. Hallinan, Conn (2004) Haiti: Dangerous Muddle, Foreign Policy in Focus, Silver City, NM: Interhemispheric Resource Center. Hentz, James (2003) ‘Introduction: New regionalism and the “theory of security studies”’, in New and Critical Security and Regionalism: Beyond the Nation State, Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 3–16. Hentz, James J. and Morten Bøås (2003) New and Critical Security and Regionalism: Beyond the Nation State, Aldershot: Ashgate. Hurrel, Andrew (1995) ‘Regionalism in the Americas’, in A. Hurrel and H. Fawcett (eds), Regionalism in World Politics, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 250–82. Jácome, Francine (2003) ‘El tratado marco de seguridad democrática en Centroamérica’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 297–315. Kirby, Peadar (2003) Introduction to Latin America: Twenty-First Century Challenges, London, Thousand Oaks and New Delhi: Sage Publications. Klepa, Hal (2003) ‘Rarely Relevant Institutions for Terribly Relevant Challenges: Some Reflections on the Inter-American Security “System” and Today’s List of Risks and Threats’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 173–204
ch4.qxd
9/4/2007
1:50 PM
Page 89
REGIONAL SECURITY IN LATIN AMERICA
89
Krause, Keith and Michael C. Williams (1996) ‘Broadening the agenda of security studies: Politics and Methods’, Mershon International Studies Review, 40, supplement 2: 229–54. Lake, David A. and Patrick M. Morgan (1997) Regional Orders: Building Security in a New World, University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press. Latinobarómetro (2004) Informe – Resumen Latinobarómetro 2004: Una década de mediciones, Santiago de Chile: Corporación de Latinobarómetro. Manaut, Raúl Benitez (2003) ‘Seguridad hemisférica versus seguridad nacional: determinantes nacionales, regionales y globales’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 379–86. Miller, Andrew (2001) ‘Colombia in Crisis’, Foreign Policy in Focus, 6(20), May. Rojas Aravena, Francisco (2004) ‘Principales tendencias que afectan la seguridad internacional: La necesidad de construir nuevos mapas cognitivos’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena y Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 81–6. Stanley, William 1996 The Protection Racket State: Elite Politics, Military Exttortion, and Civil War in El Salvador, Philadelphia: Temple University Press. Stark, Jeffrey (2003) ‘Environmental Security in Latin America and the Caribbean: Development, Conflict, and Democracy’, in James Heinz and Morten Bøås, New and Critical Security and Regionalism: Beyond the Nation State, Aldershot: Ashgate, pp. 55–73. Tapia, Gabriel Gaspar (2003) ‘Desafíos y dilemas de seguridad en América Latina en la post Guerra Fría’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena and Paz V. Milet (eds) Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 87–109. Urzúa Lira, Gustavo (2003) ‘Las amenazas asimétricas como nuevas formas de conflicto en el contexto sudamericano’, in Francisco Rojas Aravena y Paz V. Milet (eds)Seguridad y Defensa en las Américas: La búsqueda de nuevos consensos, Santiago, Chile: Flacso, pp. 213–24. Valdés, Juan Gabriel (2004) ‘Chile’s Role in the World: Independence and the Rule of Law’, Revista: Harvard Review of Latin America, Spring 2004: 3. Walt, Stephen M. (1991) ‘The Renaissance of Security Studies’, International Studies Quarterly, 35(2): 211–39. Youngers, Coletta (2003) The US and Latin America After 9–11 and Iraq, Silver City, NM and Washington, DC: Foreign Policy in Focus, June 2003.
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
11:08 AM
Page 90
Chapter 5: Regional Security in South Asia B.M. Jain
A
t the dawn of a new millennium, the processes of globalization and democratization are becoming inevitably intertwined. Both economists and political scientists agree that they are interdependent. Jagdish Bhagwati, a well-known economist, writes that globalization promotes democracy directly and indirectly. His argument hinges on the interpretation that modern information technology loosens the control of the ‘traditionally hegemonic groups’, making the dependent class ‘more-independent actors, with democratic aspirations, in the political arena’.1 Robbie Robertson considers democratization as a ‘by-product of globalization’.2 If seen in these perspectives, the globalization of ideas and information, springing from a revolution in science and communication technology, makes transition to democracy in military and authoritarian regimes possible. Without democracy, globalization will have little meaning to teeming millions who aspire to living a free, dignified and virtuous life. Democrats across the world are faced with an onerous task of promoting political pluralism and civil societies in order to help build up a free and democratic world. Nearly four dozen countries are still far away from becoming democratic. There is a widely shared belief that the cases of radical militancy, intolerance and violation of human rights are on rise in those societies where democratic institutions are either not allowed to grow or are sought to be further weakened by the narrow national ruling elites. Democratization of societies is one of the hallmarks of the globalization phenomenon. New waves of globalization on the one hand and an increasing trend towards regionalization on the other have become irreversible. Though the ongoing processes of globalization and regionalization, primarily in the economic sense, may appear paradoxical, in reality they are complementary processes in a quest for establishing an integrated and equitable international political and economic order based on the notions of democracy, freedom, equality and rule of law.
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
11:08 AM
Page 91
REGIONAL SECURITY IN SOUTH ASIA
91
The 9/11 tragedy made it imperative to promote political liberalism and to democratize traditional societies with a view to defeating the dark forces of terrorism and religious radicalism, in order to help secure a peaceful and democratic world order.3 Towards this goal, the United States and its strategic partners are committed to stamping out terrorism with political, diplomatic, economic, military and strategic resources at their command. Undoubtedly, war on terrorism has become a ‘core security interest’ in US foreign policy. Deputy Defense Secretary, Paul Wolfowitz, acknowledged that terrorism was ‘the single greatest threat’ to peace and security in the world. President George W. Bush made a fervent appeal to the world community to participate in the US-led global campaign against terrorism to make the world safe and secure for all. Response to his appeal was quick and overwhelming. He spelled out that a new global security order, based on liberal constitutional democracy and rule of law, would be a priority of the US foreign policy agenda. One may draw some plausible inferences that the conception of a new global security order departs from a traditionalist approach to security through the processes of arms control and disarmament or by concluding treaties and protocols on non-proliferation of weapons, although their importance cannot be belittled. Nevertheless, the focus has shifted from conventional threat perceptions to emerging neo-threats, for instance, in the form of international terrorism whose striking capability with a greater ‘awe and surprise’ is unmatchable even with an overwhelming military superiority of the mightiest power.4 In brief, a major challenge facing the proponents of globalization and democratisation is how a ‘move’ or ‘consolidation’ of democratisation throughout the globe is possible. According to some political analysts,5 this is made possible by ‘remaking the societies’ along democratic norms and values. Against this background, this chapter deals with those key issues and ‘disturbing trends’ in US–South Asia equations which impede the promotion of liberal democratic values and civil societies in the region. A host of questions in this regard are raised here. What are key components of peace and security in South Asia? What are the American dilemmas while dealing with a democratic India on one hand and a virtually military regime in Pakistan on the other? Does the United States have a ‘specific roadmap’ to encourage the forces of democracy and discourage pro-weapon lobbyists in South Asia? To find out answers to these questions, this chapter will examine US concerns, interest and approaches to creating a democratic, stable and peaceful South Asia. Finally, this chapter will evaluate the American commitment to democracy, rule of law and non-proliferation goals in the region. This chapter argues that in order to help create a new security order in the
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
92
11:08 AM
Page 92
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
subcontinent, India needs to encourage ‘political and economic engagement’ between India and Pakistan, to help end cross-border terrorism permanently, and to help end the geopolitical rivalry between India and Pakistan. In order to understand the complexity of the current US–South Asia engagement, it will be useful to provide a brief historical and contemporary backdrop to their relationship. South Asia has remained a turbulent region since the days of Cold War politics. With the partition of British India in August 1947, the deep-seated rivalry between India and Pakistan over the Kashmir dispute resulted in three wars between them. Apart from the Kashmir problem, systemic crises produced a string of unpalatable developments in the Indian subcontinent, which not only threatened the future of democracy but also sought to further undermine the fragile nature of peace and stability in the region. Such instances abound: the clamping of emergency in India by Prime Minister Mrs Indira Gandhi in 1975; the overthrow of democracy and a return of army rule in Pakistan after a military coup by President Zia-ul Huq in mid-1970s; Pakistan-sponsored crossborder terrorism in the State of Jammu and Kashmir since 1989 by using religion as an instrument of its foreign policy. In a chain of such developments, the Indian subcontinent turned abruptly into a ‘most dangerous spot’ in the world following nuclear weapon tests carried out by India and pakistan in May 1998. Subsequently, unprovoked aggression was launched by Pakistani armed forces in the Kargil sector of Indian Territory in May 1999 at the behest of the then General Pervez Musharraf. Synchronizing with the Kargil conflict, a democratically elected government was overthrown by General Musharraf in a military coup in October 1999. These instances validate the volatile character of the South Asian region.6 In geopolitical and geo-strategic terms, South Asia underwent a major transformation after the end of the Cold War and the demise of the Soviet Union in December 1991. The superpower rivalry in South Asia came to an end; ideological shibboleths lost their relevance while nation-states interacted with one another. If seen in this perspective, India drew closer to the United States, politically and strategically. Interestingly, the ‘lonely superpower’ status of the United States imparted a new meaning and dimension to its relations with South Asian states, and with India and Pakistan in particular. Devoid of any ideological rigidities, India went ahead with cultivating the ‘renewed ties’ with the United States, and establishing diplomatic ties with Israel from whom India had sought to maintain a benign distance during the Cold War era. At the same time, a sea change was witnessed in the US’s South Asia diplomacy both in content and style. White House officials began crafting a set of new policies
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
11:08 AM
Page 93
REGIONAL SECURITY IN SOUTH ASIA
93
in order to promote democratic institutions apart from encouraging political reconciliation between the hostile nations in South Asia. As regards India, the US ‘relationship with Russia is a case of consolidation or guarding against a slip-up. With the US, it is a reversal of the old negative trends, of strengthening of the ‘new beginning’.’7 A new era of friendship in US–India, US–Pakistan relations in the postSoviet period received a sudden setback in May 1998 when India and Pakistan each exploded nuclear devices underground. This had obviously created ‘heightened concerns’ in the world community in general, and in the United States in particular, that the arms race between New Delhi and Islamabad might further accelerate. Also, there was a widely shared belief that both the countries might enter into nuclear exchange, probably over the prolonged impasse on Kashmir. The United States not only denounced their weapon tests but it also imposed economic and military sanctions against them. It also asked both India and Pakistan to sign the NPT and CTBT without preconditions and pleaded with them to exercise maximum nuclear restraint. Since India and Pakistan had declared themselves as de facto nuclear weapon states, they refused to roll back their nuclear programme. In effect, American sanctions proved ineffectual. Its non-proliferation efforts were further impeded following the 9/11 terrorist attacks. The Bush Administration not only removed sanctions against them but also went ahead with forging a solid strategic relationship with Islamabad and New Delhi. In realistic terms, the United States was forced to embrace the military regime in Islamabad whose geo-strategic value overruled the American concern for a return of democracy and civilian rule in Pakistan. Because of its geographical location, Pakistan became indispensable to US strategic goals and interests in Afghanistan, South Asia and the Middle East.8 Shift in the US Policy A major shift in the US’s South Asia policy had occurred during the Clinton Administration II, which desirer a constructive and creative role in the region. It embarked on a balanced policy towards India and Pakistan as manifested from its nonpartisan stance on the Kargil conflict. The diplomatic support that India got from the Clinton Administration in the Kargil war was extremely unexpected. It was out of character with the pat American record in Indo-Pak disputes in which Washington was either neutral or seen as being tilted towards Islamabad. The Clinton Administration had
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
94
11:08 AM
Page 94
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
insisted that the Pakistani aggression across the Line of Control was unacceptable and Islamabad must unconditionally and unambiguously restore the status quo ante.9
It was ‘firm action’ by President Clinton that forced Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to comply with enforcing the withdrawal of Pakistani troops from the Kargil sector. This was much to Sharif’s awe and anguish: Pakistan did not expect that America would put its entire weight on the Indian side. For the Clinton Administration, the withdrawal of Pakistani troops from Kargil was a categorical necessity in the larger interest of security and stability in the region. A new phase in the US relationship with South Asian states began with President Clinton’s visit to New Delhi and Islamabad in March 2000. He spoke about four principles – the ‘4Rs’ they were called – the need for mutual restraint, respect for the LoC, rejection of violence and resumption of dialogue.10 During this visit, President Clinton signed a Vision Paper with the Indian Prime Minister A.B. Vajpayee. Both the leaders agreed to set up a Joint CounterTerrorism Committee in order to work out modalities to curb terrorism. Political analysts in India described Clinton’s visit as a ‘historic one’ in the direction of reversing negative images and trends of the Cold War era. Both the leaders expressed a common desire to begin strategic dialogue on a number of issues such as nuclear proliferation, the armament’s race, drug-trafficking and narcoterrorism. The Clinton Administration realized that there was no rationale in putting India ‘at the back end’ of American foreign policy in the twenty-first century. On his second leg to Islamabad, President Clinton met with General Musharraf. He conveyed his message to Musharraf frankly that all outstanding disputes with India be resolved through political and diplomatic channels. Clinton gave unambiguous hints to General Musharraf that Pakistan might have to pay a heavy price if it ever entertained the idea of coming into a direct conflict with India. Pakistani military rulers described Clinton’s approach as pro-India, while New Delhi described this as a departure from the US’s ‘evenhanded policy’ towards the subcontinent. The Clinton Administration attempted to move away from ‘zero-sum’ to a ‘positive-sum’ game in South Asia by treating India and Pakistan separately.11 US Engagement Policy The Bush Administration carried forward the Clinton legacy of a ‘new strategic paradigm’ for South Asia. Acknowledging India as a ‘major global player’,
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
11:08 AM
Page 95
REGIONAL SECURITY IN SOUTH ASIA
95
the Bush Administration made it amply clear that the United States needed to consult India on critically important regional and global issues ‘in the same fashion that it seeks the views of other major players such as Japan, South Korea, China, Brazil, Australia and the major European powers’.12 Assistant Secretary of State for South Asian Affairs, Christina B. Rocca in her speech before the Indian American Friendship Council in Washington on 17 July 2001, remarked: ‘The Bush Administration is committed to strengthening and intensifying relations with India. The past few years have seen the beginning of a transformation in our ties with the world’s largest democracy. Now is the time to complete that transformation.’13 A former US Ambassador to India, Robert Blackwill, also stated that in the changing geopolitical scenario, the Bush Administration did not perceive India as an ‘irritating recalcitrant.’14 To complete that transformation, the Bush Administration has acknowledged India’s ‘role and responsibility’ in securing stable and peaceful conditions in South Asia and beyond this region. The Administration has demonstrated its seriousness about expanding, strengthening and upgrading the ongoing strategic dialogue with India on numerous issues that include terrorism, nuclear proliferation, armament race, drug-trafficking, and narco-terrorism. Leadership in both the countries have expressed their firm commitment to a common goal of establishing a peaceful and stable world order by way of encouraging democratization of societies, defending Human Rights and ensuring the rule of law among authoritarian, military and orthodox regimes. Both the countries have a shared perception on the urgency of stopping the growing insurgent activities in the Himalayan Kingdom of Nepal. As one may recall, US Assistant Secretary of State for South Asian Affairs, Alan Eastham, had visited India and Nepal in April 2001 to assess the gravity of the ongoing political turmoil in Nepal. Both India and the United States expressed their profoundly anxiety over the Maoist-led endemic insurgencies. Not the least, both countries are concerned about ‘fractious democratic politics’ in Kathmandu. The Bush Administration reiterated its firm commitment to the restoration of democracy in Nepal and also underlined the urgency of the US military assistance to Kathmandu which was waging a fierce struggle against the Maoist-led violence and bloodshed. Nevertheless, what worries India is an overly forceful American involvement in the internal developments of Nepal. In the past, America had never exhibited so much keen interest in the political affairs of Kathmandu. To India, the pro-active role of the United States has wide-ranging implications for the region. Firstly, New Delhi fears that once America solidifies its strategic presence in Nepal, it might undermine Indian role and influence not only in Nepal
ch5.qxp
9/11/2007
96
11:08 AM
Page 96
CHALLENGES TO GLOBAL SECURITY
but also in South Asia. In Indian perception, a direct involvement of the ‘only superpower’ in Nepalese affairs is likely to encourage anti-Indian elements in Nepal, which is strategically indispensable for India’s defence and security. Second, it might accentuate the strategic contest between the US and China since Beijing feels its national interests directly threatened in Tibet, as being geographically proximate to Nepal. There is no secret that Washington and Beijing have political differences on the Tibetan issue. Besides, there is a possibility of US intelligence operations along Nepalese borders. Though the Bush Administration has brushed aside such fears, built-in misgivings remain ingrained in the psyche of India and China about the possibilities of American military involvement in Nepal.
Paradigm Shift: Indo-US Shared Concerns With a ‘paradigm shift’ in the US policy in South Asia, strategic relations between New Delhi and Washington appear to be on the upswing. Bureaucratic and intellectual constituencies in India have a broad consensus that New Delhi should not miss the opportunity to transform its strategic dialogue with Washington into a more durable and purposeful partnership. A host of correlates dictate this thinking. First, the shared threat of terrorism has made New Delhi and Washington conscious of an imperative need to work together to help preserve freedom, democracy and civil rights globally, regionally and nationally. Second,