This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
= |E|2 dV (2.23a) 2ρe V μ◦ < Em > = |H|2 dV (2.23b) 4 V ◦ < Ee > = |E|2 dV (2.23c) 4 V expanded up to the 1st -order fields, is given by: The complex Poynting vector, S, =1 E ∗+E 0 × H ∗+E 1 × H ∗ 0 × H S (2.24) 0 1 0 2 TRIVIA 2.1 Of the contemporary astronomers (born 1629–1656) below, who measured the speed of light to within 25% of the accepted modern value? i) Flamsteed;
ii) Halley;
iii) Huygens;
iv) Roemer.
CHAPTER 2
30
2.5 Field Solutions from the Scalar Potentials = 0), is a conservative field Any static electric field, because its curl is zero (∇ × E and thus is the gradient of a scalar potential φ: = −grad φ = −∇ φ E
(2.25)
= −∇ · ∇φ = −∇2 φ ∇·E
(2.26)
may be given by: Thus, ∇ · E
In the absence of charge density (ρc = 0), Eq. 2.2 reduces to: =0 ∇·E
(2.27)
Combining Eqs. 2.26 and 2.27, we obtain: ∇2 φ = 0
(2.28)
Equation 2.28, known as Laplace’s equation, expresses scalar potentials from which fields can be derived. physically realizable E Similarly, in the absence of free current and under the DC condition, any magnetic because ∇ × H = 0, is derivable from scalar potentials that satisfy the field H, = −∇φ. Besides electromagnetic fields, there are other Laplace’s equation; i.e., H well-known cases in engineering where Eq. 2.28 is applicable for time-independent variables: temperature (T ) in a source-free, isotropic conductive medium; volume expansion; the sum of linear strains in the x-, y-, and z-axes in a force- and moment-free, isotropic elastic medium. Selected solutions of Laplace’s equation in two-dimensional cylindrical coordinates and three-dimensional spherical coordinates are presented below. 2.5.1 Two-Dimensional Cylindrical Coordinates For a potential in two-dimensional cylindrical (r, θ) coordinates, ∇2 φ is given by: 1 ∂ ∂φ 1 ∂ 2φ 2 ∇ φ= r + 2 =0 (2.29) r ∂r ∂r r ∂ θ2 The standard technique to solve Eq. 2.29 is to express φ as the product of two functions, each a function of only one of the two coordinates: φ = R(r) Θ(θ)
(2.30)
The solutions to Eq. 2.29 have the following general forms: for n = 0
φ0 = (A1 ln r + A2 ) (C1 θ + C2 )
(2.31a)
for n > 0
φn = (A1 rn + A2 r−n )(C1 sin nθ + C2 cos nθ)
(2.31b)
where A1 , A2 , C1 , and C2 are constants.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS
31
Special Cases n = 0: The simplest form of field derivable from φ under this condition is one whose spatial dependence is 1/r. Examples are the electric field due to a line charge (λ = 2π◦ ) and the magnetic field associated with a current filament (I = 2π). Thus = (1/r)ır ; with a potential [φ0 ]H = θ, we with a potential [φ0 ]E = ln r, we have: E = (1/r)ıθ . Note that each field decays as 1/r from its source. have: H n = 1: Both φ1 = sin θ/r and φ1 = cos θ/r are potentials associated with twodimensional electric or magnetic dipoles. Note that each form has a singularity at the origin (r = 0); they are usually associated with dipole fields that do not include the origin. The choice of sin θ or cos θ depends on field orientation in the coordinate system. In addition, the potentials φ1 = r sin φ and φ1 = r cos φ are associated with uniform vector fields. Examples of 2-D dipole fields are studied in the PROBLEMS of CHAPTERS 2 and 3. n = 2: The potentials φ2 = cos 2θ/r2 and φ2 = r2 cos 2θ are associated with 2-D quadrupole fields. The potential φ2 = cos 2θ/r2 , because of the singularity at the origin, is valid only for space that excludes the origin; φ2 = r2 cos 2θ, for space that excludes infinity. An ideal quadrupole magnet is studied in CHAPTER 3. 2.5.2 Spherical Coordinates For a potential in spherical coordinates (r, θ, ϕ): 1 ∂ 1 ∂φ ∂φ ∂ div grad φ = ∇2 φ = 2 r2 + 2 sin θ r ∂r ∂r r sin θ ∂ θ ∂θ +
∂ 2φ 1 r2 sin2 θ ∂ ϕ2
(2.32)
The solutions for ∇2 φ also can be expressed as the product of functions, each involving only one of the three coordinates: φ = R(r) Θ(θ) Φ(ϕ)
(2.33a)
Functions R(r), Θ(θ), and Φ(ϕ) have the following solutions: R(r) = A1 rn + A2 r−(n+1) Θ(θ) = CPnm (cos θ)
(m ≤ n)
Φ(ϕ) = D1 sin mϕ + D2 cos mϕ
(2.33b) (2.33c) (2.33d)
A1 , A2 , C, D1 , and D2 are constants. Pn0 (cos θ), or simply Pn (cos θ), known as Legendre Functions, are useful for designing a spatially uniform solenoid magnet, which in the design phase may be assumed symmetric about the z-axis (θ = 0). Pnm (cos θ), known as Associated Legendre Functions, are useful for minimizing “error” fields of a real solenoid. A magnetic field expression derived from Eq. 2.33 is discussed in more detail in CHAPTER 3. Formulas for Pn (cos θ) for n = 0–8 and Pnm (cos θ) for n = 1–4 (0 < m ≤ n) are given in Table 2.2. Table 2.3 presents Pnm (0) for combinations of selected values of n and m. Table 2.4 presents solutions of Eq. 2.33 in Cartesian coordinates; these expressions are of practical importance in the design and analysis of uniform-field electromagnetic and ferromagnetic devices.
CHAPTER 2
32 Special Cases
n = m = 0: This case gives rise to the the simplest solution, φ0 ∝ 1/r. A well = 1/r2 ır valid for r > 0, that emanates from known solution is the electric field, E a point charge of magnitude 4π◦ . n = 1, m = 0: There are two solutions, φ1 ∝ cos θ/r2 and φ1 ∝ r cos θ. φ1 results in a dipole field outside of a sphere the surface of which is distributed with a source that generates this dipole field, while φ1 results in a uniform field within the sphere. The dipole field of a magnetic moment is also derivable from φ1 . 2.5.3 Differential Operators in Orthogonal Coordinates The four vector differential operators—grad (∇), div (∇·), curl (∇×), div grad (∇2 )—in three orthogonal sets of coordinates are given below. Cartesian The three orthogonal axes are: x, y, z. grad U = ∇U =
∂U ∂U ∂U ıx + ıy + ız ∂x ∂y ∂z
∂ Ax ∂ Ay ∂ Az + + ∂x ∂y ∂z =∇×A = ∂ Az − ∂ Ay ıx + ∂ Ax − ∂ Az ıy curl A ∂y ∂z ∂z ∂x ∂ Ay ∂ Ax + − ız ∂x ∂y =∇·A = divA
div grad U = ∇2 U =
∂ 2U ∂ 2U ∂ 2U + + ∂ x2 ∂ y2 ∂ z2
(2.34a) (2.34b)
(2.34c) (2.34d)
Cylindrical The three orthogonal axes are: r, θ, z. grad U = ∇U =
∂U 1 ∂U ∂U ır + ıθ + ız ∂r r ∂θ ∂z
=∇·A = 1 ∂ (rAr ) + 1 ∂ Aθ + ∂ Az div A r ∂r r ∂θ ∂z ∂ Ar 1 ∂ Az ∂ Aθ ∂ Az curl A = ∇ × A = − ır + − ıθ r ∂θ ∂z ∂z ∂r 1 ∂ (rAθ ) 1 ∂ Ar + − ız r ∂r r ∂θ 1 ∂ ∂ 2U ∂U 1 ∂ 2U 2 r + 2 div grad U = ∇ U = + r ∂r ∂r r ∂ θ2 ∂ z2
(2.35a) (2.35b)
(2.35c) (2.29)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS
33
Spherical The orthogonal axes are: r, θ, and ϕ. grad U = ∇U =
∂U 1 ∂U 1 ∂U ır + ıθ + ıφ ∂r r ∂θ r sin θ ∂ ϕ
=∇·A = div A
(2.36a)
1 ∂ (r2 Ar ) 1 ∂ (Aθ sin θ) 1 ∂ Aϕ + + (2.36b) r2 ∂ r r sin θ ∂θ r sin θ ∂ ϕ
=∇×A = curl A
1 ∂ (Aϕ sin θ) 1 ∂ Aθ − ır r sin θ ∂θ r sin θ ∂ ϕ 1 ∂ Ar 1 ∂ (rAϕ ) + − ıθ r sin θ ∂ ϕ r ∂r 1 ∂ (rAθ ) 1 ∂ Ar + − ıφ r ∂r r ∂θ
(2.36c)
1 ∂ 1 ∂U ∂ 2∂U div grad U = ∇ U = 2 r + 2 sin θ r ∂r ∂r r sin θ ∂ θ ∂θ 2
+
∂ 2U 1 r2 sin2 θ ∂ ϕ2
(2.32)
Adrien Marie Legendre (1752–1833)
—Passage from Dirk J. Struik’s A Concise History of Mathematics* In his history of mathematics of the Nineteenth Century Felix Klein has invited comparison between Gauss and the twenty-five year older French mathematician Adrien Marie Legendre. It is perhaps not entirely fair to compare Gauss with any mathematician except the very greatest; but this particular comparison shows how Gauss’ ideas were “in the air,” since Legendre in his own independent way worked on most subjects which occupied Gauss . . . Like Gauss he did fundamental work on number theory where he gave a formulation of the law of quadratic reciprocity. He also did important work on geodesy and theoretical astronomy, was as assiduous a computer of tables as Gauss, formulated in 1806 the method of least squares, and studied the attraction of ellipsoids—even those which are not surfaces of revolution. He introduced the “Legendre” functions. He also shared Gauss’ interest in elliptic and Eulerian integrals as well as in the foundations and methods of Euclidean geometry. . . .His comprehensive textbooks were for a long time authoritative, especially his “Exercises du calcul int´egral” (1811–19) and his “Trait´ e des fonctions elliptiques et des int´egrales eul´eriennes” (1827–32), still a standard work . . . In his “Elements de g´eom´etrie” (1794) he broke with the Platonic ideals of Euclid and presented a textbook of elementary geometry based on the requirements of modern education. * Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 1948. For many years until his retirement in 1960, Dirk J. Struik (1894–2000) taught mathematics at M.I.T.
CHAPTER 2
34 2.5.4 Legendre Functions
For m = 0 the Pnm (cos θ) polynomials (Eq. 2.33c) are known as Legendre Functions of order n; i.e., Pn0 (cos θ) ≡ Pn (cos θ) ≡ Pn (u), where u = cos θ. For 1 ≤ m ≤ n, the polynomials are known as Associated Legendre Functions. Pnm (cos θ) ≡ Pnm (u) satisfies the following differential equation for v: d m2 2 dv (1 − u ) + n(n + 1) − v=0 (2.37) du du 1 − u2 As stated earlier, Pn (u), i.e., m = 0, is of particular use in the solution of a magnetic field with rotational symmetry such as that in an ideal solenoid; Pnm (u) is useful for field analysis of a real solenoid that, because of imperfections, lacks rotational symmetry. Pn (u) and Pnm (u) are given by: n 2 1 d (u − 1)n Pn (u) = (2.38a) 2n n! dun dm Pn (u) dum (1 − u2 )m/2 dm+n (u2 − 1)n = 2n n! dum+n
Pnm (u) = (1 − u2 )m/2
(2.38b) (2.38c)
Some useful recurrence formulas for Legendre functions, Pn (u), and Associated Legendre functions, Pnm (u), are: (n+1)Pn+1 (u)−(2n+1)uPn (u)+nPn−1 (u) = 0
(2.39a)
m m (u)−(2n+1)uPnm (u)+(n+m)Pn−1 (u) = 0 (n+1−m)Pn+1
(2.39b)
2(m+1)u m+1 Pnm+2 (u)−
Pn (u)+(n−m)(n+m−1)Pnm (u) = 0 2 (1−u )
(2.39c)
Table 2.2 lists Legendre functions, Pn (u), for n up to 8; and Associated Legendre functions, Pnm (u), for m (1 ≤ m ≤ n) up to 4. Table 2.3 presents Pnm (0) for combinations of n of 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 and m of 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10. Table 2.4 presents solutions of Eq. 2.32 in Cartesian coordinates.
Answer to TRIVIA 2.1 iv). The Danish astronomer Olaus Roemer (1644–1710) used two reference objects, Jupiter and earth, to clock light at 2.27 × 108 m/s, which is 76% of the modern accepted value: 2.99792458×108 m/s.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS
35
Table 2.2: Legendre and Associated Legendre Functions Legendre Functions (m = 0) [ Pn (0) = 0 for n odd] n
Pn (cos θ) ≡ Pn (u)
Multiple-Angle Form
0
1
1
1
u
cos θ
2
1 (3u2 −1) 2 1 (5u3 −3u) 2 1 (35u4 −30u2 +3) 8 1 (63u5 −70u3 +15u) 8 1 (231u6 −315u4 +105u2 −5) 16 1 (429u7 −693u5 +315u3 16
1 (3 cos 2θ+1) 4 1 (5 cos 3θ+3 cos θ) 8 1 (35 cos 4θ+20 cos 2θ+9) 64 1 (63 cos 5θ+35 cos 3θ+30 cos θ) 128 1 (231 cos 6θ+126 cos 4θ+105 cos 2θ+50) 512 1 (429 cos 7θ+231 cos 5θ+189 cos 3θ 1024
1 (6435u8 −12012u6 +6930u4 128 2
1 (6435 cos 8θ+3432 cos 6θ+2772 cos 4θ 16384
3 4 5 6 7
−35u)
8
+175 cos θ)
−1260u +35)
+2520 cos 2θ+1225)
Associated Legendre Functions (1 ≤ m ≤ n) [ Pnm (1) = 0 ] m, n 1, 1
Pnm (cos θ) ≡ Pnm (u) (1−u )
sin θ
2 1/2
2
3u(1−u )
3
3 (1−u2 )1/2 (5u2 −1) 2 5 (1−u2 )1/2 (7u3 −3u) 2 2
4 2, 2
15(1−u2 )u
4
15 (1−u2 )(7u2 −1) 2 2 3/2
4 4, 4
3 sin 2θ 2 3 (sin θ+5 sin 3θ) 8 5 (2 sin 2θ+7 sin 4θ) 16 3 (1−cos 2θ) 2 15 (cos θ−cos 3θ) 4 15 (3+4 cos 2θ−7 cos 4θ) 16 15 (3 sin θ−sin 3θ) 4 105 (2 sin 2θ−sin 4θ) 8 105 (3 − 4 cos 2θ+cos 4θ) 8
3(1−u )
3 3, 3
Multiple-Angle Form
2 1/2
15(1−u )
105(1−u2 )3/2 u 105(1−u2 )2
Table 2.3: Values of Pnm (0) for m of 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 m
Pnm (0)
0
P2 (0) = − 21 ;
2
P22 (0) = 3;
4
P44 (0) = 3·5·7 = 105;
6
P66 (0) = 3·5·7·9·11 = 10395;
8
8 P88 (0) = 3·5·7·9·11·13·15 = 2027025; P10 (0) = − 3·5·7·9·11·13·15·17 = − 34459425 2 2
10
P4 (0) = 83 ;
5 P6 (0) = − 16 ;
P42 (0) = − 15 ; 2
P62 (0) = 105 ; 8
P64 (0) = − 945 ; 2
35 P8 (0) = 128 ;
63 P10 (0) = − 256
P82 (0) = − 315 ; 16
P84 (0) = 10395 ; 8
P86 (0) = − 135135 ; 2
2 P10 (0) = 3465 128
4 P10 (0) = − 45045 16
6 P10 (0) = 2027025 8
10 P10 (0) = 3·5·7·9·11·13·15·17·19 = 654729075
TRIVIA 2.2
Identify the location for which each of the elements below is named.
i) Copper;
i) Lutetium;
ii) Magnesium;
iv) Yttrium.
CHAPTER 2
36
Table 2.4: Solutions of Equation 2.32 in Cartesian Coordinates Legendre Functions (m = 0) n
n
r Pn (u)
0
1
1
z
2
z 2 − 21 (x2 +y 2 )
3
z 3 − 23 (x2 +y 2 )z
4
z 4 −3(x2 +y 2 )[z 2 − 81 (x2 +y 2 )]
5
z 5 −5(x2 +y 2 )[z 2 − 83 (x2 +y 2 )]z
6
z 6 − 25 (x2 +y 2 )[3z 4 − 49 z 2 (x2 +y 2 )+ 81 (x2 +y 2 )2 ]
7
7 z 7 − 16 (x2 +y 2 )[24z 4 −30z 2 (x2 +y 2 )+5(x2 +y 2 )2 ]z
8
7 z 8 − 128 (x2 +y 2 )[256z 6 −480z 4 (x2 +y 2 )+160z 2 (x2 +y 2 )2 −5(x2 +y 2 )3 ]
Associated Legendre Functions (1 ≤ m ≤ n) m, n
rn Pnm (u) cos(mϕ)
rn Pnm (u) sin(mϕ)
1, 1
x
y
2
3zx
3zy
3
6x[z 2 − 41 (x2 +y 2 )]
6y[z 2 − 41 (x2 +y 2 )]
4
10zx[z 2 − 43 (x2 +y 2 )]
10zy[z 2 − 43 (x2 +y 2 )]
3(x2 −y 2 )
3(2xy)
2, 2 3
15z(x −y )
4
45(x −y )[z
3, 3 4 4, 4
2
2
2
2
15z(2xy) 2
− 61 (x2 +y 2 )]
45(2xy)[z 2 − 61 (x2 +y 2 )]
15x(x2 −3y 2 )
15y(3x2 −y 2 )
105zx(x2 −3y 2 )
105zy(3x2 −y 2 )
105(x4 −6x2 y 2 +y 4 )
210(2xy)(x2 −y 2 )
“It was absolutely marvelous working for Pauli. You could ask him anything. There was no worry that he would think a particular question was stupid, since he thought all questions were stupid.” —Victor F. Weisskopf
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
37
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.1: Magnetized sphere in a uniform field This problem deals with a magnetic sphere exposed to a uniform external magnetic field. Note that there is no net force acting on the sphere (because the background field is uniform). The field expression inside the sphere may be used to estimate the force on a ferromagnetic object placed in the fringing field generated by a magnet nearby. This force on an iron object due to the fringing field of a magnet is the subject of DISCUSSION 3.12 (p. 200) in CHAPTER 3. Figure 2.1 shows a magnetic sphere of radius R and permeability μ in a uniform external magnetic field given by: ∞ = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) H
(2.40)
1 ) and inside a) Show that expressions for the magnetic inductions outside (B 2 ) the sphere are given by: (B 1 = μ◦ H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) B 3 μ◦ − μ R + μ◦ H0 (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) 2μ◦ + μ r 2 = 3μ◦ μH0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) B 2μ◦ + μ
(2.41a) (2.41b)
Considering the following three limiting cases, μ/μ◦ = 0, μ/μ◦ = 1, and μ/μ◦ = ∞, confirm that the resulting expressions for the field in the sphere are physically plausible. distributions that would correspond to μ = 0.1μ◦ b) Picture, in your mind, B and μ = 100μ◦ . These distributions are shown in Fig. 2.2.
x r
θ
μ
R
z
H0
μ◦
Fig. 2.1
Magnetized sphere in a uniform magnetic field.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
38
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.1 a) This problem is most easily solved using scalar potentials, as discussed in the introductory section of this chapter. Namely, the magnetic potential φ is a scalar field such that: = −∇φ H (S1.1) In linear, isotropic media, magnetic field and magnetic induction are related by: = μH B
(S1.2)
The problem is divided into two regions, Region 1 (r ≥ R) and Region 2 (r ≤ R). Based on solutions of Eq. 2.33 and because H∞ = H0 at r = ∞ and H = ±∞ at r = 0, the appropriate potential for each region is: φ1 = H0 r cos θ +
A cos θ r2
φ2 = Cr cos θ
(r ≥ R)
(S1.3a)
(r ≤ R)
(S1.3b)
Note that φ1 → H0 r cos θ for r → ∞ (Eq. 2.40), and φ2 remains finite at r = 0. 2: 1 and H Using the ∇ operator in spherical coordinates (Eq. 2.36a), we have H ∂ A 1 ∂ A H1 = − H0 r cos θ + 2 cos θ ır − H0 r cos θ + 2 cos θ ıθ ∂r r r ∂θ r = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) +
A (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) r3
2 = − ∂ (Cr cos θ)ır − 1 ∂ (Cr cos θ)ıθ H ∂r r ∂θ = C(− cos θır + sin θıθ )
(S1.4a)
(S1.4b)
Boundary Conditions is continuous, since there is no 1) At r = R, the tangential component (ıθ ) of H surface current. This is equivalent to equating the potentials at r = R (φ1 = φ2 ): H0 +
A =C R3
is continuous: 2) At r = R, the normal component (ır ) of B A μ◦ −H0 + 2 3 = −μC R
(S1.5)
(S1.6)
From Eqs. S1.5 and S1.6, we can solve for the constants C and A: C=
3H0 μ◦ 2μ◦ + μ
(S1.7)
A = (C − H0 )R = H0 3
μ◦ − μ R3 2μ◦ + μ
(S1.8)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
39
Solution to PROBLEM 2.1 (continuation) 2 are thus: 1 and B B 1 = μ◦ H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) B 3 μ◦ − μ R + μ◦ H0 (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) 2μ◦ + μ r 2 = 3μ◦ μH0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) B 2μ◦ + μ
(2.41a) (2.41b)
Now, let us consider the three special cases of μ/μ◦ . Case 1: μ/μ◦ = 0 With μ = 0 inserted into Eqs. 2.41a and 2.41b, we obtain: 1 = μ◦ H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + μ◦ H0 B 2
3 R (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) r
2 = 0 B
(S1.9a) (S1.9b)
The sphere is like a Type I superconductor; no magnetic flux density is allowed inside the sphere—the Meissner effect. The profile is identical to the schematic profile corresponding to point C for superconductor (Sc) shown in Fig. 1.1b. As will be discussed in PROBLEM 2.2, a discontinuity in the θ component of the H fields at r = R requires a surface current (confined within a thin layer). Because this current, once set up, must flow persistently, it implies that the sphere has zero resistivity to the flow of these currents. As discussed in CHAPTER 1, a material that exhibits the Meissner effect must at the same time be a perfect conductor: such a material is automatically a superconductor. Case 2: μ/μ◦ = 1 The problem reduces to the trivial case, equivalent to the absence of the sphere. Note that with μ = μ◦ into Eqs. 2.41a and 2.41b, the equations become identical. Case 3: μ/μ◦ = ∞ This case is that of a perfectly ferromagnetic material; soft iron comes close. The magnetic field is drawn into the sphere. With μ = ∞ in Eqs. 2.41a and 2.41b: 3 R (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) B1 = μ◦ H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) − μ◦ H0 r
(S1.10a)
2 = 3μ◦ H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) B
(S1.10b)
field within the sphere of μ/μ◦ = ∞ The important point to note is that the B field. Note that if the sphere’s magnetization is is three times the applied B saturated, μ no longer is ∞. The effects of field saturation, present in all magnetic materials, will be discussed in PROBLEM 2.3.
40
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.1 (continuation) b)
Figure 2.2 shows field lines for two spheres of μ/μ◦ = 0.1 and μ/μ◦ = 100.
μ/μ◦ = 0.1
μ/μ◦ = 100 Fig. 2.2 Field lines inside and near spheres of μ/μ◦ = 0.1 (top) and μ/μ◦ = 100 (bottom). For the top sphere, the line spacing at r = ∞ is ∼2.6(= 2.1/0.3) times denser than that inside the sphere, while for the bottom sphere, the inside line spacing is ∼1.7(= 300/101) times that at r = ∞. These ratios are valid in both the plane of the paper and that perpendicular to it. A cylinder of μ/μ◦ = 100 would have a ratio of 200/101, but only in the plane of the paper. Note that the field lines entering and leaving the sphere are nearly perpendicular to the surface for μ/μ◦ = 100—perpendicular for μ/μ◦ = ∞.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
41
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.2: Type I superconducting rod in a uniform field This problem deals with a Type I superconductor (Meissner effect). The field solution is interpreted in terms of the London theory of superconductivity. Figure 2.3 shows an infinitely long lead (Pb) rod of circular cross section (radius R) subjected to a uniform external magnetic field perpendicular to its axis. ∞ = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) H
(2.40)
where μ◦ H0 = 0.08 T. Initially the rod is in the normal state. The field thus is everywhere the same, including inside the rod. The rod is then gradually cooled until it becomes superconducting. 1, a) Show that an expression for the field outside the superconducting rod, H after transient effects of the field change have subsided, is given by: 2 R H1 = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + H0 (cos θır + sin θıθ ) (2.42) r 1 for a magnetic sphere.) (Note that Eq. 2.41a corresponds to B f [A/m], b) Show that an expression for the surface current (free) density, K flowing within a penetration depth λ R, is given by: f = 2H0 sin θız K
(2.43)
c) Convert the magnitude of the surface current density to that of current density, Jf [A/m2 ], and confirm that its value is consistent with that for lead derivable from London’s theory of superconductivity.
y r
θ R
x
H0
Fig. 2.3 Infinitely long, circular cross section superconducting rod in a uniform magnetic field.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
42
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.2 a) The problem is divided into two regions, Region 1 (r ≥ R) and Region 2 (r ≤ 2 = 0 (φ2 = 0) when R). Because we are dealing with a Type I superconductor, B the rod is superconducting. The field in Region 1 is derivable from a potential: φ1 = H0 r cos θ +
A cos θ r
(S2.1)
Note that φ1 → H0 r cos θ for r → ∞, as required by Eq. 2.40. 1: Using the ∇ operator in cylindrical coordinates (Eq. 2.35a), we can derive H ∂ A 1 ∂ A H1 = − H0 r cos θ + cos θ ır − H0 r cos θ + cos θ ıθ (S2.2) ∂r r r ∂θ r A A = − H0 cos θ − 2 cos θ ır − −H0 sin θ − 2 sin θ ıθ (S2.3) r r Rearranging Eq. S2.3, we have: 1 = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + A (cos θır + sin θıθ ) H r2
(S2.4)
The continuity of the normal component of B requires that the coefficient of ır in Eq. S2.3 be zero at r = R: A −H0 + 2 = 0 (S2.5) R Solving Eq. S2.5 for A, we obtain: A = R 2 H0 The field outside the superconducting rod (Region 1) is thus given by: 2 R H1 = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + H0 (cos θır + sin θıθ ) r
(S2.6)
(2.42)
1 | = 2H0 ; the field amplitude is twice the far-field Note that at r = R, θ = 90◦ , |H amplitude. Physically, the field originally inside when the rod is in the normal state is now pushed outside and compressed at and near θ = 90◦ . b) Because of the discontinuity at r = R of 2H0 sin θ in the tangential (ıθ ) com there must be a surface current density K f flowing in the rod, as ponent of H, given by Eq. 2.6. We thus have: f = ır × 2H0 sin θıθ K = 2H0 sin θız
(2.43)
This “sine” (more commonly known as “cosine”) current distribution is the basis for most of the dipole magnets in the so-called “atom smashers” used in highenergy physics facilities. An “ideal” dipole magnet is studied in PROBLEM 3.8.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
43
Solution to PROBLEM 2.2 (continuation) c) According to the London theory of superconductivity (1.2.2 in CHAPTER 1), the supercurrent density, Js , of Type I superconductors is given by Js = ense v, where e is the electronic charge (1.6×10−19 C), nse is the superconducting electron density, and v is the drift velocity of superconducting electrons. The superconducting electron density may be roughly equated to the density of free electrons, nfe (Eq. 1.2): NA nse ≈ nfe = (1.2) WA With values for lead of = 11.4 g/cm3 , NA = 6.023×1023 particle/mole, and WA = 207.2 g/mole, we have: nse ≈
(11.4 g/cm3 )(6.023×1023 particle/mole) 207.2 g/mole
(S2.7)
3.3×1022 particle/cm3 = 3.3×1028 electron/m3 With v ∼ 200 m/s roughly equal to the drift velocity of superconducting electrons, we obtain an order of magnitude for Js : Js = ense v ∼ (1.6×10−19 C)(3.3×1028 m−3 )(200 m/s) ∼ 1×1012 A/m2 The surface current density, Kf = Jf λ, required in this lead cylinder should be such that Jf is roughly equal to Js , an order of magnitude of which is computed above. The London theory gives an expression (Eq. 1.1) for the penetration depth, λ, at the superconductor’s surface within which superconducting current flows. Equation 1.1 is once again given below: m λ= (1.1) μ◦ e2 nse With m = 9.1×10−31 kg and nse from Eq. S2.7, Eq. 1.1 becomes: (9.1×10−31 kg) λ= (4π×10−7 H/m)(1.6×10−19 C)2 (3.3×1028 m−3 )
3×10−8 m Because Kf = Jf λ: Jf =
2H0 2(μ◦ H0 ) 2(0.08 T) = = −7 λ μ◦ λ (4π×10 H/m)(3×10−8 m)
4×1012 A/m2 That is, Js and Js are roughly equal.
(S2.9)
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
44
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 2.1: Perfect-Conductor Sphere in a Uniform Field Here we derive quantitative field expressions for a perfectly conducting (ρ = 0) sphere subjected to a field change, specifically the C ⇒ D change illustrated in Fig. 1.1c (CHAPTER 1). At point C, the entire space, including that within the sphere, is in a uniform external field given by Eq. 2.40 of PROBLEM 2.1. The same spherical coordinates as those of Fig. 2.1 in PROBLEM 2.1 apply. When the uniform external field is reduced to zero (point D in Fig. 1.1c), because 2 , must remain the magnetic induction cannot change within the sphere, its field, H as the same: 2 = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) (r ≤ R) (2.44a) H 1 , is zero. Near the Far away from center, r → ∞, the field outside the sphere, H sphere, the field is derivable from a scalar potential, i.e., φ1 = (A/r2 ) cos θ. The ∇ operation on φ1 leads to a dipole field in spherical coordinates of the form: 1 = A (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) H r3
(r ≥ R)
(2.44b)
At r = R, the normal component of B must be continuous. Because at θ = 0 there is only a normal component of field both inside and outside of the sphere: −H0 = 2
A R3
Therefore A =−H0 R3 /2, and thus: 3 R H1 = −H0 (cos θır + r
1 2
sin θıθ )
(2.44c)
Equation 2.44c is a quantitative expression of the field distribution, except that in Fig. 1.1c the external field is from bottom to top, whereas in Fig. 2.1 the field points from right to left. The discontinuity in the tangential component of magnetic field at r = R is equal f , flowing in the sphere at r = R. Applying Eq. 2.6 to a surface current density, K and combining Eqs. 2.44a and 2.44c, we obtain: f = ır × [H0 sin θıθ − (− 1 H0 sin θıθ )] K 2 = 23 H0 sin θıϕ
(2.45)
Note that the sin θ distribution could be approximated with a “thin” coil wound on the surface of the sphere with a uniform turn density in the the z-axis direction.
Answer to TRIVIA 2.2 Cu: Latin cuprum, from Cyprus island; Lu: Lutetia, ancient name of Paris; Mg: Magnesia, district in Thessaly, Greece; Y: Ytterby, village in Sweden. Ytterby is also used for three other rare earth elements: erbium (Er); terbium (Tb); and ytterbium (Yb).
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
45
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.3: Magnetic shielding with a spherical shell This problem deals with passive magnetic shielding, an important subject for MRI, Maglev, and other high-field systems where people and field-sensitive equipment might be exposed to a fringing field. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration limits the maximum fringing field in MRI systems to 5 gauss (0.5 mT). ∞ , is to be shielded: Within a spherical region of space, a uniform magnetic field, H ∞ = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) (2.40) H For shielding, a spherical shell of o.d. 2R and wall thickness d/R 1 of highly permeable material (μ/μ◦ 1) may be used, as shown schematically in Fig. 2.4. a) Treating the problem as one of a magnetic spherical shell in a uniform external field, show that an expression for Hss /H0 , where Hss is the magnitude of the magnetic field inside the spherical space (r ≤ R−d), is given by: Hss 9μμ◦ = (2.46) 3 H0 d 2 9μμ◦ + 2(μ − μ◦ ) 1 − 1 − R b) Show that in the limits of μ/μ◦ 1 and d/R 1, the ratio Hss /H0 given by Eq. 2.46 reduces to: Hss R 3 μ◦
2 (2.47) H0 μ d c) Next, obtain Eq. 2.47 through a perturbation approach. First, solve the field in the shell (R − d ≤ r ≤ R) with μ = ∞. Then, use a perturbation approach for the case μ/μ◦ 1 and obtain Eq. 2.47. d) In reality the magnetic flux in the shielding material must be kept below the material’s saturation flux, μ◦ Msa . Show that an expression for d/R to keep the shell unsaturated is given by: 3H0 d ≥ (2.48) R 2Msa e) Draw field lines for the case μ/μ◦ 1. x
r
θ R
z
H0
d Fig. 2.4
Spherical magnetic shell in a uniform magnetic field.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
46
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.3 a) The problem is divided into three regions: Region 1 (r ≥ R); Region 2 (the shell); and Region 3 (r ≤ R−d). The appropriate potentials are given below: φ1 = H0 r cos θ + φ2 = Cr cos θ +
A cos θ r2
D cos θ r2
φ3 = Hss r cos θ
(S3.1a) (S3.1b) (S3.1c)
Note that φ1 → H0 r cos θ for r → ∞ and that φ3 remains finite as r → 0. Using the ∇ operator in spherical coordinates, we obtain: 1 = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + A (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) H r3
(S3.2a)
2 = C(− cos θır + sin θıθ ) + D (2 cos θır + sin θıθ ) H r3
(S3.2b)
3 = Hss (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) H
(S3.2c)
Boundary Conditions (Hθ ) is continuous: φ1 = φ2 . 1) At r = R, the tangential (ıθ ) component of H 2) Similarly, at r = R−d, Hθ is continuous: φ2 = φ3 . (Br ) is continuous. 3) At r = R, the normal (ır ) component of B 4) Similarly, at r = R−d, Br is continuous. The above boundary conditions give rise to the following four equations: H0 +
A D =C+ 3 3 R R
D = Hss (R − d)3 2A 2D μ◦ −H0 + 3 = μ −C + 3 R R
2D μ −C + = −μ◦ Hss (R − d)3 C+
(S3.3a) (S3.3b) (S3.3c) (S3.3d)
Combining Eqs. S3.3a and S3.3b and eliminating C, we have:
1 A 1 +D − 3 − Hss = −H0 R3 (R − d)3 R
(S3.4)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
47
Solution to PROBLEM 2.3 (continuation) From Eqs. S3.3b and S3.3d, we can obtain D in terms of Hss : D=
μ − μ◦ (R − d)3 Hss 3μ
(S3.5)
Combining Eqs. S3.4 and S3.5, we have A/R3 in terms of Hss : 3 A d μ − μ◦ = Hss 1 − 1− 1− − H0 R3 3μ R From Eqs. S3.3c and S3.3d, we obtain:
2A μ 1 1 +2 D − 3 + Hss = H0 R3 μ◦ (R − d)3 R
(S3.6)
(S3.7)
Combining Eqs. S3.4–S3.7 and expressing Hss in terms of H0 , we obtain: Hss = H0
9μμ◦ 9μμ◦ + 2(μ − μ◦ )2
d 1− 1− R
3
(2.46)
b) We may simplify Eq. 2.46 by dividing top and bottom by μ2◦ and applying the limits μ/μ◦ 1 and d/R 1: Hss
H0
μ 9 μ◦
9μ/μ◦ 2
μ d +2 1− 1−3 μ◦ R
3 μ d 3+2 μ◦ R
In the special case μd/μ◦ R 1, Eq. S3.9 reduces to: μ◦ Hss R
23 H0 μ d
(S3.8)
(S3.9)
(2.47)
c) The same result given by Eq. 2.47 for Hss /H0 can be obtained directly by a perturbation approach for the case μ/μ◦ 1 and d/R 1. We proceed by assuming that μ of the shell material is infinite. This requires that 1 has only the B lines be perpendicular to the shell at r = R. This is because H a radial (ır ) component at r = R, because H = 0 in the shell and Hθ must be continuous at r = R. (This can be seen quite readily by noting that when μ = ∞, C = D = 0.) From Eq. S3.3a, A = −R3 H0 , and thus at r = R: 1 = −3H0 cos θır H
(S3.10)
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
48
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.3 (continuation) x
d dθ
R
z R
Fig. 2.5
θ
Flux entering into the spherical shell over the surface bounded by ±θ.
The B lines stay inside the shell without “spilling” into Region 3; that is, B inside the shell has only an ıθ component. Let us now apply magnetic flux continuity, 2 is solved for this case, an = 0, and solve for B 2 when μ = ∞. Once B i.e., ∇ · B approximate expression for H3 can be deduced for μ = ∞ but μ/μ◦ 1. First, we calculate the total magnetic flux Φ entering into the shell over the surface area bounded by ±θ (Fig. 2.5). This surface area, as indicated in the figure, is given by a differential area (a ring of radius R sin θ times Rdθ) integrated from 0 to θ. Thus, we have:
Φ = μ◦
θ
= μ◦ 1 · dA H
0
θ
3H0 cos θ 2πR2 sin θ dθ 0
= 3πμ◦ R2 H0 sin2 θ
(S3.11)
This Φ must be equal to the total flux flowing in the θ-direction in the shell at θ. Because the shell’s cross-sectional area, A2 , at θ is given, for d R, by the shell thickness d times the circumference of a ring of radius R sin θ, we have: A2 d2πR sin θ
(S3.12)
We thus have: Φ = 3πμ◦ R2 H0 sin2 θ
B2 A2 = B2 d2πR sin θ
(S3.13)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
49
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.3 (continuation) Solving for B2 from Eq. S3.13, we obtain: R 3 B2 2 μ◦ H0 sin θıθ d
(S3.14)
3 2 is for μ = ∞; we can now deduce an approximate solution for H Note that B because the ıθ -component of H must be continuous at r = R−d. Thus: Bθ2 R 3 μ◦ Hθ3
=2 H0 sin θ (S3.15) μ μ d 3: Once Hθ3 is known, we have the complete expression for H R 3 3 μ◦ H H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) 2 μ d H R 3 3 μ◦ H0 2 μ d
(S3.16a) (S3.16b)
3 /H0 | given by Eq. S3.16b agrees with Hss /H0 given by Eq. 2.47. The ratio |H Note that this perturbation approach requires the conditions μ = ∞ and d R, but not the condition μd/μ◦ R 1 in the step from Eq. S3.9 to Eq. 2.47. d) It is important to remember that d cannot be chosen arbitrarily small to satisfy the condition d/R 1. The preceding analysis is valid, in fact, only when: d μ◦ 1 (S3.17) μ R In reality μ cannot be infinite and the shielding material will eventually saturate as the external field increases. Hence, the maximum magnetic flux inside the shell, which occurs at θ = 90◦ , must be less than the saturation flux μ◦ Msa of the shell material. Thus: 3 R (S3.18) μ◦ H0 ≤ μ◦ Msa 2 d Solving Eq. S3.18 for d/R, we obtain: d 3H0 ≥ R 2Msa
(2.48)
Table 2.5 presents approximate values of differential μ/μ◦ , defined as (μ/μ◦ )dif ≡ ΔM/ΔH0 |μ◦ H0 and μ◦ M (H◦ ) in the μ◦ H0 range 1–1000 gauss (0.1–100 mT), as well as μ◦ Msa for annealed ingot iron, as-cast steel, and vanadium permendur (50%Co, 2%V). These materials are useful for magnetic shielding in external inductions up to ∼100 gauss. The materials have μ◦ Msa values, respectively, of roughly 2.1 T, 2.0 T, and 2.2 T. TRIVIA 2.3 The permanent magnet is ubiquitous in daily life (DISCUSSION 2.3 ). From the figures below, choose the one that is closest to the number of permanent magnets in a modern passenger car. i) 20;
ii) 100;
iii) 500;
iv) 2,500.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
50
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.3 (continuation) Table 2.5: Values of (μ/μ◦ )dif ; μ◦ M (H◦ ); and μ◦ Msa for Iron Alloys μ◦ H0
Annealed Ingot Iron
[gauss]
(μ/μ◦ )∗dif
1 3 5 10 20 50 100 200 500 1000
7710 3850 500 115 47 23.5 17.5 8.25 2.0 0.4
μ◦ Msa
As-Cast Steel
Vanadium Permendur
μ◦ M [T]
(μ/μ◦ )∗dif
μ◦ M [T]
(μ/μ◦ )∗dif
μ◦ M [T]
0.375 0.91 1.42 1.54 1.60 1.70 1.81 1.93 2.05 2.11
n.a. 1660 1155 565 180 50 25 10 1.0 0.45
n.a. 0.25 0.51 0.93 1.25 1.52 1.70 1.85 1.92 2.01
n.a. 4845 1875 545 170 17 4.8 1.3 0.26 0.07
n.a. 0.65 1.25 1.67 1.96 2.10 2.15 2.17 2.18 2.19
2.13 T
2.03 T
2.20 T
* Derived from M (H) plots in Permanent Magnet Manual (General Electric Company, 1963).
e)
Field lines for the case μ/μ◦ = 100 are shown below in Fig. 2.6.
Fig. 2.6 Field distribution with a spherical shell of μ/μ◦ = 100 in a uniform field. Note that the field lines entering and leaving the shell are nearly perpendicular to the shell.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
51
DISCUSSION 2.2: Shielding with a Cylindrical Shell* We use a perturbation technique similar to that used in PROBLEM 2.3 to derive an expression for Hcs /H0 , where Hcs is the magnitude of the magnetic field inside the cylindrical space (r ≤ R−d) surrounded by a shell of o.d. 2R and wall thickness d/R 1 of highly permeable material (μ/μ◦ 1) in a uniform external magnetic ∞ , of magnitude H0 . In 2-D cylindrical coordinates H ∞ is given by: field, H ∞ = H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) (2.40) H θ is defined in Fig. 2.3. We proceed by assuming that μ of the cylinder material is infinite. We then find that, as in PROBLEM 2.3, the B lines must be normal to the cylinder at r = R. Thus at r = R we have: 1 = −2H0 cos θır H B in the shell, however, is θ-directed. For d/R 1, the flux continuity requirement for B may be expressed by:
θ 2μ◦ H0 R cos θ dθ = 2μ◦ RH0 sin θ B2 d = 0
R B2 = 2μ◦ H0 sin θıθ d 2 is known for μ = ∞, we know H 2 for μ/μ◦ 1: Once B R 2 = B2 2 μ◦ H H0 sin θıθ μ μ d
Thus:
Because Hθ is continuous in the absence of surface current, the same Hθ must exist in Regions 2 and 3: Hθ2 = Hθ3 . Thus, at r = R−d: μ◦ R Hθ3 = Hθ2 2 H0 sin θ μ d From the above expression, it follows that: μ◦ R H3 2 H0 (− cos θır + sin θıθ ) μ d H R 3 ≡ Hcs 2 μ◦ H0 H0 μ d
(2.49)
As in the spherical shell studied in PROBLEM 2.3, the cylindrical shell cannot be arbitrarily thin; it must be thick enough to keep it from saturating: R μHcs = 2μ◦ H0 ≤ μ◦ Msa d From the above, we obtain: d 2H0 ≥ (2.50) R Msa * Problem 2.4 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
52
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.4: The field far from a cluster of four dipoles* This problem considers the field far from a cluster of four ideal dipoles, 1–4, arranged as shown in Fig. 2.7, in which the direction of each dipole is indicated by the arrow within a circle. The center-to-center distance between two opposing dipoles is 2δd . The field of each jth dipole of zero winding thickness, diameter 2rd , and overall length d in the y-direction, at a radial location (rj ) far from the j: dipole (rj d ) may be modeled as a spherical dipole field, B 2 j = rd d B◦ (cos ϑjır + B j 2rj3
1 2
sin ϑjıθj )
(2.51)
where rj is measured from the center of each dipole and ϑj in each dipole is defined such that the field inside the winding points in the rj -direction when ϑj = 0◦ . Figure 2.7 indicates the direction of the field inside each dipole. Also defined in Fig. 2.7 are r-θ coordinates and z-x coordinates common to all the dipoles. Note that for r δd , we have ϑ1 = θ+180◦ , ϑ2 = θ−90◦ , ϑ3 = θ, and ϑ4 = θ+90◦ .
Show that an approximate expression for the far field (B for r/δd 1) of the combined system is given by: 2 3rd d B◦ δd (− sin 2θır + 1 cos 2θıθ ) B 2 r4 Neglect end effects of each dipole, i.e., consider only the plane y = 0.
x r 1 θ 2δd
2rd
z 2
4 3
Fig. 2.7 Cross-sectional view of a four-dipole arrangement. The arrow in each dipole indicates the field direction inside the winding. * Problem 2.5 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
(2.52)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
53
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.4 For r δd , rj of each dipole may be given in terms of r and θ: r1 r − δd sin θ
(S4.1a)
r2 r + δd cos θ
(S4.1b)
r3 r + δd sin θ
(S4.1c)
r4 r − δd cos θ
(S4.1d)
With Eq. S4.1 into Eq. 2.51 for each dipole and ϑj expressed in terms of θ: 1
B
rd2 d B◦ (− cos θır − 2(r − δd sin θ)3
2
B
rd2 d B◦ (sin θır − 2(r + δd cos θ)3
1 2
cos θıθ )
(S4.2b)
3
B
rd2 d B◦ (cos θır + 2(r + δd sin θ)3
1 2
sin θıθ )
(S4.2c)
4
B
rd2 d B◦ (− sin θır + 2(r − δd cos θ)3
1 2
1 2
sin θıθ )
cos θıθ )
(S4.2a)
(S4.2d)
For r δd the denominator of each term may be expanded; to 1st order in δd /r Eq. S4.2 becomes:
rd2 d B◦ δd B1
1+3 sin θ (− cos θır − 21 sin θıθ ) (S4.3a) 2r3 r
2 2 rd d B◦ 1 − 3 δd cos θ (sin θır − 1 cos θıθ ) B (S4.3b) 2 2r3 r
δd rd2 d B◦ 1−3 B3
sin θ (cos θır + 21 sin θıθ ) (S4.3c) 2r3 r
δd rd2 d B◦ 1+3 cos θ (− sin θır + 21 cos θıθ ) B4
(S4.3d) 2r3 r Combining each field given by Eq. S4.3, we obtain: 2 2 + B 3 + B 4 3rd d B◦ δd (− sin 2θır + =B 1 + B B r4
1 2
cos 2θıθ )
(2.52)
decreases ∝ 1/r4 rather than ∝ 1/r3 , as would a single dipole. Note that |B| Answer to TRIVIA 2.3 ii). A modern military aircraft, however, may contain up to ∼2,000 pieces of permanent magnet—J.D. Livingstone, Driving Force: The Natural Magic of Magnets (Harvard University Press, 1996).
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
54
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.5: Iron electromagnet pole shape Figure 2.8 shows the active section of an iron electromagnet, with two conically tapered cylindrical poles of ferromagnetic material—the shaded area of each pole indicates the material removed from the original cylindrical pole. When the windings (not shown in the figure) of the magnet are energized, a relatively uniform field is generated in the gap between the poles. The central field has no theoretical upper limit, because it increases ∝ ln(R2 /R1 ), where 2R2 and 2R1 are, respectively, the diameters of the base and tip of each cone. There is, however, a practical field limit of ∼7 T (in magnets at Bellevue, Paris and Uppsala University, Sweden) because as R2 is increased, the magnet mass becomes prohibitively large. The tapering enhances the center field, because the field by each magnetic moment located in this section contributes a negative axial (z) field at the center.
Show that θtp = 54◦ 44 is the optimal angle for this simple pole geometry if the iron is magnetized parallel to the axis of the system. Assume that the center field is the sum of the field generated by each magnetic moment distributed uniformly over the pole pieces. (As indicated in the figure, the four dotted lines, each projected from one of the four lines defining θtp = 54◦ 44 , meet at the center. Note that if the gap is large enough, tapering will not be beneficial.) Each moment, mA [A m2 ], m (r, θ): magnetized in the z-direction, generates a dipole field, H A m (r, θ) = mA cos θır + H A 3 r
1 2
sin θıθ
(2.53)
m (r, θ) is axisymmetric with respect to the z-axis and it is From symmetry H A derivable from a scalar potential cos θ/r2 . This derivation has been used in PROBLEMS 2.1, 2.3, and 2.4, and DISCUSSION 2.1. Hint Solve the z-axis center field due to a single magnetic dipole moment, mA↑, located on the pole perimeter at the boundary between the tapered and untapered pole, as indicated by • in Fig. 2.8. z r θ
θtp
2R1 mA 2R2
Fig. 2.8 Pair of pole pieces, each tapered at an angle of θtp . • denotes the location of a magnetic dipole moment mA↑.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
55
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.5 The z-component of the field at the center, HmAz , due to moment mA is given by: mA HmAz = 3 (cos2 θ − 21 sin2 θ) (S5.1) rA where rA is the distance from mA to the center. At θ = θtp , the right-hand side of Eq. S5.1 is zero. Thus: cos2 θtp − 21 sin2 θtp = 0 (S5.2) √ √ ◦ From Eq. S5.2, cos θtp = 1/ 3 (or tan θtp = 2 ) and we find: θtp 54.736 54◦ 44 . Note that moments located in the shaded area above the perimeter are at θtp > 54◦ 44 . Because cos θ decreases with θ, while sin θ increases, HmAz is negative for θtp > 54◦ 44 . Tapering the pole piece at this angle eliminates this negative contribution, thus maximizing the center field. Remarkably, 54◦ 44 is identical to the magic angle used in NMR spectroscopy. Often an NMR sample is oriented at this magic angle with respect to the principal axial field and spun to average out anisotropic interactions.
DISCUSSION 2.3: Permanent Magnets The permanent magnet is a vital component in many devices used in daily life— cars (see Trivia 2.3 ), TV’s, computers, telephones, refrigerators, to name only a few. Indeed without permanent magnets modern life as we know it today would cease to function. They also compete with superconducting magnets for MRI in the low field range (< 1 T). MRI magnets composed of permanent magnets are popular because they are not only free of cryogenics but also relatively inexpensive. Table 2.6 shows developments of permanent magnets and superconductors over the past nine decades, from the 1910s to the 1990s, expressed in terms of maximum magnetic energy, BH|mx , for permanent magnets and maximum critical temperature, Tc |mx , for superconductors. The increase during this period by a factor of ∼30 in BH|mx is as remarkable as that by a factor of ∼20 in Tc |mx . If this pace of the development in permanent magnets continues, within the nottoo-distant future MRI magnets based on permanent magnets should reach ∼1 T, the level above which superconducting counterparts dominate. Table 2.6: Development of Permanent Magnets and Superconductors Decade(s) Permanent Magnet BH|mx [kJ/m3 ] Superconductor 1910 1920–1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990
Special steel Alnico* 1–4 Alnico 5 Alnico 8, 9 SmCo5 Sm(CoCuFeZr) Nd2 Fe14 B
11 15 35 55 140 240 350
* Iron alloys principally of Al, Ni, and Co.
Pb NbN Nb3 Sn Nb12 Al3 Ge Nb3 Ge Bi2 Sr2 Ca2 Cu3 Ox (Hg,Pb)Sr2 Ca2 Cu3 Ox
Tc |mx [K] 7.2 16 18 19 23 118 133
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
56
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.6: Quasi-static field in a cylinder A long thin cylinder of radius R is made of a sheet that is perfectly conducting (σ = ∞) but not superconducting and has a narrow slot of gap δ (Fig. 2.9). The cylinder is placed in a sinusoidally time-varying magnetic field, which is, to 0th order, uniform and z-directed (normal to the paper). Namely: ∞ (t) = Re[H◦ ejωt ]ız H
(2.54)
where H◦ is a complex amplitude. End effects may be neglected. a) Neglecting terms of order δ/R, show that the 1st -order complex voltage amplitude across the slot along the shortest path, V1 |0 ≡ V1 |θ=0◦ , is given by: V1 |0 ≡ V1 |θ=0◦ = −jωπR2 μ◦ H◦
(2.55)
b) Suppose now that a normal metal sheet of resistivity ρ [Ω m] is placed in the gap to connect the lips of the cylinder. Derive an expression for the 1st -order complex current density (per unit axial length) amplitude, J1 [A/m], through the sheet. Assume that the driving frequency (ω/2π) is low enough that the magnetic field retains the quasi-static form given by Eq. 2.54 and that the current flows uniformly over the sheet cross section. c) In the absence of the resistive sheet (or ρs = ∞), draw neatly six lines of the 1 ) vector within the space enclosed by the 1st -order complex electric field (E cylinder, clearly showing important features. d) In the absence of the resistive sheet, derive an expression for the line integral +π/2 of the 1st -order voltage, V1 |−π/2 , across the voltage taps attached, one at θ = +π/2 and the other at θ = −π/2.
y
∞ (t) H R
θ x δ
Fig. 2.9 Axial view of a long thin cylinder of radius R of perfect conductor with a narrow gap of δ at θ = 0 exposed to a sinusoidally time-varying magnetic field in the z-direction.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
57
Solution to PROBLEM 2.6 1 (t), we have: Using Faraday’s integral law for the 1st -order electric field, E 1 (t) · d s = −πR2 μ◦ dH◦ (t) E V1 (t) ≡ (S6.1) dt C The line integral is taken around the cylinder, including the gap, in the counterclockwise direction. The right-hand side of Eq. S6.1 covers the entire area defined by the cylinder (πR2 ). Because the cylinder is a perfect conductor, E1 (t) = 0 within the material. The only nonzero contribution to the line integral comes from the gap, which is equal to V1 (t). In terms of complex amplitudes, we have: a)
V1 |0 = −jωπR2 μ◦ H◦
(2.55)
b) Using Ohm’s law, we have for J1 (per unit length): V1 |0 J1 = ρs
(S6.2)
1 c) Because the cylinder is a perfect conductor, the tangential component of E 1 leaves or enters the cylinder at a right angle. As at the cylinder must be zero: E the line integral across the cylinder moves to the left of the gap, the integral area 1. decreases, making |E1 | smaller. Figure 2.10 shows six lines of E d) This is a special case of c), where from symmetry it is possible to compute the line integral exactly: the integral area is equal to πR2 /2. Thus: +π/2
V1 |−π/2 = − 21 jωπR2 μ◦ H◦
(S6.3)
Equations 2.55 and S6.3 demonstrate that voltages across the cylinder at the same axial location depend on azimuthal locations of the voltage taps. This is an important point to be remembered when measuring voltage in the presence of a time-varying magnetic field, applied externally as in the present case or generated by a current flowing in the system. Electrical measurement of AC losses in a superconductor is a good example where one must be careful.
∞ (t) H
1 E
−R
1 E
x=0
1 E
1 E
R
Fig. 2.10 Lines of E1 normal to the perfectly conducting cylinder. Note that the |E1 | decreases as the line is moved from x = R to x = −R.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
58
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.7: Induction heating of a cylindrical shell* This problem deals with induction heating of a metallic (nonsuperconducting) cylindrical shell. It is a good example of a case involving sinusoidal electromagnetic fields, power flow (Poynting vector), and power dissipation. This and the next problem are the first examples of an AC loss, specifically an eddy-current loss, to be discussed further in CHAPTER 7. Induction heating is widely used in electric furnaces to achieve high temperatures in conducting materials; it also is sometimes used as a research tool in the study of the thermal behavior of superconducting windings. In superconducting magnet technology research, induction heating is most often used in the form of pulsed fields to simulate transient disturbances that create small normal regions in otherwise superconducting windings. Figure 2.11 shows a “long” metallic cylindrical shell of resistivity ρe , of o.d. 2R, and of thickness d R, in a sinusoidally time-varying magnetic field, which within 0th order is uniform and z-directed (along the cylinder axis). Namely: 0 ejωt ) = Re(H0 ejωt )ız ∞ (t) = Re(H H
(2.54)
where H0 is a complex field amplitude. We shall approach this problem first (Part 1) by solving for the appropriate fields by two methods and then (Part 2) solving for power dissipation in the cylinder by two methods.
y r H0 θ R
H0
x
d
Fig. 2.11 Cylindrical metallic shell in a uniform sinusoidally time-varying magnetic field. * Problem 2.6 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
59
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.7: Induction heating—Part 1 (Field) First, we shall solve for appropriate fields using two methods, described below. Method 1 a) Using the integral form of Maxwell’s equations and neglecting end effects, 1 , in the region r ≤ R show that expressions for the 1st -order electric field, E st and the 1 -order current density, J1 , in the shell (r R) are given by: 1 = − jωμ◦ rH0 ıθ E 2
(2.56)
jωμ◦ RH0 J1 − ıθ 2ρe
(2.57)
1 , in the region r ≤ R − d b) Show that the resulting 1st -order magnetic field, H can be expressed by: 1 = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ız H (2.58) 2ρe c) Equations 2.56–2.58, derived using the quasi-static approximation, are valid only in the “low” frequency limit, or frequencies much less than the “skindepth” frequency, fsk . Show that fsk is given by: ρe fsk = (2.59) πμ◦ Rd Method 2 1 , derived by Method 1, each increasing with ω, are valid only for 1 , J1 , and H E frequencies well below fsk . We now demonstrate a new technique that enables us T = (H 0 + H R ), in the bore, valid for the entire range to derive the total field, H 0 is the original field, and H R is the of frequencies. HT is the total net field, H reaction field of the system in the bore. In this approach, first find the reaction R in the bore by treating H T = (H 0 +H R ) as a 0th -order field and solve for field H st HR as the usual 1 -order magnetic field response. R, H T , and J in the shell valid for d R are: d) Show that expressions for H R = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ız H 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
TRIVIA 2.4:
(2.60)
T = H
2ρe H0 ız 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.61)
J = −
jωμ◦ RH0 ıθ 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.62)
Which is responsible for the “humming” of a power transformer?
i) E field;
ii) J ×B force;
iii) ρJ 2 heating;
iv) H field.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
60
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.7—Part 1 1 and J1 are constant in the θ-direction; a) From symmetry in the θ-direction, E both are θ-directed and depend only on r. Thus the Faraday’s induction law may be applied along contour C at r enclosing surface S: 1 · ds = −jωμ◦ H 0 · dA E C
S
2π
rE1θ dθ = −jωμ◦
0
r
2πrH0 dr 0
2π
r dθ = −jωμ◦ H0
E1θ 0
r
2πr dr
(S7.1)
0
For r ≤ R, E1θ 2πr = −jωμ◦ H0 πr2
(S7.2)
Dividing each side of Eq. S7.2 by 2πr, we obtain: E1θ = −
jωμ◦ rH0 2
(S7.3)
Thus:
1 = − jωμ◦ rH0 ıθ E 2 st The 1 -order current flows only in the shell (r R): 1 (r R) E jωμ◦ RH0 J1 =− ıθ ρe 2ρe
(2.56)
(2.57)
1 , by multiFor d R, we may treat the current as a 1st -order surface current, K plying J1 by d: 1 = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ıθ (S7.4) K 2ρe 1 to the discontinuity in H 1 = 0; using Eq. 2.6, we can equate K b) For r > R, H at r = R: H0 + H1 at the inner wall of the shell, and H0 outside. Thus: 0 − (H 0 + H 1 )] = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ıθ 1 = ır ×[H K 2ρe 1 = − = ır ×−H
jωμ◦ RdH0 ıθ 2ρe
(S7.5)
1 (r ≤ R − d) with d R, we have: Solving Eq. S7.5 for H 1 = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ız H 2ρe
(2.58)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
61
Solution to PROBLEM 2.7—Part 1 (continuation) 1 , and c) Equations 2.57, S7.4, and 2.58 predict that the magnitudes of J1 , K 1 all increase monotonically with frequency; this cannot be valid for the entire H range of ω. These solutions are valid only in the “low” frequency limit, which is 1 given the applicable range of the quasi-static approximation. More specifically, H 1 | |H 0 |: by Eq. 2.58 is valid only when |H 1| = |H
ωμ◦ Rd|H0 | 0| |H 2ρe
(S7.6)
From Eq. S7.6, we can obtain the frequency limit, often called the skin-depth frequency, fsk , below which the quasi-static approximation is valid: fsk =
ρe πμ◦ Rd
(2.59)
Note that fsk depends not only on the metal’s electrical resistivity but also on the size of the object in the sinusoidally time-varying applied magnetic field. 1 ≡ d) In the second approach for computing the shell’s reaction field, we set H R , and substitute H 0 +H R for H 0 in the expression for H 1 given in Eq. 2.58: H R = − jωμ◦ Rd(H0 + HR ) H 2ρe
(S7.7)
R , we obtain: Solving Eq. S7.7 for H R = − jωμ◦ RdH0 ız H 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.60)
0 +H R , we have: T =H Combining Eq. 2.60 and H jωμ◦ Rd ız H T = H 0 + HR = H 0 1 − 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd =
2ρe H0 ız 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.61)
= J, which, for K = Jd, reduces to: R are related by ∇× H J and H 1 J = HRıθ d =−
jωμ◦ RH0 ıθ 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(S7.8) (2.62)
R given by Eq. 2.60 reduces, as expected, Note that in the low frequency limit, H R reduces, also as expected, to H1 given by Eq. 2.58. In the high frequency limit, H to −H0 and HT becomes 0. Similar observations apply to J.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
62
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.7: Induction heating—Part 2 (Power Dissipation) Now, we can solve for power dissipation in the cylinder; two methods are used. Method 1 e) We may calculate the resistive power dissipated in the cylindrical shell by · J∗ /2 = ρe |J|2 /2 (Eq. 2.21), where J is given directly computing < p > = E by Eq. 2.62. Show that an expression for the time-averaged total dissipation power (per unit length) in the shell, < P >, for d R is given by: < P > = 2πRd < p > =
πρe ω 2 μ2◦ R3 d |H0 |2 4ρ2e + ω 2 μ2◦ R2 d2
(2.63)
Method 2 The same complex power supplied to the cylinder may also be viewed as a flow of Poynting power flux entering the cylinder at r = R from a source located at r > R. f ) Show that the surface integral (per unit cylinder length) of the 1st -order 1 entering into the cylinder at r = R is given by: complex Poynting vector S 1 · dA = 1 (2πR)E1θ H ∗ − S 0 2 S
=
jπρe ωμ◦ R2 |H0 |2 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.64)
Note that E1θ = ρe Jθ , where Jθ is given by Eq. 2.62. g) Take the real part of the right-hand side of Eq. 2.64 and show that it is identical to the expression for < P > given by Eq. 2.63. h) Plot < P > as a function of ρe . Because both a perfect conductor (ρe = 0) and a perfect insulator (ρe = ∞) obviously do not dissipate power, your < P > vs. ρe plot should start with < P >= 0 and return asymptotically to zero as ρe → ∞. Note that < P > given by Eq. 2.63 indeed indicates this behavior. i) A consequence of this < P > vs. ρe behavior is that there is a critical resistivity, ρec , at which < P > is maximum. Show that ρec is given by: ρec =
ωμ◦ Rd 2
(2.65)
From Eq. 2.65, we note that for a given combination of resistivity (ρec ) and sample size (R, d), there exists an optimal frequency that maximizes the heating: this is equal to the “skin depth” frequency, fsk , given by Eq. 2.59. j) Compute fsk for a copper tube of 10-mm radius (R), 0.5-mm wall thickness (d), and ρe = 2 × 10−10 Ω m (roughly the electrical resistivity of copper at liquid helium temperatures).
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
63
Solution to PROBLEM 2.7—Part 2 e) In the sinusoidal case, the time-averaged dissipation power (per unit length), · J∗ /2 = ρe |J|2 /2, where J is the complex current density < p >, is given by E (Eq. 2.62). We thus have: < p >=
ρe ρe |Jθ |2 = 2 2
ω 2 μ2◦ R2 |H0 |2 4ρ2e + ω 2 μ2◦ R2 d2
(S7.9)
The time-averaged total dissipation power (per unit length) in the shell, < P >, is obtained by multiplying < p > by the cross sectional area of the shell: < P > = 2πRd < p > =
πρe ω 2 μ2◦ R3 d |H0 |2 4ρ2e + ω 2 μ2◦ R2 d2
(2.63)
We now examine two limits of ρe : ρe ωμ◦ Rd :
πρe R |H0 |2 ∝ ρe d
(excellent conductor) (S7.10a)
ρe ωμ◦ Rd :
πω 2 μ2◦ R3 d 1 |H0 |2 ∝ 4ρe ρe
(poor conductor)
(S7.10b)
Note that in both limits, < P > → 0, as expected. f)
expanded to 1st -order, is: The complex Poynting vector, S, 1 = 1 E ∗+E 0 ×H ∗+E 1 ×H ∗ 0 ×H S 0 1 0 2
(S7.11)
1 , the sum of the E-field Note that in computing the 1st -order Poynting vector, S subscript and H-field subscript must not exceed 1. In this particular case, we have 0 = 0; thus Eq. S7.11 simplifies to: E 1 = 1 E 1 ×H ∗ S (S7.12) 0 2 1 is given by: where from Eq. 2.62, E 1 = ρe J = − jρe ωμ◦ RH0 ıθ E 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(S7.13)
We thus have: −
S
1 · dA = 1 (2πR)E1θ H ∗ S 0 2 =
jπρe ωμ◦ R2 |H0 |2 2ρe + jωμ◦ Rd
(2.64)
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
64
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.7—Part 2 (continuation) g)
The real part of Eq. 2.64 is given by:
(πρe ωμ◦ R2 )(ωμ◦ Rd) πρe ω 2 μ2◦ R3 d 2 |H | = |H0 |2 0 4ρ2e + ω 2 μ2◦ R2 d2 4ρ2e + ω 2 μ2◦ R2 d2 Note that Eq. S7.14 (Method 2) is identical to Eq. 2.63 (Method 1). < P >=
h) i)
(S7.14)
Figure 2.12 shows a plot of < P > vs. ρe . We differentiate < P > with respect to ρe and equate it to 0 at ρec :
8πρ2ec ω 2 μ2◦ R3 d d < P > πω 2 μ2◦ R3 d = − =0 dρe 4ρ2 + ω 2 μ2 R2 d2 (4ρ2 + ω 2 μ2 R2 d2 )2 ◦
ec
ρec
ec
(S7.15)
◦
Solving Eq. S7.15 for ρec , we have: ωμ◦ Rd (2.65) 2 Equation 2.65 is important in induction heating, in which a uniform, sinusoidally time-varying magnetic field is applied to a conducting sample. The sample is heated by the eddy currents induced in the sample. At the skin-depth frequency, fsk , given by Eq. 2.59, the induction heating is maximum. ρec =
j) For a copper cylinder of R = 1 cm, d = 0.5 mm, ρe = 2 × 10−10 Ω m (corresponding to copper’s resistivity at ∼4 K), we obtain, from Eq. 2.59: ρec (2.59) fsk = πμ◦ Rd =
2×10−10 Ω m 10 Hz π(4π×10−7 H/m)(0.010 m)(0.0005 m)
∝
∝ ρe
1 ρe
ρe 0 Fig. 2.12
ρ ec
Power dissipation vs. resistivity for induction-heated cylindrical shell.
Microwave Oven Cooking Cooking in a microwave oven involves induction heating, but it is different from the type studied here. In a microwave oven the frequency is set to the dominant vibration frequency of water molecules, enabling the water in the food to absorb the electromagnetic energy and be heated.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
65
PROBLEM 2.8: Eddy-current loss in a metallic strip* In this problem an expression for eddy-current loss in a metallic strip subjected to a time-varying magnetic field is derived. It is useful in computing eddy-current heating in copper-matrix superconductor strips. (When induced-current heating is beneficial, it is usually called induction heating; when it is detrimental, it is often called eddy-current loss.) Figure 2.13 shows a “long” (in the x-direction) metallic strip of electrical resistivity ρe , width b (in the y-direction), and thickness a (in the z-direction) placed in a time-varying external magnetic induction, dB0 /dt = B˙ 0 , which is, within zeroth order, uniform and z-directed. 1 , can be expressed by: a) Show that the 1st -order electric field, E E1x = y B˙ 0
(2.66)
b) Show that the spatially-averaged power dissipation density p˜ (over the unit strip volume) can be expressed by: p˜ =
(bB˙ 0 )2 12ρe
(2.67)
c) When the external magnetic induction is sinusoidally varying in time with angular frequency ω, B(t) = B0 sin ωt, show that an expression for the timeaveraged p˜, < p˜>, is given by: (b ω B˙ 0 )2 < p˜>= (2.68) 24ρe
y ↑
B˙ 0
b 2
→x
− 2b
Fig. 2.13
˙ 0. Metallic strip of width b in a time-varying magnetic field, B
Answer to TRIVIA 2.4: iv). The “magnetostriction” effect of a magnetic field on iron causes cyclic changes in the iron sheet dimensions, creating hum of frequency twice that of the current. For 60-Hz current the hum is about an octave below middle C. * Problem 2.7 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
66
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.8 0 is uniform and the system is independent of x, E 1 points only in a) Because B 1 = −∂ B 0 /∂ t reduces to: the x-direction and depends only on y. That is, ∇× E −
dE1x dB0 =− = −B˙ 0 dy dt
(S8.1)
From symmetry, E1x (y = 0) = 0, and we have from Eq. S8.1: E1x = y B˙ 0
(2.66)
1 · J1 . The b) The local power density dissipated in the strip, p(y), is given by E total power dissipation (per unit strip length), P , is thus given by: P =a
b/2
−b/2
p(y) dy =
2a(B˙ 0 )2 ρe
b/2
y 2 dy = 0
ab(bB˙ 0 )2 12ρe
(S8.2)
Equation S8.2 is valid for “reasonably” slow variation of B0 and “reasonably” resistive materials. That is, it is valid only when the induced (1st -order) magnetic induction generated by J1 is small compared to B0 . The spatially-averaged dissipation density, p˜, is P divided by the strip cross section: p˜ =
P (bB˙ 0 )2 = ab 12ρe
(2.67)
c) Under sinusoidal excitations the time-averaged total power dissipation density, < p >, is given by: ∗ < p >= 21 E1x J1x (S8.3) With E1x = jωyB0 , J1x = E1x /ρe and < p > averaged over the strip volume is: 2a(ωB0 )2 < p˜>= 2ρe (ab)
b/2
y 2 dy = 0
(b ωB0 )2 24ρe
(2.68)
Note that p˜ and < p˜ > are proportional, respectively, to (bB˙ 0 )2 and (b ωB0 )2 ; i.e., both depend not only on the square of time rate of change of magnetic induction but also on the square of conductor width.
Discussion 2.4: Lamination to Reduce Eddy-Current Loss Suppose the strip is cut into two strips, each having a total width of b/2. From Eqs. 2.67 and 2.68 both p˜ and the total power dissipation (over the two narrow strips) will be 1/4 the original values. Thus, it is possible to reduce eddy-current power dissipation to an arbitrarily small value by subdividing the strip. This lamination technique is used widely in power transformers where iron yokes are of iron sheets. Similarly, as we shall see in CHAPTERS 5 and 7, superconductors also benefit from subdivision, leading to the universal choice of multifilamentary conductors for magnets.
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
67
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 2.9: Rogowski coil A Rogowski coil is an ammeter for time-varying current. It is a toroidal magnetic pickup coil with its integrated output voltage proportional to the total current that passes through the cross sectional area encircled by the Rogowski coil. Figure 2.14a shows a Rogowski coil placed to encircle a current, I(t), to be measured. As indicated in Fig. 2.14a, a Rogowski coil is comprised of N small circular loops connected in series. The center of each loop of radius c is located radially R from the current center, which in this drawing points out of the paper. Figure 2.14b defines the x-y coordinates of one loop. a) Show that for the case in which c R, the total flux linkage, Φ(t) = N Φ1 (t), to a Rogowski coil containing N circular loops is given by: Φ(t)
μ◦ N c2 I(t) 2R
(2.69)
where Φ1 (t) is the total flux linked to one loop. b) Show that an exact expression for Φ(t) is given by: Φ(t) = μ◦ N R − R2 − c2 I(t)
(2.70)
Place one of the N loops centered on the x-y coordinates to compute Φ(t). c) Show that in the limit (c/R)4 1, Eq. 2.70 reduces to Eq. 2.69. d) Show that Φ(t) given by Eq. 2.70 is valid even if the Rogowski coil’s axis is off-center of the current axis. e) For a Rogowski coil with N = 3600; c = 3 mm; R = 0.5 m, compute the volt-seconds generated across its terminal for ΔI(t) = 1 MA.
N loops y R c I(t)
(a)
x
(b)
Fig. 2.14 (a) Rogowski coil comprised of N circular loops, each of diameter 2c, encircling a time-varying current, I(t), to be measured; (b) Crosssectional view of one loop (radius c), centered on the x-y coordinates, with the loop center located radially R from the center of the current.
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
68
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.9 a) The magnetic field Hφ (t) generated by the current I(t) is directed azimuthally relative to the current. Hφ (t) at R in the radial direction from the center of the current is given by: I(t) Hφ (t) = (S9.1) 2πR For c R, Hφ (t) given by Eq. S9.1 is nearly valid over each loop’s cross sectional area, πc2 . Because there are N such loops in a Rogowski coil, we have: μ◦ N c2 I(t) 2R The Rogowski coil output voltage, V (t), is thus given by: Φ(t)
V (t) =
dΦ(t) μ◦ N c2 dI(t) = dt 2R dt
(2.69)
(S9.2)
b) Because Hφ (t) is not really constant over each loop, the total flux enclosed by one loop, Φ1 (t), should be integrated over the area encircled by the loop. Noting that x2 +y 2 = c2 , with the loop’s center at (0,0), Φ1 (t) is given by: √c2 −y2 μ◦ I(t) c 1 Φ(t) = √ 2 2 R + y dx dy 2π −c − c −y μ◦ I(t) = π
c
−c
c2 − y 2 dy R+y
(S9.3)
Equation S9.3 may be solved in a closed form with a new variable, ξ ≡ R+y (note that dξ = dy). Thus, we have: μ◦ I(t) R+c c2 − R2 + 2Rξ − ξ 2 Φ1 (t) = dξ π ξ R−c = μ◦ R − R2 − c2 I(t) (S9.4) The total flux linked to a Rogowski coil having N loops is given by Φ(t) = N Φ1 (t): Φ(t) = μ◦ N R − R2 − c2 I(t) (2.70) c) Equation 2.70 may be expressed as: Φ(t) = μ◦ N I(t) R − R Because for x 1,
c2 1− 2 R
(S9.5)
√
1−x 1−(1/2)x+(1/8)x2 −· · ·, Eq. S9.5 may be given by:
2 4 1 c 1 c Φ(t) μ◦ N R − R 1 − 2 2 + 8 4 − · · · I(t) (S9.6) R R Φ(t)
μ◦ N c2 I(t) 2R
(2.69)
ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELDS—PROBLEMS
69
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.9 (continuation) d) Figure 2.15 shows a cross sectional view in the plane normal (x-y) to the current direction of a current/Rogowski coil set, in which the Rogowski coil is at the center (x = 0, y = 0) and the current center is off downward by distance δi . Key parameters are defined by Fig. 2.15: r, the radial distance from the Rogowski coil center (0,0) to Point A in one circular loop; θ, the angle between the y-axis and r; s, the radial distance from the current center to Point A; and is the angle formed between r and s. From geometry, s2 is given by: s2 = (r cos θ + δi )2 + r2 sin2 θ = r2 + δi2 + 2rδi cos θ
(S9.7)
Forming a right triangle (not indicated in Fig. 2.15) by extending r by a length δi cos θ, we have: r + δi cos θ cos = (S9.8) s The magnetic field HA (t) at Point A is given by HA (t) = I(t)/2πs; its normal component on the Rogowski coil loop at Point A, HA⊥ (t), is given by: I(t) I(t) r + δi cos θ HA⊥ (t) = cos = (S9.9) 2πs 2πs s Combining Eqs. S9.7 and S9.9, we obtain: r + δi cos θ I(t) HA⊥ (t) = 2π r2 + δi2 + 2rδi cos θ
(S9.10)
y
←− Point A
2c r
R θ (0. 0) δi
s
x
Current
Fig. 2.15 Cross sectional view in the plane normal (x, y) to the azimuthal (current) direction of a current/Rogowski coil set with the Rogowski coil at the center (0, 0) of the plane and the current center off downward by distance δi .
CHAPTER 2—PROBLEMS
70
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 2.9 (continuation)
To compute Φ(t), Eq. S9.10, multiplied by (N/2π)2 c2 −(r−R)2 , must be integrated twice: once with respect to θ from 0 to 2π, at constant radial distance r, toaccount for N loops, and then with respect to r, from R−c to R+c. Note that 2 c2 −(r−R)2 is the total segment distance (in the z-direction) of each loop of diameter c at r, which is located at distance r−R from the center of the loop: N I(t) R+c 2π (r + δi cos θ) c2 − (r − R)2 Φ(t) = dθ dr (S9.11a) 2π 2 R−c 0 r2 + δi2 + 2rδi cos θ N I(t) = π
R+c
0+ R−c
c2 − (r − R)2 dr r
(S9.11b)
Note that the integration remarkably eliminates δi . Now, Eq. S9.11b is integrated over the radial extent of one loop, from r = R−c to r = R+c, resulting in: Φ(t) =
N I(t) π(R − R2 − c2 ) π
(S9.11c)
Thus, a Rogowski coil measures I(t) accurately regardless of its concentricity to the current that the coil encircles. e) For N = 3600, c = 3 mm; R = 0.5 m; and ΔI = 1 MA, Eq. 2.69 is applicable because (c/R)4 = 1.3×10−9 1. Thus, from Eq. S9.2: μ◦ N c2 ΔI V (t) dt = 2R =
(4π×10−7 H/m)(3600)(3×10−3 m)2 (1×106 A) 2(0.5 m)
41 mV s In a noisy environment such as the one typical in an experimental fusion machine, a signal level of 40-mV s is not easy, but not overwhelmingly difficult, to detect.
“ . . .as we know, there are known knowns; these are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns— the ones we don’t know we don’t know.” —Donald Rumsfeld (2002)
“ . . .the answer, my friend, is blowin’ in the wind, . . .” —Bob Dylan (1962)
CHAPTER 3 MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES 3.1 Introduction In this chapter we study key topics related to magnets, fields, and forces. Magnets treated include: 1) solenoids, single and multiple, e.g., comprised of nested coils; 2) Helmholtz coils and high-homogeneity magnets; 3) ideal dipoles; 4) ideal quadrupoles; 5) racetracks; and 6) ideal toroids. Two important solenoidal magnets for the generation of high magnetic fields, “Bitter” and “hybrid,” are also discussed. Other issues such as “load lines,” minimum volume magnets, superposition techniques, not included in the 1st Edition, are discussed in the PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS that follow this introductory section. At the present time, field and force computations are generally performed with computer codes that for a given magnet configuration give accurate numerical solutions at any location. These codes can also compute the self and mutual inductances of coils comprising the magnet and Lorentz forces acting on the coils [3.1]. Analytical expressions derived in this chapter give field values only at specialized locations such as the magnet center; however, they illustrate subtle relationships among fields, forces, and magnet parameters. In this introductory section, we first study the law of Biot-Savart that is basic to computation of a magnetic field generated by a current-carrying element in the absence of magnetic materials. Also presented in this section are rather extensive treatments of: 1) field analysis; 2) axial forces for “rings” and “thin” solenoids; 3) stresses and strains in solenoids; and 4) self and mutual inductances.
3.2 Law of Biot-Savart produced at point P by a differential current The differential magnetic field dH element I ds located at point O, a distance r away from P , is given by: = (I ds × r ) dH (3.1) 4πr3 Equation 3.1 is known as the law of Biot-Savart (also known as 1st Law of Laplace). at any location decreases inversely as the It indicates that the magnitude of dH ∝ 1/r2 . At a square of the distance from the differential current element: |dH| varies as sin θ, where θ is the angle between the s and r vectors. fixed radius, |dH| We apply Eq. 3.1 to derive an expression for the field along the axis (z) of a loop of radius a located at z = 0 and carrying current I, as illustrated in Fig. 3.1. The loop’s axis defines the z axis; θ, measured from the z = 0 plane, is defined in Fig. 3.1; ϕ (not indicated in the figure) is measured in the azimuthal direction. Hr , at each axial (z) location As seen from Fig. 3.1, the r-component of H, cos θ. For this particular case, cancels, leaving only the z-component, dHz = |dH| the (I ds × r ) term in Eq. 3.1 simplifies to (I ds × r )z = Iar cos θ dϕ, leading to: 2π Iar cos θ Ia cos θ Hz = dϕ = (3.2) 3 4πr 2r2 0 Y. Iwasa, Case Studies in Superconducting Magnets: Design and Operational Issues, DOI: 10.1007/b112047_3, © Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2009
71
CHAPTER 3
72 z H
H Hz Hr
r θ
× z=0
ρ a Fig. 3.1
Loop of radius a carrying current I.
With cos θ = a/r and r2 = a2 +z 2 , Hz (z, ρ) on the z-axis (ρ = 0), Hz (z, 0), becomes: a2 I a2 I Hz (z, 0) = 3 = (3.3a) 2r 2(a2 + z 2 )3/2 In terms of the center (z = 0, ρ = 0) field, Hz (0, 0), Hz (z, 0) may be given by: Hz (0, 0) Hz (z, 0) = (3.3b) [1 + (z/a)2 ]3/2 Equation 3.3a may be used to derive an expression for the field along the axis of a solenoid of arbitrary winding cross section having any current distribution that is invariant in the ϕ-direction. PROBLEM 3.1 and DISCUSSION 3.1 are good examples. From Eq. 3.3b, we note that for z a or far from the center, the axial field of a “ring” coil decreases as 1/(z/a)3 —this is further studied in PROBLEM 3.11.
3.3 Lorentz Force and Magnetic Pressure an electric charge q in motion with In the presence of magnetic induction B, For a velocity v experiences a force FL , called the Lorentz force: FL = qv × B. the Lorentz conductor element carrying current density J in the presence of B, force density, fL , is given by: (3.4) fL = J × B Equation 3.4 is the basic expression for magnetic forces and stresses in magnets. As stated at the beginning of CHAPTER 1, whether superconducting and operating at a temperature in the range 1.8–80 K, or resistive and operating at room temperature, magnets producing the same field must deal with essentially the same stress level. A magnet’s ultimate field is limited by the strength of its structural elements, including the current-carrying conductor. Thus, a 50-T superconducting magnet—if it ever becomes feasible—and a 50-T resistive magnet must both withstand tremendous Lorentz stresses. As illustrated below, a 50-T magnetic induction corresponds to an equivalent magnetic pressure of ∼1 GPa (10,000 atm). Consider an infinitely long, “thin-walled” solenoid (thickness δ) of average diameter 2a carrying a uniformly distributed current, which for the sake of computation is lumped into a surface current density Kθ [A/m]. The Bz -component of magnetic induction at (0,0) is given by integration of Eq. 3.3a with respect to z:
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
Bz =
μ◦ a2 Kθ 2
∞
−∞
(a2
73 dz = μ◦ Kθ ≡ B◦ + z 2 )3/2
(3.5)
The integration is taken over the entire range of z because the current “rings” extend from z = −∞ to z = ∞. The application of Ampere’s law gives that, outside the solenoid (r > a) is zero and that for this infinitely long solenoid, B within the solenoid bore (r < a) is B◦ , uniform in both z- and r-directions. (From symmetry of the current distribution, the field is also independent of θ. Also note that Eq. 3.3a is valid only for such cases.) That is, the magnetic induction within the bore of an infinitely long solenoid is completely uniform and directed only in the z-direction. A more detailed discussion of axial field analysis is given next. The Bz field just inside the winding is B◦ and that just outside the winding is zero, decreasing linearly with r over the winding thickness δ. The average induction, ˜z , to which the current element in the winding is exposed, is thus B◦ /2, resulting B in an r-directed average Lorentz force density fLrır acting on the winding: fLrır =
Kθ ˜ Kθ B◦ Bzır = ır δ 2δ
(3.6)
An r-directed Lorentz force, FLrır acting on the winding volume element, defined in Fig. 3.2, is equivalent to a magnetic pressure, pmır , acting on the winding surface element, also defined in Fig. 3.2. Thus: FLrır = fLr [(aΔθ)δΔz]ır = pm [(aΔθ)Δz]ır
(3.7)
Combining Eqs. 3.5–3.7 and solving for pm , we obtain: pm =
B◦2 2μ◦
(3.8)
That is, the magnetic pressure is equal to the magnetic energy density. For B◦ equal to 1 T, Eq. 3.8 gives a magnetic pressure of 3.98×105 Pa or ∼4 atm, from which it follows that for B◦ = 50 T, a magnetic pressure of ∼1 GPa is reached.
a Δθ fLr
pm
δ Fig. 3.2 Axial view of a differential element for a “thin-walled” solenoid (thickness δ) of average diameter 2a. The element is Δz high in the z-direction (out of the paper).
CHAPTER 3
74
3.4 Field Analysis of Solenoidal Coil Here, we derive closed-form field expressions useful for analyzing high spatial-fieldhomogeneity MRI and NMR solenoidal magnets. Also derived are expressions for simple (“long” and “thin”) coils; these expressions may be used to “get a feel” for the field homogeneity of a solenoidal coil during the early design stage. Figure 3.3 shows a cross sectional view of a solenoidal coil of winding i.d., o.d., length (width), respectively, of 2a1 , 2a2 , and 2b. Field lines are drawn to indicate that the magnetic field generated by the coil is chiefly axial in the coil bore, diverging, except along the coil’s axis and at the axial midplane, to the radial direction, particularly outside the bore. Two dimensionless parameters used in field analysis of a solenoidal coil are: α ≡ 2a2 /2a1 = a2 /a1 and β ≡ 2b/2a1 = b/a1 , respectively, the winding o.d. and length, normalized to the winding i.d. In spherical coordinates (r, θ, ϕ) as indicated in Fig. 3.4, where θ is polar angle and ϕ is azimuthal angle, the magnetic field in the z-direction, Hz (r, θ, ϕ), in any source-free space generated by any system of currents and/or magnetized material may be expressed by: Hz (r, θ, ϕ) =
n ∞
m rn (n + m + 1)Pnm (u)(Am n cos mϕ + Bn sin mϕ)
(3.9)
n=0 m=0
As discussed in CHAPTER 2, Pnm (u) is the set of Legendre polynomials (for m = 0) and associated Legendre functions (for m > 0) with u = cos θ. m 0 0 Am n and Bn are constants. Typically all but A0 and B0 are to be minimized, m because they contribute to field nonuniformity. Am n and Bn may be minimized by adjusting the parameters of each coil in the magnet. These parameters, for each coil, may include winding i.d. (2a1 ), winding o.d. (2a2 ), winding length (2b), coil midplane location relative to the magnet center, and “overall”current density. As will become clear shortly here, all parameters related to spatial field distribution are functions only of α and β, the two dimensionless parameters defined above.
2a2 2a1
2b
Fig. 3.3 Cross sectional view of a solenoidal coil of winding i.d., o.d., and length (width), respectively, of 2a1 , 2a2 , and 2b. Field lines are drawn to indicate that the magnetic field generated by the coil is chiefly axial in the coil bore, diverging, except along the axial midplane, to the radial direction outside the bore.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
75 z
θ
r y
ϕ x Fig. 3.4
Spherical coordinates.
For solenoidal systems for which all current densities are invariant in ϕ, i.e., symmetric with respect to the axis, only the m = 0 terms remain. Along the z-axis (r = z, θ = 0), we may simplify Eq. 3.9 for Hz (z) to: Hz (z) =
∞
z n (n + 1)A0n
(3.10a)
n=0
Along the x- (or y-) axis (x, θ = 90◦ ), at midplane, Eq. 3.9 for solenoids becomes: Hz (x) =
∞ n
xn (n + m + 1)Pnm (0)Am n
(3.10b)
n=0 m=0
Equation 3.10a has no Legendre functions because Pn0 (1) = Pn (1) = 1. For Eq. 3.10b note that Pnm (0) = 0 when n is even and m is odd. Table 2.3 in CHAPTER 2 gives values of Pnm (0) for even numbers of m up to m = 10. Using values of Pnm (0) for n and m = 0, 2, and 4, we may express Hz (z) and Hz (x) in Cartesian coordinates: Hz (z) = A00 + 3A02 z 2 + 5A04 z 4 + · · ·
(3.11a)
0 Hz (x) = A00 − ( 23 A02 − 15A22 )x2 + ( 15 8 A4 −
105 2 2 A4
+ 945A44 )x4 + · · ·
(3.11b)
A00 is the field at the magnet center (0,0,0): A00 ≡ H0 . For an “ideal” solenoidal coil, coefficients are zero for m > 0: Am n = 0 for m > 0. Coefficients for n > 0, m = 0, 0 An , are functions of coil parameters—specifically, α and β. Introducing hz (ζ) ≡ Hz (z)/H0 , where ζ ≡ z/a1 , and hz (ξ) ≡ Hz (x)/H0 , where ξ ≡ x/a1 , we obtain: hz (ζ) = 1 + E2 (α, β)ζ 2 + E4 (α, β)ζ 4 + E6 (α, β)ζ 6 + E8 (α, β)ζ 8 + E10 (α, β)ζ 10 + · · ·
(3.12a)
hz (ξ) = 1 − 21 E2 (α, β)ξ 2 + 83 E4 (α, β)ξ 4 −
6 5 16 E6 (α, β)ξ
+
8 35 128 E8 (α, β)ξ
−
10 63 256 E10 (α, β)ξ
+ ···
(3.12b)
CHAPTER 3
76
Note that the ξ 2 term coefficient is only half (and of opposite sign) of the ζ 2 coefficient, and the ξ 4 term is 3/8 of the ζ 4 term and of the same sign. Indeed, every coefficient in the plane direction is numerically smaller than that in the zdirection, so that field inhomogeneity tends to be smaller in the x- and y-directions than that in the z-direction. The center field H0 (≡ A00 ) is given by:
H0 = λJa1 F (α, β) = λJa1 β ln From Eq. 3.13a, we note that: F (α, β) = β ln
α2 +β 2 1+ 1+β 2
α+
α2 +β 2 1+ 1+β 2
α+
(3.13a)
(3.13b)
F (α, β) is the “field factor” for a uniform-current-density coil [3.2]. Derivation of Eq. 3.13 is left to PROBLEM 3.1. Expressions of En (α, β) in Eq. 3.12 for n = 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 are given below as the product of F (α, β) and En (α, β) [3.3]. 1 1 α3 F (α, β)E2 (α, β) = − (3.14a) 2β (1+β 2 )1.5 (α2 +β 2 )1.5 F (α, β)E4 (α, β) =
2+7β 2 +20β 4 2α7 +7α5 β 2 +20α3 β 4 1 − 24β 3 (1+β 2 )3.5 (α2 +β 2 )3.5
Equation 3.14b1 may be given more concisely as: 4 r=α r3 2r +7r2 β 2 +20β 4 F (α, β)E4 (α, β) = − 24β 3 (r2 +β 2 )3.5 r=1
(3.14b1)
(3.14b2)
This concise format is used below for terms of the 6th , 8th , and 10th order: 8 r=α 8r +44r6 β 2 +99r4 β 4 +28r2 β 6 +280β 8 r3 F (α, β)E6 (α, β) = − 240β 5 (r2 +β 2 )5.5 r=1 (3.14c) ⎤ r=α 16r12 +120r10 β 2 +390r8 β 4 +715r6 β 6 r3 ⎣ +1080r4 β 8 −1008r2 β 10 +1344β 12 ⎦ F (α, β)E8 (α, β) = − 896β 7 (r2 +β 2 )7.5 r=1
⎡
(3.14d) F (α, β)E10 (α, β) = ⎤ r=α ⎡ 128r16 +1216r14 β 2 +5168r12 β 4 +12920r10 β 6 +20995r8 β 8 r3 ⎣ +19976r6 β 10 +49632r4 β 12 −46464r2 β 14 +21120β 16 ⎦ − 11520β 9 (r2 +β 2 )9.5 r=1 (3.14e)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
77
F (α, β)En (α, β) is a recurrence formula; the nth term may be derived from: 1 ∂ F (α, β)En (α, β) = F (α = 1, β)En−1 (α = 1, β) − F (α, β)En−1 (α, β) n ∂β (3.15a) F (α, β)En (α, β) may also be expressed as: 1 fn (α = 1, β) α3 fn (α, β) F (α, β)En (α, β) = − 2 Mn β n−1 (1+β 2 )n−0.5 (α +β 2 )n−0.5
(3.15b)
where Mn is a constant. From Eqs. 3.14a, 3.14b1, and 3.15b, for example, we find: f2 (α, β) = 1 and M2 = 2; and f4 (α, β) = 2α4 +7α2 β 2 +20β 4 and M4 = 24. Values of Mn and expressions of fn (α, β) for n = 2, 3, 4, . . . , 18, 19, and 20 are given in APPENDIX IB. In PROBLEM 3.4, fn (α, β)s for even numbers of n up to 20 are used to solve a field problem. Henceforth we consider only the z-axis, because, as discussed above (Eqs. 3.12a and 3.12b), field inhomogeneity of Hz (z), though not always (as in some nestedcoil magnets), is greater than those in the plane normal to the z-axis, i.e., Hz (x) and Hz (y). From Eq. 3.12a, we obtain: ∂ 2 hz (ζ) = [2E2 (α, β) + (4)(3)E4 (α, β)ζ 2 + · · ·] ∂ζ 2 =
∞
(2n)(2n−1)E2n (α, β)ζ 2(n−1)
(3.16a)
n=1
In general: ∞ ∂ 2k hz (ζ) = (2n)(2n−1)(· · ·)(2n−2k+1)E2n (α, β)ζ 2(n−k) ∂ζ 2k
(3.16b)
n=k
At the origin, ζ = 0, Eqs. 3.16a and 3.16b reduce to simpler expressions because only the first term is nonzero. Thus: ∂ 2 hz (ζ) = 2E2 (α, β) (3.17a) ∂ζ 2 0 ∂ 2k hz (ζ) = (2k)! E2k (α, β) (3.17b) ∂ζ 2k 0 Nested-Coil Magnet For a magnet comprised of nested (coaxial and concentric) coils, each of λJ, a1 , α, β, Eq. 3.12a, given only up to the ζ 2 term, is generalized: j=1 (λJ)j a1j F (αj , βj )E2 (αj , βj ) 2 hz (ζ) = 1 + ζ + ··· (3.18) j=1 (λJ)j a1j F (αj , βj ) Before discussing in 3.4.2 errors arising in a two-coil nested magnet, we shall first consider a few special cases for single solenoidal coils.
CHAPTER 3
78 3.4.1 Simple Coils
Here, we derive for “simple” coils expressions of En (α, β), and hence hz (ζ), up to the 10th order. Each expression of hz (ζ) should give the designer, without relying on a field analysis specialist, a “feel” for how the field homogeneity of the coil under consideration is affected by its geometric shape, i.e., α and β. “Short” Coil For a short coil (β → 0), such as a pancake, F (α, β) may be simplified as: F (α, β → 0) = β ln α
(3.19)
Although extremely tedious, expressions for E2 (α, 0), . . . , E10 (α, 0) may be derived from Eq. 3.14. In the limit β → 0, the denominator of each term in fn (α, β), e.g., (1+β 2 )n−0.5 , may be expanded in a power series of β 2k up to the β n term, where the integer k runs from 1 to n/2. 1 β4 = 1−(n−0.5)β 2 +(n−0.5)(n+0.5) 2 n−0.5 (1+β ) 2! −(n−0.5)(n+0.5)(n+1.5)
β6 + ··· 3!
(−1)k (n−0.5)(n+0.5)(n+1.5) · · · (n+k−1.5)
β 2k k!
(3.20)
In the limit of β → 0, the terms higher than β n in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.20 become negligible compared with β n . Also, remarkably, all the terms below β n cancel out, leaving only the β n term in the numerator within the brackets of the right-hand side of Eq. 3.14 with a numerical coefficient, e.g., −3/4 for n = 2. En (α, 0) terms, derivable from Eqs. 3.14 and 3.19, may be given by: E2 (α, 0) = − E4 (α, 0) =
3·5 (α4 − 1) 15(α4 − 1) · = 25 α4 ln α 32α4 ln α
E6 (α, 0) = − E8 (α, 0) =
3 (α2 − 1) 3(α2 − 1) · = − 22 α2 ln α 4α2 ln α
5·7 (α6 − 1) 35(α6 − 1) · = − 25 ·3 α6 ln α 96α6 ln α
5·7·9 (α8 − 1) 315(α8 − 1) · = 210 α8 ln α 1024α8 ln α
E10 (α, 0) = −
7·9·11 (α10 − 1) 693(α10 − 1) · = − 29 ·5 α10 ln α 2560α10 ln α
(3.21a) (3.21b) (3.21c) (3.21d) (3.21e)
Thus, Eq. 3.12a becomes: hz (ζ) = 1 − +
3(α2 −1) 2 15(α4 −1) 4 35(α6 −1) 6 ζ + ζ − ζ 4α2 ln α 32α4 ln α 96α6 ln α 315(α8 −1) 8 693(α10 −1) 10 ζ − ζ + ··· 1024α8 ln α 2560α10 ln α
(3.22)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
79
“Thin-Walled” Coil For a “thin-walled” coil (α = 1), F (α, β) becomes: lim F (α, β) = β 1 + β2
α→1
β(α − 1) = 1 + β2
(3.23a) (3.23b)
Combining Eqs. 3.14 and 3.23, we may obtain expressions for En (1, β): E2 (1, β) = − E4 (1, β) =
5(3−4β 2 ) 23 (1+β 2 )4
E6 (1, β) = − E8 (1, β) =
3 2(1+β 2 )2
7(5−20β 2 +8β 4 ) 24 (1+β 2 )6
9(35−280β 2 +336β 4 −64β 6 ) 27 (1+β 2 )8
E10 (1, β) = −
11(63−840β 2 +2016β 4 −1152β 6 +128β 8 ) 28 (1+β 2 )10
(3.24a) (3.24b) (3.24c) (3.24d) (3.24e)
Thus for a “thin-walled” coil (α = 1, β), we have: hz (ζ) = 1 −
3 5(3−4β 2 ) 4 7(5−20β 2 +8β 4 ) 6 2 ζ + ζ − ζ 2(1+β 2 )2 8(1+β 2 )4 16(1+β 2 )6
+
9(35−280β 2 +336β 4 −64β 6 ) 8 ζ 128(1+β 2 )8
−
11(63−840β 2 +2016β 4 −1152β 6 +128β 8 ) 10 ζ 256(1+β 2 )10
(3.25)
“Thin-Walled & Long” Coil For a “thin-walled & long” coil (α = 1 and β → ∞), Eq. 3.25 simplifies to: hz (ζ) = 1 −
1.5 2 2.5 4 3.5 6 4.5 8 5.5 10 n+1 ζ − 6 ζ − 8 ζ − 10 ζ − 12 ζ − · · · − n+2 ζ n (3.26) 4 β β β β β 2β
As may be inferred from Eq. 3.26, note that in the limiting case of β → ∞, En (1, β) = −(n+1)/2β (n+2) . As expected, homogeneity improves with coil length.
CHAPTER 3
80
“Ring” Coil For a “ring” coil (α = 1, β = 0), En (α, β) is derivable from Eq. 3.21 in the limit of α = 1, or from Eq. 3.25 in the limit β = 0. In Eq. 3.21, αn −1 =n α→1 αn ln α lim
(3.27)
Thus, we may derive the same expressions by combining Eqs. 3.21 and 3.27 or simply inserting β = 0 in each expression of Eq. 3.24. Either way, we obtain: E2 (1, 0) = − E4 (1, 0) =
(3.28a)
3·5 3·5 = = 1.875 23 2·4
E6 (1, 0) = − E8 (1, 0) =
3 = −1.5 2
(3.28b)
5·7 3·5·7 =− −2.188 4 2 2·4·6
(3.28c)
5·7·9 3·5·7·9 = 2.461 7 2 2·4·6·8
E10 (1, 0) = −
(3.28d)
7·9·11 3·5·7·9·11 =− −2.707 8 2 2·4·6·8·10
(3.28e)
Thus, for a “ring” coil, hz (ζ) is given by: hz (ζ) = 1 − 23 ζ 2 +
15 4 8 ζ
−
35 6 16 ζ
+
315 8 128 ζ
−
693 10 256 ζ
+ ···
(3.29)
Values of E12 (1, 0), E14 (1, 0), E16 (1, 0), E18 (1, 0), and E20 (1, 0) are given, respectively, by Eqs. 3.124a, 3.124b, 3.124c, 3.124d, and 3.124e in PROBLEM 3.4 (p. 140).
Stronger Magnets (Part 1 of 2 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist [3.4] The strength of a magnetic field may be expressed in a unit called a gauss, which, like many quantities in physics, is named after a distinguished scientist. Karl Friedrich Gauss, 1777–1855, who devoted himself particularly to mathematics, astronomy, and magnetism, gave his name to this one. For an idea of what this unit means, we might say that a rather weak magnetic field—for example, that existing at the surface of the earth—is somewhat less than a gauss. The field between the poles of little toy horseshoe magnets may be as high as hundreds of gauss, or in really strong ones, such as are used in commercial apparatus, a thousand gauss or so. Between the pole pieces of a big electromagnet, like the one I used for my thesis, one might make fields of the order of 20,000 to 30,000 gauss. Fields somewhat higher than this can be produced by an iron electromagnet, but they are not very useful because they are confined to the very small volumes between the pointed pole pieces of the magnet.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
81
3.4.2 Harmonic Errors—In a Nested Two-Coil Magnet Equations 3.12a and 3.12b indicate that both hz (ζ) and hz (ξ), where hz ≡ Hz /H0 , ζ ≡ z/a1 , and ξ ≡ x/a1 , vary only as even-numbered powers of either ζ or ξ. That is, both equations express the spatial variations of the axial field for an “ideal” solenoid or an “ideal” nested set of such solenoids. Here the word “ideal” implies spatial symmetry, uniformity, and invariance in the current density. Even for a single solenoid, reality is quite different: imperfections in the coil form; conductor dimensions and shape; placement of conductor, for example, result in terms other than those even-numbered. If a magnet consists of nested coils, the number of imperfections multiplies, and many “unwanted” terms will arise. Below, we illustrate the origin of harmonic errors with a two-coil nested magnet. Consider a two-coil nested magnet of solenoidal Coil 1 of [2a1 ]1 , α1 , β1 , and [λJ]1 in the bore of solenoidal Coil 2 of [2a1 ]2 , α2 , β2 , and [λJ]2 . If the two coils are aligned axially and radially, then Hz (z) = [Hz (z)]1 + [Hz (z)]2
(3.30)
where [Hz (z)]1 and [Hz (z)]2 may be given, from Eq. 3.11a: [Hz (z)]1 = [A00 ]1 + 3[A02 ]1 z 2 + 5[A04 ]1 z 4 + · · ·
(3.31a)
[Hz (z)]2 = [A00 ]2 + 3[A02 ]2 z 2 + 5[A04 ]2 z 4 + · · ·
(3.31b)
Note that the total axial field at the center: Hz (0) = [A00 ]1 + [A00 ]2 ≡ H0 . Coils Misaligned Axially If Coils 1 and 2 are radially aligned, i.e., coaxial, but their midplanes are misaligned and are, respectively, at z = 0 and z = δz , then Hz (z) of Eq. 3.31 becomes: Hz (z) = H0 +3{[A02 ]1 z 2 +[A02 ]2 (z−δz )2 }+5{[A04 ]1 z 4 +[A04 ]2 (z−δz )4 }+· · · (3.32a) Expansion of the power terms in Eq. 3.32a results in: Hz (z) = {H0 + 3[A02 ]2 δz2 + 5[A04 ]2 δz4 + · · ·} − {6[A02 ]2 δz + 20[A04 ]2 δz3 + · · ·}z + {3[A02 ]1 + 3[A02 ]2 + 30[A04 ]2 δz2 + · · ·}z 2 − {20[A04 ]2 δz + · · ·}z 3 + {5[A04 ]1 + 5[A04 ]2 · · ·}z 4
(3.32b)
As may be observed from Eq. 3.32b an axial misalignment of Coils 1 and 2 by δz not only perturbs the coefficient of each even-numbered z-term but, more importantly, gives rise to odd-numbered z-terms which make Hz (z) axially asymmetric.
82
CHAPTER 3
In a real NMR magnet consisting of many nested coils an axial misalignment is inevitable. The z-term, for example, either results in the broadening of the NMR spectral lines or creates “dips” at each peak in the spectrum. The z 3 -term also broadens the spectrum, chiefly at frequencies away from the central frequency. Axial Shim Coils These unwanted terms are minimized by “shim” coils that are added to the superconducting magnet, located outside of its “correction” coils; further shimming is achieved by room-temperature shim coils located in the radial gap between the probe and the cryostat room-temperature bore. A shim coil that minimizes an even-numbered z-term is essentially a “Helmholtz” coil, the basic principle of which is studied in PROBLEM 3.3; a shim coil that minimizes an odd-numbered z-term is also of Helmholtz type but with one of its coils of opposite polarity, to generate an axially antisymmetric field. Coils Misaligned Radially To study the spatial variation of a two-coil nested magnet misaligned radially, we first express Hz (x, y, z) of a single solenoid in Cartesian coordinates. From Eq. 3.11 and Table 2.4 for Legendre functions of n = 0, n = 2, and n = 4, we have: Hz (x, y, z) = A00 + 3A02 z 2 − 21 (x2 + y 2 ) + 5A04 z 4 − 3(x2 + y 2 ) z 2 − 81 (x2 + y 2 ) (3.33a) When Coil 2 is misaligned radially with respect to Coil 1, in the x-direction by δx and in the y-direction by δy , we substitute x−δx for x and y−δy for y in Eq. 3.33a: Hz (x, y, z) = H0 +3 [A02 ]1 [z 2 − 21 (x2 +y 2 )]+[A02 ]2 z 2 − 21 [(x−δx )2 +(y−δy )2 ] +5[A04 ]1 z 4 −3(x2 +y 2 )[z 2 − 81 (x2 +y 2 )] +[A04 ]2 z 4 −3 (x−δx )2 + (y−δy )2 z 2 − 81 (x−δx )2 +(y−δy )2 (3.33b) Expansion of Eq. 3.33b results in many terms, including x, x2 , x3 , x4 , y, y 2 , y 3 , y 4 , xy, xy 2 , x2 +y 2 , (x2 +y 2 )2 , z 2 , z 2 x, z 2 y, and z 2 (x2 +y 2 ). An x-shim coil consists often of a pair of flat (one or a few conductors thick), rectangular-shaped coils, “saddled” to conform to the magnet’s outer cylindrical surface, with the axis along the ϕ = 0 (x) direction. It generates a z-directed field that increases with x, being zero at the z-axis (x = 0). Similarly, y-shim and xy-shim coil pairs are placed, respectively, along the ϕ = 90◦ (y) and ϕ = 45◦ axes. Each coil generates a z-directed field that increases away from the z-axis. Coils Misaligned Axially & Radially When nested coils are misaligned both axially and radially—an inevitable consequence in a real NMR— xz, yz, xyz, and many more error harmonics can result.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
83
3.5 Axial Forces We present here useful analytical expressions for axial forces, Fz , among coaxially aligned “ring” coils and “thin-walled” solenoids, all derived from the original expressions given by Garrett [3.5]. Approximate expressions for limiting cases, e.g., coils far apart, are useful to make quick numerical checks; others may be used as the building blocks to create one’s own computer code. In all cases, current flows in the same direction; reversing either current reverses the force. 3.5.1 Axial Force between Two “Ring” Coils Figure 3.5 shows two “ring” coils (α = 1, β = 0) coaxially (ız ) separated by a distance ρ. Coils A and B are, respectively, of diameters 2aA and 2aB and total ampere turns of NA IA and NB IB . The axial (ız ) field generated by each coil points in the same direction. The axial force, FzA (ρ) on Coil A due to Coil B is given by: ρ (aA + aB )2 + ρ2 μ◦ FzA (ρ) = (NA IA )(NB IB ) 2 (aA − aB )2 + ρ2 × k 2 K(k) + (k 2 − 2)[K(k) − E(k)] (3.34) FzA (ρ) is +z-directed or towards Coil B; i.e., FzA (ρ) is attractive. If the two currents flow in opposite directions, the sign changes to minus, and FzA (ρ) becomes repulsive. In Eq. 3.34, K(k) and E(k) are the complete elliptic integrals, respectively, of the first and second kinds, defined below. K(k) = 0
π/2
dθ 1 − k 2 sin2 θ
(3.35a)
π/2
1 − k 2 sin2 θ dθ
E(k) =
(3.35b)
0
The modulus, k, of the elliptic integrals for this system is given by: k2 =
4aA aB (aA + aB )2 + ρ2
2aA
2aB
(3.36)
z
ρ
Fig. 3.5
“Ring” coils A and B coaxially aligned and separated by a distance ρ.
CHAPTER 3
84
Table 3.1: Complete Elliptic Integrals of the First and Second Kinds: K(k) and E(k) for Selected Values of k 2 and k k2
k
K(k)
E(k)
k2
k
K(k)
E(k)
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
0 0.3162 0.4472 0.5477 0.6325 0.7071 0.7746
π/2 1.6124 1.6596 1.7139 1.7775 1.8541 1.9496
π/2 1.5308 1.4890 1.4454 1.3994 1.3506 1.2984
0.7 0.8 0.90 0.95 0.98 0.99 1
0.8367 0.8944 0.9487 0.9747 0.9899 0.9950 1
2.0754 2.2572 2.5781 2.9083 3.3541 3.6956 ∞
1.2417 1.1785 1.1048 1.0605 1.0286 1.0160 1
Table 3.1 gives K(k) and E(k) for selected values of k 2 and k. Note that K(0) = E(0) = π/2; also obvious are K(1) = ∞ and E(1) = 1, i.e., K(k) increases with k, whereas E(k) decreases with k. For example, if k 2 = 0.5, K(k = 0.7071) = 1.8541. K(k) and E(k) may be expressed by power series in k2 : 2 2 2 2 1 2 π 1·3 4 1·3·5 6 1·3·5·7 8 K(k) = 1+ k + k + k + k +· · · 2 2 2·4 2·4·6 2·4·6·8
(3.37a)
2 2 4 2 2 1·3 k π 1 2 1·3·5 k 6 1·3·5·7 k 8 E(k) = 1− k − − − −· · · 2 2 2·4 3 2·4·6 5 2·4·6·8 7
(3.37b)
For k 2 1, the two integrals and their difference may be approximated by: π 9 4 25 6 1225 8 1 + 41 k 2 + 64 k + 256 k + 16384 k 2 π 3 4 5 175 E(k) 1 − 41 k 2 − 64 k − 256 k 6 − 16384 k8 2 π 2 3 4 15 6 175 8 K(k) − E(k) k + 8 k + 64 k + 1024 k 4
K(k)
(3.38a) (3.38b) (3.38c)
Stronger Magnets (Part 2 of 2 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist The reason for this limitation is not hard to find. An electromagnet consists of an iron core surrounded by coils of wire. The current in the wire magnetizes the iron and the magnetized iron produces a field at the gap between the poles. In the last chapter we discussed magnetic saturation—the condition achieved when all the little ferromagnetic domains are pointing in the same direction. In iron at room temperature this is in the vicinity of 20,000 gauss, and it is roughly the maximum field that you can produce with iron core magnets. The slight increase to 30,000 gauss or so is due to an effect that we already have mentioned. There is a tendency for a magnetic field to be concentrated near corners or points. By having pointed pole pieces rather than flat ones larger fields may be obtained. (See PROBLEM 2.7).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
85
Special Case 1: Two Ring Coils Far Apart When two ring coils are far apart, i.e., ρ2 (aA +aB )2 , then k 2 1 and approximations of Eqs. 3.38a and 3.38c may be used to simplify Eq. 3.34. Equation 3.34 may first be simplified to: μ◦ (3.39a) (NA IA )(NB IB ) k 2 K(k) + (k 2 − 2)[K(k) − E(k)] FzA (ρ) 2 Now, in applying Eqs. 3.38a and 3.38c, although k 2 1, we must include terms up to k 4 when expanding the K(k)−E(k) term because it is multiplied not only by k 2 but also by −2. μ◦ FzA (ρ) (NA IA )(NB IB ) 2 π π 2 π 2 3π 4 × k2 + k + (k 2 − 2) k + k 2 8 4 32 3π 4 μ◦ (NA IA )(NB IB ) k (3.39b) 2 16 In the second approximation step, the k 6 term is neglected. Finally, we have a simple expression in the limit ρ2 (aA +aB )2 : 2 3μ◦ πaA2 NA IA πaB NB IB FzA (ρ) = (3.39c) 2π ρ2 ρ2 Equation 3.39c states that this axial force is proportional to the product of two “magnetic moments,” i.e., πaA2 NA IA and πaB2 NB IB , each reduced by ρ2 . In Discussion 3.17 (p. 213), Eq. 3.39c is derived from an expression of mutual inductance. Special Case 2: Two Adjacent Ring Coils of the Same Diameter When two ring coils have the same diameter aA = aB = a and are very close to each other, i.e., ρ 2a, hence k 2 → 1 and K(k) → ∞ and E(k) → 1, then Eq. 3.34 may be transformed to an expression much simpler than Eq. 3.34: a (3.39d) FzA (ρ) μ◦ (NA IA )(NB IB ) ρ We may derive Eq. 3.39d as the product of Ring A circumference (2πa), Ring A total current (NA IA ), and the radial field (Br ) on Ring A, generated by Ring B axially ρ from Ring A, given approximately by μ◦ NB IB /(2πρ) for ρ a—note that two rings ρ a apart may be modeled as two straight lines ρ apart. Thus: μ◦ NB IB FzA (ρ) (2πa)×(NA IA )× 2πρ a = μ◦ (NA IA )(NB IB ) (3.39d) ρ TRIVIA 3.1 A legend has it that one of the mathematicians below advanced his argument for the existence of God by using an irrelevant algebraic equation: “Sir, (a+b)n/n = x; hence God exists, answer please!” Who (and to whom)? i) Euler;
ii) Gauss;
iii) Laplace;
iv) Legendre.
CHAPTER 3
86 3.5.2 Axial Force Within a “Thin-Walled” Solenoid
Consider a thin-walled (α = 1) solenoid of 2a diameter and 2b length with a uniform surface current density of N I/2b with its midplane at z = 0. For this solenoid the axial force at a location z ≥ 0 from the midplane, Fz (z), may be given by: 2 μ◦ N I Fz (z) = − (b − z) 4a2 + (b − z)2 K(kb− ) − E(kb− ) 2 2b + (b + z) 4a2 + (b + z)2 K(kb+ ) − E(kb+ ) − 2b 4a2 + 4b2 K(k2b ) − E(k2b ) (3.40) The elliptic integral moduli, kb− , kb+ , and k2b , are given by: kb2− =
4a2 ; 4a2 + (b − z)2
kb2+ =
4a2 ; 4a2 + (b + z)2
2 k2b =
4a2 4a2 + 4b2
Special Case 3: End Force At z = b, because kb+ = k2b , we have, from Eq. 3.40, Fz (b) = 0. That is, as expected, the axial force at each end of an isolated solenoid is zero. Special Case 4: Midplane Force By inserting z = 0 into Eq. 3.40, we obtain an expression for the axial force at the midplane (z = 0), Fz (0). 2 μ◦ N I 2 2 Fz (0) = − 2b 4a +b [K(kb )−E(kb )] 2 2b −2b 4a2 +4b2 K(k2b )−E(k2b ) (3.41a) where the modulus k2b is the same as given above and kb is given by: 4a2 kb2 = 2 4a + b2 The axial compressive force at z in an isolated solenoid increases from 0 at z = b to the maximum at the midplane, Fz (0), given by Eq. 3.41a. Special Case 5: Midplane Force for a “Long” Thin-Walled Solenoid For a “long” (β 1 or k 2 1) thin-walled solenoid, Eq. 3.41a, with the approximation of Eq. 3.38c, reduces to a simple expression for Fz (0). 2 μ◦ N I Fz (0) − πa2 (3.41b) 2 2b Equation 3.41b states that Fz (0) is independent of coil length for a constant value of surface current density N I/2b. Because for a long solenoid, N I/2b = Hz (0, 0), the axial center field (see PROBLEM 3.1), we have: Fz (0) − 21 μ◦ Hz2 (0, 0)×πa2
(3.41c)
Fz (0) is thus equal to the magnetic pressure times the area of the coil bore. Indeed, it will be seen below that every expression of the axial force derived here begins with this magnetic pressure term, i.e., μ◦ (N I/2b)2 or its equivalent form.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
87
3.5.3 Axial Force Between a Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil Figure 3.6 shows a thin-walled solenoid (2as , 2bs , NS IS /2bS ) coaxial with a ring coil (2aR and NR IR ). The right-hand end of the solenoid is at distance ρ left of the ring coil. The axial field generated by each coil points in the same direction. The axial force on the solenoid, FzS (ρ), is given by: μ◦ NS IS FzS (ρ) = − (NR IR ) × 2 2bS (aR +aS )2 +(ρ + 2bS )2 2 K(kS ) − E(kS ) − kS2 K(kS )
− (aR +aS )2 +ρ2 2 K(kR )−E(kR ) −kR2 K(kR )
(3.42)
The moduli kS and kR are given by: kS2 =
4aS aR ; (aS + aR + (2bS + ρ)2 )2
kR2 =
4aS aR (aS + aR )2 + ρ2
In the right-hand side of Eq. 3.42 the second term is greater than the third term, so FzS (ρ) is positive; i.e., the axial interaction force is attractive. Special Case 6: Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil Far Apart When these two coils are far apart such that kS2 1 and kR2 1, we obtain: 2 πaS NS IS 1 μ◦ 1 2 FzS (ρ) (πaR NR IR ) − (3.43a) 2π 2bs ρ3 (ρ + 2bS )3 Again as with the two ring coils treated above, FzS (ρ), +z-directed (towards the ring), is proportional to the product of two “magnetic moments.” Special Case 7: Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil Farther Apart When these two coils are so far apart that ρ 2bs , the second term within the brackets in Eq. 3.43a may be expanded, and we obtain: 2 πaS NS IS 6bS μ◦ 2 (πaR NR IR ) FzS (ρ) (3.43b) 2π 2bS ρ4 Note that, as expected, Eq. 3.43b is equivalent to Eq. 3.39c. NR IR
NS IS 2aR
2aS
2bS
Fig. 3.6
z
ρ
“Thin-walled” solenoid and a ring coil coaxially aligned and separated by ρ.
CHAPTER 3
88 3.5.4 Axial Force between Two Thin-Walled Solenoids
Here, we derive an equation for the axial force between two thin-walled solenoids; it is based on, but expanded considerably from, the original formulation by Garrett [3.5]. The equation becomes the basis for the axial forces between solenoids that are generally not thin-walled, presented next in 3.5.5. Consider two coaxial thin-walled solenoids, A (2aA ; 2bA ; NA IA /2bA ) and B (2aB ; 2bB ; NB IB /2bB ). As shown in Fig. 3.7, the right-hand end of Solenoid A is at distance ρ left of the left-hand end of Solenoid B. The axial field generated by each solenoid points in the same direction. Axial Force on Solenoid A by Solenoid B For Solenoid A, the axial force due to Solenoid B, FzAB , may be given by: μ◦ NA IA NB IB FzAB (ρ) = × 2 2bA 2bB 2bA +ρ [aT2 +(2bA +ρ)2 ] K(kA )−E(kA ) −Υ(c2, kA ) aT2 +(2bA +ρ)2 2bB +ρ + [aT2 +(2bB +ρ)2 ] K(kB )−E(kB ) −Υ(c2, kB ) aT2 +(2bB +ρ)2 2bT +ρ − [aT2 +(2bT +ρ)2 ] K(kT )−E(kT ) −Υ(c2, kT ) aT2 +(2bT +ρ)2 ρ 2 2 2 − (3.44) (aT +ρ ) K(kρ )−E(kρ ) −Υ(c , kρ ) aT2 +ρ2 where aT = aA +aB and bT = bA +bB . The moduli, kA , kB , kT , and kρ , are given by: 4aA aB ; + (2bA +ρ)2
kB2 =
4aA aB kT2 = 2 ; aT +(2bT + ρ)2
kρ2 =
kA2 =
a2 T
4aA aB 2 B + ρ)
a2 +(2b T
4aA aB aT2 + ρ2
NB IB NA IA 2aA
2aB 2bB 2bA
Fig. 3.7
ρ
Thin-walled Solenoids, A and B, with the two nearest ends separated by ρ.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
89
In Eq. 3.44, Υ(c2, k) is defined by: Υ(c2, k) ≡ (aA − aB )2 [Π(c2, k) − K(k)] Π(c2, k) is the complete elliptic integral of the third kind, defined by: π/2 dθ Π(c2, k) = 2 2 0 (1 − c sin θ) 1 − k 2 sin2 θ
(3.45)
(3.46)
As evident from Eq. 3.46, Π(c2, k) has two moduli, c2 ≤ 1 and k ≤ 1. The modulus c2 in the cases considered here is given by: c2 =
4aA aB 4aA aB = 2 aT (aA + aB )2
(3.47)
Π(0, k) = K(k) and Π(1, k) = ∞. Π(c2, k) may be expressed in a power series in c2 and k 2 : ∞ m π (2m)! (2j)! k 2j c2(m−j) Π(c2, k) = (3.48) 2 m=0 j=0 4m 4j (m!)2 (j!)2 Low-order terms are: π 3 2 2 9 4 Π(c2, k) = 1+ 21 c2 + 41 k 2 + 83 c4 + 16 c k + 64 k+ 2
5 6 5 4 2 15 2 4 25 6 + 16 c + 32 c k + 128 c k + 256 k +· · ·
Π(c2, 0) =
(3.49a)
π 8 7·9 10 3·7·11 12 1+ 21 c2 + 233 c4 + 254 c6 + 5·7 27 c + 28 c + 210 c 2
14 5·9·11·13 16 5·11·13·17 18 11·13·17·19 20 + 3·11·13 c + c + c + c +· · · (3.49b) 11 15 16 18 2 2 2 2
Note that when c2 = 0, Eq. 3.49a becomes identical to Eq. 3.38a, because as noted above, Π(0, k) = K(k). However, for most problems of interest c2 is generally close to 1, in which case neither expansion of Eq. 3.49 is very useful, since rapid convergence requires c2 1. Later, in discussing mutual inductance, we shall use Eq. 3.49b. Table 3.2 gives Π(c2, k) for selected values of c2 and k 2 . Mathcad and a number of other software programs can evaluate K(k), E(k), and Π(c2, k). Special Case 8: Total Midplane Force on Solenoid A Let us first consider the case in which Solenoids A and B each have the same length (2b) and surface current density (N I/2b) but different diameters. By making the following substitutions to Eq. 3.44, 2bA = 2bB = 2b, NA IA /2bA = NB IB /2bB = N I/2b, and ρ = 0 (no gap between the two nearest ends of Solenoids A and B), we obtain an expression for the total midplane force on Solenoid A, FzA (0), which becomes useful when we consider a solenoid that is not “thin-walled.” 2 4b μ◦ N I FzA (0) = × [aT2 +4b2 ] K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c2, k2b ) 2 2b aT2 +4b2 4b 2 2 2 − [aT +16b ] K(k4b )−E(k4b ) −Υ(c , k4b ) (3.50) aT2 +16b2
CHAPTER 3
90
Table 3.2: Complete Elliptic Integral of the Third Kind Π(c2, k) For Selected Values of c2 and k [ Π(0, 0) = π/2; Π(1, k) = ∞; Π(c2 , 1) = ∞ ] c2 0.1 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 0.9 0.92 0.94 0.95 0.96 0.97 0.98 0.99 0.991 0.992 0.993 0.994 0.995 0.996 0.997 0.998 0.999
k=0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
0.999
1.6558 1.6600 1.6732 1.6961 1.7307 1.7803 1.8509 1.9541 2.1173 2.4295 4.8804 1.7562 1.7609 1.7752 1.8002 1.8380 1.8923 1.9696 2.0829 2.2625 2.6077 5.3514 2.0279 2.0336 2.0513 2.0822 2.1290 2.1963 2.2925 2.4343 2.6604 3.1001 6.7100 2.4836 2.4913 2.5148 2.5561 2.6187 2.7090 2.8389 3.0315 3.3418 3.9550 9.2511 3.5124 3.5246 3.5622 3.6283 3.7290 3.8751 4.0867 4.4042 4.9246 5.9821 16.070 4.9673 4.9863 5.0448 5.1480 5.3056 5.5355 5.8710 6.3796 7.2263 8.9943 27.895 5.5536 5.5754 5.6426 5.7610 5.9421 6.2069 6.5939 7.1824 8.1667 10.239 33.280 6.4127 6.4387 6.5186 6.6597 6.8758 7.1921 7.6557 8.3633 9.5535 12.086 41.737 7.0248 7.0537 7.1429 7.3002 7.5414 7.8948 8.4135 9.2071 10.547 13.414 48.138 7.8540 7.8869 7.9886 8.1681 8.4435 8.8475 9.4417 10.353 11.897 15.227 57.268 9.0690 9.1079 9.2280 9.4403 9.7662 10.245 10.951 12.036 13.884 17.905 71.507 11.107 11.156 11.308 11.575 11.986 12.592 13.486 14.867 17.233 22.440 97.397 15.708 15.780 16.002 16.395 17.001 17.894 19.219 21.277 24.832 32.789 163.12 16.558 16.634 16.869 17.286 17.927 18.874 20.279 22.462 26.239 34.711 176.15 17.562 17.643 17.894 18.338 19.022 20.033 21.532 23.864 27.903 36.986 191.85 18.775 18.862 19.131 19.609 20.345 21.431 23.045 25.557 29.914 39.735 211.22 20.279 20.374 20.667 21.185 21.985 23.167 24.923 27.658 32.409 43.151 235.80 22.214 22.319 22.642 23.214 24.096 25.400 27.339 30.362 35.623 47.552 268.26 24.836 24.954 25.318 25.962 26.956 28.426 30.613 34.027 39.978 53.523 313.54 28.679 28.816 29.239 29.989 31.147 32.860 35.412 39.400 46.365 62.286 382.16 35.124 35.294 35.817 36.745 38.178 40.300 43.464 48.416 57.088 77.009 502.08 49.673 49.916 50.666 51.996 54.050 57.096 61.643 68.776 81.309 110.30 787.66
where aT = aA +aB and the moduli k2b and k4b are given by: 4aA aB 4aA aB 2 2 = 2 k2b ; k4b = 2 aT + 4b2 aT + 16b2 Because c2 1, though always c2 < 1, for most problems of our interest, Eq. 3.50 cannot be approximated even for “long” coils (β 1). Derivation of Eq. 3.50 from Eq. 3.44 If we make Solenoids A and B identical in diameter and surface current density but each one half the length of the original, for ρ = 0 the two solenoids are transformed into one solenoid of length 2b. Next, if the following substitutions, i.e., 2aA = 2aB = 2a, NA IA /2bA = NB IB /2bB = N I/2b, and 2bA = 2bB = b, are made in Eq. 3.44, the modified equation is reduced to Eq. 3.50. Answer to TRIVIA 3.1 i). The Swiss mathematician Leonhard Euler (1707–1783) to the French encyclopedist Denis Diderot (1713–1784). This anecdote is disputed by Dirk Struik, who states in A Concise History of Mathematics (Dover Publications, 1948) that “. . . no reason exists to think that the thoughtful Euler would have behaved in the asinine way.” The great Pierre Simon de Laplace (1749–1827), once asked by Napoleon why his monumental five-volume Celestial Mechanics had no mention of God, replied, “I had no need of that hypothesis.”
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
91
3.5.5 “Thick-Walled” Solenoid—Midplane Axial Force When a solenoid cannot be treated as “thin-walled,” it may be divided radially into many “thin-walled” subsolenoids. Here, we consider the simplest case for treating a solenoid of α > 1: the solenoid divided into two “thin-walled” Subsolenoids A (inner) and B (outer), each of the same radial build and length 2b. Subsolenoids A and B have diameters respectively of 2aA and 2aB > 2aA and a current per unit length of 21 (N I/2b). FzA (0), the total axial force on one half of Subsolenoid A comprises two components, one due to its other half, FzAA (0) given by Eq. 3.41a, and the other due to Subsolenoid B, FzAB (0). Figure 3.8 shows the arrangement of two subsolenoids appropriate for derivation of an expression for the midplane axial force on Subsolenoid A. Comparing Figs. 3.7 and 3.8, we note that Eq. 3.44 is applicable if we make the following substitutions for the main parameters: 2bA = b; 2bB = 2b; and ρ = −2b. With these parameters and c2 given by Eq. 3.47, Eq. 3.44 becomes: 2 μ◦ N I FzAB (0) = − × 2 4b 2b [aT2 +b2 ] K(kb )−E(kb ) −Υ(c2, kb ) aT2 +b2 2b 2 2 2 − [aT +4b ] K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c , k2b ) (3.51) aT2 +4b2 where aT = aA +aB . The moduli, kb and k2b , are given by: kb2 =
4aA aB ; aT2 + b2
2 k2b =
4aA aB 2 T + 4b
a2
FzAA (0), the midplane axial force by Subsolenoid A on itself, is given by Eq. 3.41a with (N I/4b) in place of (N I/2b). Similarly, FzB (0) is the total midplane axial force on Subsolenoid B comprised of FzBB (0) and FzBA (0): FzA (0) = FzAA (0)+FzAB (0)
(3.52a)
FzB (0) = FzBB (0)+FzBA (0)
(3.52b)
Solenoid B (N I)/2 2aA 2aB b Solenoid A (N I)/2 2b Fig. 3.8 Arrangement of Subsolenoids A and B for computation of the midplane axial force on Subsolenoid A.
CHAPTER 3
92 Thus:
2 μ◦ N I FzA (0) = − × 2 4b 2b 4aA2 +b2 K(kbA)−E(kbA) −2b 4aA2 +4b2 K(k2bA )−E(k2bA ) 2b + [aT2 +b2 ] K(kb )−E(kb ) −Υ(c2, kb ) aT2 +b2 2b 2 2 2 − [aT +4b ] K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c , k2b ) aT2 +4b2
(3.53a)
Again c2 is given by Eq. 3.47. The moduli kbA , k2bA , kbB , and k2bB are given by: kb2A =
4aA2 ; 4aA2 + b2
2 k2b = A
4aA2 ; 4aA2 + 4b2
kb2B =
4aB2 ; 4aB2 + b2
2 k2b = B
4aB2 4aB2 + 4b2
In this case, because 2bA = 2bB = 2b and NA IA = NB IB , FzAB (0) = FzBA (0). Thus: 2 μ◦ N I × 2 4b 2b 4aB2 +b2 K(kbB )−E(kbB ) −2b 4aB2 +4b2 K(k2bB )−E(k2bB )
FzB (0) = −
2b + (aT2 +b2 ) K(kb )−E(kb ) −Υ(c2, kb ) aT2 +b2 2b 2 2 2 − (aT +4b ) K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c , k2b ) aT2 +4b2
(3.53b)
The total midplane axial force of a solenoid FzT (0), divided into two thin-walled subsolenoids, is the sum of FzA (0) and FzB (0). We thus obtain: 2 μ◦ N I FzT (0) = − × 2 4b 2b 4aA2 +b2 K(kbA )−E(kbA ) −2b 4aA2 +4b2 K(k2bA )−E(k2bA ) + 2b 4aB2 +b2 K(kbB )−E(kbB ) −2b 4aB2 +4b2 K(k2bB )−E(k2bB ) 4b + (aT2 +b2 ) K(kb )−E(kb ) −Υ(c2, kb ) aT2 +b2 4b − (3.54) (aT2 +4b2 ) K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c2, k2b ) aT2 +4b2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
93
Note that when a solenoid is divided into two thin-walled subsolenoids, FzT (0) requires computation of four terms in Eq. 3.54. When a solenoid is divided into m > 2 thin-walled subsolenoids, it will require computation of 2(m!)/[(m − 2)!] terms to obtain FzT (0). For m = 3 an expression of FzT (0) thus will contain twelve terms and 18 moduli, clearly too tedious for hand computation. To create a computer code that will accurately compute the midplane axial force of a “practical” solenoidal coil, i.e., a thick-walled solenoid, one has to extend Eq. 3.54 to a set of expressions applicable to m thin-walled subsolenoids. To ensure that each subsolenoid is thin-walled, m may have to be 10 or even greater. Note that because in most cases c2 is close to 1, it is not possible to approximate the Π(c2, k) term contained in each Υ(c2, k) even for “long” (β 1) solenoids. Special Case 9: Midplane Force for a “Long” Thick-Walled Solenoid Because in most of our applications c2 1, each Π(c2, k) in the Υ(c2, k) terms in Eq. 3.54 cannot be approximated by the first few terms of the series expansion in k 2 and c2 . The remaining terms in Eq. 3.54, however, can be expanded for β 1, as was done above in Special Case 5 (Eq. 3.41b). Thus: FzT (0) −μ◦ −μ◦
NI 4b NI 4b
2
π(aA +aB ) − (aA −aB ) 2Π(c , kb )−Π(c , k2b ) 2
2
2
2
2
2
(aA −aB )2 π(aA +aB ) 1 − 2Π(c2, kb )−Π(c2, k2b ) 2 2 π(aA +aB ) 2
2
(3.55)
Note that when aA = aB , Eq. 3.55 reduces to Eq. 3.41b. In the second form of Eq. 3.55, the last term within the braces may be considered a correction term.
Kapitza’s Magnets (Part 1 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist [3.4] One project that appealed to me was to make a stronger magnetic field than could be made with iron core magnets. The alternative was not to use iron at all, but to concentrate on the effective use of copper for carrying a current. A current passing through a coil of wire will produce a magnetic field at its center. The larger the current, the stronger the magnetic field. There is no saturation effect here. So far as we know, this increase of field with increasing current continues indefinitely. If you double the current, you double the magnetic field in the middle of the coil. The problem was to discover how far it was practically possible to go. I remember discussing these matters at some length in Cambridge with Peter Kapitza, a brilliant Russian scientist who came to England, became an important part of the scientific community there, had a laboratory built for him, did some pioneering work in developing new ways of producing strong magnetic fields, and then returned to Russia.
CHAPTER 3
94 3.5.6 Axial Forces in a Nested Two-Coil Magnet
In a magnet comprised of several nested solenoids, all coaxially aligned, it is sometimes important to compute in each solenoid the midplane axial compressive force, which in a large nested-coil magnet such as an MRI magnet can become substantial. Here we consider the simplest nested-coil magnet comprised of two thin-walled solenoids, A and B, shown in Fig. 3.9. Solenoid A (inner) has parameters of 2aA , 2bA , and NA IA /2bA ; Solenoid B (outer) similarly has 2aB , 2bB , and NB IB /2bB . Midplane Axial Force on Solenoid A The total midplane axial force on the right-hand half of Solenoid A, FzA (0), is the sum of FzAA (0) and FzAB (0), where FzAA (0) is the midplane axial force due to its own left-hand half, while FzAB (0) is that due to Solenoid B. FzAA (0) is given by Eq. 3.41a with the subscript A inserted appropriately. FzAB (0) is given by Eq. 3.44, with the following substitutions: bA for 2bA and −(bA + bB ) for ρ; 2bB in Eq. 3.44 remains the same, and c2 is still given by Eq. 3.47. 2 NA IA μ◦ FzA (0) = − × 2 2bA 2 2 2 2 2bA 4aA +bA K(kbA )−E(kbA ) − 2bA 4aA +4bA K(k2bA )−E(k2bA )
NA IA + 2bA
NB IB 2bB
2b B [aT2 +bB2 ] K(kB )−E(kB ) −Υ(c2, kB ) aT2 +bB2 bD − [aT2 +bD2 ] K(kD )−E(kD ) −Υ(c2, kD ) aT2 +bD2 bT 2 2 2 − [aT +bT ] K(kT )−E(kT ) −Υ(c , kT ) aT2 +bT2 (3.56)
Note that aT = aA +aB , bD = bB −bA , and bT = bA +bB . kbA , k2bA , kA , kB , and kAB are: kb2A =
4aA2 ; 4aA2 + bA2
2 k2b = A
4aA2 ; 4aA2 + 4bA2
kB2 =
4aA aB ; aT2 + bB2
kD2 =
4aA aB ; aT2 + bD2
kT2 =
Solenoid B NB IB 2aA Solenoid A NA IA
2aB
2bA 2bB
Fig. 3.9
Nested two-coil magnet comprised of Solenoids A and B.
4aA aB aT2 + bT2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
95
Special Case 10: Midplane Force on Solenoid A—“Long” Solenoids When both solenoids are “long,” i.e., bA2 4aA2 and bB2 aT2 , and of differing lengths so that bD2 aT2 , Eq. 3.56 may be simplified to: 2 μ◦ NA IA NA IA NB IB 2 FzA (0) − πaA + × 2 2bA 2bA 2bB ! (aA −aB )2 Π(c2, kD )+Π(c2, kT )−2Π(c2, kB ) (3.57a) The second term in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.57a represents FzAB . Physically this is due to Solenoid B’s Br on Solenoid A at the axial location near each end of Solenoid B. Note that as bA → ∞ and bB → ∞, the second term becomes zero. Special Case 11: Midplane Axial Force on Solenoid A— Both Solenoids “Long” & Solenoid B Much Longer than Solenoid A When both Solenoids are “long” as in Special Case 10 and Solenoid B is much longer than Solenoid A, i.e., bD → bB and bT → bB , Eq. 3.57a is further simplified to: 2 μ◦ NA IA FzA (0) FzAA (0) − πaA2 (3.57b) 2 2bA That FzAB (0) → 0 as bA /bB → 0 physically makes sense, because as Solenoid B becomes much longer than Solenoid A, Solenoid B’s Br , a key ingredient of FzAB (0), given by the second term in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.57a, becomes zero within its bore where Solenoid A is located. Midplane Axial Force on Solenoid B Expressions for the midplane axial forces on Solenoid B are very similar to those derived on Solenoid A. We may therefore derive these expressions from the previous section by making appropriate substitutions. The total midplane axial force in Solenoid B, FzB (0), is the sum of FzBB (0) and FzBA (0), where FzBB (0) is the midplane axial force due to its own left-hand half, while FzBA (0) is that due to Solenoid A. 2 NB IB μ◦ FzB (0) = − × 2 2bB 2 2 2 2 2bB 4aB +bB K(kbB )−E(kbB ) −2bB 4aB +4bB K(k2bB )−E(k2bB )
NB IB + 2bB
NA IA 2bA
2b A [aT2 +bA2 ] K(kA )−E(kA ) −Υ(c2, kA ) aT2 +bA2 bD + [aT2 +bD2 ] K(kD )−E(kD ) −Υ(c2, kD ) aT2 +bD2 bT − [aT2 +bT2 ] K(kT )−E(kT ) −Υ(c2, kT ) aT2 +bT2 (3.58)
CHAPTER 3
96
Here too c2 is given by Eq. 3.47. The moduli k2bB and kA are given by: 2 k2b = B
aB2 ; 4aB2 + 4bB2
kA2 =
4aA aB aT2 + bA2
The other moduli are the same as those given above for Eq. 3.56. Special Case 12: Midplane Axial Force on Solenoid B— Both Solenoids “Long” & Solenoid B Much Longer than Solenoid A When both inner and outer coils are “long” and Solenoid B is much longer than Solenoid A, as in Special Case 11, we obtain: 2 NB IB μ◦ NB IB NA IA 2 πaB + FzB (0) − π(aA2 +aB2 ) 2 2bB 2bB 2bA ! 2 2 2 2 − (aA −aB ) 2Π(c , kA )+Π(c , kD )−Π(c , kT ) (3.59a) As in Special Case 11, the second term in Eq. 3.59a represents FzBA , which is nonnegligible because Solenoid A’s Br impinges on Solenoid B at the axial location near each end of Solenoid A. Special Case 13: Midplane Axial Force on Solenoid B— Both Solenoids “Long” & Solenoid B Much Shorter than Solenoid A When both Solenoids are “long”(bB2 aT2 and bA2 aT2 ) but Solenoid B is much shorter than Solenoid A (bD2 → bA2 aT2 ), Eq. 3.58 is simplified to: 2 μ◦ NB IB FzB (0) − πaB2 (3.59b) 2 2bB Equation 3.59b is analogous to Eq. 3.57b of Special Case 11; the same physical interpretation used there applies here too. Kapitza’s Magnets (Part 2 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist The first and main difficulty to overcome in attempting to produce strong magnetic fields by passing very large currents through a coil is that strong enough currents tend to heat the coil, melt it, squeeze it out of shape, and destroy it. Kapitza’s solution was to pass currents through a coil for only such a short time that there would not be sufficient energy liberated to heat it to a dangerous extent. Kapitza, however, was not only a scientist but also an engineer. He succeeded in designing novel equipment for producing pulsed magnetic fields of this kind, and also devices for measuring the properties of matter during the small fractions of a second when the fields were reasonably constant and steady. Kapitza made great progress in developing this trick to overcome the objectionable heating of the coil, but in the end he ran into another limitation, the strength of the coil. You all know that passing a current through a magnetic field results in the application of a force on the conductor of a coil producing its own magnetic field. The parts are squeezed (axially) and pushed (radially) until finally the coil gives way. It was necessary to build a very strong coil, as well as equipment to produce and switch enormous currents on and off in a very short time.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
97
3.5.7 Axial Restoring Force on Axially Off-Centered Solenoids When the axial field of each solenoid points in the same direction and when the axial centers of Solenoids A and B mismatch by a distance of ρ, an axial restoring force, FzR (ρ), is generated to align the axial centers. FzR (ρ) may be given by: μ◦ NA IA NB IB FzR (ρ) = − × 2 2bA 2bB b −ρ T [aT2 +(bT −ρ)2 ] K(kT − )−E(kT − ) −Υ(c2, kT − ) aT2 +(bT −ρ)2 bD +ρ + [aT2 +(bD +ρ)2 ] K(kD + )−E(kD + ) −Υ(c2, kD + ) aT2 +(bD +ρ)2 bT +ρ − [aT2 +(bT +ρ)2 ] K(kT + )−E(kT + ) −Υ(c2, kT + ) aT2 +(bT +ρ)2 bD −ρ 2 2 2 − [aT +(bD −ρ) ] K(kD − )−E(kD − ) −Υ(c , kD − ) aT2 +(bD −ρ)2 (3.60) where aT = aA +aB , bT = bA +bB , and bD = bA −bB ; kT + , kT − , kD + , and kD − are given by: 4aA aB ; + (bT + ρ)2
kT2 − =
4aA aB = 2 ; aT + (bD + ρ)2
kD2 − =
kT2 + =
a2 T
kD2 +
a2 T
4aA aB + (bT − ρ)2
a2
4aA aB + (bD − ρ)2
T
Special Case 14: No Axial Misalignment When ρ = 0, kT2 + = kT2 − and kD2 + = kD2 − , and thus FzR (ρ) = 0, as expected physically. Special Case 15: “Small” Axial Misalignment For a small misalignment, defined as ρ aT2 +bD2 , FzR (ρ) is proportional to ρ: NA IA NB IB FzR (ρ) ∝ − ρ (3.61) 2bA 2bB Equation 3.61 is later used to derive an expression of MAB (ρ), the mutual inductance between Solenoids A and B misaligned by a small distance (ρ aT2 +bD2 ). Special Case 16: Either Solenoid “Long” If either Solenoid A or Solenoid B is “long,” the longer solenoid’s axial field becomes uniform, its Br becomes small and the solenoid generates little axial force on the shorter solenoid even if the solenoid centers are misaligned considerably. This can be seen because the first two +terms and the last two −terms in Eq. 3.60 cancel out when bT2 aT2 and bD2 aT2 , resulting in FzR (ρ) → 0.
CHAPTER 3
98
3.6 Stresses and Strains in Solenoid under Magnetic Force We study here stresses and strains on a superconductor, induced principally by Lorentz forces, in a solenoidal magnet [3.6]. The analytic expressions derived and graphs presented here of magnetic stresses are for “simple” properties of the winding materials under a “simple” field distribution. 3.6.1 Stress and Strain Equations The stresses, radial, σr (r, z); hoop, σθ (r, z); axial, σz (r, z); and shear, τrz (r, z) in the winding of a solenoid subjected to a magnetic force density generated by the interaction of λJ and the axial magnetic field (induction), Bz (r, z), are found from the solution of the equilibrium equations: ∂σr σr − σθ ∂τrz + + = −λJBz (r, z) ∂r r ∂z
(3.62a)
∂τrz τrz ∂σz − + = −λJBr (r, z) (3.62b) ∂r r ∂z with boundary conditions: σr (r = a1 , z) = 0; σr (r = a2 , z) = 0; σz (r, z =±b) = 0; τrz (r = a1 , z) = 0; τrz (r = a2 , z) = 0; and τrz (r, z = ±b) = 0. Note that the shear stress τrz is the only variable that couples Eqs. 3.62a and 3.62b. Most composite superconductors, LTS and HTS, may be considered orthotropic: Hooke’s law is applicable. An orthotropic material has mechanical properties, e.g., Young’s modulus, Poisson’s ratio, that are different in, but symmetric about, three orthogonal directions. The strains, r , θ , z , respectively, in the r, θ, and z directions, and the shear strain, γrz , in the r-z plane, are related to the stresses by: r =
1 ν ν σr − θr σθ − zr σz + Tr Er Eθ Ez
(3.63a)
θ = −
νrθ 1 ν σr + σθ − zθ σz + Tθ Er Eθ Ez
(3.63b)
z = −
νrz ν 1 σr − θz σθ + σz + Tz Er Eθ Ez
(3.63c)
1 τ (3.63d) Grz rz Er , Eθ , and Ez are Young’s moduli, respectively, in the r, θ, and z directions. ν12 ≡ −2 /1 is the Poisson’s ratio for transverse strains in two orthogonal directions when the material is stressed in the 1-direction (σ1 ; σ2 = σ3 = 0). Grz is the shear modulus. Tr , Tθ , and Tz are integrated coefficients of thermal expansion between room temperature (300 K) and operating temperature (Top ). Top Top Top αTr (T ) dT ; Tθ = αTθ (T ) dT ; Tz = αTz (T ) dT (3.63e) Tr = γrz =
300 K
300 K
300 K
αTr (T ), αTθ (T ), and αTz (T ) are temperature-dependent coefficients of thermal expansion parallel to the major axes. Note that because these coefficients are positive and because the integration is from 300 K to Top < 300 K, the thermal strains in Eqs. 3.63a–3.63c are negative, i.e., compressive.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
99
The following conditions among ν’s and E’s also apply: νrθ ν νθz ν νzr ν = θr ; = zθ ; = rz (3.63f ) Eθ Er Ez Eθ Er Ez In the case of an axisymmetric body, e.g., an ideal solenoid, the strains and displacements, ur and uz , respectively, in the r and z directions, are related by: ∂ur ur ∂uz ∂ur ∂uz r = ; θ = ; z = ; γrz = + (3.63g) ∂r r ∂z ∂z ∂r Note that because of axial symmetry, all variables in Eq. 3.62 are independent of θ, and uθ = 0 too. In general, there is no closed-form simultaneous solution for σr (Eq. 3.62a) and σz (Eq. 3.62b). In a “long” solenoid, such as that typically used in a spatially high-field-homogeneity NMR magnet, the Bz (r, z) variation in the z-direction, at least over most of the solenoid axial length about the midplane, is quite insignificant. The origin of the shear stress τrz is the variation in the zdirection of the radial load on the coil generated by Bz (r, z). Therefore, in a long solenoid, we can justifiably simplify Eq. 3.62a by assuming that all variables are independent of z, including ur , i.e., ∂ur /∂z = 0. Because in high-field-homogeneity magnets ∂Br (r, z)/∂z 0, we may also safely assume that over most of the magnet axial length ∂ur /∂z = 0, which, together with ∂uz /∂r = 0, leads to γrz = τrz = 0, which in turn decouples Eqs. 3.62a and 3.62b. Combining Eq. 3.62 and Eq. 3.63, with the assumption τrz = 0, and solving for σr and σθ in terms of ur , we obtain a differential equation for ur : d2 u r 1 dur ur 1 − νrθ νθr F + − ζ2 2 = − λJBz (r) + (3.64a) 2 dr r dr r Er r where " Eθ ζ= ; F = −(ζ 2 − νrθ )Tθ + (1 − νθr ζ 2 )Tr (3.64b) Er The general solution to Eq. 3.64a is given by: C2 T (3.65) ur = C1 rζ + ζ + uL r + ur r where C1 and C2 are constants to be determined from boundary conditions at T r = a1 and r = a2 . uL r and ur (the superscripts L and T stand, respectively, for Lorentz and thermal) are particular solutions corresponding to the “source” terms, given in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.64a. The thermal term uTr is given by: Fr uTr = (3.66) 1 − ζ2 For an isotropic material (Eθ = Er , and thus ζ = 1), uTr is given by: uTr (ζ = 1) = 21 F r ln r In general Bz (r) may be given by a power series in r: n Bz (r) = bk r k
(3.67)
(3.68)
k=0
Then, the Lorentz term uL r may be given by: n 1 − νrθ νθr bk rk+2 uTr = λJ Er ζ 2 − (k + 2)2 k=0
(3.69)
CHAPTER 3
100 3.6.2 Stress and Strain Equations in Isotropic Solenoid
We derive radial and hoop stresses in an isotropic solenoid with the winding current density of λJ. The axial magnetic field in the winding varies linearly with r, from Bz (r = a1 ) ≡ B1 to Bz (r = a2 ) ≡ B2 . Note that both B1 and B2 can include a “uniform” background field, generated by “long” coils, in a nested-coil magnet, located outside of this solenoid. We define two nondimensional parameters: κ ≡ B2 /B1 and ρ = r/a1 . In a high-field NMR magnet, κ for the innermost coil can exceed 0.9; for a stand-alone coil it is roughly −0.1; and for an infinitely long stand-alone coil, κ = 0. Equation 3.62a for this solenoid is modified to: dσρ σ − σθ λJB1 a1 + ρ =− [α − κ − (1 − κ)ρ] dρ ρ α−1
(3.70)
For an isotropic material, strains, with thermal strain T included, are given by: ρ =
1 (σ − νσθ ) + T E ρ
1 (σ − νσρ ) + T E θ We may solve Eq. 3.71 for σρ and σθ : $ E # σρ = + ν − (1+ν) ρ T θ 1 − ν2 $ E # σθ = + ν − (1+ν) ρ T 1 − ν2 θ θ =
(3.71a) (3.71b)
(3.72a) (3.72b)
Strains are related to displacement, u, (here only in the r-direction), by: ρ =
1 du ; a1 dρ
θ =
1 u a1 ρ
Combining Eqs. 3.72a–3.72c, we obtain: u E du σρ = + ν − a (1+ν) 1 T (1 − ν 2 )a1 dρ ρ u E du σθ = +ν − a1 (1+ν)T (1 − ν 2 )a1 ρ dρ Combination of Eq. 3.70 and Eqs. 3.72d and 3.72e yields: d2 u 1 du 1 − ν2 λJB1 a21 u + − =− [α − κ − (1 − κ)ρ] dρ2 ρ dρ ρ2 E α−1 The general solution of Eq. 3.73 is given by: 1−ν 2 λJB1 a21 (α − κ)ρ2 C2 (1 − κ)ρ3 u = C1 ρ + − − ρ E α−1 3 8
(3.72c)
(3.72d) (3.72e)
(3.73)
(3.74)
where C1 and C2 are constants determined from boundary conditions at ρ = 1 and ρ = α, and the last term is the particular solution. Combining Eq. 3.74 and Eqs. 3.72d and 3.72e, we obtain:
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
101
E C2 σρ = (1 + ν)C1 − (1 − ν) 2 (1−ν 2 )a1 ρ λJB1 a1 2+ν 3+ν ET 2 − (α − κ)ρ − (1 − κ)ρ − α−1 3 8 1−ν (3.75a) E C2 σθ = (1 + ν)C1 + (1 − ν) 2 2 (1−ν )a1 ρ λJB1 a1 1+2ν 1+3ν ET 2 − (α − κ)ρ − (1 − κ)ρ − α−1 3 8 1−ν (3.75b) With σρ (1) = 0 and σρ (α) = 0, we have expressions for C1 and C2 : 1−ν 2 [(1 + ν)C1 − (1 − ν)C2 ] = E
λJB1 a21 α−1
2+ν 3+ν (α − κ) − (1 − κ) 3 8
+ a1 (1+ν)T
(3.76a)
C2 1−ν 2 λJB1 a21 2+ν (3+ν) 2 (1 + ν)C1 − (1 − ν) 2 = (α − κ)α − (1 − κ)α α E α−1 3 8 + a1 (1+ν)T
(3.76b)
Equations 3.76a and 3.76b may be solved for C1 and C2 : 1−ν λJB1 a21 2+ν 3+ν 2 2 C1 = (α−κ)(α +α + 1)− (1−κ)(α+1)(α +1) +a1 T E α2 − 1 3 8 (3.76c) 1+ν λJB1 a21 α2 2+ν 3+ν C2 = (α−κ)− (1−κ)(α+1) (3.76d) 2 E α −1 3 8 Substituting Eqs. 3.76c and 3.76d into Eq. 3.75, we obtain: 2 α +α+1−α2 /ρ2 λJB1 a1 2+ν σρ = (α − κ) −ρ α−1 3 α+1 α2 3+ν 2 2 (1 − κ) α +1− 2 −ρ − 8 ρ 2 2+ν α +α+1+α2 /ρ2 λJB1 a1 1+2ν σθ = (α − κ) − ρ α−1 3 α+1 3 ! 3+ν α2 1+3ν 2 2 − (1 − κ) α +1+ 2 − ρ 8 ρ 8
(3.77a)
(3.77b)
CHAPTER 3
102
“Thin-Walled” Coil Figures 3.10a and 3.10b show, respectively, plots, for a “thin” coil, here α = 1.2, of normalized stresses, hoop, ςθ ≡ σθ /(λJB1 a1 ), and radial, ςr ≡ σρ /(λJB1 a1 ), as functions of normalized radial distance, ρ ≡ r/a1 , at selected “field ratios,” κ ≡ B2 /B1 . Note that κ = −0.1 is appropriate for a stand-alone solenoid; κ = 0 for an infinitely long coil; and κ > 0 for a coil exposed to a uniform background field. For each field ratio (κ) ςθ decreases with ρ, while ςr , being 0 at r = a1 and r = a2 , has an extremum (maximum or minimum) radially midway through the winding. 1.2 1.1
0.95 0.9
1.0
0.8 0.7
0.9 0.5
ςθ 0.8
κ 0.2
0.7 0.6
0 −0.1
0.5 0.4 1.0
1.04
1.08
ρ
1.12
1.16
1.20
1.12
1.16
1.20
(a) 0.010
0.95 0.9
0.005
0.8 0.7
0
ςr
0.5
−0.005
κ
−0.001
0.2
−0.015 0 −0.1
−0.020 −0.025 1.0
1.04
1.08 ρ (b)
Fig. 3.10 Plots, at selected κ ≡ B2 /B1 values, for a “thin-walled” coil (α = 1.2): (a) normalized hoop stress, ςθ ≡ σθ /(λJB1 a1 ), vs. normalized radial distance, ρ ≡ r/a1 ; (b) normalized radial stress, ςr ≡ σρ /(λJB1 a1 ), vs. ρ. In each graph κ, from the bottom trace to the top trace: −0.1 (bottom); 0; 0.2; 0.5; 0.7; 0.8; 0.9; and 0.95 (top).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
103
For κ > 0.5, the winding throughout develops a positive radial stress, which tends to separate turns, a condition that generally should be avoided. The positive effect of winding tension in reducing ςr is discussed shortly (3.6.3). “Medium-Walled” Coil Figure 3.11 shows plots similar to those of Fig. 3.10 for a “medium-walled” coil, here α = 1.8. In this medium-walled coil, ςr > 0 for κ ≈ 0.2; furthermore, ςr exceeds 0.1 for κ > 0.8. That is, an “insert” coil in the bore of a high-field background magnet should be “thin-walled,” or otherwise it should be subdivided. 2.0
1.6
ςθ
κ 0.95 0.9 0.8
1.2
0.7
0.5 0.2
0.8
0 −0.1
0.4 0.2
1
1.2
1.4 ρ
1.6
1.8
1.6
1.8
(a) 0.14
0.95 0.9
0.10
0.8 0.7
0.06
0.5
0.02
κ 0.2
ςr 0 −0.02 −0.06
0 −0.1 1
1.2
1.4 ρ (b)
Fig. 3.11 Plots, at selected κ ≡ B2 /B1 values, for a “medium-walled” coil (α = 1.8): (a) ςθ ≡ σθ /(λJB1 a1 ) vs. ρ; (b) ςr ≡ σr /(λJB1 a1 ) vs. ρ. In each graph κ, from the bottom trace to the top trace: −0.1 (bottom); 0; 0.2; 0.5; 0.7; 0.8; 0.9; and 0.95 (top).
CHAPTER 3
104 “Thick-Walled” Coil
Figure 3.12 shows plots for a “thick-walled” coil, here α = 3.6. Note that ςθ is roughly twice that for the medium-walled coil. Most significantly, though, in the thick-walled coil normalized radial stress σr > 0 unless κ is sufficiently negative. There are two practical ways to make σr nearly 0 or negative: 1) wind the coil with conductor in tension; and 2) wrap the coil at its outermost layer with a banding wire of high modulus of elasticity. Also, subdividing the coil into thinner coils reduces not only σr but also σθ .
4.5 4.0
3.0
κ
ςθ
0.95 0.9 0.8 0.7
2.0
0.5
0.2 0
1.0
0 1.0
−0.1 1.4
1.8
2.2
ρ
2.6
3.0
3.4
2.6
3.0
3.4
(a) 0.9
0.95 0.9
0.8
0.8 0.7
0.6
0.5 κ
ςr 0.4
0.2
0.2
0 −0.1
0 −0.1 1.0
1.4
1.8
2.2
ρ
(b) Fig. 3.12 Plots, at selected κ ≡ B2 /B1 values, for a “thick-walled” coil (α = 3.6): (a) ςθ ≡ σθ /(λJB1 a1 ) vs. ρ; (b) ςr ≡ σr /(λJB1 a1 )vs. ρ. In each graph κ, from the bottom trace to the top trace: −0.1 (bottom); 0; 0.2; 0.5; 0.7; 0.8; 0.9; and 0.95 (top).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
105
3.6.3 Winding Tension to Reduce Radial Stresses Using an illustrative example, we show here the beneficial effect of winding tension to reduce the radial stress, σr , in the winding. As stated above, σr should remain negative in the winding to keep the layers from separating in the radial direction. Stated simply, when a coil is wound with conductor in tension, the tension generates radial stresses directed inward, reducing the radial stresses within the winding. Even if the winding tension is kept constant during the winding process, the radial variation of the effect of tension within the winding cannot be expressed by an approximate equation as with magnetic body force. In the presence of winding tension, computation of both hoop and radial stresses must be performed through numerical analysis. Consider an insert coil placed in the bore of a high-field background magnet. The insert has an i.d. (2a1 ) of 87 mm, an o.d. (2a2 ) of 156.6 mm: α = 1.8, i.e., it is “medium” thick, and in this analysis, as in the above, the coil is assumed “long.” Other insert parameters include: Bz (r = a1 ) ≡ B1 = 28.1 T; Bz (r = a2 ) ≡ B2 = 24.3 T or κ ≡ B2 /B1 = 0.865; and λJ = 8.26×107 A/m2 . From Fig. 3.11, which gives ςr (ρ) plots for α = 1.8, we find the normalized radial stress, ςr ≡ σr /(λJB1 a1 ), has a maximum of 0.11 at ρ ≡ r/a1 = 1.3. The maximum radial stress, [σr ]mx , is thus: [σr ]mx = 0.11λJB1 a1 = 0.11(8.26×107 A/m2 )(28.1 T)(43.5×10−3 m) = 11.1 MPa A radial stress of 11.1 MPa is too large to be tolerated inside the insert. Figure 3.13 presents σr vs. r plots for this insert at selected winding tensions, Γ, from 0 to a maximum of 200 N ( 20 kg). The figure indicates that winding tension of at least 160 N is required to keep σr nearly zero or negative. In practice, a winding tension up to 200 N may be applied. For this particular insert a winding tension of 80 N results in a maximum σr at ∼5 MPa; when a coil is “wet-wound” with epoxy to “glue” adjacent layers, a positive radial stress up to ∼5 MPa is tolerable. 14 12
Γ= 0
σr [MPa]
10 40 N
8 6
80
4 120
2 0
160
−2
200
−4 40
45
50
55
60 r [mm]
65
70
75
80
Fig. 3.13 σr vs. r plots of a solenoidal coil of α = 1.8, with winding tensions, Γ, from 0 (no tension) to 200 N ( 20 kg). With Γ = 0, σr has a peak, at r 57.5 mm, of 11.1 MPa. Only at winding tensions above 160 N ( 16 kg), σr ≤ 0 everywhere.
CHAPTER 3
106
3.7 Self Inductance Total flux linking a coil, Φ, is proportional to the current I through the coil. Φ = LI
(3.78)
The proportionality constant L is the self inductance of the coil. Note that Φ is a “field concept” quantity, while I is a “circuit concept” quantity: L links these two concepts, and because the field concept quantity necessarily involves a volume, L is a geometry-dependent quantity. L is also related to the stored magnetic energy, Em , of the coil through: Em = 21 LI 2 (3.79) For systems containing no magnetic materials, Em may be computed by integrating (1/2)μ◦ H 2 over all space, i.e., Em is another field-concept quantity; L connects Em to I through Eq. 3.79. 3.7.1 Self-Inductance of a Circular Loop An approximate formula for L of a circular loop of radius R of wire of permeability μ and radius a was derived by Maxwell: 8R − 2 + 41 μR L = μ◦ R ln a R μ◦ R ln + 0.079 + 41 μR a
(3.80a) (3.80b)
In the right-hand side of each equation above, the first term is the self inductance of the loop due to the flux linked within the circular area (0 ≤ r ≤ R − a) of the loop and the second term represents, as will be studied in PROBLEM 3.18 (p. 208), the self inductance of the interior of the wire, 2πR long. Because the flux linkage outside the wire is frequency independent, the first term is valid for all frequencies, while the second term is frequency dependent. Thus, (1/4)μR is valid only at “low” frequencies; the second term reduces to 0 at “high” frequencies. Derivation of the first term of the right-hand side of Eq. 3.80 is quite complex, involving, among others, elliptic integrals.
Kapitza’s Magnets (Part 3 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist In the 1930’s, Kapitza completed the construction of a most interesting installation. Fields of the order of magnitude of 300,000 gauss (30 T), or about ten times that possible with an iron core magnet, were produced in small coils having about a centimeter inside diameter. Not only did he make and operate these coils; he also performed experiments to show how the properties of matter are influenced by strong magnetic fields. Upon Kapitza’s departure from Cambridge this work was stopped and was not picked up again until a few years ago (early 1950s).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
107
3.7.2 Self Inductance of Solenoidal Coil For a solenoidal coil containing no ferromagnetic materials and characterized by an inner winding radius a1 , α, β, and total number of turns, N , its self inductance, L, may be given by: L = μ◦ a1 N 2 L(α, β) (3.81) where L(α, β) is a dimensionless inductance parameter that is a function only of the shape of a coil, represented by α and β. Figure 3.14 plots L(α, β) plots over the range of α = 1 to α = 5 and β = 0.04 to β = 10 that covers α and β values of solenoidal coils of our interest. For the range β > 1, which covers most solenoids, important exceptions being “rings” and “pancake” (flat) coils, L(α, β), as seen from the figure, is roughly proportional to α. In fact, when a rough (“ball-park”) value of L suffices, for example, during the “first-cut” design phase, we might use: πα L(α, β) ∼ (for β → 1 from β > 1) (3.82a) 2(β + 0.5) πα L(α, β) ∼ (for β → ∞) (3.82b) 2β For a “thin-walled” solenoid, i.e., α 1, in the limit β → ∞, Eq. 3.82b reduces to π/2β, which will be derived later in PROBLEM 3.18 (Eq. 3.84c, p. 208). 5
β 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.08 0.1
4.5 0.2
4
0.4 β 0.04
0.6 0.8 1
0.1
1.5
2.5
0.2
2
2
0.4
3
1.5
0.6 0.8 1
4 5
1.5 2
10 β
3.5
L(α, β)
3
1
3
0.5 0
7
4 5 7 10
1
1.5 Fig. 3.14
2
2.5
3 α
3.5
4
L(α, β) for solenoidal coil of parameters α and β.
4.5
5
CHAPTER 3
108 3.7.3 Useful Inductance Formulas
Here, useful inductance formulas for coils with nonmagnetic material, i.e., μ = μ◦ , are given. Derivations of some of these formulas are revisited in PROBLEM 3.18. Although analytical expressions for coils of “thick” winding build were derived in the past—well before the proliferation of inductance computer codes—and given in engineering reference books, these formulas, mostly not in SI units, are generally tedious to use. Figure 3.14, or even Eq. 3.82, should be sufficient for inductance computation in most applications, particularly during early design stages. Wire The interior of a wire of radius a per unit length, L [H/m]: L=
μ◦ 8π
(3.83)
“Long” Coils a.
A long (β > 0.75), “thin” coil of i.d. 2a1 with N total turns [3.7]: L = μ◦ a1 N
2
π(1 + α)2 8β
2 (1 + α)2 1− + ··· 3πβ 32β 2
For (α−1)/(α+1) 1 Eq. 3.84a reduces to: π 2 1 2 L = μ◦ a1 N 1− + 2 ··· 2β 3πβ 8β
(3.84a)
(3.84b)
b. For a “very long” (β 1), “thin” (α 1) coil, Eq. 3.84b becomes: L = μ◦ a1 N
2
π 2β
(3.84c)
Thus, as noted above, for a very long and thin coil, L(α, β) = π/2β. “Short” Coil A short (β < 0.75), thin (α 1) coil of i.d. 2a1 with N total turns [3.7]: L μ◦ a1 N 2
α+1 2
2(α + 1) β2 1+ β 2(1 + α2 ) β2 1 − 2 1+ 4(1 + α2 )
ln
which for β 1 becomes: 2(α + 1) 2 α+1 L μ◦ a1 N ln − 0.5 2 β
(3.85a)
(3.85b)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
109
“Pancake” (Flat) Coil A pancake (flat) coil (β 1) of i.d. 2a1 with N total turns [3.7]: L μ◦ a1 N
2
α+1 2
4(α + 1) ln α−1
1+
−
1 2
1−
43 144
1 24
(α − 1)2 (α + 1)2 !
(α − 1)2 (α + 1)2
For (α−1)/(α+1) 1 Eq. 3.86a further reduces to: ! 4(α + 1) α + 1 L μ◦ a1 N 2 ln − 0.5 2 α−1
(3.86a)
(3.86b)
Note that for a “ring” (N = 1), i.e., a1 (α+1) = 2R (ring diameter) and 2a1 β = 2a or a1 (α−1) = 2a (ring wire diameter), both Eqs. 3.85b and 3.86b simplify to:
4R R L μ◦ R ln − 0.5 = μ◦ R ln + 0.886 a a
(3.86c)
Equation 3.86c applies to a ring having a rectangular cross sectional area, while Eq. 3.80a to a ring of circular cross sectional area. For a really fat (α 1) pancake, Eq. 3.86a further simplifies to: 25 101 2 − L 0.5μ◦ a1 αN ln = 0.538μ◦ a1 αN 2 6 288 L ≈ 0.5μ◦ a2 N 2
(3.86d)
Note that it is a2 , not the usual a1 , that appears in Eq. 3.86d. “Ideal” Dipole Magnet The inductance per unit length, L [H/m], of an “ideal” dipole (PROBLEM 3.8)— infinite in length and “zero” winding thickness—with N total turns: L = 81 μ◦ πN 2
(3.87)
“Ideal” Quadrupole Magnet The inductance per unit length, L [H/m], of an “ideal” quadrupole, studied in PROBLEM 3.9, infinite in length and “zero” winding thickness with N total turns: L =
2 1 16 μ◦ πN
(3.88)
Note that for an ideal dipole or quadrupole magnet, the inductance is independent of winding radius, but instead is proportional to length.
CHAPTER 3
110
“Ideal” Circular Cross Section Toroid An “ideal” toroidal coil—PROBLEM 3.10—zero-winding thickness, major radius R, and circular section of radius a with N total turns: " a 2 L = μ◦ RN 2 1 − 1 − (3.89a) R In the limit a R, L may be approximated by: a a 2 L = μ◦ aN 2 1 + 41 + 2R R a μ◦ aN 2 2R
1 8
a 4 R
+ ···
(3.89b) (3.89c)
“Ideal” Rectangular Cross Section Toroid An ideal toroid of major radius R and rectangular section of width (r-axis) 2a and height (z-axis) 2b: R+a 1 ln L = μ◦ bN 2 (3.90a) π R−a In the limit a R, L may be approximated by: a 2 2a L = μ◦ bN 2 1 + 31 + πR R 2a 2 μ◦ bN πR
1 5
a 4 R
+ ···
(3.90b) (3.90c)
My Magnets (Part 1 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist [3.4] My own thoughts ran in the direction of producing constant magnetic fields. There are many experiments that are extremely difficult or impossible to perform in a hundredth of a second. I wondered whether one might design coils having even larger diameters, so that one might put inside them either a thermos bottle with a liquid gas, like liquid air, for maintaining a low temperature, or a furnace for maintaining a high temperature, and still have room left over for experimentation. Questions then arose. How should one wind the coils so that the available power is used most effectively? How much heat could one take out of the surface of a copper conductor by means of a cooling liquid? What sort of flow would be most suitable? What liquid would be most effective? How should it be introduced so that it would not boil away before completing its function? The problem of how to design a coil to give the most intense possible magnetic field with a given supply of electric power is an interesting example to tell you about . . . If one were to wind a coil on a hollow cylinder using different-sized wires for different parts of the coil, was there a best choice of wire sizes? For example, one might use very fine wire for a certain length of the cylinder, then cover this over a longer length with thicker wire . . . It did not take me long to figure this out and to convince myself that an improvement was possible . . .
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
111
3.8 Mutual Inductance When two coils, Coil 1 and Coil 2, are near each other, they usually interact inductively. Their coupling may be quantified by means of the mutual inductance, M12 or M21 . Note that M12 = M21 = M . Thus: M12 ≡ N1
Φ12 Φ21 = M21 ≡ N2 I2 I1
(3.91)
Φ12 is the flux linking the N1 turns of Coil 1 when Coil 2 carries current I2 ; Φ21 is the flux linking the N2 turns of Coil 2 when Coil 1 carries current I1 . The total magnetic energy, Em , in a coupled 2-coil system is given by: Em = 21 L1 I12 + 21 L2 I22 + 21 M12 I1 I2 + 21 M21 I1 I2 = 21 L1 I12 + 21 L2 I22 + M12 I1 I2
(3.92)
As with self inductance, there are mutual inductance formulas for selected systems. For systems of our interest, i.e., coupled coaxial solenoidal coils, a code that computes the self inductance of a coil usually can compute the inductance matrix of a multi-coil system. Series Connected Coils The effective self inductance, Ls , of a two-coil system of L1 , L2 , and M12 , connected in series is given by: Ls = L1 + L2 ± 2M12
(3.93)
The + is chosen for the M12 term if the magnetic fields augment each other and − if they oppose each other. Parallel Connected Coils The effective self inductance, Lp , of a two-coil system of L1 , L2 , and M12 , connected in parallel is given by: Lp =
2 L1 L2 − M12 L1 + L2 ∓ 2M12
Coupling Coefficient Mutual inductance M12 is related to L1 and L2 by: M12 = k L1 L2 M12 k=√ L1 L2
(3.94)
(3.95a) (3.95b)
k is called the coupling coefficient; k = 0 when the coils are uncoupled, and k = 1 when fully coupled. For a tightly nested solenoidal coil pair, in which one coil is in the bore of the other coaxially and concentrically (with the two midplanes coinciding), k ranges 0.3–0.6, being close to 0.6 when their α’s and β’s are similar and towards 0.3 when they are not.
CHAPTER 3
112 3.8.1 Mutual Inductances—Selected Analytic Expressions
Because the force and mutual inductance between coils are related, the analytical expression given earlier for axial forces between Coils A and B may be used to derive mutual inductance expressions. From F = IA IB ∇M , it is evident that expressions for M can be one step more complicated than the axial force expressions given earlier. Therefore only a few simple cases are discussed here. Mutual Inductance between Two “Ring” Coils For two coaxially aligned “ring” coils, Coils A (diameter 2aA ; NA turns) and B (2aB ; NB ), displaced by a distance ρ, the mutual inductance, MAB (ρ), is given by: μ◦ MAB = (NA NB ) (aA + aB )2 + ρ2 2 K(k) − E(k) − k2 K(k) (3.96) 2 where the modulus, k 2 for this system is given by: k2 =
4aA aB (aA + aB )2 + ρ2
Special Case 1: Two Ring Coils Far Apart When the two ring coils are far apart, i.e., ρ2 (aA + aB )2 or k 2 1, Eqs. 3.38c and 3.38a may be used to simplify Eq. 3.96: μ◦ (πaA2 NA )(πaB2 NB ) MAB (3.97) 2π ρ3 Equation 3.97 states that the mutual inductance is approximately proportional to the product of two “total” winding areas—πaA2 NA and πaB2 NB —reduced by ρ3 . Mutual Inductance of a “Thin-Walled” Solenoid and a Ring Coil Here, we consider a coaxially aligned “thin-walled” solenoid (2aS ; uniform turn density NS /2bS ) and a ring coil (diameter 2aR and NR turns). The ring coil is at a distance ρ right of the right-hand end of the solenoid, as shown in Fig. 3.6 (p. 87). The mutual inductance, MRS , between the solenoid and the ring coil is given by: μ◦ NR NS MRS (ρ) = − × 2 2bS ρ [(aR +aS )2 +ρ2 ] K(kR )−E(kR ) −Υ(c2, kR ) (aR +aS )2 +ρ2 2bS +ρ 2 2 2 − [(aR +aS ) +(2bS +ρ) ] K(kS )−E(kS ) −Υ(c , kS ) (aR +aS )2 +(2bS +ρ)2 (3.98) where kr , ks , and c2 are given by: kR2 =
4aR aS ; (aR + aS )2 + ρ2
kS2 =
4aR aS ; (aR + aS )2 +(2bS + ρ)2
c2 =
4aR aS (aR + aS )2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES
113
Special Case 2: Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil Far Apart When these two coils are far apart such that kR2 1, kS2 1, and ρ > bS , Eq. 3.98 may be simplified to: μ◦ NR NS 2π(aR aS )2 bS bS 2 2 2 MRS = 1+ −(aR −aS ) Π(c , kR )−Π(c , kS ) 2 2bS ρ3 ρ (3.99) As long as ρ, though much greater than aR and aS , is still not much greater than bS , the “correction” terms, bS /ρ and that with Π(c2, k)s, must be retained in Eq. 3.99. Special Case 3: Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil Farther Apart When these two coils are farther apart so that ρ bS and the conditions of kR → 0 and kS → 0 are satisfied, Eq. 3.99 may be further simplified to: μ◦ NR NS 2π(aR aS )2 bS MRS = 2 2bS ρ3 2 πaS NS 2bS μ◦ 2 = (πaR NR ) (3.100) 2π 2bS ρ3 Ring Coil at the Middle of a Thin-Walled Solenoid Figure 3.15 shows a schematic arrangement of the two coils, in which the ring coil is at the midplane of a thin-walled solenoid, Note that in this arrangement, ρ = −bS , with ρ defined in Fig. 3.6. Thus by inserting ρ = −bS into Eq. 3.98, we obtain the simplified expression given below: μ◦ NR NS MRS (ρ = −bS ) × 2 2bS 2bS [(aR +aS )2 +bS2 ] K(k)−E(k) −Υ(c2, k) (3.101) (aR +aS )2 +bS2 where k is given by: k2 =
4aR aS (aR + aS )2 + bS2 2bS
NS NS 2aR
Fig. 3.15
2aS
Ring coil at the midplane of a thin-walled solenoid.
CHAPTER 3
114
Special Case 4: “Long” Thin-Walled Solenoid and Ring Coil When the thin-walled solenoid is “long,” specifically when the conditions bS aS and bS aR are met, the relative position between the ring coil and the solenoid is no longer important. For a long solenoid, with k 2 4aR aS /bS2 , Eq. 3.101 becomes: μ◦ NR NS MRS (2) bS2 K(k)−E(k) −Υ(c2, k) 2 2bS μ◦ NR NS 2(aR −aS )2 2 2 2 π(aR + aS ) 1− (3.102) Π(c , k) 2 2bS π(aR2 +aS2 ) The second term within the brackets in Eq. 3.102 may be considered a correction term which becomes negligible in the limit of aR aS or aR aS . Special Case 5: Ring Coil of Widely Differing Diameter When the diameter of the ring coil differs greatly from that of the solenoid, the condition c2 → 0 is satisfied and, as noted earlier (Eq. 3.49b), Π(c2, 0) may be given by the first few terms of the power expansion in c2 . In the limit k 2 → 0 (bS aR and bS aS ), Π(c2, k) → Π(c2, 0) in Eq. 3.102, and using 3.49b, we obtain: μ◦ NR NS (aR −aS )2 1 2 3 4 5 6 2 2 MRS π(aR + aS ) 1− 2 2 1+ 2 c + 8 c + 16 c 2 2bS (aR +aS ) μ◦ NR NS π(aR2 + aS2 )× 2 2bS 2aR aS (aR −aS )2 6(aR aS )2 20(aR aS )3 1− 2 2 1+ + + (3.103) (aR +aS ) (aR +aS )2 (aR +aS )4 (aR +aS )6 3.8.2 Mutual Inductance and Interaction Force Using expressions derived in 3.5.7 for axial restoring force on axially off-centered solenoids, we may derive an expression for axial dependance of the mutual inductance between the two solenoids. A net magnetic force, FAB , between two solenoids, A and B, is related to the total magnetic energy stored in the two solenoids: FAB = ∇EAB
(3.104a)
Inserting Eq. 3.92, with the subscripts 1 and 2 replaced, respectively, by A and B in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.104a, and noting that FAB in the z-direction (with variable ρ) is FzR (ρ), given by Eq. 3.60, we obtain: FzR (ρ) = For small ρ (ρ
∂MAB (ρ) ∂EAB = IA IB ∂ρ ∂ρ
(3.105b)
aT2 +bD2 ), we may integrate FzR (ρ) given by Eq. 3.61: MAB (ρ) − MAB (0) ∝ −ρ2
(3.106)
For small ρ, MAB (ρ) thus decreases as ρ2 , the square of the off-center distance.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
115
Magnetic Field (H ) and Magnetic Induction (B) Unless otherwise qualified, every magnet in PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS is aircored, i.e., the magnetic induction, B, is simply related to the magnetic field, H, by the magnetic permeability of air, which is virtually equal to that of vacuum μ◦ = 4π × 10−7 H/m: B = μ◦ H. Often, especially by engineers, the unit of B, tesla [T], is used for the unit of field H, ampere/meter [A/m]. Most likely, this practice of interchanging B and H stems from: 1) B [gauss] and H [oersted] are numerically equal in the cgs (centimeter-gram-second) electromagnetic unit; and 2) gauss is more universally used than oersted. In the 2nd Edition, most of field equations originally given in H in the 1st Edition are given in B.
DISCUSSION 3.1: Uniform-Current-Density Solenoids Here, the basics of a uniform-current-density solenoid, of winding i.d. 2a1 , winding o.d. 2a2 , and total winding length 2b, are first discussed. Figure 3.16 defines the winding cross section—because we are dealing with an axisymmetric solenoid, only the z- and r-axes are considered. The differential magnetic field induction at the center, dBz (0, 0) [T], generated by a current-carrying ring of differential cross section dA [A/m2 ] located at (r, z) is given by an equivalent form of Eq. 3.3a: dBz (0, 0) =
μ◦ r2 λJ dA 2(r2 + z 2 )3/2
(3.107)
where λJ [A/m2 ] is the overall current density within the differential cross section. The dimensionless number λ, called the space factor, acknowledges that not all the winding cross section is occupied by current-carrying conductors. Note that λJ in this model is uniform over the winding cross section and given by: λJ = =
NI 2b(a2 − a1 )
(3.108a)
NI 2a21 β(α
(3.108b)
− 1)
where, once again, α = a2 /a1 and β = b/a1 . N is the total number of turns, and N I is often called the total ampere-turns. λJdA
2b
z
Bz (0, 0)
r
2a1 2a2 Fig. 3.16
Cross section of a uniform-current-density solenoid.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
116
DISCUSSION 3.1: Uniform-Current-Density Solenoids (continuation) By integrating Eq. 3.107 from r = a1 to r = a2 and from z = −b to z = b, we obtain an expression for Bz (0, 0) for the solenoid, given in terms of Hz (0, 0) in 3.4 by Eq. 3.13a and the field factor F (α, β) by Eq. 3.13b: Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 F (α, β) α + α2 + β 2 F (α, β) = β ln 1 + 1 + β2
(3.109) (3.13b)
As stated earlier, F (α, β) is the “field factor” for a uniform-current-density coil and, like the inductance parameter L(α, β) in Eq. 3.81, it depends only on the cross-sectional shape of a solenoidal coil. Three graphs of F (α, β) are shown in Fig. 3.17: F (α, β) vs. α with constant β lines (dashed) in Fig. 3.17a; F (α, β) vs. β with constant α lines (dashed) in Fig. 3.17b; and β vs. α for constant F (α, β) lines (dashed) in Fig. 3.17c [3.8]. The total conductor volume in a solenoid, Vcd = λ2πa31 (α2−1)β, depends, for given λ and a1 , only on α and β, as does F (α, β): each point on the heavy line in each graph has the minimum volume for a given F (α, β). Salient features of F (α, β) are noted in connection with special coils discussed in PROBLEM 3.1 below.
5 β
10
76
4
5
4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8
3 F (α, β) 2
0.6
1
0.4 0
0.2 0.1 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
α Fig. 3.17a F (α, β) vs. α for constant β lines (dashed). The heavy curve represents the minimum conductor volume for a solenoid coil of given F (α, β).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
117
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.1: Uniform-Current-Density Solenoids (continuation) 8 α
7
200 100 50
20
10
15
9 8
6
7 6.5 6 5.5 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1.1 7
5 F (α, β)
4 3 2 1 0
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
8
β Fig. 3.17b F (α, β) vs. β for constant α lines (dashed). The heavy curve represents the minimum conductor volume for a solenoid coil of given F (α, β).
8 7 F (α, β) 5.5 6 5 4.5
5 β
3.5
4
4
3 2.5 2
3 1
0.5
2
1.5
0.25 1 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
α Fig. 3.17c β vs. α for constant F (α, β) lines (dashed). The heavy curve represents the minimum conductor volume for a solenoid coil of given F (α, β).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
118
PROBLEM 3.1: “Simple” solenoids* a) Starting with Eq. 3.107, derive Eqs. 3.109 and 3.13b. b) By combining Eqs. 3.108b and 3.109 we may also express Bz (0, 0) by: μ◦ N I α + α2 + β 2 Bz (0, 0) = ln (3.110) 2a1 (α − 1) 1 + 1 + β2 “Ring” Coil Simplify Eq. 3.110 for a “ring” coil (α = 1) of radius a1 carrying total current N I and reduce it to: μ◦ N I Bz (0, 0) = (3.111a) 2a1 “Thin-Walled” Solenoid: Show that for a “thin-walled” solenoid (α → 1) Eq. 3.110 is simplified to: μ◦ N I 1 Bz (0, 0) = (3.111b) 2a1 1 + β2 Also show:
β Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 (α − 1) (3.111c) 1 + β2 “Long” Solenoid: Simplify Eq. 3.110 for the case of a solenoid that is much longer than its outer winding diameter, i.e., β α, and reduce it to: μ◦ N I Bz (0, 0) = (3.111d) 2b
Because N I/2b = Kθ , Eq. 3.111d is equivalent to Eq. 3.5. Also, show that: Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 (α − 1)
(3.111e)
“Pancake” Coil: Simplify Eq. 3.110 this time for a winding that is very short compared with its outer winding diameter and reduce it to: μ◦ N I ln α Bz (0, 0) = (3.111f ) 2a1 α−1 Equation 3.111f is valid for “pancake” coils (see DISCUSSION 3.6 ). c) Field vs. Power: Show that an expression for the center field Bz (0, 0) in a resistive, e.g., copper, solenoid is related to its power requirement, P , by: λP Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ G(α, β) (3.112a) ρcd a1 G(α, β) =
β α + α2 + β 2 ln 2π(α2 − 1) 1 + 1 + β2
(3.112b)
where ρcd is the conductor’s electrical resistivity. G(α, β) is known as the G factor for a uniform-current-density coil [3.2]. * Based on Problem 3.1 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
119
Solution to PROBLEM 3.1 a) By integrating Eq. 3.107 over the appropriate limits for z- and r-coordinates, we have: a2 b μ◦ λJ a2 b r2 dz dr r2 dz dr Bz (0, 0) = = μ λJ ◦ 2 2 3/2 2 2 3/2 2 a1 −b (r + z ) a1 0 (r + z ) From a table of integrals we have: 0
b
b dz z b √ = = √ 2 2 3/2 2 2 2 2 (r + z ) r r +z 0 r r 2 + b2
Thus:
a2 r2 b dr √ = μ◦ λJb ln r + r2 + b2 2 r 2 + b2 a1 a1 r
= μ◦ λJb ln a2 + a22 + b2 − ln a1 + a21 + b2 a2
Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJ
= μ◦ λJa1
a2 /a1 + (a2 /a1 )2 + (b/a1 )2 b ln a1 (a1 /a1 ) + (a1 /a1 )2 + (b/a1 )2
With a2 /a1 = α and b/a1 = β, Eq. S1.1 becomes: α + α2 + β 2 Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 β ln 1 + 1 + β2
(S1.1)
(S1.2)
Thus: Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 F (α, β) α + α2 + β 2 F (α, β) = β ln 1 + 1 + β2
(3.109) (3.13b)
b) “Ring” Coil For a ring coil (α → 1; β → 0), the logarithmic term in the right-hand side of Eq. 3.110 becomes: α + α2 + β 2 lim ln = ln α β→0 1 + 1 + β2 In the limit α → 1, ln α → α−1, because ln(1 + ) = for || 1. Thus: Bz (0, 0) =
μ◦ N I μ◦ N I (α − 1) = 2a1 (α − 1) 2a1
(3.111a)
Note that Eq. 3.111a, except for μ◦ , is equivalent to Eq. 3.3a evaluated at z = 0, with a and I replaced, respectively, by a1 and N I.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
120
Solution to PROBLEM 3.1 (continuation) “Thin-Walled” Solenoid For a thin-walled solenoid (α → 1), we can combine Eqs. 3.13b and 3.23b to obtain: α + α2 + β 2 α−1 lim ln = (S1.3) 2 α→1 1+ 1+β 1 + β2 Combining Eqs. 3.110 and S1.3, we derive Eq. 3.111b; and from Eqs. 3.109, 3.13b, and S1.3, Eq. 3.111c: μ◦ N I 1 Bz (0, 0) = (3.111b) 2a1 1 + β2 β Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 (α − 1) 1 + β2
(3.111c)
Note that for a “long” solenoid (β 1), Eq. 3.111c becomes Eq. 3.111e. For β α, we have: α + α2 + β 2 α+β α/β + 1 lim ln = ln = ln βα 1+β 1/β + 1 1 + 1 + β2
“Long” Solenoid
The same approximation in “Ring” Coil, ln(1 + ) = for || 1, may be used: α/β + 1 α 1 α−1 lim ln − = βα 1/β + 1 β β β In the limit β α, we thus obtain: μ◦ N I (3.111d) 2b As remarked above, N I/2b may be considered a surface current density. From Eq. 3.108, N I/(2b) = λJ(a2 −a1 ), Eq. 3.111d may also be expressed as: Bz (0, 0) =
Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λJa1 (α − 1)
(3.111e)
For a long solenoid, the center field is independent of its length (β)—this virtual independency of Bz (0, 0) on β for “large” β ( > ∼ 3) and “moderate” α (< β) is evident from F (α, β) vs. β plots (Fig. 3.17b). Also, Bz (0, 0) is proportional to the winding build, (a2−a1 ), which makes perfect sense because the greater the winding build, the greater is the total ampere-turns per unit length—this is evident from F (α, β) vs. α plots for large β and moderate α (< β) shown in Fig. 3.17a. “Pancake” Coil
For a “pancake” coil, the appropriate limit is β → 0: α + α2 + β 2 2α lim ln = ln = ln α 2 β→0 2 1+ 1+β μ◦ N I ln α Bz (0, 0) = (3.111f ) 2a1 α−1
Note that the central field of a pancake coil is equal to that of a “ring” coil times a factor ln α/(α − 1). In the limit α → 1, Eq. 3.111f reduces to Eq. 3.111a.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
121
Solution to PROBLEM 3.1 (continuation) c)
Total conductor volume is equal to λ × <winding volume>: < winding volume > = 2bπ(a22 − a21 ) = a31 2πβ(α2 − 1)
And thus:
P = ρcd J 2 λa31 2πβ(α2 − 1)
(3.112)
where J is the current density in the conductor only. From Eq. 3.112, we can solve for J in terms of P and other parameters: P 1 J= (S1.4) ρcd λa1 a1 2πβ(α2 − 1) Combining Eqs. S1.2 and S1.4, we obtain: P 1 α + α2 + β 2 Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ λ a1 β ln ρcd λa1 a1 2πβ(α2 − 1) 1 + 1 + β2 = μ◦
λP ρcd a1
β α + α2 + β 2 ln 2π(α2 − 1) 1 + 1 + β2
Thus:
Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ G(α, β) G(α, β) =
λP ρcd a1
α + α2 + β 2 β ln 2π(α2 − 1) 1 + 1 + β2
(3.113a)
(3.113b)
Equation 3.113a implies that in resistive solenoids the required power P for a given set of α and β, increases quadratically with the central magnetic field: P =
ρcu a1 Bz2 (0, 0) μ2◦ λG2 (α, β)
(3.113c)
My Magnets (Part 2 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist . . . By using a variable-size wire in the construction of a coil, I found it possible to increase the magnetic field at the center by a factor of just 1.52 over the best design for a coil with a uniform winding. Therefore, by going into all kinds of practical complications, one could improve the performance of coils only one and a half times or a little more. However, this now was settled; there was no use worrying about it any more. In the end these calculations did show me a practical way of improving the performance of coils by an appreciable amount.
122
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.2 “Bitter” Magnet Although this book deals primarily with superconducting magnets, here we discuss the iron-free, water-cooled electromagnet. We may call the development of DC high-field, water-cooled (“water”) magnet—“Bitter” magnet—that Francis Bitter initiated at M.I.T. in the 1930s as the basis for modern magnet technology. Passages from his book Magnets [3.4] are placed in this chapter to describe, in his own words, the technical challenges and solutions for high-field magnets, including pulse magnets of Kapitza, and a chronology of Bitter’s activities in the 1930s. Bitter’s design employed a conductor in the form of a stack of annular plates, each with a slit and separated by a thin sheet of insulation except over a sector. The slit allows the bare sector to pressure-contact the next plate’s bare sector, enabling the current to commutate from one plate to the next in a quasi-helical path as it flows from one end of the stack to the other. Each “Bitter” plate is punched with hundreds of cooling holes. To generate a high field, tens of thousands of amperes of current are pushed through the electrically resistive stack, consuming megawatts of electrical power, which heat the stack. This heat is removed by water forced through the cooling holes at high velocity, ∼20 m/s. A silhouette of two nested “Florida-Bitter” plates, developed in the 1990s at the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (NHMFL), is shown in Fig. 3.18 [3.9]. A radial slit in each plate is clearly visible. Also note that each water passage hole is not circular as in Bitter’s plates; the elongated—in the direction of current—shape was first developed by Weggel at M.I.T. in the 1970s. The outer plate of the set here is 148 mm in diameter; plate sizes have been more than 400 mm in diameter. The sixteen large holes are for axially clamping the plates with tie rods. A key feature of the Bitter magnet construction is that it is modular, consisting of many similar plates. Plate thickness, mechanical properties, and electrical properties can be tailored to the axial position to optimize magnet performance.
Fig. 3.18 Silhouette of two nested “Florida-Bitter” plates, with an outer plate of 140 mm in diameter, in “water” magnets at the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory [3.9].
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
123
DISCUSSION 3.2 Bitter Magnet (continuation) As evident from Eq. 3.110 (PROBLEM 3.1), the smaller the inner winding radius, a1 , the higher the central field, Bz (0, 0), for a given total ampere-turns, N I. Also, for the same power consumption, P , reducing a1 generates a higher Bz (0, 0) (Eq. 3.113a). That is, to maximize Bz (0, 0) for a given power, it is most efficient to place ampere-turns close to the magnet bore. The Bitter design, in which J ∝ 1/r (seen below), is a practical approach to approximate this goal. A. Current Density, Field, Power Here we derive expressions for [Jθ (r)]B (current density), [Bz (0, 0)]B (center field), [F (α, β)]B (field-factor), and [G(α, β)]B (G-factor) for the Bitter magnet. Current Density Distribution We consider a single disk, in which current flows in the θ-direction. The resulting is only θ-directed (Eθ ) and E field gives a voltage V proportional to θ. Because E it is constant at a given r, Eθ 2πr = V . That is, Eθ varies as 1/r, and because cu , we have: J = E/ρ Eθ V a1 [Jθ (r)]B = = = J0 (3.114) ρcu 2πρcu r r where J0 = [Jθ (a1 )]B = V /(2πρcu a1 ). Equation 3.114 shows that in the Bitter magnet current density decreases as 1/r, with its maximum at r = a1 . Field We may substitute Jθ (r) given by Eq. 3.114 for λJ, a constant, in Eq. 3.107 and integrate over appropriate limits: a2 b α β r dr dz η dη dζ [Bz (0, 0)]B = μ◦ λB J0 a1 = μ λ J a ◦ B 0 1 2 2 3/2 2 2 3/2 a1 0 (r + z ) 1 0 (η + ζ ) where r/a1 = η and z/a1 = ζ. From a table of integrals, we have: β β dζ β ζ = = 2 + ζ 2 )3/2 2 2 2 2 (η η η +ζ η η2 + β 2 0 0
Combining the above two equations, we have: α α η dη 1 β + β 2 +η 2 [Bz (0, 0)]B = μ◦ λB J0 a1 β = μ◦ λB J0 a1 β − ln 2 β η η 2 +β 2 1 η 1 β + 1 + β2 [Bz (0, 0)]B = μ◦ λB J0 a1 ln α β + α2 + β 2 We may express the above expression as: [Bz (0, 0)]B = μ◦ λB J0 a1 [F (α, β)]B β + 1 + β2 [F (α, β)]B = ln α β + α2 + β 2 Note that there is a subtle difference between Eqs. 3.115b and 3.13b.
(3.115a) (3.115b)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
124
DISCUSSION 3.2 Bitter Magnet (continuation) Field and Power We may derive an expression relating [Hz (0, 0)]B and PB , the total power in the Bitter magnet, by integrating power density, ρcu [Jθ ]2B (r), over the entire winding volume. Again, using dimensionless parameters, we have: 2 α β J0 PB = a31 ρcu λB 2πη dζ dη = J02 ρcu λB a31 (4πβ ln α) η 1 −β From the above expression, we may relate J0 and PB : 1 PB J0 = √ a1 4πβ ln α ρcu λB a1 and combine this with Eqs. 3.115 to relate [Bz (0, 0)]B and PB : λ B PB [Bz (0, 0)]B = μ◦ [G(α, β)]B ρcu a1
(3.116a)
where [G(α, β)]B = √
1 [F (α, β)]B 4πβ ln α
(3.116b)
As in uniform-current-density solenoids, [Bz (0, 0)]B increases as the square root of PB ; PB is a quadratic function of field. The maximum of [G(α, β)]B occurs when α 6.42 and β 2.15: [G(6.4, 2.15)]B 0.166. [G(α, β)]B is at least 99% of its peak value for 5 ≤ α ≤ 9 and 1.8 ≤ β ≤ 2.6. That is, PB for a given field is within 2% of minimum throughout this range of α and β. However, because field homogeneity for a given value of a1 improves with 2b or β, most Bitter magnets have β values greater than 2.5, as in the magnet considered below. Illustration We may apply Eq. 3.116 to compute PB for a Bitter magnet of 2a1 = 6 cm, 2a2 = 40 cm, 2b = 22 cm, λB = 0.8, and ρcu = 2×10−6 Ω cm, generating [Bz (0, 0)]B = 20 T. With α = (a2 /a1 ) = 40/6 = 6.67; β = (b/a1 ) = 22/6 = 3.67, 3.67+ 1+(3.67)2 1 [G(6.67, 3.67)]B = ln 6.67 0.159 4π3.67 ln(6.67) 3.67+ (6.67)2 +(3.67)2 We have an expression of PB , similar to Eq. 3.113c, in terms of [Bz (0, 0)]B and other parameters: PB = =
ρcu a1 [Bz (0, 0)]2B μ2◦ λB [G(α, β)]2B (2×10−8 Ω m)(3×10−2 m)(20 T)2 7.5 MW (4π×10−7 H/m)2 (0.8)(0.159)2
This power is typical of 20-T Bitter magnets that were operated at the Francis Bitter National Magnet Laboratory.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
125
DISCUSSION 3.2 Bitter Magnet (continuation) B. Current Density Distributions Other Than “Bitter” One important parameter in water-cooled magnets is field efficiency, defined as the square of the field at the magnet center divided by the total power input to the magnet: [Bz (0, 0)]2B /μ2◦ PB . As with uniform-current-density magnets, field efficiency defined for Bitter magnets is proportional to λB and [G(α, β)]2B and inversely proportional to a1 and conductor resistivity ρcu . We have considered two current density distributions so far: 1) uniform, J(r, z) = J◦ , and 2) Bitter, J(r, z) ∝ 1/r. The uniform distribution means J is independent of r and z. Superconducting magnets wound with “graded” conductors have J(r) that changes with r in discrete steps. Those consisting of many nested coils, each of which is wound with a different conductor, also have J(r) distributions that change in discrete steps. We describe here three other current distributions of interest for water-cooled magnets [3.3]. Kelvin Coil The current density that gives the best field efficiency is known as the Kelvin distribution, JK (r, z): r JK (r, z) ∝ 2 (r + z 2 )3/2 Its unique feature is that every portion of the Kelvin coil produces the same field per unit power. In comparison with a Kelvin coil, a uniform-current-density coil for the same total power produces 66% of field at the magnet center; for a Bitter coil, the ratio is 77%. It is not feasible to fabricate coils having the Kelvin current density. Gaume The Gaume distribution, JG (r, z), also gives a good field efficiency: 1 1 1 JG (r, z) ∝ − 2 r a21 + z 2 a2 + z 2 The Gaume coils make each turn produce the same field per unit power as every other turn. A Gaume coil produces 85% of the field of a Kelvin coil. The current distribution of Bitter coils often approximates to a degree the Gaume distribution. This is achieved by using thicker Bitter plates axially away from the magnet midplane: JB (r, z) ∝ 1/rδ(z), where δ(z) is the z-dependent plate thickness. Polyhelix A polyhelix coil consists of many nested single-layer coils, in which the current density of each layer is adjusted to maximize the field efficiency and/or to match the stress in each layer to its conductor strength: JP (r, z) ∝ f (r) A polyhelix coil of maximum efficiency, with JP (r, z) ∝ 1/r2 , generates 92% of a Kelvin coil field. In practice, because of the need to have many electrodes at both ends, polyhelix coils are considered more difficult to manufacture than Bitter coils.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
126
PROBLEM 3.2: Maximum field in a solenoidal coil Although the axial field at the center of a magnet is one of the parameters often specified by the magnet user, an equally important parameter for the designer is the maximum field to which the magnet is exposed. In a single solenoidal magnet, as may be inferred from Eq. 3.12b, the axial field at the midplane, Hz (r, 0), within the bore increases radially away from the axis. Indeed, the maximum field, Hm , axially directed, occurs at the midplane and innermost winding radius point: Hm = Hz (a1 , 0). In multi-coil magnets comprised of nested coils, the maximum field in any but the innermost coil, because of the fields generated by the remaining coils, is generally not axially directed and occurs at points away from (a1 , 0). Again, this topic is treated here only to enhance the reader’s understanding of field distribution of a simple solenoid. In an actual multi-coil magnet, one must rely on a code to compute the maximum field and its location for each coil. a) Using expressions in 3.4, show for a “thin-walled” coil (α = 1) an expression for Hz (r, 0)/Hz (0, 0) = hz (ξ), where ξ = r/a1 , is given by: hz (ξ) = 1 +
3 15(3−4β 2 ) 4 35(5−20β 2 +8β 4 ) 6 2 ξ + ξ + ξ 4(1+β 2 )2 64(1+β 2 )4 256(1+β 2 )6
+
315(35−280β 2 +336β 4 −64β 6 ) 8 ξ 16384(1+β 2 )8
+
693(63−840β 2 +2016β 4 −1152β 6 +128β 8 ) 10 ξ 65536(1+β 2 )10 (3.117a)
b) Also, show that for a “short” coil (β = 0) an expression for hz (ξ) is given by: 3(α2 −1) 2 45(α4 −1) 4 175(α6 −1) 6 ξ + hz (ξ) = 1 + ξ + ξ 8α2 ln α 256α4 ln α 1536α6 ln α +
11025(α8 −1) 8 43659(α10 −1) 10 ξ + ξ + ··· 131072α8 ln α 655360α10 ln α
(3.117b)
c) Similarly, show for a “thin-walled and long” coil, hz (ξ) is given by: hz (ξ) 1 +
3 2 15 4 35 6 315 8 693 10 ξ − ξ + ξ − ξ + ξ − ··· 4 6 8 10 4β 16β 32β 256β 512β 12 (3.117c)
d) Compute an approximate value of Hm /Hz (0, 0) ≡ hm for a “thin-walled” (α = 1) and relatively short coil with β = 0.4. e) Calculate hm for a pancake coil of α = 2 and β 0. f ) Determine hm for a “thin-walled” and “long” coil of α = 1 and β = 2. Note that for a single solenoid of a set of any α and β values, Hm /Hz (0, 0) may be given by hz (ξ) obtained by combining Eqs. 3.12b and 3.14.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
127
Solution to PROBLEM 3.2 a) When considering Hz (r, 0), which in the midplane is equivalent to Hz (x, 0) or Hz (y, 0), we use Eq. 3.12b where ξ = x/a1 , ξ = y/a1 , or ξ = r/a1 . For a “thinwalled” solenoid, we may then combine Eqs. 3.12b and 3.25 to obtain Eq. 3.117a. b)
Similarly, Eq. 3.117b may be obtained by combining Eqs. 3.12b and 3.21.
c) We obtain Eq. 3.117c by combining Eqs. 3.12b and 3.26. Note that unlike Eq. 3.117b in which the signs of the higher terms are all pluses, the signs in Eq. 3.117c alternate. d) Inserting β = 0.4 and ξ = 1 into Eq. 3.117a, we obtain: hm = 1 + 0.5574 + 0.3055 + 0.1125 − 0.0086 − 0.0585 = 1.9082 The Hm /Hz (0, 0) vs. α plots for constant values of β and F (α, β) by Montgomery [3.2], give a value of 1.87. e)
Inserting α = 2 and ξ = 1 into Eq. 3.117b, we obtain: hm 1 + 0.4058 + 0.2378 + 0.1618 + 0.1209 + 0.0960 = 2.0222
f)
Inserting β = 2 and ξ = 1 into Eq. 3.117a, we obtain: hm 1 + 0.03 − 0.0049 + 0.0005 + 0.0000 − 0.0000 = 1.0256
A quicker but less accurate solution may be obtained from Eq. 3.117c, which is really valid for β 1: hm 1 + 0.0469 − 0.0146 + 0.0043 − 0.0012 + 0.0003 = 1.0356
My Magnets (Part 3 of 3 Parts)
—Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist The next point was to estimate how much heat could actually be removed from every square centimeter of surface. And here I ran into a great disappointment. The engineers of that time never had tried to remove a lot of heat from the surface . . . It seemed that water would be a suitable cooling medium. What would happen if the temperature of the pipes or holes through which the water flowed was at the boiling point of water, or above? Would steam layers be formed, such as are formed when you spit on a hot stove?. . . We discovered (from experiments) that it was possible to take very much more heat out of every square centimeter of surface than had been recorded . . . We found that in turbulent flow any steam layer that is formed is immediately scooped up into the body of the liquid, the steam is condensed, and that heat is transferred to the liquid without the continued existence of the steam layer. An important number for my design was 200 watts per square centimeter . . . Rather than explore the possible limits to discover whether one could go even further, we decided to stop at this point and build magnets based on this figure.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
128
DISCUSSION 3.3: Load Lines A. Solenoid Magnet Wound with “Isotropic” Superconductor Figure 3.19 shows the critical current Ic vs. B curve of an “isotropic” superconductor at a constant temperature T◦ , Ic (B, T◦ ), and two sets of “load lines” for a solenoid magnet wound with the superconductor. Here, the Ic (B, T◦ ) curve is isotropic, i.e., Ic (B, T◦ ) is independent of field direction, the condition generally met with superconductors of circular cross section. The load lines, solid and dashed, that emerge from the origin (0, 0) correspond to the “self” fields of the magnet energized alone: the solid line corresponds to the axial center field, Bz (0, 0), and the dashed line to the maximum field within the winding, Bmx —for a simple solenoid magnet Bmx occurs at the winding inside radius (r = a1 ) and the axial midplane (z = 0), Bmx = Bz (a1 , 0). The intercept of the Ic (B, T◦ ) point and the dashed load line is the maximum operating current, Iop (Bmx , T◦ ), achievable by this magnet, still fully superconducting. When a magnet is placed in the bore of another magnet, the field generated by this “background-field” magnet must be added to the load lines of the inside magnet, the so-called “insert”—in a combined system the two magnets are generally coaxial with the midplanes coincident. The solid load line emerging from Bb◦ on the Baxis corresponds to the center field of the combined system, while the dashed line to the maximum insert field—note that the dashed line starts from a field slightly greater than Bb◦ , because the background field there is greater; the intercept of the Ic (B, T◦ ) point and the dashed line gives the maximum operating current, Iop (Bmxb , T◦ ), for this combined magnet system. For various reasons, some of which are discussed in later chapters, a superconducting magnet, alone or in a combined system, is generally designed to operate at a current 50–70% of its maximum possible current. Ic (B, T◦ )
Ic (0, T◦ ) Load lines (no background field) Iop (Bmx , T◦ ) Load lines (in center field of Bb◦ ) Iop (Bmxb , T◦ ) 0
0
Bmx
Bb◦ Bmxb
B
Fig. 3.19 Critical current Ic vs. B curve of an “isotropic” superconductor at a constant temperature T◦ , Ic (B, T◦ ), and two sets of “load lines” for a solenoid magnet, by itself and placed in the bore of another magnet generating a background center field of Bb◦ .
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
129
DISCUSSION 3.3: Load Lines (continuation) B. Solenoid Magnet Wound with “Anisotropic” Superconductor For noncircular-cross-section superconductors, Ic (B, T◦ ) is generally “anisotropic,” i.e., Ic (B, T◦ ) depends on the field orientation relative to the cross section. Prominent examples of noncircular-cross-section superconductors are high-temperature superconductors, Bi2223 and YBCO, that are available only in tape form. In APPENDIX V are presented Ic (B, T )/Ic (sf, 77 K) plots—Ic (B, T ) data normalized to Ic (sf, 77 K) data—for Bi2223 and YBCO, where sf stands for “self field,” the field generated by the transport current alone; for each superconductor two sets of data are given, one in which the applied external field, B, is parallel (B ) to the tape superconductor’s “broad” surface normal to the current direction, and the other in which B is perpendicular (B⊥ ) to the surface. For both Bi2223 and YBCO, Ic (B, T◦ ) decreases more sharply with B⊥ than with B . Also note that for both superconductors, Ic (B), in both field directions, decreases more sharply with B at higher T◦ . As may be inferred from the field lines in Fig. 3.3 of a solenoid magnet, the radial component of the field, Br , which is exactly zero at the solenoid axial midplane (z = 0), increases in the ±z and r directions, with a peak radial field, [Br (α, β)]pk , occurring at z = ±b and a1 < r < a2 . No closed-form analytical expression of [Br (α, β)]pk exists. However, for most single solenoids, i.e., 1 ≤ α ≤ 3.6 and 0.1 ≤ β ≤ 10, and for a preliminary (even before the first-cut ) design of a tapebased magnet, e.g., a stack of “double-pancake” coils (DISCUSSION 3.6 ), Eq. 3.118 below gives [Br (α, β)]pk to within ±30% of those computed with a code. [Br (α, β)]pk 0.3 0.6 ≈ 2 + Bz (0, 0) α β α
(3.118)
Note that for thin- and medium-walled (α ≤ 1.8) and “short” (β < 1) solenoids, [Br (α, β)]pk can exceed Bz (0, 0), e.g., [Br (α = 1.1, β = 0.1)]pk ≈ 3Bz (0, 0)! In a tape-wound magnet, therefore, the intercept of a load line corresponding to the maximum perpendicular field, B⊥ , i.e., [Br (α, β)]pk , and the conductor’s Ic (B⊥ , T◦ ) curve may limit its operating current rather than the maximum B (= Bz ) load line corresponding to the Ic (B , T◦ ) curve. Also, because B⊥ varies over the height of the tape (tape width) itself in the winding, this variation may have to be included in computing the maximum operating current. Voccio recently formulated an analytical approach to determine the maximum operating current for “pancake coils” wound with Bi2223 and YBCO tapes [3.10].
TRIVIA 3.2 Which one of the cooling water flow rates (liters/min) below is closest for a 31-T (24 MW) water magnet at the NHMFL? i) 150,000;
ii) 15,000;
iii) 1,500;
iv) 150.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
130
DISCUSSION 3.4: Superposition Technique The law of Biot-Savart as applied in solving field problems essentially states that a magnetic field at a point in a solenoid is the vector sum (superposition) of fields generated by all current elements within the solenoid. Here we apply a superposition technique to the entire body of a solenoid and compute the axial field at any point on the axis of a solenoid. This technique, though limited to the field on the axis only, is introduced to enhance the reader’s general understanding of field generation by a solenoid. A. End Field The axial end field of an axially symmetric solenoid is half the center field of a solenoid of identical composition but twice the length of the original. We may visualize this by considering an axially symmetric solenoid comprised of two identical sections, each of the original length 2b (Fig. 3.20). The axial center field of the new solenoid is the sum of two equal fields, generated by the two sections: H(b) = H(α, β)|z=b = 21 H(α, 2β)|z=0 = 21 λJa1 [F (α, 2β)]
(3.119)
Because F (α, 2β) > F (α, β) (Fig. 3.17b), it follows that H(z = b) > 0.5H(0). That is, the end axial field of a solenoid is always greater than half its central field. Note that H(z = b) → 0.5H(0) in the limit β → ∞. B. Off-Center Axial Fields The technique may also be applied to compute the axial field at any location along the solenoid axis. Two off-center cases are considered here: 1) 0 < z < b, i.e., within the solenoid bore; and 2) z > b, i.e., outside the bore. Figure 3.21 illustrates the procedure for applying this superposition technique for each case. We thus have: b+z F α, β = +F (Case 1: z < b) H(z) = a1 b+z 1 (Case 2: z > b) H(z) = 2 λJa1 F α, β = −F a1 1 2 λJa1
b−z α, β = a1
z −b α, β = a1
(3.120a) (3.120b)
↑
× ←
2b
→
=
1 2×
⊗ ←
4b
2a1
↓
→
Fig. 3.20 In a superposition technique, the end field of an axially symmetric solenoid of length 2b may be computed as half of the center field of a solenoid of the same construction having length 4b.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
131
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.4: Superposition Technique (continuation) Case 1: z < b →
⊗ ← ←
z
←
×
ORIGINAL COIL
→
b+z
← →
b−z
2b
= ⊗
1 2×
←
→
2b+2z
+ ⊗
1 2×
←
→
2b−2z
Case 2: z > b ←
→
z
⊗ ← ←
2b b+z
× →
ORIGINAL COIL
→ =
1 × 2
⊗ ←
→
2b+2z
− 1 × 2
→ Fig. 3.21
⊗ ←
2z −2b
Superposition technique for off-center axial points. Case 1: z < b; Case 2:z > b.
132
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.5: Hybrid Magnet A “hybrid” magnet comprises two axially aligned and centered electromagnet “species:” a high-power water-cooled (“water”) magnet in the bore of a superconducting magnet (SCM). It was conceived in the mid 1960s by Montgomery and others at the National Magnet Laboratory (NML) as a means to achieve DC fields above ∼25 T [3.11], the highest DC field achievable by Bitter magnets with the power of 9 MW then available. For the next three decades, the Magnet Lab contributed to the development of hybrid magnet technologies by designing, building, and operating several hybrid magnets [3.12–3.18]. A. Selected Hybrid Magnet Facilities There are several hybrid magnet facilities now operating. Selected hybrid magnets are briefly described below in the chronological order of their operation. High Field Magnet Laboratory, Radboud University, Nijmegen Since 1977 the High Field Magnet Laboratory (HFML) at Nijmegen has operated two hybrid magnets, 25.4 T [3.12] and 32 T [3.14, 3.15], powered by a 6-MW supply [3.19]. With its newly installed 20-MW supply [3.20] and advanced “water” magnets [3.21], a 45-T hybrid magnet is scheduled to begin operation in 2012. High Field Laboratory, Tohoku University, Sendai In operation since 1983 with a 7.5-MW supply [3.22], the High Field Laboratory has replaced its 23-T “wet” hybrid with a “dry” version that generates 30 T [3.23]. For a facility hybrid magnet that must undergo many field-sweep sequences, its SCM should ideally be dry and of HTS. A dry cryostat avoids loss of liquid cryogen after a trip in its water-cooled magnet; an HTS magnet can tolerate a much greater rise in its operating temperature, caused by AC losses, than its LTS counterpart. CHAPTER 4 discusses two design/operation options that should enable even a dry HTS magnet to operate reliably under the facility operation conditions of a hybrid magnet: 1) a volume of solid cryogen in the HTS magnet chamber; and 2) a cryocirculator (DISCUSSION 4.7 ) rather than a cryocooler as the primary cooling source for the SCM. Grenoble High Magnetic Field Laboratory The Grenoble Magnet Laboratory began its hybrid magnet operation in 1987 [3.24]. Its latest 24-MW supply [3.25] is for a 40-T hybrid magnet [3.26]. Magnet Laboratory, National Research Institute of Materials Science In operation since 1995, the Magnet Laboratory at the National Institute of Materials Science at Tsukuba, with its 17-MW supply, operates 30–35 T hybrids [3.27]. National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (NHMFL) The 45-T hybrid magnet [3.28, 3.29] of the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory (NHMFL) at Florida State University generates the highest DC magnetic field in the world. Currently, the water magnet generates 34 T and the SCM generates 11 T [3.30]. The SCM is discussed in more detail below.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
133
DISCUSSION 3.5: Hybrid Magnet (continuation) B. NHMFL 45-T Hybrid Magnet Figure 3.22 shows a cross-sectional view of the “water” magnet, SCM, and some auxiliary components of the 45-T hybrid magnet at the NHMFL [3.31]. The water magnet has four nested coils; it generates a center field of 31 T at 24 MW. The SCM, consisting of three coils, A, B, and C, operated at 1.8 K, initially generated 14 T but now operates at 11 T [3.30]; the water magnet has been redesigned to contribute 34 T at 30 MW. The system includes a superfluid helium supply cryostat, to which the SCM cryostat is connected by a pipe, shown truncated at the right, middle of the figure. SCM Coils: C B A WATER-COOLED MAGNET (4 Nested Coils)
↑
↓ ↓↓
1232 mm
↓
↓
→
Magnet Center
Fig. 3.22
Cross sectional view of the 45-T hybrid magnet at NHMFL [3.31].
134
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.5: Hybrid Magnet (continuation) Table 3.3: Parameters of 14-T SCM for NHMFL 45-T Hybrid Magnet [3.31] Coils (each wound with CIC conductor) Strand composite superconductor Type of winding Number of layers/double pancakes Total number of turns Winding i.d., 2a1 [mm] Winding o.d., 2a2 , [mm] Winding length, 2b [mm] Operating current, Iop [kA] λJ @ Iop [MA/m2 ] Field contribution at center @ Iop [T] Bpeak @ Iop with water magnet idle [T] Combined inductance [H] Stored energy @ Iop [MJ]
Coil A Coil B Nb3 Sn Layer 6 7 306 378 710 908 888 1115 869 868 10* 39.6* 44.3* 3.3* 3.6* 15.7* 11.7* 1.96 98*
Coil C NbTi Pancake 29 1015 1150 1680 992 38.6* 7.4* 8.5*
* Corresponds to operation at 10 kA; currently operated at 8 kA [3.30].
Parameters of the 45-T Hybrid SCM Table 3.3 presents key parameters of the 45-T hybrid SCM [3.31]. The most notable feature of this SCM is its three coils, each wound with cable-in-conduit (CIC) conductor, which is discussed in CHAPTER 6. The two inner coils, A and B, are layer-wound, while the outer coil, C, is a stack of 29 double-pancake coils. C. Engineering Challenges of the Hybrid Magnet Hybrid magnets are rare species, operated at only a half dozen or so major national laboratories. It is not a kind of magnet that is being built regularly, not even at a rate of one a year. It is certainly not a type of magnet that a group of engineers or physicists can or would build in a few months. Because of this rarity few engineers have actually participated in the design, manufacture, and operation of hybrid magnets. Nevertheless, because it combines two species of magnets in close proximity, one operating at room temperature and the other at liquid helium temperature, the two are tightly-coupled, electromagnetically and mechanically. Thus, in addition to engineering issues specific to each magnet, there is an important design and operation challenge unique to the hybrid magnet: transmission of a horrendously large interaction force on the cold SCM to the magnet structure at room temperature with the least heat load to the SCM cryostat. Although a hybrid magnet itself will not be encountered by most of the readers of this textbook, it offers salient design and operational issues that most magnet and cryogenic engineers may find instructive. Generic topics related to hybrid magnets in the remainder of this chapter as well as in CHAPTERS 4, 6, 7, and 8 are derived chiefly from the 35-T hybrid magnet operated at M.I.T. until 1995 [3.16–3.18].
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
135
DISCUSSION 3.5: Hybrid Magnet (continuation) D. Configuration & Unique Features In a hybrid magnet, the superconducting magnet is always placed outside of its water magnet (“insert”) and not the other way around. By this configuration, each component’s features are optimized, as given below for each component. “Water” Magnet • In DISCUSSION 3.2, it has been shown that the power requirement PB for Bitter magnets is proportional to a1 and [Bz (0, 0)]2B (from Eq. 3.116a) , with PB typically in the 6∼30 MW range. A Bitter magnet is “power hungry,” and it is best to minimize its overall volume: use it as an insert in a hybrid. However, because the stronger the field strength, the greater the magnetic stresses in the conductor, the conductor materials must be stronger, which are √ generally more resistive. Thus, Bz (0, 0) ∝ P (Eq. 3.113a) and [Bz (0, 0)]B ∝ √ PB (Eq. 3.116a) both become invalid at higher fields. • Normal metals such as copper have no “intrinsic” field limit above which they cannot be used to build a magnet. However, as stated above, because those made of stronger materials require greater power, and equally demanding, the cooling that must match this increased Joule dissipation, the range 30–40 T is considered the limit for practical magnet facilities. Superconducting Magnet • Superconductors have fairly well-defined upper field limits above which they cannot remain superconducting. Thus it is best to place this magnet in the lower-field part of a hybrid: place it outside the “water” magnet. • The total energy storage increases with magnet size, but the power required, chiefly for cryogenics, remains insignificant. A 100-MJ magnet does not require a 100-MW power supply; typically 10–100 kW supplies suffice. Combination of these features makes it natural for a hybrid magnet to consist of a water-cooled insert surrounded by a superconducting magnet.
“We have learned that ‘paper’ hybrid magnets: are always built with perfect superconductors; can be built in perfect confidence with utmost materials; are not subject to fatigue; never have shorts . . .; have cryostats closed with zippers and are always vacuum tight; provide unlimited experimental access; operate themselves; . . . are always on schedule and within budget.” —Mathias J. Leupold
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
136
DISCUSSION 3.5: Hybrid Magnet (continuation) E. Interaction Force A unique and demanding aspect of a hybrid magnet system arises from interactive forces between the insert magnet and the SCM. If the two magnets are aligned axially and radially, they exert no force on each other. However, relative displacements of their field centers result in forces of increasing magnitude. Axial displacements produce axial restoring forces—the magnets center themselves axially. Radial displacements of the field centers result in forces that increase the displacement, i.e., instability. Normally, forces are modest; careful design and construction can cope with them relatively easily. However, the failure of a necessarily high-performance water-cooled insert must be accepted as inevitable. In such a failure, large forces can suddenly develop from a field displacement created when part of the insert winding becomes shorted and ceases to produce field. Although less demanding than the structural requirements to contain fault forces, magnet monitoring for electrical protection is also complicated because of magnetic coupling (mutual inductance) of the two systems. Obviously, each magnet and its power system must have electrical protection of some sort to prevent damage or injury if something goes wrong, but there are also strong electrical interactions between the two magnets which would not exist were they separate. PROBLEMS 8.3 and 8.4 in CHAPTER 8 discuss coil monitoring in more detail for magnets in general and for hybrid magnets in particular.
DISCUSSION 3.6: “Double-Pancake” vs. “Layer-Wound” Of the two magnet winding techniques, one is commonly known as “doublepancake” or simply “pancake,” and the other as “layer-wound.” A double-pancake coil is generally wound with flat conductor, e.g., tape, and sometimes with “large” square- or rectangular-cross-sectioned conductor, e.g., CIC. Each is wound with a
A C B
Fig. 3.23 Pictorial view of a double-pancake coil, with the top and bottom pancakes separated axially for clarity. The pancakes in this drawing are wound with a tape conductor. Points A and B indicate the ends of a continuous conductor, with Point C marking the approximate midpoint.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
137
DISCUSSION 3.6: “Double-Pancake” vs. “Layer-Wound” (continuation) continuous length of conductor. In a double-pancake coil, a schematic drawing of which is shown in Fig. 3.23, the starting point of the winding is the midpoint (approximately point C in Fig. 3.23) of the conductor; in a layer-wound coil, it is one end (A or B) of the conductor. Because the winding height (2b) of each double-pancake coil is about twice the conductor height (width in tape), a practical magnet requires multiple double-pancake coils, adjacent coils spliced in the radial space outside the outermost winding diameter (2a2 ). A layer-wound coil, on the other hand, is wound continuously from one end to the other end of the conductor, layer by layer from the innermost layer to the outermost. Advantages and disadvantages of both techniques are discussed below. Advantages & Disadvantages 1. For a double-pancake coil, the required length is much less than that for a full, splice-free layer-wound coil. A splice-free length as short as ∼50 m suffices for small coils. Even in a large magnet, a length of ∼1–2 km should be sufficient. In layer-wound coils, on the other hand, splice-free conductor can easily exceed 10 km in a single coil. Because longer conductors are generally more difficult to manufacture than shorter conductors, in terms of conductor length, a pancake coil is preferable to a layer-wound coil. 2. A pancake magnet generally requires many double-pancake coils, each of which ideally is an identical module, to build up the magnet winding height. This modular magnet construction approach, together with conductor length requirement stated above, makes manufacturing of a pancake magnet easier (and probably less expensive) than that of a layer-wound counterpart. Also, one catastrophic mistake during the winding process that can potentially render the entire stock unusable in a layer-wound coil will affect only one spool needed for one double-pancake. Because both electromagnetic performance and dimensions of each completed doublepancake can be slightly different, another advantage of the pancake technique is that it enables placement of each double-pancake coil at its most suitable location along the magnet axis. 3. One clear disadvantage of the pancake technique is the unavoidable need for splices between adjacent double-pancakes. Splicing is an added process in the manufacturing, made more difficult than a simple conductor splice because the splice here has to conform to the curvature of the winding. Perhaps more importantly from operation, these splices generate unwanted Joule dissipation, unless they are superconducting. Magnets for NMR and MRI generally require superconducting splices. To make a superconducting splice could be a challenge itself; to ascertain that each splice is indeed superconducting is also not an easy task.
Answer to TRIVIA 3.2 ii). Corresponds to a net temperature rise of ∼ 25◦ C. Note that this 17-MW dissipation must obviously be matched by a cooling power of 17 MW. It has been suggested, half in jest, that a water-cooled magnet is a zero-efficiency machine.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
138
PROBLEM 3.3: Helmholtz coil* Highly uniform magnetic fields are desirable in many applications. An arrangement known as the “Helmholtz coil” achieves a high uniformity of the field over a limited region of space by simple means. It uses two identical coils spaced coaxially a distance d apart (Fig. 3.24a) in the magnet axis (z-direction); the coils are located, respectively, at z = d/2 and z = −d/2. The spacing d in the Helmholtz coil is adjusted to make at the magnet center (r = 0, z = 0): d2 Hz (0, z) =0 (3.121) dz 2 z=0
a) Idealizing the two coils by two “rings” each of radius a, show that when d = a, dHz2 (0, z)/dz 2 = 0 at the magnet center. The solid curve in Fig. 3.24b gives Hz (0, z) of a coil with d that does not satisfy Eq. 3.121. b) Show that with coils of opposing polarity, a gradient field is generated at the magnet center. Evaluate this dHz /dz at z = 0.√(Note that d3 Hz (0, z)/dz 3 = 0 when d = a; d3 Hz (0, z)/dz 3 = 0 requires d = 3a.) This configuration with reverse current is called a Maxwell coil. The dotted curve in Fig. 3.24b gives Hz (z) of a gradient coil. z
z = d/2 a z =0
d
(a) Hz(z)
−d
−d / 2
0
d/2
d
z
(b)
Fig. 3.24 (a) Ideal Helmholtz coil arrangement; (b) Hz (0, z) for a “uniform” field case (solid) and Hz (0, z) for a “gradient” field case (dotted). * Problem 3.4 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
139
Solution to PROBLEM 3.3 a) The z-component of magnetic field along the axis (r = 0) due to the bottom loop, located at z = −d/2, may be given by Eq. 3.3a: Hz (0, z) =
a2 I 2[a2 + (z + d/2)2 ]3/2
Adding the field from the top coil, located at z = d/2, we have: a2 I 1 1 Hz (0, z) = + 2 2 [a2 + (z + d/2)2 ]3/2 [a + (z − d/2)2 ]3/2
(S3.1)
Differentiating Hz (z) given by Eq. S3.1 with respect to z, we have: dHz (0, z) 3a2 I (z + d/2) (z − d/2) = − 2 − 2 dz 2 [a + (z + d/2)2 ]5/2 [a + (z − d/2)2 ]5/2 Note that from symmetry dHz (0, z)/dz = 0 at z = 0 for any value of a. The second derivative of Eq. S3.1 is given by: 3a2 I d2 Hz (0, z) a2 − 4(z − d/2)2 a2 − 4(z + d/2)2 = − 2 − 2 dz 2 2 [a + (z + d/2)2 ]7/2 [a + (z − d/2)2 ]7/2 The second derivative is zero at z = 0 if d = a. This technique of locating two identical coils with axial spacing equal to the coil radius to produce a region of field homogeneity, here through the 2nd harmonic order, is one of the design principles used in MRI and other magnets requiring a high spatial field homogeneity. b) For this system with the current polarity of the bottom coil reversed, we have: a2 I 1 1 − 2 + 2 (S3.2) Hz (0, z) = 2 [a + (z + d/2)2 ]3/2 [a + (z − d/2)2 ]3/2 By symmetry, Hz (z = 0) = 0. Differentiating Eq. S3.2 with respect to z, we obtain: dHz (0, z) (z + d/2) 3a2 I (z − d/2) = − 2 (S3.3) dz 2 [a2 + (z + d/2)2 ]5/2 [a + (z − d/2)2 ]5/2 Evaluating Eq. S3.3 at z = 0, we have: dHz (0, z) 3a2 Id = dz 2[a2 + (d/2)2 ]5/2 0 This method of locating two identical coils having opposite currents to achieve a field gradient is the basic principle used in magnets requiring a gradient field at the midplane. A pulsed magnet used in an MRI system to produce a gradient field (to extract spatial information for imaging) is one example.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
140
PROBLEM 3.4: Analysis of a Helmholtz coil—another method Here, we analyze the Helmholtz coil of PROBLEM 3.3, using Eqs. 3.16a and 3.22.
Show that for a Helmholtz pair comprised of two “ring” coils, Coils 1 and 2, each of radius a, located, respectively, at ζ(≡ z/a) = +0.5 and ζ = −0.5, its axial field 2nd derivative at its center (ζ = 0), d2 hz (0)/dζ 2 |1/2 , expressed in a power series in ζ 2n converges to 0 as more terms are added. Because each coil is not evaluated at its own ζ = 0, the simplified expression of Eq. 3.17b cannot be used here. Use up to the 20th term to compute d2 hz (0)/dζ 2 |1/2 . Note that E2 (1, 0). . . E10 (1, 0) are given by Eq. 3.28. A technique used to derive E2 (1, 0). . .E10 (1, 0) may be used to derive E12 (α, 0). . .E20 (α, 0) from Eq. 3.15b and f12 (α, β). . .f20 (α, β) given in APPENDIX IB. In the limit β → 0, the expansion of 1/(1+β 2 )19.5 up to the β 20 term, for example, results in the following expression: 1 =1− (1+β 2 )19.5 +
39 2 2 β
+
39 41 2 · 2
β4 − 2!
39 41 43 2 · 2 · 2
β6 + ··· 3!
39 41 43 45 47 49 51 53 55 57 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2 · 2
β 20 10!
(3.122)
For E12 (α, 0). . .E20 (α, 0), similar to E2 (α, 0). . .E10 (α, 0) as in Eq. 3.21, we have: E12 (α, 0) =
7·11·13 (α12 − 1) 1001(α12 − 1) · = 212 α12 ln α 4096α12 ln α 5·9·11·13 (α14 − 1) 6435(α14 − 1) · = − 212 ·7 α14 ln α 28672α14 ln α
(3.123b)
5·9·11·13·17 (α16 − 1) 109395(α16 − 1) · = 219 α16 ln α 524288α16 ln α
(3.123c)
E14 (α, 0) = − E16 (α, 0) =
E18 (α, 0) = − E20 (α, 0) =
(3.123a)
5·11·13·17·19 (α18 − 1) 230945(α18 − 1) · = − 217 ·32 α18 ln α 1179648α18 ln α
3·7·11·13·17·19 (α20 − 1) 969969(α20 − 1) · = 220 ·5 α20 ln α 5242880α20 ln α
In the limit α → 1, Eqs. 3.123a – 3.123e become: 3003 3·7·11·13 3·5·7·9·11·13 E12 (1, 0) = = = 2.933 1024 210 2·4·6·8·10·12
(3.123d) (3.123e)
(3.124a)
6435 5·9·11·13 3·5·7·9·11·13·15 =− =− −3.142 (3.124b) 2048 211 2·4·6·8·10·12·14 109395 5·9·11·13·17 3·5·7·9·11·13·15·17 E16 (1, 0) = = = 3.338 (3.124c) 15 32768 10 2·4·6·8·10·12·14·16 230945 5·11·13·17·19 3·5·7·9·11·13·15·17·19 E18 (1, 0) = − = =− −3.524 16 65536 10 2·4·6·8·10·12·14·16·18 (3.124d ) 3·7·11·13·17·19 969969 3·5·7·9·11·13·15·17·19·21 E20 (1, 0) = = = 3.700 262144 1018 2·4·6·8·10·12·14·16·18·20 (3.124e) E14 (1, 0) = −
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
141
Solution to PROBLEM 3.4 d2 hz (ζ)/dζ 2 at ζ = 0 due to Coil 1 at ζ = +0.5, d2 hz (0)/dζ 2 |1/2 , is given by Eq. 3.16a: d2 hz (0) = 2E2 (1, 0) + 12E4 (1, 0)×(0.5)2 + 30E6 (1, 0)×(0.5)4 dζ 2 1/2
+ 56E8 (1, 0)×(0.5)6 + 90E10 (1, 0)×(0.5)8 + 132E12 (1, 0)×(0.5)10 + 182E14 (1, 0)×(0.5)12 + 240E16 (1, 0)×(0.5)14 + 306E18 (1, 0)×(0.5)16 + 380E20 (1, 0)×(0.5)18 + · · ·
(S4.1)
Because Coil 2 (at ζ = −0.5) gives numerically the same d2 ζz /dζ 2 at ζ = 0.5 as that of Coil 1 at ζ = 0.5 given by S4.1, we have: d2 hz (0) 3 15 35 2 =4 − + 24 (0.5) + 60 − (0.5)4 dζ 2 2 8 16 1/2
315 693 6 + 112 (0.5) + 180 − (0.5)8 128 256 3003 6435 10 + 264 (0.5) + 364 − (0.5)12 1024 2048 230945 109395 + 480 (0.5)14 + 612 − (0.5)16 32768 65536 969969 + 760 (0.5)18 + · · · 262144
(S4.2)
We compute Eq. S4.2 as each higher term is added: d2 hz (0) = −6 (only E2 ) dζ 2 1/2
= 5.25
(through E4 )
−2.9531
(through E6 )
1.3535
(through E8 )
−0.5499
(through E10 )
0.2062
(through E12 )
−0.0730
(through E14 )
0.0248
(through E16 )
−0.0081
(through E18 )
0.0026
(through E20 )
From the above, it is clear that d2 hz (0)/dζ 2 |1/2 → 0 as more higher terms are added. Note that for a single ring coil placed at ζ = 0: d2 hz (0)/dζ 2 = −3.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
142
PROBLEM 3.5 Analysis of a spatially homogeneous magnet Table 3.4 Field Parameters Figure 3.25 shows a schematic cross section of a spatially high field homoParameters Value geneity magnet consisting of three coils, Center field, B0 [T] 1.000 Coils 1–3. Coils 1 and 3 are identical d2B/dz 2 |0 [T/cm2 ] 0.4658×10−6 and located below and above the middle 4 4 d B/dz |0 [T/cm4 ] 4.8450×10−5 coil, Coil 2, to enhance the homogeneity 6 6 d B/dz |0 [T/cm6 ] 1.0893×10−4 at the center (0,0). Key dimensions (in 8 8 d B/dz |0 [T/cm8 ] 1.0789×10−4 mm) are indicated in the figure. Each coil has the same 2a1 of 100 mm and the same overall current density, λJ = 2.5147×108 A/m2 . Table 3.4 gives field parameters of the magnet computed with a computer code by Bobrov [3.32].
Figure 3.26 shows the same magnet represented by three coils, A, B, and C, each centered at (0,0). Coil A extends from Coil 1 to Coil 3, including the two gaps in between. Coil B is identical to Coil 2. 112.89 Because in the new representation Coil 2 100.00 is represented twice, by Coils A and B, Coil C “subtracts” one of the two Coil 2’s as well as the two gaps, with its current Coil 1 55.85 in the opposite direction from those of Coils A and B. a) Verify that the coil configuration of Figs. 3.26 gives the same center field of B0 = 1.000 T as the original coil configuration. Coils A, B, and C have the same overall current density, λJ.
106.44
Coil 2
B0 = 1.000 T = μ◦ λJa1 [FA (α, β) + FB (α, β) − FC (α, β)] (3.125) b) Apply Eqs. 3.14 and 3.17, and using a handheld scientific calculator, compute, d2 B/dz 2 |0 and d4 B/dz 4 |0 for this magnet. The values should agree with those given in Table 3.4 computed with a code.
Fig. 3.25
289.24
148.21
Coil 3
55.85
Magnet comprised of 3 coils. Dimensions are in mm.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
143
PROBLEM 3.5: Analysis of a spatially homogenous magnet (continuation)
106.44 100.00
112.89 100.00
148.21
Coil B
289.24
112.89 100.00
177.55
Coil A
Coil C
Fig. 3.26 The magnet of Fig. 3.25 represented by Coils A, B, and C, with each center at the magnet center. Note that the minus sign signifies that Coil C carries current in the direction opposite from those in Coils A and B. Dimensions are in mm.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
144
Solution to PROBLEM 3.5 Table 3.5 lists appropriate values of α and β for Coils A, B, and C. Using these values, we obtain: FA (α, β) = 0.12094421 FB (α, β) = 0.05287933
Table 3.5 Field Parameters Coils
α
β
A B C
1.12888 1.06444 1.12888
2.89244 1.48212 1.77548
FC (α, β) = 0.11053327 a)
From Eq. 3.125 we have: B0 = (4π×10−7 H/m)(2.5147×108 A/m2 )(5×10−2 m) × (0.12094421 + 0.05287933 − 0.11053327) = 1.000 T
b) Inserting α and β into Eqs. 3.14a and 3.14b1, we obtain: F (α, β)E2 (α, β)A = −0.002277367; F (α, β)E2 (α, β)B = −0.007938543; F (α, β)E2 (α, β)C = −0.010216278;
F (α, β)E4 (α, β)A = −0.000315757 F (α, β)E4 (α, β)B = −0.001737981 F (α, β)E4 (α, β)C = −0.002133593
When all coils have the same a1 and λJa1 , Eq. 3.18 becomes: k j=1 F (αj , βj )E2 (αj , βj ) 2 hζ (ζ) = 1 + ζ + ··· k j=1 F (αj , βj ) E2 (α, β) =
(S5.1)
F (α, β)E2 (α, β)A + F (α, β)E2 (α, β)B − F (α, β)E2 (α, β)C F (α, β)A + F (α, β)B − F (α, β)C
=
−0.002277367 − 0.007938543 + 0.010216278 = 0.000005822 0.120924421 + 0.05287933 − 0.11053327
E4 (α, β) =
−0.000315757 − 0.001737981 + 0.002132363 = 0.001261725 0.06329027
We thus have: d2 B B0 (1.000 T) = 2E2 = 2(0.000005822) = 0.4658×10−6 T/cm2 2 2 dz a (5 cm)2 0
1
B0 d4 B (1.000 T) = 24E = 24(0.001261725) = 4.8453×10−5 T/cm4 4 dz 4 0 a41 (5 cm)4 These values are virtually identical with those in Table 3.4, though one must have diligence to compute each figure up to 9 decimal places. It should be noted that the analysis presented here is useful, though tedious, for computing field gradient terms for a given magnet design. The analysis in this present form is impractical for designing a spatially high homogeneity magnet; it can, however, certainly be used as the basis for developing one’s own design code.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
145
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.6: Field expansion in Cartesian coordinates* In spherical coordinates (r, θ, ϕ) defined in Fig. 3.4, the magnetic field in the zdirection, Hz , in a source-free space generated by a magnet consisting of nested coils can be expressed by Eq. 3.9.
Show that expressions for Hz (r, θ, ϕ) in Cartesian coordinates, Hz (x, y, z), for n = 0, 1, and 2 are given by: n = 0 Hz (x, y, z) = A00 n=1
Hz (x, y, z) = A00 +2zA01 +3(A11 x+B11 y)
n=2
Hz (x, y, z) = A00 +2zA01 +3(A11 x+B11 y)
(3.126a) (3.126b)
+ 23 A02 (2z 2 −x2 −y 2 )+12z(A12 x+B21 y) + 15[A22 (x2 −y 2 )+2B22 xy]
(3.126c)
* Based on Problem 3.5 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
Help from Van (Part 1 of 5 Parts) —Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist And so the design of the first powerful water-cooled coils at M.I.T. gradually evolved. An interesting side light at this point was that a thorough search of the literature revealed that actually we were not the first to attempt to build coils along these lines. During World War I two Frenchmen tried to do the same sort of thing. They designed water-cooled coils and found that the only place they could conveniently get the power to operate them was in the private power station of one of the big department stores in Paris. But they had to stop work because of the war, and for about twenty years it was forgotten. My designs were quite different from theirs, and I decided to follow my own plans. Now I was faced with the same problem as the Frenchmen. If we did build some coils, where could we test them? Throughout this period and up to the completion of the first magnets the chief person responsible for the realization of my ambitions was Vannevar Bush, at that time the Vice-President of M.I.T. He was interested in what I was doing, and gave it the needed backing. To begin with, after I had made some preliminary designs that looked reasonable, he suggested that I try them out at one of the substations of the Boston Edison Company. They had old-fashioned DC power stations which had spare power during the early hours of the morning. He arranged to have space made available for me to set up a magnet, and to get water cooling from the city water mains. And so the first magnet was constructed in the basement of the physics building. It was to dissipate about 1000 kilowatts in a magnet having a volume of about one cubic foot (∼30 liters). If the water cooling should fail, the 1000 kilowatts dissipated in this volume would melt everything in it in a few seconds. Our water-cooling tests had indicated that the heating would not fail, that steam layers would not form and stop the cooling processes. But it was still an exciting time. When we set up the magnet at the Scotia Street substation of the Edison Company, the engineers were frankly skeptical. But because of Van Bush’s backing they were willing enough to give me a chance to prove my ideas.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
146
Solution to PROBLEM 3.6 The spherical coordinate parameters, r, u = cos θ, s = sin θ, sin ϕ, and cos ϕ are given in terms of x, y, and z: r = x2 + y 2 + z 2 (S6.1a) z u = cos θ = 2 x + y2 + z2 x2 + y 2 s = sin θ = x2 + y 2 + z 2
(S6.1b)
(S6.1c)
y sin ϕ = 2 x + y2
(S6.1d)
x cos ϕ = 2 x + y2
(S6.1e)
Equations 3.9 and S6.1a–S6.1e are combined for cases n = 0, 1, and 2. n=0: Hz (x, y, z) =
0
r0 (1 + 0)P00 (u)(A00 cos 0 + B00 sin 0)
(S6.2a)
m=0
= (1)(1)(1)(A00 )
(S6.2b)
For n = 0, we thus have: Hz (x, y, z) = A00
(3.126a)
Note that A00 represents the magnet center field: Hz (0, 0, 0). n=1: Hz (x, y, z) =
1
m r1 (2+m)P1m (Am 1 cos mϕ+B1 sin mϕ)
(S6.3a)
m=0
= r1 (2+0)P10 (A01 )+r1 (2+1)P11 (A11 cos ϕ+B11 sin ϕ) = 2ruA01 +3rs(A11 cos ϕ+B11 sin ϕ) z = 2 x2 +y 2 +z 2 A01 2 x +y 2 +z 2 x2 +y 2 A11 x+B11 y 2 2 2 + 3 x +y +z x2 +y 2 +z 2 x2 +y 2 = 2zA01 +3(A11 x+B11 y)
(S6.3b)
TRIVIA 3.3 Which of the French mathematicians below chaired a commission to draw up a new system of measurements, out of which came the metric system? i) Cauchy;
ii) Fourier;
iii) Lagrange;
iv) Poisson.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
147
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.6 (continuation) Thus for n up to 1, we have: Hz (x, y, z) = A00 + 2zA01 + 3(A11 x + B11 y)
(3.126b)
Note that Hz (x, y, z) contains terms up to those varying only as z, x, and y. n=2: Hz (x, y, z) =
2
m r2 (3+m)P2m (Am 2 cos mϕ+B2 sin mϕ)
(S6.4)
m=0
= r2 (3+0)P20 (A02 )+r2 (3+1)P21 (A12 cos ϕ+B21 sin ϕ) + r2 (3+2)P22 (A22 cos 2ϕ+B22 sin 2ϕ) 2 2z −x2 −y 2 Hz (x, y, z) = 3(x2 +y 2 +z 2 ) 21 A02 x2 +y 2 +z 2 2 2 x y 2 2 2 3z x +y 1 1 + 4(x +y +z ) 2 2 2 A2 +B2 x +y +z x2 +y 2 x2 +y 2 + 5(x2 +y 2 +z 2 )
2x2 3(x2 +y 2 ) 2 2 2xy A −1 +B 2 2 2 x2 +y 2 +z 2 x2 +y 2 x +y 2
= 23 A02 (2z 2 −x2 −y 2 ) + 12z(A12 x+B21 y)+15[A22 (x2 −y 2 ) + 2B22 xy]
(S6.4b)
Summing Eqs. S6.2b, S6.3b, and S6.4b, we have, for n up to 2: Hz (x, y, z) = A00 +2zA01 +3(A11 x+B11 y) + 23 A02 (2z 2 −x2 −y 2 )+12z(A12 x+B21 y) + 15[A22 (x2 −y 2 )+2B22 xy]
(3.126c)
Note that when evaluated for n = 0, 1, and 2, Hz (x, y, z) contains terms varying as x, y, z, z 2 , x2 , y 2 , zx, zy, and xy.
“Ignorance is like a delicate exotic fruit; touch it and the bloom is gone.” —Lady Bracknell
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
148
PROBLEM 3.7: Notched solenoid* The principle of the Helmholtz coil—to place current-carrying elements symmetrically about the solenoid center to create a spatially homogeneous field in the central zone—is the basis for notched solenoids. Many MRI and NMR magnets are variants of the notched solenoid design. For a simple solenoid, with winding inner radius a1 , winding outer radius a2 , total winding length 2b, and overall current density λJ, recall that the axial magnetic field at the center, H0 ≡ Hz (0, 0), is given by Eqs. 3.13a and 3.13b: H0 = λJa1 F (α, β) α + α2 + β 2 F (α, β) = β ln 1 + 1 + β2
(3.13a) (3.13b)
Using symmetry considerations and the superposition technique presented in DISCUSSION 3.4, show that an expression for Hz (0, z1 ) of the notched solenoid having a uniform current density λJ shown in Fig. 3.27 is given by: Hz (0, z1 ) = 21 λJa1 F (α1 , β1 + γ1 ) + F (α1 , β1 − γ1 ) − 21 λJa3 F (α2 , β2 + γ2 ) + F (α2 , β2 − γ2 ) (3.127) where α1 = a2 /a1 , β1 = b1 /a1 , γ1 = z1 /a1 , α2 = a2 /a3 , β2 = b2 /a3 , and γ2 = z1 /a3 . The coil parameters, a1 , a2 , a3 , b1 , and b2 are defined in Fig. 3.27. A simple notched solenoid has too few degrees of freedom to zero more than a couple spatial homogeneity coefficients, but it is very good at zeroing those of 2nd and 4th order. C
L
D
I a3
b2
G
H
F
K a2 b1
A
B
E a1
z1 Fig. 3.27
Geometrical arrangement of a notched solenoid.
* Problem 3.6 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
149
Solution to PROBLEM 3.7 To solve Hz (0, z1 ), we may divide the solenoid into four single solenoids whose cross sections are designated by corner points as follows: Solenoid 1: ABDC, with α1 = a2 /a1 = α and β1 = (b1 + z1 )/a1 = β + γ, where β = b1 /a1 and γ = z1 /a1 ; Solenoid 2: BEF D, with α2 = a2 /a1 = α and β2 = (b1 −z1 )/a1 = β −γ; Solenoid 3: IGDL, with α3 = a2 /a3 = α and β3 = (b2 +z1 )/a3 = β +γ , where β = b2 /a3 and γ = z1 /a3 ; Solenoid 4: GKHD, with α4 = a2 /a3 = α and β4 = (b2 −z1 )/a3 = β −γ . Note that in all solenoids J is of the same magnitude but in Solenoids 3 and 4 is of opposite sign relative to Solenoids 1 and 2. Also note that all solenoids are notchless. Field from Solenoid 1: Hz (0, z1 ) from Solenoid 1, 2b = b1 +z1 long, is one-half of the center field of a solenoid, 2b = 2(b1 + z1 ) long, having the same values of a1 , a2 , and λJ. This may be best seen by noting that the center field Hz (0, 0) of a notchless solenoid, 2b long, is the sum of the field generated by one-half of the solenoid (from 0 to z = b) and that generated by the other half (from z = −b to 0). That is, each half of the solenoid generates 50% of the total field Hz (0, 0). Thus: Hz (0, z1 )|1 = 21 λJa1 F (α, β +γ)
(S7.1)
Field from Solenoid 2: At (0, z1 ), Hz from Solenoid 2, 2b = b1 − z1 long, is one-half of the center field of a solenoid, 2b = 2(b1 −z1 ) long, both solenoids having the same values of a1 , a2 , and λJ. Hz (0, z1 )|2 = 21 λJa1 F (α, β −γ)
(S7.2)
Field from Solenoid 3: At (0, z1 ), Hz from Solenoid 3, 2b = b2+z1 long, is onehalf of the center field of a solenoid having 2b = 2(b2 +z1 ), both solenoids with the same values of a3 , a2 , and λJ. Because J is directed opposite to that of Solenoids 1 and 2, we have: Hz (0, z1 )|3 = − 21 λJa3 F (α , β +γ ) (S7.3) Field from Solenoid 4: At (0, z1 ), Hz from Solenoid 4, 2b = b2 − z1 long, is one-half of the center field of a solenoid 2b = 2(b2 −z1 ) long. Hz (0, z1 )|4 = − 21 λJa3 F (α , β −γ )
(S7.4)
Field from the Notched Solenoid Hz (0, z1 ) generated by the original notched solenoid is thus given by the sum of Eqs. S7.1–S7.4: Hz (0, z1 ) = Hz (0, z1 )|1 + Hz (0, z1 )|2 + Hz (0, z1 )|3 + Hz (0, z1 )|4 = 21 λJa1 F (α, β +γ) + F (α, β −γ) − 21 λJa3 F (α , β +γ ) + F (α , β −γ )
(3.127)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
150
DISCUSSION 3.7: Field Analysis of a Pancake-Coil Magnet Applying the superposition technique of DISCUSSION 3.4, we derive here expressions for axial field that may be used to compute field error coefficients of a solenoidal magnet comprised of 2N pancake coils (N double-pancake coils). With Bi2223 and YBCO that are available in tape form, a magnet comprised of pancake coils wound with HTS is a viable design option for spatially homogeneous magnets such as for NMR magnets [3.33, 3.34]. Pancake coils are ideal for conductors of “thin” rectangular cross sectional area. In this analysis, each pancake is of identical dimensions—2a1 ; 2a2 ; 2b = w (equal to conductor width)—and the same value of λJ in the pancake coil winding. Adjacent pancake coils are separated by a distance δ. Figure 3.28 shows a schematic drawing of the cross section of a magnet comprised of 2N single pancake coils. In deriving field equations, all centered about the magnet origin, we use the following simplified notations. Here, using an abbreviated expression for F (α, β)/β, F (α, β) α + α2 + β 2 ≡ ln(α, β) = ln (3.128a) β 1 + 1 + β2 we define a dimensionless axial magnetic field parameter, η(ζ) ≡ H(z)/(λJa1 ), where ζ ≡ z/a1 , given by: ⎡ ⎤ n H(z) η(ζ) ≡ = β ln(α, β) ⎣1 + E2j (α, β)ζ 2j ⎦ (3.128b) λJa1 j=1 Because of the use of ln(α, β), Eq. 3.128b is a dimensionless field expression slightly different from that derivable from Eq. 3.13a.
↓ w ↑
→
2a2 2a1
2N
δ ↓
(2N −1)
↑
• • 2N (w+δ)−δ
←
•
• +
• •
2 1
Fig. 3.28 Magnet comprised of 2N single pancakes (N double pancakes), each of identical dimensions—2a1 ; 2a2 ; 2b = w—and the same λJ.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
151
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.7: Field Analysis of Pancake-Coil Magnet (continuation) ↓
↑
w δ w
P2 + P1 +
+
=
−
+
↓
↑
Two-Pancake Magnet
Fig. 3.29
2w+δ
↓
δ
↑
Coil 2
Coil 2
Two-pancake magnet as Coil 2 of 2b = 2w+δ minus Coil 2 of 2b = δ.
Step 1: Two-Pancake Magnet—Pancake 1 & Pancake 2 Consider first the simplest case: a magnet comprised of two pancake coils, P 1 and P 2. Using the superposition technique of DISCUSSION 3.4, the original magnet with a gap of δ (leftmost drawing in Fig. 3.29) is equivalent to two gapless solenoids: Coil 2 (middle) of height (2b2 = w + δ) minus Coil 2 of height (2b2 = δ). The subscript 2 signifies that the magnet under consideration comprises two pancake coils. Note that the cross section of each coil in Fig. 3.29 shows only its height (2b), because this is the only relevant parameter under consideration: thus, Coil 2 has β2 = (2w+δ)/2a1 ; and Coil 2 , β2 = δ/2a1 . The dimensionless axial field due to the two coils, η2 (ζ), is given by: η2 (ζ) = [η(ζ)]2 − [η (ζ)]2
(3.129)
From Eq. 3.128b, we have [η(ζ)]2 and [η (ζ)]2 given by: n E2j (α, β2 )ζ 2j [η(ζ)]2 = β2 ln(α, β2 ) 1 +
[η (ζ)]2 =
β2
ln(α, β2 )
j=1
1+
n
(3.130a)
E2j (α, β2 )ζ 2j
(3.130b)
j=1
Combining Eqs. 3.129 and 3.130, we have: η2 (ζ) = β2 ln(α, β2 ) − β2 ln(α, β2 ) +
n
β2 ln(α, β2 )E2j (α, β2 ) − β2 ln(α, β2 )E2j (α, β2 ) ζ 2j
(3.131)
j=1
Step 2: Four-Pancake Magnet—Addition of Pancakes 3 & 4 Next, we consider a magnet comprised of four pancake coils. As illustrated in Fig. 3.30, the new magnet is the two-pancake magnet considered in Step 1 with one pancake added to the bottom and another added to the top of the two-pancake magnet. These new pancakes, as indicated in Fig. 3.30, may be modeled as Coil 4 with 2b = 4w+3δ minus Coil 4 with 2b = 2w+3δ. Thus, Coil 4 has β4 = (4w+3δ)/2a1 ; and Coil 4 , β4 = (2w+3δ)/2a1 .
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
152
DISCUSSION 3.7: Field Analysis of Pancake-Coil Magnet (continuation) ↓ w ↑
P4 +
↑ 4w+3δ −
+
=
2w+3δ
+
2w+3δ ↓
↓ w ↑
P3 + Pancakes 3&4
Coil 4
Coil 4
Fig. 3.30 Four-pancake magnet as Coil 4 of 2b = 4w+3δ minus Coil 4 of 2b = 2w+3δ added to the two-pancake magnet shown in Fig. 3.29.
The total dimensionless axial field due to all 4 coils, η4 (z) is: η4 (z) = [η(ζ)]2 − [η (ζ)]2 + [η(ζ)]4 − [η (z)]4 where
[η(ζ)]4 = β4 ln(α, β4 ) 1 +
[η (ζ)]4 =
β4
ln(α, β4 )
E2j (α, β4 )ζ 2j
j=1
n
1+
n
(3.132)
(3.133a)
E2j (α, β4 )ζ 2j
(3.133b)
j=1
From Eqs. 3.130 through 3.133 we obtain: η4 (ζ) = β2 ln(α, β2 ) + β4 ln(α, β4 ) − β2 ln(α, β2 ) + β4 ln(α, β4 ) +
n
β2 ln(α, β2 )E2j (α, β2 ) + β4 ln(α, β4 )E2j (α, β4 )
j=1
− β2 ln(α, β2 )E2j (α, β2 )+β4 ln(α, β4 )E2j (α, β4 ) ζ 2j (3.134)
Step 3: 2N-Pancake Coil—Addition of Final Two Pancakes Figure 3.31 illustrates modeling of the final pancakes, (2N −1)th and 2N th , of the magnet, Coil 2N of 2bN = 2N w+(2N−1)δ and thus β2N = [2N w+(2N−1)δ]/2a1 and Coil 2N of 2bN = 2(N −1)w+(2N −1)δ and thus β2N = [2(N −1)w+(2N −1)δ]/2a1 . An expression for the axial field for a 2N -pancake magnet, which in practice comprises N double-pancake coils, is given by: η2N (ζ) =
N
[η(ζ)]2k − [η (ζ)]2k
(3.135)
k=1
In this analysis it is assumed that the spacing between pancake coils within each double-pancake coil and those between adjacent double-pancake coils are equal.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
153
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.7: Field Analysis of Pancake-Coil Magnet (continuation) + P 2N =
+
2bN
−
2bN
+
P (2N −1)
+ 2bN = 2N w + (2N−1)δ Pancakes (2N −1) & 2N
2bN = 2(N−1)w + (2N−1)δ Coil 2N
Coil 2N
Fig. 3.31 2N -pancake magnet as Coil 2N of 2b2N = 2N w+(2N−1)δ minus Coil 2N of 2b2N = 2(N −1)w+(2N −1)δ added to the 2(N −1)-pancake magnet.
We may express Eq. 3.135 in a form similar to Eq. 3.134: N β2k ln(α, β2k ) − β2k ln(α, β2k ) η2N (ζ) = k=1
+
n
ln(α, β2k )E2j (α, β2k ) β2k ln(α, β2k )E2j (α, β2k )−β2k
ζ 2j (3.136)
j=1
where β2k =
2kw + (2k − 1)δ 2a1
β2k =
2(k − 1)w + (2k − 1)δ 2a1
Equation 3.136 may also be expressed as: η2N (ζ) = 1 + [E2 ]2N ζ 2 + · · · + [E2n ]2N ζ 2n η2N (0)
(3.137)
where η2N (0) is the dimensionless center field and [E2n ]2N is the nth overall error coefficient. η2N (ζ = 0) and [E2n ]2N are given by: η2N (0) =
N
β2k ln(α, β2k ) − β2k ln(α, β2k )
(3.138a)
k=1
N [E2n ]2N =
k=1
β2k ln(α, β2k )E2n (α, β2k )−β2k ln(α, β2k )E2n (α, β2k ) (3.138b) N k=1 β2k ln(α, β2k )−β2k ln(α, β2k )
Thus Eq. 3.138b gives an expression for computation of nth error coefficient comprised of 2N identical pancake coils, each of 2a1 i.d., 2b = w, α, and β, and separated from each other by δ.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
154
PROBLEM 3.8: Ideal dipole magnet* This problem studies an ideal dipole magnet, which is infinitely long (no end effects) and whose fields, directed normal to the dipole axis, are generated by a longitudinal surface current having zero winding thickness. Field and force solutions for real dipole magnets are more complex than those in the ideal dipole; nevertheless, except for complications at the ends, the ideal dipole illustrates most of the key aspects. Dipole magnets are used in systems that require a uniform field directed transverse to the magnet axis, such as in high-energy particle accelerators [3.35–3.40] and electric generators [3.41–3.43]. A long (two-dimensional) dipole magnet of radius R and “zero” winding thickness is energized by a surface current flowing in the z-direction at the dipole shell d1 , and that outside the (r = R). The magnetic field within the bore (r < R), H shell (r > R), Hd2 , are given by: d1 = H0 (sin θ ır + cos θ ıθ ) (3.139a) H 2 d2 = H0 R (sin θ ır − cos θ ıθ ) H (3.139b) r The 2-D coordinates are defined in Fig. 3.32. The +z-direction is out of the paper. In answering the following questions, neglect end effects. a) Draw neatly the field profile of the dipole for both regions, r < R and r > R. f at r = R is given by: b) Show that an expression for the surface current K f = −2H0 cos θ ız (3.140) K f is +z-directed Indicate on a sketch its direction, with circles (o) where K (out of the paper) and with crosses (×) where Kf is −z-directed. c) Show that an expression for the Lorentz force density per unit length, f L [N/m2 ], acting on a current-carrying element of the shell, is given by: (3.141) f L = −μ◦ H02 sin 2θ ıθ y r
θ R
Fig. 3.32
x
Cylindrical coordinate system; +z-direction is out of the paper.
* Problem 3.7 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
155
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.8: Ideal dipole magnet (continuation) d) Show that the net x-directed Lorentz force (per unit dipole length), FLx [N/m], acting on the right-hand sector (−90◦ < θ < 90◦ ) is given by: 4Rμ◦ H02 3
FLx =
(3.142)
e) Show that an expression for the total magnetic energy stored (per unit dipole length), Em [J/m], is given by: Em =
πR2 B02 μ◦
(3.143)
Compute Em for B0 = 5 T and R = 20 mm. Also, from Em , compute the inductance, L, of a 10-m long dipole with an operating current, Iop , of 5000 A. To reduce the field outside the dipole, an iron yoke (μ = ∞) of radial thickness d is placed outside the dipole, as shown in Fig. 3.33. field inside the dipole f 1 needed to generate the same H f ) Show that the new K is exactly one-half that given by Eq. 3.140. Explain this current reduction. g) In reality, the iron yoke cannot maintain its high μ for an unlimited value of H0 . Show that an expression for the minimum dm to keep the yoke unsaturated is given by: H0 dm = R (3.144) Msa where Msa is the yoke material’s saturation magnetization. Compute dm for the following set: μ◦ H◦ = 5 T; μ◦ Msa = 1.2 T; R = 20 mm. y r
θ μ◦
Fig. 3.33
R
μ
R+d
x
Ideal dipole with an iron yoke of thickness d.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
156
Solution to PROBLEM 3.8 a) The field lines are sketched in Fig. 3.34a for both regions. The normal (rdirected) component of the field is continuous at the boundary (r = R). b) The discontinuity in the tangential (θ-directed) component of the field at f ) flowing there. From Eq. 2.6: r = R is equal to the surface current density (K f = ır × (H d2 − H d1 ) = ır × −2H0 cos θ ıθ K = −2H0 cos θ ız
(3.140)
f in the −90◦ < θ < 90◦ segment points in the −zAs indicated in Fig. 3.34b, K direction, while that in the 90◦ < θ < 270◦ segment points in the +z-direction.
y
x
y
y
(a)
x
(b)
x
(c)
Fig. 3.34 Ideal dipole. a) inside and outside fields; b) surface current density vectors; c) force vectors.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
157
Solution to PROBLEM 3.8 (continuation) c)
f ×μ◦ H d1 + H d2 )/2: d , where μ◦ H d = μ◦ (H f L is given by K f × μ◦ H0 sin θ ır f L = K
(S8.1)
= −2μ◦ H02 cos θ sin θ ıθ = −μ◦ H02 sin 2θ ıθ
(3.141)
Note that f L has no r-component; it has only a θ-component (Fig. 3.34c). Also the force density is maximum at θ = π/4+nπ/2 and zero at θ = 0 + nπ/2, where n = 0, 1, 2, 3. The cumulative force, ∝ fL (θ) dθ, is maximum at θ = 0 and 180◦ . d) It is clear from Fig. 3.34c that the net Lorentz force per unit length [N/m] acting on the right-hand segment of the shell is +x-directed. Thus: FLdx =
f L · ıx dx = −R
π/2
−π/2
fLθ sin θ dθ
π/2
= −2R
fLθ sin θ dθ = 0
4Rμ◦ H02
(S8.2a) π/2
cos θ sin2 θ dθ
(S8.2b)
0
From Eq. S8.2b, we obtain:
4Rμ◦ H02 (3.142) 3 The net Lorentz force on the left-hand segment has the same magnitude as that on the right-hand segment but is −x-directed. That is, there is a large force trying to push the two halves of the dipole apart. In fact structural support to withstand these forces is a key design issue for dipole magnets. FLx =
e) Em [J/m] may be computed by integrating μ◦ |H(r, θ)|2 /2, the magnetic energy density, over the entire surface, from r = 0 to r = ∞ and from θ = 0 to θ = 2π, transverse to the dipole axis. Em
μ◦ = 2 =
R
μ◦ |Hd1 | 2πr dr + 2 2
0
∞
|Hd2 |2 2πr dr
μ◦ 2 2 μ◦ 2 2 H πR + H πR 2 0 2 0
= μ◦ πR2 H02 =
(S8.3a)
R
πR2 B02 μ◦
(S8.3b) (3.143)
From Eq. S8.3b it is clear that the total stored magnetic energy is divided equally inside and outside the dipole shell. We may imagine that one-half of the current d2 . d1 and the other half is used to create H flowing in the dipole is used to create H Inserting μ◦ H0 = B0 = 5 T and R = 0.02 m into the above expression, we obtain: Em =
π(2×10−2 m)2 (5 T)2 = 25 kJ/m 4π×10−7 H/m
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
158
Solution to PROBLEM 3.8 (continuation) For a 5-T dipole, 10-m long, the total magnetic energy becomes 250 kJ. This total energy may be equated to the dipole’s total inductive energy: 2 1 2 LIop
= 250 kJ
(S8.4)
Solving Eq. S8.4 for L with Iop = 5000 A, we have: L=
2(250×103 J) (5000 A)2
= 20 mH In 3.7.3 the inductance per unit length of an ideal dipole is given by: L = 81 μ◦ πN 2
(3.87)
Equating this L (= 2 mH/m) with 20 mH and solving for N , we find N 64 for Iop = 5000 A. Note that if the dipole’s operating current is, for example, 1000 A, then the dipole must have an inductance of 0.5 H; it must have five times more winding turns than the 20-mH dipole: N 318. d2 = 0 for R < r < R+d and, if the shield is thick enough to f ) Because μ = ∞, H d2 = 0 also for r > R+d. We still have H d1 as before. Clearly: avoid saturation, H f 1 = −H0 cos θ ıθ K
(S8.5)
f given by Eq. 3.140. Considering the surface current which is exactly one-half of K requirements for both cases, we may interpret that of the total surface current needed to generate the bore field, −2H◦ cos θ, one half comes from the “surface current” of the iron magnetization. g) All the flux per unit length [Wb/m] entering the yoke of radial thickness d between 0 and θ = 90◦ must be equal to or less than μ◦ Msa d. That is: Rμ◦ H0
π/2
sin θ dθ = Rμ◦ H0 ≤ μ◦ Msa d
(S8.6)
0
The minimum yoke thickness dm is thus given by: H0 dm = R Msa
(3.144)
With R = 20 mm, μ◦ H0 = 5 T, and μ◦ Msa = 1.2 T, we obtain: dm = (20 mm)
5T = 83 mm 1.2 T
Note that from Table 2.5 (p. 50), at μ◦ M = 1.25 T for as-cast steel, the material has a permeability of 180μ◦ which, though not ∞, is still large enough for our simple approach based on the assumption that μ = ∞.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
159
PROBLEM 3.9: Ideal quadrupole magnet* This problem studies an ideal quadrupole magnet, which is infinitely long (no end effects) and whose fields, directed normal to the magnet axis, are generated by a longitudinal surface current having zero winding thickness. Like dipole magnets, quadrupole magnets are chiefly used in particle accelerators [3.35, 3.39, 3.44–3.46]. As discussed below in f ), they are used to focus beams of charged particles. A long quadrupole magnet of radius R and of “zero” winding thickness is energized by a surface current flowing in the z-direction at the quadrupole shell (r = R). q1 , and that outside the shell (r > R), The magnetic field within the bore (r < R), H q2 , are given by: H q1 = H0 r (sin 2θ ır + cos 2θ ıθ ) (3.145a) H R 3 R Hq2 = H0 (sin 2θ ır − cos 2θ ıθ ) (3.145b) r In answering the following questions, neglect end effects. a) Draw neatly the field profiles of the quadrupole for both regions. f at r = R is given by: b) Show that an expression for the surface current K f = −2H0 cos 2θ ız K
(3.146)
f is +zIndicate neatly on a sketch its direction, with circles (o) where K directed (out of the paper) and with crosses (×) where Kf is −z-directed. c) Show that an expression for the Lorentz force density per unit length [N/m2 ], f L , acting on a current-carrying element of the shell is given by: f L = −μ◦ H02 sin 4θ ıθ
(3.147)
d) Show that an expression for the “magnetic spring constant,” kLx , in the xdirection for a proton traveling in the +z-direction along the center of the magnet with a speed nearly equal to that of light, c, is given by: kLx
qcμ◦ H0 R
(3.148)
e) Similarly, show that an expression for the “magnetic spring constant,” kLy , in the y-direction for a proton traveling in the +z-direction along the center of the magnet with a speed nearly equal to that of light, c, is given by: kLy −
qcμ◦ H0 R
(3.149)
f ) By stating whether kLx and kLy are unstable or restoring, describe the function of quadrupoles for charged particle accelerators. * Problem 3.8 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS
160
Solution to PROBLEM 3.9 a) The field lines are sketched in Fig. 3.35a. As with the ideal dipole, the rcomponent of the field is continuous at r = R. b) The discontinuity in the θ-component of the field at the boundary is equal to f ) flowing at r = R. Thus: the surface current density (K q2 − H q1 ) = ır × −2H0 cos 2θ ıθ f = ır × (H K = −2H0 cos 2θ ız
(3.146)
f vectors change directions four times around the magnet shell (Fig. 3.35b). The K y
x
(a)
y
y
x
(b)
x
(c)
Fig. 3.35 a) Quadrupole fields inside and outside the bore; b) surface current density vectors in the magnet; c) force directions in the magnet.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
161
Solution to PROBLEM 3.9 (continuation) f and μ◦ H at r = R. At r = R, the c) f L , is given by the cross-product of K q1 + H q2 )/2, is H = H0 sin 2θ ır , because the θ-component of H q1 average field, (H q2 . Noting that K f = −2H0 cos 2θ ız , we have: cancels that of H f L = −2μ◦ H02 sin 2θ cos 2θ ıθ = −μ◦ H02 sin 4θ ıθ
(3.147)
The f L distribution is sketched in Fig. 3.35c. d)
We may define the magnetic spring constant in the x-direction as:
∂FLx (S9.1) ∂x FLx , the Lorentz force in the x-direction on a proton of electric charge q traveling in the z-direction with a velocity nearly equal to c (speed of light), is given by: kLx = −
FLx [q(c ız )×μ◦ Hq1 ıθ ]θ=0 r −qcμ◦ H0 ıx R
(S9.2)
kLx is thus given by: kLx = −
∂FLx ∂FLx =− ∂x ∂r
qcμ◦ H0 R
(3.148)
e) In the y-direction (r-direction at θ = 90◦ ), the magnetic force FLy is given by: FLy [q(c ız )×μ◦ Hq1 ıθ ]θ= π2 r qcμ◦ H0 ıy R
(S9.3)
kLy is thus given by: kLy = − −
∂FLy ∂FLy =− ∂y ∂r qcμ◦ H0 R
(3.149)
f ) FLx is restoring, but FLy is unstable, diverging the beam in the y-direction. In accelerator rings, quadrupole magnets are thus used in pairs, one focusing the beam in the x-direction followed by another focusing the beam in the y-direction; the net effect is focusing in both directions.
Answer to TRIVIA 3.3 iii). Despite his friendship with the royal family, having been lionized by Marie Antoinette, it is said that Joseph Louis Lagrange (1736–1813) survived the Terror because of the general respect for his accomplishments in mathematics and his foreign birth (Torino). He was appointed to head this commission in 1793.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
162
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet* We discuss here a magnet comprised of two parallel long ideal “racetrack” coils spaced a distance 2c apart in the plane normal to the magnet axis. The name “racetrack” arises because at each end the conductor loops around 180◦ like the end of a racetrack. Unlike in a dipole winding, its windings remain in a plane, i.e., flat. The flat winding makes it easier to wind a racetrack than a dipole, and thus racetrack coils are preferred over dipole coils in generators and motors [3.47–3.50]. The racetrack magnet is also suitable for Maglev [3.51–3.53]. Figure 3.36 shows a cross sectional view of the winding configuration of a magnet comprised of two long ideal racetracks. A set of two very long racetrack coils, parallel to each other as shown, can sometimes substitute for a dipole magnet. For example, if a long length of a superconductor must be tested in a uniform field directed transverse to its major axis, this magnet configuration could be used; it has the advantage of requiring simpler winding rigs than a dipole magnet. As indicated in Fig. 3.36, each of the two racetracks, 2c apart, has a winding outer width of 2a2 , inner width of 2a1 , and contains N turns. The direction of current in the right-hand side of each racetrack coil is in the +z direction (out of the paper), while the direction of current in the left-hand side is in the −z direction. We shall derive expressions of key parameters of the magnet.
2a2 2a1 Racetrack 1 (N turns)
y
x
2c
Racetrack 2 (N turns)
Fig. 3.36
Cross section of a magnet comprised of two ideal racetrack coils.
* Problem 3.9 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
163
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet (continuation) A. Field at Magnet Center By applying the law of Biot-Savart (Eq. 3.1) on a differential surface current, K dξ, located at ξ in the right-hand side of racetrack 1 (with +z current) as shown in 1+ : Fig. 3.37, we obtain an expression for the differential field at (x, y), dH 1+ = dH
K dξ ı 2πr1
(3.150)
where the field direction is shown in the figure and K = N I/(a2 − a1 ). The ycomponent of field, Hy1+ , contributed by the entire +z-surface current, from ξ = a1 to ξ = a2 , is given by integration of Eq. 3.151 (below) from ξ = a1 to ξ = a2 : Hy1+ With r1 = Hy1+
K =− 2π
a2
a1
cos θ1 dξ r1
(3.151)
(ξ −x)2 +(c−y)2 and cos θ1 = (ξ −x)/r1 into Eq. 3.151, we obtain: K =− 2π
a2
a1
(ξ −x) dξ (a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 K =− ln (ξ −x)2 +(c−y)2 4π (a1 −x)2 +(c−y)2
Similarly, the contributions from the remaining current sheets are given (ξ +x) dξ K a2 (a2 +x)2 +(c−y)2 K Hy1− = − =− ln 2π a1 (ξ +x)2 +(c−y)2 4π (a1 +x)2 +(c−y)2 (ξ −x) dξ K a2 (a2 −x)2 +(c+y)2 K Hy2+ = − = − ln 2π a1 (ξ −x)2 +(c+y)2 4π (a1 −x)2 +(c+y)2 (ξ +x) dξ K a2 (a2 +x)2 +(c+y)2 K Hy2− = − =− ln 2π a1 (ξ +x)2 +(c+y)2 4π (a1 +x)2 +(c+y)2
dξ r1 θ1
c
(x, y) z (0, 0)
θ1
ξ 1+ dH
Fig. 3.37
Field produced by a differential current element.
(3.152a) by: (3.152b)
(3.152c)
(3.152d)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
164
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet (continuation) Combining these four contributions, we have: (a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 K (a2 +x)2 +(c−y)2 Hy (x, y) = − ln + ln 4π (a1 −x)2 +(c−y)2 (a1 +x)2 +(c−y)2 (a2 −x)2 +(c+y)2 (a2 +x)2 +(c+y)2 + ln + ln (3.153a) (a1 −x)2 +(c+y)2 (a1 +x)2 +(c+y)2 By inserting x = 0 and y = 0 into Eq. 3.153a, we obtain: 2 K a2 + c2 Hy (0, 0) = − ln π a21 + c2
(3.153b)
B. Field Near the Center We may derive an expression of Hy (x, y) (Eq. 3.153a) as the sum of Hy (0, 0) and a term containing Hy1+ derived above. Equation 3.152a may be expressed as: (a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 K Hy1+ = − ln 4π (a1 −x)2 +(c−y)2
K 2 2 2 2 =− (3.154) ln[(a2 −x) +(c−y) ]−ln[(a1 −x) +(c−y) ] 4π The term ln[(a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 ] may be given as: x2 + y 2 −2a2 x−2cy ln[(a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 ] = ln (a22 +c2 ) 1+ a22 +c2 x2 +y 2 −2a2 x−2cy 2 2 = ln(a2 +c )+ln 1+ a22 +c2 By using ln(1+x) x − x2 /2 for |x| 1, we have: ln[(a2 −x)2 +(c−y)2 ] ln(a22 +c2 ) +
(c2 −a22 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a22 +c2 )(a2 x+cy)−4a2 cxy (a22 +c2 )2
ln[(a1 −x)2 +(c−y)2 ] ln(a21 +c2 ) +
(c2 −a21 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a21 +c2 )(a1 x+cy)−4a1 cxy (a21 +c2 )2
Thus, Eq. 3.154 may be expressed as: K a22 +c2 (c2 −a22 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a22 +c2 )(a2 x+cy)−4a2 cxy ln 2 2 + Hy1+ (x, y) − 4π a1 +c (a22 +c2 )2
(c2 −a21 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a21 +c2 )(a1 x+cy)−4a1 cxy − (3.155a) (a21 +c2 )2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
165
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet (continuation) Similarly, Hy1− , Hy2+ , and Hy2− may be expressed as: K a2 +c2 (c2 −a22 )(x2 −y 2 )+2(a22 +c2 )(a2 x−cy)+4a2 cxy Hy1− (x, y) − ln 22 2 + 4π a1 +c (a22 +c2 )2
(c2 −a21 )(x2 −y 2 )+2(a21 +c2 )(a1 x−cy)+4a1 cxy − (3.155b) (a21 +c2 )2 a22 +c2 K (c2 −a22 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a22 +c2 )(a2 x−cy)+4a2 cxy Hy2+ (x, y) − ln 2 2 + 4π a1 +c (a22 +c2 )2
(c2 −a21 )(x2 −y 2 )−2(a21 +c2 )(a1 x−cy)+4a1 cxy − (3.155c) (a21 +c2 )2 a22 +c2 K (c2 −a22 )(x2 −y 2 )+2(a22 +c2 )(a2 x+cy)−4a2 cxy Hy2− (x, y) − ln 2 2 + 4π a1 +c (a22 +c2 )2
(c2 −a21 )(x2 −y 2 )+2(a21 +c2 )(a1 x−cy)−4a1 cxy − (3.155d) (a21 +c2 )2 Combining each term, near (0, 0) we have: 2 2 K a2 +c (a22 −a21 )[3c4 +(a22 +a21 )c2 −a22 a21 ] 2 2 Hy (x, y) − ln − (x −y ) π a21 +c2 (a22 +c2 )2 (a21 +c2 )2 2 2 a2 −c a21 −c2 Hy (0, 0) + K − (3.156a) (x2 −y 2 ) (a22 +c2 )2 (a21 +c2 )2 Note that the 2nd -order inhomogeneity term becomes zero when c2 satisfies: c2 = 61 (a22 +a21 )2 + 12a22 a21 − (a22 +a21 ) = 61 a42 +14a22 a21 +a41 − (a22 +a21 ) (3.156b) . C. Center Field from Four Current Elements We may further simplify the expression for the magnetic field near the center of the racetrack magnet by approximating each of the four current sheets as a current element carrying N I, illustrated in Fig. 3.38. A dot indicates it is in the +z-direction and a cross in the −z-direction. In this case, we let a1 = a, a2 = a + , and K = K(a2 − a) = N I. Substituting these parameters into Eq. 3.153b and noting ln(1+x) = x for |x| 1, we have: 2 2 2 2 K K a2 +c a +c + 2a Hy (0, 0) = − ln − ln π a21 +c2 π a2 +c2 −
K2a 2aN I − 2 2 π(a +c ) π(a2 +c2 )
(3.157a)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
166
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet (continuation)
2a 2
1 NI
y •
x
2c
(0, 0)
4 Fig. 3.38
3
Current distribution model for force calculation.
The quantity K(a22 −a21 ) = K(a2 +a1 )(a2 −a1 ) in the second term of the right-hand side of the first line of Eq. 3.156a becomes 2aN I. Thus: 2aN I[3c4 +2a2 c2 −a4 ] 2 2 K(a22 −a21 )[3c4 +(a22 +a21 )c2 −a22 a21 ] 2 2 (x −y ) (x −y ) π(a22 +c2 )2 (a21 +c2 )2 π(a2 +c2 )4 4 3c +2a2 c2 −a4 2 2 = −Hy (0, 0) (x −y ) (a2 +c2 )3 Combining the above equation and Eq. 3.156, we obtain:
3c4 +2a2 c2 −a4 2 2 (x −y ) Hy (x, y) Hy (0, 0) 1 + (a2 + c2 )3
(3.157b)
D. Forces on Current Elements The same 4-current-element model may be used to compute the Lorentz forces (per unit axial length) acting on current element 1, F1 , as the sum of Lorentz interactions on current element 1 by current elements 2, 3, and 4: F1 = F1 |2 + F1 |3 + F1 |4
(3.158)
where F1 |2 , F1 |3 , and F1 |4 are the force vectors on element 1 by elements, respectively, 2, 3, and 4. The force, F1 |2 , on element 1 carrying I1 = N I by element 2 carrying I2 = N I, is +x-directed and given by: μ◦ I1 I2 μ◦ N 2 I 2 F1 |2 = ıx = ıx 4πa 4πa
(3.159a)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
167
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.8: Two-“Racetrack” Coil Magnet (continuation) Similarly, the force on element 1 by element 3, F1 |3 , is −y-directed and given by: μ◦ I1 I3 μ◦ N 2 I 2 F1 |3 = − ıy = − ıy 4πc 4πc
(3.159b)
The force on element 1 by element 4, F1 |4 , is directed along both x and y axes: μ◦ I1 I4 a c √ √ √ F1 |4 = ıx + ıy 4π a2 + c2 a2 + c2 a2 + c2 μ◦ N 2 I 2 a c = ıx + 2 ıy (3.159c) 4π a2 + c2 a + c2 The x- and y-components of the electromagnetic force on element 1 from the three other current elements, F1x and F1y , are thus given, respectively, by: μ◦ N 2 I 2 1 a μ◦ N 2 I 2 a2 F1x = + = 1+ 2 (3.160a) 4π a a2 + c2 4πa a + c2 μ◦ N 2 I 2 1 c μ◦ N 2 I 2 c2 − + 2 F1y = =− 1− 2 (3.160b) 4π c a + c2 4πc a + c2 E. Interaction Forces Within Racetrack and Between Racetracks Because c2 < a2 + c2 , F1y points in the −y-direction. The net force between elements 1 and 2, within racetrack 1, is repulsive because their current polarities are opposite. Similarly, that between elements 3 and 4 in racetrack 2 is repulsive. Thus, in the absence of external restraint, each racetrack seeks a circular geometry. The net force between elements 1 and 3, because their polarities are the same, is attractive. Similarly, that between elements 2 and 4 is attractive. As indicated by Eq. 3.160b, the net force between the two racetracks is attractive. Help from Van (Part 2 of 5 Parts) —Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist I well remember the occasion for the first trial. We were to have the power at some time in the middle of the night, around 1 A.M. Shortly before the appointed hour Van arrived to see how things went. Then, as usual, there were seemingly endless delays. First of all, for some unforeseen reason, the power was not available, and we were told to wait half an hour. Then another hour. Then we went out to get some coffee. I don’t remember just how long, in the end, we had to wait. But finally the moment arrived. Sometime near dawn, when we were all worn out with waiting, we stood around the corner of a wall and watched as the power began to be turned up. At first everything was all right. Then there were slight hissing sounds. They got louder; finally there was a bang. Whereupon the power was shut off. When we went to examine the magnet, we could find nothing much wrong. One of the bolts in the flanges of the case holding the parts together had mysteriously exploded. The magnet had failed for some reason quite different from those we had expected.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
168
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.10: Ideal toroidal magnet* This problem deals with an ideal toroidal magnet, i.e., of zero winding thickness, illustrating key features of toroidal magnets. An ideal circular-cross-section torus of major radius R and minor radius a is energized with a surface current sheet with equivalent total ampere turns N I (Fig. 3.39). Assume that the surface current flows around the torus in the plane perpendicular to the toroidal direction, i.e., zero pitch in the ϕ-direction. a) Show that an expression for the toroidal magnetic induction, Bϕ , within the torus is given by: μ◦ N I Bϕ (r) = (3.161) 2πr Also show that Bϕ outside the torus is zero. b) Assuming that the torus consists of N loops, each carrying a current of I, show that an expression for the net radial Lorentz force FL+ acting on a single loop is given by: R μ◦ N I 2 FL+ = 1− √ (3.162) 2 R2 − a2 z ϕ
R
I
I
ϕ B
Fig. 3.39
a
ϕ B
r
Ideal toroidal magnet comprised of N loops, each carrying current I.
* Based on Problem 3.10 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
TRIVIA 3.4 Of the four pressures below, three are close to the magnetic pressure corresponding to a 1.5-T field, while the other is not. Identify this odd man out. i) Compressive, on the toes of a ballerina performing a pirouette; ii) Internal, of an uncorked champagne bottle; iii) Lift, on the wings of a 747 jet at cruising speed; iv) Thermal, of the plasma in an experimental Tokamak.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
169
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.10 a) Noting that Hϕ , from symmetry, is independent of ϕ, we can apply Ampere’s integral law within the torus: 2π Hϕ (r)r dϕ = 2πrHϕ (r) = N I (S10.1) 0
Because Bϕ (r) = μ◦ Hϕ (r), we have: Bϕ (r) =
μ◦ N I 2πr
(3.161)
Outside the torus, no net current is enclosed when the above integral is performed over the entire circumference. Therefore Hϕ (r) = 0 and Bϕ (r) = 0. b) Figure 3.40 shows a single loop in which a differential force dFL acts on a differential element ds with differential force dFLr in the r-direction. dFL is given by:
˜ϕ (r)ıϕ dFL = −I dsıθ × B
(S10.2)
˜ϕ (r) is the average field acting on the surface current. Because this field where B varies from that given by Eq. 3.161 just inside the surface current to zero just outside, the average field is one half of that given by Eq. 3.161. Thus: 2 ˜ϕ (r)ıϕ = μ◦ N I ds ıξ dFL = −I dsıθ × B 4πr
(S10.3)
where the vector ıξ points in the direction of FL (Fig. 3.40). The r-component of this differential force is given by: dFLr =
z
μ◦ N I 2 cos θ ds 4πr
(S10.4)
ϕ R ds
L dF dFr
dθ θ
r
a
Fig. 3.40
Differential force acting on a single loop.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
170
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.10 (continuation) Because ds = a dθ and r = R + a cos θ, we can write Eq. S10.4 for dFLr as: dFLr =
μ◦ N I 2 a cos θ dθ 4π(R + a cos θ)
(S10.5)
By integrating Eq. S10.5 for the entire minor circle, we have: FLr
μ◦ N I 2 a = 4π
0
2π
cos θ dθ μ◦ N I 2 a = R + a cos θ 2π
0
π
cos θ dθ R + a cos θ
(S10.6)
Using a table of integrals, we obtain: FLr
π θ R π dθ − a 0 a 0 R + a cos θ
π μ◦ N I 2 a π 2R R−a θ −1 = − √ tan tan 2π a R+a 2 a R2 − a2 0
μ◦ N I 2 a = 2π
FLr
μ◦ N I 2 R = 1− √ 2 R2 − a2
(S10.7a)
(3.162)
Note that as R → ∞, the torus becomes a straight solenoid of diameter 2a and, as expected, FLr → 0.
DISCUSSION 3.9: Nuclear Fusion and Magnetic Confinement If nuclei of light elements are confined and heated to a very high temperature (∼100 MK), they fuse. Because the total mass of the fusion products, Mf , is less than the total mass of the original nuclei, Mn , a net energy En = (Mn −Mf )c2 is released by the reaction, where c is the speed of light. The sun generates energy through this process. A controlled thermonuclear fusion reactor is a miniature man-made sun. The sun confines unstable hot plasma gravitationally. Magnetic pressure can substitute for gravitational pressure; the technique of using magnetic fields to stabilize a hot plasma is known as magnetic confinement. Power-generating fusion reactors will most likely use the Tokamak, a toroidalshaped machine configuration that uses magnetic confinement. The Tokamak was conceived in the 1950s by L.A. Artsimovich and A.D. Sakharov of the Kurchatov Institute of Atomic Energy, Moscow. The International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) project is a joint project of the European Union, Japan, Russia, United States, Korea, China, and India. ITER’s goal is to construct a break-even Tokamak based on superconducting magnets. ITER’s toroidal magnet, not circular as studied above but D-shaped, will have a major radius (R) of ∼8 m and be ∼12 m tall (2a in the z-direction); its toroidal magnetic induction (Bϕ ) is ∼6 T, with a peak induction at the conductor of ∼13 T. ITER will be built in the French region called Cadarache, ∼40 km north of Aix-en-Provence.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
171
PROBLEM 3.11: Fringing field* This problem deals with fringing fields—unwanted fields outside a magnet system. A fringing field is important because it can be a safety hazard to those near the system; it may also disrupt or distort field-sensitive equipment. For computing the f , at locations far from the magnet, the magnet can be modeled fringing field, H as a spherical dipole with an effective radius Re : 3 f = H0 Re (cos θır + 1 sin θıθ ) H (3.163) 2 r where μ◦ H0 is the central field. We may compute Re by equating the dipole’s far field (r Re ) along the z-axis (r-direction at θ = 0), given by Eq. 3.163, and that (z a) of a ring of current I and radius a, given by Eq. 3.3a. Thus: H0 Re3 = 21 a2 I
(3.164)
a) For a solenoidal coil having total ampere-turns of N I, i.d. of 2a1 and o.d. of ˜2 , that Eq. 3.164 is modified to: 2a2 , show, by using a weighted-average, a H0 Re3 = 21 a ˜2 N I = 61 (a21 + a22 + a1 a2 )N I
(3.165)
When Eq. 3.164 is applied to each layer of a winding comprising n layers, each layer having the same total turns per layer, nt/ , we have, given without derivation, an expression, which the reader with extra time may derive: (n +1) 3 2 (n +1)(2n +1) 1 2 H0 Re = 2 a1 N I 1+(α−1) +(α−1) (3.166) n 6n2 Note that N = nt/ n . For n 1, Eq. 3.166 may be approximated by Eq. 3.165. Because Re is proportional to the cube root of the right-hand side of each equation, in most cases Eq. 3.165 is a good approximation to Eq. 3.166. In any case these equations are valid only for r Re , and thus Re computed by Eq. 3.165 is independent of magnet length, 2b, and N I. For a nested-coil magnet comprised of k coils, Eq. 3.165 may be generalized to: H0 Re3 = 61 I
k
(a21j + a22j + a1j a2j )Nj
(3.167)
j=1
b) By using Eq. 3.167 and parameter values given in Table 3.3, show that Re = 0.67 m for the 45-T SCM. (Because the water magnet’s volume is much smaller than the SCM’s, the water magnet, despite its central field of 31 T, contributes little to the fringing fields and may be neglected here.) c) For reasons of safety, people and equipment associated with operation and experiment of this magnet should be outside the 100-gauss contour prolate spheroid of the magnet. Determine the radial distance rm , at z = 2.75 m, at f | is 100 gauss. which the fringing field magnitude |μ◦ H * Based on Problem 3.11 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
172
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.11 a)
The weighted-average a ˜2 of a solenoid of 2a1 and 2a2 may be given by: a2 1 (a32 − a31 ) a ˜2 = r2 dr = = 31 (a21 + a22 + a1 a2 ) (S11.1) (a2 − a1 ) a1 3(a2 − a1 )
Thus: H0 Re3 = 21 a ˜2 N I = 61 (a21 + a22 + a1 a2 )N I
(3.165)
b) Applying Eq. 3.167 to the 45-T SCM (Table 3.3) with H0 = 14 T/μ◦ , we have: (14 T) R3 = 61 (104 A)× (4π×10−7 H/m) e [(0.355 m)2 +(0.444 m)2 +(0.355 m)(0.444 m)]×306 + [(0.454 m)2 +(0.5575 m)2 +(0.454 m)(0.5575 m)]×378 + [(0.575 m)2 +(0.840 m)2 +(0.575 m)(0.840 m)]×1015 (11.1408×106 A/m)Re3 = 3.300×106 A m2 Re = 0.667 m f = 0.01 T (100 gauss) at Iop = 10 kA, we have: c) With μ◦ H
3 0.67 m (0.01 T) = (14 T) (cos θır + Rm (R m) = (x m)2 + 0 + (2.7 m)2 xm θ = tan−1 2.7 m
1 2
sin θıθ )
(S11.2a) (S11.2b) (S11.2c)
Solving Eqs. S11.2a, S11.2b, and S11.2c for x, we find: x = 6.52 m. For x = 6.52 m, we find from Eq. S11.2b that R 7.05 m and θ 67.5◦ . Note that this 100-gauss exposure to the experimenters, presumably over a period of a half day or at most a day, is different from the long-term exposure level of 5 gauss sanctioned by the FDA.
Answer to TRIVIA 3.4 iii) 747 (0.06, in atm); 1.5-T field (9) —champagne (6); ballerina toes (8); plasma (10).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
173
DISCUSSION 3.10: Scaling a Solenoidal Magnet In an early stage of magnet design, it is sometimes convenient, and certainly quick, to scale, up or down, the parameters of a magnet already designed to those of a new magnet. Requirements often imposed in scaling are to preserve the central field, Hz (0, 0), or power consumption. Note that all the scaling laws below, though formulated for a solenoidal magnet, are applicable to magnets of any shape. Thus, the original winding dimensions, a1◦ ≡ a◦ ; a2◦ ≡ α◦ a◦ ; b◦ ≡ β◦ a◦ , are scaled up by χ > 1 (or down by χ < 1), where χ is a constant, to new winding dimensions, respectively, a1χ = χa◦ , a2χ = χα◦ a◦ , and bχ = χβ◦ a◦ . Note that in the following discussion all ◦-subscripted parameters are those of the original magnet, while χ-subscripted parameters are those of the scaled magnet. The parameters of interest are: Hz (0, 0) ≡ H, the central field; λ, the space factor; J, the overall current density; I, the operating current; A, the conductor crosssectional area; E, the magnetic energy; , the total conductor length, and V, the volume in the winding. In this discussion, let us assume that both magnets have the same space factor: λχ = λ◦ = λ. A. Spatial Homogeneity As discussed in 3.4, the spatial field homogeneity of a solenoidal magnet is determined completely by α and β. Therefore, the full-scale magnet will have the same field homogeneity (over the scaled volume) as the model magnet (over the original volume) if α and β are kept the same. B. Center Field vs. Current Density From Eq. 3.13a (3.4 and PROBLEM 3.1), for the same λ, α, and β, the center field is proportional to a1 J. Because a1χ = χa◦ , Jχ must be scaled by 1/χ: Jχ = J◦/χ. Note that because the magnetic pressure is proportional to Hz2 (0, 0), it follows that the magnetic pressure of the new magnet remains the same as that of the original magnet. This can also be seen by noting that magnetic pressure is proportional to a1 J, the product of the magnet’s radial size and its operating current density, and the product is invariant in this scaling process. As may be inferred from Eq. 3.54, the total axial force at the midplane of the new magnet will be χ2 times that of the original magnet—in Eq. 3.54, the (N I/4b)2 term remains unchanged; it is the “area” term that increases by χ2 . C. Conductor Size & Operating Current The scaled magnet’s conductor cross sectional area, Aχ Iχ /Jχ , has to be scaled by χ2 if Iχ is scaled by χ: Aχ = χ2 A◦ for Iχ = χI◦ . On the other hand, if the operating current remains unchanged, Iχ = I◦ , then Aχ = χA◦ . D. Total Number of Turns The scaled magnet’s number of turns, Nχ , may be given by: Nχ =
λJχ (2βaχ )aχ (α−1) Iχ
(3.168a)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
174
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.10: Scaling a Solenoidal Magnet (continuation) As with Aχ , and Jχ = J◦/χ, because Hz (0, 0) must remain unchanged, Nχ can remain unchanged or must be scaled by χ, as shown below. (for Iχ = χI◦ )
Nχ =
λ(J◦/χ)(2βχa◦ )χa◦ (α−1) = N◦ χI◦
(3.168b)
(for Iχ = I◦ )
Nχ =
λ(J◦/χ)(2βχa◦ )χa◦ (α−1) = χN◦ I◦
(3.168c)
E. Total Conductor Length, Operating Current & Ampere-Meter The total conductor length required for the magnet, χ , may have two options: (for Iχ = χI◦ ) (for Iχ = I◦ )
χ = Nχ π(αaχ + aχ ) = N◦ χπa◦ (α + 1) = χ ◦
(3.169a)
χ = χN◦ χπa◦ (α + 1) = χ2 ◦
(3.169b)
The total ampere-meter, Iχ χ , which is a good indication of the conductor cost, thus is scaled by χ2 in either case: Iχ χ = χ2 I◦ ◦
(3.170)
F. Total Magnetic Energy Because the total magnetic energy of a magnet is the magnetic energy density integrated over the entire spatial volume occupied by the field, and because the magnetic energy density remains unchanged, it follows: Emχ = χ3 Em◦ . Illustrative Example We have a model magnet of the following parameters: Hz (0, 0) = 1.53 T; 2a1 = 80 mm; 2a2 = 130 mm; 2b = 220 mm; total number of turns, N◦ = 2976. The magnet has a self inductance of 0.301 H and generates a center field of 1.53 T at an operating current, I◦ , of 100 A. Now let us consider a “full-scale” magnet with its dimensions scaled by 10 from the model magnet with λ remaining the same. We may compute a few parameters for the full-scale magnets. Inductance Because Lχ = μ◦ aχ Nχ2 L(α, β), 1) Lχ = χL◦ (if Iχ = χI◦ ); or 2) Lχ = χ3 L◦ (if Iχ = I◦ ). Thus: 1) Lχ 3.01 H if Iχ = 1000 A; and 2) Lχ = 301 H if Iχ = 100 A. Let us first compute ◦ : ◦ = N◦
a◦ (α+1) 2
= (2976)
(0.04 m)(1.625+1) 156 m 2
Thus: 1) χ 1.56 km if Iχ = 1000 A; or 2) χ = 15.6 km if Iχ = 100 A.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
175
DISCUSSION 3.11: Particle Accelerators accelerates charged particles is the The simple principle that an electric field (E) basis for particle accelerators. Early machines of Cockroft-Walton (1928) and Van de Graaff (1930) were linear, accelerating particles along a straight path over a ·ds). A large potential is always required to produce highly energetic potential ( E field, a long distance, particles. A linear accelerator thus requires either a large E or a combination of both. The Stanford Linear Accelerator (∼20 GeV) has a beam distance of 2 miles (3.2 km). In the 1930s E.O. Lawrence developed the cyclotron, a circular accelerator. Modern circular accelerators are variations of Lawrence’s cyclotron. In a circular accelerator, charged particles are accelerated by a modest potential each time they circulate around the machine; by circulating them many times it is possible to accelerate them to energy levels well beyond those achievable by linear accelerators. One essential component of a circular accelerator is a set of magnets that supplies a magnetic field (usually in the vertical direction) to bend the particles into a circular trajectory; modern machines use dipole magnets, while Lawrence’s first 1.2-MeV cyclotron used magnet polepieces, which sandwiched the beam trajectory. As studied in PROBLEM 3.12 below, the particle energy (Ep ) in circular accelerators is proportional to the beam trajectory’s radius (Ra ), beam velocity, and vertical magnetic induction (Bz ). For a particle energy of 7 TeV of the newest particle accelerator, Large Hadron Collider (LHC), at CERN, it means a machine radius of nearly 3 km! Compare this with ∼0.1 m, the radius of Lawrence’s first cyclotron. If the LHC were to use ∼1 T, the strength of Bz in Lawrence’s first cyclotron, the factor of ∼3×104 increase in radius (and increase in beam energy) would still bring Ep to only ∼0.8 TeV. In LHC, the additional factor of ∼8 needed to reach the energy level of 7 TeV is achieved through increased field strength, a goal feasible only with superconducting dipole magnets.
PROBLEM 3.12: Circulating proton in an accelerator* The LHC, the world’s largest “atom smasher” (protons), has ∼1250 dipole magnets, each ∼14 m long and generating a field of 8.3 T within a diameter of 56 mm. The LHC will have two counter-circulating beams of protons, each accelerated to an energy (Ep ) of 7 TeV. a) The oblong-shaped main ring comprises two half circles of radius Ra = 2.8 km, connected by 4.5-km nearly straight sections for a proton with an energy Ep of 7 TeV. The dipoles occupy the ring’s two half-circle sections. Show that a dipole field of 8.3 T generates a Lorentz force, FL , that balances the centripetal force, Fcp , on a 7-TeV proton in the circular section. Assume that the proton speed is equal to the speed of light. Note: 1 eV= 1.6×10−19 J. b) Show that the proton speed at an energy of 7 TeV is nearly the speed of light. * Based on Problem 3.12 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
176
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.12 a) The centripetal force, Fcp , on a circulating proton (mass Mp ) is balanced by the Lorentz force, FL . The direction of Bz is chosen to make FL point radially inward because Fcp always points radially outward. The two forces are given by: Mp v 2 Mp c2 Ep Fcp = ır ır = ır Ra Ra Ra
(S12.1a)
FL = −qcBz ır
(S12.1b)
Solving for Ra from Fcp + FL = 0, we obtain: Ra =
Ep qcBz
(S12.2)
From Eq. S12.2, we have: Ra =
(1.6×10−19 J/eV)(7×1012 eV) (1.6×10−19 C)(3×108 m/s)(8.3 T)
2.81×103 m 2.8 km This is less than the actual radius of LHC, which is slightly over 4 km. Note that in the above computation it is assumed that the entire ring is occupied by dipoles; in fact the occupancy rate for the dipoles is ∼60%—quadrupoles, detector magnets occupy most of the rest. The average dipole field along the LHC ring is thus ∼5 T, leading to a computed radius of ∼4 km. Of course, a dipole field of Bz = 15 T, for example, will nearly halve the ring diameter; superconducting dipole magnets with a field in the range 10–16 T are not out of the question [3.54–3.56]. b) The proton mass Mp , traveling at speed v, is related to its rest mass, Mp◦ (1.67×10−27 kg), by: Mp◦ Ep v 2 = c2 1− c
Mp =
Solving for v/c from Eq. S12.3, we have: Mp2◦ c4 v = 1− c Ep2
(S12.3)
(S12.4)
Because v/c is very close to 1, Eq. S12.4 may be approximated by: Mp2◦ c4 v (1.67×10−27 kg)2 (3×108 m/s)4 1− = 1 − c 2Ep2 2(1.6×10−19 J/eV)2 (7×1012 eV)2 1 − 9×10−9 That is, the proton velocity is within nine parts per billion of the speed of light. TRIVIA 3.5 If an electron is to circle around the earth at the equator, should it travel eastward or westward? (Note that it will travel at nearly the speed of light.)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
177
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.13: Two-coil magnet Figure 3.41 shows a cross sectional view of a magnet consisting of two axially aligned identical coils, A and B, energized in the same polarity. The axial field, Bz , is in the horizontal direction. As remarked in PROBLEM 3.3 (Helmholtz coil), the antisymmetric system (Maxwell coil) generates a “linear” axial field (Bz ) at the midpoint (z = 0). The axial interaction force between coils in the symmetric system is attractive; in the split-pair antisymmetric configuration, repulsive, of identical magnitude. The winding parameters of each coil are: 2a1 = 1.5 m; 2a2 = 2.1 m; 2b = 0.1 m; N = 8900; and I = 65 A. The left coil is axially centered at z = 0.5 m, while the right coil is at z = 0.5 m—the center-to-center distance is 1 m (ρ in 3.5). Each heavy horizontal bar schematically represents a room-temperature structural element that supports the interactive force between the two coils. Figures 3.42a and 3.42b show, respectively, Bz (r, z) and Br (r, z) plots for one coil at I = 65 A. Note that here z = 0 coincides with the axial midpoint of the coil.
→ ↑ 0.1 (2b) → ←
r ↑
←
1.0 (ρ)
↑
2.1 1.5 (2a2 ) (2a1 )
•
(−0.5,0)
• (0,0)
•
(0.5,0)
→z
↓ ↓
⊗
⊗
Coil A
Coil B
Fig. 3.41 Cross sectional view of a 2-coil magnet consisting of two identical coils, A and B, energized in the same polarity. Dimension in meters.
178
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.13: Two-coil magnet (continutation) 1.5 z =0 0.05
1.0
Bz (
) [T]
0.1 0.5
0.25 0.5 0.75
1.0 1.5
0
−0.5
−1.0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Radial Displacement, r [m] (a)
0.8
0.1
) [T]
z = 0.05
0.6
Br (
1.0
0.4
0.25
0.2
0.5
0
0.75 1.0 1.5
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Radial Displacement, r [m] (b) Fig. 3.42 (a) Bz (r, z) and (b) Br (r, z) plots for one coil, A or B, at I = 65 A, with the other coil unenergized, at axial (z) locations of the energized coil.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
179
PROBLEM 3.13: Two-coil magnet (continuation) a) Compute the overall current density of Coil A at I = 65 A. b) Compute the total conductor length in the winding of Coil A. c) Using an appropriate analytical expression, show that Bz at the axial midpoint of Coil A at 65 A, with Coil B not energized, is approximately 0.4 T, as given by Fig. 3.42a. d) Using L(α, β) given by Fig. 3.14 for solenoidal coils and Eq. 3.81, compute the self inductance L of Coil A; a code gives 216.8 H. f ) Show, qualitatively, that the axial force on Coil A, FzA (ρ), studied in 3.5.1, when Coil B is energized at 65 A, is +z-directed, i.e., the axial force between Coils A and B is attractive. g) Using appropriate field data of Figs. 3.42a and 3.42b, compute the magnitude of this interactive force, when each coil is energized with a current of 65 A, to within ±20% of ∼2 × 105 N. (A code value is −193 kN, the minus sign indicating that the force is attractive.) h) Approximating each coil as a “ring coil” (see Fig. 3.5) and using Eq. 3.34, compute the axial force exerted on Coil A, FzA (ρ), by Coil B. Use K(k) = 2.10000 and E(k) = 1.2000 with k = 0.874157. Note that here aA = aB = 0.9 m and ρ = 1.0 m. i) Compute FzA (ρ) for ρ = 5 m. Table 3.6 gives computed mutual inductance vs. center-to-center distance data, MAB (ρ), for this 2-coil system. j) Show that the total stored magnetic energy of the system, Em , for ρ = 1.0 m at an operating current of 65 A is approximately 1 MJ. Use L = 216.8 H. k) By applying Eq. 3.105b on the system, compute FzA (ρ) from the MAB (ρ) data.
Table 3.6: MAB vs. ρ Data ρ [m]
MAB [H]
ρ [m]
MAB [H]
0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
85.230 69.890 57.997 48.585 41.028
0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3
34.873 29.826 25.650 22.173 19.258
“Sometimes there is as much magic as science in the explanations of the force. Yet what is a magician but a practicing theorist?” —Obi Wan Kenobi
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
180
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.13 a)
From Eq. 3.108a: λJ = =
NI 2b(a2 − a1 )
(3.108a)
(8900)(65 A) = 19.3×106 A/m2 (0.1 m)(1.05 m − 0.75 m)
b) Total conductor length, , is given by: = N π(a2 +a1 ) 50.3 km. This 2-coil magnet thus contains a total conductor length of ∼100 km. c) We may approximate Coil A (or Coil B) as a “pancake” coil with α = 1.4. By applying Eq. 3.111f , we obtain BzA , the center axial field of Coil A: μ◦ N I ln α BzA Bz (0, 0) = (3.111f ) 2a1 α − 1 (4π×10−7 H/m)(8900)(65 A) 0.336 = = 0.4 T (1.5 m) 0.4 d) From Fig. 3.14, we have L(α = 1.4, β = 0.067) 2.8. From Eq. 3.81: L = μ◦ a1 N 2 L(α, β)
(3.81)
= (4π×10−7 H/m)(0.75 m)(8900)2 (2.8) = 209 H f ) Br (r, z) of Fig. 3.42b is valid for z ≥ 0, indicating Br (r, z) is positive, pointing radially outward. When Br (r, z) generated by Coil B is applied to Coil A, however, because Coil A is located at z < 0 relative to the axial midpoint of Coil B, Br (r, z) of Coil B on Coil A is directed radially inward. If we apply the I ıθ ×−Br (r, z)ır product to the top winding cross section of Coil A in Fig. 3.41, the axial force on Coil A by Coil B is +z-directed, indicating the force, as expected, is attractive. g)
FzA (ρ) is the Lorentz interaction force, here given by: FzA (ρ) (average winding circumference)×(N I)× (Br at the winding cross section center) = π(1.8 m)(8900×65 A)(0.06 T) = 196 kN
h)
FzA (ρ) on Coil A due to Coil B is given by: ρ (aA + aB )2 + ρ2 μ◦ FzA (ρ) = (NA IA )(NB IB ) 2 (aA − aB )2 + ρ2 × k 2 K(k) + (k 2 − 2)[K(k) − E(k)]
(3.34)
where K(k) and E(k) are, respectively, the complete elliptic integrals of the first and second kinds. 4aA aB (3.36) k2 = (aA + aB )2 + ρ2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
181
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.13 (continuation) Here, we have: NA = NB = N = 8900; aA = aB = (a1 +a2 )/2 = 0.9 m; and ρ = 1 m. k2 =
4(0.9 m)(0.9 m) = 0.764151 (0.9 m + 0.9 m)2 + (1.0 m)2
⇒
k = 0.874157
We have: K(k) = 2.100000 and E(k) = 1.200000. Thus: FzA (1 m) = −
(4π×10−7 H/m) (8900×65 A)2 2
(1.0 m) (0.9 m+0.9 m)2 +(1.0 m)2 × (0.9 m−0.9 m)2 +(1.0 m)2 × (0.764151)2.10000+(0.764151−2)(2.10000−1.200000)
= (210.27×107 N)(2.059)(0.492) −213.2 kN i)
In the limit ρ2 (aA +aB )2 , Eq. 3.34 is simplified to: 2 3μ◦ πaA2 NA IA πaB NB IB FzA (ρ) = 2π ρ2 ρ2
(3.39c)
With ρ2 = 25.0 m2 and (aA +aB )2 = 3.24 m2 , the condition ρ2 (aA +aB )2 is satisfied. Because NA = NB = N = 8900, IA = IB = 65 A, aA = bB = 0.9 m, Eq. 3.39c becomes: 2 3(4π×10−7 H/m) π(0.9 m)2 (8900)(65 A) FzA (ρ) = = 2.08 kN 2π (5.0 m)2 A force of 2 kN (∼200 kg) is only about 13% the weight of each coil. j)
The total stored magnetic energy of the system, Em , is given by Eq. 3.92: Em = 21 L1 I12 + 21 L2 I22 + M12 I1 I2
(3.92)
With L1 = LA = L2 = LB ≡ L = 216.8 H, I1 = IA = I2 = IB ≡ I = 65 A, and from the table MAB 29.8 H, thus: Em = LI 2 + MAB I 2 = (L + MAB )I 2 = (246.6 H)(65 A)2 = 1.04 MJ k)
Equation 3.105b is given by: FzR (ρ) =
∂ MAB (ρ) ∂ EAB = IA IB ∂ρ ∂ρ
(3.105b)
From the table, MAB (ρ = 0.9 m) = 34.873 H and MAB (ρ = 1.1 m) = 25.650 H. Thus: ∂ MAB (ρ) (25.650 H − 34.873 H) = −46.115 H/m ∂ρ (1.1 m − 0.9 m)
(S17.1)
Inserting Eq. S17.1 into Eq. 3.105b with IA = IB = I = 65 A, we have: FzR (ρ) (65 A)2 (−46.115 H/m) = −194.8 kN Not surprisingly, this agrees quite well with the −193 kN computed by a code.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
182
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.14: Midplane axial force in a solenoid In this problem, we shall apply some of the expressions derived in Sec. 3.5 for a solenoid of 2a1 = 10 cm; 2a2 = 14 cm; 2b = 25 cm; N I = 1.5 × 106 A, shown in Fig. 3.43a. a) Although this solenoid (α = 1.4, β = 2.5) is really neither “thin-walled” nor “long,” use Eq. 3.111d to compute Bz (0, 0). b) Treating the solenoid as “thin-walled,” apply Eq. 3.41a to compute the axial midplane force, Fz (0), which by a code is −187.8 kN. Use 2a = 10 cm. c) Use Eq. 3.41b, valid for a “long” coil, to compute Fz (0). Choose: 1) 2a = 10 cm; 2) 2a = 12 cm, the solenoid average diameter. d) Now, divide the solenoid into two subsolenoids, A and B, as illustrated in Fig. 3.43b, each of an equal radial build of 1 cm, with 2aA = 10 cm, 2aB = 12 cm, and N I = 0.75×106 A. Compute Bz (0, 0). e) Apply Eq. 3.54 and compare with FzT (0) = −187.8 kN, computed by a code. f ) Apply Eq. 3.55, valid for a “long” coil, and compute FzT (0). = 0 over the surfaces of one half of a “thin-wall” g) Applying the condition ∇·B and “long” coil (2a, 2b) having a uniform surface current density N I/2b, derive Eq. 3.41b. Note that the surfaces to be considered are the coil’s x-yplane cross-sectional areas at z = 0 (midplane) and z = b, each πa2 , and the cylindrical surface area at r = a from z = 0 to z = b, i.e., 2πab. h) For a long (β 1) coil, explain why its axial force over most of its length, from the midplane to near its end, is constant and given by that corresponding to the midplane value. Try estimating the z location over one half of this long solenoid at which Bz begins to plummet from Bz (0, 0). Table 3.7 on the next page gives values of appropriate complete elliptic integrals. 14 10
25
12 10
25
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.43 (a) Solenoid with 2a1 = 10 cm; 2a2 = 14 cm; 2b = 25 cm. (b) Solenoid subdivided into subsolenoids A and B, with 2aA = 10 cm; 2aB = 12 cm; 2b = 25 cm.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
183
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.14 Table 3.7: Values of Appropriate Complete Elliptic Integrals for b) and e)
a)
k2
K(k)
E(k)
k2
K(k)
E(k)
0.137931 0.160858 0.187256
1.62961 1.64041 1.65325
1.51514 1.50558 1.49445
0.390244 0.432822 0.479600
1.77081 1.80099 1.83717
1.40400 1.38373 1.36084
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
0.991736
0.401071
18.7227
0.991736
0.657892
22.3701
Applying Eq. 3.111d we have: Bz (0, 0) = =
μ◦ N I 2b
(3.111d)
(4π×10−7 H/m)(1.5×106 A) = 7.5 T (0.25 m)
Equation 3.109 for this solenoid of α = 1.4 and β = 2.5, gives Bz (0, 0) = 6.8 T. Equation 3.111d thus errs by ∼10%, not too bad considering its simplicity. b) Equation 3.41a is given here once more. 2 μ◦ N I 2 2 Fz (0) = − 2b 4a +b K(kb )−E(kb ) 2 2b − 2b 4a2 +4b2 K(k2b )−E(k2b ) with moduli given by: kb2 = 2 k2b =
4a2 4(5 cm)2 = 0.390244 4a2 + b2 4(5 cm)2 + (12.5 cm)2 4a2 4(5 cm)2 = 0.137931 4a2 + (2b)2 4(5 cm)2 + (25 cm)2
With values of appropriate K(k) and E(k) given in Table 3.7: 2 (4π×10−7 H/m) 1.5×106 A × Fz (0) = − 2 0.25 m (0.25 m) 4(0.05 m)2 +(0.125 m)2 (1.77081−1.40400) − (0.25 m) 4(0.05 m)2 +4(0.125 m)2 (1.62961−1.51514) = −(2.262×107 N/m2 )(14.680×10−3 m2 − 7.705×10−3 m2 ) −157.8 kN Fz (0) −157.8 kN is 84% of −187.8 kN computed by a code.
(3.41a)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
184
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.14 (continuation) c)
Equation 3.41b is given by:
2 μ◦ N I Fz (0) − πa2 (3.41b) 2 2b Applying Eq. 3.41b with a = 5 cm and a = 6 cm, we obtain: 2 (4π×10−7 H/m) 1.5×106 A 1) Fz (0) − π(5×10−2 m)2 = −177.7 kN 2 0.25 m (4π×10−7 H/m) 2) Fz (0) − 2
2 1.5×106 A π(6×10−2 m)2 = −255.8 kN 0.25 m
Equation 3.41b underestimates the code value by ∼5% with a = 5 cm, while it overestimates the code value by 36% with a = 6 cm. These results appear to suggest that it is better to equate 2a with the solenoid i.d. However, this may not be valid for other values of α. d) Apply Eq. 3.111d to each subsolenoid; we find that Bz (0, 0) remains the same. Bz (0, 0) = BzA (0, 0) + BzB (0, 0) (0.75×106 A) (0.75×106 A) + = (4π×10−7 H/m) = 7.5 T (0.25 m) (0.25 m) e) Equation 3.54 is given below once again: 2 μ◦ N I FzT (0) = − × 2 4b 2b 4aA2 +b2 K(kbA )−E(kbA ) −2b 4aA2 +4b2 K(k2bA )−E(k2bA ) + 2b 4aB2 +b2 K(kbB )−E(kbB ) −2b 4aB2 +4b2 K(k2bB )−E(k2bB ) 4b − (aT2 +b2 ) K(kb )−E(kb ) −Υ(c2, kb ) aT2 +b2 4b 2 2 2 + (3.54) (aT +4b ) K(k2b )−E(k2b ) −Υ(c , k2b ) aT2 +4b2 with c2 and the other moduli given by: 4aA aB 4(5 cm)(6 cm) = c2 = 0.991736 2 (aA + aB ) (5 cm + 6 cm)2 kb2A = 2 k2b = A
kb2B =
4aA2 4(5 cm)2 = 0.390244 4aA2 + b2 4(5 cm)2 + (12.5 cm)2 4aA2 4(5 cm)2 = 0.137931 4aA2 + (2b)2 4(5 cm)2 + (25 cm)2 4aB2 4(6 cm)2 = 0.479600 2 4(6 cm)2 + (12.5 cm)2 B + b
4a2
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
185
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.14 (continuation) 2 k2b = B
4a2 B
kb2 = 2 = k2b
4aB2 4(6 cm)2 = 0.187256 2 + (2b) 4(6 cm)2 + (25 cm)2
4aA aB 0.432822 =⇒ kb 0.657892 (aA + aB )2 + b2 4aA aB 0.160858 =⇒ k2b 0.401071 (aA + aB )2 + 4b2
Inserting these and other appropriate values into Eq. 3.54, we obtain: 2 (4π×10−7 H/m) 1.5×106 A Fz (0) = − × 2 0.5 m (0.25 m) 4(0.05 m)2 +(0.125 m)2 (1.77081−1.40400) − (0.25 m) 4(0.05 m)2 +4(0.125 m)2 (1.62961−1.51514) + (0.25 m) 4(0.06 m)2 +(0.125 m)2 (1.83717−1.36084) − (0.25 m) 4(0.06 m)2 +4(0.125 m)2 (1.65325−1.49445) 4(0.125 m) + [(0.11 m)2 +(0.125 m)2 ](1.80099−1.38373) (0.11 m)2 +(0.125 m)2 − (0.05 m−0.06 m)2 (22.3701−1.8010) 4(0.125 m) − [(0.11 m)2 +4(0.125 m)2 ](1.64041−1.50558) 2 2 (0.11 m) +4(0.125 m) − [(0.05 m−0.06 m)2 (18.7227−1.6404) = −(5.655×107 N/m2 )× 14.680×10−3 m2 −7.705×10−3 m2 +20.634×10−3 m2 −11.009×10−3 m2 +34.739×10−3 m2 −6.177×10−3 m2 −18.413×10−3 m2 +3.127×10−3 m2
−(5.655×107 N/m2 )×(29.875×10−3 m2 ) −168.9 kN The computation still underestimates the code value (−187.8 kN), but now it is 90%. Although Eq. 3.54 gives a value more accurate than Eq. 3.41a, as seen here, it is extremely tedious and thus not recommended as a means to make a quick estimate of the force. Clearly, dividing a solenoid into two subsolenoids and applying Eq. 3.54 is the limit of manual computation with a pocket calculator. Note that the remarkable result of Eq. 3.41b with a = 5 cm seen above is most likely coincidental rather than a general rule.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
186
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.14 (continuation) f)
Applying Eq. 3.55 with aA = 5 cm and aB = 6 cm, we obtain: 2 1.5×106 A −7 Fz (0) −(4π×10 H/m) π[(0.05 m)2 + (0.06 m)2 ] 0.5 m
(0.05 m−0.06 m)2 (2×22.3701 − 18.7227) × 1− π[(0.05m)2 + (0.06 m)2 ] −(216.7 kN)(1 − 0.136) = −187.3 kN
Equation 3.55, which is much simpler to compute than Eq. 3.54, also turns out to give, at least in this particular example, a better result than Eq. 3.54. g) The differential force acting on one complete turn at z ≥ 0 carrying a differential current of dI is given by: dFz (z ≥ 0) = −2πaBr (z) dI The negative sign indicates this force is directed towards the midplane. Substituting dI = (N I/2b) dz and integrating over the entire half length of the solenoid, from z = 0 to z = b, we have: b NI NI b 2πaBr (z) Fz (0) = − dz = − 2πaBr (z) dz (S14.1) 2b 2b 0 0 b The integral 0 2πaBr (z)dz is the total radial flux leaving this half of the solenoid. = 0 this is equal to the difference between the total axial flux entering From ∇· B into this half of the solenoid over the circular plane at the midplane (z = 0) and that leaving the solenoid over the circular plane at z = b. Namely, b 2πaBr (z) dz = πa2 [Bz (0) − Bz (b)] (S14.2) 0
Note that it is assumed that for a “long” coil (k 2 1 or β 1), for which Eq. 3.41b is valid, Bz (0, 0) and Bz (0, b) may be assumed constant over the circular plane of area πa2 . For this long solenoid, it is also true that Bz (0, b) 0.5Bz (0, 0) (see DISCUSSION 3.4 ), thus Eq. S14.2 may be given by: b πa2 2πaBr (z) dz (S14.3) Bz (0) 2 0 For a long coil, Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ N I/2b (Eq. 3.111), thus: b πa2 μ◦ N I 2πaBr (z) dz × 2 2b 0
(S14.4)
Combining Eqs. S14.1 and S14.4, we have: N I πa2 μ◦ N I μ◦ × × − Fz (0) − 2b 2 2b 2
NI 2b
2 πa2
(3.41b)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
187
Solution to PROBLEM 3.14 (continuation) h) For a “long” solenoid, Bz (z) is constant with z, and from the requirement of = 0 the radial component Br (z) is virtually zero. Because Fz (z) is generated ∇· B by Br (z) (Eq. S14.1), dFz (z) = 0 over most of the coil length. Fz (z) thus remains constant until z approaches z = b, at which point flux lines begin to diverge away from the magnet axis, giving rise to Br (z), which generates Fz (z). For 4b2 4a2 and (b+z)2 4a2 , it can be shown that the 2nd and 3rd lines within the braces in Eq. 3.40 cancel out, leaving only the first term for Fz (z b), given by: μ◦ Fz (z b) − 2
NI 2b
2
(b−z) 4a2 +(b−z)2 K(kb− )−E(kb− )
(S14.5)
2 = 4a2 /[4a2 + (b − z)2 ] / 1 and thus K(kb− ) − E(kb− ) Because z is close to b, kb− 2 . Let us simply guess the location of z near b at cannot be approximated in kb− which point Fz (z ∼ b) is close to that given by Eq. 3.41b. If we guess z = b−2a, then:
μ◦ Fz (z = b−2a) − 2
NI 2b
2 2a 4a2 +4a2 K(kb− )−E(kb− )
(S14.6)
2 = 4a2 /8a2 = 0.5, which gives, from Table 3.1, K(kb− = 0.7071) = 1.8541 where kb− and E(kb− ) = 1.3506. Inserting these values into Eq. S14.6, we obtain:
μ◦ Fz (z = b−2a) − 2 =−
μ◦ 2
NI 2b NI 2b
2
√ 4a2 2(0.5035)
2 2.85a2
(S14.7)
Because 2.85 is ∼ 90% of π, Fz (z) indeed approaches the midplane force at a distance within ∼ 2a from each end of a long solenoid. This constant Fz (z) over most of the axial length of a long solenoid also implies that Bz (z) remains nearly Bz (0, 0) over the same axial length, ∼ (2b−4a), of the solenoid.
Help from Van (Part 3 of 5 Parts) —Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist It was too late for us to do any more about it that night, but we had made some progress although we had not reached the maximum power input into that magnet by a big factor. Then came a period of taking the magnet apart, finding out what had gone wrong, putting it together, trying again. Finally it became clear that there was nothing fundamentally wrong with the design, but that many little details hard to foresee had to be looked after. The usual expression for this sort of thing is getting the ‘bugs’ out of the apparatus. When we got the bugs out, the magnet behaved just as had been calculated. It was a success.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
188
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.15: Midplane axial forces in a nested 2-coil magnet In this problem we compute the axial compressive forces of Solenoids A and B that comprise a nested 2-coil magnet, as shown in Fig. 3.44; the axial fields of both solenoids point in the z-direction. The coil parameters are as follows: 2aA = 10 cm; 2bA = 50 cm; NA IA = 3 × 106 A; 2aB = 14 cm; 2bB = 100 cm; NB IB = 8 × 106 A. Each solenoid has a radial winding build of 1 cm. a) Treating each solenoid “thin-walled” (α = 1) and “long” (β 1), compute the center field generated by each solenoid, BzA (0, 0) and BzB (0, 0). Show that the center field of this nested magnet is ∼17.5 T (exact value: 17.31 T). b) Using Eq. 3.57b, compute FzA (0), the total midplane axial force on Solenoid A. A code gives FzA (0) = −200.9 kN. c) Using Eq. 3.57a, recompute FzA (0). The computed value should be closer to −200.9 kN than that computed in b) with Eq. 3.57b. d) Using Eq. 3.59a compute FzB (0), the total midplane axial force on Solenoid B. A code gives FzB = −1207.5 kN. e) Explain why the maximum total field within the winding of Solenoid A, BTA = Bz2A + Br2A , is likely to be at r = aA (winding’s innermost radius) and z = 0. f ) Explain why the maximum total field within the winding of Solenoid B, BTB = Bz2B + Br2B , likely will not be at or even near z = 0. Where will it likely be? Table 3.8 on next page gives values of Π(c2, k)
2bB SOLENOID B SOLENOID A 2bA z
2aA
2aB
Fig. 3.44 Drawing of a nested 2-coil magnet comprised of two “thin-walled” (α = 1) solenoids. Solenoid A (inner) 2aA = 10 cm; 2bA = 50 cm. Solenoid B (outer) 2aB = 14 cm; 2bB = 100 cm.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
189
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.15 Table 3.8: Values of Π(c2 = 0.992222, k) for c) and d)
a)
k
Π(c2, k)
k
Π(c2, k)
k
Π(c2, k)
0.155782
9.5245
0.230109
9.6468
0.426679
10.2692
From Bz (0, 0) = μ◦ Hz (0, 0) and Eq. 3.111d, we have: BzA (0, 0) = (4π×10−7 H/m)
(3×106 A) 7.5 T (0.5 m)
BzB (0, 0) = (4π×10−7 H/m)
(8×106 A) 10.0 T (1.0 m)
Bz (0, 0) = BzA (0, 0) + BzB (0, 0) 17.5 T As noted in the question statement, the exact central field value is 17.32 T. b) Equation 3.57b is given below: μ◦ FzA (0) FzAA (0) − 2
2 NA IA πaA2 2bA
(3.57b)
Inserting appropriate values into Eq. 3.57b, we have: 2 (4π×10−7 H/m) 3×106 A Fz A − π(0.05 m)2 −177.7 kN 2 0.5 m Thus Eq. 3.57b gives a value that is 88% of that computed by a code; some of the discrepancy is because Eq. 3.57b does not include the FzAB (0) contribution. c) Equation 3.57a is given below: 2 NA IA NB IB μ◦ NA IA 2 FzA (0) − πaA + × 2 2bA 2bB 2bA
(aA −aB ) Π(c2, kD )+Π(c2, kT )−2Π(c2, kB ) 2
where c2 =
4aA aB 4(5 cm)(7 cm) = = 0.972222 2 (aA + aB ) (5 cm+7 cm)2
kB2 =
4aA aB 4(5 cm)(7 cm) = = 0.052950 =⇒ kB 0.230109 aT2 + bB2 (12 cm)2 +(50 cm)2
kD2 =
4aA aB 4(5 cm)(7 cm) = = 0.182055 =⇒ kD 0.426679 aT2 + bD2 (12 cm)2 +(25 cm)2
kT2 =
4aA aB 4(5 cm)(7 cm) = = 0.024268 =⇒ kT 0.155781 2 2 aT + bT (12 cm)2 +(75 cm)2
(3.57a)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
190
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.15 (continuation) Inserting appropriate values into Eq. 3.57a, we have: 2 (4π×10−7 H/m) 8×106 A 3×106 A 3×106 A 2 Fz A − π(0.05 m) + 2 0.5 m 1.0 m 0.5 m
×(0.05 m−0.07 m)2 (10.2692+9.5245−2×9.6468) − (177.7 kN + 6.0 kN) −183.7 kN This is 91% of −200.9 kN; as expected, an improvement from b), though not enough to justify the increased complexity. d) Equation 3.59a is given by: 2 NB IB μ◦ NB IB NA IA 2 FzA (0) − πaB + π(aA2 +aB2 ) 2 2bB 2bB 2bA
− (aA −aB ) 2Π(c , kA )+Π(c , kD )−Π(c , kT ) 2
2
2
2
(3.59a)
where c2 , kD2 , and kT2 are given above; for this case, because bA = bD , kA2 = kD2 . Thus: 2 8×106 A (4π×10−7 H/m) Fz B − π(0.07 m)2 2 1.0 m 8×106 A 3×106 A + π[(0.05 m)2 +(0.07 m)2 ] 1.0 m 0.5 m
− (0.05 m−0.07 m)2 (2×10.2692+10.2692−9.5245) − (619.0 kN + 444.4 kN) −1063.4 kN This is 88% of the code value. e) Because (2bB )2 (2bA )2 , within the bore of Solenoid A the fields generated by Solenoid B and Solenoid A are both uniform and point only axially. Thus the maximum field within Solenoid A, close to 17.5 T, occurs at its innermost radius at z = 0. According to the same code, a maximum field of 17.32 T occurs at (r = 5 cm, z = 0). f ) Again because (2bB )2 (2bA )2 , the radial field component of Solenoid A impinges on Solenoid B away from its center point where the axial field of Solenoid B is still essentially the same as that at its midplane. Therefore, it is quite likely that the field maximum in Solenoid B can exceed 10.0 T, the midplane field of Solenoid B (9.94 T by code), and occur at an axial distance ∼ ±bA from the center. The code shows that the maximum field in Solenoid B is 9.96 T (Br = ±1.70 T; Bz = 9.81 T) and it occurs at (r = 7 cm, z = ±25 cm). Note that bA = 25 cm.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
191
PROBLEM 3.16: Stresses in an epoxy-impregnated solenoid* This problem deals with simple but approximate stress computations applicable for epoxy-impregnated magnets. We will use a 500-MHz (12 T) NMR superconducting magnet built in the late 1970s at FBNML as an example [3.57]. The magnet consists of a high-field insert, a main coil, and several correction and shim coils. The main coil’s winding inner radius (a1 ) is 72.6 mm, the winding outer radius (a2 ) is 102 mm, and the winding length (2b) is 488 mm. The main coil is wound with a Nb-Ti multifilamentary conductor; the volumetric ratio of copper to Nb-Ti is 2.1. The composite wire has diameters of 0.63 mm bare (Dcd ) and 0.71 mm insulated (Dov ). The winding has a close-packed hexagonal configuration. The space between the wires is filled with epoxy resin. Figure 3.45 shows three neighboring wires in a close-packed hexagonal winding configuration. When all the coils are energized, the axial (z) component of the magnetic induction, Bz , decreases linearly with radial distance (r) through the build of the main coil. At the midplane (z = 0) of the main coil, Bz varies from 8.22 T at r = a1 to −0.21 T at r = a2 . This linear decrease of Bz is quite accurate at z = 0. The overall operating current density (λJ) in the main coil is 248 MA/m2 . The analytic solution for an anisotropic cylinder loaded with body forces was used to calculate the stresses at the midplane of the main coil. The hoop stresses at the inner and outer radii were found to be, respectively, 105 MPa and 65 MPa; the hoop stress decreases roughly linearly from the inner radius to the outer radius. a) Using simple force equilibrium considerations, show that these stress values are consistent with the loading situation. b) Assuming the winding pattern is a close-packed (wires touching) hexagonal configuration, compute the area fraction for each of the three constituents, Nb-Ti, copper, and organic materials (epoxy plus insulation). c) Based on these area fractions and approximate Young’s moduli for these materials at 4.2 K (Esc = 85 GPa; Ecu = 100 GPa; Ein = 30 GPa), find the hoop stresses in the Nb-Ti and copper at the innermost layer of the winding. Dov
Dcd
Fig. 3.45
Three neighboring conductors in a close-packed hexagonal winding.
* Problem 3.17 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
192
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.16 a)
The average hoop stress in the winding is given by: σi + σo 105 MPa + 65 MPa σ ˜= = (S16.1) 2 2 = 85 MPa ˜ = (a1 + a2 )/2 is 87.3 mm; the mean magnetic inducThe mean winding radius, R ˜z = (Bi + Bo )/2, is 4.0 T. The mean hoop stress in the winding may thus tion, B be given by: ˜ ˜z = (87.3×10−3 m)(248×106 A/m2 )(4.0 T) (S16.2) σ ˜ = R(λJ) B = 86.6 MPa which is nearly identical to σ ˜ , the mean of σi and σo , computed above (Eq. S16.1). b) See Fig. 3.45 for the close-packed hexagonal configuration. The triangular area, Atr , defined by the √ dotted lines is given in terms of the overall conductor 2 diameter, Dov , by: Atr = 3Dov /4. The conductor area, Acd , within the triangle 2 is given by: Acd = πDcd /8, of which 2.1/3.1 is copper area, Acu , and 1/3.1 is Nb-Ti area, Asc . The epoxy and insulation area, Ain , within the triangle is given by: Ain = Atr − Acd . Thus: 2 2.1 πDcd 3.1 Acu (2.1)(π)(4)(0.63 mm)2 √ fcu = = √ 8 = = 0.484 (S16.3a) 2 3 2 Atr (3.1)( 3)(8)(0.71 mm) D ov 4 fsc =
Asc = Atr
fin =
Ain Acu + Asc =1− = 1 − 0.484 − 0.230 = 0.286 Atr Atr
1 Acu 2.1 Atr
= 0.230
(S16.3b) (S16.3c)
˜ may be given from the parallel c) The Young’s modulus for the composite, E, mixture rule: ˜ = fcu Ecu + fsc Esc + fin Ein (S16.4) E = (0.48)(100 GPa) + (0.23)(85 GPa) + (0.29)(30 GPa) 76 GPa We may calculate the stress of each component at the innermost winding radius: Ecu 100 GPa σcu = σi = (105 MPa) 137 MPa (S16.5a) ˜ 76 GPa E σsc = σi
Esc 85 GPa = (105 MPa) 117 MPa ˜ 76 GPa E
(S16.5b)
σin = σi
Esc 30 GPa = (105 MPa) 41 MPa ˜ 76 GPa E
(S16.5b)
These values ignore residual stresses, which in fact may be very large.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
193
PROBLEM 3.17: Stresses and axial force in an HTS magnet We present here a stress analysis performed on an 1.75-T (75 MHz) HTS “insert” solenoid, a stack of 48 double-pancake (DP) coils [3.58], each DP coil wound with high-strength HTS tape. The HTS insert, operated at 86.7 A, is combined with a 14.1-T (600 MHz) all-LTS background NMR magnet to form a 675 MHz LTS/HTS NMR magnet—later the insert was operated at 115.95 A to achieve a combined field of 16.26 T (692.2 MHz) [3.59]. Table 3.9 gives key parameters of the insert and the HTS tape, a composite of Bi2223/Ag and two stainless steel strips. The mixture rules used are based on the mechanical properties of silver and stainless steel. The axial field values, Bz and Br , in the table are for the DP coils, flanking the midplane (z = 0), that experience the largest stresses and hoop strains. Stress & Strain Equations The stresses, radial, σr (r, z); hoop, σθ (r, z); axial, σz (r, z); and shear, τrz (r, z) in the winding of a solenoid are found from the equilibrium equations of Eq. 3.62: ∂ σr σ r − σθ ∂ τrz + + = −λ JBz (r, z) ∂r r ∂z
(3.62a)
∂ τrz τrz ∂ σz − + = −λ JBr (r, z) ∂r r ∂z
(3.62b)
with boundary conditions: σr (r = a1 , z) = 0; σr (a2 , z) = 0; σz (r, z = ± b) = 0; τrz (r, ± b) = 0; τrz (a2 , ± b) = 0. The HTS composite may be considered orthotropic, and Hooke’s law, with no thermal strains included, is given by: r =
1 νrh νrz σr − σθ − σz Er Eh Ez
νhr 1 νhz σr + σθ − σz Er Eh Ez νzr νzh 1 z = − σr − σθ + σz Er Eh Ez θ = −
(3.171a) (3.171b) (3.171c)
where νξη is the Poisson’s ratio that gives ξ due to ση , where ξ and η can be, respectively, θ- (hoop-), r-, or z-direction. Table 3.9: Parameters of 48-Double-Pancake-Coil Solenoid [3.32, 58] Winding i.d.(2a1 ); o.d.(2a2 ); length (2b) [mm] 78.2; 126.6; 406.6 Interturn insulation thickness/pancake-pancake space [mm] 0.038/0.178 Total number of turns 6816 Operating current (Iop ); λJop [A; A/mm2 ] 86.7; 66.31 Bz (r = a1 ); Bz (r = a2 ) @86.7 A [T] 15.86; 13.97 Tape overall width; thickness [mm] 4.10; 0.30 Thickness: Stainless steel (ss) strips; solder lamination [μm] 40 (×2); 10 (×2) Volumetric ratio (without ss strips): Ag/non-Ag [mm] 1.5 Equivalent Young’s Moduli (mixture rule): Er ; Eθ ; Ez [GPa] 62.8; 81.3; 70.6 Equivalent Poisson’s Ratios (mixture rule): νrh ; νhr ; νzr 0.31; 0.29; 0.26
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
194
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.17: Stresses & axial force in an HTS magnet (continuation) Table 3.10: Stresses (σ) & Strains () in HTS Insert Midplane Pancake Coil [3.32] (Operating at 86.7 A in a Background Field of 14.1 T) r [mm]
σr
39.10 51.19 63.29
0 2.6 0
Average Silver Steel Silver Silver σ ¯θ [MPa] σθ [MPa] σθ [MPa] σz [MPa] σT∗ [MPa] 62.3 44.9 33.6
54.3 39.2 29.3
152.9 110.3 82.4
−2.1 −2.1 −2.1
56.4 41.3 31.4
Tape θ [%] 0.030 0.028 0.026
* Tresca stress: σT = σθ −σz .
Table 3.10 gives values of stresses and hoop strains at three radial locations, innermost, midpoint, and outermost, in one of the midplane pancakes [3.32]. The midplane axial force is −16 kN. Note that the highest stresses occur at the innermost (a1 = 39.10 mm) winding. The maximum combined stress, Tresca stress, σT (= σθ − σz ), in silver is 56.4 MPa, which is less than the allowable stress, σallow = 2σ/3 (0.2%): for silver at 77 K, σallow 120 MPa. Stresses and strains may be computed by solving Eqs. 3.62 and 3.171. However, some of the equations derived in 3.5 may be applied to estimate the midplane axial force. As noted above, the HTS magnet at its midplane will have a computed axial force of −16.2 kN (i.e., compressive), which as discussed in 3.5, arises from the self field of the HTS magnet and from the interaction of the HTS and the LTS magnet. Here, we compute approximate values of the midplane force in the HTS magnet by its own field alone. The above analysis gives a value of −8.6 kN [3.32]. a) Treating the HTS magnet as “thin-walled,” apply Eq. 3.41a to compute Fz (0). Choose a = 39.1 mm, b = 203.3 mm, and N I = 5.91×106 A. b) Apply Eq. 3.41b to compute Fz (0) with 1) a = 39.1 mm, the “a1 ” of the HTS magnet and 2) a = 51.2 mm, which is the average winding radius. c) Now treat the HTS magnet as two “thin-walled” and “long” subsolenoids, A and B, of the same winding thickness, and apply Eq. 3.55 to compute FzT (0). Choose aA = 39.1 mm and aB = 51.2 mm. d) The 14.1-T LTS magnet that surrounds this HTS insert consists of nested coils. Model the LTS magnet as a thin-walled solenoid of aB = 191.3 mm; bB = 337.5 mm; NB IB = 7.535 MA; the HTS insert as a thin-walled solenoid of aA = 51.2 mm; bA = 203.3 mm; NA IA = 0.591 MA. By applying Eq. 3.57a, compute the total midplane axial force for the HTS insert magnet: FzA (0), which is −16.2 kN. Explain why Eq. 3.57a does not give the correct value. e) Using the same models for both magnets and applying Eq. 3.60, compute an axial restoring force on the HTS insert when it is off-center by 5 mm (ρ = 5 mm in Eq. 3.60). A code gives a value of −2.1 kN. In the following pages, appropriate elliptic integral values are given, Tables 3.11 through 3.14.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
195
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.17 Table 3.11: Values of K(k) and E(k) for a)
a)
k2
K(k)
E(k)
0.128888 0.035670
1.625445 1.585092
1.518888 1.556694
We have Eq. 3.41a: μ◦ Fz (0) = − 2
NI 2b
2 2b 4a2 + b2 K(kb ) − E(kb ) − 2b 4a2 + 4b2 K(k2b ) − E(k2b )
(3.41a)
where kb and k2b are the moduli determined by a and b. For this case, in which a = 39.1 mm and b = 203.3 mm, we have: kb2 = 2 = k2b
4a2 4(39.1 mm)2 = = 0.128888 4a2 + b2 4(39.1 mm)2 + (203.3 mm)2 4a2 4(39.1 mm)2 = = 0.035670 4a2 + (2b)2 4(39.1 cm)2 + (406.6 mm)2
Appropriate complete elliptic integral values are given in Table 3.11. By applying Eq. 3.38c up to the k 6 term, we may compute K(k)−E(k) for k 2 1. Thus: π 15 (0.128888)+ 83 (0.128888)2 + 64 (0.128888)3 4 = 0.106515
K(k2b )−E(k2b )
which is essentially identical (0.04% error) to the K(k)−E(k) = 0.106557, computed from values of K(k) and E(k) given in Table 3.11. With N I = 0.591×106 A, and other values inserted in Eq. 3.41a, we have:
2 (0.591×106 A) × Fz (0) = −(2π×10 H/m) (0.4066 m) [(0.4066 m) 4(0.0391 m)2 +(0.2033 m)2 (1.625445−1.518888) −7
−(0.4066 m) 4(0.0391 m)2 + 4(0.2033 m)2 (1.585092−1.556694) = −(2π×10−7 H/m)(2.11×1012 A2 /m2 )(9.44×10−3 m2 − 4.78×10−3 m2 ) = −6.2 kN This computation underestimates the code value by 28%.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
196
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.17 (continuation) Table 3.12: Values of Π(c2, k) for c)
b)
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
0.982045 0.982045
0.402269 0.214848
12.66889 11.96934
Equation 3.41b is given by: 2 μ◦ N I Fz (0) − πa2 2 2b −
(3.41b)
2 (4π×10−7 H/m) (5.91×105 A) π(0.0391 m)2 2 0.4066 m
= −6.4 kN This is 74% of the code value. The average radius of 51.2 mm instead of 39.1 mm results in a force of 10.9 kN, 27% greater than the code value. c) If the magnet is modeled by two “thin-walled” and “long” solenoids, Eq. 3.55 applies: 2
NI (aA −aB )2 2 2 2 2 FzT (0) −μ◦ π(aA +aB ) 1 − [2Π(c , kb )−Π(c , k2b )] (3.55) 4b π(aA2 +aB2 ) The moduli, kb , k2b , and c2, with aT = aA + aB , aA = 39.1 mm, aB = 51.2 mm, b = 203.3 mm, aT = 90.3 mm, are given by: c2 =
4aA aB 4(39.1 mm)(51.2 mm) = = 0.982045 2 aT (90.3 mm)2
kb2 =
4aA aB 4(39.1 mm)(51.2) mm = = 0.161820 ⇒ kb = 0.402269 aT2 +b2 (90.3 mm)2 +(203.3 mm)2
2 k2b =
4aA aB 4(39.1 mm)(51.2) mm = = 0.046160 ⇒ k2b = 0.214848 aT2 +4b2 (90.3 mm)2 +4(203.3 mm)2
Thus: Fz (0) = −(4π×10
× 1−
−7
(0.591×106 A) H/m) (0.8132 m)
2 π[(0.0391 m)2 + (0.0512 m)2 ]
(0.0391 m − 0.0512 m)2 [2(12.66889) − 11.96934] π[(0.0391 m)2 + (0.0512 m)2 ]
= −(4π×10−7 H/m)(5.28×1011 A2 /m2 )(1.304×10−2 m2 )(1 − 0.150) = −7.4 kN This underestimates the code by 15%.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
197
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.17 (continuation) Table 3.13: Values of Π(c2, k) for d)
d)
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
0.666226 0.666226 0.666226
0.333965 0.476278 0.714162
2.822156 2.046996 3.382637
Equation 3.57a is given below: 2 μ◦ NB IB NA IA NA IA 2 FzA (0) − πaA + × 2 2bA 2bB 2bA
(aA −aB ) Π(c , kD )+Π(c , kT )−2Π(c , kB ) 2
2
2
2
(3.57a)
Parameter values other than those given in question d) are: aT = aA+aB = 242.5 mm; bT = bA +bB = 540.8 mm; bD = bA −bB = −134.2 mm; and c2 =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3 mm) = = 0.666226 2 aT (242.5 mm)2
kD2 =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.510028 ⇒ kD = 0.714162 2 2 aT +bD (242.5 mm)2 +(−134.2 mm)2
kT2 =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.111533 ⇒ kT = 0.333965 aT2 +bT2 (242.5 mm)2 +(540.8 mm)2
kB2 =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.226841 ⇒ kB = 0.476278 2 2 aT +bB (242.5 mm)2 +(337.5 mm)2
Inserting appropriate values into Eq. 3.57a, we have: 2 5.91×105 A (4π×10−7 H/m) FzA (0) − π(0.0512 m)2 2 0.4066 m 7.535×106 A 5.91×105 A + 0.675 m 0.4066 m
×(0.0512 m−0.1913 m) (3.3826+2.8222−2×2.0470) 2
− (1.09 kN + 42.2 kN) −43.3 kN This is 2.7 times the code value of 16.2 kN. The major source of error comes from the approximation of Eq. 3.57a involving the interaction force, FzAB . In order for Eq. 3.57a to be valid, as remarked in its derivation, the conditions bA2 4aA2 , bB2 aT2 , bD2 aT2 , must be satisfied. In this particular case, we have: bA2 /4aT2 = 0.176; bB2 /aT2 = 1.94; and bD2 /aT2 = 0.306. That is, none of the conditions necessary for Eq. 3.57a to be valid is satisfied in this particular case.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
198
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.17 (continuation) Table 3.14: Values of K(k), E(k), and Π(c2, k) for e) k2
K(k)
E(k)
k2
K(k)
E(k)
0.109834 0.501110
1.616815 1.855016
1.526733 1.350085
0.113269 0.518925
1.618355 1.870449
1.525324 1.341054
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
c2
k
Π(c2, k)
0.666226 0.666226
0.331412 0.707891
2.820467 3.364664
0.666226 0.666226
0.336555 0.720364
2.823887 3.400959
e) Equation 3.60 is given below: μ◦ FzR (ρ) = − 2
NA IA 2bA
NB IB × 2bB
b −ρ T [aT2 +(bT −ρ)2 ] K(kT − )−E(kT − ) −Υ(c2, kT − ) aT2 +(bT −ρ)2 bD +ρ + [aT2 +(bD +ρ)2 ] K(kD + )−E(kD + ) −Υ(c2, kD + ) aT2 +(bD +ρ)2 bT +ρ − [aT2 +(bT +ρ)2 ] K(kT + )−E(kT + ) −Υ(c2, kT + ) aT2 +(bT +ρ)2 bD −ρ
− [aT2 +(bD −ρ)2 ] K(kD − ) − E(kD − ) −Υ(c2, kD − ) aT2 +(bD −ρ)2
(3.60) Parameter values other than those given in question e) are: aT = aA+aB = 242.5 mm; bT = bA +bB = 540.8 mm; bD = bA −bB = −134.2 mm; and c2 =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3 mm) = = 0.666226 2 aT (242.5 mm)2
kT2 + =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.109834 ⇒ kT + = 0.331412 aT2 +(bT +ρ)2 (242.5 mm)2 +(545.8 mm)2
kT2 − =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.113269 ⇒ kT − = 0.336554 aT2 +(bT −ρ)2 (242.5 mm)2 +(535.8 mm)2
kD2 + =
T
kD2 − =
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.518925 ⇒ kD + = 0.720364 2 (242.5 mm)2 +(−129.2 mm)2 D +ρ)
a2 +(b
4aA aB 4(51.2 mm)(191.3) mm = = 0.501110 ⇒ kD − = 0.707891 2 (242.5 mm)2 +(−139.2 mm)2 D −ρ)
a2 +(b T
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
199
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.17 (continuation) Table 3.15: Values of Terms in Eq. 3.60 for e) bT −ρ 2 aT +(bT −ρ)2
aT2 +(bT −ρ)2
(0.2425 m)2 +(0.5358 m)2
0.345888 m2
K(kT − )−E(kT − )
1.618355−1.525324
0.093031
(aA −aB )
2
(0.5358 m) (0.2425 m)2 +(0.5358 m)2
(0.0512 m−0.1913 m)
2
0.911035
0.019628 m2
(aA −aB )2 [Π(c2, kT − )−K(kT − )] (0.019628 m2 )(2.823887−1.618355) 0.023662 m2
bD +ρ aT +(bD +ρ)2 2
aT2 +(bD +ρ)2 K(kD + )−E(kD + )
(−0.1292 m) (0.2425 m)2 +(−0.1292 m)2
−0.470210
(0.2425 m)2 +(−0.1292 m)2
0.075499 m2
1.870449−1.341054
0.529395
(aA −aB ) [Π(c , kD + )−K(kD + )] (0.019628 m )(3.400959−1.870449) 0.030041 m2 2
2
bT +ρ aT +(bT +ρ)2 2
2
(0.5458 m) (0.2425 m)2 +(0.5458 m)2
0.913860
aT2 +(bT +ρ)2
(0.2425 m)2 +(0.5458 m)2
0.356704 m2
K(kT + )−E(kT + )
1.616815−1.526733
0.090082
(aA −aB )2 [Π(c2, kT + )−K(kT + )] (0.019628 m2 )(2.820467−1.616815) 0.023625 m2
bD −ρ aT +(bD −ρ)2 2
(−0.1392 m) (0.2425 m)2 +(−0.1392 m)2
−0.497833
aT2 +(bD −ρ)2
(0.2425 m)2 +(−0.1392 m)2
0.078183 m2
K(kD − )−E(kD − )
1.855016−1.350085
0.504931
(aA −aB )2 [Π(c2, kD − )−K(kD − )] (0.019628 m2 )(3.364664−1.855016) 0.029632 m2
Applying these values in Table 3.15 into Eq. 3.60, we compute: FzR (ρ) = −2.2 kN This overestimates the code value (2.1 N) by ∼4%; the − sign implies that the force is restoring. The “spring constant” between the magnets is ∼400 kN/m.
Formula for Radial Build of a Close-Packed Hexagonal Winding With a round-wire conductor, many solenoids are wound in a close-packed hexagonal configuration. Figure 3.45, with three neighboring round wires of overall diameter Dov , is a cross sectional view of such a winding. The radial build, a2 −a1 , of a solenoid (i.d. 2a1 and o.d. 2a2 ) with a close-packed hexagonal winding containing N layers is given by: √ 3 (3.172) a 2 − a1 = 1 + (N − 1) Dov 2 Note that when N = 1, as expected, a2 −a1 = Dov .
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
200
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.12: Magnetic Force on an Iron Sphere* For safety considerations, it is very important to keep ferromagnetic objects away from a large magnet. Using the 45-T hybrid as an example, we derive here magnetic force expressions for an iron sphere (Fig. 3.46) “far” from the hybrid. The fringing (far) field of a solenoid, as discussed in PROBLEM 3.11, is given by a dipole field: 3 Re Hf = H0 (cos θır + 21 sin θıθ ) (3.163) r When a magnetic object, such as an iron sphere, is in a spatially varying magnetic field, it will be subjected to a magnetic force density, fm , given by: (3.173) fm (r, θ) = ∇em where ∇ is the grad operator in spherical coordinates and em is the magnetic energy density stored in the iron due to its magnetization. For a ferromagnetic sp , is three times sphere with μ/μ◦ 1, the magnetic induction inside the sphere, B sp 3μ◦ H f (PROBLEM 2.1). f = 3B the “uniform” applied magnetic induction: B For a sphere of a diameter much smaller than the distance from the magnet center f may be assumed uniform over the sphere. Thus: to the sphere, B em =
f sp · B f |2 B 3|B = 2μ◦ 2μ◦
(3.174)
sa , its magnetic induction is When the iron is saturated with magnetization M f . sa (= μ◦ M sa ), which is constant and aligned with B approximately equal to B Its energy density ems is thus given by: ems
f sa · B B 2μ◦
(3.175)
In Eqs. 3.174 and 3.175, it is assumed that the impinging field is “uniform” for energy density computation, but nonuniform for force density computation. z fmr
y0.1g 45-T Hybrid Platform
fmy fmθ
1m
θ
r
IRON SPHERE
Iop “45-T HYBRID MAGNET”
2Re Fig. 3.46
Iron sphere on the 45-T hybrid platform.
* Based on Problem 3.13 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
201
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.12: Magnetic Force on an Iron Sphere (continuation) A. Force on Unsaturated Sphere To derive an expression of fm (r, θ) for an unsaturated iron sphere, we first compute f |2 from Eq. 3.163: |B 6 2 2 2 Re |Bf | = μ◦ H0 (cos2 θ + r
1 4
sin2 θ)
Combining the above expression with Eq. 3.174 and using the grad operator in spherical coordinates (Eq. 2.36a) on Eq. 3.173, we obtain: 6 3μ◦ H02 ∂ Re 2 2 1 fm (r, θ) = (cos θ + 4 sin θ) ır 2 ∂r r 6 1 Re ∂ 2 2 1 + cos θ + 4 sin θ ıθ r r ∂θ
=
7 3μ◦ H02 Re −6(cos2 θ+ 41 sin2 θ)ır − 2Re r
3 2
sin θ cos θıθ
which may be simplified to: 2
9μ◦ H0 fm (r, θ) = − 4Re
Re r
7 [(1 + 3 cos2 θ)ır + sin θ cos θıθ ]
(3.176a)
Note that fm (r, θ) varies as 1/r7 and, as expected for any ferromagnetic object, the r-component of fm (r, θ) is directed towards the magnet center. B. Force on Saturated Sphere The magnetic energy density of Eq. 3.175 is given by: ems = μ◦ Msa H0
Re r
3 cos2 θ +
1 4
sin2 θ
Performing a similar grad operation on em , we obtain: 3μ◦ Msa H0 fms (r, θ) = − 2Re ×
Re r
4
sin θ cos θ 1 + 3 cos θ ır + ıθ 1 + 3 cos2 θ 2
(3.176b)
The magnetic force thus varies as 1/r4 when the iron sphere is saturated. Note also that because it is −r-directed, as in the unsaturated case, the iron sphere is attracted to the magnet center.
202
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.12: Magnetic Force on an Iron Sphere (continuation) Illustration For the 45-T hybrid magnet (only the SCM field is considered), for which B0 = 14 T and Re = 0.67 m (see PROBLEM 3.11), we may compute y0.1g , the y-axis distance from the magnet center on the platform (z = 2.75 m) at which fmy , the y-component of the magnetic force density on an unsaturated iron sphere of density , is 0.1g (an acceleration of 0.1 that of gravity) fmy is given by: fmy = fmr sin θ + fmθ cos θ
(3.177)
where fmr and fmθ are, respectively, the r- and θ-components of the magnetic force. Combining Eqs. 3.176a and 3.177, we have: 7 9μ◦ H02 Re fmy = [−(1 + 3 cos2 θ) sin θ − sin θ cos2 θ] 4Re r 7 9μ◦ H02 Re =− (1 + 4 cos2 θ) sin θ (3.178) 4Re r The minus sign in Eq. 3.178 indicates fmy actually points in the direction opposite from that indicated in Fig. 3.46. r, sin θ, and cos θ for the case x = 0 are given by: y0.1g z 2 r = y0.1g + z2; sin θ = ; cos θ = 2 2 y0.1g + z2 y0.1g + z2 Combining the above expressions and Eq. 3.178, and with fmy = 0.1g we have: 3.5 9(μ◦ H0 )2 Re6 1 4z 2 y 0.1g 0.1g = 1+ 2 2 2 2 4μ◦ y0.1g + z y0.1g + z y2 + z2 0.1g
By inserting appropriate values in the above expression, with z = 2.75 m, we have:
3.5 9(14 T)2 (0.67 m)6 1 3 2 0.1(8000 kg/m )(9.81 m/s ) = 2 4(4π×10−7 H/m) y0.1g +(2.75 m)2
4(2.75 m)2 y0.1g × 1+ 2 2 y0.1g +(2.75 m) y 2 +(2.75 m)2 0.1g
Solving the above equation for y0.1g , we find: y0.1g 2.42 m. We may compute the total field on the sphere and see if the sphere is indeed unsaturated as assumed in the computation. With r0.1g = (2.42 m)2 +(2.75 m)2 3.66 m and θ = tan−1 (2.42 m/2.75 m) = 41.3◦ substituted into Eq. 3.163, we have: 3 0.67 m |μ◦ Hf | = (14.0 T) cos2 41.3◦ + 41 sin2 41.3◦ 3.66 m = (14.0 T)(6.1×10−3 )(0.82) = 0.070 T
= 3μ◦ H f = 0.21 T ) (M
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
203
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.13: Radial Force in Two-Coil Magnet Figure 3.47 shows an arrangement of a two-coil magnet, in which the axis of Coil 1 (inner) is displaced radially in the plane normal to the z-axis—+Δx in the xdirection in the figure—with respect to Coil 2 (outer). The axial field of each coil points upward (+z direction) and the midplane of each coil is at z = 0. When Coils 1 and 2 are concentric, i.e., Δx = 0 and Δy = 0, the Jθ ×Bz interaction force on a unit winding volume is r-directed and from symmetry it cancels out: the net radial force is zero. If Coil 1 is displaced, as shown in the figure, by +Δx, then Bz2 on one half (180◦ arc on the +x side of the x-y plane) of its winding volume is on average greater than Bz2 on the other half (180◦ arc mostly on the −x side of the x-y plane) of the winding volume. The resulting net unbalanced force, Fx1 , may be given approximately by: b a2 ∂ Bz2 (r, z) Fx1 4πΔx Jθ1 r dr dz (3.179) ∂r 0 a1 where Bz2 is the axial field generated by Coil 2. As indicated by Eq. 3.12b and also by Eqs. 3.117a–3.117c (PROBLEM 3.2 ), Bz2 increases with displacement in the xy plane, i.e., ∂ Bz2 /∂ r > 0. Thus, Fx1 is positive and increasing in the x-direction; Coil 1’s displacement gets even greater: the system is unstable. Another way of looking at this is to recognize that an energized coil is always attracted to the highest field region. Thus, if Coil 1 is displaced radially, it continues to move radially towards Coil 2 because, as noted above, Bz2 increases with displacement in the x-y plane; Bz2 is maximum at the innermost winding radius of Coil 2. The same argument may be used to explain why displacement in the zdirection, on the other hand, is stable: if Coil 1 is displaced axially by Δz, because the axial field of each coil is maximum at the midplane (z = 0), Coil 1 seeks to align its maximum field region with that of Coil 2, resulting in a stable condition for displacement in the z-direction. z2 Coil 2
Coil 1
z1
x
Δx Fig. 3.47
Two nested solenoidal coils, one displaced radially from the other.
Answer to TRIVIA 3.5 Eastward. The current must point westward to make a resultant magnetic force on the electron directed toward the earth center.
204
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.14: Mechanical Support in the 45-T Hybrid* The 45-T Hybrid was designed with potential for upgrade later to 50-T operation with higher power resistive inserts—35 MW vs. 24 MW. A key element in the design is the structure for transmitting fault forces between the insert and the SCM. Especially critical is the structural component that provides thermal standoff inside the cryostat. In the 45-T Hybrid, this component is a single cylindrical steel column, coaxial to the SCM, with heat intercepts at ∼80 K and ∼20 K. To compute an upper bound on the potential fault load on the support column during an insert failure, the analysis described below was carried out for a 50-T upgrade. 1. This analysis was performed by taking the dimensions of the 45-T resistive insert, with uniform current density in each sub-coil at the peak value, and adjusting the current level in each sub-coil to the 50 T field. The analysis gives an insert that has inherently higher magnetic energy and higher misalignment forces relative to the SCM than coils with 1/r current distribution. 2. Based on this configuration, a worst-case fault was postulated corresponding to a short suddenly appearing at the midplane of each sub-coil, resulting in doubling the current (constant voltage assumption) and an axial shift of each sub-coil’s magnetic center by a distance bi (the half-height of the ith coil). For the sub-coil geometries assumed, this hypothetical fault resulted in forces in Coils A, B, and C, respectively, of ∼1.7 MN, ∼1.8 MN, and ∼2.5 MN, i.e., a total of ∼6 MN on the SCM. The wall thickness of the support column was chosen so that the mean stress during a fault would not exceed 2/3 yield. The wall thicknesses of the 1.8–20 K, 20–80 K, and 80–300 K sections were graded to match the temperature-dependance of the yield stress of austenitic steel. The resultant conduction heat input is a small portion of the system’s total cryogenic load. The resultant support-column design has the added advantage of being very stiff against both axial and transverse loads. Consequently, relative deflection between insert and outsert for typical misalignment forces are quite minimal. * John Miller (NHMFL, 2004).
Help from Van (Part 4 of 5 Parts) —Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist The Edison Company was getting rather fed up with the time-consuming experiments. While they were willing enough to make it possible to test out a brand-new piece of equipment, they were not exactly eager to go on interrupting their own schedules and having their people work overtime on a project of no interest to them. So we called a halt to these tests, and Van set out to find some money for me to get a power station of my own at M.I.T. and to construct some new magnets using the experience gained in the preliminary tests. In due course the money was made available. The sum was perhaps a tenth of what was required ten or fifteen years later to duplicate the installation, but luckily in those days (the mid-1930’s) secondhand equipment could be had.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
205
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.15: Stresses in Composite Nb3 Sn Conductor* Here we shall discuss the stress state in a composite Nb3 Sn conductor, focusing on the stress relationships among bronze, copper, and Nb3 Sn—the three major constituents of the composite [3.60]. Because the critical current densities of superconductors (LTS and HTS), are degraded when strained, particularly in tension, the maximum strain level on the superconductor is a key magnet design specification. Effects of strain, particularly on Nb-Ti and Nb3 Sn composite superconductors, are quite well documented [3.61, 3.62]; data are now also available for HTS [3.63, 3.64]. When a Nb3 Sn composite is cooled to 4.2 K, each constituent experiences a temperature reduction of ∼1000 K, from the reaction temperature of ∼1000 K to the operating temperature of 4.2 K. Because each constituent has a different coefficient of thermal contraction, residual stress arises in each constituent. Figure 3.48 shows, schematically, strain states for three cases of interest: a) the composite at a reaction temperature ∼1000 K, b) at 4.2 K if the three constituents can contract individually, c) the composite at 4.2 K. Though exaggerated, the figure indicates the relative sizes of the individual thermal contractions of bronze, copper, and Nb3 Sn, given respectively by br0 , cu0 , s0 , after cooldown from ∼1000 K to 4.2 K. Correspondingly, their residual strains, brr , cur , sr , in the composite at 4.2 K are as shown in the figure. That is, both bronze and copper will be in tension, while Nb3 Sn will be in compression. In the figure E and A refer, respectively, to Young’s modulus and cross section, with subscripts indicating constituents. Here, these strains as drawn in Fig. 3.48 are scalar quantities. Bronze Copper Nb3 Sn
brr cur br0 Ebr
Ecu
Es
Abr
Acu
As
Composite at ∼1000 K (a) Fig. 3.48
cu0
Individual Constituents at 4.2 K (b)
sr
s0
Composite at 4.2 K (c)
Schematic strain states in the Nb3 Sn composite after cooldown.
* Problem 3.18 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
206
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.15: Stresses in Composite Nb3 Sn Conductor (continuation) A. Equilibrium Equations The stress and strain equilibrium equations for the composite at 4.2 K are: brr Abr Ebr + cur Acu Ecu − sr As Es +brr + sr −cur + sr −cur + brr
=0 = br0 − s0 = cu0 − s0 = cu0 − br0
(3.180a) (3.180b) (3.180c) (3.180d)
Equation 3.180a states that the net internal force is zero. Equations 3.180b –3.180d give the strain compatibilities for, respectively, the bronze/Nb3 Sn, copper/Nb3 Sn, and copper/bronze. Be aware that Eq. 3.180 implicitly assumes that each constituent is in its elastic range, which usually is not the case. B. Residual Strains From Eqs. 3.180b and 3.180c, we may obtain expressions for sr and cur : sr = br0 − s0 − brr cur = brr − br0 + cu0 Combining the above expressions with Eq. 3.180, we obtain: brr Abr Ebr + (brr − br0 + cu0 )Acu Ecu + (brr − br0 + s0 )As Es = 0 Solving the above equation for brr , we have: (br0 − cu0 )Acu Ecu + (br0 − s0 )As Es Acu Ecu + Abr Ebr + As Es
brr =
(3.181a)
Similarly, from Eqs. 3.180b–3.180d we may obtain expressions for sr and brr : sr = cu0 − s0 − cur brr = br0 − cu0 + cur Thus, (br0 − cu0 + cur )Abr Ebr + cur Acu Ecu + (cur − cu0 + s0 )As Es = 0 Solving for cur from the above equations, we have: cur =
(cu0 − br0 )Abr Ebr + (cu0 − s0 )As Es Acu Ecu + Abr Ebr + As Es
(3.181b)
Also, brr = br0 − s0 − sr cur = cu0 − s0 − sr Thus, (br0 − s0 − sr )Abr Ebr + (cu0 − s0 − sr )Acu Ecu − sr As Es = 0 Solving for sr from the above equations, we have: sr =
(cu0 − s0 )Acu Ecu + (br0 − s0 )Abr Ebr Acu Ecu + Abr Ebr + As Es
(3.181c)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
207
DISCUSSION 3.15: Stresses in Composite Nb3 Sn Conductor (continuation) Numerical Values By using Eqs. 3.181a — 3.181c and the values given in Table 3.16 for each constituent, we may compute values of brr , cur , and sr . (1.66−1.62)(0.62)(100 GPa)+(1.66−0.72)(0.14)(165 GPa) (0.24)(100 GPa)+(0.62)(100 GPa)+(0.14)(165 GPa) 24.19 GPa = % 0.22% (from Fig. 3.48, tensile ) 109.1 GPa
brr =
(1.62−1.66)(0.24)(100 GPa)+(1.62−0.72)(0.14)(165 GPa) 62.9 GPa 19.83 GPa = % 0.18% (from Fig. 3.48, tensile ) 109.1 GPa
cur =
(1.62−0.72)(0.62)(100 GPa)+(1.66−0.72)(0.24)(100 GPa) 62.9 GPa 78.36 GPa = % 0.72% (from Fig. 3.48, compressive ) 109.1 GPa
sr =
Note that both matrix materials are in tension, while Nb3 Sn is in compression; sr of 0.72% is too severe and would certainly damage the conductor. However, when the magnet is energized, the conductor is subjected mostly to a tensile stress, which tends to place sr towards zero strain; usually, the Lorentz stresses are sufficient to put Nb3 Sn in tensile strain when the magnet is energized. C. Stresses in Bronze and Copper From brr and cur computed above, we may compute the corresponding stresses in the bronze and copper. We have: σbrr = brr Ebr (2.2×10−3 )(100×109 Pa) 220 MPa σcur = cur Ecu (1.8×10−3 )(100×109 Pa) 180 MPa The yield stresses of annealed bronze, σbry , and annealed copper, σcuy , are both only ∼100 MPa; both bronze and copper thus yield plastically during cooldown. Table 3.16: Properties of Bronze, Copper, and Nb3 Sn at 4.2 K —Approximate Values— Constituent
∗0 [%]
E [GPa]
A†
bronze copper Nb3 Sn
1.66 1.62 0.72
100 100 165
0.24 0.62 0.14
* Thermal contraction strain from ∼1000 to 4.2 K. † Fraction of the total composite cross section.
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
208
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 3.18: Self inductances of selected systems Derive the “low” frequency self inductance formulas given in 3.7.3. a)
Equation 3.83, for the interior of the wire of radius a per unit length: L=
μ◦ 8π
(3.83)
b) Equation 3.84c, for a “very long” (β α) and thin coil with N total turns: L = μ◦ a1 N 2
π 2β
(3.84c)
c) Equation 3.87, for the unit length of an “ideal” dipole with N total turns: L = 81 μ◦ πN 2
(3.87)
Derive Eq. 3.87 using two expressions: 1) L = 2Em /I 2 ; and 2) L = N Φ. d)
For the unit length of an “ideal” quadrupole with N total turns, Eq. 3.88: L=
2 1 16 μ◦ πN
(3.88)
Derive Eq. 3.88 using two expressions: 1) L = 2Em /I 2 ; and 2) L = N Φ. e) Equation 3.89a, for an “ideal” toroidal coil of major radius R and circular section of radius a with N total turns.
a 2 2 L = μ◦ RN 1 − 1 − (3.89a) R f)
Equation 3.89b, for the ideal toroidal coil of e) in the limit a R. a 2 4 1 a 1 a L = μ◦ aN 1+ 4 +8 ··· 2R R R 2
(3.89b)
g) Equation 3.90a, for an ideal toroid of major radius R and rectangular section of width (r-axis) 2a, height (z-axis) 2b, and N total turns. L = μ◦ bN
2
1 R+a ln π R−a
(3.90a)
h) Equation 3.90b, for the ideal toroidal coil of g) in the limit a R. L = μ◦ bN
2
2a πR
1+
1 3
a 2 R
+
1 5
a 4 R
···
(3.90b)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
209
Solution to PROBLEM 3.18 a) For a wire of radius a carrying current I distributed uniformly over its cross section, the interior magnetic field is given by: I r (S18.1) 2πa2 Magnetic energy per unit wire length stored in the wire interior, em , is given by: a 1 em = 2 μ◦ 2πHθ2 (r)r dr (S18.2) Hθ (r) =
0
Combining Eqs. S18.1 and S18.2, we obtain: μ◦ 2 em = I 16π
(S18.3)
Combining Eqs. 3.79 (Em = LI 2 /2; em = LI 2 /2 on a unit length basis) and S18.3 and solving for the self inductance of the wire interior, L, we have: μ◦ L= (3.83) 8π b) From Eq. 3.111d, the center field, Bz (0, 0), of a long solenoid (β α) is given by μ◦ N I/2b. As may be inferred from Eq. 3.117c, the field in a “thin-walled” and “long” solenoid is uniform in both axial and radial directions and equal to the center field. Thus the total flux linked by N turns of the solenoid is given by: 2 a1 πa1 μ◦ N I Φ= 2πrHz (0, 0) dr = N (S18.4) 2b 0 Combining Eqs. 3.78 (Φ = LI) and S18.4, we obtain: π 2 L = μ◦ a1 N 2β
(3.84c)
c) Method 1: Energy The total ampere-turns (N I) in an ideal dipole, as studied in PROBLEM 3.8, is given by: π/2 Kf R dθ (S18.5) NI = −π/2
f ) and S18.5, we have: where R is the dipole radius. Combining Eqs. 3.140 (for K π/2 NI = 2H0 R cos θ dθ = 4H0 R (S18.6) −π/2
The total magnetic energy Em per unit length of the dipole is given by Eq. 3.143: Em =
πR2 B02 μ◦
(3.143)
From S18.6, we compute H0 R = N I/4. Now combining this, Eqs. 3.143 and 3.79, and solving for L (L per unit length), we have: L = 81 μ◦ πN 2
(3.87)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
210
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.18 (continuation) f , is Method 2: Flux Linkage First, because the surface current density, K f = −2H0 cos θız (Eq. 3.140), for a not uniform over the dipole winding, i.e., K “uniform” I in the winding, the “turn density,” n(θ), must vary with θ as: n(θ) = 21 N cos θ
(S18.7)
Because the dipole has a uniform field of H0 , the total flux linkage by the N turns of the dipole is given by: NΦ =
π/2 −π/2
n(θ)μ◦ H0 (2R cos θ) dθ = μ◦ N H0 R
π/2
−π/2
cos θ2 dθ
= 21 μ◦ πN H0 R = 81 μ◦ πN 2 I
(S18.8)
Combining Eqs. S18.8 and 3.78, we obtain: L = 81 μ◦ πN 2
(3.87)
d) Method 1: Energy The total ampere-turns (N I) in an ideal quadrupole (PROBLEM 3.9 ) is given by: N I = 2×
π/4
Kf R dθ
(S18.9)
−π/4
R is the quadrupole radius. The integral is multiplied by 2 because, as may be seen from Fig. 3.35(b), the current distribution is divided in two regions—we are f ) and S18.9, we have: considering only one polarity. Combining Eqs. 3.146 (for K N I = 2×
π/4
2H0 R cos 2θ dθ = 4H0 R
(S18.10)
−π/4
The total magnetic energy Em per unit length of the quadrupole is obtained by integrating μ◦ |H(r, θ)|2 /2 over the entire surface. |H(r, θ)|2 , from Eq. 3.145, is independent of θ, because sin2 2θ+cos2 2θ = 1.
Em =
1 2 μ◦
H0 R
2
R
0
2πr3 dr + 21 πμ◦ H02 R6
= 21 μ◦ πH02 R2
∞
R
2π dr r5 (S18.11)
Combining Eqs. 3.79, S18.10, and S18.11, we obtain: L =
2 1 16 μ◦ πN
(3.88)
That Em of an ideal quadrupole is 1/2 that of an ideal dipole is reasonable because the quadrupole field varies from 0 to H0 within the bore rather than uniform as for a dipole and decays as 1/r3 outside rather than as 1/r2 for a dipole field.
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
211
Solution to PROBLEM 3.18 (continuation) Method 2: Flux Linkage As with the dipole treated above, the “turn density,” n(θ), in the quadrupole also must vary with θ, here, as: n(θ) = 21 N cos 2θ
(S18.12)
Note that the integral of Eq. S18.12 over one quadrant, e.g., from to −45◦ to +45◦ , gives, as it must, the total number of turns in that quadrant: N/2. For the ideal quadrupole, the total flux linkage, Φ, is given by: π/4 N Φ = 2× n(θ)φ(R, θ) dθ (S18.13a) −π/4
Because H1r = H0 (r/R) sin 2θ (Eq. 3.145a), we have: θ φ(R, θ) = 2μ◦ H0 R sin 2ω dω = μ◦ H0 R cos 2θ
(S18.13b)
0
Therefore:
N Φ = μ◦ N H0 R
π/4
cos2 2θ dθ
−π/4
= 41 μ◦ πN H0 R =
2 1 16 μ◦ πN I
(S18.14)
Combining Eqs. 3.78 and S18.14, we obtain: L =
2 1 16 μ◦ πN
(3.88)
e) As discussed in PROBLEM 3.10, the field within the circular section of an ideal toroid, H(r), is in the azimuthal (ϕ) direction and, from Eq. 3.161, given by: Hϕ (r) =
NI 2πr
The total flux linked by the toroid, Φ, is thus given by: R+a z=+a H(r) dz dr Φ = μ◦ N R−a
(S18.15)
(S18.16)
z=−a
The equation of the circle that defines the cross section is given by: z 2 + (R − r)2 = a2
(S18.17)
Solving z from Eq. S18.17 for the limits of z in the integral of Eq. S18.16 in terms of r and constants, and after combining with Eq. S18.15, we have: √a2 −(R−r)2 μ◦ N 2 R+a dz dr Φ= 2π R−a −√a2 −(R−r)2 r μ◦ N 2 I = π
R+a
R−a
√
a2 −R2 +2Rr−r2 dr r
(S18.18)
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
212
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 3.18 (continuation) R+a 2 2 μ◦ N 2 I (a2 − R2 ) −1 2r − 2R −1 2Rr + 2a − 2R Φ= +√ sin R sin 2 2 π 2a 2ra R −a R−a μ◦ N 2 I = π
a 2 a2 − R2 Rπ + π √ = μ◦ N 2 RI 1 − 1 − R R2 − a2
Combining Eqs. 3.78 and S18.19, we obtain: L = μ◦ RN
2
1−
1−
a 2
(S18.19)
R
For a R, we have: a 2 a 2 a 4 a 6 1 1− = 1 − 21 − 81 − 16 ··· R R R R From Eqs. 3.89a and S18.20, 4 a 6 2 2 1 a 1 a 1 L = μ◦ RN 2 +8 + 16 ··· R R R
(3.89a)
f)
Thus:
2 4 μ◦ a2 N 2 1 a 1 a 1+ 4 L= +8 ··· 2R R R
(S18.20)
(3.89b)
g) The field within the rectangular section of this ideal toroid is the same as that in the circular section of the toroid studied above. Thus: μ◦ N 2 I R+a z=+b 1 NΦ = dz dr 2π R−a z=−b r R+a μ◦ N 2 bI = ln (S18.21) π R−a Combining Eqs. 3.78 and S18.21, we obtain: μ◦ bN 2 R+a L= ln π R−a h)
For a R, we may expand ln(1±a/R) as: a 2 a 3 a 4 a 5 a a ln 1 ± = ± − 21 ± 31 − 41 ± 51 ··· R R R R R R
(3.90a)
(S18.22)
Combining Eqs. 3.90a and S18.22, we obtain: 3 5 a μ◦ bN 2 2 a 2 a 2 +3 L= +5 ··· π R R R 2 4 2μ◦ abN 2 1 a 1 a 1+ 3 +5 ··· L= πR R R
(3.90b)
MAGNETS, FIELDS, AND FORCES—PROBLEMS
213
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.16: Mutual Inductance of Rogowski Coil The Rogowski coil was studied in PROBLEM 2.11 and an expression was derived for total flux linked to the Rogowski coil: Φ(t)
μ ◦ N c2 I(t) 2R
(2.69)
where R is the radius of the Rogowski coil and c is the radius of each of N loops. Equation 2.69 is valid for (c/R)4 1, which is generally satisfied by most Rogowski coils. The mutual inductance, Mri , between the current element and the Rogowski coil is thus given by: μ◦ N c2 Φ Mri ≡ (3.182) I 2R
DISCUSSION 3.17: Force vs. Mutual Inductance From fm (r, θ) = ∇em (Eq. 3.173) given in DISCUSSION 3.12 (p. 200), we may rederive an expression, e.g., for the axial force between two “ring” coils FzA (ρ) from the mutual inductance between them, MAB , or vice versa. Here, we study a simple case in which two “ring” coils are “far apart” in which case, FzA (ρ) is given by Eq. 3.39c and MAB is given by Eq. 3.97. Thus: 2 3μ◦ πaA2 NA IA πaB NB IB FzA (ρ) = (3.39c) 2π ρ2 ρ2 and MAB
μ◦ (πaA2 NA )(πaB2 NB ) 2π ρ3
(3.97)
For this system, we have: em = IA IB MAB
(3.183)
Applying Eq. 3.173 in the ρ-direction and combining Eqs. 3.97 and 3.182, we have: dMAB dρ
d μ◦ (πaA2 NA )(πaB2 NB ) = IA IB dρ 2π ρ3 2 πaB NB IB 3μ◦ πaA2 NA IA =− 2π ρ2 ρ2
FzB (ρ) = IA IB
(3.184a) (3.184b) (3.184c)
Note that in the d/dρ operation in Eq. 3.184a, it is Coil B (right-hand side of two coils in Fig. 3.5, p. 83) that is moved by a distance of ∂ ρ, and thus FzB (ρ) points in the negative direction of ρ. That is, FzA (ρ) = −FzB (ρ) 2 3μ◦ πaA2 NA IA πaB NB IB = 2π ρ2 ρ2
(3.39c)
214
CHAPTER 3—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 3.17: Force vs. Mutual Inductance (continuation) Clearly, the above process may be reversed to obtain an expression of MAB from a known expression of FzA (ρ). Again, we must watch out for the sign. ρ 1 MAB = − FzA (y) dy (3.185) IA IB 0 μ◦ (πaA2 NA )(πaB2 NB ) = (3.97) 2π ρ3 Help from Van (Part 5 of 5 Parts) —Passage from Francis Bitter’s Magnets: The Education of a Physicist After inquiring here and there, I found that the place to look for big secondhand generators was in New Jersey, out beyond Jersey City. It was a peculiar feeling, going shopping for big secondhand electrical machinery, about which I knew very little. But I found something that looked suitable. It had a central motor, and on each end of the shaft a generator capable of delivering up to 5000 amps at 170 volts. It was an impressive object—much bigger than any magnet I had seen—about 12 feet (∼4 m) high and 20 feet (∼6 m) long. When I reported my findings to Van, he suggested that we employ a firm of consulting engineers to check on the condition of the motor generator and then to design a proper installation . . . and before long we had a 1.7 megawatt (million-watt) motor generator which could deliver power at any voltage from zero to 170 volts. This was very valuable, since gradual starting and stopping were necessary. By means of the voltage control we were able to connect the magnet to the power line without drawing current, and then slowly build up the current and increase the power drawn from the power mains. For about three years we had three or four magnets in more or less continuous operation, providing facilities for a considerable range of experiments. There were first of all some low-temperature experiments which, as I pointed out in Chapter III, might be expected to lead to particularly interesting results in high magnetic fields . . . . . .Some years after the war was over, and we were continuing work with our battered twenty-year old magnets, a colleague asked what I felt about the possibility of making even better and stronger magnets. I told him that it seemed to me that our experiments with heat transfer were inconclusive, . . . That is, it seemed possible to remove heat from the copper not at the rate of 200 watts per square centimeter, as I had designed it, but at approximately 2000 watts per square centimeter. The design of such a magnet would lead to even more critical cooling conditions, and in the event that something went wrong the magnet might literally explode. But such magnets are being built. The bugs are being taken out of the new designs, and more and more powerful magnets are becoming available for scientific investigations.* * In the 1930s Francis Bitter (1902–1967) built 10-T “Bitter” magnets [3.65] to perform research in high magnetic fields [3.66]. His magnet laboratory in the basement of an M.I.T. physics building led to the establishment in 1960 of the National Magnet Laboratory (NML) at M.I.T., the first major facility in the world dedicated to high magnetic field sciences and technologies. The NML in turn led to the creation of high magnetic field facilities in Europe (England, Netherlands, France, Germany, Poland, Russia) and Asia (Japan, China). Currently, the largest and most extensive is the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, in operation since 1995 on the campus of Florida State University. In 1995 the NML, by then the Francis Bitter National Magnet Laboratory, named in his honor in 1968, became the Francis Bitter Magnet Laboratory, as before, an M.I.T. laboratory.
MAGNETS, FIELDS,
AND
FORCES—REFERENCES
215
REFERENCES [3.1] Many codes are available, created by individuals and institutions, e.g., SOLDESIGN (M.I.T.), and by commercial outfits, e.g., COMSOL, ANSYS, ANSOFT. [3.2] D. Bruce Montgomery, Solenoid Magnet Design (Robert Krieger Publishing, New York, 1980). [3.3] R.J. Weggel (personal communication, 1999). [3.4] Francis Bitter, Magnets: The Education of a Physicist (Doubleday, New York, 1959). [3.5] Milan Wayne Garrett, “Calculation of fields, forces, and mutual inductances of current systems by elliptical integrals,” J. Appl. Phys. 34, 2567 (1963). [3.6] Based on a reformulation with new materials by Emanuel Bobrov (FBML) in 2005, with additional contribution by Seung-Yong Hahn (FBML), of a paper by E.S. Bobrov and J.E. Williams, “Stresses in superconducting solenoid” Mechanics of Superconducting Structures, F.C. Moon, Ed. (ASME, New York, 1980), 13–41. [3.7] Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers, Ed. Archer E. Knowlton (McGrawHill Book, 1949). [3.8] Benjamin J. Haid (personal communication, 2003). [3.9] Hans-J. Schneider-Muntau and Mark Bird (personal communication, 2004). [3.10] John Peter Voccio,“Qualification of Bi-2223 high-temperature superconducting (HTS) coils for generator applications” (Ph.D. Thesis, Department of System Design Engineering, Keio University, 2007). [3.11] D.B. Montgomery, J.E.C. Williams, N.T. Pierce, R. Weggel, and M.J. Leupold, “A high field magnet combining superconductors with water-cooled conductors,” Adv. Cryogenic Eng. 14, 88 (1969). [3.12] M.J. Leupold, R.J. Weggel and Y. Iwasa, “Design and operation of 25.4 and 30.1 tesla hybrid magnet systems,” Proc. 6 th Int. Conf. Magnet Tech. (MT-6) (ALFA, Bratislava), 400 (1978). [3.13] M.J. Leupold, J.R. Hale, Y. Iwasa, L.G. Rubin, and R.J. Weggel, “30 tesla hybrid magnet facility at the Francis Bitter National Magnet Laboratory,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-17, 1779 (1981). [3.14] M.J. Leupold, Y. Iwasa and R.J. Weggel, “32 tesla hybrid magnet system,” Proc. 8 th Int. Conf. Magnet Tech. (MT-8) (J. Physique Colloque C1, suppl´ement to 45), C1-41 (1984). [3.15] M.J. Leupold, Y. Iwasa, J.R. Hale, R.J. Weggel, and K. van Hulst, “Testing a 1.8 K hybrid magnet system,” Proc. 9 th Int. Conf. Magnet Tech. (MT-9) (Swiss Institute for Nuclear Research, Villigen), 215 (1986). [3.16] M.J. Leupold, Y. Iwasa, and R.J. Weggel, “Hybrid III system,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-24, 1070 (1988). [3.17] Y. Iwasa, M.J. Leupold, R.J. Weggel, J.E.C. Williams, and Susumu Itoh, “Hybrid III: the system, test results, the next step,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 3, 58 (1993). [3.18] Y. Iwasa, M.G. Baker, J.B. Coffin, S.T. Hannahs, M.J. Leupold, E.J. McNiff, and R.J. Weggel, “Operation of Hybrid III as a facility magnet,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 30, 2162 (1994). [3.19] K. van Hulst and J.A.A.J. Perenboom, “Status and development at the High Field Magnet Laboratory of the University of Nijmegen,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 24, 1397 (1988).
216
CHAPTER 3—REFERENCES
[3.20] Jos A.A.J. Perenboom, Stef A.J. Wiegers, Jan-Kees Maan, Paul H. Frings, “First operation of the 20 MW Nijmegen High Field Magnet Laboratory,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 14, 1276 (2004). [3.21] S.A.J. Wiegers, J. Rook, J.A.A.J. Perenboom, and J.C. Maan, “Design of a 50 mm bore 31+ T resistive magnet using a novel cooling hole shape,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 988 (2006). [3.22] Y. Nakagawa, K. Noto, A. Hoshi, S. Miura, K. Watanabe and Y. Muto, “Hybrid magnet project at Tohoku University,” Proc. 8 th Int. Conf. Magnet Tech. (MT-8) (Suppl´ement au Journal de Physique, FASC. 1), C1-23 (1984). [3.23] K. Watanabe, G. Nishijima, S. Awaji, K. Takahashi, K. Koyama, N. Kobayashi, M. Ishizuka, T. Itou, T. Tsurudome, and J. Sakuraba, “Performance of a cryogenfree 30 T-class hybrid magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 934 (2006). [3.24] H.-J. Schneider-Muntau and J.C. Vallier, “The Grenoble hybrid magnet,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-24, 1067 (1988). [3.25] G. Aubert, F. Debray, J. Dumas, K. Egorov, H. Jongbloets, W. Joss, G. Martinez, E. Mossang, P. Petmezakis, Ph. Sala, C. Trophime, and N. Vidal, “Hybrid and giga-NMR projects at the Grenoble High Magnetic Field,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 14, 1280 (2004). [3.26] A. Bonito Oliva, M.N. Biltcliffe, M. Cox, A. Day, S. Fanshawe, G. Harding, G. Howells, W. Joss, L. Ronayette, and R. Wotherspoon, “Preliminary results of final test of the GHMFL 40 T hybrid magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 15, 1311 (2005). [3.27] K. Inoue, T. Takeuchi, T. Kiyoshi, K. Itoh, H. Wada, H. Maeda, T. Fujioka, S. Murase, Y. Wachi, S. Hanai, T. Sasaki, “Development of 40 tesla class hybrid magnet system,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 28, 493 (1992). [3.28] John R. Miller, “The NHMFL 45-T hybrid magnet system: past, present, and future,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1385 (2003). [3.29] M. Bird, S. Bole, I. Dixon, Y. Eyssa, B. Gao, and H. Schneider-Muntau, “The 45T hybrid insert: recent achievement,” Phys. B, 639 (2001). [3.30] J.R. Miller, Y.M. Eyssa, S.D. Sayre and C.A. Luongo, “Analysis of observations during operation of the NHMFL 45-T hybrid magnet systems,” Cryogenics 43, 141 (2003). [3.31] J.R. Miller (Personal communication, 2003). [3.32] E.S. Bobrov (Personal communication, 2003). [3.33] Juan Bascu˜ n´ an, Emanuel Bobrov, Haigun Lee, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “A low- and high-temperature superconducting (LTS/HTS) NMR magnet: design and performance results,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1550 (2003). [3.34] Haigun Lee, Juan Bascu˜ n´ an, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “A high-temperature superconducting (HTS) insert comprised of double pancakes for an NMR magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1546 (2003). [3.35] J. Allinger, G. Danby, and J. Jackson, “High field superconducting magnets for accelerators and particle beams,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-11, 463 (1975). [3.36] A.D. McInturff, W.B. Sampson, K.E. Robins, P.F. Dahl, R. Damm, D. Kassner, J. Kaugerts, and C. Lasky, “ISABELLE ring magnets,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG13, 275 (1977). [3.37] W.B. Fowler, P.V. Livdahl, A.V. Tollestrup, B.F. Strauss, R.E. Peters, M. Kuchnir, R.H. Flora, P. Limon, C. Rode, H. Hinterberger, G. Biallas, K. Koepke, W. Hanson, and R. Borcker, “The technology of producing reliable superconducting dipoles at
MAGNETS, FIELDS,
AND
FORCES—REFERENCES
217
Fermilab,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-13, 275 (1977). [3.38] G. Ambrosio, N. Andreev, E. Barzi, P. Bauer, D.R. Chichili, K. Ewald, S. Feher, L. Imbasciati, V.V. Kashikhin, P.J. Limon, L. Litvinenko, I. Novitski, J.M. Rey, R.M. Scanlan, S. Yadav, R. Yamada, and A.V. Zlobin, “R&D for a single-layer Nb3 Sn common coil dipole using the react-and-wind fabrication technique,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 12, 39 (2002). [3.39] L. Rossi, “The LHC main dipoles and quadrupoles towards series production,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1221 (2003). [3.40] L. Bottura, D. Leroy, M. Modena, M. Pojer, P. Pugnat, L. Rossi, S. Sanfilippo, A. Siemko, J. Vlogaert, L. Walckiers, and C. Wyss, “Performance of the first LHC pre-series superconducting dipoles,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1235 (2003). [3.41] T Doi, H. Kimura, S. Sat¯ o, K. Kuroda, H. Ogata, M. Kud¯ o, and U. Kawabe, “Superconducting saddle shaped magnets,” Cryogenics 8, 290 (1968). [3.42] J.L. Smith, Jr., J.L. Kirtley, Jr., P. Thullen, “Superconducting rotating machines,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-11, 128 (1975). [3.43] T. Ohara, H. Fukuda, T. Ogawa, K. Shimizu, R. Shobara, M. Ohi, A. Ueda, K. Itoh, and H. Taniguchi, “Development of 70MW class superconducting generators,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 27, 2232 (1991). [3.44] J. Kerby, A.V. Zlobin, R. Bossert, J. Brandt, J. Carson, D. Chichili, J. Dimarco, S. Feher, M.J. Lamm, P.J. Limon, A. Makarov, F. Nobrega, I. Novitski, D. Orris, J.P. Ozelis, B. Robotham, G. Sabbi, P. Schlabach, J.B. Strait, M. Tartaglia, J.C. Tompkins, S. Caspi, A.D. McInturff, and R. Scanlan, “Design, development and test of 2 m quadrupole model magnets for the LHC inner triplet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 9, 689 (1999). [3.45] T. Nakamoto, T. Orikasa, Y. Ajima, E.E. Burkhardt, T. Fujii, E. Hagashi, H. Hirano, T. Kanahara, N. Kimura, S. Murai, W. Odajima, T. Ogitsu, N. Ohuchi, O. Oosaki, T. Shintomi, K. Sugita, K. Tanaka, A. Terashima, K. Tsuchiya, and A. Yamamoto, “Fabrication and mechanical behavior of a prototype for the LHC low-beta quadrupole magnets,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 12, 174 (2002). [3.46] R. Burgmer, D. Krischel, U. Klein, K. Knitsch, P. Schmidt, T. Trtschanoff, K. Schirm, M. Durante, J.M. Rifflet, and F. Simon, “Industrialization of LHC main quadrupole cold masses up to series production,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 14, 169 (2004). [3.47] S.H. Minnich, T.A. Keim, M.V.K. Chari, B.B. Gamble, M.J. Jefferies, D.W. Jones, E.T. Laskaris, P.A. Rios, “Design studies of superconducting generators,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-15, 703 (1979). [3.48] A.S. Ying, P.W. Eckels, D.C. Litz, W.G. Moore, “Mechanical and thermal design of the EPRI/Westinghouse 300 MVA superconducting generator,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-17, 894 (1981). [3.49] W. Nick, G. Nerowski, H.-W. Neum¨ uller, M. Frank, P. van Hasselt, J. Frauenhofer, and F. Steinmeyer, “380 kW synchronous machine with HTS rotor windings— development at Siemens and first test results,” Physica C: Superconductivity 372– 376, 1470 (2002). [3.50] Greg Snitchler, Bruce Gamble, and Swarn S. Kalsi, “The performance of a 5 MW high temperature superconductor ship propulsion motor,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 15, 2206 (2005). [3.51] H. Ichikawa and H. Ogiwara, “Design considerations of superconducting magnets as a Maglev pad,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-10, 1099 (1974).
218
CHAPTER 3—REFERENCES
[3.52] Bruce Gamble, David Cope, and Eddie Leung, “Design of a superconducting magnet system for Maglev applications,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 3, 434 (1993). [3.53] Kenji Tasaki, Kotaro Marukawa, Satoshi Hanai, Taizo Tosaka, Toru Kuriyama, Tomohisa Yamashita, Yasuto Yanase, Mutuhiko Yamaji, Hiroyuki Nako, Motohiro Igarashi, Shigehisa Kusada, Kaoru Nemoto, Satoshi Hirano, Katsuyuki Kuwano, Takeshi Okutomi, and Motoaki Terai, “HTS magnet for Maglev applications (1)— coil characteristics,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 2206 (2006). [3.54] A. den Ouden, W.A.J. Wessel, G.A. Kirby, T. Taylor, N. Siegel, and H.H.J. ten Kate, “Progress in the development of an 88-mm bore 10 T Nb3 Sn dipole magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 11, 2268 (2001). [3.55] G. Ambrosio, N. Andreev, S. Caspi, K. Chow, V.V. Kashikhin, I. Terechkine, M. Wake, S. Yadav, R. Yamada, A.V. Zlobin, “Magnet design of the Fermilab 11 T Nb3 Sn short dipole model,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 10, 322 (2000). [3.56] A.R. Hafalia, S.E. Bartlett, S. Caspi, L. Chiesa, D.R. Dietderich, P. Ferracin, M. Goli, S.A. Gourlay, C.R. Hannaford, H. Higley, A.F. Lietzke, N. Liggins, S. Mattafirri, A.D. McInturff, M. Nyman, G.L. Sabbi, R.M. Scanlan, and J. Swanson, “HD 1: design and fabrication of a 16 tesla Nb3 Sn dipole magnet” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 14, 283 (2004). [3.57] J.E.C. Williams, L.J. Neuringer, E.S. Bobrov, R. Weggel, and W.G. Harrison, “Magnet system of the 500 MHz spectrometer at the FBNML: 1. Design and development of the magnet,” Rev. Sci. Instrum. 52, 649 (1981). [3.58] Haigun Lee, Emanuel S. Bobrov, Juan Bascu˜ n´ an, Seung-yong Hahn and Yukikazu Iwasa, “An HTS insert for Phase 2 of a 3-phase 1-GHz LTS/HTS NMR magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 15. 1299 (2005). [3.59] Juan Bascu˜ n´ an, Wooseok Kim, Seungyong Hahn, Emanuel S. Bobrov, Haigun Lee, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “An LTS/HTS NMR magnet operated in the range 600– 700 MHz,” IEEE Tran. Appl. Superconduc. 17, 1446 (2007). [3.60] D.S. Easton, D.M. Kroeger, W. Specking, and C.C. Koch, “A prediction of the stress state in Nb3 Sn superconducting composites,” J. Appl. Phys. 51, 2748 (1980). [3.61] J.W. Ekin, “Strain scaling law for flux pinning in practical superconductors. Part 1: Basic relationship and application to Nb3 Sn conductors,” Cryogenics 20, 611 (1980). [3.62] J.W. Ekin, “Four-dimensional J-B-T - critical surface for superconductors,” J. Appl. Phys. 54, 303 (1983). [3.63] S.L. Bray, J.W. Ekin, and C.C. Clickner, “Transverse compressive stress effects on the critical current of Bi-2223/Ag tapes reinforced with pure Ag and oxidedispersion-strengthened Ag, J. Appl. Phys. 88, 1178 (2000). [3.64] J.W. Ekin, S.L. Bray, N. Cheggour, C.C. Clickner, S.R. Foltyn, P.N. Arendt, A.A. Polyanskii, D.C. Larbalestier and C.N. McCowan, “Transverse stress and fatigue effects in Y-Ba-Cu-O coated IBAD tapes,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 11, 3389 (2001). [3.65] F. Bitter, “The design of powerful electromagnets Part IV. The new magnet laboratory at M.I.T.,” Rev. Sci. Inst. 10, 373 (1939). [3.66] George R. Harrison and Francis Bitter, “Zeeman effects in complex spectra at fields up to 100,000 gauss,” Phys. Rev. 57, 15 (1940).
CHAPTER 4 CRYOGENICS 4.1 Introduction Cryogenics is essential for superconductivity. This reliance of superconductivity on cryogenics has been a major hindrance to the widespread use of superconductivity for applications such as electric power. It is, however, important to put cryogenics in perspective and not overemphasize its role. From cryogenics alone, it is clearly more efficient to operate a superconducting magnet at the highest permissible temperature, but if this superconducting magnet is a part of a system, the impact of this operating temperature on the overall system must be evaluated. The question of “What is the best operating temperature for a superconducting magnet?” becomes a real, and extremely important, design/operation issue, particularly with HTS magnets. To generate the same field an HTS magnet operating at 77 K, for example, unquestionably requires considerably more superconductor than one at 20 K; the savings in cryogenics may be insufficient to offset the increased superconductor cost. Also not to be overlooked is the mandatory requirement of thermal insulation for every superconducting system: the best thermal insulation is vacuum. A thermally “effective” vacuum is relatively easy to achieve in a cryostat when the cold temperature is below 20 K, at which point hydrogen condenses. Hydrogen, outgassed from the “evacuated” cryostat surfaces, is the primary heat transfer medium within the cryostat. Thus, for the overall HTS magnet system it might be more cost effective to operate the magnet below, rather than above, 20 K. Alternatively, if we can select an operating temperature high enough, e.g., above ∼70 K, arguably most people’s preferred option, we may be able to eliminate vacuum insulation altogether from the cryogenic system, making it one step closer to less intrusive. In this introductory section, the cryogenic design/operation issues of superconducting magnets are briefly discussed : 1) two cooling methods for superconducting magnets, “wet” and “dry;” 2) cooling sources, heating sources, and cryogenic measurements; 3) cryogens for wet magnets; and 4) solid cryogens that may become useful for dry magnets. Details of some of these topics are further studied and covered in PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS which follow this section.
4.2 “Wet” and “Dry” Magnets Until around 1990, all superconducting magnets were operated “wet,” i.e., cooled by liquid helium. The discovery of HTS, coupled with advances in cryocooler technology, spurred, beginning in the early 1990s, development of “dry” (cryogen-free) magnets “cryocooled,” i.e., cooled by a cryocooler, with both LTS [4.1–4.11] and HTS [4.12–4.18]. Because a dry cryogenic system is less cumbersome to operate and maintain, and equally important, because it is easier to make it less intrusive than its “wet” counterpart, the dry magnet is the preferred option in most applications, provided that the magnet generates virtually no dissipations of its own, e.g., AC losses, under normal operating conditions. Y. Iwasa, Case Studies in Superconducting Magnets: Design and Operational Issues, DOI: 10.1007/b112047_4, © Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2009
219
CHAPTER 4
220
Cooling Methods for Superconducting Magnets As summarized in Table 4.1, superconducting magnets can employ any of five cooling methods, four wet and one dry. Although the terms “cryostable,” “adiabatic,” and “quasi-stable” used here are discussed in more detail in CHAPTER 6, qualitatively these terms should be understandable to the reader. Each method is briefly discussed below in the context primarily of cryogenics. Bath-Cooled Cryostable Magnets built before the early 1980s were chiefly bath-cooled and cryostable. A key cryogenic feature of these magnets is “ventilation” of the windings to facilitate cryogen penetration, making virtually every part of the winding exposed to liquid cryogen. Here, convective heat transfer, discussed qualitatively below, is important; some data are presented in CHAPTER 6. Bath-Cooled Adiabatic To achieve high performance, bath-cooled “adiabatic” magnets began to be developed in the early 1980s. Here, the winding pack is dense, with virtually no cryogen penetration, resulting in overall current densities in the winding that are significantly greater than those of bath-cooled cryostable magnets. The winding pack is cooled only at its outer surfaces. Force-Cooled Cryostable To keep cryogen in one phase, which is not generally the case in bath-cooled magnets, and more importantly to reinforce winding with conductor itself, the so-called “cable-in-conduit” (CIC) conductor was developed in the early 1970s, particularly for “large” magnets. Cooling and winding are well-coupled here. Important heat transfer data are those of forced convective flow, typical heat transfer data for which are presented in CHAPTER 6. Force-Cooled Quasi-Stable Here, to make it robust, the winding is not ventilated. To achieve better stability than in bath-cooled adiabatic magnets, however, the coolant is forced through the winding, not through the conductor, but only in close proximity to the conductor pack. As in the adiabatic winding the bulk of the conductor is cooled by conduction. Cryocooled Here the magnet is connected to a cryocooler; cooling within the winding is primarily by conduction. As discussed in more detail in CHAPTER 6, LTS magnets operate quasi-stably, while, HTS magnets operate quite stably. As pointed out in DISCUSSION 4.7 (p. 247), a “cryocirculator” is actually preferable to a cryocooler for the cooling source of a dry magnet, particularly LTS. Table 4.1: Cooling Methods for Wet and Dry Superconducting Magnets Cooling Method
Wet Magnets Cooling-Conductor Coupling
Heat Transfer
Bath-cooled, “cryostable” Bath-cooled, “adiabatic”
Good; entire conductor Essentially nonexistent
Convective Conductive*
Force-cooled, “cryostable” Force-cooled, “quasi-stable”
Good; entire conductor Close proximity, but indirect
Convective Conductive
Cryocooled, “quasi-stable”
Dry Magnets Indirect
Conductive
* To the surfaces of the magnet winding pack.
221
CRYOGENICS
4.3 Cryogenics Issues—Cooling; Heating; Measurement For superconducting magnet technology, three basic cryogenics issues are relevant: 1) cooling sources; 2) heat sources; and 3) measurement. These issues are briefly discussed in this introductory section, with more detailed discussion on specific topics in PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS, as well as in later chapters. 4.3.1 Cooling Sources As summarized in Table 4.1, a superconducting magnet is cooled to and maintained at its operating temperature by either a cryogen or a cryocooler. Cryogens are briefly discussed below. As for the cryocooler only the basic thermodynamics (PROBLEM 4.1) and performance data (DISCUSSION 4.1) are presented. 4.3.2 Heat Sources Generally there are five principal sources of heat in the cold environment of a cryostat housing a superconducting magnet: 1) radiation between the cryostat walls; 2) convection in the “evacuated” space between the cryostat walls; 3) conduction through the magnet support and cryostat structural elements; 4) combination of conduction and Joule dissipation of current leads; 5) dissipation within the magnet. Radiation, convection, and current leads are discussed later in the PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS. Dissipation in magnets is discussed in CHAPTER 7. 4.3.3 Measurement In the operation of superconducting magnets, cryogenic parameters generally measured include: 1) temperature; 2) pressure (cryostat vacuum or cryogen pressure); 3) cryogen flow rate (force-cooled wet magnets); and 4) vapor flow rate (current leads in wet magnets). In this book, only temperature measurement is discussed briefly in DISCUSSION 4.13 (p. 264).
4.4 Liquid Cryogens—for “Wet” Magnets Until the early 1990s, only liquid helium (LHe) was suitable for operation of superconducting magnets. Liquid nitrogen (LN2 ) is used to intercept heat in some LHe cryostats; it also precools LHe-cooled magnets to economize on LHe consumption as the magnet is cooled down from room temperature to 4.2 K (DISCUSSION 4.2 ). Six cryogens with atmospheric saturation (boiling) temperatures below 100 K are oxygen (90.18 K); argon (87.28 K); nitrogen (77.36 K); neon (27.09 K); hydrogen (20.39 K); and helium (4.22 K). For “wet” HTS magnets and devices, cryogens called upon, in order of likelihood, are nitrogen, neon, and possibly hydrogen. For wet LTS magnets and LTS/HTS magnets, e.g., high-field NMR magnets that consist of both LTS and HTS coils, liquid helium still dominates. Boiling heat transfer parameters of five liquids—helium, hydrogen, neon, nitrogen, and, for comparison, water—are briefly discussed below. TRIVIA 4.1 Of the important events below for helium, which is said to have been achieved for the first time on February 29? i) Discovery;
ii) Liquefaction;
iii) Solidification;
iv) Superfluidity.
CHAPTER 4
222 Table 4.2: Boiling Heat Transfer Parameters Liquid
Ts [K]
h [J/cm3 ]
qpk [W/cm2 ]
ΔTpk [K]
qf m [W/cm2 ]
Helium Hydrogen Neon Nitrogen Water
4.22 20.39 27.09 77.36 373.15
2.6 31.3 104 161 2255
∼1 ∼10 ∼15 ∼25 ∼100
∼1 ∼5 ∼10 ∼15 ∼30
∼0.3 ∼0.5 ∼1 ∼2 ∼10
Boiling Heat Transfer Parameters In a wet superconducting magnet, particularly bath-cooled and cryostable, cooling relies on nucleate boiling heat transfer. Because in nucleate boiling heat transfer, cooling is achieved by vaporization of liquid, the liquid’s volumetric heat of vaporization, h , is a key parameter. It also implies that a plot of boiling heat transfer flux, gq vs. temperature, shown in Fig. 4.1 with both axes generally in log scales, looks similar for most liquids. Here the x-axis is the difference between the surface temperature, T , of the object exposed to liquid and the liquid saturation temperature, Ts : T −Ts (= ΔT ). Other key parameters of the plot are: qpk , the peak nucleate boiling heat transfer flux; ΔTpk , the ΔT at which qpk occurs; and qf m , the minimum film boiling heat flux. Table 4.2 presents values of Ts under atmospheric pressure and h , together with typical values of qpk , ΔTpk , and qf m for helium, hydrogen, neon, nitrogen, and, for comparison, water. From Table 4.2, we can easily conclude that liquid helium, the only cryogen suitable for LTS magnets, is the least effective coolant, absorbing the least energy density when vaporized. Although an HTS magnet is best operated dry, if it is to be operated wet, hydrogen, neon, or nitrogen can cover the temperature range for most HTS magnets. One outcome of fuel cell application in the automotive industry is advancement in liquid hydrogen (LH2 ) technology, including safety aspects, that may prove useful for LH2 -cooled HTS magnets. gq
qpk
qf m
ΔT (= T −Ts ) ΔTpk Fig. 4.1 Boiling heat transfer flux vs. temperature (difference between the surface temperature and liquid saturation temperature, Ts ) for a typical liquid.
CRYOGENICS
223
4.5 Solid Cryogens—for “Dry” Magnets As stated earlier, dry LTS magnets, particularly those with operating currents below ∼1 kA, are likely to gradually replace wet, low-current LTS magnets. With one, two, or even all three of the HTS currently being developed (i.e., BSCCO, coated YBCO, and MgB2 ) expected to become full-fledged “magnet-grade-conductors” in the near future, dry HTS magnets may not only replace dry LTS magnets but also find other applications that are possible only with HTS magnets. 4.5.1 “Wet” LTS Magnets vs. “Dry” HTS Magnets—Heat Capacities One positive aspect of a “wet” LTS magnet often overlooked is the large heat capacity of the “cold body,” provided by a volume of liquid helium that is an integral part of every wet LTS magnet. The “large” enthalpy density of liquid helium at 4.2 K of 2.6 J/cm3 —“large” in comparison with copper’s enthalpy density, say, from 4.2 K to 4.5 K of ∼0.0003 J/cm3 , ∼10,000 times greater than copper’s— essentially “anchors” the magnet at its operating temperature most of the time. Every “dry” magnet also should be provided with a large temperature-anchoring heat capacity: solid cryogen is an excellent candidate for this purpose. Figure 4.2 presents heat capacity, Cp , vs. T plots of solid cryogens—neon (SNe), nitrogen (SN2 ), and argon (SAr)—and metals, lead (Pb), silver (Ag), and copper (Cu). (Solid hydrogen is excluded because of its low heat capacity, ∼0.2 J/cm3 K at 13.96 K.) Lead is used often as a heat capacity enhancer in cryogenic equipment, copper is the most widely used matrix metal in LTS, and silver is the matrix metal associated with BSCCO. 2.5 Phase transition (35.61 K) 8.2 J/cm3
2.0
Cp [J/cm3 K]
SNe
1.5 SN2
Pb
1.0 Ag Cu
SAr
0.5
0
0
10
20
30
40 50 T [K]
60
70
80
90
Fig. 4.2 Heat capacity, Cp , vs. temperature, T , plots for SNe, SN2 and SAr (solid lines); and Pb, Ag, and Cu (dashed lines). Note that SN2 has a solid-to-solid phase transition at 35.61 K, absorbing an energy density of 8.2 J/cm3.
224
CHAPTER 4
4.5.2 Solid Cryogens—Neon, Nitrogen, and Argon Three solid cryogens—neon, nitrogen, and argon—that are likely to be used with dry HTS magnets are briefly described below. Selected thermodynamic properties of helium, nitrogen, neon, and argon are given in APPENDIX II. Although high heat capacity is what makes solid cryogens excellent impregnant materials, there are two other properties that make solid cryogens, in some applications, preferable to epoxy: 1) thermal conductivity; and 2) mechanical strength. Over the temperature range 10–15 K, for example, SN2 is more effective than epoxy to make the temperature over an HTS winding uniform. Also SN2 makes the winding more robust than epoxy. Solid Nitrogen (SN2 ) Because it remains solid up to 64.2 K and is inexpensive, lighter (∼1/10 the density of lead), and electrically insulating, solid nitrogen (SN2 ) can be an effective heat capacity enhancer for a dry HTS magnet that operates in the temperature range below 64 K. For example, a BSCCO or YBCO magnet may operate anywhere in the range 20–60 K. For an MgB2 magnet this could be 10-15 K or even 20–30 K. As seen in Fig. 4.2 SN2 undergoes a solid-solid phase transition at 35.61 K, absorbing an additional energy density of 8.2 J/cm3 . Because its heat capacity is ∼1.5 J/cm3 K near this transition temperature, an additional 8.2 J/cm3 energy absorption is equivalent to more than 5 K in temperature rise, a significant “temperature reserve” for an HTS magnet operating in this range. Solid Neon (SNe) The heat capacity data of Fig. 4.2 show that solid neon (SNe), which on a volume basis is ∼200 times more expensive than SN2 , would be the best heat capacity enhancer, among those in the figure, for applications in the range 4–10 K. However, above ∼10 K, SN2 should suffice for most cases. Although there are other substances, e.g., Er3 Ni, that enhance the system heat capacity better than solid neon in the temperature range 4–24 K, for magnets, solid neon, like solid nitrogen and solid argon, is more suitable. The only drawback, aside from cost, is its relatively (compared with SN2 ) low melting temperature of 24.6 K, which limits the operating range of SNe systems to below this temperature. Solid Argon (SAr) Being the most abundant inert gas in the atmosphere, argon is at least an order of magnitude less expensive than neon, though still more expensive than nitrogen. Solid argon will likely be used only for dry magnets operating in the temperature range above 64.2 K (melting point of SN2 ) and below 83.8 K (melting point of SAr). In the PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS that follow this introductory section, cryogenic topics relevant to wet and dry magnets are studied; they are followed by a brief discussion on temperature measurement. In the last section, a rather extensive treatment is given, by means of PROBLEMS & DISCUSSIONS, on current leads, all vapor-cooled, except one “dry” lead. This is because “large” magnet systems, particularly those operating at currents above 1 kA, are still dominated by wet LTS magnets that require vapor-cooled current leads. “The perpetual motion? Nonsense! It can never be discovered. It is a dream that may delude men whose brains are mystified with matter, but not me.”—Owen Warland
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
225
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.1: Carnot refrigerator Because superconductivity occurs at very low temperatures, refrigeration is required to achieve and maintain the cryogenic environment. Using a Carnot refrigerator, shown schematically in Fig. 4.3, we study the most efficient thermodynamic cycle for cooling. The Carnot cycle is composed of two reversible adiabatic (isentropic) and two reversible isothermal processes, in which a working fluid operates between two thermal reservoirs to produce refrigeration (or work) with the highest efficiency. Although Carnot efficiency can never be attained in practice, it sets an upper bound on what is possible. a) Draw a Carnot cycle on a T vs. S plot. Use the following notation indicated in Fig. 4.3—Top : the cold reservoir temperature, which is generally equal to the magnet operating temperature; Scl : the entropy of the mass flow leaving the cold reservoir; Twm : the warm reservoir temperature; and Swm : the entropy of the mass flow entering the warm reservoir. Both reservoir temperatures, Top and Twm , are maintained constant. b) Show that for an ideal Carnot refrigerator, the work input Wca required to extract heat Q from the reservoir at Top and release it to the reservoir at Twm is given by: Twm Wca = Q −1 (4.1) Top c) Show that for a Carnot refrigerator with Twm = 300 K, Wca /Q 70 for Top = 4.2 K and Wca /Q 3 for Top = 77 K.
Twm
Swm
Qwm
Wca
Scl
Q
Top
Fig. 4.3
Carnot refrigerator operating between two heat reservoirs.
* Based on Problem 4.1 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
226
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.1 a) The Carnot refrigerator operates between two reservoirs, the lower one at Top and the higher one at Twm , extracting heat Q at Top and releasing heat Qwm at Twm . As illustrated in Fig. 4.3, work Wca is needed to run the refrigerator. The Carnot refrigeration cycle consists of four reversible processes performed on a working fluid, as shown in the T vs. S plot of Fig. 4.4: • An isentropic compression of working fluid, starting at State 1 (Swm , Top ); • An isothermal compression, starting at State 2 (Swm , Twm ); • An isentropic expansion, starting at State 3 (Scl , Twm ); • An isothermal expansion, starting at State 4 (Scl , Top ) and ending at State 1. b)
From the first law of thermodynamics, we have: Qwm = Q + Wca = 0
(S1.1)
Wca is the work input to the refrigerator, equal to the area enclosed on the T S diagram. (When the directions of Wca , Q, and Qwm in Fig. 4.3 are reversed, this Carnot cycle represents an ideal working machine and the area enclosed on the T -S diagram represents the work output.) Because each process is reversible, Q = Top (Swm −Scl ) and Qwm = Twm (Swm −Scl ), and thus: Q Swm − Scl = (S1.2a) Top Swm − Scl =
Qwm Twm
(S1.2b)
Equating Eqs. S1.2a and S1.2b, we obtain: Q Qwm = Top Twm
(S1.3)
T
Twm
(3)
(2)
Top
(4)
(1)
0
Fig. 4.4
0
Scl
Swm
S
Temperature vs. entropy plot for the Carnot refrigerator.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
227
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.1 (continuation) Combining Eqs. S1.1 and S1.3, we have: Q Q + Wca = Top Twm
(S1.4)
By solving Eq. S1.4 for Wca , we obtain: Twm Wca = Q −1 Top
(4.1)
c) Temperature range 4.2–300 K: With Top = 4.2 K and Twm = 300 K, Wca /Q 70 from Eq. 4.1; i.e., for each 1 W of cooling at 4.2 K, the cryocooler requires 70 W of work input. In real cryocoolers, the “performance” ratio, Wcp/Q, where Wcp is the compressor work, improves with Q, from ∼10,000 for small units (Q = 1 W) to ∼300 for large units (Q ∼ 100 kW)—see DISCUSSION 4.1 below. Temperature range 77∼300 K: With Top = 77 K and Twm = 300 K inserted into Eq. 4.1, we find Wca /Q 3. In real cryocoolers, the performance ratio ranges from ∼50 for small (1 W) units to ∼10 for large (100 kW) units.
DISCUSSION 4.1: Cryocooler Performance Here, we shall briefly examine the cryocooler’s performance in two different ways: 1) cryocoolers rated at one refrigeration power and at different operating temperatures (Q/Top ); and 2) a cryocooler rated at one combination of refrigeration power and operating temperature but operating at different temperatures. A. Specific Cooling Powers at Specific Temperatures Figure 4.5 shows Wcp/Q vs. Top plots for cryocoolers of specific cooling powers, Q in [W], listed in the figure legend [4.19]; the symbol ⊗ is the Carnot cycle. 10,000
1,000 Wcp Q
100
⊗ 1W 10 W 100 W 1 kW 100 kW
10
1
0
10
⊗ ⊗
20
30
40
50
⊗ 60
70
80
Top [K] Fig. 4.5 Wcp/Q vs. Top plots for cryocoolers at specified levels of Q [W] (inset) [4.19]. The symbol ⊗ is for the Carnot cycle at selected Top , computed for Twm = 300 K.
228
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.1: “Cryocooler” Performance (continuation)
30
20
10
0 15
0 20
2nd -Stage Temperature [K]
2nd -Stage Heat Load [W]
40
1st -Stage Heat Load [W ] 20
40
60
80
15
8 4 1 0 20
Fig. 4.6
30 40 50 1st -Stage Temperature [K]
60
70
Performance data of a 2-stage cryocooler.
Thus, 1-W cryocoolers (solid circles) have Wcp/Q ratios, for example, of 7500 for a unit designed for Top = 4.2 K and 600 for a 1-W unit with Top = 20 K. As discussed below, its Wcp/Q ratios at different levels of Top are different from a cryocooler optimized at specific temperatures of 4.2 K and 20 K. B. Operation at Temperatures Other Than the Design Temperature Figure 4.6 shows performance (1st - and 2nd -stage refrigeration powers) data for a 2-stage cryocooler (Sumitomo Heavy Industries: Model RDK-408D2), as functions of the 1st -stage and 2nd -stage operating temperatures. Its nominal lowest 2nd -stage operating temperature is 4.2 K at a cooling power (Q) of 1 W with a compressor power (Wcp ) of 7.5 kW: Wcp/Q = 7500. The data show that the cryocooler’s 2nd stage power/temperature rating—for this same compressor power—ranges from 0 W at 3 K, i.e., Wcp/Q = ∞, to 15 W at 20 K, i.e., Wcp/Q = 500. (Note that Fig. 4.5 indicates a 15-W/20-K unit optimized at 20 K has a Wcp/Q ratio of ∼350.) The nearly horizontal 2nd -stage cooling lines, each at a given 2nd -stage temperature of up to ∼20 K, indicate that the 2nd -stage cooling power is almost independent of the 1st -stage temperature over a range from ∼25 K to ∼60 K. Because this cryocooler runs at the same compressor power of 7.5 kW irrespective of the 1st - and 2nd -stage loads, to keep the 2nd -stage temperature at a desired level, the total heat load, at least at the 2nd -stage, must match its cooling power. Thus, if a 2nd -stage operating temperature of 20 K is desired—at a 1st stage operating condition of 40 W/42 K—and if the actual heat load at the 2nd stage is, for example, 5 W, an additional heat load of 10 W must be supplied to the 2nd stage, because, as seen from Fig. 4.6, the 2nd stage provides a cooling power of 15 W at 20 K. This extra heating load of 10 W is generally supplied by a heater, attached to the 2nd -stage coldhead, making this system even less efficient.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
229
DISCUSSION 4.2: Cooling Modes for Wet Magnets* Because on a volume basis LHe not only is at least one order of magnitude more expensive than LN2 but also has only ∼1/60 the latent heat of vaporization, a LHe-cooled magnet often undergoes a two-step cooldown procedure: 1) with LN2 , cool down the magnet to 77 K; and 2) flush out the LN2 from the cryostat and immediately start cooling down with LHe. For a large magnet (>1 ton), the liquid nitrogen in Step 2 may be pumped down to a pressure of 109 torr (0.14 atm) to bring its temperature, and thus the magnet’s, to 64 K. A. “Perfect” Cooldown Mode Under a “perfect” cooldown mode, the magnet is cooled by a series of infinitesimal perfect energy exchanges with cold helium. At the nth step, the magnet at temperature Tn is cooled to Tn−ΔT by helium of mass ΔMhe , which is vaporized and heated to Tn . Note that the available enthalpy of helium vapor between Tn and room temperature is not used in cooling the magnet. If Mhe is the mass of helium required to cool a magnet of mass Mmg from Ti to 4.2 K, Mhe /Mmg is given by: Ti Mhe ccu (T ) dT = (4.2) Mmg h (T ) − hhe (4.2 K, liq.) 4.2 K he where ccu (T ) is the specific heat of copper (representing all the materials in the winding) and hhe (T ) is the specific enthalpy of helium. This cooling mode may be approached, but never realized in practice, by having liquid helium introduced in the cryostat space underneath the magnet at a very slow rate. However, the cooling rate cannot be arbitrarily slow, because it would take too long, consuming lots of LHe to cope with heat leakage into the cryostat. B. “Dunk” Mode An extreme mode of cooldown is to “dunk” the whole magnet initially at Ti into a bath of liquid helium boiling at 4.2 K. [Mhe /Mmg ]dk to cool down the magnet from Ti to 4.2 K by this “dunk” mode is given by: Mhe [hcu (Ti ) − hcu (4.2 K)] = (4.3) Mmg dk hL where hL [kJ/kg] is the specific heat of vaporization of LHe at 4.2 K. hcu (Ti ) and hcu (4.2 K) are the specific enthalpies of copper, respectively, at Ti and 4.2 K. C. Cooldown with Liquid Neon (LNe) or Liquid Nitrogen (LN2 ) With a cryocooled HTS magnet operating at Top ≥ 10 K, sometimes it is required to initially cool down the magnet from room temperature to Top much faster than would be possible with the cryocooler alone. We may meet this requirement in two steps: 1) by deploying liquid neon (LNe) to reach 27 K, if Top < 27 K, or LN2 to 77 K, if 27 K < Top < 77 K; and 2) with the cryocooler to Top . The required amount of LNe or LN2 , by either cooling mode, may be computed with Eq. 4.2 or Eq. 4.3 with the enthalpies of Ne or N2 in the equations. * Based on Problem 4.2 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
230
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.2: Cooling Modes for Wet Magnets (continuation) Table 4.3 presents liquid cryogen (LHe, LNe, LN2 ) volumes (in liters) required, by “Perfect” and “Dunk” modes, to cool a 1000-kg copper block from Ti to 4.2 K (LHe), 27 K (LNe), or 77 K (LN2 ). Copper specific enthalpy (hpcu ) data are also included. From Table 4.3 it is clear that for a LHe-cooled magnet, LN2 precooling results in a great saving of LHe. The large differences in volumetric heats of vaporization among these cryogens—2.6 [J/cm3 ] for LHe; 104 [J/cm3 ] for LNe; 161 [J/cm3 ] for LN2 —are evident in the volume requirements. Table 4.3: Liquid Cryogens (LHe, LNe, LN2 ) Required to Cool a 1000-kg Copper Block from Ti to 4.2 K (LHe), 27 K LNe), and 77 K (LN2 ) LHe Required [liter]
LNe Required [liter]
LN2 Required [liter]
Ti [K]
hpcu “Perfect” “Dunk”* “Perfect” “Dunk”* “Perfect” “Dunk”* [kJ/kg] (Eq. 4.2) (Eq. 4.3) (Eq. 4.2)† (Eq. 4.3)† (Eq. 4.2)† (Eq. 4.3)†
300 280 240 200 180 160 140 120 100 90 77 70 60 50 40 30 27 20 15 10
79.6 72.0 56.9 42.4 35.3 28.5 22.1 16.1 10.6 8.22 5.90 4.13 2.58 1.40 0.61 0.196 0.124 0.034 0.0107 0.0024
800 760 670 570 520 460 390 320 240 200 150 130 90 57 31 13 9.0 3.4 1.3 0.4
30,000 28,000 22,000 16,000 14,000 11,000 8,500 6,200 4,100 3,200 2,100 1,600 1,000 550 240 77 50 13 4.0 0.9
290 270 230 190 170 140 120 90 66 53 37 29 19 11 4.4 0.7 0 — — —
770 700 550 410 340 280 210 160 100 78 51 39 24 12 4.8 0.7 0 — — —
300 270 230 170 150 120 90 60 31 17 0 — — — — — — — — —
460 420 320 230 190 140 100 66 33 17 0 — — — — — — — — —
* Rounded to two significant figures. † Eqs. 4.2 and 4.3 applied to neon for Ti between 27 K and 300 K; and to nitrogen for Ti between 77 K and 300 K.
Answer to TRIVIA 4.1 iii). In 1928 (a leap year), by a colleague of Kamerlingh Onnes, the Dutch physicist Willem Keesom (1876–1956), who in 1927 also discovered the phenomenon of superfluidity in liquid helium. The element was first observed in 1868 by the French astronomer Pierre Jules C´esar Janssen (1824–1907) as a spectral line in the sun (h¯elios) during a total eclipse in India. The Scottish chemist Sir William Ramsay (1852–1916) in 1895 discovered the element on earth in America from samples of gas obtained from a uranium mineral.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
231
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.3: “Cryocooling” HTS Magnet In this discussion we study a dry HTS magnet as it is “cryocooled” (cooled by a cryocooler) from an initial temperature Ti to its operating temperature Top over a total cooldown period of τcn . The cooling power of the 2nd stage of this cryocooler, Qr (T ), vs. its temperature, T , is shown in Fig. 4.7. Note that the cooling power of this cryocooler is rated 10 W at 10 K. (Its 1st stage is used to cool the radiation shields that surround the magnet.) To simplify the discussion, let us consider an adiabatic control volume consisting only of the magnet and the cryocooler with no additional heat input to the system during the cooldown. Also let us assume that the magnet mass is represented by copper mass Mcu . A plot of copper heat capacity, Ccu (T ) [kJ/m3 ], is given in APPENDIX III, based on a constant copper density, cu , of 8960 kg/m3 . Assume furthermore that the cooling rate is sufficiently slow to make the copper (magnet) temperature, Tcu , uniform over the entire winding and equal to the cryocooler temperature, T , at all times during the cooldown, i.e., Tcu = T . Applying the 1st law of thermodynamics on the control volume containing the cryocooler and the copper mass Mcu , and noting Tcu = T , we have: −Qr (T ) =
Mcu dT Ccu (T ) cu dt
(4.4)
The minus sign for Qr (T ) in Eq. 4.4 signifies that the cryocooler is providing refrigeration: the magnet (copper mass) is cooling, i.e., dT /dt < 0.
100
80
60 Qr [W] 40
20
0 0
100
200 T [K]
Fig. 4.7
Qr (T ) curve for the magnet cryocooler.
300
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
232
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.3: “Cryocooling” an HTS Magnet (continuation) Table 4.4: Qr (T ), Ccu (T ), and K(T ) ≡ Ccu (T )/Qr (T ) Qr (T ) [W] Ccu (T ) [J/m3 K]
T [K] 300 250 200 150 100 77 50 30 20 10
3.44×106 3.32×106 3.17×106 2.87×106 2.26×106 1.75×106 0.88×106 0.24×106 0.69×105 0.08×105
100 87 75 63 50 40 28 19 15 10
K(T ) [s/m3 K] 3.44×104 3.82×104 4.23×104 4.56×104 4.52×104 4.38×104 3.14×104 1.26×104 0.46×104 0.08×104
Table 4.4 lists Qr (T ), Ccu (T ), and K(T ) ≡ Ccu (T )/Qr (T ) at selected temperatures. We may integrate Eq. 4.4 to solve for τcn for a set of Ti , Top , Qr (T ), and Mcu : Mcu Ti Ccu (T ) Mcu Ti τcn = dT = K(T ) dT (4.5a) cu Top Qr (T ) cu Top Mcu =
cu τcn Ti
(4.5b)
K(T ) dT
Top
In some applications, τcn is the primary design specification, which, as may be seen from Eq. 4.5b, limits the copper mass (here representing the magnet mass), ˜ cu , to be cooled within τcn . Note that for a given combination of Ti and Top , M ˜ cu for combinations of τcn , Ti , and ˜ cu is proportional to τcn . Table 4.5 lists M M Top , with Qr (T ) given by Fig. 4.7. Thus, if a magnet is to be cooled down from 300 K to 30 K in a time period of 4 h, for example, its mass is limited to 11.6 kg. The results shown in Table 4.5 clearly indicate that for a given τcn we may dra˜ cu by first cooling down the mass to 77 K. Table 4.3 may be matically increase M used to estimate the amount of LN2 required to accomplish this. ˜ cu for τcn , Ti , Top , with Qr (T ) given by Fig. 4.7 Table 4.5: M Ti [K] Top [K] τcn [hour/day]→ 300
77
77 50 30 10 50 30 10
1 3.4 3.0 2.9 2.9 29 20 19
* Up to 3 significant figures.
2
4
6.8 6.1 5.8 5.7 58 40 38
13.6 12.1 11.6 11.5 118 80 76
˜ cu [kg] M 12 1 41 36 35 34 352 242 227
82 73 70 69 704 484 453
2
10
20
164 147 140 139 1410* 968 906
820 735 700 695 7040* 4840* 4530*
1640* 1470* 1400* 1390* 14100* 9680* 9060*
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
233
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.4: Superfluidity Figure 4.8 shows the phase diagram of ordinary helium (He4 ), in which two forms of liquid are present, He I and He II [4.20]. Because of its unique properties of extremely high effective thermal conductivity (k) and low viscosity (ν), He II is known as superfluid helium; superfluidity has been compared to superconductivity. As may be inferred from the phase diagram, ordinary liquid helium (He I) boiling at 4.22 K can readily be transformed to He II simply by pumping on the liquid. When the saturation pressure of 5 kPa (37.8 torr) is reached, the liquid, at 2.18 K, becomes “superfluid.” The temperature 2.18 K is known as the λ-point and designated by Tλ . According to the “two-fluid” model, the fraction of superfluid, zero at Tλ , increases monotonically as temperature is lowered. The extraordinary thermal conductivity and viscosity of superfluid helium may be appreciated by comparing these properties of He II with those of common materials (Table 4.6). A. Transport Properties Because of its extremely high thermal conductivity superfluid helium is sometimes used as a coolant for superconducting magnets, generally operated at ∼1.8 K (< Tλ ). (Although we use the classical definition of thermal conductivity here, i.e., heat conduction ∝ temperature difference, in He II the smaller the temperature difference, the greater becomes the “equivalent” conductivity, which also varies with heat flux.) The high thermal conductivity of He II does not allow a temperature gradient in the liquid sufficient for creation of vapor. Thus, unlike the winding of a 4.2-K He I cooled cryostable magnet, the “bubbleless” winding of a 1.8-K He II cooled cryostable magnet does not require ventilation. However, this does not mean that He II can transport unlimited heat fluxes through narrow channels. Analogous to the critical current density in superconductors, He II has a critical heat flux. 10000 Solid
Pressure [kPa]
1000 Liquid (He I)
100 Liquid (He II)
Vapor
10
1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Temperature [K] Fig. 4.8
Phase diagram of ordinary helium (He4 ) [4.20].
7
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
234
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.4: Superfluidity (continuation) Table 4.6: Thermal Conductivities and Viscosities of He II, He I, Copper, Water, Air Material
k [W/m K]
ν [μPa s]
He II He I (4.2 K, liq.) Copper (4.2 K) Water (293 K) Air (293 K)
∼100,000* 0.02 ∼400 ∼1 ∼0.05
0.01∼0.1 ∼3 — ∼1,000 ∼20
* “Equivalent” k at a specified temperature difference and heat flux.
Bon Mardion, Claudet, and Seyfert studied heat flux in He II through narrow channels [4.21]. Figure 4.9 presents their results in the form of a parameter X(T ) defined by them; it is given by: X(Tcl ) − X(Twm ) = q 3.4 L
(4.6a)
where Tcl [K] is the cold-end temperature and Twm [K] is the warm-end temperature. q [W/cm2 ] is the heat flux through a channel L [cm] long between the two ends, one end at Tcl and the other at Twm . Equation 4.6a is applicable for the case with no additional heating introduced to the liquid from the channel itself. Under normal operating conditions, Tcl = Tb , where Tb is the bath temperature; Twm is the liquid temperature adjacent to a heated region within the winding, which cannot exceed Tλ . When Twm = Tλ , from Fig. 4.9, X(Twm ) = 0, and we can simplify Eq. 4.6a to: (4.6b) X(Tb ) = qc3.4 L 600 500 400 X(T ) 300 Tλ
200 q
He II L
100 0 1.3
T
Tλ 1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1
2.2
T [K] Fig. 4.9 Bon Mardion-Claudet-Seyfert plot of X(T ) for a channel of length L [cm] filled with 1-atm, superfluid helium conducting heat flux q. [4.21].
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
235
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.4: Superfluidity (continuation) For Twm > Tλ the heat flux from the surface of the heated region will be limited by qpk which, for He I as given in Table 4.2, is ∼1 W/cm2 . The limit implied by Eq. 4.6b will exceed 1 W/cm2 in magnets whose characteristic size is less than 1 m as long as Tb < 2 K. In designing channel configuration and dimensions, we must make sure that the operating heat flux, qop , through the channel does not exceed qc given by Eq. 4.6b. Heated Channel When heating is uniformly introduced over the entire length L of the channel, rather than at the hot end as discussed above, Eq. 4.6b is modified [4.22]: X(Tb ) =
qc3.4 L 4.4
(4.6c)
B. Heat Transfer—Kapitza Resistance Heat transfer between a metal or other thermally conductive material and He II is limited by Kapitza resistance. Heat transfer flux, qk [W/cm2 ], between a metal whose surface is at Tcd [K] and liquid helium at Tb [K] is given by: nk qk = ak (Tcd − Tbnk )
(4.7)
Table 4.7 gives typical values of ak and nk . Table 4.7: Approximate Values for Kapitza Resistance* Metal (surface) Aluminum (polished) Copper (polished) Copper† (polished) Copper (as-received) Copper (solder-coated) Copper (varnish-coated) Silver (polished)
ak [W/cm2 Knk ]
nk
0.05 0.02
3.4 4.0
0.02 0.05 0.08 0.07 0.06
3.8 2.8 3.4 2.1 3.0
* Based on values given in references [4.23, 4.24]. † Annealed.
TRIVIA 4.2 Of the four contemporary chemists (born 1870–1881) below, who first produced neon lights? i) Claude;
ii) Fischer;
iii) Hahn;
iv) Langmuir.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
236
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.5: Subcooled 1.8-K Cryostat* Here we discuss a cryostat for a superconducting magnet operated in a bath of subcooled superfluid helium at 1 atm and 1.8 K. Performance of a magnet improves significantly as the operating temperature is decreased from 4.2 K to 1.8 K, particularly in bath-cooled NbTi magnets [4.25], because of significant improvements in: 1) critical current density; and 2) heat transfer between conductor and coolant. Figure 4.10 shows a schematic of the subcooled 1.8-K cryostat for the Hybrid III magnet system [4.26]. A pump, located outside the cryostat, drives the helium flow, at a mass flow rate of m ˙ h , required by the 1.8-K evaporator (“ice cube”) housed in the magnet vessel. The 1.8-K/1-atm magnet vessel is connected hydraulically to the 4.2-K/1-atm reservoir located above through a narrow channel sufficient both to keep the magnet vessel at 1 atm (subcooled) and to minimize conduction heat input by helium from the reservoir to the magnet vessel. The current leads pass through the 4.2-K reservoir and then enter the magnet vessel through current links connecting the two liquid vessels. Components such as structural elements not directly related to the refrigeration cycle are not included in Fig. 4.10. m ˙h 4
5 Pump
Vapor-cooled current leads Poppet valve
Relief valve
Transfer tube vertical motion of tube
Filter
Reservoir (4.2 K)
Pumping line
Hydraulic communication
1
Feed valve
Current links Magnet vessel Evaporator (1.8 K)
J-T heat exchanger Vacuum boundary
Bottom fill tube 2
3
J-T valves (coarse & fine needle valves) Fig. 4.10
Schematic of a subcooled 1.8-K cryostat [4.26].
* Based on Problem 4.6 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
237
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.5: Subcooled 1.8-K Cryostat (continuation) From Point 1, just outside the reservoir, filtered 4.2-K/1-atm (760 torr) liquid helium is cooled by the J-T heat exchanger and then flows through the J-T valves. The valves reduce the helium pressure isenthalpically from 760 torr to 12.3 torr— more about Joule-Thomson (J-T) process in DISCUSSION 4.6—and creates a mixture of liquid and vapor, both at 1.8 K and 12.3 torr. The 1.8-K liquid enters the evaporator and cools the 1-atm liquid in the magnet vessel, as would an ice cube in a glassful of water. On its return path the 1.8-K vapor leaves the evaporator and cools the incoming 4.2-K liquid in the J-T heat exchanger. Upon leaving the pump, the helium gas is purified and stored in a pressure tank. The exhaust helium gas from the 4.2-K reservoir is funneled through the vaporcooled current leads, and it too is stored in the tank. Helium from the tank is liquefied and transferred into a 500-liter storage dewar, from which it is continuously transferred to the 4.2-K reservoir to maintain the reservoir’s liquid level. This 1.8-K cryostat thus is a closed system. Under normal operating conditions, the 1.8-K/12.3-torr superfluid helium in the evaporator is kept at a nearly constant level. The total combined heat load on the magnet vessel, Q1.8 , is thus matched by refrigeration produced by the evaporator. Q1.8 enters into the evaporator from the vessel through the evaporator wall. A. Refrigeration Power at 1.8 K Refrigeration power at 1.8 K, Q1.8 , provided by the evaporator may be derived from the first law of thermodynamics applied to the control volume (c.v.) enclosing the evaporator, schematically shown in Fig. 4.11. In the figure, m ˙ h is the mass flow rate entering and leaving the control volume. Under the steady-state condition, the difference between the total heat output, Qout and total input, Qin , to the evaporator, is equal to Q1.8 . Thus: Qout − Qin = Q1.8 Qin m ˙h •2
(4.8)
Qout m ˙h •3 c.v.
J-T valve − −−−− →
Q1.8
Fig. 4.11 Heat balance for the evaporator. See Fig. 4.10 for locations of Points 2 and 3 in the cryostat.
238
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.5: Subcooled 1.8-K Cryostat (continuation) Note that Q1.8 is also equal to the refrigeration load to the evaporator. Q1.8 consists principally of: • Dissipation within the magnet—splice losses and AC losses during field change; these losses are discussed in CHAPTER 7. • Heat input to the magnet vessel—conduction: through structural supports and by current leads between the 4.2-K reservoir and the 1.8-K vessel; superfluid conduction through the pressure communication channel; radiation as well as residual convection on the vessel surfaces. Heat output, Qout , from the control volume is given by Qout = m ˙ h h3 , where h3 is the helium (vapor) enthalpy at Point 3. Similarly, Qin = m ˙ h h2 , where h2 is the helium (liquid) enthalpy at Point 2. Solving Eq. 4.8 for Q1.8 , we obtain: Q1.8 = m ˙ h (h3 − h2 )
(4.9)
Point 1 is at 4.2 K, while Point 3 is at 1.8 K. To maximize Q1.8 at a given helium flow rate, as seen from Eq. 4.9, (h3 − h2 ) must be maximized: the helium temperature at Point 2 must be as close to 1.8 K as possible. The J-T heat exchanger cools down the incoming 4.2-K/760-torr liquid with the outgoing 1.8-K/12.3-torr vapor. Illustration We may determine m ˙ h [g/s] to make Q1.8 = 20 W for the following parameters: P2 = 1 atm; T2 = 3.0 K; P3 = 12.3 torr and T3 = 1.8 K. From APPENDIX II, h3 (1.8 K, 12.3 torr; vapor) = 24.02 J/g and h2 (3.0 K, 1 atm; liquid) = 5.64 J/g, and solving for Q1.8 (Eq. 4.9), we obtain: Q1.8 = m ˙ h (24.02 J/g − 5.64 J/g) = 20 W Solving the above equation for m ˙ h , we obtain m ˙ h = 1.09 g/s, which corresponds to a supply rate of liquid helium (at 4.2 K, 1 atm) of 31 liter/h. Note that in addition to this 31 liter/h liquid replenishment rate, it is necessary to transfer liquid into the reservoir to remove the heat from current leads and other sources. B. Refrigeration Pumping Power Requirement Assuming the pumping process to be isentropic and helium vapor to be a perfect gas, we may compute the minimum input power (between Points 4 and 5 in Fig. 4.10) required to pump helium at a mass flow rate m ˙ h = 1 g/s from Point 4 (12.3 torr/300 K) to Point 5 (760 torr). For an isentropic pump, the pump power requirement, Ps , is given by: γ−1 γ P5 γ ˙h (P4 v4) Ps = m −1 (4.10) γ−1 P4 γ = Cp /Cv for a perfect gas is 5/3; v4 is the specific volume at Point 4, which for helium at 300 K and 12.3 torr is 371 m3/kg. With P4 = 12.3 torr = 1.64 × 103 Pa, P5 /P4 = 61.8, and m ˙ h = 0.001 kg/s (1 g/s), we obtain: Ps = 6400 W (or ∼9 hp, horsepower). Note that this is for an ideal case; the power requirement for a real pump is roughly 20 kW.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
239
DISCUSSION 4.5: Subcooled 1.8-K Cryostat (continuation) Line Pressure Drop It is important to keep the pressure drop between Points 3 and 4 much less than 12.3 torr, the operating pressure at Point 3. Note that the lower P4 gets—below 12.3 torr to keep P3 = 12.3 torr—the more Ps is needed. For the Hybrid III system, the plumbing outside the cryostat consists of a pipe of 15cm i.d. and 13-m length, having five 90◦ bends and one shut-off valve. It handles a mass flow rate up to ∼2 g/s with a total pressure drop less than 1 torr. Also, precautions should be taken not to introduce contaminants into the evaporator. Such contaminants tend to freeze out at the narrowest passage areas, e.g., J-T valves, and block the line. In Hybrid III each J-T valve has a heater attached to melt away frozen contaminants. C. Heat Leakage Through Hydraulic Communication For the Hybrid III cryostat, the hydraulic communication has an effective area of 2.6 mm2 to keep the magnet vessel at 1 atm. Its effective length, L, connecting the helium in the reservoir and that in the magnet vessel is 10 cm. Using the Bon Mardion-Claudet-Seyfert plot of X(T ) given in Fig. 4.9, and assuming the helium temperature at the bottom of the reservoir to be Tλ and at the magnet vessel to be 1.8 K, we may compute the heat input into the 1.8-K magnet vessel from the 4.2-K reservoir, conducted by the superfluid helium in the channel. For narrow channels filled with 1-atm superfluid helium, as discussed in 4.4 A, we may apply Eq. 4.6a which relates X(T ) for two end temperatures, Twm (warm) and Tcl (cold), to conduction heat flux q [W/cm2 ], and channel length L [cm]. With Twm = Tλ , Tcl = 1.8 K, and L = 10 cm, we have, from Fig. 4.9: X(Tλ ) = 0, and X(1.8) = 360 (in appropriate units). Inserting these values into Eq. 4.6a, we obtain: 360 = q 3.4 10, which results in: q = 2.87 W/cm2 . With the channel cross sectional area of 2.6 mm2 , total conduction heat input to the 1.8-K magnet vessel through the hydraulic communication channel becomes ∼75 mW. Carbon resistors are placed in the bottom area of the reservoir to measure liquid temperature in that area. Although measurement indicated that the liquid temperature in this particular reservoir bottom was ∼3 K, generally in this type of 1.8-K cryostat, the liquid at the reservoir bottom would be closer to Tλ (= 2.18 K). Because 2.6 mm2 is an insufficient flow area to limit the overpressure in the 1.8-K vessel in the event of a magnet quench, the cryostat has a “poppet” valve of 40mm2 cross section. Under normal conditions the poppet valve is kept shut by a spring; the valve is opened when pressure builds up in the magnet vessel. D. Replenishment of 4.2-K Liquid One of the final steps in the “cool-down mode” of the Hybrid III magnet involves cooling the liquid helium in the magnet vessel from 4.2 K to 1.8 K. The cooling is provided by the evaporator, which is continuously fed with liquid, initially at 4.2 K in the reservoir and cooled by the J-T heat exchanger before entering the evaporator, and then pumped. For a liquid volume in the magnet vessel of 250 liters, we may estimate the total volume of “replenishment” liquid for the magnet vessel as the liquid is cooled from 4.2 K to 1.8 K.
240
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.5: Subcooled 1.8-K Cryostat (continuation) The liquid densities at 1 atm are 125 kg/m3 at 4.2 K and 147 kg/m3 at 1.8 K. Thus for Hybrid III, the 250-liter vessel starts with about 31 kg of liquid at 4.2 K and ends up with about 37 kg of liquid at 1.8 K. That is, about 6 kg of liquid must be supplied to the vessel. In terms of volume at 4.2 K, this translates to ∼50 liters. Although the cross section of 2.6 mm2 provided by the hydraulic communication channel is adequate to transport this additional mass of liquid over a cooldown period of ∼2 hr, the poppet valve with a total flow passage area of 40 mm2 is kept open until the liquid in the vessel reaches Tλ . E. Current Leads Between 4.2-K Reservoir and 1.8-K Vessel The current leads must reach from the bottom of the reservoir to the terminals of the magnet in the 1.8-K vessel. It is customary to use a composite superconductor for current leads. In this application the cross section occupied by normal metal (copper) must be small enough to minimize heat conduction by the metal from the reservoir to the vessel but sufficient to stabilize the composite superconductor. The “dry” lead criterion, to be studied in DISCUSSION 4.15 (p. 274), is applicable here, because between the two ends the lead is essentially insulated—in the Hybrid III cryostat, the vertical gap separating the reservoir and 1.8-K vessel is in vacuum. We may show that the peak steady-state temperature in the normal-state lead carrying It occurs at the lead’s reservoir end. By choosing the “current-sharing temperature” (Tcs ) of composite superconductor in the lead to be well above Tλ , the helium temperature at the reservoir bottom, we may ensure stable operation of the current leads—see CHAPTER 6 for discussion of Tcs . An expression for the steady-state temperature profile along the normal-state lead is derived from Eq. 4.52 given in DISCUSSION 4.15: (T − T0 ) ρ˜I 2 ρ˜I 2 T (z) = − t z 2 + + t z + T0 (4.11) 2A2 k˜ 2A2 k˜ In Eq. 4.11, the composite’s z = 0 is at the 1.8-K vessel and z = is at the reservoir. ρ˜ and k˜ are, respectively, the composite normal metal’s resistivity and thermal conductivity. A and are the lead’s cross sectional area and length separating the cold and warm ends, respectively, at T0 (1.8 K) and T ( Tλ ). According to DISCUSSION 4.15, a dry lead rated at It = I◦ satisfies the following condition: ˜ − T0 ) I◦ 2k(T = (4.12) A dr ρ˜ Combining the above two equations and defining a new variable ξ ≡ z/, we have: T (ξ) = −(T − T0 )ξ 2 + 2(T − T0 )ξ + T0
(4.13)
At ξ = 1, where dT/dξ = 0, the temperature peak occurs. Since this location is at ξ = 1, it implies that the peak temperature is T Tλ . That is, even if the lead is driven normal, if the lead satisfies the criterion given by Eq. 4.12, the conduction cooling is sufficient to limit the peak lead temperature to Tλ , no greater than the warm-end temperature of the lead when it is superconducting.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
241
DISCUSSION 4.6: Joule-Thomson Process In the Joule-Thomson (J-T) process, a gas expands adiabatically with no work involved (isenthalpic) through a restricted passage, e.g., a J-T (needle) valve to a lower pressure, changing its temperature in the process. Whether the change is positive, negative, or zero depends on the gas properties, the starting temperature, and initial and final pressures. For helium at initial and final pressures of 10 atm and 1 atm, respectively, liquefaction results if the initial temperature is below ∼7.5 K. Because the process is irreversible, liquefaction by the J-T process always results in a smaller portion of liquid produced than if the gas had been expanded isentropically. For example, at a starting temperature of 6 K and a pressure of 10 atm—typical values for liquefiers—the following isenthalpic relationship may be used to compute the fraction of helium liquefied (x ) at 4.2 K and 1 atm: hg (6 K, 10 atm) = x h (4.2 K, 1 atm) + (1 − x )hg (4.2 K, 1 atm)
(4.14)
From Eq. 4.14 we find x = 0.47. If the same gas is expanded isentropically, an entropy relationship similar to the enthalpy relationship of Eq. 4.14 gives x = 0.85. Despite this reduction in liquid production efficiency, the J-T expansion, because of its mechanical simplicity, is used in the final stage of many helium liquefiers. James Prescott Joule (1818–1889) — Passage from Isaac Asimov’s Asimov’s Biographical Encyclopedia of Science and Technology [4.27] Joule was son of a wealthy brewer, which meant he had the means to devote himself to a life of research . . . Joule was almost a fanatic on the subject of measurement, and even on his honeymoon he took time out to devise a special thermometer to measure the temperature of the water at the top and bottom of a scenic waterfall his wife and he were to visit . . . He went on to devote a decade to measuring the heat produced by every process he could think of . . . Even his honeymoon measurement of the waterfall temperature was based on the thought that the energy of falling water should be converted to heat once it was stopped so that the temperature at the bottom of the waterfall should be higher than that at the top . . . In all those cases he calculated the amount of work that had entered the system and the amount of heat that came out and he found, as Rumford had maintained fully half a century before, that the two were closely related. A particular quantity of work always produced a particular quantity of heat. In fact, 41,800,000 ergs of work produced one calorie of heat. This is called the “mechanical equivalent of heat.” His original statement of this discovery was rejected by various learned journals and he was forced to present it at a public lecture in Manchester and then get his speech published in full by a reluctant Manchester newspaper. A few months later he finally managed to present it before an unsympathetic scientific gathering and his presentation would have passed almost unnoticed but for a twenty-three-old in the audience. His name was William Thomson, and he was later to be known as Lord Kelvin. His comments on Joule’s work were shrewd enough and logical enough to rouse interest and even enthusiasm, and Joule’s reputation was made. * Although for many years until his death a faculty member of Boston University, the biochemist Isaac Asimov (1920–1992) devoted his life writing for the general public on virtually every subject conceivable. In the sci-fi genre his books include the Galactic Empire series (Pebble in the Sky, 1950) and the Robot series (I, Robot, 1950).
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
242
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.2: Cryocooler-based “mini” helium liquefier With proliferation of cryocoolers, as stated at the outset of this chapter, most “DC” superconducting magnets, LTS and HTS, will likely be operated “dry” (cryogenfree) with cooling provided by a cryocooler. In some applications, unlike most cryocooled magnets in which the cryocooler/magnet assembly is housed within the same cryostat, the magnet and its cryocooler are housed in separate cryostats. A schematic drawing of one such system is shown in Fig. 4.12 for a slow “magic angle spinning” (MAS) NMR magnet. In such a magnet, its principal field is directed 54.73◦ from the magnet axis (see PROBLEM 2.5) as the magnet is spun about its axis. As indicated in Fig. 4.12, the primary cooling source for the magnet may be provided by a stationary cryocooler placed ∼1 m away from the magnet. Each numbered component of the system is given in the figure caption. Stated briefly, the system permits the magnet/cryostat assembly (component 2 in Fig. 4.12) to be spun as a flow of liquid helium is continuously transferred to the magnet cryostat, through the spinning shaft, at a mass flow rate of m ˙ he from a “mini” helium liquefier, whose primary source of refrigeration is a cryocooler housed in the second cryostat (14). The thermodynamics of this cryocooler-based mini liquefier is the focus of this problem.
9
11
10
8
6 7 4
6
5 4
3 13 2 14
∼1.5 m
12
1 75-mmφ RT bore
Fig. 4.12 Schematic of a superconducting magnet system that incorporates a cryocooler-based “mini” helium liquefier, here, as applied to a slow MAS (magic angle spinning) NMR system, in which a persistent-mode superconducting magnet that generates a magnetic field directed 54.73◦ (magic angle) from the axis of rotation is cooled by liquid helium, continuously transferred, from the cryocooled-based mini liquefier, to the rotating magnet/cryostat assembly. 1: earth field compensation coils (stationary); 2: magnet/cryostat assembly; 3: driving motor; 4: bearing(s); 5: shaft; 6: swivel joint(s); 7: slip ring; 8: supporting triple; 9: LHe transfer line; 10: He recovery line; 11: warm helium return; 12: compressor; 13: cold trap; 14: cryocooled-based mini liquefier.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
243
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.2: Cryocooler-based “mini” helium liquefier (continuation) a a
j
j
Heat Exchanger 1 1st Stage Cryocooler
i
Q1 c
i
Q2 2nd Stage
Fig. 4.13
b
d
Heat Exchanger 2 h
e
f g J-T Valve Schematic drawing of a cryocooler-based mini helium liquefier.
Figure 4.13 shows schematic details of the mini liquefier, comprising the warm-tocold stream (mass flow rate m ˙ he ; pressure 10 atm) and cold-to-warm helium vapor stream (m ˙ v ; 1 atm), and the 1st and 2nd stages of a cryocooler as cooling sources. The processes are assumed “ideal,” e.g., no pressure drop; perfect heat exchange with no temperature difference between the two streams. Warm-to-Cold Helium Stream—Indicated by solid arrows in Fig. 4.13 Point a. Mini Liquefier entrance, from Cold trap (13 in Fig. 4.12): Ta = 295 K; Pa = 10 atm (1 MPa). Point a. Heat Exchanger 1 entrance: thermodynamically identical to Point a. Point b. Heat Exchanger 1 exit (1st Stage entrance): Tb . Point c. Heat Exchanger 2 entrance (1st Stage exit): Tc . Between Points b and c, the 1st Stage extracts Q1 from the helium stream. Point d. Heat Exchanger 2 exit (2nd Stage entrance): Td . Point e. 2nd Stage exit (J-T Valve entrance): Te . Between Points d and e, the 2nd Stage extracts Q2 from the helium stream. Point f.
˙ v; m ˙ p (liquefaction mass J-T Valve exit: Tf = 4.22 K; Pf = 1 atm; m rate). LHe to Point g, indicated by the dotted arrow.
Cold-to-Warm Helium Stream—Indicated by dashed arrows in Fig. 4.13 Point g. To LHe transfer line (9 in Fig. 4.12): Tg = 4.22 K; Pg = 1 atm; m ˙ . ˙ v and m ˙ r = Point h. Heat Exchanger 2 entrance: Th = 4.22 K; Ph = 1 atm; m m ˙ p − m ˙ (LHe return mass rate). Point i.
Heat Exchanger 2 exit: Ti = Tc ; Pi = 1 atm.
Point i. Heat Exchanger 1 entrance: thermodynamically identical to Point i. Point j.
Heat Exchanger 1 exit: Tj = 295 K; Pj = 1 atm.
Point j. To warm helium exit line (10 in Fig. 4.12).
244
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.2: Cryocooler-based “mini” helium liquefier (continuation) ˙ he = a) Show that to achieve a helium liquefaction rate, m ˙ p 0.202 g/s with m 1.0 g/s through the J-T process, Te = 7 K (and Pe = 10 atm) at Point e. b) For Td = 8 K (and Pd = 10 atm), compute Q2 (at 7 K), the 2nd stage refrigeration power of the cryocooler. Note that Te = 7 K (and Pe = 10 atm). c) For a cryocooler with Q2 (at 7 K), what would its Q2 at 4.22 K be? d) For Tb = 46 K and Tc = 30 K (and Pb = Pc = 10 atm), compute Q1 (at 30 K), the 1st stage refrigeration power. e) Assuming that Heat Exchanger 2 is “ideal,” i.e., no heat loss to its environment and the heat transfer between the warm-to-cold stream (of m ˙ he = 1.0 g/s) and the cold-to-warm stream (of m ˙ v and m ˙ r ) is perfect, show that m ˙ r = 0.158 g/s and hence m ˙ = 0.044 g/s. Assume Tc = Td = 30 K. f ) Similarly, show that the perfect heat transfer in Heat Exchanger 1 between the two streams is consistent with m ˙ r = 0.158 g/s. Assume that Tb = 46 K, Ti = 30 K, and Ta = Tj = 295 K. g) Applying Eq. 4.10, compute the isentropic (constant entropy) power requirement, Ps , of Compressor (12, Fig. 4.12) to boost the warm helium flow of m ˙ he = 1.0 g/s from Pj = 1 atm to Pa = 10 atm.
Sir James Dewar (1842–1923) — Passage from Isaac Asimov’s Asimov’s Biographical Encyclopedia of Science and Technology [4.27] His interest (in the field of extremely low temperatures) was kindled in the 1870s, when Cailletet and Pictet simultaneously and independently announced the liquefaction of gasses such as oxygen, nitrogen, and carbon monoxide and attained temperatures less than eighty degrees above the absolute zero. In 1892 he constructed double-walled flasks with a vacuum between the walls. The vacuum would not transmit heat by conduction or by the convection of air currents. It would do so only by radiation. By silvering the walls so that radiation heat would be reflected rather than absorbed, Dewar cut down on that variety of heat transmission as well. . . .Such flasks are called Dewar flasks and have been adapted to everyday uses, for keeping hot coffee hot during trips, for instance, or keeping cold milk cold (since heat transfer is barred in either direction). The home variety of the Dewar flask is better known as a Thermos bottle. Dewar then began to experiment with hydrogen, which still resisted liquefaction. He made use of the Joule-Thomson effect (see DISCUSSION 4.6), first discovered by Joule and Kelvin to produce low temperatures, as Cailletet and Pictet had done, but used the system of regeneration that Linde had introduced. He built a large-scale machine in which this process could be carried out more extensively and efficiently than ever before. . . .hydrogen was liquefied in 1898 and solidified in 1899. In this way Dewar reached a temperature of only fourteen degrees above absolute zero. At this temperature, all substances were reduced to a solid state, except for a new gas, helium, that had just been discovered (on earth) by Ramsay and that, at that temperature, was not even liquefied. It resisted all efforts at liquefaction for another decade, when Kamerlingh-Onnes finally succeeded (in 1908).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
245
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.2 a) Because in a J-T process, enthalpy remains constant, the following enthalpy equality relationship holds: hhe (7 K,10 atm) = x h (4.22 K,1 atm) + (1 − x )hv (4.22 K,1 atm)
(S2.1)
where hhe (7 K,10 atm) = 26.00 J/g is helium enthalpy at 7 K and 10 atm; x is the liquid mass fraction at 4.22 K and 1 atm; h (4.22 K,1 atm) = 9.71 J/g is liquid helium enthalpy at 4.22 K and 1 atm; and hv (4.22 K,1 atm) = 30.13 J/g is vapor helium enthalpy at 4.22 K and 1 atm. Solving Eq. S2.1, we find: hhe (7 K,10 atm) − hv (4.22 K,1 atm) x = h (4.22 K,1 atm) − hv (4.22 K,1 atm) =
(26.00 J/g − 30.13 J/g) = 0.202 (9.71 J/g − 30.13 J/g)
(S2.2)
˙ p = 0.202 g/s and m ˙ v = 0.798 g/s for m ˙ he = 1.0 g/s. With x = 0.202, m b)
The following power equation applies between Points d and e: m ˙ he hhe (8 K,10 atm) = Q2 + m ˙ he hhe (7 K,10 atm)
(S2.3)
Solving Eq. S2.3 for Q2 , we find: ˙ he [hhe (8 K,10 atm) − hhe (7 K,10 atm)] Q2 = m = (1 g/s)(33.44 J/g − 26.00 J/g) = 7.44 W c) The performance data of a 2-stage cryocooler shown in Fig. 4.6, indicate that this cryocooler with a refrigeration capacity of 1 W at 4.2 K delivers a cooling power of 4 W at 7 K. Thus a cryocooler with a capacity of 7.44 W at 7 K would most likely deliver a cooling power of ∼2 W at 4.2 K. Cryocoolers with a cooling power of ∼2 W at 4.22 K are expected to be commercially available by ∼2010. d) An equation similar to Eq. S2.3 may be applied between Points b and c: ˙ he hhe (30 K,10 atm) m ˙ he hhe (46 K,10 atm) = Q1 + m
(S2.4)
From Eq. S2.4 we find: ˙ he [hhe (46 K,10 atm) − hhe (30 K,10 atm)] Q1 = m = (1 g/s)(252 J/g − 168 J/g) 84 W The performance data of Fig. 4.6 indicate that Q1 84 W is not achievable with a cryocooler having the performance data of Fig. 4.6 even if its 4.22-K performance is increased to 2 W. A cryocooler with an enhanced 2nd stage refrigeration power will be required. e) The total enthalpy decrease of the warm-to-cold stream from Points c to d must be equal to the total enthalpy increase of the cold-to-warm stream from Points h to i: m ˙ he [hhe (30 K,10 atm) − hhe (8 K,10 atm)]
˙ r )hv (30 K,1 atm) − m ˙ v hv (4.22 K,1 atm) + m ˙ r hl (4.22 K,1 atm) = (m ˙ v +m (S2.5)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
246
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.2 (Continuation) Solving Eq. S2.5 for m ˙ r , we find:
m ˙ he [hhe (30 K,10 atm)−hhe (8 K,10 atm)] −m ˙ v [hv (30 K,1 atm)−hv (4.22 K,1 atm)] m ˙ r = hv (30 K,1 atm)−hl (4.22 K,1 atm) =
(1 g/s)(168.4 J/g−33.44 J/g)−(0.798 g/s)(170.2 J/g−30.13 J/g) 0.144 g/s (170.2 J/g − 9.71 J/g)
Because m ˙=m ˙ p − m ˙ r , we find: m ˙ 0.202 g/s − 0.144 g/s = 0.058 g/s, which translates to a liquid volume rate of ∼1.7 liters/h and a cooling power of 1.2 W. f ) The thermal power loss of the warm-to-cold stream from Points a to b equals the thermal power increase of the cold-to-warm stream from Points i to j: m ˙ he [hhe (295 K,10 atm) − hhe (46 K,10 atm)] ˙ r ) hv (295 K,1 atm) − hv (30 K,1 atm) = (m ˙ v +m
(S2.6)
The left-hand side of Eq. S2.6 is given by: m ˙ he [hhe (295 K,10 atm) − hhe (46 K,10 atm)] = (1 g/s)(1550.0 J/g − 253.9 J/g) 1296 W
(S2.7a)
Similarly, the right-hand side of Eq. S2.6 is given by: (m ˙ v +m ˙ r )[hhe (295 K,1 atm) − hhe (30 K,1 atm)] (0.798 g/s + 0.144 g/s)(1547.0 J/g − 170.2 J/g) 1297 W/s
(S2.7b)
Equations. S2.7a and S2.7b are equal, within round-off errors of ∼0.1 %. g) Applying Eq. 4.10, we obtain an ideal compressor power requirement, Ps : γ−1 γ Pa γ ˙h Ps = m (Pj vj) −1 (S2.8) γ−1 Pj γ = Cp /Cv for a perfect gas is 5/3; vi is the specific volume at the compressor inlet of Pj = 1 atm, which for helium at 295 K is 6 m3/kg. With Pj = 1 atm 1×105 Pa, Pa /Pj = 10, and m ˙ h = 0.001 kg/s (1 g/s), we obtain: Ps = 2.3 kW (or ∼3 hp, horsepower). Note that this is for an ideal case; the power requirement for a real pump would be roughly 7 kW. Of course in a real mini helium liquefier, the liquid yield, because chiefly of “imperfection” of the heat exchangers and pressure drops in both the warm-to-cold and cold-to-warm helium streams, would be smaller than that of an “ideal” liquefier: m ˙ p (and thus m ˙ ) will be off by a factor of perhaps as much as two, respectively, from 0.202 g/s (∼6 liters/h) and 0.058 g/s (∼1.7 liter/h) computed above.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
247
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.7: Cryocooler vs. “Cryocirculator” Two cooling sources for “dry” (cryogen-free) magnets are discussed here. Cryocooler Currently, all dry (cryogenfree) magnets, LTS or HTS, are cryocooled, i.e., cooled by a cryocooler, whose coldhead is attached to one end of the cryostat assembly of the magnet. Figure 4.14 shows a schematic drawing of a cryocooled dry magnet: the 1st stage of the coldhead is thermally attached to the radiation shield and the 2nd stage to the magnet chamber. For “large” dry LTS magnets, it will be a challenge to satisfy the tenet of LTS magnet stability, i.e., ΔTop /Top 0, where ΔTop is the temperature difference between the coldest spot (near the 2nd stage) and the warmest spot (furthest from the 2nd stage).
CRYOCOOLER COLDHEAD 1st STAGE RADIATION SHIELDS 2nd STAGE MAGNET CHAMBER Top MAGNET
Top +ΔTop
Fig. 4.14 Schematic drawing of a cryocooled dry magnet.
“Cryocirculator” To keep the magnet temperature uniform, ΔTop /Top 0, a “cryocirculator” is preferable to a cryocooler for dry superconducting magnets. As illustrated schematically in Fig. 4.15, a cryocirculator is a 2-stage cryocooler equipped with a cold helium circulator for each stage. Each circulator forces a stream of cold, high-pressure helium through a cooling coil (sometimes embossed, as illustrated in Fig. 4.15) over the surface of a radiation shield wall or magnet chamber walls. The cryocirculator has two advantages over the cryocooler: 1) it provides cooling over most of the magnet chamber surface area, enabling a magnet, regardless of its size, to satisfy the condition of ΔTop /Top 0, though for HTS magnets, ΔTop may easily exceed 1 K; and 2) the cooling source and the magnet cryostat, connected by flexible helium lines, may easily be decoupled. One early application of a cryocirculator is the Hybrid III magnet [3.14]. The radiation shields of its cryostat are maintained at their operating temperatures, one circulator keeping one set of embossed radiation shields at 90 K and the other circulator keeps another set—for the 1.8-K magnet cryostat—at 20 K. MAGNET
CRYOCIRCULATOR CIRCULATOR
RADIATION SHIELD LOAD
1st STAGE
CIRCULATOR MAGNET CHAMBER LOAD
2nd STAGE
ΔTop/Top 0
EMBOSSED RADIATION SHIELD WALLS EMBOSSED MAGNET CHAMBER WALLS
Fig. 4.15
Schematic drawing of a cryocirculator-cooled magnet.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
248
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.8: Radiative Heat Transfer* Here, we discuss heat input to a cryostat by radiation. The Hybrid III cryostat is used as an example. The theory of radiative heat transfer begins with the Stefan-Boltzmann equation: (4.15) qr = r σT 4 qr is the radiative heat flux [W/m2 ] from a surface at temperature T [K]. r is the total emissivity at T . σ is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, 5.67×10−8 W/m2 K4 . What makes computation of radiation heat input to a cryostat usually less straightforward than suggested by Eq. 4.15 is the task of determining the correct value of r for each of the two surfaces that are radiating heat. For a configuration of parallel plates with emissivities of cl and wm , respectively, with one surface at cold temperature Tcl and the other at warm temperature Twm , the effective total emissivity, r , is given by:
r =
cl wm
cl + wm − cl wm
(4.16)
Although theory distinguishes among “parallel-plate,” “cylindrical,” and “spherical” configurations, in most cryostat applications the parallel-plate equations suffice for all three geometries. (Nonparallel-plate configurations usually have surfaces of different areas.) This is because: 1) in most cryostats, the distance separating the two surfaces is generally much less than dimensions along the surface; and 2) the error that would be introduced in an estimate of radiative heat input through this geometric approximation is still likely to be considerably less than that introduced by uncertainties associated with the emissivities of the surfaces in question. Equation 4.15 is thus modified to: 4 − Tcl4 ) qr = r σ(Twm
(4.17)
Table 4.8 gives “typical” values of r and qr for combinations of materials and two temperature ranges, from Twm to Tcl : Twm → Tcl . Illustration Here we first compute the total heat input to the Hybrid III magnet vessel at 4.2 K by radiation from the 20-K and 80-K shields. The magnet vessel surface areas, both of mechanically polished stainless steel, are: 1) 7.3 m2 facing the 20-K radiation shields; 2) 2.8 m2 facing the 80-K radiation shields. To simplify the computation, we apply the parallel-plate model of Eq. 4.17 and use the same cold-temperature surface areas for respective warm-temperature areas. Using appropriate values of qr given in Table 4.8 for the mechanically polished stainless steel surface, we have: 20-K panels to vessel: Qr (0.4×10−3 W/m2 )(7.3 m2 ) 3 mW 80-K panels to vessel: Qr (162×10−3 W/m2 )(2.8 m2 ) = 454 mW
* Based on Problem 4.8 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
249
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.8: Radiative Heat Transfer (continuation) Table 4.8: Typical Values of Radiative Heat Flux [4.28] Material Copper as received
mechanically polished Stainless steel as received
mechanically polished electropolished
Aluminum as received
mechanically polished electropolished
Superinsulation
Twm → Tcl [K]
r
qr [mW/m2 ]
20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80 20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80
0.03 0.06 0.12 0.01 0.02 0.06
0.3 140 55,000 0.1 46 27,000
20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80 20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80 20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80
0.06 0.12 0.34 0.04 0.07 0.12 0.03 0.06 0.10
0.54 280 155,000 0.4 162 55,000 0.3 140 46,000
20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80 20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80 20 → 4 80 → 4 300 → 80
0.04 0.07 0.49 0.03 0.06 0.10 0.02 0.03 0.08
0.4 162 224,000 0.3 140 46,000 0.2 70 37,000
20 → 4 80 → 20 300 → 80
≤ 10* 40* 60*
2†‡ 40† 2,500†
* Number of layers in a 25-mm “vacuum” gap. † Measured values (Bascu˜ n´ an [4.19]). ‡ In the 4–20 K range, layers of superinsulation are not effective—in comparison, see qr = 0.2 mW/m2 for electropolished aluminum listed 3 lines above. A 250˚ A thick aluminum coating on each side of superinsulation is too thin compared with the wave lengths of radiation in the 4–20 K range for superinsulation layers to be effective. Instead, one layer of aluminum foil, ∼100-μm thick, may be used to emulate an electropolished aluminum surface.
Answer to TRIVIA 4.2 The French chemist Georges Claude (1870–1960) showed that electric discharge through inert gases could produce light, the start of neon lights, making him rich; now more well-known as the developer of an eponymous refrigeration cycle.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
250
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.8: Radiative Heat Transfer (continuation) We may also compute the heat input to the 80-K radiation shield facing the 300K surface; the total area of the 80-K panels facing the 300-K surface is 11.7 m2 . Again, we assume the parallel-plate geometry, i.e., the total 300-K surface facing the 80-K panels is also 11.7 m2 . Using appropriate values of qr given in Table 4.8 for the mechanically polished stainless steel surface, we have: 300-K to 80-K panels: Qr (55 W/m2 )(11.7 m2 ) = 644 W A. Effect of Superinsulation Layers As may be noted from Table 4.8, the largest radiative heat load to a cryostat is from the 80-K shield, which receives heat from the 300-K surface. Thus, it is customary to place a number of 0.5-μm aluminum coated Mylar sheets—superinsulation— in the vacuum space (< 10−4 torr) between the 80-K and 300-K surfaces. The presence of Ni superinsulation layers modifies Eq. 4.17 roughly to:
r 4 qr = σ(Twm − Tcl4 ) (4.18) Ni + 1 Equation 4.18 indicates that even one superinsulation layer reduces qr by a factor of two. A rule of thumb is to use about 10–20 layers for each 1-cm spacing. Also, to minimize solid conduction paths, each superinsulation sheet should be installed either crinkled or, if smooth, with thin insulating spacers between adjacent layers of superinsulation. (The bottom three rows of Table 4.8 give measured values of qr for layers of superinsulation in the three temperature ranges.) B. Practical Considerations of Emissivity It is important to note that radiation is an electromagnetic phenomenon: emissivity r increases with “surface” electrical resistivity of the material. The material’s emissivity is thus affected in the same way as the material’s surface electrical resistivity. Thus, we may list the following rules of thumb on emissivity: • For the same temperature range, r values of copper are smaller than those of aluminum, which in turn are smaller than those of stainless steel. • For the same surface, r decreases with temperature; r for copper decreases more markedly than for stainless steel. • r of metal is more sensitive to surface contamination than that of nonconductive material. Contamination includes oxidation and alloying. • Mechanical polishing sometimes improves (decreases) r and sometimes degrades (increases) r . If an oxide layer on a conductive metal’s surface is removed by mechanical polishing, the result is an improvement. If the metal’s resistivity is increased by work-hardening, the result is degradation. “We may not arrive at our port within a calculable period, but we would preserve the true course.” —Henry D. Thoreau
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
251
DISCUSSION 4.9: Convective Heat Transfer by Residual Gas* Residual gas transfers heat within the “vacuum” space of a cryostat. In cryostats for LTS magnets, the only residual gas is helium. In cryostats for HTS magnets operating above 20 K, hydrogen, outgassed from the surfaces of the structural components of the cryostats, metals and nonmetals, is the chief residual gas. A. “High” Pressure Limit When the pressure of a gas is sufficiently high, its mean free path (λg ) is much shorter than the typical distance (d) separating the two surfaces at different temperatures in a cryostat. Under this condition of λg d, the thermal conductivity of a gas (kg ), according to the kinetic theory, is proportional only to the mean √ velocity (¯ v ) of the molecules, which in turn varies as T . The important point here is that when λg d, kg is independent of gas pressure, Pg . The kinetic theory also shows that λg ∝ η/Pg , where η is the gas viscosity. At T = 300 K and Pg = 760 torr (1 atm), λg 0.2 μm for helium and 0.1 μm for hydrogen. Thus, the condition λg d is clearly satisfied in this “high” pressure limit. At a “vacuum” pressure of Pg <∼10−4 torr, however, the condition λg d is violated by both gases. B. “Low” Pressure Limit At Pg of ∼ 10−4 torr or less, kg becomes directly proportional to Pg . For a parallelplate configuration of a cold plate at Tcl and a warm plate at Twm , the heat flux, qg , by a “residual” gas at pressure Pg may be given by [4.29]: qg = ηg Pg (Twm − Tcl )
(4.19)
ηg depends not only on Twm and Tcl but also on accommodation coefficients, which range from 0.3 for He and H2 at 300 K to 1 for He at 4.2 K and 0.6 for H2 at 20 K. Table 4.9 presents values of ηg and qg for He and H2 at Pg = 10−5 torr (1.33 mPa) across two parallel plates at Tcl and Twm [4.29]. Illustration The principal surface areas, approximated at 4.2 K (Tcl ), of the magnet vessel of Hybrid III are 7.3 m2 facing the 20-K (Twm ) radiation shields, and 2.8 m2 facing the 80-K (Twm ) radiation shields. Using the “parallel-plates” approximation, we may compute the total heat input into the Hybrid III magnet vessel by residual helium gas of pressure 10−5 torr in the vacuum space. For a magnet vessel surface at 4.2 K exposed to 20-K radiation shields, qg at Pg = 10−5 torr is, from Table 4.9, 27 mW/m2 . Thus, for a surface area of 7.3 m2 under the parallel-plates approximation, the total heat input becomes ≈ 300 mW. Similarly, for a magnet vessel surface at 4.2 K exposed to 80-K radiation shields, qg is, from Table 4.9, 86 mW/m2 , or a total heat input of ≈ 240 mW for a surface area of 2.8 m2 . Thus the combined heat input to the magnet vessel becomes ≈ 540 mW, which for this system would be excessive; a vacuum level of 10−6 torr should be maintained. It is therefore important to keep the cryostat vacuum pressure to better (i.e., less) than ∼10−5 torr. * Based on Problem 4.7 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
252
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.9: Convective Heat Transfer by Residual Gas (continuation) Table 4.9: Heat Conduction by Residual He and H2 Gases at Pg of 10−5 Torr [4.29] Twm → Tcl [K]
Helium ηg [W/m2 Pa K]
qg [mW/m2 ]
Twm → Tcl [K]
Hydrogen ηg [W/m2 Pa K]
qg [mW/m2 ]
20 → 4 80 → 4.2 300 → 4.2 300 → 80
1.27 0.85 0.64 0.44
27 86 251 129
— 80 → 20 300 → 20 300 → 80
— 2.20 1.32 1.02
— 176 494 298
DISCUSSION 4.10: Vacuum Pumping System Figure 4.16 shows a schematic diagram of a typical vacuum system used in the operation of a superconducting magnet. The cryostat vacuum space outlet is connected to a turbomolecular pump, which in the past decade has begun replacing the once widely used diffusion pump/cold trap combination. The turbomolecular pump is the only purely mechanical vacuum pump that can function down to a pressure range of 10−10 torr without requiring a trap. Although the “turbo” pump is equipped with its own mechanical pump, in most magnet applications where the cryostat vacuum space can be quite large, a separate mechanical pump is added, as shown in the figure. The procedure used to evacuate the cryostat vacuum space is to start with the mechanical pumps(s) to reach a vacuum of ∼5 torr, and then to turn on the turbo pump (or a diffusion/cold trap), to reach 10−5 –10−6 torr.
VACUUM GAUGE
TURBOMOLECULAR PUMP
CRYOSTAT
MECHANICAL PUMP
Fig. 4.16 Schematic diagram of a typical pumping vacuum system used in the operation of a superconducting magnet.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
253
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.10: Vacuum Pumping System (continuation) Vacuum Gauges Two types of vacuum gauges are commonly used for cryostats: 1) thermocouple; and 2) ionization. Below is a brief description of each type. Thermocouple: The thermocouple gauge relies on the pressure dependance of the gas thermal conductivity, valid in the “low” pressure limit discussed above. The thermocouple junction is situated in a tube connected to the vacuum space to be measured, and its temperature is set by a heater. The gas provides cooling, which varies with the gas pressure; the change in the induced current through the junction circuit is a measure of the vacuum pressure. The gauge’s range of applicability is 10−3 ∼1 torr, the range covered by mechanical pumps. Ionization: For the vacuum range between ∼10−6 and ∼10−3 torr, the operating range in most cryostats, the ionization gauge is used most widely. There are two versions: 1) hot-cathode; and 2) cold-cathode. Hot-Cathode: This gauge consists of a heated filament (hot cathode), an anode, and a negatively biased ion collector plate, all housed in a tube that connects to the vacuum space to be measured. The electrons flowing from the filament to the anode collide with gas molecules, creating ionized molecules that are drawn to the collector plate and measured as a current through the measurement circuit. Because the molecules are ionized by electrons, the ion current depends also on the number of electrons bombarding the molecules: accurate pressure measurement thus requires careful control of filament current. The hot-cathode gauge used in the Hybrid III cryostat is turned off during magnet operation to minimize “filament fatigue” caused by the filament’s oscillating motion that results from the Lorentz interaction of the filament supply current (60 Hz) and the magnet’s fringing field. Cold-Cathode: Known as the Philips (or Penning) gauge, it uses a cold cathode and two parallel anode plates with a magnetic field applied in the direction normal to the anode plates, which are turned on (∼2 kV) one at a time. The small number of electrons produced by the cold cathode are thus made to travel in a helical path alternately toward one of the two plates. This configuration effectively increases the collision chances between the small number of electrons and gas molecules. Unlike hot filaments, cold cathodes do not contaminate the gas nor are they destroyed in the event of a loss of vacuum, but they are less accurate than hot-cathodes.
TRIVIA 4.3 Of the four contemporary physicists (born 1602–1627) below, who first achieved, in 1650, a vacuum by means of an air pump? i) Boyle;
ii) Guericke;
iii) Pascal;
iv) Torricelli.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
254
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.11: Cryocooled Solid Cryogen/Magnet A. Design and Operation Concept Generally, a superconducting magnet, LTS or HTS, remains fully superconducting and operates “stably” over a temperature range from its nominal operating temperature Top to a maximum operating temperature. Chiefly because of a much greater critical temperature, Tc , of HTS compared with that of LTS, this range, ΔTop , is an order of magnitude greater for an HTS magnet than an LTS magnet of comparable size and field performance: typically ΔTop > 1 K for HTS, while ΔTop < 1 K for LTS. (This concept of “temperature margin” for LTS and HTS magnets is discussed in CHAPTER 6 .) A design/operation concept developed at FBML recognizes this large ΔTop of HTS magnets and combines it with the large heat capacity of solid cryogen [4.30– 4.32]. In this design/operation concept, ΔTop is no longer considered a transitory excursion permitted in LTS magnets, but a new opportunity for a magnet. This combination of an expanded operating range, possible primarily with HTS but not altogether impossible with LTS, and an enhanced heat capacity offers operating options, an example of which is described below, that are infeasible with “conventional” design/operation concepts, i.e., “dry,” cryocooled but without solid cryogen, or “wet,” immersed in a bath of cryogen or force-cooled by cryogen. Note that even for a solid cryogen-cooled magnet, the primary cooling source is a cryocooler or a cryocirculator (DISCUSSION 4.7 ). Typically, such a magnet is surrounded by a volume of solid cryogen and housed in a magnet chamber. Application to Persistent-Mode Magnets One application of this design/operation concept is in constant-field magnets such as for NMR and MRI that normally operate in persistent mode. With the magnet’s operating temperature designed to span a “large” range, this concept enables such a magnet to maintain a constant operating field over a design-specified period of time even after its primary cooling source is turned off and thermally decoupled from the cold body. The cooling source may be turned off intentionally, e.g., to create a measurement environment free of the cooling source vibration or for cooling source maintenance, or under fault mode, e.g., a power outage. B. Thermal Diffusion in Solid In a homogeneous isotropic solid (density, , thermal conductivity, k, and specific heat, cp ) the rate of thermal diffusion through the solid is characterized by its thermal diffusivity, Dth [m2/s], given by: Dth =
k cp
(4.20)
The time scale required for transient heating applied at one location to “reach” a distance δsd in the solid thus is given by: 2 1 δsd τsd = (4.21) Dth π
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
255
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.11: Cryocooled Solid Cryogen/Magnet (continuation) Table 4.10: Approximate Values of Dth and τsd (for δsd = 10 mm) Solid Neon (SNe), Solid Nitrogen (SN2 ), Copper (Cu) in the 4–60 K Range T [K]
SNe
Dth [mm2/s] SN2
5 10 20 30 34* 37* 40 50 60
35 22 0.27 — — — — — —
157 70 0.58 0.22 0.16 0.18 0.17 0.13 0.12
Cu 0.36×106 0.17×106 0.29×105 8000 5000 3500 2800 1200 600
τsd [s] for δsd = 10 mm SNe SN2 Cu 0.29 0.46 38 — — — — — —
0.06 0.14 17 46 63 56 60 78 84
27×10−6 60×10−6 0.3×10−3 1.3×10−3 2×10−3 3×10−3 4×10−3 8×10−3 17×10−3
* At 35.61 K, as described in 4.5, SN2 undergoes a solid-to-solid phase transition and Dth = 0, because at this temperature the SN2 ’s heat capacity approaches infinity.
Table 4.10 lists approximate values of Dth and corresponding τsd for δsd = 10 mm for solid neon (SNe), solid nitrogen (SN2 ), and copper (Cu) in the range 4–60 K, based on (T ), cp (T ), and k(T ) data [4.33–4.35]. Over this temperature range thermal diffusivities of SN2 are 3 to 5 orders of magnitude less than those of copper—heat penetrates into SN2 much more slowly than into copper. For example, at 30 K, as given in Table 4.10 for δsd = 10 mm, τsd = 46 s in SN2 , whereas it is only 1.3 ms for Cu. However, SN2 can absorb much more heat per unit volume than Cu. “Slow” Heating If the heat required to be absorbed by a volume of solid cryogen of a “reasonable” thermal diffusion distance can be absorbed gradually, over a period of time much longer than τsd , the entire solid will remain nearly uniform in temperature. Indeed, as noted above, solid cryogen appears best applied to magnets that are generally operated in persistent mode such as those for MRI and NMR. As studied in PROBLEM 4.3 below, in a solid-cryogen-cooled magnet which has a heating time of hours over a diffusion distance of 1–2 cm, the entire solid-nitrogen volume may be assumed to be at a uniform temperature. Transient Heating Under rapid transient conditions only a very thin layer of solid cryogen—note that √ δsd ∝ τsd (from Eq. 4.21)—is effective in absorbing heat that would otherwise heat the magnet winding. Even with this limitation, and despite the probable occurrence of “thermal dry-out” (below), SN2 has proven effective in suppressing temperature rises in HTS test samples subjected to transient heating [4.36, 4.37]. Recently, a group in Kyoto University has shown that a phenomenon they term “thermal dry-out” occurs, creating a “large” temperature gap across the contact between the transiently heated surface and solid nitrogen [4.38–4.40]. Thermal dry-out and a solution to overcome this phenomenon are discussed below.
256
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.12: Cryocooled Solid Cryogen/Magnet (continuation)
Temperature [K]
30 29 SN2 ONLY
28 27
SN2 -LNe MIXTURE
26 25
0
100
200
300 Time [s]
400
500
600
Fig. 4.17 Temperature vs. time plots of an HTS strip under over-current disturbances. Solid curve: with the HTS strip cooled by SN2 only; dashed: with the strip cooled by an SN2 -LNe mixture; dotted: initial temperature at 25.1 K [4.38–4.40].
C. “Thermal Dry-Out” Nakamura and his colleagues in Kyoto University have experimentally demonstrated that when the surface in thermal contact with SN2 is subjected to a “large” heating flux, thermal dry-out occurs [4.38–4.40]. For solid nitrogen at 60 K, for example, a thermal dry-out begins at a power flux of ∼1.5 W/cm2 . Apparently, a thin vapor layer at the interface is responsible for this temperature discontinuity. Figure 4.17 shows temperature vs. time plots for an HTS strip under over-current disturbances, each disturbance lasting up to ∼600 s. The solid curve corresponds to a typical run for the strip in contact with solid nitrogen only. The dotted horizontal line, at 25.1 K, indicates the initial temperature of both the strip and solid nitrogen. Beyond ∼400 s, at which the heat flux is 14.3 W/cm2 with a temperature difference (ΔT ) in excess of 3 K, a thermal runaway occurs that, were the over-current to persist, would lead to conductor damage. Solid Nitrogen-Liquid Neon Mixture To Suppress Thermal Dry-Out The Kyoto group has demonstrated that a mixture of solid nitrogen and liquid neon—liquid neon occupying ∼1% of the total volume—is quite effective in suppressing this thermal dry-out. Of course the use of LNe restricts operation to a narrow range, between 24.5 and 27.1 K under atmospheric pressure. The dashed curve in Fig. 4.17 corresponds to a typical run for the strip in contact with an SN2 -LNe mixture. Even after repeated over-current runs, it was observed that the strip temperature remained at 26.9 K, anchored by LNe. Note that here ΔT < 2 K; more importantly, at least for up to 600 s, there appears to be no imminent thermal runaway. (Note that in both sets of measurements, the “cold body” was continuously cooled by a cryocooler, which acted as the system’s cold sink.) For applications in the liquid nitrogen temperature range, perhaps a mixture of solid argon (SAr) and subcooled liquid nitrogen operating in the range 65–77 K may be an effective option to improve the solid cryogen’s inherently poor thermal contact characteristics. Argon melts at 83.8 K and boils at 87.3 K.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
257
PROBLEM 4.3: Solid cryogen cooled magnet Here, we deal with issues on solid cryogen cooled magnets. a) Using Cp vs. T plots shown in Fig. 4.2, make T (t) plots of volumes, each 1 liter, of Cu, Pb, SNe, and SN2 , under 1-W heat input for an initial temperature of 4 K and a final temperature of 60 K, except for SNe, 25 K. Assume uniformity of temperature within each volume during the warm-up. b) Using the T (t) plot for SN2 of a)—or straight from Fig. 4.2—show that it takes ∼30 hours for a 15-liter volume of SN2 to warm up from 10 K to 15 K under a constant heat input of 0.25 W. Neglect heat capacities of other materials, including that of the magnet, in the cold body and assume temperature uniformity within the solid nitrogen during the warm-up. As discussed in DISCUSSION 4.11, it is desirable for a solid cryogen cooled magnet to be able to operate over a temperature range considerably greater than the ∼1 K (or even less) typical for LTS magnets. In an SN2 -cooled HTS magnet operating in persistent mode, for example, a typical operating mode might be to operate at a nominal temperature of 10 K with its cooling source running. When the cooling source is shut off, either purposely to eliminate its noise or accidentally by a power outage, and it is thermally decoupled from the cold body, the magnet will start warming up slowly, keeping its operating field over a temperature rise of ΔTop , which is 5 K for this particular magnet. Note that in order to take full advantage of this large heat capacity of solid cryogen available in the cold body, it is required to design the system to have the cold body automatically decoupled thermally from the cooling source whenever it is turned off. c) This 15-liter volume of solid nitrogen is to be placed inside the cold body to encircle a magnet of 896-mm winding o.d. (860-mm i.d.) and 300-mm winding length. Let the nitrogen be in the shape of a cylinder, ≈896-mm i.d., 300-mm long, and ΔrN2 thick. (Because the cold body is constructed of copper sheets of sufficient thickness, most heat entering the cold body from the i.d. side of the magnet flows through the walls of the cold body by conduction to the outer wall.) Compute ΔrN2 for this 15-liter SN2 and, assuming that heat entering the cold body flows through the solid nitrogen layer only in the radial direction from the outer wall of the cold body, show that the thermal diffusion time corresponding to this layer thickness is ∼0.6 s, which is much smaller than the 30-h warm-up time from 10 K to 15 K. d) Show that the 15-liter volume of cryogen in the cold body filled with solid nitrogen in b) may be halved if it is filled with solid neon. (Because the volumetric price of SN2 is at least ∼200 times less than that of SNe, nitrogen is preferred to neon unless neon is absolutely necessary.) e) Show that it takes this 15-liter SN2 another ∼80 hours to warm up from 15 K to 60 K. Over the 15–60 K temperature range, take an average heat input to the cold body of 3.3 W. Neglect the magnetic energy stored in the magnet that would presumably be converted into thermal energy when the magnet becomes warm enough to lose its superconductivity.
258
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.3: Solid cryogen cooled magnet (continuation) f ) During this warm-up process beyond 15 K, when the highest field part of the winding reaches, say 20 K, the magnet begins losing superconductivity and its field decays. For this magnet with a winding volume of 15,000 cm3 and a stored energy of 75 kJ, compute its final temperature for an initial temperature of 20 K, assuming that during this transient the entire magnetic energy is converted to heat within the winding only. Assume that the winding is at a uniform temperature at the end of energy conversion and its enthalpy may be approximated by copper’s. Note that because a total thermal energy of ∼1 MJ is absorbed by the solid nitrogen from 15 K to 60 K, it is reasonable to neglect the additional thermal energy of 75 kJ in e) above. Although the magnet is at uniform temperature except during the brief period of field decay and shortly thereafter, because the field within the winding is not uniform, quenching is not initiated simultaneously within the winding. Nevertheless, the field decay is expected to last only a few seconds—this is based on a quench analysis of a real HTS magnet. g) Show that it takes the same HTS magnet system ∼3 hours from an initial operating temperature of 30 K to a final temperature of 35 K for a constant heat input of 10 W. Assume the other assumptions in b) are valid. h) Repeat g) for the range 35–40 K for the same constant heat input of 10 W, and demonstrate that the extra enthalpy of the phase transition at 35.61 K doubles the warm-up time over the same temperature increment of 5 K. Solid nitrogen may also be used to stabilize an HTS winding subjected to transitory disturbances. Experiments have demonstrated that a thin layer (∼0.5 mm) of SN2 in contact with a Bi2223 tape indeed suppressed the conductor’s temperature rise when it was driven to the normal state by an over-current pulse imposed upon a constant transport current [4.36, 4.37]. It is because of the poor thermal diffusivity of solid nitrogen that only a thin layer (∼0.5 mm) is effective in absorbing transient power dissipation. i) Using Eq. 4.21 given in DISCUSSION 4.11, show that a transient heating of constant amplitude (square wave) and ∼0.1-s duration diffuses through a 0.4mm thick layer of SN2 , initially at 30 K, over this heating period. Although the solid nitrogen layer temperature rises during heating, use a constant value of Dth = 2.4×10−3 cm2/s at 30 K (Dth = 0.24 mm2/s in Table 4.10). j) For this 0.1-s transient heating of i), show that a power flux of 4.2 W/cm2 could be absorbed by this SN2 layer as it is heated to 35 K. k) Discuss the effectiveness of a thin layer of solid nitrogen subjected to transient heating when the heated layer must pass through the solid-to-solid phase transition at 35.61 K. As footnoted in Table 4.10, Dth of solid nitrogen at 35.61 K is theoretically 0. l) Discuss to what extent the expansion of a magnet may impact the spatial field homogeneity as the magnet warms up over its permitted operating temperature range, here between 10 K and 15 K.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
259
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.4 a) Figure 4.18 shows T (t) plots of 1-liter volumes of Cu, Pb, SNe, and SN2 , subjected to a constant heat input of 1 W with an initial temperature of 4.2 K and a final temperature of 60 K (25 K for SNe)—it also includes a dotted horizontal line at 4.2 K showing the duration required to boil off 1 liter of 4.2-K liquid helium (LHe). The figure clearly demonstrates that among these substances, at least on a volume basis SNe in the range 4–25 K and SN2 in the range 25–60 K are the best heat capacity enhancers. Because specific densities of SNe (1.25 g/cm3 at 25 K) and SN2 (1 g/cm3 at 25 K) are an order of magnitude less than those of Pb (11.4 g/cm3 ) and Cu (8.96 g/cm3 ), for the same extra volume in the cold body occupied by a heat capacity enhancer substance, either of these solid cryogens not only performs its task well but also is only a modest extra mass to the system. Because the entire warm-up (4.2 K–60 K) takes, for example, ∼18 hours for SN2 , we may safely conclude that the assumption of uniform temperature throughout the 1-liter volume of solid with a diffusion distance of ∼10 cm—(1000 cm3 )1/3 —is valid. The uniform temperature assumption is clearly valid for copper and lead. b) From Fig. 4.18 we note that for 1-liter SN2 , T (t 400 s) = 10 K and T (t 2,150 s) = 15 K. For 1-liter SN2 , we have the warm-up period from 10 K to 15 K with 1-W heat input: [Δt(10 K → 15 K)]11 W liter 1,750 s = 0.486 h. For 15-liter solid nitrogen with 0.25-W heat input, the 10-15 K warm-up period, [Δt(10 K→ W 15 K)]0.25 15liter , is given by: W [Δt(10 K→15 K)]0.25 15 liter
=
1W 0.25 W
15 liter W [Δt(10 K→15 K)]11 liter 1 liter
(4)(15)(0.486 h) = 29 h ∼ 30 h 60
Temperature [K]
50 Cu
Pb
SN2
40 30 20
SNe
10 LHe
0
0
5
10
15
20
Time [h] Fig. 4.18 T (t) plots with an initial temperature of 4.2 K and a final temperature of 60 K (25 K, SNe) for a 1-liter volume each of Cu, Pb, SNe, and SN2 subjected to a constant heat input of 1 W. The duration required to boil off 1 liter of liquid helium (LHe), ∼0.7 h, is indicated by the dotted horizontal line at 4.2 K.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
260
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.3 (continuation) 3 Alternatively, we may directly use Fig. 4.2 and compute h(15 K)−h(10 K) [J/cm ] by performing the Cp (T ) dT for SN2 between 10 K and 15 K:
h(15 K) − h(10 K)
Cp (10 K) + Cp (15 K) (15 K − 10 K) 2 (0.175 J/cm3 K + 0.475 J/cm3 K) (5 K) 2
1.625 J/cm3 Thus the 10–15 K warm-up time for 15-liter solid nitrogen with 0.25-W heat input, W [Δt(10 K→15 K)]0.25 15liter may be given by: (15000 cm3 )(1.625 J/cm3 ) 27.1 h ∼ 30 h (0.25 W)(3600 s/h)
W [Δt(10 K→15 K)]0.25 15liter =
c) The volume of solid nitrogen, VN2 , in a cylinder of i.d. D, length , and layer thickness ΔrN2 D, is: VN2 = πDΔrN2 (S3.1) With VN2 = 15000 cm3 , D = 90 cm, = 30 cm inserted in Eq. S3.1, we have: ΔrN2 =
VN2 (15000 cm3 ) = = 1.8 cm πD π(90 cm)(30 cm)
We may equate ΔrN2 = 1.8 cm to δsd of Eq. 4.21 and with Dth 55×10−2 cm2/s, a rough average value between 10 K and 15 K, solve Eq. 4.21 for τsd : τsd = =
1 Dth
δsd π
2
1 (55×10−2 cm2/s)
(4.21)
1.8 cm π
2 ∼ 0.6 s
The diffusion time of ∼0.6 s is much less than the 30-h warm-up time. Thus, the assumption of uniform temperature within this 15-liter SN2 is valid. d) We reverse the order of the two approaches to the solution given in b). Thus, using the Cp (T ) data for solid neon given in Fig. 4.2 and by taking the area underneath the Cp (T ) curve for SNe between 10 K and 15 K, we have: h(15 K) − h(10 K)
Cp (10 K) + Cp (15 K) (15 K − 10 K) 2 (0.400 J/cm3 K + 0.875 J/cm3 K) (5 K) 2
3.2 J/cm3
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
261
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.3 (continuation) For the same warm-up time from 10 K to 15 K with 0.25-W heat input for 15-liter W solid nitrogen, [Δt(10 K→15 K)]0.25 15liter 27.1 h computed in b), the volume of solid neon, VNe (10 K→15 K), is given by: VNe (10 K→15 K) =
(27.1 h)(3600 s/h)(0.25 W) (3.2 J/cm3 )(1000 cm3/liter)
7.6 liter ∼
1 2
× 15 liter
From Fig. 4.18 we note that for 1-liter solid neon, T (t 0.33 h) = 10 K and T (t 1.22 h) = 15 K, resulting in [Δt(10 K→15 K)]11 W liter 0.89 h for SNe; for 1-liter SN2 : [Δt(10 K→15 K)]11 W 0.486 h. We thus have: liter VNe (10 K→15 K) =
(0.486 h) (15 liter) 8.2 liter ∼ (0.89 h)
1 2
× (15 liter)
e) From Fig. 4.18 we note that for 1-liter solid nitrogen, T (t 0.6 h) = 15 K and T (t 17.75 h) = 60 K, or [Δt(15 K→60 K)]11 W liter 17.15 h. For an average heat input of 3.3 W and 15-liter SN2 , we have: 15 liter 1W 3.3 W W [Δt(15 K→60 K)]15liter = [Δt(15 K→60 K)]11 liter 1 liter 3.3 W (15)(0.303)(17.15 h) = 78 h ∼ 80 h f ) In this transition, an energy density of 5 J/cm3 [= (75 kJ)/(15,000 cm3 )] is injected into copper at an initial temperature of 20 K. Thus, we may determine the final temperature Tf from the following equation: Tf [Cp (T )]cu dT = 5 J/cm3 (S3.2) 20 K
From Fig. 4.2, we find Eq. S3.2 is satisfied with Tf 40 K. g) Using the Cp (T ) data for SN2 given in Fig. 4.2 and by taking the area underneath the Cp (T ) curve from 30 K to 35 K, we have: h(35 K) − h(30 K)
Cp (30 K) + Cp (35 K) (35 K − 30 K) 2 (1.24 J/cm3 K + 1.55 J/cm3 K) (5 K) 2
7.0 J/cm3 Answer to TRIVIA 4.3 ii). The German physicist Otto von Guericke (1602–1686) of “Magdeburg hemispheres” fame was the first with a pump, though the Italian physicist Evangelista Torricelli (1608–1647) achieved, in 1643, the first man-made vacuum by using a glass tube and a dish full of mercury.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
262
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.3 (continuation) We thus have: W [Δt(30 K→35 K)]10 15liter =
(15,000 cm3 )(7.0 J/cm3 ) (10 W)(3,600 s/h)
2.9 h ∼ 3 h h) We proceed as in g) except here an energy absorption at 35.61 K, Δh(35.61 K) of 8.2 J/cm3 , must be added. Also, the enthalpy area computation must be performed over two temperature ranges, 35–35.61 K and 35.61–40 K. Thus: h(40 K)−h(35 K)
Cp (35 K)+Cp (35.61 K) (35.61 K−35 K) 2 Cp (35.61 K)+Cp (40 K) +Δh(35.61 K)+ (40 K−35.61 K) 2 (1.60 J/cm3 K + 1.62 J/cm3 K) (0.6 K) 2 + 8.2 J/cm3 +
(1.29 J/cm3 K + 1.33 J/cm3 K) (4.39 K) 2
0.98 J/cm3 + 8.2 J/cm3 + 5.75 J/cm3 14.9 J/cm3 W [Δt(30 K→35 K)]10 15liter =
(15,000 cm3 )(14.9 J/cm3 ) (10 W)(3,600 s/h)
6.2 h ∼ 6 h Thus the contribution of the extra enthalpy at 35.61 K more than doubles (2.1 times) the warm-up time for the same temperature increment of 5 K. i) Equation 4.21 is used to compute τsd for Dth = 2.4 × 10−3 cm2/s and δsd = 0.04 cm and demonstrate that this τsd indeed is ∼0.1 s. Thus: 2 δsd 1 τsd = (4.21) Dth π 2 0.04 cm 1 = 0.067 s π (2.4×10−3 cm2/s) ∼ 0.1 s j) The maximum power flux, psd , that may inject energy in 0.067 s into a 0.04mm thick layer of SN2 from 30 K to 35 K may be given by: psd = [h(35 K) − h(30 K)] = (7.0 J/cm3 )
δsd τsd
(0.04 cm) = 4.2 W/cm2 (0.067 s)
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
263
Solution to PROBLEM 4.3 (continuation) k) As footnoted in Table 4.10, Dth = 0 for solid nitrogen at 35.61 K, because energy, instead of being diffused through, is absorbed by the solid—8.2 J/cm3 —as it undergoes the phase transition, i.e., SN2 heat capacity effectively approaches infinity. However, results of transient experiments [4.36, 4.37] have demonstrated an undiminished effectiveness of solid nitrogen in absorbing transient energy even over a range that spans this phase transition temperature. l) Because the impact of a winding’s temperature rise on the magnet’s spatial field homogeneity is potentially quite important for NMR and MRI applications, it is presented below in DISCUSSION 4.12.
DISCUSSION 4.12: Temperature Rise vs. Field Homogeneity For an NMR or MRI magnet spatial field homogeneity is a key design/operation issue. In this discussion, we shall qualitatively inquire to what extent a rise in an operating temperature may impact the magnet’s field spatial homogeneity as it warms up over a permitted range. Here, the range 10–15 K is used for computation. The coefficient of linear thermal expansion, α(T ), is defined by: 1 ∂L α(T ) = (4.22) L◦ ∂T P where L◦ is the initial length. The subscript P implies a constant pressure process. At low temperatures, α(T ) may be given by: (4.23) α(T ) = aT + bT 3 Based on an experimental α(T ) plot of copper in the range 0 ≤ T ≤ 50 K, we find a and b for copper: acu = 5×10−9 K−2 and bcu = 3×10−11 K−4 . For ΔTop = 5 K, between 10 K and 15 K, we may compute ΔL/L◦ for copper, (ΔL/L◦ )cu , by integrating Eq. 4.23 between 10 K and 15 K. Here copper is selected as representative of the winding materials. As may be deduced from Table A3.4 in APPENDIX III, which lists mean linear thermal expansion data of selected metals and nonmetals, percentage changes in expansion between 20 K and 80 K, for example, are about the same order of magnitude among these materials. We are thus justified here in choosing copper to quantitatively estimate ΔL/L. Thus: 15 K ΔL = (5×10−9 T + 3×10−11 T 3 )dT = 0.62×10−6 (4.24) L◦ cu 10 K This linear change occurs in three dimensions. If the windings were to expand equally in all directions, there would be no deterioration of homogeneity. In reality, because every winding is anisotropic, a degradation of the field homogeneity is expected but to what extent depends on how much the medium is anisotropic, and consequently this amplitude cannot accurately be predicted. Note that (ΔL/L◦ ) in all materials increases not only with ΔTop but also with initial temperature. Therefore, because of this potential field homogeneity degradation during an operating temperature excursion, for solid cryogen cooled magnets applied to NMR and MRI, it may be prudent to keep their initial operating temperatures to below ∼20 K and ΔTop no greater than 10 K.
264
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.13: Low-Temperature Thermometers Temperature plays a dominant role in the key design/operation issues—conductor, cryogenics, mechanical, protection, stability—of superconducting magnets, as may be inferred from Fig. 1.6. Temperature measurement is thus one of the requirements in the operation of and experiments on superconducting magnets. It is a large subject, with a book devoted to it [4.41] or a whole chapter [4.42]. Rubin presents, with nearly 500 papers cited, a thorough review of progress in cryogenic thermometry over the period 1982–1997 [4.43]. Here our coverage, at only an introductory level and extent, is limited to thermometers, not thermometry. Specifically, we discuss temperature sensors that are readily available and commonly used in superconducting magnets; not included here are instrumentation and calibration techniques, important topics in thermometry. Because we deal with sensors only for superconducting magnets and related experiments, our discussion on thermometers covers the temperature range 2–300 K. A. Kelvin Scale In 1854 Kelvin proposed to take absolute zero as the starting point of a thermodynamic temperature scale. In 1954, the kelvin (K) was adopted as the unit of thermodynamic temperature, defined as 1/273.16 of water’s triple point temperature (0.0100◦ C). Accordingly, 0◦ C, water’s melting point on the Celsius scale, is equal to 273.15 K. Note that K stands by itself as the unit of temperature scale: it is thus not 4.2◦ K or 4.2 degrees Kelvin, but 4.2 K or 4.2 kelvins. B. Requirements As for any sensor, there are a number of requirements for a temperature sensor. These (listed here in no particular order of importance) with the desired quality given in parentheses, include: 1) signal level (high); 2) sensitivity (high); 3) response time (fast, to detect transitory events); 4) size (small); 5) magnetic field effect (minimal); 6) DC offset (zero); and 7) cost (low). Also desirable are reproducibility, stability, and linearity. Although every sensor is a linear function of any variable over a small range, clearly it cannot be expected to remain linear over an arbitrarily large range. With the proliferation of computer-based data acquisition techniques, linearity is not as pressing as it once was. C. Types of Thermometers Three types of thermometers are used in superconducting magnets and related experiments: 1) diodes; 2) resistors; and 3) thermocouples. Gas and vapor pressure thermometers, once quite common, particularly in the laboratory setup, are rarely used now. Each of the three types of thermometers is described briefly below. Diode Thermometers The junction voltage of a semiconductor device, such as a diode, forward-biased at a constant current, increases with decreasing temperature. Most widely used diode thermometers are based on Si and GaAlAs junctions; many commercial thermometers, both calibrated and uncalibrated, are available. Calibrated versions are as little as ∼1/2 (some Si diodes) or as much as ∼4 times more expensive than uncalibrated versions, the cost differential dictated chiefly by the sensor’s operating temperature range.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
265
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.13: Low-Temperature Thermometers (continuation) Resistance Thermometers Resistance thermometers are available with either temperature coefficient sign: negative if based on semiconductors and positive if based on metals (generally pure to maximize the sensor’s sensitivity, ohm/kelvin). The negative temperature coefficient sensors include germanium, carbon resistors, carbon-glass (primarily for use in magnetic fields), and ruthenium oxide. The positive temperature coefficient sensors include platinum, platinum alloys, and rhodium-iron. Becoming increasingly popular is the zirconium oxynitride thermometer under the name Cernox, manufactured by Lake Shore Cryotronics, Inc. Among metal-based sensors, the one based on pure platinum is the most prominent and everyone’s choice when highest-accuracy is required; indeed the standard platinum resistance thermometer defines the International Temperature Standard from 13.8033 K, the triple point of hydrogen, up to well beyond 300 K. Temperature Spectrum Figure 4.19 shows a temperature spectrum over the range from 100 picokelvins (100 pK) to 1 gigakelvin (1 GK). Note that superconducting magnets operate over a temperature span that extends less than 2 log scales, 1 K–100 K. T [K] 1G
Interior of the hottest star
100M Thermonuclear fusion Sun’s interior 10M 1M
Nuclear fission (∼300,000 K)
100k 10k
Luminous nebulae; Tungsten melts (3683 K) Superconductors reacted (∼1000 K) Ice point (273.15 K=0 ◦C) Liquid nitrogen boils (77.3 K) HTS magnets
1k 100 10
Liquid helium boils (4.2 K)
1 100m 10m 1m
LTS magnets
Pumped 3He (∼0.5 K) Dilution refrigerators He becomes superfluid (2 mK)
3
100μ 10μ
16 μK, by nuclear adiabatic demagnetization (1956)
1μ 100n
150 nK, by laser cooling (1995)
10n 1n 100p Fig. 4.19
450 pK, by laser cooling (2003) 100 pK, by nuclear adiabatic demagnetization (2001) Temperature spectrum covering 19 orders of magnitude.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
266
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.13: Low-Temperature Thermometers (continuation) Thermocouples For cryogenic applications that tolerate uncertainties of temperature up to 5%—for example, 1 K at 20 K—thermocouples are widely used. This is chiefly because they can meet some of the requirements listed earlier— small size and fast response time—more readily than the diode and resistance thermometers. Also, thermocouples are the least expensive among the three types. D. Signal Levels and Sensitivities of Selected Thermometers Table 4.11 presents approximate values of signal level (V ) and sensitivity (δV/δT ) at selected temperatures in the 2–300 K range for six commonly used thermometers, two from each of the three types: diodes [4.44], resistances [4.44]; and thermocouples [4.45]. Note that these values are given here to demonstrate that both signal levels and sensitivities vary over a wide range among thermometers and as a “guide” in the selection process for appropriate sensors. Commercial sources of these sensors generally supply accurate “general” data for these sensors; each calibrated sensor is provided with its own specific data. Each thermometer in Table 4.11 is briefly discussed below, including magnetic field effects. Additional Remarks, Including Magnetic Field Effects Diode Diode thermometers, such as silicon and GaAlAs, have the highest sensitivity among the three types over the entire temperature range of our interest. Also as may be deduced from Table 4.11, the sensor’s V (T ) curve is quite linear, i.e., V decreasing roughly linearly with T , in the 50–300 K range. Also attractive is that for most applications in which temperature uncertainties up to 5% are acceptable, uncalibrated sensors that rely only on the manufacturer’s standard calibration curve may be used. The only negative is its unsuitability in the presence of a magnetic field, particularly in the temperature range below 60 K [4.45]. Table 4.11: Approximate Values of Signal Level (V ) and Sensitivity (δV/δT ) of Selected Thermometers of Diodes [4.44]; Resistances [4.44]; and Thermocouples [4.45] Sensor Silicon GaAlAs
2K
4K
10 K
20 K
50 K
100 K 200 K 300 K
V [V] 1.69 1.63 1.42 1.21 δV/δT [mV/K] −21 −33 −29 −18 V [V] 5.5 5.1 4.1 2.7 δV/δT [mV/K] −210 −210 −145 −110
1.07 −1.8 1.5 −30
0.98 −2.0 1.4 −1.5
Cernox
V [mV] 12 δV/δT [mV/K] −10 @ Current [μA] 1 Platinum V [mV] NA δV/δT [mV/K] NA @ Current [mA] —
14 −3.5 3 NA NA —
17 −1.5 10 NA NA —
Type E
4.6 2.09 39.6 12.2
24.9 91 504 4.65 8.51 18.7 124.9 286.6 768.6 15.6 16.3 16.4
V [μV] 1.3 δV/δT [μV/K] 1.15 AuFe(0.07%)V [μV] 17.2 Chromel δV/δT [μV/K] 10.0
0.76 −2.3 1.1 −2.6
0.52 −2.4 0.9 −2.7
28 13 20 33 20 −1.2 −0.24 −0.18 −0.18 −0.07 30 30 100 300 300 2.4 10 31 77 114 0.086 0.35 0.41 0.39 0.38 1 1 1 1 1 1775 31.4 1647 18.7
5871 11445 49.3 61 3667 5864 21.4 22.8
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
267
DISCUSSION 4.13: Low-Temperature Thermometers (continuation) GaAlAs There are two important aspects of GaAlAs that are different from Si: 1) greater nonlinearity of V (T ); and 2) insensitivity to magnetic fields up to ∼5 T. Cernox Although not as sensitive as diode thermometers, second to Si, Cernox is widely used. Unlike Si, it is quite insensitive to a magnetic field. Data of Lake Shore Cryotronics [4.44], the manufacturer of Cernox, show that at 20 K the sensor’s δT/T uncertainty due to magnetic field is less than 0.2% up to a field of 20 T; the error increases with decreasing temperature, reaching ∼5% at 2 K. Platinum A platinum sensor is quite insensitive to magnetic field at temperatures above ∼40 K: for example, at 40 K and 5 T, δT/T is 1.5%, which, at 80 K and 5 T, decreases by a factor of 10 [4.44]. Type E Thermocouple Both Type E and Chromel-Au0.07%Fe have the smallest signal levels and sensitivities compared with the other four sensors. Note that with the ice-point (0◦ ) reference, Type E, at 20 K, for example, has an offset voltage of ∼11 mV, while its sensitivity is only ∼10 μV/K. However, its accuracy is much improved when only changes in temperature from a specific operating point are to be measured. Also, if temperature uncertainties up to ∼5% can be tolerated and many sensors are required, Type E is an excellent choice. Field sensitivity is quite modest, e.g., 2% at 20 K and < 1% at 45 K, both in a field of 8 T [4.44]. AuFe(0.07%)-Chromel Among all thermocouples, chromel-AuFe(0.07%) gives the highest sensitivity, and thus is most suitable, at temperatures below ∼20 K. Its V (T ) values, however, can easily deviate from the published values [4.45] when the AuFe(0.07%) wire is strained—it must be handled very carefully. Its sensitivity to magnetic field is roughly one order of magnitude greater than that of Type E. Capacitance Thermometers Though not included in the above discussion, capacitance thermometers such as strontium titanate sensors are used because of their very low magnetic field dependence. Several other types based on glass or plastic materials are popular for temperatures below 1 K.
Fahrenheit Scale —Passage from Linus Pauling’s College Chemistry [4.46] The Fahrenheit scale was devised by Gabriel Daniel Fahrenheit (1686–1736), a natural philosopher who was born in Danzig (now Gda´ nsk) and settled in Holland. He invented the mercury thermometer in 1714; before then alcohol had been used as the liquid in thermometers. As the zero point on his scale he took the temperature produced by mixing equal quantities of snow and ammonium chloride. His choice of 212 o for the boiling point of water was made in order that the temperature of his body should be 100 oF. The normal temperature of the human body is 98.6 oF (37.0◦ C); perhaps Fahrenheit had a slight fever while he was calibrating his thermometer.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
268
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead* For a superconducting magnet immersed in a bath of liquid helium at 4.2 K, a vapor-cooled copper current lead can be a large heat load on the system cryogenics. The basic design concept for an optimum vapor-cooled copper lead is to make the Joule heating and conduction heating about equal and to remove the heat by funneling cold helium vapor through the lead. Work on vapor-cooled leads began in the 1960s and continues [4.47–4.52]. Vapor-cooled leads are now commercially available in the current range 100 A–75 kA. Recently, it has reached the 100-kA level [4.53]. Here we present analytical expressions for key parameters of a lead. A. Power Density Equation The total power Qin flowing into and generated within a differential volume AΔz of a vapor-cooled lead (Fig. 4.20) carrying the lead’s rated current I◦ is given by: dT ρ(T )I◦2 Qin = Ak(T ) +m ˙ I cp (T )T + Δz (4.25) dz z+Δz A where z is the axial distance along the lead, and z = 0 at the lead’s cold end. k(T ), A, and ρ(T ) are, respectively, the thermal conductivity, active cross sectional area, and electrical resistivity of the lead (usually copper). m ˙ I and cp (T ) are, respectively, the helium mass flow rate and specific heat. The heat transfer between the helium and the lead is assumed perfect; T is the temperature of both the lead and helium at z. The total power Qout flowing out of the differential volume of AΔz is given by: dT Qout = Ak(T ) +m ˙ I cp (T )(T + ΔT ) (4.26) dz z In the steady-state condition, we have Qin = Qout . Thus: dT ρ(T )I◦2 dT − Ak(T ) Ak(T ) −m ˙ I cp (T )ΔT + Δz = 0 (4.27) dz z+Δz dz z A m ˙ I cp (T )(T +ΔT )
Ak(T ) dT dz
z+Δz
z +Δz ρ(T )I◦2 A z m ˙ I cp (T )T Fig. 4.20
Ak(T ) dT dz
z
Heat balance for a differential volume of a vapor-cooled lead.
* Based on Problem 4.3 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
269
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead (continuation) Dividing Eq. 4.27 by Δz and letting Δz → 0, we obtain: d dT dT ρ(T )I◦2 Ak(T ) −m ˙ I cp (T ) + =0 dz dz dz A
(4.28)
B. Cold-End Heat Input & Boil-Off Rate In the “high” current limit, i.e., |d[Ak(T )dT/dz]/dz| ρ(T )I◦2 /A, Eq. 4.28 evaluated at z = 0, where T (0) = T0 , is simplified to: dT ρ0 −m ˙ I cp0 + I◦2 0 (4.29a) dz z=0 A where cp0 = cp (T0 ) and ρ0 = ρ(T0 ). From Eq. 4.29a, we can solve for (dT/dz)z=0 : ρ0 I◦2 dT (4.29b) dz z=0 Am ˙ I cp0 Because QI◦ at z = 0 is purely by conduction, we have, with k0 = k(T0 ): dT k0 ρ0 I◦2 QI◦ = Ak(T0 ) = (4.30) dz z=0 m ˙ I cp0 The power input QI◦ into the liquid boils off the liquid at a rate m ˙ I given by: QI◦ m ˙I= (4.31a) hL where hL is the liquid helium’s latent heat of vaporization [J/kg]. Combining Eqs. 4.30 and 4.31a and solving for m ˙ I , we obtain: k0 ρ0 m ˙ I = I◦ (4.31b) cp0 hL Inserting m ˙ I given by Eq. 4.31b into Eq. 4.30 and solving for QI◦ /I◦ , we derive: QI◦ hL k0 ρ0 = (4.32a) I◦ cp0 Note that QI◦ depends neither on , the lead active length between the bottom end (z = 0) and top end (z = ), nor on A, the lead conductor cross section. It is, however, directly proportional to I◦ , the lead’s rated current. Note that if the lead carries I < I◦ , the cold-end heat input will not be (I/I◦ )QI◦ . Throughout this discussion T0 is the cold-end temperature of a vapor-cooled lead, assumed below to be T0 = 6 K. However, in a real vapor-cooled lead, this cold end (z = 0) may be located high above the top of the magnet (and minimum liquid level)—in some cases 25 cm or even higher, because it is often desirable to provide a reservoir of liquid helium above the magnet. The cold end is then electrically and thermally connected to a superconductor-shunted copper extension, the other end (z < 0) of which penetrates into the liquid. The superconductor shunt (often of copper/NbTi composite) carries I◦ to the magnet, and the copper conducts QI◦ to the liquid. The copper extension must have enough cross sectional area to conduct QI◦ , even when exposed out of liquid helium over its entire span, without raising T0 too high, thus enabling the superconductor shunt to carry I◦ superconductively.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
270
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead (continuation) With hL = 20.7 × 103 J/kg and cp0 5.26 × 103 J/kg K for liquid helium; k0 = 600 W/m K and ρ0 2.5×10−10 Ω m for copper, we obtain: QI◦ (20.7×103 J/kg)(600 W/m K)(2.5×10−10 Ω m) I◦ 5.26×103 J/kg K = 7.7×10−4 W/A = 0.77 mW/A ∼ 1 mW/A
(4.32b)
For an optimum vapor-cooled lead, 1 mW/A is a rule-of-thumb value useful for estimating the heat input into liquid helium. For a single 10-kA lead operating at 10 kA (= I◦ ), the heat load will be ∼10 W, or ∼20 W for a pair of such leads. C. Optimal Current-Lead Parameters The high-current approximation of Eq. 4.28 is given by: dT ρ(T )I◦2 + =0 (4.33) dz A Solving for dT/ρ(T ) from Eq. 4.33 with cp (T ) c˜p , a temperature-averaged (from T0 to T ) heat capacity of helium, and integrating both sides over appropriate limits (T0 at z = 0 and T at z = ) we obtain: T 2 dT I◦ dz I◦2 = = (4.34a) ˙ I c˜p Am ˙ I c˜p T0 ρ(T ) 0 Am T For copper, the integral T0 dT/ρ(T )is given approximately by: T dT 1.2×1011 K/Ω m (4.34b) ρ(T ) T0 −m ˙ I cp (T )
for T0 = 6 K and T = 273 K. Inserting m ˙ I (Eq. 4.31b) in Eq. 4.34a and assuming c˜p cp0 , a valid assumption for helium, we obtain:
2 T dT I◦ 1 cp0 hL (4.34c) ρ(T ) Ac I k0 ρ0 p0 ◦ T0 We express the optimal-current-lead parameter ratio, (I◦ /A)ot ≡ ζ◦ , in terms of its rated current (I◦ ), lead active length (), and cross sectional area (A):
T dT I◦ cp0 k0 ρ0 ≡ ζ◦ (4.35a) A ot hL T0 ρ(T ) Inserting appropriate values for the parameters in the above equation, we can numerically solve for ζ◦ : (5.26×103 J/kg K)(600 W/m K)(2.5×10−10 Ω m) ζ◦ (1.2×1011 K/Ω m) 20.7×103 J/kg Thus:
I◦ A
2.3×107 A/m ot
For I◦ = 6 kA and = 38 cm, for example, Eq. 4.35b gives: A 1 cm2 .
(4.35b)
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
271
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead (continuation) D. Standing Heat Input The liquid helium boil-off rate when the optimized lead carries no current—called the “standing” boil-off rate, m ˙ 0 —is due to heat input into the helium by conduction only. With I◦ = 0 inserted into Eq. 4.28, we have: Ak˜
d2 T dT −m ˙ 0 c˜p =0 2 dz dz
(4.36)
where k˜ is the average thermal conductivity and c˜p is the average specific heat of helium, both in the temperature range, T0 to T . k˜ =
1 T −T0
T
k(T ) dT
(4.37)
T0
Table 4.18 (p. 307) presents values of k˜ for four materials (G-10, stainless steel 304, brass, and copper) over three common temperature ranges in cryogenic applications: 4–80 K; 4–300 K; and 80–300 K. ˜ With the boundary conditions, T (z = 0) = T0 and Ak(dT/dz) ˙ 0 hL , T (z) z=0 = m may be given by:
hL m ˙ 0 c˜p z T (z) = T0 + exp −1 (4.38a) c˜p Ak˜ Thus:
m ˙ 0 c˜p hL T () ≡ T = T0 + exp −1 c˜p Ak˜
(4.38b)
˜ we have: Solving Eq. 4.38b for m ˙ 0 c˜p /Ak, c˜p (T −T0 ) m ˙ 0 c˜p = ln +1 hL Ak˜
(4.39a)
From Eq. 4.39a we may solve for m ˙ 0 . Thus:
k˜ A c˜p (T −T0 ) m ˙0= ln +1 c˜p hL
(4.39b)
Combining Eq. 4.39b and Q0 = m ˙ 0 hL , we obtain: ˜ L A c˜p (T −T0 ) kh Q0 = ln +1 c˜p hL
(4.40a)
For an optimal lead, (I◦ /A)ot = ζ◦ , we thus obtain: ˜ L I◦ c˜p (T −T0 ) kh ln Q0 = +1 c˜p ζ◦ hL
(4.40b)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
272
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead (continuation) For an optimum vapor-cooled copper lead, the ratio of Q0 to QI◦ is given by: Q0 k˜ hL cp0 c˜p (T −T0 ) = ln +1 (4.41) QI◦ c˜p ζ◦ k0 ρ0 hL With k˜ = 660 W/m K (Table 4.18); c˜p 5.2 kJ/kg K; T = 300 K; T0 = 4 K and ζ◦ 2.3×107 A/m inserted into Eq. 4.41, we obtain: Q0 0.69 QI◦
(4.42)
That is, the standing boil-off rate of a vapor-cooled lead is roughly 70% of the boil-off rate of the lead carrying its rated current. E. Voltage Drop Across an Optimal Lead The voltage drop V◦ over the entire length of the copper lead at I◦ is given by: I◦ V◦ = ρcu dz (4.43a) A 0 Integration over the lead length is necessary because ρcu , the electrical resistivity of copper, is temperature-dependent and thus varies with z. Equation 4.43a may be expressed as:
I◦ V◦ = ρ˜cu = ρ˜cu ζ◦ (4.43b) A ot where ρ˜cu =
1
ρcu dz
0
1 T −T0
T
ρcu (T ) dT
(4.44)
T0
Equation 4.44 assumes a linear temperature gradient along the current lead. Combining Eqs. 4.43b, where ρ˜cu is given in the unit of Ω m, and Eq. 4.35b, we have: V◦ 2.3×107 ρ˜cu V
(4.45)
That is, Vot is the same among leads optimized for any rated current. For copper, ρcu is ∼2.5×10−10 Ω m (below ∼50 K) and varies linearly with temperature above ∼50 K, being 1.75 × 10−8 Ω m at 273 K. From Eq. 4.44, we have: ρ˜cu 0.4×10−8 Ω m. The voltage drop across an optimum lead at its rated current is independent of rated current; for a copper lead it is ∼100 mV. Thus, V◦ ∼ 100 mV at 100 A for a 100-A lead and at 10 kA for a 10-kA lead; when the warm end is “cool,” which often happens in vapor-cooled leads, V◦ can be less than 100 mV. This conclusion agrees, within an order of magnitude, with experimental data for vapor-cooled copper leads in the 1 kA–30 kA range [4.54]. TRIVIA 4.4:
List the temperatures below in descending order.
i) Critical, of superconductor MgB2 ; iii) Phase transition, of solid N2 ;
ii) Curie, of ferromagnet CrBr3 ; iv) Surface, of the “planet” Pluto.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
273
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.14: Vapor-Cooled Copper Current Lead (continuation) F. Heating Upon Flow Stoppage When a cooling gas flow stoppage occurs, the steady-state solution on which the design of optimum leads is based is no longer valid. If the lead continues to carry its rated current I◦ without cooling, “flow stoppage meltdown” of the lead may occur, most often near the warm end. The time-dependent power equation [W/m] for a differential element of an optimum lead is given by: dT d dT dT ρcu (T ) 2 ACcu (T ) = Ak(T ) −m ˙ I cp (T ) + (4.46) I◦ dt dz dz dz A where Ccu (T ) is the volumetric heat capacity of the lead metal (copper). With no cooling (m ˙ I = 0) and the conduction term set equal to zero (conservative assumption), Eq. 4.46 becomes: ACcu (T )
dT ρcu (T ) 2 = I◦ dt A
(4.47)
An optimum lead satisfies (I◦ /A) = ζ◦ = 2.3×107 A/m. Thus: dT ρcu (T )ζ◦2 = (4.48) dt 2 Because flow stoppage meltdown usually happens near the warm end, we replace Ccu (T ) with C◦ (a constant) and ρcu (T ) = ρ◦ + γcu T (ρ◦ and γcu both constants): Ccu (T )
dT ρ◦ ζ◦2 γcu ζ◦2 ρ◦ T = + T = + 2 2 dt C◦ C◦ γcu τ τ
(4.49)
The thermal time constant of the lead, τ , is given by: τ =
C◦ 2 γcu ζ◦2
(4.50)
The solution to Eq. 4.49 is given by: T (t) = Ket/τ −
ρ◦ γcu
(4.51)
where K is a constant. Equation 4.51 states that upon gas flow stoppage T (t) rises exponentially with a time constant of τ . Because τ is proportional to 2 , a longer optimum lead takes longer to reach the metal’s meltdown temperature than does a shorter optimum lead. Note that because ζ◦ = (I◦ /A), we may also conclude that for the same rated current a thicker optimum lead is safer than a thinner optimum lead against a flow stoppage incident. For an optimum 10-kA lead with = 1 m, for example, with C◦ = 3.5×106 J/m3 K, γcu = 68×10−12 Ω m/K, and (I◦ /A) ≡ ζ◦ = 2.3×107 A/m, we obtain: τ =
(3.5×106 J/m3 K)(1 m)2 ∼ 90 s (68×10−12 Ω m/K)(2.5×107 A/m)2
Note that τ is doubled for an optimum 10-kA lead having = 1.4 m.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
274
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.15: “Dry” Leads—Normal Metal & HTS* For a dry superconducting magnet, current leads must generally operate in a vacuum environment. Here we discuss two types of leads rated at I◦ : 1) normal metal [4.55]; and 2) HTS over its usable temperature range [4.56]. A. Normal Metal The steady-state power differential equation over a unit lead length is given by: d2 T ρ˜I◦2 + =0 (4.52) dz 2 A where A is the lead active cross sectional area; k˜ and ρ˜ are, respectively, the metal’s T -averaged thermal conductivity and electrical resistivity. Solving Eq. 4.52 with the boundary conditions T (z = 0) = T0 and T (z = ) = T , we obtain Eq. 4.11 (p. 240), from which the heat input at the cold end, QI◦ may be derived:
A dT ρ˜I◦2 ˜ ˜ QI◦ = Ak = k(T − T0 ) + (4.53) dz 2 A Ak˜
z=0
Differentiating Eq. 4.53 with respect to /A and setting it to 0 for (I◦ /A)dr , we obtain (I◦ /A)dr for an optimal dry lead that minimizes [QI◦ ]dr (Eq. 4.12, p. 240):
˜ − T0 ) I◦ 2k(T = (4.12) A dr ρ˜ From Eqs. 4.12 and 4.53, we obtain an expression for [QI◦ ]dr : [QI◦ ]dr = I◦ 2k˜ρ˜(T − T0 )
(4.54)
With k˜ = 460 W/m K and ρ˜ = 1 × 10−8 Ω m (for copper in the range 80–300 K), Eq. 4.54 gives: [QI◦ ]dr /I◦ 45 mW/A; for brass, Eq. 4.54 gives 32 mW/A [4.19]. That is, for a conduction-cooled lead, brass is preferable to copper. B. HTS Extension After the discovery of YBCO, HTS lead “extensions” were built for the cold portion (below ∼80 K) of a normal metal lead [4.57, 4.58]. The heat input to the magnet environment at T0 by an HTS extension, [QIhts ]dr , of “average” thermal conductivity khts , cross sectional area Ahts , length hts , and warm-end temperature Twhts is ideally by conduction, for which: (Twhts − T0 ) [QIhts ]dr = khts Ahts (4.55) hts In a real normal-metal/HTS lead, the normal metal heat at its cold end, given by Eq. 4.54 with T0 Twhts , generally is absorbed by the 1st stage of a cryocooler, the 2nd stage of which maintains the magnet at T0 . Also, the HTS lead, whether of bulk or tape, must be protected; protection of Bi2223 tape current lead is discussed in DISCUSSION 8.5. Besides the HTS lead considered here, there also are vapor-cooled HTS versions, as studied in PROBLEMS 4.4–4.6. * Based on Problem 4.4 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
275
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.4: Vapor-cooled HTS current lead —Fully Superconducting Version (FSV) Together with conduction-cooled HTS current leads, vapor-cooled HTS current leads were also among the earliest practical, and successful, HTS devices. Started in 1989, the work is still continuing [4.59–4.73]. HTS leads now reach rated currents of 60 kA [4.69] and 70 kA [4.74]. Here, we study a vapor-cooled current lead incorporating HTS, specifically that in the form of tape, in which the HTS’s warm end is thermally anchored at 77–80 K; at this point the HTS lead is connected to a vapor-cooled normal-metal lead, to reach the room-temperature termination. Hull has classified altogether 11 types of current leads [4.60]. Among these is a fully-superconducting version (FSV) of a vapor-cooled HTS lead, i.e., that operates fully superconducting over the entire temperature range, between 4.2 K and 77–80 K. Because such a lead relies on convective cooling by the effluent helium vapor, it is appropriate primarily for superconducting magnets that operate immersed in a bath of liquid helium. Figure 4.21 shows the basic configuration of the vapor-cooled HTS lead studied here, comprised of Nfs paralleled HTS tapes, each of active length . The HTS lead, rated at current I◦ , operates between its cold end (z = 0) at temperature T0 and its warm end (z = ), at T . The HTS lead conducts heat, Qin , into liquid helium, generating effluent vapor, of mass flow rate m ˙ h , that absorbs the heat over the lead length . Between T and room temperature, any vapor-cooled HTS lead must be coupled to an optimal vapor-cooled lead of normal metal, generally copper, rated at the same current of I◦ . Because Qin of the HTS lead is necessarily smaller than that of the copper counterpart—this reduction in Qin is the only reason for incorporating the HTS lead—the helium flow rate m ˙ h generated by the HTS section is insufficient for the normal metal section. Therefore extra coolant is introduced at the cold-end of the normal-metal vaporcooled lead, as indicated in Fig. 4.21.
Room Temperature
I◦ Normal Metal Section
Coolant I◦
HTS Section
z=0 Liquid Helium [Magnet]
Fig. 4.21 Basic configuration of a vaporcooled HTS lead coupled to an optimal vapor-cooled lead of normal metal. The HTS lead extends from z = 0, generally at 4.2 K, to z = , e.g., at 77–80 K. An extra flow of coolant is introduced at z = .
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
276
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.4: Vapor-cooled HTS current lead—FSV (continuation) The steady-state time-independent power equation for a differential element of an HTS current lead cooled by the effluent helium vapor is given by: d dT dT [Am ]fs km (T ) − [m ˙ h ]fs cp (T ) =0 (4.56) dz dz dz It is assumed here that heat transfer between the lead and helium vapor is perfect, with zero temperature difference between the two. In Eq. 4.56, [Am ]fs is the total cross sectional area in the FSV lead of HTS matrix (normal) metal, e.g., Ag-Au in Bi2223 tape: [Am ]fs = Nfs am , where am is the matrix cross sectional area of an individual tape; Nfs is the number of parallel ˙ h ]fs is the HTS tapes; km (T ) is the thermal conductivity of the matrix metal; [m helium flow rate; and cp (T ) is the specific heat of helium. We linearize Eq. 4.56 by making km (T ) = k˜ and cp (T ) = c˜p , both constants, respectively, temperatureaveraged km (T ) and cp (T ) over the range from T0 at z = 0 to T at z = , Thus: [Am ]fs k˜
dT d2 T − [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p =0 dz 2 dz
Equation 4.57 may be solved for T (z):
T −T0 [α]fs (z/) T (z) = T0 + − 1 e e[α]fs −1
(4.57)
(4.58)
where, [α]fs , a dimensionless quantity, is given by: [α]fs =
[m ˙ h ]fs c˜p ˜ m ]fs k[A
(4.59)
a) Show that [Qin ]fs , the heat input to the helium bath (z = 0), is given by: ˜ m ]fs hL c˜p (T −T0 ) k[A [Qin ]fs = ln +1 c˜p hL
(4.60)
where hL is the latent heat of vaporization of helium. Note that [Qin ]fs , unlike QI◦ ∝ I◦ (from Eq. 4.32a) for the vapor-cooled copper lead, is proportional not to current but to Nfs through [Am ]fs = Nfs am . b) Show that the difference between [Qin ]fs and [Q ]fs , the heat conducted into the FSV lead from the copper lead at z = , is equal to the difference in enthalpy energy of the effluent helium vapor at z = (T ) and z = 0 (T0 ): ˙ h ]fs c˜p (T − T0 ) [Q ]fs − [Qin ]fs = [m
Answer to TRIVIA 4.4:
(4.61)
Pluto (∼40, in K); MgB2 (39); CrBr3 (37); N2 (35.6).
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
277
Solution to PROBLEM 4.4 a)
From Eq. 4.58, we may first solve for dT/dz|0 (dT/dz at z = 0). Then, [Qin ]fs : dT ˜ m ]fs = [m [Qin ]fs = k[A ˙ h ]fs hL (S4.1) dz 0
Evaluating dT/dz|0 from Eq. 4.58 and inserting [α]fs given by Eq. 4.59, we obtain:
dT T −T0 [α]fs ˜ ˜ k[Am ]fs = k[Am ]fs dz 0 e[α]fs −1
T −T0 = ˙ h ]fs hL (S4.2) [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p = [m e[α]fs −1 Solving Eq. S4.2 for e[α]fs , we have: c˜p (T −T0 ) +1 hL c˜p (T −T0 ) [α]fs = ln +1 hL
e[α]fs =
(S4.3a) (S4.3b)
Combining Eqs. 4.59 and S4.3b, we have: [m ˙ h ]fs
˜ m ]fs c˜p (T −T0 ) k[A = ln +1 c˜p hL
Substituting Eq. S4.4 into S4.1, we obtain: ˜ m ]fs hL c˜p (T −T0 ) k[A [Qin ]fs = ln +1 c˜p hL
(S4.4)
(4.60)
Strictly, Eq. 4.60 is valid only when the system bath is continuously replenished so that its liquid level is kept constant; if it is not, a correction factor of (1−v / ) is needed for [m ˙ h ]fs hL [4.63], where v and are respectively the densities of vapor and liquid at saturation. At 4.2 K the density ratio is 0.135: (1−v / ) = 0.865. b) Conduction heat into the lead at z = from above, [Q ]fs , is given by:
T −T0 dT ˜ [Q ]fs = k[Am ]fs = [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p e[α]fs (S4.5a) dz e[α]fs −1 c˜p (T −T0 ) = [m ˙ h ]fs hL +1 hL ˙ h ]fs hL = [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p (T − T0 ) + [m
(S4.5b)
Combining the outboard terms of Eq. S4.1 and Eq. S4.5b, we note that: [Q ]fs − [Qin ]fs = [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p (T − T0 )
(4.61)
Equation 4.61 shows that the three power terms are balanced. Namely, the difference in heat entering the lead at z = and that leaving the lead at z = 0 is exactly equal to the gain in thermal power of the effluent helium vapor.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
278
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.5: Vapor-cooled HTS current lead —Current-Sharing Version (CSV) We study here a vapor-cooled HTS current lead in which a short section at the warm (T ) end is designed to operate in the so-called “current-sharing” mode [4.75– 4.77]—current sharing is studied in CHAPTER 6. This current-sharing version (CSV) of a vapor-cooled HTS lead has the same rated current as its FSV counterpart studied in PROBLEM 4.4. Figure 4.22 shows a linearized Ic (T ) plot for the superconductor in the lead, with critical currents of Ic0 at T0 (z = 0) and Ic at T (z = ). Also shown by the dotted horizontal line is the rated transport current I◦ of the lead. As indicated in the figure, Ic (Tcs ) = I◦ at Tcs , the temperature at which current sharing begins. The dashed line indicates the portion of I◦ in the superconductor’s normal metal matrix. At T the superconductor carries Ic , and the matrix I◦−Ic . This short section of the HTS lead dissipates Joule heat, which must be removed by the effluent helium. Advantage of CSV For the same rated transport current, the CSV lead contains fewer (Ncs ) expensive HTS tapes than its FSV counterpart (Ncs < Nfs ). Furthermore, as discussed in PROBLEM 4.6 for 6-kA leads, the cold-end heat input of the CSV lead, despite its Joule dissipation near the warm end, is less than that of the FSV counterpart. Analysis of Superconducting Section (0 ≤ z ≤ cs ) We first analyze the superconducting section of this CSV lead. It spans between z = 0 at T0 and z = cs at Tcs . The temperature T (ξ), with z normalized to (ξ ≡ z/) and constant materials properties, is similar to Eq. 4.58. Thus:
Tcs −T0 e[α ]cs ξcs T0 −Tcs [α ]cs ξ e T (ξ) = + (0 ≤ z ≤ cs ) (4.62) Tcs −T0 e[α ]cs ξcs −1 With [Am ]cs = Ncs am , [α ]cs is given by: [α ]cs ≡
[m ˙ h ]cs c˜p ˜ k[Am ]cs
(4.63)
Ic (T ) Ic0 I◦ Ic I◦ −Ic 0
0 T0
Tcs
T
Tc
T
Fig. 4.22 Ic (T ) plot (solid line), approximated to be linear with temperature for HTS. The dotted horizontal line is the lead’s rated current, I◦ . The dashed line indicates the current through the matrix, I◦−Ic (T ), in the current-sharing region.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
279
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.5: Vapor-cooled HTS current lead—CSV (continuation) a) Show, from Eq. 4.62, that T (ξ = 0) = T0 and T (ξ = ξcs ) = Tcs . b) Show that [Qin ]cs , the heat input at z = 0 in the CSV lead, is given by: ˜ m ]cs hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) k[A [Qin ]cs = ln +1 (4.64) c˜p cs hL In practice, as we shall see in PROBLEM 4.6, which deals with a numerical example, cs and Tcs−T0 are, respectively, nearly equal to and T−T0 of the FSV counterpart. Thus, [Qin ]cs < [Qin ]fs comes mainly from [Am ]cs < [Am ]fs . In the process of deriving Eq. 4.64, show also that [α ]cs is given by: c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) +1 hL 1 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) = ln +1 ξcs hL
e[α ]cs ξcs =
(4.65a)
[α ]cs
(4.65b)
Analysis of Current-Sharing Section (cs ≤ z ≤ ) In the current-sharing region, between z = cs at Tcs and z = at T , the power per conductor length equation, with the material properties constant, is given by: 2 dT ρ˜x I◦ (I◦ −Ic ) ˜ m ]cs d T − [m k[A ˙ h ]cs c˜p + (T − Tcs ) = 0 2 dz dz [Am ]cs (T −Tcs ) (cs ≤ z ≤ )
(4.66)
The third term in Eq. 4.66 gives the Joule dissipation that takes place over this section of the CSV lead that operates in the current-sharing mode. ρ˜x is the temperature-averaged electrical resistivity of the lead over this section. With the boundary conditions, T (cs ) = Tcs and T () = T , and normalizing z with , ξ ≡ z/, we obtain in the range ξcs ≤ ξ ≤ 1: T (ξ) = Tcs +
(T −Tcs ) e
[α ]cs 2
e
sin βcs (1−ξcs )
[α ]cs 2
ξ
sin βcs (ξ − ξcs )
where, βcs , another dimensionless quantity, is given by:
2 ρ˜x I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p 1 βcs = − ˜ m ]2 (T −Tcs ) 4 k[A ˜ m ]cs k[A cs Combining Eqs. 4.68a and 4.63, we have: ρ˜x I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 − 1 [α ]2 βcs = ˜ m ]2 (T −Tcs ) 4 cs k[A cs Combining Eqs. 4.68b and 4.65b, we also have: 2 1 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) ρ˜x I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 1 βcs = − ln +1 ˜ m ]2 (T −Tcs ) 4 ξcs hL k[A cs
(4.67)
(4.68a)
(4.68b)
(4.68c)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
280
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.5: Vapor-cooled HTS current lead—CSV (continuation) c) By equating conduction heat derivable from Eq. 4.62 and that derivable from Eq. 4.67, both at ξcs = cs /, show that ξcs may be given by: [α ]cs e
[α ]cs (1+ξcs ) 2
c˜p (T −Tcs ) βcs = sin βcs (1−ξcs ) hL
(4.69)
Combining Eqs. 4.65a, 4.65b, and 4.69, and noting that:
e e
[α ]cs 2
[α ]cs ξcs 2
1/(2ξcs ) c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) = +1 hL 1/2 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) = +1 hL
(4.70a) (4.70b)
We obtain: cs 1+ξ 2ξcs 1 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) βcs ln +1 +1 = ξcs c˜p (T −Tcs ) hL hL sin βcs (1−ξcs ) (4.71)
˜ [Am ]cs , I◦ , Ic —the Note that for a set of parameters of a CSV lead—˜ ρx , k, only unknown parameter in Eq. 4.71 is ξcs , because the only unknown in βcs (Eq. 4.68c) is also ξcs : ξcs must satisfy both Eqs. 4.68c and 4.71. d) Show that over the fully superconducting section (0 ≤ z ≤ cs ) of this CSV lead, the three power terms are balanced: [Qcs ]cs − [Qin ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p (Tcs − T0 )
(4.72)
where [Qcs ]cs is the conduction heat entering the fully superconducting section at z = cs . e) Show that in the current-sharing region, the four power terms—[Q ]cs , the conduction into the CSV lead at z = ; Qj , the total Joule dissipation generated within the region; [Qcs ]cs , the conduction out of the lead at z = cs ; and convective cooling, m ˙ h c˜p (T −Tcs )—are balanced. [Q ]cs + Qj − [Qcs ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p (T − Tcs )
(4.73)
[Q ]cs + Qj − [Qin ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p (T − T0 )
(4.74)
f ) Show that:
That is, over the entire CSV lead, power is balanced.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
281
Solution to PROBLEM 4.5 a)
By inserting ξ = 0 into Eq. 4.62, we obtain:
e[α ]cs ξcs T0 −Tcs T (0) = 1+ Tcs −T0
T0 (e[α ]cs ξcs −1) Tcs −T0 = = T0 Tcs −T0 e[α ]cs ξcs −1
Tcs −T0 e[α ]cs ξcs −1
(S5.1)
Similarly, by inserting ξ = ξcs into Eq. 4.62, we obtain:
e[α ]cs ξcs T0 −Tcs [α ]cs ξcs T (ξcs ) = e + Tcs −T0
Tcs − T0 Tcs (e[α ]cs ξcs −1) = = Tcs Tcs − T0 e[α ]cs ξcs −1 b)
Tcs −T0 [α e ]cs ξcs −1
(S5.2)
We have:
[Qin ]cs
˜ m ]cs dT k[A = dξ ξ=0
where dT/dξ is evaluated from T (ξ) given by Eq. 4.62. Thus: ˜ m ]cs Tcs −T0 k[A [Qin ]cs = [α ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs hL e[α ]cs ξcs −1
(S5.3)
(S5.4)
Combining [α ]cs given by Eqs. 4.63 and S5.4, we obtain: c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) +1 hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) 1 = ln +1 ξcs hL
e[α ]cs ξcs =
(4.65a)
[α ]cs
(4.65b)
Finally, by combining Eqs. S5.3 and 4.65b, and noting ξcs = cs , we have:
[Qin ]cs
˜ m ]cs hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) k[A = ln +1 c˜p cs hL
(4.64)
Although cs < , [Qin ]cs < [Qin ]fs , given by Eq. 4.60 for FSV, because [Am ]cs /cs is generally less, at most ∼80% of [Am ]fs / for FSV. Also note that Tcs −T0 < T −T0 , which also contributes to making [Qin ]cs < [Qin ]fs .
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
282
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.5 (continuation) c) We can solve for ξcs by equating the temperature slope derivable from Eq. 4.62 and that derivable from Eq. 4.67, both at ξcs = cs /. dT [α ]cs e[α ]cs ξcs (Tcs −T0 ) (from Eq. 4.62) = (S5.5a) dξ cs (e[α ]cs ξcs −1) (from Eq. 4.67)
[α ]cs ξcs dT βcs e 2 (T −Tcs ) = dξ cs e [α2]cs sin βcs (1−ξcs )
(S5.5b)
Equating Eqs. S5.5a and S5.5b, we obtain: [α ]cs ξcs
[α ]cs e[α ]cs ξcs (Tcs −T0 ) βcs e 2 (T −Tcs ) = [α ]cs (e[α ]cs ξcs −1) e 2 sin βcs (1−ξcs )
(S5.6)
Equation S5.6 may be rearranged and combined with Eqs. 4.70 to obtain Eq. 4.71. d)
From Eq. S5.5a, we may compute [Qcs ]cs : ˜ m ]cs dT k[A [Qcs ]cs = dξ cs ˜ m ]cs = k[A
[α ]cs e[α ]cs ξcs (Tcs −T0 ) (e[α ]cs ξcs −1)
(S5.7)
With [α ]cs given by Eq. 4.63 and e[α ]cs ξcs derivable from Eq. 4.70b, we obtain: c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) + 1 (Tcs −T0 ) hL ˙ h ]cs c˜p ˜ m ]cs [m [Qcs ]cs = k[A × c˜ (T −T ) ˜ m ]cs k[A p cs 0 hL
= [m ˙ h ]cs hL
c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) +1 hL
(S5.8)
Because [Qin ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs hL , combining this with Eq. S5.8, we have: ˙ h ]cs c˜p (Tcs − T0 ) [Qcs ]cs − [Qin ]cs = [m
(4.72)
That is, within the fully superconducting section of a CSV lead, power is balanced. [Q ]cs , the conduction into the lead at z = may be evaluated from Eq. 4.67: ˜ m ]cs dT ˜ k[A = k[Am ]cs (T −Tcs ) [Q ]cs = dξ e[α ]cs sin βcs (1−ξcs ) × e[α ]cs 21 [α ]cs sin βcs (1 − βcs ) + βcs cos βcs (1 − ξcs )
e)
=
˜ m ]cs (T −Tcs ) k[A 1 [α ]cs + βcs cot βcs (1 − ξcs ) 2
(S5.9)
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
283
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.5 (continuation) [Qcs ]cs , the conduction out of the lead at z = cs may be evaluated from Eq. S5.5b:
[α ]cs ξcs ˜ m ]cs dT ˜ m ]cs (T −Tcs ) 2 k[A k[A e = [Qcs ]cs = βcs [α ]cs (S5.10) dξ cs e 2 sin βcs (1−ξcs ) By inserting T (ξ), given by Eq. 4.67 (with ξ = z/), into the last term of the left-hand side of Eq. 4.66 and integrating from ξ = ξcs to ξ = 1, we evaluate Qj : 1 [α ]cs ρ˜x I◦ (I◦ −Ic ) Qj = e 2 ξ sin βcs (ξ − ξcs ) dξ (S5.11) [α ]cs [Am ]cs e 2 sin βcs (1−ξcs ) ξcs Making x = ξ −ξcs , we can integrate Eq. S5.11 and obtain: Qj =
=
4˜ ρx I◦ (I◦ −Ic )e
[α ]cs ξcs 2
[α ]cs
2) [Am ]cs e 2 sin βcs (1−ξcs ) ([α ]2cs +4βcs
1−ξcs [α ]cs x [α ]cs 2 × e sin βcs x − βcs cos βcs x 2 0
(S5.12a)
4˜ ρx I◦ (I◦ −Ic ) [α ]cs 2
2) [Am ]cs e sin βcs (1−ξcs ) ([α ]2cs +4βcs [α ]cs [α ]cs ξcs [α ]cs [α ]cs 2 2 2 × e sin βcs (1 − ξcs ) − βcs e cos βcs (1 − ξcs ) + βcs e 2
(S5.12b) From Eq. 4.68b we may derive: 2 [α ]2cs + 4βcs =
4˜ ρx I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 ˜ m ]2 (T −Tcs ) k[A cs
Combining Eqs. S5.12b and S5.13, we obtain: ˜ m ]cs (T −Tcs ) k[A Qj = ×
1 2 [α ]cs
− βcs cot βcs (1 − ξcs ) + βcs
e e
[α ]cs 2
[α ]cs ξcs 2
(S5.14)
sin βcs (1−ξcs )
Combining Eqs. S5.9, S5.10, and S5.14, we obtain: ˜ m ]cs (T −Tcs ) k[A [Q ]cs + Qj − [Qcs ]cs = [α ]cs And from Eqs. S5.15 and 4.63: [Q ]cs + Qj − [Qcs ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p (T − Tcs ) f)
(S5.13)
(S5.15)
(4.73)
By adding Eqs. 4.72 and 4.73, we obtain: [Q ]cs + Qj − [Qin ]cs = [m ˙ h ]cs c˜p (T − T0 )
(4.74)
284
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
Thermal Conductivity & Electrical Resistivity Data of Ag-Au Alloys Figures 4.23 and 4.24 present, respectively, thermal conductivity and electrical resistivity data of Ag-Au alloys [4.78]. Although “pure” silver used in Bi2223 has an advantage of very small electrical resistivity, its thermal conductivity is too great for current leads. A compromise has been to replace pure Ag with Ag-Au in Bi2223 manufactured specifically for use in current leads. 1000 Thermal Conductivity [W/cm K]
Pure Ag
100
0.22at%Au 1at%Au
1
2.9at%Au 11at%Au
0.1
Fig. 4.23
0.085at%Au
10
5
10
20 50 Temperature [K]
100
200 300
Thermal conductivity vs. temperature data of selected Ag-Au alloys [4.78].
10
Resistivity [μΩ cm]
11at%Au
1
2.9at%Au 1at%Au 0.22at%Au
0.1
0.085at%Au
0.01 Pure Ag
0.001
1
2
5
10
20
50
100
200 300
Temperature [K] Fig. 4.24
Electrical resistivity vs. temperature data of selected Ag-Au alloys [4.78].
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
285
DISCUSSION 4.16: Protection of FSV and CSV Current Leads Because each HTS tape (Bi2223/Ag-Au in PROBLEM 4.5) in either an FSV or a CSV lead has a relatively large ic (T ) with a relatively small am , when driven normal it generates a large Joule dissipation in comparison with the available convective cooling: neither lead is capable of surviving an episode of even a short period of flow stoppage. To protect against such a fault-mode incident, the lead must be paralleled with normal-metal tapes that not only reduce Joule dissipation but also increase the cooling surface area. n FSV [Qin ]fs for an FSV lead will be modified to [Qin ]fs , given by: n hL [kA] c˜p (T −T0 ) fs n [Qin ]fs = ln +1 (4.75) c˜p hL where n = k[A ˜ m ]fs + k˜n [An ]fs [kA] (4.76) fs k˜n and [An ]fs are, respectively, the thermal conductivity and total cross sectional area of the normal metal tapes paralleled to the HTS tapes. Note that for the sake n of protection, heat input to the liquid helium is increased because [Qin ]fs > [Qin ]fs , as given by Eq. 4.60. [α]fs , given by Eq. 4.59, is modified to: n c˜p [m ˙ h ]fs n [kA] fs c˜p (T −T0 ) = ln +1 hL
n = [α ]fs
(4.77a)
(4.77b)
n where [m ˙ h ]fs is the effluent helium mass flow rate for an FSV lead paralleled with normal metal tapes.
[Q ]cs + Qj − [Qin ]cs = m ˙ h c˜p (T − T0 ) CSV For a CSV lead, [Qin ]cs , given by Eq. 4.64, is modified to [Qin ]ncs : n hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) [kA] cs n [Qin ]cs = ln +1 c˜p cs hL n = k[A ˜ m ]cs + k˜n [An ]cs [kA] cs
(4.74)
(4.78) (4.79)
where [An ]cs is the total cross sectional area of normal metal tapes used in a CSV lead. Note that cs remains the same whether the CSV lead is paralleled with normal metal tapes or not. Note also that because [Am ]fs and [Am ]cs are different, [An ]fs and [An ]cs can be different. [α ]cs also is different: [m ˙ h ]ncs c˜p n [kA] cs c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) 1 = ln +1 ξcs hL
[α ]ncs =
(4.80a) (4.80b)
where [m ˙ h ]ncs and ξcs (= cs /) are, respectively, the helium mass flow rate and dimensionless length from z = 0 at which the current-sharing region starts for a CSV lead paralleled with normal metal tapes.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
286
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.16: Protection of FSV and CSV Leads (continuation) For the CSV lead, βcs also is modified: n βcs =
ρ˜x ρ˜n I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 − 41 ([α ]ncs )2 n n [kA] [ρA] (T −Tcs ) cs
where
(4.81)
cs
n = ρ˜x [An ]cs + ρ˜n [Am ]cs [ρA] cs
(4.82)
Equation 4.71 is modified as given below: cs 1+ξ n 2ξcs hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) 1 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) βcs ln +1 +1 = n (1−ξ ) ξcs c˜p (T −Tcs ) hL hL sin βcs cs (4.83)
Electricity —Passage from Helen Davis’ The Chemical Elements [4.79] Among the special uses for certain elements, none is more remarkable than the dependence of electrical industry upon copper. Its softness and ductility allow the metal to be drawn into wire which carries the electric current, and its electrical conductivity is greater than that of any other suitable metal except silver [and now, obviously, superconductors]. Alessandro Volta (1745–1827) in 1800 wrote to Sir Joseph Banks,* describing a piece of apparatus he had built: “The apparatus of which I speak to you, and which without doubt will surprise you, is only the assemblage of a number of good conductors of different sorts, arranged in a certain number, 30, 40, 60 pieces, preferably, of copper, or better silver, each touching a piece of tin, or, which is better, of zinc, and an equal number of layers of water, or some other liquid which should be a better conductor than simple water like salt water, lye solution, etc., or pieces of cardboard, leather, etc., well soaked in these liquids; of which pads interposed between each couple or combination of the two different metals, alternating with each set, and always in the same order, of the three sorts of conductors; that is all there is to my new instrument.” Volta drew sparks from his battery, felt light shocks in the wrists of both hands when he touched the top and bottom plates with wet fingers, and admired the way it would, after each discharge, re-establish itself—“an inexhaustible charge, a perpetual effect.” He did not notice the slight corrosion of the metal which accounts for the source of the electric current. * The English botanist Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820) was “that convenient but rare phenomenon, a scientist of great independent wealth who spends that wealth liberally in the support of science. While still a student at Oxford he financed a lectureship in botany, which is how the subject came to be taught there for the first time.” [4.27]
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
287
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.17: HTS Current Lead—Copper Extension Because all HTS current leads, at least those currently available, are usable only up to T ∼ 80 K, every HTS lead, vapor-cooled or not, must be connected to a normalmetal lead to reach the room-temperature terminal. For any vapor-cooled HTS current lead, an optimal vapor-cooled copper lead is the logical choice. However, as mentioned earlier, Qin at 4.2 K of any of these HTS current leads is necessarily smaller than that of an optimal vapor-cooled copper lead rated for the same I◦ . That is, the helium flow rate generated by the HTS lead is insufficient for the copper lead. Extra coolant (see Fig. 4.21) must be introduced at the cold end of the copper lead. Here, the effluent helium vapor of the HTS section is not mixed with the new coolant to be introduced at ∼80 K; it is diverted away, cold. Basically there are two choices for the new coolant: 1) cold gas (helium or nitrogen); and 2) liquid nitrogen boiling at 77.3 K. A. Coolant Fluid Flow Rate To determine the minimum coolant flow rate to be introduced at the cold end of the copper lead, we analyze here an optimal vapor-cooled copper current lead in the temperature range ∼80 K–300 K. For a copper lead carrying I◦ and cooled with fluid mass flow rate, m ˙ fl , the steady-state (dT/dt = 0) power equation, with ζ ≡ z/cu , for a differential element of the copper current lead is given by: k˜cu Acu d2 T m ˙ fl c˜fl dT I◦2 γcu I◦2 ρ◦ − + (T − T ) + =0 ◦ 2 cu dζ 2 cu dζ Acu Acu
(4.84)
In Eq. 4.84 k˜cu and c˜fl are, respectively, the T -averaged copper thermal conductivity and the fluid specific heat; γcu and ρ◦ are, respectively, the resistivity temperature coefficient and resistivity at the cold-end temperature, T◦ (here 77 K). Because over most of the 77–293 K range the last term in the left-hand side of Eq. 4.84 is negligible compared with the third term, Eq. 4.84 may be simplified to:
2 2 d2 T m ˙ fl c˜fl cu dT I◦ γcu cu − + (T − T◦ ) = 0 (4.85) dζ 2 dζ k˜cu Acu k˜cu A2cu With T (ζ = 1) ≡ Tcu , T (0) ≡ T◦ , and θ(ζ) ≡ T (ζ)−T◦ , θ(ζ) may be given by: θ(ζ) =
Tcu −T◦ αcu ζ e α e cu sin βcu
sin βcu ζ
(4.86)
where m ˙ fl c˜fl cu 2k˜cu Acu
2 2 m ˙ fl c˜fl cu I◦2 γcu cu = − 2k˜cu Acu k˜cu A2cu 2 I◦2 γcu cu 2 = − αcu k˜cu A2cu
αcu =
(4.87a)
βcu
(4.87b)
(4.87c)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
288
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.17: HTS Current Lead—Copper Extension (continuation) We may force θmx to occur at ζ = 1 by setting dθ/dζ|ζ=1 = 0 and obtain: αcu sin βcu + βcu cos βcu = 0
(4.88a)
αcu + βcu cot βcu = 0
(4.88b)
For a given set of lead parameters, i.e., Acu , cu , I◦ , c˜fl , γcu , there is a unique set ˙ fl ) that satisfies of αcu and βcu (and thus, from Eq. 4.87a or 4.87b, a value of m Eq. 4.86. Note that cot βcu must be negative, and therefore θmx must be greater than π/2, as we will see later in PROBLEM 4.6D. B. Cold-End Heat Input & Power Balance The cold-end heat input, Q◦ , is given by: k˜cu Acu dθ(ζ) k˜cu Acu θcu βcu Q◦ = = 0 cu dζ 0 cu eαcu sin βcu
(4.89)
Q◦ 0 because of the large value of eαcu . This will indeed be the case in PROBLEM 4.6D, in which a 6-kA copper lead is studied. The warm-end conduction heat, Qcu is, by definition, zero (Eq. 4.88a). Therefore, because no heat enters or leaves the lead by conduction from either end, the coolant is used entirely to remove the Joule dissipation, Qj , generated in the lead: I◦2 γcu cu Qj = θ(z) dz Acu 0 I◦2 γcu cu 1 = θ(ζ) dζ (4.90) Acu 0 Combining Eqs. 4.86 and 4.90, and then invoking Eq. 4.87c, we obtain: I◦2 γcu cu (Tcu −T◦ ) 1 αcu ζ Qj = e sin βcu ζ dζ Acu eαcu sin βcu 0 =
I◦2 γcu cu (Tcu −T◦ ) (αcu − βcu cot βcu ) 2 +β 2 ) Acu (αcu cu + (terms containing e−αcu )
k˜cu Acu (Tcu −T◦ )(αcu − βcu cot βcu ) cu Combined with Eq. 4.88b, Eq. 4.91a becomes: k˜cu Acu Qj = (Tcu −T◦ )(αcu + αcu ) cu Next, combined with Eq. 4.87a, Eq. 4.91b becomes:
˙ fl c˜fl (Tcu −T◦ ) Qj = m
(4.91a)
(4.91b)
(4.92)
Note that, as expected, Eq. 4.92 states that the Joule dissipation generated over the entire length of the copper lead is balanced by the cooling power of fluid introduced at the cold end of the lead.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
289
DISCUSSION 4.17: HTS Current Lead—Copper Extension (continuation) C. Liquid Nitrogen Mass Flow Rate When 77-K liquid nitrogen is introduced at the cold end at a mass flow rate of m ˙ fl , it generates a cooling power, Qn2 = m ˙ fl hn2 , at the cold end, where hn2 = 199 J/g is the liquid’s latent heat of vaporization at 77 K. When a vapor-cooled copper lead is operated down to the liquid helium environment, Qin is matched by m ˙ h hL , where hL = 20.7 J/g is the helium heat of vaporization; m ˙ h of helium vapor is sufficient to keep the entire lead stable. Because Q◦ 0, as remarked above, the cooling power of liquid nitrogen, m ˙ fl hn2 , cannot be matched at the cold end. What actually happens is that m ˙ fl hn2 soaks up the Joule dissipation generated over the lower portion of the copper lead, from the cold end to a distance of q . That is, the 77-K point instead of being anchored at the cold end now extends from z = 0 to z = q . This extended 77-K portion of the lead, because it is resistive, generates Joule dissipation Qjq , which is matched by m ˙ fl hn2 . Noting that the last term in the left-hand side of Eq. 4.84, neglected in Eq. 4.85, cannot be neglected at 77 K, we have: Qjq =
ρ◦ I◦2 q =m ˙ fl hn2 Acu
(4.93)
q and m ˙ fl in Eq. 4.93 are not yet known. With the lower portion of the lead (z = q long) at 77 K, the effective vapor-cooled length of the lead is shortened to (cu − q ), and Eq. 4.88b thus becomes: αcu + βcu cot βcu =0
(4.94)
where αcu =
m ˙ fl c˜fl (cu −q ) 2k˜cu Acu
βcu
=
I◦2 γcu (cu −q )2 )2 − (αcu k˜cu A2
(4.95a)
(4.95b)
cu
There is a unique combination of m ˙ fl and q that satisfies both Eqs. 4.93 and 4.94.
Conversion from Wt% to At% In the thermal conductivity and electrical resistivity data of Ag-Au (metal A–metal B) alloys shown in Figs. 4.23 and 4.24, the gold contents are given in Xat at%Au— an atomic weight (mole) %. However, superconductor manufacturers often express the gold content in Xwt wt%Au—a weight (mass) %, as in Table 4.12 next page. The conversion from Xwt %B to Xat %B of metal B of atomic weight WB alloyed in metal A of atomic weight WA is given by: Xat %B =
100Xwt %B ×WA (100 − Xwt %B)×WB + Xwt %B ×WA
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
290
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.6: 6-kA vapor-cooled HTS current lead In PROBLEM 4.6, the design concepts discussed in PROBLEMS 4.4 and 4.5 are applied for three types of 6-kA vapor-cooled HTS leads: A) FSV, with no parallel normal metal tapes; B) FSV, with 120 parallel normal metal tapes; and C) CSV also with the same number of normal metal tapes. Table 4.12 shows key parameters of Bi2223/Ag-Au tape. In the table, am is the cross sectional area of Ag-Au matrix in one tape: thus, [Am ]fs = Nfs am ; Ic (T ) = Nfs ic (T ); and Ic (T0 ) = Nfs ic (T0 ). Each tape is assumed to be exposed to a normal field of 0.2 T over its entire active length. k˜ and ρ˜x are, respectively, the average thermal conductivity and electrical resistivity of Ag-Au over the temperature range indicated in Table 4.12. Table 4.13 shows key parameters of brass tape.
PROBLEM 4.6A: FSV, with no parallel normal metal tapes a) Show that Nfs = 75 for this 6-kA vapor-cooled FSV lead. b) Show that [Qin ]fs = 0.0786 W for this lead with = 20 cm. Here, must be “long” on one hand to ensure good heat exchange with effluent vapor, while “short” on the other to limit the cost of the Bi2223/Ag-Au tapes. c) Verify that Eq. 4.61 is satisfied for this lead by computing each power term. Table 4.12: Parameters of Bi2223/Ag-Au Tape Parameters Overall width [mm] Overall thickness [mm] Bi2223 filling (volume) [%] Au content [wt%] Ag-Au cross section, am [mm2 ] Tape cross section [mm2 ] ic (T ) (@77.3 K @B⊥ = 0.2 T) [A] ic (T0 ) (@4.2 K @B⊥ = 0.2 T) [A] ˜ k (4.2–77 K) [W/cm K] ρ ˜x (T –77 K) [μΩ cm]
Value 4.2 0.228 42 5.3 0.555 0.958 80* 445.5† 0.327 1.0
* 1-μV/cm criterion. † At 4.2 K the effect of B⊥ = 0.2 T is negligible.
Table 4.13: Parameters of Normal Metal (Brass) Tape Parameters Width (each tape) [mm] Thickness (each tape) [mm] Total # of paralleled tapes [An ]fs and [An ]cs [cm2 ] ˜n (4.2–77 K) [W/cm K] k ρ ˜n (4.2–77 K) [μΩ cm]
Value 4.203 0.344 120 1.735 0.350 2.25
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
291
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6A a)
Because I◦ = Nfs ic (T ), we have: Nfs = 6,000 A/80 A = 75.
b) With 5.28 J/g K 20 cm into
k˜ = 0.327 W/cm K; [Am ]fs = Nfs am = 0.416 cm2 ; hL = 20.7 J/g; c˜p = (averaged between 4.2 K and 77 K) ; T = 77.3 K; T0 = 4.2 K, and = Eq. 4.60, we obtain: ˜ m ]fs hL c˜p (T −T0 ) k[A [Qin ]fs = ln +1 (4.60) c˜p hL =
(0.327 W/cm K)(0.416 cm2 )(20.7 J/g) (5.28 J/g K)(20 cm) (5.28 J/g K)(77.3 K−4.2 K) × ln +1 (20.4 J/g)
= 0.0798 W As studied in DISCUSSION 4.14 (Eq. 4.32b ), a copper vapor-cooled 6-kA lead would have had Qin 6 W; thus, ∼0.08 W is indeed an impressive improvement. ˙ h ]fs = [Qin ]fs /hL = 0.00385 g/s. Heat c) With [Qin ]fs = 0.0798 W, we obtain [m input at z = is given by the first form of Eq. S4.5b: c˜p (T −T0 ) ˙ h ]fs hL [Q ]fs = [m +1 hL (5.28 J/g K)(77.3 K−4.2 K) = (0.00385 g/s)(20.7 J/g) +1 (20.7 J/g) = 1.566 W Thus: [Q ]fs−[Qin ]fs = 1.486 W, which essentially equals [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p (T−T0 ) = 1.487 W.
TRIVIA 4.5
Of the statements below on bismuth, which is incorrect ?
i) A diamagnet with an usually large susceptibility; ii) Like water, expands upon freezing; iii) One of the four elements familiar to the medieval alchemist; iv) A superconductor with a critical temperature of 0.83 K.
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
292
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.6B: FSV, with parallel normal metal tapes Here, we study an FSV lead with 120 normal metal tapes, [An ]fs = 1.735 cm2 (Table 4.13), paralleled to the FSV lead of PROBLEM 4.6A. Although not demonstrated here, for this lead a normal metal of 1.735-cm2 cross section is sufficient against flow stoppage incidents that may occur in typical operating conditions. n a) Using Eq. 4.75, compute [Qin ]fs . Because of the presence of normal metal n tapes, [An ]fs [Am ]fs , [Qin ]fs [Qin ]fs = 0.0798 W computed above.
b) Verify numerically that the power terms are balanced for this lead too.
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6B a)
n using Eq. 4.76. Note that again [Am ]fs = 0.416 cm2 . First, we compute [kA] fs n = (0.327 W/cm K)(0.416 cm2 ) + (0.350 W/cm K)(1.735 cm2 ) [kA] fs = 0.136 W cm/K + 0.607 W cm/K = 0.743 W cm/K
From Eq. 4.75, we have: n [Qin ]fs
n hL c˜ (T −T ) [kA] fs p 0 = ln +1 c˜p hL =
(4.75)
(0.743 W cm/K)(20.7 J/g) (5.28 J/g K)(20 cm) (5.28 J/g K)(77.3 K−4.2 K) × ln + 1 = 0.4337 W (20.7 J/g)
n Note that although indeed [Qin ]fs [Qin ]fs , 0.4337 W is still only ∼1/14 of the copper counterpart (∼6 W). Also note, from Eq. 4.35b, that for an optimal vaporcooled copper lead rated at 6 kA with 20-cm active length (), A = 0.480 cm2 , n is still ∼30% of [An ]fs = 1.735 cm2 . Despite this large [An ]fs the reason [Qin ]fs ˜ ∼1/14 of QI◦ (Eq. 4.32a) is principally because kn k0 , where k0 is the copper thermal conductivity near 4.2 K, i.e., 0.350 W/cm K (k˜n ) vs. 6 W/cm K (k0 ). Also note that this lead generates no Joule dissipation over this part () of the lead. n n n b) With [Qin ]fs = 0.4337 W, we obtain [m ˙ h ]fs = [Qin ]fs /hL 0.021 g/s. Heat n input at z = , [Q ]fs , though not derived, is similar to Eq. S4.5b. Thus:
c˜p (T −T0 ) +1 hL (5.28 J/g K)(77.3 K−4.2 K) (0.021 g/s)(20.7 J/g) + 1 = 8.540 W (20.7 J/g)
n n [Q ]fs = [m ˙ h ]fs hL
n n n −[Qin ]fs = 8.106 W [m ˙ h ]fs c˜p (T −T0 ) = 8.105 W. We have thus: [Q ]fs
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
293
PROBLEM 4.6C: CSV, with parallel normal metal tapes Here, we shall consider an example of a CSV lead with Ncs = (2/3)Nfs = 50 and the same number (120) of normal metal tapes added as in the FSV studied above. a) Show that Tcs = 69.3 K for this CSV lead. Assume that ic (T ) is a linear function of T , with ic (T0 ) = 445.5 A and ic (T ) = 80 A, as given in Table 4.12. b) For = 20 cm (same value as the FSV counterparts), determine ξcs for this CSV for a special—simple—case in which: n (1−ξcs ) = 1 sin βcs n (1 − ξcs ) = π/2 βcs
(4.96a) (4.96b)
n You may determine ξcs iteratively, first guessing a value of ξcs , compute βcs n from Eq. 4.96b, then insert ξcs and βcs into Eq. 4.83 to see if Eq. 4.83 is indeed satisfied. Because ic (T ) is assumed a linear function of T , an appropriate starting value of ξcs into Eq. 4.96b may be 0.9 ( 69.3/77.3). n n c) Verify that βcs found in b) agrees with βcs computed by Eq. 4.81.
d) Compute [Qin ]ncs , the heat input to liquid helium at z = 0, given by Eq. 4.78. e) Numerically compute each term appearing in the following power balance equation and demonstrate that power is balanced. [Q ]ncs + [Qj ]ncs − [Qin ]ncs = [m ˙ h ]ncs c˜p (T − T0 )
(4.97)
[Q ]ncs is the heat into the lead at z = ; [Qj ]ncs is the Joule dissipation within the current-sharing region; and [Qcs ]cs is the heat out of the lead at z = cs . [Q ]ncs and [Qj ]ncs are given by modified forms of Eq. S5.9 and Eq. S5.14: n (T −Tcs ) [kA] cs 1 n n [α ]ncs + βcs cot βcs (1 − ξcs ) 2 n (T −Tcs ) [kA] cs n 1 n n n [Qj ]cs = 2 [α ]cs − βcs cot βcs (1 − ξcs )
[α ]n cs ξcs e 2 n + βcs [α ]ncs n (1−ξ ) e 2 sin βcs cs [Q ]ncs =
(4.98)
(4.99)
n (1−ξcs ) = π/2 here, Eqs. 4.98 and 4.99 are simplified: Note that because βcs
n (T −Tcs ) [kA] cs × 21 [α ]ncs n (T −Tcs ) [α ]n [kA] cs (ξcs −1) cs 1 n n 2 [Qj ]ncs = [α ] + β e cs 2 cs [Q ]ncs =
(4.100) (4.101)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
294
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6C a) Because Ic (T ) = Ncs ic (T ), with Ncs = 50 and, from Table 4.12, ic (T ) = 80 A, we have: Ic (T ) = 50×80 A = 4,000 A at T = 77.3 K; similarly, Ic (T0 ) = 22,275 A at T0 = 4.2 K. Thus, this particular set of Bi2223/Ag-Au tapes has the following Ic (T ) between 77.3 K and 4.2 K: Ic (T ) = 23,325 − 250T [A]
(S6C.1)
where T is in kelvins. This equation gives Tc = 93.3 K. From Eq. S6C.1, we can solve for Tcs at which Ic (Tcs ) = 6,000 A: Tcs = 69.3 K. b)
n = 28.586. As shown in Table 4.14 below, ξcs = 0.94505, which gives βcs
c) [Am ]cs = Ncs am = 50×0.555 mm2 (from Table 4.12) = 0.2775 cm2 ; and [An ]cs = [An ]fs = 1.735 cm2 (Table 4.13) and thus, from Eqs. 4.79, 4.82, and 4.80b: n = k[A ˜ m ]cs + k˜n [An ]cs [kA] cs
(4.79)
= (0.327 W/cm K)(0.2775 cm2 ) + (0.350 W/cm K)(1.735 cm2 ) = 0.0907 W cm/K + 0.607 W cm/K = 0.698 W cm/K ncs = ρ˜x [An ]cs + ρ˜n [Am ]cs [ρA]
(4.82)
= (1 μΩ cm)(1.735 cm2 ) + (2.25 μΩ cm)(0.2775 cm2 ) = 1.735 μΩ cm3 + 0.624 μΩ cm3 = 2.359 μΩ cm3 c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) 1 n [α ]cs = n ln +1 ξcs hL (5.28 J/g K)(69.3 K−4.2 K) 1 = ln +1 0.94505 (20.7 J/g) =
(4.80b)
1 ln(17.605) = 3.035 0.94505
Thus, ([α ]ncs )2 /4, required to compute Eq. 4.81 is given by: n 2 1 4 ([α ]cs )
= 2.303
n n Table 4.14: Determination of ξcs and βcs
Guess Value of ξcs 0.9 0.95 0.94 0.945 0.9451 0.94505
Eq. 4.96b n βcs *
Left-Hand Side Eq. 4.83
15.708 32.3975 31.4159 28.2120 26.1799 28.9759 28.5599 28.5898 28.6120 28.5821 28.5859 28.5860
n n * sin βcs (1−ξcs ) = 1 and thus βcs is equal to the left-hand side of Eq. 4.83.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
295
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6C (continuation) Inserting appropriate values into Eq. 4.81, we obtain: ρ˜x ρ˜n I◦ (I◦ −Ic )2 n βcs = − 41 ([α ]ncs )2 n n [kA] [ρA] (T −Tcs ) cs
28.586 = 28.586
(4.81)
cs
(1 μΩ cm)(2.25 μΩ cm)(6 kA)(6 kA−4 kA)(20 cm)2 − 2.303 (0.698 W cm/K)(2.359 μΩ cm3 )(77.3 K−69.3 K)
√ 817.58 = 28.593
d) With ξcs = 0.94505 and = 20 cm: cs = 18.9 cm. The current-sharing region for this CSV lead thus spans 1.1 cm, from z = 18.9 cm to z = 20 cm. From Eq. 4.78: n hL c˜p (Tcs −T0 ) [kA] cs n [Qin ]cs = ln +1 (4.78) c˜p cs hL (5.28 J/g K)(69.3 K−4.2 K) (0.698 W cm/K)(20.7 J/g) = ln +1 (5.28 J/g K)(18.9 cm) (20.7 J/g) = (0.1448 W)(2.868) = 0.4153 W n Thus, as expected [Qin ]ncs = 0.4153 W < [Qin ]fs = 0.4296 W; [Qin ]ncs is ∼1/15 that of n ˙ h ]ncs = 0.02006 g/s. a copper counterpart. From [Qin ]cs = 0.4153 W, [m
e)
Applying Eqs. 4.100 and 4.101, we have: n (T −Tcs ) [α ]n [kA] cs cs n [Q ]cs = 2 =
[Qj ]ncs
(0.698 W cm/K)(77.3 K−69.3 K) (20 cm)
(4.100)
3.035 2
= 0.4237 W
n (T − Tcs ) [α ]n [α ]n [kA] cs (ξcs −1) cs cs n 2 = + βcs e (4.101) 2 n (T −Tcs ) 3.035 3.035(0.945−1) [kA] cs 2 = + (28.586)e 2
(0.698 W cm/K)(77.3 K−69.3 K) 3.035 = + 26.30 = 7.7658 W (20 cm) 2
With [m ˙ h ]ncs c˜p (T − T0 ) = (0.02006 g/s)(5.28 J/g K)(77.3 K−4.2 K) = 7.7743 W and n [Qin ]cs = 0.4153 W, we obtain: [Q ]ncs + [Qj ]ncs − [Qin ]ncs = [m ˙ h ]ncs c˜p (T − T0 ) 0.4237 W + 7.7658 − 0.4153 = 7.7742 W 7.7743 W
(4.97)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
296
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.18: “Optimal” CSV Lead As we have seen from the numerical power check in e) of PROBLEM 4.6C, the largest power component is [Qj ]ncs = 7.7659 W, yet [Qin ]ncs = 0.4153 W is very nearly n = 0.4337 W for the FSV counterpart. the same as [Qin ]fs Thus, despite the large value of [Qj ]ncs , the only way this CSV lead can have [Qin ]ncs n n comparable with [Qin ]fs is to have [Q ]ncs [Q ]fs . This is indeed the case, as may n = 8.540 W, while be seen from Solution b) of PROBLEM 4.6B, which shows: [Q ]fs n Solution e) of PROBLEM 4.6C shows: [Q ]cs = 0.4237 W. How can this be? The answer may be seen from Eq. 4.98, given again here: [Q ]ncs =
n (T −Tcs ) [kA] cs 1 n n [α ]ncs + βcs cot βcs (1 − ξcs ) 2
(4.98)
n It is possible to make [Q ]ncs = 0 by a suitable choice of βcs and ξcs in the bracketed n n (1−ξcs ) < 0, term of the right-hand side of Eq. 4.98. For βcs (1−ξcs ) > π/2, cot βcs n n and there indeed exists a set of βcs and ξcs that not only makes [Q ]cs = 0 but also satisfies Eq. 4.83. Such a set in fact minimizes [Qin ]ncs , giving rise to an “optimal” CSV lead that is loaded with normal metal to satisfy a protection criterion.
Heike Kamerlingh Onnes (1853–1926) —Passage from K. Mendelssohn’s The Quest for Absolute Zero [4.80] In 1882 the University of Leiden appointed to the chair of physics a young man of only twenty nine whose early work had already given great promise. He came from an old family in Groningen in the north of Holland,. . . Two years earlier [Kamerlingh] Onnes had been much impressed by one of van der Waals’ papers which dealt with the concept of corresponding states . . . was particularly intrigued by the prediction of the critical points of as yet unliquefied gases which could be made on the basis of the van der Waals equation . . . Although he was deeply interested in the great revolution of physical concepts and theories which was to take place during his lifetime, his main preoccupation was with the measurements from which these new ideas were to arise. He was essentially an experimentalist with a keen sense for the engineering problems involved in the perfection and proper use of scientific instruments. Without ever becoming a perfectionist, he was acutely aware of the importance of careful planning and organisation for the success of an experiment and he used these ideas on a scale which had never previously been attempted in a physical laboratory. Quite apart from the decisive role which his laboratory played in the development of low-temperature research, it also served as the model for the research institutions of the twentieth century. Kamerlingh Onnes was not only a master of organisational genius, he was also a good and patient diplomatist and a wise man. His great strength was to plan not for tomorrow but for the day after. The secret of the steady output of brilliant work which issued from his institute lay in the fact that each experiment had been thoroughly thought out and prepared long before work on it was begun. [Kamerlingh] Onnes was probably the first scientist to realise that the complexity of modern research techniques would require a reliable supply of skilled and specially trained assistants. He sensed that the time of the amateur professor was over, who could go into the laboratory and discover the secrets of nature in odd afternoons with the aid of string and sealing wax . . .
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
297
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.6D: Copper section (∼80 K–300 K) Here, we study a 6-kA vapor-cooled copper current lead that may be coupled to either the FSV lead studied in PROBLEM 4.6B or the CSV lead studied in PROBLEM 4.6C. We shall determine values of three fluid flow rates: 1) gaseous helium; 2) gaseous nitrogen; and 3) liquid nitrogen. For the liquid nitrogen case, we shall also determine the value of q . Table 4.15 lists values of key parameters for a 6-kA vapor-cooled copper lead. Note that the cold end (z = 0) is at 77.3 K and the warm end (z = cu ) is at 293 K. a) Determine m ˙ fl when the coolant is gaseous helium entering the cold-end (z = 0) point at 77.3 K. b) As discussed in connection with Eq. 4.89, demonstrate here that Q◦ , the cold-end conduction heat input, is indeed negligibly small. c) Determine m ˙ fl when the coolant is gaseous nitrogen entering the cold-end (z = 0) point at 77.3 K. d) Determine m ˙ fl when the coolant is liquid nitrogen entering the cold-end (z = 0) point at 77.3 K. Also determine q .
Table 4.15: Parameters of 6-kA Vapor-Cooled Copper Lead Parameters
Value
Operating range (T◦ –Tcu ) [K] 77.3–300 Active area, Acu [cm2 ] 1.19 Active length, cu [cm] 38 Area exposed to coolant [cm2 ] 12,650 ˜cu (77–300 K) [W/cm K] k 4 ˜cfl (77–300 K): helium [J/g K] 5.28 ˜cfl (77–300 K): nitrogen [J/g K] 1.04 hn2 (77.3 K) [J/g] 199 ρ◦ (77 K) [μΩ cm] 0.22 γcu (77–300 K) [nΩ cm/K] 7.01
Answer to TRIVIA 4.5 iv). Although itself a nonsuperconductor (even at 0.83 K), Element 83 is a key constituent of HTS. The other three substances of the alchemist: antimony (Sb); arsenic (As); and zinc (Zn).
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
298
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6D a)
Inserting parameter values from Table 4.15 into Eq. 4.87c, we have: 2 I◦2 γcu cu (6 kA)2 (7.01 nΩ cm/K)(38 cm)2 2 = 2 βcu = − αcu − αcu (4 W/cm K)(1.19 cm2 )2 k˜cu A2cu 2 = 64.333 − αcu (S6D.1)
There is a set of βcu and αcu that satisfies both Eqs. 4.88b and S6D.1. These two equations may be solved iteratively; Table 4.16 gives results of the iteration. From Table 4.16, we note that βcu = 2.786750 2.786885, and thus αcu = 7.521055. Solving m ˙ fl from Eq. 4.87a, we have: m ˙ fl = =
2αcu k˜cu Acu c˜fl cu
(S6D.2)
2(7.521)(4 W/cm K)(1.19 cm2 ) = 0.357 g/s (5.28 J/g K)(38 cm)
A helium mass flow rate of 0.357 g/s computed here is very close to the boiling liquid helium mass flow rate m ˙ h corresponding to an AMI 6-kA vapor-cooled ˙ h ∼ 0.35 g/s (∼ 7.2 W/20.4 J/g). Note that the copper lead, i.e., Qin ∼ 7.2 W: m total cooling power between 77.3 K and 293 K is 407 W, given by m ˙ fl c˜fl (Tcu −T◦ ). b) Inserting eαcu = e7.521055 = 1846, sin(159.669◦ ) = 0.3474, θcu = 293 K−77 K = 216 K, and other parameter values into Eq. 4.89, we obtain: k˜cu Acu dθ(ζ) k˜cu Acu θcu βcu Q◦ = = 0 (4.89) cu dζ cu eαcu sin βcu 0
=
(4 W/cm K)(1.19 cm2 )(216 K)(2.787) 0.118 W 0 (38cm)(1846)(0.3474)
c) The values of βcu and αcu determined in a) are also valid for gaseous nitrogen entering the cold-end (z = 0) at 77.3 K. The only difference between helium and ˙ fl = 1.812 g/s. nitrogen is c˜fl , which for the latter is 1.04 J/g K. Thus: m Table 4.16: Determination of βcu and αcu βcu [degree]
Eq. 4.88b − cot βcu
βcu
Eq. 4.88b αcu
Eq. 4.87c βcu
150 160 159 159.5 159.6 159.7 159.65 159.67 159.669
1.732051 2.747477 2.605089 2.674621 2.688919 2.703351 2.696118 2.699007 2.698863
2.617994 2.792527 2.775074 2.783800 2.785545 2.787291 2.786418 2.786767 2.786750
4.534498 7.672404 7.229314 7.445612 7.490106 7.535026 7.512513 7.521505 7.521055
6.615990 2.338207 3.474194 2.982594 2.869026 2.748887 2.809832 2.785671 2.786885
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
299
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.6D (continuation) d) Here, we have to determine the value of q that satisfies Eqs. 4.93, 4.94, and 4.95 for given parameter values of ρ◦ , γcu , I◦ , and k˜cu , and Acu . Again, it is simplest to determine q iteratively. Thus we proceed along the following steps: Step 1 Guess q (1st column in Table 4.17); Step 2 Compute m ˙ fl from Eq. 4.93 (2nd column); ˙ fl into Eq. 4.95a, and compute αcu (3rd column); Step 3 Insert q and m inserted into Eq. 4.95b, compute βcu (4th column); Step 4 With this αcu in degrees (5th column): it must be between 90◦ and 180◦ ; Step 5 Express this βcu (6th column); Step 6 Compute − cot βcu using Eq. 4.94 (7th column). Step 7 Compute αcu computed in Step 7 agrees with that computed in Step 3, the iteration If αcu process is complete and q guessed at the outset of this iteration is correct. Table 4.17 gives results of the above iteration, and it shows that q = 26.98 cm ( 27 cm) and m ˙ fl = 0.902 g/s are the desired values.
Thus, with liquid nitrogen in the lower section of the copper lead, specifically over a length of 27 cm, and soaked by a mixture of liquid and gaseous nitrogen, this section is at 77.3 K. Only the remaining section, extending from z 27 cm to z = 38 cm is cooled by a flow of gaseous nitrogen; its temperature rises from 77.3 K at z 27 cm to 293 K at z = 38 cm. In comparing with m ˙ fl = 1.812 g/s found in c) with 77.3-K gaseous nitrogen, we note that liquid nitrogen requires less (∼1/2) mass flow rate. This is because liquid nitrogen contributes a large dose of cooling upon vaporization at 77.3 K, i.e., 199 J/g, which with c˜fl = 1.04 J/g K of nitrogen, is equivalent to a temperature rise of gaseous nitrogen of nearly 200 K. If the coolant to be introduced at the cold end of the copper current lead is to be 77.3-K nitrogen, the results of c) and d) suggest that 77.3-K liquid is likely preferable to 77.3-K gas. Table 4.17: Determination of q , βcu , and αcu
Eq. 4.93 q [cm] m ˙ fl [g/s]
Eq. 4.95a αcu
βcu
10 20 26 27 26.9 26.98 26.9805 26.9802 26.9804
1.023033 1.315298 1.139925 1.085120 1.089288 1.086289 1.086259 1.086277 1.086265
5.820835 3.564382 2.261869 2.052632 2.074294 2.056789 2.056686 2.056748 2.056706
0.3334453 0.668891 0.869558 0.903002 0.898304 0.902334 0.902350 0.902340 0.902347
Eq. 4.95b Eq. 4.94 βcu [degree] − cot βcu αcu 333.5 204.2 129.595532 117.607165 118.848308 117.845335 117.839402 117.842976 117.840594
no solution no solution 0.827141 1.870884 0.522947 1.073417 0.550853 1.142631 0.528252 1.086503 0.528119 1.086175 0.528199 1.086373 0.528146 1.086241
300
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.7: Vapor-cooled brass current lead Vapor-cooled current leads for a superconducting magnet operated in a bath of liquid helium may be entirely of copper (DISCUSSION 4.14 ) or superconducting over the lower cold section (PROBLEMS 4.4–4.6), extended to the room-temperature terminal by a copper lead rated at the same current. In some applications, current leads carry a rated current only occasionally or even rarely during the life of a magnet [4.81–4.84]. Examples of occasional use include magnets of low duty cycle in which the magnets are energized periodically, each time for a short duration. When the total duration of “off-current” operation far exceeds that of “on-current” operation, it may be possible to reduce the long-term consumption of helium with vapor-cooled leads having a Q0 /QI◦ ratio (Eq. 4.42) significantly smaller than the ∼0.6 achievable with copper leads. Because Q0 ∝ k˜ (Eq. 4.40), such low-Q0 leads should be of an alloy (e.g., brass), rather than pure copper. It necessarily implies that such an alloy lead would have Joule dissipation rate greater than its copper counterpart. Because the effluent helium flow rate would remain roughly the same, to be effective, the alloy lead must operate in overcurrent mode, and the thermal behavior of such a lead in overcurrent mode becomes an important design and operation issue [4.85]. For the questions below, use the following property values for brass: thermal conductivity, [k0 ]br = 22 W/m K, and resistivity, [ρ0 ]br = 21 nΩ m, both at T0 , and T dT/ρbr (T ) = 0.97×1010 K/Ω m [4.86]. T0 a) Show that for brass leads (I◦ /A), which is approximately 2.3×107 A/m for copper (Eq. 4.35b), is given by: I◦ ≡ [ζ◦ ]br 0.35×107 A/m (4.102) A br That is, a brass lead having the same and A as those of a copper lead will have its optimal rated current ∼1/7 that of the copper lead. b) Show that [QI◦ /I◦ ]br , the ratio of the cold-end heat input to rated current for the brass lead, is given by: QI◦ 1.25 mW/A (4.103) I◦ br This ratio is 0.77 mW/A for copper leads (Eq. 4.32b ). Note that for the brass lead, despite its much greater resistivity—by a factor of ∼100—than copper’s at 4.2 K, [QI◦ /I◦ ]br is only ∼60% greater than QI◦ /I◦ (for copper). c) Show that [Q0 /QI◦ ]br , the ratio of cold-end heat input of a brass lead with no current (I = 0) to that of the lead at I◦ is given by: Q0 0.21 (4.104) QI◦ br Use k˜br = 55 W/m K (Table 4.18); c˜p = 5.2 kJ/kg K; and cp0 = 6.0 kJ/kg K.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
301
& DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.7: Vapor-cooled brass current lead (continuation) Overcurrent Mode As stated above, brass leads are suitable for low-duty-cycle applications. Consider a brass current lead in the overcurrent mode carrying a constant current I > I◦ , the nominal rated current. The power equation may be given by: dT d dT dT ρbr (T ) 2 ACbr (T ) = Akbr (T ) −m ˙ br (I)cp (T ) + I (4.105) dt dz dz dz A where Cbr (T ), kbr (T ), and ρbr (T ) are, respectively, the temperature-dependent heat capacity, thermal conductivity, and electrical resistivity of brass, and m ˙ br (I) is the vapor flow rate, which depends on current. For an optimal brass lead at I > I◦ in stable operation, dT/dt = 0: the temperature of a differential element of the lead, though it depends on z, is constant with time. To solve Eq. 4.105 at I > I◦ , we make the following assumptions. 1. The entire lead is treated as a single entity with an average temperature of T˜, which is further assumed to be at the midpoint (z = /2) temperature. Cbr (T ) and cp (T ) are also assumed constants, respectively, C˜br and c˜p . ˜ ˜ 2. dT/dz appearing in Eq. 4.105 is assumed constant, T/(/2) = 2T/. ˙ br (I) = νbr I[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )], where νbr and ηbr are constants. 3. For I > I◦ m ˜ T˜◦ ), where T˜◦ is the initial midpoint temperature (when 4. ρbr (T ) = [ρ0 ]br+γbr (T− I = I◦ ); for brass, [ρ0 ]br = 21 nΩ m and γbr = 74 pΩ m/K [4.86]. With these assumptions, Eq. 4.105 becomes: AC˜br
dT˜(t) T˜(t) [ρ0 ]br 2 γbr ˜ = −νbr I[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )]˜ cp + I + [T (t) − T˜◦ ]I 2 (4.106) dt (/2) A A
Inserting θ(t) = T˜(t)− T˜◦ to Eq. 4.106, we have dθ(t)/dt and solution θ(t):
1 dθ(t) = 2νbr c˜p AI[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )] − γbr I 2 θ(t) dt A2 C˜br 2 ˜ (4.107a) + 2νbr c˜p AT◦ I[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )] − [ρ0 ]br I θ(t) = Δθ(I) 1 − e−t/τj (I)
(4.107b)
Δθ(I) and τj (I), both I-dependent constants, are, respectively, the temperature rise and response time, which is assumed to be much longer than the period during which the condition I > I◦ is established. Solving for Δθ(I) and τj (I), we have: Δθ(I) =
τj (I) =
[ρ0 ]br I 2 −2νbr c˜p AT˜◦ I[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )] 2νbr c˜p AI[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )]− γbr I 2
(4.108a)
A2 C˜br 2νbr c˜p AI[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )]−γbr I 2
(4.108b)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
302
&
DISCUSSIONS
PROBLEM 4.7: Vapor-cooled brass current lead (continuation) d) Show that νbr is given by: νbr =
[ρ0 ]br I◦ 2˜ cp AT˜◦
(4.109)
e) Show that in the overcurrent region, [QI ]br , the heat input is given by: [QI ]br = hL νbr I[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )] f ) Show that [I◦ /A]br , given by Eq. 4.102, is also given by: I◦ 2˜ cp T˜◦ [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br = A br [ρ0 ]br hL cp0
(4.110)
(4.111)
where cp0 is the helium specific heat at the cold-end temperature. g) The voltage across the entire lead, Vbr (t) is given by: Vbr (t) = V◦ (T˜◦ ) + ΔV (I)(1 − e−t/τj (I) )
(4.112)
where V◦ (T˜◦ ) is the steady-state lead voltage when the lead is carrying I◦ . Show that ΔV (I), a constant at I, is given by: γbr [ρ0 ]br I 2 − 2νbr c˜p AT˜◦ I[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )] ΔV (I) = I (4.113) A 2νbr c˜p AI[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )]− γbr I 2 h) Consider a vapor-cooled brass lead rated at 25 kA under a cyclic operation in which it is subjected to an overcurrent of 75 kA (= 3×I◦ ) over a 5-min period, followed by a 30-min off-current period. As may become evident from experimental results performed on a 40-A brass lead [4.87], presented later in Figs. 4.25 and 4.26, the 40-A brass lead can operate stably at an overcurrent of up to nearly 200 A (= 5 × I◦ ) over an indefinite period of time—in the experiment the overcurrent condition at a given I lasts only up to 500 s. Determine I◦ of a vapor-cooled copper lead that when operated at I◦ continuously results in the same cold-end heat input as that of the 25-kA brass lead operated in the mode described above. Use νbr = 6.13 × 10−8 kg/s A, determined in the experiment [4.87], and ηbr = 2.2×10−5 A−1 , scaled to a 25kA lead from the experiment (ηbr = 0.0138 A−1 at I◦ = 40 A). For the copper lead, use QI◦ /I◦ = 1 mW/A.
TRIVIA 4.6
List the metals below in the descending order of their electrical resistivities.
i) Aluminum 1100 at 4.2 K; iii) Copper (RRR 100) at 50 K;
ii) Copper (RRR 20, 000) at 100 K; iv) Copper (RRR 100) at 4.2 K in a 20-T field.
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
303
& DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.7 a)
From Eq. 4.35, [I◦ /A]br for brass leads is:
I◦ A
cp0 [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br hL
= br
T
T0
dT ρbr (T )
(S7.1)
With cp0 = 6.0 kJ/kg K and other property values inserted into Eq. S7.1, we have:
I◦ A
= br
(6.0 kJ/kg K)(22 W/m K)(21 nΩ m) (0.97×1010 K/Ω m) (20.7 kJ/kg)
Thus:
I◦ A
≡ [ζ◦ ]br 0.35×107 A/m
(4.102)
br
b) From Eq. 4.32a, which is for copper leads, we obtain:
QI◦ I◦
= br
hL [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br = cp0
Thus:
QI◦ I◦
(20.4 kJ/kg)(22 W/m K)(21 nΩ m) (6.0 kJ/kg K)
(S7.2)
1.25 mW/A
(4.103)
br
c) From Eq. 4.41 with k˜br = 55 W/m K (Table 4.18) and other values, including ln[˜ cp (T −T0 )/hL + 1] 4.32, we have:
Q0 QI◦
br
c˜p (T −T0 ) hL cp0 ×ln +1 (S7.3) [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br hL (55 W/m K) (20.7 kJ/kg)(6.0 kJ/kg K) ×(4.32) (5.2 kJ/kg K)(0.36×107 A/m) (22 W/m K)(21 nΩ m)
k˜br = c˜p [ζ◦ ]br
Thus:
d)
Q0 QI◦
0.21
(4.104)
br
Because Δθ(I◦ ) = 0 (no overcurrent), from Eq. 4.107a we have: [ρ0 ]br I◦2 − 2νbr c˜p AT˜◦ I◦ = 0
(S7.4)
From Eq. S7.4, we obtain: νbr =
[ρ0 ]br I◦ 2˜ cp AT˜◦
(4.109)
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
304
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.7 (continuation) e)
From [QI◦ ]br = m ˙ br hL and with m ˙ br (I) = νbr I[1+ηbr (I −I◦ )] (assumption 3 ): [QI◦ ]br = hL νbr I[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )]
f)
(4.110)
With [I◦ /A]br from Eq. 4.109 and [QI◦ ]br from Eq. 4.110 at I = I◦ :
I◦ A
2˜ cp T˜◦ [ρ0 ]br
= νbr br
[QI◦ ]br = hL νbr I◦
(S7.5a) (S7.5b)
Combining Eqs. S7.5a and S7.5b, we have:
I◦ A
br
QI◦ = I◦
br
2˜ cp T˜◦ hL [ρ0 ]br
Inserting [QI◦ /I◦ ]br from Eq. S7.2 into Eq. S7.6, we obtain: I◦ 2˜ cp T˜◦ [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br = A br [ρ0 ]br hL cp0
(S7.6)
(4.111)
We may determine the value of T˜◦ , the only unknown parameter in Eq. 4.111: I ] [ρ hL cp0 0 br ◦ T˜◦ = (S7.7) 2˜ cp A br [k0 ]br [ρ0 ]br (21 nΩ m) (20.7 kJ/kg)(6.0 kJ/kg K) = (0.358×107 A/m) 2(5.19 kJ/kg K) (22 W/m K)(21 nΩ m) 120 K This value of 120 K is quite reasonable because T˜◦ is assumed to be the steadystate average temperature of the entire lead at I◦ , i.e., ∼4 K at the cold end and ∼293 K at the warm end, which gives a linear average value of 149 K. g) An increase in the lead voltage, ΔV (I), at a given level of overcurrent I comes from an increase in the brass resistivity, Δρbr (I), which in turn is caused by an increase in the lead temperature, Δθ(I). Thus: ΔV (I) =
Δρbr (I) γbr Δθ(I) I= I A A
(S7.8)
Inserting the expression of Δθ(I) given by Eq. 4.108a, we obtain: γbr [ρ0 ]br I 2 −2νbr c˜p AT˜◦ I[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )] I ΔV (I) = A 2νbr c˜p AI[1+ ηbr (I −I◦ )]− γbr I 2
(4.113)
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
& DISCUSSIONS
305
Solution to PROBLEM 4.7 (continuation) h) For a vapor-cooled 25-kA brass lead at an overcurrent of I = 75 kA, we have [QI◦ ]br , with hL = 20.7 kJ/kg; νbr = 6.13×10−8 kg/s A; ηbr = 2.2×10−5 A−1 ; and I◦ = 25 kA, inserted into Eq. 4.110: [QI◦ ]br = hL νbr I[1 + ηbr (I − I◦ )]
(4.110)
= (20.7 kJ/kg)(6.13×10−8 kg/s A)(75 kA) × [1 + (2.2×10−5 A−1 )(75 kA − 25 kA)] 200 W At I◦ = 25 kA, we have, from Eq. 4.103, [QI◦ ]br = 31.5 W. When carrying no current, this 25-kA brass lead has, from Eq. 4.104, [Q0 ]br 0.21[QI◦ ]br 6.6 W. Thus, a total energy injected into the cold bath, Ebr , over a 300-s period at 75 kA and over a 1800-s period at 25 kA, is given by: Ebr (300 s)(200 W) + (1,800 s)(6.6 W)
(S7.10)
72 kJ Over this 2100-s period, a copper lead would have required a cold-end heat input of 33.8 W, to match the total energy Ebr = 72 kJ. For a vapor-cooled copper lead operating continuously at I◦ , this translates to a current rating of ∼35 kA (<75 kA). Although no detailed study is available for vapor-cooled copper leads in overcurrent mode, it is quite possible that a copper lead too can be operated safely with an overcurrent up to a “reasonable” value of I/I◦ . Experimental Results of a Vapor-Cooled Brass Lead Here we present experimental results of a pair of vapor-cooled brass leads [4.87]. Each lead has the same active length ( = 54 cm) and cross sectional area (A = 0.0613 cm2 ) as those of an optimal vapor-cooled copper lead rated at 280 A. As inferred from Eq. 4.102, this brass counterpart thus is rated at [I◦ ]br given by: [I◦ ]br =
[ζ◦ ]br I◦ ζ◦ (0.35×107 A/m) (280 A) ∼ 40 A (2.3×107 A/m)
Figure 4.25 shows a measured heat input vs. I plot of this brass lead in the current ranges of 0 to its nominally rated current of 40 A, and 40 A to 90 A (overcurrent). As expected, the results show that the heat input is linear with I up to ∼40 A, while beyond 40 A, the results agree well with the solid curve given by Eq. 4.110. Figure 4.26 shows ΔV (I) vs. t plots for three constant overcurrent levels, 130 A, 150 A, and 203 A. The solid curves are experimental, while the dotted curves are analytical, given by Eq. 4.113. The experimental curve at 203 A shows that at this level of overcurrent (I ∼ 5×I◦ ), the lead eventually—after ∼400 s—enters into an unstable (overheated) region. The results indicate that it is safe to operate the lead up to an overcurrent level ∼4 times the rated current.
306
CHAPTER 4—PROBLEMS
&
DISCUSSIONS
Solution to PROBLEM 4.8 (continuation) 200
Heat Input [mW]
150
100
50
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
I [A] Fig. 4.25 Measured heat input vs. I plot for a vapor-cooled brass lead (I◦ = 40 A) [4.87]. Solid curve: based on Eq. 4.110, with νbr = 6.13×10−8 kg/s A; and ηbr = 0.0138 A−1 . 900 I2 =203 A
800
ΔV (I) [mV]
700 600 I2 =150 A
500
I2 =130 A
400 300 200
0
100
200
300
400
500
Time [s] Fig. 4.26 ΔV (I) vs. t plots for over-current levels of 130, 150, and 203 A [4.87]. Solid curves: experimental; Dotted curves: based on τj given by Eq. 4.108b and ΔV (I) by Eq. 4.113, with A = 0.0613 cm2 ; = 54 cm; cp◦ = 5.19 J/g K; and b = 7.4 nΩ cm/K. Answer to TRIVIA 4.6 Cu @100 K (2, in nΩ m);
Cu @4.2 K, 20 T (1);
Al (0.8);
Cu @50 K (0.6)
CRYOGENICS—PROBLEMS
307
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 4.19: Vapor-Cooled Support Rods* Structural supports inside a cryostat represent a conductive heat load on the cryogenic environment. Like the vapor-cooled copper current lead in DISCUSSION 4.14, the effluent helium vapor may be used to cool a support rod of active length and cross sectional area A spanning two temperatures (T0 at the cold end and T at the warm end) and thus greatly to reduce the conductive heat loss. Assuming that the rod material’s thermal conductivity is temperature-independent and given by k˜ and that heat transfer between the helium and the rod is perfect, we may show that the ratio of conduction heat input through the rod from T to T0 without helium cooling, Qvp , to that with helium cooling, Qvp , is given by: Qvp = Qvp
c (T − T0 ) p0 cp0 (T − T0 ) hL ln +1 hL
(4.114)
Note that Qvp /Qvp is independent of the rod’s dimensions and thermal conductivity. With cp0 = 6.0 J/g K, hL = 20.4 J/g, T0 = 4 K, T = 300 K, Eq. 4.114 gives: Qvp (6.0 J/g K)(296 K) = = 19.4 ∼ 20 Qvp (20.4 J/g) ln(88) That is, it is possible to greatly reduce the conduction heat input through structural elements by an effective use of cold effluent helium vapor.
DISCUSSION 4.20: Structural Materials for Cryogenics Structural materials for cryogenic applications must withstand large stresses, while conducting very little heat flux over a temperature range. A material property ˜ U , the that can be used to quantify the suitability for cryogenic applications is k/σ ratio of the temperature-averaged thermal conductivity (over a specific span) to ˜ its ultimate tensile strength. Both Qvp and Qvp are proportional to k. Table 4.18 presents values for G-10, stainless steel 304, brass, and copper to gauge their suitability as structural materials for cryogenic applications; copper is in˜ U , G-10 is better than staincluded to demonstrate its unsuitability. Based on k/σ less steel; however, stainless steel has a virtue of weldability. Table 4.18: “Structural Data” for G-10, Stainless Steel 304, Brass, and Copper ˜ [W/m K] k
Material G-10 Stainless Steel 304 Brass Copper
σU [MPa]
˜ U [m2 /K s]† k/σ
4–80 K
4–300 K
80–300 K
295 K
(80–300 K)
0.25 4.5 24 1300
0.50 11 55 660
0.56 13 65 460
280 1300 400 250
2×10−9 10×10−9 2×10−7 2×10−6
† Approximate values.
* Based on Problem 4.5 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
308
CHAPTER 4—REFERENCES
REFERENCES [4.1] E. Trifon Laskaris, Kenneth G. Herd and Bijan Dorri, “A compact 0.8 T superconducting MRI magnet,” Cryogenics 34, 635 (1994). [4.2] Toru Kuriyama, Masami Urata, Takashi Yazawa, Kazutaka Yamamoto, Yasumi Ohtani, Kei Koyanagi, Tamaki Masegi, Yutaka Yamada, Shunji Nomura, Hideaki Maeda, Hideki Nakagome and Osamu Horigami, “Cryocooler directly cooled 6 T NbTi superconducting magnet system with 180 mm room temperature bore,” Cryogenics 34, 643 (1994). [4.3] Lisa Cowey, Peter Cetnik, Kevin Timums, Peter Daniels, John Mellors and Ian McDougall, “Cryogen free Nb3 Sn magnet, operated at 9.5 K with high Tc BiSrCaCuO (2212) current leads,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 5, 825 (1995). [4.4] Weijun Shen, M. Coffey, W. McGhee, “Development of 9.5 T NbTi cryogen-free magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 11, 2619 (2001). [4.5] C.H. Chang, F.Z. Hsiao, C.S. Hwang, M.H. Huang, and C.T. Chen, “Design of a 7.5 T superconducting quadrupole magnet for magnetic circular dichroism experiments,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 12, 718 (2002). [4.6] Achim Hobl, Detlef Krischel, Michael Poier, Ruediger Albrecht, Ralf Bussjaeger, and Uwe Konopka, “Design, manufacture, and test of a large bore cryogen-free magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 13, 1569 (2003). [4.7] R. Hirose, S. Hayashi, S. Fukumizu, Y. Muroo, H. Miyata, Y. Okui, A. Itoki, T. Kamikado, O. Ozaki, Y. Nunoya, and K. Okuno, “Development of 15 T cryogenfree superconducting magnets,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 953 (2006). [4.8] Yingming Dai, Luguang Yan, Baozhi Zhao, Shousen Song, Yuanzhong Lei, and Quiliang Wang, “Tests on a 6 T conduction-cooled superconducting magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 961 (2006). [4.9] M.A. Daugherty, J.Y. Coulter, W.L. Hults, D.E. Daney, D.D. Hill, D.E. McMurry, M.C. Martinez, I.G. Phillips, J.O. Willis, H.J. Boenig, F.C. Prenger, A.J. Rodenbush and S. Young “HTS high gradient magnetic separation system,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 7, 650 (1997). [4.10] K. Watanabe, S. Awaji, K. Takahashi, G. Nishijima, M. Motokawa, Y. Sasaki, Y. Ishikawa, K. Jikihara, J. Sakuraba, “Construction of the cryogen-free 23 T hybrid magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 12, 678 (2002). [4.11] J. Good and R. Mitchell, “A desktop cryogen free magnet for NMR and ESR,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 1328 (2006). [4.12] G. Snitchler, S.S. Kalsi, M. Manlief, R.E. Schwall, A. Sidi-Yekhlef, S. Ige and R. Medeiros, “High-field warm-bore HTS conduction cooled magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 9, 553 (1999). [4.13] K. Sato, T. Kato, K. Ohkura, S. Kobayashi, K. Fujino, K. Ohmatsu and K. Hayashi, “Performance of all high-Tc superconducting magnets generating 4 T and 7 T at 20 K,” Supercond. Sci. Technol. 13, 18 (2000). [4.14] Hitoshi Kitaguchi, Hiroaki Kumakura, Kazumasa Togano, Michiya Okada, Katsunori Azuma, Hiroshi Morita, Jun-ichi Sato, “Cryocooled Bi-2212/Ag solenoid magnet system generating 8 T in 50 mm room temperature bore; design and preliminary test,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 10, 495 (2000). [4.15] R. Musenich, P. Fabbricatore, S. Farinon, C. Ferdeghini, G. Grasso, M. Greco, A. Malagoli, R. Marabotto, M. Modica, D. Nardelli, A.S. Siri, M. Tassisto, and A. Tumino, “Behavior of MgB2 react & wind coils above 10 K,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 15, 1452 (2005). [4.16] L’ubom´ır Kopera, Pavol Kov´ aˇc, and Tibor Meliˇsek, “Compact design of cryogen-
CRYOGENICS—REFERENCES
309
free HTS magnet for laboratory use,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 1415 (2006). [4.17] Richard McMahon, Stephen Harrison, Steve Milward, John Ross, Robin Stafford Allen, Claude Bieth, Sa¨id Kantas, and Gerry Rodrigues, “Design and manufacture of high temperature superconducting magnets for an electron cyclotron resonance ion source,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 14, 608 (2004). [4.18] Kaoru Nemoto, Motoaki Terai, Motohiro Igarashi, Takeshi Okutomi, Satoshi Hirano, Katsuyuki Kuwano, Shigehisa Kusada, Tomohisa Yamashita, Yasuto Yanse, Toru Kuriyama, Taizo Tosaka, Kenji Tasaki, Kotaro Marukawa, Satoshi Hanai, Mutsuhiko Yamaji, and Hiroyuki Nakao, “HTS magnet for Maglev applications (2)—magnet structure and performance,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 1104 (2006). [4.19] Juan Bascu˜ n´ an (Personal communication, 2002). [4.20] Luca Bottura (Personal communication, 2004). [4.21] G. Bon Mardion, G. Claudet, and P. Seyfert, “Practical data on steady state heat transport in superfluid helium at atmospheric pressure,” Cryogenics 29, 45 (1979). [4.22] Steven W. Van Sciver (personal communication, 1993). [4.23] G. Claudet, C. Mwueia, J. Parain, and B. Turck, “Superfluid helium for stabilizing superconductors against local disturbances,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-15, 340 (1979). [4.24] Steven W. Van Sciver, Helium Cryogenics, (Plenum Press, New York, 1986), 182. [4.25] See, for example, C. Taylor, R. Althaus, S. Caspi, W. Gilbert, W. Hassenzahl, R. Meuser, J. Reschen, R. Warren, “Design of epoxy-free superconducting dipole magnets and performance in both helium I and pressurized helium II,” IEEE Trans. Magn. MAG-17, 1571 (1981). [4.26] M.J. Leupold and Y. Iwasa, “A subcooled superfluid helium cryostat for a hybrid magnet system,” Cryogenics 26, 579 (1986). [4.27] Isaac Asimov, Asimov’s Biographical Encyclopedia of Science and Technology (Doubleday, New York, 1964). [4.28] Takashi Noguchi, “Vacuum insulation for a cryostat,” Cryogenic Engineering (in Japanese) 28, 355 (1993). [4.29] Randall F. Barron, Cryogenic Systems 2nd Ed., (Clarendon University Press, Oxford, 1985). [4.30] Yukikazu Iwasa, “A ‘permanent’ HTS magnet system: key design & operational issues,” Advances in Superconductivity X (Springer-Verlag, Tokyo, 1998), 1377. [4.31] Benjamin J. Haid, “A ‘permanent’ high-temperature superconducting magnet operated in thermal communication with a mass of solid nitrogen,” Ph.D. thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, M. I. T., Cambridge, MA (June, 2001). [4.32] Benjamin J. Haid, Haigun Lee, Yukikazu Iwasa, Sang-Soo Oh, Young-Kil Kwon, and Kang-Sik Ryu, “Design analysis of a solid heat capacitor cooled ‘Permanent’ high-temperature superconducting magnet system,” Cryogenics 42, 617 (2002). [4.33] L.A. Koloskova, I.N. Krupskii, V.G. Manzhelii, and B.Ya. Gorodilov, “Thermal conductivity of solid nitrogen and carbon monoxide,” Sov. Phys. Solid State 15, 1278 (1973). [4.34] T.A. Scott, “Solid and liquid nitrogen,” Physics Reports (Section C of Physics Letters 27, 89 (1976). [4.35] V.A. Rabinovich, A.A. Vasserman, V.I. Nedostup, L.S. Veksler, Thermophysical
310
CHAPTER 4—REFERENCES Properties of Neon, Argon, Krypton, and Xenon (Hemisphere Publishing Corp., New York, 1988).
[4.36] Akira Sugawara, Hisashi Isogami, Benjamin J. Haid, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “Beneficial effects of solid nitrogen on a BSCCO-2223/Ag composite subjected to local heating,” Physica C, 1443 (2002). [4.37] Hisashi Isogami, Benjamin Haid, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “Thermal behavior of a solid nitrogen impregnated high-temperature superconducting pancake test coil under transient heating,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 11, 1852 (2001). [4.38] T. Nakamura, I. Muta, K. Okude, A. Fujio, and T. Hoshino, “Solidification of nitrogen refrigerant and its effect on thermal stability of HTSC tape,” Physica C, 372-376, 1434 (2002). [4.39] T. Nakamura, K. Higashikawa, I. Muta, A. Fujio, K. Okude, and T. Hoshino, “Improvement of dissipative property in HTS coil impregnated with solid nitrogen,” Physica C 386, 415 (2003). [4.40] T. Nakamura, K. Higashikawa, I. Muta, and T. Hoshino, “Performance of conduction-cooled HTS tape with the aid of solid nitrogen-liquid neon mixture,” Physica C 412–414, 1221 (2004). [4.41] Frank Pobell, Matter and Methods at Low Temperature, 2nd Ed. (Springer Verlag, New York, 1996). [4.42] Jack W. Ekin, Experimental Techniques for Low Temperature Measurements (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2006). [4.43] L.G. Rubin, “Cryogenic thermometry: a review of progress since 1982,” Cryogenics 37, 341 (1997). [4.44] Temperature Measurement and Control (Lake Shore Cryotronics, Inc., Westerville, OH 43082-8888). [4.45] G.W. Burns, M.G. Scroger, G.F. Strouse, M.C. Croarkin, and W.F. Guthrie, “Temperature-Electromotive Force Reference Functions and Tables for the LetterDesignated Thermocouple Types Based on the ITS-90” (NIST Monograph 175, 1993). [4.46] Linus Pauling, College Chemistry, 2nd Ed. (W.H. Freeman, San Francisco, 1955). [4.47] J.E.C. Williams, “Counterflow current leads for cryogenic applications,” Cryogenics 3, 234 (1963). [4.48] V.E. Keilin and E.Y. Klimenko, “Investigation into high current leads in liquid helium application,” Cryogenics 6, 222 (1966). [4.49] K.R. Efferson, “Helium vapor cooled current leads,” Rev. Sci. Instru. 38, 1776 (1967). [4.50] Yu. L. Buyanov, A.B. Fradkov and I. Yu. Shebalin, “A review of current leads for cryogenic devices,” Cryogenics 15, 193 (1975). [4.51] H. Katheder, L. Schappals, “Design and test of a 10 kA gas-cooled current-lead for superconducting magnets,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 17, 2071 (1981). [4.52] Ho-Myung Chang, Jung Joo Byun, Hong-Beom Jin, “Effect of convection heat transfer on the design of vapor-cooled current leads,” Cryogenics 46, 324 (2006). [4.53] Yuenian Huang, G. William Foster, Seog-Whan Kim, Peter O. Mazur, Andrew Oleck, Henryk Piekarz, Roger Rabehl, and Masayoshi Wake, “The development of 100 kA current leads for a superconducting transmission line magnet,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 457 (2006). [4.54] E. Tada, Y. Takahashi, T. Ando and S. Shimamoto, “Experiences on high current leads for superconducting magnets; seven types from 1 kA to 30 kA,” Cryogenics
CRYOGENICS—REFERENCES
311
24, 200 (1984). [4.55] Richard McFee, “Optimum input leads for cryogenic apparatus,” Rev. Sci. Instr. 30, 98 (1959). [4.56] Ho-Myung Chang and Steven W. Van Sciver, “Thermodynamic optimization of conduction-cooled HTS current leads,” Cryogenics 38, 729 (1998). [4.57] D.U. Gubser, M.M. Miller, L. Toth, R. Rayne, S. Lawrence, N.McN. Alford, and T.W. Button, “Superconducting current leads of YBCO and Pb-BSCCO,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 27, 1854 (1991). [4.58] B. Dorri, K. Herd, E.T. Laskaris, J.E. Tkaczyk, and K.W. Lay, “High temperature superconducting current leads for cryogenic applications in moderate magnetic fields,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 27, 1858 (1991). [4.59] A. Matrone, G. Rosatelli, R. Vaccarone, “Current leads with high Tc superconductor bus bars,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 25, 1742 (1989). [4.60] J.R. Hull, “High temperature superconducting current leads for cryogenic apparatus,” Cryogenics 29, 1116 (1989). [4.61] F. Grivon, A. Leriche, C. Cottevieille, J.C. Kermarrec, A. Petitbon, A. F´evrier, “YBaCuO current lead for liquid helium temperature applications,” IEEE Trans. Magn. 27, 1866 (1991). [4.62] J.L. Wu, J.T. Dederer, P.W. Eckels, S.K. Singh, J.R. Hull, R.B. Poepple, C.A Youngdahl, J.P. Singh, M.T. Lanagan, and U. Balachandran, “Design and testing of a high temperature superconducting current lead,” IEEE Trans. Mag. 27, 1861 (1991). [4.63] Y.S. Cha, R.C. Niemann, and J.R. Hull, “Thermodynamic analysis of helium boiloff experiments with pressure variations,” Cryogenics 33, 675 (1993). [4.64] K. Ueda, T. Bohno, K. Takita, K. Mukae, T. Uede, I. Itoh, M. Mimura, N. Uno, T. Tanaka, “Design and testing of a pair of current leads using bismuth compound,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 3, 400 (1993). [4.65] P.F. Herrmann, C. Albrecht, J. Bock, C. Cottevieille, S. Elschner, W. Herkert, M.O. Lafon, H. Lauvray, A. Leriche, W. Nick, E. Preisler, H. Salzburger, J.-W. Tourre, T. Verhaege, “European project for the development of high Tc current leads,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 3, 876 (1993). [4.66] Y. Yamada, T. Yanagiya, T. Hasebe, K. Jikihara, M. Ishizuka, S. Yasuhara, M. Ishihara, “Superconducting current leads of Bi-based oxide,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 3, 923 (1993). [4.67] R. Wesche and A.M. Fuchs, “Design of superconducting current leads,” Cryogenics 34, 145 (1994). [4.68] B. Zeimetz, S.X. Dou, H.K. Liu, “Vapour cooled high current leads utilizing Bi2223/Ag tapes,” Supercond. Sci. Technol. 11, 1091 (1998). [4.69] Q.L. Wang, D.Y. Jeong, S.S. Oh, H.J. Kim, J.W. Cho and K.C. Seong, “Design of Bi-based superconducting current lead for SMES,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 9, 499 (1999). [4.70] A. Ballarino, “High temperature superconducting current leads for the large hadron collider,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 9, 523 (1999). [4.71] Andrew V. Gavrilin, Victor E. Keilin, Ivan A. Kovalev, Sergei L. Kruglov, Vladimir I. Shcherbakov, Igor I. Akimov, Dmitry K. Rokov, and Alexander K. Shikov, “Optimized HTS current leads,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 9, 531 (1999). [4.72] Darren M Spiller, C Beduz, M K Al-Mosawi, C M Friend, P Thacker and A Ballarino, “Design optimization of 600 A-13 kA current leads for the Large Hadron Collider project at CERN,” Supercond. Sci. Technol. 14, 168 (2001).
312 [4.73] T. T. T. C:
CHAPTER 4—REFERENCES Isono, K. Kawano, K. Hamada, K. Matsui, Y. Nunoya, E. Hara, T. Kato, Ando, K. Okuno, T. Bohno, A. Tomioka, Y. Sanuki, K. Sakaki, M. Konno and Uede, “Test results of 60-kA HTS current lead for fusion application,” Physica Superconductivity 392–396, 1219 (2003).
[4.74] R. Heller, W.H. Fietz, R. Lietzow, V.L. Tanna, A. Vostner, R. Wesche, G.R. Zahn, “70 kA high temperature superconductor current lead operation at 80 K,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 16, 823 (2006). [4.75] Yukikazu Iwasa and Haigun Lee, “High-temperature superconducting current lead incorporating operation in the current-sharing mode,” Cryogenics 40, 209 (2000). [4.76] Haigun Lee, Paul Arakawa, Kenneth R. Efferson, Robert Fielden, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “AMI-MIT 1-kA leads with high-temperature superconducting sections— design concept and key parameters,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 11, 2539 (2001). [4.77] M. Lakrimi, J. Brown, P. Cetnik, M. Wilkinson, D. Clapton, R. Fair, K. Smith, and P. Noonan, “Low boil-off HTS current lead,” IEEE Trans. Appl. Superconduc. 17, 2270 (2007). [4.78] H. Fujishiro, M. Ikebe, K. Noto, T. Sasaoka, and K. Nomura, “Thermal and electrical properties of Ag-Au and Ag-Cu alloy tapes for metal stabilizers of oxide superconductors,” Cryogenics 33, 1086 (1993). Additional data by H. Fujishiro (Iwate University)—private communication (2004). [4.79] Helen Miles Davis, The Chemical Elements (Ballantine Books, New York, 1964). [4.80] K. Mendelssohn, The Quest for Absolute Zero (World University Library, New York, 1966). [4.81] M.N. Wilson and G.J. Homer, “Low loss heavy current leads for intermittent use,” Cryogenics 13, 672 (1973). [4.82] Yu. L. Buyanov and I. Yu. Shebalin, “Current leads to a cryostat working under short-term load conditions,” Cryogenics 15, 611 (1975). [4.83] R.F. Berg and G.G. Ihas, “Simple 100 A current leads for low duty cycle use,” Cryogenics 23, 437 (1983). [4.84] Sangkwon Jeong and Schwan In, “Investigation on vapor-cooled current leads operating in a pulse mode,” Cryogenics 44, 241 (2004). [4.85] Andrew V. Gavrilin, Victor E. Keilin, “Overload current leads,” MT-15 proceedings (Beijing, China: Science Press), 1254 (1998). [4.86] A.F. Clark, G.E. Childs, and G.H. Wallace, “Electrical resistivity of some engineering alloys at low temperatures,” Cryogenics 10, 295 (1970). [4.87] Haigun Lee, Paul Arakawa, Kenneth Efferson, and Yukikazu Iwasa, “Helium vaporcooled brass current leads: experimental and analytical results,” Cryogenics 41, 485 (2001).
CHAPTER 5 MAGNETIZATION 5.1 Introduction In this chapter we study the magnetization of Type II superconductors by using a phenomenological theory of magnetization developed in 1962 by Bean [5.1]. As remarked in CHAPTER 1, over the field range of interest (above ∼0.5 T) for most magnet applications, a Type II superconductor is in the mixed state, consisting of normal-state islands in a sea of superconductivity. When a Type II superconductor is subjected to a time-varying magnetic field or transport current, dissipation takes place in these islands and manifests either as “flux jumping,” a transitory phenomenon, or AC losses. Known as Bean’s critical state model, the theory, pertinent to LTS and HTS, has been successfully applied to formulate requirements in closed-form expressions to eradicate flux jumping and minimize AC losses. Today, well-established methods of producing LTS wires and cables that virtually eradicate flux jumps are available. As we will study in this chapter, flux jumping is not an overriding concern with HTS as it is for LTS. Thus, if magnetization were important only for eradication of flux jumping, for HTS applications, it might be appropriate to regard it as a minor topic. However, because it also plays a crucial role in AC losses in both LTS and HTS, we are devoting an entire chapter here to study magnetization; AC losses will be addressed in more detail in CHAPTER 7.
5.2. Bean’s Theory For a Type II Superconductor 5.2.1 No Transport Current Bean’s theory treats magnetization of a superconductor under assumptions that enable, like many successful theories, simple mathematics to derive closed-form expressions that agree remarkably well with experimental results [5.2–5.5]. In the Bean model the superconductor has the simplest geometry—a slab of width 2a (in the x-direction) and infinite lengths in the y- and z-directions. Here, magnetic field quantities (H, B, M ) point in the y-direction, while current, I, and current density, J, flow in the z-direction. Also in the Bean model, J = Jc , the critical current density, which is assumed independent of magnetic field and temperature. H, and M may thus be simplified to define magnetiVector Eq. 2.15 relating B, zation M in terms of B and H: B M= −H (5.1) μ◦ According to the Bean model, magnetic induction B is not zero within the interior of the hard superconductor but is equal to the superconductor’s volumetric average of μ◦ Hs , where Hs is the magnetic field within the superconductor. Figure 5.1 shows a Type II superconducting slab infinitely high (in the y-direction) and deep (in the z-direction), and 2a wide (in the x-direction). An external field He , applied parallel to a slab previously unexposed to a magnetic field (“virgin” = J = Jc applied slab), creates Hs (x) within the slab. With Ampere’s law ∇× H Y. Iwasa, Case Studies in Superconducting Magnets: Design and Operational Issues, DOI: 10.1007/b112047_5, © Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2009
313
CHAPTER 5
314 Hs (x)
Hp
Hp
He
He
0 Fig. 5.1
0
x∗
a
0 2a
x
Slab of Type II superconductor exposed to an external field.
to the slab, we obtain the magnetic field within the superconductor, Hs (x): ⎧ (x∗ ≤ x ≤ x ) (5.2a) ⎪ ⎨0 Hs (x) = He − Jc x (0 ≤ x ≤ x∗) (5.2b) ⎪ ⎩ H + J (x − 2a) (x ≤ x ≤ 2a) (5.2c) e c Note that the slope of Hs (x) is equal to Jc , positive where Jc is positive (z-directed, out of the paper) and negative where Jc is negative. x∗ (and 2a − x ) gives the extent of the field penetration in the slab; in terms of He and Jc : He x∗ = (5.3a) Jc At He = Hp ≡ Jc a, x∗ = x = a, and the entire slab is in the critical state; Hp is known as the penetration field: Hp ≡ Jc a (5.3b) ˜s , is thus given by The average magnetic induction within the slab, B 2a μ◦ ˜s = μ◦ B Hs (x) dx = ×<shaded area in Fig. 5.1> (5.4a) 2a 0 2a =2× =
He x∗ μ◦ μ◦ He2 × = 2a 2 2aJc
(5.4b)
μ◦ He2 2Hp
(5.4c)
˜s /μ◦ − He , we have: From the definition, M = B He2 (0 ≤ He ≤ Hp ) (5.5) 2Hp The superconductor is diamagnetic; −M is the magnitude of its magnetization. −M = He −
As the external field is increased further, the field eventually penetrates the slab ˜s = He − Hp /2, and thus: completely (He ≥ Hp ), and B −M = 21 Hp = 21 Jc a
(He ≥ Hp )
The dashed magnetization profile in Fig. 5.1 corresponds to He = Hp .
(5.6)
315
MAGNETIZATION Hs (x) Hm
Hm
2Hp
2Hp
He↓ Hm −Hp Hp
Hp
He↓
He↓= Hm −2Hp
He↓
Fig. 5.2
He↓ Hm −Hp
0
a
He↓= 0 2a
Hs (x) during a return field sequence: He↓= Hm → 0.
The dotted lines in Fig. 5.2 represent Hs (x) at He = Hm > 2Hp , where Hm is the maximum external field applied in this field sweep sequence. As He is reduced from Hm towards 0, Hs (x) changes as indicated by the solid lines in Fig. 5.2. When He = Hm −2Hp , −M becomes −Hp /2, as may be inferred from Fig. 5.2, because Hs (x) is a perfect mirror image of that at Hm . It can be shown that for the return field sweep from Hm to He↓= 0, −M (He ) is given by: −M (He ) = 21 Hp −(Hm − He ) + = − 21 Hp
(Hm −He )2 4Hp
(He↓= Hm → Hm −2Hp ) (5.7a) (He↓= Hm −2Hp → 0)
(5.7b)
Note that −M is a quadratic function of He , as is the case when an external field is applied to the virgin slab; also −M (He ) = −Hp /2 when He returns to 0. This “remanent” magnetization is indicated by the dashed lines in Fig. 5.2. Once exposed to an external magnetic field, a Type II superconductor will thus become magnetized. This remanent magnetization cannot be removed by means of the external field; one way to remove it is to heat the superconductor, raising its temperature to above Tc . Figure 5.3 gives −M vs. He plots for the entire positive field sweep sequence from 0 to Hm = Hc2 and back to 0, where Hc2 is the upper critical field. The solid curve is based on Eqs. 5.5–5.7 derived with Bean’s assumption that Jc is field-independent. The dashed curve qualitatively corrects for more realistic cases [5.2–5.5] in which Jc decreases with field, becoming 0 at Hc2 . Note that magnetization is hysteretic, and its magnitude within the range Hp < He < Hm−2Hp , ΔM = −M (He↑)+M (He↓), is equal to Hp = Jc a. A magnetization measurement is thus sometimes performed to obtain Jc (He ) data—see DISCUSSION 5.4 (p. 331).
CHAPTER 5
316 −M (He )
1 H 2 p
0
Hp
Hc2
He
− 12 Hp
Fig. 5.3 Magnetization vs. field traces for a hard superconducting slab subjected to an external field sequence of 0 → Hc2 → 0. The solid curve presents the case Jc = constant; the dashed curve qualitatively presents the case Jc (He ), with Jc = 0 at Hc2 [5.2–5.5].
Figure 5.4 shows the current distribution within the slab corresponding to the field distribution of Fig. 5.1. Note that Jc = Hp /2a. The net current per unit length in the y-direction [A/m] flowing through the slab in the z-direction is given by: 2a J(x) dx = 0 (5.8) I= 0
As expected, I = 0 in the absence of transport current. 5.2.2 Effect of Transport Current on Magnetization When a transport current It (per unit length in the y-direction) flows in the slab in the +z-direction (out of the paper), we see an increase in magnetic field of It /2 at x = 2a and a decrease in magnetic field of It /2 at x = 0. Because the shielding current within the slab builds up from each surface into the interior, the field distribution Hs (x) within the slab will be that shown in Fig. 5.5. In Fig. 5.5, x∗ and x are given by: J(x) Hp/a
Hp/a Jc = 21 Hp/a
0
x∗
a
x
2a
−Jc −Hp/a Fig. 5.4
−Hp/a
J(x) corresponding to Hs (x) given in Fig. 5.1.
317
MAGNETIZATION Hs (x) Hp
Hp 1 I 2 t
0
x∗
a
x
2a
− 21 It −Hp Fig. 5.5
−Hp
Hs (x) with transport current It in the slab.
− 21 It + Jc x∗ = 0
(5.9a)
Jc (x − 2a) + 21 It = 0
(5.9b)
It It and x = 2a − (5.9c) 2Jc 2Jc Figure 5.6 shows current distribution J(x) in the slab. By integrating J(x) across the slab width, we can show that the net current flowing in the slab is indeed It : 2a I= J(x) dx = Jc x∗ + Jc (2a − x ) (5.10a) x∗ =
0
= 21 It + 21 It = It
(5.10b)
As expected, the net current in the slab is the current supplied by the external source. Note that the presence of an external field He ıy , when applied after It , does not fundamentally change the distributions shown in Figs. 5.5 and 5.6; but if He ıy is applied before It , different Hs (x) and J(x) would emerge. In DISCUSSION 5.1 the effects of transport current on magnetization are studied in detail. J(x) Hp/a
Hp/a Jc = 21 Hp/a
Jc 0
−Hp/a Fig. 5.6
x∗
a
x
2a
−Hp/a
J(x) corresponding to Hs (x) given in Fig. 5.5.
CHAPTER 5
318
5.3 Measurement Technique We describe here the technique most widely used to measure magnetization. Figure 5.7 presents the key components of this technique [5.6]: 1) a primary search coil; 2) a secondary search coil; and 3) a balancing potentiometer. Not shown in the figure but equally essential is an integrator that converts the bridge output voltage, Vbg (t), to a voltage that is directly proportional to M (He ). The test sample is placed within the primary search coil set. When the primary and secondary search coils are subjected to a time-varying external magnetic field He (t) which is nearly uniform over the space occupied by each search coil, voltages, Vpc (t) and Vsc (t), are induced across the terminals of each search coil: ⎡
⎤ ˜e dM d H ⎦ Vpc (t) = μ◦ Npc Apc ⎣ + (5.11a) dt dt Vsc (t) = μ◦ Nsc Asc
˜e dH dt
pc
(5.11b)
sc
The subscripts pc and sc refer to the primary and secondary search coils, respectively. N is the number of turns of each search coil and A is the effective area of ˜ e is the space-averaged each turn in the coil through which He (t) is coupled. H field over each search coil. The bridge output voltage Vbg (t) is given by: Vbg (t) = (k − 1)Vpc (t) + kVsc (t)
(5.12)
where k is a constant (from 0 to 1) that expresses the fraction of the potentiometer resistance (R) appearing in the primary side of the search coil in Fig. 5.7. Combining Eqs. 5.11 and 5.12, we obtain: dM Vbg (t) = (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc dt
˜e ˜e dH dH + (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc + kμ◦ Nsc Asc (5.13) dt dt pc
sc
Magnetized test sample (M )
Vpc (t) Primary search coil + − Vbg (t)
He (t) ↑
⎫ ⎬ ⎭
kR
Balancing potentiometer (R) Vsc (t) Secondary coil
Fig. 5.7
Schematic of a magnetization measurement technique.
319
MAGNETIZATION
Now, it is possible to adjust k of the potentiometer to satisfy the following condition and make Vbg (t) proportional to dM/dt:
˜e ˜e dH dH (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc + kμ◦ Nsc Asc =0 dt dt pc
Vbg (t) = (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc
(5.14a)
sc
dM dt
(5.14b)
Although in practice the condition required by Eq. 5.14a is not always satisfied over a wide frequency range, Eq. 5.14b is a good approximation for most cases. Generally k is close to 0.5. Vbg (t) is fed into an integrator, and its output, Vmz (t), is proportional to M . Specifically, if the test sample is in the virgin state (M = 0) and He (t) is increased (He↑) from 0 (at t = 0) to He (at t = t1 ), then we have: 1 Vmz (He↑) = τit =
t1
Vbg (t) dt 0
(k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc M (He ) τit
(5.15)
where τit is the effective integrator time constant. If He > Hp , then M (He ) = −Hp /2 = −Jc a/2 (Eq. 5.6), and Eq. 5.15 simplifies to: (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc Vmz (He↑ > Hp ) = −fm τit
Jc a 2
(5.16a)
The factor fm is the ratio of magnetic material volume to the total test sample volume. This factor is needed because generally a test sample does not consist entirely of magnetic material for which magnetization is measured; in the case of a multifilamentary conductor, for example, the test sample consists not only of superconducting filaments but also of a matrix metal and other nonmagnetic materials, e.g., insulator. If an external field excursion is 0 → Hm > Hp → He ↓ < Hm −2Hp , then we have: (k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc Vmz (He↓ < Hm − 2Hp ) = fm τit
Jc a 2
(5.16b)
ΔVmz = Vmz (He ↑ > Hp ) − Vmz (He ↓ < Hm − 2Hp ) is thus proportional to the “width” of magnetization curve at He : ΔVmz = −fm
(k − 1)μ◦ Npc Apc Jc a τit
From Eq. 5.16c we note that ΔVmz is directly proportional to Jc and a.
(5.16c)
320
CHAPTER 5 80
Magnetization [emu/cm3 ]
60 40 20 0 −20 −40
10 K 20 K 30 K
−60 −80 −2
−1.5
−1
−0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
Magnetic Field [T] Fig. 5.8
Magnetization vs. field (in tesla) traces of MgB2 at 10 K, 20 K, and 30 K [5.7].
Figure 5.8 shows magnetization vs. field (here given in the unit of tesla) traces of MgB2 at 10 K, 20 K, and 30 K, each completing a field cycle, from 0 to +1.7 T, back to 0, to −1.7 T, and finally to 0 [5.7]. Note that unlike Fig. 5.3 which shows −M (He ) plots, these are +M (He ) plots. Because the traces are not tilted along the x (field) axis, we may conclude that the primary and secondary coils used in this measurement are well balanced. The hysteretic nature of its magnetization clearly indicates that MgB2 is a Type II superconductor. Note that the diamagnetic nature of this superconductor is evident in the first part of each trace when the field is increased from 0 towards 1.7 T, magnetization enters into the negative quadrant. As may be inferred from Hp = Jc a of Bean’s model, magnetization is directly proportional to the superconductor’s Jc . However, unlike in Bean’s model, Jc is a decreasing function of not only field but temperature. Dependence on Jc and T are clearly evident in Fig. 5.8. Here, the magnetization is in emu/cm3 , a non-SI unit. In DISCUSSION 5.1, we shall apply Bean’s model to the magnetization data of Fig. 5.8 to compute the material’s Jc at 10 K in zero field.
“Through measurement to knowledge.”—Heike Kamerlingh Onnes
MAGNETIZATION— PROBLEMS
321
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current* As stated at the outset, magnetization in the presence of transport current depends on the order in which the external field and transport current are applied. Here we examine three cases: A) field and then transport current; B) transport current and then magnetic field; and C) field and then current, which is subsequently changed. A. Field and then Transport Current Figure 5.9 shows the field profiles inside a Bean slab of thickness 2a, Hs (x), after specific field-current sequences given below. 1. Initially, Hs1 (x), with He = 2.5Hp and no transport current—dotted lines. 2. Next, Hs2 (x), after application of transport current It = Jc a = Ic /2, with the external field held constant—solid lines. Note that Jc a = Hp . 3. Finally, Hs3 (x), after transport current is increased further to 2Jc a = Ic , with He = 2.5Hp , resulting in Hs3 (0) = 1.5Hp and Hs3 (2a) = 3.5Hp —dashed line. Hs1 (x) and Hs3 (x) are quite straightforward. Hs2 (x) consists of three piece-wise functions, Hs21 (x), Hs22 (x), and Hs23 (x): Hs21 (x) = 2Hp + Jc x = 2Jc a + Jc x
(0 ≤ x ≤ x∗)
Hs22 (x) = 2.5Hp − Jc x = 2.5Jc a − Jc x
(x∗ ≤ x ≤ x )
Hs23 (x) = Hp + Jc x = Jc a + Jc x
(x ≤ x ≤ 2a)
where x∗ and x are given by two intersections of Hs1 (x) and Hs2 (x). Namely, Hs1 (x∗) = Hs21 (x∗) and Hs1 (x ) = Hs23 (x ): x∗ = 0.25a and x = 0.75a. Hs (x) 3.5Hp
3.5Hp 3Hp
3Hp
2.5Hp
2.5Hp
2Hp
2Hp
1.5Hp 0
1.5Hp
0 x∗
x
a
2a
Fig. 5.9 Field profiles in the presence of He = 2.5Hp , first with It = 0 (dotted lines), then It = Jc a = Ic /2 (solid), and finally It = 2Jc a = Ic (dashed). * Problems 5.1–3 in the 1st Edition (Plenum, 1994).
CHAPTER 5—PROBLEMS
322
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) Figure 5.10 shows Hs (x) for the general case in the presence of It as piece-wise solid lines of Hs21 (x), Hs22 (x), and Hs23 (x). As noted in 5.2.2, It (z-axis) is the transport current per unit y-axis length. Here, we define a dimensionless transport current, i: i ≡ It /Ic , where Ic = 2aJc . For Hs (x) dx integration, the slab in Fig. 5.10 is divided into three areas, A1 , A2 , and A3 , as partitioned by the vertical dashed lines in Fig. 5.10. Note that It = iIc = 2iaJc = 2iHp . The solid field line in area A1 (0 ≤ x ≤ x∗), Hs21 (x), that in A2 (x∗ ≤ x ≤ x ), Hs22 (x), and that in A3 (x ≤ x ≤ 2a), Hs23 (x), are given by: Hs21 (x) = He − 21 It + Jc x
(0 ≤ x ≤ x∗)
Hs22 (x) = He − Jc x (x∗ ≤ x ≤ x ) Hs23 (x) = He + 21 It + Jc (x − 2a) (x ≤ x ≤ 2a) We solve for x∗ and x , and determine Hs22 (x∗) and Hs22 (x ): Hs21 (x∗) = Hs22 (x∗) He − Hp i + Jc x∗ = He − Jc x∗
=⇒
x∗ =
Hp i = 21 ai 2Jc
=⇒
x = a 1 − 21 i
Hs22 (x∗) = He − 21 aJc i = He − 21 Hp i and Hs22 (x ) = Hs23 (x ) He − Jc x = He + Hp i + Jc (x − 2a) Hs22 (x ) = He − Hp + 21 Hp i
Hs (x) He + 21 It He
He
He − 21 It He −Hp 0
A1 0 x∗
A2
A3 x
a
2a
Fig. 5.10 Field profile with transport current (solid) for computation of magnetization. The vertical dashed lines partition three areas, A1 , A2 , and A3 .
MAGNETIZATION— PROBLEMS
323
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) M is proportional to the size of the “shaded area,” shown in Fig. 5.10, which is the sum of three partitioned areas A1 , A2 , and A3 . The area of each trapezoid is its (base)×(height1 +height2 )/2. A1 = 21 x∗[Hs1 (0) + Hs2 (x∗)] = 41 ai (He − Hp i) + He − 21 Hp i = 41 ai 2He − 23 Hp i = a 21 He i − 83 Hp i2 A2 = 21 (x − x∗)[Hs2 (x∗) + Hs2 (x )] = 21 (a − ai) He − 21 Hp i + He − Hp + 21 Hp i = 21 a(1 − i)(2He − Hp ) = a He − He i − 21 Hp + 21 Hp i A3 = 21 (2a − x )[Hs2 (x ) + Hs3 (2a)] = 21 a + 21 ai (He − Hp + 21 Hp i + He + Hp i) = a 1 + 21 i (He − 21 Hp + 43 Hp i) = a He + 21 He i − 21 Hp − 41 Hp i + 43 Hp i + 83 Hp i2 By combining these three areas, we may compute the shaded area: Shaded area = A1 + A2 + A3 = a 21 He i − 83 Hp i2 + He − He i − 21 Hp + 21 Hp i + He + 21 He i − 21 Hp − 41 Hp i + 43 Hp i + 83 Hp i2
= a(2He − Hp + Hp i) With the shaded area known, M can be computed quickly: −M (i) = He −
1 ×(Shaded area) 2a
= He − He + 21 Hp − 21 Hp i = 21 Hp (1 − i)
(5.17a)
= −M (0)f1 (i)
(5.17b)
where f1 (i) = 1 − i. −M (i) decreases linearly with i, becoming 0 at i = 1.
CHAPTER 5—PROBLEMS
324
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) B. Transport Current and then Field Here, the order is reversed for introducing external magnetic field and transport current to the slab. Specifically, a transport current of Jc a = (Ic /2)ız (out of the paper) is introduced into the slab initially in the virgin state. Next, while It is held constant, an external magnetic field of 2Hp is applied in the +y-direction. In Fig. 5.11 the dotted lines present Hs (x) after a transport current of Jc a (= Hp /2) but before He of 2Hp is introduced; the solid lines present Hs (x) after the field He = 2Hp is introduced. In both cases the net current in the slab is Jc a. Initially with He = 0: It =
2a
J(x) dx = Jc (0.5a) + Jc (2a − 1.5a) = Jc a
0
Next, with He = 2Hp : 2a J(x) dx = −Jc (0.5a) + Jc (2a − 0.5a) = Jc a It = 0
To determine the magnetization in the slab for the general case of arbitrary current (I < Ic ), we must first find x∗ (Fig. 5.12), which can be determined from the solid line in Region I, Hs1 (x) (0 ≤ x ≤ x∗) and that in Region II, Hs2 (x) (x∗ ≤ x ≤ 2a). Hs1 (x) = (He − Hp i) − Jc x
(0 ≤ x ≤ x∗)
Hs2 (x) = (He + Hp i) + Jc (x − 2a)
(x∗ ≤ x ≤ 2a)
Because Hs1 (x∗) = Hs2 (x∗), we may solve for x∗ from the above expressions: x∗ = a − ai = a(1 − i) Hs (x) He + 21 It He
He (= 2Hp )
He − 21 It Hp
Hp 1 I 2 t
0
0
0.5a a
1.5a 2a
− 21 It Fig. 5.11
Field profiles, with current only (dotted) and with current and field (solid).
MAGNETIZATION— PROBLEMS
325
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) Once x∗ is determined, we can compute Hs1 (x∗): Hs1 (x∗) = He − Hp i − Jc a(1 − i) = He − Hp We can now compute the shaded area, which is the sum of two areas, A1 and A2 , partitioned by the vertical dashed line in Fig. 5.12. A1 = 21 a(1 − i)(He − Hp i + He − Hp ) = a(1 − i) He − 21 Hp − 21 Hp i = a He − He i − 21 Hp + 21 Hp i2 A2 = 21 (2a − a + ai)(He + Hp i + He − Hp ) = a(1 + i) He − 21 Hp + 21 Hp i = a He + He i − 21 Hp + 21 Hp i2 Shaded area = A1 + A2 = a(2He − Hp + Hp i2 ) Once the shaded area is known, we have M : −M (i) = He − 21 (2He − Hp + Hp i2 ) = 21 Hp (1 − i2 )
(5.18a)
= −M (0)f2 (i)
(5.18b)
where f2 (i) = 1 − i2 . This magnetization is a parabolic function of i. Hs (x) He + 21 It He
He
He − 21 It
A1 0
0
A2 x∗
a
2a
Fig. 5.12 Field profile with transport current and field for computation of magnetization. The vertical dashed line partitions areas A1 and A2 .
CHAPTER 5—PROBLEMS
326
&
DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) C. Field and then Current Changes Finally, we shall consider Hs (x) and −M (i) for the slab when the following sequence of field and transport current is applied. Step 1:
Starting with a virgin state and It = 0 initially, the external magnetic field, He = 2Hp , is applied in the +y-direction.
Step 2:
While He remains at 2Hp , a transport current It = 2Hp i, where i = It /Ic , is introduced into the slab in the z-direction (out of the paper).
Step 3:
With He remaining at 2Hp , It is reduced to zero.
Step 4:
It is now reversed and |2Hp i| is introduced into the slab in the −zdirection (into the paper).
Step 5:
It is again reduced to zero; He still remains at 2Hp .
Figure 5.13 shows the field profile Hs (x) after Step 5, consisting of five piece-wise solid lines, the second and third of which, useful to compute M (i), are given below. Hs2 (x) = He + Hp i − Jc x
(x∗ ≤ x ≤ a)
Hs3 (x) = He + Hp i + Jc (x − 2a)
(a ≤ x ≤ x )
where x∗ and x may be solved from: Hs2 (x∗) = Hs3 (x ) = He . Thus: Hs2 (x∗) = He =⇒ He + Hp i − Jc x∗ Hp i x∗ = = ai Jc Hs3 (x ) = He =⇒ He + Hp i + Jc (x − 2a) Hp x = 2a − i = 2a − ai Jc Hs (x) He +Hp i (= He + 21 It )
He +Hp i He
He
He −Hp i
0
He −Hp i (= He − 21 It )
0
Fig. 5.13
x∗
a
x
2a
Field profile after Step 5.
MAGNETIZATION— PROBLEMS
327
& DISCUSSIONS
DISCUSSION 5.1: Magnetization with Transport Current (continuation) The magnetization is computed from appropriate areas, shown in Fig. 5.14, in which the slab is divided into four “white” areas, from left to right, designated A1 (rectangle), A2 (trape