The Budapest Fajarowicz The Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit in Action
Lev Gutman
BATS FORD
First published in 2004 Lev Gu...
222 downloads
11035 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Budapest Fajarowicz The Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit in Action
Lev Gutman
BATS FORD
First published in 2004 Lev Gutman 2004
©
ISBN 0 7 1 34 8708 9 British Library Cataloguing -in-Publication Data. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, by any means, without prior permission of the publisher. Printed in Great Britain by Creative Print and Design (Wales), Ebbw Vale for the publishers, B.T. Batsford Ltd, The Chrysalis Building Bramley Road, London, W 10 6SP
Distributed in the United States and Canada by Sterling Publishing Co., 387 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 1 0016, USA
For my daughters Dana and Tali
A BATSFORD CHESS BOOK
Contents
Introduction
4
Part l Less Popular Variations
8
Part 2 Steiner Variation 4.�c2
30
Part 3 4.�d2
76
Part 4 4.�f3
1 52
Part 5 4.a3
210
Index of Variations
285
Bibliography
287
Introduction l .d4 players are used to being treated with respect. After the game Levin Gulman, German Ch 2001, in which I played the Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit, my opponent, a solid GM and well known theoretician, was sufficiently affected by the enormous tension he had to face from the very start that some months later, in the German League 2002, he preferred to play l .ltJO against me! "The study of Chess Openings has taught us that Black, being a single-move behind, cannot achieve complete equality. He has a choice: to be content with a passive but sound position, or try early freeing moves. l.d4 �f6 :Z.«: 4 eS!? This variation was invented in 1917 by Istvan Abonyi, Zsigmo nd BartiSZ and Gyulll Breyer. Such an aggressive action seems premature; on the other hand the black squares in the centre are a bit weak due to c2-c4", Richard Reti, Die Meister des Schachbretts, 1 930.
3.dxe5 �e4!?
"The Fajarowicz-knight creates latent threats along the a5-e I diagonal and, in con junction with the consequent gambit continuation d7-d6 or d7-d5, may well make White's development more difficult", Mtu: Euwe, Theorie der Schach-Eroeffoun gen, 1965.
"The Budapest is really a counter-attack rather then a def ence and it appeals to players who like to challenge White for the initiative from early in the game. This particularly applies to the Fajarowicz Variation, in which (by contrast with the 3 ...�g4, the main line of t he Budapest) Black puts more emphasis on fighting for key squares than on seeking the early recapture of the pawn he has given up", Tim Harding, The Fighting Fajarowicz, 1996. Ev ery «:hess openi ng has its ow n hi story, its ow n destiny
Soler - Marcoff, Steinitz Chess Club, November 1 927, seems to be the very first published game with 3 ... �e4, while the British Chess Magazine, 1 9 1 9, mentions the game Mlotkowski - Barrett, already played in Philadelphia 1904/1905. However, investigations and examinations began only with the game Steiner Fajarowicz, Wiesbaden 1928, where Black got a completely winning position, and this was actually the birth of a new Gambit, Stefan Buecker/A ifred Diel, Kais siber 112001.
"In the pantheon of opening theoreticians, one of the most obscure surely has to be S.Fajarowicz. The creator of 3 ... �e4 in the Budapest Gambit, he is almost unknown outside his variation. The major recent works h ave little to say about him other than that he was from Leipzig and that he was active during the period 1920- 1 938 ", John Donaldson, Inside Chess, 1990. Thanks to Diel we now know a bit more: "on June 5, 1908, Sammi Fajarowicz was born in Mockem near Leipzig. He was one of those comet-like players of chess history, whose active period (1 927- 1 933) was too short owing to perse cution of the Jews and fatal illness", Kaissiber 112001. 4
"The Leipzig Variation was employed in master tournaments since 1 927 by its inventor Fajarowicz", MllX Bluemich, Deutsche Schachzeitung, 1932; "This variation should in any case be associated with Leipzig, where it was developed and practised many years before it appeared in public at Wiesbaden 1 928", Bluemich, Deutsche Sch achzeitung, 1941. "Unfortunately Fajarowicz lacked the technique to bring some ofthese early games, against masters, to a successful finish, but his imaginative idea was soon adopted by other players, notably grandmaster Savielly Tartakower, a player al ways attracted to unusual and ingenious paths, and the brilliant combinational art ist Kurt Richter", Harding. "3...�e4 has found in Richter a loyal supporter", Deutsche Schachblaetter, 1 932; it was Richter who published the very first survey of the practical development of the opening and some analysis of its principal variations in Wiener Schach zeitung, 1933, and it was first and foremost his advocacy which led to the great popularity of this gambit. "This variety of Budapest Gambit should promise a fighter of stature better pros pects then the usual 3 ... �g4. The knight is definitely more effectively placed in the centre but in most cases Black will have to give up the sacrificed pawn", Richter, Chess Olympiad Munich 1 936.
"Black has obviously some problems to solve", Richter, Die Moderne Schach partie, 1948.
Tartllkower seemed to have had a more optimistic view of this development and offered some new ideas in L 'echequier de Paris, 194 7. "It is in any case admirable to see how this paradoxical-looking move, despite all attempts at refutation, com binational and positional, holds its own over and over again". The n ew p rot agonist s
"S ince 1945 chess theory has expanded, both in depth and breadth, like never before. New surprising moves have been found and new strategic plans have been developed in every opening", Eu we, Theorie der Schach-Eroeffnungen, 1965. Euwe s contribution to the Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit was of enormous impor tance. After the game Alekhine -Tartakower, London 1932, 4.�d2 was very pop ular; it is intriguing that fifteen years later Alexander Alekhine still favoured this move in his comments to the game van Scheltinga - Tartakower, Buenos Aires 1939, 107 Gre at Chess Battles 1939-1945. Euwe has commented that White's success was only a result of wrong black strategy; he should play in gambit style instead of trying to recover his pawn and in this case the chances should be equal. However, despite his conclusion that a new method of fighting, exploiting the insecure position of the knight on e4, may cause serious problems for Black, the basis for a new beginning was created. ·
s
Two impressive works were published in 1966: Teoria e Practica do Gambito Budapeste, by Fernando Vasconcellos, and Budapest-Gambiten, by Alexander Hildebrand. Encyclopaedia of Chess Openings, 1 979, by Nicola Minev, was another im portant step for the further development of the Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit. Not least, there is something to be said for Budapest Defence, by JosefStllker, Alan Glasscoe and Gregory Stllyart, Thinkers Press, Davenport / 980. Budapest Gambit, by Otto Borik, came out in 1985 (the English edition in 1986). With some new ideas and instructive examples, he influenced many players to change their negative opinion about this variation; unfOrtunately the second German edition, 1 988, was less optimistic: ''the Fajarowicz-Gambit is indeed not I 00% correct". "The Fajarowicz is one of many lines which have been mishandled by theory. Even an excellent manual like BCO has it wrong", Joel Benjamin/Eric Schiller, Unorthodox Openings, / 98 7.
Czech correspondence chess expert Frantisek Nepustil managed to attract at tention with an ambitious article in Schach-Archiv, /987: "the analysis is quite interesting; however, the fmal conclusion that 3 �e4 could be a refutation of c2-c4 looks very subjective to me", Ludek Pachman. "While Fajarowicz may be a dark shadow, his variation of the Budapest has occasionally seen the light of day. In the past, Tartakower, Richter and Steiner all employed it fairly often. Arthur Bisguier has used it for nearly forty years, and for a while NM Richard Kelson of Clayton, California, was playing it every chance he got. It is sound? All the theoretical works suggest that Black does not quite get enough for the pawn against best play. But theory is one thing and practice another'', ...
John Donaldson, Inside Chess, / 990.
"This, it seems to me, is an extremely ambitious way for Black to play - to sacrifice a pawn and make no attempt to win it back! White has a number of ways to get a clear edge if (and it is a big if) he does not get carried away by the cheek of Black's opening", Julian Hodgson, Budapest Defence, Trends /99/. "Many players take a sceptical view of this move, hence from a practical stand point it is perhaps more dangerous for White then the usual 3 .. �g4", Mikhail .
Tseitlinllgor GIDskov, The Budapest/or the Tournament Player, Batsford /992. Fajarowicz-Gambit, by Niels Jiirgen Jensen, came out in 1 995 in Danish and
was the f1rst book exclusively about this opening. The author quoted many sources, found some new ideas in principal variations and published many unknown games from Danish players. The Fighting Fajarowicz, by Tim H6rding, Chess Digest, Dallas / 996, fol lowed: "The variation is far more dangerous for White than its current reputation. This is the first full-length book to be devoted to the Fajarowicz Gambit, although a 48-page booklet in Danish by Niels Jiirgen Jensen, was published shortly be fore I completed this monograph ", Harding.
6
"To write a useful and reasonably authoritative book about the Fajarowicz Gam bit is not an easy job; for a long time there was a negative view of 3 ... �e4. Authors Jensen and Harding were forced to replace their previous conclusions with new arguments; so, both books are a long way from being a convincing rehabilitation ", Stefan Buecker, Kaissiber 211997.
"If I had to define the main concept of the Budapest Gambit, it would have to be rapid development. Black is prepared to sacrifice a pawn in order to seek the initiative", Bogdan Lillie, The Budapest Gambit, 1 998. The Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit goes round the World Sammi Fajarowicz. Kurt Richter and Ludwig Engels, StJVieUy Tartakower, Bora Kostic, Herman Steiner and Arthur Bisguier, Philip Stuart Milner-Barry, Mosh e Czerniak and Raaphy Persitz; in recent years grandmasters Juan Bellon and Alfonso Romero, Jan Rogers, Artur Kogan, Dimitri Reindermann, Alonso Zapata, Stuart Conquest and Glenn Flear played this Gambit.
However, it is not only grandmasters who have to decide the future of this at tractive variation: Jorgen Hvenekilde, Froede Soby, Niels Jen sen and Roger Thomsen from Denmark, Gerard WeUing from Holland, Mario Lllnzani from Italy, Georg Mohr and An drej Vospernik from Slovenia, Pierre Toulzac from France, Kjell Krantz and Tor:sten Oskar:sson from Sweden, John Gibson and Tim Harding from Ireland, Philip Corbin from Barbados, Bernd Voekler, Helmut Reeftchllleger, Peter Schaffarth, Helmut Wiltelsberger, Peter Leisebein, Reiner Klueting, Gerhardt Kratochwil, Christo/Herbrechameier, Hans Baum, Rene Dausch from Germany; and many others - they are all evidence that this Gambit
is still alive.
"Chess has always been a subject of fashion. The styles, openings, variations have often changed without any apparent reason. One day the adorable truth can adorable truth can tum out to be a mistake; finally time refutes everything and produces new original thoughts. For me this is a main attraction of our royal game", Rudolf Spielmann, Wiener Schachzeitung, /933. Why the Fajarowicz-Richter Gambit?
I like to write about openings which are inferior according to modem theory; to show how primitive and insufficient the common knowledge is. In most va riations I have drawn new conclusions; I am sure that this Gambit is fully viable and much better than its current reputation. I hope that my endeavour for high quality and understanding will find an ap preciative public. The material included is topical up to November 2003.
7
Part One: Less Popular Variations (l .d4 �f6 l.c:4 eS 3. dxeS �e4)
4...lLlc6 (4.. .ic5 ! ? 5.e3 - 5.ig3? .ib4+ 6.lLlc3 lLlxc3 7.ti'b3 lLlxa2+ 8.�dl lLlc6, Camon Bn:ssel - Zuazua Iglesias, Asturia The material divides as follows: 200 I -, 5 .ib4+ 6.�e2 m4 7.g3 ti'hS+ 8.lLJ13and now instead of 8 ...b6 9.ti'd5 Chapter I - 4 . .ie3 lLlc5 I O.ti'xa8 .ib7 l l .ti'xb8+ 'it>e7 1 2 . (4. 13, 4.e3, 4..if4, 4 ..id2) ti'xb7 lLlxb7 13.a3, Muttoni - Gonsalves Chapter 2 - 4.g3 e-mail 1999, 8 ... g5 9.ti'd4 gxf4 is better: Chapter 3 - 4.ltk3 e.g. IO.e6 0-0 l l .gxf4 lLlg5 12.fxg5 dxe6 Chapter 4 - 4.ti'd4 13.ti'M ti'g6 or IO.ti'xe4 fxg3 1 l.fxg3 gg8 Chapter 5 - 4.ti'd3 12.ti'M ti'g6. The irunediate 4...g5 � met Chapter 6 - 4.ti'd5. by 5..ld2 lLlc6 6.lLlc3lLlxd2 7.ti'xd2 lLlxe5 8.lLJ13, while 5.ti'c2? is wrong due to 5 ... Chapter I lLlxf2! , Duby - Loeffler, Cadap 1 982. 4.. .J.b4+ 5.lLld2 'Ml4 6.g3 lLlxd2 7 .ixd2 4 .le3 ti'xc4 8.lLJ13 lLlc6 9.ig2!? - improving There are four alternatives: on 9.b3 ixd2+ IO .ti'xd2 ti'e6 l l .ti'c3 0 4.13? m4+ 5 .g3 lLlxg3, Otto Borik; 0-0 12.ig2 ge8 13.0-0 b6 14.lLld4 ti'xe5 II) 4.e3 .ib4+ (for 4 ... lLlc6 5.lLJ13 d6! see 4.lLJ13 d6 5 .e3 lLlc6 - Part 4, Chap 1 5.e3 ib7, Doyle - Storgaard, e-mail ter I) 5..id2 (5.lLld2 lLlc6 6.lLJ13ti'e7 will 1 998 -, 9 ... 0-0 1 0.0-0 ixd2 l l .ti'xd2 transpose into 4.lLld2 ib4 5.lLJ13 lLJc6 ge8 J2 .gfcJ ti'e6 1 3 .gc3 leaves White 6.e3 ti'e7 - Part 3, Chapter 2, Section 3, slightly better) � an interesting position. Sequel I) 5 ...lLlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 7.lLl13 5.lLJf3 (5.13? ib4+ 6.lLld2 ixd2+ 7.ixd2 (7.a3 ixd2+ 8.ti'xd2 lLlxe5 9.0-0-0 0-0 'Ml4+ 8.g3 lLlxg3, Borik, while 5.a3 may I O.f4 lLlc6 l l .lLle2 ge8 with advantage transpose to 4.a3 lLlc6 5 ..if4 - Part 5, for Black, de Ia Rocha - Ramiro, Spain Chapter 3) 5...ic� (5...J.b4+ 6.lLlbd2 ti'e7 1997) 7 ...ti'e7 reaches a position after 7.a3 lLlxd2 8.lLlxd2 lLlxe5 is also pos 4.lLJ13ib4+ 5.id2 lLlxd2 6.lLlbxd2 lLlc6 sible. 9.ixe5 ixd2+ IO.ti'xd2 ti'xe5 is 7 .e3 ti'e7 - Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 1; covered under 4.ti'c2 ib4+ 5..id2 lLlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 7.lLlg13 ti'e7 8.a3 ixd2+ Ill) 4..if4 seems to give Black more pos 9.ti'xd2 lLlxe5 I O.lLlxe5 ti'xe5 - Part 2, sibilities. •
•
8
Chapter 3, Section 1 , and 9.e3 .ixd2+ 10.�xd2 d6 1 1 �e2 0-0 - l l ...gS? 12..ig3 �g6 13.�d4 b6 14.Af3 l::tb8 1 S .h4! f6 16.hxgS fxgS 1 7.0-0-0 was devastating, Hrtko - Gutdeutsch, Tatry 1997 - 12 .0-0 b6 is quite comfortable for Black) 6�g3 (after 6.e3 .ib4+ 7.ltlbd2 gS 8..lg3 hS 9.h3 �xg3 10.fxg3 �e7 1 1 .�3 .ixd2+ 12.�d2 Black can play on with 12 ..l!g8 13.g4 hxg4 14.hxg4 d6 1 S .exd6 �xd6+, while 12 ... ltlxeS, Panagoupoulos - Stei ner, Dubrovnik Olympiad 19SO, is less promising in view of 13.lt:lxeS!? �xeS 14.�c3) 6 ....ib4+ (6 ... �xeS? 7.�xeS ib4+ 8.ltlc3 lt:lxc3 9.\!lYb3 ltlxa2+ IO.'i!i>d l) 7.�bd2 �e7 8.�c2 (8.a3 .ixd2+ 9.�xd2 ltlxg3 10.hxg3 �xeS) 8 .. .Axd2+!? (8 ... �xd2 9.�xd2 �xeS 1 O.e3 0-0 l l .Ae2 d6 1 2.0-0 a5 is not bad either) 9.�xd2 �xg3 10.hxg3 �xeS l l .e3 d6 12�d3 Ad7 with equal chances, Gutman. IV) 4.Ad2 was suggested by Frantisek
14.e6 �xe6 1S .gxf3 0-0-0) S.�xd2 (if S.�xd2 �c6 6.f4 d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.e3 �e7, PeterSchaJ/fll'lh) 5...�c6 6.�c3 ib4 (6 ... d6 is another option, e.g.7.exd6.ixd6 8.�f3 Ae6 9.e3 �e7 or 7.�f3. when in stead of 7 .. .dxeS 8.�xd8+ �d8 9.� Ad7 lO.�gS, Balling - Pedersen, Hor sens 19S6, 7 ...�xeS S.�xeS dxeS 9.�xd8+ 'i!i>xd8 1 0.0-0-0+ .id7 might be the right answer. Nepustil analyses 6_.,lcS 7.�f3 0-0 8.e3 l::te 8 9..id3 �xeS lO.lt:lxeSl:ixeS, yet White can do better with 8.a3 l::te8 9.�f4 d6 10. �1 a5 l l .exd6.ixd6 12.�cl) 7.�f3 �e7 8.a3 Axc3 9.�xc3 transposes to 4.�f3ib4+S.Jd2 �d2 6.�bxd2 lt:lc6 7.a3 .ixd2+ 8.�xd2 �e7 9.�c3 - Part 4, Chapter 3, Sections 3/4, Gutm an.
Nepustil.
4 .lb4+ 4 ... �e7 S.�f3 �+ (Zilberstein - Sad riev, Podolsk 1 993, went 5...�c6 6.�c2 f5 7.exf6 gxf6 8.�c3 �xc3 9.�xc3 d6 10.g3 .ig7 l l ..ig2 .ig4 12.0-0 f5 13.�c2) 6.�bd2 �xd2 7.�xd2 �xc4 8.a3 �c6 9.l::tc l �e6 I O ..if4 favours W hite. •.
4...�xd2 (4-..lcS !? S.e3 �c6 6.�f3 �e7 7.�c3 �d2 8.�xd2 �xeS 9.�xeS �xeS IO.ie2, Ihche - Foerster,Germany 2001, 1 0...0-0 1 1 .0-0 l::te8 is level, while 6.�g4 d5 7.�xg7 l::tfl! 8.�f3 At3 9.�c3 �b4, Nepustil, is to Black's !icing, e.g. 10 ..& 1 �xd2 l l .ltlxd2 d4 12.�dS dxe3 13.fxe3 �xdS 14.cxdS Axe3 or 1 o.�xe4 �c2+ l l .'i!i>d l dxe4 12.�c2 exf3+ 13.'i!i>cl �d7
s.�dl �c6 S ...eM 6.�f3 �xd2 7 ..ixd2 �xc4 8 .e3
.ixd2+ 9.�xd2 �e6 IOJ!cl �c6 l l.Ac4 �e7 12 ..idS 0-0 13 .0-0, Gutman . 6.�0
6.f4 dS !? (this is more consequent than 6_�d4 7.�f3 �xf3+ 8.exf3 .ixd2+ 9bd2 �+ 10.'i!i>e2 �g3+ l l.hxg3 �xhl 12.� 9
Bh6 13.1e3 b6 14 ..id3) 7.li:\f3 (7.cxdS Chapt er l Bxd5 8.lllf3 .its 9.a3 .ixd2+ IO.lt:\xd2 ( l.d4 � f6 l.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4) ().()..{) l l.lt:\xe4 �xe4 12.�c l gS) 7 ....lts!? 4.g3 (I prefer this move to 7...d4 8 ..ig I .ig4 9.a3 ix.O I O.axb4 hg2 l l ..ixg2 'lflt4+ 12.�f l �xf4+ 13.lt:\f3 0-0 14.�c l �ts I S.bS lt:\xeS 16..ixd4lt:\g6 J 7,gg)ll!:fd8, MacReamoinn - Armstrong, Dublin 1991 , 18..ie3!) 8.a3 ixd2+ 9.lt:\xd2 dxc4 1 0.lt:\xe4 (I O.lt:\xc4 �+ l l .g3 lt:\xg3 12 .if2 �xf4) IO .. ..ixe4 with a plus for Black, Gutman.
·
4 ...i cS!
Gutman.
Alternatives are: I) 4 ... d6 S.ig2 (for S .lt:\0 see 4.lt:\f3 d6 S .g3 - Part 4, Chapter I) 5...�cS (if S ... .its, Pfeifer - Niestrath, Germany 1994, then is 6.�d3 strong) 6.lt:\f3 lt:\c6 7 ..lgS ie7 8 . .ixe7 �xe7 9.exd6 cxd6 I O.lt:\c3 ie6 l l .lt:\d4 lt:\xd4 1 2.�xd4 I :0 Toel Klueting,Dortmund 2001 ; II) 4 ... lt:\c6 S .ig2 ib4+ 6 .lt:\d2 (6.�f l 5!) 6. . .lt:\xd2 transposes t o 4.lt:\d2 .ib4 S .g3 lt:\c6 6.ig2 lt:\xd2 - Part 3 , Chap ter 2, Section 2 ; Ill) 4 ... .ib4+ S ..id2 (S.lt:\d2 reaches a position after 4.lt:\d2 .ib4 S.g3 - Part 3, Chapter 2, Section 2) S ...lt:\xd2 6.lt:\xd2 lt:\c6 7.lt:\gf3 (7.f4 d6 leaves White very exposed) 7 ...�e7 8 ..ig2 lt:\xeS (8 ... 0-0 9.0-0 aS is also worth of try) 9.0-0 0-0 IO.lt:\xeS �xeS l l .a3 .ixd2 (l l ....ie7!? 12.1l!:blll!:e8) 12.�xd2 d6 is approxima tely equal, Gutman.
7... �xeS 8.�xeS BxeS 9.Bcl 0-0
S.eJ Yre7
6 ...Be7
6. ..0.0 7.a3 lt:\xd2 8.lt:\xd2 hd2 + 9..ixd2 (9.�xd2 lt:\xeS IO.�c3 �e7 l l ..if4 ll!:e8 1 2 .e3 b6 13 ..ie2 ib7) 9 ... lt:\xeS IO..ic3 (if l O.e3 d6 l l ..ie2, then l l ...�gS 12.g3 �g6, Lahn - Suhr, Germany 1989) 10 ... �e7 l l .�d4 f6 12.e3 d6 13 ..ie2 .ie6 is also reasonable, Gutman. 7.g3
7.a3 lt:\xd2 8.lt:\xd2 (or 8 ..ixd2 .ixd2+ 9.�xd2 lt:\xeS IO.lt:\xeS �xeS) 8 ....icS 9 ..ixcS �xeS I O.e3 �xeS l l .�c2 0-0 12 ..id3 �hS!? 13 .ie2 Bh6 14.0-0 d6,
S ...lt:\c6 6.lt:\f3 (Schandorff- Conquest, Torshavn 1997, continued 6..lg2 ib4+ 7.lt:\d2 lt:\cS 8.lt:\gf3 lt:\d3+ 9.�2 lt:\xc l+ IO.Il!:xc I 0-0 l l .a3 .ie7, when instead of 12.�c2 �e8 13 .lt:\e4 id8 14.lt:\egS g6 IS.h4 lt:\xeS 16.lt:\xeS �xeS 17.f4 �g7
9 ...lt:\xd2 IO..ixd2 ixd2+ l l .�xd2 aS!? 12..lg2 0-0 (Jirka - Cech, Pra�e 2000, went 1 2 ...1l!:a6 13.0-0 hS 14.h4) 1 2.0-0 ll!:e8 with equality. 10..lglll!:e811 .0-0 .lxdl ll.i xdl d6
Black is definitely not worse, Gutman. 10
9.�dl d6 I O..ig2.!0e4 l l.a3 a5 12.0-0 .ig4 1 3 .�c2 0-0 14 ..!0d4.!0g5 15 .!0xc6 . bxc6 16..ixc6 .!00+ (stronger than 16 ... goo s J 7..ig2.!0h3+ IS.<�h ll:W I9.!0c3 . �f7 20.!0dl . &8 2 l.b3 &6, when instead of 22.&2 Ml5 23.e4 g5, Vasicek - Stu lilc, Zlin 1 943, White could play 22..ib2, viz. 22 ..ixe3 23.!0xe3 . .!Oxf2+ 24.Wxf2 lhf2 25 .!0xg4) . I 7.'�g2 �e5 with good attacking chances for Black, Gutm an; II) 7.a3.!0xe5 8 ..!0xe5 �xe5 9..ig2 a5 10.�0 (IO.�d5 �xd5 l l .cxd5.!0d6 12.b3 b6) IO ...d6 l l .�d5 �xd5 1 2.cxd5 .if5 13.b3 0-0 is also fine for Black, Senft Kull, Wangs Pizol 1 996.
1 8 .'�f2 d6, 12 .!0e4! . �e8 1 3 .�d5 .idS 14.h4 might be good for White, yet in my opinion Black can do better with 9 ... .!Odxe5 I o.ti�xe5.!0xe5) 6...d6 (6 ...'9e7 goes back into the main line) is maybe more effective, 7.exd6 (7 ..ig2 .ib4+ 8..!0bd2 .ig4 9.h3 Jh5 IO.exd6 �xd6 or 7.a3 .ig4 8..ig2?! .!Oxe5 9.h3 .ih5 IO.g4 .!OxO+ I I ..ixO .ig6 1 2 .b4 .ib6 13..ib2 .ix e3, Vojta - Vavra, Czech Republic 1 999, are both unpleasant for White) 7.. ..ib4+ 8 .!0bd2 . (if 8 ..id2 "ef6!) 8 ...'9xd6 9.a3 (9..ie2 �f6 10.0-0 .!Oxd2 l l ..!Oxd2 .ih3) 9 .. ..ixd2+ I O..!Oxd2 .if5 l l ..ie2 ( I I ..ig2 0-0-0 12..ixe4 .ixe4 13.�g4+ f5 14.!0xe4 . �e5 1 5.!0d6+ . lhd6 16.'9e2.!0a5 1 7.�c2 &6) 1 1 ...0-0-0 12.!0xe4 . �xdl+ 13.ixdl .ixe4 14.0.0 .id3 is at least even, GutmJJn.
•
7...�xeS
7 ....ib4+ 8.�fl !? (there is nothing for White in 8.ltlbd2 ltlxe5 9.0-0, viz. 9 ... ltlxd2 I O..ixd2 .ixd2 l l .�xd2 ltlx0+ 12..ix0 d6 1 3J�fdl 0-0, Olsen - Yabra, Siegen Olympiad 1970) 8...ltlxe5 9.'9d4 ltlxO IO.�xg7!? �e5 l l .�xe5+ ltlxe5 12 ..ixe4 ltlxc4 1 3 .b3 ltlb6 1 4 ..ib2 0-0 15.ltlc3 c6 16.h3 d5 17..ic2 .ie6 18.�g2 mds 19.ltle2 appears to be slightly awk ward for Black, Gutman. 8.�xeS 1fxeS 9.0-0 0-0 10.1fcl Ke8
IO ....!Of6 I l..id2 ( l l..!Od2 a5 12 .!0b3 . is less impressive due to 12 .. ..ie7 I 3..id2 a4 14..ic3 �e6 1 5.!0d2 . d6) I l ...a5 (after l l...d6 12 ..ic3 �e7 13.b4 .ib6 1 4.�b2 Black has more problems ) 1 2 ..ic3 �e7 13.�f5 (13.ltld2 d6 14.ltle4 ltlxe4 1 5.ixe4 h6 16.gfd l ges 1 7 ..if5 .ixfS 18.�xf5, Rietra - de Laat, corr 1990, 18 ...�e4!) 13 ....!0e8 (or 13 ...ga6 14.ltld2) 14.!0d2 . .ib4 15.ltle4 keeping a very small edge for White, Gutman.
6.�0
6.� d5 f5 ( 6.. J.b4+ 7.!0 . d2.!0xd2 8..ixd2 .ixd2+ 9.�xd2 �xe5 seems playable, e.g. 10.!00 . �e7 l l ..ig2 0-0 12.0-0 d6 13.!0d4.!0d7) . 7.exffi .!Oxf6 8.�dl (8.�d3 .!Oc6 9 .!00 . .!Ob4 I O.�dl �e4 l l ..!Oa3 0-0 12 ..ie2 d5, Waleschkowski - Fer nandez Egea, Rhein Main 2001 ) 8 ... 0-0 ensures Black the initiative, Gutm an.
tt.�dl �r6 1 l.�b3 .ie7 1 3 . .idl d6
The position is balanced, Gutman .
6 ... �c6 7.Agl
Others: I) 7.�d5 fS (7 .. ..ib4+ is another option: 8.!0bd2 . .!Oxd2 9 ..ixd2 .ixd2+ I O.�xd2 .!Oxe5 and if 8.'�e2 .!Og5) 8.exf6 .!Oxf6 II
Alternatives: I) 5 ...g6 6.liJf3 h6 7.g3 (John Gibson gives 7 .i.f4 ig7 8.lThl liJc6 as level, viz. 9.�d2 �e7 I O.!!b5 a6 l l .�d5 b6) 7 ... liJc6 8..ig2 �e7 9.0-0 ig7 IO.�b l liJxe5 l l .liJxe5 ixe5 12..ie3 !? c6 13.�d2 d6 14.!!fdl if 5 1 5 .�b3 , Gutman; further II) 5 ... b6, Tseitlin/GIIIskov, 6.liJf3 ib7 7.if4!? (7.g3 liJc6 8.ih3 h6 9.0-0 .ic5 IO.�d3 �e7 l l.!!dl 0-0-0 leaves Black in control) 7 ... liJc6 8.e3 ic5 (if 8 ...h6, then 9..id3, while Lopez - Rodriguez, Zaragoza 1999, continued 9.liJd4 �e7 IO.a4 liJxe5 l l.a5 g5 12..ig3 ig7, when 13.liJf5 �f6 14.liJxg7+ �xg7 15.�d4 f6 might be tried) 9..id3 �e7 IO.i.e4 0-0-0 I IJ.d5 h6 12.0-0 g5 13.i.g3 h5 14.h4 g4 15 .liJg5, Gutman ; similarly III) 5 ...ic5 6.liJf3 liJc6 7 .ig5 !? (7.if4 �e7 8.e3 b6 9.id3 ib7 will transpose into /I, while 7 ... 0-0?! 8.e3 b6 9..id3 h6 I O.h4 f6 l l .i.c2 gave White a massive attack, Jonathan - Wurch, France 1946) 7 ... ffi (7...i.e7 8J.f4) 8.exffi gxf6 9..ih4! (less consequent is 9..if4 �e7 I O.e3 d6 I I J.d3 ig4 12.�c2 hf3 13 .gxf3 0-0-0 14.!!bl liJe5 1 5 .if5+ 'it>b8 16.i.e4 b6!? 17.�a4, when instead of 17 ...d5 18.cxd5 f5 1 9..hf5 liJxf3+ 20.'it>e2 liJd2 2 l .!!bdl �xd5 22.id3 �xd3 23.'it>xd3 and White won, Post!Pemeder - Richter/Jacoby, consultation game Berlin 1 933, 17 ...f5! 18.ixe5 �xe5 1 9.ic6 �xc3+ 20.'it>e2 f4 2 l .�hcl �a3 could be better) 9...d6 I O.liJd2 (IO.e3 �e7 l l.i.e2 id7 12 .0-0 0-0-0 1 3.liJd4 liJe5 14.!!bl !!dg8 1 5.a4 �g7 16.if3 c6 1 7 .ig3 liJxf3+ 1 8.�xf3 ig4 19.�f4 with White having the ad vantage, lgel - Donegan, Vienna 1 936, but 17 ... h5 ! 18.!.e4 h4 1 9.ixe5 fxe5 is more to the point) I O ... �e7 l l .e3 �e5 12.�f3 with a plus for White, Gutman.
Chapt er 3 (l .d4 �f6 2.c:4 eS 3.dxeS �e4) 4.�c:3
4 �xc: 3 •••
4 .. ..ib4 keeps more tension, but gener ally has no independent significance: I) 5.�d4 will transpose into 4.�d4 .ib4+ 5 .liJc3 - Chapter 4 ; D) 5.�d3 reaches a position after4.�d3 .ib4+ 5 .liJc3 - Chapter 5; 01) For 5 .�c2 see 4.�c2 .ib4+ 5.liJc3 Part 2, Chapter 3, Section 3; IV) Only 5.id2 seems to be an excep tion, 5 .. ..ixc3 6..ixc3 (6.bxc3 liJc6 7.liJf3 �e7 8..ie3 �a3 ! 9 �b3 �a5 while 8 ... liJxe5, Frantisek Nepustil, is worse due to 9.�d4 liJxf3+ I O.gxf3 liJf6 l l .�g l ) 6 ...liJxc3 7.bxc3 liJc6 8.liJf3 0-0 9.!!bl (Magrin - Contedini, Milan 1 968, went 9.e3 �e7 IO.i.e2 liJxe5 l l .liJxe5 �xe5) 9 ... �e8 I O.�b5 �e7 ( I O ...b6 l l .e3 !!e7 12 .id3 h6 1 3 .0-0 �e8 14.if5 liJxe5 !? 15 .�xe5 !!xe5 16.liJxe5 �xe5 1 7 .i.xd7 .ib7 was seen in Baguero - Alderton, Winnipeg 1 997) l l.�d3 h6 12 .e3 �e8 1 3 .i.e2 liJxe5 and I pref er the black pos ition, Gutman. S.bxc: 3 Black has no problems reckoning that Wh ite's extra pawn is worthless when doubled and isolated, Tim Harding.
6.�13
6.f4 (may well be critical, Gibson) 6 ... ic5 !? (6 ...d6 is playable, for example,
s... �c: 6
12
7.�f3 dxeS 8.Yhd8+ 'it>xd8 9.fxeS .icS lO..igS+ 'it>e8 or 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.�f3 0-0 9.e4 l::te8) 7.�f3 d6 8.exd6 0-0 9.e3 l::te8 IO ..ie2 cxd6 secure good prospects for Black, Gutman.
bxcS 17.�e2 �a4, Harding, 1 8 ..ixeS .ixeS 19.�f3 .ixc3 20.l::tc 1.if6 2l.�e1 l::tdS 22.hS gS 23.l::t f3 , while 16.c6 �xh3 17.gxh3, Harding, 1 7 ... �f3+ 1 8 .�xf3 l::txd2 1 9.'it>xd2 l::td8+ 20.�d4 .ixh3 fa vours Black) I S .cS .ixfl 1 6.'it>xfl gS! ( 1 6...bxcS 17 .�e2 cxd4 1 8.�a6+iL!b7 19.l::t b 1 �dS 20.c4 �e4 2 l itb3 d3 22.f3 d2 23.fxe4 dl�+ 24.'it>f2 l::td2+ 2S.'it>g3 fug2+ 26.'it>xg2 �e2+ is perpetual, Har ding) 1 7 . .ig3 g4 1 8 .l::th 1 bxcS 1 9 .�e2 cxd4 20.�a6+�b7 2 1 itbl �dS 22.cxd4 hS! (22...tve4 23.l:b:t Sl::txd4 24.exd4 .ixd4 2S.'it>gl f5 ? ! 26.tvg6 l::tfll 27.'it>h2 �d8 28.l::t c l lL!e6 29.tvxe6+ I :0 Taksrud Gibson, corr 1990) 23.l::tc1 l::td7 24.tvxa7 �aS 2S .tvxaS �xaS 26.'it>e2 �b7 when Black is close to win, Gutm an ; B) 7.l::tb l ! ? �e7 8.tvdS g6 9.l::tb3 .ig7 10.ia3 �e6 l l .e3 �xeS 12.�d4 looks slightly better for White, Gutman.
6...d6!
All other moves are weaker. I) 6 ... g6 7 ..igS .ie7 8 ..ih6, Harding; II) 6 .. .f6 7.�dS (7.exf6?! �xf6 8.�c2 ib4 9..id2 0-0 IO.�gS g6 l l.f4d6 12.e4, Schweinchen - Richter, Munich 1940, and now 12 ... .icS should be tried) ? ... �e7 (7.. .fxeS 8..igS .ie7 9.�xeS) 8.exf6 �xf6 9.�d4 �eS (9 �xd4 IO.�xd4 .ie7 l l .g3 0-0 1 2 . .ig2) I O.e3, Gutman; III) 6 ... �e7 7.�dS (7 ..igS �cS 8.�dS d6) 7...g6 8.a3.ig7 9..igS �e6 IO.�xe6+ fxe6 l l ..if4 l::tffi 12.e3 d6 13..ig3 ! (13.h4 �xeS 14 ..ixeS dxeS 1 S.hS e4 16.�d4 cS 1 7.�e2 .id7 was played in Mayer Kuenstl, corr 1946) 1 3...�xeS 14.�xeS .ixeS 1S..ixeS dxeS 1 6..id3 .id7 1 7 ..ie4 0-0-0 1 8.h4 .ie8 1 9.hS, Gutman; IV) 6 ... h6, after: A) 7..if4 �e7 (7 ... gS 8..ig3 �e7 9.�d4 �xeS 10.�15 �cS, Gibson, l l .�d5 �xd5 12 .cxdS d6 13.�d4 .id7 with equality) 8.h4 (8.�d4 � xeS) 8 ... g6 9.�d2 .ig7 I O.l::th3 b6 1 l .�d4 ( l l .l::td1 �aS 12 .e3 �b7!?) l l ....ia6 12.e6 0-0-0 13.exd7+ �xd7 14.e3 �aS (if 14 ...�eS IS.cS .ixfl , then White obtains a plus b y 16.'it>xfl !
7.Af4
7. .igS �d7 8.exd6 .ixd6 9.e3 f6 (9 ...0-0 1 0..id3 �eS ll.�xeS .ixeS I 2.�c2 h6 13 ..ih4 �g4 14..ig3 .ixg3 1S .hxg3 .ie6 is also not bad) IO..ih4 �f7 l l .�c2 .ie6 1 2.l::tb l 0-0 13 ..id3 g6 14.�d4?! .ixc4 IS ..ixc4 �xc4 1 6.�b3 �xb3 1 7.l::t xb3 �aS 18.l::tb l cS was excellent for Black in Hamburger - Richter, Berlin 1948.
.•
7 .ie6 ...
Less challenging are: I) 7 .. ..ie7 8.e3 0-0 9. .ie2 .ig4 1 O.exd6 .ixd6 l l..ixd6 tvxd6 12.�xd6 (12.�d4?! .ixe2 13.tvxe2 �eS 14.�0 �cS 1S.l::tab1 b6 1 6itbS tve7 17 .�hS �g6 1 8.'Wh3 cS, Franz Penndorf, corr 1989) 12 ... cxd6 13itdl l::tfd8 14.�d4 .ixe2 IS.'it>xe2 �eS 16.�fS �xc4 1 7 .l::td4, Gutman; further D) 7 ....if5 8.tva4!? (8.exd6 .ixd6 9..ixd6 �xd6 I O.tvxd6 cxd6 l l .�d4 .ie6 12.e3 l::tc8 is OK for Black) 8 ...dxeS (8 ... .id7 9.tvc2) 9.�xeS (9.l::td l? .id7 10 ..igS f6 was seen in Oestreich - Reefschlaeger, Germany 1970) 9 ...�f6 I O.l::t d1 .ie4 (if -
13
IO . .ld6 l l.�xc6 .lxf4, then 12.tt:lb4+ c6 13.�d5 �eS 14.tt:lxf4 �xf4 lS.�) l l .e3 .ld6 12.cS !? .ixeS 1 3.�xe4 0-0 14.1xeS would maintain some edge for White, Gutman. ..
Chapt er 4 (l .d4 �f6 l. c4 eS 3. dxeS �e4) 4.6'd4
Wh itefinds the only way to get a bad position, Julian Hodgson.
8. exd6
4...�cS
Some examples of other moves: I) 8.e3?! dxeS 9.�xd8+ gxd8 l O..lxeS ( I O.tt:lxeS tt:laS l l.gb 1 .ld6) lO ... tt:lxeS l l .tt:lxeS .le7 (I prefer l l...g6!?) 12 .tt:lf3 .if6 13.gc} cS 14.ie2 0-0 1 S .tt:\d2 gd7 16.f4 gfd8 17.tt:lf3 �6 1 8.e4 � 19.eS .le7 20.'�f2 �2 with a better ending for Black in Wade - Milner Barry, British Ch 19S3; II) 8.�a4 dxeS 9 ..lxeS (9.lOxeS? �f6) 9 ... �e7!? I O.id4 �a3 l l .�xa3 .lxa3 1 2.gbl 0-0, Gutman.
Th is is the right move, Otto Borik.
Practice has seen three more options: I) 4 ... dS?! S.cxdS (S.�xdS �xd5 6.cxdS tt:\d7 7 .tt:lf3 is also not bad) S ....if5 6.e3 (Sabolik - Deak, Bratislava 1 996, con tinued 6.l0c3 .lcS 7.�a4+ bS 8.�xbS+ c6 9.'�c4hf2+ I O.Wdl, when lO...cxdS l l.tt:lxdS tt:ld7 should be decisive) 6 ... .icS 7.�c4 c6 8.d6 �a5+ 9.id2 tt:lxd2 IO.tt:lxd2 .lb4 l l .tt:lf3 .lxd2+ (I I ... tt:ld7 1 2.�d4) 1 2.tt:lxd2 �xeS 1 3 .�b4 tt:ld7 14.tt:\ c4 with advantage, Gutman; ll)4 ...f5 S.exffi tt:lxffi 6..igS (6.tt:lf3 tt:lc6 7.�h4 can be met by 7 .. .i.e?!? 8.a3 0-0 9.tt:lc3 d6 I O..igS h6 l l ..lxffi .lxffi, im proving on 7...ib4+ 8.l0bd2 0-0 9.e3 d6 IO.id3 tOeS ll..ic2 .lg4? 12 .tt:lxeS dxeS 13..ixh7+ tt:lxh7 14.�xg4, Czucharski Rygie�corr 1962 ) 6 ...tt:lc6 (6.. ..ie7 7.tt:lc3 tt:lc6 8.�d2 0-Q 9.tt:lf3) 7 .ixf6 (is more precise than 7.�d2 h6, 7.�e3+ Wf7 or 7.�h4 tt:lb4 8 ..lxf6 �xf6 9.�xf6 gxf6 10.tt:la3 b6 ll.tt:lf3 .ib7) 7 ...tt:lxd4 8.ixd8 tt:lc2+ 9.Wdl tt:\xal IO..ixc7! (IO..igS dS
8.. ..lxd6 9..lxd6 1hd6 IO.thd6 cxd6 l l. e3 We7 ll.�d4
Horstmann - Hartmann , corr 199S, went 1 2 .gdl tOeS 1 3 .tt:ld2 ghc8 1 4.gb 1 b6 1 S.m.4&7 16.h3 �c8 17.Wdl tt:\xc4. l l .. J�ac8 13. lll b l b6 14. a4
If 14.tt:lbS, then 14 ...!:Dld8 I S.f4 gd7 16. .ld3 tt:laS , Gutman. 14.. .�xd4 1S. cxd4 .lxc4 16. Wdl .lxfl 1 7 .�d l lllc4
It is White who has to wony about main taining the balance, Gutman.
14
Bwjassot 1996, loses immediately to 9... .hd2+ 10.'it>xd2 dxe5+. Also 7.Y9f4 0-0 8.lt:lf3 d6! ? might give Black a strong initiative, e.g. 9.0.0.0 dxe5 IO.lt:lxe5 lt:lxe5 I I .Y9xe5 Y9h4,Vandersluys - Maidana Guena, e-mai1 200 I, or 9.exd6 .ixd6 I 0. 'Wh4 Y9e8, when neither 1 1 .0-0-0 lt:lb4 12.a3 lt:la2+ 13.'it>bl .ha3 14.bxa3 lt:lc3+ 15.'it>c2 lt:lxdl 16.'it>xdl Y9a4+, nor l l.e3 lt:lb4 12.lt:ld4, Woemdle - Karrer, Wat tens 1994, 12...c5 13.a3 cxd4 14.axb4 dxe3 are enjoyable for White) 7...0-0 (7 ...Y9e7 8.a3 .b:dl+ 9.Y9xd2 lt:lxe5 IO.e3 b6II.Y9d5 lt:lc6 12 .Jd3 ib7 13.lt:lf3 0-0-0 14.0-0 f6 15 ..ie2 lt:le5 turned out well foc Black, Knechtel - Plank, Passau 1997, but II . lt:le2 ib7 12.lt:lf4 is less clear to me) 8.a3 (8.lt:lf3 ge8 !?) 8 .. ..txd2+ 9.Y9xd2 lt:lxe5 IO.e3 d6 1 I ..te2 .ie6 1 2.gc1 Y9g5 ( 1 2 ... Y9d7 13.lt:lf3 �8 14.� lt:lxf3+ 15.ixf3 b6 16.gfd1 .ig4 1 7.ixg4 Y9xg4 is equal, Seeliger - Lindner, Wuerzburg 1997) 13.'it>fl ( 1 3 .g3 Y9e7 14.lt:lf3 .ih3) 13 ... Y9ffi with difficulties for White, Gutman; C) 5 .lt:ld2! lt:lxd2 (Svela - Gundersen, Norway 1 992, went 5 ...Y9h4 6.lt:lf3 lt:lc6 7.Y9e3 lt:lxd2 8.ixd2 Y9xc4 9.a3 .b:d2+, when instead of 1 0.lt:lxd2? Y9e6 1 l.f4 d6 12.Y9g3 0-0 13.exd6 cxd6 14.e4 d5 15.e5 ffi 1 6.lt:lf3 fxe5 1 7.fxe5 lt:lxe5 1 8.lt:lxe5 g5, I O.Y9xd2 0-0 l l .e3 Y9e6 12.Y9c3 has to be tried. However, after 6.g3 lt:lxd2 7.Y9xh4 lt:lf3+ 8.'it>d1 lt:lxh4 9.gxh4 lt:lc6 IO.lt:lf3 0-0, Class 58 - Badaknna, inter net 2002, l l .ggl ges 12..tf4 d6 13.exd6 �8 14.a3 .b:d6 15.ixd6 �d6+ 1 6.'it>el the ending is clearly better for White) 6.ixd2 lt:lc6 7.Y9d5 .b:d2+ 8.Y9xd2 lt:lxe5 9.Y9c3 Y9ffi IO.g3 0-0 ll.ig2 ges 12.lt:lh3 (12.gc l Y9g6 13.gdl d6 14.lt:lf3 lt:l xf3+ I5..txf3 .ig4 16.ixg4 Y9xg4 17.� ges 1 8.0-0 �8 19.Y9f3 Y9xf3 20.exf3 ge2 favoured Black in Garcia - hpata, Cali 2000) 12 ...c6 13.0-0 d6 14.lt:lf4 .ig4 and the chances are level, Gutman.
l l.cxd5 .if5 12.lt:lc3 .ib4 favours Black: 1 3 .lt:lb5? ! 0-0 14.f3 c6 1 5 .dxc6 Wd8+ 16.'it>cl ic2 17 .ixd8 �hd8 1 8.lt:lc3 .hc3 1 9.bxc3 gd ) + 20.'it>b2, Sed - Gedult, Paris 1971, 20...gbI+ 2I .'it>a3 Ae4! with mate in few moves, or 13.f3 � 14.e3 h6 I5..tf4 �e8 I6..tc4 g5 17.ixc7 lt:lc2 1 8.d6+'it>g7 I9..tb5 lt:lxe3+ 20.'it>cl gc8) IO ...d6 I I..ia5 .iB l2.lt:ld2 !?,Anatoli Mat�ulu!vich, viz. 12 _.J.c2+ 13.'it>c I d5 14.lt:lgf3 dxc4 15 .lt:ld4 .ig6 16.e4 gcs 17.'it>bl and the knight is gone, Gutman; III) 4 .. ..tb4+!? is more popular.
The play may continue: A) 5.lt:lc3 lt:lxc3 6.bxc3 lt:lc6 7.Y9e3 ia5 (Svela - Reefschlaeger, Gausdal 1990, proceeded 7 .. ..te7 8.Y9g3 �fB 9..if4 b6 I O.lt:lf3 h6 l l .h4 .ia6 12.e4 .ic5 1 3.h5 Y9e7 14.lt:lh4 Y9e6 1 5 ..ie2 ges 16 ..ig4 Y9xc4 17.Y9f3 'it>g8 18.e6 dxe6 19 .e5 lt:lb4 0:1, yet after I I Ed I Y9e8 1 2.lt:ld4 White keeps the pressure) 8.lt:lf3 (8 ..ia3?! is worse in view of 8 ... Y9h4 9.Y9d2 Y9xc4 J O.gc) Y9e6 l l .g3 lt:lxe5, Mohd Yusof Halim Shuhaimi, Malaysia 1996) 8 ... Y9e7 9Ebl Y9e6 10Eb3 Y9xc4 I I..ta3 b6 12.g3 ib7 13..tg2 lt:ld4 14.lt:lxd4 .b:g2 ISJ!gl .idS 16.lt:lb5 a6 17.Y9g5 f6 seems rather good for Black, Gutman; B) 5.id2 lt:lxd2 6.lt:lxd2 lt:lc6 7.Y9e3 (This is the best retreat. 7.Y9g4 0-0 8.f4 d6 9. Y9g3, Goves Tomas- Folch hragoza, 15
to I O ... ll:lxa2+! l l .ll:lxa2 ll:lb3+ 12.bl ll:lxd2+, viz. 13 Jhd2 �f5+ 14.e4 �xe4+ IS.J.d3 �g4 16.h3 ms, Karl Gilg) I 0... hd7 1 1 .0-0-0 .i.f5 (l l ...f6 12ie3 0-0-0 13 ..lxcS hcS 14.a3 ll:lc6 IS.e3) 12.b3 ltle4 are all better for Black, Gutm an. 6... d6!?
s.�o
Others tend to run into trouble: I) S .b4? l0c6 6.'lfh2 ll:lxb4 7 . .i.d2 ltlc6 8.ll:lf3 d6 9.exd6 �xd6 I O.ll:lc3 .i.fS(an other possibility is IO ...�e6 l l.e3 .i.d6) l l .ll:ldS ( l l lki l ? �e6 12.ll:ld5? li:ld3 mate Freudenberg - Defosse, Brussels 193S) 1 1 ...0-0-0 12..lf4 ll:la4, Gutman; II) S . .i.f4 ?! ll:lc6 6.�d I d6 7 .exd6 �f6! 8.�d2 ll:le4 9.�c I (if 9.�e3 , Happala Sommer, Austria 1997, then 9 ...�xb2 I O.�xe4+ .i.e6) 9 ... .i.xd6 I O.ll:lc3 �xf4 l l .�xf4 .i.xf4 12.ll:lxe4 ll:lb4, Gutman.
There are three more plans: I) 6 ...ll:le4 reaches a position after 4 .ll:l f3 ll:lc6 - Part 4, Chapter I; 1.5' S' r U)6 ...h6 is a waste of time, 7.ll:lc3 (7 ..if4 ll:le6 8..lg3 .tb4+ 9.ll:lbd2 0-0 IO.a3 .i.e7 l l .e3 d6 1 2 .exd6 hd6 13 . .i.xd6 �xd6 14.ll:le4 �e7 IS.ll:lc3 .!:ld8 1 6.ll:ldS, Ros Markus, corr 1 99S) 7...d6 8.exd6 i.xd6 9.ll:lbS 0-0 I O.ll:lxd6, Gutman; Ill) 6 ... �e7!? is more intriguing, 7.g3 (7..lgS �e6 8.�dS, Klerks - Jobski, Ger many 1998, 8...�g6!?, and if7.�dS ll:lb4 8.�d2. then not 8...�e6 9.e3 'lff5 IO.li:ld4 �xeS l l .ll:lc3, Vann - Griggs, Eng land 1 989, but 8 ...d5, e.g. 9.cxdS ll:le4 IO.d6 ll:lxd2 or 9.ll:la3 dxc4 I O.ll:lxc4 ll:le4) 7 ...ll:lxeS 8.ll:lxeS �xeS 9..ig2ll:le6 10.�0 .i.cS l l .ll:lc3 hS seems equal, Gutman.
s . .�t6 6.8'dt .
We mention here: I) 6.�e3 ll:lb4 (instead of6 ...ltle6 7.ll:lc3 .i.cS 8.�d3 d6 9.exd6 hd6 I O.e4 ll:lcS I I.� I 0-0 12ie3 .i.g4 1 3ie2 f5 14.0-0, Schroeter - Faber, e-mail 2001) 7.�d2 dS 8.cxd5 (8.exd6 .i.xd6 9.ltlc3 0-0) 8 ... .tf3 9.ll:la3 (9.ll:ld4i.xbl IO.�b l �xdS) 9 ... ll:lxdS IO.�d l ll:le4, Gutman; II) 6.�c3 dS (6 ... ltle6 7.a3 gS 8.h3 .i.g7 9 .e3 d6, Borilc, though LaS is also good, viz. 8.e4?,Lengert - Stankovic, Chely 2003, 8 .. J.b4) 7.exd6 (7 . .i.gS d4 8.�d2 �d7) 7 ... �xd6 8.ll:lbd2 .i.fS, Gutm an; III) 6.�dS d6 7 J.gS �d7 8.ll:lc3 (8.exd6 hd69.ll:lc3 ll:lb4 IO.�d2 �e6 l l.e3 �g6 and Black has a clear advantage, Borik) Lll:lb4 9.� dxeS I O.�xd7+ (1 0.().().0, Gilg- Fajarowicz, Bautzen 1929, fails
7..if4
Alternatively: I) 7 .J.gS �d7 8.exd6 .i.xd6 9 .ll:lc3 0-0 I O.ll:lbS ( IO.e3 �f5 l lie2 ll:leS) I O...�f5 l l .li:lxd6 cxd6 12.J.e3 (12.a3 ll:leS) 1 2 ... .i.e6 I Hie I ( 1 3 .�xd6 li:le4) 1 3 .. JUd8, Gutman; further 16
m 7.exd6 .ixd6 (7...�xd6!? 8.�xd6 .ixd6
deserves attention, viz. 9.i.d2 .if5 I O.g3 0-0-0 l l .i.g2 �e8, Che - TtBsi, e-mai I 2001 ) 8.lik3 .ig4 9.o!Llb5(9.e3 0-0 I O.i.e2 �ffi l l.o!Lld5 �6 12.lLld4 .ixe2 13.�xe2 o!Lle5) 9 ... 0-0 I O.o!Llxd6 cxd6 l l.e3 �f6 12.i.e2 lLle5 1 3 .lLlxe5 .ixe2 14.�xe2 (or 14.o!Lld7 o!Llxd7 1 5.�xe2 lLlb6) 14 ... dxe5 1 5 .0-0 ( 1 5 .e4 �4 1 6.b4 o!Lle6) 1 5 ... e4, Gutman; similarly Ill) 7.o!Llc3 .ig4! (After 7 ... o!Llxe5 8.o!Llxe5 dxe5 9.�xd8+'it>xd8 10.i.g5+ ffi I I .Q-0.0+ .id7 the game simplifies. 7 .. .i.f5 is more attractive, e.g. 8.a3, Geier - Schratzens taller, Germany 1999, 8 ... dxe5, or 8.o!Lld4 o!Llxd4 9.�xd4 o!Lle6 10.�e3 ie7 l l .g3 dxe5 12 .i.g2 c6 1 3 .�xe5 .ig6 14.0-0 .id6 15. �e3 .ic5, Partys - Osipov,Tomsk 2002) 8.h3 (for 8.exd6 .ixd6 see 7 .exd6 -/f) 8.. J.xf3 9.gxf3 � IO.e4 ()..()..(), Le Ga\ 1 Tripoteau, Fr.mce 200 1, gives Black fiily adequate counterplay, Gutman.
D) 7 .. .i.f5!? 8.exd6 (8.o!Llc3 dxe5 9.o!Llxe5?
o!Llb4) 8 ... �f6 9.o!Llc3 0-0-0, when: A) IO.o!Lld5 �xb2 l l.dxc7 §xd5 12.cxd5
lLlb4 13.&1 lLlc2+ 14.§x.c2 .ixc2 15.�c l o!Lld3+ 16.exd3tb4+ 17.'i!;le2 ge8 18.o!Lle5 §xeS+ 19.� �xcl 20.i.xcl .id l+ is at least quite good for Black, Graham Bur gess, The Mammoth Book of Chess ; B) I O.i.g5 �e6 l l ..ixd8 lLld3+ 1 2.'it>d2
( 1 2.�xd3 .ixd3 13.i.xc7 gives White a fair amount of material for the queen, Burgess; however, not enough in view of l 3 ...i.xc4 14.0-0-0 .ie7 15.o!Lld4 o!Llxd4 16.gxd4 .id8 17.e3 .ixtl 1 8.gxfl .ixc7 1 9.dxc7 'it>xc7 20.gfdl gc8) 1 2 ...lLlxf2 13.�a4 .ixd6 14.i.g5.gd8 (14 ... o!Llxhl !? 1 5 .lLld5 lLlf2) 1 5 .o!Lld5 f6 16.Ae3 .ib4+ t 7.<;!;lct o!Llxhl (Sarmiento - Aristizabal, Bogota 1 996, went 1 7 ... gxd5 1 8 ..ixf2 gcs 19.e4 �xe4 20 ..ixc5 .ixc5 21 .lLld2 ie3 22.�3 o!Lld4 23.�c3lLlc2, and now 24.i.d3 �xd3 25.�xd3 .ixd3 26,ID, J o!Llb4 27.a3 should win for White) 18.i.g I �e4 1 9.�b3 .id6 favours Black, Gutman; C) I O.�d2 .ixd6 l l.i.xd6 §xd6 12 .o!Lld5 �e6 13.e3 looks tougher, Gutman. 8.exd6 Yrf6
8.. .i.xd6? 9. .ixd6 �xd6 IO.�xd6 cxd6 l l .o!Llc3 (not l l .lLlfd2 o!Llb4 1 2 .lLla3 0-0 13.0 gfe8, Andre - Hickl, corr 1 987) 1 1 ...0-0-0 12.0-0-0 mte8 1 3.o!Lld4 o!Llxd4 1 4.gxd4 is Ros - Back, corr 1 995 . 9.Yfdl
9.�c l .ixd6 10bd6 �xd6 l l.�e3+ o!Lle6 12.lLlbd2 0-0-0 13.0-0-0 ghe8, Gutm an.
7 .. .Ag4
9....Axd6 10 ..Axd6 0-0-0 ll .Yrf4
Some examples of other moves, with Black employing differing strategies: I) 7 ...i.e6 8.exd6 (8.e3? dxe5 9 .�xd8+ §xd8 IO.lLlxe5 lLlb4 l l .o!Lla3 .id6 12.'�e2 f6 13.o!LJO .ixf4 14.exf4 0-0, Horvath Rabovszky, Czech Republic 1995) 8 ... �f6 9.�cl ixd6 IO.i.xd6 cxd6 l l.�c3 �xc3 12.lLlxc3 .ixc4 I H�d I gd8 14.e3 yie Ids some edge for White, Gutman;
l l .i.xc5 gxd2 1 2 .o!Llbxd2 �xb2 J 3.gb I �xa2 14.lLld4 lLlxd4 15.i.xd4 �8 16.&1 �c2 17 ..ie3 .if5, Gutman. 11 ... fh d6 12. 1 bf6
12 .�xg4+?�6 13.lLlc3 lLld3+, Gutman. ll ...gxffi 1 3.�a3 �b4
Black dominates, Gutman.
17
.ixd2+ 7.�xd2 - Part 2, Chapter 3 , Sec tion 2; however, note that relatively un explored is 6...�e7! ?, e.g. 7 ..!00 lt!c6 8 ..ic3 0-0 9.0-0-0 ixc3 1 0.ti'xc3 l!e8 l l.e3 ltlxe5, Tousersnake - Peze, inter net 2002, or 7.f4 a5 8..!00 &6 9.g3 d6) 6.�e3 b6! (6 ... lt!c6 can be met by 7.a3 ixd2+ 8 ..ixd2 �e7 9.b4 ltle6 10 . .!00. 7..!00 seems less accurate on account of 7 ... lt!e6 8.g3 0-0 9 ..ig2 l!e8 10.0-0 ltlfB, while 7 ...d5 8.exd6+ .ie6 is quite spec ulative as instead of 9.a3 �xd6 1 0.axb4 ll'lxb4 l l.�c30-0� 12 .g3, Mopati - Cor bin, Elista Olympiad 1 998, when 1 2 ... lt!e4 l3.ti'b3 ltlc5 could lead to a draw, 9.dxc7 �xc7 10.a3 .ixd2+ l l..ixd2 might be critical) 7.a3 (or 7 . .!00 .ib7 8.g3 0-0 9.ig2 l!e8 I 0.0-0 d6) 7 .. .ixd2+ 8.ixd2 .ib7 (8 ... a5 is ruled out by 9.�g3 0� 10. .ig5 lt!e4 l l ..ixd8 ltlxg3 1 2.hxg3 :!!xd8 l3.f4) 9.�g3 (9.b4 ltle4 1 0..!00 0-0 l l .g3, Lohaus Timm , Berlin 1 950, l l ...ltlxd2 l 2.�xd2 ltlc6) 9 ... ltle6 I O.f4 ( lO.b4 0-0) lO ... f5 l l .exf6 ( 1 1 ..!00 0-0 1 2 .0-0� a5 l3.h4 ltla6) l l...�xffi 12 .0-0� ltla6( l 2 ... lt!c6 l 3 .e3 0-0-0 14 . .ic3 �n 1 5 . .!00) 1 3 ..!00 lt!ac5 1 4 ..ic3 �f5 1 5 .ltld2 0-0 appears fine for Black, Gutman; Ill) 5.ltlc3 ltlc5 (5 ...d5 6.cxd5 it3 7.ti'b5+ lt!c6 8.dxc6? lt!xc3 0: l was an obscure game Brix - Engelhardt, Copenhagen 1 954, but 8 .id2 is stronger, e .g. 8... 0-0 9.ltlxe4 .ixd2+ l O.lthd2 ltld4 l l .�c4 ltlc2+ 12.� l ltlxall 3 .e4 .ig6 14.ltlg0 c6 1 5.d6 �a5 1 6.id3 b5 17.�c3 �xa2 l8.'it>e2 or 8 ...lt!xd2 9.dxc6 .ixc3 lO.bxc3 bxc6 l l.�xc6+. 5 .. .ixc3+ 6.bxc3 ltlc5 appears insufficient due to 7 .�d5 �e7 8 ..!00, for example 8 ... lt!e6 9.a4 or 8 ... lt!c6 9 . .ig5 ! ? �f8 10.g3 h6 l l ..ie3 b6 1 2 ih3 �e7 13 .0-0, while 7.�g3 0-0 !? leads after 8.ig5 �e8 9.iffi ltle6 l O.e3 'it>h8 l l �3l!g8 1 2.ixh7�7 l 3 .ti'h4+ �g6 1 4.�e4+ to a draw by repetition) is a nonnal starting position.
Chapt er S ( l .d4 �f6 l.c4 eS 3.dxeS � e4) 4.ft' d3
This move certainly deserves more ex amination than was previously thought, Tim Harding, 2000.
4 ... �cS Black wins a tempo and assumes the initiative, Otto Borik .
-
Neverthe less, it is worth noting that also 4 ... .ib4+ is a significant alternative, which leads to some striking variations. White has three possibilities: I) 5.id2 ltlxd2 6.ltlxd2 ltlc6 7.f4 0-0 (7... d6 8.exd6 �f6 is met by 9.�e3+ .ie6 lO.d7+) 8 .0-0-0 d6! 9.exd6 (if9.ltld0 �e7 ! , tho ugh 9 ...dxe5 l O.�xd8 �d8 l Uhd8+ lt!xd8 l 2.ltlxe5 ic5 l3 .g3 it3 14.ig2 .ie3+ 1 5.'it>d l c6 1 6.ltlg0 lt!e6 1 7.ltld3 l!d8 18.'it>c2 ie4 19.ltlfe l ltld4+ 20.'it>dl .if5 2l .ltlc2 ltlxe2 was equal in Bringer - lnmiChess, computer game 2000) 9 .. .ixd6 10.�0 (1 0.g3 �e8, viz. l l .ig2ltlb4 12.�3 Ad7) lO ..:t?ffi l l .g3 .ib4, Gutman ; further U) 5.ltld2ltlc5 (Black can hardly be satis fied with 5 ...� 6.g3 ltlxd2 7.gxh4ltle4+ 8 . .id2 ixd2+ 9.�xd2 ltlxd2 lO.'�xd2. 5 ... lt!xd2 6 ..ixd2 ixd2+ 7.�xd2 goes into 4.�c2 .ib4+ 5 .ltld2 ltlxd2 6 . .ixd2 18
�xd6 8.a3 .bc3+ 9.�xc3 0-0 I O.i.e3 � I I.o!OO .!Oc6, nor 7.cxd5 �xd5 8 . .!00 o!Oc6 9.id2.bc3 I O.i.xc3 ig4 are better) 7.. .i.xc3+ 8.�xc3 o!Oe4 (8 ...d4 9.�g3 0-0 IO .i.g5 �d7 l l .i.f6 o!Oe6 12 ..!00 'i!;lh8 13.i.h4 ) 9 .�d3 c6 10 ..!00 0-0 provide sufficient compensation, Gutman; C) 6 .�g3 0-0, then : Cl) 7.a3 o!Oe4 8.�d3 (8 .�e3 forces 8 ... .bc3+ 9.bxc3 fS) 8 .. .i.xc3+ 9.bxc3 o!Oc5 (9 ... f5!? IO.o!OO .!Oc6 l l .g3 �e7) IO.�g3 ( IO.�d5 b6 I l .�xa8 i.b7 12.�xa7 o!Oc6) IO ... f5 I I .i.f4 o!Oc6, Gutman ; further Cl) 7.i.h6 o!Oe6 (7 .. .i.xc3+!? 8.bxc3 o!Oe6) 8.o!Of3 o!Oc6 9.i.d2 (9.o!Og5 .bc3+ IO.bxc3 �e7 I l . f4 f5 ! ) 9 ...i.xc3 I O.i.xc3 o!Oc5 I U&c I ( l l .�f4 o!Oa4) l l .. .o!Oe4 1 2 .�f4 o!Oxc3 J 3 .gxc3 �e7 1 4.a3 a5 1 5 .g3 ge8 J6,ge3 (16.i.g2 d6!) 16 .. .a4 17.i.g2�. Gutman; similarly C3) 7.i.d2 i.xc3 (is more precise than 7...16 8.0-0-0! .bc3 9.i.xc3 o!Oe4 I O.�e3 o!Oxc3 I l .�xc3 fxe5 1 2.�xe5 o!Oc6 due to 1 3 .�d5+ Wh8 14.o!Of3 �e7 1 5.a3 d6 1 6.e3 i.g4 17 .i.d3) 8.i.xc3 (8.�xc3 o!Oe4 9 .�d4 o!Oxd2 I O.�xd2 �h4 I l .�c3 o!Oc6 12 . .!00 �e7 1 3 . � 1 ge8) 8 .. J&e8 9.b3 o!Oe4 10.�e3 o!Oxc3 l l .�xc3 �h4 12.g3 �e4 1 3.o!OO .!Oc6 with chances for both sides, Gutman .
Three retreats come into consideration: A) 6.�e3 mt4! (6...o!Oc6 7.a3 o!Ob3 8 J��b l o!Obd4 9.�d3 .bc3+ I O.�xc3 mt4 l l .b4 �e4 12.�d3) 7 .a3 (7.o!Of3 �xc4 8.i.d2 lt:lc6 9lki .!Oe6) 7 ...lt:lb3 8,gb J ia5 9.�f4 (9.�d3 o!Oc6 10 ..!00 is met by IO ... mt5 I I .i.f4 o!Oc5, e.g. 12.�c2 .bc3+ 13.�xc3 �fS 14.�c l o!Ob3 15.�d l �xf4 16.�xb3 o!Oxe5 or 12.�d5 .bc3+ 1 3.bxc3 ti'f5 ! I4 J:�dl �xf4 1 5.�xc5 �fS) 9...�xf4!? I O.i.xf4 o!Oc6 1 1 ..!0 0 0-0 1 2.e3 ( 12 .!:Jd I ge8 13 .!:Jd5 .bc3+ 14.bxc3 b6) 12..�e8 13 .i.e2 .bc3+ 1 4.bxc3 o!Oc5 1 5 .0-0 b6 looks OK for Black, Gutman; B) 6.�c2 d5! (The interpol ation of the moves 6 ... o!Oc6 7 ..!00 is favourable for White: 7...d5 8.i.g5 ffi 9.exffigxffi IO.cxd5 �xd5 I I .i.d2 ixc3 12 ..bc3 i.fS 13 .�d2 �e6 I4.e3 gd8 1 5 .o!Od4 o!Oxd4 16 ..ixd4 o!Oe4 I 7. �b4 o!Od6 1 8 .i.e2 gg8 19.�b3 as in Dankert - Voigt, Germany 1 998; 7...li::J:6, when 8.a3.bc3+ 9.�xc3 b6 10.g3 i.b7 I I .i.g2 g5, Petersen - Witte lsberger, Germany 1998, 12.b4, or 8.g3 b6 9.i.g2; 7...�e7, and now 8.a3 .bc3+ 9.�xc3 a5 IO.i.f4 0-0 l l .e3 ge8 I 2.i.e2 b6 1 3.0-0 a4 1 4.gad l i.b7 1 5.�c2 h6 1 6.i.g3 or 8.id2!? o!Oxe5 9 .o!Oxe5 �xe5 IO.a3 .bc3 I I .i.xc3 �g5 1 2.h4 �g4 1Hlli 3 �xc4, Chemyshov - Kahn, Budapest 2002, 14.b3! �g4 15,gg3 �xh4 1 6.i.xg7 o!Oe4 17 .�c4 d5 1 8.�d4) 7.a3 (neither 7.exd6
Back to the main line
19
s.Bg3 Other options: I) 5.�d l lt:lc6 6.f4 d6 7 .exd6.hd6 8.1t:l0 �f6 9.e3 .i5 I O.a3 0-0-0 l l .lt:lbd2 ghe8 1 2 .g3 gxe3+ and White's position is in ruins, Dulovic - Gold, Major 1 996; II) For 5.�c3 1t:lc6 6.1t:lf3 see 4.�d4 1t:lc5 5 .1t:lf3 lt:lc6 6.�c3 - Chapter 4; Ill) 5 .�e3 1t:lc6 6.a3 (6.1t:lf3 will trans pose to 4 .�d4 1t:lc5 5.1t:lf3 1t:lc6 6.�e3
Edwards, England NWC 1 992, went 7... .ie7 8..ixe7 �xe7 9.exd6 1t:lb4 I O.�d l I O.�c3 1t:lbd3+ l l .�d2 1t:le4+ 12 .�xd3 �xd6+ 13.�xe4 5+ 14.�3 f4+ 15.�4 .if3+ 1 6.'i!lx5 0-0+ 1 7. �g4 �e6+ leads to a draw-, IO ...cxd6 l l.e3 .if3 12 .1t:ld4 lt:lbd3+ 13 ..hd3 1t:lxd3+ 14.�tl.ig6!? 1 5 .�a4+ �ts 1 6.1t:lc3 �f6 - 1 6...1t:lxb2! 1 7.m3 1t:ld3 1 8 .gd l lt:lc5 looks viable to me -, 1 7.0&8 1 8.�xa7 �e3 1 9.1t:ld5 m-4 20.�b8+ ges 2 1 .�xd6+ �g8 with an unclear position) 8.exd6 .hd6 9.a3 (neither 9.1t:lc3 lt:lb4 1 o.�d2 �e6 l l .e3 �g6 Borik, nor 9.e3 lt:lb4 1 0.�c3 �f5 l l .lt:la3 0-0 12.JM lt:le4 -more accurate than 1 2...ge8 1 3..ie2 1t:lbd3+, Borik, due
to 1 4.�fl lt:le5 1 5 .1t:lb5 1t:lxf3 1 6 ..ixf3 .ie5 17.1t:ld4 -, 13 .�3 �a5 14.�e2.id7 are enjoyable for White) 9 ... 0-0 I O.It:lc3 (IO.b4 1t:le6 l l .c5 1t:lcd4 1 2 .1t:lxd4 1t:lxd4 l3.�d3 .ie5 14J:hl �g4 15.f4 .ixf4 gave Black a clear advantage, Jakab - Kahn, Budapest 2 002 ) 10 ...�g4 l l .lt:lb5 .if5 12.�dl lt:le6 13.1t:lxd6 cxd6 14.�cl gcs 1 5 .h3 �h5 16 ..ie3 d5 1 7 .c5 d4 leaves Wh ite frustrated, Gutman. s...�e4!? Black is ready for repetition.
We consider therefore : I) 5 ...h6 6.1t:lc3 1t:lc6 7..ie3!(an improve ment on 7 ..id2 d6 8.1t:l f3 g5, when in stead of 9.h3 .i5, AIUltoli Matsukevich, 1 0.0-0-0�d7 1 1.ie3 1t:le4 1 2.1t:lxe4 .lxe4 l 3 ..id4 1t:lxd4 14.gxd4 .lg6 1 5.e4 .lg7, White could try 9.0-0-0 g4 l O..ie3 1t:la6 l l.c5 gxf3 12.exf3, e.g. 12 ... .15 l3..ixa6 bxa6 14.exd6 cxd6 1 5 Jihel .ie6 16 ..if4 or 12 ...1t:lxc5 l3..ixa6 bxa6 14.J.d4 �g5+ 15.f4 �xg3 1 6.hxg3 lt:lg6 17 .1t:ld5 �d8 1 8 ..if6+ �d7 1 9.f5 ggs 20.fxg6 gxg6 2 l.ic3 with an edge) 7 ...1t:le6 8.0-0-0 d6 (8 ... a6 9.f4 b5 1 0.5) 9.1t:lf3 .id7 I O.It:ld5 dxe5 l l .lt:lxe5 1t:lxe5 1 2.�xe5 .*d6 l3.�c3 is clearly in White 's favour, Gutman; II) 5 ... 1t:lc6 6.1t:lc3 (Black should meet 6..lg5 1t:le4 7..ixd8 with 7 ...1t:lxg3 8.hxg3 �xd8 9.1t:lf3 g6 ! - Matsuk evich gives 9 ....ib4+?! IO.It:lbd2 h6 I I .a3 hd2+?! 12 .�xd2 ge8 1 3 .�5 as being better for White -, IO.It:lbd2 .lg7 1 1 .0-0-0 �e7! 1 2 .e4 b6! l3 . .ie2 .ib7, and not by 7 ... .ib4+ 8 .1t:lc3 1t:lxg3 9.hxg3 �xd8 1 0.f4 lt:ld4 1 1.0-0-0 lt:l5 12 ,gd3 d6 1 3.e4 1t:le7 14.1t:lf3, Conquest - Postny, Budapest 2 000) 6 . . . 1t:le6 (6 . . .1t:ld4 fails t o 7 ..lg5, and if 6 ... d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8 ..if4 .ixf4 9.�xf4 1t:lb4 I O.�e3+ .ie6 l l .gc l �e7 12.a3 1t:lb3 l 3.axb4 1t:lxc l 14.�xcl �xb4 15.e3) 7 J.d2 d6 8 .1t:lf3 dxe5 9.1t:lxe5 1t:lxe5 1 0.�xe5 .id6 l l .�h5 0-0 12 .0-0-0 and I prefer White, Gutman ; 20
III) S ...ll:l e6 is the invention of Borik . Three moves were tried : A) 6.h4 d6 (White was on top after 6... h6?! 7.id2 ll:lc6 8.ll:lc3 d6 9.ll:l0 dxeS I 0.0-0-0 id7 l l .ll:le4 'fle7 1 2.ic3 0-0-0 1 3 .ll:lxeS ll:lxeS 14.'flxeS f6 I S.'fla5 r;!;>b8 1 6 .e3, Lanzani - Conquest, Budapest 2000) 7.-lgS 'fld7 8.ll:lc3 (8.ll:l0 dxeS 9.ll:lxeS 'fld4) 8...dxeS 9.�1 id6 I O.ll:le4 'flc6 l l .ll:lxd6 cxd6, Gutman; further B) 6.ll:l0 ll:lc6 7 .e3 (7 .ll:lc3 ll:lb4 forces the king to move, and after 7 .a3 is 7 ...d6 strong: 8.exd6 ixd6 9.'flg4 0-0 I O.'fle4 &8 l l .'flc2 ll:led4 12.ll:lxd4 ll:lxd4 13 .'fldl if5 or 8.ll:lc3 dxeS 9.ll:lxeS ll:lxeS IO.'flxeS id6, Borik ) 7 ... d6 8.ie2 dxeS 9.ll:lxeS ll:lb4 10.ll:la3 id6(IO... ffi l l .ll:\0? ll:ld3+ 1 2 .hd3 'flxd3 13.id2 ha3 was men tioned by Mllls ukevich, but l l..ihS+ g6 1 2.hg6+ hxg6 13 .'flxg6t r;!;le7 14.'flf7+ r;!;>d6 I S .ll:lg6 gh6 1 6.0-0 is the correct reply) l l .f4heS 1 2.fxeS ll:ld3+ 13..lxd3 'flxd3 1 4.'flf2 0-0 IS.'fle2 ll:lcS 16.'flxd3 ll:lxd3+ 1 7.r;!;le2 ll:lxeS 1 8.b3 (1 8.h3 if5 19.gd) gad8 20 .gxd8 gxd8 2 1 .b3 ie4 22.g3 1f3+ 23 .r;!;>f2 �I ,Borik) 18 ....ig4+ 1 9 . r;t>t2 gfd8 20. r;!;lg3 ih5 !? , Piege ler Shoup, corr 1 99S, with a clear plus for Black, Gutman; C) 6.ll:lc3 !? d6 7 .ll:\0 (7.1d2 can be met by 7 ... ll:ld7 8.exd6 hd6) 7 ... dxeS (7 ... ll:ld7 8.if4 dxeS 9..ixeS ll:lxeS IO.'flxeS id6 l l .'fldS 0-0 1 2.0-0-0) 8.'flxeS !? (if 8.ll:lxeS id6, while Cafolla - O'C, Ire land 1 993, went 8 ... ll:ld4?! 9.'fld3 ll:la6 I O .ll:ldS ll:lb4 l l .ll:l xb4 ixb4+ 1 2 .id2 ifS 1 3 .e4 ixd2+ 14 .r;!;lxd2? - 14.'flxd2 should be played, e. g. l4.. ..ixe4 IS.0-0-0 ll:le6 1 6.'fle3 'flh4 17.0 if5 1 8.g3 'flf6 19.ig2 or 14 ...f6 I S .ll:ld3 'fle7 1 6.0-0-0 ig4 1 1.ge1 0-0-0 1 8 .'flb4 -, 14 ...'fle7 I S.exf5 0-0-0 1 6.�1 'flb4+ and Black won) 8 ... ll:lc6 9.'fldS id6 I O.ie3 0-0 1 1 .0-0-0 looks like the more healthy ap proach, Gutman .
6.1Je3 6.'flf4 ib4+ 7.ll:ld2 ll:lxd2 (not 7 ... dS?! 8.exd6 ll:lxd2 9..ixd2 'flxd6 1 0 .0-0-0 0-0 l l .e4 ixd2+ 12.'flxd2 'fle7 13 .id3 ll:la6 14.ll:le2 ie6 IS.ll:l f4 gad8 1 7 .'flc3 'figS 1 8.g3, An Mon - Gambit Tiger, com puter game 2001 ) 8.ixd2 'fle7 9.0-0-0 ixd2+ JO.gxd2 ll:lc6 1 1 .ll:l0 0-0 1 2 .g3 (1 2.a3 ge8 13.gd5 b6 14 .g3 ib7 1 S..ih3 d6 1 6.exd6 cxd6 1 7.&d6 ll:laS) 12 .. _gb8 13�h3 bS 14.'flb4 'flcS IS.ifS h6 seems to give Black good chances, Gutman. 6 ..1b4+ 6...ll:lcS 7..id2(7.g3 ll:lc6 8..id2 ie7 9J.g2 0-0 I O.ll:\0 d6 l l .ic3 ges 1 2 .0-0 ll:la4 J3.gd) iffi!?, while Harding - Conquest, Budapest 2000 , went 13 .. ..if51 4.b3 ll:lxc3 IS.ll:lxc3 'flc8, when 16.exd6hd6 17.'flcl could be played) 7 ...ll:lc6 8.ll:lc3 favours White, Gutman. 7.�d2 7.ll:lc3 dS 8.exd6 if5, Gutman. 7...d5!? 7 ... ll:lxd2 8.ixd2 'fle7 is also possible, viz. 9.0-0-0 ixd2+ JO.gxd2 ll:lc6 l l .ll:\0 0-0 1 2.lod4 ( 1 2.g3 'fle6 !? 1 3 .'flc3 ges 14.�S ll:le7) 1 2 . . .ll:lxd4 1 3 .'flxd4 aS!? 1 4 .f4 ga6 I S .e3 d6, Gutman. 8.ex.d6 115 9.1!ff4!? Vx.d6 The ending after I O .'flxd6 ll:lxd6 l l .e3 ie6 1 2.a3 hd2+ 1 3 ..ixd2ixc4 14..ixc4 ll:lxc4 I S .ic3 is even, Gutm an. .
21
Chapt er 6 ( l.d4 �f6 2.c:4 eS 3.dxeS �e4) 4.'trdS
This move was introduced by Max 81111! mich, Deutsche Schachzeitung, / 929.
Now there is a division: Section I - 4 ... f5 Section 2 - 4 ....ib4+ Section 3 - 4 ... itk5. Sec:t ion 1 4 fS ...
There are probably m lines where iJ is goodfor Black to play this move early on, Tim Harding.
S.ed6 The critical test is surely to capture en passant, Harding.
Other possibilities: I) 5 .it)d2 .ib4 (5 ... it)c6 fails to 6.it)xe4 it)b4 7.�dl fxe4 8.a3 it)c6 9.�d5 �e7 I O.�xe4 �xe5 l l .�xe5+ it)xe5 1 2 .e3. 5 ... c6 6.�d3 d5 7.exd6 �a5 8.a3 .ixd6 was given by Fernando Vasconcellos, yet White can do better with 8 .g3 it)a6 9..ig2 it)b4 I O.'Ml3 hd6 I I .it)gf3 it)f6
12.0-0 f4 1 3 .e4 fxg3 14.hxg3 .ie7 1 5 .e5) 6.it)f3 (6.a3 is met by 6 ...c6 7.�d3 Wb6 8.e3 hd2+ 9.hd2 �xb2) 6._it)c6 (6...c6 7.�d3 did not give Black enough coun terplay: 7 ...Wb6 on account of 8.e3 it)a6 9.a3 hd2+ I O.it)xd2 �a5 I U!bl �xe5 1 2.b4 and 7...�a5 because of 8.g3, e. g. 8 ...hd2+ 9.it)xd2 �xe5 I O.it)xe4 fxe4 l l .�c2 or 8...it)a6 9 ..ig2 it)ac5 I O.�c2 �d2 I I .hd2 it)e4 1 2.a3 �d2 J3.it)xd2 0-0 14-l:!dl hd2+ 15l!xd2 �xe5 1 6.0-0) 7.a3 �e7 Ieads to equality, for example 8.e3 hd2+ 9 ..ixd2 it)xd2 I O .'�xd2 g6 I I ..ie2 b6 IU!hdl .ib7 1 3 .'�el 0-0-0 14.c5 IDleS 1 5 .cxb6 axb6 1 6.&cl it)xe5 1 7 ..ia6 it)xf3+ 1 8 .gxf3 c6, Gutman; m 5 .lt)f3 it)c6 (5 ....ib4+, Vasconcellos, is also good, e.g. 6..id2 c6 7 .�d3 �b6 8.e3 .ixd2+ 9.it)bxd2 �xb2, Mrchess EmK, internet 2003, or 6.it)bd2 it)c6, see 4 ... f5 5 .it)d2 .ib4 6.it)f3 it)c6 -f), and now: A) 6.a3 d6 7.exd6 (7.it)bd2 it)xd2 8.hd2 dxe5 9.�xd8+ �xd8 IO..ic3 e4 I I .Q..()...()+ .id7 12.it)e5 it)xe5 1 3..ixe5 �e8 with a level ending, while after 7.b4 �e7 White has problems, e. g. 8 ..ib2 .ie6 9.exd6 it)xd6, Dyckhoff - Starke, corr 1930, or 8.exd6 �f6!? 9.l:!a2 .ixd6 IO ..ib2 �e7 l l .�dl .ie6 12.it)bd2 0-0-0 1 3 .e3 IDlfll 14..ie2 it)xd2 1 5 .it)xd2 f4 1 6 .e4 f3) 7 ... .ixd6 8.e3 (no better are: 8.it)bd2 it)c5 9.it)d4 it)xd4 IO.�xd4 �e7 l l .�d5 .ie6 12.�f3 0-0 13.b4.ie5 14,m, 1 it)e4 1 5.it)xe4 fxe4 1 6.�xe4 .i£5, Kuchta - Nepustil, Prague 1 986, or 8.it)c3 it)xc3 9.bxc3 �f6 IO.�d3 it)e5 I I .it)xe5 he5 1 2..ib2 0-0 13.e3 .ie6 I4..ie2 &d8 1 5.�c2 f4 1 6.e4 �g6 1 7.�fl f3! 1 8 .h f31:!xf3 1 9 .gxf3 .ixc4+, Stanitz - D'Adamo, corr 1 993) 8 ...�f6 (8 ...�e7 9.�dl .ie6 I O ..ie2 g5 l l .b4 it)e5 12 .c5 it)xf3+ 14.gxf3 .ie5 and Black won, Gerke - Gegner, Dortmund 2000) 9.�dl .ie6 I O. .ie2 0-0-0 l l .�c2 l:!he8 is no fun for White, Gutman; 22
B) 6.lik3 ib4 (6 ...l[Jxc3 7.bxc3 Y!Je7 8 .a4 d6 9�g5 Y!Je6 1 0.exd6 hd6 1 1 .m,1 m,8 12.e3 with some edge for White) 7 ..id2 (if 7.Y!Jd3 Y!Je7 8.J.f4 g5 9�g3 .ixc3+ I O.bxc3 g�) 7 ...hc3 (7 ...lLlxd2 8.Y!Jxd2 Y!Je7 9.a3 .ixc3 I O.Y!Jxc3 0-0 1 1 .0-0-0 brings Black nowhere, and on 7 ... lLlc5 White plays 8.0-0-0 lLle7 9.Y!Jd4 b6 IO.g3 .ib7 l l ..ig2 0-0 12.lLld5, instead of 8.a3 lLle7 9..ig5, Nepustil, 9 ... lLlxd5 I O.axb4 lLlxb4 I J .().().()Y!Jxg5+ 1 2.lLlxg5 b6 13.lLlb5 lLlba6 1 4 .e3 .ib7) 8..ixc3 lLlxc3 9.bxc3 Y!Je7 appears equal, Gutman. s...�xf6
JO.Y!Jd2 Y!Je7 l l.lLlc3 d6, when 12.a3 lLlc6 13.e3 .ig4 14�2 might be tried) 8.lLla3 d5 9.cxd5 Y!Jxd5 , Gutman ; similarly Ill) 6.Y!Jd3 lLlc6 (6 ....ib4+ 7 ..id2 lLla6 8..ixb4 lLlxb4 9.Y!Je3+! Y!Je7 I O.Y!Jxe7+ rJ:/xe7 l l .lLla3 d5 1 2.cxd5 lLlbxd5 13 _gc) was seen in Adamczyk - Owens, e-mail 1999) 7.lLlf3 d5 ! (7 ....ib4+ 8.lLlc3 with advantage, TseilDn!Gfllskov) 8.cxd5 lLlb4, Nepustil, 9.Y!Jc4 Y!Jxd5 I O.Y!Jxd5 lLlfxd5 l l .lLla3 lLJffi is fme for Black, Gutman. 6....lb4+ 6 ....ic5 7.lLlf3 0-0 (with sufficient com pensationfor thepawn, Tseidin/Gfllskov) 8.lLlc3 d6 9.e3 lLlc6 IO�e2 (or I O.h3 .its l l �e2 Y!Je7 12.0-0 �d8 1 3 .a3 a6 14.b4 .ia7, Chatzisotirou - Jouanny, e-mail 1998, 15..tb2!?) IO ....tts (IO ..�g4 l l .h3 .id7 1 2 .a3 a5 1 3 .b3 Y!Je8 1 4 ..ib2 Y!Jg6 1 5.lLld5 lLle4 1 6.g4!? �e8 17.�2 Y!Jh6 1 8.Y!Jc2 'i!.f7 19.lLlxc7, Altennan - Kogan, rapid Tel-Aviv 1 996) 1 1 .0-0 (l l .a3 a5 12 .0-0 lLle7 1 3 .lLld4 'itoh8 14..if3 is also good, Kilian - Pekrul, corr 1 990) I I ... Y!Jd7 1 2.lLla4 .ib6 13 ..id2 .ia5 14 ..ixa5 lLlxa5 1 5.c5 d5 1 6.b4 lLlc4 17 .lLlc3 .ie6 18.Y!Jd4 1eaves Black frustrated, Crafty Hiarcs, computer game 1999. 7..ldl 7.lLld2 can be answered by 7 ... 0-0 8 .a3 .ixd2+ 9 . .ixd2 b6, Gutman. 7 ... as 7 ...Y!Je7 8.lLlf3 (8.lLlc3 is inaccurate due to 8 ...lLlc6 9.lLlf3 .ixc3 1 O..ixc3 lLle4) 8 ... lLlc6 (8 ...b6 9.e3 .ib7 I 0�2 lLle4 1 1 .0-0 lLlxd2 12 .lLlbxd2 lLlc6 1 3 .Y!Jc2) 9.e3 0-0 I O ..ie2 (Tritschler - Maidana Guerra, internet 2002, continued I O.lLlc3 .ixc3 l l ..bc3 lLle4) IO ...lLle4 1 1 .0-0, Gutman. 8.�0 0-0 9.e3 � a6 IO..lel �cS IO...b6 1 1 .0-0 .ib7 is another plan. 11.� d6 ll.�d4 Y6e7 Black has some, but possibly not enough compensation, Gutman.
6.1fdl Alternatives: I) 6.Y!Je5+ i.e? 7 ..ig5 (7..if4 d6 8 .Y!Je3 lLlg4 9.Y!Je4 Yz-Yz Fortress - GLChess, computer game 2000) 7 ...lLlc6 8.Y!Je3 0-0 9.lLlc3? lLlg4 IO�xe7 lLlxe7 I I .Y!Jg3 lLlxf2 0: I Camara - Flores, Sao Paulo 1 937; II) 6.Y!Jg5 lLlc6 ( 6...ib4 + 7.id2 Y!Je7 gave White a clear plus after 8.lLlf3 0-0 9.lLlc3 lLlc6 IO.a3 .ixc3 l l ..ixc3 d6 1 2.e3 .id7 1 3 .i.d3 �e8 14.0-0 lLle5 15 .lLlxe5 dxe5 1 6.�d l , Pinho - Morais, e-mail l 997) 7.lLlf3 (if 7.lLlc3 lLlb4 8.Y!Jd2, then 8 ...d5 9.a3 d4 I O.axb4 .ixb4 I I .� a5 12 Exb4 axb4 1 3 .lLlb5 0-0 14.lLlf3 c5 1 5 .e3 � I ) 7. . .lLl b4 (Pereira - Jursik, e-mail 1 995, went 7 ... .ib4+ 8..id2 0-0 9..ixb4 lLlxb4
23
Section 2 (l.d4 �f6 2.c4 eS 3.dxe5 �e4 4.'ff d5) 4 .. .lb4+
The main line - White prefers to keep his bishop, but also 5 ..id2, Max Biue mich, should be treated with respect. 5...lLlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 (6 ...Y:nl 4!? 7 .lLlf3 V9e7 is also possible, after 8.a3 .ixd2+ 9.V9xd2 lLlc6 we reach a position with 4.ltlf3 .ib4+ 5.td2 ltlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 f"7.a3 hd2+ 8.V9xd2 Y!Je7 - Part 4, Chapter 3, Sections 2/4. Less flexible is 6... c6 7.V9d3 V9a5 8.·�:m lLla6 9.a3 0-0 1 0.gdl lLlc5 l l .V9c2 hd2+ 1 2fud2 V!lb6, when instead of l 3.lLlg5 g6 14.b4 lLle6 1 5.lLle4 a5, Han:stad - Stangeland, Norwai 1 992, 1 3 .g3 ! ? a5 14 ..ig2 a4 1 5 .0-0 might be more simple) 7.lLlf3 (7.f4 is answered by 7.. .d6 8.exd6 .ie6 9.d7+hd7 10.� V!lffi l l .V9e4+ .ie6 12.e3 0-0-0. If 7.0-0-0, then 7 ...V9e7 8.ltlgf3 returns to the text as 8.f4 d6 9.exd6bd6 10.e4? is convinc ingly refUted by 1 0... lLlb4 l l .V!Ib5+ .id7, Tim Harding; however, Black has an excellent rejoinder in 7 ...0-0 8.lLlgf3 d6, e.g. 9.a3 .ie6 1 O.V9e4 hd2+ l l .J�xd2 lLla5 12J�dl lLlxc4 l3.e3 d5 14.V9c2 V9e7 1 5 .lxc4 dxc4, Arregui - Uboldi, Villa Balester 1 992, or 9.exd6 .ixd6 l O.lLle4 .ie6 l l .V!Ib5 a6 12.V9a4 b5) 7 ...V9e7 (also
here 7 ...0-0!? appears quite promising to me, for instance 8.a3 hd2+ 9.lLlxd2 ges l O.f4 d6 l l .exd6 .ie6 1 2.V9d3 V!lffi l 3 .g3 .if5 14.e4 gadS!? 1 5 .0-0-0 gxd6 1 6.e5 V9g6 17.V9c3 gd7) 8.0-0-0 (after 8.e4 .ixd2+ 9.lLlxd2 lLlxe5 1 O.td3? d6 1 1 .0-0 c5 1 2 ..ic2 .ie6 the white queen was gone, Marake - Rost, corr 1986) 8 ....ixd2+ (8 ...b6 9.e3 .ib7 l O.h4 0-0-0 l l .V!Ib5 a6 12.V9a4 ltlxe5 l3.lLlxe5 .ixd2+ 14Exd2 V9xe5 turned out well for Black, Hartmann - Lochmann, Germany 1993, but 9.lLld4 .ib7 1 O.lLlf5 V!lfll l l .f4 0-0-0 12.V9d3 looks better) 9.gxd2 (9 .V9xd2 lLlxe5 l O.lLlxe5 V9xe5 sets no problems. l l .g3 0-0 1 2 ..ig2, and now instead of 1 2 ...d6 1 3 .f4 V9e8 14.V9c2 V9e3 1 5.V9d2 V9e8 Vz-Vz Heimbrodt - Kampfhenkel, corr 1 980, 12 ... gbs 1 3 .f4 V9e7 1 4.V9d4 d6 1 51llie 1 b5 could be tried. If l l .e3 d6 12.f4 V9e7 l3.id3 0-0 14J:�del a6 15.V9c2 h6 with b7-b5 to follow; less ambitious is 12 ... V9c5 l 3 .V9d4 V9xd4 14.exd4 .if5 15 ..id3, while after l4.fud4 .ie6 1 5 .g3 ()..(){) 16M mte8 17.\trd2 c5 181W hc4 Black won a pawn, Nedess - Augustin, corr 1988) is a critical position needing further clarification.
We survey Black's defences: I) 9 ...b6?! lO.lLld4 .ib7 l l .lLlf5 ( l l .lLlxc6 .ixc6 1 2.V9d4 0-0-0 l3.e3 ghe8 14 ..ie2 V9xe5 was even, Bluemich - Fajarowicz, 24
5th match game, Leipzig 1930) l l ...'t¥xe5 1 2.'t¥xd7+ (12.'t¥xe5 !? lL!xe5 1 3.lL!xg7+ rJ:";e7 14.e3 l"!ag8 1 5 .lL!f5+ rJ:";f6 1 6.lL!g3 h5, Bluemich, Neue Leipziger Zeitung 1930, 1 7 .h4) 1 2 ... rt;t8 1 3 .e3 ( 1 3 .lL! d6, Bluemich, 13 ...cxd6 14.'t¥xb7 't¥e8 1 5 .e3 gds 16.'t¥c7) 1 3 ... lL!b4 14.'t¥d8+ gxd8 15.fud8+ 't¥e8 1 6he8+ rJ:";xe8 17.lL!xg7+ rJ:";f8 1 8.a3 with decisive advantage for White, Gutman ; II) lf 9 ... lL!b4 I O.'t¥a5 keeping the pawn, Bluemich, IO ...b6 I l .'t¥a4 lL!c6 (with play against the pawn on e5; the white queen stands a little offside, Otto Borik) 1 2.g3 !
(on 1 2.e3 lL!xe5 13 .lL!xe5 't¥xe5 14..le2, Vinke - Fox, corr 1 989, Black can play 1 4 ... 0-0! 1 5 ..if3 c6 1 6 .h4 a5) 1 2 ....ib7 (12 ...lL!xe5 13.lL!xe5 't¥xe5 14..ig2) 13.J.h3 gds 1 4.�dl .ic8 15.lL!d4 lL!xd4 16.fud4 0-0 1 7 .f4 d6 1 8 ..bc8 gxc8 19.gd5 se cures a plus for White, Gutman; III) 9 ...a6 would have given Black every chance of equalising, Tseidin/GIIlskov, IO.c5 ( IO.a3 m,g l l .g3 b5) 10 0-0 l l .g3 ges 12.J.h3 lL!xe5 13.lL!xe5 't¥xe5 14bd7 't¥xd5 15hd5 fue2 16lhll ®18 17 i Hd2 fud2 18.rJ:";xd2 .ixd7 19hd7 &8 20.'it>c3 and the ending is quite unpleasant for Black, Gutman; IV) 9...0-0 IO.g3 a5 l l .a3 a4 12.J.g2 &5 13 .'t¥d3 b6 14.ghdl gcs appears to hold the balance, Gutman . ·-
s... �xd2! 5 ... lL!c5 leads to interesting complications, though a drawback of this idea is the loss of time. White has two possibilities: I) 6.lL!f3 b6 (Staker/Giasscoe/Stayart; however, 6...lL!c6 is very good, e.g. 7.a3? lL!e7 8.'t¥d4 lL!b3 or 7 .lL!d4 lL!xd4 8.'t¥xd4 b6 9.'t¥g4 0-0 IO.a3 d6 I I .'t¥13 .ib7, and if7 .e3, then not 7 ...d6 8.exd6 cxd6 9.J.e2 .ie6 IO .'t¥g5 't¥xg5 I I .lL!xg5 .if5 12.0-0 0-0 13.lL!gf3 gfe8 14.a3 .ixd2, Puleston Loonstra, e-mail 2002, 15bd2, but 7... 't¥e7 8 ..ie2 b6 9.0-0 .ib7 I O.lL!bl 0-0 !? I I .'t¥d l lL!xe5, improving on 1 0 ... 0-0-0 I l .'t¥dl d6 12.a3 dxe5 1 3 .'t¥c2 e4 14.lL!d4, Candan - Izquierdo, Montevideo 1 988) 7.e3 (7.g3 .ib7 8.'t¥d4 lL!c6 9.'t¥e3 is met by 9 ...0-0 IO..ig2 ge8) 7 ....ib7 8.'t¥d4.ie4 (Fuhrmann - Hiegl, Germany 1996, went 8 ...0-0 9 ..ie2 .ie4 I O.b3 lL!c6 I l .'t¥b2, when instead of I I ....ixf3 12.gxf3 't¥g5 1 3 .f4 't¥g2 1 4.gfl lL!e4 15 ..id3 !? gadS 16 ..ixe4 't¥xe4 17 .a3, I I . ..'t¥e7 !? 12.0-0 .id3 1 3 ..ixd3 lL!xd3 14 .'t¥c2 lL!dxe5 is better) 9.b3 (9.e6?! 0-0 IO.exf7+ �hf7 I I .lL!e5 lL!c6 1 2 .lL!xc6 dxc6 1 3 .'t¥xd8+ fud8, Ledfuss - Fischer, Germany 1 996) 9 ...lL!c6 IO.'M>2 't¥e7 I I .ie2 .ixf3 12.gxf3 lL!xe5 should be fine for Black, Gutman; D) 6.a3 ! .ixd2+ 7 .J.xd2 b6, after. A) 8 .'t¥xa8? .ib7 9.'t¥xa7 lL!c6 IO ..ig5 ( I O.'t¥xb7 lL!xb7 I I .lL!f3 0-0) IO ... 't¥c8 I I .'t¥xb7 't¥xb7 1 2.lL!f3 0-0 1 3 .e3 lL!xe5 (13 ...h6 14..lf4 't¥a8 1 5.l:M I 't¥a4 1 6..ie2 't¥c2 17 .b4 't¥c3+ 1 8.rJ:";fl lL!e6, Mueller Piotraschke, Germany 2000) 14.lL!xe5 f6 favours Black; B) 8 ..ic3 .ib7 9.'t¥dl lL!e4; C) 8.e6 dxe6 (8 ...fxe6 9.'t¥h5+ g6 IO.'t¥e5 gf8 l l ..ig5 lL!c6 12.'t¥g3 ltle7 1 3 .'t¥h4) 9.'t¥xd8+ rJ:";xd8 J O.gd) Y2-Y2 Beikert Brauening, Germany 1 993; D) 8.'t¥f3 (Staker!GIIlsscoe/Stayart) 8 ... .ib7 (8 ...0-0 9.b4 .ib7 I O.'t¥g4 f5 I I .'t¥g5 25
White has a range of moves: Fl) 1 0.�f3 �xb2 l l .�e3+ WfB! ( 1 1 ... 'it>d8 1 2 .�gS+ 'it>e8 1 3.�e3+ is perpet ual) 1 2.l:!dl .ia6 1 3 .�cl �a2 14.e3 tt::lc6 1S.tt::l f3 tt::laS 1 6.tt::ld2 tLla4, Borik, 1 7.tt::le4 tt::lb3 18.�1 �xa3 19hd7�+ 20.'it>dl .ib7 2 l .l:!xc7 fS 22.l:!xb7 fxe4 23 .�c2 tt::lc3+ 24.'it>el tt::la l 2S.�cl tt::la2 + 26.�d2 tt::lc2+ and Black wins, Gutman ; F2) 1 O.�xb8 0-0 l l .tt::lf3 ( 1 1 .0-0-0? .ib7 is hopeless, e.g. l 2 .�xa7 .ie4 or 1 2.tt::l f3 �e4, Borik) l l . . .�xb2 1 2 .l:!dl �c3+ (or 1 2 ...J.b7 13.�xc7 .ixf3 14.gill �c3+ 1Sl!d2 �c l+ with a draw, while 1 4.�f4 �c3+ 1 S.�d2 loses to lS ... tt::ld3+ 1 6.exd3 l:!e8+) 1 3 .tt::l d2 l:!e8 ( 1 3 ... tt::lb 3?, Borik, 14.f3) 1 4.e3 tt::le 4! 1 S .g3 d6! 1 6 .�xc7 tt::lxd2 1 7.l:!xd2 �cl + 1 8.l:!dl �c3+ \12-\12 Papakosmas - W ilders, corr 1 994; F3) 1 0.tt::lf3 �xb2 l l iW l O-O ( l l . ..�c3+ 1 2. tt::l d2 tt::l c 6 1 3.�xc8+ 'it>e7 1 4.�xh8 tt::ld4 is met by 1 S.�xh7 tt::lc2+ 1 6.�xc2 �xc2 1 7.h4) 1 2.�xb8 transposes to F2; F4) l O.l:!dl 0-0 ( 1 0 ... �xb2 l l .f3 tt::lca6 12.�e4+ WfB 1 3 .�e3 tt::l cS 14.tt::lh3 tt::lb3 1S.�f4 d6 1 6hd6 cxd6 1 7.�xd6+ 'it>e8 18.�xb8 �c3+ 19.'i!;lt2 �xc4 20.e3 �c2+ 2 l .J.e2, Santos Trullenque, corr 1 999, or 10 ... tt::lc6? l l .�xc8+ 'it>e7 1 2 .�xh8 �xb2 13.f3 �c3+ 1 4.'it>f2, Stummerer Stejskal, corr 1 994, are both of dubious value) l l .tt::l f3 �xb2 1 2 .�xb8, see F2; FS) 1 0.0-0-0! 0-0 l l .�f3 (less advisable is 1 1 .�dS �f4+ 1 2 .e3 �xf2, and 1 1 .ttJ f3 could be answered by l l ...�fS 12.tt::l d4 �gS+ 13.e3 .ib7 1 4.�xa7 tt::lb a6 l S .b4 &8 1 6.�xa8+ .ixa8 1 7 .bxcS �xeS, Bo rik) l l ...J.b7 12.�e3 �xe3+ 1 3.fxe3 tt::le4 14.tt::l h3 d6 l S .l:!gl tt::ld7 1 6.g3 tt::le S, Bo rik, 1 7.J.g2 and Black must strive to jus tify his material deficiency, Gutman. 6 .ixd2ft' e7! This excellent move was already sug gested by Savielly Ttutllkower and looks to me like the most logical reply.
tt::lb3 12.\!:hd8 l:!xd8 1 3 .l:!d l ) 9.�g3(if 9.�g4 0-0 1 0.tt::l f3 , then not 1 o ... tt::l c 6?! l l.b4 f5 12.exffi �xffi 1 3.l:!c 1 tt::la4 14.�gS �xgS l S ..bgS l:!ae8, Raikovic - Sion, Leon 1 988, 16.J.d2, but 1 O ... fS l l .exf6 �xf6 1 2.J.c3 �e7) 9 ... 0-0 10.J.h6 (more precise than 1 0 .tt::l f3 tt::le4 l l .�f4 tt::lxd2 1 2 .�xd2 tt::lc6 1 3 .e3 l:!e8 1 4 .�c3 �e7, Borik) 10 ...tt::le6 l l .tt::lf3 tt::lc6 12.e3 (after 1 2 .J.d2 tt::l cd4 1 3 .tt::lx d4 tt::lxd4 14.�d3 tt::lc6 1S.J.c3 �e7 1 6.f4 &d8 threatening 1 7 ... d6 Black gains a strong initiative, Borik) 1 2 ... 'it>h8!? ( 1 2 .. .f6 can be met by 13.tt::ld4 tt::lcxd4 14.exd4 fxeS lS .dxeS �e7 16.J.e3) 13 .J.f4 tt::l xf4 14.�xf4 �e7 1 S .�f5 l:!ae8 16.l:!dl tt::lb8 1 7 .tt::lgS g6 1 8. �f4 h6 19.tt::lf3 'it>g7 20.J.e2 ixfl 21 J.x£3 �xeS leads to equality, Gutman; E) 81Jdl ib7 9.�d4 �e7 10.�g4 ffi l l .b4 ( l l .exf6? tt::ld3 mate) l l ...tt::l e4 1 2 .exf6 �xf6 1 3 .tt::l f3 0-0 14.e3 tt::lxd2 1 S.l:!xd2 �al+ 1 6.'it>e2 �xa3 1 7 .h4 �xb4 1 8.l:!h3 .ia6 19.'it>el �1+ 20.l:!dl �+ 2 l iW2 � 1+ (Meublers gives 2 1 .. .J.b7 22 .l:!g3 �e7 23.tt::ld4 ru7 24.tt::lf5 �ffi 2S.J.d3 tt::la6 26.�S g6 27.tt::lh6+ WfB, when 28.bg6 hxg6 29.l:!xg6 is strong) 22.l:!dl �b4+ \12-\12 Karpow - Hajenus, simultaneous Antwerp 1997; F) 8..igS ! �xgS 9.�xa8 �xeS was ana lysed by Borik in Schach Magazine 64,
-
1 988.
.
26
Alternatives are less challenging:
I) For 6...1xd2+ 7.'9xd2 see 4.'tlic2 J.M+
S.lt:ld2 lt:lxd2 6.hd2 .ixd2+ 7.'tlixd2 Part 2, Chapter 3, Section 2 ; II) 6 ... aS 7.lt:lf3 (7.f4?! 0-0 8.0-0-0 d6! 9.exd6 cxd6 IO.lt:lf3 lt:ld7, e. g. l l .�b l lt:lb6 12.'9d3 h6 13.1xb4 axb4 14.cS lt:la4 or l l .a3 hd2+ 12fu.d2 lt:lcS Il.§dl �) 7 ... lt:lc6 8.e3 '9e7 9.J.e2 0-0 I 0.0-0 .ixd2 (IO...ges I I ..hb4!? axb4 12.lt:ld4 lt:lxeS 1 3 .cS &5 14.lt:lb3) I I .'tlixd2 lt:lxeS will transpose into 4.'tlic2 .ih4+ S..id2 lt:lxd2 6.lt:lxd2 lt:lc6 7.lt:lf3 'tlie7 8.e3 lt:lxeS 9..ie2 0-0 10.0-0 .ixd2 l l .'tlixd2 aS, covered in Part 2, Chapter 3, Section I, Gutman.
Section 3 (l.d4 �f6 l.c:4 e5 3.dxe5 �e4 4.1fd5) 4 ...�c:5
This move is bad, Ono Borik.
5.�0
Other possibilities: I) S.b4 lt:le6 6.a3 aS 7.bS d6 8 ..ib2 lt:ld7 9.e3 c6 I O.'tlidl (I O.bxc6 bxc6 1 I .'tlixc6 l::tb8 12 ..ic3 .ib7 13.'tlia4 lt:lecS 1 4.'tlidl dxeS I S.lt:lf3 'tlic7) IO ...dxeS I I .lt:lf3 'tlic7 (Ullrich - Richter, Bad Elster 1 937, con tinued I I e4 12.lt:ld4 lt:ldcS 13.lt:lc3 k7, when instead of 14.lt:lf5 'tlic7 1 S.lt:lg3 0-0 16.lt:lcxe4 lt:lxe4 1 7.lt:lxe4 fS ! 1 8.lt:ld2 f4 19.e4 .icS 20..id3 gds 2 I .lt:lf3 'tlid6 22 ..ic2 .ixf2+, 1 4.bxc6 bxc6 I S .lt:lxc6 'tllb6 16.lt:lxe7 'tlixb2 17 .lt:ledS might be better) 1 2lt:l c3 .ie7, Gutman; further 0) S .g3 b6!? (S ...d6 6..ig2 lt:lc6 is more typical, viz. 7.exd6.ixd6 S..igS ffi 9..if4 lt:lb4 IO.'tlid2 .if'S I I .lt:la3 .ixf4 12.'tlixb4 'tlie7) 6.'tlixa8 .ib7 7.'tlixa7 .ixhl 8.'tlia3 (if S..igS 'tlic8!, e.g. 9.lt:lf3 hf3 I O.exf3 lt:lc6 I I .'tlia3 lt:le6 or 9.e6 fxe6 I O.lt:lf3 lt:lc6 I I .'tlia3 hf3 12.'tlixf3 lt:ld4 13.'tlic3 lt:lcb3 14.axb3 .ib4, while after 8 ...'tlixgS 9.'tlixb8+ �e7 I O.f4 'tlih6 I I ..ih3 'tlic6 12.lt:lc3 g6 13.lt:ld5+ hdS 1 4.cxdS 'tlixdS IS.'tlixc7 'tlid4 16.lt:lf3 'tlixb2 I7..§dl White won in Boross - Douthwaite, Toronto 199S) 8 ... lt:lc6 9.'tlie3 lt:le6 I O.lt:lf3 .icS I I .'tlie4 0-0, Gutman ; similarly •.
7.f4 �c:6 8.�0 0-0
8 ... b6 9.g3 (better than 9.e3 .ib7 IO..ie2 1 1 .1xb4'tlixb4+ 12.'tlid2 d6 13.exd6 &d6 14.'tlixb4 l0xb4 IS.'tt12 .ixf3 16.'it>xt3 geS) 9....ib7 I O..ig2 0-0-0 I I ..ixb4 (if I I .� hd2+ 12.'tlixd2 d6) I l...'tlixb4+ 12 .'tlid2 'tlixc4 (or 1 2 ... d6 13 .exd6 l::txd6 14 .'tlixb4 lt:lxb4 I S .�f2 .ixf3 1 6 ..ixf3 l::thd8 1 7 .a3 lt:lc2 1 8J:!a2) 1 3 .lt:lgS lt:le7 14.b3 'tlia6 IS ..ixb7+ 'tlixb7 16.0-0 fa vours White, Gutman.
0.0..0
9.0-0-0 Kd8
Black is ready to play 10 ... d6 and has compensation for his pawn, Gutm an.
27
.ib7 1 6.�d3 g6 1 7./J.g2 ll:la6 1 8.ll:lg5, Gambit Tiger - Little Goliath, compu ter game 200 1 , with a plus for White; III) 5 ... ll:lc6 is more popular, then: A) For 6.ll:lc3 see 5 .ll:lc3 ll:lc6 6.ll:lf.3; B) 6..id2 a5 (if 6 ...d6 7.ig5 �d7, then not 8.ll:lc3, Wallach - Sukcharoenphon, corr 1 994, due to 8 ...ll:lb4 9.�d2 dxe5, but 8.exd6 .hd6 9.ll:lc3 ll:lb4 IO.�d2 �e6 l l ..ie3 �xc4 12..ixc5 �xc5 1 3.a3 �a5 14.e3 0-0 1 5.l:!dl ll:lc6 16.ll:lb5 with some edge) 7.ll:ld4 ll:lb4 8.�f.3 (after 8./J.xb4 Black has: 8 ...c6 9.�xc5 axb4 10.ll:lxc6 .hc5 l l .ll:lxd8 id4 12.ll:lxf7 Wxf7 l3.ll:ld2 .he5 14.g3 !l.xb2 1 5.l:!dl !l.c3, Abbon darmt - Senechaud, Parthenay 1991 , or 8 ...axb4 9.e3 c6 1 O.�f.3 g6 l l .ll:ld2 !l.g7) 8 ... ll:le6 9.ll:lxe6 dxe6 l O.ll:la3 !l.d7 is fine for Black, Gutman ; C)6.ig; jj;? 7.�xc5 (7..ixe7�xe7 8.ll:lc3 is still relatively unexplored. Timar Sinka, Gala Kupa 1 99 1 , continued 8 ... b 6 9.�d2 .ib7 lO.ll:ld5 �d8 l l .b4 ll:le6 12.e3 0-0 1 3..ie2 d6 14.exd6 �xd6, when instead of 15 .�c3 a5 1 6.b5 ll:lb4 17.e4 ll:lc5 18.e5 ll:lxd5 19.cxd5 �xd5 20.0-0 l:!ad8 2 l ..ic4?! �d7 22.ll:lg5? �g4 0 : 1 , 15.0-0 a5 1 6.a3 l:!fd8 1 7 .�b2 might be better. 8 ... 0-0 9.ll:lb5 ll:la6!? 1 0.e3 l:!e8 l l ..ie2 �+ 12.�d2 �xd2+ l3.�xd2 ll:lxe5 appears sounder, improving on 9 ... ll:lb4 IO.�dl d6 l l .a3 ll:lba6 12.exd6, Voss - Walther, corr 1 972) 7 .. ..ixc 5!? (Most sources give 7 .. ..ixg5 as dubious because of 8.ll:lc3 b6? 9.�d5 !l.b7 1 0.e6 s d6! ffi l l.ll:lxg5 fXg5 12.�xd7+�xd7 13.exd7+ Alternatives are: 'i!nc.d7 14.()..0...()+, Olsen - Martinsen, corr I) 5 ...c6 6.�dl d6 7.ll:lc3 ll:le6 8.g3 (in stead of 8.exd6 .hd6 9.ll:le4.ib4+ 1 0 .§J.d2 1945, however, Black can improve with .ie7, Tritschler - Vandersluys, internet 8....ie7 9.�e3 0-0 1 0.0-0-0 d6 l l .exd6 2001) 8 ...�c7 9.exd6 .hd6 1 0./J.g2 0-0 cxd6 1 2.c5 .if6 1 3 .cxd6 !l.e6. It seems that 8.e6 ! ? .if6 9.exf7+ 'i!ixf7 is more 1 1 .0-0, Gutman; or testing, and now not 1 O.ll:lc3 d6 1 1 .�5. II) 5 .. ..ie7 6.ll:lc3 0-0 7 ..if4 a5 8.g3 (I prefer 8.e3 b6 9..ie2 !l.b7 IO.�d l) 8 .. b6 when instead of l l ...a6?! l2 .�3 ll:la5 9.ib3 .ib7 IO.�d2 ll:le6 l l .O-O i.a6 12.b3 l3.�c2 ll:lxc4 14.ll:ld5 ll:lxb2 1 5 .l:!bl l:!e8 .ib4 l3.a3 ll:lxf4 14.gxf4 .hc3 15.�xc3 16.ll:lxf6 �xf6 1 7 .�xb2 g6 1 8.e3 !l.f5
ID) 5.ll:lc3 ll:lc6 6.ll:lf.3 (6.it'4 should be met by 6 ... d6! 7.exd6 .hd6 8 ..bd6 cxd6 9.e3 0-0 1 O.�f.3 �a5, and not by 6...ll:lb4 7.�d2 c6 8.ll:lf.3 �a5 9.ll:ld4 ll:le6 l O.ll:lxe6 dxe6 l l .l:!dl !I.e? 1 2.a3 ll:la6 1 3 .e3 0-0 14.id3 ll:lc5 15ic2, Niemann - Mikulka, Vienna 1 936) 6 ... ll:lb4 (6 ...d6 7..ig5 �d7 goes back into the main line, but 6... ll:le6 7.e3 b6 is quite interesting, for example 8..ie2 ib7 9.0-0 l:!b8 1 O.�d3 g6 l l .ll:ld5 !l.g7 12.�e4 0-0 l3..id2 ll:lxe5! 14.ll:lxe5 f5 15.�c2 .he5) 7.�d2 d6 8.ll:lb5 (8.ll:ld5 a5 9.exd6 .hd6 1 O.a3 ll:lxd5 l l .cxd5 0-0) 8 ...a6 9.�xb4 axb5 l O..ig5 �d7 l l .exd6 .hd6 12.�c3 0-0 ( l 2 ...ll:le4!?) 1 3.cxb5 �xb5 14.e3 �a4 1 5 .�c4 ll:lb3 ( l5...�c6 1 6.ll:ld4�e4 17.f.3 �g6 1 8.f4 b5 l9 .�c3 b4 20.�c4 i.a6 is not bad either, Zippy Mozart, computer game 1994) 16.�xa4 fua4 1 7 .l:!bl l:!xa2 1 8./J.c4 .ie6! looks rather comfortable for Black, Gutm an.
...
.
28
1 9 ..ic4+ 1 :0 Matthews - Elieff, Lon don 1995, l l ....ixc3+ 1 2.bxc3 YMf6 could be played, but lO.YMd5+! 'it>f8 l l .YMd2 d6 12.lik3) S ..ixdS 'it>xdS 9.lik3 ges 10.e3 ( 10.0-0-0?, Piegeler - Wendland, corr 1 994, l O ....ixf2 1 U�d5 .ie3+) 10 ... li:lxe5 l l .li:lxe5 �be5 12.J.e2 d6 13 .0-0 a6 and Black is not worse, Gutman ; D) 6.g3! is more impressive, we see: Dl) 6...d6 7.ig5(7.exd6 hd6 S.J.g2 .ie6 9.�d 1 .ixc4, Perez - Lopez de Turizo, Madrid 2003) 7 ...�d7 (7 .. f6 S.exffi gxf6 9J.h4 Ae6 1 o.�d2 .i.g7 l l .li:la3 - instead of l l .li:ld4 hc4 12.li:lf5 0-0 l3.ig2 �eS 1 4.li:lc3 �e5, Fuester - Honfi, Budapest 1 950 -, 1 1 ...0-0 12.J.g2 a5 1 3 .0-0) S.exd6 ixd6 9. .ig2 li:lb4 1 0.�d2 �e6 1 1 .0-0 li:le4 12.YMcl 0-0 l3.J.e3, Gutman; further D1) 6...li:le6 7.J.g2 .ib4+ S.id2 (S.li:lbd2 b6 9.a3 .ie7 1 0.0-0 .ib7 l l .li:le4!? 0-0 1 2 ..ie3 is possible) S ....ixd2+ 9.YMxd2 0-0 l O.li:lc3 ges 1 1 .0-0 h6 (if l l ...li:lf8 12.YMg5! li:lxe5 13.YMxdS li:lxf3+ 14.hf3 gxdS 1 5.gfdl) l 2.gfd l li:lf8 l3.c5 li:lg6 14.li:ld5, Gutman; similarly D3) 6 ... h6, Tseitlin/Glask ov, 7 ..ig2 d6 S.exd6 .ixd6 9.J.e3 !? .ie6 1 O.ftd 1 �f6 l l .li:lc3 hc4 12.li:ld2 .ie6 l3.J.xc6+ bxc6 1 4 ..ixc5 .ixc5 1 5.li:lde4 YMd4 1 6.li:lxc5 �xc5 17 .0-0 0-0 l S.gc 1 securing a bet ter position for White, Gutman.
attack was dead in Brause - Y ggdrasi, computer game 1 995) S ...cxd6 9.e3 .ie6 l O.YMdl li:lc6 l l .li:lc3 g5 1 2.J.e2 h5 13.0-0 h4 14.li:ld5 with advantage, Szuveges Van Leent, Vlissingen 2000. 7.�c:3 �c:6 8.exd6 1xd6 9.�b5
Others: I) 9.e3? li:lb4 lO.YMd2 YMfS l l .e4 li:lxe4 12.�e2 0-0 13.li:lxe4 ges 14.li:lf6+ gx f6 15.�xeS+ �g7 1 6.J.xf6+ YMxf6 1 7.0-0-0 li:lxa2+ 1 S.'it>d2 �xb2+ l S.'it>el .ib4+, Tchimino - Bielefeldt, corr 1 992; m 9.li:le4 li:lxe4 1 0.�xe4+ �e6 l l .�xe6 ixe6 l 2.gcl li:le5 l3.c5 li:lxf3+ 1 4.exf3 .ie5 1 5 .b3 f5 is level, Gutman. 9...�b4!
9...0-0 I O.li:lxd6 cxd6 l l .a3 ges 12.gdl ( l2.g3?! li:le5 l3 ..ig2 YMfS 1 4 .J.e3 .ie6 1 5.YMxd6 li:lcd3+ 16.exd3 li:lxf3+ 1 7.�e2 gadS l S.YMf4, Madhy - Jensen, Copen hagen 199S, 1S ...li:ld4+ 19.J.xd4 hc4+ 20.�fl YMxd3+ 2 l .�gl fud4) 1 2 ... li:le4 l 3 .e3 favours White, Gutman. I O.�xd6+ c:xd6 l l .tfdltfe6!
l l ...YMa4 1 2.li:ld4 0-0 1 3 .b3 YMa5 1 4.0 ges 15. 'it>t2! ( 15.e3? should be meet by 1 5 ... li:le6 16.li:lxe6 gxe6 1 7 ..if4 li:lc2+ 1S.'it>e2 �xd2+ 1 9.'it>xd2 li:lxa l , and not by 1 Lli:lcd3+ 16.J.xd3 li:lxd3+ 1 7.�e2 �xg5 1S.'it>xd3 .id7 1 9.e4 �g6 20.g4 gacS 2 l .YMf4 d5 22.cxd5 YMa6+ 23.�e3 �3+ 24.�f2. Finegold - Rogers, Pr.lgue 1990) 1 5 ...li:le6 1 6.J.e3 YMe5 l 7.gdl and Black is in trouble, Gutman.
6.1g5
6.exd6 .ixd6 7.YMg5 (7.li:lc3 ie6 S.�d4 0-0 9.e3 li:lc6 l O.�dl YMf6 l l .a3 gadS, Koebele - Brehmer, Hassloch 1997) 7 ... 0-0 S.�xdS gxdS 9.li:lc3 li:lc6, Gutman.
l l.e3 aS
The chances are about equal, e.g. l3..if4 (l3.li:ld4 YMg6 14 . .if4 0-0 15.a3 li:lbd3+ 16 ..ixd3 li:lxd3+ 1 7.�fl .ie6 1 S.li:lxe6 fxe6 1 9.J.g3 e5) l3 ...li:le4 14.YMc l li:lc5 1 5.YMc3 ( 1 5.YMb 1 YMf6 1 6.li:ld4 0-0 17 .a3 li:lc6) 1 5 ...YMg6 1 6.gdl 0-0 ( 1 6...li:le4?! 17.YMcl li:lxa2 lS.YMbl li:lb4 1 9.li:lh4 YMe6 20.gd4) 1 7.a3 ( 1 7.J.xd6?! li:le4 lS.YMe5 li:lxd6 1 9.YMxd6 .ie6) 17 ...li:lc2+ 1 S.�e2 li:la4 19.YMb3 li:lc5 with a draw, Gutm an.
6...tfd7
6..�7 7.J.xe7 YMxe7 S.exd6 (S.b4 should be met by S ...li:lcd7 9.exd6 cxd6 I O.�g5 f6, e.g. l l .YMh5+ g6 1 2 .YMb5 a6 l 3.�a4 0-0 1 4.li:lc3 li:le5 or l l .YMd2 li:le5, while after S ... 1e6 9.exd6 cxd6 lO.YMd4 li:lc6 l l .YMxg7 li:lxb4 12.YMxhS+ �d7 l3.�xaS YMf6 14.li:lfd2 YMxal 1 5 .YMxa7 YMh2 1 6.e4 �c l+ 17 .'it>e2 .ixc4+?! 1S.'it>f3 Black's 29
Chapter I
Part Two: The Steiner Variation ( l.d4 �f6 2.c4 eS 3.dxe5 �e4) 4.Vc2
• - ... \Wl . .'f� . ,. ... � �
?' ' '
f.
". ;·� ', � � ---:.. 7:tf i�J�···w �/. �
••r.• •i{rf?• •• -
-
iQ:.
-
' -�· . . � . . . � �\WI,., i!� ,., �_ f.Q!. W � O Q; O � �tD- W.t� .: s.�o
Other possibilities: I) 5 .b4 �e6 6.a3 d6 reaches a position after 4.a3 d6 5.�c2 �c5 6.b4 �e6, co vered in Part 5, Chapter 4, Section I ; U) 5 .a3 is best answered by 5 ... d6, trcms posing to 4.a3 d6 5 .�c2 �c5 - Part 5, Chapter 4, Section I, while 5...a5 6.� f3 �c6 transposes into 4.a3 �c6 5.�f3 a5 6.�c2 �c5 - Part 5, Chapter 3; Ill) 5.�c3 �c6 (for 5 ... d6!? 6.exd6 .ixd6 7.�f3 �c6 8.a3 see 4.a3 d6 5 .�c2 �c5 6.�f3 �c6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.�c3 - Part 5, Chapter 4, Section I ) 6.�f3 (6.f4?! d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.e4 �b4 9.�dl 0-0 I O.c;bf2 �f6 l l .g3 is strongly met by I I .. .ie5 ! 12..ie3 .ixc3, while Holm - BJorn, Co penhagen 1 963, went l l ...�d8 1 2.�f3 �cd3+ 1 3 .ixd3 .ic5+?! 14.c;bg2 �xd3 1 5.�ge2? �f2 1 6.�h5 .ih3+ 0:1 ) goes back into the main line, Gutman.
"As Borik says, this is the hardest move to meet. The strength of 4.�c2 depends on whether Black can support the knight for the one move by d7-d5 as a prepa ration for .. .i.f5 , or whether the knight will have to retreat. Indeed, this move is somewhat old-fashioned and I would always be happy to see White play it, but some of the lines are still considered critical", Tim Harding. "Another idea is 4.�c2, strategically very healthy, since it supports the develop ment ofthe knight to c3 and forces Black to take a decision. However, it does not enjoy a good reputation", Alfonso Ro mero .
"4.�c2, trying to evict the knight from e4 straight away, is also seen occasion ally", Bogdan Lillie.
s... �c6
The material divides as follows:
5 ... d6 is premature due to 6..ig5 �d7 (if 6....ie7 7.exd6 �xd6, Nett - Zimmermann, e-mail 2000, 8..ixe7 �xe7 9.�c3) 7.�c3 �c6 (or 7...�e6 8.ih4 �c6 9.�d5 �d7 IO.exd6 .ixd6 1 1 .0-0-0) 8Edl �b4 9.� I aS IO.a3 �c6 l l .e3, Gutman.
Chapter I - 4 ...lik5 Chapter 2 - 4 ... d5 Chapter 3 - 4....ib4+.
6.�c3!
30
Chapter 1 ( l .d4 �f6 1.c4 eS 3.dxe5 �e4 4.1fcl) 4 d5
Less effective are: I) 6.g3 d6! (6...ti'e7 7 .J.g2 lilxe5 8.lilxe5
ti'xe5 9 .J.d2 - 9 .J.f4 ti'f6 1 O ..bc7 lile6 l l ..ia5 is also good -, 9 ...d6 1 0.0-0 J.e7 l l .J.c3 t:Yh5 1 2 .J.xg7 �g8 1 3 .J.d4 �g6 14.J.f3 J.g4 1 5.J.xg4 ti'xg4 16bc5 dxc5 1 7 lld 1 J.d6, Warren - Szpisjak, Chi cago 1992, 1 8.lild2 ().()..0 l9.ti'e4) 7.exd6 (7 .J.g5 J.e7 8.J.xe7 !Nxe7 9.exd6 should be met by 9-cxd6 I O.a3 J.g4 l l.lilbd2 0-0, and not by 9 ...lilb4 I O.!Nc3 lilbd3+ l l .�d2 lile4+ 1 2.�xd3 lilxf2+ 13.�c2 !Ne4+ 14.'ilib3 lilxhl 15.lilg5 'eNg6 16.!Ne3+ J.e6 1 7 .J.g2) 7 ...J.xd6 (better than 7 ... !Nxd6 8.J.g2 lilb4 9.!Nc3 lile4 l O .!Nb3 lilc5 I I .!Ne3+ J.e6 1 2.lila3 0-0-0 1 3.0-0 a6 14..Ad2 lild7 151lfd l lilffi l 6.!Na7 and White won easily, Gutters - Olafsson, Akun:yri 1983) 8.a3 (8.J.g2 lilb4 9.�c3 lile4 1 0.�3 lilc5 l l .ti'e3+ J.e6 12.lila3 0-0 1 3 .0-0 �e8) 8 ... J.g4 9.lilbd2 (9.J.g2 J.xf3 1 O.J.xf3 lild4) 9 ... aS 1 O.J.g2 0-0 1 1 .0-0 a4 with counterplay, Gutman; D) 6.a3 d6! (6...a5 transposing to 4.a3 lilc6 5.lilt3 a5 6.ti'c2 lilc5, and 6_ti'e7, see 4.a3 lilc6 5.lilf3 ti'e7 6.ti'c2 lilc5, are covered in Part 5, Chapter 3. 6... lile6 7.lilc3 fa vours White, e.g. 7 ... b6 8..Ad2 .ib7 9.e3 g5 IO.lild5 J.g7 l l ..ic3 g4 1 2.lild4 lilxe5 l 3.lilf5 .tR; 14.0-0-0 or 7 ...gS 8.lild5 J.g7 9.ti'f5 h6 1 0.h4; less accurate is 7.e3 g5 8.h3 J.g7 9.J.e2, when instead of9 . . b6 I O.J.d2 J.b7 l l .J.c3 ti'e7 12 .lilbd2 0-0? 1 3 .h4, Rasmussen - Simonsen, Faroe 1 999, 9...lilxe5 1 O.lilxe5 J.xe5 l l .J.d2 d6 12 .lilc3 c6 could be played) reaches aposition after4.a3 d6 5.ti'c2 lilc5 6.lilf3 lilc6 - Part 5, Chapter 4, Section 1 .
..•
4... d5 gives up all hope ofrecovering the pawn; indeed Black may throw one or two more into the pot if White is greedy. This move is in the spirit of the Fighting Faj, but may not be fu lly correct, Tim Harding. 5.exd6! White has no timefor slack moves. The knight on e4 must be deprived ofpro tection, Otto Borik.
Alternatives: I) 5.lild2 J.fS (5 .. .J.b4 will transpose into 4.ti'c2 J.b4+ 5.lild2 d5 - Chapter 3, Sec tion 2) 6.ti'a4+ (6.lilxe4 dxe4 7.e3 J.b4+ 8.J.d2 .bd2+ 9.ti'xd2, Seeger - Fischer, Germany 1 997, 9...ti'e7 is excellent for Black. In case of 6.ti'b3 hoping for 6 ... lilc6 7.cxd5 lild4 8.ti'a4+ b5 9.ti'xd4 J.cS l O.ti'xe4 .be4 l l .lilxe4, 6...lilc5!? 7.ti'f3 J.e4 8.lilxe4 dxe4 9.ti'c3 lilc6 would be the right answer) 6 ... lilc6 7.lilgf3 (7.cxd5 is shown to be careless by 7 ... ti'xd5 8. lilgf3 � 9.a3 J.c5 1 O.e3 lilxe5 l l .lilxe4 .be4 12.lilxe5 ti'xe5 l 3 .J.e2 �d6 14.0-0 �g6 1 5 .13 J.d6 1 6.g3 �xg3+, Gerard . Orlandi, France 1998. 7 .lilxe4 dxe4 IS also unpleasant for White, e.g. 8.a3 !Nd4
.
6 ...h6 7.a3 aS
This position, first reached in Ander sen - Junker, corr 1 942 (Skakbladet, 1 948). is treated under 4.a3 lilc6 5.lilf3 a5 6.ti'c2 lilc5 7.lilc3 h6 - Part 5, Chapter 3.
Jl
9.e3 "t!fxe5 l O.ltle2 0-0-0 l l .ltlc3 h5 or 8.id2 "t!fd4 9.ic3 ib4 1 0."t!fxb4 ltlxb4 l lbd4 ltlc2+ 12.� ltlxd4 1 3.� Q.O.O 14.f4, NussbaKher - Klinger, Germany 1 996, 14 ...e3 15.ltlf3 c5) 7 ...ltlc5 (7 ..ib4 8.a3 hd2+ 9.ixd2 transposes to 4."t!fc2 ib4+ 5.ltld2 d5 6.a3 hd2+ 7..ixd2 its 8."t!fa4+ ltlc6 9.ltlf3 - Chapter 3, Section 2) 8."t!fdl dxc4 9.ltlxc4"t!fxdl+ 10.Wxdl ltle4 l l .Wel ib4+ 1 2 .id2 ltlxd2 l 3 .ltlcxd2 0-0-0 1 4 .a3, Tabemig - Schlindwein, Germany 2001 , 14 ... ixd2+! ? 1 5 .ltlxd2 ltlxe5 1 6.e4 l=ihe8 leads to advantage for Black, Gutman ; II) 5.a3 if5 6.ltlc3 (White can expect only trouble from 6."t!fa4+ ltlc6, for in stance 7.ltlf3 ltlc5 8."t!fdl dxc4 or 7.e3 ltlc5 8."t!fdl dxc4 9."t!fxd8+ gxd8, Asensio Granados, Cordoba 1 995. Likewise 6. "t!fb3 and now not 6...ltlc5 7."t!fdl dxc4 8."t!fxd8+ 'i!;lxd8 9.ig5+ ie7 l O.ixe7+ Wxe7 l l .ltlc3 gds 12 .e4 ie6, Eshuis Peters, Gocb 1992, but 6...ltlc6, viz. 7.cxd5 ltld4! 8."t!fa4+ b5 9."t!fxd4 ic5 10."t!fd3 ixf2+ l l .'i!;ldl !xg l ) 6 ... ic5 (6 ... ltlg3? 7.e4 ltlxe4 8.td3) 7.ltlxe4 he4 (7 ...dxe4 8.e3 ltlc6 9.b4) 8."t!fb3 ltlc6 9.ltlf3 (9.e3 d4 !?) 9 ... ltld4 1 0 .ltlxd4 ixd4 l l ."t!fxb7 0-0 1 2.0 gbs 1 3 ."t!fc6 gb6 14."t!fa4 ig6 with good attacking chances, Gutman; Ill) 5.cxd5 is more intriguing. •
Black has two possibilities:
A) 5 .. ..ifS, and now: Al) 6."t!fa4+ c6 7.d6 (7.dxc6 ltlxc6 8.ltlf3 "t!fb6 9.e3 0-0-0 1 O.ie2 ib4+ l l .ltlbd2
g5 - l l ...ltlxd2 12bd2 hd2+ l 3.ltlxd2 �d2 14.Wxd2 "t!fxb2+ is simpler, Bogdlm Lillie -, 12."t!lh5 g4 l3."t!fxb6 axb6 14.ltlh4 ie6 and White is lost, Molina - Gomez, Argentina 1993) 7 .. ."t!fb6 8.e3 (8.ltlh3?! ltld7 9.f3 ltlec5 IO."t!ff4hh3 l l .gxh3 ltle6 12."t!fe4 "t!fa5+ 1 3 .ltlc3 "t!fxe5) 8 ..."t!fc5 ! (if 8...ltld7, Ltzlic, then 9.f3 ltlec5 IO."t!fd4) 9.ltld2 ltlxd2 l O.hd2 "t!fxe5 l l ."t!fb4 b5 12.ic3 hd6 l3.'Wh4 "t!fe6 14.ixg7 ggs 1 5 .J.c3 b4 16.J.d2 gg4 appears to hold a balance, Gutman; A2) 6.ltlc3 tb4 7 .td2 (Absurd is 7."t!fa4+ ltlc6, for example 8."t!ib3? ltld4 9."t!fa4+ b5 1 O."t!fdl ltlxc3 l l ."t!fxd4 c5 0:1 Turkka Haenninen, Helsinki 1 952, or S .Jdl hc3 9.ixc3 "t!fxdS l O.ltlf3 0-0-0 l l .e3 ltlxc3 1 2.bxc3 .ie4. 7."t!fb3 is a more critical test: 7 ..."t!fe7 8.ltlf3 ltld7 9.g3, e.g. 9...0-0 l O.ig2 ltlxe5 l l .ltlxe5 !xc3+ 12.bxc3 "t!fxe5 13M4 or 9...ltlxe5 1 O.ltlxe5 hc3+ l l .bxc3 "t!fxe5 1 2 f3 holding a plus for White, while 7 ... c5? 8.a3 "t!fb6, Busch Richter, Hagen 1 978, loses to 9.axb4! c4 1 0."t!fa4+ td7 l l .ie3) 7 .. .ixc3 8.ixc3 "t!fxd5 9.gdl ! (Oieg Neikirch analyses 9.ltlf3 ltlg3 1 0.e4 "t!fxe4+ l l ."t!fxe4 ltlxe4, viz. 12.id4 ltlc6 l 3 . .ib5 .id7 1 4.0-0-0 0-0-0 1 5.J.e3 ltlxe5 16.ltlxe5 hb5 with equality, yet 9 ... ltlc6 is more flexible, e.g. 1 O.e3? ltlg3, DlDlkel - Liberto, Wild bad 1 993, or 1 O."t!fb3 ltlxc3 l l ."t!fxc3 .ig4) 9 ..."t!fc5 (9 ...ltlxc3 1 O.fudS hc2 l l .bxc3 ltlc6 1 2.f4 We7, Coudere - Gedult, Paris 1 97 1 , 13.gd2!? ie4 14.e3 �8 1 5.ltlf3) IO.e3 ltlxc3 (IO ...ltlg3? l l ."t!fd2) l l ."t!fxc3 "t!fxc3+ 1 2.bxc3 ltld7 1 3 .f4! (l3.ltlf3 ie6 14.a3 0-0-0, instead of 13 ...ig4?! 14.&14 thS 15.J.b5 0-0-0 1 6.g4, Hernando Rod rigo - Vasquez Gamero , Barrelona 1 996) l3 ...ie6 1 4.a3 0-0-0 1 5.ltlf3 did not give Black full compensation, Gutman. 32
B) L't!fxdS ! (gets the queen into action with tempo, Harding) 6.ltlc3 (6.ltlt3 ltlc6
ltlxeS 1 2 .ie2 ie6 leaves Black with a slight edge; however, less precise is 6 ... 't!fxdS, when instead of7.ltlf3 .if5 8.'t!fc4 't!faS+ 9.id2 ltlxd2 IO.ltlbxd2 ib4 l l.'t!fbS ().()..() 12.'t!fxa5 txa5 l3.a3 ixd2+ 14.ltlxd2 ltlxeS, Turon Gimeno - Tomas Batet, Gent 1996, 7 ..ic4 ib4+ 8.�fl !? 't!fxeS 9.ltlf3 't!fe7 10.ad5 f5 l l.a3 td6 12.ltlbd2 ltlxd2 l3.ixd2 td7 14.e4 might be tried) 6_.tf5 (6_.J.b4+ 7.ltlc3 see 4.'t!fc2 aM+ S.ltlc3 dS 6.ltlf3 ltlc6 7.e3 - Chapter 3, Section 3, yet 6...ltlb4 7.'t!fa4+td7 8.'t!fdl dxc4 9.a3 lDd3+ 1 O.i.xd3 cxd3 l l .O-O ltlcS 1 2.ltld4 aS 1 3 .ltlc3 l::!a6 is interesting) 7.ltlc3 (7.'t!fdl is best met by 7 .. ..ib4+!? 8.ltlbd2 d4 9.exd4 ltlxd4 IO.ltlxd4 ixd2+ l l ..ixd2 't!fxd4 1 2 . .ie3 't!fxb2 l3.'t!fd4 't!fb4+, Vasquez - Liascovich, Buenos Aires 200 1 . On 7 ... dxc4 8.'t!fxd8+ l::!xd8 9. .ixc4 .ib4+ 1 O.�e2 ltlaS White may play l l .a3 ! ? ie7 12..ia2 ltlcS 1 3.ltld4, instead of l l ..ibS+ c6 1 2.b4 ltlcS 1 3.a3 .id3+ 14.�d l , S. Rubinstein - Becker, Vienna 1 932, 14 ...ixb l+! I S .ltld4 .ic3 16.bxc3 ltlxa4) 7 ...ltlb4 (7 ...ltlg3? 8.'t!fa4 ltJxh 1 9.cxdS td7 IO.dxc6 ixc6 l l ..ibS hardly inspires sympathy, Issakainen Heikkinen, Finland 1 999) 8 .'t!fa4+ c6 9.ltld4 ltlcS I O.'t!fdl (I O.'t!fxb4?! ltld3+ l l .ixd3 ixb4 1 2.ixf5 cS l3.ltldbS 't!fgS) 1 O ...ig6 and Black is fine, Gutman; V) S .lDO is a solid response.
7.ltlbd2 ifS 8.ltlxe4 ixe4 9.'t!fdl txf3 IO.exf3 ib4+ was a disaster for White in Tyson - Chaplin, Bristol 1 993. 6.ltld2 .ib4 goes into 4.'t!fc2 ib4+ S.ltld2 dS 6. cxdS 't!fxdS, a line regarded as good for Black - Chapter 3, Section 2, while 6 ... .if5 7.'t!fd3 't!fxeS 8.ltlf3 't!faS 9.ltlh4 ltlxd2 IO..ixd2 ixd3 l l ..ixaS ltJc6 12.ic3 ie4 l 3 .a3 ie7 14.ltlf3 0-0 is even) 6 ...ltlxc3 (6.. � transposes to 4.'t!fc2ab4+ S.ltlc3 dS 6.cxdS 't!fxdS - Chapter 3, Section 3) 7.'t!fxc3 aS 8..id2 (8.a3? ib4 9.axb4 axb4 I OJ�xa8 bxc3 1 U :!xb8 c2 12 ..id2 't!faS, Roger Thomsen) 8 .. ..ib4 9.'t!fe3 ixd2+ 1 O.'t!fxd2 't!fxeS l l .ltlf3 't!fe7 with a pleas ant position for Black, Gutman. IV) S .e3 looks a bit passive.
S ...ltlc6 (S ...i.f5 6.'t!fdl aM+ 7.id2 ltlxd2 8.ltlxd2 ltlc6 9.a3 .ixd2+ I O.'t!fxd2 dxc4 l l .ltlf3 't!fxd2+ 12.�xd2 ig4 l3 ..ixc4 ix f3 14.gxf3 ltlxeS is hannless, while 6..id3? ltlc6 gives White a plenty of pro� terns, e.g. 7.a3 ltlxeS 8.'t!fa4+ bS 9.'t!fxb5+ c6 IO.'t!fb3 ltlcS, Kargaard - Thomsen, Copenhagen 1994, or 7.'t!fdl ib4+8.'i!i>e2, Ros - Thomsen, Denmark 1 994, when 8_,Y:!ih4 9.g3 't!ihS+ IO.f3 ltlxg3+ l l .hxg3 't!fxhl 12..ixf5 't!fg2+ was decisive) 6.ltlf3 (6.cxdS ib4+ 7.ltld2 't!fxdS 8.i.c4 ixd2+ 9..b.d2 't!fxd2+ IO.'t!fxd2 ltlxd2 l l .�xd2 33
S...�fS ! (5.)tlc6 6..id2? .15 7.�3 ltlc5 8."t!re3 d4 9."t!ff4 "t!rd7 I O.g4.ixg4 I I ..ig2 0-0-0 12.0-0 h5 13.h4 f6 14.b4 lLle6 gave Black advantage in Mueller - Schebler, Bad Mergentheim 1 988, yet 6.a3!? .if5 7.ltlc3 seems reasonable, e.g. 7 ...ltlg3 8. "t!ra4 ltlxhl 9.cxd5 .id7 I O.dxc6 .ixc6 I I ."t!rc4or 7.. ..tc5 8.e3 ltlg3 9."t!ra4 ltlxhl IO.cxd5 Ad? l l .dxc6 .ixc6 12..ib5) 6.�3 (6.ltlc3?! is strongly met by 6 ..ic5, and also 6."t!ra4+?! l0c6 is hardly viable for White, for instance 7..ie3ib4+8.ltlbd2 d4 9..if4 g5 IO.a3 ltlc5 I I ."t!rdl gxf4 12.axb4 ltlxb4 1 3 .�kl d3, Mititelu - Seimeanu, Romania 1 955, or 7.e3 ltlc5 8."t!rdl ltlb4 9.ltla3, Borik, 9..clobd3+ IO..ixd3 lLlxd3+ I I .'i!;le2 .txa3 12."t!ra4+ "t!rd7) 6...ltlc5 (on 6 ... ltlc6 7.cxd5 ltlb4 White has 8.ltld4! ltlc5 9."t!rdl .ig4 10.0 "t!rxd5 l l .e3 .id7 1 2 .a3 ltlc6 13.b4 ltle6 1 4.ltlxc6, while 8.d6 is wrong due to 8 ... a5 9.ltld4 cxd6 IO.ltlx5"t!rc8 I I ."t!ra4+ �8 12.ltlc3 "t!rxfS) 7."t!rdl ltlc6 8.cxd5 (other defences fail miserably, e.g. 8.a3 dxc4 9."t!rxd8+ �d8, Linn - Brauening, Trier 1992, 8.e3ltlb4 9.lLla3lLlbd3+ I O..ixd3 ltlxd3+ I I .'i!;le2 .txa3 12."t!ra4+ c6 13."t!rxa3 dxc4, Roque Cumillon, corr 1 997, or 8..ig5 ffi 9.exf6 gxf6 I O ..if4 "t!re7 l l .e3 0-0-0) 8 ... ltlb4 9.ltla3 ltlxd5 (9..."t!rxd5 I O."t!rxd5 ltlxd5 I I .ltlb5 ltle4 12.a3) I O.ltlb5 c6 (IO... ltle6 l l .e4.ixe4 12."t!ra4 ltlc5 1 3.ltlxc7+ 'i!;le? 14.ltlxd5+ "t!rxd5 1 5 ."t!ra3) I I .ltlbd4 .ig6 1 2 .a3 .ie7 13.e3 0-0 1 4 ..ie2 a5 1 5 .0-0 a4 with counterplay, Gutman.
8..ie2 .ic6 9..ie3 ltld7 I O.ltld2 "t!re7 l l .b4 5, when 12 .lLlgO might have been tried) 7.ltlc3 ltlc6 8..ie3 ltlxe4 (8 ..."t!re7 9.ltld5 "t!ff1 1 0.0) 9.ltlxe4 fxe4 IO."t!rxe4+ "t!re7 I I ..id3 "t!rxe4 1 2 ..txe4 appears inade quate, Feistenauer - Philipps, corr 1 990.
•
Black i� intent on commencing a central battle and hopes to prove that the white queen u misplaced on c2. A lthough ob jectively not entirely sound, this sharp continuation has brought him many re sounding victories, Lillie. 6.�d!
According to Max Euwe this move was found by Apking, a Dutch player, in 1 944, yet Niels Jensen traces it back to Skakbladet, / 94/.
Other continuations are: I) 6.0? "t!lh4+ (not 6 ... ltlg3 7.e4, Nicola Min ev) 7.g3 ltlxg3, Tseitlin/Giaskov; II) 6."t!rdl .ixd6 7.ltld2 ltlc6 (7 ...ltlc5 is probably not weaker, 8 .lLlgO ltlc6 9.a3 "t!re7 I O.e3 0-0-0 l l .b4 ltld3+ 12 ..ixd3 .ixd3 13.�3 .if4 14..ib2 .ixe3 1 5.fxe3 "t!rxe3+ 16.�1 ie2+ 1 7.rtJc2 l::!d3 18.i£:3, Arlandi - Lanzani, Milan Zonal l 985, 18....ixf3 1 9.ltlxt3 "t!re2+ winning) 8.ltlgf3 (8.a3 ltld4) 8 ... ltlb4 9.ltlxe4 (9.a3 ltlc3 IO.bxc3 ltlc2+) 9. ..ixe4 I O.ltld4 "t!fffi l l.e3 c5 1 2."t!ra4+ 'i!;le7 1 3 .a3 (13 ..id2 aS) 1 3 ... cxd4 14.axb4 dxe3 with attack, Gutman;
Back to the main line
s.. .trs
5 ... ltlxd6 6.e4 (6.ltlc3 ie6 7.e4 ltld7 8.b3 .ie7 9..ib2 0-0 I O.lLlO c6 I I ..ie2 .if6 12.0-0 "t!rc7 13J:!adl l:Ud8 1 4.l:Uel ltle5 1 5 .ltld4, Markus - Tuchtenhagen, corr 1 987) 6 ... f5 (Sjeng - GLChess, com puter game 2000, went 6.. ..id7 7.c5 ltlc8 34
III) 6.g4 is a rather artificial try, 6 ...
game, Borik, e.g. 9.Y!Jc3 /Oc6 IO.a3 �e8
.ig6 7 .J.g2 (7.dxc7 Y!Jxc7 8..ig2 .ib4+!? 9 ..id2 /Oxd2 I 0.Y!Ia4+ /Oc6 l l ..ixc6+ bxc6 12.10xd2 m>s 131ldl 0-0 14.a3 .id6 IS.b4 hh2 16./0gf3 .if4 1 7./0h4 �be8 18./0xg6 fxg6 19./00 Y!Je7 20.Y!Jc2 .id2+ 2 1 1lxd2 �0 was fine for Black, Jaeger Schneider, corr 199S) 7 ...IOcS (7...10xd6 8.Y!Ib3 /0d7 9.J.e3 c6 I O./Oc3 Y!JaS is not bad either) 8.dxc7 Y!Jxc7 9.Y!Ic3 10c6 I O.a3 � I I �3 (on 1 1 .100 Black can play I I ..J.e7 12.0-0 tf6 13 .Y!Ie3 .id4 14.Y!If4 Y!Je7, while l l ... hS was seen in Mullon Coursaget, Saint Lo 2001 ) 1 1 .../0eS !? (I I .. .J.d6 12./00 /Oe4 13.Y!Jcl hS 1 4.gS h4 I S ..ih3+ �b8 16.cS .ieS 17./0xeS ltlxeS looks after 18./0c3 /OxcS 19.0-0 /Ob3 20.J.xa7+ �a8 21 .Y!Jf4 /0xal 22.J.e3 quite promising for White, improving on 1 8.0?! /Og3 19.hxg3 /0d3+ 20.exd3 Y!Jxg3+, Gervais - Coursaget, Montlu con 1 997) 1 2.h3 (or 1 2.b4 /0e4 13./0xe4 .ixe4 14.0 .ig6 I S ./Od2 .ie7 16 .�fl IDleS) 12...l'ile4 13.Y!Icl .icS 14./0c3 /0xc3 I S .Y!Jxc3 �e8 with pressure, Gutman; IV) 6.Y!Ib3 .ixd6 (6.../0xd6 is best an swered by 7./0d2 /0c6 8.e3 Y!ld7 9./0gO 0-0-0 I O.J.d.J, while 7 .J.f4?! /Oc6 8./00 l'ile4 9.Y!Jxb7 .!M+ 10./0bd2 /0d4 1 1.10xd4 Y!Jxd4 12.Y!Jxb4 Y!lxf2+ 13.�1 Y!Jxf4 left White with a terrible position, Bolker Rother, corr 1 938) 7./0d2 (7.Y!Jxb7 0-0 8./00 /0d7 9./0bd2 /0df6 10./0xe4 /0xe4 l l .e3 �b8 12.Y!JdS .ib4+ 13 .<;!;>e2 /0d6 and I cannot see White's king surviving too long. 7./00 /Oc6 8./0c3 also hardly makes sense in view of 8....ib4 - less convincing is 8 ... /0b4, when instead of 9.a3? /OcS IO.Y!Jxb4 aS, Lorbek - Vos pemik, Slovenia 199 1 , 9./0d4 itS I O.e3 .ixd4 1 1 ./0xe4 Y!Je7 12.id2 Y!Jxe4 13bb4 0-0-0 14.cS could be played -, 9.e3 /0cS IO.Y!Jdl Y!Jxdl+ l l .'i!?xdl 0-0-0+) 7 ... 0-0 8.Y!Ixb7 (relatively better was 8./0gf3 !? /OcS, though Black still has a very active
l l .e3 .ie7 or 9.Y!Jdl /Oc6 I O.a3 aS l l .e3 �e8 12.J.e2 .ie7 13.0-0 a4) 8 .. .J.cS 9.e3 (neither 9./0xe4 .ixe4 I O.Y!Jxe4 .ib4+, nor 9.Y!Jxa8 .ixf2+ IO.�d l .ie3 1 1 ./00 /Of2+ 1 2.�e i, Borik, 12 ...c6! 13.g4 .ic2 14.�gl l0e4 IS.!ig2 Y!Jd7 16.gS /Oa6 are enjoyable for White) 9 ... Y!Je7 10./0dO (10./0g0 /0xf2! l l .�xf2 Y!lxe3+) 10 ... .!M+ I I.Jd2 /0xd2 12.10xd2 � 13.tvbS �8 14.0-0-0 Y!Jd6 IS./Ogf3 .ixO 16.gx0 .ixd2+ 1 7.<;!;>b i /Oc6 1 8.cS Y!Jg6+ 19.e4 Uab8 20.Y!Jc4 Y!lffi 2 1 .b3 10a5 0:1 Gilfer Richter, Olympiad Munich 1 936; V) 6.Y!Ja4+ /Oc6 7./0f3 (7.a3 Y!Jxd6 8.J.e3 Y!lf6 9.Y!Jb3 0-0-0 10./00 .icS, while 9 ... ltlaS, Nystrom - Nieminen, Tampere 1 989, is less clear due to I O.Y!JbS+ .id7 I I .Y!JxaS Y!Jxb2 1 2 .Y!JdS 0-0-0 13.Y!Jxe4 J.a4 14.Y!If5+ <;t>b8 1 S.f4 Y!Jxal l 6.\tlf2 �1 17 ./Od2. A I so 7 .J.f4 hd6 8.J.xd6 Y!Jxd6 did not help White, e.g. 9.0 /0g3 I O.hxg3 Y!Jxg3+ l l .�d2 � 12.�3 Y!Je l+ 13. �b3 .ic2+ 0: I M icholiksova - Pallova, Budapest 1 987, or 9.e3 1).0.{) 10�2 /0cS I I.Y!Ia3 /0b4, Anatoli Matsukevkh) 1 ... hd6 reaches one critical position.
There are a number of continuations: A) 8.e3 10cS 9.Y!Jd I /Ob4, Erich Eli.flulses; B) 8./0bd2 10cS 9.Y!Jdi /Ob4 IO.e4 /0xe4 1 1 ./0d4 .icS 1 2./02b3 .ixd4 1 3./0xd4 Y!Jxd4 0: I Ungar - Kostic, Sarajevo 1 948; 3S
C) s .aJ ef6 9.g3 (9.lt:l bd2 lt:lc5 w.edl
0-0-0 l l .e3 maes 1 2.J.e2 lt:ld3+ l3.J.xd3 .lxd3 14.eb3 .ic5 15.lt:lfl eg6 16.lt:lg3 .lc2 17.ec3 �l+ 18.�e2 Jd4 0: 1 Ness Rigenstrup, Drammen 1 947) 9 ... 0-0-0 (9 ....lc5!? l O ..lg2 .lxf2+ l l .�fl lt:lc5 1 2 .ed 1 gds 1 3 .lt:lbd2 .le3 looks even stronger, Jensen) IO.lt:lbd2 ( lO.J.g2 lt:lc5 l l .edl .ixg3, Borik) IO ... lt:lc5 l l .edl ghe8 12..tg2 .ld3 l3.e3 .le5 (l3 ...eg6! threatening 14 .. ,gxe3+ 1 5.fxe3 exg3+, Stefan Buecker, Kaissiber, 1 612001) 14.lt:lxe5 lt:lxe5 1 5.f4 .lxc4 1 6.'it>f2 .le6
We examine: A) 7.ea4+ lLlc6 8.lt:lf3 � 9.J.e3 (others are not better: 9.lt:lbd2 lt:lc5 IO.edl lt:lb4 or 9.id2 eb6 IO.eb3 exf2+ l l .'it>d 1 ib4 1 2 .'it>cl lt:lxd2 l3 .lt:lbxd2 gxd2 1 4.lt:lxd2 eel+ 1 5.edl .ixd2 mate Klastev - Do nev, Bulgaria 1 954) 9 ... lt:lc5 (9 ... lt:lb4?! l O.lt:la3 lt:la6 l l .c5 .lxc5 12.J.xc5 lt:lexc5 l3.ec4 was seen in Mira - Graf, Vienna 1999) IO..hc5 .lxc5 l l .e3 m6 1 2.eb3 ( 1 2.eb5 lt:lb4 1 3.a3 ed6 14.ea4 ef6) 1 2 .. .J.b4+ 13 .lt:lc3 lt:la5 0: 1 Andre - We ber, corr 1 995; B) 7.m3 lt:lc6 8.lt:lf3 0-0-0 9.J.d2 (9.e3 ? lt:lc5 , e.g. 1 o.ea3 lt:lb4 l l .exa7 lt:lc2+, Roessner - Kipke, Berlin 1933, or I O.ec3 00+ l l.J.xd3�d3. while 9.J.e3 is pun ished by 9...lt:lb4 1 O.a3 ea5 l l.lt:lbd2 lt:lc5) 9 ...lt:la5 (9.. ..ic5 1 0.e3 is less precise, e.g. IO .. .lt:lb4? l l .J.xb4 ed6 1 2.a3, Davey Richter, corr 1 985, or 1 O ... ee7 l l ..ie2 g5 1 2.lt:lc3 g4 13.lt:ld5 ee6 14.lt:lh4 lt:lxd2 1 5.'it>xd2 .le4 16.'it>e l ) IO.ea4 (I O.eb5 .ic5 l l .lt:ld4 lt:lxd2 12.lt:lxd2 a6 1 3 .ea4 .lxd4 0: 1 Froemmel - Rost, corr 1 987) 1 O...lt:lxc4 l l .exa7 (after l l.e3 lt:lexd2 1 2.lt:lbxd2 lt:lxb2 1 3.m3 00+ 14.J.xd3 .ixd3, Harding, White has no valid de fence, e.g. l 5.lt:ld4 gxd4 1 6 .exd4 ee7+ l 7 .'it>dl ee2+ 1 8 .'it>c l 'it>b8 or 1 5 .eb2 'it>b8 16..lkl ea5 17.ee5+ exe5 18.lt:lxe5 ib4 19.lt:lxf7 �8 20.11d 1 ges) l l ...ed7!
( The world premiere could have been perfect after 16 ... lt:led3+ 1 7 .'it>gl gxe3
1 8 .lt:lf3 ge l+! 1 9.lt:lxel ed4+, Borik) 17.h3 lt:lb3 1 8.'it>gl lt:lxal 19.fxe5 exe5 2o.en .id5 2 l .e4 .lc6 22.'it>h2 lt:lc 2!? 23 .exf7 gf8 (23...lt:le3!, Borik) 24.eb3 lt:ld4 25 �c3 ga 26.ge l gdtB 27.�h l ef6 28.gfl gxfl+ 29.lt:lxfl exfl +?? (29 .. .J.xe4) 30..lxfl gxfl + 3 l .'it>g2 1 :0 Steiner - Fajarowicr., WiesiNulen 1918; D) s.g3 .lc5 (8 ... lt:lc5 9.edl lt:lb4 IO.lt:la3 ee7 l l .J.g2 lt:lbd3+ 1 2.�fl ) 9.J.e3 effi 1 O..lxc5 exb2 (The famous game van Doesburgh - Richter, Olympiad Munich 1 936, continued 1 o ... lt:lxc5 l l .ea3 �e7 12.e3? .lxb 1 l3.gxbl ee4 14.lt:ld2 exh l 1 5.exc5 exh2 1 6.lt:lf3 \Wh6 1 7..!!d l �f6 1 8.ih3 gds 19Jhd8+ exd8 20.lt:lg5 h6 2 l .lt:le4 ee7 22.ed5 0.0 23.lt:lc5 lt:lb4 0:1 , but White can do better with 12.J.g2, e.g. 12 ...00 + l3.'it>fl exaJ 14.lt:lxa3 lt:lxb2 1 5 .lt:lh4 .le6 16m> l lt:lxc4 1 7.lt:lxc4 .lxc4 1 8 .gxb7 'it>d7 19 .gb2 gadS 20.lt:lf5 or 12 ...lt:lb4 l 3 .lt:ld4 0-0-0 14.0-0) l l ..id4 ee l + 1 2 .ed l exd l+ 1 3.'it>xd l 0-0-0! ( l 3 ...lt:lxd4 14.lt:lxd4 0-0-0 1 5.e3 c5 16.0 lt:lffi 1 7.lt:ld2 cxd4 18.o4, EI.Ukases) 14.�1 (14.e3 lt:lxt2+ 1 5 .� l lt:lxhl 1 6.J.g2 maes 1 7.� lt:lxd4 1 8 .exd4 �d4) 14 ... lt:lxd4 maintains a plus for Black, Gutman. VI) 6.dxc7 exc7 only increases Black's already dangerous initiative, Borik. 36
( l l . . ..ic5 12.Yh8+ �d7 I H�a4+ �c8 1 4.e3 ltlexd2 1 5 .ltlbxd2 ltlxb2 1 6.Wb3 ltld3+ 1 7 .i.xd3 .ixd3 , Harding, 18 .& I b6 1 9.ltlc4!? favours White) 12.e3 .ic5 1 3 .Wa8+ �c7 14.Wxd8+ lhd8 1 5..ixc4 .ig4 1 6..ia5+ b6 1 7 .ltlc3 .bf3 18.ltld5+ �b7 19.gxf3 ltlg5 20 ..ic3 l0xf3+ with decisive advantage for Black, Gutman ; C) 7.ltlc3 .ib4 (7... ltlg3? loses to 8.Wa4+ .id7 9.ltlb5, while 7... ltlxf2 8.Wxf5 l0xhl is strongly met by 9.ltld5!, for example 9...Wxc4 IO.We5+ �d7 l l .e4 Wc2 12.Wf5+ �d8 I3.i.g5+ ffi 14..&1 or 9 ...Wd7, Man ninen - Vahtera, Finland 1999, IO.We4+ .ie7 l l .g3 ltlxg3 12.hxg3 ltlc6 13 ..ih3 Wd8 14 ..ig5), when White has: Cl) 8.Wb3 ltlc6 9.ltlf3 (9.ie3 a5 !? I O.a3 a4 l l .axb4 axb3 12fu.a8+ �d7 13 .lhh8 ltlxc3 I4.id2 ltld4 I 5.ixc3 ltlc2+ 16.'it>dl Wd6+ I7..id2 Wd4 18.e4 Wxe4 19.c5 ltld4 20.ltle2 Wbl+, Pretto - Mairal, corr 1998) 9 ...0-0-0 I O ..ie3 Wa5 ! (instead of 10 ... mte8 l l .a3 .ic5 1 2.ltlxe4 .be3 13.Wxe3 .be4 I4.Wc3 .bn I 5.Wxf3 ltld4 16.Wc3 Wa5 17 ..& I , Schmidt - Lauer, Eppingen 1 988) l i ..&I ltlxc3 12.bxc3 .ia3 1 3 J�d l ( 13 J:�al ltlb4 1 4.ltld4 �bd4 1 5 ..ixd4, Lilley - Rivlin, Yorkshire 1948, 15 .. .ic2, HillkbrtuUVBerke/1) 1 3 ..fu.d l+ 14.�xdl gd8+ 1 5 ..id2 ( 1 5 . .id4 ltlxd4 1 6.l0xd4 gxd4+ 1 7.cxd4 .id7 and 1 5 .�el fails to 1 5 ... ltlb4 1 6.ltld4 gxd4 1 7 ..ixd4 ic2) 15 ....ie4 16.�e l (1 6.e3 .ixf3+ 1 7 .gxf3 Wf5 1 8J.g2 ltle5) 16 ....ixf3 1 7.exf3 We5+ 1 8 ..ie2 ge8 1 9.Wdl .ib2 20.f4 We4 is awkward for White, Gutman; Cl) 8.id2 ltlxd2! (Black cannot be satis fied with 8 .. .ixc3 9.ixc3 ltlg3 IO.e4 .ixe4 I I .id3 .ixd3 12.Wxd3 ltlxh I 13.ixg7 gg8 14.Wxh7. After 1 4 ...We7+ 1 5 .ltle2 gxg7 16.Wxg7 ltld7, so far Borik, 17.Wh8+ ltlffi 1 8_gd1 gd8 I9fu.d8+ �xd8 20.�fl 'it>e8 2t.Wd4 l0e6 23.We3 Y:!lb4 23.b3 Wd6 24.g3 White wins; this is more accurate than 20.Wd4+?! �c8 2 l .�fl 'Wb4 22.Wxa7
ltle6 23.We3 Wxb2 24.�g l , Harding, 24._lf:ld4!. Also 1 4...lhg7 1 5.Wh8+ �e7 16.Wxg7 is quite unpleasant as 16 ...Wxc4 17.We5+ � 1 8.Wh8+ We7 19.gdl We4+ 20.ltle2 or 1 6 ...Wc5 17.ltlh3 Wd6 1 8.gdJ 'WM+ 19.�fl . Schilling - Purschwitz, corr 1 988, shows) 9.Wxf5 .bc3 IO.bxc3 ltlxc4 I I.ltlf3 0-0 seem s level, Gutman. VD) 6.e3 ltlg3 (6_J.xd6 7.We2? ltlc6 8.a3 ltlc5 9.Wdl We7 IO.ltld2 ltld4 was a dis aster, A.Jensen - JJensen, Copenhagen 1998, yet 7..id3 ! .ib4+ 8.ltlc3 has more point, e.g. 8 ... We7 9.ltlge2 ltla6 10.0-0 .ixc3 I I .ltlxc3 ltlb4 12.Wa4+ id7 13.Wb3 ltlxc3 14.Wxc3 lbxd3 15.Wxd3 or 8._ltlxc3 9..ixf5 ltlxa2+ I O..id2 .ixd2+ I I .Wxd2 Wxd2+ 12.�xd2 ltlb4 13..ic8) 7 .id3 .ixd3 8.Wxd3 ltlxhl 9.We4+ 'tt;ld7 IO.Wf5+ �xd6 I I .Wd5+ �e7 1 2 .Wxb7 ltld7 1 3 .We4+ �d6 (13...�16?! 14.J.d2) 1 4.Wd5+ leads to a draw, Gutman. Back to the main line
6...�xd6
Others: I) 6 ... ltlxc3? 7.Wxf5 ltla4 8.Wb5+ Wd7 9.Wxb7 Wc6 I O.Wc8 mate, St�t�idly Tartllkower; II) 6...l0xf2? 7.Wxf5 ltlxhl 8.i.g5, Euwe; III) 6 ...l0g3?, frequently played, is also of dubious value, introducing the fol lowing complications: 37
A) HYb3 ll::J xh l 8.�xb7 ll::ld7 9.g4! (on 9.dxc7 �c8 I O.�f3. Bjelobrk - Spiller, Melbourne 2002, Black can play 10 .. . ic5 l l .e3 .ie6 with good chances) 9 .. . hg4 10.dxc7 �c8 1 1� �xb7 12bb7 ll::lb 6 l3 ..ixhl :!:!.c8 14 ..if4, Gutman; B) 7.e4 ll::l x hl 8 .exf5 (after 8.dxc7 �xc7 9.exf5, Kanko - Hamalainen, Finland 1 999, 9...ll::Jc6 would have kept matters unclear) 8 ....ixd6 9..ie3 (9 .�e4+ �e7 I O.�xe7+ .ixe7 l l .lLld5 .id6 1 2 .g3 c6 l 3 ..if4 Wd7 14..ixd6 Wxd6 1 5 .ll::Je3 :!:!.e8 1 6..ig2 ll::Jxf2 1 7.Wxf2, Grubling - Suhr, Germany 1989) 9.. ..txh2 (9 ...ll::Jc6 IO.ll::Jf3 0-0 l l .:!:!.dl �e8 1 2 . .ie2, Ernst - Isler, Biel 2002) l O . ll::J f3 .id6 1 1 .0-0-0 �c8 1 2.�e4+ .ie7 1 3 .ll::Jd 5 ll::Jc6 1 4.f6 gxf6 1 5 .ll::Jxf6+ Wf8 16 ..ih6 mate Likavsky Guttdeutsch, Tatry 1 998; C) 7 .�a4+ .id7 8.ll::Jb 5 ! (8.dxc7 is also reasonable, e.g. 8 ...�xc7 9.ll::l b 5 .ixb5 1 0.�xb5+ ll::Jc6 l l .hxg3 0-0-0 1 2.�f5+ Wb8 13.ll::J f3, Mertens - Selke, Minden 1 959, or 8...�c8 9.cxb8� �xb8 I O.�c2 ll::Jx hl l l .�e4+ .h6 1 2.g3 ll::Jxf2 l3.Wxf2, Sanchez - Velasco, lrapuato 1985) 8 ... .ixd6 9.hxg3 .ic5 I O.�c2 and wins, De Haan - Sarink, Utrecht 1989. IV) 6 ....ixd6 7. ll::J xe4 (7.a3 �e7 !, while 7 ... ll::Jg3? 8.e4 ll::l x hl 9.exf5 0-0 l O ..ie3 turned out well for White in Fernandez Prieto - Beltran Sequer, corr 1985) 7 ... ib4+ (if 7...0-0 8.e3 .ib4+ 9.We2 ! ? :!:!.e8 IO.f3, while 8.13, Minev, is less clear be cause of 8...�4+ 9.g3 .ixg3+ 1 0.hxg3 �xh 1 l l ..ie3 :!:!.e8 1 2 .0-0-0 ll::Jc6) 8 ..id2 .ixd2+ 9.�xd2 .ixe4 1 0.�xd8+ Wxd8 l l .f3 leaves White a sound pawn ahead, Gutman. 7.e4!
7.�dl is an insipid alternative in view of 7 ... ll::Jc6 8 .e3 ll::Je4 9..td2 ll::lxd2 IO.�xd2 �xd2+ l l .Wxd2 0-0-0+ 1 2 .Wel ll::lb4 13 .. :!:!.dl .ie7 1 4.ll::J f3 .if6, Zoeschling Mansfield, corr 1 99 5 . 38
7...�xe4
Most legal moves have been tried here: I) 7 ...�e7 8..id3 .ie6 (8 ...ll::Jc6? is absurd
due to 9.ll::Jd5 �d7 I O.exf5 0-0-0 l l .ll::J f3 l"!e8+ 12..ie3 ll::Je5 l 3.ll::Jxe5 :!:!.xe5 14.0.0.0, Allison - Shaw, Southend 2000 . 9.ll::Jge2 .h6 I O.c5 ll::Jc8 l l ..ie3 looks like a less er evil, although Borik gives 9 .. ..tg6 10. lLld5 and Sorensen - Anderr.m, Copenha gen 1 943, continued 9 ... ll::lb4 1 0.�a4+ ll::lb5 1 1 .0.0 - l l..ib l ! id7 12.cxb5 wins, Jensen -, l l ....td7 12.lLlxb5 lLlxd3 13�1 .ixb5 14.�xb5+ c6 1 5.�f5 g6 1 6.�g5 \!:Yb4, when 17.ll::J f4 ! ll::lxf4 1 8.�e5+ ll::Je6 1 9.�xh8 is decisive) 9.c5 ll::lc8 l O ..ie3 c6 l l .ll::Jge2 ll::Jd7 12.ll::Ja4 ll::Je5 1 3 .0-0 f6 14.ll::J f4 .if7 1 5 .f3 g5 1 6 .ll::Je 2, Kragh Pedersen, Copenhagen 1997; further II) 7 ....ie6 8 .b3 (8.c5 ? ! ll::J c8 9. .ie3 c6 IO.ll::Jf3 �a5 l l .�a4 �xa4 12.ll::Jxa4 ll::Jd7 l3.ll::Jd4 ll::J xc5 1 4 .ll::Jx c5 .ixc5 1 5 .ll::J x e6 .ib4+ 1 6..td2 hd2+ 17.Wxd2 fxe6 was OK foc Black, Schmidt - Wittelsberger, Germany 1993) 8 ... ll:x:6 9.ll::Jf3 .ie7 (9 ... �ffi I O ..ib2 �g6? ! , Sebban - Orlandi, France 1 998, l l .c5! ll::Jc8 12.ll::lb5) IO.Jb2 ( IO.a3 0.0 l l ..id3 .if6 1 2..ib2 .ig4 1 3.e5 ll::Jxe5 14.ll::Jxe5 .ixe5 1 5.h3 :!:!.e8 1 6.0-0, Melchor - Schwertel , corr 1 992, 16 ... hh3 1 7.gxh3 �g5+ 1 8.Whl �5 with perpetual) 10 ... 0-0 l l ..ie2 .if6 1 2 .:!:!.dl Black has no compensation, Gutman;
III) 7 ...ig6 also has its drawback s.
Then: A) 8.ie3 �xe4 9.�xe4 ib4+ 10 .�e2 'ffe7, given by Hans Haberditz, a theo retician from Vienna, l l .'ffa4+ ( 1 1 .0 f5 12 .a3 fxe4 13.'ffa4+ �c6 14.axb4 exO+ 1 5 .�xf3 0-0 16.�f2 �e5 17 .ic5 'ffb4+ 1 8.�gl lh0 1 9 .gx0 ?! �xO+) l l ...b5 1 2.'ffxb5+ c6 1 3.'ffa4 ixe4 14.c5 �a6 15 .a3 ( 1 5 .'ffxa6 'ffe5 1 6.l:�b l gd8) 15 ... 'ffe5 16.axb4 'ffxb2+ 1 7.id2 gd8 18.�0 0-0 19.'ffa3 (or 19 .. lb2 ixO+ 20.�x0 'fff6+ 2l .�g3 'ffg6+ 22.�h4 �4+ 23.f4 h5 24.h3 �xc5) 19 ...J.xfl+ 20.'i!nd3 'ffxd2 2 1 .ixa6 'f/d5+ 22.'i!i>g3 'ff g5+ 23.�0 'ffb5 + 24.�g3 'ff g6+ 25.� 0 gd4 and White's gamne is hopeless, Gutman; B) 8.c5 �xe4! ( 8...�c8 9.ie3 c6 hardly inspires confidence: 1 O.f4 V!Je7 1 1 .0-0-0 f6 1 2 .ic4 if7 1 3 .'ffb 3 ixc4 14.V!Jxc4 �d7 1 5.�a4 b5 16.cxb6 axb6 1 7.V!Jxc6 m,8 1 8.�0 �a7 19.'ffd5 �c5 20.ixc5 bxc5 2 l .�c3 'ff b7 22.'ffxb7, Mariotti Vecemik, Italy 1974, or I O.gd l !? 'ffc7 1 1 .�0 �d7 1 2.b4 a5 1 3 .a3 axb4 14.axb4 b6 1 5 .b5 ixc5 1 6.bxc6 �b8 1 7.�d5 V!Ja7 1 8.c7, F. Portisch - Brandicz, Hungary 1 990) 9.�xe4 'ffe7 1 O.id3 ixe4 ( 10 ... f5 ? l l .ig5 'ffe 6 1 2 .0-0-0) l l .ixe4 f5 1 2.ie3 ( 1 2.ig5 'ffxe4+ 13 .V!Jxe4 fxe4 1 4.gdl ?! , Mueller - Fischer, Germany 199 1 , 14 ... �c6) 1 2 ...'ffxe4 ( 1 2 ... fxe4?!
13 .0-0-0 yields White a pleasant posi tion, e.g. 1 3 ...V!Je6 14.�bl �c6 1 5 .�e2, Tseitlin/Giaskov, or 1 3 ... �a6 1 4.�e2 �xc5 1 5 .J.xc5 'ff xc5 16.�c3, Gutman) 13.'ffxe4+ fxe4 14.0-0-0 ( 14.a3 �d7 1 5.b4 b6 1 6.cxb6 axb6 17.id2 id6) 14 ...�d7 (14 ...�a6 1 5 .gd5) 1 5 .c6 ( 15 .b4 a5 1 6.a3 axb4 1 7.axb4 &4 1 8.id2 b6) 15 ... bxc6 16Jid4 �f6 17 .J.g5 �d5 1 8_gxe4+ �d7 1 9.�0 id6 with equality, Tartllkower, C) 8 .J.d3 �a6 (8 ...�c6, Hans Mueller, is met by 9.c5 �c8 I O.J.e3 V!Jd7 l l .a3 �8e7 12.0-0-0 0-0-0 1 3 .�0. while after 8...�d7 White has 9.�ge2 �c5 I O.�f4 or 9.J.e3 ie7 1 0.�0 0-0 1 1 .0-0, Cam pos - Holtz, corr 1978) 9.J.e3 c6 IO.'ffa4 (I O.a3 'ffa5 1 1 .().0-0 ltlc5 12.ltle2 ffi holds a balance) 10 ...�c8 1 1 ru1 �c5 12.ixc5 ixc5 13 .�e2 0.{) 14.0-0, Gutman; further D) 8.�0 �c6 9.ie3 (9.a3 ie7 1 O.J.e3 0-0 l l .c5 �e8 12.J.c4 'ffc8 1 3.h3 .tffi 14.�d5, Krueger - Schydlo, Gladenbach 1 999) 9...'ffe7 (9... f5 10.exf5 �xf5 l l .id3 �b4 12.'ffa4+ c6 1 3 .ixf5 AxiS 14.0-0) 10.�d5 'ffd7 1 1 �3 0-0-0 1 2.0-0..Q ge8 13 .�e l, Gutman; similarly E) 8.0 !?, Mueller, 8 ... �d7 9.ie3 ie7 I O.�h3 0-0 1 1 .0-0-0 secure a plus for White, Gutman. IV) 7 ... ixe4 8.�xe4 'ffe7 is a more en terprising choice, yet it seems to have a forced refutation.
39
White has two ways of meeting: A) 9-td3 ltlxe4 (Schlicht - Poetschmann, corr 1 978, went 9 ... f5 1 O.f3 fxe4 l l .fxe4 ltlc6 1 2.ltlf3 ltlf7 l 3 .i.d2 0-0-0 1 4.0-0-0 g5, when 1 5.e5g4 16.AB+ �b8 17 .i.xg4 might be strong, although I would prefer lO.i.g5 !? �e6 l l .�fl fxe4 1 2.liel �f7 l3.i.xe4 ltlxe4 141he4) IO.i.xe4 f5 l l .td2 ( l l .i.g5 �xe4+ 12.�xe4+ fxe4 13.0-0-0 ltlc6? 141le 1 is given by Tseitlin/GID6kov, yet l3 ... ltld7 leaves Black in control, e.g. 14.1lel ltlc5 15.'ik2 h6 16� g5 17 .i.g3 O.O.O,Harrlilg l , and if l4l!d4 ltlc5 15.c;bc2, then 1 5 ... �f7 1 6..if4 1e7 1 7.ltle2 .tf6 1 8.M5 ltld3 19.�7+ �e6 20.lixc7 rutc8 2 l .b3 b5, Andreakis - Glasewald, corr 1 988, or 15 ..1d6 1 6.ltle2 0.0) l l ...�xe4+ ( l l ...ltld7 12.0-0-0 fxe4 Bile l ltlffi 14.f3 0-0-0 1 5.fxe4 ltlg4, Harding, is insuffi cient due to 16.ltl0 �e6 17 ..mttl., Gutmlln. l l ...ltlc6 1 2.0-0-0 fxe4 l 3 . .!:ie l?! 0-0-0 14.�xe4, Tartlllwwer, allows Black def inite counterplay after 1 4 ...�c5 ! , Tseil lin/Gioskov, but White can improve with l3.1c3, e.g. l3.-�e6 141lel (}.{)..() 15.�xe4 or 1L�g5+ 14.�bl �xg2 1 5 .ltle2 .id6 1 6.c5, Gutman) 12.�xe4+ fxe4 l 3 .i.c3 1c5 14.i.xg7 .!:ig8 1 5.1e5 .!:ixg2 16 ..ig3 e3 1 7.�fl ext2 1 8 .ltlh3 .!:ig l + appears to be about equal, Tseitlin/Giaskov; B) 9. f3! f5 10 .1g5 ( l O.c5 llJ f7 l l ..ie3 isn't so forcing, l l ...fxe4 12 .�xe4 �xe4 l 3 .fxe4 ltld7 14Jkl 0-0-0 1 5 .ltlf3 ltlf6 1 6.1c4, Piscicelli - Fernandez, Buenos Aires 1994) 10 ...�e5 (lO ...�e6 l l .O-O-O fxe4 1 2.c5 �g6 l 3.�d2 ltlf7 can be met by 14.i.c4, Jensen, but also 14.�d8+!? ltlxd8 15 ...!:ixd8+ �f7 1 6.1c4+ is deci sive, Christensen - Pedersen, Aarhus 1 946) l l .�c3! (improving on 1 1 .0-0-0 fxe4 1 2J�d5 �e6 l 3 .fxe4 ltlc6 14.ltlf3 1e7 1 5 .c5 ltlf7, Lehman - Glasewald, corr 1 990, 1 6.i.d2!? 0-0 17 .1c4) l l ...�e6 1 2 .c5 saving thepinned piece with a win ning advantage, Harding.
Back to the main line
8..ld3!
Werner Biellermann, a German theore tician with some original ideas, found this neat solution in 1 941. Tartakower (Le Monde des Echecs, 1 946) and Sergiu Samarilln (Revista Romana de Sah, 1 947) agreed with his conclusions, Stefan Buecker, Kaissiber 1612001. 8.ltlxe4 1b4+ leaves Black satisfied: 1)9-td2 1xd2+ 10.�xd2 1xe4 l l .�xd8+ �xd8 1 2.0-0-0+ ltld 7! (better than 1 2... 11c8, Borik, when instead of 1 3.ltle2 lid8 14.�d8+ �xd8 1 5.ltlc3 1g6 16.g3 ltla6 17.f4 ltlc5 1 8.i.e2 c6 19.lidl + �c7 20.b4 ltle4, Alber - Trapl, Litomerice 1990, 13.ltlf3!? might be good for White, e.g. l3 ... f6 14.ltld4 ltlc6 15.ltle6 gg8 1 6.ltlc5 or l 3 ...1xf3 14.gxf3 g6 1 5 .h4 a5 16.h5 b6 1 7.hxg6 fxg6 1 8 .1d3 c5 19 .1xg6, Nielsen - Berg, Copenhagen 2000) 1 3.f3 (l 3.ltlf3 1xf3 14.gxf3 g6 1 5 .h4 c6 1 6.h5 �c7) l3 .. .i.f5 1 4.ltle2 ge8 15 .ltld4 1g6 16.g3 c6 1 7..ih3 lie7 1 8.f4 �7 (not 1 8 ... 1e4? 19 ..!:ihe l �c7 20.i.xd7, Raber Hoftnann, Muehlv 2000) 19.f5 1h5 20.g4 �3 2 l .gxh5 lhh3 22.mtel gd8 23.ge7 �c8 24..!:ixf7 ltle5, Gutman ; II) 9.�e2 ltlc6 1 0 .1e3 is a more dan gerous defence, which leaves White·s king in the centre. 40
B) 1 O...lLld4+! l l ..ixd4 �xd4 1 2.0 (Her
zog - Meizinger, Sulzfeld 1 99 1 , went 12 .�a4+? c6 13.�xb4 �xe4+ 1 4.�d2 0-0-0+ 1 5 ..id3 �xd3+ 0: 1 ) 12 ...0-0-0 13� 1 �e5 14.a3 ( 14.gd5 �d5 1 5.cxd5 gds 1 6.a3 Aa5!? 1 7 .b4 .ib6 1 8.g4 .ig6 1 9.
There are two replies: A) IO ...�e7 l l .f3 0-0-0 is, according to Minev. excellentfor Black. Up to now no body has shown the desire to doubt this opinion, Borik. However, it is difficult
8 �xtl ...
to find compensation after the natural 12J:!d l ! (Staker/Giasscoe/Stayart; less clear is 1 2 .�f2 - while 1 2.l0d6+? gxd6 1 3 .�xf3+ ge6 1 4.�f2 g6 1 5.�h3 J.c5 16 ..ixc5 �xc5+ 1 7.�g3 h 5 ! or 12.a3? gd2+ l3 ..ixd2 lLld4+ 14.�f2 l0xc2 are both losing Borik - 1 2 .. .mte8 1 3..id3 13.lLld6+ gxd6 14.�xf5+ �b8 1 5 .ti'f4 gd4! -, 1 3 ....ig6 14.a3 ! ? - 14.g4? l0e5 1 5 .gd l gxd3 ! 16.gxd3 .ixe4 17.fxe4
There is nothing better.
,
.
9..lxfS
According to Volker Hergert, 9.�e2+!? .ie7 (9. . .�e7 IO.�f2) 10 ..ixf3 may well be more potent, lO lLlxh l l l .igS (l l .o!MS c6 1 2.lLlxe7 �xe7 13.�xe7+ �e7 14J.e3 � 1 5 .�d2 lLla6 1 6.lLlh3 &d8+ 1 7J.d3 b6 1 8 .a3 lLlg3 1 9 .hxg3 comes into con sideration) l l . . . �d6 ( l l ...c6? 1 2 .gdl �c7 n .gd7 or l l ...f6? 1 2 .gdl �xd l + 13.�xdl fxg5 1 4 ..ic8, Hergert. l l . . .h6 is also hopeless, 121ldl - not 12..ixe7?! �xe7 1 3 .�xe7+ �xe7 14.l0d5+ �d6 1 5 .gdl , Janosi - Hunerfauth, corr 1990, •.
Gutman ;
41
due to 1 5 ... c6! 1 6.ltlb6+ �e5 17.ltlxa8 �xf5 1 8.ltlf3 ltla6 -, 12 .. .hxg5 13 1bld8+ �xd8, and now instead of 14.ltld5 E:e8 1 5 .�fl .ib4 16.'lbe8+ �xe8 17.ltlxc7+ �d8 18.ltlxa8 id6 19.g3 ltlxg3+, Mont roig - Tinture, corr 1 997, 14.'�'d3+!? �e8 15.ltld5 should be played) is crucial.
D) 1 O�d2 ic5 (there is nothing in 10 ... Y!Jh4+ l l .g3 Y!Jxc4 - l l ...ltlxg3 1 2 .hxg3 Y!Jxg3+ 13.� ltlc6 14l!e 1 + ie7 15.ltld5 E:d8 16..lf4 Y!Jh4 1 7.ltlf3 Y!/h5 18.�g2 -, 12.0-0-0, for example 1 2...ltlf2 131ie 1+ ie7 14..lf4 g6 15�g5 ltlc6 16.Y!Jxf2 gxf5 1 7.Y!Jxf5 or 12 ...ltlc6 13l!el+ie7 14.ltlh3 g6 1 5 �d3 Y!Jg4 1 6.ltld5 Y!Jxh3 and now 17.ltlxe7 ltlxe7 1 8.E:xe7+ �xe7 19.Y!/c5+ �d7 20.Y!Jd4+ improving on 1 7 ..ib5 0-0 18..ixc6id8 19.ltlf4 Y!/xh2, Pantaltoni David, Lugano 1 988) 1 1 .0-0-0 ltlc6 ! ? 12liel + �Ill with COIDlterplay, Gutman; III) l O .Y!Je2+ .ie7 ( I O ...Y!Je7 is met by I I �c8 Y!Jxe2+ 12 .ltlgxe2 ltld7 13 ..ixb7 E:b8 14� ffi>6 1 5.hd7+ �d7 16�3) returning to the position after 9.Y!/e2+ ie7 I O.ixf5 ltlxh l . I O... �c:6!?
12.ltld5 ( 12�1 Y!Jc5? l3.Y!Jxe7+ Y!Jxe7+ 14..ixe7 �xe7 1 5.ltld5+, Hergert, but IL ltlg3 ! l3 .Y!Jxe7+ Y!Jxe7+ 14 ..ixe7 ltlxf5 1 5.E:d8+ �xe7 1 6.!Wt8 c6 might be OK for Black) 1 2...ltlc6 l3�f4 Y!Jc5 14.040 0-0 1 5 ..ie3 ( l 5 .ltlh3 E:ad8 1 6.b4 ltlxb4 17.ltlxe7+ �h8 1 8.E:xhl E:fe8) 15 ...Y!Jd6 16.ltlf3 E:fe8 17 .a3 (if 17M 1, then 17 ... ltlb4 18.ltl xb4 Y!Jxb4) 17 ... g6 18 ..id7 !? Y!Jxd7 1 9.ltlf6+ .ixf6 20J�xd7 E:e6 with some plus for White, Gutman. 9... �xh l 9 .. �5 1 0.ltlf3 ltlxhl ( I O... ltlc6? 1 1 .0-0, Tartllkower) - see 9_. ltlxhl 10.ltlf3 ic5.
This is definitely the lesser evil. Other moves tend to run into trouble: I) 1 O ...ic5 was tried first.
10.�13
White has a choice of shots: A) 1 1 �xh7 ltld7 ( l l ... ltlf2 is premature due to 12J.gs Y!Jd6 1 3.ltle4, e.g. J3_ltJxe4 14.Y!Jxe4+ Y!/e6 1 5 .0-0-0 ltlc6 1 6.Y!Jxe6+ fxe6 17.ig6+ � 1 8�7 &8 19h4 ie7 20.h5 or 13 ...Y!Jb6 14.ltlxc5 Y!Jxc5, Tum bev - Filippov, Teteven 1 99 1 , 1 5 .b4! Y!Jxb4+ 16.�xf2 ltlc6 1 7.E:el+) 1 2 .�fl ltlf6 1 3 �g5 c6 1 4.E:e l + �Ill looks fme for Black, Gutman;
A ltematively: I) 1 O�f4 .ic5 ( IO .. �b4?! l l .�fl hc3 12.bxc3 ltlc6 13 .ltlf3) l l .ltlh3 ( l l .Y!Je2+ �fll l 2.ltlh3 ltlc6) 1 1 .. .0-0! ? ( l l ...ltlc6 1 2 .E:dl Y!Je7+ l 3.'�fl ltld4 14.Y!/a4+ b5 1 5.cxb5 ltlxf5 1 6.ltld5 Y!Jh4 1 7.Y!/e4+ Will 1 8 .Y!/xf5 ltlf2 1 9 .ltlg5 was winning for White, Kulejewski - Dubal, corr 1 992) 12�xh7+ �h8 13� ltlc6 14lidl ltld4, Harding; further '4 2
B) I I.J.g5 !? f6 1 2 .� 1 Y!le7+ ( 1 2 . . .�d6 1 3.�e3 g6 14.c5) 13.Wfl � ( 1 3 ... Wf8 14.�d5 Y!lf7 1 5 .�xf6) 14 .�xh7+ 'i!?h8 1 5 .�d5 and Black gets blasted off the board, Ernst - Winkler, Bad Ragaz 1 994; C) I l .�e4!? Y!le7 (it is hard to suggest anything better, we see: I I .. id4 12 if4 c5 13.0-0-0 Y!la5 14.�xd4 cxd4 1 5.�f6+ I :0 Walter - Lidl, corr 1958; I I ...�b6 should be met by 1 2.J.d2 ! �6 13.0-0-0 �hile 12.J.g5 f6 1 3.�xf6+ gxf6 14� 1s wrong, not due to 1 4 ... wm 1 5.J.h6+ Wg8 16.Y!Ie4 Y!ld7 1 7.�f5. Ludek Pllch mlln, but in view of l 4 ...hxg6 1 5 .Y!Ixg6+ Will 1 6.J.xf6 Y!le8+, Gutm11n; I I .J.b4+ 1 2.We2 !? h6 1 3 .�e3 � 14J:txh l l::t e8 1 5 .Wf2 Y!le7 1 6.a3! - an improvement on 1 6.�d2 hd2 1 7.Y!Jxd2 �c6 1 8.l::te l � 8 19.Y!Ie3 �e5 20.�g3 �c6 2 I .Y!Ixe7 l::txe7 22.l::tx e7 �xe7 23 .J.e4 g6 24.b3 c6 25 .We2 f5 26.�c2 Wg7 Yl-Yl MoJo Angulo, corr 1 992 -, 1 6 ...�d6 1 7.l::td I �c6 18.c5 �e5 19.�7, LIIIic) 1 2.J.g5 f6 (after 1 2 ...�b4+ White has 13 .We2 f6 14 ie3, Reuben Fine, or 1 3.W f6 14.a3 fxg5 1 5.axb4 �c6 1 6Ee l ) 1 3 .0-0-0 �a6 ( 1 3 ... fxg5 14.�xc5 Y!Jxc5 1 5 .Y!Ie4+ Y!le7 16.Y!Ixb7 � 17 .Y!Ixa8 �f2 18.Y!Id5+ 'i!?h8 1 9.l::te l with advantage to White, Borik, but 15.l::te I+! is even stronger, e.g. l 5 ... 'i!?d8 16.Y!Id3+ Y!Jd6 17.�xg5 or I5 ...'i!?m 1 6.�xg5 Y!lf2 1 7.�e6+ ..tf7 18.Y!Ic3 Y!Jxg2 1 9 .J.h3 ! , HUdebrllnd/Berkell) 14.l::td7 - White is temporarily the exchange and
II) I 0 ... g6 was suggested by Borik.
White has a wide range of options: A) I I .Y!Je4+? �e7 1 2 .�h3 0-0, Borik; B) I I .itn? �6 12.a3 Y!Je7+ 13 .Y!Ie2 ()..0.0 14.Y!Ixe7 �xe7 1 5 .�e2 l::th e8, Borik; C) I I .J.e4 c6 12 .J.g5 (better than 12 .J.e3 f5 1 3 .J.d3 Y!le7, e.g. 14.Wfl �a6 15.J.d4 �b4 1 6.Y!Id2 0-0-0 0:1 Cano - Larsen corr 1990, or 14.Y!Ie2 �a6 1 5 .0-0-0 0-0-0 161Wl I �b4 17.J.bl �g7 18.J.g5 Y!Jxe2 19.�xe2 l::tde8 20.�ed4 c5 2 l .�b5 l::te2 22.J.d2 � 23.�xa7+ Wb8 24.�b5 lhg2 25.J.f4+ WaS, Borik) 1 2 .J.e7 1 3 ixe7 Y!lxe7 14.0..Q..O � 15.fuhl f5 16.J.d3 �a6 17.&1 Y!ld6 1 8.Y!Jd2 �8 19.J.bl Y!Jxd2+ (19...Y!Ic5?! 20.Y!Ih6 Y!Jxc4? 2 1 .�e5 Y!le6 22.J.d3 b5 23.J.c2 �b4 24.�b3, Dyer Gibson, corr 1988) 20.�xd2 l::tfe8 and Black maintains the balance Gutman· D) I I .Y!Ie2+!? (J. Erb, a read�r ofBorik's book) I I . ..Y!Je7 ( I I ...J.e7 12 .�d5 gxf5 13.�ffi+'i!nR 14.ih6 mate) 12.ic8 Y!Jxe2+ 13 .Wxe2 �d7 14.J.xb7 l::tb8 (with coun terp/ay, H��rding) 1 5 ic6 �d6 1 6.b3 Wd8 1 7 .J.xd7 Wxd7 1 8.J.e3, Gutman; further E) 1 1 .�3 !? �c5 ( l l . . .�c6 1 2 ..�g5 f6 13Edl Y!le7+, H��rding, can be answered by 1 4.Wfl fxg5 1 5 .l::te l Y!lxel+ 1 6.Wxel �e7 17.wfl � I S.'i!?gl) I 2.ig5! (1 2.�e4 � 13ig5 �e7 14.l::td l , Winkler - Burk corr 19 87, 14 ...Y!Ie8 ! 1 5.�h6 f5) 12 ...£6 13.Y!Ie4+ Y!le7 (or 13 ...'t!lt7 14.�e5+ Wg7
•
•
apawn down and his bishop is hanging, but his entire army is ideally placed for attack, Borik - , 14 ...Y!Im (Kottnauer
Martin, Zurich 1 946, continued 14 ...Y!Jxd7 15ixd7+ �d7 1 6.�xc5+ �xc5 17.Y!If5+ li"dJ 18.� !lae8 19.Y!Id5+ Wc8 20.�xe6 fxg5 21 .�c5 l3el+ 22.� mte8 23.Y!Ixb7+ Wd8 24.Y!Ib8+
1 5.ih6+) 14.i.xffi t'/xe4+ 1 5 .il:lxe4 with a clear advantage for White, Gutman; F) I l lLg5! �7 ( l l ...f6 1 2..ixg6+ hxg6 13.t'/xg6+ �d7 I4..ixffi) 12.M I (but not 12 .i.xe7? t'/xe7, Borik) and Black is to tally lost, e.g. 12 ... gxf5 1 3.!!xd8+ �xd8 14.he7+ �xe7 15.t'/xf5 il:lc6 1 6.il:ld5+ �fB 17.'itm &8 1 8.l0g5 il:le5 1 9.t'/f6 I :0 Debailleul - Tinture, corr 1 99 1 ; 12 ...l0c6 1 3 J!xd8+ !!xd8 14..ie4 l0d4 1 5 .l0xd4 .ixg5 16.l0f3 .ie3 17.l0d5 .if2+ I S .�fl 0-0 19.il:lf6+ �h8 20.t'/c3 I :0 Hug - Ca sale, corr 1 995; or 12 ...t'/xdl + 13.l0xdl gxf5 14.t'/xf5 l0c6 1 5.l0e5 l0xe5 16.t'/xe5 0-0-0 17.i.xe7 IDleS I S.M !!d7 19.il:lf5 and wins, Gonda - Holms, corr 1 99 1 . The idea of 1 O... g6 was surely not the best one, Borik, 1 98 7. III) I O ... .id6 also has its drawbacks.
8) I I ..ig5 !? f6 1 2.0-0-0 (is more pro mising than 12..ie3 g6 1 3 .ie4 c6 14.0-0-0 �e7 1 5 .!!xh l ) 12 ...fxg5 1 3 ..ixh 7! (on 13.�e4+ �e7 1 4.t'/xb7 Black can play 14 ...0-0 1 5 .�xa8 g4 1 6..ixg4 il:lf2) 1 3 ... liJd7 14.lL!d5 gives White a thumping attack, Gutman; C) I I .lL!e4 !? .ixh2 ( l l ... h6 would be a waste oftime due to 12.id2 0-0 13.0-0-0, although 12.lL!xd6+t'/xd6 1 3..ie3 is good enough, e.g. 13 ... lL!g3 1 4.hxg3 �xg3+, Hansen - Lo Conte, corr 1992, 15.�f1 0-0 16 ..ih7+ �h8 17.�f5. or 1 3 ...0-0 !? 14ikll �e7 15.�2 !:le8 16.�c3 g6 1 7.ic2 f5 1 8 .g3, Lo Conte) with a further split: Cl) 12.lL!xh2 �4+ 1 3 .g3 il:lxg3 looks quite cheeky.
Now: Cia) 14.il:lxg3 �xg3+ 1 5.�fl il:lc6 1 6.a4
For convenience the variations are pre sented by: A) l l .�e4+ �e7 12 ..ie3 (1 2..ic8 lL!d7 I3..ixd7+ 'i!?xd7 I4.�xe7+.ixe7 15.<Ml .id6 1 6.�gl il:lg3 I7.hxg3 .ixg3 18 .il:le4 .id6 I9.c5, Tseitlin/Giaskov, I9 ... !!he8 20.cxd6 !!xe4 2 l .dxc7 f6 pose no prob lems for Black) 1 2...�xe4 I 3 ..ixe4 lL!d7 ( 1 3 ... lL!c6 I 4 ..ixc6+ bxc6 1 5 .�e2 0-0 I 6 .. !!xhl !!fe8 1 7.�. Markus - Back, corr 1995) I4.0-0-0 .ic5 1 5.hc5 lL!xc5 16.!!xhl l0xe4 I 7.lL!xe4 favours White,
(Ventilescu - Fontana, corr 1948/49, went 16.�e4+ �e5 17 ..if4 �xe4 1 8.i.xe4 liJd4 19 ..ixc7 �k8 20..ie5 lL!e6 2 I ..ixb7 !!xc4 22 . .id5 !!c5 23.!!d l il:lc7 24.!!e l , but Black can improve with 1 8 ...0-0-0! 19.lL!f3 !!he8, Arduini - Lotti, corr 1986) 16 . . . �fB ! ? (Less advisable is 1 6 ... lL!e7 17i!a.3 �d6, when instead of l 8.!!d3 �ffi 19lU3 lL!xfS 20.!!xf5 � e6 2I ..if4 0-0-0, H��rding, I 8.!!e3 ! 'i!lfB I 9.ie4 c6 20.lL!f3 �g8 2 I .!!d3 �c7 22.�dl !!e8 23.!!d7 �c8 24.�d6 might be more effective. 16 ...g6 17.&3 �4 1 8.!!e3+ is also quite
Gutman; 44
promising for White, for example 1 8 ... li:Je7 1 9.�c3 �g8 20.IDI3 li:JxfS 2 1 ltxh4, Lotti - Nicolosi, corr 1 986, or 1 8 .. . 'it?tB 1 9h4 �ffi 20..ih6+ 'it?g8 21 .li:Jg4 �xfS+ 22.�f4) 1 7.�a3 �4 1 8 .�h3 �d8 19 .b3 li:Jb4 20ia3 aS 2 1 .�d3, Lotti - Biraghi, corr 1986, 21 ...�ffi holds together nicely for Black, Gutman; C1b) 1 4.i.gS ! offers more chances, 14 ... �S I S .�d3 ( I S .li:Jg4 ! ? �I+ 1 6.'it?f2 may well be even stronger, viz. 16...�xal 17.li:Jxg3 li:Jc6 1 8.li:JhS h6 1 9.li:Jxg7+ 'it?tB 20.�c3! hxgS 2 1 .li:Je6+ or 1 6 ... li:Jxe4+ 17be4 �xal 1 8.�e2 0-0 1 9.li:Jffi+ 'it?h8 20.�S �xb2+ 2 1 . 'it7f3 h6 22 ..bh6 I :0 Hergert - von Leoprechting, Germany 1 99 1 ) I S ... O-O ( I S .. .f6 1 6.li:Jxf6+ gxffi 1 7.�e3+) 1 6.�xg3 and White is on the road to victory, Hergert. Cl) 1 2..igS is thematic, 1 2 .. .f6 13..ie3! (13.li:Jxffi+ gxffi 14..ig6+ hxg6 IS.�xg6+ r;!;>tB 16J.h6+ 'it?e7 1 7.�g7+ c;!;te6 1 8.�g4+ is only a perpetual. 1 3 . .ih4 .if4 1 4 .g3 gave White a winning position after 14 ... .ih6?! I S .g4 �e7 1 6.'it?fl li:Jc6 1 7.�e l , Stringa - Hucks, corr 1998, but 1 4... li:Jxg3 I S ..ixg3 .ixg3+ 1 6 .li:Jxg3 �d6 is less clear) 13 ...li:Jg3 14_gdl �e7 I SicS �f7 1 6.�d3 I :0 Gonzales Valdes - Layola Gayobart, corr 1 99S.
1 Ufel+!? l l.li:JdS � (I L.te7 12.if4 li:Jb4 13.�a4+ bS 14.�xbS+ c6 1 S .�a4 li:JxdS 1 6.�xc6+ 'it?f8, Matula - Riessbeck, corr 1 990, is hopeless for Black after 1 7.cxdS) 12..igS (1 2.�e4+ can be met by 12 ... li:Je7 1 3 ..igS c6 1 4 .li:Jxe7 .ixe7 I S .'it?e2 g6 1 6.�xe7+ �xe7 17..he7'it?xe7 18.id3 li:Jg3+ 1 9.hxg3 hS) 1 2 .. f6 1 3 ..ie3 li:Je7 1 4.0-0-0 li:JxfS ! ? IS.�xfS �d7 1 6.�xd7+ (or 1 6.�e4+ 'it?f7 17 ..fuhl c6 1 8.li:Jc3 !b4 1 9_gdl �e6) 16 ... 'it?xd7 1 7.�xh l c6 1 8.li:Jc3 1eaves White with a small plus, Gutman. l l .. .i.e7 If l l ...�e7, then l 2.li:JbS �xe2+ 13.m.e2 � 1 4.li:Jxd6+ cxd6 IS..ie3 is very prom ising, Gutman. 12-'.dl g6 13-'.hJ!? After 13..ic2 �d7 14.0-0-0 0-0-0 I S.�xh I �he8 1 6.�dl White keeps an edge since two minor pieces should outweigh rook and pawn; nevertheless Black has managed to occupy two central files with his rooks and can live with it, Gutman. 13 ... ltl b4 1 4.i.h6 1fd3 14 ... li:Jd3+ I S .'it?fl li:Jhf2 loses to 1 6.�dS. 1SJ!d1 t!h:el+ 16.Wxel t5 If 16 .. ..if6, then 1 7 .�xh I . 17.a3 ltlc6 1Uh:h1 0�0 19./()dS
Back to the main line
White has the better chances, Gutman.
4S
Chapter 3 (l.d4 �f6 2.c 4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.8'c2) 4....ib4+!
7 ...Y!Ie7 Other possibilities: I) 7 ...0-0 8.e3 ge8 9 ..id3 g6 10.0-0-0! (10.0-0 lLlxeS ll.lLlxeS �eS 12.lLlf3 �8 l3.gfdl ifB 14.&cl d6 1S.h3 .ig7 16.b4 b6 17.cS bxcS 18.bxcS �8 19.cxd6 cxd6, van den Berg - Schuit, Accom 1986) lO ...lLlxeS l l.lLlxeS gxeS l2.lLlf3 ge8 l3.h4 favours W hite, Gutman; II) 7 ...ixd2+ 8.�xd2 �e7, then: A) 9.0-0-0 reaches a position after 4.� dS .ib4+ S.id2 lLlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 7.lLlf3 �e7 8.0-0-0 .ixd2+ 9.�xd2, treated in Part 1, Chapter 6, Section 2; 8)9.e3 lLlxeS lO.lLlxeS (10b2 � 11.0-0 transposes to 4.�c2 .ib4+ S..id2 lLlxd2 6.lLlxd2 lLlc6 7.lLlgf3 �e7 8.e3 lLlxeS 9. ie2 0-0 10.0-0 ixd2 ll.�xd2) lO...�xeS ll.td3 d6 (ll ...b6 12.0-0 .ib7 is worth consideration. Also 11...0-0 12.0-0 d6 13.f4 �e7 is playable, e.g. 14.�el id7 lS. !ID ic6 16.e4 gfe8 or l4.f5 ffi lS.gf4 id7 16.ie4 ic6 1 7 ..idS+ �h8 18.ge4 � d8 19.& 1 �8. Blatt - Popp, corr 2000. Less appealingis ll ...aS 12.0-0 �6 13.f4 �cS 14.�f2 gd6 lS.�dl b6 16.e4 gd4 17.eS �f4 18.�xc5 �fl+ 19.ixfl bxcS 20� with advantage, Bielicki - Euler, Germany 2001) 12.0-0 Af5 l3.e4 ( l3.f4 �ffi 14.e4 �d4+ 1Sm2id7 16.&1 0-0-0) l3.. b614.b3 0-0 lS.�hl f5 16.f4 �d4, Weiz- Au� oorr 1991; further
This move guarantees Black a sufficient initiative, Bogdan Lalic. All authorities agree that Black's pros pects of an equal game are quite good,
Tim Harding.
The material divides as follows: Section 1 - S.id2 Section 2 - S.lLld2 Section 3 - S. lLlc3. Section 1 S..id2 �xd2 6.�xd2 �c6 7.�0 Alternatives: I) 7.f4 d6! 8.exd6 �xd6 9.g3 (9.e3? if5 10.e4 � 11.0-� �xf4) 9.. ..115 1 O.�xf5 �xd2+,NielsJensen, ll.'it>t20-0 12-'!bl �d4+ l3.e3 (l3.�g2 �xc4) 13... �d2+ 14.ie2 �Ue8 1S.�d3 gadS with a clear plus for Black, Gutman; ll) 7.a3ixd2+ (if 7 ...icS, then not 8.b4? tx.f2+, Vuorikoski- Kalteinen, Helsinki 1988, but 8.lLlgf3 �e7 9.�c3 aS 1 O.e3 0-0 l l.lLlb3 ge8 12.lLlxcS �xeS l3.gdl lLlxeS 14_gd5li)xf3+ lS.gxfl �e7 16.h4) 8.�xd2 lLlxeS leads to equality, Gutman. 46
C) 9.g3 ltlxe5 (9 ...b6 I O..lg2 ib7 1 1 .0-0 gives White the upper hand, e.g. l l ...ltlxe5 12.ltlxe5 ixg2 13 .ltlxf7 ixfl 14.ltlxhS ixe2 I S.l;!el 0-0-0 1 61!.xe2 \!!!ffB 1 7.\!!!fdS c6 1 S.\!!!ff7 "t!fxhS 19J!e7 g6 20. \!!!fg7, 1 1 ...0-0 1 2.l:Udl �d8 13.\!!!fc3 l:UeS 14.� itS ISi!c l ltlxe5 16.ltlxe5 "t!fxe5 17 .c5 or I I ...0-0-0, when both 12J!ac I ltlxe5 13.ltlxe5ixg2 14.�g2 "t!fxeS 1 5.c5 IDleS, Erkay - Zimmermann, Germany 1996, 16.e3 l;!e6 17 .b4, and 12.a4!? ltlxe5 13.ltlxe5 ixg2 14.xg2\!!!fxe5 15.a5 'itb7 1 6.axb6 axb6 1 7 J!a4 are awkward for Black) I O.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 l l .ig2 ().() 12.0.0 (12.0-0-0 reaches a position after 4.\!!!fdS ib4+ 5..ld2 ltlxd2 6.ltlxd2 ltlc6 7.ltl0 \!!!fe7 S.().().() txd2+ 9.\!!!fxd2 ltlxe5 I O.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 l l .g3 0-0 12..lg2 - Part I , Chap ter 6, Section 2) 12 ... d6 13.e3 l::!eS ( 1 3 ... l::!bS 1 4.b3 id7 1 5 ."t!fd4 "t!fxd4 16.exd4 l::!feS 17.l::! fel b6 is not bad either, Ong Chow, Pert 1997) 14.b3 aS (another pos sibility is 14...l::!bS IS _gacl !5 16.l::!fe l ie4 1 7."t!fd4 .ixg2 I S.'itxg2, Martin Gensbauer, Bad Wiessee 1 997, I S ...b6) I S .�cl "t!icS is fully adequate, Gutman; D) 9.\!!!f c 3, and now: Dl) 9...b6 1 0.e3 ib7 l l ..le2 (Stuhler Schaffranietz, Germany 1 996, contin ued l l ..ld3 0-0-0 1 2.0-0-0 l::! heS 13 ..le4 g6 14.l::!h el 5 I S.idS, when 1 5 ...ltlxe5 could have been played) I I ...().().() 1 2.0.0 (12.0-0-0 �e8 1 3.�gl li:lxe5 14.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 1 5 .\!!!fxeS fu.e5, Warisch - Schaf franietz, Germany 200 1 ) 12...mte8 (12 ... gS?! 13.a4 aS 14.c5 \!!!fxc5 15.\!!!fxcS bxc5 1 6.&£1 g4 17.ltld2) 13.l::!fcl ( 13.a4 ltlxe5 14.ltlel aS 15.&1 d6) 13 ...ltlxe5 14.ltlxe5 ( 14.lUel c5) 14 ...\!!!fxeS 1 5 .\!!!fxeS l::! xe5 1 6.b4 5 turned out quite well for Black in Paakkonen - Peltomaa, Finland 1997; 02) 9 ...0-0 IO.e3 (other moves: I O.l::! d l l::! e S l l .l::!d5 ltlb4 1 2.l::! b5 c5 1 3.a3 ltlc6 14.e3 ltlxe5 15.ltlxe5 "t!fxeS 16.\!!!fxeS fu.e5, Prosch - Kurth, Hamburg 1997; I 0.0-0-0
l::!eS, and now instead of II ru5 b6 1 2.e3 ltlb4 13.'itbl ltlxd5 14.cxd5 d6 1 5 .exd6 !5+ 1 6..ld3 !xd3+ 1 7.\!!!fxd3 "t!fxd6!?, Jasincyuk - Tamplin, Hunstville 1 993, l l .e3 ltlxe5 12.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 13.\!!!fxeS fu.e5 14.l::!d5 d6 would have been more solid; IO.g3 l::!eS l l ..lg2 ltlxe5 12.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 13.\!!!fxeS l::! xe5 1 4.e3 d6 1 5 .0-0-0 l::!a 5!? 16.a3 l::!bS 17.l;d5 �4 I S.l::!d 4.ie6 with equal chances, Ariela - Brause, compu ter game 1 997) I O...l::!eS l l ..le2 (l l ..ld3 ltlxe5 12.ltlxe5 "t!fxeS 1 3 .\!!!fxeS fu.e5 gave Black a clear advantage after 14.0-0-0 d6 15•1 a5 16.f4 l;c5 17.M2 b5 1S.l::!c2 b4 1 9.e4 ffi 20.5 ib7 21 .g4 l::!e8, Pomar De Augustin, Madrid 1943) I I ...ltlxe5 12.c5 (or 12.ltlxe5 \!!!fxe5 13.\!!!fxeS l::! xe5 14.!0 d6 15.b3 l::!bS, Horvath - Graf, Vienna 1 999) 1 2 ...d5!? 13.cxd6 "t!fxd6 14.l::! dl ltlx0+ I S ..lxO 'Wb6 1 6.0-0 ie6 and Black is not worse, W issemann Jaeck, Germany 1999.
8.e3
There are three more replies: I) S.g3 ltlxe5 9.ltlxe5 (9.ig2 lUxO+!? IO..lxO 0-0 1 1 .0-0 aS) 9...\!!!fxeS I O..lg2 ( 1 0.0-0-0 0-0 I I .ltlO \!!!ff6, improving on 1 1 ...\!!!faS?! 1 2.'itb I b5 13 .cxb5 l::! bS 14.e3 .ib7 15.ltlg5!? g6 16.e4 a6, Joro nen - Nieminen, corr 1 97 1 , 1 7 ..ic4!?) I 0...0-0 I l .e3 d6 12.0-0 !5 13 .e4 ig6 is fine for Black, Gutman; 47
II) 8.0-0-0 ll:\xeS 9.ll:\xeS ixd2+ (less precise is 9. ..\!!fxeS IO.ll:\f3 \!!fffi l l.e3 0-0, Pitule - Holl, corr 1 99 1 , due to 12.id3 h6 l3.h4 d6 14.ll:\gS) IO.l!!fxd2 (IOJ�xd2 \!!!xeS l l.e3 d6 12.id3 ie6 13.ie4 0-0-0) 1 0 ...\!!lxeS reaches a position after 4.\!!ldS .ib4+ S.id2 ll:lxd2 6.foxd2 !Oc6 7.!0gf3 l!!fe7 8.0-0-0 ixd2+ 9.\!!fxd2 \!!! xeS, co vered in Part 1 , Chapter 6, Section 2; Ill) After 8.a3 ixd2+ 9.\!!fxd2 White has a tempo less, compared to variations with 4.ll:\f3 ib4+ S.id2 ll:lxd2 6.ll:lxd2 !Oc6 7.a3 ixd2+ 8.\!!f x1d2 l!!f e7, treated "l. in Part 4, Chapter 3. ! T { rr There are two good answers: A) 9 ... b6 IO.l!!fc3 (if 1 O.e3, then not im mediately lO ... ll:\xeS in view of 1 1 .\!!fdS ll:\xf3+ I2.gxf3 gbs n.ggl .ib7 14.\!!fd4 f6 1 S _gg3 0-0 1 6.0-0-0 d6 1 7 .id3 but I O...ib7 l l.ie2 ll:\xeS 12.ll:\xeS \!!! xeS 13.0.0 and now 13 ...\!!lgS 14.f3 d6 IS.nfdl fS 16.\!!fc3 0-0, while 13...0-0-0 14.gfdl mte8 IS.l!!fd4 l!!lgS 16.\!!lg4 l!!lxg4 17 .ixg4 � 1 8 .ie2 fS 19 .nac 1 ges was equal in Henrichsen - Burgess, Lungby 1 99 1 ) I O. ..ib7 l l .e3 0-0-0 12.0-0-0 (l2.ie2 gS 13 .0-0 g4 14.!0d4 ll:\xeS gives Black the initiative, for example IS.a4 ghg8 16.aS \!!lh4 1 7.axb6 \!!lh3 18.e4 l!!lxc3 19.bxc3 axb6 or 1 S.b4 ghg8 16.cS 'it>b8 17 _gac 1 gcs I S.bS gg6 19.a4 ll:\f3+ 20.ixf3 gxf3 2 l .g3 .ie4!? 22.'it>hl gh6 23 .gfdl l!!f gS 24.\!!le l l!!l xg3 2S.l!!lg l \!!lh4 0: 1 Berend sen - Wittelsberger, Porz 1989) 12 ..Jide8 (Black could also consider 1 2...gS 1 3 .h3, when instead of l 3 ...hS?! 14 .ie2 gh6 I S .nd2 ge6 16.ggl 'it>b8 1 7 .ll:\d4 gxeS IS.ixhS fS 19_ggd 1 d6 20.if3 !OaS 2 l .b4 .ixf3 22.ll:\xf3 ll:\xc4 23.\!!lxc4, Becker W ittelsberger, Kettig 1 994, 1 3 ... ghe8 141ld5 ll:lb8 1 S .� ll:\c6mightbe even) 1 3 .\!!fd3 ( l3.gds ll:\d8!) 1 3 ...\!!fe6 14.ie2 (l4.ll:\gS ll:\xeS IS.ll:\xe6 ll:\xd3+ 16.ixd3 gxe6 1 7 ..ifS ge7) 14 ... &7 appears to be satisfactory for Black, Gutman; •.
8)9 ...ll:lxeS lO.ll:\xeS \!!IxeS l l .e3 (l l .g3 0-0 12.ig2 ges 1 3 .e3 d6 14.0-0 ifS IS. gfdl ie4 16.he4 l!!lxe4, though l 3..1lb8 14.0.0 bS 1 S.cxbS fubS 16.b4, Rzeszoto Gutdeutsch, Stary Smokovec 1996, 16 ... c6 17kl aS is also OK for Black) I I... d6 ( ll ...aS is seen quite often, e.g. l l\!!!d4 d6 1 3 .id3 id7 14.f4 l!!fe7 I S.'it>d2 0-0 16.\!!le4 \!!lh4 1 7.\!!f f3 ic6 18.\!!lg3 \!!f f6 19.gab 1 dS, Stumberger - Vospemik, Nova Gorica 1 996, or 1 2.ie2 0-0 13.0-0 a4 14.\!!ld4 ge8, although n_.na6 14.\!!ld4 l!!lxd4 1 S .exd4 gb6 1 6.&b 1 ges 1 7.id3 'itlfll l S.cS gft) was perfectly playable for Black, Stauch - Polzer, Germany 1 998) 12.\!!ld4 (12.id3 0-0 13.\!!lc2 fS 14.0-0-0 id7 IS .h3 gabS 1 6.g4 bS l7.ghg l 'it>h8 18.gxf5 bxc4 19.ie4 .h4 was a disaster for White, Bellm - Sauer, Leimen 2001 . After 12.ie2 0-0 1 3 .0-0 Black can play l 3 ...if5, e.g. l 4.gfd l ie4 I S .l!!fd4 gae8 16.gacl l!!lgS! ? 1 7.ifl b6 18.b4 ge6 or 14.&dl .b4 IS.l!!fd4 gae8 16.\!!lxeS gxeS 17.0 ic6 1 8.e4 fS, Sipka - Eberth, Fel sotarkany 1988; but l 3 ...aS 14.!0 ie6 is also reasonable, for example I S.ixb7 gabS 1 6.f4 \!!ff6 17 .idS gxb2 18.\!!lxaS cS 19.&dl gfbs or IS.&c l gabS 16.b4 axb4 1 7.axb4 b6 1 8 .gc3 gfd8 1 9.\!!fd4 cS 20.\!!lxeS dxeS, Wagner - Dujardin, Nuenen 2002) 1 2 ...b6 (more ambitious than 12 ....if5 1 3 .\!!l xeS+ dxeS 14.0-0-0 'i!;>e7 ISJ.d3 ixd3 16�d3 mx!S, Angel Computer, computer game 1996) l3.id3 ( l 3 .ie2 ib7 14.0-0 cS l S .l!!fxeS+ dxeS 161Wil 1le7 or l 3.f3 .ib7 14.\!!lxeS+dxeS IS.0-0-0 1le7 16-'e2 fS, van der Velde Elieff, London 1 993, are both preferable for Black) l 3 ....ib7 14.0-0 cS (14... 0-0 lS.l!!lxeS dxeS 1 6.gfdl cS l7.gd2 gfd8, Alsina - Sanchez Guerrero, Ideal Clave 200 1 ) lS.'theS+ dxeS 1 6.0 'it>e7 gives Black some edge, Gutman. 48
corr l 994, is met by l3 ... e4!? l 4.�xe4 �xb2) l l ...aS ( l l .. ..Ag4 l2.lt:lxeS .Axe2 l3.lt:lc6 bxc6 14.�xe2) l2.a3.AcS l3.lt:lxcS dxcS l 4.&dl is fme for White, Gutman; II) lO ....Axd2 l l.�xd2 d6 (l l ...aS is worth clarification. l 2.lt:lxeS �xeS l 3 .�fdl �e8 l4..Af3 &6 lS.�d4 isn't inspiring as in stead of lS ...�g5 16.�c3 m.6 17M � l8.h3 d6 19..§d4 �ffi 20.�xa5ixh3 , Ruf Reuter, Germany 1 997, 2 l .�xc7!, Black might try lS ..,m,6 l6.b3 d6 l7.�xe5 &eS. However, l2.lt:ld4!? d6 seems to be crit ical, and now not l 3.�ac l .Ad7 l4.�c3 �fe8 1 S.�a3 b6 1 6.�el cS l 7.lt:lf3 .Ac6, Rodriguez Rodriguez - Fabre Massana, Canovelles 1999, but l3.lt:lbS, e.g. l 3 ...a4 l4.f4 lt:lc6 lS.lt:lc3 f5 l6..Af3 .Ae6 l 7.lt:ldS �n l8.e4 or l3 ...�e8 l 4.f4 lt:lc6 lS..Af3 .Ae6 l 6.�ac l ) l 2.�fd l lt:ld7!? ( l 2 ... .Ae6 l3.cS lt:lxf3+ l4.J.xfl d5 lS.�d4 c6 l6.b4 .Af5, Bock - Schaffarth, Germany 1997) l 3 .�c l lt:lf6 should be level, Gutman.
9 .Ael •
After 9.lt:lxeS �xeS there is: I) l O.�dl b6 (10 ...0-0 l l.idJ h6 1 2.0-0 .Axd2 l 3.�xd2 d6 l4.h3 �e8 lS,gfdl b6 is not bad, Dietrich - Golzow, Germany 1 987) l l .a3 .Axd2+ l 2.�xd2 d6 l3.�d5 �b8 l4.�c6+ �d8, Gutman; further II) l O..Ad3 b6 (Letic - Majstorovic, corr l 9S4, went 1 O...�a5 1 1 � 1 �xa2 1 2.0-0 �aS l3.lt:lf3 ms l 4..AfS 0-0 l S.�dS c6 l6.g4 m6 1 1.gs ms 1 8�4 d6 1 9,gh4 .AxfS 20.�xf5 �g6 with advantage for Black, but l l .a3 .Axd2+ l2.�xd2 �xd2+ l3.�d2 is advisable. lO ...c6 l l .O-O .Ad6, Fey - Gutdeutsch, Leutersdorf2000, can be met by l 2.f4! �e7 l 3.e4) 1 1 .0-0 .Ab7 with equal chances, Gutman ; III) l O..Ae2 0-0 1 1 .0-0 aS see the text.
1 1 .�xe5 'f!heS ll.�fJ
If l 2.a3 .Axd2 l 3.�xd2 see 4.�c2 .Ab4+ S ..Ad2 lt:lxd2 6.lt:lxd2 lt:lc6 7.lt:l0 �e7 8.a3 .Axd2+ 9.�xd2 lt:lxeS IO.lt:lxeS �xeS l l .e3 aS 1 2 ..Ae2 0-0 1 3 .0-0. l l ...tff6
l 2...�e7 13 ,g.dl &6 is playable as well, l4,gds d6 1s.�fdl t5 l 6..Ad3 g6 1 1,gd4 .Ad7 1 8 .�h4 .Ac6 1 9 .�h3 �aa8 20.�g3 .Axf3 2 l .gxf3 �h8 22.f4 �f6, Bjordal Gundersen, corr l 99 1 .
9 0-0 .•.
9...lt:lxf3+ lO..Axfl 0-0 l l .O-O�e5 l2,gfdl ( l2.�adl .Ad6 1 3 .g3 c6 l 4..Ag2 .Ac7 lS. lt:lf3 �cS Yl-Yl Musielak - Riessbeck, corr 1 986) l2 ....Ad6 l3.g3 c6 l4.lt:le4 .Ac7 lS.c5 b6 1 6llac l favours White, Gutman.
13 .a3
l31t1dl d6 14,gdS g6 lS.a3.AcS l6.lt:ld2 .Ae6 1 7.lt:le4 m4 l8.g3 �e7 19.�2 .Af5 20..Ad3, Costa - Gomes, Lisbon l 99S, 20....Axe4 2 l ..Axe4 c6 22.�fdl a4 23..Ag2 f5 gives Black more control, Gutman.
1 0.0-0 a S!?
Black has two more options: I) lO ...d6 l l .lt:lb3 ( l l .lt:ld4 .Ag4 l 2.lt:l2f3 itS l3.lt:lxeS .Axe2 l4.�xe2 dxeS l S.lt:lf5 �g5 l6.e4 �d8 l7.�adl Yz-Yz Andrea sen - Jensen, corr 1992, while l l .h3 �ffi 1 2.lt:lxeS dxeS l 3.lt:lf3, Simonet - Bert,
13 ..Ac5 14.�dl d6 ••
l4 ...�eS l S.lt:le4 h7 l 6.&dl f5 l7.lt:lc3 c6 is another way, Gutman . 15.�e4 tfg6 16-*.dJ .Aa7 17.�c3 fS 18. �dS tff7
Black has a sound position, Gutman. 49
Section 2 ( l .d4 � f6 2.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.'frc2 .ib4+) s.�d2
�e7 can be met by IO.f4 0-0 I I ..ig2 &8 IH!dl d6 13.exd6 cxd6 14ik12, Gutnuzn) with another branch: Al) 9.lt:lf3 �e7 I O.b4 (I O.�dl lt:lc6 l l .a3 see 4.lt:lf3 �+ 5.id2 lt:lxd2 6.lt:lbxd2 lt:lc6 7.a3.ixd2+ 8.�xd2 lt:lc6 9.�c3 0-0 1 0. M I - Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 4) I O ... b6 (IO.. ,ges I l .b5 a6 12.a4 axb5 13.cxb5 c6 14.e3 cxb5 1 5 ..ixb5 lt:lc6 16.0-0 lt:lxe5 17.lt:lxe5 �xeS 1 8 .�xe5 �xeS 19.�fdl d5 20_gac l or I O.. .a6 1 1 .e3 lt:lc6 12.b5!? axb5 13.cxb5 &3 14.m2 "tn>4+ 15.�d2 �xd2+ 1 6.�xd2 are both hardly viable for Black, Gutman) l l .e3 .ib7 12..ie2 �e8 1 3 .�d l aS 14.b5 �a7 1 5 .0-0 .ixf3 16 ..bf3 �xeS 1 7.�xe5 �xeS and it is very diffkultfor White to make progress, Bueclu!r, Kaissiber 1 712001;
s...ds
A2) 9.g3 �e7 I O ..ig2 (this is more ac curate than I O.lt:lh3 �8 l l .f4 d6 12.exd6 cxd6 1 3.ltlf2 ltlc6, for instance 14.�d2 .ie6 15 .e4f5 16.0-0-0 �f7 1 7.�c3 a5 18. fud6 fxe4 19.lt:lxe4 lt:lb4 20.�d2 hc4, Gutman, or 1 4.0-0-0 .if5!? 1 5.e4 he4 16.�el d5 1 7.cxd5 .ixh l J 8_gxe7 lt:lxe7 19.lt:lxhl �ac8, Buecker) IO ...�e8 l l .f4 d6 ( I I ...lt:lc6 12.�dl �b8 13.�d2 b5 was mentioned by Buecker, yet 1 2.�f2 has more point: 1 2 ... d6 1 3 .exd6 cxd6 14 .e4 or 12 ...m,s 13.e3 b5 14.cxb5 l)cb5 15.ltle2, Gutnuzn) 12.exd6 (J2_gd) dxe5 13.fxe5 c6 14.lt:lf3 .ig4 1 5.�d4 hO I6..ixf3 lt:la6 17.0-0 �xeS IS.�xeS �xeS J 9_gd7 lt:lc5 20.&7 a5 is fine for Black) 12 ...cxd6 13ikll (Buecker analyses 13.�d3 ltld7! J4_gd) lt:lffi 15.�xd6 �e3 16.�d4 �e7 17.�d6 �e3 with a draw by repetition; less convincing is 1 3 ... lt:lc6 14.�dl .ie6, when instead of 15 .b3 �adS 1 6.�d2 d5 17.cxd5 lt:lb4 1 8.�c4 �d6 19.e4 .ixd5 , Peter SchDffarth, 1 5.�xd6 �f6 1 6..ixc6 bxc6 17.�d4 �e7 1 8.�c3 .if5 19.h3 �e4 20.�h2 &d8 2 1 .�xd8 �xd8 22.�f2 c5 23.lt:lf3 seems critica� Gutman) 13 .. � (13 ...lt:la6 14.�d2 .if5 1 5.lt:lf3) 14ikl2!?
This is a principal continuation. Alternatively: I) 5 ...�? 6.g3 lt:lxd2 7.gxh4 l004+ 8.id2 lt:lxd2 9.a3 ltlb3+ IO.axb4 was hopeless for Black in Brachtel - Esch, corr 1 994; II) 5 ... lt:lxd2 6.i.xd2 hd2+ (6 ... �e7 7.f4, e.g. 7 ... lt:lc6 8.lt:lf3 b6 9.e3 .ib7 I O ..ie2 .ixd2+ l l .�xd2 � 12.0.0.0, Wegmuel ler - Mani, Bern 1999, or 7...0-0 8.g3!? lt:lc6 9..ig2 d6 I O.i.xc6 hd2+ I I .�xd2 bxc6 1 2.lt:lf3 .ig4 1 3.exd6 cxd6 1 4.0-0 �fe8 15.&e l ! ? ih3 1 6.�f2 .if5, Baer Malmstrom, corr 200 1, 17.�dl &d8 1 8. lt:ld4 Ae4 19 .f5) 7.�xd2 is less common, but not entirely unplayable. Black has tried three ways to resist: A) 7...�h4 (a very new idea, suggested
.
by Stefan Bueclu!r in Kaissiber 1612001)
8.�c3 (8.&I lt:lc6 9.lt:lf3 �e7 and 8.e3!? lt:lc6 9.lt:lf3 �e7 are treated under 4.lt:lf3 .ib4+ 5 ..id2 .ixd2+ 6.ltlbxd2 lt:lxd2 7. �xd2 lt:lc6 - Part 4, Chapter 3, Section I) 8 ...0-0 (if 8 ... lt:lc6 9.g3 �e4 I O.lt:lf3 0-0 I I ..ig2&8 12.0.0, e.g. 12 ...lt:lxe5 13.lt:ld4 �g6 14.lt:lb5 �b6 15.�e3 or 12 a6 1 3 . �adl lt:lxe5 14.�d5 lt:lx 0+ 1 5.i.xf3 �e7 I 61Udl d6 17.c5 dxc5 1 8.�e5, while 9 ... __
50
(14.�d2 �c6, e.g. 15.�xd6 �e3 16.�d2 -eb6 1 7.�c3 �b4 1 8.c5 ms, Buecker, or 1 5 .�0 �ad8 1 6.0-0 �xe2 1 7.�xe2 �e2 18.nfl fun 19.'i!?xf2 J.e6, GUI'mGII) 14 ... �6 15.�0 (1 5.b4 llac8 1 6.�0 b5) 15 ...lOC5 1 6.�h4 ie4 (16.. .ig4 17.0.0 �o4 18.ixo4 �xo4 19Exd6 .be2 20JM4 �c6 2 1 .�e l ) 17 .�d4 .bg2 ( 1 7... b5 18.cxb5 .bg2 19.�xg2 m7 20.0-0 �xb5 2lltel) 18.�xg2 �o4 ( 1 8...�o4 19.nc2) 19.�xe4 �xe4 20.�c2!? (20.�d4 �ac8 21 .0-0 b5 22.cxb5 �2) 20 .&c8 21 .0-0 b5 22.�fc 1 b4 23.�el following by �3 with a plw; for White, Buecker, Kaissiber 1 71200 1. B) 7 ...0-0 8.f4 (8.�0 �c6 9.�c3 �e7 transposes to 5 id2 �xd2 6.�xd2 llJc6 7.�0 ixd2+ 8.�xd2 �e7 9.�c3 0-0 Section 1) 8...�c6 (8...b6, TseidiniGIDskov, 9.�0 ib7 1 0.g3 ffi l l .exffi �xffi 12ig2 �6 13.0-0 �e8 14.e3 d6 15.�el �c5 1 6.�g5) 9.�0 (9.g3 d6! 1 0.exd6 cxd6 1 1 .�0 -eb6 yet 9.e3!? is intriguing, e.g. 9 ... ffi IO.exffi �xf6 l l .�e2 � e8 12.0-0-0 d6 13.lOC3 or 9...�e7 10.�e2 �d8 l l .�c3 d6 12.�d5 �d7 1 3.exd6 �xd6 14.o4 �8 1 5 .�c3 �d4, Blitzmich - EtcChess, in ternet 2002, 16.e5) 9...ffi (in my opinion Black should prefer 9 �e7, treated in q 1 O.exf6 ( 10.0-0-0 !? is worth trying: on 10 ... fxe5 l l .�d5+ 'i!?h8 12.�xe5 �xeS 13.�xe5 d6 14.�d4 id7, Hartmann Schaefer, Leipzig 1994, 15.g3 ic6 1 6.o4, and if 1 o ...�e7 l l .exffi, instead of l l .e3 fXe5 12.1Xe5, Hartmann - Lindner, Wies baden 1993, 12 ...�xe5) IO ...�xf6 1 1 .e3 ( l l .g3 d6 1 2ig2 ie6 13.�g5 ig4 1 4.h3 .its 1 5.g4 h6 16.�d5+ 'i!?h8 17.�xf5 �xf5 1 8.gxf5 hxgS 19.fxg5 �xf5 20.h4 is also good, Tolw;h - Naftalin, Leningrad 1962) l l ...d6 12id3 (12.0-0-0 aS!?, improving on 12.if5 13id3 �e8 14.�hel ixd3 1 5 .�xd3 �b4 1 6.m3 a5 1 7.a3 �6 1 8. �xb7 lOC5 19.�d5+, Lo Conte - Mahns trom, corr 200 I ) 1 2 ... a5 1 3.0-0 favours White, Lokvenc - Patalas, Vienna 1943;
C) 7 ...�c6 8.f4 (8.�0 �e7 goes into 5id2 �xd2 6.�xd2 �c6 7.�0 .bd2+ 8.�xd2 �e7 - Section 1, while 8.e3 �xeS 9.�e2 d6 1 O.�c3 J.e6 l l .b3 �ffi 12ie2 0-0-0 13.0 d5 14.c5 d4 was clearly awk ward for White in Gomez Deltell - Sion Castro, Alicante 1 988) 8...�e7 (8 Y9h4 9.g3 �g4 I 0.�0 0-0 I Oig2 b6 l l .�dl �d8 1 2 .�d4, Maribau - Marc, Acede 2001 , or 8...ffi 9.exffi �xffi 10.�0 d6 1 1 .e3 id7 12.ie2 0.{)..() 13.0.0 h6 14.�4 !:ideS IS iO g5 16.�xc6 ixc6 17ixc6 bxc6 18.�ae l , Warfield - Chisam, Boylston 1998, with a winning position for White) 9.�00-0 ([n reply to 9 ...b6 White has two good possibilities. I O.g3.ib7 1 l.ig2 is the fiiSt one, e.g. l l...�cS 12.�c3 ().()..() 13.a3 or 1 1 ...0-0-0 12.0-0 �c5+ 13.'i!?hl �xc4 14Ncl m4 15.�c2. IO.O-O-O ib7 l l .e3 0-0-0 12.id3 is the second, for in stance 12 ...d6 13.exd6 �d6 14..if5+ 'itb8 15.�c3 �b4 1 6ibl or 1 2...�b4 13ibl ffi 14.exffi gxf6 15.e4 mte8 16.�hel, im proving on 13.'i!?bl �xd3 14.�xd3, when instead of l4_h6 IS.mtel g5 1 6.�e2 g4 17.�4 h5 18.�b5 a6 19.�c3 d6 20.exd6 �d6 21 Exd6 �xd6, Gnmwald - Koron owski, corr 1986, 22.nd I , 14 ffi 15 .exffi gxffi 16.'i!?al mtg8 would be much better. However, Black · s task is simpler after I O.e4 ib7, e.g. l l .a3 0-0-0 12.�c2 f6 13.exffi �xffi 14 �d2 �he8 15id3 �aS 16.�c2 �xf4, Lopez Ramirez - Garcia del Castello, Malaga 2003, or 1 1 .0-0-0, and now not 1 1...0-0-0 12J.d3 d6 13.exd6 �d6 1 4.e5 �dd8 15.�c3 h6 16.a3 'i!?b8 171Diei , Silman - Kiplinger, USA 1987, but l l ...�b4!? 12.a3 �a6 1 3 id3 �c5 14.�e3 a5 15.�d4 0-0 1 6ic2 a4) 1 0.e3 (I 0.0-0-0 �d8 l l .e4 d6 12.exd6 �xd6 13id3 ig4 14.e5 �d7 15 .�e3 �d8 16. ic2 �b4) IO ... �d8 l l .ie2 d6 1 2.exd6 �xd6 13.Y:fc3 .ig4 14.'i!?f2 �e8 15.�hel leaves Black with some but possibly not full compensation, Gutman. .•
•
,
•.
•.
51
6.fHJ
Here are four more answers: I) 6.cxd5 'I!Mxd5 (Koch - Brauner, Ham burg 197 1 , went 6 .. ..if5 7.\!Ma4+?! lL!c6 8.dxc6? .ixd2+ 9.<�dl lL!xf2 mate, but 7.\!Mb3 looks critical: 7 ...� 8.g3 lL!xd2 9.J.xd2 .ixd2+ 1 0.<�xd2 'I!Md4+ l l .
erful initiative, e.g. 9.\!MxdS lL!d4 1 OJ:k 1 lL!xd2 l l .c3 lL!xcl 16.lL!f3 0-0, Lukic - Hribovsek, corr 1 959, or 9Jtdl lL!xe5 10.\!MxdS 'I!Mf6 l l .lL!f3 ltJg4 12.J.c3 lL!xc3 l 3.bxc3 0-0 14J::td4 l::tad8 15.\!McS c6 16.e4 .ixe4, Matrai - Eberth, Czech Republic 1 988) , when Black has to make the right decision: A) 8 ...lL!g3 9.e4.ixe4 (9 ...lL!xe4 IO.cxd5, e.g. lO ... lL!g3 l l .'I!Ma4+ .id7 12.\!Mb4 lL!xhl 13.'1!Mxb7 or 1 0...'\!MxdS l l .l::td 1 !? lL!xd2 12.\!MxfS lL!xf3+ 1 3 .gxf3 'I!Me6 14 ..ib5+ c6 1 5 .\!Mxe6+ fxe6 1 6..ic4
Black won easily, Kiene - Kruger, Ger many 1 990) IO ... Itlxd2 (Maurer - Der bellau, Switzerland 1 986, went I O...dxc4 l l .i.e3 fie? 12.i.g2 1tlxe5 1 3.0-0, when 1 3 ...c3!?, Anatoli Matsukevich, 14.1tlh4 ltld6 1 5.bxc3 id7 1 6.'Wd4 ic6 is worth consideration. Also IO ... d4 l l .i.g2 �e8 may well be tried as after 1 2.�dl Black has a choice between 1 2 ... 1tlc5 1 3.'Wb5 ltlxe5 14.0-0 b6 1 5.1tlxe5 fu.e5, Hankel Feicht, Giessen 1 997, and simply 1 2 ... ltlxe5) l l .ltlxd2 1tlxe5 12.i.g2 dxc4 and I like Black, Gutman . 01) 6.exd6 it3 is also a dangerous line.
but White can try for more) 9.a3 ixd2+ (9.-i.cS 1 0.1tlxe4 'Wxdl+ l l .Wxdl ixe4 12.e3 0-0-0+ 1 3.<;!iel parrying Black's threats) 1 O.i.xd2 0-0-0 l l .i.e3 ( l l .'Wc 1 mte8 12.b4 1tld4 13.1tlxd4 'Wxd4 14.i.e3 f!eS 15.tf4 :sdl+ 1 6.'Wxdl f/c3+ 1 7.id2 ltlxd2 1 8.fixd2 flxal + 19.fidl flxa3 0:1 Ziewitz - Hagen, Germany 1 963) l l ...'Wf6 ( l l ...'We6 12.'Wa4 �he8 is not bad either, viz. 1 3 .�dl �xdl+ 14.'i!;lxdl ltld6, Barlow - Dreyer, Wanganui 1 994) 1 2.'Wb3 ( 1 2.flc l ltla5) 1 2 ...g5 1 3 .h3 h5 looks fairly grim for White, Gutman; C) 7.dxc7 fixe? 8.'Wa4+ (8.a3 !xd2+ 9.ixd2 is met by 9 ... 1tlc6 1 0.'Wcl ltld4 l l .if4 'Wd7; however, note that 9. . 0-0 l O.fic l :sd8 l l .ltlf3 1tlc6 12.c5 1tld4?! 13.1tlxd4 �xd4 1 4.i.f4 allows White to beat back the attack, Schnur - van Hove, Oldenburg 2000, and 9 ...ltlg3 is prema ture due to 10.'Wc3 1tlxhl l l .'Wxg7 �fB 12.ib4 1tld7 13.f/g5 f/e5 14.g4!? ie4 15.f/xe5+ ltlxe5 1 6.ixfB 'i!;JxfB 1 7 .f3. If 8 .'Wb3 1tlc6 9.1tlf3 0-0-0 1 O.e3, then 10 ...'Wd7 l l .'Wdl ig4 0:1 Figeac - Toul zac, Creon 1 997, improving on 1 O ... gS?, when instead of l l .ltld4? �xd4 12 .exd4 ltlxd4 13.'Wdl f!f4 0:1 Bascau - Meewes, corr 1 97 1 , l l .id3 'WaS 1 2.ixe4 ixe4 13 .0-0 would be better, e.g. 1 3 ...ixd2 14.1tlxd2 �xd2 1 5.hd2 'Wxd2 16.�adl or 1 3 ...id3 14.1tld4 l0xd4 15.exd4 ixfl 1 6.1tlxfl �xd4 1 7.hg5 f/xg5 18 .'Wxb4, Nkls Jensen) 8 ... 1tlc6 9.1tlf3 0-0-0 (the most popular continuation, but not the only one: 9..1kl8 10.e3 1tlc5 l l .fidl ig4 12.a3 !xd2+ 13 .!xd2 ltle5, Baer - Lo Conte, corr 200 1 , or 9 ... 0-0 1 O.e3 �adS l l .a3 .ixd2+ 12.i.xd2 1tlc5 13.'Wdl �d7) yields Black a strong attack. Examples: A) 1 O.a3 ixd2+ l l .ixd2 1tlxd2 12.1tlxd2 fu.d2 13.Wxd2 'We5 ! ( 1 3 ... �d8+ 1 4.'i!;le l f!eS 1 5.f3 'Wxb2 1 6_gd l f/c3+ 1 7.'i!;Jf2, Tartllkower) 14.'Wb5 (after 14.f!b3 �d8+ .
We survey White's defences: A) 7.'Wb3 ltlc6 8.1tlf3 (8.dxc7? !xd2+)
8 ...'Wxd6 9.a3 (9.e3? 0-0-0 1 O.'Wdl ig4, Tartakower) 9 ...ia5 (9 ... 1tld4?, Zuck mann - Seehase, corr 1967, is a horrible move due to 1 O.ltlxd4 !xd2+ l l .ixd2 f/xd4 12.ie3. 9 ... ix.d2+ lO.hd2 1tlxd2 l l .ltlxd2 1tld4 1 2.'We3+ 'it1B 13.0-0-0 &8 14.'Wg3 �xe2 1 5.'Wxd6 cxd6 1 6.g4 ig6 17 .f4 !e4 is sounder keeping a plus for Black) lO.'WbS f/f6 leaves White nearly lost, Gutman; B) 7.1tlf3 f/xd6 (7 ... ltlxd2 8.'Wa4+ ltlc6 9.!xd2) 8.'Wdl (8 .'Wb3 1tlc6 goes back into A, and for 8.'Wa4+ ltlc6 see D) 8 ... ltlc6 (Hoffmann - de Smet, corr 1 992, continued 8 ...0-0 9.a3 .i£5 1 O.ltlxe4 he4 l l .'Wxd6 ixd6 12.id2 1tld7 13.1tld4 'l:r-'h ,
53
1 5.'�cl o!Lla5 16.Yf/f3, Ahtianen - Nie minen, corr 1972, is 16 ...Yf/f4+! decisive, and 14.'�e l Yf/xb2 1 5J:�d l .ic2 0: 1 was seen in Muess - Reinhardt, corr 1 935) 14..,g&:J8+ 15.�1 (1 5.�e l o!Lld4 16.Yf/xe5 o!Llc2 mate, Tartakower) 15 ... o!Lld4 ( 1 5 ... Yf/f4+ 16.e3 Yf/xf2 0:1 Laske - Vauclair, Pernik 1 98 1 ) 1 6.Yf/xe5 o!Llb3 mate; B) 10.e3, and now: B 1) I O.. J�he8 I l .a3 lLlcS ( l l ....ixd2+ I 2..ixd2 o!Llxd2 13.o!Llxd2 �xd2 14.�xd2 Yf/e5, Spanier - Lorenz, Hannover 1965, fails to 15.-ebS �8+ 16.�1) 12.Yf/dl 'tYb6 (After 12 ...o!Lld3+ 13..ixd3 .ixd3 14.Yf/a4? 'tYb6 15.axb4 fue3+ 16.'�dl .ie2+ 17.�2 o!Llxb4+ Black won, Plesse - Wolff, Ger many 1 966, but 14.axb4 o!Llxb4 15.Yf/a4 seems critical. However 1 2 .. ..ixd2+! ? 13 ..ixd2 is perfectly playable, since in stead of 1 3 ....id3 14.b4 .ixfl IS.�xfl lLle4 16.Yf/c2 o!Llxd2+ 17.o!Llxd2 Yf/e5 18.&1, Pappier - Palmiero, Buenos Aires 1 996, Black has 13 ... ..ig4 1 4.b4 o!Lle4 1 5 J�a2 o!Llc3, Ebisch-Felder, e-mail 2002) 13 .o!Llh4 ( 1 3 ..ie2 o!Lld3+ 14.�fl lLlxf2) ILlLld3+ (13 ...hd2+ I4..ixd2Yfixb2 15.lLlxt5 fud2 16.Yf/xd2 Yf/xal+ 17.Yf/dl Yf/c3+ drawing, Harding) I4..ixd3 .ixd3 15.Yf/g4+ �7 16.o!LJ5 ( 16.axb4 gxe3+ 17.fxe3 Yf/xe3+ 18.�I o!Llxb4) 16 ...o!Lle5, Gutman; further 82) 10 ... o!Llc5 I I .Yf/dl o!Lle5 (if l l ...Yf/a5 12 .a3 o!Lle4 I3..ie2 �d7, then not 14 .0-0? .ixd2 15 .o!Llxd2 o!Llxd2 1 6.b4 Yf/d8, Behi tah - Aubert, Orange 1993, but 14.axb4 Yf/xa1 15.0.0 o!Llxd2 16.lLlxd2 lLlxb4 17.-eb3 Yf/a5 18.Yf/c3) 12.a3 .ixd2+ 13.o!Llxd2 (or 13..ixd2.ig4) 13 ...lLlcd3+ 14..ixd3 o!Llxd3+ I S .�fl �d7, Gutman; similarly 83) IO ...Yf/d6 1 1 .a3 ( l l .Yf/dl .ig4 12..ie2 .ixf3 1 3 ..ixf3 o!Llxd2 14 ..ixd2 Yf/xd2+) l l ...o!Llxd2 (Gerd Schippel analyses I I ... .ixd2+ 12 ..ixd2 o!Llxd2 1 3.0-0-0 o!Llb3+ 14.Yf/xb3 o!Lla5, and now not 15.Yf/a4 '!Wb6 16.b4 Yf/ffi 17 .lLld4 lLlc6, but 1 5.Yf/c2 .ixc2 1 6.�xd6 �xd6 17.�xc2 ghd8 1 8 ..ie2)
12.axb4 o!Llxf1 13.b5'tYb4+ 14.Yf/xb4 o!Llxb4 15.l0d4 fud4 16.exd4 �e8+ J7,je3 lLJc2+ 1 8.�e2 o!Llxa l , Gutman; finally 84) IO ...Yf/d7 I I .a3 .ixd2+ (l l ... o!Llxd2!? 12.axb4 o!Llxfl 1 3 .b5 o!Llb4 14.o!Lld4 ghe8 1 5.o!Llxf5 Yf/d3) I2..ixd2 o!Llxd2 13.0-0-0 lL!aS (13 ... lLlb3+? 14.Yfixb3 lLla5 15.Yf/c2 .ixc2 1 6.gxd7 �xd7, Froemrnel - Ries sbeck, corr 1987, 1 7.�xc2) 1 4.Yf/xd7+ fud 7 15.o!Llxd2 �d8 are all winning for Black, GuJman. D) 7.Yf/a4+ o!Llc6 is a bit sounder.
Two moves were tried: Dl) 8.o!Llf3 Yf/xd6 (8 ... 0-0!? may well be played, for example 9.a3 .ixd2+ IO..ixd2 o!Llxd2 l l.o!Llxd2 Yf/xd6 1 2.e3 �d8 13.�1 Yf/g6 1 4.�c l �he8 or 9 .e3 �e8 I O ..ie2 Yf/xd6 l l.a3 o!Llc5 12.Yf/d l o!Lld3+ 13.�fl .ic5 14.b4 .id4 1 5.c5 Yf/f6 1 6.�a2 �d8 17.b5 o!Llxf2 18.�f2 fue3 19.o!Llxd4 Yf/xd4 20.o!Llf3 �xe2+, Henriksen - Hvenekilde, Denmark 1 965) 9.a3, then: AI) 9..Jas IO.b4 Yf/ffi l l lla2 l0c3 12.-eb3 o!Llxa2 13.Yf/xa2 Yf/c3 14.Yflb2 !? (14 ..ib2 o!Llxb4 15 .axb4 Yf/xb4 1 6 .ia3 Yf/a4) 14 ... Yf/xb2 1 5 ..ixb2 o!Llxb4 1 6.axb4 .ixb4 17. �d I (17 ..ixg7 �g8 18 ..iffi �g6 1 9..ig5 �6 20.e4 .ixe4 2 l .�e2 .ig6 22.g4 f6 23 ..ie3 0-0-0, Danos - Rapoport, corr 1967) 17 ...0-0-0 1 8.�cl keeps a balance; Al) 9 ... .ixd2+ I O..ixd2 (I O.o!Llxd2 o!Llc5 I I .Yf/d l 0-0-0 12.f3 �e8, Rodriguez .
54
Alonso, Pruca Gijon 1 994) 1 0 ... 0-0-0 (another possibility is 1 o...l0xd2 l l .li)xd2 0-0-0 1 2.li)f3, when instead of 12.. .li)d4 13 .li)xd4 'lt/xd4 14.'ltlb4, Cuevas - Zait seva, Odessa 1 990, 1 2 ....ie4! might be better) l l ..ie3 'ltff6 1 2.'ltfb3 g5 13 J:k 1 ( 13 .g3 g4 14.li)h4 li)d4, Wallinger - Tie fenbach, Germany 1988) 13 ...g4 14.li)d2 li)xd2 15.ixd2 ll)d4 16.'ltfc3 'lt/g6; likewise A3) 9 ...li)c5 !? l O.'ltfdl 0-0-0 l l .e3 ( l l .g3 illie8 12..ig2 00+ 13.'-t;>fl li)xcl 14.axb4 li)xe2 1 5 .'lt/b3 Wb8 1 6.b5 .id3 17 .'lt/a3 li)xg3+ 1 8.Wgl li)e2+ 1 9 .Wfl li)f4+ 20. Wgl 'lt/g6 2 I .li)h4 li)h3 mate Krasenni kov - Lerner, UdSSR 1967) l l ...l:�he8 12..ie2 .ixd2+ ( l 2...li)d3+ 13.i.xd3 .ixd3 14.axb4 li)xb4 1 5.'lt/a4) 1 3.ixd2 li)e5 and the pressure molmts, Gutman. 02) 8.a3 .ixd2+ (Laghkva - Contedini, Leipzig Olympiad 1 960, continued 8 ... li)c5 9.dxc7? 'lt/e7 1 0 .'ltfdl li)d3 mate, but 9.'lt/d 1 poses more problems, since 9 ... li)d4 IO.e4? .ixd2+ l l ..ixd2 .ixe4, Borik, can be improved with 1 0.axb4, e.g.l O....ic2 l l .bxc5 .ixdl 1 2.Wxdl cxd6 13 .e3 or lO_lilc2+ l l .'ltfxc2 .ixc2 12.bxc5, Asger Paaske) 9..ixd2 li)xd2 1 0.Wxd2 'lt/xd6+ 1 1 .� 1 ().().() 12.li) f3 li)e5 13 .'ltfb4 li)xf3+ 1 4.gxf3 'ltff4 with a pleasant po sition for Black, Jensen . E) 7.a3.ixd2+ 8 . .ixd2 appears to be a more serious attempt.
8...'lt/xd6 ( 8. ..li)xd6 9.'ltlb3 .ie6 1 0.e3 was fine for White, Stoltz - Meyer, corr 1954. 8...li)c6 is more appealing as White must play 9J�dl 'lt/xd6 IO.'lt/cl Q.O.O l l.li)f3 'lt/ffi 12 .g3 struggling for equality in variations like 1 L . ig4 13..ig2 li)e5 14..if4 li)xf3+ 15J.xi3 lhdl+ 16 'lt/xdl .ixf3 17 .exf3 li)c5 18.'lt/e2 'lt/xb2 1 9.'lt/xb2 li)d3+ 20.'it>d2, 12 ... li)xd2 l 3J:�xd2 gxd2 14.'lt/xd2 gd8 15.'lt/cl .ie4 16..ig2 li)d4 17.li)xd4..ixg2 1 8.ggl gxd4 1 9 .gxg2 'lt/c6 20.'lt/c3, or 12 ... �7 13..ig2 �8 14.0-0 .ig4 15..ic3 li)xc3 1 6.bxc3 gxdl l 7 .gxdl � dl+ 1 8. 'lt/xd 1 'lt/xc3 19.'lt/d3 'lt/c l + 20 ..ifl .ih3 2 I .li)d2 g6 22.f4 'lt/el 23.e3 h5 24.'lt/e2. 9.li)f3 'lt/xd6 1 O.'lt/cl can be met by either 1 0...().().() 1 1 �3 mte8 1 2.e3 li)c5 or even 10 ...0-0 l l .g3 &d8 12..ig2, Solis - Rodriguez, Spain 1 998, 12 ... li)xd2 13.'lt/xd2 'ltfffi 14.'lt/cl gfe8; however, note that 9 ... li)g3 is premature due to 1 0.'lt/c3 li)xhl l l .'lt/xg7 gf8 1 2.ih6 'lt/xd6 13 ltd 1 'ltle7 14.g4 .ie4 15..ig2, while 9 ... 0-0 IO.dxc7 'lt/xc7 l l .'ltfcl li)c5 1 2.'lt/c3 li)e4 13.'lt/e3 gfe8 14.'lt/f4 'ltfb6 1 5 ..ie3 'lt/xb2, Oleg Neikirch, leads to a draw after 1 3.'lt/c l ) 9.'lt/c 1 (9.g4 'lt/xd2+ IO.'lt/xd2 l0xd2 l l .gxtS li)xc4 1 2lk l li)d6 13.ffi gxffi, Borik, yet I like 9 .. ..ig6: IO..ig2 .!l)xf2 or IOJ.e3 li)c6. 9.gdl is best met by 9 ... li)c6 as 9 ...Wb6, Slllk er/Giasscoe/Stayart, allows 1 0.c5, e.g. 1 O...'lt/xc5 l l .'lt/xc5 li)xc5 12.f3 li)c6 13.e4 or 1 0 ...'lt/c6 l l ..ie3 0-0 1 2 .'ltfc l ) 9 ...li)c6 l O ..i£4 'lt/e7 l l .b4 ( l l .e3 0-0-0 12.li)f3 g5 13� h5 14.h3 li)a5 15..ie5 ffi 16..ic3 li)b3 1 7.'lt/bl li)g3, Naidorf- Bo Detthow, simultaneous San Paulo 1 950, though 12 ... li)a5, Borik, is also not bad) l l ...Q.O.O ( l l ...g5 1 2..ie3 ffi 13.c5 g4 14.f3 ¢3 15 .exf3 li)g5 1 6.g4 .ig6 17. 'i!n2 ()..()...() 1 8.h4 li)e6 19.b5, Jankowicz - Vujadin ovic, e-mail l998, 19 ... li)cd4, yet 14.h3!? gxh3 15.g3 Q.O.O 16.i.xh3 has more point) 1 2.li)f3 l:llie8 1 3 .c5 .ig4 1 4..ie3 'i!1b8 is quite comfy for Black, Gutman. 55
IV) 6.e3 .if'S reaches a position which is more complicated than evaluated.
Black should welcome this line as of fering him excellent practical winning chances and, objectively, at least equal ity, Tim Harding.
We examine: A) 7 ..id3, the less precise course, then: Al) 7...ll:\a6 was suggested by Frllllelis k Nepustil, 8.cxd5 (8.ll:\ O ll:lac5 9 ..ixe4 .he4 lO.�dl chc4 1 1 .0-0 .idJ, Forsberg Gundersen, corr 1 993, or 8 .a3 .ixd2+ 9.ixd2 /0a:5 lO.ll:\O ll:\xd3+ l l.�xd3 ll:lg3 12.�xd5 �xd5 1 3 .cxd5 ll:\xhl 14.�e2 ll:lxf2 l5 .'�xf2 0-0-0, GerdSchippel, are both hopeless for White) 8 ... ll:\ac5 !? (is more consequent than 8 ... �xd5 9 .i.xa6 ixd2+ 1 O.J.xd2 bxa6 l l .�a4+ ! ? �b5, Bethmann - Burk, corr 1 989) 9.i.b5+ c6 1 O.dxc6 0-0 l l .cxb7 ( l l .�d l �aS 1 2 ..ic4 ll:\xd2 13 ..ixd2 lhd8) l l ..J�b8 1 2 .�d l gxb7 1 3 ..ie2 gd7 1 4.ll:\O .ig4 l 5 .ll:\d4 ll:\d3+ 1 6.i.xd3 .ixd 1 1 7 ..ixe4 .ia4 with advantage for Black, Gutman; Al) 7...�g5 8.g3 (after 8.'itfl ixd2 9.ll:\O �g6 lO.ixe4.he4 l l .�xd2 dxc4 12.ll:lel ll:\c6 13.0 gd8 14.�c3 id3+ l5.'�f2 0-0 1 6 .b3 gfe8 1 7 .J.b2 gxe5 1 8.gdl ged5 19.e4ixe4 Black won easily, Lundin Berkell, Stockholm 1 983) 8 ._ll:\d7!? (8 ... ll:\xd2 9..ixd2 .ixd3 1 o.�xd3 is less cri-
tical, for example 1 0 .. .J.xd2+ l l .�xd2 dxc4 12.�4 ll:\d7 1 3 .f4 �g6 14.�xc4 ll:lb6 l5.'ml5+ c6 1 6.�e2 ().()...(), Sieglen Freuendorfer, Germany 1 980, l7.ll:\0 !? gd7 1 8 .o-o ghd8 19.gfd l , or l O ...dxc4 l l .�e4 .hd2+ 1 2.�d2 ll:\c6 13.ll:\O �e7 14.�xc4 0-0-0+ 1 5 .�e2 ll:lxe5) 9.ll:\ O �h5 (improving on 9 ...�g4 1 0.0-0 .ixd2 l l .ll:lxd2 ll:lxd2 1 2 .ixf5 ll:\O+ 1 3 .�h l �h5 14.ixd7+ �xd7 l 5 .'�g2 ll:lh4+ !? 16.gxh4 �g4+ l 7.'�hl �0+ 'lz-'lz Ti met - Meyer, Zagreb 1 953) 1 0.0-0 .ixd2 l l .ll:\xd2 ll:\xe5 ! ( l l ...ll:\xd2 12 .�xd2 e.g. 12 ...ih3 l3.J.e2 �xeS, Tseillin/GIAskov, 14.gdl dxc4 15ixc4 or 12 ... ll:\xe5 13.J.e2 ll:\0+ 14.i.x0 �xO l 5 .�dl �xdl 1 6. fud l dxc4 17.0 id3 1 8.�f2. However, less appealing is 12 ..ixf5 , not because of 12...ll:\0+ l 3 .'�g2 ll:ldxe5, Tseitlin! Glllskov, 14.h3 g6 15.ig4 ll:\xg4 16.hxg4 �xg4 l 7.�d 1 , but due to 1 2 ...ll:lxfl , e.g. 13.ixd7+ 'it>xd7 14.�fl �xh2 l 5.�f5+
Play might continue: 56
81) 7...lt)xd2 8.ti'a4+ lt)c6 9�d2 .ixd2+ IO.lt)xd2 0.0 l l .f4 dxc4 1 2�c4; further 82) 7 ...0-0 8.ti'b3 (fer 8 ..id3 lt)c6 see 7... lt)c6 8..id3 0-0 - BJ, but 8 ...lt)d7!? 9.0-0 lt)dc5 I O..ixe4 dxe4 J J .lt)d4 .ig6 1 2 .a3 .ixd2 1 3 ..ixd2 ti'e7 14 ..ib4 ti'xe5 may prove to be a more critical test) 8 . . .lt)a6 9.cxd5 lt)ec5 I O.ti'c4 .ie4 I I .ti'd4 .ixd5 1 2�a6 lt)xa6 1 3 .0-0 leaves Black with not enough compensation, Gutman; 83) 7 ... lt)c6 8..id3 (if 8 .ti'd l , then 8 ... 0-0! 9.a3 .ixd2+ I O..ixd2 l::t e8 looks to me like the most logical reply; 8 ....ig4 9.ti'c2 .i5 is only a repetition, since 9 ... .ixf3 10 gxf3 .ixd2+ I I ..ixd2 lt)xd2 12 ti'xd2 lt)xe5 1 3 .0-0-0 dxc4 14.ti'b4 ti'f6 1 5.l::tgl was OK for White in Canfora Bradley, e-mail l 996, and 8 ...ti'e7 9.cxd5 lt)xe5 I O .lt)xe5 .ixd2+ I I . .ixd2 ti' xe5 12.f3 lt)xd2 13.ti'xd2 0-0-0 14.0-0-0 gave White advantage in Gross - Hoennann , Germany 1989) is a more popular contin uation, to which Black has three options: 83a) 8 ..ig6 9.0-0 lt)xd2 IO..ixd2 .ixd2 ( I O .. ..ixd3 I I .ti'xd3 dxc4 12.ti'xc4 .ixd2 13 .l::tfd I) I I �g6 hxg6 I U!ad I! (instead of 1 2 .ti'xd2 dxc4 1 3 .ti'c3 ti'd3 14.l::ta cl ti'xc3 15.&c3 b5 1 6.lt)d4 lt)xd4 17.exd4 0-0-0, Ladanyi - Vospemik, Budapest 200 1 ) 1Ldxc4 1 3 .ti'xc4 ti'e7 14Exd2 with a clear plus for White, Gutman; 83b) 8...lt)xd2 9�d2 .ixd3 IO.ti'xd3 dxc4 ( I O ....ixd2+ J I .lt)xd2 lt)xe5 1 2 .ti'd4!?) l l .ti'xc4 ( l l .ti'e4? ti'd3) I I . ...ixd2+ 12. lt)xd2ti'e7 13.lt)f3 0-0 14.ti'c3 W 15.&1 l::tac8 16.We2 lt)xe5 1 7.lt)xe5 ti'xe5 1 8 . ti'xe5 l::txe5 1 9.l::th dl l::te7 20.b4 and the endgame is a bit better for White, Kubi kova - Pavlanin, Czech Republic 1 996; 83c) 8...0-0 9.0-0 (9.We2 hd2 I O..ixd2 �8 I I ..ic3 lt)xc3+ 12 .ti'xc3 .ixd3+ 1 3 . ti'xd3 lt)xe5 14.ti'xd5 ti' f6 1 5 .lt)xe5 &e5 1 6 .ti'd4 l::td8 1 7 .ti'c3 l::tde8 occurred in Rodriguez - Needleman, corr 1988, yet I prefer 13 ...dxc4 14.ti'xc4 lt)xe5 15.lt)xe5 •
l::txe5 1 6.l::th dl ti'e7) 9 ... lt)xd2 (not 9 ... .ixd2 IO..ixd2 lt)xd2 I I .ti'xd2 .ig4 12. cxd5 txf3 1 3.gxf3 lt)xe5 14.i.e2 ti'M, e.g. 15.ti'c3 et\5 16.e4l:iad8 17i'!ael E'.d6 1 8.f4 ti'g6+ 19.ti'g3 lt)d7 20.i.f3 ti'h6 2 1 .5 I :0 Timar - Einax, corr 1988, or 15 .Whl ti'h3 1 6.ti'd4 !, when neither 1 6...l::tfe8 1 7.l::tgl g6 1 8.l::tg3 ti'd7 19 .f4 lt)c6 20.dxc6 ti'xd4 2 I .exd4 �e2 22cxb7 l::tb8 23.l::tb3, Sham kovich - Elbekov, Russia 1955, nor 1 6 ... lt)xf3 1 7.ti'f4 lt)h4 18.ti'g3 ti'xg3 19.fitg3 lt)g6 20.&cl are enjoyable for Black) IO..ixd2 .ixd3 I I .ti'xd3 dxc4 ( I I .. ..ixd2 1 2.lt)xd2 dxc4 1 3 .ti'c3 lt)xe5 14.ti'xe5 ti'xd2 1 5 .l::t a dl ti'e2 1 6.ti'xc7 b5 17.ti'a5, Harding, 1 7 ...ti'xb2 1 8Eb l ti'e2, yet we can improve earlier with 1 3 .ti'xd8 l::t fitd8 14.lt)xc4) 12 .ti'xc4 .ixd2 1 3.l::t adl ti'e7 14.l::txd2 lt)xe5 1 5 .lt)xe5 ti'xe5 1 6.l::t fd l &e8 17.ti'b3 b 6 1 8 .g3 l::te6 1 9 .ti'c2 c5 20.l::td5 ti'f6 is equal, Milic - Moehring, Yugoslavia - Holland 1 949 ; 84) 7 ....ixd2+! ? 8 ..ixd2 (8.lt) xd2 lt)g3 9.e4 lt)xe4 IO.J.d3 lt)xd2 I I ..ixd2 .ixd3 12.ti'xd3 dxc4 1 3 .ti'xc4 lt)c6 1 4..ic3 0-0 15.0-0 ti'e7 is even, yet Black can try for more with 8 ... lt)c6 9.ti'b3 lt)xe5 IO.ti'xb7 c6 J J .lt)xe4he4, e.g. 1 2.f4 l::tb8 13 .ti'xa7 eM+ 14.'ite2 lt)d7 or 12.cxd5 0-0) 8 _lt)g3 9.e4 he4 (9_be4 10� bd2 I I .ti'xd2 hd3 1 2.ti'xd3 dxc4 1 3 .ti'xc4 0-0 14.0-0 lt)c6 15Efe l is fme for White) IO .ti'a4+ b5 I I .ti'xb5+ c6 1 2.ti'b7 lt)xhl 1 3 .ti'xa8 .ixf3 ( 1 3 . . .ti'b6 14 ..ie3 ti'b4+ 1 5 .lt)d2 ti'xb2 I6rui!?O-O 17.be4 dxe4 1 8.ti'xa7 ti'c3+ 19.id2 ti'xe5 20.ti'e3 ti'xh2 2I .ti'f4) 14.gxf3 ti'b6 1 5.0-0-0 lt)xfl 1 6.l::tel 0-0 17.cxd5 ( 1 7..ie3? d4 1 8 ..ixfl lt)d7) 1 7 ... ti'c5+ 1 8.Wbl ti'xd5 19.J.b4 (19.i.e3 lt)d3 20..ixd3 ti'xd3+ 2 1 .Wa I lt)d7 22.ti'xc6 lt)xe5) 19 .. .E'.d8 ( 19 ...lt)d3 20.hd3 ti'xd3+ 2 1 .Wal E'.d8 22..id6) 20..id6 ti'd2 2 1 .�1 lt)d3 22�d3 ti'xd3+ 23.Wal ti'e3 24Eb I ti'b6 25 ..ie7 l::te8 26..id6 E'.d8 leads to a draw , Gutman. 57
II) 7 ...ie6 was recommended by Fran tisek Nepustil.
Back to the main line
Possibly best and leading to some cri tical lines, Harding.
White has tried a range of moves: A) 8.b3 ig4 (after 8...�xd2 9..lx.d2 dxc4 IO.ixc4ixd2+, Nepuslil, l l .�xd2 10xe5 12.i.xe6 fxe6 13 .0-0 0-0 1 4.gadl White keeps a plus) 9.i.e2 ic3 IO.cxd5 ( IO.ib2 is refuted by I O ... ll:lb4 1 1 .'9'cl ixd2+ 12.�xd2 he2 1 3 .'.t>xe2 �xf2) 10 ...'9'xd5 I I .ic4 '9'a5 12.'9'xe4 txf3 13.'9'xf3 � is fine for Black, Gutman; B) 8.cxd5 '9'xd5 9.a3 ixd2+ I O.ll:lxd2 if'S (Franzen - Vonhof, corr 1990, con tinued I O ...ll:lxd2 l l .i.xd2 gds 1 2 .ic3 0-0 13.� 1 . when 13 ...'9'a2 14.gcl '9'd5 might be played) I I .ic4 (not I I .id3? �xd2 12.i.xf5 '9'xg2) 1 1 ...'9'xe5 I2..id3 �d6 1 3 .ll:lf3 '9'e6 (better than 1 3 .. .i.xd3 1 4.'9'xc6+ bxc6 1 5 .�xe5 ie4 1 6.f3 f6 17.�g4if5 1 8.�f2. Schmidt - Augus tin, corr 1979) 14..ixf5 �x15 15.0-0 0-0, Gutman; further C) 8.ll:ld4 ixd2+ (8 ... ll:\xe5?! 9.'9'a4+, e.g. 9 ...'9'd7 1 0.'9'xb4 c5 1 1 .'9'b5 cxd4 12.ll:lxe4,Ham Baum, or 9....!Llc6 IO.�xc6 ixd2+ I I .ixd2 '9'd7 1 2..ia5 0-0 1 3.cxd5 ixd5 14,gd) '9'xc6 15 .'9'xc6 bxc6 16.b3 gac8 1 7.f3) 9bd2 �xd4 (if9 ... �xe5 IO.ic3 /0g4 l l .cxd5 ixd5 1 2.ic4 �gxf2 1 3 .ixd5 '9'xd5 1 4.0-0 �xc3 1 5 .gxf2) I O.exd4 ll:lxd2 1 1 .'9'xd2 dxc4, Baum, I2..ie2 0-0 13.0-0 c5, Gutman; similarly
6 .lfS! . .•
Tseidin and Gllzskov consider this move to be morepromising but itrjustification depends on afantasy variation which may be flawed, Harding This is only a sideline, and not critical to the ultimate value ofthe Faj because Black has a playable alternative ... , Har ding, Kibitzer 1 9. .
6 ... ll:\c6 7.e3 (7.a3 ixd2+ 8.i.xd2 if'S!? 9.'9'a4 transposes to 6.a3 ixd2+ 7.i.xd2 �f5 8.'9'a4+ �c6 9.� f3 ; however, 8 ... � xd2 is less ambitious but possible, e.g. 9.'9'xd2 .if6 I O.ll:lg5 ll:\xe5 I I .ll:\xe6 fxe6 12.'9'e3 '9'16 13.cxd5 O-O,Aifonso Romoo, and if9.�xd2, then not 9 ..J.e6 IO.f4 llJd4 1 1 .'9'c3 dxc4 1 2.�xc4 '9'd5 1 3 .e3 ll:\f5 1 4.ll:ld2 ll:le7 1 5 .e4 with advantage for White, Degiorgis - Berthelsen, e-mail 1 998, but 9 ... ll:\xe5 IO.cxd5 '9'xd5 l l .e4 '9'c6 1 2 .'9'c6+ ll:lxc6 1 3 .ib5 id7) is another sub-variation. The logical responses are the following: I) 7 .. .i.f5 ! seems the best opportunity to me, reaching a position after 6.e3 if'S 7.ll:\f3 �c6; 58
D) 8.ie2 YNe7 (8 ...0-0 9.0-0 ltJxd2 brings
Keprt, Moravian League 1998, should lose at once to l5.gxf3 !) 9.ixd2 ixd2+ IO.ltJxd2 ( IO .YNxd2 dxc4 l l .YNc3 YNe7) IO.. .J.xe2 l l .�xe2 ltJxe5 ( l l ...d4 l2.ltJf3 dxe3 l3.fxe3 YNe7 14 .YNc3 040 I S �dl gde8 l 6.E:d5 g5 1 7 _gfl E:hg8 may well be played, Meduna - Nepustil, Prague 1985) l2.YNc3 YNd6 13.YNd4 dxc4 14.YNxd6 cxd6 l 5 .f4 c3 l6.bxc3 ltJc6 with a level ending, Gutman. B) 8.cxd5 ixf3 appears critical, after: 81) 9.gxf3 ltJxd2 IO.J.xd2 (I O.dxc6 ltJb3+ l l .�e2 ltJxal l 2 .YNa4 0-0 13 .cxb7 E:b8 l4.YNxb4 YN d5, Jindrich TIYipl) 10 ...YNxdS l l .J.xb4 ltJxb4 l2.YNa4+ ltJc6 l 3 .J.g2 (if l 3 .ib5, then not 13 ... YNxf3 because of l4.E:gl 0-0 l 5.J.xc6 bxc6 l 6.YNg4, but 13 ...0-0 l4.J.xc6 bxc6 15 .YNe4 YNbS) 13 ... 0-0 14.0-0 (so far Trapi/Piacltetka, New in Chess, 1987; Beck - Gibson, internet game 1 997, went l 4.E:dl YNxeS 1 5 .0-0 YNxb2? l6.E:bl YNf6 1 7.E:xb7, but Black might play better 15 ... ltJd8! l 6.E:d2 c6) l4 ... ltJxe5 (after 14 ...YNxe5?! 1 5 .f4 YNe6 l6.gfc l E:fd8 l7 .YNb3 White exerts strong pressure on the c�file) l 5.f4 ltJf3+ l6.�hl YNhS 17.h3 ltJh4! (this seems to be quite OKfor Black, John Donaldson, Inside Chess, 1 990, while 1 7 ... E:fd8 is inaccurate due to l 8.YNb4 &b8 l9�d l ) l8.hb7 E:ab8 l 9.YNxa7 YNbS ( l 9 . . .ltJ f3 20.�g2 ltJh4+ 2 l .�h2 ltJf3+ i s not good in view of 22.ixf3 YNxf3 23 .YNd4 gb6 24.ggl ) 20.J.e4 gfe8 (20 ...YNc4 2 l .YNd4 YNxd4 22.exd4 E:fd8 23.a4 E:xd4 24.E:fe I E:xb2 25.a5 and the a-pawn appears to be too dangerous) 2 l .a4 YNd7 (2 l ...YNc4 22.J.g2 ltJxg2 23.�g2 E:xb2 is possible) 22.�h2 gxb2 23.Ah I YN d3 24.E:ac I h6 25lkel E:e2 26he2 YNxe2 27.�gl llJf3+ 28.ixf3 YNxf3 29.YNxc7 YNxh3 30.E:b I (30.E:c I? ge6 3 l.f5 E:e4, Harding) 30 ... &6 3 l .YNd8+ �h7 32.E:b6 YNg4+ 33.�fl E:xb6 34.YNxb6 YNdl + 35.�g2 YNxa4 is totally equal, Gutman ;
Black no success due to I O.ixd2 ixd2 l l .cxd5 .hd5 12_gfdl ib4 l3.e4, and also 8 ... ltJxd2 9.ixd2 ixd2+ IO.YNxd2 dxc4 l l .YNc3 YNe7 l2.J.xc4 .hc4 l3.YNxc4 Q.O.O, Mueller - Scheef, Germany 1 992, 14� I E:d7 l5 .YNc5 &8 16.0-0 favours White) 9.0-0ltJxd2 I O.J.xd2 ixd2 l l .cxd5 ixd5 l 2.ltJxd2 (12 .E:fd l ltJxe5 13.ltJxe5 YNxeS l4.E:xd2 ic6) 12 .. .YNxe5 !? l 3 .ltJf3 YNe7 l4.E:fd l E:d8 appears to hold a balance, Gutman;
E) 8.a3 ! ixd2+ 9.ltJxd2 (9.J.xd2 ltJxd2 IO.YNxd2 dxc4 I I .YNc3 YNdS l 2.E:cl 040 l 3 .J.xc4 YNxc4 l 4.YNxc4 ixc4 l 5.E:xc4 E:d5 l 6.E:f4 E:hd8 17 .'�e2 E:c5 l 8_gb I is worth trying) 9...ltJxd2 I O.J.xd2 d4 ( 1 0... dxc4 l l ..lxc4 hc4 12.YNxc4 0-0 l3 .i.c3) I I .f4 (an improvement on l l _gdl YNh4 1 2.ie2 0-0 13 .0-0 dxe3 14.J.xe3 ltJxe5 l 5 .E:d4 YNf6 l6.E:f4 YNg6 l 7.YNxg6 ltJxg6 )8_gd4 'l:z- 'lz Grosshans - Augustin, corr 1 989) l l ...YNe7 12 .J.d3 and Black has no compensation for the pawn, Gutman. III) 7 .J.g4 is more enterprising. •
Two replies come into consideration : A) 8�2 ltJxd2 (SIJUI"lder than 8...0.0 9.cxd5 ltJxd2 I O.ixd2 YNxdS l l .ic3 !? ixc3+ 12 .YNxc3 �8 13.0-0 ltJxeS l4.E:fdl, e.g. 14 ...YNe4 l5 .E:xd8 E:xd8 l 6.YNxc7!? gc8 17 �I h6 t 8ru8+ gxd8 l9.YNxd8+ �h7 20 YNdl , while l 4...ltJxf3+ ?, Rachunek 59
82) 9.dxc6! Y:!lh4 I O.g3 (I O.gxf3? �xf2+ l l .�dl lt:lxd2 12 ..b.d2 O-Q.O, Trap{) 10... lt:lxg3 l l .fxg3 ( l l .hxg3 �xh I 1 2.cxb7 .ixd2+ 13..bd2�8 14.ib4Jg2 15.�a4+ c6 16.�a6 .ixfl 17.�xfl �xfl + 1 8.� m,s 19.&1 Ib.b7 201bl.c6 �d7 2 U�d6+ �c8 22..ic3, yet 13 .. J:�b8 is the correct answer, e.g. 14.�a4+.ic6 15.�xa7 0-0 or 14.ib4 �bb7 1 5.�f5 �d8) I I ...�h6
16.�xf3 � 17.�c3 goo8 18 ..ie3 �xc6 19.�xc6 bxc6 20.gc1 gfe8 2 1 .gcs and White won, Finegold - Voekler, Gronin gen 1990) 14.� hd2 15..b.d2 gxd2+ 16.� �xh2 17 ..ig2 Y:!lhS+ 1 8.g4 �xeS 19.�c3 �d5+ 20.e4 �d6 2I ..ifl leaves Black insufficient for the piece, Gutman; 82a4) 12 ....b.d2+! 1 3..ixd2 Axhl l4.cxb7 gb8 ( is given by Tseitlbr/GIIlskov) 1 5.e4 (on I5..ib5+ c6! I6..ic4 0..0 17.0-0-0 Ad5 18.e4 hc4 19.�xc4 �e6 20.�xe6 fxe6 2I .Ab4 gn 22.gd6 gfxb7 23 .Ac3 �f7 24_gxc6gd7, while 1 5 .. .ic6?, HartUng, is rerut.d by 1 6.e6) 15...�g6 1 6.�a4+ c6 I7 .Aa6 0-0 18.Ae3 �h5 19..ixa7 gbd8 (19 �xh2?!, Harding, 20.0-0-0 Af3 2 1 . hb8 ixdl 22�xdl Ib.b8 23.�d6 �gl+ 24.�d2 � f2+ 25.�c3 !? �e3+ 26.�c4 �a7 27.�xc6 �8 28.e6) 20.b8� gxb8 2 I .hb8 gxb8 22.�d4 h6!? 23 .e6 fxe6 24.i.c4 �xh2 25..b.e6+ �h8 26.�12 Y:!lh5 27.�f5 �h2 with equality, Gutman. 82b) 12�.b5! �xe3+ 13.� 0-0 14.ggl ! (1 4.lt:lxf3 �xf3+ 1 5 .�gl �d5 1 6.�e2 Ac5+ 17..ie3 he3+ 18 .�xe3 �xb5 19. �c3 �xc6 20.�xc6 bxc6 gives Black a superior ending, Tl'llpl, yet 1 5 ... Aa5 !? is even more effective, for instance 16.h3 �xg3+ 17.�g2 �e l+ 1 8 .�fl �g3+ 19. �g2 �xeS 20.�e2 Ab6+ 2 1 .�g2 �d5+ 22�h2 gae8 23.�c4 �e5+ 24.�g2 ge6 25.gd) gg6+ 26.�hl �5 27.�d3 gd6 0: 1 Stohl - Trap !, Namestovo 1 987, or 16.h4 �xg3+ 17.�g2 �xe5 1 8 .ie2 Ab6+ 19.�fl gae8 !? 20.cxb7 ge6, Gutman) looks to me like a decisive improvement, 14...Ac5 (there is only a choice of evils: 14.. &d8 15.t¥b3, 14 ...bxc6 15.�d3 hd2 I6..ixd2 �xe5 1 7.�xf3 �xb5+ 18.�g2 �xb2 19.�c3, 14 ...gae8 15 .�d3 �xd3+ I6..ixd3 hc6 17 .lt:lb3 gxe5 1 8..if4 ge7 19.�f2) J 5 _gg2 Axg2+ 1 6.�xg2 �f2+ 17.�h3 gae8 1 8 .�e4! bxc6 1 9..id3 f5 20.�f4 1eaves White with a winning po sition, Gutman. .•
The complexities ofthis extremely risky continuation were neverfolly resolved; there are still many uncharted branches. What a picturesque position! So many pieces are hanging, Bogdan Lillie.
There are two interesting ideas: 82a) 1 2.�b3 introducing the following complications: 82al) 12 ..bxc6 1H�gl AdS (13 .. ..b.d2+ 1 4.Axd2 �xh2 15 .e4) 14.�xb4 �xe3+ I5.ie2 �xg l+ I 6.lt:lfl , Harding; further 82a2) 12 ..b.hl 13.�xb4 �xe3+ 14 ..ie2 .ixc6 ( 1 4 ...�gl + 15.lt:lfl Axc6 16.Ag5 or 14 ...�xe5 15 .cxb7 gb8 1 6.lt:lc4 �e4 17..ie3 Ib.b7 18.�a4+ are both devasta ting) I H10 �e4 16.�xe4 he4 1 7..if4 and White dominates, Harding; 82a3) ILO..O J 3_ggJ &d8 (wi� compen sation for the material deficit, Lalic; this is an unsuccessful attempt to improve on 13 ..b.d2+ 14..ixd2 �xh2 15.e4 �xgl •
.
•
60
Ill) 7...ltla6 8.cxd5 0-0 9.e3 't!le7 I O..ie2
Back to the main line
1 1 .0� ltlxd2 12..ixd2.ixd2 13.ltlxd2 't!lxe5 14..if3 ltlc5 15 .'t!lc4 b6 1 6.e4 .ic8 17.b4 ia6 18.b5 .ic8 19.ltlb3 f5 20.ltlxc5 bxc5 21 _gfe1 f4 22J�ac1 and White won, Matamoros - Quadrio, Loures 1 998; IV) 7....ixd2+ 8.ltlxd2 ltld7 (on 8...ltlc5 9. 't!lb5+ ltlbd7 1 0.cxd5 c6 1 l .dxc6 bxc6 1 2 .'t!lc4 't!le7 1 3 .ltl 0 0-0 14 . .ig5 't!le8, Matamoros - Quadrio, Orense 1 996, I suggest 1 5J.e3!? ltle4 1 6.g4 .ig6 17 ..ig2 ltlxe5 1 8.ltlxe5 't!lxe5 1 9.0-0) 9.cxd5 0-0 (9 ... ltlxe5? IO.ltlxe4 .ixe4 1 l .'t!la4+, and also 9 ...ltlxd2 IO ..ixd2 is hopeless, e.g. 10 ...0-0 1 1 .0 ltlxe5 12 .e4 or IO ... ltlxe5 l l .e4!, GeraldHertneck) I O.ltlxe4 .ixe4 1 1 .0 ig6 12J.f4 't!le7 1 3 .'t!lc3 ltlb6 14.e4 c6 1 5.d6 't!le6 16.'t!lb3 't!lc8 1 7.h4 h5 1 8.g3 'it>h8 19ih3 't!le8 20.0-0 f5 2 l .&e1 fxe4 22.fxe4 tf7 23.e6 ig8 24..ig5 1 :0 Hert neck - Trap!, German Bundesliga 1 99 1 ; V) 7 ...ltlc6 8.cxd5 ltlc5 9.'t!lc4 b5 10.'t!ff4 (maintains a clearplusfor White, Trt�pl; however, this move is forced as IO.'tYxbS 't!lxd5 turns the tables, e.g. 1 1 .e4 Axe4 12..ic4 't!ld7 13.ltlg5 l::!.b8 14..ixf7+ 'it>e7 or 1 l .ltld4 ()..()..() 12.'t!lxc6 't!lxd4) 1 O...'tYxdS 1 l .'t!lxf5 ltle4, when Black's threats are difficult to meet, Tseitlin/Giaskov. !h18
7.Vb3 Others: I) 7.ll:l d4 ?! ltlxd2 8.'t!la4+ ltlc6 9..ixd2 (9.ltlxc6 ltl0+ 10.'it>d 1 bxc6 1 l .'t!lxb4 dxc4+ 1 2..id2 �8) 9 .. ..ixd2+ IO.'it>xd2 dxc4 1 1 .e3 0-0, Gutman; II) 7.a3 ltlxd2 (7 .. ..ixd2+ 8 ..ixd2 ltlc6 -9.'t!la4 transposes to 6.a3 .ixd2+ 7..ixd2 .if5 8.ltl0 ltlc6 9.'t!la4) 8.'t!la4+ ltlc6 9. ltlxd2 (9..ixd2 .ixd2+ 10.ltlxd2 see 6.a3 Axd2 + 7.ixd2tf5 8.ltl0ltlc6 9.'t!la4 ltlxd2 IO.ltlxd2) 9 .ixd2+ (9...d4!?) 10bd2 Q.O 1 l .cxd5 ( l l ..if4 d4) 1 l ...'t!lxd5 12 ..ic3 ltlxe5 13J�d1 't!le6 14.'t!lb5 l::!.fe8 15..ixe5 c6! and Black is not worse, Gutman; III) 7.e3 goes into 6.e3 .irS 7.ltl 0 . •
7.. .�xdl! Less challenging are: I) 7 ... c5 8.cxd5 'tVaS ( 8 ... 't!lb6 9.a3 iaS 1 O.'t!lxb6 axb6 1 l .e3 0-0, Schendel - Sae bele, corr 1988, 1 2.ltlh4 ltlxd2 1 3 ..ixd2 .ixd2+ 14.'it>xd2 .ie4 1 5 .d6 ltlc6 1 6 .f4) 9.a3 ltld7 IO.l::!.a2 .ixd2+ 1 1 ..ixd2 ltlxd2 12.ltlxd2 0-0 1 3 .'t!lc3, Gutman; m 7....ic5 8.e3 d4 9.exd4 .ixd4 1 0.'t!lxb7 (Tabemig - Cigan, Austria 1995, went 1 0.ltlxe4 .ixe4 1 1 .ltlxd4 't!lxd4 1 2 .�e3 ltlc6 1 3 .0 .itS 14.'it>f2 't!lxe5 Yz-Yz) 10 ... ltlxf2 1 I .ltlxd4 't!lxd4 1 2 .ltl0 't!le4+ 1 3 . 't!lxe4 ltlxe4 14.ltld4, Gutman;
In my opinion Black cannot take the po sition by violent attack because he is not sufficiently developed.
61
We see: A) 1 2 .a3 gd8, when: AI) 1 3.axb4 ttlxb4 14.ttld4 (This despe
13 ... g5 (an attempt to resuscitate this va riation for Black, given by Max Bou araba, while Buecker analyses 13 0-0� 14.�xb5 ttlxd2 1 5 .h6+ cit>b8 1 6.�xd2 �xd2+ 17.cit>e2) 14.ti'f5 ttle7 1 5 .ti'h3 !? ( 1 5 .�xb5+ c 6 16.ti'h3 i s less clear due to 16 ...cxb5 17.0-0 .bd2 t 8rut h5 19.g4 ttlg6 20.ixd2 ti'e6) 15 .. .h5 16.ttld4 (1 6.a3 g4 17.ti'h4 ttlg6 1 8 .axb4 ttlxh4 1 9.ttlxh4 0-0-0 20.ttlf5 ti'xeS , Bouaraba, or 1 6.g4 gd8 1 7.ttld4 ttlxd2 1 8.ixd2 �xd2+ 19. cit>xd2 c5 20.�xb5+ cit> � 2 l .�d3 cxd4 22.ghdl ?! ti'xe5 , Gerard - Toulzac, St. Quentin 2002, are both hardly viable for White) 1 6 ...c5 ( 1 6 . . . g4 1 7 .ti'h4 has its drawbacks, e.g. 1 7 ... ttlg6 1 8ixb5+ cit>fB 19.�c6 or 1 7 ... c6 1 8.�d3 ttlg6 1 9�xe4 ti'xe4 20.ti'f6) 1 7 .�xb5+ cit>� 1 8 .�d3 !? ( 1 8 .0-0 g4 19.ti'h4 �xd2 20ixd2 ttlg6 21 ic6 is probably not weaker, e.g. 2 1 ... ti'c4 22.ixe4 ttlxh4 23�fcl ti'a6 24.ha8 or 2 1 ...ti'xe5 22.f4) 18 ...cxd4 1 9 ixe4 ti'xe4 20.0-0 ti'xe5 2 1 . ttlf3 with advan tage for White, Gutman. .•
rado counter-sacrifice, gaining a tempo, seems to be critical, Htuding. 1 4.gxa7
ti'c4, TS�?itlin/Giaskov; 14.gb) ttlc2+!? 15 .'it>dl ti'b3, Harding; 14. ttlg5 ttlc2+ I S.'it>dl ttlxal are all winning fer Black) 14 ...ti'xd4 15 .e3 ttlc2+ 1 6.'it>dl (1 6.'i!ie2? ti'd3+ 17.cit>dl ttlc3+ 1 8.bxc3 ti'xfS) 16 ... ti'b4 17.cit>xc2 (or 17J.d3 �d3 18.cit>xc2 gxd2+ 1 9.ixd2 ti'xd2+ 20.cit>bl ti'd3+) 17 ..Axd2+ 18.ixd2 ti'xd2+ 19.'i!;t3 ti'd5+ (not 19 ...ttlc5+? 20.cit>a2 ti'a5+ 2 1 .cit>bl ti'e l + 22.cit>c2 ti'b4 23 .ti'c8+, Crafty Martin, computer game 1 998) 20. cit>a3 ti'c5+ 2 1 .cit>a2 ti'd5+ 22.cit>a3 ti'c5+ w ith a draw by perpetual check, Harding; Al) 13.ti'f4! g5 14.ti'e3 .bd2+ (14...ti'c4 1 5 .b3 !? ti'c2 1 6.axb4 ttlxb4 1 7.ttld4 c5 1 8.ttlxc2 ttlxc2+ 19.cit>dl ttlxe3+ 20.fxe3 ttlf2+ 2l .cit>c2 ttlxh I 22.ttle4, Estremera Milia, Orense 1 997) 1 5 .ixd2 g4 16.gd) ( 16.ti'd3 gxf3 17.ti'xd5 �d5 18.if4, Ste fan Buecker) 1 6 ... gxf3 17 .exf3 ttlxd2 1 8Axd2 ti'xd2+ 19 .ti'xd2 gxd2 20.cit>xd2 leaves Black with nothing of value for the material deficit, Gutman. B) 1 2.e3 g6 1 3 .ti'f4 was suggested by Buecker in Kaissiber 211 997.
8 b:d2 Black has no reason to be worried about: I) 8 .ti'xb4 ttlxf3+ 9.exf3 ttlc6 I O.ti'xb7 ttld4 l l .�g5 gb8 ( l l ...ti'xg5 12 .ti'xa8+ rtle7 13.ti'xh8 ttlc2+ 14.cit>dl ttlxal IS.'trbS tc2+ 16.cit>el ti'cl+ 17.cit>e2 idl+ 1 8.cit>d3 ti'xc4+ 19.cit>d2 ti'c2+ 20.cit>e3 ti'cl+ for ces a dmw, 2 1 .cit>d4 ttlc2+ 22. cit>xd5 ti'd2+ ..
He seems to have found the flaw, Harding, The Kibitzer 1 9.
62
23 .'it>e4 ti'el+ 24.'it>d3 ti'xe5 25 .ti'xa7 ti'd6+ 26.'it>c4 ti'h4+) 12 .ti'xa7 (1 2.i.xd8 ltlc2+ 13 .'it>dH txb7 1 4Jkl 'it>xd8) 12 ... ltlc2+ 1 3 .'it>e2 f6 1 4.exf6 'it>f7 ! 1 5 J:td l gxb2 1 6.'it>d2 ti' d6 I 7. We i ti'e5 leads to a quick mate, Gutman; II) 8.ltlxd2 ltlc6 9.e3 d4 (9...dxc4 IO.ixc4 seems less flexible, e.g. 10 ... 0-0 I I .e6 fxe6 12.ixe6+ i.xe6 13 .ti'xe6+ 'it>h8 14.a3 .hd2+ 15.ixd2 ti'd3 16.ic3 �8 17.ti'g4 or I O...ti'e7 l l .a3 .ixd2+ 1 2 .ixd2 0-0-0 13 .f4) I O.a3 i.xd2+ l l .ixd2 0-0 1 2.gdJ ( 1 2.f4 can be met by 1 2 .. .f6) 1 2 . . .ti'h4 13 .ti'xb7 ltlxe5 14.ti'xc7 gfe8 and Black has an enduring initiative, Gutman. 8 . Axdl+ 9.�xdl dxc4
Bellon, Oviedo 1 9 9 1 , but 14 ... ltlxc4!? 15.Axc4 c6 appears more logical) 1 3 ... &b8 14.0-0 b5 1 5.ltld2 gfd8 1 6.ltlf3 did not give Black enough for the missing pawn, Gutman. l l .Y!hb7 J J .gdJ ti'e7 12.ti'xb7 (12 .e3 ltld7 13..ie2 ltlxe5 14.ltlxe5 ti'xe5 15.ti'xb7 � 16.ti'h5 ti'xb5 17..1xb5 &b8) 12 ... ltld7 13.ti'xc7 ( 1 3 .ltle3 ltlb6!? 1 4.ltlxf5 ti'b4+ 15 ,gd2 gfd8) 13 ...ti'h4+ 14.ltld2 gac8 1 5 .ti'd6 ( 15.ti'xa7 ti'xb2 1 6.e4 is strongly met by 16 ... ltlxe5 ! 17.exf5 gfe8 1 8.Ae2 ltld3+ 1 9.'it>fl ti'xd2) 1 5 ...ti'xb2 16.e4 ltlxe5 17.exf5 We8 18..1e2 gcd8 19.ti'a6 ltld3+ 20.'it>fl ti'c2 2 I .g3 ltlb2 shows the pow er of Black 's position, Gutman. l l ... �d7
..
10.�xc4 I O.ti'xb7 ltld7 l l .e4 ( l l .ltlxc4 0-0 goes back into the text) l l ...c3 1 2.bxc3 Ae6 1 3 ..1c4 0-0 14..1xe6 ltlc5 15 .ti'd5 ltld3+ 1 6.'it>fl fxe6 1 7.ti'xd8 ( 1 7.ti'xe6+ 'it>h8 1 8 .ltlf3 fails to 1 8 ... gxf3 1 9.gxf3 ti'h4) 1 7 ...�d8 1 8.ltlf3 ( 1 8.f3 ltlcl 19.gxc l gxd2) 1 8 ...gf4 ! ? 1 9.gd J gxe4 20.ltlel �el+ 20Jhel ltlxel 2 1 .'it>xel gds with a presumably even ending, Gutman. 1 0...0-0 IO ...ltlc6 l l .e3 ( l l .ti'xb7!? .id7 12.ti'b3 ti'e7 13.ti'c3 is also reasonable) I J ._Q..O 12..1e2 ti'e7 13 .f4 (13.0-0 ltlxe5 14.&cl l::tab8 15.ti'b5 ltlxc4 16.ti'xf5 ltle5 17 l:tfdl gave White an edge in Comas Fabrego -
ll.bJ 121:tcl gb8 13.ti'xa7 &8 14.ti'd4 gxa2, Gutman.
ll ...aS!? 12 ...ti'e7 1 3 .gc l ltlxe5 14.ltlxe5 ti'xe5 15.ti'xc7 ti'b2 1 6.ti'c3 ti'xa2 17.&1 ti'c2 should be equal, Gutman. IJ.!cl a4 In spite of being two pawns down, Black maintains the balance, Gutman.
63
Stcllon l ( l ,d4 tift 2.c4 tS l.dxe5 tle4 4.Vc:l &b4+) S.tlcl
White carefully avoids the temporary congestion ofhis pieces, Bogdtm Ltdic.
5.-dS! We have to consider two more moves: I) 5...l0xc3 6.bxc3, when the lost tempo could become significant: A) 6.. � H:lf3 h6 8.g3 l0c6 9.J.g2 Y!Je7 IQ,g})l �8 (l0...g6 l l .l0d4 Y!Jxe5 1 2.J.f4 or 10 ...g5 l l .J.e3 .ig7 1 2.h4 g4 13.l0d4) l l .O-O l0xe5 1 2.l0xe5 Y!Jxe5 l3..if4 Y!Jc5 14 . .id5, Gutman; further B) 6.. .J.a5 7.l0f3 (7 � l0c6 leads White nowhere, e.g. 8.f4 ffi 9.l0f3 fxe5 1 0.fxe5 l0xe5 l l .l0xe5 Y!Jf6 or 8.l0f3 f6 9 .exffi Y!Jxf6) 7 ... ffi (Otto Borik gives 7... 0-0 8 . .ig5 Y!Je8 followed by... l0c6 with the bet ter game for Black, but we can improve with 8.l0g5 g6 9.l0e4) 8.J.d2 ().() 9.exffi Y!Jxf6 1 0.e3 l0c6 l l ..id3 h6 1 2 .0-0 d6 l3.l:�abl , Gutman; sim ilarly C) 6...J.c5 7.l0f3 l0c6 (7 ...d5 8.cxd5 Y!Jxd5 9.e4 Y!Jd8 lO.Y!Jb3 ie7 l l .J.c4 0-0 1 2.0-0 b6 131M 1 Y!Je8, Schneider - Nwmi, corr 1 989, 14.e6 secure a clear plus for White, though 8.J.g5 ffi 9.exf6 gxffi l O..ih4 is also good) 8.J.f4 (8.J.g5 .ie 7 9.J.f4 seems reasonable, e.g. 9 ...g5 1 O.J.g3 g4 l l .l0d2
h5 1 2.e3 d6 1 3 .exd6 .ixd6 1 4.�bl h4 15 .hd6, Danner - Schaffarth, Wolfs berg 1986, or 9 ... .ic5 l O.�dl a6 l l .e3 Y!Je7, Bekemann - Leisebein,e-mail l999, 12.J.e2 ().() l3.Q.O) 8 ...h6 9.e3 Y!Je7 lO.J.d3 ( l O.J.e2 !? b6 brought Black no success in the praxis, we see l l .O-Oi.b7 12.a4 a5 l3.Y!Jf3 0-0-0 14.l0d4 IDleS 15 ..if3 l0xe5 16..ixb7+ 'i!n!.b7 17 ..ixe5 Y!Jxe5 18.Y!Jxt7, Krumm - Wittelsberger, Kettig 1 994, or l l .l0d4 ib7 12 ..if3 0-0-0 l3.l0xc6 hc6 14..id5 hd5 15.cxd5 d6 16.exd6 .ixd6 1 7.ixd6 �xd6 1 8 .c4 �e8 19 .0-0 Y!Je4 20.�c 1 , Verat - Herbrechtsmeier, French League 2002) 1 O...b6 (l0 ...g5?! 1 1 �3 0-0 12..ie4 d6 13..id5 �g7 14.h4, Carbonell - Popp, corr 1 953) 1 1 .0-0 !? .ib7 ( l l ...g5 1 2.J.g3 h5 1 3 .h4 g4 14.l0g5 .ib7 1 5 .J.g6!, e.g. 1 5 . . .fxg6 1 6.Y!Jxg6+ �tB 1 7.f3 Y!Jg7 1 8.l0e6+ dxe6 19 .fxg4+ or 1 5 ... l0d8 16.J.e4 l0c6 17 .J.d5, Garcia Suarez - Angel Gomez, Asturia 1 998) 12..ie4 ()..()-0 l3.J.d5 g5 14.J.g3 h5 1 5 .h4 leaves Black with insufficient counter play, Gutman. II) 5 .. .J.xc3+ 6.bxc3 deserves attention.
After: A) If 6 ... d5 we have two independent lines (7.e3, 7.cxd5, 7.l0f3 and 7.exd6 all transpose to the main line with 5 _.d5) : AI) 7 .J.f4 .if3 8.Y!Jb2 (8.Y!Jb3 can be met by 8 ... l0c5 9.Y!Jb5+ l0bd7 lO.cxd5 c6!? 64
l l .dxc6 bxc6 1 2.\!1/xc6 0-0) S ...dxc4 (S ... g5 9.ie3 ltld7 1 O.cxd5 ltlxe5 l l .ltlO ltlg6 12.\!1/b5+!? .id7 13.\!1/b4 f5 14.\!1/xb7 g4 1 5 .ltld2 ltld6 16.\!1/b3 !? f4 1 1 ..id4 gbs l S .\!1/d l 0-0 19 ..ixa7 gas 20 ..ic5 l0e5 2 l .e3 .ia4 22.ltlb3 \!1ff6 23.\!1/c2 fxe3?! 24..ixe3 .ixb3 25.\!1/xb3 gaeS 26.0-0-0 and White won, Apfelhnofer - Meyer, corr 1 9S9) 9.\!1/xb7 ltld7 IO.lLJO ( 1 0.e6 fxe6 1 1 .\!1/c6 0-0 1 2J''td 1 \!1ff6) 1 0 ... 0-0 l l .l0d4 .ig6 is fine for B lack, Gutman; A2) 7..ia3! .if5 (7 ...c5 S.cxd5 \!1/xd5 9.0 ltlg5 1 0.c4 \!1/xe5 l l ..ib2 \!1/e3 12 ..ixg7 ggs 1 3 .\!1/c3) s.gd l ! (S.\!1/a4+ ltlc6 9.e3 seems dubious in view of9 ..\!1/h4; less convincing is 9 ... ltlxc3 1 0.\!1/b3 d4, not because of 1 1 .\!1/xb7? .ie4 1 2 .\!1/b2 gbs, Frantisek NepustU, but due to l l .ltlf3, e.g.l l..ln>S 12.exd4 ltlxd4 13.\!1/xc3 l0c2+ 14.�2 ltlxal 15.ltld4 or l l ....ig4 12.l0xd4 ltlxd4 1 3 .\!1/xc3) S ... c6 9.cxd5 cxd5 (9 .. \!1lb6 is refuted by 10.ltlh3 ltlg3 1 1 .\!1/c 1 ltlxhl 12.\!1/g5 c5 1 3 .\!1/xf5) 1 O.e3 \!1/c7 (10...ltlg3 l l .e4 ltlxe4 1 2.Jd3 l0d7 13 .ltlf3 &S 14.0-0 !lxc3 15.\!1/b2) l l .ltle2 l0d7 12.\!1/b2 and the white bishop on a3 becomes too strong, Gutman. B) 6 ... ltlc5 (Black is intending to follow up with ltlc6, b7-b6, .ib7, \!1/e7 and ()..().() , Jindrich Tmpl) 7 .lLJO , and now: 81) 7 ...\!1/e7 S..ig5 (Elburg - Krantz, corr 1990/92, continued S ..if4 lOc6 9.e3 b6 1 0..ie2 .ib7 1 1 .0-0 h6 12.h4 0-0-0 1 3.a4 a5 14.\!1/f5 gdgS 15.ltld4 ltldS 16..ig3 Ae4 17.1ru lM:tl l S.O ib7 19.\!1/f5 g6 20.\!1/c2 ltlg7 2 l .f4 ltlf5 with a plus for Black) S ...\!1/e6 (S ...\!1/fS 9.g3 !? ltlc6 1 O..ig2) 9.e3 h6 IO..if4 b6 l l .ltld4, Gutman; further 82) 7 ...h6 S..ia3! (more consequent than S...if4 ltlc6 9.e3 \!1/e7 1 O.ie2 b6 l l .ltld4, Wagenaar - Woudsma, Soest 199S, 1 1 ... ltlxe5) S ...\!1/e7 9.g3 b6 1 O..ig2 .ib7 1 1 . 0-0 ltlc6 12.gadl ltlxe5 1 3 ..ixc5 bxc5 14.ltlxe5 .ixg2 15.<;!;>xg2 \!1/xe5 16 .gd5 \!1/e7 17.gxc5, Gutman; similarly .
.
83) 7 ...ltle6 S ..ia3 (S.e4?! ltla6 9 . .ie2 ltlac5 1 0.0-0 b6 l l ..ie3 .ib7 1 2.ltld2 g5 1 3.0 \!1/e7 14.ltlb3 0-0-0 1 5.gfd l gdgS 16l!d5 gg6 17 ..ifl h5, Capit - Lopez de Turizo, Zaragoza 1 995) S ...c5 (S ... ltla6 9.ltld4 ltlac5 1 0.ltlxe6 ltlxe6 l l .e3 b6 12..id3 or S ... b6 9.e3 .ib7 10 ..id3 .ixO l l .gxO \!1/h4 12..ie4 ltlc6 13.f4 are both no better) 9.e3 0-0 (9 ... l0c6 10..id3 \!1/c7 l l ..ie4 ltlxe5 12.ltlxe5 \!1/xe5 1 3.f4 \!11c7 14.0-0) 1 0..id3 g6 1 1 .0-0 ( l l .h4!? <;!;>g7 12 .g4 ghs 1 3 .0-0-0 is also reasonable, 13 . . . \!1/a5 1 4.\!1/b3 a6 1 5 .ltld2 b5 1 6.f4 ltlc6 1 7 ..ie4 gbs 1S . .ixc6 dxc6 1 9.f5 , Papp - Graf, Balatonbereny 1 993) 1 1 ... l0c6 12� \!1/c7 13lladl ltlxe5 14.ltlxe5 \!1/xe5 1 5 .f4, Gutman; finally 84) 7 ... 0-0 S.ia3 (S.ltlg5 g6 9.h4 d6 Duessel - Jonitz, Germany 1 993, went 9 ...d5? lO.iaJ ltlba6 l l .!ld 1 \!1/e7 12.cxd5 \!1/xe5 13.e4 ltlxe4, when 14.ltlxe4 ges 15.gd4 f5 1 6..ic4 is decisive -, I O..ie3 ltlc6 l l .exd6 cxd6 12.h5 .if5 13.\!1/cl geS 14.g4 .ixg4 yields an unclear position, e.g. 15.hxg6 hxg6 16.IDtS+ Wg7 17.mt7+ <;!;>gS lSl!hS+ drawing by perpetual, or 15..ixc5?! dxc5 16.hxg6 hxg6 1 7 .!lhS+ <;!;>xhS 1 S.ltlxf7+ Wg7 1 9.ltlxdS gaxdS 20.\!1/g5 ltle5, Schwarz - Dausch, Ger many 1 99 5) S ...\!1/e7 9.g3 (9..ixc5 \!1/xc5 1 0.e3 is too passive, viz. 10 ltlc6 l l ..ie2 ltlxe5 1 2.ltlxe5 \!1/xe5 1 3 .0-0 d6, Knies Riessbeck, corr 1 9S7. Also 9.gdl b6!? 1 0.g3 .ib7 l l ..ig2 ltlba6 1 2.h4 .ixO !? 13..ix0 !ladS 14..ie4 h 6 1 5.f4 d 6 gives Black a fully satisfactory game, imp roving on 13 ...c6? 14 ..ie4 h6 1 5.f4 f6 1 6..ih7+ �hS 17.exffi gxffi 1 S..i.f5 \!1/e3, Lj ubomir - Dausch, Crailsheim 1 995, when 19.icl \!1/xg3+ 20.Wfl lid5 2 1 .\!1/xfS \!1/xc3 22100 \!1/xc4 23�2 ltle6 24.!lxd7 would have been critical) 9...b6 I O..ig2 ltlc6 ( I O ....ib7? l l ..ixc5 bxc5 12 .ltlg5 \!1/xg5 1 3 ..ixb7) 1 1 .0-0 and Black does not have enough for the pawn, Gutman. .•
65
mann - Steinberg, corr 1995) 7 ...Y!Vxd2+ (7.. .1xc3 8.Axc3 favours White: 8...lilxc3 9.Y!Vxc3 lilc6 10.lilf3 0-0 l l .e3 ge8, Borik, is doubtful on account of 1 2.Ac4 Y!Va5 1 3 .Y!Vxa5 lilxa5 1 4..Ae2 ig4 1 5.gc l , and 8 ....Af5 goes into 4.Y!Vc2 d5 5.cxd5 if5 6.lilc3 ib4 7.Ad2 Axc3 8 .Axc3 Y!Vxd5Chapter 2) 8.Y!Vxd2 lilxd2 9.'it>xd2 lilc6 (if 9 ...0-0, then 1 0.f4, instead of 1 0.e4?! lilc6 l l .f4 �8+ 1 2.�el � 1 3.g3 �e4+ 14.lilge2 ig4 15.�f2 Ac5+ 1 6.�el ge3 1 7.lildl lilb4 0: 1 Iversen - Soby, Aarhus 1 973) 10.f4 ( 1 0.lilf3 ig4!? l l .e3 0-0-0+ 12.�c2 its+ 1 3 .e4 Axc3 1 4.exf5 AxeS 1 5 .Ac4 lild4+ 1 6 .lilxd4 gxd4 1 7..Axn ghd8 1 8.Ae6+ �b8 19 ,gadl gxdl 20. �dl �dl 2l .�dl hb2, Cruz Lopez Bellon, Spanish Ch 1 99 1 , and also 1 0.a3 Ac5 l l .e3 lilxe5 12 .lile4 Ae7 1 3.f4 lilg4 14.h3 lilf6, Gerusel - Schuppert, Gennan Bundesliga 1 980, are in Black's favour) l O _ .J.f5 l l .lilf3 ( l l .gdl 0-0-0+ 12.�cl Ac5 13.�d8+ gxd8 14.e4 Ae3+ 1 5.�c2 �+ 1 6.�b 1 Axe4+ 0: 1 Shoup - Henke, corr 1 995) 1 1 ...()..()..()+ 1 2.�el ffi 13.exf6 gxffi with compensation for the pawn, Anatoli Matsukevich ; C) 6 .. ..Axc3+! 7.bxc3 Y!Vxd5 8.f3 (8.lilf3 lilc6 9..Af4 Y!Vc5) 8 ...lilc5 9.Af4 lile6 (9 ... lilc6 1 0.e4 Y!Ve6 l l .lile2 lilxe5 1 2.lild4 Y!Vffi 13..Ae3 0-0 1 4..Ae2 Y!Vg6 1 5.0-0 se cures some edge for White) 1 0.e3 Y!Vc5 (after 10 ... g5 l l ..Ag3 Y!Vc5 12.Y!Vd2 lild7 13.f4 lilb6 14.f5 lild8 1 5.e4 lilc6 1 6.gdl .td7 1 7.e6 0-0-0 1 8...tf'2 'l'e7 19.exd7+ �d7 20.Y!Vc2 �dl + 2 l .�xdl gd8+ 22. �1 lilb4 23.Y!Vb 1 White won, Pracejus Sasse, corr 1 992) l l .lile2 ( l l .Y!Vd2 0-0 12ig3 lilc6) l l ...lilc6 (or l l ...g5 1 2..Ag3 Y!Vxe3 1 3Bdl and now not 13 ...0-0 14.h4 h6 1 5Bd5 Y!Vb6 1 6.hxg5 lilxg5 17.e6 1 :0 Schiller - Riessbeck,corr 1989, but 1 3 ... lilc6 14Bd5 g4 1 5 .fxg4 lilc5 1 6..Af4 Y!Ve4) 12.Y!Ve4 0-0 13 ..Ag3 b6 looks highly reli able for Black, Gutman.
6.exd6 Alternatives: I) 6.a3 Axc3+ 7.bxc3 Af5 UVb2 (after 8.Y!Va4+ lilc6 9.Ab2 dxc4 l OJ:M l Y!Ve7 l l .lilf3 0-0 1 2.lild4?! lilxd4 1 3 .cxd4 c3 14..Aal c5 Black won in Lee-Gossell, Las Vegas 2002) 8 ...0-0 9 ..if4 dxc4 (9... lila6?! l OJ�dl c6 l l .f3 lilec5 1 2 .e4 Ae6 13 .cxd5 cxd5, Sirens - Touzane, French League 1 995, 1 4 .exd5) 1 O.Y!Vxb7 lild7 l l .f3 ( l l .lilf3 lildc5) l l . ..lilec5 1 2 .Y!Vc6 Y!Vb8 looks fairly grim for White, Gutnwn ; II) 6.Ad2 lilxd2 7.Y!Vxd2 d4 8.0-0-0 c5 (Beckett - Fraser, Isle of Man 1 993, con tinued 8 ... lilc6 9.a3 dxc3 1 0.Y!Vxd8+ lilxd8 l l .axb4 cxb2+ 1 2.�b2 lilc6 13.b5 lilxe5 1 4.e3 Ae6 1 5J�d4, when 15 ...a6! might be tried) 9.e3 lilc6 10.exd4 cxd4 l l .Y!Vf4 ( l l .a3 Aa5 1 2.Y!Vf4 Axc3 1 3 .bxc3 Y!Va5 1 4.cxd4 Y!Vc3+) l l ...Axc3 1 2.bxc3 Y!Va5 1 3.cxd4 Y!Vxa2 1 4..Ad3 lila5 winning for Black, Retamar - Blanco, corr 1 982; 01) 6.cxd5, when we have to consider: A) 6....At5 reaches a position after 4.Y!Vc2 d5 5.cxd5 if5 6.lilc3 ib4 - Chapter 2; 8 ) 6...Y!Vxd5 7..Ad2 (there is no reason for 7.f3 because of7._li\xc3 8.bxc3 Y!Vxe5 9.Ab2 AaS , while 7.Y!Va4+ lilc6 8.Y!Vxb4 lilxb4 9.lilxd5 lt:lxd5 1 O.a3 lilc5 l l .ig5 c6 1 2 J�dl Ae6 13.lilf3 0-0 14.e3 h6 1 5 ..Ah4 ig4 16.Ae2 �Ue8 1 7 .Ag3 lile4 1 8 .0-0 lilxg3 19.hxg3 �e5 was equal in Horst66
IV) 6.e3 is calm and sensible, Harding.
D) Also the exchange 6 ...ixc3+ 7.bxc3 seems premature to me, introducing the following complications: Dl) 7 ... ltJc6?! S.ltJO (S .f4!? if5 9.id3 'Wb4+ is according to Harding good for Black due to IO.g3? ltJxg3, but in fact JO.'i!lfl ltJg3+ l l .hxg3 ixd3+ 1 2 ."tYxd3 "tYxhl 1 3 .cxd5 ltJdS 14.ia3 appears to be just the opposite) S . . .if5 9.id3 ig6 I O.ia3 with a plus for White, Gutman; 02) 7 ...0-0 can be met by S.id3 f5 (S ... i f5 9.cxd5 "tYxd5 1 0. 0 ! ltJf2 l l .ixf5) 9.ia3 ! ? ges IO.ltJO ltJc6 1 1 .0-0 ltJxe5 12.ltJxe5 :IDeeS 1 3 .gfdl c6 1 4.cxd5 cxd5 1 5 .c4, Gutman; 03) 7 ...ltJa6 S�3 if5 9.'Wb2 c5 (9...icS J O.gd) c5 l l .cxd5 "tWaS I Utcl 0-0 1 3.0 ltJg5 1 4.h4 I :0 Laubis - Melchor, corr 199 1 ) 1 0.0 ( I O."tYxb7 ltJc7 I I .'Wb3 0-0 1 2.ltJO gbs is unclear) IO ..."t!M+ l l .g3 'Wb6 ( l l ...ltJxg3 1 2."tYf2 "tYh6 1 3 ."tYxg3 "tYxe3+ 14.ltJe2) 12 .fxe4 ixe4 1 3 .'Wb5+ "tYc6 (or 1 3...'it>f8 1 4."tYxb7 ges 1 5 .cxd5 "tYxe3+ 1 6.ltJe2 ixh l 1 7."tYxa6) 14.cxd5 ixd5 1 5."tYxc6+ ixc6 16.ixa6!? bxa6 17 .o!tJO ixO I S.0-0 with a much better ending for White, Gutman; 04) 7 ... if5 keeps more options open: D4a) S.id3 ltJd7 9.cxd5 ltJdc5 I O.ib5+ c6 l l .dxc6 0-0 1 2.ia3 ( 1 2 .cxb7? gbS) 12 ..."tYa5 1 3 .'Wb2 bxc6 14.ie2 gabS 1 5 . ib4 "tYa4 1 6.0 ( 1 6."tYa3? "tYc2 1 7 .ixc5 gbl+ I S.:i:Dcbl "tYxbl+ 1 9.idl ltJxc5 20. ltJo gdS) 16 ... a5 1 7.fxe4 ixe4 1 S.ltJO axb4 1 9.0-0 "tYa3 20."tYxa3 bxa3 should be about equal, Gutman; D4b) S.'Wb2 0-0 (S ... ltJd7 9.cxd5 ltJxe5 I O.c4 "tYf6 l l .ltJ O ltJg4 1 2 ."tYxf6 gxf6 1 3 .h3 ! ltJgxf2 1 4.gh2) 9.ltJO (9."tYxb7 ltJd7 might offer Black good attacking chances, e.g. I O."tYxd5 c6 l l ."tYxc6 "tWaS or I O.cxd5 ltJec5 l l ."tYc6 gbs 1 2.d6 cxd6 13.exd6 "tYf6) 9 ... ltJc5 I O."tYd2 dxc4 I I . ixc4 "tYxd2+ ( l l ..."tYe7 1 2�3) 12 ..bd2 ltJbd7, Gutman; similarly
We survey Black's defences: A) 6.. .d4 7.a3 (7.exd4 "tYxd4 S.ltJO .ixc3+
9.bxc3 "tYxc3+ IO."tYxc3 ltJxc3 l l .id3 ltJa4) 7 . . .ixc3+ S.bxc3 ltJxc3 9.ltJO c5 I O.id2 ltJc6 l l .exd4 cxd4 1 2 .ltJxd4! ? ( 1 2 .id3 ig4 1 3 .ltJxd4 ltJxd4 1 4."tYxc3) 12 ..."tYxd4 13.J.xc3 "tYf4 14..td3 W l5.0.0, Jaeger - Ros, corr 1 995 ; further B) 6...0.0 7.id3 .if5 S.ltJO ltJd7 (Zinner Pitschak, Bmo 1 934, went S ... ltJc6 9.0-0 ixc3 IO.bxc3 &8 l l .cxd5 ltJxe5 12.ltJxe5 :IDce5 1 3 .0 ltJd6 1 4.e4 ig6 1 5.if4 ges 1 6.c4 "tYf6 1 7 .ig3 and White won, but 1 3 .f4 ges 1 4.g4 could be even stronger) 9.0-0 ixc3 (9... ltJdc5 fails to I O.ltJxd5 ltJxd3 l l ."tYxd3 ltJg3 12 ."tYb3) I O.bxc3 ltJdc5 l l .ia3, Gutman; similarly C) 6 ... ltJc6 7.ltJO .b5 (7 .. .ig4 Sie2 0-0 9.0-0 ixc3 l l .bxc3 ixO 1 2.gx0 ltJc5 13�3 and for 7 ...if5 S.id3 seeB) S.id2 (S.ie2 if5 9."tYb3 d4 ! ? I O.ltJxd4 ltJxd4 l l .exd4 "tYxd4 1 2.0-0 ltJxc3 1 3.bxc3 "tVxeS 14.10 0-0 1 5.ie3 ixc3 1 6.gadl gadS 1 7 .:IDcdS :i:DcdS IS."tYxb7 a5 with equality, An Mon - Fritz 6, computer game 200 1 ) S. . .ltJxd2 ( S.. .if5 9.cxd5ixc3 is refuted by I O.dxc6 ixd2+ l l .ltJxd2 ltJg3 1 2.e4) 9."tYxd2Ae6 (9...tg4 10.cxd5 ixt3 l l .dxc6 "tYxd2+ 12.'i!i'Xd2 ixc6 13.'i!lc2 ()..() 14�1) IO.c5 1b4 l l ib5 are all better for White, Gutman; 67
Black has a couple of possibilities: A) 6 ...d4 7 .a3 (7 .�xe4 dxc3 8.b3, Mat sulu!vich, is doubtful in view of 8.../l)c6 9.a3 c2+ 1 O..id2 .ixd2+ l l ./l)xd2 �e7 12.�xc2 �xeS) 7...dxc3 (7 .. J.xc3+ 8.bxc3 .fu.c3 9.e3 see 6.e3 d4 7.a3 .ixc3+ 8.bxc3 /l)xc3 9./l)f3 - I VA) 8 .axb4 cxb2 (8 ... .iB 9.�b3) 9.J.xb2 .its l O.m3 0-0 1 1 . g3 with advantage for White, Gutman; B) 6 ...0-0 7.e3 (7 ..id2 /l)xd2 8./l)xd2 is best answered by 8 ...dxc4 9./l)xc4 /l)c6; 8 ...d4 9./l)dS .ixd2+ 1 O.�xd2 �e8 is less precise, since instead of l l .g3 c6 12./l)f4 �xeS 1 3 ..ig2 �e7 1 4.0-0-0 cS 1S .il)dS �d8 16.e4 /l)c6 1 7.f4 �e8 1 8.mrll .ig4, Lemke - Steinberg, carr 1 99S, 1 1 .0-0-0 cS 12.f4 /l)c6 1 3.e4 might be a better try) 7.../l)a6 (7 .. .if3 8.i.d3 transposes to 6.e3 0-0 7 .1d3 .if5 8./l)f3- WC) 8�13 (8.cxdS deserves attention, for example 8 .../l)acS 9.id2 .AB 1 0./l)xe4 .ixe4 l l .�c4 .ixd2+ 12./l)xd2 �xdS 13./l)xe4 �xc4 14.i.xc4 /l)xe4 1 S.f3 /l)cS 16.�c l or L.ixc3 +!? 9.bxc3 �xdS l O ..ixa6 bxa6 1 1 .0-0) 8 ... /l)acS 9.0-0 .ixc3 IO.bxc3 �e8 l l .h3 keeping an edge for White, Gutman; C) 6...la:6 7.e3 (7..ad2 .fu.d2 8./l)xd2 dxc4, e.g. 9.0-0-0 .ie6 1 0./l)xc4 m4 l l ./l)e4 0-0 12.g3 �e7 1 3 .a3 �fd8 or 9./l)xc4 0-0 IO.e3 .ie6 l l .a3 �h4) goes back into 6.e3 /l)c6 7./l)f3 - IVC, Gutman; D) So, 6.. .if3! 7.�b3 is again the critical sequence, when: Dl) 7 ... cS?! 8.cxdS �aS 9.J.d2 /l)xd2 10. /l)xd2 bS l l .e4 c4 1 2.�c2 .ig6 l 3 .J.e2 /l)d7 14.f4 h6 I S.0-0 with advantage, Thygesen - Heiberg, Copenhagen 198 1 ; D2) 7. ..hc3+ 8.bxc3 /l)cS ( 8...0-0 9.cxd5 c6 1 O ..ia3 �e8 l l .d6 /l)d7 12.e3 /l)ecS 13 ..ixcS /l)xcS 14.�c4 �aS?! lS.�. Shoup - Weinland, carr 199S, or 8...dxc4 9.�xb7 /l)d7 10./l)d4 /l)dcS l i .'BbS+ IJA1 12 .�xc4, are both insufficient) 9.�bS+ /l)bd7 1 O.cxdS c6 (if I 0 ... 0-0 l l ./l)d4!) l l.dxc6 bxc6 1 2 .�xc6 0-0 13 ..Aa3 ge8
D4c) 8 �bl /l)c5 (8 .../l)bd7 9.cxd5 �xeS I O, it)f3 and also 8...0·0 does not work well due 1o 9.cxd5 �bd7 IO.�rJ!'l �e8 l l .ie2 /l)xeS 12./l)xeS&eS ll.o4) 9.'Bb5+ it)bd? IO.cxd5 c6 l l.dxc6 bxc6 12.�xc6 �8 (more exact than 12 ...0-0 l3..ia3 �c8 14 .•dS !e8 I S .�f3 .ie4 16.�d4 .ixf3 17 .gxf3 /l)xeS 1 8.�xd8 gexd8 1 9-i.xcS gxcS 20.f4 /l)d3+ 2 l .hd3 �xd3 22.'�e2) l 3 .�d6 �aS 14..id2 /l)e4 lS.� �xb4 1 6 .cxb4 /l)xd2 17.'�xd2 �c2+ 1 8 .'�e l /l)xeS 19./l)f3 ( 19-i.bS+ r!le7 20./l)e2 .ad3 2 l ./l)d4 gb2 22_gdl gc8) 19 ... /l)xf3+ 20. gld3 r!le7 seems OK for Black, Gutman; D4d) 8.f3! /l)g3 9.e4 /l)xh 1 IO.ex5 Wlh4+ l l.g3 .fu.g3 12.hxg3 �xg3+ 13.�t2 �xe5+ 14.�e3 �xe3+ 1 S ..be3 dxc4 1 6..hc4 0-0 17 .()..()...0 and I like White, Gutman. E) 6 � .i.f5 ! at once is preferable:7.'t!�b3 (7.f3? /l)xc3 8.�xf5 /l)xa2+ and after 7 .i.d3 /l)d7 8./l)f3 /l)dcS 9.i.d2 .ixc3 10. .ixc3, then lO ... ig6!, as after 10 .../l)xd3+ l l.�xd3 /l)g3 12.�d4 /l)xhl l 3.cxd5 �xt2 14.r!lxt2 �d7 1S.e4Jg6 16.a4 ()..() 17 .h3 cS 1 8.�e3 White had value fa the exchange, Basant - Blaskova, M oravian League 1998) 7...ixc3+ (7...�e7 8.cxd5 ().() 9.ll:\f3 lbd7 IO..h2 lOdcS l l.�xb4 /l)d3+ 12.hd3 �xb4 l 3 .a3, but not l l .�c4 bS 12.�d4 /Oe6 13 .dxe6 �fd8) 8.bxc3 see 6 .i.xc3+ 7.bxc3 .AB 8.'Bb3 - D4c, Gutman. V) 6./l)f3 is a natural reply. •
68
(after 13 ... lk8 1 4."tYd5 l::!e8 White has a choice: 1 5 ."tYd4 "tYc7 1 6.e3 ltle6 17 ."tYd2 ll:\xe5 1 8.ltld4 or 1 5 .e3, reaching a posi tion after 6.e3 .ixc3+ 7 .bxc3 .if5 8."tYb3 ll:\c5 9."tYb5+ ll:lbd7 I O.cxd5 c6 l l .dxc6 bxc6 12."tYxc6 0-0 1 3 ..ia3 l::! c8 14."tYd5 l::!e8 15.ltlf3 -IVD4c) 14.e3 (l4."tYd5 ll:le4 15..&l lk8 is quite dangerous for White, e.g. 1 6."tYd4 "tYa5 1 7.'Wb4 "tYc7 1 8.ltlh4 "tYxe5 19.ll:lxf5 "tYxf5 20."tYd4 "tYe6 or 16 . .ib4 ll:\g5 !? 17.ll:\xg5 "tYxg5 1 8.e3 ll:\xe5 1 9 .f4 "tYh4+ 20.g3 "tYh6 2 l ..ie2 l::! c d8) 14 ...ll:\e4 15.e6 l::!xe6 16."tYd5 .ig6 17 ...ib5, Gutman ; further D3) 7 ..."tYe7 8.cxd5 ll:\a6 (8 ..."tYc5 9...ie3 .ixc3+ I O.bxc3 "tYxc3+ l l ."tYxc3 ll:\xc3 1 2.ltld4.id7 l 3 .e6 fxe6 14.dxe6 .ic8 1 5 . & l ltld5 1 6...ig5 c 6 1 7.e4 ll:\c7 1 8...ic4 and White won, Petersen - Jensen, corr 1990, while 8...ll:\d7 is met by 9.d6 .ixc3+ lO."tYxc3) 9.e3 ltlac5 1 O."tYc4 (lO."tYxb4!? t0d3+ l l ..ixd3 "tYxb4 12.a3)10..0.0 l l A!2 ( 1 1 J/!2? reaches a position after 6.e3 .itS 7."tYb3 "tYe7 8.cxd5 0.0 9.ltlf3 ltld7 IO...ie2 ll:\dc5 l l ."tYc4 - lYE) l l ...ll:lxd2 12.ltlxd2 a5 1 3 .a3 .ixc3 1 4."tYxc3 l::!fd8 1 5 ."tYd4 parrying B lack ' s threats, Gutman; D4) The normal moves does not help, but we can improve with 7 ...ll:\a6! 8.cxd5 c6 9.dxc6 (9.e3 .ixc3+ I O.bxc3 ltlac5) 9 ..."tYa5 ! retaining enough counterplay for the missing pawns. In my opinion, this may well be Black 's best and perhaps the only correct course ofaction.
However, IO.ltlg5 ! ? ( l O.cxb7 l::!d8 l l J.d2 ll:\ac5 12."tYc4 ll:\xd2 l 3 .ll:lxd2 .!t6 14."tYf4 0-0) lO..J/!6 l l .cxb7 l::!b8 12.ll:\xe6 ll:\xc3 l3 ...id2 ltle4 14...ixb4 ll:lxb4 forces after 1 5 .0-0-0 ltlxa2+ 16.bl ltlac3+ 1 7 .bxc3 ll:\xc3+ 1 8.'it>c2 ltlxdl 19.'it>xdl fxe6 20. "tYxe6+ 'it>tB 2 l ."tYd6+ rM7 a draw by per petual, Gutman. Back to the main line
6 .i.xc3+! Alternatives are weaker: I) 6...ll:lxc3 7.a3 (instead of7.bxc3 .ixd6 8.ltlf3 ll:lc6 9.e3 tvffi IO.i!b l ltle5 l l .ltlxe5 "tYxe5 1 2 ..id3 c6, Dunn - Mann, e-mail 1 999) 7 .. ..ixd6 (7 ...ll:\xe2+ 8.axb4 ll:lxgl fails to 9."tYe4+ 'it>tB IO.dxc7 "tYxc7 l l.if4) 8."tYxc3 0.0 9.ll:lf3 l::!e8 IO.g3 "tYe7 (IO. .J.g4 l l ...ig2 ll:ld7 1 2 ..ie3 .ic5 1 3 .ltld4 ll:lb6 14.l::! d l "tYc8 15.0-0 .ixd4 16.l::!xd4 .ixe2 17.l::!e l) l l ...ie3 ltla6 1 2...ig2 ll:\c5 13.0-0 ll:\e4 14."tYc2 favours White, Gutman ; II) 6 ... .if5 , and now: A) 7.dxc7 "tYxc7 goes back into 4."tYc2 d5 5.exd6 .if5 6.dxc7 "tYxc7 7.ll:\c3 .ib4, covered in Chapter 2; B) 7."tYa4+ ll:lc6 8...id2 (8.dxc7 "tYd4 9.e3 .ixc3+ l O.'it>e2 "tYd7) 8 . . .ll:\xd2 9.'it>xd2 "tYxd6+ and Black wins, Gutman; C) 7."tYb3 ll:\c6 S.ll:\0 (8.a3 ll:\d4 9."tY a4+ .id7 lO."tYdl ll:\xc3; however, note that 9 ... b5 allows White to struggle on with IO."tYd l .ic5 l l .ltld5 ll:\xd6 12.ltle3 .ig6 1 3 .ltl f3, instead of 10.dxc7?? "tYd7 0: 1 Garcia - Witte, Guanabara 1 968) 8 ... "tYxd6 9.e3 (9.a3 ltlc5 lO."tYa2 Q-0.0 1 1 Jd2 IDleS with depressing prospects fCI" White , e.g. 12.0-0-0 .ixc3 l3.bxc3 ll:\e4 14.l::!e l ll:lxf2 15.l::!g l ltle5 1 6.ll:\xe5 l::!xe5 17.g4 .ig6 1 8...ig2 &5 1 9."tYb2 "tYa6 20...ie3 c6 2 l ...ixf2 fu.a3, Larsen - Nielsen, Copen hagen 194 l , or l 2.e3 .ig4 13.l0<15 .ixd2+ ..
69
14.l0xd2 l0d4 I SJ�cl �h6 ! ?) 9 ...0-0-0 IO..lc2 (I O.a3, Michel - Kostic, Warsaw Olympiad 1935, IO...ixc3+ l l.bxc3 l0c5) IO ...'Bg6 I I .l0h4 (I l id2 l0xd2 12.l0xd2 .ic2) l l ...�ffi 1 2.l0xf5 �xf5 13.� l0c5 0: I Deutgen - Schmid, Celie 1948; D) 7 .J.d2! ought t o be the only move.
Black has two ideas in his disposal: Dl) 7..bc3 8..ixc3 with a further split: D l a) 8 . . . l0xd6 9.�d2! (less promising is 9.�3 0-0 I O.e3, not because of 10 ... l0c6 I I .lOO �c8 1 2..1e2 aS 1 3 .0-0 l0 e4 14JUdl b 6 15.l0d4 l0xc3 1 6.�xc3 .i.e4 1 7 .0, Lim - Richter, Bad Woerishofen 1 99 1 , but due to IO...l0d7, e.g. l l ..id4 c5 12 ..i.c3 �e8 1 3 .�dl �e7 14.l00 l0 e4!? 15 ..i.d2 l0b6 16 ..1e2 .i.d7 1 7.�c2 J.£5 I 8.J.d3 �8 19..tc3 l0xf2, Haack - Prie demann, Pinnenberg 1992, or l l .�d I ! ? �e7 1 2.l00 l0c5 13 .�a3 l0de4 14 ..i.d4 �fd8 1 5 ..i.e2 �d6 1 6.b4 l0e6 1 7.0-0 c5 1 8 .bxc5 �6) 9 ... � IO.�d4 �gS I I .lOO �h6 12.c5 l0b5 (if 12 ...l0e4, then 1 3 .g4) 13 .�xg7+! ( 1 3 .�e5 l0xc3 1 4.bxc3 .i.e6 15.�xc7 l0d7 16.�xb7 &b8, Thalmann Walther, corr 1 972) 1 3...�xg7 14 ..ixg7 'i!lxg7 1 5 .a4 and White wins, Gutman; D lb) 8 . . . l0g3 9.e4 .ixe4 I O ..id3 ! (for _ I O.dxc7 �xc7 see 4.�c2 d5 5.exd6 .if5 6.dxc7 �xc7 7.l0c3 .ib4!? 8..1d2 .ixc3 9 ..ixc3 l0g3 I O.e4 .ixe4 - Chapter 2) IO....ixd3 (IO....ixg2 l l .hxg3 ixhl I2.!e4
ixe4 13.�xe4+ 'i!ld7 14.�xb7) l l .�xd3 lOxh l 1 2..1xg7 �g8 ( 1 2 ... cxd6 13.�e4+ �e7 14.�xe7+ �e7 15.ixh 8 l0c6 !6..1c3 �c8 17.l00 l0d8 18.'i!le2 1 :0 Krogius Nilsson, Helsinki 1949) 13.�e4+ 'i!ld7 14.�xb7 ! (less effective are: 14.�d l ? �e8 15 .dxc7+ 'i!lxc7 1 6..ie5+ 'i!lc8 with advantage for Black, Tseitlin/GIIIskov; 14.0-0-0, suggested by LotharSchmid, in view of 1 4 ... �g5+, e.g. 1 5 .�d2 l0c6 or 1 5 .f4 l0 f2, so far Tseitlin/Giaskov, 16.dxc7+ 'i!lxc7 17 ..ie5+ 'i!lc8 1 8.�c2 �g4 19.�xf2 �xg2 20.� l0c6 2I .�xh7 �g6 22�h3+ �g4 23.� e3 �e6. Gutmlln; 14.�f5+ tt>e8 15.�e5+ 'it\17 16.0.0.0 'i!lc8 17.dxc7 �xc7 1 8.�f5 + l0d7 19 .�xn �8 20.l0h3 �xh2 2 1 &d7 �d7 22�e8+ �d8 23 .�e6+ with perpetual, Harding, improving on 16..c5? 17 .�f5+ 'i!lc6, H ve nekilde - Petersen, Copenhagen 1 962, 1 8.�0+) 14 ...�c8 (14 ...�h4 1 5 .0-0-0) 1 5 .�xa8 �xg7 1 6.dxc7 l0c6 1 7.�d l + 'i!lxc7 1 8 .�xc8+ 'i!lxc8 19 .'i!lfl i s hope less for Black, Hildebrand/Berkell. 02) 7 ...l0xd6 seems to be forced.
White has three continuations: D2a) 8.�a4+ l0c6 9.e3 �e7 (9 ...0-0 may well be tried, viz. I O.lOO .ixc3 I I .i.xc3 l0e4 12.�b5 �c8, Marches - Vazquez, Badalona 2000) IO.lOO 0-0-0 ( IO ..ixc3 I I ..ixc3 0-0-0 1 2.l0d4 l0xd4 13 ..ixd4 lOe4 14.c5) I I .l0d5 (l l .a3 .ixc3 12..ixc3 •
70
lL!e4 I H �b5 .id7 1 4."M,3 f5 1 5 .g3 rutg8 1 6_gdl g5 17.ie2 f4 1 8.J.b4 fxe3 19.fxe3 "f!Vf6 was fme for Black in Saga - Gun dersen, corr 199 1 ) I I ...J.xd2+ 12.lL!xd2 t!Ve5 13.0-0-0 lL!e4 14.lL!xo4 !xo4 1 5."M,3 �he8 looks unclear, Gutman; Dlb) 8."M,3 lL!c6 9.e3, when: Dlbl) 9 ...0-0 I O.lL!f3 .ie6 (Wendland Henke, corr 1994, went 10 "f!Ve7 I I .lL!d5 ixd2+ 12 .lL!xd2 "f!Vd7 1 3.c5 lL!o4 14.lL!xo4 ixe4 1 5 .MI ixd5 1 6."f!Vxd5 t!Vxd5 17. �xd5 �adS 1 8 .J.c4 with a clear advan tage for White, and I 0 _ges l l .ie2 .k6 12_gdl a6 1 3 .a3 icS 1 4."f!Va4 .ig4 1 5.0-0 ixf3 1 6.J.xf3 l0e5 17 .J.e2 t!Vh4 1 8.b4 b5 1 9 .cxb5 axb5 20."f!Vb3 ia7 2I .lL!d5 is no better, Iversen - Jacobsen, corr 1 965) I I .ie2 �b8 1 2 .a3 (if 1 2 .lL!d4, then not 1 2 ...lL!xd4 1 3.exd4 c5 14.d5 !5 1 5 .0-0 �e8, Berdichevsky - Retamar, corr 1 989, 16.J.e3, but 12 ...t!Vg5!?) 12 .. .J.as 13 ."f!Va4 .bc3 1 4 ..ixc3 lL!e4 1 5 .�c I ; further D2b2) 9 ..."f!Ve7 IO.lL!f3 0-0-0 I I .J.e2 (also I I .lL!d5 ixd2+ 1 2.lL!xd2 "f!Ve6 1 3 .lL!f4 "f!Vffi 14.J.e2 g5 15.lL!d5 "f!Ve6 16.0-0
1 4.lL!xe4 ixe4 appears more dynamic) 12 .J.xc3 lL!e4 13.0-0 �g8 (this variation was given by Stllker/GIIIsscoe!SIIIyllrt) 14lhl l g5 (14...lL!c5 1 5."f!Va3 �d7 1 6.lL!d4 maintains a plus for White, Schjonning Jorgenssen, corr 1 987) 1 5 .lL!d4 (in case of l 5 .�xd8+ is 1 5...�xd8 !? 1 6.�dl �e8 the right answer since 1 5 ... lL!xd8 16_gdl lL!e6 17 _gd5 lL!xc3 18."f!Vxc3 !e4 19.�e5 favours White, Gahtmann - Hoftnann, corr 1 995) 1 5 ... lL!xd4 ( 1 5 • .J.d7 1 6.lL!xc6 .bc6 1 7.ig4+
•.
_
Black has tried: Old) 8 ... lL!xe4 9."f!Va4+! (there is little to like in White's game after 9.J.d3 "f!Ve7 IO.lL!xe4 ixd2+ l l .
corr 199 1 , 19 ... g5) 9 ...b5 (9 ... �c6 is met by IO.�xe4 Y9e7 I I .ixb4, for example I I . ..Y9xe4+ 1 2 .ic2 0..().() IJ.�n or I I ... Y9xb4+ 12.Y9xb4�xb4 13.fJ �c2+ 14.'&bd2 �xa l IS .idJ 0.0-0 16.�e2) IO.YBxbS+ c6 I I .YBe5+ Y9e7 12.exe7+ .ixe7 13.�xe4 ixe4 14.Ac3, Gutman ; further D2c2) 8 ....ig6 9.0-0-0 (Less impressive is 9 ..id3 0-0 IO.�ge2 �c6, e.g. 1 1 .0-0-0 f5 12 .exf5 �xf5 or l l .f4?! ges 12.0-0, Walther - Kirwald, corr 1972, 12 ....ic5+ I J .<;!i>hl �b4. 9.�f3. hoping for 9 .. ..ixc3 I O..ixcJ .ixe4 I I .Y9d2 0-0 1 2.0-0-0, is best answered by 9 ... �d7, e.g. I O.aJ?! .ixc3 l l ..ixcJ .ixe4 12.Y9dl Y9e7 1 3 ..ie2 .ixO 1 4.gx0 0-0-0, Engler - Bauem distel, corr 1 984, or I O..id3 �cS I 1 .0-0 0-0 12 ..!;adl �8) 9_.0-Q 10.0 �d7 (to ... �c6 l l .�dS aS 12.�h3 !? .icS 13.�hf4 �b4 14.�xb4 axb4 I S .Y9b3) l l .�dS ! (more consequent than l l .a3 .icS 1 2..if4 aS IJ.h4 ffi 14.g4 �eS IS.hS ..if7 16.lLlbS Y9e7 17 ..ixeS .!LlxbS 18..if4 .!Lld4 IH�c3 gfd8, Marotz - Bemardt, corr 1986) I I ... .ixd2+ ( ll ....icS 12.lof4) 1 2.gxd2 lLJcS 1 3 ..id3 did not offer Black compensa tion for the pawn, Gutman; D2c:3) 8 ... .ixc3 9 ..ixc3 (9.Y9xc3 .!Llxe4 I O.Y9e5+ Y9e7 1eads to .quality) 9 ....ixe4 (9 ... .!Llxe4? t o.idJ , e.g. I O...Y9e7 l t .<;!i>ft .ig6 1 2.gel f5 1 3 .g4 or 10 ...0-0 l l .lLJO .!Llc6 12.0-0) I O .Y9d2! ( I O..id3?! .ixg2 1 1 .0-0-0 l0d7 12.l;e I+ c.t>tB 13 ..!Lle2 .ixhl 1 4 .gxh l lLlcS I S .ggl looks too expensive after IS ....!Llxd3+!? 1 6.Y9xd3 .!Lle8, although IS ....!Lle6 16.f4 lLle8 17 .<;!i>bl cS 1 8.i.e4 Y9b6 19.Y9a4 a5 20.f5 .!Lld4 21 .lLlf4 lLlf6 22.lLldS Y9d6 23.lLlxf6 gxf6 24.gd I VBeS was also good, Erhardt - Schmitt, corr 19S6. IO.Y9e2 0-0 is playable, since instead of I I .Y9g4?! .ig6 12 .0-0-0 �c8 I J .h3 Y9xg4 14.hxg4 .!Lle4 I S ..id-4 cS 16 . .ie3 .!Llc6 17 .lLle2 lLlb4 1 8.b3 gfd8 and Black won, Bruun - Schjonning, corr 1 987, White has 1 1 .0-0-0 VBgS+!? - not
I J ...ges 1 2 .Y9g4 f6 I J.cS Y9c8 14.Y9xc8 �xc8 1 S ..ic4+ c;!ttB 16.0 .ic6 17 . .!Lle2 .!Lld7 1 8 .b4 lLleS 19 ..ib3 .!Ll x0 20.lLlf4 lLlgS , Andriessen - Boone, corr 199 1 , in view of 2 1 .h4 .!Lle4 2 2..ie I - 1 2.Y9d2 Y9xd2+ 13 _gxd2 .!Lla6 with chances for both sides) I 0 ... 0-0 1 1 .0-0-0 is critical
•
All choices fail to equalise: D2c:3a) l l ...lLlc6 1 2 .cS .!Llc4 ( 1 2 ... lLl fS IJ.f3 Y9xd2+ 14.l;xd2 lLle3 IS.fxe4 lLlxfl l6.ge2 1 :0 De Carbone ll - Starke, Leip zig 19S3) 1 3 .Y9f4 Y9e7 14 ..ixc4 .ixg2 IS.Y9g3 was a disaster for Black in van der Lijn - Michel, Amsterdam 1962; D2c:3b) I I ...Y9h4 1 2.0 .ig6 13.g3 Y9e7 14.h4 �f5? I S .h5 .!Llxg3 1 6.hxg6 lLlxhl 17.gxh7+ <;t>xh 7 1 8.%'1h2+ and White won, Aiello - Nunez Bibaz, Brazil 197 1 ; D2c:Jc:) l t ...Y9e8 12.cS (1 2.0 .ig6 13 .g4, Helwig - Walther, corr 1 972, is rather too provocative on account of 13 ...lLle4! 14.fxe4 Y9xe4) 1 2 ....!Llf5 (12 ....!Llc8 1H�d4 ffi 14.l;el) 1 3.Y9f4 Y9a4 14..id3, Gutman; D2c:3d) I I ...Y9e7 12 .ge1 (1 2.cS!? might be more consistent 12 ....!Llf5 I J .gel lLlc6 14.lLJO �8 I S.Y9f4 or 12 ....!Lle8 I J .gel Y9h4 1 4.g3) 12 ... Y9h4 1 3 .cS (instead of I J . .!LJO?! .ixO 1 4.gx0 .!Llc6 I S .ggl g6 16.l;g4 Y9h5 17 .id3 rues 1 8.l;xe8+ �e8, Garcia - Gunther, corr 1980) IJ ... .!Llc4 14 ..ixc4 .ixg2 I S ..idS .ixhl 1 6 ..ixh l , Gutman; 72
Dlc:Je) l l ...f5 12.cS (if l2..ieS, then 12 ... �8 13.ixd6 cxd6 14.'f!hd6 �aS, while Meyer - Nonnan, corr 1 968, went 1 2 ... �c8 13.f3 ic6 14.�gS �e8 I SJ�d8 I :0) 1 2 ... �17 1 3 .f3 ! ? �xd2+ 14 J�xd2 .lc6 IS..icA �d7 16.�h3 h6 17 .�f4, Gutman; DlcJf) l l ...�a6 1 2.� f3 ! ? ( 1 2.�f4 �e8 13.b3 .lg6 14..ld3 �cS I S .�d4 �xd3+ 1 6�d3 fO 17.�dS+ �t7 1 8.�xf7+ Y:r-Yz Vaiser - Voekler, Groningen 1991) 1 2 ... �e8 1 3 .�d4 (after 1 3 .�gS �a4 1 4.b3 Black might play 14 ... �c6!? IS.f3 .lg6, improving on 14 -�a3+ IS.�b2 �xb2+ 1 6.�b2 i.g6, Gonzales Manchon - Car pintero, Caseres 199S, 17.b4 �8 1 8.cS) 1 3 ...�a4 ( 1 3 .. J�d8 14.f3 .lg6 1 S .h4 f6 1 6.hS) 14.b3 �a3+ I S .�b2 �cS 1 6.f3 .lg6 17 .h4 &1:8 1 8.g4 fO 19.hS .tt7 20.h6 and White holds the initiative, Gutman; DlcJg) l l ...�d7, suggested by Euwe, must be judged as the lesser evil
We examine: DlcJgl) 1 2 .�f4 �e8 1 3 .h4 �e7 1 4.�el ( 14.�h3 �fB IS .�g3 f6) 14 ...�f8 IS .hS h6 J 6_gh3 .lh7 1 7 .�e3 �xe3 1 8 .�xe3 �e8 19.�g3 f6 20.ge3 �t7 2 1 ..le2 a6 22.b3 �e4 23�e4 �xe4 turned out well for Black, Szilagyi - Krantz, corr 1 986; DlcJgl) 12.J.b4 aS 1 3 .ixd6 cxd6 14.f3 .lt5 (14 ....lc6! ? I S .�xd6 �b6 is worth trying) I S.�xd6 � 16.�d4 �c7 17.�h3 �c6 (not 1 7...�eS?! 1 8 .�f4 �c6 1 9.�dS
�8 20.�d2 b5 2 l .cxbS �c8 22 ..lc4 WfB 23.bxa6, Hatton - Adrian, corr 1 9 9 1 ) 1 8.�f4 �b6 1 9.b3 a4 with active.piece play for the pawn, Gutman; DlcJgJ) 1 2.�f3 �e8 1 3 .h4 �e7 ( 1 3 ... �cS? 14.�d4 �e6 1S .�e3 b f3 1 6.gxf3 b6 17 _ggJ fO 18.�6, Kran� - Melchor, corr 1 986) 14.�f4 &d8 leaves Black in control, Gutman; Dlc3g4) However, after 1 2. f3 ! it is not easy to find a safe place for Black's white squared bishop. 12 ....lc6 (1f l2 ....lg6, then 13 .h4 forces ugly looking 13 ...h6. Now 14.�e2 is the logical reply since 14 ...llX:S? IS.�f4 ih7, given by Borik, loses to 1 6.�d4, while 14 .. _ge8 IS .�f4 �fB 1 6.g4 isn't inspiring for Black; nevertheless 14.�d4 is good as well, for instance 14 ... fO IS .cS, Shoup Piegeler, corr 1 99S, or 1 4...�f6 I S .g4) 13.�e2 (1 3.h4 �8 14.hS h6 1 S.�t2 �g5+ 1 6.Wbl �f5 1 7.J.d3 �e3 brought White in difficulties, Walther - Thalmann, corr 1972. Also 1 3 .�d4 f6 gives Black coun ter-chances: 1 4.�h4 �e7 IS.i.d3 g6 1 6. �h3 �ae8 1 7 .� f2 �eS 1 8 .�g4 �xg4 19.�xg4.ld7 20.�4 �e3+ 2l .Wb l .lt5, Genser - Ahlin, corr 1 976, or 1 4..lb4 �e7 1S�I �t7 1 6.ixd6 cxd6 1 7.�xd6 �eS) 1 3...�8 ( 1 3 ...�xc4? 14.�d4 �deS fails to IS.b3 �xd4 1 6.ixd4 �fe8 17.bxc4 �xc4 1 8.�g3, improving on I S.f4 �xd4 16�d4 �xb2 17 .J.xb2 �g4 J 8_g(J2 �fe8, Kuhlmann - Spoel, corr 1 99 1 . 1 3 ...b6 is a bit better, yet 1 4.�d4 .lb7 1 S.�bS �xbS 1 6.cxbS �cS 1 7.�f4 keeps a plus for White) 14.�d4 � (14-�eS IS.cS, e.g. 1 5 ...�dc4 1 6.�xc6 �xd2+ 1 7 �d2 bxc6 18�2 or 1S -�c8 16.�xc6) IS.�xc6 bxc6 16.�d4 �xd4 1 7.ixd4 with a pro mising position for White, Gutman. The conclusion is that Black must play more energetically. Back to the main line 73
7.bxcl
7 ..�fS! This is an intriguing attempt to resus citate the wrialion for Black, suggested by Bo Malmsroem, Jensen. 7 ...lt:lxd6 does not promise equal chan ces, but White must react precisely: I) 8.e3 .if5 (8 ... b6 9..ia3 cS is playable as well, according to A lfonso Romero) 9..id3 �gS 1 0.ltle2 .ixd3 l l .�xd3 ltld7 1 2.�dS ( 12.0-0 �cS 1 3 Jibl 0-0-0) 1 2 ... �xdS 13 .cxd5 ltlb6 and Black retains his pawn, Gutman; II) 8.cS .if5 9.�a4+ (9.�b2 ltle4 1 O.�xb7 �f6! l l ..id2 lt:lxd2 1 2 .�xd2 0-0 1 3 .e4 lld8+ 14.<;t>c2 ltlc6) 9 ....id7 1 0.�f4 ltlf5 l l .�eS+ ( l l .�e4+ .ie6 1 2 .�xb7 .idS 1 3 .'Wbl �f6 secures Black a dangerous initiative, e.g. 1 4.�d3 0-0 1 S.lt:lf3 .ie4 16 .�xe4 �xc3+ 17.�d l gd8+ 1 8 .ltld2 gxd2+ 19 ..ixd2 �xa 1 + 20..ic 1 lt:lc6 or 14.c4 .ic6 1 S.ltlf3 lt:ld7 1 6�2 �e6 17.e3 gbs 1 8..id3 lt:lxe3 1 9 .fxe3 lt:lxcS) 1 1 ... te6 1 2..if4 lt:ld7 13.�xc7 �xc7 14.hc7 gc8 1S ..if4 (this is sounder than 1 S ..id6 lt:lxcS 1 6..ixcS �bcS 1 7.e4 lt:ld6 1 8..id3 �c3 1 9.<;t>d2 lla3 20.ltle2 �e7 2 1 .ltlc3 gds 22.ltldS+ �fB 23.ghcl lt:lxe4+ 24. .ixe4 .ixdS , Tiemann - Augustin, corr 1 988) l S ... lt:lxcS 1 6.f3 lt:le7 ! ? 1 7.e4 a6 1 8 ..id6 lt:la4 is OK for Black, Gutman;
Ill) 8.o4! 0-0 (after 8 ... 5 9.eS �e7 1 0.f4 .id7 l l ..ia3 �e6 1 2 .'Wb3 .ic6 1 3 .ltle2 lt:le4 14.lt:ld4 'l:nt 6 1 S.'Wb4 �h4+ 16.g3 �d8 1 7..ig2 <;t>f7 1 8J:idl �e8 1 9.lt:lxfS White won, Leisebein - Augustin, corr 1 988) 9..id3 lt:lc6 l O.cS! ( I O.lt:lf3 f5, e.g. l l .eS lt:lf/ 12.0-0 Y:r:-Yz Leisebein - Bwk, Corr 1 987, 12 ...ltlcxeS, or l l .exf5 .ixf5 12.cS .ixd3 13 .�xd3 �e7+. Also I O.ltle2 fS is comfortable for Black, e.g. 1 1 .0-0 fxe4 12 ..ixe4 lt:lxe4 1 3 .�xe4 lle8, Pet zold - Leisebein, corr 1 988, or l l .exfS lt:leS 1 2.0-0 �ffi 1 3 .ltlg3 lt:lxd3 14.�xd3 ixf5 1 S.lt:lx5 �xf5 16.�d4 ru"e8) 10 ...lt:le8 l l .ltlf3 .ig4 12..igS ffi 1 3M4 ( 13..ie3 ! ?) 13 .. ..ixf3 1 4.gxf3 �e7 1 S..ie3 (I S.'Wh3+? �h8 16.�xb7 �xeS 17.�b3 gbs 1 8.�c4 ltleS 19�eS �xeS 20..§bl �bl+2l�bl lt:ld6 22.�xc7? l:k8 occurred in Lenz Leisebein, corr l991) lS ...lt:leS 16�2 �8 17.llbl with a plus for White, Gutman. 8.Vb3 Other opportunities: I) After 8.dxc7 �xc7 Black dominates: A) 9.f3 lt:lg3 10.e4 lt:lxhl l l .ex5 ()..() 12.g3 �+ (12 ...ltlxg3 13.hxg3 �xg3+ 14.�12 �eS+ 1S.ltle2 ge8, HIUIS Baum, 1 6..ib2 �xf5 17.0-0-0) 1 3..ie2 �cS ( 1 3 ...ltlxg3 14.hxg3 �xg3+ IS.<Ml hS, &um, 16.�d2) 14.lt:lh3 lt:lc6 I S .�fl g e7, Gutman; B) 9.�a4+ lt:lc6 1 O.lt:lf3 (others are even worse: IO.ib2 � I I .().()..() lt:lxt2, Rues set - Matthigack, corr 1 970; 10.f3 loses to IO ...ltlg3, e.g. l l .hxg3 �xg3+ 12.�dl ()..()...()+ 13Jd2�t2 or 1 l .o4 ltlxhl 1 2.exf5 �xh2 0:1 Petzold - Leisebein, corr 1989; 10.�b5 te6 l l .f3 a6 12.�b3 lt:lg3 13.hxg3 �xg3+ 14.�dl 0-0-0+ l S ..id2 ltleS !?) 10...()..()...() 1 1 .� IDleS 1 2..ie3 ( 1 2.e3 lt:lcS 13.'WbS lt:leS 14.lt:lxeS �eS 1S.'Wb4 �d6 16�2 lt:ld3+ 17�d3 �xd3 1 8.'Wb3 .ig4 19.f3 llxe3+, de Vries - Bo nkenburg, Holland 1 96S) 12...�a5 1 3.&1 .h6 14.lt:ld2 lt:lxd2 1 S..ixd2 ltleS 1 6.e3 �c7 1 7.gb l lt:lxc4, Gutman; 74
C) 9.m3 lt:lc6 (9 ... li:lc5 !? w.m5+ lt:lbd7 l l .ltlO 0-0) l O.lt:lO (after I O..b3 0-0-0 l l .e3 g5 1 2.ltlO g4 13.lt:ld4 �d4 14.m5 .id7 1 5.cxd4 lt:lxd4 White lost quickly in Cardelli - Baurn,corr 1 99 1 ) 10 ... 0-0!? (10 ... 0-0-0 l l ..ie3) l l .e3 lt:lc5 1 2 .�d l .ie4, Gutman; D) 9.g4 .ig6 IO .f4 f5 l l .J.g2 �e7 1 2 .g5 (12be4 �4+ 1 3.<;t>dl fxe4 14.f5 �xg4 1 5.fxg6 0-0 16.gxh7+ <;t>hs 17 .m3 lt:lc6) 1 2 ...ltlc6 13.ltl0 0-0-0 (an improvement on 1 3 ... �c5 1 4.e3 0-0 1 5 .lt:ld4!? �xc4 1 6 .�b3 lt:la5 1 7 ..ifl , Rochel - Smith, corr 1967) 14.0-0 �c5+ 15.e3 �xc4 1 6. lt:lh4 (1 6.lt:ld4? fails to 16 ..hd4 17.exd4 lt:lxd4 1 8 .�b2 ltle2+ 1 9 .<;t>h l h6) 1 6... l:Dle8 1 7.lt:lxg6 hxg6 1 8 .m3 ltl a5 19.m4 b6 20..ib2 lt:lc5 are all better for Black, Gutman. II) s .m2 lt:lxd6 appears more serious. 9.c5 (in case of9.J.f4 0-0 I O.e3 I am in trigued by 10 ... lt:le4 1 1 .ltl0 c5 !? 1 2.�xb7 �a5 13..ie5 lt:ld7 14.m5 �d8, while the schematic 10 ...ltlc6 l l .ltl0 :Eib8 1 2 ..ie2 b6 13.lt:ld4 lt:lxd4 1 4.cxd4 brought White success in Shoup - Stroeher, corr 1 995) 9 ... lt:le4 I O ..ie3 (the benefit of playing 1 0 .�xb7 is shown by 1 0 ... �f6 l l ..ib2 0-0 12.�xa8 lt:lc6 13.�xm+ 'it>xm 14.lt:l0 .ie6 1 5.e3 lt:le5 16.J.e2 .ic4) 10 ... .ic8!? 1 1 .0 lt:lg5 12.�1 �e7 and Black has no complaints, Gutman.
8...� xd6 Less impressive are: I) 8...�xd6 9.�xb7 0-0 1 0.0 ( 1 0.�xa8? lt:lc6 1 1 .m1 :Eib8 12.�a6 lt:lb4 1 3 .�xd6 lt:lc2+ 14.<;t>dl lt:lxf2+ 1 5.<;t>d2 cxd6, Hildebrand/Berkell) 1 0 ... ltlc5 l l .�d5 �f6 1 2 ..ie3 �xc3+ 1 3 .<;t>f2, Gutman; II) 8 ... lt:lc6 9.�xb7 �xd6 (after 9 ...0-0 I O.dxc7 �f6 1 I .m2 &c8 12.J.f4 g5 1 3 . .ig3 lt:lxg3 14.hxg3 :Eixc7 1 5 .lt:l0 :Eib8 1 6.�d2 h6 1 7.lt:ld4 :Eicb7 1 8.f4!? lt:lxd4 19.�xd4 �xd4 20.cxd4 White won in Baldomero Garcia - Miguel Tomas, corr 1 996) IO.�xa8+ <;t>d7 1 1 .m1 ( l l .�xh8? lt:lb4 12.e3 ltlc2+ 13.<;t>e2 ltlxc3+ 14.<;t>O lt:le 1 mate NN Berkell, simultaneous Sweden 1 983) l l ...:Eib8 12.�a6 �f6 1 3 . �a3, Hildebrand/Berkell; III) 8 ...�f6 9.dxc7 (if 9.ltl0, Meyer Mohring, Obemlorf 2002, then 9 ...cxd6) 9 ... lt:lc6 I O.lt:lO 0-0 l l .J.e3 :Eiac8 1 2..id4 �d6 1 3 .g3 :Eixc7 14 ..ig2, Gutman. 9.cS �e4 9 .. .J.e6 10.�a4+ ( I O.m2 ltle4 l l .�xb7 .id5) I O .. ..id7 l l .�f4 lt:lf5 reaches a po sition after 7 ...ltl xd6 8 .c5 .if5 9.�a4+ .id7 I O.�f4 lt:lf5 . 10.Ae3 For 10.�xb7 see s.m2 lt:lxd6 9.c5 lt:le4 1 0.�xb7. 10...�c6 10 ...lt:ld7 is a daring reply in view of 1 1 .0 �4+ 1 2 .g3 �e7 1 3 .Wfxb7 0-0 1 4.J.d4 lt:lexc5 1 5 .�xc7 lt:ld3+ 1 6.<;t>d l ltlb2+ 1 7 .<;t>d2 :Eifc8 1 8 .�f4, Gutman. 1 1 .0 �f6 l l.Rdl 12.�xb7 .id7 1 3 ..ig5 :Eib8 1 4 .�a6 can be met by 14 ...h6 15.J.h4 0-0 16.e4 �e7 1 7.:Eidl �xc5, Gutman . 1 2 ... .id7 13.AgS ffe7 1 4.e4 Rb8 White 's position is not easy to defend, Gutman. -
75
Chapter 1
Third Part ( l .d4 �f6 2.c4 eS 3.dxeS � e4) 4.�d2
This is the only way to avoid simplifi cation, Anatoli Matsukevich. The big question is whether the knight on c5 is well placed or not? Harding. White has displaced the li)e4, but, after all, is his knight well placed?, Alfonso Romero. Although is normally disastrous to play the same piece three times in the fim four moves, in this unusual position it can be justified by the fact that White has con gested his own pieces with 4.li)d2, Lalic.
This move is usually played in conjun ction with an early a2-a3 to secure the bishop pair. Because its significance is mostly in restricting Black's choice, the second player needs to be aware of the various transpositional possibilities, Tim Harding. It is not easy for White to prove an ad vantage after 4.l0d2 because the knight on d2 hinders his queenside develop ment, Bogdan Lalic . However, the text move is designed to prevent the establishment of the Black 's knight en e4 and may well be the most simple way to relieve congestion in the centre.
The material divides as follows: Section 1 - 5.a3 (5.e4, 5.l0df3, 5 .b3, 5 .g3) Section 2 - 5.l0gf3 l0c6 (5 . . .d6) 6.b3 Section 3 - 5.�gf3 l0c6 6.li)b3 Section 4 - 5.l0gf3 �c6 6.e3 Section 5 - 5.l0gf3 l0c6 6.a3 Section 6 - 5.l0gf3 l0c6 6.g3 Section 7 - 5 .b4 !?.
We divide the materilll into two Chapters: Chapter 1 - 4 . . . �c5 Chapter 2 - 4 ...�b4!?.
76
more point: 8 ...'f/cS 9.e3 'f/aS+ 1 O.l0d2 'f/xd2+ l l .'flxd2 l0xd2 12.\!/xd2 or 8...a5 9.'f/c2) 8.a3 aS 9.e6 ffi 1 0.exd7+ Axd7 l l .e3 0.0.0 12.l0d4ig7 13.l0gf3 f5 looks quite promising for Black, Gutman; IV) S.g3 l0c6 (S ...hS is dubious, since both 6.Ag2 h4 7 .l0df3 Ae7 8.l0h3 l0c6 9.Ae3 l0e6 1 0.0-0 gS l l .l0d4, Hurme Maki, Uusikaupunki 1990, and 6.h4 l0c6 7 .l0df3 are in White's favour) 6.l0gf3 transposes to S.l0gf3 l0c6 6.g3, covered in Section 6.
Section 1 5.a3
There are four more possibilities: I) S.e4 l0c6 6.f4 (After 6.l0gf3 Black has two options. The first is 6 ... 'f/e7 7 ie2 lOxeS, e.g. 8.-!0xeS 'fixeS 9.'flc2 b6 10.0.0 ib7or 8.0.0 l0xf3+9.ixfl g6, improving on 8...d6 9.l0d4 g6 10.f4 l0c6 l l .l0xc6 bxc6 1 2�. HIITding. The second is 6... d 6 7.exd6 ixd6 8.a3 with another branch: 8...a5 9 .'f/c2 0-0 1 0 ie2 f5 1 1 .0-0 fxe4 12.l0xe4 1f5 13.l0fd2 lild4 14.'fldl l0xe4 0:1 Cavalcanti - Engels, Recife 1 947, or 8...'f/e7 9.'flc2it5 10.id3 0.0.0 1 1 .0-0 ig6 1 2.Ae2 l0xe4, Martinez Bejar.mo McDonald, e-mail 200 1 ) 6 ...d6 (6 ... f6 7.a3 is interesting, and now not 7 ...fxeS 8.b4 l0e6 9.f5 lOgS 1 O.'flh5+ lOfl l l .lOdO, but 7 ... a5, e.g. 8.:!!b l fxeS 9.b4 axb4 1 0. axb4 l0a4 l l .bS lOc3 12.'f/f3 l0xbl with decisive advantage for Black, Kludacz Bircher, Lyngby 1 996, or 8.exf6 'f/xf6 9.g3 d6 10.l0gf3 .lg4) 7.exd6 V9xd6 8.eS 'f/d4 (8 lOxeS 9.fxeS 'fixeS+ is doubtful due to 1 Oie2, instead Flingou - Senec haud, N iort 1 987, went 10.'fle2 l0d3+ 1 1 .\!/d l V9xe2+ 1 2.\!/xe2 .ifS 1 3 .l0gf3 0-0-0 14.l0b3 Ab4 1S.ie3 mte8) 9.l0df3 'f/xd l + 1 0.\!/xdl .ifS leaves White in grave difficulties, Gutman ; II) S.l0df3 l0c6 6..igS Ae7 7.'f/dS b6!? (7...ixgS 8.-!0xgS 'f/xgS 9.'f/xcS 'fixeS is possible) 8.Axe7 'f/xe7 9.b4 (after 9.e4 ib7 1 O..ie2, Hossain - Timman, inter net 1 998, 1 0 ... l0b4 would be annoying) 9 ...l0xb4!? 10.'f/xa8 0-0 l l .�dl .ib7 is tine for Black, Gutman; Ill) S.b3 l0c6 6.Ab2 'f/e7 7.l0df3 (for 7.l0gf3 d6 see S.l0gf3 l0c6 6.b3 'f/e7 7. .lb2 d6 - Section 2) 7 ...g6 (Brunner Toubac, Selestat 2000, continued 7...l0e4 8.'f/c2 'flh4+ 9.l0d2 l0xd2 10.'f/xd2 � l l .Ac3 aS!? 12.l0h3 Ab4 13.l0f4 hc3 14.'f/xc3 V9b4 l S.lOdS Y�Yz, but 8.a3 has
5 ... a5! 6.b3
Less challenging are: I) 6.l0gf3 a4 ! ?, Tseitlin/Giaskov, e.g. 7 .g3 d6 8.exd6 Axd6 9.Ag2 0-0 1 0.0-0 l0c6, Gutman; further U) 6.l0b3 b6 (6 ... l0c6 7.l0f3 see S.l0gf3 l0c6 6.a3 aS 7.l0b3 - Section S, Sequel l ) 7.l0f3 l0xb3(instead of7 ...Ab7 8 ..igS 'f/c8 9.e3 ltx:6 IO.l0bd4 a4 l l .ie2, Lauer Grantz, e-mail 2000) 8.'f/xb3 l0a6 9.igS Ae7, Gutman.
•.
6 ...d6!?
Other possibilities: I) 6 ... g6 7 ib2 .lg7, TSI!itlin/Giaskov, 8.b4 (8.l0gf3 l0c6 9.'f/c2 0-0 1 0.e3 'f/e7 1 1 ie2 lOxeS 12 .lOxeS AxeS 13 .l0f3 is about equa� e.g. 13 ...ig7 14.ixg7 '.!lxg7 1 S.O-O b6 16.l0d4 .ib7 17if3 Axf3 18. l0xf3 l0e6 19_gfdl d6, Jordan - Willsch, Germany 1990, or 1 3 .. .ixb2 14.'f/xb2 77
7 ..ib2 o!Llc6 8.o!Llgf3 dxe5 (8 ....if5 9.e4 o!Llxe4 IO.o!Llxe4 .ixe4 is less promising, e.g. 1 1 �. when instead of l l ...d5 12.0.0 .ixd3 13.�xd3, An:hangelsky - Vidal del Rio, Mondariz 2000, l l .. bd3 12.�xd3 dxe5 might be played, or 1 1 .exd6 .ixd6 12-'.e2 0-0 13.0-0 &8 14.&1 ge6 15.�cl gg6 16.c5 .ie7 17.�e3,Braun - Weitzer, Germany 1997, 1 7 .. ..id5 1 8.�dl �d7) 9.e4 (9.o!Llxe5 o!Llxe5 lO,j,xe5 �e7 l l .o!Llf3 .ig4 12,j,d4 0-0-0) 9 .. ,j,d6 1 O,j,e2 0-0 1 1 .0-0 B 12.�c2 fxe4 1 3.o!Llxe4 .i£5 14. o!Llfd2 o!Lld4 1 5bd4 exd4 1 6..if3 .if4 and Black won, Hunger - Schmitt, corr 1957.
b6 15.0-0.ib7. However, White should avoid 9J:�a2? 0-0 10.g3 d6 l l .exd6 Jle8 1 2.o!Llbl? .ixb2 1 3J�xb2 �f6, Knorr Svendsen, corr 1989) ll ... o!Lle6 9.�b 1 !? (both 9.lLlc4 lLlc6 1 O.o!LJ f6+ 'i!lm l l .o!LJO d6 and 9.lLlgf3 d6 10.� 1 dxe5 l l .lLlxe5 0-0 12.e3 �e7 1 3 .b5 f5 14 ..ie2 f4 are weaker) 9 ... 0-0 (9 ... o!Llc6 lO.lLlgf3 axb4 l l.axb4 g,;al 12..ixal 0-0 13.b5) lO.o!Llgf3 ges l l .e3 is fine for White, Gutman; II) 6...�e7 7.o!Llgf3 (if7.o!Lldf3 o!Llc6 8,j,b2, then not 8...�6. Tseitlin/GIIIskov, due to 9.o!Llh3 � l O.o!Llf4 gxb3 l l .lLld5 �d8 1 2.�c2 b5 1 3.o!Lld2 bxc4 14.o!Llxb3 cxb3 1 5.�c3, but 8 ...a4 9.b4 o!Llb3, viz. lO.l'l'.al? o!Llxb4, Alonso - Vidal Del Rio, Orense 2002) 7 ...o!Llc6 8,j,b2 d6, when: A) 9.exd6? o!Lld3 mate; B) 9.e3 dxe5 lO,j,e2 .iB 1 1 .0-0 gds 12 . .ic3 g6 13.�cl .ig7 l4,gdl 0-0 15.b4?!, Diehm - Klueting, Weilburg 1995, 15 ... .id3 !, Gutman; C) 9.e4 dxe5 IQ,j,e2 f6 l l .�c2 �f7 12. 0-0 o!Lle6 13,j,c3 lLJf4 14_gfel ih3 1 5,j,fl .ixg2 16.ixg2 �g6 17.o!Llh4 �g4 18.o!Lldf3 o!Llxg2 19.o!Llxg2 �xf3 with advantage for Black, Barlov - Lanzan i, Catania 1 993; D) 9.e6 �xe6 (9....ixe6 IO.�c2 f6 l l .e3 g6 12,j,e2 .ig7 is not bad either, Kiss Godard, Agneaux 1998) 10.e3 �g6 1 1 . o!Llh4 %nt6 12.lLlhf3 .ie7, Gutman; further E) 9.b4 axb4 IO.axb4 Uxal l l.�xa l o!Llxb4 1 2.�a8, Abrahams - Lenton, London 1938, 1 2 ... 'i!ld8!? (better than 1 2 ...�d8 13.exd6, e.g. 13 ...cxd6 14,j,c] o!Llc6 15.g3 f6 1 6,j,g2 .ie7 17.o!Lld4 or 13 .. ,j,xd6 14. .ixg7 ggs 15,j,c3 o!Llc6 1 6.g3) 13.g3 o!Lld7 14 ,j,g2 dxe5 15.0-0 lLlb6 16.�a 1 ffi leads to a balanced position, Gutman; F) 9.g3 ! ? dxe5 IQ,j,g2 .ig4 l l .O-O gds ( l l ...f6 12ook3 �8 13.�c2 e4 14.b4 exf3 1 5.exf3) 12.�c2 e4 13.o!Llh4 .ixe2 1 5..§el .id3 16.�dl �e6 17 ..ic3 may hold out more chances for White, Gutman.
7... .Axd6
7...�xd6 8.�c2 o!Llc6 9..ib2 .ig4 IO.l0gf3 ih5 l l .e4 .ig6 12,j,e2 �e7 1 3 .0-0 .ixe4 14.o!Llxe4 �xe4 1 5.�xe4+ o!Llxe4, Donk Tan, Holland 1992, 16. gfel 0-0-0 17.idl with a clear plus for White, Gutman. 8..Abl 'ffe7
8...0-0 9.�c2�e7 (9 ...o!Llc6 l O.o!Llgf3 .ig4 l l .e3 �d7 12-'.e2 f6 13.0-0 gfe8 14.gfel .i£5 1 5 .�d l �f7. Smit - Hawley, corr 1993, 1 6.o!Lld4) is just a transposition. 9.'ffc l 0-0
9...o!Llc6 10.o!Llgf3 0-0 (IO ...o!Lle5 l l .e3 is to White's liking: l l...g6 12,j,e2 .iB 13.e4 .id7 14.b4 axb4 1 5 .axb4 �al+ 1 6,j,xal o!Lla6 1 7.c5 o!Llxb4 1 8.�b3 1 :0 Kogan Starke, corr 1 979; l l ..,j,g4, Lazarev Stankovic, Marseille 2003, 1 2.b4 axb4 13.axb4 Uxal+ 1 4bal o!Lla6 1 5.c5 .ixf3 16.cxd6 �xd6 17 .�f5 ; 1 1 0-0 12,j,e2 ges 13.0-0 o!Llg4 14.h3 o!Llxe3 1 5 .fxe3 �xe3+ 1 6.'i!lhl �f4 1 7 .gael .iB 1 8.�c3 �g3, Esquiviel - Velasco, Mexico 1 984, 1 9. �d4 .ixh3 20.�xg7+) l l .e3 .ig4 12,j,e2 (12�3 o!Llxd3+ 13.�xd3 �8 14.�c3 f6 15.0-0, McGowan - Will, Grangemouth 1995, 1 5 ...gfe8!?) 12 ..§fe8 1 3.0-0 gadS 14.gfel .ih5 seems playable, Gutman. .•
•
lO.�gfJ b6 l l.eJ .Ab7 l l..Ael�ba6!? 13.0-0 f5 14.�d4 �e4 Black maintains the balance, Gutman.
7.exd6
78
lt:lxb3 10.\!!!/xb3 .ib4+ l l .�fl lt:lc6 1 2 .h3 .ixD 13..ixfl lt:ld4 14.\!!!/d3 lt:lxf3 15.\!!!/xf3 0-o.o are worth attention) 9.lt:lxc5 .ixc5 10ig2 lt:lc6 1 1 .0.0 0.0 (Koming - Peder sen, Aarhus 1 943, went 1 1 .._gd8 1 2.\!!!/a4 0.0 13 .J.f4 \!!!/xe2 1 4.\!!!lb5 \!!!/e7 1 5 .\!!!/xb7 .ie4 16.�Ue l f5 17 .lt:lg5? .ixf2+ 1 8 .�xf2 \!!!lc5+ 19.J.e3 §d2 + 20Jk2 l:txe2+ 2l .�e2 lt:ld4+ 22.J.xd4 YHxc4+ 0 : 1 , yet 1 7.J.g5 \!!!/d6 1 8 ..ixd8 might be critical) 12.\!!!/a4 \!!!/xe2 13.YHb5 1o4 14.\!!!/xc5 .ixf3 15.\!!!/e3 \!!!/xe3 1 6.J.xe3 .ixg2 17.�g2 lt:le5 gives Black enough counterplay, Gutman; D) 6.lt:lb3!? lt:lxb3 (neither 6 ...lt:le4 7.g3 Ae6 8ig2 d5 9.0-0, nor 6 ...lt:le6 7.g3 lt:lc6 8.exd6 .ixd6 9.J.g2 are better) 7.\!!!/ xb3 lt:lc6 (7 ...dxe5 8.lt:lxe5 \!!!f f6 9.lt:ld3 lt:lc6 10.e3.ie7 l l .J.e2) transposes to 5.lt:lgf3 lt:lc6 6.lt:lb3 lt:lxb3 7.\!!!/xb3 d6 - Section 3. 6.b3
Section 2 (l.d4 �f6 l.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.�dl �cS) s.�go
s ...�c6 5 ... d6 appears premature, when: I) 6.a3 dxe5 7.YHc2 ffi (more accurate than 7 ... lt:lc6 8.b4 lt:le6 9.e3 g5 lO.J.b2 .ig7, Morales Cano - Tomas Batet, Seville 200 1 , l l .b5) 8. b4 lt:le6 9.e3 g6 1 O ..id3 .ig7 l l . .ib2 a5, Gutman; further m 6.b4 lt:lcd7 (6 ... lt:le6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.c5 YHf6 9.l::t b 1 .ie7 1 O ..ib2 YHh6 l l .g3 a5 1 2.a3 lt:la6 13.J.c3 0.0 1 4ig2 l:M8 15.\!!!/c2 c6 16.0-0 lt:lec7 1 7.lt:lc4 gave White ad vantage, Blaho - Berg, Bratislava 1 993. Also 6...lt:lca6 7.exd6 lt:lxb4 8.dxc7 \!!!/xc7 9.a3 lt:l4a6 10.Ab2 lt:lc6, Mobuty - Maxxx, internet 2002, l l .g3 ft) 1 2ig2 /i£7 1 3.0.0 0-0 1 4.lt:lb3 favours White) 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.c5 .ie7 9.J.b2 .i.ffi (9 ...lt:lc6 1 O.b5 lt:lb4 l l .a3 lt:ld5 12 ..ixg7 �g8 1 3 ..id4 .ixc5 14.\!!!/c2 .ixd4 1 5.lt:lxd4 YHffi 16.\!!!/01+ 1 lt:le7, Passerotti - Lochte, Porto San Giorgio 1 996, 1 U:tc 1) 1 O ..ixf6 \!!!fxf6 l l .a3 a5, Gutman; similarly III) 6.exd6 .ixd6 7.g3 \!!!/e7 !? (7 ... lt:lc6 reaches a position after 5.lt:lgf3 lt:lc6 6.g3 d6 7 .exd6 .ixd6, covered in Section 6, Sequel 2) 8.lt:lb3 .its (also 8 ... 0-0 9.J.g2 �8 10.lt:lxc5 .ixc5 l l .YHb3 ib4+ 12�2 .ixd2+ 1 3.lt:lxd2 lt:ld7 or 8 ...J.g4 9 ..ig2
6 Yre7 Alternatives: I) 6 ... g5 7 ..ib2 .ig7 8.\!!!/c2 (8.e3 d6 is innocuous, e.g. 9 ..ie2 dxe5 1 0.0-0 .if5 l l .b4 lt:lxb4 1 2.J.xe5 .ixe5 13 .lt:lxe5 \!!!/d6 14.e4 YHxe5 1 5 .exf5 0-0-0 1 6 . .if3 \!!!/c3 and Black won, Demirei - Kogan, Vlis singen 1 996, or 9.lt:ld4 lt:lb4!? 10.lt:l2f3 dxe5 l l .a3 lt:lba6 12.b4 exd4 1 3.bxc5 g4 14.lt:lxd4 lt:lxc5!? - an improvement on 14 ...0.0, when instead of l 5.g3 c6 1 6.\!!!/c2 lt:lxc5 17.0-0-0 \!!!/a5 18.h3 \!!!/a4 19.hxg4 •••
79
�xc2+ 20.�xc2 hg4 2 l .f3 .id7 22..m.5 �a4 23..ial We8 with equality, Ulko Gorbatov, Moscow 1 997, 1 5.c6!? bxc6 16 ..id3 �c5 17 ..ic2 could be played-, l 5 .�c6 �xdl+ lH!xd l f6 1 8.�b4 .ie6) 8...�e7 9.e3 �e5 lO.�xe5 (1 o.�d4!? d6 1 1 ,je2 .id7 12.0-0) 1 0 �..ixe5 1 1 ,je2 d6 1 2.0�0 with an edge for White, Gutman; D) 6 ... g6 7.e3 .ig7 8..ia3 !? � 9.�c2 (more logical than 9.gcl �xe5 l O.�xe5 he5 l l ..id3 d6 l2.�f3 .ig7 1 3 .c 5 c6, Back - Schneider, corr 1995) 9 ... �xe5 1 0 .�xe5 he5 l l .gdl d6 1 2.g3 0-0 13 . .ig2 and I prefer White, Gutman; Dl) 6 ... d6!? is a better interpretation of Black's possibilities, 7.exd6 (7..ib2 dxe5 8.e4 .td6 9.a3 a5 see Section 1 . 8.�xe5?! can be punished by 8...�xe5 9..ixe5 �e7 lO.�f3 .ig4, Bruene - Van Hove, Ger� many 200 1 , l l .�d4 .ixf3 1 2.gxf3 f6 1 3 . .if4 �e6 14.�e4 �xf4 1 5 .�xf4 �b4+ 16.�dl .id6, although 8-�ffi 9.�df3 is also none too impressive for White, e.g. 9 ....id6 I O.�xc6 �xb2 l l .�d4 �a3 12. �xg7 g f8 or 9.. ..if5 10.�c l �b4 I I .ll:ld3 �cxd3+ 12.exd3 �e6+ l3.�d2 0-0-0 as in Gogollok - Schork, Hassloch 1 997) 7 .. ..ixd6 (if7...� ffi 8Ja3 hd6, then not 9 ..ixc5?! hc5 I O.e3, Vincze - Libich, Jihlava 1 99 1 , due to l O ... �b4, but 9.b4 �e6 I O.l0e4 hb4+ I l ..ixb4 �g6 1 2 . lLld6+ cxd6 13..ixd6 ll:led4 14.�xd4 �xd6 1 5.e3 0-0 1 6..ie2) 8..ib2 �e7 9.e3 .ig4!? (9...0-0 l O..ie2 .ig4 1 1 .0-0 &d8 is pos sible as well. Less appealing is 9 ... .if5 l O..ie2 0-0-0 1 1 .0-0 etJe4 12 .�d4, while I O..ixg7 gg8 is quite risky for White, e.g. l l ..Ac3 0-0-0 12.ll:ld4 �d4 13..ixd4 l004 or I l .t0d4 jd7 12.�xc6hc6 13� 0-0-0 14.�h5 �e4) l O..ie2 ( l 0.a3 .ie5 l l .�c2 hb2 12.�xb2 0-0 1 3 ..ie2 &d8 or IO..ixg7 gg8 l l ..ic3 .ie5 1 2.�cl hc3 13.�xc3 0-0-0 14. ie2.ixf3 15.ixfl �e5) 1 0 ... 0-0-0 1 1 .0-0 ( l l..ixg7 gg8 1 2 ..ic3 is met by 12 .. ..ixf3 13 ..ixf3 .ie5 14..ixe5
�xe5, and if l l .�c2 �b4 l 2.�c3 ht3, e.g. 13..ixf3? .ie5, Tosunogly - Huebner, Germany 1 997, or 1 3.�xf3 �bd3+ 14. hd3 �xd3+ 15.�fl �xb2 16.�xb2 f5) l l ...f5 keeping contro� Gutman. 7 ..ibl d6 8.e3 Most legal moves have been tried here: I) 8.exd6? �d3 mate Klebe1 - Brauening, Germany 1 990; H) 8.b4 �b4 9.�1 dxe5 (9....Ae6 lO..ic3 �c6 l l .e3 0-0-0 12.exd6 �xd6 is not bad either, Eeckhout - Tinture, corr 1 996) I O.�xe5 .ie6 l l ..ic3 �a4, Gutman; m) 8.a3 dxe5 !? (8...�xe5 9.�xe5 dxe5 1 0.b4 �d7 l l .c5 g6 12 .g3 .ig7 13 ..ig2 0-0 14.0-0) 9.e4 (9.b4 e4 1 0.�d4 �d3+ l l .exd3 exd3+) 9 .. .f5, Gutman; IV) 8.�c2 dxe5 (8...�xe5 9.�xe5 dxe5 1 0.e4 a5 l l ..ie2 g6 12.0-0.ig7 13.f4 0-0 14.�c3 M8 15.fxe5 he5 1 6.�xe5 �xe5 17..ixe5 gxd2 1 8 .&dl �xe4? 1 9_gxd2 �xd2 20.gd I , Struylaart - Bruyntjes, HoUand 1938)9.e4 (9.a3 e4 10.� �d3+ 0: I Moor - Lanzani, S ilvaplana 1 993) 9 ....ig4 I O ..ie2 0-0-0, Gutman; V) 8.g3 dxe5 9..ig2 .ig4 (9 ....if5 l O.�h4 .ig4 is met by 1 1 .0-0 0-0-0 12 ..ixc6 bxc6 13.�e I , instead of l l .�e4? �xe4 12 ..ixe4 �b4+ 1 3.�fl gd8 1 4..ixc6+ bxc6 15.�cl ihl+ 1 6.ll:lg2 ffi, Doncea David, Bucharest 200 1 ) 1 0.0-0 0-0-0 1 1 . h3 .ih5!? (l l ....ixf3 1 2 .exf3 f5 1 3 ..ic3 g5 14.b4 �d3 1 5 .b5 �d4 1 6..ixd4 �d4 17.�b3 gd7 18.�c2 .ig7, Lanchava Pallova, Policka 1 996, 19.c5) 1 2 .�h4 �f6 13 .�e 1 �d4 14 ..ixd4 exd4 is fine for Black in each case, Gutman. 8... dxe5 8.. ..if5?! 9.exd6 �xd6 l O.�d4 �xd4 1 1 . hd4 0-0-0 12..ie2 �d3+ 1 3..ixd3 bd3 14.c5 (14.lOf3? �g6 15_ggJ .ib4+ 16.�d2 �d4, Drobusch - Schuttrich, corr 1 982) 14 ...�d5 1 5 .� f3 . Gutman. 9.le2 .ifS l0.0-0 ��0 1 1.a3 �d3 Black 's game is much freer, Gutman. 80
Section 3 (l.d4 �f6 2.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.�d2 �cS S.�gfJ �c6) 6.�b3
Galyas - Harding, Budapest 2000) 7... li)xe5 8.li)xe5 �xe5 9..ic3 �e4 to.li)xc5 .ixc5 l l .e3 0-0 1 2 .�d2 d6 13..id3 �xg2 (I L�g4 1 4.h3 �5 15.g4 .ixg4 l 6.�gl �xh3 17 ..if5 h5 1 8..ixg4 hxg4 19.�d5) 14.0�0 and White obtains the initiative, Gutman; III) 6 ... b6, then: A) 7 ..ig5 .ie7 8.li)xc5 .ixg5 (instead of 8...bxc5 9..if4 0-0 IO.g3 �b8 l l.�d2 m>4 1 2.�cl �e8 1 3..ig2 g5 1 4.li)xg5 li)xe5 1 5 .0-0 �b6 1 6.li)e4 li)xc4 17 .�xc4 d5 1 8.�xc5 .ixc5 1 9 .li)xc5 1 :0 Bricard Toulzac, Toulon 1 998) 9.li)d3 (or 9.li)e4 .if4 I O.e3 .ixe5 l l .li)xe5 li)xe5 1 2 .�d5 li)c6) 9 .. ..ih6 IO.g3 (I O.e3 0-0 l l ..ie2 �e7 12.0-0 g6) 1 0 ... 0-0 l l ..ig2 �e7 1 2 . �O �b8 13 .e3 g6 14.�a4 a6 15.�c2 .ig7 seems playable for Black, Gutman ; B) 7 ..id2! ? li)e4 8.e3 .ib7 9..id3 li)xd2 I O.li)bxd2 .ib4 1 1 .0-0 ! ? ( l l .a3 .ixd2+ 1 2.�xd2 �e7 transposes to 4.li)f3 .ib
6... �xb3 Other possibilities: I) 6 ...li)e6 7 ..id2 (7.e4 d6 8.exd6 .ixd6 9..ie2 .ib4+ I O.�fl �xdl+ l l ..ixdl b6 1 2..ie2 .ib7 13..ie3 �0 14.e5 aS 15J:tdl a4 1 6.li)cl a3 1 7.b3 .ic3 1 8.li)d3 f6 was OK for Black in Nimzo 1 998 - Hiarcs 6, computer game 1 998) 7. ..aS ( Cr:ha - Ple tanek, Czech Republic 1 99 1 , continued 7 ...b6 8.e3 .ib7 9..ie2 �e7 1 0.0-0 0-0-0, when l l ..ic3 g5 1 2.li)fd4 might be tried) 8.e3 ib4 9.a3 .ixd2+ IO.�xd2 �0 I I J.d3 b6 (if l l ... li)g5 1 2 .li)xg5 �xg5 1 3 .f4) 1 2.0-0 with a plus for White, Gutman; II) 6 ...�e7 7..id2 (7 ..if4 li)e6 8..id2 g6 9..ic3 .ig7 causes less problems. I O.e3 0-0 l l..ie2 is met by l l ..lk8 12.0-0 li)c5 13 .li)xc5 �xc5 14.�d5 �e7 15.c5 li)xe5 1 6.li)xe5 .ixe5 1 7.&cl c6 18.�xe5 �xe5 l9.he5 �e5 20lH"dl b6. After IO.g3 0-0 l l ..ig2 Black has a choice between 1 1 ... �e8 12.0-0 li)c5 l 3 .li)xc5 �xc5 14.�d5 �e7 15.e3 li)xe5 1 6.li)xe5 .ixe5 and I I ... li)c5 12.li)xc5 �xc5 1 3 .�d5 �e7 14.� lk8 15.th3 l:M8 16.e3 d6 1 7.hc8 �axeS, improving on 13. . .d6 14.�xc5 dxc5 151Fdl .ie6 1 6.b3 li)b4?! 1 7 ..ixb4 cxb4 1 8.tai4 .ixe5 l9.li)xe6 -*c3+ 20.� txe6 2l..hb7, 81
1 996, and 8.g3 is hannless on account of 8 ...dxe5 9 .'tYxd8+ 'it>xd8 1 O..ig2 i.d6 l l.ltJxe5 ltJxe5 12..ixe4 ltJxc4 13..id5 .ie6) 8 . � 9.exd6 ltJxd6 appears to be more complicated than evaluated in theory. Now: A) 1 0.ltJc5 'tYffi l l .e4 0-0-0 1 2.exf5 ltJe8 13.ltJe4 'tYe7 14.ffi (14..ig5 ltJffi 15..ixffi gxffi 1 6.'tYb5 'tYxe4+ with a massive attack against the white king, Bogdan Lillie) 14 ... ltJxf6 1 5 .'tYf5+ a:d7 1 6.i.d3 ( 1 6..ie3?! 'tYxe4 17.'tYxe4 ltJxe4 1 8.g3 f5 1 9.a:dl a:xd l + 20.'it>xdl i.c5 2 1 .i.xc5 ltJxc5 was seen in Kozul - Mohr, Ljub ljana 1 989) 16 ... ltJxe4 1 7 .0-0 ( 1 7i.xe4 fails to 1 7 ... g6 followed by 1 8 ... f5, La lic) 1 7...�c5 1 8.a:e l 'tYd8 19.i.c2 g6 20. 'tYh3 f5 ! (Fritz 6 - Gambit Tiger, com puter game 200 1, went 20 ..ig7 2 l ..ie3 ltJe6 22.i.a4 f5 23.l:i:ab 1 l:i:d3 24.i.xc6 bxc6 25..ih6 A.xh6 26.'tYxh6 'tYf6 27.ltJe5 wilh advantage for White) 2 l .b4 (2l .J.g5 i.e? 22 . .he7 fue7 23 .b4 ltJe6 24.a:ad 1 ltJed4 gave Black a plus, Little Goliath Fritz 6, computer game 200 1 ) 2 l ...i.g7 22..ig5 'tYg8 23.a:adl (23.bxc5 hal 24. a:xal 'tYxc4) 23..fudl (23 ...'tYxc4 24fud7 ltJxd7 25.'tYxh7! tvn 26.i.b3) 24.a:xd l h6 (24 ...'tYxc4? 25..ixf5+ gxf5 26.'tYxf5+ ltJe6 27.a:e l ) 2 5 ..ie3 'tYxc4! 26.i.xf5+ gxf5 27.i.xc5 'tYg4 is equal, Gutman; B) IO..ig5 !? i.e? (if 10 .. .f6 l l ..if4 ltJe7 1 2.'tYd4) l l .ltJc5 ( l l .i.xe7 ltJxe7) 1 1 ... 'tYc8 ( l l ....ixg5 can be met by 12.ltJ xb7! ltJe7 1 3.ltJxd8 ltJxd5 14.ltJxg5 ltJe7 15 .c5 a:xd8 16.cxd6 a:xd6 1 7.a:c l ) 12.e4 i.g4 ( 1 2 ..ie6 13.ltJxe6 fxe6 1 4.'tYd3) 1 3 .ltJd4 0-0 ( 1 3 ... .hg5 14.ltJxc6 .if4 15 .'tYd4 f6 1 6.ltJd3 i.h6 1 7.ltJxa7) 1 4. ltJxc6 bxc6 1 5 .'tYd2 ltJxc4 16..ixc4 .hc5 17 . ..a:cl se cures an edge for White, Gutman. V) Perhaps it is just a question of taste, but to me the ancient 6 ... ffi!? looks fully viable, immediately exerting strong pres sure on e5.
We examine: A) 7.g3 fxe5 8.ig2 ltJxb3 (8 ...'tYffi?! 9.0-0 h6 I O..ie3 ltJe6 l l .ltJfd2 g5 12.ltJe4, Szir may - Pusztay, Budapest 1 998) 9.'tYxb3 (9.axb3 i.b4+ 1 O..id2 �e7 1 1 .0-0 i.xd2 1 2.'tYxd2 0-0) 9 ...i.b4+ I O.i.d2 i.xd2+ l l .ltJxd2 0-0, Gutman ; B) 7.ltJxc5 .hc5 8.exf6 (8.e6 is dubious as 8 ...dxe6 9.'tYxd8+ 'it>xd8 or 8 ...'tYe7 !? 9.e3 dxe6 1 O..id2 e5, Thomsen - Simon sen, Oy1dbakki 2000, shows. 8.'tYd5 Jb4+ 9.'it>d l , Frantisek Nepustil, is best an swered by 9 ...b6 1 0 .a3 i.fB l l .b4 i.b7 1 2..ib2 l:i:b8 as 9 ...d6 does not work well due to I O.exfti 'tYx.fti l l .fth5+ g6 12.�g5 'tYf7 1 3 .'tYe3+ 'it>d8 14.'tYf4) 8 ...'tYxffi 9.a3 d6 1 O.e3 0-0 l l .i.e2 i.f5, Gutman; C) 7.exf6 'tYxffi 8.g3 (8.a3 ltJe6 9.g3 a5 1 O..ig2 a4 l l .ltJbd2 ltJc5 12.0-0 �7) 8 ... ltJe4 !? (8 ... ltJxb3 9.'tYxb3 i.b4+ I O.i.d2 makes White's task easier. 1 0 ...i.xd2+ l l .ltJxd2 0.0 is met by 12.ltJe4 'tYf7 13..a:cl b6 14.i.g2 ib7 15 .0-0 a:ae8 16.'tYdl, while after 10 ...ic5 he has two options: l l .'tYc3 'tYe7 1 2.a3 d6 1 3 .i.g5 �n 1 4.i.e3 0-0 1 5..ixc5 dxc5 16.� ltJd4 17.ltJxd4 cxd4 1 8 .'tYxd4 c5 19.'tYxc5 i.e6 20.i.g2 a:ac8 21.'tYe3 .ho4 22.'ttbl a:ce8 23.'tYxa7, Little Goliath - Gambit Tiger, computer game 200 1 , or l l .i.g2 !? ltJd4 1 2.ltJxd4 i.xd4 1 3 .e3 i.xb2 1 4.a:b l i.e 5 1 5 .c5) 9.'tYc2 (9.a3 ltJe5 I O.tg2 ltJxc4 1 1 .().() c6 12.ltJfd4
_
•
82
d5 13.�c2 /t)ed6 14.J.f4 j,e7 15.e4 dxe4 16./t)xc6 bxc6 17 .hd6 �xd6 1 8.�xc4 ie6 19.�c2 0-0 20.&dl �e5 2 1 ./t)d4 e3 22. /t)xc6 exf2+ 231W2 �c7 24./t)xe7+ �xe7 25 . .haS gxa8 26.�c6 1 :0 Stahlberg Reinhardt, Niendorf 1 934, yet we can improve with 13 ... /t)b6!? 14 .J.xe4 dxe4 15.�xe4+ j,e7 1 6.J.f4 0-0) 9...J.b4+ (9 ... d5 10.cxd5 j,b4+ l l .j,d2 j,fS 12.Axb4 /t)xb4 13.�c4 �b6 14./t)fd4 0-0-0, HlllrS Baum, 1 5.a3 /t)xd5 1 6J.g2 liihe8 1 7.0-0 leaves Black with difficult problems to solve; however, insufficient is 12 .ti'dl 0-0-0 1 3 .dxc6 /t)xd2 1 4.cxb7+ �b8 1 5 . /t)fxd2 gxd2 1 6 ./t)xd2, Baum, not be cause of 16 ...ti'xb2 1 7 .J.g2 hd2+ 1 8 . ti'xd2 ti'xal+ 19.�dl ti'c3+ 20.�1 , but due to 16 .. _gd8 1 7.J.g2 �d2 18.0-0 �dl 1 9.&xdl j,d6 20.� ti'e7 2 l _gfdl j,e4) IO..id2 (more precise than 10./t)bd2 ti'f5 l l.Jh3 /t)d4 12.�d3 /t)xf3+ 1 3.�xf3 ti'e5 1 4.�f4 �xf4 1 5 .gxf4 gm 1 6.e3 g5) 1 0 ... hd2+ l l ./t)bxd2 /t)c5 12.a3 ( 12./t)b3 /t)b4 1 3 .�d2 /t)cd3+ 14 .exd3 �xf3 15.�e2+ �xe2+ 1 6.�xe2 d5) 1 2 ...d6 are all OK for Black, Gutman .
Bawnann - Gikas, Germany 1 988, or 9_b6 10.g3 j,b7 l l .J.g2 /t)xe5 - instead of 1 1 ...0-0-0 12.0-0 h5 1 3 .ti'd2 h4, Ka man - Pusztay, Hungary 2000, 14..ixb4 /t)xb4 1 5 .gxa7 - 1 2 .0-0 hc3 1 3 .bxc3 0-0 14./t)xe5 hg2 15 .�g2 �xe5 16.�d4 me8 with equality) 9...0-0 1 0.J.e2 /t)xe5 l l ./t)xe5 hd2+ 12.�xd2 �xe5 13.0-0 d6 14.j,f3 a6 (Crafty - Brause, computer game 1 997, went 1 4 ...ges 1 5 J�a5 �f6 1 6_gdl a6 17.�c3 �g6 1 8.�d4 m,8 19.c5, when 1 9...b6 20.cxb6 gxb6 2 l .b4 j,e6 might be tried) 1 5 .b4 gb8 16.mc l gds 11.ga3 Ae6 and Black is defmitely not worse, Moskalenko - Mohr, Bled 1 99 1 . 7 ..Ab4+ 7...d6 8.Ag5 �d7 (there is little promise in 8 j,e7 9.he7 �xe7 1 0.exd6 �xd6 l l .gdl , Musso - Zimmermann, e-mail 200 1 , l l ...�e7 12 .e3 0-0 13.Ae2, or 8 ...ffi 9.exffi gx.ffi 10..id2 a5 l l .a4 j,d7 12.e3 b6 1 3 .j,e2 �e7 1 4./t)d4 0-0-0 1 5 ./t)b5 h5 1 6./t)c3 �g7 1 7.ggl /t)e5 1 8./t)d5, Kris tensen - Olsen, Copenhagen 2000) 9.exd6 (9_gdl �g4 1 0.h3 �e6 l l .�c3 dxe5 1 2 . /t)xe5 f6 1 3 ./t)xc6 �xc6 1 4.Af4 j,e7 or 9.0-0-0 �g4, Roger Thomsen, are both less clear) 9 .. ..hd6 10.�e3+ �e6 l l .a3 0-0 1 2.�xe6 j,xe6 n .gc l did not give Black full compensation, Gutman. 8..Adl ..
• .
Back into the main line
7.1hb3 7.axb3 Ab4+ 8.Ad2 �e79.e3 (after 9..ic3 Black can play 9 ... /t)xe5 10./t)xe5 hc3+ l l .bxc3 �xe5 1 2.�d4 d6 13.�xe5+ dxe5,
8 aS! ...
83
8 .. .ixd2+ 9.�xd2(9.�xd2 0-0 l OJ:idl l:le8 l l .tvc3 �xeS 12.�xeS tvgS+ l3 .e3 tv xeS, Moriana Garcia - Heesen, e-mail 200 1 ) 9..�xeS (9 ...tve7 1 O.f4 d6 l l .exd6 tvxd6 1 2 .e3 iB 13.0-0-0 0-0-0 1 4 .ie2 l:lhe8 1S.�e4 tve7 16.�g3) looks less inspiring to me, when: I) 10.�f3 tve7 l l .�xeS tvxeS, Pompoes Reinicke, Germany 1 992; further m 10.g3 0-0 (l O ...tve7 l l .ig2 d6 1 2.<�0 �c6 l3.e4 0-0 14.f4.l:le8, Rosner - Baer, corr 200 1 ) l l .ig2 aS (or l l ...d6 1 2.0-0 aS l3.tvc3 tve7 Yl-Yl Nicoara - Lanzani, French League 1 999) 1 2.tvc3 tve7 13.0-0 d6 (13 &6 is less sound due to 14.�b3 a4 1 S .�d4, while Nicoara - Herbrechts meier, French League 200 1 , continued 14.�0 �xf3+ 1 S.ixf3 � 1 6.tvc2 l:ld6 1 7 .l:lfdl l:lxdl+ 1 8 .l:lxdl d6 1 9.a3 \Wb6 20.tvc3 ie6 2 l .idS c6 Yz-Yl) 14.�b3 a4 1 S .�d4 c6 seems harmless, Gutman; Ill) IO.tvg3 ! tve7 (if 10 ...�g6 l l .h4 0-0 1 2 .hS �e7 l3.h6 �B 14.tvg4 g6 1 S .e4 �d4 1 6.0-0-0) l l .f4!? ( l l .tvxg7 �d3+ 12.�dl �xt2+ 1 3 .�e l �d3+ with per petual) l l...�g6 12.13 (an improvement on 12.e4 ffi 13�2 0-0 14.0-0 b6 1S�? tvcS+ 16.l:lt2 tvxhS, Grosse Frintrop Renn, Germany 1999) 12 ...�eS l3.tvxg7 �d3+ 14.�dl �t2+ 1S.�c2 l:lfl! 16.l:lgl dS ( 1 6...tve3 1 7 .g4 �e4 1 8.tveS+ �d8 1 9.�0) 17.g4 hS 1 8.cxdS �xg4 ( 1 8 ... hxg4 19.e4! �xe4 20.l:lel .ixB 2 l .tvd4) 19.e4 �e3+ 20.�d3 �xfl 2 l .�xfl .id7 22.tvd4 with advantage, Gutman. 9.a3 a4 1 0.tfe3 .Axdl+ l l .tfxdl l l .�xd2 0-0 1 2.f4 can be met by 12 ... ffi. ll ...tfe7 ll.tfcl 0-0 13.!dl !e8 14.l:ld5 b6 15.e3 .Ab7 16 ..Ae2 �d8!? 16 ...�b8 17 .l:ld4 &5 is another way to play, viz. 1 8.0-0 .AxO 19 ..ix0 l:lxeS 20.tvc2 &S 2 l .idS �a6!? 22.l:le4 tv f8 23.l:lf4 l:le7 24.l:ld l �cS , Gutman. 1 7,gd2 �e6 18.0-0 �c:S 19.gd4 gadS Black is quite comfortable, Gutman.
Section 4 (l.d4 �f6 2.c:4 e5 3.dxe5 �e4 4.�d2 �c:S S.�gO �c:6) 6.e3
.•
6...d6!? Less effective are: I) 6 ... gS 7..Ae2 (7.h3 .Ag7 has its draw backs, for example 8..ie2 tve7 9.a3 �xeS l O.�xeS .AxeS 1 1 .�0 .Af6 1 2.tvc2 d6 l3.lt)d4 .Ad7 14.b3 �e4 1Sb2 cS 16.�f3 .if5 17.id3 �xt2 1 8.� .Axd3 19.ixffi .ixc2 20.ixe7 �xe7, Johansson - Moe Nielsen, R.wlaberg 198S, or 8.�d4 �xeS 9.�2f3 d6 lO.tvc2 tvffi l l .ie2 hS 12.l:lbl g4 1 3llxg4 hxg4 14_gm8+ .Axh8 1S.�d2, Zoumatsidis - Kogan, Athens 1999, lS ... tvh4) 7.. .ig7 (7...g4 8.�d4 �xeS 9.�b 1 hS 1 0.�c3 d6 l l .b3 .Ag7 12.ib2) 8.�bl �xeS 9.�d4 d6 1 0.�c3 yields an edge for White, Gutman ; m 6 ...g6 7.b3 !? (if 7.�b3 �xb3 8.tvxb3 .ig7 9..Ad2 tve7 1 O.ic3, then not 1 0 ... 0-0 l l .ie2 b6 12.0-0 .ib7 1 3.l:lfd l &d8 14. &c l �xeS l S .�xeS .ixeS 1 6.cS tvgS 17 ..ifl .ixc3 1 8 .tvxc3 1c6 1 9 .b4 with a slight plus for White, Psakhis - Zapata, Fide Wch, Las Vegas 1999, but l O...�xeS l l .�xeS 1xeS 1 2 . .Ae2 aS !? 1 3 ..AO a4 14.tvc2 d6 l S .0-0, Leonard - Gibson, Dublin 1993, l S...O-O) reaches a position after s.�gO �c6 6.b3 g6 7.e3, treated in Section 2; 84
IU) 6..'fle7 is the most natural reply, 8.a3 though White is still a bit better after Alternatively: I) 8.lLlb3 lLlxb3 9.'flxb3(9.axb3 'flf6 1 0. 7.J.e2 (for 7.a3 see 6.a3 'fle7 7.e3 - Sec tion S , Sequel 2 ) 7 ... lLlxeS 8 .0-0 lLlxO+ �d4 0-0 l l .li.d3 ltlxd4 1 2.exd4 ges+, Damjanovic - Bosnic, Belgrade 2003) (8...g6 9.lLlxeS 'fixeS I O.lLJO 'flf6 1 1 � 1 li.g7 l2.b4!? ltle4 l 3 .i.b2 ltlc3 14 .1i.xc3 9...'flffi 1 O.J.e2 1i.f5 l l .'flxb7 0-0; further 'flxc3 lS.lLld4 li.xd4 16.exd4 'fla3 17.'fld2) D) 8 .ltld4 0-0 (in Muster - Behling, corr 1 987, Black was unsuccessful with 8... 9.ltlx0, Gutman. lLlb49.lLl2f3 1i.g4 1 O.a3 1xt3 l l .gxf3 ltlc6 7.exd6 1 2.b4 ltle6 l3.ltlxc6 bxc6 14..ib2 0-0 l S . 7.ltlb3 dxeS 8.'flxd8+ l!ixd8 9.lLlxcS hcS 1 O.J.d2 �e7 l l .J.c3 f6 12 .a3 a5 1 3.0-0-0 cS �7 16J.c4 a5 1 7-ilg l , while 8 ...ltlxd4 9.exd4 'fle7+ 10 �2 ltld3+ l l .�fl ltlxcl li.f5 14.id3 i.xd3 1 S.fu.d3 mtd8 16.fu.d8 gxd8 1 7Jldl gxdl+ 1 8 .�xd l �e6 1 9. 12 .gxc 1 0-0 1 3.gc3 did not promise him ltld2 �7 20.�c2 a4 2 l .lLlbl lLlb8 22.Ad2 enough for the pawn) 9.ltlxc6 (if9.lLlbS ltld 7 gave Black a fine ending, Pomar - li.fS) 9 ...bxc6 10.ltlf3 ( I O ..ie2 is met by 10 ... 'flgS, e.g. 1 1 .0-0? li.h3 12./i.O 'fleS, Bisguier, Hollywood 1 9S4. 7.. .lxd6 l l .lLJO 'flxg2 12.ggl 'flh3 1 3.b4 ltle6 or 7 ...'flxd6 8.J.e2 (8.ltlb3? 'flxdl+ 9.�xdl l l .g3 1i.h3 12.b4 ltle6 1 3 .cS ii.e7 14.lLJO 'flf6) lO ...lLle4 l l .li.d3 ( l l .a3? li.g3 or ltle4 l O.�e l lLlb4, Goldberg - Feicht, Braunfels 1998, or 8.a3 a5 9.b3 'flg6 10. l l .li.e2 1i.b4+ 12.�fl 'fle7 1 3.'flc2.ges 14.a3 id6 lS .J.d3 f5 are even worse) 1 1 ... li.b2 1i.e7 are less impressive for White) 8 .../i.fS 9.0-0 0-0-0 1 O.ltlb3 ( 10.a3 'flf6 .tb4+ 12.c;t>e2 f5 1 3.'flc2 'fle7 give White a plenty of problems, Gutman; 1 1 .� .tbl 12.gal li.fS leads to a draw by repetition, while Finegold - Sprague, Ill) 8 .1i.e2, and now: USA 198 1, ended abruptly with l l .e4?! A) 8 ...0-0 9.0-0 (9.ltld4 'figS !, improving ltlxe4 12.ltlxe4 1i.xe4 13.'flel h6 14.&2 on 9 ...1i.d7 1 0.0-0 ltlb4, Jaeger - Back, corr 1 99S, l l .ltl20 'flf6 12..id2) 9 ...'flffi li.d6 lS .J.e3 ghe8 16.cS li.xcS 1 7 .J.xcS (9.. _ges 1 O.ltlb3 ltle4 l l .lLlbd4 lLleS 12. li.xO 18 .J.e3 li.dS 19 .ga 1 'flg6 0: 1 ) 10 ... 'flf6 l l.ltlbd4 .io4 12.ge1 .ht3 ( 12 ...Ad6 lLlbS lLlxO+ 13 ..ixf3, Wohlers - Kava sjukova, Prague 1989) 1 O.ltlb3 ( 1 O.a3 li.f5 1 3 .ltld2) 1 3 .li.xO ltlxd4 14 .exd4 'fl xd4 l S .'flxd4 gxd4 1 6.1i.dS with some pres 1 1 .ga2 �d8!? 1 2 .b4 ltld3; this is more sure for White, Gutman . accurate than l l ...aS 1 2.b3 gadS 13 .g3, e.g. 13 ...gS 14.ib2 'f/g6 lS.'flcl h5 1 6.'flc3 f6 1 7.ltld4, Wild - Schratzenstaller, Bad Woerishofen 2002, or l 3 ... gfe8 1 4.1i.b2 'fle7 l S .ge l ) 10 .../i.fS ( I O ... gds gives Black sufficient activity to compensate for his material deficit, Bogdan Lillie; yet in my opinion l l .lLJ bd4 - instead of l l .lLlxcS ii.xcS 1 2.'flb3 aS !? 1 3 .1i.d2 a4 14.'flc3 'flg6 l S.gfd l li.h3 1 6./i.fl li.g4 Y:z-Yz Lputian - Eolian, Yerevan 1 977 -, l l .. .J.g4 1 2 .b3 1i.x0 1 3 .J.xf3 is OK for White, e.g. l 3 .. ..ixh2+? 14.�xh2 ltlxd4 1S.exd4fud4 16.'fle2 g),4+ 17.�gl 'flxal 8S
lS,j,gS or l3 .. ieS 14.hc6 bxc6 1S.�e2 .hd4 16.exd4 lLle6 1HVe5 lLlxd4 1 S.�xffi gl(ffi 19�h6) l l .lLlbd4 !? ( l l .lLlxcS AxeS 12.�3 lLlaS l 3 .�a4 b6 14J:tdl gadS is less convincing) 1 1 .. _gadS 1 2,j,d2 i.e4 (l2 ... lLlxd4 13.exd4 lLle4 14ie3 cS 1S.i.d3 cxd4 16.ixd4 Yflb6 17 .i.e3 brings Black no success either, as 17 ...YfihS lS.g3 lLlc3 19.bxc3 .bd3 20.�xd3 �xt3 2 l .�d5 or 17 ...if4 1S ..bf4 �xf4 1 9 .�c2 shows) 1 3.�3 �g6 ( 13...� 14.g3 lLleS lS.lLld2) 14.g3 lLleS l S.lLlh4 (Gref- Brause, com puter game 1997, went l S.lLlxeS? AxeS 16l!cl lLld3 17gc2 .hd4 1 8.exd4 lLlf4 0:1) 1S ...Yflh6 1 6.f4 and White is able to de fend himself, Gutman; B) S...�ffi 9.0-0 (9.lLlb3 lLlxb3 !? IO.�xb3 see I; 9 ...0-0 1 O.lLlxcS i.xcS 1 1 .0-0 gds goes into IliA , while 9 ...i.d7 l O.lLlxcS i.xcS 1 1 .0-0 0-0-0 1 2 .�c2 gS l 3 .i.d2 is in White 's favour, e.g. 13 ...g4 14,j,c3 Yflb6 l S .lLleS, Nilsson - Evertsson, Ha ninge 1 997, or 1 3 ... gheS 1 4.i.c3 �h6 l S .gad l i.d6 1 6.g3) is a critical test.
Black has three options: 81) 9 ...i.e6 I O.a3 aS ( 1 0 ...0-0-0 1 1 .�2 threatening 12.b4) l l .lLlb3 0-0 12 .lLlxcS .hcS 13.�3 b6 14.i.d2 ig4 1H�c3 �e7 16.gfe l &dS 1 7 .�c2 �7 1 S .ic3 gfdS 19.lLld4.hd4 20.exd4 .he2 2 l �e2 �d6 22.�el 'lk7 23.dS gxe2 24.�xe2 lLlbS 2SieS 1 :0 Levine - Welling, corr 1 9SO;
82) 9 .. .ig4 l O.lLld4 .he2 l l .�xe2 �eS ( l l ....txh2+? 1 2.� � eS+ 1 3.f4 lLlxd4 14.�d l) 1 2.f4! ( l 2.lLl4t3 was tested in two games. Motta - Urquiza, corr 1 9SS, went 12 ...�hS 1 3 .g3 lLleS, when instead of 14.&l lLlg4 l S.�fl 0-0-0 l6.�g2 lLld3 11.ge2 f5, 14.lLld4 �xe2 l S.lLlxe2 0-0-0 16.lLld4 would be more consistent; how ever, 12...�f0 is a better try, viz. l3.gbl a5 14.b3 and now not 14 ...0-0-0 1S,j,b2 �g6 16.lLld4 lLlxd4 1 7.exd4 mteS lS.�f3 lLld3 1 9.cS i.f4 2 0.lLlc4 lLlxb2 2 l .gxb2 liltd4 22.lLlxa5, Burgess - Pfeiffer, Vienna 1990, but 14 ... 0-0 1SJ.b2 Yfih6 16goo l 15) 12 ... lLlxd4 l3 .�f2 �f5 1 4.exd4 0-0-0 lS. lLlb3 lLle4 1 6.�0 mteS 1 7.ie 3 with Black gets nowhere, Gutman; B3) 9 ...if5! I O.lLlb3 (I O.a3 O-O!? see A ; 1 0. . .0-0-0 seems too optimistic, not be cause of l l .'it>h l gS 12 .e4 i.g6 1 3.ga2, Helms - Krempner, Germany 199S, 13 ... g4 ! ? 14.eS lLlxeS l S .lLlxeS �xeS 1 6.f4 gd3 17 .lLlxfl mts, but in view of 1 1 �2 mteS 12.b4, e.g. 12 ...lLle4 13.lLlxe4 .he4 14gd2 or 12 ...00 l3.cS i.fB 14.bS lLlceS 1S.c6) 1 0...0-0-0 ( 1 0...0-0 transposing to A is now favourable for White. Also lO ...lLle4 l l .lLlbd4 �S is less advisable: 12.b3 i.b4 l3.�c2 i.g6 1 4.id3 i.c3 l S . .he4 .hal 1 6.lLlxc6 bxc6 1 7 .i.a3 gd7 l S.ic5 1eS 1 9.ixg6 hxg6 20.�e4. Mar tinez Martin - Vidal del Rio, Mondariz 2000, or 1 2.a3 0-0 l3.id3 i.g6 l 4.�c2 rues l S.b4 lLleS 16.lLlxeS �xeS 17.f4 YfihS l S.cS i.fB 1 9.f5 �d4 20.fxg6 1 :0 Cama rena - Milia, Madrid 2000 ) l l .lLlfd4lLlxb3 (if l l ...hS, then 1 2. 'it>h l lLlxb3 1 3 .�xb3 lLlxd4 14.exd4 �xd4 l S .ie3 Yfih4 1 6.f4 �eS 1 7.cS .hcS 1 S.i.f3, instead of 1 2 . lLlxc6? .ixh2+ l3.'it>xh2 �dl 14.lLlxa7+ 'it>b8 lS�dl, Rohde - Splane, San Mateo 19S9, l S ... lLle4) 12.�xb3 (l2.axb3 i.cS l3.b4 lLlxd4 14.exd4 .bd4 1S.�3 �eS) 12 ... lLlxd4 l 3 .exd4 �xd4 14 .i.e3 �h4 1 S.f4 gheS keeps the balance, Gutman. 86
Cl) IO.J.e2 ti'f6 1 1 .0-0 0-0 12.llJbd4 l:ld8 13.ti'c2 ( 1 3.J.d3 llJcxd4 14.llJxd4 llJxd4 1 5.exd4 ti'xd4 16..ixh7+ Wxh7 1 7.ti'xd4 1xh2+ 18.®xla l:lxd4 19.b3 a4, Schmid Bircher, Switzerland 1 994) 1 3 ... llJcxd4 14.exd4 llJxd4 1 5.llJxd4 ti'xd4 1 6.1e3 ti'e5 1 7.g3 1f5 with an edge for Black, Dittmar - Klueting, Weilburg 1996; C2) I O.llJbd4 ti'f6 (Black lost quickly after IO ...llJcxd4 l l .exd4 0-0 12.J.d3!? l:le8 1 3 .0-0 l:le7 14.c5 1f4 15 .d5 Axe I 16.dxe6 1xb2 1 7.1xh7+ I :0 Henke Wendland, corr 1 994, while I O...llJexd4 l l .exd4 1g4 12.J.e3 ti'f6 13.J.e2 h6 14.d5 ixO 1 5.1x0 llJe5 1 6.1e2 llJd7 1 7.0-0 0-0 18ltbl l:lfe8 1 9.g3 l:lxe3 20.fxe3 ti'g5 2 1 .�g2 gave White a clear advantage in Romanov - Karatsioras, Schwaebisch Gmuend 2002) l l .llJxc6 (J I .llJxe6 1xe6 1 2.J.e2 0-0 13.0-0 .if5 14.J.d3 �d8 1 5.e4 1g4 1 6.J.g5 ti'xb2 1 7.1xd8 l:lxd8) I I ... bxc6 12.J.e2 a4 1 3 .0-0 0-0 14 .ti'c2 llJc5 15� .if5 16.ti'c3 ti'h6 and Black dom inates, Gutman; CJ) I O.J.d2 !? 0-0 l l .ie2 a4 1 2 .llJbd4 llJc5 13.ti'c2!? id7 14.0-0 l:le8 1 5.l:lfdl llJxd4 16.llJxd4 l:la6 ( 1 6 ...llJe4 1 7.1e l ti'h4 1 8.g3 ti'h6 1 9.10 f5 20.c5 llJxc5 2 l .llJxf5 was seen in O rr - Santacruz, Novi Sad Olympiad 1990 - Orr's hand ling ofthe opening casts a shadow over Black's system, he keeps his extra pawn and stays ahead in development, Julian Hodgson) 17.g3 (17..ic3 1xh2+ 1 8.� ti'h4+ 19.�gl l:lh6 20.0 ti'hl + 2 l .'t!1f2 ti'M+ is a perpetual) 17 .. .J.h3 1 8.J.c3 se cures White a plus, Gutman . 9.�b3 �xbJ Best in view of: I) 9 ...0-0 I O.llJxc5!? 1xc5 l l .id3 1g4 1 2 .ti'c2, Gutman; ll) 9 ... llJe6 IO .J.d3 a5 ( I O .. ..id7 l l .ti'c2 0-0-0 12.c5 1e7 13 .0-0) 1 1 .0-0 0-0 ( I I ... a4 12.llJbd4 llJcxd4 13.exd4 llJxd4 14lte l+) 1 2.ti' c2 h6 ( 1 2.. .a4 is innocuous owing
8. .Yff6 Other possibilities: I) 8 ...J.f5 is premature due to 9.b4 llJd3+ IO .ixd3 1xd3 l l .ti'b3, Gutman; II) 8 ...a5 with a further split: A) 9.J.e2 ti'ffi I O.ti'c2 (Hrbolka - Inne man, Czech League 1 994, went I 0.0-0 a4 l l .llJd4 llJxd4 12.exd4 ti'xd4 13.ti'c2, when 13 ...hh2+ 14.Wxh2 ti'e5+ might be strong) 10 ... 0-0 (I 0 ... 1f5 l l .e4 1g4 may well be played, viz. 12ltbl a4 13.b4 axb3 14.llJxb3 1xO 1 5 ..ix0 llJxb3 16. ti'xb3, Findlay - Will, Glasgow 1 995, 16...llJd4 17.ti'd3 1xa3) I I .0-0 115 1 2.e4 lffi:8 13.id3 llJxd3 14.ti'xd3 �d8 15.ti'c2 1g6 16J�el llJe5 1 7.llJxe5 ti'xe5 1 8.g3 mt5 19.b3 1c5 20.J.b2 1xf2+ 2l .Wxf2 ti'xh2+ 22.We3 l:lxd2 0: I Lundgren Bang Christiansen, Copenhagen 1 943; B) 9.ti'c2 0-0 (9 ...ti'ffi can be met by 10. llJe4 llJxe4 l l .ti'xe4+ 1e6 and now not 1 2.id2 ti'xb2 1 3ltbl ti'xa3 1 4.J.e2 J.b4 1 5 .J.xb4 axb4 1 6.0-0 ti'c3 17 .llJd4 llJxd4 1 8 .exd4 0-0 1 9.l:lfc l ti'a3 20.d5 1d7 2 1 . id3 g6 22.ti'd4, Robledo - P.Romero, Buenos Aires 2 000, 22 ...c5!? 23 .dxc6 hc6, but 12.c5 1xc5 13�5 0-0 14.J.xc6 bxc6 1 5.ti'xc6 1d6 16.llJd4) IO.J.e2 ti'f6 reaches a position after 8...a5 9.J.e2 ti'f6 I O.ti'c2 0-0 - A ; C) 9.llJb3 !? llJ e6 (9 ...ti'ffi I O.llJxc5 1xc5 l l .ti'c2 1g4 12.J.e2 0-0 13 .J.d2), when: .
87
to 1 3 .ltlbd4 ltJexd4 14.ltlxd4 ltlxd4 l S .
ll..Ae2 There seems to be nothing better: I) l l .cS AxeS 12.ti'c4 AxO 1 3 .gx0 (if 1 3.ti'xcS 0-0-0 14.gx0 ti'xO) 13 ...0-0-0 14.Ag2 ltleS 1 S.ti'b3 ltld3+ 16.'it>e2 ti'a6 17.'it>d2 .ixe3+ 1 8.'it>c2 ltlb4+ 0:1 Straz das - Richter, Berlin 1 933; II) l l .ti'xb7 0-0 1 2 .Ae2 (not 1 2 .ti'xc6? Ah4+) 12 ... &b8 1 3.ti'a6 Ad7 (13 ...ltld4?, Otto Borik, 14.exd4) 14.cS (1 4.0-0 ltld4) 14 ... .ixcS l S .0-0 ( 1 S .ti'c4 Ad6 1 6.0-0 ltlaS 17.ti'c2 ltlb3 1 8.gb l Aa4 19.gel gfd8) 1S .. .id6 1 61ldl gfe8 17.ti'c4 ltlaS 1 8 .ti'c2 ltlb3 1 9.gb l Aa4 20.ge l ltlcS 2l .ti'c4 AbS puts White under pressure, Gutman. 11 .0-0-0 1 1 ...0-0 1 2.Ad2 gfe8 1 3 .Ac3 ti'h6 14.h3 �e3 lS .fxe3 ti'xe3 1 6hxg4 Ag3+ 1 7.'it>d 1 �8+ 1 8.id3! (instead of 18.ltld2 gxd2+ 19bd2 ti'xb3+, Stluka - Netusil, Czech Republic 2000) 1 8 .. hd3+ 1 9.'it>c2 ti'e2+ 20.'it>bl ti'xg2 2 1 .ge l ! ? .bel 22.ltlxe l leaves Black frustrated, Gutman. 12..Ad2 1 2.h3 AhS 1 3 .Ad2 ltleS (the situation appears unclear, but Black is certainly very active, Borik) 14.ltlxeS (if 14.Ac3 .ixf3 lS ..beS AxeS 1 6 ..ix.O c6 1 7.gbl hS 1 8 .0-0 gS) 14 ... Axe2 1 S .ltlc6 Ag3 ! 16.ltlxa7+ ( 16.fxg3 ti'xc6) 16 ... 'it>b8 17. fxg3 ti'd6 1 8.'it>xe2 ti'xd2+, Gutman. ll �eS 12 ... hS 13.h3 Ae6 1 4.0-0-0 ti'g6 lSilhgl ltlb8 1 6.Ad3 fS 17.ti'c2 h4 1 8 .e4 fxe4 19 ..be4 turned out very well for White in Vorackova - Pallova, Czech Repub lic 1 994. lJ..AcJ 13.ltlxeS Axe2 14 .ltlc6 bxc6 1 S .'it>xe2 Axh2 1 6.gadl AeS, Gutman . 13....Axf3 14..Axe5 .AxeS!? 1 5..Axf3 c6 16.!bl .Ac7 17.0-0 'treS 1 8.g3 hS Black has obviously enough play for the pawn, Gutman.
exd4) 13.cS Ae7 14.id2 a4 1 S.Ac3 axb3 1 6. ti' dl ltled4 17 .ltlxd4, Gutman; lll) 9 ...Ag4 lO.ltlxcS AxeS l l .Ae2 Ad7 1 U�a2! (more precise than 12.ti'c2 0-0-0 13.id2 at5 14.ti'c3 ti'e6 1S.b4 Ae7, when instead of 1 6.ltld4? ltlxd4 1 7 .exd4 af6 1 8 .ie3 ti' lt4, Derieux - Coursaget, Saint Lo 2001 , 16.ti'cl .i16 17Jc3 .id3 18bd3 l:bd3 19.Axf6 ti'xf6 20.0-0 would have been better) 12...0-0-0 13.id2 Ag4 14.b4, Gutman. 1 0.1hb3
..
1 0....Ag4! We consider therefore: I) 10 ...0-0 l l .Ad2 ge8 12.Ac3 ti'g6 1 3 . 0-0-0 (13.ie2 deserves attention) 1 3 ...a5 14 .ti'bS !? Ag4 1 S .id3 eh6 1 6.cS axo 1 7 .gxO AeS 18 .AxeS gxeS 1 9 .f4 ghs 20.Ae2 gf5 2 l .ig4 gxf4 22.exf4 ti'xf4+ 23.bl ti'xg4 24.ti'xb7 and White won, Kelecevic - Boichetti, Ticino 1 992; D) 10 .. .id7 l l .Ad2 ( l l .ti'xb7 is a risky venture in view of l l ...gb8 1 2 .ti'a6 gb6 1 3.ti'a4 ltld4 14.ti'd l ltlb3 l S .gb l 0-0 16.id3 gfb8 1 1.0-0 Ag4) 1 1 ...0-o-o (1 1 ... ltleS 1 2.ltlxeS AxeS 1 3 .f4) 1 2.Ae2 ghe8 13Jc3 ti'f5 14.0-M (1 4.0.0 ltla5 lS ..lxaS ti'xaS 1 6.cS ti'xcS 1 7 .ti'xf7 is also not bad) 14 ...ti'g6 ( 14 ...ltlaS lS ..ixaS ti'xaS 1 6.gds ti'a6 1 7 .ti'c3) 1 S .g3 and Black has insufficient oompensation, Gutman.
...
88
Section S (l.d4 �f6 2.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.�d2 �cS S.�gfJ � c6) 6.a3
A positional threat is to expand on the Q-side by b2-b4 and drive the c5-knight to an inferior post, Tim Harding. This move makes a lot of sense as White prevents a potential _..ib4+ and prepares a later b2-b4. He also keeps his options open of whether to develop with e2-e3 or g2-g3, Bogdan Lalic.
The material divides as follows: Sequel I - 6... a5 (6 . . . f6, 6 ... d6) Sequel 2 - 6 ...�e7. Sequel I 6... as Less accurate are: I) 6 ... ffi 7.b4 ltle6 8.exf6 �xf6 9J�bl /JJ:.7 I O ..ib2 �g6 l l .g3 .if6 1 2 . .ixf6 �xf6 1 3 ..ig2 0-0 1 4.0-0, Tornado - Lostpawn, internet 2002; D) 6...d6 7.b4 ltle6 (7 ...ltld7 8.exd6 .ixd6 9.ltle4 .ie5 IO.lLlxe5 lLldxe5 l l .�xd8+ ltlxd8 12 ..ib2, Lind - Zimmermann, e mail 2000) 8.exd6 reaching a position after 5.b4 ltle6 6.a3 ltlc6 7 .ltlgf3 d6 8. exd6 - Section 7.
7.�b3 Alternatives: I) 7 _m,) d6 8.b4 axb4 9.axb4 ltla4 )O_gb3 ltlxe5 l l .e3 .id7 (better than I I ....ig4 1 Uia3 ltlb6 1 3 ..ie2 .ie6 14.�b3 .ie7 1 5.ltld4 .id7 1 6.0-0, Schilly - Larsson, e-mail 1 999) 1 2Jia3 .ie7 is harmless; II) 7.b3 g6 !? 8..ib2 .ig7 transposing to 5.a3 a5 6.b3 g6 7 ..ib2 .ig7 8.lLlgf3 lLlc6 Section I ; III) 7.�c2 �e7 (7 ...d6 8.exd6 .ixd6 9.ltle4 see 4.a3 d6 5.�c2 ltlc5 6.exd6 .ixd6 7. ltlf3 a5 8.ltlc3 ltlc6 9.ltle4 - Part 5, � ter 4, Section I ) 8.�c3 (8.e3 a4!? 9.�c3 �e6 I O..ie2 g6 I I .0-0 .ig7, while 8 ... ltlxe5 goes into Sequel 2) 8...g 6 (8...�e6 9.e3 g6 I O ..ie2 .ig7 may be tried) 9.e6 (9.b3 .ig7 IO..ib2 d6) 9 ... f6 I O.exd7+ .ixd7 I l .e3 .ig7 12 ..ie2 5 1 3 .�c2 f4 1 4.e4 g5 appears promising for Black, Gutman; IV) 7.e3 �e7 (if 7 ... d6, then not 8.ltlb3 .!iJxb3 9.�xb3 dxe5 I O.�b5 ffi I I..id2 id7 12.�xb7 gb8 0: I Rasmussen - Jensen, corr 1 991 , but 8.exd6 .ixd6 transposing to 5.lLlgf3 lLlc6 6.e3 d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.a3 a5, covered in Section 4) 8.ltlb3 (8 ..ie2 ltlxe5 9.0-0 d6 I O.lLlb3lLled7 I I ..id2 a4 12.lLlxc5 lLlxc5 13.ic3, Sharden - Grantz, e-mail 2000, 13 ... c6) 8 ...ltlxb3 (8 ...ltlxe5 9.ltlxc5 �xc5 is possible, e.g. I O..id2 id6 I I ..ic3 ltlxf3+ 1 2.�xf3 0-0 1 3..id3 ge8 or I O.ltlxe5 �xe5 I I ..id3 .ic5 12.0-0 &6 J3.gb I gh6, Knol - Gibson, corr 200 I ) 9.�xb3 g6 leads to equality, Gutman; V) 7.g3 with another branch: A) 7 ... b6 8..ig2 (8.ltlb3 .ib7 9.gg I ltle6, instead An Mon - Little Goliath, com puter game 200 I , continued 9 . . .ltlxb3 I O.�xb3 a4 l l .�d3 ltla5 1 2 ..ie3 .ic5 13 ..ixc5 ltlb3 14..if8 �xfB 1 5 .gdJ lLlc5 1 6.�5 �e7 1 7.ltld4) 8 ... .ib7 9.0-0 a4 (9...�e7 I O.ltlb3) IO.�c2 (I o.geJ !? �e7 I I .lLlfl lLlxe5 1 2.ltle3) I O -.�e7 l l .�c3, Gutman; further 89
B) 7...Vfie7 8.i.g2 ll:lxe5 9.ll:lxe5 (on 9.0-0 Black should play 9 ... d6 l O.ll:lxe5 dxe5, since 9 ... ll:lx0+?! fails to l O.exO Vfid8, Kuhn - Schwichtenberg, Gladenbach 1999, l l .�el+ .le7 l 2 .Vfie2 &6 1 3 .i.h3 ll:le6 l4.f4) 9 ...Vfixe5 10 .0-0 .le7 ( l O ... g6 l l .ll:\0 Vfie7 l2 ..lg5 ffi l 3 ..le3) l l .ll:\0 Vfif6 l 2.ll:ld4 0-0 l 3.e4 d6 14 .i.e3, Gut man; similarly C) 7 ... g6 8.ll:lb l ! (8..lg2 .lg7 9.0-0 0-0 lO.ll:lb3 ll:lxb3 l l .Vfixb3 a4 l2.Vfic2 ll:lxe5 l3 ..id2 d6 l 4.ll:lxe5 .lxe5 was equal in Tuchenhagen - Zill, Gennany 2000) 8 ... h6 9.ll:lc3 .lg7 l O..te3 ll:le6 l 2.Vfid2 ll:lxe5 l3 .ll:lxe5 .lxe5 l4..lg2 .lg7 1 5.ll:ld5 with a plus for White, Gutman; D) 7 ...d6 . 8 .exd6 is critical, when: Dl) 8 ...Vfixd6 9 ..lg2 .lf5 was indicated by Ludwig Engels.
l 0.0-0 ( l O.b3 0-0-0 l l ..lb2 h5 ! makes life a bit too easy for Black, l2 ..lc3 1 2 .0-0 h4 l3.b4 hxg3 , e.g.l 4.fxg3 Vfih6 l 5 .bxc5 .lxc5+ l 6.�h l .le3 17 �3 .lg4 or l4 .bxc5 gxf2+ l 5 .�xf2 VfJh6 l 6 .�fl .lxc5+ l 7.�hl .lg4 l 8.Vfic2 .le3-, 1 2 ... ll:ld3+ l 3 .�fl h4 1 4.ll:lg5 Vfig6 l 5 .ll:lh3 hxg3 l 6.hxg3 and now I like 16 ... ll:lc5, for example 17 .ll:lf4 � l + l 8..txh l Vfih6 or 1 7 .Vfie l .lc2 l 8.�gl .id6, instead of l 6 ...Vfie6 1 7 .exd3 .lxh3 l 8.VfJO .lxg2+ l9.�xg2 �xhl 20.�xhl .lxa3 2 l ..lxg7 Vfig6 22..ih6 �xd3 23..le3 !12-Yl Luckis Engels, Montevideo 1 94 1 ), and n ow:
Dla) 10 ...0-0-0? l l .b4 axb4 ( l l ...ll:le4 l2.b5 Vfiffi l 3 .&2 ll:lc3 l4.i.b2 ll:ld4 1 5 . .lxc3 ll:lx0+ l 6..lx0 Vfixc3 l 7.Vfib3 ! ?) l2 .axb4 ll:lxb4 l 3 .ll:lg5 (another possi bility is 13 .�aS+ �d7 l 4.�xd8+ �xd8, when instead of l 5 ..lb2 ffi l6.ll:ld4 .id7 l7 .ll:le4 ll:lxe4 1 8 ..lxe4 W l 9.�el c5 20.ll:lf5?! Vfixdl 2 l .�xd l + �c7 22-i.c l ll:lc6 23..lf4+ ll:le5 24.�bl .lxf5 25.i.xf5 .id6 with only a small edge for White, Golombek - Bisguier, Southsea 1 950, l5..la3 ! ll:lba6 16..lxc5 ll:lxc5 l7.Vfial ffi l8.e4 might be tried, e.g. l 8 ....lc8 19 .e5 Vfia6 20.Vfid4+ <;t>es 2 1 .& l l :0 Muller Bemad, corr 1978, or l8 ....ie6 l9.e5 fxe5 20.ll:lxe5 <;t>es 2 Uidl Vfia6 22 .�2 .le7 23.& l) 13 .. ..tg6 ( l 3 ...�b8 l4.ll:lxJ7 Vfif6 l5.ll:lxd8 .lc2 16..lb2 Vfixb2 1 7.Vficl Vfixc l l 8.�fxcl .le7 1 9 .ltln �f8 20.ll:le5 was seen in Troianescu - Stulik, Karlsbad 1 948) l4.ll:lde4!? ll:lxe4 l 5 .ll:lxe4 .lxe4 l6 ..lxe4 �b8 1 7 .�3 and White's ad vantage is overwhelming, Gutman; Dlb) lO..M8!?, Fernando VasconceUos, l l .ll:lh4 ( l l .Vfie l .le7 l 2 .h3 0-0, Vas concellos) l l ...i.e6 ( l l . .J.e4?! l2..lxe4 ll:lxe4 l3.ltllif3 ) 12-ID>l a4 (l2 ....lxc4 l3.b4 axb4 l4.axb4 ll:le6 l 5 .b5 ll:lb4 l 6.Vfia4 he2 l 7.�el .ld3 l 8.ll:le4) l 3 .Vfiel .le7 l4.b4 axb3 l 5 .ll:lxb3 .lxh4 1 6.gxh4 b6 l 7.Vfic3 0-0 is fully adequate, Gutman. D2) 8 ..bd6 9..lg2 SKillS more typical.
90
We examine: D2a) 9...ie6 10.�0 �ffi (lO...�e7 l l .�c2, e.g. 1 1 .. .0-0 1 2 .b3 or l l ...�f6 l z..!l1b3 i.f5 13.e4 he4 14J:�e 1 ) l l ..!Db3 ( l l .�c2 .i5 1 2.e4 .ig4 1 3 .IDll a4 1 4J:�el �0 1 5 . e5? .ixe5 1 6 . .!Dxe5 .!Dxe5 1 7 . .!De4 �f5 1 S.f4 .!Df3+ 1 9:;!;>12 .!Dxel 20.'i!;>xel �feS 0 : 1 Koming - Pedersen, Aarhus 1 944) l l...a4 (l l .. ..bc4 12 ..!Dxc5 hc5 13.�c2) 1 2..!Dxc5 .bcS 13 ..!Dg5 � 14..!Dxe6 �xe6 1 5 ..id5 �f6 1 6 .e3, Gutman; further Dlb) 9 .. ..ig4 1 0.0-0 �e7 (10...a4 l l .b4 axb3 12 ..!Dxb3, e.g. 12...�0 13 ..!Dxc5 .bcS 14.�xd8 m'xd8 1 5..if4 or 12...�16 13 ..ig5 �e6 - 1 3 ...�c3 1 4..!Dxc5 hc5 1 5 .�d5 &5?, Luckis - Schroeder, Mar del Plata 1 9 5 1 , loses to 1 6.i.d2 -, 14.i.e3 .!Dxb3 15 .�xb3) l l .�c2 (Akesson - Eliet, Ant werp 1 996, went l l .b3 � 1 2 .1b2 5 ! ? 1 3 .e3!? .!Dd3 14 .i.c3 �adS 1 5 .�c2 1c5 16 ..!Dd4 .!Dxf2 17.fuf2 �xe3 l S..!Dfl .!Dxd4 19 ..!Dxe3 .!Dxc2 20 ..!Dxc2 f4 2 l .gxf4 �xf4 22.&fl Y2-Y2, while 13.&1 �dS 14.�c2 f4 might well be unpleasant for White, e.g. 1 5 .e3 fxe3 1 6 .�xe3 .!De6 1 7 .�ae l .ic5 l SIDe2 �f7 or 1 5 J.c3 .!DeS 16.ixa5 1f5 1 7 .�c3 fxg3 1S .hxg3 .!lJg4 19..ib4 �f7 20.�fl �5 2 l .�adl .ie5 22.�c l .id4 23.i.c3 1e4 24.�fe 1 hf2+ 25 .'i!;>fl .ie3 0 : 1 Durao - Carpintero, Portugal 1 996) 1 1 ... 0-0 1 2.e3 �ffi (12 ...5 13 ..!Dd4) 13 ..!Dh4 (not 13 ..!Dd4 .!Dxd4 14.exd4 �xd4 1 5 ..!D f3 �d3 1 6 .�xd3 .!Dxd3, Christen sen - Jonsson, Frederikshavn 193S) 13 ... �feS (13 .. .i.e2 14 ..!De4 .!Dxe4 l 5 .�xe2) 14 ..!De4 .!Dxe4 l 5 .1xe4 h6 16 ..id2 and White is on top, Gutman; Ole) 9...� 10.� (lO..!lJb3 .!Dxb3 l l .�xb3 h6 12.0-0 �ffi 1 3 .i.e3 a4 !? 14.�c2 .if5 l 5 .�cl .!Da5 and after l O .b3 Black has l O ...�ffi 1 1 � .ig4 1 2..ib2 �6 1 3 .�0 �adS, Frantisek Nepustil, or 1 0... 5 1 1 . .ib2 �e7 12.0-0 f4) 1 o ..a4 l l .�c2 �f6 l2 ..!lJe4 .!lJxe4 1 3.�xe4 15 14.� �xh4 l 5 ..!Dxh4 � 6 OK for Black, Gutman.
Back to the main line
7 �e6! Other possibilities: 1)7 .. .i.e7 S ..!Dxc5 ixcS 9.i.g5 �7 IO..if4 (lO.Ad2 �0 l l .e3 d6 12..lc3 � l 3.exd6 1xd6 14.1e2 may be played) 1 0 ... 0-0 l l .e3 ffi l 2.exffi (Nicolll Minev mentions 12..id3 or l2 ..ie2) l 2 .. ..ixf6 1 3 .�c2 d6 14.i.d3, Kottnauer - Seidl, Prague 1937; further II) 7 ... f6 S . .!Dxc5 .ixc5 9.e3 a4 (neither 9 ...fxe5 lO . .!lJxe5 .!Dxe5 1 1 .�5+ .!D f7 12.�xc5 nor 9....ie 7 10.exffi hffi l l..id3 �e7 12 .�0 d6 13 .�c2 are better) lO..idJ fxe5 l l ..!Dxe5 �g5 l2 . .!D f3 ! ?, Gutman; similarly ID) 7...�e7 S..!Dxc5 (S ..ig5 �e6 9. .!Dxc5 1xc5 l0..1f4 �xc4 l l .e3 �e6 l2.�cl .ie7 13 .i.c4 is worth trying) 8...�xc5 9.�d5 b6 l O..id2 (this is more consequent than IO.i.e3 �e7 l l .i.gS �e6 l 2.e3 h6 13 ..if4 g5 l 4..ig3 .ib7 1 5.�xe6+ dxe6 l 6..!Dd4 0-0-0 17 ..!Dxc6 hc6 1 S.h4 g4 l9.h5 �7 20.1h4 .ixh4 2 l .�xh4 �hgS, Tunik Heinzel, Pardubice 1 996) 10 ..�7 l l .J.c3 a4 1 2.e3 �e7 1 3 .�dl leaves Black with no compensation for the pawn, Gutman; IV) After 7 ...a4 White has a choice of: A) S . .!Dxc5 .ixc5 9.1g5 (if 9 ..if4, then not 9...�0 lO.e3 .ib6, Hofmann - Vos pemik, Budapest 2002, due to l l ..id3 .ia5+ 12.'i!;>e2 ffi l 3.�c2, but 9...ib6 l O.e3 ...
.
91
ia5+ l l .'it'e2 J.b6 12.igS ffi 1 3.exffi gxft'i 1 4.if4 d6) 9 ...i.e7 IO.if4 ffi (Banusz Vospernik, Budapest 200 1, went 10 ...0.0 l l .e3 ffi 1 2.exf6 hffi I HYc2 d6 14.td3 g6 1 S .h4 fie7 1 6.0-0-0 i.d7, when 1 7 .cS could be strong) l l .e3 �S 1 2.exffi .b:ffi 13.ltld4 (13 .fic2 d6 14.id3 gS) 13 ...ltlxd4 1 4.exd4 0-0 I S .i.eH !e8 1 6.fid2 b6 17. i.e3 dS 1 8 .0-0 .b6 1 9J:!acl cS 20.dxcS d4 2 1 .if4 bxc5 22.af3 gave White a plus in Jedlicka - Innernan, Czech Repub lic 1 997; B) 8.i.gS f6 (8 . . .i.e7 9.ltlxcS hgS was refuted by I O.ltl xa4 fie? l l .ltlc3 ltlxeS 1 2.ltlxgS fixgS 13.ltlbS fid8 14.fid4 d6 I S .f4, Crafty - Bronto, computer game 1 997) 9.exffi gxffi I O.ltlxcS ixcS l l .ih4 ( l l .th6, TseiiJin/G/Iko IS v, l l ...fie7 1 2 .e3 d6 1 3 .id3 l::!g8) I I ... fie? 12 .fidS d6 13. flh5+ �8 14.e3 �S I S.flb6 l::!f8 1 6.id3 ltld4 1 7.ltlxd4 bd4 1 8.0-0 i.b6 1 9.fif4 with advantage for White, Cerny - In neman, Czech Republic 1 9 97. V) 7 ... ltlxb3 8.fixb3 , M ax Bluemich, with a further split: A) 8 .. .i.cS 9.if4 (White lost in Cerny Pletanek, Czech Republic 200 1 , with 9.fibS? b6 IO..igS ffi l l .exffi gxft'i 1 2..ie3 a4 ! 1 3..ixcS �S) 9... 0-0 IO.e3 b6 l l .td3 i.b7 12.fic2 h6 13.0-0 l::!e8 14.ih7+ �h8 I S .if'S fie? J 6_gfd I �d8 17 .i.g3 ltlb8, Esch - Brachtel, corr 1 994, 1 8 .i.e4 !?; B) 8 .. ..ie7 9.g3 (also good is 9.i.f4 0-0 I O.e3 l::!e8 l l .i.d3 d6 12.l::!dl a4 1 3 .fic2 g6, Lacosta - Alozy, corr 1 993, 14 .ie4, or 9 .e3 d6 I O.exd6 fixd6, when instead of l l ..id2 0-0 1 2 .g3 i.f5 1 3 ..ig2 a4 14. fidl W IS.& I ru-d8 16.ltlgl ltleS, Reh bein - G iesemann, corr 1 970, l l .fic2! i.g4 12..id3 l::!d8 13.ie4 should be tried) 9 ... d6 I O.exd6 fixd6 l l .i.g2 0-0 1 2.0-0 a4 1 3 .fic2 i.g4 1 4.i.f4, Gutman; C) 8 ...h6 9.id2 (9.fic3?, Tseit6n/GIIIskov, loses to 9 ...i.b4, and i f 9..if4, then not 9 ...g6 I O.l::!dl i.g7 l l .l::!dS, Tseil/in/G/IIS-
kov, I I ...fie? 1 2.e3 b6 1 3.id3 i.b7 14.ie4 ltld8 I S � .b:e4 1 6.l::!xe4 ltle6 1 7.fic2 0-0 1 8.i.g3 a4 19.0-0, but 9 ... gS IO..ig3 i.g7 l l .e3 fie? 1 2 ..ie2 b6 1 3 .fic2 i.b7 14.fif5 fie6 IS .fixe6+ fxe6 1 6.h3 ltld8 17.0-0.0 ltlf7) 9...icS (9 ...g6 I O.ic3 i.g7 can be met by l l .e6!? 0-0 1 2.exf7+ !W'7 13 .e3 a4 14.9c2 i.xc3+ I S .fixc3 d6 1 6. i.e2) I O.i.c3 fie? l l .e3 a4 1 2 .fic2 b6 1 3 .id3 i.b7 1 4.l::! dl 0-0 I S .O-O are all in White 's favour, Gutman. VI) 7 ... h6, introduced by Kun Richter.
We survey White's defences: A) 8.ltlbd4 ltlxd4 9.ltlxd4 b6 IO..if4 (IO.f4 a4 l l ..ie3 i.b7) I O ...a4 ( I O ... gS l l .i.g3 ltle4, Nepustil, 1 2 .e3 hS 1 3 .fif3 ! i.b7 14.l::! d l ltlcS I S.fifS i.e4 1 6.fif6 fixf6 1 7 .exf6 0-0-0 1 8.f3) I l .e3 i.b7 is fine for Black, Gutman; B) 8.g3 ltlxb3 (8 ... a4!?, e.g. 9.ltlxcS i.xcS IO..ig2 fie?, Nepustil, or 9.ltlbd4 ltlxd4 IO.ltlxd4 d6 l l .exd6 i.xd6 1 2.i.g2 0-0 13 .0-0 fif6 14..ie3 l::!d 8) 9.fixb3 g6 10. i.g2 i.g7 1 1 .0-0 fie?, Gutman; C) 8..id2 ltle4 (for 8 ... a4 9.ltlxcS i.xcS see 8.ltlxcS i.xcS 9.i.d2 a4 - VIE, and 8 ...fie7 isn't inspiring in view of9.ltlxcS fixeS I O.e3 ltlxeS l l .lLlxeS fixeS 12.ic3 figS 1 3 .fidS) 9.i.e3 (9.fic2 ltlxd2 1 0 . ltlbxd2 g 6 l l .g3 i.g7 1 2.i.g2 fie?, Ne pustil) 9 . . . fie7 I O.fidS ltlgS l l .ltlbd4 ltlxf3+ 1 2.ltlxf3 g6 13M4 i.g7, Gutman; 92
D) 8..if4 lLle6 (8 ... lLlxb3 9.Wxb3 trans poses to 7 ... lLlxb3 8.Wxb3 h6 9..if4 g5 VC) 9..ig3 a4! (Bogoljubow - Richter, Swinemuende 1 93 1 , went 9 .ic5 1 O.e3 d6 l l .exd6 Wf6 1 2.lLlxc5 lLlxc5 13.dxc7 Wxb2 14 ..ie5 Wb3 15..bg7 gg8 16..if6 Wxdl+ 17l!xdl lLle6 18.lLle5 lLle7 19..Ae2 lLlxc7 20.Jh5 if6 2 l ..txf7+ .bf7 22.l;d7 lLlc6 23.gxt7 lLJe6 24.gxb7 lLlc5 25.l:3b5 lLlxe5 26..ixe5 1 :0) lO.lLlbd4 lLlcxd4 1 1 . lLlxd4 lLlc5 12.e3 g6 1 3..ie2 .ig7 1 4.0-0 0-0 15.lLlf3 b6 1 6.Wc2 .ib7 1 7� 1 We7 gives equality in all instances, Gutman; E) 8.lLlxc5 hc5 9id2 (9..if4 'fle7 1 O.e3 b6 l l .Wc2 .ib7 12 .te2 g5 !? l 3.tg3 h5 14.h4 g4 15.lLlg5 lLlxe5 1 5.Wf5 d6 1 7.0-0 lLld7 1 8l!abl a4; however, note that 9 ... g5 IOjg3 g4 l l .Wd5 d6 12.exd6 cxd6 l3.lLld2 lLld4 14.We4+ �f8 15.0-0-0 .it5 16.Wd5 Wb6 17.e3? Wb3 ! 1 8.Wxf5 Wxdl+, Ac hilles - Augustin, corr 1 989, is less clear due to 17.lLle4 lLlb3+ 1 8.�l .ig6 1 9.�) 9 ...a4 (on 9 ...lLld4 1 O.ic3 lLlxf3+ l l .exf3, Nepustil) IO..ic3 0-0 l l .Wc2 ( l l .e3 i.b6 1 2..ie2 .ia5 l3.Wc2 ge8 14.0-0.ixc3 1 5. 'flxc3 'fle7, Nepastil) l l ..k8 12.gdl b6 ( l 2 ...'fle7 l3.e3 .ib6 14..ie2 ia5 1H :!d5 hc3+ l 6.'flxc3 b6 1 7.0-0 i.b7 1 8.gfd 1 ) l 3 .e3 i.b7 1 4..ie2 maintains a pleasant game for White, Gutman.
8..ld2 8.e3 g6!? (White gained the advantage after 8 b6 9 .td3 i.b 7 1 0.0-0 d6 l l ..ie4 dxe5 12.lLlxe5 lLlxe5 l3 ..ixb7 Wxdl 14. �dl �8 1 5l!xd8+ lLlxd8 16.ia6, Peek van den Berg, Tilburg 2003, while 8 ... d6 9.exd6 .ixd6 transposes to 5.lLlgf3 lLlc6 6.e3 d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.a3 a5 9.lLlb3 lLle6 - Section 4) 9..id2 (if 9.lLlbd4 We7 l O.lLlxc6 dxc6 l l ..id2 .ig7 12 ..ic3 0-0, since 9 ....ig7 10.lLlxc6 bxc6 l l .td2 lLlg5 1 2.lLlxg5 'flxg5 1 3 .f4 'fle7 14 ..id3 0-0 1 5.0-0 d6 1 6..ie4 !? gb8 1 7..ixa5 dxe5, Fernandez Urrutia - M arquez, Spain 1997, 18 ..ic3 "§ c5 19 .'fle2 appears pro mising for White) 9 ... .ig7 l O . .ic3 0-0 ( I O ...a4 is best answered by l l .lLlbd4 !? lLlxe5 1 2.lLlxe6 lLlxf3+ l 3.�e2 fxe6 1 4. hg7 gg8 15.ic3 lLlh4 1 6.g3 lLlt5 1 1.tg2 'fle7 1 8.gc 1 gf8 19.ge 1 "§f7 20.f4, in stead of l l .lLlcl lLlc5 12 .'fld5 d6 l3.exd6 .ixc3+ 14.bxc3 if6 15.dxc7 1rxc7 1 6.Wdl gd8 1 7 .ti'c2 lLla5 1 8.lLld4 .ixc4 19 .txc4 lLlxc4 20.lLld3? lLlb3 2 l .lLlb2 lLlxb2 22. 'flxb2 lLlxa 1 and Black won material in Dias - Stinis, Calicut 1 998) l l .'fld5 We7 1 2.lLlbd4 ( 12..ie2 gd8 13.0-0 a4 14.lLlbd4 lLlexd4 1 5.exd4 d6) 12 ...lLlexd4 1 3.exd4 d6 1 4..Ae2 dxe5 1 5.dxe5 gd8 1 6.We4 J.f5 l 7.'fle3 ge8 18.0-0 lLlxe5 19.lLlxe5 .ixe5 20.he5 'flxe5 is equal, Kaabi - Ham douchi, Manila Olympiad 1 992. 8 a4 Other moves bring Black no joy: I) 8 ... g6 9.lLlcl .ig7 IO .lLld3 0-0 l l .g3 'fle7 12 ..ig2 lLlc5 1 3.0-0 lLlxd3 14.exd3 lLlxe5 1 5 .ge l , Gutman ; II) 8 ... g5 9.i.c3 i.g7 1 0.e3 h5 ( l O...a4 l l .lLlbd4 lLlxe5 12.lLlxe6 lLlxf3+ 1 3 .�e2) l l .Wc2 g4 12.lLlfd4 lLlxe5 l3.lLlf5 (Jack land - Hvenekilde, Denmark 1 988, con tinued l 3.lLlxe6 fxe6 14.0-0-0 a4 1 5.lLlc5 d6 1 6.lLld3 lLlxd3+ 1 7..ixd3 We7 1 8.h3 e5 1 9.hxg4 hg4 20.tg6+ �d7 2 l .tf5+ .ixfS 22.'flxf5+ 'fle6 23 .'fle4 ga6, when •.
.•
Returning to the main line
...
93
24.c 5!? might be strong) l3 ...if6 ( 1 3 ... 'i!!lfti l4.ll:lxg7+ 'i!!lxg7 15 .ll:lxa5 b6 l6.ll:lb3 i.b7 l7.'i!!l f5 d6 l 8 J�dl h4 1 9.c5) l 4.c5 a4 l 5 .ll:ld2, Gutman . 9.�cl
but because of 13 .g3 0-0 l4.i.g2 ll:la5 l 5..ixa5 B:xa5 16.0-0 b6 1 7.'i!!ld2 ic6 1 8. B:adl 'i!!lc8 l9.ll:lb4 i.e4 20.ll:ld5 i.c5 2 1 . ll:lc3 B:d8 22.'i!!l cl i.c6 23 .B:xd8+ 'i!!lxd8 24.Ml 'i!!le8 25.e3, Crafty -Brause, com puter game 1 997) 12 ...0-0 l3 ..ig2 ll:la5 l4.exd6 cxd6 1 5.ll:ld2ift> l6..ixa5 'i!!lxaS 17 .0-0 ll:lg5 l 8.h4 ll:le6 1 9 .ll:le4 ( 19.i.xb7 B:ab8 20.i.g2 i.xb2 2 l .lbxb2 �xb2 22 . ll:le4 i.c6?! 23.ll:l ffi+ gxfti 24.i.xc6 was used in Crafty - Brause, computer game 1997) l 9 ...i.e7 20.ll:lb4 with advantage for White, Gutman. IO.'ff cl lO.ll:ld3 ll:lb3 l l ..ig5 (l l .� l d6 1 2.exd6 hd6 l3�3 0-0) l l ..ie7 l2..ixe7 ll:lxe7 (l prefer this move to l 2 ...'i!!lxe7 1 3 .�bl b6 l4.e3 i.b7, suggested by Alfonso Romero) l3Ebl c6 l4.o!Od2 'i!!laS l 5 .e4 lbg6 l6.f4 0-0 1 7 ..ie2 �d8 puts White under pressure, Gutman. 10 d6 l l ..AcJ After l l .exd6 i.xd6 1 2 .e3 0-0 1 3 .i.e2 'i!!le7 14.0-0 i.g4 l5 .h3 i.h5 Black holds the initiative, Gutman. l l ....Ag4 l l.exd6 1fxd6 lJ.eJ 1re6 l3 ... .b:f3?! l4.gxf3 'i!!lh6 l 5.ll:ld3 ll:lb3 l6.l:Ml �7 l 7.ll:l f4 0-0 l 8_ggl tuJn4M1 out very well for White in Pielar - Pletanek, Czech Republic 1 993. 14-i.el l 4.ll:ld4 ll:l xd4 l 5 .i.xd4 i.f5 l 6 .'i!!ld l is met by l 6 ...'i!!lc6! 1 7.0 �d8 1 8..ie2 ll:le6 19 .ll:la2 ll:lxd4 20.exd4 i.c5 2 l .ll:lb4 'i!!ff6 22 .ll:ld5 'i!!l h4+ 2 3.g3 'i!!l xd4, Gutman. 14 ..lf5 IS.'ftdl !d8 Black is at least not worse, for example l6.ll:ld4 'i!!lg6 1 7.0-0 i.h3 l8.in ll:le5 19. rtlhl ll:lxf3 20.'i!!lxf3 (better than 20.gxh3 'i!!le4 2 l .'i!!lxf3_gxd4 22.'i!!lxe4+ �xe4 23 . id4 ll:le6 24_gdl c5 25..ic3 B:xc4 26.ll:le2 �g8 ! 27.ll:lg3 g6) 20 ... i.g4 2 l .'i!!lg3 i.d6 22.'Mt4 i.e? with a draw by repetition, Gutman. •
9... �cS! More direct methods fail to equalize: I) 9 ... g5 l O..ic3 (l O.e3 g4 l l .ll:ld4 ll:lxe5 l2..ic3 d6 l 3.ll:lce2 i.g7 l 4.ll:lg3 is also reasonable) lO ...g4 l l .ll:ld2 i.g7 12 .ll:ld3 d6 l3.exd6!? (an improvement on l 3 .e4 ll:led4 l4.exd6 'i!!lxd6 15 ..ie2 Ymt6 l 6..ixd4 ll:lxd4 1 7.0-0 0-0 1 8.& 1 � l 9..ifl &6 20.B:e3 'i!!l g 5!? 2 l .ll:lb4 B:h6, Rivas Ro mero - Alzola Tovar, corr 1 996) 1 3 ... hc3 l 4.bxc3 'i!!l xd6 l 5 .g3 0-0 l 6 .i.g2 gives White too much control Gutman m 9 ...d6 l O..ic3 i.d7 l l .ll:ld3 i.e? ( l l ... lba5 l2.ll:ld2 ll:lc6 has been discarded on account of l 3 .e3 dxe5 l 4.ll:lxe5 ll:l xe5 l 5 ..ixe5 i.c6 l6.ll:lf3 'i!!le7 l7.ll:ld4 ll:lxd4 l 8 .i.xd4 B:d8 l 9 .'i!!lg4 i.e4 20.0-0-0 f5 2 l .'i!!le2 c5 22..ic3 B:xdl+ 23.'i!!l xdl 'i!!lg5 24.'i!!lxa4+ rtlfl 25.h4 'i!!lh6 26.i.d3 i.c6 27.'i!!lc2 l :0 Huebner - Pedersen, Athens Zonal 1 969) 1 2 .g3 (on l 2.exd6 Black should play l2 ...cxd6 l3 .g3 i.ffi l4..ixffi 'i!!lxfti l5..ig2 0-0 16.0-0 a:t'd8 l 7.e3 ll:lc5; 12 .. .i.xd6 has less point, not because of l 3 .ll:lde5 i.xe5 l4..ixe5 'i!!le7 l 5.e3 ll:lc5 l 6 .hg7 B:g8 l 7 .i.c3 if5 l 8 .'i!!ld5 i.e6 1 9.'i!!lhS �, Floter - Meyer, corr 1990,
.•.
.•
94
Sequel l (l.d4 �f6 l.c4 eS J.dxeS �e4 4.�dl �cS S.�gf3 �c6 6.a3) 6...'Be7
j,e?) J 3. .. j,e7 (less accurate is 1 3 ...g5 1 4..ig3 h5 1 5.f3 ltlxg3 16.hxg3 j,g? 17. j,d3 j,d?, Baerentsen - Thomsen, Co penhagen 1 994, 1 8 .0-0-0) 1 4 ..ie2 0-0 seems comfortable for Black, Gutman; m 7.b4 ltlxe5 8.e3 (8.bxc5? ltld3 mate) 8...ltlcd3+ 9bd3 ltlxd3+ I 0.�2 reaches a remarkable position.
The correct move; Black makes sure of regaining his pawn, Tim Harding. 7.e3 Other possibilities: I) 7.'i!Jc2 ltlxe5 8.ltlxe5 "t!fxe5 9.ltlf3 "t!fe4 (9 ..."t!fh5!? is perhaps a more attractive way to play : l O .ltld4 j,e? J J .j,e3 d6 12.g3 Q.O 13.ig2 a5 14.h3 - White overes timates his position, the normal course of action would have been 14.b3 and 1 5 . 0-0. However, Black should b e satisfied with whichever direction the game takes as his pieces are well poisedf or action, Bogdlln LIJJk - 14 ... a4 1 5.�1 j,£6 1 6. � c6 17.g4 "t!fe5 1 8.ltlf3 "t!fe7 1 9.g5 .ie5 20.h4 5 2 t .gxft'i Lffi 22.ltlg5 g6 23..th3 ltlb3 24_gdl hh3 25.� �8 26.ltlf3 "t!fe4 2U!.d3 Wh8 28.Wdl d5 29.h5 g5 30.bg5 Lg5 3 I .ltlxg5 "t!fg2 32 ."t!fc3+ d4 33�d4 'Bfl+ 34.Wc2 ltlal+ 0:1 Ad ler - Reinderrnan, Antwerp 1 994) 1 0. "t!fxe4+ ltlxe4 I J .j,f4 (Knuth - Hoch graefe, Germany 200 I, continued I I . ltld4 j,e? 1 2.j,f4 d6 1 3.g3 j,f6 1 4J::! d l b6!? I 5.ltlb5 wd8 I 6.j,g2 j,b7) I I ...d6 1 2 .e3 (if 12.ltld2, then 1 2 ... ltlc5) 1La5 1 3 .ltld4 ( 13..id3 ltlc5 1 4.j,e2 a4 1 5 .0-0
Black has tried: A) IO ...d5? I I .Wxd3 "t!ff6 12 .ltld4 dxc4+ 13.ltlxc4 j,5+ 14.�2 ()..()..() 15�2 "t!fg6 16."t!fb3 "t!fg4+ 1 7 .Wfl with decisive ad vantage, Holm - Erhard, Lyngby 1 986; B) I O ... ltlxc I+ (Black is virtuaUy unde veloped but has two bishops versus two knights and no weaknesses, Harding) I U !.xcl ( l l ."t!fxcl g6 12."t!fc3 f6 1 3 ."t!fd4 j,g? 1 4."t!ff4 d6 1 5 .l::!ac l Q.O left White in difficulties, Guichard - Mourot, Pau 2000 ) l l ...d6 (after l l ...g6 White should play 12 ."t!fc2 j,g? I H !.hdl 0-0 1 4.c5 a5 l 5.ltlc4, while Stoinic - Navinsek, Ljub ljana 1 99 5 , went 1 2 .ltlb l j,g? 1 3 .ltlc3 c6 14."t!fd3 a5 1 5 .ltle4 0-0 1 6.ltld6 axb4 17.axb4 l::!.a2+ 1 8.ltld2 j,e5 1 9.c5 b6!?) 1 2.ltlbl ( 1 2 .ltld4 is also good) 1 2 ... j,f5 1 3 .ltlc3 c6 14."t!fd4 a5 J 5 _ghd I yields a plus for White, Gutman; C) IO ... ltl f4+! I I .Wfl ltle6 12.ltlb3 b6 13..ib2 j,b? 14.ltlbd4 ltlxd4 ( 14 ...0-0-0 is probably not weaker, e.g. l 5.ltl5 "t!fe8 or 1 5.ltlb5 Wb8 16.ltlc3 'Bffi 1 7."t!fe2 'ifg6
,
95
I S.lt)dS ffi 19rul id6) IS.exd4 (IS.�xd4 16.'it>e2 ffi 17..mtdl �e6 18.cS 'it>b8) IS ...0-0-0 16.�3 ges 11_ge 1 �d8 1 8. d5 ( 1 8.gxe8 �xeS 19.�e3 .id6 20.fild2 f5 2 1 .�xe8+ gxe8 22.h4 .if4 23..ic3 dS 24.gh3 dxc4 2S.filf3 .ie4 26.fileS .idS and Black won, Rabar - Richter, Mu nich 1 94 1 ) 18 ...hel+ 19.'it>xel ft) gives Black the better chances, Gutman. III) 7 .g3 has more point.
�ffi 12..ig2 or IO ...�xb3 l l .�xb3 �xeS 12 ..if4 �cS 13.�c3 ggs 14 ..ieS ! ? �c6 IS..if6 d6, McDaid - Gibson, Dublin League 1 987/88, 16_ggl .ie6 17 .ig2 �a6 1 8.0-0-0 .ie7 1 9 .J.xe7 'it>xe7 20 ..idS! ) IO.ie3 .ig7 l l,jg2 Q.O 1 2.Q.O a4 13.�bd4 �xd4 14.�xd4 �xeS (14...�xd4 IS.hd4 .ixeS 16.e3) ISNdl d6 is equal, Gutman; Cl) 8..ig2 .ig7 9.0-0 �xeS (9...0-0 I O.b4 �xeS l l .�xeS .ixeS 1 2.�1 �e6 13.cS .ig7 14.�c4 or 9 ... aS I O.�b3!? �xb3 l l .�xb3 �xeS 1 2.J.e3 0-0 1 3 .&c l d6 14.cS are both none too impressive for Black) I O.�xeS .ixeS l l .�f3 !? (Zagor ovsky - Gibson, corr 1 983, went l l .�b I 0-0 1 2..ih6 ges 13 .�c2 �ffi 14..icl d6 IS� 1f3 1 6.e4 .id7 1 7.b3 a5 Yz-Yz, yet Black could play on with IS ...aS 16.b3 a4 17.b4 �b3, Gibson) 1 1 .. �7 1 2..igS ffi!? (12...�e4 13..ie3 d6 14.�4 �e7 IS.�c6! gives Black problems, e.g. IS ...�e6 16.J.xcS 0-0 1 7..id4 bxc6 1 8..ixc6 gbs 19-tdS or IS ...�d7 1 6� .ixd4 17.�xd4 ().() 1 8.�b4 f5 - 1 8...�b3 1 9.�c3 �xal 20.�dS �d8 2 1 .�f6+ 'it>h8 22.gxa I -, 19.�dS �d8 20.&dl �e6 2 1 .�d2 .id7 22.e3 aS and now instead of 23 .b4 axb4 24.axb4 ga4 2S.&I gxal 26.gxal bS? 27�8 �xa8 28.�e7+ 'it>f7 29.J.xa8 'it>xe7 30..lg2?! bxc4, Beecham - Gibson, corr 198S, 23.�f4!? �xf4 24.exf4) 1 3 ..ie3 0-0 gives Black adequate counterplay,
(}..().()
There are four options: A) 7 ... aS will transpose into 6.a3 a5 7.g3 �e7 - Sequel I ; B) 7 ...d6 8..ig2 �xeS (if 8...dxeS 9.b4, e.g. 9...e4 IO.lt:lgl e3 l l .fxe3 �7 I H::lh3 �xe3 13.�f4 fildeS 14.�b3 �c3+ IS.J.d2 �xc4 l6.gc 1 �a6 17.�dS .id6 1 8 .�cS or 9 ... �d7 1 0.0-0) 9.0-0 .id7 IO.�xeS �xeS I I .�f3 �ft) 12.�d4 c6 13.e4 .ie7 14..ie3 with an edge for White, Gutman; C) 7 ...g6 !?, John Gibson, and now: Cl) 8.�c2 aS (8 ...�xeS 9.�xeS �xeS I O.�f3 �e4 l l .�xe4+ �xe4 12.ie3 .ig7 13 ..id4 or 8 ... .ig7 9.b4 �xeS IO.�xeS .ixeS J J .gb J �e6 12..ig2 0-0 13.0-0 d6 14 . .ib2 are both less ambitious) 9.�b3 (9..ig2 .ig7 1 0.0-0 0-0 1 1 .ge1 �xeS 12. �xeS .ixeS 1 3.�f3 .if6 14..id2?! �e4 I S ..ie3 d6 16.�d4 ges 1 7.gadl a4 was seen in McDaid - Gibson, Dublin League 1988/89) 9 ... l0e6 (better than 9 ... �xeS IO.�xeS, for example IO ...�xeS l l ..if4
Gutman; D) 7 ... �xeS !? 8.�xeS �xeS (if 8 ...d6,
then not 9.b4? �xeS, but 9..ig2 ! dxeS IO.b4 �e6 l l ..ib2 f6 1 2.cS g6 1 3 .�c4 .ig7 14.�3 0-0 I S_gdl 'it>h8 1 6.0-0 with a spatial advantage for White, Koch Richter, Swinemuende 1933) 9.�f3 �e4 (after 9 ...�f6 I O ..ig2 .ie7 1 1 .0-0 �e6 12.e4 d6 1 3.�c2 0-0 14..ie3 .id7 IS.Imdl .i.c6 16.�4 �xd4 17 .hd4 White keeps some pressure, yet 9 ... �e7 I O ..ig2 g6 l l ..igS ffi 12.J.e3 .ig7 1 3.0-0 0-0 is pos sible transposing to C2) IO..ie3 (IO.b4 96
ltJe6 l l .�d5 �c2 12.�d3 �xd3 13.exd3 a5 is harmless) I O...�xo4 (I O...ie7 I 1.& I ()..{) 12.ig2 aS 13.().{)) 1 1 .&1 �S I2.�d5 d6 13..ixcS (13.b4 c6 14J:bcS is refuted by 14 ... dxcS IS.�e4+ .ie6 16..ih3 �c4) 13 ...dxcS (13 ..ie6 14.�e4 dxcS IS..ih3 0-0-0 1 6 ..ixe6+ fxe6 17 .ltJgS) 14.lOgS ( 14.�e5+ ie6 IS.ih3 .id6 16.�xg7 ()..()...() 1 7.he6 fxe6) 14 ... �d7 I S ..ig2 h6 1 6. �eS+ �e7 1 7 .�xe7 .ixe7 1 8.ltJe4 0-0 19 .ltJxcS c6 is OK for Black, Gutman.
IO...�g6 and IO...d6 1 1.ltJd4ie7 12..ic3 �gS 13.b4 ltJe6 14.ltJf5 .iffi IS..ixfti, Hil denbrandt - Storgaard, e-mail 1997, IS ... �xf6) 9...aS I O.b3 goes into 8 ...aS 9.b3 ltJxf3+ I O.gxf3- ///; Ill) 8...aS 9.b3 ltJxf3+ I O.gxf3 (I O.ltJxf3 is best answered by 10 ... b6 l l ..ib2 .ib7 12..ie2 �e4 or IO ...�f6 l l ..ib2 �g6 12. �xg6 hxg6. IO.. .a4 l l .b4 ltJb3 1 2J�bl ltJxc l 1 3Jbcl g6 is a waste oftime as 14.�c3 ffi IS.cS ig7 1 6..ic4 d6 17.cxd6 �xd6 1 8.0-0 .id7 1 9.�fdl �e7, Voigt Pfeiffer, Wuerzburg 1 987, 20.idS!? c6 21.J.a2 f5 22.�c2 shows while IO ...d6 l l..ib2�e4, Windfuhr- Schaffarth, Ger many 1987, 12.�xe4+ ltJxe4 13..td3 ltJcS 14.lc2 with an edge for White) IO ...b6! ( I O . . .�f6!? l l ..ib2 �g6 simplifies the game. Haring - Spoel, corr 1 989, went J O_d6 l l .ib2 .id7 12..ie2 �4!? 1 3.f4 � 14..if3 .if5 I S.�c3, when instead of IS ...Wd7 16.e4 M 17.Wdl ig4 1 8.hg4+ �xg4+ 1 9.f3 �xf4 20.�xaS �g8 2 1 .b4 �xd2+ 22.Wxd2 ltJb3+ 23.Wd3 ltJxaS 24. bxaS .ie7, I S ...hS 1 6.e4 .ig4 could have been tried, yet we can improve earlier with 12.h4!?) l l ..ib2 .ib7 12 ..ie2 (after 1 2.�gl �4!? 1 3 .h3 �g8 )4_gg4 �6 is the flexible reply, improving on 12 ft'i 13.b4 axb4 14.axb4 &a!+ IS..ixal ltJa6 16.bS , Quinn - Gibson, Dublin 1989, 16...ltJcS) 12...ffi 1 3.h4 (in reply to 13_gg1 I recommend 1 3 ...�e6 14.f4 � . while Gillam - Gibson, corr 1 990, continued 13...�f7 14.f4 id6 1S.O-O-O O-O-O 16.'kt>bl �deS 17.if3 g6 18 ..ixb7+ 'kt>xb7 19.h4 mtg8 20.ltJf3 �e7 2 l .lOd4 ltJe4 22f3 ltJcS 23.�gel f5 24.h5 c6 Y�Yz) 13...�e6 ( 13 ... �f7!? might well be more potent, e.g. 14.�gl �S or 1 4.hS .id6 I S.�gl ieS) 14.hS .id6 I S.�gl �e7 16.0-0-0?! (16.f4 was better as 16 ...ltJe4? fails to 17 ..if3, Kurt Richter) 16 ...ieS 17 ,gg4 .ixb2+ 1 8.�xb2 ltJe6 1 9.ltJbl ( 1 9.f4 ! ?) 19 ... f5 20.�gg I f4 2 l .ltJc3 (neither 2 1 .e4 �4
•
7 �xeS ...
7 ... aS may well be played, transposing to 6.a3 aS 7.e3 �e7 - Sequel I .
8.�xeS Ludwig Engels preferrtd 8.�c2, when
_
Black has three opportunities: I) 8 ... g6 9.b4! .ig7 IO.ltJxeS .ixeS ( 1 0... �xeS l l .�b I ltJe6 1 2 ..ib2) l l ..ib2 �f6 12.ltJe4 �g7 1 3.ltJc3 ltJe6 1 4.f4 .if6 IS. 0-0-0 (IS..ie2 0-0 1 6.0-0, NkoiD Minev) IS...aS 16.g4 axb4 17.axb4 0-0 18.gS ie7 19.ltJdS with the advantage, Engels Richter, Swinemuende 193 3 ; D) 8 ...ltJxf3+ 9.gxf3 (In case of9.ltJxf3 Black should avoid 9 ...�e4 because of IO.�xe4 ltJxe4 l l ..td3 ltJcS 12..ic2, im proving on IO.�c3 aS l l ..td2 a4 12i:tdl d6 13.ltJd4 .id7 14.ltJbS �k8 IS.f3 �e7 1 6.Wf2, Vanderstricht - van de Fliert, Ghent 2002, 1 6 ...c6 I 7.ltJd4 �f6. After 9 ...�fti I O..id2 he has a choice between 97
nor 21 .h6 fxe3 22.fxe3 0-0-0! 23.fxg7 l3hg8 are sufficient, Richter) 2 1 ...fxe3 22.fxe3 �c5 23.e4 � xh5 24.�d2 �f7 25 .c;!;lb2 0-0-0 26.b4 axb4 27.axb4 �f6 28 .c;!;lb) �e5 and Black won, Engels Richler, Bad Oeynhausen 1937, Gutman.
Alternatives: I) I O.l':Ibl �g6 ( IO ... a5 l l .b3 �c3+ is
not bad either, viz. 12.�d2 c!Lle4 13.�xc3 c!Llxc3 14.l3al c!Lle4 1 5..id3 c!Llc5 1 6..ic2 .ie7 17 ..ib2 0-0, van der Himst - Pover, Alkmaar 1 995) l l . .id2 .ie7, Gutman; further ll) I O.�c2 a5 (IO ...�g6 is more simple, Tseitlin/G/Qskov, for example l l .�xg6 hxg6 12.c!Lld4 a5 or l l .�c3 .ie7, while IO ...g6 1 1 �2 �e7 1 2..ic3 ffi 13.b4 c!Lle4 14..ib2 b6 15h4ib7 16..id3 ih6 17.c!Llg5 fXg5 18..ixh8 gxh4 19 ..ixe4 1xe4 20.�c3 .ixg2 2 1 .iffi .ig7 22..ixg7 ixh I 23..if6 �e6 24..ixh4 c;!(f7 25.0-0-0 .ic6 26.b5 .ib7 27.l3d4 d6 28..ig5 c;!;lg8 29.l3f4 �e5 was unclear, Johansson - Bisguier, Hel sinki Olympiad 1 952) l l ..id2 ( l l .c!Lld4 c6) l l ...a4 12..ic3 �g6 poses no prob lems for Black, Gutman.
8. . . �xeS
9.fHJ
9.l3b I a5 (9...�f5 IO.b4 c!Lld3+ l l ..ixd3 �xd3 1 2.l3b3 �g6 13.0-0 favours White, e.g. 13 ...d6 14.e4 .ig4 1 5.�c2 .ie7 16.h3 .id7 17lig3 �e6 18. l3xg7, A32ll31ldius Robinhood, intemet 2002, or 1 3 ....ie7 14.e4 0-0 15..ib2 .i£6 1 61ig3 �h6 1 7.e5 .ig5 1 8.c!Lle4 ih4 19lig4 d6 20..icl .ixg4 2 l .�xg4, Gomez - Cubas, Spain 1 992) IO.b4 (IO.b3 �f5 l l ..ib2 d6 12..ie2 .ie7) I O ...axb4 l l .axb4 c!Lla4 (instead of I I ... c!Lle4 12.�c2 c!Llxd2 1 3..ixd2 &I 14.i.d3 l':Ixbl + 1 5.�xbl .ie7 16.0-0, Gual - Vaz quez, Cugat 1 996) 1 2.c5 .ie7 13 ..id3 (13 ..ib5 c!Llc3 1 4..ib2 � 1 5 .\Wb3 l3xb2 1 6.�xb2 �f6) 1 3 ... c!Llc3 14 ..ib2 �d5 !? 15..ixc3 �xd3 16..ixg7 l3g8 17..ie5 l3xg2 with a balanced position, Gutman.
IO .. ..le7
Less effective are: I) I O ... b6, suggested by Minev, 1 1 .0-0 (l l ..l332 a5 12.b3 ib7 13..ib2 �g6 14.0-0 .ie7 15..id4 d6 1 6.c!Llel 0-0 is harmless, Vujanovic - Storgaard, e-mail 2000. On l l .�d4 Black should play l l ... .ie7, in stead of I L ..ib7?! 1 2.�xf6 gxf6 1 3 .b4 c!Lle4 14..ib2 l3g8 1 5 .c!Llh4 .ie7 1 6.f3 c!Lld6 17.c5 f5 18.cxd6 .txh4+ 19.g3, Schmid Petzenhauser, Germany 1999) I I ...ib 7 12.c!Lld4 .ie7 (12 ....id6 1 3 .c!Llb5 .ie5 14.f4
9...1tf6
9 ...�f5 I O..ie2!? (IO.b4 �ffi l l ..l332 c!Lle6 12..ib2 �d8 13..id3 a5 14.b5 d6 1 5.0-0 .ie7 1 6.�c2 h6, Kulczycki - Newton, e mail 2000) IO .. ..ie7 1 1 .0-0 0-0 12 .c!Lld4 �f6 1 3 .b4 c!Lle6 14 ..ib2, Gutman. IO..lel
98
id6 is an intriguing attempt, and now not 1 5.l0xd6+ cxd6 16if3 0-0 1 7ixb7 l0xb7 1 8 .&2 l0c5 19.b3 Wc3, Fabris Storgard, corr 1 998, but 15.Jd2 0-0 16. 1c3) 13.b4 l0e6 (13 ... l0e4 I4if3 c5 is doubtful in view of IH�c2 We5 16.l0b5 0-0 17.1b2 Wf5 1 8.l0c7 E!ac8 19.l0d5) 14ib2 Wg6 15.1f3 1xf3 16.l0xf3 .tf6 17 ixffi Wxffi, Vujadinovic - Storgaard, e-mail 2000, 1 8 .Wa4 !?, Gutman; m IO ...a5 I I .l0d4 c6(if I I ..ie7 12.l0b5, e.g. 12 ... l0e6 1 3 id2 ! ? c6 1 4.1c3 Wg6 1 5 .l0d6+ 1xd6 1 6.Wxd6 Wxg2 1 7.E!fl WgS 18.f4 or 12.id 8 1 3..id2 l0e4 14.1f3 l0xd2 1 5.Wxd2 0-0 16.0-0 d6 17�fd I &8 18i!acl) 12.0-0 (1 2.b3 is premature due to 12 ...a4 1 3 .b4 l0b3 14.l0xb3 axb3 1 5. .E!b l Wg6 I 6.E!xb3 Wxg2 17.10 Wg6) 12 ..ie7 (12 ... Sd6 1 3.b3 0-0 14ib2 E!e8 1 5 .b4) 1 3 .b3 0-0 I4ib2 Wg6 (14 ...E!e8 1 5 .b4 l0e6 1 6.f4) 1 5 .b4 axb4 16.axb4 E!xal 1 7 .1xal l0a6 1 8.1d3, Gutman.
1 5.l0d5 1d8 1 6.e4 or 1 4 ...c6 1 5 .e4 1g5 1 6..bg5 Wxg5 1 7.Wd6, while Rejfir Richter, Prague Olympiad 1 93 1 , went 14.e4 .ig5 15.g3 a6 16.l0c3 hcl i7.Wxcl Wxcl 1 8.E!axcl l0d4 19.E!cdl l0xe2+ 20. l0xe2 d6 Y2-Yz) 14.1d2 (Otto Borik has commen ted that I4if3 E!d8 I S.E!bl?! c6 16.l0c3 l0g5 1 7ie2 1f5 I8id3 l0h3+! 19.gxh3 Wg6+ 20.�hl ixd3 is good for Black) 14 ...1d7 1 5 .l0c3 c6 1 6.f4 and I prefer White, Gutman. 1 2.0-0 aS
12 ...d6 13.b4 l0e6 I4ib2 l0xd4 1 5ixd4 Wg6 I 6i f3!? (1 6ih5 Wg5 1 7.f4 'Ml6 1 8 ..if3 Wg6 Yz-Yz Agostini - Bologni, Italy 1996) 16 ... c6 1 7.b5, Gutman. 13.b3
13.l0b5 c6 14.l0c3 d6 and White gets nowhere, Gutman.
1 1 .�d4
13...b6
13 ...d6 14ib2 Wg6 1 5.�hl id7 I 6,jh5 Wh6 1 7.1f3 1ffi is also OK for Black, Mollenschott - Keller, Berlin 1 98 7. 14. 1 b2
11 ...0-0
14.E!a2 ib7 1 5 .1g4 1e4 1 6.1b2 Wg6 1 7if3 c6 I8ixe4 l0xe4 19.l0e2 E!fd8 20.l0f4 Wg5 2 I id4-*':5 22Wf3 E!e8 was seen in EX Chess - huni Chess, compu ter game Cologne 2000. 14...1b7 Black has the greater mobility, Gutman.
Some examples of other moves: I) I I ...d6 12.0-0 ie6 13.b4 l0d7 14ib2 0-0 1 5.Wc2 'Ml6 1 6.f4 l0b6 1 7.r!f3 1g4 1 8.E!g3 gave White the advantage, Feuer - Def osse, Liege 1 934; m l l ...l0e6 1 2.l0b5 0-0 1 3.0-0 d6 ( 13 ... 1!/h6 could be met by 1 4.l0c3, e.g. 14...d6
99
Section 6 Th e Alekhine Variation (l .d4 'tlf6 l.c4 e5 3.dxe5 'tle4 4.'tldl 'ticS 5.'tlgf3 'tlc6) 6.g3
This plan is a little slow and does not hing to show up the disadvantages of the knight's placement on c5, Tim Htu ding.
White reinforces the kingside by fian chettoing his bishop, leaving Black to justify his pawn sacrifice. The move is very natural and was given its first stamp of approval by the great Alatltukr Akkhine, Bogdan Lalic.
U) 6 ... g5 7.J.g2 g4 8.ltlh4 .ig7 (is more stubborn than 8 ...'f!e7 9.0-0 ltlxe5 I O.b4 ltla6 l l .a3 d6 12.'flc2 ltlg6 13.J.bH lg8 14.ltlf5 'f!g5, when instead of 15.e4 ltlb8 16.c5 dxc5 17.bxc5 ltlc6 1 8.f4 'f!h5 19. l::!ad 1, Eliskases - Pitschak, Moravska Osllava 1 933, 15.ltle4! would have been decisive, e.g. 1 5 ... 'f!xf5 1 6.ltlf6+ �d8 17 .ie4 or 1 5 ...ixf5 16.'f!a4+ .id7 17.'f!b3 'f!f5 1 8.ltlf6+) 9J�b I!? a5 10.0-0 .ixe5 l l .ltle4 ltlxe4 12 ..ixe4 d6 1 3 .J.e3 .le6 14.b3 'f!d7 1 5.'f!d2 f5 1 6.J.hl 'f!g7 1 7 .a3 h5 1 8.l'Ud 1 .if6 1 9.J.d5 .lc8 20.c5 dxc5 2 U�bcl ltle5 22.lhc5 c6 23 ..ig2 .le6 24.'f!d6'f!d7 25.ltlxf5 0-0-0 26_gxa5 and White won, Kasimdzhanov - Schlind wein, German Bundesliga 200 1 ; III) 6 ....ie7 7 .J.g2 0-0 8.0-0 f6 9.ltlb3 (in place of9.ex.f6 .ixf6 1 O.l:ibl a5, Gon zales - Alonso, Castellar 1 995) 9 ...l!:\xb3 I O.axb3!? fxe5 l l .'f!d5+ �h8 12.ltlxe5 ltlxe5 13.'f!xe5 d6 14.'f!d5 .if6 1 5.'f!d3 leaves Black with no compensation for the pawn, Gutman; IV) 6...b6 7..ig2 .ib7 8.0-0 'f!e7 9.gbJ (9.ltlbl ?!, de Andres Gonalons - Krug, Dortmund 2003, is well met by 9 ltlxe5. Gambit Tiger - Fritz 6, computer game 200 1 , proceeded 9.ltlb3 ltlxb3 IO.axb3 l!:lxe5 l l .ltlxe5 .ixg2 1 2.�xg2 'f!xe5 13. .if4 'f!e4+ 14.f3 'f!c6 15.&6 .ib4 16.'f!d5 'f!xd5 1 7.cxd5 �e7 1 8.gfal .id6 19.J.d2, yet 1 5 ....lc5!? 16.'f!d5 'f!xd5 17.cxd5 �d8 18.gfal ge8 19. e4 b5 20.b4.id4 should hold for Black) 9 ...a5 IO.b3 ltlxe5 I I J.b2 f6 1 2.ltlxe5 .ixg2 13.�xg2 fxe5 14.ltlf3 d6 15.'f!d5 l::!d8 1 6..mdl g6 17.'f!c6+ gd7, Mueller - Klein, Eisenberg 1999, 18..ia3 .lg7 19.J.xc5 bxc5 20.ltld2 0-0 2 1 .ltle4 yields an advantage for White, Gutman; V) 6 ... d5 7.cxd5!? (7.exd6 will transpose into 6.g3 d6 7.exd6 - Sequel 2) 7...'f!xd5 8.J.g2 �xe5 9.0-0 .ie7 (9 ...a5 IO.�xe5 'f!xe5 l l .ltlc4 'f!f6 1 2 ..if4 .ie6 13.'f!cl 'f!d4 14.b3 .ixc4 1 5 .gd J 'f!f6 16.'f!xc4 .•
The materilll divUies tiS follows:
Sequel I - 6...'f!e7 (6.. .h5, 6...g5, 6.. �7. 6...b6, 6...d5, 6...g6) Sequel 2 - 6... d6. Sequel 1 6...1re7
Some examples of other moves: I) 6...h5 7.a3 'f!e7 (7.. .aS 8.'f!c2 'f!e7 9.ltle4 ltlxe5 I O.ltlxe5 'f!xe5 I I .J.g2, Gutman) 8.b4 ltlxe5 9 ..ig2!? (9.bxc5? ltld3 mate Koppe - Hain, Siegen 194 1 ) 9 ... l!:\cd3+ IO.exd3 ltlxf3+ I I .<Ml ltlxd2+ 12.'f!xd2 with a plus for White, TseitHn/GIIISkov;
1 00
c6 1 7 .ie3, Keres - Mikulka, corr 1 938; 9.. .J.d7, Harding, lO.�g5 "t!fd4 l l .�de4 "t!fxd l 12Jhdl ffi 13.ie3 �xe4 14.�xe4, or 9 ... �xf3+ lO ..ixf3 "t!fd4 l l ."t!fc2 .ih3 , Cordoba - Molinari, corr 1 977, 1 2.ixb7! �xb7 1 3 ."t!fc6+ "t!fd7 1 4."t!fxb7 �d8 1 5 . �e l are all awkward for Black) 1 0.�g5 (I O.b4 �e6 1 1 ib2 �xf3+ 1 2..ixf3, giv en by Jacques de Monnier, is useless due to 12 ..."t!ib5) lO ..."t!f d6 l l .�ge4 �xe4 1 2 .�xe4 "t!fxdl 1 3 .�xdl 0-0 1 4.J.f4 f6 1 5..ixe5 fxe5 16.�d5 iffi 1 7.�xf6t gxffi 1 8�dl and Black is still worse, Gutman; VI) 6 ... g6 deserves attention.
White has three options: A) 7.�b l , suggested by Nicolll Minev,
7...�e6 (7 ... ig7 8.�c3 0-0 9.J.g2 �xe5 IO.�xe5 ixe5 l i .J.h6 �e8 1 2.0-0 is an analysis by Tseitlin/GIIlskov, on which we can improve with 8.ig5, e.g. 8 . . .f6 9.exf6 ixf6 I O .ixf6 "t!fxf6 l l .�c3 or 8 ...�e7 9.�c3 h6 I O.J.e3 b6 1 1 J.g2 ib7 1 2.0-0) 8.�c3 ig7 9.ig2 (if 9."t!fd5 b6 to .J.g2 ib7) 9 ... b6 (9 ... 0-0 10.0-0 �xe5 l l .�xe5 ixe5 1 2 .ih6 �e8 1 3 ."t!fd2 is better for White) 1 0.0-0 tb7 l l ."t!fd2 (on l l ."t!fd5 0-0 1 2ru1 Black plays 12 ..."t!fb8 13 ."t!fd2 �xe5 14.�xe5 ixe5) 1 1 ...0-0 12_gdl �c5 1 3�1 �xe5 14.�xe5 .ixe5 15 .hb7 �xb7 1 6."t!fxd7 "t!fxd7 17 .�xd7 �c5 1 8.�d5 .ixc3 19.bxc3 �fe8 20.J.e3 �e4 appears good for Black, Gutman;
B) 7 .J.g2 ig7 8.�b3 �e6 (8 ... �xb3?! 9.ig5) 9.0-0 0-0 (9 ... a5 1 0."t!fd5 !?, e.g. 10...a4 l l.�c5 &5 12.�xe6 fxe6, Nedo bora - Granados, Zaragoza 199 5, 13."t!fxa5 �xa5 14.J.g5; 1 0 ...b6 l l .�bd4 ib7 1 2 . �xe6 fxe6 13."t!fe4 0-0 14J.f4 o r I O ..."t!fe7 l l .J.d2 b6 1 2 .J.c3 ib7 1 3 .�ad 1 ) I O.e4 ( IO."t!fd5 "t!fe7 is fine for Black, for in stance l i .J.e3 a5 1 2 .�c5 �b4 1 3 .�xe6 �d5 14�5 "t!fxe6 15.cxd5 "t!fxd5, Perez Zapata, Havana 200 1 ; l l .h4 a5 12.J.d2 a4 13.�cl ru8 14.i.c3 a3 15."t!fe4 �c5 16. "t!fc2, Gual - Ballesteros, Foment 1 994, 16...�a4; or l i .J.d2 b6 1 2 .�bd4 �exd4 13.�xd4ib7) 10 ..."t!fe7 l l..ie3 a5 ( l l ...b6 12."t!fd2 a5 1 3 .�adl ia6 14."t!fc l ixe5 15.�xe5 �xe5 1 6."t!fc3 ffi 17 .�d2 b5!? 1 8 .b3 bxc4 19.�xc4 "t!lb4 20.�cl �ab8 2l .�xe5 .ixfl 22.�xd7 .ixg2 23 ."t!fxb4 �xb4 with sufficient counterplay, Gior gadze - Buckley, Andorra 1 997, while l l ...�xe5 1 2 .�xe5 ixe5 1 3 ."t!fd2 d6?! 14.f4 ig7, Paavilainen - Rantaleinen, corr 1 988, is doubtful in view of 1 5 .fS �d8 1 6.c5) 12."t!fd2 a4 1 3.�bd4 �exd4 14.�xd4 �xe5 should be even, Gutman; C) 7.�b3 ! ? �e6 (7 ... �xb3 8."t!fxb3 h6, Tseillin/GIIlskov, 9.ig2 ig7 1 0.0-0 "t!fe7 l l .�d l , e.g. 1 1 ...0-0 1 2 .�d5 b6 1 3 .ie3 ib7 14.�2 md8 15_gad l or l l ...�xe5 1 2.�xe5 .ixe5 13 J.e3) 8.i.d2 ig7 9.ic3 a5 (9 ...0-0 10..ig2 �e8 1 1 .0-0 with some pressure for White, for example 1 1 .�b8, Fragnaud - Bert, corr 1 995, 12 ."t!fc2 "t!l e7 13:�d l , or l l ...a5 12."t!fc2 a4 1 3 .�bd2 �c5 14.b4 axb3 1 5 .axb3 �xal 16_gxa l) I O.J.g2 (I O."t!fc2 0-0 l l .�dl a4 12.�bd2 �c5 brings White nowhere: 1 3 .b4 axb3 14.axb3 "t!fe7, 13.�e4 �xe4 14."t!fxe4 �e8 or 1 3 .J.g2 "t!fe7 14.0-0 �xe5) IO ...a4 I I . �bd4 (Taimanov - Mukhitdinov, USSR 1 95 5, went l l .�bd2 d6 1 2 .exd6 !xc3 1 3.bxc3 "t!fxd6 14.�e4 "t!fe7 1 5 ."t!fd2 fS?! 1 6.�eg5 �a5 1 7 .�xe6 .ixe6 1 8.�e5 0-0 19.0-0 c6 20."t!ff4 �ae8 2 1 .�fel "t!fc5 _
101
22J�ab l .ic8 23 .�d3 with some edge for White, but l S ...0-0 16.Y:!Ih6 ffi 1 7.0-0 �g7 1 8 .�d4 �eS looks more logical) l l ...�exd4 ( l l ... �xeS 12.�xe6 �xO+ l3 .cJ?fl fxe6 14 ..ixg7 ggs 1S ..ic3 �gS 1 6.h4 �17 17.hS) 1 2.�xd4 �xeS ( 1 2... .ixeS l3.�bS 0-0 14.0-0 d6 1S.f4) l3.�bS 0-0 14.0-0 d6 1 S .f4 �c6 16..hg7 cJ?xg7 17.e4 is preferable for White, Gutman. Back to the main line
7..lg2 g6 Is it Black s best to delay the immediate recapture of the pawn?. According to StJVieUy Tartll kower, 7 ... �xeS 8.0-0!? (After S.�xeS �xeS 9.0-0 g6 lOl!bl �e7 l l .b4 �e6 1 2 ..ib2 ffi 13. � .ig7 14.cS 0-0 1 S .�c3 Black faces some problems, yet 9 ... d6!? is the right answer. If now lOl!bl , so lO ....ie7 l l .b4 l£k:6 12..ib2 Y:!lhS since lO ....ig4 1 1.�0 is to White's liking, e.g. l l ...�e4 12.J.e3 �xc4 1 3 .J.xcS �xeS 14.�a4+ .id7 lS. �e4+ .ie7 1 6.�xb7, l l ...Y:!IhS 12.b4 �e6 l 3 ..ie3 Ae7 14.�a4+ c6 1S.bS or l l ...ti'f5 1 2 .J.e3.ie7 l3.b4 �d7 14.�d4 Y:!lhS l S . .ixb7 gbs, San Pedro - Tomay Gomez, Guipuzcoa Mondragon 2002, 1 6 ..10. Black is also in good shape after 1 0.�0 tru l l.b4 llk:6 12..ib2 Ae7 l3 .�d5 �g6) fa vours White 's development, then:
I) 8 ... �x0+ 9.ex0 (9.�xf3 is harmless, e.g. 9 ... g6 1 0.�d4 ffi l l .b3 �e6 1 2 .�d2 .ig7 l 3 .J.b2 0-0 14.gad l d6, Pesonen Auvinen, Finland 1998, or 9 ... �e6 IO.b3 �f6 l l .gb l .ib4 12 ..ib2 .ic3 1 3 ..ixc3 �xc3 14.e3 0-0 l S .& l �2 l 6_gc2 �ffi 1 7.�4 d6, Bailen - Humme ling, e-mail 1998) 9...�d8 l01!e l + .ie7 l l .�e2 �e6 1 2.f4 can only benefit White, Gutman; II) 8 ... �c6 (would have offered Black betterchancesfor his development, Ald hine) 9.�b 1 �e4 I O.�fd2 �xd2 l l .J.xd2 �d8 1 2.�c3 .ie7 1 3 .�dS, Gutman; m) 8 ...�g6 9.�b3(instead of9.�c2 d6 IO.b4 �e6 l l ..ib2 c6 1 2.e4 �c7 l3.gfel f6 14 .�fl .ie7 l S .� l �eS l 6.�h4 g6 17.�3 �g7 18.h3 0-0, Seppings - Taba kiemik, Oxford 1967) 9 ...�e6 1 0.�c2 �d8 l l ..ie3 .ie7 1 2 .gad l , Gutman; IV) S...aS 9.�xeS!? �xeS 1 0.�0 �f6 ( l O...Y:!IhS l l .�d4 .ie7 1 2 .�bS .idS 1 3 . .ie3 ga6 is strongly met by 14 ..if3 �f5 lS.�d4 �e6 1 6.�dS �ffi 17.�a7, while 14.gc 1 d6 1 S .J.d4 0-0 1 6.e4 �xd 1 led to equality, Sieglen - Lanzan i, Lugano 198S) l l .li:ld4 (l l .�c2ti'g6 12.�xg6 hxg6 is innocuous, Jorgensen - Pedersen, Co penhagen 1997) l l ...c6 ( ll ....ie7 l2.�bS) 1 2.e4 d6 13..ie3 Ae7 14.�c2 0-0 lS�l are all better for White, Gutman; V) 8 ... d6 9.b4 will demonstrate itself to be hardly satisfactory either, Alekhine.
1 02
We examine: A) 9 ...li)xO+ lOoexO ! ? (Noden - Stor
gaard, e-mail l 997, went l O o.lxO lt)e6 l l ..lb2 �g5 l2..lg2 .le7 13oe4 0-0 l 4.f4 �6 l5o�e2 .iffi l6oli)b3 .lxb2 l 7o�xb2, when 17 oooli)d8 l 8J:!ael .lh3 might be played) l 0oooli)e6 l l .f4 �f6 l 2 ol:!bl 1e7 l 3 o1b2 �h6 l 4 ol:!e l , Gutman; further B) 9oo oli)a6 l 0oa3 c5 l l .b5 li)c7 l2 ..lb2 ffi l3oli)xe5 dxe5 l4oe3 g6 l 5 of4 .th6 l 6o li)e4 0-0 l 7o�d6 �xd6 l 8oli)xd6, Tadzik Grzegorzewski, corr 1 992; similarly C) 9 00 oli)e6 l Oo.lb2 (l Ooli)xe5 dxe5 l l . 1b2 f6 l 2oa3 c6 l 3 oe3 .id7 l 4ob5 cxb5 l 5 ..lxb7 l:!b8 l 6o.ld5 li)c7 left Black in control, Arasan - Inmi Chess, computer game 2000 ) l 0oo.f6 (10ooolt)d8 is best met by l l .c5! , while Milligan - Rasmussen, Copenhagen 1 997, continued l l .�c2 g6 l 2 o&dl 1g7 l3 oc5 dxc5 l4oli)xe5 1xe5 l 5 ..lxe5 �xeS l 6oli)e4 0-0 l 7ol:!d5 �g7 l 8 ol:!fdl .ifS) 1 1 .m3 ( l l .l:!c l !? g6 l2oc5 1g7 l3oc:r..d6 �xd6 l4oli)xe5 fxe5 l5 oli)c4 is also good, Kaiser - Stulik, Aschach 1 994) l l ...�n l2 oli)h4 li)g6 (if l2 oo.J.e7 l3oli)f5 .idS l4.f4 li)d7 l5 oc5) l3oli)f5 lt)e7 l4oli)e3 g6 1 5 oli)e4 .lg7 l 6oli)d5 li)xd5 l 7 ocxd5 li)d8 l 8 o&cl .its (after 1 8 0000-0 l 9 o�c2 fS 20oli)g5 �e7 2 1 .1xg7 �xg7 22.�xc7 White won easily in Vidmar Kostic, Yugoslavia 1 947) l91k4 0-0 200 l:!fc l 1xe4 21 .1xe4 and White's advan tage is overwhelming, Gutman; D) 9oooli)cd7 lO..lb2 g6 ( l 0oooli)c6 l l .a3 li)de5 l 2 o�c2 g6 l 3 .b5 li)d8 l 4oli)xe5 dxe5 l 5oa4 c5 l 6obxc6 li)xc6 occurred in Trailovic - Bosnic, Yugoslav League 2003, when l 7o.lxc6+ bxc6 1 8o�e4 was crying to be played) l l oli)xe5 ( l l oli)d4 .lg7 l 2of4 li)g4 13om3 �e3+ l4o�xe3+ li)xe3 l S oli)bS .lxb2 came to a bad end for White in Kaufmann - Storgaard, e mail l 997) l l ...dxe5 l2oc5 1g7 l 3 oli)c4 0-0 was TIUtlllwwer's choice of evils, with a further split:
01) l4o�d5 l:!b8 (not l4ooM l 5 oc6 bxc6 l6o�xc6 l:!b8 l 7o�xc7 .h6 l8oli)d6, Lan naiolui - Storgaard, e-mail 1 997) l 5..§ad l l:!e8 makes Black's task easier, Gutman; 02) l 4oc6 bxc6 l 5 o.lxc6 ( l S oli)aS li)b8 or l 5oa3 e4 1 6..bg7 �xg7 17o�d4+ lt)ffi are less promising, Alekhine) l 5 oool:!b8 l 6ob5 l:!d8 17 Jb3 �e6 (if l 7...�f6, then l 8oli)d2 �e6 l9oli)e4, while l8o�a4 li)b6 l 9o�xa7 li)xc4 20o�xb8 li)xa3 2 l o�xc7, Alekhine, fails to 2 1 00..1� 22ol:!fd l .id6) l 8oli)a5 �f6 l9o�c2 ( l 9o.lg2 is rather better here, but the te:ct is good enough, Alekhine) l 9oool£)� 20ol:!fdl (the co"ect way of maintain ing the positional ad vantage was 2001g2,for example 20 000 l:!xb5 2 1 .�xc7 �b6 22 o�xb6 l:!xb6 230 li)c6 or 20oooli)e6, so far Ale/chine, 2 l ..h7 �xe7 22oli)c6) 20 .1fS 2 l o�c5 li)e6 220 �e7 (after 22�xa7 li)d4 23.�xc7 lt)xe2+ White should play 24o�g2 e4 25 1!xd8+ l:!xd8 26.k7 ih3+ 27.�h3 �fS+ 28o�g2 �0+ 29o�fl � l+ 30o�e2 �f3+ with a draw byperpetual, since 24o�h l? loses to 24oooe4 25 o.le7 .lg4 ! 26ol:!xd8+ .t�. Alekhine) 22 oooe4 (Hans Kmoch gives 22oo oli)d4) 23 oli)b3 �xe7!? (improving on 23 oooe3 24o�xffi ixffi 251!acl fud l+ 26ol:!xdl .lc2 271!d7 .lxb3 28oaxb3 exf2+ 29o�xf2 l:!d8 30ol:!xd8+ li)xd8 3 l ..id5, van Scheltinga - Tartakower, Buenos Aires Olympiad 1 939) 2401xe7 1xa l 25ol:!xal li)d4 26o.lxd8 li)xc6 with equal chances, Gutman; 03) l 4oli)a5!? c6 l 5 oli)c4 l:!d8 l 6o�c2 lt)� 17 oli)d6 li)e6 l 8oe3 leaves Black in desperate straits, Alekhine; 04) l 4o§c2 !? l:!b8 l 5 ol:!adl l:!e8 l 6.1c3 lt)� 17 o�b2 f6 l 8oli)a5 g5 19 ol:!d2 li)g6 20Mdl h5 2 l .�c2 f5 22oc6 b623.�7�ffi (23-..lxd7 24oexd7 bxa5 25odxe8�+ l:!xe8 26o�xf5 �ffi 27.\!MI3) 24-.idS+ �h7 25M7 and White won in Szp otanski - Kam kowski, Czestochowa 19560 _
1 03
Back to the main line
8.� b l ! "This move, though astonishing a tfirst sight, is in fact perfectly logical. Once Black has clearly revealed his intention to develop his bishop on g7, White no longer needs to reckon with any action on the e 1 -a5 diagonal. Therefore he has no reason to refrain from bringing his knight to the dominating square d5", Alekhine. Profound as well as original. The knight is bound for d5. The effect of this fine retrograde manoeuvre is most remar kable, Tartakower. Other possibilities are: I) 8.li:lb3 lL\xb3 !? (8 ... lL\xeS 9.0-0 .ig7 IO.lL\xeS .ixeS l l .lL\xcS �xeS 12..ih6 c6 1 3 .'lfb3 �b6 1 4.�a4!? d6 1 S J:Ud l .id7 1 6.gd3 a6 1 7.� I 0-0-0 1 8 .gb3 turned out well for White, Palenius - Seppala, corr 1 979) 9.�xb3 .ig7 10.0-0 0-0 with a level game, Gutman ; ll) 8.0-0 .ig7 9.IDII (9.lL\bl lL\xeS I O.lL\c3 goes back into the main line) 9 ... a5 I O.b3 0-0 (Krause - Klueting, Dortmund 200 1, went I O...lL\xeS l l .ia3 d6 1 2.lL\xeS .ixeS 13 ,gc I 0-0 1 4.lL\b I and now instead of 14 ...gd8 IS.lL\c3 c6 1 6.�d2 .ie6 1 7.�e3 .ixc3 1 8 .gxc3, Black could play 14 ...c6 I S .lLlc3 hS!? 1 6.�d2 h4) l l ..ib2 ge8!?
(l l . . .lL\xeS 12 .lL\d4 d6 1 3 .�c2 f5 1 4.a3 c6 I S .b4 axb4 16.axb4 lL\e6 1 7 .e3 .id7 is also playable, Kohlweyer - Dohmes, Baden-Baden 1987, though I prefer 13 ... .id7 !?) 1 2 .ge l lL\xeS 1 3 .lL\d4 ( 1 3 .lL\xeS .ixeS 14..ixe5 �xeS IS .ll:lf3 �ffi 16.�d4 �xd4 1 7.lL\xd4 d6 1 8.e4 .id7 1 9.ge3 ge7 20.gbe l &e8 2 1 .a3 b6 22.f4 f6 23.h3 rt1g7 24.'it12? f5 2S.eS dxeS 26.lL\c6.ixc6 27..ixc6 gd8 with advantage to B lack in Gemzoe - Koming, Copenhagen 1 94 1 ) 1 3 ...d6 1 4.�c2 .id7 I S.a3 lL\c6 1 6.lL\xc6 .ixc6 17..ixc6 bxc6 1 8..ixg7 rt1xg7 1eads to equality, Gutman; III) 8.b4 lL\xb4, and now: A) 9.0-0 .ig7 IO..ib2 lL\c6 (also 1 0 ... 0-0 l l .lL\b3 lL\c6 12.lL\xcS�xcS 13.�cl lL\xeS 14.lL\xeS .ixeS IS..ia3 �d4 1 6.gbJ ge8 is reasonable) I I IDJI 0-0 12.lL\b3 (12.h3 d6 1 3.exd6 cxd6 1 4.lL\b3 .if'S) 12 ...aS !? ( 1 2...lL\xb3 13 .�xb3 lL\xeS 14.lL\xeS .ixeS IS..ixb7 Ml8 16.�e3 seems even) 13..ia3 (13 .lL\xcS �xeS 14 .�dS is best answered by 1 4...�e7) 13 ... lL\b4 14.lL\xcS (1 4.�d2 lL\xb3 t s .gxb3 ge8) 1 4 ... �xcS I S .�d2 ( I S .�a4 ga6) I L.ge8 appears fme for Black, Truelock - Gibson, Dublin 1 992; B) 9.lL\b3 lL\xb3 (less impressive is 9 ... �e6 10.0-0, e.g. IO...lL\c6 l l .lL\bd4 �xc4 12..ig5 lL\xd4 13 .lL\xd4 .ig7 14.gc l 'Ml4 IS,gbJ �c4 1 6.lL\bS lL\e6 17..idS or 10 ... lL\xb3 l l .axb3 .ig7 12.&S !? 0-0 1 3.ia3 �e7 14.�d2 cS t s.gxcS �xeS 16..ixb4, Raffalt - Suhr, Graz 1 993) I O.axb3 lL\c6 (better than I O .. ..ig7 l l ..igS �e6 1 2.h4 h6 13..th3 �c6 1 4..if4 d6 IS..ixc8 gxc8 16.0-0 dxeS 1 7..ixeS .ixeS 18 .lL\xeS �d6 19.lL\d3, while Black lost in Beliavsky Toulzac, Bastian 1 998, with I S ... dxeS 16..id2 gxc8 1 7 ..lxb4 gd8 1 8.�ci i :O) l l ..igS ( I I .O-O .ig7) l l ...'lfh4+ 12 ..id2 �e7 1 3 ..igS is a repetition, Gutman. s... �xes 9.0-0 9.lL\xeS �xeS 10.0-0 (I O.lL\c3 lL\e6, while IO d6? l l ..if4 �g7 1 2 .lLldS f6 1 3..id2
1 04
.•
.15 1 4.J.c3 was a disaster for Black in Zlotnik - Lopez de Turido, Oviedo 2002) 1 o .. .J.g7 l l .ltlc3 ltle6 1 2.ti'd5 ti'f6 ( 1 2 ... c6 13.ti'xe5 .he5 14.J.d2 b6 1 5 .f4 .ig7 16.15 gxf5 171WS .ia6 18.b3 ltld4 191U2 0-0 20.ge 1 gae8 2 l .ltle4 d5!? 22.cxd5 ltlxe2+ 23.&xe2 .he2 24.!he2 cxd5 25. ltlc3 occurred in Crafty - Brause, com puter game 1997, when 25 _.J.xc3 could lead to equality) 1 3.ti'e4 0..0 14.ltld5 �d8 and chances are balanced, Gutman.
9 .lg7 Alternatives: I) 9 ...aS 1 O.ltlc3 c6 l l .ltlxe5 ti'xe5 1 2.J.f4 ti'e7 13.ti'd4 ft) 14.ti'd2 ti'e6 15.&cl .ie7 1 6.ltld5 cxd5 1 7 .cxd5 ti'f5 1 8.d6 .idS 19 .g4 ti'xg4 20J::!xc5 0-0 2 l .h3 ti'h4 22. gfc 1 ib6 23 .J.g3 ti'b4 24 ..id5+ 1 :0 Bo risenko - Mukhitdinov, U SSR 1 953; II) 9 ...ltlxf3+ (Black allows his adver sary to obtain a powerful base ofaction on the kingside, Tartakower) 1 0.exf3! .ig7 1 1 .gel ltle6 12.ltlc3 0-0 ( 1 2 .. .J.xc3 is the lesser evil, Tartakower, though 1 3 .bxc3 0-0 14 ..ih6 ge8 1 5.f4 secures White good attacking prospects) 1 3 .ltld5 ti'd8 (not 1 3 ...ti'c5 14.J.e3 ti'xc4 1 5.J.fl , Tartllkower) 14 .f4 c6 (Black'sposition is already dijjicult, but it would be wiser to avoid the weakness byplaying at once 14 ...d6, Tartakower. "However the im mediate 14 ._d6 was quite risky in view .•
ofthe temporary pawn sacrifice 1 5 .5 !" Alekhine, for example 1 5 ...gx5 1 6.J.h3 c6 1 7 .J.xf5 cxd5 1 8.� h6 19.J.xh6 ti'ffi 20.J.h7+ �h8 2l .J.d2 and Black is lost, Gutman) 1 5.ltlc3 d6 16.J.e3 ti'c7 17 �1 .id7 1 8.ti'd2 &d8 1 9JW 1 .ic8 20.ltle4 ltlc5 (If 20... 5, then 2 l .ltlxd6 .hb2 22. ti'xb2 gxd6 23.gxd6 ti'xd6 24.J.xa7 and White wins a valuable pawn, Tartako wer. "Black's position was very dijjic:ult in any case, e.g. 20 ... d5 2 l .cxd5 gxd5 22.ltlf6+ winning the exchange, 20 ...c5 2 l .f5 ! gx5 22.ltlc3 ltld4 23.ltld5 ti'b8 24.J.g5 with advantage, and after the rel atively best 20 ...b6 White could increase his space advantage with 2l .b4", Alek hine) 2 1 . ltlxd6 ltla4 22.c5 ltlx b2 23.ge 1 b5 24.cxb6! ti'xd6 25 .ti'xd6 gxd6 26. bxa7 .ib7 27.J.c5 gdd8 28 ..ixfll �xfl! 29.J.xc6.hc6 30_gxc6 l::!a8 31 _gb6 gxa7 32.gbs mate, Alekhine-Tartakower, London 1 932. IO.�c:3 0-0 Black has nothing better: I) 1 O ... d6 l l .ltld5 ti'd8, Albert Becker, 12.ltlxe5 dxe5 (Burdge - Nash, Wash ington 1945, went 12 .. .J.xe5 13.J.g5 ! f6 14.ic l ) 13.J.g5 f6 14.J.e3 ltle6 15.ti'a4+ .id7 1 6.ti'b4 c6 1 7 .ltlc3 .ic8 1 8.ltle4 .ifll 1 9.c5 , Gutman; II) 10 ...h6 l l .ltld5 ti'd8 (after l l ...ti'd6 1 2.ltlxe5 .he5 1 3.f4 .ig7 14.e4 ltla6 1 5 . e5 ti'f8 1 6.ti'e2 c6 17.ltlfO+ �d8 1 8.ltle4 ti'e7 1 9.ltld6 White won in Siegmund Poetschmann, corr 1 984) 12.ltlxe5 .he5 13.J.e3 ltle6 14.ti'd2 c6 15 .ltlc3 does not look too appetizing for Black, Gutman. ll.�dS 'lt'd8 ll.�xeS .lxeS 13 .lh6!? fle8 1 4.9d:Z White has a spatial advantage and can try to exploit his control of the d5-square, Ludek Pachman. •
1 05
Sequel l (l .d4 �f6 l.c4 eS 3.dxeS �e4 4.�dl �c5 S.�gO �c6 6.g3) 6 .d6! 7.exd6 Nothing else merits attention: I) 7.b4 ltlxb4 (better than 7 ... ltle6 8.exd6 ixd6 9.b5!? ltle5 l O.J.g2, while 9.c5, Schmitz - Jensen, Copenhagen 1 998, is less clear in view of 9...i/!7 10.tg2 0-0) 8.ltlb3 (8 ..ia3 a5) 8 ... .ie6 favours Black, Gutman; II) 7 .ltlb3 dxe5 (7 ... ltlxb3 8 .axb3 dxe5 9.�xd8+ �xd8, Cardon - LanzaJli, Sas van Ghent 1 982,1 0.J.g2 .ib4+ l l .J.d2 ffi 12 .0-0 �e7 is also reasonable) 8.�xd8+ �xd8 reaching a level ending, Gutman. ..
7 ...tfxd6 There are two other plans: I) 7 ....if5 , Kurt Richter, and now: A) 8 .J.g2 �xd6 (8 ... .ixd6 see 7 ... .ixd6 8 . .ig2 .if5 - II) returns to the text; B) 8.ltlh4 .ie6 (8 .. .J.g4 9.ltlb3 1xd6 10 . .ig2 �f6 I I .J.xc6+ bxc6 1 2.�d4 't!fe6 1 3 .0 ltlxb3 14.axb3 was OK for White, Federau - Jaeger, Germany 1 990) 9.ltlb3 't!fxd6 (Schutt - Spoel, corr 1986, went 9 .. .J.xd6 lO.ltld4? ltlxd4 l l .'t!fxd4 ltlb3 12.axb3 ib4+and Black won yet 10� has more point: 10...J.xc4 l l .ltld4 or 10 ... 't!ff6 1 1 .0-0) I O.'t!fxd6 (if I O.i/!3 't!fxdl+ l l .�xdl ltla4) I O..bd6 I I .ltlxc5 .A.xc5 1 2 .J.g2 0-0-0 is fme for Black, Gutman;
C) 8.dxc7 't!fxc7 9 ..ig2 0-0-0 I 0.0-0 .ie7 l l .a3 .if6 1 2 _ga2 .ib I ( 1 2 ...�he8 1 3 .b4 ltle4 1 4..ib2, e.g. 14 ..ic3 1 5.ltlxe4 fu.dl 1 6.�xd I .ixe4 1 7 ..ixc3 f5 1 8.�ad2 or 14.. .J.xb2 15.�xb2 ltlc3 16.'t!fal ltlxe2+ 1 7.�hl ltle5 18.ltlxe5 't!fxe5 1 9.ltlf3 't!fc3 20.c5) 13.&1 .if5 with a draw, Gutman; D) 8.ltlb3 ltlxb3 9.'t!fxb3 1xd6 (9 ...'t!fxd6 I O..ig2 0-0-0 1 1 .0-0) I O.a3 ( l O.'t!fe3+, Tim Harding, is only a waste of time due to lO . . ..ie7 l l .a3 0-0 12 ..ig2 �e8 13 .0-0 .if6) 10 ...0-0 l l.i/!3 (l l ..ig2 �e8 12..ie3 't!fe7 13.0-0 .ie4 14.�acl is not bad either) l l ...ltla5 1 2.'t!fc3 ( l 2.m5 c5 13 ..ixc5? loses to 13 ....id7 14.m4 ltlc6 15.m5 ltld4, Torsten Oskarsson. Also 1 2 .�a4 c5 is enjoyable for White, e.g. 13.0-0-0 � 14.ltld2 .ie5 15.m5 ltlxc4 16.'t!fxb6 ltlxb6 1 7 ..if4, Hansson - Os carsson, corr 1950, 17 ... �fe8, or 1 3.�dl b6!? 1 4.J.f4 .id7 1 5 .'t!fc2 .ixf4 1 6.gxf4 't!fe8) 1 2 ...b6 13 ..ig2 secure an advan tage for White, Gutman. D) 7 ..bd6 8..ig2 (less precise is 8.ltlb3 't!fffi 9.i/!3 l034 10.c5 ltlxb2 l l .'t!fcl ltld3+ 1 2.exd3 't!fx13 13.�gl .ie5 14.d4 .if6 1 5 . .ig2 'Mt5 1 6.h3 0-0 17.g4 'Mt4 1 8.'t!fd2 �d8 1 9.0-0-0 .ie6 20.f4 .ixb3 2 I ..if2, Zwikker - Spoel, corr 1 993, when 21 ... 'Mt6 might be decisive) is more natural. The possibilities are presented by: A) 8 ...'t!fe7 9.ltlfl 0-0 lO.ltle3 �d8 1 1 .0-0 with 1 2 .ltld5 to follow, Frantisek Ne pustil; further B) 8 ... h5 9.ltlfl !? (White lost quickly in Jose Abril - Granados Gomez, Barce lona 1 996, after 9.h4?! .ig4 I 0.0-0 't!le7 l l .a3 a5 1 2.b3 0-0-0 1 3 ..ib2 f6 1 4..ic3 1xg3) 9 .. ..ie6 lO.ltle3 't!fd7 l l .ltld5, Gutman, similarly; C) 8 .. ..ig4, Nicolo Minev, 9.ltlb3 (9.ltlfl 't!fd7 I O.ltle3 .ih3) 9 ...�e7 I O..ie3 0-0-0 1 1 .0-0 (I I .ltlbd2 h5 1 2.'t!fc l h4 13.ltlxh4 ltld4 14.ltldf3 ixJ3 15.ltlxf3 't!fe4, Johan sen - Olsson, Carlstad 1 999, may well •
1 06
be met by 16.•;�;'(1 lt:lc2 1 7.lt:ld4 lt:lxe3+ D2) l l .lt:lbd4 lt:lxd4 1 2 .lt:lxd4 .lxc4 13. 1 8.'t¥xe3, but 1 2 .. .f6 1 3.0-0 gS is better) ll.e3, Nepustil, l 3 ... lt:le6 14.'t¥c2 .ia6 l S. l l ...hS 12.lt:lbd4 are all hardly viable for �fd l �fe8 1 6.lt:lf5,Poupinel - Campant, corr 1 998, 16 .. .ll. f8; likewise Black, Gutman; D) 8 .. Jl.e6 9 .0-0 'tYRi (9 ...'t¥e7 1 0.a3 !? DJ) 1 1Ji.e3 lt:la4 ( l l _lt:lxb3 12.axb3 laad8? aS transposes to 4.lt:ld2 lt:lcS S.lt:lgf3 lt:lc6 l3.lJ.gS, Levitt - Helman, Chicago 199S) 12.lt:lbd4 ( 12 .ll.d4 lt:lxd4 13.'tYxd4 'tYxd4 6.a3 aS 7.g3 d6 8.exd6 ll.xd6 9.ll.g2 ll.e6 1 0.0-0 't¥e7, a line regarded as awkward 14.lt:lbxd4 lt:lxb2 1S.lt:lxe6 fxe6 1 6.lt:ld4 � 17Ji.xb7 � or 12.cS lJ.xb3 l3.'t¥xb3 fCI' Black - Section S, Sequel l. However, White can play the simpler 1 0.e3 as 1 0... lt:lxcS l4.'t!lc4, John Nunn, 14...lt:le6, are hS l l .lt:ld4 gd8 12bc6+ bxc6 1 H::Jxc6 even) 12 ... lt:lxb2 1 3 .'tYc2 lt:lxc4 1 4.lt:lgS 't¥d7 14.lt:lxd8JJ.h3 lS.'tYf3 't¥xd8 16 .lt:le4 't¥g6 l S .'tYxg6 hxg6 16 .lt:lgxe6 fxe6 1 7 . lt:lxe6 lt:lxe3 1 8 .fxe3 gf6 19 ..AdS 'i!;lh7 ll.xfl 17.'i!;lxfl , Forgacs - Pusztay, Hungary 1998, or IO ....tg4 l l .'t¥c2 0.0 12.lt:ld4 20l!ab l lt:ld8 2 1 Ji.xb7 !::fu8 22.lt:lxd8 �d8 lt:lb4 13.'t¥bl i.eS 14.a3 lt:lbd3 1S.b4 lt:lxcl and Black is close to equality, Gutman; 16.gxcl lt:le6 1 7.'t¥e4 are both none too D4) l l .lt:lxcS lJ.xcS 1 2 .'t¥b3 ! ? (Absurd impressive for Black) 1 0.lt:lb3 ( I O.a3 aS is 1 2 .lJ..gS 't¥xb2 1 3 .'tYd3 't¥a3 1 4.gfd l see 4.lt:ld2 lt:lcS S.lt:lgf3 lt:lc6 6.a3 a5 7.g3 't¥a6 1S.ll.f4 ll.xc4 1 6.'t¥f5, Scherer - Gegd6 8.exd6 ll.xd6 9Ji.g2 ll.e6 1 0.0-0 'tYRi _, l 1'ner, Germany 1987, 1 6...'tYbS 17.e3 ll.b6 . Section S, Sequel 1) 1 0. . .0-0 (1 O .. h6 1 1 . If 12.'tYc2 h6 l3..tf4 �fe8; this is sounder ll.e3 (}.0..0 12.lt:lfd4 lt:lxb3 l3.lt:lxe6 lt:lxal than 12 ...lt:lb4 1 3 .'t¥b3 bS 14.'t¥c3 't¥xc3 1S.bxc3 lt:lc2 1 6,gbl ll.xc4 17.lt:leS �d8 1 4 .lt:lxd8 lt:lxd8 l S .'tYxa 1 ) seems to be more threatening. 18.lt:lxc4 lt:lxc4 19.ffi>S ll.b6 20.E!:d.S while 14.lJ.gS 't¥f5 l S.lJ..f4 lJ..xc4 16.lt:lh4 'tY e6 17.'tYc3 lt:ldS 18.lJ.xd5 'tYxd5 19,gfdl � 20.'t¥f3 'tYxf3 2 l .exf3, Camp - van der Waal, corr 1990, could have been par ried by 2l .. .i.b6 22.b3 .Ae6 23-k 1 ID'd8. Barcza - Halic, Budapest 1937, went 12. 't¥a4 .Ag4 13.lt:lgS gae8 14.lt:le4 gxe4!? lS..be4 lJ.xe2 16..tf4 't¥xb2 17..txc6 bxc6 when instead of 1 8.'t¥xc6? ixf2+ 19.lhf2 'tYxal+ 20.c;!;>gl lJ.d3 2 l .'t¥xc7 't¥d4 22't¥e5 �+ 23.'i!;lgl 't¥xc4, 18.mbl 't¥f6 19.�el ge8 20,gadl would be critical; never theless Black can do better with 1 6.. ..txfl We survey White's defences: 17� 't¥xb2) 12 ... lt:laS (12 ...i.b6 l3.lJ.gS Dl) l l .lt:lgS lJ..fS (if l l ...�d8, then not 'tYg6 14!!acl h6 1S..tf4 &d8 16.'tYa4 'tYhS, 1 2 .lt:lxcS lJ.xcS 13.'t¥c2 .Af5 14.ll.e4 lt:ld4 Carneiro - Morais, Lisbon 1 997, 1 7.b4) l S.'tYd3 �fe8 16.'i!;lg2 h6 1 7.g4 ll.xg4 0:1 l3.'tYc2 h6 14..tf4 lt:lxc4 l S.b3 gS l 6Jl.xgS Rossi - Boschetti, Ticino 199 1 , but 12. (16.id2? lt:lxd2 17.'t¥xd2 g4 18.lt:lh4 laad 8, de Lange - Spoel, corr 1 99 1 ) 16 ...hxgS lt:lxe6 lt:lxe6 1 3 .ll.xc6 !? bxc6 14.'t¥c2 cS 17.bxc4 &!:8 1 8 .&dl c6 19.'tYcl g4 20. 1 S JI.e3) 12.lt:lxcS lJ.xcS 1 3.lt:le4 ll.xe4!? lt:ld2 .Af5 2 l .lt:lb3 keeps a clear plus for 14be4 &118 l S.'tYc2 lt:ld4 16.'t¥d3 gfe8 White, Gutman . with a balanced position, Gutman; 107
E) 8 .. .i.f5 9.0-0 is a traditional way to treat this position.
Black has three options: El) 9 ... 0-0 I O.llJb3 (in case of I O.llJel "t!/ft) I I.liJb3 llJa4!? 12.llJd3 &d8 13 .llJa5 Black has a good answer in 1 3 ...llJc3 ! ? 14 .bxc3 llJxa5 1 5 ."t!/a4 b 6 1 6.c5 ie7 17. cxb6 cxb6 18 ..ie3 "t!/xc3 1 9 .l:�acl "t!/a3 20."t!/xa3ixa3 2 Uk7 gd7, while 1 3 ... llJxa5 1 4 ."t!/a4 b6 1 5 .c5ie7, Mathot Defosse, corr 1 936/37, 1 6.cxb6!? cxb6 17 ..id2 is a bit better for White) IO ... ge8 ( I O ...llJxb3 I I ."t!/xb3 "t!/d7 1 2.gd1 "t!/e6, Treasurer - Will, Glasgow l 995, seems dubious due to 13 "t!/xb7 "t!/xc4 14.i.e3) I I .ie3(1ess flexible is I I .llJfd4 llJxb3 1 2 .axb3 llJxd4 1 3 ."t!/xd4 gxe2 14..ixb7, Jones - Edwards, England NWC 1987, due to I I ...llJxd4 12."t!/xd4 "t!l e7 13.llJxc5 .ixc5 14 "t!/d5 ig4 I5.j,g5 "t!/f& 1 6.e3 c6) I I ...llJxb3(I I ..."t!/e7? 12 .i.xc5 ixc5 13. "t!/d5) 1 2 ."t!/xb3 ie4 1 3 .c5 ie7 1 4 .llJe5 llJxe5 (14..bg2 fails to 1 5 Mdl) 15 be4, Gutman; further E2) 9 ..."t!/e7 IO.llJb3 (I O.llJh4 ig4 I I ..if3 .ih3 1 2.ge 1 0-0, Minev, improving on I I ....ixf3 1 2 .llJdxf3 "t!/e6 13 ."t!/d5 0-0-0 14."t!/xe6+ fxe6 15� llJe4 1 6.llJg5 llJxg5 17 bg5, Koomen - de Jong, Amsterdam 1 937) 1 0 ...0-0-0 (IO...gd8 I I .llJxc5 .ixc5 12."t!/a4 goes into 5.llJgf3 d6 6.exd6 .ixd6 7.g3 "t!/e7 8.llJb3 .if'S 9.llJxc5 .ixc5 IO.i.g2
llJc6 1 1 .0-0 gd8 1 2."t!/a4, see Section 2. 10 ... 0-0 I I.llJxc5 .ixc5 reaches a position after 5.llJgf3 d6 6.exd6 .ixd6 7.g3 "t!/e7 8.llJb3 if5 9.llJxc5 ixc5 I O ..ig2 llJc6 1 1 .0-0 0-0 - Section 2, yet White has an extra resource in the form of I I .ie3 goo8 1 2.llJfd4 llJxd4 1 3 .llJxd4 ie4 1 4 .i.xe4 "t!/xe4 1 5 ."t!lb l "t!/e5 1 6."t!/c2) I I .i.e3 h5 (l l . .b4 1 2.llJxc5 .ixc5 1 3..Axc5 "t!/xc5 14."t!lb3 llJa5? 1 5 ."t!/c3 f6 1 6 .gac l llJc6 17 .gcdl .ix f3 18 .i.xf3 llJd4 1 9 .ig4+ fS 20.e3 llJe6 2 1 .b4 , Gasiorowski - Ilczuk, Lubniwiece 1995) 1 2 .llJfd4 (sharper than 12.llJxc5 .ixc5 13bc5 "t!/xc5 14."t!lb3 f6 1 5.a3 ghe8 1 6 .gfel g5 17 ."t!/c3 "t!/e7 18.b4 h4 1 9.b5 llJe5) 1 2 . . .i.e4 1 3 .llJxc6 .ixc6 14bc6 (14.ih3+'i!>b8 1 5.llJd4 io4 16.b4 h4 17.g4 llJe6 1 8.llJfS ixfS 1 9.gxf5 .ixh2+ 20.'i!>xhl �dl favoured Black in Cosma - Stefanova, Niksic 1992) 14 ...bxc6 1 5.llJxc5 .ixc5 I 6.j,xc5 "t!/xc5 17."t!/a4 and White is on top, Gutman; EJ) 9 ... "t!/f6 is a most popular choice.
Play might continue: Ela) I O.a3 0-0 (I 0 ... 0-0-0?! 1 1 .&2 h5 12.h4 "t!!g6 13.b4 llJe6 1 4.'i!>hl f6 1 5.c5 .ie5 1 6.llJxe5 llJxe5 1 7."t!/a4, Hrubant Chapu, Prague 1 996) I I .llJb3 gfe8 ( I I ... llJe6, Galje - van der Vecht, Haarlem 2000, 12.llJfd2) 1 2.llJbd4 ( 12.llJxc5 .ixc5 13."t!/d5 .ib6 I4.j,g5 "t!/g6) ILllJxd4 13. llJxd4 .ie4, Gutman;
108
E3b) I O.l0b l l0e5 ( 1 0 ... 0-0-0 l l .l0c3 hg3 12.l0d5 .bh2+ 1 3.� 't!ld6+ did not provide Black any real attack, 14M4 't!lg6 1 5JThl mte8 16..ixc7 .ic2 1 7.'t!ld2 l:!d7 1 8..ig3 .if5 1 9.l0h4 't!le6 20.l0xf5 't!lxf5 2l .'t!ff4, Wijdeveld - Boers, Hol land 1 940) l l .lLic3 lLixO+ 12 ..ixn (if 12 .exn 0-0-0 1 3 .l0d5 't!lg6 14.'t!ld4 mte8 1 5.l0f4 't!ih6) 1 2 ... 0-0 ( 1 2 ... c6 1 3 ..ig5) 1 3 .l0d5 't!le6 14..ie3 �adS, Gutman; E3c) I O.l0b3!? l0e6 (I O ...h6 can be met by l l ..ie3 0-0-0 12.l0fd2) l l .l0h4 (On l l ..id2 Black should grab the pawn with l l ...'t!lxb2; however, note that after I I ... 0-0-0 1 2.l0h4!? is even stronger, while there is no real problems in 12 ..ic3 't!lb6 13.'t!lcl 't!lb5 14.�el ih3 15J.hl 't!lg4 16. l0bd2 �he8, Dlouhy - Chapu, Prague 1996. l l ..ie3 is best answered by I I ... 0-0-0 1 2 .'t!lcl h 6 t3ru t io4; this keeps more tension than l l ... �d8 12.'t!lcl 0-0 1 3 .�d l .ie7 14.'t!lc3 't!lg6 1 5 .l0bd4 .if6 t 6.l0xc6 bxc6 1 7 .l0e5 't!th5 1 8 -.iO as in Vallin-Hoffinann, Bischwille 1 998) 1 1 ..�4 (t t ..rus 12.l0xf5 't!lxf5 13 .'t!id5 't!if6 14.'t!lh5 ().() 1 5.ixc6 bxc6 1 6.'t!lxc6 .ie5 17 .�bl h5 1 8 .'t!!O 't!lg6 19..ie3 h4 20.l0c5 left White two pawns ahead in Havasi - Defosse, Stockholm Olympiad 1937) 1 2 .h3 ( 1 2.ixc6+ bxc6 13.0 .ih3 14.l0g2 h5 1 5 .'t!tc2 h4 1 6.c5 .ie5 1 7.f4 hxg3 18.hxg3 hg2 19.�g2't!lb6 20.fxe5 't!ih2+ 2 1 .<M3 mt3 saw Black triumph in Rossi - Lanzan i, Bratto 1 994) 12 ... 1h 5 1 3 .'t!td5 g5 (13 .. .ig6? 1 4 .'t!tb5 0-0 1 5 .l0xg6 't!lxg6 1 6.'t!lxb7 l0cd4 1 7.e3) 14.'t!lh5 gxh4 15.'t!txb7 0-0 16.'t!lxc6 .be2 17 _gel 1d3 18.�e3 ( 1 8.gxh4 't!lxh4) 1 8 ... hxg3 19.hxg3 ic2 20.c5 ie5 21 .'t!id5 �8 (2l .. .ixb2 22.ixb2 't!lxb2 23.'t!ld2 �d8 24.'t!it2) 22.'t!txe5 !:kit+ 23.c;tb2 't!lt2 24.h4 .if5 25.g4 .ixg4 26.id2 �xal 27.lOxal 't!lxd2 28�3 h5 29.'t!ixh5 f5 30.'t!lg6+ lOg? 3 1 .b4 l"ie8 32l0b3 't!lt2 with enough play in each case, Gutman.
F) 8 ... 0-0 ! ? 9.0-0 is more tempting:
Fl) 9 ...'t!fffi IO.l0b3 (lO.�bl ?! a5 l l .lLiel �e8 12.e4 't!lg6 1 3 .b3 f5 14..ia3 fxe4 1 5 . .hc5 .bc5 16.ltlxe4 �e4 17.'t!id5+ �. Comas - Vega, Antwerp 1992) IO...ltlxb3 (IO . . ..ie6 transposes to 8 ..ie6 9.0-0 't!fffi IO.ltlb3 0-0 - D) l l.'t!lxb3 .ic5 12..id2 .if5 13.ic3 't!le7 14.e4he4 1 5�1 f5 1 6.ltld2 ltld4 17.ixd4hd4 1 8.ltlxe4 fxe4 1 9�e4 't!lc5 20.'t!lc2 &e8 2 1 .b4 't!lf5 22.�xe8 I :0 Pokorny - Weil, Munich Olympiad 1936; Fl) 9 ....ie6 10.b3 (I O.ltlb3 't!ff6 see F1) IO ...'t!ff6 l l ..ia3 ( l l .�b l .if5 12 ..ib2, Becker - Manthey, Germany 1 995, 12 ... 't!lh6) l l . . .'t!lh6 ( l l .. .a5 12 ..ixc5 .ixc5 1 3 .ltle4) 12.b4 ltld7 13.b5 .ixa3 14.bxc6 bxc6 1 5 .'t!ta4 favours White, Gutman; F3) 9..Ee8! IO.ltlb3 (IO.ltlbl ltle4 l l .ltlfd2 ltlxd2 1 2.ixd2 .ig4) IO ... ltlxb3 (lO...'t!fffi l l ..ie3 ltla4 12.ltlbd4, Nepustil) l l .'t!lxb3 .ic5 (both I I .Ae6, Casas - Benko, Mer cedes 1 975, 12.'t!txb7 ltla5 13.'t!le4 .ixc4 14.'t!lf5 c6 15.id2, and l l ..�e2 12.l0g5 �e7 13.'t!lc2 g6 1 4.l0e4 �e8 15 .ig5 .ie7 1 6.�dl l0d4 17 ..ixe7.�xe7 1 8.'t!ld3 �d7 19.l0c5 are worse) 1 2 ..ig5 f6 1 3 .�adl 't!le7 14.if4 (1 4..id2 a5 1 5 .�fe I a4) 14 ... a5!? (14 ...g5 15.J.e3 .be3 16.'t!lxe3 't!lxe3 17.fxe3 �g7 1 8.�f2 a5 19.b3 a4 20.l0d4 l0e5 2 1 .h3 c6 22.l00 \12-\12 Esposito Flores, Mar dei Piata Zonal l95 1 ) J5 _gfel a4 1ooks fully adequate to me, Gutman.
1 09
•
•
Back to the main line
8..lgl 8 .'t!lc2 l0b4 9.'t!lbl 't!ff6 (JoanSegura mentions 9 ...g6? IO.a3 i5 l l .axb4 ixbl 1 2 .bxc5 't!txc5 1 3 .Hxb l .tg7 1 4.b4 't!ff5 1 5 .e4 't!le6 1 6..tb2 hb2 17.fub2) IO.e4 ( I O.a3 .tf5) 1 O .. ..ig4 and Black holds the initiative, Gutman. s ....lrs 8...J.e6 9.(}.0 (9.l0g5 ().()..() IO.l0xe6 't!lxe6 1 1 .0-0 h5) 9 ... 0-0-0 IO.b4 l0xb4 l l ..ia3 't!lb6 (l l ...l0c6 12..m,t 't!ld7 13..ixc5 ixc5 14.'t!la4!?) 1 2.Hb l ltle4 1 3 ..txb4 .txb4 1 4 .'t!la4 l0 xd2 1 5 .Hxb4 't!la6 16.l0xd2 't!lxa4 1 7..ixb7+ <;t>b8 1 8.fua4 <;t>xb7 19. l0b3 with advantage for White, Segura. 9.0-0 Alternatives: I) 9.a3 't!ff6 (for 9 ... a5 see 5.l0g0 l0c6 6.a3 a5 7.g3 d6 8.exd6 't!lxd6 9..ig2 .i.f5 Section 5, Sequel I ) 1 0 .0-0 0-0-0 goes into the main line; II) 9.l0h4 .te6 1 O..txc6+ 't!lxc6 1 1 .0-0 0-0-0 ( l l ....ie7 12 .ltlhf3 .tf6 1 3 .'t!lc2 g6 14.Hel 0-0 15.e4 Had8 16.Hb l a5 1 7.b3 l0d3 1 8.He3 l0 b4 1 9.'t!ldl l0xa2 is also good, Har1mann - Hoo1rnann., corr 1 995) 12.'t!lc2 .th3 13l!el .te7 (13_g5!? 14.l0hf3 g4 1 5.'t!tf5+ <;t>b8 16.b4ig7 17..m,) l(}e6 18. b5 't!le8 19..m,3 h5 20l!d3 Y2-Y2 Schmidt Kampfhenkel, corr 1979, but Black can play on with 20 .. . gxf3 2 1 .'t!lxh3 l0d4!?)
14.l0df3 (1 4.l0hf3 .tf6 1 5 .Hb l l0e6 1 6. e4 h5 17.b4 h4) 14 .. .ixh4 15.l0xh4 l0e6 16 ..te3 l0d4 ( 1 6 ... f5? 1 7.f3 HhfB 1 8 . b4 l0d4 19 .'t!lc3 g5 20..ixg5 I : 0 d e Lange van der Weyer, corr 1989) 17 .'t!lc3 l0f5 1 8.l0f3 Hhe8 1 9.Hedl Hxd l + 20.Hxdl l0xe3 2 1 .fxe3 f6 seems equal, Gutman. 9... 0-0-0 9....ie7!? is probably not weaker, we see : I) I O.a3 .tffi I I .Ha2 (}.0-0 1 2.b4 l0e4 and White is overwhebned, Gutman; II) I O.e4 .tg4 ( 1 0 ... l0xe4 l l .l0h4 hh4 12.l0xe4 't!lxdl 1 3 .Hxdl gives White an edge) l l .l0b3 ( l l .h3 .te6 1 2 .a3 0-0-0 1 3 .'t!lc2 l0d4) l l ...'t!lxdl 1 2 .Hxdl l0xb3 1 3 .axb3 l0e5 14.l0xe5 .i.xdl 1 5 ..th6 .tffi (15 .. ..ixb3 16..ixg7 Hg8 17 .J.h6 a5 looks worth trying) 1 6 .l0d7 <;t>xd7 17.Hxdl + <;t>e7 1 8..if4 :!:llid8 19.Hel .i.xb2 20..ixc7 Hd7 2 1 .J.a5 <;t>tB 22.e5 He8 23..ib4+ <;t>g8 24.f4 Hd3 25 ..txb7 .td4+ 26.<;t>g2 fub3 27 ..tc6 Hb2+ 28.<;t>f3 Hc8! (instead of 28 _goo 29.id6 f5? 30.&2 fue2 3 I .<;t>xe2 Hh6 32..id5+ <;t>h8 33.h4 a5 34.e6 .tf6 35.c5 .td8 36.c6 Hf6 3 7 .e7 1 :0 Reti Richter, Munich 1 94 1 ) 29.e6 (29 ..td7 Hxc4 30 ..td6 .tc5) 29 .. .f5 30 .g4 Hf2+ 3 l .<;t>g3 Hc2 32.Hdl Hxc4 33 ..td7 Hb8 leaves White in trouble, Gutman; III) IO.ltlbl 't!le6 (not 10 ...0-0-0? l l .'t!lxd6 fud6 1 2.l0c3 h5 1 3 .l0d5, Najdorf- Ros setto, Buenos Aires 1 94 1 ) l l .ltld4 (on l l .'t!td5 Black plays I I ...Hd8 1 2 .'t!lxe6 ixe6 13.l0bd2 .tffi 14.Hbl a5 1 5 .b3 .tc3 1 6..ia3 l0b4) l l ...l0xd4 1 2.'t!ixd4 0-0 1 3 . l0c3 c6 1 4 ..tf4 Hfe8 15 .Had l l0a6 with active play for the pawn, Gutman. lO.aJ Practice has seen three more moves: I) I O.l0g5 't!tffi l l ..ixc6 bxc6 1 2.l0gf3 g5 13 .e4 .th3 1 4.e5 't!lt5 1 5.He l l0d3 and Black won, Hildago - Hohns, corr 1990; U) I O.b4 l0xb4 ( I O ... 't!ff6 l l ..ta3 't!lc3 12.'t!lcl 't!lxcl 13llfxcl �6 14�2 �b4 1 5.a3 ltla6 1 6.ltlb3 ffi 1 7.ltlfd4 l0xd4 1 8.
1 10
_
.ixd4 with equal chances; however, note that l l .bxc5 't!/xal l2 .'t!/a4, Minev, 1 2 ... 't!ff6 l 3.l0b3 h6 can only benefit Black) l l ..ib2 't!lb6 ( l l ...l0c6!? l 2 .l0b3 't!/xdl l 3 �fxdl �dl+ l4.�dl l0xb3 l5.axb3 f6) l 2.l0d4 .ih3 l 3..ixh3+ 't!/xh3 l4.a3 l0ba6 1 5 .'t!/c2 h5 1 6.1020 f6 I U�ad l .id6 l 8.l0f5 l0e6 l 9.l:�d5 .ic5 (instead of 19 ... l0ac5? 20.lUd l 't!l g4 2 1 .g ld4 l0xd4 22.gxd4 l0e4 23.'t!/xe4 't!/xe4 24.gxe4, Gereben - Moehring, Hungary - Hol land, Budapest 1 947) 20 .. gfdl 't!/g4 is OK fer Black, Gutman; ID) IO.b3 is a solid continuation which can be met in four ways: A) IO ....ie7 l l ..ia3 g5 ( l l ...9h6 l2.'t!/cl a5 l 3 ..ixc5 .ixc5 l 4.a3, e.g. l4 ... ghe8 l 5 .e3 with b3-b4 to follow or l 4. . . l0d4 l 5 .l0xd4 hd4 1 6.&2) l 2.b4 l0e6 1 3 .c5 't!/d7 l4.b5 (Most theoretical works state that l4.'t!/a4 'it?b8 l5.b5 l0cd4 l6.l0e5 is decisive, e.g. l 6... l0xe2+ l 7.'it?hl 't!/xd2 l 8.l0c6+ bxc6 1 9.b6 or l 6...'t!/e8 l 71tacl l0xe2+ l 8.�h l , when both l 8 ... l0 6d4 l9..ixb7 c;!nc.b7 20.'t!/a6+ 'it?a8 2 l .b6 cxb6 22.cxb6 l:ld7 23.l0xd7't!/xd724J:k7 't!/d5+ 25.f3 l0b5 26..ixe7 g4 27�6 l :0 Faure Meyer, corr l96 l , and l 8 ... l0xcl l9..ic6 't!/f8 20.hb7 l0d4 2 l .b6 cxb6 22.cxb6 axb6 23.'t!/a8+ rt1c7 24fucl + .ic5 25.'t!/a6 ltx:2 26.te4 are losing. Nevertheless, we can improve with l 6...'t!/xb5, e.g. l7.l0c6+ bxc6 l 8,gfb l hbl l 9.�bl l0xe2+ 20. �hl 't!/xb l+ 2 l .l0xbl l02d4 22.'t!/c4 g4 or l7.'t!/xb5 l0xb5 l 8..ib4 .b.c5 l 9..ixc5 �d2 20.l0xf7 ge8) l4 ... l0b8 l 5 .c6 bxc6 l 6.bxc6 l0xc6 17 .'t!/a4 l0b8 l 8.'t!/xa7 and White wins, Gutman; B) 10 't!/ffi l l ..ia3 l0e4 l2.l0xe4!? (this is more consistent than l 2 . .b.f8 ghxf8, given by Minev, l 3.10xe4 .ixe4 l4.'t!/cl gfe8) l2 ....ixe4 (12 ..fudl l3.10xffi �al l4fual .ixa3 l 5.l0h4) l3.'t!/c l .ha3 14. 't!/xa3 g5 l 5 .&d l with good prospects for White, Gutman;
C) IO ...l0e4 l l .l0h4 l0xd2 l2..ixd2 .ig4 l3..ic3 (l3..if3 .ih3 l4..if4 't!ff6 l 5 .'t!/cl .ie7 l 6.l0g2 g5 is Faures analysis but l4 ...'t!/e7!? l 5 .'t!/c l .ixfl l 6.'it?xfl l0d4 looks more logical) l3 ...'t!/e6 ( l3 ...'t!/xdl l4�fxdl �dl+ 1 5fudl .ixe2? l6..ih3+ 'itb8 17..§el) l4..idS 't!/xe2 15.'t!/xe2 he2 l 6.gfe l .ih5 17 ..ixc6 bxc6 1 8 �e5 .ig6 19 .l0xg6 hxg6 20.gae I gives White the better endgame, Max Euwe; D) IO ...h5! l l .a3 ( l l ..ia3 't!lb6 l 2.'t!/cl h4 l 3.gxh4 l0e6 l4.e3 �d2 l5 .l0xd2 't!/xh4 l 6.l0f3 't!/h5 1 7 .h4 .ie4 1 8.l0el 't!/xh4 l 9.f3 l0cd4 20.exd4 .b.a3 2 l .'t!le3 .ic6 22.f4 l0xd4 0: I Sanchez - Starke, corr 1998) l l ...h4 l 2.b4 (l2.l0xh4 .ig4) 12 ... hxg3 13 .hxg3 l0e4 14.'t!lb3 't!/g6 1 5 .10xe4 .b.e4 l6..ie3 .id6 l 7.b5 l0e5 and Black dominates, Gutman.
•.
Ill
10 15'f6 Less challenging are: I) IO ...a5 l l .b4 goes into 5.l0gf3 l0c6 6.a3 a5 7.g3 d6 8 .exd6 't!/xd6 9..ig2 .if5 1 0.0-0 0-0-0 l l .b4, treated in Section 5, Sequel I ; II) IO .. ..ie7 l l .b4 l0e4 l 2 .'t!lb3, when: A) l2 ...l0c3 l3,gel l0d4 l 4.'t!/xc3 ! (Saj tar - Moehring, Czechoslovakia -Hol land 1 949, went l4.l0xd4 't!/xd4 l 5 ..ib2 't!/xd2 l6 ..ixc3 't!lh6 l 7 .'t!/a4 a6 l 8 .b5) l4 ....if6 (if l4 ...l0c2 l 5 ..ih3 !) l 5 .l0xd4 hd4 1 6.'t!/f3, Gutman ; ••.
B) 12 ...�xd2 13 .i.xd2 .te4 14.ic3 .tf6 l Htad l 't!/e6 16 .b5 .hf3 17.ixf3 �d4 1 8.i.xd4 �d4 1 9fud4 hd4 20�1 �8 2 l ..td5, Maas - Richter, Berlin 1 950; C) 12 ....tf6 13 .�xe4 .txe4 14 .if4 't!/e7 15J:Iad l , Simonovic - Scherbakov, Par is 1 953; D) 12 .. h5 13.�e4 he4 14..tb2 (14..te3 h4 15 J:ladl 't!/g6 16Jhd8+ hd8 1 7 .b5 .txn 18.exf3 �e5 19.'t!/a4 hxg3 20.fxg3 't!/d3 2l .'t!/xa7 �xc4 22..if2 �d2 23.'t!/a8+ �d7, Scheltinga - van Geet, Amsterdam 1977, 24Jidl ! ?) 14 ...h4 15.c5 't!lb6 16. �Ud l hxg3 17.hxg3 ID\7 18fud8+ �xd8 1 9.'t!/a4 f5 20�1 c6 2 l .'t!/xa7, Ceteras Reindennan, Sas van Ghent 1 992, are all better for White, Gutman.
l l.Ral Others: I) l l .�h4 .te6 ( l l ....te4? 12.�xe4 �xe4 l3 .'t!/c2 �g5 14.hg5 't!/xg5 15J:Ifd 1 left Black lost, Elliot - Le Clair, e-mail l996. However, I I ....tg4!? 12.&2 't!/e6 1 3 � .tx n 14.�hxf3 �e4 1 5 Jiel h 5 16.'t!/c2 �d2 17 .ixd2 h4 18 ..tf4 .te7 19.b4 ID\5 20.b5 �d4 2 l .'t!tc3 .tf6 22.�xd4 hd4 23.'t!/f3 hxg3 24.hg3 �k5 appears more logical, Gambit Tiger - Fritz 6, comput er game 2001) 12 ..txc6 bxc6 l3.'t!tc2 g5 1 4.�g2 ( 1 4.b4 gxh4 1 5.ib2 't!th6 offers Black good chances, e.g. 16.i.xh8 �d2 17.'t!lb l hxg3 18 .hxg3 't!/h3 1 9.bxc5 .tf5
20. e4 .txc5 2 l ..te5 .tg4 22.'t!tb3 't!/h5 23..tf4 .tn or 16.�f3 gg8 17 J:ladl hxg3 1 8.hxg3 �d7 19 .'t!/a4 .txc4!? 20.gxd7 �d7 2 l .'t!/xa7 �8 22.�d4 �8 23.'t!/b8+ gd8 24.'t!/xc7 't!/d6 25 .'t!/xc6+ 't!/xc6 26. �xc6 .txe2 21.ge 1 �1 0:1 List - Rich ter, Swinemuende 1932) l4_,.tf5 (After 14 .. ..tg7 White has a choice. Pracejus Koronowski, corr 1989, saw 15J:Ia2 't!/g6 16.b4 't!/xc2 17 fuc2 .tf5, when instead of 18.e4 �xe4 1 9.�xe4 .txe4, 1 8 Jta2 �4 19.�b3 �3 20J:Ib2 h6 2 l .�a5 might be tried; however, Black can do better with l5 _.i.fS 16.e4 .th3 17.0 't!/d4+ 18.�hl g4. I prefer 15.�e3! .th3 l6,gel h5 and now not 17 .�e4 �xe4 1 8.'t!/xe4 gd4 19.'t!/f3 't!/e6 20.gbl h4 2 1 .b4 hxg3 22.hxg3 � 23.�fl .tg4 24.'t!/g2 gxe2, Sonntag Prevot, Bourbon-Laney 1998,but 17llbl h4 18.g4 ghe8 19 .�f3) 1 5 .e4 .th3 1 6.f3 ( 1 6.b4 �3 17J:Ia2 ig7 1 8.'t!/a4 �b8 19. &2 g4 20.b5 c5) 16 ...'t!/d4+ 17.�hl g4!? 18.fxg4 .txg4 with initiative, Gutman; m l l .'t!/el ge8 ( l l . ...td6 l2.ga2 ghe8 13.'t!/dl 't!/e7 14.b4 �e4 l 5 .�xe4 .txe4 16.'t!/a4 �b8 17..te3 and White won in Scholtz - Kratochwil, German Bundes liga 1 998/99. l l . ...tc2 1 2 .ga2 also fa vours White, e.g. 12...�b3 l3.�xb3 hb3 14.ih3+ �b8 1 5..tg5 't!/g6 16.�1 ffi 17. 't!/c3 or 12 ... &8 1 3.b4 �d3 14..th3+ �8 15.�e4 �xel 16.�xffi �xf3+ 17 .exf3 ge2 18.�e4 .td3 19fue2 he2 20..ge 1 �d4 2 l .�g5 �xf3+ 22.�xf3 .txf3 23,ge3) 12.'t!tdl gd8 is a repetition, Gutman. ll .. ..Abl l l ..� 12.�xe4 ( 12't!lb3?! ie7 13.�e4 .be4 14.ig5 't!/e6 1 5 .he7 't!/xe7 16.&81 �4 17.�xd4 hg2 18.�g2 �d4, Ha restad - Simonsen, Gausdal 2003) 12 ... .be4 13.'t!/a4 ie7 (13 ...h6 14.b4 't!/e6 15.b5, Ribas - Melchor, corr 1 994) 14.b4 't!/c3 15.b5 �a5 1 6..tf4 and Black is lost. ll.!at .tfs A draw is quite difficult to avoid. .
1 12
Section 7 (l.d4 �f6 :Z.c4 e5 3.dxe5 �e4 4.�d2 � cS) 5.b4!? �e6 6.a3
"The attack must lose no time, the defence no space", Emanuel Lasker. 6 b6 Alternatives: I) 6 .. J.e7 7 .i.b2 0-0 8.lt:\gf3 aS 9..lc3 ! ? axb4 I O.axb4 fbal I I .tyxal b 6 1 2 .e3 f:!e8 ( 12 ...lt:\a6 1 3.tyb2 f:!e8 14ie2 .lb7 1 5.0-0 tyaS 16.& 1 , Gref- Brause, com puter game 1997) 1 3 ..le2 !? .lb7 14.0-0 lt:\c6 15.�2 tyaS 1 6.&1 tycS 17.td3 h6 1 8 ..le4 with advantage, Gref- Brause, computer game 1 997; m6.. .d6 7.exd6 .ixd6 8.lt:\e4J.e5 9.tyxd8+ ft»ld8 10.&2 .15 l l .lt:lf.3 lt:lbc6 1 2.lt:\xe5 lt:\xeS 13.lt:ld2 lt:ldc6 14.e4 .ie6 1 5.f4 lt:\g4 16.lt:\f.3 0-0-0 1 7 .ru2 f:!de8 1 8 ..id3 lt:le3 19.c5 ft) ( 19 ..J.c4 20.e5 ffi? 2 l ..bc4 lt:\xc4 22.f:!c2 is mentioned by Stefan Buecker, Kaissiber I 61200/) 20.f:!e2 lt:\g4 2 l .h3 lt:\h6 22.';f;lf2 f:!d8 231id2 gave Black no compensation for the pawn, Hemnann Fajarowicz, Frankfurt 1 930; ID) 6...lt:\c6 7.lt:\gf.3 d6 8.exd6 .ixd6 (8... tyxd6 9J.b2 tye7 IO.e3 lt:lf4 l l .tyc2 .lg4 1 2 .0-0-0 lt:\g6 1 3 .h3 .le6 14.lt:lb3 b6 1 5 . lt:\bd4, Jacobsen - H eldarskard, Faroe 1 999) 9./.0e4 (also 9.i.b2 0-0 IO.e3 is not .••
easy to meet: I 0... tye7 l l .cS .if4, Josef Sjohan, internet 2002, 12.i.d3 .ih6 1 3 . tyc2 g 6 14.0-0, while I O. . .aS l l .b5 lt:lb8 1 2 .lt:\ e4 .le7 gives White a choice be tween 1 J .tyc2 fS 1 4.lt:\c3 .id6 1 5 ..le2 lt:\d7 1 6.0-0 lt:\gS 17.lt:\xg5 tyxgS 1 8 .f4 �6 19.lt:\a4 lt:\c5 20..id4 lt:\e6 2 l ..ib2 lt:\c5 22.lt:\xc5 hcS 23Jd4, Solozhenkin van de Fliert, Berga 199 3, and I J.ty xd8 f:!xd8 14J.e2 5 1 5 .lt:\c3 .if6 1 6.0-0 lt:lcS 1 7.goo I) 9 .. J.e7 (9 ...0-0 I O.lt:\xd6 cxd6 l l .e3 tye7 12ie2 lt:\c7 13.h3 .le6 14.0-0 f:!ad8 I SJ.b2 d5 1 6.c5, Back - Markus, corr 1 995) I O.tyxd8+ .lxd8 l l ..ib2 b6 12.e3 .lb7 1 3.lt:\c3 .i16 14.0.0.0 ().() I S.lt:\dS is in White's favour, Wabschke - Lenz, Germany 1995; IV) 6...c5 7.b5 d 6 8.exd6 tyaS (8 ...lt:\d7 9.lt:\e4 lt:\f6 IO.ft»lffi+ tyxf6 1 1 .�2 tyc3+ 121id2 .ixd6 13.i.b2 tya5 14.e3) 9..lb2 .lxd6 I O.e3 0-0 was recommended by Buecker, Kaissiber 161200/, but l l .tyc2 f:!d8 12.td3 lt:lt8 1 3 .lt:\gf.3 keeps an edge for White, Gutman ; V) 6 ...a57.b5 , when: A) 7 ...d6 8.exd6 .lxd6 is a typical reply.
We examine: AI) 9.lt:\gf.3 lt:lcS (9 ... 0-0 is met by the annoying l O.lt:\e4 ! ? .le7 ( l .tyxd8 f:!xd8 12J.b2 b6 13.e3 .ib7 14.lt:\c3 lt:\c5 15ie2. More appealing is 9 ..,tyf6 1 0.&2 lt:\c5 l l .e4 tyg6!?, while O'Connor - Gibson, 1 13
Dublin 1 994, proceeded l l ...�bd7 1 2 . .le2 �eS 1 3 .�xeS .lxeS 1 4 .0-0, when instead of 14 .. ..le6 I S.\!Mc2 0-0-0 1 6.a4 mte8 17.�f3 h6 18..le3, 14 ...0-0 I S.\!Mc2 ges could have been tried) I O.e3 ( I O.g3 \!Me7) I 0 ...0-0 1 1 .1b2 \!Me7 (if l l ....ifS 1 2 .�b3 �a4 13 .1xg7! �xg7 14.�d4) 12 ..le2 1f5 13.0-0 �bd7 14 .�b3 gfd8 (14 .. .a4 I S.�xcS �xeS is not bad either, e.g. 1 6.\!MdS .le4 17.\!MhS .ig6 18.ti'h4 ffi, Ruckschloss - Vlasin, Czech Republic 1992) IS.�xcS �xeS 16.Jd4 �7 1 7lla2 gadS with a balanced position, Gutman; Al) 9. .ib2 �d7 (9 ...0-0 I O.�e4 \!Me7 I I . �xd6 gds 12.\!Mc2 �d6 13.e3 �d7 is no better, for instance 14.�f3 �ecS IS..ie2 �f6 1 6.0:0 or 14..ld3 h6 I S .E!dl �ecS 16.�f3 �ffi 17..le2, Sanders - Storgaard, e-mail l 998) I O.�gf3 �deS (if 1 0 ...0-0 l l .g3) l l .e3 ( l l .g3 !? \!Me7 12..lg2) I I ... 0-0 (Black is OK: the e6-knight har the c5 square while the other comes to f6 or e5, Otto Borik) 1 2..le2 b6 ( 1 2... f5 1 3 .0-0 �e4 is innocuous due to 14.�xe4 fxe4 I S.�d2 �cS 16.�xe4) 13.0-0 .lb7 goes back into the main line, Gutman; AJ) 9.�e41e7 (9.. ..teS I O.\!Mxd8+ �xd8 l l .gu .if'S, AnatoU MIIISukevich, is met by 1 2.�f3! �d7 13.�xeS �xeS 14.�d2. 9 ... 0-0 IO .�xd6 is even worse, we see 10 ...\!Mxd6 1 1 .\!Mxd6 cxd6, Wittal - Blankenberg, corr 200 1 , 1 2..le3 �d7 13.�f3 �deS 14.gdl or IO ...cxd6 1 1 .e3 \!Me7 1 2. .lb2 �d7 1 3 .�e2 !? �ecS 1 4.�f4 �f6 I S ..le2 &8 1 6.0-0 .if5 17.\!Md4 �b3 1 8. �dS �xd4 19.�xe7+, Blitzmich - Peze, internet 2002) IO .\!Mxd8+ .lxd8 l l ..ib2 b6 1 2 .�f3 .lb7 1 3 .�c3 .itO 14.e3 �d7 I S ..ie2 clearly favours White, Gutman. B) 7 ...b6 (a modem way to play given by Borik) 8.�gf3 (in case of 8.�df3 .lb7 9.�h3 is 9._g6 IO.�f4.lg7 1 1 .�xe6 dxe6 1 2.\!Mxd8+ �xd8 13 ..lb2 �d7 14.0-0-0 �e7 IS.�e I mtd8 16.�d3 c6 the correct answer, while Hubert - Voekler, Ger-
many 1 990, went 9 ... d6 I O.�f4 �xf4 l l .i.xf4 1xf3 12.gxf3 �d7 13..th3 �xeS 14.\!MdS .le7 I S ..ixeS dxeS 16.\!Mc6+ �f8 17 ,gdl .ld6 1 8.cS!? bxcS 19.b6 \!Me8 20. .id7 ti'h8 2 1 .b7) 8 ...1b7 9.e3 transposing into the main line, Gutman. 7.�gt3 J.b7
8.e3 Other possibilities: I) 8.e4 a5 9 .bS d6! (9 ... gS I O.h3 .lg7 I I . .lb2 �cS 12.\!Mc2) I O..ib2 �d7 I I .exd6 1xd6 1 2.\!Mc2 (1 2.eS .le7 1 3 .\!Mc2 �deS) 12 ... 0-0 and I like Black, Gutman; m 8.g3 a5 (8...�c69..lb2 a5 I O.bS �d4 fails to l l .�xd4, e.g. I I ....ixh l 12.�xe6 dxe6 1 3.f3 .lcS 14.�e4 .le3 1 S .�f2 or l l ...�xd4 12..lxd4 1xhl 1 3.f3) 9.bS d6 I O..ib2 �d7 l l .exd6 .lxd6 1 2 ..lg2 0-0 13.0-0 �ecS (13 ...�dcS 14.\!Mc2 geS can be rnet by IS .gfe l \!Me7 1 6.e4!?) 1 4.\!Mc2 \!Me7 (less precise is 1 4 ... ge8 I S.e3, e.g . IS...�ffi 16.�gS, I S ...l0e4 1 6.�gS \!MxgS 17.l0xe4 \!Mg6 18.�ffi+ or I S ...h6 1 6.�d4 .lxg2 1 7.�xg2 �eS 1 8 .�2f3 �xf3 1 9. �f3 \!Me7 20..md l ) ISJ!fel �eS 16.lOxeS .lxg2 1 7.�xg2 .lxeS 1 8 ..lxeS \!MxeS is double edged, Gutman; Ul) 8..lb2 g6 (8 ...d6 9.exd6 .ixd6 I O.e3 returns to the main line, while 8 ...aS 9.bS g5 IO.\!Mc2 g4 1 I .� �xd4 1 2..lxd4 .lg7 1 3.cS ! was a disaster for Black in Badkarma Maxxx, internet 2002) 9.e3 -
1 14
(9.g3 !? .tg7 l O ..tg2 is also promising, e.g. 10 ...� e7 1 1 .0-0 ll:lc6 12 .ll:le4 0-0-0 13.�c2 h6 1 4.c5 g5 1 5 .b5 ll:la5 1 6.cxb6 axb6 17.ll:ld6+, Coret Frasquet - Albert Garrote, Valencia 1998, or 10 ...0-0 1 1 .0-0 �e7 12.�c2 ges 13.ll:le4 .txe4 14.�xe4 ll:lc6 15_gfd l ll:ltB 16.�c2) 9 .il.g7 lO.il.e2 0-0 1 1 .0-0 �e7 1 2.�c2 &8 13.ll:le4 he4 14.�xe4 ll:lc6 1 5�1 ( l 5 .c5 bxc5 1 6.b5 ll:lxe5 17.ll:lxe5 ll:lg5 18.�d3 he5 19.il.xe5 �xe5 20.�xd7 gadS 2 l .�g4 ll:le4, im proving on 15 ...a5 1 6.cxb6 cxb6 17 .il.c3 &c8 18.gfdl ll:lf8 19.bxa5 bxa5 20.gd5 ll:le6 2 l .h3 ll:lc7 22.gd2 d5 23.�a4, Ca posciutti - Toulzac, Montecatini Terme 1 998) 1 5 ... ll:ltB 1 6.gd5 f6 1 7.c5 ll:l xe5 18 .ll:lxe5 fxe5 19.lUdl maintains an edge for White, Gutman. s...as Some examples of other moves: I) 8 ... g6 9 ..tb2 see 8 . .tb2g6 9.e3 ; II) 8 ...g5 9..tb2 a5 (9 ... ll:lc6 is ruled out by l O.ll:le4 .tg7 l l .ll:lf6+ .txffi 1 2 .exf6 d6 1 3 .�c2 g4 14.ll:lh4 �d7 15 ..te2 h5 1 6 .0-0, Hauser - Krug, Germany 2002. After 9.. .il.g7 White has a choice between l O.ll:ld4 ll:lxd4 l l .exd4 �e7 1 2 .�e2 ll:lc6 13 .h4 h6 14 .hxg5 hxg5 1 5 _gxh8+ .txh8 1 6.g3 0-0-0 1 7.0-0-0, Saksgard - Gun dersen, Namses 1995, and lO..id3 !? g4 l l .ll:ld4 ll:lxd4 1 2.exd4 .txg2 13 .ggl .th3 14..ie4 c6 15..if5 h5 1 6.ll:le4) 1 0.b5 .tg7 l l .�c2 ( l l .h3 �e7 1 2 .�c2 ll:lc5 1 3 .J.e2 is not bad either, Fownarakos - Papas tavropoulos, Athens 200 1 ) l l ...g4 12. ll:ld4 ll:lc5 1 3 .ll:l f5 ( l 3 . ll:le2 d6 14.ll:lg3 .txe5 1 5 . .txe5 dxe5 and Black's pos ition is preferable,Borik) 13...�g5 14.h4 �g6 1 5 .h5 with pressure, Gutman; lli) Lll:lc6 9.ib2 a5 (9 ...d6 10.exd6 hd6 l l .il.e2 0-0 12.ll:le4 .te7 1 3.�c2 �e8 14. O-O ll:lcd8 15.ll:lg3 a5 16.il.c3 axb4 17.axb4 ll:lc6 1 8l!abl � 19..id3 h6 20.ll:lf5 �8 2 l .ll:lxh6+ led to a crushing defeat for Black, Lemke - Horstmann, corr 1 995. •
Also 9 ...�e7 is hardly viable for Black, e.g. lO.il.e2 Q-0...0 l l .c5 g5, Behm - Kmg, Germany 2002, 1 2.cxb6 axb6 13.0-0, or lO.Jd3 a6 1 1 .0-0 0-0-0 12.c5 bxc5 13.�a4 ll:lb8 14.b5 axb5 15.il.xb5, Malmstrom Wittal, corr 2001) lO.b5 ll:le7 l l ..id3 (in stead of l l .g3 h5 12 ..tg2 g5 13.ggl �c8 14.ll:ld4 ll:lc5, Brechten - Roeberg, Ger many 1989) l l ...ll:lc5 1 2 .il.c2 ll:l g6 13 .0-0 .te7 14..if5 0-0 1 5 .�c2 gives White the advantage, Gutman; IV) 8...d6 9.exd6 hd6 1 O.J.b2 0-0 l l .il.e2 a5 12.b5 ( 1 2..tc3 is less clear due to 12 ... axb4 13.axb4 ml l4.�xal �e7 15.�1 ll:la6 1 6.b5 ll:lac5) 12 ...ll:ld7 goes back to the main line. 9.bS d6 9 ... ll:lc5 lO.J.e2 .te7 1 1 .0-0 0-0 12.J.b2 f6 1 3 .exf6 .txffi 14.J.xffi gxf6 1 5 . ll:ld4 d6 1 6 ..tf3 .txO 1 7 .ll:l2xf3 occurred in Caissa - Blitzmich, internet 2002. 10.exd6 lO..ib2 ll:ld7 l l ie2 dxe5 (on l l ...ll:lxe5 12 .ll:lxe5 dxe5 White plays 13..if3 .txO 14.�xf3 f6 15_gd l ) 12 .ll:lxe5 ll:lxe5 1 3 . .txe5 .txg2 14.ggl .tb7 1 5 ..tf3 .txO !? 1 6.�xf3 ffi 1 7 .il.c3 .te7 leaves Black in control, Gutman. 10....txd6 ll.i.bl 0-0 l l.i.el �d7 13. 0-0 �deS 14.1fcl 14.ll:ld4 �h4 15.g3 ll:lg5 !? 16.ll:lc6 �h6 17.ll:lf3 .txc6 18.bxc6 &d8 1 9 .�c2 and White is only marginally better, while Engels - Keller, Wien 1 939, went 1 5 ... mu 1 6..if3 .txn 1 7.ll:l2xf3 &d8 18.�c2 f5 1 9�dl gde8 20.ll:lxe6 ll:lxe6 2 l .�h l f4 22.ll:lgl �h6 23.gxf4 g5 24.ll:lf3 �h3 25.ll:lgl � 26.0 gxf4 27.e4 ll:lc5 28.ll:le2 &6 29.ggl + gg6 30.�d2 �3 31 .� d5+ �e6 32_gxg6+ hxg6 33.�d4 �f7 34.e5 g5 35 .exd6 �xe2 36.�g7+ 1 :0. 14-Be7 1Sllfel !ad8 16Jiadl Black will be hard pressed to justify his material deficit, Gutman.
1 15
Chapter 1 (l .d4 �f6 l.c4 eS 3.dx.eS �e4 4.�dl) 4 .J.b4!? ••
S � 6.g3 .ixd2+ (6....icS? 7.e3 ltlxf2 8.'i!;lxf2 �6 9.ltldf3 occurred in Guag liana Giuseppe - Canelli, Asti 1997, and if6 ltlxd2?, then not 7.gxh4? ltlf3 mate Mueller - Benzinger, M1mich 1 933, but 7.axb4 �e4 8.0, An11toli M11tsukevich) 7 ..ixd2 �e7 (7...�S 8.ltlf3 ltlc6 9 ..if4 g5 I O ..ie3 g4 l l .ltld2 ltlxd2 1 2 .�xd2 �xeS 1 3 ..ig2 with advantage for White, while Schmidt - Kruger, G ermany 1 99 1 , continued 9..ig2 ltlxd2 I O .�xd2 ltlxeS l l .ltlxeS �xeS) 8.ltlf3 !? ltlc6 (after 8 ... ltlxd2 9.�xd2 ltlc6 Black has a tempo less, comparing to variations with 4.ltlf3 .ib4+ S ..id2 ltlxd2 6.ltlbxd2 ltlc6 7.a3 .ixd2+ 8.�xd2 � e7 9.g3- Part 4, Chap ter 3, Section 2) 9..if4 �cS I O.Ae3 �xc4 l l .�d3 d5 12..ig2 �a4 13.0-0 .ie6 14.b3 �aS I S .b4 �a4 16.bS ltle7 17.ltld4 isn 't inspiring for Black, Gutman. 6.Ax.dl ••.
.•
lf4 ...ib4, then S.liH3 followed by a2-a3 secures the bishop pair for White, Ala: ander Akkhine. The problem with the latter move if that the simplification if not always favour able, even when it involves recapturing the pawn, if White obtoins the bifhop pair after exchanges on d2, Tim H11rding.
We divide the m11terilll into three sections: Section I - S .a3 Section 2 - S.g3 Section 3 - S.ltlf3. S .�c2 will transpose into 4.�c2 .ib4+ S.ltld2, treated in Part 2, Chapter 3, Sec tion 2. Section 1 S.a3 The immediate challenge to the bishop if the main independent possibility. Nevertheless it seems that Black need notfear this move, H��rding. s ...Ax.dl+
6...�c6 Alternatives: I) 6...�e7 7.ltlf3 (Mucklow - Taylor, corr 1 998, went 7.e3 �xeS 8..id3 d6 9.ltlf3 �e7 I O.h4 .ig4 l l .�c2, when l l ....if3 1 2 .gxf3 ltlxd2 1 3 .�xd2 ltld7 is good) 7 ... ltlc6 goes back into the main line; II) 6 ... 0-0 with a further split: A) 7.ltlf3 ltlxd2 (7 ... b6 can be met by 8 ..ib4 ! ? cS 9.�dS ltlc6 I O .�xe4 cxb4 l l .e3 .ib7 12..id3 g6 13.0-0) 8.�xd2 ( if 1 16
8 .l0xd2 l0c6 9.f4 d6 ! ) 8 ... l0c6 reaches a position after 4 ..!00 .ib4+ S..id2 l0xd2 6.l0bxd2 l0c6 7.a3 .lxd2+ 8.�xd2 0-0 Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 2 ; B) 7.J.e3 d6 (7 ... f5 8.l0h3 �e7 9.0 lOcS IO ..lxcS 'i!rxcS l l .�dS+) 8.0!? (8 .�dS .if'S 9.�xb7 is a daring reply in view of 9 ...l0d7 I O.exd6 l0xd6) 8 ...lOcS 9.exd6 cxd6 10..ixc5 dxcS I I .�xd8 lhd8 12�1. Gutman; similarly C) 7 .i.f4 b6 8..!00 (8.�dS .!OcS 9.'Wxa8? .ib7 I O.�xa7 l0c6) 8 .. .1b7 9.e3 aS 1 0 . .id3 l0a6 1 1 .0-0 lOac S 12.1c2 a4 13.l0d4 yields White a clear plus, Gutman. Ill) 6 .. .f6, indicated by Herman Stei ner, and now: A) 7..!00 fxeS 8 .g3 (8 .lOxeS is unsound due to 8 ... l0xf2 9.
IV) 6 ... l0xd2 7.�xd2 l0c6 (7. . .�e7 8.f4 g5 9 ..!00 g4 IO.lOgS b6 l l .l0e4, Brachtei Notheisen, corr 1 994) 8.f4 (a similar position was treated wtder4.�c2 .ib4+ S.l0d2 l0xd2 6..ixd2 .lxd2+ 7.�xd2 l0c6 8.f4 Part 2, Chapter 3, Section 2; the only difference is that the white pawn stands on a3 now), to which Black has: A) 8 ...0-0 9..!00 (9.g3 d6 IO.exd6 cxd6 1 1 . .!00 \1:n)6 12.0-0-0 .if'S or 9.e3 ges IO.l0e2 d6 l l .exd6 cxd6) 9 ...d6 (Esnault Zouaoui, corr 1 996, went 9 aS IO.e4 f6 l l .�d5+�8 12.� fXeS 13 .lOxeS .!OxeS 14.�xeS d6 I S.�gS �xg5 1 6.fxgS ges, but IO.e3 a4 1 1 ..Ad3 is critical) IO.exd6 cxd6 l l .e3 �b6 12.�f2 .ifS 1 3.b4 gfe8 14..id3 .ig4 1 S .lOgS !? h6 1 6.l0e4 gadS 1 7.l0c3 aS 18.lOdS �a7 1 9 .bS 1 :0 Arlandi - Isonso, Mantova 1 996; B) 8 ...�e7 9 . .!00 b6 IO.g3 .ib7 1 1 .ig2 0-0-0 12 .0-0 (12 .b4 d6 1 3 .exd6 gxd6) 1 2 . . .�cS+ 1 3 .�h l �xc4 14.gacl and White obtains the initiative, Gutman; C) 8 ...Ri 9.exRi �xffi I 0..!00 ( I O.g3!? is also reasonable, viz. I O ...d6 1 1 .1g2 .if5 12.gd l 0-0 1 3.l0h3 gae8 14.l0f2 �g6 IS.0-0 �h8 16 ..10 ge7 17 ,gc I gfe8 1 8. e4 .id7 1 9 .cS dxcS 20.gxcS h6 2 1 ..ihS �d6 22.gds I :0 Bastrakov - Beldugov, Russia 199S, while IO.e3d6 1 1 .l0e2 0-0 1 2.l0g3 geS 1 3 .0-0-0, ltter - Laure1es, e-mail 1 999, 13 ...aS 14 ..ie2 a4 I S .�b1 lOaS leaves White with no safe place for his king) 10 ... d6 (I 0 ... 0-0 l l .g3 d6 is a transposition, yet White has additionally l l .e3 ges 12.1e2 d6 13.gc1 .ig4 14.0-0 ge7 IS.h3 .if'S 1 6.cS dxcS 11.gxcS gae8 18.J.bS lhe3 19.lOeS :i:kl4, Silva Marcelo Richard Andy, e-mail 1 999, 20.�dS+!? 1k6 2 1 ..ixc6 winning) l l .g3 0-0 (II..Jdi 1 2.gc1 0-0-0 13 ..ig2 dS 14.cS d4 IS .0-0 .idS 16.b4 l0e7 17 .bS c6 1 8.b6 a6 19.J.h3+ .ie6 20.f5, Czerwonski - Chrz, Litomysl 1 996) 12.1g2 .if5 13.o-o gae8 1 4.gfe l appears good for White, Gutman. -
.•
1 17
V) 6 ... d6 7.exd6 (7.lt:lf3 dxe5 is harmless. If 8.lt:lxe5, then not 8 .. :t!ld4 9.lt:ld3 .ie6 IO.e3"t!/ffi ll ikl lt:lc6 1 2."t!/f3 "t!/g6 13.lt:lf4 lt:lxd2 14."t!/xc6+ bxc6 15 .lt:lxg6 hxg6 16. �d2, Lieb - De Liberto, Bad Liebenzell 1996, but 8 ... lt:lxf2 9.�xt2 "t!/d4+ IO.e3 "t!/xe5 t t .ic3 "t!if5+ 12."t!/f3 0-0 13..ie2 ie6 14.Hadl lt:ld7. In case of 8 ..ie3 Black should avoid 8 ... "t!/e7?!, Harding, 9."t!/d5 lt:ld6 IO."t!/xe5 "t!/xe5 l l .lt:lxe5 ffi 12.c5 lt:lf5 13.lt:lc4 .k6 14.Hcl, and play 8 ..."t!/xdl+ 9.Hx dl f6 or 8 ... lt:ld7!? 9."t!/c2 fS IO.Hdl "t!/e7 1 1 .g3 0-0 12..ig2 lt:ldffi 1 3 .0-0, Ve sely - Melmuk, Bmo 1 987, 13 .. ..id7 14. lt:ld2 .ic6) 7 ..."t!/xd6 is more intriguing.
There are two possibilities: A) 8.lt:lf3 keeps more options open: At) 8 "t!lb6? 9..ie3 (instead of 9.e3 "t!/xb2, Otto Borik), Gutman; Al) 8 ... lt:lxd2 9."t!/xd2 "t!/xd2+ IO.lt:lxd2 (IO.�d2!? lt:lc6 l l .e3.ig4 12..ie2 � 13 .c;t>c3) IO ...o!Oc6 l l .g3 (l l.e3 .its 12�2 lt:le5 13.0-0 0-0-0 14.00 lt:lxf3+ 15..ixf3 Hd2 16.b4 ie6 112--'lz Knudsen - Galberg, corr 1 993) l l .. ..ie6 1 2 ..ig2 lt:ld4 13.& I 0-0-0 14.e3 lt:lf5 1 5 .lt:le4, Gutman; A3) 8 ... 0-0 9..ie3! (9..ib4 "t!ib6 or 9.e3 lt:lc6 to."t!/c2 �8 t t.id 3 .its, improving on 9 ... Hd8 to."t!/c2 .its l l .lt:lh4 "t!/xd2+ 12."t!/xd2 Hxd2 1 3.lt:lxf5 g6, Frantisek Nepustil, 14.lt:le7+ �tB 15.lt:ld5 lt:la6 16. f3) 9 ..."t!/e7 IO.g3 lt:lc6 l l ..ig2, Gutman; .•
A4) 8 ... lt:lc6 9.lt:lg5 (There is no argu ment for 9.b4?!, Savage - Hall, e-mail 2002, 9 ...0-0. Also 9�3 is less effective due to 9 ..."t!/ffi I O.lt:ld4 0-0, while after 9... .ie6 White has a fine rejoinder in to."t!/d3 fS I I .Hc I 0-0-0 12."t!/xd6 lt:lxd6 1 3.lt:ld4 lt:lxd4 14..ixd4) 9 ...lt:lxd2 (9 .. ..its I O.lt:lxe4 .ixe4, Battaglini - Cornette, France 1 9 99, l l ..ic3 "t!/g6 1 2 ."t!/d2 0-0 13.f3) to."t!/xd2 "t!/xd2+ ( I O..."t!/e7 t l .lt:lf3 0-0 1 2 .e3 .ig4 13 ..ie2 Had8 1 4 ."t!/c3 fS 1 5.0-0 f4 16 .Hae l or I O. . ."t!ff6 t t .lt:le4 "t!/e5 12.lt:lc3 0-0 13.lt:ld5 J.f5 14.Hdl Had8 1 5 ."t!/c3 "t!ie6 1 6.e3 h4 17 ..ie2 .ixd5 1 8. cxd5 Hxd5 1 9.Hxd5 "t!/xd5 20.0-0) 1 0... "t!/xd2+ l ! .�d2 h6 12.lt:lf3 (12.lt:le4 .ig4 13.f3 0-0-0+ 14.�3 mte8 15 .e3 fS 16.lt:lf2 Hxe3+ 17 ..id3? .ixf3 and Black won in Jensen - Nicolaisen, corr 1 988) 1 2 .. ..ig4 (Merlicek - Hrubos, corr 1988, went 1 2... .ie6 13.e3 0-0-0+ 1 4.�c3 Hhe8 1 5 ..ie2 g5 1 6.Had I f5 17 .Hxd8+ Hxd8 1 8.Hd I Hxdl 1 9..ixd l ) 13 .e3 0-0-0+ 1 4.�c3 are all awkward for Black, Gutman; AS) 8 ..."t!/f6! 9."t!/cl (9..ie3 lt:lc6 I O."t!/d5 lt:ld6 1 1 .0-0-0 .k6 12."t!/g5 "t!/xg5 1 3.lt:lxg5 .ixc4 1 4..ic5 0-0-0 1 5..ixd6 cxd6 16.e3 .ixfl t7 .Hhxfl Hd7 1 8 .Hd5 h6 1 9.lt:le4 �7 20.Hfdl l:llid 8 2 l .lt:lc3 was played in Legky - ToulZllc, Quentin 1999, yet 16 ... .ie6 equalises) 9 ...lt:lc6 (9 ... 0-0!? I O..if4 He8 l l .e3 lt:la6 12 ..ie2 g5 13.ig3 h5 is possible, while 9 ... lt:lxd2 to."t!/xd2 lt:lc6 l l .e3 0-0 1 2.Hcl Hd8 1 3 ."t!/c3 1eads no where) IO ..if4 ( 1 0..ic3 lt:lxc3 l l ."t!/xc3 "t!/xc3+ 1 2.bxc3 .ie6 13 .e3 lt:la5 1 4.Hbl 0-0-0 15.lt:lg5 mte8 16.lt:lxe6 Hxe6 17�2. Fernandez Torre - Boo Martin, Asturia 1 997, 17 ...g6) to .ie6 (instead of i O....ig4 t t ."t!/e3 0-0-0 12."t!/xe4: 12 .. ..ixf3 13."t!/xf3 "t!/xb2 14.Hc l Hd4 1 5.g3 Hxf4 16."t!/xf4 lt:ld4 17."t!/d2 "t!/xa3 1 8..ih3+ I :0 Mayer Dausch, Germany 1 995, or 12 ...l:llie8 13. .ig5 Hxe4 14..ixffi gxf6 1 5.e3) l l .g3 0-0 12 ..ig2 lt:lc5 and Black is fme, Gutman. •
1 18
B) 8.ie3 !? 't!/e7 (if 8...ltlc6 9.f3 't!/xdl+
D) 7..i£4 't!/e7 (7...g5?! 8..ie3 't!/e7 9.'t!/d5 't!/xe5 IO.'t!/xe5 lt:lxe5 l l .f3!? lt:ld6 12.c5 lt:ldc4 13..ixg5 ggs 14..if4 ffi 15.b3 lt:la5, Tepi - EtcChess, internet 2002, 1 6.gb I ) 8.'t!/d5 lt:lc5 9.lt:lf3 lt:le6 10.Ad2 b6 l l ..ib4 lt:lc5 with enough counterplay, Gutman.
I OJ�xdl lt:ld6 l l .c5 lt:lc4 1 2..ic l ) 9.lt:lf3 lt:lc6 I O.g3 0-0 l l ..ig2 lt:ld6 ( I I . . .ie6 1 2.Wfc2 lt:ld6 1 3 .ic5 b6 14.hd6 cxd6 15.0-0 !:!ac8 16.'t!/d3 l:Ud8 17.b3 d5, Dau tov - Gutman, internet 2003 but 13..if4! lt:lxc4 14.lt:lg5 has more point) 1 2 ..ic5 gfd8 13.0.0 .ie6 14.lt:ld4!? lt:lxd4 15.Wfxd4 maintains an edge for White, Gutman.
7 ...'f!/e7
Others: I) 7 ... lt:lxe5? 8.lt:lxe5 lt:lxf2 9.�1'2 't!lh4+
Back to the main line
I O.g3 't!/d4+ l l .e3 't!/xe5 12.ic3 , Blaz quez - Rodriguez, Las Palm as 199 5; D) 7 ...d5 8.cxd5 (8.exd6 goes back into 6...d6 7.lt:lf3 lt:lc6 8.exd6) 8 't!/xd5 9..if4 (9.e3 lt:lxe5 I O.lt:lxe5 't!/xe5 l l .'t!/c2 lt:lxd2 12.'t!/xd2 0-0 is level, Porter - Moore, Alburquerque 1 997, but Black can try for more with 9 . ..ig4, e.g. I O..ie2 0-0-0 l l .lt:ld4? ixe2 1 2.'t!/xe2 lt:lxd4 13.exd4 lt:lxd2, Howard - Metge, Auckland 1996, or I O.ib4 't!/xd l+ J J .gxd l a5 1 2 .ic3 lt:lxc3 13.bxc3 hf3 14.gxf3 lt:lxe5 1 5.f4 lt:ld7) 9...'t!/c5 (9 ...ie6 IO.'t!/xd5 ixd5 l l.e3, Scholten - Frommherz, Germany 200 I ) IO.e3 0.0 l l.ie2 seems preferable for White, Gutman; III) 7 ...0-0 !? 8.if4 d6 (8 ...b6 9.'t!/c2 f5 I O.exf6 lt:lxf6 l l .e3 ib7 12.id3) 9.e3 (9.'t!/d5 dxe5 I O.lt:lxe5, Weber - Andre, corr 1 995, could be met by I O ...'t!/xd5 l l .cxd5 lt:le7 1 2 _gd I lt:l f6 1 3 .d6 cxd6 14.gxd6 ie6) 9 ...dxe5 (9 .. ..ig4 1 0.exd6 't!/f6 1 1 .'t!/c2 ht3 13.gxf3 lt:lxd6 14.0-0-0) I O.lt:lxe5 't!/ft) (IO ... lt:lxe5 l l .'t!/xd8 gxd8 1 2 ..be5 c6 13.f3 f6 14 .ig3) l l .lt:lxc6 't!/xb2 12.ltle7+ Wh8 1 3 ..ie2 ltlc3 ( 1 3 ... ig4 14.f3 lt:lc3 1 5.ie5 gfe8 fails to 16. gb) 't!/xb l 1 7 .ixc3 't!/xd l+ I S .Wxd l ) 14..ie5 lt:lxdl 15..ixb2 lt:lxb2 16.gbJ lt:la4 17.lt:lxc8&xc8 1 8.�b7 gbs 19� �8 20.0-0 lt:lc3 2 l .if3 c5 22.gxb8 gxb8 is close to equalising, Gutman; IV) 7 ... lt:lxd2 !? 8.'t!/xd2 't!/e7 see 4.lt:lf3 ib4+ 5.id2 lt:lxd2 6.lt:lbxd2 lt:lc6 7 .a3 hd2+ 8.'t!/xd2 't!/e7 - Part4, Chapter 3, Sections 2/4. •.
7.�0
There are two more plans: I) 7..ie3 't!/e7 8.f3 lt:lc5 (Zoltai - Karker, corr 1989, went 8 ... lt:ld6 9.exd6 't!/xe3 I O.dxc7 0-0 1 1 .& 1 d6 1 2_gc3 't!lb6 1 3 .b3 't!/xc7 14.g3 Ae6 15.lt:lh3 't!/a5 16.b4 't!/e5 17 .'t!/d2 gadS 1 8.ltlf4 gfe8 1 9..ig2 with a plus for White, though I prefer l l .'t!/d2 't!/b6 12.lt:lh3 't!/xc7 1 3 .lt:lf4 lt:le5 1 4.e3 �8 15.lt:ld5) 9.f4 (against 9.b4 lt:le6 IO.f4 both I O ...d6 l l .exd6 cxd6 12 .ltlf3 0-0 13 .'t!/d2 lt:lc7!? 14.gdl ges 1 5 .if2 ie6 16.b5 lt:lb8 17.'t!/d3 d5 and IO ... ffi l l .lt:lf3 fxe5 12.fxe5 0-0 13.g3 b6 14.ig2 ib7 1 5.0-0 a5 16.b5 lt:lcd8 1 7.'t!/c2 lt:lt7 keeps control) 9...d6 I O..ixc5 (I O.b4 lt:ld7) IO ...dxc5 l l .e3 id7!? (1 1...0-0 1Hfb3 f6 13.exf6 gxf6 14..ie2 if5 1 5 .wf2 ges 16..if3 ie4, Little Goliath - Gambit Ti ger, computer game 200 I ) 12.lt:lf3 0-0-0, Gutman; further
1 19
Baumgartner, St. Wendel l 992) 1 2 .ic3 i.b7 1 3.�xe5 dxe5 1 4.f3 !ladS 1 5 .�c2 �xc3 1 6.�xc3 c5 with a slight edge for Black, Plattner - Fileman, internet 2002. 8...g5!
8..lf4
After S.e3 Black has little to fear: A) S ...0-0 9.id3 (9.�c2 �xd2 I O.�xd2
�xe5 l l .�xe5 �xe5 12.id3 d6 1 3.�c2 f5 14.0-0-0 .ld7 1 5 .h3 !labS 1 6.g4 b5 171ihg l 'it>hS I S.gx5 bxc4 19 .ie4 .h4 gave Black a winning position, Bellm Sauer, Leimen 2001 ) 9...�xd2 I O.�xd2 �xe5 l l .�xe5 �xe5 see 4.�f3 .lb4+ "�..id2 �xd2 6.�bxd2 �c6 7.a3 .lxd2+ S.�xd2 �e7 9.e3 �xe5 I O.�xe5 �xe5 II Jd3 ()..() - Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 2; B) S ... b6 9..le2 (9.�c2 �xd2 IO.�xd2 .lb7 see 4.�c2ib4+ 5.id2 �xd2 6.�xd2 �c6 7.�f3 �e7 S.a3 .bd2+ 9.�xd2 b6 I O.e3 .lb7 - Part 2, Chapter 3, Section I ) 9. ..ib7 10.0-0 �xd2 l l .�xd2 �xe5 with a transposition into 4.�f3 .lb4+ 5.i.d2 �xd2 6.�bxd2 �c6 7.a3 .bd2+ 8.�xd2 �e7 9.e3 b6 IO.ie2 i.b7 1 1 .0-0 �xe5 Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 2 ; C ) S. . .�xe5 9.ie2 d6 10.0-0 0-0 ( 1 0 ... �xd2 l l .�xd2 0-0 reaches a position after 4.�f3 .ib4+ 5.id2 �xd2 6.�bxd2 �c6 7.a3 .bd2+ S.�xd2 �e7 9.e3 �xe5 10�2 ()..() 1 1 .0.0 d6 - Part 4, Chapter 3, Section 2) I I .& I ( l l .�c2 it3 1 2.�xe5 �xe5, as 12 ... �g3?, Voracek - Baum ruk, Klatovy 1995, is a blunder due to 1 3.Jd3 .bd3 14.�xd3) l l ... b6 ( 1 1 .. .15 12�1 a5 13.�4id7 14.�c2 5 is worth trying, but not 13 .. .ig6? 14.f4, Graeser -
Normal moves don't help: I) S ...0-0? 9.�d5 (more effective than 9.e3 g5 I O.ig3 �xg3 l l .hxg3 �xe5 12. �xe5 �xe5 13.�5 �g7 14.id3 5 1 5.f4 d6, Aldrich - Kitts, Germany 1999) 9... g5 IO.ie3 g4 l l .�xe4 gxf3 1 2.ih6 and Black has no defence, Gutman; II) 8...�c5 9.e3 brings Black no success either, e.g. 9 ... g5 (9...�a5+ I O.b4 �xb4 l l .axb4 �xb4+ 12.�2 a5 1 3 .�c2, Sieg mund - Moehring, Baden 2001 ) I O.ig3 h5 l l .�d5 �xd5 12.cxd5 �7 1 3.d6 �6 14.h3 cxd6 1 5 .exd6 !ih6 1 6.!id l , Sieg mund - Gutdeutsch, Leutersdorf 2000; ID) S ...d6 9.exd6 (9.�d5 !? may well be more potent 9 ... 5 IO.exd6 cxd6 1 1 .�4 �ffi 1 2.�xc6 �xd5 1 3 .�xe7 �xf4 14. �xeS !ixcS 1 5.e3 and if9 ...dxe5, then not I O.ixe5, Bujisho - Le Dref, Nantes 1 993, 1 0 ...5 ! l l .!idl i.e6 1 2 .�b5 0-0, but I O.�xe5 �xe5 l l .�xe5) 9... cxd6 I O.g3 ( I O.�d5 !?) I O ...i.e6 l l .!ic l 0-0 12.ig2 !ladS 13.0.0 g5 14.ie3 5 1 5.�d4 i.cS 1 6.�b5 (instead of 1 6.�xc6 bxc6 17.�a4 c5 IS.�dl i.b7 19.id2 f4 20.ia5 !id7, Weinberg - Schmidt, Caorle 19SS) 16 ... a6 1 7.�c3 �xc3 1Siixc3 f4 1 9.ib6 is clearly awkward for Black, Gutman; IV) S ... 5 9.h4 b6 IO.e3 i.b7 l l .id3 (also l l .�c2 0-0-0 1 2.0-0-0 h6 1 3 .h5 looks quite promising) 1 1 ...0-0-0 1 2 .�c2 h6 1 3.0-0-0 (1 3.h5!?) 1 3 ... !id� 1 4.h5 �c5 1 5.ix5 !ix5 1 6.�x5 �b4 17 .axb4 ie4 I S.!ixd7 �b3+ 19.\t>dl �xb4 20.�xe4 �5 2 1 .!ixc7+ and White won quickly, Olafsson - Olaffson, Reykjavik 1994; V) S ...h6 9.h4!? (9.�d5 is only a waste oftime since both 9...�g5 IO.�xg5 hxg5 l l .i.g3 a5 1 2 .b3 b6 1 3 .e3 i.b7, Tait Corbin, Barbados 200 1 , and 9.-�c5 10. 1 20
e3 a5 I I �e2 b6 J2_gd I .ib7 1 3.0-0 0-0 14 ..ig3 a4!? are fme foc Black) 9 ...lt:lc5 IO.'�c2 ( IO.b4 is premature due to I 0... lt:le6 l l �g3 b6 1 2.e3 a5!? 1 3 .b5 lt:lcd8 14.lt:ld4 lt:lc5 15 ..ie2 lt:le4 1 6.lt:lf5 �f8 17 ..if4 .ib7 18�f3 lt:le6 19.'�c2 lt:l6c5, Dempsey - Forman, Bruege 1999) 10 ... lt:le6 l l ..ig3 b6 12.e3 .ib7 13..ie2 0-0-0 ( 1 3 .. J�g8 14.h5) 14.b4 g5 1 5 Jk l with advantage for White, Gutman .
1 6�xe7 .ixc4 17 �xc4 �xe7 was level in Gambit Tiger - An Mon, computer game 200 1 ) 16.�d3 gg8 17.0-0 (1 7.g3 gg7!? t 8.o-o b6 t9 ..ib4 gd7) 1 1 ...gd8 1 8.�b3 b6 19.�a4 .id7 20�b4 lt:ld4 2 1 . � dl .ic6 and Black is o n top, Gutman; D) 9.�c2 gxf4 (9 ... o!Oxf2? I O.hg5, e.g. I O...�c5 l l .b4 lt:ld4 1 2.'M>2 or I O...lt:ld4, when both l l .�d2 lt:le4 12be7 lt:lxf3+ 13.exf3 lt:lxd2 14.if6, Raff- Meyer, Ger many 1 997, and l l .lt:lxd4 �xg5 12.�xf2 �4+ 13.�e3 are winning) IO.�xe4 re turns to the main line. 9...gxf4
9 .. .f5 I O.exffi lt:lxf6 l l .�xg5 d6 1 2 .e3 ( 12.'�'h4 .if5 1 3.e3 0-0-0 14�g5, O'Con nell - Kill iane, Dublin 1 99 1 ) 1 2 ....id7 13.c5 0-0-0 14.cxd6 cxd6 1 5.gd) d5 1 6 . .ig3 gdf8 17 kl leavesBlack in trouble, Pichler - Schweiger, corr 1 990. 1 0.ti'xe4 d6 9.ti'dS
Two more moves are worth mentioning: I) 9�3 g4 IO.�d5 gxf3 (IO...lt:lxf2? loses to l l ..ig5 �e6 12.�xf2 gxf3 13.exf3) l l .�xe4 d6 ( l l ... fxg2 12 ..ixg2 �xe5 1 3 .�xe5+ o!Oxe5 14 ..id4 d6 1 5 .f4 gg8, Nepustil, 16.gg) gg4 17.fxe5 gxd4 18. exd6 cxd6 19 ..id5 �e7 20.gg8 gg4 is OK for Black, but as Hans Baum points out, 13�f4!? �xe4 14�xe4 d6 15 ..ig5 gg8 1 6�ffi h6 17.0-0-0 might be a good answer, viz. 17 .. ..ie6 1 8.m.g t �d7 1 9.b3 &e8 20�7 �gl 21fugl) 1 2.exf3 dxe5 1 3 . .ie2 f5 (Duemer - Kasperett, Ger many 1 99 1 , continued 1 3 .. �e6 1 4.f4! exf4 1 5.�xf4 0-0-0 1 6.0-0 gdg8, when instead of l 7.b4.ih3 1 8�f3 gxg2+ 19. �hi gg6 20_ggl IDtg8 Y:t-%., 17 _gfe I .ih3 1 8 ..ifl gxg2+ 19�xg2 gg8 20..ha7!? gxg2+ 2 1 .�hl would be decisive) 14. �d5 .ie6 15�5 ( 1 5 .�b5 0-0-0 1 6.0-0 f4 17 ..ic5 �g7) 1 5 ...�f6!? ( 1 5 ....ixd5
l l .ti'xf4
l l .g3 fxg3 (l l ...f5 1 2.�xf4 dxe5 13.�e3 J47 14Jg2 0-0-0 15.0-0 e4 16.lt:ld4 lt:lxd4 17.�xd4 �b8 1 8 .e3 h5 19.h4 mtf8 20.b4 .ia4 2 1 .'M>2 � turned out well for Black in Baur - Augustin, corr 1988) 12.hxg3 lt:lxe5 13.lt:lxe5 �xe5 14�g2 �f8 (better than 14...h6 1 5.0-0-0 �xe4 16be4 m,8 J 7.gh4 �f8 1 8.c5 dxc5 1 9 .gd8+ �g7 20.fuh8 �xh8 2 1 _gxh6+ �g7 22_gh7+ �g8 23.gh5 b6 24.g4, Janos Balogh) 121
11.1l'g5
e-mail 2002, went 13.b4 e4 14.ltJd4 ltJxd4 15.�xd4 � 1 6.�e3 �e5 J 7.gc) a5 1S.b5 .ie6 19.f4 �b2 20.g4 �a2 2 1 .�c3 e3 22. �xe3 hc4 23.�c5 id5 24,gg l , yet 14 ... �!? 15.ltJxc6 hc6 1 6.�xa7 b6 17.g3 �d7 would make this way quite risky) 13 ... e4 (13 ...0-0-0 14.g3 �e6 is also rea sonable, viz. 1 5.�c3 mt6+ 1 6.gd2 .lg4 1 7 ..lg2 e4 I S.ltJh4 lLld4 19.�bl ltJxe2 20,gxdS+ gxdS 2 1 .�e5 m6 22.1xe4 m3) 14.Ci:Jd4 Q..O..O 1 5.g3 (15.ltJxc6 hc6 16.gxdS+ gxdS 17 .�xa7 is suicidal due to 1Lb6 1 S.g3 �d7) 1 5 �c5 1 6.ig2 f5 1 7 .�bl �xc4 1 S.Ci:Jxc6 �xc6 19.�xa7 .id5 20.gd2 �a2+ 2 1 . �c I b6 22 ..ih3 � 231Dldl ga; 24.gd4 �a I+ 25.�c2 ti'a2, Gutman; further V) 1 2.mt4 .if5 ( 1 2...�e6?! J 3.gdl id7 14.b4 h5 1 5.b5 ltJa5 1 6.e3 f6 1 7 .c5 e4 IS.ltJd4) 13 .0-0-0 ggs 14.�xe7+ �xe7 looks fully viable to me, Gutman.
White has a choice of retreats: I) 12.�e4 .id7 1 3.e3 0-0-0 1 4.b4 f5 1 5. �c2 e4 1 6.ltJd2 mrlB 17.g3 ltJe5 IS..ie2 f4 1 9.gxf4 ltJd3+ 20..ixd3 exd3 2l .�c3 gxf4 22.gg l gf7 left White frustrated in Lupes - Badkarna, internet 2002; II) 12.�d2 e4 13.ltJd4 ltJe5 14.�c3 .lg4 1 5.h3 .ih5 16.ltJf5 �ffi 17.ltJg3 .lg6 IS. 0-0-0 0-0 1 9.h4 h6 20.e3 gfeS 2 1 .gd2 gadS is fine for Black, Weyerstrass Beukmann, Interne Laren 1 973; ffi) 12.mt6 e4 (Riedmiller - Fitzinger, Vienna 1 942, went 12 ..J.d7 13.�g5 ti'e6 14.e3 h6 15.mt4 ggs 16.h3 Ci:Je7, when White could repeat moves with 1 7.�e4 l0::6 IS.mt4) 1 3.ltJd2 .id7 14.�f4 0-0-0 1 5.ti'xe4 ti'f6 16.�c2 Ci:Jd4 17.ti'c3 gheS I S.e3 (I S.e4 .la4 19.J.d3 ltJO+) IS .ic6 19 .Ci:Jb3 .lxg2 20.1xg2 gxe3+ 22.fxe3 mt4+ 23.�fl �f6+ 24.�el mt4+ with a draw by perpetual check, Gutman; IV) 12.�e3 .id7 13.().().0 (For 13.g3 ().().0 14.1g2 f5 see l l .g3 f5 12.�xf4 dxe5 13. �e3 lur1 14.ig2 ().().0, Bilsel - Kerekes,
Other defences fail to equalise: I) 1 2 ...�e6?! 13.�g7 grs I 4.ltJg5 �g6 1 5 .�xg6 hxg6 1 6.e3, Gutman; m 12 ...e4 13.�xe7+ (13.�g7 ruB 14.ltJg5 .if5 1 5 .ltJxh7 hh7 16.�xh7 0-0-0 1 7.g3 lLld4 I S.0-0-0 was played in Vasquez Yabm, Siegen Olympiad 1970, but 17 ... ti'e5!? IS.1g2 f5 19.mt 6 ti'xb2 20.�c l �e5 is critical) 13...�xe7 14.ltJd2 f5 15.e3 (15.g3 Ae6 16_gcl &dS 1 7 J.g2, Crafty Timm an, internet 199S, 17 ...ltJe5) 15 ..Je6 1 6.f4, Gutman; ffi) 12 ... .le6 1 3.ti'xe7+ (13.e3?! is less consequent in view of 1 3 .. .f6 14.mt5+ iJ.f7 15.mt4 0-0-0 16.J.e2 �bS!? 17.ltJd2 .lg6, improving on 1 6...e4 1 7 .Ci:Jd2 .lg6 IS.ltJb3 a5 19.0-0 a4 20.Ci:Jcl ltJe5 2 1.ltJa2 �g7 22.gad l , Burkart - Guffart, Ger many 1995) 1 3 ... �xe7 1 4.e3 gadS (if 14..1DlgS, then not 15.b4, Kekki - Haa piniemi, Kiljava 19S6, 15 ... f6!? 1 6.ltJd2 a5 1 7 .b5 ltJbS, but 1 5.ltJd2 f5 16.g3 e4 17.f4) 1 5.ltJd2 (15_gdl a5 1 6.b3 f5 17.J.e2
1 5.0-0-0 �g7 1 6.mt4 (1 6.\!�he5+ dxe5 17.l:�d5 ges t s.ghdl c6!? 1 9.gds .le6, Balogh) 1 6 .. .h6 1 7 _gd5 �f6 I S.�xf6+ �xfti 19.ilh4 gbs 201b.S a6 2 l .c5 dxc5 22ilxc5 c6 23.a4 1d7 24.�h5 �g7 was even, Lundquist - Balogh, corr 194S-50. l l ...dxeS
.•
•.
l l...'ffxgS
·
1 22
lhdl+ 18.�xdl �d8+ 1 9.�c2 f4 20..id3 h6 2 1 .�3 �g8 22,gg1 �f6 23.i.e4, Ber tok - Persitz, Ljubljana 1955) 15 ... f5 16. g3 e4 1 7.f4, Gutman.
Section l (1.d4 �f6 l.c:4 eS 3.dxeS �e4 4.�dl Ab4) S.g3
13 .�xgS �d4
13 ... f5 14.e3 (after 14.g3 h6 15 ..!tJh3?! Ae6 16.�c I 0-0-0 1 7.e3 a 5 18 .i.g2 �d3 19.0-0 �d8 Black got an active position, Opocensky - Schmidt, Kladno 1 936) 14 ...h6 1 5 . .!tJf3 aS 16.b3 Ae6 1 7.0-0-0 �e7 1 8.i.eH !hg8 19.gH !ad8 20.�xd8 �xd8 2 1 .�dl left White a sound pawn ahead, Galavics - Hausler, corr 1 980.
This neglectedpossibility (suggested by S�n�ieUy Tartakower) must be taken se riously, Tim Harding.
s... �c:6
14.Jllc :l
14.0-0-0 .tf5 1 5.e4 .lg6 !? (better than 1 5 .. .i.g4 16.f3 .ld7 1 7.f4 .lg4 18 .�d3 f6 19.fxe5 fxe5 20J:!g3 .ld7 2 l ..!tJx h7! 0-0-0 22..!tJffi Aa4 23.i.d3, Crafty - Ta mar, computer game 1 998) 16 . .!tJf3 (on 1 6.f4 0-0-0) 1 6 ....lh5 1 7 J!d3 Axf3 1 8. gxf3 0-0-0 1 9.�d2 (1 9J!gl l::!g8 20Eg3 c5) 1 9 ... .!tJxf3+ 20.�e3 l::!xd3+ 21 .i.xd3 ltJh4 22,ggJ .!tJg6 23.c5 �d7 24..ic4 �e7, Norgaard - Paaske, Denmark 1 999. 14 -AfS 15.�13 .•
1 5.e3?! .!tJb3, e.g. 16.&3 .!tJc5 17.b4 .!tJa4 1 81k: I ffi or J6,gdl l::!g8 17 ..!tJf3 ffi 18 ..!tJd2 ltJc5, Gutman. 1S...�xf3+ 16.exf3 Jlld8 17.Ael �7 18. Jlld 1 aS Black is close to equalising, Gutman.
Alternatives: I) 5 ...b6 6.Ag2 .lb7 7.f3!? (7 . .!tJf3 will transpose into 4 . .!tJf3 b6 5 ..!tJbd2 .lb7 6. g3, covered in Part 4, Chapter 2 ) 7...ltJxd2 8.Axd2 't!Je7 9..!tJh3 (9.e4 ltJc6 I O ..!tJe2 ltJxe5 1 1.0-0 ltJxc4 12.i.xb4 't!Jxb4 13.'t!Jd4 c5 14.'t!Jxg7 't!Jxb2 1 5.'t!Jxb2 .!tJxb2 gave Black the advantage, Epishin - Bellon, Malaga 2000) 9.. ..ic6 (9 0-0 IO ..!tJt2) 10.0-0 Axd2 l l.'t!lxd2 't!Jxe5 12.&cl 0-0 13 ..!tJf4, Gutman; further m 5 ...'t!Je1, Harding, 6.Ag2 (6..!tJf3 't!Jc5 7.e3 .!tJc6 8.a3 Axd2+ 9 .Axd2 .!tJxd2 I 0. 't!Jxd2 .!tJxe5 or 6.a3 bd2+ 7.Axd2 't!Jxe5 8.i.g2 .!tJxd2 9.'t!Jxd2 d6! ? I O . .!tJf3 't!Je7 l l .ltJd4 .!tJd7 1 2.0-0 0-0 are innocuous) 6...'t!Jxe5 (6...ltJxd2 7.i.xd2 hd2+ 8.'t!Jxd2 't!Jxe5 9. .!tJf3 't!Je7 I O . .!tJd4 d6 l l ..!tJb5!? 0-0 1 2.0-0 maintains an edge for White) 7..!tJf3 .lxd2+ (7 't!Jf6 8.0-0 .!tJxd2 9..!tJxd2 Ae7 I O..!tJe4 't!Je6 l l .b3 d6 1 2 . .!tJc3 c6 13.i.b2 was played in Lupez - Maxxx, .•
.•
1 23
internet 2002, while 7 ...�c5 8.0-0 ltlxd2 9.ltlxd2 .ixd2 I O.hd2 �xc4 ) J .gc) !?, Harding, l l...�xa2 1 2..ic3 f6 13...id 5 �a6 14.m,3 is worse) 8.�xd2! (8.ltlxd2 ltlxd2 9.�xd2 0-0, Harding) 8...�e7 9. �e3 ltlc6 IO.ltld4, Gutman; similarly III) 5 ... d5 6.ltg2 (for 6.exd6 see 5 ...d6 6.exd6 - IV) 6 ... 0-0 7 .ltlf3 (7 .a3 .ixd2+ 8..ixd2 ltlxd2 9.�xd2 dxc4 IO.�xd8 �d8 1 1 ..&1 c6 121b.c4 .ie6 13ikl ltld7 14.f4 ltlb6 1 5.ltlf3 h6 1 6.'�t2 ltla4 1 7.b4 ltlb2 1 8.ltlh4 a5 19.f5 .ib3 20.b5 ltldl+ 2 1 .'i!?el cxb5 looks OK for Black) 7 ...dxc4 8.0-0 ltlxd2 9bd2 .ixd2 IO.ltlxd2!? (I O.�xd2 �e7 l l .&cl ltl'c6 12.�f4 ltla5 1 3.gfdl gb8) I O ...�d4 l l .e6!? ( J J .gc) �xe5 12. ltlxc4 �e7 13.m,3 c6 14lUdl is less pro mising in view of J4_ltld7 151Y:12 ltlb6· however, Black should avoid 14 ...�xe2 15 .ge) �g4 16.ltld6 �d7 J7.gcdl �c7 1 8.ltle8 �a5 1 9 lk7 ltla6 20.ltld6 ltlc5 2 l .�e3 � d8 22_ge5 ltle6 23...ih 3 as well as 14�..ie6 15.�e3 ltla6 1 6.a3 h6 1 7.b4 gfe8 18.ltla5 ltlc7 19.ltlxb7 ltld5 20.hd5 .ixd5 2 1 .�xe7 �e7 22.ltla5 gxe2 23.b5 .if3 24.bxc6 ge5 25 .gd3, Thorstein Olafsson, Iceland Ch 1988) l l ... fxe6 1 2.�c2 c3 13.bxc3 �ffi 14JMbl appears good for White, Gutman; IV) 5 ...d6!? is more potent, 6..ig2 (6.exd6 �xd6 gives Black unexpected resources: 7 ..ig2 �d4 8.e3 �xc4 and if7.ltlf3, then not 7 ...0-0 8..ig2 gd8 9.a3, when both 9... � IO.�O .ixd2 l l .ltlxd2 ltlxd2 12.hd2 �x b2? 1 3 ..ic3 and 9 .. ..ic5 I 0.0-0 .ig4, Frunliuk NqNSiil, l l.m,3 /()xd2 12..ixd2 favours White, but 7 ...m,6!? 8.e3 �f6 9..ig2 .ixd2+ I O..ixd2 �xb2) 6 .. .bd2+ (6�..if5 7.ltlf3 dxe5 is met by 8.ltlh4, e.g. 8...ltlxd2? 9.�a4+ or S...�ffi 9.ltlxf5 �xf5 IO.�O .ixd2 l l .�c2! .ixcl 1 2.he4 �c8 13.&xcl ) 7..ixd2 ltlxd2 8.exd6 (8.�xd2 dxe5 9.�xd8+ 'i!?xd8 IO.ltlf3 ffi) 8 ... ltlxc4 9.�a4+ c6 I O.�xc4 �xd6 with equality, Gutman.
6.�13
White has two more possibilities: I) 6.f4 d6! ( 6...d5 7.a3 .ixd2+ S..ixd2 dxc4 9..ie3 .ie6 IO.�c2 f5 I I Edt �e7 12..ig2 ltlc5 13.ltlh3 with advantage for White, while 13...id 5?, Wiedemann - Leisebein, corr 1989, runs into 13 ...ltld3+) 7.exd6 �xd6 8 ..ig2 �d4 9..ixe4 �xe4 I O.ltlf3 �e3 l l .�c2 ( l l .a3 .ic5 12 _gf) .ih3 13. ltlb3 �e7, TartJikower) l l ....ig4 12.gfl 0-0-0 13.a3 ghe8 gave Black a winning attack, Pemeder - Post, Berlin 1934; ll) 6..ig2 with a further split: A) 6 ... ltlc5 7.ltlf3 �e7 8.a3 (8.0-0 0-0 9.a3 .ixd2 IO..ixd2 ltlxe5 l l .ltlxe5 �xe5 12..if4 �xb2 1 3 .hc7 ge8 1 4.e3 is not bad either) 8 .. .hd2+ 9 ..ixd2 ltlxe5 (9. . ltle4 IO..ie3 ltlxe5 l l .ltlxe5 �xe5 12.i.d4) IO.ltlxe5 �xe5 l l ..ic3 �g5 1 2.h4 �g4 (12 ...�6 1 3.b4 ltle6 14.�d2, Nepustil) 13.�d5 (instead of 13...ih 3 �xc4 14..ixg7 gg8 1 5 .gcl �e4 16.f3 �e7, Nepustil) 13 ...ltle6 ( 1 3 ...d6 1 4 ..if3 �g6 1 5 ..ih5) 14.h5 c6 15� cxd5 16.hg4 d4 17..id2 h6 J 8_gd) with a plus for White, Gutman; B) 6 ...ltlxd2 7bd2 .ixd2+ (7 ...�e7 goes after 8.ltlf3 ltlxe5 9.ltlxe5 .ixd2+ I O.�xd2 �xe5 into the main line, yet White has an extra resource in the form of8.f4!?. Larsen - Romero, Mesa 1992, went 8 ... g5 9.bb4 �xb4+ IO.�d2 �xc4 l l .gc) �xa2 12.10f3 g4 13.ltlg5 �a5 14.�xa5 .
1 24
lflxa5 1 5id5 f6 1 6.exffi c6 17 ie4 d5 1 8.J.xh7 gxh7 19 . .!flxh7 � 20.e4 dxe4 2 1 .gc5 o!flb3 22.gg5 .lB 23 .gxf5 'it>g6 24_gg5+ �7 25.h3 I :0, and also 8 .. .J.c5 9.e3 0.0 I O.a3 a5 l l .o!fle2 d6 1 2.exd6 cxd6 13 .�3 is hardly viable for Black, e.g. 13 ...ge8 14.0-0 .lxe3+ 1Hhe3 �xe3+ 16.J.xe3 fue3 17.o!flc3 .le6 18.gfdl hc4 19.&d6 or 1 3..�4 14.�d3 gfe8 15.o!flc3 .lxe3 1 6.he3 �xe3+ 17 .�xe3 gxe3+ 1 8.'it>d2 gae8 19 .ghe I ) 8.�xd2 lflxe5
1 0.gc1 �e7 l l ..lg2 0-0-0 1 2.�a4 'it>b8 13.0-0 .ld7 14.�3 .le6 15.J.e3 .lc8 16. .lc5 b6 17 .J.xd6 gxd6 1 8.c5 gffj 19.cxb6 cxb6 20.�a4 .lb7 21 .e3, Carneiro - Cary, Portugal 1 994) IO.J.e3 �ffi I I � (this is safer than 1 1 .�3 0-0-0 1 2ig2 g5 13.0-0 h5 14.&dl h4 1 5.lfld2 lflxd2 J6_gxd2 fud2 17..ixd2 &8) l l ...o!flxd4 (if l l ...�h6 1 2.lflh4) 1 2.�xd4 and l prefer White, Gutman; m 7 ...�xd6 8.a3 (8..lg2 .lg4!, e.g. 9.0-0 0-0-0 I O.c 5, Schmitz - Goy, Cologne 1 993, IO ... �e6! winn ing, or 9.a3 .lxf3 I OJ.xf3 �d4 l l .e3 hd2+ 12..ixd2 �xc4 J3_gcJ �d5 14.�c2 f5 1 5..ic3 0.0 16.0-0 �e6. But, 8 ..if5, treated in I, and 8 ... .le6 9.a3 .ixd2+ I O.lflxd2 lflxd2 I I . �xd2 o!fld4 12.�c3 0-0-0 13 ..le3 .lg4 14.h3, Waltz) - Kunerth, corr 1942, are less impressive) 8 ... �c5 9.e3 .ixd2+ I O.lflxd2 represents a critical position.
(R recapturing the pawn but conceding an edge in space and development, H111' ding) 9.gcl (if 9.�c3, then not 9 ... �e7?
1 O.f4 .!flg6 t t .�xg7 �b4+ t 2.'it>fl grs 13.lflf3 I :0 Nikolac - Boehmfeldt, Dort mund 1 979, but 9 ...�f6 I O ..!flh3 .!flg4!? l l .�d2 0-0 12.0-0 d6 1 3.lflf4, Burma kin - Gutdeutsch, Velden 1 995, 13 ..�h6 1 4.h3 lflf6 t 5 .gadl ge8) 9 ... 0-0 I O.f4 (IO.c5 �e7 l l .o!flf3 gd8 12.0-0 d6) 1 0... o!flc6 l l .e4 d6 12.lfle2 f5!? (Petl!rSchilf farth ; IL�ffi 13.o!flc3 i.e6 14.lfld5 �d8 t5.0-0 a5 t 6.h4 ffi t7.'it>h2 gn 18.gfdt �f8 1 9.b3 ge8 20.a3 gd7 2 1.�c3 �f7 22_gd2 &8 23.gcdl gdd8 24.J.f3 gave White some pressure, Epishin- Schaf farth, Bad Woerishofen 1998, though one could also play 16.f5 hd5 1 7.exd5 .!fle5 1 8.f6 &8 19.fxg7 �xg7 20..ie4) 13.exf5 ( 1 3 .0-0 fxe4 14..ixe4 �ffi) 1 3 .. .hf5 14. 0-0 (1 4.c5 dxc5 1 5 .�xd8 o!flxd8 16.�c5 c6) 1 4 ...�f6 appears even, Gutman.
•
6 Yfe7 •••
6 ... d6!? 7.exd6, popular a number of years ago, is less fashionable nowadays. There are two major variations: I) 7 .. if5 8.a3 (less appealing is 8.J.g2 �xd6, e.g. 9.a3 .ixd2+ IO.hd2 lflxd2 l l.�xd2 �xd2+ 12.�d2 Q..().()+ 13.1t>c3 mJe8 14.lflh4id7 or 9.o!flh4 lflxd2 IO..bd2 ()..().() l l.lflxf5 .lxd2+ 12.'it>fl �e6 13.J.xc6 �xf5 14if3 h5) 8 ....ixd2+ (8 ..ixd6 9. lflxe4 .lxe4 IO..lg5!? �d7 I I ig2 �e6 12.0-0 0.0 13.Eci)9.J.xd2 �xd6 (9...lflxd6
We have to consider two continuations: A) IO ...lflxd2 l l ..ixd2 .le6 ( l l ...lfle5 is
doubtful owing to 12ib4 �c6 13.�d5 .!flO+ 14.';t.e2 �xd5 1 5.cxd5 .lg4 16.J.g2, but also 12ic3 is not easy to meet, e.g. 12....ig4 t3.J.e2.lxe2 14.�xe2 �c6 1 5.e4 lflxc4 16..ixg7 gg8 17ic3 0-0-0 18 .0-0, Kort - Hoogendoom, Holland 1 995, or 12 ....le6 1 3.lxe5 �xe5 14.�d4 �xd4 1 5.exd4 � 16.0-0-0 .lg4 17 _gd2 l:nle8 1 8 ..lg2), then:
1 25
At) 1 2..ic3 gds! (for 12 . ..ltJeS see I I ... tOeS 12 ..ic3 .ie6, and 12 ...0-0 allows 1 3 .b4 'tYf5 1 4..id3 'Ma3 I S .Wn) 13.'t¥b3 0.0 14.'t¥bS Wd6 IS�2 (IS.Wxb7 .ig4 or I S.'tYhS g6! 16.Wf3 tOeS 17 .Wf6 .ig4) I S ... .th3 16.gd 1 We6, Gutman; further Al) 12.'tYc2 � ( l 2.. .id5? l 3.b4 l0d4 14.Wc3! LOn+ IS.'it>dl 'tYd6 1 6.cxdS and White wins, while 14.Wa4+ bS l S.cxdS WxdS 16 .J.xbS+ lOxbS 17.0-0, given by Alexantkr Alekhine, is refuted by 1 4 ... Wc6!? I S.Wxc6+ .ixc6 1 6.exd4 .ixh l . 1 2 ...J.f5 is too flashy since 1 3J.d3 .ixd3 14.'tYxd3 lOeS I S.'tYe4 � 16.ib4 l0d3+ 17 .Wxd3 Wxb4+ I S.axb4 gxd3 19.gxa7 is excellent for White: 19 ... 'it>bS 20.&3 flli dS 2 l .�d3 gxd3 22.'it>e2 gb3 231tb 1 gxb4 24.b3, Anatoli Matsukevich, or 1 9.. .IDtdS 20.&S+'it>d7 2l l:txdS+ 'it>xdS 22.'it>e2 1Th3 23.gdl+ 'it>e7 24.gd2 gxb4 2S.'it>d3 � 26.'it>d4, N ajdorf- Czerniak, Buenos Aires 1 939) 1 3 ..ie2 ( l 3.b4 'MIS 14.J.e2 'Ma3) 1 3 ...lOeS 1 4..ic3 (14.0-0-0 l0xc4 IS..ixc4 .ixc4 16.ic3 f6 17 l:txdS+ gxdS I S.gdl gxd l+ 1 9.Wxdl 'tYf5 20.n 'Ma3, Mandelbaum - Bisguier, Helsinki Olympiad 19S2) J4 _f6 I S.J.xeS ( I S.O-O Wc6) lS ...'tYxeS 16.0-0 .its 1 7.Wc l ih3 yields Black the initiative, Gutman; AJ) 12.'tYa4!? 0-0-0 13..ic3 mteS 14 ..ie2 (White does best to delay 14..ixg7 .ig4 l S .'tYc2 ge6!, e.g. 1 6.Wc3 .in or 16..ig2 f6 1 7 .ih6 li:Jd4. 14.'t¥bS may be met by 14 ...'tYd6, for example IS�2 !h3 1 6..§dl We6 or I S ..ig2 'tYd3 !? 1 6..ixc6 bxc6 17. Wxc6 .ixc4 I S.WaS+ 'it>d7 1 9.Wn .idS 20.Wg4+ f5 2 1 .gdl fxg4 22.gxd3 'it>e6 23 .0-0 .in 24.gxdS fudS 2 S.J.xg7 gdl 26.gxd·J .ixdl 27.'it>fl 'it>dS 2S.'it>ei .in 29.'it>d2 'it>c4 with a draw) 1 4. . .J.h3 I S . 'tYbS (I S..ixg7? 'tYf5 16.'t¥bS We4 1 7.ggl .ig4 I S ..ixg4 Wxg4 1 9 ..ic3 gd7 2 0.cS gedS 2 1 .'tYe2 WfS) IS ...We7 ( I S ...'tYxbS 16.cxbS lOeS,MIItSUkevich, 17