matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 1
BRITTLE MATRIX COMPOSITES 9
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 2
Proceedings of the Ninth International Symposium on Brittle Matrix Composites BMC9, held in Staszic Palace, Warsaw, Poland, 25-28 October 2009
Also published previously: Brittle Matrix Composites 1 Proceedings of the 1st International Symposium and EUROMECH Colloquium 204, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1985 Brittle Matrix Composites 2 Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1988 Brittle Matrix Composites 3 Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1991 Brittle Matrix Composites 4 Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium, Woodhead Publ. Ltd. (Cambridge) and Inst. of Economic Education (Warsaw), 1994 Brittle Matrix Composites 5 Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium, Woodhead Publ. Ltd. (Cambridge) and BIGRAF (Warsaw), 1997 Brittle Matrix Composites 6 Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium, Woodhead Publ. Ltd. (Cambridge) and BIGRAF (Warsaw), 2000 Brittle Matrix Composites 7 Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium, Woodhead Publ. Ltd. (Cambridge) and ZTUREK Research-Scientific Institute (Warsaw), 2003 Brittle Matrix Composites 8 Proceedings of the 8th International Symposium, Woodhead Publ. Ltd. (Cambridge) and ZTUREK Research-Scientific Institute (Warsaw), 2006
II
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 3
INSTITUTE OF FUNDAMENTAL TECHNOLOGICAL RESEARCH POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
BRITTLE MATRIX COMPOSITES 9 Edited by
A.M. BRANDT Institute of Fundamental Technological Research Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw, Poland
J. OLEK Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Purdue University, West Lafayette, USA
I.H. MARSHALL Monash University, Melbourne, Australia
Woodhead Publishing Ltd., Cambridge, and Institute of Fundamental Technological Research Warsaw 2009
III
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 4
© 2009 Institute of Fundamental Technological Research, Warsaw WOODHEAD PUBLISHING LIMITED Abington Hall, Abington, Cambridge, England INSTITUTE OF FUNDAMENTAL TECHNOLOGICAL RESEARCH Warsaw, Poland
ISBN 978-83-89687-48-7 ISBN 978-1-84569-775-4
Conditions of sale: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
The selection and presentation of material and the opinion expressed in this publication are the sole responsibility of the authors concerned.
No responsibility is assumed by the Publishers for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any method, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein.
Produced by:
ZTUREK Research-Scientific Institute 00-950 Warsaw 1, P.O. Box 674 http://www.zturek.pl,
[email protected]
IV
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 5
PREFACE These Proceedings include a collection of papers presented during the 9th international symposium on Brittle Matrix Composites (BMC-9), which was held October 25-28, 2009 in Warsaw, Poland. The series of BMC Symposia started as the EUROMECH 204 Colloquium on Brittle Matrix Composites, which was held in Jablonna, Poland in November 1985. This meeting was later renamed BMC 1. Three years later (September 1988), the Second Symposium (BMC 2) was organized in Cedzyna, also in Poland. This was followed by a series of triennial Symposia, each held in Staszic Palace in Warsaw, Poland. In each case, the Institute of Fundamental Technological Research (IFTR) of the Polish Academy of Sciences served as the host. From the 1985 BMC 1 to the present BMC 9, these Symposia have served both as effective forums for dissemination of knowledge and as catalysts for innovation. They have undoubtedly contributed to international scientific collaboration, both on institutional and personal levels. The objective of this series of symposia is to bring together researchers in the broad field of different composites that behave (or may behave under certain conditions) like brittle materials. It covers materials with cement, ceramic and polymer matrixes. While their intended applications can be quite different, these composites share many similar characteristics. Some examples illustrating the positive impact of one field on another include the mechanics of fiber/matrix debonding, fiber bridging behavior, application of non-conventional components, and multiple cracking processes. The BMC Symposia provide a forum which encourages and enhances crossdisciplinary collaboration and exchange of knowledge. Since the beginning, the BMC Symposia have created an environment where researchers from many countries of the world gather once every three years to share their latest research findings and to learn first-hand about the developments in composite research in various regions of the world. Brittle matrix composites are used in various fields (civil engineering, mechanical equipment and machinery, vehicles, etc.). In the last decades, their importance and diversity amongst engineered materials has continuously increased. Examples of materials covered in the accepted papers include the following: x aggregate-binder composites (concretes, fiber concretes, polymer concretes), x sintered materials (ceramics), and x other composites with brittle matrices. Various approaches to material engineering problems are presented in the papers, including: x mechanical properties, strength, toughness and rheology, x analysis of materials structure and microstructure, x various degradation effects, crack propagation and control, x test methods and new test results, x computation methods and manufacturing processes, x durability assessment of materials and structures, and x applications of new materials and their behavior in structures.
V
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 6
The present volume of the BMC 9 Proceedings should prove useful to experienced researchers and to students entering this field as a helpful reference. The included papers have been selected on the basis of a two-stage peer review process. The volume contains 45 papers prepared by 116 authors from 22 countries. To a great extent this set of papers represents the latest advancements in the field of Brittle Matrix Composites, including works on applications of different kinds of fibers in cement matrix, various test techniques used for evaluation of concrete and ceramics, durability and repair of structures, analytical methods and other new problems in composites. In 2008 we lost two of our eminent colleagues who were involved in the organization of BMC Symposia since the beginning. Professor Janusz Kasperkiewicz (Poland) died in May and Professor Ian H. Marshall (Scotland, UK) passed away in November. They participated actively in the creation of both intellectual and organizational frameworks for this series of Symposia. We feel their absence very deeply. Particular thanks are due to the authors of the articles in this volume for their readiness to present the results of their outstanding investigations in the form of original contributions. Grateful thanks are extended to members of the International Advisory Board for their significant help in reviewing the papers and in solving problems encountered during the organizational stages. The efforts and creative attitude of the local Organizing Committee during preparations for this event is highly appreciated. Without their dedicated work it would not have been possible to publish this volume before the Symposium date. The support from the Institute of Fundamental Technological Research of the Polish Academy of Sciences was essential for organization of this Symposium, as well as previous Symposia. The scientific sponsorship of RILEM is acknowledged with gratitude. We sincerely hope that this volume, along with the eight previously published in this series, will contribute to the development of science and technology in the field of composite materials.
A.M. Brandt J. Olek I.H. Marshall
VI
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 7
INTERNATIONAL ADVISORY PANEL Prof. R. Al-Mahaidi, Melbourne (Australia) Prof. A. Bentur, Haifa (Israel) Prof. J.J. Biernacki, Tennessee (USA) Prof. J. Kasperkiewicz, Warsaw (Poland) D.A. Lange, Urbana-Champaign (USA) S. Mindess, Vancouver (Canada) Z. Mróz, Warsaw (Poland) Y. Ohama, Koriyama (Japan) H.W. Reinhardt, Stuttgart (Germany) S.P. Shah, Evanston (USA) H. Stang, Lyngby (Denmark) P. Stroeven, Delft (The Netherlands) R.N. Swamy, Sheffield (UK) A. Vautrin, St. Etienne (France)
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
Prof. J. Kasperkiewicz Prof. M.A. Glinicki Mrs. A. Gutweter Dr. D. JóĨwiak-NiedĨwiedzka Prof. M. Marks Mr. M. Sobczak Mrs. J. Tymkiewicz
VII
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 8
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 9
Table of contents Preface
KEYNOTE PAPER Retrofit of shear strength deficient RC beams with sprayed GFRP Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS, Canada …...………..1 Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER, France ……………………………………………………………11 Round panel vs. beam tests toward a comprehensive and harmonic characterization of FRC materials Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI, Italy …………………………………...23 The influence of steel fibres content and curing conditions on mechanical properties and deformability of reactive powder concrete at bending Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ĝLIWIēSKI, Poland …………………………………...……33 Interface bond characteristics between wood fibres and a cement matrix Mercedes G. SIERRA BELTRAN and Erik SCHLANGEN, The Netherlands ……...…43 Shear strength and ductility of beams reinforced with synthetic macro-fibers Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER, UAE,USA, Germany ……………………………….......53 The impact of amount and length of fibrillated polypropylene fibres on the properties of HPC exposed to high temperature Izabela HAGER and Tomasz TRACZ, Poland …………………………………………63 Assessment by law of mixtures approach of interfacial adhesion strength in cellulose-cement composites Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI, Brazil, The Netherlands ……………………………………71 Tensile fatigue response of Sisal Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO, Brazil, USA ……………………………………..…81 Investigation on the strength and flexural toughness of hybrid fibre reinforced concrete Surinder Pal SINGH, India …………………………………………………………...…91
IX
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 10
Textile reinforced concrete - durability issues: changes of the bond and tensile strength due to ageing Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH, Germany ………...101 Impact study of textile reinforced cementitious materials: test method and preliminary results Johan Van ACKEREN, J. BLOM, D. KAKOGIANNIS, J. WASTIELS, D. Van HEMELRIJCK, S. PALANIVELU, W. Van PAEPEGEM, J. DEGRIECK and J. VANTOMME, Belgium ……………………………………...…111 The ductile behavior of HPFRCC in compression Alessandro P. FANTILLI, Hirozo MIHASHI, Paolo VALLINI and Bernardino CHIAIA, Italy, Japan …………………………………………………121 Investigation of random distribution of fibres in cement composites Tomasz PONIKIEWSKI, Poland ………………………………………………………131 Permeability of SFRCC based on fine aggregate after pre-load cycles Jacek KATZER, Poland ………………………………………………………………..139 KEYNOTE PAPER Statistical optimization of low slump ternary concrete mixtures with ground granulated blast furnace slag (GGBS) and high calcium fly ash for pavement applications Adam RUDY, Jan OLEK, Tommy NANTUNG and Richard M. NEWELL, USA ……149 Durability performance of Roller Compacted Concrete using fly ash Jong-Pil WON, Chang-Il JANG, Sang-Woo LEE and Wan-Young KIM Republic of Korea …………………………………………………………………...…161 Structure and properties of NaOH activated cement free binder (CFB) concretes Deepak RAVIKUMAR, Sulapha PEETHAMPARAN and Narayanan NEITHALATH, USA …………………………………………………169 Model of concrete carbonation as limitable process – experimental investigations of fluidal ash concrete Lech CZARNECKI and Piotr WOYCIECHOWSKI, Poland …………………………183 Modification of mineral binding matrixes carbon nanostructures Grigory I. YAKOVLEV, Grigory N. PERVUSHIN, Jadviga. KERIENE, Hans-Bertram FISCHER and Bernd MÖSER B., Russia, Lithuania, Germany ……….195 Mechanical-acoustic and structural study of degradation processes in corundum ceramics and aluminous porcelain Przemysáaw RANACHOWSKI, Zbigniew RANACHOWSKI and Feliks REJMUND, Poland ………………………………………………………...201
X
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 11
Descriptive microstructure and fracture surface observations of fired volcanic ash C. LEONELLI, E. KAMSEU, U.C. MELO, A. CORRADI, and G.C. PELLACANI, Italy, Cameroon ……………………………………………...215 Dehydration, dehydroxylation, densification and deformation during sintering of geopolymers based on the K2O-Al2O3-SiO2 system E. KAMSEU, A. RIZZUTI, C. LEONELLI and D. PERERA, Italy, Australia ……….217 Multicriterial optimization of autoclaved aerated concrete properties and expenditure of energy resources Tatiana V. LYASHENKO, Vitaly A. VOZNESENSKY and Varvara P. GAVRILIUK, Ukraine ………………………………………………...219 Application of machine learning for prediction of concrete resistance to migration of chlorides Maria MARKS, Daria JÓĩWIAK-NIEDħWIEDZKA and MICHAà A. GLINICKI, Poland ………………………………………………….227 Carbon spheres as possible micro-reinforcement of cement-based composites Jan M. SKOWROēSKI and Agnieszka ĝLOSARCZYK, Poland ………………….…237 Properties of fiber reinforced cement composites with cenospheres from coal ash Waldemar PICHÓR, Poland …………………………………………………………..245 How to get reliable 3D information on concrete porosity? Piet STROEVEN, The Netherlands ……………………………………………………255 Analysis of the influence of the type, amount and way of introduction of anti-foaming admixture (AFA) on the properties of self-compacting concrete mix Beata àAħNIEWSKA-PIEKARCZYK, Poland ………………………………………265 Predicting the elastic moduli of enhanced porosity (pervious) concretes using reconstructed 3D material structures Milani S. SUMANASOORIYA, Omkar DEO and Narayanan NEITHALATH, USA ...275 KEYNOTE PAPER Enhanced durability of concrete by superabsorbent polymers Hans W. REINHARDT and Alexander ASSMANN, Germany ……………………….291 Volumetric stability of concrete using recycled concrete aggregates Yogini DESHPANDE, Jacob E. HILLER and Cory J. SHORKEY, USA ……………..301 Damage assessment in sections for durability purposes: two arguments not to opt for automation Piet STROEVEN, Huan HE and Martijn STROEVEN, The Netherlands ……………..313 The effects of laser cleaning process on geometrical microstructure of cementitious composites Agnieszka KLEMM, Poologanathan SANJEEVAN and Piotr KLEMM, UK, Poland ..323 XI
matrix2009.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 12
Assessing the repeatability of the restrained ring test Aleksandra RADLINSKA and Jason WEISS, USA …………………………………...335 Performance evaluation of rapid-setting materials for concrete pavements/bridge decks repair: laboratory and field perspectives Prashant V. RAM and Jan OLEK, USA ……………………………………………….347 The effect of temperature on the rheological properties of self - compacting concrete Jacek GOàASZEWSKI and Grzegorz CYGAN, Poland …………………………..….359 Assessment of the rheological properties of cement mixes using electrical resistance Dominik LOGOē, Poland …………………………………………………………….369 Experimental techniques for multi-scale characterization of mechanical response in cement-based materials Joseph J. BIERNACKI, USA …………………………………………………………..379 Influence of hydrothermal curing on microstructure and mechanical properties of ultra-high performance concrete Patrick FONTANA, Christian LEHMANN and Urs MÜLLER, Germany ……………391 Patches in concrete: recent experimental discovery of a natural phenomenon - supporting evidence by DEM Piet STROEVEN and Huan HE, The Netherlands ……………………………………..399 Relationships between fractal dimension and the mechanical and structural parameters of basalt aggregate concretes Janusz KONKOL and Grzegorz PROKOPSKI, Poland ……………………………….409 T-stress values during fracture in wedge splitting test geometries: A numerical study Stanislav SEITL, Pavel HUTAě, Václav VESELÝ and ZbynČk KERŠNER, Czech Republic ………………………………………………419 The influence of aggregate size on the width of fracture process zone in concrete members Marta SàOWIK and Ewa BàAZIK-BOROWA, Poland ………………………………429 Effect of steel strip geometry on pull-out strength of aerated concrete Dariusz ALTERMAN, Juan VILCHES, Thomas NEITZERT and Hiroshi AKITA, Poland, New Zealand, Japan ……………………………………439
INDEX OF CONTRIBUTORS ……………………………………………..……………….…449 SUBJECT INDEX ……………………………………………………………………………...451
*
* XII
*
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 1
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
KEYNOTE PAPER
KEYNOTE PAPER RETROFIT OF SHEAR STRENGTH DEFICIENT RC BEAMS WITH SPRAYED GFRP Andrew J. BOYD1, Nemkumar BANTHIA2,Sidney MINDESS2 McGill University, Department of Civil Engineering, Montreal QC, Canada e-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Civil Engineering, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada 1
ABSTRACT Worldwide, a great deal of research is currently being conducted concerning the use of fibre reinforced plastic wraps or laminates in the repair and strengthening of reinforced concrete members. Such techniques can be both effective and economical when compared to the existing practice of retrofitting with steel plates. A novel technique which further simplifies the application procedure is to apply the fibre using a spraying process. By spraying the fibres onto the member surface concurrently with a suitable matrix resin a two dimensional random distribution of discontinuous fibres is obtained, resulting in an FRP plate that exhibits isotropic in-plane behaviour. This work reports the application of a sprayed glass fibre reinforced plastic (GFRP) retrofit system on reinforced concrete beams. Using E-glass fibres embedded in a polyester matrix, a sprayed FRP system was used to strengthen beams intentionally designed to be deficient in shear capacity. This approach was shown to be capable of significantly increasing both the strength and stiffness of such concrete beams, while at the same time dramatically improving their energy absorption characteristics. When compared with fabric wrapped specimens, and with published literature on similar specimens retrofitted with either fabric or laminates, the sprayed GFRP material proved to be capable of producing results equivalent or better than any of the other techniques. The sprayed FRP approach also tended to improve the bond between the FRP and concrete surface, thus providing resistance to the primary mode of failure exhibited in FRP retrofit systems; failure at the bond line.
Keywords Glass fibre reinforced plastics (GFRP), retrofitting RC beams, sprayed FRP
INTRODUCTION One of the largest problems facing the construction industry today is the maintenance, repair and strengthening required by a large proportion of our transportation infrastructure. Throughout the world, transportation agencies are constantly faced with the need to repair and maintain deteriorating structures, a task which is made even more difficult by shrinking resources, budgets and manpower [1-3]. Many countries are also in the process of upgrading existing structures that are now considered inadequate due to building code revisions or changes to their original purpose (such as the need to carry heavier loads or higher traffic volumes) [2,4-11]. For example, nearly half of all bridges in the U.S.A. are currently considered to be structurally deficient [3,5]. Some form of external reinforcement is needed to repair and strengthen these deficient structures.
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
2
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 2
Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS
In recent years, a great deal of research has been conducted into the use of fibre reinforced plastics (FRPs) in place of steel plates for such strengthening procedures. Such reinforcement is usually performed using FRP fabrics or plates adhesively bonded to the structure [12-17]. There are a number of significant advantages to the use of FRP laminates to replace steel as external reinforcement, including excellent corrosion resistance, excellent fatigue resistance, low density coupled with very high stiffness and strength and a very low coefficient of thermal expansion in the fibre orientation [1,3,7,9,10,12,13,18-20]. The higher costs associated with these FRP materials is often offset by savings in labour when compared to the difficulty of steel plate jacketing [3,12,13]. Banthia et a1 [21] investigated the effectiveness of using a sprayed fibre reinforced plastic in the external strengthening of plain concrete beams. By spraying the fibres onto the member surface concurrently with a suitable matrix resin, a two dimensional random distribution of fibres was obtained. Using E-glass fibres embedded in a matrix consisting of a polyurethane/polyester blend, it was shown that significant increases in load carrying capacity, fracture toughness and fracture energy can be achieved with such a system. Comparisons of the obtained results for confined cylinders with those available from current literature showed that the sprayed glass FRP technique can produce more effective confinement than either carbon or ararnid FRP wrappings [22]. This paper discusses an investigation into the usage of a sprayed glass fibre reinforced plastic (GFRP) retrofit system on small-scale reinforced concrete beams.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM Existing RC beams can be deficient in shear strength for several reasons, including shear deficient design procedures in older codes, increased service loads on the structure and corrosion of the shear stirrups (which are typically placed outside the flexural reinforcement and are thus protected by less cover concrete) [23-26]. The primary objective of this investigation was to determine whether such a reinforcing system would be effective for retrofitting members exhibiting a shear failure mode. To this end, a series of 22 reinforced concrete beams was cast, with each beam measuring 96 mm wide x 125 mm high x 1.0 m long. The longitudinal flexural reinforcement was over-designed in these members and shear reinforcement was intentionally omitted in order to induce a shear failure under third point loading. After a 28-day immersion curing period, the beams were separated into three groups: the control specimens, specimens to be damaged and later repaired with GFRP, and undamaged specimens to be strengthened with GFRP. Damaging, in this case, consisted of subjecting the specimens to third point loading until the first visible shear crack appeared. This corresponded to a centre point deflection of L/180 (5 mm). Following this preloading stage, the surfaces of both the damaged and undamaged specimens were sandblasted in an attempt to optimize the GFRP-concrete bond. The GFRP material (ıult = 28 MPa, E = 4.0 GPa, Vf § 8 %) was applied in a coating 6 mm thick. Four different retrofit schemes were investigated, as depicted in Figure 1, resulting in a total of nine different specimen groups. Figure 2 illustrates the spraying operation.
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 3
Retrofit of shear strength deficient RC beams with sprayed GFRP
3
Figure 1: GFRP retrofit schemes
Figure 2: Photograph of sprayed GFRP application process All of the retrofitted beams, as well as the control specimens, were tested to failure under third point loading. During testing, the applied load and the deflection at rnidspan were monitored and recorded. Two additional LVDTs were added over the supports to account for settlement at the supports and crushing during loading. Load vs. corrected deflection curves were plotted for all specimens, where the corrected deflection was taken to be the deflection at mid-span less the average rigid body settlement in the testing apparatus. From these data, values for peak load and fracture energy absorbed up to peak load were determined. Also noted during testing was the failure mode exhibited by each specimen.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Retrofitting the beams with the sprayed GFRP coating actually succeeded in changing the failure modes exhibited by the specimens. The resulting failure modes varied, depending upon the particular retrofit scheme used. The control specimens, as expected, exhibited a characteristic shear failure mode (Figure 3). The specimens coated on the sides only (Scheme A) or on the sides and the top (Scheme B) failed due to rebar debonding in the shear span, as shown in Figure 4.
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
4
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 4
Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS
Figure 3: Shear failure in control specimens (side of beam)
Figure 4: Rebar bond failure in Scheme A and B specimens (bottom of beam)
Figure 5: Typical rebar bond/shear in Scheme C specimens (top of beam)
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 5
Retrofit of shear strength deficient RC beams with sprayed GFRP
5
Figure 6: Typical flexural failure in Scheme D specimens (side of beam) Specimens coated on the two sides and the bottom (Scheme C) failed in a combination of rebar debonding followed later by the shear splitting shown in Figure 5. Also evident in this photo is some localized debonding of the GFRP on either side of the specimen. This debonding actually occurred during the large deflections after specimen failure and was thus not a contributing factor. Coating of all four sides actually succeeded in shifting the failure location from the end span to the centre span and the failure mode from shear to a typical flexural failure, as depicted in Figure 6. The values obtained for peak load and fracture energy are depicted graphically in Figures 7 and 8, respectively. Retrofitting the beams with Scheme A or B resulted in a significant increase in peak load over the control specimens, though there was very little difference between the two. Similarly, Schemes C and D produced an even larger increase in peak load, though again there was little difference between the groups. Though these increases in peak load are significant, the real difference in effectiveness among the four schemes is better illustrated by the energy absorbed by the members up to the peak load. As shown in Figure 8, all of the retrofit schemes resulted in large increases in fracture energy. Scheme A actually outperformed Scheme B in this case. This was due to the stiffening effect of the top plate in the Scheme B specimens, which reduced the deflection capability of the beam. This effect will be mentioned again later. Scheme C specimens, in turn, absorbed significantly more energy than those of Scheme A or B, and the beams from Scheme D far outperformed all of the other configurations. No consistent and significant difference was observed between damaged and undamaged specimens within the same scheme. It appears that the change in failure mode induced by the GFRP coating rendered the effect of the preloading shear damage insignificant. As these figures show, all of the retrofit schemes significantly increased both the peak load and the fracture energy absorbed by the specimens. Though Scheme D is by far the most effective, it is Scheme C that is of the most interest from a practical standpoint due to the inability, in most cases, to gain access to the upper surface of in situ reinforced concrete beams. The superior performance exhibited by the Scheme D specimens can be attributed to the higher degree of confinement achieved by coating all four sides of the element.
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
6
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 6
Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS
Figure 7: Peak load by retrofit scheme
Figure 8: Fracture energy by retrofit scheme Upon examining the load-deflection curves of the 22 beams, it was found that the shapes of the curves were very consistent among beams retrofitted with the same scheme. Figure 9 shows the typical behaviour, up to failure, for each of the four repair schemes. The curve representing the control specimens is exactly as expected for a shear failure. Coating beams on both sides as in Scheme A resulted in an increase in load carrying ability and deflection compared to the control specimens. The increased fracture energy for these
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 7
Retrofit of shear strength deficient RC beams with sprayed GFRP
7
specimens is a direct result of the increased load carrying ability. This is basically the same curve as for the control specimens, but extended to a higher load level.
Figure 9: Typical load-deflection curves by retrofit scheme. Considering the curve for those beams coated on both sides plus the top (Scheme B) we see that now we have a significant increase in member stiffness. This is why the Scheme B specimens exhibited inferior energy absorption values compared to those from Scheme A. Basically, these beams reached the same peak loads but underwent significantly lower deflections due to this increase in member stiffness. Beams retrofitted using Scheme C also exhibited the same increase in stiffness, though this time it was accompanied by very large increases in both load carrying ability and deflection, resulting in much high energy absorption capacity. The Scheme D beams exhibited an even more interesting phenomenon, the appearance of significant plastic deformation before reaching peak load. These were the specimens that failed in flexure in the centre span of the member. It is also apparent from this figure that the Scheme C specimens also underwent some plastic deformation. Actually, one of the Scheme C beams did fail in flexure as well. This would indicate that the GFRP thickness used was very close to the optimum thickness required to produce flexural failure even in Scheme C retrofitted members. Comparison with other retrofit schemes Tables 1 and 2 provide a comparison between the beams from this study and comparable beams in previously published literature. The values shown in the table represent the percent increases exhibited by the retrofitted members relative to their control specimens. Table 1 refers to retrofit Scheme A. Both the peak load and fracture energy increases produced by the sprayed GFRP are significantly larger than those previously reported for GFRP plate bonding. Though the thickness of the sprayed GFRP material is significantly greater than the GFRP plates used for this process, its much lower fibre content still results in a retrofit material with a lower total cost.
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
8
11:55 AM
Page 8
Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS
Table 1: Comparison with previously published results – Scheme A
Retrofit Type
Fibre Type
Peak Load Increase (%)
Fracture Energy Increase (%)
Sprayed GFRP
GlassA
23
Plate Bonding
72
300
o B
20
-9
o C
32 to 66
51 to 173
Glass (0/90 )
18
Plate Bonding
Glass (±45 )
Matrix: A Polyester/Polyurethane
B
Polyester
C
Epoxy
Examination of the increases exhibited by the Scheme C specimens (Table 2) shows that the sprayed GFRP coating can produce similar or better results even when used in a Ushaped application where the sides and bottom of the beam are coated. In this case, previous data were found not only for GFRP plate bonding but also for wrapping with fabrics composed of aramid, glass and carbon fibre. This superior behaviour is primarily due to an improved bond between the FRP and concrete when using the sprayed system. In the previously published literature most failures occurred at the bond, meaning that the FRP did not reach its full potential. The sprayed FRP, though still not able to reach its ultimate capacity except in one case, was able to shift the failure mode to the rebar bond. Table 2: Comparison with previously published results – Scheme C
Retrofit Type
Fibre Type
Peak Load Increase (%)
Fracture Energy Increase (%)
Sprayed GFRP
GlassA Glass (0/90o)B Glass (±45o)B Glass (0/90o)C Aramid (0/90o)D Glass (0/90o)D Carbon (±45o)D
160 128 to 193 131 to 179 45 83 88 125
723 513 to 1002 549 to 942 187 168 317 479
Fabric Wrapping Plate Bonding27 Fabric Wrapping28
Matrix: A Polyester/Polyurethane
B
Polyester with vinyl ester coupling agent
C
Polyester
D
Epoxy
It should be noted that the figures shown in Tables 1 and 2 for fracture energy from previously published literature are estimates. These values were not actually reported by the respective authors but were estimated from the load-deflection curves provided. Procedure comparison When viewed from an application viewpoint, it must be noted that the thickness of the sprayed FRP coating can easily be controlled during the spraying operation simply by adjusting the number of passes made. With the wrapping systems, on the other hand, an increase in thickness requires a corresponding increase in labour as successive layers of material must be added separately. Thus, not only is the spraying process itself much less labour intensive than wrapping, this labour savings increases dramatically as the required material thickness (i.e. required strength gain) increases. This benefit could potentially result
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 9
Retrofit of shear strength deficient RC beams with sprayed GFRP
9
in large savings in production costs when one considers large scale application of this material. The equipment used for spraying FRP is completely portable and thus very easily adapted to on-site applications. It requires very little support equipment; an air compressor is needed though a power supply is not. Additionally, operation of this equipment requires only a single worker and its simplicity ensures that operator training times are minimal.
CONCLUSIONS The retrofit of shear strength deficient reinforced concrete beams with sprayed GFRP appears to be a feasible method not only for improving the strength and stiffness of the section, but also for helping to produce a more ductile failure mode by increasing the member's energy absorption capability. Furthermore, its ability to produce improvements similar or better than those achieved with other FRP retrofit methods, combined with the less labour intensive application procedure, makes the sprayed GFRP process very desirable from an economic viewpoint. It is essential that more work be done to fully explore the benefits of this retrofit technology. REFERENCES 1. Chajes, M.J., Thomson, T.A., Januszka, T.F., Finch, W.W., Flexural strengthening of concrete beams using externally bonded composite materials. Construction & Building Materials 8(3), 1994, pp 191-201 2. Ehsani, M.R., Rehabilitation of the infrastructure with advanced composite materials. Repair and Rehabilitation of the Infrastructure of the Americas, NSF, Mayaguez, PR, 1994, pp 193-205 3. Meier, U., Carbon fibre-reinforced polymers: modern materials in bridge engineering. Structural Engineering Int. 1(12), 1992, pp 7-12 4. Chajes, M.J., Thomson, T.A., Tarantino, B., Reinforcement of concrete structures using externally bonded composite materials. Symp. Non-Metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, Ghent, Belgium, 1995, pp 501-508 5. Ehsani, M.R., Saadatrnanesh, H., Fiber composite plates for strengthening bridge beams. Composite Structures 15(4), 1990, pp 343-355 6. Meier, U., Winistijrfer, A., Retrofitting of structures through external bonding of CFRP sheets. Symp. Non-Metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, Ghent, Belgium, 1995, pp 466-472 7. Meier, U., Deuring, M., Meier, H., Schwegler, G., Strengthening of structures with advanced composites. Alternative Materials for the Reinforcement and Prestressing of Concrete, Blackie, Glasgow, U.K., 1993, pp 153-171 8. Nanni, A., Concrete repair with externally bonded FRP reinforcement. Concrete International 17(6), 1995, pp 22-26 9. Nanni, A., Noms, M.S., Bradford, N.M., Lateral confinement of concrete using FRP reinforcement. Symp. Fiber-Reinforced-Plastic Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, ACI SP- 138, 1993, pp 193-209 10. Norris, M.S., Nanni, A., Construction and repair of concrete members with FRP reinforcement. Construction Technology Update, National Research Council of Canada, 1993, Vol 3, pp 2-3 11. Triantafillou, T.C., Plevris, H., Strengthening of RC beams with epoxy-bonded fibercomposite materials. Materials and Structures 25, 1992, pp 201-211
01-Retrofit of shear.qxd
10
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 10
Andrew J. BOYD, Nemkumar BANTHIA and Sidney MINDESS
12. Meier, U., Deuring, M., The application of fibre composites in bridge repair. Strasse und Verkehr 77(9), 1991, pp 534-535 13. Meier, U., Kaiser, H., Strengthening of structures with CFRP laminates. Conf. Advanced Composite Materials in Civil Engineering, Las Vegas, NV, USA, 1991, pp 224-232 14. Plevris, N., Triantafillou, T.C., Time-dependent behavior of RC members strengthened with FRP laminates. Structural Engineering 120(3), 1994, pp 1016-1042.Triantafillou, T.C., Plevris, N., Post-strengthening of RC beams with epoxy-bonded fibre composite materials. Conf. Advanced Composites Materials in Civil Engineering Structures, Las Vegas, NV, U.S.A., 1991, pp 245-256 15. Meier, U., Deuring, M., Meier, H., Schwegler, G., CFRP bonded sheets. FiberReinforced-Plastic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures: Properties and Applications, A. Nanni, editor, Elsevier, New York, 1993, pp 435-434 16. Meier, U., Deuring, M., Meier, H., Schwegler, G., Strengthening of structures with CFRP laminates: research and applications in Switzerland. Conf. Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada, 1992, pp 243-251 17. Berset, J.D., Strengthening of reinforced concrete beams for shear using FRP composites. M.Sc. Thesis, Dept of Civil Eng, MIT, Cambridge, MA, U.S.A., 1992 18. Triantafillou, T.C., Plevris, N., Reliability analysis of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with CFRP laminates. Symp. Non-Metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, Ghent, Belgium, 1995, pp 576-583 19. Triantafillou, T.C., Deskovic, N., Deuring, M., Strengthening of concrete structures with prestressed fiber reinforced plastic sheets. Structural Journal 89(3), 1992, pp 235-244 20. Banthia, N., Yan, C., Nandakumar, N., Sprayed fibre reinforced plastics (FRPs) for repair of concrete structures. Conf. Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, CSCE, Montreal, QC, Canada, 1996, pp 537-545 21. Nandakumar, N., Repair and retrofit of damaged concrete structures using sprayed fibre reinforced plastics. Dept of Civil Eng, UBC, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 1996 22. Al-Sulaimani, G.J., Sharif, A., Basunbul, I.A., Baluch, M.H., Ghaleb, B.N., Shear repair for reinforced concrete by fiberglass plate bonding. Structural Journal 91(3), 1994, pp 458-464 23. Shehata, E., Morphy, R., Rizkalla, S., FRP as shear reinforcement for concrete structures. Pres. 1997 ACI Fall Convention, Atlanta, Georgia, U.S.A., Nov 9-14, 1997 24. Dorton, R.A., Development of Canadian Bridge Codes. Conf. Developments in Short and Medium Span Bridge Engineering, CSCE, Halifax, NS, Canada, 1994, pp 1-12 25. Bonneau, I., Massicotte, B., Strengthening of shear deficient reinforced concrete beams by external prestressing. Conf. Developments in Short and Medium Span Bridge Engineering, CSCE, Halifax, NS, Canada, 1994, pp 767-778 26. Boyd, A.J., Banthia, N., Comparison of sprayed GFRP and FRP wraps for retrofit of reinforced concrete beams. Dept of Civil Eng, UBC, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 1998. 27. Chajes, M.J., Januszka, T.F., Mertz, D.R., Thornson, T.A., Finch, W.W. Shear strengthening of reinforced concrete beams using externally applied composite fabrics. Structural Journal, 92(3), 1995, pp 295-303
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 11
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
STUDY ON THE FLEXURAL BEHAVIOUR OF REINFORCED FIBROUS CONCRETE BEAMS Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT, Alain SELLIER Université de Toulouse UPS –INSA; LMDC (Laboratoire Matériaux et Durabilité des Constructions), 135 avenue de Rangueil ; F- 31077 Toulouse Cedex 04, France e-mail:
[email protected]
ABSTRACT In this study, behaviour of composite concrete with conventional reinforcement (i.e., steel bars) and randomly distributed metallic fiber reinforcement, and subjected to flexural loading has been examined. The objective was to investigate the effect of adding fiber in mono and hybrid form on the flexural properties of reinforced concrete. Two types of metallic fibers were used: amorphous metallic fibers (type I fibers) characterised as high performance non-slipping fibers with large specific surface area, and carbon steel hooked-end fibers (type II fibers) characterised as slipping fibers. Four types of reinforced concretes were prepared: one control (without fibers) and three fibrous. Out of three reinforced fibrous concretes, two contained single fiber and one contained fibers in hybrid form. The total volume fraction of fibers was 0.25% (20 kg/m3) and 0.5% (40 kg/m3) for single fiber and hybrid fiber concrete respectively. Three point bending test were performed according to European standards “NF EN 14651” on beam specimens of 150 x 150 mm cross section and length of 550 mm. The experimental results showed that the presence of metallic fibers appreciably reduces the crack opening and deflection and improves moment capacity of the reinforced concrete section. Moreover, as a result of positive synergetic interaction between fibers, reinforced fibrous concrete containing fibers in hybrid form exhibited more improved response at all loading stages in comparison of reinforced fibrous concrete containing fibers of one type only. Cracking and ultimate moment capacities of the beams were also determined analytically. Analytical results were found to be in good agreement with experimental results.
Keywords Reinforced fibrous concrete beam, metallic fibers, hybridisation, moment capacity, deflection, CMOD
INTRODUCTION Among different construction materials, concrete exhibits low tensile strength and is relatively brittle material. Its mechanical behaviour is critically influenced by crack propagation. Reinforcement of concrete with randomly distributed fibers can address some concerns related to concrete brittleness and poor resistance to cracking, Banthia and Sappakittipakorn [1]. Many of the properties of fiber reinforced concrete can be used to advantage in the concrete flexural members reinforced with conventional bar reinforcement, Swamy et al. [2]. The use of steel fibers along with longitudinal steel bars improves the yielding moment, ultimate moment and post-yield behaviour. Moreover, addition of fibers reduces the immediate deflection, long-term deflection and crack width of beam, Ashour et al. [3], Vandewalle [4]. Many kinds of fibers have been used in concrete since last six decades and up till now no single fiber reinforced concrete could exhibit perfect mechanical properties. In recent years, attention has been given to the hybridization of fibers in the
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
12
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 12
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
concrete to get more enhanced response in term of mechanical properties; Banthia and Soleimani [5], Pons et al. [6], Hsie et al. [7], Ahmed and Maalej [8]. Hybridization means to mix two or more than two different fibers in a matrix. The basic purpose of using hybrid fiber is to control cracks at different size level, in different zones of concrete and different loading stages, Barragam et al. [9]. The hybridization of fibers in concrete can be done in different ways, such as by combining different lengths, diameters, geometry, modulus and tensile strengths of fibers, [8]. Most studied hybrid combinations of fibers include steelpolypropylene, steel-carbon and carbon-polypropylene. In the family of metallic fibers, there are many types of fibers according to their geometrical, mechanical and physical properties. Use of fibers from the same family in hybrid-fiber reinforced concrete is not so common. Therefore, in the present experimental study, flexural behaviour of the reinforced concrete containing two different metallic fibers in hybrid form has been investigated. The two metallic fibers used differ in their geometrical, physical and mechanical properties. The main interest of this investigation is to obtained experimental data on the flexural strength of reinforced concrete beams containing the metallic fibers in mono and hybrid forms at different loading stages. The experimental results are to be compared with analytical solution based on engineering practices in reinforced concrete calculation, in order to render fiber addition in concrete elements more attractive for practical applications.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM Material The materials used for the non-fibrous (control) and fibrous concrete mixtures consisted of CEM I 52.5 R cement, the coarse aggregates (gravels) having size range of 4 to 10 mm, and the locally available natural river sand of maximum particle size of 4 mm. The additives are two types of metallic fibers shown in Fig.1. Type I fibers, 30 mm length, 1.6 mm width and 0.03 mm thickness (Tensile strength of 1400 MPa and modulus of elasticity of 140000 MPa), are made of amorphous metal (Fe, Cr)80 (P, C, Si)20. Type II fibers, 30 mm length and 0.5 mm diameter (Tensile strength of 1200 MPa and Modulus of elasticity of 210000 MPa), are carbon steel wires that have been cut into suitable lengths and are hooked at each end. They are usually adhered together in clips of certain number of wires (Fig. 1). When these clips enter in the mix, the adhesive is dissolved and individual fibers are distributed evenly throughout the mix. A super-plasticizer was used in order to improve the fresh properties of concrete in the presence of metallic fibers. The composition of the control concrete is given in table 1.
Type I fibers
Type II fibers
Figure 1- amorphous metal fibers (on left), carbon steel fibers (on right)
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 13
13
Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams
Concrete Compositions A total of four reinforced concretes: one control (without fibers) and three containing fibers were investigated. Among the three reinforced fibrous concretes, two contained single fiber and one contained fibers in hybrid form. Fiber type and dosage for all the concrete mixtures are given in Table 2. Test Specimens A total of 8 notched beams (2 beams for each concrete mix) with cross section of 150 x 150 mm and total length of 550 mm were constructed. Each beam was reinforced with two 6 mm diameter steel bars (fy = 500 MPa) fulfilling the minimum requirement of Eurocode 2 for the tension steel. The cross section and reinforcement details of tested beam specimen are shown in Fig.2.
Table 1 – Mixture Proportion of the control concrete Cement (Kg/m3) 322
Sand (Kg/m3) 872
Gravel (Kg/m3) 967
Water (Kg/m3) 193
Super-Plasticizer (Kg/m3) 1.61
Table 2 – Fiber contents in different concrete mixtures Mixture No.
Mixture Type
M-0 M-1 M-2
Control single fiber Hybrid fiber
M-3
Type I
Type II
--0.25 ---
----0.25
Total quantity of fibers, Vf (%) --0.25 0.25
0.25
0.25
0.5
Volume fraction of fibers, %
43
LOAD
150
150
Compressive strength, MPa 42 44 42
10
2 - Ø= 6 mm
2 - Ø= 6 mm
500 550
Figure 2: Cross-section and reinforcement details of the test specimen Testing Procedure 28 days after the casting, three point bending tests were performed on reinforced non-fibrous (control) and fibrous concrete notched beams according to European Standards NF EN 14651 “Test method for metallic fibered concrete”. Although this standard is for fiber concrete without steel bars, the same procedure has been adopted for the fiber reinforced concrete with conventional steel reinforcing bars. All the tests were controlled by crack mouth opening
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
14
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 14
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
displacement (CMOD) using LVDT. In each test, mid-span deflection of the beam was also measured using LVDT. CMOD and deflection measurement scheme is shown in Fig. 3.
Figure 3: Test setup and measurement scheme
TEST RESULTS The experimental results (all compositions) on cracking and ultimate moment (moment corresponding to peak load attained by each composite) are given in table 3 and CMODmoment and deflection-moment curves for each mix are shown in Fig.4. It can be observed that for a given CMOD or a given deflection, the load carrying capacity of the reinforced concrete beam with metallic fibers is significantly improved.
Table 3: Cracking and ultimate moments for all compositions Concrete Mix M-0 M-1 M-2 M-3
Sample # 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 2
Cracking moment, Mcr (kN-mm) 2379 2281 3216 3163 2333 2338 3653 3292
Ultimate moment* Mult (kN-mm) 5831 5669 5874 6113 6138 6228 7029 6974
* Maximum value in CMOD-Moment or Deflection-Moment curve Fig.5 shows the values of cracking moment for all concretes and strength effectives with the addition of metallic fibers. Compared to control reinforced beam (without fibers), the cracking moment is increased by 36.8%, 0.3% and 49.1% for M-1, M-2 and M-3 concretes respectively. This shows that cracking moment is increased significantly in the presence of type I fibers. On the other hand, type II fibers do not affect importantly. Fig.5 also shows the increase in ultimate moment of reinforced concrete with the addition of metallic fibers. Similar to cracking moment, M-3 exhibited maximum value of ultimate moment. Compared to control beam, the ultimate moment is increased by 4.1%, 8.5% and 21.7% for M-1, M-2 and M-3 concretes respectively.
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 15
15
Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams
The evolution of CMOD and deflection with the increase of moment is shown in Fig.6. It can be observed that for a given moment, addition of metallic fibers significantly reduced the crack opening and deflection. Deflection value at ultimate moment was 2.8 times less with M-1 compared to M-0. Similarly deflection was 2.2 times less with M-2 and 3.9 times less with M-3 compared to M-0. Same observations were also made with crack opening. CMOD value at ultimate moment was 2.6 times less with M-1, 2.1 times less with M-2 and 2.7 times less with M-3 compared to M-0.
8000
8000
M-3
M-3 M-2
M-1
6000 ) m m N k( t n e m o M
6000
4000
) m m N k( t n e m o M
M-1 M-0 M-0
2000
M-1 M-2
4000
M-2 M-0 M-0
2000
M-1 M-2 M-3
M-3
0
0
1
2 3 CMOD (mm)
4
0
5
0
1
2 3 Deflection (mm)
4
5
Figure 4: CMOD-moment and Deflection-moment curves 8000
Cracking Moment
49,1
Strength Effectiveness (%)
Moment (kN-mm)
M-1 M-2
60
Ultimate moment (Moment at Peak) 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 0
M-3
50 36,8 40 30
21,7
20 8,5 10
4,1
0,3
0
M-0
M-1
M-2
M-3
Cracking Moment
Ultimate Moment
Figure 5: Cracking and ultimate moment (experimental results) 1,8
M-0
1,6
M-0
1,6
M-1
1,4
M-1
1,4
M-2
1,2
M-2
1,2
M-3
1
M-3
Deflection (mm)
CMOD (mm)
2 1,8
1 0,8 0,6
0,8 0,6
0,4
0,4
0,2
0,2 0
0 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
Moment (kN-mm)
5000
6000
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
Moment (kN-mm)
Figure 6: Evolution of CMOD and deflection with moment (up to Mult attained by M-0)
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
16
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 16
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
FLEXURAL CAPACITY OF BEAMS: ANALYTICAL APPROACH Commonly accepted mechanics and equilibrium conditions have been used to calculate the flexural capacity in term of cracking and ultimate moment of the beams containing randomly distributed metallic fibers and reinforcing steel bars. The tensile forces carried by the added fibers create an additional internal moment capacity, which is simply superposed to the moment capacity of reinforced concrete beam section. The analysis is based on following three assumptions: (1) plane section remains plane after bending; (2) the tensile forces balance the compressive forces, (3) the internal moment is equal to external applied bending moment Cracking Moment Simplified procedure proposed by Campione [10] is used here to calculate the cracking moment. Neglecting the effect of steel bar and referring to Fig.7. The cracking moment is calculated using eq. 1.
(a) cross-section
(b) strain distribution
(c) stress distribution.
Figure 7: Linear stress and strain distributions just before cracking
M cr
bh 2 u MOR 6
(1)
Where, MOR is modulus of rupture of fiber reinforced concrete. Additionally, a separate series of 3 point bending tests on prisms of cross section 100 x 100 mm and length of 500 mm was also carried out in order to determine the modulus of rupture of concrete compositions used in this study. For each composition, three samples were tested. These tests were performed according to European standard NF EN 14651 with the exception of specimen size. The results (average of three samples) are shown in Fig. 8. Ultimate moment The assumed and simplified stress distribution of reinforced non-fibrous and fibrous concretes at failure is shown in Figs. 9 and 10. In reinforced fibrous concrete, steel reinforcing bar, concrete matrix and randomly distributed fibers contributes to carry the post cracking tension. Referring to assumed and simplified stress distribution of reinforced fibrous concrete shown in Fig.10, where parabolic compressive stress zone is divided into two parts: rectangular and triangular, the ultimate moment is calculated using Eq. 2.
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 17
17
Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams
Ts u z1 T f u z 2
MOR (MPa)
Mu
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
(2)
7,0
6,6
4,3
4,0
M-0
M-1
M-2
M-3
Figure 8: Modulus of rupture (MOR) In Eqs.2, Ts and Tf are tensile forces carried by steel bar and fibers respectively, z1 and z2 are lever arm distances. For reinforced fibrous concrete beam containing fibers in hybrid form, the ultimate moment capacity is calculated by simply adding the contribution of individual fibers in carrying tension and the expression is given in Eqs.3
Mu
Ts u z1 (T f 1 T f 2 ) u z 2
(3)
Tf1 and Tf2 are the tension carried by each fiber used in hybrid combination. Ts and Tf are calculated using Eqs.4 and 5. Ts T f 1, 2
As u f y
(4)
V t 1, 2 u b u (h c)
(5)
In Eqs.5, ıt is ultimate tensile strength of fiber reinforced concrete and is greatly influenced by the properties and contents of fibers.
(a) cross-section
(b) strain distr.
(c) assumed stress distr.
(d) simplified stress distr.
Figure 9: Stress and strain distributions in reinforced concrete
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
18
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 18
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
(a) cross-section
(b) strain distr.
(c) assumed stress distr.
(d) simplified stress distr.
Figure 10: Stress and strain distributions in reinforced fibrous concrete Determination of z1, z2 In the following section, step by step procedure is given to calculate z1 and z2. In the following equations A1 is area of the rectangular compressive stress block, A2 is area of triangular compressive stress block shown in Fig.10.
A1
0.85 f c' u 0.80c
y1
(0.80 u c) / 2
A2 y2
0.68 f c' c
(7)
1 (0.85 f c' u 0.20c) 0.085 f c' c 2 1 (0.20 u c) 0.80c 3
A1 A2
(6)
0.765 f c' c
(8) (9) (10)
y c'
A1 y1 A2 y 2 ¦A
z1
d y c'
(12)
z2
(
hc ) (c y c' ) 2
(13)
0.452c
(11)
Depth of the neutral axis “c” is determined using Eqs.14 for single fiber concrete and using Eqs.15 for hybrid fiber concrete. Eqs.14 and 15 are obtained by equating compression and tension forces i.e., C = Ts+Tf. c
V t bh As f y ( single fiber) 0.765 f c' b V t b (V t 1 V t 2 )bh As f y ( hybrid fiber) c 0.765 f c' b (V t 1 V t 2 )b
(14) (15)
Determination of ıt About the contribution of matrix in the ultimate tensile strength of fiber reinforced concrete ‘ıt’, one can consider interlocking between aggregates but it vanishes quickly with the crack
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 19
19
Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams
opening after the peak load. Moreover, this contribution is small compared to tensile strength contributed by the fibers, so contribution by the matrix is ignored. Therefore, ultimate behaviour of FRC is governed by properties of fibers, number of fibers, etc. According to Hsu and Hsu [11], number of fibers acting across the cross section is determined by the following expression:
Do u
N
Vf
(16)
Af
From the Eqs.16, NAf is the area of fibers per unit area of section and is equal to ĮoVf.. Af is area of fibers and Vf is volume fraction of fibers. In the analysis of reinforced fibrous concrete, each fiber is considered as small longitudinal reinforcement present through the whole length of section. The ultimate tensile strength of fiber reinforced concrete is calculated by using the following equation:
Vt
Do uV f uV f uDb
(17)
Where, Įo is orientation factor and is equal to 0.41, Oh [12], Įb is bond efficiency factor and its value varies from 1 to 1.2 depending upon fiber characteristics, ACI Committee 544 [13]. For straight fibers, the value of Įb is taken equal to 1, Henager and Doherty [14], but in this study, for type I straight fibers, taking into account high bond strength with matrix due to surface roughness, its value is taken equal to 1.2; the maximum value proposed by ACI Committee. For hooked-ends fibers (type II), Dancygier and Savir [15] proposed the value of Įb equal to 1.2, here in this study, the same value (i.e., Įb =1.2) has been used. ıf is tensile strength of fibers and the values of ıf for the fibers used in this study are given in section 2.1. Analytical values of cracking and ultimate moment capacities are given in table 4 along with ratios between experimental and analytical values.
Table 4 – Analytical and experimental moment capacities of fibrous composites Composition M-1 M-2 M-3
Cracking moment (kN-mm) (Mcr)anl (Mcr)exp 3188* 3234 2338* 2107 3475* 3430
( M cr ) anl ( M cr ) exp 1.014 0.901 0.987
Ultimate moment (kN-mm) (Mult)exp (Mult)anl 5988* 5225 6238* 5101 7000* 6861
( M ult ) anl ( M ult ) exp 0.872 0.817 0.980
* Value is averaged of two samples
DISCUSSION
The experimental results show that the resistance of reinforced concrete beam is increased with the addition of randomly distributed metallic fibers. Fiber action to arrest cracking at micro or macro level is strongly depended on one hand, on the properties of fiber (geometry, strength and stiffness) and on the other hand, on the bond between the fibers and concrete matrix. For the bond between fiber and matrix, matrix compactness also plays an important role.
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
20
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 20
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
Between the two fibers used in this study: type I fibers develop good bond with the matrix because of surface roughness and large specific surface area. According to a study carried out by Turatsinze and Bascoul [16], micro-cracking occurs inside the matrix before the peak load in flexure, in this context, type I fibers act as soon as the first micro-cracks open and immediately restrain their propagation due to good bond with concrete matrix. By this way, they enhance the response prior and just after the peak load. With further increase of crack opening, the fibers contribute to carry tension along with steel bar and response of the composite is improved in term of load bearing capacity, reduced deflection and smaller crack opening (Figs. 4 and 6). As well as the failure of the type I fibers is concerned, when the stress in the fiber exceeds its tensile strength with further increase of crack opening, the fibers break instead of pulling out from the matrix and the postpeak residual load bearing capacity approaches towards a value equal to control concrete (Fig. 4). On the other hand, type II fibers develop poor bond with concrete matrix due to their smooth surface and small specific surface area. As a result of poor bond, at micro-cracking, these fibers slip from the concrete matrix and minor effect on the response of the composite in term of strength is observed. Since these fibers are hooked-end, sufficient anchorage in the matrix helps these fibers to restrain macro-cracks propagation by transferring the stress across the crack; as a result, post-crack response (toughening effect) of the concrete composite is significantly improved. With the increase of crack opening, these fibers are stretched and anchorage in the concrete matrix due to hooked-end is further improved and fibers play important role in carrying tension along with steel reinforcing bar at macro cracking level. After the yielding of steel bars, crack opening is increased significantly; as a result, fibers are pulled out (slipped) from the concrete matrix instead of breaking and their hooked-ends turn straight. Since the two metallic fibers used in this study provide reinforcement at different level: type I fibers at micro-cracking level and type II fibers at macro-cracking level, the best composite properties are obtained from the hybrid composite containing both fibers which exhibits the greatest flexural strength and toughness because of positive synergetic interaction. The theoretical equations developed here to determine the cracking and ultimate moment capacities taking into account the metallic fibers are a simple and more practical way and thus a useful tool for engineers to assess the bending capacity of reinforced fibrous concrete. The analytical values of cracking and ultimate moment obtained show a good agreement with experimental results. The ratios between analytical and experimental values of cracking and ultimate moment lie between 0.8 and 1.1 with different concretes used in this study.
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK
Based on the test results and predicted values of cracking and ultimate moment capacities, the following conclusions are drawn: x Addition of randomly distributed metallic fibers causes an increase in the flexure strength and toughness of the reinforced concrete beams. x The level of improvement in the flexural response of the reinforced fibrous concrete beam is greatly depended on the physical and mechanical properties of metallic fibers. x A significant reduction in the crack width and deflection is guaranteed by the addition of metallic fibers in the reinforced concrete beam.
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 21
Study on the flexural behaviour of reinforced fibrous concrete beams
21
x The matrix-fiber high bond due to rough surface and large specific surface area of amorphous metallic fibers (type I fibers) makes the fibers more effective in strengthening the composite. In opposite to that ductile behaviour and hooked-ends of carbon steel fibers (type II fibers) make the fibers more effective in toughening the composite. x Positive synergetic effect exits between the two metallic fibers used in this study. Hence the composite containing these fibers in a well chosen hybrid form can exhibit high performance in term of strengthening and toughening. x Simplified analytical approach is developed to calculate the ultimate flexural strength of reinforced fibrous concrete rectangular section taking into account the contribution of metallic fibers. Analytical results showed good agreement when compared to experimental results. For the future work, research will be carried on to find more realistic value of bond efficiency factor for high performance amorphous metallic fibers used in this study. REFERENCES
1.
Banthia, N., Sappakittipakorn, M., Toughness enhancement in steel fiber reinforced concrete through fiber hybridization, Cement and Concrete Research, 37, 2007, 13661372 2. Swamy, R. N., Sa’ad A. Al-Ta’an, Deformation and ultimate strength in flexure of reinforced concrete beams made with steel fiber concrete, ACI Journal, SeptemberOctober 1981, 395-404 3. Ashour, S.A., Mahmood, K., Wafa, F., Influence of steel fibers and compression reinforcement on deflection of high-strength concrete beams, ACI Structural Journal, V.94, No.6, November-December 1997 4. Vandewalle, L., Cracking behaviour of concrete beams reinforced with a combination of ordinary reinforcement and steel fibers, Material and Structures, Vol. 33, April 2000, pp 164-170 5. Banthia, N., Soleimani, S.M., Flexural response of hybrid fiber-reinforced cementitious composites, ACI Materials Journal, V.102, No.6, November-December 2005. 6. Pons, G., Mouret, M., Alcantrara, M., Granju, J.L., Mechanical behaviour of selfcompacting concrete with hybrid fiber reinforcement, Materials and Structures, 2007, 40, 201-210 7. Hsie, M., Tu, C., Song, P.S., Mechanical properties of polypropylene hybrid fiberreinforced concrete, Materials Science and Engineering, A 494, 2008, 153-157 8. Ahmed S.F.U., Maalej M., Tensile strain hardening behaviour of hybrid steelpolyethylene fiber reinforced cementitious composites, Construction and Building Materials, 23, 2009, 96-106 9. Barragam, B., Gettu, R., Zalochi, R.F., Martim, M.A., Agullo, L., A comparative study of the toughness of steel fiber reinforced concrete in tension, flexure and shear. Fiber Reinforced Concrete (FRC) BEFIB’ 2000, Proceedings of the Fifth International RILEM Symposium, pp- 441-450 10. Campione, G., Simplified flexural response of steel fiber-reinforced concrete beams, journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, Vol.20, No. 4, April 2008 11. Hsu, L.S., Hsu, T., Stress strain behaviour of steel-fiber high-strength concrete under compression, ACI Structural Journal, V.91, No.4, July-Aug. 1994, pp. 448-457 12. Oh, B.H., Flexural analysis of reinforced concrete beams containing steel fibers, Journal of structural engineering, Vol.118, No.10, October 1992
02-Study on the flexural.qxd
22
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 22
Rashid HAMEED, Anaclet TURATSINZE, Frédéric DUPRAT and Alain SELLIER
13. ACI Committee 544.4R-88, Design consideration for steel fiber reinforced concrete 14. Henager, C.N., Doherty, T.J., Analysis of reinforced fibrous concrete beams, journal of structural division, ASCE, 102 (STT): 177-188 15. Dancygier, A.N., Savir, Z., Flexural behaviour of HSFRC with low reinforcement ratios, Engineering Structures, 28, 2006, 1503-1512 16. Turatsinze, A., Bascoul, A., Restrained crack widening in Mode I crack propagation for mortar and concrete, Advanced Cement Based Materials, 1996, 4, 77-92
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 23
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
ROUND PANEL VS. BEAM TESTS TOWARD A COMPREHENSIVE AND HARMONIC CHARACTERIZATION OF FRC MATERIALS Fausto MINELLI, Giovanni A. PLIZZARI DICATA - Department of Civil, Architectural, Environmental and Land Planning Engineering, University of Brescia. Via Branze, 43, 25123 Brescia, Italy, e-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected].
ABSTRACT Standard test methods for determining the mechanical properties of Fibre Reinforced Concrete (FRC) are better defined if they reproduce the actual structural behavior. A comparison between different test typologies for characterizing FRC is reported and discussed in the present paper, with special emphasis on the different scatter that each test produces. Tests are performed on beams as well as panels. All specimens have the same concrete mechanical properties and fibre content. Aim of the investigation is to critically discuss advantages and disadvantages of each testing procedure, focusing on the applicability of the method and on the reliability of results toward a consistent characterization of the structural behavior. A new geometry for the panel test is herein proposed and discussed in order to make the panel easier to place and handle, avoiding one of the major drawbacks which limits an extensive utilization of the panel tests. Suitable correlations among the different fracture and energy parameters defined in the assumed standards are reported, resulting very useful for a harmonization of the available standards. Moreover, an analytical study is finally carried out focusing on the determination of the constitutive V-w law of FRC materials from panel tests. Results from the analytical study are compared with the experimental results and critically discussed.
Keywords Fibre-Reinforced Concrete, standard test methods, cracking, toughness
INTRODUCTION Fibre Reinforced Concrete (FRC) is gaining an increasing interest among the concrete community for the reduced construction time and labor costs. For this reason, many structural elements are now reinforced with steel fibres as partial or total substitution of conventional reinforcement (rebars or welded mesh, [1]). Besides cost issues, quality matters are of paramount importance for a construction and FRC also fulfill these requirements since fibres allow for more distributed cracks with a smaller opening that enhances durability. New construction materials requires standards for measuring their mechanical properties and building codes or guidelines for structural design [2-3]. As far as FRC is concerned, design guidelines are already available in some countries [4-6] and work is in progress for including them in the coming fib Model Code. In these guidelines, structural design is usually based on design values of the material parameters that are normally determined by dividing the characteristic values by a partial safety factor (JM). Mechanical properties of FRC are traditionally determined from beam tests that are usually based on a three [3] or four point bending schemes [7]. Early experiences with the low
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 24
24
Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI
volume fractions of fibres that are nowadays used in practice (Vf < 0.8 - 1.0%) evidence that the characteristic values determined from beam tests [3,7] are quite low because of the high scatter present in the beam-test results; it should be observed that the latter scatter is not related to the material itself but it is mainly due to the small fracture areas of the beams (ranging from 160 to 180 cm2). Such a scatter becomes particularly high when low contents (25-50 kg/m3) of macro steel fibres (length ranging between 30 and 60 mm) are used, Sorelli et al. [8]. It is commonly accepted that FRCs with a low volume fraction of fibres are particularly suitable for structures with a high degree of redundancy where stress redistribution may occur. Because of this redistribution, large fracture areas are involved (with a high number of fibres crossing them) and, therefore, structural behaviour is mainly governed by the mean value of the material properties; furthermore, because of the large fracture areas, the scatter of experimental results from structural tests is remarkably lower than that obtained from the beam tests. A typical example is shown in Fig. 1, which exhibits a set of curves obtained from a standard (bending) test on notched specimens (Fig. 1a) and from structural tests on full scale slabs on grade made of the same material (Fig. 1b); the different scatter between material and structural tests is clearly evident (Cominoli, [9]). Load vs. Central deflection 350
4
300 3
250 Load [kN]
Nominal Stress s N [MPa]
5
2
200 Slab P22 50/0,75 Vf=0,38 %
150
Slab P21 50/0,75 Vf=0,38 %
100
1
Slab P20 50/0,75 Vf=0,38 %
50 0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
CTODm [mm]
2.5
3.0
3.5
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Central deflection [mm]
(a) (b) Fig. 1: Experimental results from bending tests on a notched beam (a) and from a full-scale slab on grade (b) made of the same FRC (di Prisco et al. [6]). In order to obtain a more realistic value of the scatter from FRC material tests, specimens with larger fracture areas are needed; this suggests the use of larger beams or different specimens like slabs where stress redistribution may also occur. A Round Determinate Panel (RDP) test was proposed by ASTM [10]; it is a statically determinate test (a round slab: I = 800 mm; thickness = 75 mm, with three supports at 120 degrees) where the crack pattern is predictable and the post-cracking material properties can be better determined. However, handling and placing such a specimen is quite complicated due to the large size and, consequently, the high weight. In addition, standard servo-controlled loading machines may not fit with the geometry of the panel, which is too big for most of them. The need to have a specimen easier both to handle and to test brought the Authors to come up with a proposal of a smaller round panel having a diameter of 600 mm and thickness of 60 mm. The present paper focuses on the comparison of different tests for FRC materials tested in the last few years at the University of Brescia. A comparison between beam and panel tests, a discussion on the smaller round panel herein proposed as well as the correlations between the different fracture properties obtained from different Standards are here presented.
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 25
Round panel vs. beam tests toward a comprehensive and harmonic characterization of FRC materials
25
Last but not least, an analytical study is finally carried out focusing on the determination of the constitutive V-w law of FRC materials from panel tests. Results from the analytical study are compared with the experimental results and critically discussed.
MATERIALS, SET UP, EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Among more than 100 comparative experiments carried out on beams and panels, the following discussion will deal with a number of tests conducted on members containing either 20 or 30 kg/m3 of hooked-end steel fibres having a length of 50 mm and a diameter of 1 mm (the aspect ratio L/Iis 50); fibres have a circular cross section and tensile strength of 1100 MPa. Besides the FRC specimens, plain concrete beams and panels were also made. Beams according to UNI 11039 [7] and EN 14651 [3] as well as classical round panles (called round panels large in the following, RPL) according to ASTM (2004) and round panel small (RPS, radius 600 mm; thickness 60 mm) were tested. All geometrical characteristics and further details are reported in Minelli and Plizzari [11-12]. In order to study the behavior of all specimens up to failure, including any possible unstable branch after cracking, a displacement controlled testing method was adopted. The equipment shown in Fig. 2 (a) was adopted for all tests except for RPL, whose dimensions, as already mentioned, required to utilize a different equipment. In the first case, an INSTRON 1274 machine was used (having a closed loop and a maximum load of 500 kN). In the second case, the displacement was imposed by adopting an electro-mechanical screw jack (having a maximum load of 500 kN and a stroke of 300 mm) placed into a steel frame. Fig. 2 (b) shows the steel supporting system suitably designed for performing tests on RPS with INSTRON 1274 machine.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 2: Set up for performing panel tests (a), and steel supporting system (b) A CMOD (Crack Mouth Opening Displacement)-controlled procedure was adopted for both notched beams (UNI and CEN prescribe a notch with a different length) and round panels small, whereas a displacement-controlled test (screw control with the electromechanical jack) was performed in the case of the large panel tests, resulting in an instability of the test immediately after the peak of the concrete matrix [13]. Fig. 3 shows the Nominal Stress (according to a linear stress distribution in the cracked section) versus the CTOD for both CEN and UNI beam tests as well as the load versus the central vertical displacement of both large and small round panels made of the identical material. As expected, the post-peak behavior is similar for the two types of beam tests, which are characterized by a large scatter of experimental responses. Referring to Fig. 3c and Fig.
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 26
26
Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI
3d, the dispersion of results is definitely much smaller than in the corresponding beam tests, both for large and small round panels. It is worth underlining that, in order to characterize the post-peak behavior of panels, three LVDTs were placed to monitor the development of the crack widths, at a distance of 120 mm from the center of the panel. Crack widths greater than 20 mm were measured with a post-cracking load higher than one third of the peak load. Such an instrumentation is not required by the ASTM Standard [10], which states that one should only calculate the energy absorption (defined by the vertical load and the vertical displacement). However, monitoring the crack widths supported the analytical studied, which will follow in next paragraph. 7
Comparison UNI Beams Steel fibres
7
20 kg/m³
20 kg/m³
30 kg/m³
5
Comparison RILEM Beams Steel fibres
6
Nominal Stress s N [MPa]
Nominal Stress s N [MPa]
6
4 3 2 1
5
30 kg/m³
4 3 2 1
0
0 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2 2.5 CTODm [mm]
(a)
CTODm [mm] 35
3
3.5
4
4.5
(b)
25
Comparison LARGE ROUND PANEL Steel fibres
30
Comparison SMALL ROUND PANEL Steel fibres 20
20
Load [KN]
Load [KN]
25 20 kg/m³ 30 kg/m³ 15
15 20 kg/m³ 30 kg/m³ 10
10 5 5 0
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
0
10
20
(c)
Displacement [mm]
40
30
(d)
Displacement [mm]
Fig. 3: Comparison of UNI, CEN and round panels tests, both for FRC with 20 and 30 kg/m. Comparison coefficient of variation Steel Fibers 0.5
Comparison coefficient of variation Steel Fibers FF1
Properties determined at SLS
Properties determined at ULS 20 kg/m³
0.41
0.4
0.5
0.46
20 kg/m³
30 kg/m³
30 kg/m³ 0.4
0.37 0.32
0.3 0.3
0.24
0.23 0.23
0.2
0.16
0.15
0.09
0.1
0.23 0.19
0.2
0.14 0.08
0.05
0.0
0.08
0.1
0.0 UNI
CEN
RPL
RPS
UNI
CEN
RPL
RPS
Fig. 4: Coefficient of variation calculated for all parameters required by the standards considered in the present experimental campaign The coefficient of variation, as an indicator of the test result scatter, was calculated for all properties and indexes defined in the different standards (Fig. 4), both for quantities which refer to the serviceability limit states (SLS) and ultimate limit states (ULS). Once again, a significant lower coefficient of variation can be outlined for panel tests in comparison with beam tests, according to the experimental results aforementioned.
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 27
Round panel vs. beam tests toward a comprehensive and harmonic characterization of FRC materials
27
ANALYTICAL MODEL Based on the broad experimentation, an analytical model was then undertaken to the aim of: - determining local stress-crack opening cohesive law from round panels; - defining suitable equivalent post-cracking strength directly from panel tests, as it usually occurs from beam tests. First of all, according to the thin plate theory, appropriate general relations, in the elastic range, were determined describing the maximum tangential stress (Vt) and the displacement at the load point (Fig. 5). An elastic finite element analysis was performed with the following results: PD V t 0.001816 2 (1) t
P D3 (2) E t3 where P is the external load applied at the slab center, D is the diameter of the panel measured form the supports, t is the panel thickness, E and Q are the Young Modulus and the Poisson ratio of concrete, respectively. The elastic analysis was also able to predict the distribution of radial and tangential stresses along the line of crack formation, as depicted in Fig. 5. Note that the elastic solution is an easy-to-use tool that allows a simplified calculation of the equivalent post-cracking strength being feasible for practical and design applications, in the same way as it was done for beam tests.
K RPS
0.000429
1.2
Comparison distribution r(r)/ r,max - t(r)/ t,max, z = 60 mm SMALL ROUND PANEL 1.0
] a P M [ 0.8
t
x
s t(r) Serie1
r
x a m t,
s r(r) Serie1
/ t 0.6 d n a
y
z
x a ,m r
0.4 r
s s e tr 0.2 S
0.0 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
r [mm]
Fig. 5: Elastic radial and tangential stresses along the line of crack formation By using the above equations for the determination of the local tangential maximum tensile stress at the load point, it is possible to come up with a V-w cohesive law and compare it with those determined from beam tests, being w the experimental measured crack widths. As an alternative, without direct measurement of the crack width, a kinematic approach based on the yield line theory could be adopted to calculate the crack width, as done by Bernard [14] and Tran et al. [15]. In the yield line analysis of a round panel, the governing mode of failure is taken to comprise three symmetrical yield lines-cracks emanating from the center of the face opposite to the point load and running radially to the edge while bisecting each sector between adjacent pivot supports. The crack width was experimentally measured at a distance from the point load of 120 mm (point Q in Fig. 6). Based on geometry consideration, it can be written that:
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 28
28
Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI
BC
BQ
K RPS
GQ
(3)
where CQ =120 mm, according to the experiments. From trigonometry one can derive that: 2r
BQ
K RPS
GQ
§K · BQ ¨ RPS ¸ © 2r ¹
GQ
(4)
with r = 275 mm. Hinge Line
Zero Displacement
B
Yeld Line
Q C Central Load Point
P
Support Pivot
Pivot Lines
Fig. 6: Yield Line Approach for the determination of crack width The rotation at the support is therefore equal to:
GQ
D P PQ
(5)
By substituting PQ and Gq one can obtain: BQ §K · BQ ¨ RPS ¸ D P 3 © 2r ¹ The rotation at the support P therefore results:
(6)
3 K RPS (7) 2 r The rotation in Q, at the crack location (point of experimental measurement) can be derived as:
DP
M RPS
2 DP
3
K RPS
r The corresponding bottom crack opening) is therefore evaluated as:
(8)
§ 3 K RPS · ¸ 2t tg ¨¨ (9) ¸ © 2 r ¹ where r is the radius (r = 275 mm) and t is the panel thickness (t = 60 mm). It is worthy noticing that the crack opening obtained using Eq. 9 is constant along the radius, for a given value of panel displacement. However, in the actual case, the crack width will increase from the external surface to the load point. wm
§M · 2t tg ¨ RPS ¸ © 2 ¹
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 29
Round panel vs. beam tests toward a comprehensive and harmonic characterization of FRC materials
29
Fig. 7 plots the comparison between experimental and analytical crack width, which was derived from regression of experiments as follows:
wm
0.67 K RPS 0.32
(10)
The experimental straight line is bilinear, with a first constant line with zero crack representing the uncracked phase, in which the vertical displacement increases prior to cracking (up to a value of around K0 = 0.5 - 0.6 mm), and a second linear branch, showing a quite good fitting of the experiments (R2 = 0.99). The difference between the two curves (with the experimental showing higher cracks for the same vertical displacement) is probably due to the fact that a little elastic deformation is always measured by the LVDTs in the experiments (150 mm gauge length) and, moreover, their location is at 120 mm from the load point, while the yield line theory would match better with a measurement at r/2 from the load point (i.e., 137.5 mm). This procedure allows now the definition of a constitutive cohesive V- w law based on round panel experiments.
Fig. 7: Crack width at bottom surface of a small round panel As far as the beam tests are concerned, from a linear regression of experimental results, an analytical relation between the crack tip opening displacement CTOD and the vertical displacement at midspan was derived as follows: CTODm 1.03 K B (11)
MB
From a kinematic model shown in Fig. 8, it was obtained that: 4 K B l
(12)
Load Points
Fig. 8: Kinematic model for 4 point bending tests UNI beams The Italian Standard (UNI 11039) defines two different equivalent post-cracking strengths, feq(0-0.6) and feq(0.6-3), which represent the toughness given to the matrix by fibres in a conventional serviceability (crack width from 0 to 0.6 mm) and ultimate limit states (crack widths from 0.6 to 3 mm).
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 30
30
Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI
Using the two above mentioned equations, it is possible to correlate crack ranges with vertical displacements KB and rotations MB of beams. By imposing that the rotation of round panels be equal to that of beams (Eqs. 8 and 12) according to the yield line theory, one can first determine the vertical displacement at the point load KRPS , and then the crack width (Eq. 10) corresponding to the rotation given. The crack width values then define two ranges that allow the definition of two equivalent postcracking strengths, relevant for serviceability and ultimate limit sates, respectively. The results of this procedure are reported in Table 2. Table 1: Midspan displacements and rotations corresponding to the CTODm defined by the UNI standard 11039 (2003). CTODm [mm] 0.6 3
KB [mm] 0.58 2.91
MB 0.052 0.0259
Table 2: Vertical displacement and crack width values corresponding to the same yield line rotation between panels and beams. MRPS=MB
KRPS
0.0052 0.0259
[mm] 0.82 4.11
wm [mm] 0.55 2.75
It is now possible to define two crack width ranges and to determine the corresponding equivalent post-cracking strengths, which are: x feq,1 from w0 to w0 + w1; x feq,2 from w0 + w1 to w0 + w2. here w0 - crack width at first cracking, w1 = 0.55 mm and w2 = 2.75 mm (Table 2). The two equivalent post-cracking strengths can therefore be defined as: k2 D U1 (13) f eq1 w1 t2 f eq 2
k2 D U2 w2 w1 t2
(14)
in which: x feq,1 is the equivalent post-cracking strength relevant for serviceability limit states; x feq,2 is the equivalent post-cracking strength relevant for serviceability limit states; x U1 is the area under the P-w experimental graph calculated in the crack range from w0 to w0 + w1 (Fig. 9); x U2 is the area under the P-w experimental graph calculated in the crack range from w0 + w1 to w0 + w2 (Fig. 9); x k2 = 0.001816 mm-1 is the constant already calculated. This approach can therefore be used to determine average values, standard deviations and characteristic values of the toughness parameters defined, taking strong advantage from the lower scatter of panel tests over beams (see Conti and Flelli for details [16]). Fig. 10 depicts a V- w curve with the indication of feq1 and feq2. Moreover, these two values allows the definition of a constitutive simplified bilinear law according to CNR DT 204 [4]. A similar approach can be derived starting from the load-displacement curve of panels, neglecting the crack width measurements (often not provided). In such circumstances, one can define suitable displacement ranges for the definition of feq1 and feq2. The displacement ranges, calculated using Eq. 8 and reported in Table 2, are incorporated into the definition of the two equivalent post-cracking strengths as:
03-Round panel.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 31
31
Round panel vs. beam tests toward a comprehensive and harmonic characterization of FRC materials
f eq1
k 2 D E1 K1 t2
(15)
f eq 2
k2 D E2 t 2 K 2 K1
(16)
Load C arico
where all coefficients were already defined.
U
U
1
w
w
+
w
1
2
w
+
w
2
w
Fig. 9: Load-crack width curve for small round panels depicting areas U1 and U2
Fig. 10: Typical V-w curve for a small round panel showing the equivalent postcracking strengths
CONCLUDING REMARKS
A comparative study between beam and panel tests was discussed in the present paper. The experimental high scatter generally present in beam tests is definitely caused by the small geometry and fracture area involved in the tests. It does not represent the real structures where much larger fracture areas are involved and, consequently, a lower dispersion occurs. Panel tests are therefore more suitable for representing the actual behaviour of FRC materials. A number of improvements in the test procedures, such as close-loop control and crack width measurements were adopted allowing the characterization of FRC with a much lower dispersion of experimental results. The proposal of carrying out panel tests on smaller specimens brought to positive results, as such geometry does not affect the low scatter of the standard ASTM panel and, moreover, it allows for an easier placing and handling (lower weight and smaller geometry that fits with many servo-controlled testing machines). The correlation among fracture parameters found are in general very promising and allow engineers not to repeat different tests in different countries but to analytically calculate the fracture parameters of different tests from performing only one or few test typologies. These correlations, that were somehow expected since we are always referring to fracture properties of the same material, are important from practical point of view as they can give immediate indications related to the fracture properties without performing expensive tests. Given the analytical study undertaken, the round panel test can be considered as a complete test for the characterization of FRC: suitable range of crack widths are defined and the corresponding equivalent (or residual) post-cracking strengths are derived (from V-w plots) following the same procedure as done for beam tests. The panel test is relatively easy to perform, not expensive, it might require only one vertical displacement transducer, and, last but not least, it is characterized by a very low scatter of results.
03-Round panel.qxd
32
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 32
Fausto MINELLI and Giovanni A. PLIZZARI
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Authors would like to deeply thank Engs. Yuri Marinoni, Raoul Martin Milla, Nicola Vezzoli, Moira Conti and Giovanni Flelli for their valuable assistance in performing the experiments and in data processing. REFERENCES
1. di Prisco, M., Failla, C., Plizzari, G.A. and Toniolo, G., Italian guidelines on SFRC, in: Fibre Reinforced Concrete: from theory to practice, di Prisco, M. and Plizzari, G.A. Eds., Proceedings of the International Workshop on advances in Fibre Reinforced Concretes, Bergamo (Italy), September 24-25, pp. 39-72, 2004 2. Vandewalle, L., Test and design methods for steel fibre reinforced concrete proposed by RILEM TC 162-TDF, Proceeding of the International Workshop “Fibre Reinforced Concrete. From theory to practice”, Bergamo, September 24-25, pp. 3-12, 2004 3. EN 14651, Test method for metallic fibred concrete. Measuring the flexural tensile strength (limit of proportionality (LOP), residual), CEN, 2005, pp.15 4. CNR DT 204, Guidelines for the Design, Construction and Production Control of Fibre Reinforced Concrete Structures, National Research Council of Italy, 2006 5. RILEM Final Recommendation TC-162-TDF, Test and Design Methods for Steel Fibre Reinforced Concrete; VHDesign Method, Materials and Structures, Vol 36, pp. 560-567, 2003 6. di Prisco, M., Felicetti, R. and Plizzari, G.A. Eds., Proceedings of the 6th RILEM Symposium on Fibre Reinforced Concretes, BEFIB 2004, RILEM PRO 39, 1514 pp, 2004 7. UNI 11039, Steel Fibre Reinforced Concrete - Part I: Definitions, Classification Specification and Conformity - Part II: Test Method for Measuring First Crack Strength and Ductility Indexes, Italian Board for Standardization, 2003 8. Sorelli, L., Meda, A. and Plizzari, G.A., Bending and uni-axial tensile tests on concrete reinforced with hybrid steel fibres, ASCE Materials Journal, Vol.15(5), pp. 519-527, 2005 9. Cominoli L., Studio sul calcestruzzo fibrorinforzato per applicazioni industriali: dalle proprietà del materiale al comportamento strutturale (in Italian), Ph.D. Thesis, University of Brescia (ISBN 978-88-96225-10-3), pp. 431, 2007 10. ASTM C1550-04, Standard test method for flexural toughness of fibre reinforced concrete (using centrally loaded round panel), pp. 9, 2004 11. Minelli, F. and Plizzari, G.A., Round Panel Tests for Characterizing Steel Fibre Reinforced Concrete; Proceedings of the Fib Symposium Keep Concrete Attractive, Budapest, Hungary, 23-25 May 2005 (Edited by György L. Balázs and Adorján Borosnyói, Published by the Publishing Company of Budapest University of Technologi and Economics), Vol.1, pp. 310-315, 2005 12. Minelli, F. and Plizzari, G.A., Fibre Reinforced Concrete characterization: Round Panel vs. beam test toward a harmonization, Proc. of the 3rd Central European Congress on Concrete Engineering CCC 2007 – Visegrád, Hungary, 17-18 September 2007. G.L. Balázs and S.G. Nehme (eds), Publishing Company of Budapest University of Technology and Economics, pp. 213-220, 2007 13. Marinoni, Y., Minelli, F., Plizzari, G.A., and Vezzoli, N., Prove di frattura su calcestruzzi fibrorinforzati in accordo con le principali normative internazionali (in Italian), Technical Report, University of Brescia, Department DICATA, 2007 14. Bernard, E.S., Correlations in the behavior of fibre reinforced shotcrete beam and panel specimens, Material and Structures, Vol. 35, pp. 156–164, 2002 15. Tran, V.N.G., Bernard, E.S. and Beasley, A.J., Constitutive Modeling of Fibre Reinforced Shotcrete Panels, Journal of Engineering Mechanics, Vol. 131, No. 5, pp. 512-521, 2005 16. Conti, M. and Flelli, G., Caratterizzazione del calcestruzzo fibrorinforzato attraverso prove su piastre sottili (in Italian), M.Sc. Thesis, University of Brescia, March 2009, 2009
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 33
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
THE INFLUENCE OF STEEL FIBRE CONTENT AND CURING CONDITIONS ON MECHANICAL PROPERTIES AND DEFORMABILITY OF REACTIVE POWDER CONCRETE AT BENDING Tomasz ZDEB, Jacek ĝLIWIēSKI Cracow University of Technology, Faculty of Civil Engineering Warszawska 24, 31-155 Kraków, Poland e-mail:
[email protected] ;
[email protected]
ABSTRACT This paper refers to cementitious material belonging to Reactive Powder Concretes (RPC) and containing variable content of steel fibres. The test results include mechanical properties of this composite, cured in three different conditions: in water, steam-cured and in autoclave. Depending on curing conditions and fibres volume the compressive strength ranged from 200 to 315 MPa and the tensile strength at bending varied from 10 to 30 MPa. Moreover three-point bending test results are presented as load-deflection curves. On the basis of the afore mentioned measurements the following coefficients were calculated: work of fracture WF and toughness indices I5, I10 and I20. It was observed that both volume of steel fibres and curing conditions influence on flexural behaviour of RPC.
Keywords Reactive powder concrete, ultra high performance cementitious composites, steel fibres, fibre volume ratio, curing conditions, strength, fracture energy, fracture toughness index
INTRODUCTION According to Collepardi’s definition of reactive powder concretes (RPC), dispersed reinforcement is a standard component, [1]. Amongst the concretes the most recognized materials are the ones containing steel fibres. Fundamental aims for steel fibres application are: enhancing of mechanical properties, reduction of the shrinkage and inducing ductility of loaded material. The mean length of steel fibres in RPC ranges from 6 to 15 mm and diameter from 0.16 to 0.18 mm, while the volumetric content varies from 2.0 to 2.5% [2]. Characteristics of compressive and tension strength of RPC composites with constant amount of fibres are described among the others in papers [3-7]. However, it is difficult to find some information on influence of variable content of fibres with constant geometrical parameters on mechanical properties of RPC.
04-The influence.qxd
34
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 34
Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ŒLIWIÑSKI
MATERIALS AND SPECIMEN PREPARATION Materials In order to produce RPC test specimens the following components were used: portland cement CEM I 52.5R, silica fume, ground quartz 0/0.2 mm, quartz sand 0/0.5 mm, ordinary acrylic-based superplasticizer and straight and smooth steel fibres. Characteristics of applied materials are presented in Tables 1÷4. Table 1. Properties, chemical and phase composition of cement CEM I 52.5R Properties Initial setting time [min] 130 Final setting time [min] 220 Specific surface [cm2/g] 4100 Compressive strength after 2 days [MPa] 34.5 Compressive strength after 28 days [MPa] 70.8 Chemical composition [% w.] CaO – 65.58; SiO2 – 22.98; Al2O3 – 4.41; Fe2O3 – 2.10; SO3 – 3.32; MgO – 1.06; Na2OE – 0.51; Cl- - 0.009 Phase composition [% w.] C3S – 59.09; C2S – 17.97; C3A – 8.12; C4AF – 6.38 Table 2. Particle size distribution and chemical composition of ground quartz and sand Ground Sand Properties quartz Dmax [m] 200 500 D50 [m] 16 110 Specific surface BET [m2/g] 0.80 0.04 Density [g/cm3] 2.65 Polimorfic modification ȕ-quartz SiO2 [%] 99.0 98.5 Al2O3 [%] 0.30 0.80 Fe2O3 [%] 0.05 0.03 Table 3. Properties and chemical composition of silica fume Properties Specific surface [m2/g] 22.4 Density [g/cm3] 2.23 Chemical composition [% w.] SiO2 – 94.06; Al2O3 – 0.74; Fe2O3 – 0.78; CaO – 0.06; MgO – 0.49; Na2Oe – 1.43; SO3 – 0.63; LOI – 0.74 Table 4. Properties of steel fibres Length [mm] 6 Diameter [m] 175 Modulus of elasticity [GPa] 210 Tensile strength [MPa] 2200
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 35
The influence of steel fibres content and curing conditions on mechanical properties and deformability of reactive powder concrete at bending
35
Fig. 1. Applied steel fibres (l = 6 mm; ij = 0.16 mm) Composition of RPC matrix Composition of examined RPC was developed in the other research project. Mass fractions of ingredients are presented in Table 5. The maximum volume fraction of steel fibres (Vfmax = 4% vol.) was defined by obtaining proper workability of concrete mix without changing its composition and assumption that inclusion is homogeneously dispersed in whole composite. Table 5. Composition of RPC matrix by weight ratio Cement CEM I 52,5R 1.00 Silica fume 0.20 Grounded quartz 0/0,20 mm 0.34 Quartz sand 0/0,50 mm 0.81 Superplasticizer 0.02 Water 0.24 Above mentioned mixture includes the following amount of steel fibres: Vf = 0.5; 1.0; 2.0; 3.0 and 4.0 % vol. (i.e. 39, 78, 155, 233 and 310 kg/m3). Specimens and curing conditions The mixtures without and with fibres were molded and densified in gravitational manner. Beams dimensions were as follow: 40x40x160 mm. Preliminary setting of concretes lasted for 6 or 24 hours at +20oC, during this time evaporation of water was prevented. After demoulding the specimens were cured under three different conditions: - curing in water (W) at +20oC after 24 hours of preliminary setting, - steam curing (S) at +90oC after 6 hours of preliminary setting, according to cycle presented on Fig. 2, - autoclaving (A) at +250oC and under pressure of 40 bars after 24 hours of preliminary setting, according to cycle presented on Fig. 2.
04-The influence.qxd
36
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 36
Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ŒLIWIÑSKI
Fig. 2 Temperature versus time for the two curing conditions
PROCEDURES AND TEST RESULTS Compressive and tensile strength at bending The tensile strength of each material was obtained by testing 6 beams (40x40x160 mm) in three-point bending test. 12 cubes (40x40x40 mm) were cut from the broken beams and tested for compressive strength. Regardless of steel fibres volume, the cross section confirmed that each specimen has homogeneous fibres dispersion (see Fig. 3).
Fig. 3 Cross sections of tested beams with homogeneously dispersed steel fibres Table 6 presents average values of compressive and tensile strength at bending. In case of curing in water (W) , specimens were examined after 28 days of setting. Steam cured (S) and autoclaved (A) specimens were tested after heat treatment was completed and test specimens were cooled down. Table 6 Compressive and tensile strength of RPC with and without steel fibres, cured in three different conditions Variable volume fraction Without Curing of fibres [% vol.] fibres Features conditions [MPa] 0.5 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 W 194 202 201 208 211 217 Compressive S 212 219 215 224 228 235 strength [MPa] A 268 282 281 297 308 315 W 10.6 12.1 13.2 16.0 19.3 22.7 Tensile strength at S 14.3 14.5 15.6 17.2 22.7 23.0 bending [MPa] A 18.6 21.2 23.7 25.1 26.1 26.8
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 37
The influence of steel fibres content and curing conditions on mechanical properties and deformability of reactive powder concrete at bending
37
Deformability at bending In the study, the three-point bending test for specimens with dimensions 40x40x160 mm was used. The distance between supports was equal to 100 mm. Loading of the specimen was determined by force gain. Dimensions of the specimens and the rate of loading were not consistent with ASTM C1018-97 [8]. Therefore, the following analysis of calculated parameters has only comparative character. Fig. 4 presents representative load-deflection curves that were recorded during studies.
Fig. 4 Representative load-deflection curves recorded in the bending test of RPC with variable steel fibres content; (a) setting in water, (b) steam curing, (c) autoclaving (x - the 1st crack) On the basis of the load-deflection curves for each RPC test specimen containing variable steel fibres, work of fracture WF and fracture toughness indices I5, I10 and I20 were calculated [8]. Calculated toughness indices I5, I10 and I20, showed that first cracking point (marked as x on Fig. 4) was defined as the point where nonlinearity in the load-deflection
04-The influence.qxd
38
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 38
Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ŒLIWIÑSKI
curve becomes evident. Values of work of fracture, toughness indices and their variability versus fibres content are presented on Fig. 5.
Fig. 5 Influence of curing conditions and fibre content on work of fracture WF (a) and fracture toughness indices I5 , I10 , I20, (b, c, d) respectively Microstructure of RPC The influence of curing conditions and fibre content on compressive and tensile strength as well as deformability at bending can be explained by microstructure formation of tested materials. There are at least three factors that permit to obtain ultra-high performance cementitious composites: - very compacted microstructure of CSH phase (Fig. 6), - very good adhesion of CSH phase to mineral inclusions (grains of grounded quartz and quartz sand) and also to steel fibres (Fig. 7 and 8), - fill in voids in microstructure of materials caused by crystallization of xonotlite and tobermorite during autoclaving (Fig. 9). Fig. 6 and 7 show microstructure formation of the composites cured in three different hydrothermal environments. Very compacted microstructure of CSH phase and its excellent adhesion to grains of cement (light inclusion) as well as to quartz grains (dark inclusion) can be observed in each case of curing conditions. Steel fibres with tightly sheathed products of cement hydration are presented on Fig. 7 and 8. Each voids of autoclaved RPC (pores, microcracking etc.) are completely or partly filled with crystals of xonotlite and tobermorite (Fig. 9).
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 39
The influence of steel fibres content and curing conditions on mechanical properties and deformability of reactive powder concrete at bending
Fig. 6 CSH phase (a) curing in water, (b) steam curing, (c) autoclaving, SEM, magnification 10 000x (photo: B. Trybalska)
Fig. 7 Contact zone of steel fibre and CSH phase in RPC, (a) curing in water, (b) steam curing, (c) autoclaving, SEM, magnification 2 000x (photo: B. Trybalska)
Fig. 8 Steel fibre in RPC, (a) curing in water, (b) autoclaving, SEM, magnification 500x (photo: B. Trybalska)
Fig. 9 Partly filled micropore with xonotlite and tobermorite crystals, (a) magnification 2 000x, (b) magnification 10 000x (photo: B. Trybalska)
39
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 40
Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ŒLIWIÑSKI
40
DISCUSSION Compressive strength Depending on curing conditions the compressive strength of RPC without fibres varies from 194 to 268 MPa. The lowest value is ascribed to material setting in water, while the highest to autoclaved one. After obtained test results, presented in Table 6, it could be affirmed that steam curing causes increase of compressive strength about 10%, while autoclaving about 40% in comparison to material setting in water. Increase of compressive strength of RPC with variable fibre volume are similar for steam curing as well as autoclaving. The values of compressive strength of RPC with fibres varies from 202 MPa (Vf=0.5% vol. setting in water) to 315 MPa (Vf=4.0% vol. autoclaving). Linear progression of compressive strength versus steel fibres volume fraction can be observed for all studied curing conditions, [10]. Moreover it is worth to notice that regardless of curing conditions, the influence of steel fibres volume on increase of compressive strength is similar. Only in case of autoclaved RPC containing 2 to 4% vol. of fibres a little deviation in plus can be observed. Tensile strength at bending Depending on curing conditions the flexural strength of RPC without fibres ranges from 11 to 19 MPa. As well as in case of compressive strength, above mentioned extreme values are ascribed to setting in water and autoclaving respectively. The steam curing contributes to 35% flexural strength enhancement, while autoclaving to 75% in comparison to material setting in water. The tensile strength of RPC with variable volume of fibres varies from 12 MPa (Vf=0.5% vol. setting in water) to 27 MPa (Vf=4.0% vol. autoclaving). The influence of fibres volume on discussed strength is greater than in case of compressive strength. The highest, more than double, increase of tensile strength was observed for RPC cured in water and containing 4 % vol. of fibres. In case of steam cured and autoclaved materials with the same volume of fibres the increase of tensile strength was equal to 60 and 45%, respectively. Like in case of compressive strength, the tensile strength for all curing conditions increases in linear rate versus volume fraction of fibres, [10]. Opposite to compressive strength test results (Table 6), the influence of hydrothermal treatment on tensile strength of RPC versus volume fraction of steel fibres is less distinct. Deformability at bending Work of fracture enhances, with increase of steel fibres volume. It is worth to notice that regardless of fibre volume in all considered cases, work of fracture is the highest for autoclaved materials (Fig. 5a). This phenomenon could be explained by two following mechanisms: the first is strengthening of mineral matrix of the composite as a result of hydrothermal treatment at 250oC and the second is the increase of adhesion between matrix and fibres. Materials that were steamed and cured in water show nearly identical values of fracture toughness indices for whole range of fibres dosage (Fig. 5b,c,d). The maximum value of indices I5, I10 and I20 can be observed in composites containing 3% vol. of fibres. Further increase of fibre volume (Vf = 4% vol.) leads to decrease of all determined toughness indices. This effect is ascribed to steamed and cured in water materials, while the autoclaved composites do not reveal such a tendency. The similar tendency was observed in case of mortars with addition of carbon fibres. Fracture toughness indices increase until 1% of fibre volume and their further growth causes decrease of their values, [12].
04-The influence.qxd
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 41
The influence of steel fibres content and curing conditions on mechanical properties and deformability of reactive powder concrete at bending
41
This can be attributed to increase of strength of mineral matrix. Calculated fracture toughness indices I5 and I10 suit to results presented by Katz et al. [13]. The authors showed 6.4 and 11.4 values for indices I5 and I10, respectively. Their specimens had the same dimensions, were cured in natural conditions and contained as much as 9% vol. of steel fibres (length 6 mm, diameter 0.16 mm). In turn, autoclaved RPC require relatively high energy to trigger off the first crack in mineral matrix, what entails decrease of all fracture toughness indices up to 3% vol. content of steel fibres. CONCLUSIONS The presented test results allow to propose following conclusions: 1. It is possible to receive ultra-high performance concrete using regular components and generally traditional curing conditions. In case of material without fibres and cured in natural conditions its obtained compressive strength is about 200 MPa and tensile strength in bending 11 MPa. Application of steam curing allows to increase both strengths up to 212 and 14 MPa, respectively, while autoclaving even to 268 MPa and 18 MPa. 2. Addition of steel fibres allows to further increase both compressive and tensile strength. The highest values reached 315 MPa for compressive strength and 27 MPa for tensile strength. These parameters were obtained for autoclaved composite, containing 4% vol. (310 kg/m3) of steel fibres. 3. On the basis of presented test results of compressive and tensile strength (Table 6), it can be observed that content of examined steel fibres (l = 6mm, ij = 0.16 mm) should not exceed 3% of volume fraction. Further increase of fibre dosage does not bring significant advantages. 4. Content of steel fibres and curing conditions strongly influence deformability of reactive powder concrete in bending test. In order to obtain optimum ductility of tested composites, addition of steel fibres should not exceed 3% vol. It is similar phenomenon which was observed during determination of compressive and tensile strength. 5. Taking into consideration presented test results; it seems to be purposeful to continue research in order to determine impact of hybrid fibres, with variable length on mechanical properties of RPC. REFERENCES 1. Collepardi S., Coppola L., Troli R., Collepardi M., Mechanical Properties of Modified Reactive Powder Concrete, American Concrete Institute, 173, 1997, 1 – 22 2. Richard P., Cheyrezy M., Composition of Reactive Powder Concrete, Cement and Concrete Research, vol. 25 Nr 7, 1995, 1501 – 1511 3. Blais P., Couture M., Precast, prestressed pedestrian bridge – World’s first reactive Powder Concrete Structure, PCI Journal IX-X 1999, 60-71 4. Acker P., Behloul M., Ductal technology: a large spectrum of properties, a wide range of application, International Symposium on Ultra High Performance Concrete, Kessel Germany, 2004, 11 – 23 5. Herold G., Müller H. S., Measurment of porosity of ultra high strength fibre reinforced concrete, International Symposium on Ultra High Performance Concrete, Kessel Germany, 2004, 685-694 6. Staquet S., Espion B., Influence of Cement and Silica Fume Type on Compressive Strength of Reactive Powder Concrete, 6th International Symposium on High Strength /High Performance Concrete, Leipzig, June 2002, 1421-1436 7. Orgass M., Klug Y., Fibre Reinforced Ultra-High Strength Concrete, International
04-The influence.qxd
42
9/19/2009
11:55 AM
Page 42
Tomasz ZDEB and Jacek ŒLIWIÑSKI
Symposium on Ultra High Performance Concrete, Kessel Germany, 2004, 637-647 8. ASTM C1018-97 Standard test method for flexural toughness and first-crack strength of fiber-reinforced concrete (using beam with third-point loading), Withdrawn 2006 9. Dong Joo Kim, Naaman, A.E., El-Tawil, S., Comparative flexural behaviour of four fiber reinforced cementitious composites, Cement & Concrete Composites, 30, 2008, 917-928 10. Zdeb, T., ĝliwiĔski, J., Effect of curing conditions and steel fiber addition on the compressive and flexural strength of reactive powder concrete (in Polish), InĪynieria i Budownictwo, 12, 2008, 693-697 11. Cherezy M., Maret V., Frouin L., Microstructural analysis of RPC (Reactive Powder Concrete), Cement and Concrete Research 25, 1995, 1491 – 1500 12. Brandt A. M., Cement-based composites, materials, mechanical properties and performance, Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, London and New York, 2009 13. Katz A., Bentur A., Dancygier A., Yankelevsky D., Sherman D., Ductility of high performance cementitious composites, Concrete Science and Engineering. A Tribute to Arnon Bentur, International RILEM Symposium, Evanston, IL, USA, March 2004, 117-127
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 43
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
INTERFACE BOND CHARACTERISTICS BETWEEN WOOD FIBRES AND A CEMENT MATRIX M. Guadalupe SIERRA BELTRAN1, a, Erik SCHLANGEN1,b Microlab, M & E, Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences Delft University of Technology, P.O. Box 5048, 2600 GA Delft, The Netherlands a
[email protected],
[email protected] 1
ABSTRACT When a brittle cement matrix is reinforced with fibres the composite’s toughness improves and a ductile behaviour could be developed. Wood fibres are currently being studied as a less energy-intensive alternative to synthetic fibres that have been successfully applied in reinforcing cementitious materials. In order to maximize the potential of wood fibres as reinforcement the fibre-matrix interface is being studied. The bonding will depend on: physical and chemical properties of the bundles, water/cement ratio of the matrix and its admixtures, curing conditions and age. One common way to determine important interface parameters such as chemical bond, frictional bond and slip-behaviour, either softening or hardening, is from a single fibre pull-out test. Therefore pull-out tests have been conducted using different matrices and softwood fibres. The effects of air-curing and water-curing are evaluated, as well as the influence of fibre embedment lengths. Beside pull-out tests the fibrematrix interface is also evaluated through Environmental Scan Electron microscope ESEM, CT-scan images and optical microscopes. The results from this study should allow the researchers to tailor the interface properties in order to achieve the desired composite behaviour.
Keywords Wood fibre, cement matrix, pull-out tests, bonding
INTRODUCTION In order to turn a brittle cement matrix into a ductile composite different types of man-made energy intensive fibres are currently in use: stiff fibres such as glass or steel and flexible fibres as polyvinyl alcohol, polypropylene and polyethylene fibres. However, in this study natural fibres are proposed. They are more easily available worldwide as well as cheaper and friendlier to the environment compared to the artificial fibres. Natural fibres in general demand less energy to be produced than synthetic fibres do. However, the properties of the wood fibres are not as constant as those of artificial fibres: they shrink and swell in the presence of water and they have a lower tensile strength. From the different types of wood, softwood fibres have been chosen for this study because they are longer and more uniform than hardwood fibres. Additionally, this paper proposes the use of bundles of wood fibres instead of single fibres. Bundles will achieve slightly lower tensile strength than single fibres but bundles have the advantage over single fibres that they have a rough surface which may promote a better mechanical bond with the cement matrix. In order to maximize the potential of wood bundles as reinforcement the fibre-matrix interface is studied. The bonding will depend on: physical and chemical properties of the bundles, water/cement ratio of the matrix and its admixtures, curing conditions and age. Pullout tests have been conducted using different matrices and softwood bundles to determine important interface parameters such as chemical bond, frictional bond and slip-behaviour. Six
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
44
11:56 AM
Page 44
Mercedes G. SIERRA BELTRAN and Erik SCHLANGEN
different mix designs and three softwood types (pine, larch and spruce) have been used. Some of the mix designs are high strength mortars and all include by-products admixtures. The effects of air-curing and water-curing are evaluated, as well as the influence of fibre embedment lengths. During the study two different tests setups have been used. Beside pullout tests the fibre-matrix interface is also evaluated using optical microscopes, Environmental Scan Electron microscope ESEM and CT-Scan images. The pullout tests results and the ESEM and CT-Scan images are finally presented and discussed.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM Materials Wood. Softwood fibres from spruce, larch and pine are used in this study. Fibres from softwood have a more simple form without vessels compared to hardwood fibres and the fibres are also longer (3 to 5 mm average) and thicker (up to 45 Pm). Softwood was found by Blankenhorn et al. [1] to be less inhibiting to cement setting than hardwood is. For larch and spruce and pine two different pulping procedures have been used. To obtain bundles of fibres out of lumber pieces of larch and spruce blocks of 1x1x2 cm have been cooked following a neutral sulphite semi-chemical (NSSC) pulping procedure as described by Walker [2] after which the bundles were manually taken apart. The bundles from pine on the other hand were prepared out of a veneer sheet which was first cut into pieces of about 2x3 cm and then cut into bundles using a microtome. Due to the difference in pulping procedure the pine bundles have a uniform rectangular section while the spruce and larch bundles cross sections vary in dimensions and shape. All bundles were cut at length 10 mm. The bundles have a tensile strength of 700 to 1000 MPa, and Modulus of elasticity of 25 to 40 GPa according to Sierra and Schlangen [3]. From now on these bundles will be referred as fibres. Cement matrix. Different cement matrices, of which the proportions per weight are shown in Table 1, were tested. The materials used are cement type CEM I 52.5 N, pulverized fly ash, blast furnace slag, limestone powder (Zhou et al [4]) and sand of which the size ranges from 0.125 – 0.25 mm. The last column in the table shows the water-cementitious material ratio. Table 1. Compression strength (MPa) and mix proportions (weight percentage) Fly Mix Compr. Sand BFS Lime. SP Water Cement Ash ID strength M1 1 1.2 0.8 0.013 0.6 67 M2 1 2.8 0.030 1 NC M3 1 0.8 1.2 0.013 0.6 58 M4 1 1.2 0.8 0.025 0.81 NC M5 1 1.2 1.5 0.023 0.98 48 M6 1 1.2 2 0.018 1.09 41
w/cm 0.27 0.26 0.27 0.27 0.27 0.26
NM Not measured
Fibre-matrix interface To evaluate the fibre-matrix interface properties single wood fibre pullout tests are performed. In these tests a fibre with a controlled embedment length is pulled out from a block of matrix while the load vs. displacement relation is recorded (Li et al. [5]).
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 45
45
Interface bond characteristics between wood fibres and a cement matrix
Two sets of specimens were prepared. In the first set the fibre embedment length and the matrix length were the same while the second set was prepared in such way that the fibre was completely embedded in a cement matrix and the fibre embedment length and the cement matrix were independent from each other. The embedment lengths for both sets were chosen from 1 to 5 mm. A shorter length will ensure full debonding, while a longer length will lead to a higher pullout stress. The maximum embedment length will be half the total fibre length (5 mm in this case). Both sets of samples were prepared by hand lay up of fibres in the centre of the cement matrix along the specimen length (Fig. 1). In the first set each specimen was cut 28 days after casting to dimensions 6 mm thick, 8 mm wide, and 1 to 5 mm long. In the second set each specimen was cut to dimensions 12 mm thick, 10 mm wide and 5 or 10 mm long. All the specimens were demolded after 1 day. Some samples were thereafter kept continuously in water and the other samples were air cured at 20% RH and about 22 °C for at least 28 days.
a
b
Casting direction
Casting direction Cutting line Cutting line 10 mm
8 mm 6 mm
Fibre 1 to 5 mm
12 mm
1 to 5 mm
Fibre
5 or 10 mm
Fig. 1 Pullout specimens: (a) same matrix-fibre embedment length, (b) fibre fully embed Microstructure analysis The fibre-matrix interface microstructure was analyzed by optical microscope (Leica M26), electronic scanning electron microscope (ESEM, XL30 FEI) and computer tomography (CTScan Phoenix). Also an EDAX energy dispersive x-ray analyzer system (EDS) was used for determining phase chemistry of the interface. For the ESEM and XDS analyses tested and untested samples were cut and polished along their width showing the fibre cross section as well as the interface. Different microstructure features were studied, such as the alignment of the fibre inside the cement matrix, the matrix penetration into the fibre or the gaps between fibre and matrix and the chemical elements present in the interface. Once the microstructure of the different composites was characterized it was correlated with the mechanical properties of the samples. Pullout tests The two sets of specimens were tested with two different setups for the pullout tests. All tests were conducted at speed of 0.002 mm/s. For the first set of specimens the pullout tests were carried out in a MTS 810 testing machine (Fig. 2a) in which the displacement of the test is given by the displacement of the actuator (±80 mm stroke) and the results data interpretation and calculation of the interface parameters will be done according to Lin et al. [6]. A 2-N load cell is used to measure the pullout forces. The cement matrix sample was glued to a specimen mount plate and the free side of the fibre was glued to a fibre mounting plate.
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
46
Page 46
Mercedes G. SIERRA BELTRAN and Erik SCHLANGEN
Fig. 2 Pullout tests set up: (a) same matrix-fibre embedment length, (b) fibre fully embeded The second set of pullout specimens were tested in a micro tension-compression testing device (developed by Kammrath & Weiss) (Fig. 2b) where the pullout forces were measured with a 500-N load cell. The displacement of the test is given by the displacement of the actuator (±6 mm). The cement matrix sample in one side and the free fibre end on the other were glued to two steel non-rotating loading plates with a two component epoxy resin. In both tests a free fibre length of 1 mm was left between the cement matrix and the plate. The force and displacement were recorded during the tests.
Pullout load
Slip hardening
Pmax
2
Pfr Constant friction 1 Slip softening Displacement Debonding
Fibre slippage
3
le embedment length
Fig. 3 Schematic description of fibre pullout behaviour A schematic pullout load-displacement curve is shown in Fig. 3. As described by Redon et al [7] there are three zones that can be clearly distinguished. Initially a stable debonding process takes place between the fibre and the matrix, zone 1, until reaching a maximum pullout resistance by the fibre Pmax. Then, at zone 2, the load decreases from Pmax to Pfr pullout frictional load. If this drop of load is sudden the chemical bond between the fibre and the matrix is assumed to be broken. At this point fibres with a homogeneous cross section such as polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polyethylene or steel, are fully debonded. For natural fibres with a variable cross section and irregular fibre surface this may not be the case. At the slippage zone (zone 3), the fibre load is resisted by frictional forces as mentioned by Redon et al [7]. Depending on the relative hardness of the fibre and the matrix, and the curvature of the fibre
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 47
47
Interface bond characteristics between wood fibres and a cement matrix
in the cement matrix the fibre undergoes sliding with slip hardening, constant friction or slip softening effect. RESULTS Fibre type When comparing the overall results for the three types of wood, spruce and larch fibres show higher maximum pullout stress compared to the pine fibres. Fig. 4 shows the results for pullout tests of 1 mm thick air cured samples of pine and spruce. Here the spruce fibres embedded in M4 and M6 have higher pullout stress than pine fibres.
Pullout stress (MPa)
Pine
0,8
Spruce
0,6 0,4 0,2
Pullout stress (Mpa)
0,8
1
0,6 0,4 0,2 0
0
0
M1
M2
M4
M6
Fig. 4 Pullout stress of air cured samples (1 mm thick)
Fig. 5 Pullout curves of pine (M6, air cured)
Air cured Water cured
2 1,5 1 0,5 0
Pullout Stress (MPa)
Pullout stress (MPa)
3 2,5
1,6 Air cured
1,2
Water cured
0,8 0,4 0 0
M1
M2
M3
M4
M5
M6
1
0,5 Displacement (mm)
0,5 1 Displacement (mm)
1,5
Fig. 6 Pullout stress of spruce fibres (1 mm thick) Fig 7 Pullout curves of spruce fibres and M6 Regarding the pullout behaviour, in 54% of the pine fibres specimens the fibre broke during the test. The fibres that undergo sudden rupture have a higher ultimate stress than the ones that were pulled out due to a very strong interface bond. 60% of the cases where the fibre was pulled out have an interface bond mainly governed by friction. This behaviour can be seen in Fig. 5 where several load-displacement pullout curves recorded for pine fibres embedded in M6 are presented. In these curves there is no sudden drop from the maximum stress Pmax to maximum friction stress Pfr. The larch fibres show mixed results. In 30% of the cases the fibre broke, in 30% the pullout behaviour is mainly frictional and in 40% there is a noticeable chemical bond. The spruce fibres on the other hand have a strong chemical bond with most of the cement matrices tested (66%) and only 13% of the spruce fibres composites undergo fibre rupture during the pullout test.
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
48
Page 48
Mercedes G. SIERRA BELTRAN and Erik SCHLANGEN
Cement matrix In fibre reinforced composites the pullout rather than rupture will favour the development of ductility (Lin and Li [8]). A higher amount of energy will be released during pullout if the fibre undergoes sliding with slip hardening or constant friction (Fig. 3). Pine samples with matrices M4 and M6 show these effects. Specimens tested with pine and 1 mm thick samples of M1 and M4 have the higher stress values (Fig. 4). Spruce fibres on the other hand have the best pullout behaviour with matrices M1 and M4. Stress wise M3 has the higher stress values for both air and water cured spruce samples (Fig. 6). Larch casted in M3 matrix shows good pullout behaviour. From EDX measurements there are very small differences in the atomic components recorded in the fibre-matrix interface (less than 5 um from the fibre) and the components recorded at 250 Pm distance, or in bulk matrix. Curing condition For both air and water cured pine samples tested, the main pullout behaviour is fibre rupture with a higher percentage within water cured samples. Air cured specimens show, beside fibre rupture, distinctive non chemical bond behaviour. In order to understand this behaviour both tested and untested water and air cured samples for all the fibres were analyzed with the ESEM. The samples were prepared by impregnating them with epoxy but not following the common procedure in which the samples are first put in a vacuum chamber. The samples were not vacuum to avoid further volume changes in the fibres. The fibres swell with the water present in the cementitious mixture. In this initial moment cement paste next to the fibre hydrates creating the thin layer of reacted paste shown in Fig. 8. Later as the cement hydration continues and if the curing conditions do not provide additional water (as with air curing) the fibre shrinks and breaks the young cement paste leaving a gap that was filled with epoxy when preparing the sample for the ESEM images. When the fibre shrinks the chemical bond with the cement matrix is lost. From the samples observed the gap width range between 3 and 30 Pm. In images of tested fibres and videos of pullout tests done in the ESEM patches of cement matrix covering the fibres have been observed. Those patches are these thin layers of reacted paste. ESEM images of water cured specimens reveal a sound and intimate contact between the fibre and cement matrix. 30
Cement matrix
Thin cement layer
25
Load (N)
Epoxy
20 15 10 5
Fibre
0
0
Fig. 8 ESEM image of pine fibre-M3 interface
0.5 Displacement (mm)
1
Fig. 9 Pullout curves of pine fibres, M2, water cured
Pine fibres embedded in M2 matrix have a higher pullout stress when water cured. Two load-displacement pullout curves recorded from these samples are presented in Fig 9 showing
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 49
49
Interface bond characteristics between wood fibres and a cement matrix
different behaviour: one fibre broke during testing and the other fibre was fully pulled out with a strain hardening effect. As mentioned before for spruce fibres, air and water cured, the main pullout behaviour is slip softening. Within the water cured samples the percentage of slip softening was even higher than for air cured samples. Air cured samples of spruce embedded in M4 show mainly a non-chemical bond while water cured samples show chemical bond behaviour. With this mix the pullout stress was about the same for both curing conditions. 1 mm thick samples of M3 and M6 that were water cured have higher pullout stress than the air cured samples as shown in Fig. 6. Two curves with different behaviour due to different curing conditions can be seen in Fig. 7. The air cured sample shows a non chemical bond while the water cured sample has a chemical bond assumed as the first peak in the curve and later with an increase in stress that corresponds to slip hardening. Larch fibres tend to break when pulled out of an air cured specimen. On the other hand most water cured samples have constant friction effect (Fig. 10).
12 Air cured
12
Water cured
8 4 0 0
1 Displacement (mm)
2
Pullout stress (MPa)
Pullout Stress (MPa)
16
10 8 6 4 2 0 0
1
Area (mm2)
2
3
Fig. 10 Pullout curves of larch fibres and M3 Fig. 11 Pullout stress vs. embedment area for larch fibres, M3, water cured Interface geometry The wood fibre is a natural mini-composite by itself with naturally bonded filaments. The shape of the fibres made partially or completely mechanically is not uniform. The fibres have a rough surface with short filaments coming out which may help the adherence and mechanical bond resulting in an effective reinforcement for a cement matrix composite as long as the fibres do not shrink. The mechanical bond is also increased by the fact that the fibres are not straight. The fibres curve naturally even inside the cement matrix. Images produced by a CT scan of single fibre embedded in a cement matrix reveal the importance of the curving angle in which the fibres are inside the matrix and its influence in the behaviour during the pullout. For example: A pine fibre in matrix M1 with 5 mm embedment length that showed a constant friction effect when pullout has an angle of 3.6° while a fibre that broke during the test had an angle of 11.6° (Fig. 12). In Fig. 12a it is noticeable that the embedment end has slipped inside the fibre tunnel before rupture. Larch fibres composites with pullout areas between 1 and 2.5 mm2 have the best behaviour when tested and the highest pullout stress. The pullout area is calculated as the perimeter of the fibre times the embedment length. For larch samples in M3 and water cured an optimal area of 1.7 mm2 is calculated (Fig. 11). Regarding the angle of curvature the CT-scan showed that a larch fibre that broke when tested had an angle of 27° while for a sample that was fully pulled out with a non-chemical bond the angle was 15°. From images produced for spruce fibres samples in M2 matrix the
05-Interface bond.qxd
50
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 50
Mercedes G. SIERRA BELTRAN and Erik SCHLANGEN
angle of a fibre that shows slip softening behaviour is smaller (6.9°) than for a fibre that shows slip hardening (8.2°). Spruce fibres embedded in M3 and water cured have a clear stress- area relation, where the smaller the pullout area, the higher the stress will be. For the same fibre and matrix type, embedment length of 1 to 2 mm, but air cured the results were too scattered. There is a tendency to lower pullout stress with bigger area but it is not so clear.
a
b
Fig. 12 CT-Scan of pine and M1 air cured samples: (a) fibre rupture, (b) constant friction
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS The interface behaviour between softwood fibres and cement matrices depends on the fibre type, the cement matrix composition, the curing conditions and fibre geometry, as shown in this study. Among this factors it is necessary to highlight the lost of interface bond due to the volume changes of the fibres in the presence of water. Therefore fibres should be treated in order to reduce these changes and keep the chemical and mechanical bond between wood fibres and cementitious matrices. On the other hand the natural curving from the fibres increases the mechanical bond. Currently the wood fibres are being treated successfully to reduce the shrinkage and swelling and therefore promote a constant and sound interface bond. Future work also includes the design of new cement matrix with lower strength since this will promote better pullout behaviour. Depending on the type of fibres certain matrices with different by products produce the highest stress or the better pullout behaviour. In order to further study the interface IR-spectroscopy to investigate a possible organic bond between the wood fibres and the cement matrix ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Financial support for this research from the National Council of Science and Technology (CONACYT), Mexico (Grant # 206108) and from INTRON is gratefully acknowledged. Furthermore the authors thank Prof. V. C. Li and Prof. K. Van Breugel for valuable discussions on the subject. REFERENCES 1. Blankenhorn, P.R., Blankenhorn, B.D., Silsbee, M.R., DiCola, M., Effects of fiber surface treatments on mechanical properties of wood fiber-cement composites. Cement and Concrete Research, 31, 2001, 1049-1055
05-Interface bond.qxd
9/19/2009
11:56 AM
Page 51
Interface bond characteristics between wood fibres and a cement matrix
51
2. Walker, J.C.F. Pulp and paper manufacture. In: “Primary wood processing principles and practice”. Springer, The Netherlands 2006, 477-534 3. Sierra Beltran, M.G., Schlangen, E., Wood fibre reinforced cement matrix: a micromechanical approach. Key Engineering Materials, 385-387, 2008, 445-448 4. Zhou, J., Qian, S., Sierra Beltran, M.G., Ye, G., van Breugel, K., Development of Engineered cementitious composites with limestone powder and blast furnace slag. To be published in: Journal of Materials and Structures, RILEM, 2009 5. Li, V.C., Wu, C., Wang, S., Ogawa, A., Saito, T., Interface Tailoring for Strain-hardening PVA-ECC. ACI Materials Journal, 99, 2002, 463-472 6. Lin, Z., Kanda, T. and Li, V.C., On Interface Property Characterization and Performance of Fiber Reinforced Cementitious Composites. Journal of Concrete Science and Engineering, 1, 1999, 173-184 7. Redon, C., Li, V.C., Wu, C., Hoshiro, H., Saito, T., Ogawa, A., Measuring and modifying interface properties of PVA fibers in ECC matrix. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 13, 2001, 399-406 8. Lin, Z., Li, V.C., Crack bridging in fiber reinforced cementitious composites with sliphardening interfaces. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 45, 1997, 763-787
06-Shear strength.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 53
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
SHEAR STRENGTH AND DUCTILITY OF BEAMS REINFORCED WITH SYNTHETIC MACRO-FIBERS Salah ALTOUBAT 1, Samer BARAKAT2, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN 3 and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER 4 1 Assistant Prof., University of Sharjah, Sharjah, UAE,
[email protected] 2 Associate Prof., University of Sharjah, Sharjah, UAE 3 PhD Student, Texas A&M University, College Station, TX, USA 4 Senior Principal Scientist, Grace Construction Products, Luegde, Germany
ABSTRACT The application for synthetic macro fibers has been extended beyond shrinkage and cracking control to include some structural applications such as composite metal deck and industrial floors. One issue that has remained a matter of concern for engineers and designers is the shear behavior of the concrete when macro synthetic fibers are incorporated in the concrete mix. This paper is part of a recent research project that showed macro synthetic fibers to significantly improve the shear strength and ductility of reinforced concrete beams. The paper presents results from testing of 14 large beams under center-point monotonic loading. The beams were tested with a shear span to depth ratio of 2.3 and 3.5. The beam cross-section was 390 × 230 mm. Macro synthetic fibers were added at three volume fractions of 0.5 %, 0.75 %, and 1.0 %, which is equivalent to 4.6, 6.9, and 9.2 kg/m3. The results showed that the addition of macro synthetic fibers significantly improved the shear strength and ductility of the RC beams and modified the cracking and failure behavior. The ultimate shear strength of slender and short beams was increased up to 30% compared to the control RC beams.
Keywords beams; concrete; shear behavior; shear strength; macro synthetic fibers
INTRODUCTION Research over the past three decades has clearly established the potential use of fiber reinforcement for enhancing the shear capacity of reinforced concrete beams [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. The effect of fiber reinforcement on shear strength of concrete beams is attributed to the improved post-cracking behavior of the concrete and the associated improvements in the aggregate interlock and dowel action of flexural reinforcement. Consequently, shear strength of the concrete beam, ultimate shear capacity and ductility of FRC beams are improved. Several research studies which involved small and large scale testing of FRC beams have confirmed this theory [6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. The majority of the past published research on shear of FRC beams has focused exclusively on steel fiber reinforced concrete (SFRC). The results showed that steel fibers can be used to boost the shear capacity of concrete and to improve the shear crack distribution in concrete structural members. A large database of test results for shear strength of steel fiber reinforced concrete (SFRC) beams obtained by many investigators was compiled by ParraMontesinos, [11]. Based on this, the list of beams exempt from the minimum shear reinforcement requirement in Section 11.5.6.1 of ACI 318-08 now includes beams that are
06-Shear strength.qxd
54
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 54
Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER
constructed with SFRC. This addition to ACI 318 represents the first permitted structural use of SFRC in the ACI building Code. Unlike in the case of SFRC, there are only few studies reporting results on shear with synthetic fibers [4, 12, 13, 14]. The limited research on shear behavior with synthetic fibers is attributed perhaps to the little increase in toughness and associated structural performance of concrete when low-modulus micro synthetic fibers, typically made of polypropylene, are added to concrete. In recent years however, increasing efforts have been devoted towards the development of new generation of macro synthetic fibers which impart significant toughness and ductility to concrete comparable to commonly used steel fibers. Accordingly, the application of macro synthetic fibers in the concrete industry has extended beyond shrinkage and thermal cracking control to structural applications, and therefore it becomes necessary to study the shear behavior of concrete beams with macro synthetic fibers. This study is part of a comprehensive experimental program conducted at the University of Sharjah, which focused on the shear behavior of beams reinforced with a new type of macro synthetic fiber [15, 16]. This fiber has a higher modulus of elasticity compared to regular polypropylene fibers and an optimized geometry to enhance the bond between the fiber and the concrete matrix, which leads to an increase in the toughness properties of concrete. Results obtained from testing 14 large scale beams under shear loading are summarized in this paper. The beams were reinforced with longitudinal flexural reinforcement and were designed to fail in shear under monotonic center-point loading in a simply supported configuration. The macro synthetic fibers were added to the concrete at three different volume fractions, namely 0.50%, 0.75% and 1.0% in addition to the control beams without fiber reinforcement. The beam cross section was 390 mm × 230 mm. Loaddeflection measurements and the shear capacity of the beams are presented and discussed in this paper.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM Large beams testing Fourteen large-scale concrete beams were designed, instrumented and tested in displacement control mode under a monotonic three-point loading system in a simply supported configuration. The main experimental parameters in this test series were shear-span to depth ratio a/d, and the macro synthetic fiber content Vf. Two shear span to depth ratios were considered, namely 3.5 and 2.3 to reflect the behavior of slender and short beams, respectively. The cross-section of the beams was 390 mm × 230 mm. All beams were reinforced with three longitudinal reinforcing bars with a diameter of 32 mm, which corresponds to a steel ratio of 0.0318. The average cylinder compressive strength of the concrete used in this study was around 41 MPa (6000 psi). Macro synthetic fibers were added at volume fractions of 0.50%, 0.75% and 1.0%. Table 1 presents details of the beams. The beams were labeled to indicate the type of beam (short or slender), and the fiber content. The letter ‘L’ denotes long or slender (a/d =3.5) while ‘Sh’ means short (a/d =2.3). For example the beam labeled as L-0.50 stands for a slender beam with a fiber volume fraction of 0.50 %.
06-Shear strength.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 55
55
Shear strength and ductility of beams reinforced with synthetic macro-fibers
Table 1 – Details of the large scale beams tested in the study Test Series L-0.0 L-0.50 L-0.75 L-1.0 Sh-0.0 Sh-0.50 Sh-0.75
No. of beams 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
h, mm 390 390 390 390 390 390 390
d, mm 330 330 330 330 330 330 330
b, mm 230 230 230 230 230 230 230
Length, Span, m m 2.7 2.31 2.7 2.31 2.7 2.31 2.7 2.31 1.9 1.5 1.9 1.5 1.9 1.5
a/d
ȡ, %
Vf , %
3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 2.3 2.3 2.3
3.18 3.18 3.18 3.18 3.18 3.18 3.18
0.00 0.50 0.75 1.00 0.00 0.50 0.75
Identical pairs (duplicate) of slender and short beams were cast to enhance the reliability of the test results. The large beams and the companion lab specimens, including the 100 mm by 200 mm cylinders for compressive strength measurement and the 150 mm by 150 mm by 550 mm beams for flexural toughness measurement were all cast in one day in a modern precast plant. Materials The mix proportions and properties of the concrete used for casting the beams are presented in Table 2. The final water to cement ratio was around 0.47. The coarse to fine aggregate ratio was targeted to be close to 50:50 in order to maintain workability and to have sufficient paste volume for coating the fibers. The coarse aggregate used in this concrete mix was a Gabro gravel with a maximum aggregate size of 20 mm and a specific gravity of 3.1. The fine aggregate constituents were natural washed sand with a specific gravity of 2.6 and dune sand with specific gravity of 2.63. The 28-day compressive strength values measured according to ASTM C39-05 and flexural strength values measured according to ASTM C78-08 are summarized in Table 2. Typical values of the equivalent flexural strength, fe,3, measured according to JSCE-1984 [17] up to 3 mm deflection are also reported. The equivalent flexural strength, fe,3, was developed in Japan and can be obtained from bending of beams under third150 toughness value defined in the point loading. The fe,3 value is directly proportional to the T150 ASTM C1609-07 [18] flexural beam test using a 150 x 150 x 550 mm beam. The fe,3 value as 150 well as the T150 value are directly proportional to the area under the load-deflection curve up to a central beam deflection of 3 mm (for a support span of 450 mm). The main components of the macro synthetic fibers used in this study are polypropylene and polyethylene. This “macro” synthetic fiber’s mechanical properties and geometry are significantly different from traditional “micro” synthetic fibers, which are used to control plastic shrinkage cracking. The fiber’s nominal length is 40 mm and has an aspect ratio of 90 and a specific gravity of approximately 0.92. The fiber has a rectangular cross section with an average width of 1.4 mm and average thickness of 0.105 mm. The average tensile strength of the fiber is 620 MPa with a modulus of elasticity of 9500 MPa measured according to EN 14889-2. The fibers were added at volume fractions of 0.50 %, 0.75 % and 1.0%, which correspond to 4.6, 6.9 and 9.2 kg/m3, respectively.
06-Shear strength.qxd
56
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 56
Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER
Table 2 - Mix proportions and average properties of concrete
Vf = 0.0%
Vf = 0.50%
Vf = 0.75%
Vf = 1.0%
Coarse Aggregate, kg/m3 943 943 Fine Aggregate, kg/m3 942 942 Cement, kg/m3 380 380 Water, kg/m3 195 195 Superplasticizer Daracem 205, kg/m3 2.15 4.55 Water to Cement Ratio 0.474 0.474 Slump, mm 100 100 Cylinder Compressive Strength, MPa 42 42 Flexural Strength, MPa 5.8 5.8 Equivalent Flexural Strength (fe,3), MPa 0.15 2 1 kg/m3 = 1.686 lbs/cyd; 25.4 mm = 1 inch; 1 MPa = 145 psi
943 942 380 195 6.70 0.474 90 42 5.9 2.8
943 942 380 195 7.45 0.474 80 35* 5.8 3.1
Materials
* This mix exhibited signs of segregation due to high contents of fiber and superplasticizer
Testing and measurements The test setup consisted of a simply supported loading configuration with roller supports to prevent restraint to axial elongation. The beams were loaded at midspan (center point) and tested in displacement control mode using a hydraulic actuator with a capacity of 500 kN (Fig. 1). The loading rate was 0.48 mm/min to allow for accurate observation and mapping of the cracks development.
Fig. 1 – Test setup and the arrangement of LVDTs The parameters measured in the test program were beam deflections, strain in the concrete at different locations, strain in the reinforcing flexural steel bars, and the applied load. The cracking patterns were observed visually and marked during testing at different load levels. The load levels corresponding to formation of first diagonal shear crack as well as the ultimate shear capacity were determined for the beams using the load deflection and strain measurement data with the aid of visual observation. The formation of the first diagonal shear
06-Shear strength.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 57
57
Shear strength and ductility of beams reinforced with synthetic macro-fibers
crack was associated with a sudden reduction in load carrying capacity of the RC beam in the load-deflection curve. The maximum load carried by the RC beam before failure was used to calculate the ultimate shear capacity of the beam. Further details of the experimental plan and test results can be found in Altoubat et al. (2009) [16].
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Load-deflection results The load versus mid-span deflection curves of the tested slender and short beams are presented in Fig 2 and 3, respectively. The load versus deflection response of all beams were similar up to the load at which the first diagonal shear crack was formed in the control beams. The first diagonal crack was associated with a sudden load reduction in the load deflection curve. The control beams failed upon the formation of the first diagonal crack, and thus it marked their ultimate capacity. The addition of macro synthetic fibers increased the first diagonal crack load relative to the control beams as can be seen from the results shown in Fig. 2 and 3. Furthermore, the fiber concrete beams did not fail when the first diagonal shear crack was formed and the post cracking behavior was dependent on the fiber dosage. The beams with 0.50% of macro synthetic fibers exhibited little load reduction after the first diagonal cracking and then continued to resist similar or higher loads until another shear crack formed at a much higher deflection before failure. The beams with higher dosage of fibers (0.75 % and 1.0 %) exhibited no reduction in load after the first diagonal crack and continued to resist greater deflection and more shear cracks were developed before failure. The plateau in the load deflection curve in Fig. 2 for the beams with 0.75 % and 1.0 % of the fibers reflect the multiple shear cracks developed in the beams before failure and showed the improvement in ductility.
400
Control Vf = 0.50% Vf = 0.75% Vf = 1.0%
350
Load (kN)
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Deflection (mm)
Fig. 2 – Load versus deflection curves of the slender beams
06-Shear strength.qxd
58
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 58
Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER
400 350
Control Vf = 0.50% Vf = 0.75%
Load (kN)
300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Deflection (mm)
Fig. 3 – Load versus deflection curves of the short beams Table 3 presents a summary of the loads corresponding to the formation of first diagonal shear crack and ultimate load capacity of the tested beams. The table also includes the percent increase of the load carrying capacity of the SNFRC relative to the corresponding control RC beams. The results show that the addition of macro-synthetic fibers to the concrete beams significantly increased the first diagonal cracking load and the ultimate load. Table 3 Loads at first diagonal crack and ultimate capacity of the beams Beam
a/d
First diagonal crack load, kN
Ultimate load, kN
Increase in ultimate load, %
L2-0.0 L2-0.5 L2-0.75 L2-1.0 Sh2-0.0 Sh2-0.50 Sh2-0.75 1 kN = 224.809 lbf
3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 2.3 2.3 2.3
230 236 266 260 270 285 308
230 265 279 303 270 318 339
14 20 30 18 26
Table 4 presents a summary of the average deflection resisted by the RC beams at ultimate load. The macro-synthetic fiber increased the deflection at ultimate above the control beam by 63% to 100% for slender beams and by 103% to 138% for short beams as shown in Table 4. The deflection results showed the significant improvement in the ductility of the beams due to the addition of macro synthetic fibers. Table 4 - Average values of beam deflections at ultimate load Beams Slender beams Short beams 25.4 mm = 1 inch
Control
Vf = 0.50%
Defl., mm 3.7 1.7
Defl., Increase, mm % 6.0 63 3.5 103
Vf = 0.75% Defl., mm 7.1 4.1
Vf = 1.0%
Increase, Defl., Increase, % mm % 93 7.3 100 138 -
06-Shear strength.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 59
59
Shear strength and ductility of beams reinforced with synthetic macro-fibers
Cracking and failure Cracking of the beams were carefully monitored and mapped during testing. Fig. 4 presents pictures of cracking pattern and sequence for slender and short beams. Flexural cracking in the slender beams started at mid-span and spread out to the shear span, where the flexural cracks - with increasing load - began to incline as flexural shear cracks (diagonal crack). The number of flexural cracks and the inclination of the diagonal crack that lead to failure characterize the cracking pattern of the tested RC beams. The control RC beams failed with a single and steep diagonal shear crack as can be seen in Fig. 4a. The SNFRC beams developed multiple flexural and diagonal shear cracks before failure occurred as can be seen in Fig. 4b and c. The creation of multiple flexural and shear cracks in the SNFRC beams contributed to the increase of the ductility as reflected in the load deflection curves, particularly for the RC beams reinforced with 0.75% and 1.0% of fibers. Furthermore, the primary diagonal crack that leads to failure of the SNFRC beams (Fig. 4b and c) was flatter relative to that of the control beam (Fig. 4a), and extended further toward the support. According to Fenwick and Paulay [19], appreciable arch action develops when the diagonal crack extends to the support, thereby separating the tension and compression zones of the shear span and allowing the relatively large translational displacement associated with arch action to occur. The cracking patterns of the SNFRC beams suggest that macrosynthetic fibers improve the arch action in slender RC beams and thus lead to an increase of the shear strength. Fig. 4d - e show the cracking pattern and sequence for short beams. The short control RC beams shown in Fig. 4d developed web-shear cracks that led to a sudden and brittle shear failure. Conversely, the SNFRC short beams developed flexural shear cracks before failure as can be seen in Fig. 4e and f. The addition of macro synthetic fibers changed the mode of failure of short beams from web-shear cracking to flexural shear cracking. This can be attributed to the fact that macro-synthetic fibers increased the shear strength of the beam to a level that was sufficient to mobilize flexural cracking prior to shear failure.
Slender
(a)
0.50% SNFRC beam Slender
Control RC beam
Control RC beam Short
Short
0.50% SNFRC beam (e)
(b)
0.75% SNFRC beam
0.75% SNFRC beam Slender
(d)
(c)
Short
(f)
Fig. 4 – Cracking sequence and patterns of the tested beams. Comparison with previous studies Few studies [12-14] that report experimental results on the shear capacity of slender concrete beams with different synthetic fibers are compiled and compared to the test results obtained in this study. The properties of the synthetic fibers used in those studies are listed in Table 5.
06-Shear strength.qxd
60
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 60
Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER
The previous published results showed that macro synthetic fibers enhanced the shear strength of the concrete beams. The improvement in shear strength of the SNFRC beams above the control beams due to the addition of macro synthetic fibers are compiled for the different studies in Fig. 5. The results presented in this study showed that macro synthetic fiber reinforced concrete increased the first diagonal cracking strength and the ultimate shear strength relative to the control RC beams as summarized in Table 3. The increase in shear strength above the reference beams ranged between 14% and 30% for slender SNFRC beams depending on the dosage of fibers and by more than 18% to 26% for short beams. This significant improvement in the ultimate shear strength is consistent with published results obtained by these previous investigators as shown in Fig. 5. Table 5 – Properties of synthetic fibers used in previous studies
Researcher
Noghabai[12]
Elastic Tensile Aspect strength, Modulus, ratio MPa MPa 275 2600
Specific Density, g/cc 0.90
Polyolefin
Fiber length, mm 50
Polyolefin
25
-
275
2600
0.90
54
360
375
3500
0.90
50
85
540
9500
0.92
50
63
400
-
0.91
40
90
640
9500
0.91
Fiber material
Polypropylene Majdzadeh et Polypropylene/ al.[13] Polyethylene Greenough et Polypropylene al.[14] Polypropylene/ Current study Polyethylene
% increase above control
50
40
30
20 Noghabai [12] Majdzadeh et al [13] Greenough et al [14] Current study
10
0 0
0.25
0.5
0.75 1 1.25 1.5 Fiber volume fraction
1.75
2
Fig. 5 – Increase in shear strength of slender SNFRC in previous studies
06-Shear strength.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 61
Shear strength and ductility of beams reinforced with synthetic macro-fibers
61
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS The results obtained from large scale testing of 14 longitudinally reinforced concrete beams with macro synthetic fibers were presented and discussed. Slender and short beams with shear span to depth ratios (a/d) of 3.5 and 2.3 were tested. The length of the beams was varied between 1.9 m and 2.7 m, and the macro synthetic fibers were added at volume fractions of 0.50%, 0.75% and 1.0%. Global deflection of the RC beams, load at first diagonal cracking and ultimate load were measured during the test. The cracking pattern was also monitored during the shear tests at different stages of loading. The experimental results showed that the addition of macro synthetic fibers significantly improved the shear strength and ductility of the RC beams and modified the cracking and failure behavior of the RC beams. Macro synthetic fibers at 0.50, 0.75, and 1.0 percent volume fraction increased the ultimate shear strength of slender beams by 14%, 23%, and 30%, respectively compared to the control beams. Similarly, macro synthetic fibers at 0.50% and 0.75% increased the ultimate shear strength of short beams by at least 18% and 26%, respectively. The load versus deflection curves showed that the SNFRC beams are more ductile compared to the control RC beams. The control beams failed abruptly upon the formation of the first diagonal crack whereas the SNFRC beams continued to resist higher load and deflection after the formation of the first diagonal crack. The addition of macro synthetic fibers at 0.50%, 0.75%, and 1.0% increased the deflection at maximum load for slender beams by 63%, 93% and 100% compared to the control beams. Similarly, macro synthetic fibers at 0.50% and 0.75% increased the deflection at maximum load for short beams by 103% and 138% relative to the control RC beams. This increase in the deflection capacity of the SNFRC beams demonstrates the significant improvement in ductility that macro-synthetic fibers could impart to the concrete beams.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Support to this project was provided in part by W.R. Grace, Cambridge, MA, USA; Juma Almajid Company in Dubai; and by the Hazard and Risk Management Research Group at the University of Sharjah. The authors would like to acknowledge support provided for this project. REFERENCES 1. Batson, G.B., E. Jenkins, and R. Spatney, “Steel Fibers as Shear Reinforcement in Beams”, ACI Journal, Proceedings, vol. 69, No. 10, 1972, p. 640-644 2. Calixto, J.M., L.V. Filho, and C.M., “Goncalvez, “Shear behaviour of reinforced concrete beams with the addition of short steel fibers”, in 3rd International Conference on HighPerformance Concrete: Performance and Quality of Concrete Structures, Recife, Pernambuco, Brazil, eds. American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich., 2002 3. Dupont, D. and L. Vandewalle, “Shear Capacity of Concrete Beams Containing Longitudinal Reinforcement and Steel Fibers”, Innovation in Fiber Reinforced Concrete for Value, SP-216, N. Banthia, M. Criswell, P. Tatnall, K. Folliard, eds., American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Mich., 2003, pp. 79-94 4. Li, V., R. Ward, and A.M. Hamza, “Steel and Synthetic Fibers as Shear Reinforcement”, ACI Materials Journal, vol. 89, No. 5, 1992, pp. 499-508 5. Swamy, R.N. and H.M. Bahia, “Effectiveness of Steel Fibers as Shear Reinforcement”, ACI Concrete International, vol. 7 N. 3, 1985, pp. 35-40
06-Shear strength.qxd
62
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 62
Salah ALTOUBAT, Samer BARAKAT, Yazdanbakhsh ARDAVAN and Klaus-Alexander RIEDER
6. Sharma, A.K., “Shear Strength of Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete Beams”, ACI Journal, Proceedings, vol. 83, No. 4, 1986, pp. 624-628 7. Narayanan, R. and I.Y.S. Darwish, “Use of Steel fibers as Shear reinforcement”, ACI Structural Journal, vol. 84, No. 3, 1987, pp. 216-227 8. Mirsayah, A.A. and N. Banthia, “Shear Strength of Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete”, ACI Materials Journal, vol. 99, No. 5, 1987, pp. 473-479 9. Mansur, M.A., K.C.G. Ong, and P. Paramsivam, “Shear Strength of Fibrous Concrete Beams without Stirrups”, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol. 121, No. 9, 1986, pp. 2066-2079 10. Kwak, Y.K., et al., “Shear Strength of Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete Beams without Stirrups”, ACI Structural Journal, vol. 99, No. 4, 2002, pp. 530-538 11. Parra-Montesinos, G.J., “Shear Strength of Beams with Deformed Steel Fibers”, ACI Concrete International, vol. 28, No. 11, 2006, pp. 57-67 12. Noghabai, K., “Beams of Fibrous Concrete in Shear and Bending: Experiment and Mode”, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol. 126, No. 2, 2000, pp. 243-251 13. Majdzadeh, F., M. Soleimani, and N. Banthia, “Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete Beams with a Fiber Concrete Matrix”, Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, vol. 33, 2006, pp. 726-734 14. Greenough, T., Nehdi M., “Shear Behavior of Fiber-Reinforced Self-Consolidating Concrete Slender Beams”, ACI Materials Journal, vol. 105, No. 5, 2008, pp. 468-477 15. Yazdanbakhsh, A., “Shear Behavior of Synthetic Fiber Reinforced Concrete Beams”, Master Thesis in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering. University of Sharjah: Sharjah, UAE, 2008, pp. 125 16. Altoubat, S. A., Yazdanbakhsh, A., Rieder, K.-A.,” Shear Behavior of Macro-Synthetic Fiber Reinforced Concrete Beams without Stirrups” ACI Materials Journal, vol. 106, No. 6, July-Auguts-2009 17. JSCE-SF4, ”Methods of Tests for Flexural Strength and Flexural Toughness of Steel Fiber Reinforced Concrete”, Japan Society of Civil Engineers, Concrete Library International, No. 3, Part III-2, 1984, pp. 58-61 18. ASTM C 1609-07, “Standard Test Method for Flexural Performance of Fiber-Reinforced Concrete (Using Beam With Third-Point Loading),” ASTM International, 2007, West Conshohocken, Pa. 19. Fenwick, R.C. and T. Paulay, “Mechanisms of Shear Resistance of Concrete Beams”, Journal of Structural Division, ASCE, Proceedings, vol. 94, ST10, 1968, pp. 2325-2350
07-The impact.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 63
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
THE IMPACT OF AMOUNT AND LENGTH OF FIBRILLATED POLYPROPYLENE FIBRES ON THE PROPERTIES OF HPC EXPOSED TO HIGH TEMPERATURE Izabela HAGER, Tomasz TRACZ Institute of Building Materials and Structures Cracow University of Technology Warszawska 24, 31-155 Kraków, Poland e-mail:
[email protected];
[email protected]
ABSTRACT This paper presents the results of research on high performance concretes (HPC) modified with polypropylene fibres (PP fibres). The scope of the research was the measurement of the residual transport properties of heated and recooled concretes: gas permeability and surface water absorbability. Seven types of concrete modified with fibrillated PP fibres were tested. Three lengths: 6, 12 and 19 mm and three amounts of fibres: 0, 0.9 and 1.8 kg/m3 were used. The research programme was designed to determine which length of fibres, used in which minimum amount, will, after the fibres melt, permit the development of a connected network and pathway for gases and liquids.
Keywords High performance concretes, high temperature, spalling, PP fibres, gas permeability
INTRODUCTION The behaviour of high performance concrete (HPC) exposed to high temperature can prove a major limitation on the use of such concrete in the construction industry. HPC exposed to high temperature can be prone to explosive spalling, which could result in the exposure of steel reinforcement. This would create a vulnerability in the load-bearing capacity and stability of the structural element. According to various sources (Bazant [1], Hertz [2] , Kalifa et al. [3]), the explosive behaviour of concrete is a combination of two phenomena occurring in parallel in heated concrete: a thermo-mechanical effect and a hydro-thermal effect. The temperature increases the pressure of the gas and liquid contained in the material’s pores, accompanied by rapid moisture vaporization within the surface area of the heated concrete (hydro-thermal effect). Additionally, the difference of thermal strains in layers of concrete with different temperature (thermo-mechanical effect) becomes apparent in the heated material, and the accumulated energy is released violently, resulting in so-called explosive spalling. These two effects together cause unfavourable stresses in the concrete. In situations where stress exceeds the ultimate tensile strength of the concrete, explosive spalling can occur. As numerous tests have shown (Kalifa et al. [4], Nishida et al. [5], Hoff et al. [6] ) polypropylene fibres improve the stability of high performance concrete exposed to high temperature. At temperature near to 170°C the fibres melt. The melted polypropylene is partly absorbed by the cement matrix [4],
07-The impact.qxd
64
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 64
Izabela HAGER and Tomasz TRACZ
creating a network of open pores, which increases permeability, and consequently reduces the internal pressure in the heated concrete. However, the exact mechanism by which PP fibres work is still not fully explained. In research conducted by Kalifa et al. [4], an increase was observed in the micro-cracking of heated concretes with PP fibres compared to concretes without fibres. This suggested that the presence of fibres in the cement matrix may be considered a discontinuity that favours the initiation and development of micro cracks during heating, contributing to an increase in concrete permeability. Moreover, it has been pointed out that when melting, polypropylene undergoes a transition from the crystalline to the amorphous phase (polypropylene density decreases from 910 kg/m3 to 850 kg/m3), which causes its volume to increase by approximately 7%, Pasquini [7]. The results presented here are a continuation of the research carried out by the authors and described in Hager and Tracz [8]. In that study, the properties of two types of concrete were compared: concrete without fibres and concrete with an addition of PP fibres amounting to 1.8 kg/m3. The results obtained suggested that the addition of PP fibres was effective and had the desired impact causing a considerable increase in concrete permeability after melting. The increase in the transport properties of the concrete was confirmed by measurements of its surface absorbability, which demonstrated that the capillary porosity of concrete with fibres when heated to 160÷200°C was higher than that of concrete without fibres. The current research, the results of which are presented in this paper, is an attempt to establish the optimum amount and length of PP fibres. From the technical point of view, the use of polypropylene fibres in quantities amounting to 0.1÷0.2% of concrete volume is an effective way of limiting the occurrence of spalling in HPC; however, there are no reports that would clearly indicate the optimum fibre length. According to the percolation model presented by Bentz [9], given a fixed amount of fibre, long fibres should be more efficient. The objective of this research was to assess the impact of the temperature to which concrete is heated on the concrete’s properties affecting its ability to allow liquid and gas transport. The research included the determination of such properties as gas permeability, surface water absorbability and microporosity for several types of concrete mortars before and after heating. These properties are the most relevant to the quantitative assessment of the effectiveness of polypropylene fibres as an addition limiting the occurrence of spalling in HPC. Moreover, the impact of heating temperature on changes in the compressive strength of samples heated to a temperature of 600oC was also assessed.
MATERIALS AND SAMPLE PREPARATION The study was carried out using concretes made from basalt aggregate and CEM I 52.5R cement. The quantitative and qualitative composition of all high-performance concretes examined was the same, with the exception of the amounts and lengths of the polypropylene fibres used. Fibrillated polypropylene fibres with lengths of 6, 12 and 19 mm, and in amounts of 0, 0.9 and 1.8 kg/m3 were used for the purposes of the research. According to the figures quoted by the manufacturer, the melting temperature for the fibres used was 163°C, and their flash point was 360°C. The fibrillated fibres used had a density of 0.91 g/cm3. Cylindrical samples with a diameter of 150 mm and 50 mm high were used for gas permeability and surface water absorbability measurements. These samples were sawn out from 150/300 mm standard cylinders. Compressive strength was determined using 100 mm cubic samples. All samples were formed and cured in compliance with the PN-EN 12390-2 standard, and the tests were conducted after 90 days of curing. Detailed compositions of the concretes that were prepared together with their designations are shown in Table 1.
07-The impact.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 65
The impact of amount and length of fibrillated polypropylene fibres on the properties of HPC exposed to high temperature
65
Cement CEM I 52,5
kg/m3
490
Water
kg/m3
145
Sand 0/2 mm
kg/m3
611
Basalt aggregates 2/8 mm
3
kg/m
712
Basalt aggregates 8/16 mm Fibrilated PP fibres: length 6 mm length 12 mm length 19 mm
kg/m3
712
Plasticizer
% mc
0.9
Superplasticizer
% mc
1.0 ÷ 2.0
kg/m3 kg/m3 kg/m3
-
B100/1.8/19
B100/0.9/19
B100/1.8/12
B100/1.8/6
Type of component
B100/0.9/6
Unit
B100
Concrete labels
B100/0.9/12
Table 1 Mix designs of HPC with and without PP fibres
0.9 1.8 - 0.9 1.8 - 0.9 1.8
Complementary data Water-cement ratio
-
0.30
Cement paste content
dm3/m3
§ 310
Mortar content
dm3/m3
514
MEASUREMENT RESULTS AND ANALYSIS Concrete samples were heated in a Nabertherm LH30/13 furnace at a constant rate of 1°C/min. After the target temperature had been reached, the samples were heated for a further two hours in order to stabilise the temperature over their entire cross-section. The next stage was the free cooling of samples in the furnace to room temperature. Therefore all the properties established are residual ones. This procedure was applied to all the samples examined. Permeability Gas (nitrogen) permeability was determined using the RILEM-Cembureau method for samples with a diameter of 150 mm and a height of 50 mm cut from 150/300 mm standard cylinders. Permeability measurements started with the determination of initial permeability for samples dried to constant mass at a temperature of 105oC, according to the guidelines for the method applied described in RILEM Technical Recommendation [10]. Subsequently, the samples were heated to temperature ranging from 140 to 200oC, and their permeability was measured following cooling. The measurement results presented in Figure 1 show the ratio of permeability of concrete after heating to its permeability before heating (initial permeability). Each measurement series comprised three samples.
07-The impact.qxd
66
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 66
Izabela HAGER and Tomasz TRACZ
Fig. 1 Relative change in average HPC permeability with and without polypropylene fibres added depending on heating temperature. An increase in heating temperature causes residual permeability to rise. For concrete without fibres (B100) and concrete with a small addition of short fibres (B100/0.9/6), this increase is relatively small. At 160oC, a significant increase in residual permeability starts to takes place, and at the same time considerable differences with respect to its value start to emerge. An addition of 12 mm and 19 mm long fibres had a very large impact on the increase of concrete permeability after heating. An addition of 0.9 kg/m3 of 12 mm long fibres (B100/0.9/12) caused a 12-fold increase in permeability after heating to 200oC compared to the initial value. When the amount of these fibres was doubled to 1.8 kg/m3, a 45-fold increase in permeability was recorded. When analysing measurement results, the immense impact of 12 mm fibre dosage was observed. For 19 mm long fibres, even higher permeability was recorded, but the impact of dosage was not as significant as for 12 mm long ones. Surface Water Absorbability Changes in surface water absorbability in g/cm2 over time were measured for cylindrical samples heated to 140, 160, 180 and 200oC following permeability measurements. The increase in sample mass was recorded at intervals of 60 seconds and with an accuracy of ±0.01 g. During measurements, one sample surface was in permanent contact with water. Irrespective of the amount of water absorbed by the samples tested, the water level remained constant during the measurement, i.e. for 72 hours. The measurement set-up is shown in Fig. 2. Selected measurement results are presented in two sections. In section one, test results depend on the quantity of fibres used, and in section two, test results depend on their length. In Figure 3, changes in surface water absorbability in g/cm2 following heating for concrete samples without fibre additions and for concrete samples with 0.9 and 1.8 kg/m3 of 12 mm long fibres added are shown.
07-The impact.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 67
The impact of amount and length of fibrillated polypropylene fibres on the properties of HPC exposed to high temperature
67
Fig. 2 Set-up for measuring water absorbability. The curves on Figure 3 demonstrate significant variation in the magnitude of the increase in surface water absorbability of the concretes tested as a result of heating. Concrete without fibres (B100) exhibits an increase in the value measured during the initial heating phase for a heating temperature of 200oC. A similar trend can be observed for concretes that contain 0.9 kg/m3 of 12 mm long fibres. For a larger amount of fibres (1.8 kg/m3), surface water absorbability is already starting to increase in temperature exceeding 140oC. This is reflected in the results of the residual permeability measurements presented above. Heating the B100/1.8/12 concrete to 160oC caused residual permeability to increase more than 25fold, while for the B100/0.9/12 concrete, only a six-fold increase in the value measured was observed.
Fig. 3 Changes in the surface water absorbability of HPC without fibres (B100) and with fibres (B100/0.9/12 and B100/1.8/12) caused by heating to 140, 160, 180 and 200oC
Figure 4 presents the results of measurements concerning the impact of the length of the PP fibres on the magnitude of surface water absorbability changes as a result of heating.
07-The impact.qxd
68
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 68
Izabela HAGER and Tomasz TRACZ
Fig. 4 Changes in the surface water absorbability of HPC with 1.8 kg/m3 of 6, 12 and 19 mm long fibres caused by heating to 140, 160, 180 and 200oC. As the tests carried out have shown, it is not only the quantity of PP fibres added that has an impact on the surface water absorbability of heated concretes, but also their length. In general, as the length of the fibres used increases, changes in concrete surface water absorbability become more pronounced. It is probable that 19 mm long fibres added to concretes heated to 160oC or higher create a continuous network of interconnected capillary pores, which affects the magnitude of surface water absorbability increase during the first few hours of soaking. Porosity In order to explain the changes observed in properties affecting the ability of heated concrete to transport gas and water, tests were carried out to determine the microporosity distribution in mortars extracted from the HPCs tested. Concretes with additions of 0.9 kg/m3 of 6 mm long fibres and 1.8 kg/m3 of 19 mm long fibres were selected for testing. Measurements concerned the microporosity of concretes before heating and after heating to 180oC. Measurement results are presented in Figure 5.
Fig. 5 Distributions of porosity in mortar samples determined using the mercury porosimetry method
07-The impact.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 69
The impact of amount and length of fibrillated polypropylene fibres on the properties of HPC exposed to high temperature
69
Before heating, very similar porosity distributions were observed for HPC mortars with different additions of PP fibres. After heating to 180C, the overall porosity of B100/0.9/6 concrete mortar rose from 0.058 to 0.068 cm3/cm3, while for the B100/1.8/19 concrete, the increase was from 0.061 to 0.101 cm3/cm3. The change observed does not result from the additional porosity caused by the melting of polypropylene fibres. It is most probably the result of the increase in the micro-cracking of heated concretes with fibres described by Kalifa et al. [4]. Residual Compressive Strength Compressive strength and its change as a function of temperature were determined using 100 mm cubic samples. Two samples of each concrete type were heated to 120, 160, 200, 250, 400 and 600°C, and their compressive strengths were tested after cooling. Residual strength and compressive strength results for unheated samples are presented in Figure 6.a. In Figure 6.b, relative changes in residual compressive strength are shown.
a)
b)
Fig. 6 Impact of heating temperature on absolute and relative changes in residual compressive strength On the basis of the Figures shown, it may be concluded that concrete strength initially declines as a result of heating to 120oC, and then, at 250oC, the strength is partially restored. Further heating leads to a steady decrease in strength caused, inter alia, by the dehydration of the CSH gel, portlandite decomposition and the destruction of the contact zone due to the different thermal expansion coefficients of cement paste and aggregate. On the basis of the compressive strength test results shown above, it may be concluded that this property does not vary considerably for the concretes tested. The results obtained for unheated and heated concrete samples without fibres do not differ significantly from the results obtained for concretes with 0.9 kg/m3 and 1.8 kg/m3 of PP fibres added.
07-The impact.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 70
70
Izabela HAGER and Tomasz TRACZ
CONCLUSIONS The following conclusions may be stated on the basis of the measurements presented above: x Both the amount and length of polypropylene fibres added has an impact on the magnitude of changes in residual permeability caused by HPC heating. x The greatest increase in the residual permeability of heated concretes can be observed in samples in which 1.8 kg/m3 of 12 or 19 mm long fibres have been added. x Permeability measurements using the RILEM-Cembureau method are very useful when evaluating the effectiveness of adding polypropylene fibres which, after melting, enables water vapour to be evacuated from heated concrete and its pressure to be reduced. x The addition of polypropylene fibres to HPCs heated to temperature ranging from 160 to 200oC affects the capillary porosity of the cement matrix, which is confirmed by measurements of changes in surface water absorbability over time. x Microporosity measurements indicate a significant increase in the quantity of pores with diameters of less than 1 Pm in concrete with fibres (B100/1.8/19) heated to 180oC. The change observed does not stem from the additional porosity caused by melting polypropylene fibres, but is rather the result of an increase in the micro-cracking of heated concrete with PP fibres. x Compressive strength determined as a function of temperature indicates that, for the concretes tested, the presence of fibres and their length do not affect this property significantly. x The research results presented confirm the need for further tests aimed at confirming the beneficial effect of PP fibres on reducing spalling in real HPC elements during fires. REFERENCES 1.
Bazant Z. P.: Analysis of pore pressure, thermal stresses and fracture in rapidly heated concrete, Int. Workshop on fire performance of high strength concrete, February 1997, NIST Maryland, pp. 13-14, 2. Hertz K.: Limits of Spalling of Fire Exposed Concrete, Fire Safety Journal, Vol. 38, 2003, pp 103-116, 3. Kalifa P., Menneteau F.D., Quenard D.: Spalling and pore pressure in HPC at high temperature, Cement and Concrete Research, August 2000, pp 1915-1927, 4. Kalifa P., Chéné G., Gallé C.: High-temperature behaviour of HPC with polypropylene fibers: From spalling to microstructure, Cement and Concrete Research, Vol. 31, Issue 10, October 2001, pp. 1487-1499, 5. Nishida A., Yamazaki N., Inoue H., Schneider U., Diederichs U.: Study on the properties of high strength concrete with short polypropylene fibre for spalling resistance, Concrete Under Severe Conditions Environment and Loading, vol. 2. 1995, 6. Hoff A., Bilodeau A. and Malhotra V.M.: Elevated Temperature, Effects on HSC, Residual Strength, Concrete International, 2000, pp. 41-47 7. Pasquini, N. Polypropylene handbook, 2nd Edition, Hanser Publishers, Munich, 2005. 8. Hager I., Tracz T.: Influence of high temperature on selected properties of high performance concrete modified with the addition of polypropylene fibres, Cement-LimeConcrete, January / February 2009, nr 1, p. 3 9. Bentz, D.P.: Fibers, percolation, and spalling of high performance concrete, ACI Journal 97, 3, 2000, pp. 351-359 10. RILEM Technical Recommendation: Tests for gas permeability of concrete, TC 116PCD: Permeability of concrete as criterion of its durability, Materials and Structures, vol. 32, April 1999, 174-179
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 71
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
ASSESSMENT BY LAW OF MIXTURES APPROACH OF INTERFACIAL ADHESION STRENGTH IN CELLULOSE-CEMENT COMPOSITES Conrado S. RODRIGUES1, Piet STROEVEN2, Khosrow GHAVAMI3 Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Federal Centre for Technological Education of Minas Gerais, CEFET-MG, Brazil,
[email protected] 2 Full Professor, Department of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, TU Delft The Netherlands,
[email protected] 3 Full Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Pontifical Catholic University, PUC-Rio Brasil,
[email protected] 1
ABSTRACT Cellulosic-pulp-reinforced cement sheets are produced in large scale for more than 25 years. This followed studies that had focused on the fibre and matrix characteristics, and on their composite behaviour, solving to a limited extent the problems arising from fibre-matrix incompatibility and deterioration due to alkali attack. In spite of that, much has yet to be done in terms of providing a material with properties competitive with those of asbestos cement, mainly considering their long term performances. Current research on cellulose-pulp reinforced cement composites concentrates on evaluating the deterioration mechanisms, the treatment methods and the modelling of the effects of these mechanisms on the physical, mechanical and micro-structural aspects of the material. Interfacial adhesion governs the mechanical behaviour and many physical properties of composites. Therefore, it is a key issue when focusing on durability, since the deterioration mechanisms and the treatment methods exert direct influences on the fibre-matrix interface. Direct assessment of adhesion strength by pull-out tests on fibres generally shorter than 2 mm in cellulose-cement composites presents practical difficulties. Also, direct application of the equations derived from the composite’s micromechanics to this type of cement composites, as produced by the vacuum-dewatering process, and containing high volume fractions of curly fibres would be problematic. Fortunately, a significant amount of data is available in the literature regarding the physical and mechanical behaviour of cellulose-cement composites of a variety of compositions and produced under similar conditions. This allows establishing mutual correlations. This is used as reference framework for the design of the cellulose-cement compositions tested by the authors. The outcomes reveal this approach a valuable tool in comparative studies on the mechanical behaviour of cellulose-cement composites dealing with effects of treatment methods, deterioration mechanisms and processing parameters.
Keywords Cellulose-cement composites, interfacial adhesion, mechanical behaviour, semi empirical formulation
INTRODUCTION With the need to replace asbestos fibres in cement composites, cellulosic reinforcement has always being considered a viable alternative. Since the 70´s there has been a significant amount of data in the literature regarding the raw materials, production processes and properties of cellulose-pulp-reinforcing cement composites. Mostly, the many variables investigated are considered on the basis of their effects on the mechanical behaviour of the composites; more specifically, on the bending tests results. In spite of the amount of experimental data collected in three decades, there is not an analytical approach describing the
08-Assessment by law.qxd
72
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 72
Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI
behaviour of these composites, as for other materials produced commercially, such as de semi empirical formulations for asbestos-cement and for steel fibre reinforced concrete [1, 2]. The law of mixtures is the most usual approach for a preliminary evaluation of the mechanical behaviour of composites. For many types of composites, the law of mixtures and its variations result in a good approximation for the mechanical parameters [3], being a key tool for the design, materials selection and processing control in the composites’ industry. In the case of high performance fibre-cement sheets, with a high reinforcement content and produced by the vacuum-dewatering process, the application of the law of mixtures presents practical difficulties resulting from the characteristics of these composites, including: a) the high reinforcement contents used prevent uniform fibre distribution in the matrix, favouring the formation of fibre bundles; b) the cellulosic pulp fibres are not uniform in length and the length distribution is depending on the source of the pulp; c) due to their low modulus, the fibres can curve during composite production, reducing their efficiency as reinforcement; and d) the small length of the fibres seriously complicate carrying out pull-out tests, impairing the direct assessment of the interfacial adhesion between the fibres and the matrix that would allow experimental basis for assessment of the efficiency factors [4]. Nevertheless, the law of mixtures concept has yielded good approximation with experimental data for asbestos reinforced cement composites, despite facing similar difficulties [2]. The use of cellulosic pulp as reinforcement results in fibre-matrix interaction that is quite different from that observed for the asbestos-cement, requiring different parameters to be adopted for the law of mixtures equations. Thus, based on data from the literature and the results of experiments carried out by the authors, empirical equations and the formulation from the law of mixtures were investigated, considering cellulosic pulpreinforced cement composites.
METHODOLOGY Among the vast literature related to the mechanical performance of fibre cements with cellulosic pulp reinforcements, articles were selected based on common characteristics that enabled comparative studies of the properties reported. In this sense, data were considered related to composites produced by the vacuum-dewatering process, whose bending tests followed the same methodology (such as the moisture content of the specimens). The papers had to present results on the modulus of elasticity (MOE), the bending strength (Vu), the apparent porosity (p) and also data regarding the reinforcement characterization, at least average fibres’ length. These requisites greatly limited the number of studies considered. The composites produced by the authors are based on kraft bamboo pulp reinforcement. Also, a modified matrix is considered by blending the cement with different amounts of rice husk ash. Characterization of the raw materials, the composite production and the experiments carried out have been reported in a previous study [5].
RESULTS Empirical relationships based on relevant data in the literature It was intended to compare empirical relationships between fibre content, on the one side, and stiffness, strength and porosity, on the other side, with estimates from the law of mixtures approach. In the first, fibre content is described in terms of binder mass, whereas in the law of mixtures the fibre and matrix fractions are described in terms of volume. Therefore, a correlation had to be established among the reinforcement percentages in mass and volume.
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 73
Assessment by law of mixtures approach of interfacial adhesion strength in cellulose-cement composites
73
An approximate expression was developed assuming that: a) the cellulosic pulp density was 1500 kg/m3, a value reported for a kraft Pinus radiatta pulp [2]; b) square 120mm fibrecement sheets produced by the vacuum-dewatering process employed a fixed 120g of blended cement; and c) the sheets with reinforcement rates ranging from 2 to 14% had an average thickness of 6.5mm. Therefore, the sheet volume was around 93,600 mm3. From these considerations, the relationship between the fibre volume fraction, Vf (in relation to the volume of the fibre-cement sheets), and the fraction in mass, Mf (related to the blended cement weight) can be expressed by Vf
120 M f 1.5 x93.6
0.86 M f
(1)
Data in the literature reporting the physical and mechanical properties of cellulosicpulp-reinforced fibre-cements were used to verify the dependence of these properties on reinforcement content. For this purpose, composites reinforced with bamboo pulp submitted to conventional moist curing [6, 7] and accelerated autoclave curing [8] were considered, in addition to studies with banana [9] and Pinus radiatta pulps [10], both in fibre-cements submitted to conventional curing. Figs. 1 and 2 show the dependence of MOE and porosity on fibre content. It was observed that MOE decreased with fibre content due to the additional porosity incorporated into the composites with the cellulosic reinforcement [1, 2]. Furthermore, the correlations were similar for the different composites considered, even considering that these composites were produced by using different infrastructures. Fig. 2 shows that the matrix of the composites submitted to autoclave curing was more porous than that of composites submitted to normal curing, but the increasing rate of porosity with Vf was similar to the other composites considered.
Figure 1: Empirical relations of MOE with Vf
Figure 2: Empirical relations of porosity with Vf
According to the linear regression of the experimental data in Figs.1 and 2 dealing with composites with normal curing, the unreinforced matrix yields values for MOE and p of about 17 GPa and 27%, respectively. The dependence of MOE and porosity on Vf in these materials can be approximately expressed by p Vf 0.27 MOE
110V f 17
(2) (3)
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
74
11:58 AM
Page 74
Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI
This allows correlating MOE and porosity by MOE
110 p 0.27 17
110 p 46.7
(4)
Fig. 3 shows the dependence of bending strength, Vu on Vf for different composites not to follow an approximate common equation as found for MOE. While MOE was a function principally of porosity of the matrix and interface, Vu depends also on the adherence conditions, and, consequently, on particular characteristics of matrix and reinforcement. We are confronted here with differences in structure-sensitivity between MOE and Vu [11].
Figure 3: Empirical relationships of Vu versus Vf Mechanical parameters of fibre-cement due to law of mixtures approach MOE (Young’s Modulus) The basic formulation of the law of mixtures for short fibres defines efficiency factors related to length (K1) and orientation distribution (K2) of the fibres as expressed by [1] Ec
Em 1 Vf Ș1Ș2 Ef Vf
(5)
in which Ec, Em and Ef are the Young´s Modulus of composites, matrix and fibres, respectively; and Vf is the volume fraction of fibres. In the case of cellulosic-pulp-reinforced fibre-cements there are practical difficulties in defining K1 and K2. This is due to: the small fibre length, the lack of dimensional uniformity and their flexibility and curling during production. Furthermore, Em was considered constant for different fibre volumetric fractions, despite Fig. 2 and eq. (4) showing that with the increase in the reinforcement contents there was an increase in the incorporated porosity (mainly at the interface), resulting in reduced stiffness of the matrix and interface. In agreement with Aveston et al. [2, 12] it is assumed that the pull-out resistance of ductile fibres in cementitious matrices is not depending on the angle of inclination. Thus, the efficiency factor is solely governed by the number of fibres that cross the fractured surface. For the case of random fibres in the plane this leads to K2 = 2/S [1, 4, 12]. To consider the correlation between the composite’s porosity and the reinforcement rate, the empirical relationship between p and Vf of eq. (2) was combined with the law of mixtures expression in eq. (5). Thus, the matrix volume fraction, Vm, is given by (1-Vf - p(Vf)), instead of by (1-Vf). Also, Em = 17 GPa was derived from the empirical relationship, eq. (3), while Ef = 40 GPa was taken from the literature [13, 14]. The MOE of cellulosic pulp-reinforced fibrecement is then described by
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 75
Assessment by law of mixtures approach of interfacial adhesion strength in cellulose-cement composites
MOE
Em (1 Vf p (Vf )) K Ef Vf ? MOE
MOE 12.41 8.4Vf
Em (1 Vf (Vf 0.27)) K Ef Vf ?
75
(6)
An increase in Vf from 2 to 14% would result according to eq. (6) in a decline in MOE from 12.2 GPa to 11.2 GPa. This is not reflected by the experimental data used in Fig. 1 and in eq. (3), however.
Vu (Bending strength) Application of the law of mixtures concept for estimating tensile and bending strength of asbestos cement composites yielded good correlation with experimental results, [2]. The contribution of the matrix was neglected when considering tensile performance; fibre strength (Vf) was determined assuming a bonding strength of W 2.4 MPa in accordance with a regression analysis of experimental data [2, 15]. The matrix is taken into consideration for estimating Vu; good correlation with experimental data is observed for asbestos-cement, assuming an aspect ratio of fibres lf / d f = 160 and bonding strength of 0.83 MPa, [2]. The expression for the law of mixtures estimate the bending strength for cellulosic-pulpreinforced fibre-cements V u V m (1 V f ) KV f V f
(7)
requires the definition of the fibre and matrix strength, Vf and Vm, respectively, and the efficiency factor, K. The linear regression of experimental results for different composites reported in the literature (Fig. 3) revealed the plain matrix bending strength (Vm) to range from 9.6 to 12.5 MPa; an approximate value of 10 MPa was adopted. Further, an efficiency factor K= 2/S was used [1, 4, 12]. In this case, the 2D distribution of the fibres was the tendency observed during the production of fibrecements following the vacuum-dewatering method. Regarding the fibre strength, Vf = 500 MPa was obtained by estimation from composite data on Pinus radiatta pulp available in the literature [2, 13]. As a consequence of these considerations, Fig. 4 shows good correlation between the Vu dependence on Vf as given by eq. (7) and the experimental data for the composites with this particular type of reinforcement (Pinus radiatta, in Fig. 3).
Figure 4: Comparison between bending strength by law of mixtures and experimental data However, for the other composites the same approach did not yield good correlation. This is mainly due to the high Vf adopted for Pinus radiatta kraft pulp, which may not occur in the other fibres. The correlation between Vu and Vf became more compatible to the other
08-Assessment by law.qxd
76
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 76
Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI
composites when Vf = 200 MPa was adopted. In this case, the distribution of Vu with Vf was close to that observed in composites with cellulosic pulp submitted to normal curing [6]. For cement composites reinforced by cellulosic pulps, in which the fibres contribution is governed by pull-out, the equilibrium for a single fibre is expressed by [2] Vf
§ lf 2W ¨ ¨d © f
· ¸ ¸ ¹
(8)
In the present case, eq. (8) yields an adhesion strength of W = 1.33 MPa when Vf = 200 MPa. When efficiency is reduced by a factor 2/S, this leads to a value of KW = 0.85 MPa. The values of fibre length (lf =1.5mm) and diameter (df = 20Pm) measured by authors were employed in this case. Hence, aspect ratio lf / df = 75. The experimental dependence of bending strength on fibre length was considered to verify the goodness of fit of this average value of adherence tension for other cellulosic pulp composites. For this purpose, data from the literature were used where the mechanical properties of composites submitted to conventional curing were reported together with the characteristics of the reinforcement. The correlation of Vu with lf shown in Fig. 5 considered composites with reinforcements of bamboo [6], Pinus radiatta [13], banana [16], sisal [16, 17], pineapple [18], eucalyptus [16] and recycled paper [19], and referred to an 8% reinforcement rate (on weight basis). Using the general equation of the law of mixtures (eq. (7)) in which Vf was given by eq. (8) and KW = 0.85 MPa, and assuming that the fibres of the different reinforcements had an average 20m diameter, the following expression was derived Vu
0.93V m 5.84l f
(9)
Fig. 4 shows that the approximation represented by eq. (9), adopting Vm=10 MPa, had a correlated properly with the experimental data points, and was close to their linear regression line. Thus, the adhesion strength calculated from a fibre tensile strength estimated at 200 MPa, was shown to be a good approximation for fibre cements reinforced by cellulosic pulp with 1 to 3.5mm long fibres, even considering that each experimental point in Fig. 5 represents a different composite regarding the type of reinforcement, matrix and composites’ production infrastructure.
Figure 5: Vu versus lf - experimental results and approximation by law of mixtures concept Adhesion strength of cellulosic-pulp-reinforced cement due to law of mixtures approach Table 1 shows the mechanical properties obtained by bending tests carried out on plain cement pastes and fibre-cements reinforced by bamboo pulp with a constant 8% fibre content
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 77
Assessment by law of mixtures approach of interfacial adhesion strength in cellulose-cement composites
77
(in relation to dry cement weight) [5]. In these composites, the matrix was modified by partial substitution of Portland cement by rice husk ash with high (RHA-I) and low (RHA-II) carbon content. The nomenclature of the different materials considered in Table 1 is as follows: CP15-II refers to the composite (CP) with 15% cement replacement with RHA-II. Further, the results concern materials tested under two moisture regimes: in equilibrium (stored at 23°C, 50% UR before the tests) and saturated, indicated by indices “eq” and “sat”, respectively. Table 1. Mechanical parameters of cellulosic pulp reinforced fibre cements Composites M0 M15-I M30-I CP0 CP15-I CP30-I CP15-II CP30-II
Vu
Vi(eq)
Vi(sat)
KW
KW1
MPa 12.93 14.72 13.32 15.53 14.61 11.86 15.31 16.51
MPa
MPa
MPa
MPa
12.85 11.90 9.51 13.95 15.78
7.86 9.26 9.51 6.75 6.66
0.36 0.35 0.30 0.24 0.19
0.54 0.33 0.07 0.75 0.94
Figs. 3 and 4 show that adoption of an adhesion strength of KW = 0.85 MPa for fibrecements reinforced by 8% bamboo pulp submitted to conventional curing enabled the description of an approximate correlation between the bending strength and lf. However, this approach did not ascertain how modifications in the matrix and interface (whether by different compositions, or by deterioration mechanisms) affect the interfacial adherence strength. The law of mixtures equations was again used to verify the influence of incorporating rice husk ash on the interfacial adherence of bamboo pulp reinforced fibre cement. In this case, the adhesion strengthKW was determined from experimental data of Vu pertaining to different fibre-cements. Thus, considering lf / d f = 75 and a reinforcement content on weight basis of 8% (Vf = 0.86 x 0.08), the adhesion strength can be obtained by Vu
V m 1 0.08 x0.86 2KW 75 x0.08 x0.86 ? KW
V u 0.93V m 10.32
(10)
Analysis of the composites of which the mechanical properties of corresponding plain pastes were determined (CP0, CP15-I and CP30-I), demonstrated that only CP0 revealed bending strength significantly higher than that of the corresponding plain matrix (M0) resulting in a KW adhesion strength of the order of 0.34 MPa (much lower than the 0.85 MPa adopted as approximation in eq. (9) and in Fig. 5). The non-significant differences between the Vu values of composites with RHA-I and of the corresponding plain pastes, M15-1 and M30-I, reflect very low adhesion strength to be obtained by eq. (10), in conflict with the real interactions at the interface of these composites. Since it was observed that the Vu was significantly higher than the limit of proportionality (Vi) in these composites [20], it can be concluded that there was energy absorption by fibres and interface after the matrix cracking. Thus, interfacial adhesion in the composites of different constitutions can be assessed more realistically when identifying Vi as the as the matrix resistance of the composites (Vm). The interfacial adhesion resulted from the difference of the bending stresses Vu - Vi, obtained from specimens in equilibrium condition, is related to the frictional (mechanical) adherence KW2, acting during the pull-out of the fibres after the matrix cracking. Thus, KW2 did not consider the fibre-matrix adhesion during the elastic stage of the loading, where the chemical interaction KW1 prevailed, [21]. High KW1 levels indicate composites with enhanced
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
78
11:58 AM
Page 78
Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI
chemical interaction between fibres and matrix, leading to a higher resistance to matrix cracking. Therefore, the bending strength of the composites was related to the set of interfacial adhesion strength values, KW and KW. Considering the Vi of composites tested under the aforementioned equilibrium and saturated conditions, it could be detected that saturation decreases the chemical adhesion between fibres and matrix, resulting in Vi significantly lower in the saturated state (Table 1). When it is assumed that the resistance to matrix cracking is much less sensitive to saturation than the interactions at the interface, this would point towards chemical adherence among the fibres and the matrix being responsible for the relatively high Vi values manifested by the composites under equilibrium condition. Thus, the difference between the Vi values obtained in the equilibrium and saturated states, respectively, can be used to calculate the chemical adherence (pre-cracking). So, KW 2 KW 1
V u ( eq ) 0.93V i ( eq )
(11)
10.32
V i ( eq ) 0.93V i ( sat ) 10.32
Table 1 and Fig. 6 show the adhesion strength calculated for the fibre-cements studied. These parameters contribute to mechanical characterization, and enable the assessment of the energy absorption mechanisms acting in the elastic phase of the loading and after the matrix cracking. These results refer to fibre-cements subjected to standard moisture curing.
Figure 6: Interfacial adhesion strength in the bamboo cellulosic pulp-reinforced fibre-cements
In the composites submitted to conventional curing it was observed that KW2 presented values ranging from 0.19 to 0.36 MPa and KW1 from 0.07 to 0.94 MPa. The analysis of these results corroborated previous conclusions regarding the influence of rice husk ash (RHA) on the mechanical performance of bamboo cellulosic pulp-reinforced fibre-cements [20]. RHA-I did not favour the chemical interaction among fibres and matrix, so, did not permit extra energy absorption through the pull-out mechanism. Contrary, composites with RHA-II presented higher chemical adhesion, with less energy absorption in the form of pull-out in the post cracking phase. CONCLUSIONS Based on experimental data of the mechanical performance of cellulosic pulp-reinforced fibre-cements reported in the literature, a study was carried out addressing the suitability of the law of mixtures concept in describing these properties.
08-Assessment by law.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 79
Assessment by law of mixtures approach of interfacial adhesion strength in cellulose-cement composites
79
Fibre-cement stiffness was shown to be not very sensitive to variations in the fibre and matrix characteristics. Thus, it was observed that the different fibre-cements obey an approximate common expression relating stiffness to fibre volume fraction. However, the law of mixtures concept cannot satisfactorily represent the empirical stiffness results, as dependence on Vf is a function mainly of the porosity associated with modifications in fibre reinforcement, which is difficult to describe in terms of isolated matrix and fibre characteristics. Bending strength (Vu) is a function of specific reinforcement and matrix characteristics. There is not a common approximate expression that reflects the dependence of Vu on Vf for experimental data of different composites. However, when different composites with similar reinforcement rates were considered, the law of mixtures concept provided a relationship between Vu and average fibre length (lf) that correlated well with the experimental data. Also, this expression of Vu versus lf considers an approximate value for the adhesion strength which varies only as a function of the fibre length, regardless the different fibres, matrix and composites’ production infrastructure considered. Because this expression satisfactorily represents empirical data in the literature, this approach is instrumental in assessing the effects of modification in the fibrecement matrix on the interfacial adhesion strength. Hence, the mechanical parameters of bending tests of bamboo-pulp-reinforced fibrecements allowed evaluation of the interfacial adhesion strength values by law of mixtures concept. This finally made it possible to establish the structural effects of partial substitution of cement by rice husk ash.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank the public research agencies FAPEMIG, CAPES and CNPq, that supported this study financially; and ABMTENC, that encourages and brings together researchers of unconventional materials and technologies. REFERENCES 1. Hannant, D.J. Fibre cements and fibre concretes, John Wiley & Sons, 1978 2. Bentur, A., Mindess, S. Fibre reinforced cementitious composites, 2nd ed. Taylor & Francis, 2007 3. Jones, R.M. Mechanics of Composite Materials, McGraw-Hill Company, 1975 4. Stroeven, P., Stereological principles of spatial modeling applied to steel fiber reinforced concrete in tension. Mat. J. A.C.I., 2009 (accepted for publication) 5. Rodrigues, C. S., Ghavami, K., Stroeven, P. Porosity and water permeability of rice husk ash-blended cement composites reinforced with bamboo pulp, J. Mat. Sci. 41, 2006, 69256937 6. Coutts, R.S.P., Tobias, B.C. Air-cured bamboo pulp reinforced cement, J. Mat. Sci., Letters, 13, 1994, 283-285 7. Anjos, M.A.S., Ghavami, K., Barbosa, N.P. Cement based composites reinforced by bamboo pulp. Part I- determination of the optimum reinforcement rate. Brazilian J. Agricul. Environ. Engn., 7, 2003, 139-145 (in Portuguese) 8. Coutts, R.S.P., Ni, Y. Autoclaved bamboo pulp fibre reinforced cement. Cem. Concr. Comp., 17, 1995, 99-106 9. Zhu, W.H., Tobias, B.C, Coutts, R.S.P., Langfors, G. Air-cured banana-fibre-reinforced cement composites. Cem. Concr. Comp., 16, 1994, 3-8 10. Coutts, R.S.P., Warden, P.G. Air-cured, wood pulp, fibre cement composites. J. Mat. Sci.
08-Assessment by law.qxd
80
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 80
Conrado S. RODRIGUES, Piet STROEVEN and Khosrow GHAVAMI
Letters, 4, 1985, 7-119 11. Stroeven, P., Hu, J., Stochastic heterogeneity as fundamental basis for the design and evaluation of experiments. Cem. Concr. Comp., 30, 2008, 506-514 12. Aveston, J., Mercer, R.A., Sillwood, J.M. Fibre reinforced cements – scientific foundations for specifications. In: “Composites, standards, testing and design”. Proc. National Physical Laboratory Conference, UK, 1974, 499-508 13. Coutts, R.S.P. Wood fibre reinforced cement composites. In: “Concrete technology and design, volume 5: Natural fibre reinforced cement and concrete”, Swamy, R.N. ed., Blackie and Son Ltd, Glasgow, 1988, 1-62 14. Fördös, Z., Tram, B. Natural fibres as reinforcement in cement-based composites. In: Swamy, R.N., Wagstaffe, R.L., Oakley, D.R., eds. Rilem 3rd International Symposium on Developments in Fibre Reinforced Cement and Concrete - Vol. 1, Rilem Symposium FRC 86, 1986, pp.6 15. Akers, S.A.S., Garrett, G.G. Fibre-matrix interface effects in asbestos-cement composites. J. Mat. Sci., 18, 1983, 2200-2208 16. Savastano Jr., H., Warden, P.G., Coutts, R.S.P. In: “Performance of low-cost vegetable fibre-cement composites under weathering”, Proc. CIB World Building Congress. Wellington-New Zealand, April 1st–6th 2001, 1-11, www.irbdirekt.de/daten/iconda/CIB3084.pdf
17. Savastano Jr., H., Warden, P.G., Coutts, R.S.P. Mechanically pulped sisal as reinforcement in cementitious matrices. Cem. Concr. Comp., 25, 2003, 311-319 18. Coutts, R.S.P., Warden, P.G. Air-cured abaca reinforced cement composites. Int. J. Cem. Comp. Lightw. Concr., 9, 1987, 69-73 19. Coutts, R.S.P. Wastepaper fibres in cement products. Int. J. Cem. Comp. Lightw. Concr., 11, 1989, 143-147 20. Rodrigues, C.S., Ghavami, K. The influence of rice husk ash on physical and mechanical properties of high performance cellulose-cement composites. In: Proc. First Colloquium on Non-Conventional Materials Brazil-Colombia, Cali - Colombia, May 23rd - 26th 2005, 1-11, (available on CD-Rom) 21. Coutts, R.S.P., Kightly, P. Bonding in wood fibre-cement composites. J. Mat. Sci. 19, 1984, 3355-3359
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 81
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
TENSILE FATIGUE RESPONSE OF SISAL FIBER REINFORCED CEMENT COMPOSITES Flávio de Andrade SILVA1, Barzin MOBASHER2 and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO3 1 Institute of Construction Materials, Technical University of Dresden, 01062 Dresden, Germany, e-mail:
[email protected] 2 Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287-8706, USA, e-mail:
[email protected] 3 Department of Civil Engineering Alberto Luiz Coimbra Institute – Graduate School and Research in Engineering (COPPE) Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ) P.O. Box 68506, 21945 – 970, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil, e-mail:
[email protected]
ABSTRACT Tensile fatigue behavior of composite materials are of significant interest since in structural applications they are often subjected to cyclic loading. However, very few results for fiber reinforced concrete under cyclic load have been reported. In the present research sustainable cement composites were produced by partially replacing 50% of Portland cement with calcined clays and using natural sisal fibers as reinforcement. These composites presented ultimate monotonic tensile stress of 12 MPa and strain at failure of up to 1.5%. Tension-tension fatigue tests were performed with maximum stress levels ranging from 4 to 9.6 MPa at a frequency of 2 Hz. These tests were carried out up to 106 cycles or until the composite failure, whichever occurred first. It was found that up to 6 MPa the composites were able to survive 106 cycles. Composites that survived 106 cycles were re-tested under monotonic load to establish its residual strength. Optical fluorescent microscopy was used to observe the cracking mechanisms after fatigue tests.
Keywords Cementitious composites, sisal fiber, fatigue.
INTRODUCTION Sisal fiber is one of the most widely used natural fibers in yarns, ropes, twines, cords, rugs, carpets, mattresses, mats, and handcrafted articles. During the past two decades sisal fibers have also been used as reinforcement in cement and polymer based composites [1-7]. The sisal reinforcement can be used as short randomly distributed fibers, long oriented fibers, or as a fiber fabric. The sisal fiber is extracted from the sisal plant leaf by a mechanical process called decortication. The sisal leaf consists of a sandwich structure composed of approximately 4% fiber, 1% cuticle, 8% dry matter, and 87% water [8]. Figure 1 shows a picture of the sisal plant, its leaf and the fiber distribution inside the leaf.
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
82
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 82
Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO
10 mm
(a)
Arch fiber
(b)
Structructural 200 m fibers
(c)
Figure 1. The sisal: (a) its plant, (b) cross section view and (c) optical microscopy of region selected in (b). Within the leaf, there are three basic types of fibers: Structural, arch, and xylem fibers. The structural fibers give the sisal leaf its stiffness and are found in the periphery of the leaf. The equivalent diameter of the structural fibers is around 200 m and the cross-section is rarely circular and usually has a “horse-shoe” shape. The structural fibers are of great importance commercially because they almost never split during the process of extraction. The arch fibers grow in association with the conducting tissues of the plant (see Figure 2a) and are usually found in the middle of the leaf (see Figure 1c). These fibers run from base to tip of the plant and have good mechanical strength [9]. The xylem fibers grow opposite to the arch fibers and are connected to them through the conducting tissues (see Figure 2a). According to Nutman [9], they are composed of thin walled cells, and are invariably broken up and lost during the process of fiber extraction.
ML
Lumen Conducting tissue
200 m
10 m
(a) (b) Figure 2. Sisal fiber microstrucutre (a) arch fiber showing its conducting tissue and (b) Details of the fiber-cells showing the lumens and middle lamellae (LM). Every fiber contains numerous elongated individual fibers, or fiber-cells, which are about 6 to 30 m in diameter (see Figure 2b). Each fiber-cell is made up of four main parts, namely the primary wall, the thick secondary wall, the tertiary wall, and the lumen. The fiber-cells are linked together by means of the middle lamellae (ML), which consist of hemicellulose and lignin (see Figure 2b). Long aligned sisal fiber reinforced cement composites have been investigated under static tension and bending tests in previous studies [10-13]. Continuous sisal fiber reinforced cement based composites are a new class of sustainable construction materials with superior tensile strength and ductility. These materials are strong enough to be used as load bearing
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 83
Tensile fatigue response of Sisal Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites
83
structural members, therefore, they can be used in different types of applications such as structural panels, impact & blast resistance, repair and retrofit, earthquake remediation, and strengthening of unreinforced masonry walls. Although high ultimate tensile strength (UTS) and modulus of rupture (MOR) was obtained no information regarding to its fatigue resistance is known. Fatigue can be defined as a permanent, localized, and progressive structural change that occurs in a material subjected to cyclic strains [14]. Those strains are created by loads smaller than the UTS of the material in a static test. In practice, fatigue affects all of the known engineering materials. Many structures are often subject to repetitive cyclic loads. Examples of such cyclic loads include machine vibration, sea waves, wind action and automobile traffic [15]. Fatigue failure occurs when a concrete structure fails at less than design load after being exposed to a large number of stress cycles [16]. The exposure to repeated loading results in a steady decrease in the stiffness of the structure, which may eventually lead to fatigue failure [15]. According to Hsu the interest in the fatigue of concrete started with the development of concrete railroad bridges which were exposed to millions of cycles during their entire life [17]. There is still a lack in understanding of the fatigue behavior of concrete materials and this is even more pronounced for fiber reinforced concrete (FRC). Although natural fibers such as cotton [18], wood pulp [19] and sisal [20] have been tested under fatigue load, cement composites reinforced with those fibers have not yet been investigated. Most of the fatigue tests in concrete or FRC have been performed under bending loads [21-26]. Naaman [23] found that fiber reinforced concrete mixtures containing 2% of hooked steel fibers can sustain bending fatigue stresses more than twice of the plain concrete. This type of FRC (pre-cracked specimens) presented average fatigue lives of the order of 10 cycles for loads ranging between 10 and 90% of their static strength, 8000 cycles for loads ranging between 10 and 80%, and more than 2.7 x l06 cycles for loads ranging between 10 and 70%. Parant et al. [22] tested multi scale steel fiber cement composite (MSCC) under bending fatigue and observed that below a loading ratio of 0.88 (maximum fatigue stress ranging from 35.9 to 40.8 MPa for a MOR of 61.5 MPa), specimens do not fail by fatigue before 2 million cycles. Just a few works in the literature are related to fatigue in uniaxial compression [27-28] and tension loads [29-31]. In this paper we investigate the stress versus cycles fatigue behavior of sisal fiber reinforced composites. The composites were subjected to tensile fatigue load with maximum stresses ranging from 4 to 9.6 MPa at a frequency of 2 Hz. These stress levels represents approximately 30% and 80% of the UTS, respectively. Monotonic tensile tests were performed in previous works [12]. The fatigue tests were stopped either at 106 cycles or complete failure of the composite, whichever occurred first. Composites that survived 106 cycles were tested under monotonic tension to establish its residual strength. Optical fluorescent microscopy was performed to investigate the composites microstructure after fatigue tests.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE Materials and Processing Continuous sisal fibers were obtained from an agricultural farm located in the city of Valente, state of Bahia – Brazil. Their mechanical properties of bulk fibers defined in terms of Young´s modulus and tensile strength of 18 GPa and 400 MPa, respectively were reported by Silva et al. [32]. The Wollastonite fiber (JG class), obtained from Energyarc, were used as a micro-reinforcement in the composite production.
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
84
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 84
Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO
The matrix was produced using the Portland cement CPII F-32, Metakaolin (MK) from Metacaulim do Brasil Industria e Comércio LTDA, calcined waste crushed clay brick (CWCCB) from an industry located in Itaborai – RJ, Brazil, burned at 850 oC, river sand with maximum diameter of 1.18 mm and density of 2.67g/cm3 and a naphthalene superplasticizer Fosroc Reax Conplast SP 430 with content of solids of 44%. The mortar matrix used in this study presented a mix design 1:1:0.4 (cementitious material:sand:water by weight). The Portland cement was replaced by 30 % of MK and 20 % of CWCCB following recommendations of a previous work [20] to increase the durability of the composite system. The matrix was produced using a bench-mounted mechanical mixer of 20 liters capacity. The cementitious materials were dry mixed during 30 seconds (for homogenization) with the subsequent addition of sand and then a volume fraction of 5% wollastonite. The powder material was mixed for more 30 seconds when the superplasticizer diluted in water were slowly poured in the running mixer and then mixed for 3 minutes. The production of the laminates was achieved by placing the mortar mix in a steel mould one layer at a time, followed by one layer of unidirectional aligned fibers (up to 5 layers) and vibration resulting in a sisal fiber volume fraction of 10% (see Figure 3). The vibrating table was used at a frequency of 65 Hz. After casting the composites were compressed at 3 MPa during 5 minutes. The specimens were covered in their molds for 24 hours and after this time they were demolded and fog cured for 28 days in a cure chamber with 100% RH and 23±1 oC.
Figure 3. Molding procedure for long aligned sisal fiber reinforced composites. Fatigue tests The composites were tested under tensile fatigue loading at a stress ratio (R ratio = Vmin/Vmax) of 0.2 and frequency of 2 Hz. Testing was conducted on a MTS 810 testing system under force control. The experiment was conducted in samples with a 300 mm gage length at five different stress levels: 4, 4.8, 6, 7.2, and 9.6 MPa which presented mean static UTS of 12 MPa [12]. Three samples were tested for each stress level and they presented exactly the same geometry (400 mm x 50 mm x 12 mm – length x width x thickness) than the ones used in the authors previous works [12]. The tests were stopped after 106 cycles or after failure, whichever occurred first. Specimens that survived 106 cycles were tested under monotonic tensile load using the same testing system (MTS 810). The monotonic tensile test was controlled by the cross-head displacement at a rate of 0.1 mm/min. Microstructural investigation The microstructural analysis was performed using a Nikon Elipse TE300 Inverted Video Microscope. Samples that were tested under fatigue up to 106 cycles were pre-loaded to 0.4% strain and then glued with epoxy so the cracks remained open. These samples were then embedded in a polymer mixed with fluorescent dye in order to be analysed using the Nikon
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 85
Tensile fatigue response of Sisal Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites
85
Inverted microscope. This microscope is outfitted with two cameras; a low light level CCD camera (Quantix) and also a standard CCD camera that allows realtime image capture. A fluorescent light (including both Phase and DIC contrast enhancement capabilities) was used. Images were captured and processed by Inovision’s hardware/software interface on a SGI O2 R5000 computer.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS Figure 4 shows the stress versus cycles to failure behavior of the sisal reinforced cement composite tested at various maximum fatigue stresses (4 MPa-9.8 MPa). It can be seen that the composites can survive 106 cycles up to 6 MPa, which represents 50% of its UTS. The sisal fiber composite average UTS and tensile Young´s modulus was determined in the author´s previous work [12]. The average UTS was 12 MPa and the Young´s modulus computed from both cross head displacement and strain gage data was 9.5 GPa and 34 GPa, respectively. The fatigue maximum stress of 6 MPa can be considered a threshold limit where composites may present fatigue failure at cycles close to 106. Beyond 6 MPa all the composites failed below reaching 103 cycles. It was observed that for high fatigue stress levels (i.e.>6 MPa) all the cracks are formed at the first cycles. The number of cracks (12) were the same as the ones observed in monotonic tensile tests. After the crack formation, cracks started to widen. The cycles at these high stress levels caused a degradation process in the fibermatrix interface which increased the rate of cracking opening leading the composite to complete failure at low cycles (i.e. < 103). 1
12
8
4
Maximum Fatigue Stress / UTS
Maximum Fatigue Stress, MPa
16
0 1x101 1x102 1x103 1x104 1x105 1x106 1x107 Cycles to Failure
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1x101 1x102 1x103 1x104 1x105 1x106 1x107 Cycles to Failure
(a) (b) Figure 4. Stress versus cycles fatigue curve for composites subjected to maximum stress levels ranging from 4 to 9.8 MPa at constant R ratio of 0.2. Fatigue runout was taken at 106 cycles. The maximum stress was normalized by the ultimate tensile stress (UTS) of the composites in (b). Composites that survived 106 cycles were tested under monotonic tensile load and the results are presented in Figure 5a. When comparing the UTS from monotonic to post-fatigue tensile tests a slight decrease was observed. Nevertheless, this decrease lies in the standard variation range of the monotonic tests and no significant variation among the post-fatigue UTS for
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
86
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 86
Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO
different stress levels was observed. Stiffness degradation was observed when calculating the modulus for the post-fatigue tensile tests. Figure 5b shows that samples subjected to a maximum fatigue stress level of 4 MPa presented higher modulus as the one calculated for the monotonic tensile tests. Above 4 MPa the modulus started to decrease from approximately 11.5 to 2 GPa. It is important to mention that these moduli were calculated from cross-head displacement data. First crack strength was also computed for post-fatigue tensile tests. The composites presented increased first crack strength for higher maximum fatigue stress levels (see Figure 5b). 14
8
8
4 Stress Level = 4 MPa Stress Level = 4.8 MPa Stress Level = 6 MPa Reference
0
0
0.004 0.008 0.012 0.016 Strain, mm/mm
(a)
0.02
7
10 8
6
6 4
5
2 0
First Crack Strength, MPa
12
Initial Modulus, GPa
Monotonic Tensile Stress, MPa
12
Modulus First crack strength
4
0
2
4
6
8
10
Fatigue Maximum Stress, MPa
(b)
Figure 5. Monotonic tensile behavior of composites that have survived 106 cycles: (a) stressstrain curves of composites subjected to maximum fatigue stresses of 4, 4.8 and 6 MPa and (b) effect of the cycles on modulus of elasticity and first crack strength. To understand the evolution of damage, stress-strain hysteresis measurements were conducted at various stress levels. These are shown in Figure 6. These plots were obtained from composites that survived 106 cycles at maximum stress levels of 4, 4.8 and 6 MPa. The Young’s modulus was computed from the linear unloading portion of the cycle for several cycles (see Table 1). For the maximum stress level of 4 MPa the thickness of the individual hysteresis loops, a measure of inelastic damage or energy during a given cycle, was not significant and did not change with cycles. No stiffness degradation was observed for this stress level. The dynamic modulus computed from cross head displacement data at a fatigue stress of 4 MPa was 16.81 GPa whereas the one calculated from the monotonic tests was 9.5 GPa. The dynamic modulus computed from strain gage measurements was only computed for the maximum fatigue stress of 4 MPa. It was found an increase from 34 to 46.61 GPa when comparing to monotonic tests. When increasing the maximum fatigue stress to 4.8 and 6 MPa a different behavior in the hysteresis loops was observed. An increase in the thickness of the hysteresis loops as a function of cycles was observed for both levels. This behavior can be explained due to the formation of several cracks in the first cycles and posterior widening of these cracks. Stiffness degradation as a function of number of cycles was observed for fatigue stresses equal to 4.8 MPa and above. Nevertheless, when computing the dynamic modulus at the first cycle a decrease was only observed for maximum fatigue stresses of 6 MPa and above. It was
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 87
87
Tensile fatigue response of Sisal Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites
observed a change of shape in the hysteresis loops above 103 cycles for maximum fatigue tensile stresses of 4.8 and 6 MPa. The hysteresis loop changes to an “s” shape due to a continuous degradation process in the fiber-matrix interface. 6
6
106
4
Fatigue Stress, MPa
Fatigue Stress, MPa
1
1
2
0
0
105
3.105
106
4
2
0
0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025 Strain, mm/mm
103
0
0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025 Strain, mm/mm
(a)
(b)
Fatigue Stress, MPa
8
1
6
102 103
104
5.104 105
0.004
0.006
106
4
2
0
0
0.002
0.008
0.01
Strain, mm/mm
(c) Figure 6. Hysteresis stress-strain behavior of composites subjected to 106 cycles. Maximum stress levels of (a) 4 MPa, (b) 4.8 MPa and (c) 6 MPa. The labels over the hysteresis loops refer to the number of cycles. Samples that survived 106 cycles at a stress level of 6 MPa were investigated using fluorescent optical microscopy. Figure 7 shows the capacity of the fibers to arrest and bridge the cracks formed during fatigue cycles in lateral cross section views. This behavior attests the high efficiency in the fiber matrix bond adhesion of the composite system even when subjected to 106 cycles at a maximum stress of 6 MPa. Two ranges of crack widths were observed in the micrographs: (i) from 1 to 20 Pm and (ii) from 150 to 200 Pm at a
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
88
11:58 AM
Page 88
Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO
deformation of 0.4%. The use of fluorescent dye possibilities the visualization of micro cracks with width less than 20 Pm that were not observed in conventional optical microscopy. The enhancement in contrast was also achieved with the fluorescent microscopy.
Sand CONCLUSIONS
Crack Fiber
200 Pm
Figure 7. Fluorescent optical micrograph showing the crack bridging mechanisms on a composite subjected to 106 cycles at maximum fatigue level of 6 MPa. Note the higher contrast in the fluorescent optical microscopy that allows the visualization of small cracks (< 20Pm).
Table1. Summary of fatigue and post-fatigue monotonic tensile tests. Results in parenthesis were computed from strain gage measurements Max. Fatigue Stress (MPa)
Post-Fatigue Monotonic Tensile Test First Young´s UTS Crack Modulus (MPa) Strength (GPa) (MPa)
4
10.39
5.22
11.22
4.8 6 7.2 9.8
9.51 10.72 -
6.87 7.59 -
3.47 2.26 -
Dynamic Modulus (GPa)
Cycle 1 16.81 (46.61) 16.30 8.70 3.11 2.62
Cycle 102
Cycle 103
Cycle 104
Cycle 105
-
-
-
-
15.52 5.60 2.08 -
10.2 3.21 -
9.92 2.55 -
6.31 2.12 -
Cycle 106 16.69 (44.37) 5.13 1.96 -
CONCLUSION Long aligned sisal fiber reinforced cement composites were tested under tensile fatigue loading and the main findings are described below: x Composites did not fatigue up to 106 cycles when subject to maximum stress level below 6 MPa. Above this stress the composites presented fatigue below 103 cycles.
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 89
Tensile fatigue response of Sisal Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites
89
x Composites that survived 106 cycles and were tested under monotonic tension did not present significant reduction in UTS but presented decrease in Young´s modulus. The first crack strength increased when increasing the fatigue stress levels. x From the hysteresis stress-strain curves it was noticed no signs of degradation for maximum stress level of 4 MPa. For maximum stress levels of 4.8 and 6 MPa there was noticed an increase in the hysteresis area and decrease in the Young´s modulus as a function of number of fatigue cycles. x The use of fluorescent optical microscopy resulted in high contrast images. The sisal fibers were able to arrest and bridge the cracks even when subjected to 106 cycles at 6 MPa of maximum stress. REFERENCES 1. Silva, F.A., Toledo Filho, R.D. Sisal Fiber Reinforcement of Durable Thin Walled Structures – A New Perspective. In: Proceedings of International Workshop on Cement Based Materials & Civil Infrastructure, Karachi, Pakistan, 2007, 575-586 2. Oksman, K., Wallstrom, L., Toledo Filho, R.D. Morphology and mechanical properties of unidirectional sisal-epoxy composites. Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 84, 2002, 2358-2365 3. Gram HE. Durability of natural fibers in concrete. Swedish Cement and Concrete Research Institute, Research Fo. 1983, p. 225 4. Bisanda, E.T.N., Ansell, M.P. Properties of sisal-CNSL composites. Journal of Materials Science, 27, 1992, 1690-1700 5. Toledo Filho, R.D., Ghavami, K., England, G.L., Scrivener, K. Development of vegetable fiber-mortar composites of improved durability, Cement and Concrete Composites, 25, 2003, 185-196 6. Toledo Filho, R.D., England, G.L., Scrivener, K., Ghavami, K. Durability of alkalisensitive sisal and coconut fibers in cement mortar composites, Cement and concrete composites, 22, 2000, 127-143 7. Towo, A.N., Ansell, M.P. Fatigue of sisal fiber reinforced composites: constant life diagrams and hysteresis loop capture. Composites Science and Technology, 68, 2008, 915-924 8. Murherjee, P.S., Satyanarayana, K.G. Structure properties of some vegetable fibers, part 1. Sisal fibre. Journal of Materials Science,19, 1984, 925-34 9. Nutman, FJ. Agave fibres Pt. I. Morphology, histology, length and fineness; frading problems. Empire Journal of Experimental Agriculture, 5, 1936, 75-95 10. Toledo Filho, R.D., Silva, F.A., Fairbairn, E.M.R., Melo Filho, J.A. Durability of compression molded sisal fiber reinforced mortar laminates. Construction and Building Materials, 68, 2009, 3438-3443 11. Silva, F.A., Melo Filho, J.A., Toledo Filho, R.D., Fairbairn, E.M.R. Mechanical behavior and durability of compression moulded sisal fiber cement mortar laminates (SFCML). In: 1st International RILEM Conference on Textile Reinforced Concrete (ICTRC), Aachen, Proceedings, 2006, 171-180 12. Silva, F.A., Mobasher, B., Toledo Filho, R.D. Cracking mechanisms in durable sisal reinforced cement composites. Cement and Concrete Composites 2009, (in press) 13. Silva, F.A., Melo Filho, J.A., Toledo Filho, R.D., Fairbairn, E.M.R. Effect of Reinforcement Ratio on the mechanical response of compression molded sisal fiber textile reinforced concrete. In: High Performance Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites (HPFRCC5), Mainz, 2007, 175-182
09-Tensile fatigue.qxd
90
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 90
Flavio de Andrade SILVA, Barzin MOBASHER and Romildo D. TOLEDO FILHO
14. Revuelta, D. and Miravete, A. Fatigue damage in composite materials. International Applied Mechanics, 38, 2002, 121-134 15. Lee, M.K. and Barr, B.I.G. An overview of the fatigue behavior of plain and fibre reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 26, 2004, 299-305 16. Li, H., Zhang M-H., Ou J-p. Flexural fatigue performance of concrete containing nanoparticles for pavement. International Journal of Fatigue, 29, 2007, 1292-1301 17. Hsu, T.C. Fatigue of Plain Concrete. ACI Journal, 78, 1981, 292-304 18. Hkarlk, J.W.S. and Sparrow, J.T. Tensile Fatigue of Cotton Fibers. Textile Research Journal, 49, 1979, 242-243 19. Hamad, W.Y. Some microrheological aspects of wood-pulp fibres subjected to fatigue loading. Cellulose, 4, 1997, 51-56 20. Silva, F.A., Chawla, N., Toledo Filho, R.D. An experimental investigation of the fatigue behavior of sisal fibers. Materials Science and Engineering A, 2009, in Press 21. Herández-Olivares, F., Barluenga, G., Parga-Landa, B., Bollati, M., Witoszek, B. Fatigue behavior of recycled tyre ruber-filled concrete and its implications in the design of rigid pavements. Construction and Building Materials, 21, 2007, 1918-1927 22. Parant, E., Rossi, P. and Boulay, C. Fatigue behavior of a multi-scale cement composite. Cement and Concrete Research, 37, 2007, 264-269 23. Naaman, A.E. and Hammoud, H. Fatigue characteristics of high performance fiberreinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites, 20, 1998, 353-363 24. Johnston, C.D., Zemp, R.W. Flexural fatigue performance of steel fiber reinforced concrete-influence of fiber content, aspect ratio and type. ACI Materials Journal, 88, 1991, 374-383 25. Zhang, J., Stang, H. Fatigue performance in flexure of fiber reinforced concrete. ACI Materials Journal, 95, 1998, 58-67 26. Ramakrishnan, V., Lokvik, B.J. Flexural fatigue strength of fiber reinforced concretes. In: Reinhardt H.W., Naaman AE, editors. High Performance Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites: Proceedings of the International RILEM/ACI workshop. London: E&FN SPON:1992, 271-287. 27. Gao, L. ,Hsu, T.C.C. Fatigue of concrete under uniaxial compression cyclic loading. ACI Materials Journal 95,1988, 575-581 28. Rafeez, A.S., Gupta, A., Krishnamoorthy, S. Influence of steel fibers in fatigue resistance of concrete in direct compression. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 12, 2000, 172-179 29. Xianhong, M. and Yupu, S. Residual tensile strength of plain concrete under tensile fatigue loading. Journal of Wuhan University of Technology-Mater. Sci. Ed., 22,564-568. 30. Zhang, J., Stang, H., Li, V.C. Experimental study on crack bridging in FRC under uniaxial fatigue tension. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 12, 2000, 66–73 31. Saito, M. Characteristics of microcracking in concrete under static and repeated tensile loading. Cement and Concrete Research, 17, 1987, 211–8 32. Silva, F.A., Chawla, N., and Toledo Filho, R.D. Tensile behavior of high performance natural (sisal) fibers. Composites Science and Technology, 68, 2008, 3438-3443
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 91
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
INVESTIGATION ON THE STRENGTH AND FLEXURAL TOUGHNESS OF HYBRID FIBRE REINFORCED CONCRETE Surinder Pal SINGH Department of Civil Engineering Dr B R Ambedkar National Institute of Technology Jalandhar – 144 011, India, e-mail:
[email protected]
ABSTRACT The paper presents results of an experimental investigation carried out to study the compressive strength, flexural strength and flexural toughness of steel fibre reinforced concrete (SFRC) containing hybrid fibres. An experimental programme was planned in which approximately seventy five beam specimens of size 100 mm x 100 mm x 500 mm were tested under four point static flexural loading. In addition, cube specimens of size 150 mm x 150 mm x 150 mm were also tested to obtain the compressive strength of SFRC. The specimen incorporated three different volume fractions i.e. 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% of corrugated steel fibres with each volume fraction containing steel fibres of two different sizes and in different mix proportions by weight. The complete load-deflection curves under static flexural loads were obtained using the displacement control mode of the Actuator system. The flexural toughness indices were calculated using procedure laid down in ASTM C-1018, JCI method and ASTM 1609/C 1609 M. The compressive strength results indicate that with the type of fibres used in this investigation, the best performance is given by concrete containing 100% short fibres at a volume fraction of 1.5% whereas, the best performance in terms of static flexural strength and toughness parameters is obtained with concrete containing 100% long fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5%. However, concrete containing 100% short fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5% gave the best results in terms of first crack load and first crack toughness.
Keywords Fibre reinforced concrete; flexural toughness INTRODUCTION The addition of fibres to concrete considerably improves its structural characteristics such as static flexural strength, impact strength, tensile strength, ductility and flexural toughness. The degree of improvement depends upon many factors such as size, type, aspect ratio and volume fraction of fibres. Many researchers have conducted investigations to study different characteristics of fibre reinforced concrete in the past. The mechanical properties of concrete and mortar reinforced with randomly distributed smooth steel fibres were investigated by Shah and Rangan (1). Hughes and Fattuhi (2) investigated the effect of fibre type (polypropylene, steel), fibre shape (straight, duoform, crimped, hooked), specimen size (cube, prismatic) and age on the compressive stress-
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 92
92
Surinder Pal SINGH
strains curves of steel fibre reinforced concrete. The factors influencing flexural strength measurement of SFRC such as specimen span, width, depth and mode of loading was investigated by Johnston (3). The test results of Nagarkar et al. (4) indicated that the compressive, split tensile and flexural strength increase by addition of fibres, but the workability of concrete was reduced. Nakagawa et al. (5) reported the results of an investigation on the mechanical properties of concrete reinforced with carbon, aramid and high strength vinylon fibres. Toutaji and Bayasi (6) investigated the effect of manufacturing techniques on the mechanical properties of steel fibre reinforced concrete. Ramanalingam et al. (7) presented the results of an experimental investigation on fibre reinforced mortar incorporating different combinations of fibres to exhibit strain-hardening under flexural loading. Recently some investigators i.e. Sivakumar and Santhanam (8), Banthia and Sappakittipakorn (9), Hsie et al. (10) and Ding et al. (11) attempted to study the flexural toughness of fibre reinforced concrete using fibre hybridization. Different combinations of fibres such as metallic-metallic, metallic-nonmetallic and nonmetallic-nonmetallic were employed for different volume fractions of fibres. It has been reported that there has been improvement in the properties and toughness of fibre reinforced concrete through fibre hybridization. However, it is expected that this improvement will depend upon the type of the fibres used. Different types of steel fibres are commercially available in India. This investigation was, therefore, planned to study the flexural toughness of fibre reinforced concrete containing different combinations of metallic-metallic fibres. It is proposed to use the standard test specimen used in India for static flexural tests i.e. of size 100 x 100 x 500 mm and to obtain the toughness parameters using ASTM 1018 C, JCI Method and ASTM 1609/C 1609 M. This investigation forms a part of a large project work being undertaken in this direction in which different combinations and types of metallic and non-metallic fibres are proposed to be used.
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM The concrete mix used for casting the test specimens is shown in Table-1. Portland Pozzolana Cement, crushed stone coarse aggregates having maximum size 10 mm and river sand were used. The specimens incorporated two different types of corrugated steel fibres i.e. rectangular (38 mm long, 2 mm wide and 0.6 mm thick) and round (25 mm long and 1 mm in diameter) by weight of the longer and shorter fibres in mix proportions of 100% - 0%, 75% - 25%, 50% - 50%, 25% - 75% and 0% - 100% at each of the fibre volume fractions of 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5%. The specimens used for compressive strength tests and static flexural strength tests were 150 x 150 x 150 mm cubes and 100 mm x 100 mm x 500 mm beams respectively. Table-2 presents the details of various fibre concrete mixes used in this investigation. Table 1: Concrete Mix Proportion. Water/Cement Ratio
Sand/Cement Ratio
Coarse Aggregate/Cement Ratio
0.46
1.52
1.88
The compressive strength tests were conducted on a 2000 kN Universal Testing Machine.
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 93
93
Investigation on the strength and flexural toughness of hybrid fibre reinforced concrete
The maximum compressive load was recorded as that load at which the specimen failed to take any further increase in load. The compressive strength was calculated by dividing the maximum compressive load by the cross sectional area of the cube specimen on which the load was applied. Table 2: Steel Fibrous Concrete Mixes. Fibre Type
Fibre Mix Proportion by Weight (%) Vf = 0.5%
Vf = 1.0%
38 mm 100 75 50 25 0 100 75 50 25 0 100 Long* 25 mm 0 25 50 75 100 0 25 50 75 100 0 Long** * Rectangular, corrugated, 38 mm long, 2 mm wide and 0.6 mm thick. ** Round, corrugated, 25 mm long and 1 mm in diameter.
Vf = 1.5% 75
50
25
0
25
50
75
100
The static flexural strength tests were conducted on a 100 kN servo-controlled actuator and the specimens were loaded at third points. The specimens were turned on their side with respect to the position as cast before placing these on the support system so as to have a plain and uniform surface in contact with the supporting and loading rollers. Complete load-deflection curve was obtained for each specimen tested. A minimum of four samples were tested for each combination of fibres. The static flexural strength and toughness parameters were evaluated as per the standards mentioned in preceding section.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Compressive Strength Test Results The results of the compressive strength tests conducted on fibre reinforced concrete specimens with different fibre volume fractions, each fibre volume fraction containing different combinations of mixed steel fibres, are presented in Table 3 and Fig. 1. It can be seen that for a constant mixed aspect ratio of fibres, there is an increase in compressive strength of concrete as the percentage of fibres is increased. The results show that in general, there is an increase in compressive strength varying from 1% to 32%, on addition of fibres to the concrete mix. The results indicate that there is an increase in the compressive strength with respect to that of plain concrete varying from 1% to 26%, 3% to 29% and 4% to 32% for mixes having 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% volume fraction of fibres respectively. However, for a particular mix, there is an optimum volume fraction of fibres that will give the maximum compressive strength. In the case of mixes tested in this investigation, the optimum percentage of fibres was 1.5%, when using 100% short fibres and the maximum increase in compressive strength in this case was 32%. The maximum increase in compressive strength for all the other mixes was observed at a fibre volume fraction of 1.0%. In general, it may be concluded that on increasing the percentage of short fibres in the mix, the compressive strength increases. Chen and Carson (12) also reported that for a given volume fraction of fibres, the mixes with shorter fibres had higher compressive strength compared to those with the longer fibres.
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:58 AM
Page 94
94
Surinder Pal SINGH
Table 3: Compressive Strength Test Results. Fibre Mix Proportion by Weight
Fibre Volume Fraction (%)
28 Days Compressive Strength (MPa)
% Increase
38 mm Long 25 mm Long Fibres* Fibres** 38.75 0 0 0.0 39.15 100 0 0.5 41.10 75 25 0.5 41.92 50 50 0.5 45.87 25 75 0.5 48.81 0 100 0.5 40.01 100 0 1.0 41.39 75 25 1.0 44.45 50 50 1.0 46.83 25 75 1.0 50.10 0 100 1.0 40.43 100 0 1.5 42.56 75 25 1.5 45.99 50 50 1.5 47.82 25 75 1.5 51.05 0 100 1.5 * Rectangular, corrugated, 38 mm long, 2 mm wide and 0.6 mm thick. ** Round, corrugated, 25 mm long and 1 mm in diameter.
Compressive Strength (MPa)
Fibre Mix Combination 55
100% 38mm Long + 0% 25mm Long Fibres
50
75% 38mm Long + 25% 25mm Long Fibres
45
50% 38mm Long + 50% 25mm Long Fibres 25% 38mm Long + 75% 25mm Long Fibres
40
0% 38mm Long + 100% 25mm Long Fibres 35 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
%age of Fibres
Figure 1: Compressive strength of concrete with mixed fibres at different fibre volume fractions.
0 1 6 8 18 26 3 7 15 21 29 4 10 19 26 32
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 95
95
Investigation on the strength and flexural toughness of hybrid fibre reinforced concrete
Flexural Strength Test Results Flexural strength results for fibrous concrete mixes with mixed aspect ratio of fibres at different fibre volume fractions are shown in Table 4 and Fig. 2. The load-deflection curves obtained in this investigation for concrete with different volume fractions of fibres, each volume fraction containing different combinations of fibres are presented in Fig. 3. Figure 3 (a) presents the load-deflection curves for all the fibre mix combinations for fibre volume fraction of 0.5% whereas, Fig. 3 (b) and 3 (c) present the curves for concrete with fibre volume fraction of 1.0% and 1.5% respectively. It can be seen from Table 4 that the maximum increase in flexural strength with respect to plain concrete, taken as the average of the samples tested for a particular mix combination of fibres, varied from 32% to 36%, 39% to 43% and 50% to 59% for concrete mixes with 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% volume fraction of fibres respectively. The maximum increase in static flexural strength of 59% was obtained for concrete with 100% long fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5%. Table 4: Flexural Strength Test Results Fibre Mix Proportion by Fibre Deflection Flexural % Weight Volume at Peak Strength Increase Fraction Load 38 mm 25 mm (MPa) (%) (mm) Long Long Fibres* Fibres** 0 0 0.0 4.65 0 0.502 100 0 0.5 6.33 36 0.677 75 25 0.5 6.17 33 0.628 50 50 0.5 6.26 35 0.602 25 75 0.5 6.12 32 0.619 0 100 0.5 6.19 33 0.652 100 0 1.0 6.57 41 1.106 75 25 1.0 6.58 42 0.678 50 50 1.0 6.53 40 0.693 25 75 1.0 6.48 39 0.736 0 100 1.0 6.65 43 0.702 100 0 1.5 7.38 59 1.235 75 25 1.5 6.97 50 0.953 50 50 1.5 6.99 50 0.830 25 75 1.5 7.06 52 0.701 0 100 1.5 7.15 54 0.820 * Rectangular, corrugated, 38 mm long, 2 mm wide and 0.6 mm thick. ** Round, corrugated, 25 mm long and 1 mm in diameter.
First Crack Load (kN)
First Crack Deflection (mm)
10.35 12.87 12.53 12.80 12.31 13.05 13.59 13.61 13.26 13.39 13.61 14.17 15.19 14.85 15.67 15.87
0.502 0.568 0.528 0.602 0.552 0.577 0.515 0.525 0.522 0.520 0.552 0.528 0.652 0.530 0.567 0.665
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 96
96
Surinder Pal SINGH
Fibre Mix Combination 100% 38mm Long + 0% 25mm Long Fibres
Flexural Strength (MPa)
7.5
75% 38mm Long + 25% 25mm Long Fibres 7
50% 38mm Long + 50% 25mm Long Fibres 25% 38mm Long + 75% 25mm Long Fibres
6.5
0% 38mm Long + 100% 25mm Long Fibres 6 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
%age of fibres
Figure 2: Flexural strength of concrete with mixed fibres at different fibre volume fractions.
The average centre-point deflection corresponding to peak load for concrete with different mixed aspect ratios and different volume fractions of fibres are also listed in Table 4. The increase in average centre point deflection corresponding to peak load with respect to plain concrete was observed to vary between 20% to 35%, 36% to 120% and 40% to 146% for concrete mixes containing 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% fibre volume fractions respectively. The maximum increase in peak load deflection of 35%, 120% and 146% with respect to that of plain concrete was observed in fibrous concrete containing 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% fibre volume fractions respectively for fibre mix containing 100% long fibres. It can also be observed from Table 4 that there is an increase in first crack load over that of plain concrete, taken as average of the samples tested for a particular mix combination of fibres, of the order of 4% to 10%, 12% to 15% and 20% to 34% for concrete mixes having 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% volume fractions of fibres respectively. The maximum increase in first crack load of 10%, 15% and 34% with respect to plain concrete was observed with 100% short fibres at fibre volume fractions of 0.5%, 1.0% and 1.5% respectively. The maximum increase in first crack deflection of 20% to 33% with respect to that of plain concrete was observed for fibrous concrete specimens with fibre volume fractions of 0.5% to 1.5% respectively. Flexural toughness Un-reinforced concrete is a brittle material, with little ability to resist pronounced tensile stress and strain. As reported by Mohammadi (13), discontinuous fibres are added to concrete to improve post-cracking behaviour i.e. to improve its energy absorption capacity and to provide improved resistance to cracking. For fibre reinforced concrete, the term toughness is used to characterize such energy absorption. Hence flexural toughness is an important parameter in assessing the influence of fibres on the post-peak behaviour of fibre reinforced concrete.
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 97
97
Investigation on the strength and flexural toughness of hybrid fibre reinforced concrete
15
Fibre Mix Combination
12
Load (kN)
100% 38mm Long + 0% 25mm Long Fibres 75% 38mm Long + 25% 25mm Long Fibres
9
50% 38mm Long + 50% 25mm Long Fibres 25% 38mm Long + 75% 25mm Long Fibres
6
0% 38mm Long + 100% 25mm Long Fibres 3
(a) 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Deflection (mm) 16
Fibre Mix Combination 100% 38mm Long + 0% 25mm Long Fibres 75% 38mm Long + 25% 25mm Long Fibres
Load (kN)
12
50% 38mm Long + 50% 25mm Long Fibres 25% 38mm Long + 75% 25mm Long Fibres
8
0% 38mm Long + 100% 25mm Long Fibres
4
(b) 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Deflection (mm)
Fibre Mix Combination
18
100% 38mm Long + 0% 25mm Long Fibres 75% 38mm Long + 25% 25mm Long Fibres
15
Load (kN)
50% 38mm Long + 50% 25mm Long Fibres 12
25% 38mm Long + 75% 25mm Long Fibres 0% 38mm Long + 100% 25mm Long Fibres
9 6 3
(c)
0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Deflection (mm)
Figure 3: Load-deflection curves for concrete with mixed fibres, (a) Vf = 0.5%; (b) Vf = 1.0%; (c) Vf = 1.5%.
10-Investigation on.qxd
98
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 98
Surinder Pal SINGH
Over the years, a number of test methods have been developed in an attempt to measure or quantify the toughness and performance of fibre reinforced concrete. In this investigation, flexural toughness was determined from the load-deflections curves using the procedure laid down in different standards. The ASTM C 1018 (14) though withdrawn now a days, was used to quantify the toughness parameters of fibre reinforced concrete. Different indices such as TF.C., I5, I10 and I20, were calculated and are presented in this paper. The JCI Method (15) was used to calculate the toughness TJCI. The flexural performance parameters such as residual loads and strengths and specimen toughness were calculated from the load-deflection curves using ASTM C 1609/C 1609 M (16). The symbols used for various toughness parameters are the same as given in the above mentioned standards. Due to lack of space, only limited results are reported here as far as toughness parameters are concerned. The results of the toughness parameters using different methods for concrete mixes with different mixed aspect ratio of fibres at each of the three volume fractions of steel fibres as obtained from the corresponding load deflection curves are presented in Table 5. The toughness index for plain concrete is taken as 1.0 because plain concrete flexural test specimens fail immediately after the formation of first crack. From the perusal of the test results, it is evident that in general, the TJCI, the indices I5, I10 and I20 and the parameters f600 and f150 increase with increasing fibre content and increasing percentage of long fibres in the concrete mix. The indices I5 and I10 are relatively less sensitive to the use of mixed aspect ratio of fibres. Further, comparison of toughness indices shows that the mixes with long fibres have higher values of the indices than those with short fibres. The first crack toughness (TFC) increases with increasing fibre volume fraction and increasing content of shorter fibres in the mix. The maximum value of TFC were obtained for a mix with 100% short fibres, for all the three volume fractions tested in this investigation. The toughness indices were found to be sensitive to the volume fraction and percentage of the longer fibres in the concrete mix. Higher values of the toughness indices were obtained at higher fibre volume fractions and at higher percentage of the longer fibres in the concrete mix, in contrast to the trends in the first crack toughness values. The mixed fibres are used in concrete with the understanding that relatively short fibres are more effective in arresting micro-cracks whereas, the longer fibres are effective in arresting macro-cracks in concrete. When a specimen is subjected, for example, to flexural loads, a number of micro-cracks appear initially which are preceded by one or two major cracks that lead to the failure of the specimen. As observed in this investigation, the ultimate load increases with the increase in aspect ratio of the fibres in the concrete mix, hence it can be concluded that the longer fibres are offering more resistance to the pull out of fibres because of their better bond characteristics being longer in length. The residual strengths f600 and f150 also present more or less same trends as presented by toughness parameters obtained by other methods. The residual strength f600 increases with increase in the percentage of long fibres in concrete mix except at fibre volume fraction of 1.5% where some conflicting results are obtained. However, the residual strength f150 increases with increase in the number of long fibres in concrete for all the three volume fractions of fibres tested in this investigation.
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 99
99
Investigation on the strength and flexural toughness of hybrid fibre reinforced concrete
Table 5: Flexural Toughness/Performance Parameters for Fibrous Concrete. Fibre Mix Proportion by Weight
Fibre Volume Fraction (%)
Flexural Toughness/Performance Parameters
JCI ASTM C – 1018 Method T(JCI) TF.C. I10 I5 (kN-mm) (kN-mm) 100 0 0.5 19.06 4.05 3.20 4.76 75 25 0.5 17.77 3.95 3.07 4.61 50 50 0.5 15.90 4.02 2.77 4.14 25 75 0.5 14.25 3.75 2.61 3.78 0 100 0.5 11.61 4.08 2.27 2.91 100 0 1.0 30.81 4.32 4.02 6.90 75 25 1.0 27.23 4.29 3.53 5.97 50 50 1.0 25.60 4.24 3.36 5.60 25 75 1.0 21.19 4.19 3.04 4.85 0 100 1.0 20.12 4.23 2.70 4.41 100 0 1.5 36.18 4.68 4.72 8.15 75 25 1.5 35.19 5.00 4.71 7.85 50 50 1.5 34.23 4.72 4.70 7.78 25 75 1.5 33.80 4.64 4.70 7.67 0 100 1.5 30.72 4.86 4.48 6.76 * Rectangular, corrugated, 38 mm long, 2 mm wide and 0.6 mm thick. ** Round, corrugated, 25 mm long and 1 mm in diameter. 38 mm Long Fibres*
25 mm Long Fibres**
I20 6.32 --6.13 4.74 --9.91 8.35 7.55 6.83 5.19 11.07 10.72 10.19 9.94 8.83
ASTM C – 1609/C 1609 M f150 f600 (MPa) (MPa) 4.12 1.57 3.75 1.44 4.01 1.31 3.11 1.24 2.56 0.63 5.97 3.21 5.74 2.96 5.29 2.18 4.86 1.73 4.34 1.28 6.49 4.13 6.79 3.79 6.56 3.73 6.61 3.57 6.63 3.26
CONCLUSION Properties, such as compressive strength, flexural strength and flexural toughness of fibre reinforced concrete containing mixed steel fibres have been investigated. Complete loaddeflection curves were obtained under static flexural loading and flexural toughness indices/parameters were obtained as per procedure laid down in ASTM C 1018, JCI Method and ASTM C 1609/C 1609 M. A maximum increase in compressive strength of the order of 32% over plain concrete was observed in case of concrete containing 100% shorter fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5%. In case of static flexural strength tests, a maximum increase in static flexural strength of the order of 59%, centre point deflection corresponding to peak load of the order of 146% and toughness parameters were obtained for fibrous concrete with 100% long fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5%. The maximum increase in first crack load in flexure equal to 34% and first crack toughness were obtained in a concrete mix with 100% short fibres at a fibre volume fraction of 1.5%. Keeping in view the size and type of fibres used, it can be observed from the results reported in this investigation that no single combination of fibres can be adjudged as the optimum combination for the all the properties tested in this investigation.
10-Investigation on.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 100
100
Surinder Pal SINGH
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4.
5.
6. 7.
8.
9.
10. 11.
12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
Shah, S. P., Rangan, B.V., Fibre reinforced concrete properties. ACI Journal, Vol. 68, No. 2, February, 1971, pp. 126-135. Hughes, B.P., Fattuhi, N.I., Stress-strain curves for fibre reinforced concrete in compression. Cement and Concrete Research, 7, 2, 1977, 173-183. Johnston, C.D., Steel fibre reinforced and plain concrete: factors influencing flexural strength measurement. ACI Journal, 79, 2, 1982, 131-138. Nagarkar, P.K., Tambe, S.K., Pazare, D.G., Study of fibre reinforced concrete. Proceedings of International Symposium of Fibre Reinforced Concrete, December 16-19, Madras, India, 1987, 2.130-2.138. Nakagawa, P.K., Akihama, S., Suenaga, T., Mechanical properties of various types of fibres reinforced concretes. Fibre Reinforced Cement and Concretes: Recent Developments, Ed. by R N Swamy and B. Barr, University of Wales, College of Cardiff, UK, 1989, 523-532. Toutanji, H., Bayasi, Z., Effects of manufacturing techniques on the flexural behaviour of steel fibre-reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Research, 28, 1, 1998, 115-124. Ramanalingan, N., Paramasivam, P., Mansur, M.A., Madlej, M., Flexural behaviour of hybrid fibre reinforced cement composites containing high volume fly ash. 7th Canmet/ACI International Conference on Fly Ash, Silica Fume, Slag and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete, SP-199, Vol. 1, Ed. V.M. Malhotra, 2001, 147-161. Sivakumar, A., Santhanam, M., Mechanical properties of high strength concrete reinforced with metallic and non-metallic fibres”, Cement and Concrete Composites, 29, 2007, 603-608. Banthia, N., Sappakittipakorn, M., Toughness enhancement in steel fibre reinforced concrete through fibre hybridization. Cement and Concrete Research, 37, 2007, 1366-1372. Hsie, M., Tu, C., Song P.S., Mechanical properties of polypropylene hybrid fibre reinforced concrete. Material Science and Engineering A, 494, 2008, 153-157. Ding, Y., Jhang, Y., Thomas, A., The investigation on strength and flexural toughness of fibre cocktail reinforced self compacting high performance concrete. Construction and Building Materials, 23, 2009, 448-452. Chen, W.F., Carson, J.L., Stress-strain properties of random wire reinforced concrete”, ACI Journal, 68, 12, 1971, 933-936. Mohammadi, Y., Behaviour of steel fibre reinforced concrete in flexural fatigue. Ph.D. Thesis, IIT Roorkee, 2002, pp 304. ASTM C 1018, Standard test method for flexural toughness and first crack strength of fibre reinforced concrete. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, 04.02, 1994, 509-516. JCI-SF4, Methods of tests for flexural strength and flexural toughness of fibre reinforced concrete. 45-56. ASTM C 1609/C 1609 M, Standard test method for flexural performance of fibre reinforced concrete. ASTM, 2007, 1-9.
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 101
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
TEXTILE REINFORCED CONCRETE – DURABILITY ISSUES: CHANGES OF THE BOND AND TENSILE STRENGTH DUE TO AGEING Till BÜTTNER1, Jeanette ORLOWSKY, Michael RAUPACH Institute of Building Materials Research, RWTH Aachen University, Germany 1 e-mail:
[email protected] ABSTRACT Textile reinforced concrete (TRC) is one promising possibility to produce thin-walled high load bearing structural elements. Besides the maximum load bearing capacity, the durability under various conditions is one major issue for future applications. Usually AR-(Alkali-Resistant)-Glass is used as reinforcement. Even if it is AR-Glass, the high alkaline environment in concrete leads to a loss of the tensile strength. The paper deals with two major issues of the durability of TRC. On one hand the behavior of the bond due to ageing and on the other hand the loss of strength due to glass corrosion is discussed. Also the paper presents possible ways of predicting the long-term loss in strength based on the short-term laboratory ageing. Besides this, possibilities of improving the durability by the use of polymer modified concrete and polymer impregnated reinforcement are shown. In general, the results show that the bond of TRC is not affected by ageing and a polymeric modification of the reinforcement and also of the concrete can lead to a significant improvement of the durability – that means the loss of tensile strength due to the alkalinity is reduced.
Keywords Textile reinforced concrete (TXC), AR glass fibres, bond INTRODUCTION Textile reinforced concrete (TRC) represents an interesting new construction material, offering several additional advantages compared to steel or fibre reinforced concrete. These advantages dominate in those fields of applications where thin-walled, structural elements with a high load carrying capacity are required. In textile reinforced concrete, textiles made of alkali resistant (AR) glass fibers are applied in order to carry the forces arising by tensile loads. Previous investigations showed that the mechanical properties of the glass reinforcement have not been fully exploited [1]. The outer filaments, which are in direct contact to the concrete, only carry the tensile loads and the inner filaments are not connected to the concrete. Therefore these filaments cannot be activated for any load transmission. One possibility to improve the load bearing behavior is the use of polymeric impregnations which “glue” the inner and outer filaments together and the load is transferred to all the filaments, [1]. Even the reinforcement is called alkali resistant glass, there is a strength loss due to the alkalinity of the concrete, [2]. So it is obvious that the amount of alkali ions, which are able to attack the reinforcement, have to be reduced. On one hand the amount of alkali ions reaching the reinforcement is reduced by impregnating the reinforcement and on the other hand polymer modified concretes should reduce the water uptake of the concrete matrix and thus
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
102
Page 102
Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH
lead also to a reduction of the amount of alkali ions attacking the reinforcement. This chemical attack is eventually not the only factor, which leads to a reduction of the load bearing capacity of TRC – also the bond between the fiber bundles and the matrix material might alter due to ageing. Even if no loss of strength is measured, the stress-strain behavior and crack openings (both important characteristics in serviceability limit state design for constructions, according to the European standards) might be influenced. The paper considers various aspects concerning the durability of TRC: x Influences of the bond evolution and effecting the durability of TRC without any polymers added x Influences of the polymeric modifications of TRC in respect to the loss of strength.
THEORETICAL BACKGROUND The tensile stress-strain behavior of brittle matrix composites - including TRC composites has already been studied in previous publications [3] and is only discussed briefly here. Initially the TRC composite shows linear elastic behavior and the fibers and matrix share the applied load. At a certain stress, a first crack appears in the TRC specimen, leading to a sudden extra strain: at the vicinity of the crack face, the cracked matrix will show elastic unloading and redistribution of stresses leads to a sudden increase of the internal fiber stress (and thus also strain) at the vicinity of the crack. Simultaneously, the interface between matrix and fibers becomes debonded for a certain length along the fiber. At the vicinity of each crack face there is only frictional stress transfer between fibers and matrix in this debonded interface. When the load on the composite is further increased the composite stiffness is slightly lower. Upon further loading, extra cracks appear in the matrix, each time leading to extra deformations and loss of stiffness. The matrix progressively cracks in multiple places, until the crack spacing (distance between neighboring cracks) is such that, at every crack, the gradual stress transfer at the fiber matrix interface is interrupted by the stress relief from the neighboring crack before the strength of the matrix is exceeded. In order to determine a link between the interface stresses and the global measured behavior of the composite, a type of cohesive bond-slip relation should be proposed. In this case, expression of equilibrium of forces at every cross-section of the specimens leads to following relationship between composite stress Vc and composite strain Hc [4, 5] as long as full multiple cracking did not occur yet:
Vc §
DG · ¸ ; [6] ¨1 E c1 © x ¹
Hc here: x
D
Vf* Ec1
G
measured average crack spacing (distance between cracks) at Vc relative contribution of matrix stiffness to fiber stiffness (EmVm/EfVf*) effective fiber volume fraction (amount of fibers contributing to load transfer) linear elastic composite stiffness [N/mm2] debonding length, which can be calculated as follows:
G here:
Am Em T
(1)
Am E mV c ; [6] E c1T
effective matrix cross-sectional area [mm2] matrix stiffness [N/mm2] bond shear flow [N/mm]
(2)
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 103
Textile reinforced concrete - durability issues: changes of the bond and tensile strength due to ageing
103
The normalized bond shear flow T is introduced to represent the global transfer of stresses between fibers and matrix, once debonding occurs. It corresponds to the integrated effect of the bond shear stress between the fibers and matrix. Since the unit reinforcing element is a strand rather than a discrete filament it is difficult to estimate its true contact perimeter with the matrix. The total stress transfer from the fiber bundle to the matrix, which might thus include non-homogeneous matrix-fiber and fiber-fiber stress transfer, is represented globally in this paper by a bond shear flow T in each section - perpendicular to the load - of the composite. It should be mentioned that equation (1) is only valid as long as the last crack in the matrix did not appear yet. Once the last matrix crack does appear, equation (3) should be used:
Hc
§
1 Dx ·¸ ; [6] * E V 4 G Ec1 ¸¹ © f f
V c ¨¨
(3)
MATERIALS Rovings and textiles Due to the low price mainly AR-glass reinforcement for TRC is used. The structure of the reinforcement made out of AR-glass rovings, carbon rovings and aramid rovings is similar. They all consist of some hundreds to some thousands of filaments with diameters of a few Pm. Theses rovings (yarns) are processed usually into two- or three-dimensional textiles like the one depicted in figure 1.
Figure 1: (a) AR-glass roving 2400 tex, (b) glass fibre textile MAG 07-03, (c) glass fibre textile MAG 07-03 impregnated with an epoxy The rovings used in this paper consist out of approximately 1560 filaments with an average diameter of 27 Pm, corresponding to a linear density of 2400 tex (1tex = 1 g/km). Table 1 gives an overview of the mainly used reinforcement materials for the current research. As previously mentioned one of the main intentions of concrete modification and roving impregnation with polymers is the improvement of the durability. Therefore different types of polymers, primarily polymer dispersions and epoxies, were used for roving impregnation in previous investigations. These investigations showed that the best results can be achieved by using epoxies for roving impregnation [6], which is the main reason why the investigations with epoxies are carried on. The results obtained with three different epoxies are presented: EP STF STD is a cold hardening epoxy system; EP 3.1.2 is also a cold hardening but waterborne system; EP STD PRE1 is a Prepreg (used for PREimPREGnated textile structures) system which was cured at 120 °C for 2 hours. The epoxy resins are hardened by addition of an amine hardener according to the stoichiometric ratio. The detailed mechanical and chemical properties of these epoxy resins can be found in [1].
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
104
Page 104
Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH
Table 1: Characteristics of the reinforcement including standard deviation Filament Roving VET-FName ARGVET-RO-ARG-2400-1-05 2400-1-05 STD Polymeric EP 3.1.2 EP STF STD EP PRE1 Impregnation Titer tex 1.55 2400 2400 2400 2400 Tensile 890 r 52 1541 ± 64 1885 ± 72 1700 ± 96 N/m 1691 r 275 strength m² 53340 51330 60400 63200 56200 E-Modulus *: in 0° direction (direction of the applied load)
Concrete Within the scope of the SFB 532 (Collaborative Research Center 532 at Aachen University) a special micro grained concrete denominated as PZ 0899-01 has been developed, which serves complex requirements for the application for textile concrete, [7]. The epoxy modified micro grained concrete mixture (called EP 3.1.2-10%) is based on this mixture PZ 0899-01. The epoxy content of the concrete mixture is set to 10 Mass-% with regard to total binder content. The volume, which is filled by the added polymer, is taken into account as proportionately to the total masses of the other components; the ratios of the other materials are kept constant. In order to achieve a constant water/binder ratio of 0.4 in the concrete mixture the water content of the epoxy is taken into account. The compositions of PZ 0899-01 and the epoxy modified concrete are shown in table 2. The pH value of both concretes is about 13.5. All specimens were cured at 23 °C and 99 % RH for duration of 28 days. After this the accelerated ageing starts.
Table 2: Composition of fine grained concrete with and without polymer modification, [7] Cement Fly ash Silica Epoxy Sand Quartz Super(CEM I fume (fa) 3.1.2 < 0.6 mm flour plastiziser Name 52.5 R) (sf) kg/m³ PZ 0899-01 EP-3.1.2-10 %
490 458
175 164
35 33
65
714 667
499 467
%Ȉc+fa+sf 1.5 1.5
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM Test methods to characterize the bond between AR-glass and Matrix The bond behavior of the filaments in combination with the previously mentioned concrete was published before [5, 6], so this paper focuses on the roving-matrix interphase, which is relevant for the transition of the research work to building applications. For all test series the previous described cohesive interface model was used to determine the evaluation of the bond from global load-displacement curves, [4, 5, 9-15]. These global load-displacement curves were derived by using a tensile test combined with visual crack recording. The geometry of the test specimens is identical to the specimen, depicted in figure 3 (specimen called “TSP-specimen”), but there is a small but nevertheless important difference. If one is interested in the tensile strength of the fibers as a function of
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 105
Textile reinforced concrete - durability issues: changes of the bond and tensile strength due to ageing
105
ageing, the reinforcement can best be glued with epoxy resin to the ends of the specimens, so that the tensile load is applied to the fibers directly (as in figure 3). Since in this part of the investigations however the behavior of the specimen should be similar to the behavior of a building component and the main focus is put on the interaction between the matrix and the textile, the load is not transferred directly to the fibers any more, but should be introduced from matrix to fibers and vice-versa. Three layers of textile made out of VET-RO-ARG 24001-05 rovings (called MAG 07-03) are used, which corresponds to reinforcement degree of 2.67% vol. - the specimens were 10 mm thick. The tensile load is applied via rounded off steel elements. The TSP-Tests are carried out at a displacement rate of 0.5 mm/min. During the tensile tests pictures are taken at each load step of 0.5 kN to detect the cracks at the surface of the composite specimen (see Figure 2). Three series of specimens were tested. On the first series, no accelerated ageing has been applied. The second series was tested after 14 days of accelerated ageing (the specimens were kept under water at 50°C) and the third series after 28 days of accelerated ageing. Before the specimens are tested, they are dried under ambient conditions for several days until their weight stabilizes.
Figure 2: Test setup used for characterizing the bond between reinforcement and matrix TSP-Test for investigation of the durability Other than described before, the aim while investigating the durability of TRC is to achieve a roving failure within the specimen. As mentioned above before this roving failure is achieved by gluing the rovings, which are sticking out of the specimen, to the end of the specimen. So the individual filaments are fixed at each end of the sample. During the loading process, filaments are unable to slip towards the centre of the sample from the sample edges. Therefore the rovings can reach their maximum tensile strength. Due to this sample preparation the TSP-Test allows conclusions concerning the changes in the stress-elongation behavior, the cracking image and the maximum roving tensile strength after climatic stress. The amount of reinforcement depends on the type of roving – e.g. using 2400 tex rovings 8 single rovings are required; if the AR-glass is polymer modified only 6 single rovings are used (2400 tex). As described previously the specimen are tested in a displacement-controlled test with a velocity of 0.5 mm/min. During testing the change of length is measured on two sides over 250 mm using electrical gauges.
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
106
11:59 AM
Page 106
Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH
The test results are then used to compute the loss of strength according to the following formula:
(a)
(b)
Figure 3: Testing of a TSP specimen; (a) Top view of the specimen; (b) Cross-section
'f l , t with
'fl,t ft
1
ft ft 0
(4)
degree of strength loss at time t tensile strength of the specimen at time t
The computed loss of strength due to accelerated ageing can then be used to calibrate a model developed in the SFB 532, which allows predicting the long term loss of strength due to outdoor weathering, [2, 6]. At the moment the model is functional for non polymer-modified materials as it can bee seen in figure 4. It can be seen that the predicted loss of strength and the measured loss of strength of specimens, which were stored outdoors over a time of four years show a good alignment.
Figure 4: Outdoor weathering: measured and predicted strength loss after four years of outdoor weathering
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 107
Textile reinforced concrete - durability issues: changes of the bond and tensile strength due to ageing
107
RESULTS Bond behavior between textile reinforcement and matrix due to ageing Figure 5 shows the composite strain and the distance between cracks as a function of the applied composite stress. For each series, only one stress-strain curve is shown so that the diagram is not overloaded, but the difference between several specimens in one series was relatively small. The points indicating the average distance between neighboring cracks are the average values of the three tested specimens per series. From these measurements of the strain Hc and crack distance x as function of stress Vc and with help of equations (1), (2) and (3) the normalized bond shear flow T can be calculated at several stress levels per tested specimen. These results are depicted in figure 6. Figure 5 and figure 6 show that, although a distinct loss of composite failure stress due to ageing was measured, no evolution of T with accelerated ageing was noticed. This does not mean that there are no effects of embrittlement at all, since the effect was only measured after the standard curing and hydration products will be mainly deposited during curing. One can however say that the studied standard cured specimens will not suffer further noticeable degradation due to embrittlement during the service life of a structural element made of TRC.
Figure 5: Strain and distance between crack as a function of tensile stress (TRC specimen 2.67% vol fibres); cured at 23 °C and 99 % RH for 28 d before ageing
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
108
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 108
Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH
Figure 6:Normalized bond shear flow T as function of ageing,TRC specimen 2,67% vol fibres Durability of polymer modified textile reinforced concrete The presented results were obtained by using the previously described TSP-specimens with the reinforcement glued to the end of the specimens. After the curing (28 d at 99 % RH) the specimens were stored under water at 50 °C in order to age them accelerated. This accelerated aging represents one possible set of parameters. In order to predict the long-term loss of strength due to outdoor weathering with the presented model, the ageing as a function of humidity and temperature has to be investigated. It is not possible to predict the long-term loss of strength just on the basis of a single parameter ageing. The detailed way is described in [2, 6]. The influence of different polymeric modifications of the reinforcements can be seen in figure 7 left, where the test results are displayed – the lines represent regression curves calculated with the durability model. In all investigations the reference is represented by a non-polymer modified concrete with AR-glass reinforcement, which is supposed to be the harshest environment for AR-glass reinforcement. It can be seen that after 200 days of accelerated ageing (50 °C and water storage) the loss of strength of the non-impregnated textile reinforcement in a non modified concrete is approximately 60 %. The use of a polymeric impregnation leads to a noticeable reduction of the loss of strength in accelerated ageing. The cold-hardening resin (EP STF STD) leads to higher losses than the Prepreg-Resin. At the moment it is assumed that the diffusion of alkaline ions is mainly effected by the different structures of the two resins. The actual research is dealing mainly with this phenomenon. In figure 7 right the results of a polymer modified concrete in combination with a plain AR-glass reinforcement and a polymer modified reinforcement are shown –the identical polymer was used for both modifications. It can be seen, that the loss of strength is reduced by the use of a polymer modified concrete. Investigations, which were carry out in parallel, show that the capillary water absorption is significantly reduced by the PCC. Actual research deals with the question how big does the reduction of the capillary water uptake has to be in order to reduce the loss of strength effectively and what the influence of the storage conditions (especially storage under water) on the behavior of the specimens is. By combining the PCC with a polymer modified reinforcement (identical polymer) the loss of strength can
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 109
Textile reinforced concrete - durability issues: changes of the bond and tensile strength due to ageing
109
be reduced to nearly zero. This behavior could only be detected with this combination of polymers. The reasons are not clarified yet.
Figure 7: Left: strength loss of TSP-specimens using two different polymer modified reinforcements; right: strength loss of TSP-specimens using polymer modified reinforcement as well as polymer modified concrete
CONCLUSIONS
Two aspects of the durability of TRC are discussed in this paper. Results dealing with the evolution of the bond between matrix and reinforcement as well as the loss of strength of the AR-glass reinforcement due to glass corrosion are presented. The measurement of the stress-strain behavior was used in combination with the crack counting technique to evaluate the bond behavior under accelerated ageing for full TRC composite specimens. These investigations showed no loss of bond strength, although a distinct loss of the composite failure strength was detected. This loss of strength was investigated for various polymer modified materials. The durability of impregnated AR-glass textiles embedded in micro grained concrete is improved compared to the non-impregnated AR-glass textiles. But also a polymeric modification of the matrix can reduce the loss of strength of the AR-glass reinforcement. Actual research deals with the reasons for the improvement of the durability caused by polymeric systems [1]. As mentioned above, it is also important to mention that the obtained values of the strength loss in accelerated ageing conditions can not be correlated directly with any strength loss due to outdoor weathering – in order to predict a long term strength loss, calculations with the durability model have to be carried out. ACKOWLEDGEMENTS
The investigations at the ibac, RWTH Aachen University, are part of the Collaborative Research Center 532 ”Textile reinforced concrete – Basics for the development of a new technology” and sponsored by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG). The support is
11-Textile reinforced.qxd
110
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 110
Till BÜTTNER, Jeanette ORLOWSKY and Michael RAUPACH
gratefully acknowledged. Furthermore the close collaboration with Dr. ir. H. Cuypers (VUB – Brussels) is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES
1. Keil, A., Raupach, M.: Improvement of the load-bearing capacity of textile reinforced concrete by the use of polymers, in: Proceedings of Ohama Symposium, 12th International Congress on Polymers in Concrete ICPIC'07, September 26-28, 2007 Chuncheon, Korea, 873-881 2. Orlowsky, J.: Zur Dauerhaftigkeit von AR-Glasbewehrung in Textilbeton (Durability of TRC; PhD Thesis). Berlin: Beuth. - In: Schriftenreihe des Deutschen Ausschusses für Stahlbeton, 2005, No. 558 3. Orlowsky, J., Raupach, M.: Modelling the loss in strength of AR-glass fibres in textilereinforced concrete. In: Materials and Structures (RILEM) 39, 2006, No. 6, 635-643 4. Cuypers H., Wastiels J.: A stochastic matrix cracking theory for glass-fibre reinforced cementitious composites. Materials and Structures, vol. 39 (292), 2006, 777-786 5. Cuypers H., Wastiels J., Van Itterbeeck P., De Bolster E., Orlowsky J. and Raupach M.: Durability of glass fibre reinforced composites experimental methods and results, Composites Part A: Applied Science and Manufacturing, vol. 37 (2), 2006, 207-215 6. Büttner, T., Orlowsky, J., Raupach, M.: Investigation of the durability of textile reinforced concrete - test equipment and modelling the long-term behaviour: [ISBN 9782-35158-046-2] Bagneux: RILEM, 2007. - RILEM Proceedings PRO 53. - In: High Performance Fiber Reinforced Cement Composites (HPFRCC5), Proceedings of the Fifth International RILEM Workshop, Mainz, July 10-13, 2007, Reinhardt, H.W. and Naaman, A.E. eds., 333-341 7. Brameshuber, W.; Brockmann, T.; Hegger J.; Molter, M.: Untersuchungen zum textilbewehrten Beton (Investigations of TRC). Beton 52, 2002, Nr.9, 424-429 8. Orlowsky J., Raupach M., Cuypers H., Wastiels J.: Durability modelling of glass fibre reinforcement in cementitious environment. Materials and Structures, vol. 38 (276), 2005, 155-162 9. Banholzer B., Brameshuber W., Jung W.: Analytical simulation of pull-out-tests - the direct problem. Cement and Concrete Composites, 27 (1), 2005, 93-101 10. Banholzer B., Brameshuber W., Jung W.: Analytical evaluation of pull-out-tests - the inverse problem. Cement and Concrete Composites 28, 2006, 564-571 11. Pryce A. W., Smith P. A.: Matrix cracking in unidirectional ceramic composites under quasi-static and cyclic loading. Acta Metall. Mater., No. 41., 1993, 1269-1281 12. He M. Y., Wu B.-X., Evans A. G., Hutschinson .J W.: Inelastic strains due to matrix cracking in unidirectional fiber-reinforced composites, Mechan. Mater., vol. 18, 1994, 213 13. Curtin W. A.: Multiple matrix cracking in brittle matrix composites, Acta Metal. Mater., No. 41, 1993, 1369 14. Curtin W. A.: Stochastic damage evolution and failure in fibre-reinforced composites, Advances in Applied Mechanics (36), 1999, 163-253 15. Naaman A. E., Namur G. G., Alwan J. M., Najm. H. S.: Fiber pull-out and bond slip, I: analytical study. II: experimental validation. Structural engineering 117 (9), 1991, 27692800
12-Impact study.qxd
9/19/2009
11:59 AM
Page 111
Proc. Int. Symp. "Brittle Matrix Composites 9" A.M. Brandt, J. Olek and I. H. Marshall, eds. Warsaw, October 25-28, 2009 IFTR and Woodhead Publ., Warsaw 2009
IMPACT STUDY OF TEXTILE REINFORCED CEMENTITIOUS MATERIALS: TEST METHOD AND PRELIMINARY RESULTS
J. Van Ackeren, J. Blom, D. Kakogiannis, J. Wastiels, D. Van Hemelrijck, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Department of Mechanics of Materials and Constructions, Pleinlaan 2, 1050 Brussels, Belgium, e-mail:
[email protected] S. Palanivelu, W. Van Paepegem, J. Degrieck, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Universiteit Gent, Sint-Pietersnieuwstraat 41, 9000 Gent, Belgium. J. Vantomme, Koninklijke Militaire School, Civil and Materials Engineering Department, Building G, Level 0, 8 Av. Hobbema B-1000, Brussels, Belgium.
ABSTRACT In building engineering, impact loading and other accidental loads are mostly taken into consideration by measures on the structural level rather than on the material level, the latter one is even seldom explored. Textile reinforced Cements (TRCs) is a composite material group which is still in full development. Its potential to dissipate a significant amount of energy under low velocity impact loading was already indicated in a preliminary study. In the present study, the low velocity impact behaviour of TRC laminates is investigated more closely and this by means of an instrumented drop weight test. This study has shown the ability of th