AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS Frances Tustin Child Psychotherapist an...
340 downloads
2228 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS Frances Tustin Child Psychotherapist and Honorary Affiliate of the British Psycho-Annlyticnl Society
Foreword b y
James S. Grotstein
London
KARNAC BOOKS
Drawing by J.F. Batellier, reproduced from Is Anybotiv Ozrl There:) courtesy of Free Association Books. Ted Hughes' poem 'Wodwo' is reprinted from Wo&-o by perlnission of Faber and Faber Ltd. Verses from ' I an1 a Rock' are reproduced by kind permission of Mr Paul Simon. O Paul Simon, 1965.
First published in 1986 by H. Karnac (Books) Ltd. Karnac Books Ltd. 6 Pelnbroke Buildings 118 Finchley Road London N W I0 6RE London NW3 5HT Second impression 1994 Reprinted 2003
O 1986 by Frances Tustin All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means. electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher.
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A C.I.P. for this book is available frorn the British L,ibraly 0 94643 ISBN: 0978 946439 25925 7 6 www.karnacbooks.com
Printed & bound by Antony Rowe Ltd, Eastbourne
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
11but three of the papers that compose this book have been written since the publication of my last book, Autistic States in Children. An invitation to speak to a receptive audience inevitably engenders new thoughts, so my gratitude goes out to the various organizations who have welcomed me into their midst. The book also owes a great deal to those psychoanalysts mid psychotherapists from England and abroad who have consulted me about their work and have generously allowed me to use their observations. When they presented their work to me, they were often not aware of the new thoughts that were stirring in my mind; their work and the discussions I had with them either confirmed or modified what I was thinking. I am grateful to these people for their carefully recorded material and for the discussio~~s I had with them. They are too numerous to nlention individually, but they will know who they are, and I take this opportunity to thank them. As always, gratitude is felt towards my husband for raising uncomfortable question-marks in niy mind about the conclu-
vi
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
sions I was drawing from my observations. These have opened doors to increased insight. The effort to think about such questions lights a lamp in the mind which helps in facing the inevitable areas of darkness imposed by one's own human limitations. Warm thanks are also due to Miriam and Alex'mder Newman of the Squiggle Foundation, wlno have always been on hand to help me in situations of crisis. I also want to thank my friend Victoria Hamilton for giving me a complete copy of Tennyson's In Memoriant. and for all tlne helpful discussions I have had with her. These acknowledgements would not be complete without mentioning Professor Adri'ulo Giannotti, wlno now has the Chair of Child Neuropsychiatry in the Institute of Childhood Neuropsyclniatry of Rotnle University, and his co-workers, who have welcomed me every year for the past ten years to give papers to well-attended conferences. Work with this well-endowed institute, in which autistic children are investigated from tlne metabolic, organic, psychotherapeutic, and educational points of view, has extended my knowledge of autistic children. I am grateful to Dr Decobert of the Clapar&de Clinic in Paris, and to Dr Genevieve Haag, Leni Iselin, and Dr Anik Maufras de Chatellier for their support and invitations over many years. Dr Viky Subirana, Medical Director of Carrilet Unit for Autistic Children in Barcelona, is remembered for her warm welco~nneto me and to my ideas. I am also grateful to the California Institute of the Arts and tlne Continuing Education S e m i n m of Los Angeles for their encouragement and the videos they have made of my presentations to them. I must also acknowledge with thanks the per~nnissionfro111 the editors of the Inter-national Review cf Psycho-Analysis, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. BI-itishJournal of Medical Psychology, Journal of Child Psychottrer'apy, Patio, and Topique to reprint papers originally published in their journals.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
vii
I should also like to thank Ann Scott for her careful and facilitating editing of this book. Finally, I am grateful to Harry K'u~lacand Cesare Sacerdoti for giving me the privilege of preparing a book which I knew had a publisher enthusiastic to receive it, and who would expedite its publication. Last but not least, I want to thank Audrey Franklin and Mrs. G. Soloman, who have typed these papers so accurately and-expeditiously. Frances Tustin
March 1986
This book is dedicated to the sad and terrified children from whom I have learned so much, and also to their parents who have supported me so valiantly
CONTENTS
v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS FOREWORD
by James S. Grotstein
xiii
Preface (1 994) Introduction
PART ONE
1
2
3 4
Psychogenic autism The nature of psychogenic autism: an overview The growth of understanding: a personal statement Thoughts on psychogenic autism with special reference to a paper by Melanie Klein A significant element in the development of psychogenic autism
19 33 48 67
xii AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS 5 6 7
8 9 10
Situations which may precipitate psychogenic autism Autistic objects Autistic shapes exemplified in childhood psychopathology Autistic shapes exemplified in adult psychopathology Shapes associated with emergence from psychogenic autism A glimpse into the world of an autistic child
PART TWO
11 12 13 14
15 16
Psychogenic autism in neurotic patients Falling Spilling and dissolving The development of 'I-ness' Anorexia nervosa in an adolescent girl The rhythm of safety Psychotherapy with psychogenic autistic states
Concluding remarks
BIBLIOGRAPHY INDEX
94 102 119 141
157 170
FOREWORD
b y James S . Grotstein
nfantile autism, once located in the obscure outback of the mental health field, has recei~tlycome into welldeserved prominence because of the pioneering contributions of several distinguished investigators who have spent a great portion of their lives in the clinical investigation of this disorder. Leo Kanner (1949) did yeoman's service in separating infantile autism from mental retardation. Following this, Margaret Mahler (1958) recognized the differences between infantile autism and infantile symbiosis and then postulated that these disturbances represented pathological extensions of what she proposed to be normal, successive stages of infant development, each of which paved the way for the separation and individuation of the child. Then Donald Meltzer and his colleagues published a significant monograpl~(1975) which detailed the phenomenology of infantile autistic psychosis and helped us to understand it from an intrapsychic point of view. They postulated that the infant who is to become autistic recognizes the presence of depression in his or her mother and,
xiv
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
as a consequence, dismantles his or her own ego, particularly those capacities that knowingly depend upon mother for their welfare. The autistic children dismantle their dependencyaware egos allegedly so as not to jeopardize their depressed mothers further. Illusory autistic autonomy is the result. Frances Tustin has more recently joined this distinguished group of investigators of autism and has already made contributions that have not only greatly increased our knowledge about the nature of this disorder and how to treat it but, perhaps even more significantly, have brought the concept of autistic enclaves into the very centre of our concept of neuroses as well as other more common psychopathological disorders. Moreover, she has nude formulations which, if accepted, may help to alter some of our fundamental conceptions about infant development itself. The present work comprises a series of papers, most of which were published subsequent to her latest book, Autistic States In Children (1981). They continue the thrust of this earlier work 'and also constitute clarifications and modification of her rich ideas. In addition, they offer some significant newer ideas about autism, not only in infants and children, but also ill adults, particularly in such entities as neuroses, phobias, anorexia nervosa and other eating disorders, substance abuse, and perversions. Frances Tustin's wellspring is that of Melanie Klein and Wilfred Bion, but the range of writers she draws on is noteworthy-Winnicott, Bowlby, Meltzer, Erikson, Mdller, and also, poignantly, such poets as Tennyson, MacNeice, Plath, Eliot. Hughes, and Yeats. The reader is therefore presented with a patchwork quilt of many colours but one which nevertheless achieves har~nony,texture, and quality. In her earlier works, particularly Autistic Stares in Children. Frances Tustin emphasized two childhood psychotic entities, the encapsulated or shell-type child and the confusional or entangled child. The former constitutes infaantileautistic illness proper, and the latter, symbiotic or schizophrenic psychosis of childhood. She described the encapsulated child as a being
FOREWORD
xv
characterized by the use of hard autistic objects, which differ from transitional objects both in their aim and in the technique of using them. Autistic objects are employed by the encapsulated autistic infant in an idiosyncratic and surreptitious manner to soothe himself in his isolation; they are not meant to maintain the illusion of bondedness to the mother in her absence. Thus, according to Tustin, transitional objects are object-related, and autistic objects are purposely nonobject-related. The confusional child, on the other hand, is characterized as employing soft objects in order to 'mop up' the experience of woundedness. Both types of autistic child have in common the experience of a process of 'premature mental birth', which propels them into a world of precocious sep'uateness from their mothers without the requisite individuation that this cataclysmic separation would ordinarily entail. The encapsulated children protect themselves from this cataclysm by developing an imaginary hard shell to shield their hypersensitive surfaces from the hostile, dangerous impingements of all 'not-me' experiences, primary among which is that of the 'stranger/mother'. The confusional child, on the other hand, seems to t'ke the opposite course, becoming inextricably bound in the substance of mother, confused with her, so as not to be separate. In this present work, Frances Tustin concentrates more on encapsulated children, reiterating her belief that they have experienced 'premature mental birth', that they are probably born with a hypersensitivity to life, and that they frequently have experienced impingement by mothers who suffered from depressive illness, a fhding that Meltzer and his colleagues had also noted (1975). Confusional children, Tustin now believes, may have developed a maternal bond and then regressed from it. Further, she now states that the autistic encapsulated child is not psychotic by virtue of his or her encapsulation; in fact, this seenls to protect this type of child against the psychosis that charncterizes the confusional child. What I find to be of particul'u significance in Frances Tustin's present work is her elaboration of aurosensuousness,
xvi
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
a phase of development which she now suggests occurs normally prior to autoeroticism and autosadism and is followed in turn by narcissism. The emphasis in classical psychoanalysis has clearly shifted lately from neuroses to more primitive stages of development, and narcissism seems to have emerged as the commonly designated term to embrace them. Melanie Klein had been there all along with her psychoanalytic conception of internalized objects and the infant's identifications with them, which constituted her version of narcissism. Klein, however, as Tusti~lpoints out, dealt with infants who were thought to have been already bonded with their motliers and, consequently, to have developed psycliopathology in proportion as they attacked (or believed ~ J phantasy I that they attacked) those bonds, metaphorically represented principally as the breast. Tustin suggests that Klein's psychology applies to symbiotic or schizophrenic-type children, not to autistic ones. Here, she is explaining a stage that is more primitive th'm bonding, a state already alluded to by Fairbairn's description of the schizoid position (1952). by Bion's theory of infantile catastrophe (1970). by Mahler's idea of infantile depression (1966), and by Winnicott's of 'failure to go-on-being' (1958). In my own writings, I have referred to this stage as that of inchoate randomness or meaninglessness awaiting the mother's loving signification to give the i11fa11t its tneaningfuh~essand thus to rescue him or her from the 'abyss of the deep and formless infinite'. Two other followers of Klein, Esther Bick and Donald Meltzer (1968), had already made forays into this earlier era of mental life when tliey posited that some of their autistic children showed developmental arrests which occurred even earlier than Klein's paranoid-schizoid position. They termed this adhesive identification and postulated tliat these children suffer consequently from adhesive identity, by which they tneai tliey have no sense of identity of their own mid achieve a tentative 'as if' identity by adhering to solid surfaces, including the surfaces of their mother's body, at first concretely and later metaphorically.
FOREWORD xvii Frances Tustin's conceptualization of autosensuousness seems to give important perspective to this newly discovered phase of infant development and is undoubtedly being conf m e d at this time by empirical itlfiult observation. Of particular importance for clinical psychoanalysis and psychotherapy, however, is her postulation of critical deficits in this primitive stage, an area that she has explored extensively over decades. I understand her to suggest that encapsulated autistic children in particular demonstrate a pathological, abrupt rupture of autosensuousness so that, whereas normal autosensuousness and subsequent development into sensual differentiation and integration ultimately link to bonding with objects through the senses separately and together, pathological autosensuousness has cut the cord, so to speak. Herein lies the brilliance of Tustin's contribution, I believe. She states that, in effect, the encapsulated autistic child seems never to have developed a viable, sanguine sensuous colltact with its motlier because of its experience of premature mental birth. It felt too existentially alone too early and therefore became sealed off by this very aberrant, involuted autosensuousness. Thereafter, tlie objects of the senses are no longer tlie desired and needed mother; instead, they are tlie sensuous pllantoms of the sense organs themselves; the autoclitl~onous'objects' that autosensations now patllologically create on their own become the new-found 'objects' of the encapsulated child. Frances Tustin's first discovery in the area of deviant autosensuality was in relation to autistic objects, hard objects barred from the outside or objects from the self (the tongue, faeces, extensions of the inner tilucosa of the mouth, etc.) which would, by their reassuring hardness, seemingly, 'plug up the holes above their inner emptiness'. Her later discovery, elaborated in the present work, is that of autistic shapes. Thus, clutchblg an object tightly produces hard object-like sensations, whereas stroking or holding an object loosely produces evanescent shapes soothing to the encapsulated child. Thus, such a child seems trapped in an empty fortress surrounded by
xviii AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS a wall of pathological autosensuousness which conjures up hard object-like sensations 'and soft idiosyncratic shapes to reassure the child, wlio is now cut off from humui contact. Mention should also be made of Tustin's emphasis on the importance of dentition as a catastrophic landmark in the development of autistic children. Apparently, the transforniation from the sucking inf'ant to the biting infant is a critical one and seems to inspire the emergence of atavistic phantasies belonging to the preylpredator category. According to Tustin, predator anxiety beconies intimately linked 'and confused with all 'not-me' experiences and associated with the experience of infantile depression. To that, I would add infantile panic disorder. It therefore becomes more understmidable that these children should hide behind their shells, involute developmentally back into tlien~selves,mid compulsively manipulate their objects, both autistic objects mid hum'an 'not-me' objects, into being their servants-so that they do not have to leave the capsule and experience disaster while servicing their needs. In this regard, Tustin's observations display tlie origins of perversions, both physical a i d cyclical, froni tlie ~iiostunique arid credible perspective. These ideas might seen1 to be recondite and confined to the limited area of infantile autistic illness, were not Tusthi's ideas so credible when linked to more comn~onlydiscussed adult psychopathology. Dr Sydney Klein, a fellow traveller of Frances Tusthi's, had already made a contribution along these lines, and she greatly elaborates on his contribution in the present work. Pathological autosensuousness can clearly be seen, for instance, in patients with anorexia nervosa who can be thought of as having erected mi imaginary autosensuous shell around them to keep out 'not-me' food from the outside world. Again, it can be seen in the behaviour of a patient of mine, a dutiful housewife wlio shunned sex mid obsessively engaged in meaningless crossword puzzles till late in the night while by day she distracted herself with meaningless bookkeeping-all to keep her emotions at bay as well as her awarenesses of need for her husband and her analyst. Another
FOREWORD xix patient of mine, a man in his late fifties who had been mamed five times, revealed a dream in which one of the features was a concrete bathroom. His associations led to the need for privacy aid insulation, from which developed a history of pseudocontact with people but with a sense of detachn~ent from them. Where he really lived was in his concrete bathroom of isolation. The sub-clinical encapsulated child probably continues on in tlie wide variety of alexithyniic disorders and the whole gamut of those suffering from schizoid detachment, whereas the sub-clinical confusional child s e e m to live on as borderline with narcissistic personality disorders and, in particular, in the new category known as hysteroid dysphoria, an entity known for its particular hypersensitivity to object loss and its compensatory use of objects in an entangled, addictive manner. While there is some similruity to Winnicott's concept of the 'true selflfalse self', Tustin has amended her views about this correlation in her present work, She now finds that the phenomenon she designates is even deeper than 'true self/false self' insofar as autistic children have never even developed a sense of self; they have only a neuronientd ego looking for a self, but never finding it because of tlie barricade erected by their autistic autosensuousness. Even more profoundly, Frances Tustin's research allows us to penetrate to a level of meaning beyond cognition, beyond instincts, beyond emotions, even beyond phantasy; she has given us a glimpse into the very roots of perception and has thereby elevated (auto)sensuousness to its deserved signific~mce. This is an important work and also a most enjoyable one to read. I am sure that many readers will feel, as I did, 'That applies to a patient of mine; this applies to another patient. Hey, wait a minute, that applies to tne !'
xx
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
REFERENCES Bick, E. (1968). 'The experience of the skin in early object relntions'. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, 49: 484-486. Bion, W. R. (1970). Attention and Interpretation. London, Sydney, Toronto, and Wellington: Tnvistock Publications. meprinted London: Kmnac Books, 1984.1 Fairbairn. W. R. D. (1952). Psyckoanalytic Studies of the Personality. London, Henley and Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Kanner, L. (1949). 'Problems of nosology and psychodynamics of enrly infantile autism'. American Journal of Orthopsycltiutry, 19: 41-26.
Klein, M. (1950). Contributions to Psycho-Analysis 1921-1945. London: The Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis. Klein, M. (1959). The Psycho-Analysis of Children. London: The Hogarth Press and the Institute of Psycho-Analysis. Mnhler. M. (1959). 'Autism and sy~i~biosis-two extreme disturbances of identity'. International Jorrrnal of Psycho-Analysis, 39: 77-83.
Mahler, M. (1966). 'Notes on the developnient of basic moods: the depressive affect'. In R. M. Lowenstein. L. M. Newman, M. Schur, and A. J. Solnit (Eds.), Psyckoanalysis: Essays in Honor of Heinz Hartmann @p. 152-168). New York: Internntional Universities Press. Meltzer, D. (1975). 'Adhesive identification'. Contenrporary Psyclzoanalysis, 11: 289-3 10. Meltzer, D., Bremner, J., Hoxter, S., Weddell, H.. & Wittenberg. I. (1975). Explorations in Atttisni. Strnth Tny, Perthshire: Clunie Press. Tustin. F. (1981). Atttistic States in Clzilclrcn. London, Henley, and Boston: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Winnicott, D. W. (1958). Collected Pupers: Throligh PaeJiutrics to Psychoanalysis. London: Tnvistock Publications.
An infant crying in the night: An infant crying for the light: And with no language but a cry. Tennyson, In Memoriant. LIII
PREFACE
am grateful to Cesare Sacerdoti of Kamac Books for giving me the opportunity to write a new preface to this second impression of Autistic Barriers in Neurotic Patients. for since this book was first published certain experiences have caused me to think more deeply about the nature of Childhood Autism. Of necessity, what I have to say will be somewhat anecdotal because I shall be instancing recent experiences that have influenced my thinking along certain lines. Revised views on normal printnry auzism After I had given up the hypothesis of autistic illness being a regression to an early infantile stage of normal primary autism ('Revised understandings of psychogenic autism', 1991, and 'The perpetuation of an error', 1994), I made a careful survey of the early histories of my own treatment cases of autistic disorder. As a result of this, I developed the alternative hypothesis that early-childhood autism is a two-stage illness:
2 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS the first stage being an unduly close association with the mother, the father often being virtually absent or excluded. Such a child has been described as a 'cork child' to plug the hole of the mother's depression and loneliness (Joyce McDougall, 1986 and 1989). The second stage is when this over-vulnerable, 'hot-housed' child inevitably becomes aware of bodily separateness. This is in such a sudden and painful way for it to seem to be a life-threatening disaster. It is traumatic. Trauma as a precipitant The undue closeness of mother a11d child me'ans that from birth the infant has had the illusion that (s)he was still part of the mother's body. This prevented normal attachment processes from developing. Sudden awareness of their separatedness from each other had felt like being violently wrenched apart. It was experienced as a death-dealing catastrophe of poignant loss. It had been a traumatic 'psychological birth' (1981), following which the mother had not been able to provide the 'mental uterus' the baby needed. Lacking the focus of a secure attachment to a breast that was the source of sensuous satisfaction, post-umbilical susten'mce, and safety has tainted the whole of these children's psychological development. Autistic processes have developed as a reaction to this unbearable elemental trauma of separatedness: the deadening of responsiveness being a reaction which is specific to any kind of trauma. Murderousness as a consequence of trauma and non-attachment My conviction about the appositeness of this hypothesis relating the precipitation of autism to a traumatic experience was strengthened by two broadcasts about serial killers. The milkers of one of these (ITV Chulnel 4, Sunday, 12 December 1993) talked to the parents of a mass killer and were given unique access to audio-taped interviews between hirn and a forensic psychologist.
PREFACE
3
They found that research into more than 200 cases of serial murders had enabled forensic psychologists to create a model of a typical mass-murderer's personality. This had sliown that the behaviour of some serial killers could be traced back to childhood traumas. The traumas of being subjected to physical or sexual abuse, or of experiencing a painful break-up of their parents' mamage, were cited. Tlie elemental trauma of awareness of wounding bodily separatedness such as I had found to have happened to autistic children was not instanced, although Dr John Bowlby's work comes close to this. In his early paper concerning 'Forty-four juvenile thieves: tlieir characters and home-life' (1944), Bowlby traced their delinquency back to early traumas of geographical separation from the mother, such as going into hospital. He described actual experiences of separation fro111 the mother, but these were at an age older than that of the autistic children I have studied. In the second programme about 'Serial Killers' (Radio 4, 3 December 1993), a psychiatrist called Janice Morrison, who had spent hundreds of hours with some of America's most notorious murderers, described her interviews with them. I was particularly struck by her description of these killers as not making tlie distinction between animate and inanimate objects. This is the distinguishing feature of autistic children. For example, Peter Hobson, in his recent book Autism and the Development of Mind (1 993), writes about autistic children as follows: They are relatively successful hi following the I-It developmental pathway. . . It is specifically in 1-Thou interpersonal relatedness that we find the abnormalities characteristic of 'autism'. (p. 197)
.
When Momson investigated tlie early personal history of the murderers, she found that, as infants, many of them had been relatively undifferentiated from their mothers with whom they had been unduly close.
4 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS Conzparison of autistic children and serial killers In spite of the differences in the traumas that have precipitated their disorder, both autistic children and delinquents (including mass murderers) have important features in common. They have both experienced difficulties in what Bowlby, influenced by ethology, called 'Bonding'. This notion of 'bonding' is now used in popular speech and was used by the makers of the television programme about serial killers. This early lack of a primal attachment affects the development of relationships to people-the 'I-Thou' approach. As will become clear from this book, clinical work has caused me to see primal attachment as a time when sensuous contraries, such as llard and soft, male 'and female elements, come together as the infant's attention becomes focused upon the suckling mother in a working relationship. The apathy of a depressed mother and possibly a depressed child prevents this resilient contact. Both autistic children and mass murderers are out of touch with people. The makers of the television programme I have cited said:
The future killer fends off unhappiness by suppressing a11 feelings towards family and friends and becomes increasingly isolated. Refuge is found in f'antasies which provide situations which can be controlled. (Article in the Radio Times. 11-17 December 1993, p. 5) Autistic children have no fantasies, iuld their trauma has occurred earlier. However, there are other features that autistic children and mass murderers have in common. They both have trouble in managing their violent feelings. In addition, because they both feel so weak and helpless, they need to feel powerful and in control. Interesth~gly,the forensic psychologists found that killers conlmitted murders when some person had threatened to separate from them. An autistic cltild wlto becantc?nzurderous The mass murderers were usually glad to be arrested and imprisoned. The programme-makers suggested that this could
PREFACE
5
be due to the fact that, after this took place, they received a great deal of attention. It could also be due to the fact that they felt that their violence was being contained. Unlike the autistic children, they have not had the 'prison of autism' to hold it in check. Several years ago, I saw a BBC television film about Bruno Bettelheim's Orthogenic School, in which former pupils of the school talked about their experiences there. One of them (now a professor!) told about an autistic boy in the school. He described, with great sadness, how this boy had given up his autistic controls only to become schizophrenic and murderously violent. [The fact that, as I have previously noted (e.g. Tustin, 1990), a schizophrenic illness can develop when the controls of autism break down makes me think that there is something to be said for seeing autism as part of a psychotic continuum.] From being suicidal-as most autistics a r e - h e had become tnurderous. Bettelheim could no longer keep him in the school. He was sent to a state institution, where he was given a loboton~y.This account brought home to me that it is a serious matter to disturb the barrier of autism until, it1 psychoanalytic therapy, an 'infimtile transference' has begun to develop. This sets in train sociable ru~d friendly feelings towards people in the outside world. Even the murderous feelings are attached to real people and begin to lose their largerthan-life quality. Until these attachn~entsrein in the violence, the children are instinctively afraid that the violent feelings that are entrapped by the autism will be let loose. Work with autistic children highlights the importance of social relationships in human development. These provide constraints on violence and give protection. The stripping away of autistic processes by lnetllods that do not take account of the importance of early relationships must be a cause for concern. A ysycko-analytic trcatnzcnt A further relevant experience has been a weekly discussion
with a very experienced child psychotherapist about a threetimes-a-week psycho-analytic treatment of a non-speaking
6 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS autistic boy, who, since the age of thirteen, has been in psychotherapy for one year. The parents are co-operative and intelligent. They had sought psycho-analytic help for Denis (as I will call hirn), when he was much younger, but it was not available. He is not a classic Kanner-type autistic child. His early history was quite complicated. Just before he was born, his head was thought to be too small, with the possibility of tleurological disturbance. He screamed constatltly for the first three months of life and could not be comforted. He was a difficult baby to rear. He developed a considerable amount of l'mguage between the ages of one-and-a-half and three but stopped speaking following several traunlatic hospitalizations. He has been diagnosed as 'autistic' by several psychologists, with a score of 49 on the CARS scale. This corresponds to 'severe autism'. He hums persistently and displays characteristic stereotyped hand movements. About a year before he started treatment, he began to have fits (which were unsatisfactorily controlled by medication), but as treattilent has proceeded, these have become much less frequent. He seeins to use psycho-physical ways of dealing with his developmental difficulties. In trying to understand this boy, it has become clear to us that we are in the thick of his moral problem. In working with him, we seem to be studying the mainsprings of morality-that which Winnicott (1958) called 'the innate morality' of the child. This seems to stem from the fact that human beings are social herd animals. An i~nportantp,m of our understanding has been to realize the value of his autistic processes to this boy. We have come to see that Denis is desperately afraid of his vulnerability and his murderously violent impulses. The autism seems to provide a tough outer skil, bolh to protect his vulnerability and also to cage in his murderous violence. It is a defence against the 'black-hole' type of depression that is exemplified by John in Chapter 4. This means that it is a bllrrier against the disintegration 'md chaos threatened by the 'black hole', but it makes him resistant to our attempts to help him.
PREFACE
7
Denis expresses his violence in a 'low-key' way. For example, he pinches his therapist as he comes down the corridor to the therapy room. However, the terrible devil-grimaces he makes leave no doubt as to the intensity of his violence. As he enters the room, he bites and snaps at what he conceives to be the threats that have left traces behind them, such as smells, or at sensuous vestiges left on chairs, which he removes with scooping hand movements. He rubs his teeth with a toothbrushing motion as if to sharpen his fangs for an attack. Sometimes he is impelled to pace the room in a11 effort to master his feelings. However, he is never violent in a 'smashing-up' kind of way, although he will batter his own head very cruelly if not stopped. Ordinarily, he does not play with the toys that are put out for him to use, but recently, on one exciting day, he picked up the toy crocodile. He felt its hard skin and open mouth, which he put inside his own n~outli.He then tunled it over so that its soft vulnerable under-belly was exposed. After this, he sat on the couch, clutching a pillow. Then he wrapped himself in the blanket, so that only his head 'and a bit of the pillow were exposed. From experiences with other patients, I intuited that he could be feeling that the hard back protected the soft front. Dr Sydney Klein (1984), in describing 'an adult patient, gives us words for the feelings we have had about Denis when he writes: He gave me the impression of being covered by a leathery skin in which little flaps opened to take in interpretations which then disappeared without a trace 'and without any recognisable response. (p. 307) The 'crocodile session' was an occasion when one of the 'little flaps' opened in his tough autistic skin. We felt that, temporarily at least, Denis was less at the mercy of his violent feelings. By his use of a plaything, he had been able to clothe them in imagery, which enabled him to depict and communicate about them. Synlbolic play was beconling a possibility.
8
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
However, our joy was short-lived. hi succeeding sessions he was closed up again. Perhaps he was afraid of having shown us his vulnerability? Most of the time, violent sensations seemed to rampage through muscle and vein to impel him to crude actions. His body was taut and tense as if to feel that in this way he could control these violent sensations. Feelings of weakness and helplessness make autistic children feel that they must be in control. As one sucli child said to me, 'I am the m'anager'. The autistic processes of 'autistic sensation objects' and 'autistic sensation shapes' (such as are described in this book) help them to feel that poign'ant violent sensations are blocked out. Realizing this function of the autistic processes has helped us to see it in a more positive light. We do not wait to batter it down. Rather, we want to niodify it and to help Denis to develop less crude ways of coping with the vulnerability and murderous violence that threaten him with sucli disintegration and chaos. Work with these children has made tile realize that sensations are the beginnings of psychic life. To paraphrase Freud, the 'body ego' is 'first mid foreniost' a 'sensation ego'. We have all used 'sensation objects' 'and 'sensation shapes'. It is when these beconie compulsive atid addictive, and are used inappropriately to tlie exclusion of more socialized ways of dealing with sensation-driven impulses, that they can be called 'autistic sensation objects' and 'autistic sensation shapes'. As a result, such children's sensation life has gone awry. It has become perverse. From time to time, Denis feels that lie spills, spits out, throws, or stares the violent sensations out of him to a corner of the room, where they form a shadow on tlie wall, of which he is then frightened (the beginnings of projection). At this stage tlie Jungian image of 'the shadow' seems a potent and pertinent one. It is formed from the stormy serisatioiis of his psycliotlierapy, tlie 'inviolent impulsions. In psycho~~nlytic fantile transference' focuses tliese teliipestuous feelings. Until
PREFACE
9
now, he had felt that there was no one to focus them and contain them adequately, nor to be aware of the content of his alarms. He had established no framework of relationships to help him to feel safe. Instead he made use of his autistic straitjacket. The beginnings of fantasy An import'ant difference between the violence of autistic children and that of mass murderers is that-as I mentioned earlier-autistic children do not have proper fantasies. It is a progress when they begin to do so. This has brought home to me that the time when autistic children begin to develop fantasies is a critical one. This progress needs to be dealt with by an experienced and insightful psychotherapist, who well understands the use of the 'infantile tr'ansference'. This mecans that the infantile trauma of awareness of separatedness can be reexperienced, and the powerful feelings associated with it can be felt in the presence of sonleone who u~lderstandsthem and who can help the child to come to tertns with them. All this is exemplified in Chapter 4. The working-over of this early situation towards the suckling mother is critical. It will affect the development of relationships and also the type of fantasies developed by the child. What I am trying to say is that the primary relationship ('bonding') needs to have become established before it is safe for the strict controls of autism to be modified. Otherwise the autistic child may become a murderer, like the child in the Orthogenic School, instead of confining himself to the murder of his own mind. An indication that basic infantile feelings associated with relationships are developing is that the child begins to miss the therapist when a separation occurs. The violence associated with this needs to be handled with p'uticularly insightful understanding. (It is pleasing that on two occasiol~sbefore a recent holiday separation, Denis put his arnls around his therapist's neck in an affectionate hug rather thul giving her the strangleholds he had inflicted on her previously.)
10 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS Brain damage and generic predisposition The forensic psychologists stated that predisposing factors for the personalities of tlie serial murderers included braindamage and a genetic tendency to violence. Some autistic children do have brahi damage, but in lily experience not all of them had been found to be brain-damaged by tlie methods of investigation available at the time. (I have only treated tlie ones where no brain damage had been detected). Altliougli organic factors were clearly important bi Denis's development, they cmnot by themselves account for his autism. Thus lie was able to produce a complete sentence at the age of six, tliough this was not repeated. Wliile in therapy, he showed himself to be capable of considerable humour, though this was sparingly expressed bi sign lmiguage. A genetic tendency towards violence in autistic children is more difficult to ascertain. The fact that not all babies who have had an unduly close relationship with a depressed mother develop autism makes one wonder if there is some genetic predisposition at work in those who do? It could be that different factors operate i i different children. Childhood Autism is a rwe syndrome tliat probably results from a rare combination of factors; the likelihood of their occurring together bebig somewhat remote. We should also remember tliat when a disturbance occurs in very early infancy, there is the temptation to ascribe it to genetic factors. Whether genetic factors are at work in sonie forms of autism is one of the i~nponderableswe have to live with. 'Psycl~ogerric'or 'psychobiologiccll'? Tliere is one more change in my thinking that needs to be mentioned. In the present book, as i i others, I have used the term 'psychogenic autism'. I did this to distinguish the type of autistic child in whom no serious brahi dnniage could be detected, from tlie type of autistic child in whom organic factors had been clearly shown to be present. However, a review by Charlotte Riley (1993) of the revised edition of A ~ ~ r i s r Sln/es ic in Children (1992) has sliown lile tliat tlie tern1 'psychogenic autism' is misleading. Riley writes:
PREFACE
11
The word 'psychogenic' becomes a red rag to the readers who espouse the current popular conviction that autism is a discrete diagnostic entity with entirely biological origins. She goes on to say that we cannot know with any certainty that a particular diagnosis is either psychological or biological in origin. She points out that the division of the human being into 'psychic' or 'somatic' is 'an artefact of our methods of study m d acadenlic disciplines. Quite rightly, Riley said that I have presented statements of the complexity of tlie interweaving of biological mid psychological factors in autisni. This has caused nle to revise niy termhiology. I now realize that a more accurate term would be 'psychobiological autism'. It would be helpful if readers of this book would bear this in mind when they come across the phrase 'psychogenic autism'. It will also become clear to the reader that throughout the book I no longer think of 'autisni' as the name of a specific discrete illness, but that, based on my findings from working with children who have full-blown autism, I see the name 'autism' as designating a specific set of processes that deaden awareness, and which niay be operating in other psychopathologies in which 'an elemental trauma with its attendant autistic reactions has been split off and has lain dorniant, to surface later hi life. I developed this theme further in a subsequent book, The Protective Shcll in Children and Adults, also published by Kaniac Books. [I wish to express my gratitude to Maria Rhode for help in org'mizing this preface.] FI-ancesTustin January 1994
12 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS REFERENCES Bowlby. J . (1944). 'Forty-four juvenile thieves: their characters and hotne life'. International Jorrrnal of Psyclro-Analysis, 25: 1-57 and 207-228 [republished as a ~nonogrnphby Bailliere, Tindall and Cox, London, 19461. Hobson, P. (1993). Autism and the Developnlent of Mind. Hove, Sussex, & Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaurli Associates. Klein, S. (1984). 'Delinquent perversion: problems of assirnilation: a clinical study'. Internutioncll Jorrrncll of Psyclro-Anc~lysis,65: 307. McDougall, J. (1986). Tl~cutrcsof tlie Mind. London. Free Association Books. McDougall, J. (1989). Tlteutres of t11e Botly. London. Free Association Books. Riley, C. (1993). Review of F. Tustin, Atitistic S t u t ~ sin Chitir.cn, revised edition (1992). Winnicott St~rtlics,8. Tustin, F. (1981). 'Psychologicnl birth and psychologicnl catastrophe'. In: J. S. Grotstein (Ed.), D o I Dare D i s t l ~ r bthe Uniiu~rsc? @p. 181-197). Caesura Press. [Reprinted London: Knrnnc Books, 1983.1 Also in F. Tustin, Alitistic Stutcs it? Chiltlrcw (revised edition) (pp. 96-1 00). London: Tnvistock/Routledge, 1992. Tustin, F. (1994). 'The perpetuation of an error'. Jotirnul of Cltild Psychotlzerupy: 20 (1). Tustin, F. (in press). Letter: 'A c o ~ n ~ n opsychoanalytic n error about the etiology of nutistic disorders of children'. .lorrrncll of tile Antrricun Psychounulytic Associcltion.
INTRODUCTION
In words, like weeds. I'll wrap me o'er. Like coarsest clothes against the cold; But that large grief which these enfold Is given in outline and no more. Tennyson, In Memoriuni, v
his collection of papers seeks to share insights derived from my work with autistic children whose autism seems to be primarily psychogenic in origin. These insights have shed light on a hidden part of certain has conneurotic patients-both adults ru~dchildren-which stituted a b'urier to their emotional ,and intellectual functioning. Thus, this book will be of wider clinical relevance than my two previous ones, which were mostly restricted to the study of psychogenic autistic childre~i.S o ~ n eof the papers have been published in various psychoanalytic and psychotherapeutic journals, but others have been written especially for this book. In a collection of papers some repetition is inevitable, but this should help to familiarize the reader with what may be an unfamiliar approach to the problem of getting in touch with certain hard-to-reach neurotic patients. Although the papers are concerned with a 'way-out' part of the personality, this does not mean that it is a 'way-out' book.
14 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS It represents an attenipt to get in touch with idiosylicratic preverbal states to try to bring them within tlie orbit of human communication. I have called upon poets and writers to help me in this task. It has seemed to me that we need to be encircled by their integrating aesthetic embrace as we go through the states of unintegration and disintegration that will be discussed in this book. The attempt has been made to use a kind of poetic science, hi tlie hope that it will hold both author and reader through states of hypervuhierability such as are experienced when the protective autism falls away. Thus although this will inevitably be a disturbing book, it is hoped that it will also be a therapeutic one. One more importmit point needs to be made. It has seemed to be niore useful to study in detail tlie disturbmice to the psyche encountered in psychogenic autism than to adjudicate 'blame', either to parents or children. In such a study, tlie attempt lias to be made to live inside the skin of ,an autistic child in order to feel what it is like to be there. There are limits to one's capacity to do this, but the fact tliat many mothers of autistic children have said tliat what I have written in my two earlier books on autism 'rings true' lias encouraged me to feel that I have managed to do this to soirle extent. With each book, I feel I have become more closely i11 touch with tlie nature of psychogenic autism. Thus, tliis book will be divided into two parts. The first part will deal with tlie nature of psychogenic autism, based mostly on my work with autistic children. Since tliis promises to throw light on the psychogenic autism encountered in adult neurotic patients, the second part of the book will deal with tlie capsule of autism encountered in such neurotic patients. In his paper, 'Autistic phenomena ui neurotic patients', drawing on his work with autistic children, Dr Sydney Klein has alerted us to the hidden autistic part of certain neurotic patients. He writes as follows: In tlie course of a periodic review of the progress of lily analytic practice, and particularly of my patients' habitual
INTRODUCTION
15
modes of communication, I became aware that certain among whom I thought of initially as being only mildly neurotic, some of whom were also 'analytic candidates, revealed during the course of treatment phenomena familiar in the treatment of autistic children. These patients were highly intelligent, hard-working, successful and even prominent professionally and socially, usually pleasant and likeable, who came to analysis either ostensibly for p,rofessional reasons or because of a failure to maintain a satisfactory relationship with a husband or wife. It gradually became clear that in spite of the analysis apparently moving, the regular production of dreams, 'and reports of progress, there was a part of the patient's personality with which I was not in touch. I had the impression that no real fundamental changes were taking place. (S. Klein, 1980, p. 395) I have quoted at length from the introduction to Sydney Klein's paper because it describes so well the encapsulated, well-nigh impenetrable, autistic part of the personality of those neurotic patients who seem as though they will never be ready to finish coming to analysis because a crucial empty part of them has never been reached. Some readers may have difficulties in accepting the thesis that neurotic patients can have autistic impediments. This nlay be because they have never worked with psychogenic autistic children, 'and thus find it difficult to accept that such odd children can have 'an affinity with people with whom they can more easily identify. However, those of us who work with such children find an answering echo in ourselves. Other readers, p6uticularly those with a psychiatric orientation, may have difficulties in accepting this thesis because they think of autism as an irreversible, discrete syndrome, which is often associated with brain lesions and always with mi inbuilt cognitive defect. This has not been my experience. Sotile autistic children are undoubtedly brain-damaged. But there are other children whose autism seenls to be psychogenic in origin. It is
16 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
these latter children who have been the source of inspiration for the findings in this book. It will become clear that, as I have worked with these children, my understandings have been in a continual process of evolution. Chapter 2 traces the growth of this understanding. Frances Tustin
March 1986
PART ONE
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM Autistic children are diagnosed by their behaviour or, sometimes, lack of it. In their severest state they do not speak, or only echo what someone else has said, either immediately or after a period of time (delayed echolalia). If they move about (some will sit all day long motionless or producing one activity such as lifting and dropping an object), they usually appear uninterested in their surroundings. In fact, the behaviour of severely autistic children, unlike that of all except the most severely brain-damaged child, appears purposeless, but compares notably with that displayed by animals reared in strict isolation. Attempts to interest them in alternative behaviour are usually avoided or actively resisted, and can produce severe tantrums or attempts to escape the situation. They appear to have no sense of identity, and to inhabit an empty world. Brian Roberts, Introduction to Furneaux and Roberts (eds), Autistic Children, p. 10
CHAPTER ONE
The nature of psychogenic autism : an overview My mother groan'd, my father wept, Into the dangerous world I leapt: Helpless, naked, piping loud: Like a fiend hid in a cloud.
Struggling in my father's hands, Striving against my swaddling bands. Bound and weary I thought best To sulk upon my mother's breast. William Blake, 'Infant Sorrow'
o one would dispute that psychogenic autistic children are hard to reach. Indeed, the dispute might be as to whether they can be reached at all. However, it was my experience, as I became increasingly in touch with their idiosyncratic mode of functioning, that some young autistic children (though not all) could be reached by psychoanalytically based psychotherapy. However, before discussing psychogenic autism, let me say a word about the organic hypothesis.
The organic hypothesis I respect the concern of the organicists who feel that it is irresponsible to raise hopes in parents who have already suffered so much. It is regrettably true that in the early days, following Kanner's distinguishing 'early infantile autism' from mental deficiency, in an outburst of enthusiasm, psycho-
20 A U T I S T I C B A R R I E R S I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S analysts and psychotherapists made unjustified claims for the possibilities of the psychodynamic treatment of autism. Even today, in some quarters, the psychodynamicists do not make a clear distinction between psychogenic and organic autism, nor between autistic-type and schizophrenic-type disorders, and disorders arising from parental neglect. Some autistic children are undoubtedly brain-damaged, and thus have a cognitive defect. However, the organic hypothesis - that they have a genetic defect in terms of a 'fragile chromosome' - does not seem to have been borne out by attempts to replicate the treatment suggested for it. But these neurophysiological matters are not really my concern. As a psychotherapist, those children whose autism seems likely to be psychogenic in origin have been the focus of my attention. For those readers who have never worked with psychogenic autistic children, here is a brief description of them.
Description of psychogenic autistic children Such children seem to be in a massive, unmitigated primal sulk such as was described by Blake at the head of this chapter. But it is a much more intense sulk than that described by Blake. As we shall see in later chapters, it is shot through with umbrage and black despair such as have been described by Ted Hughes in Crow. This has caused them to be unrelated to the mother, and thus to people in general. They avoid looking at people, and communication by language, play, drawing or modelling is scanty, and often not present at all. T h e children I have treated have all been mute at the outset of treatment, but some autistic children are echolalic so that they communicate in a limited but bizarre way. These latter children also sometimes 'play' in a restricted, obsessional way. T h e late Margaret Mahler, in illuminating papers and books arising from her long experience with such children, has focused attention upon autistic children's difficulties concerning separation and individuation, and their fragile awareness of their own identity (Mahler, 1958). Such children lack empathy (see Hobson, 1986). They also lack
THE NATURE OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
21
imagination (see Frith, 1985). These children have no inner life. T o ascribe fantasies to them is incorrect. This makes psychotherapy with such children different from that with our other patients. Overall there is a gross early arrest of cognitive and affective development, although autistic children's physical development is usually normal. Indeed, they often have beautiful faces and well-formed bodies. Let me embody this description in a flesh-and-blood child patient who illustrated many of the features characteristic of psychogenic autism.
A consultation with an autistic child Six-year-old Stephen is brought to see me in my consultingroom. He makes no complaint about coming. He has on a shiny white plastic mackintosh with a zip up the front. He carries a toy car clutched tightly in the palm of his hand. His mouth, which is slightly open, seems limp and slack, but his body feels tight and hard as I guide him into the room. He is mute. Stephen stands before me with a well-formed body, an otherworldly look and melancholy eyes which do not meet mine directly. Whilst I wrestle to undo the zip of his mackintosh, he stands stiff and inert like a statue. He does not co-operate with me in any way. In fact, he seems to be oblivious of me. However, when I have half undone his zip, he steps out of the mackintosh and, still avoiding looking at me directly, retreats to a remote corner of the room, hastily grabbing a brown crayon from the table as he does so. In the corner, with this crayon, he immediately starts to draw large sweeping lines on the floor in front of his feet. I feel more and more cut off from him as he multiplies the encircling lines around him. At last, I take his plastic mackintosh from the chair and hold it in front of me. Although he seems so unaware of me, he is aware of this and runs forward to dive into the protection of the mackintosh like a snail returning to its shell. Stephen shows many of the features which are typical of autistic children. There is the avoidance of direct eye-to-eye
22 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S contact with me, although he has a fringe awareness of what I am doing. He does not co-operate but cuts himself off from me. He leaves his mother without a backward glance and shows none of the normal responses to people. Physically, he is well formed and his face would be attractive were it not so expressionless. This is the case apart from his eyes which sometimes look anguished and melancholy. He carries a hard object clutched tightly in the palm of his hand. I call autistic children 'shell-type' or encapsulated children. Their parents often say such things as 'I can't reach him'. 'My child seems to be in a shell all the time.' 'It's as though he can't see or hear us, or won't.' Such children are often thought to be deaf and some even try to walk through objects as if they were blind. However, on being tested, thkir perceptual apparatus is found to be intact; it is the processing of incoming information which is faulty. This could be due to brain lesions or to psychogenic damage. (Clinical work has given me clues as to the nature of the psychogenic damage, which will be discussed in various chapters throughout the book.) This psychogenic damage causes autistic children to turn their attention away from the things that the developing child usually attends to. This seems to be because they are protecting their bodies from 'not-me' threats which are felt to be overwhelmingly dangerous. When working with these children, it becomes clear that anything which is not familiar, and is 'notme', arouses intense terror. A grown man of twenty-five, who had been diagnosed by Leo Kanner at age four as suffering from early infantile autism, said that his outstanding memory of the autistic state from which he had emerged to some degree was of 'terror' (Piggott, 1979). In certain neurotic patients, both children and adults, the autistic features which have just been described and exemplified are overlaid by more normal functioning. The instability of this becomes apparent as work at depth proceeds. The origins of psychogenic autism Clinical work with psychogenic autistic children in whom no
THE NATURE OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
23
brain damage can be detected by the investigative methods at present available indicates that they developed, as infants, a massive formation of avoidance reactions in order to deal with a traumatic awareness of bodily separateness from the mother. This impinged upon their awareness before their psychic apparatus was ready to take the strain. You will notice that I am emphasizing the organizational state of the infant rather than the age at which the trauma occurred. This is because, in some infants, the impingement occurred following a too-close association with the mother which went on for too long, whereas in other infants it occurred in earliest infancy. Winnicott (1958) has described this latter situation as follows:
...certain aspects of the mouth.. .disappear from the infant's point of view along with the mother and the breast when there is separation at a date earlier than that at which [the child] had reached a stage of emotional development which could provide the equipment for dealing with loss. T h e same loss of the mother a few months later would be a loss of object without this added loss of part of the subject. I n terms of Stern's recent formulations concerning the development of self (1986), a traumatic awareness of separateness occurred in the state of being an 'emergent self', and before 'the core of the self' had developed. I n other words, it occurred before the suckling mother, and all that this implies, had become well established as an inner psychic experience and before a secure sense of 'going-on-being' had developed. Thus, these patients are beset by such elemental dreads as falling apart, of 'falling infinitely' (Winnicott's phrase), of falling with a damaging bump, of spilling away, of exploding away, of losing the thread of continuity which guarantees their existence. These terrors were experienced in a state which was preverbal, pre-image and preconceptual. They meant that the infant's emotional and cognitive development was either slowed down, or virtually stopped. In a hidden area of their personality, certain neurotic patients feel helplessly immobilized and at the point of death.
24 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S They are always trying to counteract this deathly arrest to their 'going-on-being' by overreaching themselves and by having unlimited expectations of themselves and of other people. Since they are usually well endowed they achieve a great deal, often of a cerebral nature, but it is at great personal cost. Two dreams of an intelligent man who coped efficiently with a professional job vividly portray such autistic handicaps. In the first dream, the dreamer was standing on the raised veranda of a house looking down on a large expanse of water through which a boat was very slowly making its way. The progress of the boat was so slow that the season changed to winter and the boat became frozen into the ice. The dreamer noticed the rotting timbers of the boat. He set out in a snowmobile to release the boat but he went so fast that he overshot it. This means that he went to the edge of the expanse of water, which was now reduced in size from being a sea to being a lake. Also, the boundaries of this lake were obliterated by the snow that had fallen, so that the differentiation of land from water was obscured. The dreamer went on trying to get to the boat by other means, but he was always foiled in his attempts by obstructions and confusions. In the second dream, the dreamer saw a man falling from an open window to the ground which was hard and damaging. Before the surgeon could finish attending to his injured legs, the falling process was reversed and, as sometimes happens in films, the man shot up again, to fall from the open window as before. But this time he had heavy casts on his legs which seemed to be made of concrete. These made him fall faster and more heavily than before, so that when he landed his injured legs were embedded in the ground and he was immobilized like the boat.
Discussion of autistic immobilization These two dreams poignantly illustrate the autistic encapsulation which develops to encase and immobilize the damaged part of the personality which is concerned with understanding.
T H E N A T U R E OF P S Y C H O G E N I C .4UTISM
25
Over-concretized thinking becomes the order of the day; the capacity to make the abstractions necessary for imaginative and reflective thought is restricted. The second dream also brings in the notion of the catastrophic fall which provoked these autistic reactions. Dreams are the only way neurotic patients can tell us about this catastrophe. It is fortunate that they can use the image-making capacities of the non-autistic part to do so. However, when they can talk, young autistic children can tell us about this tragedy more directly (see the material of John in Chapter 4). The Fall from the sublime state of blissful unity with the 'mother' who, in early infancy, is the sensation-dominated centre of the infant's universe, is part of everyone's experience. However, for some individuals, for a variety of reasons, different in each case, the disillusionment of 'coming down to earth' from this ecstatic experience has been such a hard and injurious experience that it has provoked impeding encapsulating reactions. It has been the pebble which provoked the landslide. The encapsulating reactions support and protect the damaged part and shut out the fear of being killed but, metaphorically speaking, their psychic functioning is frozen and immobilized. There is no flow. Also, in the first dream, the dreamer was observing these experiences as happening outside himself. He was in an elevated state looking down upon them. In the second dream they were happening to someone else. Such 'out-of-the-body' experiences counteract the threat of dying. In most cases, the threat is of worse than death. It is the threat of total annihilation. Encapsulating reactions mean that in an isolated area of the personality, attention has been deflected away from the objective world which presents such threats, in favour of a subjective, sensation-dominated world which is under their direct control. In certain neurotic patients (and, as Sydney Klein says, some of them are only 'mildly neurotic'), this has become an established way of life. These avoidance reactions, which were necessary at the time of the catastrophic Fall, but
26 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS which have outlived their usefulness, become autistic barriers to cognitive and affective functioning. T h e effort to keep going and to maintain an appearance of nornlality is very hard work. In an isolated area of their being, such patients feel that their life goes in ever-decreasing circles, as is shown by the sea which shrinks to being a lake. T h e Fall and its accompanin~entstend to be repeated in later life situations where ecstatic expectations have been built up to be dashed to the ground by contact with reality. Thus, they can occur in such situations as giving birth to a baby, in the midlife crisis, after the 'honeymoon period' of marriage, in psychotherapy or psychoanalysis ... Such people compensate for their unacknowledged sense of being irreparably damaged by perfectionist expectations of themselves and of other people. When these impossible expectations are disappointed, the infantile experience of damaging disillusionment is re-evoked. At the base of their being they live in an 'all or nothing' world. It is an uncompromising black-and-white world in which opposites cannot be tolerated because they seem to threaten to destroy each other. These fears lead to narrow-mindedness, to bigotry and fanaticism. They may be covered up by so-called 'progressive attitudes', often of an extreme ideological nature. T h e instability of these extreme attitudes sometimes becomes apparent when there is a sudden switch to those of a totally opposite kind. Primary psychic mishaps also lead to an obsessional need to feel in control of what happens. They may also lead to phobic reactions. A phobia is terror of a specific part of the outside world, usually of one that has been attractive to the individual, whereas autism is terror of almost the whole of the outside world, particularly of the mother. When phobic patients are analysed at depth, we are likely to find that bodily separateness from the mother has been experienced as an insufferable catastrophe. This,will be illustrated in various chapters in the book. This catastrophe is also at the heart of the manic defence. There are even some so-called borderline patients who are so
T H E N A T U R E OF PSYCHOGENIC A U T I S M
27
frozen with terror that they do not know what feelings are, a condition now termed 'alexythymia' (Grotstein, 1983). At this point, I want to link what I have been saying to the findings of other writers, so that readers with a different orientation from my own may find themselves in familiar territory.
Thefindings of other writers In the quotation cited earlier Winnicott described such catastrophic separation experiences. He sees them as resulting in what he calls 'psychotic depression': This type of depression is associated with a sense of collapse - of what Winnicott (1958) calls 'flop'. Edward Bibring, who has focused on the feelings of littleness and helplessness, calls it 'primal depression' (Bibring, 1951.) Spitz writes of 'anaclitic depression' (Spitz, 1960). Balint has written about such patients' 'basic fault' (Balint, M., 1968). Bion writes of a 'psychological catastrophe' (Bion, 1962b). Influenced by Bion and also, of course, by Freud, James Grotstein has described such patients' main 'deficit' as the lack of a 'filter' for incoming and outgoing stimuli (Grotstein, 1980). T h e behaviourists write of autistic children's incapacity 'to encode and process information'. They see this as arising from an 'innate cognitive defect'. Acquired cognitiz~eand emotional defects This chapter has indicated that cignitive defects (as also emotional defects, with which they are intertwined) are not always innate but can also be acquired. All the chapters in this book are concerned with how this can occur. T h e basic thesis is that the autistic state is a reaction to a traumatic awareness of separateness from the sensation-giving suckling mother. Autistic reactions divert attention away from this mother, who is spurned in favour of self-generated sensations which are always available and predictable, and so do not bring shocks. These bring about a state of diminished perception which leads to diminished thinking and feeling. T h e autistic child, and the autistic part of a neurotic patient, is numb and dumb. They
28 A U T I S T I C B A R R I E R S I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S seem to be in a state of suspended animation similar to that of the babies in the Mexican earthquake in 1985 who were found alive after many days of being buried by the rubble. T o use this as a metaphor: as therapists with such patients, we have to tunnel through the rubble to reach them. Having reached them we need to give them all the psychic resuscitation and healing that growing insight makes available to us. But this is a sensitive and delicate task, and we need to be well in touch with, and to understand the detail of, their autistic experiences. This book is an attempt to do this. When the psychic mishap of seemingly irretrievable loss first occurred, these autistic reactions were appropriate and necessary. But over the years they have become impediments to psychic functioning. T h e only way that the autism can be modified is by interaction with life and by a more spontaneous use of their own inbuilt capacities. Many of the chapters in this book are concerned with how we can help our patients to begin to do this. T h e emphasis in this type of psychotherapy is not on attempting to make up for what we infer may have been the deficiencies of their infancy. (After all we were not there and we cannot be sure about this.) T h e emphasis is on helping them to go through primitive processes of mourning, which will heal the wound of their too-early sense of loss, and relax the tensions associated with the trauma, so that they can begin to use the capacities with which they are usually well endowed. This is a very realistic and unsentimental procedure. I n some psychoanalytic formulations, the mother seems to be held to be totally responsible for her child's psychogenic autism. It is as if the child is viewed as a lump of clay to be moulded, instead of the bit of dynamite the human baby is. As well as distorting our views on aetiology, such an approach distorts our views on psychotherapy. T h e patients' natural, inbuilt propensities for growth, healing and creativity are not given sufficient weight in attempts to free them from their autistic impediments. Recognition of these biological 'givens' immediately promotes a more hopeful approach to therapeutic
29 endeavours. Instead of trying to compensate our patients for what we think they may have lacked, we try to free them, with stern but compassionate understanding, from their autistic practices so that they can begin to use the abilities they have, often in very good measure. T o do this, they need to feel that we believe in their capacity to do so. Thus, it is implicit throughout this book that the patients' own nature and their capacity for response, as well as external nurturing circumstances, will have played their part in psychogenetically induced autistic pathology, whether it is well nigh total as in the autistic child, or partial as in certain neurotic patients. T H E N A T U R E OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
The importance of early suckling experiences In order to understand such patients, it is necessary to be in touch with the nature of the infant's early suckling experiences. This is where relationships begin. Clinical work indicates that the sensation of nipple-in-mouth (or teat of the bottle experienced in terms of an inbuilt gestalt of the breast) is the focus for the development of the psyche. Associated with the mother's encircling arms, her shining eyes and the mutual concentration of their attention, it becomes the core of the self. It becomes associated with regulation, with bearing the suspense of waiting, with tolerating human limitations, with boundaries and with the sorting out of sensations. T h e way in which the 'breast' is given and the way in which it is taken leaves a mark for good or ill on the developing psyche. This will be affected by the child's responses and by the quality of the mother's relationship to the infant's father, and by the circumstances of the parents' own infancy. In normal development, the heightened degree of responsiveness and the especial quality of attention of both the suckling mother and her infant partake of the sublime, and even of the 'mystical'. It is a physically based psychic experience. This empathic communion is the earliest form of communication. It fosters the growth of the psyche. Patients who are prone to autistic ways of behaving have had this early state
30 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS of communion traumatically disturbed. This means that, instead of a psychic core which holds them together, they have an unmourned sense of loss - a 'black hole with a nasty prick', as John, who is discussed in Chapter 4, so graphically described it.
Remedying the 'black hole' This 'black hole' cannot be filled by 'autistic objects' nor glossed over by 'autistic shapes'. (Autistic objects and autistic shapes will be discussed in later chapters.) It can only be healed by cooperative activities with people and creative activities with the outside world. These stimulate the biological 'givens' for psychic growth and healing. States of autism prevent these 'givens' from being recognized, because such patients are afraid of anything which cannot be brought under their tyrannical control. These 'givens' are unseen and mysterious. When they come into play, they are much more powerful for influencing the way in which we live our lives than are our puny efforts at controlling what happens to us. They work within us without our doing anything about it. T h e effectiveness of psychotherapy depends upon their release. We never really know how it happens. But we find that as patients in an autistic state gradually work over their experience of separateness, and begin to relate to human beings who are experienced as separate and different from themselves, they become able to let unseen, intangible forces which are beyond their control begin to work within them. Hope and trust start to develop. This means that there is the basis for reality-based beliefs about themselves and about the outside world. I n short, inbuilt impulsions come into play which have previously been blocked.
ilfod$ying the autism But before this can be achieved the autistic blockage has to be modified. In an autistic state, patients are not in touch with their own humanity, nor that of other people. In this state they cannot make the abstractions needed for imagination and
T H E NATURE OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
31
empathy. They are stuck in a sensation-dominated, overconcretized mode of functioning. This is a great stumblingblock to psychoanalytic work. In such states, these patients are suffering from a miscarriage of motivation. They have turned away from commonly agreed reality. Instead of attending to the life-enhancing possibilities that are available to them, both within themselves and in the outside world, their attention has become fixated upon autochthonous (self-generated) sensation objects and shapes. These patients are creative and resourceful, but these gifts have gone in a sterile direction because they have generated artefacts which were unshared and unshareable. Our task is to help them to turn from these automatic, idiosyncratic ways of behaving and to begin to tolerate the sadness and the frustrations, and to enjoy the delights of deep, interactive relationships with other people. These patients cannot be bullied or coaxed out of their simplistic, isolating modes of behaviour. These will only be modified as their need for them is understood, and they experience being held in a warm, firm, sane, caring, disciplined and disciplining relationship which gets in touch with the part of them that has been left to go its own whimsical and eccentric way. As they experience this, the psychic mishaps of their infancy begin to be healed. This occurs through the medium of the infantile transference, in which they repeat the situation of tragic disillusionment. We need to be aware of this form of transference and to have some understanding of it, if we are to get in touch with autistic states and to modify them. Thus, neurotic patients can be relieved of their fear of a breakdown which has already occurred (see Winnicott, 1974). T h e healing and disciplining type of psychotherapy needed by patients with such an injured psyche will be discussed in Chapter 16. It has seemed to me that in enlightening us about the idiosyncratic, restricted world in which they live, autistic children enable us to get in touch in a realistic and meaningful way with neurotic patients who have an immobilized, frozen part of their personality. They demonstrate for us the autistic
32 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS operation of pre-image, preverbal, preconceptual ways of behaving. They show us that this behaviour has inhibited their use of their capacities and caused them to feel excessively insecure and underconfident.
CHAPTER TWO
The growth of understanding : a personal statement Nobody can tell you how you are to live your life, Or what you are to think, Or what language you are to speak, Therefore, it is absolutely essential that the individual analyst should forge for himself the language which he knows, Which he knows how to use, and the value of which he knows.
W.R.Bion, 'Evidence'
his chapter is a much revised version of a paper which was written for the French psychoanalytic journal Patio (1984) 3 :109-21. Originally, the paper was for an issue which was to be devoted to innovations in psychoanalysis. The editor asked me for an interview-article to describe the growth of my thinking with regard to the psychoanalytic treatment of psychogenic autistic children. Thus, the paper was the story of how I came to be involved with these children and was driven to try to understand them. Dr Peter Medawar, the well-known British research scientist, whose sayings I shall quote from time to time in this chapter, has rightly stressed the part that luck and opportunity play in making new discoveries, however small these may be (Medawar, 1979). This chapter will be an account of the many privileges I have had which encouraged me to embark on the difficult task of trying to get in touch with these seemingly
34 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
inaccessible children. Dr Medawar quotes Fontanelle, who said, 'Ces hasards ne sont que pour ceux quijoient bien!' ('These strokes of good fortune are only for those who play well.') But to 'play well' we have to remember the words of Pasteur, who said, 'Fortune favours the prepared mind.' Thus, this contribution must acknowledge the many people who have shed light upon my path and helped to prepare my mind for the daunting task of entering the mind of an autistic child in such a way that changes in his view of the world could be initiated. Preparation for the task Firstly, I have been helped and supported by being married to a physical scientist who, in his own speciality, has been an innovator. (In his war work on automatic control, he pioneered the early formulations for what is now called systems theory or cybernetics.) My personal analysis with Dr W.R. Bion also brought me into contact with an original mind. In addition, in my training as a child psychotherapist at the Tavistock Clinic in London, I had the great good fortune to have as my teachers Dr Esther Bick and Dr John Bowlby, both of whom, from their different points of view, impressed upon their students the value of detailed observations and the importance of specific rather than general formulations. Supervision from Dr Herbert Rosenfeld and D r Donald Meltzer was also a very important preparation. Having finished my training at the Tavistock Clinic, I was fortunate in that I accompanied my husband to the United States for a year in 1954 and, on Dr Bowlby's advice, went to work at the Putnam Children's Center in Boston, Massachusetts. At that time this was a research and treatment centre for young 'atypical' children (as they called them), amongst whom were a number of autistic children whose disturbance seemed to be mainly psychogenic rather than organic in origin. Here, as well as working as a psychotherapist, I went to look after some of the autistic children in their own homes. I was very moved by the tragedy to the parents of these
T H E GROWTH O F UNDERSTANDING
35
unresponsive children, and felt very strongly that I wanted to see if something could be done so that they became more accessible. I was again fortunate when I returned to England in that Dr Mildred Creak, who was very knowledgeable about childhood psychosis and also a superb diagnostician in this field, sent me several autistic children as private patients. Eventually I went to work with her at Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital in London. Of course, all these possibilities would have passed me by, had it not been that my own temperament and pathology made me interested in shy, inhibited children. Also, I had always had a tendency to study the basic aspects of a subject, one of my early pieces of work being a study of 'Plant movements and tropisms'. Thus, the privileges, the good fortune, the prepared mind, the motivation and the opportunities were all there. What was needed now was a capacity for patience and hard work. I had always been persevering and this stood me in good stead. So, after the first twenty years of working with psychogenic autistic children, and as a result of a profound disturbance in my own emotional life from which I learned a great deal about the roots of phobic inhibition, I was driven to write my first book, Autism a n d Childhood Psychosis. This was written as the result of great emotional pressure from within myself. The second, Autistic States in Children, written ten years later, was a less emotionally-charged book and was the result of lectures I had given, on yearly visits over a period of five years, in Rome University's Institute of Childhood Neuropsychiatry. Here there is a special unit for the psychoanalytic treatment of both autistic and schizophrenic-type children, under the unflagging and humane care of Professor Adriano Giannotti, with Professor Giovanni Bollea in overall charge of the Institute. In the early days of the unit the two senior psychotherapists, Dr Guilianna De Astis and Eleonora Ft D'Ostiani, flew over to England separately each month, over a period of two years, to discuss every single child they had in treatment. Thus I could see psychotherapeutic work being carried on in a unit which
36 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S had far more resources than I had had in private practice; the parental relationship and the mother-child couple, in particular, could be studied much more fully than I had been able to do. I have found the scientific rigour and orderliness of the Kleinian psychoanalytic technique to be very suitable for the treatment of autistic children. However, since Melanie Klein's findings were drawn from schizophrenic-type chilren, it was inevitable that work with autistic children would generate new insights. The only autistic child seen by Mrs Klein was the boy called Dick whom she describes in her paper, 'The importance of symbol formation in the development of the ego' (see next chapter). Mrs Klein was writing in 1930, fourteen years prior to Kanner's differential diagnosis of early infantile autism. Although she anticipated many of Kanner's findings, she was naturally perplexed about the diagnosis of Dick's condition. Reluctantly and after much uncertainty, she finally interpreted Dick's psychopathology in terms of the schizophrenic-type children she had previously studied. Melanie Klein has given us a great legacy, but it does both her work, and the cause of scientific enquiry, a grave disservice if we blindly apply her insights to autistic states for which they are not appropriate, at least in the early stages of treatment. I had to learn this after many heart-searching9 as to whether I was being treacherous to someone to whom I owed so much. But John, the four-year-old autistic boy whom I have already mentioned, taught me about the 'black hole with the nasty prick' (Tustin, 1972) which I also became aware of in myself. This made me realize that there were even earlier states than those described so courageously by Melanie Klein. I then found that Michael Balint (1968), Winnicott (1958) and Mahler (1961) had described the phenomenon of the 'black hole', though in other terms: Balint's 'basic fault', Winnicott's 'psychotic depression', Mahler's 'loss and restoration of the symbiotic love object'. Following Mahlerl and also James Anthony whose classic
T H E GROWTH OF UNDERSTANDING
37
paper on autism broke new ground (Anthony, 1958), 1began to use the term 'autistic' for the earliest state of normal infantile development, as well as for pathological states. T o use the term 'autism' in this way was appropriate at the time when Mahler and Anthony were writing, but since then the word 'autism', as first used by Bleuler in 1913 in terms of its etymology, has become so contaminated with pathological associations that it can no longer be usefully used for normal states. For example, if we use the adjective 'autistic' for early infantile states, it gives the impression that such states are being viewed as inactive and passive, instead of the aware, questing states they obviously are. Thus I have come to use the term 'auto-sensuous' for the earliest states of normal infancy, and autism for pathological ones. This will be discussed more fully later. At this point, let me discuss the understandings I have found to be mutative in psychotherapy with autistic states. Mutative understandings My particular contribution to understanding psychogenic autistic children has been to realize the tactile, sensationdominated nature of their world, and to highlight the way in which what I have called 'autistic objects' and 'autistic shapes' (described later in this book) have impeded such children's cognitive and emotional functioning, as also their sense of identity and relationships with people. These findings from work with autistic children have made very meaningful to me certain passages of Dr Peter Medawar's Advice to a Young Scientist, where scientific methods and discoveries are discussed. Even though Medawar is mainly writing about the biological sciences, what he says has much relevance to psychological investigations. For example, in writing about Thomas Kuhn's two books, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions and Essential Tension, Medawar says : 'The "essential tensionJ' to which Kuhn refers in the title of his latest book is between our inheritance of doctrine and dogma as they affect science and the occasional upheavals
38 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS that inaugurate a new "paradigm" ...' (p.92). Medawar sees scientific exploration as a dialogue 'between two voices, the one imaginative and the other critical, between conjecture and refutation, as Popper has it' (p.85). (In my case, my husband has often supplied the 'critical voice'!) Later, Medawar says: '. scientific research, like other forms of exploration is, after all, a cybernetic - a steering process, a means by which we find our way about, and try to make sense of a bewildering and complex world' (p.86). In the case of autistic children we have to try to 'make sense' of a 'bewildering' elemental 'world', haunted by primeval forces. In studying this world we can again draw guidance from Dr Medawar when he says: 'Heroic feats of intellection are seldom needed. "The scientific method", as it is sometimes called, is a potentiation of common sense' (p.86). The need for common sense was never more urgent than in studying the world of the psychogenic autistic child. We do not need esoteric theories, but we do need to train ourselves not to disregard the obvious. I also think that at the beginning of our work we should not confuse ourselves with tpo much reading of what other people have said. Some papers seem to be like a Tower of Babel amongst which the writer's own voice is lost. Fortunately, the Tavistock child psychotherapy training was a somewhat cloistered affair in which we digested Freud and Klein, with Dr Bowlby introducing us to ethology and researches in child development (Dr Bowlby's critical voice keeping the balance alongside Mrs Bick's imaginative one). The Kleinian psychotherapeutic technique, with its simplicity and its emphasis on the dynamic transforming influence of the infantile transference, is a very good instrument for studying what is going on in the psyche of the child. It is as if we put the child's psyche under our mental and empathic microscope to study it in detail. So long as we have not developed 'tunnel vision', we do not see only Kleinian phenomena. From this secure base of sound training in observation and
..
THE GROWTH OF UNDERSTANDING
39
psychotherapeutic technique, the work with autistic children gradually led me to the writings of other psychoanalytic workers who were not members of the Kleinian school in which I had been trained. This happened in the following way. When I wrote my first paper on autism in 1966, in which I described John's revelations about the 'black hole', it was an eye-opener to me when I was told by a colleague that Winnicott, in a paper entitled 'The mentally ill in your case load', as long ago as 1958, had mentioned in passing this very early type of depression which occurs when the loss of the mother is experienced as the loss of part of the body (Winnicott, 1958). I also learned that Margaret Mahler had written a paper about this with reference to childhood autism (Mahler, 1961). Similarly, after I had finished my first paper on autistic shapes, and after it had been accepted for publication, I heard a paper given by Dr Piera Aulangier of Paris who, from her long experience with schizophrenic adult patients, described what she called 'tactile hallucinations' (Aulangier, 1985). She distinguished these from the usual type of schizophrenic hallucinations. From her description of them they sounded very like the tactile autistic shapes I had learned about from the autistic children; indeed in a paper published in the International Review of Psycho-Analysis in 1984, I had said that these autistic shapes seemed to be a kind of 'tactile hallucination' (see Chapter 7). I also found that Michael Fordham (1976) had coined the term 'self-object', and that Winnicott had used the term 'subjective object' (Winnicott, 1958), for similar phenomena. (However, although the self-object and the subjective object have certain features in common with autistic objects, I have found it necessary to distinguish between normal and pathological manifestations. Normal auto-sensuous objects are sucked and are such things as the finger, the fist, the knobs on the cot, a piece of shawl, etc. They are associated with a developing sense of self. Autistic objects are pathological. They are not sucked but are hard objects which are clutched. They
40 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
are associated with states in which there is no sense of being a self .) I found these separate confirmations from various sources unconnected with each other, and with a different orientation from my own, very reassuring, in that they indicated that my findings were not idiosyncratic to me alone. You will remember that Spitz has said that such confirmation is the only validation we can have in psychoanalytic investigations. Schizophrenictype children (or 'confusional entangled' children, as I call them) are very open and tell us about their strange misconceptions quite clearly. The encapsulated autistic children are very different in that they are closed up and secretive. It is difficult to feel sure about what one has inferred, so confirmation of one's insights is very necessary. The fact that I was not the first in the field was outweighed by the relief that other workers had seen what I had seen, though in different contexts. As Medawar so picturesquely exprdsses it, the growth of scientific ideas 'is not at all like cooks elbowing each other from the pot of broth'. Usually, in developing new understandings, unbeknown to ourselves, we are developing ideas which are 'in the air' and waiting to be developed further; to continue with Medawar's image, 'the broth' is waiting to be stirred by experienced cooks (1979, p. 33). My job has been that of a synthesizer and harmonizer. I have been able to relate the phenomenon of the 'black hole' to autistic objects and to autistic shapes, as part of the pathological network which we call psychogenic autism. These phenomena have been integrated into a scheme of understanding which helps us to enter the encapsulated states of autistic children, and the capsule of autism of neurotic patients, in a tactful, sensitive, mutative way so that more normal psychological functioning can be facilitated. As well as learning from my patients I have, of course, learned a great deal from the psychotherapists and psychoanalysts who have discussed their clinical work with me. I
T H E GROWTH OF UNDERSTANDING
41
would like to mention all these people by name, but this is not possible. As an illustration of the enlargement of my understanding from such a source, I will quote a recently published paper by Mrs Sheila Spensley, a psychoanalytic psychotherapist who discusses her work with me from time to time. The paper was called 'Mentally ill or mentally handicapped? A longitudinal study of a severe learning disorder' (1985b). In this paper Mrs Spensley recounts the sad story of A, a twenty-seven-year-old young woman who, as the result of a misdiagnosis when she was seven years of age, had been constantly moved back and forth from psychiatric hospital to mental subnormality units, none of which had been appropriate or helpful. Finally, by great good fortune, she was seen by Mrs Spensley, who had treated psychogenic autistic children. T o everyone's surprise and dubious incredulity, Mrs Spensley suggested individual psychotherapy for A. In the summary of her paper Mrs Spensley writes of this patient as follows: 'Psychotherapy has disclosed a significant component of autism in the personality which is resorted to regularly and which seems to drag the patient into a passive acceptance of half-life which she tries not to mind.' Mrs Spensley also says: In the course of some eighteen months of psychoanalytic psychotherapy, this young woman of twenty-seven, once deemed brain-damaged at the age of seven years, has shown herself capable of sustaining once-weekly psychotherapy. Against all expectations she has taken responsibility for her own attendance, travelling by public transport alone to her sessions. She has also taken initiatives in relation to finding work for herself.
I should also add that she has been able to live amicably at home with her parents, who had previously found her impossible. Mrs Spensley's report of this patient has made me realize the value of the understandings derived from clinical work with
42 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S psychogenic autism, in making our diagnoses more precise, so that fewer patients waste their time in inappropriate placements and in receiving inappropriate treatments. I have also been greatly helped by the constructive criticism of some of my British colleagues. They have helped me to see where I had not made myself clear in Autistic States in Children, and also where I needed to modify certain of my suggestions about early infantile development. Again, as Medawar so well expresses it, 'A senior scientist is much more flattered, by finding that his views are the subject of serious criticism than by sycophantic and sometimes obviously sim.ulated respect' (p. 55). (In this connection I want to thank Anne Alvarez who, in the midst of a busy programme, found time to enter into a discussion with me by means of an interchange of letters.) Such constructive criticism, and further evidence, have meant that the thinking embodied in my two books on autism has been in a constant state of revision. As Medawar says: 'As for revolutions, they are constantly in progress: a scientist does not hold exactly the same opinions about his research from one day to the next, for reading, reflection and discussions with colleagues cause a change of emphasis here and there and possibly even a radical appraisal of his way of thinking' (p. 93).
Clanjkation and revision of previous views Let me now outline some of the clarifications and revisions of my views which have occurred since writing Autistic States in Children. As mentioned earlier in this chapter, one of these revisions has been to use the term auto-sensuous for normal early infantile developments, and to reserve the term autistic for pathological ones. Making this distinction has thrown light for me on the current psychoanalytic controversies concerning awareness of bodily separateness in early infancy. I should like to discuss this. The work of observers such as Trevarthen (1979), Tom Bower (1977) and Brazelton (1969) implies that when early
T H E GROWTH OF UNDERSTANDlNG
43
differentiations are proceeding normally, there are likely to be flickering moments of awareness of bodily separateness from the mother even from the very beginning of life. Also, arising from their work with autistic children, De Astis and Giannotti have suggested that, in normal development, the caesura of birth is healed by responsive interactions between mother and baby (De Astis and Giannotti, 1980). They have shown - and my own work confirms this that in autistic children this healing has not occurred. In my experience, every subsequent awareness of bodily separateness from the mother reactivates the unhealed primary wound of bodily separateness. Psychotherapy heals this 'wound', which in autistic children is often experienced as a 'hole' because, for them, bodily separateness from the mother has been experienced as a traumatic breaking away from an inanimate 'thing', rather than as a gradual process of differentiation from an alive human being. One reason for this traumatic breaking away is that the mother of an autistic child has often been depressed and unresponsive in the child's early infancy. She may have experienced the child in her womb as a comfort for her sense of inner loneliness. In such a situation, when the infant is born, the mother feels that she has lost a reassuring part of her body. The baby also seems prone to this elemental 'black hole' type of depression. (This will be discussed more fully in Chapter 4, and should become clearer to any reader who may be having difficulties in understanding it.) In this state, the need for a continuous tangible bodily presence is very intense, as also the disappointment that this is not possible. I would suggest that in normal early infantile development, there is an awareness of separateness which is made bearable by auto-sensuous activities such as sucking and bodily interactions with other people, particularly with the mother. But, in pathological autistic development, as, the result of the lack of responsive interactions, any awareness of bodily separateness, however slight, has been unbearable. It has provoked an agony of consciousness. This painful awareness has been muted, and
-
44
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
restricted by the use of autistic objects and autistic shapes. These autistic manipulations and stereotypes replace the normal responsive interactions between mother and baby, and prevent normal differentiations and integrations from taking place. It has seemed to me that merging with the mother, who is experienced as an inanimate part of the subject's own body, is apathological reaction which is both sought and feared. Further thought on work with psychogenic autistic children has also enabled me to make another clarification. At least to my own satisfaction, I have become able to distinguish more clearly between the 'ego' and the 'self'. Early ego activities would seem to arise, in the first place, from the neuromental system. At first, the newborn infant who is lacking in experience of the outside world can only react in terms of inbuilt neuromental propensities which become expressed through auto-sensuous activities. The early ego is an auto-sensuous ego. This view is consonant with Freud's statement that 'the ego is first and foremost a body ego' (Freud, 1923, p.26). In normal development, increasing experience of the outside world facilitates the maturation and sophistication of this elemental ego. But the traumatized autistic child shuts out experience of the outside world. Thus, his ego development is morbidly fixated at an uncouth, crude bodily level of precocious, overconcretized and hypertrophied reactions. This leads to the sense of having a swollen empty shell fabricated from the subject's own bodily activities. This is a barrier to intercourse with the outside world. Patients in encapsulated autistic states also lack a sense of self and of individual identity. This is because the sense of self and of individual identity is dependent upon relationships with other people. Autistic children are averted from such relationships, and so they have no sense of self. Thus, I have come to realize that I was incorrect in attributing to psychogenic autistic children a 'false self' as described by Winnicott (1960). I have also come to realize that states of autism are not narcissistic. This is because a sense of self is
T H E GROWTH O F UNDERSTANDING
45
obviously a prerequisite for the development of narcissism. Schizophrenic-type patients and neglected children have developed relationships with people, albeit these are fragile and disturbed. Thus they can be said to have a 'false self' and to be narcissistic. The psychogenic autistic child, and neurotic patients in an autistic state, avoid human relationships. Thus they are empty of a sense of self, and cannot be said to have a 'false self' or to be narcissistic. (As early as 1963 Enid Balint described such an empty state in a paper called 'On being empty of oneself'.) For these reasons I agree with Dr Sydney Klein who, in describing neurotic patients who manifested autistic phenomena, writes about them in the following way:
.
There is an obvious parallel with what Winnicott.. has called 'the false self', and which Rosenfeld (1978) has termed 'psychotic islands' in the personality, but I do not think these terms quite do justice to what may be described as an almost impenetrable cystic encapsulation. ..which cuts the patient off from both the rest of his personality and the analyst. (Klein, S., 1980)
I suggest that the 'impenetrable cystic encapsulation' is the expression of a hypertrophied, crude body 'ego' which had been startled into precocious development along an aberrant path by the impingement of unbuffered awareness of bodily separateness from the mother. This puffed-up ego is not a 'true' ego formed by bearable contact with the outside world, It is both a deceit and a conceit. Lacking object relations, and thus being empty of a sense of self, the psychogenic autistic patient can best be described as having an ego which is an 'empty fake' or a 'hollow sham'. He does not have a 'self' to be 'false'. Another revision I have made in my thinking is that I have come to realize that psychogenic autism is a defence against the confusion and entanglement of pyschosis, rather than psychosis itself. It seems more accurate to see it as a gross arrest of mental and emotional development. When the autism is lifted, a
46 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS vulnerable, clinging, confused, helpless child is revealed who may become psychotic unless we realize his need for safety and protection, and can provide it for him by our understanding. The autism has been a protection for this hapless creature. It is a serious responsibility to deprive such patients of their autistic protections. We need to be able to help them to develop something better to replace them. The more accurately we understand the& patients, the greater will be the possibility that they will develop 'basic trust in other people, and confidence in themselves. These are very necessary developments, since the autistic encapsulation means that they have been cut off from the outside world, and so are liable to a psychotic breakdown. Michael Faraday, that great pioneer in the field of electrical phenomena, defined innovation as 'finding the "go" of things'. With the help of the children, their concerned parents, and friendly professional colleagues, I have come to understand a little of the 'go' of autistic development. There is much that remains to be understood. But the insights outlined in this paper, and those of other psychodynamic workers, have enabled us to enter the psychogenic autistic children's world in a therapeutic way so that they could begin to respond to other people and become aware of the outside world. Thus, they are glad to be 'born', both physically and psychologically. Let me end by a quotation from Dr Medawar, whose sayings have illuminated this paper. He writes: 'Those with enough hopefulness in their make-up willingly go along with the belief that ... the pursuit [of understanding] is truly via lucis, the way of light' (p. 106). An alternative title to this paper could have been 'The dawning of enlightenment'. It has been a slow dawn, but the efforts of dedicated workers, some of whom are mentioned in the references, are ensuring that this crepuscular light will be increased, so that more patients who are entrapped by autistic reactions can be helped to normal functioning. But it requires professional workers who do not impose theoretical con-
T H E GROWTH OF U N D E R S T A N D I N G
47
structions, evolved for other psychopathologies, upon such patients' behaviour. We need to realize that these patients are different from any other patients that we see, because they have not developed relationships. .Also, in the growth of understanding, we are always trying to evolve language which is a closer fit to the phenomena we are observing. I hope that this will take place as the book proceeds.
CHAPTER THREE
Thoughts on psychogenic autism with special reference to a paper by Melanie Klein 'There was, on his side, no affective tie to people. He behaved as if people as such did not matter or even exist. It made no difference whether one spoke to him in a friendly or harsh way. He never looked at people's faces. When he had any dealings with persons at all, he treated them or rather parts of them, as if they were objects.' Paul, aged five years, described in Leo Kanner's original paper on autistic disturbances of affective contact (1943, p. 217)
his revised paper was originally published in the Journal of Child Psychotherapy (1983) 9 :119-3 1, and discussed a paper by Meianie Klein entitled 'The importance of symbol formation in the development of the ego' (1930a). She described her analysis of a four-year-old boy whom she called Dick, and whom we would now recognize to be autistic. I sought to discuss Mrs Klein's paper from the point of view of autistic pathology.
T
Mrs Klein's paper When Mrs Klein wrote her paper in 1930, Leo Kanner's classic paper differentiating the syndrome he called 'early infantile autism' from mental deficiency had not been written. We had to wait until 1943 for his findings to be available to us. It is a mark of Melanie Klein's originality and perspicacity that in her paper she anticipated many of Kanner's findings. For example, of
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM AND MELANIE KLEIN
49
Dick's case she wrote: 'many cases of this sort are classified as ... mental deficiency' (1930a, p.230). Also, compare Mrs Klein's description of Dick with the extract from Leo Kanner's description of Paul which headed this chapter. Mrs Klein wrote : This child, Dick, was largely devoid of affects, and he was indifferent to the presence or absence of his mother or nurse. From the beginning he had only rarely displayed anxiety, and that in an abnormally small degree .. He had almost no interests, did not play, and had no contact with his environment. For the most part he simply strung sounds together in a meaningless way, and constantly repeated certain noises. When he did speak he generally used his meagre vocabulary incorrectly. But it was not only that he was unable to make himself intelligible; he had no wish to do so. More than that, Dick's mother could at times clearly sense in the boy a strong negative attitude which expressed itself in the fact that he often did the very opposite of what was expected of him .... When he was hurt, he displayed very considerable insensitivity to pain, and felt nothing of the desire, so universal with little children, to be comforted and petted ... he also ran round me, just as if I were a piece of furniture ... (1930a, pp.221,222)
.
As an infant, Dick had had great difficulty in sueking. Klein describes how his mother tried to breastfeed him, but he would not suck and nearly died of starvation (p.222). I have found early difficulties in sucking to be characteristic of all the autistic children I have seen, and also of those cases I have supervised. Dick's weaning difficulties were also characteristic of autistic children. Klein reports: 'When the time came for him to have more solid food, he refused to bite it up and absolutely rejected everything that was not the consistency of pap' (p.223). Time and again, the parents of an autistic child have told me such things as 'he will only eat soft food and rejects hard lumps' or that 'he will only accept semi-liquid food'. Thus, if Dick were
50 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS seen now he would certainly be diagnosed as autistic, his autism being seen to be akin to that described by Kanner. This Kanner-type autism needs to be distinguished from the autism which arises from disorderly rearing practices, or from detectable brain damage, or from hospitalization or surgical intervention in early infancy, or other interruptions to early ongoing infantile development. Since he had made some developments before coming to see Mrs Klein, Dick would be likely to be assessed as having a hopeful prognosis. For example, he had become toilet-trained and he used a few words appropriately. H e also responded very quickly to Mrs Klein's unique ability to be in therapeutic touch with a withdrawn and frightened child, even though this fear was not shown openly. Mrs Klein herself writes: 'The fact ... that analysis made it possible to establish contact with Dick's mind and brought about some advance in so comparatively short a time suggests the possibility that there had already been some latent development as well as the slight development outwardly manifest' (p.231). She goes on to say: 'But, even if we suppose this, the total development was so abnormally meagre that the hypothesis of a regression from a stage already successfully reached will hardly meet the case' (p.231). She says this because she was puzzled about the diagnosis of Dick's condition, Leo Kanner's paper not being available to her. She realized that Dick was different from the schizophrenic children she had analysed. She writes: 'Against the diagnosis of dementia praecox is the fact that the essential feature of Dick's case was an inhibition in development and not a regression' (p.230, my italics). However, she finally decided that Dick's illness was a variant of schizophrenia, although she obviously felt uneasy about this diagnosis, because later in the paper she wrote about Dick's illness as follows: 'It is true that it differs from the typical schizophrenia of childhood in that in him the.trouble was an inhibition in development, whereas in most such cases there is a regression after a certain stage of development has been
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM A N D MELANIE KLEIN
51
successfully reached (p.231). This coincides with my own experience. On the basis of an entangled relationship with his mother, the schizophrenic child has made tenuous psychological development from which he regresses when faced by difficulties which are too much for him. T h e autistic child appears to be cut off from the mother, and manifests an almost complete arrest of emotional and cognitive development at an early stage. T o use Winnicott's terms, the autistic child is 'unintegrated', whereas the schizophrenic child is 'disintegrated'. Making this distinction between childhood autism and childhood schizophrenia affects our views on early infantile development, and the processes to be inferred there. It also affects our views on the aetiology of autistic illness, and the interpretations that we give in the early stages of the analysis. However, in these early stages, the therapeutic ambience of the analyst's own personality, and the disciplined orderliness of the therapeutic setting are as important as what is said to the child. For example, it is important that the child is not allowed to wander from room to room with the therapist following in his wake, as is the case in some forms of psychotherapy. Those of us who use Melanie Klein's technique of child analysis have come to value highly the procedure she bequeathed to us. Its sensible orderliness with, for example, each child having his own drawer or box of toys seems to be a safe hammock in which child and analyst swing. This containment is important for all children, but particularly so for the unintegrated autistic child. Klein, fifty years ago, was ahead of her time in realizing that not only adults but also children could be psychotic, and in realizing the need for a more precise differential diagnosis, from a psychoanalytic point of view, between the various types of childhood psychosis. She writes:
I think that one of the foremost tasks of analysis is the discovery and cure of psychoses in childhood. T h e theoretical knowledge thus acquired would doubtless be a valuable contribution to our understanding of the structure
52
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PAI'IENTS
of the psychoses and would also help us to reach a more accurate differential diagnosis between the various diseases. (p.231) Orthodox psychiatric opinion has now accepted that children can be psychotic, but Mrs Klein is still ahead of orthodox opinion today in thinking that some psychotic children can respond to psychoanalytic therapy. This hopeful view has been confirmed by individual child analysts and child psychotherapists. It has obtained indubitable confirmation from workers in the Institute of Childhood Neuropsychiatry of Rome University, who have made a statistical analysis of the results of their psychoanalytic work with thirty-nine psychotic children treated in the Institute's special unit for such children. Their results are striking and rewarding. Later, Klein again anticipates Kanner when she says of Dick's case :
I have reason to think that
... it is not an isolated one, for
recently, I have become acquainted with two analogous cases in children of about Dick's age. One is therefore inclined to conjecture that, if we observed with a more penetrating eye, more cases of this kind would come to our knowledge. (p.231) What a pity Mrs Klein's 'penetrating eye' did not have the opportunity to become focused upon more autistic children. Her theories might have been extended, and certain unfortunate controversies avoided. As it was, she finally interpreted Dick's clinical material in terms of the theories she had formed from her work with other psychopathologies. Mrs Klein states this quite frankly when she says:
I would emphasize the fact that in Dick's case I have modified my usual technique. In general, I do not interpret the material until it has found expression in various representations. I n this case, however, where the capacity to represent it was almost entirely lacking, I found myself
PSYCHOGENIC A U T I S M A N D MELANIE KLEIN
53
obliged to make my interpretations on the basis of my general knowledge, the representations in Dick's material being relatively vague. (p .228) Thus her interpretations in the early stages of Dick's analysis would seem to be more applicable to schizophrenic children than to autistic ones. I have analysed ten autistic children, and have supervised several psychoanalytic workers with other such children, as well as observing autistic children for long periods of time, some of these being in their own homes. I have also analysed two schizophrenic children and have supervised other psychoanalytic workers with children of this type. This work has made it very clear to me that, on deep investigation, the psychopathology of an autistic child is very different from that of a schizophrenic one. Thus it has seemed to be important to study childhood autism in its own right, and not to confuse it with childhood schizophrenia, as is often the case. Let me outline what I have found to be some of the essential differences between a young autistic child and a young schizophrenic one. (I use the terms 'confusional' or 'entangled' rather than schizophrenic, since these terms describe the predominating features of their pathology.)
Dr3fferencesbetween young autistic and schizophrenic children The schizophrenic child is in a confused entanglement with his mother. Mahler refers to this as 'pathological symbiosis'. By this means, the child makes some degree of insecure psychological development because, in spite of the interpenetration of mother and child, he has a confused awareness of their bodily separateness from each other. Thus the processes of projective identification as described by Klein are very active and obvious. Such a child is aware of insides and outsides and of objects which, in Klein's terms, he 'phantasies9* are inside *'Phantasy1refers to unconscious processes, 'fantasy' to conscious ones (see Isaacs, 1952).
54
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
the mother's body. He has a capacity for relationships of a bizarre kind. He is 'object-seeking', and has usually developed speech, although this may be slurred and the sentences may be incomplete or have words missed out. Such a child will meeet the eyes of other people, but his own eyes may be blurred and unfocused. T h e autistic child's functioning is very different. His is a sensation-dominated world in which he seeks set~sntiorlsrather than objects as such. He is not responsive to people as people, but mostly in terms of the sensations they engender. His is a primal state of seeking correspondences, in sensation terms, from the outside world which coincide with his inbuilt patterns. If he becomes aware of lack of fit to his inbuilt pattern-seeking propensities, he blocks it out so that he feels continuous with the outside world and not separate from it. He lives in a world of forms and shapes and patterns. If such a child responds to psychological tests at all, it is to those to do with shapes. He seems to be in a state of imitative 'identicality' with the world around him, such as we see in a normal young baby who will put out his tongue in response to his mother doing the same. I n the autistic child, this state has become pathological and he is stuck there. In terms of his imitative fusion with objects in the outside world, he relates to them in terms of the contours of his own bodily parts. Thus, cupboards and chests of drawers are 'equated' (to use Hanna Segal's term) with stomachs; openings in things are equated with mouths. I have much evidence to show that pencil sharpeners are often felt by the child to be equated with his cruel biting mouth. For example, he will put part of a toy into the 'mouth' of a pencil sharpener, whilst at the same time making circular biting movements with his mouth. T h u s when Dick saw some pencil shavings, he said, 'Poor Mrs Klein.' T o him, they were a cut-up Mrs Klein. He was sorry for this 'Mrs Klein' whom he perceived solely in terms of his own activities, and not as a person in her own right. Indeed, he did not see her as a person at all, but as an inanimate thing.
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM A N D MELANIE KLEIN
55
(Mrs Klein said that he ran around her as if she were a piece of furniture.) As I hope to show later, it is his incapacity to work through such prematurely induced 'sorrow' which has played a major part in his autistic disorder. It seems as if these children have reached the 'depressive position' as described by Klein in a state in which human beings are not clearly differentiated from inanimate objects and are merely experienced in terms of hard and soft sensations. It is difficult for us, as differentiated human beings, to understand such undifferentiated states in which 'me' and 'notme' are scarcely differentiated. Everything is experienced in terms of 'me', 'me' being the flux of bodily sensations which constitute the child's early sense of 'being', even before the 'notme' has been clearly differentiated, although there will be flickering moments of awareness of it. Work with autistic children has convinced me that this primal sense of 'me-ness' has to be well established before longstanding awareness of the 'not-me' can be tolerated. Without it, the necessary selfconfidence is lacking. I n autistic children, this primal sense of 'me-ness' has been disturbed. Thus, beneath their autistic impenetrability they feel exceedingly vulnerable. T o offset this, they feel that they bite off sticking-out bits and pieces. I n the process of analysis, it becomes clear that they have felt that sticking these extra 'titbits' to the surface of their body would protect them and ensure their survival. (Bodily survival is their main preoccupation.) But this feeling that they have bitten off 'titbits' means that, in flickering moments of awareness of separateness, they feel surrounded by cut-up, broken things; the mournful wail of 'broken' often being the autistic child's first word. In Winnicott's terms, in a state which should be one of 'pre-ruth', they have experienced 'ruth'. Biting, which has precociously supplanted sucking, is feared. T h u s they dare not take the breast in the energetic ruthless way of a normal infant, and during weaning the biting of solid food is avoided. Their main emphasis is on surfaces to which they can adhere
56
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
in order to acquire some sense of bodily definition. Such a child lives mostly in a two-dimensional world. If he goes inside a box, or a tunnel, or a cupboard, it is the sensation of being hidden and protected which is significant to him. It is not the going inside. For most of the time, he he has little awareness of the difference between outsides and insides, and also little awareness of time and space. (Some children even try to walk through objects as if they were not there.) Thus, unlike the schizophrenic child, the autistic child has little curiosity about the inside of the mother's body, which Melanie Klein sees as the starting point for all learning. This may be because he has become aware of insides too soon, or because he has never reached this stage. In any case, it is clear from their developmental histories that such children's experience of their mother's body has been very limited. They have sucked very little, and only limply when they did so. Thus they have not learned much and appear mentally defective. k n autistic child avoids meeting the eyes of other people. He does not relate to people in the normal way. They are only significant to him as inanimate objects. If these objects - and people are included in this - seem to become obstreperous (that is, they do not do what the child expects of them) they provoke tantrums of rage and terror. These are dealt with either by ignoring the offending object or by manipulating it to seem part of their auto-sensuous flow. Thus, for most of the time, these children appear 'affectless', as did Mrs Klein's Dick. Apart from these primitive emotions of rage and terror, autistic children do not manifest the emotions associated with sociability such as we see in neurotic children, and even in schizophrenic ones. As treatment proceeds, and they begin to tolerate bodily separateness, the social emotions of love, hatred, envy and jealousy begin to become manifest, but they are not in evidence at the beginning of treatment, when the child is averted from relationships with people. Lacking contact with people as people, such a child has little
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM AND MELANIE RLEIN
57
motivation to communicate in the usual way. Language is either absent, sparse or echolalic. All the child's energies are concentrated on engendering a protective covering of 'me' sensations to keep the 'not-me' at bay. The fact that Dick had a few communicative words (for example, he said 'cut' to Mrs Klein) shows that he was not as completely cut off from human contact as many of these children are. Those who care for them feel that they cannot get through to them, and speak of their being in a 'shell'. In treatment, it becomes clear that the child also feels that his body surfaces are hard and shell-like. For example, he often turns his hard back to protect his soft front. It is for this reason that I have termed them 'encapsulated' or 'shell-type' children. However, there is always an opening, however minuscule, through this seemingly impenetrable fasade, and it is this which makes psychoanalytic work possible. For example, such children usually understand something of what is said to them, and they are responsive to the analyst's moods and attitudes, the latter being shown by such things as tones of voice, muscle tensions, body movements and the like. Another feature unique to autistic children is their use of what I have called 'autistic objects'. These will be discussed in Chapter 6. T o the child they are not objects as we see them, but are experienced in terms of the sensations they engender. Since there is no delay in getting the sensations he wants, the child can feel that these objects are part of his body. By means of these sensation objects, he feels completely self-sufficient and without the need for other people. These children will spin or twiddle hard objects, or carry hard objects such as toy cars around in their hand. They cling tenaciously to these objects and will not be parted from them. If they are parted from them, it is as if they have lost a part of their body. Dick was intensely interested in cars and door handles, but he was open to their being used by Mrs Klein as a means of communicating with him. This is not the case when the use of an autistic object has become entrenched, as is the
58 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS case with many autistic children. The attempt to use it to get in touch with them is felt by some of these children to be a threat to take away an important part of their body. In autistic children, the manipulation of pathological autistic objects has pre-empted the sucking of normal auto-sensuous ones such as the thumb, the fist, or the fingers. In the undifferentiated state of early infancy, the mother's fingers, the nipple of the breast or the teat of the bottle will also be experienced as auto-sensuous objects. When they first come into treatment, a marked feature of autistic children is that they do not suck their fingers or other objects. This is in marked contrast to the schizophrenic and environmentally deprived young children who usually suck avidly. Instead of sucking, autistic children manipulate hidden parts of their body. These shut out the terror of the unfamiliar 'not-me'. But why does the autistic child have this terror of the 'notme'? It has become clear to me that a crucial factor in the precipitation of the autism was the realization that the nipple of the breast was not part of the mouth, but was separate from it, and could be 'gone'. This had been enraging and terrifying. As I have said, I was first alerted to this by the four-year-old autistic boy whom I have called John (see Chapter 4). I was startled by this boy's revelation to me about 'the black hole with the nasty prick', since it was not part of my Kleinian training. Later, having written a paper about this, I was told by other workers that Winnicott had mentioned this phenomenon in one of his papers, and that Margaret Mahler had just published a paper on this topic. Looking up the references I found that Mahler had written of the autistic child's 'grief and mourning' when he lost what she terms 'the symbiotic love object' (Mahler, 1961, p.332). Winnicott (1958, p.222) had written: 'This loss was experienced as loss of part of his body and not as the loss of the mother and her breast.' Both Winnicott and Mahler saw this as the starting point for childhood autism. Mahler (1961, p.332) writes: 'What we seldom see, and what is rarely described in the literature, is the period of grief and
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM A N D MELANIE KLEIN
59
mourning which I believe precedes and ushers in the complete psychotic break with reality.' Anyone who sees the mournful eyes of an autistic child will not question that he is griefstricken. I have come to see that a significant factor in the precipitation of psychogenic autism is the fact that the child experienced loss in such an immature state of psychic organization that he had not been able satisfactorily to work over the grief and mourning entailed by the loss. Satisfactory mourning entails giving up the lost object and establishing it as a mental construct. Hanna Segal has shown the importance to symbol formation of dealing with feelings of loss (Segal, 1957). The autistic child has not been able to mourn because the nipple he felt he had lost had scarcely reached the status of an object; it was mostly experienced as a cluster of sensations.
A turning point My experience with John's 'black hole with the nasty prick' marked a turning point, not only for John but also for myself. Finding that other workers had had similar experiences to those I had had with John, I was encouraged to explore outside the boundaries of the theoretical school in which I had been reared. This made me realize that there are states other than those which Mrs Klein explored and described with such courage and penetration. For example, seeing Dick's illness as a schizophrenic one, Mrs Klein placed its fixation point in narcissism. There is much evidence that the roots of psychogenic autism are in the earlier pre-narcissistic condition identified by Freud in the following quotation from his paper on narcissism. The auto-erotic instincts are there from the very first so there must be something added to auto-erotism, a new psychological action, to bring about narcissism. (1914, p.77)
I would modify this statement and suggest that undifferentiated auto-sensuousness is there 'from the very first' and
60 A U T I S T I C B A R R I E R S I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S that, in normal development, this gradually differentiates into auto-erotism and auto-sadism. It is suggested that in aberrant development, auto-erotism and auto-sadism have developed precociously, which means that erotism and sadism are not directed towards external objects in an appropriate way. This has happened in psychogenic autism which, as was suggested in the previous chapter, is not associated with narcissism, because the autistic child has no sense of being a self. Kohut has cast additional light on this, in that he suggests a further factor which sets in train 'the psychological action to bring about narcissism'. He writes: 'We may thus conclude that the mother's exultant response to the total child (calling him by name as she enjoys his presence and activity) supports, at the appropriate phase, the development of auto-erotism to narcissism' (Kohut, 1971). T h e mothers of psychogenic autistic children almost invariably report that they were depressed around the time of this particular infant's birth, or prior to the autism, if this occurs some time after the birth. For such subdued mothers, the lively, 'exultant response' towards their infant described by Kohut would not be possible. Thus, such infants become trapped in an aberrant auto-erotic and auto-sadistic condition. This has a precocity and artificiality, interlaced with stark terror, which are not part of normal development. Unmanageable erotic excitements and sadistic biting almost obliterate the urge to suck.
Maternal depression as a factor in the development of psychogenic autism In connection with the effect of a mother's depression on a young infant, I was impressed by Brazelton's observation of a normal three-week-old baby when the mother intentionally presented him with what Brazelton describes as a 'still, unresponsive face'. Brazelton records the baby's reactions as follows: he becomes visibly concerned, his movements become jerky, he averts his face, then attempts to draw her into I . . .
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM AND MELANIE KLEIN
61
interaction. When repeated attempts fail, he finally withdraws into an attitude of helplessness, face averted, body curled-up and motionless' (Brazelton, 1969, p.137). This description could be that of an autistic child; the 'still, unresponsive face' could be that of a depressed mother who feels herself to be a 'non-person', which is how some of the mothers have described their depression. T h e normal infant soon recovers from such a transitory experience of non-responsiveness in the mother. But for 'stresssusceptible' autistic children, it has been a constantly repeated experience which has had tragic consequences for their ongoing mental and emotional development. I have come to realize that this lack of mental connection with the mother has caused them to overvalue the physical bodily connection to her by means of the nipple of the breast (or the teat of the bottle experienced in terms of inbuilt responses to the breast). For such a baby, the frustration of the inevitable realization that this is not a part of his mouth is a bitter blow from which he does not recover. I agree with Meltzer (1975) and Tischler (1979) in seeing the mother's depression as a factor in the breakdown of normal relations between the mother and her autistic child. I have a great deal of sympathy for these mothers. I n my view, Kanner started a regrettable fashion in seeing them as being 'cold and intellectual'. Ever since he said this, phrases such as 'refrigerator mothers' have been bandied about to describe them. I do not subscribe to this view. Such a mother's depression was not usually a clinical one entailing hospitalization. It was associated with events which are part of the ordinary vicissitudes of life, which impinged upon a sensitive mother at a particularly vulnerable time. For example, the family may have moved house, or the father may have had to be away from home a good deal, or the mother may be living in a foreign country, or it may be a mixed marriage (racially or religiously, or both), or an emotionally important relative may have died, or there may be interfering relatives, or there may be important anniversaries around the time of the child's birth.
62 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S Part of such a mother's difficulty seems to come from feeling unsupported by the father. (This may be a repetition of feelings from her own infancy or childhood.) Thus, she clings to her child as if he is still part of her body. She does this in order to keep going in spite of her depression and lack of confidence. This can happen both when the child is inside her womb and also after he is born. She fears the'black hole'of recognizing his separateness from her. When, for various reasons, the child experiences his separateness from her, she cannot hold him through his states of alarm because they coincide too much with her own. It is not only through states of alarm that he needs her support. Uncontrollable states of pleasurable excitement are threatening also. T h e father of an autistic girl has described how she could not stand states of what he called 'rapture'. However, many relatively normal mothers become depressed as the result of certain disturbing happenings, but their children do not become autistic. I am convinced that there is something in the nature of the child which predisposes him to autism. T h u s it has seemed to me to be more fruitful to investigate the child's contribution to his disorder than to concentrate on that of the mother. We may be able to do something about the child, whereas we cannot change the mother of his infancy. When an autistic child is in analysis, work with the parents would seem to be best directed towards helping the father to support the mother who needs to regain both her own self-confidence and also her love for her nowrecovering child.
Critical factors in the child Recent research work by T o m Bower (1977) and also by Meltzoff and Barton (1979) has thrown light on some of these critical factors. It has indicated that in normal development in relation to certain significant gestalts, the integration of tactile and visual perceptions takes place in the first few days of the infant's life. T h e baby who later becomes autistic seems to be a hypersensitive child, unduly prone to panic reactions. I n these
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM AND MELANIE KLEIN
63
children the 'startle response' seems to have become excessively exaggerated. In such children the normal integration of sense modalities seems to have been prevented by uprushes of unmitigated primal panic. The insufficiently buffered shock of bodily separateness from the mother means that the normal integration of touch and sight has been halted, and the child lives in a flat, tactile-dominated world of mere surfaces. Such a child's experiences are superficial and limited, and do not include an interest in insides. In contradistinction to the schizophrenic-type children studied by Mrs Klein, who feel that their insides are full of objects which have dramatic interplay with each other, the autistic child feels empty and objectless. The hard tactile sensations of autistic objects on body surfaces, and the soft touch of autistic shapes, dominate his world. (These are to be discussed in later chapters.) For these children, touch is magical. Only what is tangible seems real to them. The autistic child is trapped in what Spitz has rightly called a 'dead-end street'. But it is a 'dead-end street' with primeval horrors lurking in the shadows.
Primeval terrvrs Whence do these primeval terrors come? Let me make some tentative suggestions about this. Just as in the physical womb of the mother's body the foetus goes through some of the bodily forms of our evolutionary past, so it seems possible that in the post-natal 'womb' of the mother's 'maternal preoccupation' (Winnicott's term) the infant goes through states connected with our evolutionary heritage. Some of these atavistic states seem to be associated with inbuilt fears of animal predators which ensured survival in past ages, but which are now vestigial. In normal development, the infant will be buffered from acute experiences of these atavistic terrors by an ultraresponsive mother who acts as a shock-absorber. A baby who lacks such shock-absorbing primary caregivers is thus exposed to primeval terrors which are not the lot of the normally sheltered infant.
64 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS D r John Bowlby (1973) has come upon this fear of predators in children who have suffered traumatic geographical separation from their mothers in their early years. This fear is also in evidence in psychoanalytic work with autistic children who have suffered psychological separation from their mothers in early infancy. Their fear of predators does not always seem to come from an active projection of their own predatory impulses. Rather, these passive children seem to feel at the mercy of terrors of which they are the helpless victims. The foregoing is an imaginative attempt to make sense of some of the savage terrors encountered in psychotherapeutic work with autistic children. In these children, phylogenetic and ontogenetic factors seem to be intertwined. These atavistic terrors have poisoned the child's relationship to his mother. Insightful, professional intervention can draw the fangs of this poison by realizing the part that autistic objects and autistic shapes have played in these children's pathology. These have been reactive protections against the threat to their survival posed by the vestigial terrors to which they have been abnormally exposed, but they have damaged the child's relationship to the mother. This is because the inanimate, tactile, autistic objects and autistic shapes are always available in just the way the child wants them. When their use has become entrenched, the human mother, by contrast, seems very unsatisfactory. Thus, autistic children expect an impossible mechanical 'perfection' from their mother (and their therapist). For example, they expect her to be always with them, always to give them what they want in the exact terms they have wanted it, and to be for them alone. The autistic delights, comforts and seeming invulnerabilities have completely replaced and made impossible the relationship with a real mother who, supported by the father, can give them safeties and satisfactions of more permanent value. Through the infantile transference, informed by insights such as have just been described, the therapist can negotiate the development of a more trusting relationship between autistic children and their parents. As this occurs, the
PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM A N D MELANIE KLEIN
65
parents' desire to respond to their offspring finds an answering echo in the children themselves. The use of autistic shapes and autistic objects, which have been developed to deal with a situation of mental and emotional disconnection from the mother, results in this disconnection becoming intensified. The 'hole' of disconnection becomes a 'black hole' as the child 'negates' the mother because she is not always as available as are his autistic concoctions. Also, his dependency needs are denied and a pathological self-sufficiency results. This is based on fear. Although they do not show it at the beginning of treatment, autistic children are terrified of the 'black hole' or the 'blacked-out' mother. As treatment proceeds, their fears of being 'blacked out' by her are revealed. These are grave misconceptions on the part of such children which, in the early days of psychodynamic investigation, led some workers to think that the mother was 'to blame' for her child's tragic state. This rubbed salt into the wounds caused by the years of unremitting rejection by her child which the mother had experienced. T o say, as Bettelheim does, that these mothers have had 'death wishes' towards their child, before as well as after birth, is both cruel and erroneous. After years of courageous struggling with their own troubles and with their unresponsive child, is it to be wondered at if, as a passing thought, they wish him or her out of the way? But these parents do not get rid of their autistic child. Far from it, they go to many agencies seeking help. In my experience, if they come to a psychotherapist when the autistic child is under seven years of age, and if there are no detectable organic impairments, these insights into autistic objects and.autistic shapes promise to open the closed doors of autism. There are other insights which it is more difficult to make meaningful to the reader. These concern the tactile, sensuous extremes in which such a child lives and moves and has his being. They are difficult for us to understand because these children's predominantly tactile reactions are so different from our own experiences, in which touch and sight are closely
66 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS associated, and where mental states are distinguished from tangible 'things'. The shock of unbuffered awareness of bodily separateness from the mother seems to have polarized and fixated the autistic child's sensuous experiences at a tactile level. He lives in a world in which tactile, sensuous opposites such as 'hard' and 'soft', 'light' and 'dark', 'big' and 'little', 'full' and 'empty', 'nice' and 'nasty', and so on, are felt to be in opposition to each other. In the non-cooperative state in which he is immured in which savage rivalry holds sway, he fears that an opposing sensation will totally destroy its opposite: for example, that 'darkness' will extinguish 'light', that 'emptiness' will annihilate 'fullness', that 'bigness' will crush 'smallness', that 'nastiness' will poison 'niceness'. If the 'nasty' sensations cancel the 'nice' ones, he fears that he will be made into a 'nothing' - losing his sense of existence being the autistic child's greatest dread. Such a catastrophe will be fatal. There will be no hope of recovery from it. It is difficult to empathize with these states in which qualities are experienced as fluids and substances. For example, one autistic boy felt that by drawing tall towers he could draw their 'tallness' into himself, and that this 'tallness' would counteract his 'shortness'. Similarly 'shortness' could nullify 'tallness'. In these states, sensuous perceptions seem to have been experienced as tangible 'things' which needed to be controlled and manipulated so that they did not crash into and destroy each other. If he fails in this rigid manipulative control, the child feels that he will cease to exist. It is only as an area of co-operation and reciprocity develops that these opposing states can come into creative conjunction, to transform and modify each other so that other more subtle states are born.
Concluding note Rereading Mrs Klein's pioneering paper has made me realize how much those of us who work with childhood phychosis owe to her far-sightedness (Klein, 1930b). It is primarily due to her example and inspiration that some of us have had the courage to do so.
CHAPTER FOUR
A significant element in the development of psychogenic autism Black was the without eye Black the within tongue. Black too the muscles Striving to pull out into the light Black the nerves, black the brain With its tombed visions Black also the soul, the huge stammer Of the cry that, swelling, could not pronounce its sun. Ted Hughes, 'Two Legends', Crow
T
his chapter, which is a considerably revised version of a paper published in the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry (1966) 7:53-67, concerns a particular type of elemental depression manifested by autistic children. Rank and Putnam (1953) used Edward Bibring's term 'primal depression' (1953) for this type of depression. Winnicott (1958) has called it 'psychotic depression'; Margaret Mahler (1961) has written of such children's 'grief'. My own work has confirmed that this elemental depression has been crucial in the massive arrest of emotional and cognitive development which afflictspsychogenic autistic children. Clinical material will now be presented which illustrates the specific characteristics of such autistic children's grief, and demonstrates why it has been so damaging to their psychic development.
68 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S Clinical material John's parents became worried by his lack of speech and the fact that he seemed different from and slower in mental development than other children of his age. When aged 2 yrs 6 mths, he was seen by a psychiatrist who feared mental defect. However, on being seen again six months later John was found to have made a small, hopeful development in that he now put toy motor cars the right way up. (Previously, he had kept them upside down all the time in order to spin their wheels.) On the basis of this, John was referred for a second opinion to Dr Mildred Creak, at Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital, who had an international reputation as a diagnostician in the field of childhood psychosis. She gave a diagnosis of autism, and then referred John, now aged 3 yrs 7 mths, to me for intensive psychotherapy with the following report: There has been a failure almost from birth to take his milestones in his stride, as if there were a reluctance and drag back at each stage. He now shows so many of the attitudes we associate with autism. His chief interest seems to be to tap different surfaces, orto spin round objects. He is fascinated by mechanical moving parts, and has always been quite clever at learning to move his body. Although he is surefooted he still does not feed himself; not that he cannot - it seems as if he will not. This is what I mean by jibbing at milestones. He shows excessive anxiety at times, with days of screaming, but this aspect is much less evident. He has no useful speech, and only communicates very tentatively by trying to use your hand. Nevertheless, I felt sure he was capable of making a primitive contact at this sort of level, and that therefore there was something on which one could build an attempt at therapy. My deepest anxiety is as to whether the basic determinant of all this may be an inherent degree of mental retardation.
A 'bad family history on the paternal side' was reported. Father's only sister was a hospitalized schizophrenic, and there
T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
69
were other eccentric and psychotic relatives. It was also reported that there had been 'tremendous strain' between the child's mother and an aunt who had been mainly responsible for the care of the father during infancy and childhood. John was a first baby. On the physical side pregnancy and birth were normal, but the mother, who came from a remote village in Europe, had been upset by what she felt to be the foreign procedures of an English maternity hospital. She also felt that the nurses prevented her and the baby from getting together in a good feeding relationship. She had a great deal of milk and was very disappointed when breastfeeding could not be established. T h e baby seems to have been a poor sucker and the mother reported that for one week after birth he did not open his eyes. When mother and baby left hospital they went to live with the paternal aunt. Again, the mother felt she was prevented from getting together with her baby, this time by the interference of the aunt. The father was working in another town for the first few months of the baby's life and the mother was insecure and unhappy during this time, but her depression was not such that she had to have treatment. When I saw the parents, they reported that John had had no traumatic experiences such as separations or serious illnesses. He had shown little reaction to the birth of his sister when he was eighteen months old, and had always been a quiet baby. They could give no details about the time at which he first held up his head or sat up, but in the locomotor sphere his development seems to have been quite normal. They began to worry when he failed to learn to talk, and by the strange nature of his play. Bizarre hand movements were reported; he moved his fingers in front of his face in a queer, stiff way. He could not be to put pencil or crayon to paper. Soft fbods would be eaten but he rejected hard lumps. He seemed to confuse his mother's mouth with his own. Bowel and bladder control had not been achieved. I had the impression that the mother had had special difficulty with this aspect of childcare. Remembering her own childhood in which she had exper-
70 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S ienced, on the death of her father, the deprivation of living mostly away from home in an institution, she spoke of her impatience at being a child and her longing to be grown up. The referring psychiatrist gave intermittent but important supportive help to the parents (although, sadly, this was no longer available when the psychiatrist retired). They needed this support, because when the treatment 'holding situation' (Winnicott, 1958) was ruptured on various unfortunate occasions, John had screaming attacks and sleeping difficulties which they found very difficult to bear. The parents were sensitive, intelligent people, and it says much for their concern for John that they maintained support for the treatment during these times and brought him regularly. Without this, the present relatively satisfactory result could not have been achieved.
Course of treatment John was aged 3 yrs 7 mths when he began treatment. At first he came once a week, later three times, and finally five times a week. On his first visit he was expressionless. He went past me as if I did not exist. The one moment when this was not so occurred in the consulting-room when he pulled my hand towards the humming top which I spun for him. At this, he became very flushed, and leaned forward to watch it spin. As he did so, he rotated his penis through his trousers whilst his other hand played around his mouth in circular spinning movements. This suggested to me that he made little differentiation between the movements of the top and those of his own body. He exuded a quality of passionate, sensuous excitement. It convinced me of the importance of maintaining the analytic setting and interpretative procedure if I was to be gradually distinguished from his primitive illusions, and to do my work as a therapist who would help him to come to terms with his sensuous excitements and disillusionments. From now on, I kept to a bare minimum my compliance with the actions he pressed me to do. I made simple interpretations, interspersing them with
T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
71
the few words the parents had told me he might understand. These were 'John, Mummy, Daddy, Nina [his sister], pee-pee, baby, potty, spin, spinning'. I repeated the interpretations in several different ways, and occasionally used actions to supplement my meaning - although I kept these to a minimum when I sensed that they were interpreted by him as seductive or threatening approaches. The following are extracts from detailed notes which illustrate John's responses to interpretations. The first reported session is one in which he used his first word with me. It occurred after the Christmas holiday (he had begun treatment in November 1951.) John had no pronouns, so that this, and his limited vocabulary, restricted what could be said in the interpretations, although I had the impression that he understood much more than was implied by the restricted vocabulary he was reported as knowing.
Friday 10 Janua y 1952: Session 9 John now came three times a week. This was his last session of the week. I quote verbatim from my notes: 'As he had done since his second session, he began by playing with the humming top. On the basis of previous material, as well as the manner of his play in this session, I interpreted that he was using his hand to spin the Tustin top so that he could feel that John was Tustin and Tustin was John. Thus he could feel that we were always together.' Immediately following this, he took out the mother doll and handled the bead that joined the handbag to her hand with the same circular movement with which he had handled his penis in the incident with the humming top. After tapping the mother doll he threw her to the ground, saying very plainly 'Gone'. (I interpreted that John was spinning the mummy's bead as if it were his pee-pee to feel he could go right inside the mummy bag, but then he felt it made her into a 'gone' mummy.) He immediately picked up the little girl doll, turned her round and round and ground his teeth loudly. (I interpreted that John was
72 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N NEUROTIC P A T I E N T S spinning into the mummy's bag to bite the girl baby, but then he felt he made the girl 'gone' and the mummy 'gone'.) He now took the baby doll and put it in the cot which he turned upside down so that the baby fell out. (I interpreted that he was spinning into the Tustin mummy bag to upset her babies because he wanted to be her only baby.) Following this, he worked the top inside the suitcase provided for his toys, pressing the point into some soft plasticine strips in the bottom of it. Once he touched the baby doll and said 'Baby' or 'Peepee', I could not tell which. (I interpreted that John felt that his spinning made a soft mummy who let him spin inside her to make her babies gone, and this made her into a'gone' mummy.) (During such material, I found my thoughts wandering so that I was in danger of complying with some unspoken request and thus behaving as if I were a part of his body or a toy, instead of a mature, thinking person who was trying to help him to come to terms with his feelings. Other workers have found that this is a not infrequent occurrence with such 'atmospheric' children. Later, I found it helpful to interpret to him that he felt he spun inside my head to make my 'brain children' 'gone', so that he could feel that I was a 'softie' with whom he could have all his own way.) In the above material, we see the beginning of his disillusionment arising from the fact that I can be 'gone', both in the sense of not attending to him, and in the actual bodily sense of being separated from him. This meant that I was not under his control. This was developed further four weeks later, when he spoke two more words. Again it was in the last session of the week.
Fn'day 9 February 1952 :Session 23 Mother and John had rung several times before I could manage to get to the door to open it. As they stood on the step they looked cold and frozen. John had stopped rattling the letterbox; on previous occasions I had had the impression that he felt he controlled me to come to the door by doing this. He mournfully repeated 'Dirty' after
T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
73
his mother, as she looked into the orifice of his ear. In the consulting-room he tried to spin the top on the soft carpet. It would not spin. Violently thrusting his hand into mine, he tried to use it as an appendage to his own hand to make it do so. It did not. Spitting with rage and breathing heavily, he threw the offending top to the ceiling. It just missed the electric light. With a crash it fell to the ground and broke into two halves. The inside fell out. Shocked, he went to it and said 'Broken!' and 'Oh dear!' in a grief-stricken way. He spent the rest of the session hopelessly trying to mend it. It seemed that depressing realities were penetrating the autism. There now followed a confused period in the analysis (February - April 1952). During this there was the attempt to make people and things behave in a way,which ran counter to their real nature, as in the incident with the humming top. The toys and myself seemed to be manipulated as if they were his excreta or parts of his own body. During this time he spent most of the sessions lying on the couch playing with his penis, and with his own faeces and occasional bits of plasticine, which hardly seemed to be differentiated from faeces. There was also nose-picking and spitting. This ceased after the three-week Easter holiday in April. This was his second long break in treatment. He now developed an obsessional habit of tapping a button on a cushion and saying 'Daddy!', 'Daddy!' (his father was away from home during this time). This, and the toy he called 'the red daddy bus', played a large part in the analysis during this period. There were tantrums when he realized that they were not part of him and so could go away and leave him. Following this, he would say 'Broken!' 'Gone!' 'Oh dear!' very dolefully (May- June 1952) His first use of the personal pronoun came after he had broken the 'red daddy bus' in such a tantrum. He said, 'I mend it! I mend it!' (Session 118).
Monday 26 November 1952 : Session 130 One day, after changes in the routine of bringing him, he was distressed when
74 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS his father, who had now returned home, nearly missed his footing on the front steps as he was waving goodbye to John after leaving him for his session. During this session, John seemed to be trying to maintain that the movements of his body could keep his father alive. (For example, he jumped up and down on the couch, saying 'Daddy mended! Daddy mended!'.) At the end of the session, when he found that his mother, not his father, was waiting for him, he screamed 'Daddy! Daddy gone! Daddy broken!' Following this incident he had a severe nocturnal screaming fit. It was reported to me that in it he had said such things as, 'I don't want it! Fell down! Button broken! Don't let it bite! Don't let it bump!' With hindsight, I realized that these nightmare screams expressed infantile terrors which had been active in relation to the father, the red toy bus, and the button on the cushion, all of which had been felt to be identical with each other. They were not symbols for the father, they were felt to be the father who was undifferentiated from his bodily parts (Hanna Segal(1957) has written of such symbolic equations). But as long as the terrors were scattered in this way, I could not sufficiently understand them to help him to come to terms with them. A session which occurred fifteen months after treatment began will now be reported in detail. In this session terrors which had been adumbrated in previous sessions were brought together, and John was able to use representations by means of words and toys to tell me about them. He could do this because people were now being distinguished as people instead of being used like inanimate objects, such as toy buses, buttons and the like. Thus the autism was much diminished and representational activities were beginning, 25Januavy 1953 : Session 153 (Before giving this session, I should say that in December John had seen a baby feeding at the breast and had shown great interest. I had not used the word 'breast', not knowing whether he knew it. It now came into his material.) He carefully arranged four pencil crayons in the form
THE DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
75
of a cross and said 'Breast!' Touching his own mouth, he'said 'Button in the middle!' (I interpreted baby John's desire to make up a breast for himself out of his own body.) He then put out more pencils in a hasty careless fashion to make a ramshackle extension to the cross. T o this he said, 'Make a bigger breast! Make a bigger breast!' (These children feel called upon to be extra-ordinary, and so they feel they need an extraordinary breast. In the session I interpreted baby John's desire to have a bigger breast than really existed.) He angrily knocked all the pencils so that they spread in a higgledy-piggledy fashion over the table. He said 'Broken breast!' (I interpreted his baby anger that he could not have a breast as big as he wanted.) He said, 'I fix it! I fix it! Hole gone! Button gone! Hole gone! Button gone!' (I interpreted his baby desire to have a breast he could make or break as he pleased.) He again angrily pushed the pencils all over the table and said, 'Broken!' He then opened and shut a wooden box with ear-splitting bangs. (1 interpreted his baby anger that he couldn't have a breast with which he could do as he liked.) He said 'Broken' again and went to the umbrella stand which is in the consulting-room; he put his hand into the glove cavity which is in dark shadow. He shuddered and said, 'No good breast! Button gone!' (I interpreted that he felt that his anger with the breast that would not behave exactly as he wanted it to do made him feel he had a 'no-good breast' with a hole instead of a button.) He went to the case and fetched a piece of dirty grey cardboard and a crocodile. He put them on the chest he had banged. He pointed to the Sellotape round the edge of the cardboard and said 'Icy! Icy!' Then he said, 'No good breast! Button broken!' He slid the crocodile around the cardboard as if it were slithering on ice. His face went cold and pinched. ( I took up his feeling that breaking the breast made an icy no-good breast which was no comfort to him when he was on his own.) Now that the infantile transference was well established and the anxieties were 'contained' in the analysis, his behaviour outside showed great improvement. He was eager to come to
76 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS analysis and made good progress in spite of family illness, changes in the routine of bringing him, and family bereavements. He began to admit his dependence and helplessness, and would say of things that were beyond his powers, 'I can't do it! Please help me!' This progress was maintained when his mother and younger sister went abroad and he was left with his father. An unfortunate break now occurred in the 'holding situation' (Winnicott, 1958, p.268). Friday 5 April 1953 :Session 194 I showed him, by means of a diagram, the day he would come back to analysis after the twoweek Easter holiday. Family circumstances made it impossible for his father to bring him back until one week later. In addition, he had been left for one week with the aunt with whom they lived. When he came back I was appalled. He seemed traumatized and frozen. He had a stiff-legged mechanical gait. What speech he had left was stammered. He was indeed in the grip of the 'icy, no-good breast'. This had provided no comfort for 'poor little baby John left all alone on an island', as he put it later. As the bodily tensions relaxed, the night-time screaming fits became such a regular occurrence that the referring psychiatrist prescribed a sleeping draught. During the screaming fits he would hallucinate birds in various parts of the bedroom, and say some of the phrases he had used in his first screaming fit. The birds threatened to peck him and were a great source of terror. However, he gradually began to bring the infantile terrors back into the analysis. He again proceeded with the differentiations he had been making ever since his first word of 'Gone!' He continued to relate to his father in a more real way, and less in terms of a 'thing' like a button that could be broken. He accepted that space and time separated him from me. He put experiences into categories such as 'nice' and 'nasty', and people were classified as 'naughty' or 'sensible' according to whether they did what he wanted them to do. There was the
THE DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
77
beginning of the differentiation between fact and fantasy. He would sometimes say 'It's a story', or 'It's not really true'. He now told me in more detail the illusory terrors that had given rise to the cryptic phrases in the screaming fits. He began to associate the misuse of objects with their being broken. For example, of the humming top he said :'It's broken! Tops don't go on the carpet.' At the end of sessions he sometimes hinted that he felt I left him because he had a part missing, or because he was a 'stinky little goat'. Sometimes he would make as if to break off his 'stinkers' (his word for the hard faeces that hurt his anus), and pretend - a significant development - to drop them down the front of my dress. Sometimes he got rid of his own feelings of silliness by calling his father 'silly' and 'naughty', and to his sister, Nina, as to me, were assigned all the nasty experiences he did not want himself. Thus he demonstrated clearly the fantasy of breaking off unacceptable parts of himself and thrusting them into other people.
Tuesday 28 January 1954 : Session 360 The effect on his psychic development of having his projections contained by understanding was again shown by his use of the pencil crayons which he arranged to make a 'breast'. This was the first time he had done this since the previous occasion eight months earlier, before the unfortunate separation experiences. He pointed to the carefully arranged pencils and said 'Breast!'Then, touching his own mouth, he said, 'Button in the middle!' Then he st009 a pencil in the middle and said 'Rocket!' He called the whole thing a 'firework breast'. This linked with the drawing of a dome-shaped object with brown and red 'stinkers' coming out of it which he afterwards called 'fireworks'. (This had been drawn following a tantrum when I would not let him use my hand as if it were his own.) Holding his mouth as if it hurt, he said, 'Prick in my mouth!' Then, 'Falls down!', 'Button broken!', 'Nasty black hole in my mouth!' Then in an alarmed way, he held his penis and said, 'Pee-pee still there?' as if he
78. A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S thought it was not. (In the session which followed, he said of the broken humming top, 'Broken top! Nasty peoples coming out to blow me up!')
Wednesday 29 January 1954 : Session 361 Material then came about his 'stinkers' burning and piercing the button and making 'a black hole in my mouth'. I asked him about the black hole. He answered simply, 'When naughty things are burned they go black.' Following this he said sadly, 'My nice dreams turn into nasty dreams', and then, brightening up, 'I have my nasty dreams with Tustin.' One day the screaming fits, the cryptic phrases and some of the previous fantasies all came together into one session. Thursday 6 February 1954 : Session 367 H e was in a screaming tantrum when I opened the front door because he had fallen and bumped his head. There was no sign of damage, but he seemed panicistricken as well as enraged. When he stopped crying I took him to the consulting-room. Without taking anything from the case of toys, he went to the table to talk to me. He said, 'Red button gone! It fell with a bump!' H e then indicated both his shoulders with a semi-circular movement and said, 'I've got a good head on my shoulders. Can't fall off. Grows on my shoulders.' He then said, 'It was the naughty pavement, it hit me.' (I said I thought that he was trying to tell me about his fears when he fell down just now.) Touching his own mouth, he said, 'Nina's got a black hole. She had a prick in her mouth. Button broken! Nasty black hole!' (I should have interpreted here that these were his own nasty experiences of which he was ridding himself by attributing them to Nina, but I birked it.) He took the plastic tractor, which was a toy he had attacked remorselessly. He touched the plastic axle, which is not in reality sharp. However, he touched it, gave a huge shudder and said, 'Nasty hard tractor, it pricks.' He spat as though spitting out something that was repugnant. He then screwed himself up
T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
79
and screamed loudly. (I reproached myself for not having attempted to put his feelings into words, and so possibly spared him from having to express them in violent action.) In his screaming he pushed away flying beaks. I was afraid that he would fall off his chair, so I took him on my knee and interpreted through the shrieks, The interpretations concerned his feeling that the button was part of his mouth and the destructive feelings he had when he found that this was not so. He then felt he had a 'black hole' and a 'nasty prick' instead of a nice button. He felt he spat the nasty thing into the girl baby whom he felt had taken the button away from him. But then he felt that she tried to spit it back at him and her nasty mouth seemed like flying birds. (We had had material where he had equated the flying birds with mouths.) Without the 'button' he felt that they could hurt him. He was afraid that he might lose his head or his penis, as he felt he had lost his button. For two sessions after this he was afraid of certain objects in the consulting-room: one was the dark glove cavity, another was a penis-like pipe near the ceiling, a third was the 'dirty water bucket'. (This room had no water plumbed in, so there was a jug of water and a bucket for dirty water.) After these sessions the night-time screaming stopped. (It came back after a particularly worrying holiday, and when the question of ending treatment was being discussed.) The hallucinations subsided and did not, so far as I know, trouble him after this:
Closure note Treatment came to an end when John was aged 6 yrs 5 mths. This was earlier and more sudden than I would have liked, but the parents were urging that he finish, particularly as his need for psychotherapy was not now so obvious. He attended a school for normal children. He was making friends, enjoyed school, and was learning avidly. He had a vocabulary beyond that of most children of his age, but this was not surprising since his parents were both intelligent people. He was still a 'finicky' eater. In times of stress he was inclined
80 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
to stammer and to have sleeping difficulties. These remaining symptoms made me want to continue, but since there were signs that he was moving into latency, and since I felt that the parents very much wanted to have John to themselves, I agreed to the cessation of treatment, with the proviso that it might be advisable to seek further help in adolescence. Follow-up It has only been possible to get information about John in a somewhat roundabout way. T h e parents of encapsulated autistic children seem to want to forget the whole experience once it is over. This is in marked contrast to the attitude of parents of symbiotic (entangled) children, who keep contact with the therapist. John's parents did not seek further help. 1 have heard that John attended public day school at the normal age and did well. Later he obtained a good university degree. He has developed into a sensitive young man who is very musical. Discussion child's descriptions John's experience of pi'ef' Such a are probably the closest we can get to crucial, panic-stricken experiences concerned with grief about the loss of a vital object, which John called the 'button'. This was his experience of the nipple of the breast which he had taken for granted, and indeed had not known that it existed, until he discovered that it was not always there. When he became aware that it was not there, overwhelming feelings of disillusionment were aroused, the essence of this grief-provoking situation being partly expressed in his first words of 'Gone!', 'Broken!', 'Oh dear!'. These ejaculations expressed evocations from his infancy, when the loss and seeming destruction of the 'button' had been felt to leave a 'black hole with a nasty prick'. This was John's present day formulation for the previously undifferentiated, unformulated, insufferable experience of sensuous loss which had precipitated the autism. Seeing the baby feeding at the breast had evoked the whole system of illusion which had set
THE DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
81
John's autistic reactions in train. He was now able to get sufficiently in touch with this experience to put me in touch with it also. Being preverbal, it is difficult to discuss in words; evocative rather than theoretical language seems most appropriate to describe it. Recalling the two sessions in which he represented the breast with coloured pencils (Sessions 156 and 360) it will be remembered that the 'no-good breast' with the hole becomes the 'firework breast' with 'stinker' rockets discharged into it by himself. T h e firework, rocket-like discharges had been felt to go into a 'hole' - into a nothingness - instead of being received by a human presence who responded to them in an appropriate way and helped him to manage them. These are very early infantile experiences, in which 'feelings' are experienced in a bodily tactile way as sensations of various kinds. When the 'button' will not stay in John's mouth to be under his control and to be available just whenever, and however, he wants it, he becomes discombobulated. I n panic and rage, the aggravatingly 'naughty' 'button' is felt to be discharged from his body like spit or faeces. It seems to leave a 'hole' in the breast where the 'button' had been. Since his mouth had been undifferentiated from the breast, it leaves a 'hole' in his mouth also. T h e burning sensations of rage make it into a 'black hole'. (As John says, 'When naughty things are burned they turn black.') Putting these preverbal experiences into words distorts their original nature, but both John and I felt that it had to be done, if we were to come to terms with them. 'Acting out' is often the first way in which such primal dramas find expression. But following this way of dramatizing them in psychotherapy, words are necessary if the impulsive discharges are to be contained by thinking about them. As this is done the patient feels that a part of himself, which had previously reacted impulsively in terms of powerful illusions, is being brought within the orbit of thoughtful attention and understanding care. Autistic patients like John have felt assailed by nameless dangers, some of which will be discussed in later chapters. In
82 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS order to feel that these dangers were kept at bay, they have needed to feel in control of what happened to them. When they find that they are not in control but, in reality, are weak and helpless, they are devastated. This is well illustrated in Session 367, in which the 'naughty' pavement got out of control and 'hit' John. In this session it was clear that he felt he had lost a part of his body. In his relatively undifferentiated state, he was not sure which part had 'gone'. Was it his head? His penis? Or was it that sensuously exciting 'button'? I had the impression that he experienced his screams as solid, piercing tangible objects; his mouth emitting them as a round black hole. In later sessions, not presented here, he told me that he avoided looking at people's eyes, 'because of the black hole in the middle'. As these agonies and terrors about the 'black hole' were worked over in the analysis, John began to look at people's faces in the way a normal child will do. T h e material presented implies that in the relatively undifferentiated state, phallic and anal sensations were drawn into the primary oral experience, which seemed to affect every orifice of the boy's body. His body, fretted with sore black holes, seemed to face an outside world which was pitted with similar black holes. Empathic identification with John put me in touch with the wordless elemental dramas which had provoked the psychogenic autism. These illusory dramas arose from sensations in his body, the 'button' being the product of these bodily sensations. Let me now discuss this 'button' and the role it played in the development of John's psychogenic autism. The button It is obvious, in terms of John's early sensuous experience, that the 'button' was something more than the actual nipple of the breast or teat of the bottle. Other objects which had similar shapes, or aroused similar sensations, had accreted to it. It was an illusion which could be different things at different times. T h e core of the sensation experience was a
T H E DEVELOPMENT O F PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
83
'teat-tongue' combination. This arose from the lack of clear differentiation of his mouth from the breast. (You will remember that in the referral notes John was reported as confusing his mother's mouth with his own.) Later his penis, his head, his 'stinkers', a toy red bus, a button on a cushion and even his 'Daddy' were all drawn into this 'teat-tongue' combination, probably on the basis of their common sensation of hardness. I t is difficult for us, as differentiated individuals, to get in touch with such undifferentiated modes of operation. In these states objects which, in sensuous terms, have a roughand-ready 'clang' similarity with each other are grouped together and treated as if they were the same. In undifferentiated states, the tendency is to be aware of similarities rather than differences. Thus, objects which, to our more differentiated awareness, seem very unlike are experienced by the relatively undifferentiated child as being the same. T o a young child, a boiling kettle and a steam train may seem to be the same as each other, because the thing that is important to him is the steam. For John, I suspect hardness was what was important to him, because hardness could protect him from the terrible dangers by which he felt threatened. Thus the nipple, his penis, his head, his stinkers, a pipe in the therapy room, a button on a cushion, the toy red bus, and his 'Daddy' all evoked the same reactions. It is not that they are similar and so can be used to represent each other. They are felt to be the same. In John's undifferentiated state the button on the cushion and the toy red bus evoke the same sensations as Daddy does. They did not represent Daddy, they were felt to be Daddy because they evoked the same hard sensuous in~pressionas Daddy did (Session 130), hardness being the trigger sensation. But, so far as John is concerned, these objects had another thing in common as well as hardness - they could all be broken. T h e fact that they were not unbreakable, in spite of being hard, fills John with grief and despair. His desperate efforts to keep himself
84 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S absolutely safe have failed. None of us likes broken things, but to the hypersensitized autistic child a broken thing is not merely a mishap, it is a catastrophe. John's behaviour is not puzzling when we realize that the primary mode of organizing our experience is by means of classification. We sort things in terms of the characteristics they have in common. John's method of classification is strange to us because he sees things as being the same which, to our more differentiated awareness, are very different. For him, objects are sorted in terms of their hardness or softness. Looked at from this point of view, John's behaviour becomes more understandable. In terms of his sensuous reactions, there is logic to his seemingly strange behaviour and puzzling statements. We need to try to think as he does, if we are to begin to understand him. This classifying of objects and experiences in terms of sensuous,!y significant features which they have in common also seems to be responsible for the relatively undifferentiated autistic child's confusion of the configurations of nipple-inmouth, stool-in-bottom and penis-in-vagina. In these children, due to the lack of an adequate capacity for differentiation, as well as to the precocious arousal of auto-erotism, oral, anal and phallic constellations become confused with each other in a polymorphous way. This results in the homosexual tendencies of untreated autistic children. An important part of psychotherapy is the sorting out of such confusions. In. studying autism we find that we are studying the beginnings of perception. The phenomenon of the 'button' seems to arise from inborn nipple-seeking patterns of response which take shape again in treatment. It is obvious that such a nipple-seeking pattern will promote breast - or bottle feeding. Piaget's observations of his own babies complement and confirm inferences derived from psychoanalytic work in respect of this (Piaget, 1954). For example, when Piaget hid a feeding bottle or a toy stork with different parts of the body left showing, he found that it was only when the teat of the bottle or
T H E DEVELOPMENT O F PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
85
the beak of the toy stork were left exposed that the young infant would search for the object; that is, nipple-like objects promoted his response. Clinical work has made me think that such inborn responses are like 'feelers' which reach out into the outside world to mould, and be moulded by, it. In my first book Autism and Childhood Psychosis (1972) 1 suggested the term 'innate forms' to describe them. The 'button' is the result of such an innate form.
Innate fonns These will also be discussed in Chapter 9. They seem to be flexible sensuous moulds into which, at an elemental level of psychic development, experience is cast, and which are modified by the experience so cast. When an innate form seems to coincide with a correspondence in the outside world, the child has the illusion that everything is synonymous and continuous with his own body stuff. In primitive states, patternseeking tendencies are active but, since discrimination is minimal, any one part of the subject's own body, or other people's bodies, or objects in the environment, can seem to be the same. Thus the nipple can be felt to be part of John's body because fingers can be equated with the innate form of nipple; the knob of the humming top could match this form; penis, tongue, 'stinkers', and so on could all be equated with it and with each other. Such unmodified equivalents led to bodily confusions which presaged later mental ones. In this state, live and inanimate objects were treated in almost the same way: for example, the father could be a button on a cushion and the same things could happen to him. In the confused period of the material presented, it seemed that John used parts of his body - and outside objects as if they were parts of body stuff - for the manipulation of what later could become abstracted as mental concepts; much as a child uses fingers or sticks to do arithmetical processes which he later becomes able 'to do in his head'. In these early days, when the fact of his separateness from me was forced upon him, words seemed to be experienced by John
86 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS as solid objects. When he was told about the ends of sessions, or breaks in the treatment due to holidays, he winced as if something had been stuck into him. These separations seemed to be experienced quite concretely as broken things which pierced his body. It is difficult to know how to discuss such states, in which the singular feature is that feelings seem to be experienced as physical entities. Absence was 'goneness' 'goneness' was a broken thing - 'a black hole' full of a 'nasty prick'. T h e observer might speak of 'depression', but for John this was a 'black hole'; 'persecution' was a'nasty prick'; 'despair' was felt as taking into his irreparably broken body an object felt to be broken beyond repair. H e did not 'think' about these things; he felt he took them into his body. When the allpowerful, controlling 'button' was gone, uncontrollable dangers rushed in in an uncontrollably painful way. These dangers were experienced as tangible things. Also, the pain of preverbal, preconceptual loss was experienced as bodily rather than mental pain.
The 'black hole' This illusion was the significant element which had set John's autistic reactions in train. This was what was felt to be left when the 'button', and all that it signified, was 'gone'. T h e patient can only tell us about this experience when it is over. When it is happening, he is frozen by it. It was reevoked for John when he saw the baby feeding at the breast. This enabled him to work over his reactions to his breastfeeding experiences. In so doing, he showed me the multiple significances of the 'button'. Absence of the 'button' was not just the absence of 'nice' things which we might intellectually expect it to he, but it was a nasty physical presence - a 'black hole'. When I asked John about this, he said: 'When naughty things are burned they go black.' T h e uncontrollable 'button' was a 'naughty' button which had been burned away and turned black, by the flames of his impulsive rage which he had never been helped to manage appropriately. These children have
THE DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
87
never become toilet-trained in either the psychological or the physiological sense. As well as being associated with feelings that John has not been able to control, the 'button' is also associated with things that will not be controlled by him, and so arouse his uncontrollable rage. It is associated with the top that will not spin, my hand that will not spin it, the 'button' that will not remain part of his body. These children lack sufficient experience of hard 'Daddy' discipline being married to comfortable 'Mummy' softness. They have been left alone to manage their outbursts of temper aroused by frustration. In the outburst in which they unburden themselves, they feel that they explode away a vital bodily part. In their undifferentiated state they are not sure which part it is, or whether it is theirs or another's. Thus as John's fiery rage burned the 'naughty' object that would not do as it was told, he felt that a bodily part was 'blacked out' also. Was it his penis? Was it his head? Was it that sensuous 'titbit', the 'button'? Was it broken off like his 'stinkers'? Was it the hard 'Daddy' bit? In his hypersensitized state, in which everything was exaggerated, the results of his unheld tantrums were experienced as 'catastrophe'. Bion (1962b) has shown that the critical decision for psychic development is whether frustration is avoided, or whether the attempt is made to come to terms with it. Winnicott's transitional area of skills, 'let's pretend' play, humour and aesthetic activities come into being when depression about this catastrophe is experienced, and the attempt is made to control the feelings aroused by frustration. The child learns to sustain tension and to delay action. In the clinical material presented here, we see John's attempts to avoid frustration by explosive projection. On the other hand, his first words of 'Gone!', 'Broken!', 'Oh dear!' show that as soon as he developed even a limited capacity to be in touch with the 'black hole', he began to develop speech (Session 23). Later he was able to re-present his emotional situation (Sessions 153 and 360). Such representation required
88 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS IN N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S that his impulsivity should be beginning to be held in check, and that he should be beginning to have some capacity to tolerate his separateness. T h e 'black hole' was John's experience .of 'primal' or 'psychotic depression'. As we shall see in Chapter 14, getting in touch with and working over this depression was a crucial situation for the anorexic girl's recovery. Getting in touch with this depression is crucial in the amelioration of autistic states. As one adult patient expressed it, 'You held me firmly so that I did not "break out" and so my "breakdown" became a "breakthrough".' Work with autistic children has brought home to me that such patients need to be held in a firm but understanding 'holding situation' (Winnicott, 1958, p.268).
The 'holding situation' I n earliest infancy, the coincidence of innate forms with matching correspondences in the outside world is the first 'holding situation'. Winnicott expresses this when he says 'The mother places the actual breast just where the infant is ready to create and at the right moment' (Winnicott, 1958, p.238). Bion expresses the same idea when he says 'A preconception mates with a realization' (Bion, 1962b). Mother and baby, teat and tongue, work together to produce the illusion of continuity and to confirm it. T h e 'button' illusion seems to 'button' mother and child together, and also to enable each of them to feel 'all buttoned-up'; falling apart being an existential dread. Both Winnicott (1958, p.238) and Milner (1956, p. 100) have stressed the importance of ample opportunities for such illusion in early infancy, and the dangers of a disastrous impingement of awareness of bodily separateness. But coincidences cannot always be exact, nor can they always be forthcoming, and Bion has increased our understanding of this early situation by delineating the role of the mother as a 'container' for her infant's burning rage, which is experienced as bodily discharge. Lacking an adequate 'conta~ner',the f~erypass~ons of the e nf a ~ ? ~ 9m~ !.c h autlstic chlld have been covered by the ~ c cap
T H E DE\'ELOPRIENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
89
a child is like a volcano waiting to erupt. When an autistic child starts having tantrums he is beginning to recover. How he is held through these tantrums is important if the recovery is to be sustained. He must never be left alone with them. We must 'talk him through' them. Thus 'held', tantrums can be the beginnings of creative responses. In the North of England, it is common for a mother to describe her child's tantrums by saying, 'He created something terrible!' What a common-sense way to react to tantrums! In early infancy the infant's lack of discrimination, and the mother's adaptation arising from empathic identification with him in the form of 'reverie' (Bion, 1962a, p.309), serve to minimize the explosion-producing gap between primitive illusions and actuality. This empathic reciprocity at first fosters the illusion of bodily continuity, and then gradually acclimatizes the nursing couple to the dimly apprehended fact of separateness. It enables the mother to support her infant through the turbulence arising from awareness of separateness; separateness which seems to be experienced as a break in bodily continuity - as a loss of a part of the body. Changes of state, for example, from 'button-in-mouth' to 'button-gone', inevitably bring tensions, tensions experienced as bodily turgor, to be relieved by bodily discharges. A mother with unbearable, unformulated infantile insecurities, and little support in bearing them, finds it difficult to.take such projections from her infant. I n a way, both mother and child are too alike in their reactions. Such a mother easily succumbs to attacks on her capacity to pay attention to her infant -to hold him in her awareness. Such attacks may come from her own infantile 'privations', or from outside events and people, or from her infant's atmospheric reactions; it is usually a combination of these. They mean that her attention is gone, her mind wanders just as mine tended to do in one of the reported sessions (Session 9). It seems that if a mother, through no fault of her own, is absent-minded, the 'holding' situation' (Winnicott, 1958, p.268) is broken just as
90 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S much as by a traumatic geographical separation between mother and baby. It is feasible that this 'holding situation' is affected by the parents' relationship with each other, in that this will affect the mother's responses to the infant who is the outcome of that relationship. A breakdown in the 'holding situation' means that the naive infant is left to bear intolerable feelings alone. These seem to be discharged into a void to come back at him with renewed force. T h u s stresses and strains accumulate. Continuing to use his own body as if it were another's body, and part of another's body as if it were a lifeless part of his own, means that he remains undifferentiated and cut off from alive human beings who can help him with his troubles. Instead other people are experienced as inanimate things to be manipulated in terms of his needs and caprices. Thus John became more and more enmeshed in the terrors and sufferings associated with the illusion of the 'black hole'. T h e realistic fear of dying pales by comparison with these illusory agonies and terrors. T h e autism had been a reaction to deal with John's explosive feelings in relation to loss of the 'button', for which he felt that no help was forthcoming from the people around him. They seemed to be as frightened of them as he was. But John had cut himself off from such help as was there. In colloquial terms he had 'cut off his nose to spite his face'. This had landed him in serious trouble. As his autism broke down, these impetuous outbursts, experienced as bodily discharges, were released from their autistic wraps. As they were released, other elements in the 'black hole' depressive situation were revealed. These were mourning feelings.
Mourning feelings When I first encountered these feelings, I found it difficult to believe that they could be possible at such a primitive level of psychic development. Finally, however, the evidence was so compelling that I had to face the fact, and help John to face the fact, that he was mourning the loss of the ultraspecial 'button' which could never exist in reality. It was an
THE DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTIShl
91
illusion, but an important one. H e felt bereft of a very vital thing. It was like a bereavement. When I was introduced to Margaret Mahler's paper 'On sadness and grief in infancy and childhood: loss and restoration of the symbiotic love object' (1961), I was reassured that I was not reading feelings into the child that were not there. I realized that the 'button' was John's 'symbiotic love object', the loss of which had rendered him numb and dumb. As we worked this over together, we realized that his 'crow-black' sulk about this loss had prevented him from working over the disillusionment that the 'button', conceived in his terms, was not available in the outside world. Another type of baby would have reacted d#erently. As he relinquished his unrealistic hopes of finding the superlatively perfect 'button' in the outside world, it became established as a psychic construct in his mind. This seemed to be the basis for a more trusting relationship with me, based on more realistic expectations. T h e therapeutic 'holding situation' seemed to provide a 'cradle', in which John's baby self could go over early unresolved psychic situations, and modify his unrealistic, perfectionist, exacting demands, both of himself and other people.
Conclusion On superficial observation, organic and psychogenic autistic disorders can look the same. However, on careful investigation, it becomes clear that organic autism arises from gross damage to the brain, whereas in the present state of our knowledge, psychogenic autism seems to arise mainly from damage to the psyche. In my view, psychic damage needs to be investigated as meticulously as the neurophysiologists are investigating brain damage. Global understandings in terms of unresponsive mothers and unresponsive babies just will not do. If we are to be able to help children with the handicap of psychogenic autism, we need to have detailed insight into its nature. In studying this, we find that we are studying the elemental emotions associated with the beginnings of perception, and of
92 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS IN N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S the ways in which perception can become blocked and distorted. John's revelations give us some insight into this. Later chapters will carry this understanding further. Psychotherap-v with psychogenic autistn An understanding of psychogenic autism is complicated by the fact that in the elemental, relatively undifferentiated state in which psychic damage occurred, such psychic damage is experienced as bodily damage. Since subject and object are scarcely differentiated from each other, the damage seems to happen to both child and object. Both mother and child are felt to lose the vital 'Daddy button' which holds them together. John, a young child suffering from psychogenic autism, showed us the details of this psychic damage. Such a child is in shock. H e feels damaged, weak and helpless. T h e reaction, to counteract this, has been to develop practices which give him the illusion that he is impenetrable, invulnerable and in absolute control. Although they look so passive, such children are little tyrants. In colloquial terms, they are 'too big for their boots'. They need firm but understanding 'containment', mixed with compassion and common sense. They welcome this, for they are as unhappy about their state as are the concerned people around them. From what she told me, I had the impression that John's mother was stunned by the beautiful baby whom she felt she had lost, as part of herself, by giving birth to him. He was not a real live baby to her, but a precious piece of Dresden china. How hurting it would have been to her, and how far from the truth, if she had been told by an 'expert' that she had a 'death wish' towards her child, and that this was the cause of his troubles. Some of the psychodynamicists have made grave mistakes in their approach to autism. This chapter has been an attempt to bring in evidence which corrects some of these mistaken notions. It has also been an attempt to get in touch with the elemental feelings which have provoked the psychogenic autism. In reality, what happened to the children was in the nature of
T H E DEVELOPMENT OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
93
a sensuous mishap, but in the hypersensitized, illusiondominated state of early infancy, it had become exaggerated to seem like a catastrophe. But the feelings associated with this illusion had been traumatizing. As one patient said to me, I know it's an illusion, but the terror is real. I have found that this early, seemingly catastrophic damage can be healed by a form of psychotherapy which is realistic about the nature of the disorder being treated. I have also found that insights gathered from such psychotherapy have thrown light on the autistic barriers encountered in certain neurotic patients.
CHAPTER FIVE
Situations which may precipitate psychogenic autism So he took his birth-sneeze in one hand And his death-chill in the other And let the spark scour him to ashes.
Ted Hughes, 'Crow Improvises', Crow
utism is a pseudo-independent state in which the child grimly and stubbornly goes his own eccentric way with no attempt to adjust and adapt to other people's ways. Parents' reports indicate that this is partly because the mother's confidence was being undermined in the baby's early infancy. Thus it had been easy for the child to treat her as a manipulable, lifeless object who was a part of his body. Also, the father's influence, in many cases, was absent or excluded. Now let me instance a few situations which have caused the mothers of the autistic children I have treated to feel underconfident.
A
Undemttning situations for the mothers A large number of the mothers have reported that they were tlepressed before o r attcr the tlmc of the baby's b ~ r t h . 5.ornctrrncs the fathcr had to be away d u r ~ n gthc tlme ot the b ~ r t hand the nlottler had telt unsupported. In other cases there
PRECIPITANTS OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
95
were interfering relatives who undermined the mother's confidence. Sometimes the parents had moved house around the time of the baby's birth. In others, the mother was not living in her native country and felt lonely and uncertain. In other cases, mother and father were of different religious persuasions. Some mothers report the death of an earlier baby, or have had a previous miscarriage, the emotional effects of which were still being felt when the later, autistic child was in the womb and was born. Other mothers reported that an emotionally important person had died around the time of the child's birth. In an underconfident and distressed state such a mother is called upon to cope with an infant who, for various reasons, needs especially firm and confident handling. The situations which have just been described are not uncommon, and do not usually lead to autism in the child. For autism to develop, a special concatenation of circumstances has to occur. The primary caregiver's state of mind and that of the rest of the family will affect the developing mind of the baby. A mother who feels lonely and unsupported may be unable to respond adequately to her baby. She will not be able to absorb the inevitable shocks which impinge upon him, such as finding that the nipple is not a part of his mouth; changes from one biological state to another, such as teething; or environmental changes such as removal from one house to another, changes of babysitters, etc. One recovering autistic child spoke of his autism as a 'shock-proof habitat'. This prevented the impingement of shocks and kept him safe, 'safe' being the operative word. Autism is a reaction to promote a feeling of safety when the infant feels that this is not forthcoming from the outside world. As we know, the newly born infant needs extra-special attention. Winnicott (1958) has formulated this in his concept of 'maternal preoccupation'. Bion (1962a) has enshrined it in his notion of maternal 'reverie'. Masud Khan (1964) speaks of the 'protective shield'. This special kind of attention can be affected in various ways. Depression or harassment in the
96
AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
mother will affect the fantasies she has about her child both before and after birth. The baby may not seem to measure up to her expectations, or may seem to be the monster or handicapped creature she had feared she would produce, or may be idealized to such an extent that the mother feels that she is inadequate for such a wonderful being. Mothers with recent bereavements may be communing with departed spirits more than with their alive, human baby. This is bewildering to the child, who is called upon to comprehend something which is outside his comprehension. All these are inevitable human reactions on the part of both mother and child. We need to try to understand them rather than make moral judgements. If, in such circumstances, the child has autistic tendencies, the stage is set for mother and child to become cut off from each other. In some cases, something upsetting has also happened to the child which has set autistic reactions in train. Once these have been set going, they are difficult to reverse. Thus, he is a difficult child to rear. Now, having discussed distressing situations for the mother, let me turn to disturbing situations for the child which, when combined with other circumstances, may lead to autism.
Disturbing situations for the child In some cases, autism has arisen after or during a debilitating illness, or surgical intervention in infancy, especially if the limbs have been immobilized (Olin, 1975). But obviously there are many children who have suffered such experiences and who have not become autistic. It is clear that for autistic reactions to become established, a special combination of circumstances has to coincide. Important factors in this are the child's own constitutional tendencies and the emotional climate of the family in which he is reared. Also, it'seems that in situations of biological change the pangs of bodily separateness are likely to be reactivated, and thus may call forth autistic reactions. For example, De Astis and Giannotti (1985) report that they have had several cases
PRECIPITANTS OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
97
where autism became manifest at the onset of teething, although they suspect that there had been some fragility in the mother-child relationship before then. An interesting, as yet unpublished detailed observation of an infant by psychologist Shirley Gault (1983) has brought confirmation of the part that the advent of teething can sometimes play in provoking autistic reactions in a somewhat insecure nursing situation. This carefully documented observation shows how a seemingly normal baby met a mother who, due to various external circumstances, gradually became depressed. At weaning, and with the advent of dentition, it seemed as if the child were destined to be autistic. Many specialists were seen, and eventually deafness was diagnosed (wrongly, as it turned out later). This sent the already depressed mother into a downward spiral of increased depression. The baby resorted to inanimate objects, such as; leaves and a piece of muslin cloth, instead of responding to people. However, the encouraging fact about this sequence of observations, which covered the baby's first year of life, is that he was rescued from the downward slide into autism by his own resilience and by the vitality of his father and elder brother. Mother and baby again began to attend to each other, the baby no longer seemed deaf, and all now seems to augur well for the normal development of this baby. It has seemed to me that amongst other precocious developments caused by the trauma of bodily separateness, biting has developed prematurely in the infant who becomes autistic. For a variety of reasons, these children seem to become afraid of their savage biting impulses, and this may, in part, account for their restricted sucking. In a book as yet to be published, Josephine Klein has suggested another possible conjunction of factors which could contribute to the initiation of autism in a child. She suggests that a baby may be born with its sensory apparatus not yet ready for out-of-womb existence but which, over the first few days, or even over weeks and months, gradually matures to a normal
98 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S state. She suggests that by the time this maturation has occurred, the mother's confidence may have become so undermined by her baby's strange unresponsiveness that mother and baby never get together. Other autistic children seem to have suffered disturbances in utem, and so are born prone to be autistic even from birth. Grotstein (1983) has suggested that, as the result of the mother's depression, some of them may have suffered a 'biochemical assault in the amniotic bath'. Rubinfine (1962) has suggested that there could be excessive 'proprioceptive stimulation' in the womb or just after birth. Of course, the mother's fantasies about her unborn child will profoundly affect the developing foetus. The fact that disturbances in utem can lead to autistic-type reactions after birth was brought home to me by a case I supervised recently. This was a little girl who, at three years, was referred for psychotherapy because she had transitory autistic-like episodes in which she went stiff as if with terror, and was impervious to what was going on around her. The significant facts in her early history were that the mother became distressed towards the end of the pregnancy, and that the infant, when near to term, whilst still in the womb, had started to breathe and to defecate, behaviour which denoted foetal distress. Obviously, such a child will be difficult to rear after (s)he is born. A variety of situations can lead to autism. In the past, psychogenic hypotheses have been too simplistic and judgemental. It is clear that several different combinations of factors can result in an autistic picture of varying degrees of intensity. However, in all cases, the autism is an attempt to deal with intense elemental terror. The child freezes like a frightened animal. In every case, the crux of the situation is that mother and child have been prevented from getting together because the mother and child's interest in, and attention to, each other had been disturbed by factors such as have been described. Let me now discuss some of the consequences of this failure of mother and child to meet each other.
PRECIPITANTS O F PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
99
Consequences of the fuilure to meet Several writers have written of the way in which a happy mother and her responsive newborn baby heal each other from the caesura of birth by their sensuous interactions with each other (De Astis and Giannotti, 1980). But for a variety of reasons they may not experience that special psychological ambience, which is probably just as important for the mother as for the baby. If it is lacking it is a tragic situation for both of them; as also for the father, who plays his part in promoting this psychological healing and protection. All the tiny details of family life and infant care generate a healing atmosphere, and lack of it means that the child remains emotionally unattached to his parents. He does not grow emotional roots. Thus he suffers the loneliness of self-incarceration. He is cut off from all those responsive interactions which promote psychic growth. In infancy, the relevant interactions are activities such as sucking, eye-to-eye meetings, playful encounters and caresses. These are the physical bases for that communion between mother and baby which is the first form of communication. Without this the child remains uncouth and unnurtured. His psychic life is curtailed. Lacking adequate memories, he is left in the grip of agonizing terrors about losing his sense of existence - his 'going-on-being', as Winnicott has so aptly called it. Some of these terrors accrete around the basic inbuilt fear of falling. There is the terror of being 'dropped', of 'falling infinitely' (as Winnicott puts it), of 'falling apart', of 'falling to bits', of falling with a damaging bump. There are others such as spilling or dissolving away, or exploding away, or of losing the sense ofphysical continuity with an everlasting entity who is felt to guarantee the infant's existence. These 'nameless dreads', as Bion called them, will be discussed later in the book. For these children, also, the unhealed primary wound of bodily separation from the mother is again laid bare whenever further separation experiences impinge upon them; for example, when they become aware that the nipple of the breast (or
100 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
its substitute) is not a permanent part of their mouth - witness John's experience, cited in chapter 4. In the absence of healing, these traumatic wounds are 'scabbed' over by autistic practices which drive the child further and further away from the healing and humanizing influences of his family and his culture. As David Rosenfeld (1981) has shown, autism 'preserves the traumatic experiences so that they can be dealt with when propitious circumstances arise for doing so, but it does not promote integration. The child is left in a crude, unintegrated state. He does not develop a working simulation of reality which is effective for coping with the exigencies of the outside world in an ongoing way, nor with his own inner states. Let me discuss this further.
The representation of reality As we know, we can never be in touch with ultimate reality. We make a kind of analogue which helps us to function effectively. An important part of cognitive and emotional development is the creation of more and more effective working simulations of reality. In relatively normal development, on the basis of his own constitutional 'blueprint', the child absorbs the constructions of his family and of the culture in which he lives. In the first place, this absorption comes from interactions with the primary caregivers through all the tiny details of infant care. Thus the infant's state of mind, and that of the caregiver, are of paramount importance if progressive and effective working simulations are to develop. Due to a variety of combinations of unfortunate circumstances autistic children have become stuck in crude simulations arising from their inbuilt gestalts and their own bodily processes. Their behaviour becomes automatic and mechanical. I have also come to realize that this can happen in an isolated part of more normal individuals as well. The autistic part in neurotic patients I share Dr Sydney Klein's findings that many neurotic patients
PRECIPITANTS OF PSYCHOGENIC AUTISM
101
have an autistic split-off part to their personality. When they get in touch with this, the unhealed psychic wounds of primal separateness are exposed. These have driven them along the road of psychogenic autism, but in a less total way than is the case with the autistic child. Perhaps, even in normal development, such psychic wounds are never totally healed, but throughout life creative interactions promote their healing, to prepare the individual for the ultimate separation of death. Glazing over the wounds with autistic shapes and plugging them with autistic objects prevent this natural healing, because such manipulative activities impede the necessary creative interactions. Neurotic patients with such autistic barriers will be discussed and illustrated in Part Two of this book. In conclusion, let me say a few hopeful words about psychotherapy with psychogenic autistic states. Psychotherapy with psychogenic autism The events and circumstances which have been outlined as contributing to the development of psychogenic autism are only important in so far as they have affected the psychic situation of the patient. They are in the past. We cannot do anything about them. However, we may be able to do something about the patient's psyche. I have come to the conclusion that for the type of autism which has developed to deal with the unhealed psychic wounds of early infancy, psychotherapy is just what is needed. But this must be psychotherapy which is based on a thorough understanding of the nature of psychogenic autism, and its possible origins. In psychotherapy with such autistic states, be they partial or more total, a Pandora's Box opens up before us. If both patient and therapist have the courage to look into its depths, and if they have the resilience and patience to generate the necessary insights, it has been my experience that hope usually emerges from its inner darkness.
CHAPTER SIX
Autistic objects Once upon a time there was a person Almost a person. Somehow he could not quite see Somehow he could not quite hear He could not quite think Somehow his body, for instance, Was intermittent. Ted Hughes, 'A Bedtime Story', Crow
T
he chapter that follows is a considerably revised version of a paper which was originally published in the International Review of Psycho-Analysis (1980) 7:27-39. I n working with autistic children I have become aware of their perseverative use of certain objects, peculiar to each individual child, in sensation-dominated ways which impede mental and emotional development. These will be referred to as autistic objects.
Autistic objects Two clinical illustrations will now be given which exemplify the nature of autistic objects: At the beginning of treatment, an autistic ten-year-old boy called David used to bring a dinky car to every session. This car was clasped so tightly in the hollow of his hand that it left a deep impression when he took it out, In working with him it became
AUTISTIC OBJECTS 103 clear that the dinky car was felt to have magical properties to protect him from danger. As such, it was like a talisman or amulet. The difference between David's car and a talisman was that he felt that by pressing it hard into the hollow of his hand it became a hard extra bit to his body. Even if he placed it on the table, the deeply imprinted sensation remained, so that it was as if the car were still a part of his body to keep him safe. Another autistic child called Peter who was six years old at the beginning of treatment used to bring to his sessions a large keyring with over fifty keys on it. It became clear that he felt that this was a hard extra bit of his body. However, during the period when these children felt protected by their autistic objects they were impenetrable to my attempts to help them. Thus it seemed important to understand the nature of these objects and the possible origin of their use.
The nature of autistic objects An outstanding characteristic of autistic objects is that they are not used in terms of the function for which they were intended. Instead they are used in ways which are idiosyncratic to each child. For example, David did not push his dinky car along the table or play with it on the floor as a normal or neurotic child would have done. Peter did not use the keys to open cupboards or doors. He just carried them around. From a realistic point of view they were used in a way which was useless and meaningless; from the child's point of view it became obvious that they were absolutely essential. The hard metal trains and cars which some autistic children take to bed with them to put under their pillows are similarly not used in terms of their intended function as playthings. Nor can it be said that they are used for fantasy purposes. There is a 'let's pretend' quality in fantasy play and a realization of bodily separateness from the object which are lacking in the autistic child's use of his autistic objects. They have a bizarre and ritualistic quality and the child has a rigidly intense preoccupation with them, which is not a feature of fantasy play.
104 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS The objects which some autistic children spin obsessively have a similar quality. This brings me to another characteristic feature of autistic objects as used by autistic children. They have no fantasy associated with them. Psychogenic autism is a sensationdominated state, and autistic objects are sensation-dominated objects. As a result of the lack of fantasy, they are used in an extremely canalized and repetitive fashion. They are static and do not have the open-ended qualities which would lead to the development of new networks of association. They are the result of, and result in, repetitive circles of activity which become entrenched. Another typical feature of autistic objects is the seeming 'promiscuity' of their use. The keyring that Peter carried around with him had many keys on it. If one were lost, there was always another to replace it. David did not bring the same dinky car each time. At the beginning of his treatment, it was the hard sensation in the hollow of his hand which was important to him . Many dinky cars could give him the same sensation. Thus it did not matter which one he used. If one dinky car were not to be found, another one would do. Some autistic children have one autistic object which is used for a time in a stereotyped and ritualized way. It is then discarded, to be replaced by another which is used similarly. Thus over a period of time, there may be a succession of objects which have been used in turn, with an intensity which shuts out awareness of anything else. They are used, discarded and replaced by another one. If an autistic object is gone, the child is distressed as if he had lost a part of his body, but the object is soon replaced by another one which is experienced as being the same. However, it is important to realize that the autistic child's inability to tolerate the fact of loss comes from his having experienced excruciating distress about the seeming loss of an instinctually significant part of the nursing mother which had been felt to be part of his body (Winnicott, 1958; Mahler, 1961 ; Tustin, 1972). This loss was experienced as a loss of part of his
AUTISTIC OBJECTS
105
body and not'as the loss of the mother and her breast. It is this situation which has led to the obsessive use of objects which are experienced as if they are bodily parts. The foregoing discussion hints at another characteristic feature of autistic objects. The sensation-dominated state of the autistic child means that such children live in a globally apprehended world. This is very different from ours. We distinguish objects from each other by more than the mere sensation of their shape. We use other clues. Autistic children do not. Their responses are solely on the basis of contour and outline: meaning and function are not taken into account. Thus, at one time, Peter thought that the word 'boiler' was 'boy' with an extra bit to his body. This was not a bit of fun. He was very serious about what, to us, is an amusing misconception. Segal(1957) describes an adult schizophrenic patient who was also operating on this basis of meaningless 'clang' similarities. T o this patient, the piece of furniture called a 'stool' and his faecal 'stool' were equated because the same word was used for both. Another factor which comes into this discussion is that in autistic children the sensory modalities are not always clearly differentiated from each other. Thus, seeing and hearing are often experienced by the child in a tactile way as being touched by the object. Written words which have roughly the same shape are felt to be the same. This applies also to objects, pictures and sounds. This leads to what the observer designates as the concrete nature of the autistic child's experience. As his treatment proceeded David brought evidence of misconceptions which arose from the imprecise, tactile apprehension of the shapes of words. For example, an Aston Martin dinky car was felt to have in it the essence of the.village where he lived which was called Martin. An Austin car was felt to have in it the essence of Tustin. T o those people who have not worked with autistic children this might seem to be an example of rhyming or punning. But these are developed forms of expression when the individual has a sense of his bodily
106 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
separateness from other objects and has a normal perception of them. As he emerged from his autism, David was able to tell me that he had felt that the words 'Tustin' and 'Austin' must be the same because they were the same shape when they 'touched' his ears or eyes. In working with David, it was necessary to help him to realize that bringing the Aston Martin dinky car did not mean that he brought a bit of his village with him: nor did bringing and taking home the Austin car mean that he could carry Tustin around with him. A neurotic child would have used these cars to represent his feelings about his village and about himself. For David they did not represent his feelings. He felt them to be actual bits of Martin and of Tustin. This realization means that in the psychoanalytic situation we deal with such material very differently from the way we would approach it with a neurotic patient. Gradually, as David developed more sense of his bodily separateness from the outside world, it was possible to talk to him about his homesickness for Martin (he was in a small boarding school for autistic children), and his craving to have me always with him (quite literally in his pocket). T o have talked to him about this in the early days would have been meaningless to him because the dinky cars were autistic objects which shut out any sense of missing Martin or myself. An important part of modifying such children's pathological use of their autistic objects seems to be the realization on the part of people caring for the child that these objects are not experienced by him as substitutes for longed-for people. For him, they are that person because they give him the sensations he desires, the sensation of an object being of pre-eminent importance to him. Also, the desired sensation is not localized in any specific part of his body. For example, if the car gave him nice feelings in the hollow of his hand, it was the same as if it were in his mouth. However, even to use the word 'desire' in this context makes the communication inexact. Autistic children cannot become aware of needs, wants or desires because thky have little mental equipment to help them to bear the
AUTISTIC OBJECTS
107
frustration these feelings entail. Instead they use autistic objects. By these they avoid the suspense of waiting. The way in which these children provoke others in their environment to be as concerned as they are to have an autistic object readily available is a striking illustration of their power to keep the autism going and to get others to collude with it. Autistic objects bring almost instant satisfaction, and prevent the delay between anticipation and realization which, so long as the suspense can be tolerated, leads on to such symbolic activities as fantasies, memories and thoughts. Thus the autistic child continues to live in a bodily way, but his mental life is massively restricted. This is why many of these children function as mental defectives when first seen for clinical assessment. This pathological use of autistic objects results in the autistic child's lack of motivation and his lack of basic trust in the 'facilitating environment'. It is only when insightful caring gets through to him that he is able to begin to give them UP. 'Hardness' is a characteristic feature of most autistic objects. This gives the child the feeling that they keep him safe. Autistic chilren, because they lack experience of civilizing relationships with other human beings, feel constantly threatened with being attacked and hurt. They feel that their helpless bodies are a target for savage and brutal attacks. They particularly feel that the projecting parts of their bodies will be bitten off in very barbarous ways. The castration anxiety of neurotic children is mild as compared with the perils that autistic children feel they have to face. The main purpose of autistic objects (that is, objects used as part of the body to give reassuring and diverting sensations) is to shut out menaces which threaten bodily attack and ultimate annihilation. Hardness helps the soft and vulnerable child to feel safe in a world which seems fraught with unspeakable dangers, and about which he feels unutterable terror. These objects help to prevent the realization of bodily separateness, and to promote the delusion that impingements from the outside world are obstructed. One of the ways in
108 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
which they do this is by focusing attention on familiar bodily sensations rather than the strange 'not-me' outside world. But this is the sophisticated view of the observer and, in order to bring clarity to a discussion of undifferentiated states through the differentiated medium of words, it is necessary to distinguish the experience of the observer from the very different experience of the relatively undifferentiated child. For the child, an autistic object is primarily a sensation. But the observer is aware of the object which provokes the sensation. The observer distinguishes differences in objects which all seem to be the same to the child, who only distinguishes them in terms of the sensations they give him as they seem to touch his body. The pseudo-protection of autistic objects (or sensation objects) prevents the child from using and developing more genuine means of protection. In particular, it prevents him from getting in touch with the caring human beings around him who would help to modify his terrors. It keeps him trapped in a bereft state beset with fantastic terrors with no authentic means for these to be alleviated and modified. I have always been puzzled by the fact that some psychogenic psychotic children are reported as having been withdrawn from birth. Whilst writing this paper, it has occurred to me that these children may have chanced upon autistic objects very early in life and have thus been diverted from turning to the suckling mother. A depressed or underconfident mother would not be able to muster sufficient firmness and resilience to attract her infant away from the illusory delights of his sensation objects to the real enjoyments of her breast, which he gradually learns to use as separate from his body. In such a situation the use of autistic objects could become entrenched and pathological.
The on'gzns of pathological autistic objects Our understanding of the origins of autistic objects is helped if we realize that, at first, it is not the milk which is significant to the nursing infant, but the cluster of sensations experienced as
AUTISTIC OBJECTS
109
'mouth-encircled-nipple'. Nature baits the hook, as it were, and ensures that a lifegiving instinctual activity is also pleasurable. But things can go wrong here for many and varied reasons, which can be in different constellations in each nursing couple. The infant is then driven to obtain almost constant tranceinducing ecstasy from his own body to distract his attention from the unutterable pain of the outside world. Clinical work indicates that pathological autistic objects have their origin in hidden auto-sensuous activities which began in infancy. Autistic children often bite their compressed tongue, or the bunched-up pads of their cheeks. Or they wriggle their bottoms to feel the faeces in their anus. All these observations have been culled from the psychoanalytic situation, in which children demonstrate to the therapist what they are doing, or, when they can talk, they will tell her. The children may do other things to which I have not been alerted. As a rule, the caring adults are relatively unaware of these activities because they do not see them. This means that these auto-sensuous activities become more and more deviant and perverse, since outside agencies cannot modify them because they are unobserved. The infants who practise such activities become increasingly odd and eccentric. The autistic objects which such children use later, as if they are part of their bodies, seem to arise from this earlier pathology. This accounts for the idiosyncratic nature of pathological autistic objects. The need to shut out the outside world to the massive degree characteristic of the autistic child arises from a wide variety of situations, all of which seem to occur in infancy. According to my observations, a very common precipitating infantile situation for psychogenic childhood autism is a situation in which a particularly vulnerable child experiences a series of shocks at a time when his neuromental apparatus is not sufficiently developed to stand the strain. These occur in a nurturing situation which, at that particular time, for a variety of reasons, cannot help him to handle it, or cannot handle it for him. A sad situation which often seems to be the starting place for autistic
110 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS IN N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
withdrawal is a mother and baby who experience bodily separateness from each other as being torn violently apart and wounded (Bick, 1968). Autistic objects seem to plug the gap between the couple so that bodily separateness is not experienced. Unhappily, these delusions prevent a healing, reciprocal relationship between the couple from developing. They have meant that the child had sensation-dominated, inanimate artefacts which blocked his approach to the outside world, instead of human beings who facilitated the gradual development of a differentiated and differentiatingmedium for communication and interpretation.
The deleterious effects of the use of autistic objects Erikson (195 1) is trying to convey the notion of the deleterious effects of deviant auto-sensuousness when he writes that the infant 'will find his thumb and damn the world'. But this notion is not relevant to autistic chidren. In normal development, as Winnicott (1958) has shown, finding the thumb leads to exploration and enjoyment of the world outside the child's own body. Sucking the thumb or the fingers becomes associated with rich fantasies and ideas which enable the child to wait until more appropriate and authentic satisfaction comes. This is not the case with the infant who shows signs of psychogenic autism, in whom sucking has been virtually replaced by the clutching of hard autistic objects. Perpetual recourse to autistic objects means that autistic children have remained in a raw, unnurtured state relatively unmodified by the disciplining and humanizing elements of the nursing situation. They are at the mercy of elemental inbuilt patterns which are stereotyped and unmodified by experience. These are unregulated and have not been coordinated in the normal way. They also seem to be affected by atavistic elements. Such children feel threatened by predatory mouths and creatures. They feel they can be trodden underfoot like insects. They feel they are jostling with other creatures in a desperate effort to survive. It is rivalry 'red in tooth and claw'
AUTISTIC OBJECTS 111 and the hard autistic objects seem to be extensions of nails and teeth. The constant use of autistic objects means that the autistic child has little possibility of learning to tolerate frustration. When frustration impinges, tantrums pound through muscle and vein and cause the child to fear total annihilation. T o counteract this deadly terror he clutches a hard autistic object. This means he never learns to deal with frustration in a considered, thinking way. Such a child has also missed the 'practising' stage of normal infancy which takes place during the mother's absences. For example, when studying the language development of autistic children, Ricks (1975) found that many of them had missed the lalling and babbling stage of normal infancy. My own observations have shown that many of them have missed the normal sucking and mouthing stage when the child creates a working simulation of the breast. This simulation enables him to develop a more skilful and efficient use of the actual breast when it comes. In short, they have missed the early learning experiences associated with play. Such a child expects to do everything at the first attempt without any practice away from the actual situation. When he fails to do this, he desists from effort. This seems to be an important component in the passivity and lack of confidence of autistic children. They have missed the creative work of adjusting illusions, and developing fantasies which Winnicott's (1958) work on the transitional object and transitional phenomena has shown are a bridge to reality. Instead they use pathological autistic objects, which are a barrier to it. They block the apprehension of a reality which can be shared with other human beings in his culture. Nothing can get in but, more important still, nothing can get out. Such objects are the result of primary creativity having gone wrong. Such children's premature and shocking disillusionment means that they have had insufficient opportunities for illusion. Felt needs which are tolerable provoke anticipatory pictures (normal hallucinations) which prepare
112 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
the infant for what is to come. This is the beginning of hope. Instead of creating a valid working simulation of the breast which enables them to use it when it comes, autistic children have developed fake artefacts which replace the breast and for which they do not have to wait. (In neurotic development a rubber 'comforter', if over-used in an obsessive way, long past the time when it is usually given up, can become such a pathological autistic object.) Winnicott writes: 'The mother places the actual briast just where the infant is ready to create, and at the right moment' (Winnicott, 1958). However, as Winnicott well realizes, the 'good-enough mother' inevitably fails in this feat of adaptation to her infant. For the child who is developing normally, these 'failures' on the part of the mother are his opportunity for 'creating' anticipatory pictures and new responses to the mother. As in her absences, so in the times when she does not perfectly understand and meet his needs, he has opportunities for adjusting his anticipatory pictures and adapting to his changing perceptions of her. He learns to wait. H e learns to control his impulsiveness. H e begins to create ideas which are a substitute for the mother, but which do not obliterate his need for her, or inhibit his instinctual responses to her. H e begins to relate and respond to people and situations when they are not actually present. Thus, imagining and thinking develop. T h e frustration of unbearable disappointment means that instead of the creation of healthy illusions and hallucinations which lead on to dreams, fantasies and ideas, the infant begins to manipulate autistic objects in an excessive way. These, being tangible, sensation-dominated and ever-present, keep the child stuck at a primitive level of over-concretized mental functioning. Material objects become unduly important because they stimulate entrancing bodily sensations. Autistic objects develop to deal with unbearable frustration, but they prevent the development of thoughts, memorics and imaginations which, in normal development, in some measure, compensate for the inevitable lack of complete satisfaction w h ~ c hbeing a
AUTISTIC OBJECTS
113
human being entails. Another result is that the children themselves are vulnerable to being manipulated as autistic objects instead of being treated as human beings. The echopraxia of some psychotic children is an extreme example of this. Echolalia is a manipulation of words and sounds as if they are tangible physical objects in order to make them into 'me'. Thus, words can be autistic objects. This echolalic behaviour is often reinforced by the adults around them who, because of the children's non-responsiveness, repeat what they say to the children many times in an effort to attract their attention. This is a good illustration of the effect that such children have on their environment. As Stroh (1974) puts it, 'The parents are forced into walking the child's autistic way.' If, as therapists, we do this and unduly collude with the child's pathological, autistic use of objects, we leave him in the grip of his pathology with no possibility for developing genuine relationships characterized by effort and co-operation. If mother and child become autistic objects for each other, they live in a sensation-dominated cocoon in which they seem to fit each other predictably and perfectly. They become each other's ecstasy. Some autistic children come into treatment with a history of such an idyllic infancy. But the benefits from such an infancy are spurious. A beneficial feature of the bearable lack of fit of the 'good-enough mother' is that it provides a space in which chance happenings can occur. Such chance happenings are agents of transformation and change. The mother and child who become entrancing autistic objects for each other, so that they fit each other perfectly, prevent the possibility of such a space. This means that the child's mental development is massively stunted and goes awry, because agents of change are shut out. In my experience, the father in the family has an important part to play in supporting the nursing couple through the pains and tribulations aroused by the lack of perfect fit with each other, and the realization that they cannot absolutely control each other.
114 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
Such a child never experiences 'missing'. In his concretized mode of experience, absence of a needed person is experienced as a 'hole', which can be filled immediately with an autistic object. He experiences 'emptiness' and 'nothingness', which are different from missing a needed person. T h e persistent repetitiveness of some autistic children in psychotherapy may be the result of our undue collusion with their use of autistic objects. Also, if the analyst is unduly passive and malleable, he can become used as an autistic object. It is progress in the analysis of an autistic child when he begins to miss the analyst. Until this occurs, he has replaced the absent analyst with autistic objects which block any sense of lack and the consequent development of memories which compensate for this lack. Another deleterious effect of the undue use of autistic objects is that in times of extreme crisis hard autistic objects are liable to break under the strain, and to let the child down. This is due to their inflexible, rigid nature, which makes them brittle. It also comes from their being inanimate obects. Alive people can grow and change and be healed. They can recover from states in which they failed the child. Inanimate, inflexible autistic objects can seem to break irreparably. Also, autistic objects are cast in the mould of innate dispositions and in their formation have not been wrought by experience as, for example, the transitional object has been. T h u s they are more liable to snap and break. Such an irreparable breakdown is the source of the autistic child's despair. T h e autistic child (or the autistic child in all of us) is always trying to rubber-stamp the world in terms of rigid systems which seem to be safe. I n doing this, an endless succession of autistic objects is manipulated and these hamper genuine change and growth. Thus it is obvious that the study of autistic objects has implications far beyond the study of the serious mental illnesses of childhood which bring such tragedy to the families in which they occur. They can also bring tragedy to the societies in which we live. However, these wider implications -
AUTISTICOBJECTS
115
such as the part they play in bigotry and fanaticism - cannot be developed in this chapter, which is concerned with the development of autistic pathology in children.
Therapeutic implications of these understandings Firstly, in the therapeutic situation, this replacement of needed people by autistic objects which help the child to feel impenetrable and safe leads to behaviour on the part of the child which, to the outside observer, appears idiotic, but to the child seems essential. It is only by finding what such behaviour means to the child, and by entering and understanding his world, that we can help him. If we stand outside and merely describe it, we shall try to manoeuvre and manipulate him into our more normal ways of behaving. This will leave untouched and unmodified the rages and panics which give rise to his peculiar state. Also, if we ruthlessly deprive him of his autistic objects we shall expose a hypervulnerable child to unbearable terrors. T o cope with these he may develop an even more entrenched form of autism. Thus, the handling of the transition from the undue use of autistic objects to developing feelings of trust in the alive human beings around him needs consummate tact, patience and skill. It cannot be done in a hasty, mechanical way. We need to wait patiently for the appropriate moments when we can demonstrate to him that human beings, in spite of their unpredictability and mortality, give more long-term and effective support than these objects imbued with excessive auto-sensuousness. Secondly, the foregoing understandings concerning the nature, origins and functions of autistic objects enable us to take a compassionate but unsentimental view of psychogenic childhood autism. Those workers in the psychological and psychiatric field who propose inhumane methods for the treatment of these children may begin to realize that, behind such children's seeming lack of fear, there is a terror so great that it cannot be expressed. This needs to be put into words by the therapist who supports the child in experiencing it. This does
116 A U T I S T I C B A R R I E R S I N N E U R O T I C P A T I E N T S
not mean that unbridled abreaction is the order of the day. On the other hand, those educationists who are unduly permissive in their approach to these children may change some of their attitudes. Both they, and some psychoanalytic therapists, may become more active and rigorous in discouraging and even stopping pathological activities. Some objects may even have to be taken away from the child, so that he can develop more appropriate ways of relieving tension. Or, we may be more strict than we are with neurotic children about whether we allow a child to take toys home with him, or to bring toys from home to the consulting-room. However, any such action on our part needs to be associated with interpretations which show that we understand the meaning of such behaviour to the child. As well as being both more disciplined and disciplining in our technique in the consulting-room, recognition of the impeding efforts of autistic objects will modify the ways in which we couch our interpretations. This should make treatment more effective. As the child begins to feel held in our awareness by our thought, care and concern for him, he begins to hold experiences in his mind as thoughts, memories and imaginations. The undue use of autistic objects begins to wane. As Bion (1962a) has pointed out, the mother mediates sanity to the nursling as well as nourishing milk. By their sensible attention and behaviour, therapists can convey such sanity also. The feeling-tone of the therapeutic setting is of especial importance to autistic children. Thirdly, it has been my experience that an autistic object is often mistaken for Winnicott's transitional object. These understandings concerning the nature of autistic objects should help to prevent this. Confusion between autistic objects and the transitional object leads to mismanagement in both education and psychotherapy, in that the caring person colludes with the use of autistic objects instead of patiently and gently weaning the child from using them so inappropriately, by giving him more authentic means of protection. In terms of Winnicott's (1958) definition of the transitional object as 'the child's first
AUTISTIC OBJECTS
117
not-me possession', it can be said that autistic objects are elemental 'me-possessions'. They are not companionable objects as is the transitional object; their role being that of protection and escape from danger. Also, autistic objects are peculiar to each individual child, transitional objects such as teddy bears and comforting pieces of cloth being objects the like of which many other children use. That is, they have communality in their use (Winnicott, 1958; Gaddini, R., 1978). Fourthly, understanding the nature and function of autistic objects enables us to have a deeper understanding of the ways in which the development of the mental life of autistic children has been impeded. For example, we begin to realize that the autistic child's eccentric and impatient way of relieving himself by the persistent and pathological use of autistic objects has prevented him from learning the appropriate skills and techniques which he can share with other human beings in his culture. Thus, an educational setting in which, as autistic objects are given up, the child can begin to learn from experience and be'helped to make the basic distinctions and integrations which, in normal development, are taken for granted is a valuable adjunct to psychoanalytic therapy. In psychotherapy, we shall be more aware of such children's lack of, or shaky capacity for, symbol formation. Symbol formation is based on the capacity to use substitutes for actual things and situations. It is also based on the capacity to feel separate from the outside world and thus to use abstractions. The use of material objects which are felt to be part of his body and permanently to replace the real thing has prevented the autistic child from doing this. Thus, we shall not read into his behaviour the complicated fantasies and ideas which are encountered in neurotic children, but which are not possible for him. We shall realize that the complicated and esoteric interpretations which are sometimes given to autistic children do not convey to them the meaning they have for us, although they will probably feel 'touched' (quite physically) by our care and
118 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS interest. Paradoxically, a more sophisticated understanding will simplify our approach to these children. Fifthly, this understanding of the nature and origin of pathological autistic objects would seem to throw light on the perversions and also on the development of fetishistic objects. There have been attempts to relate Winnicott's concept of the transitional object to the development of fetishism (Greenacre, 1970), but findings from work with autistic children would seem to indicate that fetishistic objects have more in common with autistic objects than with transitional objects. T h e obsessive quality in the use of autistic objects also indicates that they could add to our understanding of the early beginnings of obsessional neurosis.
Conclusion In this chapter, human emotions such as love, hate, aggression, envy and jealousy have not been emphasized as being the main determinants of the child's behaviour. This is not because these feelings are thought to be unimportant, but clinical work with autistic children indicates that distress, panic, rage and predatory rivalry (Gaddini, E., 1969) need to be talked about with the child before interpretations about love, aggression, envy and jealousy will be meaningful to him. There is much evidence that autistic children have experienced an agony, of consciousness in early infancy in which these more sophisticated feelings were experienced precociously and in a compacted way. If we interpret these feelings too soon, before the child has the primal basis to distinguish and bear them, we shall reinforce the precocity which led to the development of an empty fake. Our aim is to help a sincere but tactful child to emerge from the artificial layers of autism with which he has felt protected. T o do this, we have to be in touch with basic elemental depths in ourselves.
CHAPTER SEVEN
Autistic shapes exemplified in childhood psychopathology Shape without form, shade without colour Paralysed force, gesture without motion T.S. Eliot, 'The Hollow Men', Collected Poems
T
his chapter is a revised version of a paper previously published in the International Review of PsychoAnalysis (1984) 11 :280-8. It seeks to study a phenomenon which certain autistic children have called 'shapes'. T h e nature and function of these 'shapes' is investigated, and also the part they play in autistic pathology. Finally, psychoanalytic therapy in which such 'shapes' play a part is described.
'Shapes ' In the days when I was working as a psychoanalytic child therapist with young autistic children, they would tell me, as they began to talk, about their 'shapes'. I knew that shape was important to such children because if they were testable at all (and most of them were not), the psychological tests on which they did best were those to do with the matching of shapes. But
120 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS I began to realize that the 'shapes' the autistic children were talking about to me were not those objective geometrical shapes which we all share. They were entirely personal shapes which were idiosyncratic to them, and to them alone. They were not the shapes of any particular object. They were just 'shapes', the circle being an especially comforting one for all of them. I do not know what other forms were covered by what they referred to as 'shapes', but I do know that it was the bodily 'feel' of such 'shapes' which mattered to the child. These 'shapes' brought in the rudiments of the notion of boundaries enclosing a space, although they themselves were not located in external space as are the shared geometrical forms to which we ordinarily give the name 'shapes'. As we shall see later, the feel of an object held loosely in the hand could be a 'shape'. When it was used in this way, the particular features which made it into a specific named object were not differentiated or attended to. It was not the shape of a specific object which existed in actuality; it was just a'shape'. I inferred that it had arisen from inbuilt dispositions in the first place. Later, we shall see that an autistic adolescent girl was concerned to produce a bipartite 'shape' whose two sides were symmetrical, whereas two shapes which exactly matched each other were important to an autistic young man. It is characteristic of autistic children that asymmetry, contraries, differences and lack of fit to shapes are unpleasant and are avoided. With the younger children the 'shapes' of sound, smell, taste and sight seemed to be 'felt' rather than heard, smelled, tasted or seen. Such children's consciousness is very restricted because what they take in is so restricted; 'touch' being an avenue of awareness which, in these younger autistic children, overrides other sense perceptions. Also, conscious and unconscious levels of functioning are scarcely differentiated, although, at times, these children can become agonizingly conscious as the outside world impinges unexpectedly. The children struggled to use words to tell me about these unverbalized experiences.
CHILDHOOD PSYCHOPATHOLOGY
121
It is a struggle for us to understand them. They seem so different from our own more differentiated experiences. However, let me make an attempt to describe their nature still further. T o do this, autistic shapes must first be differentiated from those that can be inferred to be normal ones.
Normal shape-making activities It seems likely that the normal human infant has an inbuilt disposition to form 'shapes'. These primary 'shapes' are likely to be vague formations of sensation. They would tend to offset the randomness of the flux of sensation which constitutes the infant's early sense of being. In the first place, these 'shapes' will occur without the child's intervention. However, the child will soon learn that he can make some 'shapes' recur Gy his own movements. Thus, as well as arising spontaneously, they will become self-induced. These early shapes arise from the 'feel' of soft bodily substances such as faeces, urine, snot, spit, the food in their mouths, and even vomit, some of these being elements for repeated experiences. However, it is the 'shapes' rather than the bodily substances which are important to the child. The bodily substances are merely shape-producers, In normal development, this shape-making propensity will soon become associated with the actual shapes of actual objects. This will result in the formation of percepts and concepts which facilitate a working relationship with objects in the outside world which can be shared with other people. Normal sensation shapes are the basic rudiments for emotional, aesthetic and cognitive functioning. If things go wrong here, then dire trouble is in store. This is what happened with autistic children. Austistic children's 'shapes' In autistic children, the shapemaking propensities have taken an atypical course which seriously hampers ongoing psychological development. Because their 'shapes' are unshared with other people, they become entirely personal and peculiar. They are much more contrived than those of normal children, their use of regurgitation of
122 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS food, for example, being similar to that of infants suffering from 'rumination' (Gaddini, R. and E., 1959). Their use of contrivances gives their functioning a stilted, mechanical quality. When they first come into treatment, young autistic children are usually not toilet-trained. At home some of them smear with their faeces, presumably making 'shapes' on their skin. When they become toilet-trained, they manipulate the faeces in their anus to make 'shapes' on the skin surfaces there (outside and inside of the body not being clearly differentiated). This is not to imply that, at this stage, the child does anything as developed as drawing a shape. It is the impression of a shape which these young children obtain on body surfaces. Nor are the skin surfaces differentiated clearly as such, they are merely the medium upon which the impression of 'shapes' arises, some surface media being more sensitive than others. The young autistic children told me that they wriggled or rocked their bodies to make 'shapes' from bodily substances. Spinning and swinging also produced them. The children also bubbled with the spit in their mouth or the snot in their nose. These bubbles were experienced as the 'felt' sensation of a circle, and not as a three-dimensional object located in external space. 1 presume that all the 'shapes' had this two-dimensional quality, although most of them would not have such a precise shape as that of a circle. (In discussing such elemental preimage manifestations which arose in his pyschoanalytic work with the psychosomatic disorders of adult patients, Eugenio Gaddini (1982) makes especial reference to the circle.) ' These autistic 'shapes' were also produced by non-bodily objects and processes experienced as if they were bodily ones. The 'felt' shapes produced on the child's bodily surfaces by these non-bodily objects and processes did 'not lead to their being shared with other people, as is the case with more normal children. The objects and processes were at the service of the autistic child's entirely personal idiosyncratic purposes. Like the bodily substances they were merely shape-producing
CHILDHOOD PSYCHOPATHOLOGY
123
agents. They scarcely existed in their own right for the child. Some young autistic children are so unaware of the actual existence of objects that they try to walk through them as if they did not exist. I n the same way, they listen to other people's voices, not as a communication but as a self-envelopment by lulling shapes. Thus they are often thought to be deaf before it is recognized that they are autistic. The children are capable of forming elementary percepts and concepts from their shapemaking propensities, but these are idiosyncratic to them, and they are not very interested in them; they are so captivated by 'shapes'. The non-bodily equivalents to bodily substances are such things as mud, sand, plasticine, clay, water, paint, and so on. As we shall see later, toys can also be used in this way. Also, we shall meet a thirteen-year-old girl who used arithmetical notation, and an eighteen-year-old young man who used the letters of the alphabet as equivalents to bodily processes. The necessary quality of these equivalents is that they lend themselves to being manipulated as 'shapes'. These 'shapes' are not the differentiated shapes of actual objects as we see and 'feel' them. Nor were the arithmetical and alphabetical processes used as we would use them. They were used as contrivances to produce the 'shapes' that the child wanted. Autistic children are 'stuck' in this peculiar mode of functioning. Very little ongoing psychological activity takes place. There was another important way in which the autistic child's 'shapes' were different from those of more normal children. They were repetitive and unchanging. Metaphorically speaking, they went round and round in an unbroken sequence. Unexpected, spontaneous 'shapes' which popped up out of the child's control were upsetting. They struggled laboriously to shut out the unexpected 'shapes' by trying to make the known and familiar ones recur again and again. They felt that things must not get out of their control. T o the child, bodily movements were felt to be all-powerful to produce known and familiar 'shapes'. These 'shapes' were also felt to be
124 A U T I S T I C BARRIERS I N N E U R O T I C PATIENTS
all-powerful in that they could make the child feel soothed and comforted or, if they got out of control -for example, a loud and unexpected noise hitting his ears - they could upset him. 'Shapes' had powerful effects upon his moods. He tyrannized over them and they tyrannized over him. He was enthralled by them. The child felt that the existence of the magical 'shapes' depended upon his activities, and that he depended upon their magical presence to give him a sense of 'being'. Just as the philosopher Bishop Berkeley felt that his'looking' created the world, so autistic children feel that their 'shapes' are all-powerful to create it. With the younger autistic children, these were primarily 'felt' shapes; with the older children sight became important also. Of course, we all create our world in that, in terms of our modes of perception, we construct a working simulation which helps us to function in what we quaintly call 'the real world'. We all share the experience of the Scandinavian god Odin who, at the beginning of time, before he could create the World, leaned over a bottomless chasm until the swirling mists below formed themselves into shapes. 'Shapes' are the primary means by which we create both our inner and our outer worlds. The trouble with autistic children is that their 'creation' is unduly 'quirky'. They have used the shape-making propensities of the human mind in their own, idiosyncratic way. The evolution of their construction has not been modified by co-operative interplay with other people. It is also unduly suffused with crude auto-sensuousness. This makes the children pick up the wrong cues for ongoing psychological development. They becoae trapped in a vicious circle from which they cannot escape. Only what they can easily manipulate seems real. 'Shapes' are easier to manipulate than actual objects used as actual objects, thus 'shapes' seem more real. This means that the activities of autistic children are mostly asymbolic. They do not play, dream, fantasize or imagine to any appreciable extent. It is progress when, in treatment, such a child has visual hallucinations. (The 'shapes' may be a kind of
125 tactile hallucination.) They do not suck their fingers or their thumbs. Nor does genital masturbation appear. It is progress when they do these things. It is great progress when they begin to play. Through lack of contact with other people's 'shapes', which could change and transform their 'shapes' into common coin, they are cut off from the enriching psychological possibilities of everyday life with ordinary people. Their thinking, if it can be called such, is restricted and meagre. Imagination is completely lacking. Speech is either absent or cripped by echolalia. Their emotional life is similarly muted, except on the rare occasions when it bursts forth in an explosive way which is terrifying to the child. In Greek mythology Morpheus, the son of the god of sleep, could change his shape at will. From this we get the term 'morphology'. Winnicott has suggested the term 'psychomorphology' for the study of psychological forms and shapes. This chapter concerns an aspect of psychomorphology which is concerned with non-objective shapes. We live in a world dominated by words and by the shapes of actual objects. In studying autistic children we have to try to enter a wordless world dominated by self-induced, amorphous, unclassified, concocted 'shapes'. Writing this chapter has brought home to me how difficult it is to cross the threshold into this world. The reader may be finding it as difficult as I did. T o help you to understand it, try a little experiment. Forget your chair. Instead, feel your seat pressing against the seat of the chair. It will make a 'shape'. If you wriggle, the shape will change. Those 'shapes' will be entirely personal to you. T h e autistic child's attention becomes so focused upon these entirely personal 'shapes' that the chair, as such, is not important to him, although he may be vaguely aware of its existence and may even know its name. Perhaps this has made it a little clearer. It may become clearer still when these 'shapes' are seen in action in actual children. CHILDHOOD PSYCHOPATHOLOGY
126 AUTISTIC BARRIERS IN NEUROTIC PATIENTS
Autistic 'shapes' in action T h e stereotypes which are so characteristic of autistic children are an exhibition of the child's shape-producing activities. Mrs Shirley Hoxter described a moving example of such a stereotype when she wrote as follows: On my way to the clinic, I drive past a couple who are slowly making their way along the pavement - apparently a father taking his twelve-year-old(?) daughter to school(?). Every now and again the girl stops, obviously immovable, she holds u p her hand, twists it and twiddles her fingers, gazing at it in entranced joy. Nothing else in the world exists and certainly there are not joys like this to be found elsewhere. Her father stands by, patiently waiting for long minutes like someone resigned to chronic, repeating spasms of pain. T h e eternity of suspended time is over. They proceed on their way for a few yards and then it is repeated. (personal communication) As I read this account, I feel full of sadness that the girl could not turn to her caring father for comfort and reassurance from her terrors, instead of resorting to her concocted, self-induced 'shapes'. But at twelve years of age this is likely to have become an established way of life. It would be very difficult to help her to change it. However, it has been my experience that it is possible to bring about changes if autistic children come into psychotherapy at under seven years of age or thereabouts. If such psychotherapy is to be tactful and sensitive, we need to understand some of the functions that 'shapes' have