ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research Review
How emotions affect eating: A five-way model Michael Macht Department of Psychology, University of Wu¨rzburg, Marcusstr. 9-11, 97070 Wu¨rzburg, Germany Received 18 April 2006; received in revised form 13 July 2007; accepted 16 July 2007
Abstract Despite the importance of affective processes in eating behaviour, it remains difficult to predict how emotions affect eating. Emphasizing individual differences, previous research did not pay full attention to the twofold variability of emotion-induced changes of eating (variability across both individuals and emotions). By contrast, the present paper takes into account both individual characteristics and emotion features, and specifies five classes of emotion-induced changes of eating: (1) emotional control of food choice, (2) emotional suppression of food intake, (3) impairment of cognitive eating controls, (4) eating to regulate emotions, and (5) emotioncongruent modulation of eating. These classes are distinguished by antecedent conditions, eating responses and mediating mechanisms. They point to basic functional principles underlying the relations between emotions and biologically based motives: interference, concomitance and regulation. Thus, emotion-induced changes of eating can be a result of interference of eating by emotions, a byproduct of emotions, and a consequence of regulatory processes (i.e., emotions may regulate eating, and eating may regulate emotions). r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Emotion; Eating; Mood; Emotional eating; Restrained eating; Motivation; Food choice
Contents Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Variability of emotion-induced changes of eating . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Variability across individuals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Variability across emotions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Previous theories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A five-way model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Food-induced emotions control food choice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Intense emotions suppress food intake . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Negative and positive emotions impair cognitive eating controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Negative emotions elicit eating to regulate emotions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Emotions modulate eating in congruence with emotion features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Emotion-induced eating in restrained and emotional eaters. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Emotion-induced eating in normal eaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 2 2 3 4 4 5 5 6 6 7 7 7 8 8
Introduction
E-mail address:
[email protected] 0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.07.002
Emotions serve distinct motivational functions and contribute essentially to control of basic behavioural
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
2
systems in animals and men (e.g. Frederickson, 1998; Frijda, 1986; Izard & Ackerman, 2000; Plutchik, 1984; Tomkins, 1963). Specific emotions such as anger, fear, sadness, and joy, as well as moods that are thought to last longer and be more diffuse (e.g. Ekman, 1992; Frijda, 1993) have been found to affect eating responses along the entire process of ingestion: motivation to eat (Macht & Simons, 2000), affective responses to foods (Ferber & Cabanac, 1987; Willner & Healy, 1994), food choice (e.g. Gibson, 2006; Oliver & Wardle, 1999), chewing (Macht, 1998), eating speed (Krebs, Macht, Weyers, Weijers, & Janke, 1996), amount ingested (Greeno & Wing, 1994 for a review), as well as metabolism and digestion (Blair, Wing, & Wald, 1991; Wing, Blair, Epstein, & McDermott, 1990). Surveys demonstrate that most people experience changes of eating in response to emotional stress (on average 30% an increase and 48% a decrease of appetite or intake, Table 1). Epidemiological data indicate that stress-related eating is associated with increased body weight (Laitinen, Ek, & Sovio, 2002). Not surprisingly, effects of emotions on eating have been studied extensively, but due to their variability it remains difficult to predict how an emotion affects eating in a given group of persons. Emotions can increase food intake in one group of persons, e.g. restrained eaters, but decrease food intake in another group, e.g. non-restrained eaters. Furthermore, different emotions may increase or decrease eating in the same group of individuals. For example, boredom may be associated with increased appetite, but sadness with decreased appetite (e.g. Pudel & Richter, 1980). This twofold variability (across individuals and emotions) has been neglected by previous research. Based on an individual difference model, it was mostly examined whether eating habits predispose people to increase food intake in response to negative emotions (Greeno & Wing, 1994). The present paper introduces an integrative model that takes into account both individual characteristics and emotion features. First, the empirical evidence on varia-
Table 1 Changes of eating in response to emotional stress reported in surveys Change of eating 11% more appetite, 70% less appetite 16% more appetite, 38% less appetite 25% more appetite, 32% less appetite 44% eat more, 48% eat less 4% eat more, 55% eat less 49% eat more, 51 do not eat more 55% eat more, 45% do not eat more 38% eat more, 42% eat less
N
Reference
364 1950
Krumbacher and Meyer (1963) Pudel and Richter (1980)
1024
Pudel (1984)
80
Willenbring et al. (1986)
475 500
Popper et al. (1989) Spillman (1990)
101
Weinstein et al. (1997)
212
Oliver and Wardle (1999)
bility of emotion-induced changes of eating is summarized briefly. Variability of emotion-induced changes of eating Variability across individuals A series of experiments showed that restrained eaters (as identified by questionnaire; e.g. Herman & Mack, 1975; Stunkard & Messick, 1985) consume more food than nonrestrained eaters in response to fear and negative mood states (for a review, see Greeno & Wing, 1994, also Heatherton, Striepe, & Wittenberg, 1998; Rotenberg & Flood, 1999; Rutledge & Linden, 1998; Tuschen, Florin, & Baucke, 1993). Restrained eating refers to a persistent pattern of eating-related cognitions and behaviours in order to reduce or to maintain body weight (Herman & Mack, 1975). Another experiment demonstrated that emotional eaters (also identified by questionnaire; van Strien, Frijters, Bergers, & Defares, 1986) consume more sweet, high-fat foods in response to emotional stress than non-emotional eaters (Oliver, Wardle & Gibson, 2000). Field studies showed that negative emotional states in everyday life can be associated with a tendency to eat as an emotion regulation strategy (Macht, Haupt, & Ellgring, 2005; Macht & Simons, 2000). Emotional eating is thought to be instigated in order to cope with negative emotions (Bruch, 1973; Kaplan & Kaplan, 1957). Probably, the influences of both eating habits are reflected in effects of emotions on binge eating. Negative emotions have been found to increase the tendency to binge in bulimia nervosa and the binge eating disorder (experiments: Agras & Telch, 1998; Cattanach, Malley, & Rodin, 1988; Chua, Touyz, & Hill, 2004; Gluck, Geliebter, Hung, & Yahav, 2004; Telch & Agras, 1996; field studies: Alpers & Tuschen-Caffier, 2001; Cooper & Bowskill, 1986; Davis, Freeman, & Garner, 1988; Johnson & Larson, 1982; Kenardy, Arnow, & Agras, 1996). Taken together, studies indicate that restrained eaters increase food intake, emotional eaters consume more sweet, high-fat foods, and binge eaters tend to binge in response to negative emotions. By contrast, normal eaters (i.e. normal-weight persons whose emotional and restrained eating scores fall within the normal range) are usually assumed to reduce food intake in response to negative emotions (Herman & Polivy, 1984; Schachter, Goldman, & Gordon, 1968). The evidence does not support this assumption. Table 2 summarizes experimental studies in normal-eating populations: 43% of the results indicate an increase, 39% a decrease and 26% no change of eating in response to emotions (as shown by Bellisle et al. (1990), in the latter studies possibly one part of the sample reduced and the other part increased food intake). Similarly, surveys and field studies showed that stress and negative emotions can be associated with both increased and decreased motivation to eat and food intake
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
3
Table 2 Effects of emotions on eating: experimental studies in normal subjects Effect
Eating measure
Emotion
Reference
Increase
Food intake
Negative mood Negative mood Fear Fear Fear Arousal Arousal Arousal Boredom Anger Arousal/stress Joy Joy Anger Negative mood Negative mood Fear Fear Fear Fear Fear Arousal Depressive mood Sadness Sadness Arousal Arousal Emotion Negative mood Negative mood Negative mood Negative mood Fear Fear Fear Fear
Lowe and Maycock (1988) Willner et al. (1998) Pine (1985) Pines and Gal (1977) Bellisle et al. (1990) Glass (1967) Cantor et al. (1982) Grunberg and Straub (1992) Abramson and Stinson (1977) Macht (1996) Ferber and Cabanac (1987) Macht et al. (2002) Macht et al. (2002) Macht (1996) Willner et al. (1998) Baucom and Aiken (1981) Schachter et al. (1968) Herman and Polivy (1975) Heatherton et al. (1991) Herman et al. (1987) Bellisle et al. (1990) Grunberg and Straub (1992) Willner and Healy (1994) Macht et al. (2002) Macht et al. (2002) Macht (1998) Macht (1998) Reference Frost et al. (1982) Tuschen et al. (1993) Telch and Agras (1996) Ruderman (1985) Reznick and Balch (1977) Heatherton et al. (1991) Schotte et al. (1990) Cools et al. (1992)
Hedonic responses Motivation to eat
Decrease
Chocolate craving Food intake
Hedonic responses Motivation to eat
Effect No effect
Chewing Eating measure Food intake
(Table 1; de Castro, 1986; Hill, Weaver, & Blundell, 1991; Macdiarmid & Hetherington, 1995; McCann, Warnick, & Knopp, 1990; Michaud et al., 1990; Pollard, Steptoe, Canaan, Davies, & Wardle, 1995; Rosenfield & Stevenson, 1988; Slochower, 1983; Steptoe, Lipsey, & Wardle, 1998; Stone & Brownell, 1994; Striegel-Moore et al., 1999; Wardle, Steptoe, Oliver, & Lipsey, 2000; Weidner, Kohlmann, Dotzauer, & Burns, 1996). Based on this evidence, it is difficult to predict how normal eaters change eating in response to emotions. Variability across emotions Dimensions used to classify emotions, namely valence (pleasure–displeasure), arousal (e.g. Greenwald, Cook, & Lang, 1989; Russell & Feldman Barrett, 1999) and intensity (Frijda, Ortony, Sonnemans, & Clore, 1992), have been found to make an essential contribution to variability of emotion-induced changes of eating. There is clear evidence that emotions differing in valence and arousal or intensity exert different influences on eating.
Animal studies point to a role of intensity for the direction of effects of emotional stress on food intake. Rats decrease food intake during intense noise (Alario, Gamallo, Beato, & Trancho, 1987; Pare´, 1964), in response to intense electric shock (Strongman, 1965; Weiss, 1968), and during chronic stress (Sampson, Muscat, Philips, & Willner, 1992; Willner, Muscat, & Papp, 1992), but increase food intake or eating speed in response to low or moderate noise and electric shock (Krebs et al., 1996; Kupferman, 1964; Rasbury & Shemberg, 1971; Sterritt, 1962, 1965; Sterritt & Shemberg, 1963; Strongman, Coles, Remington, & Wookey, 1970; Ullman, 1951, 1952). Results of a human study correspond to these data (Mehrabian, 1980). Participants imagined themselves in various emotions and reported how much they would eat during each of these emotions. Compared with low-arousal states (e.g. boredom, depressive mood) high-arousal states (e.g. tension, fear) were reported to inhibit food intake. These results support the view that high-arousal or intense emotions decrease food intake whereas low- to moderate emotions may increase food intake (Robbins & Fray, 1980).
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
4 Table 3 Previous models of emotion-induced changes of eating Type of model
Explained phenomenon
Mediating mechanism
Scope
Reference
Psychological models
Increased food intake in response to emotions dto. Increased food intake in response to negative emotions
Disinhibition of restrained eating
Restrained eaters
Impairment of cognitive capacity Reduction of negative emotions by eating
Restrained eaters Emotional eaters
Binge eating
Escape from aversive self-awareness
Decreased food intake in response to stress and fear Decreased hedonic reactions during chronic mild stress Eating induced by tail-pinch Increased eating speed in a stressful environment
Antagonistic physiological stress responses Reduced brain dopamine
Restrained eaters, bulimics Animals, humans
Herman and Polivy (1984) Boon et al. (2002) Bruch (1973), Slochower (1983), Booth (1994) Heatherton and Baumeister (1991) Schachter et al. (1968) Willner et al. (1992)
Physiological models
Biological models
Eating bouts in response to arousal and frustration
Animals, humans
Activation of endogenous opiates Disposition to ensure energy supply
Rats Animals
Reduction of arousal through eating
Animal, humans
Human studies demonstrated that positive and negative emotions could differ markedly in their effects on eating. Negative emotions such as anger, fear, and sadness may increase impulsive eating (i.e. fast and irregular eating directed at any food available), eating to regulate the emotional state and consumption of junk food, but decrease food pleasantness. By contrast, joy and other positive emotions increase food pleasantness and consumption of healthy foods (Lyman, 1982; Macht, 1999; Macht, Roth, & Ellgring, 2002). To summarize, high-arousal or intense emotions suppress eating, and negative emotions can increase or decrease food intake. Little is known about effects of positive emotions on eating and about differences between negative emotions such as anger, sadness and fear in their effects on eating. Clinical studies indicate that anger is an important antecedent of binge eating (Arnow, Kenardy, & Agras, 1992). It has also been suggested that disgust contributes to the maintenance of pathological eating patterns and may complicate attempts to normalize eating (Troop, Treasure, & Serpell, 2002). Previous theories During the past decades, a number of theories have attempted to explain the manifold effects of emotions on eating. Whereas emotion-induced increase of food intake was explained by psychological mechanisms (Bruch, 1969, 1973; Heatherton & Baumeister, 1991; Herman & Polivy, 1984; Slochower, 1983), physiological mechanisms were proposed to explain emotion-induced decrease of intake (Herman & Polivy, 1984; Schachter et al., 1968; Willner, 1997). Biologically oriented theories emphasized the adaptive function of changes of feeding behaviour in stressful situations (Cantor, 1981; Lima, 1987; Whishaw, Dringenberg, & Comery, 1992). As can be seen from
Morley et al. (1983) Lima (1987), Whishaw et al. (1992) Cantor (1981)
Table 3, previous theories aim at different phenomena, propose different mediating mechanisms and differ in scope. It has been a major problem for research that theories were mostly treated separately. Therefore, a general framework is provided in the following. It is suggested that emotions affect eating in five basic ways, which encompass phenomena addressed by previous theories. A five-way model As shown above, a number of factors were identified that make an essential contribution to emotion-induced changes of eating: arousal/intensity, valence and food relatedness of emotions as well as restrained and emotional eating. Taking into account these factors as antecedents, effects of emotions on eating can be classified into five basic classes: (1) Emotions aroused by food stimuli affect food choice. (2) Emotions high in arousal or intensity suppress eating due to incompatible emotional responses. (3) Emotions moderate in arousal or intensity affect eating depending on motivations to eat: (a) In restrained eating, negative and positive emotions enhance food intake due to impairment of cognitive control. (b) In emotional eating, negative emotions elicit the tendency to be regulated by eating and, as a consequence, enhance intake of sweet and high-fat foods. (c) In normal eating, emotions affect eating in congruence with their cognitive and motivational features. The flow diagram in Fig. 1 gives a visual presentation.
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
5
Emotion
Food-induced emotion?
yes
Control of food choice
Preference Craving Avoidance
Suppression
Decreased food intake
Restrained eating
Impairment of cognitive eating controls
Increased food intake
Emotional eating
Eating to regulate emotions
Increased intake of sweet, high-fat foods
no
yes Intense emotion?
no
Eating habits related to emotions?
yes
no
Emotion features relevant to eating?
yes
Congruent modulation
Change of eating congruent with emotion features
no
No change of eating
Fig. 1. A flow diagram to predict basic classes of emotion-induced changes of eating.
Emotions of low arousal or intensity are not expected to affect eating. In the following, each class is described in detail. Food-induced emotions control food choice Food-induced emotions are powerful determinants of food choice (Galef, 1996; Martins & Pliner, 2005; Rozin & Schulkin, 1990). Tasting energy-dense food such as sugar and fat evokes positive affective responses that promote ingestion, whereas tasting bitter compounds, which are correlated with toxins, evokes negative affective responses that promote rejection (Rosenstein & Oster, 1988; Steiner, 1979). The biological basis of these affective reactions is demonstrated in homology across primate species (Steiner, Hawilo, Glaser, & Berridge, 2001). Notably, food-induced emotional responses encompass full-blown emotions, in particular, neophobia and disgust (Raudenbush & Frank, 1999; Rozin & Fallon, 1987). Appetitive food-related stimuli can elicit a strong desire to eat or craving that can be conceived as an additional variant of food-induced emotions. Such craving co-occurs with a number of autonomic responses (Nederkoorn,
Smulders, Havermans, & Jansen, 2004; Nederkoorn, Smulders, & Jansen, 2000) which vary across individuals and can contribute to binge eating (Jansen, 1998). A number of studies demonstrated heightened cue reactivity in restrained eaters, binge eaters and bulimics as compared to controls (Carter, Bulik, McIntosh, & Joyce, 2001; Federoff, Polivy, & Herman, 2003; Karhunen, Lappalainen, Tammela, Turpeinen, & Uusitupa, 1997; Staiger, Dawe, & McCarthy, 2000), although lack of differences between groups has also been reported (e.g. Klaijner, Herman, Polivy, & Chhabra, 1980; Overduin, Jansen, & Eilkes, 1997). It is important to recognize that in some persons by contingent pairing of emotions and eating, emotions may become food-related cues and thus elicit eating (Booth, 1994). Intense emotions suppress food intake Animal studies demonstrated that intense or chronic stress sharply decreases food intake (for reviews see Greeno & Wing, 1994; Robbins & Fray, 1980, Section ‘‘Variability across emotions’’). Consequently, it was proposed that a decreased food intake is the ‘‘natural’’ response to stress
ARTICLE IN PRESS 6
M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
(Herman & Polivy, 1984; Schachter et al., 1968). In fact, intense emotions are linked with both behaviours and physiological responses that interfere with eating. For example, intense sadness is associated with behavioural deactivation and withdrawal from the environment. Intense fear motivates flight and avoidance, and is also associated with autonomic responses inhibiting motivation to eat. Stress-induced physiological changes may interfere with digestion by delaying glucose absorption and gastrointestinal transit (Blair et al., 1991; Wing et al., 1990). Negative and positive emotions impair cognitive eating controls Restraint theory suggested that emotional stress disinhibits dietary restraint and therefore increases food intake (Herman & Polivy, 1984). In this view, negative emotions were thought to undermine restrained eaters’ ability to continue dieting, because they impose a ‘‘more urgent concern (i.e., how to cope with the stressor) than even dieting’’ and lead to eating ‘‘as if the diet boundary had been knocked down’’ (p. 152). The diet boundary was conceived as ‘‘the dieter’s self-imposed quota for consumption on a given occasion’’ (p. 149). Although this appeared to be a plausible explanation, the common experimental design comparing individuals with high or low scores on restraint scales was not appropriate to test putative mediating mechanisms (Greeno & Wing, 1994). An alternative explanation was suggested by Boon, Stroebe, Schut, and Jansen (1998). According to their ‘‘limited capacity hypothesis’’, restrained eaters’ food intake is increased, if their cognitive capacity to maintain restricted food intake is limited by distraction (be it emotional or not). Processing of emotional stimuli requires attention, and since cognitive capacity is limited, cognitive control over eating may be impaired. The overeating response was attributed to ironic processes, i.e., the more people exert cognitive control, the higher their vulnerability to overeating will be. A number of experimental studies supported this assumption (Boon, Stroebe, Schut, & IJntema, 2002; Boon et al., 1998; Lattimore & Caswell, 2004; Lattimore & Maxwell, 2004; Vreugdenberg, Bryan, & Kemps, 2003; Wallis & Hetherington, 2004; Ward & Mann, 2000). Negative emotions elicit eating to regulate emotions Emotional eating theory suggested that certain individuals eat in order to cope with stress and are therefore at risk of becoming obese (Bruch, 1969, 1973; Kaplan, 1957; Slochower, 1983). As the German colloquialism ‘‘Kummerspeck’’ (literally: fat of sorrow) shows, it is a popular view that emotional eating causes obesity. Although this view proved to be over-simplistic (Greeno & Wing, 1994), evidence did emerge for a role of emotional eating in a subgroup of obese persons. Obese binge eaters experience an increased tendency to binge in negative mood (Agras &
Telch, 1998; Gluck et al., 2004) and can be treated successfully by improving their skills to regulate emotions (Telch, Agras, & Linehan, 2001; Wiser & Telch, 1999). Moreover, studies indicate that healthy, normal-weight persons regulate negative emotions by eating (Macht, 1999; Macht et al., 2005; Macht & Simons, 2000). Emotional eating theory originated from psychodynamic thinking, but can be related to a number of more recent approaches. The core assumption of the theory (i.e., that negative emotions induce eating and are, as a result, reduced) has been viewed from a learning perspective, with negative emotions as eliciting stimuli, eating as operant behaviour, and its consequence, the eating-induced reduction of negative emotions, as negative reinforcement (Booth, 1994). Regulation was also taken into account by biological approaches which conceptualized arousalinduced eating as ‘‘adjunctive behaviour’’ or ‘‘displacement activity’’ that reduces arousal (Cantor, 1981). Finally, eating has been viewed as a strategy to improve negative mood (Thayer, 1989, 2001), to mask stress (masking hypothesis; Polivy & Herman, 1999), or to escape from aversive self-awareness (escape theory; Heatherton & Baumeister, 1991). In spite of its popularity and plausibility, the concept of emotional eating does however face some unresolved problems. Above all, the underlying mechanisms are far from clear. Usually, nutrient-dependent physiological changes are proposed to mediate mood-elevating effects of eating. Carbohydrate-rich meals may lead to a postprandial improvement of mood (for reviews see Benton & Donohoe, 1999; Christensen, 1993, 1997; Gibson & Green, 2002) and also to reduced stress responses in emotionally labile subjects (Markus, Panhuysen, & Tuiten, 1998). These effects were explained by meal-induced increase of brain serotonin availability (Wurtman, 1982). However, relatively small proportions of protein in a meal may deteriorate the increase of tryptophan levels at the blood–brain barrier and, thus, an increase of brain serotonin. Since most carbohydrate-rich meals in everyday life contain some protein, the ecological validity of the serotonin hypothesis can be questioned (Benton, 2002). Another physiological mechanism is suggested by animal data demonstrating that ingestion of high fat and carbohydrate ‘‘comfort foods’’ (Wansink, Cheney, & Chan, 2003) reduces activity of the hypothalamo-pituitary– adrenal axis and dampens stress responses (Dallman et al., 2003). The main problem with both the serotonin and the endocrine hypothesis is that emotional effects of eating can occur only with delay. Such delayed effects might be useful for coping with chronic stress, but not for responding to negative emotions, as they arise from unpredictable stimuli such as daily hassles. In order to cope with these emotions, it would be most efficient to reduce their intensity immediately. Indeed, sweet solutions have been shown to rapidly calm stress responses in human newborns (Smith, Fillion, & Blass, 1990). Similarly, in adults, experimentally
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
induced negative mood is improved immediately and selectively after eating palatable food, and this effect is most pronounced in persons scoring high on emotional eating (Macht & Mu¨ller, 2007). This suggests that immediate positive affective reactions elicited by palatable foods diminish the impact of stress. Additionally, it may be important here that eating distracts from the experience of negative emotions (Spitzer & Rodin, 1983). One might speculate that immediate effects of eating based on hedonistic mechanisms and distraction, play a major role in the regulation of everyday emotions and constitute a common phenomenon that applies to the general population. By contrast, in binge eating, immediate hedonic effects may be backed up or substituted by delayed and long-lasting physiological effects of chronic high fat and carbohydrate consumption. Emotions modulate eating in congruence with emotion features During negative mood, negative verbal information is retrieved more readily than positive information, and conversely, positive information is retrieved more readily during positive mood (for a review, see Berkowitz, 2000, pp. 78–83). This congruency effect was also shown for recognition of palatable and unpalatable food flavours (Pliner & Steverango, 1994) as well as for emotion-induced changes of eating. Sadness has been found to decrease and joy to increase food pleasantness and motivation to eat (Macht et al., 2002; Willner & Healy, 1994). These changes can be explained by emotion features. Sadness is associated with a slowing of cognitive processes and motor activity (Izard & Ackerman, 2000), with an absence of interest (Frijda, 1986, p. 22), and with a lowering of attention to the outside (Barr-Zisowitz, 2000). By contrast, joy is associated with an increased capability to perceive and process stimuli and an increased readiness to engage in activities (Frederickson, 1998; Frijda, 1986; Izard & Ackerman, 2000). Such emotion-congruent changes of eating can be conceived as a by-product of emotional activation, and should mostly occur, if emotions are elicited during eating. Discussion The present paper proposes five basic classes of emotioninduced changes of eating that can be predicted by antecedent conditions and point to basic functional principles relating emotions and eating. Depending on emotion features and eating habits emotion-induced changes of eating can be a result of interference (suppression of food intake; impairment of cognitive eating controls), a by-product of emotions (emotion-congruent modulation of eating), and a consequence of regulatory processes (emotional control of food choice; eating to regulate emotions). Future research may examine whether these principles can be applied to relations between emotions and other biologically motivated behaviours
7
such as thirst, sex and aggression. To improve understanding of the manifold effects of emotions on eating research has to disentangle mediating mechanisms and to identify relations between classes of emotion-induced changes of eating. In particular, two problems remain to be resolved. Emotion-induced eating in restrained and emotional eaters Negative emotions increase food intake in restrained eaters as well as intake of sweet, high-fat food in emotional eaters (Section ‘‘Variability across individual’’). To explain these findings, it was suggested that emotional eaters eat to reduce negative emotions. By contrast, restrained eaters were thought to increase food intake, because emotions impair cognitive control over their restricted eating pattern (Sections ‘‘Negative and positive emotions impair cognitive eating controls’’ and ‘‘Negative emotions elicit eating to regulate emotions’’). Although restrained and emotional eating appear to reflect different neurobiological processes (Volkow et al., 2003), it remains unclear whether increased consumption in response to emotions is in fact mediated by different mechanisms in restrained and emotional eaters. The present model suggests two ways to test empirically the assumption of different mechanisms. First, emotional and restrained eaters should differ in their eating responses to various emotions and stressors. Provided that cognitive control of eating can be impaired by a variety of influences, restrained eaters should increase food intake in response to both negative and positive emotions and also to cognitive demand. By contrast, emotional eaters should increase eating only in response to negative emotions. Second, emotioninduced eating should exert different effects on emotional state in emotional and restrained eaters. Consistent with the assumption that emotional eaters increase food intake to reduce negative emotions, they can be expected to report reduced negative emotions due to eating. By contrast, restrained eaters should experience no change of mood due to emotion-induced eating or may even report deterioration of mood (because of fear to gain weight). There is some evidence supporting these predictions. Restrained eaters have indeed been shown to increase food intake not only in response to negative emotions, but also to positive emotions (Cools, Schotte, & McNnally, 1992; Tuschen et al., 1993) and cognitive demand (e.g. Wallis & Hetherington, 2004); it remains, however, to be examined whether emotional eaters’ intake can also be increased by positive emotions and non-emotional stressors. Also, improvement of experimentally induced negative mood by eating has been found to be correlated with emotional, but not with restrained eating (Macht & Mu¨ller, 2007). In spite of this evidence, however, more studies comparing emotion-induced changes of eating in restrained and emotional eaters are needed.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 8
M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
Emotion-induced eating in normal eaters
References
In normal eaters, negative emotions decrease or increase food intake. The five-way model explains decreased intake, depending on emotion intensity, by emotion-congruent modulation (Section ‘‘Intense emotions suppress food intake) or emotional suppression of eating (Section ‘‘Emotions modulate eating in congruence with emotion features’’), but it remains unclear how to explain increased intake in normal eaters. To understand this phenomenon, it should be recognized that emotional and restrained eating are regarded as continuous variables and that persons are classified as emotional or restrained eaters, if they score high on these continua. For example, emotional eaters may be defined as lying above the 80th percentile of scores in the most appropriate norm group (van Strien, 2002; personal communication). These persons can be expected to eat in order to regulate negative emotions frequently and consistently across situations. Presumably, a high proportion of their meals and snacks is based on the motivation to eat in order to cope with negative emotions. Persons with low scores of the emotional eating scale (e.g. below the 50th percentile) can be expected to experience this motivation, if at all, less frequently and less consistently. However, normal eaters with moderate emotional eating scores (e.g. between the 60th and 80th percentile) may occasionally also eat to cope with negative emotions. In these persons, a transient tendency to regulate emotions by eating may enhance consumption during emotions, although they are not classified as emotional eaters. It has indeed been demonstrated that normal eaters increase motivation to regulate emotions by eating in response to negative emotions induced in the laboratory (Bekker, van de Meerendonk, & Mollerus, 2004) and experienced in everyday life (Macht et al., 2005; Macht & Simons, 2000). Similarly, normal eaters may occasionally restrict eating, although they do not score very high on restraint scales, and thus enhance their susceptibility to emotion-induced eating. It can therefore be assumed that normal eaters increase intake due to transient shifts in motivations to eat. In other words, impairment of cognitive eating controls and emotion regulation eating (Sections ‘‘Negative and positive emotions impair cognitive eating controls’’ and Negative emotions elicit eating to regulate emotions) may occasionally also occur in normal eaters. Future research is needed to test the hypothesis that transient shifts in motivations to eat enhance susceptibility in normal eaters to increase intake in response to emotions. A suitable starting point for an experimental approach could be a study by Willner et al. (1998), who reinforced responses with chocolate under a progressively increasing work requirement and showed that craving for and intake of chocolate were increased by depressive mood. It remains to be examined whether the linking of operant responding for food and depressive mood can transiently increase motivation to eat in order to regulate mood in persons not classified as typical emotional eaters.
Abramson, E. E., & Stinson, S. G. (1977). Boredom and eating in obese and non-obese individuals. Addictive Behaviors, 2, 181–185. Agras, W. S., & Telch, C. F. (1998). The effects of caloric deprivation and negative affect on binge eating in obese binge-eating disordered women. Behavior Therapy, 29, 491–503. Alario, P., Gamallo, A., Beato, M. J., & Trancho, G. (1987). Body weight gain, food intake and adrenal development in chronic noise stressed rats. Physiology & Behavior, 40, 29–32. Alpers, G. W., & Tuschen-Caffier, B. (2001). Negative feelings and the desire to eat in bulimia nervosa. Eating Behaviors, 2, 339–352. Arnow, B., Kenardy, J., & Agras, W. S. (1992). Binge eating among the obese: A descriptive study. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 15, 155–170. Barr-Zisowitz, C. (2000). ‘‘Sadness’’—Is there such a thing? In M. L. J. M. Haviland (Ed.), Handbook of emotions (2nd ed., pp. 607–622). New York: Guilford Press. Baucom, D. H., & Aiken, P. A. (1981). Effect of depressed mood on eating: Among obese and nonobese dieting and nondieting persons. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 41, 577–585. Bekker, M. H. J., van de Meerendonk, C., & Mollerus, J. (2004). Effects of negative mood induction and impulsivity on self-perceived emotional eating. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 36, 461–469. Bellisle, F., Louis-Sylvestre, J., Linet, N., Rocaboy, B., Dalle, B., Cheneau, F., et al. (1990). Anxiety and food intake in man. Psychosomatic Medicine, 52(4), 452–457. Benton, D. (2002). Carbohydrate ingestion, blood glucose and mood. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Review, 26, 293–308. Benton, E., & Donohoe, R. T. (1999). The effects of nutrients on mood. Public Health Nutrition, 2, 403–409. Berkowitz, L. (2000). Causes and consequences of feelings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Blair, E. H., Wing, R. R., & Wald, A. (1991). The effect of laboratory stressors on glycemic control and gastrointestinal transit time. Psychosomatic Medicine, 53, 133–143. Boon, B., Stroebe, W., Schut, H., & IJntema, R. (2002). Ironic processes in the eating behaviour of restrained eaters. British Journal of Health Psychology, 7, 1–10. Boon, B., Stroebe, W., Schut, H., & Jansen, A. (1998). Food for thought: Cognitive regulation of food intake. British Journal of Health Psychology, 3, 27–40. Booth, D. A. (1994). Psychology of nutrition. London: Taylor & Francis. Bruch, H. (1969). Hunger and instinct. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 149, 91–114. Bruch, H. (1973). Eating disorders. Obesity and anorexia nervosa. Riverside: Behavior Science Book Service. Cantor, M. B. (1981). Bad habits: Models of induced ingestion in satiated rats and people. In S. Miller (Ed.), Behavior and nutrition. Franklin Institute Press. Cantor, M. B., Smith, S. E., & Bryan, B. R. (1982). Induced bad habits: Adjunctive ingestion and grooming in human subjects. Appetite, 3, 1–12. Carter, F. A., Bulik, C. M., McIntosh, V. V., & Joyce, P. R. (2001). Changes in cue reactivity following treatment for bulimia nervosa. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 29, 336–344. Cattanach, L., Malley, R., & Rodin, J. (1988). Psychologic and physiologic reactivity to stressors in eating disordered individuals. Psychosomatic Medicine, 50, 591–599. Christensen, L. (1993). Effects of eating behavior on mood: A review of the literature. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 14, 171–183. Christensen, L. (1997). The effect of carbohydrates on affect. Nutrition, 13, 503–514. Chua, J. L., Touyz, S., & Hill, A. J. (2004). Negative mood-induced overeating in obese binge eaters: An experimental study. International Journal of Obesity, 28, 606–610.
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11 Cools, J., Schotte, D. E., & McNnally, R. J. (1992). Emotional arousal and overeating in restrained eaters. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 101, 348–351. Cooper, P. J., & Bowskill, R. (1986). Dysphoric mood and overeating. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 25, 155–156. Dallman, M. F., Pecoraro, N., Akana, S. F., la Fleur, S. E., Gomez, F., Houshyar, H., et al. (2003). Chronic stress and obesity: A new view of ‘‘comfort food’’. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 100, 11696–11701. Davis, R., Freeman, R. J., & Garner, D. M. (1988). A naturalistic investigation of eating behavior in bulimia nervosa. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 56, 273–279. De Castro, J. M. (1986). Macronutrient relationships with meal patterns and mood in the spontaneous feeding behavior of humans. Physiology & Behavior, 39, 561–569. Ekman, P. (1992). An argument for basic emotions. Cognition & Emotion, 6, 169–200. Federoff, I., Polivy, J., & Herman, C. P. (2003). The specificity of restrained vs. unrestrained eaters’ responses to food cues: General desire to eat, or craving for the cued food? Appetite, 41, 7–13. Ferber, C., & Cabanac, M. (1987). Influence of noise on gustatory affective ratings and preference for sweet and salt. Appetite, 8, 229–235. Frederickson, B. (1998). What good are positive emotions? Review of General Psychology, 2, 300–319. Frijda, N. (1986). The emotions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Frijda, N. (1993). Moods, emotion episodes, and emotions. In M. L. J. M. Haviland (Ed.), Handbook of emotions (pp. 381–403). London, New York: Guilford Press. Frijda, N., Ortony, A., Sonnemans, J., & Clore, G. L. (1992). The complexity of intensity—Issues concerning the structure of emotion intensity. In M. S. Clark (Ed.), Emotion (pp. 60–89). Newbury Park: Sage Publications. Frost, R. O., Goolkasian, G. A., Ely, R. J., & Blanchard, F. A. (1982). Depression, restraint and eating behavior. Behavioral Research and Therapy, 20, 113–121. Galef, J. R. (1996). Food selection: Problems in understanding how we choose food to eat. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 20(1), 67–73. Gibson, E. L. (2006). Emotional influences on food choice: Sensory, physiological and psychological pathways. Physiology & Behavior, 89, 53–61. Gibson, E. L., & Green, M. W. (2002). Nutritional influences on cognitive function: Mechanisms of susceptibility. Nutrition Research Reviews, 15, 169–206. Glass, L. B. (1967). The generality of oral-consummatory behavior of alcoholics under stress. Dissertation Abstracts International, 28, 5205. Gluck, M. E., Geliebter, A., Hung, J., & Yahav, E. (2004). Cortisol, hunger, and desire to binge eat following a cold stress test in obese women with binge eating disorder. Psychosomatic Medicine, 66, 876–881. Greeno, G. G., & Wing, R. R. (1994). Stress-induced eating. Psychological Bulletin, 115, 444–464. Greenwald, M. K., Cook, E. W., & Lang, P. J. (1989). Affective judgement and psychophysiological response: Dimensional covariation in the evaluation of pictorial stimuli. Journal of Psychophysiology, 3, 51–64. Grunberg, N. E., & Straub, R. O. (1992). The role of gender and taste class in the effects of stress on eating. Health Psychology, 11(2), 97–100. Heatherton, T. F., & Baumeister, R. F. (1991). Binge eating as escape from self-awareness. Psychological Bulletin, 110, 86–108. Heatherton, T. F., Herman, C. P., & Polivy, J. (1991). Effects of physical threat and ego threat on eating behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60, 138–143. Heatherton, T. F., Striepe, M., & Wittenberg, L. (1998). Emotional distress and disinhibited eating: The role of self. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 24(3), 301–313.
9
Herman, C. P., & Mack, D. (1975). Restraint and unrestraint eating. Journal of Personality, 43, 647–660. Herman, C. P., & Polivy, J. (1975). Anxiety, restraint and eating behavior. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 84, 662–672. Herman, C. P., & Polivy, J. (1984). A boundary model for the regulation of eating. Eating and Its Disorders, 141–156. Herman, C. P., Polivy, J., Lank, C. N., & Heatherton, T. F. (1987). Anxiety, hunger, and eating behavior. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 96, 264–269. Hill, A. J., Weaver, C. F. L., & Blundell, J. E. (1991). Food craving, dietary restraint and mood. Appetite, 17, 187–197. Izard, C. E., & Ackerman, B. P. (2000). Organizational and motivational functions of discrete emotions. In M. L. J. M. Haviland (Ed.), Handbook of emotions (2nd ed., pp. 253–264). New York: Guilford Press. Jansen, A. (1998). A learning model of binge eating: Cue reactivity and cue exposure. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 36, 257–272. Johnson, C., & Larson, R. (1982). Bulimia: An analysis of mood and behavior. Psychosomatic Medicine, 44(4), 341–351. Kaplan, H. I., & Kaplan, H. S. (1957). The psychosomatic concept of obesity. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 125, 181–201. Karhunen, L. J., Lappalainen, R. I., Tammela, L., Turpeinen, A. K., & Uusitupa, M. I. J. (1997). Subjective and physiological cephalic phase responses to food in obese binge-eating women. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 21, 321–328. Kenardy, J., Arnow, B., & Agras, W. S. (1996). The aversiveness of specific emotional states associated with binge-eating in obese subjects. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 30(6), 839–844. Klaijner, F., Herman, P. C., Polivy, J., & Chhabra, R. (1980). Human obesity, dieting, and anticipatory salivation to food. Physiology & Behavior, 27, 195–198. Krebs, H., Macht, M., Weyers, P., Weijers, H.-G., & Janke, W. (1996). Effects of stressful noise on eating and non-eating behavior in rats. Appetite, 26, 193–202. Krumbacher, K., & Meyer, J. E. (1963). Das Appetitverhalten des gesunden unter emotionalem StreX. Psychosomatische Medizin, 9, 89–94. Kupferman, I. (1964). Eating behavior induced by sounds. Nature, 201, 324. Laitinen, J., Ek, E., & Sovio, U. (2002). Stress-related eating and drinking behavior and body mass index and predictors of this behavior. Preventive Medicine, 34, 29–39. Lattimore, P., & Caswell, N. (2004). Differential effects of active and passive stress on food intake in restrained and unrestrained eaters. Appetite, 42, 167–173. Lattimore, P., & Maxwell, L. (2004). Cognitive load, stress, and disinhibited eating. Eating Behaviors, 5, 315–324. Lima, S. L. (1987). Vigilance while feeding and its relation to the risk of predation. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 124, 303–316. Lowe, M. R., & Maycock, B. (1988). Restraint, disinhibition, hunger and negative affect eating. Addictive Behaviors, 13, 369–377. Lyman, B. (1982). The nutritional values and food group characteristics of foods preferred during various emotions. Journal of Psychology, 112, 121–127. Macdiarmid, J. I., & Hetherington, M. M. (1995). Mood modulation by food: An exploration of affect and cravings in ‘‘chocolate addicts’’. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 34, 129–138. Macht, M. (1996). Effects of high- and low-energy meals on hunger, physiological processes and reactions to emotional stress. Appetite, 26, 71–88. Macht, M. (1998). Effects of noise-induced arousal on chewing of sweet food and the subjective motivation to eat. Nutritional Neuroscience, 1, 213–222. Macht, M. (1999). Characteristics of eating in anger, fear, sadness, and joy. Appetite, 33, 129–139. Macht, M., Haupt, C., & Ellgring, H. (2005). The perceived function of eating is changed during examination stress: A field study. Eating Behaviors, 6, 109–112.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 10
M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11
Macht, M., & Mu¨ller, J. (2007). Immediate effects of chocolate on experimentally induced mood states. Appetite, doi:10.1016/j. appet.2007.05.004. Macht, M., Roth, S., & Ellgring, H. (2002). Chocolate eating in healthy men during experimentally induced sadness and joy. Appetite, 39, 147–158. Macht, M., & Simons, G. (2000). Emotions and eating in everyday life. Appetite, 35, 65–71. Markus, C. R., Panhuysen, G., & Tuiten, A. (1998). Does carbohydraterich, protein-poor food prevent a deterioration of mood and cognitive performance of stress-prone subjects when subjected to a stressful task. Appetite, 31, 49–65. Martins, Y., & Pliner, P. (2005). Human food choices: An examination of the factors underlying acceptance/rejection of novel and familiar animal and nonanimal foods. Appetite, 45, 214–224. McCann, B. S., Warnick, G. R., & Knopp, R. H. (1990). Changes in plasma lipids and dietary intake accompanying shifts in perceived workload and stress. Psychosomatic Medicine, 52, 97–108. Mehrabian, A. (1980). Basic dimensions for a general psychological theory. Cambridge: Oelgeschlager, Gunn & Hain. Michaud, C., Kahn, J. P., Musse, N., Burlet, C., Nicolas, J. P., & Mejean, L. (1990). Relationships between a critical life event and eating behaviour in high-school students. Stress Medicine, 6, 57–64. Morley, J. E., Levine, A. S., & Rowland, N. E. (1983). Stress-induced eating. Life Sciences, 32, 2169–2182. Nederkoorn, C., Smulders, F., Havermans, R., & Jansen, A. (2004). Exposure to binge food in bulimia nervosa: Finger pulse amplitude as a potential measure of urge to eat and predictor of food intake. Appetite, 42, 125–130. Nederkoorn, C., Smulders, F. T. Y., & Jansen, A. (2000). Cephalic phase responses, craving and food intake in normal subjects. Appetite, 35, 45–55. Oliver, G., & Wardle, J. (1999). Perceived effects of stress on food choice. Physiology & Behavior, 66, 511–515. Oliver, G., Wardle, J., & Gibson, E. L. (2000). Stress and food choice: A laboratory study. Psychosomatic Medicine, 62, 853–865. Overduin, J., Jansen, A., & Eilkes, H. (1997). Cue reactivity to food- and body-related stimuli in restrained and unrestrained eaters. Addictive Behaviors, 22, 395–404. Pare´, W. P. (1964). The effect of chronic environmental stress on stomach ulceration, adrenal function, and consummatory behavior in the rat. Journal of Psychology, 57, 143–151. Pine, C. J. (1985). Anxiety and eating behavior in obese and nonobese American Indians and white Americans. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 49, 774–780. Pines, C. J., & Gal, R. (1977). The effect of food on test anxiety. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 49, 774–780. Pliner, P., & Steverango, C. (1994). Effect of induced mood on memory for flavors. Appetite, 22, 135–148. Plutchik, R. (1984). Emotions: A general psychoevolutionary theory. In K. R. Scherer (Ed.), Approaches to emotion (pp. 197–219). Hillsdale: Lawrence Erlbaum. Polivy, J., & Herman, C. P. (1999). Distress and eating: Why do dieters overeat? International Journal of Eating Disorders, 26, 153–164. Pollard, T. M., Steptoe, A., Canaan, L., Davies, G. J., & Wardle, J. (1995). Effects of academic examination stress on eating behavior and blood lipid levels. International Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 2(4), 299–320. Popper, R., Smits, G., Meiselman, H. L., & Hirsch, E. (1989). Eating in combat: A survey of US Marines. Military Medicine, 154, 619–623. Pudel, V. (1984). Psychosoziale Bewertung der Erna¨hrung in Familien mit Kindern. Eine Repra¨sentativerhebung in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. In Deutsche Gesellschaft fu¨r Erna¨hrung (Ed.), Erna¨hrungsbericht (pp. 103–144). Frankfurt am Main: Henrich. Pudel, V., & Richter, M. (1980). Psychosoziale bewertung der erna¨hrung. Eine repra¨sentativ-erhebung in der bundesrepublik deutschland. In D. G. f. Erna¨hrung (Ed.), Erna¨hrungsbericht. Frankfurt: Deutsche Gesellschaft fu¨r Erna¨hrung.
Rasbury, W., & Shemberg, K. (1971). The effects of aversive levels of white noise on consummatory behavior. Psychonomic Science, 22, 166–167. Raudenbush, B., & Frank, R. A. (1999). Assessing food neophobia: The role of stimulus familiarity. Appetite, 32, 261–271. Reznick, H., & Balch, P. (1977). The effects of anxiety and response cost manipulations on the eating behavior of obese and normal weight subjects. Addictive Behaviors, 2, 219–225. Robbins, T. W., & Fray, P. J. (1980). Stress-induced eating: Fact, fiction or misunderstanding? Appetite, 1, 103–133. Rosenfield, S. N., & Stevenson, J. S. (1988). Perception of daily stress and oral coping behaviors in normal, overweight, and recovering alcoholic women. Research in Nursing & Health, 11, 165–174. Rosenstein, D., & Oster, H. (1988). Differential facial responses to four basic tastes in newborns. Child Development, 59, 1555–1568. Rotenberg, K. J., & Flood, D. (1999). Loneliness, dysphoria, dietary restraint, and eating behavior. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 25(1), 55–64. Rozin, P., & Fallon, A. E. (1987). A perspective on disgust. Psychological Review, 94(1), 23–41. Rozin, P., & Schulkin, J. (1990). Food selection. In E. M. Stricker (Ed.), Neurobiology of food and fluid intake (pp. 297–328). New York: Plenum Press. Ruderman, A. J. (1985). Dysphoric mood and overeating: A test of restraint theory’s disinhibition hypothesis. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 94, 78–85. Russell, J. A., & Feldman Barrett, L. (1999). Core affect, prototypical emotional episodes, and other things called emotion: Dissecting the elephant. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76, 805–819. Rutledge, T., & Linden, W. (1998). To eat or not to eat: Affective and physiological mechanisms in the stress-eating relationship. Journal of Behavioral Medicine, 21, 221–240. Sampson, D., Muscat, R., Philips, G., & Willner, P. (1992). Decreased reactivity to sweetness following chronic exposure to mild unpredictable stress or acute administration of pimozide. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 16(4), 519–524. Schachter, S., Goldman, R., & Gordon, A. (1968). Effects of fear, food deprivation, and obesity on eating. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 10, 91–97. Schotte, D. E., Cools, J., & McNally, R. J. (1990). Film-induced negative affect triggers overeating in restrained eaters. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 99, 317–320. Slochower, J. (1983). Excessive eating: The role of emotions and environment. New York: Human Sciences Press. Smith, B. A., Fillion, T. J., & Blass, E. M. (1990). Orally mediated sources of calming in 1- to 3-day-old human infants. Developmental Psychology, 26(5), 731–737. Spillman, D. (1990). Survey of food and vitamin intake responses reported by university students experiencing stress. Psychological Reports, 66, 499–502. Spitzer, L., & Rodin, J. (1983). Arousal-induced eating: Conventional wisdom or empirical findings? In J. Capiocco, & R. Petty (Eds.), Social psychophysiology (pp. 565–591). New York: Guilford Press. Staiger, P., Dawe, S., & McCarthy, R. (2000). Responsivity to food cues in bulimic women and controls. Appetite, 35, 27–33. Steiner, J. E. (1979). Human facial expressions in response to taste and smell stimulation. Advances in Child Development and Behavior, 13, 257–295. Steiner, J. E., Glaser, D., Hawilo, M. E., & Berridge, K. C. (2001). Comparative expression of hedonic impact: Affective reactions to tastes and other primates. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 25, 53–74. Steptoe, A., Lipsey, Z., & Wardle, J. (1998). Stress, hassles and variations in alcohol consumption, food choice and physical exercise. British Journal of Health Psychology, 3, 51–63. Sterritt, G. M. (1962). Inhibition and faciliation of eating by electric shock. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 55, 226–229.
ARTICLE IN PRESS M. Macht / Appetite 50 (2008) 1–11 Sterritt, G. M. (1965). Inhibition and facilitation of eating by electric shock: III. A further study of the role of strain and of shock level. Psychonomic Science, 2, 319–320. Sterritt, G. M., & Shemberg, K. (1963). Inhibition and facilitation of eating by electric shock-II. Shock level, shock schedule and strain of rats. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 7, 215–223. Stone, A. A., & Brownell, K. (1994). The stress-eating paradox: Multiple daily measurements in adult males and females. Psychology and Health, 9, 425–436. Striegel-Moore, R. H., Morrison, J. A., Schreiber, G., Schumann, B. C., Crawford, P. B., & Obarzanek, E. (1999). Emotioninduced eating and sucrose intake in children: The NHLBI growth and health study. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 25, 389–398. Strongman, K. T. (1965). The effect of anxiety on food intake in rats. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 17, 255–260. Strongman, K. T., Coles, M. G. H., Remington, R. E., & Wookey, P. E. (1970). The effect of shock duration and intensity on the ingestion of food of varying palatability. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 22, 521–525. Stunkard, A. J., & Messick, S. (1985). The three-factor eating questionnaire to measure dietary restraint, disinhibition, and hunger. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 29, 71–83. Telch, C. F., & Agras, W. S. (1996). Do emotional states influence binge eating in the obese. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 20(3), 271–279. Telch, C. F., Agras, W. S., & Linehan, M. M. (2001). Dialectical behavior therapy for binge eating disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 69(6), 1061–1065. Thayer, R. E. (1989). The biopsychology of mood and arousal. New York: Oxford University Press. Thayer, R. E. (2001). Calm energy—How people regulate mood with food and exercise. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Tomkins, S. S. (1963). Affect, imagery, consciousness, 2: The negative affects. New York: Tavistock/Routledge. Troop, N. A., Treasure, J. L., & Serpell, L. (2002). A further exploration of disgust in eating disorders. European Eating Disorders Review, 10, 218–226. Tuschen, B., Florin, I., & Baucke, R. (1993). BeeinfluXt die Stimmung den Appetit? Zeitschrift fu¨r Klinische Psychologie, 22(3), 315–321. Ullman, A. D. (1951). The experimental production and analysis of a ‘‘compulsive eating syndrome’’. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 44, 575–581. Ullman, A. D. (1952). Three factors involved in producing ‘‘compulsive eating’’ in rats. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 45, 490–496. van Strien, T. (2002). Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire (DEBQ)— Manual. Bury St. Edmunds: Thames Valley Test Company Ltd. van Strien, T., Frijters, J. E. R., Bergers, G. P. A., & Defares, P. B. (1986). The Dutch Eating Behavior Questionnaire (DEBQ) for assessment of restrained, emotional and external eating behavior. International Journal of Eating Behavior, 5, 295–315.
11
Volkow, N. D., Wang, G.-J., Maynard, L., Jayne, M., Fowler, J. S., Zhu, W., et al. (2003). Brain dopamine is associated with eating behaviors in humans. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 33, 136–142. Vreugdenberg, L., Bryan, J., & Kemps, E. (2003). The effect of selfinitiated weight-loss dieting on working memory: The role of preoccupying cognitions. Appetite, 41, 291–300. Wallis, D. J., & Hetherington, M. M. (2004). Stress and eating: The effects of ego-threat and cognitive demand on food intake in restrained and emotional eaters. Appetite, 43, 39–46. Wansink, B., Cheney, M. M., & Chan, N. (2003). Exploring comfort food preferences across age and gender. Physiology & Behavior, 79, 739–747. Ward, A., & Mann, T. (2000). Don t mind if I do: Disinhibited eating under cognitive load. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78, 753–763. Wardle, J., Steptoe, A., Oliver, G., & Lipsey, Z. (2000). Stress, dietary restraint and food intake. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 48, 195–202. Weidner, G., Kohlmann, C. W., Dotzauer, E., & Burns, L. R. (1996). The effects of academic stress on health behaviors in young adults. Anxiety, Stress, and Coping, 9, 123–133. Weinstein, S. E., Shide, D. J., & Rolls, B. J. (1997). Changes in food intake in response to stress in men and women: Psychological factors. Appetite, 28, 7–18. Weiss, J. M. (1968). Effects of coping responses on stress. Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology, 65, 251–260. Whishaw, I. Q., Dringenberg, H. C., & Comery, T. A. (1992). Rats (Rattus norvegicus) modulat eating speed and vigilance to optimize food consumption: Effects of cover, circadian rhythm, food deprivation, and individual differences. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 106, 411–419. Willenbring, M. L., Levine, A. S., & Morley, J. E. (1986). Stress induced eating and food preference in human: A pilot study. International Journal of Eating Behavior, 5(5), 855–864. Willner, P. (1997). Validity, reliability and utility of the chronic mild stress model of depression: A 10-year review and evaluation. Psychopharmacology, 134, 319–329. Willner, P., Benton, D., Brown, E., Survijt, C., Davies, G., Morgan, J., et al. (1998). ‘‘Depression’’ increases ‘‘craving’’ for sweet rewards in animal and human models of depression and craving. Psychopharmacology, 136, 272–283. Willner, P., & Healy, S. (1994). Decreased hedonic responsiveness during a brief depressive mood swing. Journal of Affective Disorders, 32, 13–20. Willner, P., Muscat, R., & Papp, M. (1992). Chronic mild stress-induced Anhedonia: A realistic model of depression. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews, 16, 525–534. Wing, R. R., Blair, E. H., Epstein, L. H., & McDermott, M. D. (1990). Psychological stress and glucose metabolism in obese and normalweight subjects: A possible mechanism for differences in stress-induced eating. Health Psychology, 9, 693–700. Wiser, S., & Telch, C. F. (1999). Dialectical behavior therapy for bingeeating disorder. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 55(6), 755–768. Wurtman, R. J. (1982). Nutrients that modify brain function. Scientific American, 246, 50–59.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research report
Television use and food choices of children: Qualitative approach Giovanna Medeiros Rataichesck Fiatesa,, Renata D.M.C. Ambonib, Evanilda Teixeirab Departamento de Nutric- a˜o, Centro de Cieˆncias da Sau´de, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Floriano´polis 88010-970, SC, Brasil Departamento de Cieˆncia dos Alimentos, Centro de Cieˆncias Agra´rias, Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, Floriano´polis 88034-001, SC, Brasil a
b
Received 1 September 2006; received in revised form 29 March 2007; accepted 9 May 2007
Abstract This study reports the results of 12 focus group interviews with primary school students (7–10 years old, n ¼ 57) in Floriano´polis, Brazil, regarding their food choices, television (TV) viewing, and physical activity habits. In 2005, an average Brazilian child aged 4–11 years watched TV almost 5 h per day. Intensive TV use in childhood and adolescence may contribute to sedentarism and unhealthy eating habits, and excessive viewing might have long-lasting adverse effects on health. Results indicated that frequent ingestion of snack foods was not a habit for most students, possibly because of an acknowledged parental interference, but these were the food items they bought with their own money. Daily TV viewing was reported by almost all students, especially during meals and before bedtime, but students still found the time to be physically active. Most of them mentioned going to sports classes and engaging in active play regularly. No attempts by the parents to regulate TV viewing in the household were mentioned. The habit of eating while watching TV, together with the students’ behavior as primary consumers of food products, pointed to the need for strategies that will reduce TV viewing and educate the children as consumers. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Children; Food choices; Television viewing; Consumer behavior
Introduction This article examines the behavior of a group of Brazilian children regarding their food choices, television (TV) viewing, and physical activity habits. Nowadays, children’s food preferences seem to influence food selection in ways that are inconsistent with dietary guidelines (Birch, 1999). Dietary patterns that result in high intakes of fat, saturated fat, and refined carbohydrate as well as low intakes of fruit, vegetables, and complex carbohydrate are becoming increasingly common, escalating the risks of coronary heart disease, certain cancers, diabetes, hypertension, and obesity (Coon & Tucker, 2002). Excessive TV viewing during childhood and adolescence plays an important role in this matter, since it has been associated with higher intakes of energy, fat, sweet and salty snacks, and carbonated beverages as well as with lower intakes of fruit and vegetables (Coon, Goldberg, Rogers, & Tucker, 2001). One of the reasons why TV has such effect is Corresponding author. Tel.: +554837219784; fax: +554837219542.
E-mail address: gifi
[email protected] (G.M.R. Fiates). 0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.002
because food is the most frequently advertised product category on children’s TV programming, and it has been established that exposure to food advertisements effectively promotes consumption of the advertised products (Halford, Gillespie, Brown, Pontin, & Dovey, 2004). TV also contributes to sedentarism, displacing more energetic activities that could help in burning the excessive calories contained in nutritionally unbalanced diets (Gortmaker et al., 1996; Hancox, Milne, & Poulton, 2004). The average American child spends 5.5 h per day with a variety of media, mostly TV (Strasburger, 2004). In Brazil, the situation is not different. In 2005, Brazilian kids aged 4–11 years watched TV around 4 h and 52 min per day (Instituto Midiativa, 2006). In a study about TV programming in Brazil, Almeida, Nascimento, and Quaioti (2002) analyzed 432 h of advertising in Brazilian commercial TV during weekdays and 216 h during Saturdays; they found that foods were the most advertised category of products, especially those rich in fat and sugar. The fact that children can be very sensitive to the effects of advertising has led to a large body of research. In Chile, the high percentage of children watching TV and the
ARTICLE IN PRESS G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
marked influence of commercials over their food preferences convinced researchers that an urgent educational strategy was necessary to promote healthy eating habits (Olivares, Albala, Garcia, & Jofre´, 1999). In a study with Spanish students, Ruano and Pujol (1997) concluded that unhealthy dietary habits clustered in high consumers of TV. In Turkey, Arnas (2006) reported that TV advertisements affected young children’s unhealthy food consumption. In the United Kingdom, Halford et al. (2004) concluded that the ability to recognize food advertisements significantly correlated with the amount of food eaten after exposure to them. In the United States, Coon et al. (2001) verified that watching TV during meals negatively affected the dietary patterns of children and their families. As one can see, TV viewing can certainly influence the behavior of children to an extent that can cause concern. Throughout the world, children do not only influence family purchase decisions in a variety of product categories, but also have considerable amount of money to spend with their own needs, which qualifies them to be an important primary market (McNeal, 1998). It is estimated that children between the ages of 4 and 14 living in urban environments spend approximately US$ 300 a year in their personal wants and needs. In the US alone, children spend more than US$ 7 billion a year in food and beverage (McNeal, 2000). Although it is likely that some aspects of children’s consumer behavior are universal across cultures, local studies provide valuable opportunities to generate information about what is happening in different settings. There have been no studies about the consumer behavior of Brazilian children, or how their TV viewing habits affect their food choices. The present pilot study, which is exploratory in nature, aimed to obtain preliminary data about this relevant and yet unknown situation in Brazil. We expected that the students from the sample, who only attend school for half periods (like virtually every student in Brazil), dedicated most of their leisure time to watching TV, and that this would negatively influence their eating habits and physical activity levels. We expected to find high consumption of snack foods, together with low intakes of fruits and vegetables, and low levels of exercise. Methods
13
Also, starting at the age of eight, kids already have money of their own to spend, and sometimes spend it independently (John, 1999). Since this is a relatively unexplored area, we chose to apply a qualitative approach to promote idea generation via group interaction. Bringing children together to discuss an idea or concept minimizes direct inquiry and produces richer responses because the children are not only responding to the researcher, but to other members of the group as well (McNeal, 2000; Heary & Hennessy, 2002; Green & Thorogood, 2004). Participants A total of 57 students (28 male, 29 female), aged 7–10 years (mean age: 8.9 years), returned the consent forms signed by their parents. The participants’ response rate (40.4%) fairly represents the overall student population. The participants were composed of 43% of the 1st graders, 28% of 2nd graders, 38% of 3rd graders, and 49% of 4th graders. Additional data about the sample are presented in Table 1. No children had special needs. The majority of the students were white and from middle-class families living near the school. Nonparticipation in the study was due to failure in returning the signed consent forms or absenteeism on the day of the focus group interview. Focus group interviews The students participated in 12 focus group sessions. Participants were divided into groups on the basis of grade and gender with an average of about five students in each focus group (range of 4–6 students per group). Two focus groups were formed from 1st grade students (one with boys and one with girls, n ¼ 9), two from 2nd grade students (both mixed, n ¼ 9); three from 3rd grade students (two with boys and one with girls, n ¼ 15) and five from 4th grade students (two with boys and three with girls, n ¼ 24). The mixed groups with 2nd-graders were formed because there were not enough participants to create female or male only groups. Interviews were conducted within the school setting, during school hours, in a special room with little furniture and distraction.
Table 1 Characteristics of interview participants
Study design The study was conducted in a primary private school in Floriano´polis, Brazil. The protocol was approved by the Federal University of Santa Catarina Human Research Ethics Committee (Protocol # 293/05). All 141 students from the seven existing classrooms of 1st to 4th grade were invited to participate in the study, and received informed consent forms to be signed by the parents. This age group was chosen because some of the most important consumer knowledge and skills are developed during this period.
Boys ðn ¼ 28Þ
Freq. (%)
Girls ðn ¼ 29Þ
Freq. (%)
Total ðnÞ
Freq. (%)
Age/grade 7 years (1st grade) 8 years (2nd grade) 9 years (3rd grade) 10 years (4th grade)
05 04 10 09
9 7 18 15
04 05 05 15
7 9 9 26
09 09 15 24
16 16 26 42
School period Morning Afternoon
13 15
23 26
06 23
10 40
19 38
33 67
ARTICLE IN PRESS 14
-
G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
Can a food be healthy and tasty at the same time? Give examples. Do you like eating fruits? How often? What about vegetables? Do you like eating snack foods? How often? What else do you like to eat? Do your parents try to interfere with your eating habits? When you have your own money to spend, what food items do you buy? Do you like watching TV? When? What are your favorite shows? Do you usually eat something while watching TV? Do your parents try to interfere with your TV viewing habits? Between watching TV and playing outside, what do you prefer? Do you practice any sports?
Fig. 1. Focus group interview structure: sample of main questions.
Each focus group interview was conducted in Portuguese by the same moderator (first author), using a discussion guide with open-ended questions to ensure consistency in interviewing style (Fig. 1). Moreover, a semi-structured questioning route was used to ensure consistency in questions asked across groups, yet allow for some flexibility in accordance with the topics raised and level of participation within the groups. Focus group interviews were audio-recorded with participants’ permission and lasted approximately 30 min. Interviews were transcribed verbatim, in Portuguese, and then translated to English. A total of 6.6 h of tape-recorded interviews were obtained to produce a manuscript. Data were analyzed through content analysis (O’Dea, 2003). With this method, ideas or trends were coded in the transcript margin; then, they were selectively retrieved and reassembled together, and grouped according to common themes, using the cut-and-paste technique (Bardin, 2004). Words and phrases used by participants were analyzed to determine the degree of similarity among responses. We considered the context in which responses were given, with particular emphasis on the stimulus that elicited each response. We also considered the frequency of comments to measure the significance of specific topics. Frequencies were used only in the broadest of terms (for example, many, some, a few). Quotes were pulled from the transcripts to illustrate categories. The specific quotes were selected on the basis that they illustrated a variety of response types, including responses which were typical or common; unusual responses; responses which represented a concise summary of a discussion topic; or responses showing a range of viewpoints on a topic. After this systematic process was completed, the data were categorized as follows:
Consumption of fruits, vegetables and snack foods Parental interference over food choices Food consumer behavior
TV viewing habits Physical activity
Results Consumption of fruits, vegetables, and snack foods Most of the interviewed students referred to the ingestion of fruits and vegetables with many positive remarks denoting a regular intake of salads and fresh fruit. Very few students reported intense rejection of fruits and vegetables; negative comments were mostly on restrictions about the way of eating, use of seasoning, or addition of toppings. ‘‘Everyday I eat three fruits: one in the morning, other at noon and another one at night.’’ (2nd-grade boy) ‘‘The salad I like best is beets! No seasoning, of coursey’’ (4th-grade boy) ‘‘I only [eat fruit] when I feel like ityonly when my mother buys strawberries, but it has to be with some kind of sweet added to it, like condensed milkyor sugary’’ (1st-grade girl) ‘‘yI don’t really eat them; I just suck the juice and throw away the rest.’’ (4th-grade girl) Snack food intake was a topic that generated several controversies. Many students admitted liking and eating more than they should. More students, however, made negative remarks and considered snacks not a regular item in their diets. ‘‘I kind of think, actually [about eating healthy foods], but I go towards not so healthy items, because I think they taste bettery’’ (4th-grade girl) ‘‘I eat a lot of chocolateyalmost everything I eat everyday is cookies and chocolateyand milky’’ (2ndgrade girl) ‘‘y I hate chocolatey if someone offers me, I eat, but rarelyy I really don’t like.’’ (3rd-grade boy) ‘‘yice cream only once a week or even only once a month, but I don’t really like ice cream.’’ (4th-grade girl) ‘‘I had esofagitisyI couldn’t eat chocolate, soda, chipsynow it’s been treated, but I still don’t eat much because my mom forbids, I eat whatyonce a monthy’’ (4th-grade boy) Parental interference over food choices Students provided many comments about how their parents interfered with their food choices. This topic was brought to discussion because we thought that the students’ habits or product requests could generate conflict between them and their parents. Parental control over the children’s food choices seemed to be exercised in several ways: (1) some simply did not buy what their children wanted; (2) some bought and restricted access to them at
ARTICLE IN PRESS G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
home; (3) others tried educating, negotiating or forcing; and (4) yet others appealed for health reasons. ‘‘My motherykeeps them in a kitchen cabinetywhen she is sleeping I go there and eat everythingythen she put a locker in the cabinetymade only two copies of the keyy’’ (3rd- grade boy) ‘‘ythey say I must eat at least two or three vegetables per day, fruitsy’’ (4th-grade boy) ‘‘My mom and dad, we have a dealyif I eat lettuce, I don’t have to eat apples, which I don’t like.’’ (4th-grade girl) ‘‘ymy mother warned me that if I did not eat the vegetables in my plate I would stay all day long eating what was left from my lunchythen I started to eat vegetables.’’ (4th-grade boy) ‘‘When I get something to eat while watching TV he says I can only have two pieces of it and then put it awayybecause if not I keep eatingythen I get fat and out of shapey(3rd-grade boy) Most of the students seemed to accept what their parents were doing, acknowledging that they knew better and were acting in their best interest. A few of them reported getting annoyed, indicating that some degree of conflict was taking place. ‘‘They are rightythey want our healthy’’ (3rd-grade girl) ‘‘We feel hurt, because we cannot have what we wantythey [the parents] go like this: you’ve had enough, now you can’t have it anymorey’’ (2nd-grade girl) Food consumer behavior Many interviewed students reported having money to spend, either as allowance or as pocket money. When prompted to talk about buying food items, every statement obtained referred to buying snack foods, such as sweet and salted snacks, candies, gum, lollypops, and ice pops. Places where they usually shopped were supermarkets, newsstands, shopping malls, and the school cafeteria. These little purchases were often done independently. ‘‘I like candy very muchyonce I went to the mall and we bought a lot of candyythen we went to the play area, won those tokens, you know, traded them all for gumy’’ (4th-grade boy) ‘‘Sometimes my mom gives me money, but it’s only for buying stuff at the school canteenyI buy popsiclesy’’ (1st grade girl) ‘‘yI sneak to the supermarket and buy a lot of stuffyTic Tacsy’’ (3rd-grade boy) TV viewing habits The subject of TV viewing generated much interest. Almost all students reported watching TV daily, at all
15
hours, but especially during meals and at night. Some were really passionate about it, while others regarded it as a last resort, when there was nothing more interesting left to do or no friends to play with. Their favorite shows were cartoons and kid’s programs, followed by soap operas and movies. By analyzing the shows they usually watched and the times they were aired, we found that the students watched a lot of adult programming and cable TV. Many students reported having TV sets in their bedrooms, which they left on until they fell asleep. Very few students mentioned watching more TV programs on weekends than on weekdays. ‘‘I will watch anything that is on TVy (1st-grade boy) ‘‘I don’t watch much TV becauseyI’ve got books to read; sometimes I play with my sister or with my dog.’’ (3rd grade girl) ‘‘If I have to choose between using the computer, watching TV or playing soccer, I’d rather play soccer.’’ (4th-grade girl) ‘‘yI try to do other things, but when I have nothing left to do, then I go watch TVy’’ (4th-grade boy) When asked to talk about their parents’ attitudes towards their TV viewing habits, all the students could remember were warnings about the mess caused by bringing food to the living room or the bedroom, or the parents turned the TV off as punishment for some wrongdoing. Absolutely no comments were made about any attempts to control the hours spent by the children in front of the TV, indicating a situation where there seems to be no conflict at all. ‘‘ywhen I am watching cartoons I eat in the living roomymy mom says: you will have to clean everything, try not to make a messy’’ (1st grade boy) ‘‘My father doesn’t want me to eat in his bedroom, but in my bedroom it is oky’’ (1st grade girl) The ingestion of food during TV viewing periods appeared as a very strong habit in the studied population. Virtually, every student admitted eating while watching TV, from simple candies to whole meals, in the kitchen, living room, or bedroom. ‘‘yI always stay in front of the television eating something; I eaty whatever is in front of mey’’ (2nd-grade boy) ‘‘When I get back from school, I go straight to bedytell my grandma to make me a plate of foodythere is a little table, then I eatyand watch cartoonsy’’ (3rdgrade boy) ‘‘ythere was a TV set in my bedroom, then she [my mom] put it in the kitchen to watch the newsythen I watch from the kitchen tabley(4th-grade girl) ‘‘Afternoon snackyand lunchyand dinnery [in front of the TV]’’ (2nd-grade girl) Many students mentioned that eating in front of the TV set clearly interfered in the amount of food they ate. Some
ARTICLE IN PRESS G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
16
reported eating more; others said they almost forgot to eat. Either way, watching TV distracted them to a point where they paid no attention to the amount of food being eaten. ‘‘My mother hands me a full plate, and leavesyI stay watching TVyI don’t touch the foodywhen I see that she is coming back, then I remember to eaty’’ (4th grade girl) ‘‘Every day, I am watching Xuxa and my mom tells me to go eat in the kitchenyif she lets me eat in the living room I eat everything, when I eat in the kitchen I eat almost nothingy’’ (1st-grade girl) ‘‘y I turn the TV on, start eating, then sometimes I look more at the television than I look at my foodyI end up eating less!’’ (4th grade girl) ‘‘Sometimes we don’t realize what we are eating, and then we get stuffedy’’ (4th grade girl) Physical activity TV viewing apparently did not keep the students from being physically active. Many attended sports classes before or after school (swimming, soccer, dance), and even more reported active leisure activities at home, outside their apartments, with neighbors and friends (bike, roller skating, soccer). Boys were clearly more active than girls. This was the only difference we could observe between sexes. Some of the boys were so restless that they even reported trying to play soccer inside their apartments. ‘‘ycan’t play ball in the kitchen, can’t play in the living room, can’t play in my room, and can’t play in my sister’s roomy’’ (3rd-grade boy) ‘‘When it’s a hot day and I am allowed to play, my friend goes to my placeyor I go to hisyride our bikesy (3rd grade boy) ‘‘Sometimes I go skating, I do karate, once in a while I go to the University campus with my father, and we play basketball, handball, when I go to the beach I swim a loty’’ (4th grade boy) ‘‘I live in an apartment, my bike is too small, I don’t do sports; I stay in front of the computer, eat and sleep.’’ (4th-grade girl) Discussion In this study, a qualitative methodology was used to investigate TV viewing habits and food choices in a group of primary school students. Results showed that TV viewing was indeed an important part of the children’s leisure hours, and that eating was a habit strongly associated with it. The findings also provided key insights into the parents’ concerns, from the children’s viewpoint. The interviewed students could clearly describe their parents’ interference over their food choices, but not over the time they spent watching TV. Contrary to what we expected, the majority of students reported eating fruits and vegetables regularly, and snack
foods only occasionally but mainly when purchased with their own money. TV has a negative influence in the domestic environment, stimulating the consumption of unhealthy foods and reducing the period during which the parents are the main socializing power in their children’s lives (Hart, Bishop, & Truby, 2002; Harrison, 2005). This seems not to be true for the studied population, since children could easily mention parental attitudes that affected their food choices and eating habits. Some strategies adopted by them, however, could backfire. Restricting children’s access to snack foods makes the restricted foods more attractive, and the pressure to eat may discourage fruit and vegetable intake (Fisher & Birch, 1999; Fisher, Mitchell, Smiciklas–Wright, & Birch, 2002). Children’s food choices are shaped by many factors; some are endogenous to the individual child and others are environmental. These include the foods made available to children and the modeling of food behaviors by caregivers, especially parents, who are responsible for choosing most of the food that makes its way into the family kitchen (Harrison, 2005). Apparently, the food choices made by the children when spending their own money were more difficult to control. Food items purchased by the children as primary consumers were various types of sweet and salted snacks; no fruits or natural fruit juices were mentioned even once. Besides supermarkets, newsstands, and malls, snack food purchases occurred in the school cafeteria. In Floriano´polis, southern Brazil, where this study was conducted, school canteens are prohibited by law to sell candy, gum, lollypops, fried snacks and soda, which certainly limits the unhealthy options (Santa Catarina, 2001). Nevertheless, students can still spend money (and apparently were doing so) with unhealthy snacks such as ice cream, chocolate, mini pizza, hot dogs, and hamburgers. The findings were similar to those reported by Olivares, Ya´n˜es, and Dı´ az (2003) in Chile that whenever Chilean students had money to buy foods, they bought French fries, chocolates, cookies, and other sweet and salted products rich in fat, soft drinks, yogurt and fast food. Coincidentally, these were the same foods advertised in the ads they liked on TV. We also proved that the children who participated in our study were allowed to watch TV at all hours, apparently without any interference from the parents. They might be heavily exposed to food advertisements for unhealthy products, since these were the most advertised items both in daytime and nighttime TV programming (Almeida, Nascimento, & Quaioti, 2002; Arnas, 2006; Coon & Tucker, 2002; Kuribayashi, Roberts, & Johnson, 2001). It is true that children have a natural fondness for sweets and snacks, but it is also possible that the TV ads are accomplishing their goal and influencing the purchases of the children. Eating in front of the TV was a common situation for the children in this study. Research has shown that children indeed snack more while watching TV (Borzekowski &
ARTICLE IN PRESS G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
Robinson, 2001; Francis, Lee, & Birch, 2003); that snacking while watching TV was associated with increased overall caloric intake and calories from fat (Gore, Foster, Di Lillo, Kirk, & West, 2003); and that TV ads influence the types and amounts of foods they choose to eat (Arnas, 2006; Harrison, 2005). The students in the present study not only snacked, but they were used to eat their meals with the TV on, denoting a family habit that could have nutritional implications. According to Coon et al. (2001), the dietary patterns of children from families in which TV viewing is a normal part of meal routines may include fewer fruits and vegetables, and more pizzas, snack food, and sodas than the dietary patterns of children from families in which TV viewing and eating are separate activities. Brazilian children do not go to school full-time; they either spend mornings or afternoons in school, giving them plenty of spare time to dedicate to leisure activities. What we learned from the students’ opinions was that their TV viewing habits did not stop them from being physically active. Although we could not determine how much of their spare time was dedicated to activities that required energy expenditure, our results differed considerably from previous research that concluded that TV viewing contributes to sedentarism because it displaces more energetic activities (Gortmaker et al., 1996; Hancox et al., 2004). This was unexpected, since previous studies conducted with schoolchildren in Floriano´polis revealed that the prevalence of overweight and obesity was 22.1% (De Assis et al., 2005). When compared to a similar group of French children, the ones from Floriano´polis were heavier, had lower levels of physical activity, and watched more TV (De Assis et al., 2006). A possible explanation for our findings could be that the spare time available either before or after school was enough for the students in the present study to both exercise and watch TV. Comments about the physical environment (living in small apartments, lack of space to play) suggested that the children might have no other option than filling their daily schedules with TV watching. Several studies have come up recently, aimed at reducing the time children spend in front of the TV through educational strategies to be carried out by parents and teachers (Dennison, Russo, Burdick, & Jenkins, 2004; Ford, McDonald, Owens, & Robinson, 2002; Jason & Fries, 2004). Other approaches proposed by the academic community deal with the issue of advertising regulations. In some European countries, like Belgium, it is forbidden to broadcast commercials before, during, and after children’s programs. Sweden has introduced a total ban on TV advertising directed at children under 12 years of age (Valkenburg, 2000). Research is also being conducted about how advertising could be used to promote nutritional messages and influence the adoption of good eating behaviors (Bannon & Schwartz, 2006; McNeal, 2000). Thus, even though they could be considered regular TV watchers, the students in this study benefited from parental guidance that led them to eat fruits and vegetables
17
regularly, and found time to exercise. When left on their own, however, the students spent their money with a variety of potentially unhealthy snack foods. Since consumption has become part of the way in which children are brought up and socialized, they should probably receive some kind of formal consumer education, in order to become educated, accomplished consumers (Benn, 2002). In our opinion, the more disturbing findings were the habit of eating while watching TV and the absence of parental control over the children’s TV viewing time. Both situations point to the need of developing educational strategies directed towards the children and their families, addressing the issue of excessive TV viewing and its implications. Aside from the media, schools are influential environments in children’s lives, and could serve as effective mediums in relaying information to promote modification of ‘‘bad’’ behaviors and adoption of new, ‘‘healthier’’ ones. Limitations Several methodological issues need to be considered when interpreting the findings presented in this study. This study’s sample comprised students who volunteered to participate, and therefore may have been more likely to have an interest in matters related to nutrition than others. Also, students may have misreported their eating behaviors to be more socially desirable than they actually are. It also should be noted that the study comprised only one school, therefore, results are necessarily of a local nature and findings may differ from those of other regions or countries. There were, however, a number of strengths to the present study. Conclusions were based on responses from 57 students, which is relatively large for a qualitative study. There was a diverse range of students in the sample, not only from different genders, but also of different ages, and, probably, different classes and parental education levels. This study was of exploratory nature; results suggested that the qualitative approach generated valuable and interesting data that can be tested later on by other methods, such as a quantitative survey to be completed by a larger number of students. Additional work is necessary so that more solid conclusions can be obtained. References Almeida, S. S., Nascimento, P. C. B. D., & Quaioti, T. C. B. (2002). Quantidade e qualidade de produtos alimentı´ cios anunciados na televisa˜o brasileira. Revista de Sau´de Pu´blica, 36, 353–355. Arnas, Y. A. (2006). The effects of television food advertisement on children’s food purchasing requests. Pediatrics International, 48, 138–145. Bannon, K., & Schwartz, M. B. (2006). Impact of nutrition messages on children’s food choice: Pilot study. Appetite, 46, 124–129. Bardin, L. (2004). Ana´lise de Conteu´do. Lisboa: Edic- o˜es 70. Benn, J. (2002). Consumer education: educational considerations and perspectives. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 26, 169–177.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 18
G.M.R. Fiates et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 12–18
Birch, L. L. (1999). Development of food preferences. Annual Review of Nutrition, 19, 41–62. Borzekowski, D. L., & Robinson, T. N. (2001). The 30-second effect: an experiment revealing the impact of television commercials on food preferences of preschoolers. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 101, 42–46. Coon, K. A., Goldberg, J. G., Rogers, B. L., & Tucker, K. L. (2001). Relationships between use of television during meals and children’s food consumption patterns. Pediatrics, 107, 1–9. Coon, K. A., & Tucker, K. L. (2002). Television and children’s consumption patterns. A review of the literature. Minerva Pediatrica, 54, 423–436. De Assis, M. A. A., Rolland Cachera, M.-F., Grosseman, S., de Vasconcelos, F. A., Luna, M. E., Calvo, M. C., et al. (2005). Obesity, overweight and thinness in schoolchildren of the city of Florianopolis, Southern Brazil. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 59, 1015–1021. De Assis, M. A. A., Rolland-Cachera, M.-F., Vasconcelos, F. A. G., Bellisle, F., Calvo, M. C. M., Luna, M. E. P., et al. (2006). Overweight and thinness in 7–9 year old children from Floriano´polis, Southern Brazil: a comparison with a French study using similar protocol. Revista de Nutric- a˜o, 19, 299–308. Dennison, B. A., Russo, T. J., Burdick, P., & Jenkins, P. (2004). An intervention to reduce television viewing by preschool children. Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, 158, 170–176. Fisher, J. O., & Birch, L. L. (1999). Restricting access to a palatable food affects children’s behavioral response, food selection and intake. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 69, 1264–1272. Fisher, J. O., Mitchell, D. C., Smiciklas-Wright, H., & Birch, L. L. (2002). Parental influences on young girls fruit and vegetable, micronutrient, and fat intakes. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 102, 58–64. Ford, B. S., McDonald, T. E., Owens, A. S., & Robinson, T. N. (2002). Primary care interventions to reduce television viewing in AfricanAmerican children. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 22, 106–109. Francis, L. A., Lee, Y., & Birch, L. L. (2003). Parental weight status and girls’ television viewing, snacking and body mass indexes. Obesity Research, 11, 143–151. Gore, S. A., Foster, J. A., Di Lillo, V. G., Kirk, K., & West, D. S. (2003). Television viewing and snacking. Eating Behaviors, 4, 399–405. Gortmaker, S. L., Must, A., Sobol, A. M., Peterson, K., Colditz, G. A., Graham, A., et al. (1996). Television viewing as a cause of increasing obesity among children in the United States, 1986–1990. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 150, 356–362. Green, J., & Thorogood, N. (2004). Qualitative methods for health research. London: Sage. Halford, J. C. G., Gillespie, J., Brown, V., Pontin, E. E., & Dovey, T. M. (2004). Effect of television advertisements for foods on food consumption in children. Appetite, 42, 221–225.
Hancox, R. J., Milne, B. J., & Poulton, R. (2004). Association between child and adolescent television viewing and adult health: A longitudinal birth cohort study. Lancet, 364, 257–262. Harrison, K. (2005). Is ‘‘fat free’’ good for me? A panel study of television viewing and children’s nutritional knowledge and reasoning. Health Communication, 17, 117–132. Hart, K. H., Bishop, J. A., & Truby, H. (2002). An investigation into school children’s knowledge and awareness of food and nutrition. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 15, 129–140. Heary, C. M., & Hennessy, E. (2002). The use of focus group interviews in pediatric health care research. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 27, 47–57. Instituto Midiativa. Brasileiro veˆ TV mais de 5 horas por dia. [WWW page]. URL /www.midiativa.org.br/index.php/midiativa/content/ view/full/2717S. Jason, L. A., & Fries, M. (2004). Helping parents reduce children’s television viewing. Research on Social Work Practice, 14, 121–131. John, D. R. (1999). Consumer socialization of children: A retrospective look at twenty-five years of research. Journal of Consumer Research, 26, 1–42. Kuribayashi, A., Roberts, M. C., & Johnson, R. J. (2001). Actual nutritional information of products advertised to children and adults on Saturday. Children’s Health Care, 30, 309–322. McNeal, J. U. (1998). Tapping the three kids’ markets. American Demographics, 20, 37–41. McNeal, J. U. (2000). Children as consumers of commercial and social products. Washington, DC: Pan American Health Organization. O’Dea, J. A. (2003). Why do kids eat healthful food? Perceived benefits of and barriers to healthful eating and physical activity among children and adolescents. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 103, 497–501. Olivares, S. C., Albala, C. A., Garcia, F. B., & Jofre´, I. C. (1999). Publicidad televisiva y preferencias alimentarias en escolares de la Regio´n Metropolitana. Revista Me´dica de Chile, 127, 791–799. Olivares, S. C., Ya´n˜es, R., & Dı´ az, N. (2003). Publicidad de alimentos y conductas alimentarias en escolares de 51 a 81 ba´sico. Revista Chilena de Nutricio´n, 30, 36–42. Ruano, I. R., & Pujol, M. E. S. (1997). Ha´bitos de vida en una poblacio´n escolar de Mataro´ (Barcelona) asociados al nu´mero de veces diarias que se ve televisio´n y al consumo de azu´cares. Revista Espan˜ola de Salud Pu´blica, 71, 487–498. Santa Catarina. Lei n1 12.061, de 18 de dezembro de 2001. Dispo˜e sobre crite´rios de concessa˜o de servic- os de lanches e bebidas nas unidades educacionais, localizadas no Estado de Santa Catarina. Lex: Dia´rio Oficial do Estado de Santa Catarina, p. 1, 20 dez, 2001. Strasburger, V. C. (2004). Children, adolescents and the media. Current Problems in Pediatric and Adolescent Health Care, 34, 54–113. Valkenburg, P. M. (2000). Media and youth consumerism. Journal of Adolescent Health, 27(Suppl.), 52–56.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research report
Repeated cue exposure effects on subjective and physiological indices of chocolate craving Dinska Van Gucht, Debora Vansteenwegen, Tom Beckers, Dirk Hermans, Frank Baeyens, Omer Van den Bergh Department of Psychology, University of Leuven, Tiensestraat 102, 3000 Leuven, Belgium Received 2 February 2007; received in revised form 19 April 2007; accepted 9 May 2007
Abstract The aim of this study is to investigate the effects of repeated unreinforced exposure to chocolate cues in persons reporting chocolate craving. Participants in the experimental group (n ¼ 40) received 10 consecutive brief exposures to chocolate cues in each of two sessions, separated by 1–3 days. Control participants (n ¼ 18) received two exposures at the start and end of each session. Chocolate craving was measured (alternately) through subjective report and the amount of saliva secretion to chocolate cues. Results showed a between-sessions decrease in both craving measures in the experimental group, whereas no differences in craving between sessions were observed in the control group. These results provide evidence for the effects of cue exposure treatment in chocolate craving. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Chocolate craving; Cue exposure; Salivation
Introduction Food craving, which is defined as an intense desire or longing (Kozlowski & Wilkinson, 1987; Weingarten & Elston, 1990) to eat a particular food (Marlatt, 1987; Rozin, 1976), is a common phenomenon in the general population (Weingarten & Elston, 1991). In Western cultures, the food most frequently craved is chocolate, especially among women (Pelchat, 1997; Rogers & Smit, 2000; Rozin, Levine, & Stoess, 1991). Although for the majority of people chocolate craving is not harmful (Lafay et al., 2001), it may be subjectively experienced as unwanted, being an element of an unhealthy life style and possibly contributing to weight problems. In some cases, it may become a real problem when it rises to the level of binge eating (Kales, 1990). Therefore, it is important to gain insight into the craving process and to develop ways that can help to reduce chocolate craving (Kemps, Tiggemann, & Hart, 2005). Moreover, given that chocolate craving is highly prevalent Corresponding author.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (O. Van den Bergh). 0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.003
and, unlike for example alcohol dependency and binge eating (Jansen, 1998), much less confounded by psychiatric comorbidity, it allows craving and craving reduction techniques to be investigated in a relatively pure manner in easily accessible populations (Weingarten & Elston, 1991). Only a few studies have hitherto been devoted to the reduction of chocolate craving, none of which has yielded clear results. One study looked at suppression of cravingrelated thoughts, but this did not seem to have a substantial effect (Johnston, Bulik, & Anstiss, 1999). Kemps et al. (2005) recently found that visuo-spatial working memory-based techniques reduced imagery vividness and self-reported chocolate craving in both female chocolate cravers and non-cravers. However, contrary to what was predicted, irrelevant speech also reduced both vividness and craving, be it to a lesser extent. For any attempt to reduce chocolate craving, it is relevant to understand the critical cues and processes underlying the craving response to chocolate. Several accounts have been proposed (e.g., Rozin et al., 1991), which we will briefly discuss. Chocolate is known for its ‘‘melt in the mouth’’ sensation that is attributed to one of its main fat
ARTICLE IN PRESS 20
D. Van Gucht et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24
ingredients, cocoa butter. Chocolate is also high in sugar. The combination of sugar and fat has a particular appeal (Drewnowski & Greenwood, 1983). Chocolate also has a uniquely attractive aroma. As a result, the taste and flavor of chocolate have a high incentive value (Rozin et al., 1991). Comparing the role of sensory and pharmacological properties of chocolate revealed that the former but not the latter satisfied the craving response (Michener & Rozin, 1994). In line with this, chocolate cravers reported that non-chocolate substitutes were inadequate to abate their craving (Polivy, Coleman, & Herman, 2005; Weingarten & Elston, 1991). In sum, results suggest that pharmacological factors play little—if any—role in the satisfaction of craving (Rogers & Smit, 2000). Despite findings that depressed mood may increase chocolate craving (Willner et al., 1998) and that people report to self-medicate with chocolate (Schuman, Gitlin, & Fairbanks, 1987), a recent review revealed that the moodenhancing effect of chocolate consumption is short-lived and that chocolate prolongs a dysphoric mood when consumed for comforting (Parker, Parker, & Brotchie, 2006). Women often report a stronger craving for chocolate in their perimenstruum (e.g., Hill & Heaton-Brown, 1994), suggesting a role for sex hormones (Bruinsma & Taren, 1999). However, Spanish women reported much less premenstrual chocolate craving than American women, suggesting a cultural origin (Osman & Sobal, 2006; Zellner, Garriga-Trillo, Centeno, & Wadsworth, 2004). One way to frame this is by assuming that chocolate craving is triggered by classically conditioned food cues. Zellner and Edwards (2001) state that conditioning is strongly involved in the production of food cravings; neutral stimuli or cues that have been associated with food intake can, over time, elicit reactivity that can be experienced as craving for the food. So, with repeated consumption of chocolate during the perimenstruum, moods and typical feelings during this period may become conditioned cues for the high incentive value of the sensory properties of chocolate. Chocolate craving is then seen as a mediator of cue-induced eating. Craving or urge to use a given drug is considered an important source of maintenance and relapse in addiction literature (Drummond, Tiffany, Glautier, & Remington, 1995; Jansen, 1998). Exposure-based therapies, inspired by Pavlovian conditioning models of addiction, aim to extinguish this craving. These therapies consist of repeated exposures to drug cues while preventing drug use (response prevention) and have proven successful to extinguish craving. Given its success in the domain of alcohol abuse (Drummond et al., 1995), bulimia nervosa (Carter, McIntosh, Joyce, Frampton, & Bulik, 2006) and binge eating (Jansen, 1998; Jansen, Broekmate, & Heymans, 1992), the conditioning model of food craving (Jansen, 1998; Zellner & Edwards, 2001) seems to provide the best heuristic tool when trying to devise techniques to reduce chocolate craving. Specifically, Jansen et al. (1992) have
demonstrated cue exposure to be efficacious in binge eaters, reducing the binge frequency. Nevertheless, techniques for chocolate craving reduction based on the conditioning model have not been put to empirical test yet. In the present study, we repeatedly presented chocolate cues to chocolate cravers in a clinical analogue study in two consecutive sessions. Chocolate craving was measured in two ways and this alternately: By subjective report and by the amount of saliva secretion to chocolate cues, using the cotton roll method. This method appears to yield a sensitive, valid and reliable index of craving (Nederkoorn, de Wit, Smulders, & Jansen, 2001; Tuomisto et al., 1999; White, 1977). Research on addiction has shown that effects of exposure are often limited to the context in which exposure is conducted (e.g. Thewissen, Snijders, Havermans, van den Hout, & Jansen, 2006). Therefore, the experiment also contained a mood induction manipulation aimed at exploring to what extent reduction of craving would generalize to different mood contexts. However, our mood manipulation failed to induce the intended mood changes (see infra); therefore, the contextual control of chocolate craving could not be addressed. Method Participants Participants (n ¼ 58) were recruited on the basis of a questionnaire, administered to 335 students, that labeled them as chocolate cravers. They met the criterion for chocolate craver when they reported to (a) be ‘‘very bad’’/ ‘‘bad’’/‘‘rather bad’’ at postponing a chocolate craving, (b) ‘‘rather like’’/‘‘very much like’’ to gain more control over their chocolate craving and (c) find it ‘‘neutral’’/ ‘‘rather difficult’’/‘‘very difficult’’ to gain more control over their chocolate craving. All were female psychology students at the University of Leuven, aged between 20 and 24 years (M ¼ 20.71, SD ¼ 0.80). All participated on a voluntary basis. Measures Chocolate craving was measured, alternately, through subjective report and the amount of saliva secretion to chocolate cues. Subjective report Self-reported craving was measured using an online scale. The scale, presented on a computer screen in front of the participant, ran from bottom to top and ranged from 0 (no craving for chocolate at all) to 100 (extreme craving for chocolate). It was divided in 10 boxes representing 10 units each. Above the scale the question ‘‘How strong is your craving for chocolate at this moment?’’ appeared. During the time of an exposure trial (2 min), participants were instructed to rate their craving at any time, but at
ARTICLE IN PRESS D. Van Gucht et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24
least every time they heard a tone (every 30 s; at 0.50 , 10 , 1.50 and 20 into the trial). They were told that their craving could either change or not and that it was important to reevaluate their craving at every specific moment. Since participants hardly ever reported their craving in absence of the tones, only the four scores reported at the times of the tones were taken into account for the analyses. Per trial a craving score was calculated by taking the mean of those four scores. Saliva secretion The amount of salivation was measured by weighing the amount of saliva absorbed by rolls of cotton before and after application to the mouth. This amount can be interpreted as an indicator of craving (Nederkoorn et al., 2001). Participants were shown where and how to place the cotton rolls at fixed locations in the mouth, consistently in the same order (left, right, middle), and how to take them out. It was emphasized that swallowing needed to be restricted as much as possible. After each cotton roll measurement participants were instructed to take a little sip of water. Procedure The experiment consisted of two 1-h sessions with 1–3 days between sessions. Participants were instructed not to eat nor drink coffee 3 h prior to the sessions and to abstain from chocolate and other candies 24 h prior to the sessions. Each participant was asked beforehand what kind and brand of chocolate she preferred; this was then used for cue exposure. The experiment also implied mood induction manipulations in order to explore to what extent reduction of craving would generalize to different mood contexts. In the first session half of the participants were shown a film fragment (4 min, 40 s) from Dead poets society (Witt, Thomas, & Weir, 1989) intended to induce a negative mood. The other half watched two film fragments: one (3 min, 26 s) from A fish called Wanda (Shamberg & Crichton, 1988) and the other (3 min, 32 s) from There’s something about Mary (Farrelly & Farrelly, 1998) intended to induce a positive mood (clips were selected on the basis of film excerpts used in previous research by Schaefer, Nils, Sanchez, & Philippot, 2007). In the second session participants were instructed to look at both the negative movie clip and the two positive fragments, to see whether reduced craving would generalize to the same and a different mood context. The valence of the mood induction (first session) and the order (positive or negative mood induction; second session) were counterbalanced across participants. To measure emotional changes the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) Scales (Watson, Clark, & Tellegen, 1988) were used (Dutch validated version: Engelen, De Peuter, Victoir, Van Diest, & Van den Bergh, 2006). The mood manipulations did not yield the
21
intended effects1 and mood-related aspects will not be discussed further. First the two sessions for the experimental group (n ¼ 40) will be described. Then the procedural differences for the control group (n ¼ 18) will be mentioned. Session 1 Participants were first asked to fill out an informed consent form, a biographical questionnaire and the PANAS Scales. An exercise trial with the cotton rolls followed, which served as a baseline measurement of saliva secretion (BS ¼ baseline salivation). Following BS measurement, participants were exposed to chocolate for the first time. The chocolate (an unwrapped bar) was presented on a plate, which was placed behind the monitor, out of sight of the participant. When an exposure trial started, the experimenter placed the plate in front of the participant. At the end of each trial, the plate was again placed behind the monitor. All cue exposure trials lasted 27 min, during which time participants either had to report their craving online or salivation was measured. Participants were instructed to first look at the chocolate for 30 s, and to then hold the chocolate for another 30 s, followed by 1 min of constantly smelling the chocolate. At the end of the first trial only, participants were allowed—after smelling the chocolate—to taste a very small piece. Craving during the first exposure trial was measured by means of an online scale (C1 ¼ first online craving). A second exposure trial followed (S0 ¼ salivation measure) after approximately 1 min. After this trial, film fragments were shown, followed by four cue exposure trials. Craving was measured alternately by means of the cotton rolls and the online scale (S1, C2, S2, C3). Next, the same film fragments were presented and followed by another four cue exposure trials (S3, C4, S4, C5). The last trial (C5) lasted for 10 min (9 min of constant smelling, with a tone probing for online craving every 30 s) or until a participant rated her craving to be lower than 10 on the online scale. In sum, the first session consisted of 10 cue exposure trials with five salivation measurements and five online craving measurements, in the following order: (BS), C1, S0, (film), S1, C2, S2, C3, (film), S3, C4, S4, C5. At the end of the session participants were again asked to fill out the PANAS Scales. Session 2 This session was similar to the first session, with the following exceptions. Participants were now presented with both the negative and the positive mood movie clips. The first clip was presented between S0 and S1, the second between C3 and S3. An additional set of PANAS Scales 1 Apart from a significant induction effect in the NA-scores for session 1, F(1, 56) ¼ 4.93, po.05; our mood manipulations failed to result in reliable mood change effects. Consequently, mood induction was not included as a factor in statistical analyses.
ARTICLE IN PRESS D. Van Gucht et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24
Session 1 Session 2
80 60 40 20
Experimental group
Results Online craving scores As can be seen in Fig. 1, there was a significant decrease from session 1 to session 2 for the experimental group, F(1, 56) ¼ 35.14, po.001, whereas there was no difference between sessions for the control group, Fo1. The group session interaction was significant, F(1, 56) ¼ 11.91, po.01, but the group session trial interaction was not, F(2, 112) ¼ 1.54, n.s. In the experimental group, we observed no decrease in craving from start to end (C1–C5) in session 1, Fo1, and even an increase in session 2, F(1, 56) ¼ 7.59, po.01. From the beginning of the experiment (C1 in session 1) to the end (C5 in session 2), a significant decrease in reported craving was observed, F(1, 56) ¼ 6.08, po.05. In the control group, we saw an increase in reported craving from C1 to C5 both in session 1, F(1, 56) ¼ 6.42, 2
Right before the S0 measure, participants were instructed to taste a small piece of chocolate. Due to the chocolate tasting right before, the S0 trial can be seen as a maximal amount of saliva secreted and is therefore not included in the analysis.
C5
M(C2,C3,C4) Control group
Session 1 Session 2
1.60 1.50 1.40 1.30 1.20 1.10
Experimental group
Trial
S4
M(S1,S2,S3)
BS
S4
M(S1,S2,S3)
1.00 BS
A 2 2 3 (group session trial) ANOVA was performed on the amount of saliva secreted. The three trials that were included were (1) the BS, (2) the mean of S1, S2 and S3 since these were the three trials where the experimental group was exposed to chocolate whereas the control group was not [M(S1,S2,S3)], (3) and the last exposure trial S4.2 Similarly, a 2 2 3 (group session trial) ANOVA was run on the online craving scores, with the following three trials: (1) C1, (2) the mean of C2, C3 and C4 since these were the three trials where the experimental group was exposed to chocolate whereas the control group was not [M(C2,C3,C4)], (3) and the last exposure trial C5. We followed these ANOVAs up with planned comparisons to check for effects of exposure within and between sessions in both groups.
Trial
Fig. 1. Mean chocolate craving scores on the online scale ranging from 0 (no craving for chocolate at all) to 100 (extreme craving for chocolate) (+SE) for the experimental and control group, by session and trial, with C1 ¼ first online craving measure; M(C2,C3,C4) ¼ the mean of the trials C2, C3 and C4; C5 ¼ last online craving measurement.
Saliva secreted in grams
Data analysis
C1
C5
0 M(C2,C3,C4)
Control group Participants in the control group were treated in the same way as participants in the experimental group, except that they only received exposure to chocolate at the beginning of each session and at the end. More precisely, they were only exposed to chocolate at C1, S0, S4 and C5. Their craving was measured in the same way as for participants in the experimental group at the other trials (S1, C2, S2, C3, S3 and C4) but without chocolate exposure.
100
C1
was administered right before the second clip. The last exposure trial (C5) lasted 2 min.
Mean reported online craving
22
Control group
Fig. 2. Mean amount of saliva secreted in grams (+SE) for the experimental and control group, by session and trial, with BS ¼ baseline saliva; M(S1,S2,S3) ¼ the mean of the trials S1, S2 and S3; S4 ¼ last salivation measurement.
po.05, and in session 2, F(1, 56) ¼ 9.67, po.05. From the beginning of the experiment (C1 in session 1) to the end (C5 in session 2), a significant increase in reported craving was observed, F(1, 56) ¼ 4.18, po.01 [interaction between groups: F(1, 56) ¼ 9.43, po.01]. The mean reported craving at C2, C3 and C4 (when participants were not exposed) was significantly lower than at C1 and C5 (when exposure did take place) in both sessions, F(1, 56) ¼ 78.72, po.001. Note that subjective craving at C1 did not differ between groups in session 1, F(1, 56) ¼ 2.35, p4.05. Amount of salivation As can be seen in Fig. 2, there was a marginally significant decrease from session 1 to session 2 for the experimental group, F(1, 56) ¼ 3.52, p ¼ .07, whereas there was no difference between sessions at all for the control
ARTICLE IN PRESS D. Van Gucht et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24
23
group, Fo1. Similar to the online craving data, the mean amount of saliva secreted in session 2 was lower than in session 1 in the experimental group but not in the control group. However, neither the three-way interaction, nor the group by session interaction turned out significant, Fo1. Note that BS did not differ between groups in session 1, Fo1.
physiological, behavioral) for tracking extinction learning’’ (p. 165). Their plea is consistent with Bouton’s (2000) and Havermans and Jansen’s argument (2003) that learning theory can provide a strong model to conceptualize problems of maintenance and change of health-related behavior. The current experiment constitutes one of the first steps in this direction.
Discussion
Acknowledgments
In this clinical analogue study, chocolate cravers were repeatedly exposed to their favorite chocolate in two consecutive sessions in order to extinguish their cueinduced craving. Both subjective craving and the amount of saliva secretion were measured. In the experimental group, reported craving for chocolate was not reduced within a single session of repeated exposure to the cues, but did diminish between sessions and from the beginning of the experiment to the end. In contrast, in the control group, no differences between sessions were found and reported craving increased within both sessions and from the beginning to the end of the experiment. These results show that a cue-exposure manipulation was effective in reducing subjective craving in the experimental group and not in the control group. The data pattern that emerges for salivation was in line with these findings, rendering it unlikely that the subjective craving results would be due to mere demand. In general, our data are in accordance with a conditioning model in showing that exposure is effective to reduce chocolate craving. This mirrors the positive effects of exposure-based therapies for bulimia nervosa, alcoholism and phobias (e.g. Carter et al., 2006; Drummond et al., 1995; O¨st, 1997). However, also differences emerged. For example, a typical within-session pattern during exposure to fear cues in anxiety disorders implies an initial increase in fear reactions followed by a continuous decrease until the end of the exposure session, while fear is reduced across trials (Foa & Kozak, 1986). The present results are in line with the between-session, but not with the within-session part. Possibly, different expectations may play a role here: Exposure to fear cues is typically framed in a fear reduction context, whereas in the present study no clear information was given as to the course of the sessions. It is likely that at the end of a session participants were still expecting to receive chocolate, possibly leading to a within-session increase of craving. Another possible explanation is the short duration of our experiment (28 min in session 1; 20 min in session 2); Jansen et al. (1992) found that craving in binge eaters only extinguished after half an hour of cue exposure. Although cue exposure has been proven efficient for the treatment of alcoholism (Drummond et al., 1995), a review by Conklin and Tiffany (2002) concluded that no consistent evidence was available for the efficacy of cue exposure for the treatment of other addictions and that there is a need for ‘‘cue-reactivity work investigating the value of different response measures (e.g. self-report,
Debora Vansteenwegen and Tom Beckers are postdoctoral researchers of the Research Foundation—Flanders (FWO). References Bouton, M. E. (2000). A learning theory perspective on lapse, relapse, and the maintenance of behavior change. Health Psychology, 19, 57–63. Bruinsma, K., & Taren, D. L. (1999). Chocolate: Food or drug? Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 99, 1249–1256. Carter, F. A., McIntosh, V. V. W., Joyce, P. R., Frampton, C. M. A., & Bulik, C. M. (2006). Cue reactivity in bulimia nervosa: A useful selfreport approach. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 39, 694–699. Conklin, C. A., & Tiffany, S. T. (2002). Applying extinction research and theory to cue-exposure addiction treatments. Addiction, 97, 155–167. Drewnowski, A., & Greenwood, M. R. C. (1983). Cream and sugar: Human preferences for high-fat foods. Physiology and Behavior, 30, 629–633. Drummond, D. C., Tiffany, S. T., Glautier, S., & Remington, B. (1995). Addictive behaviour: Cue exposure theory and practice. New York: Wiley. Engelen, U., De Peuter, S., Victoir, A., Van Diest, I., & Van den Bergh, O. (2006). Verdere validering van de Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) en vergelijking van twee Nederlandstalige versies. [Further validation of the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) and comparison of two Dutch versions.]. Gedrag & Gezondheid, 34, 89–102. Farrelly, B., & Farrelly, P. (Directors/Co-screen writers). (1998). There’s something about Mary [Motion picture]. United States: Twentieth Century Fox. Foa, E. B., & Kozak, M. J. (1986). Emotional processing of fear: Exposure to corrective information. Psychological Bulletin, 99, 20–35. Havermans, R. C., & Jansen, A. T. M. (2003). Increasing the efficacy of cue exposure in preventing relapse of addictive behavior. Addictive Behaviors, 28, 989–994. Hill, A. J., & Heaton-Brown, L. (1994). The experience of food craving: A prospective investigation in healthy women. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 38, 801–814. Jansen, A. (1998). A learning model of binge eating: Cue reactivity and cue exposure. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 36, 257–272. Jansen, A., Broekmate, J., & Heymans, M. (1992). Cue-exposure vs selfcontrol in the treatment of binge eating: A pilot study. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 30, 235–241. Johnston, L., Bulik, C. M., & Anstiss, V. (1999). Suppressing thoughts about chocolate. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 26, 21–27. Kales, E. F. (1990). Macronutrient analysis of binge eating in bulimia. Physiology and Behavior, 48, 837–840. Kemps, E., Tiggemann, M., & Hart, G. (2005). Chocolate cravings are susceptible to visuo-spatial interference. Eating Behaviors, 6, 101–107. Kozlowski, L. T., & Wilkinson, D. A. (1987). Use and misuse of the concept of craving by alcohol, tobacco, and drug researchers. British Journal of Addiction, 82, 31–36. Lafay, L., Thomas, F., Mennen, L., Charles, M. A., Eschwege, E., Borys, J., et al. (2001). Gender differences in the relation between food
ARTICLE IN PRESS 24
D. Van Gucht et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 19–24
cravings and mood in adult community: Results from the Fleurbaix Laventie Ville Sante Study. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 29, 195–204. Marlatt, G. A. (1987). Craving notes. British Journal of Addiction, 82, 42–43. Michener, W., & Rozin, P. (1994). Pharmacological versus sensory factors in the satiation of chocolate craving. Physiology and Behavior, 56, 419–422. Nederkoorn, C., de Wit, T., Smulders, F. T. Y., & Jansen, A. (2001). Experimental comparison of different techniques to measure saliva. Appetite, 37, 251–252. Osman, J. L., & Sobal, J. (2006). Chocolate cravings in American and Spanish individuals: Biological and cultural influences. Appetite, 47, 290–301. O¨st, L. G. (1997). Rapid treatment of specific phobias. In G. Davey (Ed.), Phobias A handbook of theory, research and treatment (pp. 227–246). Chichester: Wiley. Parker, G., Parker, I., & Brotchie, H. (2006). Mood state effects of chocolate. Journal of Affective Disorders, 92, 149–159. Pelchat, M. L. (1997). Food cravings in young and elderly adults. Appetite, 28, 103–113. Polivy, J., Coleman, J., & Herman, C. P. (2005). The effect of deprivation on food cravings and eating behavior in restrained and unrestrained eaters. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 38, 301–309. Rogers, P. J., & Smit, H. J. (2000). Food craving and food ‘‘addiction’’: A critical review of the evidence from a biopsychosocial perspective. Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior, 66, 3–14. Rozin, P. (1976). The selection of food by rats, humans, and other animals. In J. S. Rosenblatt, R. A. Hinde, E. Shaw, & C. Beer (Eds.), Advances in the study of behavior (Vol. 6, pp. 21–74). New York: Academic Press. Rozin, P., Levine, E., & Stoess, C. (1991). Chocolate craving and liking. Appetite, 17, 199–212. Schaefer, A., Nils, F., Sanchez, X., & Philippot, P. (2007). A multi-criteria assessment of emotional films, submitted for publication.
Schuman, M., Gitlin, M. J., & Fairbanks, L. (1987). Sweets, chocolate, and atypical depressive traits. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 175, 491–495. Shamberg, M. (Producer), & Crichton, C. (Director). (1988). A fish called Wanda [Motion picture]. United States: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer. Thewissen, R., Snijders, S. J. B. D., Havermans, R. C., van den Hout, M., & Jansen, A. (2006). Renewal of cue-elicited urge to smoke: Implications for cue exposure treatment. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 44, 1441–1449. Tuomisto, T., Hetherington, M. M., Morris, M. F., Tuomisto, M. T., Turjanmaa, V., & Lappalainen, R. (1999). Psychological and physiological characteristics of sweet food ‘‘addiction’’. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 25, 169–175. Watson, D., Clark, L. A., & Tellegen, A. (1988). Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: The PANAS Scales. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 54, 1063–1070. Weingarten, H., & Elston, D. (1990). The phenomenology of food cravings. Appetite, 15, 231–246. Weingarten, H., & Elston, D. (1991). Food cravings in a college population. Appetite, 17, 167–175. White, K. D. (1977). Salivation: A review and experimental investigation of major techniques. Psychophysiology, 14, 203–212. Willner, P., Benton, D., Brown, E., Cheeta, S., Davies, G., Morgan, J., et al. (1998). ‘‘Depression’’ increases ‘‘craving’’ for sweet rewards in animal and human models of depression and craving. Psychopharmacology, 136, 272–283. Witt, P. J., & Thomas, T. (Producers), & Weir, P. (Director). (1989). Dead poets society [Motion picture]. United States: Buena Vista Pictures. Zellner, D. A., & Edwards, E. M. (2001). Conditioning models of food craving. In M. M. Hetherington (Ed.), Food cravings and addiction (pp. 365–390). Surrey UK: Leatherhead Publishing. Zellner, D. A., Garriga-Trillo, A., Centeno, S., & Wadsworth, E. (2004). Chocolate craving and the menstrual cycle. Appetite, 42, 119–121.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research report
Validation of a scale for the assessment of food cravings among smokers Benjamin A. Tolla,, Nicole A. Katulakb, Pamela Williams-Piehotab,1, Stephanie O’Malleya a
Department of Psychiatry, Yale University School of Medicine, 1 Long Wharf Drive—Box 18, New Haven, CT 06511, USA b Department of Psychology, Yale University, 1 Long Wharf Drive—Box 18, New Haven, CT 06511, USA Received 8 May 2007; accepted 11 May 2007
Abstract Weight gain associated with smoking cessation impedes attempts to quit smoking and may lead to obesity. One factor that might contribute to weight gain is cravings for sweet or rich foods. To date, no reliable measure exists for evaluating these cravings. The purpose of the current study was to validate an assessment of craving for sweet or rich foods for use among smokers. With a sample of 385 smokers enrolled in a clinical trial for smoking cessation, the study examined the factor structure, internal consistency, and convergent and predictive validity of the Questionnaire on Craving for Sweet or Rich Foods (QCSRF). A two-factor model best represented the data. Factor 1 contained six items assessing perceptions about the ability of sweet or rich foods to relieve negative affect and about self-control over eating. Factor 2 contained three items assessing the intensity of cravings. Both factors demonstrated high internal consistency and good convergent and predictive validity. These results suggest the QCSRF is a reliable and valid measure for examining cravings for sweet or rich foods among smokers. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Food craving; Sweet; Rich; Smoking; Weight gain
Introduction People who quit smoking gain an average of 10 to 13 pounds within the first 1 to 2 years of quitting (Hudmon, Gritz, Clayton, & Nisenbaum, 1999; Klesges et al., 1997). This weight gain often prevents successful attempts to quit smoking (Borrelli & Mermelstein, 1998; Meyers, Klesges, Winders, Ward, Peterson, & Eck, 1997; Ockene et al., 2000) and may lead to obesity (Koh-Banerjee et al., 2003). Postcessation weight gain has been attributed to several processes, including changes in metabolism related to a reduction in nicotine intake (Perkins, 1992) and an increase in the body weight set point among smokers who quit (Cabanac & Frankham, 2002; Perkins, 1993). Another primary contributing factor to weight gain after quitting smoking is eating more (Perkins, 1993). After smoking cessation, individuals may eat more calorie-dense foods Corresponding author. Tel.: +203 974 5767; fax: +203 974 5790.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (B.A. Toll). Pamela Williams-Piehota, Ph.D. is now at Research Triangle Institute, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina. 1
0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.001
(Grunberg, 1982; Hall, McGee, Tunstall, Duffy, & Benowitz, 1989) and more total calories per day (e.g, Hatsukami, LaBounty, Hughes, & Laine, 1993; Perkins, Epstein, & Pastor, 1990; Spring, Wurtman, Gleason, Wurtman, & Kessler, 1991). Increases in caloric intake during smoking abstinence tend to occur in the presence of simultaneous cigarette and food cravings (Kos, Hasenfratz, & Battig, 1996), and in general, increased caloric consumption has been associated with food craving, particularly craving for sweet or rich foods (Mercer & Holder, 1997). Research on food craving has been somewhat scarce (see Weingarten & Elston, 1990 for a review) and specific to studies involving bulimics (Waters, Hill, & Waller, 2001), menstruating (Cohen, Sherwin, & Fleming, 1987; Kurzer, 1997; Michener, Rozin, Freeman, & Gale, 1999) or pregnant women (Worthington-Roberts, Little, Lambert, & Wu, 1989), and ‘‘chocolate addicts’’ (Bruinsma & Taren, 1999; Macdiarmid & Hetherington, 1995). However, this limited literature on food craving among these specific populations bears many similarities to larger bodies of research on craving in other domains (Weingarten & Elston, 1990). Research on craving for cigarettes
ARTICLE IN PRESS 26
B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
(Heishman, Singleton, & Moolchan, 2003; Shadel, Niaura, & Abrams, 2004; Willner, Hardman, & Eaton, 1995), alcohol (Sinha & O’Malley, 1999), and other drugs of abuse (Weinstein, Feldtkeller, Malizia, Wilson, Bailey, & Nutt, 1998) is far more plentiful and provides a window into the areas of food craving that have yet to be explored. One such topic that has been investigated only minimally in food craving research is its conceptualization. That is, does craving represent a unified construct, or does it have a multidimensional nature? A review of drug craving measures supports the idea that craving is best described and assessed in terms of multiple constructs (Sayette, Shiffman, Tiffany, Niaura, Martin, & Shadel, 2000; Tiffany & Drobes, 1991). Accordingly, studies on cigarette and marijuana use have conceptualized craving with separate constructs relating to the intensity of desires or cravings, the anticipation of the immediate effects of fulfilling cravings or urges, and the intentions to satisfy these cravings (Heishman, Singleton, & Moolchan, 2003; Singleton, Trotman, Zavahir, Taylor, & Heishman, 2002; Tiffany, 1990). The Food Craving Questionnaire (FCQ; Cepeda-Benito, Gleaves, Williams, & Erath, 2000), used primarily in eating disorders research, also characterizes craving as multidimensional, with factors representing constructs similar to those used to conceptualize drug craving. Another well-researched aspect of cravings for tobacco and other drugs, which has shed some light on preliminary food craving research, involves the biochemical mechanisms hypothesized to underlie craving. Several neurological pathways have been implicated in drug use, craving, and addiction including those related to neurotransmitters such as dopamine, opioid peptides, serotonin, GABA, and glutamate (Koob, 2000). Like drug craving, craving for foods, especially those high in sugar and fat, may also involve the opioid reward system (e.g., Drewnowski, 1992, Mercer & Holder, 1997) and the serotoninergic system (Wurtman & Wurtman, 1995). In particular, changes in endogenous opioid activity may elicit food craving and result from food intake (Mercer & Holder, 1997), and certain levels of brain serotonin may trigger cravings for foods rich in carbohydrates and fats and result from satisfying these cravings (Wurtman & Wurtman, 1995). The notion that the same biological processes and chemicals associated with cravings for substances of abuse are implicated in cravings for sweet or rich foods is of particular interest to researchers of smoking cessation and weight gain. Because both eating sweet, rich foods and smoking may affect levels of endogenous opioids and serotonin, cravings for sweet or rich foods and cigarette cravings may co-occur during attempts to quit smoking. Furthermore, satisfaction of either type of craving may alleviate the need to satisfy the other. Accordingly, several controlled studies have shown that food deprivation increases self-administration of nicotine (de la Garza & Johanson, 1987; Donny, Caggiula, Mielke, Jacobs, Rose, & Sved, 1998) and nicotine craving (Saules, Pomerleau,
Snedecor, Brouwer, & Rosenberg, 2004) and that smoking deprivation increases food consumption (Hatsukami, LaBounty, Hughes, & Laine, 1993), particularly that of sweet foods (Rodin, 1987). Hence, some smokers attempting cessation may experience cravings for sugary foods, which tend to be high in fat and calories and to lead to weight gain. Although research on the relationship between smoking cessation and sweet cravings is equivocal (e.g., Pomerleau, Garcia, Drewnowski, & Pomerleau, 1991), studies indicating that glucose may reduce cigarette cravings and withdrawal discomfort after quitting smoking (McRobbie & Hajek, 2004; West, 2001) support this idea. Despite studies that point to a relationship between smoking and craving for sweet or rich foods, a standard scale for testing this relationship or these types of cravings has not been developed. Various measures of food craving have been created for specific use among eating-disordered and other populations (e.g., Gendall, Joyce, Sullivan, & Bulik, 1998), and scales have been designed to measure cravings very narrowly with lists of specific foods (Harvey, Wing, & Mullen, 1993; White, Whisenhunt, Williamson, Greenway, & Netemeyer, 2002) or very broadly with questions about food craving in general (Cepeda-Benito, Gleaves, Williams, & Erath, 2000). Still, no published scale exists to assess cravings for sweet or rich foods, despite evidence suggesting that foods from this category may be craved often, particularly among smokers, and may contribute largely to excess caloric intake and weight gain associated with quitting smoking. Thus, the purpose of the current study was to refine and validate a self-report questionnaire for the assessment of craving for sweet or rich foods among smokers. To this end, this study examines the factor structure, internal consistency, and convergent and predictive validity of the Questionnaire on Cravings for Sweet or Rich Foods (QCSRF).
Method Participants The study sample included 385 daily smokers (48.1% female; 87.3% white) enrolled in a clinical trial comparing the effectiveness of the nicotine patch in combination with placebo or naltrexone for smoking cessation (O’Malley et al., 2006). Participants were eligible for the trial if they were at least 18 years of age, smoked an average of at least 20 cigarettes per day for at least one year, and had a baseline expired carbon monoxide (CO) level of at least 10 ppm. Participants were excluded for unstable medical or psychiatric problems, current alcohol dependence, or opiate use. The mean age of eligible participants was 45.95 (SD ¼ 11.17), and the mean number of cigarettes smoked per day was 27.70 (SD ¼ 10.30). On average, participants reported having smoked for 28.67 years (SD ¼ 11.09).
ARTICLE IN PRESS B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
Materials The Questionnaire on Craving for Sweet or Rich Foods (QCSRF) is a 14-item, self-report measure adapted from the Alcohol Urge Questionnaire (Bohn, Krahn, & Staehler, 1995) by M.J. Bohn and D. Krahn (personal communications), who originally developed these items to assess food cravings among alcohol dependent individuals whose reported cravings for sweet and rich foods increase after abstaining from alcohol. The QCSRF contains one question on craving sweet or rich foods ‘‘at this moment’’ and five questions on craving these foods ‘‘during the past week,’’ which are rated on a seven-point scale from ‘‘none at all’’ to ‘‘more than ever.’’ Eight additional questions assess current cravings and are formatted according to the Alcohol Urge Questionnaire (Bohn, Krahn, & Staehler, 1995), with cravings rated on a seven-point Likert-type scale from ‘‘strongly disagree’’ to ‘‘strongly agree’’. The Weight Control Subscale of the Smoking Consequences Questionnaire-Adult (SCQ; Copeland, Brandon, & Quinn, 1995) is a 5-item subscale of the 55-item selfreport SCQ that assesses nicotine expectancy factors (negative consequences, positive reinforcement, sensory satisfaction, negative reinforcement, negative affect reduction, and weight control). Subjects rate the likelihood of each item on a 10-point Likert scale from 0 to 9. The SCQ has been validated among current smokers, ex-smokers, and individuals entering smoking cessation treatment and has demonstrated good reliability (subscale coefficient alphas ranged from 0.83 to 0.96.) Scores on the Weight Control Subscale of the SCQ are consistently higher for women than men (Cepeda-Benito & Ferrer, 2000; Copeland, Brandon, & Quinn, 1995). The Dieting and Bingeing Severity Scale (DBSS; Kurth, Krahn, Nairn, & Drewnowski, 1995) is a 25-item survey that classifies individuals according to the frequency and severity of dieting and bingeing behaviors. The DBSS has been validated with the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IIIR (SCID) in a sample of college women and has demonstrated adequate reliability (Cronbach’s alpha ¼ 0.77). The DBSS is useful for identifying risk factors for developing eating disorders including binge eating, excessive weight control behaviors, and extreme concerns about eating and body weight/shape. Individuals with excessive concerns about weight and shape are identified according to their responses to the following three items: ‘‘I feel out of control when I eat’’; ‘‘I am terrified of gaining weight’’; and ‘‘I feel satisfied with the shape of my body’’. These items have the following descriptors: ‘‘never’’, ‘‘rarely’’, ‘‘sometimes’’, ‘‘often’’, ‘‘always’’. To meet criteria for excessive concerns, respondents need to endorse at least two of these questions as either ‘‘often’’ or ‘‘always’’ on the first two questions or ‘‘never’’ or ‘‘rarely’’ on the third question. Basic demographic information (e.g., age, gender, and race) and smoking background were assessed at baseline. Smoking background included current smoking status as well as smoking history, such as number of cigarettes
27
smoked per day, number of years smoked, number and length of quit attempts, and amount of weight gained in previous attempts to quit smoking. The Timeline Followback interview method (Sobell & Sobell, 1992, 2003) was used to obtain reports of daily cigarette use at baseline and during treatment. Carbon monoxide levels (CO) were also obtained to verify smoking abstinence. Procedure The QCSRF, DBSS (Kurth et al., 1995), and the Weight Control Subscale of the SCQ (Copeland, Brandon, & Quinn, 1995) were administered, as parts of a larger battery of questionnaires, to all participants as baseline assessments before they attempted to quit smoking. At intake and at each of the six weekly appointments during treatment, weight, carbon monoxide levels (CO) and reports of daily cigarette use were obtained. The QCSRF was readministered at each of these appointments during treatment. During treatment, all subjects received 21 mg transdermal nicotine patches for six weeks, beginning on the day they were scheduled to quit smoking. In addition, subjects were randomized to receive either placebo naltrexone or one of three doses of active naltrexone beginning on the day after their quit date. Smoking abstinence during treatment was defined as no smoking, not even a puff, and was verified by an exhaled CO level of 10 ppm or less. Additional details about the study can be found in O’Malley et al. (2006). Baseline data for the entire sample was used to investigate the factor structure and the convergent validity of the QCSRF. Predictive validity was tested only for those in the placebo naltrexone group (n ¼ 90). Results Factor analysis A principal components analysis with varimax rotation was performed on the 14 items comprising the QCSRF using SPSS 11.0 for Windows (SPSS, Inc., 2000). Rotation was used to enhance the scientific utility and interpretability of the component solution (Tabachnick & Fidell, 1996). This analysis revealed three factors with eigenvalues greater than 1, accounting for 66.1% of the total variance. However, the scree plot demonstrated a break in slope between components 2 and 3, suggesting a two-factor solution (Zwick & Velicer, 1986). In addition, the third component accounted for only 7.5% of the variance and included only two items with meaningful loadings. Therefore, a second principal components analysis was conducted with varimax rotation that forced a two-factor solution. To demonstrate good simple structure, only items that loaded over 0.40 on one factor and less than 0.40 on all other factors were assigned to factors (Hatcher, 1994). Factor 1 contained six items, and Factor 2 contained
ARTICLE IN PRESS 28
B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
three items. These items and their loadings are displayed in Table 1. The content of the items from each factor was examined and used to develop factor interpretations and subscale/ factor names. Factor 1 appeared to assess perceptions about the ability of sweet or rich foods to relieve negative affect and about levels of self-control over eating. Therefore, this factor was named ‘‘Relief/Control.’’ Higher scores on this factor represented higher expectations that food would relieve negative affect and lower expectations that one would have control over eating. Factor 2 measured the intensity of desire for sweet or rich food in the past week; therefore, this factor was named ‘‘Intensity.’’ Higher scores on these items related to more intense urges. Reliability In order to evaluate the degree of homogeneity or consistency of the items within the scale for each factor, alpha reliability coefficients were calculated. Internalconsistency reliability of the QCSRF was good for both the Relief/Control Factor (coefficient alpha ¼ 0.87) and the Intensity Factor (coefficient alpha ¼ 0.90; DeVellis, 1991). Convergent validity Research suggests that individuals who engage in weight control efforts or who are concerned about controlling their weight experience food cravings more often than individuals who are not concerned about controlling their weight (Gendall, Sullivan, Joyce, Fear, & Bulik, 1997; Lafay et al., 2001; Pelchat, 1997). Therefore, we compared QCSRF scores to scores on the Weight Control Subscale of the SCQ (Copeland, Brandon, & Quinn, 1995) and on the
Dieting and Bingeing Severity Scale (Kurth et al., 1995) in order to examine convergent validity (the evidence of similarity between two related constructs; DeVellis, 1991). For the SCQ, we first classified participants into two groups based on their SCQ Weight Control subscale scores: those who smoked for weight control (i.e., weightcontrol smokers; the top third of the sample) and those who did not (i.e., non-weight-control smokers; the bottom third of the sample). Then, QCSRF scores were analyzed using independent samples t-tests for each factor. For the Relief/Control Factor, there was a significant difference between the groups, t (256) ¼ 3.56, po0.05, with weightcontrol smokers having higher scores (M ¼ 8.71, SD ¼ 4.37) as compared to non-weight-control smokers (M ¼ 6.85, SD ¼ 4.01). For the Intensity Factor, there was also a significant difference between groups, t (257) ¼ 2.83, po0.05, with weight-control smokers again having higher scores (M ¼ 12.89, SD ¼ 7.16) as compared to the non-weight-control group (M ¼ 10.52, SD ¼ 6.21). These results support the idea that food cravings are experienced more in individuals who smoke for weight control and provide evidence of good convergent validity for both factors of the QCSRF. We then classified individuals according to whether or not they had excessive concerns about weight and body shape based on DBSS scores. Individuals who met DBSS criteria for excessive weight concern had higher Relief/ Control Factor scores (M ¼ 14.51, SD ¼ 8.72) and higher Intensity Factor scores (M ¼ 9.00, SD ¼ 5.03) than those who did not meet these criteria (M ¼ 11.07, SD ¼ 6.14), t (372) ¼ 3.32, po0.05, and (M ¼ 7.51, SD ¼ 4.07), t (370) ¼ 2.24, po0.05, for each of these factors respectively. Similarly, those who indicated on the DBSS that they had ever exercised for weight control reported more intense food cravings (M ¼ 8.13, SD ¼ 4.15), as indicated by higher Intensity Factor scores, than those who
Table 1 Rotated two-factor matrix for the questionnaire on craving for sweet or rich foods (N ¼ 375) Item
1. Rate the intensity of desire for sweet or rich food you feel at this moment. 2. Rate your strongest desire for sweet or rich food during the past week. 3. Rate how intense your desire for sweet or rich food was, overall, during the past week. 4. To what extent have you thought about sweet or rich food? 5. When you have smelled sweet or rich food or seen someone eating or advertisements for food, how much have you been able to taste it? 6. When you have passed by a grocery or other food store, how much do you feel a ‘‘need’’ to eat sweet or rich food? 7. Having something sweet and rich to eat would make me feel less depressed. 8. I could easily control how much sweet and rich food I ate right now. 9. I crave something sweet and rich to eat right now. 10. I would not enjoy having something sweet and rich right now. 11. Having something sweet and rich to eat would make me happier now. 12. I have an urge for something sweet and rich to eat. 13. I would be less irritable now if I could have something sweet and rich to eat. 14. I would not be able to control how much rich and sweet food I ate if I had something here to eat.
Relief/control factor
Intensity factor
0.54 0.09 0.23 0.29 0.45
0.56 0.88 0.87 0.84 0.57
0.51
0.63
0.62 0.32 0.77 0.15 0.81 0.78 0.83 0.54
0.32 0.38 0.33 0.34 0.21 0.27 0.15 0.28
Note. Varimax rotation method was used. Bold items were assigned to factors. Italicized items loaded on both factors and were not assigned.
ARTICLE IN PRESS B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
had never exercised for weight control (M ¼ 6.89, SD ¼ 4.23), t (370) ¼ 2.75, po0.05. Those whose DBSS responses indicated that they had ever had an eating binge reported higher Relief/Control Factor scores (M ¼ 12.86, SD ¼ 7.79) than those who had never had one (M ¼ 10.92, SD ¼ 5.90), t (372) ¼ 2.64, po0.05. Accordingly, DBSS reports of more frequent dieting were also associated with higher Relief/Control Factor scores r (374) ¼ 0.11, po0.05 and higher Intensity Factor scores r (372) ¼ 0.11, po0.05.
29
quit smoking during the first week had significantly lower scores (M ¼ 11.05; SD ¼ 5.87) than those who reported smoking (M ¼ 14.23; SD ¼ 8.49), t (84) ¼ 2.01, po0.05. Similarly, there was a trend for participants who reported quitting to have lower Intensity Factor scores (M ¼ 7.42; SD ¼ 4.13) than those who smoked (M ¼ 9.08; SD ¼ 4.69), t (84) ¼ 1.64, p ¼ 0.10. These findings indicate that scores on both factors of the QCSRF are associated with quitting smoking, showing evidence of good predictive validity for the measure.
Predictive validity Gender differences In order to examine predictive validity, we analyzed how QCSRF scores related to weight gain and to success at quitting smoking using data from the participants in the placebo group. First, because smoking cessation is associated with weight gain (Hudmon et al., 1999; Klesges et al., 1997), which could be related in part to eating in response to cravings, we investigated the convergence of the QCSRF with weight gain. When we examined weight gain reported during prior attempts at smoking cessation, we found that higher Intensity Factor scores at baseline (i.e., week 0) were associated with the reported amount of weight gained in previous quit attempts r (289) ¼ 0.16, po0.05. We then examined the relationship between weight gain from baseline to week 6 for successful quitters in the placebo group only (n ¼ 35) and the QCSRF, using area under the curve scores. When attempting to detect relationships between repeated measures and another variable, the ‘‘area under the curve’’ (AUC) can be calculated to account for multiple time points. One advantage of using this method is that multiple comparisons, which represent problems for statistical analyses, are not needed. Using a standard method, we computed the AUC for all QCSRF time points (Pruessner, Kirschbaum, Meinlschmid, & Hellhammer, 2003). We then used a median split to classify subjects with regard to weight gain (i.e., participants that gained 5 pounds or less and those that gained over 5 pounds) and compared these two groups. These analyses did not show a relationship between AUC for the Relief/Control Factor. However, participants who gained less weight over the course of the study treatment had somewhat higher AUC scores on the Intensity Factor (M ¼ 322.00, SD ¼ 145.87) than those who gained more weight (M ¼ 245.75, SD ¼ 146.58), t (29) ¼ 1.45, p ¼ 0.16, although this effect was nonsignificant. The lack of significant relationships between the QCSRF factors and weight gain may have been due to the restricted range of weight gain during the initial weeks of quitting (week 6 weight change: M ¼ 4.40, SD ¼ 3.89) and the small sample size. We then examined whether or not QCSRF scores would differ for participants who successfully abstained from smoking over the first week of treatment (n ¼ 60) compared to participants who were unsuccessful in maintaining smoking abstinence during this period (n ¼ 26). For the Relief/Control Factor, participants who
Research has shown that women, more often than men, experience food cravings in general (Lafay et al., 2001) and cravings for sweets more than savory foods (Pelchat, 1997; Weingarten & Elston, 1991; Zellner, Garriga-Trillo, Rohm, Centeno, & Parker, 1999). Although these studies included samples from the general population, which tends to consist of only a minority of smokers, we hypothesized that females in our smoking sample would also exhibit stronger cravings than male smokers. To test this prediction, we compared scores between women and men on the two factors of the QCSRF. As expected, women exhibited higher Intensity Factor scores (M ¼ 8.14, SD ¼ 4.67) than men (M ¼ 7.25, SD ¼ 3.69), t (374) ¼ 2.05, po0.05. However, women and men did not differ significantly in Relief/Control Factor scores. Discussion The goal of the current study was to refine and validate a food craving measure, the Questionnaire on Craving for Sweet or Rich Foods (QCSRF), for use among smokers. Psychometric analyses revealed two factors, one measuring perceptions about the ability of sweet or rich food to relieve negative affect and about self-control over eating and the other assessing the intensity of urges. The emergence of these two factors is consistent with research on craving for various drugs (Heishman, Singleton, & Moolchan, 2003; Singleton et al., 2002; Tiffany, 1990) and with findings from a measure of food craving used in research on bulimia (Cepeda-Benito, Gleaves, Williams, & Erath, 2000). In addition, the QCSRF demonstrated high internal consistency, and evidence was found for good convergent validity with measures of weight control and measures of dieting and bingeing behavior. Gender differences consistent with previous research (Lafay et al., 2001; Pelchat, 1997; Weingarten & Elston, 1991; Zellner et al., 1999) also emerged for the Intensity Factor of the QCSRF. Good predictive validity was also demonstrated by showing an association between QCSRF scores and quitting smoking and past weight gain, but not with weight gained during the current quit attempt. Despite the significant association of QCSRF scores and weight gain during previous quit attempts, reports of craving during treatment did not significantly predict weight gain during
ARTICLE IN PRESS 30
B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
treatment. Although this may be due to the restricted range of weight gain and the small sample size of the placebo group, this finding is in line with other research that shows a variable relationship between smoking cessation and weight gain (e.g., Filozof, Fernandez-Pinilla, & FernandezCruz, 2004). The failure to find a closer correspondence between food cravings and weight gain is perhaps not surprising because individuals may engage in a range of behaviors that may ultimately influence how much weight they gain, for example, eating in response to craving, restricting food intake, or increasing exercise. Moreover, individuals with high food craving may resume smoking either to directly suppress weight gain or because the combined effort to resist eating and smoking diminishes their ability to succeed at smoking cessation by depleting their self-control resources (Baumeister, Bratslavsky, Muraven, & Tice, 1998; Perkins, 1994; Perkins et al., 2001). Consistent with the hypothesis that food craving will predict smoking cessation failure, our study found that those who were unable to successfully maintain abstinence from smoking in the first week had higher food craving scores than those who were successful. These findings suggest that the QCSRF may provide a tool for investigating how food cravings and strategies to limit weight gain influence weight gain and the ability to quit smoking. This research could help identify and intervene with those smokers for whom cravings are a significant barrier to smoking cessation. The present study had several limitations. First, many of the effect sizes of the indices of reliability and validity were small. However, smoking cessation research has clearly shown that small effects are often clinically relevant. For instance, a recent review of over 100 clinical trials of Nicotine Replacement Therapy revealed a small (Odds Ratio ¼ 1.77; CI ¼ 1.66–1.88) but clinically relevant effect (Silagy, Lancaster, Stead, Mant, & Fowler, 2004). Second, the sample for the study was limited to participants enrolled in a smoking cessation clinical trial and all received nicotine patches; additional validation of the scale using a sample of smokers not actively trying to quit or smokers who quit without the use of a medication may be beneficial. Third, because this was a preliminary investigation of the QCSRF and naltrexone treatment may have affected food cravings (Zimmerman, Rechlin, Plaskacewicz, Plaskacewicz, Barocka, Wildt, & Kaschka, 1997), we limited some of our analyses to the placebo group. Future studies should test the reliability of the QCSRF at multiple points in time prior to quitting smoking as well as compare QCSRF scores of smokers before and after cessation attempts and at various follow-ups. A fourth limitation involves the questionnaire wording, specifically the terms ‘‘sweet or rich foods.’’ This wording was initially chosen because food craving research shows that sugary and fatty foods (e.g., chocolate) are those most frequently craved (Hill & Heaton-Brown, 1994), especially in the United States (Zellner et al., 1999). However, use of the word ‘‘or’’ makes it impossible to know the types of
foods and their macronutrient composition. This is particularly important given that the serotonin effect of carbohydrate intake may only occur in the absence of protein (Wurtman & Wurtman, 1995). Also, the terms ‘‘cravings,’’ ‘‘sweet,’’ and ‘‘rich’’ were not defined for the subjects in the study, despite multiple possible interpretations of their meanings. However, these terms were used in all QCSRF questions, so any errors of interpretation were likely constant across conditions. Fifth, the QCSRF only measures cravings for foods classified as sweet or rich, whereas urges for other foods may also contribute to weight gain in smokers attempting to quit. For example, while women in studies primarily consisting of nonsmokers tend to crave sweet more than savory foods, the opposite may be true for men (Pelchat, 1997; Weingarten & Elston, 1991; Zellner et al., 1999). Although one study in smokers found increases in snacking without a shift in preference for sweet foods after one day of abstinence from smoking (Gilbert & Pope, 1982), commonalities in research on the biochemical pathways involved in smoking and food intake and cravings, as well as some controlled studies (e.g., McRobbie & Hajek, 2004; Perkins, Epstein, Sexton, & Pastor, 1990; Rodin, 1987; West, 2001), support the link between smoking and sweet or rich foods, in particular, as opposed to other types of foods. Moreover, many studies examine associations between drug dependency and cravings for sweets and not other types of foods (Mercer & Holder, 1997). Future work using this scale may benefit from: 1) including a more comprehensive measure of cravings (e.g., a specific food listing) or additional categories such as salty foods, and 2) providing definitions of ‘‘cravings,’’ ‘‘sweet’’ and ‘‘rich’’ to participants before they complete the assessment. The current study investigated the psychometric properties of the QCSRF using a sample of smokers and provides evidence for its potential use as a valuable tool in studies of smokers and smoking cessation. Specifically, it could be used to expand upon past research on increases in caloric intake or weight gain after quitting smoking and to examine how medications may modify this relationship. Additionally, it would be interesting to examine correlations between QCSRF scores and scores on measures of craving for cigarettes and of withdrawal symptoms postquit (e.g., QSU; Tiffany & Drobes, 1991; Minnesota Nicotine Withdrawal Scale; Hughes, 1992). Future research could also investigate the relationship between QCSRF scores and success with smoking cessation and how this relationship may be mediated by weight gain, weight concern, and the satisfaction of cravings for sweet or rich food. The focus of the current study was to examine sweet or rich food cravings among smokers and hence was limited to a smoking sample. However, research in multiple domains suggests that food craving, particularly for sugar and fat, may play a significant role in a variety of psychological and physiological disorders including eating and mood disorders (Yanovski, 2003) as well as obesity
ARTICLE IN PRESS B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
(Delahanty, Meigs, Hayden, Williamson, & Nathan, 2002) and diabetes (Strachan, Ewing, Frier, Harper, & Deary, 2004). Accordingly, the QCSRF could be used to investigate other non-smoking populations, particularly those with eating, metabolic, and other weight-related disorders.
Acknowledgements We would like to thank Drs. Tanja Wranik and Amy Latimer for comments on earlier drafts of this paper. This research was supported in part by NIH grants K12DA00167, K05-AA014715, P50-AA15632, and P50DA13334.
References Baumeister, R. F., Bratslavsky, E., Muraven, M., & Tice, D. M. (1998). Ego depletion: Is the active self a limited resource? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74, 1252–1265. Bohn, M. J., Krahn, D. D., & Staehler, B. A. (1995). Development and initial validation of a measure of drinking urges in abstinent alcoholics. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, 19, 600–606. Borrelli, B., & Mermelstein, R. (1998). The role of weight concern and selfefficacy in smoking cessation and weight gain among smokers in a clinic-based cessation program. Addictive Behaviors, 23, 609–622. Bruinsma, K., & Taren, D. L. (1999). Chocolate: Food or drug? Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 99, 1249–1256. Cabanac, M., & Frankham, P. (2002). Evidence that transient nicotine lowers the body weight set point. Physiology & Behavior, 2002, 539–542. Cepeda-Benito, A., & Ferrer, A. R. (2000). Smoking consequences questionnaire-Spanish. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 14, 219–230. Cepeda-Benito, A., Gleaves, D. H., Williams, T. L., & Erath, S. A. (2000). The development and validation of the State and Trait food-cravings questionnaires. Behavior Therapy, 31, 151–173. Cohen, I. T., Sherwin, B. B., & Fleming, A. S. (1987). Food cravings, mood, and the menstrual cycle. Hormones and Behavior, 21, 1637–1640. Copeland, A. L., Brandon, T. H., & Quinn, E. P. (1995). The smoking consequences questionnaire-adult: Measurement of smoking outcome expectancies of experienced smokers. Psychological Assessment, 7, 484–494. de La Garza, R., & Johanson, C. E. (1987). The effects of food deprivation on the self-administration of psychoactive drugs. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 19, 17–27. Delahanty, L. M., Meigs, J. B., Hayden, D., Williamson, D. A., & Nathan, D. M. (2002). Psychological and behavioral correlates of baseline BMI in the diabetes prevention program (DPP). Diabetes Care, 25, 1992–1998. DeVellis, R. F. (1991). Scale Development: Theory and Applications. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications. Donny, E. C., Caggiula, A. R., Mielke, M. M., Jacobs, K. S., Rose, C., & Sved, A. F. (1998). Acquisition of nicotine self-administration in rats: The effects of dose, feeding schedule, and drug contingency. Psychopharmacology, 136, 83–90. Drewnowski, A. (1992). Food preferences and the opioid peptide system. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 3, 97–99. Filozof, C., Fernandez-Pinilla, M. C., & Fernandez-Cruz, A. (2004). Smoking cessation and weight gain. Obesity Reviews, 5, 95–103. Gendall, K. A., Joyce, P. R., Sullivan, P. F., & Bulik, C. M. (1998). Food cravers: Characteristics of those who binge. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 23, 353–360.
31
Gendall, K. A., Sullivan, P. F., Joyce, P. R., Fear, J. L., & Bulik, C. M. (1997). Psychopathology and personality of young women who experience food cravings. Addictive Behaviors, 22, 545–555. Gilbert, R. M., & Pope, M. A. (1982). Early effects of quitting smoking. Psychopharmacology, 78, 121–127. Grunberg, N. E. (1982). The effects of nicotine and cigarette smoking on food consumption and taste preferences. Addictive Behaviors, 7, 317–331. Hall, S. M., McGee, R., Tunstall, C., Duffy, J., & Benowitz (1989). Changes in food intake and activity after quitting smoking. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57, 81–86. Harvey, J., Wing, R. R., & Mullen, M. (1993). Effects on food cravings of a very low calorie diet or a balanced, low calorie diet. Appetite, 21, 105–115. Hatcher, L. (1994). A step-by-step approach to using the SAS system for univariate and multivariate statistics. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc. Hatsukami, D., LaBounty, L., Hughes, J., & Laine, D. (1993). Effects of tobacco abstinence on food intake among cigarette smokers. Health Psychology, 12, 499–502. Heishman, S. J., Singleton, E. G., & Moolchan, E. T. (2003). Tobacco craving questionnaire: Reliability and validity of a new multifactorial instrument. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 5, 645–654. Hill, A. J., & Heaton-Brown, L. (1994). The experience of food craving: A prospective investigation in healthy women. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 38, 801–814. Hudmon, K. S., Gritz, E. R., Clayton, S., & Nisenbaum, R. (1999). Eating orientation, postcessation weight gain, and continued abstinence among female smokers receiving an unsolicited smoking cessation intervention. Health Psychology, 18, 29–36. Hughes, J. R. (1992). Tobacco withdrawal in self-quitters. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology, 60, 689–697. Klesges, R. C., Winders, S. E., Meyers, A. W., Eck, L. H., Ward, K. D., Hultquist, C. M., et al. (1997). How much weight gain occurs following smoking cessation? A comparison of weight gain using both continuous and point prevalence abstinence. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65, 286–291. Koh-Banerjee, P., Chu, N., Spiegelmann, D., Rosner, B., Colditz, G., Willett, W., et al. (2003). Prospective study of the association of changes in dietary intake, physical activity, alcohol consumption, and smoking with 9-y gain in waist circumference among 16,587 US men. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 78, 719–727. Koob, G. F. (2000). Neurobiology of addiction. Toward the development of new therapies. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 909, 170–185. Kos, J., Hasenfratz, M., & Battig, K. (1996). Effects of a 2-day abstinence from smoking on dietary, cognitive, subjective, and physiologic parameters among younger and older female smokers. Physiology & Behavior, 61, 671–678. Kurth, C. L., Krahn, D. D., Nairn, K., & Drewnowski, A. (1995). The severity of dieting and bingeing behaviors in college women: Interview validation of survey data. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 29, 211–225. Kurzer, M. S. (1997). Women, food, and mood. Nutrition Reviews, 55, 268–276. Lafay, L., Thomas, F., Mennen, L., Charles, M. A., Eschwege, E., Borys, J., et al. (2001). Gender differences in the relation between food cravings and mood in and adult community: Results from the Fleurbaix Laventie Ville Sante´ Study. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 29, 195–204. Macdiarmid, J. I., & Hetherington, M. M. (1995). Mood modulation by food: An exploration of affect and cravings in ‘chocolate addicts’. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 34, 129–138. McRobbie, H., & Hajek, P. (2004). Effect of glucose on tobacco withdrawal symptoms in recent quitters using bupropion or nicotine replacement. Human Psychopharmacology, 19, 57–61. Mercer, M. E., & Holder, M. D. (1997). Food cravings, endogenous opioid peptides, and food intake: A review. Appetite, 29, 325–352. Meyers, A. W., Klesges, R. C., Winders, S. E., Ward, K. D., Peterson, B. A., & Eck, L. H. (1997). Are weight concerns predictive of smoking
ARTICLE IN PRESS 32
B.A. Toll et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 25–32
cessation? A prospective analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 65, 448–452. Michener, W., Rozin, P., Freeman, E., & Gale, L. (1999). The role of low progesterone and tension as triggers of perimenstrual chocolate and sweets craving: some negative experimental evidence. Physiology & Behavior, 67, 417–420. O’Malley, S. S., Cooney, J. L., Krishnan-Sarin, S., Dubin, J. A., McKee, S. A., Cooney, N. L., et al. (2006). Controlled trial of naltrexone augmentation of nicotine replacement for smoking cessation. Archives of Internal Medicine, 166, 667–674. Ockene, J. K., Emmons, K. M., Mermelstein, R. J., Perkins, K. A., Bonollo, D. S., Voorhees, C. C., et al. (2000). Relapse and maintenance issues for smoking cessation. Health Psychology, 19, 17–31. Pelchat, M. L. (1997). Food cravings in young and elderly adults. Appetite, 28, 103–113. Perkins, K. A. (1992). Metabolic effects of cigarette smoking. Journal of Applied Physiology, 72, 401–409. Perkins, K. A. (1993). Weight gain following smoking cessation. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 61, 768–777. Perkins, K. A. (1994). Issues in the prevention of weight gain after smoking cessation. Annals of Behavioral Medicine, 16, 46–52. Perkins, K. A., Epstein, L. H., & Pastor, S. (1990). Changes in energy balance following smoking cessation and resumption of smoking in women. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 58, 121–125. Perkins, K. A., Epstein, L. H., Sexton, J. E., & Pastor, S. (1990). Effects of smoking cessation on consumption of alcohol and sweet, high-fat foods. Journal of Substance Abuse, 2, 287–297. Perkins, K. A., Marcus, M. D., Levine, M. D., D’Amico, D., Miller, A., Broge, M., et al. (2001). Cognitive-behavioral therapy to reduce weight concerns improves smoking cessation outcome in weight-concerned women. Journal of Consulting & Clinical Psychology, 69, 604–613. Pomerleau, C. S., Garcia, A. W., Drewnowski, A., & Pomerleau, O. F. (1991). Sweet taste preferences in women smokers: Comparison with nonsmokers and effects of menstrual phase and nicotine abstinence. Pharmacology, Biochemistry, & Behavior, 40, 995–999. Pruessner, J. C., Kirschbaum, C., Meinlschmid, G., & Hellhammer, D. H. (2003). Two formulas for computation of the area under the curve represent measures of total hormone concentration versus timedependent change. Psychoneuroendocrinology, 28, 916–931. Rodin, J. (1987). Weight change following smoking cessation: The role of food intake and exercise. Addictive Behaviors, 12, 303–317. Saules, K. K., Pomerleau, C. S., Snedecor, S. M., Brouwer, R. N., & Rosenberg, E. E. (2004). Effects of disordered eating and obesity on weight, craving, and food intake during ad libitum smoking and abstinence. Eating Behaviors, 5, 353–363. Sayette, M. A., Shiffman, S., Tiffany, S. T., Niaura, R. S., Martin, C. S., & Shadel, W. G. (2000). The measurement of drug craving. Addiction, 95, S189–S210. Shadel, W. G., Niaura, R., & Abrams, D. B. (2004). Thinking about craving: An experimental analysis of smokers’ spontaneous self-reports of craving. Addictive Behaviors, 29, 811–815. Silagy, C., Lancaster, T., Stead, L., Mant, D., & Fowler, G. (2004). Nicotine replacement therapy for smoking cessation. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 3. Art. No.: CD000146.pub2. DOI:10.1002/14651858.CD000146.pub2. Singleton, E. G., Trotman, A. J., Zavahir, M., Taylor, R. C., & Heishman, S. J. (2002). Determination of the reliability and validity of the marijuana craving questionnaire using imagery scripts. Experimental and Clinical Psychopharmacology, 10, 47–53.
Sinha, R., & O’Malley, S. S. (1999). Craving for alcohol: Findings from the clinic and the laboratory. Alcohol & Alcoholism, 34, 223–230. Sobell, L. C., & Sobell, M. D. (1992). Timeline follow-back: a technique for assessing self-reported ethanol consumption. In J. Allen, & R. Z. Litten (Eds.), Measuring Alcohol Consumption: Psychosocial and Biochemical Methods (pp. 41–72). Totowa, NU: Humana Press Inc. Sobell, L. C., & Sobell, M. B. (2003). Alcohol consumption measures. In J. P. Allen, & V. B. Wilson (Eds.), Assessing alcohol problems: A guide for clinicians and researchers (second ed, pp. 75–99). Bethesda, MD: National Institute on Alcohol Abuse & Alcoholism. Spring, B., Wurtman, J., Gleason, R., Wurtman, R., & Kessler, K. (1991). Weight gain and withdrawal symptoms after smoking cessation: A preventive intervention using d-fenfluramine. Health Psychology, 10, 216–223. SPSS, Inc. (2000). SPSS for Windows, Release 11.0.0. Chicago: SPSS, Inc. Strachan, M. W., Ewing, F. M., Frier, B. M., Harper, A., & Deary, I. J. (2004). Food cravings during acute hypoglycaemia in adults with Type 1 diabetes. Physiology & Behavior, 80, 675–682. Tabachnick, B. G., & Fidell, L. S. (1996). Using multivariate statistics (third ed). Northridge, CA: Harper Collins Publishers. Tiffany, S. T. (1990). A cognitive model of drug urges and drug-use behavior: Role of automatic and non-automatic processes. Psychological Review, 97, 147–168. Tiffany, S. T., & Drobes, D. J. (1991). The development and initial validation of a questionnaire on smoking urges. British Journal of Addiction, 86, 1467–1476. Waters, A., Hill, A., & Waller, G. (2001). Bulimics’ responses to food cravings: Is binge-eating a product of hunger or emotional state? Behaviour Research & Therapy, 39, 877–886. Weingarten, H. P., & Elston, D. (1990). The phenomenology of food cravings. Appetite, 15, 231–246. Weingarten, H. P., & Elston, D. (1991). Food cravings in a college population. Appetite, 17, 167–175. Weinstein, A., Feldtkeller, B., Malizia, A., Wilson, S., Bailey, J., & Nutt, D. J. (1998). Integrating the cognitive and physiological aspects of craving. Journal of Psychopharmacology, 12, 31–38. West, R. (2001). Glucose for smoking cessation: Does it have a role? CNS Drugs, 15, 261–265. White, M. A., Whisenhunt, B. L., Williamson, D. A., Greenway, F. L., & Netemeyer, R. G. (2002). Development and validation of the foodcraving inventory. Obesity Research, 10, 107–114. Willner, P., Hardman, S., & Eaton, G. (1995). Subjective and behavioural evaluation of cigarette cravings. Psychopharmacology, 118, 171–177. Worthington-Roberts, J. J., Little, P., Lambert, P., & Wu, S. (1989). Dietary cravings and aversions in the postpartum period. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 89, 647–651. Wurtman, R. J., & Wurtman, J. J. (1995). Brain serotonin, carbohydratecraving, obesity, and depression. Obesity Research, 3, 477S–480S. Yanovski, S. (2003). Sugar and fat: Cravings and aversions. Journal of Nutrition, 133, 835S–837S. Zellner, D., Garriga-Trillo, A., Rohm, E., Centeno, S., & Parker, S. (1999). Food liking and craving: A cross-cultural approach. Appetite, 33, 61–70. Zimmerman, U., Rechlin, T., Plaskacewicz, G. J., Barocka, A., Wildt, L., & Kaschka, W. P. (1997). Effect of Naltrexone on weight gain and food craving induced by tricyclic antidepressants and Lithium: An open study. Biological Psychiatry, 41, 747–749. Zwick, W. R., & Velicer, W. F. (1986). Comparison of five rules for determining the number of components to retain. Psychological Bulletin, 99, 432–442.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research Report
Food, eating, and weight concerns of men in recovery from substance addiction Jennifer Cowan, Carol Devine 351A MVR Hall, Division of Nutritional Sciences, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853-4401, USA Received 11 August 2006; received in revised form 12 May 2007; accepted 18 May 2007
Abstract Dysfunctional eating patterns and excessive weight gains have been observed during recovery from drug and alcohol addictions. Yet, little is known about food choice behaviors among substance abusers and the role that food plays in their lives. The purpose of this study was to understand how men at different stages of recovery from substance addictions experienced food and eating, weight changes, and used food in recovery. A purposive, multi-ethnic sample of 25 urban men at different stages of recovery from drug and alcohol addictions participated in qualitative interviews. Data analysis based on the constant comparative method revealed three main themes: excess weight gain, meaningful use of food, and disordered eating and a struggle to eat healthy that differed by recovery stage (early, mid, and later recovery). Men in early recovery described dysfunctional eating practices such as mood and binge eating, the use of food as a substitute for drug use, and the use of food to satisfy cravings. Men in mid to later recovery expressed weight concerns and distress about efforts to lose weight. The findings also suggest that food deprivation in active addiction and interactions between stage of recovery and living environment may contribute to changes in food choice behaviors and to excess weight gains in recovery. These findings highlight behavioral interactions between food and substance abuse and opportunities for nutrition and weight interventions in recovery. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Substance abuse; Eating behavior; Recovery stage; Food meaning; Weight
Introduction Overweight and dysfunctional eating patterns have been observed among people in recovery from drug and alcohol addictions (Hatcher, 2004; Hodgkins, Jacobs, & Gold, 2003; Jackson & Grilo, 2002). Overeating, binge eating, and the use of foods, especially those high in fats and sugars, as substitutes for alcohol and drug use have been reported. High rates of eating disorders have also been reported in this population (Cepik, Arikan, Boratav, & Isik, 1995; Hudson, Weiss, Pope, McElroy, & Mirin, 1992; Krahn, 1991; Mitchell, Pyle, & Specker, 1992; Wiseman et al., 1995), but little is known about how substance abusers themselves experience food and eating in recovery and the roles that food plays during the recovery process. Recovery from drug and alcohol addiction has been viewed as a behavior-change process in which total Corresponding author.
E-mail address:
[email protected] (J. Cowan). 0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.006
abstinence from alcohol and illicit drugs is achieved while promoting overall health and well-being. It is also the period in which the addicted person begins to learn new skills while slowly moving away from old habits and patterns of thinking (Gorski, 1989a, 1990; McDuff, Solounias, RachBeisel, & Johnson, 1994; Moyer, 1989; Rioux & Van Meter, 1990). A developmental model rooted in a cognitive-behavioral framework (Rawson, Obert, McCann, & Marinelli-Casey, 1993) has been suggested as a way of helping recovering addicts and treatment professionals identify appropriate treatment goals and evaluate progress during recovery (Gorski, 1990). This model describes six progressive recovery stages: (1) transition or pretreatment phase, in which the addicted individual recognizes the addiction problem; (2) stabilization, marked by detoxification and recuperation from acute withdrawal; (3) early recovery, in which the compulsion to use chemicals is reduced and the sober individual becomes more comfortable with being abstinent; (4) middle recovery, in which the individual begins to experience a balance and
ARTICLE IN PRESS 34
J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
productive daily life; (5) late recovery, in which the addicted individual begins to move towards healthy living; and (6) maintenance, marked by an awareness for continued growth and development (Gorski, 1990; Gorski & Kelly, 1996; McDuff et al., 1994). This developmental framework for understanding recovery guided participant recruiting, and it informed the interpretation of the emergent findings of this qualitative study. We chose this framework because it is widely used in relapse prevention programs (e.g., McDuff et al., 1994; Moyer, 1989; Rawson et al., 1993), and because one of the aims of this study was to inform nutrition interventions for men in recovery from substance abuse. In the population at large, food is used not only to satisfy hunger but also serves many roles in providing social interaction, comfort, identity, and pleasure in people’s lives (Angulo, 1987; Sobal & Nelson, 2003; Wanksink, Cheney, & Chan, 2003; Westenhoefer & Pudel, 1993). Some dietary practices have been linked to increased risk for chronic food-related diseases such as diabetes and cardiovascular diseases; and these chronic conditions are more common in the substance abuse population (Anders & Anders, 1999; Howard, Arnsten, & Gourrevitch, 2004; Parillo & Riccardi, 2004; Poilkolainen, 1998; Rehm, Gmel, Sempos, & Trevisan, 2002; Selwyn, 1996; Sone, Yamada, Mizuno, Aida, & Ohashi, 2004; Sutter & Vetter, 1999; van de Weil, 2004). Obesity plays a key role in these chronic conditions (Howard et al., 2004; Sutter & Vetter, 1999) because the excess weight gained in recovery may contribute to these health problems. There is a need to understand the perceptions and behaviors related to food choices among men in recovery from drug and alcohol addictions to promote improved health and reduced disease in this population. Our aim in this study was to understand how men at different stages of recovery from substance addictions experienced weight changes and how they described the functions and meaning of food and eating behaviors in recovery. We conducted the study to inform nutrition interventions to address weight, nutrition, and health concerns during recovery. Methods We used a grounded theory approach in this analysis (Charmaz, 2000; Glaser & Strauss, 1967; Strauss & Corbin, 1998) because we were interested in understanding the multiple experiences, meanings, and functions of weight change and food and eating from the perspective of men in recovery from substance abuse. We also hoped to develop a new conceptual understanding of the issues of interest to inform the design of interventions with men in recovery settings. Twenty-five men in recovery from drug and alcohol addictions were purposively recruited to vary in race/ ethnicity, age, living environment (halfway houses, rehabilitation program, supportive, and independent living), and
recovery status, from a city of approximately 700,000 people in Upstate New York. Adult men were recruited for this study because men are more widely affected by alcohol and drug addictions (Drug and Alcohol Service Information System Report (DASIS), 2005; National Survey on Drug Use and Health Report (NSDUH), 2004). All of the study participants were recruited through personal contacts at drug treatment agencies and at Alcoholics Anonymous meetings in the research community. Study participants were recruited from four types of recovery environments: (1) a halfway house, a drug-free residential group community that provided 24-h recovery services; (2) a highly structured rehabilitation program that provided group housing and rehabilitative services; (3) a supportive living environment that provided apartments and weekly recovery counseling services; and (4) independent living where men lived independently at home and participated in community recovery support groups. We recruited participants from different recovery environments because we wanted to include men at different stages of recovery. Halfway houses and rehabilitation programs typically house men in early recovery; supportive and independent livings are used in later stages of recovery. The treatment of nicotine dependence was not a primary objective of these treatment facilities. No formal smoking cessation program was offered, and the residents were allowed to smoke while in treatment. We used social cognitive theory (Bandura, 1977) and a life course perspective (Devine, Conners, Bisogni, & Sobal, 1998) in the study design and data collection. The lead researcher, trained in qualitative research methods, conducted 1-h face-to-face interviews in English with study participants using a semi-structured interview guide (Denzin & Lincoln, 2003). We tested the open-ended interview guide with three men in recovery. We also conducted 15–20 min follow-up telephone interviews with participants 5–7 months after the initial face-to-face interviews to update information on weight and eating behaviors in recovery. We audiotape-recorded all face-to-face interviews, transcribed them verbatim and reviewed them for accuracy. Study participants provided demographic information (age, drug of choice, ethnic identity, recovery status, living situation, treatment history, and self-reported weight and height). The interviewer wrote detailed field notes after each interview and follow-up telephone call to provide the context for the interview, comments on data quality, and preliminary analytic observations. Following the face-toface interview, each participant completed the Eating Attitude Test (EAT-26), a standardized instrument used to assess eating disorders (Garner, Olmstead, Bohr, & Garfinkel, 1982). All the study participants provided informed consent and received a gift certificate to a local supermarket. The University Institutional Review Board (IRB) reviewed the study procedures. We conducted data analysis guided by the constant comparative method (Glaser & Strauss, 1967) continuously
ARTICLE IN PRESS J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
throughout the study. Researchers read interviews and field notes, and discussed each case until consensus was achieved. We used open and axial coding (Strauss & Corbin, 1998) to identify emergent thematic categories from interview transcripts. In this process, it emerged that participants’ descriptions of the meaning and function of food, weight, and eating differed by recovery status. We then developed a recovery timeline for each participant from active addiction to recovery and examined emergent patterns in participants’ descriptions of their eating behaviors over time. We next used participants’ narratives to develop a data matrix to explicitly examine differences in body weight, weight concerns, food function and meaning, and eating behaviors (Miles & Huberman, 1994). Participants commonly referred to ‘‘early’’ and ‘‘later’’ stages of recovery. Men described common experiences with food, eating, and weight and similar ways of interpreting them in each of these stages. The ‘‘mid’’ recovery group emerged as a transitional stage in which participants described transitions in self-awareness and meaning about weight, food, and eating. The three distinctive stages of recovery that emerged from this matrix were used in subsequent analysis. We then connected these findings to the published literature. We used peer debriefing through discussions about emergent themes and member checks with study participants, and community members to verify interpretations (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). We calculated body mass index (BMI, weight in kg/height in m2) from each participant’s self-reported weight and height at the time of the interview. We also calculated the mean EAT score for each participant (Garner et al., 1982).
Table 1 Characteristics of study participants Numbers Gender Male
25
Age (years) 24–30 31–40 41–50 Over 50
3 7 11 4
Race/ethnicity Black White Latino Other
11 10 3 1
Primary drug of choice Alcohol Cocaine (including crack) Heroin Marijuana
5 16 2 2
Mean body mass index (BMI) at the time of interviewa Early recovery 26 Mid recovery 27 Later recovery 29 a
Self-reported weight and height.
Table 2 Study participants by stage of recovery (months of sobriety) living in the four recovery environments Living situations
Early recovery (1–6 months)
Mid recovery (7–13 months)
Later recovery (14–36 months)
Halfway house Rehabilitation program Supportive living Independent living
7 2
2 1
0 1
0 1
1 2
5 3
Findings Twenty-five men in recovery from substance abuse participated in this study (Table 1). The participants differed in type of drug use, age, and living environment. Men from three major race/ethnic groups participated: black, Latino and white of European background. Participants fell into one of three emergent recovery stages: (1) early recovery (1–6 months), (2) mid recovery (7–13 months), and (3) later recovery (14–36 months) (Table 2). The mean ages of the participants in early, mid, and later recovery were 39, 43, and 42 years, respectively. Three dominant themes emerged from participants’ descriptions of their experiences in recovery: excess weight gain, meaningful use of food (e.g., as a drug substitute or mood regulator), and disordered eating and the struggle to eat healthy. All of these themes differed by recovery status. Weight changes Most of the participants recalled that they rarely ate while they were in active addiction and consequently experienced severe weight loss during that time. Some men reported eating as little as twice a week. In contrast, during recovery, all but two study participants gained weight;
35
many described gaining what they saw as too much weight over short periods of time. One participant who had been in recovery for 3 months said this about his weight since recovery, ‘‘I weigh more now than I ever have in my life! When I went intoywhen I first started my recovery I weighed like 160 pounds, and now I weigh over 200 [pounds]. The highest I’ve ever weighed in my life like 190yactually I think I’m a little overweight right now.’’ More than half of the men in the study, particularly those interviewed during later recovery, fell above the normal BMI range based on self-reported weight. More than half of the participants interviewed in early recovery reported that they had stopped smoking at the start of their treatment while only three of the nine men in later recovery described themselves as non-smokers. All of the six men interviewed when they were in mid recovery
ARTICLE IN PRESS 36
J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
described themselves as smokers. Some of the smokers reported that they had not quit smoking because they were afraid they would gain weight. Weight changes in early recovery (1–6 months) All 10 participants interviewed when they were in early recovery reported gaining weight since entering recovery. In early recovery, men presented weight gain as inevitable and desirable to replace pounds lost during active addiction. These men estimated that they had gained between 14 and 45 lb within the first 6 months of recovery. One man who had been in recovery 1 month reported gaining 14 lb in 28 days. A participant who had been in recovery for almost 5 months contrasted his weight changes during active addiction and during recovery: When I first came here [in recovery] I was weighing like 130 [pounds]. I weigh like 170 now, you know, big difference! ‘Cause when I was out there I was not eating. And I wouldn’t eat properly. And I was constantly running so the little bit that I was feeding into my body was going, ‘cause I was in and out, in and out. Weight changes in mid recovery (7–13 months) All six participants interviewed during mid recovery expressed consciousness of weight gain and the desire to lose the extra weight they had gained in early recovery. The men in mid recovery reported gaining between 33 and 60 lb within the first stages of their recovery. Three of these men were able to lose some weight (1–15 lb) during mid recovery using a variety of strategies. One man who had gained 40 lb since entering recovery said he was ‘‘slowly pulling’’ away from fried foods in an attempt to lose some weight. Another man who had been in recovery for 9 months described his strategy to lose weight: ‘‘I can lose weight if I stop eating for two days. I can be down to my other weight I want to be.’’ A man who had been in recovery for 7 months described his weight loss success: I’ve gained—well in the halfway house [early recovery] I figured I gained about fifty pounds. I was there for six months. [Now] I’ve just, you know, tried to wean myself off of so much, [I] try to cut down a little bit and it’s been working. Since I’ve come here [supportive living] I’ve noticed that I have lost weight. I’ve lost about fifteen pounds. Weight changes in later recovery (14–36 months) Most of the nine participants interviewed during the later stage of recovery recalled gaining a lot of weight in early recovery; they were currently losing weight and/or wishing to lose the excess weight gained previously. The participants in this phase of recovery reported an estimated total weight gain in recovery between 15 and 80 lb, most of which had occurred in early recovery. Five of these men reported an estimated weight loss between 8 and 65 lb
during later recovery and four still hoped to lose some weight. One man who had been in recovery for 15 months was depressed by his current weight, and his doctor had told him he needed to lose some weight. Another man who had lost 65 lb in 6 months through an ‘‘extreme’’ weight loss regimen described his weight concerns since recovery: I came in [recovery] weighing about 180, which is probably about my normal weight. I just had unlimited access to foody with my addictive personality and my addictive eating styles—I just went wild, you know, and that’s where I went from 180 pounds to 240. I came into supportive living at probably about 230–235 but after six months of being here [supportive living] it didn’t go down. It sure went upylast time I weighed myself, I was about 242, uh, and I gotten bigger after that but I didn’t weigh myself. So I was over 240 pounds and that was at January 1st of this year, yeahyI lost a lot of weight and I was on my feet as far as eating healthyymy weight’s been stable between 180 and 185 [pounds]. And I’m still sugar and flour freey Meaningful use of food Meaning of food in early recovery (1–6 months) The men interviewed in early recovery described many functions and meanings of food in their lives. Men described using food, usually sweets and ‘‘junk’’ foods, as a drug substitute, to regulate moods, to alleviate boredom, to satisfy cravings, and to provide structure to the days. One participant who had been in recovery for only 1 month told how he had replaced his drug use with food: I just eat just to, just to eat. Just to eat! ‘Cause once you come off narcotics, you have to replace that narcotic with something else. And a lot of people chain smoke. If they smoke, they go to chain smoking. Um, if not, they eat. And they eat constantly! You know, ‘cause, you’re replacing it [narcotics]. You’re replacing that drug with something else, you know! So, I replace my drug with food, with food and working out. Most of the participants in this early phase of recovery also described having mood ‘‘swings.’’ They often used food to regulate their moods or ate more frequently when they were sad and depressed, nervous/anxious, or upset. A man in recovery for 5 months expressed that when he was anxious and depressed, eating was a soothing activity. He said: Moods and eating yeah, when I’m depressed, anxiousyeating’s often some kind of a soothing activity and I might have a harder time you know controlling the portions. I might snack more frequently, I might choose more instantly gratifying foods like sugary foods, that’s sweet maybe not so healthy.
ARTICLE IN PRESS J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
These men also described how they used food to alleviate boredom. One man interviewed in early recovery when asked about his eating simply said, ‘‘I’ll eat and I won’t even be hungry, I just eat it anyway.’’ The men in early recovery also used food to satisfy (food) cravings. One diabetic participant said that he had ‘‘real bad cravings’’ for chocolate and on one occasion he ate so many chocolate bars his face became ‘‘numbed’’. The participants interviewed in early recovery also commonly expressed that food provided some structure while they were in recovery from drug and alcohol addictions. One man who had been in recovery for 3 months when asked about his eating pattern said: So basically what I’m trying to do since I’ve been here [halfway house recovery program] is I’m trying to be more structured. I’m trying to eat at least three times per day, breakfast, lunch and dinner. Meaning of food in mid recovery (7–13 months) Most of the men interviewed in mid recovery also expressed the theme that food provided some structure in their lives. A man who had been in recovery in the halfway house for 7 months stated that he had a food routine, which was to prepare him for independent living: [Eating] More of a routine, like I said breakfast, lunch and dinner! Where, as before in addiction it might be every two days or basically whatever. It’s reallyyit’s basically for when we get back out there and uh, go to independent living. You know, live like normal people do or did [a little laugh]ywhen you get your own apartment. It’s good to have standards like that to uhymoreybe uh, responsible. But, uh, basically breakfast, lunch and dinner, maybe a late night snack. It’s a good routine, basically. I tried, like I said, to get into a routine with everything I doy Few participants interviewed in mid recovery described using food as a drug substitute, to alleviate boredom and/ or to satisfy food cravings. One man who had been in recovery for 7 months, stated that he had to have his coffee first thing in the morning instead of drugs to start his day. Only one participant reported using food to alleviate boredom: ‘‘Usually when I’m bored, you knowyboredom leads me to food. You knowysomething to munch on, you knowysomething to use my hands with umyI think that’s the only time that I’m really attracted to food.’’ Those study participants who reported using food to satisfy food cravings were usually reflecting back to food cravings experienced in early recovery. One man who had been in recovery for 7 months reflected, ‘‘I couldn’t get enough sugar when I first got into the halfway house [early recovery].’’ Meaning of food in later recovery (14–36 months) Unlike participants interviewed in early recovery, the men in later recovery did not describe current use of food
37
as a substitute for drugs but mainly reflected back to early recovery when food had served this function in their lives. One participant who had been in recovery for 27 months said this about food as drug substitute when he first came into recovery: It [eating] was like a drug addiction. I would go to the store and buy candy and a lot of junk food, and eat it compulsive. I had to have some. I felt deprived if I didn’t have cakes and ice cream just before I went to bed at night. Only one participant interviewed in later recovery stated that he had used food to alleviate boredom and to satisfy food cravings. He had been in recovery for 15 months and said he ate until he was full when he was bored. Like the men in mid recovery, most of the participants interviewed in the later recovery phase reported that food provided some structure in recovery and that they were currently trying to maintain their food structure. One participant who had been in recovery for 14 months said: I’ve managed to maintain a normal eating regimen currently. Sometimes it varies. Some days I may not have time to eat or maybe in a hurry and I just neglect to eat. But usually in the past nine or ten months I’ve been pretty disciplined as far as eatingyI’m eating in the morning, afternoon, evening. Another man who had been interviewed while in late recovery emphasized that it was important for him to have a food structure because he was an ‘‘impulsive type of person’’. He also said ‘‘I have to have a plan, I have to have the right food in the house,’’ when he was asked about his eating patterns in recovery. Disordered eating and the struggle to eat healthy Eating behaviors in early recovery (1–6 months) The eating behaviors described by the study participants differed by their stage of recovery. Most of the participants interviewed in early recovery expressed that they regularly ate large amounts of food in a short period of time (binging) and that they had often hoarded food during their recovery. Two participants diagnosed with diabetes and hypertension reported that they were struggling to control their food intake because of their health. A study participant who had been in the program for 5 months described his binging behavior: Over the past months [I] just would eat and eat and eat ‘til I’m stuffed. I’ll eat and eat and I’ll feel so stuffed and then I’ll get really good disgusted with myself, and just say, why did I take it to that extremeyI really didn’t like it but I still didn’t feel like I could control it. The participants interviewed in early recovery described food hoarding as a common behavior in the halfway house. One man complained that food was stolen and eaten on a regular basis in the halfway house even when someone
ARTICLE IN PRESS 38
J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
else’s name was written on it. Another participant described hoarding pork chops and eating them in his room even though eating in the bedroom was against the program policy: I eat two pork chops, I’d come back later on that night and I eat like two more. I take them up to my room and eat in the room, right. I go in and grab it, wrap it up and hide it right here [in his pocket] then have it in the room. Eating behaviors in mid recovery (7–13 months) Most of the participants in mid recovery described overeating, especially their favorite foods, on special occasions at restaurants and/or at family events. One participant who had been in recovery for 7 months described it this way: I can eat likey a whole pizza. And uh, totally know I’m full and still eat, and still eat, and still eat. And basically that’s what I thinkythat’s the only food I do it withy But, like I said, it all goes back toyfrom years ago. Pizza has always been my favorite and I could sit and eat it until I get sick. For some reason, that’s the only food that does it to me. None of the participants interviewed in mid recovery reported hoarding food but reflected back to food hoarding in early recovery. One participant who had been in recovery for 7 months and had transitioned from a halfway house program into supportive living described his memory of food-hoarding behaviors earlier in his recovery: The halfway house more or lessyall the food was comfort food, you know. It’s been so long, every one gets in there and the first thing they do is go to the kitchen, you know, becauseywe were never worried about before, you know. And now there’s some people there that were worrying about they’d never get it again, so hiding it, and putting it in different spots so they know it was theirs or something like that. Most of the study participants in this stage of recovery reported some struggle for control over food and their eating, particularly the struggle to eat healthier. One man who had been in the halfway house for 7 months and was trying to eat less red meat expressed his struggles for control over food: ‘‘There’s a lot of red meat here [halfway house]. I’m finding it hard because of that.’’ That’s one thing I got to watch out for and stay away from because of the red meats and all that. It’s hard for me in here and then when I go out, I love eating that stuff but I’ve been doing I think OK but I can’t totally get to where I want to be in hereyCause I do like eating that food and I know it’s not healthy for me. Another participant who had been in recovery for 10 months felt that he lacked nutrition knowledge:
I guess I would like to develop some type of eating pattern, you know, um, and, I think it’s lack of, you know, knowledge in what is good, and stuff like that. And, you know, what could be done quick! I would like to find, I guess, better ways of eating. Eating behaviors in later recovery (14–36 months) Most of the men interviewed in later recovery described overeating less frequent than those interviewed in early or mid recovery. The men in this stage of recovery described eating large portions or overeating only on special occasions such as eating out at restaurants and family events. One participant in recovery for 23 months said, ‘‘I overeat at times. I tend to gorge myself too, at dinnertime or at night. One of my goals is to start eating less portions.’’ One man (in recovery for 33 months) described his overeating episodes at family events: ‘‘Not often, I can go back to the family gatherings it’s like a spread! You want everything, so you eat ‘til you like you’re about to burst. I eat ‘til I become miserable.’’ All of the study participants interviewed in later recovery expressed some struggle to control their eating in recovery: struggle to eat healthier or to eat smaller portion sizes. One man in later recovery when asked about food and eating simply said, ‘‘I try and eat pretty healthy it’s just I think I overeat at timesyjust need to have more control, more disciplineylike smaller portions.’’ Another man (in recovery for 29 months) shared his struggles with eating the wrong foods: Mostly, I’d say my food is grease. It’s high carbs, you know, in factyI need to experience with more of the correct way of eatingyjust like last week, in my, inserviceywe was talking about nutrition. And, I eat a lot of sugar uhyit’s wrong. I did eat wrong. I know I eat wrong. And I can’t stop and change that. I can’t! I need help in ity I just know I eat wrong. The mean Eating Attitude Test (EAT-26) scores also differed by the three recovery stage (early: 15, mid: 3.33, later: 7.89). Three out of the four participants who scored at or above the cut-off score for eating disorders (20) were in early recovery. Discussion This investigation provided new insights into the meaning of food and eating to men at different stages of recovery from substance abuse. Participants in this analysis provided descriptions of weight changes, meaningful use of food, and disordered eating and struggles to eat healthy that differed by their stage of recovery. Our findings suggest that regaining weight lost during active addiction was dominant and perceived as positive by the participants in early recovery. This is consistent with the evidence that most drug addicts have poor diets during active addiction and are usually malnourished and underweight when they enter recovery (Cepik et al., 1995; Hauser
ARTICLE IN PRESS J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
& Iber, 1989). The new finding that emerged from our data, which suggests that weight gain in early recovery may exceed the weight lost during active addiction and become a concern to men in recovery needs to be confirmed with longitudinal measured weights. If true, this suggests that treatment should address healthy weight goals early in the recovery process. Both animal and human studies in a variety of populations provide evidence that weight gain follows food deprivation or restriction. Studies in eating disordered populations have reported positive associations between food deprivation and/or restrained eating and bingeing (e.g., Lowe, Foster, Kerzhnerman, Swain, & Wadden, 2001; Ouwens, Van Strien, & Van der Staak, 2003; Ricciardelli, Williams, & Finemore, 2001; Van Strien, Cleven, & Schippers, 2000). Similarly, animal experiments of eating behavior after food deprivation found an increase in food hoarding, food seeking behaviors (e.g., Day & Bartness, 2003; Day, Mintz, & Bartness, 1999; Pierre, Skjoldager, Bennett, & Renner, 2001), and food consumption in proportion to the degree of body mass loss (Wood & Bartness, 1996). Previous studies conducted in recovery populations also support the idea that changes in eating behaviors and weight may occur as the drug addicts recover (Hatcher, 2004; Hauser & Iber, 1989; Hodgkins et al., 2003). The classic Minnesota starvation experiment may also provide some insight into the eating behaviors of people previously in a semi-starvation state (Keys, Brozek, Henschel, Mickelsem, & Taylor, 1950). This experiment provided a unique and complete account of the body’s response to sustained food deprivation followed by periods of refeeding. Like the men in the Minnesota experiment who were in a semi-starvation state, many of our participants in recovery reported that they rarely ate while they were in active addiction. Once abstinence was achieved and food became more available to the participants as they entered early recovery, recovering addicts gained excessive weight and exhibited disordered eating behaviors such as binge eating and hoarding food, similar to those documented in the Minnesota Starvation Study (Keys et al., 1950). Increases in food intake after periods of food restriction may be due to the need to maintain body weight to its biologically suitable levels. Consequently, weight regain may be an important factor in food consumption after periods of food restrictions, which would support the participants’ descriptions of severe weight loss in active addiction and bingeing behaviors in early recovery. Abnormal neurological mechanisms in the brain may play a role in the eating pathologies observed in the study participants in early recovery. Drugs of abuse (e.g., alcohol and cocaine) are believed to release dopamine (DA) in the brain, the neurotransmitter involved with the ‘‘reinforcing properties of food’’ (Wang, Volkow, Thanos, & Fowlers, 2004). Dopamine acts as a strong inhibitor of food intake by preventing the expression of hypothalamic neuropeptides responsible for stimulating food intake (see also
39
Gillard, Dang, & Stanley, 1993; Meguid et al., 2000). Low dopamine brain activities, reduction in dopamine release and/or decreased dopamine receptors (DA D2) stimulation, are associated with dysfunctional eating patterns (Wang et al., 2004). Positron Emission Tomography (PET) studies that have measured DA D2 receptors in obese and drug-addicted individuals reported significantly lower levels in these groups (Volkow et al., 1993, 1996, 2001; Wang et al., 1997, 2004). Our study participants in early recovery may have compromised neurobiological systems, which cause them to use food as a temporary compensation for the decrease in dopamine activities in the brain (Wang et al., 2004). Our study findings also suggest that food had different meanings and uses at different stages of recovery. While food as a substitute for drugs, to regulate moods, alleviate boredom, or satisfy cravings dominated early recovery; food and meals that provided structure and preparation for future living situations dominated later recovery. A developmental framework is consistent with the changes in food meaning and use described by the men in the different stages of recovery in this study. In a developmental model of recovery, as the recovering addicts move from one stage to another in the recovery process they develop new skills that are critical to the next stage of recovery (Gorski, 1989b). Therefore, some behaviors that the recovering addicts may display early in their sobriety may not necessarily be exhibited later on in the recovery process because the individuals are changing as they learn new skills. For example, excessive caffeine and nicotine use following detoxification (pre-early stage of recovery) usually decline over time (Gorski, 1989b). The developmental stages in recovery may be associated with the change in dopamine activities in the brain over time. The developmental model of recovery (Gorski, 1990) is also a good fit with behavioral differences in eating behavior during recovery. In our sample, which covered three stages of recovery, there is some evidence supporting a development process with eating behavior as well as weight changes and concerns in recovery. The experiences of these men suggest that dysfunctional eating practices such as mood and binge eating, the use of food as a substitute for drug use and the use of food to satisfy cravings were experienced more commonly in early recovery than in mid or later recovery. The participants interviewed during early recovery also scored higher on the eating disorders assessment (EAT-26), than those in mid to later recovery. Also, three out of the four men who scored at or above the cut-off score on the eating disorders assessment were in early recovery. Our finding that men indicate dysfunctional eating patterns in early recovery is consistent with previous studies. One study conducted by Farkas and Dwyer (1984) suggested that cravings for sweet and the use of sweets to satisfy the cravings for alcohol and drugs occur frequently in the early stages of recovery. Similarly, foodhoarding behaviors were reported only by the participants
ARTICLE IN PRESS 40
J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
in early recovery, which is consistent with previous studies in which food-hoarding behaviors were observed when normal feeding was administered following periods of food deprivation (Day & Bartness, 2003; Day et al., 1999; Keys et al., 1950; Wood & Bartness, 1996). This suggests that any intervention conducted in this population should take recovery stages into consideration, particularly during early recovery when a normal diet is reintroduced. A further question is raised by the living situations of men in different stages of recovery. Because the men at different stages of recovery lived in different environments, it is difficult to disentangle the relationship of the eating environment and the stage of recovery to food choice behaviors and weight changes. Within the same recovery environment, were experiences related to the environment or to the stage of recovery? However, some participants at different stages of recovery differed in their eating and weight experiences. This observation provides supports for a stage of recovery interpretation. On the other hand, some participants who were interviewed in mid and later recovery reflected back on earlier recovery experiences and described a past environment, the halfway house, as having contributed to their poor food choices and excess weight gain. These experiences are consistent with an environmental interpretation. The food and eating environment has been identified as an influence on food choice behaviors leading to excess weight gain and obesity (e.g., Hill & Peters, 1998; Jeffery & Utter, 2003). It is likely that interactions between recovery stage and the food environment may provide an alternative explanation for the differences described by our study participants. An interaction interpretation is consistent with social cognitive theory, the theoretical framework that helped to guide the study design and data analysis. This theory suggests that a person’s actions are determined through reciprocal interactions between personal and cognitive factors, behaviors, and environmental influences (Bandura, 1977). Therefore, the study participants’ weight changes, eating behaviors, and the way in which food was interpreted in recovery may be a function of the recovery stage as well as the food environment. A longitudinal study with a larger sample of men at different stages of recovery living in different environments is needed to sort out these issues. Tobacco use may be another explanation for the differences observed in the eating patterns of the participants at different stages of recovery. Five of the eight participants in early recovery were non-smokers; they reported that they had stopped smoking following detoxification. It is well documented that smoking tobacco reduces appetite, and that smoking cessation can lead to hyperphagia and weight gain (e.g., Carney & Goldberg, 1984; Chen et al., 2005; Grunberg, 1982; John, Meyer, Rumpf, Hapke, & Schumann, 2006; Shiffman, West, & Gilbert, 2004). There is also some evidence suggesting that appetite tends to be higher in recent quitters than in daily smokers (Etter, 2005). Therefore, smoking cessation at the
beginning of the recovery process could have exacerbated the effects of drug and alcohol abstinence on appetite and weight gain of the six non-smokers interviewed in early recovery. Further research should study the role of interactions among these factors on appetite and weight gain in this population. This study provides support for the importance of nutrition education and dietary counseling that is tailored to stage of recovery. Most of the participants in this study lacked from the start and did not gain during recovery, the necessary nutrition skills to move forward into healthy eating. These findings highlight the need for more attention towards food and nutrition in the recovery population. Recovering addicts who become more aware about nutrition and who are more involved in improving their personal health and nutritional status are more likely to embrace better eating patterns (Hauser & Iber, 1989). Because drug addicts may be at increased risk for chronic diseases such as diabetes, cardiovascular diseases (coronary heart disease, hypertension, stroke), liver problems, and digestive problems such as peptic ulcers and chronic pancreatitis (e.g., Howard et al., 2004; Johnson, Barzargan, & Cherpitel, 2001; Rehm et al., 2002; Sone et al., 2004; van de Weil, 2004) it is especially important to provide nutritional support appropriate to each stage of recovery. Moreover, it is vital for people in recovery programs to learn new and healthy ways of eating early in order to give them the skills for healthful eating when they are living on their own. The qualitative research methods and the emphasis on weight changes and eating patterns at different stages in recovery provided a better understanding of food choice behaviors and the ways in which food is used in recovery from the perspective of men in recovery from substance addiction. These approaches also provided some insight into the weight concerns observed in the recovery population. Our study sample was limited to an urban male population studied in a cross-sectional design. These findings will be most useful in understanding food behaviors, weight changes and concerns, and the perceptions of food functions of urban men with similar characteristics. Longitudinal investigation to address these food and weight concerns at different stages of recovery from substance addiction is warranted. Implications for research and practice The goal of this study was to understand how men in recovery from substance addiction experienced food and eating, and used food for the purpose of improving their nutritional health and well-being at different stages in the recovery process. Our intention was also to highlight body weight changes and concerns experienced by adult men in various stages of recovery for the improvement of programs or policies concerning nutrition education in recovery facilities.
ARTICLE IN PRESS J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
This study’s findings emphasized the need for more attention towards food and nutrition at the different stages of recovery and the potential for restructuring treatment programs so that eating behaviors and nutrition education address specific needs at each stage of recovery. The results also revealed the need for a better programmatic approach in which weight gain issues are targeted more systematically, perhaps through nutrition skill building at different stages of recovery. For example, in early recovery when excessive weight gain and disordered eating such as binging and hoarding food occurred frequently, more support is needed to encourage healthy eating patterns in order to facilitate healthy weight gain. These findings also highlighted the need for more attention towards physical activity as an accompanying systematic approach to combat the excessive weight gain in recovery. Moreover, individuals in mid recovery who are usually faced with more responsibilities to purchase and prepare their own meals need to learn good shopping and budgeting skills, and healthy food choices, which will promote a healthy lifestyle. For people in later recovery, maintaining a healthy lifestyle, which includes healthy eating will be essential to a successful recovery thus warrants continued nutritional support perhaps through follow-up services tailored to the needs of recovering alumni living on their own. This study emphasized the differences in weight changes, meaningful use of food, and eating behaviors at different stages of recovery and the opportunities for nutrition interventions at each stage. The excessive weight gain that usually occurs in early recovery and the struggles to lose weight later on in the recovery process further highlight the importance of early nutrition and weight interventions in drug and alcohol treatment facilities. Acknowledgments This research project was supported by a grant from Division of Nutritional Sciences at Cornell University and a fellowship from the State University of New York. The authors would like to acknowledge the helpful comments of Drs. Barbara Strupp and John Cawley and the contributions of the men who shared their perspectives with us. References Anders, R., & Anders, L. (1999). Association between alcohol consumption and mortality, myocardial infarction, and stroke in 25 year follow up of 49, 618 young Swedish men. British Medical Journal, 319(25), 821–822. Angulo, J. (1987). Three meanings of food: The psychological, ecological and symbolic perspecitves. Transformation, 2(2-3), 33–37. Bandura, A. (1977). Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Carney, R. M., & Goldberg, A. P. (1984). Weight gain after cessation of cigarette smoking: A possible role for adipose-tissue lipoprotein lipase. The New England Journal of Medicine, 310, 614–616.
41
Cepik, A., Arikan, A., Boratav, C., & Isik, E. (1995). Bulimia in a male alcoholic: A symptom substitution in alcoholism. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 17, 201–204. Charmaz, K. (Ed.). (2000). Grounded theory: Objectivist and constructivist methods (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. Chen, H., Vlahos, R., Bozinovski, S., Jones, J., Anderson, G. P., & Morris, M. J. (2005). Effect of short-term cigarette smoke exposure on body weight, appetite and brain neuropeptide Y in mice. Neuropsychopharmacology, 30(4), 713–719. Day, D. E., Mintz, E. M., & Bartness, T. J. (1999). Diet self-selection and food hoarding after food deprivation by Siberian hamsters. Physiology & Behavior, 68, 187–194. Day, D. E., & Bartness, T. J. (2003). Fasting-induced increases in food hoarding are dependent on the foraging-effect level. Physiology & Behavior, 78, 655–668. Denzin, N. K., & Lincoln, Y. S. (2003). Collecting and interpreting qualitative materials. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc. Devine, C. M., Conners, M., Bisogni, C. A., & Sobal, J. (1998). Lifecourse influence on fruit and vegetable trajectories: Qualitative analysis of food choices. Journal of Nutrition Education, 30, 361–370. Drug and Alcohol Service Information System Report (DASIS). (2005). A comparison of female and male treatment admission, 2002. Retrieved May 23, 2005, from /http://www.oas.samhsa.gov/2k5/genderTX/ genderTX.htmS. Etter, J. F. (2005). A self-administered questionnaire to measure cigarette withdrawal symptoms: The cigarette withdrawal scale. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 7(1), 47–57. Farkas, M. E., & Dwyer, J. (1984). Nutrition education for alcoholic recovery homes. Journal of Nutrition Education, 16(3), 123–124. Garner, D. M., Olmstead, M. P., Bohr, Y., & Garfinkel, P. E. (1982). The eating attitudes test: Psychometric features and clinical correlates. Psychological Medicine, 12, 871–878. Gillard, E. R., Dang, D. Q., & Stanley, B. G. (1993). Evidence that neuropeptide Y and dopamine in the perifornical hypothalamus interact antagonistically in the control of food intake. Brain Research, 628, 128–136. Glaser, B., & Strauss, A. (1967). Discovery of grounded theory. Chicago, IL: Aldine. Gorski, T. T. (1989a). The CENAPS model of relapse prevention planning. Journal of Chemical Dependency Treatment, 2(2), 153–169. Gorski, T. T. (1989b). The passage through recovery: An action plan for preventing relapse. Center City, MN: Hazeldon. Gorski, T. T. (1990). The Cenaps model of relapse prevention: Basic principle and procedures. Journal of Pscychoactive Drugs, 22(2), 125–133. Gorski, T. T., & Kelly, J. M. (1996). Counselor’s Manual for relapse prevention with chemically dependent criminal offenders. Technical Assistance Publication (TAP) Series 19. DHHS Publication No. (SMA) 96-3115, Center for Substance Abuse Treatment (CSAT), Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), Rockville, MD. Grunberg, N. E. (1982). The effects of nicotine and cigarette smoking on food consumption and taste preferences. Addictive Behavior, 7, 317–331. Hatcher, A. S. (2004). Weight matters during recovery: Unhealthy eating behaviors can impede client progress. Addiction Professional, 2(6), 23–24. Hauser, M. B., & Iber, F. L. (1989). Nutritional advice and diet instruction in alcoholism treatment. Alcohol Research and Health, 13(3), 261–266. Hill, J. O., & Peters, J. C. (1998). Environmental contributions to the obesity epidemic. Science, 280, 1371–1374. Hodgkins, C. C., Jacobs, S., & Gold, M. S. (2003). Weight gain after adolescent drug addiction treatment and supervised abstinence. Psychiatric Annals, 33(2), 112–116. Howard, A. A., Arnsten, J. H., & Gourrevitch, M. N. (2004). Effect of alcohol consumption on diabetes mellitus. Annals of Internal Medicine, 140(3), 211–219.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 42
J. Cowan, C. Devine / Appetite 50 (2008) 33–42
Hudson, J. I., Weiss, R. D., Pope, H. G., McElroy, S. K., & Mirin, S. M. (1992). Eating disorders in hospitalized substance users. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 18, 75–85. Jackson, T. D., & Grilo, C. M. (2002). Weight and eating concerns in outpatient men and women being treated for substance abuse. Eating Weight Disorder, 7, 276–283. Jeffery, R. W., & Utter, J. (2003). The changing environment and population obesity in the United States. Obesity Research, 11, 12S–22S. John, U., Meyer, C., Rumpf, H. J., Hapke, U., & Schumann, A. (2006). Predictors of increased Body Mass Index following cessation of smoking. The American Journal on Addictions, 15(2), 192–197. Johnson, K. H., Barzargan, M., & Cherpitel, C. J. (2001). Alcohol, tobacco, and drug use and the onset of type-2 diabetes among inner city minority patients. Journal of American Board of Family Practice, 14, 430–436. Keys, A., Brozek, J., Henschel, A., Mickelsem, O., & Taylor, H. L. (1950). The biology of human starvation, Vol. 2. Minneapolis: The University of Minnesota Press. Krahn, D. D. (1991). The relationship of eating disorder and substance abuse. Journal of Substance Abuse, 3, 239–253. Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage. Lowe, M. R., Foster, G. D., Kerzhnerman, I., Swain, R. M., & Wadden, T. A. (2001). Restrictive dieting vs. ‘‘undieting’’ effects on eating regulation in obese clinic attenders. Addictive Behaviors, 26, 253–266. McDuff, D. R., Solounias, B. L., RachBeisel, J., & Johnson, J. J. (1994). Psychiatric consultation with substance abusers in early recovery. American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 20(3), 287–299. Meguid, M. M., Fetissov, S. O., Varma, M., Soto, T., Zhang, L., Lavino, A., et al. (2000). Hypothalamic dopamine and serotonin in the regulation of food intake. Nutrition, 16, 843–857. Miles, M. B., & Huberman, A. M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: An expanded sourcebook (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Mitchell, J. E., Pyle, R. L., & Specker, S. (1992). Eating disorder and chemical dependency. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc. Moyer, D. L. (1989). Relapse treatment and prevention in an outpatient rehabilitation program. Journal of Chemical Dependency Treatment, 2(2), 225–240. National Survey on Drug Use and Health Report (NSDUH). (2004). Gender differences in substance dependence and abuse. Retrieved May 23, 2005, from /http://www.oas.samhsa.gov/2k4/genderDependence/ genderDependence.htmS. Ouwens, M. A., Van Strien, T., & van der Staak, C. P. F. (2003). Tendency toward overeating and restraint as predictors of food consumption. Appetite, 40, 291–298. Parillo, M., & Riccardi, G. (2004). Diet composition and the risk of type-2 diabetes: Epidemiological and clinical evidence. British Journal of Nutrition, 92, 7–19. Pierre, J. P., Skjoldager, P., Bennett, A. J., & Renner, M. J. (2001). A behavioral characterization of the effects of food deprivation on food and nonfood object interaction: An investigation of the informationgathering functions of exploratory behavior. Physiology & Behavior, 72, 189–197. Poilkolainen, K. (Ed.). (1998). Editorial: It can be bad for the heart, too— Drinking patterns and coronary heart disease. Addiction, 93(12), 1757–1759. Rawson, R. A., Obert, J. L., McCann, M. J., & Marinelli-Casey, P. (1993). Relapse prevention strategies in outpatient substance abuse treatment. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 7(2), 85–95.
Rehm, J., Gmel, G., Sempos, C. T., & Trevisan, M. (2002). Alcoholrelated morbidity and mortality. Alcohol Research and Health, 27(1), 39–51. Ricciardelli, L. A., Williams, R. J., & Finemore, J. (2001). Restraint as misregulation in drinking and eating. Addictive Behaviors, 26, 665–675. Rioux, D., & Van Meter, W. I. (1990). The ABC’s of awareness: A multimodal approach to relapse prevention. Alcoholism Treatment Quarterly, 7(3), 77–89. Selwyn, P. (Ed.). (1996). Editorial: Overcoming the mind/body dichotomy in drug abuse treatment. Addiction, 91(1), 11–13. Shiffman, S., West, R. J., & Gilbert, D. G. (2004). Recommendation for the assessment of tobacco craving and withdrawal in smoking cessation trials. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 6(4), 599–614. Sobal, J., & Nelson, M. K. (2003). Commensal eating patterns: A community study. Appetite, 41, 181–190. Sone, H., Yamada, N., Mizuno, S., Aida, R., & Ohashi, Y. (2004). Alcohol use and diabetes mellitus. Annals of Internal Medicine, 141(5), 408–409. Strauss, A., & Corbin, J. (1998). Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Sutter, P. M., & Vetter, W. (1999). Alcohol and ischemic stroke. Nutrition Reviews, 57(10), 310–314. van de Weil, A. (2004). Diabetes mellitus and alcohol. Diabetes/ Metabolism Research and Reviews, 20, 263–267. Van Strien, T., Cleven, A., & Schippers, G. (2000). Restraint, tendency toward overeating and ice cream consumption. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 28, 333–338. Volkow, N. D., Chang, L., Wang, G. J., Fowler, J. S., Ding, Y. S., Sedler, M., et al. (2001). Low level of brain dopamine D2 receptors in methamphetamine abusers: Association with metabolism in the orbitofrontal cortex. The American Journal of Psychiatry, 158(12), 2015–2021. Volkow, N. D., Fowler, J. S., Wang, G. J., Hitzemann, R., Logan, J., Schyler, D. J., et al. (1993). Decreased dopamine D2 receptor availability is associated with reduced frontal metabolism in cocaine abusers. Synapse, 14, 169–177. Volkow, N. D., Wang, G. J., Fowler, J. S., Logan, J., Hitzemann, R., Ding, Y. S., et al. (1996). Decreases in dopamine receptors but not in dopamine transporters in alcoholics. Alcohol: Clinical and Experimental Research, 20, 1594–1598. Wang, G. J., Volkow, N. D., Fowlers, J. S., Logan, J., Abumrad, N. N., Hitzemann, R. J., et al. (1997). Dopamine D2 receptors availability in opiate-dependent subjects before and after naloxone-precipitated withdrawal. Neuropsychopharmacology, 16, 174–182. Wang, G. J., Volkow, N. D., Thanos, P. K., & Fowlers, J. S. (2004). Similarity between obesity and drug addiction as assessed by neurofunctional imaging: A concept review. Journal of Addictive Disorders, 23(3), 39–53. Wanksink, B., Cheney, M. M., & Chan, N. (2003). Exploring comfort food preference across age and gender. Physiology & Behavior, 79, 739–747. Westenhoefer, J., & Pudel, V. (1993). Pleasure from food: Importance for food choice and consequence of deliberate restriction. Appetite, 20, 246–249. Wiseman, C. V., Sunday, S. R., Halligan, P., Korn, S., Brown, C., & Halmi, K. A. (1995). Substance dependence and eating disorder: Impact of sequence on comorbidity. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 40(5), 332–336. Woods, A. D., & Bartness, T. J. (1996). Caloric density affects food hoarding and intake by Siberian Hamsters. Physiology & Behavior, 59, 897–903.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research Report
Sensitivity to reward and body mass index (BMI): Evidence for a non-linear relationship Caroline Davisa,b,, John Foxc a
Kinesiology & Health Sciences, York University, 343 Bethune College, 4700 Keele Street, Toronto Ont., Canada, M3J 1P3 Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, 343 Bethune College, 4700 Keele Street, Toronto, Canada, M3J 1P3Toronto, Ont., Canada c McMaster University, Hamilton, Ont., Canada
b
Received 8 November 2006; received in revised form 21 May 2007; accepted 22 May 2007
Abstract The role of brain reward mechanisms, and associated personality traits, are of growing interest to researchers in the field of eating behaviours and obesity. However, the direction of causal influence has produced some debate and inconsistency in the literature. Some have argued that a reward deficiency syndrome increases the risk for obesity while others have claimed that a heightened sensitivity to reward is linked to higher body mass index (BMI). To reconcile these two perspectives, a non-linear relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI was predicted. Previous research has also not considered whether sex moderates the relationship between these two variables. Results indicated that although men had significantly higher reward sensitivity than women, the interaction between sex and BMI was not significant. As predicted, the quadratic term of BMI was statistically significant indicating a moderately positive relationship between BMI and reward sensitivity in the normal and overweight range of BMI (18–30) after which the relationship changed direction and was inversely related in those with moderate and extreme obesity. This curvilinear relationship meshes with, and helps to integrate, the two perspectives described above and found in previous studies. It would behoove future researchers to identify behaviours that might explain the association between a psychobiological trait like reward sensitivity and a physical characteristic like body size, and to explicate the possibly reciprocal causal mechanisms that underlie this association. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Sensitivity to reward; BMI; Overeating; Dopamine; Non-linear
Dopamine (DA) availability in the brain’s mesocorticolimbic pathway has been widely implicated in the regulation of our emotional capacity to feel pleasure and our desire to seek out natural rewards in our environment (Berridge, 2003; Wise, 2004). As with all biological systems, however, there is considerable response variability across individuals. Gray’s (1987) reinforcement sensitivity theory describes a personality dimension, based on individual differences in the activation threshold of brain reward regions—what Gray has called the behavioural activation system (BAS). Those with a more sensitive BAS (i.e. high
reward sensitivity) are more prone to detect signals of reward in their environment, to approach with greater alacrity potentially rewarding stimuli, and to experience more positive affect (pleasure/reinforcement) when they are in situations with cues of reward. Accordingly, those with a more sensitive or reactive DA pathway1 are likely to have a greater capacity for reward and a stronger drive to engage in behaviours with potentially pleasurable outcomes (Cohen, Young, Baek, Kessler, & Ranganath, 2005). Alternatively, a sluggish DA system is thought to foster an anhedonic demeanor and a relative insensitivity to natural rewards (Depue & Collins, 1999; Evans et al., 2006).
Corresponding author. Kinesiology & Health Sciences, York University, 343 Bethune College, 4700 Keele Street, Toronto Ont., Canada, M3J 1P3. E-mail address:
[email protected] (C. Davis).
1 The strength of the DA signal and the level of DA availability are influenced by many factors such as the DA transporter, the density of DA receptors, the ability of the neuron to synthesize DA, and its ability to secrete DA into the synapse.
Introduction
0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.007
ARTICLE IN PRESS 44
C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49
There is now substantial evidence, from animal studies and human research, that brain reward regions play an important role in the development of obesity through their regulation of appetite (Di Chiara, 2005; Kelley, Baldo, Pratt, & Will, 2005; Need, Ahmadi, Spector, & Goldstein, 2005). However, the manner in which reward sensitivity impacts eating behaviour—in other words, the direction of causal influence—has produced some debate and inconsistency in the scientific literature. Reward Deficiency Syndrome One argument favours the view that hypo-dopaminergic functioning—what has been called a reward deficiency syndrome (RDS)–is a key factor in the development of obesity (e.g. Pagoto, Spring, Cook, McChargue, & Schneider, 2006; Wang et al., 2002; Wang et al., 2001; Wang, Volkow, Thanos, & Fowler, 2004). When there is sub-optimal functioning of the brain reward cascade, which could be caused by certain genetic variants in the DA system, that person is likely to need a DA ‘fix’ to feel good and to improve the DA deficit (Blum & Braverman, 2001). In other words, a sluggish or under-reactive DA reward pathway will foster a diminished motivation to engage in rewarding behaviours.2 In this context, highly palatable foods can serve a ‘self-medicating’ function similar to drugs of abuse because of their ability to enhance DA activation and improve mood (Bowirrat & Oscar-Berman, 2005). Supporting evidence for the RDS theory is based largely on the finding of lower DA D2 receptor densities in obese adults compared to their non-obese counterparts as assessed by neuroimaging scans (Wang et al., 2001) and some genetic research (e.g. Blum et al., 1996). Indirect evidence also comes from the findings that certain DA antagonist drugs (such as clozapine) used in the treatment of psychotic disorders cause increased appetite and significant weight gain in some patients (e.g. de Leon, Diaz, Josiassen, Cooper, & Simpson, 2007; Guo et al., 2007; Masi, Mucci, & Pari, 2006). Currently unknown genetic factors are likely to contribute to the variability of appetite response among patients, resulting in substantial interest in the pharmacogenetics of neuroleptic drug use (Reynolds, Templeman, & Godlewska, 2006). Heightened sensitivity to reward Supporting the hedonic route to obesity, studies have found that sensitivity to reward (SR) —as assessed by selfreport questionnaires—correlates with eating habits that contribute to weight gain. For instance, this trait has been positively associated with emotional overeating, preference for high fat food, binge eating, and food 2 It is important to emphasize that hypo-functioning of the DA pathways may be a genetically inherited condition or it may be caused by various environmental factors such as chronic stress or substance abuse.
cravings (Davis et al., 2007; Davis, Strachan, & Berkson, 2004; Davis & Woodside, 2002; Franken & Muris, 2005; Loxton & Dawe, 2001). To date, only a few studies have investigated direct links between SR and body weight in humans. Franken and Muris (2005) reported a positive relationship between these two variables, but, their sample comprised only young females (mean age of 20 years), and more than 90% of the sample was either normal weight or below. In an earlier study, Davis et al. (2004) found some evidence for a non-linear relationship between BMI and physical anhedonia—a personality trait that has some conceptual overlap with SR. Although their sample reflected a broader range of BMI values, and was therefore more representative of the general adult population, it too was limited in its generalizability because it included only female participants. Argument for a curvilinear relationship As a means of reconciling the alternative viewpoints described above, an inverted-U function is proposed to describe the relationship between SR and BMI whereby both ends of the BMI dimension could reflect low reward sensitivity, albeit from differing motivational processes. Such a proposition is not only theoretically intuitive, but it meshes well with the existing data. First, it was expected that a positive association would be found between SR and BMI in the non-obese range of the body-weight continuum. There is good evidence that within normal limits increases in mesolimbic DA are associated with more appetitive behaviours as seen, for example, in a recent study by Volkow et al. (2002). Amplification of the DA signal via a small dose of oral methylphenidate3 increased the desire of their participants to eat in response to a palatable food cue. Also, according to reinforcement sensitivity theory (Gray, 1987), those with a greater SR have a stronger appetitive drive, and therefore should be more likely to engage in hedonic eating than their less reward-sensitive counterparts. Over time, this pattern of behaviour may foster an energy imbalance associated with incremental weight gain.4 Secondly, at the higher (obese) end of the body-weight continuum, an inverse relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI was expected. Such a finding would map onto the RDS evidence—in particular, the often-cited study by Wang et al. (2001) who found a negative relationship between DA D2 receptor densities and BMI. In other words, the most morbidly obese participants in 3 Methylphenidate is a psychomotor stimulant which binds to the DA transporter, thereby inhibiting the reuptake of DA into the cell, and increasing its availability in the synapse. 4 It is important to keep in mind, however, that DA activation is likely to have a biphasic effect on appetite response as seen by the appetitesuppressing effects of powerful DA agonists like amphetamine (e.g. Kuo, 2003). In other words, an increase of the DA signal within the moderate/ normal range is likely to foster appetitive motivation, while augmentation to very high levels is likely to have an anorexic effect.
ARTICLE IN PRESS C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49
their study had the fewest DA D2 receptors and were assumed to be the most deficient in hedonic capacity. Wang and colleagues have argued that highly palatable foods, eaten in large quantities, can compensate for a reward deficit in the same manner as addictive drugs. With this pattern of excessive and high-calorie consumption, weight gain could be rapid and prodigious. It is important, however, to consider that Wang et al’s data could reflect the sequelae of overeating rather than a factor antecedent to its onset, especially since all cases in their study were in the morbidly obese range of BMI. Excessive food consumption is likely to cause a down-regulation of post-synaptic D2 receptors as is typically seen in the case of chronic drug addicts (see Leshner & Koob, 1999 for a review) and animals subjected to repeated intake of sweet and fatty food (Kelley, Will, Steininger, Zhang, & Haber, 2003). In summary, we are predicting a non-linear relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI because a reward deficit could relate either to low or to high BMI. For some individuals, a low SR may contribute to reduced food intake (and consequently low body weight) because of diminished motivation for, and pleasure from, eating. In other individuals, a reward deficiency might foster overeating of highly palatable food (and a relatively high body weight) as a means of ‘self-medication’ to compensate for a sluggish brain reward system. A third process is also relevant to the dynamics of our predicted curvilinear relationship. Individuals who are inherently highly sensitive to reward—those who we argue are prone to hedonic overeating—could over time experience a down-regulation of DA pathways and reward sensitivity as a result of the chronic over-consumption of calorically dense foods. Such a neuroadaption would mimic that found in addicts who abuse addictive substances (see Davis et al., 2004; Wang et al., 2004). The current study represents the first attempt to examine, in a comprehensive way, the relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI in a large sample of men and women who represent a broad range of BMI values, including a substantial proportion of moderate and morbidly obese participants. It is also the first to examine sex differences and their possible moderating effect on the relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI. In light of our prediction that sensitivity has an inverted-U relationship with BMI, we fit a quadratic regression model to the data, allowing as well for the possible interaction of BMI with sex. In addition, to enable us to discover a nonlinear relationship different from the one that we predicted, we fit a non-parametric regression model to the data.
45
years, SD ¼ 7.13) and BMI (men: x¯ ¼ 28:24, SD ¼ 5.56; women: x¯ ¼ 30:67, SD ¼ 8.01). In both groups, the participants were predominantly Caucasian with a smaller proportion of Afro-Canadians. Individuals of South Asian (e.g. Korean, Japanese) and Chinese descent were excluded from the study because of evidence that a uniform risk-classification system based on BMI is inappropriate across all ethnicities. In particular, it is recommended that in South Asian and Chinese populations, BMI cut-offs for optimal health should be far below the WHO values currently in common use (Razak et al., 2005). Participants were recruited from newspaper advertisements and from posters placed at several large urban institutions (e.g. hospitals and universities) asking for ‘healthy adults’ to take part in a psychology study. In order to attract a sufficiently large sample of obese individuals, some of our advertisements and posters asked for ‘Plus-Sized Adults’ to participate in the research. Volunteers were screened during an initial telephone interview and excluded if they were: (i) pregnant, (ii) not fluent in English, (iii) had not resided in Canada for at least 5 years, and (iv) were currently being treated for a serious medical condition such as angina or diabetes, or had any psychiatric conditions such as depression, substance abuse, or an eating disorder.5 If participants passed the telephone screening interview, they were assessed individually, after giving signed informed consent, in one of two research facilities. Trained research assistants conducted a more comprehensive screening using a standard medical and psychiatric interview protocol. Following this, the questionnaire package was completed, height and weight were measured, and each individual was paid a small stipend for participation. The data used in this study are part of a larger, ongoing project whose results will be published at a later date. Measures SR was assessed by one scale of the Sensitivity to Punishment and Sensitivity to Reward Questionnaire (SPSRQ) (Torrubia, Avila, Molto, & Caseras, 2001), and comprises 24 forced-choice items reflecting the respondent’s approach responses under various conditions of reward. The scale items reflect both the anticipation of reward (e.g. Does the good prospect of obtaining money motivate you strongly to do some things?) and pleasure experienced from rewarding activities (e.g. Does you attention easily stray from your work in the presence of an attractive stranger?). This scale was developed to
Methods Participants and procedure Study participants included 369 healthy adult men (n ¼ 138) and women (n ¼ 231). They were similar in age (men: x¯ ¼ 28:24 years, SD ¼ 7.66; women: x¯ ¼ 30:67
5 By eliminating participants with depression, the representativeness of the sample is somewhat compromised, especially because of the high prevalence of obesity in those with depression (Ohayon, 2007). However, since most people in treatment for depression take anti-depression medications, many of which affect appetite and body weight, it was our feeling that the medication factor could present a potential confound in the interpretation of our results.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 46
C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49
assess Gray’s psychobiological model of personality (see Gray, 1987, 1990), a well-validated theory based on two independent neurobiological motivational systems: the BIS and the BAS. High reward sensitivity (reflected by high scores on the SR scale) is seen as a reflection of a strong BAS—i.e. a heightened tendency to approach pleasurable stimuli in one’s environment, and to find the associated behaviours rewarding. Low SR scores would reflect a deficient SR. This scale has shown good internal consistency, temporal stability, and concurrent validity (e.g. Caseras, Avila, & Torrubia, 2003). Nevertheless, psychometric evaluation of the factor structure of the SPSRQ in two recent studies has identified a number of poor items (Cogswell, Alloy, van Dulmen, & Fresco, 2006; O’Connor, Colder, & Hawk, 2004). Indeed, in both studies the same 7 items were identified as problematic in the SR scale, and their authors noted some improvement in the factor structure of the questionnaire— without sacrificing the validity of the scales—when these items were trimmed from the item pool. Cogswell et al. (2006) strongly recommend that researchers will benefit from continued evaluation of the full versus the trimmed version of these scales in future studies. For this reason, both the 24-item original SR scale and the trimmed 17-item scale were employed in the data analysis. The alpha coefficients in the present study were 0.76 for the full scale and 0.74 for the trimmed scale, and their inter-correlation was 0.96. BMI (weight[kg]/height[metres2]) was calculated from height and weight measured with the participant wearing indoor clothing and standing in stocking feet.
Results Descriptive statistics Table 1 presents the means, standard deviations, extremes, and quartiles for BMI and SR, shown separately for male (n ¼ 136) and female (n ¼ 230) subjects. Only subjects with complete data on all variables in the analysis are included: 3 subjects were omitted because they did not answer all of the questions comprising the SR scale.6 Male subjects have a statistically significantly lower average BMI than female subjects (t ¼ 3.39, df ¼ 354, po.001, twosided) and higher average SR (t ¼ 5.29, df ¼ 259, po.001, two-sided).7 Variation in BMI is smaller for males than for females; variation in SR is slightly larger for males. 6 The results reported below use the 17-item trimmed version of the scale, but we obtained essentially identical results with the full 24 items, as is unsurprising given the very high correlation between the two versions of the scale. 7 The degrees of freedom for each t-test were computed by the commonly employed Welch–Satterthwaite approximation, appropriate when the variances are not assumed to be equal, and are reported here to the nearest whole number.
Table 1 Distribution of BMI and sensitivity to reward by sex
BMI Males Females
Mean
SD
Minimum
Q1
Median
Q3
Maximum
28.23 30.65
5.60 8.01
19.03 17.16
23.67 24.41
27.38 29.79
31.21 35.84
46.09 51.60
0 0
6.75 4
8 7
11 9
17 16
Sensitivity to reward Males 8.62 3.59 Females 6.64 3.22
Table 2 Analysis-of-variance table for the regression model fit to sensitivity to reward Source
df
Sum of squares
Mean square
F
p
Sex BMI Linear Quadratic Sex BMI Linear Quadratic Error
1 2 1 1 2 1 1 360
256.7 94.9 24.4 70.5 0.32 0.11 0.21 4021.9
256.7 47.5 24.4 70.5 0.16 0.11 0.21 11.2
23.0 4.2 2.2 6.3 0.01 0.01 0.02
o0.001 0.015 0.14 0.012 0.99 0.92 0.89
Total
365
4451.7
Regression analysis As explained, we undertook a quadratic regression of SR on BMI, expecting to find a positive relationship between the two variables at low levels of BMI and a negative relationship at high levels. We employed an orthogonal polynomial basis for the quadratic in BMI.8 The regression model includes a dummy variable for sex, coded 1 for males and 0 for females, and interaction regressors for BMI and sex. As well, so that we could detect a relationship between BMI and SR different from the one anticipated, we also fit a non-parametric-regression model to the data, employing a smoothing spline in BMI, and selecting the equivalent degrees of freedom for the spline by generalized cross-validation (Wood, 2000). An analysis-of-variance table for the quadratic regression appears in Table 2. The interaction between sex and BMI is essentially absent (p ¼ 0.99): The regression curves for male and female subjects are almost perfectly parallel. There is, however, strong evidence of a sex effect on SR (po0.001), and moderately strong evidence of an effect of BMI (p ¼ 0.015); moreover, the quadratic component of the BMI term is statistically significant (p ¼ 0.013).
8 The linear regressor is therefore centred at 0, and the quadratic regressor is uncorrelated with the linear regressor. The fitted quadratic curve itself, however, is identical to that produced by employing the raw quadratic regressors BMI and BMI2.
ARTICLE IN PRESS C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49
Table 3 displays the coefficients for the additive quadratic regression of SR on BMI and sex. At fixed levels of BMI, male subjects on average are nearly 2 points higher than female subjects in SR, a difference that is only slightly smaller than the marginal difference in means for the sexes. Sex and BMI account for about 10% of the variation in SR. The quadratic partial relationship between SR and BMI is displayed in the ‘effect plot’ (Fox, 1987, 2003) in Fig. 1, panel (a): This graph was constructed by setting the dummy regressor for sex to 0.5, representing a hypothetical group composed equally of males and females, allowing BMI to range over the values observed in the data, and computing fitted values from the regression model in Table 3. The broken lines in the graph represent a point-wise 95% confidence envelope around the fitted quadratic regression. Panel (b) of Fig. 1 shows a similar effect plot for the additive non-parametric regression that we fit to the data. The equivalent degrees of freedom for the BMI spline term in the model is 2.61—slightly more than the 2 degrees of freedom used by the quadratic regression in panel (a). Not only are the two fitted curves very similar, but the two models produce nearly identical fits to the data: Fitted values for the 366 subjects under the two models correlate in excess of 0.99.
Discussion The role of brain reward mechanisms, and associated personality traits, are of growing interest to researchers in the field of eating behaviours and obesity. As we predicted, results from the present study identified a non-linear relationship between SR and BMI in a sample of men and women who represent a broad spread of values on both variables. It was also clearly evident that this relationship was essentially identical in men and women, although the former reported significantly greater reward sensitivity. There is increasing recognition that many biopsychosocial relationships are not linear in the full range of their expression (Waldman, Atwater, & Davidson, 2004; Wong & Lachenbruch, 1996), including factors that influence BMI (Oh & Seo, 2001; Payne & Morrison, 2002; Vandewater, Shim, & Caplovitz, 2004). In these cases, it is generally more appropriate to use a quadratic model, or other non-linear models to represent the relationship between the two variables. SR and BMI Among normal-weight and overweight participants, the relationship between reward sensitivity and BMI was in the positive direction, but changed to a negative association in the cohort who were moderately and morbidly obese. In considering this inverted-U relationship, it is probable that the causal direction of influence between the two variables is dynamic and even reciprocal, and is dependent on how each interfaces with other relevant psycho-social factors. Undoubtedly there are many routes to obesity. Those with a relatively high SR-by definition, individuals with a strong appetitive drive—are likely to have more difficulty resisting the temptation of readily available, rich and tasty foods in our current ‘supermarket’ environment. Gradually, and over time, weight gain will ensue, which can bring its own, sometimes stressful, consequences. Concerning those at the opposite end of the reward sensitivity continuum, our findings suggest that a doublepronged mechanism could link low SR with body weight
Table 3 Coefficients and standard errors for the additive quadratic regression of sensitivity to reward on sex and BMI Coefficient Intercept Sex (male ¼ 1) BMI Linear Quadratic
Standard error
6.72 1.77
0.22 0.37
5.19 8.47
3.38 3.36
R2 ¼ 0.096
Quadratic Regression 8
b Sensitivity to Reward
Sensitivity to Reward
a
7 6 5 4
47
Additive Nonparametric Regression 8 7 6 5 4
3 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 BMI
20 25 30 35 40 45 50 BMI
Fig. 1. Fitted sensitivity to reward by BMI, for a hypothetical group composed equally of males and females. The ‘‘rug plot’’ at the bottom of each panel shows the distribution of BMI. The broken lines give a 95-percent point-wise confidence envelope around the fit.
ARTICLE IN PRESS 48
C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49
via two different motivational responses to food intake. On the one hand, a relatively depressed appetite (and therefore low body weight) could occur—as is typically seen in the melancholic form of depression (Gold & Chrousos, 2002)—because of the subjectively diminished reward potential of food. On the other hand, a low SR might promote the use of highly palatable food to boost an anhedonic affect in order to compensate for what is believed to be a DA deficit. If ‘self-medication’ with food occurs frequently, and to a great degree, the outcome would almost certainly be a high BMI. One important limitation of this study is its sole reliance on a self-report assessment of the reward sensitivity construct. To date, there has been very little human research bridging the gap between neurobiological studies of brain reward functioning and psychological research using personality measures of SR. In other words, evidence that psycho-behavioural assessments of this trait correlate with biological markers of DA activation in the mesocorticolimbic regions is minimal. Exceptions are two recent studies. One (White, Lott, & de Wit, 2006) found a positive association between response to amphetamine (greater liking, more wanting of the drug) and a questionnaire measure of reward sensitivity (using the Multidimensional Personality Questionnaire-Brief Form: Patrick, Curtin, & Tellegen, 2002), while the second demonstrated that selfreport reward sensitivity (as assessed by the Drive subscale of the BIS/BAS: Carver & White, 1994) was positively correlated with degree of activation of brain reward regions in response to visual images of appetizing food (Beaver et al., 2006). Before we can claim definitively that variation in brain reward mechanisms can be conceptualized and assessed in any meaningful way as a personality trait— and thereby related to risk for obesity—we need to have a converging base of human research that links personality and behaviour to relevant biological markers.
References Beaver, J. D., Lawrence, A. D., Van Ditzhuijzen, J., Davis, M. H., Woods, A., & Calder, A. J. (2006). Individual differences in reward drive predict neural responses to images of food. Journal of Neuroscience, 26, 5160–5166. Berridge, K. C. (2003). Pleasures of the brain. Brain and Cognition, 52, 106–128. Blum, K., & Braverman, E. R. (2001). ‘‘Reward deficiency syndrome’’: An emerging concept. Molecular Psychiatry, 6(Suppl 1), S3. Blum, K., Sheridan, P. J., Wood, R. C., Braverman, E. R., Chen, T. J. H., Cull, J. G., et al. (1996). The D-2 dopamine receptor gene as a determinant of reward deficiency syndrome. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 89, 396–400. Bowirrat, A., & Oscar-Berman, M. (2005). Relationship between dopaminergic neurotransmission, alcoholism, and reward deficiency syndrome. American Journal of Medical Genetics Part B-Neuropsychiatric Genetics, 132B, 29–37. Carver, C. S., & White, T. L. (1994). Behavioral inhibition, behavioral activation, and affective responese to impending reward and punishment: The BIS/BAS scales. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67, 319–333.
Caseras, X., Avila, C., & Torrubia, R. (2003). The measurement of individual differences in Behavioural Inhibition and Behavioural Activation Systems: A comparison of personality scales. Personality and Individual Differences, 34, 999–1013. Cogswell, A., Alloy, L. B., van Dulmen, M. H. M., & Fresco, D. M. (2006). A psychometric evaluation of behavioral inhibition and approach self-report measure. Personality and Individual Differences, 40, 1649–1658. Cohen, M. X., Young, J., Baek, J-M., Kessler, C., & Ranganath, C. (2005). Individual differences in extraversion and dopamine genetics predict neural reward responses. Cognitive Brain Research, 25, 851–861. Davis, C., Patte, K., Levitan, R. D., Reid, C., Tweed, S., & Curtis, C. (2007). From motivation to behaviour: A model of reward sensitivity, overeating, and food preferences in the risk profile for obesity. Appetite, 48, 12–19. Davis, C., Strachan, S., & Berkson, M. (2004). Sensitivity to reward: Implications for overeating and overweight. Appetite, 42, 131–138. Davis, C., & Woodside, D. B. (2002). Sensitivity to the rewarding effects of food and exercise in the eating disorders. Comprehensive Psychiatry, 43, 189–194. de Leon, J., Diaz, F. J., Josiassen, R. C., Cooper, T. B., & Simpson, G. M. (2007). Weight gain during a double-blind multidosage clozapine study. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology, 27, 22–27. Depue, R. A., & Collins, P. F. (1999). Neurobiology of the structure of personality: Dopamine, facilitation of incentive motivation, and extraversion. The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 22, 491–517 (discussion 518–569). Di Chiara, G. (2005). Dopamine in disturbances of food and drug motivated behavior: A case of homology? Physiology & Behavior, 86, 9–10. Evans, A. H., Lawrence, A. D., Potts, J., MacGregor, L., Katzenschlager, R., Shaw, K., et al. (2006). Relationship between impulsive sensation seeking traits, smoking, alcohol and caffeine intake, and Parkinson’s disease. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 77, 317–321. Fox, J. (1987). Effect displays for generalized linear models. Sociological Methodology, 17, 347–361. Fox, J. (2003). Effect displays in R for generalized linear models. Journal of Statistical Software, 8(15), 1–27. Franken, I. H. A., & Muris, P. (2005). Individual differences in reward sensitivity are related to food craving and relative body weight in healthy women. Appetite, 45, 198–201. Gold, P. W., & Chrousos, G. P. (2002). Organization of the stress system and its dysregulation in melancholic and atypical depression: High vs low CRH/NE states. Molecular Psychiatry, 7, 254–275. Gray, J. A. (1987). The neuropsychology of emotion and personality. In S. M. Stahl, S. D. Iverson, & E. C. Goodman (Eds.), Cognitive Neurochemistry (pp. 171–190). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Gray, J. A. (1990). Brain systems that mediate both emotion and cognition. Cognition and Emotion, 4, 269–288. Guo, J. J., Keck, P. E., Jr., Corey-Lisle, P. K., Li, H., Jiang, D., Jang, R., et al. (2007). Risk of diabetes mellitus associated with atypical antipsychotic use among medicaid patients with bipolar disorder: A nested case-control study. Pharmacotherapy, 27, 27–35. Kelley, A. E., Baldo, B. A., Pratt, W. E., & Will, M. J. (2005). Corticostriatal-hypothalamic circuitry and food motivation: Integration of energy, action and reward. Physiology & Behavior, 86, 773–795. Kelley, A. E., Will, M. J., Steininger, T. L., Zhang, M., & Haber, S. N. (2003). Restricted daily consumption of a highly palatable food (chocolate Ensure) alters striatal enkephalin gene expression. European Journal of Neuroscience, 18, 2592–2598. Kuo, D. Y. (2003). Further evidence of the mediation of both subtypes of dopamine D1/D2 receptors and cerebral neuropeptide Y (NPY) in amphetamine-induced appetite suppression. Behavioural Brain Research, 147, 149–155. Leshner, A. I., & Koob, G. F. (1999). Drugs of abuse and the brain. Proceedings of the Association of American Physicians, 111, 99–108.
ARTICLE IN PRESS C. Davis, J. Fox / Appetite 50 (2008) 43–49 Loxton, N. J., & Dawe, S. (2001). Alcohol abuse and dysfunctional eating in adolescent girls: The influence of individual differences in sensitivity to reward and punishment. International Journal of Eating Disorders, 29, 455–462. Masi, G., Mucci, M., & Pari, C. (2006). Children with schizophreniaClinical picture and pharmacological treatment. CNS Drugs, 20, 841–866. Need, A. C., Ahmadi, K. R., Spector, T. D., & Goldstein, D. B. (2005). Obesity is associated with genetic variants that alter dopamine availability. Annals of Human Genetics, 70, 293–303. O’Connor, R. M., Colder, C. R., & Hawk, L. W., Jr. (2004). Confirmatory factor analysis of the sensitivity to punishment and sensitivity to reward questionnaire. Personality and Individual Differences, 37, 985–1002. Oh, H. S., & Seo, W. S. (2001). The compound relationship of smoking and alcohol consumption with obesity. Yonsei Medical Journal, 42, 480–487. Ohayon, M. M. (2007). Epidemiology of depression and its treatment in the general population. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 41, 207–213. Pagoto, S. L., Spring, B., Cook, J. W., McChargue, D., & Schneider, K. (2006). High BMI and reduced engagement and enjoyment of pleasant events. Personality and Individual Differences, 40, 1421–1431. Patrick, C. J., Curtin, J. J., & Tellegen, A. (2002). Development and validation of a brief form of the Multidimensional Personality Questionnaire. Psychological Assessment, 14, 150–163. Payne, R. L., & Morrison, D. (2002). The differential effects of negative affectivity on measures of well-being versus job satisfaction and organizational commitment. Anxiety Stress and Coping, 15, 231–244. Razak, F., Anand, S., Vuksan, V., Davis, B., Jacobs, R., Teo, K. K., et al. (2005). Ethnic differences in the relationships between obesity and glucose-metabolism abnormalities: A cross-sectional population-based study. International Journal of Obesity, 29, 656–667. Reynolds, G. P., Templeman, L. A., & Godlewska, B. R. (2006). Pharmacogenetics of schizophrenia. Expert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy, 7, 1429–1440.
49
Torrubia, R., Avila, C., Molto, J., & Caseras, X. (2001). The sensitivity to punishment and sensitivity to reward questionnaire (SPSRQ) as a measure of Gray’s anxiety and impulsivity dimensions. Personality and Individual Differences, 31, 837–862. Vandewater, E. A., Shim, M. S., & Caplovitz, A. G. (2004). Linking obesity and activity level with children’s television and video game use. Journal of Adolescence, 27, 71–85. Volkow, N. D., Wang, G.-J., Fowler, J. S., Logan, J., Jayne, M., Francesschi, D., et al. (2002). ‘‘Nonhedonic’’ food motivation in humans involves dopamine in the dorsal striatum and methyphenidate amplifies this effect. Synapse, 44, 175–180. Waldman, D. A., Atwater, L. E., & Davidson, R. A. (2004). The role of individualism and the Five-Factor Model in the prediction of performance in a leaderless group discussion. Journal of Personality, 72, 1–28. Wang, G. J., Volkow, N. D., Felder, C., Fowler, J. S., Levy, A. V., Pappas, N. R., et al. (2002). Enhanced resting activity of the oral somatosensory cortex in obese subjects. Neuroreport, 13, 1151–1155. Wang, G.-J., Volkow, N. D., Logan, J., Pappas, N. R., Wong, C. T., Zhu, et al. (2001). Brain dopamine and obesity. The Lancet, 357, 354–357. Wang, G. J., Volkow, N. D., Thanos, P. K., & Fowler, J. S. (2004). Similarity between obesity and drug addiction as assessed by neurofunctional imaging: A concept review. Journal of Affective Disorders, 23, 39–53. White, T. L., Lott, D. C., & de Wit, H. (2006). Personality and subjective effects of acute amphetamine in healthy volunteers. Neuropsychopharmacology, 31, 1064–1074. Wise, R. A. (2004). Dopamine, learning and motivation. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 5, 483–494. Wong, W. K., & Lachenbruch, P. A. (1996). Tutorial in biostatistics designing studies for dose response. Statistics in Medicine, 15, 343–359. Wood, S. N. (2000). Modelling and smoothing parameter estimation with multiple quadratic penalties. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 62, 413–428.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
Appetite 50 (2008) 50–56 www.elsevier.com/locate/appet
Research Report
Effects of short-term moderate alcohol administration on oxidative stress and nutritional status in healthy males Giovanni Addoloratoa,, Lorenzo Leggioa,c, Veronica Ojettia, Esmeralda Capristoa, Giovanni Gasbarrinia, Antonio Gasbarrinib a
Institutes of Internal Medicine, Catholic University of Rome, L.go A. Gemelli 8, I-00168, Rome, Italy b Medical Pathology, Catholic University of Rome c Center for Alcohol and Addiction Studies, Department of Psychiatry and Human Behaviour, Brown University Medical School, Providence (RI), USA Received 28 March 2007; received in revised form 21 May 2007; accepted 22 May 2007
Abstract The effects of moderate amounts of different alcoholic beverages on oxidative stress and nutritional parameters were investigated in 40 healthy subjects. Ethanol 40 g/day was administered at the two main meals for 30 days by beer (group A), wine (group B) or spirit (group C); controls (group D) maintaned abstinence. Malondyaldeide (MDA), adenosine-triphosphate (ATP), reduced-glutathione (GSH), E-vitamin and nutritional status were evaluated at the start (T0) and the end (T1) of the study. At T1 controls did not present significant changes in the assessed parameters, while a significant increase of malondyaldeide (MDA) and a significant decrease of reducedglutathione and E-vitamin in group A, B and C and of ATP in group C were observed. Fat mass (FM) increased slightly in group A and B and decreased in group C. Ethanol decreased antioxidant parameters and increased lipoperoxidation parameters. However some of these changes appeared attenuated when ethanol was consumed in beer or wine. Finally, short-term moderate ethanol intake appeared to influence the FM, although it was not able to significantly affect nutritional or body composition. r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Ethanol; Beer; Wine; Oxidative stress; Lipid peroxidation; Antioxidants
Introduction The impact of alcohol consumption on individual’s health is related to drinking behaviour patterns as well as to genetic factors (Lieber, 1995). Beneficial and adverse effects due to alcohol intake have been reported in several epidemiologic studies, showing a J-shaped relationship between the amount of alcohol consumed and mortality (Criqui and Ringel, 1994; Stefanini, Caputo, & Addolorato, 1998). In particular, although acute and chronic alcohol abuse are related to an increase in mortality, particularly due to liver diseases (Gramenzi et al., 2006; Lieber, 1988), hemorragic stroke and cardiovascular diseases (Lucas, Brown, Wassef, & Giles, 2005), consumption of moderate doses of ethanol seems to be associated Corresponding author. Institute of Internal Medicine Catholic University of Rome. E-mail address:
[email protected] (G. Addolorato).
0195-6663/$ - see front matter r 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.05.008
with a lower death rate from coronary heart disease (CAD) and thrombotic stroke (Klatsky, 2002; Renaud and De Lorgeril, 1992). Apart from the mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of tissue injury, mortality and morbidity related to alcohol abuse, great attention has been recently devoted both to alcohol induced nutritional disorders (Addolorato, Capristo, Greco, Stefanini, & Gasbarrini, 1997, 1998; Addolorato et al., 2006) and alcohol related oxidative stress (Addolorato et al., 2001; Lieber, 2005). Gender-related difference seems to play an important role in these mechanisms (Addolorato et al., 1999; Gasbarrini et al., 2001). On the other hand an increase of the antioxidant activity in blood of subjects with a moderate alcohol intake has been recently indicated as a possible protective mechanism against CAD mortality (Gorinstein et al., 1997), in addition to an alcohol-related action on the high-densitity-lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) (Rapaport, 1989) and on platelet aggregation (Renaud & De Lorgeril, 1992).
ARTICLE IN PRESS G. Addolorato et al. / Appetite 50 (2008) 50–56
Wine and beer are the most common ethanol-containing beverages in developed countries; both beverages have many non alcohol components with antioxidant proper