Animal Science Reviews 2010
Animal Science Reviews Animal Science Reviews provides scientists and students in the field with timely analysis on key topics in current research. These chapters were originally published online in CAB Reviews. This volume makes available in printed form the reviews in animal science published during 2010.
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Edited by
David Hemming CAB International, UK
CABI is a trading name of CAB International
CABI Head Office Nosworthy Way Wallingford Oxfordshire OX10 8DE UK Tel: +44 (0)1491 832111 Fax: +44 (0)1491 833508 E-mail:
[email protected] Website: www.cabi.org
CABI North American Office 875 Massachusetts Avenue 7th Floor Cambridge, MA02139 USA Tel: +1 617 395 4056 Fax: +1 617 354 6875 E-mail:
[email protected]
g CAB International 2011. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or by any means, electronically, mechanically, by photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owners.
ISBN: 978 1 84593 880 2 Commissioning editor: Nigel Farrar Production editor: Mike Bodinham Typeset by S R Nova Pvt Ltd, Bangalore, India Printed and bound in the UK by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
Contents 1. Protein nutrition and nitrogen balance in buffalo cows G. Campanile, G. Neglia, D. Vecchio, R. Di Palo, B. Gasparrini and L. Zicarelli
1
2. Expression QTL and their applications in genetic improvement of farm animals K. Wimmers, E. Murani and S. Ponsuksili
9
3. A brief history of mammalian coat colour genetics J. J. Lauvergne 4. Functional genomic approaches to understand the biological pathways underpinning intramuscular fat in beef L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney
17
23
5. Assessing impacts of organic production on pork and beef quality Albert Sundrum
35
6. Whole genome marker-assisted selection Joel I. Weller
49
7. Quantitative trait mutations in cattle, sheep and pigs: a review Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens, and Nadine Buys
59
8. Technical, epidemiological and financial implications of large-scale national vaccination campaigns to control HPAI H5N1 J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton 9. Accelerated lambing: Part 1. Housing for sheep G. L. Hunter 10. Accelerated lambing: Part 2. Increasing the frequency of pregnancy in sheep G. L. Hunter 11. Poultry sector development, highly pathogenic avian influenza and the smallholder production systems J. Rushton, R. E. Viscarra, N. Taylor, I. Hoffmann and K. Schwabenbauer 12. Fat and taste perception Philippe Besnard, Dany Gaillard, Patricia Passilly-Degrace, Ce´line Martin and Michael Chevrot 13. Microgoats in India and their role in future animal production in an era of climatic change Pramod Kumar Rout and M. C. Sharma
73 93 115
139 147
157
14. Assessing biosafety of GM plants containing lectins Morten Poulsen and Jan W. Pedersen
165
15. Ovine and caprine brucellosis (Brucella melitensis) Assadullah Samadi, M. M. K. Ababneh, N. D. Giadinis and S. Q. Lafi
171
16. Plants as reservoirs for human enteric pathogens Nicola J. Holden
185
17. Use of high-density marker genotyping for genetic improvement of livestock by genomic selection Jack C. M. Dekkers
197
18. Natural antimicrobials for food processing Ana Yndira Ramos-Villarroel, Robert Soliva-Fortuny and Olga Martı´n-Belloso
211
19. Palatability: principles, methodology and practice for farm animals J. Michael Forbes
229
20. Embryo cryopreservation in domestic mammalian livestock species C. R. Youngs, S. P. Leibo and R. A. Godke
245
21. Risk assessment of toxic contaminants in animal feed Alberto Mantovani and Chiara Frazzoli
257
Index
271
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Protein nutrition and nitrogen balance in buffalo cows G. Campanile*, G. Neglia, D. Vecchio, R. Di Palo, B. Gasparrini and L. Zicarelli Address: DISCIZIA, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, ‘Federico II’ University, V.F. Delpino 1, Naples 80137, Italy. *Correspondence: G. Campanile. Fax: +39-081-292981. Email:
[email protected] 21 September 2009 1 December 2009
Received: Accepted:
Abstract The buffalo species represents the mainstay of the rural economy of small farmers in many developing countries, and is also an important source of protein. Because of its area of origin, it shows some peculiar characteristics regarding protein requirements and nitrogen balance. Therefore, this review aims at clarifying some aspects of protein digestibility and, consequently, manure management in buffalo cows. Keywords: Buffalo, Protein, Nitrogen balance
Introduction Livestock products in tropical areas play a crucial role, which extends beyond their traditional supply of meat and milk. Unprecedented economic growth in developing countries, accompanied by the increases in income and purchasing power and by changes in food preferences, together with the growth of human population, has increased demands on the livestock sector. Livestock products, such as milk and meat, have undergone great modification in response to these recent developments [1]. The buffalo is considered a triple-purpose animal, providing milk, meat and draught, though milk is the main product, followed by meat. However, it is worth pointing out that the swamp type of buffalo is used for work in Southeast Asia and China, and it often represents the mainstay of the rural economy of small farmers in many developing countries, as well as becoming an important source of meat and milk. When buffaloes are compared with other animals, they are more adaptable and show many homeo-kinetic mechanisms to maintain critical body functions. This condition, which is obtained at the expense of changes in other physiological functions, allows them to represent an economic and valuable species in rush areas of tropical countries [2]. The water buffalo is a domestic species raised in many different parts of the world. Its importance for the wealth and welfare of the human population has been recognized
g
in recent years. About 97% of the total world buffalo population is located in South and Southeast Asia, and about half of this population is bred in India [3]. In India, river buffaloes are an important source of milk, representing about 35% of India’s milch animals and supplying around 70% of the total milk production [3]. The nutritive forage characteristics of equatorial and sub-equatorial zones could be limiting factors for milk yield in buffaloes bred in these areas. Tropical forage shows low levels of growth (less than 20% annual growth), low digestibility (because of a high concentration of ligneous fibre) and low crude protein (CP) concentration [4]. However, it is worth pointing out that buffalo breeding is usually preferred to that of dairy cattle in these zones, because of their superior quality of milk, better efficiency in utilization of nutrients from poorquality fibrous tropical feeds and relatively better disease resistance and adaptability to tropical climates [5]. The dry matter (DM) intake in buffaloes is reduced when the proportion of indigestible fibre increases [6, 7]. The forage protein content represents the main factor limiting productive capacity of buffalo cows. Low protein concentration in the feeds causes a considerable diminution of production and duration of lactation together with small variations in milk composition. This phenomenon is partially responsible for the low production (1713.83+576.26 litres), short lactation period and the chemical composition of buffalo milk in Brazil [8]. Consequently, protein nutrition in buffalo cows plays a
CAB International 2010
2
Animal Science Reviews 2010
fundamental role in milk yield and in reproductive activity. In the intensive breeding system, diets with higher protein content are always administered at start of lactation to promote milk yield and length of lactation. This condition could enhance nitrate pollution risk. Consequently, the optimization of protein requirements in intensive breeding favours the management of manure and risk of nitrate pollution. Hence, it is necessary to understand nitrogen metabolism to evaluate the nitrogen balance in buffaloes. The current review presents a summary of knowledge in nitrogen metabolism and nutrition in buffalo cows. The review also identifies gaps in knowledge on protein nutrition and digestibility that could be considered important for the milk production and management of manure in the intensive breeding system.
Urea Metabolism The urea nitrogen concentration in plasma and milk in cattle is influenced by the amount of CP in the diet [9–11], as well as by degradable intake protein (DIP) and undegradable intake protein (UIP). Moreover, it is clearly correlated with dietary protein supply relative to requirements [11]. Roseler et al. [12] also showed that urea concentrations in blood and milk are influenced by changes in DIP and UIP and by increasing energy intake. The relation between the protein fraction of the diet and the protein/energy (P/E) ratio in cattle has previously been described [13, 14]. Blood urea concentration decreased in lactating dairy cows when an optimal level of ruminally fermentable carbohydrate was supplied to enhance the capture of DIP into microbial protein [15]. Excess degradable protein, responsible for increases in blood and milk urea (MU) levels, is shown to be poorly used in the production of milk proteins. In fact, Baker et al. [11] noted an increase in ‘true’ proteins when the DIP and UIP were consistent with production requirements. Azotaemia is closely correlated with MU concentration [11–13, 16]. This parameter can be used, since it facilitates monitoring for sampling feeding adequacy. This analysis cannot replace conventional feed analysis, but can be utilized as a valuable complement to it [13]. The change in MU content in response to an altered dietary composition is very rapid in cattle [14]. In buffalo cows, as in dairy cows, MU is positively related to blood urea (BU) [17]. The relationship between MU and BU in buffalo cows [8] is expressed by the following equation, which is similar to the results found by other authors in cattle [10–12]: BU(mmol/l)=1:675+0:817 MU(mmol/l); R2 =0:769: In buffaloes at the start of lactation, urea levels in milk and blood are conditioned by CP intake and days in milk, while protein degradability does not influence either parameter [18]. The relationship is described in the
g
following equation: MU(mmol/l)=712:475+0:008 CP intake (g) +0:029 days in milk; R2 =0:587 As specified above, nitrogen levels in blood are affected by days in milk and diet. The trend of nitrogen levels in blood of buffaloes fed a diet of low protein content is similar to that of DM intake throughout lactation. Low nitrogen levels in blood are responsible for higher growth hormone (GH) secretion in dairy cattle. GH favours fat mobilization, inhibits insulin and increases nitrogen availability from tissues, in order to optimize the P/E ratio for production [19]. When higher protein concentrations are utilized in the diet, which in our opinion are more suitable to guarantee protein requirements, in particular, at the start of lactation, feeding is characterized by low DM intake, and in high-producing buffaloes, the lowering in nitrogen levels does not occur [20]. On the contrary, in middle lactation [17] MU and BU are conditioned by the P/E ratio: MU(mmol/l)=75:371+41:60 CP/NSC753:58 UIP/NSC; R2 =0:906 where NSC is the non-structural carbohydrate. Carruthers et al. [21] found that in cows at late lactation, the P/E ratio increased microbial protein synthesis. Urea levels in blood and milk increase as a function of days open because of the higher DM intake and hence CP, as usually observed in the buffalo cow [22]. In buffaloes in mid-lactation, the urea concentration in blood and milk reached a higher level when a low-protein diet was administered for a fairly long period. In this species, a decline in circulating urea occurred after a sharp reduction [17]. We suppose that an increase of insulin levels reduced or blocked the normal amino acid breakdown, and therefore reduced the urea levels in the blood. Smith [23] reports that in ruminants from tropical areas, nitrogen deficiency decreases kidney clearance, increases ruminal return and decreases haematic levels of urea. As a result, the urea recycling in the digestive tract and the ruminal bacteria protein synthesis are improved [24]. The lower P/E ratio in buffalo milk compared with the bovine milk allows buffaloes to use forage characterized by low protein content [4, 5]. This may explain the adaptation of this species in South American countries where forage is characterized by a low P/E ratio [4]. In any case, we must underline that buffaloes react to protein deficiencies better than dairy cattle [25]. The utilization of diets characterized by a larger P/E ratio in buffalo species causes fewer deleterious effects than reported in dairy cattle. This is probably the result of higher ammonia utilization by rumen microbes or to a higher urea synthesis in the liver, which would reduce the increase of blood ammonia. In fact, buffaloes utilize diet nitrogen better than cattle in carbohydrate deficiency
CAB International 2010
G. Campanile, G. Neglia, D. Vecchio, R. Di Palo, B. Gasparrini and L. Zicarelli
[26], because the ruminal environment of the former species is more favourable for the growth of microbes that utilize non-protein nitrogen. Singh and Gupta [27] observed a higher level of volatile fatty acids and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in the rumen of buffaloes that received a higher quantity of nitrogen through ammoniatreated straw. Hence, it is confirmed that urea levels in blood and milk are positively correlated to CP/(NSC) ratio in buffalo species. In fact, the higher energy availability allows better ammonia utilization by microbial fauna for protein synthesis, causing low urea production [28]. Ammonia blood level is negatively affected by rumendegradable protein (RDP) intake and, as found in dairy cows, it is not conditioned by BU [29]. The authors attributed this result to the fact that urea peaks 4–8 h after feeding [29]. Ammonia values in buffalo cows are higher than those reported by Elrod and Butler [30] in dairy cows and McEvoy et al. [31] in sheep, and lower compared with the results of Jordan et al. [32] and GarciaBojalil [33] in cattle. We can conclude that when protein requirements are satisfied in both buffalo and cow, urea blood levels in buffalo are higher than those of dairy cattle, whose physiological values (28–32 mg) cannot be considered as a suitable reference. This has been confirmed by the evidence that between October and February, buffaloes bred in Egypt, India and Iran receive a high quantity of Trifolium alexandrinum L., which is characterized by higher CP on DM than alfalfa (lucerne, >25%), without suffering any health problem such as alkalosis or laminitis.
Protein Requirements As mentioned above, protein requirements in buffalo species are lower than those reported for dairy cows if the same energy is produced by milk [4]. In a trial carried out on buffaloes fed with six different P/E ratio diets, Kurar and Mudgal [34] reported a maintenance requirement of digestible CP (DCP) of 3.2 g/kg W0.75/day and 166.34 g DCP/100 g of milk-produced proteins. Analogous values were previously observed in Indian Murrah buffaloes [35]. The results obtained in a study carried out to evaluate the effects of the P/E ratio on milk characteristics and on blood and MU levels showed 2.53 g of CP/kg W0.75 and 2.7 g of CP/g of protein produced with milk [17]. According to Rai and Aggarwal [36], a diet with a protein concentration of 11–14% should be administered to buffaloes during lactation. It has been noticed that the protein concentration used in Mediterranean buffaloes could be lower than 12% [37, 38]. The protein concentration depends on the genetic merit of the buffaloes and on the number of days in milk. As mentioned above, this changes throughout the year because of the concentration of calving both in seasonal herds and in the out-of-seasonal ones. Protein
g
3
concentrations 9% lower blood and MU levels and increase the milk freezing point, especially if combined to a high level of fermentable energy [17]. Therefore, it is important to evaluate the P/E ratio, to obtain a balanced diet. In buffaloes, this ratio may be higher, as the administration of high protein concentrations has less deleterious effects than in dairy cows. In our studies, we noticed that an increase of the protein concentration (up to 15% DM) at the beginning of lactation stimulates the productive activity of the buffaloes, without affecting the increase of fat mobilization. Nonesterified fatty acid (NEFA) values were lower than those registered in animals that ingested DM with lower CP levels. It is known that in cattle a higher protein concentration increases milk yield because the increase of absorbable proteins quickens fat mobilization [39, 40]. Post-ruminal casein infusion determines an increase of the palmitate percentage [41]. It seems that high protein concentrations stimulate GH [42, 43], which is responsible for the decreased response of the adipose tissue to insulin and for a greater sensitivity to the adrenergic stimulus at the end of gestation and at the beginning of lactation. These stimuli might be mediated by gastroenteric hormones that can modulate the sympathetic nervous system activity [44]. Confirming this hypothesis, Cado´rniga and Lopez Diaz [45] noticed a greater fat mobilization in cattle that showed a higher Body Condition Score (BCS) and fed with diets containing a higher dose of rumen undegradable proteins (RUP); they also reported that their adipose tissues were more sensitive to epinephrine administrations. As mentioned above, dietary proteins and their digestibility in the rumen affect BU and MU concentration [9–11]. Overfeeding proteins has been associated, in sheep and cattle, with a decline in fertility in most [30–46], but not all [47] studies. Jordan et al. [32] found an increase in urea-N concentration in uterine secretions and plasma of cows fed 23% CP. Elrod and Butler [30] showed that an excess of either digestible (RDP) or indigestible (RUP) protein in the rumen increases BU and alters uterine pH to a similar degree, interfering with the normal inductive effects of progesterone on the microenvironment of the uterus, thereby providing sub-optimal conditions to support embryo development. Moreover, the elevation of ureic nitrogen in the local (reproductive) or systemic apparatus reduces the ovarian receptors’ luteinizing hormone (LH) linkage and, therefore, it would be responsible for the lower production of progesterone in the post-ovulation days and for the lower conception rate. It is known that this ovarian steroid is fundamental for embryo progression in the uterine tube, for the production of uterine milk that represents the only nourishment of the embryo before implantation and, finally, for pregnancy maintenance. A reduced hypophisary activity, characterized by a lower progesterone secretion in the first phases of gestation, causes early embryo mortality. It seems that the unfavourable action of ammonia on reproductive activity is insulin mediated [48] through
CAB International 2010
4
Animal Science Reviews 2010
its known effects at the hypothalamic level. It has been hypothesized that ammonia acts on the central nervous system through the increase of glutamate and depletion of a-ketoglutarate, interrupting ATP synthesis [48]. A diet with 50% protein content higher than required led, in Mediterranean buffaloes, to an increase of heat phase followed by an appropriate luteinic phase and a prolongation of the inter-oestrus interval [49]. In this species, anoestrous is favoured by lack of CP and energy [50]. Analogous results have been noticed in beef cattle with a lack of energy and protein [51]. Protein and/or energetic underfeeding determines a decrease of ruminal microbial activity and, therefore, of the whole volatile fatty acid content. The organism responds through an increase in GH and a decrease in insulin, allowing the mobilization of the muscular proteins used for glucose synthesis and, therefore, for glycaemic homeostasis. Even in this case, the reduction of insulin activity could interfere with buffalo reproductive activity. Protein digestibility in the rumen does not influence reproductive activity in buffalo cows [18]. In a trial carried out on Italian Mediterranean buffalo cows [18], the urea values measured in vaginal mucus were similar [32] or higher than those reported, respectively, in dairy cow [52] and sheep [31]. By contrast, the ammonia levels in vaginal mucus were considerably lower than those found by Rumello et al. [52] in dairy cow and by McEvoy et al. [31] in sheep. High levels of ammonia in the uterus affect fertility in dairy cows because of the detrimental effect on embryo development [31]. It is possible that in buffalo, independently of the BU, a lower diffusion of ammonia occurs in the uterus, reducing the detrimental effect on reproductive efficiency. It is widely reported that the negative effect of a protein surplus on fertility, in cattle, may be the result of the RDP intake [29–31, 32]. The negative effect of RDP excess is not observed in buffalo cows [18] since this species uses nitrogen better than cattle, including when in NSC deficiency [26]. Energy deficiency decreases the ability of the liver to transform ammonia into urea. This results in an increase in blood ammonia levels and, by diffusion, levels of vaginal mucus ammonia. In addition, Schepers and Meijer [53] found a relationship between diet energy and MU. The high values of fertility registered in buffaloes fed with a high CP levels show that urea levels in the blood and in vaginal mucus do not have a negative effect on reproductive performance [18] in natural mating. This may well reflect the tropical (north of the Equator) origin of buffalo, which modifies diet protein use according to season and feed availability. Indeed, in tropical regions, forage availability occurs only for a few months.
Nitrogen Balance The knowledge of nitrogen balance in buffalo species is fundamental in order to optimize the production and to
g
Table 1 Growth rate (g/d) and feed efficiency of growing Bhadawari calves fed on different energy diets [54] modified by Campanile et al. (unpublished data) Parameters Nitrogen balance Intake Faecal-N Digestible-N Urinary-N N balance % N absorption Growth Initial weight (kg) Final weight (kg) Growth rate (g/d) Growth rate for 1 gram of N1 Feed efficiency Feed conversion ratio CP conversion ratio
EL
EL1
EL2
SEM
41.4 18.5 22.9 8.4 14.4 34.8
38.2 16.9 21.2 10.9 10.3 27.0
39.2 17.8 21.4 6.0 15.4 39.2
2.71 1.52 1.47 0.83 1.16 2.14
75.9 143.7 368.5ab 25.5
74.9 129.8 298.4a 28.9
77.5 146.3 374.3b 24.3
7.62 12.9 – –
7.76 0.70
8.49 0.80
7.25 0.66
0.37 0.04
1
Growth rate (g/d): N balance. Superscripts within a row differ significantly (P < 0.05); SEM, standard error of means.
a,b
perform adequate manure management. Few trials have been carried out in buffalo species compared with bovine. Some Indian authors [54] evaluated the nitrogen balance in female buffalo calves to be a mean between 76 and 140 kg of live body weight with three iso-nitrogenous concentrate mixtures (CM) of different energy density (CM1: 2.56, CM2: 2.20 and CM3: 3.04 M cal) to meet their energy and protein requirements in EL [55], EL1 (20% less metabolizable energy (ME) than EL) and EL2 (20% more ME than EL). Independently of the dietary energy levels, the animals intake a mean of 39.6 g/day of nitrogen and excreted 17.7 g/day as faeces and 8.4 g/die as urine (Table 1). Hence, all the groups were in positive N balance, although the urinary-N loss was higher in EL2 (10.9 g/day) than in other groups (Table 1). The authors concluded that the efficiency of protein utilization in buffaloes is reduced when the diet is characterized by low energy concentration [54]. However, if the data are analysed taking into account both the daily weight gain and N availability, it is clear that 1 g of retained N allows the growth of 25.5, 28.9 and 24.3 g for EL, EL1 and EL2, respectively. Hence, when high amounts of N are available, the efficiency of utilization is lower. In fact, in a recent trial performed on growing male Thai buffaloes [56], 1-year-old male calves were fed ad libitum with four diets, using four combinations of pineapple waste silage (P) and concentrate (C), in the proportions (on a DM basis) of 0.8 : 0.2 (P80:C20), 0.6 : 0.4 (P60:C40), 0.4 : 0.6 (P40:C60) and 0.2 : 0.8 (P20:C80). Also in this trial, all the groups were in positive N balance, although it has been observed that an increase in concentrate caused a significant increase in N intake, N balance, microbial nitrogen [57] and urea-N in the
CAB International 2010
G. Campanile, G. Neglia, D. Vecchio, R. Di Palo, B. Gasparrini and L. Zicarelli
5
Table 2 Nitrogen (N) balance in adult buffalo and in growing buffalo (culling rate)
Live weight1 Days True days2 DM intake Milk yield per lactation Milk yield per year CP intake3 Retained CP Retained N Excreted CP Excreted N Volatilization nitrogen loss (28%) Stocked nitrogen
Milking period (kg)
Dry period (kg)
Buffaloes (kg)
670 270 224 3266 2200 1237 441 70 11.2 371 59 16.61 42.7
670 95 141 1269
670 365 365 4535
102 12 1.92 90 14 3.92 10
1237 543 82 13 461 73 21 53
Culling rate (kg) 300 365 2409 289 12 1.9 277 44 12.32 31.9
1
Live weight was calculated in adult buffalo considering a 20% incidence of animals at the first lactation and in growing buffaloes the incidence of different categories. 2 True days were calculated by consideration of incidence of milking and dry period. 3 It has been calculated considering the diets utilized in different physiological phases.
urine [58]. The last-named finding is probably the result of an inefficient utilization of protein in the rumen for energy and nitrogen excess, since in these conditions proteins break down into amino acids and undergo a deamination process, leading to urea formation that is excreted in the urine [59]. Furthermore, it is known that in diet characterized by nitrogen deficiencies, the buffalo reduces the kidney clearance and improves the rumen nitrogen utilization [17]. In any case, the proportion P40:C60 produced the best efficiency of urinary purine derivatives (PD) excretion (mmol) per kg of digestible organic matter intake [56]. The study of PD excretion rate has been used as an index to predict rumen microbial protein production in various ruminants. In fact, urinary allantoin and uric acid excretion rates reflect the magnitude of microbial protein flow into the small intestine. Liang et al. [60] reported that PD excretion rates for buffaloes were 44–57% lower than for zebu cattle under similar feeding conditions. In a more recent trial [61], four male swamp buffaloes with an initial body weight of 244+19.8 kg were used to study the recovery rate of urinary PD after they were duodenally infused with incremental amounts of purine bases (PB). Similarly to cattle, in which values of 80–89% of total PD have been reported [60–62], the main PD was allantoin (84% of total PD), followed by uric acid and they were linearly correlated with PB input, whereas no relationships were found for other PD. Negligible amounts of hypoxanthine and xanthine were recorded in this study, confirming the high activity of xanthine oxidase in tissue of liver, intestinal mucosa and blood of buffaloes [63]. The relationship between daily urinary PD (i.e. allantoin, uric acid) excretion (mmol) and duodenal PB infused (mmol per day) suggested that only 12% of supplied exogenous PB were excreted in the urine [61]. These results were in agreement with those previously reported in Murrah [63]
g
and Swamp [60] buffaloes. Furthermore, these studies were recently confirmed by another trial [64] performed concurrently in adult Mediterranean dry buffaloes and adult dry Friesian cows. Also these authors reported a total PD urinary excretion of 11% compared with cattle (2.711 versus 23.707 mmol/l/day in buffalo and bovine, respectively). Interestingly, a higher urine amount was reported in buffalo compared with cattle during the experimental period (10.84 versus 8.54 l/day in buffalo and cattle, respectively). The low urinary PD excretion rate recorded in buffalo species is not easily explainable. Thanh and Ørskov [65] demonstrated that differences between buffalo and bovine arise only after rumen development, since no significant variations in purine excretion were observed during weaning. However, when the study was performed on the same animals after weaning, buffaloes excreted around 38% of the total PD excreted by cattle [65]. Cutrignelli et al. [64] investigated the presence of allantoic acid, the final product of purine degradation in several fish species, in the urine of buffalo, but it was not detected. The same authors also evaluated differences in the saliva content of PD, but the concentration was similar in both cattle and buffalo [66]. Other authors [60–63] suggested that this could be the result of higher recycling of plasma PD than in cattle. However, when the renal and non-renal losses of plasma PD in bovines and buffaloes were investigated by examining [8-14C] uric acid as tracer [67], PD lost via non-renal routes, as a measure of recycling, for buffaloes did not differ from that of cattle, although the recovery rate of plasma tracer PD for buffaloes was much higher than 12%. Another hypothesis considers the glomerular filtration rate [65]. It was proposed that it was lower in buffaloes than in cattle, leaving more time in the blood for recycling to the rumen and metabolizing by bacteria the PD. This speculation is supported by a previous study
CAB International 2010
6
Animal Science Reviews 2010
[68], in which the glomerular filtration rate was lower in buffalo than in bovine, but it is in contrast with other research [61] that demonstrated a higher glomerular filtration rate in buffalo. Other hypotheses concern a higher permeability from the blood to the rumen in buffaloes than cattle [65] or a lower absorption rate at the small intestine [61]. In any case, further studies are needed to clarify this aspect. The knowledge of nitrogen balance is also fundamental in order to optimize manure management. Manure composition noticeably changes as a result of several factors, such as alimentation, management, manure storage and dilution with water, either rainwater or water for washing the milking room. Nitrogen balance in buffaloes has been considered similar to bovine and hence total nitrogen produced by an adult animal of 550 kg live weight is around 85 kg/year, taking into account the losses during the storage period. However, taking into account the productive characteristics, the duration of lactation and the dry period, this value cannot be utilized for an adult buffalo. In fact, in this species, nitrogen intake is lower than that reported for the dairy cow, because of the lower DM intake and the lower protein concentration of the diet [17–69]. If the nitrogen balance is calculated in buffalo species (Table 2), the mean quantity of nitrogen eliminated for a year for an adult buffalo and successively stocked is around 53 kg/year. This value is obtained by calculating the mean DM intake and its characteristics in terms of ingested and retained nitrogen in a buffalo that produces milk for 270 days and is in the dry period for 95 days. Furthermore, the value has been corrected considering the mean fertility of a buffalo herd (which is around 75%), which affects the length of lactation and consequently the quantities of ingested and retained nitrogen. These calculations are supported by some recent research carried out on buffalo manure, which demonstrates that nitrogen concentration is lower than that reported in bovine [70]. Furthermore, in some trials performed in buffaloes characterized by different days of lactation it has been observed that the buffalo excretes around 60% of nitrogen excreted by a bovine (Campanile et al., unpublished data). Growing buffaloes (culling rate) excrete on an average 32 kg of nitrogen throughout the year (Table 1). The incidence of growing subjects on the total number of animals present in the farm has to be considered, in order to determine the correct nitrogen balance. In fact, growing animals are around 50% of the total number of animals present in the farm and, hence, they weigh upon the nitrogen balance of the farm in this percentage. In conclusion, nitrogen excretion for buffalo bred in a farm is around 44.3 kg/year. Therefore, the manure characteristics deriving from a buffalo farm would need to be revaluated in order to manage an optimal nitrogen supplementation to the agronomic cultivation performed in the breeding zones of buffalo species.
g
Conclusions The peculiar productive characteristics of buffalo species, together with its low lactiferous habit and the length of the dry period, reduce nitrogen intake throughout the productive life. The satisfying of protein requirements depends on the tropical origin of these animals and the breeding management. In this review, the adaptation and the metabolic response of this species to diets characterized by different protein content have been demonstrated. Furthermore, the basis for the application of a new nitrogen balance calculation in buffalo species has been noted and it has been demonstrated that it is very different from that reported in bovine. The application of the value estimated for dairy cattle to buffalo would negatively affect buffalo breeders for both manure management and utilization for agronomic purposes.
References 1. Cruz LC. Trends in buffalo production in Asia. Italian Journal of Animal Science 2007;6(Suppl. 2):9–24. 2. Vale WG. Effects of environment on buffalo reproduction. Italian Journal of Animal Science 2007;6(Suppl. 2):130–42. 3. Zicarelli L. Buffalo milk production world-wide. In: Proceedings of the VI World Buffalo Congress, 20–23 May 2001, Maracaibo, Zulia, Venezuela, Volume I: 2001. p. 202–30. 4. Zicarelli L. Management under different environmental condition. Buffalo Journal 1994;2:17–38. 5. Paul SS, Mandal AB, Mandal GP, Kannan A, Pathak NN. Comparative dry matter intake and nutrient utilization efficiency in lactating cattle and buffaloes. Journal of Science Food and Agriculture 2003;83:258–67. 6. Campanile G, Di Palo R, De Filippo C, Zicarelli L. Tempi di ingestione e di ruminazione nella bufala in funzione della distanza dal parto. In: Proceedings XII Congresso Nazionale ASPA, 23–26 June 1997, Pisa, Italy; 1997. p. 211–12. 7. Campanile G, Di Palo R, De Filippo C, Zicarelli L. Dietary characteristics and feeding behaviour in buffalo cows. In: Proceeding of the 5th World Buffalo Congress, 6–10 October 1997, Caserta, Italy. Bubalus Bubalis S.r.l., Italy; 1997. p. 367–71. 8. Tonhati H, Lima ALF, Duarte JMC, Munoz MFC. Factors affecting milk yield and milk constituents in Brazilian buffaloes. Buffalo Newsletter 2004;20:15. 9. Carlsson J, Pehrson B. The influence of the dietary balance between energy and protein on milk urea concentration. Experimental trials assessed by two different protein evaluation systems. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica 1994;35:193–205. 10. Gonda HL, Lindberg JE. Evaluation of dietary nitrogen utilization in dairy cows based on urea concentrations in blood, urine and milk, and on urinary concentration of purine derivatives. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica Section A, Animal Science 1994;44:236–45. 11. Baker LD, Ferguson JD, Chalupa W. Responses in urea and true protein of milk to different protein feeding schemes for dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 1995;78:2424–34.
CAB International 2010
G. Campanile, G. Neglia, D. Vecchio, R. Di Palo, B. Gasparrini and L. Zicarelli 12. Roseler DK, Ferguson JD, Sniffen CJ, Herrema J. Dietary protein degradability effect on plasma and milk urea nitrogen and milk non-protein nitrogen in Holstein cows. Journal of Dairy Science 1993;76:525–34. 13. Oltner R, Wiktorsson H. Urea concentrations in milk and blood as influenced by feeding various amounts of protein and energy to dairy cows. Livestock Production Science 1983;10:457–67. 14. Oltner R, Emanuelson M, Wiktorsson H. Urea concentrations in milk in relation to milk yield, live weight, lactation number and amount and composition of feed given to dairy cows. Livestock Production Science 1985;12:47–57. 15. Hoover WH, Miller TK. Carbohydrate and protein consideration in ration formulation. In: Proceedings: Large Dairy Herd Manage Conference, Cornell Cooperative Extension, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY; 1990. p. 71.
7
(Bos indicus) on a feeding regimen deficient in carbohydrates. Indian Journal of Veterinary Science 1969;38:333–6. 27. Singh SP, Gupta BN. Effect of ammonia treatment of wheat straw on fibre digestion and volatile fatty acids production rates in the rumen of male Murrah buffaloes. Indian Journal of Animal Nutrition 1984;1:27–30. 28. Journet M, Verite R, Vignon B. L’azote non prote´ique du lait: facteurs de variation. Le Lait 1975;543–544:212–21. 29. Butler WR. Effect of protein nutrition on ovarian and uterine physiology in dairy cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 1998;81:2533–9. 30. Elrod CC, Butler WR. Reduction of fertility and alteration of uterine pH in heifers fed excess ruminally degradable protein. Journal of Animal Science 1993;71:694–701.
16. Gustafsson AH, Palmquist DL. Diurnal variation of rumen ammonia, serum urea, and milk urea in dairy cows at high and low yields. Journal of Dairy Science 1993;76:475–84.
31. McEvoy TG, Robinson JJ, Atken RP, Findlay PA, Robertson IS. Dietary excesses of urea influence the viability and metabolism of preimplantation sheep embryos and may affect foetal growth among survivors. Animal Reproduction Science 1997;47:71–90.
17. Campanile G, De Filippo C, Di Palo R, Taccone W, Zicarelli L. Influence of dietary protein on urea levels in blood and milk of buffalo cows. Livestock Production Science 1998;55:135–43.
32. Jordan ER, Chapman TE, Holtan DW, Swanson LV. Relationship of dietary crude protein to composition of uterine secretions and blood in high-producing postpartum dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 1983;66:1854–62.
18. Campanile G, Di Palo R, Infascelli F, Gasparrini B, Neglia G, Zicarelli F, et al. Influence of rumen protein degradability on productive and reproductive performance in buffalo cows. Reproduction, Nutrition, Development 2004;43:557–66.
33. Garcia-Bojalil CM, Staples CR, Thatcher WW, Drost M. Protein intake and development of ovarian follicles and embryos of superovulated non-lactating dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 1994;77:2537–48.
19. Ndibualonji BB, Dehareng D, Godeau JM. La sousalimentation e´nerge´tique et/ou azote´e chez la vache tarie. Effect sur les acides gras volatils du rumen, quelques me´tabolites et hormones du plasma et l’excre´tion urinaire de la 3-methylhistidine. Reproduction, Nutrition, Development 1995;35:137–54.
34. Kurar CK, Mudgal VD. Protein requirement of Murrah buffaloes in the early stage of lactation. Indian Journal of Dairy Science 1980;33:443–50.
20. Campanile G. Relationship between nutrition and reproduction in buffalo. In: Proceedings of the Third Course on Biotechnology of Reproduction in Buffaloes, 6–10 October 1997, Caserta, Italy. Bubalus bubalis S.rl, Italy; 1997. p. 217–35. 21. Carruthers VR, Neil PG, Dalley DE. Effect of altering the non-structural carbohydrate ratio in a pasture diet on milk production and ruminal metabolites in cows in early and late lactation. Animal Science 1997;64:393–402.
35. Sivaiah K, Mudgal VD. Protein requirement for maintenance and milk production in buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) in first lactation. Indian Journal of Animal Science 1985;53:236–42. 36. Rai SN, Aggarwal SK. Effect of substitution of green fodder with ammoniated straw on nutrient utilization and milk production in Murrah buffaloes. Buffalo Journal 1991;1:51–61. 37. Verna M, Bartocci S, Amici A, Agostini M. Effect of diets with different energetic concentration on the qualitative and quantitative yield in lactating buffaloes. In: Proceeding of the International Symposium on Prospect of Buffalo Production in the Mediterranean/Middle East, 9–12 November 1992, Cairo, Egypt; 1992. p. 258–61.
22. Campanile G, Di Palo R, Esposito L, Boni R, Di Meo C. Variazioni di alcune costanti ematiche in bufale in lattazione. In: Proceedings XI Congresso Nazionale ASPA, 19–22 June 1995, Grado (GO), Italy; 1995. p. 77–8.
38. Verna M, Bartocci S, Amici A, Agostini M. Effetto di diete diverse sulle prestazioni produttive di bufale in lattazione. Agricoltura e Ricerca 1994;153:73–8.
23. Smith RH. Reviews of the progress of dairy science. Dairy Research 1969;36:313–31.
39. Ørskov ER, Grubb DA, Kay RNB. Effect of postruminal glucose or protein supplementation on milk yield and composition on Friesian cows in early lactation and negative energy balance. British Journal of Nutrition 1977;38:397–405.
24. Houpt R. Transfer of urea and ammonia to the rumen. In: Phillipson AT, editor. Physiology of Digestion and Metabolism in the Ruminant. Oriel Press Limited, Royaume-Uni, New Castle Upon Tyne; 1970. p. 119–31. 25. Bertoni G, Amici A, Lombardelli R, Bartocci S. Variations of metabolic profile and hormones in blood of buffaloes, cattle and sheep males fed the same diets. In: Proceeding of the International Symposium on Prospect of Buffalo Production in the Mediterranean/Middle East, 9–12 November 1992, Cairo, Egypt; 1993. p. 345–8. 26. Langer PN, Sidhu GS, Bhatia JS. A study of the microbial population in the rumen of buffalo (Bos bubalus) and zebu
g
40. Rulquin H. Effect sur la degestion et le metabolisme des vaches laitie`res d’infusions d’acides grass volatils dans le rumen et de caseinate dans le duode´num. II. Production et digestion. Reproduction, Nutrition, Development 1982;22: 905–21. 41. Ko¨nig BA, Oldham JD, Parker DS. The effect of abomasal infusion of casein of acetate, palmitate, and glucice kinetics in cows during early lactation. British Journal of Nutrition 1984;52:319–28. 42. Oldham JD, Hart IC, Bines JA. Effect of abomasal of casein, arginine, methionine or phenylalanina on growth hormone,
CAB International 2010
8
Animal Science Reviews 2010 insulin, prolactin, tyroxine and some metabolites in blood from lactating goats. The Proceedings of the Nutrition Society 1978;37:9.
43. Oldham JD, Hart IC, Bines JA. Formaldehyde-treated proteins for dairy cows. Effects on blood hormone concentration. British Journal of Nutrition 1982;48:543–7. 44. Choung J, Chamberlain DG. Protein nutrition of dairy cows receiving grass silage diets. The effects of postruminal supplements of proteins and aminoacids. Journal of Science, Food and Agriculture 1992;60:25–30. 45. Cado´rniga C, Lopez Diaz MC. Possible modulation of adipose tissue responsiveness to catecholamines by available dietary protein in dairy cows during early lactation. Reproduction, Nutrition, Development 1995;35:241–8. 46. Kaim M, Folman J, Neumark H, Kaufmann W. The effect of protein intake and lactation number on postpartum bodyweight loss and reproductive performance of dairy cows. Animal Production 1983;37:229–35. 47. Howard HJ, Aalseth AP, Adams GD, Bush LG, McNew RW, Dawson LJ. Influence of dietary protein on reproductive performance of dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 1987;70:1563–71.
57. Kozloski GV, Bonnecarrere LM, Cadorin Jr RL, Reffatti MV, Perez Neto D, Limal LD. Intake and digestion by lambs of dwarf elephant grass (Pennisetum purpureum Schm. cv. Mott) hay or hay supplemented with urea and different levels of cracked corn grain. Animal Feed Science and Technology 2006;125:111–22. 58. Kaur R, Nandra KS, Garcia SC, Fulkerson WJ, Horadagoda A. Efficiency of utilization of different diets with contrasting forages and concentrate when fed to sheep in a discontinuous feeding pattern. Livestock Science 2008;119:77–86. 59. Nolan JV. Nitrogen Kinetics. In: Forbes FM, France F, editors. Quantitative Aspects of Ruminant Digestion and Metabolism. CAB International, Wallingford, UK; 1993. p. 123–43. 60. Liang JB, Matsumoto M, Young BA. Purine derivative excretion and ruminal microbial yield in Malaysian cattle and swamp buffalo. Animal Feed Science and Technology 1994;47:189–99. 61. Pimpa O, Liang JB, Balcells J, Jelan ZA, Abdullah N. Urinary purine derivative excretion in Swamp buffaloes after duodenal purine base infusion. Animal Feed Science and Technology 2003;104:191–9.
48. Visek WJ. Ammonia: its effect on biological system, metabolic hormone, and reproduction. Journal of Dairy Science 1984;67:481–98.
62. Verbic J, Chen XB, MacLeod NA, Ørskov ER. Excretion of purine derivatives by ruminants: effect of microbial nucleic acid infusion on purine derivative excretion by steers. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 1990;114:243–8.
49. Campanile G, Di Palo R, Esposito L, Boni R, Zicarelli L. Influenza dei fabbisogni produttivi e del clima su alcune caratteristiche dell’estro nella bufala. In: Proceedings IX Congress Nazional ASPA, 3–7 June 1991, Rome, Italy; 1991. p. 180–200.
63. Chen XB, Samaraweera L, Kyle DJ, Ørskov ER. Urinary excretion of purine derivatives and tissue xanthine oxidase (EC 1.2.3.2) activity in buffaloes (Bubalis bubalis) with special reference to difference between buffaloes and Bos taurus cattle. British Journal of Nutrition 1996;75:397–407.
50. Salama AA, Ali HM, Shokry MM. The effect of feeding different energy levels on the reproductive performance of buffalo. In: Proceedings of the 2nd World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production, 4–8 October 1982, Madrid, Spain; 1982. p. 410–3.
64. Cutrignelli MI, Piccolo G, D’Urso S, Calabro` S, Bovera F, Tudisco R, et al. Urinary excretion of purine derivatives in dry buffalo and Friesian cows. Italian Journal of Animal Science 2007;6(Suppl. 2 – Part 1):563–6.
51. Randel RD. Nutrition and post-partum re-breeding in cattle. Journal of Animal Science 1990;68:853–62. 52. Rumello G, Bergero D, Tarantola M, Mimosi A, Ladetto G. Nutrizione azotata e metaboliti derivati nel latte e nel muco cervicale della bovina lattifera. Large Animal Review 1999;5:27–30. 53. Schepers AJ, Meijer RGM. Evaluation of the utilization of dietary nitrogen by dairy cows based on urea concentration in milk. Journal of Dairy Science 1996;81:579–84. 54. Singh S, Kundu SS, Kushwaha BP, Maity SB. Dietary energy levels response on nutrient utilization, nitrogen balance and growth in Bhadawari buffalo calves. Livestock Research for Rural Development 2009;21:http://www.lrrd.org/lrrd21/8/ bhad21125.htm. 55. NRC. Nutrients Requirements of Dairy Cattle. 7th ed. National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC; 2001. 56. Jetana T, Suthikrai W, Usawang S, Vongpipatana C, Sophon S, Liang JB. The effects of concentrate added to pineapple (Ananas comosus Linn. Mer.) waste silage in differing ratios to form complete diets, on digestion, excretion of urinary purine derivatives and blood metabolites in growing, male, Thai swamp buffaloes. Tropical Animal Health and Production 2009;41:449–59.
g
65. Thanh VTK, Ørskov ER. Causes of differences in urinary excretion of purine derivatives in buffaloes and cattle. Animal Science 2006;82:355–8. 66. Cutrignelli MI. Escrezione di derivati purinici nella bufala [PhD Thesis]. Federico II University, Naples, Italy; 1997. 67. Pimpa O, Liang JB, Balcells J, Jelan ZA, Abdullah N. Recovery rate of plasma purine derivatives in the urine of swamp buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) with special references to differences with zebu cattle. In: Proceedings of the Second Symposium on Sustainable Utilization of Agricultural Byproducts for Animal Production, 26–27 July 2001, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand; 2001. p. 112–5. 68. Norton BW, Moran JB, Nolan JV. Nitrogen metabolism in Brahman cross, buffaloes, Benteng and Shorthorn steers fed on low quality roughages. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 1979;30:341–51. 69. Campanile G. Nutrition and milk production in dairy buffalo. In: Proceedings of the III Simposio bu`falos de las Ame´ricas and 2nd Buffalo Symposium of the Europe and Americas, 6–8 September 2006, Medelli`n, Columbia; 2006. p. 132–41. 70. St-Pierre NR, Thraen CS. Animal grouping strategies, sources of variation, and economic factors affecting nutrient balance on dairy farms. Journal of Animal Science 1999;77(Suppl 2):72–83.
CAB International 2010
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Expression QTL and their applications in genetic improvement of farm animals K. Wimmers*, E. Murani and S. Ponsuksili Address: Research Institute for the Biology of Farm Animals (FBN Dummerstorf), Wilhelm-Stahl-Allee 2, 18196 Dummerstorf, Germany. *Correspondence: K. Wimmers. Email:
[email protected] Received: Accepted:
24 May 2009 6 November 2009
Abstract The integration of approaches based on genetic linkage maps and those based on function-driven holistic expression profiling, termed ‘genetical genomics’, has great potential for elucidating the expression and inheritance of complex traits. This review discusses the status and potential applications of ‘genetical genomics’ and how genomic/genetic, transcriptomic and phenotypic information can be used to promote the identification of functional positional candidate genes for traits important in farm animal breeding schemes. Linkage and/or genome-wide association analyses for traits that are relevant in animal breeding provide information about the positional candidacy of a particular gene. Analysing the relationship of the expression levels of genes and these traits adds information about the functional role of a gene and gives insight into functional pathways involved in the conversion of the traits. Mapping of expression quantitative trait loci (eQTL) enables the display of regulatory networks and localization of genomic variations affecting the mRNA expression of a gene either within the genes itself (cis) or distant from the gene (trans). The key advantage of eQTL mapping is that it connects variation at the level of RNA expression to variation at the level of DNA. Only the latter provides versatile tools for breeding, whereas the first reveals information on the biology of a trait and directs research to new candidate genes. Keywords: QTL, Linkage, Gene expression, Microarray, Genetical genomics Review Methodology: We searched the following databases: ISI Web of Knowledge, PubMed and Google Scholar (keyword search terms used: ‘genetical genomics’, ‘eQTL’). In addition, we used the references from the articles obtained by this method to check for additional relevant material.
Prerequisites and Rationale of ‘Genetical Genomics’ Researchers have used different strategies to detect genes controlling quantitative traits, quantitative trait loci (QTL); typically complex phenotypic characteristics (classical traits) are considered that vary in degree and can be attributed to effects of many genes (subsequently termed pheneQTL=pQTL). The most general approach to the identification of genes controlling the ‘final phenotype’ is the positional mapping by which the inheritance of a trait is compared with that of a large number of markers to locate the region(s) in which the gene(s) responsible for the trait lie. QTL analyses are in general hypothesis-free
g
approaches that allow researchers to address any variable heritable trait without knowledge of the physiology of that trait. Most of the successful approaches used to detect pQTL in pigs and chicken were based on genome scans performed in experimental F2 or backcross populations of divergent breeds, whereas in cattle mostly advantage was taken of the population structure by using existing paternal and grandpaternal pedigrees mainly within breeds. The first pQTL detected in livestock by this approach were reported by Andersson and colleagues in 1994 [1]. Subsequently, linkage studies identified pQTL regions for various traits in livestock; the actual status of pQTL mapping in pig, cattle and chicken can be reviewed at public accessible internet databases (AnimalQTLdb;
CAB International 2009
10
Animal Science Reviews 2010
http://www.animalgenome.org/QTLdb/) [2]. QTL regions are generally large and contain many putative causal genes. Thus, pQTL analyses fail to identify anything more than large genomic segments. Subsequent experiments including fine mapping and positional cloning have to be conducted. In fact, so far the underlying polymorphisms (quantitative trait nucleotides, QTNs) were identified by positional cloning and verified in livestock species for only a few pQTL: the Protein Kinase, AMP-activated, gamma 3 non-catalytic subunit (PRKAG3) locus and the Insulin-like growth factor 2 (IGF2) gene in swine [3–6], the DGAT1 (diacylglycerol O-acyltransferase homolog 1) gene in cattle [7] and the MSTN (myostatin; GDF-8, growth/ differentiation factor-8) (myostatin) gene in sheep [8]. That means that even after the successful identification of genomic regions containing the pQTL that are responsible for the variation of final phenotypes, high monetary and time expenditure are still necessary. The novel and powerful gene expression profiling techniques have brought a new level of hope to unravelling the secrets of complex classical traits with a polygenic inheritance. The introduction of microarray technology enabled expression profiling of thousands of genes simultaneously [9]. Functional genomics approaches can be used to generate information about gene function, as well as data on genetic interactions, not only among and between gene complexes but also in response to environmental stimuli. In order to successfully apply holistic expression profiling, an educated guess of the physiology of a trait is required in order to select the relevant tissues/cells at relevant developmental stages for the analysis. The outcome of bioinformatic analyses of microarray experiments are functional networks of genes reflecting interactions at the level of DNA, RNA or proteins. The results enable the derivation of new hypotheses on the nature of a trait. In livestock, expression microarrays were used regarding development and reproduction traits, growth, immune response and host–pathogen interaction [10–17]. One of the major challenges and opportunities is the combination of genetic linkage data of DNA and information of the abundance of RNAs and proteins to dissect complex classical traits or economic trait loci. These genomic data provide an understanding of metabolic, regulatory and developmental pathways. Jansen and Nap [18] proposed the merging of genomics and genetics into ‘genetical genomics’. This involves expression profiling and marker-based fingerprinting of each individual of a segregating population, and exploits all the statistical tools used in the analysis of QTL. Doerge [19] proposed the use of current QTL methods and software to identify loci that affect the level of expression of a particular gene or a set of genes. That means that the quantitative data of gene expression analyses are handled as phenotypic data (here termed ‘expression phenotype’) and their inheritance is compared with that of large numbers of markers applying methods of QTL analyses. QTL analysis of expression
g
levels of a gene identifies genomic regions that are likely to contain at least one causal gene with regulatory effect on the expression level, termed expression QTL (eQTL) [20–22]. Thus, the term ‘eQTL’ refers to the loci that control the abundance of particular transcripts, the expression phenotype [23]. However, in order to link the eQTL to the genetic background of a classical phenotypic trait of interest, it is necessary to establish a relationship between the variation of that classical phenotypic trait and its corresponding pQTL position on the one hand, and either the expression level of that particular transcript or the mapping position of the eQTL on the other hand.
Mode of Regulation of Expression and eQTL Mapping Combining microarray data with QTL linkage studies, by simply mapping genes that are differentially expressed depending on a classical trait, offers new options of understanding the biology at a global level and the genetic factors affecting the classical trait of interest, and it facilitates focusing on the most relevant candidate genes in each region shown to contain pQTL for that classical trait [20, 24, 25]. This projection of the position of traitassociated regulated genes onto QTL maps might be taken as ‘genetical genomics in the broader sense’. Differential expression of the gene in the pQTL region suggests a polymorphism in the gene itself (or close by) contributes to both variation of the transcript level and the classical trait of interest. These genes are functional positional candidate genes with cis-acting regulation. However, regulated genes depending on classical traits and mapping in the pQTL region might also be controlled by a locus mapping elsewhere, i.e. they might be under trans control. This implies that the genes are not causal or that they are not the only causal genes in the pQTL region. The differential expression of the genes might be an effect rather than a cause of variation. Mapping of eQTL, i.e. the identification of regions harbouring loci that affect the expression of a gene by linkage analysis, allows us to get further insight into these possible scenarios. eQTL mapping enables the addressing of cis-acting control of the transcription of genes within the pQTL for a classical trait of interest but also the studying of gene interactions via trans-acting regulation, where either the regulated gene or the regulating gene (the eQTL) may be located in the pQTL. Polymorphisms associated with trait variation can either be in coding, non-coding or regulatory regions; functional polymorphisms will be likely to be located in coding or regulatory regions. Variants that affect gene expression (eQTL) may have a substantial impact on quantitative classical traits, whereas qualitative traits, including hereditary disease, may more often depend on structural variation [26, 27]. A literature survey revealed
CAB International 2009
K. Wimmers, E. Murani and S. Ponsuksili
that of 107 genes with experimentally verified functional cis-regulatory polymorphisms, 82% had proven effects on phenotypes [28]. In humans, more than 100 cis-regulatory polymorphisms were associated with phenotypic variation of classical traits [29]. Also, in livestock, current findings suggest high importance of cis-regulatory polymorphisms: two of the causal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) identified in livestock are regulatory SNPs, an SNP in the 0 3 untranslated region (UTR) of the ovine GDF8 gene, affecting a mRNA-binding site and thus modulating transcription and translation of GDF8 [8] and an SNP in intron 3 of the porcine IGF2 gene, affecting its transcription [6]. The fact that in most genome-wide association studies SNPs were detected in non-coding regions supports the view that polymorphisms in regulatory regions are important [30]. eQTL studies revealed that about one-third are cis-acting eQTL [31, 32]. Pomp et al. [32] hypothesize that the majority of genes affecting complex classical traits are acting in trans. The authors describe four modes of relationships between the dependent variation of gene expression and the independent position of the expression-modulating gene including (1) cisacting regulation; (2) regulation in trans mode represents cases where the expressed genes is regulated by an unlinked eQTL; but there are also cases where (3) a single eQTL regulates many unlinked expressed genes (pleiotropic effect of an eQTL, master transcript modulators); (4) expressed genes regulated by a common eQTL might be organized in closely linked groups: so-called ‘expression neighbourhoods’ [32, 33]. The identification of the mode of action of an eQTL will provide clues as to the nature of the candidate gene underlying the trait of interest. The identification of trans-acting eQTL provides genetical evidence for gene–gene interaction and epistasis effects on a trait of interest. The variation of complex classical traits is the result of many genes of largely unknown function combined with environmental influences. The extent to which epistasis is involved in regulating complex traits is not known, but estimates of statistical epistasis in mouse and chicken, i.e. via modelling of effects of interaction of QTL effects, indicated that up to 81% of phenotypic variation can be explained by epistatic QTL effects [34–38]. Mapping of eQTL detects interaction among DNA sequence variations that gives rise to a particular final phenotype (genetical epistasis), and for genetic improvement, trans-acting eQTL direct researchers to the loci affecting the final phenotype. A trans eQTL affecting the expression level of several genes (master controller) potentially affects several (correlated) traits; the eQTL has pleiotropic effects. This is relevant in attempts to select for trans-acting eQTL [39]. Genotypes environment interactions are responsible for variation in phenotypic differences among different genotypes, depending on environmental factors such as climate, feeding, housing and various treatments. The characterization of the relationship of expression level of a target
g
11
gene, final phenotype and genotype, i.e. either cis- or transacting QTL, at various environments will enable selecting the right genotype for particular environments [40].
Feasibility of the eQTL Approach and Model Experiments It is evident that eQTL analyses are based on heritability of transcription. Expression studies in fact showed that inter-individual variability in gene expression is genetic, implying heritable variation in cis-acting sequences, transacting factors or both [41, 42]. Heritability is assessed by the resemblance among relatives and from parent– offspring regression between generations. The integration of QTL and expression analyses is based on the assumption that the functional polymorphism that affects the gene expression level also affects the classical trait in question. Such a finding will further increase the potential association of the gene with the trait in question. However, first reports of eQTL studies did not primarily relate to any classical phenotypic trait but demonstrate the feasibility of this ‘genetical genomics’ approach. Brem et al. [43] demonstrated that among some 6000 genes analysed for 570 eQTL could be detected, 33% of which were cisacting. In human, lymphoblastoid cell lines obtained from 167 individuals of 15 Centre d’Etude du Polymorphisme Humaine (CEPH) families of 23 499 genes surveyed by microarray analysis, 2340 were examined to estimate eQTL based on the comparison of the expression level of an individual sample with the expression level obtained from a pool of all samples [44]. Monks et al. [44] found heritable variation in 762 transcripts, i.e. transcripts showing a variance of expression levels caused by polygenic effects as revealed by maximum-likelihood estimation. The median heritability for the 762 transcripts was 0.3. Linkage study was performed using 346 markers at 11 cM median marker intervals. Stringent significance thresholds (pointwise significance level of 0.000005) revealed 33 eQTL accounting for 50% of the variance of the expression phenotype, with 75% of the QTL having heritabilities of >0.76; [44]. Using human lymphoblastoid cell lines of members of 14 CEPH families (of which 7 were the same as used by Monks et al. [44]) for micorarray expression profiling of about 8500 genes, Morley et al. [45] found 142 eQTL in a genome scan performed with 2756 autosomal SNP markers (at P < 0.00000004). The authors report on 2 eQTL regions that control expression of several genes. About 50% of the genes controlled by these master regulators could be assigned to regulated clusters showing correlated expression exceeding the level expected by chance. This reflects a complex regulatory network where master transcriptional regulators control expression level of genes with similar expression patterns that might reside close together certain genomic regions. Interestingly, these kinds of hotspots were also detected in other species [21, 43].
CAB International 2009
12
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Monks et al. [44] also found six regions with statistically significant enrichment of eQTL; however, the authors argue that because these hotspots correspond to linkage for highly variable and highly similar major histocompatibility complex (HLA) genes, this observation of hotspots might be an artefact of less reliable estimations of expression levels. Taking into account the particular phenotypic characteristics of the founders of the pedigrees used in eQTL studies enables us to relate expression levels, eQTL and phenotype. In mice, eQTL for obesity-related genes, diabetes, drug-abuse liability or allergic response were identified [21, 46–48]. The experiments demonstrate the feasibility of eQTL mapping: however, in particular, when comparing the two human studies by Monks et al. [44] and Morley et al. [45] it becomes obvious that because of differences in analytical and statistical methods, the outcome may differ in terms of number of eQTL, mode of eQTL and eQTL effects that are related to the power of the study [49]. Theoretical examinations of the eQTL experiments show up the limits of eQTL studies through experimental constraints (including specificity, sensitivity and efficiency of microarray experiments, dynamic range of detectable expression differences, size of intervals used to define cis eQTL) and insufficient statistical power (mainly depending on sample number), given the complex nature of genetic regulation of transcription levels [23, 49]. The estimation of heritability of transcript variation is difficult. Studies in model organisms and humans indicate that non-additive effects modulate transcript levels including epistatic and parent-of-origin effects [41]. At more stringent statistical thresholds, the proportion of cis-acting eQTL usually becomes higher in many studies, indicating a higher impact of cis eQTL that are consequently more readily detectable. This might be because effects of SNPs within the expressed genes themselves are easier to detect than second-order effects [23, 32, 41, 44]. However, a higher number of trans eQTL might be expected to be detected by chance than cis eQTL, because for the trans eQTL, the whole genome represents a target except one position, whereas for cis eQTL only exactly one position is the target.
Applications of the eQTL Approach The most obvious application of ‘genetical genomics’ is to scale down the number of candidate genes for a classical trait of interest. ‘Genetical genomics in the broader sense’ of mapping differentially expressed genes onto the pQTL map, as well as ‘genetical genomics in the narrow sense’ of mapping eQTL, enables a reduction in the number of positional candidate genes for a pQTL when seeking positional functional candidate genes. Arbilly et al. [25] reported that the integrated application of pQTL mapping and expression analysis allowed a narrowing down of a pQTL region for susceptibility to neuropathic pain of 12 Mb that contains some 150 genes by assigning
g
segregating SNPs to coding and regulatory regions of genes, addressing 34 polymorphic positional candidate genes, and finally prioritizing two positional functional candidate genes in mice. In chickens, this approach is promoted and has been exemplarily performed to identify genes related to Marek’s disease resistance [24]. Essentially, it has become common in expression analyses to refer to the position of the differentially expressed genes relative to existing pQTL for the trait of interest. With the aim of detecting genes affecting immune responsiveness De Koning et al. [50, 51] propose to extend this approach by obtaining microarray expression profiles of animals of a segregating F2 population after immunological stimulation and by genotyping the same animals in order to estimate eQTL and pQTL for immune-response-related traits. In order to increase the power and reduce the number of the analyses for eQTL analysis, individuals homozygous for the respective pQTL should be used, whereas for fine mapping of the pQTL, recombinant individuals of the F2 should be selected. The use of animals that are homozygous for a putative pQTL for the estimation of eQTL increases the power to detect additive effects and the focus on just two contrasting groups and on predicted regions only allows simpler genetic tests and less multiple testing. The combination of the eQTL data and fine mapping data will allow the accurate assigning of a candidate gene as a cis- or transregulated locus [51]. Fine mapping based on a subset of animals showing recombination between the initial identified flanking markers of the pQTL enables the precise detection of cis-acting eQTL, whereas to detect of transacting eQTL, additional expression analysis using selected animals of the fine mapping study may be required to resolve eQTL that correlate with the pQTL and those that are linked effects. Power analyses showed that the size of the resource populations required to detect eQTL depends on the number of QTL regions taken into account, the size of the effects of QTL to be detected, and the resolution of the genetic map. The authors state that the number of individuals that need to be genotyped using their proposed strategy is much lower than the size of the population [51]. Cardoso et al. [52] compared different strategies to select subsets of animals used for eQTL detection taking into account genetic and phenotypic dissimilarity, their combination and recombination events. Three samples sizes (80, 160 and 240 individuals of 510 F2 animals) were simulated. In terms of sensitivity and precision of estimates of QTL effects, selection of animals based on genetic dissimilarity and phenotypic extremes within genotype methods was preferential, in particular, when a low numbers of animals used [52]. There are numerous publications highlighting the possible merits of ‘genetical genomics’ applications in livestock breeding [32, 39, 40, 53, 54] and/or addressing issues of data evaluation and experimental design in silico [50, 51, 55–57]. However, there is a lack of experimental data on eQTL mapping obtained in non-model animal
CAB International 2009
K. Wimmers, E. Murani and S. Ponsuksili Genome: gene and marker genotypes
Transcriptome: expression levels
eQTL
cis
13
trans
Yes
No
Yes
Gene regulation not relevant to the classical trait
pQTL
Trait-depend. expression
Within pQTL
Neither gene nor Gene within pQTL eQTL within pQTL eQTL within PQTL
Outside pQTL
Likely a causal gene with Member of a relevant network a regulatory SNP
Member of a relevant network; link to a regulatory superior gene
The regulatory superior gene is a functional positional candidate gene
Final phenotype: records of traits
Figure 1. Outline of integration of data from eQTL and pQTL analyses and expression profiling towards identification of candidate genes for complex classical traits facilitating the detection of markers for genetic improvement of livestock.
species. In lake whitefish, a valuable commercial freshwater fish, eQTL were mapped for white muscle and brain transcripts quantified in 66 and 57 individuals of the first backcross generation of the F1 hybrid of dwarf and normal whitefishdwarf whitefish [58, 59]. eQTL of genes that were differentially expressed between the founder lines points to genes involved in the divergence of these populations. Regions were identified that harbour genes controlling the expression of many loci of functional groups relevant to the phenotypic divergence of the dwarf and normal whitefish [58, 59]. The co-localization of eQTL and pQTL for growth enable researchers to address candidate genes for these classical traits, although positional data for the transcripts are lacking and thus a discrimination of cis- and trans-acting eQTL was not possible [59]. Recently, the first study in livestock on eQTL mapping of trait-dependent expressed genes obtained from microarray experiments was reported in the pig [60]. The study aimed to find relevant biological pathways and candidate genes for water-holding capacity of meat. Therefore, correlation between gene expression of 11 453 muscle expressed genes (out of 23 256 loci represented on the Affymetrix Porcine Genome Array) and drip loss phenotypic traits was calculated. A total of 1279 genes were significantly associated with the trait (r=10.37–0.67l; P0.001; q0.004). Subsequently, eQTL were identified for transcripts that showed traitcorrelated expression, providing information about the
g
genomic location of putative regulatory loci relevant for the trait of interest. In total, 897 eQTL were identified with 104 eQTL mapping in pQTL target regions for water-holding capacity identified in the same population. Among the 104 eQTL co-localized with pQTL 96 represent trans-acting eQTL and 8 were cis-acting. Of the 793 eQTL mapping away from of any pQTL, 119 eQTL were trans-acting eQTL of 66 genes mapping to the pQTL target regions. These three groups of eQTL, in particular, provide additional insight into the control of the trait of interest: (1) The eight genes categorized as positional functional candidate genes, which map together with their corresponding eQTL in cis, are genes showing variation with impact on the trait of interest and its expression level, indicating that the nature of the variation is likely a polymorphism in regulatory regions of the gene. (2) The 96 eQTL detected within pQTL for which the functional candidate genes themselves are located elsewhere, i.e. trans control, are influenced by hierarchically superior genes located in the pQTL that actually represent candidate genes (positional candidate genes). (3) For 66 functional positional candidate genes under trans control, it can be speculated that the nature of variation affecting the final phenotype of water-holding capacity is differential expression owing to polymorphisms in hierarchically superior genes and different responsiveness of the candidate genes to regulatory mechanisms. The study revealed a network of genes relevant to the trait of interest representing additive and pleiotropic as well as
CAB International 2009
14
Animal Science Reviews 2010
non-additive epistatic effects on the trait. cis-acting eQTL serves as an important new resource for the identification of positional candidates in QTL studies.
4. Ciobanu D, Bastiaansen J, Malek M, Helm J, Woollard J, Plastow G, et al. Evidence for new alleles in the protein kinase adenosine monophosphate-activated gamma(3)-subunit gene associated with low glycogen content in pig skeletal muscle and improved meat quality. Genetics 2001;159:1151–62.
Summary and Implications
5. Georges M, Andersson L. Positional identification of structural and regulatory quantitative trait nucleotides in domestic animal species. Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 2003;68:179–87.
The benefit of ‘genetical genomics’ approaches to identify functional positional candidate genes and to elucidate functional networks of genes relevant for complex classical traits has been demonstrated experimentally in humans, model organisms and livestock species. A key advantage of eQTL mapping is that it connects variation at the level of RNA to variation at the level of DNA. Variation at the transcript level, especially in holistic approaches, is conclusive towards identification of relevant functional networks and for deriving hypothesis on the control of expression and inheritance of a trait of interest. However, measures at the level of RNA are less promising tools for breeding than genotyping at the DNA level. The application of expression microarray data by breeders including the estimation of breeding values for gene expression in ‘expression-assisted selection’ schemes [39, 40] is hampered by the costs and the high situation-specificity (tissue-, age-, sex-, housing-, feedingand treatment-depending) of expression analyses. Variation at the DNA level is easily detectable in any tissue at any developmental stage and under endogenous and exogenous conditions. Furthermore, variation at the DNA level is inherited. For genetic improvement, traitassociated markers or preferentially causal markers at the level of DNA are versatile tools. Integration of records of complex classical traits, genome scans and holistic transcriptome analyses for the identification of pQTL and eQTL will largely contribute to the detection of such DNA markers for genetic improvement (Figure 1). Current applications of DNA marker genotype in best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) animal models will be extended using information on pQTL and eQTL. The availability of SNP microarrays for livestock species for genome-wide association studies improves the mapping resolution for pQTL and eQTL, leading to more precise discrimination of cis and trans eQTL and further scaling down the length of lists of functional positional candidate genes.
References 1. Andersson L, Haley CS, Ellegren H, Knott SA, Johansson M, Andersson K, et al. Genetic mapping of quantitative trait loci for growth and fatness in pigs. Science 1994;263:1771–4. 2. Hu Z, Fritz ER, Reecy JM. AnimalQTLdb: a livestock QTL database tool set for positional QTL information mining and beyond. Nucleic Acids Research 2007;35:604–9. 3. Milan D, Jeon JT, Looft C, Amarger V, Robic A, Thelander M, et al. A mutation in PRKAG3 associated with excess glycogen content in pig skeletal muscle. Science 2000;288:1248–51.
g
6. Van Laere AS, Nguyen M, Braunschweig M, Nezer C, Collette C, Moreau L, et al. A regulatory mutation in IGF2 causes a major QTL effect on muscle growth in the pig. Nature 2003;425:832–6. 7. Grisart B, Coppieters W, Farnir F, Karim L, Ford C, Berzi P, et al. Positional candidate cloning of a QTL in dairy cattle: identification of a missense mutation in the bovine DGAT1 gene with major effect on milk yield and composition. Genome Research 2002;12:222–31. 8. Clop A, Marcq F, Takeda H, Pirottin D, Tordoir X, Bibe´ B, et al. A mutation creating a potential illegitimate microRNA target site in the myostatin gene affects muscularity in sheep. Nature Genetics 2006;38:813–8. 9. Schena M, Shalon D, Davis RW, Brown PO. Quantitative monitoring of gene expression patterns with a complementary DNA microarray. Science 1995;270:467–70. 10. Bai Q, McGillivray C, da Costa N, Dornan S, Evans G, Stear MJ, et al. Development of a porcine skeletal muscle cDNA microarray: analysis of differential transcript expression in phenotypically distinct muscles. BMC Genomics 2003;4:8. 11. Moser RJ, Reverter A, Kerr CA, Beh KJ, Lehnert SA. A mixedmodel approach for the analysis of cDNA microarray gene expression data from extreme-performing pigs after infection with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:1261–71. 12. Ponsuksili S, Murani E, Schellander K, Schwerin M, Wimmers K. Identification of functional candidate genes for body composition by expression analyses and evidencing impact by association analysis and mapping. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta – Gene Structure and Expression 2005;1730:31–40. 13. Ponsuksili S, Murani E, Walz C, Schwerin M, Wimmers K. Pre- and postnatal hepatic gene expression profiles of two pig breeds differing in body composition: insight into pathways of metabolic regulation. Physiological Genomics 2007;29:267–79. 14. Ponsuksili S, Murani E, Phatsara C, Jonas E, Walz C, Schwerin M, et al. Expression profiling of muscle reveals transcripts differentially expressed in muscle that affect water-holding capacity of pork. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2008;56:10311–7. 15. Band MR, Olmstead C, Everts RE, Liu ZL, Lewin HA. A 3800 gene microarray for cattle functional genomics: comparison of gene expression in spleen, placenta, and brain. Animal Biotechnology 2002;13:163–72. 16. Suchyta SP, Sipkovsky S, Kruska R, Jeffers A, McNulty A, Coussens MJ, et al. Development and testing of a high-density cDNA microarray resource for cattle. Physiological Genomics 2003;15:158–64. 17. Cogburn LA, Wang X, Carre W, Rejto L, Porter TE, Aggrey SE, et al. Systems-wide chicken DNA microarrays, gene
CAB International 2009
K. Wimmers, E. Murani and S. Ponsuksili expression profiling, and discovery of functional genes. Poultry Science 2003;82:939–51. 18. Jansen RC, Nap JP. Genetical genomics: the added value from segregation. Trends Genet 2001;17:388–91. 19. Doerge RW. Mapping and analysis of quantitative trait loci in experimental populations. Nature Reviews Genetics 2002;3:43–52.
15
analysis reveals complex genetic determinants of circadian behavior in mice. Genome Research 2001;11:959–80. 37. Sugiyama F, Churchill GA, Higgins DC, Johns C, Makaritsis KP, Gavras H, et al. Concordance of murine quantitative trait loci for salt-induced hypertension with rat and human loci. Genomics 2001;71:70–7.
20. Wayne ML, McIntyre M. Combining mapping and arraying: An approach to candidate gene identification. Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 2002;99:14903–6.
38. Carlborg O, Kerje S, Schu¨tz K, Jacobsson L, Jensen P, Andersson L. A global search reveals epistatic interaction between QTL for early growth in the chicken. Genome Research 2003;13(3):413–21.
21. Schadt EE, Monks SA, Drake TA, Lusis AJ, Che N, Colinayo V, et al. Genetics of gene expression surveyed in maize, mouse and man. Nature 2003;422:297–301.
39. Walsh B, Henderson D. Microarrays and beyond: What potential do current and future genomics tools have for breeders? Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:292–9.
22. Tabakoff B, Bhave SV, Hoffman PL. Selective breeding, quantitative trait locus analysis, and gene arrays identify candidate genes for complex drug-related behaviors. Journal of Neuroscience 2003;23:4491–8.
40 Kadarmideen HN, von Rohr P, Janss LLG. From genetical genomics to systems genetics: potential applications in quantitative genomics and animal breeding. Mammalian Genome 2006;17:548–64.
23. Williams RBH, Chan EKF, Cowley MJ, Little PFR. The influence of genetic variation on gene expression. Genome Research 2007;17:1707–16.
41. Gibson G, Weir B. The quantitative genetics of transcription. Trends in Genetics 2005;21:616–23.
24. Liu H-C, Cheng HH, Tirunagaru V, Sofer L, Burnside J. A strategy to identify positional candidate genes conferring Marek’s disease resistance by integrating DNA microarrays and genetic mapping. Animal Genetics 2001;32:351–9. 25. Arbilly M, Pisante A, Devor M, Darvasi A. An integrative approach for the identification of quantitative trait loci. Animal Genetics 2006;37(Suppl.1):7–9. 26. Farrall M. Quantitative genetic variation: a post-modern view. Human Molecular Genetics 2004;13(1):R1–7. 27. Yan H, Zhou W. Allelic variations in gene expression. Current Opinion in Oncology 2004;16:39–43. 28. Rockman MV, Wray GA. Abundant raw material for cisregulatory evolution in humans. Molecular Biology and Evolution 2002;19:1991–2004. 29. Wray GA. The evolutionary significance of cis-regulatory mutations. Nature Reviews Genetics 2007;8:206–16. 30. McCarthy MI, Abecasis GR, Cardon LR, Goldstein DB, Little J, Ioannidis JP, et al. Genome-wide association studies for complex traits: consensus, uncertainty and challenges. Nature Reviews Genetics 2008;9:356–69. 31. Doss S, Schadt EE, Drake TA, Aldons JL. Cis-acting expression quantitative trait loci in mice. Genome Research 2005;15:681–91. 32. Pomp D, Allan MF, Wesolowsky SR. Quantitative genomics: exploring the genetic architecture of complex trait predisposition. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:300–12. 33. Oliver B, Parisi M, Clark D. Gene expression neighbourhoods. Journal of Biology 2002;1:4. 34. Brockmann GA, Kratzsch J, Haley CS, Renne U, Schwerin M, Karle S. Single QTL effects, epistasis, and pleiotropy account for two-thirds of the phenotypic F(2) variance of growth and obesity in DU6iDBA/2 mice. Genome Research 2000;10:1941–57. 35. Kim JH, Sen S, Avery CS, Simpson E, Chandler P, Nishina PM, et al. Genetic analysis of a new mouse model for non-insulin-dependent diabetes. Genomics 2001;74:273–86. 36. Shimomura K, Low-Zeddies SS, King DP, Steeves TD, Whiteley A, Kushla J, et al. Genome-wide epistatic interaction
g
42. Stamatoyannopoulos JA. The genomics of gene expression. Genomics 2004;84:449–57. 43. Brem RB, Yvert G, Clinton R, Kruglyak L. Genetic dissection of transcriptional regulation in budding yeast. Science 2002;296:752–5. 44. Monks SA, Leonardson A, Zhu H, Cundiff P, Pietrusiak P, Edwards S, et al. Genetic inheritance of gene expression in human cell lines. American Journal of Human Genetics 2004;75:1094–105. 45. Morley M, Molony CM, Weber TM, Devlin JL, Ewnes KG, Spielman RS, et al. Genetic analysis of genome-wide variation in human gene expression. Nature 2004;430:733–4. 46. Karp CL, Grupe A, Schadt E, Ewart SL, Keane-Moore M, Cuomo PJ, et al. Identification of complement factor 5 as a susceptibility locus for experimental allergic asthma. Nature Immunology 2000;1:221–6. 47. Eaves IA, Wicker LS, Ghandour G, Lyons PA, Peterson LB, Todd JA, et al. Combining mouse congenic strains and microarray gene expression analyses to study a complex trait: the NOD model of type 1 diabetes. Genome Research 2002;12:232–43. 48. Palmer AA, Verbitsky M, Suresh R, Kamens HM, Reed CL, Li N, et al. Gene expression differences in mice divergently selected for methamphetamine sensitivity. Mammalian Genome 2005;16:291–305. 49. De Koning D-J, Haley C. Genetical genomics in human and model organisms. Trends in Genetics 2005;21:377–81. 50. De Koning D-J, Carlborg O¨, Haley CS. The genetic dissection of immune response using gene-expression studies and genome mapping. Veterinary Immunology and Immunopathology 2005;105:343–52. 51. De Koning D-J, Cabrera CP, Haley CS. Genetical genomics: combining gene expression with marker genotypes in poultry. Poultry Science 2007;86:1501–9. 52. Cardoso FF, Rosa GJ, Steibel JP, Ernst CW, Bates RO, Tempelman RJ. Selective transcriptional profiling and data analysis strategies for expression quantitative trait loci mapping in outbred F2 populations. Genetics 2008;180:1679–90.
CAB International 2009
16
Animal Science Reviews 2010
53. Kadarmideen HN, Reverter A. Combined genetic, genomic and transcriptomic methods in the analysis of animal traits. CAB Reviews: Perspectives in Agriculture, Veterinary Science, Nutrition and Natural Resources 2007;2:16. 54. Wimmers K, Ngu NT, Murani E, Schellander K, Ponsuksili S. Linkage and expression analysis to elucidate the genetic background of muscle structure and meat quality in the pig. Archives of Animal Breeding 2006;49 (Special Issue):116–25. 55. Perez-Enciso M, Toro MA, Tenenhaus M, Gianoly D. Combining gene expression and molecular marker information for mapping complex trait genes: a simulation study. Genetics 2003;164:1597–606. 56. Perez-Enciso M. In silico study of transcriptome genetic variation in outbred populations. Genetics 2004;166:547–54.
g
57. Perez-Enciso M, Quevedo JR, Bahamonde A. Genetical genomics: use all data. BMC Genomics 2007;8:69. 58. Derome N, Bougas B, Rogers SM, Whiteley AR, Labbe A, Laroche J, et al. Pervasive sex-linked effects on transcription regulation as revealed by expression quantitative trait loci mapping in Lake Whitefish (Coregonus sp., Salmonidae). Genetics 2008;179:1903–17. 59. Whiteley AR, Derome N, Rogers SM, St-Cyr J, Laroche J, Labbe A, et al. The phenomics and expression quantitative trait locus mapping of brain transcriptomes regulating adaptive divergence in lake whitefish species pairs (Coregonus sp.). Genetics 2008;180:147–64. 60. Ponsuksili S, Jonas E, Murani E, Phatsara C, Srikanchai T, Walz C, et al. Trait correlated expression combined with expression QTL analysis reveals biological pathways and candidate genes affecting water holding capacity of muscle. BMC Genomics 2008;9:367.
CAB International 2009
Animal Science Reviews 2010
A brief history of mammalian coat colour genetics J.J. Lauvergne* Address: 147 C/3 avenue J.B. Cle´ment, 92 140, Clamart, France. *Correspondence: Email:
[email protected] Received: Accepted:
19 August 2009 6 November 2009
Abstract The study of coat colour genes of mammals can be traced back to the rediscovery of Mendel’s laws in 1900. A phenotypic homology of coat colour loci based on a phenotypic similarity of allelic series has been demonstrated and is known as comparative coat colour genetics. This homology has been verified by molecular genetics. Loci controlling coat colour in mammals are numerous: more than 280 have been discovered in genetic analysis of the mouse, the leading laboratory species. Loci for which mutants have been kept in breeding species (mainly farm animals) are less numerous because only viable alleles have been saved. The colour loci are highly pleiotropic, being involved not only in coat colour pigmentation but also in many other biological processes. The comparative study of DNA chains of numerous variants in several species may help to follow evolution at the locus level in mammals. The colour mutants that segregate in those domesticated populations termed the primary populations may be used as markers to follow genetic dynamics after domestication. Keywords: Mammals, Coat colour genetics, History Review Methodology: The present review was initially prepared at the request of an informal committee which met at the Veterinary School of Alfort near Paris on 22–23 June 2009 devoted to re-launching in France a network on coat and plumage colour genetics.
The Visible Polymorphism in Domesticated Mammals
visible effects. The Mouse New Letter (MNL) list included the following:
During the Middle Ages, a polymorphism affecting visible traits of mammals was described in the miniatures of the Livre de Chasse from Gaston Phoebus [1] for the dog. Nineteenth-century authors such as Darwin [2, 3] and Isidore Geoffroy St Hilaire [4] then noticed the contrast between the wild state (in which this polymorphism was rather rare) and the domestic state, in which it was a general rule.
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
The Mendelian Profile of Visible Polymorphisms in Mammals After the rediscovery of Mendel’s laws in 1900, mutants inducing visible effects were sorted according to their
g
coat colour, skin fibres or horn, skeleton, appendices, neurological and muscular, endocrinian defects (nanism, obesity), or reproductive organs.
The list can be used in other species such as sheep, as proposed by Dolling et al. [5]. In some mammalian species, such as the mouse, humans and cattle, it is possible to divide visible mutants into various categories. There is a worldwide network of laboratories studying the mouse – the best genetically known laboratory mammal. Thousands of animals are raised and all new mutants are scanned to be saved and studied. The genetic
CAB International 2009
18
Animal Science Reviews 2010
results were gathered in the MNL before being made available online by Mouse Genome Informatics (MGI), published by the Jackson Laboratory, Bar Harbor, Maine, USA. As far as man are concerned, every year, thousands of human births are surveyed for birth defects or congenital diseases in maternity hospitals. Several hospitals have sections devoted to hereditary traits whether pathologic or not. In the 1960s, the results of these genetic analyses were electronically compiled by McKusick [6, 7] in Mendelian Inheritance in Man (MIM). MIM is now available online under Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM). For cattle (Bos taurus), a Mendelian Inheritance in Cattle (MIC) [8] has been published, covering the whole visible Mendelian inheritance in which ‘clinical, pathological and other visible hereditary traits’ could be scanned with the results of Artificial Insemination programmes [9]. From these explorations, the following is apparent: (1) Pleiotropy is a constant behaviour of mutants with visible effect and (2) mutants usually have a very low viability.
The Beginnings of Coat Colour Genetic Studies in Mammals Studies on the coat colour genetics of mammals were initiated in the mouse by Cue´not [10], in sheep by Davenport [11] and Wood [12], and in cattle by Barrington and Pearson [13] and others. At the end of the 1910s, Wright [14–23] reviewed coat colour in ten species: the mouse, rat, rabbit, guinea pig, cattle, horse, dog, pig, cat and humans. Later, Haldane [24] compared coat colour in rodents and carnivores, for which Mendelian studies were made easier by their high prolificity, short generation intervals and low individual cost of maintenance. The same species were scanned by Little [25], followed by Searle [26], who has taken into account all the mammalian species then genetically analysed for their coat colour genetics (around 70).
The Laws of Comparative Coat Colour Genetics in Mammals Wright [14–23] postulated that genes were controlling the same enzyme from one species to another, and his 1917 and 1918 papers were obviously premonitory, but the notion of homology between mammalian species in its definitive shape must be assigned to Haldane [24], who compared phenotypes induced by allelic series in various species. These phenotypes were very similar: for example in the A (Agouti) series, there were alleles controlling similar patterns of distribution of phoeomelanic (red) and
g
eumelanic (black or brown) pigments in the coat, when the colour of eumelanin (black or brown) is under the control of alleles at Brown (B) locus. Such phenotypic and genotypic homology has been confirmed by Little [25] and then by Searle [26]. The latter author moreover deduced rules for the genetics of mammalian coat colour. Therefore, before the true biochemical composition of hereditary particles (DNA chains) was known after Watson and Crick in the 1950s, followed by the deciphering of DNA chains in the 1970s, the comparison of coat colour genetics had already brought strong proof that, at least in mammals, evolution has used the same loci. Currently, the presence of the same loci in the genotype of three species as far from each other in the evolutionary tree as human, mouse and zebrafish as compared by Oeting et al. [27] show that the lessons of the comparative coat colour genetics have a historical interest. From these pioneering times, the field has inherited an alphabetical nomenclature (A, Agouti, B, Brown, C, Colour, D, Dilution, E, Extension, etc.) which, while it will probably vanish, may be kept for the variants that have not been biochemically identified.
Enumeration of Colour Loci in Mammals In the mouse, Silvers [28] enumerated more than 50 loci with 130 determinants (phenotypic alleles). Four years later, according to Bennett and Lamoreux [29], this number was 127, with more than 800 alleles, and 59 of these loci had been sequenced. Recently, Oetting et al. [27] gave a total number of 281 loci, of which 114 were cloned and 167 not yet cloned: twice the score of Bennett and Lamoreux! In farm animals, the number of coat colour loci is much lower, because only those which are viable have been kept and analysed. Therefore one may find only 18 loci in the dog [30, 31], 14 in cattle [32] and 11 in sheep [33]. It also appears that there is a prevalence of some homologous loci (A, B, C, D, E, etc.) Even in the small number of farm animals having a catalogue of Mendelian loci such as sheep [34], cattle [35] or dog [30, 36], there is a prevalence of viable mutants belonging to the phenotypic category 1 (coat colour), over all the other phenotypic categories. The second phenotypic category to be represented is category 2 for skin fibres and horn as observed in the dog: 52 alleles at 18 loci controlling coat colour have been described against only 16 alleles at 8 loci for the architecture of coat [30].
Present Studies The molecular genetic exploration of farm animals has followed the purely Mendelian studies reviewed by Searle
CAB International 2009
J.J. Lauvergne
[26]. In cattle, these studies go back to 1995 for cattle [37] and to 1999 for sheep [38–40]. The genes have received new names: MC1R for Extension, TRPY for Brown, etc.
An Explanation for the Uniformity of Coat in Wild Species, with Some Exceptions In wild species, where all animals are uniform, the disruptive role of coat colour for both prey species and for predators gives a strong selection pressure in favour of the best fitted colour allele [41, 42]. Nevertheless, in several wild species, a uniformity of coat or shell colour is not observed. An example is given by the snail Cepaea nemoralis, studied by Lamotte [43]. Every allele controlling shell colour confers a disruptive advantage on a given coloured background and the colour of the background is of course variable. Therefore one of the reasons why we can observe several coat colour mutants in domestic mammals may result from the fact that in the domestic state the disruptive effect does not play a role in selection.
Biological and Evolutionary Interest of Coat Colour Genes The various levels of action of coat colour genes on coat colour have been summarized [26, 27]. They already affect a wide range of biological phenomena. The range of defects listed by the last author shows that the biological importance of colour genes is even much bigger. The interest of these colour genes in the study of evolution derives from an homology betwwen allelic series (Agouti, Brown and Extension etc.) in several species. Once the DNA chains will be deciphered the evolution between and intra species will be explored.
The Colour Gene to Follow Genetic Dynamics after Domestication Farm animal population in which several alleles for coat colour segregate were described in cattle, in England [44] and in Norway [45]; in sheep in Iceland [46] and in London cat [47]. In his World Dictionary of Breeds, Types and Varieties of Livestock, Mason [48] states that several breeds, types or varieties present a great diversity of external aspects, especially in their coat colour i.e. are multi-segregating for colour alleles. Such entities were then named ‘non-uniform populations or by a geographical term meaning cattle of such and such a place or breeds of such and such a place’, by Mason [48] and Lauvergne [49] proposed to use the shorter term
g
19
‘traditional population’. In turn, the term ‘traditional population’ has been replaced by ‘primary population’, because they are the first type of populations to appear after domestication, Lauvergne [50]. According to the laws of population genetics established in the 1900s [51, 52], followed by Haldane [53–57] a stable gene frequency equilibrium is reached, provided that: coefficients of selection do not disadvantage mutant carriers (homozygous or heterozygous), which is the case because under domestication the natural selection does not play a role; reproduction is made under random mating, which may still be verified in existing primary populations of goats in Cameroon (F. Meutchie`ye, personal communication, 2009) and Senegal (D. Bouchel, personal communication, 2009) or in Damara sheep of South Africa, (D. Du Toit, personal communication, 2009). In Europe and in other places, the primary populations have disappeared because breeders have been able to control reproduction more strictly, mating animals of the same phenotype with a choice that has mainly been of a given coat colour. This is the way modern standardized breeds have originated from primary populations. Since Mason [48] multi-segregating populations have been described in sheep in Iceland [58], in North Atlantic islands (Shetland, Orkney and Soay) [59] and in Corsica [60]. Several papers of the INRA 1986 Conference of Manosque [61] described also such primary sheep and goat populations. More recently in Africa studies in goat – in Algeria [62, 63] and in sub-Saharan countries such as Chad [64], Nigeria [65] and Cameroon [66] and Senegal (D. Bouchel, personal communication, 2009) show that primary populations are numerous in a very large zone. This could also be the case in Africa with sheep from the Damara population of Namibia and South Africa [67], for which great colour variability has been described [68, 69]. The great interest is that such primary populations are probably derived with minute variations (appraisal of new mutants) from the first populations of the two species kept in Middle East during some centuries (or millenaries?) after domestication, 12 000 years ago [70].
Conclusion/Summary This very brief history of coat colour genetics in mammals stress the central biological role played by the genes belonging to this phenotypic category of loci as seen by the wide range of their pleiotropy.
CAB International 2009
20
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Moreover, their mutants are the most frequently observed category of viable mutants among the domestic mammals and may be used as markers.
13. Barrington A, Pearson K. On the inheritance of coat colour in cattle. Biometrika 1906;4:427–64. 14. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. II. The mouse. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:373–8. 15. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. III. The rat. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:426–30.
Acknowledgments
16. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. IV. The rabbit. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:473–5.
The subject matter of this review was proposed by Dr Genevie`ve Aubin-Houzelstein (Molecular and Cellular Genetics, UMR 955, INRA-ENVA, Maisons-Alfort, France) and Professor Ahmad Oulmouden (Animal Molecular Genetics UMR 1061, Limoges, France). Professor Carlo Renieri (Environmental Sciences Department, University of Camerino, Italy) has been kind enough to read the manuscript.
17. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. V. The guinea pig. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:476–80. 18. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. VI. Cattle. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:521–7. 19. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. VII. The horse. Journal of Heredity 1917;8:561–4. 20. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. IX. The dog. Journal of Heredity 1918;9:87–90. 21. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. VIII. Swine. Journal of Heredity 1918;9:33–8. 22. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. X. The cat. Journal of Heredity 1918;9:139–44.
References 1. Phoebus G. Le Livre de chasse (The Book of the Hunt). Manuscript, Ortez (France); 1369.
23. Wright S. Color inheritance in mammals. XI. Man. Journal of Heredity 1918;9:227–40.
2. Darwin C. 1. Variations under domestication. In: Darwin C, editor. On the Origins of Species by Means of Natural Selection. John Murray, London; 1859 (In Burrow JW, Darwin C. The Origin of Species. Penguin Books Ltd, Harmondsworth, Middlesex, UK; 1968. p. 71–100).
24. Haldane JBS. The comparative genetics of color in rodents and carnivora. Biological Review 1927;2:199–212.
3. Darwin, C. The Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication. 2 volumes. John Murray, London; 1868.
26. Searle AG. Comparative Genetics of Coat Colour in Mammals. Logos Press/Academic Press, London/New York; 1968.
4. Geoffroy-Saint-Hilaire I. Taming and Domestication of Useful Animals. 4th ed. La Maison rustique, Paris; 1861.
27. Oetting WS, Montollu L, Bennett DC. Color genes (Mouse). European Society for Pigment Cell Research; 2009. Available from: URL: http://www.espr.org/micemut: 1–2.
5. Dolling CHS, Millar P, Denis B, Rae AL, Lauvergne JJ, Renieri C. Listing loci and alleles of sheep and goats for visible traits other than colour 1987. In: Lauvergne JJ, editor. Standardized Genetic Nomenclature for Sheep and Goats 1987, Loci for Visible Traits Other Than Colour and Blood and Milk Polymorphisms. Lavoisier, Paris; 1989. p. 27–32.
25. Little CC. Coat colour genes in rodents and carnivores. Quarterly Review of Biology 1956;33:103–37.
28. Silvers WK. The Coat Color of Mice. Springer-Verlag, Berlin; 1979. 29. Bennett D, Lamoreau ML. The colour loci of mice – a genetic Century. Pigment Cell Research 2003;16:333–44.
6. McKusick V. Foreword. In: McKusick V, editor. Mendelian Inheritance in Man. The John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, MD; 1966. p. vii–xi.
30. Sponenberg DP. Rothschild genetics of coat color and hair texture. In: Ruvinsky A, Sampson J, editors. The Genetics of the Dog. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxon, UK; 2001. p. 61–85.
7. McKusick V, editor. Mendelian Inheritance in Man. The John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, MD; 1966.
31. Denis B. Dog Coat Colours. Aniwa SAS, Paris; 2008.
8. Millar P, Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, editors. Mendelian Inheritance in Cattle 2000. Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands; 2000. 9. Huston K, Saperstein G, Steffen D, Millar P, Lauvergne JJ. Clinical, pathological and other visible traits loci except coat colour (Category 2). In: Millar P, Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, editors. Mendelian Inheritance in Cattle. EAAP publication No. 101. Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands; 2000. p. 107–29. 10. Cue´not L. Mendel Law and Heredity of Pigmentation in Mouse. Archives de Zoologie Expe´rimentale et de Ge´ne´tique 3e`me se´rie 1902;10:27–30. 11. Davenport CB. The origin of black sheep in the flock. Science NS 1905;22:674. 12. Wood. Note on the inheritance of horns and face colour in sheep. Journal of Agricultural Science (London) 1905;364–5.
g
32. Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, Rae AL, Renieri C, Sponenberg DP, Denis B. 1. Coat colour loci (category 1). In: Millar P, Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, editors. Mendelian Inheritance in Cattle. Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands; 2000. p. 37–105. 33. Sponenberg DP, Dolling CHS, Lundie RS, Rae AL, Renieri C, Lauvergne JJ. 1. Coat colour loci (category 1). In: Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, Renieri C. Mendelian Inheritance in Sheep 1996 (MIS 96). COGOVICA/COGNOSAG and University of Camerino, Clamart/Camerino; 1996. pp. 15–57. 34. Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS, Renieri C, editors. Mendelian Inheritance in Sheep 1996 (MIS 96). COGOVICA/ COGNOSAG and University of Camerino, Clamart and Camerino; 1996. 35. Millar P, Lauvergne JJ, Dolling CHS. Mendelian inheritance in Cattle. EAAP publication No. 101. Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, The Netherlands; 2000.
CAB International 2009
J.J. Lauvergne 36. Nicholas FW. Genetics of morphological traits and inherited disorders. In: Ruvinsky A, Sampson J, editors. The Genetics of the Dog. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxon, UK; 2001. p. 87–116. 37. Klungland H, Va˚ge D, Gomez-Raya L, Adalsteinsson S, Lien S. The role of melanocyte-stimulating hormone (MSH) receptor in bovine coat color determination. Mammalian Genome 1995;6:636–63. 38. Parsons YM, Fleet MR, Cooper DW. Short communication – isolation of the ovine Agouti coding sequence. Pigment Cell Research 1999;12:394–7. 39. Parsons YM, Fleet MR, Cooper DW. The Agouti gene: a positional candidate for recessive black in Australian Merino sheep. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 1999;50:1099–3. 40. Va˚ge ID, Klungland H, Lu D, Cone RD. Molecular and pharmacological characterization of dominant black coat color in sheep. Mammalian Genome 1999;10:39–43. 41. Cot HB. Adaptative Coloration in Animals. Methuen, London; 1940. 42. Bourlie`re F. The Natural History of Mammals. Harrap, London; 1955. 43. Lamotte M. Recherches sur la structure ge´ne´tique des populations naturelles de Cepaea nemoralis (L.). Bulletin Biologique de France et de Belgique 1951;Suppl. XXXV: 1–239. 44. Wilson J. The colours of highland cattle. Scientific Proceedings of the Royal Dublin Society 1909;12:66–76. 45. Berge S. Inheritance of dun, brown and brindle colour in cattle. Heredity 1949;5:195–204. 46. Zophoniasson P. Nogle Bemaerkninger om enkelte Arvelighedsforhold hos de islandske Faar. Nordisk Jordbruksforskning 1934;16:217–3. 47. Searle AG. Gene frequencies in London cats. Journal of Genetics 1949;49:214–0. 48. Mason IL. A World Dictionary of Breeds, Types and Varieties of Livestock. Technical Communication No. 8 of the Commonwealth Bureau of Animal Breeding and Genetics, Edinburgh Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux, Farnham House, Farnham Royal, Slough, Bucks., England; 1951. 49. Lauvergne JJ. Genetics in animal populations after domestication, the consequences for breed conservation. In: Proc. 2nd World Congress on Genetics applied to Livestock Production, Madrid, Volume 6; 1982. p. 77–87. 50. Lauvergne JJ. Breed development and breed differentiation. In: Proceedings CEC Workshop and Training Course, 7–9 December1992, Hannover. Commission of the European Communities, Agriculture, Brussels; 1993. p. 53–64. 51. Hardy GH. Mendelian proportion in a mixed population. Science 1908;28:49–50. 52. Weinberg W. U¨ber die Nachweis der Vererbung beim Menschen. Jahresb. Verein. Vaterl. Naturk. in Wu¨rttemberg 1908;64:368–82.
21
composition of Mendelian populations, and on natural selection. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society – Biology 1924;1:158–63. 55. Haldane JBS. A mathematical theory of natural and artificial selection. III. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1926;23:363–72. 56. Haldane JBS. A mathematical theory of natural and artificial selection. IV. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1926;23:607–15. 57. Haldane JBS. A mathematical theory of natural and artificial selection. V. Selection and mutation. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1927;23:838–44. 58. Adalsteinsson S. Colour inheritance in Icelandic sheep and relation between colour, fertility and fertilization. Journal of Agriculture Research Iceland 1970;2(1):3–135. 59. Ryder ML, Land RB. Coat colour inheritance in Soay, Orkney and Shetland sheep. Journal of Zoology London 1974;173:477–85. 60. Lauvergne JJ, Adalsteinsson S. Ge`nes pour la couleur de la toison de la brebis Corse. Annales de Ge´ne´tique et de Se´lection animale 1976;8:153–72. 61. Lauvergne JJ. Populations traditionnelles et premie`res races standardise´es d’Ovicaprinae dans le Bassin me´diterrane´en. Colloque INRA N 47 Gontard/Manosque France 30 juin–2 juillet 1986; 1988. 62. Khemici E, et al. Indice de primarite´ et diffe´renciation ge´ne´tique des populations caprines de la steppe (Arabia) et du de´sert (Mekatuatia) d’Alge´rie. Genetics Selection Evolution 1995;27:503–17. 63. Khemici E, et al. Etude des ressources ge´ne´tiques caprines de l’Alge´rie du nord a` l’aide des indices de primarite´. AGRI 1996;17:69–80. 64. Ozoje MO. Coat colour genes in West African dwarf sheep and goats: a theoretical appraisal. Proceedings of the Sixth World Congress on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production, Volume 26; 1998. p. 53–6. 65. Lauvergne JJ, Bourzat D, Souvenir Zafindrajaona P, Zeuh V, Ngo Tama AC. Indices de primarite´ de che`vres au Nord Cameroun et au Tchad. Revue d’Elevage et de Me´decine Veterinaire des Pays Tropicaux 1993;46:651–65. 66. Meutchieye F. Caracte´risation morphome´trique de la che`vre locale des hautes terres de l’Ouest Cameroun. The`se de Master of Science en Biotechnologie et Productions animales, option Ame´lioration ge´ne´tique et syste`mes de production, Universite´ de Dschang (Cameroun), Faculte´ d’Agronomie et des Sciences agricoles, De´partement des Productions animales; 2008. 67. du Toit D, editor. The Damara of Southern Africa. Dawie Du Toit, PO Box 141, Prieska 8940, South Africa; 2007. 68. Lundie RS. Coat colour genetics of the Damara sheep. In: du Toit D, editor. The Damara of Southern Africa. Dawie Du Toit, PO Box 141, Prieska 8940, South Africa; 2007. p. 38–122.
53. Haldane JBS. A mathematical theory of natural and artificial selection. I. Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 1924;23:19–41.
69. Sponenberg DP. Colour genetics and Damara sheep. In: du Toit D, editor. The Damara of Southern Africa. Dawie Du Toit, PO Box 141, Prieska 8940, South Africa; 2007. p. 28–37.
54. Haldane JBS. A mathematical theory of natural and artificial selection. II. The influence of partial self-fertilization, inbreeding, associative mating and selective fertilization on the
70. Vigne JD. Les origines de la culture: les de´buts de l’e´levage. Collection Le Colle`ge de la Cite´, Le Pommier et Cite´ des Sciences et de l’Industrie, Paris; 2004.
g
CAB International 2009
This page intentionally left blank
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Functional genomic approaches to understand the biological pathways underpinning intramuscular fat in beef L. Pannier1,2, R. M. Hamill1, A. M. Mullen1 and T. Sweeney2* Address: 1 Teagasc, Ashtown Food Research Centre, Ashtown, Dublin 15, Ireland. 2 School of Agriculture, Food Science and Veterinary Medicine, University College Dublin, Belfield, Dublin 4, Ireland. *Correspondence: Torres Sweeney. Fax: +35317166253. Email:
[email protected] Received: Accepted:
4 August 2009 20 November 2009
Abstract Meat quality traits, such as intramuscular fat level, have a heritable component and are quantitative in nature, being influenced by many genes of variable individual effects. The identification of the genetic variation associated with meat quality is an important step towards the improvement of meat quality in livestock selection programmes and meat management systems. Functional genomic approaches relate the static information of variation in genomic regions and individual genes with the dynamic interplay of gene expression pathways and biological processes. Therefore, through the application of functional genomic tools, researchers are gaining deeper insights into the biological pathways underpinning meat quality. Knowledge gained from these approaches can be beneficial in defining and optimizing management systems for quality, providing assurance of meat quality and in tailoring quality to suit market needs. Keywords: Functional genomics, Genetic markers, Bovine genome, Single nucleotide polymorphisms Review Methodology: This review paper was established by researching several databases such as PubMed, NCBI and Science Direct. Conference proceedings such as International Conference of Meat Science and Technology (ICoMST) and the European Association of Animal Production (EAAP) meetings, as well as CABI and Woodhead published books were used for information and references. In addition to this, advice and unpublished work from collaborating partners and colleagues was collected.
Intramuscular Fat (IMF) The concept of meat quality has been defined in many ways, from safety through to sensory experience [1]. Palatability traits include juiciness, flavour and tenderness. While consumers maintain an increasing desire for these traits, they are increasingly seeking lower fat/healthier options in food choices [2]. In beef, these consumer drivers are linked through the level of IMF [2], also subjectively assessed as marbling [3]. IMF has been shown to contribute 10–15% of the variance in palatability [4], which can be compromised if the fat content is less than 3%, but is enhanced as IMF levels increase from 3 to 6% [5]. Juiciness and flavour tend to increase with increased IMF content. Fat can affect juiciness in a number of ways: (1) by enhancing the water holding capacity of meat, (2) by
g
lubricating muscle fibres during cooking and (3) by stimulating the salivary glands during mastication [5]. Fat has also been identified as one of the major components of the meat flavour lexicon [6]. When meat is cooked, the lipid components (principally triglycerides) melt and along with other meat constituents (amino acids and reducing sugars) undergo a series of thermally induced reactions, which form flavour compounds. This is known as the Maillard reaction [7]. Fat is a precursor of a large number of flavour compounds, such as aldehydes and ketones, and it contributes to undesired (e.g. rancidity) as well as desired tastes and aromas [7]. There is conflicting evidence on the precise nature of the relationship between fat content and tenderness. Some evidence is available that IMF increases meat tenderness [8], but other studies suggests that it has a negative effect [9, 10]. The relationship between those
CAB International 2009
24
Animal Science Reviews 2010
two aspects of quality is thought to be indirect [11] and an earlier study estimated that marbling explains just 5% of the variation in beef tenderness [12]. IMF clearly has an important influence on palatability given its specific contribution to juiciness, flavour and possibly tenderness [12–14]. Furthermore, IMF is integrated in most industry grading systems and it is an important determinant of carcass value for certain markets such as Japan, where Japanese Black cattle are highly regarded for their higher marbling characteristics [15, 16]. Hence, in this review paper, we will discuss recent molecular research focused on increasing our understanding of the genetic component of IMF and review progress towards the identification of biological pathways controlling IMF in the bovine. Genetic Control of IMF in the Bovine Genome Considerable progress has been achieved towards the goal of placing whole genome sequences and associated genomic tools into the public domain for high-priority domestic animal species. Today, the complete draft of the bovine genome has been released [17, 18] and is free to public access on different databases such as NCBI (www. ncbi.nih.gov/Genbank) and EMBL (www.ebi.ac.uk/embl/ index.html). The bovine genome contains approximately 2.87 billion base pairs and at least 22 000 protein-encoding genes [19]. Gene annotations are being continuously updated, e.g. by construction of a gene atlas of expressed transcript tags in up to 100 tissues [20]. Quantitative Trait Loci (QTLs) Most production and meat quality traits are complex traits, influenced by many genes with variable effects [21, 22]. While environmental factors such as nutrition have an influence, a significant proportion of this variation is influenced by the genetic potential of the animal. Because of the consumer’s demand for high and consistent quality of beef, researchers are aiming to develop DNA markers of beef quality and to increase the understanding of muscle biology [23, 24]. Through mapping studies, genomic regions (QTLs) have been associated with meat quality [25]. Polymorphic markers are used to detect regions on a chromosome that have a substantial effect on quantitative traits and include restriction or amplified fragment length polymorphism (RFLP or AFLP) markers, microsatellites, single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and/or expressed sequence tags (ESTs) to map genes to large chromosomal regions which may contain hundreds of genes [24–26]. QTLs for marbling have been identified and are shown in Table 1 [25, 27, 28]. There are a number of drawbacks to the QTL mapping approach. Firstly, it can fail to detect trait loci with small effects and secondly large pedigrees with good phenotypic and genotypic data are required. Consequently, the
g
Table 1
QTLs for beef IMF/marbling
BTA
Literature
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 13 14 16 17 18 20 21 23 26 27 29
[29–31] [32–34] [35, 36] [29, 33] [36–38] [38, 39] [32] [33, 38, 40] [32, 33, 38] [35] [33, 41] [34] [42] [31] [38] [36, 38] [33] [31] [33] [42, 31]
BTA, Bos taurus autosome.
identification of QTLs for many traits including meat quality has proven to be quite slow and in reality many studies lack power due to insufficient sample sizes [25].
Polymorphisms in Candidate Genes The ultimate goal of functional genomics analysis is to identify the causative polymorphisms controlling variation in meat quality traits. Two different approaches have been used to identify candidate genes for further exploration. These are: (1) genes underlying particular QTL regions and (2) genes involved in biological pathways hypothesized to regulate a trait of interest. Sequencing phenotypically divergent individuals at candidate gene loci has led to the identification of mutations, most of which are SNPs. These SNPs can influence the level of transcription of the gene or the amino acid structure of the transcribed protein. SNPs have been associated with numerous meatquality-related traits including tenderness [43, 44], waterholding capacity [45], colour [46], muscular hypertrophy [47] and growth rate [48]. SNPs in candidate genes associated with IMF/marbling scores and fat-related traits are presented in Table 2. With a view to uncovering the molecular basis of IMF deposition, research has focused on a number of candidate genes based on their major regulatory roles in pathways associated with triglyceride synthesis, adipose differentiation and fatty acid metabolism. Some of these are outlined below. The leptin gene, also known as the obese gene, encodes a 16 kDa peptide hormone, which is synthesized and secreted mainly from white adipocytes [72]. Leptin acts both centrally and peripherally and regulates adiposity, food intake, energy expenditure, body weight and overall
CAB International 2009
L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney
25
Table 2 Overview of association studies of DNA markers for IMF, marbling score and fat related traits Marker
BTA
EDG1 RORC BM 1500 Leptin
3 3 4 4
CSSM34
5
ETH10
5
AFABP
14
BMS1747 CBFA2T1 CSSM66
14 14 14
DGAT1
14
DECR1 TG
14 14
FASN
19
GH1
19
FGF8 SCD
26 26
Association study
Literature
Association detected
Marbling breeding value in Japanese Black cattle Marbling scores in a Bos taurus population Marbling scores in purebred Angus, Charolais, Simmental and Hereford Increased fat deposition in purebred Angus, Charolais and Hereford IMF content in commercial cattle Fat and lean yield in commercial cattle IMF content in commercial cattle IMF and marbling score in cross-bred bull calves (HolsteinCharolais) Marbling scores in offspring of Angus and Shorthorn sires Marbling scores in offspring of Wagyu sires Marbling scores in offspring of Wagyu sires Marbling scores in offspring of Angus and Shorthorn sires Marbling score in a WagyuLimousin F2 population IMF content in commercial cattle Marbling scores in Angus and Shorthorn cattle Ultrasound marbling scores in Angus, Charolais and cross-bred cattle Marbling scores in offspring of Wagyu sires Marbling scores in offspring of Angus and Schorthorn sires Marbling scores in Angus and Shorthorn cattle IMF in German Holstein cattle Marbling score in Bos indicus cattle Backfat levels in B. taurus cattle IMF content in commercial cattle Milk fat content in dairy cattle Ultrasound backfat in Angus, Charolais and cross-bred cattle Marbling scores in offspring of Angus and Shorthorn sires Marbling scores in Angus and Shorthorn cattle IMF in German Holstein cattle Marbling score on a B. taurus population Backfat levels in B. taurus cattle Marbling score on a B. indicus population IMF content in commercial cattle Marbling score in purebred cattle Milk fat content in Holstein cattle Fatty acid composition of IMF in Japanese Black cattle Fatty acid composition of longissimus dorsi muscle in purebred Angus bulls Fatty acid composition of adipose tissue and milk fat in B. taurus cattle Marbling scores in Japanese Black cattle Marbling scores in Angus and Shorthorn cattle Carcass backfat in Angus, Charolais and cross-bred cattle MUFA content and melting point of IMF in Wagyu cattle
[15, 16] [49] [50] [51] [52] [52] [53] [54] [55] [55] [55] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [55] [55] [58] [60] [61] [41] [57] [62] [59] [55] [58] [60] [63] [41] [61] [57] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [59] [71]
Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes No No Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
BTA, Bos taurus autosome.
metabolism [73]. Because of leptin’s close location to microsatellite locus BM1500 [74], which was associated with fat measurements in beef bulls [50], the gene was hypothesized to influence fat-related traits in cattle [51, 54]. A number of other SNPs have been reported in the bovine leptin gene, both in the coding region [51, 54, 75] and in the promoter region [48, 76]. Numerous association studies have been carried out with these SNPs, not only for IMF or marbling levels (Table 2) but also for diverse meat quality traits. Polymorphisms have also been associated with fat deposition [51], feed intake [48, 54], fat and lean yield [52], quality and yield [77], milk
g
fat yield [76], milk yield [78] and average daily gain [48]. However, in some cases, where a different population was studied or different sample sizes used, these associations could not be replicated [53, 54, 77, 79, 80]. The thyroglobulin (TG) gene is a precursor molecule of the thyroid hormones that are known to affect adipocyte differentiation and lipid metabolism. The TG gene became a positional candidate gene for marbling after 0 the association of an SNP in the untranslated 5 region with marbling score, and is the source of a commercially available DNA test marker [81, 82]. However, conflicting results concerning its effect on marbling in beef cattle
CAB International 2009
26
Animal Science Reviews 2010
exist [60, 61, 63, 81, 83]. Recently, novel bovine SNPs 0 have been identified in the 3 flanking region of the TG gene and an association was found between several of those SNPs and marbling score [64]. The diacylglycerol O-acyltransferase (DGAT1) gene codes for a microsomal enzyme that catalyses the final step of the triglyceride synthesis pathway [84]. Studies have indicated that mice lacking both copies of DGAT1 are completely devoid of milk secretion, most likely because of deficient triglyceride synthesis in the mammary gland [85]. Few SNPs were identified in the DGAT1 gene [62], with the most studied being a dinucleotide polymorphism in exon 8 which causes a lysine (K) to alanine (A) amino acid exchange at position 232 of the predicted protein [86]. Significantly higher levels of IMF were identified in musculus semitendinosus in purebred German Holstein cattle for this polymorphism [60], but no significant association with marbling score was observed in Bos indicus cattle [61]. The Adipocyte Fatty Acid Binding Protein (AFABP) gene codes for adipocyte fatty acid binding protein which is expressed almost exclusively in adipocytes [87] and is involved in the intracellular targeting of fatty acids [88]. The importance of AFABP for IMF deposition has been confirmed by several independent studies [89, 90] and few SNPs have been identified which have a significant association with marbling score and subcutaneous fat depth [56] and back fat traits [91]. Other candidate genes for IMF include: the sterol regulatory element binding protein-1 (SREBP-1), stearoylCoA desaturase (SCD) gene, fatty acid synthase (FASN) gene and the retinoid-related orphan receptor gamma (RORC) gene. They are considered important because of their related functions in fatty acid metabolism in cattle. SREBP-1 belongs to group of transcription factors that play a central role in energy homeostasis by promoting glycolysis, lipogenesis and adipogenesis [92, 93]. A deletion mutation in this gene contributed to a higher monounsaturated fatty acid (MUFA) proportion and lower melting point in IMF tissue in Japanese Black cattle [92]. The SCD gene located on BTA26 codes for SCD, which is the enzyme responsible for the conversion of saturated fatty acids into MUFA in mammalian adipocytes. It was proposed as a candidate gene for variation in fatty acid composition because of its role in fatty acid oxidation and several SNPs in the gene have been identified [71]. Associations between SNP genotypes and MUFA percentage and melting point of IMF were determined in Japanese Black cattle [71]. The FASN gene, mapped to BTA19 [68, 94], plays a role in de novo biosynthesis of long-chain fatty acids and lipogenesis in mammals [95]. Several SNPs on this gene have been identified by various independent studies and have been associated with milk fat content in Holstein–Friesian cattle [65] and with the fatty acid composition of IMF [66], longissimus dorsi muscle [67] and adipose fat and milk fat [68]. The RORC gene is a member of the steroid and thyroid hormone
g
receptor superfamily [96, 97] and binds retinoic acid as well as thyroid hormone. The gene is highly expressed in skeletal muscle [98] and associations between intronic and exonic alleles in the RORC gene and marbling score have been identified [49]. Furthermore, other genes which might affect fatness in cattle, are located in QTL regions on BTA3 [32–34, 99–101], these include the phosphatidylinositol 4-kinase (PIK4CB) [102], AMP-activated protein kinase b-2 subunit (PRKAB2) [103] and endothelial differentiation sphingolipid G-protein-coupled receptor 1 gene (EDG1) [15, 16]. Recently, an AFLP-based genome-wide scan has led to the direct identification of a novel candidate gene associated with fat metabolism, i.e. the mitochondrial poly A polymerase gene (PAPD1), SNPs in which were subsequently found to contribute to extreme fat deposition in cattle [104, 105]. While progress has been made by using the candidate gene approach, the necessity of prior knowledge of the physiological and biological pathways of the candidate genes, the time in evaluating all genes potentially involved in a given trait, plus the potential contributions of yet uncharacterized genes and biological pathways have hindered progress.
DNA SNP Arrays, Genome-Wide Association Studies and Genomic Selection Today, progress in the bovine genome sequencing project [19] and associated SNPs discovery efforts [106, 107] has resulted in the identification of hundreds of thousands of SNPs in all major breeds of cattle. Based on this research, a number of high-throughput SNP genotyping platforms have been developed including the Affymetrix GeneChip1 Bovine 10 and 25 K SNP chips featuring respectively 10 and 25 000 SNPs and the Illumina Infinium1 Bovine SNP50 BeadChipä genotyping system, which permits interrogation of more than 54 000 SNPs evenly spaced throughout the genome. Larger chips are in development and to give an indication of the ultimate potential of bovine chips for fine mapping, human chips containing more than 1 million SNPs (e.g. Human1M-Duo BeadChip, www.illumina.com) are currently available. Hence, higher-throughput platforms for the bovine are likely to be available in the near future. One of the major applications of these arrays is in whole-genome association (WGA) studies. Chips are currently being applied to identify genomic regions influential in relation to numerous economically important traits in livestock, including fertility, growth, milk production, reproduction, disease susceptibility and meat quality [108, 109]. Marker density is very important in determining the power to detect markers in linkage disequilibrium with causative SNPs and this depends on the extent of linkage disequilibrium in the genome. In cattle, linkage disequilibrium is quite extensive; however,
CAB International 2009
L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney
achieving high power to identify specific variation influential on quantitative traits may require upwards of 100 000 SNPs [25]. A second major application of these markers lies in the enhancement of breeding programmes, via markerassisted or genomic selection [110, 111]. Genomic selection refers to the making of selection decisions based on genomic estimated breeding values (gEBV). These are calculated as the sum of the effects of dense genetic markers, or haplotypes of these markers, across the entire genome. This can potentially capture the effects of all QTLs that contribute to trait variation, even if their individual contribution is small [111, 112]. In order to calculate gEBV, a large reference population is first genotyped and fully phenotyped and subsequently the genotype effects on the trait of interest are estimated. In subsequent generations, animals can be genotyped at birth to identify the chromosome regions they have inherited. Using this information, by summing the marker effects across the whole genome, gEBV can be estimated. Simulations have shown that EBV could be predicted with an accuracy of 0.85 from marker data alone, where markers are in high linkage disequilibrium with causative mutations [111]. Advantages of genomic selection include dramatic increases in the accuracy of EBV estimates, a more balanced approach to selection across traits, increased ability to select dams and decreases in generation interval and cost of progeny testing. Challenges include achieving sufficient numbers of genotyped and phenotyped individuals, accounting for breed and family structure, the potential for loss of linkage disequilibrium between marker and trait over time and the development of appropriate statistical methods [110]. Genome-wide selection requires a large set of DNA markers, hence is becoming feasible with larger SNP chips [113]. While the approach needs to be robustly tested and validated in multiple populations, it is expected to increase the rate of genetic improvement two-fold per year in many livestock systems [112]. The increased application of high-density chips for livestock animals has the potential to revolutionize production methods in breeding, husbandry and nutrition, to improve beef quality and to produce differentiated products [23]. Genomic selection is already being applied to dairy cattle breeding programmes around the world [110, 113–116]. Meat quality traits such as IMF and tenderness have moderate or low heritabilities and can currently only be measured in a research setting. For these reasons, substantial genetic progress for important meat quality traits via WGA and genomic selection approaches is likely to be viable as long as appropriate methodologies are applied [25].
Gene Expression Expression arrays allow the detection of genes that are actively transcribing at a given time point. The
g
27
transcription rate of genes related to meat quality can be affected by endogenous factors such as cell type and stage of development as well as environmental factors such as nutrition, growth rate, handling and post-mortem changes [27, 117–119].
Gene Expression Techniques Traditional gene expression measurement techniques included northern blotting, slot and dot blotting and more recently, quantitative real-time PCR. These techniques have identified a number of individual genes associated with IMF levels in meat [90, 120, 121]. More recently, techniques have progressed to transcriptome-wide approaches, including suppressive subtractive hybridization (SSH) [122, 123], differential display [124, 125], serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) [126], microarray hybridization [127–129] and next-generation cyclic array sequencing approaches which incorporate library construction, in vitro amplification by e.g. emulsion PCR and iterative cycles of enzymatic synthesis and array imaging and analysis [130]. One of the widely applied technologies for exploring pathways underpinning meat quality and in particular, IMF, has been RNA expression microarray technology. This technology allows the simultaneous analysis of thousands of genes in a single experiment. This contrasts with ‘single gene’ studies where throughput is very limited. Two types of microarrays, spotted cDNA arrays and oligonucleotide arrays, are most commonly used for gene expression profiling. Commercial oligonucleotide arrays are now available for different domestic animal genomes (bovine, porcine, mouse, rat and chicken). For instance, the Affymetrix GeneChip1 Bovine Genome Array contains 24 027 probes sets which can be used to study gene expression of over 23 000 bovine transcripts. Given the complex nature of expression data, statistical refinement through bioinformatics is crucial. Bioinformatics tools such as Genomatix Bibliosphere Pathway Edition (www. genomatix.de/) or PANTHER classification system permit enhanced interpretation of the biological process and metabolic pathways involved. This further data mining can provide more information regarding the complex interplay of gene networks and their regulation by transcription factors [131].
Application of Microarrays to Enhance our Understanding of IMF Development Microarrays have been used to examine gene expression profiles in animals divergent in meat quality traits (Table 3). A cDNA microarray comprising 1915 bovine ESTs and 7291 anonymous cDNAs clones from bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA libraries [144] has been used in several breed and developmental stage
CAB International 2009
28
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Table 3 Bovine meat quality expression studies Array
Identification of differentially expressed genes
Literature
Bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA array Bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA array Bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA array Bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA array Bovine skeletal muscle and fat cDNA array Bovine skeletal muscle, fat and liver cDNA array Bovine 0.5 K muscle cDNA array Bovine mixed tissue cDNA microarray Bovine mixed tissue cDNA microarray Bovine mixed tissue cDNA microarray Human and murine oligonucleotide array Human and murine oligonucleotide array
between Brahman steers fed with different diets
[132]
of Brahman and Brahman composite steers fed on different feeding regimes
[133]
between Japanese Black and Holstein cattle
[134]
between foetuses from WagyuHereford and PiedmonteseHereford crosses
[135]
between muscle biopsies from WagyuHereford and PiedmonteseHereford crosses taken at five different time points between different muscle samples in Korean cattle
[136]
between high IMF and low IMF longissimus samples of cross-bred cattle
[138]
between skeletal muscle samples of Polish Black and White bulls between 6 and 12 months of life between 12-month-old bulls of four cattle breeds
[139]
0
[137]
[140]
in Holstein–Friesian bulls carrying a polymorphism in the 5 -flanking region of the mstn gene between normal and double-muscled cattle
[141]
between beef meat cuts differing in tenderness, juiciness and flavour
[143]
comparative studies. When foetuses from both Wagyu Herford crosses were compared with foetuses from PiedmonteseHereford crosses, 82 differentially expressed genes were detected according to the breed of the foetus sire [135]. The most marked increase or decrease in gene expression was observed between day 195 of foetal development and birth [135]. The majority of changes in gene expression in foetal longisimus muscle comprised structural and metabolic components of extracellular matrix and muscle fibres. Although IMF is a latedeveloping fat depot, this microarray study identified a number of genes associated with adipogenesis/lipogenesis (e.g. FABP4 and FABP5) to be already differentially expressed according to sire in early developmental stages and confirms that the cellular development of adipocytes is fixed relatively early in life. The same array was used to study and investigate differential gene expression in the longisimus muscle of Japanese Black (characterized with high IMF levels) and Holstein cattle at 11.5 months of age [134]. The results indicated that at 11 months of age, the genes associated with adipogenesis, mono-unsaturated fatty acid synthesis and fatty acid accumulation were highly expressed in Japanese Black cattle. A heterologous microarray (human and murine oligonucleotides sequences) of around 6000 genes expressed in muscle was used to identify genes that were differentially expressed between double-muscled (hypertrophy) and normal animals in the semitendinosus muscle [142]. Double-muscled animals are characterized by leaner carcasses with less fat. Several differentially expressed genes were identified (MEF2A, ID1, ZFX1B, MyoD1, RPL28 and
g
[142]
CoLIAI) which are involved in several physiological processes of muscle tissue development at 260 days of foetal development. The authors concluded that the biological trait of double-muscling is associated with specific gene profiles at the time of fibre differentiation and/or specialization in late foetuses. For example, there was a decrease of collagen (COL1A1 and COL1A2) gene expression of late-stage bovine foetuses carrying the myosin mutation. Recently, a cDNA microarray was developed consisting of 448 genes and ESTs derived from an SSH library for IMF, tenderness and drip loss, plus 100 candidate genes from the literature. Thirty-eight genes were identified as being differentially expressed (e.g. ATP synthase F0 subunit 6, ACADVL, MRLC2 and Collagen type I) between two groups phenotypically divergent for IMF level [138].
Conclusions Major advances are occurring in functional genomics tools that will accelerate the acquisition of the pathways underpinning meat quality, in particular IMF, and it is clear that these will ultimately provide a mechanism to control quality for the consumer. A wealth of DNA SNP and RNA expression data are being generated experimentally through breed, nutritional status and developmental studies as well as studies focused on individual variation in meat quality. In order to develop a holistic systems biology approach to the understanding of IMF in beef, there is, however, an urgent need for the continuing development of the bioinformatical platforms to facilitate
CAB International 2009
L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney
the effective integration of DNA SNP data and RNA expression data.
29
G-protein-coupled receptor 1 gene with marbling in Japanese Black beef cattle. Animal Genetics 2009;40:209–16. 16. Yamada T, Sasaki S, Sukegawa S, Miyake T, Fujita T, 0 Kose H, et al. Novel SNP in 5 flanking region of EDG1 associated with marbling in Japanese Black beef cattle. Animal Science Journal 2009;80:486–9.
References 1. Hocquette JF, Gigli S. The challenge of quality. In: Hocquette JF, Gigli S, editors. Indicators of Milk and Beef Quality. EAAP publication No. 112. Wageningen Academic Publishers, The Netherlands; 2005. p. 13–22. 2. Harper GS, Pethick DW. Fatness in production animals: using genetic and environmental levers to meet consumer demand. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2004;13:37. 3. Harper GS, Pethick DW. How might marbling begin? Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:653–62. 4. Dikeman ME. Fat reduction in animals and the effect on palatability and consumer acceptance of meat products. In: Proceedings of the 40th Annual Reciprocal Meat Conference; Chicago, USA. National Livestock and Meat Board, Chicago, IL; 1987. p. 93–103. 5. Savell JW, Cross HR. The role of fat in the palatability of beef, pork, and lamb. In: Farrell DJ, editor. Designing Foods: Animal Product Options in the Marketplace. National Academy Press, Washington, DC; 1988. p. 345. 6. Johnsen PB, Civille GV. A standardized lexicon of meat WOF descriptors. Journal of Sensory Studies 1986;1:99–104. 7. Shahidi F. Lipid-derived flavors in meat products. In: Kerry J, Ledward D, editors. Meat Processing: Improving Meat Quality. Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge, UK; 2002. p. 105–21. 8. D’Souza DND, Mullan BP. The effect of genotype, sex and management strategy on the eating quality of pork. Meat Science 2002;60:95–101. 9. Romans JR, Tuma HJ, Tucker WL. Influence of carcass maturity and marbling on the physical and chemical characteristics of beef. Journal of Animal Science 1965;24:681–5. 10. Kipfmu¨ller H, Bodis K, Peschke W, Eichinger HM. Qualita¨t von Schweinefleisch. Erna¨hrung-Umschau 2000;47:416–22.
17. Liu Y, Qin X, Song XZH, Jiang H, Shen Y, Durbin KJ, et al. Bos taurus genome assembly. BMC Genomics 2009;10:180. 18. Zimin AV, Delcher AL, Florea L, Kelley DR, Schatz MC, Puiu D, et al. A whole-genome assembly of the domestic cow, Bos taurus. Genome Biology 2009;10(4):R42. 19. Elsik CG, Tellam RL, Worley KC, The Bovine Genome Sequencing and Analysis Consortium. The genome sequence of Taurine cattle: a window to ruminant biology and evolution. Science 2009;324:522–8. 20. Sonstegard TS, Keele JW, Harhay GP, Smith TPL, Matukumalli LK, Liu G, et al. Creation of a gene atlas in cattle using sequence-based transcriptional profiling. Journal of Animal Science 2007;85:415–415. 21. Williams JL. The use of marker assisted selection in animal breeding and biotechnology. Scientific and Technical Review, Office International Des Epizooties 2005;24:379–91. 22. Andersson L, Georges M. Domestic animal genomics: deciphering the genetics of complex traits. Nature Reviews Genetics 2004;5:202–12. 23. Hocquette JF, Lehnert S, Barendse W, Cassar-Malek I, Picard B. Recent advances in cattle functional genomics and their application to beef quality. Animal 2007;1:159–73. 24. Gao Y, Zhang R, Hu X, Li N. Application of genomic technologies to the improvement of meat quality of farm animals. Meat Science 2007;77:36–45. 25. Allan MF, Smith TPL. Present and future applications of DNA technologies to improve beef production. Meat Science 2008;80:79–85. 26. Eggen A, Hocquette JF. Genomic approaches to economic trait loci and tissue expression profiling: application to muscle biochemistry and beef quality. Meat Science 2004;66:1–9.
11. Miller RK. Factors affecting the quality of raw meat. In: Kerry J, Kerry J, Ledward D, editors. Meat Processing: Improving Meat Quality. Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge, UK; 2002. p. 27–63.
27. Ku¨hn C, Leveziel H, Renand G, Goldammer T, Schwerin M, Williams JL. Genetic markers for beef quality. In: Hocquette JF, Gigli S, editors. Indicators of Milk and Beef Quality. EAAP publication No. 112. Wageningen Academic Publishers, The Netherlands; 2005. p. 23–31.
12. Wheeler TL, Cundiff LV, Koch RM. Effect of marbling degree on beef palatability in Bos taurus and Bos indicus cattle. Journal of Animal Science 1994;72:3145–51.
28. Polineni P, Aragonda P, Xavier SR, Furuta R, Adelson DL. The bovine QTL viewer: a web accessible database of bovine quantitative trait loci. BMC Bioinformatics 2006;7:283.
13. Neeley TR, Lorenzen CL, Miller RK, Tatum JD, Wise JW, Taylor JF, et al. Beef customer satisfaction: role of cut, USDA quality grade, and city on in-home consumer ratings. Journal of Animal Science 1998;76:1027–32.
29. Stone RT, Keele JW, Shackelford SD, Kappes SM, Koohmaraie M. A primary screen of the bovine genome for quantitative trait loci affecting carcass and growth traits. Journal of Animal Science 1999;77:1379–84.
14. Thompson JM. The effects of marbling on flavour and juiciness scores of cooked beef, after adjusting to a constant tenderness. Australian Journal of experimental Agriculture 2004;44:645–52.
30. Schimpf RJ, Winkelman-sim DC, Buchanan FC, Aalhus JL, Plante Y, Schmutz SM. QTL for marbling maps to cattle chromosome 2. In: Proceedings of the 27th International Conference on Animal Genetics, 22–26 July 2000, Minneapolis, USA; 2000. p. 48, abstract number B103.
15. Yamada T, Itoh M, Nishimura S, Taniguchi Y, Miyake T, Sasaki S, et al. Association of single nucleotide polymorphisms in the endothelial differentiation sphingolipid
g
31. MacNeil MD, Grosz MD. Genome-wide scans for QTL affecting carcass traits in Herefordcomposite double
CAB International 2009
30
Animal Science Reviews 2010 backcross populations. Journal of Animal Sciences 2002;80:2316–24.
32. Casas E, Stone RT, Keele JW, Shackleford SD, Kappes SM, Koohmaraie M. A comprehensive search for quantitative trait loci affecting growth and carcass composition of cattle segregating alternative forms of the myostatin gene. Journal of Animal Science 2001;79:854–60. 33. Casas E, Shackelford SD, Keele JW, Koohmaraie M, Smith TP, Stone RT. Detection of quantitative trait loci for growth and carcass composition in cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2003;81:2976–83. 34. Casas E, Keele JW, Shackelford SD, Koohmaraie M, Stone RT. Identification of quantitative trait loci for growth and carcass composition in cattle. Animal Genetics 2004;35:2–6. 35. Mizoshita K, Mizoshita T, Watanabe T, Hayashi H, Kubota C, Yamakuchi H, et al. Quantitative trait loci analysis for growth and carcass traits in a half-sib family of purebred Japanese Black (Wagyu) cattle. Journal of Animal Sciences 2004;82(12):3415–20. 36. Mizoguchi Y, Watanabe T, Fujinaka K, Iwamoto E, Sugimoto Y. Mapping of quantitative trait loci for carcass traits in a Japanese black (Wagyu) cattle population. Animal Genetics 2006;37(1):51–4. 37. Kim JJ, Farnir F, Savell J, Taylor JF. Detection of quantitative trait loci for growth and beef carcass fatness traits in a cross between Bos taurus (Angus) and Bos indicus (Brahman) cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2003;81(8):1933–42. 38. Takasuga A, Watanabe T, Mizoguchi Y, Hirano T, Ihara N, Takano A, et al. Identification of bovine QTL for growth and carcass traits in Japanese Black cattle by replication and identical-by-descent mapping. Mammalian Genome 2007;18(2):125–36. 39. Hirano T, Watanabe T, Inoue K, Sugimoto Y. Fine-mapping of a marbling trait to a 2.9-cM region on bovine chromosome 7 in Japanese black cattle. Animal Genetics 2008;39(1):79–83. 40. Imai K, Matsughige T, Watanabe T, Sugimoto Y, Ihara N. Mapping of a quantitative trait locus for beef marbling on bovine chromosome 9 in purebred Japanese black cattle. Animal Biotechnology 2007;18(2):75–80. 41. Moore SS, Li C, Basarab J, Snelling WM, Kneeland J, Murdoch B, et al. Fine mapping of quantitative trait loci and assessment of positional candidate genes for backfat on bovine chromosome 14 in a commercial line of Bos taurus. Journal of Animal Science 2003;81:1919–25. 42. Casas E, Shackleford SD, Keele JW, Stone RT, Kappes SM, Koohmaraie M. Quantitative trait loci affecting growth and carcass composition of cattle segregating alternate forms of myostatin. Journal of Animal Science 2000;78:560–9. 43. Page BT, Casas ER, Quaas L, Thallman RM, Wheeler TL, Shackelford SD, et al. Association of markers in the bovine CAPN1 gene with meat tenderness in large crossbred populations that sample influential industry sires. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:3474–81. 44. Casas E, White SN, Wheeler TL, Shackelford SD, Koohmaraie M, Riley DG, et al. Effects of calpastatin and m-calpain markers in beef cattle on tenderness traits. Journal of Animal Science 2006;84:520–5. 45. Hamill RM, Reardon W, Aslan O, Sweeney T, Mullen AM. Association of single nucleotide polymorphisms in candidate
g
genes with meat quality in crossbred cattle. In: Book of Abstracts of the Third International Symposium on Animal Functional Genomics, 7–9 April 2008, Edinburgh, Scotland; 2008. p. 61. 46. Amills M, Vidal O, Varona L, Toma`s A, Gil M, Sa`nchez A, et al. Polymorphism of the pig 2,4-dienoyl CoA reductase 1 gene (DECR1) and its association with carcass and meat quality traits. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:493–8. 47. Kambadur R, Sharma M, Smith TP, Bass JJ. Mutations in myostatin (GDF8) in double-muscled Belgian Blue and Piedmontese cattle. Genome Research 1997;7(9):910–5. 48. Nkrumah JD, Li C, Yu J, Hansen C, Keisler DH, Moore SS. Polymorphisms in the bovine leptin promoter associated with serum leptin concentration, growth, feed intake, feeding behaviour, and measures of carcass merit. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:20–8. 49. Barendse W, Bunch RJ, Kijas JW, Thomas MB. The effect of genetic variation of the retinoic acid receptor-related orphan receptor C Gene on fatness in cattle. Genetics 2007;175:843–53. 50. Fitzsimmons CJ, Schmutz S, Bergen RD, McKinnon JJ. A potential association between the BM 1500 microsatellite and fat deposition in beef cattle. Mammalian Genome 1998;9:432–4. 51. Buchanan FC, Fitzsimmons CJ, Van Kessel AG, Thue TD, Winkelman-Sim DC, Schmutz SM. Association of a missense mutation in the bovine leptin gene with carcass fat content and leptin mRNA levels. Genetics Selection Evolution 2002;34:105–16. 52. Schenkel FS, Miller SP, Ye X, Moore SS, Nkrumah JD, Li C, et al. Association of single nucleotide polymorphisms in the leptin gene with carcass and meat quality traits of beef cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:2009–20. 53. Pannier L, Sweeney T, Hamill RM, Ipek F, Stapleton PC, Mullen AM. Lack of an association between single nucleotide polymorphisms in the bovine leptin gene and intramuscular fat in Bos taurus cattle. Meat Science 2009;81:731–7. 54. Lagonigro R, Wiener P, Pilla F, Woolliams JA, Williams JL. A new mutation in the coding region of the bovine leptin gene associated with feed intake. Animal Genetics 2003;34:371–4. 55. Barendse WJ. Assessing lipid metabolism. International Patent Publication WO 99/23248. 1999. 56. Michal JJ, Zhang ZW, Gaskins CT, Jiang Z. The bovine fatty acid binding protein 4 gene is significantly associated with marbling and subcutaneous fat depth in WagyuLimousin F2 crosses. Animal Genetics 2006;37:400–2. 57. Pannier L, Stapleton P, Mullen AM, Hamill R, Sweeney T. Assessment of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in genes on bovine chromosome 14 in association with intramuscular fat (IMF) in beef. In: Book of Abstracts of the 58th Annual Meeting of the European Association for Animal Production, 26–29 August 2007, Dublin, Ireland; 2007. p. 38. 58. Barendse W, Bunch R, Thomas M, Armitage S, Baud S, Donaldson N. The TG5 thyroglobulin gene test for a marbling quantitative trait loci evaluated in feedlot cattle. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:669–74.
CAB International 2009
L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney 59. Marques E, Nkrumah JD, Sherman EL, Moore SS. Polymorphisms in positional candidate genes on BTA14 and BTA26 affect carcass quality in beef cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2009;87:2475–84. 60. Thaller G, Ku¨hn C, Winter A, Ewald G, Bellman O, Wegner J, et al. DGAT1, a new positional and functional candidate gene for intramuscular fat deposition in cattle. Animal Genetics 2003;34:354–7. 61. Casas E, White SN, Riley DG, Smith TPL, Brenneman RA, Olson TA, et al. Assessment of single nucleotide polymorphisms in genes residing on chromosome 14 and 29 for association with carcass composition traits in Bos indicus cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:13–19. 62. Winter A, Kra¨mer W, Werner FAO, Kollers S, Kata S, Durstewitz G, et al. Association of a lysine-232/alanine polymorphism in a bovine gene encoding acyl CoA:diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT) with variation at a quantitative trait locus for milk fat content. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 2002;99:9300–5. 63. Rincker CB, Pyatt NA, Berger LL, Faulkner DB. Relationship among GeneSTAR marbling marker, intramuscular fat deposition, and expected progeny differences in early weaned Simmental steers. Journal of Animal Science 2006;84:686–93. 64. Gan QF, Zhang LP, Li JY, Hou GY, Li HD, Gao X, et al. Association analysis of thyroglobulin gene variants with carcass and meat quality traits in beef cattle. Journal of Applied Genetics 2008;49:251–5. 65. Roy R, Ordovas L, Zaragoza P, Romero A, Moreno C, Altarriba J, et al. Association of polymorphisms in the bovine FASN gene with milk-fat content. Animal Genetics 2006;37:215–8. 66. Abe T, Saburi J, Hasebe H, Nakagawa T, Misumi S, Nade T, et al. novel mutations of the FASN gene and their effect on fatty acid composition in Japanese Black beef. Biochemical Genetics 2009;47:397–411. 67. Zhang S, Knight TJ, Reecy JM, Beitz DC. DNA polymorphisms in bovine fatty acid synthase are associated with beef fatty acid composition. Animal Genetics 2008;39:62–70. 68. Morris CA, Cullen NG, Glass BC, Hyndman DL, Manley TR, Hickey SM, et al. Fatty acid synthase effects on bovine adipose fat and milk fat. Mammalian Genome 2007;18:64–74. 69. Chikuni K, Mitsuhashi T. Method of evaluating useful cattle. Patent Document CA 2441938. 2001. 70. Barendse W, Bunch RJ, Harrison BE, Thomas MB. The growth hormone GH1:c.457C>G mutation is associated with relative fat distribution in intra-muscular and rump fat in a large sample of Australian feedlot cattle. Animal Genetics 2006;37:211–4. 71. Taniguchi M, Utsugi T, Oyama K, Mannen H, Kobayashi M, Tanabe Y, et al. Genotype of stearoyl-coA desaturase is associated with fatty acid composition in Japanese Black cattle. Mammalian Genome 2004;15(2):142–8. 72. Zhang YY, Proenca R, Maffei M, Barone M, Leopold L, Friedman LM. Positional cloning of the mouse obese gene and its human homolog. Nature 1994;372:425–32. 73. Houseknecht KL, Baile CA, Matteri R, Spurlock ME. The biology of leptin: a review. Journal of Animal Science 1998;76:1405–20.
g
31
74. Stone RT, Kappes SM, Beattie C. Two polymorphic microsatellites within an 18 kb genomic clone containing the bovine ob gene. Animal Genetics 1996;27(2):64. 75. Haegeman A, Van Zeveren A, Peelman LJ. New mutation in the bovine leptin gene. Animal Genetics 2000;31:68–79. 76. Liefers SC, Veerkamp RF, te Pas MFW, Delavaud C, Chilliard Y, Platje M, et al. Leptin promoter mutations affect leptin levels and performance traits in dairy cows. Animal Genetics 2005;36:111–8. 77. Kononoff PJ, Deobald HM, Stewart EL, Laycock AD, Marquess FLS. The effect of a leptin single nucleotide polymorphism on quality grade, yield grade, and carcass weight of beef cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:927–32. 78. Madeja Z, Adamowicz T, Chmurzynska A, Jankowski T, Melonek J, Switonski M, et al. Short Communication: Effect of leptin gene polymorphisms on breeding value for milk production traits. Journal of Dairy Science 2004;87:3925–7. 79. Lusk JL. Association of single nucleotide polymorphisms in the leptin gene with body weight and backfat growth curve parameters for beef cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2007;85(8):1865–72. 80. Banos G, Woolliams JA, Woodward BW, Forbes AB, Coffey MP. Impact of single nucleotide polymorphisms in leptin, leptin receptor, growth hormone receptor, and diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT1) gene loci on milk production, feed, and body energy traits of UK dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 2008;91:3190–200. 81. Barendse W, Bunch R, Thomas M, Armitage S, Baud S, Donaldson N. The TG5 thyroglobulin gene test for a marbling quantitative trait loci evaluated in feedlot cattle. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:669–74. 82. Barendse W, Bunch RJ, Harrison BE. The leptin C73T missense mutation is not associated with marbling and fatness traits in a large gene mapping experiment in Australian cattle. Animal Genetics 2005;36:86–8. 83. Anton I, Kova´cs K, Fe´su¨s L, Va´rhegyi J, Lehel L, Hajda Z, et al. Effect of DGAT1 and TG gene polymorphisms on intramuscular fat and on milk production traits in different cattle breeds in Hungary. Acta Veterinaria Hungarica 2008;56(2):181–6. 84. Cases S, Smith SJ, Zheng YW, Myers HM, Lear SR, Sande E, et al. Identification of a gene encoding an acyl CoA: diacyl glycerol acyltransferase, a key enzyme in triacylglycerol synthesis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 1998;95:13018–23. 85. Smith SJ, Cases S, Jensen DR, Chen HC, Sande E, Tow B, et al. Obesity resistance and multiple mechanisms of triglyceride synthesis in mice lacking DGAT. Nature Genetics 2000;25:87–90. 86. Grisart B, Coppieters W, Farnir F, Karim L, Ford C, Berzi P, et al. Positional candidate cloning of a QLT in dairy cattle: identification of a missense mutation in the bovine DGAT gene with major effect on milk yield and composition. Genome research 2002;12:222–31. 87. Matarese V, Bernlohr DA. Purification of murine adipocyte lipid-binding protein: characterisation as a fatty acid-and retinoic acid-binding protein. Journal of Biological Chemistry 1988;263:14544–51. 88. Gerbens F, Jansen A, Van Erp AJM, Harders F, Meuwissen THE, Rettenberger G, et al. The adipocyte fatty
CAB International 2009
32
Animal Science Reviews 2010 acid-binding protein locus: characterisation and association with intramuscular fat content in pigs. Mammalian Genome 1998;9:1022–6.
highly expressed in skeletal muscle. Journal of Biological Chemistry 1998;273:12443–50.
89. Wang YH, Byrne K, Reverter A, Harper G, Taniguchi M, McWilliam S, et al. Transcriptional profiling of skeletal muscle tissue from two breeds of cattle. Mammalian Genome 2005;15:201–10.
104. Xiao Q, Wu X, Michal J, Reeves J, Busboom J, Thorgaard G, et al. A novel nuclear-encoded mitochondrial poly(A) polymerase PAPD1 is a potential candidate gene for the extreme obesity related phenotypes in mammals. International Journal of Biological Sciences 2006;2:171–8.
90. Jurie C, Cassar-Malek I, Bonnet M, Leroux C, Bauchart D, Boulesteix P, et al. Adipocyte fatty acid-binding protein and mitochondrial enzyme activities in muscles as relevant indicators of marbling in cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2007;85(10):2660–9.
105. Michal JJ, Jiang Z, Xiao Q. Identifying animals having desirable intramuscular fat deposition by determining the presence of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in a PAPD1 gene of the animal, which indicates intramuscular fat deposition. Patent WO2007134162-A2. 2008.
91. Cho S, Park TS, Yoon DH, Cheong HS, Namgoong S, Park BL, et al. Identification of genetic polymorphisms in FABP3 and FABP4 and putative association with back fat thickness in Korean native cattle. BMB Reports 2008;41(1):29–34.
106. Gibbs RA, Taylor JF, Van Tassell CP, Barendse W, Eversole KA, Gill CA, The Bovine HapMap Consortium. Genome-wide survey of SNP variation uncovers the genetic structure of cattle breeds. Science 2009;324(5926):528–32.
92. Hoashi S, Ashida N, Ohsaki H, Utsugi T, Sasazaki S, Taniguchi M, et al. Genotype of bovine sterol regulatory element binding protein-1 (SREBP-1) is associated with fatty acid composition in Japanese Black cattle. Mammalian Genome 2007;18:880–6.
107. Van Tassell CP, Smith TP, Matukumalli LK, Taylor JF, Schnabel RD, Lawley CT, et al. SNP discovery and allele frequency estimation by deep sequencing of reduced representation libraries. Nature Methods 2008;5(3):247–52.
93. Shimano H. Sterol regulatory element-binding proteins (SREBPs), transcriptional regulators of lipid synthetic genes. Progress in Lipid Research 2001;40:439–52.
108. Feugang JM, Kaya A, Page GP, Chen L, Mehta T, Hirani K, et al. Two-stage genome-wide association study identifies integrin beta 5 as having potential role in bull fertility. BMC Genomics 2009;10:10.
94. Roy R, Gautier M, Hayes H, Laurent P, Eggen A, Osta R, et al. Assignment of the fatty acid synthase (FASN) to bovine chromosome 19 (19q22) by in situ hybridisation and confirmation by hybrid somatic cell mapping. Cytogenetics and Cell Genetics 2001;93:141–2.
109. Kim ES, Berger PJ, Kirkpatrick BW. Genome-wide scan for bovine twinning rate QTL using linkage disequilibrium. Animal Genetics 2009;40(3):300–7.
95. Wakil SJ, Stoops JK, Joshi VC. Fatty acid synthesis and its regulation. Annual Review of Biochemistry 1983;52:537–79.
110. Hayes BJ, Bowman PJ, Chamberlain AJ, Goddard ME. Invited review: Genomic selection in dairy cattle: progress and challenges. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92(2):433–43.
96. Evans RM. The steroid and thyroid hormone receptor superfamily. Science 1988;240:889–95.
111. Meuwissen THE, Hayes BJ, Goddard ME. Prediction of total genetic value using genome-wide dense marker maps. Genetics 2001;157:1819–29.
97. Petkovich M, Brand NJ, Krust A, Chambon P. A human retinoic acid receptor which belongs to the family of nuclear receptors. Nature 1987;330:444–50.
112. Goddard ME, Hayes BJ. Mapping genes for complex traits in domestic animals and their use in breeding programmes. Nature Reviews Genetics 2009;10(6):381–91.
98. Hirose T, Smith RJ, Jetten AM. ROR-gamma, the 3rd member of ROR-RZR orphan receptor subfamily that is highly expressed in skeletal-muscle. Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 1994;205:1976–83.
113. Wiggans GR, Sonstegard TS, VanRaden PM, Matukumalli LK, Schnabel RD, Taylor JF, et al. Selection of single-nucleotide polymorphisms and quality of genotypes used in genomic evaluation of dairy cattle in the United States and Canada. Dairy Science 2009;92:3431–6.
99. Andersson-Eklund L, Danell B, Rendel J. Associations between blood-groups, blood protein polymorphisms and breeding values for production traits in Swedish red and white dairy bulls. Animal Genetics 1990;21:361–76.
114. VanRaden PM, Sullivan PG. National and international genomic evaluations for dairy cattle. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92(1):175.
100. Barendse W. DNA markers for marbling. Patent Publication WO2004070055, 1–53. 2003. 101. Yamada T, Taniguchi Y, Nishimura S, Yoshioka S, Takasuga A, Sugimoto Y, et al. Radiation hybrid mapping of genes showing intramuscular fat deposition-associated expression changes in bovine musculus longissimus muscle. Animal Genetics 2006;37:184–5. 102. Nakanishi S, Catt KJ, Balla T. A wortmannin-sensitive phosphatidylinositol 4-kinase that regulates hormone-sensitive pools of inositolphospholipids. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 1995;92:5317–21. 103. Thornton C, Snowden MA, Carling D. Identification of a novel AMP-activated protein kinase beta subunit isoform that is
g
115. Daetwyler HD, Schenkel FS, Sargolzaei M, Robinson JA. A genome scan to detect quantitative trait loci for economically important traits in Holstein cattle using two methods and a dense single nucleotide polymorphism map. Journal of Dairy Science 2008;91(8):3225–6. 116. Berry DP, Kearney JF, Harris BL. Genomic selection in Ireland. Interbull Bulletin 2009;39:29–34. 117. Davoli R, Zambonelli P, Bigi D, Fontanesi L, Russo V. Analysis of expressed sequence tags of porcine skeletal muscle. Gene 1999;233:181–8. 118. Hocquette JF. Where we are in genomics? Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 2005;56(3):37–70. 119. Bahar B, Monaghan FJ, Moloney AP, Schmidt O, McHugh DE, Sweeney T. Long-term stability of RNA in post-mortem
CAB International 2009
L. Pannier, R. M. Hamill, A. M. Mullen and T. Sweeney bovine skeletal muscle, liver and subcutaneous adipose tissues. BMC Molecular Biology 2007;8:108.
33
tissue in Brahman steers during nutritional restriction. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:1–2.
120. Bonnet M, Faulconnier Y, Leroux C, Jurie C, Cassar-Malek I, Bauchart D, et al. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase and leptin are related to marbling differences among Limousin and Angus or Japanese BlackAngus steers. Journal of Animal Science 2007;85:2882–94.
133. Reverter A, Byrne KA, Bruce HL, Wang YH, Dalrymple BP, Lehnert SA. A mixture model-based cluster analysis of cDNA microarray gene expression data on Brahman and Brahman composite steers fed high, medium and low quality diets. Journal of Animal Science 2003;81:1900–10.
121. Brandstetter AM, Sauerwein H, Veerkamp JH, Geay Y, Hocquette JF. Effects of muscle type, castration, age and growth rate on H-FABP expression in bovine skeletal muscle. Livestock Production Science 2002;75(2):199–208.
134. Wang YH, Byrne K, Reverter A, Harper G, Taniguchi M, McWilliam S, et al. Transcriptional profiling of skeletal muscle tissue from two breeds of cattle. Mammalian Genome 2005;15:201–10.
122. Wan J, Wright MB, Cai L, Flament A, Lindpaintner K. Efficacy of SSH PCR in isolating differentially expressed genes. BMC Genomics 2002;3:12.
135. Lehnert S, Reverter A, Byrne KA, Wang YH, Nattrass GS, Hudson NJ, et al. Gene expression studies of developing bovine longissimus muscle from two different beef cattle breeds. BMC Development Biology 2007;7:95.
123. Mohan M, Hurst AG, Malayer JR. Global gene expression analysis comparing bovine blastocysts flushed on day 7 or produced in vitro. Molecular Reproduction and Development 2004;68:288–98. 124. Liang P, Pardee AB. Differential display of eukaryotic mRNA by means of the polymerase chain reaction. Science 1992;257:967–71. 125. Davis Jr W, De Sousa PA, Schultz RM. Transient expression of translation initiation factor eIF-4C during the 2-cell stage of the preimplantation mouse embryo: identification by mRNA differential display and the role of DNA replication in zygotic gene activation. Development Biology 1996;174:190–201. 126. Graff JC, Behnke M, Radke J, White M, Jutila MA. A comprehensive SAGE database for the analysis of {gamma} {delta} T cells. International Immunology 2006;18:613–26. 127. Schena M, Shalon D, Davis RW, Brown PO. Quantitative monitoring of gene expression patterns with a complementary DNA microarray. Science 1995;270:467–70. 128. Moody DE. Genomics techniques: an overview of methods for study of gene expression. Journal of Animal Science 2007;79:E128–35. 129. Rinaudo P, Schultz RM. Effects of embryo culture on global pattern of gene expression in preimplantation mouse embryos. Reproduction 2004;128:301–11. 130. Shendure J, Ji HL. Next-generation DNA sequencing. Nature Biotechnology 2008;26(10):1135–45. 131. Le Be´chec A, Zindy P, Sierocinski T, Petritis D, Bihoue´e A, Le Meur N, et al. M@IA: a modular open-source application for microarray workflow and integrative datamining. In Silico Biology 2008;8(1):63–9. 132. Byrne KA, Wang YH, Lehnert SA, Harper GS, McWilliam SM, Bruce HL, et al. Gene expression profiling of muscle
g
136. Wang YH, Bower NI, Reverter A, Tan SH, De Jager N, Wang R, et al. Gene expression patterns during intramuscular fat development in cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2009;87(1):119–30. 137. Yu SL, Chung HJ, Sang BC, Park CS, Lee JH, Yoon DH, et al. Identification of differentially expressed genes in distinct skeletal muscles in cattle using cDNA microarray. Animal Biotechnology 2007;18(4):275–85. 138. Pannier L. A search for DNA polymorphisms and signature gene expression profiles associated with meat quality [PhD thesis]. University College Dublin; 2008. 139. Sadkowski T, Jank M, Oprzadek J, Motyl T. Age-dependent changes in bovine skeletal muscle transcriptomic profile. Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 2006;57(7):95–110. 140. Sadkowski T, Jank M, Zwierzchowski L, Oprzadek J, Motyl T. Transcriptomic index of skeletal muscle of beef breeds bulls. Journal of Physiology and Pharmacology 2009;60(1):15–28. 141. Sadkowski T, Jank M, Zwierzchowski L, Oprzadek J, Motyl T. Gene expression profiling in skeletal muscle of Holstein–Friesian bulls with single-nucleotide polymorphism 0 in the myostatin gene 5 -flanking region. Journal of Applied Genetics 2008;49(3):237–50. 142. Cassar-Malek I, Passelaigue F, Bernard C, Leger J, Hocquette JF. Target genes of myostatin loss-of-function in muscle of late bovine fetuses. BMC Genomics 2007;8:63. 143. Bernard C, Cassar-Malek I, Le Cunff M, Dubroeucq H, Renand G, Hocquette JF. New indicators of beef sensory quality revealed by expression of specific genes. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2007;55:5229–37. 144. Lehnert SA, Wang YH, Byrne KA. Development and application of a bovine cDNA microarray for expression profiling of muscle and adipose tissue. Australian Journal Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:1127–33.
CAB International 2009
This page intentionally left blank
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Assessing impacts of organic production on pork and beef quality Albert Sundrum* Address: Department of Animal Nutrition and Animal Health, University of Kassel, D-37213 Witzenhausen, Germany. *Correspondence: Email:
[email protected] 21 November 2008 29 April 2009
Received: Accepted:
Abstract Organic livestock farming is based on a low-input production method, aiming to provide meat of a high product and process quality rather than maximizing production. Such high meat quality corresponds to the expectations of consumers, who are both seeking a premium product and who are willing to pay premium prices. This review focuses on the question of whether organic pork and beef production currently meet consumer demands, and it elaborates the potentials and limitations for producing high-quality meats under the current organic framework. Although defined by specific and basic guidelines, organic livestock production is characterized by largely heterogeneous farming conditions that allow for huge differences in the availability of nutrient resources, the implementation of feeding regimes, the use of genotypes, etc., all of which variously impact meat production. Correspondingly, there is substantial variation in the quality of organic meat entering the marketplace. According to the available literature, the quality of organic pork and beef was inconsistent and often fell short of expectations, as it is often similar to the quality of conventionally produced meat. Obviously, organic guidelines play a minor role with respect to meat quality. On the other hand, there is evidence that less intensified production systems may present suitable preconditions that would yield meats of high eating quality assumed that the relevant pre- and post-farmgate factors are considered and balanced within quality assurance systems. However, the trade value of carcasses is determined primarily by lean meat and cut composition while qualitative traits of meat are of no relevance. Neither does continuous recording of qualitative traits take place nor is an outstanding meat quality rewarded by higher prices. Of the various parameters, the intramuscular fat is highly related to palatability traits in both pork and beef and could be used to distinguish between different levels of eating quality. Despite the fact that many consumers express their wish for high-quality meats, the payment and marketing systems counteract all efforts to follow consumer demands and fail to communicate adequately differentiated meat palatability. It is concluded that only a direct assessment of qualitative traits and a payment system that honours meat quality grades that are above average can contribute so as to improve the currently unsatisfying situation. This, however, requires a shift in the paradigm from a guideline-oriented to an output-oriented approach, and the implementation of a systematic approach for an effective and efficient balancing of the multiple variables and complex interactions within each farming system. Keywords: Eating quality, Production method, Output orientation, System approach, Marketing
Introduction In the past, a lot of research effort has been devoted to meat quality. Nevertheless, problems with regard to the quality of meat are still evident in conventional production
g
and this explains why consumers are looking for alternatives [1]. The introduction of the ‘wholesomeness’ concept in meat production, most often represented by organic production, is mainly the result of a wish to reestablish a positive meat sector image, including meat
CAB International 2009
36
Animal Science Reviews 2010
quality, meat safety and animal welfare aspects [2, 3]. Consumers make a whole range of positive inferences from the label ‘organic’; referring not only to a better taste but also to the concern for the environment and health [4]. The holistic approach of organic farming is also in line with the growing wish of consumers for improved traceability, including the ever-rising consumer concern in relation to the introduction of genetically modified organisms in the feed and food production [5]. In Germany, guidelines are a characteristic feature of organic farming since 1954 and have been so since the country’s trademark legislation required clear criteria to identify organically produced goods [6]. Because the variety of production sites and the resulting product properties did not allow their identification to be linked to products qualitatively in terms that could be described exactly and understood analytically, the production method itself became the identifying criterion. This fundamental principle of the original privately developed economic approach has been adopted in many countries by legislation to harmonize the rules of organic farming and to make all organic systems across countries subject to minimum standards. In Europe, the legal basis is provided by the revised Council Regulation No. 834/2007. One of the main objectives is to protect consumers from unjustified claims and to avoid unfair competition between those who label their products as being organic. The organic concept refers to the whole farm as the base of a comprehensive system where the production process is intended to ensure quality production rather than maximizing production, therewith meeting the demands of an increasing number of consumers, who are more and more critical of conventional production methods. Labelling meat as being ‘organic’ identifies the products as deriving from a production method defined by guidelines. So far, only a few studies have been conducted to assess the quality of pork and beef produced under these conditions. In this paper, some major findings, with a particular emphasis placed upon the eating quality of meat, are reviewed. The possibilities and limitations of both the production of high-quality meats and their assessment are outlined below.
Meat Quality, the Outcome of Complex Interactions Meat quality is multifaceted and comprises sensory, nutritive, hygienic or toxicological and technological factors [7]. Factors such as colour, flavour, softness and tenderness are considered to be primary sensory factors. Nutritive factors in meat include the type and amount of protein, carbohydrate, lipid, vitamins and minerals. Hygiene and toxicological factors of beef and pork are outside the scope of this review and the reader is referred to corresponding reviews [8, 9]. Technological factors include the intrinsic properties of meat that govern its
g
suitability for manufacturing. Sensory factors are the major focus of this review, with passing reference being made to nutritive and technological factors. The intrinsic properties (i.e. those extant at the time of slaughter) of an animal’s muscles influence the eatingquality attributes of meat. Some of these intrinsic characteristics of muscle are changed little by processing and cooking, while others interact with pre-slaughter stress, post-slaughter processing conditions and method and time of storage to subsequently influence eating quality of meat [10, 11]. The conditions that apply in the 24–48 h immediately before and after slaughter are recognized as having the largest influence on pork and beef palatability [1, 12]. Thus, failure to control the pre- and postslaughter environment can have a particularly large impact on meat quality attributes. As there is no evidence for grave differences in post-farmgate factors such as preslaughter handling, transport, slaughter or chilling rate between organic and conventional production, the review is primarily focused on the effects of on-farm factors on meat traits. The significant factors involved in generating high levels of meat quality have been in the focus of animal science for decades. However, most of the present knowledge is based on studies investigating the influence of a single or of very few factors pertaining to meat quality under ceteris paribus assumptions. Thus, there are limited data available concerning the understanding of how the various factors within the production chain interact in relation to the qualitative traits of meat [1, 13]. Under the current marketing conditions, carcasses with the leanest meat generate the highest profit. At the same time it is the most efficient strategy to reduce production costs as an increase in protein accretion goes along with a clear increase in daily weight gain and an improvement in feed conversion [14]. A lean carcass also provides the highest yield and profit for the processing industry. In responding to market pressures and attracted by profit taking, improved nutritional practices in combination with genetic selection have been implemented and have improved the leanness of pork and beef considerably within the recent decades [1]. However, striving for a high lean-meat percentage has provided several negative side effects. With an increase of lean meat and an extreme reduction of overlay fat, the risk increases that meat deficiencies will appear [15, 16]. In the carcasses of pigs, lean meat percentage and intramuscular fat (IMF) content in longissimus muscles are correlated negatively [17, 18]. Because of the substantial efforts to increase carcass lean content, an appropriate IMF content that would be associated with a high level of eating quality has almost been eliminated [19, 20]. Compared with highly fat-marbled pork chops, leaner chops are darker, have a more acceptable appearance and are more likely to be purchased [21]. However, they are also less tender, juicy, oily and flavoursome than highly fatmarbled chops, indicating a disparity between purchase
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum
37
Table 1 Differences between organic and conventional livestock production in various aspects Council Regulation (European Commission) No 834/2007 on organic production Principles Management strategy Genotypes Housing conditions Nutritional potential Feeding regime Processing of products
Conventional
Quality production rather than maximizing production Maximizing efficiency within the whole farm system Breeding animals of organic origin; high variety of breeds between farms, often comparable to conventional genotypes but partly indigenous and robust breeds Special rules according to space allowance, lying and outdoor area as well as pasture; ban of tethering and fully slatted floors Limited availability of energy-rich feedstuffs for ruminants and high quality protein for monogastric animals; restrictions in quantity and quality of bought-in feedstuffs, ban of extracted meals and synthetic amino acids Prolonged weaning; restrictions in the use of concentrate for ruminants; pigs have to be provided with roughage Use of defined products and substances in processing
intent based on visual evaluation, and quality or palatability attributes of the cooked product. While high glycogen levels at slaughter bears the risk of a low ultimate meat pH and consequently colour and drip loss, lower-than-normal muscle glycogen stores at the time of slaughter include the risk of dark cutting meat, because of a low lactic acid production after slaughter and a high ultimate meat pH [22, 23]. As ultimate pH is directly related to tenderness, a reduction in muscle glycogen level obtained through selection will indirectly increase tenderness in pork. On the other hand, glycogen showed a positive correlation to meat percentage and was negatively correlated to the feed conversion ratio (kg feed : kg gain) when studied in pure-breds [24]. Thus, selecting pigs for low glycogen levels may be in contradiction to the genetic improvement of performance traits. In beef production, fattening bulls are preferred in most European countries because of their higher economical efficiency. At the same time, bulls provide poorer preconditions for high eating quality compared with the meat of steers and heifers [25]. While the fattening of steers has nearly vanished in many countries, heifers are seldom used to produce quality meat. Based on these preconditions, beef production in Europe is more oriented to a quantitative rather than a qualitative production. Many beef-producing countries have attempted to utilize the potential of meaty, large and late-maturing beef breeds. On the other hand, beef cattle with a high lean-meat percentage such as White Blue Belgians showed a clearly lower IMF content compared with beef from dairy breeds [26]. Steers and heifers of small- and medium-sized breeds are well suited for extensive production, while bulls of larger breeds are not subjected to as much fattening, as a prolonged fattening period is expected to have a negative impact on the tenderness of meat [27]. This effect, however, has not been found in steers and heifers [28].
g
Minimizing production costs Maximizing productivity at the level of the farm animals High-yielding pure- or cross-bred, often bred for a specific production goal No prescriptions apart from the general regulations, primarily indoor housing No prescriptions apart from the general recommendations of good farming practice Good farming practice Good manufacturing practice
When offered a low feeding level, the IMF of heifers and steers was higher (4.8 and 3.4%, respectively) compared with a high feeding level (3.5 and 3.0%, respectively) [29]. At a high feeding level, the meat of the bulls contained less IMF (2.3%) than that of heifers and steers. Last but not least, while most of the consumers would prefer to receive meat that is tender rather than tough, it is preferable for certain manufactured products to rely on meat that does not disintegrate too easily [30]. If the fat content can vary within an established grade then this variance would not be helpful for processors wanting to produce a consistent and specified low-fat product.
Characteristics of Organic Livestock Production In recent years, organic agriculture has shown rapid growth and dynamic developments in many countries, but especially throughout Europe [31]. Based on worldwideapplied guidelines, organic livestock farming has set goals to establish environmentally friendly production methods, to sustain animals in good health, to achieve high animalwelfare standards and to produce products of high quality [32]. In the European countries, the EEC Regulation No. 834/2007 stipulates the maximum number of farm animals/ha in pasture and the maximum organic livestock numbers/m2 in covered and uncovered housing. Furthermore, these regulations include specifications for housing conditions, animal nutrition, care and breeding, disease prevention and veterinary treatment, while they create frameworks for organic livestock production and product labelling in all European countries on an equal and legal basis. Differences between organic and conventional conditions for livestock production are outlined in Table 1. For a producer or a farmer, an important principle is to rely mainly on the management of internal farm resources
CAB International 2009
38
Animal Science Reviews 2010
rather than on external input and, in relation to health management, to rely on prevention measures rather than on treatment. While in conventional production increasing demands for nutrients are covered mainly by broughtin feedstuffs, in organic production the possibilities for nutrient imports are limited. According to the new EU Regulation (EEC/834/2007), organic livestock farming intends to contribute to the equilibrium of agricultural production systems, to establish and maintain interdependence between soils, plants and animals; to establish land-related and rule out landless productions, and therewith support the development of a sustainable agriculture. The realization of this approach usually requires a complete re-organization of the farm, in which crop requirements have to be tailored to the concerns of animal husbandry and the extent and direction of animal husbandry adapted to home-grown feedstuffs [33]. Dealing with a limited availability of resources is therefore a main feature of organic production, while maximization of protein accretion is of less importance. However, organic agriculture is not organized uniformly, either with respect to the various objectives or in the degree of their implementation. There are different perspectives on organic agriculture with different understandings of what it is and what it develops. Not only farmers but also many different entities, such as policymakers, small agri-businesses, agri-food corporations, supermarkets and consumers, seek to influence the production process in accordance with their own goals and values. Alroe and Noel [34] identified three significant perspectives on organic agriculture based on protest, meaning and market. These three perspectives on organic agriculture cannot be merged into one but can be helpful in understanding of its past and of its future development. Although organic meat production is clearly demarcated from conventional production by organic guidelines, framework conditions differ markedly between organic production systems [35]. The production conditions vary from outdoor production to indoor production and encompass huge differences between regions, not only in relation to environmental conditions and the genotype used but also especially in relation to the nutrient supply. While common ideas and guidelines exist only on a meta-level, the concrete implementation in farm practice results in a large variety of stocking densities, performance levels, nutrient flows and efficiencies in the use of home-grown and bought-in feedstuffs. Thus, highly intensified conventional livestock systems and organic systems mark the cornerstones of opposite approaches, providing divergent implications for the understanding and the development of livestock systems. In farming practice, both approaches are often mixed. With regard to the different objectives, different priorities and different framework conditions, it has, however, to be taken into account that organic and conventional livestock productions belong to completely different farm systems. General conclusions derived from conventional
g
production systems are not directly compatible with organic livestock production and are therefore invalid.
Meat Quality in Organic Farming When organic meat is offered, those choosing the organic variety expect it to be of better quality across all quality dimensions, including taste and tenderness. The expectations focused on an alternative production method might be reasonable as the quality of conventional produced meat has been of concern for a long time. Several authors highlight that the limit of leanness that will still allow one to market palatable pork and beef has already been exceeded [36–38]. According to Andersen [19], the intensity of pork flavour has decreased during recent years, probably as a result of the production of pork with a minimal content of IMF. Slaughtered pigs from intensified production units currently showed an average IMF content in the longissimus muscle around 1%, clearly below the threshold of 2.5%, having a resounding effect on palatability [39, 40]. Compared with conventional meat production, little information is available on the current relation of meat palatability attributes to technological quality for organic production. In a field study, considerably higher variations in the lean meat content of carcasses have been found in organic pigs compared with conventionally produced pigs [41]. In a study by Jonsa¨ll et al. [42], loins from organically raised pigs were less juicy than those conventionally raised. Olsson et al. [43] found that the meat of a specific organic treatment was of poorer quality (higher drip loss and increased shear force values) compared with meat from the conventional treatment. A recently conducted field study on organic farms in Germany and Austria re-vealed that the average IMF content in longissimus muscle ranged on a level of about 2.2%, at the same time showing a substantial variation within and between farms [44]. Different experiments were carried out to study the impacts of different organic feeding regimes on meatquality traits. Unbalanced organic diets enriched with grain legumes in the growing and finishing period led to an average IMF content of 2.8% in the longissimus muscle of pigs, compared with 1.2% in the conventional treatment [18, 45]. Also Millet et al. [46] found a higher IMF content associated with organic diets, although on a lower level. In addition, ultimate pH in ham and loin was lower and the meat was redder compared with the conventional treatment. In contrast, Millet et al. [47] did not find an increased level of IMF when feeding diets consisting of organic feed ingredients. Also Hansen et al. [48] found no significant difference in meat-quality characteristics when compared with results obtained in the conventional system. While the percentage of leanness increased in meat from organic pigs raised on 70% concentrate plus roughage compared with meat from pigs given 100%
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum
concentrate, restricted concentrate feeding gave rise to a decrease in tenderness compared with pork from pigs fed 100% concentrate. In a study by Partanen et al. [49], pigs fed diets with ingredients of organic origin had fatter carcasses, but the eating quality of organic pork did not differ from that of pork from pigs fed conventional diets. Heyer et al. [50] compared carcass and technological quality traits of indoor and outdoor raised pigs fed organic or conventional diets ad libitum or restrictively. Technologically based meat quality differed only slightly between indoor- and outdoor-raised pigs. The diet (organic/ conventional) for indoor pigs did not affect carcass and meat-quality traits. When comparing organic and conventional beef production systems in the USA (including ionophore implants), steers in organic finishing had significantly lighter carcasses, smaller rib eyes and higher marbling than steers in conventional finishing [51]. In Europe, grazing in summer and feeding a minimum of 60% roughage during the whole year are inevitable components of an organic beef production system. According to Nielsen and Thamsborg [52], quality of organic beef in Denmark is affected by the production system used, especially differences in grazing and exercise. They assume that grazing and exercise may affect the eating quality by resulting in darker meat colour, lower risk of off-flavour, yellow fat and a higher content of unsaturated fatty acids, including conjugated linoleic acid. Nevertheless, the authors conclude that the overall effect on sensory attributes may be of minor importance. According to Russo and Preziuso [53], carcasses from organically raised beef cattle in Italy were characterized by poor muscular development and low IMF content, while other organoleptic characteristics of the meat were not influenced by the organic rearing system. They concluded that the results were probably associated with the fact that native breeds were preferred, which are often characterized by a rather slow development, and the rations were mainly based on forage, with low energy yields from concentrates. Summing up, it can be assumed that the variations with respect to the eating quality of pork and beef in organic farming are caused by differences in the genotypes and the feeding regime used, and differences in the adaptation of the nutrient supply to the genetic protein and fat accretion of the animals in the various stages of life.
How to Improve Meat Quality In intensified livestock production systems, the procedures and measures used to achieve a certain product are highly standardized in order to obtain a more or less uniform and interchangeable product. This standardization includes the use of comparable genotypes and feeding strategies. In contrast, organic farmers are challenged by more heterogeneous preconditions.
g
39
Selection of Genotype and Sex Genetics are known to have a marked influence on both production and quality traits. The capacity for protein accretion is determined principally by the genotype. Meatrich genotypes achieved clearly higher protein accretion over the entire fattening period than those with an average muscle growth [54]. The superiority of animals with a high genetic capacity for protein accretion becomes manifest, however, only in combination with a corresponding protein and energy supply. In general, genotypes used in organic pig production do not differ markedly between organic and conventional production, except for some rare or robust breeds used on single farms [41]. Robust breeds, especially Iberian pigs, are known for their potential to emerge as high eating quality of pork. Muscles from pure-bred Iberian pigs contain significantly higher amounts of IMF, haem pigments and iron than those from cross-bred pigs [55]. The use of other robust breeds, however, does not automatically provide clear advantages with respect to pork quality traits [17, 45]. Although an enormous amount of research has been directed at the pale, soft and exudative (PSE) problem in pig meat, and the genetic basis for an understanding of the impacts of the gene defects are known [56, 57], only a few countries have reacted accordingly [58]. In many countries, little progress to eliminate the gene defect or to minimize the problem is recorded [59]. In Germany, currently only few progeny-tested Pietrain boars have the homozygous positive genotype nn in relation to the malignant hyperthermia syndrome (MHS) genotype, but more than 50% of the boars are heterozygous gene carriers (Nn) [60]. The gene defect results in higher than normal muscle glycogen stores and in extended postmortem pH decline that leads to pork with a lower-thannormal ultimate meat pH, reduced water-holding capacities and greater cooking losses [61, 62]. If the main gene defects are excluded, genetics contributes less than 30% to the total variation of meat quality criteria [63]. Hence, most attributes referring to the eating quality of meat show a low heritability, except for that of IMF content [13]. Although the heritability of IMF and fat tissue is high, the genetic correlation between both is very low [64], which suggest that selection for high IMF in lean carcasses should be possible. A successful implementation of a breeding programme focusing on IMF content in pork has been reported from Switzerland [65]. Moreover, there has been considerable interest in the use of genotypes (especially Duroc) with high levels of IMF in an attempt to improve eating quality with variable results. While Edwards et al. [66] found no significant advantage for the Duroc breed in eating quality, others highlighted the benefit of this breed in several, but not all, quality traits [45, 67]. In the past, the favoured breeds with respect to beef quality were the small-framed and early maturing beef breeds such as Aberdeen Angus and Hereford, and the
CAB International 2009
40
Animal Science Reviews 2010
small-framed dairy breed Jersey [68]. In many countries, early maturing breeds have been nearly squeezed out by large-framed beef cattle. Meat of local rustic breeds that are still extant in some regions offers a certain attractiveness to consumers. In general, rustic breeds show the reddest meat, which is directly related to their higher content in muscular haem pigments [69]. In studies that compared sensory characteristics of beef between different rustic breeds in Spain and Germany, breeds were significantly different from each other according to sensory attributes, indicating that some, although not all, rare breeds are providing high eating qualities [70, 71]. Furthermore, sensory analysis indicated that meat from the rustic breed may require a longer ageing period than meat from an improved cross-breed [72]. Data from Lively et al. [73] showed that dairy genotypes produce more tender meat than beef genotypes. Bulls selected for their high-phenotypic ultrasound IMF percentage and their fat-marbling score can be expected to produce steer progeny with significantly higher amounts of marbling and quality [74, 75]. It also appears that marbling can be increased without a corresponding increase in external fat thickness. Meat from steers and heifers is expected to be tenderer compared with meat from bulls, which can be related to a higher IMF content and to a different rate of proteolysis post mortem [25, 76]. In studies of Maher et al. [77], bulls were more variable than steers for ultimate pH, Warner Bratzler shear force, flavour and cooking loss. It has, however, to be taken into account that muscle type accounts for a greater proportion of the variation in the muscle characteristics such as fibre crosssectional area, percentage of fibre types, total and insoluble collagen and lipid concentration than breed and sex of the animals [78].
Feeding Regime Because of limitations in the availability of home-grown feedstuffs and restrictions concerning bought-in feedstuffs, the first limitation in exploiting the genetic potential of growing pigs in organic farming is the supply of limited amino acids. As soybean meal from conventional processing and synthetic amino acids are banned, grain legumes represent the main protein source. Correspondingly, the performance capacity of pigs under organic conditions is diminished compared with conventional production. The preferred use of home-grown versus brought-in feedstuffs can cause a high variation in the nutrient content of feeding rations and this has consequences in carcass composition and meat quality. Possibilities and limitations of protein supply in organic pig production have been recently reviewed [79]. A number of feeding strategies have been proven to be potential control tools in the production of superior quality meat. According to Rosenvold et al. [80], the level
g
of macroglycogen before slaughter can be changed by dietary manipulation. A reduction in glycolytic potential results in an increase of ultimate pH and decreases the temperature 45 min post mortem, which will lead to reduced drip loss. According to Cisneros et al. [81], Sundrum et al. [18] and D’Souza et al. [82], the IMF content in the Musculus longissimus dorsi can be increased by feeding livestock diets low in essential amino acids without increasing fat area and back-fat thickness. Nutritional effects on IMF characteristics and content have shown to be clearly of higher importance than genetic effects [45, 83]. Under standardized conditions, a diet enriched with grain legumes in the growing and finishing periods led to an average IMF content of 2.8% in the longissimus muscle of pigs [45]. The results supported the hypothesis previously developed by Katsumata et al. [84] that a reduced supply of essential amino acids could provoke the de novo synthesis of fat in the muscle cell and therefore lead to a higher IMF content. Oksbjerg et al. [85] studied the influence of feeding strategies that combined outdoor and indoor rearing on pig meat quality. They conclude that ad libitum feeding in organic production systems gives superior meat quality compared with a restrictive feeding strategy. Variations in nutrient supply result in both varying growth processes within the different stages of life and varying ages at which each animal are slaughtered. These are expected to have an additional effect on IMF content [86]. For high variations in feed intake and growth rate, as well as in protein and fat accretion, differences in nutrient supply and digestibility [87], age [88], living conditions and environmental temperature [89], stocking rate and group size [90], rank order [91], feeding environment [92, 93] and generally stressful situations [94] must be considered. This makes a prediction of the specific requirements at the farm level very complex and difficult. In organic farming, beef is primarily produced on a grass-based system consisting of a period of summer pasture feeding followed by an indoor, finishing period of grass silage feeding. Because of a lack of availability of energy-rich forage such as maize silage and restrictions in the use of concentrate, farmers are challenged to provide an appropriate energy supply. Tenderness in muscles with a high content of connective tissue decreases with age [27]. Prolonged grazing may decrease quality grade, either by impairing the ability of the animal to deposit IMF or by decreasing the time during which dietary energy supply is adequate for IMF deposition to occur [95]. In contrast, Scheeder et al. [28] found no relationship between an increased age of steers and heifers kept on grassland and the tenderness of their meat. The greatest potential for the manipulation of IMF accretion during fattening is via an increase in the net energy of feed rations, specifically by increasing the cereal grain content and the lipid content of the diet [75, 96]. In a study by Nuernberg et al. [97], done with bulls, the substitution of energy-dense concentrate ingredients with
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum
grass of lower energy concentration resulted in carcasses with lower IMF content and tougher meat when compared with concentrate-fed bulls. On the other hand, feeding grass had a positive effect on the fatty acid profile of their meat. O’Sullivan et al. [98] found that beef from grass silage-fed animals had better overall quality in terms of colour, lipid oxidation and a-tocopherol levels than beef from maize silage fed animals. From an experiment conducted with varying proportions of autumn grass and grass silage, French et al. [99] concluded that the quality of meat from steers that consumed grass supplemented with low levels of concentrate produced the most tender and acceptable meat. However, further ageing eliminated all treatment effects on eating quality of beef. In a comparison between beef from Holstein Friesian bulls fed either ad libitum throughout the rearing period or subjected to a compensatory growth feeding strategy, the compensatory feeding was found to improve the tenderness and elevate the eating quality [100]. Beyond these establishments there are many uncertainties: experiments have examined the effects of diets with high protein, low protein, protected lipid, protected protein, added oil with and without calcium and vitamin A deficiency. None of these manipulations gave consistent improvement in marble score or IMF% [75]. Quality traits of pork and beef are characterized by a large variation between the animals of a herd and between the preconditions of farm systems while at the same time the degree and the source of the variation differs widely. Sources of variation in relation to meat quality attributes arise from interactions between genotype, age, sex, nutrient supply and their varying impacts on the dynamic nature of muscle and fat accretion, connective tissue composition and structure. To strive for a high eating quality requires high management skills; one must be capable enough to gain an overall picture of the complex interactions within a farming system, to reflect on the most relevant factors, to implement feedback mechanisms and guide the production process. Thus, it primarily depends on the management whether the potentials for a high level of eating quality are fully realized.
Barriers Scientific knowledge on how to produce pork and beef of a high intrinsic quality has markedly increased during the last few decades. However, it is obvious that knowledge alone is not sufficient to change the current unsatisfactory situation, and that the production of a high eating quality is not solely the responsibility of the farmer. While the production processes at the farm level and the quality traits of meat products are characterized in the first place by heterogeneity, branding programmes and marketing strategies often are reducing the heterogeneity of reality to very simple messages. Many brands put an emphasis only on some very specific traits while
g
41
neglecting or ignoring others [1]. The less that is known by the consumer about a product’s production processes and traits, the easier it is to construct an image, and this enables the consumer to project and connect individual and favourable ideas with the product while leaving plenty of room for speculation. On the other hand, a specific food item’s image and a consumer’s previous experience with its quality become more and more decisive in the purchase situation [101]. Based merely on single traits to transmit images to the consumer, food marketing ignores existing and production-related variability but nonetheless tries to sell a more or less uniform image of the product. The market is full of over-simplifications and inaccurate images and this makes it difficult to employ more meaningful quality assessments into practical shopping/ consuming situations. Since the consumer is seldom able to evaluate whether the food product has delivered on promised process qualities, process-related qualities of food products are almost exclusively based on trust. Thus, food image and reputation, whether based on facts or anecdotal, are increasingly important in food marketing [1]. Currently, meat often has a negative image in the public both as a result of food scandals of past few years and the anecdotal statement that present-day meat is fatty and unhealthy from a nutritional viewpoint [102]. When purchasing meat products, price, appearance and place of purchase are all primary and interrelated meat-selection criteria [103]. Different consumers show different preferences and subjective perceptions in relation to different features and rank quality criteria differently. While some groups of consumers exhibit greatest preference for dark firm and dry (DFD) pig meat, others prefer normal appearing chops; a relevant number of consumers show a preference for PSE pork [104]. Reactions of consumers in four countries to the appearance and taste of pork with and without information concerning outdoor production were tested by Dransfield et al. [105]. In all countries, consumers relied on colour of pork rather than marbling and drip loss to make their choice. Almost half of the British and Danish preferred the paler and the French preferred the darker pork. When information was provided in the form of labels, the vast majority of consumers preferred the pork labelled as originating from their own country as opposed to ‘imported’ and those labelled as pork from pigs ‘raised outside’ as opposed to ‘inside’. What consumers were willing to pay varied widely and the amount was higher for those consumers who found more of the characteristics they sought. A study about consumer visual preference and value for beef steaks showed that consumers who preferred low marbling seemed to desire lean products, and consumers who preferred high marbling seemed to desire products with high eating quality [106]. Boleman et al. [107] and Platter et al. [108] found that consumers could discriminate between steaks of different tenderness classes and that marbling scores and Warner–Bratzler shear
CAB International 2009
42
Animal Science Reviews 2010
forces influenced both the probability that consumers will purchase and the price they are willing to pay for strip loin steaks. Oliver et al. [109] concluded from their studies that the individual preferences could lead to a concept of market segmentation based on taste preferences. Although there are several attributes that are closely linked to the eating quality of meat, they are hardly assessed in the general production process. The marketing system does not reward high eating quality with a premium, but rather pays for quantity. Moreover, farmers are punished by deductions if they do not fulfil the quantitative demands of the meat industry. As long as qualitative traits are not directly assessed and not used to distinguish between different qualities, the use of the term ‘meat quality’ for marketing purpose is misleading and correspondingly leads to unfair competition between those producers who really strive for eating quality and those who, without proof, only claim to do so. Given a high variability in the preconditions of meat production, following the organic guidelines does not automatically lead to a higher eating quality of meat. From a superordinate perspective there is reason to conclude that organic livestock production is trapped between aroused consumer expectations and limited resources. Although there is evidence that organic production has the potential to offer a higher level of eating quality, there is concern that organic farming has manoeuvred itself into a blind alley because of a lack of both clear objectives and threshold values concerning acceptable eating qualities. Many consumers seem to be willing to pay more to purchase organic products. However, as long as relevant traits of meat quality are not routinely assessed and as long as the market does not distinguish between meat products of different quality there seems to be little chance to establish a specific target market based on quality products. To prevent the loss of credibility, organic farmers and retailers are obliged to take the burden of proof. Thus, there is a need for a shift in the paradigm from a guideline to an output-oriented approach [110]. Marbling respectively IMF content in both pork and beef can be easily used to differentiate between products of different eating quality because of the close relationship between IMF and various palatability traits. The grading systems for beef in USA, Australia and Japan provide examples of how grading relevant eating qualities and traits might work. Retailers of organic products so far have failed to provide a clear profile of traits closely related to eating quality and have made no efforts to explain any differences to those consumers groups that are interested in what they eat. Thus, there is a need for more transparency and guidance in the confusing issue of eating quality both for the farmers and the consumers. Reliable monitoring systems for assessing meat quality are urgently required. No progress, however, can be expected with regard to eating quality if the farmer will not gain any benefit and
g
profit from the market. Retailers have to make sure that a high level of meat quality will be honoured by adequate prices to cover the additional efforts needed to ensure the production of high-quality meat. In the past, the marketing of organic products has done a lot to use the image of organic to increase turnover rates but has done nothing to ensure that organic products actually correspond to the image.
Scientific Challenges From a systemic point of view, meat quality is the outcome of a very complex process that emerges on the level of the single organism. Numerous factors such as genotype, age, sex, growth development, etc. interact within each organism and react with the various factors outside of the organism such as feeding, housing and management conditions. Accordingly, the large variation within a herd in relation to quality attributes of meat is the result of the potential of numerous interactions. There is a growing understanding within the scientific community that it is necessary to develop more comprehensive concepts that simultaneously consider a larger number of causal relationships. The isolated view under ceteris paribus assumptions appears to be guilty of selective attention and over-generalization, and is beginning to be replaced by a systemic approach [111]. This requires interdisciplinary collaboration, since this problem’s definition cuts across conventional commodity and disciplinary lines. The key feature of a systemic approach is that it captures the dynamics and interactions between the various elements within each system [112]. Thus, there is a need for a higher level of plausibility and coherence in relation to general statements and conclusions regarding marketing, labelling and branding. Furthermore, efficient feedback mechanisms, such as monitoring concepts and quality assurance schemes have to be promoted to increase the predictability of meat quality. On the other hand, new hopes related to new methods in animal breeding should not be overestimated. The current progress in genomics will definitely increase the knowledge of physiology and genetics. These progressions are, however, not likely to improve meat quality automatically, especially when this approach does not match with the complexity of the meat growth processes within the farming system. The development of modelling systems which aim at predicting meat quality based upon data collected from an animal’s birth, through its slaughter, preparation and consumption, including all the details of its growth, may be helpful to better understand the sources of quality-related variance. On the other hand, the ordinal- and interval-scaled traits relevant for assessing the eating quality of meat aggravate any statistics, as operations such as multiplication and division cannot be carried out directly and coefficient of variation cannot be defined properly. Moreover, the partly antagonistic
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum
relationships between single traits and the bio-cybernetic self-regulation processes within both the organism and the farm system are opposed to the development of valid algorithms. The development of specific attributes of meat is influenced and regulated on different process levels (cell, organism, herd and farm system), which narrows the potential for valid conclusions drawn from results obtained on one process level to be transferred to other process levels. Following these considerations, there is limited potential to generalize results obtained under standardized conditions and to transfer these results into the heterogeneity of organic farm systems. Implications Currently, the quality of organic pork and beef is characterized by a substantial variation in different traits reflecting the various preconditions, objectives and implementations within the production chain. In general, organic can only partly set itself apart from the level of eating quality, or palatability, in intensified production units. Obviously, organic guidelines play a minor role with respect to meat quality. The various animal and farmrelated factors known to influence meat quality have to be balanced by management and the antagonistic relationships between some quantitative and qualitative traits must be taken into account. Within quality assurance systems, all aspects of meat production chain, including pre- and post-farmgate factors need to be optimized in order to minimize variation in eating quality. The trade value of carcasses is primarily determined by lean meat and the composition of its cuts while the production of meats with high levels of eating quality are not rewarded by the current market and are at risk of facing even lower market prices. Thus, the current marketing system is in contradiction to the production of pork and beef with high eating qualities. Only a direct assessment of qualitative traits and payment systems that honour qualities beyond average will contribute to improve this unsatisfying situation. This will, however, require a paradigm-shift from a guideline-oriented to an outputoriented approach. Additionally, as eating quality is the outcome of a very complex process, a systematic approach is needed to make the most effective and efficient use of the multiple factors within each farming system and production chain.
References 1. Andersen HJ, Oksbjerg N, Therkildsen M. Potential quality control tools in the production of fresh pork, beef and lamb demanded by the European society. Livestock Production Science 2005;94:105–24. 2. Verbeke WA, Viaene J. Ethical challenges for livestock production: meeting consumer concerns about meat safety
g
43
and animal welfare. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 2000;12:141–51. 3. Mayfield LE, Bennet RM, Tranter RB, Wooldrige MJ. Consumption of welfare-friendly food products in Great Britain, Italy and Sweden, and how it may be influenced by consumer attitudes to, and behavior towards, animal welfare attributes. Journal of Sociology of Food and Agriculture 2007;15:59–73. 4. Bech-Larsen T, Grunert KG. Integrating the theory of planned behaviour with means-end chain theory – a study of possible improvements in predictive ability. In: Andersson P, editor. Proceedings of the 27th EMAC Conference, 20–23 May 1998, Stockholm, Sweden; 1998. p. 305–14. 5. Oughton E, Ritson C. Food consumers and organic agriculture. In: Cooper J, Niggli U, Leifert C, editors. Handbook of Organic Food Safety and Quality. Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge, UK; 2007. p. 74–94. 6. Schaumann W. Der wissenschaftliche und praktische Entwicklungsweg des o¨kologischen Landbaus und seine Zukunftsperspektive. In: Schaumann W, Siebeneicher G, Lu¨nzer I, editors. Geschichte des o¨kologischen Landbaus, Volume 65. SO¨L-Sonderausgabe; 2002. p. 11–58. 7. Hofmann K. What is quality? Definition, measurement and evaluation of meat quality. Meat Focus International 1994;3:73–82. 8. Hocking AD, Arnold A, Jenson I, Newton K, Sutherland P. Foodborne Microorganisms of Public Health Significance. Australian Institute of Food Science and Technology Inc., Sydney; 1997. 9. Nowak B, Sammet K, Klein G, Mueffling TV. Trends in the production and storage of fresh meat – the holistic approach to bacteriological meat quality. International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2005;41:303–10. 10. Oddy VH, Harper GS, Greenwood PL, McDonagh MB. Nutritional and developmental effects on the intrinsic properties of muscles as they related to the eating quality of beef. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2001;41:921–42. 11. Hambrecht E, Eissen JJ, de Klein WJH, Ducro BJ, Smits CHM, Verstegen MWA, et al. Rapid chilling cannot prevent inferior pork quality caused by high preslaughter stress. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:551–6. 12. Ferguson DM, Bruce HL, Thompson JM, Egan AF, Perry D, Shorthose WR. Factors affecting beef palatability – farmgate to chilled carcass. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2001;41:879–91. 13. Rosenvold K, Andersen HJ. Factors of significance for pork quality – a review. Meat Science 2003;64:219–37. 14. Susenbeth A. Anpassung der Aminosa¨urenversorgung an das Wachstumsvermo¨gen von Schweinen. Lohmann Information 2002;21–4. 15. Affentranger P, Gerwig C, Seewer GJ, Schwo¨rer D, Ku¨nzi N. Growth and carcass characteristics as well as meat and fat quality of three types of pigs under different feeding regimes. Livestock Production Science 1996;45:187–96. 16. Fischer K. Bedingungen fu¨r die Produktion von Schweinefleisch guter sensorischer und technologischer Qualita¨t. Mitteilungsblatt BAFF Kulmbach 2001;40:7–22.
CAB International 2009
44
Animal Science Reviews 2010
17. Baulain U, Ko¨hler P, Kallweit E, Brade W. Intramuscular fat content in some native German pig breeds. EAAP Publication 2000;100:181–4. 18. Sundrum A, Bu¨terfering L, Henning M, Hoppenbrock KH. Effects of on-farm diets for organic pig production on performance and carcass quality. Journal of Animal Science 2000;78:1199–205. 19. Andersen HJ. What is pork quality? EAAP Publication 2000;100:15–26. 20. Rosner F, Von Lengerken G, Maak S. The value of pig breeding herds in Germany and progress in improvement of meatiness and pork quality. Animal Science Papers and Reports 2003;21:153–61. 21. Brewer MS, Zhu LG, McKeith FK. Marbling effects on quality characteristics of pork loin chops: consumer purchase intent, visual and sensory characteristics. Meat Science 2001;59:153–63. 22. Warriss PD, Bevis EA, Ekins PJ. The relationship between glycogen stores and muscle ultimate pH in commercially slaughtered pigs. British Veterinary Journal 1989;145:378–83. 23. Wulf DM, Emnett RS, Leheska JM, Moeller SJ. Relationships among glycolytic potential, dark cutting (dark, firm, and dry) beef, and cooked beef palatability. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:1895–903. 24. Oksbjerg N, Henckel P, Andersen S, Pedersen B, Nielsen B. Genetic variation of in vivo muscle glycerol, glycogen, and pigment in Danish purebred pigs. Acta Agriculture Scandinavica, Section A, Animal Science 2005;54:187–92. 25. Temisan V, Augustini C. Qualita¨tsrindfleisch – Definition, Standardisierung, Wege zur Erzeugung. Fleischwirtschaft 1989;69:31–7. 26. Nuernberg K, Wegner J, Ender K. Factors influencing fat composition in muscle and adipose tissue of farm animals. Livestock Production Science 1998;56:145–56. 27. Purchas RW, Burnham DI, Morris ST. Effect of growth potential path on tenderness of beef longissimus muscle form bulls and steers. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:3211–21. 28. Scheeder MR, Meili E, Bezencon M, Spring J, Kreuzer M. Beziehungen zwischen dem Alter von Rindern und Ochsen aus einem Weidemastverfahren und Merkmalen der Fleischtextur (Zartheit). Schriftenreihe Institut fu¨r Nutztierwissenschaften, ETH Zu¨rich, 2007;29:140–3. 29. Frickh JJ, Steinwidder A, Baumung R. Einfluss von Rationsgestaltung, Geschlecht und Mastendgewicht auf die Fleischqualita¨t von Flechvieh-Tieren. Zu¨chtungskunde 2003;75:16–30. 30. Fisher A. Beef carcass classification in the EU: an historical perspective. EAAP Publication 2007;123:19–30. 31. Willer H, Yussefi M. The World of Organic Agriculture 2007: Statistics and Emerging Trends. 7th ed. International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements Publication (IFOAM), 2007. Available from: URL: http://www.soel.de/ oekolandbau/weltweit.html (accessed 15 November 2008). 32. IFOAM (International Federation of Organic Agricultural Movement). Principles of Organic Agriculture. Bonn, Germany; 2006. 33. Sundrum A. Organic livestock farming – a critical review. Livestock Production Science 2001;67:207–15.
g
34. Alroe HF, Noel E. What makes organic agriculture move – protest, meaning or market? A polyocular approach to the dynamics and governance of organic agriculture. International Journal of Agricultural Resources, Governance and Ecology 2008;7:5–22. 35. Vaarst M, Padel S, Arsenos G, Sundrum A, Kuzniar A, Walkenhorst M, et al. Challenges for animal health and welfare in the implementation of the EU legislation on organic livestock production: analysis of questionnaire survey among SAFO participants. In: Rymer C, Vaarst M, Padel S, editors. Future Perspectives for Animal Health on Organic Farms: Main Findings, Conclusions and Recommendations from the SAFO Network. 5th SAFO-Workshop, 30–31 May 2006, Odense, Denmark; 2006. p. 43–74. 36. NCBA (National Cattlemens’s Beef Association). National Beef Instrument Assessment Plan II. NCBA, Englewood, CO; 2002. 37. Ender K, Fiedler I, Dietl G. Muskelstrukturmerkmale fu¨r die Selektion beim Schwein. Archiv Tierzucht Dummerstorf 2003;46:72–7. 38. Murray A, Pommier S, Robertson W, Johns M. Effect of genotype on marbling content. Advances in Pork Production 2004;15, Abstract 17. 39. Mo¨rlein D. Bestimmung des intramuskula¨ren Fettgehaltes (IMF) im M. longissimus von Schweinen mittels Ultraschallspektralanalyse (dissertation). Halle University; 2005. 40. Fischer K, Lindner JP, Judas M, Ho¨reth R. Schlachtko¨rperzusammensetzung und Gewebebeschaffenheit von schweren Schweinen – II. Mitteilung: Merkmale der Fleisch- und Fettqualita¨t. Archiv Tierzucht 2006;49:279–92. 41. Sundrum A, Ebke M. Problems and challenges with the certification of organic pigs. In: Hovi M, Sundrum A, Padel S, editors. Proceedings of the 2nd SAFO-Workshop, 25–27 March 2004, Kassel, Germany; 2004. p. 193–8. 42. Jonsa¨ll A, Johansson L, Lundstro¨m K, Andersson KH, Nilsen AN, Risvik E. Effects of genotype and rearing system on sensory characteristics and preference for pork. Food Quality and Preference 2002;13:73–80. 43. Olsson V, Andersson K, Hansson I, Lundstro¨m K. Differences in meat quality between organically and conventionally produced pigs. Meat Science 2003;64:287–97. 44. Abel S, Weissensteiner R, Marien C, Zollitsch W, Sundrum A. Effect of a feeding strategy to increase intramuscular fat content of pork under the conditions of organic farming. In: Proceedings of the Second Scientific Conference of the International Society of Organic Agriculture Research (ISOFAR), 18–20 June 2008, Modena, Italy, 2008. p. 198–201. 45. Sundrum A, Aragon A, Schulze-Langenhorst C, Bu¨tfering L, Henning M, Stalljohann G. Implications of genotype and amino acid sup-ply on pork quality. In: Proceedings of the European Joint Congress Organic Farming and European Rural Development, 30–31 May 2006, Odense, Denmark; 2006. p. 542–3. 46. Millet S, Hesta M, Seynaeve M, Ongenae E, De Smet S, Debraekeleer J, et al. Performance, meat and carcass traits of fattening pigs with organic versus conventional housing and nutrition. Livestock Production Science 2004;87:109–19.
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum 47. Millet S, Ongenae E, Hesta M, Seynaeve M, De Smet S, Janssens GP. The feeding of ad libitum dietary protein to organic growing-finishing pigs. Veterinary Journal 2006;171:483–90. 48. Hansen LL, Claudi-Magnussen C, Jensen SK, Andersen HJ. Effect of organic pig production systems on performance and meat quality. Meat Science 2006;74:605–15. 49. Partanen K, Siljander-Rasi H, Alaviuhkola T. Feeding weaned piglets and growing-finishing pigs with diets based on mainly home-grown organic feedstuffs. Agricultural and Food Science 2006;15:89–105. 50. Heyer A, Andersson KH, Lundstro¨m K. Performance, carcass and technological meat quality of pigs in indoor and outdoor production system.Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A Animal Science 2006;56:55–64. 51. Woodward BW, Fernandez MI. Comparison of conventional and organic beef production systems II. Carcass characteristics. Livestock Production Science 1999;61:225–31. 52. Nielsen BK, Thamsborg SM. Welfare, health and product quality in organic beef production: a Danish perspective. Livestock Production Science 2005;94:41–50. 53. Russo C, Preziuso G. Carcass and meat quality of organic beef: a brief review. Animal Breeding Abstracts 2005;73:11N–14N. 54. Susenbeth A, Dickel T, Diekenhorst A, Hohler D. The effect of energy intake, genotype and body weight on protein retention in pigs when dietary lysine is the first-limiting factor. Journal of Animal Science 1999;77:2985–9. 55. Ventanas S, Ventanas J, Jurado A, Este´vez M. Quality traits in muscle biceps femoris and back-fat from purebred Iberian and reciprocal IberianDuroc crossbred pigs. Meat Science 2006;73:651–9. 56. Fujii J, Otsu K, Zorzato F, De Leon S, Khanna VK, Weiler JE, et al. Identification of a mutation in the porcine ryanodine receptor associated with malignant hyperthermia. Science 1991;253:448–51. 57. Monin G, Larzul C, Le Roy P, Culioli J, Mourot J, RoussetAkrim S, et al. Effects of the halothane genotype and slaughter weight on texture of pork. Journal Animal Science 1999;77:408–15. 58. Oksbjerg N. Effects of manipulating muscle glycogen on meat quality in pigs. In: Garnsworthy PC, Wiseman J, editors. Recent Advances in Animal Nutrition 2006. Nottingham University Press, Nottingham, UK; 2007. p. 229–41. 59. Cassens RG. Historical perspectives and current aspects of pork meat quality in the USA. Food Chemistry 2000;69:357–63. 60. Stamer E, Brade W, Kalm E. Genetic trends in different MHS genotypes of Pietrain boars in Lower Saxony. Zu¨chtungskunde 2008;80:279–90. 61. Le Roy P, Moreno C, Elsen JM, Caritez JC, Billon Y, Lagant H, et al. Interactive effects of the HAL and RN major genes on carcass quality traits in pigs: preliminary results. EAAP Publication 2000;100:139–42. 62. Jonsa¨ll A, Johansson L, Lundstro¨m K. Sensory quality and cooking loss of ham muscle (M. biceps femoris) from pigs reared indoors and outdoors. Meat Science 2001;57:245–50.
g
45
63. De Vries AG, Faucitano L, Sosnicki A, Plastow GS. Influence of genetics on pork quality. EAAP Publication 2000;100:27–35. 64. Wood JD. Consequences for meat quality of reducing carcass fatness. In: Wood JD, Fisher AV, editors. Reducing Fat in Meat Animals. Elsevier Applied Science, London; 1990. p. 344–97. 65. Schwo¨rer D, Hofer A, Lorenz D, Rebsamen A. Selection progress of intramuscular fat in Swiss pig production. EAAP Publication 2000;100:69–72. 66. Edwards SA, Wood JD, Moncrieff CB, Porter SJ. Comparison of the Duroc and Large White as terminal sire breeds and their effect on pigmeat quality. Animal Production 1992;54:289–97. 67. Ellis M, Webb AJ, Avery PI, Brown I. The influence of terminal sire genotype, sex, slaughter weight, feeding regime and slaughter-house on growth performance and carcass and meat quality in pigs and on the organoleptic properties of fresh pork. Animal Science 1996;62:521–30. 68. Campion DR, Crouse JD, Dikeman ME. Predictive value of UDSA beef quality grade factors for cooked and meat palatability. Journal of Food Science 1975;40:1225–8. 69. San˜udo C, Albertı´ P, Campo MM, Olleta JL, Panea B. Instrumental quality of beef meat from seven Spanish breeds. Archives of Zootechnology 1998;48:397–402. 70. Augustini C, Pirchner F, Eichinger H, Reinsch N, Ko¨gel J. Fleisch-Leistung der gefa¨hrdeten bayrischen Rinderrassen. 2. Mitteilung: Fleischqualita¨t. Zu¨chtungskunde 1998;70:328–37. 71. Serra X, Guerrero L, Gua`rdia MD, Gil M, San˜udo C, Panea B, et al. Eating quality of young bulls from three Spanish beef breed-production systems and its relationships with chemical and instrumental meat quality. Meat Science 2008;79:98–104. 72. Vieira C, Garcı´ a-Cacha´n MD, Recio MD, Domı´ nguez M, San˜udo C. Effect of ageing time on beef quality of rustic type and rusticCharolais crossbreed cattle slaughtered at the same finishing grade. Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research 2006;4:225–34. 73. Lively FO, Moss BW, Keady TW, Patterson DC, Gordan AG. The effect of genotype and carcass hanging method on eating quality. In: Proceedings of the 51st International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, 7–12 August 2005, Baltimore, MD; 2005. p. 1808–14. 74. Sapp RL, Bertrand JK, Pringle TD, Wilson DE. Effects of selection for ultrasound intramuscular fat percentage in Angus bulls on carcass traits of progeny. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:2017–22. 75. Bindon BM. A review of genetic and non-genetic opportunities for manipulation of marbling. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:687–96. 76. Morgan JB, Wheeler TI, Koohmaraie M, Savell JW, Crouse JD. Meat tenderness and the calpain system in longissimus muscle of young bulls and steers. Journal of Animal Science 1993;71:1471–6. 77. Maher SC, Mullen AM, Keane MG, Buckley DJ, Kerry JP, Moloney AP. Variation in the eating quality of M. longissimus dorsi from Holstein-Friesian bulls and steers of New Zealand and European/American descent, and Belgian BlueHolstein-Friesians, slaughtered at two weights. Livestock Production Science 2004;90:271–7.
CAB International 2009
46
Animal Science Reviews 2010
78. Schreurs NM, Garcia F, Jurie C, Agabriel J, Micol D, Bauchart D, et al. Meta-analysis of the effect of animal maturity on muscle characteristics in different muscles, breeds, and sexes of cattle. Journal of Animal Science 2008;86:2872–87. 79. Sundrum A, Schneider K, Richter U. Possibilities and limitations of protein supply in organic poultry and pig production. In: Proceedings of the European Joint Congress Organic Farming and European Rural Development, 30–31 May 2006, Odense, Denmark, 2006. p. 528–9. 80. Rosenvold K, Petersen JS, Laerke HN, Jensen SK, Therkildsen M, Karlsson AH, et al. Muscle glycogen stores and meat quality as affected by strategic finishing feeding of slaughter pigs. Journal of Animal Science 2001;79:382–91. 81. Cisneros F, Ellis M, Baker DH, Easter RA, McKeith FK. The influence of short-term feeding of amino acid-deficient diets and high dietary leucine levels on the intramuscular fat content of pig muscle. Journal of Animal Science 1996;63:517–22. 82. D’Souza DN, Pethick DW, Dunshear FR, Mullan BP. Nutritional manipulation increases intramuscular fat levels in the longissimus muscle of finisher pigs. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 2003;54:745–9. 83. Cameron ND, Enser M, Nute GR, Whittington FM, Penman JC, Fisken AC, et al. Genotype with nutrition interaction on fatty acid composition of intramuscular fat and the relationship with flavour of pig meat. Meat Science 2000;55:187–95. 84. Katsumata M, Kobayashi S, Matsumoto M, Tsuneishi E, Kayi Y. Reduced intake of dietary lysine promotes accumulation of intramuscular fat in the M. longissimus dorsi muscle of finishing gilts. Animal Science Japan 2005;76:237–44. 85. Oksbjerg N, Strudsholm K, Lindahl G, Hermansen John E. Meat quality of fully or partly outdoor reared pigs in organic production. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A Animal Science 2005;55:106–12. 86. Candek-Potokar M, Zlender B, Lefaucheur L, Bonneau M. Effects of age and/or weight at slaughter on longissimus dorsi muscle: biochemical traits and sensory quality in pigs. Meat Science 1998;48:287–300. 87. Schinckel AP, Smith JW, Tokach MD, Dritz SS, Einstein M, Nelssen JL, et al. Two on-farm data collection method to determine dynamics of swine compositional growth and estimates of dietary lysine requirements. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:1419–32. 88. Lebret B, Juin H, Noblet J, Bonneau M. The effects of two methods of increasing age at slaughter on carcass and muscle traits and meat sensory quality in pigs. Animal Science 2001;72:87–94. 89. Le Bellego L, Van Milgen J, Noblet J. Effect of high ambient temperature on protein and lipid deposition and energy utilization in growing pigs. Animal Science 2002;75:85–96. 90. Hyun M, Ellis M. Effect of group size and feeder type on growth performance and feeding patterns in growing pigs. Journal of Animal Science 2001;79:803–10. 91. Scho¨nfelder A. The effect of rank order a feed intake and growth of fattening pigs. Deutsche Tiera¨rztliche Wochenschrift 2005;112:215–8.
g
92. Botermans JA, Svendsen J. Effect of feeding environment on performance, injuries and behaviour in growing-finishing pigs: group-based studies. Acta Agriculture Scandinavica Section A, Animal Science 2000;50:237–49. 93. Wolter BF, Ellis M, Curtis SE, Parr EN, Webel DM. Effect of feeder-through space and variation in body weight within a pen of pigs on performance in a wean-to-finish production system. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:2241–6. 94. Whittemore CT, Tullis JB, Emmans GC. Protein growth in pigs. Animal Production 1988;46:437–45. 95. Sainz RD, Vernazza Paganini RF. Effects of different grazing and feeding periods on performance and carcass traits of beef steers. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:292–7. 96. Pethick DW, Harper GS, Oddy VH. Growth, development and nutritional manipulation of marbling in cattle: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 2004;44:705–15. 97. Nuernberg K, Dannenberger D, Nuernberg G, Ender K, Voigt J, Scollan ND, et al. Effect of a grass-based and a concentrate feeding system on meat quality characteristics and fatty acid composition of longissimus muscle in different cattle breeds. Livestock Production Science 2005;94:137–47. 98. O’Sullivan A, O’Sullivan KO, Galvin K, Moloney AP, Troy DJ, Kerry JP. Grass silage versus maize silage effects on retail packaged beef quality. Journal of Animal Science 2002;80:1556–63. 99. French P, O’Riordana EG, Monahan FJ, Caffrey PJ, Vidal M, Mooney MT, et al. Meat quality of steers finished on autumn grass, grass silage or concentrate-based diets. Meat Science 2000;56:173–80. 100. Hansen S, Therkildsen M, Byrne DV. Effects of a compensatory growth strategy on sensory and physical properties of meat from young bulls. Meat Science 2006;74:628–43. 101. Grunert KG, Bredahl L, Brunso K. Consumer perception of meat quality and implications for product development in the meat sector – a review. Meat Science 2004;66:227–59. 102. Kubberod E, Ueland O, Tronstad A, Risvik E. Attitudes towards meat and meat-eating among adolescents in Norway: a qualitative study. Appetite 2002;38:53–62. 103. McEachern MG, Schro¨der MJ. The role of livestock production ethics in consumer values towards meat. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 2002;15:221–37. 104. Jeremiah LE. Consumer responses to pork loin chops with different degrees of muscle quality in two western Canadian cities. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 1994;74:425–32. 105. Dransfield E, Ngapo TM, Nielsen NA, Bredahl L, Sjo¨den PO, Magnusson M, et al. Consumer choice and suggested price for pork as influenced by its appearance, taste and information concerning country of origin and organic pig production. Meat Science 2005;69:61–70. 106. Killinger KM, Calkins CR, Umberger WJ, Feuz DM, Eskridge KM. Consumer visual preference and value for beef steaks differing in marbling level and color. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:3288–93. 107. Boleman SJ, Boleman SL, Miller RK, Taylor JF, Cross HR, Wheeler TL, et al. Consumer evaluation of beef of known categories of tenderness. Journal of Animal Science 1997;75:1521–4.
CAB International 2009
Albert Sundrum 108. Platter WJ, Tatum JD, Belk KE, Koontz SR, Chapman PL, Smith GC. Effects of marbling and shear force on consumers’ willingness to pay for beef strip loin steaks. Journal of Animal Science 2005;83:890–9. 109. Oliver MA, Nute GR, Font i Furnols M, San Julian R, Campo MM, Sanudo C, et al. Eating quality of beef, from different production systems, assessed by German, Spanish and British consumers. Meat Science 2006;74:435–43. 110. Sundrum A. From a standard to an output oriented approach in organic live-stock farming. In: Proceedings of the European Joint Congress Organic Farming and European
g
47
Rural Development, 30–31 May 2006, Odense, Denmark; 2006. p. 508–9. 111. German Research Foundation (DFG). Future Perspectives of Agricultural Science and Research. Wiley-VCH Publisher, Bonn, Germany; 2005. 112. Sundrum A. Achievements of research in the field of livestock systems and quality production. In: Rosati A, Tewolde A, Mosconi C, editors. Animal Production and Animal Science Worldwide. WAAP Book of the Year 2006. Wageningen Academic Publishers, Wageningen, The Netherlands; 2007. p. 95–106.
CAB International 2009
This page intentionally left blank
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Whole genome marker-assisted selection Joel I. Weller* Address: Institute of Animal Sciences, A.R.O., The Volcani Center, PO Box 6, Bet Dagan 50250, Israel. *Correspondence: Email:
[email protected] 24 November 2009 25 January 2010
Received: Accepted:
Abstract Most applications of genomic selection (GS) have so far been in animals, especially dairy cattle, although theoretical studies have also been conducted for maize. For the last 50 years, commercial breeding programmes for dairy cattle have been based on the progeny test scheme, which results in an average generation interval of approximately 7 years for the sire to dam path. It should be possible to double rates of genetic gain by the application of GS, if generation intervals are reduced to close to the biological minimum. During the last decade, methods were developed for highthroughput genotyping of thousands of single nucleotide polymorphisms per individuals. The number of potential polymorphic markers per species was increased from about 1000 to tens of thousands, and costs per individual marker genotype were reduced from several dollars to less than one cent. The application of marker-assisted selection based on genome-wide association studies requires solutions to new statistical problems. Specifically how should information from pedigree, phenotypic records and genotypes be combined to optimally rank candidates for selection? Various linear and Bayesian methods have been proposed and tested to compute genomic estimated breeding values. Linear models require significantly less computing time, and perform nearly as well as Bayesian methodologies. Methods are generally evaluated by comparing genomic evaluations based only on pedigree and genotype to genetic evaluations based on daughter records of the same bulls. Genomic selection programmes for dairy cattle have been implemented in the USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the Netherlands. With declining genotyping costs it becomes economically viable to genotype more individuals, including candidate bull dams. More emphasis can be placed on low heritability traits, such as fertility and disease traits, and it will be easier to control the increase in inbreeding in commercial animal populations. Keywords: Genomic selection, linkage disequilibrium mapping, marker-assisted selection, genomic estimated breeding values, single nucleotide polymorphism Review Methodology: ISI Web of Knowledge and PubMed were searched using the key words ‘genomic selection’.
Introduction During the 1950s and 1960s, advance breeding programmes were developed for most economically important plant and animal species. These programmes were based on the ‘infinitesimal model’ of quantitative genetic inheritance [1], that is, quantitative traits are controlled by a very large number of genetic and environmental factors, and the effect of any specific factor is very small. The infinitesimal model and the statistical techniques developed made virtually no use of the principles of Mendelian genetics.
g
In 1923, Sax [2] first demonstrated with beans that individual genes affecting quantitative traits, denoted ‘quantitative trait loci’ (QTL), could be detected with the aid of morphological genetic markers. In 1961, NeimannSørensen and Robertson [3] used blood groups as genetic markers to detect QTL in dairy cattle. Although a number of papers were written during the next two decades on QTL detection, the application of QTL to breeding was limited by the lack of segregating genetic markers in commercial populations. With the advent of molecularlevel genetic markers in the 1980s and microsatellites or
CAB International 2010
50
Animal Science Reviews 2010
‘simple sequence repeats’ (SSRs) in the 1990s [4], markerassisted selection (MAS) in both plants and animals became possible; although costs of defining individual genotypes were still relatively expensive. During the last decade, methods were developed for high-throughput genotyping of thousands of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) per individual [5]. The number of potential polymorphic markers per species was increased from about 1000 to tens of thousands, and costs per individual marker genotype were reduced from several dollars to less than one cent. In this review, I will describe in detail the application of genomic selection (GS) to cattle, because most of the theoretical literature has dealt with this species. I will then briefly describe methodologies for GS in plants, and finally consider directions for future research.
50 candidate bulls 30 000 cows 5000 daughters
Records on daughters
100 elite cows
3 foreign bulls
200 elite cows
4 local bulls
120 000 cows 20 bulls
5 bulls are selected 55 bulls are culled
Figure 1 A traditional progeny-test breeding scheme for a dairy cattle population of 120 000 cows
DNA-level Genetic Markers, SSRs versus SNPs Traditional Dairy Cattle Breeding Schemes Commercial dairy cattle breeding has been based on the constraints that nearly all economic traits are expressed only in females, while female fertility is extremely limited. Heritabilites of all important economic traits are low to moderate. Therefore, in order to utilize the nearly unlimited fertility of males, most advanced breeding programmes are based on the ‘progeny test scheme’. An example is given in Figure 1. A cohort of male calves is selected based on pedigree, and each of these calves sires between 50 and 100 milking cows. On the basis of the records of their daughters and other female relatives, about 10% of these calves are returned to general service and the rest are slaughtered. This scheme allows for high selection intensities along the sire-to-sire, sire-to-dam and dam-to-sire genetic paths, but results in generation intervals much greater than required by biological constraints. Although bull calves reach sexual maturity at the age of 1 year, milk production records on their first crop of daughters are only available when the bull calves are 5 years old. Rates of genetic gain could be doubled if the genetic paths generation intervals were reduced to near the biological limits [6, 7]. All else remaining equal, reducing the mean generation interval on the sire-to-dam path from 7 to 3 years will increase the annual rate of genetic gain by 20%. The rate of genetic gain per generation is a function of the selection intensity and the accuracy of the estimated breeding values (EBV). ‘Accuracy’ is defined as the correlation between the genetic evaluation and the actual genetic value, while ‘reliability’ is defined as the square of this correlation. Based on pedigree only, that is, the EBV of the calf’s sire and dam, the accuracy of the calf’s genetic evaluation for milk production traits with heritabilities close to 0.3 will be at most 0.6, as compared with an accuracy of 0.9 after completion of the progeny test.
g
SSRs consist of tandem repeats of a sequence of 1–4 DNA base pairs, the most common being ‘TG’. SSRs are polymorphic in the number of repeats of the core sequence. In the early 1990s, SSRs became the marker of choice, chiefly because of their high polymorphic information content and relative ease of genotyping [8]. Thousands of SSR sequences are scattered throughout the genomes of all advance organisms. Genetic maps of at least several hundred SSRs were developed for nearly all the important agricultural species (e.g. http://www.thearkdb.org/). Unlike SSRs, SNPs are nearly always biallelic. SNPs occur at a frequency of approximately 0.3–1 SNP/kb throughout the human genome [5], and apparently at equal frequencies in other mammalian species. Advantages of SNPs are summarized by Werner et al. [9]. Genotyping error rates tend to be lower for SNPs [10, 11], larger numbers of markers can be run jointly and genotype determination is completely automatic, eliminating what is generally the largest cost element of genotyping [11, 12]. In January 2008, Illumina announced the release of the Infinium1 BovineSNP50 BeadChip, which includes 54 001 SNPs approximately evenly spaced across the entire bovine genome (http://www.illumina.com/products/bovine_snp50_wholegenome_genotyping_kits.ilmn). Similar bead chips have been developed for the other major commercial animal species, and SNP chips with >1 million SNPs are available for humans.
QTL Detection and MAS Prior to SNPs Detection of QTL requires generation of linkage disequilibrium (LD) between the genetic markers and the QTL. In plants, this is generally accomplished by crossing inbred lines to produce either F2 or backcross populations [13]. These options are not available for farm animals in which inbred lines are not available and breeding is conducted within breeds. Until 2006, the most appropriate experimental designs for QTL detection and
CAB International 2010
Joel I. Weller
analysis in cattle were the daughter and granddaughter designs [14]. These designs have been applied to nearly all advanced dairy cattle populations [13]. Numerous QTL have been identified in farm animals, and this information has been summarized for cattle at two web sites: http:// www.vetsci.usyd.edu.au/reprogen/QTL_Map/ and http:// www.animalgenome.org/QTLdb/cattle.html. Limited use was made of this information in commercial animal breeding programmes. Unlike plant breeding, animal breeding is generally conducted within a single breed, or within a small number of breeds. For a QTL to be useful in an MAS animal breeding programme it must fulfil the following criteria: 1. Given the huge multiple comparison problem, normal significance levels of 0.01 or even 0.001 are meaningless. Confidence that a segregating QTL has in fact been detected is only obtained if the observation is repeated in several independent studies [15]. 2. The effect should be sufficiently large so that the confidence interval for QTL location is small enough so that a haplotype including the QTL can be determined and followed through pedigrees. This problem is alleviated if the causative quantitative trait nucleotide has been identified, but this has been accomplished for dairy cattle in only two cases [16, 17]. 3. The net effect of the QTL on the selection index must be significant. For example, in the polymorphism in the gene DGAT1 the allele that increases fat production decreases protein production [17], so the net effect on most current selection indices is close to zero. 4. Scope for selection is possible only if the frequency of the economically positive allele is relatively low.
51
criterion of the false discovery rate, many more statistically significant SNP effects have been found, as compared with linkage-based genome scans [24–26]. The apparent reasons are as follows: 1. LD effects can be tested by a simple linear model of number of ‘+’ alleles on the bulls’ EBV or daughter yield deviation (DYD) [26]. This test is inherently more powerful than the test of significance for linkage that must be conducted within families. 2. Genome coverage with tens of thousands of SNPs is more complete. 3. Unlike granddaughter designs, which can only utilize bulls from large half-sib families, all sires with evaluation can be included in LD analyses. Thus, effective sample sizes are greater. The results of Cole et al. [25] and VanRaden et al. [26] for the US Holstein population confirm that at least with respect to the QTN that have been detected, results of GWAS do correspond to the results obtained previously by granddaughter designs. The largest effects found were for protein concentration on Bos taurus chromosome (BTA) 6 and fat concentration on BTA14. The effects on BTA6 flanked the ABCG2 gene, which has been shown to have a major effect for this trait [16], and the effects on BTA14 flanked the DGAT1 gene [17], which has a major effect on fat concentration with lesser effects on milk and fat yield. Both effects were first discovered by daughter and granddaughter designs.
Estimation of QTL Effects from Genome Scans
No QTL detected so far in dairy cattle meet all four of these criteria. Nevertheless, MAS breeding programmes based on microsatellites were started in Germany and France in 2001, both based on following a rather limited number of chromosomal regions [18, 19].
The application of MAS based on GWAS requires solutions to new statistical problems. Specifically, how should information from pedigree, phenotypic records and genotypes be combined to optimally rank candidates for selection? Goddard and Hayes [27] proposed that GS could be divided into three steps:
Genome Scans, Within Family Linkage versus Population-wide LD
1. Use the markers to deduce the genotype of each animal at each QTL. 2. Estimate the effects of each QTL genotype on the trait. 3. Sum all the QTL effects for selection candidates to obtain their genomic estimated breeding values (GEBV).
Meuwissen and Goddard [20] proposed that confidence intervals for QTL location could be dramatically reduced by the application of population-wide LD mapping. Unlike analysis of genetic linkage within families that extends over tens of cM, population-wide LD extends in dairy cattle at most only over individual cMs [21]. The application of LD mapping therefore requires much denser genetic maps than required for the detection of QTL via linkage, but does not require a specific family structure [22]. Since the first reports of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) based on dense arrays of SNPs in 2006 [23], very few specific results of effects detected and their locations have been published. All studies agree that based on the
g
Estimation of QTL effects by LD from genome scans is problematic, firstly because only a very small fraction of the population will be genotyped. Furthermore, these will generally be males without records on the traits of interest. In addition, there are at least five potential sources of bias. Firstly, estimated effects will be underestimated because LD between any specific marker and the QTL will be incomplete. Thus only part of the QTL effect will be detected. Secondly, if the effects of the SNP
CAB International 2010
52
Animal Science Reviews 2010
are analysed on sires, then the dependent variable analysed will generally be the sires’ EBV or DYD. EBV for commercial dairy cattle populations are generally computed by an individual animal model, based on the principles of best linear unbiased prediction (BLUP) [13, 28]. All animals with records and all known ancestors are included in the analysis, and the heritability is assumed known. The additive genetic effect is assumed to be random, and ‘nuisance’ effects, such as the cows’ herd–year– seasons are assumed to be fixed. The genetic variance is computed as the numerator relationship matrix times a scalar equal to the genetic variance among unrelated animals. EBV computed by the animal model are regressed in proportion to the amount of information available for each animal. Thus, if QTL effects are estimated by analysis of EBV, the effects will be underestimated [29]. The problem is somewhat alleviated if DYD, which are unregressed means of daughter records corrected for fixed effects, are analysed instead of EBV. Unlike EBV, the variances of DYD decrease with an increase in the number of daughters. Thus, weighting DYD by the bulls’ reliabilities in an analysis of marker effects is in accordance with the generalized least-squares principle that records with greater variance should be given smaller weights. However, estimates of QTL effects based on analysis of DYD will still be biased [30]. In addition, there are three sources of upward bias. In a simple regression model, animals that are related will tend to have a higher probability to inherit the same marker alleles identical by descent. Since these animals also have a common polygenic variance, the estimated effect will also include a polygenic component because of relationships [31]. Various studies have proposed that this problem could be solved by inclusion of the inverse of relationship matrix in the analysis (e.g. [32]). However, if EBV or DYD are analysed, and the QTL effect is assumed to be a random variable, the distributional properties of the model are problematic. If the residual variance in this model represents deviation of the ‘record’ from the animal’s true additive variance, a DYD or EBV based on thousands of daughters should then have a residual variance approaching zero. The second source of upward bias is because of the fact that only a small fraction of the markers will be linked to segregating QTL. Beavis [33] first noted that the estimates for effects deemed ‘significant’ will be biased as only the largest effects will be reported and retained for further analysis. Bias will be greater for small effects for the following reason. Although large QTL effects will be deemed significant in any case, small or marginal effects will be denoted ‘significant’ only if the estimate is larger than the actual effect [33, 34]. Since in nearly all QTL analyses only the absolute value of the effect is considered, leastsquares estimates will be inflated because of non-zero residuals. Assuming that the residual and the actual QTL effects are uncorrelated, the variance of the least-squares estimates will be equal to the sum of the residual and true
g
QTL effect variance. Thus, positive values for QTL effects will be obtained even in the absence of a segregating QTL. The third source of upward bias results from the fact that when a LOD score or regression effect is maximized over many point-wise tests in interval mapping, the locusspecific effect-size estimate is also maximized, and this will tend to be greater than the actual QTL effect [35]. This will also be the case for the LD mapping [20, 36].
Studies on the Distribution of QTL Effects Several studies have proposed that the second source of upward bias could be alleviated by the application of Bayesian estimation methods (e.g. [37]). Bayesian estimation differs from maximum likelihood estimation in that in Bayesian estimation the likelihood function is multiplied by the ‘prior distribution’ of the parameters. This generally results in ‘shrinkage’ of the parameter estimates, but requires assumptions about the nature of distribution of QTL effects. If many QTL are analysed jointly, it should be possible to estimate both the QTL effects and the parameters of the distribution of QTL effects [38]. The extent of shrinkage will vary inversely with the sample size. Hayes et al. [39] estimated that the number of detectable QTL affecting milk production is on the order of 150, based on a whole genome scan with 10 000 SNPs, while Chamberlain et al. [40] estimated the total number of QTL at 30 by analysis of a daughter design. These studies demonstrate that most of the additive genetic variance can be explained by QTL that can be detected by SNP genome scans, provided that the number of animals analysed and the SNP densities are sufficient. A number of studies have considered the question of the appropriate distribution for QTL effects, and in nearly all cases a single-sided distribution was assumed; that is, the QTL effect was assumed to vary from zero to infinity. Hayes and Goddard [37] estimated the distribution of QTL effects for cattle and swine by combining results from several studies. They assumed a gamma distribution for the QTL effects. The dairy cattle analysis was based on the QTL estimates from three granddaughter design analyses, considering only ‘significant’ effects. Thus, a truncated gamma distribution was assumed. Weller et al. [38] estimated the parameters of the distribution of QTL effects for nine economic traits in dairy cattle from a daughter design analysis of the Israeli Holstein population including 490 marker-by-sire contrasts [41]. A separate gamma distribution was derived for each trait. The estimates derived for the individual QTL effects using the gamma distributions for each trait were regressed relative to the least-squares estimates, but the regression factor decreased as a function of the least-squares estimate. On simulated data, the mean of least-squares estimates for effects with nominal 1% significance was more than twice the simulated values, while the mean of the maximum
CAB International 2010
Joel I. Weller
likelihood estimates was slightly lower than the mean of the simulated values. The coefficient of determination for the Bayesian estimates was five-fold the corresponding value for the least-squares estimates.
Appropriate Criteria for Evaluation of GEBV Evaluation of methodology to compute GEBV are generally based on analysis of a population of bulls with EBV derived from progeny tests. The population is then divided into two sets. In the ‘training set’ consisting of older bulls, all information including genotypes, genetic relationships and daughter records are used to estimate the marker effects. In the ‘validation set’ consisting of younger bulls, GEBV are computed based only on the marker genotype effects derived from the training set and pedigree. The GEBV of the validation set of bulls are then compared with the EBV of these bulls based on their daughter records and relationships [26, 42]. Most studies that have compared GEBV with EBV based on daughter records have done so on the basis of coefficients of determination between the two evaluations [42]. Although this criterion is important, a second criterion is the bias of GEBV. That is, GEBV are unbiased if the regression of true breeding values on GEBV is not significantly different from unity and the y-intercept is not significantly different from zero [43]. If the regression is less than unity, then the bulls with the highest GEBV will be inflated relative to the true genetic values of these bulls.
Implementation of Methodology to Compute GEBV for Dairy Cattle ‘Interbull’, a sub-committee of the International Committee for Animal Recording, is responsible for promoting the development and execution of international genetic evaluations for cattle. Nine countries (Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Ireland, Israel, New Zealand, the Netherlands and the USA), responded to the Interbull survey question: ‘Which methodology is being used to estimate SNP effects [24]?’ Several different methods are being implemented. Four countries have adopted Bayesian methods, described briefly previously. ‘Bayes-A’ and ‘Bayes-B’ methodology differ in that in Bayes-A all marker included in the analysis are assumed to have a non-zero effect on the trait analysed, while in Bayes-B methodology it is assumed that most markers have no effect [44]. Bayes-B methods are clearly closer to reality, but require significantly greater computing time. Other methodologies will now be discussed in detail. VanRaden [32] proposed analysis of DYD as the dependent variable with all SNPs included as random effects. Genotypes for 38 416 informative markers of the 54 001 included on the BeadChip and the August, 2003,
g
53
genetic evaluations for 3576 Holstein bulls born before 1999 were used to predict the January, 2008, daughter deviations for 1759 bulls born from 1999 through 2002. GEBV were computed using linear and non-linear genomic models. For linear predictions, the traditional additive genetic relationship matrix was replaced by a genomic relationship matrix, which is equivalent to assigning equal genetic variance to all markers. Final GEBV combined three terms by selection index: 1. Direct genomic prediction. 2. Parent averages computed from the set of genotyped ancestors using traditional relationships. 3. Published parent averages or pedigree indexes, constructed as 0.5(sire EBV)+0.25(maternal grandsire EBV) + 0.25(birth year mean EBV). Combined predictions were more accurate than official parent averages for all 27 traits analysed [26]. Reliabilities were 0.02 to 0.38 higher than non-linear genomic predictions included as compared with parent averages alone. Misztal et al. [43] found that regressions of EBV based on progeny tests on GEBV derived by this method were less than unity for the trait ‘final score’ (a conformation trait). Regressions for other traits have not been published. Variations of this method have also been applied to other national dairy cattle populations, e.g. as described by Liu et al. [45]. GEBV have been published in the US since April 2008. Nearly all of the top US bulls are currently young bulls with GEBV, but without progeny tests (http:// aipl.arsusda.gov/dynamic/sortnew/current/OHOnm.html). The same data were also analysed by Bayes-A and Bayes-B procedures [32]. In the Bayes-A analysis, the prior distribution was a simple, heavy-tailed distribution generated from a normal variable divided by 1.25abs(s–2), where s is the number of standard deviations from the mean and 1.25 determines departure from normality. In the Bayes-B analysis, only 700 markers of 50 000 included in the analysis were assumed to have non-zero effects. Gains in realized reliabilities were minimal, as compared with the linear model [26]. Similar results were found for Australian dairy cattle [42]. This is not surprising considering that very large samples of bulls were analysed. Therefore ‘shrinkage’ of estimates by Bayesian methodology should be minimal. Advantages of the multistage system for genomic evaluation include no change to the regular evaluations and simple steps for predicting genomic values for young genotyped animals. Disadvantages include weighting parameters, such as variance components [46] or selection index coefficients [26], loss of information and biased evaluations [43]. Furthermore, the extension to alternative analysis models, such as multi-trait evaluations or test-day models, is not obvious. Finally, tracing back anomalies in a two- or three-step procedure might become very complicated. As for the loss of information, several problems exist in the use of DYD for bulls or
CAB International 2010
54
Animal Science Reviews 2010
‘yield deviations’ for cows [28]. These problems are weights (caused by different amount of information in the original data set), bias (caused by selection, for example), accuracy (for animals in small herds) and colinearity (for example, the yield deviations of two cows in the same herd). Finally, the expectation of Mendelian sampling in selected animals is not zero [47]. Other studies proposed methods for deriving GEBV from direct analysis of the complete population, even though only a small fraction is actually genotyped. Legarra et al. [48] assumed that SNPs effects are random, with conditioning of the genetic value of ungenotyped animals on the genetic value of genotyped animals via the selection index (e.g. pedigree information), and then used the genomic relationship matrix for the latter. This results in a joint distribution of genotyped and ungenotyped genetic values, with a pedigree–genomic relationship matrix H. In this matrix, genomic information is transmitted to the covariances among all ungenotyped individuals. Matrix H is suitable for iteration on data algorithms that multiply a vector times a matrix, such as preconditioned conjugated gradients [49]. This method was applied to 10 466 066 US Holsteins records for the final score [43]. GEBV were computed based on 6508 bulls genotyped for the Illumina BovineSNP50 BeadChip and records up to 2004. GEBV were compared with those obtained by the multi-step method [32] on the same data. Comparisons were based on regressions of 2009 EBV of bulls without daughter records prior to 2005 on GEBV, and coefficients of determination. This approach includes a parameter, l, that represents the fraction of the additive variance explained by the genomic information. By estimating l, the goodness of ‘genomic’ fit can be determined without creating the training and validation populations. Subsequently, comparisons of different models are simplified. With ‘optimal’ scaling, this method was more accurate and less biased than the multi-step method [43]. Another alternative that has been proposed is to use genotypes to construct a realized relationship matrix between individuals, as opposed to the average relationship matrix generally included in animal model evaluations. In the realized relationship, matrix elements are the realized proportion of the genome that is identical by descent between pairs of individuals, based on shared marker haplotypes. Hayes et al. [50] demonstrated that by replacing the average relationship matrix derived from pedigree with the realized relationship matrix, the accuracy of breeding values can be substantially increased, especially for individuals with no phenotype of their own. They also demonstrated that this method of predicting breeding values is exactly equivalent to the GS methodology where the effects of QTL contributing to variation in the trait are assumed to be normally distributed. The accuracy of breeding values predicted using the realized relationship matrix can be deterministically predicted for known family relationships, for example half-sibs.
g
Visscher [51] compared the theoretical results with empirical data from 4401 pseudo-independent full-sib pairs from Australian families. The siblings and their parents were genotyped for microsatellite markers, and additive and dominance coefficients of relationships were estimated at each cM and genome-wide using exact multipoint probability calculations. The mean and S.D. were 0. 498 and 0.036 for the additive coefficients and 0.248 and 0.040 for the dominance coefficients. Both the mean and variance were close to expectation. The extreme values for the additive coefficients were 0.37 and 0.63, so that at the low range, some full-sibs are between average half-sibs and average full-sibs, and at the high range, the sibs are between average full-sibs and monozygotic twins.
Calculation of GEBV Based on Selection of Markers Similar to Bayes-B methodology, several studies have proposed a priori selection of relatively small sets of markers for computation of GEBV, e.g. Aulchenko et al. [52]. Hayes et al. [42] proposed a two-step procedure in which the effect of each SNP is first evaluated in a simple linear model. All significant SNPs in the linear model are then analysed jointly with SNP effects assumed to be random. This model requires an estimate of the variance of the SNP effects. To estimate this variance, Hayes et al. [42] assumed that the SNPs included in the analysis explain all the additive genetic variance among the bulls, and are approximately equal. In this case, the additive genetic variance, s a 2, can be approximately modelled as follows: s 2a =2g2
m X
pi (17pi ),
i
where g is the additive effect of each SNP, m is the number of SNPs included in the analysis and pi is the frequency of the less frequent allele for the ith SNP. The variance of the SNP effects, s g2, is then assumed to be equal to g2, and is computed as follows: s 2g =s 2a =2
m X
pi (17pi ):
i
Approximately 4000 SNPs were included in joint analysis. Thus, the effect of each individual SNP was assumed to be quite small. Weigel et al. [53] compared GEBV computed with all valid SNP markers to GEBV computed with subsets of markers. A total of 3305 US Holstein bulls born from 1952 to 1998 were used as the training set, and 1398 bulls born from 1999 to 2002 were used as the testing set. The coefficient of determination (R2) from regressing the April 2008 progeny test EBV of bulls in the testing set on their
CAB International 2010
Joel I. Weller 2
August 2003 GEBV was 0.375. The R values for subsets of the 300, 500, 750, 1000, 1250, 1500 and 2000 SNP with largest effects were 0.184, 0.236, 0.279, 0.289, 0.307, 0.313 and 0.322, respectively. Solberg et al. [54] proposed the selection of markers based on either partial least-square regression or principal component regression. With 8080 total markers, the correlation between estimated and true breeding values reached a maximum when 350 principal components were fitted. Both methods gave a lower accuracy and greater bias compared with a Bayes-B analysis including all markers, but computing time was 65 times greater for the all-marker analyses. These results indicate that a lowdensity assay comprising selected SNP may be a costeffective alternative for selection decisions.
Explaining the Genetic Variation A further question of interest is how efficient are current SNP chips in explaining the genetic variation in a given trait. Although this question has not been dealt with in detail in farm animals, it has been considered for humans, especially with respect to height and several high-heritability disease traits [55]. Three groups of researchers analysed the genomes of huge populations for genetic variants associated with the height, which has a heritability of 80%, in the ‘broad sense’. (‘Narrow-sense’ heritability only includes ‘additive’ genetic variance that responds to selection, while broad-sense heritability includes all genetic variance.) More than 40 effects were verified by detection in independent analyses, but these altogether accounted for little more than 5% of the variance. Similar results were found for autism and schizophrenia, even though both traits have very high heritability. Various explanations have been advanced to explain these disappointing results. Firstly, sample sizes of tens of thousands of individuals are required to obtain the statistical power to detect QTL explaining < 0.5% of the total variance [56]. For example, with a sample size of 10 000, the statistical power to detect a variant that explains 0.2% of the variance is only 29%. Therefore, the chance that two independent studies of this size will both detect this variant is only 0.292=0.08. A significant fraction of the genetic variation may be the result of rare alleles, which are very difficult to detect [55]. Also genes affecting only the non-additive genetic variance will not be detected by most models used for analysis of SNP effects. Finally, a large fraction of the genetic variation in quantitative traits may be the result of polymorphisms in DNA other than SNPs, for example copy number variation [55].
Genomic Selection in Plants Until the development of high-throughput genotyping methodology for SNPs, the application of MAS in plants
g
55
was clearly ahead of application in animals. Now the situation has been reversed. Most applications of GS have so far been in animals [57]. The costs of producing and scoring each individual plant are generally much lower than for animals. Thus plant MAS programmes have generally been based on generating populations specifically for MAS, while animal programmes have been based nearly entirely on analysis of animals from the commercial population. For a simulated breeding programme of maize based on doubled haploids generated from inbred lines, the response of genome-wide selection was 18–43% larger than for marker-assisted recurrent selection [58]. Efficiency of GS with low-cost genotyping in a composite line from a cross between inbred lines was evaluated for a trait with heritability of 0.10 or 0.25 using a lowdensity marker map [59]. GS was the sum of estimates of effects of all marker intervals across the genome, fitted either as fixed or random effects. Reponses to selection over 10 generations, starting from the F2, were compared with standard BLUP selection. Both genomic strategies outperformed BLUP selection, especially in initial generations. Random GS outperformed fixed GS in early generations and performed slightly better than fixed GS in later generations. Random GS gave higher genetic gain when the number of marker intervals was greater, whereas fixed GS gave higher genetic gain when the number of marker intervals was low.
Conclusions and Future Prospects As demonstrated by ‘The Pirate Bay’ (http://thepiratebay. org/), the technology always wins. This will also be the case for genetic markers. Genotyping costs will continue to decline. Human GWAS will now be based on a new family of genotyping chips designed to simultaneously assay 4 million sites of variation. In the near future, new SNP chips in cattle will be developed with much higher density than the BovineSNP50 BeadChip (D. Schnabel, personal communication). Complete Genomics (Mountain View, CA, USA) plans to offer complete human genome sequence per individual for US$5000 next year [60]. Increasing SNP density will increase the level of LD between SNP genotypes and the QTLs. LD is generally measured by the parameter r2 [61]. Simulation studies demonstrate that the accuracy of GEBV increases dramatically with an increase in average r2 between adjacent markers [62]. However, the development of a new higher-density chip would probably require reanalysis of all bulls with evaluations. This, in fact, may be advantageous in that LD relationships will tend to decay over time. Thus, it will probably be necessary to reanalyse populations after several generations in any event. The number of young bulls that could be progeny tested was limited by the cost of keeping each bull for 5 years, and the potential pool of cows that could be
CAB International 2010
56
Animal Science Reviews 2010
mated to these bulls. Even at $400 per individual, genotyping costs are much less that the cost of producing a progeny-tested bull. Recently, genotyping costs for the BovineSNP50 BeadChip have declined to $175 per individual (D. Pomp, personal communication). With the reduction of genotyping costs it becomes possible to increase the number of bull candidates. Also as genotyping costs decrease, genotyping of potential bull dams becomes economically viable [63]. Since bull dams generally have reliabilities of only 0.3 to 0.4 for milk production traits, this could also make a significant increase in rates of genetic gain. For secondary traits with lower heritability, such as fertility, the potential gain will be even greater [42]. Finally with the information on the genotypes of individual animals, it becomes easier to control inbreeding. Current methods of genetic analysis include the complete relationship matrix. For young bulls without records, until now, this has been the only source of information. Therefore, bull candidates are generally all sons of the sires and dams with the highest evaluations. This tends to increase inbreeding in the population. With genomic data as a new source of information, it should be possible to increase the pool of potential parents of candidate bulls [42]. So far, no studies have dealt with economic optimization of breeding programmes under the new realities.
Acknowledgements This research was supported by grants from the Israel milk marketing board and the European Sixth Research and Technological Development Framework Programme, Proposal No. 016250-2 SABRE. I thank M. Ron and M. Shani for their critical reading and suggestions.
References 1. Fisher RA. The correlation between relatives on the supposition of Mendelian inheritance. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1918;52:399–433. 2. Sax K. The association of size differences with seed-coat pattern and pigmentation in Phaseolus vulgaris. Genetics 1923;8:552–60. 3. Neimann-Sørensen A, Robertson A. The association between blood groups and several production characters in three Danish cattle breeds. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica Section A – Animal Science 1961;11:163–96. 4. Litt M, Luty JA. A hypervariable microsatellite revealed by in vitro amplification of a dinucleotide repeat within the cardiac muscle actin gene. American Journal of Human Genetics 1989;44:397. 5. Marth G, Yeh R, Minton M, Donaldson R, Li Q, Duan SG, et al. Single-nucleotide polymorphisms in the public domain: how useful are they? Nature Genetics 2001;27:371–2. 6. Spelman RJ, Garrick DJ, van Arendonk JAM. Utilization of genetic variation by marker assisted selection in commercial
g
dairy cattle populations. Livestock Production Science 1999;59:51–60. 7. Schaeffer LR. Strategy for applying genome-wide selection in dairy cattle. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2006;123:218–23. 8. Glowatzki-Mullis ML, Gaillard C, Wigger G, Fries R. Microsatellite based parentage control in cattle. Animal Genetics 1995;27:7–12. 9. Werner FAO, Durstewitz G, Habermann FA, Thaller G, Kramer W, Kollers S, et al. Detection and characterization of SNPs useful for identity control and parentage testing in major European dairy breeds. Animal Genetics 2004;35:44–9. 10. Bonin A, Bellemain E, Eidesen PB, Pompanon F, Brochmann C, Taberlet P. How to track and assess genotyping errors in population genetics studies. Molecular Ecology 2004;13:3271–73. 11. Kennedy GC, Matsuzaki H, Dong SL, Liu WM, Huang J, Liu GY, et al. Large-scale genotyping of complex DNA. Nature Biotechnology 2003;21:1233–7. 12. Anderson EC, Graza JC. The power of single nucleotide polymorphisms for large scale parentage inference. Genetics 2006;172:2567–82. 13. Weller JI. Quantitative Trait Loci Analysis in Animals, 2nd edn. CABI Publishing, London, UK; 2009. 14. Weller JI, Kashi Y, Soller M. Power of ‘daughter’ and ‘granddaughter’ designs for genetic mapping of quantitative traits in dairy cattle using genetic markers. Journal of Dairy Science 1990;73:2525–37. 15. Lander ES, Kruglyak L. Genetic dissection of complex traits: guidelines for interpreting reporting linkage results. Nature Genetics 1995;11:241–7. 16. Cohen-Zinder M, Seroussi E, Larkin DM, Loor JJ, Everts-van der Wind A, Lee JH, et al. Identification of a missense mutation in the bovine ABCG2 gene with a major effect on the QTL on chromosome 6 affecting milk yield and composition in Holstein cattle. Genome Research 2005;15:936–44. 17. Grisart B, Coppieters W, Farnir F, Karim L, Ford C, Berzi P, et al. Positional candidate cloning of a QTL in dairy cattle: identification of a missense mutation in the bovine DGAT1gene with major effect on milk yield and composition. Genome Research 2002;12:222–31. 18. Bennewitz J, Reinsch N, Reinhardt F, Liu Z, Kalm E. Top down preselection using marker assisted estimates of breeding values in dairy cattle. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2004;121:307–18. 19. Boichard D, Fritz S, Rossignol MN, Guillaume F, Colleau JJ, Druet T. Implementation of marker-assisted selection: practical lessons from dairy cattle. In: Proceeding of the 8th World Congress of Genetics Applied to Livestock Production Belo Horizonte (MG), Brazil; 2006. CD Communication No. 22-11. 20. Meuwissen THE, Goddard ME. Fine mapping of quantitative trait loci using linkage disequilibria with closely linked marker loci. Genetics 2000;155:421–30. 21. Sargolzaei M, Schenkel FS, Jansen GB, Schaeffer LR. Extent of linkage disequilibrium in Holstein cattle in North America. Journal of Dairy Science 2008;91:2106–17.
CAB International 2010
Joel I. Weller 22. Grapes L, Dekkers JC, Rothschild MF, Fernando RL. Comparing linkage disequilibrium-based methods for fine mapping quantitative trait loci. Genetics 2004;166:1561–70. 23. Goddard ME, Hayes B, McPartlan H, Chamberlain AJ. Can the same genetic markers be used in multiple breeds? In: Proceeding of the 8th World Congress of Genetics Applied to Livestock Production, Belo Horizonte (MG), Brazil; 2006. CD Communication No. 22-14. 24. Loberg A, Du¨rr J. Interbull survey on the use of genomic information. In: Interbull Bulletin No. 39. Proceedings of the Interbull International, Uppsala, Sweden; 2009. p. 3–14. 25. Cole JB, VanRaden PM, O’Connell JR, Van Tassell CP, Sonstegard TS, et al. Distribution and location of genetic effects for dairy traits. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92: 2931–46. 26. VanRaden PM, Van Tassell CP, Wiggans GR, Sonstegard TS, Schnabel RD, Taylor JF, et al. Invited review: Reliability of genomic predictions for North American Holstein bulls. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92:16–24.
57
39. Hayes BJ, Chamberlain A, Goddard ME. Use of linkage markers in linkage disequilibrium with QTL in breeding programs. In: Proceeding of the 8th World Congress of Genetics Applied to Livestock Production, Belo Horizonte (MG), Brazil; 2006. CD Communication No. 30-06. 40. Chamberlain AJ, McPartlan HC, Goddard ME. The number of loci that affect milk production traits in dairy cattle. Genetics 2007;177:1117–23. 41. Ron M, Feldmesser E, Golik M, Tager-Cohen I, Kliger D, Reiss V, et al. A complete genome scan of the Israeli Holstein population for quantitative trait loci by a daughter design. Journal of Dairy Science 2004;87:476–90. 42. Hayes BJ, Bowman PJ, Chamberlain AJ, Goddard ME. Invited review: Genomic selection in dairy cattle progress and challenges. Journal of Dairy Science 2009; 92:433–43.
27. Goddard ME, Hayes BJ. Genomic selection. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2007;124:323–30.
43. Aguilar I, Misztal I, Johnson LD, Legarra A, Tsuruta S, Lawlor TJ. A unified approach to utilize phenotypic, full pedigree and genomic information for genetic evaluation of Holstein final score. Journal of Dairy Science 2010;93:743–52.
28. VanRaden PM, Wiggans GR. Derivation, calculation and use of national animal model information. Journal of Dairy Science 1991;74:2737–46.
44. Meuwissen THE, Hayes BJ, Goddard ME. Prediction of total genetic value using genome-wide dense marker maps. Genetics 2001;157:1819–29.
29. Thomsen H, Reinsch N, Xu N, Looft C, Grupe S, Kuhn C, et al. Comparison of estimated breeding values, daughter yield deviations and deregressed proofs within a whole genome scan for QTL. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2001;118:357–70.
45. Liu Z, Seefried F, Reinhardt F, Reents R. Dairy cattle genetic evaluation using genomic information. In: Interbull Bulletin No. 39. Proceedings of the Interbull International, Uppsala, Sweden; 2009. p. 23–8.
30. Israel C, Weller JI. Estimation of candidate gene effects in dairy cattle populations. Journal of Dairy Science 1998;81:1653–62. 31. Calus MPL, Veerkamp RF. Accuracy of breeding values when using and ignoring the polygenic effect in genomic breeding value estimation with a marker density of one SNP per cM. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2007;124:362–8. 32. VanRaden PM. Efficient methods to compute genomic predictions. Journal of Dairy Science 2008;91:4414–23. 33. Beavis WD. The power and deceit of QTL experiments: lessons for comparative QTL studies. In: Annual Corn Sorghum Research Conference, Volume 49. Washington, DC; 1994. p. 252–68. 34. Georges M, Nielsen D, Mackinnon M, Mishra A, Okimoto R, Pasquino AT, et al. Mapping quantitative trait loci controlling milk production in dairy cattle by exploiting progeny testing. Genetics 1995;139:907–20. 35. Goring HH, Terwilliger JD, Blangero J. Large upward bias in estimation of locus-specific effects from genomewide scans. American Journal of Human Genetics 2001;69:1357–69. 36. Meuwissen THE, Goddard ME. Mapping multiple QTL using linkage disequilibrium and linkage analysis information and multitrait data. Genetics, Selection, Evolution 2004;36:271–79. 37. Hayes B, Goddard ME. The distribution of the effects of genes affecting quantitative traits in livestock. Genetics, Selection, Evolution 2001;33:209–29. 38. Weller JI, Shlezinger M, Ron M. Correcting for bias in estimation of quantitative trait loci effects. Genetics, Selection, Evolution 2005;37:501–22.
g
46. Guillaume F, Fritz S, Boichard D, Druet T. Short communication: correlations of marker-assisted breeding values with progeny-test breeding values for eight hundred ninety-nine French Holstein bulls. Journal of Dairy Science 2008;91:2520–22. 47. Party C, Ducrocq V. Bias due to genomic selection. In: Interbull Bulletin No. 39. Proceedings of the Interbull International, Uppsala, Sweden; 2009. p. 77–82. 48. Legarra A, Aguilar I, Misztal I. A relationship matrix including full pedigree and genomic information. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92:4656–66. 49. Misztal I, Legarra A, Aguilar I. Computing procedures for genetic evaluation including phenotypic, full pedigree, and genomic information. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92: 4648–55. 50. Hayes BJ, Visscher PM, Goddard ME. Increased accuracy of artificial selection by using the realized relationship matrix. Genetic Research, Cambridge 2009;91:47–60. 51. Visscher PM. Whole genome approaches to quantitative genetics. Genetica 2009;136:351–8. 52. Aulchenko YS, de Koning DJ, Haley C. Genomewide rapid association using mixed model and regression: a fast and simple method for genomewide predigree-based quantitative trait loci association analysis. Genetics 2007;177:577–85. 53. Weigel KA, de los Campos G, Gonza´lez-Recio O, Naya H, Wu XL, Long N, et al. Predictive ability of direct genomic values for lifetime net merit of Holstein sires using selected subsets of single nucleotide polymorphism markers. Journal of Dairy Science 2009;92:5248–57.
CAB International 2010
58
Animal Science Reviews 2010
54. Solberg TR, Sonesson AK, Woolliams J, Meuwissen THE. Reducing dimensionality for prediction of genome-wide breeding values. Genetics, Selection, Evolution 2009;41:29.
59. Piyasatian N, Fernando RL, Dekkers JC. Genomic selection for marker-assisted improvement in line crosses. Theoretical and Applied Genetics 2007;115:665–74.
55. Maher B. The case of the missing heritability. Nature 2008;456:18–21.
60. Hayden EC. Genomics shifts focus to rare diseases. Nature 2009;461:458–9.
56. Visscher PM. Sizing up human height variation. Nature Genetics 2008;40:489–90.
61. Hill WG. Estimation of effective population size from data on linkage disequilibrium. Genetic Research 1981;38:209–16.
57. Piepho HP. Ridge regression and extensions of genomewide selection in maize. Crop Science 2009;49: 1165–76.
62. Calus MP, Meuwissen THE, de Roos AP, Veerkamp RF. Accuracy of genomic selection suing different methods to define haplotypes. Genetics 2008;178:553–61.
58. Bernardo R, Jinming Y. Prospects for genomewide selection for quantitative traits in maize. Crop Science 2007;47: 1082–90.
63. Schaeffer LR. Strategy for applying genome-wide selection in dairy cattle. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2006;123:218–23.
g
CAB International 2010
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Quantitative trait mutations in cattle, sheep and pigs: a review Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys* Address: Laboratory of Livestock Physiology, Immunology and Genetics, Department of Biosystems, KULeuven, Kasteelpark Arenberg 30, 3001 Leuven, Belgium. *Correspondence: Nadine Buys. Fax: +32(0)16/32 19 94. Email:
[email protected] 19 October 2009 4 February 2010
Received: Accepted:
Abstract Most economically important traits in farm animals, such as daily gain, muscularity, meat quality, milk production, reproduction and others, are complex multifactorial traits that are controlled by an unknown number of genes combined with environmental factors. Since these traits show a continuous distribution rather than discrete values as monogenic or qualitative traits do, they are called quantitative traits and a polymorphism that affects such a quantitative trait is called a quantitative trait mutation (QTM). During the last few decades, several QTMs for different economically important quantitative traits in farm animals, such as muscularity, meat quality and milk production, were discovered. Also, for various congenital disorders, causal polymorphisms could be found or are under investigation. However, for other quantitative traits, no such QTMs have been revealed so far. An explanation for this discrepancy lies in the extent of the effect of the different polymorphisms that underlie a certain quantitative trait since this effect can vary from very small to quite large (up to 25–30% of the total phenotypic variance of a particular trait). Although new, emerging cost-effective genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping techniques have become available, only QTMs that explain a large portion of the phenotypic variation are worth unravelling, especially in the light of genome-wide selection. In this review, the research for QTMs is positioned against these contemporary techniques. Moreover, an overview is given of, past and present, research efforts in identifying QTMs in farm animals and the incorporation of these polymorphisms in modern animal breeding. Keywords: Farm animals, Quantitative trait mutations, Candidate gene approach, Linkage analysis, Linkage disequilibrium, Whole genome association analysis, Genomic selection Review Methodology: We searched the following databases: Entrez Pubmed, AnimalQTLdb and Web of Science (Keyword search terms used: genomic selection, quantitative trait nucleotides in farm animals, causative mutations, animal breeding, etc.). In addition, we used the references from the articles obtained by this method to check for additional relevant material.
Introduction Since animal breeding is especially focused on economically important traits, farm animals are of particular interest in the search for genes that control growth, muscularity, meat quality, behaviour, reproduction and other traits [1]. Moreover, since productivity is dependent on good health, farm animals are also very important in the research for disease-related genes [2]. Some of the researched traits have a simple monogenic basis: the so-called qualitative traits. However, this is the
g
case for a minority of the traits. Most economically important traits, such as muscularity and reproduction, are complex multifactorial traits that are controlled by an unknown number of genes – a few with a major effect and a lot with a minor effect – in combination with several environmental factors. Since these traits show a continuous distribution rather than discrete values as qualitative traits do, they are called quantitative traits. Therefore, the region on a chromosome that bears one or more genes that affect a quantitative trait is called a quantitative trait locus (QTL) [1, 3]. Until recently,
CAB International 2009
60
Animal Science Reviews 2010
nucleotide variation underlying a QTL was called a quantitative trait nucleotide (QTN) [4]. In 2009, however, Leif Andersson introduced the expression ‘quantitative trait mutation’ (QTM), since structural mutations such as copy number variation, insertions, deletions and inversions can also be causative mutations for some QTLs [5]. The identification of genes for complex traits would greatly enhance our understanding of quantitative traits, but there would also be a great practical benefit to livestock breeding. Traditionally, the genetics of complex traits in domestic animal species has been studied without studying the genes underlying these traits. Selection was based on estimated breeding values calculated from phenotypic records and pedigrees, and on knowledge of the heritability of a trait [6]. Nowadays, QTL information is used in breeding programmes to improve a range of traits, using marker-assisted selection (MAS) with markers linked to the QTM, markers in linkage disequilibrium (LD) with the QTM or, ultimately, the QTM itself [2, 7]. The research for markers applicable in MAS in farm animals has taken a giant leap forward during the last two decades. In this review, it is explained why this research was given such a priority and why farm animals, in particular, are such prized subjects for this research. Also, an overview is given of the different research methods used in the search for markers, and more specifically QTM, during the last few decades. The use of QTM and MAS is positioned against a background of the most contemporary techniques using single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) chips. Finally, an overview is given of known QTMs involved in production and reproduction traits and in congenital disorders in farm animals.
The Genome of Farm Animals: A Wealth of Functional Mutations The magnitude of variation in domestic animals was created during the 10 000-year-old process of domestication and selective breeding. This process can be seen as an extensive screening for genetic variants with a phenotypic effect and without a deleterious effect on fitness [5]. Also, this process led to a rather remarkable LD structure in domestic animals. This structure is best characterized in dogs, but is comparable in other farm animals [8–11]. Before the creation of different breeds, the LD extended over chromosome segments of 10 kb, with 3–5 haplotypes per LD block. These haplotypes were responsible for the major part of the genetic variation. About 200 years ago, the creation of the modern breeds began. They were created as genetically isolated, closed populations and, in almost all cases, experienced episodes of severe bottlenecks and long-time decreases of the effective population size. From a chromosomal point of view, the creation of breeds can be seen as the selection of a limited number of haplotypes from a large pool of ancestral chromosomes. Nowadays, the LD within
g
different dog breeds still extends over a very long chromosomal segment, since not enough time has passed for recombination to have mixed the different haplotypes. Therefore, within breeds, the long-range haplotypes still span 0.5–1.0 Mb with a small number of haplotypes (3–5) that account for the majority of the observed variation. Within the different long-range haplotypes, however, independent of the breed, the same short-range haplotypes can be found. This short-range haplotype corresponds to one of the haplotype variants that were present in the original population, before breed creation [9]. It is this remarkable genome structure that makes domestic animals such appreciated models for the exploration of genotype–phenotype relationships of quantitative traits. One of the major drawbacks of positional cloning of genes with an influence on quantitative or complex traits is their multifactorial character. This makes it very hard to detect the effects of the different QTLs and therefore, large groups with thousands of individuals would be needed in QTL mapping experiments. However, in domestic animals, the localization of genes underlying complex traits is simplified because of the recent creation of breeds and the particular LD structure that arose from it [1, 3, 7]. The complexity of many economically valuable traits has decreased because of the ancestral effects that accompanied the creation of different breeds. This is because, in domestic animals, the effective population size is very small. For cattle and pigs, the effective population size of most breeds is about 100 animals [7, 9]. Because of this, the number of animals necessary to localize genes that underlie a certain quantitative trait is reduced drastically. For disease alleles causing a simple Mendelian dominant trait, the probability of detecting the locus is over 99% given 100 affected and 100 unaffected animals [9]. For recessive Mendelian traits, detecting the locus is already possible with smaller number of animals. Karlsson et al. [12] successfully mapped recessive Mendelian trait loci with 10 affected and 10 unaffected dogs [12]. Also, in cattle, recessive disorders were characterized based on 12–30 animals [13]. For mapping risk factors that lead to a 2–5 higher incidence of a polygenic disorder, it was estimated that 200 animals should be sufficient [9].
QTM Mapping Throughout (Recent) History To date, thousands of QTLs for numerous traits have been reported (e.g. see http://www.animalgenome.org/ QTLdb/). However, the identification of the mutations that underlie these QTLs, the so-called QTMs, has been hard [5].
The Candidate Gene Approach Over the past 20 years, two approaches have been used to discover genes and polymorphisms underlying the
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys
phenotypic variation in complex traits. The first approach is the so-called candidate gene approach, which is based on the identification of segregating marker alleles in a candidate gene associated with the trait of interest [6]. The approach can be justified when candidate genes fulfil one or more of the four criteria. The first two criteria involve the function of the candidate gene: the gene either has a known physiological role in the trait of interest or the gene affects the trait of interest based on studies of knockouts, mutations or transgenics in other species. The next two criteria involve time and place of expression of the candidate gene: the gene is preferentially expressed in organs related to the quantitative trait and the gene is preferentially expressed during developmental stages related to the phenotype [14, 15]. A problem with the candidate gene approach is that a lot of genes fulfil at least one criterion and, until now, none of the genes in which a QTM was discovered meets all four of them [15]. On the other hand, the advantage of the candidate gene approach is that it can be very powerful and can detect loci even with small effects, provided that the candidate gene harbours a true causative mutation [1]. Examples of QTM that were found using the candidate gene approach include the QTM in Ryanodine receptor 1 (RYR1) [16] and Myostatin (MSTN) in cattle [17–19] and dogs [20],
Using Linkage and LD The second approach used to detect QTM in domestic animals in the past is used to map the genes that affect the trait of interest to a chromosomal location using genetic markers, also called positional cloning. Until recently, a whole genome scan was performed using linkage and low-density microsatellite panels [21], and the progress in mapping causal genes for complex traits has been slow because of the techniques used [6]. Linkage analysis uses recombination events in the pedigree and traces chromosome segments to a common ancestor [6]. This approach, however, gives a poor resolution and confidence intervals for the detected QTL are typically 10–20 Mb wide and may contain hundreds of genes. Therefore, this method should be followed by LD fine mapping of the most prominent QTL via high density, de novo developed, SNP maps [5, 7]. LD mapping depends on chromosome segments inherited before the recorded pedigree, since it is the inheritance of identical chromosome segments by multiple descendents from a common ancestor that causes LD. The use of LD allows one to do precise mapping, because LD decays as the distance between the marker and the QTL increases [6]. In cattle, an LD measure of 50% was noticed for marker pairs separated by less than 5 cM, but a rapid decay to 16% was witnessed, reaching a plateau slightly below 14% for more distant markers [22]. Identification and production of dense SNP marker panels to reduce the confidence
g
61
intervals of the most eminent QTL was expensive and time-consuming, until the arrival of genome-wide SNP panels [6]. QTMs detected using linkage and LD scanning include the mutations in insulin-like growth factor 2 (IGF2) [23] and in protein kinase AMP-activated gamma 3 non-catalytic subunit (PRKAG3) in pigs [24, 25], in MSTN in mice and sheep [26, 27], in acylCoA:diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT1) in cattle [28], the callipyge (CLPG) gene [29, 30] and the Booroola fecundity (Fec) gene in sheep [31].
Whole-genome Association Analysis (WGAA) Nowadays, high-density genome-wide SNP maps have been developed for almost all domestic animals and, at the moment, it is possible to genotype 20–60 000 SNP markers using random SNP chips, available for cattle, horse, sheep, pig, dog and chicken. Using the SNP chips (instead of applying the traditional separate mapping and fine-mapping strategy), it is possible to merge two steps into a single combined linkage and LD analysis or direct WGAA [7, 32]. The basic design of a WGAA study is that a certain trait is recorded in a group of animals and a genome-wide panel of SNP markers is assayed to detect significant associations between the trait of interest and any of the markers. The validated markers of the WGAA study can subsequently be used in MAS in domestic animals, in two different ways [6]. A first method for implementing validated WGAA markers into MAS is to make direct use of markers that are in LD with the QTM. To avoid bias, the effect associated with each allele of the significant marker or markers is estimated in a population that is independent from the one in which the significant markers were found. Breeding values for selection candidates can then be estimated combining pedigree, markers and phenotype information [6]. This type of MAS has already been applied, in practice, but it has some major disadvantages. Firstly, alleles at linked markers cannot be used to predict the phenotype until the association between alleles at the marker and alleles at the trait gene is known (called ‘phase’). This phase, however, is only valid within the tested population and may change in subsequent generations through recombination [2]. Therefore, for every new population, a new association analysis has to be done. Secondly, this kind of MAS is mainly a tool for traits that are easy to measure and are therefore recorded routinely. However, many traits that have an important impact on profitability and welfare, such as feed conversion efficiency, fertility and disease resistance, are difficult to measure. Obtaining the necessary phenotype information to carry out WGAA would be very expensive [2]. A possible solution for these disadvantages and a second method for implementing WGAA markers into MAS is to identify the functional mutations or QTMs underlying the traits of interest and use these as markers
CAB International 2009
62
Animal Science Reviews 2010
for MAS. Since it concerns causal mutations, it is possible to predict the effect of a particular allele in all animals in a population, without having to determine the phase [2]. However, the identification of QTMs also requires considerable investment. Therefore, the search for QTMs is only economically feasible if it concerns mutations in genes that explain a large portion of the phenotypic variance of a specific trait, or so-called major genes. Research for QTMs using WGAA has been successful for genes causing simple Mendelian traits [12, 13]. For the unravelling of quantitative traits, however, this approach has not yet proven to be successful.
QTM in Production and Reproduction Traits in Farm Animals As mentioned in the previous paragraph, during the last few decades, several QTMs for different economically important quantitative traits related to production and reproduction in farm animals were discovered using both the candidate gene approach and combined linkage and LD analysis. In this paragraph, an overview of these QTMs in different farm animal species is given.
Production Traits RYR1 The first QTN involved in muscularity in pigs was detected in the RYR1 gene, the gene encoding the predominant Ca2+ release channel in the sarcoplasmic reticulum of skeletal muscle. A substitution at position 1843 in the porcine RYR1 gene (Ryr1 g.1843C>T), leading to an alteration from an arginine residue to a cysteine residue, was associated with higher lean meat content and muscularity in different pig breeds, including the heavily muscled Pie´train breed. However, the mutation was also associated with malignant hyperthermia, which is a disorder that can be triggered by inhalational anaesthetics such as halothane or by skeletal muscle relaxants such as succinylcholine. In pigs, homozygous for the defect, malignant hyperthermia can also be triggered by stress and this is referred to as the porcine stress syndrome (PSS) in pigs [16]. PSS is a disorder witnessed typically in Pie´train, Poland, China and strains of Landrace pigs, and is triggered by stimuli as transportation, increase in environmental temperature, physical exercise, restraint or general handling. The PSS is characterized by muscle tremor, increased respiratory rate, systemic acidosis and a rise in body temperature. Typically, animals that die in this state, either naturally or by slaughtering, exhibit an immediate rigor mortis, leading to the so-called pale, soft and exudative (PSE) meat [33]. This post-mortem manifestation of the PSS leads to major economical losses in the pig breeding industry and is an important downside to the selection for the RYR1 g.1843C>T polymorphism [16].
g
PRKAG3 The rendement Napole or RN7 phenotype is common in Hampshire pigs and is characterized by a 70% increase in glycogen content in skeletal muscle and large effects on meat characteristics. Meat from RN7 pigs has a low ultimate pH, a reduced water-holding capacity, and gives a reduced yield of cured cooked ham [24, 25]. However, animals bearing the mutation also show higher growth rates and meat content in the carcass [34]. In 1996, the RN gene was mapped to porcine chromosome 15 [35]. A candidate gene for this QTL was the muscle-specific PRKAG3, which encodes the gamma 3 isoform of AMPactivated protein kinase (AMPK). This enzyme can inactivate glycogen synthase, the key regulatory enzyme of glycogen synthesis by phosphorylation [24]. A nonconservative, causative arginine to glutamine substitution (R200Q) was found in the most conserved region of the gene denoted as RN7. It concerns an activating mutation that increases glucose uptake but it may also have other effects like fatty acid oxidation or synthesis. The mutation was supported by very strong genetic evidence [24, 25]. A second mutation (V199I) was found by Lindahl et al. [36, 37], denoted as rn*. This gives three alleles as followed: 199V-200R for the wild-type rn+, 199V-200Q for RN7 and 199I-200R for rn* [36]. The RN7 allele was dominant over rn* and rn+ concerning ultimate pH, water-holding capacity and cooking loss but with regard to residual glycogen content RN7 was only dominant in entire male pigs and not in female pigs, where rn* had a glycogen-lowering effect [36]. Both mutations also have an influence on the colour of pork meat [37]. IGF2 In 1998, a paternally expressed QTL with large effects on muscularity, heart weight and fat deposition was described at the distal tip of porcine chromosome 2 [38–40]. Based on the conserved synteny between the QTL on Sus scrofa chromosome 2 (SSC2) and human chromosome 11p, IGF2 was suggested as a candidate gene for this QTL in an intercross between European wild boar and Large White domestic pigs and another intercross between Large White and Pie´train domestic pigs [39, 40]. The IGF2 protein plays a key role in skeletal muscle growth, since it has an effect on carbohydrate and fat metabolism, protein turnover, growth and differentiation in skeletal muscle [41, 42]. The effects of the identified QTL on muscle mass and fat deposition are of the same magnitude as those reported for the RYR1 locus, although apparently without the associated negative effects on meat quality. It is estimated that both loci jointly explain about 50% of the phenotypic difference for muscularity and leanness between Large White and Pie´train [40]. In 2003, a QTM was discovered in the porcine IGF2 gene. A substitution in an evolutionary conserved CpG island in intron 3 of the IGF2 gene (IGF2 intron3-g.G>A) leads to an abrogation of the interaction of a regulatory
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys
63
locus in the IGF2 gene and a repressor protein. This subsequently leads to a threefold increase in IGF2 mRNA levels and a subsequent increase in muscle growth and heart size and a decrease in fat deposition [23]. Oczkowicz et al. [43] noticed significant effects of this mutation on body composition and growth performance and no significant effect on meat quality in Polish pig breeds [43]. In 2004, also the existence of porcine IGF2 antisense transcript (IGF2-AS) was reported. Its expression was also shown to be imprinted, paternally expressed and affected by the QTM [44].
genes DLK1 and PEG11, and it is the overexpression of DLK1 that causes the muscular hypertrophy. In animals that are homozygous for the CLPG mutation, both the maternally and the paternally expressed genes are overexpressed, but since this leads to a post-transcriptional trans-inhibition of the paternally expressed proteinencoding genes by the maternally expressed miRNA genes, no phenotypic difference can be seen in these animals [7].
CLPG In 1993, a mutation causing muscular hypertrophy, associated with leanness and improved feed efficiency was identified in the Dorset sheep breed. Animals bearing the mutation show little external fat and unusual muscling in the hind quarters. Therefore, the locus in which this mutation occurred was called the callipyge (CLPG) locus, from the Greek calli- which means beautiful and -pyge buttocks [45, 46]. The CLPG locus was mapped to a 400 kb chromosome fragment of ovine chromosome 18 and displays an unusual parent-of-origin effect referred to as polar overdominance: only heterozygous individuals having inherited the CLPG mutation from their sire exhibit the muscular hypertrophy [29, 30]. In 2002, an A to G mutation causing the CLPG phenotype was located in a dodecamer region that was highly conserved in sheep, cattle, human and mouse genome sequences. Although the mutation was located outside the boundaries of any previously identified transcript, it was proven to be located within an (unknown) expressed transcript and shown to alter a serine codon into a proline residue [47, 48]. Within the CLPG region, different genes that are preferentially expressed in skeletal muscle and subject to parental imprinting in this tissue were studied. The results showed that the CLPG mutation did not alter the imprinting status of the genes, but it enhanced their expression levels in cis, while maintaining their exclusive expression from either the paternal or maternal allele. This indicated that the CLPG mutation affects a long-range control element and either boosts an enhancer or inhibits a silencer regulatory element [30, 48]. As only the heterozygous individuals that inherited the CLPG mutation from their father (+mat/CLPGpat) exhibited the CLPG phenotype, it was hypothesized that the mutation involves a physiological interaction in trans between a maternally expressed repressor and its paternally expressed growthpromoting target [48]. From this hypothesis, the actual working mechanism could be deduced. Animals that inherit the CLPG mutation from the mother only overexpress the maternally expressed long non-coding RNA genes hosting tandem clusters of C/D small nucleolar RNAs and microRNAs present in the CLPG locus. Animals that inherit the CLPG mutation from the father only overexpress the paternally expressed protein-encoding
Naturally occurring mutations of the MSTN gene were found in several species, including cattle, mice, humans, sheep and dogs [17–20, 26, 27, 49–51]. The first species in which a mutation of the MSTN gene was found was cattle. In total, 12 different mutations were found in the MSTN gene of the so-called double-muscled cattle, 8 of them were located in the coding sequence and 4 were located in the intronic sequences of the gene [17–19, 49–51]. Of the 8 polymorphisms that were located in the coding region of the MSTN gene, 6 mutations led to a disruption of the function of the protein, one was a conservative mutation and one was a silent mutation. Of the 11 different double-muscled cattle breeds, the analysed double-muscled animals were either homozygous for one of the mutations predicted to disrupt the function of the MSTN protein or compound heterozygous for two distinct of these mutations. In two of the double-muscled breeds studied, namely Limousin and Blonde d’Aquitaine, there was no clear evidence for the role of the MSTN loss-of-function mutations in double muscling in these breeds. This suggests that either MSTN is not responsible for the muscular hyperthrophy in these breeds or there are additional mutations in bovine MSTN that are not located in the coding sequence of the gene [49–51]. The hypermuscular compact (Cmpt) mouse was the first animal species other than cattle that was found to have a naturally occurring functional mutation in the MSTN gene. It concerns a 12-bp deletion in the propeptide region of the MSTN gene and so the apparent loss of function of the MSTN protein is not because of disruption of the growth factor domain as in cattle. But the proregion may play a role in the proper folding, efficient secretion or regulation of the target of the mature C-terminal portion of the MSTN gene. Since the deleted region is conserved in all known vertebrate MSTN genes, it is possible that one or more of these functions are affected, which may decrease the amount or the availability of the MSTN protein or confuse the proper targeting of the MSTN protein [26]. Recently, a mutation in the canine MSTN gene was found. A 2 bp deletion in the third exon of the MSTN gene in some individuals of the whippet dog breed led to a double-muscled phenotype known as the ‘bully’ whippet. This mutation caused the formation of a premature stop
g
MSTN
CAB International 2009
64
Animal Science Reviews 2010
codon at amino acid 313 of the canine MSTN, and subsequently led to a truncated protein [20]. In sheep, a deletion in the coding region of the MSTN gene of Norwegian White Sheep was found to disrupt the reading frame from amino acid position 320, ending in a premature stop codon in amino acid position 359 (c.960delG). As the bioactive part of MSTN is known to constitute the C-terminal domain, this mutation is most likely to generate a completely non-functional protein [52]. In addition to the c.960delG mutation, also a mutation was found in the non-coding region of the MSTN gene of the exceptionally muscled Texel breed. The possibility that a functional mutation could occur in the non-coding region of the MSTN gene was already postu0 0 lated by Grobet et al. [49]. In the 3 -UTR (3 -untranslated region) of the ovine MSTN gene, a guanine to adenine 0 transition (c.2630G>A) creates one of the 3 -UTR octamer motifs (ACATTCCA) that correspond to miRNA targets. This octamer is a binding site for mir1 and mir206, microRNAs that are highly expressed in skeletal muscle, and binding of these microRNAs causes translational repression of the MSTN gene and double-muscling in Texel sheep [27]. It was shown that ‘double-muscled’ sheep are either homozygous for the c.960del G or c.2360G>A mutation or compound heterozygous for both mutations. When comparing the phenotypes of sheep bearing different mutations, it could be seen that the most extreme phenotypes regarding carcass conformation and fatness were found in the animals that were homozygous for the c.960delG mutation, followed by the compound heterozygous animals and then the homozygous c.2360G>A group. An explanation for this difference can be found in the type of mutation. The deletion in the coding sequence of the MSTN gene causes a premature stop codon that leads to a non-functional protein. The c.2360G>A mutation causes a translational inhibition, which decreases the amount of circulating MSTN to approximately one-third compared with wildtype animals [52]. Also in humans, a functional mutation in the non-coding MSTN gene was found. It concerns a guanine to adenine transition at position +5 in intron 1 of the human MSTN gene. This is a common location of splicing and in vitro studies show that approximately 69% of the MSTN gene bearing the transition is misspliced, leading to a severely truncated protein, as also seen in cattle [53]. DGAT1 In 1998, a QTL with a major effect on milk fat content and other milk characteristics was mapped onto chromosome 14 in cattle [54]. A very strong positional candidate gene within the QTL confidence interval was DGAT1, a gene that encodes diacylglycerol-O-acyltransferase, a microsomal enzyme that catalyses the final step of triglyceride synthesis [28, 55]. In exon 8 of the DGAT1 gene, an ApA to GpC dinucleotide substitution was found that caused an amino acid substitution of a conserved positively
g
charged lysine residue into a neutral, hydrophobic alanine residue (K232A) [28]. This mutation leads to an increased activity of the enzyme and a subsequent higher production of triglycerides [56]. In 2004, an additional polymorphism was found at position 1465 in the promoter gene of the DGAT1 gene that was associated with milk fat percentage variation within the German Holstein population. Alleles of a variable number of tandem repeats (VNTR) polymorphism were found to be associated with milk fat content in animals that were homozygous for the lysine to alanine substitution. Since a potential transcription factor binding site is present within the VNTR, it also might concern a causal mutation [57]. ATP-binding cassette sub-family G member 2 (ABCG2) In 2005, another QTM for cattle milk production was proposed on chromosome 6, affecting milk fat and protein concentration [58]. Besides being a strong positional candidate gene, ABCG2 was also an interesting functional candidate, since ABCG2 is strongly expressed in the mammary gland of mice, cows and humans and it is responsible for the active secretion of clinically and toxicologically important substrates into mouse milk [59]. A single nucleotide change from A to C encoded for a tyrosine residue instead of a serine residue (Y581S) in the ABCG2 transporter. Animals with the tyrosine residue showed a decrease in milk yield and a change in milk composition with a higher fat percentage and a higher protein percentage compared with those with the serine residue [58, 60].
Reproduction Traits The B. fecundity gene and other genes involved in prolificacy in sheep At a workshop on the Booroola Merino at Armidale, Piper and Bindon [61] were the first to report the B. fecundity gene (FecB) as the first major gene causing an increase in the ovulation rate in sheep. The effect of FecB is additive for ovulation rate (increasing by about 1.6 corpora lutea per cycle for each copy) and the FecB mutation increases litter size by one to two extra lambs with each copy [31]. The QTM underlying FecB was found to be a G to A transition at position 746 of the coding sequence of the Bone Morphogenetic Protein Receptor-type 1B (BMPR-1B) gene, located on sheep chromosome 6. This polymorphism leads to an alteration from a glutamine residue to an arginine residue at position 249 of the BMPR-1B protein, which is a member of the transforming growth factor-b (TGF-b) receptor family [31, 62–64]. Other mutations increasing the ovulation rate in sheep were found in two members of the TGF-b family: the Bone Morphogenetic Protein 15 (BMP15) and the Growth and Differentiation Factor-9 (GDF9) [65–67]. In the BMP15 gene on the X chromosome (FecX), not less than 5 independent mutations have been found that
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys
all result in the same phenotype: one copy of the mutation gives an increase in ovulation rate, whereas two copies make the ewe sterile with small underdeveloped ovaries containing follicles with not more than one layer of granulose cells. The mutations in BMP15 are called FecXI, FecXH, FecXG, FecXB and FecXL. FecXI or the Inverdale mutation is a T to A transition at nucleotide position 896 in the cDNA, resulting in a substitution of valine with aspartic acid at amino acid 31 of the mature protein (V31D). FecXH is called the Hanna mutation. This is a transition of C to T residue at nucleotide position 871 and leads to a stop codon at position 23 of the mature protein (Q23stop). FecXG (Galway), FecXB (Belclare) and FecXL (Lacaune) are C to T, G to T and G to A transitions at nucleotides 718, 1100 and 1196 of the cDNA, respectively. They are responsible for a stop codon at position 239 of the unprocessed protein (T239stop), a substitution of a serine with an isoleucine at position 99 (S99I) and a substitution of a cysteine with a tyrosine at position 53 (C53Y) of the mature protein, respectively [64]. The mutation in the GDF-9 gene on chromosome 5 is an A to T transition at position 1184 of the cDNA is a substitution of a serine with a phenylalanine (S77F). It is called the High Fertility mutation (FecGH). Homozygous FecGH/FecGH ewes are (like the homozygous FecX mutant carriers) infertile but, in contrast to the FecX phenotype, their ovarian follicles develop to an abnormal type 5 early antral stage [68].
QTMs in Congenital Disorders in Farm Animals In addition to the search for genes involved in the ‘classical’ (re)production traits, the search for diseaserelated genes in farm animals becomes increasingly important. Several QTMs involved in the susceptibility to various (congenital) disorders in dogs, cattle and sheep are known or are under investigation. The advent of the SNP chip has speeded up the progress in this area. Examples are the discoveries of the genetic components of congenital muscular dystonia (CMD) types 1 and 2, foetal ichytiosis and complex vertebral malformation (CVM) in cattle [13, 69]. It has to be noted, however, that it concerns simple monogenic disorders and not the more complicated polygenic disorders. However, it is expected that risk factors that lead to a 2–5 higher incidence of a polygenic disorder could also be mapped using the SNP chip, screening as few as 200 animals [9].
Transmissible Spongiform Encephalopathy (TSE) TSEs are transmissible prion diseases, caused by abnormally folded prion proteins (PrPs) that induce the conversion of the non-infectious, cellular form of the host PrP into the abnormal, infectious form. This group of
g
65
diseases includes scrapie in sheep and goats, bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle, chronic wasting disease in deer and elk, feline spongiform encephalopathy in cats, transmissible mink encephalopathy and variant Creutzfeldt–Jacob disease (CJD) in humans. All TSE diseases are dependent on the expression of the host PrP protein and substitutions in this gene are found to have direct consequences for TSE pathogenesis, TSE susceptibility and the host species barrier of transmissibility [70–72]. Scrapie is an invariably fatal, neurodegenerative disease in sheep and goats [73]. However, since scrapie outbreaks in goats in many countries are very rare, the study of scrapie in goats is not a priority. Therefore, in what follows, only the progressions in the research for scrapie in sheep will be discussed. Clinical observations of classical scrapie are increased anxiety, teeth grinding, pruritus, a crouched or wide-based stance, ataxia, hyperthermia, tremors and a loss of weight. Neuropathologically, the disease is characterized by the presence of vacuoles in neurons and neuropil, together with PrP proteins in the brain [74]. The host PrP protein is known to be a major component of scrapie and polymorphisms appear throughout the entire PrP gene. However, only three mutations in the part of the sequence that encodes for the highly structured C-terminal domain have been found to be associated unambiguously with TSE susceptibility and incubation period: an alanine to valine substitution at amino acid (AA) 136 (A136V), an arginine to histidine substitution at AA 154 (R154H) and a glutamine to arginine/histidine substitution at AA 171 (Q171R/H) [70, 75, 76]. Between these polymorphisms, a complex relationship exists. From a simplistic perspective, V136, R154 Q171 and H171 were linked to susceptibility to scrapie, while A136, H154 and R171 were linked to resistance. However, of the 12 possible combinations of these polymorphisms, only five occur with any frequency: ARR (A at codon 136, R at codon 154 and R at codon 171), ARQ, AHQ, ARH and VRQ [77, 78]. More recently, also the AHR and VRR alleles were reported, however, no information on the susceptibility to scrapie is available [79, 80]. When examining these alleles, it becomes apparent that a high degree of susceptibility is associated with the VRQ allele. Furthermore, the resistance conferred by the ARR allele is also very clear [70, 78]. Other alleles/genotypes that play a role in the susceptibility of scrapie include the ARQ/ARQ genotype, the ARQ and ARH alleles and the ARH/VRQ genotype. However, these effects are either largely dependent on sheep breed and scrapie strain or are rather subtle [70]. In addition to the susceptibility for scrapie, also the incubation period for scrapie is genetically determined [81]. Between the susceptibility of a genotype and the age at death, a clear negative relationship exists, such that sheep of the genotypes with the greatest scrapie risk (VRQ/VRQ and ARQ/ VRQ) die, on average, the youngest. However, exceptions do exist [70].
CAB International 2009
66
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Atypical scrapie is quite different from the classical form of the disease. Sheep with this unusual type of scrapie displayed predominantly ataxia without pruritus. Neuropathological findings of vacuolation and PrP proteins were restricted to cerebellar and cerebral cortices and not present so much in the brainstem at the level of the obex [74]. The three most common atypical scrapie PrP alleles are ARR, AHQ and AF141RQ. The latter is ARQ containing a phenylalanine residue at amino acid position 141 instead of a leucine [82]. BSE is another example of a TSE and is a fatal, neurodegenerative disease in cattle that causes a spongy degeneration in the brain and spinal cord. BSE has a long incubation period of about 4 years and mainly affects adult animals at a peak age onset of 4–5 years (http://fsrio. nal.usda.gov/document_fsheet.php?product_id=169). In cattle, two forms of BSE exist. Classical BSE is associated with ingestion of BSE-contaminated feed and is therefore greatly dependent on environmental factors. H- and L-type BSE, collectively known as atypical BSE, differs from classical BSE by displaying a different disease phenotype and not being linked to the consumption of contaminated feed. Atypical BSE thus is much more independent of environmental factors than classical BSE [72, 83]. As for scrapie in sheep, also in cattle, polymorphisms in the PrP gene, associated with the susceptibility for BSE were found. In cattle with classical BSE, a 23-bp indel poly0 morphism was found in the 5 -flanking sequence of the bovine PrP gene and a 12-bp indel polymorphism in intron 1. These two indel polymorphisms, which contain binding sites for the RP58 and SP1 transcription factors, were found to modulate the expression of the PrP gene in vivo, and can therefore play a role in the susceptibility for BSE in cattle. For both mutations, the deletion alleles confer a higher risk of developing BSE in comparison with the insertion alleles; however, whether the major effect is associated with the 23-bp indel or 12-bp indel differs between studies [71, 84, 85]. In cattle with H-type atypical BSE, a polymorphism at codon 211 (E211K) of the bovine PrP gene was found. This mutation resulted in the substitution of a glutamic acid residue into a lysine residue and is highly analogous to a human polymorphism described as the most common cause of inherited CJD in humans (E200K). The presence of the lysine residue at this codon in humans resulted in complete penetrance of CJD, but the functional significance of the mutation is still unknown. However, taken together, these findings suggest that the bovine PrP E211K mutation is most likely to cause BSE in animals carrying the mutation [72, 85].
Bovine and Canine Leukocyte Adhesion Deficiency (LAD) Bovine LAD (BLAD) in dairy cattle is a lethal autosomal recessive congenital disease characterized by recurrent bacterial infections, delayed wound healing and stunted
g
growth, and is also associated with persistent marked neutrophilia [86]. BLAD is characterized by lack of expression of adhesion molecules of the CD11/CD18 family, which play an essential role for host defence on the leukocyte surface. Therefore, the gene encoding bovine CD18 was sequenced as a candidate gene for BLAD in Holstein cattle. An A to G point mutation was found at position 383 of the CD18 gene, which caused an aspartic acid to glycine substitution at amino acid 128 in the glycoprotein. This mutation occurs near the centre of 26 consecutive amino acids that are identical in normal bovine, human and murine CD18 and lies within a large extracellular region that is highly conserved across integrin b subunits [86, 87]. Restriction analysis of PCR amplified DNA containing position 383 of the CD18 gene allows discrimination between normal, carrier and affected animals [87]. Also in dogs, and more specifically in Irish Setters, leukocyte adhesion deficiency was found (canine LAD (CLAD)) and the clinical manifestations are very similar to those of BLAD. Also, similarly to cattle, a mutation in the CD18 gene (G to C transversion) is responsible for this neurodegenerative disease in dogs. The G to C mutation leads to a replacement of a conserved cysteine residue to a serine residue at codon 36 of the CD18 protein. This mutation leads to the inability of CD18 to form heterodimers with the human CD11 subunit, as normal canine CD18 does [88].
CMD Types 1 and 2 CMD types 1 and 2 are important recessive genetic defects that occur in Belgian Blue cattle. Calves affected with CMD1 show impaired swallowing, fatigue upon stimulation or exercise, and muscle myotonia, resulting in an inability to flex limbs and injurious falling. CMD1 calves usually die within a few weeks as a result of respiratory complications. CMD2 calves suffer severe episodes of myoclonus upon acoustic or tactile stimulation and typically die within a few hours after birth. For both these defects, functional mutations were found using the recent technique of the genome-wide SNP analysis. Using this genome-wide SNP scan on DNA samples from affected individuals and controls, a 2.12 Mb segment encompassing the CMD1 locus was found. Within this interval, a missense mutation leading to a R559C substitution in exon 14 of ATP2A1 was found. It is known that Arg559 in bovine ATP2A1 is located within the nucleotidebinding domain and is a highly conserved, functionally significant residue that directly interacts with the b-phosphate moiety of ATP. Substitution of this residue leads to impaired ATP binding and is therefore very likely to be the causative mutation underlying CMD1. For CMD2, a 3.61 Mb segment containing the CMD2 locus was found on chromosome 29, including a strong candidate gene: SLC6A5. In exon 4 of this gene, a missense
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys
mutation was found, resulting in a L270P substitution in the third membrane-spanning domain of GlyT2. This Leu270 is not predicted to be involved in the binding of glycine or Na+, but was shown to be conserved at this position in all vertebrates studied. This indicates that the residue has an important structural or functional role. Indeed, it was found that the mutation disrupted the presynaptic uptake of glycine by GlyT2 and was causative for CMD2 in cattle [13].
Crooked Tail Syndrome (CTS) CTS is another genetic defect in Belgian Blue cattle. Typical characteristics of animals with CTS are a crooked tail and shortened head, growth retardation, extreme muscularity and spastic paresia. The disease is not lethal but can cause substantial economical losses due to growth retardation and treatment [13]. Carrier animals have an enhanced muscular development, and this heterozygote advantage is the cause for a selective sweep, which explains the fact that the incidence of CTS has risen very suddenly in Belgian Blue cattle and that 25% of the animals now appear to be CTS carrier [89]. Using a genome-wide SNP scan on DNA samples from affected individuals and controls, a 2.42 Mb segment on bovine chromosome 19 encompassing the mutation causing CTS was found [13]. The mutation is a 2 bp deletion in the open reading frame of the Mannose Receptor C type 2 (MRC2), creating a frameshift which is the cause for a premature stop. Consequently, the 180 kDa endocytic transmembrane glycoprotein can no longer be formed in affected animals [89].
Foetal Ichytiosis Severe forms of ichytiosis fetalis (IF) have been reported in Chianina cattle. Calves affected with ichtyosis fetalis show cutaneous lesions, with deep fissures separating hyperkeratotic skin plaques and eversion of mucocutaneous junctions, comparable to harlequin ichtyosis in humans. Using a genome-wide SNP scan on DNA samples from affected individuals and controls, an 11.78 Mb segment encompassing the IF locus was found. In this interval, a strong candidate gene was found: namely the ABCA12 gene. In exon 39 of this gene, a missense A5804G mutation was found, resulting in an H1935R substitution in the fourth extracellular loop. It was found that this mutation was causal for the disease [13].
CVM CVM is a recessively inherited disorder with onset during foetal development, leading to frequent abortions of foetuses or perinatal death. Animals affected with CVM
g
67
show misshapen and fused vertebrae around the cervicothoracic junction. It was found that CVM is caused by a missense mutation in the Golgi-resident nucleotidesugar transporter (UDP-N-acetylglucosamine transporter) encoded by positional candidate gene SLC35A3. It concerns a G to T transversion that replaces valine with phenylalanine at position 180. This mutation was functionally tested by yeast complementation assay in the Kluyveromyces lactis mutant mnn2–2, which is deficient in transport of N-acetylglucosamine in Golgi vesicles. This assay showed a partial or complete loss of function of the mutant protein. From these results, it could be concluded that indeed the missense polymorphism in SLC35A3 was the causative mutation for CVM. It also excluded the possibility that a mutation in another gene, tightly linked to SLC35A3 is causing the defect [69].
Factor XI (FXI) A deficiency in blood coagulation FXI has been found in Holstein cattle. The mutation responsible for this deficiency is a 76 bp insertion in exon 12 of the FXI gene. This polymorphism leads to a stop codon, which results in a mature FXI protein lacking the functional protease domain encoded by exons 13, 14 and 15 [90]. The disorder seems to have an impact on reproductive traits and udder health in cattle [91].
Genomic Selection Traditional selection has been successful in improving a large number of traits for a long time. However, it requires widespread, reasonably accurate and preferably early-in-life recording of traits. Functional traits only partially fulfil these requirements [92]. Also, estimated breeding values should be able to predict more accurately by implementing information on DNA polymorphisms underlying traits of interest. Research towards MAS has been active and extensive but implementation of results has been limited and the increase in genetic gain is mostly rather disappointing [93]. Therefore, quite recently, in addition to research for markers for MAS, genomic selection has become an area of intense research. Genomic selection could be defined as MAS on a genomewide scale. Different to the MAS previously described, where selection was for only a few causal or linked markers, genomic selection is the simultaneous selection for many (tens or hundreds of thousands of) markers, which cover the entire genome in a dense manner. This way, all genes are expected to be in LD with at least some of the markers so that potentially all the genetic variance is explained by the markers [6, 94, 95]. In 2001, when Meuwissen et al. introduced this technique, major limitations to implementation were the large number of markers required and the cost of genotyping these
CAB International 2009
68
Animal Science Reviews 2010
markers. Nowadays, however, with the development of the SNP chips for almost all domestic animals and the developments in SNP genotyping technology, these limitations have been overcome. Simulation results and limited experimental results suggest that breeding values can very accurately be predicted using genetic markers alone. However, more validation is required, especially in samples of populations that are different from the original population wherein the effect of the markers was estimated. Nevertheless, many livestock breeding companies are implementing or are planning to implement genomic selection in their breeding programmes [6].
Conclusion/Summary In conclusion, although numerous QTLs have been found for quantitative traits in different species of domestic animals, the number of causative mutations (QTMs) identified is very limited. This is due to the fact that most QTLs have a mild phenotypic effect, so the mutations that underlie them are difficult to distinguish from neutral polymorphisms [3]. The QTMs, such as the one of IGF2, which have a major influence and are responsible for quite a large amount of phenotypic variance, are therefore the ones first found. Another factor that complicates the finding of the QTL mutations is the fact that a good proportion of these are located in regulatory regions. It becomes even more complex to unravel the underlying mutations when epistasis or epigenetic inheritance is involved in the quantitative genetic variation [3]. Both candidate gene approaches and whole genome linkage analysis followed by LD mapping have contributed to the characterization of QTMs. Whole genome scans using the SNP panels recently developed for different species already lead to the identification of mutations involved in monogenic traits. Their usefulness in detection of QTMs remains to be elucidated, although it is expected that these could also be mapped. Although the new trend in livestock breeding or genomic selection does not require the knowledge of causative mutations, QTMs are the only type of mutations that do not require validation in each new population. Hence, besides its scientific value, or its contribution to increasing the knowledge on the regulatory mechanisms underlying phenotypic traits, the identification of QTM in domestic animals will remain important for breeding purposes.
3. Andersson L, Georges M. Domestic-animal genomics: deciphering the genetics of complex traits. Nature Reviews Genetics 2001;5:202–12. 4. Mackay TFC. Quantitative trait loci in Drosophila. Nature Reviews Genetics 2001;2:11–21. 5. Andersson L. Genome-wide association analysis in domestic animals: a powerful approach for genetic dissection of trait loci. Genetica 2009;136:341–9. 6. Goddard ME, Hayes BJ. Mapping genes for complex traits in domestic animals and their use in breeding programmes. Nature Reviews Genetics 2009;10:381–91. 7. Georges M. Mapping, fine mapping and molecular dissection of quantitative trait loci in domestic animals. Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics 2007;8:131–62. 8. Harmegnies N, Farnir F, Davin F, Buys N, Georges M, Coppieters W. Measuring the extent of linkage disequilibrium in commercial pig populations. Animal Genetics 2006;37:225– 31. 9. Lindblad-Toh K, Wade CM, Mikkelsen TS, Karlsson EK, Jaffe DB, Kamal M, et al. Genome sequence, comparative analysis and haplotype structure of the domestic dog. Nature 2005;438:803–19. 10. De Roos APW, Hayes BJ, Spelman R, Goddard ME. Linkage disequilibrium and persistence of phase in Holstein Freisian, Jersey and Angus cattle. Genetics 2008;179:1503–12. 11. MacEachern S, Hayes BJ, McEwan J, Goddard ME. An examination of positive selection and changing effective population size in Angus and Holstein cattle populations (Bos taurus) using a high density SNP genotyping platform and the contribution of ancient polymorphism to genomic diversity in domestic cattle. BMC Genomics 2009;10:181. 12. Karlsson EK, Baranowska I, Wade CM, Salmon Hillbertz NHC, Zody MC, Anderson N, et al. Efficient mapping of Mendelian traits in dogs through genome-wide association. Nature Genetics 2007;39:1321–8. 13. Charlier C, Coppieters W, Rollin F, Desmecht D, Agerholm JS, Cambisano N, et al. Highly effective SNP-based association mapping and management of recessive defects in livestock. Nature Genetics 2008;40:449–54. 14. Yu TP, Tuggle CK, Schmitz CB, Rothschild MF. Association of PIT1 polymorphisms with growth and carcass traits in pigs. Journal of Animal Science 1995;73:1282–8. 15. Ron M, Weller JI. From QTL to QTN identification in livestock – winning by points rather than by knock-out: a review. Animal Genetics 2007;38:429–39. 16. Fujii J, Otsu K, Zorzato F, de Leon S, Khanna VK, Weiler SE, et al. Identification of a mutation in porcine ryanodine receptor associated with malignant hyperthermia. Science 1991;253:448–51. 17. Grobet L, Martin LHR, Poncelet D, Pirottin D, Brouwers B, Riquet J, et al. A deletion in the bovine myostatin gene causes the double-muscled phenotype in cattle. Nature Genetics 1997;17:71–4.
References 1. Andersson L. Genetic dissection of phenotypic diversity in farm animals. Nature Reviews Genetics 2001;2:130–8.
18. Kambadur R, Sharma M, Smith TPL, Bass JJ. Mutations in myostatin (GDF8) in double-muscled Belgian Blue and Piedmontese cattle. Genome Research 1997;7:910–5.
2. Williams JL. The use of marker-assisted selection in animal breeding and biotechnology. Revue Scientifique et Technique (International Office of Epizootics) 2005;24:379–91.
19. McPherron AC, Lee SJ. Double muscling in cattle due to mutations in the myostatin gene. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 1997;94:12457–61.
g
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys 20. Mosher DS, Quignon P, Bustamante CD, Sutter NB, Mellersh CS, Parker HG, et al. A mutation in the myostatin gene increases muscle mass and enhances racing performance in heterozygous dogs. PLoS Genetics 2007;3:e79. 21. Georges M, Nielsen D, Mackinnon M, Mishra A, Okimoto R, Pasquino AT, et al. Mapping quantitative trait loci controlling milk production in dairy cattle by exploiting progeny testing. Genetics 1995;139:907–20. 22. Farnir F, Coppieters W, Arranz J, Berzi P, Cambisano N, Grisart B, et al. Extensive genome-wide linkage disequilibrium in cattle. Genome Research 2000;10:220–7. 23. Van Laere A, Nguyen M, Braunschweig M, Nezer C, Collette C, Moreau L, et al. A regulatory mutation in IGF2 causes a major QTL effect on muscle growth in the pig. Nature 2003;425:832–6. 24. Milan D, Jeon JT, Looft C, Amarger V, Robic A, Thelander M, et al. A mutation in PRKAG3 associated with excess glycogen content in pig skeletal muscle. Science 2000;288:1248–51. 25. Andersson L. Identification and characterization of AMPKg 3 mutations in the pig. Biochemical Society Transactions 2003;31:232–5. 26. Szabo´ G, Dallmann G, Mu¨ller G, Patthy L, Soller M, Varga L. A deletion in the myostatin gene causes the compact (Cmpt) hypermuscular mutation in mice. Mammalian Genome 1998;9:671–2.
69
and technological meat quality in Hampshire-sired pigs. Livestock Production Science 1997;47:221–9. 35. Milan D, Woloszyn N, Yerle M, Le Roy P, Bonnet M, Riquet J, et al. Accurate mapping of the “acid meat” RN gene on genetic and physical maps of pig chromosome 15. Mammalian Genome 1996;7:47–51. 36. Lindahl G, Enfa¨lt A, Von Seth G, Josell A, Hedebro-Velander I, Andersen HJ, et al. A second mutant allele (V199I) at the PRKAG (RN) locus – I. Effect on technological meat quality of pork loin. Meat Science 2004;66:609–19. 37. Lindahl G, Enfa¨lt A, Von Seth G, Joseli A, Hedebro-Velander I, Andersen HJ, et al. A second mutant allele (V199I) at the PRKAG (RN) locus – II. Effect on colour characteristics of pork loin. Meat Science 2004;66:609–19. 38. Andersson-Eklund L, Marklund L, Lundstro¨m K, Haley CS, Andersson K, Hansson I, et al. Mapping quantitative trait loci for carcass and meat quality traits in a wild boarLarge White intercross. Journal of Animal Science 1998;76:694–700. 39. Jeon JT, Carlborg O¨, To¨rnsten A, Giuffra E, Amarger V, Chardon P, et al. A paternally expressed QTL affecting skeletal and cardiac muscle mass in pigs maps to the IGF2 locus. Nature Genetics 1999;21:157–8. 40. Nezer C, Moreau L, Brouwers B, Coppieters W, Detilleux J, Hanset R, et al. An imprinted QTL with major effect on muscle mass and fat deposition maps to the IGF2 locus in pigs. Nature Genetics 1999;21:155–6.
27. Clop A, Marcq F, Takeda H, Pirottin D, Tordoir X, Bibe´ B, et al. A mutation creating a potential illegitimate microRNA target site in the myostatin gene affects muscularity in sheep. Nature Genetics 2006;38:813–8.
41. Florini JR, Magri KA, Ewton DZ, James PL, Grindstaff K, Rotwein PS. ‘Spontaneous’ differentiation of skeletal myoblasts is dependent upon autocrine secretion of insulin-like growth factor-II. Journal of Biological Chemistry 1991;266:15917–23.
28. Grisart B, Coppieters W, Farnir F, Karim L, Ford C, Berzi P, et al. Positional candidate cloning of a QTL in dairy cattle: identification of a missense mutation in the bovine DGAT1 gene with major effect on milk yield and composition. Genome Research 2001;12:222–31.
42. Oksbjerg N, Gondret F, Vestergaard M. Basic principles of muscle development and growth in meat-producing mammals as affected by the insulin-like growth factor (IGF) system. Domestic Animal Endocrinology 2004;27:219–40.
29. Cockett NE, Jackson SP, Shay TL, Nielsen D, Moore SS, Steele MR, et al. Chromosomal localisation of the callipyge gene in sheep (Ovis aries) using bovine DNA markers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 1994;91:3019–23. 30. Charlier C, Segers K, Karim L, Shay T, Gyapay G, Cockett N, et al. The callipyge mutation enhances the expression of coregulated imprinted genes in cis without affecting their imprinting status. Nature Genetics 2001;27:367–9. 31. Wilson T, Wu X, Juengel JL, Ross IK, Lumsden JM, Lord EA, et al. Highly prolific Booroola sheep have a mutation in the intracellular kinase domain of bone morphogenetic protein IB receptor (ALK-6) that is expressed in both oocytes and granulose cells. Biology of Reproduction 2001;64:1225–35. 32. Meuwissen THE, Goddard ME. Mapping multiple QTL using linkage disequilibrium and linkage analysis information and multitrait data. Genetics Selection Evolution 2004;36:261–79.
43. Oczkowicz M, Tyra M, Walinowicz K, Ro´zycki M, Rejduch B. Known mutation (A3072G) in intron 3 of the IGF2 gene is associated with growth and carcass composition in Polish pig breeds. Journal of Applied Genetics 2009;50:257–9. 44. Braunschweig MH, Van Laere AS, Buys N, Andersson L, Andersson G. IGF2 antisense transcript expression in porcine postnatal muscle is affected by a quantitative trait nucleotide in intron 3. Genomics 2004;84:1021–9. 45. Jackson SP, Miller MF and Green RD. The effect of a muscle hypertrophy gene on muscle weights of ram lambs. Proceedings, Western Section, American Society of Animal Science 1993;44:196–8. 46. Jackson SP, Miller MF, Green RD, Brdecko KS. Carcass characteristics of Rambouillet ram lambs with genetic muscle hypertrophy. Proceedings, Western Section, American Society of Animal Science 1993;44:167–9.
33. Lister D. The physiology and biochemistry of the porcine stress syndrome. In: Tarrant PV, Eikelboom G, Monin G, editors. Evaluation and Control of Meat Quality in Pigs. Martinus Nijfhoff Publishers, Boston, MA; 1987. p. 3–16.
47. Freking BA, Murphy SK, Wylie AA, Rhodes SJ, Keele JW, Leymaster KA, et al. Identification of the single base change causing the callipyge muscle hyperthrophy phenotype, the only known example of polar overdominance in mammals. Genome Research 2002;12:1496–506.
34. Enfalt A, Lundstro¨m K, Hansson I, Johansen S, Nystro¨m P. Comparison of non-carriers and heterozygous carriers of the RN7 allele for carcass composition, muscle distribution
48. Georges M, Charlier C, Cockett N. The callipyge locus: evidence for the trans interaction of reciprocally imprinted genes. Trends in Genetics 2003;19:248–52.
g
CAB International 2009
70
Animal Science Reviews 2010
49. Grobet L, Poncelet D, Royo LJ, Brouwers B, Pirottin, Michaux C, et al. Molecular definition of an allelic series of mutations disrupting the myostatin function and causing double-muscling in cattle. Mammalian Genome 1998;9:210–3.
62. Souza CJH, MacDougall C, Campbell BK, McNeilly AS, Baird DT. The Booroola (FecB) phenotype is associated with a mutation in the bone morphogenetic receptor type 1 B (BMPR1B) gene. Journal of Endocrinology 2001;169(2):R1–6.
50. Karim L, Coppieters W, Grobet L, Valentini A, Georges M. Convenient genotyping of six myostatin mutations causing double-muscling in cattle using a multiplex oligonucleotide ligation assay. Animal genetics 2000;31:396–9.
63. Mulsant P, Lecerf F, Fabre S, Schibler L, Monget P, Lanneluc I, et al. Mutation in bone morphogenetic protein receptor-IB is associated with increased ovulation rate in Booroola Me´rino ewes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 2001;98(9):5104–9.
51. Marchitelli C, Savarese MC, Crisa` A, Nardone A, Marsan PA, Valentini A. Double muscling in Marchigiana beef breed is caused by a stop codon in the third exon of myostatin gene. Mammalian Genome 2003;14:392–5.
64. Fabre S, Pierre A, Mulsant P, Bodin L, Di Pasquale E, Persani L, et al. Regulation of ovulation rate in mammals: contribution of sheep genetic models. Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology 2006;4:20.
52. Boman IA, Klemetsdal G, Blichfeldt T, Nafstad O, Va˚ge DI. A frameshift mutation in the coding region of the myostatin gene (MSTN) affects carcass conformation and fatness in Norwegian White Sheep (Ovis aries). Animal genetics 2009;40:418–22.
65. Galloway SM, McNatty KP, Cambridge LM, Laitinen MPE, Juengel JL, Jokiranta S, et al. Mutations in an oocyte-derived growth factor gene (BMP15) cause increased ovulation rate and infertility in a dosage-sensitive manner. Nature Genetics 2000;25(3):279–83.
53. Schuelke M, Wagner KR, Stolz LE, Hu¨bner C, Riedel T, Ko¨men W, et al. Myostatin mutation associated with gross muscle hyperthrophy in a child. New England Journal of Medicine 2004;350:2682–8.
66. Hanrahan JP, Gregan SM, Mulsant P, Mullen M, Davis GH, Powell R, et al. Mutations in the genes for oocyte-derived growth factors GDF9 and BMP15 are associated with both increased ovulation rate and sterility in Cambridge and Belclare sheep. Biology of Reproduction 2004;70(4):900–9.
54. Coppieters W, Riquet J, Arranz JJ, Berzi P, Cambisano N, Grisart B, et al. A QTL with major effect on milk yield and composition maps to bovine chromosome 14. Mammalian Genome 1998;9:540–4. 55. Winter A, Kra¨mer W, Werner FAO, Kollers S, Kata S, Durstewitz G, et al. Association of a lysine-232/alanine polymorphism in a bovine gene encoding acylCoA:diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT1) with variation at a quantitativ trait locus for milk fat content. Proceedings of the National of Academy of Sciences of the USA 2002;99:9300–5. 56. Grisart B, Farnir F, Karim L, Cambisano N, Kim JJ, Kvasz A, et al. Genetic and functional confirmation of the causality of the DGAT1 K232A quantitative trait nucleotide in affecting milk yield and composition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 2004;101:2398–403.
67. Davis GH. Major genes affecting ovulation rate in sheep. Genetic Selection Evolution 2005;37(Suppl. 1):S11–23. 68. McNatty KP, Galloway SM, Wilson T, Smith P, Hudson NL, O’Connell A, et al. Physiological effects of major genes affecting ovulation rate in sheep. Genetics Selection Evolution 2005;37(Suppl. 1):S25–38. 69. Thomsen B, Horn P, Panitz F, Bendixen E, Petersen AH, Holm LE, et al. A missense mutation in the bovine SLC35A3 gene, encoding a UDP-N-acetylglucosamine transporter, causes complex vertebral malformation. Genome Research 2006;16:97–105. 70. Baylis M, Goldmann W. The genetics of scrapie in sheep and goats. Current Molecular Medicine 2004;4:385–96.
57. Ku¨hn C, Thaller G, Winter A, Bininda-Emonds ORP, Kaupe B, Erhardt G, et al. Evidence for multiple alleles at the DGAT1 locus better explains a quantitative trait locus with major effect on milk fat content in cattle. Genetics 2004;167:1873–81.
71. Sander P, Hamann H, Dro¨gemu¨ller C, Kashkevich K, Schiebel K, Leeb T. Bovine prion protein gene (PRNP) promotor polymorphisms modulate PRNP expression and may be responsible for differences in bovine spongiform encephalopathy susceptibility. Journal of Biological Chemistry 2005;280:37408–14.
58. Cohen-Zinder M, Seroussi E, Larkin DM, Loor JL, Everts-Van der Wind A, Lee J, et al. Identification of a missense mutation in the bovine ABCG2 gene with a major effect on the QTL on chromosome 6 affecting milk yield and composition in Holstein cattle. Genome Research 2005;15:936–44.
72. Nicholson EM, Brunelle BW, Richt JA, Kehrli ME, Greenlee JJ. Identification of a heritable polymorphism in bovine PRNP associated with genetic transmissible spongiform encephalopathy: evidence of heritable BSE. PLoS One 2008;3:e2912.
59. Jonker JW, Merino G, Musters S, Van Herwaarden AE, Bolscher E, Wagenaar E, et al. The breast cancer resistance protein BCRP (ABCG2) concentrates drugs and carcinogenic xenotoxins into milk. Nature Medicine 2004;11:127–9. 60. Olsen HG, Nilsen H, Hayes B, Berg RR, Svendsen M, Lien S, et al. Genetic support for a quantitative trait nucleotide in the ABCG2 gene affecting milk composition of dairy cattle. BMC Genetics 2007;8:32. 61. Piper LR, Bindon BM. The Booroola Merino and the performance of medium non-peppin crosses at Armidale. In Piper LR, Bindon BM, Nethery RD, editors. The Booroola Merino, Proceedings of a Workshop, Armidale, 24–25 August 1980, CSIRO; 1982, pp. 9–19.
g
73. Prusiner SB. Research on scrapie. Lancet 1982;2:494–5. 74. Konold T, Davis A, Bone G, Bracegirdle J, Everitt S, Chaplin M, et al. Clinical findings in two cases of atypical scrapie in sheep: a case report. BMC Veterinary Research 2007;3:2. 75. Goldmann W, Hunter N, Foster JD, Salbaum JM, Beyreuther K, Hope J. Two alleles of a neural protein gene linked to scrapie in sheep. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 1990;87:2476–80. 76. Goldmann W, Hunter N, Benson G, Foster JD, Hope J. Different scrapie-associated fibril proteins (PrP) are encoded by lines of sheep selected for different alleles of the Sip gene. Journal of General Virology 1991;72:2411–7.
CAB International 2009
Anneleen Stinckens, Martine Schroyen, Liesbet Peeters, Steven Janssens and Nadine Buys 77. Belt PBGM, Muileman IH, Schreuder BEC, Bos-De Ruijter JB, Gielkens ALJ, Smits MA. Identification of five allelic variants of the sheep PrP gene and their association with natural scrapie. Journal of General Virology 1995;76:509–17. 78. Ikeda T, Horiuchi M, Ishiguro N, Muramatsu Y, Kai-Uwe GD, Shinagawa M. Amino acid polymorphisms of PrP with reference to onset of scrapie in Suffolk and Corriedale sheep in Japan. Journal of General Virology 1995;76:2577–81. 79. Kutzer T, Pfeiffer I, Brenig B. Identification of new allelic variants in the ovine prion protein (PrP) gene. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2002;119:201–8. 80. Tkacikova L, Hanusovska E, Novak M, Arvayova M, Mikula I. The PrP genotype of sheep of the improved Valachian breed. Folia Microbiologica 2003;48:269–76. 81. Houston EF, Halliday SI, Jeffrey M, Goldmann W, Hunter N. New Zealand sheep with scrapie-susceptible PrP genotypes succumb to experimental challenge with a sheep-passaged scrapie isolate (SSBP/1). Journal of General Virology 2002;83:1247–50.
71
87. Shuster DE, Kehrli ME, Ackermann MR, Gilbert RO. Identification and prevalence of a genetic defect that causes leukocyte adhesion deficiency in Holstein cattle. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 1992;89:9225–9. 88. Kijas JMH, Bauer TR, Ga¨fvert S, Marklund S, Trowald-Wigh G, Johannisson A, et al. A missense mutation in the b-2 integrin gene (ITGB2) causes canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency. Genomics 1999;61:101–7. 89. Fasquelle C, Sartelet A, Li W, Dive M, Tamma N, et al. Balancing selection of a frame-shift mutation in the MRC2 gene accounts for the outbreak of the crooked tail syndrome in Belgian Blue Cattle. PLos Genet 2009;5(9):e1000666. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1000666. 90. Marron BM, Robinson JL, Gentry PA, Beever E. Identification of a mutation associated with factor XI deficiency in Holstein cattle. Animal Genetics 2004;35:454–6.
82. Juling K, Schwarzenbacher H, Williams JL, Fries R. A major genetic component of BSE susceptibility. BMC Biology 2006;4:33.
91. Gurgul A, Rubis D, Slota E. Identification of carriers of the mutation causing coagulation factor XI deficiency in Polish Holstein–Friesian cattle. Journal of Applied Genetics 2009;50:149–52.
83. Saunders GC, Cawthraw S, Mountjov SJ, Hope J, Windl Q. PrP genotypes of atypical scrapie cases in Great Britain. Journal of General Virology 2006;87:3141–9.
92. Meuwissen T. Genomic selection: marker assisted selection on a genome wide scale. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2007;124:321–2.
84. Haase B, Doherr MG, Seuberlich T, Dro¨gemuller C, Dolf G, Nicken P, et al. PRNP promoter polymorphisms are associated with BSE susceptibility in Swiss and German cattle. BMC Genetics 2007;8:15.
93. Dekkers JC. Commercial application of marker- and gene-assisted selection in livestock: strategies and lessons. Journal of Animal Science 2004;82:E313–28.
85. Richt JA, Hall SM. BSE case associated with prion protein gene mutation. PloS Pathogens 2008;4:e1000156.
94. Meuwissen THE, Hayes BJ, Goddard ME. Prediction of total genetic value using genome-wide dense marker maps. Genetics 2001;157:1819–29.
86. Nagahata H. Bovine leukocyte adhesion deficiency (BLAD): a review. Journal of Veterinary Medical Science 2004;66:1475–82.
g
95. Goddard ME, Hayes BJ. Genomic selection. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 2007;124:323–30.
CAB International 2009
This page intentionally left blank
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Technical, epidemiological and financial implications of large-scale national vaccination campaigns to control HPAI H5N1 J. Hinrichs1*, J. Otte1 and J. Rushton2 Address: 1 FAO, Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00153 Rome, Italy. North Mymms, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, AL9 7TA, UK.
2
Royal Veterinary College (RVC), Hawkshead Lane,
*Correspondence: J. Hinrichs. Email:
[email protected] 30 September 2009 15 January 2010
Received: Accepted:
Abstract This paper reviews the literature on highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) vaccination of poultry and the resulting technical, epidemiological and financial implications for the control of HPAI H5N1 through national vaccination campaigns. Large-scale HPAI vaccination programmes have been implemented in a number of Southeast Asian countries and in Egypt, requiring substantial financial and human resources. HPAI remains endemic in these countries and it thus appears warranted to comprehensively assess all major aspects of large-scale vaccination campaigns for the control of HPAI. The paper reviews existing data and literature on HPAI vaccines, HPAI epidemics and large-scale HPAI H5N1 vaccination programmes and draws on calculations carried out by the authors to assess and evaluate the potential contribution and the financial implications of mass vaccination in the control of HPAI H5N1 in domestic poultry in developing countries. We conclude that the high and recurrent costs, technical difficulties and epidemiological drawbacks of large-scale, open-ended, blanket vaccination programmes in national efforts to control HPAI call for careful targeting of vaccination in national control strategies, which ‘intelligently’ combine available disease control measures. Keywords: Vaccination, Epidemiology, Economics, Highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI), Poultry production systems, Chicken, Ducks
Introduction Since its emergence in 1996 in China, highly pathogenic avian influenza (HPAI) H5N1 virus has infected 61 countries, been associated with more than 260 human fatalities, and resulted in disease mortality and culling of several hundred million domestic birds. In most of the affected countries, the H5N1 virus could be eliminated through swift and determined interventions of national animal health systems. In some countries, however, the virus appears to have become endemic in specific eco- and production systems, leading to resurgence of infection in poultry and humans, the moment control efforts are relaxed. The major countries in which HPAI H5N1 virus can currently be considered endemic comprise China, Egypt, Indonesia and Vietnam, all of which have
g
included vaccination as a part of their national control strategy. Under laboratory conditions, vaccination trials against HPAI have shown that a variety of commercially available vaccines protect against clinical signs and reduce virus shedding in the case of contact with field virus but do not prevent infection in all vaccinated birds [1, 2]. However, prior to the massive epidemics of H5N1 in Southeast Asia, only very few attempts to control HPAI outbreaks in domestic poultry populations by vaccination have been reported. Pre-H5N1 experience in the use of vaccination in large-scale HPAI control programmes was gained in Mexico (H5N1, 1994), Italy (H7N1, 2000) and Pakistan (H7N3, 2003) [3]. In the course of the current H5N1 avian pandemic, several large-scale HPAI vaccination campaigns have been implemented by national animal
CAB International 2010
74
Animal Science Reviews 2010
health authorities in China, Hong Kong, Vietnam, Indonesia and Egypt. Experience has shown that despite the theoretical potential of vaccination to control HPAI epidemics [3, 4], this potential is in practice not fully realized in largescale vaccination efforts due to the numerous constraints to delivering and administering vaccine in large and heterogeneous poultry populations [3]. Large-scale vaccination campaigns require substantial financial and human resources and therefore are unlikely to be sustainable over long time periods. It thus appears warranted to assess the technical, epidemiological as well as the financial implications of large-scale vaccination campaigns for HPAI control, both from a theoretical as well as from a practical perspective. This paper reviews existing data and literature on HPAI vaccines, HPAI epidemics and large-scale HPAI H5N1 vaccination programmes and draws on calculations carried out to assess and evaluate the potential contribution and the financial implications of mass vaccination in the control of HPAI H5N1 in domestic poultry in developing countries. The paper starts by reviewing the literature on various characteristics of commercially available HPAI vaccines that determine their utility as a tool for the control of HPAI in different poultry species. The following section presents the three HPAI vaccination strategies proposed by the Office International des Epizooties (OIE) and provides an overview of estimates of immunization rates that would be necessary to suppress H5N1 virus transmission to a level where infection dies out. Estimates of the maximum vaccination coverage that would be achievable in different poultry production systems through mass vaccination campaigns carried out under ideal conditions are presented in ‘Practical Challenges of Large-Scale HPAI Vaccination Programmes’. The following section summarizes common challenges for the implementation of large-scale vaccination programmes and experiences with the implementation of such programmes are compiled in ‘Experiences from Large-Scale HPAI H5N1 Vaccination Programmes’. ‘Costs and Incentives for HPAI Vaccination’ provides assessments of the costs and returns of vaccination from a production systems perspective as well as considering the broader public aspects of embarking on vaccination as a part of a national HPAI control programme. Finally, the last section discusses the advantages and drawbacks of large-scale vaccination programmes and their potential contribution to HPAI control.
Characteristics of Commercial HPAI Vaccines Route and Schedule of Vaccine Administration All commercially available HPAI vaccines require administration to poultry via injection with a syringe. Vaccines for administration via other routes, such as aerosols, drinking water or injection during egg incubation are not
g
currently available [5]. Generally, a two-dose vaccination schedule is required to achieve satisfactory protection against HPAI in any poultry species. Application of the booster vaccination is often inconvenient and may not be ensured in all production systems for a number of reasons. Also, in many commercial production systems it is most efficient to vaccinate birds at one day of age. Trovac, a recombinant live H5N1 vaccine (A/Turkey/Ireland/83 recombinant fowlpox vector) is the only commercially available vaccine purposely developed for a one-shot at day-old age vaccination schedule.
Vaccine Efficacy From a technical and biological perspective, for individual birds, vaccination efficacy can be measured using the following three parameters: (i) degree of protection from infection when exposed to a given amount of infectious virus, (ii) the degree of reduction of morbidity and mortality given infection occurred and (iii) the level of reduction of virus excretion by infected poultry. The efficacy of most commercially available vaccines has been determined in studies with chickens or turkeys, since, from an economic perspective, globally they represent the most important poultry species. However, in many developing countries, particularly in Southeast Asia, other species such as ducks, muscovy ducks and quails also represent significant parts of the poultry sector. Thus, vaccination strategies for poultry populations with significant shares of species other than chicken and turkeys require vaccines with proven efficacy in these species to contain viral transmission. Peyre et al. [2] have compiled a list of commercially available H5 and H7 vaccines with information on reductions in mortality and viral shedding based on experimental results from challenge trials under laboratory and controlled field conditions. Although almost all commercially available vaccines provide some level of protection from infection with virulent virus and significantly reduce morbidity and mortality in infected chicken, no HPAI vaccine has so far proved to satisfactorily perform on all three of the above parameters [3, 6]. Challenge trial results on the efficacy of Trovac are conflicting. Inui [7] conducted challenge trials with Trovac and observed 90–100% mortality 3, 4 and 6 weeks postvaccination in chickens when challenged with several clades of the Asian lineage HPAI H5N1 virus (clades 1(08), 2.3.4 (08), 1(04)). In contrast, Swayne et al. [8], in a challenge trial with H5N2 virus isolated in Mexico, observed 90–100% protection against morbidity and mortality, and significant reductions in virus shedding in chickens vaccinated at one day of age. Bublot et al. [9] challenged Trovac-vaccinated chicken with HPAI H5N1 A/chicken/Vietnam/0008/2004 and observed full protection against morbidity and mortality. This diversity of challenge trial results with different HPAI H5N1 field
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
strains for Trovac indicates a limited breadth of protection of Trovac vaccine, and most likely of other HPAI vaccines as well, against field strains that change over time. Unpublished results of challenge trials carried out by the Friedrich–Loeffler Institute in 2008 showed that vaccinated layer chicken reared under commercial conditions did not attain sterile immunity and that infection with HPAI virus may facilitate bacterial infections which can then dominate the clinical disease picture [10]. In a vaccination trial with goose parents and a low pathogenic avian influenza virus strain vaccine (A/duck/ Potsdam/1402/86 (H5N2)), Rudolf et al. [11] found that vaccinated geese became infected and transmitted challenge virus (A/Cygnuscygnus/Germany/R65/06 (H5N1)) to non-vaccinated geese. The contribution of ducks to the maintenance and spread of HPAI H5N1 virus has been shown in several studies [12–14]. Several vaccines with proven efficacy in domestic ducks and geese are commercially available. A H5N3 reversegenetics vaccine has been shown by Webster et al. [15] to control clinical signs and virus shedding in Peking ducks challenged with a duck-lethal H5N1 virus after the application of two doses of vaccine. A H5N1 inactivated vaccine was used by Beato et al. [16] to vaccinate Peking ducks at 1 and 30 days of age. The vaccinated ducks were subsequently challenged with an Asian-lineage H5N1 virus and neither clinical signs nor virus shedding were detected. After one shot of a recombinant H3N3 or H5N1 vaccine administered to 2-week-old SPF Peking ducks and a challenge with duck lethal HPAI Dk/Laos/25/06 (clade 2.3.4), no clinical signs or virus shedding were detectable [17]. A specific challenge in developing vaccines for ducks and monitoring the effectiveness of duck vaccination campaigns is the lack of correlation between the serum antibody levels of vaccinated ducks and their degree of immunity. Kim et al. [17] found complete protection in vaccinated ducks in the absence of detectable antibody responses. This may indicate that cell-mediated immune response is important in protecting ducks from HPAI and would constitute a major gap in the current capacity of assessing HPAI vaccine efficacy in this species, which constitutes a major part of the poultry population in a number of developing countries.
Onset and Duration of Immunity The time lag between vaccination and protective immunity and the respective duration of protection depends on the vaccine used, timing of vaccination, number of doses given, species, immunologic condition of the birds and the challenge virus. The literature is dominated by studies with SPF birds reared under laboratory conditions, the results of which cannot safely be extrapolated to field conditions, and in which protection is often assessed by serology, the assumption being that birds with a specified
g
75
antibody level (e.g. a haemagglutination inhibition (HI) titre P16) are protected. However, under conditions of antigenic variability and diversity of the HPAI viruses circulating in the field, a given titre found under laboratory conditions cannot unequivocally be interpreted as protective against field virus challenge, and the observed variation in the level and length of protection also makes generalizations on vaccine efficacy problematic. Despite these limitations, some examples of published literature on vaccine efficacy and the duration of protection under field and laboratory conditions are summarized in the following. Field studies with a killed oil-adjuvanted H5N2 (A/chicken/Mexico/232/94/CPA) vaccine in Hong Kong showed effective protection by 13–18 days postvaccination [18, 19]. Serologic response monitoring after vaccination of 3 flocks of white leghorn layer chicken in commercial farms in California, USA with two doses of killed LPAI H6N2 (CK/CA/0379/02) vaccine at 7.5–9 and 11–13 weeks of age showed significant differences in the onset and duration of immunity. In one flock, 72% (15/21) of the tested chicken were sero-positive, based on agar gel immunodiffusion tests, within 21 days after the first vaccination and 100% were sero-positive 4 days after the second vaccination, but by 20.5 weeks after the second vaccination, all chicken were sero-negative again. In two other flocks, situated on a different farm, serologic response monitoring only began 13 weeks after the first vaccination. Nearly 100% of the tested 32 chicken were sero-positive from 13–19 weeks post vaccination. Sixtynine weeks after the second vaccination, the proportion of seropositive chicken had declined to 22.9% [20]. Under laboratory conditions, vaccination experiments with 6-week-old white leghorn SPF chicken, using a single vaccination with H7N1 (A/Chicken/Italy/99) and H7N3 (A/Chicken/Pakistan/95) vaccines resulted in HI titres P16 11 days post vaccination. In challenge experiments with a H7N7 virus (A/Chicken/Netherlands/621557/03) 2 weeks post-vaccination, virus could not be recovered from tracheal and cloacal swabs and chicken did not infect unvaccinated chicken that were in close contact [21]. Qiao et al. [22] vaccinated 4-week-old white leghorn SPF chicken once with a vaccine derived from A/Harbin/ Re-1/2003 (Re-1) and conducted challenge trials with A/goose/Guangdong/1/96 (GSGD/96). Two weeks postvaccination and 3 days post challenge, shedding of 0.9 log10 EID50 was detected in one chicken out of a group of eight. Five days after challenge, no virus shedding was detectable in groups of chicken that had been vaccinated 2 or 43 weeks before the challenge trial. An ex-ante assessment of control strategies in the case of H5N1 outbreaks in the UK, based on a mathematical simulation model, assumes a period of 21 days for vaccination to become effective [23]. During the HPAI outbreaks in the Netherlands in 2003, van Boven et al. [24] based their advice on the use of vaccination on the assumption that it takes 2–4 weeks until vaccination offers
CAB International 2010
76
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Table 1 Vaccination strategies, objectives, time frame, critical success factors and alternative/complementary control measures Vaccination strategy
Objective
Time frame
Critical factor
Alternatives
Preventive
Protect individual/specific flocks/birds
Emergency
Curtail potential of an acute epidemic after virus introduction Reduction of mortality/ production losses in endemic situations; in longer term, may facilitate eradication of HPAI virus presence in domestic poultry Reduction of human health risk
Variable, depending on risk of exposure to infectious virus Short-term
Accuracy of the exposure risk assessment Time to achieve immunity
Medium- to long-term
Effective immunization coverage (reduction of between-flock Rn < 1)
Improve biosecurity, limit contact to secure sources Movement control and pre-emptive depopulation Passive and active surveillance with rapid stamping out
Routine
Reduction of viral shedding by infected birds
effective protection and therefore concluded that ring vaccination in a radius < 50 km would have little effect in reducing the size of an outbreak. No conclusions were provided for vaccination in a radius >50 km.
Vaccine Cost and Storage Requirements Legok and Harbin Werke vaccines purchased in large quantities for use in vaccination programmes in Indonesia and Vietnam cost about US$0.02–0.03 per dose. Swayne and Kapczinski [5] provide a wholesale price for HPAI vaccines of US$0.05–0.15 per dose. Avian influenza vaccines have to be stored within a temperature range of 2–8 C [25] and cold storage and a cold chain is required to maintain the efficacy of all commercially available vaccines [26].
Antigenic Drift and Long-term Vaccine Efficacy Avian influenza viruses vary antigenically and evolve rapidly, which poses a major challenge for the use of vaccines as an effective and sustainable HPAI control measure. H5N1 virus isolates from human cases in Vietnam show evidence of antigenic drift [27]. Although several studies demonstrated cross-protection for HPAI viruses with regard to morbidity and mortality, a correlation between virus shedding and antigenic differences of vaccine and field strains was shown by Lee et al. [28] for the Mexican lineage H5N2 virus and by Swayne and Suarez [29] with nine different H5 HPAI viruses representing 87.3–100% deduced amino acid identity in the HA1 between the vaccine and challenge virus. During and after the extensive use of about 2 billion doses of H5N2 vaccine in commercial poultry farms in Mexico, molecular
g
Behaviour change reducing human exposure
drifts with a yearly trend have been shown [28, 30]. Antigenic drift of avian influenza viruses was observed in the USA after vaccination programmes for LPAI in commercial poultry [31]. H5N1 HPAI outbreaks in Hong Kong in December 2008 were speculated to be the result of the vaccine used being ineffective as a result of antigenic shift of circulating field virus. Variant field strains that escaped the protection by the used vaccines emerged in Shanxi China during 2006, in Egypt in late 2006 and in Indonesia early 2007 [5].
HPAI Vaccination ‘Strategies’ and Effective Immunization Rates OIE [32] lists three HPAI vaccination ‘strategies’ with distinct objectives: (i) preventive vaccination, (ii) emergency vaccination and (iii) routine vaccination. A summary of the objective, time frame and critical success factors of these HPAI vaccination strategies is given in Table 1.
Preventive Vaccination Preventive vaccination is proposed as an option to prevent the infection of poultry flocks in a country or region that is free of disease but at ‘high’ risk of virus introduction and in which early detection and elimination of infection may not be feasible or realistic. Incorporation of DIVA1 is recommended as part of such a strategy. For example, in the Netherlands, vaccination of free-range
1
DIVA: differentiating infected from vaccinated animals, i.e. vaccinated birds can be distinguished from (vaccinated and subsequently) infected birds.
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
laying hens and hobby poultry with inactivated H5N9 vaccine was permitted as an alternative risk reduction measure to indoor housing in 2006. In Hong Kong, a killed oil-adjuvanted H5N2 vaccine is used in broiler chicken farms since the HPAI outbreak in 2002 to reduce the likelihood of outbreaks, if introduction of infection were to occur from mainland China [33].
Emergency Vaccination This vaccination strategy is considered an option for the control of HPAI introduced into the national flock when the epidemiological situation suggests an immediate and high risk of massive and rapid spread of infection, which cannot be contained by culling and movement restrictions. Emergency vaccination includes ‘ring’ vaccination of flocks located within a pre-defined (but not further specified) radius around detected outbreaks to create a ‘buffer zone’. This strategy was applied in northern Pakistan within a 3 km ring after H7N3 outbreaks in 2003 when layer and breeder flocks were vaccinated [33].
Routine Vaccination Routine vaccination is listed as an appropriate measure in ‘countries and regions where the disease is endemic and where the classical control cannot be effectively implemented to eliminate the virus’. It can achieve a reduction in poultry mortality and in the longer term decrease the prevalence of infection to a level where surveillance and stamping out could be applied cost-effectively. Eradication of HPAI virus is not stated in the OIE [32] document as an objective that is achievable solely through routine vaccination.2 In addition the contribution of vaccination to reducing the risk of human cases via reducing the virus load is mentioned in OIE [32] as a potential result of any vaccination strategy. All three of the above ‘strategies’ can be applied in different ‘tactics’, i.e. either in a ‘mass or a targeted manner’, targeting specific sub-populations (age, species, location and production systems) and/or times within production cycles.
Effective Immunization Rates Whichever the applied vaccination strategy, its effectiveness depends on the proportion of poultry which are rendered immune and will therefore not significantly
2 ‘Routine vaccination’ was successfully used for the eradication of other trans-boundary diseases such as Rinderpest in Africa [34] and FMD in parts of South-America [35].
g
77
contribute to virus transmission in the case of exposure. As poultry populations are segregated into flocks (or other types of management units), both within-flock and between-flock transmission need to be sufficiently contained to avoid sustained virus transmission and potential development of endemicity. A number of studies estimated the minimum withinflock immunization rate required to stop virus transmission within a poultry flock. Depending on the assumptions made, the calculated within-flock immunization rate required to avoid disease spread range from 50 to 90%: Tiensin et al. [36] analysed within-flock HPAI transmission data from the 2004 epidemic in Thailand and conclude that 80% of birds need to be immunized to avoid major within-flock disease spread. Bouma et al. [37] estimated that a within-flock immunization rate of 60–80% was necessary to avoid major outbreaks, which they defined as more than 50 infected birds. Mathematical modelling conducted by Savill et al. [38] indicated a required 90% within-flock coverage to reduce the outbreak probability by 50%. According to Lesnoff et al. [39] a flock immunity rate of 50–67% is necessary to completely interrupt within-backyard-flock virus transmission. A factor of high importance for disease control is the contact rate between flocks and the level of risk of each contact to transmit infection [40]. The objective of emergency and routine vaccination would be to interrupt the infection chain between flocks/farms, i.e. achieve a between-flock/farm-to-farm ‘reproductive number’ (Rn) that is below unity. The required proportion of flocks that would have to be immunized within an affected region can be derived from the infection dynamics in that region in the absence of control measures. For HPAI outbreaks in the Netherlands, Canada and Italy, Garske et al. [41] estimated mean farm-to-farm reproductive numbers prior to the introduction of control measures to range from 1.1 to 2.4. For Vietnam and Romania, countries with less industrialized poultry sectors, Rn was estimated to have been in the order of 2–3 prior to the introduction of control measures [42, 43]. Under the ideal condition of full protection of vaccinated flocks, immunization of between half and two-thirds of flocks would be necessary to stop sustained between-flock transmission under the situation prevailing in Vietnam (based on the fraction of 1–1/R0 [44]). Under conditions where only partial immunity of vaccinated flocks is achieved, a higher proportion of immunized flocks would be required to interrupt disease transmission to the extent needed to control an outbreak.
Maximum Vaccination Coverage Achievable with Vaccination Campaigns As pointed out by Alders et al. [45] production system characteristics need to be considered to estimate the potential vaccination coverage and whether this coverage
CAB International 2010
78
Animal Science Reviews 2010
is capable of preventing, or at least significantly reducing, virus transmission. Important characteristics are the average lifespan of poultry, origin of replacement birds (home-bred versus bought), synchronization of flock age and the disease status and immuno-competency of flocks in the respective production system. Furthermore, poultry owners’ incentives to vaccinate against HPAI strongly influence potential vaccination coverage. Although incentives are generally similar for owners of flocks of the same type of production system, they may still vary depending on their flocks point in the production cycle. It would, for example, be very unlikely that a broiler farmer would allow vaccination of a flock close to the point of sale because of fear that the vaccination will affect the birds and potentially kill a proportion.
Poultry Production Systems Within the poultry sector, four main production systems can be identified: (i) breeder flocks, (ii) layer flocks (iii), broiler flocks and (iv) backyard multi-purpose flocks. This production system classification roughly applies to both chickens and ducks [46]. Sub-systems, such as short- and long-lived broiler production and free-range grazing duck production systems prevail in some countries. The major poultry production systems are briefly described in the following to provide an overview of the main characteristics relevant for the effectiveness of HPAI vaccination campaigns. Breeder flocks (grandparent and parent) are kept in closed houses and cages and the birds are bought from specialized poultry genetic supply companies. Several batches of birds of differing ages are required to meet the continuous demand for day-old chicks (DOCs). The average lifespan of breeder chicken for the production of DOCs varies between 63 and 65 weeks. The production period of breeder duck flocks varies between 52 and 104 weeks. Breeder ducks are kept in houses with outdoor access [47]. Layer chickens are typically kept in cages in open or closed housing without outdoor access. Hens start laying eggs at 23–25 weeks of age and are kept for 63–74 weeks. Continuous egg supply requires a layer flock with chickens of several age groups. Either DOCs or pullets (at 16–25 weeks of age) are bought to replace spent hens, which are either sold for immediate slaughter or for fattening. In Asia, layer ducks are kept between 1 and 3 years and for a varying proportion of this time flocks are freeranging in rice fields to use left over rice, weeds and snails as a feed resource. Semi-confined fishponds with temporary or permanent shelters are used to house the ducks when they are not left to range in rice fields [47]. Two broiler chicken production systems need to be distinguished, namely long- and short-finish systems. Short-finish, ‘industrial’, broilers are usually kept indoors
g
on the ground, whereas long-finish, cross-bred broilers are kept under semi-confined conditions to utilize some feed resources from the natural environment. The attention to hygiene and animal health management is normally lower than in breeder and layer flocks. Chicken broilers are kept for a relatively short lifespan. ‘Industrial’ broilers are kept in batches of the same age for 5–7 weeks, while ‘cross-bred’ broilers are kept for 9–26 weeks and achieve a premium price in local markets. Similar to broiler chicken production systems, the production cycle length of broiler ducks varies depending on the breed and feeding system used. Scavenging broiler ducks are reared under similar conditions to layer ducks and are usually sold for slaughter after about 80 days. Confined and intensively fed ducks, usually of specific meat type breeds, are finished in about 60 days [47–49]. Mixed backyard poultry production systems are characterized by scavenging indigenous birds that consume leftover feed and produce their own replacement chicks with very little cash investment by the owner [50]. The systems typically have high mortality rates in the early stages of life because of predation, poor diets and diseases [51–54]. Given the high mortality rates, particularly in young birds, a relatively high population turnover is common, in which birds get replaced by newly hatched chicks. This high population turnover significantly limits the duration of flock immunity that can be maintained with vaccination campaigns. The potential coverage of HPAI or Newcastle disease vaccination in backyard poultry with uncontrolled but more or less continuous replacement dynamics has been modelled by several authors (e.g. [39, 55, 56]). For nonbackyard poultry production systems, in which birds are periodically replaced by controlled reproduction, and which in most countries constitute a significant share of the standing poultry population, no estimates of the maximum vaccination coverage achievable through mass vaccination were available in the literature. We therefore had to make our own estimates, which are based on the simplifying assumption that the birds within a specific flock and production system are of the same age (i.e. all-in/ all-out flock management) and that the age of all flocks in a region is uniformly distributed (i.e. no seasonal production). The maximum flock vaccination coverage with a vaccination campaign, in which vaccination teams visit each farm once only (or twice in the case of booster application) is then theoretically given by the time a particular flock is eligible for vaccination within its production cycle (including the idle time between batches). The estimated maximum achievable vaccination coverage applies to the area that can be vaccinated within a day. For areas that require more than one day for vaccination teams to visit all flocks, the theoretical maximum vaccination coverage is lower as a result of flock turnover. The results of the calculations are displayed in Table 2.
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
79
Table 2 Estimated flock vaccination coverage and time until flocks are fully susceptible again after an HPAI vaccination campaign
Layer chicken; vaccination during laying period Layer chicken; no vaccination during laying period Broiler chicken; industrial Broiler chicken; cross-bred Broiler ducks; intensive confined Broiler ducks; scavenging
Time Length of Idle time eligible production between for cycle batches 1st shot (days) (days) (days)
Time eligible for 2nd shot (days)
Proportion of flocks Proportion eligible for of flocks 2nd shot eligible for 14 days 1st shot (%) later (%)
Time until all flocks are 100% nai¨ve again after 1st shot (days)1
Time until all flocks are 100% nai¨ve again after 2nd shot (days)1
490
0
476
462
97
94
180
180
490
0
140
126
29
26
147
133
32
14
18
4
39
9
25
11
120
14
106
92
79
69
113
99
60
21
46
32
57
40
53
39
80
–
66
52
83
65
73
59
Source: authors’ calculations. 1 Protection assumed to be lost 180 days after vaccination because of waning immunity.
Maximum Vaccination Coverage of Breeder and Layer Flocks
breeder and layer flocks usually do not receive a booster vaccination [57].
Chicken breeder and layer flocks In theory, relatively high vaccination coverage could be achieved for chicken layer flocks with a production cycle length of 490 days, assuming owners would allow vaccination during the egg-laying period (Table 2). Since layer flocks usually comprise of birds of several age groups (are not kept under all in and all out management), the coverage of 94% for a single-shot campaign and 92% for a double-shot campaign is a reflection of the share of birds that could be vaccinated at any point in time within a flock of heterogeneous age composition. It should, however, be recognized that in most layer flocks, birds are vaccinated before point of lay and owners are reluctant to revaccinate during egg-laying periods. If vaccination during the laying period is not accepted, within-flock vaccination coverage would not exceed 26% in a double-shot vaccination campaign.
Scavenging layer duck flocks The age distribution and the number of layer duck flocks are related to the rice harvest seasons. Vaccination coverage similar to those in layer chicken could be achieved with well-timed vaccination campaigns that take into account the seasonality of rice harvest and laying period. However, the poor accessibility of scavenging duck flocks in rice paddies makes the administration of vaccine, especially the second booster shot, very difficult and experience from China shows that scavenging duck
g
Maximum Vaccination Coverage of Broiler Flocks Short-lived industrial chicken broiler flocks During the average 32-day production cycle of an industrial batch of broiler chicken, vaccine can be administered over a period of 18 days, since vaccination should only be applied at a minimum age of 7 days and requires at least 7 days to confer protection, i.e. needs to be applied more than 7 days prior to slaughter to have any effect. Given an assumed average idle time of 14 days for cleaning and disinfection between batches, a significant proportion (18/46) of broiler houses in a country or region will either be empty or not be populated by birds eligible for vaccination on any given day. Hence, the maximum achievable vaccination coverage with a single injection in a one-day visit vaccination campaign is 39% of all industrial broiler flocks within a country or region. As described in ‘Characteristics of Commercial HPAI Vaccines’, two injections are required to achieve full protection in domestic poultry. Therefore, if each broiler flock needs to be given a booster shot 14 days after the initial vaccination, only the flocks that received their first injection during the first 4 days of the 18-day window will be eligible for the booster shot 14 days later. Although some previously non-eligible farms will have become available for the first vaccination in the 14-day interval, only 9% of all broiler flocks would have received the two injections required to achieve full protection. All industrial broiler flocks would
CAB International 2010
80
Animal Science Reviews 2010
be nai¨ve again within 25 days after a single injection vaccination campaign, since vaccinated birds will have been slaughtered and replaced.
campaign, the population immunity rate is estimated to have dropped to 25%.
Intensively raised duck broiler flocks The relatively short production cycle length of about 60 days for duck broilers in intensive closed systems results in a low maximum coverage of 40% for a two-injection at 14-day interval HPAI vaccination campaign. However, experience from China shows that flock owners usually do not vaccinate these birds given their short life span [57].
Maximum Vaccination Coverage of National Poultry Populations
Long-lived cross-bred chicken broiler flocks The maximum achievable vaccination coverage for crossbred broiler flocks would be 79 and 69% for a one- or two-injection campaign, respectively. The higher coverage compared with industrial broiler flocks results from the considerably longer production cycle. All cross-bred broiler flocks would be nai¨ve again within 113 days after a single injection vaccination campaign. Scavenging duck broiler flocks Seasonal peaks of available rice in harvested paddies are utilized by raising broiler ducks around the time of rice harvests. Therefore the timing of vaccination campaigns should take into account this seasonality. The maximum achievable vaccination coverage by a vaccination campaign will depend on the age distribution of duck broiler flocks within a region. However, under the assumption that the start of broiler flock raising in a region is uniformly distributed over a time period of at least 80 days, 65% of all flocks can be vaccinated in a two-shot campaign. It should be noted that the delivery of a second shot is a challenge due to the difficult accessibility of scavenging ducks in rice paddies and will require significantly higher vaccinator time inputs for travelling and catching ducks.
Immunization Rates in Extensively Reared, Mixed Backyard Flocks Based on a spreadsheet poultry population model, Taylor [55] estimates that a maximum immunization rate of 52% of all backyard birds can be achieved with a two-shot vaccination campaign under the assumption that 80% of all chicken older than 4 weeks are caught for an initial vaccination and a booster shot 14 days later. Immunization coverage would fall to 19% within 17 weeks, because of replacement. These results assume a vaccine efficacy of 80% and that 50% of the eggs are used for human consumption and the remaining 50% are hatched. Also under a two-shot vaccination scenario, vaccinating all poultry P14 days and assuming 80% vaccine efficacy, Lesnoff et al. [39] estimate a maximum achievable population immunity rate of 55%. Seventeen weeks after the vaccination
g
The maximum vaccination coverage of national poultry populations achievable through vaccination campaigns is determined by the specific mix of flock types in the national poultry industry and the time required to carry out a campaign. Given that in most countries, broilers are the most common type of poultry followed by backyard birds, while layer and breeder flocks are comparatively rare, immunization rates needed to break infections chains will be difficult to achieve unless vaccination campaigns are complemented by restocking bans.
Practical Challenges of Large-Scale HPAI Vaccination Programmes There are three main steps in the process of implementing vaccination programmes: (a) planning, which includes estimation of vaccine needs, identification of vaccine source, storage, delivery, as well as procedures and schedules of administration, and respective budget allocation, (b) information campaigns and monitoring of vaccine quality, delivery and administration, and (c) programme evaluation that covers technical and cost elements and would lead to a revision of the programme if necessary. For this purpose, long(er)-term performance indicators are required. Depending on whether the public veterinary staff are responsible for the implementation of vaccination campaigns or whether their role is restricted to monitoring and ensuring the efficacy of the campaign, public agents are involved in all or a part of the following tasks: selection of vaccines, monitoring the production or importation of vaccine, organizing the timely distribution of vaccines, and monitoring of field virus strains and the efficacy of the vaccine(s) employed. It needs to be emphasized that due to scarce veterinary staff and animal health funds, the inevitable effect of large-scale vaccination campaigns is a detraction of public animal health services from other disease control activities, both with respect to HPAI and other diseases (e.g. FMD outbreaks increased in Vietnam during and after HPAI vaccination campaigns). It has been emphasized by several authors that the achievable protection through vaccine use in the field is unlikely to reach the potential shown under experimental studies with SPF chicken [3, 29]. Since commercially available HPAI vaccines are not thermostable, maintaining the cold chain from production to administration is crucial for obtaining high levels of immunization in vaccinated birds in the field. This represents a significant challenge in many developing countries with high daytime temperatures
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
and shortages of cold storage capacity. A list of factors which compromise the effectiveness of avian influenza vaccination campaigns are provided by Wooldridge [58] and Alders et al. [45]: Inappropriately matched field and vaccine strains. Vaccines that are inappropriate for the species or age group vaccinated. Spoiled (ineffective) vaccine. Inadequate hygiene during vaccine administration to birds (clean needle and disinfectants). Vaccine administration to inappropriate tissues of the birds. Infection of birds with immunosuppressive disease agents. Assessments of rinderpest [34] and classical swine fever [59] vaccination campaigns have identified similar risk factors to those mentioned above for avian influenza vaccination campaigns. The results of an evaluation of the cold chain for Newcastle disease vaccination in Mozambique have been documented by Chicamisse et al. [60]. All transport and storage systems exceeded the recommended temperatures. Some reasons for nonoptimal storage temperature were: storing too much vaccine in the refrigerator, too high temperatures in vaccine storage rooms, and old refrigerators. In addition to the above listed practical and technical issues, the perception of poultry owners and vaccinators with respect to the benefits of vaccination is a crucial factor for vaccination to be effective. If owners and vaccinators are not convinced of the need for vaccination they are unlikely to be cooperative, which increases the risk of not achieving immunization targets. Information and communication campaigns are therefore necessary to ensure the preparedness and optimal cooperation of all stakeholders. The target audience comprises of a wide range of stakeholders with different information requirements, e.g. senior government decision-makers, veterinary staff, local authorities, poultry owners and poultry traders [45]. Properly trained and motivated (paid) vaccinators and cooperative poultry keepers are the key to achieve high vaccination coverage and immunization levels. Wooldridge [58] describes a formal risk assessment for vaccination campaigns which serves for identifying different risk pathways and risk reduction measures. Identification of the necessary data to quantify the risk linked to each pathway facilitates the planning and monitoring of vaccination campaigns. An effective tracing and monitoring scheme for the vaccines used, storage locations and temperature, vaccinator, poultry flocks and post-vaccination protection rate is necessary to accurately determine the cause of poor performance and implement the appropriate corrective measures. While such a standardized approach to vaccination campaign monitoring is seductive in its apparent accuracy it appears
g
81
to lack the necessary appreciation of the importance of the people involved in a vaccination campaign and their incentives to collaborate. The assumption is that their interest and willingness is a given, something that is rarely if ever the case. Given the changing nature of HPAI virus strains circulating in the field, the need for post-vaccination monitoring of vaccine efficacy is stressed in the HPAI literature. Virus isolation and sequencing should be an essential part of any vaccination strategy to detect potential genetic shifts and to monitor vaccine efficacy. The possibility that the efficacy of the vaccine(s) used in the programme decreases over time needs to be considered in the planning process because the frequency with which a new representative master-seed for the production of adapted vaccines needs to be found directly influences the profitability of commercial vaccine production. Producers need a certain level of security about the potential scale and duration of market demand for their vaccine to embark in vaccine development and production. The recommended number of blood samples to test for sero-conversion and swab samples to test for virus presence and potentially isolate field virus represents a major challenge for the capacity of most laboratories in developing countries.
Experiences from Large-Scale HPAI H5N1 Vaccination Programmes China Since the introduction of vaccination in China in 2004, the national vaccination policy has evolved. Until the end of 2005, all waterfowl and terrestrial poultry near waterways and wetlands were vaccinated [33]. Eight billion birds (60% of China’s domestic poultry population) were vaccinated between the onset of vaccination in 2004 and November 2005 [61]. In 2006, compulsory vaccination of all poultry was mandated and 8.2 billion head of poultry were vaccinated from January to September 2006 [62]. A vaccination coverage of 20–50% was achieved in mainly backyard poultry [2]. Since then, a twice-yearly vaccination campaign is estimated to result in the annual administration of 11 billion doses of vaccine [63]. Relatively low vaccination rates have been observed in waterfowl. The required booster vaccination for layer and breeder ducks is not actually administered in most flocks and broiler ducks are usually not vaccinated because of their short life span [57]. Testing of 1113 chicken sera from Guangdong and Guiyang Provinces collected at markets in 2005 and 2006 revealed that only 180 (16%) were positive against Ck/HK/YU22/02 (H5N1) and that 55 of the positive sera had low or no neutralizing antibodies against the predominant FJ-like sub-lineage [64].
CAB International 2010
82
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Hong Kong A killed oil-adjuvanted H5N2 (A/chicken/Mexico/232/94/ CPA) vaccine was used in Hong Kong after HPAI outbreaks in February–April 2002. HPAI vaccination was introduced after a 12-month vaccination field trial in commercial broiler chicken (yellow meat) flocks to evaluate its effectiveness. All broiler chicken between 8 and 55 days of age were vaccinated followed by a booster 4 weeks later. In 75.8% (188/248 for a total of 1.35 million broilers) of the batches vaccinated, results were considered successful (P70% of chickens per batch had a HI titre of P16 and a geometric mean batch titre P20, see results in Table 4). Some HPAI outbreaks occurred on farms shortly after vaccination. In one farm, where chicken developed clinical HPAI 9 days after vaccination, vaccination had not yet induced a protective immune response. In a few other farms that became infected it was shown that vaccination provided protection from disease and reduced virus excretion by 13–18 days postvaccination [18]. Compulsory vaccination was introduced for local chicken farms in June 2003 and by the end of 2003 all chicken from Hong Kong entering the live poultry were vaccinated using the killed H5N2 vaccine. The farm biosecurity enhancements introduced between 1998 and 2002 were not sufficiently effective to prevent the spill over of circulating virus from markets to farms. The contact rates between broiler chicken farms and live poultry markets were relatively high as a result of rearing of several batches of different ages on the same farm. HPAI vaccination was introduced as an obligatory condition for poultry farms to have market access, which required substantial enforcement and laboratory capacity (Sims, personal communication). In addition to vaccination, bio-security measures were further enhanced on farms and live poultry markets [33]. No outbreaks were detected until 2008. Surveillance results showed that virus circulation in live poultry markets had ceased for the 5-year period after the introduction of vaccination [65]. The re-emergence of an HPAI outbreak on a vaccinated chicken farm in Hong Kong in December 2008 led to speculation3 about vaccine efficacy.
Egypt Voluntary vaccination with registered vaccines was permitted by the government in 2006. Over 750 million birds were vaccinated with H5N2 and 150 million with H5N1 in commercial farms [66]. For backyard or household village
3 The China Post cited Guan Yi from University of Hong Kong on 12 December 2008, based on a press release on 9 December 2008 by Dr York Chow, Secretary for Food and Health Bureau, Hong Kong.
g
poultry, vaccine was provided by the government since mid-2007 [67]. Seventy million birds were vaccinated with H5N1 in backyards and 11 million DOCs were vaccinated with H5N2.
Indonesia By March 2008, 20 vaccines were registered for use in poultry in Indonesia. Vaccine seed strains include a highly pathogenic local strain, A/chicken/Legok/2003 (H5N1), A/ckichen/Mexico/94 (H5N2), A/turkey/ Wisconsin/69 (H5N9) and A/turkey/England/73 (H5N2). The widely used Legoc/03 strain is not fully protective against all circulating viruses. The OFFLU network is therefore collecting HPAI virus isolates and screening these to identify a new vaccine seed strain, which affords better protection against circulating HPAI viruses [68]. A compulsory vaccination policy for all poultry was adopted by the Government of Indonesia in June 2004. Poultry classified as sector 4 (backyard) and sector 3 (small-scale commercial) up to maximum flock size of 5000 birds were to be vaccinated free of charge by government services. Problems were reported with respect to vaccine availability and confidence of flock owners in the benefits of vaccination [69]. Vaccination coverage assessed by the Ministry of Agriculture rarely exceeded 30% of the poultry population. Post-vaccination monitoring of HI-titres ranged from 11% with protective titres (HI-titre P16) in native chicken populations in Bali to 78% protected in industrial breed chicken populations in Medan [69]. The commercial poultry sector implemented vaccination programmes using a variety of protocols mainly in chicken layer flocks (including grandparent and parent flocks) until point of lay. Short-lived broilers were not vaccinated except in areas considered to be at high risk and was based on a half dose shot at 7 days of age [69]. No information was available on vaccination in long-lived broilers and male layers (90–120 day finish), which make up a substantial proportion of the poultry raised for meat. A vaccination pilot study in semi-intensive and native chicken layer farms coupled with the use of sentinel chicken was conducted in Sukabumi to assess the efficacy of locally produced homologous vaccines. Farmers were reluctant to have sentinel birds in their systems. After receiving two doses of vaccine, 75% of the semi-intensive layer chicken hens developed HI-tires P32, while only 15–40% of the native layer chicken hens in 4 vaccinated flocks showed a titre P16. Blood samples from sentinel birds remained sero-negative for HI [69]. Vaccination of backyard poultry was conducted under a World Bank and USAID funded operational research project. A total of 2.9 million birds in 425 villages located in 32 sub-districts in the provinces West Java, Yogyakarta and Central Java received two doses of vaccine. It took 3 weeks each to administer the first and second shots of
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
83
Table 3 Estimated vaccination coverage in Vietnam, 2005 and 2006 HPAI vaccination campaigns
Year
Campaign
Shot
Chicken population vaccinated (%)
2005 2005 2006 2006 2006 2006
1st 1st 1st 1st 2nd 2nd
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd
66 58 51 35 47 22
Duck population vaccinated (%) 79 73 58 22 72 26
Source: Taylor [78], based on poultry population census data.
Legok 2003 H5N1 vaccine and required 64 community vaccinator coordinators and 1088 community vaccinators. The campaign was estimated to have covered only 32% of the 9.0 million poultry reported by official livestock statistics to be in the sub-districts where vaccination was implemented [70]. About 18 000 blood samples from vaccinated backyard chicken and ducks were taken for sero-monitoring, of which 33.1% showed a protective HI titre P16 [71], Table 4). The participatory disease surveillance and response (PDSR) project also vaccinated poultry. The PDSR teams visited 9326 villages, detected HPAI infection in 494 of them and vaccinated poultry flocks in 56 (11.3%) of the infected villages [67].
Pakistan Strategic vaccination and increased biosecurity was used in 1995 to control outbreaks of H7N3 HPAI. The outbreak was controlled within 4 months. However, H7N3 HPAI virus re-emerged in November 2003. The HPAI virus originated from an LPAI outbreak in April 2003. Breeder and layer flocks were vaccinated prophylactically and no H7N3 virus has been isolated since January 2005 [72]. The vaccination strategy in the area affected by HPAI H5N1 in 2007 has been to vaccinate all flocks within 3 km of the outbreak with a water-based vaccine. Ten days after the first vaccination a second vaccination with an oil-based vaccine was given. Breeder and layer flocks were given up to 4 shots per bird. Infected flocks were destroyed by immediate burial. Mild clinical signs with some mortality have been observed in vaccinated flocks [33].
Vietnam A large-scale vaccination programme of domestic poultry against HPAI based on twice-yearly vaccination campaigns has been conducted since mid-2005 by public veterinary services. This vaccination programme was combined with
g
supplementary age-based vaccination of larger commercial poultry flocks between the main campaigns [73]. The vaccination policy, in terms of the eligible poultry population and cost-recovery schemes, has evolved over time. Currently, all domestic chicken and ducks older than 7 and 15 days, respectively, are eligible for vaccination. However, broiler chickens and ducks kept for less than 70 days until slaughter and for broiler chicken to be slaughtered within 15 days are exempted. Vaccine delivery has required immense labour inputs from public veterinary services and contracted commune animal health workers. According to a survey conducted by Cristalli in 2006, about 25 000 commune animal health workers were involved in administering vaccine during the 2005 and 2006 campaigns [33, 73, 74]. Farm labour inputs to these campaigns have not been estimated. Initially, flocks with less than 2000 birds were vaccinated free of charge. This flock size cut-off point for free vaccination has been reduced to 500 birds for the 2009 campaigns. Each campaign, comprising of two injections within a 4-week interval, required about 60 days to be completed. In 2005, 158 million chicken and 72 million ducks were vaccinated, while for 2006, the respective numbers were 177 million and 28 million [75]. In 2007, 164 million poultry were vaccinated during the first campaign, comprising of 87 million chicken and 74 million ducks plus 42 million doses of vaccine administered by private livestock firms [73, 75, 76]. Vaccination costs have been estimated at US$20 million annually [77]. In 2008, the use of 500 million doses of HPAI vaccine was planned. Vaccination coverage estimations based on the number of vaccinated domestic poultry in relation to available domestic poultry census have been conducted by Taylor [78] (Table 3) and To et al. [79]. The data show a decreasing trend in vaccination coverage, which could be related to increasing vaccination fatigue of vaccinators and reduced vaccination acceptance of poultry owners. Post-vaccination monitoring results with regard to the prevalence of protective antibody levels in vaccinated poultry are provided in Table 4. The proportion of tested poultry with protective antibody levels varied between 33 and 72%. No outbreaks of avian influenza were reported in Vietnam between December 2005 and December 2006.
CAB International 2010
84
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Table 4 Prevalence of protective HPAI antibody levels in poultry after vaccination campaigns Country
Species
‘Protected’
Comment(s)
Source
China China
n.s. Chicken
69% (n=n.s.) 16% (n=1113)
In 2004 Sera collected from November 2005 to April 2006 in Guangdong and Guiyang Provinces; HI titre P20
EFSA [33] Smith et al. [64]
Egypt Hong Kong
n.s. Broiler chicken
Indonesia
Chicken and ducks
25.6% (n=160) 75.8% batches (n=248 batches) 33.1% (n18 000)
Vietnam
n.s.
53.8% (n=364)
Vietnam
n.s.
44.9% (n=203)
Vietnam
n.s.
56.2% (n=269)
Vietnam
n.s.
33.3% (n=43)
Vietnam
n.s.
72.1% (n=1263)
Vietnam
Ducks
55% (n=182)
Vietnam
Chicken Ducks
40% (n=30) 63% (n=302)
Chicken
37% (n=57)
1 month after second vaccination, HI titre P16 1–2 months after campaign ended, H5N1 HI titre P16 1–2 weeks after end of 1st round of 2005 campaign 3–4 weeks after end of 1st round of 2005 campaign 1–2 weeks after end of 1st round of 2006 campaign 3–4 weeks after end of 1st round of 2006 campaign 1 month after end of 1st round of 2007 campaign 4–6 weeks after end of the 1st round of the 2007 campaign >12 weeks after end of the 1st round of the 2007 campaign
CIRAD [80] Ellis et al. [18] McLaws [71] Nguyen Van Long [81] Nguyen Van Long [81] Nguyen Van Long [81] Nguyen Van Long [81] Nguyen Van Long [81] Henning et al. [82] Henning et al. [82]
n.s.: not specified.
Table 5 Mass vaccination campaign costs per vaccination (USD/100 birds) Layer
Broiler
Backyard
Cost component
Indonesia
Vietnam
Indonesia
Vietnam
Indonesia
Vietnam
Vaccine Vaccinator (labour, equipment) Storage and distribution Post-vaccination monitoring Planning and communication Total
3.18 0.84 0.04 0.02 0.03 4.12
4.06 0.36 0.01 0.02 0.31 4.75
3.18 0.84 0.04 0.02 0.03 4.12
2.03 0.36 0.01 0.02 0.31 2.72
3.18 4.88 3.27 0.02 0.03 11.38
2.03 1.36 0.01 0.02 0.31 3.72
(77%) (21%) (1%) (0%) (1%) (100%)
(85%) (8%) (0%) (0%) (6%) (100%)
(77%) (21%) (1%) (0%) (1%) (100%)
(75%) (13%) (0%) (1%) (11%) (100%)
(28%) (43%) (29%) (0%) (0%) (100%)
(55%) (36%) (0%) (0%) (8%) (100%)
Source: authors’ calculations.
However, assessment of the contribution of vaccination to the absence of reported outbreaks is challenging, since vaccination has not been implemented as an isolated control measure. Other factors, such as improved hygiene practices together with a significant reduction in the susceptible poultry population subsequent to culling and market reactions in 2004, probably also have contributed to the reduction of outbreaks. However, in 2005, at the time the decision to embark on mass vaccination campaigns was taken, a reduction of the human infection risk rather than disease eradication was the main goal in an emergency situation with several human cases [83]. Table 4 provides a compilation of post-vaccination sero-monitoring results obtained in different countries which have embarked on large-scale HPAI vaccination programmes. In individual birds, the prevalence of antibody levels regarded as protective ranges from 16 to 72.1%.
g
Costs and Incentives for HPAI Vaccination Costs of Large-scale Vaccination Campaigns in Indonesia and Vietnam Essential cost components of any mass vaccination programme comprise of (i) planning, monitoring and communication, (ii) vaccinator labour and equipment, (iii) storage and distribution of vaccine and equipment, (iv) post-vaccination sero-monitoring and (v) vaccine. The recurrent and investment costs differ between countries because of different economic and (veterinary) infrastructure conditions and because of differences in the structure of the poultry industry. Unfortunately, comprehensive cost estimates for vaccination campaigns are only available for Indonesia and Vietnam. The vaccination costs presented in Table 5 are derived from ex-ante assessments for a government-run mass
CAB International 2010
0.09
0.28
40
120
Source: Poultry production survey data from May 2008 in Vietnam [85]; international egg production costs comparison data from Thailand, Vietnam and Indonesia for June 2006 [86]; backyard production parameters and costs from Otte [50]; Aviagen1 and Hy-Line1 poultry management guides; own calculations for selected examples of existing production systems. Prod. cycle= production cycle. 1 ‘Standard flock’ of 16 birds including 5 chicks, 6 growers, 4 hens, 1 cock.
0.02 0.71 0.46 0.68 0.39 0.15 0.03 0.22 0.08 2.17 70.13 0.63 0.08 70.12 0.02 0.12 0.06 70.03 0.15 70.03 0.35 0.92 0.09 0.09
0.80 3.14 0.80 0.74 0.37 4.86 4.86 0.41 0.26 19.55 0.37 2.26 0.37 0.37 0.31 3.84 3.84 0.25 0.09 14.38
5 5 5 5 10 12 12 20 46
16.0 45.0 61.0 4.6 8.6 39.0 39.0 21.0 3.0
25.0 54.0 79.0 6.7 25.7 41.0 41.0 23.0 5.0
10.0 43.0 53.0 5.0 4.4
0.25 0.23 0.23 0.44 0.44
0.46 0.46 0.46 0.62 0.62
2.26 3.86 3.86 3.09 3.55 4.29 4.29 3.84 0.25 38.20
3.14 4.89 4.89 5.71 5.68 5.44 5.44 4.86 0.37 48.70
320 320
0.15 0.11
0.94 0.48 70.25 160 30.00 10.00
5
63.0
65.0
52.0
0.23
0.46
3.86
4.89
0.22
44.97 13.26 6.00 18.00 160 4.89 3.86 0.46 0.23 52.0 65.0 63.0 74.00 38.00
DOC to grandparent (meat purpose) layer spent hen DOC to parent (meat purpose) layer spent hen DOC to pullet Pullet to spent hen DOC to spent hen DOC to broiler (industrial) DOC to broiler (cross-bred) Backyard grower to spent hen Backyard grower to cock Backyard chick to grower Backyard egg to chick Backyard flock1
Max. Min. Production system
5
Max. Min. Eggs (no.) Min. Max. Max. Min.
Feed costs Feed (USD/kg) (kg/prod. cycle) Min. Max. Prod. cycle Mortality length (weeks) (%/prod. cycle) Min. Max. Bird input (USD)
Table 6 Chicken values and gross margins in different production systems in Southeast Asia
Bird output (USD)
Egg price (USD)
Gross margin (USD/bird & week)
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
g
85
vaccination campaign in Vietnam and a planned mass vaccination campaign in Western Java, Indonesia. The total costs per vaccination vary between US$0.03 in broiler flocks and US$0.12 in backyard flocks in Indonesia. HPAI vaccination costs per bird differ between production systems because of varying accessibility and flocksize-related differences in achievable vaccinations per vaccinator and day4. Predominantly scavenging extensive backyard flocks in remote areas demand significantly higher labour input for vaccination than confined chicken broiler production systems. The relatively high storage and distribution costs for the vaccination of backyard poultry in Indonesia result from necessary investments in motorbikes to supply vaccinators with vaccine.
Private Incentives for HPAI Vaccination If poultry owners see an economic advantage in vaccinating their flock against HPAI compared with (or in addition to) applying other control measures, they are more likely to comply with a compulsory national vaccination strategy and a higher level of vaccination coverage can be achieved [84]. Whether poultry owners regard vaccination as a financially worthwhile risk reduction measure not only depends on the infection risk and cost of vaccination but also on the overall profitability of their respective poultry enterprise. Indicative values for production inputs, prices of inputs and outputs, performance indicators and production margins for the various production systems in Southeast Asia are provided in Table 6. As market prices for feed and poultry products have been highly volatile and differ between countries in the region, the presented values and prices reflect the price range since 2006. The gross margins for the production systems are calculated per production cycle and only account for feed costs and the costs of replacement birds. From a flock owner’s perspective vaccination represents a protective measure against the economic impact of a HPAI outbreak. The decision on whether to contract the ‘vaccination insurance policy’ depends on the vaccination costs (‘insurance premium’), which also include production impacts of vaccination such as decreased egg laying, the expected economic loss in the case of an outbreak, and the perceived probability of an outbreak. The ratio of vaccination costs to outbreak losses (‘breakeven outbreak risk per year’ in Table 7), adjusted for an average 80% vaccine efficacy, indicates the probability of flock infection at which expenditure on vaccination would be profitable for a risk-neutral flock owner. The expected absolute loss in the case of an outbreak
4
One hundred and fifteen (300) birds per day and vaccinator assumed in backyard systems and 500 (500) birds per day and vaccinator assumed in broiler and layer systems in Indonesia (Vietnam).
CAB International 2010
86
Animal Science Reviews 2010
Table 7 Financial breakeven outbreak risks for HPAI vaccination
Production system DOC to grand parent (meat purpose) layer spent hen DOC to parent (meat purpose) layer spent hen DOC to pullet Pullet to spent hen DOC to spent hen DOC to broiler (cross-bred) DOC to broiler (industrial) Backyard grower to spent hen Backyard grower to cock Backyard chick to grower Backyard egg to chick Backyard flock
Vaccinations required per production cycle
Vaccination costs per production cycle (US$ cents)
Vaccination costs per year (US$ cents)
HPAI outbreak loss (US$)1
Breakeven outbreak risk per year (%)2
Breakeven outbreak frequency in years2
min.
max.
min.
max.
min.
min.
min.
max.
4
16
19
13
15
55
182
289
1141
4
16
19
13
15
1
6
3
20
5
39
3 1 4 2
12 4 16 5
14 5 19 8
24 4 11 10
41 5 16 40
1 3 2 2
2 5 4 4
18 1 3 3
84 3 9 28
1 39 11 4
6 104 32 35
2
5
8
33
65
1
6
7
75
1
14
1
4
11
5
15
2
3
2
8
13
56
1
4
11
5
15
2
3
2
9
11
48
1
4
11
8
28
3
3
3
14
7
31
2
7 72
23 219
77 453
394 2191
0.02 23
1 33
190 17
29 987 120
0 1
1 6
max.
0.1
max. 0.3
Source: authors’ calculations. 1 A potential outbreak is assumed to occur in the middle of the production cycle which would lead to the loss of 50% of the bird value at the production cycle end and 4 weeks of lost gross margin due to subsequent downtime for cleaning and disinfection. 2 Based on 80% vaccine efficacy.
varies during the production cycle. The applied absolute losses for the calculations of the break even risks in Table 7 are based on the assumption of a 50% loss of the maximum bird value and a 4-week gross margin loss associated with production downtime subsequent to an outbreak. In case outbreaks occur when birds are of lower value than assumed in Table 7 or a salvage value can be derived from selling sick birds, the calculated breakeven risks are underestimated. The breakeven risks presented in Table 7 are underestimates due to several other reasons. In all production systems, the ‘background’ mortality requires vaccinating more birds than will eventually be produced. Vaccination can depress production, leading to the foregoing of revenue. In Vietnam, layer chicken reportedly showed a decrease in egg production of 5% over 3 weeks following vaccination [73]. This cost component has not been accounted for in the estimation of vaccination costs for layer flocks. The vaccination campaign costs in Table 5 were used to calculate vaccination costs per production cycle in Table 7, while an age-based vaccination scheme to achieve the maximum immunization coverage of the birds during the production cycle is assumed. For shortproduction-cycle broiler flocks, in particular, this is not achievable through mass vaccination campaigns. A more continuous vaccination delivery system would be required, for which the costs are likely to be higher than
g
the cost estimates from vaccination campaigns used to calculate the figures in Table 7. Grandparent and layer-chicken production systems have a relatively low estimated breakeven outbreak risk. Compared with vaccination in other production systems, vaccination in these production systems would be most cost-effective and flock owners have a relatively high private incentive to adopt vaccination and HPAI vaccination is commonly used by parent stock keepers in Indonesia [69]. However, even for relatively valuable laying hens with an estimated potential HPAI outbreak loss of US$3–5 per bird, the breakeven risk of 1–3% would not economically justify the use of vaccination for a risk-neutral poultry keeper under infection risk conditions similar to the peak HPAI H5N1 incidence in 2004 in Thailand and Vietnam, which was around 0.2% [87]. Nevertheless, HPAI vaccination is reportedly widely used by layer flock owners in Vietnam and Indonesia (Sims, personal communication), which indicates that these poultry producers are risk-averse and regard vaccination as an important component of their strategy to reduce the likelihood of the high economic losses an HPAI outbreak would cause. Although the value of broiler flocks increases over their relatively short life span, broiler producers have a relatively small financial incentive to vaccinate against HPAI with a vaccine that becomes fully effective only
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
about 13 to 21 days after the first of two injections, since they only keep chicken for a short time thereafter. The financial incentive to vaccinate duck broilers, despite their longer production cycle is also low as they normally only show mild clinical signs of disease when infected with HPAI [14]. Vaccination of an average backyard chicken flock would only be ‘profitable’ for a risk-neutral flock owner, if the annual risk of HPAI infection were higher than 17% and resulted in a loss of US$1–3 per bird. Since such a high infection risk is very unlikely, the average benefit of freeof-charge vaccination for backyard chicken flock owners would be marginal. Notwithstanding the relatively high gross margins of backyard poultry production, poultry keepers have shown little motivation to vaccinate against HPAI or other more prevalent diseases such as Newcastle disease. A survey on the willingness to pay for HPAI vaccination in Vietnam showed that only 32% out of the surveyed 62 poultry owners used Newcastle vaccine at an average price of US$0.026 per chicken [85]. If other vaccines to prevent more financially relevant diseases were delivered in addition to HPAI vaccination and if HPAI-vaccinated flocks would be exempted from culling, subsidized HPAI vaccination might be a pro-poor disease control intervention. The breakeven outbreak frequency is given by the reciprocal of the breakeven outbreak risk per year (per production cycle) and indicates the time period in years (in production cycles) within which the use of vaccination is expected to result in the same costs as the disease itself. The breakeven outbreak frequency for an industrial broiler flock owner would be one outbreak every 10 to 82 production cycles, depending on the assumed vaccination costs and losses. However, outbreak risk and absolute loss of an outbreak are not equally distributed over the time period of a production cycle. The economic value at risk is correlated with the feed investments in growing broilers. Broilers within a batch usually do not grow homogenously and are therefore not finished at exactly same time, which leads to the sale of smaller batches over several days. The interaction with traders is likely to increase the infection risk of the remaining birds towards the end of a production cycle. Protection through vaccination for this specific time point, however, needs to be started early in the production cycle. If market access of poultry producers is made conditional on the proven use of vaccination, as is the case in Hong Kong and Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, vaccination is likely to be used by producers supplying these markets. However, this only holds if the capacity to control market access and the diagnostic capacity to test for antibodies is sufficiently high. The higher the difference between the calculated breakeven outbreak risk and the actual outbreak risk, the higher is the incentive for flock owners to ‘bypass’ market access restrictions. Flock owners may consider other available protection measures such as improvements of production hygiene
g
87
and investments in cleaning and disinfection equipment. The calculated vaccination costs to achieve the maximum achievable protection through vaccination could be considered as a benchmark for the maximum expenditure on other protection measures. For a flock of 1000 industrial broilers the annual vaccination costs vary between US$325 and US$651. Annual vaccination costs would rise to US$106–157 for an integrated layer production system with a flock size of 1000 birds. Detailed assessments of the specific risk factors for the entry of HPAI virus into these production systems would be essential to estimate the potential feasibility, costs and effectiveness of achieving a higher disease protection level for the respective flocks. Nevertheless, simple improvements, such as cleaning and disinfection of equipment, cages, and work clothes are likely to cost less than the above estimated costs for vaccination. It is recognized that the ease of applying such measures will differ between systems and the quality of housing. For example, layer units with multiage flocks may not be in a position to regularly disinfect units and may have difficulty in cleaning egg trays, whereas an all-in/all-out broiler system with concrete flooring may be in a better position to apply cleaning and disinfection measures. Such measures require significant investments in training and then need to be followed with management so that they are continuously applied. Production hygiene improvements would also likely have additional benefits from reduced mortality and morbidity and subsequently increased productivity.
Public ‘Returns’ to Vaccination Positive externalities from vaccinating poultry flocks result from the reduced probability of secondary outbreaks and the public health benefits from reduced exposure to HPAI virus, neither of which is taken into account in the estimated financial incentives for vaccination presented in Table 7. The main benefit of vaccination for the community of poultry producers stems from the expectation that vaccinated flocks will act as ‘dead ends’ of infection chains and thereby also indirectly ‘protect’ non-vaccinated flocks. This indirect benefit is deemed to outweigh the ‘direct’ benefits of vaccination, but, given the uncertainty surrounding prevented infections/outbreaks, the inclusion of prevented outbreaks in public cost-benefit analyses is problematic. For Vietnam, Soares Magalhaes et al. [88] estimated that vaccination of all commercial smallholder farms would more than halve ‘secondary’ outbreaks by reducing Rn from 2.24 in the case of culling of infected premises and pre-emptive cull in a 3-km zone to 1.05 in the case of the same measures complemented by vaccination. Additional immunization of 25% of backyard flocks was estimated to further reduce secondary outbreaks from 1.05 to 0.23 per infected premises. These major reductions in secondary outbreaks would result in much
CAB International 2010
88
Animal Science Reviews 2010
higher public cost-benefit ratios than those that can be derived from Table 7 for individual producers, the order of magnitude depending on the generations of cases avoided. Assuming three successive generations of cases resulting from one HPAI H5N1 outbreak, vaccination of commercial smallholder farms (in addition to standard culling of infected and surrounding premises) would theoretically lead to a 90% reduction of the outbreak size, i.e. a ten-fold increase in cost-effectiveness. Disincentives are needed to counter the ‘free-rider’ problem that results from the above positive externalities that reduce overall disease risk, from which farmers who do not vaccinate benefit without incurring respective costs. To reduce the public health risk, it would be essential to limit the contact of humans with infected poultry. Broilers represent the largest share of poultry that is marketed through live poultry markets and in contact with a magnitude of consumers in many developing countries. Effective immunization of broilers would reduce the exposure of live-bird market customers to HPAI virus. However, high immunization coverage of marketed broilers is not likely to be achieved because of low economic incentive for flock owners to vaccinate their birds. Subsidized vaccination in these flocks may be justified for public health reasons, but even if the vaccine delivery was entirely free, owners’ willingness to participate may be affected by their perception of risk and the impact of a vaccination campaign on production in terms of potential losses of birds and their condition. In addition, these costs need to be assessed against market hygiene interventions. The required vaccination costs to supply a medium size live bird market with a daily trade volume of 1000 broilers would amount to US$1151–1707 per month. Similarly to the situation on broiler farms, a detailed assessment of the costs, effectiveness and feasibility of other market hygiene improvements and behaviour changes need to be considered in order to choose the most cost-effective risk reduction strategy.
Discussion and Conclusions The available literature on field vaccination experiments with commercially available vaccine indicates that antibody titres considered as protective can develop within 13 days after the first vaccination. However, with the exception of Trovac, two injections at two-week intervals are required to achieve full protection and one of the few long-term serologic response studies indicates that immunity is lost in most chicken 20.5 weeks after vaccination. In general, vaccinated birds have been shown to shed less amounts of virus than unvaccinated controls at specific times post challenge. Thus, most commercial vaccines have the potential to reduce the level of circulating virus in infected chicken populations. However, a crucial factor for achieving significant reductions in circulating virus in poultry flocks are sufficiently high vacci-
g
nation coverage levels (50–90% immunization of at least 50% of all flocks at risk of infection) with a vaccine that protects against the circulating virus(es). Both theoretical considerations as well as field observations show that such high immunization rates are difficult to attain in large poultry populations through vaccination campaigns and that they are even more difficult to maintain over a longer time period given the high population turnover in short-lived commercial broiler5 and mixed-age backyard poultry flocks. There are also problems of maintaining immunity levels in long-lived commercial layer and parent flocks as the currently available vaccines do not lead to lifetime immunity. The short- to medium-term gains in reducing the virus load with vaccination are not likely to result in a cost-effective long-term control approach, if no additional measures are in place, because infection chains are unlikely to be totally interrupted and virus will not be eliminated from the entire poultry population. A major drawback of vaccination is that the probability of detecting outbreaks may decrease because of a lack or reduction of clinical signs, which could lead to the silent spread of virus [38]. Incentives for disease reporting are relatively low and masking disease signs through vaccination further depresses an already low level of reporting. For northern Vietnam, Walker et al. [42] estimated a 45% effective vaccination coverage achieved by mass vaccination campaigns, not only leading to a greatly reduced transmission of virus between communes but also to an increase in the commune-level infectious period because of outbreaks remaining unreported for a longer duration. The same authors estimated that, had detection levels been maintained at pre-vaccination levels, around twothirds of outbreaks which occurred in the 2007 wave in northern Vietnam would have been prevented. This highlights the fact that, regardless of the underlying reasons for less rapid reporting of outbreaks, in order to translate the reductions in disease transmission following vaccination into greater gains in disease control, more effective reporting and surveillance strategies are required. Another drawback of the extensive use of vaccination is the increased likelihood of genetic drift as seen in Mexico [28, 30] and the USA [31]. Therefore close virus monitoring of circulating field strains, continuous vaccine testing via challenge trials, and subsequent development of new vaccines that protect from infection with evolving field strains are an inevitable component of any longerterm routine vaccination programme. This requires considerable financial resources and supporting activities have to be based on surveillance systems that have a high
5
Theoretically, close to 50% of all vaccinated broilers have been replaced by non-vaccinated birds in the 60 days required by the Vietnamese animal health system to conduct one national vaccination campaign.
CAB International 2010
J. Hinrichs, J. Otte and J. Rushton
probability of detecting circulating HPAI viruses even in the absence of significant clinical disease. It also requires the sharing of isolates with laboratories capable of assessing the suitability of the vaccines used. At present, these significant ‘collateral’ investments to vaccination are rarely found in countries with problems of HPAI endemicity. In Indonesia, a donor-funded OIE/FAO network of expertise on Avian Influenza (OFFLU) is monitoring avian influenza virus variants and the efficacy of vaccines used in commercial poultry production systems [89]. Short-lived broilers, mainly chicken but also ducks, constitute a relatively large share of the standing poultry population of most countries, which, given their rapid turnover, provide a constant and ample supply of susceptible avian hosts. Campaign-based vaccination programmes can only achieve a very low coverage in these systems, particularly if two injections are required to achieve immunity. An age-based vaccination schedule for broilers would be an option to achieve higher vaccination coverage and its maintenance over time, but the logistical requirements for age-based vaccine delivery and associated costs differ significantly from those of vaccination campaigns. The private incentives for owners of broiler flocks to regularly vaccinate replacements are low and even if owners do vaccinate, broiler flocks will remain at least partially susceptible for 2 to 3 weeks, i.e. most of their life span (unless Trovac is used and protects against circulating virus strains). Broilers thus represent the ‘Achilles’ heel’ of any HPAI control strategy that relies, at least to some extent, on the use of vaccination. Although vaccination of more valuable breeder and layer flocks is generally more ‘profitable’ from the flock owners’ perspective, the incentives to vaccinate are not constant over the production cycle and immunity of birds might have waned towards the end of their productive life. Also, as breeder and layer flocks have relatively high contact rates with other flocks and as HPAI vaccination is frequently used in these production systems, postponed detection of infection because of potential masking of symptoms by vaccination may undermine the success of a vaccination strategy in breeder and layer systems. Upgrading of bio-security is likely to be safer and more costeffective in these production systems than vaccination. From a public health and national health security perspective, the reduction of human cases of avian influenza as a means of reducing the risk of a national panic and global pandemic is most important. Human cases of avian influenza receive high media attention and the political pressure to act is high. The impact of poultry vaccination on human health risk is controversially debated in the scientific community. Human cases of H5N1 infections in China in January 2009 raised concerns about the role of vaccination in increasing the virulence of HPAI virus and masking its symptoms in poultry [63]. Hygiene practices and awareness of risk factors for poultry to human transmission are possibly as important for preventing human infections as reducing virus shedding by vaccination.
g
89
The cost-effectiveness of national vaccination efforts need to be weighed against those of alternative measures to reduce disease spread in the national flock. In Vietnam for example, the culling strategy employed during the first wave of outbreaks led to the destruction of about 44 million birds (20% of the standing poultry population) and caused major losses to poultry owners and costs to the government. However, even this extensive depopulation of poultry flocks was not sufficient to break the chain of infection in all locations [90]. As a consequence, the government decided to use vaccination as an additional control measure, which, in combination with a modified culling policy, reduced the number of culled poultry, but added substantial vaccination costs. On the other hand, Thailand managed to very significantly reduce or even eliminate the circulation of H5N1 virus in its domestic poultry population within 2 years without resorting to vaccination, largely through intensive active and passive surveillance combined with, progressively restricted, culling in the case of outbreaks. The high and recurrent costs, technical difficulties, and epidemiological drawbacks of large-scale, open-ended blanket vaccination programmes in national efforts to control HPAI call for careful targeting of vaccination in national control strategies, which ‘intelligently’ combine available disease control measures. In principle, vaccination can be targeted spatially, temporally, and/or by production system to maximize its impact and costeffectiveness. Effective targeting, however, requires sound risk assessments, for which data and expertise are often lacking. Strengthening of the epidemiological capacity of national animal health systems would thus be a major prerequisite for large-scale use of vaccination in the control of HPAI.
Acknowledgements We thank all those who provided the sources on which we drew and are grateful for the constructive suggestions made by colleagues, in particular Professor Dr Dirk Pfeiffer at Royal Veterinary College and Leslie Sims, and reviewers in the course of the gestation of this paper. We also express our gratitude to the UK Department for International Development (DFID) for funding this work through the HPAI risk reduction project (GCP/UK/804/ INT).
References 1. Swayne DE, Kapczinski D. Vaccines, vaccination and immunology for avian influenza viruses in poultry. In: Avian Influenza. Blackwell Publishers, Ames, IA; 2008. p. 407–451. 2. Peyre M, Fusheng G, Desvaux S, Roger F. Avian influenza vaccines: a practical review in relation to their application in the
CAB International 2010
90
Animal Science Reviews 2010 field with a focus on the Asian experience. Epidemiology and Infection 2009;137:1–21.
vaccine suppresses shedding and prevents viral meat colonization in commercial (Pekin) ducks challenged with HPAI H5N1. Vaccine 2007;25(20):4064–72.
3. van den Berg T, Lambrecht B, Marche´ S, Steensels M, Van Borm S, Bublot M. Influenza vaccines and vaccination strategies in birds. Comparative Immunology, Microbiology and Infectious Diseases 2007;31(2-3):121–65. doi:10.1016/ j.cimid.2007.07.004.
17. Kim JK, Seiler P, Forrest HL, Khalenkov AM, Franks J, Kumar M, et al. Pathogenicity and vaccine efficacy of different clades of Asian H5N1 avian influenza A viruses in domestic ducks. Journal of Virology 2008;82(22):11374–82.
4. Swayne DE, Garcia M, Beck JR, Kinney N, Suarez DL. Protection against diverse highly pathogenic avian influenza viruses in chickens immunized with a recombinant fowl pox vaccine containing an H5 avian influenza hemagglutinin gene insert. Vaccine 2000;18:1088–95.
18. Ellis TM, Sims LD, Wong HKH, Bissett LA, Dyrting KC, Chow KW, et al. Evaluation of vaccination to support control of H5N1 avian influenza in Hong Kong. In: Schrijver RS, Koch G, editors. Wageningen UR Frontis Series: Avian Influenza, Prevention and Control. Springer, Dordrecht, London; 2005.
5. Swayne DE, Kapczinski D. Strategies and challenges for eliciting immunity against avian influenza virus in birds. Immunological Reviews 2008;225:314–31. 6. Swayne DE. Principles for vaccine protection in chickens and domestic waterfowl against avian influenza: emphasis on Asian H5N1 high pathogenicity avian influenza. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2006;1081:174–81. 7. Inui K. Vaccination against HPAI H5N1 in Vietnam. Unpublished presentation at OFFLU Technical Activity on Vaccination in Southeast Asia. 1st meeting, Jakarta, 14 November 2008. 8. Swayne DE, Beck JR, Mickle TR. Efficacy of recombinant fowl poxvirus vaccine in protecting chickens against a highly pathogenic Mexican-origin H5N2 avian influenza virus. Avian Diseases 1997;41(4):910–22. 9. Bublot M, Pritchard N, Cruz JS, Mickle TR, Selleck P, Swayne DE. Efficacy of a fowlpox-vectored avian influenza H5 vaccine against Asian H5N1 highly pathogenic avian influenza virus challenge. Avian Diseases 2007;51(1 Suppl.):498–500. 10. Rudolf M, Poeppel M, Blohm U, Teifke J, Beer M, Harder TC. Use and efficacy of inactivated AIV-H5 vaccines in the field (industrialized holdings). Unpublished presentation at OFFLU Technical Activity on Vaccination in Southeast Asia. 1st meeting, Jakarta, 14 November 2008.
19. Ellis T, Leung C, Chow M, Bissett L, Wong W, Guan Y, et al. Vaccination of chickens against H5N1 avian influenza in the face of an outbreak interrupts virus transmission. Avian Pathology 2004;33(4):405–12. 20. Cardona CJ, Charlton BR, Woolcock PR. Persistence of immunity in commercial egg-laying hens following vaccination with a killed H6N2 avian influenza vaccine. Avian Diseases 2006;50(3):374–9. 21. van der Goot JA, Koch G, de Jong MCM, van Boven M. Quantification of the effect of vaccination on transmission of avian influenza (H7N7) in chickens. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 2005;102(50):18141–6. 22. Qiao C, Tian G, Jiang Y, Li Y, Shi J, Yu K, et al. Vaccine developed for H5 highly pathogenic avian influenza in China. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 2006;1081:182–92. 23. Truscott J, Garske T, Chis-Ster I, Guitian J, Pfeiffer D, Snow L, et al. Control of a highly pathogenic H5N1 avian influenza outbreak in the GB poultry flock. Proceedings of the Biological Sciences 2007;274(1623):2287–95.
11. Rudolf M, Poeppel M, Froehlich A, Mettenleiter T, Beer M, Harder T. Efficacy of a commercial inactivated H5 influenza vaccine against highly pathogenic avian influenza H5N1 in waterfowl evaluated under field conditions. Revue Scientifique et Technique (International Office Epizootics) 2009;28(1): 275–91.
24. van Boven M, Boender G, Elbers A, et al. Epidemiologische consequenties van vaccinatie. Rapport voor het Ministerie van Landbouw, Natuur en Voedselkwaliteit. cited in English in: Vaccination of poultry against avian influenza: epidemiological rules of thumb and experimental quantification of the effectiveness of vaccination. In: Proceedings of the Frontis Workshop on Avian Influenza: Prevention and Control Wageningen, The Netherlands, 13–15 October 2003. p. 85–92.
12. Chen H, Deng G, Li Z, Tian G, Li Y, Jiao P, Zhang L, Liu Z, Webster RG, Yu K. The evolution of H5N1 influenza viruses in ducks in southern China. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, USA 2004;101:10452–7.
25. Amorij J-P, Huckriede A, Wilschut J, Frijlink HW, Hinrichs WLJ. Development of stable influenza vaccine powder formulations: challenges and possibilities. Expert Review. Pharmaceutical Research 2008;25(6):2008.
13. Gilbert MP, Chaitaweesub T, Parakamawongsa S, Premashthira T, Tiensin W, Kalpravidh H, et al. Free-grazing ducks and highly pathogenic avian influenza, Thailand. Emerging Infectious Diseases 2006;12:227–34. 14. Hulse-Post DJ, Sturm-Ramirez KM, Humberd J, Seiler P,