AND ALONG CAME BOAS
AMSTERDAM STUDIES IN THE THEORY AND HISTORY OF LINGUISTIC SCIENCE General Editor E. F. K O N R A ...
506 downloads
1395 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
AND ALONG CAME BOAS
AMSTERDAM STUDIES IN THE THEORY AND HISTORY OF LINGUISTIC SCIENCE General Editor E. F. K O N R A D K O E R N E R (University of Ottawa)
Series III - STUDIES IN THE HISTORY OF THE LANGUAGE SCIENCES
Advisory Editorial Board Sylvain Auroux (Paris); Ranko Bugarski (Belgrade) Lia Formigari (Rome); John E . Joseph (Edinburgh) Hans-Josef Niederehe (Trier); Emilio Ridruejo (Valladolid) Rosane Rocher (Philadelphia); Vivian Salmon (London) Kees Versteegh (Nijmegen)
Volume 86
Regna Darnell And along came Boas Continuity and revolution in Americanist anthropology
AND ALONG CAME BOAS CONTINUITY AND REVOLUTION IN AMERICANIST ANTHROPOLOGY
REGNA DARNELL University of Western Ontario
JOHN BENJAMINS PUBLISHING COMPANY AMSTERDAM/PHILADELPHIA
The paper used in this publication meets the m i n i m u m requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences — Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, A N S I Z39.48-I984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Darnell, Regna. A n d along came Boas : continuity and revolution in Americanist anthropology / Regna Darnell. p. c m . - (Amsterdam studies in the theory and history of linguistic science. Series III, Studies in the history of the language sciences, ISSN 0304-0720; v. 86) Includes bibliographical references and indexes. I. Anthropology-United States--History--2oth century. 2. Boas, Franz, I858-I942. 3. Smithsonian Institution. Bureau of American Ethnology.--History. I. Title. II. Series. GNI7.3.U6D37 I998 98-28940 30I'o973--dc2I CIP ISBN 9 0 272 4574 6 (Eur.) / I 556I9 623 7 (US) (Hb; alk. paper) ISBN 9 0 272 4584 3 (Eur.) / I 556I9 8 9 9 X (US) (Pb; alk. paper) © 2 0 0 0 - John Benjamins B . V . N o part of this book m a y be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O.Box 75577 · I070 A N Amsterdam · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America · P.O.Box 275I9 · Philadelphia P A I9II8-05I9 · U S A
Franz Boas (1858-1942) in 1901 American Philosophical Society. Reprinted with permission
Contents
Frontispiece Preface Introduction: Continuities Across Scientific Revolutions I. T h e Bureau of American Ethnology 1
v xi 1 9
The Development of Professional Anthropology in America
11
2
Government-Sponsored Science 2.1 Joseph Henry and the Smithsonian Institution 2.2 Spencer Baird and the Collection of Specimens 2.3 The Geological Surveys 2.4 The Curtailment of Government Science 2.5 From Geology to Ethnology
19 19 22 24 25 27
3
Constraints of Government Anthropology 3.1 Bureau Archaeology 3.2 Finances of the Bureau 3.3 Applied Anthropology 3.4 The Limitation to the American Indian
31 32 34 36 40
4
The Mapping of North America 4.1 The Myth Concordance 4.2 Linguistic Manuscripts 4.3 Bibliographies 4.4 'Introduction to the Study of Indian Languages' 4.5 The Definition of Linguistic Families 4.6 Brinton's Linguistic Classification 4.7 The Authorship of the Powell Classification
45 47 47 48 50 51 57 60
Contents
viii
5
Organizing Anthropological Research in America 5.1 Problems in Professional Standards 5.2 Bureau Fieldwork 5.3 Collaboration 5.4 The Missisonary Question 5.5 Powell's Evolutionary Synthesis 5.6 The End of an Era in the Bureau
Π . The Development of Institutional Alternatives 6
Early Attempts at University Anthropology
69 70 73 79 85 87 93 97 99
6.1
Graduate Education in America
100
6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6
False Starts in Academic Anthropology The University of Pennsylvania Clark University The University of Chicago The Temporary Insufficiency of Academic Anthropology
104 105 107 110 114
7
The 7.1 7.2 7.3
Tradition of Museum Research The Peabody M u s e u m The Bureau and the National Museum Changing Times in the Bureau
117 118 123 125
8
Uneasy Institutional Cooperation 8.1 The Field Columbian Museum 8.2 The American Museum of Natural History 8.3 The University of California, Berkeley
133 133 139 148
9
Boasian University Programs 9.1 Boas's Teaching at Columbia 9.2 The University of Pennsylvania 9.3 Boasian Anthropology at Chicago 9.4 The Geological Survey of Canada 9.5 The Autonomy of Academic Anthropology
157 157 161 166 167 168
Contents Π Ι . Continued Mapping of North America
ix
177
10 Boas and the Bureau of American Ethnology 10.1 From Synonymy to Handbook 10.2 Boas's 'Handbook of American Indian Languages' 10.3 The Myth Concordance 10.4 The Phonetics Committee
179 180 182 192 195
11 Mapping the Languages of California 11.1 'The Handbook of California Indians' 11.2 California Institutional Cooperation
199 202 204
12 Revising the Linguistic Classification 12.1 'Diffusional Cumulation' and 'Archaic Residue' 12.2 The Linguistic Stocks of California 12.3 The Sapir Classification 12.4 Radin and the Genetic Unity of All American Languages
211 217 223 229 241
IV. Boasian Hegemony Consolidated
243
13 Formalizations in the Face of Opposition 13.1 The Establishment of a National Journal 13.2 The American Anthropological Association 13.3 The National Association Becomes Boasian 13.4 The American Folklore Society 13.5 The American Council of Learned Societies 13.6 Confrontations with the Old Establishment 13.7 Boasians in the Bureau
245 246 249 251 254 260 261 265
14 Articulating the Boasian Paradigm 14.1 The Content of the Boasian Paradigm 14.2 Boasian Ethnology 14.3 The Distribution of Folklore Elements 14.4 Boasian Fieldwork 14.5 The Culture Area Concept 14.6 The Critique of Evolution 14.7 The Emphasis on Cultural Wholes
271 273 276 279 280 282 285 288
Contents
χ
14.8 Theoretical Syntheses
290
14.9 Envoi
296
List of Illustrations
299
Illustration Credits
299
List of Figures
300
References
301
Index of Biographical N a m e s
321
Index of Subjects and Terms
327
Preface
I have been thinking about the paradigm shift which produced Boasian anthropology for a long time, at least since 1966 w h e n I began m y M . A . research on the career of Daniel Garrison Brinton, Philadelphia anthropology, Americanist studies at the American Philosophical Society, and the transition between amateur and professional anthropology (Darnell 1967, 1968, 1971c, 1976b, 1988). M y subsequent dissertation work broadened the scope to professionalization more generally and, inevitably, to assessing the role of Franz Boas in 20th-century American anthropology (Darnell 1969, 1971c). Professionalization involved simultaneous change in the character of scholarly networks and the institutions within which anthropological work could be carried out; in practice, it was accompanied by a shift in theoretical framework from cultural evolution to historical particularism. T h e pivotal variable distinguishing amateur from professional proved to be academic training in anthropology. With this credential,fledglingprofessional anthropologists could expect to obtain employment in m u s e u m s and/or universities. T h e academization of Americanist anthropology, then, was the key factor in its professionalization. Without m u c h in the w a y of prior expectations, I discovered substantial continuities from the government-sponsored professional anthropology spearheaded by John Wesley Powell in the Bureau of American Ethnology ( B A E ) after 1879 to Boasian anthropology as I understood it. This seemed to contradict an oral history in which Boas took North American anthropology by storm, importing graduate education on the G e r m a n model and mounting an instantly devastating critique of cultural evolution. I became intrigued by what happened in the interstices of this putative 'scientific revolution' and resolved to attend to the continuities rather than the already well-known discontinuities or revolutions. I found that Boas initially worked within the existing anthropological establishment and adopted m a n y of its characteristic preoccupations, particu-
xii
Preface
larly a commitment to mapping the cultural and linguistic diversity of the continent. Moreover, it w a s closer to 1920 than 1900 before Boasian anthropology could be said to have exerted anything like hegemony over the discipline in North America. T h e telling of this story has precluded the telling of other stories. Powell's anthropology no more arose full-blown from a vacuum than did Boas's. Insofar as the B A E heralded a prior 'scientific revolution' in Americanist anthropology, it too had continuities to earlier work. Similarly, Boasian anthropology diversified into various competing paradigms after the Second World W a r , alongside institutional expansion in universities. Here too there are continuities and cross-fertilizations rather than virtual eclipse. These transitional periods could be approached with the same methods applied here. N o claim is m a d e that the shift from Bureau to Boasian anthropology is unique in its alignment of continuities and discontinuities, only that this 'scientific revolution' is the one explored in these pages. Although Americanist anthropology is generally distinguished from other national traditions, particularly British social anthropology, by its fourfield approach (encompassing prehistoric archaeology, physical anthropology, linguistics, and ethnology or cultural anthropology), I found that neither Boasian anthropology nor its B A E predecessors gave equal attention to these areas. In fact, there were persistent tensions between the scientific and humanistic poles of the discipline and between the forms of institutionalization most receptive to each (Darnell 1996). In this arena, Powell and Boas were of like mind, foregrounding the linguistic/symbolic/humanistic tradition and placing considerably less emphasis on the physical/archaeological/natural science tradition. This held true even though the institutions within which they pursued these humanistic priorities (the B A E and the American M u s e u m of Natural History being the prime examples) were ostensibly committed to more scientific forms of anthropological research. T h e emphasis shared by Powell and Boas will be foregrounded in this interpretation because it is the core of the continuity across paradigm transition which is the problematic of m y argument. Language held the place of honour in the Americanist paradigm which persisted from the B A E to Boasian anthropology on at least two grounds: 1) Language w a s understood to be the symbolic form par excellence, the characteristic which distinguished humans from all other species (and, not entirely incidentally, from the constraints both of biological evolution as
Preface
xiii
modelled by Charles Darwin (1809-1882) and social evolution as appropriated by Herbert Spencer). 2) Language provided the most plausible method to classify the otherwise nearly overwhelming cultural diversity of aboriginal North America. Powell and Boas agreed that 'culture' was the appropriate unifying concept for the emerging professional discipline of anthropology and, further, that culture was a mental construct, a symbolic form. Although both were trained in natural science — Powell's first career was in geology and Boas's doctorate was in physics in the materialist tradition of Ernst M a c h (see Ellen et al. 1988 for influences on Malinowski (1884-1942) and Stocking 1996 for the German Volksgeist tradition). Each separated out a sphere for ethnology or anthropology that was unabashedly subjective, particularistic and idealist. Boas's early article "The Study of Geography" (1887), following Wilhelm Dilthey (1833-1911), distinguished Naturwissenschaft from Geisteswissenschaft, i.e., natural science from social or h u m a n science, as requiring fundamentally different methods. His o w n career had m o v e d from physics to geography to ethnology; he justified the latter as requiring historical methods, different from those of the natural sciences but equally valid as forms of knowledge. Powell (1878) m o v e d from geology to ethnology w h e n he argued that land in the arid regions of the American Southwest could not be divided by principles independent of water resources on particular parcels of land. His political enemies were enraged when Powell modelled land use as a relationship between social organization, technology and environment. His insight was not different in kind from that resulting from Boas' sojourn a m o n g the Eskimo of Baffin Island: environment could not determine culture because, in spite of the extremity of their environment, the Eskimo had produced a complex symbolic culture (Boas 1888, Cole 1983). Although I n o w formulate it somewhat differently, I a m still committed to the essential structure of m y initial interpretation. Most of m y work in the intervening three decades has dealt with the interwar period, the classic Boasian synthesis. I have focused on the work of Edward Sapir (Darnell 1986a, b, 1989, 1990a, c; Darnell & Irvine 1994, Darnell, Irvine & Handler, in press) as paramount exemplar of the role of language and symbol at the core of Americanist anthropology (Darnell 1990b, 1992, 1997, forthcoming). In this progression, I have taken for granted m y o w n reading of the emergence of Boasian anthropology and its dominance of the North American discipline
xiv
Preface
until at least the end of the Second World W a r . F r o m the hindsight of a contemporary inheritor of the Boasian tradition, and to establish the continuity of m y o w n work, I wish to return in this volume to the roots, the origins, as it were, of the Americanist anthropology I practice. Since 1969, the place of history of anthropology within the discipline has changed substantially. The postmodernist turn to reflexivity in the humanities and social sciences has m a d e practising anthropologists more conscious of their o w n standpoint(s) and the groundedness of present practices in past histories. History itself has c o m e to be seen as contingent, relative to a standpoint, interpretation rather than direct representation of the past. This link has long been present in the historicist literature of anthropology (e.g., Hallowell 1965, Darnell 1977b, 1974a, H y m e s 1969, 1983). Only in the last decade, however, has its audience within anthropology entered passionately into the debate about h o w our shared past shapes our continuing present and emerging future. A contemporary turn to relativism across the sciences would seem to encourage cross-cultural research attuned to the epistemological premises of socially constructed symbolic cultures and to the ways in which their potential incommensurabilities m a y be transcended through fieldwork in the Boasian/ Americanist m o d e . In practice, however, the anthropological contribution to this potential discourse has been strangely muted as anthropologists themselves appear to reject the possibility of knowing anything that is not a fiction. Meanwhile, analytic philosophy has, at least in some circles, given w a y to a pragmatic history of science as all that can be k n o w n . Although this position would seem to set the stage for conversations across cultural boundaries, Richard Rorty (1979), for example, proudly and self-consciously proclaims his ethnocentrism, restricting the potential conversation to one internal to western philosophy. Everything I have learned, from anthropological theory as from aboriginal North American consultants, tells m e that this need not be so. At the completion of this manuscript, I feel that a myriad of acknowledgements are in order. M y personal take on anthropology is deeply rooted in Philadelphia. I took m y first anthropology course from Frederica de Laguna, one of Boas's last P h . D . students, and got hooked on the idea that scholarship could arise from personal experience, that is, fieldwork in the participantobservation m o d e . A s an undergraduate at Bryn M a w r , I studied history of anthropology with A . Irving ("Pete") Hallowell. A s a graduate student at the
Preface
xv
University of Pennsylvania, working simultaneously with Dell H y m e s and George Stocking, I developed, in sheer self-defense, m y o w n position about the inseparability of the practice of anthropology from the reflexive reading of its history. F r o m Dell H y m e s , as from Pete Hallowell, I learned not to separate history and practice and to honour the detail in the ethnography that anthropologists produce. I acquired at Penn a career-long commitment to acknowledging m y o w n situated position within an historically-constituted tradition. I have written primarily for an audience of anthropologists and exhorted m y colleagues to attend, at least some of us some of the time, to the history of our discipline. I quote a lot — the ethnographic and personal details matter, as does the style of expression. Moreover, our anthropological ancestors were articulate spokespersons for their o w n positions, quite capable of speaking for themselves. In correspondence as well as in published work, they debated, disagreed, tested ideas against one another. Although Powell imposed a certain degree of uniformity on the published work of the Bureau, internal correspondence reveals underlying eddies and currents. T h e former students of Franz Boas certainly did not agree with him on all issues. They are defined as 'Boasian' because their differences took place within a context of shared professional training, personal loyalties within a long-term social network, and overall commitment to Boas's version of anthropology (albeit they did not all always understand this the same way). Viewed from the inside, they were remarkably different; viewed from the outside, they were perceived to present a united front. W h e n in doubt, I present multiple sources shedding light on the same events and personalities. T h e organization of the narrative is not always chronological. Because the emphasis is on institutional frameworks and interactions of scholars around research problems, coherence requires finishing one story before beginning another. The work is divided into four sections which are roughly sequential. Nonetheless, continuities across these periods and emphases are frequent, confirming the postulated gradual and partial nature of the paradigm shift. T h efirstsection deals with anthropology at the Bureau of American Ethnology, the second with the development of alternative institutional frameworks in m u s e u m s and universities, the third with Boasian efforts to continue Bureau projects mapping the cultural and linguistic diversity of aboriginal North America, and the fourth with the syntheses that signalled the
xvi
Preface
coming to maturity of Boasian anthropology around 1920. Along with m a n y others, I was enjoined to debate by T h o m a s Kuhn's assertion (1962) that the social sciences were 'pre-paradigmatic', because past theories persisted alongside their successors and no single paradigm dominated at a given point in time. I concluded that K u h n did not follow his o w n logic, that theoretical paradigms are only part of the story. A n adequate history of anthropology, as of any other science, will consist of attention to three major factors: the theories, the institutions within which they are propounded, and the networks of practitioners a m o n g w h o m ideas are set forth and peer judgment is applied. Moreover, the linear process of professionalization occurs once and does not follow the cyclic, supposedly non-cumulative pattern characteristic of scientific theories or paradigms. Joseph Rouse (1987) suggests that it is possible to read K u h n in more than one w a y . There is a conservative sense in which each paradigm exists in isolation from all others and practitioners work without relation to any external matrix of evaluation. In a more radical and interesting w a y , which K u h n m a y not have intended, practitioners exist within an active community testing and disputing paradigmatic claims. It is this give and take within and across paradigms that engages the attention of disciplinary historians seeking ties between theory, social organization and the agency of individual scientists. W e all define ourselves in relation to scientific paradigms which are far from static, holding in tension both continuity and revolution. George Stocking's engagement with m y work has long outlasted his brief formal affiliation with the University of Pennsylvania in 1967, however serendipitous that proved for m e personally. His work challenges anthropologically-grounded historians of anthropology to produce competent history as well as competent anthropology. O n the one hand, this involves standards of archival research; more interesting, however, is the question of interpretation, reading 'beyond the words' of traditional historical documents (Brown & Vibert 1996) to the contexts which generate their multiple and emergent meanings. Also at the University of Pennsylvania, D a n B e n A m o s and Charles Rosenberg welcomed m e to their seminars, on history of folklore and interpretive methods in American history, respectively. I acknowledge Penn's commitment to interdisciplinary research, which permitted m e access to courses and scholarship in folklore, American civilization, communication, and linguistics, as well as in m y h o m e discipline of anthropology. I didn't
Preface
xvii
k n o w h o w rare that was until I went elsewhere. The original version profited from readings of part or whole by Igor Kopytoff, R a y m o n d DeMallie, the late John Witthoft, Joel Sherzer, and Margaret C . Blaker. Anthony F. C . Wallace was warmly supportive of this work and its place in anthropology. Bruce Nevin, Judith Irvine and R a y m o n d DeMallie provided collegial support and intellectual challenge at the dissertation stage and have continued to do so to the present day. Konrad Koerner has urged m e to m a k e the full argument of m y dissertation available, with the kind of refraining necessitated by the considerable time elapsed since original production, and to assume that linguists as well as anthropologists will be interested in the story of the coming of age of the Americanist tradition. Keith Basso, Harold Conklin, D o n Fowler, James M . Nyce and Stephen O . Murray have provided critical sounding boards for a long time. Alex Long sent m e back to think a few things over one more time. At the University of Western Ontario, m y collaboration with Lisa Valentine and Allan McDougall has empowered us all within a broadly defined and vibrantly contemporary Americanist tradition. The manuscript in its present form has profited from careful response from Keith Basso, R a y m o n d DeMallie, Konrad Koerner and Stephen O. Murray. I a m grateful for the editorial skills of A n k e de Looper of John Benjamins Publishing C o m p a n y . M y husband Gyorgy Ozoray and m y children — Tracy, Kevin, A d a m and Karin Vanek — have contributed and occasionally resisted in myriad ways that defy concise description. I a m thankful for their presences in m y life. Archivists are the mainstay of any disciplinary history. I would like to thank particularly Murphy D . Smith (then) and Edward C . Carter II (now) of the American Philosophical Society, the late Theodora Kroeber, Alan Dundes, Robert V a n Kemper, and Dale Valory of the University of California, Berkeley, Margaret C . Blaker and R a y m o n d DeMallie (then) of the National Anthropological Archives, and William C . Sturtevant of the Smithsonian Institution. Research has been supported at various times by the Phillips Fund of the American Philosophical Society, the National Science Foundation, the Canada Council, the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, the University of Alberta General Research Fund and the VicePresident's Research Fund of the University of Western Ontario. In Philadelphia, I have cited the Franz Boas and Frank Speck papers at
xviii
Preface
the American Philosophical Society (APS), the Daniel Brinton papers at the Van Pelt Library of the University of Pennsylvania ( D G B ) , the archives of the University of Pennsylvania (UPA) and the University of Pennsylvania M u seum ( U M A ) , and the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia Archives (ANSP). Sources in Washington, D . C , include the National Anthropological Archives at the Smithsonian Institution (BAE) and Archives of the Smithsonian Institution itself (SIA). The papers of Frederick W a r d Putnam are in the Widener Library, Harvard University ( F W P ) . In Chicago, I have cited the Frederick Starr papers at the Newberry Library (SP), the Field M u s e u m of Natural History, Department of Anthropology Archives ( F C M ) , and the University of Chicago Archives at the Regenstein Library ( U C A ) . In Berkeley, I have consulted the University of California Anthropology Department Archives ( U C D A ) , and the Alfred L . Kroeber ( A L K ) and Robert H . Lowie papers ( R H L ) at the Bancroft Library, University of California, Berkeley. William Sturtevant provided m e with access the papers of F. W . Hodge from the Southwest M u s e u m ( S W M ) . I have systematically reviewed the following periodicals, journals and monograph series for the years between 1879 and 1925: American Anthropologist, Journal of American Folklore, International Journal of American Linguistics, BAE Bulletins/Annual Reports, Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections, Smithsonian Contributions to North American Ethnology, University of California Publications in American Archaeology and Ethnology, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, Proceedings of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, Columbia University Contributions to Anthropology, Memoirs of the American Museum of Natural History, Memoirs of the Peabody Museum, and Annual Reports of the Geological Survey of Canada. I have examined university catalogues covering the same years for the following institutions: University of California at Berkeley, University of Chicago, Clark University, Columbia University, Harvard University, University of Pennsylvania, Yale University. Regna Darnell London, Ontario, Canada December 1997
Introduction
Continuities Across Scientific Revolutions
The central problematic in the history of American anthropology, as perceived by American anthropologists, has been the role of Franz Boas. Historical writings by American anthropologists reveal considerable ambivalence about establishing a place relative to the Boasian tradition and simultaneously asserting autonomy from it. Commentaries, depending on the author's point of view, have ranged between extremes of eulogy and depreciation. T o o often the urgency of presentist concerns has compromised standards of historical writing as understood by historians (Stocking 1968: 1-12). Dogged recapitulation of such efforts by anthropologists, however, attests to an on-going concern, however superficial, with problems of the history of the discipline. There is a certain oedipal flavour to all of this; moreover, its permutations appear to run in cycles. The existence of a disciplinary "paradigm" or series of "universally recognized scientific achievements that for a time provide model problems and solutions to a community of practitioners" (Kuhn 1962:x) is confirmed by the intensity with which North American anthropologists have responded to the organization of their discipline around a single founding figure — Franz Boas. The issues fall into two major categories: Early critiques focused on the overpowering entropy of past Boasian hegemony. B y the 1960s, American anthropology seemed to m a n y practitioners to lack consensus about problems for study and methods for their solution. This was particularly poignant for linguistic anthropologists, given the hoop-la over the so-called Chomskian revolution, often cited with varying degrees of hyperbole as the quintessential exemplar of a Kuhnian revolution in the social sciences. A s w e near the millennium, there is perhaps hope of more balanced perspective toward the accomplishments of C h o m s k y as well as those of Boas. In any case, m a n y anthropologists in the 1960s believed that the Boasian tradition had provided the last synthesis capable of encompassing the disci-
2
Introduction
pline as a whole. The profession was m u c h smaller when Boas trained his first generation of students and they had formed a compact, face-to-face social group. Disciplinary content centred around the critique of evolutionary theory and methodology for collection of basic ethnographic information about the American Indian. With growth in size and expansion of geographical and theoretical foci, the perceived unity of American anthropology disintegrated. For m a n y , the unity of the profession came to reside, if indeed it existed at all, in its c o m m o n historical roots within the Boasian tradition and its offshoots. In light of collegial fixation on pinning d o w n the actual influence of Boas, a number of his early students attempted to 'set the record straight' about their teacher's contribution to the substance of anthropology and the training of anthropologists. Robert Lowie (1937, 1946, 1956a, b, 1959, 1965), Alfred Kroeber (1939b, 1940, 1950, 1956, 1959, 1960; Kroeber & Valory 1967), and Margaret M e a d (1959, 1972, 1974) have been particularly concerned with historiographic problems in relation to their o w n careers (see also Beals 1982, Cole 1952, Golla 1984, T . Kroeber 1961, 1970; Steward 1973, T h o m p s o n 1968). These works appeared in the period w h e n post-war growth in academic programs and professional employment threatened an earlier imagined sense of unity and c o m m o n purpose. Melville Herskovits wrote a biography of Boas in 1953. Verne Ray's review of this volume in the American Anthropologist in 1955 produced further commentary the following year by Ray, Herskovits, Lowie, Kroeber and Murray W a x . T h e American Anthropological Association devoted two memoirs to the evaluation of Boas's work, one at his death, the other at the centenary of his birth (Linton 1943, Goldschmidt 1959). The choice of editors demonstrates the continuing relevance of Boas to the practice of Americanist anthropology. Ralph Linton did not identify himself as a Boasian and dramatically reoriented the Columbia Department when he succeeded Ruth Benedict as Chair after Boas's death in 1942. Walter Goldschmidt did not k n o w Boas but wrote his dissertation under Robert Lowie, one of Boas's first generation of students. Contributors to both of these works reasserted the unity of anthropology in America and the shared disciplinary culture of its practitioners w h o were the intellectual heirs of Franz Boas. Nor is the subject closed at the turn of the Boasian century. A symposium at Columbia University in 1992 celebrated the 50th anniversary of Boas's death. A session evaluating the m a n and his work was held at the A A A meetings in 1997. George W . Stocking's History of Anthropology 8 (1996)
Continuities Across Scientific Revolutions focuses on Boas's G e r m a n anthropological background (cf. Darnell 1997). Another set of persistent critiques has emphasized that Boasian anthropology is/was the wrong paradigm because Boas was uninterested in m a n y things that contemporary anthropologists wanted to study, particularly evolution. It was convenient to attack a Boasian strawperson as defining an overly limited set of problems. T h e challenge to anthropology was to establish the validity of research concerns beyond the Boasian paradigm as originally defined. Thus, historical scholarship has served to rationalize revisionist paradigms: " W h e n there is no single framework which unites all the workers in a field, but rather competing points of view or competing schools, historiography simply extends the arena of their competition" (Stocking 1968:8). T w o examples suffice: This paper will examine the dominant convictions of Franz Boas on a variety of subjects. W e will show that, whatever their individual merits, they formed, when linked together, a chain that constricted creative research in cultural anthropology. B y their combined standards, scarcely any research was judged satisfactory. The great talents of Boas himself were so restricted that he could not produce any positive, integrated work of significance, and his function became that of critic. (Ray 1956: 167) Franz Boas, also, helped to establish anthropology in American universities and did m u c h to stimulate field research. But so far as constructive and progressive achievements in the realm of science — its philosophy, outlook, and goals — are concerned, there is precious little with which the Boas school can be credited. O n the contrary, w e believe that Boas' influence was reactionary and unscientific at some points, such as for example, his attitude toward cultural evolutionism. This is not to say, of course, that no good work was done by individual members of the school of Boas. Good work was certainly done. But, I believe, the cult of Boas tended to constrict rather than to expand these achievements. (White 1966:54; see also White 1945, 1947, 1963) The most extensive historical work arising from such revisionist concerns is Marvin Harris's The Rise of Anthropological Theory (1968). Harris rues the coherence of Boasian anthropology on behalf of the wrong causes, but advances considerably in sophistication of historical argument. H e contrasts Boas's 'historical particularism' with his o w n 'historical materialism' but acknowledges that Boas's efforts to counteract the excesses of evolutionary ethnology were justified by the "shoddy standards" of his contemporaries (1968:250). H e thus makes a serious effort to characterize the evolutionary paradigm Boas rejected. H e does not, however, address extensively either
3
4
Introduction
institutional or social factors in the organization and persistence of Boasian anthropology. Indeed, those anthropologists challenging the homogeneity of the Boasian paradigm have dismissed the coalescence of a cohort of scientists with limited but attainable research commitments as a detriment to scientific progress. Most virulent a m o n g these was Leslie White, whose career-long efforts to revive evolutionary models in American anthropology waged an uphill battle against the Boasian mainstream. White concluded (1966:54): In cultural anthropology as in other sciences, w e find conceptual processes in operation in which premises and goals are determined, and results evaluated, by the concepts and logic of science. But w e also find social organizations — schools — of ethnological theory which closely integrate such non-scientific factors as personality, nationality, and race with scientific concepts such as evolution, diffusion, independent development, integration, determinism, choice and law. These schools are by their very nature deceptive. They m a k e it appear and would have everyone believe that their choice of premises and goals has been determined by scientific considerations and that the value of their results is measured by scientific yardsticks alone. F r o m the point of view of the history of science, however, attention to such a melange of theory, method and social organization is a necessary part of scientific progress. A n adequate disciplinary history must include: 1) the theoretical and substantive content of the science, 2) the social organization of the scientific community, and 3) the institutional structure within which it operates. Concern for such historical complexity is relatively recent a m o n g anthropologists and in large part responds to work of historians o n the materials of the discipline. In particular, the work of George W . Stocking, Jr., on Franz Boas and the concepts of race, evolution and culture (Stocking 1960, 1968) has broadened the perspective of Americanist anthropologists toward their o w n past. Isolation and analysis of successive changes in disciplinary worldview encourage historian and anthropologist alike "to see historical change as a complex process of emergence rather than a simple linear sequence — in short, to understand the science of a given period in its o w n terms" (Stocking 1968:8). Voget (1975) provides an exhaustive catalogue of work done within the Boasian paradigm, in which he w a s a latter-day participant. H o n i g m a n n (1976) is unique a m o n g the histories to date in emphasizing the ideational character of the Americanist tradition as practised by Boas and his students. S o m e of the revisionists have attempted to rehabilitate particular strands of
Continuities Across Scientific Revolutions
5
work. For instance, M a r k (1980) emphasizes continuities from the Harvard archaeological tradition that developed around Frederick W a r d Putnam, whose skills as an organizational leader were at least as significant as Boas's, particularly in the transitional years. Hinsley (1981) traces the anthropological work of the Smithsonian Institution, founded in 1846, and the Bureau of American Ethnology. Vincent (1990) traces a strand of Americanist theorizing about politics and political anthropology. Murray (1994) examines linguistic anthropology in the Bureau and a m o n g the Boasians in setting the context for his broad-ranging exploration of theories and theory groups in 'the study of language' in North America. This project focuses on the transition period between two paradigms in the history of American anthropology, assessing the relative effects of continuity and change. T h e first professional Americanist paradigm in the United States developed around John Wesley Powell in the Bureau of [American] Ethnology after 1879. Although evolutionary interpretations of American Indian history had existed previously, Powell first provided institutional support for research by a group of scientists; paid employment, social network and intellectual content coalesced for the first time within the Bureau. This was, of course, part of a wider professionalization of American science which facilitated the imposition of c o m m o n standards establishing a coherent framework. Continuity and change coexist in the emergence of every scientific paradigm. T h e professional scientists of the Bureau are not always easy to distinguish from their quasi-professional and amateur contemporaries. N o r did they single-mindedly seek to professionalize their nascent discipline. Nonetheless, in retrospect, professionalization was more than a by-product of the work that they, collectively and individually, did. Powell at least w a s reflexively committed to putting the discipline on a firm scientific footing with institutional and intellectual standards understood across a community of anthropologists. This was a one-way process over which he attempted to exert some degree of direction if not control. T h e theory which organized the work of the Bureau w a s that of evolution. A number of empirical difficulties in the application of evolutionary method emerged from the work of the Bureau. The sense of internal crisis w a s precipitated by Boas's identification of "empirical anomalies" which led to an extensive critique of the evolutionary position (Stocking 1968:303). Although the tone of the critique is destructive, there remains some possibility of
6
Introduction
ultimate reconstitution on alternative grounds. Krupat (1990) has considered a reading of Boas as theoretician from the standpoint of postmodernist relativism. Although the reading can be m a d e (for example, I believe that Boas and his students used "standpoint" as a technical term), Krupat concludes that Boas was caught in an unresolved and paralyzing tension between science and history. H e was never able to embrace fully one pole or the other. The unresolved incommensurability of anthropological method and theory, then, is a peculiarly modernist rather than postmodernist dilemma. In Kuhn's terms, the result of Boas's intellectual efforts constituted a 'scientific revolution'. In addition to his substantive revisions of the older paradigm, Boas w a s able to draw on n e w resources for scientific professionalization, particularly in the universities. His critique of evolution constituted a 'paradigm statement' and he attracted a group of distinguished students w h o practised, and transmitted to their o w n students, a 'normal science'fillingin the details of the paradigm statement. Whatever the continuities to earlier work, especially in the Bureau, Boas and his students perceived themselves as doing something n e w . They employed a rhetoric of revolution rather than one of continuity (Murray 1983, 1994). A n d because the paradigm was successful, it effectively expunged the work of its predecessors from the history of the discipline. This development was quite gradual, however, and the inevitability of the shift could be observed only in retrospect. B y about 1920, Boas's students held teaching positions in most major American universities. Disciplinary coherence rested on detailed andrigorousethnographic description of the American Indian. In spite of internal disagreements and personal enmities, these individuals considered themselves a group and cooperated to promote a version of anthropology which w a s shared, broadly, by all. Differences a m o n g them provide a cautionary tale about overstating the homogeneity of professional cultures (Darnell 1977a). Oral histories of American anthropology have generally assumed that the transition w e are discussing was fairly sudden, that professional anthropology in America sprang forth full-blown about 1900 w h e n Boas began teaching at Columbia. Consequently, the roots of Boas's anthropology in an older and firmly established tradition of American ethnology have been glossed over. Boas himself was not above rewriting disciplinary history on ideological grounds to emphasize his o w n positions (e.g., Boas 1904a). In fact, however, the resources available to Boas before about 1920 were extremely limited and
Continuities Across Scientific Revolutions
1
his early work necessarily proceeded in the context of preexisting personnel and institutional structures. T h e gradualness of the transition disappeared from professional m e m o r y during the interwar period w h e n Boas's students held key positions in the major institutions for anthropological research and the theoretical critique of evolution could be taken for granted. Before World W a r I, however, the direction of development of anthropology as a professional science w a s problematic and Boas himself was not uniformly optimistic. Over thefirsttwo decades of the century, American anthropology came to have the character that he envisioned for it. H e w a s a talented organizational leader, consolidating institutional arrangements and encouraging intellectual networks, as well as theoretical (or, in some views, anti-theoretical) leader (Murray 1983, 1994). In any case, it behooves us to reconstruct the context, largely invisible to contemporary practitioners, within which early Boasian anthropology emerged and c a m e to dominate American anthropology.
I The Bureau of American Ethnology
Chapter 1
The Development of Professional Anthropology in America
Professional anthropology in the United States developed gradually in the years following the founding of the Bureau of [American] Ethnology in 1879. "American" was added only in 1897 (Trumbull 1903:vi). For the sake of consistency, however, references to the Bureau in this work employ the full title Bureau of American Ethnology or the B A E . For anthropology, the process of professionalization was continuous after 1879, ending around the end of the First World W a r w h e n Franz Boas and his students formed the core of the discipline. This n e w Americanist anthropology built on an established tradition of amateur anthropology rooted in the linguistic and ethnographic interests of T h o m a s Jefferson, Albert Gallatin and Lewis Henry Morgan (Andresen 1990, Bieder 1986, Edgerton 1943, Hallowell 1960, Mitra 1933, Murray 1994, Resek 1960, Wissler 1942, Wolfart 1967). Through this preliminary period, the American Philosophical Society, founded by Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) in 1743, served as the central institution for the collection of data about the American Indian. T h e continuity of this Americanist tradition, however, was limited. The crucial intervening period, dominated by the Bureau, provides the transition to full professionalism. The concept of professionalization is itself something of an oversimplification. It summarizes and stands for a series of complex and interrelated changes across American science. These changes occurred neither simultaneously or suddenly. During m u c h of the 19th century, the few anthropologists were amateurs with loose affiliations to localized scientific societies; "the number of m e n w h o shared serious scientific aspirations exceeded the capacity of the society to provide opportunities for full-time pursuit of those activities" (Hinsley 1981:19). Horatio Hale (1817-1896), Lewis Henry M o r gan (1818-1881) and Daniel Garrison Brinton (1837-1898) serve as exemplars. Hale (Gruber 1967) engaged in ethnological research at the beginning
12
Chapter 1
and end of a distinguished business career. Morgan (Resek 1960, Stern 1931, Trautman 1987) was a successful Rochester, N e w York, businessman and lawyer, Brinton a prominent Philadelphia physician. Financial success allowed both m e n to devote considerable energy to anthropological scholarship, particularly later in life. Despite sporadic efforts, none of these m e n ever succeeded in earning a living from anthropology. Morgan unsuccessfully sought the position of Commissioner of Indian Affairs, and Brinton's professorship at the University of Pennsylvania was without salary (Darnell 1970). Prior to the establishment of academic anthropology, practitioners were self-taught and self-identified. Franz Boas (1858-1942) was trained as physicist and geographer. John Wesley Powell (1834-1902), founder of the B u reau, was a natural scientist turned geologist. The early B A E necessarily drew upon m e n with a diversity of professional backgrounds: Henry Wetherbe Henshaw (1850-1930), Walter James Hoffman (1846-1899), William Henry Holmes (1846-1933), Albert Samuel Gatschet (1832-1907), William J. M c G e e (1853-1912), and James Constantine Pilling (1846-1895) had formerly worked for the various territorial and geographical surveys under U . S . government auspices. Gatschet had some training in Indo-European philology in Europe. Jeremiah Curtin (1835-1906) was a statesman and world traveller. Jesse Walter Fewkes (1850-1930) received a Harvard P h . D . under Louis Agassiz (1807-1873; cf. Lurie 1974) and ran the Harvard Zoological M u s e u m before turning to the archaeology and folklore of the American Southwest. John Napoleon Brinton Hewitt (1859-1937) was a part-Tuscarora streetcar conductor and schoolteacher before becoming secretary to Erminnie Smith (1836-1886) of the Bureau. James O w e n Dorsey (1848-1895) was a missionary, Garrick Mallery (1831-1894) a statistician turned army officer, James M o o n e y (1861-1921) a newspaper reporter, Washington Matthews (1843-1905) an army physician, Stephen Powers (1840-1904) a California farmer andfinitgrower, W J M c G e e (whose preference for omitting periods after his initials is respected here) a blacksmith turned geologist. Henshaw turned from ornithology to ethnology "with the understanding that if the new field proved to be congenial I should make it m y life work" (Henshaw 1919:10); in fact, he ended his career as chief of the Biological Survey. Otis Tufton M a s o n (1838-1908) switched from culture history of the eastern Mediterranean to American Indian ethnology during the 1870s under the influence of Joseph Henry (1797-1878), Secretary of the Smithsonian. Cyrus Thomas (1825-1910) had been a lawyer, minister, college professor and
The Development of Professional Anthropology in America
13
entomologist before turning to ethnology. These m e n m a d e ethnology their career, at least for a time. For others, anthropology remained an avocation. T h e founders of the Anthropological Society of Washington included (Lamb 1906:565) such m e n as John C . Lang ("an antiquarian"), Miles Rock ("a civil engineer") and J. E . Snodgrass ("well-known in Washington"). The early membership sported physicians, army officers, lawyers, clergymen and denizens of assorted government bureaus, including the Pension Office, Department of Agriculture and the Geological Survey (Lamb 1906:578). The Bureau and the A S W attracted individuals with practical vocations, especially former army personnel turned to government service after the Civil W a r . These amateur ethnologists shared a concept of science closer to the natural sciences than to the social. M a n y were westerners and most were selfeducated. The early Bureau staff were professional scientists, but their individual disciplinary affiliation could and did fluctuate over their careers. The local scientific societies which provided institutional support for early 19th-century American anthropology varied considerably in size and scope. Not all were geared toward increasing the professionalization of science. Morgan and his friends organized a club called 'the Pundits' which heard papers on such diverse topics as "The Origin and Dispersion of the Celtic Races", "Trial by Jury", "Arabic Metaphysics", "The English University System", "Sanscrit G r a m m a r and Language", " R o m a n L a w " , and "English Cathedral Architecture" (Resek 1960:62). A similar organization, the Cosmos Club, was founded by Powell in 1878. In addition to anthropologists Mason, Mallery, Henry Crecy Yarrow (1840-1929), Holmes and Henshaw, the founders included geologists Grove Karl Gilbert (1843-1918) and Clarence King (1842-1901), sociologist Lester W a r d (1841-1913) w h o was employed as a paleobotanist for Powell's Geological Survey, Georgetown University anatomist Robert Fletcher (1823-1912), Smithsonian Secretary Spencer Baird (1823-1887), and Johns Hopkins University educators Daniel Coit Gilman (1831-1908) and Ira Remsen (1846-1927). Not all of these m e n , of course, were engaged in professional anthropology but it was part of the moral imagination of an emerging North American modernism (Crossette 1966). The A S W ostensibly restricted itself to ethnology, being established to "encourage the study of the Natural History of M a n , especially with reference to America" and stressing "the duty of all members to seek to increase and
14
Chapter 1
perfect the materials of anthropological study in the national collections at Washington" {Transactions of the Anthropological Society of Washington 1: 136, 141). The Society established its journal, the American Anthropologist, in 1888. Powell intended it to establish new standards for local scientific societies ( T A S W 1: 132, 136): The Transactions [...] exhibit evidence that Anthropology in its various branches is already receiving attention from the objective standpoint; subjective discussions find but little place herein [...] Anthropology needs trained devotees with philosophic methods and keen observation to study every tribe and nation of the globe almost de novo; and from materials thus collected a science m a y be established. In spite of Powell's optimism, the A S W program remained almost as diverse as that of the Pundits or the Cosmos Club. Topics included "Color Blindness as affected by Race", "The Old R o m a n Senate — a Study of Deliberative Assemblies", "The Use of Agricultural Fertilizers by the American Indians and the Early English Colonists" and "The Testimony of the R o m a n c e Languages Concerning the Forms of the Imperfect and Pluperfect Subjunctive in R o m a n Folk-Speech". Meetings drew audiences of up to 300 ( M c G e e to Putnam, 2 Feb. 1884: F W P ) . The A S W was one of a number of scientific societies in the national capital. Most of its members also belonged to several others. B y 1902, these included the Medical Society, the Chemical Society, the Entomological Society, the National Geographic Society, the Geological Society, the Columbia Historical Society, the Society of Foresters, the Botanical Society, the W a s h ington Society of the Archaeological Institute of America (Lamb 1906:564). Each of these was associated with the Washington A c a d e m y of Sciences which functioned on the local level as did the American Association for the Advancement of Science ( A A A S ) on the national level. L a m b (p. 564) noted that the size of the A S W membershipfluctuatedwith the successful founding of additional societies "the functions of some of which more or less directly related to anthropology". That is, the Society drew on general scientific rather than specific disciplinary interests. Professional affiliation was not a membership requirement. Washington anthropology was dispersed across institutions, including the Smithsonian Institution, the United States National M u s e u m , the Bureau of Indian Affairs, and the Carnegie Institute. Joseph Henry founded the Philosophical Society of Washington in 1871 to facilitate communication
The Development of Professional Anthropology in America
15
a m o n g Smithsonian scientists. Founders included Powell and m a n y of his cronies at the Geological Survey. T h e Smithsonian in those days had an "informal, family atmosphere" emphasizing "fluid structure," "personal freed o m " and "absence of bureaucracy" (Hinsley 1981:56, 75). Localism also characterized the scientific societies of Philadelphia, where the anthropological interests of each were encouraged by Brinton (Smith et al. 1900, Starr 1892a). Over one third of his extensive bibliography appeared in the publications of Philadelphia societies, especially the American Philosophical Society, the A c a d e m y of Natural Sciences, the Numismatic and Antiquarian Society, the M u s e u m of Archaeology (later the University of Pennsylvania M u s e u m ) and the Oriental Club of Philadelphia (Darnell 1970, 1974, 1988). Although the late 19th century was not a major period in the anthropological interests of the American Philosophical Society, Brinton spearheaded its shift in emphasis from archaeology to ethnology and linguistics in the 1880s and 1890s (Freeman 1967:39). Despite his international reputation as an ethnologist, Philadelphia audiences and publications provided Brinton's primary connection to these wider intellectual circles. N o n e theless, Brinton's efforts to professionalize Philadelphia anthropology, particularly his teaching at the University of Pennsylvania and the A c a d e m y of Natural Sciences, were abortive. His vision of the future of anthropological science exceeded his ability to realize it. Comparable localism prevailed in other late 19th century American cities with pretensions to scientific culture. Major societies with anthropological interests included: in Boston, the American Antiquarian Society, the Peabody M u s e u m , the Boston Society of Natural History, and the Essex Institute; in N e w Haven, the American Oriental Society and the Connecticut Historical Society; in N e w York, the American Ethnological Society, the American Geographical Society, the American M u s e u m of Natural History, and the L y c e u m of Natural History. The A A A S was the major organization of national scope. Frederick W a r d Putnam (1839-1915) of the Peabody M u s e u m became its permanent secretary in 1873, assuring anthropology of strong connections to this association — itself a harbinger of less localized and more professional science. This combination of local and national affiliation allowed Putnam to build an institutional framework for anthropology, especially archaeology. In this context, the innovation represented by the Bureau becomes clear. American science, particularly during the 1880s, was becoming more profes-
16
Chapter 1
sional (Bruce 1987, Kargon 1974, Israel 1972, Oleson & Voss 1979, Reingold 1964). The choice of noted physicist Joseph Henry as the first Secretary of the Smithsonian set a course toward specialization and pure science, although Henry himself was an old-style scientist w h o failed to patent major discoveries and turned from physics to full-time administrative work due to his conviction of the need for a n e w and more professional style of American science (Coulson 1950). Bureau staff considered themselves the vanguard of a n e w kind of anthropology. According to Powell's right-hand m a n ( M c G e e to T h o m a s , 29 March 1898: B A E ) : There w a s no scientific ethnology in America until about the time this Bureau was instituted [...]. Anthropology is undergoing organization so complete that traveller's tales and inexpert inferences must be replaced by expert observation and matter of fact discussion.
Powell's annual reports as director of the Bureau repeatedly stressed its innovative role. Although these reports had a clear propagandistic dimension, the implicit challenge was directed toward the older, amateur American anthropology as well as toward the Congressional and public opinions on which the Bureau's financial support depended. Papers accompanying the Annual Reports were chosen to represent the work of the Bureau and attest to its success in organizing American anthropology. Atfirst,these papers were short, with each volume drawing on the work of several staff members. Later, a single major work was showcased. The discourse of Powell's reports centres around the mandate to "organize anthropologic research in America" (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xxxiv). The Director's reports form the most explicit and accurate record of the aims and practices of the Bureau. Extensive detail and informal style are characteristic: The discreditable fact that until within a few years past no real advance has been m a d e in the ethnology of North America is by no means owing to the paucity of published material, but rather to its enormous quantity, confused by its unordered bulk and filled with contradictions and absurdities. (2nd A R for 1880-81, 1883, p. xxx) It is also important to note that m a n y errors m a d e by earlier writers, which have been repeated in ethnologic textbooks and have become c o m m o n l y accepted as facts, are not corrected. (11th A R for 1889-90, 1894, p. xlii) B y long training, by great zeal, and by deep scientific insight, these gentlemen are n o w able to accomplish results far beyond the elementary stage, and the
The Development
of Professional Anthropology
in America
17
significance of the data being rapidly gathered becomes more and more apparent. (12th A R for 1890-91, 1894, p. xxii) Powell argued that the Bureau had reorganized the scope of the w o r k of the individual scientists on the staff. For example, Dorsey's initial w o r k w a s received with minimal enthusiasm by the Smithsonian due to its non-professional style of discourse. Dorsey w a s advised (Roehrig to Henry, 18 M a r c h 1873: S I A ) : to admit nothing but the bare material without any kind of "comparisons" or would-be philological remarks. The work ought to be simple, clear, plain and written in sober style [...] Thus Mr. Dorsey will have to avoid in his work all sorts of digressions and everything else that savors of eccentricity and enthusiasm, especially those very crude and immature comparisons with Hebrew! Powell d e e m e d Dorsey to have mastered Siouan language and habits during his term a m o n g them as a missionary but his examination of the social system w a s not possible until he entered into "a special study of the science of anthropology" (3rd A R for 1881-82, 1884, p. xxxv). Primarily this involved acquaintance with the theories of M o r g a n ; Ancient Society in 1877 w a s ideally timed to frame the n e w ethnology of the Bureau. Powell focused on style of presentation as the major obstacle in earlier anthropological work; thus, Matthews's paper on the Navajo mountain chant presented familiar myths "in a m u c h m o r e pure and accurate m a n n e r than those published by Schoolcraft and other oft-quoted authors" (5th A R for 1883-84, 1887, p. xliv). Historians of American anthropology have concurred with Powell's view of the importance of his Bureau (Hinsley 1981; Fowler & Fowler 1969, 1971). Stegner's biography (1954:258) c o m m e n t s : " N o n e of the branches of the study of m a n w a s really established in the United States in 1879 [...] Powell's contemporaries [...] entertained n o broad views such as his". Hallowell (1960:37) notes that, prior to 1879 investigations were carried on by individuals whose pursuit of the subject was not primarily vocational. What is remarkable is the immense amount of material that was accumulated under these conditions, the quality of so much of it, the knowledge and definition of basic problems, and the impetus given to later investigations. Early scholars "operated single-handedly, whereas Powell set an early example of fruitful cooperative effort" (Kroeber 1960:5). T h e B A E institutional framework dominated American anthropology
18
Chapter 1
w h e n Franz Boas arrived from Germany in the later 1880s and his early Americanist work was done in this context. Through the early years of the 20th century, the Bureau sponsored m u c h of the fieldwork of Boas and his students and published their linguistic and ethnographic materials. Although Boas gradually redefined research standards in American anthropology, he also took over m a n y of the continuing projects of the Bureau and used its resources for his o w n purposes. This partial continuity shaped m u c h of the early development of 'Boasian anthropology'. The Bureau thus constitutes the baseline for both theoretical and institutional developments in American anthropology. The appearance of additional institutions for anthropological research establishes the context for the emergence of a reorganized and revitalized Americanist anthropology dominated by Boas and his students during thefirsttwo decades of the 20th century.
Chapter 2
Government-Sponsored Science
The development of the Bureau cannot be understood apart from changing concepts of science and the role of the federal government in its pursuit at the end of the 19th century. The peculiar relations of Powell's Bureau to the politically vulnerable Geological Surveys and to the relatively abstract and apolitical science of the Smithsonian Institution determined what anthropological research w a s possible. Powell walked a fine pragmatic line between professionalization and politics. Earlier in the 19th century, American science had represented itself to the public as utilitarian and consistent with egalitarian, democratic values. But after the Civil W a r , scientists began to value their work for its o w n sake, taking for granted the usefulness of scientific results. T h e tendency to justify scientific research by practical applications w a s most persistent, however, in government science. B y the turn of the century, the American government was probably the largest sponsor of science in the world, with the expectation that this science would contribute to public life (Daniels 1967:1703-1704): In keeping with the egalitarian democratic context, every single advance in government support had been m a d e on the basis of some presumed public purpose of a practical character that the research would serve. That a democratic government should become a "patron" of the privileged group of pure scientists was unthinkable [...]. Democratic politics demands that no expenditure of public funds be separated from political control, or, to state it another w a y , that no power be granted without responsibility, which always includes accountability.
2.1
Joseph Henry and the Smithsonian Institution The Smithsonian Institution was founded in 1846 from a white elephant bequest by the illegitimate son of an English nobleman for the "increase and diffusion of knowledge". T h e United States government almost refused the gift as outside the legitimate scope of government activity. Even after its acceptance, debate raged about whether a library, m u s e u m or national univer-
20
Chapter 2
sity would best fulfill the terms of James Smithson's will. The Congressional law creating the Smithsonian Institution w a s sufficiently vague to allow almost any project (Hinsley 1981; Oehser 1949, 1970; Winsor 1889). In practice, policy was set by the first secretary. Joseph Henry, a product of earlier 19th-century science, saw no contradiction between research, teaching and practical applications in the Jeffersonian tradition of benefit to all mankind. H e envisioned utilitarian science as research which could not be pursued or coordinated by smaller institutions and devoted himself to maintaining a clearing-house for publications, answering public inquiries, and providing an environment for scientists to concentrate on their o w n work. According to the Smithsonian plan of operations (Goode 1897:142): "if preference is to be given to any branches of research, they should be to the higher and apparently more abstract, to the discovery of n e w principles rather than of isolated facts". T h e Smithsonian was intended to be a n e w kind of institution in American science, with less direct responsibility for public education than the local scientific societies. Limited funds would be preserved for research rather than devoted to extensive field projects, collection of material specimens, or the establishment of a library. Rather, the bequest would aid individuals and organizations to systematize and publish the results of their research. Smithsonian questionnaires covered a wide range of scientific disciplines, stressing "the desirability of guiding and expanding such casual contributions" (Judd 1967:7). Henry envisioned "a national system of scientific correspondents... suited to a sparsely populated continent and an early stage of social organization" (Hinsley 1981:34). Contributors did not themselves have to be professional scientists. B y 1897, w h e n an official history of the Smithsonian was prepared (Gill 1896, G o o d e 1897), appreciations of its scientific contributions were written by scholars in physics, mathematics, geology and mineralogy, astronomy, chemistry, meteorology, paleontology, zoology, geography, botany and anthropology — very nearly the range of American science at the century's end. Henry's "austere personality" (Dupree 1957:88) kept the Smithsonian at arm's length from politics during its early years. Even politicians w h o detested him acknowledged his integrity. In an era of jostling for research funds, Henry concentrated on coordinating research within the limited appropriation guaranteed to the Smithsonian through its founding bequest. In line with this conservative policy, Henry opposed the formation of a National A c a d e m y
Government-Sponsored
Science
21
which would be limited to government service and to the establishment of a National Department of Science which might subordinate the goals of science to political issues. The Smithsonian was widely acknowledged to exemplify fruitful coordination of research under a single government agency (e.g., Dabney 1897). Ambitious theoretical projects were to be avoided in favour of immediately practical and descriptive investigations. Science was a 'moral enterprise' based on 'Baconian induction' in which facts and synthesis could be separated. Henry's broad view of the content of science included anthropology (Smithsonian A R for 1857:36): It is the sacred duty which this country owes to the civilized world to collect everything relative to the history, manners and customs, the physical peculiarities, and, in short, all that m a y tend to illustrate the character and history of the original inhabitants of North America. Nonetheless, some of the speculations which attracted popular interest in anthropology were on the 'fringes' of science (Hinsley 1981:36), for example, the conjectural history of the m o u n d builders by George Ephraim Squier (1821-1888) and Edwin Hamilton Davis (1811-1888). Henry acknowledged the considerable precedent for government anthropology, beginning with Thomas Jefferson's (1743-1826) instructions to the Lewis & Clark Expedition, intended to help untrained m e n acquire information useful to the progress of scientific knowledge. Other early attempts included Lewis Cass's (1782-1866) "Inquiries concerning the History, Traditions, Languages, Manners, Customs, Religion, etc. of the Indians, living within the United States" in 1823, John Pickering's (1777-1846) "Essay on a Uniform Orthography" in 1820, and Henry R o w e Schoolcraft's (1793-1864) circulars on American Indians published under government auspices during the 1850s. Albert Gallatin (1761-1849) circulated ethnographic and linguistic questionaires to Indian agents through the Secretary of W a r . The inaugural volume of the Smithsonian Contributions to Knowledge was Squier & Davis's Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley in 1848. The Smithsonian subsidized John Gilmary Shea's Library of American Linguistics and published Morgan's Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family (Hallowell 1960). The Smithsonian provided the ideal institutional context for the n e w Bureau of American Ethnology. Indeed, Powell's collection of Indian vocabularies began in response to Henry's suggestions during his geological
22
Chapter 2
expeditions in the Southwest. The institutional cooperation was fruitful, although lines between the Bureau and the Smithsonian were not clearly drawn. Frank Hamilton Cushing (1857-1899), for example, remained primarily within the Smithsonian for his anthropological work (Brandes 1965; Judd 1967:58). Powell's Bureau, like Henry's Smithsonian, could draw upon incidental results of other kinds of research. H e obtained information from exploring expeditions and diplomatic missions (Powell to Langley, 28 Jan. 1899: B A E ) . Collection of such incidental acquisition remained standard. In 1900, for example, Boas still had to defend (to Abbe, March 1900: A P S ) restricting the American M u s e u m ' s Jesup North Pacific Expedition to ethnology. 2.2 Spencer Baird and the Collection of Specimens Henry, although he discouraged the foundation of a m u s e u m under Smithsonian auspices, realized that the accumulation of scientific information necessarily involved the collection of specimens, especially in ethnology. These were not "considered as mere curiosities collected to excite the wonder of the illiterate", but provided "materials [...] to reconstruct by analogy and strict deduction, the history of the past in its relation to the present" (Smithsonian A R for 1868:33). Specimens were a greater concern to Spencer Baird (Dall 1915), w h o began collecting for the Smithsonian in 1848, becoming assistant secretary in 1850 and succeeding Henry as secretary in 1878. Baird's personal collections in natural history formed the basis for systematic m u s e u m administration which he later developed for the National M u s e u m (Goode 1897:167). H e was "an all-around naturalist — one of the last of a school which has n o w almost ceased to exist" (p. 175). Anthropology, to Baird, w a s no different from any other science in its need for systematic collections. T h e Bureau initially followed Powell's mentalist predilections in collecting information on social organization, religion and language, but extended its interests to material culture in response to Baird's priorities. The concept of science shared by the Smithsonian, the National M u seum and the Bureau grew out of 19th-century breakthroughs in the physical and natural sciences which seemed applicable to h u m a n variation by analogy. Not surprisingly, former natural scientists predominated in the early Bureau staff, with almost no literary scholars except Pilling, the bibliographer. Henry insisted that the Smithsonian appropriation not be used to support
Government-Sponsored
Science
23
collections, but willingly accepted and accumulated specimens obtained by government surveying parties. These required storage if not display. From 1841 on, Congress set aside a small fund to store such collections in the Patents Office (True in Goode 1897:311-321). This incipient national m u seum, arranged by the National Institute, quickly outgrew these quarters with the "deluge of m u s e u m materials" resulting from its circulars and expeditions (Goode 1897: 310). Funds were appropriated and construction begun in 1879; the building was completed in 1881. In 1881 Congress authorized a fire-proof building to house the growing collections: In proportion as suitable arrangements can be made for their reception, all objects of art and of foreign and curious research, and all objects of natural history, plants, and geological and mineralogical specimens belonging to or hereafter to belong to the United States, which m a y in the city of Washington, in whatsoever custody the same m a y be, shall be delivered to such persons as m a y be authorized by the [Smithsonian] Board of Regents to receive them and shall be arranged in such order and so classed as best to facilitate the examination and study of them. (Goode 1897:315) In spite of its leisurely beginnings, the National M u s e u m grew quickly (Dupree 1957:85-86): The force of events and Baird's patient work turned the National M u s e u m into the most significant branch of the [Smithsonian] Institution, despite the doubts of the Secretary. A n d yet Henry's very laggardness w a s of great positive importance, for he insisted on the M u s e u m ' s beingfinanciallyable to take care of its collections, and prevented the dead weight of the National Institute jumble from sinking the new M u s e u m at the outset. Like the Smithsonian, the National M u s e u m was envisioned as a research organization. The National M u s e u m foregrounded anthropology. Otis T . M a s o n was curator of ethnology and of arts and industries, Thomas Wilson (1832-1902) of prehistoric archaeology, and Cyrus Adler (1843-1920) of oriental antiquities and religious ceremonials (True in Goode 1897:351). O f 138,000 specimens in the National M u s e u m in 1906, over 100,000 were North American (Hough 1906 M S : B A E ) , confirming government exploration and Bureau research as the major sources. The personal relationship between Powell and Baird, however, was not cordial (Judd 1967:15) and the institutions they directed often operated at cross-purposes. Indeed, the M u s e u m viewed the B A E as simply an adjunct of the Smithsonian to provide specimens: "cultural objects, the paraphernalia of customs, writings, and inscriptions are tangible
24
Chapter 2
things and m a y be exhibited" (Smithsonian A R for 1904: 74-75). Thus, the official history of the Smithsonian emphasized "not only the results shown in [the Bureau's] publications but the material acquired and hereafter to be used" (Goode to Powell, 11 N o v . 1895: B A E ) . Public interest in museums and specimens of material culture imposed order on the exoticisms of cultural diversity and educated the general populace about the moral and material superiority of their o w n culture. American m u s e u m s hit their heyday between the Civil W a r and World W a r I. Powell could not avoid collecting specimens, although he personally cared little about material products of the h u m a n mind. Hinsley (1981:89) notes: "While Powell concentrated on language, religion and folklore, M a s o n turned to the works of the hands for insight into the mind". The Smithsonian was the closest thing in 19th century government science to professional or pure science. Henry's broad definition of the content and potential usefulness of scientific research was unique in North America at the time. Powell, in contrast, immersed himself in politics and applied science. 2.3 The Geological Surveys Geology, like other American sciences, became increasingly professional during the late 19th century. The government-sponsored expeditions of the 1840s and 1850s were minimally scientific in acquiring and reporting information (Goertzmann 1967). They were (Dupree 1957:99) "almost always military in organization and c o m m a n d " and "depended upon civilians either at the Smithsonian or elsewhere for working up and publishing the results". Despite "continuity in personnel and purpose", they were "usually ad hoc" and short-lived. The situation had changed considerably by the time Powell began his exploratory work in geology on the Colorado River (Powell 1895). His Geological and Geographical Survey of the Rocky Mountain Region was the fourth and last of the major surveys and can be understood only in relation to the others (Dupree 1957:196-213; Stegner 1954). The King Survey concentrated on pure geology and mapped the Central Pacific Railroad route; the results were written up during the 1870s, with the administrative organization liquidated after completion of its fieldwork. The Wheeler Survey began with the A r m y Corps of Engineers and was intended to produce quick maps for military use; it grew quickly in area covered and in political clout. T h e
Government-Sponsored Science
25
Hayden Survey originated in the Land Office. Hayden w a s a politician and full-time administrator w h o pursued a "lavish publication policy" without presenting "a planned survey" (Dupree 1857:199). T h e Pacific Railway Survey focused particularly on Indian issues (Geortzmann 1959). Powell's Survey was innovative from the start: it emphasized "a survey of the Indians of the Colorado Plateau" as potentially useful to the W a r Department (Dupree 1957:199). Previous surveys had considered Indians a hindrance to the acquisition of geological information. Henry's support of these ethnological interests was probably instrumental in Powell's attainment of Congressional support. B y a clerical mistake, the n e w Survey was placed temporarily under the Smithsonian, where only its collections had been intended to go. B y 1874 w h e n the Survey returned to the jurisdiction of the Interior Department, Powell's interests had diverged even further from geology as then understood. H e w a s concerned with "the influence of the land on its inhabitants" whether Indian or white (Dupree 1857:202). Land use w a s an issue not only to anthropology but also for Western settlement and development. Scientific geology had to turn to these practical political issues. Powell argued (quoted in Dupree, p . 202): [There is] n o w left within [...] the United States no great unexplored region, and exploring expeditions are no longer needed for general purposes.... It is of the most immediate and pressing importance that a general survey should be m a d e for the purpose of determining the several areas which can... be redeemed by irrigation. B y the time of the 1878 Report on the Lands of the Arid Region of the United States, vested land interests in the West had attacked Powell and his fellow scientists as visionaries with no concept of the realities of opportunity in the n e w lands (Smith 1950, Stegner 1954). Political interest outweighed impartial science. 2.4 The Curtailment of Government Science T h e results of the multiple surveys, each with its o w n approach, became progressively more chaotic. President Ulysses S . Grant (1822-1885) failed to see w h y policy problems in the Surveys mattered to mapping the nation, but others realized that consolidation of the overlapping organizations entailed a choice, one which would channel the course of federal government science. Previous laissez-faire politics could no longer control the proliferation of
26
Chapter 2
bureaucracies. A government commitment to "turn science to account in the rapid development of an empire" became in practice "an interlocking series of quarrels." T h e Surveys led by Ferdinand Vandiveer Hayden (1829-1887) and Lt. George M . Wheeler (1842-1905) clashed in thefieldin 1874 and the scandal became public. "The American people became dimly conscious" that government science "did not organize itself automatically, that some kind of over-all policy was urgently needed". T h e "scandal, corruption, waste, and duplication" which characterized the "excesses of the Grant administration" seemed equally likely to exist in the Surveys (Dupree 1957:203). In 1874, the major issue was military versus civilian control of the Surveys. Powell favoured consolidation of the Surveys, even if his o w n were subordinated to Hayden's under the Interior Department. H e pointed out that Wheeler's results were too inaccurate for geological work and that his military escorts antagonized Indians. Powell was powerless relative to the larger surveys and his only hope for continued autonomy was his emphasis on ethnology. In the debates preceding the consolidation of the Surveys in 1878, Powell supported scientific classification of public lands and the ideal of science for a democratic society. In the Smithsonian tradition, he insisted that government science should restrict itself to research which "could not be undertaken by individuals" (quoted in Dupree 1957:207). T h e government should pursue rational social planning rather than cluttering the literature with publications in natural history. Powell targeted the political opportunism of the Hayden Survey. After the consolidation of the Surveys, Powell retired to the relative political anonymity of the Smithsonian and his newly created Bureau of American Ethnology. H e successfully supported Clarence King, recognizing him as the least politically-embroiled of the available candidates (Smith 1947), for Director of the n e w survey. Although Powell apparently intended his retirement from geology to be permanent, when King resigned in 1881, Powell was appointed to replace him. Several members of the Bureau staff worried that Powell would forsake ethnology just as it gathered m o m e n t u m (Dorsey to Powell, 21 March 1881; Pilling to Smith, 25 March 1881; Pilling to Warner, 24 March 1881; B A E ) . Powell, however, continued on a characteristic course which did not fit disciplinary boundaries — his geology and his ethnology were never fully separate. Hinsley (1981:125) recognizes a "monistic tendency" in Powell's science, leading him to "blur distinctions between the subject matter of
Government-Sponsored
Science
27
diverse sciences". The method of science, by which Powell meant primarily natural science, was more important than disciplinary boundaries. Immediately Powell began a campaign to extend the scope of the G e o logical Survey. T o this end, he manipulated personnel, collections, wording of Congressional bills, and political networks in order to build up an organization for government science. But he was in a minority position in a progressively more conservative political climate. M a n y Congressmen felt that government science had grown too powerful. T h e Allison Commission of 1885 proposed administrative consolidation of a number of government scientific organizations. Powell suggested Smithsonian auspices for an even larger list of bureaus engaged in original research. The opposition, including the journal Science, argued that such an administrative role would be an unwarranted reversal of policy for the Smithsonian and that the bureaus should remain autonomous. Powell (1885:23-35) met the challenge head-on, arguing that private enterprise had shown little initiative in the study of America's unprecedented growth. In a laissez-faire atmosphere with wealth as the basis of political power, Powell insisted that scientific research must be controlled and defined by scientists themselves. The government's scientific institutions were interdependent, with a flexible "corps of scientists". T o a committee on administrative efficiency, Powell argued that research results could not be specified in advance and that utility could be assessed only in retrospect. The Allison Commission rejected a National Department of Science but, by refusing to abolish the existing organizations, "affirmed the usefulness of science to the nation and recognized the growth of the n e w bureaus as accepted parts of the government" (Dupree 1957:229). Powell w o n this round, but broad public hostility to government science could not be ignored. His budget was cut in 1890; salaries were itemized and personnel cut in 1892. The Geological Survey was not alone in these restrictions, but Powell's political visibility m a d e him a lightning rod for personal conflict and he found it expedient to retreat again to the Bureau. 2.5 From Geology to Ethnology Although Powell has been remembered more as geologist than as ethnologist (except of course within anthropology), his interests in the two sciences were consistent. Ethnology provided a welcome respite from politics during several periods in his career. Dupree's history of government science
28
Chapter 2
in America depicts Powell as a symbol of the n e w government science, mentioning ethnology only incidentally. "As Powell gained m o m e n t u m , his path increasingly conformed to that of the head of the ideal n e w scientific bureau" (Dupree 1957:211). Powell's biographers have stressed his Colorado explorations (Goetzman 1966, M e a d o w s 1952, Slotkin 1974, Stegner 1954, Terrell 1969) and his political career (Darrah 1951), rather than his role in the Bureau (cf. Hinsley 1981). Powell's interest in ethnology began during the early years of his geological research and his commitment to it increased gradually over a decade "among the Indians of the Rocky Mountain region". H e began by collecting and later enlarging "many short vocabularies of the various tribes w h o m I met". H e "soon learned to enlist Indians in m y party, and to seize every opportunity of conversing with them in their o w n language, in order that I might acquire as m u c h knowledge of their tongues as possible". The vocabularies ranged from several hundred to several thousand words. Powell "also m a d e notes on the grammatic characteristics of these languages to the extent of m y opportunity". Initially, he intended to "turn over the whole of what I had collected, through others and through m y o w n labors, to the Smithsonian Institution" ( C N A E l:v). The vocabularies from the early government exploring expeditions were being prepared by George Gibbs (1815-1873) at the time of his death. They had been submitted to James H a m m o n d Trumbull (1821-1897), an independent scholar from Hartford, Connecticut, to organize for publication. Powell requested that the Smithsonian materials be transferred to him for publication in order to avoid duplication of effort (Powell to Henry, 2 Oct. 1876: SIA). Henry (to Powell, 20 Oct. 1876: SIA) agreed, stressing "the general policy of the Smithsonian Institution of doing nothing with its income which can be equally well done by other means". Powell fully realized the value of the material thus received: This threw into m y hands several hundred manuscript vocabularies, with extensive grammatic notes collected from tribes scattered throughout the greater part of North America. Examination proved that I probably had in m y hand valuable linguistic material relating to every family, and perhaps every language but two within the limits of the United States. After a somewhat hasty review of the subject, a selection from this material was made, to be published as the first volume of Contributions to North American Ethnology. The volume was "rather hurriedly sent to the press" so that collaborators would have use of it. "Proper digestion of the subject" might have suggested
Government-Sponsored Science
29
"a somewhat different arrangement". Powell hoped "to improve on the methods of presenting the subject in subsequent volumes" ( C N A E 1: vii-viii). H e continued for some years to publish linguistic and ethnographic records of the American aborigines as memoirs of the Geological Survey. With the founding the Bureau in 1879, the vocabularies in his possession returned physically to the Smithsonian, although he retained personal control over them while Pilling (1881) catalogued them. The line between geology and ethnology was not firmly drawn in the 1870s. Powell had amassed a group of loyal followers, m a n y of w h o m changed careers on the founding of the Bureau. T h e First Annual Report quoted a long section from the final report of the Geological Survey in 1877 listing ethnographic and linguistic work in progress. Dorsey, M a s o n , Gatschet, Mallery and Yarrow were already collaborators. Their work simply continued under the n e w auspices. Gatschet in particular was set to work on the Smithsonian vocabularies, since Powell m a d e no claim to be a philologist. Powell's summary (to Baird, 2 April 1880: B A E ) of researches up to that time catalogues a curious hodge-podge of subjects — some subdisciplines of anthropology, others topics incidentally of interest to the original staff. In this sense, the Bureau systematized research already in progress. The choice of 1879 as the watershed year for the professionalization of American anthropology, however, is justified by the change from integration of the n e w government anthropology around the personality of Powell to incorporation within a formal government bureau mandated to ethnology, if not all anthropology. The n e w autonomy of the Bureau, particularly its immunity from political changes, however, could not be taken for granted. W h e n Powell resigned from the Geological Survey in 1891 to devote himself to "summarizing and correlating [the Bureau's] past researches and formulating plans for future investigation and publication" (16th A R for 1894-95, 1897, p. xix), Secretary Samuel Langley (1834-1906) preferred to contain Powell's influence within the Smithsonian. But Powell insisted on his right to control the detailed operations of the Bureau (to Langley, 11 June 1891: B A E ) : Y o u are aware that for nearly three years I have intended to resign from the Geological Survey and devote m y time exclusively to the work of the Bureau of Ethnology. With this end in view, at the last session of Congress I secured an increase to the appropriation made for the Bureau of Ethnology [...]. I have on hand a large body of manuscript [in which] m a n y years of labor are represented, and it will be lost to m e if I permit myself to be occupied with administrative work as I have for the last six years.
30
Chapter 2
Powell reviewed the history of the Bureau, stressed that it existed solely because of his o w n researches which had preceded it, and insisted that his foray back into geology had always been intended as temporary. H e considered Langley's administrative restrictions an aspersion on his integrity and that of the Bureau (loc. cit.): So far as I know, up to the present time the work has been carried on without criticism, the accounts have all been settled in the Treasury promptly, the publications of the Bureau have been well received by the scholars of America and of the world, and the service has inspired the confidence of Congress. I do not shrink from the most thorough exhibition of the methods of procedure, the most careful inquiry into the ability and industry of the employees or the most rigid scrutiny of m y accounts. Powell's challenge to Langley's authority was successful. During his lifetime he w a s able to run the Bureau, albeit within the general constraints of government science. It is perhaps ironic that Powell, w h o stands at the threshold of professional anthropology in North America, w a s himself an individualist. His scientific world was dominated by personal loyalties and shifting subject matters according to the vicissitudes of politics and funding. Yet the institutional structure created through his personal charisma and political skill set the stage for a n e w anthropology which would carry the study of language, myth and social structure, as well as that of material culture, into the following century, to the m u s e u m and university based researches of Boas and his students.
Chapter 3
Constraints of Government Anthropology
Although the Bureau of American Ethnology has been remembered largely for the n a m e and personal style of John Wesley Powell, his anthropology was subject to general constraints of late 19th-century United States government science. His directorship must be evaluated as m u c h in the context of his political career as of his theoretical stance in anthropology. At the most superficial level, publications provided valuable propaganda to influence Congress and the general public alike in support of the Bureau. A s a public institution, the Bureau was expected by Congress and the American public to maintain both appearance of unanimity and factual reporting and a style of discourse which would not offend the Bureau's non-professional readers. For example, linguistic texts had to meet standards of appropriateness imposed on the literature of the period. Thus, passages from Boas's Eskimo texts were translated into Greek or Latin, which Pilling at least considered an unreasonable w a y to avoid what Boas "fitly" called obscene materials in the native narratives (Pilling to Boas, 16 M a y 1887: B A E ) . The public relations problem persisted. Thirty years later, Boas's Tsimshian texts were investigated on a charge of sending obscenity through the mails (Hodge to Boas, 31 March 1917: B A E ) . Moreover, a number of Bureau publications were withdrawn from circulation because of supposedly objectionable content (Fewkes to Michelson, 14 M a y 1920: B A E ) . The Bureau was not, of course, the only institution to face such censorship; as late as 1909, Sapir's Wishram texts were published by the Boas-dominated American Ethnological Society with passages in Latin to avoid scandalizing readers. Occasional differences of opinion among Bureau staff were d o w n played. Powell wanted peace at all costs. For example, he requested (14 March 1895: B A E ) that Fewkes modify his harsh review of the work of Matilda C o x e Stevenson (1850-1915):
32
Chapter 3 A s an old m a n I do not desire to criticize your work or your paper but only to direct your researches in a wise direction [...]. There is not very m u c h in the paper which seems to be wrong but there is a theory at the bottom of it which will lead you astray and put you in antagonism with many good workers and able m e n in America.
Freedom of scientific thought was defended in principle. But, at Powell's insistence, minority opinions were explicitly labelled. M c G e e , Powell's assistant, noted to T h o m a s (8 April 1898: B A E ) : Should you chance to run counter to those conclusions of other collaborators which are of such sort as to demand recognition in the scientific anthropology which this institution is engaged in developing, some changes m a y prove necessary. Powell responded to unresolved disagreement by publishing the history of efforts to convince the wayward collaborator. Even Stephen Powers's candid rebuke ( C N A E 1, p . xxvi) of Powell's lack offirst-handknowledge of the aborigines of California was duly recorded. Although divergent opinion was tolerated with reasonable equanimity, the Bureau went to great lengths to avoid scandal. For example, w h e n a laboratory photographer accused Frank Cushing (1857-1899) of forging a jeweled toad in the Southwest and a painted shell in the course of his archaeological expedition to Florida, the Bureau administration stonewalled the press (Fewkes to H e m e n w a y , 30 N o v . 1896: B A E ) . Fewkes used his position as a Smithsonian official to insist that the affairs of a private individual should not be subject to such publicity. With an air of considerable relief, Cushing expressed his gratitude to Powell (12 March 1897: B A E ) for avoiding an investigation which would have been disquieting to friends and injurious to the Bureau. Although the truth of this matter has never been settled unequivocally (Greene 1977, 1990; Hugte 1994; M a r k 1976, 1980), the Bureau attained its primary goal — avoiding publicity which might prejudice its image as a repository of pure scientific knowledge and selfless public service. 3.1
Bureau Archaeology Congress, by virtue of its financial control over the operations of the Bureau, held the ultimate power to define research priorities. Although Powell emphasized American Indian culture, Congress imposed archaeology on the Bureau's scope in 1881. Powell unabashedly acknowledged that he had
Constraints of Government
Anthropology
33
initially "neglected" archaeology (12th A R for 1890-91, 1894, p. xi): it being the dominant purpose and preference of the Director to investigate the languages, arts, institutions, and mythologies of extant tribes rather than prehistoric antiquities; but certain archaeologists, by petition, asked Congress to enlarge the scope of the Bureau to include a study of the archaeology of the United States. The imposed addition of mound exploration (Haven 1856, Silverberg 1968) was "a surprise", given that Powell "had not been informed that such a movement was on foot" (12th A R for 1890-91, 1894, p. xii). But the n e w work was duly incorporated within the broad view of anthropology, an additional route to understanding the American Indian (4th A R for 1882-83, 1886, p. xxiv-xxv): The Bureau of Ethnology was first organized on the basis of the work developed by the Director while in charge of explorations and surveys in the valley of the Colorado River... [It] did not embrace any plan for archaeologic investigations in the eastern portion of the United States, and in particular did not contemplate researches relating to the mounds; but Congress having directed that such work should be added to the functions of the Bureau, a limited amount of work was accomplished in this during the past year. Although archaeology never became a major interest for Powell, he had studied it in the course of his geological work and was impressed by watching Shoshonean Indians fashioning stone tools not dissimilar to those of the European paleolithic (Judd 1967:5). Indeed, Powell thought that the wealth of archaeological data in North America would help Old World archaeologists fill the gaps in their evolutionary sequences (4th A R for 1882-83, 1886, p. lxii). In 1879, the consensus in American archaeology was that the mounds were "vestiges of a people more ancient and advanced in culture" than the known Indians (12th A R for 1890-91, 1894, p. xxxix). Powell, however, favoured explanation by continuity of prehistoric populations to the present time, "subject to known evolutionary laws, as against cataclysmic theories" (4th A R for 1882-83, 1886, p. lxiii). Archaeological material could thus be supplemented by "definite history", taken from documents and "reliable tradition" to reconstruct the history of the American Indian. The Bureau thus sought sites linking historic and prehistoric sites (Pilling to Long, 19 M a y 1884: B A E ) . Powell was interested in archaeology when it elucidated larger problems.
34
Chapter 3
For example, reviewing a paper on Pueblo archaeology, he stressed its general importance, although the title referred "only" to archaeology (8th A R for 1886-87, 1891, p. xxx). M o u n d research shed light on k n o w n Indians and "the culture-status of their ancestry" (12th A R for 1890-91, 1894, p. xliv). Linguistic families, if not particular tribes, could be correlated with the mounds (Powell to Thomas, 11 July 1887: B A E ) . Powell avoided specifying definite time periods or migration routes despite his belief that the total time depth represented by the sites was slight. Powell assumed that the goals of archaeology were those of ethnology and linguistics. Survey archaeology was typical in this period, in which archaeology usually meant collection of artistic specimens without context. But Powell wanted m o u n d exploration to embrace (7th A R for 1885-86,1891, p. xvi): "a careful examination and study of the archaeologic remains in the United States east of the Rocky Mountains". Cyrus Thomas prepared a catalogue of relevant archaeological remains; initially an aid to m a p making, it became a reference work in its right. David I. Bushnell (1875-1941) revised it through circulars as late as 1911 (33rd A R for 1911-12, 1919, p . 32). Holmes's Handbook of Aboriginal Antiquities appeared in 1919. Powell's attempted synthesis of American Indian archaeology with ethnology and linguistics was, however, short-lived. B y the late 1890s, interest in the antiquity of the Indians had subsided and m o u n d exploration was less crucial. The Bureau was already entrenched in other kinds of archaeological work, particularly in the Southwest. Powell's focus on the history of mankind in America was subordinated; in practice, emphasis shifted to m u s e u m specim e n collection (Powell 1887). The National M u s e u m preferred to secure the contents of mounds rather than to m a p their location (Pilling to Thomas, 6 Dec. 1881: B A E ) , an attitude which persisted into the 20th century. During his lifetime, Powell balanced the theoretical and material concerns of Bureau archaeology. But after his death in 1902, the Bureau moved closer to the National M u s e u m in its definition of research problems and specimen collection policy. 3.2 Finances of the Bureau Most of the constraints of government anthropology were outgrowths of financial control by Congress. Powell was a conspicuous figure in government politics and his Bureau could not afford additional notoriety. The early years of the Bureau, however, coincided with the height of Powell's political
Constraints of Government Anthropology
35
power. H e took full advantage of this position, receiving appropriations increasing from $20,000 in 1881 to $40,0000 in 1884. W h e n he resigned from the Survey, Powell obtained another increase; but this was withdrawn after only two years. Not until 1899 when scandals of government scientific administration had subsided did the Bureau's appropriations again reach the 1891 figure. This time, thefinancialstate of the Bureau was stable until the budget was cut in 1904; m a n y Congressmen felt that the Bureau should die with its founder. The budget figures reflect changes in Powell's political bargaining power far more than the research planned or executed by the Bureau. A s the First Annual Report noted, scope was to be limited only by the amount of Congressional appropriation. Such support was necessarily unpredictable. The Bureau could never make definite commitments beyond a single fiscal year, and cutbacks in research and publication were often needed. Powell decreased expenses wherever possible, especially by juggling the administrative facilities of the Bureau and the Geological Survey (Powell to Baird, 12 M a y 1887: B A E ) . B y 1894, when Powell began receiving a salary as Director, matters were so desperate that all salaries were scaled d o w n 15% and some staff were on indefinite leave without pay (Powell to Langley, 3 Dec. 1893: B A E ) . S o m e Bureau research could be pursued through collaboration with other government or private organizations. The Tenth Census was partially "supervised" by the Bureau, formally at the request of its Director (Powell to Baird, 17 Jan. 1882: B A E ) . Powell began this work while directing the Geological Survey and brought it into the Bureau after 1879. Cuts in Census funds in 1883, however, led to severe cutbacks in the overall research of the Bureau. W o r k on linguistic classification, picture language, and the history of Indian treaties had to be dropped, and the Smithsonian was forced to pay B A E salaries for the duration of thefiscalyear (Powell to MacCauley, 9 Jan. 1883:
BAE). B y strict economy, the Bureau managed to maintain most of its research. M o r e serious was the constant spectre that the Bureau itself would be discontinued ( M c G e e to Gates, 8 January 1895: B A E ) . This became most acute under Holmes, w h o succeeded Powell as Director. Appropriations were cut and he found it difficult to justify the over-all research plan of the Bureau, even on the basis of its past record. Budgets were initiated for specific research projects, replacing Powell's policy that scientists should determine
36
Chapter 3
their o w n research agenda. T h e Bureau never regained its prominence and political visibility in the 20th century, although work in progress continued to completion. 3.3 Applied Anthropology Although the most obvious constraints on Bureau activity were financial, research priorities were also influenced by Congressional and public expectations of practical results. Objections were posed to its lack of utility for Indian policy decisions. Swanton believed (n.d.: 47) that Congress had intended the Bureau to be temporary and recalled that " w e had to answer the question to every n e w session of the national legislature w h e n w e would be through". The Bureau thus had considerable stake in appearing essential to an 'Indian problem' which was then considered more foreign than domestic policy. Indeed, most of the early Bureau staff shared Powell's conviction of the importance of government-sponsored research in a democratic society. H e hired sociologist Lester W a r d w h o advocated "the scientific participation of government in the advancement of h u m a n welfare" (Curti 1943:575) as a clerk and paleobotanist for the Geological Survey so W a r d could continue his writings on political philosophy (Chugerman 1939). M a s o n (cf. H o u g h 1908), a prominent utilitarian scientist, summarized the c o m m o n belief in: the application of the instrumentalities and methods of natural science to the inductive study of m a n . T h e anthropologist, in this sense, is not a dilettante philosopher, w h o inquires into old things because they are old, or into curious things while they are curious, omitting all the great movements and needs of society, and overloading the baggage train of progress with trumpery picked up along the march. The practical spirit of our age demands that w e ask what truth, or good, or beauty comes from such investigations, and h o w w e can make them subservient to human weal. (1883:358) Such m e n were firmly convinced of the value of their science for the idealized social order they envisioned. They were uniquely qualified to promote the study of American Indians a m o n g the more literal-minded and pragmatic of the Congressmen. In 1879, Powell was realistic in proposing that the Bureau could guide the United States government in dealing with the American Indian, the greatest foreign policy problem facing the nation, precisely because the Indians were located within the nation-state. T h e urgency of pacifying the Indians and settling them on reservations helped Powell to gain political support for his Bureau. In his First Annual Report for 1879-80, 1881 (p. xvi)
Constraints
of Government
Anthropology
37
he quoted his o w n 1877 intention in the Geological Survey report to "endeavor as far as possible to produce results that would be of practical value in the administration of Indian affairs", with: especial attention [...] to vital statistics, to the discovery of linguistic affinities, and the progress m a d e by the Indians toward civilization, and the causes and remedies for the inevitable conflict that arises from the spread of civilization over a region previously inhabited by savages. Less formally, Powell noted (to Davis, 2 June 1880: B A E ) : If w e are to conduct our Indian affairs wisely and induct our barbaric tribes into the ways and institutions of civilization that the red m a n m a y become c o m pletely under our government and share in its benefits, the first step to be taken is to acquire a knowledge of the Indian tribal governments, religion, and sociology and industrial organizations. References to the reservation system recurred in the early annual reports and budget requests. For example: The immediate purpose in instituting these researches and in organizing the Bureau in 1879 was the discovery of the relations a m o n g the native American tribes to the end that amicable groups might be gathered on reservations. This demand for the practical researches conducted by the Bureau led directly and unavoidably to an innovation in ethnic classification. (14th A R for 1892-93, 1896, p. xxvii-xxix) M c G e e recognized the same relationship between policy-making and theoretical considerations in anthropology: the [linguistic] classification affords a means of measuring the susceptibility of the various tribes to civilization, to education, and to arrangement on reservations in harmonious groups. The classification is thus essentially practical. (22nd A R for 1900-1901, 1904, p. x) The practical aims of the Bureau were to provide basic information and rational policy guidelines about American Indians. A m a p , synonymy and linguistic classification were the goals of practical statesmen, but the scientific considerations involved required Powell to reverse the order of these priorities. Thus, public goals could be attained only after more extensive scientific research not envisioned by the politicians w h o awaited practical results. Similarly, Powell expanded the scope of the Geological Survey to include both private and public lands and to c o m m e n t on land use. T h e dramatic conflict of his policies with those of land speculators and Western entrepreneurs contributed to his political unpopularity by about 1890.
38
Chapter 3
Powell quickly c a m e to see language as the key to ethnic classification and existing ethnic classifications as hopelessly inadequate. L a n g u a g e had long been accepted as one important m e a n s to classify peoples. In the late 19th century, the only serious alternative w a s classification b y race. Powell's position w a s , therefore, explicitly directed against evolutionary biology. Because language w a s correlated with other features of social ('demotic') life, it could serve as an index for cultural development, and ultimately could facilitate the juxtaposition of linguistically related peoples o n reservations. T h e linguistic similarity of tribes w a s "a self-evident b o n d of sympathy and ultimate union" which could be encouraged b y reservation administration (14th A R for 1 8 9 2 - 9 3 , 1 8 9 6 , p . xxviii). Powell's reformer science involved intimate k n o w l edge of the A m e r i c a n Indians which could be tested b y the policies applied to their gradual but inevitable incorporation into civilized society. T h e interaction of theory and practice w a s constant: So the initial work of the Bureau was the development of a practical system of classifying primitive peoples, and the conditions were such as to permit an actual test of the classification and to complete the rejection of unnatural, illogical, or incongruous systems. Thus it was found absolutely necessary to abandon current systems of ethnic classification, and to devise and adopt a system based on purely human characteristics springing from intellectual activities. (14th A R for 1892-93, 1896, p. xxix) Great weight rested o n linguistic classification in this scheme: the linguistic characters have been found to be interrelated with other characters, including those expressed in arts, industries, institutions, and beliefs.... [T]he several categories of characters represented by language have been found, through study of traditions and direct survivals, to express the actual phylogenetic development of tribes and stocks. Accordingly each linguistic character is treated not merely as an external adventive feature, but as a product of evolution, a record of the past, and a precursor of the future. The classification of American Indians devised and applied by the Bureau is accordingly a condensed expression of the sum of present knowledge concerning the origin and development of the native American people. (McGee in Goode 1897, p. 377-378) In addition to the practical purposes of linguistic w o r k , moreover, Powell w a s convinced that A m e r i c a n Indian languages m a d e important potential contributions to general linguistics. Philology had remained too long "in the hands of the metaphysicians" (1st A R for 1 8 7 9 - 8 0 , 1 8 8 1 , p . 78): anthropology required an objective s c h e m e for classification which could b e applied to all the languages of the world. 'Linguistic Anthropology' (as M a s o n called it)
Constraints of Government
Anthropology
39
should deal with the history and evolution of language itself and with the classification of peoples for comparative anthropological study (Mason 1881: 397). Such studies led back to questions of social organization, religion and evolution of the American Indians, making language the model for the study of the others. Ideally, language would prove to be related to the rest of culture so that linguistic classification could serve directly as an ethnic classification. Powell was more concerned to classify extant Indians than to reconstruct their past history, although he realized that ethnic and linguistic units were potentially variable through time and that classifications might prove more complex than the ideal case. Historically, he believed that most existing ethnic groups were formed by admixture, "with a general progress toward unity" which had "obscured primitive ethnic divisions, if such existed" (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. 80). Powell even granted the theoretical possibility that classifications based on language, religion, mortuary customs, sociology and physical characteristics might remain separate and irreconcilable. In the absence of existing classifications for these ethnic phenomena, Powell accepted language as the closest thing to an adequate classificatory variable. The argument had a different focus w h e n Boas returned to it in his Introduction to the Handbook of American Indian Languages, published in 1911. Race, language and culture were analytically separate variables which might coincide because of particular historical circumstances but need not do so. It was the complex history of such groups which enjoined anthropologists to employ all possible lines of evidence, not only linguistic, toward reconstruction of culture history. N o single classificatory principle could be adequate or aesthetically satisfying. The Bureau received numerous inquiries, official and unofficial, about the American Indians. Each was diligently answered by some m e m b e r of the Bureau staff. Powell intervened (to Lewis Henry Morgan, 4 April 1880: B A E ) w h e n an Abenaki chief was charged customs duties for moving his baskets from Canada to the United States. O n another occasion, Powell (to Hayt, 12 Jan. 1880: B A E ) reminded the Bureau of Indian Affairs of the need to consider Indian patterns of thought in introducing Western style family names. T h e Bureau advised political procedures consistent with Indian political process (Powell to Teller, 12 Feb. 1880: B A E ) and provided technical information on such subjects as locations of reservations to facilitate settlement and administration (Powell to Morgan, 24 Jan. 1881: B A E ) . Occasionally, the Bureau even accepted responsibility for the "discreet conduct of the
40
Chapter 3
work on reservations" by non-Bureau staff w h o needed permission for their work (Holmes to Wissler, 27 April 1906: B A E ) . In any case, like the Bureau of Indian Affairs, the B A E was forced to deal with practical and recurrent problems about American Indians whether or not its o w n research w a s furthered by such digressions into politics and administration. Powell's was a program of urgent anthropological research. Although he was the first to use the term 'acculturation' (Hallowell 1965), the Bureau was not interested in studying adaptation to Western society. T h e aim in every case was to describe the aboriginal culture which was modified by contact with civilization, resulting in "the completion of a systematic and wellrounded record of the tribes before the ever accelerating march of change shall have robbed them of their aboriginal characteristics and culture" (18th A R for 1906-07, 1912: 9). The linguistic classification was a salvage operation, intended as "the chart of savage occupation of the continent" although civilization had "almost entirely swept away the living representatives of this primitive culture" (Mason 1891a:377). Powell was appalled that the National M u s e u m did not firmly separate native products influenced by acculturation and trade goods from those which were aboriginal ('pure'). Thus, ironically, although the original motivation had been to deal with modern American Indians, their contemporary plight was explicitly excluded by Powell from the proper scope of anthropology. Reservations were, in this sense, a solution to the dilemma of a people w h o preserved a stage of h u m a n civilization that was quickly passing away. T h e Indians were part of American history and their traditional customs had to be recorded in the most pristine form possible. Nonetheless, this was not applied anthropology as later understood and had little to do with the plight of particular groups of Indians (cf. Berkhofer 1978, Bieder 1986). 3.4 The Limitation to the American Indian Because the Bureau grew out of the geological and geographical surveys of the United States territories, like them, it was expected to provide basic information about the n e w country and problems of settling and developing it. The Bureau, responding to the great diversity of American Indians, collected m u c h such information. Government sponsorship meant that researches were restricted in practice to the territory of the United States, although this soon became an unwelcome constraint from the standpoint of anthropology as a theoretical and comparative science. A s early as 1881, Powell pointed out (1st
Constraints of Government Anthropology
41
A R for 1879-80,1881, p. xv): "The contributions already received from m a n y parts of the world relating to the lower stages of culture among other people have been of value in elucidating the problems presented in North America". Indeed, the researches of Mallery on picture writing and gestures and of Yarrow on burial customs were not restricted in scope to North America. Powell wanted to use the familiar questionnaire approach to acquire comparative materials (to Langley, 28 Jan. 1899: B A E ) and assumed that his evolutionary theory would integrate these materials independently of particular culture histories, e.g., those of North America. In practice, the North American restriction meant that the Bureau could not logically extend its researches in directions which would have been reasonable otherwise. B y 1895, Powell and M c G e e were campaigning to have the word "North" omitted from the Congressional bill. At about the same time, the word "American" was inserted into the n a m e of the Bureau itself, suggesting the widest possible scope for the institution (McGee to Langley, 8 Oct. 1895: B A E ) . Occasional forays into Middle and South American materials thus became feasible on the grounds that American Indians did not respect later political boundaries. The Bureau was never able to support m u c h Mexican work, for example, of Alphonse Louis Pinart (1852-1911) in archaeology (Powell to Pinart, 8 March 1890: B A E ) or Spanish language publications (Powell to Rathburn, 22 M a y 1899: B A E ) . But it extended the 1891 linguistic classification to include Central America. W o r k began about 1895 but appeared in print only in 1911 (Mason 1900; Thomas & Swanton 1911). Extensions of the Bureau's scope during the 19th century were modest. But at the end of Powell's lifetime, the role of the United States in world politics was changing rapidly. In response, the Bureau attempted to deal with the ethnology of peoples newly involved in U . S . foreign policy, just as it had previously dealt with Indian policy problems. In Hawaii and the Philippines, M c G e e (to Langley, 12 June 1901: B A E ) stressed that "educational systems and methods adapted to the conditions and requirements of the natives" required ethnological research. Congress approved researches in Hawaii early in the century, but in practice these were rarely carried out. B y 1922, lack of resources for such work led Fewkes to rationalize that local investigators had the archaeology well in hand and Hawaii was a poor place to study anyway because it was only on the fringes of Polynesia (41st A R for 1921-22, 1928:48). West Indian researches early in the century were also abortive.
42
Chapter 3
B y the end of the First World W a r , American politics reflected expanding consciousness of other peoples and cultures. Fewkes, as head of the Bureau, tried unsuccessfully to involve the institution in this broadening of public interest based on the need for "accurate knowledge of other races besides the American Indian. It needs no prophet to predict [...] demand [for] an extension of the Bureau work to other races" (40th A R for 1920-21, 1925:2). Or: The Great W a r has enlarged our view of the practical value of ethnological studies. A s our country has become a world power and has entered into political and commercial relationships with many other races whose ethnology is little known, it is desirable that the ethnological researches of the Bureau be enlarged in order that w e m a y better appreciate these foreign peoples. From necessity w e have limited our researches to the American Indian and natives of Hawaii. There is, however, an urgent call for more extended studies of all peoples whose amalgamation will constitute the future America. (41st A R for 1921-22, 1928:3) The Bureau faced great difficulty justifying even its American Indian researches at this time, putting it in a poor position to claim its qualifications to meet the challenge of an expanding national consciousness. The ethnologists w h o went into the n e w territories were not employed by the government, although Powell's concept of the role of government anthropology could have been extended easily in this direction. T h e rest of American anthropology m o v e d away from emphasis on American Indians (Murray in press) and the importance of the Bureau declined proportionately. This constraint, however, was imposed on the Bureau, not chosen by it. In fact, for each of the constraints placed on the Bureau by its status as a government institution, the personality of John Wesley Powell was a major factor in permitting productive research in spite of the limitations of support. Powell was effective in securing favourable publicity and adequate if not munificent funds. Goals of government policy did not seem to him inconsistent with theoretical anthropology. American Indians provided sufficient diversity to keep the staff occupied, although an occasional foray into comparative ethnology was required to provide context. Archaeological time depth required additional resources to acquire and present to the public a full picture of the American Indians. Government support of anthropological research through the Bureau was crucial to late 19th-century institutional development of the science, because m u s e u m s and universities could not yet support professional scientists. T h e rationale for government support, however, was not pure science but the
Constraints of Government
Anthropology
43
foreign policy implications of Indian resistance to western expansion. Realistic politicians sought reliable information to guide Indian legislation; indeed, treaties were negotiated and signed through the W a r Department. Powell's work spanned the transition of the American Indian from an external to a domestic problem as illustrated by the brief placement of his Bureau under the Interior Department. T h e early Bureau w a s expected by its government sponsors to provide both accurate information about the Indians and philosophical justification, within evolutionary theory, for the expansion of American civilization at the expense of the aborigines. After 1900, Indian policy retreated from public consciousness, with less intense need for knowledge of Indian cultures. T h e Bureau was ineffective in claiming expertise on n e w problems of American colonialism beyond the continent. Indian administration with anthropological input, with the Indians as an important domestic responsibility, arose only in the 1930s. T h e Bureau remained outside the developing university framework of American anthropology and could not perpetuate itself w h e n the original rationale became insufficient to justify its continued existence.
John Wesley Powell (1834-1902) Smithsonian Institution. Reprinted with permission.
Chapter 4
'The Mapping of North America'
T h e phrase "the mapping of North America" summarizes the empirical program uniting the early researches of the Bureau of American Ethnology — that is, the amassing of basic ethnographic and linguistic information about the American Indian, conceived as a fairly straight-forward collection of factual data. Indeed, the Bureau was founded to remedy gaps in systematic knowledge of American aborigines, m u c h of which had emerged from Powell's western explorations. Results appeared in a series of compendia — handbooks and monographs — summarizing and supplementing research results of staff and collaborators. Powell had originally envisioned a series of "Manuals for use in American Research" (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xxxii). His o w n Introduction to the Study of Indian Languages would be followed by similar introductions to mortuary customs (Yarrow) and sign language (Mallery), as well as manuals of medical practice (Mooney), tribal government (Powell & Dorsey), and North American myths (Powell, Curtin, Hewitt) (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xxxiii): These additional manuals are nearly ready. Still others are projected, and it is hoped that the field of North American anthropology will be entirely covered by them. The series will then be systematically combined in a Manual of Anthropology for use in North America. T h e work quickly became more complex than Powell had expected. B y 1909, 'handbooks' (compilations of varying scope) had appeared on tribes, race history, language, social systems, religions, technology, aesthetic arts, sign language, pictographs, treaties and cessions, games and amusements, burial customs, economics, archaeology, geographical names, Hawaii. Bibliographies, grammars and portfolios of portraits were considered similar projects (30th A R for 1908-09, 1915:10-11). Although not all of these were carried out during Powell's lifetime, all are consistent with his view of the
46
Chapter 4
Bureau's mandate to acquire, compile and present to the public information on the Indian population of the United States. The 'mapping' projects varied considerably in scope. The research of Royce on Indian treaties and cessions and Yarrow on burial customs were individual specializations. Mallery's focus on picture and sign language was supplemented by questionnaires and examples from the rest of the Bureau staff. Other projects outgrew their original scope. Powell's standardization of alphabets and vocabularies led to a linguistic classification which aided Pilling in organizing his bibliographies, which in turn fed into the tribal synonymy. T h e overlap in these long-term projects meant that the same people worked on several of them, involving most of the Bureau staff at one time or another, and Powell directed the overall enterprise. The result was a cooperative effort never again duplicated in American anthropology. N o other anthropological institution at this time possessed comparable resources for cooperative research. Indeed, Boas noted (to W o o d w a r d , 12 Jan. 1905: A P S ) : "In reality the Bureau of American Anthropology has partially performed the work of an anthropological survey of the United States, and it should be developed so as to perform this office in a m u c h more systematic manner". In fact, of course, events evolved quite differently. It was Boas and his early students w h o maintained the Bureau tradition of compiling basic information about the American Indians during the 20th century (see Part III). In any case, the reputation of the Bureau in the late 19th century rested on the scope and implementation of these cooperative ' m a p ping' projects. Although in retrospect the linguistic classification of 1891 looms largest, it was only part of Powell's systematic research program. T h e mapping projects were essential to the Bureau's place in the emerging professional discipline of anthropology. Although individual scientists did not have absolute freedom to pursue their personal researches, they had access to collective resources unmatchable by private scholars. Hinsley (1981: 164, 174) argues that they were "incomplete scientists" because of these constraints, describing a career "pattern" of "intense early field work succeeded by an office career of collating and synthesizing with only sporadic returns to thefield."H e reads the scientific commitments of the early staff, e.g., M o o n e y and. Cushing, as exceptional individual characteristics rather than "institutional perspective" (Hinsley 1981: 224). The institutional vision of the Bureau, however, resided in Powell, assisted by M c G e e , and need not have been shared by every m e m b e r of the early staff in order to have
'The Mapping of North America'
47
profoundly redirected the course of professionalization in North American anthropology. 4.1 The Myth Concordance O n e of the Bureau's first projects, albeit abortive, was a classification of North American mythology; the First Annual Report included a summary by Powell. Although the Director moved on to other subjects, the concordance was pursued by Jeremiah Curtin between 1883 and 1892. Curtin, primarily a diplomat and literary translator, joined the Bureau to implement "a systematic study of our Indian languages" (Schafer 1940:311). Most of his time, h o w ever, was spent collecting myths which he believed would reveal the mental systems of various American Indian groups (Curtin to Powell, 18 N o v . 1883: B A E ) , the synthesis to be framed in evolutionary terms (Curtin, quoted in Schafer 1940:306): Mythology and philology taken together form a science bearing the same relation to the history of the h u m a n mind that geology does to the history of the earth [...] so in mythology, folklore, and languages of nations w e find stereotype impresses of the mental conditions of these nations at successive periods... [Each language] has a system of thought, an entire philosophy of things. Curtin did not publish most of his vocabulary and myth collections, although they have been utilized by later scholars (Curtin 1898). Curtin's most ambitious project was an indexed collection of world myths (to Powell, 15 Feb. 1882: B A E ) . His application for Bureau funds was backed by his Harvard classmate, John Fiske (1842-1901), a prominent American mythologist (Fiske to Powell, 21 April 1882: B A E ) . W h e n Curtin failed to carry out his massive task, the Bureau did not pursue his program, even within North America. The project would be picked up by Boas and his students a generation later. 4.2 Linguistic Manuscripts The more than 600 manuscripts that Powell brought from the Smithsonian in 1879, to which he continued to add, constituted the most valuable physical property of the Bureau (19th A R for 1897-98, 1901: xxxi). M c G e e (in Goode 1897:380) emphasized this value: The greater part of the material used in classifying the fifty-nine [linguistic] stocks and over eight hundred tribes above enumerated was collected by collaborators of the Bureau. N o other linguistic collection of comparable extent
48
Chapter 4 and variety is k n o w n to exist; and since the material w a s recorded in large part by trained linguists, and since all the languages and stocks represent a widely distributed people in the simpler stages of intellectual development, the Bureau collection is invaluable to students of the origin and growth of language.
The collection was intended for use by the staff. M u c h of the material could not be published because it was fragmentary or overly technical for government publications (15th A R for 1893-94, 1897, p. lxxxii): "While the amount of linguistic material published is not voluminous, the manuscripts constantly accessible for purposes of study are abundant — richer, it is believed, than for any other body of linguistic records of a primitive people". Powell apparently conflated 'the American Indian' with a generic 'primitive people'. Manuscripts were carefully sequestered for exclusive use of staff and collaborators. The Bureau w a s a research organization, not a resource for outside scholars (Hodge 1907:1179): " M a n y of the manuscripts in the archives [...] have been consulted in the preparation of the Handbook, but as they are not readily accessible to students outside of Washington they are not included in this list." N o other institution or individual had access to so m u c h American linguistic material. In practice, responsible anthropologists were permitted occasionally to consult these manuscripts to supplement their o w n researches. 4.3
Bibliographies Powell conceived the idea of extensive bibliographies of North American Indians early in the Bureau's history (to Hale, 12 April 1881: B A E ) . Originally, the bibliography w a s a record of titles available for office use (Powell to Trumbull, 15 June 1880: B A E ) . But, w h e n the vocabularies were examined and classified as well, Powell considered it of "general linguistic interest". The bibliographic part of Powell's effort to prepare a synopsis of the languages and dialects of North America and a m a p of geographical distributions was delegated to James Constantine Pilling, formerly an employee of the Geological Survey, whose bibliographic labours occupied his spare time as clerk and disbursing agent of the Bureau and Geological Survey. The rest of Powell's staff were decidedly less enthusiastic about this armchair research, though grateful for access to the results. Pilling w a s somewhat loath to arrange his materials according to the tentative linguistic classification of the Bureau but finally concluded that
'The Mapping of North America'
49
indexing by tribe (before completion of the Synonymy) was too indefinite (Pilling to Eames, 1 Dec. 1882: B A E ) . Publications thus refer to the Bureau's linguistic m a p in progress, although Pilling himself never worked on the linguistic classification. Thefirstversion of the bibliography appeared in 1885; the Proof-Sheets, covering all linguistic families in North America, were distributed to collaborators for revision, with these appearing in separate volumes for each major stock — the Eskimo, Siouan, Iroquoian, Muskhogean, Algonkian, Athabaskan, Chinookan, Salishan and Wakashan were completed between 1887 and 1894. Pilling himself realized that the task was impossible, though whatever was completed would be useful. H e commented to John Gilmary Shea (11 April 1881: B A E ) : "If I ever print m y Bibliography I should like to insert a note telling w h y the work was neverfinished".Pilling died in 1895, leaving 49 stocks without the planned revisions (Holmes to Dougherty, 5 Dec. 1903: B A E ) . Considerable progress was made, however, by cooperative effort. Pilling was surprised by the patience with which unrecognized collaborators gave of their time and energy (to Eames, 11 July 1882: B A E ) . Bureau staff wrote to acquaintances, government officials, missionaries and private scholars. Pilling consulted sources ranging from the Jesuit Relations to the Cherokee Advocate. Whatever their degree of completeness, the bibliographies were invaluable in a period when each scholar previously had to find his/her o w n w a y among scattered and unsystematic descriptive materials. ( C o m m e r cial reprinting of the Pilling bibliographies in 1968 attests to their continuing use.) Pilling was not the only person to recognize the utility of such a project. John Bartlett (1820-1905) wrote to Powell (25 A u g . , 1879: B A E ) that he wanted to prepare an extensive bibliography of American Indians excluding linguistic items; G . Stanley Hall (Powell to Hall, 8 Oct. 1884: B A E ) envisioned a bibliography of American myths and folklore; the Royal Society of London wanted help in preparing an international bibliography (Hodge to the Royal Society, 1 June 1894: B A E ) ; Samuel Barrett (to Hodge, 29 N o v . 1910: B A E ) thought the Bureau should sponsor a general North American bibliography, perhaps even with a worldwide extension. In each case, the Bureau was forced to respond that it lacked resources and personnel for such ambitious projects. Pilling's bibliographies were produced within a broad mandate to systematize knowledge of the American Indian. Even the limited project pursued by Pilling underscored the difficulties of comprehensiveness and
50
Chapter 4
justified the relegation of bibliographic work to an instrumental role in other systematizing projects, particularly the linguistic classification. 4.4
'Introduction to the Study of Indian Languages' Powell's Introduction to the Study of Indian Languages first appeared in 1877. O n the basis of his o w n fieldwork and study of American Indian vocabularies, Powell extended the vocabulary list of George Gibbs (18151873) in 1863 and proposed a n e w standardized alphabet. The second edition in 1880 placed more emphasis on morphology, attempting to elicit concepts corresponding to European parts of speech. Powell (1880:70) believed that languages were organized by their grammatical forms and that adequate description required both morphological and lexical evidence, although genetic classification should rely on lexicon. Further revisions of both vocabulary and alphabet were planned. During the 1890s, Dorsey prepared several hundred questions for a third edition. Boas initially justified his Handbook of American Indian Languages as a revision of the 1880 edition. Boas recognized the value of this work, requesting copies for his students in thefieldas late as 1898. The alphabet, originally devised by William Dwight Whitney (18271894) of Yale, caused considerable consternation in the Bureau. Powell intended to set a standard to be followed in all the work of the Bureau, although Whitney warned that suchrigiditywas untenable in the description of particular languages. Whitney objected to Gatschet's phonetic suggestions but demurred to Powell (25 July 1877: B A E ) : "you have no good reason for regarding and treating m e as an authority in these matters, [...] questions of alphabetizing are questions of expediency and compromise". T h e Bureau staff incorrectly attributed the problems to Whitney and never really adopted the system. For example, Gatschet complained to Powell that he could not record Indian languages by a "scientific alphabet" (3 A u g . 1879: B A E ) : Professor Whitney is an excellent Orientalist, but knowing nothing of the phonetics of American languages he could not be expected to draw up an alphabet setting at rest all requirements in this line. There is perhaps nobody in the world living n o w w h o could do it. Despite the desirability of standardized forms, Gatschet'sfieldworkhad convinced him that the study of particular languages would require changes in any abstract scheme and that room must be left for appropriate modifications. Symbols had to be acceptable to the Government Printing Office, which
'The Mapping
of North
America'
51
objected to preparing linguistic material in any form. Gatschet w a s not the only dissenter: Boas developed his o w n scheme for recording Northwest coast languages and w a s unenthusiastic about the Bureau alphabet and early 20th century attempts to revise it. Powell circulated his Introduction widely a m o n g investigators in contact with Indians. It w a s "a portable course in ethnology for the untutored but zealous traveller" (Hinsley 1981:161). Like M o r g a n ' s kinship questionnaire and in the Smithsonian tradition, it w a s meant to be used b y untrained observers. Indeed, Powell agreed with Gibbs (1863:7) that: " T h e work, moreover, is a mere matter of observation, to be accomplished with the requisite expenditure of time and labor to almost any degree of minute accuracy that m a y be desired". Dorsey looked for individuals working o n American languages and noted those w h o had not advanced too far to change their recording system (Dorsey to Pilling, 17 N o v . 1879: B A E ) . Materials received by the Bureau were often returned with a copy of the Bureau alphabet (Pilling to Croft, 13 Oct. 1882: B A E ) . Powell summarized his o w n views (to Grayson, 5 June 1885: B A E ) : While it may be easier for you to prepare your manuscript in the Muscogee alphabet, I think it would be of greater advantage in the long run, and afford you more satisfaction to use the alphabet as prepared by the Bureau. O f course, modifications such as would better convey special sounds of the Muscogee tongue can be used. In addition to Boas's students, the Bureau staff used the Introduction, with its standard vocabulary items. Survey fieldwork by H e n s h a w , Curtin, Dorsey, Hewitt, Gatschet and others w a s expected to produce just enough information to specify linguistic affiliation. T h e earlier Gibbs vocabularies suggested " m o r e remote affinities must be sought in a wider research, demanding a degree of acquaintance with their languages beyond the reach of transient visitors" (Gibbs M S : B A E ) . T h e Introduction w a s designed for broad-scale 'mapping' projects and w a s less well adapted to careful study of single languages. 4.5 The Definition of Linguistic Families With the framework for acquisition of linguistic data provided b y the alphabet and vocabulary list in the Introduction, Powell turned to linguistic classification. Detailed description of particular languages w a s of little interest to h i m . Increases in amount and quality of American linguistic data,
52
Chapter 4
largely through the efforts of Powell and his associates, however, permitted a more "comprehensive and satisfactory" classification (6th A R for 1884-85, 1888, p. xliv). Albert Gallatin's classifications of 1836 and 1848 had exhausted the results of 'direct comparison of vocabularies' and he wanted to elucidate the development of languages. In fact, however, Powell followed Gallatin's emphasis on observational comparison of fairly closely related languages. The innovation of the Bureau was primarily in the number of languages covered, especially in the West, where its fieldwork provided for thefirsttime sufficient information to support a systematization effort. In 1877, Powell added to Powers' Tribes of California an appendix of vocabularies (on the basis of manuscripts obtained from the Smithsonian) but did not indicate which items he thought were cognates. W h e n his interests turned to linguistic classification, however, vocabularies alone declined in usefulness. Publications were intended as "models for subsequent reports" and were expected to "form a sound foundation for subsequent research;" analysis as well as fact collection was necessary. T h e Bureau had been collecting linguistic data since its establishment (Gatschet 1879), and Powell (1891:xxxvi) felt an obligation to systematize this material. Moreover, the accumulating body of reliable information about American languages was already concentrated with the Bureau, between its manuscript collection and on-going staff researches. The 1891 linguistic classification was intended to be tentative. A s in other collaborative projects, Powell hoped for feedback and subsequent reformulation (Powell 1891:216): The author has delayed the present publication somewhat, expecting to supplement it with another paper on the characteristics of those languages which have been most fully recorded, but such supplementary paper has already grown too large for this place and is yet unfinished, while the necessity for the speedy publication of the present results seems to be imperative. The needs of the Bureau of Ethnology in directing the work of the linguists employed in it, and especially in securing the organizing the labor of a large body of collaborators throughout the country, call for this publication at the present time. Although revisions of the linguistic classification would take place largely outside the Bureau, Powell's other unfinished goals, at least in linguistics, were largely achieved by Boas's Handbook of American Indian Languages (see Chap. 10).
'The Mapping of North America'
53
At least some of the Bureau staff, however, regarded the classification as a final product. The Bureau's unsigned biographical sketch of Gatschet refers to Powell's determination to "reexamine" all the linguistic stocks "to establish this standing on a true and undeniable basis, so that the tribes w h o speak them m a y be assigned their definite and irrevocable position in the array of American nations". Publication of the classification was postponed repeatedly pending further fieldwork on the ubiquitous "undetermined problems" (9th A R for 1887-88, 1892, p. xxxv). Although Powell insisted his classification w a s tentative, later scholars have failed to acknowledge the extreme limitations of the evidence on which it was based. For example, Hoijer (1904-1976) in 1946 used 55 stocks, refusing to recognize later connections for which more evidence had been presented than for most of Powell's units. A s further consolidations were proposed, the Powell classification was enshrined as representing conservative consensus, regardless of the evidence for particular cases. Before turning to the classification itself and the collaborative work behind it, let us examine Powell's o w n goals for it. Kroeber (1876-1960; 1905b:579) stressed the practical utility of the enterprise: "What Powell did was to seize clearly the conception of the necessity of some classification, and of the inevitability of this being on a linguistic basis, and then to carry through his purpose rigorously, systematically, and completely". Other projects, particularly the S y n o n y m y , to which Powell devoted great energy depended on the completion of at least a provisional linguistic classification. T h e S y n o n y m y was intended to collate variant names, locations and sources for all North American tribes. "[D]elay has been occasioned chiefly by the fundamental necessity of defining linguistic stocks or families into which all tribes must be primarily divided" (7th A R for 188-86, 1891, p. xxxv). Problems of ethnological classification (ultimately of reservation policy and Congressional budgetary approval) were more salient than c o m plexities of historical linguistics. Powell stressed "the accumulation of data, rather than any problems of comparative linguistics" (Sturtevant 1959:196). Significantly, Powell's classification was thefirstserious attempt to fill the blank spaces on the m a p of North America and thefirstto use solely linguistic criteria. Vexing problems were presented by the number of totally isolated languages in America. Powell placed each in a separate linguistic family. In fact, it has even been suggested (Swadesh 1967:281) that: "these m e n did not ordinarily set d o w n the points of contact they noted between one
Chapter 4
54
and another languages." Certainly this was not the major goal. Powell was not interested in distant genetic relationships (to Faris, 12 April 1888: B A E ) : T o establish connection between languages it is necessary to compare extensive vocabularies, to study the phonetic systems and to analyze roots of words. T o limit comparison to a large number of languages having no possible affinities can lead to no beneficial results, and tends only to confuse and mislead. Powell's classification was based on explicit theoretical assumptions which were listed in the text (1891:216): 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6)
the classification was deliberately conservative; m a n y cases of doubtful assignment were present; all languages contained borrowed material; there were probably more languages in "primitive" times; all languages had diverse histories; primitive languages changed slowly.
These postulates already influenced h o w Powell would use his linguistic classification. His goal was to elucidate "the history and laws of development" of languages and of linguistic development in general (14th A R for 1892-93, 1896, p. xl). Powell ostensibly believed that American languages formed "a class entirely distinct from any others in the world" (Powell to Morris, 28 April 1896: B A E ) . In practice, he was more interested in differences within North America which might reflect different stages in evolution. T h e notion of a single type of American language ('incorporating' or 'polysynthetic') was well established in an earlier Americanist linguistics, particularly in the work of Gallatin, Peter Stephen Duponceau (1760-1844), Pickering and Brinton. T h e logic of Morgan's postulated single type of kinship system is parallel. Powell believed that the original character of a language was preserved in its vocabulary; thus genetic classification should rely primarily on lexical evidence (1891: 87,88): Grammatical similarities are not supposed to furnish evidence of cognation, but to be phenomena in part relating to state of nature and in part adventitious [...] Grammatic structure is but a phase or accident of growth and not a primordial element of languages. The roots of a language are its most permanent characteristics, and while the words which are formed from them m a y change so as to obscure their elements or in some cases even to lose them, it seems that they are never lost from view but can be recovered in large part. The grammatic structure or plan of a language is forever changing, and in this respect the languages m a y become entirely transformed.
'The Mapping of North America'
55
G r a m m a r was supposed to provide evidence of the evolutionary stage reached by a group, but its susceptibility to change meant that languages might show mixed evolutionary features (Powell 1891:139): The languages are very unequally developed in their several parts. L o w gender systems appear with high tense systems, highly evolved case systems with slightly developed m o d e systems, and there is scarcely any one of these languages [...] which does not exhibit archaic devices in its grammar. Powell believed he k n e w the evolutionary sequence by which h u m a n language developed to its ultimate efficiency in English. The amount of variation in American Indian languages m a d e such a simple unilinear scale impossible to apply, since grammatical type did not correlate with level of social and political organization. The notion of a 'mixed' language due to instability of grammatical form was an evasion which preserved the evolutionary sequence, at least in theory. Thus, Powell found grammar interesting from the point of view of the mental development of American Indians but declined to consider it in linguistic classification. Powell's classification began with set assumptions about the history of language and the number of linguistic families in North America. H e realized that a conservative classification implied that some families would later be fused, but believed that new and unrelated languages would still be discovered. This would maintain approximately the same number of families "at least under the present methods of linguistic analysis" (1891:102). Each stock was composite as a result of the blending of peoples. Because Powell did not discuss innovative processes within language, divergence of related languages through borrowing from their neighbours became salient. Powell envisioned more languages when people lived independently in small groups which had been progressively incorporated within larger political units (17th A R for 1895-96, 1898, p. lii). Linguistic classification thus reflected the social evolution of the American tribes. Languages began in a kind of pristine isolation and became more similar through absorption from contiguous tribes (Powell 1891: 141). Indeed, differentiation of dialects into languages was directly comparable to organic specialization and biological differentiation, since a language spoken over a wider area was deemed clearly superior. Progress toward mutual intelligibility could only reflect degeneration in the level of social organization (Powell to Taylor, 23 Feb. 1881: B A E ) . Indeed, culture growth through blending was predicted by Powell's evolutionary framework (17th A R for 1895-96, 1898, p. xxxv):
56
Chapter 4 But the conspicuous fact of the aboriginal American tongues is their diversity, a diversity so wide as to imply essentially independent development [...]. T h e present tendency is toward diffusion through imitation, and this tendency is so far preponderant that the vast collections of records of aboriginal languages are little m o r e than records of linguistic blending; so that the well-ascertained course of linguistic development is toward interchange and thence to ultimate union. In primitive society, language grows in two ways: on the one hand there is a steady enrichment and differentiation due to the coining of expressions for n e w ideas; on the other hand there is a spasmodic enrichment and modification, both in terms and in grammatic structure, produced by the shock of contact, [....] At the same time both the lexic and the structural forms [...] are simplified through the natural tendency toward economy in expression [...]. It is accordingly a necessary inference that a large number of distinct, albeit simple if not inchoate, tongues originally existed in North America and that the subsequent history has been chiefly one of linguistic integration.
Powell's theory of political development was formulated in his studies of social organization in the tradition of Morgan; it was only incidentally applied to language. Hewitt applied a similar mechanism to his studies of Iroquois cosmology (18th A R for 1896-97, 1899, p. xliv). Originally independent myths had blended more often than they had differentiated, "so that myth, like the speech in which it is crystallized, is a composite of m a n y elements". Whatever its sources, Powell's view of the difficulties of preparing a linguistic classification to accurately reflect culture history w a s startlingly similar to that Franz Boas formulated a generation later in response to the efforts of his former students to define more distant relationships of linguistic families. Like Powell, Boas was interested in linguistics primarily as a tool for ethnology. Again like Powell, he preferred a conservative classification. H e even stressed the areal diffusion of grammatical traits, arguing that resulting similarities between two languages could not be distinguished from those which were genetic. But he did not distinguish the causes of grammatical and lexical phenomena. Powell, in sum, justified his theory of culture history within a context of American uniqueness in the evolutionary history of mankind as a whole, whereas Boas w a s concerned with the culture histories of particular peoples. Linguistic classification had ethnographic implications for both Powell and Boas, although Powell envisioned a useful classification of Indian tribes and Boas an aid to description of particular culture histories. Powell's point of view guided the researches of the Bureau in producing its linguistic classifica-
'The Mapping of North America'
57
tion, but Boas's view had no comparable influence on changes in the Bureau classification formulated by his students during the early 20th century. Rather, Boas remained conservative in his attitude toward classificatory problems while his students, especially Edward Sapir, turned to the definition of broader relationships a m o n g the stocks of the Powell classification (e.g., Sapir 1921 a, b; Darnell 1971 a,b; Darnell & H y m e s 1986). 4.6 Brinton's Linguistic Classification That Powell had choices in procedure and theory is illustrated by the appearance of another linguistic classification in 1891 with a different approach to the same problem. W h e r e Powell relied on lexical evidence for genetic relationship, Daniel Brinton preferred grammatical criteria (1885:x): Whenever the material permitted it, I have ranked the grammatic structure of a language superior to its lexical elements in deciding upon relationship. In this I follow the precepts and example of students in the Aryan and Semitic stocks, although the methods have been rejected by some w h o have written on American tongues. A s for myself, I a m abidingly convinced that the morphology of any language whatever is its most permanent and characteristic feature. At the end of The American Race, in which he presented his o w n linguistic classification, Brinton stressed that grammar was often unknown; thus, by default, he relied on basic vocabulary items for the little studied languages of South America (1891:344): The linguistic classification of American tribes is at present imperfect in m a n y regions on account of the incomplete information about their tongues. A proper comparison of languages or dialects includes not merely the vocabulary, but the grammatical forms and the phonetic variations which the vocal elements undergo in passing from one form of speech to another. In some respects, the morphology is more indicative of relationship than the lexicon of tongues; and it is in these grammatical aspects that w e are peculiarly poorly off when w e approach American dialects. Yet it is also likely that the tendency of late years has been to underestimate the significance of merely lexical analogies. T h e vocabulary, after all, must be our main stand-by in such an undertaking. This disclaimer of his o w n principle, however, appears only in the appendix to a text summarizing conclusions derived primarily from grammatical evidence. Thus, Brinton's divergence from Powell rests primarily on reasons for specific decisions. Brinton's classification was in principle m u c h less conservative than Powell's. H e discussed only 13 major units for North America, though several
58
Chapter 4
of these were primarily cultural and geographical (Pueblos, Northwest coast, California). H e also referred to 59 stocks (i.e., the Bureau classification) which he divided into five geographic groups "for convenience" (Brinton 1891:57). T h e degree of genetic relationship reflected in the 13 units is thus different from Powell's. Areal and genetic features are not clearly distinguished. Brinton proposed to accept some genetic relationships which Powell rejected, although these were by no means sufficient to reduce the total number of stocks to 13. H e combined Gallatin's Pawnee and Caddoe, joined Catawba to Yuchi, Natchez, Chetimacha, and Adaize and was the first to relate Chontal, Seri and Hokan (for which Kroeber presented detailed evidence in the early 20th century). Brinton briefly considered that K i o w a and Shoshonean were related, but concluded that evidence was insufficient; this relationship was proposed again by Harrington years later. S o m e comparisons were less fortunate, for example, Atakapa and Uto-Aztecan or Hopi and Navajo. Brinton accepted superficial similarities more easily w h e n the classification m a d e geographic sense; he, like Powell, saw linguistic classification as a means to organize the ethnographic diversity of North America. The major instance in which Powell and Brinton m a d e different decisions, however, was in evaluation of the evidence for Uto-Aztecan. Brinton was intrigued by this family, which included the range of development within the American continent, from the root-digging Utes to the Nahuatl empires. H e was willing to accept this connection partially because he believed that the American Indian comprised a single cultural and political (evolutionary) type. "The learned and indefatigable" Johann Carl Eduard Buschmann (1805-1880), whose evidence Brinton cited (1890:23), had failed to connect Sonoran to Nahuatl on the one hand and to Shoshonean on the other because he was obsessed with demonstrating the northern origin of the Aztecs (Lamb 1964: 114). Brinton thus used Buschmann's o w n data, particularly grammatical, to deduce conclusions implicit in it. Powell, committed to relying on lexical evidence, rejected this relationship. In fact, he cited Nahuatl as part of Buschmann's family, apparently never examining the original German. Powell's source was probably Brinton, w h o coined the term Uto-Aztecan but presented very slight evidence for the connection. Skepticism, therefore, was not unjustified (Lamb 1964:120): A short comparative word list was given in support of the relationship of the languages. It w a s m u c h too short to offer convincing evidence, and since
'The Mapping of North America'
59
Powell's work was on the whole more careful than Brinton's, those w h o consulted only Powell and Brinton could hardly be blamed if they rejected the Uto-Aztecan stock. The Brinton classification is intriguing historically because of its relationship to the linguistic work of the Bureau. H o d g e (1931:100) recalled that the Powell classification w a s rushed into print because of competition with Brinton's The American Race. Kroeber (1960:4-5) explicitly contrasted the two classifications: There was some conscious competition between Powell's classification and D . G . Brinton, whose American Race appeared in 1891. It was [...] a work of quite a different sort from Powell's monograph, although it did group m a n y languages [...]. H e gave only tiny samples of evidence, insufficient to be sure; but then Powell wisely published none. A s early as 1885, Brinton had requested the current Bureau classification of tribes, whether "by linguistic stocks or otherwise" (to Pilling, 12 June 1885: B A E ) . Pilling's apologetic reply (13 June 1885: B A E ) m a d e it clear that the Bureau's ongoing research would not be available to Brinton; despite having m a d e contributions to Pilling's bibliographies, he w a s considered a competitor rather than a collaborator: I regret to have to say that the linguistic classification is still unfinished — indeed in so unsatisfactory a condition that it would scarcely be intelligible to those not engaged in its compilation. It is a slow affair, as you m a y well imagine, and I fear it will be some time yet before it is available for use. In 1890, just before presenting his o w n classification (written as a course of lectures before the A c a d e m y of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia between 1884 and 1890), Brinton wrote a series of letters to Henshaw about details of classification. H e requested a classification of Pacific coast stocks, noting that he was preparing a list of linguistic families for use in his lectures (1 A u g . 1890: B A E ) . Four days later, he asked about Cherokee and Iroquois, Apache and Navaho, and Kiowa: "These are m y inquiries about which m y authorities do not quite satisfy m e . " Ten days later, he wanted to k n o w about Beothukan, San Antonio, Coahuiltecan, Caronkaway, United States Shoshonean and the Texas coast stocks. In his published classification, Brinton acknowledged Henshaw's aid with the Northwest coast classification (reflecting the work of Boas for the Bureau) and for "various other suggestions" (Brinton 1891:xii). H e then indicated that he had not used the Bureau classification, with the implication
Chapter 4
60
that he was not permitted to do so. Correspondence in the Bureau archives indicates that this is not entirely accurate. Brinton had written Henshaw (7 N o v . 1890: B A E ) indicating his interest: " H o w is the m a p of North American languages getting on? Is the classification of the Bureau yet completed, and could I have a sight of the proofs, or, if not that far along, of the M S copy?" Brinton's next letter (15 N o v . 1890: B A E ) indicates that the decision was his
own: I a m m u c h obliged to you for the courteous offer [...] about the m a p , etc. At first, I was inclined to c o m e on and look it over; but on second thoughts, I think I had better not. T h e information I wish to gain could be m a d e public soon in m y lectures, and perhaps in printed reports from them, and this, I can readily see, might not be agreeable to the Bureau. It would, for this reason, be better for m e not to see the m a p ; as even if I confined m y publication to matters already in m y possession, some members of the Bureau might think I had learned them by the facilities you offer, and I had refrained from giving credit. There are, in fact, only a few points in the ethnology of the United States area about which I a m m u c h in doubt.
H e then asked about Comecrudo, Choctaw, Eskimo and Aleut. The Brinton classification indicates that Powell and his staff were far from the only ones interested in the classification of American languages at this time. The Bureau had an advantage in its access to manuscript materials and in the presence of a number of linguists whose cooperative efforts at fieldwork and library research could be applied to the linguistic classification. Dating of particular items in the Powell and Brinton classifications becomes crucial in establishing priorities, since both were published in the same year. Predecessors of the Powell classification within the Bureau suggest that it was completed in substantiallyfinishedform before Brinton's. 4.7 The Authorship of the Powell Classification The 1891 Bureau linguistic classification appeared under Powell's n a m e but was described by him as a cooperative effort. "The task [...] is of great magnitude, and in its accomplishment an army of scholars must be employed" (Powell 1891:216). Powell's personal contribution was to recognize the need for classification and to ensure its place among the other researches of the Bureau. The project had been important to the Director for a number of years and had taken its final shape gradually. T h e 1877 Geological Survey Report (quoted in the 1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p . xiv) noted that "a tentative
'The Mapping of North America'
61
classification of the linguistic families of the United States has been prepared" with the aid of several collaborators. In 1880, the Tenth Census referred to Powell's linguistic classification which "had been in tentative outline for several years" (quoted in Stegner 1954:268). Vocabularies in the C N A E added factual knowledge about West coast languages. Indeed, Powell personally prepared the vocabulary lists for the Powers volume on California, using Smithsonian manuscripts. In 1877, Gatschet, already employed by Powell, had classified the Pacific coast languages on the basis of the Powers vocabularies (Powell 1891:99). A n unsigned biographical sketch in the B u reau archives indicates that Powell intended Gatschet to pursue this goal: early in 1877 the rich collections of Indian manuscripts in the Smithsonian Institution, prevalently of a linguistic import, were placed at M r . Gatschet's disposal. The first task n o w incumbent upon him was to arrange them according to the linguistic families to which they belonged. The other linguist of the early Bureau staff was J. O w e n Dorsey. In 1885, Henshaw and M o o n e y published a manuscript titled "Linguistic Families of the Indian Tribes North of Mexico, with a Provisional List of the Principal Tribal N a m e s and Synonyms". The Synonymy, a key part of Powell's plan for summarizing existing knowledge of North American Indians, was prepared by James M o o n e y (Bass 1954, Moses 1984), a newspaper reporter w h o had collected such information from the age of twelve. T h e linguistic classification was attributed to Henshaw. O f course, this is an oversimplification, since Powell's interest in the subject began long before Henshaw worked on it. Although Henshaw systematized m u c h of the prior work of the Bureau staff, Dorsey and Gatschet did most of the relevant fieldwork. Gatschet considered himself a co-author (to Powell, 21 April 1884: B A E ) . Powell (1891:142) noted his debt to these two linguists "for the preparation of m a n y comparative lists necessary to my work" [emphasis added]. Goddard's review of American linguistics (1914:559) cited them as the major contributors to the classification; he valued the actual work on the languages over decisions about relationship. T o Powell as well, assessment of the evidence was not especially crucial (Sturtevant 1959:198): For this sort of relationship, publication of the evidence was hardly necessary [...]. Powell was quite careful to give credit for the collection of vocabularies and for work on etymology and mapping, but he tended to pass over the actual comparisons without giving specific credit [...] the difficult matter was to obtain
62
Chapter 4 the vocabularies; once these were in hand, simple juxtaposition was all that was required and this could have been done by almost anyone, and certainly was done in different instances by almost all the early staff [...].
Henshaw was responsible for the administrative work of compiling the classification. H e took charge of the S y n o n y m y in 1885 "in accordance with the plans submitted" (7th A R for 1885-86, 1891, p. xxxv). Because the S y n o n y m y presupposed a linguistic classification, Henshaw also prepared this. His autobiography, written years later, noted extensive linguistic work during the 1880s which "I had planned and been put in charge of, and which, with the assistance of several members of the Bureau, was completed and published in 1885" (1919:56). At the time, he noted (1889:197): "For the past fifteen years Major Powell and his assistants of the Bureau of Ethnology, with the aid of m a n y collaborators in various parts of the country, have been accumulating vocabularies by means of which to classify Indian languages". Letters of inquiry on American languages were referred to Henshaw as a matter of course. H e also decided where additional fieldwork was needed. For example, he sent a reluctant Dorsey to Oregon to collect survey vocabularies. Brinton corresponded with Henshaw, not Powell, in line with the delegation of authority in the Bureau. The Powell classification was important in American linguistics because it established a baseline from which future classifications had to proceed. T h e authorship of the classification was thus an important issue for later linguists and anthropologists using the results to determine. Early 20th-century scholars recognized that Powell had hot produced the classification singlehandedly. Sapir's review of the work of the Bureau (1917b) referred to 'the Powell classification,' the quotations indicating his understanding of its multiple authorship. Kroeber, whose interest was in systematizing anthropological terminology in the early 20th century, stressed the role of Henshaw, whose biological training m a y have been the source of the principles of synonymy and priority of nomenclature used in the Bureau classification. Not long after the classification appeared, Kroeber commented (1905b:580): It is well k n o w n that Powell did not carry out the work of this undertaking. Another hand, that of a scholar-administrator, was necessary for the fulfillment and realization of the plan [...]. That he was not by training or profession an anthropologist will m a k e his distinction all the greater. But it was Powell's mind that first conceived the idea of a classification [...] and it was Powell's will and character that held to the idea [...].
'The Mapping of North America'
63
Kroeber wrote to Hodge (9 N o v . 1905: A L K ) urging recognition of Henshaw's role in the classification: I a m not so situated here as to find out definitely anything as to the real authorship of Powell's work. I had always understood that the m a n w h o was responsible for the work was Henshaw and he himself has since stated this to m e quite explicitly. If I a m correct, the work was done by a number of m e n , including Henshaw himself, under Henshaw's direction according to the general plans of Powell which he had not been able to carry out, with an understanding that the acknowledged responsibility for the work was to be entirely Powell's [...]. I understand, for instance, that while the general idea of a classification was Powell's, it was Henshaw w h o was really responsible for the principles of nomenclature [...]. Hodge's reply apparently did not satisfy Kroeber, since he referred later (1913:390) to Powell's classification "which, as is well known, was largely the result of the labors of H . W . Henshaw." Kroeber returned to the issue at the end of his life (1960:2-3), recounting conversations with Henshaw on the subject of authorship, probably around 1910 (Hymes 1961b: 15-16). Conflicting statements of authorship, however, are not contradictory as long as authorship is acknowledged to have meant different things to different people. There is no question that Powell conceived the project, nor that Henshaw implemented it. Nor is it in question that particular decisions resulted from fieldwork and library research by the Bureau staff. Sources of evidence for particular decisions of acceptance or rejection varied greatly. Henshaw m a d e only a few changes in the 1885 classification before it appeared in print in 1891 (Hymes M S a ) . The changes, and the apparent reasons for them, illustrate the cooperative nature of the Bureau's linguistic work. For example, the connection of Catawba and Siouan was proposed by Gatschet in 1881. Powell (1891: 188) was convinced by Dorsey's reexamination of the evidence between 1885 and 1891. Kwakiutl and Nootka were combined into Wakashan on the basis of Boas's fieldwork on the Northwest coast, sponsored at different times by the Bureau and the B A A S . Natchez and Taensa were merged into Natchesan, presumably in response to Brinton's exposure of the Taensa language as an elaborate forgery (Brinton 1890). Powell's source for Aleut as an unintelligible dialect of Eskimo was perhaps George Dall, whose work on Eskimo was published by him in the C N A E . The 1891 classification, however, gives no source for joining the two. The two cases in which Powell separated previous families both resulted from the 1888 fieldwork of Henshaw in California. Henshaw confirmed
64
Chapter 4
Curtin's opinion that Esselenian and Salinan, Costanoan and Moquelumnan (Miwokan) were distinct (Powell 1891: 139, 148). The latter decision was in opposition to Gatschet, whose notation on the Bureau manuscript dealing with these languages states that Mallery, Hoffman, M o o n e y , Hewitt and Dorsey agreed (Dorsey, in a marginal note on the same document, disclaimed this opinion). In any case, Powell was interested in lexical correspondences and followed Henshaw's more conservative opinion. But the 1891 classification carefully chronicled the history of previous classifications and noted that Gatschet had favoured connections in both instances whereas Powell had followed Henshaw. Four n e w stocks were added to the 1885 classification. The distinctiveness of Beothukan emerged from Gatschet's work in the 1880s (Powell 1891:133-134): M r . Gatschet has been able to examine a m u c h larger and more satisfactory body of material, and although neither in amount nor quality is the material sufficient to permit final and satisfactory deductions, yet so far as it goes it shows that the language is quite distinct from any of the Algonquian dialects, and in fact from any other American tongue. Chimarikan was separated from Porno on the basis of Curtin's vocabularies collected by the Bureau. Karankawan was separated from Attakapan on the basis of insufficient evidence and the Bureau's failure to locate surviving speakers (1891:158). Gatschet's 1884 vocabulary had proved inconclusive. Tunica was defined as an independent family on the basis of Gatschet's vocabularies in 1886. Its earlier connection to Caddoan w a s rejected. Gatschet had suggested that Tunica, Shetimacha and Atakapan might be related before this fieldwork (Gatschet to Powell, 28 Feb. 1885: B A E ) . Powell rejected the conclusion but noted it as an area of possible later study. Powell did none of the fieldwork on which these decisions were based. The relative importance of Henshaw and Powell in reevaluating the vocabularies, particularly those of Gatschet, cannot be assessed readily. Probably, both m e n reviewed the evidence, sharing the conservative policy of Powell. Indeed, the 1891 classification includes several cases where evidence in favour of relationship is noted but deemed insufficient. Often, the rejected connections themselves had been proposed by Bureau staff: Moquelumnan and Costanoan, Esselenian and Salinan, Chimariko and Kalapuya (Porno), Shetimacha and Attakapa, Karankawa and Attakapa. Adaize and Caddoan, Shasta and A c h o m a w i were noted as possibly
'The Mapping of North America'
65
related. Both were united in the Bureau's 1903 revision of its classification. The only other revision accepted within the Bureau, the uniting of Natchez and Muskhogean, was dismissed by Gatschet in the 1880s, although Brinton had suggested it in 1863. T w o connections proposed by Boas — Haida and Tlingit, Salish and Wakashan — were both considered tentative. Powell also rejected Piman and Nahuatl, which Brinton had accepted and noted Tanoan and Shoshonean as possibly related. Both were accepted by later workers in America languages as conservative identifications. Gatschet had attributed Kiowa and Shoshonean similarities to "long associations of these peoples" (6th A R for 1884-85, 1888, p. xxv), while Powell had avoided forming "a decided opinion" (1891:198). Powell also suggested that Natchez and Chitimacha, Timuquana and Carib might eventually prove related. This series of rejected connections m a y be taken as a second Powell classification which posed problems for future fieldwork. Powell himself felt the stocks to be tentative and subject to revision. The connection of linguistic stocks which took place in the early 20th century drew on such previously proposed relationships, although without crediting Powell for his intended flexibility. S o m e Bureau linguistic work was not directed to classificatory problems. The only family on which detailed internal classification was possible was Siouan, Dorsey's specialty (e.g., Dorsey 1885). In 1879, the Bureau recognized eight dialects, including Tutelo as suggested by Horatio Hale and Catawba on the basis of Dorsey's analysis of the manuscripts (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xix). Biloxi was added to the Siouan family by Gatschet in 1887. Gatschet's specialization in comparative Algonquian "for the purpose of formulating a definite and satisfactory classification" (19th A R for 189798, 1900, p. xxv) was begun after the appearance of the 1891 Powell classification. Indeed, Gatschet (to Powell, 10 July 1894: B A E ) was surprised by the closeness of the relationship among the 40 or 50 dialects after working so long with languages where the very fact of relationship was in question. The least k n o w n languages at the time of the Powell classification were those of the west coast. Gatschet worked extensively on the Northwest coast, concluding that Coos was independent and that Shasta would prove to be related to A c h o m a w i . Powell (1891:210) rejected Gatschet's separation of Siuslaw and Yakonan on the basis of Dorsey's brief fieldwork in Oregon. Dorsey's work was done at Henshaw's insistence and relied heavily on
66
Chapter 4
Powell's Introduction of 1877 with its ready-made vocabularies. Nonetheless, he expanded the standard format to include more extensive verbal paradigms (DeMallie, p.c.)· Although Dorsey was a Siouan specialist, Powell used his results on a variety of other language families without questioning his conclusions. Hewitt worked on Northwest Coast languages, on the basis of manuscript collections. H e defended the c o m m o n history of Shahaptian, Molale-Cayuse, and later Klamath-Modoc (15th A R for 1893-94, 1897:3-4). Powell had rejected this connection in 1891 because lexical similarities were limited. M o r e extensive evidence for the connection was presented years later by Melville Jacobs (1902-1971), and Hewitt's work went virtually unrecognized. His particular evidence, however, was insufficient to establish relationship, and was often based on secondary sources w h o had not themselves studied the languages in question; multilingualism was confused with mutual intelligibility (Rigsby 1965:92; 1966:369). Powell did, however, accept Hewitt's evidence for the relationship of Cherokee and Iroquoian for which lexical evidence was available. H e accepted Hewitt's separation of Serian and Y u m a n , although Gatschet (1900: 558) had agreed with Brinton that they were probably related. Although Powell had intended to extend and correct the classification on the basis of further work by the Bureau and its collaborators, the 1891 results formalized previous knowledge of American Indian languages so systematically that the classification itself became the starting point for all future work. Acceptance of further relationships depended on willingness to consider genetic relationship as a problem more than on evidence for particular cases. For some, the Powell classification was sufficient for ethnographic purposes. For others, particularly Sapir, Kroeber and Dixon, the interesting problems were those of more distant relationships*. T h e Bureau had little part in the linguistic fieldwork, mostly in California and on the Northwest coast, which revised the 1891 classification over thefirsttwo decades of the 20th century. Hewitt (41st A R for 1919-20, 1928:8), like Powell and Henshaw, was not interested in remote genetic relationships and refused to accept the efforts of later workers to demonstrate further connections: In view of works recently published on the genetic relationship of certain linguistic stocks of California and other North American linguistic stocks, and as a result of a conference of the staff of the Bureau [...] on late linguistic work in California, M r . Hewitt carefully examined the methods and the evidence for
'The Mapping of North America'
67
relationships relating to the Y u m a n , the Serian, the Tequistlatecan, the Waicuran, the Shoshonean, the Lutuamian and the Waiilatpuan, claimed in recent publications by Doctor Radin and Doctor Kroeber. In no instance did he find that these authors had proved their case. With such an attitude, the Bureau was almost by definition excluded from the emerging synthesis of the early 20th-century work on consolidation of linguistic stocks of North America (cf. Goddard 1996).
Daniel Garrison Brinton (1837-1899) American Philosophical Society. Reprinted with permission.
Chapter 5
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
Powell's depiction of the Bureau mandate as "organizing anthropologic research in America" in the 1st A R for 1879-80 (1881:xiv) reflects the increasing professionalization of American anthropology under its auspices. The Bureau was one of thefirstinstitutions to provide full-time employment for a substantial number of anthropologists. Its scientific staff pursued their scientific researches, albeit within Powell's general guidelines. In practice, however, individual research was often delayed or modified to accommodate projects representing the effort of most of the staff over a prolonged period. Powell was particularly committed to the linguistic classification, tribal synonymy and tribal m a p , but most of the projects contributing to the "mapping of North America" drew on group resources. Powell (4th A R for 1882-83, 1886, p. xxvii) expressed the general intent to produce: an account of the particular character of the work of each person engaged therein, though [...] all of these are at times diverted from the special works mentioned to combine their exertions for purposes regarded as of immediate general importance. S o m e of the lines of study require both prolonged compilation and exhaustive discussion and delays occur by ascertained necessity for renewed research on points of difficulty. T h e results of the cooperative work were considered the product of the Bureau as a whole or even of Powell personally. Staff occasionally c o m plained about lack of credit for their o w n work (e.g., M c G e e to M o o n e y , 29 July 1893: B A E ) . Scientists outside the Bureau more often objected to the cooperative research projects. Kroeber's objection that Henshaw's contribution to the linguistic classification had been unfairly subordinated to Powell's was not unique. M c G e e ' s discussion of Bureau collaboration in the official history of the Smithsonian Institution went to some effort to justify the policy of group as well as individual research (in G o o d e 1897:371):
70
Chapter 5 This work w a s performed largely by Director Powell, w h o not only originated, but constantly coordinated the various lines of research, though collaborators were always encouraged to seek relations and educe principles, and to publish under their o w n names such results of their work as were not inconsistent with those of other investigators, for it was recognized that research is best promoted by encouraging the investigator. Such have been the methods of the Bureau; they are in no w a y peculiar.
In spite of the effort to maintain a balance, however, most staff members contributed considerable time and energy to cooperative enterprises. Even those most engrossed in their o w n specialties were drawn into such work. The most frequent objections came from Dorsey (to Pilling, 16 Dec. 1879: B A E ) , w h o refused to collect sign languages, because it took too m u c h time from his o w n researches. Dorsey, w h o felt that his job was insecure and preferred to concentrate on Siouan languages as m u c h as possible (DeMallie, p.c.), c o m mented laconically on one inquiry: "I k n o w nothing about the survey of the line between the United States and Canada" (1886: B A E ) . Dorsey, however, contributed significantly to the Synonymy and Bureau manuscript catalogue and did Oregon and Caddoan fieldwork for the linguistic classification. M u c h of the uniqueness of the Bureau contribution to late 19th-century American anthropology lies in Powell's coordination of the researches of his large staff. T h e overall purpose of 'mapping North America' drew on both individual and collective efforts, with institutional goals eclipsing idiosyncratic ones. 5.1 Problems in Professional Standards Early Bureau staff incorporated a great diversity of training, or lack of it. Formal anthropological education did not yet exist in 1879. Thus, m a n y early staff had difficulty meeting the increasinglyrigorousstandards of the professional competence which grew, ironically, in large part out of the work of the Bureau itself. The development of anthropology in other institutions and the accumulation within the Bureau of information about American Indians m a d e n e w standards feasible. The kind of research the Bureau could do during its early years was influenced strongly by the semi-professional background of m a n y staff and collaborators. Thus, individuals w h o had m a d e important contributions to the 'mapping of North America' later found themselves more peripheral to the work of the Bureau and to American anthropology generally. Perhaps least professional among the staff was Mrs. Erminnie Smith, w h o had no formal training and said of Powell that "association with you has
Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
71
changed entirely m y old orthodox way of thinking" (Smith to Powell, 3 N o v . 1881: B A E ) . Mrs. Smith had such difficulties with the government system of vouchers andfinancialrecords that she wasfinallyput on a fixed salary to expedite bookkeeping (Pilling to Smith, 15 Sept. 1880: B A E ) . Her lack of confidence about her o w n work on the mythology and languages of the Iroquois m a y have motivated her accusations that other Bureau employees encroached on her territory. W h e n Mrs. Smith died in 1886, the Bureau inherited her assistant, a partTuscarora Indian named J. N . B . Hewitt. Hewitt denigrated Mrs. Smith's work and insisted that he deserved a promotion (Hewitt to Pleasant, 24 Dec. 1886; Hewitt to Powell, 11 June 1886: B A E ) . Hewitt considered his o w n work to rest on a different basis than that of the other staff members. " H e excused his failure to turn in material on the grounds that he had been appointed in a peculiar manner as a sort of inside assistant and was not expected to furnish material like the rest of the staff' (Swanton to H y m e s , 14 March 1957). Hewitt's lack of productivity was proverbial, although Powell defended his contribution to the Bureau (to Langley, 1900-1901 budget: B A E ) : "his work has been conducted with great assiduity, and [...] he has acquired a noteworthy grasp of ethnic relations, his capabilities promising to place him in the leading rank among ethnologists as the results of his researches are published". The sense that his contribution might be related to his status as a Native American did not seem to be an issue (cf. Liberty 1978). In 1909, the requirements for Bureau staff positions had changed so m u c h that the Secretary of the Smithsonian decided Hewitt should be paid for manuscripts rather than by salary (as native 'informants' were often paid). Hewitt was warned by M c G e e (25 July 1909: B A E ) that he should stress his contributions to the cooperative projects of the Bureau rather than his unfinished linguistic researches. M c G e e lacked his former influence in the Bureau by 1909 but consoled Hewitt that Major Powell would never have permitted the value of his work to be questioned. Hewitt's self-justifications were that he never took his annual leaves, was wholly loyal to the Bureau and needed more fieldwork to complete his studies for publication (Hewitt to Holmes, 17 April 1909: B A E ) . A s the discipline's professionalism increased, Hewitt's position became increasingly anomalous (Walcott to Curtis, 16 Jan. 1911: B A E ) : M r . Hewitt has accumulated a large fund of information, but the trouble has been in getting it out of him. H e has had every opportunity to present the results
72
Chapter 5 of his studies for publication, but he seems so constituted that although he apparently devotes much time to his work, he lacks the systematic application necessary to the production of results. [Yet he expects] compensation at a higher rate than other members of the Bureau whose work is prolific of results.
The other m e m b e r of the early staff with difficulties over limited productivity was Albert S. Gatschet, whose work was usually described by the Director's Reports as "digesting" and "cataloguing" his field materials. Gatschet's fieldwork was extensive but Powell refused to publish it in the unsystematic form which Gatschet preferred (Powell to Gatschet, 14 Feb. 1895: B A E ) . At the founding the Bureau, Powell had been delighted by any information on little-known languages, but by 1895 he was interested only in reasonably complete materials on single languages. M c G e e refused to impose the n e w standards on Gatschet, insisting (to Boas, 1 March 1900: B A E ) that he had been "a sort of special collaborator" for Powell in his plan for a comprehensive monograph on American linguistics, stressing that Gatschet's work required critical editorial revision which could rarely be obtained. M c G e e felt Gatschet's significant contribution was the number of languages on which he had worked. Mooney' s obituary in the American Anthropologist (1907:565) listed: Achomawi, Adai, Alibamu, Apache, Arapaho, Attacapa, Bannock, Bidai, Biloxi, Caddo, Catawba, Cherokee, Cheyenne, Chickasaw, Chimariko, Choctaw, Chumash, Clackamas, Clatsop, Coahuilteco, Comanche, Comecrudo, Coronam, Delaware, Guatuso, Haname, Havasupai, Hitchiti, Isleta, Kalapuya, Kansa, Karankawa, Kickapoo, Kiowa, Kiowa-Apache, Klamath, Koastati, Kutenai, Lipan, Maidu, Maya, Miami, Micmac, Modoc, M o h a w k , Molala, Muskogi, Muskwaki, Mutsun, Narraganset, Natchez, Nez Perce, Ojibwa, Ottawa, Passamaquoddy, Penobscot, Peoria, Potawatomi, Queres, Sauk, Seminole, Seneca, Shasta, Shawnee, Shetimacha, Shoshoni, Tlascaltec, Tonkawa, Tunica, Umpqua, Warmspring, Wichita, Yavapai, Yuchi, Zuni. Although Gatschet produced few published descriptions, his manuscripts provided information on most of the languages k n o w n to the Bureau during his active lifetime. B y the end of his career, however, canons of relevance in American linguistic research had changed radically. Although his work was a major contribution to the collection of basic information about little k n o w n languages for the Bureau linguistic classification, the mere collection of vocabularies and other superficial information increasingly was superseded after 1891. Gatschet was dismissed, not entirely fairly, by Boas as having never m a d e this transition.
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
73
5.2 Bureau Fieldwork A large part of the Bureau's contribution to the development of American anthropology lay in its facilitation of fieldwork. During the early 19th century, anthropology depended on information from travellers, missionaries and civil servants, m e n w h o were not themselves primarily concerned with the anthropological questions for which their responses were mined. Anthropological questions were posed by m e n from other professional backgrounds w h o considered themselves primarily scholars rather than observers. In this division of labour, comparison and theory did not presuppose fieldwork. Insistence onfieldworkin America is often attributed to Boas, but in fact it was already present in the early Bureau. T h e original staff were m e n of action, trained in the Civil W a r and the exploration of the American West rather than in university programs of anthropology. These self-taught anthropologists emphasizedfirst-handobservation of American Indians and practical reasons for studying them. Indeed, the Americanist tradition of empirical study of Indians goes back to the questionnaires of T h o m a s Jefferson, and before him to the missionaries on whose work the questionnaires were based. Such avocational work persisted until the founding of the Bureau through the work of statesmen and public figures Lewis Cass, Albert Gallatin, Lewis Henry Morgan, Henry R o w e Schoolcraft and others (Hallowell 1960, Bieder 1986). Powell thus had ample precedent for his emphasis onfieldworkwith relevance to government policy. This orientation was so strong that the Bureau avoided association with work based on existing literature. 'Scholastic' publications were not considered scientific. M c G e e (to Baker, 18 Feb. 1896: B A E ) insisted that the American Anthropologist should not be "founded on ancient books, however respectable". Applicants for staff positions, even if they had not done original fieldwork, were expected to be familiar with the researches of the Bureau. Not all staff members didfieldwork,for example, Pilling and Royce, but the armchair scholars were equally committed to the n e w style of original research. M c G e e (to Halleck, 15 July 1901: B A E ) believed that "anthropology has risen to the rank of a science within the last quarter century [...] mainly through American work which is not yet incorporated in text-books or other trade publications in minute part". That is, the Bureau was engaged in ongoing research in afieldwhich was changing rapidly, leaving behind m u c h of the work which preceded it. Powell, as Director of the Bureau, was in a position to impose his o w n
74
Chapter 5
standards for fieldwork on his staff and to strongly suggest them to potential collaborators. Within constraints of available funds and time, Powell encouraged as m u c h fieldwork as possible. Results obtained by travelling anthropologists were unlikely to be scientifically useful: "the only results of value at the present time [...] c o m e from years of well directed labor" (Powell to Parkman, 11 April 1882: B A E ) . Brief studies could be carried out with profit only where the subjects spoke English (Powell to Hall, 7 June 1884: B A E ) . Attempting to dampen the enthusiasm of another, less well k n o w n inquirer, Powell stressed (to O w e n , 21 April 1888: B A E ) that learning to speak an Indian language fluently required at least two years; analysis in terms of nonEnglish parts of speech required a knowledge of dialects which five or ten years might not even complete. The Bureau was not always able, however, to meet its o w n ideal standards for fieldwork. T h e policy was to use any existing means to acquire further information and to preserve partial records until they could be c o m pleted. Indian delegations in Washington and students in Indian boarding schools were particularly useful sources of information. Powell frequently interceded to obtain permission for such individuals to remain longer in Washington as informants (Powell to Schurz, 23 Jan. 1880: B A E ) . In most instances, however, brief informant sessions were intended to supplement investigations in progress. The aims of investigation were sufficiently complex to require close acquaintance with the peoples being studied. Powell ( T A S W 1: 128-129) believed that: The objective or scientific method of studying a mythology is to collect and collate its phenomena simply as it is stated and understood by the people to w h o m it belongs. In tracing back the threads of its historical development the student should expect to find it more simple and child-like in every stage of his progress. This is a clear statement of w h y Powell sought the native point of view rather than imposing European categories. In an evolutionary theory of mental development, the categories of a people at a lower stage of development were bound to differ. Instead of positing the nature of the Indian mind in advance, Bureau researches stressed that the "only satisfactory and reliable sources of information [...] are the Indians themselves"(Pilling to Barron, 24 Oct. 1887). The result was a great deal of rather sophisticated fieldwork by present standards. M c G e e (in Goode 1897:376) stressed that research necessarily
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
75
began with arbitrary and convenient criteria but aimed to replace them by "natural arrangements" w h e n increasing knowledge permitted. There might not be a "uniform system a m o n g the various practitioners" so that a simple description could introduce unexpected complications (11th A R for 1889-90, 1894, p. xxviii). Ethnographic materials ideally were recorded in the native language to avoid distortion imposed by the investigators. Powell praised Mallery's work (10th A R for 1888-89, 1893, p. xxx) for recording the "unbiased conceptions" of the Indians in their o w n method of (pictographic) writing. H e also valued the George Bushotter (1864-1892) texts as the first major collection of North American material contributed by a native (8th A R for 1886-87, 1891: xxix). Dorsey's revisions of the translation carefully maintained original forms of expression. M o o n e y (to Powell, 4 A u g . 1889: B A E ) used standardized forms to elicit texts but attempted to follow out mythic ideas with his informants. A s early as 1879, Gatschet ( T A S W 1: 10) noted that Indian colour terms m a d e as m a n y distinctions as European, although they were not the same ones and differed in degree of abstraction. Gatschet believed (1890:vii) that linguistic data reflected "the ideas that were moving the Indian's mind, not only recently but long before the historic period." The goal was to understand the native organization of material in order to comprehend the development of the h u m a n mind through the same stages everywhere. Ironically, the doctrine of psychic unity of mankind, although it posited essential equality of savage and civilized mind, produced less work on native categories than Powell's brand of evolutionism which did not take such equality for granted. Comparably, Daniel Brinton used texts collected by others to posit categories of mythological interpretation for American Indians, Egyptians and Chinese. Similarities were attributed to the structure of the h u m a n mind. In the 20th century, Boas and his students eliminated the evolutionary assumption of inferiority, while continuing to study native concepts. Psychic unity remained the base which m a d e an understanding of another culture possible. The Bureau took its fieldwork extremely seriously. W h e n Frank Cushing needed a scalp for his initiation at Zuni, it was provided by Spencer Baird from m u s e u m collections (Brandes 1965:68). In this case, the Zuni were doubly impressed — Cushing was so powerful that such an important object would be given to him by another. Pilling (to Chamberlain, 4 Feb. 1890: B A E ) found himself requesting Washington hotels to save wild turkey feathers from
76
Chapter 5
their kitchens so that ethnologists would be prepared to meet Indian standards of hospitality and ceremonial etiquette (Hugte 1994, Sherwood 1979). Official correspondence records the field experiences of early Bureau staff in great detail, thereby clarifying the change in ethnological style which began under Powell in the Bureau and continued with Boas and his students in the 20th century. At one extreme of ethnocentrism in the field, Mrs. Matilda Stevenson had a low opinion of the Indian mind, commenting to Powell (7 July 1890: B A E ) : "The more I study these Indians the more I a m impressed that there are but few w h o carry in their minds any clear and intelligent history of their cosmogony and mythology". Powell was unable tofireher because of her political connections. Mrs. Stevenson was delighted at anti-liquor legislation among the Pueblo, failing to note the contradiction in her remark that "[i]f they can only have their citizenship and at the same time be prevented from getting hold of liquor they will have clear sailing" (Stevenson to Hodge, 27 Oct. 1913: B A E ) . Not surprisingly, she was unpopular among the Indians she wanted to elevate to (her) civilization (Parezo 1993). O n e letter from the field indicated that her work could not continue since the spies she sent out had been caught. She complained of having to employ ruses to obtain information and that the Indians would have to learn that they couldn't treat government representatives so shabbily (Stevenson to Holmes, 3 April 1906: B A E ) . The work of Frank Hamilton Cushing in the Southwest is not entirely different in character, although he was felt by his contemporaries to be unique in his understanding of the Indian mentality (Fontana 1963, Hinsley 1983, Sherwood 1979). Even those w h o disliked Cushing agreed that he was a genius. His colleagues were astonished that Cushing came to consider himself a "full-blown Indian" (Judd 1967:59). Legend has it that Cushing appeared at an anthropological meeting in full Zuni regalia and was ordered by Powell to go h o m e and get dressed (Judd 1967:63). Powell (quoted in Mitra 1933:154155) believed that Cushing, more than any other m a n of his generation, had penetrated the minds of his subjects: "Cushing can think as myth-makers think, he can speak as prophets speak, he can expound as priests expound, and his tales have the verisimilitude of ancient lore". Cushing arrived in the Southwest expecting to find Morgan's postulated early stages of h u m a n history reflected in the lore of the Zuni. His leaves and assignments were periodically extended at his o w n request. Nonetheless, Cushing was not content with the Zuni w a y of life. Initially he had to be
Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
11
forced into Zuni dress, refused to have his ears pierced, and eventually had to get married to avoid taking a Zuni bride (Brandes 1965: 36, 89, 95). Cushing's letters solicit sympathy for the hardships of his life at Zuni pueblo and reveal him as a self-styled martyr to the cause of ethnology. Cushing's o w n view (Greene 1990) of the progress of his understanding of the 'inner life' of the Pueblo was doubtless exaggerated. After a single year, Cushing thought he spoke the language sufficiently well to "take an important part in councils" and reported that he was m a d e "chief councillor of the nation" (Powell's comment in the 2nd A R for 1880-81, 1883, p. xxv). Cushing (to Baird, 4 Dec. 1881 : Β Α Ε ) considered it a major triumph when he "broke d o w n " the last objection to his initiation. H e considered himself (to Mindeleff, 23 Dec. 1882: B A E ) virtuous when he kept his temper in council and did not threaten Indians w h o attempted to have him thrown out of Zuni territory. Cushing was determined to stay in spite of all indications that he was not wanted, merely complaining that ethnographic specimens could only be obtained by force (4th A R for 1882-83,1886, p. xl). This style of fieldwork was apparently acceptable to his colleagues in the Bureau and the Smithsonian. Cushing had the additional problem that, although he considered his o w n work brilliant, he could never persuade himself that it was completed and should be published (to Powell, 11 June 1881: B A E ) . Despite Congressional emphasis on publications, even Cushing's failure to submit monthly reports to the Director was tolerated; he received only a mild reprimand (Pilling to Cushing, 30 Jan. 1883: B A E ) . A n extreme contrast to this prima donna approach was found in the work of James O w e n Dorsey. Dorsey was "actuated by an earnest desire to ac quaint himself fully with primitive modes of thought" and progressed from linguistics to the "crude philosophy" of the Siouan peoples (Powell in 11th A R for 1889-90, 1894, p. xliii). O . T . M a s o n (1893:616) was convinced that Dorsey knew the Siouan languages as well as his o w n . Even Franz Boas, w h o generally disparaged the linguistic work of the Bureau staff, acknowledged that Dorsey recorded "authentic literature" although he dealt with only a small part of native life (Boas 1906:643). Dorsey's recognition of the difficulties of recording data adequately is impressive. H e suggested that an abstract grammar of O m a h a should call attention to the fact that m a n y O m a h a and Ponca spoke their language 'incorrectly' (Dorsey to Croffut, 7 N o v . 1889: B A E ) . Acculturation had produced differential skills in the use of Indian languages which m a d e the
78
Chapter 5
grammar of the aboriginal language something of an idealization. Dorsey also noted phonological variation in the same speaker at different points in the life cycle (DeMallie 1969a:6). Dorsey described (to M c G e e , 17 Jan. 1894: B A E ) the production of n e w dialects by recent contact of different Dakotan groups, realizing that the languages were still changing. His Biloxi dictionary provided copious notes explicating single words so that related parts of the vocabulary could be studied together (Dorsey to Powell, 15 Feb. 1893: B A E ) . Dorsey (to Powell, 17 Jan. 1890: B A E ) also understood that the parts of speech were different from those of Indo-European and tried to preserve the grammatical categories. Whenever a conference with an informant was interrupted, Dorsey had the sensitivity to switch from ceremonial topics to verification of words for his dictionary (Dorsey to Pilling, 13 Jan. 1880: B A E ) . Dorsey's fieldwork is often contrasted to that of A . S. Gatschet, the only university graduate on the early Bureau staff. Swanton (n.d.: 23) remarks that Gatschet spread himself over various languages and lacked Dorsey's sensitivity to the mentality of his subjects. Gatschet thus restricted himself to pure linguistics, while Dorsey turned to problems of mental organization and development. Gatschet, however, was delegated by Powell to study every language on which further information was needed for the classification. Boas (to W o o d w a r d , 13 Jan. 1905: A P S ) noted that Powell continually interfered with Gatschet's work. Bureau fieldwork caused problems with less disinterested government employees in contact with the Indians. Several staff members antagonized Bureau of Indian Affairs officials, schoolteachers and missionaries — publicity which did little to improve the Bureau's image in government science. Dorsey (to Powell, 1 Sept. 1879: B A E ) was forced to insist that writing letters for Indians did not imply encouraging discontent. Accusations against Cushing ranged from licentiousness to shooting Navajo horses and came from nearly every other white m a n in the Zuni area (Howard to Powell, 26 Dec. 1882: B A E ) . S o m e comments were clearly malicious, but Cushing's unpopularity is indisputable, as is the repeated need for Powell to defend his actions and integrity (Powell to Hale, 11 April 1882: B A E ) . The Bureau's most persistent difficulties with unwanted publicity for its fieldwork came from James M o o n e y , whose years as a newspaper reporter had taught him to be at the centre of whatever was happening. M o o n e y attained reasonably good rapport with his informants but constantly antago-
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America
79
nized Indian agents and other bureaucrats. His insistence that Indian ceremonies depended on the hallucinagenic properties of the peyote cactus was objectionable in a period where the performance of any Indian ceremony was actively discouraged (18th A R for 1896-97, 1899, p. xlv; cf. Cole & Chaikin 1990). M o o n e y was instrumental in obtaining a chemical analysis of mescal (McGee to M o o n e y , 19 March 1895: B A E ) because this was an essential part of the ceremonial to the Indians. H e also objected (to Powell, 21 June 1893: B A E ) to the unenforced ruling prohibiting all Indian ceremonies after about 1887. Powell agreed and even argued (to the Commissioner of Indian Affairs, 28 June 1893: B A E ) that ceremonies should be performed so that Bureau staff members could record them. Powell also defended Mooney's work on the forbidden Ghost Dance (to Langley, 26 M a y 1897: B A E ) , although parts of it raised political havoc. W h e n M o o n e y was accused of paying for a sun dance which include self-mutilation and thus of inciting cruelty among the Cheyenne, Holmes (to Rathburn, 24 A u g . 1903: B A E ) became so upset by the publicity that he recalled M o o n e y from thefieldwithout hearing his version of the story (Moses 1984). O n an earlier occasion, M o o n e y attempted to represent a faction of reservation Indians and was officially reprimanded ( M c G e e to Shelley, 19 M a y 1894: B A E ) . M c G e e , however, accepted Mooney's explanation that it was "no more than chance that your presence in Indian country concurs with expressions of dissatisfaction on the part of some of the Indians" ( M c G e e to M o o n e y , 21 Dec. 1896: B A E ) . Bureau administrative style was m u c h more relaxed and less bureaucratic during Powell's lifetime. In sum, the Bureau's goal of recording aboriginal culture and defending the Indians in their disagreements with government officials was in conflict with the laissez-faire political philosophy of the period. Fieldwork was one thing, but, in spite of its original practical purposes, the Bureau had to stay out of Indian politics, which was difficult for conscientious and informed staff members. Such conflicts arose less frequently after the turn of the century, in part because Indians were a less salient problem for the federal government by this point and were studied primarily by non-government anthropologists w h o had less commitment to enforcing Indian policy. 5.3 Collaboration Powell did not distinguish firmly between those members of his staff w h o were paid for their research and various kinds of collaborators w h o
Chapter 5
80 Figure 1. Major staff and collaborators of the bureau
NAME
DATES
SPECIALTY
PREVIOUS PROFESSION
John Wesley Powell
pre-1879 d.1902
Director
Geologist
James O w e n Dorsey
pre-1879 d.1895
Siouan lang. & soc. str.
Missionary
Otis Tufts Mason
pre-1879 d.1908
National Museum
Eastern Mediterranean
Garrick Mallery
1877 to d.1894
Sign & gesture langugae
U.S. Army
Albert Samuel Gatschet
pre-1879 to 1905
Linguistics
College educated
H . C . Yarrow
pre-1879 1887
Mortuary customs
—--
James Constantine Pilling
1879 to d.1895
Linguistic bibliography
Geologist
Erminie Smith
1879 to d.1886
Iroquois mythology
None
C . C . Royce
1879-80, 1883-84
Indian treaty history
---
James Stevenson
1879 to d.1888
Southwestern archaeology
U.S. Army
Henry Wetherbe Henshaw
1880-93
Classification
Biologist
Frank Hamilton Cushing
1892 to d.1900
Zuni ethnology
None
Washington Matthews
ca. 1879 d.1905
Navajo, Hidatsa
U.S. Army physician
Victor & Cosmos Mindeleff
1881-92
Southwestern archaeology
---
W . J . Hoffman
1881-97
Archaeology, Picture writing
Geologist
Cyrus Thomas
1882 to d.1910
Archaeology, Central America
Entomologist
Jeremiah Curtin
1883-92
Mythology, linguistics
Diplomat
81
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America " Matilda Coxe Stevenson
ca. 1883 d.1915
Pueblo ethnology
None
John Napoleon Brinton Hewitt
1886-1937
Iroquois
Secretary to Mrs. Smith
James Mooney
1885 to d.1921
Cherokee, Kiowa
Newspaper reporter
Frederick W e b b Hodge
1891-1901, 1910-1918 (Chief)
Administr.
Librarian
Jesse Walter Fewkes
1894-1928 (1918 on, Chief)
Southwestern archaeology
Zoologist
Alice Cunningham Fletcher
1899 to ca.1910
Omaha
None
Franz Boas
1902-1919
Honorary Philologist
Physicist
Frank Russell
1900-1903
Pima ethnology
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
John Reed Swanton
1900-1944
Southeastern ethnology
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
William Jones
1901-1902
Fox language
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
Henry Hull St. Clair
1901-1905
Northwest coast languages
Anthropologist
Thomas T . Waterman
1922
Temporary
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
Leo Frachtenberg
1910-1917
Northwest coast languages
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
Paul Radin
1910-1911
Winnebago
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
Herman Haeberlin
1915, 1917
Psychology, Southwest
Anthropologist (Ph.D.)
Frances Densmore
1907-1957
Music
Truman Michelson
1910 to d.1938
Algonquian linguistics
Indo-European linguistics
John Peabody Harrington
1914 to d.1953
Linguistics
Linguist
None
82
Chapter 5
contributed information and analyses. The full-time staff was never large, but almost everyone working in American anthropology during the late 19thcentury had some connection. Staff and collaborators alike were drawn from a diversity of backgrounds and their degrees of professionalism were not sharply distinct. Indeed, thefinancialrelation of the early Bureau staff and collaborators to the institution cannot always be established. Paid staff, associates from other Washington institutions, and outside collaborators whose manuscripts were purchased were all part of the cooperative research program. Figure 1 includes, for the early years, individuals w h o were not paid a salary but whose researches were integral to the functioning of the Bureau, e.g., O . T . M a s o n of the National M u s e u m . Although the policy of encouraging collaborators was modified in the 20th century, during Powell's lifetime, information was welcome from any source (5th A R for 1883-84, 1887, p. xviii): Collaboration is constantly invited from competent explorers and writers w h o are not and do not desire to be officially connected with the Bureau [...]. T h e liberality of Congress, it is hoped, will soon allow of the publication of bulletins specifically designed to make known without delay, the discoveries and deductions of the scholars throughout the world w h o m a y thus cooperate with the Bureau. B y this means an effective impulse will be given to their researches. The Bureau published primarily the researches of its o w n staff, but because its monographs had a large circulation, they set increasingly high standards for ethnographic reporting. T h e Bureau policy of avoiding "purely technical publications" meant that amateur anthropologists were also influenced by the accessibility of its work. The effort was to gradually accumulate and m a k e available enough information to formulate general anthropological theories. In practice, of course, m u c h of this work was highly technical, particularly in linguistics. W h e n the detailed observations were of widespread importance they were published in part or in full; when they were of a technical character, or for other reasons of interest to few people only (as in linguistics), only typical collections were published, the mass being held for comparative study. A s research progressed, the relations themselves were compared and grouped, for the purpose of educing laws of relations or principles. (McGee in Goode 1897:371) Preliminary research reports were often published so that other interested persons could contribute further information. For example, Mallery's pictographs were presented descriptively, with theoretical interpretation awaiting
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
83
further facts, in part to be supplied by collaborators. T h e knowledge sought by the Bureau under Powell was more extensive than the staff could gather with the internal resources available to it. Use of unofficial collaborators was thus necessary to the research plan. Although the Bureau answered all inquiries and kept manuscript files of anything submitted to it, publications aspired to a more professional level. Powell's reports as Director frequently employ 'destructive criticism' designed to raise the quality of American anthropology, as well as that of government publications in anthropology. T h e Bureau maintained contact with as m a n y scholars as possible, sending out copies of Powell's Introduction and corresponding with collaborators in all walks of life. Staff opinion was pooled regularly over the allocation of scarce funds. For example, Mallery, M a s o n , and M o o n e y cabled Powell from a meeting of the A A A S that he should hire Alice Fletcher (25 Aug. 1882: B A E ) . Occasionally, work of collaborators could be accepted for publication virtually on the basis of previous work, e.g., George Bird Grinnell (1849-1938) on Cheyenne (Holmes to Grinnell, 19 Sept. 1903: B A E ) . In other cases, the difficulty was to refuse publication without offending collaborators w h o were at best semi-professional. Excuses included location of research, lack of funds, overlap of scientific results, work in progress. Powell (to Scollen, 11 April 1892: B A E ) stressed that the Bureau rarely employed outside collaborators, and M c G e e suggested that "work of this kind is naturally unsatisfactory unless performed con amore" (to Chief Pokago, 16 M a y 1901: B A E ) . Specialized researches were usually avoided, for example, Cherokee texts written in syllabary (Powell to Duncan, 20 March 1886: B A E ) . In some cases, alternative publication outlets were suggested. In others, scientific value was clearly limited. The Bureau was even k n o w n to request return of its unfilled questionnaires (Pilling to Everette, 8 N o v . 1883; 25 January 1884: B A E ) : while the vocabularies indicate m u c h diligence in collection and great care in recording, they d o not possess sufficient accuracy and linguistic merit to warrant their publication and can only be used to supplement the work of others in this field. Enthusiastic amateurism was insufficient to meet Bureau standards. S o m e scholars became insulted at the 'exclusiveness' of the Bureau; others responded by attempting to meet its stringent standards.
84
Chapter 5
In addition to collaboration with individual scholars, the Bureau attempted to maximize the institutional resources. Albert Bickmore of the American M u s e u m of Natural History cooperated with Powell in the division of labour in the description of American Indians and in collections for exhibitions (Bickmore to Powell, 15 March 1880: B A E ) . T h e linguistic researches of John P. Harrington (1884-1861) in the Southwest were sponsored by the Archaeological Institute of America before his employment by the Bureau in 1915; his work for the B A E was coordinated to that of the University of California Department of Anthropology. Alice Fletcher (18381923) held a fellowship at Harvard alongside her connection with the Bureau. M c G e e (to Russell, 22 February 1901: B A E ) was concerned that the Bureau cooperate with the academic departments of anthropology which were sprouting up at the turn of the century. The work of Frank Cushing was sponsored at different times by the Smithsonian Institution, the B A E , the H e m e n w a y Expedition, Harvard University and the University of Pennsylvania. Putnam of Harvard (to H e m e n w a y , 10 M a y 1897: B A E ) considered Cushing a useful link to increasing cooperation with the Bureau. Powell was also responsible for the choice of Adolph Bandelier (1840-1914) to lead an expedition to Mexico under the Archaeological Institute of Boston (Hodge 1932). Powell gave Bandelier kinship and linguistic vocabulary questionnaires and insisted that he should "know what w e are doing here, the w a y in which our work is organized, thefieldof research w e are pursuing" (Powell to Bandelier, 11 June 1880: B A E ) . (Bandelier remains best k n o w n for his novel The Delight Makers of 1890.) In each of these cases, the Bureau extended its influence beyond its o w n direct researches and helped to consolidate the developing structure of the discipline. The Bureau did not dissociate itself from its roots in a less professional American anthropology and thus maintained the possibility of influencing the style of work of its collaborators. At the same time, however, the rest of American anthropology was becoming more exclusive in its professionalism, and the Bureau, with its semi-professional base, was increasingly left behind. University and m u s e u m anthropologists around the turn of the century rejected ties to earlier work and asserted their o w n professionalism — in apparent conflict to the public service ethic of the Bureau as a government institution. Indeed, because the Bureau was among thefirstprofessional institutions to sponsor anthropological research, it had to c o m e to terms with the anthro-
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
85
pological 'establishment' of the late 19th century. M e n such as Morgan, Brinton, and Hale were not professional anthropologists in all the senses suggested in Chap. 1, but they were treated by Powell and his staff with a deference reflecting their reputations among non-Bureau anthropologists. Powell realized that anthropology was moving in the direction of professional careers and institutions, but still dealt courteously with his older associates. There was even talk within the Bureau of memoirs of Morgan, Brinton and Hale, although none was actually completed. For their part, such established anthropologists welcomed the Bureau as an important institutional innovation in American anthropology. Brinton requested help in his linguistic classification. Morgan's work on kinship was sponsored partially by the Smithsonian. Hale sought Bureau support to revise the results of his o w n research from the Wilkes Expedition in the 1840s (Hale to Powell, 14 M a y 1881; 2 June 1881: B A E ) . T o some extent, the courtesy was perfunctory, but Powell acknowledged that his o w n anthropology grew out of such a context. Thus, while Powell himself m o v e d in a new institutional context, he did not sever ties to contemporaries w h o continued to work within the earlier tradition even well after 1879. 5.4
The Missionary Question M u c h of the existing work on American Indian languages at the time of the founding of the Bureau had been done by missionaries. Although the Handbook of American Indians (Hodge 1907:874) stressed the heroism and devotion of missionaries, the Bureau rarely collaborated with missionaries, although m a n y of the manuscripts in its library had been collected by them. The only former missionary on the early Bureau staff was James O w e n Dorsey. Because of his special knowledge of missionary organizations and publications, Dorsey was designated to correspond with Indian territory missionaries about sign language and bibliography. Missionary cooperation with government agencies was so minimal that the Commissioner of Indian Affairs could not provide addresses and Dorsey had to inquire of the secretaries of the various religious bodies (Dorsey to Pilling, 9 July 1879: B A E ) . Dorsey attempted to maintain a dual role as missionary and scientist. W h e n invited to act as interpreter for an Indian at the American Missionary Association meetings, he offered to m a k e up the time by working nights so that he could accept (Dorsey to Powell, 11 Sept. 1879; Dorsey to Pilling, 20 Oct.
86
Chapter 5
1879: B A E ) . Dorsey stressed the need of missionaries for accurate scientific information such as the Bureau could provide. Most of the Bureau's experience in dealing with missionaries came in Siouan linguistics where science and religion seemed to conflict. Dorsey's primary affiliation was to the Bureau and he apparently (DeMallie, p. c , ca. 1969) did not find his position an uncomfortable one. H e continued to preach near Washington to the end of his lifetime. Other missionary collaborators relegated anthropological work to their spare time. The Smithsonian published a grammar and dictionary in 1852 by the Reverend Stephen Return Riggs (1812-1883) w h o lived in Sioux country from 1837 until leaving the missionfieldto his children on his retirement after 'the Dakota conflict'. In his preface, Riggs acclaimed (quoted in C N A E 7, p. vii [1890]) "the contributions to science made by the great missionary enterprise of the present age". This value "was not premeditated, but has been a result altogether incidental to our work". Initially, Riggs had accepted Powell's advice, noting to Pilling (20 April 1881: B A E ) : "I do not profess to be skilled in Ethnology as a science". Riggs did not object to subordinating himself to Dorsey because he was a former missionary despite his scientific employment. Conflicts, however, were not long in arising. Riggs became particularly bitter towards Dorsey, complaining that his recording of sounds was too detailed (Dorsey to Powell, 13 A u g . 1879: B A E ) . Powell m a d e various suggestions for revision and format of presentation which Riggs interpreted as insults. For instance, Powell asked Riggs (18 Sept. 1880: B A E ) to record creation narratives in Dakota, suggesting Gatschet's grammar of Klamath as a model of the Bureau's methods of linguistic description (Powell to Riggs, 4 Oct. 1880: B A E ) . Powell complained (to Riggs, 16 April 1881: B A E ) that he had not provided a general ethnographic sketch, as had Dorsey and Gatschet. In each case, Riggs was held to the standards of the Bureau. Riggs resented this, believing his o w n extensive experience with the Sioux to be more important than the Bureau's standardization of anthropological methods. After Riggs's death in 1883, the Bureau hoped for continued revision of the Siouan materials by other missionaries. Because progress was slow, Powell assigned Dorsey to help. Pilling explained this to A . L . Riggs, the son of the original missionary, also a missionary (26 M a y 1883: B A E ) . Riggs the younger found this a "most astonishing proposition, since his father had been collecting idioms for years and Dorsey lacked such intimate knowledge of [the] Dakota" language (A. L . Riggs to Powell, 14 June 1883: B A E ) .
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
87
Other missionaries refused to put aside their religious work to complete the dictionary and Dorsey eventually sorted out the contributions of Riggs and other missionaries to the Dakota from his o w n contributions in an elaborate set of footnotes ( C N A E 7. p. xii [1890]). The younger Riggs was insulted that Dorsey w a s listed as editor (to Pilling, 8 Feb. 1893: B A E ) , while Dorsey insisted that he had m a d e only such changes as brought the work into conformity with "the general plan of publications of this Bureau" ( C N A E 9, p. xi [1893]) and hoped Riggs never realized the extent to which his father had approved Dorsey's modifications (Dorsey to Powell, 18 March 1893: B A E ) . The cumulative weight of all the difficulties of collaboration with the missionaries to the Sioux assured the Bureau that missionaries had little or no part in its primary enterprise, the organization of anthropology in America. Cyrus Byington's dictionary of Choctaw, for example, remained unpublished until it was edited by Swanton, w h o was professionally trained in anthropology (Margaret C . Blaker, p. a ) . Missionary labours provided useful data, to be sure, but only Dorsey was in any serious sense a participant in Powell's plan to 'Organize anthropological research' on the American Indian. Most missionaries had no stake in professional science and studied anthropology for religious reasons if at all. Missionary work was only used if it met scientific standards of Bureau professionalism. There is an element of rationalization to this position, however, in that missionaries threatened the newly professional anthropologists because they were able to spend more time in thefield,establishing longterm rapport, and thus to obtain more intensive results. 5.5 Powell's Evolutionary Synthesis Although at the time of its founding the Bureau was already involved in a number of research projects, Powell believed that m u c h remained to be done (3rd A R for 1881-82, 1884, p. xxxii): The science of anthropology is inchoate. A multiplicity of facts have been collected which have not yet been assigned to their proper places in the system, so that the sequence of events in the course of human culture is but partly m a d e out. Yet anthropologists are everywhere attempting to discover and explain the origin and growth of arts and customs, and all other phenomena that relate to the activities of mankind. M a s o n suggested (1893:627) that comparative study was the key to unravel "the tangle of American archaeology and ethnology". T h e unity of Bureau researches, for participants, was evolutionary.
88
Chapter 5
M u c h of this evolutionary synthesis came from earlier American anthropology, particularly the work of Morgan. The evolutionary theory of Powell and Morgan, however, was not Darwinian. Rather, the effort was to define mankind outside the biological realm (Hallowell 1960:55). T h e science of m a n was "primarily and in every essential respect superorganic" (15th A R for 1893-94, 1897, p. xviii). Both the goal and the principle of explanation were expressed in terms of mind, but a h u m a n mind shaped by, and accessible through, sociocultural rather than biological factors (Ibid.): The observations on Indian habits and artifacts [...] afford a satisfactory index to and measure of the aboriginal mind. [This principle was] established early in the history of the Bureau through observations on activital coincidences which have since been formulated in the comprehensive law of the responsivity of mind; so generalized, the principle m a y be regarded as the keynote of ethnic science, the Rosetta stone whereby the characters of all races m a y be interpreted. The recognition of the principle serves also to explain and establish the sequence of stages in h u m a n development inferred from observations of m a n y peoples. The evolution of interest, for Powell, Morgan and Brinton, stressed "the long-favored doctrine of progress, the power of m a n to reconstruct society and a generally optimistic faith in the future" (Curti 1943:555). Powell (1885:347) accepted Morgan's insistence on the growth of institutions through "a conscious effort at reform" at each stage, that is, through mental factors. In summary, Powell adopted from Morgan his faith in science, belief in reform and progress, solicitude for the Indian, and commitment to natural science (Hofstadter 1944, Stanton 1960, Banister 1979). At the time of the Bureau's founding, Morgan was the primary exponent of social evolutionism in America and Powell consciously built on his work. Systematic classification of the western tribes among w h o m Morgan had collected kin terms was attempted based on linguistic family. Powell's 1877 and 1880 vocabulary lists adapted Morgan's questionnaire methods to language. Powell was intrigued by Morgan's identification of the same kinship system in southern India and aboriginal North America, presumably reflecting similar evolutionary stages. The Bureau did not adopt Morgan's kinship questionnaires officially, although Dorsey, at least,filledthem out for the Smithsonian in the early 1870s. Powell planned a third edition of his lexical questionnaire, which was to have added questions on mythology and social organization. H e proposed to study additional areas of culture with the same methods.
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
89
Morgan's theories were to be "submitted to the test of field observation during several successive seasons" (McGee in Goode 1897:390) to provide an objective record of the evolutionary development of the American Indian. "The purpose of the work of the Bureau is to collect, record, and discuss facts in a strictly scientific manner; this work is done by specialists trained in observation and discrimination" (Powell to Langley, 13 A u g . 1889: B A E ) . The results of such investigations could then be applied to the past history of western society and to the whole of comparative ethnology (2nd A R for 188081, 1883, p. xix): From the ascertained laws governing that advance from the uniformity of their operation and from the necessary limitations of the development of intelligence, it m a y be inferred that our o w n remote ancestors passed through a similar experience and possessed corresponding institutions. B y this study, therefore, some portion of the lost history of our o w n race m a y be recovered, the Aryan family having preserved but to a limited extent, and that unconsciously, the data of its history prior to the closing period of barbarism. Morgan's Ancient Society (1877) was required reading for the entire Bureau staff. Powell read it "long into the night and planned to take it into the field with him" (Resek 1960:141). Cushing requested that a copy be sent to him in the field and Pilling sent him one belonging to Powell with the comment that "the difficulties experienced by you are sufficient, I think to justify it" (30 N o v . 1880: B A E ) . Swanton (n.d.: 34, 46) referred to Morgan as "the prevailing genius of Bureau thought in sociological lines" and noted that Powell's "anthropological philosophy" was "part of the necessary equipment of every Bureau m e m b e r . " For the most part, the sociological studies of the Bureau followed guidelines set by Morgan. Dorsey's Omaha Sociology used Powell's terms, revised from Morgan, and Dorsey's work in turn inspired Powell's paper on Wyandot government (3rd A R for 1881-82, 1883, p. xxxvi, ix). The only dissenter on the early Bureau staff was M o o n e y , w h o refused to find matrilineal clans among the Kiowa, although the accepted evolutionary sequence required their presence (Swanton, n.d.: B A E ) . For Powell, all the activities of the American Indian were united within a single symbolic system of which language was the index. Since all the aspects of culture were correlated, none could be studied in isolation (13th A R for 1891-92, 1896, p. xxiv). The correlation of such social facts was characteristic of h u m a n development represented by the American Indian, and thus a
90
Chapter 5
systematic study of Indian customs was required (16th A R for 1894-95, 1897, p. xvii). Powell insisted that "the activities of language are essentially demotic [social], their course of development is unlike that of living organisms and m a y be characterized as involuntary rather than evolutionary". This single symbolic system encompassed all that could still be recovered of the previous history of the American Indian (2nd A R for 1880-81,1883, p. xxix). Primitive m a n , as opposed to his civilized counterpart, could not separate the parts of his social existence (13th A R for 1891-92, 1896, p. xxiii). T h e goal of anthropology was to understand this unity ( M c G e e in G o o d e 1897:383): F e w civilized m e n have learned to grasp primitive thought, and no primitive m a n grasps civilized thought save at the end of a civilizing process. Indeed, it would appear that it is this diversity of m o d e of thought rather than differences in arts, industries, institutions, and beliefs, more indeed than all other things combined, that separates primitive m a n from civilized. A major goal of Powell's Bureau was to place the American Indian within the evolutionary development of mankind as a whole (11th A R for 1889-90, 1894, p. xli). Powell considered Yarrow's work on mortuary practices ("quaint customs and abhorrentrites")to offer evidence of "traits of character and lines of thought that yet exist and profoundly influence civilization" (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xxvii). Mallery stressed parallels between Old and N e w World mythology which were "too numerous and obvious to be merely accidental" ( T A S W 1: 13-14) and had to be attributed to a "widespreading and systematic evolution". Matthews (Link 1960), in his descriptive work on the Navajo, noted parallels with Hindu, Egyptian and Greek civilizations, stressing "the instructive evidence of similarity in the stage of mythic philosophy coming from a before unexplored area and only modified by the readily understood differences in environment" (5th A R for 1883-84, 1887, p. xlv). Powers (1877:5) drew salutary lessons from barbaric American Indian customs and noted that individual frontiersmen had exceeded Indians in their acts of savagery (cf. Halpern and McGreery 1997). Royce's researches in history of land cessions and treaties used the evolutionary synthesis to rationalize the progress of American civilization "notwithstanding the petty conflicts yet occurring where the relations of the Indian tribes to our civilization have not yet been readjusted by the adoption on their part of the first conditions of a higher life" (1st A R for 1879-80, 1881, p. xxviii). Most of the Bureau's work on sign language was carried out by former army officer Garrick Mallery whose standardized "outlines and forms" were
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
91
circulated to other Bureau staff members and to others "not necessarily scientific, n o w in contact with savage and barbaric tribes" all over the world (Mallery to Lowell, 17 March 1880: B A E ) . Powell was so interested in the implications of this work that it was continued after Mallery's death in 1894 (19th A R for 1897-98, 1900, p. xxvi). Indeed, gesture and picture language showed the American Indian higher in "the evolutionary order of h u m a n culture" than previously realized (4th A R for 1882-83, 1887, p. lxi). Detailed work was thus called for. Cushing also found the usual evolutionary stages to be in need of detailed description, since zootheism, physitheism, hekastotheism and fetichism (all Powell's terms) were all present in some form in Zuni (2nd A R for 1880-81, 1883, p. xxviii). A n evolutionary history of the h u m a n mind thus had to separate different kinds of survivals in present Indian culture. T h e evolutionary synthesis was retained but rendered more explicit by empirical researches based on fieldwork. This was the selfimposed task of the Bureau. Powell was also concerned with the scope of anthropology and the place of the science of m a n among other scientific disciplines. Powell, because of his prominence in government science, became an interpreter of science for late 19th-century laymen: "The Major accepted the challenge to survey the universe and drew his baseline" (Stegner 1954:375). Although Major Powell considered his primary task to "establish some order where there had been chaos before" in American Indian studies (Swanton n.d.:4), ethnographic data alone were insufficient and only a means to the end of establishing a holistic science of m a n . M a s o n (1883:505) noted: "The great mass of our ethnologic literature is ethnographic. Little has been attempted [...] toward developing a rational scheme of humanity on indisputable marks". O n e of Powell's particular interests was in defining the scope and subdisciplines of anthropology (1881a,b,c,d,e; 1899; 1900). H e was a m o n g the first to use an inclusive definition of the science (Brinton 1892b:268): "in late years Anthropology has been used as a term to designate the whole science of m a n — m a n as animal, m a n as a thinking being, and m a n as an actor in the economic arts, institutions, languages, literature, fine arts, religions, and opinions". Powell considered the term 'Ethnology' in the Bureau's title unfortunate. Indeed, his first Annual Report already used the term 'Anthropology' in its broadest sense. M c G e e (to Chamberlain, 3 Jan. 1894: B A E ) even referred to "the ill-named bureau in which I a m placed". Powell divided anthropology into somatology (physical anthropology),
92
Chapter 5
psychology, esthetology, technology, sociology, philology (linguistics) and sophiology (philosophy). His classification of the science was "designed for the guidance of operations in the Bureau" (23rd A R for 1901-02, 1904, p. xvi). Research described in the annual reports was organized according to these categories and staff members were expected to specialize in one or more of them (15 A R for 1893-94, 1897, p. lxix). Powell had considerable opportunity to broadcast his views. T h e 15th Annual Report (for 1893-94, 1897, p. lxxxvii) stated that his classification was "imparted to the members of the Bureau in a series of informal lectures, establishing a firmer and more definite basis for their researches". Lectures on each of the seven subdivisions of anthropology were presented to the Anthropological Society of Washington and subsequently published in its journal, the American Anthropologist. M c G e e (to Russell, 10 N o v . 1897: B A E ) prepared a similar series of articles which he intended to develop Powell's ideas. During Powell's lifetime, his evolutionary framework persisted, at least within the Bureau. The annual reports specifically placed individual research in evolutionary perspective and pointed out the importance of detailed studies to a theory of the development of the h u m a n mind. Powell's interest in particular problems within an evolutionary context was, indeed, shared by the members of his staff, although they employed his synthesis in rather different ways. But outside the Bureau itself, Powell's neologisms met with limited success. T h e Bureau could not dictate to other American anthropologists, particularly since some consensus in terminology already existed (Dieserud 1908). T h e system of anthropological classification proposed by Daniel Brinton in 1892 and presented to the A S W was explicitly designed to systematize existing usage rather than to establish n e w terms (Brinton 1892b:255-256). Brinton recognized somatology, ethnology, ethnography and archaeology as major divisions. Ethnology included sociology, technology, religion, linguistics and folklore. The confrontation of these two classificatory systems in a meeting of the A S W gave Powell the h o m e ground advantage. Brinton's paper w a s published by the American Anthropologist, but Powell's rejoinder, prepared for discussion before the A S W , was printed immediately following. In reprinting the two sets of comments, Frederica de Laguna (1960:98) expressed surprise that Powell's position in anthropology, and greater opportunity to publicize
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
93
his terms, did not compel their acceptance. But the existence of a previous consensus, coupled with a relative lack of interest in terminological disputes after 1900, meant that Powell's terms were only used where reinforced by the administrative organization of the Bureau (Anon. 1930). Although Powell was fond of coining terms, almost none have survived. Even in geological survey work, most of his names were replaced by later explorers. Powell believed that classification in science was to some extent a priori and referred to his classificatory efforts as 'philosophy'. S o m e of his statements on the subject appear to contradict his emphasis on data in ethnology. For example, he was particularly intrigued by the universal significance of the number five (Powell 1901:601): forever w e must observe that pentalogic kinds are found in pentalogic series. It is sometimes affirmed and more often taken for granted, that a scientific classification is a creation of the scientific mind [...]. It is sometimes affirmed that there m a y be m a n y valid classifications, and yet practically all scientific m e n repudiate that doctrine and are forever striving for a valid and final classification, realizing there can be but one. B y the beginning of the 20th century, American anthropology was moving toward classifications which grew out of particular data, and Powell's 'philosophical' taxonomy was relegated to the history of the discipline. 5.6 The End of an Era in the Bureau Powell's death in 1902 marked the end of the classic period in the history of the Bureau of American Ethnology. In retrospect, the early Bureau was inseparable from Powell's vision of it. His official obituary, written by M c G e e , eulogized the importance of the m a n to the institution (24th A R for 1902-03, 1907, p. xxxv): The Bureau of American Ethnology is peculiarly his, the lines of research initiated by him being in the main those that must be followed as long as the Bureau lasts — in fact as long as the h u m a n race remains a subject of study. Although the investigations m a d e and directed by Powell related almost exclusively to the h u m a n race, the results are so broad as to apply to all mankind. It was a fortunate circumstance that his energies were directed to a field little encumbered by the forms, methods, and determinations of earlier students, since it enabled him to conduct his investigations on new lines, and thus to raise the science to a higher plane. Powell had a charismatic effect on the individuals around h i m and managed to integrate the diverse labours of the Bureau by the sheer force of
94
Chapter 5
his personality. Pilling (to Powell, 7 Oct. 1879: B A E ) found life "a comparative blank" when Powell was away. M c G e e (in Langley 1902: 789) considered him "a unique character in his generation" and "an intellectual giant among his fellows". At the end of his lifetime, however, Powell became rather disoriented, due to illness and also to changes in the science of anthropology that he had helped to put on solid professional ground. Swanton (n.d.: 31) remembers him primarily as losing the thread of conversations. Boas expressed his sympathy to M c G e e (23 A u g . 1895: A P S ) for Powell "who has of late lost so m a n y of his old friends". Mallery and Dorsey died in 1894, Pilling in 1895 and Cushing in 1900. Henshaw left the Bureau and Gatschet was no longer productive. A s Powell became less able to cope with his administrative burden, ordinary tasks devolved on M c G e e , w h o was appointed as Ethnologist-in-Charge shortly after Henshaw's resignation as Ethnologist in 1893. M c G e e fully expected to succeed Powell as Chief of the Bureau, but Smithsonian Secretary Langley appointed W . H . Holmes of the National M u s e u m instead. Langley (to Gilman, 24 Nov. 1902: SIA) saw himself as conducting a "purge" of the Bureau: "its scientific work shall be limited to the observation and recording of phenomena [and] its sanction shall not be given to theoretical or speculative work". The integration of diverse anthropological topics which Powell's evolutionary theory had encouraged receded into the amateur past of the Bureau for the archaeologists (Holmes and Jesse Fewkes) w h o directed its researches in the early 20th century. The precarious independence of the Bureau from the National M u s e u m was also threatened. Without Powell's political prominence, the unity of the Bureau could not be preserved. The centre of gravity of the linguistic-symbolic-mentalist strain of Powell's anthropology increasingly, in perhaps inevitably, moved to Boasian locations as the Bureau was subsumed under the archaeological and m u s e u m constraints of its new administration. The Bureau was also, however, affected by external changes in the profession of anthropology. In 1879, the B A E set the standard for ethnological and linguistic studies in America, even for those not formally associated with it. B y 1902, m a n y of the major anthropological institutions of the 20th century had been established. M u s e u m s and universities were able to provide employment and research funds for professionals w h o were increasingly likely to have had formal training in anthropology. For the new generation of anthropologists, the Bureau was one of a number of institutional alternatives,
"Organizing Anthropological Research in America"
95
one which offered more constraints on individual research than a m u s e u m or university position. T h e Bureau did not change in response to these n e w alternatives and thus found itself in the 20th century, ironically, outside the mainstream of a professional American anthropology which it had helped to create. Hinsley (1981:151) argues that the "survey impulse finally expired" after the 1891 linguistic classification, resulting in a loss of direction for the Bureau. T h e survey mapping projects which united the Bureau, however, continued into the Boasian era of the early 20th century, suggesting that changing political contexts of funding for the linguistic and ethnological work of the Bureau m a y have been more significant in its marginalization after 1902.
James Owen Dorsey (1848-1895) Smithsonian Institution. Reprinted with permission.
II T h e Development of Institutional Alternatives
Chapter 6
Early Attempts at University Anthropology
The localism of mid-19th century American anthropology, centred primarily in Washington, Cambridge, Mass., and Philadelphia, m a d e the development of a self-conscious and nationally unified profession difficult. Powell, Putnam, and Brinton all began within such localized institutional contexts. B y the end of the century, however, these same individuals began to extend the scope and cohesiveness of the nascent discipline. Geographical expansion brought Chicago, N e w York, and Berkeley, California, to anthropological prominence, increasingly after 1900. Putnam, like Powell, was a key entrepreneur in the professionalization of anthropology. His appointment to a professorship at Harvard University in 1887 confirmed the dominance over Americanist archaeology which was already incumbent on his Peabody M u s e u m curatorship. Further organizational forays at the World Columbian Exposition in Chicago in 1894 — providing the baseline for anthropology at the Field Columbian M u s e u m and the University of Chicago — at Berkeley, where Putnam provided established backing for A . L . Kroeber's innovations in anthropological teaching and research — and in N e w York, where Putnam served as a patron behind the scenes for Franz Boas in his early efforts to establish an institutional base in America. Increase in the number of centres for anthropological research was facilitated by increasingly frequent collaboration a m o n g anthropologists. M u s e u m s and university departments exchanged personnel. Qualifications for employment became more standardized. A national profession of anthropology emerged — and grew rapidly over thefirsttwo decades of the n e w century. The n e w emphasis on professionalization meant that m e n were seeking institutions not only to support their personal research but also to modify the character of anthropology itself. The university was best suited to this function because its programs propagated anthropologists. Nonetheless, institu-
100
Chapter 6
tional support from museums provided a necessary balance, especially in sponsoring and fundingfieldresearch, during the early years of the academic departments. Indeed, several early attempts at teaching were abortive. A u tonomous academic programs arose to resolve conflicts between university anthropologists w h o emphasized the autonomy of their profession and m u seum administrators w h o were dominated by practical and public interests. A s long as m u s e u m goals were set by patrons and administrators, anthropology as a science was subordinated. Moreover, m a n y university-trained anthropologists found m u s e u m duties — the administration and collection of specimens — excessively constraining. The resulting crystallization of the profession in an academic milieu has persisted to the present day. T h e gradual development of this academic framework occupied m u c h of the energy of Franz Boas and his first generation of students during the crucial years between 1900 and 1920. B y the latter date, although their work had arisen from m u s e u m anthropology, Boas's students and their students constituted the majority of American anthropologists; of these, the vast majority were committed to pursuing their research in an academic context. Boas stands out for the self-conscious tenacity with which he constructed an institutional structure for his version of anthropological science. 6.1 Graduate Education in America Major changes in American graduate education were necessary at the end of the 19th century in order for the university to become a plausible institutional framework for anthropology. American universities (for instance, Harvard, Yale, William and Mary, the University of Pennsylvania, the University of Virginia) had been offering college degrees since the 18th century. Graduate training, however, did not become a requirement for most scientific professions until the end of the 19th century. The growing professionalism of American science generally motivated rapid development of facilities for advanced study. The European, particularly German, model for graduate education was readily available at precisely the right m o m e n t (Furner 1975, Burke 1983, Conrad 1885). These changes in concepts of education and professional training set the context within which anthropologists sought university sponsorship for their research and designed university curricula specifically to train anthropologists. The German model was crucial on a number of fronts: First, Franz Boas
Early Attempts at University Anthropology
101
was trained in Germany and m a n y of his early students, for example, Alfred Krober and Robert Lowie, were German in background. Second, the scope and organization of Lowie (1937) confirms that m u c h of the intellectual foundation of Americanist anthropology was adapted directly from the Germ a n anthropological heritage: Johann Bachofen (1815-1887), Adolph Bastian (1826-1905), Friedrich Ratzel (1844-1904), Wilhelm W u n d t (18321920). The German anthropological tradition of volksgeist studies (Stocking 1996) brought the ideas of Johann Gottfried Herder (1744-1803), Wilhelm von Humboldt (1767-1835), and Hermann Steinthal (1823-1899) into the Americanist tradition. Third, late 19th-century German scholarship was organized around academic professional training at the graduate level. This was the model upon which Boas and his first generation of students would differentiate professional anthropologists from their amateur contemporaries. American national pride required keeping up with the n e w standards for scholarship in Germany, even if initial training had to be obtained at European universities. M a n y American university professors of the late 19th century were among the 'German-returned'; their growing presence in American institutions of higher learning further enhanced the prestige of German graduate education. Science required professional credentials not available in America until the influx of the n e w model. These changes in American education were foreshadowed by the resignation of B r o w n University president Francis Wayland (1796-1865) in 1850 on the grounds that the college failed to meet the educational needs of its students for more advanced studies that emphasized original research (Ryan 1939:4). Graduate studies were initiated at Yale and perhaps a few other places before 1870 and the first American P h . D . was awarded in 1861. During this period, even state universities, influenced by the provisions of the Morrill Land Grant Act of 1962, "convinced their legislatures of the importance of research" (Curti 1943:585). State universities, however, were mandated to provide education for practical purposes, for example, agriculture and ' m e chanical arts') rather than scholarship for its o w n sake. In fact, Daniel Coit Gilman, founder of the Johns Hopkins graduate university, had served previously as president of the University of California where his educational goals on the German model proved frustratingly unattainable (Gilman 1906:3). The history of American graduate educationrightfullybegins with Johns Hopkins, intended as an entirely n e w kind of institution from its opening in 1876. Its first library accessions were purchased to inform the would-be
102
Chapter 6
trustees of the still non-existent university on the state of education in America and Europe, and by implication the necessity for adopting the G e r m a n model (Ryan 1939:18). Gilman's pedagogical philosophy reflected changes in American intellectual life as well as the particular history of Johns Hopkins. H e believed (Ryan 1939:28): all "sciences" were worthy of promotion, and that there w a s therefore no essential difference between the "old" and the "new" education; that religion had nothing to fear from science, and that science need not be afraid of religion [...]; that in the promotion of science "remote utility" was quite as worthy to be thought of as of immediate advantage; that no university could encourage with equal freedom all branches of learning, and that therefore a selection must be m a d e in accordance with the requirements and deficiencies of a given people at a given period. The almost immediate success of Johns Hopkins demonstrated general dissatisfaction with American education at the time of its founding. Gilman felt that Johns Hopkins maintained higher scholarly standards than its predecessors and that previously "the idea of the university had not been generally understood" (quoted by Ryan 1939:18-19). Gilman's autobiography summarized the accomplishments of the early years (1906:2-3): science receives an amount of support unknown before. This is a natural consequence of the wonderful discoveries which have been m a d e in respect to the phenomena and laws of nature and the improvements m a d e in scientific instruments and researches [...]. With this increased attention to science, the old-fashioned curriculum disappeared, of necessity, and m a n y combinations of studies were permitted in the most conservative institutions. Absolute freedom of choice is n o w allowed in m a n y places. History and political science have c o m e to the front, and it is no longer enough to learn from a textbook wearisome lists of names and dates; reference must be m a d e to original sources of information [...] in order to understand the progress of h u m a n society. S o m e knowledge of French and G e r m a n is required of everyone. English literature receives an amount of attention never given to it in early days. Medicine is no longer taught by lectures only [...]. The admission to the advantages of higher learning is also one of the most noteworthy advances of the period. Gilman, although his reputation was more as administrator than scholar, created an atmosphere for scholarship to flourish. Germanic philology was perhaps the most characteristic discipline within the n e w G e r m a n model of science education. (In 1907, Gilman had the perspicacity to hire H e r m a n n Collitz (1855-1935). Collitz had returned from Göttingen to teach Germanic philology at Bryn M a w r College. At Johns
Early Attempts at University Anthropology
103
Hopkins, where he remained until his retirement in 1927, Collitz was able to pursue research as well as undergraduate teaching. H e was admirably situated institutionally and intellectually to serve as the first president of the Linguistic Society of America in 1925 (simultaneously holding the presidency of the Modern Language Association). His preeminence in historical-comparative linguistics is still attested by the Collitz Professorship at the annual L S A S u m m e r Institute. The Johns Hopkins example stimulated other universities to adopt similar experimental programs. Granville Stanley Hall (1844-1924) had served for several years at Johns Hopkins before being appointed as the first president of Clark University in Worcester, Mass. in 1887. In the same year, at the age of thirty-five, he founded the Journal of American Psychiatry. Hall combined researches in psychology and pedagogy, based on his studies of experimental psychology with Wilhelm W u n d t in Leipzig in 1879-80, with university administration on the Johns Hopkins model. The University of Chicago was founded in 1892 with a comparable emphasis on graduate training and scholarship. President William Rainey Harper included anthropology within the initial scope of the University, partly in response to its prominence in the World Columbian Exposition with which its founding was coupled. Established universities, previously restricted to undergraduate education, were forced to respond to the challenges set by the n e w graduate institutions. In 1863, Harvard initiated a lecture series in philosophy and modern literature which provided the germ of the graduate school four years later (Ryan 1939:8). President Charles William Eliot (1834-1926) designed an elective system which enabled him to employ specialists on his faculty. B y the 1890s, Harvard had one of the leading graduate schools in the country (Berman 1961:80). Eliot, whose presidency lasted from 1869 to 1909, hired scholars of established reputation and young, professionally trained m e n w h o would m a k e their reputations at Harvard (Berman 1961:120). This was, of course, the only w a y such institutions could obtain noted scholars for underpaid positions. Harvard was unique in its early extension of the seminar system to its undergraduates. Eliot aspired to create a university out of the existing college system (Butler 1935:144) rather than to seek a n e w kind of education at the graduate level. Eliot m a d e an abortive attempt to persuade William Dwight Whitney, the most distinguished American linguist of the 19th century, to abandon Yale for
104
Chapter 6
Harvard. This effort confirms the importance of linguistics in the prestigious German-modelled scholarship. At Columbia, in N e w York City, deliberations on educational reform began in 1852, but graduate education awaited the founding of the School of Political Science by John William Burgess (1844-1931) in 1876 (Ryan 1939:11). F r o m 1887 on, debates raged about the wisdom of giving up the undergraduate program entirely. Nicholas Murray Butler (1862-1947), w h o became president of Columbia in 1901, expressed his view as follows: The time has fully come when the work of Columbia College can no longer be confined to the old channels even though these channels be broadened and deepened [...]. Situated as it is in the metropolis with its libraries, m u s e u m s , art galleries, and busy intellectual life, that Columbia College [...] should develop into a University is as necessary as it is natural [...]. Those conceptions of a university which identify it with a group of technical or professional schools, or with a college in which all or most of the courses of study are elective, are equally to be avoided. A true university exists today, as it has always existed, by virtue of the methods of instruction it employs and the privileges which it offers. (Butler 1935:138) Intense debates centred around h o w to proceed with reorganization of American higher education, while allaying the fears of those traditionalists w h o opposed the fundamental changes associated with professionalization and specialization on the German model. 6.2
False Starts in Academic Anthropology Innovations in graduate education were most successful, at least at first, in the established academic disciplines of classics, literature, history and natural sciences. Anthropology, however, had no prior claim to a place in the emerging u