Modern Birkhfiuser C l a s s i c s Many of t h e original r e s e a r c h and survey m o n o g r a p h s in p u r e a n d a p p l i e d m a t h e m a t i c s p u b l i s h e d by Birkhfiuser in r e c e n t d e c a d e s have b e e n g r o u n d b r e a k i n g and have c o m e to be r e g a r d e d as foundational to t h e subject. Through the MBC Series, a select n u m b e r of t h e s e m o d e r n classics, entirely u n c o r r e c t e d , are being re-released in p a p e r b a c k (and as eBooks) to e n s u r e t h a t t h e s e t r e a s u r e s r e m a i n acc e s s i b l e to new g e n e r a t i o n s of s t u d e n t s , scholars, a n d r e s e a r c h e r s .
Algebraic K-Theory Second Edition
V. Srinivas
R e p r i n t o f the 1995 Second E d i t i o n
Birkh~iuser Boston 9 Basel 9 Berlin
V. Srinivas Tara Institute of Fundamental Research School o f Mathematics H o m i B h a b h a Road, Colaba M u m b a i 4 0 0 005 India
Originally published as Volume 90 in the series P r o g r e s s in M a t h e m a t i c s
Cover design by Alex Gerasev. Mathematics Subject Classification: 18F25, 19-XX, 19Dxx, 19D55, 19E08, 19E15
Library of Congress Control Number: 2007937324 ISBN-13:978-0-8176-4736-0
e-ISBN-13:978-0-8176-4739-1
Printed on acid-free paper. 9 Birkh~iuser Boston All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (BirkMuser Boston, c/o Springer Science+Business Media LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. 987654321 www. birkhause r. corn
(IBT)
V. Srinivas
Algebraic K-Theory Second Edition
Birkh~iuser Boston 9 Basel 9 Berlin
V. Srinivas School o f Mathematics Tata Institute of Fundamental Research B o m b a y , India
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Srinivas, V. Algebraic K-theory / V. Srinivas. -- 2nd ed. p. cm. -- (Progress in mathematics ; v. 90) Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 0-8176-3702-8 1. K-theory. I. Title. II. Series: Progress in mathematics QA612.33.$67 1993 93-9417 512'.55--dc20 CIP
Printed on acid-free paper 9 Birkhltuser Boston 1996
Birkhiiuser
Copyright is not claimed for works of U.S. Government employees. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without prior permission of the copyright owner. Permission to photocopy for internal or personal use of specific clients is granted by Birkh~user Boston for libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC), provided that the base fee of $6.00 per copy, plus $0.20 per page is paid directly to CCC, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, U.S.A. Special requests should be addressed directly to Birkh~luser Boston, 675 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA 02139, U.S.A. ISBN 0-8176-3702-8 ISBN 3-7643-3702-8 Layout and typesetting by Martin Stock, Cambridge, MA Printed and bound by Quinn-Woodbine, Woodbine, NJ Printed in the United States of America 987654321
Dedicated to my parents.
Contents
Preface to t h e F i r s t E d i t i o n
...............................
Preface to t h e Second Edition 1. "Classical" K - T h e o r y
.............................
xi xvii
.....................................
Review of parts of Milnor's book: definitions of K0, K1, Ks of rings; computation of K1 of a noncommutative local ring; definition of symbols; statement of Matsumoto's theorem; examples of symbols (norm residue symbol, Galois symbol, differential symbol); presentation for K2 of a commutative local ring. 2. T h e Plus C o n s t r u c t i o n
....................................
18
The plus construction; computation that ~r2(BGL(R)+) ~- K2(R); H-space structure of BGL(R) + and products in K-theory (following Loday); statement of Quillen's theorem on Ki of a finite field. 3. T h e Classifying Space of a Small Category . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
31
Simplicial sets; geometric realization; classifying space of a small category; elementary theorems about classifying spaces (compatibility with products, natural transformations give homotopies, adjoint functors give homotopy inverses, filtering categories are contractible); example of the classifying space of a discrete group as the classifying space of the category with one object, whose endomorphisms equal the group. 4. E x a c t C a t e g o r i e s a n d Quillen's Q - C o n s t r u c t i o n
...............
Exact categories; admissible mono- and epimorphisms; definition of QC for a small exact category C; definition of K~(C) for a small exact category C; statements of theorems about Ki (Ko agrees with that defined "classically", theorem on exact sequences of functors, resolution theorem, d~vissage theorem, localization theorem); "bare hands" construction of a homomorphism Ko(C) ~ ~rl BQC).
38
viii
Algebraic K-Theory
5. T h e K - T h e o r y of Rings and Schemes
.......................
46
Statement of the theorem comparing the definitions of Ki of a ring using the plus and Q constructions; definition of G~(A) as K~ of finitely generated A-modules, for Noetherian rings A; computations of G~(A[t]), G,(A[t,t-1]) for Noetherian A, and hence K~(A[t]), Ki(A[t,t-1]) for Noetherian regular A; definition of Ki(X), Gi(X) for schemes, using vector bundles and coherent sheaves, respectively; construction of direct image and inverse image maps for Ki and Gi of Noetherian schemes for morphisms satisfying appropriate conditions; action of K0 on Ki, Gi and projection formulas; Ki, Gi commute with filtered direct limits; localization for Gi of a closed subscheme and the open complement; Mayer-Vietoris for Gi; Gi of affine and projective space bundles; filtration by codimension of support and the BGQ spectral sequence; Gersten's conjecture for power series rings, and semilocal rings of finite sets of points on a smooth variety over an infinite field; Bloch's formula; Ki of projective bundles, of p l over a noncommutative ring, and of Severi-Brauer schemes. 6. P r o o f s of the T h e o r e m s of C h a p t e r 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
89
Proofs of the following theorems: 7r~BQC) ~- Ko(C); Theorems A and B of Quillen; the theorem on exact sequences of functors; the resolution theorem; the d6vissage theorem; the localization theorem. 7. C o m p a r i s o n of t h e Plus and Q - C o n s t r u c t i o n s
................
126
Monoidal categories; localization of the action of a monoidal category on a small category; computation of the homology of the classifying space of a localized category; the S - 1 S construction, viewed as a "functoriar' version of the plus construction; construction of the homotopy equivalence 8 - 1 3 ---, 12BQC for any exact category C in which all exact sequences are split, where 3 is the category of isomorphisms in C; corollary that the plus and Q-constructions yield the same K-groups for projective modules over a ring. 8. T h e M e r k u r j e v - S u s l i n T h e o r e m
............................
145
The Galois symbol; statement of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem; Hilbert's Theorem 90 for K2; proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem; torsion in K2; torsion in CH 2. 9. Localization for Singular Varieties
..........................
Quillen's localization theorem for the complement of an effective Cartier divisor in a quasi-projective scheme with affine complement; discussion of naturality of this sequence (after Swan); proof of the "Fundamental Theorem" on Ki of polynomial and Laurent polynomial rings; Levine's localization theorem; computation of K0 of the category of modules of finite length and finite projective dimension over the local ring of a normal surface singularity, in terms of Hi(K:2) of the resolution; computation of this Ko for quotient singularities; Chow groups of surfaces with quotient singularities.
194
Contents
ix
230 Appendix A. Results from Topology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (A.1) Compactly generated spaces; (A.2)-(A.6) Homotopy groups, Hurewicz theorems; (A.7) Products; (A.8)-(A.12) GW-complexes, Whitehead theorem, Milnor's theorem on the homotopy type of mapping spaces, comparison of singular and cellular homology and cohomology; (A.13)-(A.15) Local coefficients, homology and cohomology with local coefficients for CW-complexes via cellular chains; (A.16) Obstruction theory for maps and homotopies between CW-complexes (which may not be simply connected); (A.17)-(A.22) Fibrations, the homotopy lifting property, long exact homotopy sequence, fiber homotopy equivalence, fibrations over a contractible base are fiber homotopy equivalent to a product, local coefficient systems of the homology and cohomology groups of the fibers of a fibration; (A.23)-(A.26) Leray-Serre spectral sequence for homology and cohomology of a fibration over a CW-complex; (A.27) Homotopy fibers; (A.28) Spectral sequences for the homology and cohomology of a covering space; (A.29)-(A.35) Quasi fibrations (some results of Dold and Thorn); (A.36)-(A.42) NDR-pairs and cofibrations (following Steenrod); (A.43)-(A.47) H-spaces; (A.48)(A.50) Covering spaces of simplicial sets; (A.51)-(A.54) nurewicz and Whitehead theorems for non-simply connected H-spaces; (A.55) Milnor's theorem on the geometric realization of a product of simplicial sets. Appendix B. Results from Category Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
276
Small categories; equivalences; Abelian categories; construction of the quotient of a small Abelian category by a Serre subcategory; examples of quotients; adjoint functors; filtering categories and direct limits. Appendix C. Exact Couples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 287 The spectral sequence of an exact couple; bigraded couples; elementary discussion of convergence; the BGQ spectral sequence; the spectral sequence of a filtered complex. Appendix D. Results from Algebraic Geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 295 (D.1)-(D.14) Sheaves; (D.15)-(D.20) Schemes; (D.21)-(D.41) Some properties of schemes; (D.42)-(D.59) Coherent and quasi-coherent sheaves; (D.60)-(D.66) Cohomology and direct images of quasi-coherent and coherent sheaves; (D.67)-(D.70) Some miscellaneous topics. Bibliography
...............................................
339
Preface to the First Edition These notes are based on a course of lectures I gave at the Tata Institute during 1986-87. The aim of the course was to give an introduction to higher K-theory, and in particular, to expose in detail the results of Quillen, contained in the following basic papers: 1. D. Quillen: Higher Algebraic K-Theory I, Lecture Notes in Math. No. 341, Springer-Verlag, New York (1973). 2. D. Grayson: Higher Algebraic K-Theory II (after Daniel Quillen), Lecture Notes in Math. No. 551, Springer-Verlag, New York (1976). The audience consisted of colleagues and some graduate students who were mainly algebraists and algebraic geometers, and were interested in learning about K-theory because of its applications to these fields. Most members of the audience had a limited background in topology. As such, one of my aims during the course was to give proofs of the topological results needed, assuming the minimum possible. The two applications (beyond Quillen's results) which are discussed also reflect the tastes of the audience (and the lecturer). In a few places, I chose not to prove results in the maximum possible generality, when I felt that the ideas behind the proofs might be obscured by technical details. Algebraic K-theory is an active area of research, which has connections with algebra, algebraic geometry, topology, and number theory. Some recent interesting results in algebra and related fields proved using Ktheoretic methods are the following: (i) Merkurjev and Suslin's theorem on Brauer groups of fields, its generalizations due to Merkurjev and Suslin, Levine, and the work of Rost and others on Milnor's conjecture relating K2 and Witt groups; these results have interesting consequences for the Chow groups of algebraic cycles modulo rational equivalence on a smooth algebraic variety. (ii) Serre's conjecture on the vanishing of intersection multiplicities for modules over a regular local ring, proved by Gillet and Soule (this was independently proved by Paul Roberts, using intersection theory, as developed in Fulton's book). (iii) Levine's computation in terms of KI, for the Grothendieck group of modules of finite length and finite projective dimension over the local
xii
Algebraic K-Theory ring of an isolated Cohen-Macaulay singular point of a variety, which leads to a new proof of the results of Dutta, Hochster, and MacLaughlin on modules of finite projective dimension with negative intersection multiplicity. Levine's results also have applications to Chow groups of singular varieties. A generalization of Levine's results has been announced by Thomason and Trobaugh, which should have similar applications.
Chapters 8 and 9 touch on the first and third "algebraic" applications mentioned above. Lack of knowledge prevents me from giving a detailed list of results in topology and number theory, but I will mention Waldhausen's algebraic K-theory of spaces, which is a key ingredient in the recently announced proof by Hsiang and Madsen of the Novikov conjecture on the surgery obstruction map; the higher dimensional generalization of class field theory due to Bloch, Kato, Saito, and others; work of Bloch, Colliot-Thelene, Sansuc, and others on the torsion and cotorsion of Chow groups of varieties over number fields and local fields; and finally, results of Bloch, Beilinson, and others relating the ranks of K-groups and Chow groups of varieties over number fields to the orders of vanishing of L-functions, leading to the celebrated Beilinson conjectures. For the algebraic geometers, I should also mention Beilinson's generalization of the Hodge conjectures, which relate certain groups of transcendental cohomology classes to K-theory. The work of Quillen, cited above, provides the foundation for much of this work, and forms the core of these notes. The more algebraically minded reader may prefer, at a first reading, to read Chapters 1, 3, 4, and 5, skip the more topological Chapters 2, 6, and 7, and go on to applications of interest. The somewhat long Appendix A should, I hope, help such a reader to eventually work through the "topological" chapters. The detailed contents of the notes are as follows (this is for the benefit of readers who may already have some acquaintance with K-theory, say at the level of K0, and to state where we have omitted topics from Quillen's papers). Chapter 1 contains a quick review of "classical" K-theory (i.e., K0, K1, K2), mainly based on Milnor's book. In Chapter 2, Quillen's plus construction is given, leading to the definition K~(R) - 7h(BGL(R) +) for i >_ 1, for the higher K-groups of a ring. We construct products Ki(R) | Kj(R) --, K~+j(R), following Loday. We also show that K1, K2 agree with the "classical" K1, K2 of Chapter 1. Chapters 3-7 contain our exposition of "Higher Algebraic K-Theory I", and the comparison of the plus and Q constructions for Ki. Chapter 3
Preface to the First Edition
xiii
introduces the language of simplicial sets, and leads to the basic notion of the classifying space BC of a small category C. This leads to a "dictionary" between category theory and topology, under which we have the following correspondences: small category functor natural transformation adjoint functors category with an initial or final object
; topological space (CW complex) ; cellular map , homotopy , homotopy inverse pair of maps ~ contractible space
In Chapter 4, we give Quillen's Q construction, using the K-groups of a small exact category C in terms of the homotopy groups of the classifying space of its associated Quillen category QC, Ki(C) = ~r,+l (BQC). We then state a number of purely "K-theoretic" results, contained in the first part of "Algebraic K-Theory r' (the computation of K0, and the theorems on exact sequences of functors, resolution, ddvissage, and localization). Given that K0 is the same as that defined "classically", these theorems express standard facts about K0. However, the extensions to the higher K~ involve a lot of new machinery. As such, we postpone the proofs of these results to Chapter 6. In Chapter 5, we apply the results of Chapter 4 to study the K-theory of rings and schemes (the second part of "Higher Algebraic K-Theory I" ). If R is a ring (or a Noetherian ring), let Ki(R) (or G~(R), respectively) be the K-groups of the category of finitely generated projective R-modules (or of all finitely generated R-modules, respectively). We first prove the formulas G,(R[t]) ~- G,(R), G,(R[t,t-1]) ~- G,(R) $ G,_I(R). (Quillen deduces these formulas from more general results about filtered rings, which we omit; we also omit the applications to computing Ki for certain division rings.) For a (Soetherian separated) scheme X, define K~(X) (or G,(X), respectively) using the category of vector bundles (or coherent sheaves, respectively). We first study the groups Gi(X), and in particular construct the BGQ-spectral sequence
E[ 'q = (~codimx=p K_p_q(k(x)) ~
C_p_q(X)
using the filtration of the category of coherent sheaves given by "codimension of support." We give Quillen's proof of Gersten's conjecture for a power series ring, and for the semi-local ring obtained from a finite set of
xiv
Algebraic K-Theory
smooth points on a variety over an infinite field (Quillen proves it, more generally, assuming only that the variety is regular over a field). This is used to obtain Bloch's formula
CHv(X) = Hv(X, lCv,x) where GHv(X) is the Chow group of Mgebraic cycles of codimension p on X modulo rational equivalence, and/Cp,x is a sheaf for the Zariski topology with stalks Kv(O~,x). This generalizes the familiar formula Pic(X) HI(x, 0~) for the Picard group of invertib]e sheaves on X. Chapter 5 ends with the computation of Ki for a projective bundle, and for a SeveriBrauer scheme. Chapter 6 contains the proofs of the results stated in Chapter 4. We begin by computing K0 using simplicia] coverings. We then prove Quillen's Theorem A, which gives a criterion for a functor to induce a homotopy equivalence on classifying spaces, and Theorem B, which identifies the homotopy fiber of such a map on classifying spaces, in certain cases. These proofs make use of various topological results proved (or discussed) in Appendix A. Theorems A and B are then used to give "algebraic" proofs of the remaining results of Chapter 4 (exactness, resolution, d6vissage, and localization). Chapter 7 is devoted to the proof that "+ -- Q", using the notions of monoida] categories, and actions of these on other categories. A monoidal category is, roughly speaking, a (small) category S, together with a functor + : S x S ~ S which is "associative" and has an "identity". Thus the classifying space B S becomes an H-space ("homotopy monoid"). The basic example for us is ,~ = IsoP(R), the category whose objects are finitely generated projective modules, and whose arrows are all isomorphisms of projective modules; the operation + is the direct sum. The set ~0(BS) of path components is just the monoid of isomorphism classes of projective R-modules. The construction of S - 1 S yields an H-group ("group up to homotopy") with an H - m a p B,~ ~ B S - 1 S , which is "universal up to homotopy" among such maps; on ~0, this just yields the Grothendieck group Ko(R). One first shows that there is a homotopy equivalence Ko(R) x BGL(R) + ~- B S - I S by computing the homology of B S - t S . Then, using Quillen's extension construction, one shows that B 8 - 1 , ~ is homotopy-equivalent to the loop space of BQT'(R). This yields the isomorphisms ~i(BGL(R) +) ~- ~i+1 (BQP(R)), relating the two definitions of K~(R), and in particular identifying K1 (R), K2(R) with the groups of Chapter 1. Chapter 8 gives the proof of the theorem of Merkurjev and Suslin, relating/(2 and the Brauer group of a field. Let F be a field containing a primitive n-th root of unity. Then the theorem states that the natural
Preface to the First Edition
xv
map (the "Galois Symbol" or "Norm Residue homomorphism") gives an isomorphism: K2(F) | Z / n Z ~- , S r ( F ) . We give the proof of this theorem in detail, based on an expository article by Suslin. We omit only one step in the proof r a t h e argument (see Prop. (8.7)(c)) using Gillet's Riemann-Roch theorem for the vanishing of certain differentials in the BGQ spectral sequence, up to torsion; the proof of the Riemann-Roch theorem involves tools from K-theory and topology beyond the scope of these notes (e.g., the homotopy theory of simplicial sheaves). We then prove the relevant easy case of the results of Bloch and Ogus, and deduce the result that if X is a smooth variety over an algebraically closed field, then the n-torsion subgroup nCH2(X) of the Chow group of codimension-2 cycles on X is finite. We also prove Roitman's theorems on torsion-zero cycles. Chapter 9 begins with Quillen's localization theorem for singular varieties, contained in the latter half of "Higher Algebraic K-Theory II", leading to the Fundamental Theorem (computation of K~(R[t]), K~(R[t,t-~])). Next, we give a generalization of Quillen's localization theorem due to Levine, and use it to obtain a presentation for Ko(C.n), where Cn is the category of R-modules of finite length and finite projective dimension over the local ring R of a normal surface singularity. This is used to show that quotient singularities do not contribute to the Chow group of zero cycles on a normal surface. Appendix A discusses the topological results needed in the main text. We sketch proofs for standard results when these are not too long, and give references in other cases. We also give more detailed proofs for the results of Dold and Thorn on quasi fibrations, and of some results on H-spaces, and on simplicial sets, which are perhaps less standard. Appendix B discusses category theory, and in particular contains the construction of the quotient of a small Abelian category by a Serre subcategory. Appendix C deals with spectral sequences from the point of view of exact couples. Though this is standard in topology, it seems to be less familiar to algebraists. We give an ad hoc treatment of convergence that suffices for our purposes. A word about sources w Chapters 4-7, and the first half of Chapter 9, are based on the work of Quillen cited above. For the other chapters, we list a few main sources at the beginning of the chapter, and give other references in the course of the text. The absence of a specific reference, however, does not imply any claim to originality on my part; in fact, all the material covered in these notes (with the exception of parts of Chapter 9 on singular surfaces) is based on other sources.
xvi
Algebraic K-Theory
Acknowledgements I must thank the people who attended the original course of lectures, and made many comments that clarified my ideas, primarily the members of the "algebra school" at the Tata Institute. I began learning algebraic geometry and K-theory when I was a graduate student at Chicago, from Bloch, Murthy, and Swan; at the Tata Institute, I have also learned a lot from Mohan Kumar and Madhav Nori; to all these people, I owe a considerable debt. I received generous help from several people on topics connected with these notes: Balwant Singh, Bhatwadekar, Coombes, Dalawat, Esnault, Lemaire, Levine, Parimala, Paranjape, Pati, Raghunathan, Ramanan, Roy, Simha, Soule, Sridharan, Stienstra, Suslin, and Vaserstein. Thanks are also due to M.K. Priyan for the major effort of typing the first version of the notes, and to K.P. Shivaraman for help with the final version.
Preface to the Second Edition Apart from the improved typescript, now rendered in TEX, there are two main changes in the second edition. Several people with more of a background in topology, but who were unfamiliar with algebraic geometry, commented to me that the first edition of the book was difficult for them to follow. In response to these comments, I have added Appendix D, entitled "Results from Algebraic Geometry," which contains all the definitions and results (with sketches of proofs, and/or suitable references) needed to understand Chapter 5. I have also added suitable cross-references to this appendix throughout Chapter 5. The reader who masters this material ought to be able to also read Chapters 8 and 9, consulting the references given there. Secondly, I have rewritten major parts of Chapter 8, based on a later proof of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem given by Merkurjev in Uontemp. Math. 55, Part II, A.M.S. (1986). This proof is more elementary than the one given in the first edition of this book, in that higher K-theory and K-cohomology are needed only to prove Hilbert's Theorem 90 for Kz. The treatment of the Merkurjev-Suslin theorem now given is thus self-contained (at least with respect to K-theory), as we do not need to invoke the theory of Chern classes or the Riemann-Roch theorem for higher K-groups. A reader interested in the connections with Cyclic Homology (or "additive K-theory") can consult the book J.-L. Lodny, Cyclic Homology,Grundlehren Math. 301, SpringerVerlag (1992). The reader would also do well to consult the book J. Rosenberg, Algebraic K-Theory and Its Applications, Graduate Texts No. 147, Springer-Verlag (1994). His treatment of K-theory assumes less background of the reader than mine, but covers different ground. The book also gives some historical background, discusses the connections with number theory, C*-algebras, etc. and contains a more complete list of references. Thanks are due to Birkh~iuser-Boston, and in particular Ann Kostant, for the job of rendering the manuscript into TF_/X, to obtain the muchimproved result now before the reader. V. Srinivas Bombay, 1995
1. "Classical"
K-Theory
The main reference used here is Milnor's book: Introduction to Algebraic K-Theory, Annals of Mathematical Studies, No. 72, Princeton University Press (1971). Let R be an associative ring (with 1), and let 7~(R) denote the category of finitely generated projective R-modules. We define the Grothendieck group Ko(R) to be the quotient
go(R) = y / n , ~" = free Abelian group on the isomorphism classes of projective modules in P(R), = subgroup generated by elements [P (9 Q ] - [ P ] - [Q], for all P, Q E P(R). Thus, for any P, Q E P(R), [P] = [Q] in Ko(R) ~ P (9 P' ~- Q (9 P' for s o m e P ' E 79(R) ~ P ( g R = ~ Q ( g R n for s o m e n >_ 0. Indeed, if [p] = [Q] in K 0 ( R ) , then we have a relation in jr of the form T
8
i=1
j=l
[P]- [Q] = ~([P/(9 Q/]- [P/]- [Q/I)- Z([P~ (9 Q~]- [P~I- [Q~]). Hence T
[Q] + ~ [ e ,
8
(9 Q,] + ~ ( [ P ; ] + [Q;]) =
i=1
[P]
j-----1
T
8
+ Z ( [ P , ] + [Q,]) + ~ [ P ; i=1
(9 Q;]
j----1
in ~ , the free Abelian group on isomorphism classes in 7)(R). Hence the terms on the right must be a permutation of the set of terms on the left. In particular, if we let
P'=
P, (gQ,)
(9
(gQ~)
then P (9 P ' ~ Q (9 P'. Thus, we have shown that [P] = [Q] in Ko(R) --> P $ P' ~ Q (9 P ' for some P ' E P(R). The converse is obvious. Further, we can find Q' E 7~(R) such that P' (9 Q' ~ R" for some n, since P ' is a
2
Algebraic K-Theory
quotient of some R n ( P ' is finitely generated) and p t is projective. Hence p $ p ' ~- Q ~ P' ~ P @ Rn ~ Q (g R n. If f : R -4 S is a homomorphism of rings, f induces a functor P ( R ) --. P ( S ) given by P : ; S | P. This preserves direct sums, and hence induces a homomorphism f . : K0 (R) --, K0 (S). E x a m p l e (1.1). Let (R,j~4) be a local ring, i.e., R is a possibly noncommutative ring (with 1), .h4 C R is a 2-sided maximal ideal, and R - . h 4 = R*, the group of units. Then Ko(R) = Z, with a generator given by the class of the free R-module of rank 1. Indeed, there is a natural h o m o m o r p h i s m p" g o ( R )
, go(R/M)
= Z,
since R / f l 4 is a division ring, and a finitely generated projective (left) R / f l 4 - m o d u l e is a left vector space, i.e., a free R / M - m o d u l e of rank equal to t h e dimension of the vector space. T h u s p is surjective, since p([Rn]) is the cla~s of a vector space of dimension n; we prove t h a t in fact every projective R-module is free, so t h a t p is an isomorphism. Let P E P ( R ) , and let d i m R / ~ P / . M P = n. Choose x l , . . . ,xn E P whose images :~I,...,:E n E P / f l 4 P give a basis for the ( R / A d R ) - v e c t o r space. We claim t h a t X l , . . . ,xn give a basis for P as a free R-module. Let Q E :P(R) such that P (9 Q ~ R ~+m is a free module, where we m u s t have m = dimR/y~Q/A/IQ. Let X n + l , . . . , x m + n E Q m a p to a basis of Q / A 4 Q over R / M R , so t h a t x l , . . . , x m + n E R m+n give a basis of ( R / f l 4 R ) m+n. We claim then t h a t x l , . . . , x m + ~ give a basis for the free R-module R re+n, which immediately implies t h a t X l , . . . ,xn E P , X ~ + l , . . . , xm+n E Q give bases, so t h a t P , Q are free R-modules of ranks n, m, respectively. Let xi = (ail,...,ai,m+n) E R m+n. It suffices to prove t h a t A = [aij] e GLm+n(R), i.e., A has a 2-sided inverse. If a q : ; ~q e R / . M , and ft. = [5ij], then A E GLm+n(R/.h4), so there exists B E U m + n ( R ) , with B : ; B E GLm+n(R/A4), and A B = B A = Ira+n, where Im+n is the identity matrix. Then A B - B A - Im+,,(modA4), and so A B = [c~j] with c~i E R*, c~i E f14 for i ~ j. Hence, there exists an elementary m a t r i x E with A B E = d i a g ( c l , . . . ,cm+n) for suitable c l , . . . , c ~ + n E R*, i.e., A B can be diagonalized by right column operations, involving adding a right multiple of a column to another c o l u m n - - w e m a y first add a suitable multiple of the first column to each of the other columns to make all offdiagonal entries on the first row vanish; this does not alter the condition t h a t other off diagonal entries lie in r and diagonal entries are units, since R is local; now perform a similar reduction of the second row, etc.
1. "Classical" K-Theory
3
Since d i a g ( c l , . . . , am+n) is invertible, A has a right inverse. By a similar argument using row operations on B A, we see that A has a left inverse. Since matrix multiplication is associative, A is invertible. E x a m p l e (1.2). Let R be a Dedekind domain, i.e., R is a commutative Noetherian integrally closed domain such that every non-zero prime ideal of R is maximal. Then Ko(R) ~ Z (9 Ct(R) where Ct(R) is the ideal class group of R, defined to be the group of isomorphism classes of invertible ideals (with tensor product as the group operation--see Milnor's book for details). D e f i n i t i o n of K1. Let R be an associative ring (with 1), GLn(R) the group of invertible matrices of size n over R; let En(R) be the subgroup of elementary matrices, defined to be the group generated by the matrices e~. ) (A) , 1 < _(n) (A) is the unipotent matrix whose - i # j < - n, A e R, where ~ij only non-trivial off-diagonal entry is A in the (i,j)th position. Thus, if i < j , then ~ij -(") (A) has the form j t h column
!
"1
" " ' ~
0
0 0
0
, ith row.
...1...
~ . . .
0
0
......
0
1
Let GLn(R) "--. GLn+I(R) by A:
,[Ao
0]1
and let GL(R) = lim GLn(R). Similarly, let E(R) = lim En(R). Since ; _(n+l) e~)(A) : vq (A) under En(R) "-, En+I(R), we obtain matrices eq(A)
E E(R) as the common image of all the e~)(A) for n >_ i, j, and E ( R ) is the subgroup of GL(R) generated by the eq(A). The eq(A) satisfy the following identities:
(1.3) b) legaCY), ktCt,)l = 1 for j # k, i # t
4
Algebraic K-Theory
These identities are deduced from similar identities for the e~)(A). We deduce immediately that En (R) is perfect for n > 3 (i.e., [En (R), En (R)] En(R)) and E(R) is perfect. L e m m a (1.4) (Whitehead). For any A e GLn(R),
[a 0] 0 A-'
Proof.
e E2n(R).
For any B E Mn(R), it is easy to see that
[~ ,] [,. 0] o
I,,'
B
I,~
lie in E2n(R). Now use the identity
[0~ 0] [ ,. A -~
=
0][,.,~][ ,. 0][,. All
A-I-I,~
In
0
In
A-In
In
0
I,~
"
P r o p o s i t i o n (1.5). E(R) = [E(R),E(R)] = [GL(R), GL(R)]. P r o o L We have already noted that E ( R ) is perfect, so it suffices to note that for any A , B e GLn(R),
[A,AI~I 0] [A~ 0 ][Ai 0][~1 0] 0
In
=
0
(AB) -1
0
A
0
B
and the right side lies in E~n(R) by Lemma (1.4). Definition.
K1 (R) -- GL(R)/[GL(R), GL(R)] -- G L ( R ) / E ( R ) - H I ( G L ( R ) , Z ) (the definitions are equivalent by Proposition (1.5), and the isomorphism
gl (G, Z) ~ G a b - G/[G, G] for any G). E x a m p l e (1.6). Let (R,.h4) be a (possibly non-commutative) local ring. Then the natural map GLI(R) -~ K1 (R) induces an isomorphism
R*/[R*, R*] ~ K, (R). Indeed, let
~. = (R*) -b If A = [ao] E GL,,(R), then by adding another column to the first one if necessary, we may assume all E R* (any row or column must have an entry in R*, since A = [hij] e G L n ( R / . M ) has a non-zero entry in every row and column). Adding multiples of the first column to the others, we
1. "Classical" K-Theory
5
can make a li = 0 for all i > 1. Similarly, we work on the second row to make a22 E R*, a2i = 0 for i # 2, etc. Thus, after column operations, given by right multiplication by an element of E n ( R ) , we can make A diagonal without changing its image in K1 (R). Now by the Whitehead lemma (1.4), we deduce t h a t the image of A in K1 (R) lies in the image of R* = GL1 (R). Hence R* --~ g l (R). Since g l (R) is Abelian, we have an induced surjection n* = n ' / [ n * , n * ]
.
(n).
Next, if x, y E R such t h a t 1 - x y E R*, we claim t h a t 1 - y x E R* also, and (1 - xy)(1 - y x ) -1 E [R*, R*]. If 1 - xy, y e R* then
with yl E [R*,R*] proving our claim in this case. A similar a r g u m e n t works if x E R*. So we may assume x, y E j~4, in which case clearly 1 - y x , 1 - x y E R*. If xl = l + x - xy, then x l , 1 - y x l , 1 - x l y E R*, and we compute t h a t (1-xy)(1-y)=l-y-xy+xy (1 -
y
)(1 -
y) = 1 - y-
and
2=l-xly, +
= 1 -
Hence (1 - x y ) ( 1 - y x ) - 1 - (1 - x l y ) ( 1
-
y X l ) - 1 E [R*, R*].
as claimed. (I learned this argument from L. Vaserstein, who has used analogous arguments to compute K1 for most semi-local rings.) We now show t h a t there is a well-defined determinant homomorphism det " G L ( R ) ~ R*, satisfying (i) d e t ( A B ) = det A . det B (ii) det A = 1 for all A e E ( R ) (iii) the composite R* = G L l ( R ) tient map.
, GL(R)
det
~. is the natural quo-
Our construction of 'det' follows the treatment given in Artin's book Geometric Algebra of the determinant over division rings. It suffices to construct a compatible family of maps detn 9 G L , ( R ) --. R* such t h a t m
1),~ if A E G L n ( R ) , and A r is obtained from A by multiplying a column on the right by ~ E R*, then detn A t = ~ - d e t n A, where # ; ; ~ E R* m
2),~ if A E G L n ( R ) and A ~ is obtained from A by adding a right multiple of a column to another column, then detn A ~ = detn A 3),, if In E G L n ( R ) is the identity matrix, detn In = 1, the image of 1 E R* in R*. m
6
Algebraic K-Theory
We prove by induction on n that detn exists, and observe at once that detn, if it exists, is characterized by the above properties, since any A E GLn(R) can be transformed by operations as in 2)n to a matrix a
0 1 1
,
~
0
a E R*,
1
so that detn A -- 5 E R*, by 1)n and 3)n. Further, if detn exists, it must satisfy: a) detnIGL._l(R) = detn-1 b) detn(AB) = detn(A)" detn(B) c) if A' is obtained from A by interchanging 2 columns, detn A ~ = (---1) 9 detn A. We establish b), and leave a), c) to the reader (see Artin's book for details)" write B = diag(b, 1 , . . . , 1). B' with b E R*, B' E En(R). Then detn B = b by 2)n. Similarly
detn(AB) = detn(A, diag(b, 1 , . . . , 1)) (by 2)n) =b.det, A (byl)n) = detnA- detnB, since R* is commutative 9 P r o o f T h a t detn Exists. Clearly detl exists and is the natural quotient R* -+ R*. Assume n > 1, and by induction, detn_ 1 exists, and hence is well determined and satisfies a), b), c) above. Let A E GLn(R) have columns A t , . . . ,An, so that A = [A1,... ,An]. Then the columns Ai give a basis for the free right R-module R n of columns of length n, so that there is a unique 1 0 linear combination ~ AiAi = . , the first standard basis vector. Clearly 0
atleastoneA,
E R* 9 W r i t e A , = [ aBi li],B,
E R n-1 , ati E R, so that
aliA~ = 1 and ~ BiA~ = 0. For any i, let C~ = [B1,... ,B~-I, BI++,...] be the matrix with columns B1,..., Bi_l, B i + l , . . . , Bn. If A~ E R*, then 1 0 clearly A 1 , . . . , Ai_l, A i + t , . . . , An, 9 form another basis for the free 0
right module of columns R ~, so that B 1 , . . . , Bi-1, B i + l , . . . , Bn form a
1. "Classical" K-Theory
7
basis for the free right module of columns R n-1. Hence A~ E R* ~
Ci E
GLn_,(R). If Ai, Aj E R* with i < j, then by 2)n-i we get det~_, [B,,..., B~_I, B~A~,..., Bj_,, Bj+,,..., B~]
= detn_I[B,,...,B~_,,-BjAj,B~+I,...,Bj_,,Bj+I,...,B~], where both matrices lie in GL,~_,(R) since Ai, Aj e R*, and Ci, Cj e GL,~_I(R). Thus we have (the o verbar denotes the image in R*) d e t n - l C j = (----T)J-i-lA~-l(-Aj)detn-1 (Ci)
i.e., (_-_---T)i + 1L - 1detn_ 1(Ci) = (---T)~+ 1~j - 1detn_ 1(C~), if AiA/ E R*. Define detn A = (-'ZT)i+IA~-I det,,_l(Ci) for any i such that Ai E R*; this is well defined by the above remarks. We have to verify 1)n, 2)n, 3),, of which 3)n is obvious. 1)n" Suppose Ai is replaced by Aip, for some/~ E R*. Then Ai is replaced by/~-1Ai, and the remaining Aj are unchanged. If Ai E R*, Ci is unchanged, and #-1)ki E .R*, SO that detnA' = ( - ' ~ ) i + I ( # - I A i ) - I
detn-1 (Ci)
= p detnA. If A1 E R* with j r i, a column of Cj is multiplied by/~ to get C~, so t h a t d e t , A' = (----1)i+1 ~ 1 . detn-1 (C~) ---- ( - - T ) i + l , ~ , j l ( / ~ ,
9 det,_l(Ci))
= ~ . detnA.
2)n: Suppose Ai is replaced by A~ + Ai# for some # in R. Then Aj is replaced by Aj - pAi, while Ak is unchanged for k ~ j, since (A~ + Aj/~)A~ + Aj(A~ -/~A~) = A~A~ + AjAj. If some Ak E R*, k ~ i,j then C~ is obtained from Ck by a column operation, and so detn A' = (---T)k+IA~ 1 detn C~ = detn A. If Ai E R*, (7' = Ci and A' = A~, so that detn A' = det~ A. Finally, if Aj e R* and Ak E A4 for k ~- j, then we compute that if i < j (the computations when i > j are similar), C~ = [B1,... ,B~_I,B~ + Bjp, B~+~,...,Bj_~,B.~+I,...] = [B~, ..., Bi_l, B,(I
- ~
-
AiA;1]~)
BkAkA-~'p,B,+,,...,Bj_,,Bj+,,...]
[B~,...,B~_~,B,(1 - A~j-~#), B~+~,... ,B.i_I,Bj+~,...],
8
Algebraic K-Theory
where + ; denotes the result of a column operation. This last matrix is obtained from Cj by multiplying the ith column of the right by 1 - AiAf 1# E R* (since Ai E r Hence detnA' = (---T)J+I(Aj - # ) q ) - l ( 1 - AiA~x~u) 9detnCj = (Aj - #Ai) - 1 . (1 - AiA~l/z) 9 A j - d e t n A . So we must show t h a t
Aj - #Ai = A = Aj (1 - AiA~-1) in/~* r
(I - #uAiAj -I) = (I - AiA~-I#)
since
r
(1 - # . (AiAj-1)) = (1 - (A,Aj-X)/z)
--is
a homomorphism
which has the form (1 x y ) = (1 - yx), with x = / z , y = A+A~-x ~ A4. But we have seen that this relation holds in R*. This completes the proof t h a t detn has all the required properties. C o r o l l a r y (1.7) (Dieudonnd). If D is a division ring, then K I ( D ) D*/[D*,D*], induced by the Dieudonnd determinant G L ( D ) ~ (D*) ab. E x a m p l e (1.8). Let R be a commutative ring. The determinant gives a surjection G L ( R ) --+ R* split by GL1 (R) ~ G L ( R ) . Let S L ( R ) C G L ( R ) be the group of matrices with determinant 1. Then [ S L ( R ) , S L ( R ) ] = E ( R ) . Let S K i ( R ) = S L ( R ) / [ S L ( R ) , SL(R)] = S L ( R ) / E ( R ) . Then we have a natural split exact sequence
O:
; SKI(R) ~
KI (R)
, R*
~0.
E x a m p l e (1.9) (Mennicke symbol). Let R be a commutative ring, a, b ~ R such that a R + bR = R. Choose c, d E R so that a d - be = 1, and define the Mennicke symbol [a, b] e SK1 ( R)
tobethectassof[a c
db] i n S K l ( R ) .
Then
(i) [a, b] is well defined. (ii) [a, b] = [b, a]; if a e R*, [a, b] = 1 for all b e R. (iii) [ala2, b] = lax, b][a2, b] if a,a2R + bR = R. (iv) [a, b] = [a + Ab, b] for all A e n. (v) If R is Noetherian of Krull dimension < 1, then the Mennicke symbols generate S K i ( R ) (see Bass: Algebraic K-Theory).
1. "Classical" K-Theory
9
(vi) If R is Noetherian of Krull dimension < 1 with finite residue fields at all maximal ideals, then SK1 (R) is torsion. (vii) If R is a Euctidean domain
(e.g., Z, Z[i], k[t] where k is a field) then
SKI(R) -- O. (viii) If R is the ring of algebraic integers in an algebraic number field (a finite algebraic extension of Q) then SK~(R) = 0 (see Milnor's book, Ch. 16). D e f i n i t i o n o f K 2 . Let R be a ring. The nth Steinberg group Stn(R) is defined to be the quotient of the free group on symbols ~ _(n) (~) for 1 < i,j < n, i ~ j, and for all A E R, modulo the normal subgroup generated by the words:
(i)
- ( " ) ( # ) . x~; ) (A + #) - ' for all i, j, for all A, # e R x,j
(ii) [x~. ) (A), x(~ ) (#)1 for i ~/~, k ~ j, for all A,/z e R (iii) [x~. ) (A), ~jk "(n) (#)]" ~ik ,,.(n) (,X#)- 1 for i r k, for all X, # E R. From (1.3) we have a natural surjection Cn : Stn(R) --, En(R), given by Cn(x~-J(X)) = e~)(A). We also have natural homomorphisms Stn(R) --' Stn+t(R) (which need not be injective), and so we obtain the infinite Steinberg group St(R) = aim Stn(R), and the surjection r
St(R)
} E(R).
D e f i n i t i o n . K2(R) - ker r Let xij(X) E St(R) be the common image of x_(n) ij (X), for any n > i, j, where i r j, and X E R. L e m m a (1.9). K2(R) /s the center of St(R). P r o o f . It is easy to see that the center of E(R) is trivial, so that the center of St(R) lies in K2(R). Hence it suffices to prove t h a t K2(R) is central in
St(R).
Suppose a e K2(R)f3 image(Stn_,(R) --, St(R)), i.e., a can be expressed as a word in the xo(A ) with i , j < n. Let Pn be the subgroup of St(R) generated by all the xin(#), 1 <_ i < n - 1, # E R. Then from the relation (ii) in Stm(R), m > n, we deduce that 1), is commutative. From (i), x~i(0 ) = 1, so t h a t each element of Pn has a unique expression in the form Zln(]-tl) ...Xn-l,n(l~n-1),~l,...,l~n-I
E R,
10
Algebraic K-Theory
SLn(R) C GL(R)
and r is a n i s o m o r p h i s m o n t o t h e g r o u p of m a t r i c e s in of t h e f o r m 1 0 --- 0 /zl 1
--- 0 #2 9 -. 1 ~tn-1 9 -- 0 1 N o w we c o m p u t e t h a t if i, j < n t h e n 9
"
ifj#k
=
ifj =k
so t h a t t h e given class a e K2(R) n o r m a l i z e s Pn. Since CIR. is injective, while r = 1, c~ centralizes Pn, i.e., [cr, xm(A)] = 0 for all 1 < i < n - 1, A E R. B y a similar a r g u m e n t we see t h a t [c~, xnj(A)] = 0 for all 1 < j < n - 1, A e R. H e n c e a c o m m u t e s w i t h [xjn(A),xn,(~)] = xji(A~t) for all A, # E R, 1 < j # i < n - 1. Since n c a n b e t a k e n t o b e a r b i t r a r i l y large, we are d o n e . T h u s
,, st(n)----, E(R)
o - - , K (n)
o
is a c e n t r a l e x t e n s i o n of E ( R ) . Definition.
If G is a g r o u p , a c e n t r a l e x t e n s i o n
(E)... is called a
0
;g
-H
universal central extension o f
(E')...
0
,K'J
;G
;0
G if for a n y o t h e r c e n t r a l e x t e n s i o n
~H'
t h e r e is a u n i q u e h o m o m o r p h i s m f : H
,G---,0, ; H ' o v e r G.
Remark. In the above situation, f l K " K ~ K' in fact d e t e r m i n e s ( E ' ) u p t o i s o m o r p h i s m , in t h e following sense. If K ' is a n y A b e l i a n g r o u p , g: K .~ K ' a n y h o m o m o r p h i s m , t h e n t h e p u s h o u t o f K
~
H
Kl yields a c e n t r a l e x t e n s i o n (E") ...
0
, K'
.- H x K K '
: G ~
0.
If g = f[K w h e r e f - H ~ H ' is as a b o v e , t h e n b y t h e universal p r o p e r t y of t h e p u s h o u t , t h e r e is a m a p H x K K ' ." H ' g i v i n g a d i a g r a m 0
;
K'
;
0
}
K'
~
II
HXKK'
H'
~
G
~
0
=~- G
~
0
II
1. "Classical" K-Theory
11
Hence ( E " ) and ( E ' ) are isomorphic central extensions of G. F r o m homological algebra, it is s t a n d a r d t h a t central extensions of G by an Abelian group K ~, up to isomorphism, are classified by elements of H Z ( G , K ' ) , where K ' is regarded as a G-module with trivial action. From t h e above remarks, if (E) is a universal central extension with kernel K , t h e n we have an isomorphism H2(G, K ' ) ~- H o m ( K , K ' ) of functors on the c a t e g o r y of Abelian groups. From the proposition below, we also have H1 (G, Z) = 0, since G has a universal central extension; hence by the universal coefficient theorem, H 2 ( G , K ') ~- Hom(H:2(G,Z),K') is an isomorphism of functors. Thus, g ~ H2(G, Z). Proposition
( 1 . 1 0 ) . (a) A central extension
(E)...
0
,K
,H
,a
,0
is universal r H is perfect (i.e., H I ( H , Z ) = H/[H,H] = O) and every central extension of H is split (i.e., H2(H, Z) = O, from the above remarks). (b) G has a universal central extension ~ G is perfect. Outline of Proof. G: (E')...
(a) (r 0
let (E') be an arbitrary central extension of ,K'
,H'
,G
,0.
T h e pull-back of ( E t) along H ~. G is a cemral extension of H , which must be trivial. Hence the projection
p2 : H ' x c H
~.H
has a section s : H ~ H ' x G H, and f = pl o s : H ~. H ' is a m a p over G. To prove t h a t f is unique, we see that if f~ is another m a p H ~H ~ over G, and x, y E H are arbitrary, then f ' ( x ) = a f ( x ) , f ' ( y ) = b f ( y ) with a, b E K ' n c e n t e r ( n ' ) . T h u s f'([x, V]) = [f'(x), f'(v)] = I f ( x ) , f(v)] = f([x, y]) since f, f ' are homomorphisms. Since H = [H, HI, f ' = f . ( ~ ) If
(E) . . .
0
,K
,n
0 ~G
-~0
is a central extension such t h a t H is not perfect, then there is a non-zero map r : H ~ A for some Abelian group A. If H ' = A x G is t h e split central extension of G by A, then f = (0, 0) and f ' = (r 9) are 2 distinct homomorphisms H ---4 H ' over G. Hence (E) cannot be universal, unless H is perfect. If (E) is universal, and if 0
~K'
; H'
~ H
~0
12
Algebraic K-Theory
is a central extension, then one shows t h a t the induced surjection H ' ~G has a central kernel; hence there is a (unique) map H ; H ' over G, which must be a section of H ' ; H (one first shows that [H', H'] is perfect, and r H; if x0 e ~ - x ( g ) , then x ~-. x o x x o 1 gives a map [H', g ' ] ----* [g', H'] over H). (b) If G has a universal central extension
(E)...
0
~.g
,H---,G---.O
then H = [ g , g ] by (a) above, so G = [G, G]. Conversely, if G = [G, G], and F , G is a surjection from a free group to G, giving a presentation 0
~.R---*F
DO,
~.G
then o
, R / t F , R] - - 4 F / [ f , R]
, G --- 0
is a central extension, and o
'
R n IF, F]
IF, R]
, [F, FI/[F, R]
, G ---, 0
is a central extension with [F, F]/[F, R] as a perfect group. One directly verifies t h a t this is a universal central extension: given any central extension
(E)...
0
~.K---~H
~G
;0,
there is a map F ; g over G (as F is free), which kills IF, R] since (E) is central; as in (a), the restriction of this map to [F, F] is independent of the choice of F , H over G. P r o p o s i t i o n (1.11). (a) S t ( R ) and S t n ( R ) , n > 3 are perfect. (b) S t ( R ) and Stn(R), n > 5 have no non-split central extensions. Corollary
(1.12). The extension 0
, K2(R)
; St(R)
, E(R)----, 0
is a universal central extension of E ( R ) . In particular, K2(R) = H 2 ( E ( R ) , Z ) . P r o o f o f (1.11). (a) is clear from the definitions of Stn(R), S t ( R ) . (b) (Outline) Let
(E)...
0
:~. g ~
g
r
~0
be a central extension. For each i ~ j and each xij(X), choose h ~ i, j, and let yl e ~b-l(xih(1)), Y2 e r Then y,j(X) -- [Yl,Y2] e
1. "Classical" K-Theory
13
r is independent of the choices of yl, y2, since (E) is a central extension. One checks that (i) yij(A) does not depend on the choice of h ~ i,j (ii) {y,j(A)} satisfy the Steinberg identities (1.3)(a), (b), (c). Thus, xij(A) 9 ; yij (A) gives a section of r St,,(R), n > 5.
A similar argument works for
P r o d u c t s . Suppose R is a commutative ring. Then the tensor product (P, Q) ---' P | Q on projective modules induces a pairing
K0(R) |
K0(R)
, Ko(R)
making Ko(R) into a commutative, associative ring, with identity element given by the class [R] of the free module of rank 1. We claim that there are natural pairings
Ko(R) |
K,(R)
, Ki(R), i = 1, 2
making K~(R), i = 1,2 into K0(R)-modules. Given a projective module P and a matrix A E GLn(R), choose a projective module Q such t h a t P ~ Q '~ R m is free, and fix such an isomorphism. Then we have an automorphism (A | 1p) $ (1R~ | 1Q) e Aut(R n |
(P 9 Q)) ~- GLmn(R).
If hp : GLn(R) ~. GL(R) is the resulting map, then it is well defined up to an inner conjugation on GL(R). If h p ' G L n ( R ) } KI(R) is induced by composing with the natural quotient map, then h p l e p 2 = hpl + hp2, so hp depends only on the class [P] e Ko(R). Thus one gets a well defined product Ko(R) | K1 (R) ~ K1 (R). Next, we note that hp(En (R)) lies in the commutator subgroup E ( R ) C GL(R), and one checks~ that the induced map En(R) ----, E(R) is well defined up to an inner conjugation of E(R). Hence hp induces a m a p (hp). : H2(En(R),Z) } H2(E(R),Z). Further, one can check (hp| -(h-pp). + (hQ).. Hence the induced map
(hp). " H2(E(R), Z) = lim H2(En(R), Z) --4
; H2(E(R), Z)
depends only on the class [P] E Ko(R). This gives a product Ko(R) |
K2(R)
, K2(R).
I To verify that hp 9 En(R) , E(R) is well defined up to an inner conjugation, we note that it factors through E,~(R); now conjugation by B E GLmn(R) agrees with conjugation by [B0 B-1 0 ] E E2m~(R) C E(R) on the subgroup
14
Algebraic K-Theory
E x a m p l e (1.13). Let R be a commutative ring, R[t, t -1] the Laurent polynomials over R. Change of rings yields a homomorphism ~ : Ko(R) go(R[t,t-1]). Since t e R[t,t-1] * C GL(R), t gives a class in g l (R[t, t - l ] ) . Composing c~ with multiplication by It] E g l (R[t, t - l ] ) yields a map r g o ( R ) -~. g l ( R [ t , t-l]). It turns out that r is always injective, and its image is (functorially) a direct summand in KI(R[t, t - ' ] ) . Next, for commutative rings R, we construct a pairing
KI (R) ~Ko(R) K1 (R)
, K2(R).
Suppose a, fl E E(R) commute; we define a 'product' a , fl e K2(R) by a , fl = [&, fl], where 5, fl e St(R) are inverse images in St(R) of a, respectively. Then a , fl does not depend on the specific lifts 5, f], and has the following properties: (a) if a l and a2 both commute with fl, then ( ~ 1 ~ 2 ) * t~ : ( ~ l * f ~ ) - ( ~ 2 * f~)
(b) for any v e E(R), r a y -1 . vflv -1 = a .
(c) ~ * f~ = - ( ~ .
~).
Now let A e GLn(R), B e GLm(R), and let In E GLn(R), I m e GLm(R) be the respective identity matrices. Then
a = (A | I m , A -1 | Im, I , | 13= (In | B, In | Im, In | B -~) give commuting elements of E3mn(R). We define
{A, B} = a , fl. One checks that this determines a well-defined skew-symmetric pairing g l (R) @ g l (R)
.~K2(R)
which is K0(R)-bilinear (see Milnor's book, Ch. 8 for details). In particular, if m = n = 1, we have a product R* |
R*
." K2(R)
[O 0 0] [b0 0]
called the Steinberg symbol, given by (a ~ b):
, {a, b} =
0
a -1
0
0
0
1
*
0
1
0
0
0
b -1
.
One knows (Lemma (9.8) of Milnor's book) that the Steinberg symbol has the property that if a E R* such that 1 - a E R*, then the Steinberg relation {a, 1 - a } = 1 is valid in K2(R); also, for any a e R*, { a , - a } = 1.
1. "Classical" K-Theory
15
Theorem
(1.14) (Matsumoto). IfF is a (commutative) field, then K2(F) has a presentation as the free AbeHan group on the symbols {a,b} with a, b E F* subject to the relations: (i)
b} =
b}
b}/o
b e F*
(ii) {a, b} = {b, a } - I for all a, b E F* (iii) {a, 1 - a} = 1 for all a ~. F* - { 1}. S y m b o l s o n a F i e l d . Let F be a field. A symbol on F with values in an Abelian group G is a map (,):F*xF*
~G
satisfying (i) (ala~, b) = (al, b) (a~, b) for all al, a~, b ~ F* (ii) (a, b) = (b, a ) - 1 for all a, b E F* (iii) (a, 1 - a) -- 1 for all a E F* - { 1}. From Matsumoto's theorem, there is a bijection between symbols on F with values in G, and homomorphisms K2(F) ~ G. There are m a n y interesting examples of symbols arising "in nature". We list some below. E x a m p l e (1.15) (Tame Symbol). Let F be a field with a discrete valuation v, whose residue field is k(v). Let U c F* be the kernel of v : F* ~ Z, and let 0 : U ". k(v)* be the quotient map. Define the tame symbol :Iv : F* x F* --~ k(v)* by the formula Tv(a, b) - r (We also denote the resulting map K2(F) , k(v)* by Tv and call it the tame symbol; we follow this practice in the other examples too.) E x a m p l e (1.16) (Galois symbol). Let F be a field, n a positive integer 1 such that -~ E F. Assume that F contains the nth roots of unity, and let E F* be a primitive nth root of unity. The nth order Galois symbol is a map F* x F* ~ nBr(F), where ~ B r ( F ) is the n-torsion subgroup of the Brauer group of similarity classes of central simple algebras over F. The map is given by (a, b)
, [D((a, b)! e B r ( F )
16
Algebraic K-Theory
where De(a, b) is the cyclic algebra of dimension n 2 over F with generators X, Y satisfying X n = a, y n = b, X Y = ~ Y X . E x a m p l e (1.17)(Differential symbol). Let F be a field, 121F = VllF/Z the F-vector space of absolute Khhler differentials of F; thus l)lF is spanned by symbols da, for a E F, subject to the relations d(ala2) = al 9da2 + a2 . dal for all al,a2 e F. Let ~2F "-- / k2F Q 1F . The differential symbol is the map F*
x
F*
.~~2~-
given by (a, b) --~ d. A ~ for all a, b e F* ~
9
E x a m p l e (1.18) (Norm-Residue symbols). Let k be a local field with __t E k, and containing the mth roots of unity. Let k' be the extension m field obtained by adjoining the ruth roots of all elements of k. By K u m m e r theory, we have an isomorphism k* |
Z / m Z ~= H o m ( G a l ( k ' / k ) , pro),
and by local class-field theory, we have an isomorphism Gal(k'/k) ~= k*/Nk,/k(k')* where Nk,/k is the norm (note that k l / k is a finite extension, since k* | Z / m Z is finite). Thus we have a pairing k* |
k* ('); #m
called the local ruth-power norm-residue symbol; one can check that it does indeed satisfy the conditions (i)-(iii) in the definition of a symbol. In fact, if k ~ C, then the m-torsion subgroup of B r ( k ) is known to be isomorphic to Z / m Z ~ pro; for a suitable choice of this isomorphism, one can identify the local norm residue symbol with the Galois Symbol (Ex. (1.16)). Now let K be a number field. For any place v of K which is either real or non-Archimedean, if re(v) is the number of roots of unity in the local field K~, let ( , )v denote the composition of K 2 ( K ) ----, K 2 ( K , ) with the local m(v)th power norm-residue symbol, taking values in the group /z. C K~, of roots of unity. If m is the order of the group #K of roots of unity in K, we have surjections #v ;/zN given by raising to the (m--~)-th k m / power. T h e o r e m (Moore Reciprocity Law). The sequence K2(K)
a ; (~ tp
#v
;#K-
;0
1. "Classical" K-Theory
17
is exact, where c~ is the s u m of the maps ( , )v (and in particular, almost all ( , )v are trivial on a given class in K2(K)), and Z is the s u m of the surjections I~v ~. I~K above. Example
( 1 . 1 9 ) . Let F be a finite field. Then K 2 ( F ) = 0.
This is easily proved using Matsumoto's theorem (1.14), and the fact t h a t the multiplicative group F* of non-zero elements of F is a cyclic group. Indeed, let u E F* be a generator. It suffices to prove t h a t {u, u} is trivial in K 2 ( F ) . If F has characteristic 2, then {u, u} = { u , - u } is trivial. So we may assume F has odd characteristic. If F has cardinality q, then u (q-1)/2 = - 1 , so {u, u (q+1)/2} = { u , - u } is trivial. Hence {u, u} has order dividing (q + 1)/2, as well as q - 1 (as u has order q - 1 in F*), i.e., {u, u} has order at most 2. Now F* - {1 } is invariant under the bijection v H 1 - v. Since F* - { 1 } has ( q - l ) / 2 non-squares, and ( q - 3 ) / 2 squares, there m u s t be a non-square v such t h a t 1 - v is also a non-square. Then v = u i, 1 - v = u j with i , j odd, so t h a t the triviality of (v, 1 - v} implies that {u, u} has odd order. Hence {u, u} is trivial. R e m a r k . M. Stein has shown t h a t if R is a commutative semi-local ring, which is generated by R* as an additive group, then K 2 ( R ) is generated by Steinberg symbols (see "Surjective stability in dimension 0 for K2 and related functors", Trans. A . M . S . 178 (1973), 165-191). W. van der Kallen has further shown t h a t the relations (i), (ii), (iii), in T h e o r e m (1.14) determine a presentation for K2(R), provided all residue fields have at least 5 elements (see "The K2 of rings with many units", Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 10 (1977), 473-515).
2. T h e P l u s C o n s t r u c t i o n In this section, all spaces, pairs, etc. have the homotopy type of a CW-complex. The main reference for this chapter is: J.-L. Loday, Kth~orie alg~brique et representations de groupes, Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 9 (1976). A general reference for topology is: G.W. Whitehead, Elements of Homotopy Theory, Grad. Texts in Math., No. 61, SpringerVerlag. These are cited below as [L] and [W], respectively. For any associative ring R, we regard GL(R) as a topological group with the discrete topology, and let BGL(R) denote the 'classifying space' of GL(R). For our purposes, it is only i m p o r t a n t to know that B G L ( R ) is an Eilenberg-MacLane space K(GL(R), 1), i.e., BGL(R) is a connected space with ~I(BGL(R)) ~- GL(R), lr,(BGL(R)) = 0 for i > 2, and t h a t these properties characterize BGL(R) up to homotopy equivalence (since we are assuming that all spaces considered here have the homotopy type of a CW-complex). We give a construction of the classifying space of a discrete group in the next chapter (Example (3.10)). Since ~t (BGL(R)) ~ GL(R), ~rl(BGL(R)) has a perfect normal subgroup E(R). We will construct below a space BGL(R) + by applying the plus construction of Quillen to the pair (BGL(R), E(R)). There is an inclusion i" BGL(R) ; BGL(R) + such t h a t
(i)
9 rl(BGL(R)) ~ ~I(BGL(R) +) is the natural quotient m a p GL(R) ~GL(R)/E(R). i.
(ii) for any local coefficient system L on BGL(R) +,
i. " H,,,(BGL(R),i*L)
~ Hn(BGL(R)+,L)
is an isomorphism for all n > 0. These properties will characterize B G L ( R ) + up to homotopy equivalence. Quillen's first definition of higher K-groups is: Ki(R) = ~,(BGL(R)+), for i>1. T h e plus construction is described in the following result. (2.1) (Quillen). Let ( X , x ) be a path connected space, N ~rl (X, x) a perfect normal subgroup. Then there exists a continuous map of pairs f " ( X , x ) ". (X+,x +) such that Theorem
2. The Plus Construction
19
(a) there is an exact sequence
0
}N
~ 1rl(X, x) I. 7rl(X+, x +)
,0
(b) for any local coe]ficient system L on X +,
I. " Hn(X, f'L)
, H,(X+,L)
is an isomorphism for any n > 0 (c) if g" (X, x)
~ (Y, y) is a continuous map such that N C ker(g. "1rl ( X , x )
; 7rl(Y, y)),
then there exists a continuous map h" ( X + , x +) to homotopy, making the diagram
} (Y, y), unique up
(Y,Y) commute. P r o o L We construct X + by attaching 2-cells and 3-cells to X, so t h a t ( X + , X ) is a CW-pair of (relative) dimension 3, and take x + = x. We construct X + in a number of steps: S t e p (i). First choose classes ea E lrt(X,x), for a running over a suitable index set ,4, such that ea generate N as a normal subgroup. For each a E A, choose a loop 7a representing e~, and attach a 2-cell a~ to X using 7a on the boundary. Let X1 be the resulting space. Then by van Kampen's theorem, Irl (X1, x) is the quotient of lrl(X, x) by the normal subgroup generated by the e~, i.e., l r l ( X l , x ) = l r l ( X , x ) / N . S t e p (ii). Let )(1 .~X1 be the universal covering, and let )~ ;X be the induced covering, so that we have a pullback diagram
-,~
1
X
'
~
.Xl
l"
X1
Then Xl is obtained from X by attaching 2-cells; since )(1 is connected, so is )(. Thus )~ " X is the covering space corresponding to the subgroup N C ~rl(X,x), and is Galois with group ~ r l ( X , x ) / Y . For each 2-cell aa of ( X 1 , X ) , ~r~(X,x) acts transitively on the 2-cells in ~r-l(aa), with the isotropy of any of these 2-cells being N. Hence H 2 ( ) f l , ) ~ ; Z ) is a free Z[lrl(X,x)/N]-module on generators [ha], where 5a is a 2-cell in l r - l ( a ~ ) .
20
Algebraic K-Theory
S t e p (iii). We have the following diagram, whose vertical maps are Hurewicz maps,
-2(2)
7r2(Xl)
--,
1
H2(X, Z)
}
1
l
H2(X,, Z)
,
~, H2(X,,X; Z)
J = ~r,(R) ~b = N "b = 7rl (X1) = 0, lr2(X1) ~ H2(X1,Z) by onto, we can thus find maps f~ 9S 2 ILl e ~(2~) m~p~ t o [a~l e H 2 ( 2 ~ , 2 ; Now HI(R,Z)
~2(21)
71"2(21,)~)
; H2(X1,7/~)
}
7rl(j3~)
'
H1(2,Z).
1
0 since N is perfect.
Next, since the Hurewicz theorem. Since j is , 2 1 such t h a t the homotopy class Z ) u n d e r t h e composite
J} U2(Xl, )~; 7/~).
Let f a 9 S 2 , X1 be the composite ~ o ]a, and let X + be the space obtained by attaching 3-cells ba to X1 using fa along the boundary, for each c~ E ,4. By construction, (X +, XI) is a relative CW-complex with only 3-cells, so t h a t r l ( X l , x ) ~ l r l ( X + , x ) ~ lr,(X,x)/N. This proves (a) of the theorem for (X,x) } (X+,x +) where x + = x. Let )( + be the universal cover of X + ; then we can extend our earlier diagram as follows"
2
, 2,
I
i
, 2+
i
X ~ XI ~ X+ The 2 squares are Cartesian (i.e., are pullbacks). T h e relative cellular chain complex (see (A.14)) for ()C+, X ) looks like:
, c3(~: + , 2 )
9"" 0
a,
c2(2+,2)
.~0 - . -
with non-zero terms only in dimensions 2 and 3. We also have isomorphisms (from the definition of the relative cellular chain complex)
C3(X§ , X) ~-C3(2§ Xl) -~-/-/3(2§ 21; ~), c~(2+,~:) ~- c2(2,,)~) u H~(2,,)~; Z), such t h a t d is identified with the boundary map in the homology sequence of the triple ()~+,)fl, )()" 9""
' H3(X1,X; Z)
}H3(X+,X;Z)
d H2()~l, X; ~)
} H 3 ( X + , ) ~ I ; Z)
}
9 ~
From the construction of the homology sequence of a triple, d = j o 0 where 0 is the boundary map 9 ..
~3(2 + z)~ ,
~H3(s + 2,;Z) ,
o H2(21,Z) }
o~
~
2. The Plus Construction
21
in the homology sequence of the pair ()~+,)~1), and j is the natural m a p H2()~1, Z) , H2(X1, )~; Z) (used in (ii) above to construct X +). Let ba be the 3-cell of X + with attaching map ],,. We have a diagram with vertical Hurewicz maps .~
;
~'3(2 + )
'
1
H3(X + , Z)
;
II'3(2"~, Xl)
I
H3(X + , X I , Z )
.~
~-2(21)
1
0 ~. H2(X,, - Z).
Then ba also determine elements of 7r3()(+, X1), which we also denote by [b~], whose images under the Hurewicz map are the class Ibm] e Ha()~ +, X1;Z) corresponding to the 3-cells b~,. If []a] e 71"2(X1) is the class determined by ]a, the attaching map of b~, then [ba] maps to []a] under the boundary m a p 7 r 3 ( 2 + , X l ) ~ 712(X1) , from the definition of this boundary map. By construction, [fa] e 71"2(X1) maps to [g~] E H2()~1, )~; Z) under the composite
~2(x1)
* H2(X1, Z) J;
H2(XI,X; Z).
We conclude that d" H3()(+,X1; Z) ~ H2(X,,)(; Z) maps [ba] to [ha]. As in (ii) above, H3()~+,)(1;Z) is a free [Th(X,x)/N]-module on the generators [ba]. Hence, C3()~+,X) and C2()~+,)~) are both free (~rl (X, x) /N)-modules on generators indexed by the same set ,4, and d puts the two sets of generators in bijection. Hence d is an isomorphism of (7rl (X, x)/N)-modules. Now let L be a local coefficient system on X +, i.e., L is an Abelian group on which Irl(X+,x +) acts. Equivalently, L is a (~l(X,x)/g)-module. The relative homology groups Hr,(X+, X; L) are computed as the homology groups of the tensor product complex
L|
C.()~+,)~) 9
But this complex is acyclic, so Hn(X+,X;L) = 0 Vn. From the exact homology sequence for (X+,X) with local coefficients in L, we see t h a t H,.,(X,i*L) ~ Hn(X+,L) Vn, where i : X -4 X +. This proves (b). The proof of (c) is by obstruction theory; we omit the details (however,
see (A. 16)). (2.2). Let X = BS~, where S~o = U , > I So is the infinite permutation group. Let Aoo c So~ be the infinite alternating group [Jn>_l An. Then Aoo ,~ Soo = lh(BS~) is a perfect normal subgroup, so we can form the space B S +, with lrl(BS +) = Z/2Z. In fact, by
Example
the theorem of Barrat, Priddy and Quillen, one has a homotopy equivalence Z x B S + "~ fl~176176176176 where S o is the 0-sphere (discrete 2 point
22
Algebraic K-Theory
space) (see S. Priddy, On ~~176176 and the infinite symmetric group, Proc. Syrup. Math. 22, A. M. S. (1971), pp. 217-220). We note that for any ( X , x ) , if ]EX is the reduced suspension and f~X the loop space of loops based at x, with natural base points, then there is a natural continuous map X ; f ~ X ; by applying this to ~ n X and applying the functor f~n, we obtain a direct system X
} ~"~"],X
} ~'~2~"]2X
}''"
} ~'~n~,,nX
}...
whose direct limit is called f~~176176176 Then we have
so that we have a direct system of groups /ri(X)
' 7ri+l()-]-X)
, 7ri+2()-]2X)
,-.-
w h o s e direct limit is the ith stable homotopy group of X.
Let lri be the ith stable homotopy group of S ~ 7r, = lim r,+k(S k) ~ 7r,(BS+), --t
i > 1.
Now Soo c GL(Z) as the group of permutation matrices, and A ~ C E(Z). Hence, by the functoriality of the plus construction, there is a map B S + ---, B G L ( Z ) +. This induces maps on homotopy groups
lr~ ~- lr~(BS+)
} 7ri(BGL(Z) +) = g i ( z ) .
For i = 1, the image of the generator of ~rl = Z / 2 Z is ( - 1 ) e K1 (Z).
Let (f(,~) } ( X , x ) be the covering of X corresponding to the subgroup N ,~ 7rl (X, x), and let ( X +, ~.+) be the universal covering of (X +, x +). Then (f(+, ~+) is the result of applying the plus construction to ()(, ~).
P r o p o s i t i o n (2.3).
P r o o f . This was built into our construction of X +. (2.4). Let fi 9 (Xi,xi) } (X + , x i+), i = 1,2 be obtained from the plus construction, for given perfect normal subgroups Ni <~ 7rl(X~,x,). Then ( f l , f 2 ) " (X, x X2, (Xl,X2)) ; ( X + x X +, (x+,x+)) is homotopy equivalent to the result of applying the plus construction to
Proposition
N1 x N2 <] 7rl(X1 • X 2 , ( X l , X 2 ) ) . P r o o f . The properties (2.1) (a), (b) are easily verified. By (c), this characterizes the homotopy type of the resulting space. We now return to the special case when X -- B G L ( R ) , N = E(R).
2. The Plus Construction
23
Let F ( R ) be the homotopy fiber of B G L ( R ) ~ BGL(R)+; since B G L ( R ) + is connected, the homotopy type of F(R) is independent of the choices of the base points (see (A.27)). P r o p o s i t i o n (2.5). (a) F(R) is acyclic, i.e., Hn(F(R),Z) = 0 for all n > O. (b) ~I(F(R)) ~ St(R), the Steinberg group.
(c)
t ,i lly dimensions > 2.
i > 2
F(R)
P r o o f . (a) If we replace BGL(R) + by its universal cover, and B G L ( R ) by the induced covering, this does not change the homotopy type of F ( f ) (see (A.27)); we again use F(R) to denote the homotopy fiber of
BGL(R)
~ B G L ( R ) +,
where B G L ( R ) + is the universal cover the induced covering of BGL(R), which ciated to the subgroup E(R) c GL(R) has the homotopy type of BE(R), the
of BGL(R) +, and B G L ( R ) is is just the covering space asso= ~I(BGL(R)) (thus B G L ( R ) Eilenberg-MacLane space with lrl(BE(R)) ~- E(R), lr~(BE(R)) = O, i ~ 1). We have a spectral sequence (see (A.27)) E2,q = Hp(BGL(R) ~ + , Hq(F(R), Z)) ~
Hp+q(BGL(R), Z)
(where the E2-term is the usual homology group with coefficients in
Hq(F(R),Z), since the local coefficient system associated to H q ( F ( R ) , Z ) is trivial on the simply connected space BGL(R)+). Further, from Proposition (2.3) and Theorem (2.1)(b), the edge homomorphisms
Hn(BG~"~L(R),Z)
:: En,~176 " E~,o = Hn(BG~L(R) +, Z)
are isomorphisms, i.e., E~, 0 = EC~ and E~,q = 0 for q ~ 0. Now suppose F(R) is not acyclic; since ~ ( R ) + is simply connected and B G L ( R ) is connected, F(R) is path connected. Thus if q is the smallest integer such t h a t I-Iq(F(R), Z) r 0, then q > 0. Then Ep,q, 2 = Ep,q, r = 0 for all p, and all q' with 0 < q' < q. Since dr : E~,q * E~-r,q+r-l, we see t h a t E2o,q ~- Eq,+q1 E 0,q q+2 ~- E 0,q' ~176and E 0,q q+2 is the cokernel of dq+l 9E q+l,0 q+l E 0,q q+l 9 B u t E ~ , 0 = E n,0, ~176so that dq+l = 0 also. Hence E~,q = E 2O,q ~ =0as seen above. But on the other hand, E,O,q 2 =
Ho(BGL(R) + Hq(F(R),Z) ~ 0
as we assumed Hq(F(R), Z) - Hq(F(R), Z) ~ 0. This contradiction proves t h a t F(R) is acyclic.
Algebraic
24
K-Theory
(b), (c)" Let G - vr,(F(R)), and consider the spectral sequence (see (A.28)) for the universal covering F ( R ) "~F(R). This has the form
E~,q = Hp(G, Hq(F(R), Z)) ~
gp+q(F(R), Z)
where by (a) we have H , ( F ( R ) , Z) = 0 Yn. Also, F ( R ) is simply connected, so HI (F(R), Z) = 0. This forces E 2 , 0 = E ~176 1,0 = 0 ,
2 - E 2,0 ~176 =0; E2,o
further E32,0 ~ E3,0 da * E03,2 t,j = E 02,2 must be an isomorphism, since the kernel and cokernel are respectively E~176= 0 and E ~176- 0 . Thus H1 (G, Z) = Ha(G, Z) -- 0, and H3(G, Z) ~ Ho(G, H2(F(R)). The homotopy exact sequence (see (A.lS)) for
F(R) ~
BG"'~L(R)
~ BG~L(R) +
together with lr,(~(R)
i >_ 2,
+) ~ 1ri(BGL(R)+),
~r~(BGL(R)) = O, i >_ 2,
and 7r, (BGL(R)) = E(R) yields isomorphisms Ir~+I(BGL(R)+) ~ 7q(F(R)), i >_ 2, and an exact sequence
0
~. 7r2(BGL(R) +)
,
7q(F(R))
(,)
II
--4
E(R)
----,
O.
G By Lemma (A.26), the conjugation action of G on itself is trivial on ker(G ~. E(R)), and G acts trivially on ~r,(F(R)), i > 2 (i.e., F ( R ) i s simple in dimensions i > 2). Thus the above exact sequence (,) is acentral extension of E(R), such that H1 (G, Z) = H2(G, Z) - 0, i.e., by Proposition (1.10) is isomorphic to the universal central extension
0
, K2(R)
~ St(R)
~.E ( R )
~ O.
In particular G ~- St(R). C o r o l l a r y (2.6). vr~(BGL(R)+) ~- Ki(R), {= 1,2, and
Ir3(BGL(R)+) ~- H3(St(R), Z).
2. The Plus Construction
25
P r o o L The only thing left to prove is the formula for ~r3(BGL(R)+). But lr3(BGL(R) +) ~- lr2(F(R)) ~ ~2(F(R)) ~- H2(F(R),Z) (by Hurewicz); we also had an isomorphism H3(G, Z) ~ Ho(G, H2(F(R))) "~ Ho(G, lr2(F(R))) "~ ~2(F(R)), since F(R) is simple in dimension 2. This corollary motivates Quillen's first definition of higher K-theory (for projective modules over a ring). Definition. Ki(R) = ~(BGL(R)+), i >_ 1. As a consequence, we obtain C o r o l l a r y (2.7). K 3 ( R ) - - H3(St(R),Z). R e m a r k . We note that there are Hurewicz homomorphisms
Ki(R)
= ~r,(BGL(R)
+)
~ H~(BGL(R)+,Z)
~ H,(BGL(R),Z).
Following Loday, we describe below a natural H-space structure on
BGL(R) +, which we then use to construct products gi(R) | Kj(R) - , gi+j(R). One other consequence of the H-space structure is that by a theorem of Milnor and Moore (see J. Milnor, J.C. Moore, On the Structure of Hopf Algebras, Ann. Math. 81 (1965), 211-264), the Hurewicz maps above are injective up to torsion, and the Q-subspace
K~(R) |
Q c H~(BGL(R),
Q) = H~(GL(R),
Q)
is identified with the subspace of primitive elements for the comultiplication of the natural Hopf algebra structure on H.(GL(R), Q) (for any connected space X, there is a comultiplication
A. : H.(X, Q)
; H.(X, Q) •
H.(X, Q)
induced by the diagonal A : X : X x X, and the Kunneth isomorphism H.(X x X, Q) ~ H.(X, Q) | H.(X, Q); the primitive elements H,(X, Q) are those elements x satisfying A(x) = x | 1 + 1 | x). This result has been used by A. Borel (Stable Real Cohomology of Arithmetic Groups, Ann. Sci. E.N.S. 7 (1974), 235-272) to compute the ranks of the higher K-groups of the ring of algebraic integers in a number field. The following discussion is based closely on ILl. Let R be a ring; for a,/3 6 GL(R) let c~ (t)~ be defined by (a~fl)ij=
{
c~ke i f i = 2 k - l , j = 2 s ~k~ i f i = 2 k , j = 2 t 0 otherwise.
26
Algebraic K-Theory
Schematically, if
9
Lemma
X
X
X
-'-
9 ""
X
X
X
'''
o
,
9
o
9
9
o
9
o
9
o
o
then
a(gf~
9 ""
=
,
0
,
0
0 , 0
x 0 x
0 * 0
x 0 x
9
o
.
.
( 2 . 8 ) . @ ' G L ( R ) • GL(R)
o o
o
o
6 GL(R).
GL(R) is a homomorphism.
P r o o f . Left as an easy exercise. Remark.
Let c~ 6 GL,.,(R), ~3 6 GLm(R),
7=
[oo] 0
/3 6 G L m + n ( R ) ,
and let a s, /3s, 78 denote their images in GL(R). T h e n a" @/3 s ~ 7 s, but the two homomorphisms G L , ( R ) x G L , , ( R ) ; GL(R), given by (~,/3) ~-* c~s @/38, and (~,/3) ~-. 7 s, are conjugate by an element of GL(R) (even by one of E(R), since the two maps factor through GLd(R), d 2 m a x ( m , n), on which conjugation by A e GLd(R) equals conjugation by
0
A -1
6 E2d(R)). In particular, for any c~ 6 GL(R), ot@o~-1 e E ( R ) .
We define a product on BGL(R), as follows. By Proposition (2.4), the natural m a p
k : B(GL(R) x GL(R)) +
; BGL(R) + x BGL(R) +
is a h o m o t o p y equivalence. Choose a h o m o t o p y inverse k -1, and let + be the composite
+" BGL(R) + x BGL(R) + k-__~ B(GL(R)
x GL(R)) + ~+~ BGL(R) +,
where we note t h a t (by L e m m a (2.8)) there is a m a p B ( G L ( R ) x GL(R)) B G L ( R ) , such that the induced map on fundamental groups carries E ( R ) x E(R) into the commutator subgroup E ( R ) C GL(R), and hence induces a map ~ + between the plus constructions.
2. The Plus Construction
27
P r o p o s i t i o n (2.9). ( B G L ( R ) +, +) is a homotopy commutative and associative, connected H-space, hence a commutative H-group. The proof will depend on a few simple lemmas, which we prove first. Let u 9N - , N be an injective self-map of the set of positive integers. Define u ~ GL(R) ~ GL(R) by
u~
=
akt 8i1
if (i, j) = (u(k),u(s (Kronecker delta) otherwise.
We call u~ a 'pseudo-conjugation' of GL(R). L e m m a (2.10). For each pseudo-conjugation u~ there is an induced map u+ 9 BGL(R) + ; B G L ( R ) + which is a homotopy equivalence. P r o o f . Since u. is a homomorphism, by an easy computation, it induces a map B G L ( R ) + ; BGL(R)+; it also induces a GL(R)/E(R)-equivariant self-map on the universal covering space B G L ( R ) + ~- B E ( R ) + (by Prop. (2.3), and the fact t h a t B E ( R ) ; B G L ( R ) is precisely the covering associated to E ( R ) C G L ( R ) = ~rl(BGL(R))). Let Ct : B E ( R ) + B E ( R ) + be this induced map; since B E ( R ) + is simply connected, if we show that it induces an isomorphism on integral homology groups, then it is a homotopy equivalence (see (A.10)). Let x E H n ( B E ( R ) , Z) be the class of the cycle r~n,(g~i)),..., g(ni)) (in the standard complex for E(R), say). Then ft.(x) is the class of the cycle En,(u.(g~ ') ...,u~ Now the g!')j range over a finite set in E ( R ) , contained in Era(R), say. The map u~ Era(R) ~. E ( R ) is equal to conjugation by some C E E ( R ) (we can take C to be an even permutation matrix), so that ft.(x) is also represented by C(F~n,(g~O,...,g(O))C-1. But inner conjugation induces the identity map on group homology, so that ft.(x) = x. L e m m a (2.11). Let M be the monoid (under composition) of injective self-maps of the set N of natural numbers. Then the Grothendieck group Ko(M) = 0 (i.e., any monoid homomorphism from M to a group is trivial). P r o o f . Suppose u E M has infinitely many fixed points; let i E M be given by i(n) = n t h fixed point of u. Then u o i = i, so t h a t the class [u] e Ko(M) is trivial. In general, for any v e M, we claim there exists u E M such that u, vu both have infinitely many fixed points. The proof of the claim is left as an exercise to the reader. C o r o l l a r y (2.12). For any u e M, u+ " B G L ( R ) + ~ B G L ( R ) + is homotopic to the identity (through maps preserving the base point).
28
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o o f . T h e assignment u ---~ [u +] gives a monoid homomorphism from M to the group of homotopy classes of base point preserving self-homotopy equivalences of B G L ( R ) +. R e m a r k . The fact that fi: B E ( R ) + , B E ( R ) + induces the identity on homology groups does not suffice to conclude t h a t it is homotopic to the identity. In fact, there exist spaces with self-maps not homotopic to the identity, but which induce the identity on homology and homotopy (where we assume the map fixes a base point, to make sense of the statement about homotopy groups). M. Lemaire has constructed such an example. D e f i n i t i o n . Let G be a group. Two homomorphisms f, g" G ". G L ( R ) are pseudo-conjugate if there exists u E M such t h a t either u. o f and g, or u. o g and f, are conjugate by an element of GL(R). C o r o l l a r y (2.13). /] f, g 9 G the induced maps f +, g+ 9 B G preserving the respective base points.
G L ( R ) are pseudo-conjugate, then B G L ( R ) + are homotopic as maps
P r o o f . For any map f : G ; GL(R), let f ~ 1 denote the map given by x ~-. f ( x ) ~ l , for any x E G. Then f + is homotopic to ( f ~ l ) +, preserving the base point, because f ~ 1 = (u0)~ o f , where u0 E M is defined by 0(i) = 2 i -
1.
Now suppose the given maps f, g satisfy g = (u~ o f ) a for ~ e G L ( R ) (where ( u ~ ~(u~ -1 for a l l x e G). If/~ = a~c~ -1 E E ( R ) , then g @ 1 = ((u~ o f ) ~ 1) ~. Thus, the induced maps B G , BGL(R) are freely homotopic, such that under a homotopy, the image of the base point of B G is a loop homotopic to [/~] E Irl(BGL(R)) ~ GL(R) (Lemma (A.50)). T h e induced maps B G ~. B G L ( R ) + are homotopic preserving the base points, since [/~] ~-. 0 in l r l ( B G L ( R ) +) (see (A.41)). P r o o f o f P r o p o s i t i o n (2.9). Let u0, v0 E M be given by Uo(i) = 2i - 1, vo(i) = 2i, for all i E N. Then (U0)o(a) = a 9 1, and (V0)o(a) = 1 ~ a for any c~ E GL(R). By construction, the map + : B G L ( R ) + x B G L ( R ) + B G L ( R ) +, when restricted to B G L ( R ) + x {,}, is homotopic to (u0) +, and when restricted to {,} x B G L ( R ) +, is homotopic to (v0) +. Hence the base point * E B G L ( R ) + is a 2-sided identity, up to homotopy, for the operation +. By definition, this makes ( B G L ( R ) +, + ) a H-space. Next, there exist w,w t E M such t h a t for any x , y , z E GL(R), x ~ y = W o O ( y S x ) , and ( x @ y ) @ z = w~ o ( x ~ ( y S z ) ) . Hence B G L ( R ) + is homotopy commutative and associative. Since it is connected, it is an
2. The Plus Construction Loday's Product products
in K - T h e o r y .
K,(R) | K i( R )
29
Following [L], we construct natural
, K,+i(R),
i,j > 1
which generalize the product for i = j = 1 considered in w First, fix a choice of a bijection r 9N x 1~ , N. Given rings R, R ~ and elements a e GL(R), a' e GL(R'), r enables us to convert a | a ' into an element of G L ( R | R~) 9 Thus we obtain a homomorphism GL(R) x GL(R') , G L ( R | R'), which clearly maps E ( R ) x E(R') into the commutator subgroup E ( R | R~), and hence induces a continuous map g: B G L ( R ) + x B G L ( R ' ) + ) B G L ( R | R') +. Let xo, x~o be the respective base points of BGL(R) +, B G L ( R ' ) + and define a new map
~" B G L ( R ) + x B G L ( R ' ) +
; BGL(R |
R') +
by ~(x, x') = g(x, x') - g(xo, x') - g(x, x~o)+ g(xo, xto) where the operations on the right side are performed using the H-group structure on the space B G L ( R | R') + given by Proposition (2.9). Then by construction ~ is null homotopic when restricted to B G L ( R ) + VBGL(R') + - B G L ( R ) + • {X~o}U {x0} x BGL(R~) +. Hence there exists a mapping on the smash product
h" B G L ( R ) + A B G L ( R ' ) +
~ BGL(R |
R') +,
unique up to homotopy, making the diagram below commute up to homotopy:
BGL(R) + x BGL(R') +
BGL(R |
~ BGL(R) + A B G L ( R ' ) +
R') +
This induces bilinear pairings on homotopy groups (see (A.7))
h.
Ki(R) |
Kj(R)
~ Ki+j(R |
R'),
from the homeomorphisms S ~ A SJ -~ S ~+j. Further, the "switch map" S ~AS j - - ~ S j AS ~ has degree ( - 1 ) ~j (compute it on homology) so that if R is commutative, the homomorphism R | R ; R given by multiplication induces bilinear products
, " Ki(R) |
Kj(R)
, Ki+j(R),
i,j > 1
satisfying x , y = ( - 1 ) i J y , x for x e Ki(R), y E Kj(R). Loday computes t h a t for i = j = 1, this product is the negative of the product constructed in w following Milnor (see [L], Proposition (2.2.3)).
30
Algebraic K-Theory
Finally, we remark that Quillen has computed the K-groups of a finite field in the following paper: D. Quillen, On the Cohomology and K - T h e o r y of the General Linear Group over a Finite Field, Ann. Math. 96 (1972), 552586. In fact, the computations in this paper motivated the definition of the plus construction. The result is as follows: If ]Fq denotes the field with q elements, then K0(F ) = Z;
K2~(Fq) = 0,
for i > 0;
K2,-ICFq) ~ ZICq'- 1)Z,
for i > 0.
3. The Classifying Space of a Small C a t e g o r y The references for simplicial sets are: J. Milnor, The geometric realization of a semi-simplicial complex, Ann. Math. 65 (1957), 357-362, and J.P. May, Simplicial Objects in Algebraic Topology, Midway reprints (1982). Apart from Quillen's paper, Higher Algebraic K-Theory - I, a reference for the classifying space of a category is: G. Segal, Classifying spaces and spectral sequences, Publ. Math. IHES 34 (1968), 105-112.
( S e m i - ) S i m p l i c i a l S e t s . Let A be the following category: for each nonnegative integer n, let n_n_= {0 < 1 < ..- < n} be the ordered set consisting of 0 , 1 , . . . , n; t h e objects of A are the ordered sets _n, a n d morphisrns are monotonic m a p s (i.e., m a p s f " m ~ _n such t h a t f(i) <_ f ( j ) for i < j ; in particular equality f(i) = y ( j ) is p e r m i t t e d ) . For each positive n, we have n + 1 maps in A On " n - 1 ~ n which are injective, given by a~(j)=
j j+l
ifj < i
ifj>i.
These are called the face maps. Next, we have n maps s r~--I i "n_n_ which are surjective, given by n-~ (J s~ ( J ) = , j - 1
~ n-
1
ifj < i ifj>i.
T h e s e are called t h e degeneracy maps. T h e face a n d degeneracy m a p s satisfy certain obvious identities (see May's book, pg. 1) a n d any m o r p h i s m in A can be w r i t t e n as a composition of face and degeneracy m a p s (if f 9 rn : n_n_,we can uniquely write f = g o h where h 9 m_ ;; p a n d g 9p ~-~ n are respectively surjective and injective arrows in A; now h is a composition of degeneracies and g a composition of faces). D e f i n i t i o n . A simplicial object in a category C is a c o n t r a v a r i a n t functor A , C i.e., a functor A ~ , C, where A ~ is the opposite category. A m o r p h i s m of simplicial objects in C is a natural transformation. Thus, a simplicial set is a functor Aop ; Se__~t,where Set denotes t h e category of sets; similarly a simplicial space is a functor A ~ - - - 4 Top w h e r e
32
Algebraic K-Theory
Top denotes the category of topological spaces. In the older terminology, a simplicial set was called a semi-simplicial set. Suppose F 9 A ~ .~ Set is a simplicial set. T h e n for each nonnegative integer n, F ( n ) is a set, called the set of n-simplices of F . T h e maps 0~ give rise to n + 1 maps of sets F(_n) } F ( n - 1), called the face maps, which associate to each n-simplex in F ( n ) a collection of n + 1 ( n - 1)-simplices in F ( n - 1), called its faces. Similarly the n maps n-1 give maps F ( n - 1) } F(_n) associating to each ( n - 1)-simplex a collection of n "degenerate" n-simplices; these maps F ( n - 1) ; F(n_) For e the of and F(s~)(6) E F(n.+ 1) the ith degenerate simplex of 6. (3.1). Let X be a topological space. Let S(X) denote the total singular complex of X, so t h a t Sn (X), the set of n-simplices of S(X), is just the set of singular n-simplices in X , i.e., S , ( X ) is the set of all continuous
Example
maps An
} X, where An is the s t a n d a r d n-simplex
An "- { ( t O , . . . , tn) E ~n-{-1 I ti >-- O, ~ t i :
1 }.
To make S(X) = {Sn(X)}n>o into a simplicial set, we must show t h a t to any morphism m .~ n in A, it is possible to assign a m a p of sets Sn(X) } Sin(X), compatible with compositions. If f " m ~ n is a m o r p h i s m in A, i.e., a monotonic m a p of ordered sets, we first describe a continuous map ] " Am } An, such that__re" .~ Am, f : ; f is a functor A } Top. Since Sn(X) = H o m w o p ( A , , X ) , and Y } Homwop(Y,X) is a functor (Top) ~ ~ Set, we will have shown t h a t S(X) is a simplicial set. If Am = {(so,...,sm) E Rm+l I s ~ >_ O, Esj = 1}, let ] ' A m
, An be the map ] ( ( s o , . . . , S m ) ) : (to,...,tn) where ti --
~
Sj ,
l(j)=~ where we define tj = 0 if {j I f(J) = i} is empty. One easily verifies t h a t this gives a functor A .~Top. E x a m p l e (3.2) ("The n-sphere"). set of m-simplices is given by
(S")m =
Let (S n) be the simplicial set whose
{era} {e., 1.} {era} U {all degenerate m-simplices associated to f , } ,
if 0 _< m < n ifm=n if m > n.
T h e faces of em all equal era-1 (for m >_ 1), and the degenerate simplices of em all equal em+l (for m >_ 0). T h e faces of fn all equal en-1, if n > 0 (if
3. The Classifying Space of a Small Category
33
n - 0, there are no face maps to be defined). We leave it to the reader to check t h a t these conditions do uniquely define a simplicial set; the reason for the name ("The n-sphere") is explained below (Ex. (3.4)). (3.3) G e o m e t r i c R e a l i z a t i o n . To each simplicial set F 9A ~ , Set, we can associate a topological space IF[ called the geometric realization of F. This is defined to be the quotient space
where for each n >_ 0, F(_n) is regarded as a discrete space. The equivalence relation ~ is defined as follows: given f 9m__ , n in A, let f 9 Am , An be the continuous map defined in Ex. (3.1) above. Then for any $ E F(n_), we set (~, ](y)) ..~ (F(f)~, y) for all y E Am, where (~, ](y)) E F ( n ) x An, and (F(f)~, y) E F(m__)x Am. Let ~ be the equivalence relation so generated, and let IFI be the quotient space, with the quotient topology (an open subset is a set whose inverse image in I_In F(n_) x An is open). Clearly the construction of the geometric realization is functorial, i.e., if F ---. G is a morphism of simplicial sets (i.e., a natural transformation of functors Aop , Set) we get a continuous map IFI , IGI . For any simplicial set F , a simplex ~ E F(_n) is called non-degenerate if it is not the degenerate simplex assigned to any ( n - 1)-simplex by one of the degeneracies. T h e n IF I is homeomorphic to a CW-complex, which has one n-cell corresponding to each non-degenerate n-simplex of F . If F, G are simplicial sets, let F x G denote the simplicial set whose n-simplices are F(_n) x G(_n), with obvious maps. Then by a theorem of Milnor (see the references cited earlier) the natural continuous map IF x G I , IFI x IGI (induced by the maps of simplicial sets F x G , F, F x G , G) is a continuous bijection, and is a homeomorphism if IFI x IGI is given the compactly generated topology associated to the product topology (i.e., the product is formed in the category of compactly generated spaces). In particular, if IFI or IG[ is locally compact (e.g., if F has only a finite number of non-degenerate simplices, so that IF I is compact) then IF x G I is homeomorphic to IFI x IGI. Let A(n) = n o m ~ (-,_n_n) be the simplicial set naturally associated to n_ E Ob A; then one sees easily that IA(n)l = An. Milnor's theorem follows from the special case f = A(n), G = A(m), which we prove in the Appendix (see (A.55)) (see also Lemma (6.8)). Finally, we note t h a t the homology of IFI can be computed as follows. Let Cn(F) denote the free Abelian group on F(n_), and let 0~' 9
34
Algebraic K-Theory
Cn(F) ~ Cn-I(F) be the map induced by F(O['). Ifdn = ]E(-1)'(9~, then C(F) -- (C,,,(F), d~)n>l is a chain complex. Then, for any Abelian group A, H . ( I F [ , A ) ~- H , ( C ( F ) | A), and H*([FI, A) ~- H * ( H o m z ( C ( F ) , A ) ) (see May's book, Prop. (16.2) and Corollary (22.3)). Let X be a topological space, and let S ( X ) denote the total singular complex (Ex. (3.1)). Then there is a continuous surjective map f : IS(X)I } X. If x0 E X is a base point, then S(xo) C S ( X ) i s a subcomplex (i.e., S(x0)(n) C S ( X ) ( n ) for all n) such that IS(x0)[ is a point whose image under f is x0. We have:
f " (JS(X)l, IS(x0)l) , (X, xo) induces isomorphisms on homotopy groups. Hence if X is a CW-complex, it is a homotopy equivalence
Theorem.
(see May's book, Theorem (16.6)). E x a m p l e (3.4). Let (S n) be the simplicial set described in Ex. (3.2). Then the geometric realization I(S r')l is naturally homeomorphic to the n-sphere S ~. Indeed, the only 2 non-degenerate simplices of (S n) are eo e (S n)(O) and fn e (S n)(n), so I(S")I is a C W complex with exactly 2 cells. If n > 0, all faces of f . are degenerate, so that I(S")I is obtained by attaching an n-cell to the 0-cell le0] with a constant attaching map. This is the standard description of S n as a CW-complex. (3.5) T h e C l a s s i f y i n g S p a c e of a C a t e g o r y . Let C be a small category, i.e., a category whose objects form a set. The nerve of C, denoted NC (or N(C)) is defined to be the following simplicial set: an n-simplex of NC is a diagram A0 /~ ,A1 f2 ' A2 I~ ' " " ~
A~
with Ai E ObC, fi E MorC. Given a m a p f 9m .~_n in A, the corresponding map NC(n_) ~ N C ( m ) m a p s the above n-simplex to the msimplex Bo gx }B1 g~~,92
~ - . . g'%Bm
where By = AI(j), and Bs ~- Bj+I is the composite map AI(j) } AI(j+I), where if f ( j ) = f ( j + 1), let AI(i) } Al(s+l) be the identity map. In particular the ith face of the above n-simplex is the ( n - 1)-simplex Ao I , AI
} ....
, A~-I f~+to.f~ ----* Ai+l
"---
} An,
while the ith degenerate simplex is the (n + 1)-simplex
Ao It, A1
}
. . . .Ai "
1-" Ai I,+,~ Ai+l
-~-'-
} An.
3. The Classifying Space of a Small Category
35
The classifying space of C is defined to be the geometric realization of NC and is denoted by BC (or B(C)); thus BC = INCl. Clearly, if F : C ; D is a functor between small categories C, :D then there is an induced map of simplicial sets NC ; N D , and hence an induced continuous map B F : BC ~ BD. A simple and useful example is given by the category {0 < 1}, consisting of two objects 0, 1 and a unique non-identity morphism 0 ; 1. Then one checks easily that B {0 < 1 } = I, the unit interval, since the only non-degenerate simplices in N{0 < 1} are {0}, {1}, {0 ~ 1} (the first two are 0-simplices, and the third is a 1-simplex). Let C, C~ be small categories, C x C~ their product, so that Ob(C x C')= (ObC) x (ObC'), and Homcxc,((A, B), (C, D)) = Homc(A, C) x Homc,(B, D). Then clearly N ( C x C') is the product simplicial set N C x NC ~. Hence B(C xC ~) ~. BC x BC ~ is a continuous bijection, which is a homeomorphism if the product on the right is given the compactly generated topology; in particular it is a homeomorphism if either BC or BC ~ is locally compact. Thus B(C x {0 < 1}) ~ BC x I . h functor H : C x {0 < 1} ; :/9 is just a pair of functors F, G : C ; :D (given by F ( A ) = H ( ( A , O ) ) , G(A) = H ( ( A , 1))) together with a natural transformation 77: F , G (given by r/(A) = H((1A, 0 , 1))). Hence we deduce the following lemma. L e m m a (3.6). Let F, G : C ~ l) be functors between small categories, such that there is a natural transformation F ~ G. Then B F , B G : BC
~B D
are homotopic maps.
C o r o l l a r y (3.7). Let F : C ~ l) be a functor between small categories. Suppose F has either a left or a right adjoint. Then B F is a homotopy equivalence. In particular, if C is a small category with either an initial or a final object, then BC is contractible. (See Appendix B for the definitions of adjoint functors.) L e m m a (3.8). Let I be a small filtering category, and let {C~}~ez be a family of small categories indexed by I. Let t7 = li__mCi be the direct limit I
category. Let X i ~ Ci be a family of objects such that X i 9 ; X j under
36
Algebraic K-Theory
the transition functors C~ , Ci of the given family (corresponding to morphisms i --. j in 1), and let X ~ C be the common image of the X~. Then 7rn(BC, {X}) = li__m7rn(BCi, {Xi}) for all n > O. I
(See Appendix B for the definitions of filtering category, etc.) P r o o f . Any finite diagram in C is the image of a similar diagram in some Ci. Thus NC = lirn NCi (where (lirn NC,)(_n) = lim NC,(n)), and any finite subcomplex of NC (a simplicial subset of NC with a finite number of non-degenerate simplices) is the isomorphic image of a subcomplex of some NCi. Since 7rn(BC, {X}) is the direct limit of r n of all finite subcomplexes of NC containing X (regarded as an element of NC(O)), and a similar claim holds for each BCi, the result follows easily. By abuse of terminology, a category is called contractible if its classifying space is; similarly a functor F is called a homotopy equivalence if B F is one, etc. C o r o l l a r y (3.9). Any small filtering category is contractible. P r o o f . Let I be a filtering category. For each i E I, let I / i denote the category of objects over i, consisting of pairs ( j , j ~i) with morphisms
(jl,jl
151
) il) ---* (j2,j2
U
152
) i2) being commutative diagrams:
j2
jl i
In fact, since I is filtering, one verifies easily that for this direct system i ) I / i , the naturally defined functor lim I / i ) I is an equivalence. But (i, i 1 ~. i) is a final object of I/i, so that I / i is contractible. Hence B I is weakly contractible (has vanishing homotopy groups). Since it is a CW-complex, it is contractible, by Whitehead's theorem (see (A.9)). R e m a r k . The classifying space functor is not full. An interesting example is given by the natural homeomorphism BC ~- BC ~ where C~ is the opposite category. E x a m p l e (3.10). Let G be a discrete group. Let _G be the category with one object * such that the monoid HomE(*,*) is the group G. We claim t h a t B_G is the classifying space of G. In fact, let G denote the category whose objects are in bijection with the elements of G, and the
3. The Classifying Space of a Small Category
37
following arrowswif [g] is the object of G corresponding to g E G, then Hom~([g], [h]) consists of a unique arrow 6(g,h). Then the 6(g,h) are forced to satisfy the composition rules ~(92, 93) o 6(gt, 92) = 6(gt, 93); one checks that these rules do define a category. There is a functor G , G__ given by [g] ~ ,, If(g, h) ~ h9 -1 E G = HomG__(*,,). The group G acts on (~ by g([h]) = [hg-1], g(i~(gl,g2)) = 15(gig -1, g2g-1). Since the isotropy group (for the G-action) of any object of (~ is trivial, the isotropy group of any n-simplex in N(G) is trivial. Hence G acts freely on the classifying space B(~. The functor (~ ~G is G-equivariant for the trivial G-action on G, so t h a t B(~ ~ B G is also G-equivariant for the trivial G-action on BG. From the criterion of (A.49), we see t h a t B(~ ~ BG is a locally trivial covering space with (discrete) fiber isomorphic to G, considered as the 0-skeleton of BG, and the group G acts transitively on this fiber. Thus BG__~ B G / G , and B(~ , B__Gis a Galois covering space with group G. Since G has an initial object (any object is an initial object) B G is contractible. Thus G ~ 7rl(BG), and 7ri(BG) = 0 for i # 0. One also sees that B G ~. BG..G_is a principal G-bundle with contractible total space, which is the usual defining property of the classifying space, which characterizes it up to homotopy equivalence.
4. Exact Categories and Quillen's Q-Construction
For our purposes, an exact category C is an additive category C e m b e d d e d as a full (additive) subcategory of an Abelian category ,4, such t h a t if 0 -, M ~ --, M ~M" ~ 0 is an exact sequence in j [ with M ' , M " E C, t h e n M is isomorphic to an object of C. An exact sequence in C is t h e n defined to be an exact sequence in ,4 whose t e r m s lie in C. Let ~: be t h e class of exact sequences in C. One can give an intrinsic definition of an exact category C in terms of a class s of d i a g r a m s in the additive category C, satisfying suitable axioms (see Quillen's p a p e r for details). In all cases relevant to us, the category embeds n a t u r a l l y in some Abelian category jr, such t h a t C is closed under extensions in .A. An exact functor F : C ~ l) between exact categories C, :D is an additive functor such t h a t if 0 ;Mt ~M ~M" , 0 is exact in C, then
0
~F ( M ' )
~. F ( M ) - - ~ F ( M " )
~0
is exact in D. If C is a small exact category, then we define the Grothendieck group K0(C) in t h e usual way: K0(C) - ~ / 7 ~ , where ~ is the free Abelian group on t h e objects of C, and T~ is the subgroup generated by classes [M] [ U ' ] - [ U " ] for each exact sequence 0
~M I
~M
.~ M "
t0
in C (the more standard definition involves t a k i n g the free Abelian group on isomorphism classes of objects of C, b u t is easily seen to be isomorphic to the above group, using sequences with M " - 0). If C is an exact category, we form a new category QC defined as follows: QC has the same objects as C, b u t a morphism X ~ Y is given by an isomorphism class of d i a g r a m s
(.)
x
i
q~-z~-, Y
where i is an admissible monomorphism and q an admissible epimorphism
4. Exact Categories and Quillen's Q-Construction
39
in C; by definition, this means t h a t there are exact sequences 0
~Z--~Y
~yi
~0
0
,X'----*Z
q*x
~0
in C. Another diagram X ~q' Z t ~' ; Y
(,)'
gives the same morphism (in which case we say the two diagrams (,), ( , ) ' , are isomorphic) if there is an isomorphism Z .~Z' making the d i a g r a m
x
commute. Composition of arrows in QC is defined as follows: given X --Z ~-~ Y and Y ,-- V ~ T, form the diagram (in the ambient category .At) X
T T Z
ZxyV
,,"
;
~
Y
T
~V~
~T
Since C is closed under extensions, and ker(Z x v V --* Z) -~ ker(V --~ Y) E C, (Z x y V) E C and Z x v V --~ X, Z x y V ~-* Y are respectively admissible epi and mono. Hence the diagram X , - Z x v V ~-, T defines an arrow in QC from X to T. One checks that the isomorphism class of this diagram depends only on the isomorphism classes of X ~- Z ~-, Y and Y ~- V ~ T, so t h a t we have a well-defined composition rule for morphisms; next, one verifies t h a t composition is associative. Hence if C is a small category, then QC is well defined, and is a small category. Let 0 E O b C = O b Q C be a zero object, so that {0} is a point of B Q C . Quillen's first result in this context is: T h e o r e m (4.0). There is a natural isomorphism ~ I ( B Q C , {0}) ~- Ko(C) (where K0(C) is as defined above). This motivates Quillen's second definition of higher K-theory.
40
Algebraic K-Theory
D e f i n i t i o n . K~(C) = 7r,+I(BQC, {0}), i > 0. We note t h a t this does not depend on the choice of a zero object, since given another zero object 0', there is a canonical isomorphism 0 -~; 0' in C, and hence in QC, giving a canonical choice of a path joining {0} and {0'} in B Q C . The isomorphism of Theorem (4.0) can be described explicitly as follows: given an object M E C, there are 2 canonically defined maps 1
0 --~ M in QC, given by the diagrams 0 ~- 0 ~-, M and 0 ~- M ~ M (where 1 denotes the identity map on M) 9 These give rise to a loop {0} ~~'~ {M} in .~ B Q C . The map Ko(C) ~ lrl ( B Q C , {0}) is given by mapping [M] E Ko(C) to the class of the above loop in ~rl. We defer the proof of this theorem to chapter 6 (however, see Ex. (4.10) below). At this point, we merely list certain properties of the K-groups defined above, whose proofs will be given in chapter 6. To illustrate the theory, and to provide motivation to work through the details of the proofs (if it is required!), we will use these properties in chapter 5 to get interesting results on the K-theory of rings and schemes; a high point will be the proof of the formula H P ( X , 1Cp,x) ~ C H P ( X ) for the Chow groups of a smooth variety. These properties of Ki are generalizations of familiar properties of the Grothendieck group functor K0. Let C be a small exact category, $ the category of (short) exact sequences in C. If C C ,4 is an embedding as a full exact subcategory of an Abelian category, then $ can be regarded as a full additive subcategory of the Abelian category of complexes in .4 of the form 0
; M'
,M
, M"
,0,
where a morphism of complexes is a (commutative) diagram in ,4 M'
~
M
~
N
1
~
M"
~
N"
l
N r
~
0
~
O.
1
Hence ~ is an exact category in a natural way, such that if E ' , E, E " E $, then 0 - ~ E ' , E ~E" , 0 is exact precisely when the corresponding diagram in C has exact rows and columns. There are exact functors s, t, q : t; , C such that if E E $, then 0
, sE
, tE ~
qE
".0
is the corresponding exact sequence in C. We can now state the first property of the functors Ki. Theorem
(4.1). (s,q)" QC
QC x Q c is a homotopy equivalence 9
4. Exact Categories and Quillen's Q-Construction Corollary
(4.2).
t. = s.
+ q. " Ki(C)
41
, Ki(C) for all i.
C o r o l l a r y ( 4 . 3 ) . Let 0 } F' ". F ; F" } 0 be an exact sequence of exact functors C ; l ) between small exact categories (i.e., there are natural transformations F ' } F and F ~ F " such t h a t 0 ----, F ' ( M ) , F(M) ~. F " ( M ) , 0 is exact in 79 for any M E C). Then F. = F~. + Ft.': K~(C) , K,(:D) for all i. ---. :/9 is an additive functor between small exact categories, an admissible filtration 0 = F0 C F1 C ..- C F,,-1 C F,~ = F by subfunctors is a sequence of additive subfunctors Fi 9C ; ~9 such t h a t F n_ 1( M ) , F p ( M ) is an admissible monomorphism in :D for each M E C. Hence the quotients F v / F n_ 1, p > 1, make sense as additive functors C } :/9. I f F 9C
C o r o l l a r y (4.4). I f {Fi}0<~
F. = ~ ( F n / F n _ I ) .
" Ki(C)
". K~(19) f o r all i.
p=l
C o r o l l a r y ( 4 . 5 ) . If 0
,Fo
}F~
,...
;Fn
,0
is an admissible long exact sequence of exact functors C obvious sense), then for all i > 0,
} 1) (in the
n
~ - ~ ( - 1 ) J ( F j ) . = 0" g i ( c ) j=0
, gi(D).
Next, we give the resolution and d6vissage theorems which allow us to replace one exact category by another, in certain situations, w i t h o u t changing the K-groups. Let ~4 be an exact category, 79 C ~4 a full additive subcategory, closed under extensions in ~4; then P is an exact category in a natural way such t h a t the inclusion :P ; ~4 is an exact functor. T h e o r e m (4.6) (Resolution theorem). A s s u m e that 7:' C A4 are as above, and assume f u r t h e r that i/o , M' then M ' E 79
, M
, M"
; 0 is exact in .&4 and M , M " ~_ 79,
(b) f o r any object M E .M, there is a finite resolution 0 with P~ E 79.
-'Pn
,Pn-1
'""
}Pc
,M
,0,
42
Algebraic K-Theory
Then BQ'P ~ BQ./t4 is a homotopy equivalence, and hence K i ( P ) K i ( . M ) for all i. C o r o l l a r y (4.7). Let {Zi}i>_l be a 5-functor from the exact category A4 to the Abelian category .A (i.e., Ti : A4 , ~4 are additive functors such t h a t if 0 .~ M ~ , M , M" .~ 0 is an exact sequence in A4, then there are functorial b o u n d a r y maps T~+~(M") , T~(M'), i > 1, giving a long exact sequence ; Ti+I(M") , T~-I(M')
, T~(M') ~ ,...
Ti(M)
, T~(M")
, T~(M")).
Let 7~ C M be the full exact subcategory of T-acyclic objects P with Ti(P) = 0 V i). Assume that for every object M E an admissible epimorphism P ". M with P E 79, and that for all su.O~ciently large n (depending on M ) . Then BQ7 9 homotopy equivalence.
(i.e., objects A4, there is Tn(M) = 0 ; BQ.A4 is a
T h e o r e m (4.8) (D~vissage theorem). Let ~4 be an Abelian category, 13 a full A belian subcategory which is closed under taking subobjects, quotients and finite products in .4. Suppose each object M E .A has a finite filtration in A O= Mo C M1 C ... c Mn = M
with M i / M i - 1 E 13 for all i > 1. Then B Q B equivalence, so that Ki(13) ~ K i ( A ) .
; BQr
is a homotopy
Finally, we state the localization theorem, which under certain circumstances gives us long exact sequences of K-groups. We recall t h a t if .4 is an Abelian category, B C ,4 a full Abelian subcategory closed under taking subobjects, quotients and extensions in .A, then B is an Abelian category, and is called a Serre subcategory of ,4. Under these conditions one can construct a quotient Abelian category .A/B (see Appendix B), which, in various concrete cases of interest to us, is naturally equivalent to a suitable "localization" of the category ,4; indeed the construction of .A/B is a generalization of the construction of the localization of a ring, and of modules over the ring, with respect to a central multiplicative set. T h e o r e m (4.9) (Localization). Let 13 be a Serre subcategory of the Abelian category .4, and let C be the quotient Abelian category .A/B. Let s" B ,4, p" .A ~.C be the natural exact functors. Then
BQB
~ BQA
BQ8
~ BQC
BQp
4. Exact Categories and QuiUen's Q-Construction
43
is a homotopy fibration (i.e., the natural map B Q B : F ( B Q p ) is a homotopy equivalence, where F ( B Q p ) is the homotopy fiber (see (A.27) of B Qp)). Hence there is a long exact sequence 9..----,
K (B)
,
-,
, Ko(C)
,...
,K,(c)
,g0(.a)
o.
It is possible to give a "naive" construction of the map Ko(C) ) 7rl (BQC, {0}) of T h e o r e m (4.0); we discuss this below. This may give t h e reader a little practice in thinking about the Q-construction. Example
( 4 . 1 0 ) . As noted above, the isomorphism O" Ko(C)
~-, Irl(BQC,{O})
is explicitly given by associating to each M E C a certain loop rM based at 0, such t h a t r = [rM] e lrl(BQC, {0}). There is a canonical admissible mono iM : 0 ~ M and an admissible epi qM : M --~ O, associated to any object M E C. Given any admissible mono i 9 M1 ~ M2, there is an arrow it : M1 ~ M2 in QC, corresponding to the (class of the) d i a g r a m 1
i
M1 ~-- M1 ~-, M2. Similarly, given any admissible epi q ' M i --~ M2, there is an arrow q ! : M2 --* M1 in QC, corresponding to the diagram 1
M2 q M1 ~-* M1. One sees at once t h a t if M q M ~ i : N is a diagram representing an arrow u : M - - ~ N in QC, then from the definition of composition of morphisms, u - i! o qt. T h e two arrows 0 ) M in QC given by i M! and q ~ give 2 p a t h s {0} , { M } in BQC, denoted (iM!) and (q~4)- Let rM = (iM!)o (q~t4) - 1 where the inverse and composition are the usual operations on paths; thus r M is the oriented loop obtained by first following (iM!) and then following ( q ~ ) in reverse. To see t h a t [M] ~ [rM] defines a homomorphism Ko(C) , IrI(BQC, {0}), we must show t h a t if (E)...
0
:M'--~M
q;M"--40
is an exact sequence in C, then [rMl [rM!]" [rM,,] in lrl(BQC) where denotes the group operation in 7rl. From the split exact sequences =
M I ----, M l @ M "
0
"
0
~ M"
) MI@M"
) M"
; MI
-----, 0, )0
one sees i m m e d i a t e l y t h a t the classes [rM,], [rM,,] commute, so the homomorphism r Ko(C) ~ n l ( B Q C , {0}) will be well defined. We note t h a t from the sequence (E) above, and the facts t h a t i M = I i o iM', qM = qM" o q in C, giving iMt = i! o iM,! and q~M = q! o q'M" in QC,
44
Algebraic K-Theory
we have a d i a g r a m where the shaded triangles c o m m u t e :
i
9
!
?iiiii!iiiiiiT}
!
!i',:,!',
I
:~iiii!ii!
!i};iliiiiii!ii? i
i?ili
2:iii:::?
.
0 T h e s h a d e d triangles give 2-simplices in B Q C . F r o m t h e d i a g r a m , we also notice 2 m o r e arrows 0 ; M in QC, n a m e l y i! o q"M" and q! o iM,,!. We claim t h a t in fact i! o q"M' = q! o iM,,!. By definition t h e composite i! o q"M" corresponding to the d i a g r a m 0 q_M, M ' --, i M in C, represents an arrow u 90 ~ M in QC. On the other hand, t h e c o m p o s i t i o n law gives t h a t q: o i M,,! is represented by
0
0 •
T T
iM,I r
B u t t h e r e is an isomorphism 0 x
M"
~
p
q
)M"
r" M >
1->M
M - - ~ M t such t h a t
OXM,,I~
M' c o m m u t e s , since 0 .. M~ i M q ~ M " - - * 0 is exact. T h u s u i! o q~4, a n d q! o i M,,! are represented by isomorphic d i a g r a m s , a n d so give equal a r r o w s in QC. Thus, in t h e earlier d i a g r a m w i t h 2 s h a d e d triangles, we can a d d on a t h i r d arrow u 9 0 ~ M , a n d a d d 2 s h a d e d triangles
4. Exact Categories and Quillen's Q-Construction
45
(corresponding to 2-simplices in B Q C ) , from the diagram M l
i~
~ M
"~
q~
M"
0
We do not draw the resulting diagram with 4 shaded triangles, but the reader can imagine it as yielding a CW-complex homeomorphic to a 2sphere with 3 holes, such that the boundary circles have a common point {0}, and (properly oriented) are just the 3 loops r M , r M , , r M , , . Taking the orientations into account one checks that r M is homotopic to rM, 9rM,,.
5. T h e K - T h e o r y of Rings and Schemes
If R is a ring, let P(R) denote the category of finitely generated projective (left) R-modules. This is a full subcategory of the Abelian category of left R-modules, so that 7~(R) is an exact category where all exact sequences are split. We will prove the following result, comparing the plus and Q constructions, in Chapter 7. T h e o r e m (5.1). There is a homotopy equivalence
BGL(R) +
, (I~BQ'P(R)) ~ which is natural up to homotopy.
(where ~ denotes the loop space, and the superscript 0 denotes the connected component of the trivial loop at {0} E BQT~(R)). Hence there are natural isomorphisms K i ( P ( R ) ) ~ lri(BGL(R)+), i >_ 1. From Theorem (5.1), we see that Quillen's new definition K i ( R ) Ki(Ta(R)) agrees, for i > 1, with the definition given by the plus construction; in particular, K0, K1 and Ks agree with the earlier definitions. This fact will be needed in a couple of places for certain computations. We will assume in the following discussion that all rings are left Noetherian, unless specified otherwise. If A is a Noetherian ring, let fld(A) denote the category of finitely generated (left) A-modules. Then AA(A) is equivalent to a small full subcategory, and any two such full subcategories are naturally equivalent to their union. Hence we can define Ki(~4(A)). A similar convention is used for all other exact categories which we will deal with, and has already been tacitly used in the definition of K~(Ta(R)) above. We define Gi(A) - Ki(AzI(A)); this is also sometimes denoted by K~(A). The inclusion P(A) C fld(A) induces a natural map K i ( A ) ~. Gi(A). By the resolution theorem (4.6), if A is (left) regular, then K i ( A ) ~Gi(A) (recall that a Noetherian ring A is left regular if every finitely generated A-module has a finite resolution by finitely generated projective A-modules).
5. The K-Theory
of Rings and Schemes
47
Our first goal is to prove: T h e o r e m (5.2). Let phisms for all i > 0 (i)
G,(A) ~
A
be
Noetherian.
Then there are natural isomor-
a,(A[t]), induced by change of rings;
(ii) Gi(A[t,t-1]) ~- Gi(A) r Gi-I(A).
(in (ii), for i = 0 we define G_ 1(A) = 0). P r o o f (ii). We first prove (ii), assuming (i). Let B C ~t(A[t]) be the Serre subcategory consisting of modules annihilated by a power of t (strictly, we must first replace M(A[t]) by an equivalent small full subcategory, and let B be the Serre subcategory of this small Abelian category consisting of modules annihilated by a power of t--we will in future suppress such points, leaving it to the careful reader to make the necessary modifications). The quotient Abelian category .M(A[t])/B is naturally equivalent to Ad(A[t,t-1]). Hence the localization theorem (4.9) yields an exact sequence 9"
~ ai+i
(A[t,
t-l])
, K~(13)
, a,(A[t])
, a,(A[t,
f;--1])
.....
Now j~4(A) C B as the full subcategory of modules annihilated by t. Hence by d6vissage (Theorem (4.8)), Ki(B) ~- Gi(A). Hence the localization sequence can be rewritten as
9. . - - - . Gi(A)
~ G,(A[t])
f~ Gi(A[t,t-x])
, Gi-1 (A) ---* -...
From (i), the fiat change of rings A ~ A[t] gives an exact functor A4(A) --. M(A[t]), M ~ A[t] | M, which gives an isomorphism Gi(A) ~ Gi(A[t]). Since A ~ A[t,t -1] also gives an exact functor i" .h4(A) ~ M(A[t,t-~]) we have a commutative diagram Gi(A[t])
I
G,(A[t,t-'l)
J'"
C,(A) It suffices to prove that i. is a split inclusion; then the same holds for f , and (ii) follows immediately. Let .Ml(A[t,t-1]) C .M(A[t,t-1]) be the full subcategory of modules A) = 0, where we let A be the A[t, t-1]-module M satisfying w"'A[t't-t](M, -'-"'l A [ t , t - l ] / ( t - 1). Then by the resolution theorem (or rather, Cor. (4.7)), K~(~l(A[t,t-~]) ~- G,(A[t,t-1]). The functor i" .h/l(A) ~ fl4(A[t,t-1])
48
Algebraic K-Theory
clearly factors through ~41(A[t,t-1]). Also, there is an exact functor j 9 .A41(A[t,t-1]) } jg4(A)given by M ~ A | M (where as above, A is the cyclic A[t,t-1]-module with annihilator ( t - 1)). Clearly j o i is isomorphic to the identity functor. Hence j . o i . - Gi(A) } Gi([t, t - 1]) } Gi (A) is the identity. P r o o f (i). We begin by proving a lemma. Let B = A[tl,...,tn] be the polynomial ring in n variables over A, with its usual grading (degti = 1 for all i, deg a = 0 for all a E A). Let MgrB denote the category of positively graded, finite B-modules. Thus each N E .MgrB can be written as N = (~p>0 Np where the Np are finite A-modules. Then N has a finite increasing filtration {FvN}v>0, where FpN is the B-submodule generated by No ~ . - - ~ 9 Np. Regard A as a graded B-module annihilated by t 1 , . . . , tn and concentrated in degree 0. Then A | N is a graded B-module with
(A
g).
+ . . . + B go
as A-modules, where B~ C B is the A-submodule of homogeneous polynomials of degree i. Thus
(.)
(A |
FpN)rn =
0
(A |
N)m
ifp<m ifp>m.
For any N ~_ .MgrB, and any p > O, let N ( - p ) E .M,qrB be the graded module with underlying B-module N and grading
Nm-v
N(-p)m-
0
ifm >p ifm
L e m m a (5.3). Let N e MgrB such that Tor~ (A, N) = 0. Then for each p > 0 the natural map of graded B-modules
Cn " B ( - p ) |
(A |
N)v
, FpN/Fp_IN
is an isomorphism. P r o o f . Since (A | N)v "~ (FpN/Fp-IN)v, and FpN/Fv_IN is generated over B by its A-submodule of elements of degree p, there is a natural map Cv as in the statement of the lemma, which is surjective. We prove t h a t under the condition Tor~(A,N) = 0, Cv is an injection for each p. We work by descending induction on p; for large p, N = FpN = Fv_l N so t h a t both sides vanish. We also have WorB (A, F p - I N ) = 0. Assume that r is an isomorphism, and that Tor B (A, FvN ) = 0; we will deduce that Cv is an isomorphism, and that Tor~(A, Fv_IN ) = O.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes From the sequence 0 have an exact sequence
, Fp_ 1N
, FpN
Tor~(A, FpN) --4 Tor~(A, FpN/Fp_IN) ---. A | ~ A|
l[
49
~ FpN/Fp_ 1N Fp_IN
', A |
, 0 we F~,N--,
(FpN/Fp_,N) ---, O.
0 From (.), A @B Fp_ 1N , A | B Fp N is an isomorphism in degrees _< p - 1, and A| Fp_ 1N vanishes in all higher degrees. Hence the map i is injective, and so T o r f (A, FpN/Fp_ I N) = O. Now consider the exact sequence (which defines M)
0 Tens|
;M
~B ( - p ) |
(A |
g)p r
FpN/Fp_IN
, O.
with the B-module A, we obtain
0--, Wor~(A, F p N / F p _ l g ) ~ A |
M --, (A |
N)n --'
~ (A | F p N / F , _ I N ) p - 4 0 .
[1 0
Since r is an isomorphism in degree p, we obtain A | M - 0. Since M is a finite graded B-module, this forces M = 0. Hence r is an isomorphism. Since B is a polynomial ring, Wor~(A, B ( - p ) | K) = 0 for all i > 0, for any A-module K. Hence, using the isomorphism Cp,
Tor~(A, FpN/Fp_IN) = 0 for a l l / > 0. Hence Wor~(A, F p g ) = 0 ~ Wor~(A, F p _ l g ) = O. This completes the inductive step, and the proof of the lemma. The operation N , N ( - 1 ) gives an exact functor from A4grB to itself. Hence there is a natural Z[t]-module structure on Ki(A4grB), where t acts by shifting the grading by - 1 . The change of rings map gives a homomorphism Gi(A) ~ Ki(A/Igr B), and hence a homomorphism 0 : G,(A)| ; Ki(.A4grB), where r =) = Cn(x), and Cn is induced by the functor fl4(A) ; A4grB, P ~-~ B ( - n ) | P. P r o p o s i t i o n (5.4). r gives an isomorphism G,(A) |
X[t] ~= Ki(A4grB).
P r o o f . Let Af C fl4grB denote the full subcategory consisting of all modules N such that T o r ~ ( A , N ) = 0 for all j > 0. Since the functors Tj = WorB ( A , - ) vanish for all j > n (the number of polynomial variables), Cor. (4.7) to the resolution theorem implies that Ki(Af) ~ Ki(A4gr~). Let Afp C At" be the full subcategory of modules N satisfying FpN = N i.e., N is generated by elements of degree < p. There are exact functors
. ~ ( a ) p+I
,,
~.Afp b ,
. M ( A ) P +~
50
Algebraic K-Theory
given by
p
a ( M 0 , . . . , Mp) = @ B ( - j ) |
Mj
j=O
and
b(N) = ((A |
N ) o , . . ., (A |
N)p).
Clearly b o a : M ( A ) p+I , M ( A ) p+I is the identity. Now the identity functor Ip :Afp , Alp has an admissible filtration by additive subfunctors Fq : N ~ F q N , O<_q<_p. I f 0 , N' , N , N" ,0isanexact sequence in Af, then 0
;A |
N'
*A |
N
, A |
N"
~0
is exact. Hence, from Lemma (5.3), the sequences
0
~FqY'/Fq_lg'
, FqN/Fq_IN
~Fqg"/Fq_lN"
~0
are exact, for 0 < q < p. Hence by Cor. (4.4), p
E ( Fq / Fq_ I ) . = ( Ip ) . " K i (./kfp)
, K , (.N'p) .
q=l
But by Lemma (5.3), the map ~ ( F q / F q _ l ) . is precisely the map on Ki(Afp) induced by the composite functor a o b. Hence the functor a induces an isomorphism a . : G,(A) p+I , g,(A/'p). Taking the direct limit over p (Lemma (3.8)), the proposition follows. P r o o f o f T h e o r e m (5.2) (i). Let B = A[t, u] be the polynomial ring, C - A[t, u, u -1] the localization with respect to powers of u. As above let A/IsrB denote the category of finite positively graded B-modules. Let A4grC denote the category of finite Z-graded C-modules. Then A4grC is naturally equivalent to the quotient of A/[grB by the Serre subcategory ,4 of modules annihilated by a power of u. Clearly A/fgr(A[t]) C .A as the full subcategory of modules annihilated by u; by d6vissage, K,(J~d3r(A[t]) ) ~ K , ( A ) . Also, we have a natural equivalence of categories Ad3rC -~; A/f(A[x]), where x = ~t E C, given by N ~-, No (the inverse functor is given by change of rings). Hence from the localization theorem we have an exact sequence
--, K,(M2p(A[t]) ) *, K , ( M g r B )
, G,(A[x])
, Ki_I(MSr(A[t]) ) ---~.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes Now
K~(~gr(A[t])) ~- G,(A) |
Z[y]
g,(MgrB) u G,(A)|
Z[y]
51
where multiplication by y corresponds to a shift in grading by - 1 in both cases. Hence r is Z[y]-linear, so to compute it, it suffices to compute For any A-module M we have an exact sequence of graded B-modules 0
, B ( -- 1 ) |
u ~B |
M
~ A[t] |
M
~0
where Air] = B / u B . Thus the composite functor i" M ( A )
, Mg(A[t])
M ~-, A[t] |
M
fits into an exact sequence of functors j~4(A)
o
,j(-1)
, MgrB , A/lgrB
,j:
,o,
where j ( - n ) " .M(A) , .M,qr B is j ( - n ) ( M ) = B ( - n ) | M. Hence i, ( 1 - y ) . j , 9 G,(A) ~ K~(MgrB). Thus r is identified with multiplication by 1 - y . In particular r is injective with cokernel isomorphic to Gi(A), where the isomorphism is given by
j , " G,(A) Hence G,(A)
, g~(.MgrB)
, g , ( . M g r S ) / ( 1 - y ) . g , ( M g r B).
; G,(A[x]), given by change of rings, is an isomorphism.
C o r o l l a r y (5.5). Let A be a regular ring. Then
(i)
K,(A)
~- g , ( A [ t ] )
(ii) Ki(A[t,t-1]) ~- Ki(A) @ K i _ I ( A ) (where if i = 0, K _ I ( A ) is defined to be 0). (5.6) K - T h e o r y of S c h e m e s . For terminology from algebraic geometry, we refer to Appendix D. If X is an arbitrary scheme, let P ( X ) denote the category of locally free sheaves of finite rank, which is a full subcategory of the Abelian category of quasi-coherent sheaves of Ox-modules on X (see (D.10), (D.17), (D.43)). Define K ~ ( X ) = K~(T'(X)). If X is a Noetherian scheme (D.24), let A4(X) be the Abelian category of coherent sheaves (see (D.44)) on X; define G i ( X ) - Ki(.A4(X)) (sometimes this is also denoted by K ' ( X ) ) . Since we will mainly study Gi at this point, we assume until further notice that all schemes under consideration are Noetherian and separated (D.33), unless explicitly mentioned otherwise.
52
Algebraic K-Theory
There is a natural homomorphism Ki(X) , a i ( x ) induced by 7)(X) C fl4(X). If X is regular (D.25), then (since X is Noetherian, hence quasi-compact (D.23)) every coherent sheaf on X is a quotient of a locally free sheaf of finite rank (see (D.54), (D.55)), and hence has a finite resolution by locally free sheaves of finite rank. Hence by the resolution theorem, Ki(X) ~ Gi(X). If E is a locally free sheaf on X , then the assignment (see (D.8) for tensor products)
c
.r, .r
M(X)
gives an exact functor [s176: M ( X ) , M(X), and hence a map [t:]. : Gi(X) ~, G,(X) for each i. If 0 ~ E' , E , C" ) 0 is an exact sequence in 7~(X), then [E]. - [E~]. + [C']., since we have an exact sequence of functors M(X) , M ( X )
0
,re'].
,[el.
,[e"].
,0
corresponding to the exact sequences in M ( X ) 0
~ ,~' |
~E |
, g" |
tO.
Thus, C ~-~ [g]. extends to a homomorphism Ko(X) , End(G,(X)), i.e., a pairing Ko(X)| G,(X) , G,(X). Since Ko(X) is a ring with the multiplication induced by tensor products of locally free sheaves, the above pairing in fact makes G,(X) a module over the commutative ring Ko(X). Similarly one can define K0 (X )-module structures on all the Ki(X), such that K~(X) ~G,(X) is a K0(X)-module homomorphism. If X - Spec A is affine (see (D.15)), then we have natural equivalences of categories P ( X ) -~ "P(A), .M(X) ~'~ .M(A). Hence K~(X) ~- K~(A), Gi(X) '~ Gi(A), and we identify these groups under these natural isomorphisms. R e m a r k (5.7). From Theorem (5.1), Ki(A) defined using the Q-construction agrees with the earlier definition in Chapter 3 as 7r~(BGL(A)+), for i >_ 1. The latter groups have the product K~(A)| Kj(A) ~ K~+j(A) defined in Chapter 3 for i,j >_ 1; one can show that this is K0(A)-bilinear, making {~)i>0 Ki(A) into a graded anti-commutative ring. More generally, F. Waldhausen (Algebraic K - T h e o r y of Generalized Free Products, Ann. Math. 108 (1978), 135-256) has shown t h a t if ,4, B, C w
are exact categories , and ,4x B F .~ C is bi-exact (i.e., F ( M , - ) and F ( - , N) are exact functors for each M E .4, N E B) then there is a product (for each i, j > 0)
g,(A) | Kj(B)
, gi+j(C)
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
53
satisfying certain naturality properties, and which agrees with Loday's product if ~4 - B - C - P(A). This new product will make ~ _ > 0 K , ( X ) into a graded anti-commutative ring, and ~ i > 0 G~(X) into a graded (~),>0 K~(X)-module (if X is Noetherian) such that
, Oa,(x) ~>_o
,>o
is a module homomorphism. (5.8) F u n c t o r i a l i t y P r o p e r t i e s . If f : X ~ Y is a morphism (see (D.16), (D.17)) of schemes, the exact functor f * : P ( Y ) .~ T'(X) (see (D.41) for f*)gives homomorphisms f* : K~(Y) ~ K~(X). Clearly K~ becomes a contravariant functor from schemes to Abelian groups. If f : X , Y is a flat morphism (D.40) of Noetherian schemes, we have an exact functor f* : A4(Y) ; A4(X), and hence a map on K-groups G i ( Y ) ~ G~(X). Thus G~ is a contravariant functor on the category of Noetherian schemes and flat morphisms. L e m m a (5.9). (i) Let i ~-, Xi be a filtered inverse system of schemes such that the transition morphisms X~ : ; Xj are affine (D.28), and let X = lim X,. Then Kq (X) = lim Kq (Xi). ---4
.---4
(ii) If in (i), X, X~ are all Noetherian, and the transition morphisms are also fiat, then Gq(X) - lim Gq(Xi). ---4
P r o o f . (i) We wish to apply Lemma (3.8), since :P(X) is essentially the direct limit of the P(X~). However i ~-, P(Xi) does not form a directed system of categories indexed by iop, since for morphisms i --, j --, k in I, (i --4 k)* " P ( X k )
, P(Xi)
(i -~ j ) * o ( j -~ k)* " P ( X ~ )
and ~P(X,)
are not equal, but only isomorphic (the tensor product involved in defining the pullback of a sheaf is not strictly associative, but only associative up to isomorphism). One gets around this problem by the following device. Let I' = ItJ {0} where 0 is an initial object, and let X0 = X. For i E I', let I ' / i be the full subcategory of I' consisting of objects j preceding i; then there is a unique morphism j ---, i for j e I~/i since iop, hence (It)Op, is directed. Let P~ denote the following category, for each i E / ' - - a n object in P~ is a family {(Pj,Oj) [ j e I ' / i } where Pj E :P(Xj), and Oj : (j --, i)*Pi , Pj is an isomorphism. An arrow f : { (Pj, 0j) } , { (P~, 0~) } is a collection of
54
Algebraic K-Theory
~rrow~ yj: Pj
) P; in P ( X j ) such that the diagram below commutes:
(j ---* i) *Pi
Oj
---.
(j ...4 i)*fi 1
0;
(J --. O'P"
~-
Pj
P~
, 7~(X,) given by { (Pj, Oj) } Pi is an equivalence Then 7~i egories for each i E I', and we claim (see the remark below) i a functor from (i,)op to small categories. Further, since (i,)op has object 0, the direct limit is just 79q~, which is equivalent to 79(X). the lemma follows from Lemma (3.8), and the fact t h a t
of cat, 7>/ is a final Hence
Q(lim 79i) = lim Q79i. --.4
(ii) The proof is similar and is left to the reader. R e m a r k . The transition functor T'i ~ Pj for a morphism j given by {(Pe, 0t) ]/~ e I ' / i } ~ {(Pt, Ct) ]/~ e ( I ' / j ) } , where so it makes sense to consider the subfamily of Pt with t E I ' / j family of Pc, e. E I'/i; the map Ce is the unique isomorphism following diagram commute: (e 9 j)* o ((j ~ i)*Pi)
(t -,j)'0j,
(e - , j ) * P j
(e ~ i)*Pi
ot
P,e
--~ i in I ' is I'/j C I'/i, of the given making the
where r/it is the "natural" isomorphism
(e - , j)* o ((j -~ 0*p~) -~ (e - , j)*P,, given by
O x , | (Oxj | Pi)
' O x t | Pi ,
which is locally given by a | (b | p) ~ ab | p. So one has to verify that with the above transition functors,
(e
,~)*=(e
.~j).o(j
~)*:p~
,7~,
for e ,j , i in I'. Both operations take a family {(Pro, 0,,,) [ m e I ' l l } to the same family of objects {P,,., [ m e I'/s and possibly two sets of isomorphisms Xm, X " " (m ---, e)*Pt ~ Pro; we have to verify that Xm = X " for every m E I ' / L This is a local question, so we are reduced to the affine case. Now the situation is as follows: we are given a direct system of rings {A/}iej, where g = (it)op is a filtering category. Let 79j = {(P~,O~)IP~ e
7)(Aj), Oj" Aj@A, Pi ~-} Pj}. The transition functors (i < j)*" 79i
; :Pj
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
55
are given by (i < j)* {(Pt, Oe)} = {(Pe,r where for j < t, Ce is the unique isomorphism making the following diagram commute:
Ae | (Aj | P,)
lt|
At | Pi
At|
ot
Pt
i.e., Ct = Oe o rio o (lt | 0#)- 1. Here rio is induced by a | (b | p) ~ ab | p. Now suppose i < j < g < m; then
(j < g)* o(i < j)*
{(Pro, Ore)} = { ( P m , xm)}
where Xm is defined by the commutativity of
Am | (At | Pj)
1.,,| ,
'1
Am|
1Xm
Vlmt
am | Pj
~",
I'm
(and ~7~e(a | (b | p) ) -- ab | p). On the other hand (i < g)"
{(Pm,0m)} = { ( P m , x ' ) } ,
where X" is the unique map making the following diagram commute:
A|174
1,,,|
A.-,|
Om
Am|
~
I'm.
Since Cm = Om o v/mj o ( l m | 0j)-x, the desired equality Xm = X" follows from the commutativity of the diagram:
A,~ | Pt (l,,,,@Ot Am|174
(x,,.|
Am|174174 ,. | (lt | 0,)
m|174 X,., = X "
qmt
l Illmt
Am| Pm
". e,,.
Am | P~
(
.,,.,
A,n |
@ P~)
56
Algebraic K-Theory
The commutativity of the outer border, with left vertical arrow Xm, is by the definition of Xm, while the commutativity of the left rectangle, with left vertical arrow X'm, is by definition of X ' - Hence, the commutativity of the hexagon proves Xm = X ' . To prove commutativity of the hexagon, let a E Am, b E At, c E Aj, p E Pi; then a | (b | (c | p)) E Am | (At | (Aj | Pi)) yields the hexagon | (b~ ~ p)(
~ ~ (b | ( ~ p))
~|174 Oj(~|
1
ab|174 abc | p
(
ab | (c@/p)
We note that the commutativity of the hexagon reflects a basic coherence property of the tensor product (see MacLane's book Categories for the Working Mathematician, Grad. Texts, No. 5, Springer-Verlag (1972)). (5.10) Let f : X , Y be a morphism (of Noetherian schemes) of finite Tor-dimension, i.e., there is an integer N > 0 such t h a t the Ox-modules Tor ~ (Ox, ~) -- 0 for all i > N for any ~" e A~t(Y). Let Ad (Y, f ) C j~4(Y) denote the full subcategory of sheaves ~- satisfying Tar~ v (Ox, ~ ) = 0 for all i > 0; then 7~(Y) C A/[(Y, f). Hence, if every coherent sheaf on Y is a quotient of a vector bundle, then by Cor. (4.7) of the resolution theorem, K,(.Ad(Y,f)) "~ G~(Y) for all i. Also, f * : fl/[(Y, f ) , Ad(X), ~ ~-. f*~-, is an exact functor in any case, yielding a map f* : Ki(.hd(Y, f)) Gi(X), so t h a t in the above situation, we have a map f* : Gi(Y) Gi(X). The condition that every coherent sheaf is a quotient of a vector bundle holds if either (i) Y is regular (D.54), or (ii) if Y supports an ample invertible sheaf (D.57) (e.g., Y is quasi-projective over a Noetherian ring (D.52)). Finally the formula (fog)* = g* of* is valid for maps f : X ." Y, g :Y , Z, both of which have finite Tot-dimension, such that coherent sheaves are quotients of vector bundles on Y and Z. (5.11) Let f : X ~. Y be a proper morphism (see (D.34), (D.38)), so that for any ~" E AA(X), Rif..T" E .Ad(Y) for each i, and the functors Rif. vanish for sufficiently large i on Ad(X) (see (D.12), (0.61), (0.62)). Let .A,4(X,f) C ~A(X) be the full subcategory of sheaves ~" satisfying Rif..T" - 0 for all i > 0. Then if every coherent sheaf on X is a subsheaf of a sheaf in M ( X , f ) , then K i ( M ( X , f)) ~ K i ( M ( X , f ) o p ) _~ Ki(.h~(X)Op) ~_
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
57
Ki(.M(X)), where the middle isomorphism follows from Corollary (4.7) of the resolution theorem, and we have used the fact that QC ~ QC ~ for any small exact category C (this is proved later, Cor. (6.3)). Hence, under this hypothesis on A4(X), there is a direct image map f . : G i ( X ) ---4 Gi(Y); and for appropriate maps f, g we have the formula ( f o g). = f . o g.. The hypothesis above on A//(X) (namely, that any coherent sheaf is a subsheaf of an object of A4(X, f)) is satisfied if either (i) f is finite, in which case A4(X) = A4(X, f), or (ii) X has an ample line bundle s In the latter case, s174 is generated by a finite number of global sections (as an Ox-module) for all sufficiently large n. For any coherent sheaf 3r on X, let ~'(n) denote 9r | s174 Then for all sufficiently large n, Rif.3r(n) = 0 for all i > 0 i.e., ~'(n) e A 4 ( X , f ) (this follows from (D.57), combined with (D.62)-(D.65)). If we fix such a value of n, which is large enough so that O x ( n ) is also generated by global sections, then we can find N global sections which generate Ox(n) for some N > 0, i.e., a surjection O~xI~ ~ O x ( n ) from a trivial bundle of rank N, whose kernel is a vector bundle on X. Applying the functor ~Omox ( - , O x ( n ) ) (i.e., dualizing and tensoring with O x ( n ) ) we obtain an exact sequence of vector bundles O --.
Ox
:
Ox(n)
,
-: , O,
and hence on tensoring with ~- an exact sequence in A4(X) o ---,
y(n)
--,
&, |
J:
o,
which gives an inclusion of ~" into a sheaf in A4(X, f). Note that in this construction, if j c e P ( X ) , then 3C(n)r162e 7~(X,f) = 7~(X)N A4(X, f ) . This is used below, in the proof of Prop. (5.12). P r o p o s i t i o n (5.12) (Projection formula). Let f : X ". Y be a proper morphism of finite Tot-dimension between schemes supporting ample line bundles, so that f* : G,(Y) ~ G,(X), f . : G,(X) ~ G,(Y) are both defined. Then (i) there is a well defined map f . : K i ( X ) ---* K i ( Y ) giving a commutative diagram
O,(X)
,-! K,(r)
l,-
---,
a,(y).
(ii) for any x e K o ( X ) , y e Gi(Y), we have the formula f . ( x ) . y f , ( z " f*y)
=
(iii) for any x e K o ( X ) , y e Ki(Y), we have the formula f . ( x ) . y
-
f,(x" f'y)
58
(iv)
Algebraic K-Theory for any y e Ko(Y), x e G i ( X ) , we have the formula f , ( f * ( y ) , x) -y. f.(~).
(in (ii), (iii), (iv) above,-denotes the K0-module structure; in (iv), we do not need the hypothesis that Y supports an ample line bundle).
Proof. The projection formula for sheaves (see (D.41)) f.(f*~ |
.7:') ~ ~ |
f..T,
for ~ y e e ~'(Y), J= e M ( x ) , immediately yidds Ov). We prove (i) ~nd (ii) below; the proof of (iii) is similar and is left to the reader. Let :P(X, f) = 7)(X) N Ad(X, f ) be the category of vector bundles C on X satisfying Rif.,f. = 0 for all i > 0. As noted at the end of (5.11), since X supports an ample line bundle, for any E E P ( X ) there is an admissible monomorphism E .~ s with E' E 7~(X, f ) (i.e., such that 0 ; C .~ E' .~ s ~ 0 is an exact sequence in 79(X)). Hence Ki(79(X, f)) ~ Ki(7~(X)) = Ki(X), as in (5.11). Let g" E P(X, f); then we claim that f . E E 7/(Y), the full subcategory of fld(Y) consisting of sheaves of finite homological dimension (see (D.56)); since Y supports an ample line bundle, these are precisely the sheaves which have finite resolutions by vector bundles (so that Ki(Y) ~ Ki(7"I(Y)) by the resolution theorem). Since being of finite homological dimension is a local property, our claim (that f . E E 7~(Y)) is local on Y. Hence for proving the claim we may assume Y = Spec A is affine. Now for any affine open subset U = Spec B in X, we know that T o r A ( B , - ) = 0 for all i > N (for some N independent of U), since f has finite Tor-dimension. Let Ui be an affine open cover of X by a finite number of open sets, such that C[u' is trivial; since f is separated, all the intersections Uil N - . . fq Ui.~ are affine (see (D.33)), and we can compute the cohomology groups Hi(X, E) from the (~ech complex associated to this affine cover (D.61). But Rif.E is just the sheaf on the affine scheme Y = SpecA associated to the A-module Hi(X,E), for each i _> 0 (see ( D . a 3 ) ( i v ) ) . Since ~ e P(X, f), we h a v e H'(X,C) = 0 for i > 0, and an exact sequence (with a finite number of non-zero terms)
0
' H~163
~
H H~163 i
' n
S~
fq Uj,s
--,....
i,j
Each germ in this sequence except the first is an A-module M which is given to have the property T o r ~ ( M , - ) - - 0 for i >_ N. Hence the functors Tor~(H~ C ) , - ) also vanish for i _> N, from repeated applications of the long exact sequence of Tors. But f.~" is the coherent Ov-module associated to the finite A-module H~ ~r which satisfies T o r f ( H ~ ~ ) , - ) -- 0 for
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
59
i > N. Hence H~ s has projective dimension < N over A, i.e., f . s has finite homological dimension. This completes the proof of (i). (ii) Let s E P(X, f) be fixed, and let
0
,Cm---~Cm-~
,'-----*Co
,f.E--,O
be a finite resolution by vector bundles on Y (which exists, as f , s E ~ ( Y ) ) . T h e n by definition, the action of [f,E] E Ko(Y) on G,(Y) is given by rn Y ~ ~-d=o(-1)Jxj.y, where y e Gi(Y), and xj = [E/]. Let Af C Ad(Y, f ) be the full subcategory of sheaves satisfying T o t OY ( / . E , ~') -- 0 for all i > 0 (this Tor sheaf is an Or-module). T h e n Ki(A/') ~ Gi(Y) by the resolution theorem. For any jc E Af, we have an exact sequence, natural in ~',
0
,c.~|174
,..---~c0|
,f.$|
,0
which we interpret as an exact sequence of functors Af , fld(Y). Hence the functor Af = ; fld(Y) given by tensoring with ].s represents the action of [f.E] E Ko(Y). Hence if x = [s E Ko(X), y H f. ( x ) . y is represented by the functor Af ; fld(Y) given by tensoring with f . s Next, we want a similar representation of y ~-. f. (x. f* (y)) by a functor Af ; Ad(Y). We claim t h a t for any ~- E Af, we have (a) R~f.(E| c) = 0 for all i > 0, (b) there is a natural isomorphism f . ( E | ~ (f.E)| In view of the claimed naturality in (b), both statements are local on Y, so to prove them, we may assume t h a t Y = Spec A is affine. T h e n ~" = M is the sheaf associated to a finite A-module M. Since T o t ~ ( f . s ~-) = 0 for i > O, T o r # ( H ~ 1 6 3 = 0 for i > 0 (as f.E is just the sheaf associated to H~163 Further, since ~ E Af C Ad(Y, f), if U = S p e c B is any affine open subset of X , then TorA(B, M) = 0 for all i > 0. Thus, if {Ui} is an affine open cover of X by a finite number of open sets such t h a t E Iu~ is trivial, then the exact sequence (obtained from the (~ech complex)
(,)
...0-
, H~ (X, s ) ~
H H~ ( Ui ' E ) --* H H~ ( Vi n Uj , s ) i i,j
,...
remains exact on tensoring with the A-module M, since for each t e r m in the sequence, TorA( - , M ) = 0 for all i > 0. For any affine open subset U = Spec B C X, f*.T'lv is the sheaf associated to the finite B - m o d u l e B | M , and so (E | f*.T')l v is the sheaf associated to the B - m o d u l e g~ F_.)| (B | M) ~ g ~ F_.)| M. Thus the sequence ( , ) , tensored with M (over A), is the analogous complex obtained from the (~ech complex for E | f * ~ by adjoining H~ | M at the beginning. Since this complex is exact, we conclude t h a t H~(X,F_. | f*.T') = 0 for i > 0, and
60
Algebraic K-Theory
H~ | f*:F) ~- H ~ | M as A-modules. This means precisely that R * f . g | f * ~ = 0 for i > 0, and f . ( g | f - j r ) ~ (f.E) | jr, proving the claims (a) and (b). Now the exact functor iV" , M ( X , f ) given by 5v ~-. g | f*~" represents G , ( Y ) ~.G~(X), y ~ x. f*y. Hence the exact functor Af ~ A d ( Y ) given by ~" H f . ( g | f*.T') represents G i ( Y ) ~ Gi(Y), y ~-* f . ( x . f ' y ) . Since we have an isomorphism of functors Af , Ad(Y) given by the natural isomorphism f . ( s | f ' J : ) "~ ( f . g ) | Jr, we obtain the formula ( f . x ) . y = f . ( x . f ' y ) for any y E Gi(Y) and x = [g], with g E 7~(X, f). But such classes x generate K o ( X ) , and both sides are additive in x. Proposition
(5.13). Let X !
y'
gt }
X
,
Y
g
be a fiber product diagram of schemes with ample line bundles. Assume that f is proper and g has finite Tor dimension, and that O x , Or', are Tot-independent over O r . Then g* o y. = $" o g'* in Hom(a,(X), G , ( Y ' ) ) . P r o o f . We leave the proof to the reader (see Quillen's paper, Prop. (2.11) for a proof using the analogous formula in the derived category). The point is to prove that if ~ E j~d(X, f) n 2vI(X, g~), then f . ~ E Ad(Y, g), g~.jc- E M ( X ~, f~), and we have an isomorphism g*f..T ~ ].g ; the interested reader can give a direct proof of this using a suitable (~ech complex, along the lines of the previous proof. C l o s e d S u b s c h e m e s . Let i : Z ~ X be a closed subscheme, j : U ,X the open complement. Let Iz denote the (coherent) sheaf of ideals of Z in O x . We can identify M ( Z ) with the full subcategory of A d ( X ) consisting of sheaves annihilated by Iz, via the functor i. (see (D.29), (D.43)). Proposition
(5.14). If I z is nilpotent, then Gi(Z) ~ G , ( X ) .
P r o o f . Immediate from the d(~vissage theorem (4.8). Proposition
(5.15). There is a long exact sequence
) Gi+l(V)
' Gi(Z) i . Gi(X) J ' ; ,...
,Go(X)
Gi(U)
,Go(U)
9 a~_ ~( Z ) ~0.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
61
P r o o f . Let B c A4(X) be the Serre subcategory of sheaves ~" with Jc[u = 0; then A4(Z) c B is a homotopy equivalence by d6vissage, and the quotient . A 4 ( X ) / B is equivalent to A4(U). The result follows from the localization theorem (4.9). (5.16) N a t u r a l i t y . The exact sequence of Prop. (5.15) has certain naturality properties. For example, if Z
i
;
Z l
,}
i
X
are closed subschemes, we have a diagram 9. . - - ,
G~+~(X-Z)
-.
G~(Z)
9. . - 4
G~+~(X-Z')
-.
G~(Z')
(i' o i).
G~(X)
--.
~-L
a~(x-
z)
-~...
II
it
G~(x)
-~
(J~
G~(X-Z')--,...
where X-
Z'
j,
} X-Z
.}
3
X
are the corresponding open immersions. Also, a fiat map f : X ' , X induces a map from the sequence for (X, Z) to that for (X', f - 1 Z ) . Finally, if U, V c X are open subschemes, there is a Mayer-Vietoris sequence
G,(U)@G,(V)
,G,(Uuv)
9
, c,~(unv)
~....
Indeed, we may assume without loss of generality that U U V = X; then ifY =X-U, Z =X-V, then Y N Z = O a n d X - ( Y O Z ) -- U A V . Since A4(Y O Z) ~ Ad(Y) x A4(Z), as Y and Z are disjoint, we have G , ( Y U Z) ~- G , ( Y ) @ G , ( Z ) . The Mayer-Vietoris sequence follows by a standard diagram chase from G~(Y) ~9 Gi(Z)---.Gi(X) @ Ci(X)--~ G~(U) ~ G~(V) ---~G~-I(Y) ~ g G i - l ( Z )
II ---~G,(YUZ)
1 --~
Gi(X)
II
l ~
G~(UAV)
---,
Gi-I(YuZ)
(where the top row is the direct sum of the localization sequences for
Y, Z).
P r o p o s i t i o n (5.17) (Homotopy property). Let f : P ~ X be a fiat map whose fibers (see (D.31)) are al~ne spaces (e.g., a geometric vector bundle (D.59)). Then f * : G,(X)
-, G , ( P )
is an isomorphism for all
i.
62
Algebraic K-Theory
ProoL
For any morphism T
, X let PT = P x x T, so t h a t all fibers of
PT f r T are also affine spaces and f T is flat. In particular, if Z C X is a closed subscheme, U = X - Z, we have a diagram 9. . ~
c,(z)
c,(Pz)
9 . . - ~
~
c,(x)~
~
c,(P)
By the 5-1emma, the proposition to hold for the other two.
-~ holds
c,(v)
~
c,(Pv)
~
G,_,(z)
--,...
C,_a(Pz)
- ~ . . .
for any one of X, Z, U ifit
is known
By Noetherian induction, we may assume t h a t the proposition is valid for all proper closed subschemes Z c X , and we will prove it for X . If X is non-reduced, we can take Z = Xred, SO t h a t P z = Pred, and the proposition holds for X if it holds for Z, by Prop. (5.14). Next, if X is reducible, say X = Z1U Z2, then the proposition holds for Z1 and X - Z 1 = Z 2 - ( Z 1 N Z 2 ) (since it holds for Z2 and Z1 N Z2), hence it holds for X. Thus, we are reduced to the case when X is reduced and irreducible. Now we take the direct limit of the above diagrams as Z runs over all proper closed subschemes of X (ordered by inclusion; use the functoriality properties (5.16)). Since direct limits are exact, we obtain a d i a g r a m (where k ( X ) is the function field of X ) 9-.--~ l i m O i ( Z )
I
9-. --. l i m G i ( P z )
--*
Oi(X)
--*
Gi(P)
I
---*
Oi(k(X))
-4
Gi(Pk(x))
I
~
limGi_l(Z) --,---
--*
limai_l(Pz)
I
.=-b
-*'"
where we have identified lim G~(U) with G~(k(X)) (and similarly c o m p u t e d lim G , ( P u ) ) by Lemma (5.9). Thus we are reduced to the case X = Spec k, where k is a field, and P -~ Spec k [ t l , . . . , tn] is affine space of some dimension over k; this follows from T h e o r e m (5.2).
P r o p o s i t i o n (5.18) (Projective Bundles). Let s be a vector bundle of rank r over X, P ( E ) = Proj(S(E)) the associated projective b~ndt~, wh~,~ S ( ~ ) is the symmetric algebra of E. Let f : P ( C ) ~ X be the structure map. Then we have an isomorphism of Ko(P(s
go(P(e)) |
c,(x) -% c,(~(e))
for each i > O, given by y | x H y . f * x . Further, if z E K0(]F(C)) is the
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
63
class of Or(z)(-1), then the above isomorphism can be rewritten as
a,(xy r--1
i=0
P r o o f . One knows that K0(P(s is a free Ko(X) module of rank r with basis 1, z , . . . ,z r-1 (we prove a stronger result, Theorem (5.29), later; but this fact is "classical"-- see e.g., Manin, Lectures on the K-functor in algebraic geometry, Russian Math. Surveys 24 (5) (1969) 1-89). Hence it suffices to prove the second formulation of the result. Using the localization sequence and Noetherian induction as above, we easily reduce to the case X = Spec k, where k is a field, and ~: corresponds to a vector space E of dimension r over k. Then S(s corresponds to S(E) ~- k[to,..., tr-l], the polynomial ring in r variables, and P(s ~ p~-l. The standard correspondence (see (D.46)) between finite graded S(E)modules and coherent sheaves on P(E) identifies A4(P(E)) with the quotient of the Abelian category of finite positively graded S(E)-modules A4grS(E), by the Serre subcategory A4f,grS(E ) of modules of finite length. By d6vissage, the Serre subcategory has the same K-groups as the subcategory A42p(k) of positively graded finite dimensional k-vector spaces, considered as S(E)-modules annihilated by E . S(E). The K-groups of A4grS(E) are computed by Prop. (5.4) as
K~(A4gr(S(E)) ~- Gi(k) |
Z[t]
where t acts by shifting the grading by - 1 . Clearly K~(A42?rk) "~ G~(k) | Z[t] since fl4grk ~ limA4(k) n, where A4(k) n C A4grk is identified with the subcategory of graded finite dimensional vector spaces which vanish in degrees > n; again t E Z[t] acts by shifting the grading. Hence the localization sequence gives a diagram (whose commutativity defines h)
9..
,
K~(fl4grk)
l
a (k) |
Z[t]
where h is Z[t]-lineax.
-----, K~(A4grS(E))
h
l a (k) |
~. G, (P(E))
,..-
Z[t]
Hence to compute h it suffices to compute the composite G~(k) , Ki(A4,qrk) i. K~(A4grS(E)), which is induced 'by the functor associating to a k-vector space W the S(E)-module obtained by letting E . S(E) act trivially on W; this is graded by assuming it to be concentrated in degree 0. The Koszul resolution for the S(E)-mcdule k
64
Algebraic K-Theory
gives an exact sequence 7"
0
, S(E)(-r) | , S(E)|
W
AE| , W
W ,
,...
, S(E)(-1) |
E|
W
O.
Regarding this as an exact sequence of functors ~4(k) , A4grS(E), we see t h a t h is just multiplication by X - t ( E ) e Z[t], where A_t(E) = ~ ( - 1 ) ~d i m ( ~ ' E ) - P . Since A - t ( E ) is a monic polynomial in t of degree r-1 r, h is injective and ~ j = o Gi(k) tj maps isomorphically onto the cokernel. Thus the map
a~(k) r
, G,(F(E)), (xo,. . . , x r - 1 ) H ~
z'x,
is an isomorphism, since the operation of shifting the grading by - 1 corresponds to tensoring with Op(E)(--1), i.e., to the action of z e K0(IP(E)) under the module structure. (5.19) F i l t r a t i o n b y C o d i m e n s i o n o f S u p p o r t . (See (D.30), (D.45).) Let X be a Noetherian scheme, Z c X a closed subscheme; we define the codimension of Z in X to be c o d i m ( Z , X ) = i n f z e z ( d i m O z , X ) . If E 2vl(X), the support of ~" is the subscheme of X with ideal sheaf A n n ~ ' , the annihilator of ~" in O x . Let M P ( X ) C j ~ ( X ) be the Serre subcategory consisting of those coherent sheaves ~ whose support is a subscheme of codimension ~_ p in X. From Lemma (3.8) and Prop. (5.14), K,(j~/IP(X)) = lim Gi(Z), where Z runs over closed subsets of codimension --t
> p in X. If f " X ' , X is flat, then f*.A/ln(X) C J~4n(X'); indeed it suffices to note that if Z C X is a closed subscheme with codim(Z, X) > p, then c o d i m ( f - l ( Z ) , X ') > p, which follows from the following statement about local r i n g s - if R ~ S is a flat homomorphism of local rings such t h a t the maximal ideal of R generates an ideal in S primary to the maximal ideal of S, then dim R = dim S. (Compare with (D.40).) If i ~-~ Xi is a filtered inverse system of Noetherian schemes with affine, flat transition morphisms, such that the inverse limit X is Noetherian, then Kq(.A4P(X)) - - l i m Kq(.A4P(X,)). Indeed, since Kq(.A4P(X)) - lim Gq(Z), ---t
---t
where Z runs over subschemes of codimension _> p in X, and a similar result holds for Kq(.MP(X~)) for each i, it suffices to prove t h a t if Z C X is a closed subscherne of codimension >_ p, and fi " X , Xi is the canonical map, then for some i and some subscheme Z' C Xi of codimension > p in Xi, we have f i - l ( z ') = Z. If i E I is fixed (where I is the indexing category), and Ui c Xi is an affine open subset, then for any j E I \ i, (j --, i ) - x ( u i ) = Uj C X j is affine open, and if Uj = SpecAj, then f - 1 (U~) = U = Spec A c X is affine open, with A = lim Aj. The ideal of ---t
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
65
l(z~)
Z N U is finitely generated, since X is Noetherian, so t h a t Z fq U = fjfor some closed subscheme Z~ C Uj. Since Xi has a finite cover by affine open subsets, the claim follows. Define a decreasing filtration on G~(X) = Ki(A4(X)) by
FPG,(X) =
image(g,(fl4n(X))
, K,(M(X))).
This is called the filtration by codimension of support, and is a finite filtration provided X has finite Krull dimension. ( 5 . 2 0 ) . Let X n C X be the set of points of codimension p in X. There is a spectral sequence (of cohomological type)
Theorem
Ef'q = E['q(X) = H
K-n-q(k(x)) ~
G-n-q(X),
xEXn
which is convergent when X has finite Krull dimension, such that the induced filtration of Gn(X) is the filtration by codimension of support. The spectral sequence is contravariant for fiat morphisms; further, if i ~ Xi is a filtered inverse system of Noetherian schemes with affine, fiat transition morphisms whose inverse limit X is Noetherian, then the spectral sequence for X is the direct limit of the spectral sequences for the X~. R e m a r k . This spectral sequence is sometimes referred to in the literature as the BGQ (Brown-Gersten-Quillen) spectral sequence. In the statement of the above theorem, we interpret the notation to mean Kn = 0 for n < 0. Thus the spectral sequence is concentrated in degrees p _> 0, p + q _< 0; in particular it is a 4th quadrant spectral sequence of cohomological type. Proof of Theorem
(5.20). Consider the filtration by Serre subcategories M
(x) . . . .
There is an equivalence of categories I_[
x6_.X,
where .A(Ox,x) is the category of O.,x-modules of finite length. By d~vissage, if k(x) is the residue field of Ox,x, then
Kq(k(x)) ~ Gq(k(x)) ~ Kq(.A(O.,x)), for any x E X. Hence we have localization sequences
, Ki(MP+'(X))--~ K,(A,ff(X))
K,(k(x))
' H xEXp
, . . .
66
Algebraic K-Theory
giving rise to a spectral sequence by the method of exact couples (see Appendix C). The functoriality assertions follow immediately from the functorial properties of the filtration {AdP} noted earlier. (5.21). The following conditions on a Noetherian scheme X are equivalent:
Lemma
(i) Vp ~ 0, .MP+I(X)
, M P ( X ) induces 0 on K-groups.
(ii) V q < 0, EP'q(x) = 0 for p ~ O, and the edge homomorphism a _ q ( X ) - - , E~ is an isomorphism. (iii)
Vn
>_ O, the sequence of Abelian groups 0
,On(X)
e
H
Kn(k(x)) d ,
xEX o
H
K n - l ( k ( x ) ) d , ...
xEX 1
is exact, where dl is the differential on the E1 terms of the spectral sequence, and e is obtained by functoriality from the (fiat) morphisms Spec Ox,x : ; X, for x e X ~ and the isomorphism Gq(Ox,x) ""= Gq(k(x)) ~= Kq(k(x)). P r o o f . This follows easily from the construction of the spectral sequence. For any p _> 0, i > 1, the differential dl on I_Ixexp K~(k(x)) is obtained from the following diagram whose rows are exact localization sequences:
--* I_Ixex~' K~(k(x))
--'
' Ki-1 (AdP+I(X)) ~
'
Ki_I(fldP(X))--.
' ILex,§
Now if (i) holds, the various localization sequences break up into short exact sequences 0
' K'(MP(X))
' H
K,(k(x)) --~ K , _ I ( M p + I ( x ) )
,0.
zEXP
These sequences splice together to give the exact sequences in (iii). Since the sequences in (iii) are constructed from the complexes of E1 terms, whose cohomology groups are precisely the E2 terms, clearly (ii) is a reformulation of (iii). Hence (i) =~ (iii) r (ii). Now assume (iii). We prove by induction on p _> 0 that
K,(.AdP+ I (X)) ~ K,(.MP (X) ) is 0, for all i. To start the induction, we note that the injections e "G,(X)
' H xEX o
K,(k(x))
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
67
fit into the localization sequence
9..---, g,(.h,41(X))---,
g,(M(X))--~I_[g,(k(x))--, K , _ I ( . M I ( X ) ) 4 . . . xEX o
II
a (x) Hence this breaks up into short exact sequences 0 ~
Ki(.A,4(X))
e;
n
Ki(k(x))
, Ki_I(M'(X))
, O,
zEX o
and Ki(.MI(X)) ~ Ki(.M(X)) is 0 for all i _> 0. Suppose we already know, by induction, that for 0 < p' < p, the localization sequence of AAP'+I(X) c M r' (X) splits into short exact sequences 0
' H K,(k(x))
' Ki(M/"(X))
, K,_,(MI"'+I(x))
, O,
xEXP'
so that Ki(.MV+I(X))
dl"
. Ki(.MV(X)) is 0 for all i. The differential
H
K,+l(k(x))
'
xiF.X I , - 2
H
K,(k(x))
xEX t,- t
factors as the composite
H
g,+,(k(x))
", K i ( M P - ' ( X ) )
xeXv-2
I I K,(k(x)), zEXI,- t
whose cokernel is
,,
H
zEXv-t
Thus, in the factorization
dl"
H
K,(k(x))
, K,_I(MP(X))
' II
:r.EXP
xEXP-l
we see that by the exactness of the sequence in the hypothesis (iii) of the lemma, K'-I(MP(X))
' H gi_l(k(x)) zEXv
must be injective, for all i. Thus the localization sequence for AdP+I(X) c AdP(X) breaks up into short exact sequences, and Ki(aMP+I(X)) Ki(.MP(X)) is 0 for all i. We have assumed p > 1 in the above argument, but a minor variant works for p = 0.
68
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o p o s i t i o n (5.22). Let Gn,x denote the (Zariski)sheaf on X associated to the presheafU ~-. Gn(U). Assume that SpecOx,x satisfies the equivalent conditions of Lemma (5.21) for each x E X . Then there are canonical isomorphisms E~ 'q ~ H P ( X , G-q,X) (where the E2 groups are those obtained from the spectral sequence of Theorem (5.20)). P r o o f . For each open set U C X, form the complex given in Lemma (5.21) (iii); as U runs over all open subsets of X, we may view these complexes as defining a complex of presheaves for the Zariski topology on X. The associated complexes of sheaves have the form 0
} Gn,X
} H
(ix).gn(k(x))
' H
xEX o
(ix).gn_l(k(x))~
...
xEX 1
for n > 0, where ix " Spec k(x) } X is the canonical map, and for x E X n, K n _ n ( k ( x ) ) is regarded as a constant sheaf on Speck(x). The stalk of the above complex (for a given n) at x E X is just the corresponding complex for the scheme Spec Ox,x, since lim Gn(U) - Gn(Ox,x), and the xEU
spectral sequence commutes with filtered inverse limits of schemes (with affine flat transition maps). By hypothesis, this complex of stalks is exact for each x c X and n > 0. Hence the above complex of sheaves gives a resolution of Gn,x by flasque sheaves, which are known to be acyclic for the Zariski topology. Hence the associated complex of global sections, which is a complex of E1 terms, computes the cohomology groups H i ( X , Gn,x). But the cohomology groups of the complexes of E1 terms are precisely the E2 terms of the spectral sequence. G e r s t e n ' s C o n j e c t u r e . The equivalent conditions of Lemma (5.21) are valid if X = Spec R, where R is a regular local ring. T h e o r e m (5.23). Gersten's conjecture holds for R = k [ [ k l , . . . , x , ] ] , the ring of formal power series in n variables, and for R equal to the ring of convergent power series in n variables over a field k complete with respect to a non-trivial valuation. P r o o f . First consider the case n -
k [ [ x l , . . . ,xn]]. We prove that , M
(R)
induces 0 on K-groups (where 2vln(R) stands for Adn(Spec R)). Clearly K , ( M n + ' ( R ) ) = lirn K , ( M n ( R / t R ) ) t
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
69
where t runs over non-zero non-units of R. Hence it suffices to prove t h a t fl4n(R/tR) ~, fl4P(R) induces 0 on K-groups for any such t. By the Weierstrass preparation theorem, after a change of coordinates, we can assume t h a t A = k [ [ X l , . . . , xn-1]] is such that the composite A } R ~ R / t R is injective, and R / t R is a finite A-module. Let B = R | R/tR; since R -~ A[[x.]], B ~ (R/tR)[[~.}l. There is a natural surjection of (R/tR)-algebras r B = R | R/tn , R/tR; if r = a E R/tR, then the kernel of r is generated by ( x n - a) (here xn E R C R | R/tR). Thus, given any (R/tR)-module M we have an exact sequence 0
;B |
M (x.-~) B |
M
~M
;0
of B-modules, where ( x n - a ) denotes multiplication by x n - a . Considering these as R-modules, if M E A4P(R/tR), then the above sequence yields an exact sequence of exact functors
A4n(R/tR) ---. A/In(R). Since the first two terms correspond to isomorphic functors, which yield the same map on K-groups, the last term, corresponding to the inclusion functor fl4n(R/tR) } fl4n(R), induces 0 on K-groups. The above argument also works when R is a convergent power series ring, since the Weierstrass preparation theorem holds in t h a t case too. Theorem
(5.24) (Quillen). Let R be a regular semi-local ring, which is a
localization of a finitely generated algebra over a field k. Then the equivalent conditions of Lemma (5.21) hold for R. P r o o f . We will only prove the result in the special case when Spec R is smooth over an infinite field k (see (D.67)). We refer the reader to Quillen's paper Higher Algebraic K-Theory I for the proof in the general case. Let A be a finitely generated k-algebra, and S a finite set of primes of A, such t h a t R is the semi-local ring of S on X = Spec A. Since R is smooth, we may assume t h a t A is smooth over k. Without loss of generality we may take R, A to be domains. We want to prove t h a t A4 n+ I(R) ---, .hAP(R) induces 0 on K-groups. Clearly K , ( M n+l (R)) = lim K,(.Mn+I(AI)), where f runs over all elements of A which do not vanish at S. Replacing A by any one such AI, it suffices to prove that A,In+I(A) } .A4n(R) induces 0 on K-groups. Now
K,(~4n+' (A)) = lim K,(~4P(A/tA)) t
Algebraic
70
K-Theory
where t runs over non-zero divisors in A. Hence it suffices to prove t h a t for each non-zero divisor t E A, there exists f E A such t h a t f does not vanish on S, and fl4V(A/tA) ,
~ fl4P(AI),
M ~ M f,
induces 0 on K-groups. We now use: N o r m a l i z a t i o n L e m m a ( 5 . 2 5 ) . Let A be a smooth, finitely generated k algebra o f dimension r; let S C Spec A be a finite set, and t E A a non-zero divisor. T h e n there is a polynomial subring B = k [ x l , . . . , Xr-1] C A such that (i) A / t A is finite over B (ii) A is smooth over B at the points o f S. P r o o L Let X = Spec A; then there is an embedding X C AN as a smooth, closed subvariety. Let Y = S p e c ( A / t A ) c X; then dim Y = r - 1. Since k is infinite, the "general" linear projection A N ; A t - 1 restricts to a finite morphism Y , A r - l , by the Noether normalization lemma (see (D.69)). Since X is smooth, the "general" linear projection X , A r-1 is s m o o t h at S, since k is infinite, by Bertini's t h e o r e m (see (D.68)). This proves t h e lemma. Now let B ' = A / t A , A' = A | B ' , so t h a t there is a m a p of B ' algebras s 9 A ' ~ B ' , giving a diagram A'
(
(
"
"A
J~
9 B
Let S ' - v - 1 (S) be the set of primes of A' lying over S. Since A is s m o o t h over B on S, A' is smooth over B ~ on S'. Since the relative dimension of A ~ over B ' is 1, if I = ker s, then I is locally principal at the points of S ~ (if x ~_ S ' C SpecA t, y E Spec B ' the image under (u~) * 9 Spec A' ; Spec B ~, t h e n to see that I is principal near x we may replace A ~, B ~ by their respective complete local rings at x, y, by N a k a y a m a ' s lemma; now we are reduced to the situation ( A ' ) ^ ~ (B~)A[[z]], the ring of formal power series, where the claim is obvious--see the proof of (5.23)). Thus I is principal in a neighborhood of S'. Since A' is finite over A, and S ' = v - l ( S ) , we can find f E A such t h a t f does not vanish on S, and I f = I . A~ is principal. Since A' is smooth over B ' on S', it is s m o o t h in a neighborhood of S ~, and we m a y assume f above has been chosen so t h a t in addition A~ is s m o o t h (hence flat) over B'.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
71
Given any finite ( A / t A ) = B~-module M we have an exact sequence of finite A~ modules 0
~ II |
M
~A~I |
M
~M f
, O.
Since A~ is flat over S', if M E A/IP(B'), then A~ | M - ~ / / | M lies in j~cff(A~). Since A~ is finite over A! we can then regard the above sequence as an exact sequence in .MP(AI) , giving an exact sequence of exact functors ./vff( A I t A )
, .h/ff ( A l ) .
Since b is principal, b ~ A~, and so M ~ - , / / | M, M ~-, A~ | M yield isomorphic functors, giving the same map on K-groups. Hence M ~ My induces 0 on K-groups. P r o p o s i t i o n (5.26). Let X be a scheme of finite type over a field k. Then the image of the differential dl "
H
K,(k(x))
a:EXp -t
' H Ko(k(x)) ~- H Z xEXP
x6.XP
in the spectral sequence of Theorem (5.20), consists precisely of the group of codimension p cycles rationally equivalent to 0 (in the sense of Fulton's book Intersection Theory). Hence E~ '-p ~ CHP(X), the Chow group of codimension p cycles modulo rational equivalence. C o r o l l a r y (5.27) (Bloch's formula). Let X be a regular scheme of finite type over a field k. Then there are natural isomorphisms HP(X, ICp,X) "~ CHP(X),
p>0
where lCv,x is the sheaf associated to the presheaf (for the Zariski topology) U ~ Kp(U). We have a flasque resolution xEX 1
xEX o
'""
H
xEXP
(izl.KoCk(x))
,0
and isomorphisms E~ 'q ~= H P ( X , ~ _ q , X ) for the terms of the spectral sequence (5.20). P r o o f of C o r o l l a r y (5.27). have isomorphisms
By Theorem (5.24)and Prop. (5.22), we
J~'q ~ H p ( X , ~ - q , X ),
and from the proof of (5.22) we have a flasque resolution as above for ~p,x. But Gp(U) "~ Kp(U) for every open set U C X, since X is regular; hence Gp,x ~/Cp,x. The formula for CHP(X) now follows from Prop. (5.26).
72
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o o f o f (5.26). For any y e X p-1 and x e X p such t h a t x E {y}, we have a natural map ordx~ : k(y)* , Z, defined as follows: let Y = {y} with the reduced structure, and let R = Ox,y. T h e n R is a 1-dimensional Noetherian local domain with quotient a field k(y). Given a E k(y)*, choose a, b E R - {0} with ~ - a, and define ordxu(~x) = e(R/aR) - e(R/bR),
e = length.
One sees (cf. Fulton, Intersection Theory, Appendix A) t h a t this gives a well-defined homomorphism ordxu with integer values. Combining the maps ordxu for all x, y we obtain a m a p
H
ord"
k(y)"
' H
yEXp-1
Z.
xEXp
By definition, the cokernel of 'ord' is the Chow group CHP(X) of codimension p cycles modulo rational equivalence. Hence, we need to show t h a t 'ord' and dl have the same image. Let (dl)xy " k(y)* , Z be the (xy)-component of the differential dl, for each y E X p - l , x E X p. Fix y E X p - 1 , and let Y = {y}. T h e closed immersion Y , X gives an exact functor Azs ~ A4(X), such t h a t ~ i ~ ( Y ) c fl4P-I+~(X) for all i. Hence we have a map of spectral sequences
(5.20)
Eir'i(Y)
, Er
1J+'-P(X),
which increases the filtration degree by p diagram
1; in particular we have a
E~-"-P(X)
,
E~' ' - p ( X ) ~
~
'
E1
T
0,--1
gl(k(vl) = El
(Y)
T
1,--1
(Y)
I.Ixex,, Z
]
ILo,, z
Thus (dl)~u = 0 unless x e Y. Next, if we fix x0 E Y, and let R - Oxo,y, then the fiat map Spec R --, Y induces a contravariant map of spectral sequences, yielding a diagram
Kl(k(y)) ~- E~
--I
Kl(k(y)) ~- E~
d,
I
d,
E~'-'(y) ~
I
H Z xEY 1
TM
E~,-I(R)_
where P0 is projection onto the s u m m a n d corresponding to x0. Hence we are reduced to proving:
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
73
( 5 . 2 8 ) . Let R be an equicharacteristic Noetherian local domain of dimension 1 with quotient field F and residue field k, and let
Lemma
---, GI(R) --~ g l ( f )
o Ko(k)
~ Go(R)
be the localization sequence associated to the closed immersion Spec k Spec R. Then O: g l ( F ) ~ Ko(k) is isomorphic to o r d : F* L , Z (i.e., there are functorial isomorphisms K I ( F ) ~ F*, Ko(k) ~- Z under which c0 corresponds to ord). P r o o f . By T h e o r e m (5.1), there is a functorial isomorphism
F* ~ ~1 (BGL(F) +) '~ K1 (F), while by T h e o r e m (4.0), there is a functorial isomorphism
Ko(k) ~- g. W i t h respect to these isomorphisms, we show a = i o r d up to a universal choice of signs. We have an isomorphism
R* "~ lrl (BGL(R) +) "~ K1 (R) such t h a t
K,(R) R*
commutes.
K,(F)
~.
l
~
F*
K1 (F) factors through GI(R), we see t h a t
Since K I ( R ) ~
o ( x ) = 0 for x e R" c F * ; ~1~o o r d ( ~ )
= e(R/~:R)
= 0. So it ~ u m ~
to
show O(x) = + o r d ( x ) for all x e R - (R* U {0}), for a universal choice of the sign; we fix such an x. Let ko be the prime field; then there is a homomorphism ko[t] --~ R mapping t to x, where ko[t] is the polynomial ring. Since x -r 0 and x is a non-unit, this is flat. By the naturality of the localization sequence for fiat maps, we have a diagram
,
K,(ko[t])
1
-.
G,(R)
K,(ko[t,~_,])
--~
----*
KI(F)
o ~
Ko(ko)
o,
Ko(k)
--~
and a diagram
K, (ko[t, t-'l) g,(FI
lrl(BGL(ko[t,t-l]) +) ~ ko[t,t-l] *
~1 (BGL(F)*) ~ F*
,
74
Algebraic K-Theory
such that u(t) = x. The map v is induced by the functor sending a k0-vector space V to the R-module of finite length ( R / x R ) | V, and using d~vissage to identify the K-groups of the categories of finite torsion R-modules and of finite dimensional k-vector spaces. Hence under the identifications Ko(ko) - Z, Ko(k) = Z, v is just multiplication by ~ ( R / x R ) = ord(x). Hence it suffices to prove that O(t) - 4-1 in the top row. But from Cor. (5.5) (ii), g l (k0[t, t - l ] ) -~ g l (k0[t]) (9 Ko(ko) with the latter summand being identified with ker(Kl(k0[$,t-1]) ---* Ki(k0)),
t ~ 1:
Under Kl(ko[t,t-1]) ~- ko[t,t-1] *, the summand K0(k0) is thus the cyclic subgroup generated by t, i.e., O(t) is a generator of Ko(ko) -- Z. Hence O(t) -- +1. To check that the sign is universal, we compare with the localization sequence for Z[t] ~-, Z[t,t -1] (which is possible because k0[t] has finite Tor-dimension over Z[t]).
Projective B u n d l e s a n d S e v e r i - B r a u e r S c h e m e s . Let S be an arbitrary scheme, s a vector bundle on S (i.e., locally free Os-module) of rank r, and X = P(~) - Proj(S(s where S(s is the symmetric algebra of s over Os (see (D.58), (D.59)). Let O x ( 1 ) be the canonically defined line bundle on X. We had earlier computed G.(F(E)); our present goal is to prove: T h e o r e m (5.29). If S is quasi-compact, then one has isomorphisms
g (s) for all q > O, given by
r-1 (ai)o~i
f*ai'
where z E Ko(X) is the class of O x ( - 1 ) , and f " X morphism. Equivalently,
Kq(X) Ko(X)|
Kq(S),
S is the structure
aU q >_O.
In the following discussion, let "Ox-module" stand for "quasi-coherent Ox-module", and similarly interpret "Os-module".
Lemma (5.30). a) For any Ox-module J~, Rq f.cF is an Os-module, and isOif q>r.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
75
b) For any Ox-module jz and any vector bundle C' on S, we have isomorphisms
(Rq f . Yz) |
~' "~ Rq f . ( y: |
f*g'), for all q > O.
c) For any Os-module Af we have
n~ y.(Ox(~) |
f*~f)
0,
=
Sn(E) | S-"-r(s
if q ~ 0, r -
Af, A r *| s |
1
if q = o
iV', if q = r - 1
(where 9 denotes the dual vector bundle, and we define SIn(C) = 0 for
m<0).
d) If yz is an Ox-module of finite type, and S is al]ine, then yc is a quotient of O x ( - n ) Sk for some n, k > 0 (~" is of finite type if it is locally finitely generated). P r o o f . These are all standard facts about projective bundles. Clearly a), b), c) are local on the base, so we may assume S - SpecA, and E, s ~ are trivial bundles. T h e n R q f . ~ is the Os-module associated to the A-module Hq(x,.T'), since the cohomology of ~- on X can be computed using the (~ech complex corresponding to the standard affine open cover of IF~-1 (see the proof of (D.63)), and the formation of this (~ech complex commutes with localization on S = Spec A (i.e., the (~ech complex for ~r on X ! = X • s Spec A I is obtained from the (~ech complex for 5r on X by tensoring with AI). This proves a), and b) follows since E7 is trivial. To prove c), we note t h a t if ~" = Ox(n), the terms of the (~ech complex are fiat A-modules; hence if Af is the Os-module associated to the A-module N, then
H q ( X , O x ( n ) ~ f*JV') ~ Hq(X, O x ( n ) ) |
N.
To prove d), since S = Spec A is affine, E is associated to a finitely generated projective A-module, so t h a t there is a surjection O~sr --~ s giving an embedding X c IP~- 1 which satisfies Op..-, (1)Ix "~ O x (1) Hence we are reduced to the case X = IP~-1 = IP~-1. If {Ui}0
0. For example, O x ( n ) | f * Af is regular for n >_ 0, and any O s - m o d u l e Af.
76
Algebraic K-Theory
The idea of the proof of (5.29) is to show that any regular vector bundle on X has a canonical resolution by twisted pullbacks of vector bundles on S. L e m m a (5.31). Let 0 of Ox-modules.
~ if:'
" 3z ~
J:"
~ 0 be an exact sequence
a) If :7:'(n) and 3:"(n) are regular, then so is 3Z(n). b) If 3Z(n) and ~r'(n + 1) are regular, then so is ~ " ( n ) . c) If 3:(n + 1) and 3z"(n) are regular, and if f . ~ r ( n ) - - ~ f . 3 : " ( n ) , then 3z'(n + 1) is regular. P r o o f . Immediate from the definition of regularity and the long exact sequence of higher direct images. L e m m a (5.32). If jr is regular, JZ(n) is regular for n > O. P r o o f . It suffices to prove that ~-(1) is regular, by induction. We have the Koszul exact sequence of vector bundles on X T
0
; Ox(-r) | Af*s
~""
-+ O x ( - 1 ) | f * s
,
Ox
,
O.
Tensoring with ~" we obtain the exact sequence r
(.)
0
, ~ ' ( - r ) | A f*E - , - . . - . ~ ' ( - 1 ) | f * e
, Jr
9 0---.
Since j r is regular, Lemma (5.30)(b) (projection formula) yields P
P
so that ~ @ A p f * c -~ ( ~ ( - p ) @/~P f*~)(p) is regular. Splitting (.) into short exact sequences P
0
,z _a
,o,
(with Z~ = O, Zo = ~') we see, by descending induction on p and Lemma (5.31)(b), that Zp(p + 1) is regular for each p > O. In particular Zo(1) = ~(1) is regular. L e m m a (5.33). I f 3 z is regular, the natural map f * f . Y
; ~" is onto.
P r o o f . From the proof of (5.32) above, we have an exact sequence 0
; Z1 ~
~'(-1)
|
f*~"
' ~ " ----4 0
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
77
where Z1(2) is regular; hence Zl(n) is regular for all n > 2, and R l f . Z x ( n ) = 0 for all n > 1. Hence we have exact sequences
0
,A
(n-1)|
, y.y(n)
,o,
n > l.
Thus the natural map of graded S(E)-modules
f , jr |
S(F.)
~.( ~ f , Jr(n) n>_O
is onto. The lemma follows by taking the associated sheaves on lP(E) (in fact, the lemma would follow from the weaker statement that the above map of graded S(E)-modules is a surjection in sufficiently large degrees). L e m m a (5.34). Any regular Ox-module Y: has a resolution
; O x ( 1 - r) | f*Zr-l(.~) , f*To(5r) , jF ,0
-'-*''"
~
O x ( - 1 ) | f*Zl(ff~)
where Ti(.~') are Os-modules determined up to isomorphism by .~'. Further, ; Ti(~r) is an exact functor from the category of regular Ox-modules to the category of O s-modules. P r o o f . We first prove uniqueness. Given a resolution as in the lemma, since ~ is regular, the sequence obtained by twisting by O x ( n ) ,
0
~.O x ( n + l - r ) ~ f * T r _ l ( f f ~) ---~...--~ Ox(n)@f*To(J] ~)
, ff~(n)
,0
consists of O x - m o d u l e s which are acyclic for R i f , , i > 1, provided n >_ O. Applying f , thus yields exact sequences 0
~" s n + l - r ( ~ )
~ T r - l ( ~ ) --* --" --* Sn(s | T0(~)
; f , JcCn)
;0
(as before we use the convention Sn(E) = 0 for n < 0). In particular, for 0 < n < r we have 0
' Tn(ff~')
~" ~ @ O s
Tn-l(~')
"'r
" " " -'r
f.~'(n)
~ O.
This shows t h a t Tn (Jr) is uniquely determined, by induction, up to isomorphism. This also tells us how to define Tn(Jz). We define inductively a sequence Zn = Zn(2F) of Ox-modules, and Tn = Tn(Jc) a sequence of Osmodules, by taking =
T. = y.(Z._l(n)),
and letting Zn = ker(Ox ( - n ) | f ' T n ' Zn- 1). Clearly Zn, Tn are additive functors. We will prove, by induction on n, that Zn(n + 1) is regular, this being given when n = - 1 since ~ is regular.
78
Algebraic K-Theory If Zn-1 (n) is regular, then by (5.33)
f*Tn = f * ( f . Z n - l ( n ) )
, Zn-~(n),
and by definition the kernel of this m a p is Zn (n). T h u s we have an exact sequence
0
(*)n
' Zn(n)
; f*Tn
; Zn-l(n)
; 0 ....
By (5.31)c) and (5.32), Zn(n + 1) is regular, giving the inductive step; the sequences O x ( - n ) | (*)n splice t o g e t h e r to give the resolution in the s t a t e m e n t of the lemma (modulo the injectivity of the first m a p on the left). We also obtain
f . Z n ( n ) = 0 for all n > O,since f . f * T n = Tn = f . Z n - l ( n ) . F r o m the sequence Ox(1)| we see t h a t if Zn-1 and Tn are already known to be exact functors on the category of regular O x - m o d u l e s , t h e n so is Zn(n + 1) (and hence also Zn); since f . is exact on the category of regular O x - m o d u l e s , Tn+l = f . Z n ( n + 1) is also an exact functor. Lastly, we show Z r - 1 = 0. F r o m O x ( n ) | ( . ) , + q we have exact sequences
Rq-l f.Zn+q-l(n)
' Rq f.z,.,+q(n)
, Rq f . O x ( - q ) | f*Tn+q.
from f.Z,.,(n) = O, these sequences inductively show t h a t Rqf.Zn+q(n) = 0 for all q,n > O. T h u s R q f . Z r _ l ( r - 1 - q) = 0 for all q > 0 (this is a special case of the previous s t a t e m e n t if r - 1 - q = n _> 0, but is trivial if r - 1 - q < 0, i.e., if q > r - 1). This means precisely t h a t Z r _ l ( r - 1 ) is regular. But f . Z r - l ( r - 1 ) = 0, so by (5.33), Z r - l ( r - 1) = 0, i.e., Z r - 1 = 0. Starting
Assume that S is quasi-compact. Then for any vector bundle jr on X , there exists an integer no such that for all Os-modules Af and n >_ no, we have
Lemma
(5.35).
(a) nqf.(JZ(n) | f*Af) = 0 for all q > O. (b) f . (.T'Cn) | f*JV') ~ (f,.T'Cn)) |
(r
jV"
,, v , a o , - b ,ndt, on S.
P r o o L B y quasi-compactness, the existence of no is local on the base S, so we m a y assume S is affine. Then by (5.30)(d), ~ is a quotient of a vector bundle s -- O x ( - m ) r for some m, k > 0, and we have an exact sequence of vector bundles 0 ,~'---*s -~" ' , 0 .
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes Further, (5.30) implies the lemma for s 0
,
|
79
Since
|
,
,0
is exact, we have a sequence
Rq f,(L(n)
@ f*.N')
Hence (a) follows
; Rq f,(.T'(n)
by descending
| I*N')
,
induction
Rq+I f,(.T"(n)
on q, being
| f*.N').
trivially
valid
for
q > r (note t h a t 9r' also satisfies the hypothesis of the lemma). Using (a), if n > no, we have a d i a g r a m with exact rows (for any O s - m o d u l e A/') (f..T" (n)) | .Af
0 --, f . ( ~ ' ( n ) | f*AO
v
(f.E(n)) |
,
f.(s
~
@ f*AO
-*
(f..~'(n)) | .Af
~
0
/.(Jr(n) | f*JV') --* O.
Hence u is onto; a similar argument applied to ~ t shows t h a t u t is onto, so t h a t u is an isomorphism. Again, the same argument applied to 9~' shows u' is an isomorphism. T h u s ker v = Tar ~ ( f . i F ( n ) , N ' ) = O, for any Af, i.e., f.ffZ(n) is a flat O s - m o d u l e . Since it is a quotient of f . E ( n ) , it is of finite type; applying a similar argument to ~ , we see t h a t f . ~ ( n ) is finitely presented. Since a finitely presented flat module over a ring is projective, f.ff:(n) is a vector bundle. L e m m a ( 5 . 3 6 ) . / f ~- is a vector bundle on X with R q f . J : ( n ) = 0 for all q > O, n > O, then f . J r ( n ) is a vector bundle on S f o r all n >_ O. P r o o f . Since the assertion is local on S, we may assume S is affine; now by (5.35)c) the result holds if n > no. Applying the functor 7-lOmox ( - , 3~(n)) to the Koszul exact sequence in the proof of (5.32) yields an exact sequence , .T'(n)
0
----, .T'(n 4- 1) C~ f ' C * |
~, .T'(n + 2) --+ ... --, ~'(n + r) ~ A f*~*
.~0.
For n > 0 all of these sheaves are acyclic for R q f . , q > O; hence on applying f , we have an exact sequence r
0 --, f..T'Cn) --4 (f.JrCn + 1)) |
E* - , . - .
--, (f.:FCn + r)) |
A E* --, O.
Hence by descending induction on n, f . ~ : ( n ) is a vector bundle on S for n>0. m
L e m m a ( 5 . 3 7 ) . /jr ~" is a regular vector bundle on X , then Ti(J:), 0 < i < r are vector bundles on S.
80
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o o f . As in the proof of uniqueness in (5.34) we have sequences o ----, T ,
, C|
T,_~ --,...
--, y , J r ( n ) ~
O,
0 <_ n < r.
Hence the result follows from (5.36), by induction on n. Recall t h a t P ( X ) denotes the category of vector bundles on X , and K q ( X ) = Kq(7)(X)) by definition. Let 7~n C 79(X) be the full subcategory consisting of bundles ~" satisfying R~f..T(k) = 0 V i > 0 and for all k > n. Let T~n C 79(X) denote the full subcategory of bundles ~ such t h a t j r ( n ) is regular. Both :Pn, 7~n are closed under extensions in T~(X), and so are exact categories; we have inclusions :Pn-1 C :Pn, T~n-1 C 7~n and 7~n C Pn and further tAT~n = lim 79n = 7~(X) = tAT~ = lim 7Zn. ---4
----r
( 5 . 3 8 ) . For all n, the inclusions 7Zn C 7),, C T'(X) induce iso-
Lemma
morphisms Kq(T~n) "~ Kq(Tan) ~- K q ( P ( X ) ) = K q ( X ) . P r o o f . For any vector bundle ~', we have an exact sequence, which is functorial in jc,
o
, .r
, ~-(i) | I'E* - , . . .
~ .r(,-) | I* ] ~ E"
, o.
For each p > 0, Y ~-~ ~'(p) | f* Av E* gives exact functors Cp : ~)n "---~ P n - - i ,
~)p : T~n 9 ; T ~ n - 1 .
If i : ~Pn-1 - - ' ~Pn is the inclusion, then we have an exact sequence of functors (id = identity) 79n ~ 7~n, 0
*ida, --~ior
,ior
and an exact sequence of functors T~n_1 0 ----* idr=_l ---+ r
o i
~-'"
'ioCr---*0,
* 79n- 1, , . . . ---+ C r o i
Thus i. " Kq(79n_l) , Kq(P,.,) and ~-~p>0(-1)p-l(r Kq (Pn_ 1) are inverse maps. Similarly, if j : T~n-1 ~- T~n is the inclusion, then
j . : gq(nn-1) and
:~(-1)~-~(r
.K~(n.)
*0.
" Kq(Pn)
'
". gq(n,.,)
: K~(n._i)
p>O are inverse maps. T h u s Kq('Pn) ~- lim Kq('Pn) "~ Kq('P(X)) = K q ( X ) , and similarly
K q ( n . ) ~ aim K~(nn) ~ K~(~'(X)) = Kq(X).
5. The KoTheory of Rings and Schemes
81
P r o o f o f ( 5 . 2 9 ) . Let un " K q ( S ) ' Kq(PO) ~- K q ( X ) be the homomorphism induced by the exact functor Af H O x ( - n ) | where 0 < n < r (these inequalities ensure t h a t the functor has values in Po, by (5.30)). Let
u" Kq (S) $r
; Kq (X) be given by r--1
9
n---0
T h e n Theorem (5.29) states precisely t h a t u is an isomorphism. If 9r E P0, then f.:F(n) is a vector bundle on S for any n > 0, and R~f.Y:(n) = 0 V i > 0, by (5.36). Hence we have maps vn " Kq(7~o) Kq(S), induced by Y ~-* f.:F(n), for each n ___0. The composite vn o u m 9 Kq(S) ---, Kq(S) is induced by the functor
.hf ~-~ ( f . O x ( n - m)) | Af { = 0 =Af
if m > n i f m = n.
Thus if v = ( v o , . . . , V r _ l ) ' K q ( 7 9 o ) , Kq(S) ~ , then v o u is described by a triangular m a t r i x with all diagonal entries equal to 1; hence v o u is invertible, and so u is injective. On the other hand, by (5.34) and (5.37) we have exact functors 71, 9 T~ ----4 79(S), for 0 < n < r, which induce maps t , 9 K q ( 7 ~ ) ". Kq(S). Let t = (..., ( - 1 ) ~ t , , . . . ) " K q ( X ) ~. Kq(S) ~ . The exact sequence
0
, O x (1 - r) | f * T r - 1 --*"" --* f ' T o ~
~"
;0
can be interpreted as an exact sequence of functors T~ --~ P0, so t h a t u o t . Kq(RO) } Kq(79o) equals the isomorphism induced by the inclusion T~ C 790. Hence u is surjective. II~1 o v e r a R i n g . Let A be a not necessarily commutative ring, t a (commuting) indeterminate and let i + : A[t]
, Air, t - ' l ,
i _ : A[t-1]
, Air, t - ' ]
be the natural inclusions of the polynomial ring in the Laurent polynomials. We define ~A(IP~) to be the Abelian category of triples M = (M+, M_,O) where M+ is a left A[t]-module, M_ a left A[t-']-module, and 0 : i ; M+ --. i*_ M_ is an isomorphism of A[t, t-1]-modules. Similarly define P ( P ~ ) to be the full subcategory of j~4(IP~) consisting of triples M with M+ e P(A[t]), M_ e P(A[t-']).
Theorem (5.39). Let hn " 7~(A) P
(Air] |
; ~(P1A) be given by
P, Air
|
P, 0.)
82
Algebraic K-Theory
where On = multiplication by t" on A[t, t -1] | phisms gq(A) .2
P. Then we have isomor-
~-, Kq(V(IPIA)), (x, y) H (ho).X + ( h , ) . y ,
and we have the relations ( h , _ l ) . - 2 ( h , ) . + ( h n + l ) . = 0 for all n.
P r o o f . For any M = (M+, M _ , 0) define M ( n ) = (M+, M _ , t-nO), V n.
T h u s hn is induced by P ----. h o ( P ) ( - n ) . For any triple M = (M+, M _ , 0) define X0, X1 e Hom(M, M (1)) by XolM+ = 1 =
XolM_ =t
t, x, IM_ =
t
t
(here 't' denotes multiplication by t). Then one checks easily that there is an exact sequence, functorial in M, 0
$2
,M(m)~M(m+l)
~,M(m+2)~O
where ~ = (Xo, X1) and 13(x,y) = X l x - Xoy. In particular taking m - 1 - n and M = ho(P), P e TO(A), we have an exact sequence of functors V(A)
,
0
} hn+l ~
h~n2 ---"* hn-1 -
}0
giving the relation (hn-1). - 2(hn). + (hn+l). = O. Next, for any triple M = ( M + , M _ , O ) , we define f . M , RI f . M A4(A) to be the cohomology modules of the 2-term complex 0
.~ M+ ~ M _
~.~ i*_ M _
E
-. 0,
where r y) = 0(1 | x ) - 1 | y. We now define a triple M to be regular if R l f . M ( - 1 ) = O. With this definition, one can check t h a t the various steps in the proof of (5.29) go through in the given situation also. T h e details are left to the reader. S e v e r i - B r a u e r S c h e m e s . Let S be a scheme, and let X be a SeveriBrauer scheme over S of relative dimension r - 1. By definition X is locally isomorphic to IP~-1 as an S-scheme, in the ~tale topology on S, i.e., for some faithfully flat ~tale morphism S' ~ S, if X ' = X x s S ', t h e n X ' ~ IP~, 1 as S'-schemes. Let f 9X , S be the structure map. If there exists a line bundle s E P i c X which restricts to O ( - 1 ) on each geometric fiber, then X = IP(C), where C = f . s In general, s will exist only ~tale locally on S. However, there is a canonically defined vector
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
83
bundle ff of rank r on X , which restricts to O ( - 1 ) r on each geometric fiber of f. T h e idea is as follows (compare (D.70)). Let Y = IP~-,, and let GLr,s act on O sr in the usual way. T h e n the induced action on Y = IP(OsS t ) factors through the quotient group scheme G = PGLr, s = GLr, s / G m , s . Since Gm,s acts trivially on O y ( - 1) | f * f . O y ( 1 ) ~- O y ( - 1 ) Cr, G acts on this vector bundle, compatibly with its action on Y. Since X / S is 4tale locally on S isomorphic to Y / S , and G is the group scheme of automorphisms of Y / S , we know t h a t X = Y x c T, where T is a torsor (principal G-bundle) for G over S which is 4tale locally trivial, and Y x G T is the associated fiber space over S with fiber Y (i.e., X = (Y x T ) / G where G acts by g(y, t) = (gy, gt)). At any rate, by descent theory, O y ( - 1) | f* f . O y (1) descends to a vector bundle ff of rank r on X. The construction of , f is compatible with base change; further, ff = O x ( - 1 ) | f*E if X = ]P(E) for a vector bundle E on S. In general, there is a faithfully fiat 4tale morphism g" S' ~ S giving a Cartesian square
X'
S'
g' '~
X
,
S
g
such t h a t X ' "~ = P~71 , and further g'*ff ~ O x , ( - 1 ) | f'* f~Ox,(1). Let .A be the sheaf of non-commutative Os-algebras
.,4 = f . End o x ("7)op (where the superscript "op" denotes the opposite algebra). g* f . =" I- ,. g ,. 9 Hence
As g is flat,
g*~4~ ~ ft. Endox , ( O x , ( - 1 ) | f*.f, Ox,(1)) "- f :'.M (Ox )= where M r denotes the algebra of r x r matrices. Hence j t is an A z u m a y a algebra of rank r 2. Further, the natural map
y*.a = l * Y.
__, end(Y)oo
is an isomorphism, as is easily seen by applying g'* (note t h a t g' is also a faithfully fiat 6tale map). Conversely, if ,4 is an Azumaya algebra over S of degree r, so t h a t the underlying sheaf of O x - m o d u l e s of ~4 is locally free of rank r 2, let f :X ~ S be the scheme over S parametrizing locally free quotient O smodules of rank r of ,4, whose kernels are right ideals of J[, so t h a t X is a closed subscheme of the Grassmannian of locally free quotients of rank r of Jr. T h e n X is a Severi-Brauer scheme, and the vector bundle ff on
84
Algebraic K-Theory
X is identified with the dual of the restriction of the universal quotient bundle on the Grassmannian. These facts are checked by passing to S', where g" S' ~ S is faithfully flat and &ale, and g*,4 ~ .A4r(OS,). Let fin = fl| An = A | so that J n is a vector bundle of rank r n on X, and An is an Azumaya algebra on S of rank(m) 2. Then .An f . ~ n d o x (fin) ~ and f*3", ~- s (fin) ~ (as can be verified by pulling back to X ' ~ P~s-;1). Let 79(.An) be the exact category of vector bundles on S which are left .A,-modules. Since J , is a right f*(.4,)-module, which is locally (on X) a direct summand of f * ( A , ) , we have an exact functor
Cn "79(.An)
, "P(X),
M ~-, ..Tn |
f* (M) .
Define K , ( A n ) = K,(79(An)). T h e o r e m (5.40). If S is quasi-compact, we have isomorphisms r--1
r--1
IIK,(A.)
K , ( X ) , (xn)o<,
n=0
n=0
P r o o f (Sketch). This is again just a modification of the proof of (5.29). Fix g 9 S' ~ S, a faithfully flat &ale morphism such that X ' - X • s S' IP~-I and let g " X ' ~X f " X ' ~ S' be the resulting maps We define an Ox-module Jr to be regular if g ' * ~ is regular on X ' . For regular ~', define inductively 9
'
~
Z _ I ( ~ ) = :7:, Tn(]:) = f . TlOmox (Jn, Zn-,(.7:)), and
Zn(.T') = ker(ffn | f*Tn(.T')
' Zn-I(.T')) (where if0 = O x ) .
Then we obtain a resolution (~)
0
--* "'" ~ f*To(.T')
' Jr-1 |
, .T" ,
0...
where Tn (~-) has the natural left A~-module structure; this resolution pulls back to that of (5.34) on X ' for g'*~. Similarly, the canonical epimorphism ,.7" --~ O x gives rise to a Koszul complex T
o
,AJ---,...-,y
,Ox
,o
which pulls back to the Koszul resolution on X ' used in (5.32), (5.36), (5.38). In particular, the analogue of (5.38) is valid: let T~n (X) C 79, (X) C P ( X ) be the full subcategories of bundles ~" such that g'*~" lies in the corresponding subcategory of P ( X ' ) ; then
K , ( T ~ ( X ) ) ~- K,(T'n)) ~ K,(79(X)) = K { ( X ) .
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
85
Now let un : K~(.An) , K~(X) be given by un = ( r where C n ( M ) = fin | Let u 9 IJ0
N ~ f . 7"lom(flm, J ~ | B u t we c o m p u t e t h a t
7"lOmox(ffm, ffn |
N) = ?'lOmox(ffm, ffn ) |
f~ N
{ =bO yf , aN p pi f m l =
(. . ., ( - ) " t , , .
. .) : K , ( X )
;
II
K,(A.),
O
then the resolution (a) obtained above shows t h a t u o t is the isomorphism K i (T~) , Ki (7)0) induced by T~ C P0. Hence u is surjective. There is a different technique for proving lemma (5.34), which is perhaps longer t h a n t h a t given earlier, but yields an explicit description of the functors Ti. This point of view is closely related to the following paper of A. A. Beilinson: "Coherent sheaves on pn and problems of linear algebra", J. Funct. Anal. Appl. 12 (1978), pp. 214-215. T h e idea is t h a t on X = P(s we have an exact sequence of locally free O x - m o d u l e s 0 --~ S ~ f * e - - 4 0 x ( 1 ) --~ 0 and a dual exact sequence 0 --~ O N ( - 1 ) ---* f*~* --* S* ~ O. Hence if pi " X Xs X -4 X , i = 1, 2 are the projections, then one has a surjection
P~f*s | P2J c
--, p l O x ( 1 ) | p2 8 .
Now if q : X • s X -~ S is the structure morphism, then there is a n a t u r a l isomorphism
q* End(E) "~ = pl*f* E | p2*fiE* , and the identity endomorphism of E yields a global section E F(X •
X,p~Ox(1)@p~S*).
86
Algebraic K-Theory
We claim that the scheme of zeroes of ~ is the diagonal A x C X x s X. This is easily proved locally on S using homogeneous coordinates, for example. Or else, it can be deduced from the universal property of a projective bundle (for any S-scheme g 9T --* S, there is a bijection between S-morphisms T --* ]P(s and isomorphism classes of invertible quotient sheaves of g'C). We leave the details to the reader. Granting this, we deduce that the structure sheaf of the diagonal has a resolution by a Koszul complex i
9. . - - , A ( P ; O x ( - 1 ) |
p~S) - - , . . . p ~ O x ( - 1 ) |
p~S ---, O X x s X --' O a x ~ O.
Further, if Lr is the ideal sheaf of the diagonal, then Z / Z 2 ~ (p~ O x ( - 1) | p~S) | O a x
(this is a general property of ideals resolved by a Koszul complex). But Z / Z 2 ~ f~lx/s, so that S ~ f~c/s(1), and our Koszul complex assumes the form *' (i)--,.-. "'" ~ Pl9 O x ( - i ) | p2f~x/s 9
9
---' p l O x ( - 1 )
1
| P2f~X/S(1) ~ O X x s X ~ O A x ---~O.
Now (5.34) follows from: P r o p o s i t i o n (5.41) Let f " X --, S be as above, Y= an O x - m o d u l e . (a) There is a convergent spectral sequence of O x - m o d u l e s (the Beilinson spectral sequence), concentrated in the range p < O, q > O,
with E~q --
(b)
f 0 I. .1"
if (p, q) # (o, o) if (p, q) = (o, o).
Suppose R' f . (f~Jx/s(J) | :7=) = 0 for aU i > O, j > O. Then there is resolution of ~ given by the E1 terms along the line q = 0
a
9..--+ O x ( - i ) 0 f*Ti(.7~) --*"" --* f*To(fl:) ~ if" ~ O, where
~,(~=) =
~:).
s. (a.~/s(O |
(~) %
i > O,j > O, and Ti is an exact functor on the category of regular O x - m o d u l e s for each i > O.
5. The K-Theory of Rings and Schemes
87
P r o o f . (Sketch) We have a canonical identification p~.(O~ x | =~ jc, and R i p l . ( ( 9 ~ x | ~ ) = 0 for i > 0. On the other hand, the resolution of the diagonal yields a resolution on X x s X
9 .. -~
.~o~(-~) |
(~'x/s(~) |
9.. --* , ~ O x ( - 1 )
| p~
~) -~'"
(a~/s(1) | Y) -* p~-
(O,,x
| p.~.T')
O.
Hence there is a spectral sequence for the hyperderived functors of f . , concentrated in degrees - r <_ p _< 0, r > q >_ 0 (i.e., set p = - i in the resolution)
E~ 'q = R q p l . ( p ; O x ( p ) | p~(gtxP/s(-p) | ~ ) )
=~ RP+qpl. ( O a x | p ~ )
.
Now Pl " X x s X --, X is itself a projective bundle, associated to f ' E , so t h a t by (5.30)(b), we may rewrite the E l terms as
E~ ,q
= Ox(-p)| n~p,.p~ (nx%(-p)|
~).
Further, since f is fiat, we have a canonical isomorphism
This gives the expression for the E1 terms in the proposition. The vanishing condition in (b) means that E[ 'q the spectral sequence is concentrated on the line q - 0. E~om'~ : 0 for all p > 0, so that the complex E~-p'~
statement of the
0 for q > 0, and Further, E ~ p'~ is a resolution of
E~ '~ = --ooE~176 = ~'. Now we prove (c). One first proves t h a t if ~" is regular, then
nJs. ( ~ / ~ ( ~
+ ~ - J)|
.*) = o v ~ _> o, ~ > o.
This is done by descending induction on i; the case i - r is the definition of regularity, since fffx/s ~ O x ( - r - 1). By taking exterior powers of the Euler exact sequence 0 --~ f ~ / s ( 1 ) - , f * E ---, O x ( 1 ) --* 0 (which we constructed earlier, when we identified 8 with f ~ / s ( 1 ) ) , obtain exact sequences of locally free Ox-modules
we
i
--4
---,
f~XlS(Z) ---, O.
Tensoring with ~ ' ( - j ) and applying R J f , , we obtain an exact sequence of Os-modules
(
'
)
88
Algebraic K-Theory
where of ~',
RJf. ( f * ( A ' e) | ~ ( - j ) ) ~ A' F-.| and RJ+lf. (fl~/s(i) | 3 r ( - j ) ) = 0
= o by the regularity by induction.
In particular, setting i = 0, we see that 3r(1) is regular, and hence ~'(i) is regular for all/_> 0 (compare (5.32)). Hence RJf. ( f ~ / s | JZ(k)). = 0 for i >_ 0, j > 0, and k >_ i+ 1 - j . This includes the case k = i, which is what was needed. The exactness of Ti on the category of regular Ox-modules is immediate from the vanishing of Rlf.Q~/s(i) | 3~ for regular ~'. The above argument for (c) was shown to me by Donu Arapura. Resolutions for the diagonal are known, which yield computations of the K-groups, in certain other cases (Grassmannians, their twisted forms, and quadrics); this point of view is seen in papers of Kapranov, Panin and a joint paper of mine with Levine and Weyman. Panin noted that in fact for K-theoretic consequences, one only needs that the class of the diagonal in K0 has a certain form, which would be implied by the existence of an appropriate resolution of the structure sheaf of the diagonal. A recent reference putting much of this work in perspective is the following paper of Panin: A.I. Panin, On Algebraic K-Theory of Generalized Flag Fibre Bundles and Some of their Twisted Forms, in Advances in Soviet Mathematics, Vol. 4, ed. A. A. Suslin, Amer. Math. Soc. (1991).
6. P r o o f s o f t h e T h e o r e m s of C h a p t e r
4
We first prove:
There is a natural isomorphism K0(C) ~ 7rl(BQC, {0}) for any small exact category C and null object 0 E C. Theorem
(4.0).
Here, K0(C) is the quotient of the free Abelian group on the objects of C modulo the relations [M] = [M'] + [M"] for all exact sequences 0
~M'
,M
~M"
t0
in C. We begin by proving a lemma. We use the notation and terminology of Chapter 3. ( 6 . 1 . ) . The category of covering spaces of the classifying space BC of a small category C is naturally equivalent to the category of functors F : C ~. Set (where Set is the category of sets) such that F(u) is a bijection for any morphism u of C.
Lemma
ProoL
Let p - E
.~ BC be a covering space. For any object X E C, let
E ( X ) be the fiber over X E BC (where X is regarded as a 0-simplex in NC, and hence determines a 0-cell in BC). Given a morphism u : XI .~ X2, we may regard u as a 1-simplex in NC, which determines a p a t h B u in BC joining X1 to X2. Since p is a covering, it has the unique p a t h lifting property, which gives a bijection ( B u ) . : E(X1) ~ E ( X 2 ) , by associating to a point y E E ( X I ) the second end-point of the unique path in E which lifts B u and begins at y. Hence X ~ E ( X ) , u ~-. (Bu). determine a functor C .~ Set carrying all arrows of C into bijections. Conversely, if F : C ~. Set is a "morphism inverting" functor (i.e., F(u) is a bijection for each u E Mor(C)), let F \ C be the category of pairs ( X , x ) with X E ObC, x E F ( X ) , where a morphism ( X , x ) ( X ' , x ~) is a m o r p h i s m u : X .~X ~ such t h a t F(u)(x) = x'. T h e forgetful functor F \ C ~ C, (X, x) ~-~ X gives a map on classifying spaces PF :
90
Algebraic K-Theory
B ( F \ C) , BC, with fibers p F l ( X ) = F ( X ) for any object X e C. We claim t h a t PF is a covering space. If we prove this, then for any morphism u" X , X ' in C and any x e F ( X ) , if x' = F ( u ) ( x ) , then u determines a morphism ( X , x ) ~ ( X ' , x ' ) in F \ C, which gives the unique p a t h in B ( F \ C) lifting B u and beginning at x E p F I ( X ) . Thus the above two constructions are inverse to each other, and give the desired equivalence of categories. To check t h a t PF " B ( F \ C) : ; BC is a covering space, we use the criterion (A.48) of Appendix A. Thus, we m u s t show t h a t the map of simplicial sets N ( F \ C) ; NC is a simplicial covering, i.e., if A(n) is the simplicial set A(n)(p) = H o m a ( p , n ) , (so t h a t [A(n)[ = An, the s t a n d a r d n-simplex), then given any diagram of maps of simplicial sets A(O)
1
A(n)
;
----4
N ( F \ C)
1
NC
we must show t h a t there is a unique m a p A ( n ) : , N ( F \ C) (of simplicial sets) m a k i n g the diagram commute. Of course, a m a p a 9 A(n) ; NC is just an n-simplex a E NnC, so we must show t h a t if a E NnC is an n-simplex of NC, ao E No(F \ 17) a 0-simplex lying over the ith vertex of a, then there exists a unique n-simplex T E N n ( F \ C) which maps to a, such t h a t a0 is the ith vertex of T. Assume t h a t a is given by the diagram in C M0
ul ,
M1
u2
; - - - -u-. 4 Mn;
the ith vertex of cr is given by the object Mi, so t h a t a0 is given by an object (M~,xi) e F \ C, where x, e F(M~). We have bijections
F(Mo) F(u,) ; F(M1) F(u2) ~ F(M2)
; ... F(u.)~. F ( M n )
giving composite bijections f j " F ( M j ) ; F ( M i ) for each j (f~ is the identity) such t h a t f1 = f j + l o F ( u j + l ) . Let xj e F ( M j ) be the unique element satisfying f i ( x j ) = x,. Then clearly x, = f j ( x j ) = f j + l ( f ( u j + l ) ( X i ) ), so t h a t x j + l = F(uj+l)(Xj). Thus we have a d i a g r a m in F \ C, giving re Nn(F\C),
(Mo,xo) r,, , ( M l , x l ) a2 , ' "
- (Mn, xn) "",
where fii is the morphism induced by uj. One sees at once t h a t v is the unique n-simplex lifting a whose ith-vertex is ( M i, xi). This proves t h a t p F ' B ( F \ C) , BC is a covering, and finishes the proof of (6.1). Now let C be a (small) exact category. Recall t h a t if M, N E C, an arrow i 9M , N is called an admissible monomorphism if we have an
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
91
exact sequence in C (for some P E C) 0 Similarly, q : M sequence
;M
i.~N
,P
,0.
.~ N is an admissible epimorphism if t h e r e is a n e x a c t
0
;P
,M
q,N----,O
for some P E C. We write i : M ~-4 N to denote t h a t i is a n admissible m o n o m o r p h i s m , a n d q : M -~ N to denote t h a t q is an a d m i s s i b l e epimorphism. Next, we recall t h e construction of morphisms in t h e c a t e g o r y QC. A m o r p h i s m M --, N in QC is an equivalence class of d i a g r a m s M ~-- M ~ ~-, N , where M ~- M " ~ N is an equivalent diagram if a n d only if t h e r e is an isomorphism u : M ~ --, M " m a k i n g the following d i a g r a m c o m m u t e : M !
\/
N
M" C o m p o s i t i o n of m o r p h i s m s is defined as follows. Given d i a g r a m s M ~M ~ ~-, N , N ~- N ' ~-, P t h e composite morphism M --, P in QC is represented by the d i a g r a m M ~- M ~ x Iv N ~ ~-* P. We have t h e d i a g r a m (where t h e square is a pullback)
Nl
M t • jv N '
M'
~-~
~
P
N
M In particular, if i : M ~-, N , we have an associated arrow i! : M --, N in QC, given by M ~- M ~-, N , where 1M is the identity of M . Similarly, 1M
i
if q : M --~ N , we have an associated arrow qt : N --, M in QC, given by
N,--M~--, q
IM
M.
If f : M --, N is an a r b i t r a r y arrow in QC, given by t h e d i a g r a m M ~-- M ' ~-* N , t h e n in fact f = i! o qt as is i m m e d i a t e from t h e a b o v e q
i
description of composition of m o r p h i s m s in QC. We can form t h e p u s h o u t
92
Algebraic K-Theory
s q u a r e in C:
i ~-~
M t
N
it
M ~-* N' w h i c h will also be Cartesian (i.e., pullback); such a square is called bicartesian. T h e n we claim t h a t f = q a o i~ in QC, from the d i a g r a m giving t h e c o m p o s i t i o n on the right: M' ~ IN ~-~ N N
M
it ~
N p
M T h u s , t h e assigments i ~-, i,,9 q ~ q! (i) if i, i ~ are composable admissible d o m a i n i) t h e n (i oil)! = it oi~; similarly, e p i m o r p h i s m s , then (q o qt), = q,! o q~'. (ii) if i M' ~-,
q~
have t h e following properties: m o n o m o r p h i s m s (i.e., r a n g e i ~ = if q,q' are composable, admissible
N
~q'
M ~-+ N' is a b i e a r t e s i a n square, where i, i' are admissible m o n o m o r p h i s m s , q, q' are admissible epimorphisms, t h e n i! o q' - q': o i~. In fact, (i) and (ii) characterize QC, in the following sense. Lemma
( 6 . 2 ) . Let C be an exact category, I) a category. Assume that
(i) for each M e C, we are given an object F ( M ) e T), (ii) for each admissible mono i : M ' ~ M , we are given an arrow FI(i) : F(M') ~ F ( M ) , such that Fl (i o i') = Fl (i) o F1 (i') if i, i' are composable; similarly, for each admissible epi q : M --. N , we are given F2(q) : F ( N ) ~ F ( M ) , such that F2(q o q') = F2(q') o F2(q) if q, q' are composable (iii) if
i
M'
~-~
M
~-+
i'
N
N'
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
93
is a bicartesian square, then F1 (i) o F2(q) = F2(q') o F1 (i').
Then there is a well-defined functor F " QC ~ 1) given by M ~-~ F ( M ) , ( M ~-- M ' ~-, N ) H F1 (i) o F2(q). q
Proof.
If M
i
~ - M ~ ~-, N , M q
i
~- M "
~-~ N are equivalent d i a g r a m s
ql
ii
giving a m o r p h i s m M ---4 N in QC, we have an isomorphism u " M ~ M " such t h a t q - ql o u, i - i l o u. Regarding u as admissible epi, we get F~(q) = F 2 ( u ) o F2(ql), and regarding u as admissible mono, we get F1 (i) = F1 (il) o FI (u). F r o m the bicartesian square Ml
~-~
M"
M tt
we have Fl (u)oF2(u) -- F2(1M,, )oF: (1M,, ) -- 1F(M,,). Hence Fl (i)oF2(q) -F l ( i l ) o F2(ql). T h u s , Fl(i) o F2(q) d e p e n d s only on t h e arrow in QC, a n d not on t h e p a r t i c u l a r d i a g r a m which represents it. Next, if M ~- M ' ~-, N , N ~- N ~ >-4 P are given a n d M ~ql
~1
q2
is
q
M ~ x jv N ~ >-4 P represents the composite arrow in QC, we have a d i a g r a m i (where t h e s q u a r e is bicartesian) i
M I x N N'
~-~
M'
~-*
il
N'
i2
~-,
P
N
M and q = ql o q', i = i2 o i'. T h e n
F1 (i) o F2(q) = F1 (i2) o F1 (i') o F2(q') o F2(ql) = Fl(i2) o F2(q2) o El(J1) o F2(ql). T h i s proves t h a t ( M
~- M ' q
~-, N ) ~-~ F l ( i ) o F2(q) is c o m p a t i b l e w i t h i
composition in QC, and so yields a well-defined functor QC proves t h e l e m m a .
.- :O. T h i s
C o r o l l a r y ( 6 . 3 ) . For any exact category C, there is an i s o m o r p h i s m QC ~QC ~ .
94
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o o f . For any arrow f in C, let f be the corresponding arrow in C ~ T h e n if i 9M ~-, N is admissible mono, i 9N --~ M is admissible epi, and if q" M --~ N is admissible epi, q = N ~-, M is admissible mono. If i
M'
~
N
M
~-,
NI
i'
is bicartesian, then
q - I
N'
~-~
N
M
~-, q
MI
is bicartesian in C~ Thus i,9 o qt H q,. ~ o -i '! gives a functor (which is the identity on objects) QC ~ QC~ inducing a bijection Horn Qc (M, N) ---, n o m Qco, (M, g ) . This is the desired isomorphism. P r o o f o f (4.0). Let C be an exact category, 0 E C a null object. T h e category of covering spaces of B Q.C is equivalent to the category 3c of functors F ' Q C " Set such t h a t F(u) is a bijection for every arrow u of QC. Let ~ ' C ~ be the full subcategory consisting of functors F 9QC Set w i t h F ( M ) = F(O), F(i!) = 1F(0) for any admissible mono i " M ' ~-, M in C. If F E 5r is an a r b i t r a r y functor, let F E ~ ' be the functor given by /~(M) = F ( 0 ) , and if M q~- M ' ~-, ~ N represents an arrow u " M --, N in QC, let F ( u ) = F(iM,,.) -1 o f ( q !) o F(iM~) (where for any M e C, we have iM " 0 ~ M, qM " M ;~ 0). Clearly M H F(iM!) gives a n a t u r a l transformation F --, F which is an isomorphism of functors, since F(iMI) is an isomorphism in the category Set. Thus every object of ~" is isomorphic to an object of ~c,, so t h a t ~ is equivalent to ~ ' . It suffices to show t h a t ~ ' is equivalent to the category of Ko(C)sets (a K0(C)-set is a set on which Ko(C) acts t h r o u g h permutations). Indeed, by (6.1) and C h a p t e r 3, Ex. (3.10), t h e category of coverings of BKo(C) (the classifying space of the group Ko(C)) is clearly equivalent to _
,
,
the category of K0(C)-sets. But BKo(C), the universal cover of BKo(C), is an initial object in the category of pointed coverings of BKo(C), and the a u t o m o r p h i s m group of BKo(C) in the category of coverings is just Ko(C), the fundamental group of BKo(C). Hence the category of pointed
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
95
coverings of B Q C also has an initial object (which m u s t be the universal cover) whose a u t o m o r p h i s m group in the category of coverings is Ko(C). If S is a K0(C)-set, r : Ko(C) ; Aut(S) the p e r m u t a t i o n representation, let Fs : QC .~ Set be the functor defined by L e m m a (6.2) and the assignments F s ( M ) = S V M E C, (Fs)l(i~) = l s , the identity map, and (Fs)2(q !) = r q]) E Aut(S). If i
M'
~-4
N
q~
~q'
M
~
Nt
il
is a bicartesian square, then ker q ~ ker q', so that r q) = r q'), and the conditions of (6.2) hold. One sees at once t h a t Fs E ~r~. Conversely, if F E jr,, let C f : Ko(C) , A u t ( F ( 0 ) ) be given by CF([M]) = F(q"M). To see t h a t this gives a well-defined h o m o m o r p h i s m on K0(d), if we have an exact sequence in d 0
~- M '
~
i
M
~
q
M"
;0
we have a bicartesian square M'
~-*
M
qMt
0
M"
M" !
so t h a t q'o iM,,, = i, o qlM, SO that F ( q ~ , ) = F(q"); also q~t = q ' o qkx,,, so that F(q~M ) = F(q"M,, ) = F ( q ~ , ) o F(q~M ,, ). In particular, by considering the split exact sequences 0 0 ~
; M'
~M ' @ M "
M " ----* M I @ M "
; M"
t0
; M'
;0
we see t h a t F(qIM , ) , F(q'M,, ' ) e Aut(F(0)) commute. Hence CF is well defined. Clearly (5, r ~-~ Fs, F ~ (F(0), e l ) give the desired equivalence of categories. This proves Theorem (4.0). Our next goal is to prove two technical results on classifying spaces of (small) categories, which are the basic homotopy theoretic tools needed to prove the remaining results of Chapter 4. We begin with a result, called "Theorem A" by Quillen, which gives a criterion for a functor f :C ; :D to be a homotopy equivalence. For any functor f 9C ; / ) , and any object Y E T~, let Y \ f be the category whose objects are pairs (X, v), X E Ob C, v: Y ; f ( X ) an arrow in T), where a morphism (X, v) ; (X', v') is a
96
Algebraic K-Theory
morphism w : X
, X'
such that the triangle below commutes:
Y
"
, f(X)
f(X') Given an arrow u : Y' , Y in :D, we have a functor u* : Y \ f - , Y' \ f given by u*(X, v) = (X, v o u). Theorem
A . If f : C ~ ~ 1) is a functor, such that Y \ f is contractible,
for each Y E T~, then f is a homotopy equivalence. If f : C ~ T~ is a functor, the fiber f - l ( y ) over Y E T~ is the subcategory of C whose objects X satisfy f ( X ) = Y , with morphisms v :X , X ' being precisely those morphisms in C such t h a t f ( v ) = l v , the identity morphism. There is a naturally defined functor f - l ( y ) ~y \ f , for any Y E D, given by X H (X, 1y). We say t h a t f makes C preJibered over 1) if for each Y e D, f - l ( y ) __, y \ f has a right adjoint. If this is t o hold, t h e n for any (Z, v) e Y \ f , we have an object v*X e f - l ( y ) (so that v*: f - l ( f ( X ) ) ; f - l ( y ) is a functor) such t h a t H o r n y \ l ( - - , (X, v)) ~ Hom f - , ( v ) ( - - , v*X). T h u s if v : Y , Y~ is any arrow in :D, we have a functorial basechange v* : f - l ( Y ' ) , f-l(r). We say t h a t f : C , Z~ makes C
fibered over :D if for Y ~, Y' ' ' ; Y " in T~, the canonically defined n a t u r a l transformation v* o v'* , (v' o v)* is an isomorphism. Thus, we have the following corollary to Theorem A (recall (3.7) t h a t a functor which has a right adjoint is a homotopy equivalence). C o r o l l a r y (6.4). Let f : C ~ • make C prefibered over l). Suppose that for each Y E ~), f - l ( y ) is contractible; then f is a homotopy equivalence. Since BC is naturally homeomorphic to BC ~ we can deduce "dual" versions of Theorem A and Corollary (6.4). For any functor f : C , 1), and any Y e :D, let f \ Y denote the category of pairs (X, v), where X e C, v: f ( X ) .~ Y a morphism in T~, where a morphism (X, v) L, ( X ' , v ' ) i s a morphism w : X ~ X ' in C such t h a t the triangle below commutes:
f(X)
y(x')
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
97
T h e o r e m A (dual version). Let f 9C ~ l) be a f u n c t o r such that f l Y is contractible f o r all Y E ~9. Then f is a homotopy equivalence. Next, f :C , :/9 is said to make C pre-cofibered over :D if the functor f - l ( y ) .___, f / y , X ~-~ (X, 1y), has a left adjoint, for every Y E :/9. This gives functorial co-base change arrows v . : f - l ( y ) ___. f - 1( y , ) associated to morphism v : Y ~ Y'. f makes C cofibered over :D if the natural transformations (u o v). .~ u. o v. are isomorphisms, for any Y u y , v y . in D. C o r o l l a r y (6.4) (dual version). Let f " C ~ 1 ) m a k e C pre-cofibered over D. Suppose f - 1 ( y ) is contractible for each Y E C. Then f is a homotopy equivalence. (Note: Below, we may refer to Theorem A, Corollary (6.4), or to their dual versions, simply as Theorem A; it will be clear from the context as to which result we mean). We need two lemmas in the proof of Theorem A. L e m m a (6.5). Let i ~-~ X i be a functor from a small category I to the category of topological spaces, and let g 9X t ~. B1 be the space over B 1 obtained by realizing the simplicial space
P~
lI
X~o
(where io ~ . . . ---, ip ranges over p-simplices in the simplicial set N I ) . I f f o r every i --, i t in I, X i ~ X e is a homotopy equivalence, then g 9X I -~ B I is a quasi-fibration. (See Chapter 3 for the definition of a simplicial space; if 19 ~-~ Xp is a simplicial space, its realization is obtained by putting the quotient topology on (H,>_0 • a , ) / ~ , where ,~ is the equivalence relation used to define the realization of the underlying simplicial set. See Appendix A, (A.29) for the definition and some properties of quasi-fibrations). ProoL
Since B I = lim Fp, where Fp c B I is the p-skeleton (the re-
alization of the simplicial subset of N I generated by the non-degenerate simplices of dimension < p), it suffices to prove that g - l ( F p ) ---, Fp is a quasi-fibration for each p > 0, by (A.35). We have a map of pushout
98
Algebraic K-Theory
squares, induced by g,
llX,o•
N~,I
I
g-l(Fp-1)
, HX,o• N~,I
,
I
g-1 (Fp)
H0
N~,I
I
F,-1
,
' II
N~,I
,
,
I
F,
where N~I C NpI is the set of non-degenerate p-simplices in N I . Let U C Fp be the open set obtained by removing the barycenters of the p-cells (indexed by N~I), and let Y = F p - Fp-1. By (A.30), it suffices to prove t h a t U, V and U N V are distinguished for g (as U U V - Fp); this is clear for V and for U N V, since g is a product over V. We may assume by induction t h a t Fp_ 1 is distinguished for g. There is a fiber-preserving deformation Dt of g - l ( u ) into g-l(Fp_l) induced by the radial deformation of Ap, with its barycenter removed, onto 0Ap. Let dt be the induced deformation of U onto Fp-1. To apply (A.34), we need only show t h a t if x e U, x ' = dz(x), then Dz 9 g - Z ( x ) ~ g-Z(x') induces an isomorphism on homotopy groups. Since dz is the identity when restricted to Fp-1, we may assume x E U N V. Suppose x lies in the interior of the simplex i0 --* il -* .-- --* ip, and suppose dl (x) lies in the interior of the q-face with vertices ijo , i j l , . . . , ijq (the interior of Aq is Aq --OAq, where OAq = 0 if q : 0). Then g - l ( x ) : Xio, and g-l(dl(x)) = g - l ( x t ) - Xk, where k - ijo. The map D1 " X~o * Xk is the one induced by the edge i0 --~ ijo of i0 --* il --* -.. --* ip. Indeed, Dt is induced by the deformation of Ap \ {b} onto 0Ap, where b E Ap is the barycenter, by first taking the product deformation of Xio • (Ap -- {b}) onto Xio • 0Ap, for each simplex in N~I. If x' lies in the interior of a q-face of 0Ap whose first vertex is k, then we identify Xio x {x'} C X~,, • 0Ap with the image of Xio in Xk, where Xio * Xk is induced by the arrow in I corresponding to the edge joining i0 to k in OAp. (The geometric realization is constructed using such identifications.) Now X~o - . Xk is a homotopy equivalence, by hypothesis. Hence D t 9 g - l(x) . g - 1(x ~) induces isomorphisms on homotopy groups, proving
(6.7).
The next lemma involves the notion of a bisimplicial space. A bisimplicial space is defined to be a functor A ~ x A ~ - Top where Top denotes the category of topological spaces. Thus for each ordered pair (p, q) of objects of A, we are given a topological space Tpq, such that given any pair of morphisms p ; if, q ; q' in A, we have a corresponding map of topological spaces Tp, q, ~ Tpq. In particular, for each fixed p E A, q ~-~ Tpq is a simplicial space; similarly for each fixed q E A, p_ H T ~ is a simplicial space. Thus, we can form the geometric realizations Iq ~-* Tpql
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
99
and [q ~-, Tpq[, and obtain simplicial spaces ;2_ ~
lq ~
Tpql,
Ip ~ Tpql,
q ~
and hence their geometric realizations (which are topological spaces)
Ip ~ Iq ~ T~.II,
Iq ~ le ~ T..II.
Finally, we have the diagonal simplicial space p ~ realization ]p ~-~ Tpp]. Lemma
Tpp, with geometric
(6.8). There are natural homeomorphisms
P r o o f . Suppose first that T is of the form A(r) x A(s) x S for a given topological space S, i.e., T is given by the functor A ~ x A ~ --, Top, h r,s x S" (p, q) ; H o m a (p, r) x Homa (q, s) x S, where the Horn-sets are regarded as discrete spaces. Then we claim that the diagonal realization has a natural homeomorphism (1) . . .
[p ~-+ Hom~ (p, r) x Hom~ (p_,_s) x S I ~ A r x As x S.
Indeed, given any simplicial set F " A ~ ~ Set and a topological space S, if F x S " A ~ ; Top, is the simplicial space p ~-. F(p) x S, where F ( p ) is regarded as a discrete space, then from the definition of the geometric realization of a simplicial space, there is a continuous bijection
IF x sl
(2)...
, IFI
x S
which is a homeomorphism if [F[ is compact. Thus, it suffices to verify that there is a natural homeomorphism
lh""l
, A ~ x A..
But h ~'s 9 _ 4 Set is just the product simplicial set A(r) x A(s), so t h a t the projections h r,8 --, A(r), h r,8 ~ A(s) (which are maps of simplicial sets) induce maps Ihr'Sl --, At, ]hr'Sl --' As and hence a map Ihr'Sl Ar x As. By Appendix A, (A.55), this is a homeomorphism. This gives the homeomorphism in (1). Next, we have homeomorphisms (applying (2)) IP_~-* Iq ~-* Homh (p, r) x H o m a (_q,S) X Sll --~ IP_H HomA (p_,_r) x As x Sl u Ar x A s x S, and similarly
lq ~
Ip_. ~
HomA (p, r) x
[q ~ A r x ~A~xAsxS.
HomA (_q,_s) x S[
H o m ~ (q, s) x S[
100
Algebraic K-Theory
Thus, L e m m a (6.8) holds for bisimplicial sets of the form h r's x S. Now let T = {T~s} be a general bisimplicial space. Given any arrow (r, s) , (if, s') in A x A, we have (i) a map of topological spaces Tr,,, T~s, and (ii) a natural transformation of functors (i.e., a m a p of bisimplicial sets) h r,s --, h r''s'. Thus we have two maps of bisimplicial spaces (~,s)-~Cr,,s,)
(r,s)
such t h a t the direct limit of the above diagram is T, i.e., the direct limit in Top of the diagram H h r'8 (p, q) x Tr, s, :=~ H hr's (P' q) x Tr, (~_,,_)-~(_~',~_') (~,~_) is Tpq, for every (p, q) E A x A. We leave the proof of this claim to the reader (who may find it instructive to first prove the analogous claim for simplicial spaces; it is useful to observe t h a t there is at least a map g
H
,q_) • T .
(~,s)
,
since if f " (p__,q_) ) (r__,s) E hr'S(p, q), we have a m a p f * 9 Trs , Tvq as part of the data defining the bisimplicial space T. One verifies t h a t g induces a map from the direct limit of the diagram to Tpq, which one proves is a homeomorphism). Now Lemma (6.8) follows from the special case dealt with earlier, and the observation that all three realization functors commute with direct limits. P r o o f o f T h e o r e m A. Let S ( f ) be the category of triples (X, Y, v) with X E C, Y E l:), v : Y ~. f ( X ) an arrow in :D; a morphism of triples (X, Y, v) ; (X', Y', v') is defined to be a pair of arrows u : X , X', w : Y' , Y in C, 1:) respectively, such t h a t
Y yl
f(x) I Ut )
f(x')
commutes, i.e., v' -- f ( u ) o v o w. We have functors pl : S ( f ) ~. C, , :D~ given by pl ( X , Y, v) -- X , p 2 ( X , Y, v) -- Y . Let T ( f ) be the bisimplicial set given by Tvq = set of pairs of diagrams (Yp ~ " " ~ Yo --* f ( X o ) , X o ~ . . . ~ X q ) where Yp --, ..- --. Y0 is a p-simplex in N D ~ and X0 --* ..- --* Xq is a q-simplex in NC. The bisimplicial structure of T ( f ) is induced by the simplicial structures of NC
P2 : S ( f )
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
101
and NT) ~ in the obvious way. We may regard NC as a bisimplicial set with (gC)pq - NqC. Then (Y,,
. . . - - , Yo
f(Xo),Xo
--,...--,
(Xo --,...--,
yields a m a p of bisimplicial sets
(,)...
T(f)r ~
~.(gc)pq = gqc..
The diagonal simplicial set of T ( f ) is just g s ( f ) , the nerve of S ( f ) , and the map N S ( f ) , N ( of simplicial sets given by (,) is just the natural m a p on nerves induced by the functor pl. Hence the realization of (,) (in any of the equivalent senses of Lemma (6.8)) is the map Bpl " B S ( f ) , BC. On the other hand, we may compute the realization of (,) by first realizing in the p-direction, to obtain a map of simplicial spaces in the variable q, and then forming the associated map between the realizations of these simplicial spaces. Realizing (,) in the p-direction yields the m a p of simplicial spaces which, on the spaces of q-simplices, is
H
B(:D/f(X~176
(Xo. . . . --,X, )e N~C
'
H
(point) = NqC.
(Xo--,. . . . X,)e N~C
Here NC is regarded as a simplicial space with the discrete space NqC of qsimplices; for any Y E D, D / Y is the category of pairs (Y', v) where Y' E T~, v" Y' --, Y is a morphism in T), with morphisms (Y', v) , (Y", w) being arrows u- Y' , Y" such that yl
y" commutes (thus, ~ / Y = I ~ / Y , 1~ 9~ .~ :D the identity functor). Now X ~ B ( D / f ( X ) ) ~ is a functor C , Top from the small category C to the category of topological spaces, where if u 9X ~ X ~ is an arrow in C, composition with $(u)'l(x) , f ( x ' ) yields a functor D / f (X) , :D/f(X'), and hence a map of topological spaces
B(:D/f(X)) ~
, B(:D/f(X')) ~
The simplicial space obtained by realizing T ( f ) = (Tpq} in the p-direction is clearly just the simplicial space associated to C ; Top by L e m m a (6.7), with I = C. Clearly B(iD/Y) is contractible for any Y e T), since (Y, l v ) is a final object of Z)/Y. Hence the map
B(V/J'(X))
~
, BC
I/CX'))
102
Algebraic K-Theory
induced by any given arrow X ::; X', is a homotopy equivalence. Hence the hypotheses of (6.7) are satisfied, and Bpl " B S ( f ) , BC is a quasifibration. Clearly, p ~ l ( X ) = (:D/f(X)) ~ for any X e C, so that (Bpl) -1 {X} - B ( : D / f ( X ) ) ~ (where X is regarded on the left as a 0-cell of BC), which is a contractible space. Thus Bpl induces isomorphisms on homotopy groups, from the definition of a quasi-fibration; since B S ( f ) , BC. are CW-complexes, Bpl is a homotopy equivalence, from the Whitehead theorem (see Appendix A, (A.9)). We note here that so far, the arguments given are valid for any functor f " C ---, :D between small categories. Next, let N / ) ~ be regarded as a bisimplicial set with (NT)~ NpT) ~ Then
(Yp ---, " . ' ~ Yo --, f ( X o ) , Xo - - , . . . - - , X q ) ~ (Yp - - 4 . . . - , Yo) gives a map of bisimplicial sets
T ( f ) vq
,,
(NT)~
-- N p T ) ~
whose diagonal realization is just Bp2 " B S ( f ) , B D ~ On the other hand, if we first realize in the q-direction, we obtain a map of simplicial spaces, which is given on the space of p-simplices by
H Yo. . . . .
S(Yo\f)-----* Yv
H Yo. . . . .
(p~
= NP:D~
Yv
Since by the hypothesis of Theorem A, B ( Y \ . f ) is contractible for every Y E Z), Lemma (6.7) applies again, showing (as above) t h a t Bp2" B S ( f ) =, BZ) ~ is a quasi-fibration with the contractible fibers ( B p 2 ) - I ( Y ) = B ( Y \ f ) , and is hence a homotopy equivalence. Finally, let f ' S ( f ) , S(lz)) be the functor f ( X , Y , v ) = ( f ( X ) , Y, v). Then we have a commutative diagram of categories and functors ~:)op
P2
73op
,
S(f)
pl
S(1~) P2
C
;
7)
Pt
where all the arrows except f, fl are known to be homotopy equivalences. This finishes the proof of Theorem A. Given a functor f : C ; :D between categories, we have the homotopy fiber F ( B f ) of the map B f : BC ----, B:D (over any given base point of
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
103
B7)), giving rise to a long exact homotopy sequence (we omit the base points) 9..---. ~ ( F ( B f ) )
~
7r,(BC) ~
~,(BT))
,7ri_l(F(Bf)) -*....
However, F ( B f ) is not in general the classifying space of a category naturally associated to f . Suppose t h a t we are given a category C', together with a functor g : C' 9 C, and a natural transformation from the composite functor f o g : C' ; :D to the constant functor C' ; {Y}, for some object Y E D. T h e n we have the map B g : BC' ~ BC, together with a homotopy from B f o g : BC' ; B1) to the constant map BC' ; {Y}, where we regard Y as a 0-cell in BiD. Thus we have an induced factorization of B g through the h o m o t o p y fiber over Y, i.e., a map h : B C ' , F ( B f , {Y}). If this is known to be a homotopy equivalence, then we would have a long exact h o m o t o p y sequence
9. . ~
7q(BC') ag. ~,(BC) ~
~r,(BI))
,1r,_I(BC')
~....
Given a d i a g r a m of topological spaces and maps EI
B'
h'
h
E
"- B
we say t h a t the d i a g r a m is homotopy Cartesian (or a h o m o t o p y fiber product) if the induced m a p E 1 ----- B 1 x B F(I, B) x B E is a homotopy equivalence. Here F ( I , B ) is the path space of B, and B ' xB F ( I , B) X a E = {(bl,7, e) e B ' x F ( I , B ) x E [ h ( b ' )
= 7(0),
g(e) = 3'(1) } is the h o m o t o p y fiber product; the map E ' , B ' x B F ( I , B ) XB E is e' ~ (g'(e'), "/o, h'(e')) where ~/0: I ; {g o h'(e')} is the constant path. The h o m o t o p y fiber p r o d u c t is characterized by the p r o p e r t y t h a t to give a map X ---, B 1 x B F ( I , B) x B E is equivalent to giving a pair of m a p s gx :X ; E , h x : X ------, B ' together with a homotopy H : X x I ~B between h o g x and g o h x . In particular, the identity m a p of B 1 x B F ( I , B ) X B E is given by the natural projections to B 1 and E , and the homotopy ( B ' x B F ( I , B ) x B E) x I) ; B, ((b', 7, e), t) " 7(t). Suppose B 1 is contractible; let H 1 : B 1 x I ; B I be a h o m o t o p y from the identity m a p of B 1 to the constant map B I ; {b~}, ,or a fixed base point b~ E B ' . Let b0 = g(b'o) E B. Let H - ( B ' x B F ( I , B) x s E) x I - - , B' XB F ( I , B ) XB E
104
Algebraic K-Theory
be given by
~I((b',7, e),t) = (H'(b',t),Tt, e) where 7t E F(I, B) is the path 7 (s) =
g ~ H ' ( b ' , t - (1 + t ) s )
if o _< s _<
7((1 + t)s - t)
if T~t <_ s <_ 1.
Then one verifies immediately that H is a deformation retraction of B' XB F ( I , B ) xB E onto {b~} xB F ( I , B ) XB E, which is naturally homeomorphic to the homotopy fiber F(h, bo). Thus, if the square is homotopy Cartesian, a n d B t is contractible, there is a homotopy equivalence E ~ F(h, bo), from E ~ to the homotopy fiber of h over any point
bo e g(B'). B. Let f 9C ; "19 be a functor between small categories such that for every arrow u 9Y ~ Y~ of T), the functor u* 9 Y' \ f ~Y \ f is a homotopy equivalence. Then for any object Y of l) the square
Theorem
BY \ f
Bj
BC
BS'~ BY \ D
~BS B~,' B D
is homotopy Cartesian, where j ( X , v) = X , j ' ( Y ' , v) = Y', f ' ( X , v) = ( f ( X ) , v). Since Y \ l) is contractible, for any X e f - l ( y ) we have an exact homotopy sequence ( X -- (X, 1y)) 9-. --* ni+l(B'D, {Y}) ~,(B:D, {Y})
,1ri(B(Y \ f ) , {X}) S j . ni(BC, {X}) et'~ , lr,_l ( B ( Y \ f ) , {X}) - - --..
As with Theorem A, there is a dual version of the above theorem, involving the categories f l Y ; further, if f is either prefibered or pre-cofibered, we have an analogous result with suitable hypothesis on the fibers f-1 ( y ) (if f is prefibered, u" Y~ ~ Y an arrow in :D, we assume u* 9 f-l(y) , f - 1 (y~) is a homotopy equivalence; then we deduce the result that
B f - I (Y)
l
{Y}
;
,
BC
1
B/)
is homotopy Cartesian). We leave it to the reader to formulate these statements in detail, and deduce them from the above form of Theorem B. P r o o f o f T h e o r e m B. As in the proof of Theorem A, we consider the category S ( f ) of triples (X, IF, v) with X E C, Y E l), v" Y ~f ( X ) an
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4 arrow i n / ) , together with the diagram ~)op,
]O2
S(f)
Pl
105 : .~C.
As remarked
during the proof of Theorem A, pl is a homotopy equivalence for an arbitrary functor f. Since u* : y t \ f , Y \ f is a homotopy equivalence for any arrow u : Y ; Y' in :D, by hypothesis, Lemma (6.7) shows that Br, 2 : B S ( f ) , B D ~ is a quasi-fibration, as in the proof of Theorem A, i.e., any fiber of Bp2 is weak homotopy equivalent (and hence homotopy equivalent, since both spaces have the homotopy types of CW-complexes) to the corresponding homotopy fiber. If Y E D, p ~ l ( y ) = y \ f; hence
BY \ f
{Y}
, ,
BS(f)
~
BD~
is homotopy Cartesian. Consider now the diagram ( f ' is as in the proof of Theorem A) BpI BC BY \ f , BS(f)
l
BY \ D
|
,
BS(lv)
,
Bt)~
| {Y}
|
""1
Bpl
""I
BZ)
where the arrows marked Bpl are homotopy equivalences. The square O + @(with vertices B ( Y \ f ) , {Y}, B S ( f ) , B:D~ has been shown, above, to be homotopy Cartesian. The two vertical arrows marked ~ are homotopy equivalences. Hence (T)is homotopy Cartesian, and also (~)+ (~)(since the maps Bpl are homotopy equivalences). This is precisely the conclusion of the theorem. Our next goal is to prove Theorem (4.1) and its corollaries. We recall the statement below. Let C be an exact category, E the category of (short) exact sequences in C. If E, E ' , E " E s we say that the diagram 0 E~ ; E ~ E" ; 0 in g" is an exact sequence if the corresponding diagram in C has exact rows and columns. We have three exact functors s, t, q from E ; C and natural transformations s ---4 t, t ; q such t h a t for any E E s
0
, s(E) ----, t(E)
; q(E)
:0
is the corresponding exact sequence in C.
T h e o r e m (4.1). equivalence.
The functor (s, q) : Qs ~
QC • QC is a homotopy
106
Algebraic K-Theory
P r o o f . By T h e o r e m A, it suffices to prove t h a t the category (s, q ) / ( M , N ) is contractible for every ( M , N ) e QC x QC. Let 171 = ( s , q ) / ( M , N); by definition it is the category of triples (E, u, v) with E E QC, u " s(E) M , v" q(E) ~ N morphisms in QC. Let C2 c 171 be the full subcategory of triples (E, u, v) such t h a t u = j" for some admissible epimorphism j, and let Ca c 172 be the full s u b c a t e g o r y of triples (E, u, v) such t h a t v = i! for some admissible monomorphism i. L e m m a ( 6 . 9 ) . The inclusion functors C2 C C1 and C3 C C2 have left adjoints, and are thus homotopy equivalences. P r o o f . First consider (:2 c C1. If X = (E, u, v) E C1, we must show t h a t there is a universal arrow X , X in 171, with X E (:2. Factor u as u = j" o i!, where i 9 s ( E ) ~ M ' , j 9M ~ M ' are respectively an admissible mono and an admissible epi in C (by the discussion preceding (6.2), every arrow in QC has such a factorization which is unique up to isomorphism). Define an exact sequence i . E in t7 by pushout"
E'O
i.E'O
~ s(E)
~
,1
M'
,
t(E)
,
T
III
~ q(E)
,
q(E)
:*. 0
;
0
(since 17 is closed under extensions in an ambient Abelian category, T E (7, and so i . E E g). Let ~" = ( i . E , j ! v ) ; clearly )~ e (72, and there is an evident m a p X .* X given by the admissible monomorphism E ~ i . E in g;, described by the above diagram. We claim X , X is universal for maps X : ~- X ' with X ' E C2. Indeed, given X , X ' in C1 where X ' = ( E ' , j,!, v') lies in C2, we represent the corresponding morphism E ; E ' in QE by the diagram E ~-~ Eo *- E ' in C. By definition of the morphisms in (:1 = ( s , q ) / ( M , N ) , we have a d i a g r a m in QC
s(E)
) s(E') M
and hence a diagram in 17
ql
e/'
(Eo)
"-' M
M
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
107
Since the factorization u = q!o i~ is unique up to isomorphism (by the definition of a morphism in QC), there is a (unique) isomorphism s ( E o ) M making the diagram commute. Hence, without loss of generality we m a y assume s ( E o ) = M ' , i ~ = i, and q' 9 s ( E ~) --~ M ~ is the unique arrow in C such t h a t q' o j~ = q. By the universal property of the pushout, E --. Eo factors uniquely as E ~ i . E ~ Eo. This gives a map X ; X ' in C2, associated to the diagram i . E ~ Eo ~- E ~ in s such t h a t X , X ' factors as X ---, X ~. X ' . If E0 is replaced by an isomorphic exact sequence (so as to yield the same morphism X ---, X'), clearly we obtain the same morphism i . E ----. E ~ in Q E , and hence the same morphism X ---. X ~ in G2. Lastly, the morphism X , X ' , factoring the given morphism X ~. X ' , is unique; indeed, once we choose a diagram E ~-* Eo ~- E ' representing the underlying morphism E ---, E ' in Q~:, it suffices to show t h a t there is a unique arrow i . E ~ Eo in ~: factoring E ~-. Eo, which yields an arrow in C2. But by the universal property of the pushout, such morphisms i . E ~-. Eo are in bijection with morphisms s ( i . E ) ~ s ( E o ) factoring s ( E ) ~-, s ( E o ) . However, as seen above, since E ; E ' is an arrow in QE arising from X ~. X ' in C1, for the arrow s ( i . E ) , s(Eo) to arise from an arrow in C2, we must have a diagram
s( o)
J s(E)
\ I
M
where all the arrows except the vertical one are already given. Thus the vertical arrow is uniquely determined, and is an isomorphism. This completes the proof t h a t C2 C C1 has a left adjoint. Next, consider the inclusion C3 c C2, and let (E, u, v) E C2. We factor v" q(E) ~. N as v - i~ o j!, where j 9N ~ --~ q ( E ) , i" N t ~-, N , and define j * E by pullback: j*E " O
~
s(E)
---,
T
;
Nt
~
0
By an argument similar to the one above, we see that the map (E, u, v) ( j ' E , u, il), induced by the admissible epi j * E ~ E in s is universal, so t h a t ( E , u, v) ~ ( j ' E , u, il) is a left adjoint to the inclusion (:3 C C2. This proves (6.9).
108
Algebraic K-Theory
To finish the proof of (4.1), it suffices to prove t h a t C3 is contractible, for any M, N E C. Let ( E , j !, i!) E (33, and consider j M " M --~ O, iN " 0 N , giving an object (0, 3"M, " iN!) E C3. We claim there is a unique morphism (0, 3"M",iN,) ~ ( E , j !, i!) in C3, so t h a t (0, 3M," ira) is an initial object. A m o r p h i s m (0, 3M, " iN!) ' (E, j! , i!) consists of a morphism 0 , EinQE such t h a t the induced diagrams below are commutative: ) M
s(E)
q(E)
) N
"
0
0
, s(E) to equal qs(E), ' This forces 0 and 0 , q ( E ) to equal iq(E) ! and hence the morphism 0 E in Q s must be the morphism given by the diagram 0
0
0
~
0
'*
s(E)
,
T Jt
0
-"
0
',
0
s(E)
,
o
--,
o
---,
0
T I.
t(E)
,,
I
q(E)
(this is immediate from a factorization 0 ~-- E0 ~-~ E). Hence (0, 3"M, Qw.)" is an initial object of C3. Thus C3 is contractible. Next, we recall the statement of Corollary (4.2). C o r o l l a r y (4.2). Let C be an exact category, s the exact category of short exact sequences in C, and let s, t, q 9E ---, C be the exact f u n c t o r s defined above. Then t. = s. + q. 9 K i ( E ) ----. Ki(C) ~/i >_ 0. P r o o f . Let f 9C x C ---, E be the exact functor given on objects by f ( M , N ) = (the split exact sequence 0 , M , M (9 N ,N , 0 in E). Now the exact functor (s, q) : s , C x C has the property t h a t the induced functor QE ---. Q(C x C) = QC x QC is a homotopy equivalence, by (4.1) proved above. Hence
q),. K (E)
Ki(C x C) ~ K,(C)(9 K~(C)
is an isomorphism. The composite exact functor (s, q)o f 9C x C .~C x C is t h e identity; hence f . 9 K~(C x C) ~ K~(E) is an isomorphism ~/i > 0. Next, we have an exact functor (9 9C x C , C given by (9 (M, N ) = M ( g N ; if we fix a 0-object 0 E C, then the functors C ; C given by M ~-~ (9(M, 0) and M ~-~ (9(0, M ) are both isomorphic to the identity functor of C. Since
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
109
t h e functors C ~. C x C given by M ~-, (M, 0), M H (0, M ) represent K i ( C x C) as a direct s u m Ki(C) ~ Ki(C), we deduce t h a t ~,:
K,(C x C)
, Ki(C)
is identified w i t h the addition m a p K,(C) ~ K~(C)
~, K,(C),
(x, y) ~ x + y.
Thus ~.o(s,q). :Ki(E) , Ki(C) i s j u s t s . + q . . N o w t o f = ( 9 o ( s , q ) o f : C • C , C; hence t . o f . = (s. + q.) o f . . Since f . is an i s o m o r p h i s m , t . = s. + q., which is w h a t we wanted to prove. C o r o l l a r y ( 4 . 3 ) . Let C, T) be exact categories, F, G , H " T~ ~ C exact fanctors, F ; G, G ~ H natural transformations, such that f o r any object U E T~, 0 ~. F ( M ) ~. G ( M ) ~. H ( M ) , 0 is an exact sequence in C. Then G . = F. + H . 9 K i ( T 0 ~ Ki(C) V i > O. P r o o L Let ~ be the exact category of short exact sequences in C. T h e n we have a well-defined functor L : T) , C given by L ( M ) = (the e x a c t sequence 0 ; F(M) , G ( M ) - - , H ( M ) ---, 0). If s, t, q : E ---, C are the exact functors defined above, clearly F = s o L, G = t o L, H = g o L. Since t . = s . + q . , we deduce t h a t G . = ( t o L ) . = t. o L . = (s. + q . ) o L . = (s o L ) . + (q o L ) . = F . + H . . Corollaries (4.4), (4.5) follow easily from (4.3), and are left to t h e reader. Next, we prove the resolution theorem. Let AJ be an exact category, P C A4 a full additive s u b c a t e g o r y which is closed under extensions in A4, so t h a t :P is an exact category, and P c f14 an exact functor. Theorem that
( 4 . 6 ) (Resolution Theorem). Let 7) C A4 be as above. A s s u m e
(i) if 0 , M' ~ then M ' E P
M
: M"
~. 0 is exact in f14, and M , M "
e P,
(ii) f o r each object M e f14, there is a finite resolution in f14 0
= ;Pn
;Pn-l~'"-~Po
~M-~-O
with Pi e P (and n m a y depend on M ) . Then Q7) ~
Qfl4 is a homotopy equivalence; hence K i ( P ) ~- K i ( f l 4 ) Vi.
P r o o f . Let r C A4 be the full additive subcategory whose objects are M E A/I which have a resolution O - - ~ Pn - - * P,~-I ~ " " ~ Po
~. M
,0
Algebraic
110 w i t h Pj E P V j , A4 = lim A4i.
andn_<
Lemma
Let 0
(6.10).
K-Theory
i. Clearly P = A4o C A41 C . - . C A/I, a n d
". M '
; M
0 be an exact sequence
; M"
in .A4. Then (i),~ M E A4n, M " e J ~ n + l ""@- M ' E A4n (ii)n M ' , M "
~_ A4,.,+1 --> M ~_ .A~n+1
(iii)n M , M " E .h,4n+l ~
M ' E A4n+l.
P r o o f . We first prove t h e above s t a t e m e n t s for n = 0; t h e n we verify t h a t t h e t h r e e s t a t e m e n t s for n - 1 t o g e t h e r imply t h e t h r e e s t a t e m e n t s for n, if n > 1. W e use t h e following two constructions: given a n admissible epi P " --~ M " w i t h P " E P , we have t h e pullback d i a g r a m in jVt (with e x a c t rows a n d columns) 0
0
l 1 II 1
0
--~
0
--,
0
;
M'
---*
0
~ M'
1 1 l l
0
M[' M
--,
X M"
P"
M~'
--~
P"
,,
M"
M
0
1 l 1 l
---,
0
,
0
~
0 ~ 0
0
Next, if P ' ~ M ' , P " --~ M are admissible e p i m o r p h i s m s in A4 w i t h P ' , P " E P , then t h e c o m p o s i t e P " --- M " is a n admissible e p i m o r p h i s m . W e have a d i a g r a m w i t h e x a c t rows a n d c o l u m n s 0
1 l 1 l
0
1 l l l
0
l l 1 l
0
~
K'
,
K
,
K"
0
;
pI
~
p,q~p,,
.
p.
'
M'
:
M
,
M 'l
0
-
0
0
w h e r e t h e middle row is t h e split e x a c t sequence.
0
0
;
0 0
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
111
If M E ~40 = 7~, M " E f141, choose an exact sequence 0
;M~'
;P"
-~M"
;0
with M~', P " E P. Then from the middle column of the first (pullback) diagram above, M x M" p , , E P. Hence from the middle row of the same diagram, M ' E 7~. This proves (i)0. If M ' , M " E A41, then from (i)0, we see that K', K " E :P in the second diagram above; hence K E P, and so from the middle vertical sequence, M E A41. This proves (ii)0. If Mr, M t~ E .h41, then from (i)0, we have K, K n E P in the second diagram above; hence K ~ E P, and from the left hand vertical sequence, M ~E r This proves (iii)0. Now assume n > 1, and (i)n-1, (ii)n-1, (iii)n-1 hold. Suppose M E A/In+l, M " E A/In. Then from (i)n- 1, M~' e A/in- 1 in the first diagram above (as p u E :P c 2~4n-1). Hence from the middle row of the first diagram and (iii)n-1, M " e r This proves (i)n. Next, suppose M ~ , M H E A/In+l. Then from (i)n, K ' , K " E A/ln in the second diagram above. Hence from (ii)n-1, K E A/In, and so from the middle column of the same diagram, M E 2~4n+1. This proves (ii)n. Lastly, let M, M ~t E A/[n+1. Then from (i)n, K, K u E A/In in the second diagram above. Hence from the top row of that diagram, and (iii)n-1, K E A/In, so t h a t M ~ E ~ n + l . This proves (iii)n, and completes the proof of (6.10). Thus, it suffices to prove:
T h e o r e m ( 6 . 1 1 ) . Let P be a full additive subcategory of an exact category A4 which is closed under extensions, such that (i) f o r any exact sequence O P-~
, M t,
, M
, M"
~ 0 in A4, M E
M' EP
(ii) for any M H E A4, there is an exact sequence as in (i) udth M E P. Then the natural f u n c t o r Q79
~ QA4 is a homotopy equivalence.
P r o o f o f ( 4 . 6 ) . Assuming (6.11), we see that QJ~/In c QA/in+l is a homotopy equivalence for each n >__0. Thus we have homotopy equivalences ~=
lim
n ~=
Q(n
m A4n ) ~=
9
P r o o f o f ( 6 . 1 1 ) . Note that Q P C Qcg4 is a subcategory which is in general not full. Let C C QA4 be the full subcategory with the same objects as Q:p. Then the inclusion of Q P in QA/I factors as the composite Q p ~-4 C ~-* QA4; g f it suffices to prove that f, g are homotopy equivalences.
112
Algebraic K-Theory
To prove g is a homotopy equivalence, it suffices to prove that g/P is contractible V P e C, by Theorem A. Let (P1, u) ~_g/P, where P1 e P, u : /)I , P the morphism in C C Q ~ t given by the diagram P1 ~- P~ ~-* P; a morphism (P2, v) * (P1, u) in g/P is given by a diagram
I P2
I ""
P~
"~
"~ P
where the top row defines u, the bottom row defines v, and the left vertical column defines a morphism in QP. The commutativity of P1
u
P2 in QA4 is expressed by the existence of an isomorphism w making the diagram commute. Since P2 ~- P3 ~-* P1 is an arrow in Q7 ), P3 ~-' P1 and P3 --~ P2 are admissible mono and epi in 7), respectively. Given an object (pl, u) E g/P, with u represented by P1 ~- P~ ~-* P, we q
9
can associate to it the A/l-admissible layer (image i, i(ker q)) of subobjects of P, (where an M-admissible layer (P1, P2) of subobjects in P is a pair of subobjects P2 C P1 C P, such that P2 ~-' P1, P1 ~-* P are admissible monomorphisms in ,A/I). Given an arrow (P2,v) ; (P1, u), if (P~,P~') and (P~, P~') are the layers associated to (P1, u) and (P2, v), respectively, then there are inclusions P;~ C P~ C P~ C P; C P. Thus, g/P is equivalent to the partially ordered set (considered as a category in the usual way--see Appendix B) of M-admissible layers (pt, p , ) in P such that P'/P" E ~, i.e., P " r P ' is P-admissible. The partial order is given by (P;,P;~) < (P~,P~') ~ P~ C P~' C P; C P~ (so that there is a (unique) morphism (P;,P;') , (P~,P~) in J) and P~ r P~ is P-admissible (so that all the inclusions P~' ~-~ P;' ~-, P~ ~-, P~ are/)-admissible). We have inequalities (i.e., arrows) in J
(P',P") < (P', O) >_ (0, 0), since 0 ~-, P', P" ~-~ P ' are P-admissible. These can be viewed as natural transformations of functors J .~ J 1j
~h~
-0
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
113
where 1j is the identity, 0 is the constant functor with value (0, 0), and h(P', P") - (P', 0). T h u s the identity functor of J is homotopic to the constant functor 0, and so J is contractible. This proves t h a t g is a homotopy equivalence. To prove f is a homotopy equivalence, it suffices to prove t h a t M \ f is contractible VM E QA4. If ~" = M \ f, then 9r consists of pairs (P, u) with P E :P, u 9 M .~ P a morphism in QcVi. Let ~'~ be the full subcategory of pairs where u = q! for some admissible mono q 9P --- M . If X = ( P , u ) E ~ - , w r i t e u = i ! o q ~ whereq'tb~M,i'lb~P. Since P is closed under taking subobjects, t5 E P, so that .~ = (/5, q!) E ~", and i! gives a m a p X , X in jc. From the uniqueness (up to isomorphism) of the factorization u = i! o q" we verify easily that )~ ; X is universal among morphisms X ~ , X in with X ' E ~'~. Hence ~ ' r ~" has a right adjoint, and so is a homotopy equivalence. Now ~-~op is equivalent to the category of pairs (P, j) where P E 7~, j " P ~ M an admissible epi in A/I, where a morphism (P, j ) ; (P', j') is an admissible epi P --~ P~ in A4 making
P
,~
f(X)
M commute. There exists at least one admissible epi jo " Po ~ M, by the hypothesis of (6.11); fix one such. (liven any admissible epi j 9P ~ M in 3,t, we have a diagram of admissible epis Po
T
Po xM P
Jo ;;
M
T
",~ P
where ker(P0 x M P -~ P0) ~ k e r ( P --~ M) e P, so t h a t P0 x M P E :P. Let k : .~t , .T"t be the functor k ( P , j ) - ( P o x M P, jo o j l ) . T h e n the above can be viewed as giving natural transformations from k to the identity functor of ~'t, and to the constant functor with value (Po,jo). Hence the identity functor of ~'~ is homotopic to a constant functor, and so ~-t is contractible. This completes the proof of (6.11), and hence (4.6). The proof of Corollary (4.7) is left to the reader. Next, we prove the ddvissage theorem.
Theorem
Let .A be an Abelian category, B c A a full Abelian subcategory which is closed under taking subobjects, quotients and finite (4.8).
114
Algebraic K-Theory
products in .A. Suppose each object M E .A has a finite filtration 0 = M0 C M1 C .-. C Mn = M (where n may depend on M) such that Mi/M~-I E 13 V i > O. Then QB ; Q A is a homotopy equivalence; hence K,(B) ~ Ki(.A). P r o o f . Let f : QI3 ~ QA be the inclusion; by Theorem A, it suffices to prove t h a t f / M is contractible for each M E ~4. The category f / M consists of pairs (N, u) with N E B, u : N ~ M a morphism in Q~4. Let N --- M ' ~-o M be a diagram giving u; there is a unique such diagram with M ~ C M , and we then have an associated layer ( M ' , M ") in M, where M " = k e r ( M ~ ~ N). Thus f / M is equivalent to the partially ordered set J ( M ) of ~4-admissible layers (M', M ' ) in M with M ' / M " E 13. Since M has a finite filtration 0 = M0 c M1 c ..- c Mn = M with M~/Mi-1 e 13, it suffices to show that if M ' C M with M / M ' E B, then J(M') ; J(M) is a homotopy equivalence. If (MI, M2) E J(M), then (M1,M2 M M') e J ( M ) , and (M1 N M ' , M2 M M') e J(M'), since
(M1 M M')/(M2 MM') C M1/(M2 N M') C (M1/M2) @ ( M / M ' ) E 13. Let r : J ( M )
; J(M'), s: J(M)
" J ( M ) be the functors
r(Ml, M2) = (M1 M M', M2 N M'),
s(M1, M2) - (M1, M2 M M ' ) ,
and let i : J(M') ~ J(M) be the inclusion. T h e n r o i = 1j(M,). Also, we have inequalities in J(M) (M1 M M ' , M2 M M ' ) < (M1, M2 N M ' ) :> (M1, M2) giving natural transformations i o r ~ - - s b 1 j ( M ) . Hence i o r is homotopic to the identity, and so i is a homotopy equivalence. This proves
(4.s).
O o r o l l a r y (6.12). Let A be an Abelian category (with a set of isomorphism classes) such that every object of A has finite length. Let {Xj l j e J} be
a set of representatives for the isomorphism classes of simple objects, and let Dj = E n d ( X j ) ~ Then K~(A) ~ H j e J g i ( D j ) . P r o o f . Let B c A be the full Abelian subcategory of semi-simple objects. From (4.8), Ki(13) ~= K~(A). Since Ki commutes with finite products and filtered direct limits, we reduce to the case when vi = B has a single object X up to isomorphism. But then M ~-, H o m A ( X , M ) is an equivalence of j4 with P ( D ) , D = EndA(X) ~ where 7~(D) is the category of finite dimensional left D-vector spaces. This proves the corollary.
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
115
The last aim of the chapter is the proof of the localization theorem (see Appendix B for the construction of the quotient Abelian category of an Abelian category modulo a Serre subcategory). T h e o r e m (4.9). Let 13 be a Serve subcategory of an Abelian category .A, with quotient Abelian category .A/B; let e" B ; A, s" .4 = ~ .AlE be the natural functors. Then there is a long exact sequence 9 .. --~
K~+~(~/U)
,
K,(B)
"" ,
K,(.,4)
e. K o ( A )
"-
,
K,(A/B)
~" Ko(.AIB) ,
t~
, K~_,(U)...
~0.
Further, the sequence is functorial for exact functors (,4, B)
~=, (,4', B').
C o r o l l a r y (6.13). Let A be a Dedekind domain with quotient field F. Then there is a long exact sequence
9.. - , Ki+I(F)
' H Ki(AIA4) .h4
, K~(A)
, KI(F)---,...
, Ko(A)
, Ko(F)
, O,
where A4 runs over the maximal ideals of A. P r o o f . Let ,4 = A4(A), B C ~4 the full subcategory of torsion A-modules (i.e., modules M with F| M = 0). Then .A/13 is equivalent to the category P ( F ) of finite dimensional F-vector spaces, while Ki(B) ~ L I ~ Ki(A/.h4) from Corollary (6.12) above. Since A is a Dedekind domain, any M E ,4 has a projective dimension < 1 over A, so that Ki(A) ~ K i ( P ( A ) ) = Ki(A) by the resolution of Theorem (4.6). Hence the result follows from (4.9). P r o o f of T h e o r e m (4.9). Fix a zero object 0 E .A, and let 0 also denote its image in .A/B, which is a zero object in r Now B is the full subcategory of objects M E A such that s ( M ) ~ 0 in .A/B; since 0 is a zero object, there is a unique such isomorphism. Thus the composite functor QB Qe
Q A Q'~ Q ( A / B ) is isomorphic to the constant functor with value 0, and Qe factors as QB ~.0 \ Qs ~. Q A U ~ (M, 0 ~-, s ( i ) ) ,
(N, u ) ~
N.
By Theorem B, it suffices to prove the following claims, in order to prove (4.9): (~) for . ~ . r y . ~ - v '
: v in QCA/U), ~,* . V \ Q s
, V' \ Q s
116
Algebraic K-Theory is a homotopy equivalence, and
(b) the functor QB
~ 0 \ Qs is a h o m o t o p y equivalence.
Indeed, (a) together with Theorem B implies t h a t
0 \ Qs
,
1
QA
1
o \ QC IB) , QC.alB) is h o m o t o p y Cartesian, where 0 \ Q(.A/B) has 0 as an initial object and is hence contractible. By (b), we deduce t h a t the following square is homotopy Cartesian (which implies (4.9))
QB
l
o \ Q( t/B)
O~,
,
Q.A
1
To prove (a) for u = i! o qV where i is an admissible mono, and q is admissible epi, it suffices to prove it when u = i! or u = q!. Now by Corollary (6.3), we have isomorphisms
Q(.AIB) ~ Q ( A I B ) ~ ~- Q(,4~176 under which the roles of admissible monos and epis are interchanged. T h u s u = i! o q! gets transformed into q~ o i ~-wwhere qr, i ~ are the dual arrows in (Jr/B) ~ to q, i respectively (in .A/B). T h u s if we prove (a) for all u = i.~, for all quotients ~4/B of an Abelian category by a Serre subcategory, we deduce (a) for all u = q! by passing to the opposite category (,4/B) ~ Hence it suffices to prove (a) for all u = i~.. For any V E .A/B, let iv : 0 ~-~ V; t h e n if i : V ~ ~-~ V, i~. o iv,! = iv!. Hence it suffices to prove (a) for all u = iv!, for all V E .A/B. Let ~ v be the full subcategory of V \ Qs consisting of pairs (M, u) such t h a t u : V ~ s ( U ) is an isomorphism in Q(.A/B). Clearly ~-0 is isomorphic to QB; thus (b) is a particular case of: Lemma
(6.14). The inclusion ~ v
~ V \ Qs is a homotopy equivalence.
P r o o f . Let f : :7:v ". V \ Qs be the inclusion functor. By T h e o r e m A it suffices to prove t h a t f / ( U , u) is contractible for any ( i , u) in V \ Qs. T h e arrow u : V ~ s ( U ) in Q(.A/B) corresponds to a unique d i a g r a m V ~- V1 ~-+ s ( M ) in .A/B; let V0 = ker j. This gives an A/B-admissible layer j i (i(V1),i(Vo)) in s(M). Choosing i to be an inclusion (there is a unique d i a g r a m representing u with this property), (II1, V0) is an A / B - a d m i s s i b l e layer in s ( M ) .
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
117
An object of f / ( M , u) is a triple (N, v, w) consisting of (N, v) e ~'v and a morphism w 9 5/ 9 M in Q~4 such t h a t y
t$
s(M)
s(N) commutes in Q(.A/B) (thus w determines an arrow (N, v)
; (M, u) in
V \ Qs). S i n c e ( g , v ) e J:v, v " V ~, s(N). L e t N ~ - - M 1 ~ - * M b e t h e unique diagram representing w such t h a t Ml ; M is a subobject, and let M0 = ker(Mi -~ N); thus we have an A-admissible layer ( M : , M0) in M associated to w. Since v is an isomorphism, (s(Ml),s(Mo)) = (V1, V0) as layers in s(M). T h e layer (M1,M0) determines (N,v,w) up to isomorphism; hence f \ (M, u) is equivalent to the partially ordered set J of A-admissible layers (M1,Mo) in M such t h a t (s(M1),s(Mo)) = (111,Vo), with (M1, M0) <_ (M~, M~) ~ M~ C Mo C M1 C M~. We claim t h a t J is filtering (so t h a t by (3.9), J is contractible), i.e., J is non-empty, and is directed (i.e., any two elements of J have a common upper bound). Every subobject VI of s(M) is (up to isomorphism) of the form s(N) for some subobject N of M; indeed V1 - s(N) for some object N E O b , 4 = Ob(~4/B), and 111 :; s(M) is induced by a morphism N ~ - ; M ' in .A, where N ~ C N, M -~ M ' , and N/N', k e r ( M --~ M ' ) E B. T h e n N ' x M' M -~ N ' has kernel in B, so s(N) "~ s(N') ~- s(N' x M' M). So s(N) "~ V1 is the image of an arrow u 9N :: ; M in ,4, without loss of generality. Since s(u) is mono, k e r u e B, and N -~ i m u maps to an isomorphism in .A/B. Hence if we let N = im u, t h e n N C M and s(N) ~- VI. T h u s any layer (V1, V0) in s(M) is of the form (s(M1), s(Mo)) for some layer (/141, M0) in M . Hence J is non-empty. If (MiM0), (M~, M~) are layers in J, then clearly (MI +M~, MoOM~) e J is a common upper bound. Hence J is directed, and hence contractible, proving (6.14). To prove (a) above for u = iv.,., we must show t h a t (iv:)* 9V \ Qs 0 \ Qs is a homotopy equivalence. This is done in a number of steps. First, we introduce some notation. For any N E ~4, let s be the category whose objects are pairs (M,h) with M E A, h 9 M ; N a morphism in ,4 such t h a t s(h) is an isomorphism, i.e., ker h, coker h E B. A morphism (M, h) ; ( M ' , h') in s is defined to be a morphism u " M ~. M ' in Q.A such t h a t if u = i, o j!, then the diagram in A M1
i,
M'
M
h ----,
N
118
Algebraic K-Theory
commutes; this condition does not depend on the specific factorization u = i! o j!, since for an isomorphic factorization u = i~ o j'", there is an isomorphism w making the following diagram commute: M1
M
~1 w
M'
Associated to a morphism ( M , h ) ; ( M , h ' ) , we have a m o r p h i s m ker h ---4 ker h' in QB, given by the diagram in B ker h ~- j - ] ( k e r h) ~-, ker h' corresponding to u = i! o j"; again, the morphism in QB is independent of the factorization u = i., o j!. Thus, there is a well-defined functor kN 9 CN ----, QB, k N ( M , h ) = kerh. We first prove t h a t klv is a h o m o t o p y equivalence, in two steps. Let C~ C SN be the full subcategory of pairs (M, h) where h is an admissible epimorphism in j4, and let k~ 9 C~ *. QB be the functor obtained by restricting kN. Lemma
(6.15). k~ " C~
, QB is a homotopy equivalence.
P r o o f . By Theorem A, it suffices to prove k ~ / T is contractible for any T E QB. Let C = k ~ / T , so t h a t C is the category whose objects are triples (M, h, u) with ( M , h ) E ~ , and u 9 ker h ; T a m o r p h i s m in QB. Let C' c C be the full subcategory of triples (M, h, u) with u = q! for q" T -~ ker h in B. Given X = (M, h, u) E C, with u = jtoi!, i 9 ker h ~-, To, j 9T -~ To, let (i.M, h) E C~ be defined by pushout along i, kerh
;
; M
-----~ N
To
;
~ i.M
= ~" N h
,1
ltt
Let )( = (i.M, h, j") E C'; there is an evident map X , ,~ in C. We claim this is universal among arrows X ; X ' with X ~ E C'. This is easy to verify from the definitions of C, C' and the uniqueness up to isomorphism of the factorization u = j! o i!, and is analogous to the argument given in the proof of (6.9); the details are left to the reader.
6. Proofs of the Theorems of Chapter 4
119
Thus, the inclusion of C' in C has a left adjoint, and is hence a homotopy equivalence. But (N, 1N,q~-) (where 1~ : N ; N is the identity, qr : T --~ 0) is an initial object of C~, from the diagram (in ,4) T
"" kerh
0
; M h--~N
~
N
1N
-,
N
(note that we need h to be an admissible epimorphism, for this argument to work, since h must simultaneously give a morphism in ,4 and Q~4). Thus C', and hence C, are contractible. This proves the lemma. Lemma
(6.16). kN : ~N ~
QI3 is a homotopy equivalence.
P r o o f . From the previous lemma, it suffices to check that s ~-~ s is a homotopy equivalence. Let Z be the ordered set of subobjects I C N such that N / I ~. B. There is a functor f : EN ~ iT given by (M, h) * im h. We claim f makes s fibered over Z; indeed the fiber f - 1 (I) = E~, and for any arrow J , I in iT, corresponding to the inclusions J C I C N, the base change functor ~} ; S~ is given by J•
: (M ~ I ) ~
(J •
M--~ J).
We claim
el
J•
,
e5
commutes up to a natural transformation (so that the induced diagram of classifying spaces commutes up to homotopy). Indeed, there is a natural isomorphism ker(U ;; I) =~ ker(J • U ~ g). Since k~, k~r are homotopy equivalences, by (6.15), J x t? is also a homotopy equivalence. By Theorem B, eN
1
{N}
1, ,
z
is homotopy Cartesian. Since N E I is a final object, X is contractible. Hence ~v ~ ~N is a homotopy equivalence, proving the lemma.
120
Algebraic K-Theory
We now want to prove that if s(N) ~ V, then f v is homotopy equivalent to t~N; this will give homotopy equivalences V \ Qs ~ f v ~ 81v ~ QB, so that the homotopy type of V \ Qs is independent of V. L e m m a (6.17). Let g: N , N' be a map in ,4 such that s ( g ) : s(N) , s(N') is an isomorphism. Then g . : 8 n ~ ~:N,, (M, h) , ( M , g o h) is a homotopy equivalence. P r o o f . Given (M, h) E tf~v there is a natural admissible monomorphism ker h ~-~ ker g o h. This defines a natural transformation kN ) k~r o g. of functors ~r162 ) QB. Since kN, k~,, are homotopy equivalences, so is g.. This proves (6.17). Given V e A/B, let Zv be the category of pairs (N, r with N E ~4, r s(N) ~-; V an isomorphism in A / B , where a morphism (N, r ) (N', r is a morphism g : N ~ N ~ in ,4 such that the following diagram commutes:
sCN') V L e m m a (6.18). Zv is a filtering category for any V e A / B . P r o o f . We must show (i) Ob I v is non-empty. (ii) Given ( g , r (N',r e Zv, there exists ( g " , r diagram in I v
(g,r
E Zv and a
\ (N n, r
(N',r
7
(iii) Given by two arrows ( g , r ==t ( g ' , r in Zv, there is an arrow (N', r ~. (N", r in Zv