Algebraic and Analytic Methods in Representation Theory
PERSPECTIVES IN MATHEMATICS, Vol. 17 S. Helgason, editor
Algebraic and Analytic Methods in Representation Theory Edited by Bent Orsted Department of Mathematics and Computer Science Odense University Odense, Denmark
Henrik Schlichtkrull Department of Mathematics and Physics The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University Frederiksberg, Denmark
ACADEMIC PRESS San Diego
London
Boston
New York
Sydney
Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper. ( ~ Copyright © 1997 by Academic Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA 1300 Boylston Street, Chestnut Hill, MA 02167, USA http://www.apnet.com ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24-28 Oval Road, London NW 1 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Algebraic and analytic methods in representation theory / edited by Bent ¢trsted, Henrik Schlichtkrull. p. cm. - - (Perspectives in mathematics; vol. 17) Main lectures from the European School of Group Theory held Aug. 15-26, 1994, in SCnderborg, Denmark. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-12-625440-0 (alk. paper) 1. Lie groups. 2. Representations of groups. I. Orsted, Bent. II. Schlichtkrull, Henrik, 1954- . III. European School of Group Theory (1994: SCnderburg, Denmark) IV. Series. QA387.A44 1996 512' .55--dc20 96-22985 CIP
Printed in the United States of America 96 97 98 99 00 EB 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Contributors Preface
vii ix
Modular Representations of Algebraic Groups and Relations to Quantum Groups HENNING HAAHR ANDERSEN Orbital Varieties, Goldie Rank Polynomials, and Unitary Highest Weight Modules 53 ANTHONY JOSEPH Discontinuous Groups and Clifford-Klein Forms of PseudoRiemannian Homogeneous Manifolds TOSHIYUKI KOBAYASHI
99
The Method of Stationary Phase and Applications to Geometry and Analysis on Lie Groups 167 V. S. VARADARAJAN The Orbit Method and Unitary Representations for Reductive Lie Groups DAVID A. VOGAN, JR.
243
Index
341
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors HENNING HAAHR ANDERSEN, Department of Mathematics, Aarhus Universitet, 8000 Arhus C, Denmark ANTHONY JOSEPH, Department of Theoretical Mathematics, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 76100, Israel TOSHIYUKI KOBAYASHI, Department of Mathematical Sciences, University of Tokyo, Komaba, Meguro, Tokyo 153, Japan V. S. VARADARAJAN, Department of Mathematics, UCLA, Los Angeles, California 90095-1555, USA
DAVID A. VOGAN, JR., Department of Mathematics, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139-4307, USA
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface The European School of Group Theory for the summer of 1994 was held in S0nderborg, Denmark, from August 15 to August 26 at the Sandbjerg Estate. About 50 advanced students participated, with interests quite wide but centered around algebraic and analytic aspects of Lie groups and their representations. The main lectures were delivered by five outstanding researchers, covering some of the deepest areas of the field today, yet giving introductions that were a pleasure to follow. It was a summer school with a high level of participation and interest on the part of the students, and it is our hope that the present volume will convey a similar spirit to its readers. The theory of reductive groups is at present as active and important as ever. Building on classical tools and structure theory as well as ideas from classical and quantum physics, many problems have been solved, and new research avenues have opened up. The subject has always required knowledge in several branches of mathematics, but even more so today, where an expanding amount of algebraic, geometric, and analytic techniques are combined. Since the written material by the lecturers at the summer school went far beyond usual lecture notes and the different topics formed a unifled view, albeit from perspectives quite apart, it was decided to publish the five contributions together. Chapter 1 by Henning Haahr Andersen gives an introduction to algebraic groups and their representation theory with a clear aim at reaching recent results about modular representations and quantum groups. Indeed, one of the lessons of the past few years of quantized enveloping algebras is that one should develop a good part of the theory parallel to that of algebraic groups. For this point of view, these lectures are very valuable. In Chapter 2, Anthony Joseph gives a full account of the classification of unitary highest weight modules for semisimple Lie algebras, simplifying and expanding previously published work as well as proving results about associated varieties.
In addition, several recent results are given on the
algebra of differential operators on orbital varieties. Toshiyuki Kobayashi ix
x
Preface
treats, in Chapter 3, discontinuous actions of discrete groups on homogeneous spaces and the corresponding problem of constructing Clifford-Klein forms. A number of classification results are given, opening up promising new areas of research on analogs of automorphic functions and locally symmetric spaces. Chapter 4 by V. S. Varadarajan develops the method of stationary phase from its very beginnings to advanced applications in geometry and in analysis on Lie groups. This fundamental technique is present in much of modern physics; in these lectures emphasis is on applications to the Plancherel formula, asymptotics of eigenvalues on locally symmetric spaces, character formulae, and related questions. David Vogan constructs, in Chapter 5, unitary representations of reductive Lie groups by the orbit method, in analogy with the quantization procedures leading from classical mechanics to quantum mechanics. Starting with the basic concepts and some motivating examples, these lectures patiently develop Lie theory, symplectic geometry, the theory of ideals in universal enveloping algebras, Dixmier algebras, and the induction techniques that enter in the orbit method. Emphasizing the distinction between semisimple and nilpotent orbits, many deep results are obtained and intriguing examples as well as conjectures are discussed. It is a pleasure to thank the five authors for their contributions to this volume as well as for their enthusiastic lectures at the summer school. Also, we thank the participating students for their dedication to mathematics and other sports. For financial support, we acknowledge Thomas B. Thriges Fond, Odense University, Aarhus University, The Danish Natural Science Research Council, and a grant from the EC, Euroconferences in Group Theory under the program Human Capital and Mobility. Finally, we are grateful to the staff at Sandbjerg for adding to the pleasant memories of this summer school. Djursholm, October 1995 Bent Orsted, Henrik Schlichtkrull
Chapter 1 Modular Representations of Algebraic Groups and Relations to Quantum Groups HENNING HAAHR ANDERSEN
University of Aarhus
CONTENTS
.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12.
Introduction Algebraic groups and their representations Reductive algebraic groups Classification of simple G-modules Derived functors of induction Representations of SL2 (k) The Borel-Weil-Bott theorem Serre duality and complete reducibility Frobenius kernels and their representations Injective GrT-modules Kempf's vanishing theorem Quantum groups Tilting modules References
Introduction
The (very informal) notes in this chapter present some highlights in the "classical" representation theory for reductive algebraic groups over algebraically closed fields. The theory is developed in such a way that almost everything carries over to quantum groups. In particular, we have emphasized the similarities between the modular representation theory (the case
2
H . H . Andersen
where the underlying field for the algebraic group has positive characteristic) and the representation theory for q u a n t u m groups at roots of unity. We start out by giving the basic general definitions concerning algebraic groups and their representations.
One of the most important tools
for us when studying representations will be the induction functor. So already in the first section we introduce this concept and give some of its first properties. In Section 2 we specialize to the case of reductive groups. Here we need some of the key results about the relations between these groups and their associated root systems. Most of what we need is collected in Facts 2.6. Our first real theorem comes in Section 3, where we present the classification of finite dimensional simple modules for reductive groups. To obtain this we rely heavily on induction from a Borel subgroup.
In the
following sections we explore also the higher derived functors of this induction. In particular, we prove the Borel-Weil-Bott theorem (in Section 6) and Serre duality (in Section 7). From these two results we easily deduce the complete reducibility of all finite dimensional modules for algebraic groups in characteristic zero. Then we turn to characteristic p > 0. Here we shall explore the socalled Frobenius subgroups.
To handle these properly, we need a more general
definition of algebraic groups than the one we have been working with so far. So we begin Section 8 by introducing this more general concept (of algebraic group functors), and we have some remarks on how to generalize the previous results. Then we study (in the rest of Section 8 and in Section 9) the Frobenius subgroups and their representations in a wav quite parallel to our presentation of representations of reductive groups.
As a reward,
we show in Section 10 how we can now very easily deduce the i m p o r t a n t K e m p f vanishing theorem. In Section 11 we sketch how the representation theory of q u a n t u m groups behaves very similarly to the representation theory for reductive algebraic groups. In fact, we leave most of the quantization to the reader, giving only some indications in a few key places. We conclude by a section on tilting modules that makes sense both for algebraic groups and q u a n t u m groups. The results here have applications to the recent work on invariants of 3-manifolds. The material in these notes formed the major parts of my lectures at the Summer School on Group Theory at Sandbjerg in August 1994. It is
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
3
a pleasure for me to thank both the organizers and all the participants for their patience and enthusiasm. 1
Algebraic groups and their representations
Throughout, k will denote an algebraically closed field. For n C N consider the general linear group GLn(k) with coefficients in k, i.e., GLn(k) = {(aij)i,j=l,2
.....
n
l aij C k, det(aij) 7£ 0}
Clearly, this is an open subset (in the Zariski topology) of k n2 (being the complement of the zeroes of det), or alternatively, it is a closed subset of k n2+1 (being identified with the zeroes of the polynomial T det(Xij) - 1 C kiT, (X~j)]). Definition 1.1 By an algebraic group (over k) we understand a Zariski closed subgroup of GLn(k) for some n E N. E x a m p l e s 1.2 i) GL~(k), n E N. ii) SLn(k)-- {A e G L n ( k ) i d e t ( A ) = 1}, n e N. iii) The 1-dimensional additive group (k, +). This is a subgroup of GL2(k) viaxH
(ix) 0
1
'
xCk
iv) The 1-dimensional multiplicative group (k x, .). Here k x = k\{0}, i.e., (kx, ") = G L I ( k ) . v) Tn -- Tn (k) -
_( [
dimensional torus.
/ tl 0
"..
0/
} tC i
kx
o
This is called the n-
tn
vi) Bn - B n ( k ) - {(aij) e GLn(k) I aij = 0 for i > j}, the subgroup consisting of the upper triangular matrices in G L n ( k ) . vii) Un = U~(k) = {(aij) e Bn] aii - 1 for i - 1,2,...,n}. Note that U~ is a normal subgroup of Bn and that Bn = Tn U~. If V is an n-dimensional vector space over k we can (and shall) identify the group of invertible k-linear endomorphisms of V, GL(V) with the algebraic group GLn(k).
4
H.H. Andersen
D e f i n i t i o n 1.3
The coordinate ring k[G] of an algebraic group G is k[G] = {f: G ---, k l f is regular}.
(Here regular refers to the notion of "regular function on a variety," cf. [Ha]. In the following, all maps between varieties are tacitly assumed to be regular. In the case at hand, k is considered as the l-dimensional affine space. More generally, we always consider an n-dimensional vector space as the affine n-space.) T h e group structure on G gives rise to a Hopf algebra structure, cf. [Sw], on k[G].
The comultiplication A: k[G] ~
k[G] ® k[G] comes from
multiplication G x G ~ G, the counit e: k[G] ~ k from the unit 1 -~ G, and the antipode S: k[G] ~ k[G] from the inverse map G ~ G. Show t h a t we have the following identities:
E x e r c i s e 1.4
k[(k,-~-)]- k[X], k[Tn ] --
Definition
1.5
]~[(]gx,.)]_ k[X,X-1],
k[Xl,... ,xn,xll,...,xnl].
A homomorphism f:G1 --~ G2 between two algebraic
groups is a map of varieties t h a t is also a group homomorphism.
A representation of an algebraic group G on a finite dimensional vector space V is a h o m o m o r p h i s m p: G ~ GL(V). We say in short t h a t V is a representation of G (or a G-module), and we often write gv instead of
p(g)(v), when g e G and v e V. If V and V t are two G-modules, then a G-homomorphism from V to V t is a linear map t h a t commutes with the G-actions. The set of these is d e n o t e d H o m a ( V , V'). We shall need to extend the preceding definition of representations to a class of infinite dimensional ones. Namely, we say t h a t a group homom o r p h i s m p: G ~ GL(V) from an algebraic group G into the general linear group on some vector space V is a a rational representation of G if V is a union of finite dimensional representations as just defined. In the following, when we write G-module we u n d e r s t a n d such a rational representation of G.
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
5
E x a m p l e s 1.6 i) The trivial representation of an algebraic group G is the representation on k,
G~GL(k)=k
×
that takes any g C G into I C k. More generally, the trivial representation of G on any vector space V is given by the trivial homomorphism G ~ GL(V). ii) A homomorphism G ~ GLn(k) defines a representation of G on k n (via the identification GLn(k) - GL(k~)). In particular, the identity GLn(k) --, GL~(k) defines the natural representation of GLn(k) on ]¢n. iii) A rank one representation of G is a homomorphism G -~ GL(k) = k x. These representations are called the characters of G and they constitute the set X(G). We have for instance X ( ( k , +)) = 0 and
x(kx)_ z.
iv)
The coordinate ring k[G] of G may be equipped with several representations: a) (the right regular representation) Pr: G ---, GL(k[G]) is defined by
Pr(g) f : X ~ f (xg),
g, x e G, f e k[G].
b) (the left regular representation) Pl: G ~ GL(k[G]) is defined by
pl(g)f: x H f ( g - l x ) ,
g,x e G, f e k[G].
c) (the conjugation representation) p: G--~ GL(k[G])is defined by
p(g) f : x H f (g-lxg),
g, x e G ,
fek[G].
Using the correspondence between the algebraic group G and the Hopf algebra k[G], we see that a representation of G corresponds to a comodule for k[G]: If V is a representation of G, then we get a k-linear map Av: V --. V ® k[G] satisfying the appropriate comodule axioms, cf. [Sw, p. 30].
6
H . H . Andersen
D e f i n i t i o n 1.7 Let V be a representation of G. Then the fixed points of G in V are defined by
V G={vCVIgv=vforallgEG}.
Note that
V a "~ H o m a ( k , V).
D e f i n i t i o n 1.8
Let H be a closed subgroup of the algebraic group G and
let V denote a representation of H. The induced representation IndaH V is defined by IndaH V -- { f ' G ~ V l f ( g h ) -
h - i f ( g ) , g e G, h E H}
with G-action given by
(xf)(g) - f ( x - l g ) ,
x,g e G, f e IndGHV.
In the case where V is infinite dimensional, we require that the elements f C IndaHV are maps of varieties in the sense that f(G) is contained in a finite dimensional G-invariant subspace W of V such that f: G --~ W is a map of varieties. The map Ev" IndaH V --, V that takes f C IndaHV into f ( 1 ) i s called the evaluation map. It is clearly an H-homomorphism. Examples
1.9
i) Consider the trivial subgroup H = 1, and let k denote
the l-dimensional trivial representation of H. Then I n d l a k - k[G]. The action is the left regular representation of G on k[G], cf. Example 1.6(iv). ii) The other extreme is the case H = G. In that case, we have
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
7
Indaa V "~ V for all G-modules V. iii) Let G - SL2(k) and take H - T2 gl G. Then IndaHk ~ S ( V ) , the symmetric algebra on the natural 2-dimensional representation of G. (To see this takes a little work, cf. also Section 5.) P r o p o s i t i o n 1.10 (Frobenius reciprocity) Let H be a closed subgroup of G. Suppose V is an H-module and M is a G-module. Then the map
H o m a ( M , IndaHV) ---, HomH(M, V) that takes ¢ to Ev o ¢ is an isomorphism. Proof: The inverse map takes ¢ C HomH(M, V) into the homomorphism that maps m C M to g ~-, ~p(g-lm). [-7 Proposition 1.10 has several consequences. We mention a few of the more immediate ones: C o r o l l a r y 1.11 Let H denote a closed subgroup of G. i) The functor Ind/a/ is left exact (being the right adjoint of restriction). ii) Induction is transitive; i.e., if K is a closed subgroup of H, then IndaK ,-~ IndaH o Ind H. iii) IndaH takes injective H-modules into injective G-modules. (An injective G-module is by definition a G-module that is injective in the category of all rational representations of G.) By taking H = 1 in (iii) we get for any G-module V an embedding of V into IndlaV. The latter is injective by (iii), and hence
iv) The category of rational representations of G has enough injectives. We shall also need the following useful result (the proof of which takes a little more work, see [Ja, Proposition 1.3.6])
Let V be a G-module and W an H-module. Then there is a natural isomorphism of G-modules
P r o p o s i t i o n 1.12 (The tensor identity)
I n d ~ ( V ® W) "" V ® IndaH W.
8 2
H.H. Andersen Reductive algebraic groups
From here on, we shall concentrate on reductive algebraic groups. In this section, we give the appropriate definitions, prove a key result on representations of tori, and list some facts about reductive groups that we shall need in developing their representation theory. D e f i n i t i o n 2.1 i) An algebraic group T is called a torus if there exists n C N such that T __ Tn (cf. Example 1.2(v)). ii) An algebraic group G over k is called reductive (resp., sernisimple) if the maximal connected solvable normal closed subgroup in G is a torus (resp., trivial). E x a m p l e s 2.2
i) A torus is clearly reductive.
ii) GL~(k) is reductive: This is a consequence of Lie-Kolchin's theorem, [Hu2, 17.6], which says that a connected solvable closed subgroup N of GLn(k) is conjugate to an upper triangular subgroup. If N is also normal, it follows that N is upper triangular. By symmetry, N is therefore diagonal. But if Eij denotes the n x n matrix with 1 at the ( i , j ) - t h entry and 0 elsewhere, then
(1 + Eij)
/
"'. 0
0/
(1 + Eij) -1 -
tn
/
".. 0
0/
+ (tj - ti)Eij
tn
for all t l , . . . , tn E k. Hence, we see that
N<__{
I t °I "..
0
tEk×}-Z(GL~(k))
t
and the claim follows (the only connected subgroups of k x are 1 and
k×).
iii) SL~ (k) is semisimple: This follows from the same arguments as in (ii). Let now T be a torus. If T ~_ Tn, then X ( T ) ~_ Z n (in the following we shall identify ( A I , . . . , A n ) E Z n with the character A:Tn --- k x that
Chapter 1 Modular Representations takes
I
t1
•
0I
..
into
t h1 i ' ' '
t n)~n , t l , . .
"~
tn
9
C k X ). As T is abelian, we
0 tn know t h a t all irreducible representations are 1-dimensional, i.e., belong to X ( T ) . The following result says that all finite dimensional representations split into a direct sum of 1-dimensional representations (i.e., are completely reducible). P r o p o s i t i o n 2.3
Let V be a finite dimensional representation of the torts
T. Then V-
~V~,
ACX(T)
where for each A E X(T), v~ - {v e v l t v - A(t)v, t e T}.
Proof: Choose first arbitrarily a basis { V l , . . . , Vr} of V. Then we can write
tvi - E fij(t)vj, J
t C T,
for some fij E k[T].
Identifying T with Tn and recalling that k[Tn] = k [ X 1 , X ~ I , . . . , X n , X n 1] (cf. Exercise 1.4)), we have
fij
I
t1
"'.
0
0I
-- E
AEX(T)
t~
rij'xt~ll""t~n"
If we denote our representation of T on V by p: T ---, GL(V), then the preceding tells us that we may write
p(t)- Z
AEX(T)
where p~ E Endk(V) is the endomorphism that in the basis
Vl,...,
Vn
is
given by the matrix (rij~)i,j=l .....n. Now X ( T ) is a linearly independent subset of k[T]. This together with the fact that p(tt') = p(t)p(t'), t, t' E T, i.e.,
x(t)x(t')p XCX(T)
-
Z ~,,~X(T)
for
t,t'
T,
10
H. H. Andersen
means first that
ik(t')pa -
~ #(t')pap, ,~x(r)
and then
pxp,
if A - # ,
[ 0,
p
"'. 0
1
Z pa" a~x(r)
From (2.1) and ( 2 . 2 ) i t follows clearly that V -
p~ ( v ) -
(2.1)
otherwise.
/ 1 °/
Note t h a t we have also
Id-
_ fp~,
for all t' C T,
(~p~(V)
(2.2)
and t h a t
v~. D
Terminology
2.4
Let V be as in Proposition 2.3. If A E X ( T ) , then
we call Va the A-weight space in V, and we say that ~ is a weight in V if
v~, # o. Let G be a connected reductive algebraic group, and fix a maximal torus T <_ G (i.e., T is a torus, T _< G and T is maximal with these properties). If g E G, the conjugation action x H gzg -1, x C G, gives rise to an endomorphism Ad(g)" g + g, where t~ is the Lie algebra of G. In this way we obtain a representation g ~-~ Ad(g) of G on t~, i.e., Ad" G ~ GL(g) is a homomorphism of algebraic groups, called the adjoint representation of G. W h e n we restrict Ad to T we have a finite dimensional representation of T, and by Proposition 2.3 it splits into a sum of weight spaces. D e f i n i t i o n 2.5
Let G and T be as before. The nonzero weights of T in
g are called the roots of G (with respect to T). The set of roots will be denoted by R. We collect some basic facts about the correspondence between R and G; see, e.g., [Hu2].
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
11
Facts 2.6 Let G be a connected reductive algebraic group with a maximal torus T < G. The set of roots R of G w.r.t. T is a root system in the euclidian space span•R C_ X ( T ) ®z R. ii) For each a E R, there exists a (unique up to scalar) homomorphism x~: (k, +) ---, G such that t x ~ ( z ) t -1 = x~(c~(t)z), t ~ T, z C k. The image of x~ is called the root subgroup in G associated with. cx. It is denoted Us. iii) Choose a set R+ C R of positive roots, and let U (resp., U ~) denote the subgroup of G generated by {U~ !c~ E - R + }
(resp., {&~ t o~ C R~_}).
Then U - I - I ~ R+ V_~ (resp., U' = I-I~c R+ V,~ ), with ~ denoting direct product. Moreover, U M T = 1 = T A U ~, and if we set B = T U then U~B is an open subset of G.
iv)
W = N G ( T ) / T is a finite group, which via its natural action on X ( T ) becomes identified with the Weyl group for R.
E x e r c i s e 2.7
3
Check the facts (i)-(iv) for G = GL~(k).
Classification of s i m p l e G - m o d u l e s In this and the next sections we consider a connected reductive al-
gebraic group G over k with a fixed maximal torus T.
We will use the
n o t a t i o n X ( T ) , R, R+, B, U, U I, Us, and W from Section 2.
L e m m a 3.1 Let V be a finite dimensional representation of G. Then the weights in V (w.r.t. T ) form a W-stable subset of X ( T ) . Proof." Let w = n T C W , n E N a ( T ) .
Take v E V~\{0}. T h e n t(nv) =
n ( n - l t n ) v = n ( A ( n - l t n ) v ) = (wA)(t)nv, for all t C T; i.e., nv E Vw~\{0}. D
L e m m a 3.2
Let E be a finite dimensional representation of B. Suppose
e C E a \ { 0 } for some A C X ( T ) .
Then, for all ct E R+, we have
U_~e C_ e + ~ n>O
Ea_n(~.
H. H. Andersen
12
Proof:
Since by Proposition 2.3 we have E -- ~ # E X ( T ) E , ,
we may for
each c~ E R+ write z e k,
ttEX(T)
where e. E E . and f~ e k[(k, +)] - k[X]. If a.,n e k are determined by
f . ( z ) - }--~n>Oa.,n zn, z E k, then by Fact 2.6(ii)we get tx_a(z)t-le
-
-
x_a(ol(t)-lz)e.
The left hand side is equal to l ( t ) -1 ~--~, f , ( z ) p ( t ) e , ,
whereas the right
hand side is }--~ f~(c~(t)-lz)e~. This means
A(t)-lA(z)p(t)-
A(c~(t)-lz),
for all #, t, z,
i.e.,
A(t)-lp(t)a~,n -- a~,nOl(t) -n, Hence, f~ - 0 unless p - I -
for all #, t, n.
n a for some n _> 0 and f~-n~(Z) - an Zn
for some an E k. Using also that x_~(0) - 1, we see that fx - 1 and the lemma is proved. [3 The choice of R+ induces an ordering on X ( T ) , namely I _< # if P-
I-
~ER+
n~c~ for some n~ E N.
P r o p o s i t i o n 3.3
Let E be a finite dimensional B-module. Then we have,
for any )~ E X ( T ) and e E E~\{0}, Ue C_ e + E
E,.
tt
In particular, E~ C_ E U if I is minimal among the weights in E. P r o o f : Immediate from Lemma 3.2 and Fact 2.6(iii). W1 Recall that by Facts 2.6 we have U,~B and B / U ~_ T. Each I E X ( T ) therefore gives a character (also denoted by A) of B, namely,
A(tu) - l(t),
t E T, u E U.
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
13
Now X ( k , +) = 0, cf. E x a m p l e 1.6(iii), and hence also X ( U ~ ) = 0 for all a C R. It follows t h a t X ( U ) = 0. In other words, all characters of B come from T (as before) or
X ( B ) ": X ( T ) .
(3.1)
We m a y therefore consider (in a unique way) every ~ e X ( T )
as a 1-
dimensional representation of B.
Corollary 3.4 tration
Any finite dimensional representation E of B has a ill0-
F r+l
C F r C '''
C
F°
-
E
by B-invariant subspaces F i with F i / F i+1 ~ )~i, i - O, 1 , . . . , r , where Moreover, the filtration may be chosen such that )~i < Aj only if i > j.
{ A 0 , . . . , At} is the set of weights in E.
N o t a t i o n 3.5
If E is a representation of B, then we write H ° ( E )
-
IndaB E. A weight ~ C X ( T ) is called dominant if (,~, c~v) _> 0 for all c~ E R+. (Here, c~v denotes the coroot associated with a.
Recall t h a t s~A -
~-
(~, c~V)c~ defines the reflection s~ in W associated to c~ E R+.) Clearly, is d o m i n a n t iff s~A _< ~ for all c~ E R+. T h e set of d o m i n a n t weights is denoted X ( T ) +. Theorem
3.6
Let )~ e X ( T ) and suppose H°()~) # O. Then
i) ~ e X(T)+. ii) The restriction map ¢: H°()~) --~ k[U'], which takes f e g ° ( A ) into f l u ' , is injective. iii) If we let T act on k[U'] via t . h" u H )~(t)h(t-lut),
t~T, u~U' h~k[U']
then ¢ becomes a T-homomorphism. iv) The weight spaces H °()~)~ are all finite dimensional; and if H °(~), O, then # < A. v) dim H°(A)~ - 1. vi) dim H ° (~) < c~.
H. H. Andersen
14
Proof: Consider first (ii): If f e H°(A) restricts to 0 on U', then f(ub) = A(b)-lf(u) = 0 for all u E U', b E B; i.e., f is also zero on the open set U'B (cf. Fact 2.6(iii)). Now a connected group is an irreducible variety, and hence U'B is dense in G. It follows that f = 0. Next we deal with (iii): Take f E H°(~), t E T. Then ¢(tf)(u) = f ( t - l u ) = f ( t - l u t t -1) = A(t)f(t-lut) = t¢(f)(u) for all t e T, u E U'. Let us then look at (iv): Suppose h E k[U'],\{0} for some p E X(T) (we consider the action of T on k[U'] defined in (iii)). Then we have A(t)h(t-lut) - p(t)h(u), By Fact 2.6(iii) we have u write
(3.2)
I-[aER+ x~(za) for some z~ E k, and we may
h(u)- Ear_ r
for some at_ E k, r -
(ra)~eR+ (using t - l u t -- I-Is x~(a(t)-lz~))
a
~(~)
t E T, u e U'.
H
za
hER+
E N IR+I • Inserting this in (3.2) we get
zar~) -- #(t) Er
a r _ ( ~ zar~).
We conclude that # - ~ - ~--~R+ r ~ a for some r E NIR+I and (iv) now follows from (ii) and (iii). In fact, we get d i m g ° ( A ) , _< # { r E N IR+I ] - ~ -
~c~+
r~}.
To prove (v) we see by the preceding that we only have left to check that H °(~)~ # 0. But i f H °(A)~ = 0, then E v ~ : H °(~) +
~ would be
the zero map, which, by the universality (Proposition 1.10) of the induced module, would imply H ° (~) = 0. Now we have only left to observe that (i) follows from (iv) and (v) (by Lemma 3.1, we see that s~A is a weight of H°(A) for all a E R+) and that (vi) is a consequence of (iv) (it is well known that any weight is W-conjugate to a dominant weight and that there are only finitely many
p E X(T) + with # _< ~). [::]
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
15
C o r o l l a r y 3.7 If E is a finite dimensional representation of B, then N ° ( E ) is a finite dimensional representation of G.
Proof." Apply H ° to a filtration of E as in Corollary 3.4 and use Theorem 3.6(vi). (Recall that H ° is left exact). D It turns out that the converse of the implication H°(A) ¢- 0 :=~ A C X ( T ) + (see Theorem 3.6(i)) is also true, i.e., Let A E X ( T ) . Then H°(A) -y: 0 iff A E X ( T ) +
(3.3)
(This involves a little algebraic geometry; see, e.g., [Hu2, 31.4].) Theorem
3.8
Let ~ E X ( T ) +
i) There is a unique irreducible G-invariant subspace L(A) in, H°(A). ii) dim L(A)a - 1. P r o o f : We claim
U'-
(3.4)
Note that the containment 2 follows from Proposition 3.3 (with U replaced by U'), since H ° ( A ) t , -
0 for all # > A. To get the other inclusion, take f E H°()~) U' nonzero and note that f(u'b) - A(b)-I.W(1) for all u'b C U'B. Since U'B is dense in G (Fact 2.6(iii)) we conclude that E v a f f(1) is nonzero. But this means that EVaiHo(X)u, is injective, and hence d i m H ° ( A ) u ' < 1. Let us now prove (i). Suppose S and S I are two different irreducible G-invariant subspaces of H°(A). Then S N S I -- 0. On the other hand, using Proposition 3.3 we have 0 =/= S U' C H°(A) U' - H°(A)~; and since the latter space is 1-dimensional (Theorem 3.6(v)), we conclude S U' - H°(A)~. The same is, however, true for S ~, and we get a contradiction. The same reasoning proves L()~) v' - H°(A)~; i.e., L(A)~ ~- 0 and (ii) follows. IS] 3.9 If S is a finite dimensional irreducible representation of G, then there exists a unique ~ C X ( T ) + with S ~ L(/~).
Theorem
P r o o f : The uniqueness we get from Theorem 3.8(ii). To get the existence, By
we pick A E X ( T ) such that A is maximal among all weights of S.
Corollary 3.4, we can then find a B-invariant subspace F C_ S with S / F ~_
H. H. Andersen
16
A. In particular, 0 :/: HomB(S, A) -~ Homa(S,H°()~)); see Proposition 1.10. But this means that A E X ( T ) + (by (3.3)) and that S may be identified with a G-invariant subspace of H°()~). The conclusion follows by Theorem 3.8(i). K] E x a m p l e 3.10 i) 1 for all t C T. to ambiguities representation
Let ,~0 E X ( T ) denote the trivial character, i.e., ,~0(t) = (Sometimes we write 0 for this character, but this leads in the present context.) Then H°(,~0) = k, the trivial of G. (By Theorem 3.6, we see that A0 is the only
weight of H ° (,~0).) ii) Let co E X ( T ) +, and suppose co is minimal among dominant weights (i.e., no ,~ e X ( T ) + satisfies ,~ < co). Then H°(co) = L(co). (One checks that the only weights of H°(co) are {w(co) [ w e W}). Let V be a finite dimensional representation of T. Then we set (cf. Proposition 2.5) ch V -
E(dim
V;~)e~ C Z[X(T)],
and we call this the (formal) character of V. Clearly, ch is additive on short exact sequences.
(3.5)
Also, we see from
L e m m a 3.1 that If V is a representation of G, then ch V e Z[X(T)] W.
(3.6)
Here, W acts on Z[X(T)] via w(}-~ a~e~) - ~-~,~a~e w~, w E W. Problem
3.11
Determine ch L(A) for all A e X ( T ) +.
This problem is in some sense the very first problem one encounters when studying finite dimensional representations of reductive groups. W h e n char(k) = p > 0, it is still open in general. (We will have more to say about it later on; see Problems 8.9, 9.7, and 11.7 and Proposition 11.8.)
Chapter 1 4
Modular Representations
17
D e r i v e d f u n c t o r s of i n d u c t i o n We still keep the general assumptions from Section 3. Consider two
closed s u b g r o u p s H I _-/2 _< G.
Recall that IndH~ is a left exact functor from the category of HImodules to that of H2-modules and that these categories have enough injectives (Corollary 1.11(iv)). Hence, we may consider the right derived functors RiIndH~ of IndH~. If V is an Hi-module, then RiIndH~V is obtained by choosing an injective resolution O---> V----+ Io---+ I1 ---~ I 2 - - + ' " --H2 and applying IndH~. Then R i T lnCtH1V is the ith cohomology of the resulting complex, IndH~ Io.
In the case where Hi = B and/-/2 = G, we write H i-
RiIndCB .
(4.1)
(Note that this is consistent with the use of H ° in the previous section, see Notation 3.5). In the general case, we sometimes write H i ( H 2 / H 1 , - ) 1H2 instead of R i-lnOH1. If Hi -- 1, then Ind H2 (E) - k[H2] ® E, for any k-vector space E (this follows, e.g., from the tensor identity of Proposition 1.12). In particular, Ind H2 is an exact functor, and hence RiInd H2 - 0 for i > 0. Similarly, Ind H2 is exact for all /-/2 >_ T (because all T-modules are injective by Proposition 2.3). Note in particular that
IndBE - k[U] ® E for all T-representations E.
(4.2)
Here, U acts on k[U] via the left regular
representation and T acts by t f: u ~ f ( t - l u t ) , t e T, u e U, f e k[U]. P r o p o s i t i o n 4.1 Let E be an Hi-module and V an H2-module. we have for all i an H2-isomorphism,
Then
--H2 (V @ E ) ~ V ® R i IndH1 H2 E . R i-INCH1
Proof." For i = 0, this is the tensor identity from Proposition 1.12. It follows for i > 0 by noting that if E ~ I. is an injective Hi-resolution of
18
H. H. Andersen
E, then V ® E ~ V ® I. is an injective Hi-resolution of V ® E (injectivity is preserved when tensoring by an arbitrary representation). D The preceding derived functors of induction relate to sheaf cohomology of bundles on the homogeneous space
H2/H1 as follows:
Let V be an Hi-module. Then V induces a bundle £ ( V ) on the sections of which over an open subset U C F ( U , £ ( V ) ) - { f ' T r - l ( u ) --~ (here,
H2/H1,
H2/H1 are
V l.f(xb) - b - i f ( z ) , w E 7 r - l ( u ) , b C B}
7r:H2 ~ H2/H1 denotes the canonical map). F(H2/HI,£(V))- IndH~V. We claim that in fact
Note that
Hi(H2/H1 £ ( V ) ) ~ RiIndH2V •
~
,
HI
(4.3/
for all i. Since we already observed (4.3) for i = 0, it follows for all i by standard dimension shift once we check that an injective H i - m o d u l e I induces a bundle
£(I) that is acyclic for the global section functor. This in turn
reduces to the standard fact t h a t on the affine variety/-/2 any bundle has vanishing higher cohomology, see [Ja, 1.5.11]. Via (4.3) we are now able to carry over properties of sheaf cohomology to our derived functors of induction. Although we could make much more heavy use of this (e.g., in Theorem 3.6(vi) or later in Theorem 7.1), we shall prefer to give pure representation theoretic arguments whenever possible. However, we shall need the following vanishing theorem (see [Ha, Theorem III.2.7]):
Hi(H2/HI,.T ") = 0 for all sheaves 5c on
for a l l / >
dimH2/H1,
(4.4)
H2/H1.
Let us use this opportunity to also introduce Ext-groups as derived functors: If H _< G is a closed subgroup and if E is a representation of H we may consider the right derived functors of the left exact functor H o m H ( E , - ) from H-modules into k-vector spaces. As usual, we write Ext'(E,-)-
RiHomH(E,-).
Chapter 1
5
Modular Representations
19
R e p r e s e n t a t i o n s of SL2(k) In this section, we set G = SL2(k) and t
U-{(0
0
tEk×},
1 u 1)
~ E k}, t
t- 1
t E k x ~1,E k
It is then straightforward to check that G-BUU(0
\ 1
-1'~ B 0 /
(disjoint union).
Set V = k[X,Y], and let G act on V by
b)
a
d
c forall ( ac
f(X,Y)-
db ) E G, f ( X , Y )
f ( a X + cY, bX + dY),
E k[X,Y]. Then V is a rational G-module.
In fact, V = t~,>0 V,., where V~ = span k { x i Y j I i ÷ j = n}. Note that V,, is G-stable, and that we have
(o (o (o t
t -0 1 ) x i y j
__ t i _ J x i y j
1
1
(5.2)
1
m--0
-1)0 x~YJ - ( - 1 ) J x J Y i "
By (5.1), these formulas tell everything. In this case, X ( T ) = Z. For n E Z, let A,:T --, k × denote the character
0
t -1
~
'
"
H. H. Andersen
20
Proposition 5.1
For all n >_ O, there is a natural G-isomorphism Cn" Vn "~ H°()in).
Proof:
The projection V~ --~ k onto the basis element y n E Vn is a B-
homomorphism if we let B act on k via )in.
By Frobenius reciprocity
(Proposition 1.10), we get a G-homomorphism ¢'Vn ~
H°()in).
One
checks that this is an isomorphism. [] C o r o l l a r y 5.2
Let n >_ O. Then H°()in) has a basis { v 0 , . . . , v ~ } such
that, for all i - 0 , . . . , n , i) tvi -- )i2i_~(t)vi, ii)
(10 u) 1
~ ( im)U'--'~Vm, " Vi -- Em=O
Proof: Set v i -
Remark
t C T. u e k.
C n ( X n - i y i) and compare with (5.2). D
It is easy from this corollary to check that in characteristic zero
the H°()in) are all irreducible. This is a special case of a general fact; see Theorem 7.6. We now want to compute the higher cohomology groups H / ()in), i > 0, n E Z. Here we use the exact sequence 0 ~
)in ""+ ]g[U] (~))i n ~
Q ~ 0,
(5.3)
where the first homomorphism is the natural B-homomorphism )in --* IndB)i~ (see (4.2)) and Q is the quotient. A careful examination of the long exact sequences arising from (5.3) for various n C Z gives (cf. [Do, 12.2])"
Proposition 5.3
Let n C Z.
i) Hi(An) - 0 for i > 1. ii) If n >_ - 1 , then HI(An)- O. iii) If n <_ --1, then H°(An) - O. Moreover, H 1 ()~n) has a basis of elements wo, w l , . . . , W-n-2 such that twi --/k-n-2-2i(t)wi,
t E T,
-n-2
( 10
U 1 )wi_
E j=0
( ~ ) uY-~wJ"
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
21
If we compare the result in Proposition 5.3(iii) with Corollary 5.2 we obtain
Corollary 5.4
Let n >_ O. Then
k, O,
H°mG(HI(Am)'H°(An))-
if m -- - n - 2, otherwise.
A nonzero h o m o m o r p h i s m (~n" H 1 ( A - n - 2 ) ~ H ° (An) i8 given by
{~n(Wi)- (ni)Yn_i,
Corollary 5.5
i--O,...,n.
L e t n e N. If(~ e H o m G ( H I ( / ~ _ n _ 2 ) , H ° ( A n ) ) is nonzero,
then I m (1) - -
Remark
L(An).
Similar computations show that we have for each n _> 0 a G-
homomorphism ~n" N ° ( A n ) + H I ( A - n - 2 ) given by
~n(Vi) -- (n -- i)! i! Wn_ i. The composite (in either order) of/I/n and
6
On
is multiplication by n!.
The Borel-Weil-Bott theorem Let c~ be a simple root. Then we define a subgroup P~ _< G by P~ - B U B s ~ B ,
(6.1)
where (by abuse of notation) we have written s~ also for a representative for s~ E W in N o ( T ) (note that s ~ B is independent of which representative we choose). Now Ind P~ behaves exactly as IndB C in the case G - SL2(k) considered in the previous section. Writing H~ instead of RiInd g~ , we have thus
H. H. Andersen
22 Proposition
Let )~ E X ( T ) .
6.1
Then
i) If i > 1. then H~ ( A ) - O. ii) If (A,(~ v} - n _> - 1 , then H~(A) elements v0, V l , . . . , v. with t~ - (~-
(~-
O, and H(°()~) has a basis of
i)~)(t)~,:,
tET, zEk.
j=O
iii) If (£,c~ v) -
n < -1,
then H ° ( £ ) -
O, and H i ( A ) has a basis of
elements wo, wl . . . , W - n - 2 with twi - ()~- (n + i + 1)a)(t)wi, X-c~(Z)Wi
Notation
6.2
Set p -
--
.
.
t E T,
zJ-iwj.
~1 ~-~ER+ c~. We have then (p,c~ v) -- 1 for all
simple roots a, and we assume p E X ( T ) .
T h e n the dot action of W on
X ( T ) is defined by ~ . ~ - ~ ( ~ + p) - p,
wEW,
)~ E X ( T ) .
If w E W, then we let l(w) denote the length of w, i.e., the length of a reduced expression for w in terms of simple reflections. The aim of this section is to prove the following result, cf. [Bo], [De], or JAn1]. Theorem
6.3
Suppose c h a r ( k ) -
0, and let )~ E X ( T ) .
If w E iV is
chosen such that w(~ + p) E X ( T ) +, then we have G-isomorphisms
{ HO(~.~), m(~)~ O,
if i -
l(~),
otherwise.
Chapter 1
Modular Representations
23
Remark We say that A is singular if there exists c~ E R w i t h (A-+-p, ozv} -0. In this case, w.A ¢_ X ( T ) + and Theorem 6.3 therefore says H i ( A ) - 0 for all i. On the other hand, if A is regular (i.e., nonsingular), then the
E X ( T ) + is unique and w.A C X ( T ) +. So in this
w E Wwithw(A+p)
case there is a unique nonvanishing cohomology group, namely the one in degree l(w). To prove Theorem 6.3 we need two lemmas.
Let A C X ( T ) , and suppose (A,c~v) >_ - 1 for some simple root ct. Then we have a G-isomorphism
Lemma
6.4
Hi(A) ~ H~(G/p~, H°(A)) for all i > O. Proof:
Let 0 --~ A --~ I. be an injective B-resolution of A. Then, since
H ~ ( A ) - 0 for i > 0 (Proposition 6.1), we have that 0 ~ H°(A)--~ H ° ( I . ) is an injective P~-resolution. The injectivity comes from Corollary 1.11(iii). Hence, the right hand side in the lemma is the ith cohomology of the complex H ° ( G / P ~ , H ° ( I . ) ) .
By transitivity (Corollary 1.11(ii)), this complex
is isomorphic to H ° ( I . ) , which has H~(A) as its ith cohomology. [Z]
Let A C X ( T ) , and suppose (A,o~v} _< - 1 for some simple root (~. Then we have G-isomorphisms
Lemma
6.5
Hi(A) ~ H i - I ( G / P ~ , H ~ ( A ) ) for all i >_ 1. Pro@
Let again 0 --~ A ~ I. be an injective B-resolution. By Proposition
6.1 the complex 0 ~ H°(Io) ~ H°(I1) - . . . .
is exact except in degree 1,
where its cohomology is H~ (A). If we set Q - I0/,~ ~ Ker(I1 ~ means that we have exact sequences 0
and
no(z )
/2), this
H. H. Andersen
24
The long exact sequence arising from the first of these gives
Hi(G/P~,HI(A)) ~ Hi(G/P~,H°(Q)) for i _> 1. Arguing as in Lemma 6.4, we get
Hi(G/P~, H°(Q)) ~ Hi+I(A) for all i >_ 0, and we are done. E5
P r o o f of Theorem 6.3: From Proposition 6.1 it follows that if A E X ( T ) has (A,(~ v) >__ - 1 for some simple root a, then H°(A) ~ U~(s~.A) (cf. Corollary 5.4 it is at this point that we use char(k) - 0; otherwise, the binomial coefficients (n) are not necessarily all nonzero, i.e., the ~n are not necessarily isomorphisms). By Lemmas 6.4 and 6.5, we get from this Hi(A) Hi+l(sc~.A ) for all i. Using this repeatedly, we get (with w as ~
stated)
Hi(A) ~ Hi-l(W)(w.A)
for all i.
If i < l(w), we see that Hi(A) - 0. A symmetric argument gives
Hi(A) ~_ Hi+N-l(~)(WoW.A), where N = ]R+I and w0 E W is the maximal element in W (of length l(wo) - N). Hence if i > l(w) we get Hi(A) = 0 by appealing to (4.3) (note that dim G / B - N). E] Remarks i) Theorem 6.3 remains true when char(k) - p > 0 for those A which satisfy (A + p, av) < p for all a E R. The proof goes through unchanged because for such A the relevant binomial coefficients are all prime to p. If p >_ h (the Coxeter number of R), we see in particular that
dim H i ( w . O ) - 5i,z(~) ii) Suppose again char(k) - p
for all i >_ 0, w C W.
(6.2)
>_ h, and let r > 0. Then we have, for all
wEW, { H°((p ~ - 1)p),
Hi(p~w(P) - P) ~-
O,
if/=/(w), otherwise.
(6.3)
Again the proof of Theorem 6.3 goes through (this time the point is that (ap~-l) ~ 0 (mod p) for a l l / - 0, 1 , . . . , ap ~ - 1, a - 1 , . . . p). iii) Actually (6.2) and (6.3) hold also for p < h, cf. [An2, An3]
Chapter 1 Modular Representations 7
25
Serre d u a l i t y a n d c o m p l e t e r e d u c i b i l i t y In this section, we shall prove
Theorem
Let A C X ( T ) .
7.1
Then, for each i > O, there is a G-
isomorphism Hi(A) ~_ H N - i ( - A -
2p)*.
This theorem is a consequence of the Serre duality theorem for locally free sheaves on projective varieties [Ha, III.7]. However, we shall deduce Theorem 7.1 directly from the results of the previous sections. Combining it with Theorem 6.3 we obtain the complete reducibility of all finite dimensional G-modules in characteristic zero. First, let us make sure we agree about dual representations: If V is a representation of G, then G acts on V* = Homk(V, k) via
gf" v ~ f (g-lv),
H N(-2p)
L e m m a 7.2
g E G , v E E f E V*.
~ k.
Proof: This is the w - w0 case of (6.2). [:] Let E and F be two B-modules. Then we have natural Ghomomorphisms
L e m m a 7.3
Hi(E) ® H i (F) ~ H i+j (E ® F) for all i, j > O. Proof: We go by induction on i + j . For i - j - 0, we have the map g ° ( E ) ® H°(F) ~ H ° ( E ® F) given by fl Q f2 ~-+ (g ~-+ f l ( g ) Q f2(g), g e G),
fl e H°(E), f2 e H°(F). Suppose j > 0, and embed F ~ I with I an injective B-module. Then
0 ~ H°(F)~
H°(I)~
H°(I/F)~
H~(F)-~ 0
(7.1)
H. H. Andersen
26
is exact, and for j > 1 we have
Hi(F) ~ HJ-I(I/F).
The last s t a t e m e n t
clearly gives the lemma for j > 1 via the induction hypothesis. To handle the j - 1 case, tensor (7.1) by
Hi(E)
to obtain the commutative d i a g r a m
0
Hi(E) ® H°(F)
,
Hi(E ® F)
H ~(E) ® H ° (I)
,
H ~(E ~ I)
H~(E) ® H ° ( I / r )
, H~(E 0 I/F)
re(E) 0 Hi(r)
m÷l(E ® r)
0 where the columns are exact and the horizontal maps exist by induction hypothesis. We get the desired map
Hi(E)®
H I ( F ) --~ H i + I ( E @ F ) . 7]
Let E be a finite dimensional B-module. The n a t u r a l map E ® E* ~ k t h a t takes e ® f into
f(e)
is clearly a B - h o m o m o r p h i s m . By the previous
two lemmas, we get G - h o m o m o r p h i s m s
OiE"Hi(E)® HN-i(E * ®-2p)
~
HN(--2p)"~ k
for all i _> O. This gives us a G - h o m o m o r p h i s m ~iE" H i (E) ~ H N-i (E* @
Now T h e o r e m 7.1 is a special case of
-2p)*,
(7.2)
Chapter 1 C l a i m 7.4
Proof:
Modular Representations
27
9 ~ is an isomorphism for each i > O.
Consider first the case i -
0 and E -
A C X ( T ) + • Set R -
K e r ( H ° ( 1 ) ~ - ~ l ) . If we tensor the diagram 0-+
RNL(1)~
L(1)
n
n
I
H°(t)~
1
0---+ by - I -
R
--+
-+
1
~
0
~
0
2p and take cohomology, we get
L(1) ® H N ( - l -
2p)
-+
n H°(1) ® H N ( - l -
H N(-2p) ~ k
-+
II 2p)
~
H N ( - 2 p ) _~ k
~
0
where we have used Proposition 4.1 to rewrite the terms on the left and (4.4) to get the 0's on the right. This and a little weight argument (note t h a t all weights of the quotient H ° ( 1 ) / L ( 1 ) are strictly less t h a n I ) prove t h a t 9 o is nonzero when restricted to L(1).
Hence, 9 o is injective (because by T h e o r e m 3.8 we
know t h a t L(1) is the unique irreducible G-invariant subspace of H ° ( 1 ) ) . It is now an easy induction on dim E to check t h a t ~ o is injective for all E. We prove next t h a t 9 ~ is surjective. For t - ( p r - 1 ) p , this follows from (6.3). For arbitrary A E X ( T ) +, we choose r E N such t h a t (p'r-1)p+wo,k E X ( T ) + Note t h a t wo((p ~ - l ) p + w o t ) =-(S-1)p+I is the minimal weight in H°((p " - 1)p + woA), so t h a t we have an exact B-sequence
0 ~ A ~ H°((p r - 1)p + woA)® (p~ - 1)p -+ Q -~ 0. This gives us the diagram 0
1 ,
;
2p) *
+
H°((p " - 1)p + w0A) ®H°((p ~ - 1)p)
'
H°(Q)
,
H°((p r - 1)p + w0A) ®Hg((--p r-
H x (Q* ® - 2 p ) *
1)p)*
H. H. Andersen
28
As we have observed, the middle horizontal map 1 ® ~ is an isomorphism. Since we also know that bottom horizontal map ~ is injective, it follows that ~ is surjective. Again, an easy induction gives that ~ o is surjective for all E. Hence, ~ o is an isomorphism. Standard degree shift arguments show that so are all ~ , i >_ 0. [3 C o r o l l a r y 7.5
Let A, # E X ( T ) +. Any short exact sequence of G-modules 0--~ H°(A)--~ E ~ H°(#) * --~ 0
splits, i.e., ExtlG(H°(p)*, H°(A)) = 0
for all A,# E X ( T ) +.
Proof: Suppose first that A ~ -w0(#). Then A is maximal among the weights of E, and this implies that we have a B-homomorphism E --+ A, see Corollary 3.4. By Frobenius reciprocity (Proposition 1.10) this is the same as a G-homomorphism E ~ H°(A); i.e., we have found a retraction H ° (A) --+ E of the given embedding. If A < - w 0 ( # ) , we dualize the sequence and repeat the previous argument. [] Combining Serre duality and the Borel-Weil-Bott theorem, we obtain the following classical result. T h e o r e m 7.6
Suppose char(k) - 0.
i) H°(A) is an irreducible representation of G for all A C X ( T ) +. ii) Any finite dimensional representation of G is completely reducible. Proof: i) By Theorems 6.3 and 7.1, we have H°(A) ~- H N (wo.£) ~- g ° ( - w o A ) *. Now we know already that H°(A) has a unique irreducible G-invariant submodule L(A) (Theorem 3.8(i)). The displayed isomorphism shows that L(A) is also the only irreducible G-quotient of H°(A). It follows that H°(A) L(A). =
ii) follows from (i) and Corollary 7.5. [--]
Chapter 1 Modular Representations Remark
29
The results in Theorem 7.6 remain true in char(k) = p > 0
if we require (A + p , a v) _< p for all a E R+ in (i), resp., if the same condition holds for all weights in the representation in (ii). On the other hand, the results fail without this bound: For SL2(k) we have, for instance,
L()~p) =/=H°(Ap), p = char(k). 8
Frobenius kernels and their representations In the previous sections we have been working with the "pedestrian"
definition of an algebraic group given in Definition 1.1.
When dealing
with algebraic groups over more general fields and rings (e.g., Z) or when considering infinitesimal groups (like the ones we are going to introduce shortly), we need a better definition: D e f i n i t i o n 8.1
Let R be a commutative ring.
By an
algebraic group
over R, we understand a functor G from the category of R-algebras into the category of groups such that there exists an R-algebra type over R (i.e.,
R[G] of finite
R[G] is a quotient of a polynomial ring in finitely many
variable over R) for which we have
G(A) = HomR_alg(R[G], A) for all R-algebras A. We shall call R[G] the coordinate ring of G. Then the definition says that an algebraic group is a representable functor from the category of Ralgebras into the category of groups (with a coordinate ring of finite type). The coordinate ring is a Hopf algebra over R.
It clearly determines G
uniquely. When R = k is an algebraically closed field, an algebraic group over
G(k) = Homk_alg(k[G],k). In fact, k[G] G(k) is nothing but (the closed points in) the affine variety defined by k[G]. In the k is determined by its k-points,
may be identified with the set of regular functions on G(k), since previous sections we have just been working with these k-points.
When S is an R-algebra and G is an algebraic group over R, we can define an algebraic group G s over S by extensions of scalars as follows: Gs(A) = G ( A )
H. H. Andersen
30
for all S-algebras A. Note that S[Gs] = RIG] ®R S. On the other hand we say that an algebraic group H over S is defined
over R if there exists an algebraic group H0 over R with H = H0s. Examples
8.2
i) The additive group ~a
R is defined by
over
Ga(A):(A,+) for any R-algebra A. Note that R[G] = R[T], where T is an indeterminate. ii) The multiplicative group Gm over R is defined by Gm(A)=(A×,
.)
for any R-algebra A. (Here A × denotes the set of units in A.) We have R[Gm] = R[T, T-~]. iii) The general linear group over R is given by GLn(A)-
{(aij)i,j=l .....n E Mn(A) I det(aij) 6 A ×}
for any R-algebra A.
For this algebraic group, we have R[GLn] =
R[Xij, T]/(T det(Xij) - 1). We leave it as an exercise for the reader to generalize the other algebraic groups we have encountered in the previous sections and to compute their coordinate rings (as well as to verify that the notation k[G] in Definition 1.3 is consistent with the conventions just given). Likewise, the various definitions and constructions found in the previous sections also generalize.
Let us give the details in the case of the
construction of induced modules: Let G be an algebraic group over k, and suppose V is a vector space over k. Then a representation of G on V is a morphism of functors between the two algebraic groups G and GL(V).
Here the latter is the algebraic
group whose value on a k-algebra A is the set of A-automorphisms of V®k A. If now H is a subgroup of G (i.e., H is itself an algebraic group, and
H(A) <_ G(A) for all k-algebras A), we shall construct a functor IndCH • {Representations of H} ~ {Representations of G},
Chapter 1 Modular Representations
31
which is a right adjoint of the restriction functor. Suppose M is a representation of H. Let Ma denote the functor
]Via: { k-algebras } --~ { k-modules }, A~MQA. We then define I n d C H ( M ) - {f e Mor(G, Ma) ] f A ( g h ) -
h-lfA(g),
for all g E G(A), h G H(A), and all k-algebras A}.(8.1) Here, fA: G(A) --~ Ma(A) denotes the A-component of f. Note that IndCH(M) is a representation of G via x e G(R), g e G(A), f E Mor(G, Ma)® A,
(gf)R: x ~ fR(g-lx),
for any k-algebra A and any A-algebra R (we identify Mor(G, M a ) ® A with
Mor(GA,MQA)). We have M ® k[G] -- Ma(k[G]) -~ Mor(G, Ma), and using this we get Ind/~(M) - (M ® k[G]) H,
(8.2)
where H acts on M ® k[G] via the given action on M and the right regular representation on k[G], see Example 1.6(iv)(a) (properly generalized). Our purpose in this and the next two sections is to explore the representations of Frobenius kernels. These are certain subgroup functors of G whose only point over the field k is 1: We continue to assume that k is an algebraically closed field and that G is a connected reductive algebraic group over k, but now this is considered as an algebraic group in the new sense (whose k-points form a connected reductive algebraic group in the old sense).
From now on, we assume
p = char(k) to be positive.
i Suppose A is a k-algebra. Let k ~ A be the structure map. Then, for
each r C Z, we define a new k-algebra A (r) by setting A (r) = A as a ring
H. H. Andersen
32
and choosing the composite k~-2fki-~A as the new structure map. Here, F is the Frobenius homomorphism on k, i.e., F(x) - x p, x C k. If X is a functor from {k-algebras} into {Sets}, then we denote by X (r) the functor given by
X(~)(A) - X(A(-r)),
A e {k-algebras}.
The r t h Frobenius morphism on X is the morphism x
x
given by
F~:(A)" X ( A ) X ~ ) X ( A where "yr"A ~
(-~))
A (-r) is the k-algebra homomorphism that takes a into
a p~, a C A . W h e n we apply this to G, we obtain in particular the Frobenius hom o m o r p h i s m F~" G --~ G (r). This is clearly a homomorphism of algebraic groups. Definition
8.3
Gr - Ker(F~). Similarly, we have Frobenius subgroups Tr, Br, Ur, etc., of the subgroups T, B, U of G. From now on, we shall assume that all our groups are defined over Fp C k. Since F is the identity on Fp, this assumption implies that G (r) = G for all r. We thus have an exact sequence of algebraic groups: 1 ~ Gr ~ G ~
G ~ 1.
(8.3)
It turns out that the representation theory for Gr is quite similar to the one for G. W i t h o u t worrying too much about details and proofs (the reader is referred to [Ja] for these), we now give some of the highlights.
Chapter 1 Modular Representations Definition
8.4
33
For any B~-module E, we set
Z~(E) - IndCB~E. One big difference between the induction functor Z~ and the "global" version H ° (induction from B to G) is that (8.4)
Zr is an exact functor.
The reason is that G~/B~ is affine, namely G~/B~ ~_ U¢, so that all higher sheaf cohomology of bundles on G~/Br vavishes. This fact also gives
(8.5)
dim Z~ (E) = pNr dim E, because dim k[U¢] = pN~ (cf. Fact 2.6(iii)). In analogy with Theorems 3.8 and 3.9, we have Theorem
8.5
Let A E X(T).
i) Z~()~) contains a unique irreducible Gr-submodule, which we denote Lr()~). ii) Any finite dimensional simple G~-module is isomorphic to some such L~()~). iii) If also # E X ( T ) , then L~()~) ~_ Lr(#) iff A - # (mod p X ( T ) ) . Definition
8.6
Set
Xp~(T) = {A E X(T) I 0 _< (A, av> < p" for all simple roots a}. The elements in this set are called the p~-restricted weights. Note that any A E X ( T ) can be written uniquely
)~ = )~0 + pr)~l
with )~0 E Xpr(T),
)k 1 E
X(T).
(8.6)
Note that prA1 is trivial as a Gr-module. Hence Z~(A) _~ Z~()~°) and L~(A) _~ L~(A°). This explains the if-part of Theorem 8.5(iii), which can be rephrased The finite dimensional simple Gr-modules are parametrized by the set of p~-restricted weights. Now comes the surprise:
(8.7)
H. H. Andersen
34 T h e o r e m 8.7
If )~ e Xp~(T), then L~()~) ~_ L(~X)Ia..
For r = 1 this result goes back to Curtis [Cu]. It may be proved by closely examining the natural G~-homomorphism N°(A) -~ Z~(~) (this idea is due to G. Kempf [Ke2]). Alternatively, see [Ja, II.3.15]. For many purposes it is convenient to develop an analogous theory for the subgroup schemes G~T and G~B. Note that
G~T = (F~)-I (T) and
G~B = ( r h ) - ~ ( B ) . We shall use the notation 2~ (resp., Z~) for the induction functor from {B~T-modules} to {G~T-modules} (resp., from {B-modules} to {a B-modul s}). Th n we T h e o r e m 8.8
Let A E X ( T ) .
i) Z~(A) (resp., Z~(A)) contains a unique simple G~T-submodule (resp., G,.B-submodule), which, we denote L~ (~) (resp., L~ (~)). ii) Any finite dimensional simple G~T-module (resp., G~B-module) is isomorphic to some such (unique!) L~(.k) (resp., L~ (~)). iii) L~(A)IG ~ ~_ L~(A) ~_ L~(A)IG,. One advantage of G~T-modules over G~-modules is that we may consider their (formal) characters. In particular, we can therefore pose the P r o b l e m 8.9
Determine ch Lr(&) for ~ e X ( T ) , r ¢ N.
Note that by the preceding, ~,r(A) _~ L(/~ °) ®
pr)tl,
and hence this
problem is equivalent to Problem 3.11. It turns out that the crucial case is the case r = 1; see [Ja].
9
Injective GrT-modules We keep the assumptions from Section 8.
Chapter 1 Modular Representations P r o p o s i t i o n 9.1
35
The category of finite dimensional G~T-modules has
enough injectives. Proof." Let M be a finite dimensional G~T-module. We have to find a finite dimensional injective GrT-module I containing M. Recall that M is injective as a T-module (this follows immediately from Proposition 2.3). Hence I - IndTa~TM is an injective G rT-module, see Corollary 1.11(iii). Moreover, I is finite dimensional (the dimension being given by a formula analogous to (8.5)). By Frobenius reciprocity, the identity M ~ M induces a G~T-injection M --~ I. [:] D e f i n i t i o n 9.2
Let A E X(T). Then we set Q~(A)equal to the injective
hull of L~(A). Note that by Proposition 9.1 (or rather its proof) we have (~(A) C Indra~TL, r(A). Hence, by injectivity, Q~ (A) is a direct summand of IndTa'TL~ (A).
(9.1)
D e f i n i t i o n 9.3 A G
c F.~ = M
in such a way that Fi/Fi-1 ~ 2~(Ai) for certain A~: E X(T). When M has a 2~-filtration we denote by []VI" Zr(#)] the number of times 2~(#) occurs in such a filtration; i.e., in the preceding notation
[M- 2<(p)]- #{i I A{ = p}. E x a m p l e 9.4 BrT-filtration
Let V be a finite dimensional BrT-module. Then V has a 0--
Vo C V 1 C
"'" C Vt -
V
with V i / ~ - i -~ Ai for certain Ai C X ( T ) (this is the same argument as in Corollary 3.4). Applying the exact functor Z~, we obtain a Z~-filtration of Z~V.
In other words, any G~T-module that is induced from a finite
dimensional B~T-module has a Zr-filtration. Moreover, [ 2 r V - 2~(#)] - dim V,.
H. H. Andersen
36
P r o p o s i t i o n 9.5 Let A e X(T). Then Q~(A) has a Z~-filtration, and for each # E X(T) we have
[Q~(~). 2~(~)1- [2~(~). L~(~)] (the latter symbol denoting composition factor multiplicity). Proof." Note that IndTG~T -- 2r o Ind B~T. Hence the first statement is a consequence of (9.1) and Example 9.4. To prove the second half, we first need some preparation: Let B' denote the opposite Borel subgroup; i.e., B' = woBwo, where w0 is (a representative in G of) the longest element in W. Set 2 ' - I n d ~ T T. Then, clearly, Z~ has properties completely analogous to Z~. Elementary weight considerations show ch 2~(A) - ch 2'~(A- 2 ( / -
1)p)
(9.2)
for all A E X(T). We now have
Let A,# E X(T). Then k, i f # - A + 2 ( p r - 1 ) p , i) Homa~T(2'~(A),2~(tt)) ~ O, otherwise.
L e m m a 9.6
ii) Ext~T(2'~(A), 2~(#)) -- 0. Proof: (ii) is proved just as Corollary 7.5 noticing that the (contravariant) dual of Z~(A) is isomorphic to Zr(A + 2 ( / - 1)p). This also implies (i) via Frobenius reciprocity and some easy weight considerations. [3
Proof of Proposition 9.5 (continued): From Lemma 9.6, it follows that [M" 2 ~ ( , ) ] - dimHomG~T(Z'r(#- 2 ( / -
1)p), M)
for any G~T-module M that has a Z~-filtration. Combining this with the equation
IV. L~(A)] - dimHomc~T(V, Q~(A)), valid for any finite dimensional G~T-module V, we are done because of (9.2). I-1 The equality in Proposition 9.5 is known as the Brauer-Humphreys reciprocity law. It shows that Problem 8.9 (or 3.11) is equivalent to the following:
Chapter 1 Modular Representations P r o b l e m 9.7 C o r o l l a r y 9.8
37
Determine ch Or(A) for all )~ e X(T). L((p r - 1 ) p ) - 2~((p ~ - 1)p) - Q ~ ( ( p ~ - 1)p).
Proof: By Lemma 9.6(i) we have a nontrivial homomorphism from the module Zr~(-(p r - 1)p)* to the module Zr((p r - 1)p). But the first (resp., second) module has L((p r - 1)p) as its unique simple quotient (resp., submodule), and so the first equality follows. The last equality is then a consequence of Proposition 9.5 (combined with the fact that all Zr(A) have the same dimension). Z] The irreducible G-module L((p r - 1)p) is known as the r t h Steinberg module and also denoted Str. By Corollary 9.8, it is an irreducible injective and induced (from BrT) GrT-module. The standard argument shows that injectivity is preserved when tensoring by an arbitrary finite dimensional module. It is then easy to see that for any )~ C Xr(T) we have an isomorphism of GrT-modules,
Str @ L((pr - 1 ) p + wo)~) ~- (~r(A) ® (~> (~r(#) "~)
(9.3)
for certain m~ > 0. In other words, (~r(A) appears as a distinguished GrTsummand of this tensor product. For p > 2 ( h - 1) it is known also to be a G-summand, whereas for smaller p the question of a G-structure on (~r(A) is still open; see [Ja, 11.11]. 10
Kempf's vanishing theorem
The Frobenius morphisms F~ and the Steinberg modules Str, r >_ 0, from the last sections are used here to prove the following. Theorem
10.1 ([Kel])
Let )~ E X(T) +. Then H~(~)-0
for/>0.
Note that in characteristic zero this result is a special case of the Borel-Weil-Bott theorem 6.3. So, as in the previous two sections, we shall assume char(k) - p > 0.
H. H. Andersen
38 D e f i n i t i o n 10.2
Let V be a representation of G. Then we define V (r)
to be the representation of G on the same vector space but with G-action given by g v -
F~(g)v, g E G, v E V.
We shall derive Theorem 10.1 from
Let E be a B-module. Then, for any r > O, we have an isomorphism of G-modules
Theorem
10.3
Hi(E(r) ® ( p r _ 1 ) p ) ~ Hi(E)(r) ® Str. Proof: Since H ° - IndaB -- IndaaB o Zr and since 2r is an exact functor (8.2), which takes injective B-modules into acyclic modules for IndaaB (in fact, into injective GrB-modules, see Corollary 1.11(iii)), we have
H ~ - H~(G/GrB, 2 r ( - ) ) . Now 2 r ( E ( r ) ® ( p r - 1 ) p ) - E ( r ) ® 2 r ( ( p r - 1 ) p ) - E ( r ) ® S t r , the first equality being the tensor identity for Zr and the second coming from Corollary 9.8. Hence, the tensor identity for H i ( G / G r B , - )
gives
Hi(E(r) @ ( p r _ 1 ) p ) ~ Hi(G/GrB, E (r)) ® Str, and we are done if we show that
H i ( G / G r B , E (r)) ~ Hi(E) (r).
(10.1)
One checks this easily for i - 0. To do the obvious dimension shift., we need to check that H i ( G / G r B , I (r)) - 0 for i > 0 whenever I is an injective B-module. In fact, it is enough to consider I -
k[B], and since k[B] (r) -~
Indaa;B(k) we have H i ( O / O r B , k[B] (r)) ~ Hi(G/Or, k). Induction from Gr to G is exact (because G/Gr ~ G is affine), and we are done. [3
P r o o f of T h e o r e m 10.1" By Theorem 10.3 we have, for all ,~ C X ( T ) , Hi(A) (~) ® St~ __ Hi(p~(A + p) - p), and for r >> 0, A E X ( T ) + the right hand side vanishes whenever i > 0. This is so because the line bundle £ ( ~ + p) on G / B is ample when A E X ( T ) + ; see [Ha, III.5.2]. [-1
Chapter 1 Modular Representations
39
Let I E X ( T ) +. Then
C o r o l l a r y 10.4 (Weyl's character formula)
ch H°(1) = J(e~+P)/J(eP),
where J is the Z-endomorphism on J(e~) - E
Z[X(T)] given
by
p E X(T).
(-1)l(W)eW(~)'
wEW
Proof: By Theorem 10.1 we have ch H ° (A) = ~--~i( - 1)ich Hi(1). The rest is standard; see, e.g., [Ja, II.5.10]. [3
11
Q u a n t u m groups
In this section we introduce quantum groups and briefly sketch how many of the preceding results in the representation theory for algebraic groups have quantized counterparts. Let (aij)i,j=l .....n be a Cartan matrix, and choose a set of relatively prime integers d l , . . . , dn such that (diaij) is symmetric. Fix also an indeterminate v, and set vi = v d~, i = 1 , . . . , n . If m C N we write [m] = (v m - v - m ) / ( V - - V - I ) and [m]! = [ m ] [ m - 1]... [2][1]. For t C N, we set [t] - [m][m - 1]-.. [m - t + 1]/[t]!. We write [m]i, [m]i!, and [~]i for the corresponding expressions with v replaced by vi. D e f i n i t i o n 11.1 The quantum group attached to (aij) is the Q(r)-algebra U with generators Ei, Fi, Ki, K/--I, i = 1 , . . . , n, and relations i) K i K ( -1 = 1 = K ~ I K i and KiKj = K j K i ii) K i E j K ( -1 - v ia i j Ej, iii) EiFj - FjEi
iv/
z r+s=l--aij
v)
E
K i F j K i -1
gi-gi -
~ij
-- v-iaiJFj
-1
vi -
-1 v i
8
i
(-1)s [1-aiJ 1 F[FjF~-O,
r+s--1--aij
8
i#j
i
It turns out that U is a Hopf algebra with comultiplication A given by A ( K i ) - Ki®Ki,
A ( E ~ ) - Ei®I+K~®Ei,
A(Fi) - Fi®K~ - l + l ® F i ,
H. H. Andersen
40 coidentity e given by
e(Ki) = 1,
=
and antipode S given by
S ( K i ) -- K[ -1,
S(Ei)-m--K[-1Ei,
Set now A = Z[v, v - l ] , a n d let generated by Ki,K~ 1, E} m) , F (m) , i Em/[rn]i! and similarly for F (m).
S(Fi) - - - F i K i.
UA denote the A-subalgebra of U 1 n, m C N, where E} m) , ' ' ' ,
If q is a nonzero element in some field F, then F becomes a A-algebra by specializing v to q, and we define
UF, q = UA @A F. Sometimes we write just
UF or Uq instead of gF, q. By the preceding, UF is
a Hopf algebra. It is called the q u a n t u m group over F associated with (aij). Of course, this construction makes sense also for any commutative ring F and q E F a unit. However, we shall here always assume that F is a field, and in fact for simplicity we only consider fields of characteristic zero. For instance, we may take F = C and let q be a nonzero complex number. By abuse of notation, we shall write F/(m), etc., also for the elements in Uq corresponding to
F.(,m), etc. E UA.
We have
- v: vov:,
where Uq (resp., U +) is the subalgebra of E}m)), i -
1,...,n,
Uq generated by F.(,m) (resp.,
rn E N, and U ° is the subalgebra generated by
Ki, KC 1, [K~;c], i - - 1 , . . . , n, c, t E N. Here, [K~.c] is the element
[K~;c]- l~i Ki vc+l-j Ki-lv-i -c-l+j j=l Vi _ Vi 2 Let R be the root system associated with the set of simple roots.
(aij), and let
O ~ 1 , . . . ,OZn
be
Set X equal to the set of integral weights, i.e.,
X - - Z n where A C X is an n-tuple A = (/~1,...,/~n) with Ai = (A, ai}, i =
Chapter 1
41
Modular Representations
1 , . . . , n. Such a weight gives rise to a character of U° (and hence of U°) via
If V is a U°-module and • E tU/ °, we set L/
v~ - {~ e v l ~ -
~(~)~, ~ e Uq°}.
It turns out (but this is a nontrivial fact; see, e.g., [APW, Section 9]) that any finite dimensional Uq-module V (of type 1) is a sum of weight spaces (note that replacing vi by - v i in the foregoing formulas defines an equally good character )~ and type 1 simply means that we work with all signs positive). We shall consider a slightly more general category of Uqmodules. Namely, define fq to be the category consisting of all Uq-modules V that satisfy i) V = ( ~ e z V~. ii) For every v C V, we have F(m)v - E}m)v - 0 for all m >> 0, i 1,...,n. Note that if V is arbitrary, then F(V) =
{v E e
V,x r.,i
v-
v-O,
m >> O, i - 1 , . . . , n
,~EX
}
is a Uq-submodule of V. By definition, F ( V ) E fq. Let f q (resp., fro) be the category obtained in the same way when we replace Uq by Uq U° (resp., U°). D e f i n i t i o n 11.2
The induction functor H°.¢~ - ~ Cq
is defined by Hqo (V) = F ( H o m G- uo (Uq, V)),
v~¢;.
Here, Uq is considered a UqU°-module via left multiplication, and the Uq-structure on H ° ( V ) comes via right multiplication on Uq" u . f : x ~ f(xu),
x , u 6 Uq, f C H ° ( V ) .
H. H. Andersen
42
It is straightforward to check that H ° satisfies Frobenius reciprocity, etc. We leave to the reader the task of verifying that the results from Section 4 on remain true when we add index q. One result, which is not clear how to quantize, is (4.4). We shall now indicate how one may derive the special case of this that we need from the classical case: Let Z be the A-algebra obtained by specializing v to 1. Choose also q E k (where k is an algebraically closed field of characteristic p > 0 as in previous sections) such that q is a primitive lth root of unity (so p ~ 1). Specializing v to q, we have made k into an A-algebra. 11.3 There exists a Hopf algebra homomorphism .7":Uk Uz ® k determined by
Proposition
E} rn/l) (~ 1, ~(E[m))-
if lira , otherwise,
0,
{ F{ ~/t) ® 1, -
if lira,
0,
5~(K?l) - K ? I ( ~ 1, i-
1,...,n.
Proof: [Lul, Lu2]. Let now U denote the enveloping algebra over Q for the semisimple Lie algebra corresponding to (aij). Denote the standard generators of 0 by /~i,/~i, i - 1 , . . . , n , and set /ti - [/~i,/~i]. The Kostant Z-form of U- is the Z-subalgebra of 0 generated by /~r),/~i!r), i - 1 , . . . , n, where E~) - E~/r! and similarly for/~/(~);see [Hul, Section 26]. Proposition
11.4
There is a Hopf algebra isomorphism (]z--%Uz/({Ki- 1 1 i -
1 , . . . , n})
given by /~r) H image of E~r), /~(~) ~ /ti ~
image of F (~), image of [K/l; 0 ] .
Chapter 1 Modular Representations
43
Proof: [Lul, Lu2]. [--1 Let now 9~: Ua. ---, Uz ® k be the composite obtained from Propositions 11.3 and 11.4. If we then start by a representation V of the algebraic group G over k corresponding to (aij), then this representation is also a module for the so-called hyperalgebra Uz ® k. Hence V gives rise via Y to a module for Uk. We denote this Uk-module by V It]. Imitating the arguments for (10.1) we obtain
Proposition 11.5
H q i(vl;3)
~ H~(V)I;3
,
i _> o.
We can now prove the quantized version of the special case H1 = B, He - G Theorem
Proof:
of (4.4)" 11.6
i Let A e X(T). Then Hq(A) - O f o r i > N.
Let uk be the subalgebra of Uk generated by E i , F i , K ~ 1, i U~u~,
1 , . . . , n. (This corresponds to GI C G.) Set Zq -IndcU/-g°A
" T h e n Zq is
an exact functor, and we have
i H~(a) - H i ( U ~ / U [ U ~ °u~= Zq(A)). ,
Let Lq(#) be a U~U°uk-composition factor of Zq(A).
Then Lq(#) Lq(# °) ® l# 1, where # - # o + 1#1 with #o E Xz (i.e., 0 < #o < l, i 1 , . . . , n). Hence, by Proposition 11.5, we have
H i ( U k l U k U ~o k , L q ( ~ ) )
~ L~ (/_to) @ H i ( #1 ) [l] .
Now (4.4) gives H i ( p 1 ) = 0 for i > N, and we are done. [Z] Remark
From Theorem 11.6, it is a standard base change argument to
derive
H~(~)-
0
for ~ni > N.
It follows that the vanishing H~(A) - 0 for i > N also holds for q any nonzero element in any field F. Let us return to the case where F - C
and q E C\{0}. I f q i s not a
root of unity, the Borel-Weil-Bott theorem holds for Uq and hence Lq(A) -
H. H. Andersen
44
H°(A) for all A e X ( T ) +. Moreover, in this situation ~q is semisimple (as it follows from that theorem combined with quantized Serre duality, cf. Theorem 7.6). So suppose q is a primitive /th root of unity.
Then we have as an
analog of Problem 3.11
Problem
11.7
Determine ch Lq()~), A C X +.
Now Lusztig has conjectured that if 1 - p _> h (h denoting the Coxeter number of R), then ch Lq()~)
-
ch L(A)
for all A e Xp(T).
(11.1)
This conjecture has recently been proved ([AJS]) for p >> 0. Moreover, work of Kazhdan and Lusztig [KL] relates Problem 11.7 to a similar problem for affine Lie algebras. Early in 1994 Kashiwara and Tanisaki announced a solution of this latter problem [KT], and hence Problem 11.7 is also solved (although there still seems to be some problem if (aij) is not symmetric) for all 1. The proof of (11.1) in [AJS] (for p :>> 0) involves the "dual" approach of injective modules, :see Problem 9.7. We conclude this section with a few remarks on injective modules for Uq. Set Stz = L q ( ( l - 1)p) (We are again in the situation where q E C is a n / t h root of 1. For simplicity, we shall assume that 1 is odd.) Then Stl is injective in ~q (this is in contrast with the situation for representations of G in characteristic p > 0, where no finite dimensional representation is ever injective). Considering Stl ® Lq()~), )~ E Xz, we obtain (compare Corollary 9.8)
For each )~ e Xt, the injective hull Qq(A) of Lq(£) in Eq is finite dimensional. In fact, Qq()~) is a distinguished summand of Stq ® Lq(wo)~ + ( 1 - 1)p).
Proposition
11.8
We also have a Brauer-Humphreys reciprocity law for the Qq()~):
Chapter 1 D e f i n i t i o n 11.9
Modular Representations
45
A Uq-module M is said to have a good filtration if there
exists a filtration by Uq-submodules
O=FoCFlC...cF~=M with Fi/Fj_ 1
~
H°(/~i) for certain hi e X +, i -
1 , . . . ,s. The number of
times a given H°(#) occurs in such a filtration is denoted [ M ' H ° ( # ) ] .
Let A C X1. Then Qq(A) has a good filtration and
P r o p o s i t i o n 11.10
[Qq()~) . H°q(#)] - [H°(p) . Lq()~)].
12
Tilting modules In this section we shall give a short account of the theory of tilting
modules for algebraic groups, as well as for quantum groups. We will use the language of algebraic groups leaving it in most cases to the reader to quantize the results by adding the index q. Whenever this quantization is not straightforward, we have added a note or a remark. We shall assume that G is a connected reductive group over an algebraically closed field k. The corresponding quantum group is Uq, where q E C is a n / t h root of unity, 1 odd. D e f i n i t i o n 12.1 A finite dimensional representation M of G is called a tilting module if both M and M* have good filtrations (see Definition 11.9). (The dual module M* in the quantum case has Uq-action given by u f ( m ) = f ( S ( u ) m ) , u e Uq, f e M*, m e M.) Examples
12.2
Since H°(0) - k, the trivial module is a tilting mod-
ule. The same is true more generally whenever H°(A) is irreducible (because then H°(A) * = L(A)* ~_ L(-w0A) = H°(-w0A)).
Elementary
weight considerations show that H°(£) is irreducible for all p whenever )~ is minuscule. By the linkage principle [An1], the same is true, e.g., for = (pC={ucX
1)p and for ~ in the upper closure of the fundamental alcove + I ( u + p , aV) < p f o r a l l a c R + } .
H. H. Andersen
46
Let us denote by £t the category of tilting modules. It is easy to see that £t is closed under finite direct sums and under extensions (but not under formation of submodules and quotients). It is not trivial to see that it is also closed under tensor products: T h e o r e m 12.3 If_M1, M2 E £t, then also M1 ® M2 E G. (The Uq-action on tensor products is obtained via the comultiplication A" Uq ---, Uq C~ Uq.) This theorem was proved by Wang [Wa], Donkin [Do], and Mathieu
[Ma]. A proof (taking care of also the quantum case) using Lusztig's canonical bases was written down by Paradowski [Pal. T h e o r e m 12.4 i) For each A C X ( T ) +, there exists an indecomposable tilting module D(A) with highest weight A. Moreover, dimD(A)~ - 1. ii) The modules {D(A) [ A e X ( T ) +} .form a complete set of inequivalent indecomposable tilting modules.
Proof: (This theorem is due to Ringel [Ri] in a somewhat more general context.) We give a proof which only works for p not too small, namely we assume that H°(a;) C G for all fundamental weights a~. For p > h + 6 this is OK by Example 12.2, because then all fundamental weights ~ belong to the fundamental alcove C). (i) Write A - - E i=1 n a i, ~ , where ~Zl,.. . : a;,. are the fundamental weights By our assmnption and Theorem 12.3, H°(a;1)®al®...QHO(~dn)®an belongs to G, and since this module has highest weight A and this occurs with multiplicity 1, we find D(A) as an indecomposable summand. (ii) Let M E £t, and pick a maximal weight A of M. Thus, we have a B-homomorphism M ~ A (see Corollary 3.4), and by Frobenius reciprocity (Proposition 1.10) this gives a G-homomorphism M - G H ° ( A ) . Since M has a good filtration, this must be a surjection. On the other hand, we 71- t
also have a surjection D(A)--* H°(A). Since E x t ~ ( H ° ( # ) *, H°(A)) - 0 (see Corollary 7.5), we obtain G-homomorphisms ¢: M --* D ( A ) a n d ¢': D(A) M making the diagrams
M
~
H°
¢
D(a)
H°
Chapter 1 Modular Representations
47
commutative. Since ¢ o ¢~ is nonzero on the 1-dimensional space D(A)A, we conclude that D(A) is a summand of M, and we are done. [-1 E x a m p l e s 12.5
i) D(0) = k.
ii) D((p- 1 ) p ) = St1. iii) D ( A ) = H°(A) for all ~ E C. iv) Let A~ E C ~, where C ~ is the alcove obtained from reflecting C in the {~ E X ] (~ + p,a~)} - p }
wall H short root
(here, a0 E R+ is the highest
we are assuming that R is indecomposable). Then we
have an exact sequence 0 ~ H°(A)~
D ( , ~ ' ) ~ H°(A ') ~ 0,
where/~ = S~o.A' + pet. Problem
12.6
Determine ch D(A) for all ~ E X ( T ) +.
To convince you that Problem 12.6 is an interesting (and hard) problem, we prove P r o p o s i t i o n 12.7 Let )~ E Xl. Then Qq(£) = Dq(2(1- 1)p + w0A). (Contrary to our usual convention we have stated this result in its quantized version. The reason is that we have no finite dimensional injective G-modules although it is possible to define G-modules that behave like the Qq()~) by putting an upper bound on the weights allowed.) I
Proof: Proposition 11.10 says that Qq()~) has a good filtration. Since Stl is self-dual, we see that Qq(/~)* is also injective (cf. the construction of Qq()~) in Proposition 11.8), and hence Qq()~)* has also a good filtration. Thus, Qq(A) E ~t. By construction, we furthermore see that Qq()~) has highest weight 2 ( / - 1)p + w0£ and that this weight occurs with multiplicity 1. [2] We conclude by some results whose quantized version play a role in the construction of invariants of 3-manifolds by Reshetikhin and Turaev [RT]. The key is Theorem Enda(M). Tr(f) =0.
Let M E et, and suppose f e If M has no summands of the form D(,~) where /~ E C, then
12.8 ((JAn4, Theorem 3.4]))
H. H. Andersen
48
(In the quantum case, we (of course) have to use the quantum trace Trq. It is defined by T r q ( f ) = Tr(K2pf).)
Proof." By Theorem 12.4 we immediately reduce to the case M = D(A) with A C X(T)+\C. Moreover, since D ( A ) i s indecomposable, any f C E n d a ( D ( A ) ) may be written f = a . Id + f ' for some a E k and some nilpotent f ' E Enda(D(A)). Since T r ( f ' ) = 0, we have reduced the theorem to the following statement: If A e X(T)+\C, then Pl dim D(A).
(12.1)
By Weyl's dimension formula, [Hul, Corollary 24.3], we have dim H ° (#) -- 1-I
+ p' c~v) ~eR+ (#
In particular, we see that if # is p-singular (i.e., PI(# + P, c~v} for some c~ e R+), then pldimH°(#) (we assume
For any two finite dimensional G-modules M and N with M indecomposable, we have
Lemma
12.9
p[ dim M =~ Pl dim Q
for all G-summands Q of M ® N.
Proof: Exercise (Hint: look at Tr(¢) for ¢ E E n d a ( M ® N)). [--] Theorem 12.8 allows us to define a new tensor product on {t. First, let for M C {t the integers (a~(M))~X(T)+ be determined by
M-
@ AEX(T)+
Then ha(M) = 0 for all but finitely many A E X(T) +.
Chapter 1
Definition 12.10 fined by
Modular Representations
49
Let M1, M2 C ~t. The reduced tensor product is de-
M1 ~ M2 -- ( ~ D(,~) a~(Ml®M2) AEC
Proposition 12.11
® is associative.
Proof: Use Theorem 12.8. E] For further results in this direction, see, e.g., [AP].
References
[Anl]
H. H. Andersen, The first cohomology group of a line bundle on G / B , Invent. Math. 51 (1979), 287-296.
[An2]
~ , The strong linkage principle, J. reine angew. Math. 315 (1980), 53-59.
JAn3]
~ , The Frobenius morphism on the cohomology of homogeneous vector bundles on G / B , Ann. of Math. (2) 112 (1980), 113121.
[An4]
, Tensor products of quantized tilting modules, Comm. Math. Phys. 149 (1992), 149-159.
[AJSI
H. H. Andersen, J. C. Jantzen, and W. Soergel, Representations of quantum groups at a p-th root of unity and of semisimple groups in characteristic p: independence of p, Asterisque 220 (1994).
[AP]
H. H. Andersen and J. Paradowski, Fusion categories arising from semisimple Lie algebras, Comm. Math. Phys. 169 (1995), 563-588.
[APW]
H. H. Andersen, P. Polo, and K. Wen, Representations of quantum algebras, Invent. Math. 104 (1991), 1-59.
[Bo]
R. Bott, Homogeneous vector bundles, Ann. of Math. (2), 66 (1957), 203-248.
[Cu]
C. W. Curtis, Representations of Lie algebras of classical type with applications to linear groups, J. Math. Mech. 9 (1960), 307-326.
[De]
M, Demazure, A very simple proof of Bott's theorem, Invent. Math. 33 (1976), 271-272.
50
H. H. Andersen
[Do]
S. Donkin, Rational representations of algebraic groups, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1140, Springer-Verlag, 1985.
[Ha]
R. Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 52, Springer-Verlag, 1977.
[Hull
J. E. Humphreys, Introduction to Lie Algebras and Representation Theory, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 9, Springer-Verlag, 1972.
[H,,2]
, Linear Algebraic Groups, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 21, Springer-Verlag, 1975.
[Ja]
J. C. Jantzen, Representations of Algebraic Groups, Academic Press, 1987.
[KT]
M. Kashiwara and T. Tanisaki, Characters of the negative level highest weight modules for affine Lie algebras,Int. Math. Res. Not. 1994, 151-160.
[KL]
D. Kazhdan and G. Lusztig, Tensor structures arising .from. afifine Lie algebras, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 6 (1993), 905-947, 949-1011:7 (1994), 335-381,383-453.
[Kel]
G. Kempf, Linear systems on homogeneous spaces, Ann. of Math. (2), 103 (1976), 557-591.
[Ke2]
~ , Representations of algebraic groups in prime characteristics, Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 14 (1981), 61-74.
[Lull
G. Lusztig, Finite dimensional Hopf algebras arising from quantized universal enveloping algebras, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 3 (1990). 257-296.
[Lu2]
~ , Introduction to quantum groups, Progress in Mathematics, BirkhSuser, 1993.
[Ma]
O. Mathieu, Filtrations of G-modules, Ann. Sci. Ecole Norm. Sup. 23 (1990), 625-644.
[Pa]
J. Paradowski, Filtrations of modules over quantum algebras, Proc. Symp. Pure Math. 56 (1994), Part 2, 93-108.
[Hi]
C. M. Ringel, The category of modules with good filtrations over a quasi-hereditary algebra has almost split sequences, Math. Z. 208 (1991), 209-223.
[RT]
N. Reshetikhin and V. Turaev, Invariants of 3-manifolds via link polynomials and quantum groups, Invent. Math. 103, 547-597.
Chapter 1 Modular Representations
[Sw]
51
M. Sweedler, ttopf Algebras, Benjamin, 1969. J.-P. Wang, Sheaf cohomology of G/B and tensor products of Weyl modules, J. Alg. 66 (1982), 162-185.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chapter 2 Orbital Varieties, Goldie Rank Polynomials and Unitary Highest Weight Modules ANTHONY JOSEPH
Weizmann Institute of Science
CONTENTS
Lecture Lecture Lecture Lecture Lecture Lecture Lecture Lecture
Lecture 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Introductory lecture The geometry of orbital varieties Goldie rank and characteristic polynomials Unitarizable highest weight modules The Parathasarathy equality The last place of unitarity Quantization of orbital varieties Further results and perspectives Comments and further reading Acknowledgments References
I n t r o d u c t o r y lecture
These lectures combine a number of related topics inspired by the orbit method and a desire to complete our knowledge of the primitive spectrum of the enveloping algebra of a semisimple Lie algebra. Let ~ be a complex finite dimensional Lie algebra with enveloping algebra U(~). Its dual g* admits the action of an irreducible algebraic group G, and the orbit method suggests the existence of a bijection between ~*/G and Prim U(~). This works rather well for g solvable [D], and it is now even known that the method of induction provides a homeomorphism 53
54
A. Joseph
[Ma] of these topological spaces. For g semisimple, however, this point of view is not as good. Basically, the greater noncommutativity of g forces discrepancies between these objects, which are a priori unrelated. If we consider that our basic aim is to determine Prim U(g) along with some interesting (for example, unitary) modules, then it will be enough that the orbit method provides a (key) part of Prim U(g). For example, the zero orbit in g* should correspond to the primitive ideals of finite codimension. which for g semisimple is an infinite set containing nevertheless just one completely prime member. One could therefore just replace Prim U(g) by Prime U(g) := {J E Prim U(g) 1 U ( g ) / J is a domain}; however, it would be a mistake to ignore the structure imposed by the presence of the remaining ideals. This is indicated by the following discussion. Here and from now on, it will be assumed that g is semisimple. Identify g* with g through the Killing form. Call x E g* nilpotent if ad~ x is a nilpotent derivation. This property is preserved under the action of G, and so it is natural to define a nilpotent orbit in g* to be one consisting of just nilpotent elements. T h e o r e m 1.1 ([BBr2, J5, Vo3]) For each J e PrimU(g), the associated variety V(gr J) of J is the closure of a nilpotent orbit. Thus, for each nilpotent orbit 49 in g* it makes sense to consider the subset X(O) of X - Prim U(g) of primitive ideals whose associated variety is 49. Now for J E X one may form Fract(U(g)/J), which is a matrix algebra over a skew field. The rank of this matrix algebra is denoted rk(U(g)/J) and called the Goldie rank of U(g)/J. Rank 1 corresponds to U(g)/,] being a domain or, equivalently, to P being completely prime. Let D denote a Cartan subalgebra of g. For each A E [~* one may associate a simple highest weight module L(A) of highest weight A - p (where p is the sum of the fundamental weights), and hence a primitive ideal J ( A ) " - Annu(~)L(A). After Duflo [Du], the map A ~ J(A) of [1" into X is surjective. In other words, the elements of X (and of X(O)) are parametrized by [?*. One may ask, how does the Goldie rank depend on this parametrization? The answer is that this dependence is essentially a polynomial one; that is, there is a finite set of polynomials the values of which determine these Goldie ranks. Moreover, for each X(O) it is appropriate to select a subset of these polynomials. Remarkably, this subset forms a basis for an irreducible representation of the Weyl group W for the pair (g, D), and this representation can be identified with the Springer representation
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
55
attached to (_9 defined by quite different (geometrical) considerations. It would clearly be almost a ridiculous coincidence if just one of these polynomials took the value 1 and moreover just once in the appropriate parameter set. These considerations will be made more precise in Lecture 3. For the moment, let us just stress a few salient points. 1) Up to scale factors, the Goldie rank polynomials are known and indeed given by a simple formula involving the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials (or rather their values at q = 1). 2) The scale factors can be largely determined just by knowing that X((_9) A Prime U(I~) ~: 0 for each (9. Hence an interest in the foregoing question. So far, one can really only check this case by case. In other words, we have no satisfactory general theory for constructing Prime U(~). 3) The Goldie rank polynomials are intimately related to the geometry of the nilpotent orbits via what was at first just a strange coincidence with the Springer theory. However, one can now directly attach to a nilpotent orbit polynomials that are not quite the same, but that span the same space. These are the characteristic polynomials of the orbital varieties attached to a given orbit. It turns out that these are given by exactly the same formulae, but involving geometric analogs of the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials that can be and are different. This gives an entirely new twist to the orbit method and insight into geometry from representation theory rather than vice versa. For example, one can conjecture that the inclusion relation of orbital variety closure is determined by these geometric Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials (the values of these are as yet unknown) in a manner analogous to the known ordering [J1, Vol] in Prim U(g). 4) The relationship between Goldie rank and characteristic polynomials allows one to conclude that the latter (and hence the former) can be expressed as a positive linear combination of products of (distinct) positive roots. Consequently, Goldie rank 1 occurs only at small parameters. This is also true for annihilators of unitary modules, though the reason is not so clear. Yet D. A. Vogan [Vo2] has noted that if the simple quotient U(~)/J is a unitary module for g × ~ (in the appropriate sense), then it is necessarily a domain. This establishes at least
56
A. Joseph one link between unitarity and small parameters.
In the case when
L(A) is unitary, it need not be that Ann L(~) E Primc V(g); yet there is a natural bound (Theorem 8.2 and remarks following) on the Goldie rank, which fails completely in the nonunitary case. So far we have gained at least one motivation for studying orbital varieties. Let us give their precise definition. Fix a triangular decomposition ft = n - ® D ® n +, where n + (resp., n - ) denotes the span of the positive (resp., negative) root vectors. Set b + = D ® n +. Then, for each nilpotent orbit (9, the intersection (9 n n + is a locally closed subset of n + and, therefore, may be expressed as a union of its irreducible components, which by definition are just the orbital varieties attached to (9. As we shall see in the next lecture, the Spaltenstein-Steinberg theory allows one to describe them more precisely as follows. Let B be a Borel subgroup corresponding to b +. Then, for each w C W, there is a unique orbital variety V(w) the closure of which coincides with the B saturation set of n + N w(n+); that is, V(w) = {b(n + n w(n+))b-1 : b C B}. Moreover, the map w H V(w) of W to the set 12 of orbital varieties is surjective. Finally, there is a unique nilpotent orbit O(w) the closure of which coincides with the G saturation set of n + n w(n +), and the map w ~ O(w) of W to the set N" of nilpotent orbits is surjective. Thus, one has surjections W---~12---~N', and the orbital varieties attached to a given orbit are just fibers of the second map. The fibers of the first map are called the geometric cells of W. They differ ever so slightly from the left cells of W defined by the theory of primitive ideals. One may note that an orbital variety is Lagrangian and therefore a natural subject for quantization, a process that may be interpreted as follows. Can one give the algebra of regular functions A[V] on the closure V of an orbital variety a U(g)-module structure that at least preserves (up to a shift) its D-module structure? A more demanding version of this question is whether one can find a highest weight module N(A) such that g r A n n u ( n - ) e~ coincides with the ideal of definition of V. This is quite possibly so, and also one would expect N(A) and in particular A to be completely determined (modulo some obvious reservations).
A different but
related approach is to study the algebra D[V] of differential operators on V. Obviously, A is a faithful D-module, and so one can ask if there is a natural map of U(I~) into D making A a U(g)-module of not worse than finite length? Since V can be singular, it is not immediate (and not known)
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
57
if A[V] is simple as a D[V]-module. These questions have particularly nice answers when V lies in the nilradical m + of a parabolic subalgebra p of ft with m + commutative. Then A[V] has even the structure of a unitary highest weight module. Moreover, except for easily described special cases, D[V] coincides with
U(g)/Anna[V]. Conversely, every unitary highest weight module L is associated to a parabolic subalgebra with a commutative nilradical m +, and remarkably Annu(m-) L is a prime ideal and hence the ideal of definition of the closure of an orbital variety contained in m+. The proof of these results will be indicated in Lectures 3-6. Some further perspectives including the use of q u a n t u m groups and of differential operators are given in Lectures 7 and 8.
Lecture 2
The geometry
of o r b i t a l v a r i e t i e s
A key observation of the orbit method of Kirillov-Kostant-Souriau is that a G-orbit in g* admits the structure of a G-equivariant symplectic variety. Let us brush aside the geometric sophistication for the moment and consider what this means in just algebraic terms. Recall that S(g) identifies with the algebra of polynomial (and hence regular) functions on ft*. It is a commutative algebra and admits a Poisson bracket { , }, which we recall for any algebra A is a bilinear antisymmetric map A x A >A satisfying the Jacobi identity such that for each a C A the map b ~-+ {a, b} is a derivation of A. Clearly, { , } is defined by its value on generators, and for S(g) one just takes the Lie product on IJ. A basic question is to determine the prime Poisson ideals of A, namely those prime ideals I satisfying { A , I } C I. Notice one can take { , } to be the c o m m u t a t o r bracket, and this is one reason that their study for S(t~) and for V(g) are supposed to be related. On the other hand, S(g) being commutative gives rise to ideals that are not obviously present in U(t~/, that is, the ideal I of definition of any closed subvariety V of g*. If the variety in question is irreducible and G-invariant, then I is prime and Poisson. An important special case is when V is the closure of a G-orbit (9. Then, the Poisson bracket gives a nondegenerate antisymmetric bilinear form on the cotangent space T~, V to any point x C O. Indeed, for all a E A / I , x E O, define 2 where mx is the ideal of definition of {x}. Then d x a - a - a(x) mod rex, d~a e T ' v , and d~a x dxb H {a, b}(x)is the required form.
58
A. Joseph The construction of prime (or primitive) ideals in U(0) follows a quite
different path. For the latter, one constructs a simple U(0)-module M. In terms of growth rate, M should be one-half the size of U(O)/Ann M. Thus, a geometric equivalent should be a subvariety of the corresponding orbit, in the sense of Theorem 1.1 having half the dimension. It turns out that there is a natural candidate, namely the variety of zeros of grAnnU(0 ) rn, which is independent of the choice of 0 =/= m E M. (See exercises at the end of this lecture.) It is called the associated variety V(M) of M and is trivially contained in V(Ann M). Moreover, by a deep result of O. Gabber [G], it is an involutive subvariety of V ( A n n M ) , and this remembers to a large extent the U(0) module structure of M.
Here, being involutive
can be expressed by saying that the ideal I(M) of definition of V(M), namely v/grAnnU(0)m, satisfies { I ( M ) , I ( M ) } C I(M). This is equivalent to (dxa, dxb) := {a, b}(x) = 0 for all a, b E I(M), x E V(M). Thus, the subspace {dxa • a C I(M)} of T*x,V(Ann M) is isotropic and so can have at most half the dimension. Its orthogonal in Tz,V(AnnM ) identifies with 1 dim V(Ann M). So far no appeal T~,V(M), and this forces dim V(M) >__-~ to the proposed simplicity of M has been made, and this should provide the reverse inequality. One calls a subvariety of an orbit (9 (or more generally, of a symplectic variety) Lagrangian if it is involutive and of exactly half the dimension. The preceding discussion suggests that one should be able to attach to a Lagrangian subvariety 12 a simple module M satisfying Ann M E X(O) and with associated variety /2. However, it is too much to expect a bijective map, as involutivity cannot be expected to capture the full meaning of M being a U(0)-module, nor need a simple module necessarily have the correct dimension. On a finer level, modules may differ appreciably in size and yet still have the same associated variety because the latter only sees the radical of grAn n U(0) m. Recall V(w) of Lecture 1. The involutivity of V(w) has an easy proof based on the observation that the orthogonal of n + N w(n +) in n - is a subalgebra. That V(w) is Lagrangian results from the Spaltenstein-Steinberg equality (see Theorem 2.1), which asserts that dim(O M n +) - 1 dim (_9 for any nilpotent orbit (9. A deeper analysis of orbital varieties results [St] from considering the Steinberg variety 8. This is defined as follows. Let b/ denote the set of all unipotent elements of G, and B the set of all Borel subgroups of G.
Chapter 2
59
Orbital Varieties
By definition, S "-- {(u, U l , B 2 ) E U x B x B I u E B 1 n U2}. For each conjugacy class d c U, let $(C) denote the inverse image of C in $ under projection onto the first component. Obviously, 8 is a disjoint union of the $(C), and since the number of conjugacy classes is finite, this is a finite union. Under conjugation, B identifies with G / B for some fixed Borel subalgebra B of G. Set g B g -1 - 9B for all g E G. Bruhat decomposition implies that under diagonal action, the G orbits Z~ in B x B have as representatives the (B,'~'B) • w E W .
Set 8w(C) -
{(u, B 1 , B 2 ) E 8 ( C ) ]
(B1, B2) E Z~}. These form a finite disjoint union of 8(C). Set U - B N b/ and U~, - U n ~U. The fibers of the projection 8 ~ ( d ) isomorphic to d n U~.
~ 13 x 13 are all
Since Zw identifies with G / ( B n ~B), it follows
that dim 8~(C) - d i m ( G / B N ~ B ) + dim(C N U~) _< dim G - rk G, with equality if and only if C N U~ is dense in U~, equivalently if (GU~) - C. We denote the subset of w E W satisfying this last condition by St -1 (C). In this case, C n U~ is irreducible. Now S~(C) can be identified with the set of G translates of the fiber C n U~ over (B, WB). Since G is irreducible, it follows that so is S~(C). Its closure is hence an irreducible component of ,5(C) when w E S t - I ( c ) . At least for characteristic zero, the B a l a - C a r t e r - D y n k i n theory gives a specific procedure for determining for each conjugacy class d an element w E W such that d N U~ is dense in Uw. The idea is as follows. Consider e Efl nilpotent. By the Jacobson-Morosov theorem, there exists an s[(2) triple (e, h, f) containing e. Let g-
(~gi iEX
be the decomposition of g into its t? eigenspaces with gi corresponding to h-eigenvalue i. Now [e, go] = g2 from s[(2) theory, and so dim g2 < dim go implies g~ -76 0. Moreover, g~ - go/, and so this subalgebra is reductive. Let ~0 C g~ be a Cartan subalgebra. Then gbo is a proper Levi factor of g containing e. This reduces the problem to a strictly lower rank case. If dim g2 = dim go, then gl
-
-
0 by the B a l a - C a r t e r - D y n k i n theorem.
This was at first checked case by case, but then J. C. Jantzen found the following "one-line" proof. Consider the Dynkin parabolic p = (~i>0gi, whose nilradical is rn = 1~i>1 gi. By Richardson's theorem (which is also m
proved using Bruhat decomposition), the corresponding parabolic group
A. Joseph
60 P has a dense orbit in m.
In Lie algebra terms, this means t h a t there
exists x C ra such t h a t [p,x] - m. Decomposing x into h eigenvectors xi, one obtains [g0,Xl + x2] + [~1,Xl]
--
~1 O ~2. The first t e r m on the left
h a n d side has dimension _< dim S0 - dim g2, whereas the second t e r m has dimension < dim ~1 unless ~1
--0.
Hence the assertion.
On the other hand, setting m ~ - ~ i > 2 gi one checks again from ~[(2) theory t h a t d i m G e -
dimg-dimg~
and dim Pe >_ dim G e - dim m present case ~1
--
-
dimm+dimm
t. Yet Pe C m ~
dim m t, and so Pe is dense in m ~. In the
0, SO t h a t Pe is dense in m. Finally, for an appropriate
choice of w C W, one has Lie U~ - m. T h e r e is a second n a t u r a l way to obtain irreducible components of 8(C).
Fix u E C, and set B~ -
{B E B I u C B}.
An a r g u m e n t of
N. Spaltenstein IS] based on B r u h a t decomposition (which we use later in a related context) shows how to move from component to component of B~. From this, one concludes t h a t Bu is equidimensional. Now let X be a S t a b c u orbit of an irreducible component of Bu × B~, hence in particular a finite union of pairs of irreducible components of B~. Let Y be the inverse image of X under the continuous map (guy- 1, B1, B2) ~ (g- 1B1, g- 1B2) of $(C) onto Bu × B~. T h e n Y is closed, irreducible, and has dimension dim C + dim X = dim C + 2 dim Bu. Since 8(C) is a finite irredundant union of such Y, the latter run over its irreducible components. On the other hand, we have seen t h a t at least one such component has dimension equal to dim G -
rk G. Consequently, every component has this
dimension and furthermore, (2.1)
2 dim Bu + dim C = dim G - rk G.
A further comparison of these two descriptions of irreducible components shows t h a t the S t a b a u orbits of an irreducible component of B~ are the closures of t h e C w ' St-I(c).
{gB I v g E G
such t h a t g ( B M W B )
~u}'wc
Finally, let V1, V 2 , . . . , Vn be the irreducible components of C M U C M B, and C1, C 2 , . . . , Cm the irreducible components of B~. Consider the surjective morphisms
71"l ( g )
--
g--lug o f
e
onto C and ~2(g) - gB of G onto
~. Identifying B with G / B identifies ~21(Ci) with CiB. Since C~ and B are irreducible, so is 71-21 (Ci), and so these sets form the irreducible components of ~ - l ( B u ) -
~11(C M V).
Thus, the Vi • i -
1,2,...,n
are among the
Chapter 2 7r17r~-l(cj) " j -
1,2,...,m.
Orbital Varieties
Moreover,
7r17121(Ci) is
61 independent of the
choice of Ci in its S t a b a u-orbit. Thus, the V/ are among the closures of the 7tl(Tr21(Cw)) - B(Uw n C ) . Notice t h a t from the definition of Zrl, zr2 one has d i m C j + d i m B - dimzrlTr~-l(cj) + dim S t a b o u.
(2.2)
Combined with (2.1) and the equidimensionality of Bu, this implies t h a t U n C is equidimensional and of dimension dim(U n C) -- dim Bu + dim B - dim S t a b a u - 1 dim C. The preceding result may be summarized by the following. Theorem
2.1
Let 0 be a nilpotent orbit of a complex semisimple Lie
algebra g with triangular decomposition g -
n + N 1? n n - .
Then the irre-
ducible components of n + n O are Lagrangian subvarieties of 0 and take the form V(w) "- B(n+ n w(n+)) N O" w e s t - l ( o ) . Note t h a t V(w) ¢2 B(n+ a w(n+)). This point must be carefully taken into account in what follows. Spaltenstein's operation on the components of Bu caries over to the components of n + n O and takes the following form. Let ~r be the set of simple roots defined with respect to the foregoing triangular decomposition. Let V be a component o f n + n O ,
and take a C zr. Let Ps denote
the parabolic subalgebra b + ® g - s , and ms its nilradical. Let Ps be the connected subgroup of G with Lie algebra Ps.
The T-invariant of V is
defined to be T(V) "-- {a e 7r I V c m~}. Since ms is Ps-stable, it follows that a C T(V(w)) if and only if n + N w(n +) C ms, which in turn is equivalent to w - l a C -NTr or that s s w < w for the Bruhat order. In particular, V is Ps stable if a E ~-(V). Suppose a ~ T(V). Let us show that
m,~ m "~(V(w)) c V(w) u V(s~w) u (
U
zEwls~z
V(z)).
(2.3)
Set Vl(W) =B (n + n w(n+)). By Bruhat decomposition and the hypothesis, one has P s w B -
B w B U B s s w B . Then, since ms is Ps stable,
ms N P°'(VI(w)) -- P~(ms n w(n+)) =
=
n
u
n Vl (w))U Vl
(SAW).
A. Joseph
62
Set V2(w) - Vl(w) N O. Then ms n P~(V2(w)) -- (ms n V2(w)) U V2(s~w). Now consider V(w) \ V2(w). This has codimension _ 1 in V(w) and is B-stable. Hence dimP~ (V(w) \ V2(w)) _< dim V(w). Since O N n + is equidimensional, it follows that ms N P~(V(w) \ V2(w)) is precisely those components of O n n + that lie in ms and whose union contains Together with the first observation, this proves (2.3).
V(w) \ V2(w).
Notice it is not guaranteed that V(saw) is actually a component of n + N O, as it may be of codimension _> 1. The contribution in the far right hand side of (2.3) may be quite sizable. Starting from a given orbital variety V, the operation defined by (2.3) iterated sumciently often eventually gives all the orbital varieties lying in the unique dense orbit O contained in
GV. This was originally proved by
Spaltenstein [S] using an argument of Steinberg involving Bruhat decomposition. It implies that O n n + is equidimensional. A similar argument can be used to show that O n n + is equidimensional. Using the characteristic polynomials introduced in Lecture 3, we can follow this operation more closely. By this means, it is possible to generate interesting examples of what can occur on the right hand side of (2.3). However, a complete description is still an important open problem. Exercises and results on associated varieties Let {~-~n(U(g))}mcN be the canonical filtration [D, 2.3] of U(g). By the Poincard-Birkhoff-Witt theorem, gr 7 U(g) identifies with S(g). Let M be a finitely generated U(g)-module with generators ml, m 2 , . . . , ms. Then M can be made a filtered module for (U(g),J c) through
.
-
i--1
1) Show that
V(Anns(g) gr 7
M) - V(gr(fi Annv(g) mi)),
(2.4)
i=1
and that both sides of this expression are independent of the choice of generators. (It is important in Lecture 3 to know that these assertions also hold in the scheme theoretic sense.)
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
63
2) One writes V(M) for the variety in (2.4), and, by a slight abuse of notation, V ( A n n M ) for V(U(g)/ Ann M). Show that V(Ann M) = V(gr Annv(~) M) D GV(M). One knows Suppose M ple, if M is that V(M)
3) 4)
(2.5)
that equality holds in (2.5) under certain circumstances. is homogeneous for Gelfand-Kirillov dimension, for examsimple. Then a result of O. Gabber [LS, Appendix] asserts is equidimensional. For further results on associated vari-
eties, see [BE]. Show that gr~= Ann M prime implies that Ann M is completely prime [J7, 8.1]. Assume g semisimple. Given J E PrimU(g), show that V(grj= J) is contained in the cone of nilpotent elements of g*.
Lecture 3
Goldie rank and characteristic polynomials
Let us describe more precisely how rk U(g)/J(A) depends on A E b*. First some notation is needed. Let R (resp., R +,Tr) denote the set of nonzero (resp., positive, simple) roots relative to our triangular decomposition of ~. For each c~ E R, set av = 2c~/(a, a). The lattice of integral weights is defined to be P ( R ) : = {A E [~* ] (c~V,A) ¢ Z, V c~ E R}. The Weyl group W leaves P(R) invariant, and this action admits the subset P(R) + := {A c P ( R ) ] (c~,A) _> 0, V c~ c R +} of dominant weights as a fundamental domain. Finally, a weight A is called regular if (c~, A) ¢- 0, V c~ C R. A regular dominant weight is just one which belongs to the subset P(R) ++ := P(R) + + p. The fibers of the map w ~ J(w)~) of W into Prim U(~) are known after W. Borho and J. C. Jantzen [BJ] to be independent of the choice of
A C P(R) ++ (with some degenerations for A C P(R)+). They are called the left cells of W. Their conjectured [J1] description in terms of the Jordan-HSlder multiplicities [M(yA): L(wA)] was settled by D. A. Vogan [Vol], a result that was one of the motivations for the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomials [KL1] now known to determine these multiplicities. This result leads naturally to a conjectural description [J4, 9.9] of the geometric cells of W (Lecture 1), but one that is as yet unresolved. (There is unfortunately a gap in the proof in [T, 2.11].) One calls the set of ideals {J(A) : A C P ( R ) }
A. Joseph
64
the integral fiber (of the Duflo map). Except in ~[(n), not all nilpotent orbits occur as associated varieties (cf. Theorem 1.1) of ideals in the integral fiber. Those that do coincide with the special orbits of G. Lusztig, which were defined in a rather different manner [Lu]. Notice that this already means that left cells and geometric cells must differ outside ~[(n). If we let a(w,y) denote the coefficients of the matrix inverse to [M(yA) : L(w)~)]y,~w (known by [Janl] to be independent of A C P ( R ) + + ) , then the formal character of L(w)~) takes the form
ch L(w)~) - ~
a(w' y)eY:~-P
yCW
ii~eR+(1 _ e_~).
(3.1)
It turns out that the required Goldie ranks are obtained by studying the asymptotics of the right hand side of (3.1). Indeed, fix u C P(R) ++. Then it makes sense to consider e ( ~ ' ' ) as a genuine exponential and to expand the function
E
a(w'y)e(Y~'V)
yEW
in powers of (yA, u). The first nonvanishing term in the expansion has the remarkable property that it factors as a product of two polynomials; namely, one has
E
a(w, y)(y)~, u) ~ -- p~()~)q~(u).
(3.2)
,yEW
This fact (observed by a student, D. King, of D. A. Vogan) resulted from the interpretation of the first factor p~ (A) as the required Goldie rank, namely, one has [J3, Theorem 5.1] T h e o r e m 3.1
For all )~ C P ( R ) +, w C W, rk(U(9)/J(w)~)) - p~(£).
Notice one can express this result by saying that
p~ - ~ yEW
a(w, y)y-lpm
(3.3)
Chapter 2 Orbital Varieties
65
up to some scalar. These scalars are not yet completely known [J6]. However, since Pw takes integer values on P ( R ) +, it must take integer values on the whole of P(R). Then the scalar would be determined by knowing t h a t it takes at least once the value 1. I conjectured this to be always true [J7, 8.4(i)]. Parts (ii), (iii) of the cited conjecture have counterexamples
[B, T]. The factorization (3.2) has some further remarkable consequences, which are quite easy to prove [J3, Section 2].
QWpw is a simple W-module. Moreover, this simple module
A)
occurs with multiplicity one in the space of homogeneous polynomials on O* of degree m and not in lower degree. To prove this, one should observe that replacing p by zp: z C W in the expression (3.3) for p~ only changes the latter by a scalar. This result generalizes an observation of I. G. Macdonald [M]. We call such modules univalent. Not all W-modules have this property. B)
p~ is a W-harmonic function on 0", that is, it satisfies the relation
E
p(w# + ~) -[W]p(~),
for all #, ~ C O*.
wOW
For this, one should recall the vanishing of the sum
Y~y~w a(w, y)(y)~, ~,)n
for n < m. The second polynomial q ~ ( , ) occurring in the factorization (3.2) has also an i m p o r t a n t interpretation and leads to a determination of the associated variety of L(w)~). Formalizing this leads to the notion of the characteristic polynomial of an orbital variety, and this has some important geometric consequences. This will be examined. First note, however, after [J2, 5.4] one has a(w, y) = a(w -1, y - l ) and so C)
q~-i = pw up to a scalar.
Let V be a closed irreducible O-stable subvariety of n +. View its ideal of definition
I(V) as an O-invariant ideal of S ( n - ) .
From the previous
discussion, it is natural to study the asymptotics of the formal character of
S(n-)/I(V). Indeed, fix v C P(R) ++ and consider E
dim(S(n-)/I(V))_~
(~,~,)~_n
as a function of n. From Hilbert-Samuel theory, it is a polynomial in n the degree of which is the dimension of V. Moreover, the leading coefficient
A. Joseph
66
rv({) is a function of {, and the simple calculation following will show that this takes the form =
for some polynomial Pv on 11", called the characteristic polynomial of V. If V is the associated variety of L(wA) and the latter is irreducible as in, say, ~[(n) by [Mel], then comparison with the previous analysis shows that
py - Pw- ~ up to a nonzero scalar. More generally, pw-1 is a sum with strictly positive rational coefficients of the characteristic polynomials of the components of the associated variety of L(wA). The general form that Pv can take is easily deduced using hyperplane intersection [J8, Section 8]. Let n + -
nl+Dn2~ . . . .
0 be any l)-stable
flag of n +. It will be sufficient to suppose that V C ni and to relate rw to rVnni+l" Here, V n ni+l is interpretated scheme theoretically; that is, V n rti+l is a linear combination of the components Vj of V n hi+l, each possibly occurring several times; then, rvnn~+l
--- ~_~ r V 5 • J
It remains to prove the following lemma. Let c~i be the weight of a vector in ni/ni+l. Lemma ii) ry -
i) rvn,i+l - r v , if !OLi r y n , i + l , otherwise.
3.2
V C ni+l.
Proof: Only (ii) is nontrivial. Write a - c~i, n - hi, m - hi+l, I - I(V), and
Rv(u)-
E
dim(S(n*)/I)-~e(~")
~ ENrr
for all L, E P(R) ++. Set J - I + S(n*)x_~. For each { E NTr, choose a subspace V_ e of ( S ( n * ) / I ) _ e that under the canonical projection S ( n * ) / I S ( n * ) / J maps bijectively to ( S ( n * ) / J ) _ ~ .
,
Set V - ~ V_~, which as an
l~-module is isomorphic to ¢o(m*)/I N S(m*).
Chapter 2
67
Orbital Varieties
The hypothesis of (ii) implies that x_~ is a nonzero divisor in S ( n * ) / I , and so the sum }--~kV x ~ is direct and equals S(n*)/I. One concludes that
Rv(u)- Z
Z (dim V_~)e(~-k~'')
(1)
kEN ~ENTr
and hence the assertion of (ii) follows by a simple asymptotic analysis [J4, 2.3]. I-I This simple argument gives the following significant positivity result [J8, 8.6], not apparent from our previous explicit formula. C o r o l l a r y 3.3 The Goldie rank polynomial pw is a linear combination with positive rational coefficients of products of distinct positive roots. This helps [J8, 8.6] to locate completely prime primitive ideals. For example, one can show that U ( g ) / A n n L ( w A ) : A E P ( R ) ++ is a domain if and only if L(wA) is induced from a one-dimensional representation of a parabolic subalgebra. Unfortunately, the restriction on A is rather strong in this context. (See [J9, 5.3] for a slight improvement.) Examples
1) Take g - s[(4) and V the orbital variety closure with ideal
of definition (e21, e43, e31e42-e32e41). Then Pv - c~1c~3(al +2c~2+a3). 2) Take g - s[(6) and V the orbital variety closure with ideal of definition (C21, e43, e54, e53, e31e42--e32e41, e41e52--e42e51, e 3 1 e 5 2 - - e 3 2 e 5 1 ) . Then pv
-
+
+
+
+
OL3 -31-OZ4)] .
3) Take ft - ~0(7) and :r = { a l , a 2 , a 3 } with a3 short. Then 7r' = {a2,a3} is a simple system for a Lie algebra g' of type so(5). This admits a unique orbital variety of dimension 2, the closure V' of which has characteristic polynomial pv, - a3(a2 + a3). Set V - n + + V', which is the closure of an orbital variety of ft. Then Pv - a3(a2 + a 3 ) . Neither pv' nor Pv can be proportional to Goldie rank polynomials attached to ideals in the integral fiber. However, in the so(7) example one has the additional surprise that G V is the associated variety of a primitive ideal in the integral fiber. This in turn implies that the associated varieties of the corresponding highest weight modules cannot all
A. Joseph
68
be irreducible and illustrates the discussion in (3) following Theorem 1.1. This example was developed from a note of T. Tanisaki, and we refer the reader to [J9, 8.6] for further details. Determining all such occurrences is still very much an open problem. In general, pv need not be W-harmonic, nor need it generate a simple W-module. To prove that these properties do hold when V is an orbital variety closure motivates a similar but independent presentation of these characteristic polynomials analogous to that already established for the Goldie rank polynomials. This is provided by [JS] using the geometric considerations sketched briefly in what follows. Fix ~ C O*, h E O. One knows that expressions of the form
E
A(w,y)e (y~)(h) "A(w,y) C Z
can be obtained as integrals. Then the key factorization property should be obtained by reexpressing this integral in product form by some change of variables. Now, the orbital variety V(w) can be viewed as the image under the moment map of the conormal
Y(w) "- {bwB, b(n+ N w(n+))b -1" b e B} in T*(G/B). Consequently, one should integrate over Y(w). To determine the relevant integrals, one appeals to the remarkable theory of M. F. Atiyah and R. Bott as developed more recently by N. Berline and M. Vergne [BGV] and W. Rossmann [R]. Essentially, the integrand is chosen so that Stokes theorem can be applied. The integral over V(w) becomes Pv(w) by [J8, 5.7]. Explicitly, this means that, up to a nonzero constant,
Pv(w) - E A(w' y)YPm'
(3.4)
yEW
where m is the least integer _> 0 for which such an expression is nonvanishing. This result was first obtained by W. Rossmann using Hotta's result [Ho] and answered a conjecture of [J4]. A key point in the required factorization is that the integral over a fiber of the moment map is independent of which fiber is chosen. This is because the integral represents the class of the fiber in homology [J8, 3.6],
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
69
which through the G action is independent of the fiber chosen. Finally, it is possible to express the A(w, y) in terms of Euler numbers [J8, 4.8] and in particular to show that A(w, y) - A(w -1, y - l ) . Then by the analog of (C) following Theorem 3.1, the Pv(w) must form a basis for (Springer's) W-module Mo(w) attached to (9(w) lying in the homology space of a fixed point set Bu " u E (9(w). This recovers the aforementioned result of R. Hotta [Ho]. Set A(w) - E y ~ W A(w,y)y. As in (A) following Theorem 3.1, the factorization of the first nonvanishing term (A(w)A, u)~n implies that Mo(~) is invariant. In particular, an isomorphism Mo(~)-Z-,Mo(~,) of W-modules must be an equality. Moreover, according to Springer's well-known result, one has T h e o r e m 3.4
The M o • (9 C A/" are pairwise nonisornorphic.
As first noted by Kazhdan-Lusztig [KL2], following a suggestion of Springer, this may be obtained from a study of the Steinberg variety (see also IT] and references therein). It gives the following important and a priori surprising result. C o r o l l a r y 3.5
The p~. • V E Y are linearly independent.
E x e r c i s e Take u E V(w). Show that the fiber over u under the moment map Y(w) ~ V(w) is just a Stabc u-orbit of an irreducible component of B~. (See Lecture 2.) Except possibly in type s[(n), the A(w, y) and a(w, y) do not quite coincide [J8, 4.9]. Thus, we obtain the following rather subtle version of the orbit method correspondence. Orbital varieties and primitive ideals satisfy exactly analogous theories, but the data that must be used to calculate their properties (viz. left cells or geometric cells, Goldie rank, or characteristic polynomials) differ slightly. Again the A(w, y) contain data (for example, the characteristic polynomials) concerning all the nilpotent orbits, whereas a(w, y) concern only those occurring in the integral fiber (Lusztig's special orbits). For example, take g = s0(5). Then 1~ admits four nilpotent orbits of dimensions 8, 6, 4, 0. Exactly the four-dimensional one does not occur in the integral fiber. The unique orbital variety attached to it has the characteristic polynomial given in example (3). Again using t~(.) for reduced
70
A. Joseph
length and > for B r u h a t order, one has a(w, y) a n d is zero otherwise.
( - 1 ) ~(w)+~(y) if y > w
One concludes from T h e o r e m 3.1 t h a t the Goldie
r a n k polynomials are p r o p o r t i o n a l to 1, a2, a3, a 2 a 3 ( a 2 + c~3)(c~2 + 2c~3). In particular, the p o l y n o m i a l of example (3) does not appear. Yet it m u s t a p p e a r in the right h a n d side of (3.4). Consequently, A(w, y) must differ from a(w, y) in this case. F u r t h e r reasons t h a t A(w, y) and a(w, y) m u s t differ are given in [J8, 4.9]. Let us go into how the i n t e g r a n d is chosen in a little more detail. Let M be a C ~ manifold with symplectic form a, and x a vector field on M .
If f is a s m o o t h function on M , the compatibility condition we
need is t h a t df + c(x)a - 0, where c(x) denotes contraction by x. T h e n
dx "- d + c(x) is just the "covariant differential." One has dx(~ + f ) - 0, a n d so dx(a + f ) n _ 0 for all integer n > 0. T h e integrand is chosen to be e x p ( a + f ) - exp a exp f , with the convention t h a t only the t e r m O"n i s r e t a i n e d if the i n t e g r a n d is over a variety Y of real dimension 2n. U n d e r suitable conditions (in p a r t i c u l a r t h a t the set ~ of zeros of x is finite), the A t i y a h - B o t t - B e r l i n e - V e r g n e - R o s s m a n n t h e o r y asserts t h a t
y fO'n -- E ef(W)n(w) wE~ for certain real n u m b e r s n(w). In the present case we identify G / B with the c o m p a c t real variety K / T , where K is a m a x i m a l c o m p a c t s u b g r o u p (see Lecture 4) of G viewed as a real Lie group and T a m a x i m a l torus for K . Set t - Lie T. T h e n T* ( G / B ) identifies as a real manifold with K ×T t ±. W i t h respect to the elements x~ • a E R of a Chevalley basis for ~c, one has Cartisian coordinates
es "- i ( x s + x - s ) ,
fa "- Xs - x - s " a C R + on t ±. Fix h E b, i~ C t*
regular. T h e n one takes f to be the function on K X T t ± defined by 1
f (k, a) - (h, k~) - -~ E
2
2
(es + f s ) ,
sER+
where (es, f s ) " a C R + denotes the coordinates of ka" k C K u n d e r the p r o j e c t i o n onto t ± defined by the d e c o m p o s i t i o n ~ - t ± ® t. This function satisfies the preceding (integrability) condition for a " - a~ +Th, where a~ is the 2-form on K / T defined t h r o u g h a~(x, y ) ( k T ) and where
1 sCR+
(des A d f s ) .
([x, y], kA), V x, y E [,
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
71
Examples and exercises Let 7r~ be a subset of 7r, and set R '+ = NTr~ N R +. One easily checks that there exists an orbital variety the closure V of which has characteristic polynomial p~, := H~cR'+ c~. According to the preceding theory, the W-module generated by p v has a basis formed by the characteristic polynomials of the orbital varieties attached to the unique dense orbit in GV. Moreover, these polynomials are given by (3.4), though here the A(w, y) are unfortunately not yet known. However, in low rank cases one can obtain these polynomials just by following the rules imposed by Spaltenstein's operation described in Lecture 2 in the following manner. Let V be an orbital variety, and recall (Lecture 2) the definition of the T-invriant T(V). 1) Set 7r' = T(V). Show that p~, divides p~. 2) Suppose c~ ~ 7r~. Show that s ~ p ~ - p~ is a linear combination with nonnegative rational coefficients of characteristic polynomials of orbital varieties. 3) Assume there exists c~ C :r \ 7r', /~ C 7r' such that (c~,c~)= (/~,/3)= -2(a,/3). Show that there exists a unique irreducible component V' in rn~ N P~ V such that c~ C ~-(V'), /3 ~ T(V). For more details see [J4, Sect. 9]. 4) Calculate p~ for each of the 26 orbital varieties V occurring in ~[(5) using the information provided by (1)-(3). Lecture 4
Unitarizable
highest weight m o d u l e s
Let g be a complex semisimple Lie algebra. The notion of a complex unitarizable g-module depends on the choice of a real form go of g. Let j: g ~ g denote complex conjugation with respect to g0. Let {x~ :c~ C R; h~ := [x~,x_~] : /3 C 7r} be a Chevalley basis for t~. This basis generates a real Lie subalgebra of g, and we let jc denote complex conjugation with respect to this basis. The (compact) Chevalley antiautomorphism ~rc associated to this basis is defined by Crc(X~)= x_~. Define an involution 0 through O ( x ) = - j ~ ( x ) , V x E 1~. One may check that the Killing form is negative definite with respect to the fixed points of 0, and this defines the compact real form of ~. By, say [H, Chapter 2, Theorem 7.1], one may choose the Chevalley basis so that Oj = jO. Consequently, g0 is 0-stable. 0 is called the Cartan
72
A. Joseph
involution of go and gives g0 a 7-a grading. Indeed, setting
~o = {z e go l e ( x ) = one
~},
po - {x e ~o l e ( x ) =
-x},
has
~o
=
~o • po,
[~o, ~o]
c
~o,
[~o, po]
c
po,
[po, po]
c
~o.
The adjoint action of g0 on itself defines a Lie algebra homomorphism x H ad~o x of g0 into g[(n,R) : n = dimg0, which is injective since g is semisimple.
The compact real form can be viewed as {~0 ® ip0. W i t h
respect to the (anti)orthonormal basis it defines for the Killing form, one may identify 0 with x ~ - t x , where t denotes transpose of a matrix. Let G be the connected (real) subgroup of GL(n,R) of elements of the form exp x : x C go. Then Lie G = go. Let K be the subgroup of G of all orthogonal matrices (that is, tg = g - l ) . Then K is a compact subgroup of G, in fact, maximal compact. Moreover, Lie K = ~0. After Harish-Chandra (see D. A. Vogan's lectures in Chapter 5), classifying irreducible unitary representations of G is equivalent to classifying simple admissible (g,K)-modules admitting a positive definite invariant Hermitian form ( , ) .
If K is connected, then a (g, K)-module M is simply
a g-module, admissibility means that M is a direct sum of simple {~-modules each occurring with finite multiplicity, and invariance of the form means that
O= (xm, n) + (m, xn),
V m, n E M, x E go.
We shall call such modules unitarizable. Let g = m + ® ~ ® m - be a decomposition of g into Lie subalgebras such t h a t p := m + ® ~ is a parabolic subalgebra with nilradical m + and Levi factor {~ leaving m + stable.
One may assume that ~ D ~, and then
any such decomposition corresponds to writing 7r
=
71-1 ]_I 71"2
taking the
root vectors in ~ (resp., m +, m - ) to have roots in the subset R N ZTrl (resp., R + \ (R A NTrl), R - \ (R A - N 1 r l ) ) . ~(~+)
In particular, crc([~) = ~ and
= ~-.
If m + (and hence m - ) is commutative, one may define an involution 0 on g taking the value 1 on ~ and - 1 on m - ® m +. Suppose this holds, and set cr = 0ac. Then j ( x ) = - j c a ( x ) defines a new complex structure on g. Set g0 = {x C g I j ( x ) = x}. Explicitly, g0 has an R-basis formed
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
73
from { i h ~ ' ~ E 7r, i ( x a + x - a ) , (xa-x-a)'c~ER + ' - R +MNTrl} and from {xa + x - a , i ( x a - x - a ) " c~ E R + " - R + \ ( R + N NTrl)}. Moreover, the former (resp., latter) gave an IR-basis for t~0 - t~0 N t~ (resp., P0) taking 0 Igo to be the Cartan involution. The preceding condition on m + implies that R + N 7r is a singleton, called the noncompact simple root, which must furthermore occur with multiplicity one in any root/3 of m +. Let Q(~) be a highest weight module with highest weight ~, that is, a quotient of a Verma module M(~).
(Note our change of convention
compared with Lecture 3.) By the Poincar~-Birkhoff-Witt theorem, the triangular decomposition of 1~ gives a direct sum decomposition U(g) - U(O)® (n-U(f;) + U(f;)n+). Let p be the projection of g(g) onto U(O) defined by this decomposition. Define a Hermitian form on U(I~) through (a,b) ~ p((j~a)(a)b)(,~). One easily checks that its kernel contains Annu(~) e~, where e~ denotes a highest weight vector for M(A). Writing rn - ae~, n - be,x, one thus obtains a Hermitian form on M(A) satisfying (m, x n ) - (j~cr(x)rn, n) for all m , n E M(A), x E g. One easily checks that its kernel is precisely the unique maximal submodule of M(A), and so the form passes to Q(A) and in particular to L(A). Notice that j~a - - 1 on go, and hence ( , } is the unique (up to scalars) form on Q(A) satisfying the required invariance condition for unitarity. In particular, Q(A) is simple if this form is positive definite. Again, L(A) being admissible implies that its highest weight vector generates a finite dimensional p-module V. Then L(A) is an image of the induced module U(g) ®u(p) V. Thus, L(A) is admissible and hence is unitarizable if and only if the form is positive definite. All unitarizable highest weight modules for noncompact connected real Lie groups arise in this fashion. Let c~ E 7r~ "-- R + N 7r denote the noncompact simple root and aJ the fundamental weight corresponding to c~. Set 7r~ - 7r \ 7rn. In P ( R ) , P ( R ) + let a subscript c denote the condition that the corresponding weight is orthogonal to c~. Given 7- E P ( R ) +, let V(T) denote the simple finite dimensional t~-module with highest weight T. For all u E C, set A~, "= ~- + ua~. The simple highest weight {~-module it defines can be identified as V(~-) ® C ~ , which we view as a p-module by letting rn + act by zero. The induced module N(A~) "- U(f;)®u(p)(V(~-)® C u ~ ) i s isomorphic to S ( m - ) ® V(~-) ® C ~
as a p-module.
For its simple quotient to be
A. Joseph
74
unitarizable, one requires u E IR. It remains to describe for which pairs (~-, u) C P ( R ) + × IR this quotient L ( ~ ) is unitarizable. In this, it is enough to assume g simple. One defines a totally ordered sequence ~1,/32,...,/~t of (strongly orthogonal) noncompact positive roots as follows. Let
~1 be the highest root.
Delete the simple roots in the Dynkin diagram of ~t not orthogonal to 13, and take the unique connected component containing a. Let ~2 be the unique highest root of this component, and continue until a itself is deleted. One may show that the partial sums i
E/3j
"i-
1,2 . . . . ,t
j=l
belong to P ( R ) +. Moreover, up to scalars there exists for each i a unique nonzero vi E S(m)"
of weight - # i . Let Vi denote the simple ~-submodule
of S(m) generated by vi under adjoint action. Fix ~- C P ( R ) +. According to a result of K. R. Parthasarathy, R. Ranga Rao, and V. S. Varadarajan [PRV], there exists a unique component Pi of V(~-) ®Vi having extreme weight T - # i . Call this the PRV component. Finally, define ~- to be of level s if (~i - / 3 j , T) - 0, V i, j - 1, 2 , . . . , s, and s is maximal _< t with this property. The classification of unitarizable highest weight modules now goes as follows [EJ]. Take ~- C P ( R ) + and suppose it is of level s. Take i E {1, 2,.. • , s}. Then there is a unique value u iT of u such that S(m)P~ ® Cu~ is a V(g)-submodule of N ( / ~ ) .
The u~ • i -
1,2,...,s
are decreasing,
and for u < u~ the induced module N(~u) is unitarizable. The remaining unitarizable modules are its quotients by the previous submodules.
One
~ 1 " 2 <_i < s may also calculate the u i . Notably, the differences u i - ui_ are independent of ~- and of i. One calls u~ the first reduction point, and u[ the last place of unitarity. One may show, [J10, 2.3] for example, that the S(m)V~" i -
1, 2 , . . . , t
run through the ideals of definition of the closures of the orbital varieties lying in m +. Thus, when 7- - 0, the corresponding unitarizable highest weight modules identify with the spaces of regular functions on these varieties. Their highest weights are the u°w • i - 1, 2 , . . . , t. Example
Take tt - ~[(n), and choose m E { 1 , 2 , . . . , n -
1}. One may
take a - am to be the noncompact simple root. Then, t - min{m, n - m } .
Chapter 2
75
Orbital Varieties
Moreover, vi : i = 1, 2 , . . . , t is the lower left hand corner i x i minor, and V/is the subspace spanned by all i x i minors lying in the b o t t o m left hand rn x ( n - m) corner. In particular, if n = 4, m = 2, one recovers examples (1) and ( 2 ) o f Lecture 3. In the last example, take ~- = a~l. Then V(T) is a two-dimensional ~-module (here, t~ ~_ t3[(2) x ft[(2)). One may choose a basis {x, y} for V(T) and a basis { a , b , c , d }
for rn- such that v2 = a d -
bc and P1 has basis
a y - bx, cy - d x . Then,
( a d - b c ) x -- c ( a y - bx) - a ( c y - d x )
(4.1a)
( a d - bc)y = d ( a y - bx) - b(cy - d x ) ,
(4.1b)
and
which shows that v 2 V ( T )
is contained in rnP1.
Consequently, we have
Annv(m-) L ( ~ ' ) - U(m-)v2, which identifies with a p r i m e ideal of S ( m - ) . Of course, (4.1a, b) is just Cramer's rule of linear algebra, which here translates to a statement about Annu(rn-) L(A) being prime [J10, 5.16] whenever L(A) is unitarizable! An interesting example also occurs in ET, and the cotresponding polynomial v3 C V3 is of degree 3 in 27 variables [J10, 8.1]. It was studied in an old paper of A. Freudenthal [F] concerning geometry over an octionic field.
Lecture 5
T h e P a r t h a s a r a t h y equality
Recall the setup and notation of Lecture 4. Take A - ~- ÷ ua~ with ~- C P ( R ) +, u E C, and let N(A) be the induced module N(A) = U ( g ) ® v ( p ) V(A). Let e be a t~ highest weight vector of highest weight p. Let ( , ) denote the C a r t a n inner product on [?*, and set I]ull2 = (u, u). The key to studying when L(A) is unitarizable obtains from the following result due to K. R. P a r t h a s a r a t h y [P]. Lemma
5.1
(ll x ÷ pll 2 aER +
76
A. Joseph
Proof." Let I (resp., J) denote the Casimir invariant for t~ (resp., 2). Then, up to appropriate choices, Ie - I A + pll2e, Je - I]# + Pll 2e. On the other hand, for these choices I-
J-
2 ~_, X--aXa. hER +
Recalling that a(x_~) - - x ~ for all a E R +, the assertion results. Z] Remark
Of course, for the "compact" Chevalley antiautomorphism one
has a ( x _ ~ ) = x~, and the resulting conclusion would lead to quite different results. A similar result holds for any real form of 9, and fairly easy calculations similar to those following can be used to show that only the real forms we are considering lead to unitary highest weight modules. It is clear that the assertion of the lemma applies to any quotient of N(A), in particular to L(A). This gives the following important C o r o l l a r y 5.2 The Hermitian form on L(A) is positive definite if and only if I1# + Pl > IIA + Pll for every 2 highest weight # ~ A occurring in L(A).
P r o o f : Let 9~m(L(A)) denote the image of ~ m ( U ( m - ) ) ® Y(A) in L(£). Obviously, x ~ m ( L ( A ) ) C 9~m-1 (L(A)) for all a E R +. Since K is compact and 20 - Lie K, an invariant form on any simple finite dimensional 2 (20)c-module is either positive or negative definite. In particular <, } can be assumed to be positive definite on 9~°(L(A)) - Y(£). Take m e N, and assume <, } is positive definite on 9~m(L(A)). Assume e e ~'m+l(L()~)). The sum occurring in the right hand side of the assertion of the lemma is >__0, with equality if and only if x~e - O, V a E R +, which forces A - p. Hence the required assertion follows. [:] For each dominant weight ~, let V(~) denote the simple finite dimensional {~-module with highest weight y. One calls ~ the 2-type of V(~). Let ~1, ~2 be dominant weights, and let V(~) be a composition factor of V(~I) ® V(~2), which one may recall is completely reducible. One calls a minimal 2-type if I1~ ÷ Pl] takes its minimal value among those 2-types occurring in V ( ~ I ) ® V(~2). The PRV component of V ( ~ I ) ® V(~2) is by definition the composition factor with extreme weight ~1 + w0~2. L e m m a 5.3
~-type.
The P R V component of V (111) ~
V
(/]2) is its unique minimal
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
77
Proof: Let u be a tNtype of V(ul) ® V(u2). By complete irreducibility, one has a surjective map V ( u l ) ® V(-2) , V(u). Now e. 1 ® ewo.2 is a cyclic vector for the preceding tensor product and hence has a nonzero image in V(u). Let u0 be the highest weight of the PRV component. This takes the form y(ul + w0u2) for some y E W. Then
i) I1~11 > 11-1 -+-wo~211- II~oll. ii) ( u - uo, p) > 0, with equality if and only if u - uo. Hence II~ + pll > I1~o + pll, w i t h equality if and only if u - uo. This gives the lemma. Kl Exercises
Let A1, A2, A3 be dominant weights.
1) One knows (but this is quite difficult) that Annu(n+)
g--)~l - - E
U(l~nt-)x~O~V'/~l)nt-l"
c~Err
2) Recall that ea~ ® e_~ 1 is a cyclic vector for V(A3) @ V(')~I). (Here, V(-A1) denotes the simple module with lowest weight -A1. It is isomorphic to V(A1)*.) Let V(A2)~;_Xl denote the subspace of vectors in V(A2) of weight A a - A1 and annihilated by Annu(,+)e_a I . Construct an isomorphism Hom,(V(A3) ® V ( - A , ) ,
V(A2))--7-+ V(A2)~;_A1.
3) Deduce from Frobenius reciprocity that dimHom,(V(A1) ® V(A2) ' V(Aa)) - dim V(A2) ~1 A3 --A 1 " 4) Define -1, "2, u0 as in Lemma 5.3. Using (1), verify that
V(-o) ul - ~ nt-wo ° ~ v2 -- - V ( - o ) ~ + ~ o ~ 5) Deduce from (1)-(4) that dimHom~(V(ul) ® V(u2), V(u0)) - 1. This proves the existence and uniqueness of the PRV component. (See [W2, Section 9] for further details.) Recall the notation of Lecture 4. Suppose r c P(R) + has level s. Take j E { 1 , 2 , . . . , s } , and let uj denote the highest weight of the PRV component Pj of Vj ® V(7). Set
.
~J =
II-j + pll 2 -I1~ + pll 2 2j(~, ~)
"
78
A. Joseph
Take A - ~- + Theorem
T
U j 03.
5.4
N(/~)'-
U ( m ) ( P j ® Cu;~) • j -
1,2,...,s
is a U(g)-
submodule of N (~).
We give the proof for j - 1, which is a little easier. By definition, the simple I-module P1 has highest weight # - Ul + u ~ . I ~ + pll ~ -
I~ + pll ~ =
Then
I1-~ + p I~ - I 1 ~ + p I~ - 2(~ - -1, ~ ) ~ Y 2~
(~ -
"1 -
~, ~).
Yet c~ occurs with multiplicity 1 in any root - ~ of m - , and so ( r - u l - ~ , w ) = 0. L e m m a 5.1 shows that y ~ a +
( x ~ e , , x~eu} - O. Yet x~eu E V(A),
on which the form is positive definite.
Thus, x~eu, -
O, V c~ C R +, as
required. [5] Remarks For the general case, one notes that ( r - u k Moreover, the u~ • k - 1, 2 , . . . , s are strictly decreasing and
kcx, w) -
[m+, Vk] c [~Vk-1 ÷ Vk-1
0.
(5.1)
by [EJ, 2.5, 3.6]. One proves inductively that ( , ) is positive definite on Vk ® V~ ® Cu~ for k < j and then the required assertion of the theorem by the procedure used for the case j - 1. W h e n 7 - - 0, one has
0
[]uj + pl[2 _ [[pl[2
uj --
2j(c~, ~)
[[pjl[2 + 2(p, #j)
=
2j(c~, ~)
"
Now the/3/ are always long roots and pairwise orthogonal. Thus, Ilpjll 2 = j (/31,/31). Consequently, 0
0
Uj_ 1 -- Uj --
J
1
j ( j _ 1)(c~ ~) E ( / 3 i - / 3 j , p) > 0, '
i=1
and so the fact that the uj0 are strictly decreasing is quite easy.
Thus,
apart from verifying (5.1), we have also proved the theorem for 7 - 0. This proves that the space of regular functions on the closure of an orbital variety contained in m + admits the structure of a U(g)-module of highest weight, namely N()~)/N()~) where ~ - u°~ • i -
1 , 2 , . . . , t. Further estimates of
this type show that this quotient is unitarizable and hence simple [E J, 8.2].
Chapter 2 Lecture 6
Orbital Varieties
79
T h e l a s t p l a c e of u n i t a r i t y
The description of the unitary module for 7- - 0, namely the L(A °) • i - 1 , 2 , . . . , t , was given by N. Wallach [W1]. The set A° - 0 > A° > ..- > At° is often called the Wallach set.
Their relation with orbital varieties
(using a slightly different language) is due to Harris and Jakobsen [H J]. It was realized (particularly by M. Kashiwara and M. Vergne [KV]), that the tensor product of unitary modules is again unitary. In particular, given that the L(A[) are unitary, then so are the L()~[) ® L()~°) • i -
1, 2 . . . . , t,
and moreover, for i _< s (the level of T) one recovers the L(A~) • i 1, 2 , . . . , s in this fashion as the orthogonal direct s u m m a n d with highest weight /~ + A°.
(The L(A~)" i > s are also unitary but correspond to
members of the continuous family of unitary modules occurring before the first reduction point is reached.) Moreover, one can show that all unitary modules are obtained in this fashion (excluding the continuous families of induced ones). u~-u~
This can be regarded as explaining the independence of
on T and on i, j, since A~ - A ~ + A °. Note again that 1 ° - 0
and corresponds to the trivial module, whereas tensoring L(A °) with itself i times gives L(A°+I). One may call L()~ °) the generalized metaplectic representation. Notice we have now solved the purely algebraic problem of quantizing all orbital varieties lying in any nilradical (of a parabolic subalgebra) that is commutative. In this, the positive definiteness of the form leads to a significant simplification. However following [E J, Section 2] and as noted in Lecture 7, one also obtains this result by more naive algebraic calculations. It thus essentially remains to establish unitarity at the last place A[, and this was a point of view emphasized by H. P. Jakobsen [Ja]. However, his analysis was case by case and rather complicated. easy intrinsic proof.
Here, we give an
Simultaneously with to the Jakobsen classification,
one should also mention, the unitary highest weight modules were classified by T. J. Enright, R. Howe, and N. R. Wallach [EHW]. The present analysis comes from joint work with T. J. Enright [E J]. Set A - A[. Theorem 5.4 established the existence of the quotient N ( A ) / N ( A ) . Now we prove its unitarity. Set
R< - { . e
+
v,
+ p) < 1}
A. Joseph
80
and Ft = UieN f~i, where Fti = { r - 71 - 7 2 . . . . . 7i17i E R<}. (Here, the 7i need not be distinct.) Let ft + denote the set of {~-dominant elements in f~; that is, a + = { h C a [ ( c x v,8)_>0, g a C r r ~ } . Our aim is to prove the following [E J, 7.9]. P r o p o s i t i o n 6.1
Every ~-type of N(A)/N(/~) belongs to f~+ + u[aJ.
Let us first show how this establishes unitarity at the last place.
Take 7 e P(R) +, and set ~ - 7 + u[w. Then N()~)/N()~) is unitarizable (and simple).
T h e o r e m 6.2
Proof: If N(A)/N(A) were not simple, then some highest weight ~ of a submodule would have to satisfy I1~ c + P]I = IIA + PlI. Further, taking account of Corollary 5.2, it is enough to show that I1" + Pll > IIA + Pll for every ~-dominant w e i g h t , ¢ A of N()~)/N()~). By the proposition, we can w r i t e , = 7 - 5 + u [ ~ with 5 C NR< \ {0}. Then the required inequality will result from 2(5, A + p) < (5, 5). Now, 5-
E
7i
"~i E R<
and (7i, 7j) ~ 0, because in R + the sum of two roots is not a root. Hence,
> Z
"~iER<
+ p),
by definition of R<. Moreover, the second inequality is strict, as 5 ~: 0. [3 We now sketch a proof of the proposition. Set R> = Rn \ R<, and let m< (resp., m>) denote the subspace of m := m - spanned by the root vectors x_~ : 7 E R< (resp., R>). An easy verification gives Lemma6.3 i)[n + , m < ] C m < . ii) [n~-,m>] C m>. Let Me(v) denote the Verma module for ~ with highest weight ~-. Consider M := m ® Mc(7) as ~-module for the diagonal action. It has a Verma flag [D, 7.6.14] with quotients isomorphic to the M ~ ( T - 7 ) " 7 C R +. Moreover, writing My = U(n~-)(x_~ ® er) and
-~ER<
~,ER>
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
81
then by Lemma 6.3(i), M< identifies with a submodule of M and M> can be viewed as the quotient M/M<; that is, we have an exact sequence 0
> M<
>M
> M>
>0
(6.1)
of U(£)-modules. One checks that [ I T - ' 7 + P~ll # IIw- ~ ' + pcll for all 7 E R< and "7' C R>. Using the center of U(t~), it follows that (6.1) splits. Let M~ denote the image of M> in M. L e m m a 6.4
P1 is the image of M~ under the map m ® Mc(~)
, r. ® v ( ~ ) .
Proof: Observe that M r identifies in the Verma flag of M with Mc(~--'7). NOW,
I1~ + p - ~11~ = I1~ + pll ~ + (~, ~ ) - 2(~, ~ + p) ~ I1~ + pll 2 if and only if ~/C R>. Then the assertion follows from Theorem 5.4.71 it is not hard to deduce Proposition 6.1 from Lemma 6.4, though in working out the details it is convenient to work with the tensor algebra of m rather than the symmetric algebra, as the appropriate quotients are easier to identify. This completes the proof of unitarity in the last place and with it the classification of unitarizable highest weight modules. Of course, far more detailed results are available [E J, E]. For example, one has [E J, 4.2] an explicit general formula for u i • i - 1 , 2 ,.. . , s, w h i c h f o r i - l g i v e s u I - 1 + ~ 1 IS1,~1 + 2(pc,/3 v ) - 0 - + p , /3v ), where/3 is the unique highest root and
S1,7 - {~ e Rc+ [ (T, .)iv)_ 1, (/3, 7 v) -- 2}. (This is empty in the simply laced case.) That N(A) is in fact the maximal submodule of N(A) for an arbitrary unitary parameter I results from [E] or [DES].
A. Joseph
82 Lecture 7
Q u a n t i z a t i o n of o r b i t a l v a r i e t i e s
Let V c n + be the closure of an orbital variety and I(V) C S ( n - ) its ideal of definition. As noted in Lecture 1, one may interpret the quantization of V as the construction of a highest weight module N(A) : )~ E b* with highest weight vector e~ of weight A such that gr A n n u ( , - ) e), = I(V).
(7.1)
A particularly intriguing aspect of (7.1) is the determination and meaning of ~ + p, which in general can neither be integral nor regular. Physicists may recognize ~ as the analog of the zero point energy that arises in the quantization of a Hamiltonian system. One may remark that (7.1)implies [J7, Section 8.2] that A n n N ( ~ ) i s completely prime. Thus, a positive answer to quantization would construct a large part if not all of Primc U(fl). As noted in Lecture 6, the preceding problem was completely solved in the case when N(~) can be a unitarizable module. Then, the possible values of ~ define the Wallach set. For fl = s[(n) : n _< 6, this problem was solved by E. Benlolo in her thesis. To appreciate the amount of work involved, we remark that for ~[(6) there are 76 orbital varieties that have to be individually quantized. An important result of hers [B] is that there are two of these orbital varieties in ~[(6) that cannot be made to satisfy (7.1) if N(~) is required to be simple, but which paradoxically do satisfy (7.1) for some nonsimple N(~). This introduces some obvious difficulties, in particular the significance of ~, which can now also serve for some other orbital variety. However, one can "canonically" replace ~ by the highest weight of the necessarily unique simple submodule of N(~) whose associated variety is V. A sophisticated approach to (7.1) would no doubt cunningly exploit the fact that V is Lagrangian and is even (see Lecture 8) the image under the moment map of a conormal to a B-orbit in G/B. At present, we do not even understand the possible nonintegrality of ~ in geometric terms. Thus, one can at present only propose the naive approach indicated in the following. The solution to (7.1) naturally decomposes into three stages. 1) Find a system of generators for I(V).
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
83
2) Find a left ideal J(V) of U ( n - ) such that gr J(V) = I(V). 3) Give U(n-)/J(V) a left U(g)-module structure. The work of Benlolo indicates that (1) has the following solution when ft = s[(n). Let M be the n x n matrix with 0 above the diagonal, 1 on the diagonal, and for i > j having eij C n- c S ( n - ) as its ijth entry. Then
I(V) should take the form gr(al, a 2 , ' " , an}, where the ai are among the minors of M. Notice that then I(V) contains (gr al, gr a 2 , " - , gr an), and we remark t h a t there was one case found by Benlolo in s[(6) where this inclusion was strict. In the preceding, we can also interpret the eij as elements of U ( n - ) . This makes it possible to write down elements bl, b2,..., bn C U ( n - ) as corresponding "minors," though there is an obvious and significant ambiguity in doing so. These elements should generate J(V) as a left ideal. Whereas one may anticipate no difficulty in checking that gr J(V) D I(V), equality should only be a deeper consequence of the involutivity of V. Finally, for (3) it is sufficient to linearly order the bi (possibly using degree) and to solve the system of equations i-1
x~bie,x = 0 mod
a E 7r, i = 1 , 2 , . . . , n , j=l
for A. Heuristically, this should be possible because V is B-invariant. It leads to a condition on (A, c~v) that if not empty should be (miraculously) independent of i. This point of view does not integral or regular, nor that U(n-)/J(V) be the unitary case, one finds that (/~,c~v) = 0 noncompact root one has -(A,c~ v) = m - 1,
imply that A + p be either a simple U(g)-module. In if c~ E 7rc, whereas for the where m is the size of the
minor t h a t (Lecture 4) is the unique highest weight vector of the ~-module generating J(V). It turns out that the use of q u a n t u m groups facilitates steps (1) and (2). First, it gives a natural interpretation of the mysterious M matrix. Second, no ambiguities arise in step (2). Finally, the formalism naturally generalizes to arbitrary ft semisimple. All this is now detailed, the notation being essentially that of [Jll]. Let Uq(ft) denote the Drinfeld-Jimbo quantization of the enveloping algebra U(ft) of a complex semisimple Lie algebra g. It is a Hopf algebra over C(q) that has essentially the same finite dimensional modules as U(t~).
84
A. Joseph
Set A - C[q,q-1], and identify C with A / ( q - 1}. Let UA(~) be the Asubalgebra of Uq(ft) generated by the obvious "canonical generators" of Uq(~). Up to a minor triviality, UA($)®A C identifies [Jll, 4.1.15] with
u(g).
One may adopt the construction of the algebra R[G] of regular functions on G to construct the Hopf dual of Uq(g) as follows. For each w 6 P ( R ) +, let Y(~) be the simple finite dimensional Uq($)-module with highest weight ~. For all ~ 6 Y(w)*, v e V(~), let c~,v be the element a ~-. ~(av) of Uq(9)*. Then the c~v generate a Hopf subalgebra Rq[G] of Uq(9)*. We write c~,v - c~,~ when ~ (resp., v) has weight # (resp., ~). Define an order relation on P(R) through # _> ~ if # - ~ 6 NTr. Set RA[G] - {c 6 Rq[G] I c(UA(g)) C A}. One easily checks that Corresponding to the triangular decomposition 9 - n + ® ~ ® n - , one has subalgebras Uq(n +) of Uq(9). Let 7 be an isomorphism of the additive abelian group P(R) to a multiplicative abelian group T. In what follows, we must assume that Uq(g) is its so-called simply connected version with torus T, that is, Uq(9) - Uq(n-)TUq(n+). The subalgebras Uq(n +) "Uq(n+)T are Hopf subalgebras. Writing UA(n +) -- UA(I~)CI Uq(n+), one has UA(n +) @A C - U(n +) by [Jll, 3.4.5]. The advantage of quantum groups arises from the Drinfeld isomorphism, first given in the context of topological Hopf algebras but reinterpreted in a purely algebraic context in [Jll, 9.2.12] as follows. Consider the map Rq[G] ---+Uq (b +)* defined by restriction, the kernel of which we denote by J ± . To describe its image, we remark (see, for example, [Jll, 9.2.10]) that there exists a nondegenerate skew-Hopf pairing ~: Uq (b-) × Uq (b +) C(q). This defines in particular an injection O"b H (a H ~(a,b)) of Uq(b-) into Uq(b+) *, which is a homomorphism of algebras and an antihomomorphism of coalgebras. The result in [Jll, 9.2.11] asserts that Im(~ ' - Im(Rq[G] ~ Uq(b+)*). This and a corresponding result with + interchanged eventually gives T h e o r e m 7.1
There is an isomorphism ~+" Rq[G]/J + ~ ~Uq(b+) of Hopf
algebras. In what follows, it is convenient to consider the algebra isomorphism • '" Uq(b-) ~ ~Rq[G]/J +, since this more closely corresponds to the vector space isomorphism b- ~ >(b+)* obtained from the Killing form and which
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
85
allows one to consider S ( n - ) as the algebra of regular functions on n + and as the graded dual of U(n +) viewed as a graded algebra through weight space decomposition. Set [3~ - {~ E 13" ] (~, c~v) C Q, V c~ E 7r}. By adjoining nth roots of q to C(q), one may view A E ~ as the character on T given by T(p) H q(',a). From this, one may define a highest weight module Nq()~) of Uq(g). Such a module is given by a left ideal L of Uq (b-). Through (I)', one may identify L as a left ideal of Rq[G]/J +. Moreover, the latter identifies with the algebra of matrix coefficients c~,. in which the entries strictly above the diagonal (i.e., when p ;~ ~,) are set equal to zero. Again, the torus element c cO, , , must act by a scalar on the highest weight vector ex of Nq(A) (specifically, the scalar q - ( " ~ ) via [Jll, 9.2.11(ii)]). Thus, L contains the left ideal L~
of I~q[G]//J + generated by the c ~ , , - q-("'a)l • co C P(R) +, # C P(R). Consequently, the diagonal matrix coefficients specialize to 1 in the q ~ 1 limit. Finally, when G = SL(n), the algebra Rq[G] is generated by the cO , where w corresponds to the n-dimensional defining matrix coefficients c~,, representation. These matrix coefficients may be written a s Cij : i,j = 1, 2 , . . . , n and then, for an appropriate ordering, J + is generated by the Cij : j > i. For the k-fundamental weight a;k (corresponding to the kth exterior power of w), the matrix coefficients C~cOkcO ,YcOk k " x,y C W are the q u a n t u m k x k minors in the cij, and of course these specialize to ordinary minors in the q ~ 1 limit. From all this, we can understand that our previous conjectured description of I(V) has a more intrinsic formulation. Our program for quantizing an orbital variety closure V can be expressed as determining some A e 13~ and a left ideal Jq(V,A) of Uq(b-) containing J~ " - }-~,eP(R)Uq(b-)(T(p)- q(a'")l) such that 1) The Uq(b-)-module structure on Nq(A) := Uq(b-)/Jq(V,A) extends to a Uq(g)-module structure. 2) I(V) = g r ( J ~ ( V ) ® A C), where J'A(V) = rb'(Jq(V, A))A I m R a [ G ] . For (2), we note that (I)'(Uq(n-))N ImRA[G] = {c e O'(Uq(n-)) ] c(UA(n+)) C A} and so coincides with the A-subalgebra S A defined analogously to S + of [Jll, 3.4.5]. Thus, S A ®A C coincides with S ( n - ) viewed as the graded dual of U(n +) (see the paragraph following Theorem 7.1). Since ~ ' ( J ~ ) - L~, it follows that the (c~,u - 1) belong to J~A(V)®A C, which may therefore be viewed as an ideal of S ( n - ) , which is [~-stable but not necessarily graded for gradation by degree. Defining formal character
A. Joseph
86
ch as in [Jll, 3.4.7], one obtains from (2) that =
(s(.-)/i(v)).
(7.2)
On the other hand, we can define a second specialization J(V) of Jq(V,A) by setting J(V) = JA(V)®A C, where JA(V) = Jq(V,A) N UA(n-)T. It identifies with a left ideal of U ( n - ) . Moreover, N(A) := V ( n - ) / J ( V ) has by (1) the structure of U(g)-module of highest weight A, and ch Nq ( A ) = ch N(£).
(7.3)
The obvious diagram involving the preceding two specializations fails to be commutative. Yet (7.2) and (7.3) imply that PV(N(~,)) = PV. Now, s u m o f the characteristic polynomials of the orbital varieties occurring in V(N(A)), and so by their linear independence (Corollary 3.5)
PV(N(A)) is a
we deduce that V ( N ( A ) ) = V. Thus, gr J(V) C I(V), and equality holds by (7.2) and (7.3) again. Although (1) and (2) can be expected to essentially uniquely determine Jq(V, A) if it exists, we would clearly like to have a formula for it analogous to that for I(V). Toward this aim we note that ~' gives Uq(b-) a Uq(b +) bimodule structure! Then to satisfy (1) we need only require that O'(Jq(V, A)) be invariant with respect to the adjoint action of Uq(b+) (defined by (a,b) H axbS(a2) for all a E Uq(b+), b C Rq[G]/J +, where A(a) = al ® a2 in the sum convention of [Jll, 1.1.8] and $ is the antipode). This is the quantum analog of the orbital variety closure V being B-stable. Finally, ~'(Jq(V, A)) is a left ideal of Rq[G]/J + ~-~ Uq(b+) *, and so it is natural to think of it as an ideal of zeros of some subset. We already require it to contain L~ and to be ad Uq(b+)-stable. If V = V(w), one should therefore further require it to vanish on some quantum analog of n + n w(n+). This should be a subspace of Uq(n +) with basis formed by choosing for each 7 C R + n w - l R - a weight vector a~ of weight 7. Such vectors can be obtained using the Lusztig-Soibelman automorphisms [Jll, 10.2], but this procedure is not canonical. An alternative would be to make the choice specified by the conclusion of [J13, 4.5]. Finally, A must be chosen to ensure that Jq(V, A) is big enough to satisfy (2). Although this point of view may seem a little far-fetched, it is nevertheless true that the generic prime (two-sided) ideals of Rq[G] can be viewed as ideals of zeros [J14, Theorem 1].
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
87
Exercises 1) Assume N(A) satisfies (7.1). Show that N(A) has a simple socle, say L(A'), and that V ( N ( ) ~ ) / L ( ) ~ ' ) ) C V ( N ( A ) ) . 2) Take 9 of type G2 with 7r - {c~,/3}, where c~ is the short root. Let V be the closure of the unique 3-dimensional orbital variety. Show that I ( V ) is generated by x_~ and by three further quadratic generators that span the unique 3-dimensional representation of M x M, where M =
CX-/3 0 CX-(c~+~) (~ CX-(2c~+~) 0 CX-(3c~+~) viewed as an [~® Cx_~ ® Cx~module. Let a-2z-2~ denote its highest weight vector. Solve the equation xf~a_2z_2~e), = 0 for (~, ~v) and hence determine the solution to (7.1) in
this case. Show that N(A) = L(A). This constructs a completely prime ideal, namely Ann L(A), the associated variety of which is the unique 6dimensional orbit. In this example, one fails [Z] to have an embedding U ( ~ ) / A n n N ( ~ ) ~ D ( V ( N ( ) ~ ) ) ) unless one localizes at the Ore set generated by the image of the highest weight vector.
Lecture 8
F u r t h e r results and p e r s p e c t i v e s
Take A - A° • i - 1, 2 , . . . , t, that is, in the Wallach set. One has [LS, Chapter IV for ~ classical; J10, 4.2 in general]. T h e o r e m 8.1
Ann L(A) is a maximal ideal.
This is false for arbitrary unitary parameters. It can happen that Ann L(A) is strictly contained in the augmentation ideal. E. Gvirsk (unpublished) classified all such occurrences for ~ = ~[(n). One has a simple sumciency [J10, 6.8] criterion for AnnL(A) not to be maximal, but this does not quite seem to be a necessary one. Take A in the Wallach set. That Ann L(A) is completely prime is an easy consequence of the fact that Annv(m-)e~ is prime. Again, this fails for arbitrary unitary parameters.
However, one does have the following
curious fact [J10, 5.16]. Theorem
8.2
A s s u m e )~ a unitary parameter, say )~ - ~- + u iT ~.
Then
Q(A) := A n n u ( m - ) L ( ~ ) is a prime ideal. As a fairly easy consequence, one can show [J10, 6.5] that the rank r k ( U ( g ) / A n n L ( A ) ) divides dim V(r), but it need not be 1 nor dim V(T).
A. Joseph
88
It can be 1 even if dim V(~-) > 1 by [J10, 8.91. A table describing Q(A) as a function of A is given in [J10, 7.13]. We remark that the proof of Theorem 8.2 is a rather delicate matter. The result is quite false for nonunitary parameters and especially those which are unitary for the compact real form. This seems to exclude any easy shortcuts. One has a remarkable surjectivity theorem [J7]. Call a simple highest weight module L quasi-induced if it is a submodule of some E ® M with E of finite dimension and M a simple highest weight module induced from a proper parabolic subalgebra p of 0- One may easily show that L, M have the same associated varieties, and the latter is in some obvious sense nontrivially induced. Thus, it is easy to find L that are not quasi-induced. For example, L(A) for A in the Wallach set is quasi-induced if and only if its associated variety is the nilradical of a parabolic subalgebra, and in 5[(n), for instance, this only happens when the noncompact simple root is either
OL1 o r Ctn_ 1. L e t
F(L) (resp., A(L)) denote the set of g (resp., n - )
locally finite elements of End L. T h e o r e m 8.3
Assume L is not quasi-induced. Then A ( L ) = F(L).
If Ann L is maximal, then F(L) can only differ from U ( g ) / A n n L if their rings of fractions differ. Using this, one may check that F(L(,~)) = U(O)/AnnL(A) for A in the Wallach set. On the other hand, in this case A(L()~)) is just the algebra of differential operators on V(Anngrj: L(A)). This gives the following result [J10, 4.5], due to T. Levasseur and J. T. Stafford for 0 classical [LS]. C o r o l l a r y 8.4
Except if 0 = s[(n) and a
=
o~ 1 o r
an-l,
one has
U(o)/L()~) ~, D [ P ( A n n g r y L ( A ) ) ] for all )~ in the WaUach set. A key step in the proof of Theorem 8.3 comes from the study of (9algebras, that is, U(0)-algebras that as modules belong to the (9 category. There are surprisingly few such objects, especially if one demands that the algebra in question be semiprime [J12, 5.6]. In the completely prime case, this can be generalized to the case when 0 is Kac-Moody as in what follows. Let m be a Lie algebra and A an associative algebra. We say that an algebra homomorphism ~: U(m)
~ End A is a Leibniz action of U(m) on
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
89
A if ¢(x) E Der A for all x c m. By definition, this makes A a U(m)-algebra. We say that the action is nondegenerate if A m reduces to scalars. Take g a symmetrizable Kac-Moody Lie algebra with triangular decomposition = n + ® 0 ® n - . Let ac be the Chevalley antiautomorphism of g (defined on generators through crc(x+~) = xT~, V a C ~). Given M C Ob O, consider M* as a left s-module through ac and set 5M C {m C M* ] dim U(O)m < c~}. Then 5M is a U(~)-submodule and belongs to (.9.
Let ~p,¢1 be ~ equivariant nondegenerate Leibniz actions of U(n +) on S ( n - ) . Then there is an algebra isomorphism intertwining ~p, ~p' and commuting with O.
L e m m a 8.5
Proof: Let c" S ( n - ) ~ (E be the augmentation, and define a pairing U(n +) x S ( n - ) ~ C by (x,a) - c(¢(x)a). Then (xy, a) - c(~p(xy)a) (x,~p(y)a) for all x , y e U(a+), a e S ( n - ) . Clearly, (1, 1) - 1 and ( , ) respects weight space decomposition. Let ~ E Nrr be minimal such that some nonzero a_ z C S ( n - ) of weight - Z lies in k e r ( , }. Then Z > 0, and the foregoing formula shows that a_ z is invariant hence zero. Since d i m U ( n + ) ~ - d i m S ( n - ) _ z < c~, V Z e N~, one concludes that {, ) i s nondegenerate. Similar assertions hold for the pairing defined by (x, a ) ' - c(¢'(x)a). We may therefore define an [}-linear isomorphism ~a of S ( n - ) by (x, ~a(a)) = (x, a}'. Then, ( x , ' @ ( y ) ( ~ ( a ) ) ) - ( x y , ~ a ( a ) ) - (xy, a)' -- (x, ¢' (y)a)' - (x, ~a(~p'(y)a)), which shows that ~a intertwines the actions. Clearly, p(1) = 1. To establish ~a(ab) - ~(a)~(b) = 0, it is enough to show that the left hand side is annihilated by ¢(x) : x E n + when x, a, b are all weight vectors. This results from ¢(x), ¢'(x) being derivations and from ~ intertwining ~, ~ / u s i n g an obvious induction on weight. E3 Lemma 8.5 is needed to justify the claim just preceding (.) of [J13, 4.4]. Such an action obtains from, say, the conclusion of [Jll, 3.4.6], which holds without any assumptions on the Cartan matrix (in the sense of [Jll, 3.1.2]). However, we shall also want S ( n - ) to have a U(g)-algebra structure. For this recall that, after Kac, ~ admits a nondegenerate invariant bilinear form K that identifies (b-)* with b+ (this only needs the Cartan matrix
90
A. Joseph
to be symmetrizable [Jll, 4.2.2]). The Verma module M(0) of highest weight 0 is just U(g)/U(g)b + ~ U(n-). Since U(g)b + is a coideal and a left ideal, (U(g)/U(g)b)* is a subalgebra of U(g)* admitting an action of g on the right through the coproduct [Jll, 1.1.6] and hence by derivations. This gives M(0)* a U(g)-algebra structure. The submodule 6M(O) is also a subalgebra and identifies with Crc(S(n+)) - S ( n - ) as a U(O)-algebra. Finally, S ( n - ) n+ - H°(n+,6M(O))- H0(n-, M ( 0 ) ) - C by [Jll, 4.2.9]. This result can be improved as follows. By transposing the adjoint action of b+ on itself under K, one obtains a linear action of b+ on b- and hence an [3-equivariant Leibniz action of U(n +) on S(b-). For each positive root ,3~ let {a~} be a basis for n~- and {bJz} a basis for n-z. One checks that a}(bJ_z) - /36ij. Let I be a maximal ideal of S([3) not containing any positive root. Then the Leibniz action of U(n +) on S(b-) factors to an [3-equivariant Leibniz action of U(n +) on S ( n - ) " ~~ S(b-)/I S ( n - ) , in which the pairing n - × n + --+ C, defined by restricting ( , } of the lemma, is nondegenerate. From this, one easily checks that S ( n - ) n+ reduces to scalars. By the lemma, any such action is equivalent to the foregoing (linear) one. In particular, it follows that 6M(O) admits a subspace V isomorphic to n - as an O-module satisfying U(b +)V C V • C. Moreover, given any compatible nontrivial U(b+)-algebra structure on 6M(O) (that is, compatible with its U(g)-module structure and for which (6M(0)) "+ - C as an algebra), it follows from [Jll, 3.4.4(i)] that 6M(O) is isomorphic to S(V) as a U(b+)-algebra. The foregoing may be generalized as follows. Given 7r~ C 7r, let p~, b + be the parabolic subalgebra of g whose Levi factor r~, contains (3 and the root subspaces corresponding to R ~ := ZTr~ A R. Let m~+ be the nilradical of Pr', and set m~, - ac(m +,). Set M r , ( 0 ) " - M(O)/~-]~cr' M(-a), which is just the generalized Verma module obtained by inducing from the trivial one-dimensional pr,-module. Then 6Mr,(O) is isomorphic to S(m~,) as an [3-module and hence is actually a U(g)-subalgebra of 6M(O), which we can view as S(m;,). Again, (6Mr,(O))m+~' identifies with (Mr,(O)/m;Mr,(O))* and hence reduces to scalars. On the other hand, taking I to contain just the positive roots in R '+ gives an 0-equivariant Leibniz action of V(m+,) on S(m~,) with a nondegenerate pairing mr-, x mr+ --+ C. Then, by the +
analog of Lemma 8.5 with n + [3 replaced by mr, , rr,, we conclude that 6Mr,(O) admits a subspace V isomorphic to m~-, as an rr,-module and satisfying V(pr,)V C V ® C. Then, for any compatible nontrivial V(pr,)-
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
91
algebra structure on 5M~,(O), we conclude from [Jll, 3.4.4(i)] that 5M~,(O) is isomorphic to S ( V ) as a U(p~,)-algebra. Let us now show that one may obtain a nondegenerate pairing rn~, x rn~+ --~ C from the adjoint action of rn~, on ~ (rather than the coadjoint action we have considered). This requires that the Cartan matrix be integrable in the sense of [J12, 3.1.2] and not just symmetric. Set f i t ; , - ad U(n-)(EE~c~E~\ ~, C x _ ~ ) c rn;,. Lemma
8.6
One has r~-~, - m-~, .
If not, there exists/3 E R + \ R I+ minimal and a nonzero vector bz E + of weight/3 such that K ( b z , ~n-~,) - O. Certainly,/3 ¢ 7r. Assume c~ E 7r 1TtTr~ Proof:
is such t h a t / 3 - ( ~ E R + \ R I+. Then, the invariance and nondegeneracy of K combined with the choice of/3 imply that (ad x_~)b z - 0. Setting b_ z (7~(bz) gives (ad x ~ ) b _ z - O. Let e0 be the canonical generator of M~,(0) of weight 0. The preceding property of b_ z implies that x ~ ( b _ z e o ) - 0 for all c~ E 7r. Then ( p - / 3 , p - / 3 ) - (p, p) by [J 1 l, 4.2.9], which is impossible by, say, [Jll, A.1.3]. [5] For each c~ E 7r \ 7r~, one may choose p _ ~ E 5M~,(O) of weight -c~ such that x ~ p _ ~ - K ( x _ ~ , x ~ ) . Take /3 E R + \ R '+, c~ G 7r\Tr'. One checks that K((ad a_(z_~))x_~,bz) for all a_(z_a) E n of weight - ( / 3 - a ) (ad a _ ( z _ ~ ) ) x _ ~ - ~ ( a _ ( z _ ~ ) p _ ~ ). -
L e m m a 8.7
(8.1)
and bz E rn~, + of weight /3. Set
n extends to a linear surjection of ~ - ~ 6 ~ \ ~, U ( n - ) p _ ~ onto
m~, s a t i s f y i n g / ( ( n ( P - Z ) , Proof:
- bza_(z_~)p_ ~
bz) - DZP-Z"
Suppose that ~--~6~\~' a - ( Z - ~ ) P - ~ - O, and set a-z--
E
(ad a - ( z - ~ ) ) x - a "
~E~\~'
The formula (8.1) shows that K(a_;~, bz) - 0 for all bz E m~+ of weight /3. Then a_z - 0 by the nondegeneracy of K. Hence ~ is a well defined map, which by Lemma 8.6 is surjective. By construction, it satisfies the required identity. [5] Let V I be an O-stable complement of ker ~. The identity of Lemma 8.7 and the nondegeneracy of K imply that we have an injection S ( V I)
A. Joseph
92
5M~,(O) of O-modules. Yet as [3-modules both sides are isomorphic to S(m~-,), and so S(V')--%,SM~,(O). Remark
It does not seem obvious that we can choose V = V'.
8.8 Let A be an O-algebra such that A n+ = C as an algebra. Then there exists 7r' C zr such that A ~_ 8M~,(O) as a U(9)-algebra.
Proposition
Proof:
One defines 7r' := {a e ~r ] A_a = 0}.
Since H o ( n - , S A ) =
C by the hypothesis, it follows that 5A is a quotient of M~,(0).
Then
A ~-~ 5M~,(O). Yet A contains V' in the conclusion of L e m m a 8.7, and so A ~ >SM~,(O). It remains to check that 5M~,(O) can admit only one (nontrivial) V(9)-algebra structure. In this it is enough to show that the V(p~, )algebra isomorphism ~: S(V) ~ ~SM~,(O) satisfies x _ ~ ( b _ ~ ) = ~(x_~b_~) for all a C 7r and all b_z E 5M~, (0) of weight -/3. This follows by the obvious induction on weights applying x~ : 7 C 7r to both sides and using that (SM~, (0))"+ reduces to scalars. D Remark. Exercise.
This gives an alternative proof of [J12, 3.6]. Let ~ be a nondegenerate O-equivariant Leibniz action of
V ( n - ) on S ( n - ) .
Let ¢ ' be an 0-equivariant action of U(n +) on S ( n - )
commuting with ~. Show that ¢~ is Leibniz. One may place the question of quantizing orbital varieties in a wider context as follows. Let 7) denote the (possibly twisted) sheaf of differential operators on the flag variety G / B . The Beilinson-Bernstein theory [BB] relates U(g)-modules with an appropriate central character to coherent 7)-modules on the flag variety G / B . This allows one to cut down to the family of U(9)-modules corresponding to holonomic/)-modules, which seem to be the most interesting.
Now the associated variety 1;(j£4) in
T * ( G / B ) of a coherent 7)-module A4 can be defined in an analogous way to the associated variety I;(M) C 9" of a U(9)-module M, using the filtration on differential operators defined by degree. As before, 1;(A/I) is homogeneous and involutive. By definition, A/i is holonomic if dim ~;(J~/[) = ! dim T* ( G / B ) - dim G / B Then 1;(A/I) must be the closure of the conormal C ( Y ) of some smooth subvariety Y C G / B . By definition, this is the subvariety of T * ( G / B ) with base Y such that the fiber over each y E Y is just the cotangent space T*y,G/B . Obviously, C(Y) has dimension n and is involutive and homogeneous. Let 7r:T*(G/B) ' 9" be the moment 2
"
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
93
map. Expressing T*(G/B) as G XB n*, this is just the map (g, x) ~ gx defined by the (coadjoint) action of G on ~*. Suppose M is the U(~)module corresponding to M under the Beilinson-Bernstein equivalence. By a result of W. Borho and J.-L. Brylinski [BBr, Theorem 1.9c], one has
~(V(M)) = V(M). Holonomic D-modules arise in the study of (ft, K)-modules. Here, K may be (the complexification of) a maximal compact subgroup of (a real form of) G or, more generally, a closed subgroup of G for which K \ G/B is finite (for example, B). The classification of simple (ft, K)-modules in terms of holonomic 79-modules was indicated by A. A. Beilinson and J. Bernstein [BB]. For such a module, the variety Y is a union of K orbits in
G/B.
The foregoing discussion (see also [Vo3]) motivates the following general question. Let K be as before. Let Y be a K-orbit in G/B, and set V = 7r(C(Y)). Can one give R[V] a natural structure of an admissible (fl, K)-module of finite length? This generalizes our previous question when V is orbital. One may anticipate that this will not be too easy to solve.
C o m m e n t s and further reading The main content of Lectures 1-6 and 8 was derived from the author's papers given in the bibliography. Lecture 7 was partly based on [B] and some new results on quantum groups [Jll]. A further study of characteristic polynomials and cells is made in [BBM], [Lu], and IT]. For an introduction to enveloping algebras, see [D] and [Jan2]. For the orbit method, one may consult the introduction to [BBG], and for a further point of view on the geometric approach to representation theory, the book of N. Chriss and V. Ginzburg [CG]. The integration method used in Lecture 3 is described in [BGV] and has been used notably in [R] and [V] to obtain results of a similar nature. For recent results on completely prime ideals, see [MG]. For the combinatorics of orbital varieties in s[(n), see [Me2]. Finally, the primitive ideal theory of quantum groups is developed in [Jll].
Acknowledgments I should like to express my appreciation to Professors Bent Orsted and Henrik Schlichtkrull for organizing a delightful meeting in Sandbjerg
A. Joseph
94
in which I had the opportunity to give these lectures. I should also like to thank Dr. Anna Melnikov for useful comments on the manuscript. References
[BB]
A. Beilinson and J. Bernstein, Localisation de ~ modules, C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris (A) 292 (1981), 15-18.
[B]
E. Benlolo, Sur la quantification de certaines varidtds orbitales, Bull. Sci. Math. 3 (1994), 225-241.
[BGV] N. Berline, E. Getzler, and M. Vergne, Heat Kernels and the Dirac Operator, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1991.
[BE]
J.-E. Bjbrk and E. K. Ekstrbm, Filtered A uslander-Gorenstein rings, pp. 425-448 in Operator Algebras, Unitary Representations, Enveloping Algebras, and Invariant Theory, Progress in Mathematics 92, Birkh£user, Boston, 1990.
[BBrl] W. Borho and J.-L. Brylinski, Differential operators on homogeneous spaces. II, Bull. Soc. Math. France 117 (1989), 167-210. [BBr2]
, Differential operators on homogeneous spaces. III, Invent. Math. 80 (1985), 1-68.
[BBM] W. Borho, J.-L. Brylinski, and R. MacPherson, Nilpotent Orbits, Primitive Ideals and Characteristic Classes, Progress in Mathematics 78, Birkh£user, Boston, 1989.
[BJ]
W. Borho and J. C. Jantzen, Uber primitive Ideale in der Einhiillenden einer halbeinfachen Lie-Algebra, Invent. Math. 39 (1977), 1-53.
[BBG] J. L. Brylinski, R. K. Brylinski, V. Guillemin and V. G. Kac (eds.), Lie Theory and Geometry: In Honor of Bertram Kostant, Progress in Mathematics 123, Birkh~user, Boston, 1994.
[cc]
N. Chriss and V. Ginzburg, Representation Theory and Complex Geometry, Birkh£user, Boston, 1994.
[DES] M. G. Davidson, T. J. Enright and R. J. Stanke, Differential Operators and Highest Weight Representations, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 455 (1991).
[D]
J. Dixmier, Alg~bres enveloppantes, Gauthier-Villars, Paris, 1974.
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
95
[Du]
M. Duflo, Sur la classification des ideaux primitifs dans l'alg~bre enveloppante d'une alg~bre de Lie semi-simple, Ann. of Math. 105 (1977), 107-120.
[E]
T. J. Enright, Analogues of Kostant's u cohomology formulas for unitary highest weight modules, J. reine angew. Math. 392 (1988), 27-36.
[EHW] T. J. Enright, R. Howe and N.R. Wallach, A classification of unitary highest weight modules, pp. 97-143 in Representation Theory of Reductive Groups, Progress in Mathematics 40, Birkh£user, Boston, 1983.
[EJ]
T. J. Enright and A. Joseph, An intrinsic classification of unitary highest weight modules, Math. Ann. 288 (1990), 571-594.
IF]
A. Freudenthal, Zur eben Oktavengeometrie, Indag. Math. 15 (1953), 195-200.
[C]
O. Gabber, The integrability of the characteristic variety, Amer. J. Math. 103 (1981), 445-468.
[HJ]
M. Harris and H. P. Jakobsen, Singular holomorphic representations and singular modular forms, Math. Ann. 259 (1982), 227-244.
[HI
S. Helgason, Differential Geometry and Symmetric @aces, Academic Press, London, 1962.
[Ho]
R. Hotta, On Joseph's construction of Weyl group representations, Tohoku Math. J. 36 (1984), 49-74.
[Ja]
H. P. Jakobsen, Hermitian symmetric spaces amd their unitary highest weight modules, J. Funct. Anal. 52 (1983), 385-412.
[Janl] J. C. Jantzen, Moduln mit einem hSchsten Gewicht, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 750, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979.
[Jan2]
, Einhiillende Algebren halbeinfachen Lie-Algebren, SpringerVerlag, Berlin, 1983.
[J1]
~ , W module structure in the primitive spectrum of the enveloping algebra of a semisimple Lie algebra, pp. 116-136 in NonCommutative Harmonic Analysis, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 728, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1979.
[j2]
~ , Dixmier's problem for Verma and principal series submodules, J. Loud. Math. Soc. 20 (1979), 193-204.
96
[J3]
A. Joseph ~ , Goldie rank in the enveloping algebra of a semisimple Lie algebra. II, J. Alg. 65 (1980), 284-306.
[J4]
~ , On the variety of a highest weight module, J. Alg. 88 (1984), 238-278.
[Js]
, On the associated variety of a primitive ideal, J. Alg. 93
(1985), 509-523.
[J6]
, A sum rule for scale factors in the Goldie rank polynomials,
J. Alg. 118 (1988), 276-311, Addendum 312-321.
[JT]
, A surjectivity theorem for rigid highest weight modules, In-
vent. Math. 92 (1988), 567-596.
[Js]
, On the characteristic polynomials for orbital varieties, Ann.
Ec. Norm. Sup. 22 (1989), 569-603.
[Jg]
, The surjectivity theorem, characteristic polynomials and induced ideals, pp. 85-98 in The Orbit Method in Representation Theory, Progress in Mathematics 82, Birkh~user, Boston, 1990.
[J10]
, Annihilators and associated varieties of unitary highest weight modules, Ann. Ec. Norm. Sup. 25 (1992), 1-45.
[Jll]
, Quantum Groups and their Primitive Ideals, SpringerVerlag, Berlin, 1995.
[J12]
~ , Rings which are modules in the Bernstein-Gelfand-Gelfand (9 category, J. Alg. 113 (1988), 110-126.
[J13]
~ , Enveloping algebras: Problems old and new, pp. 385-413 in Lie Theory and Geometry: In Honor of Bertram Kostant, Progress in Mathematics 123, Birkh~user, Boston, 1994.
[J14]
~ , Sur les ideaux gdndriques de l'alg~bre des fonctions sur un groupe alg~brique, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris ( I ) 3 2 1 (1995), 135-140.
Preprint, 1995.
[KV]
M. Kashiwara and M. Vergne, On the Segal-Shale-Weil representations and harmonic polynomials, Invent. Math. 44 (1978), 1-47.
[KL1] D. A. Kazhdan and G. Lusztig, Representations of CoxeterGroups and Hecke Algebras, Invent. Math. 53 (1979), 165-184. [KL2] ~ , A topological approach to Springer's representations, Adv. Math. 38 (1980), 222-228.
Chapter 2
Orbital Varieties
97
[LS]
T. Levasseur and J. T. Stafford, Rings of Differential Operators on Classical Rings of Invariants, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 412 (1989).
[Lu]
G. Lusztig, Characters of Reductive Groups over a Finite Field, Annals of Mathematics Studies 107, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1984.
[M]
I. G. Macdonald, Some irreducible representations of the Weyl groups, Bull. London Math. Soc. 4 (1972), 148-150.
[Ma]
O. Mathieu, Bicontinuity of the Dixmier map, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 4 (1991), 837-863.
[MG]
W. M. McGovern, Completely Prime Maximal Ideals and Quantization, Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 519 (1994).
[Mel]
A. Melnikov, Irreducibility of the associated variety of simple highest weight modules in s[(n), C.R. Acad. Sci. Paris (I) 316 (1993), 5357.
[Me2]
, Orbital varieties and order relations on Young tableaux, Preprint, 1994.
[P]
K. R. Parthasarathy, Criteria for the unitarizability of some highest weight modules, Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. 86 (1980), 1-24.
[PRV] K. R. Parthasarathy, R. Ranga Rao, V. S. Varadarajan, Representations of complex Lie groups and Lie algebras, Ann. of Math. 85 (1967), 383-429.
[R]
W. Rossmann, Nilpotent orbital integrals in a real semisimple Lie algebra and representations of Weyl groups, pp.263-287 in Operator Algebras, Unitary Representations, Enveloping Algebras, and Invariant Theory, Progress in Mathematics 92, Birkh~user, Boston 1990.
IS]
N. Spaltenstein, On the fixed point set of a unipotent element on the variety of Borel subgroups, Topology 16 (1977), 203-204.
[St]
R. Steinberg, On the desingularization of the unipotent variety, Invent. Math. 36 (1976), 209-224.
IT]
T. Tanisaki, Characteristic varieties of highest weight modules and primitive quotients, Adv. Studies in Pure Math. 14 (1988), 1-30.
IV]
M. Vergne, Polyn6mes de Joseph et reprdsentations de Springer, Ann. Ec. Norm. Sup. 23 (1990), 543-562.
98
A. Joseph
[Vol]
D. A. Vogan, Ordering in the primitive spectrum of a semisimple Lie algebra, Math. Ann. 248 (1980), 195-203.
[Vo2]
, The orbit method and primitive ideals for semisimple Lie algebras, Canad. Math. Soc. Conf. Proc. 5 (1986), 281-316.
[Vo3]
, Associated varieties and unipotent representations, pp. 315-388 in Harmonic Analysis on Reductive Groups, Progress in Mathematics 101, Birkh£user, Boston, 1991.
[Wl]
N. R. Wallach, The analytic continuation of the discrete series, I, II, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 251 (1979), 1-17, 19-37.
[w2] [z]
, Real Reductive Groups L Academic Press, New York, 1988.
M. Zahid, Orbite nilpotente minimale en type G2 et operateurs diffdrentiels, Th~se, Pattie 2, Univ. Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, 1991.
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups and Clifford-Klein Forms of Pseudo-Riemannian Homogeneous Manifolds TOSHIYUKI KOBAYASHI
University of Tokyo
CONTENTS
Introduction Clifford-Klein forms Discontinuous actions (discrete and continuous version) Calabi-Markus phenomenon Generalized Hirzebruch's proportionality principle and its application 5. Compact Clifford-Klein forms of non-Riemannian homogeneous spaces 6. Open problems Acknowledgment Postscript References 1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction
Let G be a Lie group and H a subgroup. A Clifford-Klein form of the homogeneous manifold G / H is a double coset space F \ G / H , where F is a subgroup of G acting properly discontinuously and freely on G / H . For example, any closed Riemann surface M with genus _> 2 is biholomorphic to a compact Clifford-Klein form of the Poincar~ plane G / H PSL(2, IR)/SO(2). On the other hand, there is no compact Clifford-Klein form of the hyperboloid of one sheet G / H - PSL(2, R)/SO(1, 1). Even 99
T. Kobayashi
100
more, there is no infinite discrete subgroup of G that acts properly discontinuously on G / H (the Calabi-Markus phenomenon). We discuss recent developments in the theory of discontinuous groups acting on G / H where G is a real reductive Lie group and H a noncompact reductive subgroup. Geometric ideas of various methods together with a number of examples are presented regarding the fundamental problems:
Which homogeneous manifolds G / H admit properly discontinuous actions of infinite discrete subgroups of G ? Which homogeneous manifolds admit compact Clifford-Klein forms ? 1 1.1
Clifford-Klein forms Homogeneous manifolds First, we consider the setting:
GDH. Here, G is a Lie group and H is a closed subgroup of G. Then the coset space G / H equipped with the quotient topology carries a C ~ - m a n i f o l d structure, so that the natural quotient map
7~: G ---, G / H is a C ~ - m a p . We say G / H is a homogeneous manifold. 1.2
Clifford-Klein forms Second, we consider a more general setting:
FcGDH. Here, G is a Lie group, H is a closed subgroup, and F is a discrete subgroup of G. Then one might ask
Does the double coset space F \ G / H equipped with the quotient topology carry a COO-manifold structure so that the natural quotient map, w: G --, F \ G / H ,
Q u e s t i o n 1.1
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups
101
is a C~-map ? If yes, we say F\G/H is a Clifford-Klein form of the homogeneous
manifold G/H. Unfortunately, the action of a discrete subgroup F on G/H is not always properly discontinuous (see Definition 2.1) when H is not compact, and the quotient topology is not necessarily Hausdorff. Thus, we cannot always expect an affirmative answer to Question 1.1.
This is the main
difficulty of our subject. However, leaving this question aside for a moment, we first discuss the geometric aspect of Clifford-Klein forms in this section.
1.3
C l i f f o r d - K l e i n f o r m s f r o m the viewpoint of g e o m e t r y From the viewpoint of differential geometry, the important point in
considering a Clifford-Klein form F\G/H is that we have a local diffeomorphism p: G/H --. F\G/H, with the following commutative diagram: G
7r/ G/H
P
,r\G/H
Therefore, any G-invariant local structure (e.g., affine, complex, symplectic, Riemannian, or pseudo-Riemannian) on a homogeneous manifold G/H induces the same kind of structure on a Clifford-Klein form F\G/H. In other words, the double coset space F\G/H is a manifold enjoying the same local properties as G/H, as long as the discrete subgroup F allows an affirmative answer to Question 1.1. Conversely, let us start from a differentiable manifold M endowed with some local structure T and then explain how a Clifford-Klein form arises. Let M be the universal covering manifold of M. Then, the local structure T is also defined on M through the covering map M ~ M. We set G = A u t ( M , T ) " - {~ e Diffeo(M) • ~ preserves the structure T}. We note that G is the group of isometries if T is a Riemannian structure; it is the group of biholomorphic automorphisms if T is a complex structure. We fix a point o C M and write 5 E M for its image under the covering map M ~ M. Then, the fundamental group ~I(M, 5) acts effectively on
102
T. Kobayashi
M as the covering automorphism. We write F for the image of the injection 7]"I ( M , 6) ~
G - Aut(M, T). That is, F is a discrete subgroup of G in the
compact open topology, which is isomorphic to 71"I ( M , O). Then we have a natural diffeomorphism M _ F \ M . Assume G - A u t ( M , T )
is small enough to be a Lie group (see a
textbook by Shoshichi Kobayashi [Ko-S] for some sufficient conditions) and is large enough t o a c t transitively on M. Then, M is represented as a homogeneous manifold M ~ G / H with the isotropy subgroup H at o E M. Consequently, M is naturally represented as a Clifford-Klein form of G / H : M ~
7r1(M)~
GIH
Ir
M ~_ r \ G / H
We remark that Question 1.1 has automatically an affirmative answer in this case. We shall give a number of examples of simply connected manifolds M "~ G / H equipped with some local structure in Section 1.4; and Clifford-
Klein forms of these manifolds in Section 1.5. 1.4
E x a m p l e s of h o m o g e n e o u s m a n i f o l d s
First, we present some examples where G - A u t ( M , 7-) acts transitively on a simply connected manifold M, so that M is represented as a homogeneous manifold of G. E x a m p l e 1.2
Let
M " - R ~, 7"
the canonical affine connection V.
Then Aut(R n, V) _~ GL(n,R) ~< IRn is the affine transformation group, acting transitively on IRn by (a,b). x := ax + b
f o r ( a , b ) c G L ( n , R ) b
x C I R ~.
The isotropy subgroup at the origin 0 E R" is isomorphic to GL(n,R), and therefore the manifold R n is represented as the homogeneous manifold GL(n, R) ~< R n / G L ( n , IR).
Chapter 3
E x a m p l e 1.3
{
~r
:=
Discontinuous
103
Groups
Let
R ~ ,
T := standard Riemannian structure g.
Then A u t ( R n, g) _~ O(n) ~
for (a, b) E O(n) ~< IR~,
x C ]~n.
Thus, IRn is represented as the homogeneous manifold O(n) ~< R n / O ( n ) . E x a m p l e 1.4
Let
{ ~'i "-- {X C i~n+l : X2 ÷ . .
" ÷ X n2- - X n +2 1 = 1}
(n _> 3),
T " - the Lorentz metric g induced from dx~ + . . .
+ dx 2 -dX2+l
.
Let O(n, 1) be the indefinite orthogonal group preserving the quadratic form x~ + • • • + x n2_ Xn+2 1" Then O(n, 1) acts transitivelv~ and isometrically on the hyperboloid of one sheet M, and it coincides with the group of isometrics of M. Thus, A u t ( M , g) - O(n, 1) and M ~ O(n, 1 ) / O ( n - 1, 1). E x a m p l e 1.5
Let
M " - C, T"
the standard complex structure J.
Then the group of biholomorphic automorphisms is given by Aut(C, J) ~_ C x ~< C, a semidirect product of C x and C with C normal. The action of C x ~< C on C is given by the complex affine transformation: (a,b).z=az+b
for (a,b) E C x ~
This action is obviously transitive, so that the complex plane C is represented as the homogeneous manifold C x ~< C / C x .
T. Kobayashi
104
Example 1.6
{
Let
/ ~ := C P 1
(the complex projective space),
7" "- the standard complex structure J.
The natural action of SL(2, C) on C 2 \ {0} induces a transitive action of PSL(2, C) on the projective space C P 1 = (C 2 \ {0})/C × _~ CtJ{c~}, which is given by the linear fractional transformation:
(ab) c d
•z -
az+b cz+d
for
(a c
b)
d
e PSL(2, C) = SL(2, C ) / { ± I 2 } .
Then PSL(2, C) ~_ A u t ( C P 1 , J ) , the group of biholomorphic automorphisms. The projective space CP 1 is represented as a homogeneous manifold PSL(2, C)/B, where B is a Borel subgroup of PSL(2, C).
Example 1.7
{
Let
M "- 7 / 7" :
{z e C : Imz > 0}
(the Poincar4 plane),
the standard complex structure J.
Then the group of biholomorphic automorphisms is given by A u t ( ~ , J) _~ PSL(2, I~), where the action of PSL(2, I~) is also defined by the linear fractional transformation:
(ab) c d
•z -
az+b cz+d
for
(a c
d
e PSL(2, R) - SL(2, R ) / { ± I 2 } .
This action is transitive, so that the Poincar4 plane 7-/is represented as the homogeneous manifold PSL(2, I~)/SO(2).
1.5
Examples of Clifford-Klein forms Next, we present a number of examples of Clifford-Klein forms of the
homogeneous manifolds given in Examples 1.2-1.7. We also explain that these examples are closely related to the following interesting topics: Examples 1.8 and 1.9 Example 1.10 Example 1.11
The Auslander Conjecture on the fundamental group of compact complete affine manifolds The Calabi-Markus phenomenon for relativistic spherical forms The uniformization theorem of Riemann surfaces due to Klein, Poincar4, and Koebe
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
105
E x a m p l e 1.8 (see Example 1.2) An affine manifold M is a manifold that admits a torsion free affine connection the curvature tensor of which vanishes. It is said to be complete if every geodesic can be defined on all time intervals. Then it is known that the universal covering of any complete affine manifold M = M n is isomorphic to (R n, V) as affine manifolds. Therefore, it follows from Example 1.2 that M can be represented as a Clifford-Klein form M _~ F \ G L ( n , ]~) ~< R n / G L ( n , ]1{), where F is a discrete subgroup of GL(n, ]1{) ~<]~n that is isomorphic to the fundamental group ~1 (M). E x a m p l e 1.9 (see Example 1.3) Retain the notation in Example 1.8. If M n is a Riemannian manifold and if M n is a complete affine manifold (see Example 1.8) for the Levi-Civita connection, then the universal covering of M is isometric to R n endowed with the standard Riemannian metric g. Therefore it follows from Example 1.3 that M is represented as another Clifford-Klein form
M _~ F \ O ( n ) ~, ]~n/O(n)
with F C O(n) ~< ]~n. Similarly, if M n is a Lorentz manifold (namely, M carries a pseudoRiemannian metric of type ( n - l , 1)), and if M is a complete affine manifold for the Levi-Civita connection, then M is reduced to be a Clifford-Klein form M _~ F \ O ( n with F C O ( n -
1, 1) ~< ] ~ n / O ( n - 1, 1)
1, 1) ~< R n.
R e m a r k (the Auslander conjecture) Regarding to Examples 1.8 and 1.9, we mention the Auslander conjecture, which asserts that the fundamental
group Th of any compact complete affine manifold is virtually solvable (see [Au], [Mi], [Ma], and references therein). In view of Example 1.8, this is equivalent to the conjecture that a discrete group F is virtually solvable if F \ G L ( n , 1~) ~( ]~n/GL(n, R) is a compact Clifford-Klein form of a homogeneous manifold GL(n,I~) ~< R n/GL(n,]~) _~ R n. Auslander's conjecture remains open except for some special cases such as F C O(n) ~
106
T. Kobayashi
also [To] for a generalization to rank one groups). The geometric meaning of F C O(n) ~ 3 with constant sectional curvature K = +1. Any relativistic spherical space form M is represented as a Clifford-Klein form: M _~ F \ O ( n , 1)/O(n - 1, 1), where F is a discrete subgroup of O(n, 1) that is isomorphic to the fundamental group 7rl(M). We shall see that F must be a finite group in Section 3 (the Calabi-Markus phenomenon [CM]). E x a m p l e 1.11 (the uniformization theorem of Riemann surfaces: see Examples 1.5-1.7) The uniformization theorem of Riemann surfaces due to Klein, Poinca%, and Koebe asserts that a simply connected Riemann surface M is biholomorphic to one of the following complex manifolds: C,
C P 1,
or 7-L
We recall that the Riemann mapping theorem is the special case obtained by assuming M to be a domain of C. We refer the reader to [Sp], [AhSa] for details. The point here is that any of simply connected Riemann surfaces C, C P 1, and 7-/ has a transitive transformation group of biholomorphic automorphisms, as we have seen in Examples 1.5, 1.6, and 1.7, respectively. Consequently, any connected Riemann surface M is represented as a Clifford-Klein form M ~_ r \ a / H ,
where ( G , H ) i s (C x ~< C, CX), (PSL(2, C),B), or (PSL(2, R),SO(2)), and F is a discrete subgroup of G that is isomorphic to 7rl(M). In particular, suppose M is compact. The rank of the first homology group H i ( M ) is always even, and it is denoted by 2g. Then, g is said to be the genus of the Riemann surface M, and such a Riemann surface is usually
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups
107
denoted by My. Then the universal covering of Mg is uniquely determined up to biholomorphic automorphism by the genus g. In fact, we have
Mg _~ F\PSL(2, C)/B,
r = ~ (M~) = {~}
(g = 0),
M~ ~_ r \ c
F = 7rl(Mg) -~ Z 2
(g = 1),
r = ~I(M~)
(g > 2).
x ~ C/C x ,
Mg _~ F\PSL(2, R)/SO(2),
2
Discontinuous actions (discrete and continuous version) Let G be a Lie group, H a closed subgroup, and F a discrete subgroup
of G. In Section 1, we have defined a Clifford-Klein form of a homogeneous manifold G/H as the double coset space F\G/H if it is Hausdorff and carries naturally a C ~ structure (see Question 1.1). This condition is satisfied if F acts properly discontinuously and freely on G/H (see Definition 2.1), as we shall see in Lemma 2.2. The purpose of this section is to understand properly discontinuous actions by exhibiting a number of typical bad features of the action of noncompact groups. 2.1
C l i f f o r d - K l e i n f o r m of PSL(2, R)/SO(2)
First, we recall Example 1.11. Let Mg be a closed Riemann surface with genus g > 2. The universal covering manifold of My is biholomorphic to the the Poinca% plane 7-/. So My is represented as a compact CliffordKlein form F\PSL(2, R)/SO(2) of the Poincar6 plane PSL(2, R)/SO(2), where F is an infinite discrete subgroup of PSL(2, R) isomorphic to 71"1 (Mg). There are two directions of generalization of this classical example, namely, i) generalization to higher dimensions (e.g., Theorem 5.2) ii) generalization to noncompact isotropy subgroups Here, we are interested in the latter direction. 2.2
C l i f f o r d - K l e i n f o r m of PSL(2,R)/SO(1, 1) There is no compact Clifford-Klein form of the hyperboloid of one
sheet PSL(2, R)/SO(1, 1). This fact can be proved in various ways, which
108
T. Kobayashi
are of importance as typical examples of later arguments. We indicate here four different proofs, which we shall elaborate in the following sections. i) A direct calculation (this section). Assume that F is a discrete subgroup of PSL(2, I~) such that ~F = co. Then we can show that the action of F on PSL(2, I~)/SO (1,1) is never properly discontinuous, and the corresponding quotient space F\PSL(2, I~)/SO(1, 1) is not Hausdorff. We consider first the most nontrivial case, where F consists of unipotent elements. For example, let us consider the case where F is a discrete subgroup of PSL(2, I~) generated by a single unipotent element. Then, the quotient topology of F\PSL(2,]~)/SO(1, 1) is locally Hausdorff but nonHausdorff, as we shall explain in this section (see Example 2.8 and Exercise 2.9(iii),(v)). On the other hand, if F does not contain a nilpotent element (still we assume ~F = c~), then the action of F has an accumulating point in PSL(2, R)/SO(1, 1) (see Definition 2.4), so that F\PSL(2, ]~)/SO(1, 1) is not Hausdorff, too (see Example 2.7(ii) and Exercise 2.9(iv),(v)). ii) Calabi-Markus phenomenon (Section 3). We will give a necessary and sufficient condition in terms of the ranks of G and H for a homogeneous space G/H of reductive type to admit an infinite discontinuous group (see Theorem 3.10 for a criterion of the so-called Calabi-Markus phenomenon; see also Example 1.10). The idea of proof is to study an analogous problem in a continuous setting and to look at the infinite points by means of the Cartan decomposition. iii) Hirzebruch's proportionality principle (Section 4). A CliffordKlein form M of PSL(2, R)/SO(1, 1), the hyperboloid of one sheet, carries an indefinite-Riemannian metric of type (1, 1) induced from the Killing form. This metric gives rise to a nonvanishing vector field on M. If M were compact and orientable, this would imply the vanishing of the EulerPoincar~ class of M thanks to a theorem of Poincar~-Hopf. On the other hand, the Euler-Poincar~ class of a "compact real form" S 2 ~_ SU(2)/SO(2) does not vanish. This leads to a contradiction by a generalized Hirzebruch's proportionality principle (see Corollary 4.6). The idea here leads to a necessary condition for the existence of compact Clifford-Klein forms (see Corollary 4.12 and Example 4.13). iv) Semisimple orbits, invariant comple¢ structure (Section 5). The hyperboloid of one sheet is realized as a semisimple orbit of the adjoint representation of PSL(2,1~). We shall see in Section 5 that a semisimple
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
109
orbit having a compact Clifford-Klein form must be isomorphic to an elliptic orbit, so that it carries an invariant complex structure (see Corollary 5.13). But this is not the case for the hyperboloid of one sheet.
2.3
P r o p e r l y discontinuous action
A distinguished feature in the setting Section 2.2 is that the isotropy subgroup H _~ SO(l, 1) is noncompact. As a consequence, the action of a discrete subgroup F on G / H is not automatically properly discontinuous. Here, we recall the definition of properly discontinuous actions: Suppose that a discrete group F acts continuously on a locally compact Hausdorff topological space X. For a subset S of X, we put
r s := {~ E F : ~ S n S # O } . Note that if S is a singleton {p} (p E X), then Fs is nothing but the isotropy subgroup at p. In general, F s is not a subgroup.
Definition 2.1
The action of F on X is said to be
i) properly discontinuous, if Fs is a finite subset for any compact subset S of X; ii) free, if F{p} is trivial for any p E X. Then we have the following standard fact: L e m m a 2.2 Suppose that a discrete group F acts on a [C ~ , Riemannian, complex, ... ] manifold X properly discontinuously and freely [and
smoothly, isometrically, holomorphicaUy, ... ]. Equipped with the quotient topology, F \ X is then a Hausdorff topological space, on which a manifold structure is uniquely defined so that 7r : X ~ F \ X is locally homeomorphic [diffeomorphic, isometric, biholomorphic, ... ]. Although this lemma is well known, we give a sketch of its proof so that readers get used to the definition of properly discontinuous actions.
S k e t c h o f proof'. 1) (Hausdorff) (We use only the assumption that the action is properly discontinuous.) Take x, y E X so that 7r(x) ~: 7r(y).
110
T. Kobayashi
We want to find neighborhoods V, W of X such that x C V, y C W, and 7r(V) N 7r(W) = q). First, we take relatively compact neighborhoods V1 and W1 of X such that x C V1, y C W1. As the action of F on X is properly
discontinuous, Fvluw 1 -- {')/C F : ")/(V1 U W1)N (V1 U Wl) ~ 0} is a finite set, say, {~/1,..., ~/k}. Second, we take neighborhoods V and W such that x E V C V1, y E W C W1, a n d ~ j V n W =
0
(j = 1 , . . . , k ) .
Then, we
have FV N F W = 0, that is, 7r(V)n 7 r ( W ) = 0, which we wanted to prove. 2) (manifold structure)
The proof is quite similar to that of (1). In
fact, by using the assumption that the action is properly discontinuous and free, we can find a neighborhood V C X at each point x E X such that e r:-yv
n v
O} =
Such an open set V is homeomorphic to 7r(V) C F \ X , and these sets form a basis for the open sets giving local charts of F \ X .
[-1
Here is a necessary condition that the action of F on X is properly discontinuous. L e m m a 2.3
Suppose a discrete group F acts properly discontinuously on
a locally compact, Hausdorff topological space X . Then we have i) There is no accumulating point of the action of F on X . ii) Each F-orbit is a closed subset of X . Here we recall D e f i n i t i o n 2.4
For each element x of X, the F-orbit through x is a
subset of X given by r.x
:= { ' y x : 7
r}.
We say y (E X) is an accumulating point of the F-orbit F. x if e r.
=
for any neighborhood U of y in X. We say y (E X) is an accumulating point
of the action of F on X if there exists x E X such that y is an accumulating point of the orbit F . x.
P r o o f o f L e m m a 2.3:
i) We want to show that the action of F on X
is not properly discontinuous if there exists an accumulating point of the
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups action of F on X .
111
Suppose t h a t y E X is an a c c u m u l a t i n g point of the
action of F on X . T h a t is, there exists x E X such t h a t ~(U n F - x) = oc for any n e i g h b o r h o o d U of y. We choose U to be relatively c o m p a c t and define S := U U {x} and F' := {~/E F : ~x E U}. T h e n we have ~F' = oc, because ~(U n F - x ) = oc. T h e n we have ~Fs = co, because
Fs = {'y E F : "yS N S # O} D F ' . Hence, the action of F on X is not properly discontinuous. ii) We want to show t h a t the action of F on X is not p r o p e r l y discontinuous if t h e r e exists a nonclosed orbit F . x. Take y E F . x \ F . x and relatively c o m p a c t , open n e i g h b o r h o o d s Uj (j = 1, 2 , . . . ) of y such t h a t U1 D U2 D • .. and t h a t n j
uj
-
{y}. Then, we can take ~j E F such t h a t %j-x E Uj for
each j E N, because F . x n uj 7~ O. T h e n we have ~ {~j : j = 1, 2 , . . . } = oo, because n j u j - {y}. Finally, we p u t S " - Vl U{x}, and we have ~Fs - oc, because
U
c
aj} D
5 - 1, 2 , . . . } .
J H e n c e , the action of F on X is not properly discontinuous.
2.4
Discontinuous groups acting on homogeneous
W1
manifolds
A discrete s u b g r o u p F of G is said to be a discontinuous group acting on G/H if the action of F on G/H is p r o p e r l y discontinuous.
D e f i n i t i o n 2.5
If F is a discontinuous group acting on G/H and if the action of F on G / H is free, t h e n the double coset space F \ G / H carries a n a t u r a l C ~ manifold s t r u c t u r e from L e m m a 2.2, so t h a t F \ G / H is a Clifford-Klein form of the h o m o g e n e o u s manifold G/H.
Thus, we have an affirmative
answer to Q u e s t i o n 1.1 in this case. Here, the point is t h a t F is a s s u m e d to be a s u b g r o u p of G, so t h a t
F\G/H inherits
any G-invariant (local) s t r u c t u r e on the h o m o g e n e o u s m a n -
ifold G/H. One should keep in m i n d the essential difference b e t w e e n the action on G/H of a discrete group F C G (our case) and a discrete group F C Diffeo(G/H). For example, if G/H = SL(2, R ) / S O ( 1 , 1 ) (a hyperboloid of one sheet), t h e n G/H is diffeomorphic to S 1 x R (a cylinder),
T. Kobayashi
112
which admits a properly discontinuous action of Z ( C Diffeo(G/H)) along the direction of JR. But this action does not come from SL(2, R) and is not isometric with respect to a natural indefinite Riemannian metric on the hyperboloid. 2.5
A remark
In this section, proper discontinuity is essentially important, but freeness is less important. In fact, if a discrete group F acts on a manifold X properly discontinuously, then the isotropy group F{p} at p E X is indeed not necessarily trivial, but it is always finite. Correspondingly, F \ X is not necessarily a smooth manifold but still has a nice structure called
V-manifold in the sense of Satake [Sa] or called an orbifold in the sense of Thurston (see also [Car]). Moreover, if F acts properly discontinuously on X and if F' C F is a torsion free subgroup (i.e., x E F', x n = e (n > 1) =~ x = e), then the action of F ~ on X is properly discontinuous and free. In view of this, the following result due to Selberg is quite useful. Theorem
2.6 ([Sel, Lemma 8])
A finitely generated matrix group has a
torsion free subgroup of finite index. 2.6
Examples and exercises
E x a m p l e 2.7 Suppose a discrete group F : - Z acts on a manifold X :--IR in two different manners: i)
FxX---~X,
(n,x)~-.x+n.
ii)
F x X ~ X,
(n,x) ~ 2nx.
The action in (i) is properly discontinuous and free.
The resulting
quotient manifold F \ X is diffeomorphic to S 1. On the other hand, the action in (ii) is not properly discontinuous: in fact, F s = Z is not a finite set if we take S := [0, 1], the unit interval in R. The resulting quotient space F \ X has a non-Hausdorff topology. T h a t is, F \ X is homeomorphic to S 1 U {point} U S:, which is topologized to be connected! In Example 2.7(ii), we easily see that the action of F is not properly discontinuous because the origin 0 is an accumulation point of the action of F. The next example is more subtle, without accumulation points.
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups
113
E x a m p l e 2.8 Suppose a discrete group F := Z acts on a manifold X := I~2 \ {0} in the following manner:
(n, (x, y)) H (2nx, 2-ny).
FxX~X,
Then this action is not properly discontinuous. In fact, we let B~(x, y) be a ball of radius c with the center (x, y) and put S := B1/2(1, 0) t2 B1/2(0, 1). Then, it is an easy exercise to see that F s - {7 C Z : ~S A S # 0} is equal to Z. We note that there is no accumulation point of F. In fact every F-orbit is closed in X. The resulting quotient topology of F \ X is not Hausdorff, though it is locally Hausdorff in the sense that one can find a Hausdorff neighborhood of each point of F \ X . A picture of a similar topology as that of F \ X is illustrated by the following one-dimensional example:
E x e r c i s e 2.9
In the setting as in Example 2.8, prove the following:
i) F s = Z if S = B1/2(1, 0) U B1/2(0, 1). ii) Let G = SL(2, I~) act naturally on R 2 \ {0} from the left. This action is transitive, and the isotropy group at 1
(1)0 is
X
- {(01) so that we have a diffeomorphism:
G/H _~ ]t{2 \ {0}. Let 0
0)
y-1
"y>0
}
,
Lz'-
0
0)
2 -x
.xEZ
}
_~Z.
Via the isomorphisms G/H ~- ]~2 \ {0} and Lz "~ F (= Z), the action of Lz on G/H coincides with that of F on R 2 \ {0} in Example 2.8. Thus,
114
T. Kobayashi
the action of Lz on G/H is not properly discontinuous, and the quotient topology on L z \ G / H is not Hausdorff. iii) Let Hz'-{(0
1
x 1)"xEZ}.
Then the action of Hz on G/L is not properly discontinuous, and the quotient topology on Hz\G/L is not Hausdorff. iv) The action of Lz on G/L has an accumulating point and is not properly discontinuous, either.
v)
We define a quadratic form on R 2 b y Q ( X ) "-xy. The polarization \ Y/ of Q gives an indefinite metric of signature (1, 1). Then L is the identity component of
Thus, G/L ~_ SL(2, R)/SO0(1, 1). Hint: The topology whereas that of Lz\G/L and in (iii) are in a kind that of H on G/L. That
of Hz\G/L has similar features as Example 2.8, is similar to Example 2.7(ii). The actions in (ii) of duality, between the action of L on G/H and is, in the setting Lz c L c G D H D Hz
with L/Lz and H/Hz compact, the action of Lz on G/H is properly discontinuous if and only if that of Hz on G/L is properly discontinuous (see Lemma 2.16(i); see also Observation 2.12 and [Bou, Chapitre 3]). 2.7
B a s i c p r o b l e m s in a d i s c r e t e s e t t i n g Here are the basic problems in the theory of discontinuous groups
acting on a homogeneous manifold: P r o b l e m 2.10
Suppose G is a Lie group and H is a closed subgroup.
i) Which homogeneous manifold G/H admits an infinite discontinuous group ? ii) Which homogeneous manifold G/H admits a compact Clifford-Klein form?
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
115
(i) is a first step in the study of discontinuous groups acting on homogeneous manifolds. The existence of a compact Clifford-Klein form in (ii) would be interesting not only from the viewpoint of geometry but also from that of harmonic analysis and representation theory (see Open problem (x) in Section 6). We will study (i) in Section 3, and (ii) in Section 5 (partly also in Sections 3 and 4). 2.8
as a c o n t i n u o u s a n a l o g of p r o p e r l y
Proper actions
discontinuous actions
In general, the study of a discrete group is quite difficult. Our approach is to approximate the action of discrete groups by that of connected Lie groups.
For this purpose, it is crucial to find a continuous analog of a
properly discontinuous action: D e f i n i t i o n 2.11 (see [Pal)
Suppose that a locally compact topological
group L acts continuously on a locally compact topological space X. For a subset S of X, we define a subset of L by
Ls = {'7 C L : "yS N S ~ O}. The action of L on X is said to be proper if and only if Ls is compact for every compact subset S of X. Compared with the definition of proper discontinuity (Definition 2.1), compactness in Definition 2.11 has now replaced by finiteness. We note that the action of L on X is properly discontinuous if and only if the action of L on X is proper and L is discrete, because a discrete and compact set is finite. 2.9
An observation
The following elementary observation is a bridge between the action of a discrete group and that of a connected group.
Suppose a Lie group L acts on Let F be a cocompact discrete subgroup of L.
O b s e r v a t i o n 2.12 ([Ko2, Lemma 2.3])
a locally compact space X . Then
1) The L-action on X is proper if and only if the F-action is properly discontinuous. 2) L \ X is compact if and only if F \ X is compact.
116
T. Kobayashi
P r o o f : 1) Suppose F acts properly discontinuously. Take a compact subset C in L so that L = C . F and C = C -1. Then, for any compact subset S in X, Ls = {g E L : g. S N S ~ O} C C . F c s . Because F c s is a finite set from the assumption, we conclude that the action of L is proper. In view of F s = F A Ls, the "only if" part follows immediately from the definition. 2) Suppose L \ X
is compact. We take an open covering X = ~ s Us by
relatively compact sets Us. Then X - ~Js LUs gives an open covering of
L \ X . By the compactness of L \ X , we can choose finitely many Uj among {Us} so that X - Uj L . Uj - U j
(F.
C ) . Uj - U j F . ( C . Uj),
F \ X is compact. The converse statement is clear. 2.10
P r o b l e m s in a c o n t i n u o u s
showing
[3
analog
In view of Observation 2.12, we pose the following analogous problems in a continuous setting. P r o b l e m 2.13
Let G be a Lie group and H and L closed subgroups.
1) Find the criterion on the triplet (L, G, H) such that the action of L on G / H is proper. 2) Find the criterion on the triplet (L, G, H) such that the double coset L \ G / H is compact in the quotient topology. We will give a complete answer to Problem 2.13 in terms of Lie algebras in the following cases: i) Problem 2.13(1) when G is reductive (see Section 2) ii) Problem 2.13(2) when the groups G, H, L are real reductive (see Section 5). In preparation for the next section we introduce here some notations that are useful for a further study of Problem 2.13(1). 2.11
Relations ~ and
Suppose that H and L are subsets of a locally compact topological group G. D e f i n i t i o n 2,14 ([Kol0, Definition 2.1.1])
We denote by H ~ L in G if
there exists a compact set S of G such that L C S H S -1 and H C S L S -1. Here, S H S -1 "- {ahb -1 E G" a, b 6 S, h C H } . Then the relation H ~ L in G defines an equivalence relation.
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
117
We say the pair ( H , L ) is proper in G, denoted by H rfi L in G, iff S H S -1 n L is relatively compact for any compact set S in G. Definition 2.14 is motivated by the following: 2.15 Let H and L be closed subgroups of G, and F a discrete subgroup of G.
Observation
1) The action of L on the homogeneous manifold G / H is proper if and only if H rh L in G. 2) The action of F on the homogeneous manifold G / H is properly discontinuous if and only if H rh F in G. Here are some elementary properties of the relations ~, rfi : L e m m a 2.16 ([Kol0]) Suppose G is a locally compact topological group and that H, H t and L are subsets of G.
i) H ~ L if and only if L ~ H. ii) If H ~ H' and if H rfi L in G, then H' rh L in G. Now we are ready to give a reformulation of Problem 2.13(1) as:
Problem 2.17 (a reformulation of Problem 2.13(1))
Let G be a Lie group, and H and L subsets of G. Find the criterion on the pair (L, H) (or on the pair of their equivalence classes with respect to ~ ) such that L dl H in
G.
2.12
Property (CI)
If a discrete group F acts on X properly discontinuously, then every isotropy subgroup is finite and every F orbit is closed (Lemma 2.3). The latter condition corresponds to the fact that each point is closed in the quotient topology of F \ X . In general, the converse implication does not hold (cf. Example 2.8). We have a similar picture in a continuous setting. In fact, let H, L be closed subgroups of a locally compact topological group G. If L acts properly on G / H , then any L-orbit L g H "~ L / L N g H g -1 C G / H is a closed subset, and each isotropy subgroup L n gHg -1 is compact. In general, the converse implication is not true. However, we focus our attention on the latter property, that is, each isotropy subgroup is compact.
118
T. Kobayashi
D e f i n i t i o n 2.18 ([Ko4, Ko6]) Suppose that H and L are subsets of a locally compact topological group G. We say that the pair (L, H) has the property (CI) in G if and only if L n gHg -1 is compact for any g E G. Here (CI) stands for that the action of L has a compact isotropy subgroup L n g H g -1 at each point gH E G / H , or stands for that L and gHg -1 has a compact intersection (g E G) (see also [Lip]). If H M L in G, then the pair (L, H) has the property (CI) in G. The point is to understand how and to what extent the property (CI) implies the proper action. P r o b l e m 2.19 ([Ko6, Problem 2]; see Open problem 6(ii))
For which
Lie groups, does the following equivalence (2.1) hold? H M L in G e, the pair ( L , H ) has the property (CI) in G.
(2.1)
In the next section, we shall see that the equivalence (2.1) holds if G, H, L are real reductive algebraic groups (see Theorem 3.18). R. Lipsman [Lip] has pointed out that it is likely that the equivalence (2.12.3) holds as well if G is a simply connected nilpotent group. There are some further cases, especially in the context of a continuous analog of the Auslander conjecture (see the remark following Example 1.9), where the equivalence (2.1) is known to hold. See Example 5 and Proposition A.2.1 in [Ko4, Ko6]; Theorem 3.1 and Theorem 5.4 in [Lip]. However, we should note that the equivalence (2.1) does not always hold. For instance, if G = K A N is an Iwasawa decomposition of a real reductive group G and if we put L := A and H := N, then (L, H) has the property (CI) in G, while L ~ H in G as we saw in Exercise 2.9 when G = SL(2, R).
3 3.1
Calabi-Markus phenomenon E x i s t e n c e of infinite d i s c o n t i n u o u s g r o u p s
Let G be a Lie group and H a closed subgroup. In the section, we focus our attention on the first basic problem:
Which homogeneous manifold G / H admits an infinite discontinuous group?
P r o b l e m 3.1 (see Problem 2.10(i))
We first note that if M is a compact manifold, then there is no infinite discrete group (C Diffeo(M)) acting on M properly discontinuously. So, we
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
119
might expect that the answer to Problem 3.1 should be related to certain aspect of compactness of a homogeneous manifold G / H with respect to the transformation group G C Diffeo(M). One observes that a criterion given in the reductive case (Theorem 3.6) has such an aspect. Our main interest here is the (non-)existence of an infinite discontinuous group in the reductive case. However, we include a quick review for some other typical cases as well.
i)
relativistic spherical space form (Section 3.2),
ii)
G / H with H compact (Section 3.3),
iii)
G / H with G solvable (Section 3.4),
iv)
G / H with G reductive (Section 3.5- Section 3.10).
3.2
R e l a t i v i s t i c s p h e r i c a l s p a c e form In 1962, Calabi and Markus discovered a surprising phenomenon on
the fundamental group ~1 of a Lorentz manifold with constant curvature"
Every relativistic spherical space form is noncompact and has a finite .fundamental group 7q (see Example 1.10 for definition). T h e o r e m 3.2
([CM])
As we saw in Example 1.10, the Calabi-Markus theorem is reformulated in a group language as"
If n > 3, then there does not exist a discrete subgroup F of O(n, 1) acting on O(n, 1 ) / O ( n - 1, 1) properly discontinuously and freely such that the fundamental group ~ I ( F \ G / H ) is infinite.
T h e o r e m 3.3
We note that if n - 2, then G / H is diffeomorphic to a cylinder and has the fundamental group ~ Z. Theorem 3.3 is also reformulated as
Any discontinuous group acting (see Definition 2.5) on a homogeneous manifold SO(n, 1 ) / S O ( n - 1, 1) (n > 2) is finite.
T h e o r e m 3.4
This result will be generalized in Section 3.5 for homogeneous spaces of reductive type (Definition 3.12). Setting the main subject aside for a moment, we mention a related problem in non-Riemannian geometry based on the following observation:
T. Kobayashi
120
i) Any complete Riemannian manifold M n (n ~_ 2) with constant sectional curvature +1 is compact with finite fundamental group. ii) Any complete Lorentz manifold M n (n >_ 3) with constant sectional curvature +1 is noncompact with finite fundamental group.
O b s e r v a t i o n 3.5
We recall again in a group language that M _~ F \ O ( n + 1)/O(n) in the first case, whereas M _~ F \ O ( n , 1 ) / O ( n - 1, 1) in the second case. A classical theorem due to Myers may be interpreted as a "perturbation" of Riemannian metric in the first statement:
If the Ricei curvature of a complete Riemannian manifold M satisfies K(U, U) >_ c > 0 for all unit vectors, then M is compact with finite fundamental group.
Theorem
3.6 ([My])
The author does not know a result concerning a "perturbation" of the Lorentz metric in Observation 3.5(ii). So we pay an attention on the following problem in pseudo-Riemannian geometry:
Suppose M is a complete Lorentz manifold (or more generally a complete manifold equipped with an indefinite Riemannian metric). Find a sufficient condition in terms of a local property of M that assures that M is noncompact with a finite fundamental group. In particular, is there a sufficient condition given by some positiveness of the curvature of M?
P r o b l e m 3.7
3.3
H is c o m p a c t Suppose that H is compact.
Then it follows immediately from the
definition of properly discontinuous actions that The action of F on G / H is properly discontinuous ¢=~ F is a discrete subgroup of G. Moreover, if F is a torsion free discrete subgroup of G, then the action of F on G / H is properly discontinuous and free whenever H is compact. Therefore, we have the following:
If G is a noncompact connected linear Lie group and H is a compact subgroup, then there always exists an infinite discrete subgroup F of G acting on G / H properly discontinuously and freely on G / H . P r o p o s i t i o n 3.8
Chapter 3 Proof:
Discontinuous Groups
121
It suffices to show t h a t any noncompact linear Lie group G con-
tains an infinite torsion free discrete subgroup. Assume first t h a t G is a noncompact semisimple Lie group; we write
G - K A N for an Iwasawa decomposition. We note t h a t G is noncompact if and only if I~-rank G - dim A > 0. So we can take a lattice of A, which is isomorphic to %dim A and is an infinite and torsion free discrete subgroup of G. Assume second t h a t G is a noncompact solvable Lie group. Let G be the universal covering group of G, and Z the kernel of the covering map G --. G.
It follows from Theorem 1 and R e m a r k of [Ch] t h a t we find
(0 _<) r _ n - dim G and a basis X 1 , . . . , Xn of the Lie algebra of G which has the following properties: i) R n -~ G,
(tl,...,tn)
H
exp(tlX1)...exp(tnXn)
is a surjective
homeomorphism. ii) Z is isomorphic to the free abelian group generated by the elements exp X 1 , . . . , exp Xr. We note t h a t G is noncompact if and only if r < n. Therefore, if G is noncompact, we put F " - { e x p ( n X r + l ) E G ' n
E Z}, which is an infinite
and torsion free discrete subgroup of G. Now, we suppose G is a noncompact connected linear Lie group. Let g -
[ + ~ is a Levi decomposition, where ~ is the radical of 9 and [ is a
semisimple Lie algebra. We write L, S for the analytic subgroups of G with Lie algebra [, ~, respectively. Then, L and S are closed subgroups of G. If G is noncompact, then L or S must be noncompact. In either case, we can find an infinite and torsion free discrete subgroup of G. 3.4
[3
Solvable groups
In the case of simply connected solvable homogeneous spaces, it turns out t h a t the C a l a b i - M a r k u s phenomenon does not occur. The following result is proved based on a structural result of a simply connected solvable groups due to Chevalley [Ch].
Suppose G is a solvable Lie group and H is a proper closed subgroup of G. Then there exists a discrete subgroup F of G acting on G / H properly discontinuously and freely such that the fundamental group Trl ( F \ G / H ) is infinite. Theorem
3.9, ([Ko8, T h e o r e m 2.2]; see also [Lip])
T. Kobayashi
122 3.5
Reductive
cases
The Calabi-Markus phenomenon in the reductive case has been studied by Calabi, Markus, Wolf, Kulkarni and Kobayashi, and it has been settled completely in terms of a rank condition:
Let G / H be a homogeneous space of reductive type. The following statements are equivalent: T h e o r e m 3.10, ([CM; Wol; Wo2; Wo3; Zu; Zo2])
1) Any discontinuous group acting on G / H is finite. 2) •-rank G = R-rank H. We will explain some terminology used here in Section 3.6 Section 3.6, and then give some examples and a sketch of the proof in Sections 3.7 and 3.8. 3.6
Homogeneous
spaces of reductive type
We set up some notation of real reductive groups.
Good references
for what we need are [He, Chapter VII and [War, Chapter I]. Let G be a connected real linear reductive Lie group. Fix a maximal compact subgroup K in G. We write ~ = ~ + p for the corresponding Cartan decomposition of the Lie algebra of G. Then, the homogeneous space G / K equipped with a G-invariant Riemannian metric is said to be a Riemannian symmetric space. We fix a maximal abelian subspace a C p. Then, a is said to be a maximally split abelian subspace
for G. If we want to emphasize the group G, we write aG for a. We write A for the corresponding connected Lie subgroup. We define E(~, a) : the restricted root system, Wc : the Weyl group associated to E(~, a), rank G := the dimension of any maximal semisimple abelian subspace of 0, c-rank G := rank K, ]R-rank G := dim a = rank G / K ,
d(G) := dimp = d i m G / K . We note that c-rank G _< rank G >__ JR-rank G <_ d(G).
Chapter 3 Example
3.11
Let G -
Discontinuous Groups
123
SO0(p, q) (p > q) be the identity component of
the indefinite orthogonal group of signature (p,q). Then K _~ SO(p) x SO(q) ' A -~- R q ' c - r a n k G [~] + [~] ' rank G [P+ql R-rankG - q' 2 J' d(G) - pq, and Wa ~ ®q ~ (Z//2Z) q. Here, Gq denotes the qth symmetric group. D e f i n i t i o n 3.12
Suppose that H is a closed subgroup in G with at most
finitely many connected components. If there exists a C a r t a n involution of G that stabilizes H, then H is said to be reductive in G and G / H is said to be a homogeneous space of reductive type. If G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type, then G and H have a realization in GL(n, N) such that H C G C GL(n, R) are closed subgroups and that H - tH and G - tG. Here tG "- { t g . g E G}, the transposed set of G in GL(n, R). Example
3.13
Suppose G is a real reductive linear group.
i) If H is compact, then G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type. ii) ([Yo]) If H is semisimple, then G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type. iii) Let a be an involutive automorphism of G. If H is an open subgroup of G ~ " - {g C G" c r g - g}, then G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type. The homogeneous space G / H is said to be a reductive symmetric space. If G is semisimple, G / H is said to be a semisimple
symmetric space. iv) If X E 1~ is a semisimple element, namely, ad(X) E End(g) is semisimple, then the semisimple orbit G/ZG(X) "~ A d ( G ) . X (C g), where Z c ( X ) "- {g C G ' A d ( g ) X - X}, is a homogeneous space of reductive type. v) ([Mos]) If Go D G1 D . . . D Gn and if Gi-1/Gi (1 _< i <_ n) are all homogeneous spaces of reductive type, then so is Go/Gn. Suppose G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type.
There is
a nondegenerate Ad(H)-invariant bilinear form B on g that is positive definite on p and negative definite on 2. (Actually, there exists B t h a t is Ad(G)-invariant.) nondegenerate.
Because b is 0-stable, the restriction of B to ~ is also Therefore, B induces a nondegenerate Ad(H)-invariant
bilinear form g/[~ ~ To(G/H), the tangent space of G / H at o - e H
C G/H.
T. Kobayashi
124
It induces a G-invariant (indefinite-)Riemannian metric on G / H by the left translation. The signature of this metric is (dim(p/p N O), dim(~/~ N O)). In analogy with the polar coordinate in the Euclidean space R n , there is a polar coordinate in a Riemannian symmetric space G / K .
In group
language, this means that a real reductive linear Lie group G has a Cartan decomposition
G = KAK. In this decomposition, there is an element a(g) E A, unique up to conjugation by WG, such that g C K a ( g ) K for each g 6 G. D e f i n i t i o n 3.14 ([Ko2], [Kol0])
For each subset L of G, we define:
A(L) := A N K L K = {w. a(g) : w e W a , g e L} C A, a(L) := logA(L) C a. Here, log: A ~ a is the inverse of the diffeomorphism exp: a ~ A. If L is a subgroup of G that is reductive in G, then we can take a maximal compact subgroup K of G such that L N K is also a maximal compact subgroup of a reductive Lie group L. Let aL be a maximally split abelian subspace for L. Then there exists an element g of G such that
Ad(g)aL c aG. Then a(L) is a finite union of subspaces in aG: a(L) = W a . Ad(g)aL C aa. In this case, the notation a(L) coincides with that in [Ko2] as a subset of
at~We. Remark
Some remarks are in order.
i) If G / H is a homogeneous space of reductive type, then both G and H are real reductive Lie groups. Note that the converse statement is not always true.
ii) We avoid the terminology reductive homogeneous space,
which is usually used in the following sense: the Lie algebra g may be decomposed into a vector space direct sum of the Lie algebra ~ and a H-stable subspace m (see, for example, [KoN, Chapter X, Section 2]). This notion is wider than that of homogeneous spaces of reductive type in Definition 3.12. In particular, neither G nor H itself is required to be reductive in this usual definition of a reductive homogeneous space.
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups 3.7
E x a m p l e s of t h e C a l a b i - M a r k u s
125
phenomenon
We present here some examples of Theorem 3.10. E x a m p l e 3.15 Let G/H = SO(p + 1, q)/SO(p,q). Then R - r a n k G = min(p + 1, q) and R-rank H = min(p, q). Therefore, we have there is no infinite discontinuous group acting on ¢~
R-rank G = R-rank H
ca
q<_p.
G/H
The case q = 1 is the original result of Calabi-Markus (see Theorem 3.4). E x a m p l e 3.16
i)Any para-Hermitian symmetric space does not admit
an infinite discontinuous group (see [Lib] for the definition of para-complex structure; see also [KaKo] for the definition and a classification of irreducible para-Hermitian symmetric spaces), ii) Any hyperbolic orbit does not admit an infinite discontinuous group. Here, we say a semisimple orbit G/Za(X) ~- A d ( G ) X (see Example 3.13(iv)) is a hyperbolic orbit if X C g is a hyperbolic element, that is, if all eigenvalues of ad(X) E End(fl) are real. We note that a para-Hermitian symmetric space is a reductive symmetric space that can be realized as a hyperbolic orbit. E x a m p l e 3.17
There does not exist an infinite discontinuous group act-
ing on the following homogeneous manifolds: i) reductive symmetric spaces GL(n,
C)/GL(n,R),
SO(2n + 1,C)/SO(2n,
C),
U(m,n)/O(m,
n).
ii) para-Hermitian symmetric spaces
Sp(n,R)/GL(n,R),
SO*(nn)/SU*(2n) x R.
iii) hyperbolic orbits GL(nI + . . . +
nk,R)/GL(nl,R) x . . . x GL(nk,R).
On the other hand, there exists a discontinuous group that is isomorphic to Z n acting on the following homogeneous manifolds:
Sp(2n, R)/U(n,n),
n)
GL(2n, IR)/GL(n, C),
(n _<m).
T. Kobayashi
126 3.8
S k e t c h of p r o o f of t h e c r i t e r i o n for C a l a b i - M a r k u s First we explain a continuous analog, that is, Problem 2.13(1) for
the criterion for a proper action in a general reductive setting (Theorem 3.18). The criterion for the Calabi-Markus phenomenon (Theorem 3.10) is obtained as a very special case of the continuous analog, combined with Observation 2.12. 3.9
C r i t e r i o n of p r o p e r a c t i o n s in a c o n t i n u o u s s e t t i n g
Let G / H , G / L be homogeneous spaces of reductive type. Then the following five conditions are equivalent:
Theorem
3.18 ([Ko2])
1) L acts on G / H properly. 1)~ H acts on G / L properly.
1)" H ~ L
inG.
2) The triplet (L, G, H) has the property (CI). That is, for any g C G,
L N g H g - 1 is compact. 2)' a(L) N a(H) = {0}. See Section 2.11 for the definition of ~ , Section 2.12 for the property (CI), and Definition 3.14 for a(L). In the theorem, (1) w (1)' ¢:~ (1)", (2) ~:v (2)' and (1) =~ (2) are easy. The nontrivial part is the implication (2) =v (1). The proof of (2) =~ (1) is divided into two steps: i) Reduction to the case where H and L are abelian. This is an easy step that can be proved by using the Caftan decomposition. ii) Proof of the abelian case. This is done by looking at the infinite points in a Riemannian symmetric space based on some structural results on parabolic subgroups and nilpotent elements. 3.10
C r i t e r i o n of p r o p e r a c t i o n s in a d i s c r e t e s e t t i n g Similar techniques lead us to a generalization to the case where H and
L are not necessarily reductive: Theorem
3.19 ([Kol0])
Let H , L be subsets of a real reductive linear
Lie group G. i) H ~ L in G ¢v a(H) cfi a(L) in a. ii) H-.~ L in G ¢=~ a ( H ) ~ a ( L ) in a.
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
127
If H and L are reductive in G, then it is easy to see t h a t Theorem 3.19(i) implies Theorem 3.18. If G = GL(n,N) and H = G L ( m , N ) , then Theorem 3.19(i) implies a result of Friedland ([Fr, Theorem 3.1]). For more details, we refer to [Ko2], [Kol0]. Example
3.20
Let G -
SO(2m, 2n), L -
SO(p,q) ~ 12m-p x SO(p,q) x 12n-q C G.
U(m,n)
C G, and H -
Here, we assume 0 < q <
p, 0 < n < m, p < 2m, and q < 2n for simplicity. Then, with a suitable coordinate, we can identify aa with N 2n and WG ~ G2, ~< (Z/2Z) 2n in GL(aG). Up to the conjugacy by an element of WG, we have
a(L) - { ( a l , a l , a 2 , a 2 , . . . , a n , a n ) a(H) - { ( b l , b 2 , . . . , b q , O , . . . , O ) ' b i
" ai E R (l _< i <_ n)}, C ]R (1 __ i _< q)}.
So the condition (2)' in Theorem 3.18 amounts to q -
1. Therefore, we
conclude that U(m, n) acts on SO(2m, 2n)/SO(p, q) properly if and only if q-1. Exercise
3.21
Let G / H = SO(2p, 2q)/U(i,j)
(i < p, j < q, i < j).
Prove that if i < min(p, q) then there exists a discontinuous group F (C G) acting on G / H such that F is isomorphic to 7rl(Mg). Hint: Show first that there is a subgroup of G isomorphic to PSL(2, N) that acts properly on G / H (use Theorem 3.18). Then use the fact that there exists a discrete subgroup F of PSL(2, R) such that F _~ 7rl(Mg) (see Example 1.11). 3.11
Historical notes
neductive case:
The implication (1) =~ (2) in Theorem 3.10 was first
proved by E. Calabi and L. Markus in the case G / H = S O ( n + l , 1)/SO(n, 1) in [CM] (see Theorem 3.2). Then J. Wolf extended their result to the case
G / H = SO(p + 1, q)/SO(p, q) (q <_ p) in [Wol]. After finding some other similar results for symmetric spaces of rank one (e.g., [Wo2]), he finally obtained the sufficiency of the real rank condition in the case of semisimple symmetric spaces in the 1960s (see [Wo3]). His idea is also applicable to our more general setting. On the other hand, the proof of the necessity of the real rank condition given there was incomplete because of some confusion with the definition of properly discontinuous actions (see Example 2.8 for the difference between local Hausdorff topology and Hausdorff topology).
128
T. Kobayashi
The converse implication (2) =v (1) in Theorem 3.10 is more difficult because we have to show the existence of an infinite discontinuous group acting on G / H if ]R-rankH < R-rankG. It took about 20 years before the converse implication was first proved in the rank one case G / H SO(p + 1, q)/SO(p,q) (q > p) by R. Kulkarni ([Ku, Theorem 5.7]).The method there is based on a study of quadratic forms of type (p + 1, q). with the aid of a lemma due to N. Wallach. The general case is due to T. Kobayashi [Ko2] as an application of Theorem 3.18 with dim L - 1. Solvable case:
It was proved by Kobayashi that there always exists a
Clifford-Klein form of a homogeneous manifold G / H with infinite fundamental group (Theorem 3.9) if G is a solvable group and H ¢ G ([KoS]). Lipsman made a further study of properly discontinuous actions and the property ( C I ) i n [Lip]. General case: It is still an open problem to find a criterion on (G, H) for a general Lie group G such that a homogeneous space G / H admits an infinite discontinuous group.
G e n e r a l i z e d H i r z e b r u c h ' s proportionality principle
and its application 4.1
H i r z e b r u c h ' s proportionality principle In 1956, Hirzebruch proved
T h e o r e m 4.1([Hi]) Let D be a bounded Hermitian symmetric domain, F a torsion free discrete cocompact subgroup of the automorphism group Aut(D) of D, and M the compact Hermitian symmetric space dual to D. Then there is a real number A = A(F) such that c"(F\D)[F\D] = Ac~(M)[M] for any c a, where a = ( a l , . . . , a k ) is a multi-index and c a - c ~ 1 U . . . U c ~k k is a monomial of Chern classes. In this section, we shall clarify this principle by eliminating unnecessary conditions. The setting is generalized as follows: Hermitian symmetric spaces tangent bundles characteristic numbers
homogeneous spaces of reductive type homogeneous vector bundles characteristic classes
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups
129
As an application, we find an obstruction to the existence of compact Clifford-Klein forms of homogeneous spaces of reductive type by means of the Euler-Poincar~ class (see Corollary 4.12). 4.2
S k e t c h of i d e a
It has been a classical and standard technique, in particular, in representation theory, to compare two objects through a holomorphic continuation: For instance, i) Weyl's unitary trick - - finite dimensional representations of reductive groups ii) Flensted-Jensen duality
eigenspaces on semisimple symmetric spa-
ces (e.g., IF1]) The argument in this section lies in the same line: iii) (generalized) Hirzebruch's proportionality principle classes of homogeneous spaces of reductive type
characteristic
Let us explain the idea briefly in the case of Theorem 4.1, taking G = SL(2, R) as an example. In this case D = SL(2, N)/SO(2)
(the Poincar~ upper half plane),
M = SU(2)/SO(2)(~_ C P 1)
(the projective space).
There are two ways to compare the two manifolds D (or F \ D ) and M: i) D C M ii) D C SL(2, C)/SO(2, C) D M
(the Borel embedding), (complexification).
The proportionality principle for Hermitian symmetric spaces (Theorem 4.1) can be proved based on the Borel embedding (i) as well as based on the complexification (ii). However, we will see that the argument using (ii) has a wider application, even when there is no natural map between D and M. Returning to our special example, we note that Mc := SL(2, C)/SO(2, C) is a common complexification of M = SU(2)/SO(2) and D = SL(2, R)/SO(2) in (ii), if we forget the original complex structures and look upon M and D simply as real manifolds. Now, we can compare differential forms that represent characteristic classes of two manifolds D and M through the holomorphic continuation on Mc.
This is the main
idea of the proof of a generalized Hirzebruch's proportionality principle, which we discuss in Sections 4.3 and 4.4.
130
T. Kobayashi
4.3
C o m p l e x i f i c a t i o n a n d a s s o c i a t e d R i e m a n n i a n s p a c e s of compact type
Let us introduce the setting to realize the idea in Section 3.2. Let G be a connected real reductive linear group and H a connected subgroup reductive in G. We assume that there is a connected complex reductive Lie group Gc and a connected closed subgroup Hc with Lie algebras gc and I?c respectively, such that G C Gc. Take a Cartan involution 0 of G such that OH = H. We write the corresponding Cartan decomposition as g = [~+ p. Let Gu be the connected subgroup of Gc with Lie algebra gv := t~ + x/%--lp, and Hu the connected subgroup of Gc with Lie algebra I?v := t) n t~+ x/r2-1I~ np. Then, Gu is a maximal compact subgroup of Gc, and so is Hu of Hc. The homogeneous manifold G u / H u is said to be an associated Riernannian space of compact type. In summary, we have the following setting:
G
C
u
H
Gc
D
u C
Hc
Gu u
D
Hu
Remark The argument in this section is still valid for H with finitely many connected components, if we replace Hc by Hc(H n K) and Hu by
Hu(HnK). E x a m p l e 4.2
Here are some typical examples of Go~He and G u / H u .
i) Let G / H = SL(n,]R)/SO(p, n - p). Then Go~He - SL(n, C)/SO(n, C) and G u / H u - SU(n)/SO(n). ii) Let G / H = GL(n, IR)/(IR x)n. Then Go~He - GL(n, C)/(C x )n and G u / H u = V ( n ) / V ( 1 ) n. iii) Let G / H = Sp(2n,]R)/Sp(n, C). Then Go~He = Sp(2n, C)/Sp(n, C) x Sp(n, C) and G u / g u = Sp(2n)/Sp(n) x Sp(n). E x a m p l e 4.3
The foregoing assumption (i.e., closedness of He) is satis-
fied for (G, H) in Example 3.13(i)-(iv). We recall that G / H is a reductive symmetric space in Example 3.13(iii); G / H is a semisimple orbit in Example 3.13(iv). The corresponding associated Riemannian space of compact
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups type
4.4
131
Gu/Hu is Gu/Hu = a compact symmetric space
for Example 3.13(iii),
Gu/Hu = a generalized flag variety
for Example 3.13(iv).
A homomorphism
between cohomology rings
In the setting of Section 4.3, suppose a discrete subgroup F of G acts
G/H properly discontinuously and freely, so t h a t F\G/H is a smooth manifold. (We do not require that F\G/H is compact. F is allowed to be on
the trivial subgroup {e}.) We define
Mu := Gu/Hu C Mc := Go~He D MR := G/H. Then, to compare characteristic classes of the two manifolds
Mu and MR,
we use the following restriction maps:
(.9 /
rest.
"~ rest.
Gu and G acting on Mu and MR, respectively, have the common complexification Go, which acts holomorphically on Me. Because Gu
The groups
is compact, we can find a Gv-invariant differential form as a representative of an arbitrary element of the de R h a m cohomology group
H*(Gu/Hu; C). Go~He, and
This element extends to a holomorphic differential form on then we can restrict to
G/H and to F\G/H. Thus, the diagram induces a
h o m o m o r p h i s m on the cohomology level: Theorem
4.4
We have a natural C-algebra homomorphism ~7: H*(Gu/Hu;C) ~ H*(F\G/H;C).
If F\G/H is compact and H is connected, then ~ is injective. The last s t a t e m e n t follows from the Poincar@ duality.
132 4.5
T. Kobayashi
Real homogeneous vector bundles We review the definition of an associated vector bundle. Let p" H ~ GLR(V)
be a representation of H on a real vector space V.
Suppose a discrete
subgroup F acts on a homogeneous space G / H properly discontinuously. Associated to the principal H-bundle H --. F \ G ~ r \ a / H
is a real homogeneous vector bundle over F \ G / H , r E " - F \ G x o V, defined by the set of equivalence classes with respect to the action of H , that is, (~, v), (g--7,v') E F \ G x V are equivalent ¢ , - g - g-Th and v - p ( h - 1 ) v ~ for some h C H.
The projection on the first component F \ G x V ~ F \ G gives rise to the projection r E - F \ G x p V ~ F \ G / H with typical fiber V. Similarly, an associated real vector bundle E u := G u x pv Vu over G u / H u
is defined if
a representation p v : H u --* GLR(Vu) is given. 4.6
Weyl's unitary trick The idea of Weyl's unitary trick is a holomorphic continuation of finite
dimensional representations. Here, we set up some notation of finite dimensional representations that fits into Hirzebruch's proportionality principle. Let H C He D H u be as in Section 4.3, namely, Hc is a complex reductive Lie group, H is a real form, and H u is a compact real form. Let p" H ~ GL~(V), Pu" H u --~ GL•(Vu)
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
133
be finite dimensional representations over R. We say that the complexifications of p and pv are isomorphic if there are i) a complex vector space Vc ii) a holomorphic representation Pc: He ~ GL(Vc, C) iii) isomorphisms ~b: V ® C -% Vc and Cu: Vu ® C -% Vc such that the following diagram commutes:
4.7
L
H
¢-~
Hc
~
Hu
GLut(V)
~
GLc(Vc)
~-"
GLR(Vu)
principle
Hirzebruch's proportionality
T h e o r e m 4.5 ([KoO]) Retain the setting of Section ~.3. Let F be any discrete subgroup of G acting on G / H freely and properly discontinuously from the left. Suppose that the complexifications of p: H ~ GL~(V) and pu : Hu ~ GL~t(Vu) are isomorphic. Then the ith Pontryagin class satisfies V(p~(Eu)) = p~(rE) e H4~(F\G/H;I~). In particular, if there is a relation ~ a~pa(Ev) = 0 in H * ( G u / H u ; ] ~ ) , then the equation ~-]a~pa(rE) = 0 in H * ( F \ G / H ; I ~ ) holds. Here c~ = (C~l,..., c~k) is a multi-index and pa p~l U ... U Pk~k is a monomial of _
Pontryagin classes. S k e t c h o f Proof'. We take an invariant connection (the canonical connection of the second kind on G / H in the sense of [No]) on the principal bundles G ~ G / H , Gu ---* G u / H u , respectively. Then the curvature forms are represented in terms of the Lie algebras. By the Chern-Weil theory (see [D], [NON], [We]), characteristic classes are represented by using curvature forms. Now, we have the theorem by the usual Weyl's unitary trick for finite dimensional representations and by using the holomorphic
continuation through r/.
D
We note that in the case of Riemannian symmetric spaces (in particular, Hermitian symmetric spaces), we can prove the theorem without using a holomorphic continuation. That is, we pull back directly the curvature forms via the R-linear bijection ~ v / O v ~~g/[}. This map is different from r] in Theorem 4.4 only by a constant multiple depending on degrees.
T. Kobayashi
134
4.8
Tangent bundle The characteristic classes of a manifold are, by definition, those of the
tangent bundle. The tangent bundle T ( F \ G / H ) is associated to the adjoint representation AdlH" H ~ GL~(g/O), that is,
T ( F \ G / H ) ~_ F\G
x g/l],
AdlH
and similarly
T ( G u / H u ) ~ Gu
x
AdIHu
gu/i)u.
Since AdiH" H ~ GL~(9/[3) and AdiH u • Hu ~ GL~(gu/[~u) have isomorphic complexifications, we have now relations of Pontryagin classes (of the tangent bundle) between G u / H u and F \ G / H as follows.
In the same setting as Theorem 4.5, we have
C o r o l l a r y 4.6
rl (pi(Gu/Hu)) - p i ( F \ G / H ) E H4i(F\G/H;N). Furthermore, if H is connected, then we have a relation of Euler-Poincard classes:
( x ( G u / H u ) ) - X(F\G/H) e H~(F\G/H;R). We note that both F \ G / H and G u / H u are orientable if H is connected. 4.9
Complex homogeneous vector bundles Let p: Hc ~
GLc(Vc) be a holomorphic representation on a finite
dimensional vector space Vc over C. Associated to the principal H-bundle
H ~ F\G ~ F \ G / H , we define a homogeneous complex vector bundle over F \ G / H by
rEc:=r\G
x Vc.
Pig
Similarly, we define a homogeneous complex vector bundle over G u / H u by
Euc := Gu x Vc. P[Hu
Chapter 3 4.10
Discontinuous Groups
135
C h e r n classes
Retain the same setting as before. Let F be any discrete subgroup of G acting on G / H freely and properly discontinuously from the left. Then the i th Chern class satisfies Theorem
4.7 ([KoO])
~(cg(Euc)) = c g ( r E c ) ~ H2~(F\G/H;R). In particular, if there is a relation ~-~a~c~(Ev) = 0 in H*(Gu/Hu;I~), then the equation ~-~a~c~(rE)= 0 in H*(F\G/H;I~) holds. I f F \ G / H is compact and H is connected, the converse statement also holds. E x e r c i s e 4.8 Formulate an analogous result to Corollary 4.6 in the case of Chern classes of homogeneous manifolds. (Hint: The assumption will be that G / H is an elliptic orbit. See Section 5.12. See also [KoO, Corollary
4]) 4.11
Some examples
E x a m p l e 4.9
We consider a semisimple symmetric space
G / H = SO(p, q)/SO(p - 1, q). All Pontryagin classes of any Clifford-Klein form F \ G / H of a homogeneous manifold G / H vanish in H* (F\G/H; ~) because we know the corresponding result holds for G u / H u ~- S p+q-1. In particular, all Pontryagin classes of a Riemannian manifold of constant sectional curvature vanish (see also [Su]). We mention that there exist compact Clifford-Klein forms of SO(p, q)/SO(p - 1, q) if (p, q) = (1, n), (2, 2n), (4, 4n), (8, 8) (n e N) (see Example 5.14). E x a m p l e 4.10
We endow C p+q+l with an (indefinite) Hermitian metric
of type (p + 1, q), that is, ( Z , Z ) :-- Z l - ~ - J r ' ' " + Z p + l Z p + l -- Zp+2Zp+2 . . . . .
Zp+q+lZp+q+l.
Let X(p, q) be the open subset of the projective space CP p+q, which consists of the complex lines on which the restriction of the indefinite Hermitian
136
T. Kobayashi
metric is positive definite. Then U(p + 1, q) acts transitively on X (p, q), so that we have a diffeomorphism X(p, q) "" U(p + 1, q)/U(1) x U(p, q) -" G / H _~ U(n + 1)/U(1) x U(n)
C C.P n
-" G u / H u .
Here, we put n - p + q. We note that X ( n , O ) - CP n ~ G u / H u and that X(0, n) is the dual Hermitian symmetric domain of the noncompact type (see [He] for the terminology). Let F be a discrete subgroup of V(p ÷ 1, q) acting on X(p, q) freely and properly discontinuously, so that F \ X ( p , q) is a Clifford-Klein form of X(p, q). Then, we have a relation among Chern classes:
cj(r\X(p,
q))
-
n
n+ +1 -11
el (1-'\X (p, q) )J
(1 ~ j ~ n) .
This follows from the corresponding fact for X ( n , O) - CP n ~ U(n + 1)/U(1) x U(n), that is, the total Chern class c(CP n) - 1 + c~ (CP ~ ) + . . . + Cn (CP n) of the complex projective space C,P n is given by c(CP ~) - (1 + x) n+l
mod x ~+1,
where x is the first Chern class of the hyperplane section bundle (see [BoHi, 15.1], [MiSt, Theorem 14.10]). If F \ X ( p , q ) i s a compact Clifford-Klein form of X(p, q), then cj(r\x(p, q)) ¢ 0 for any j with 1 _< j <_ n. There exists a compact Clifford-Klein form of X (0, n), X (n, 0) (Pdemannian case), and X(1,2r) (see Corollary 4.7), whereas any discrete subgroup acting properly discontinuously on X(p, q) with p >_ q is finite (see Theorem a.10). E x a m p l e 4.12
Let M be a compact Clifford-Klein form of a complex
manifold SO(p, q + 2)/SO(p, q) × SO(2). Then the Chern class cj(M), for any j with 1 <_ j _< p + q, of a complex manifold M does not vanish, because we know that the corresponding result holds for the Hermitian symmetric space SO(n + 2)/SO(n) × SO(2). There exists a compact Clifford-Klein form for (p, q) - (n, 0) (n E N) and (4, 1) (see Corollary 5.6).
Chapter 3 Discontinuous Groups
4.12
137
Compact Clifford-Klein form We mentioned in Section 2.2 a third proof that PSL(2, R ) / S O ( 1 , 1)
does not admit a compact Clifford-Klein form by using a nonvanishing vector field. Now we are ready to state a generalization of this result to a higher dimensional setting:
Corollary 4.13 Let (G, H) be as in Section ~.3. Denote by K a maximal compact subgroup of G such that H N K is also a maximal compact subgroup of H. If r a n k G = rank H and dim K / H n K is odd, then G / H admits no uniform lattice, that is, there exists no compact Clifford-Klein form of G/H. Sketch of proof:
We may and do assume H is connected. Then, G / H
admits a G-invariant orientation, so that a Clifford-Klein form F \ G / H is an orientable manifold. The tangent bundle T(F\G/H) splits according to the H n K - m o d u l e decomposition q = q n ~ + q n p . Then,
X(F\G/H) = 0
because dim• q n t = dim K / H N K is odd. On the other hand, as H is of maximal rank in G, so is Hu in Gu. As H is connected, so is Hu. Therefore,
Gu/Hu is a compact orientable manifold with nonvanishing Euler number X(Gu/Hu) ([HoS]). Now it follows from Theorem 4.4 t h a t x ( G u / H u ) ~ 0 contradicts the fact that x(r\a/H) = 0 if F \ G / H is compact. Hence, F \ G / H cannot be compact. [2]
Example 4.13 (see Section 2.2) We know that the hyperboloid of one sheet G / H = SL(2, R)/SO(1, 1) does not admit a compact Clifford-Klein form. This fact was explained by using nonvanishing vector fields in the item (iii) of Section 2.2, which is a geometric idea of Corollary 4.12. In this case, we have rank G - rank H = 1 and dim K / H N K = 1, so t h a t the assumptions in Corollary 4.12 are satisfied.
Exercise 4.14 (see also Example 5.14)
Prove that a semisimple sym-
metric space S O ( / + k,j + l)/SO(i,j) × SO(k,/) does not have a compact Clifford-Klein form if exactly one element among i, j, k, 1 is even. At the end of this section, we pose the following conjecture:
Conjecture 4.15 (see [Ko3, Conjecture 6.4]) Let G / H be a homogeneous space of reductive type. It is likely that the inequality rank G + r a n k ( H n K ) _> rank H + rank K
T. Kobayashi
138
holds if G/H admits a compact Clifford-Klein form. The case with rank G = rank H can be proved based on Corollary 4.6 and on an argument of the cohomological dimension of a discrete group, as a slight improvement of Corollary 4.12 (see [Ko2, Corollary 5]). If H is compact satisfied. holds for compact
or if G/H is a group manifold, then the inequality is obviously As far as the author knows, the inequality in Conjecture 4.15 all homogeneous spaces of reductive type that are proved to admit Clifford-Klein forms (cf. Corollary 5.6).
N o t e s 4.16
i) Most material in this section is taken from [KoO].
ii) To establish the holomorphic continuation, we calculate characteristic forms in terms of Lie algebras. Similar calculations are also carried out in [Bo2], [CGW] for Riemannian symmetric spaces. iii) There exist different generalizations of Hirzebruch's proportionality principle, due to D. Mumford [Mu] for the noncompact Clifford-Klein forms of Hermitian symmetric spaces, and due to J. L. Dupont and W. Kamber [DK] for the secondary characteristic numbers. iv) F. Labourie informed me that Corollary 4.12 is also valid for a manifold modeled on a homogeneous space G/H (by e-mail, 1994). v) A similar idea (at least implicitly) to Corollary 4.12 is used in [Zu] based on the Gauss-Bonnet theorem in the case of rank 1 symmetric spaces G/H = SO(p + 1, q)/SO(p, q) (cf. Exercise 4.13).
C o m p a c t C l i f f o r d - K l e i n f o r m s of n o n - R i e m a n n i a n homogeneous spaces In Section 5, we focus our attention on compact Clifford-Klein forms of homogeneous spaces of reductive type. This section is organized as follows: Subsections 5.1 - 5.9
Homogeneous spaces with compact Clifford-Klein forms.
Subsections 5 . 1 0 - 5.12
Homogeneous spaces without compact Clifford-Klein forms.
5.1
U n i f o r m lattice, compact Clifford-Klein form
D e f i n i t i o n 5.1 Suppose G is a Lie group and H is a closed subgroup. Suppose a discrete subgroup F C G satisfies the following two conditions:
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
F acts properly discontinuously and freely on G/H. F \ G / H is compact.
139 (5.1a) (5.1b)
Then F is said to be a uniform lattice .for the homogeneous space G/H. The double coset space F \ G / H is a compact Clifford-Klein form of the
homogeneous space G/H. Suppose there exists a G-invariant measure on G/H. (This is the case for a homogeneous space of reductive type.) Then it induces a measure on a Clifford-Klein form F\G/H. The discrete subgroup F is said to be a
lattice for the homogeneous space G / H provided both (5.1a) and F \ G / H is of finite volume
(5.2)
are satisfied. If H is compact (in particular H = {e} or H = K), Definition 5.1 coincides with a usual one. 5.2
Riemannian
cases
If the isotropy subgroup H is compact, then any discrete subgroup of G acts properly discontinuously on G/H, as we saw in Section 3.3. This case, reffered to as the Riemannian case, allows a compact Clifford-Klein form. We recall the following important theorem due to Borel, Harish-Chandra, and Mostow-Tamagawa.
Suppose G is a real linear reductive Lie group and H is a compact subgroup of G. Then G / H admits compact Clifford-Klein forms. Furthermore, G / H has noncompact Clifford-Klein forms with finite volume if G contains a noncompact semisimple factor. T h e o r e m 5.2 ([Bol],[BoHa],[MoTa])
We shall not prove this theorem, and instead we refer the reader to [Ra], [Zil] and the original papers. We shall mention, however, some typical examples. i) A compact Riemann surface Mg (g _> 2 ) i s a compact Clifford-Klein form of the Poincar(~ plane PSL(2, R)/SO(2) (see Example 1.11). ii) If F = 7/~n C G = l~n D H = {0}, then F \ G / H __ ~ 1 x . . . x ~ 1 is a compact Clifford-Klein form of G / H ~_ I~n . iii) If F = G L ( n , Z ) C G = GL(n,R) D H = {e} (n >__ 2), t h e n F \ G / H is a noncompact Clifford-Klein form of G / H ~_ G L ( n , ~ ) with finite volume.
T. Kobayashi
140 5.3
Moore's ergodicity theorem A simple remark here is that if F is a uniform lattice for a group
manifold G = G/{e}, then the quotient topology of the double coset space F \ G / H is always compact. However, if H is noncompact, the double coset space F \ G / H does not have a good topology in general. In fact, the action of F on G / H is not properly discontinuous. We leave it to the reader as an easy exercise: E x e r c i s e 5.3
Prove that the action of F on G / H is not properly discon-
tinuous if F is a uniform lattice of G and if H is noncompact. Furthermore, the action of F on G / H can be ergodic: 5.4 ([Moo], see also [Zil, Chapter 2]) Let G be a noncompact simple linear Lie group. IS F C G is a lattice and H C G is a closed subgroup, then
Theorem
The action of F is ergodic on G / H
¢:~
H is noncompact.
Here, we recall that the action of F is said to be ergodic if every F-invariant measurable set is either null or conull. Thus, a uniform lattice for G / H must be smaller than a uniform lattice for G in some sense. In this respect, the cohomological dimension of an abstract group is a nice measure for the "size" of a discrete group (see [Ko2, Corollary 5.5]). We use it in the proof of Theorems 5.7 and 5.8. Basic references for the material we use on the cohomological dimension of groups are [Ser] and [Bi].
5.4
Indefinite-Riemannian
case
Suppose that G is a real reductive linear group and that H and L are both reductive in G. If the triplet (G, L, H) satisfies both conditions
T h e o r e m 5.5 ([Ko2, Section 4])
a(L) n a(H)
= {0},
d(L) + d(H) = d(G),
(5.3b)
Chapter 3
Discontinuous Groups
141
then G / H admits compact Clifford-Klein forms. Furthermore, G / H admits noncompact Clifford-Klein forms that have finite volume if L contains a noncompact semisimple factor. The same results hold for G/L because of the symmetric role of H and L. 5.5
W e l l k n o w n e x a m p l e s (I)
Riemannian
cases revisited
Suppose G / H is of reductive type. We know t h a t there exist compact Clifford-Klein forms of G / H if H is compact (Theorem 5.4). This fact is explained in the context of Theorem 5.5 as follows. Suppose H is compact. Then we have a(H) = {0} and d(H) - 0. If we take L = G, then the conditions (5.3a,b) are satisfied. Thus, Theorem 5.4 (Riemannian case) is a special case of Theorem 5.5. But this does not give a new proof of Theorem 5.4 because we shall use T h e o r e m 5.4 as a starting point for the proof of Theorem 5.5. 5.6
W e l l k n o w n e x a m p l e s (II)
group manifold cases
Let G' be a noncompact real reductive Lie group. Suppose