Wolfgang Pietsch Agglomeration Processes Phenomena, Technologies, Equipment
Wolfgang Pietsch
Agglomeration Processes...
80 downloads
2151 Views
34MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Wolfgang Pietsch Agglomeration Processes Phenomena, Technologies, Equipment
Wolfgang Pietsch
Agglomeration Processes Pheno mena, Tech no Iogies, Eq uipme nt
Dr.-/ng.Wolkang Pietsch, EUR INC
COMPACTCONSULT, INC. 2614 N. Tamiami Trail, #520 Naples, Florida 34103-4409 USA In Europe: Holzweg 127 67098 Bad Durkheim, Germany
This book was carefully produced. Nevertheless, author and publisher do not warrant the information contained therein to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate. Library of Congress Card No.:
Applied for.
Cover illustration
British Library Cataloguingin-Publication Data:
Like an agglomerate, the picture on the cover is composed of many disparate components, all of which relate to the topics discussed in this book. The panels on the left and right are microphotographs of naturally agglomerated nano-particles The top and the bottom panels depict different products from spray drying and fluid bed agglomeration. The four sectors (between the panels and the circle) represent Scanning Electron Micrographs (SEMs) of agglomerate structures as well as photographs of coated agglomerates and of granules. The top half of the circle shows products from tumble/growth agglomeration and the lower half are briquettes from roller presses as well as product from compaction/granulation. The center square includes tablets from punch and in die presses. The originals of the individual pictures from which sections are reproduced were supplied by (in alphabetical order): Albemarle Corp., Baton Rouge, LA, USA: Cabot Corp., Tuscola, IL, USA: Eirich, Hardheim, Germany: Euragglo, Qievrkhain, France; Niro A/S, Soeborg. Denmark; Norchem Concrete Products, Inc., Fort Pierce, FL, USA: Koppern GmbH & Co, KG, Hattingen, Germany. Their support is appreciated and acknowledged
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Die Deutsche Bibliothek - CIP Cataloguingin-Publication Data:
A catalogue record for this publication is available from Die Deutsche Bibliothek.
0 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, Weinheim, 2002 Printed on acid-free paper. All rights reserved (including those of translation in other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form - by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means - nor transmitted or translated into machine language without written permission from the publishers. In this publication, even without specific indication, use of registered names, trademarks, etc., and reference to patents or utility models does not imply that such names or any such information are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and, therefore, free for general use, nor does mention of suppliers or of particular commercial products constitute endorsement or recommendation for use. Mittenveger 6 Partner Kommunikationsgesellschaft mbH, Plankstadt Printing betz-druck GmbH. Darmstadt Bookbinding Grogbuchbinderei J. Schaffer GmbH & Co. KG, Crunstadt
Composition
Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany. ISBN 3-527-30369-3
I"
Contents Dedication, Acknowledgements and References
VII
1
Introduction
2
A Short History o f Agglomeration
3
Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science 5
4
Glossary o f Agglomeration Terms
5
Agglomeration Theories
5.1 5.1.1 5.1.2 5.2 5.2.1 5.2.2 5.3 5.3.1 5.3.2 5.4 5.5
The Development of Strength of Agglomerates 32 Binding Mechanisms 35 Binders, Lubricants, and Other Additives 42 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength 55 Theoretical Considerations 55 Laboratory and Industrial Evaluations 61 Structure of Agglomerates 76 General Considerations 78 Porosity and Techniques That Influence Porosity 89 Other Characteristics of Agglomerates 100 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration 109
6
Agglomeration Technologies 133
7
Tumble/Growth Agglomeration
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.4.1 7.4.2
Mechanisms of Tumble/Growth Agglomeration 140 Kinetics of Tumble/Growth Agglomeration 144 Post-treatment Methods 150 TumblelGrowth Agglomeration Technologies 151 Disc and Drum Agglomerators 153 Mixer Agglomerators 164
1
3
11
29
139
VI
I
Contents
7.4.3 7.4.4 7.4.5 7.4.6
Spray Dryers 187 Fluidized Bed Agglomerators 196 Other Low Density Tumble/Growth Agglomerators Agglomeration in Liquid Suspensions 221
8
Pressure Agglomeration
8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.4.1 8.4.2 8.4.3 8.4.4
Mechanisms of Pressure Agglomeration 231 Structure of Pressure Agglomerates 236 Post-treatment Methods 241 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies 252 Low-Pressure Agglomeration 253 Medium-Pressure Agglomeration/Pelleting 266 High-pressure Agglomeration 300 Isostatic Pressing 373
9
Agglomeration by Heat/Sintering 385
9.1 9.2 9.2.1 9.2.2
Mechanisms of Sintering 385 Sintering Technologies 389 Batch Sintering 390 Continuous Sintering 397
10
Special Technologies Using the Binding Mechanisms of Agglomeration 409
10.1 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.3
Coating 415 Separation Technologies 440 Gas/Solid Separation 440 Liquid/Solid Separation 442 Fiber Technologies 447
11
Engineering Criteria, Development, and Plant Design 453
11.1 11.2 11.3
Preselection of the Most Suitable Agglomeration Process for a Specific Task 462 Laboratory Equipment, Testing, and Scale-Up 468 Peripheral Equipment 492
12
Outlook
13
Bibliography 525
13.1 13.2 13.3 13.4
List of Books or Major Chapters on Agglomeration and Related Subject 526 References 530 Author’s Biography, Patents, and Publications 531 Tables of Contents of Related Books by the Author 541
14
Indexes 543
14.1 14.2 14.3
List of Vendors 543 Wordfinder Index 580 Subject Index 591
212
229
507
I
Dedication, Acknowledgements and References When this book was first planned, the idea was to combine in one volume concise descriptions of the agglomeration phenomena, technologies, equipment, and systems as well as a compilation of the applications of agglomeration techniques in industry. The latter was intended to demonstrate the widespread natural, mostly undesired occurrences of the phenomena, including possibilities to avoid them, and discuss the varied old, conventional, and new beneficial uses of the technologies. However, it soon became obvious that, in its entirety, this project became too voluminous and required much more time than anticipated. Therefore, it was decided to split the subject’s presentation into two volumes whereby both books will be “stand alone” publications that are also complementary. The first volume, available here, covers the fundamental phenomena that define agglomeration as well as the industrial technologies and equipment for the size enlargement by agglomeration. Applications are mentioned in a general way throughout the text of this presentation but without going into details. These applications will be presented in a separate book entitled “Agglomeration Technologies - Industrial Applications” that is scheduled for publication in 2003. A preliminary table of contents is given in Section 13.4. Many persons, institutions, and companies have contributed to the two volumes of this book. First and foremost, I wish to thank my wife Hannelore for her support and understanding while, thorughout my professional career, I was compiling various papers and books (see Section 13.3).All are dedicated to her. Without my wife’s active participation in preparing almost all publications, in elaborating the textbook entitled “Size Enlargement by Agglomeration” [B.42],which is a major reference for this publication (see also below), and her, if sometimes reluctant, acceptance that I was not available for long hours on many days during almost four decades, the books, in particular, could not have been completed. It is impossible to acknowledge all the help, extensive and small, that was provided by a large number of individuals and companies. In Section 14.1, a list ofvendors and other organizations is compiled which mentions those who have, in one way or another, contributed as well as some others who may be of interest as potential contacts for the readers of this book. While I have decided not to clutter the text with references, sources have been acknowledged if figures or tables were provided by or are based
“I’
Vlll
I
Dedication, Acknowledgements and References
on information from particular companies. The Discialmer at the beginning of this book (see page IV) should be referred to when using such cross-references. Regarding references to literature, Chapter 13 should be consulted. The earlier textbook “Size Enlargement by Agglomeration” [B.42] contains treatments as well as many references relation to the developing science of the unit operation and covers in some detail the sizing of and scale-up methods for agglomeration equipment. Since the emphasis of the new book is on practical considerations and industrial applications, not theory, the earlier book “Size Enlargements by Agglomeration” (Wiley, 1991) should always also be referred to. Information on the availability of reprints is available at the beginning of Section 13.1 and as a footnote later in the same Section. Since Size Enlargement by Agglomeration is one of the unit operations of Mechanical Process Technology (see Chapter 1) and, for the design and construction of agglomeration systems of any kind, many or all of the other unit operations are required, together with the associated transport and storage technologies, often even in multiplicity, and the analytical methods are applied for process evaluation and control, the reader who is interested in the topic of this book should also learn about or have access to information on the other fields of Mechanical Process Technology. This is also emphasized in Chapter 13. At this point I wish to acknowledge two books of general importance to which I have contributed chapters on agglomeration and ofwhich major portions were included in this book. They are: “Handbook of Powder Science and Technology” M. E. Fayed, L. Otten (eds,), 1st ed., Van Nostrand Reinhold Co., New York, NY (1983) and 2nd ed., Chapman & Hall, New York, NY (1997). Source references can be found in [B.21] and [B.56], Section 13.1. Finally, I like to mention with gratitude the following individuals who, as professionals and experts in their own fields, are or have been colleagues and/or partners in several continuing education courses over many years in the USA as well as in Europe. They have agreed that statements during their presentations and the elaborations for their course notes can be used directly, adopted, or modified for this book. They are, in alphabetical order: T. van Doorslaer, W. E. Engelleitner, M. E. Fayed, M. Gursch, D. C. Hicks, S. Jagnow, R. H. Leaver, R. Lobe, K. Masters, S. Mortensen, H. B. Ries, F. V. Shaw, J. Storm, R. Wicke, and R. Zisselmar. For additional references and acknowledgements please refer to Sections 13.1 and 13.2.
Naples, November 2001
Wolfgang Pietsch
Agglomeration Processes Wolfgang Pietsch Cowriqht 0Wilev-VCH Verlaq GmbH, Weinheim. 2002
1
Introduction
In 1957, under the leadership of Professor Dr.-Ing. Hans Rumpf at the Technical University (TH) of Karlsruhe, Germany, Mechanical Process Technology or Particle Technology [B.11] was first introduced as a field of science in its own right. It comprises the interdisciplinary treatment of all activities for the investigation, processing, and handling of solid particles as well as the interactions of such particulate solids. Four unit operations and associated techniques were defined (Fig. 1.1).Other common English names for this field of science, which was quickly adopted around the world, are Mechanical Process Engineering, Powder Technology, or Powder & Bulk Solids Technology. Size enlargement by agglomeration is the generic term for that unit operation of mechanical process engineering which is characterized by “combination with change in particle size” (Fig. 1.1).The author of this book had the privilege to become one of the first assistants of Professor Rumpf. For several years he was responsible for the research and development of size enlargement by agglomeration at the Institute of
Fig. 1.1 Unit operations and associated techniques o f Mechanical Process Technology
2
I
7 Introduction
Mechanical Process Engineering and earned his PhD with a doctoral thesis on specific aspects of a binding mechanism [1.1] of agglomeration. Webster’s Unabridged Third New International Dictionary [1.2] defines the verb agglomerate as: “to gather into a mass or cluster; to collect or come together in a mass; to collect into a ball, heap, or mass, specifically: clustered or growing together but not coherent”, and the noun agglomerate as: “a cluster of disparate elements; an indiscriminately (= randomly) formed mass”. A technical dictionary [ 1.31 defines agglomeration as: “sticking or balling of (often very fine) powder particles due to short range physical forces. Therefore these forces become active only if the individual particles (forming the agglomerate) are brought closely together by external effects”. These definitions distinguish the term size enlargement by agglomeration from the more general size enlargement such that particle growth occurring, for example, during crystallization or the production of particulate solids by melt solidification are not part of this unit operation of Mechanical Process Technology.
Agglomeration Processes Wolfgang Pietsch Cowriqht 0Wilev-VCH Verlaq GmbH, Weinheim. 2002
2
A Short History of Agglomeration As a basic physical efect, agglomeration has existed since particulate solids were first formed on Earth. Binding mechanisms between solid particles cause the stability of wet and dry soil and (often under the influence of heat and pressure) participate in the development of rock formations. Sandstone is the most easily recognized “agglomerate”. Agglomeration as a phenomenon, e.g. the natural caking and build-up of particulate solids, must have been observed and has been used by higher developed organisms and later by humans since prehistoric times. Sea creatures covered themselves with protective coats, birds as well as other animals built nests, and humanoids formed artificial stones, all from various solids, sand, clay and different binders that were often secreted by the creature itself. As a “tool” to improve powder characteristics, agglomeration was used by ancient “doctors” in producing pills from medicinal powders and a binder (e.g. honey) or by food preparers during the making of bread from flour whereby the inherent starchy components act as binder. In spite of this long “history”, agglomeration as a technology is only about 150 years old today (excluding small scale pharmaceutical and some little-known ancient, mostly Chinese applications as well as brick and bread making). Agglomeration as a unit operation, defined within solids processing, started around the middle of the nineteenth century as a method to recover and use coal fines. Agglomeration as a science is very young. It began in the 1950s with the formal definition of the binding mechanisms of agglomeration, interdisciplinary collection of knowledge relating to all aspects of agglomeration, and fundamental research which was no longer application oriented [B.42]. At approximately that time, the first recurring series of professional meetings were organized which were exclusively devoted to the science and technology of agglomeration (International Briquetting Association (IBA), - today Institute for Briquetting and Agglomeration (IBA) -, beginning in 1949 with biennial meetings and proceedings; International Symposia on Agglomeration, initiated in 1962 with proceedings, (see also Section 13.1)). Since that time, agglomeration science, technology, and use have experienced rapid growth but still without finding a corresponding awareness at institutions of higher learning and in the technical or process engineering communities. This book is the second by the author on the general subject of size enlargement by agglomeration. While frequently referring to fundamentals and specifics which are
4
I
2 A Short History ofAgglomeration
covered in more detail in the first book [B.42],this new text tries to provide an updated, comprehensive summary of the state-of-the-art of agglomeration, its basics, technologies, and applications, at the beginning of the 21st century.
Agglomeration Processes Wolfgang Pietsch Cowriqht 0Wilev-VCH Verlaq GmbH, Weinheim. 2002
Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
As mentioned in the previous chapter, size enlargement of particulate solids by agglomeration is as old as the existence of solids themselves. Originally, agglomeration happened naturally during the development of soil, stone, and rock formations. Later, unwanted agglomeration occurred during handling and storage of particulate matter particularly when hygroscopic and/or soluble materials (such as salt) “set-up”into lumps or large, more or less solidified masses. In the animal world agglomeration was used to develop protective coatings (e.g. many marine worms, Fig. 3.1), to build nests (e.g. swallows, termites, Fig. 3.2), and to provide a nourishing and protective environment for the offsprings (e.g. dung beetles, Fig. 3.3). Humans most probably first used agglomeration during the making of bread by taking flour (= particulate solids including an inherent binder, starch) and liquid additives (= additional binder for plasticity and “green”bonding), mixing and forming the mass, and, finally, “curing”the product, the removal of much of the moisture that was added during the mixing and agglomeration steps, to obtain structure and permanent bonding during baking. The technology of bread making combines all com-
Fig. 3.1 Protective agglomerated coating of a Rhizopod, a creping marine Protozoan (Difflugia urceolata)
6
I
3 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
Fig. 3.2a Nest of swallows made by agglomeration from mud, the bird’s saliva as a binder, and organic fibers for strengthening
Fig. 3.2b Nest of termites made from earth as well as the animal’s excrements and/or secretions as binder
3 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science 17
Fig. 3.3 Dung beetle, Scarabaeus Sacer, “pelletizing” d u n g
ponents of a complex agglomeration process including preparation of solid feed particles by milling (= adjustment of particle size and activation of the inherent binder, starch), mixing of particulate solids with additional binder(s),forming the mass into a “green”agglomerate, and a “post-treatment” (curing = baking =heating and cooling) to provide strength and texture, Very early it was also found that the porosity of the final product could be modified (= increased) by making use of gases that are produced during fermentation (initiated by sour dough or yeast) and result in bubbles in the green mass. These voids are stabilized by “strengthening” the bread during post-treatment (baking). For the construction of permanent shelter, humans may have observed the activities of animals that formed nests and protective “walls” from wet clay which hardened during drying (Fig. 3.2). By copying this behavior, wet clay, which was soon reinforced and made more water resistant by mixing-in straw or other fibrous material, was filled into a framework of wood branches and let harden during natural drying. To make building activities independent of the location of clay “mines”, during prehistoric times bricks were already produced from clay and sand and, after hardening, transported to building sites. Since fire was known for providing heat, the accidental “firing” of a piece of clay most probably resulted in the adaptation of an improved posttreatment that yielded waterproof bricks for areas where rock was not easily available, thus allowing the development of villages and, during the 4th millenium B.C. in Mesopotamia, cities with large brick structures. By experience, humans learned that certain natural materials helped cure specific illnesses. Minerals as well as dried animal and plant matter were ground to powder and “formulated” to yield medicines. Since powders cannot be easily consumed orally, natural binders, such as honey which, incidentally, also masked the unpleasant taste of
8
I
3 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
some of the medicinal components, were mixed with the powder and the resulting plastic mass was rolled by hand into little balls (= pills). The sticky binder(s) caused pills to adhere to each other; therefore, it was soon found that coating the pills by rolling them in flour or pollen solved this problem (see also Section 10.1). These three, well known ancient agglomeration techniques were used with little change through the ages of human history. Many other, lesser known and somewhat more recent processes could be added. However, it is not the objective here to produce a history book. Rather, these examples relating to three major modern “industries”, food, building materials, and health products, were selected to show that humans always lived with and used agglomeration. As a result, agglomeration technologies as all the other unit operations and associated techniques of Mechanical Process Technology (see Fig. 1.1)were considered to be “normal activities” which, with the beginning of industrialization in the 18th and 19th centuries A.D., were merely mechanized by simulating what was done manually before. During these early modernization efforts it was not considered necessary to question the fundamentals of the processes and “improvements” were based on empirical developments. Until very recently, agglomeration technologies had been developed independently in the particular industries in which they were applied. Because the process requirements are fundamentally different in such unlike industries handling, for example, coal and ores on one hand or food and pharmaceuticals on the other, no interdisciplinary contact and exchange of information took place. In fact, although agglomeration techniques developed along similar lines, application related “theories” were defined which were derived from investigations of specific requirements and their solutions together with a terminology that was often incomprehensible and, therefore, not useable by the “agglomeration expert” of another industry (see Chapter 4). Agglomeration as a science began when an effort was made to interdisciplinarily combine the extensive knowledge that had been accumulated during sometimes hundreds of years in specific fields of human activities. This approach showed that (in alphabetical order, not indicating importance): Baking: A thermal post-treatment process, does not only induce the development of final bonding, structure, and consistency in bread but produces similar characteristics during the heat curing of any “green” agglomerate. Briquetting: Is not predominantly a technique for the enlargement of coal fines for beneficial use but equipment which was specifically developed for that application is also suitable for such diverse uses as, for example, the briquetting of salt for the regeneration of water softeners, the briquetting of flaked DMT to decrease the bulk volume and improve handling and shipping, the briquetting of frozen vegetable pulps to be used as rations for field kitchens, the hot briquetting of sponge iron to reduce this commodity’s reactivity and allow open handling and storage, or the production of fertilizer spikes and the manufacturing of artificial fireplace logs. Coating: Is not only suitable for the modification of surface characteristics or the control of dispersion and dissolution of medicinal specialties but also to achieve similar properties in agrochemicals as well as human and animal foods, among others.
3 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science 19
Compacting: Is not only applicable for the production of “green” bricks or other ceramic bodies prior to firing but finds many uses in powder metallurgy or for the production of battery cathodes, etc. Granulating: Is not primarily a method to improve flowability of powders and formulations in the pharmaceutical industry but also in the fertilizer and bulk chemical industries as well as for carbon black, silica fume, and many other materials. Instantizing: As an example of a relatively new agglomertion process, is not limited to applications in the food industry for easily dissolvable drink and soup mixtures but is equally important for pigments, insectizides, fungizides, and many more. Pelleting: Originally developed for the shaping of animal feed formulations by extrusion, is also applicable for the production of catalyst carriers and other materials requiring uniform size and shape together with relatively high porosity. Sinteuing: When going back to the fundamentals of this process, was found to be not only a high temperamre process for the agglomeration of ores but, at much lower temperatures, also for plastics and other man made powders with low melting points or softening ranges, and, quite obviously, for powder metallurgy, mechanical alloying, or the like at many different temperature levels including extremely high ones for refractory metals. The above is only a small selection of the many diverse applications of particular agglomeration methods which, in all the different environments, follow the same fundamentals, apply the same rules, and use essentially the same equipment and systems if looked at from an interdisciplinary point of view. Although these facts become more and more known, there is still the understandable preconceived notion of, for example, somebody working in an ultraclean environment, such as the pharmaceutical, food, or electronic industries, that developments, expertise, and know-how gained in the “dirty” plants of, for example, minerals or metals production and processing, can not be considered as valid information that may be applied for the solution of a “clean”problem - and vice versa. In the case of “dirty” industries, a typical concern is that the often more deeply and completely investigated technologies originating in “clean” industries can not be applied because the production capacities are too small, the process may be batch, the equipment too complex, the execution and the materials of construction too expensive, etc., etc. However, as will be shown among other topics in this book, methods for the selection of the most suitable agglomeration process for a specific application (see Section 11.1)are the same for all projects. While some requirements, for example in regard to equipment or system capacity, or on the shape, size, and special properties of the products, may result in the definition of “cleaner” or “more heavy-duty, rugged” processes already in the preselection phase, the normal approach is to determine the preferred method and/or technique by considering the fundamentals as well as an interdisciplinary pool of expertise and know-how first. Conditions of the particular application such as, for example, “hot and dusty large volume processing”, or the opposite, “clean, small capacity operation with cGMP (= current Good Manufacturing Practice) and CIP (= Cleaning In Place) capabilities” are special design criteria that can be added to most of the systems later during the engineering phase.
10
I
3 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, a n d Interdiscip/inary Field of Science
Nevertheless, for manufacturing reasons and sometimes also because of special requirements on the company’s test facilities (see Section 11.2), some vendors specialize in equipment for one or the other industry. This is a decision of convenience by the individual supplier and does not indicate the existence of a fundamentally different technology. In fact, techniques or apparatus that were developed for a specific industry can be adopted for use in areas with different environment and requirements while still maintaining the fundamental underlying principle as well as the general machinery and process. Examples are flaking (see Section 8.4.3),instantizing (see Section 5.4),spheronizing (see Section 8.3),and spray dryer agglomerators (see Sections 7.4.3 and 7.4.4).
Agglomeration Processes Wolfgang Pietsch Cowriqht 0Wilev-VCH Verlaq GmbH, Weinheim. 2002
I
4 2
Glossary of Agglomeration Terms A Short History of Agglomeration
Newly developing fields of science are organized according to universally recognized As a basic physical agglomeration existed since particulate solids were first classifications usingefect, well-defined terms has to describe the fundamentals, correlations, formed on Earth. Binding mechanisms between solid particles cause the stability equipment, procedures, and processes. This is not the case for those technologiesof wetwere and dry soil for andcenturies (often under of heat and pressure) in the that known and the haveinfluence been developed empirically andparticipate independently development of rock formations. Sandstone is the most easily recognized “agglomfor different applications (see also Chapters 2 and 3). In such cases the same process, erate”. Agglomeration as aofphenomenon, e.g. have the natural caking andinbuild-up partiprocedure, activity or piece equipment may different names differentofindusculate solids, must have been observed and has been used by higher developed organtries or the same term may have different meanings in different fields of application. isms later by humans since prehistoric times. Sea creatures covered themselves The and earlier book “Size Enlargement by Agglomeration” [ B.421 contained already a with protective coats, birds as well as other animals built nests, and formed glossary of agglomeration terms. In the following this glossary ishumanoids repeated and upartificial stones, all from various solids, sand, clay and different binders that were dated. Although the author and many others that are active in the promotion of often “agsecreted by the As a “tool” to technical improve powder glomeration” arecreature trying toitself. use scientific and termscharacteristics, consistently inagglomeraan intertion was used by ancient “doctors” in producing pills from medicinal powders disciplinary manner (terms shown bold), it is still helpful to also explain some ofand thea binder (e.g. honey) or by food preparers during the making of bread from flour wheremore common names and expressions including a few historical ones. In the followby the inherent starchy components act as binder. ing, crossreferences are indicated by italic letters. The same and many more “agglomIn spite of this long “history”, agglomeration as atrade technology is only about 150 years eration terms”, the latter mostly descriptive and/or names, are mentioned and old today (excluding small scale pharmaceutical and some little-known mostly used in the text of the book. Sections 14.2 and 14.3 help locate these ancient, words and exChinese applications as well as brick and bread making). Agglomeration as a unit pressions. operation, defined within solids processing, started around the middle of the nineteenth recoverofand use coal from fines. the surface or edges of an Removal solid matter Abrasioncentury [n.] as a method to Agglomeration as a scienceagglomerate. is very young. It began in the 1950s with the formal The matter removed is much smaller than definition of the binding mechanisms of agglomeration, interdisciplinary collection the agglomerate itself. (See also attrition, erosion.) of knowledge relating to allMeasure aspects for of the agglomeration, andfor fundamental ability of a body, example an research agglomAbrasion resistance which was no longer application oriented [B.42]. At approximately that time, the first erate, to withstand abrasion. recurring [n.] series of professional organized which were deThemeetings process ofwere growth or enlargement by a exclusively gradual buildAccretion voted to the science and technology of agglomeration (International Briquetting Asup, such as: increase by external addition or accumulasociation (IBA), - today Institute Agglomeration -, begintion, for for Briquetting example by and adhesion of external (IBA) parts or partining in 1949 with biennial meetings and proceedings; International Symposia cles. (See also agglomeration, aggregation, build-up.)on Agglomeration,[vb.] initiated in 1962 (see pile also up. Section 13.1)). Since that Towith heapproceedings, up into a mass; Accumulate time, agglomeration science, technology, and use have experienced growth The action or process of accumulating; an rapid accumulated Accumulation [n.] but still without finding a corresponding awareness at institutions of higher learning mass, quantity, or number. and in the[ n.] technical or process engineering communities. A sticking together of solids. The molecular attraction Adhesion This book is the second by exerted the author on the general subject size enlargement by between the surfaces of of solids. Distinguished agglomeration. While frequently referring to fundamentals and specifics which are from cohesion.
”
12
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Agglomerate [vb.] Agglomerate [n.]
Agglomeration [n.] Agglomerator [n.] Aggregate
b.1
Aggregate [vb.] Aggregation [n.]
Agtation [n.] Agitator [n.] Ammoniation [n.] Angle of repose Angle of compaction Anticaking agent
Apparent density Atomizer [n.] Atomizing [vb.] Attrition [n.] Auger [n.] Axial extruder
To gather (particulatesolids) into a ball, mass, or cluster. (See also aggregate.) An assemblage of particles which is either loosely or rigidly joint together. Particles adhering to each other. (See also conglomerate.) The action or process of gathering particulate solids into a conglomerate. Specific equipment in which agglomeration is accomplished. Any of several hard, inert materials (as sand, gravel, rock, slag) used for mixing with a binding material to form concrete, mortar, plaster or, for example, road surfacing products. Also: A mass or body of units or parts somewhat associated with one another. To collect or gather into a mass. (See also agglomerate.) A group, body, or mass composed of many distinct parts or individuals;the collection of units or parts into a mass or whole; the condition of so collected. (See also agglomerate, aggregate, cluster, agglomeration, accretion, build-up.) Changes in characteristicsofparticulate solids or agglornerates that occur naturally with time. (See also post-treatment.) A state of movement of particulate solids and/or fluids induced by external effects or forces. See mixing tool, intensijer bar. The formation of fertilizer granulates using ammonia to obtain chemical modification and bonding. The basal angle of a pile of powder that has been freely poured onto a horizontal surface. See nip angle. Liquid or solid matter applied to the surface of, for example, agglomerates that prohibits sticking or growing together. (See also caking.) The weight of the unit volume of a porous mass, for example, an agglomerate. See nozzle. Finely dispersing liquids. The unwanted break-down of agglomerates. (See also abrasion, erosion.) See screw. Low, medium, or high pressure extruder with a flat die plate at the end of a barrel; the material is extruded in the same direction as it is transported by the screw(s).
4 Clossaty of Agglomeration Terms
Backmixing [n.]
Bag set
Ball [n.] Ballability [n.]
Balling [n.]
Barrel [n.] Basket extruder Beading [n.]
Bin [n.]
Binder [n.] Binding mechanism
Biomass [n.] Blade [n.] Blunger [n.] Boiling Bed Bonding [n.] Bowl [n.]
Bridging [n.]
Briquette [n.] Briquetter [n.]
During the flow of particulate solids, reverse movement of some particles due to their stochastic motion caused by turbulence or special equipment design. Typical in the fertilizer industry; unwanted agglomeration of particulate solids in a closed bag during storage. Mostly caused by recrystallization of dissolved materials. Synonymous with spherical agglomerate. (See also pellet.) Typical in the iron ore industry; the capability of particulate solids to form more or less spherical agglomerates during growth agglomeration. Originally in the iron ore industry; any method producing spherical agglomerates by tumble or growth agglomeration. (See also pelletizing.) Cylindrical (or sometimes tapered) housing for screws, e.g. offeeders or extruders. Low pressure extruder in which the die plate resembles a basket, using rotating or oszillating extrusion blades. Formation of bead-like particles; typical in solidification of melt droplets. (See also prilling, pastillation, melt solidijcation.) A container, box, frame, crib, or enclosed volume used for storage. (See also hopper, silo.) An inherent component of or an additive to particulate matter providing bonding between the disparate particles. Physical and chemical effects that cause adhesion and bonding between solid surfaces. See Section 5.1, Tab. 5.1 and Fig. 5.8. Organic plant and animal residuals. Often organic waste material that is especially used as a source for fuel. See extrusion blade. Typical in the ceramic and fertilizer industries; double shafted pug mill. SeeJluid bed. The process of binding particles together by the action of binding mechanisms. A vertical or inclined, cylindrical, conical or convex vessel enclosing and defining the operating volume of some coaters, mixers, spheronizers, etc. Unwanted arching of solid matter in a converging discharge chute or cone. Prohibits discharge of particulate solids from containers or chutes. Also briquet; agglomerate produced and shaped by highpressure agglomeration. (See also compact, tablette.) Also briquetting machine; equipment that produces briquettes.
14
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Briquetting [n.] Brittleness [n.] Build-up [n.]
Bulk density
Capillary [adj.] Capping [n.]
Cake [n.] Caking [n.] Cement [n.]
Cement [vb.] Cementitious [adj.] Channel [n.]
Chelate [adj.]
Chelate [n.] Chopper [n.] Clam shelling
Closed pore Cluster [n.] Clustering [n.] Coalesce [vb.]
The process of forming briquettes or compacts. The tendency of particles or agglomerates to break down in size easily. (See also friability.) The unwanted coating of surfaces with particles which adhere naturally due to their fineness and/or inherent binding mechanisms. The weight of the unit volume of a particulate mass under non-specific condition, e.g. in storage or in a shipping container. (See also density.) Describing full liquid saturation. Separation of a thin layer from the face(s) of compacts during decompression. Defect in tablettes caused by the recovery of elastic deformation and/or expansion of compressed air. See sheet; typical in fertilizer applications. Unwanted agglomeration during storage mostly by recrystallization of dissolved materials. (See also bag set.) A powder of alumina, silica, lime, iron oxide, and magnesium oxide burned together in a kiln, finely pulverized, and used as an ingredient of mortar and concrete. Also any mixture used for a similar purpose. (See also pozzolan.) To unite or make firm by or as if by cement. Having the properties of cement. Open ended compacting tool set for high pressure extrusion in a ram press; also any elongated opening through which material is extruded. (See also pressway.) Relating to, producing, or characterized by a cyclic structure usually containing five or six atoms in a ring in which a central metallic ion is held in a coordination complex by one or more groups each of which can attach itself to the central ion by at least two bonds. To combine with a metal to form a chelate ring or rings. See h i v e head. Opening of the leading or trailing edge of briquettes discharging from roller presses; one-sided splitting along the web.Also duck billing, oyster mouthing. A pore not communicating with or connected to the surface of a porous body. A number of similar individual entities that occur together. (See also accretion, agglomerate, aggregation.) The growing together of primary agglomerates to form larger entities. (See also satellites formation.) To unite by growth.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Coalescence [n.] Cohesion [n.]
Coating [n.]
Coating pan
Cold bonding
Compact [n.]
Compact disperse Compactibility [n.] Compacting [n] Compacting tool set Compactionlgranulation
Composite [adj.] Compressibility [n.]
Compression ratio
Conditioning [n.]
Cone agglomerator
A growing together or union in one body, form, or group. (See also growth agglomeration.) Molecular attraction by which the particles of a body (e.g. agglomerate) are united throughout the mass whether like or unlike. Distinguished from adhesion. Applying a layer of material, a film, or a finish to a substrate; in agglomeration, application of a layer of solids to a particulate unit. Specially shaped p a n in which a material layer is applied on agglomerates (such as tablettes) usually in the presence of liquid, heat, or both. Typical in the pharmaceutical and food industries. A binding process that occurs at ambient or low temperatures and uses the cementitous or pozzolanic reactions of many hydroxides; often assisted by pressure. An object of specific size and shape produced by the compression of particulate matter. Synonymous with briquette. A state of particulate solids in which individual particles are closely packed. Distinguished from discrete dispers. See compressibility. Also compaction. The method of producing sheet. The part or parts making up the confining form in which a powder is pressed. Synonymous with die. The normally dry methods of obtaining granular products by crushing and screening compacts and/or sheet into granulate. Consisting of two or more separate materials whereby each retains its own identity. The capacity of a particulate matter to be compacted. Compressibility may be expressed as the pressure or force to reach a required density or, alternately, the density at a given pressure or force. Synonymous with compactibility. The ratio of the volume of loose particulate matter in a die to the volume of the compact made from it. Synonymous withjll ratio. In low and medium pressure extruders, the total thickness of material that is under compression in a die (including any inlet chamfer) divided by the nominal hole diameter. Development of special characteristics of particulate solids by, for example, treatment with steam, kneading, heating, etc., or surface treatment by, for example, anticaking agents. Pan with relatively high conical rim.
16
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Conglomerate [n.]
Contact point Coordination number
Core rod Coufinhal press
CUP b.1 Curing [n.] Cut size Decrepitation [n.] Densification [n.] Density [n.] Deposit [n.] Die In.]
Die plate Disc [n.] Discrete dispers
Dispers [adj.] Dispersibility [n.]
Distribution plate
Doctor blades Dome extruder Double action pressing
An adhering mass of particles made up of parts from different sources or of various kinds. (See also agglomerate.) Area at which two particles touch each other. Sum of all near and contact points of a particle with surrounding particles in a structure made up of particulate solids, for example an agglomerate. Member of the compacting tool set that forms a through hole in the compact. (See also mandrel.) Punch-and-die press with multiple die sets on an indexed table for making large (e.g. coal) briquettes. (No longer used.) See pocket. Induration ofgreen agglomerates by any method. (See also post-treatment.) The actual value at which separation of a particle size distribution into “coarse” and “fines” has taken place. Breakdown in the size of particles or agglomerates due to internal forces, generally induced by heat. The act or process of making dense. Mass per unit volume of matter at specific conditions. For example: apparent, bulk, or true densities. A (natural) accumulation of particles. Member of the compacting tool set that forms the periphery of the part being produced. Also open ended channels for extrusion. Plates, rings, or other machine parts with perforations for extrusion. (See also die.) See pan. A state ofparticulate solids in which individual elements can be clearly distinguished. Distinguished from compact dispers. See particulate. Measure for the ease with which, under specific conditions (e.g. in liquids), an agglomerate breaks down into primary particles. Perforated plate at the bottom of aJuid bed through which fluidizing gas enters from the plenum. (See also gil plate.) See scraper. Axial, low pressure extruder, most often with two screws, in which the die plates resemble domes. A method by which particulate solids are pressed between opposing punches which are both moving relative to the die.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
117
Downdraft [n.] Drum agglomerator Dry granulation Duck billing Dwell time Encapsulation [n.] Erosion [n.]
Equivalent diameter
Expansion [n.]
Exter press Extrudate [n.] Extruder [n.] Extrusion [n.]
Extrusion blade
Feeder [n.] Feed screw Fill ratio
Flake [n.]
Flake breaker Flashing [n.] Flight [n.]
Downward flow of gas, for example through a particle bed. Slowly rotating, slightly inclined drum for growth agglomeration. See compaction/granulation. See clam shelling, oyster mouthing. In compacting, time during which certain process conditions, for example pressure, persist or are held constant. Typically used as microencapsulation. The gradual wearing away of an agglomerate by the progressive removal of small pieces of material. (See also abrasion.) Diameter of immaginary monosized spherical particles which feature the same property as the particulate mass to be characterized. For example: surface equivalent diameter. Increase in volume of, for example, an agglomerate after production or during post-treatment. Converse of shrinkage. See ram extruder. Product of extrusion. (See also pellet.) Machinery for the production of extrudates. (See also screw and ram extruder.) The formation of (often cylindrical) agglomerates by forcing a “plastic” mass through open ended channels or holes in (perforated) dies. In low pressure extruders, the flat, curved, or engineered blade that pushes material through the openings of a die plate; it is the part closest to the die plate. Device to deliver feed material to a processing unit. (see also force feeder.) Element@)providing forces onto particulate solids in a feeder. (See also screw.) Typically used in tabletting or other confined volume compression equipment. Synonymous with compression ratio. See sheet. Also: 1. Grains or other malleable particles flattened between smooth rollers. 2. Material solidified from a melt on a rotating, cooled drum (flaker) and removed by scrapers. A primary crusher (often two rollers with teeth) used to reduce the size of sheet. See web. A continuous or semi-continuous spiral flat plate that is attached to the shaft of a screw.
18
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Floc [n.] Flocculant [n.] Flocculate [vb.] Flocculation [n.] Flocculent [adj.] Fluid bed
Fluid bed agglomeration Force feeder Fraction [n.]
Fragmentation [n.]
Friability [n.] Friction plate
Funicular [adj.] Gap b.1
Gear pelleter
Gil plate Globulation [n.] Granular [adj.] Granulate [n.]
Aflocculent mass formed by the aggregation of a number of fine suspended particles. A flocculating agent. To aggregate or coalesce into small lumps or loose clusters or into aflocculent mass or deposit. The act or process offlocculating. Containing, consisting of, or occurring in the form of loosely aggregated particles or soft flocs. Also fluidized bed. A bed of particles in which the particulate solids are kept in suspension by forces caused by an upward flowing fluid. Growth agglomeration in afluid bed. A feeder that provides forces onto particulate matter by, for example, the action offeed screws. That portion of a sample of particulate solids which is between two particle sizes (see cut) or in a stated range (e.g. fine, coarse, etc.). The process whereby a particle (or agglomerate) splits into usually a large number of smaller parts with a range of sizes. The tendency of particles to break down in size during storage and handling. (See also brittleness.) In spheronizers, a circular flat disc with a rough surface or uniformly spaced grooves which rotates inside a cylindrical bowl. Describing the transitional liquid saturation. In pressure agglomeration,the distance between the surfaces of compactingtool sets; specifically: in extrusion, the distance between the pressure generating device and the die plate, in roller presses, the closest distance between the rollers. Double-rollpellet mill in which the rollers are in the shape of coarse, intermeshing gears with bores at the root sections between the gear teeth. (Also gear pelletizer.) Distributionplate in which the perforations are manufactured such that they produce a directional flow of gas. See melt solidijication. Present as particles in “grain” shape and size. Coarsely particulate. Also Granule. From Latin granula = grain, particle. Any kind of relatively coarse particulate matter. In size enlargement, synonymous with agglomeration to a size range of between approx. 0.1 and 10 mm. In size reduction, synonymous with crushing into approx. the same size range. Granulate is normally considered dustfree, free flowing, and non-segregating.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Granulate [vb.]
Granulation [n.] Green [adj.]
Grid [n.] Growth [n.] Growth agglomeration Heat bonding Heel [n.]
Hopper [n.] Hot melt agglomeration Hot pressing Immiscible binder agglomeration Induration [n.] Inkbottle pore
Instant [adj.] Instantizing [n.]
Intensifier bar
Interconnected porosity
Producing a granular solid matter; possible by size enlargement (agglomeration, melt solidijcation [pastillation, prilling], and crystallization) or by size reduction (crushing). (See also compaction/granulation.) A general term for the production of solids in granular form by either size reduction or size enlargement. As in “green agglomerate”, “green pellet”, etc., means fresh, moist, uncured, etc. In spheronizers, the design (size and shape) of the grooves on the fnction plate surface. An increase in dimension by for example agglomeration or crystallization. (See also coalescence.) See coalescence, tumble agglomeration. See sintering. In batch processing, for example agglomeration, a percentage of the previous batch retained in or returned to the processing vessel. The funnel or chute that stores material and/or directs it into equipment. (See also bin, silo.) Granulation of a hot melt of e.g. urea or ammonium nitrate in a pan. The simultaneous heating and molding of a compact or briguetting of hot material. Selective agglomeration of particles suspended in a liquid by adding an immiscible binder during agitation. (See also oil agglomeration.) Strengthening of green agglomerates, mostly by heat. Non-cylindrical pore with varying diameter; particularly a pore with narrow entrance followed by a large, internal volume. Quickly soluble. Characteristic as, for example, in “instant coffee”. Producing agglomerated products with instant characteristics, i.e. material exhibiting, as compared with the untreated powder, particularly high solubility, even in cold liquids. In high shear mixers and agglomerators, an independently driven bar, rotating with high speed, usually carrying mixing tools and, sometimes means for atomizing liquid binder, that extends into the particulate mass to be mixed and causes an additional turbulent motion of the particles. (See also knive heads.) A network of contiguous pores in and extending to the surface of a porous body, e.g. agglomerate.
20
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Interface [n.]
A plane or other surface forming a common boundary of two bodies or spaces. Isostatic pressing The densijication of a particulate mass by subjecting it to nominally equal pressure from every direction. In high shear mixers and agglomerators, independently Knive head driven high speed rotating tools which extend into the particulate mass and cause additional turbulent motion of the particles as well as desagglomeration in mixing and controlled destruction of agglomerates in agglomeration. (See also intensijier bar.) Land area The area surrounding briquette pockets on the roller surface of briquetters. (See also fiashing, web.) During briquetting in roller presses the forward edge of a Leading edge discharging briquette. A member of the compacting tool set that determines the Lower punch powder fill level and forms the bottom of the part in a punch-and-die press. Extruder in which the die plates consist of screens or thin, Low pressure extruder perforated sheets and exert small frictional resistance during extrusion. An agent mixed with or incorporated into particulate Lubricant [n.] matter or applied to the tooling to facilitate pressing and ejection of a compact, tablette, or extrudate. Lump [n.] See second meaning of aggregate. Mandrel [n.] Also mandril. A metal bar that serves as a core around which material may be bent, cast, forged, molded, or otherwise shaped. (See also core rod.) Marum [n.] Sometimes used to describe a particle which has been spheronized. Marumerizer [n.] See spheronizer. Original (Japanese)name. Mechanical alloying A technology of powder metallurgy by which powders of metals, that cannot be combined in molten stage, are mixed and compacted to form the alloy. Medium pressure extruder See pellet mill. Melt solidification A method by which molten substances are converted into particulate solids by cooling droplets of the melt. (See also beading, pastillation, prilling.) A method by which small portions of liquids, particulate Microencapsulation [n.] solids, or gases are enclosed by a shell (membrane, capsule) to form a dry, free flowing product often with spherical particle shape. The capsule shell may provide specific product characteristics (e.g. dispersibility, solubility). The formation of small agglomerates, usually not larger Micropelletizing [n.] than 3 mm, by growth agglomeration. (See also pelletizing.)
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Mixer agglomeration Mixing tool
Mix-Muller [n.] Mold [n.] Muller [n.]
Multiple pressing Near point
Nip [n.]
Nip angle
Nodulizing [n.]
Nozzle In.] Nucleus [n.], Nuclei [pl.]
Oil agglomeration
One pot processor
Open pore Orifice [n.]
Agitation and growth agglomeration in powder mixers. Any of a large number of differently shaped tools that are attached to a rotating shaft and cause irregular movement in a particle bed. See Muller. See die. Also Mix-Muller. Originally, a device that used a heavy stone roller to grind and/or mix particulate solids. Today, a blender with one, two or four large metal rollers that mix and knead (densify) material. Often used prior to pressure agglomeration. (See also p a n grinder.) A method of pressing whereby two or more compacts are produced simultaneously in separate die cavities. Area at which two particles approach each other closely enough for a binding mechanism to become effective. (See also coordination number.) In roller presses and pellet mills, converging space (volume) between two counter-rotating rollers and, respectively, the pressure generating device and the extrusion surface. (See also nip angle.) In rollerpresses, radial angle defining the line on the roller surface at which the speed of the particulate mass is identical with that of the roller; in extruders, the angle between the extrusion surface (e.g. die plate) and the pressure generating device (e.g. extrusion blade, screw, roller). Formation of nearly spherical lumps (agglomerates) from a wet mixture of particulate solids by either drying or chemical reaction during tumbling; typically accomplished in dryers or rotary kilns. Also atomizer. Means for atomizing liquids. Primary agglomerate(s) consisting of only a few particles on which further growth occurs. (See also seed.) Also spherical agglomeration. Selective agglomeration of suspended particles in water by adding a bonding oil during agitation; typical in coal preparation. (See also immiscible binder agglomeration.) A batch processing vessel in which several process steps, for example mixing, agglomeration, post-treatment, and finishing, are carried out without opening the vessel during the entire processing sequence. A pore communicating with or connected to the surface of a porous body. (See also inkbottle pore.) The mouth or opening of something, for example an extrusion channel, that forms material into defined shape.
I
22
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Oyster mouthing Pan [n.] Pan grinder Particle [n.] Particle size Particulate [adj.] Pastillation [n.]
Pastille [n.] Pellet [n.]
Pellet mill Pelleting [n.]
Pelletizing [n.]
Pelletization [n.]
Pelletizer [n.] Pendular [adj.] Penetrating pore Pin mixer Piston press Plenum [n.]
Plow [n.] Plug flow
See clam shelling, duck billing. Also disc. An inclined rotating circular plate with low cylindrical rini for growth agglomeration. See Muller. A piece of solid material that is an entity in itself. The controlling dimension of an individual particle as determined by analysis. Of or relating to separate particles. A method of melt solidijcation by which droplets of a molten material are solidified on a cooled, moving stainless steel belt. Product of pastillation. Name for many different types of agglomerates. Most commonly used in the iron ore industry for nearly spherical agglomerates formed by growth agglomeration in pans, cones, or drums and in the animal feed industry for extrudates produced by pelleting. Often synonymous with agglomerate. Equipment for extrusion through perforated dies. Agglomeration by extrusion of plastic material or of particulate matter containing binders through bores of dies in “pelleting machines” or pellet mills. Originally, production of pellets by growth agglomeration. Today typically agglomeration by balling. Often also used as synonym for agglomeration. Typical in the (iron) ore industry; any agglomeration method involving growth agglomeration with subsequent heat induration. (See also sintering.) Usually rotating pan, drum, cone, or the like for growth agglomeration. (See also “gear pelletizer”.) Describing the liquid bridge model. A pore that connects opposite sides of a porous body, for example, an agglomerate. (See also through pore.) A stationary, cylindrical mixer using a single shaft agitator with pins. See punch-and-die press. Specially designed chamber at the bottom of afluid bed from which fluidizing gas enters the apparatus through the openings of a distribution plate. Plow shaped mixing tool. Forward movement of particulate solids to the discharge end of tumbling drums orfluid beds, caused by a continuous particle feed and optionally assisted by downsloping the drum or the application of gil plates influid beds.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Pocket [n] Pore [n.] Pore volume Porosity [n.] Porous [adj.] Post-treatment
Pozzolan [n.]
Pozzolanic [adj.] Powder [n.] Powder metallurgy
Powder rolling Pressway [n.]
Pressure agglomeration
Prill [n.] Prilling [n.] Pug mill Punch [n.] Punch-and-die press
Radial extruder
Indentation on the surface of rollers, normally forming one half of a briquette shape. (See also cup.) An inherent or induced cavity in a particle or void space between particles within an object e.g. agglomerate. Void space (volume)in porous objects. (See alsoporosity.) The amount of pores (voids) in an object expressed as percentage of the object’s total volume. Possessing or “full of” pores. Any treatment of green agglomerates to modify moisture content, strength, structure, etc., by, for example, aging, drying, heating, sintering, etc. (See also curing.) Also Pozzolana. Finely divided siliceous or siliceous and aluminous material that reacts chemically with slaked lime at ordinary temperature and in the presence of moisture to form a strong, slow hardening cement. Having the properties of pozzolan. Particles of dry matter typically with a maximum dimension of less than approx. 1,000 pm. The art of producing metal powders and of their utilization for the production of massive materials and shaped objects as well as for mechanical alloying. See roll compacting. Also used in powder metallurgy for direct rolling of sheet from metal powders. In extruders, the (length of the) channel in which frictional resistance causes the extrusion pressure; the total distance material is compressed inside a die. Also press agglomeration. Agglomeration technique during which agglomerates are formed by pressure. Distinguished from tumble agglomeration. Product of prilling. In the fertilizer industry often (incorrectly!!) synonymous with agglomerate. The formation of spherical particles by solidification of melt droplets. (See also melt solidllfication, shotfoming.) A paddle type mixer usually with open top, single or double shafts, and trough shaped chamber. Part of a compacting tool set which transmits pressure to the particulate matter in the die cavity. A mechanically or hydraulically actuated press in which a reciprocating piston compacts particulate matter in a die. Low pressure extruder in which part of the barrel consists of a screen or perforated thin sheet through which moist, plastic material is passed by extrusion blades to form extrudates; the material is extruded radially to the direction in which it is transported.
I
23
24
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Ram [n.] Ram extruder
Ram press Rim [n.] Ring die
Ring die extruder Ring roll press Roller [n.]
Roll(er) compacting
Roll(er) press Roll(er) pressing Rope [n.] Rotary press Satellites formation
Saturation [n.]
Schugi flexowall
Scraper [n.]
Synonymous with punch. Press in which a fly-wheel powered reciprocating ram densifies and extrudes particulate solids through a long extrusion channel. Particularly suitable for elastic materials (such as peat, lignite, biomass, etc.). Also ram press, exter press. See ram extruder. Cylindrical or conical wall surrounding the circular plate of pan, disc, or cone agglomerators. A usually narrow hollow cylinder that is equipped with perforations for extrusion. See pellet mill. Special roller press with one press roller within a large ring-shaped die. (No longer used.) Also Roll. Cylindrical rotating body that is: 1.Paired with an identical, counter-rotating one in a suitable frame. This arrangement is used for briquetting, compacting, pelleting, densijkation, jlaking, and granulating particulate solids. 2. Rolling close to a die plate and forces material to flow through openings, for example, in flat die pellet mills. 3. Mixing and kneading material in a cylindrical or “figure eight”-shaped bowl. (See also Muller.) Also powder rolling. The (progressive) compacting of (metal) powders in roller presses (often called “rolling mills”). (See also roll pressing.) Equipment for pressure agglomeration between two rollers. Densification between two counter-rotating rollers. (See also compacting.) In spheronization, referring to the rotating particulate material. Tabletting machine in which compacting tool sets are arranged on a rotating table (= turret). In agglomeration, the attachment of smaller solid entities, often agglomerates, to other agglomerates by binding mechanisms. (See also clustering.) Relative amount of pores in an agglomerate filled with a liquid or solid substance, as in “liquid saturation”, “binder saturation”. High speed, high shear mixer and/or agglomerator with vertical axis, adjustable mixing tools, flexible shell, flexing roller cage, and short residence time. A tool for removing build-up in agglomeration equipment. Also doctor blades.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Screen [n.]
Screw [n.]
Screw extruder Seed [n.] Segregation [n.]
Selective agglomeration
Sheet [n.]
Shot forming Shrinkage [n.] Silo [n.]
Single action pressing Sinter [n.] Sintering [n.]
Slug [n.]
Slugging [adj.]
Slugging press
A (usually mounted) perforated thin plate or cylinder or a meshed wire or cloth fabric used to: 1. Separate coarser from finer particles or 2. Form extrudates. A mechanical device spiral in form or appearance; a conveyor working on the principle of a screw; a conveying tool in afeeder, mixer, or extruder. Also auger, worm. Extruder in which screw(s) produce the extrusion pressure. See nucleus. The desirable or undesirable separation (according to mass, shape, size, etc.) of one or more components of a particulate mass. Agglomeration of only one component of a powder mixture controlled by, for example, binding mechanism, binder, particle size. (See also immiscible binder agglomeration.) A more or less continuous band of compacted material produced in roller presses featuring smooth or shallowly profiled rollers and a gap between those rollers. Also, anything that is thin in comparison to its length and/or breadth. The solidification of a melt into little spheres in a tall form tower. (See also prilling.) A decrease in dimension. In agglomeration, usually of a compact during sintering. Converse of expansion. A trench, pit, or especially a tall cylinder (as of wood, metal, or concrete) often sealed and used for storing particulate solids. (See also hopper, bin.) A method by which a particulate mass is pressed in a stationary die between one moving and one fixed punch. Agglomerated product of sintering. Technique involving induration of green agglomerates by heat. Generally, bonding at a temperature below the melting or softening points of the main constituent of a mixture by the application of heat. (See also heat bonding.) Large, flat faced compressed disk prepared for the purpose of stabilizing the mixture of ingredients in the pharmaceutical industry. 1. Producing slugs in a sluggingpress. 2.Influid bed technology, the slow, upward movement of large, somewhat cohesive masses of particulate solids. Punch-and-die press for the production of large tablettes or slugs which are crushed to obtain granulate. Mostly in the pharmaceutical industry. (See also tabletting machine.)
26
I
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Spherical agglomeration Spheronizing [n.]
See oil agglomeration. Rounding of soft, plastic (usually green) agglomerates (usually extrudates) in a spheronizer. Vertical drum with rotating bottom for spheronizing. Spheronizer [n.] (See also Marumerizer.) Characteristic parameter for roller presses; defined as Specific force pressing forcelactive roller width. The formation of granular solids or small spherical agSpray drying glomerates by dispersing a liquid or slurry in droplet form at the top of a tower and evaporating the liquid in the presence of drying gases. The formation of small, spheroidal agglomerates in a Spray granulation fluid, circulating, or spouted bed by spraying a solution, slurry or melt onto the particles; often combined with drying. Stabilize [vb.] Avoid segregation by agglomerating a powder mixture. An elongated body; synonymous with uncut extrudate. Strand [n.] Strip [n.] See sheet. Surface equivalent diameter The diameter of immaginary monosized spherical particles, calculated from the mass related specific surface area, in m2/g,of a particle size distribution, that produce the same specific surface area as the powder. The state ofparticulate solids which are uniformly mixed Suspension [n.] with but undissolved in a fluid. Also Tablet. A compressed agglomerate made of particuTablette [n.] late solids, specifically,in pharmacy, a small compact of a medicated particulate formulation usually in the shape of a disc or a flat polyhedral body. (See also briquette.) The process of forming tablettes. Tabletting [n.] Compaction press for the manufacture of tablettes. Tabletting machine A tall tower with enlarged conical bottom. Tall form tower To drive in or down by a succession of light or medium Tamp [vb.] blows; predensify. See tamp. Tamper [n.] A receptacle for holding, storing, or transporting liTank [n.] quids. Using heat to fuse particulate solids into agglomerates. Thermal agglomeration (See also heat bonding, sintering.) The property of various materials to become fluid when Thixotropy [n.] disturbed (as by shaking, vibration, pressure, etc.). Materials tending to exhibit Thixotropy. Thixotropic [adj.] See penetrating pore. Through pore Parts making up the compacting tool set of a tabletting Tooling [n.] machine.
4 Glossary of Agglomeration Terms
Tower [n.]
Trailing edge True density Tumble agglomeration
Turret [n.] Updraft [n.] Upper punch Wear [n.]
WDG Web [n.] Wet agglomeration Withdrawal process
Worm [n.] WSG
In spray drying or prilling, a cylindrical structure in which liquid droplets that were formed at the top solidify during their descend in a gas atmosphere with suitable temperature. During briquetting in roller presses the back edge of a discharging briquette. The mass of the unit volume of a solid material that is free of pores. Agglomeration technique during which agglomerates are formed by growth during tumbling; synonymous with growth agglomeration. (See also coalescence.) Rotating table carrying the compacting tool set of some tabletting machines. Upward flow of gas, for example through a particle bed. Member of the compacting tool set that closes the die and forms the top of the part being produced. Similar to erosion, but usually refers to the surface of a solid body such as a part of machinery. (Easily) Water Dispersible Granulate. Thin flashing surrounding briquettes made in roller presses; caused by the land area. Tumble andgrowth agglomeration in which the major binder is a liquid. Operation of some tablettingpresses by which the die descends over a fixed lower punch to reduce density variation in the tablette and facilitate removal of the compact. See screw. (Easily) Water Soluble Granulate. (See also instant.)
Agglomeration Processes Wolfgang Pietsch Cowriqht 0Wilev-VCH Verlaq GmbH, Weinheim. 2002
I
5
Agglomeration Theories The distinguishing characteristic of size enlargement by agglomeration is the formation of larger entities from particulate solids by sticking particles together by short range physical forces between the particles themselves or through binders, substances that adhere chemically or physically to the solid surfaces and form a material bridge between the particles. The components of an agglomerate are often widely disparate and, except if matrix binders are applied (see Section 5.1.2) or after shrinkage during sintering (see Sections 5.3.2 and 9.1), void spaces are present between the particles forming an agglomerate. The above definition of size enlargement by agglomeration sets this unit operation of Mechanical Process Technology apart from other grain growth techniques, particularly crystallization whereby a uniform solid body grows from a mother liquor by forming a structure in which the same atoms and/or molecules have a regularly repeating internal arrangement. As will be shown later (see Section 7.4.6),agglomeration may also play a role during crystallization if nuclei or crystallites adhere to each other in the mother liquor and form macroscopically amorphous, porous structures. Size enlargement by agglomeration is also distinguished from another particle forming technique, melt solidification. In this process a molten material is divided into droplets or extruded through die plates and cut into cylindrical pellets. The product is then solidified by cooling. The melt may be directly synthesized, as in the case of urea prilling, or obtained by heating the solid. In the latter case, similar to the meaning of the term granulation, melt solidification can be a particle size reduction, if large chunks of a solid are melted and then divided into small droplets or extrudates that are solidified, or a particle size enlargement, if a powder is melted, divided into relatively larger droplets or extrudates, and solidified. Droplet formation can be by spraying through a number of differently designed nozzles (see also Section 7.4.3) or by dividing a liquid stream either naturally, by mechanical means, or by gas or liquid impingement. Solidification is accomplished during the free fall in a cooling tower (Fig. 5.la) which results in spherical “prills” (Fig. 5.2), on a cooled stainless steel belt (Fig. 5.1b) yielding flattened “pastilles” (Fig. 5.3), or in water (Fig. 5 . 1 ~ producing ) cylindrical extrudates (underwater granulation/pelleting).
29
30
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
I
Fig. 5.la
Fig. 5.1 Schematic representations o f the three most common melt solidification processes. (a) Prilling [8.42], (b) pastillation (courtesy Sandvik, Totowa, NJ,USA), (c) underwater granulation/ pelletizing (courtesy Gala, Eagle Rock, VA, USA).
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.2 Photograph of urea prills (courtesy KaltenbachThuring, Beauvais, France).
I
31
32
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.3 Photograph o f the discharge end o f a pastillator also showing pastillated product (courtesy Berndorf Band, Berndorf, Austria).
Since most of the commercially produced urea for fertilizer applications is prilled by the tower melt solidification process and urea is one of the most important nitrogen providing fertilizers, farmers and suppliers often wrongly name all spheroidal agrochemicals “prills” even if they were produced by true agglomeration processes, for instance on discs or in drums (see also Section 7.4.1). In the following only size enlargement by agglomeration will be covered.
5.1 The Development of Strength o f Agglomerates
Fig. 5.4 is the random cut through part of an agglomerate. Obviously, in reality, the structure is three dimensional. In such a body strength can be caused in several ways. In Fig. 5.4a the entire pore space is filled with a matrix binder. Typical examples of agglomerates held together in this manner are concrete, where the matrix between the aggregate particles consists of hardened cement (Fig. 5.5), or road surfaces, in which bitumen occupies the volume between crushed stone (Fig. 5.6). Fig. 5.4b generally looks very similar to 5.4a but shows an agglomerate structure in which the entire void volume is filled with a liquid that wets the solid particles. If concave menisci form at the pore ends on the surface of the agglomerate, a (negative) capillary pressure develops within the pores which affords strength to the body. As explained in Fig. 5.7, depicting a series of situations representing different liquid saturations in particulate bulk solids or of agglomerates, distinct distribution models exist which depend on the amount of liquid in the structure. The term liquid saturation is defined as the percentage of total void space that is filled with the liquid. A precondition for cohesiveness of particulate solids due to the presence of liquid is that the liquid wets the solids. Although, depending on the application, other liquids may be used to totally or partially fill the voids between particulate solids, in agglomeration water is most commonly used. Referring to Fig. 5.7, absolutely dry particulate bulk solids (Fig. 5.7a) are non existent under normal atmospheric conditions. The water molecules of adsorption layers (Fig.
5.7 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
Fig. 5.4 Random cut through part o f an agglomerate or a partculate bulk solid mass and explanations o f how strength may be caused. (a) Pore volume filled with a matrix binder. (b) Pore volume tilled with a wetting liquid. (c) Liquid bridges at the coordination points. (d) Adhesion forces at the coordination points.
Fig. 5.5 Cement bonding: Structure developing during early hydration [10.5].
Fig. 5.6
Structure o f stone mastic asphalt (SMA),
a modern asphalt matrix bonded road surfacing material.
I
33
34
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.7 Schematic representations o f different liquid saturations in particulate bulk solids o r o f agglomerates. (a) Dry, (b) adsorption layers, (c) liquid bridges (“pendular” state), (d) transitional (“funicular” state), (e) fully saturated (“capillary” state), (f) droplet.
5.7b) that quickly form on the solid surfaces are bonded so strongly that they are not mobile and, therefore, do not cause “liquid saturation” or moisture content which can be measured with “normal” laboratory equipment. However, as will be shown later (see Section 5.2.1), adsorption layers can participate in the development of strength by enhancing molecular (van-der-Waals)forces. With small amounts of “free” water, i.e. producing moisture contents of little more than a few tenth of a percent and, correspondingly, very small “saturation”, liquid bridges begin to form at the contact points between particles. With increasing moisture content or saturation liquid bridges form at all coordination points (see below) in the structure (Figs 5 . 4 ~and 5.7~).Further increase in liquid saturation produces a transitional situation in which liquid bridges and void spaces that are filled with liquid coexist (Fig. 5.7d). The theoretically highest saturation (100 %) is reached, when all voids within a bulk mass or an agglomerate are filled (Fig. 5.4b) and concave menisci are formed at the pore ends (Fig. 5.7e). Beyond complete saturation, liquid droplets shaped by the surface tension may enclose solid particles (Fig. 5.7f). Slurries, bulk particulate solids containing an excess amount of water, are shapeless. All above models exist in wet agglomeration, methods that are based on the processing of slurries, suspensions, or solutions (see Sections 7.4.3 and 7.4.6) or the presence of liquids as binders (see Section 7.4).
5.1 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
Fig. 5.4d depicts the action of solid bridges or forces at the coordination points of a particle with other particles surrounding it in the agglomerate structure. Coordination points are points of contact with other particles and near points, areas of the particle surface which are so close to a neighboring particle surface that significant adhesion forces act or bridges can form. The coordination number is the average of the sum of all contact and near points of each particle with others surrounding it in a particular agglomerate structure (see also Section 5.3.1). Typical examples of agglomerates bonded in this manner are “natural” aggregates of very fine particles which are held together by molecular forces or agglomerates with solid bridges at the coordination points which have formed during drying of originally wet agglomerates by recrystallizing materials which had been dissolved in the liquid. 5.1.1 Binding Mechanisms
The binding mechanisms of agglomeration were first defined and classified by H. Rumpf and his co-workers (see Chapter 1).According to Tab. 5.1 they are divided into five major groups, I to V, and several subgroups (see also Fig. 5.8).
Tab. 5.1
Binding mechanisms of agglomeration
1. Solid bridges
1. Sintering 2. Partial melting 3. Chemical reaction 4. Hardening binders 5. Recrystallization 6. During drying: a) Recrystallization (dissolved substances) b) Deposition (colloidal particles) 11. Adhesion and cohesion forces 1. Highly viscous binders 2. Adsorption layers ( < 3 nm thickness) rlr. Surface tension and capillary pressure
1. Liquid bridges 2. Capillary pressure
IV. Attraction forces between solids 1. Molecular forces a) Van-der-Waals forces b) Free chemical bonds (Valence forces) c) Associations (nonvalence); hydrogen bridges 2. Electric forces (electrostatic, electrical double layers, excess charges) 3. Magnetic forces V. Interlocking bonds
I
35
36
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
I. Solid Bridges 1. If the temperature in a disperse system rises above approximately two- thirds of the melting temperature or softening range of the solids, diffusion of atoms or molecules from one particle to an other one occurs at the points of contact. The solid bridges that develop with time are called sinter bridges. The velocity of diffusion depends on temperature, size of contact area, and contact pressure. It increases with rising temperature, larger contact area, and higher pressure. Heat can be introduced from an external source or created during agglomeration by friction and/or energy conversion (see also Section 9.1). 2. At the contact points of particles, roughness peaks may melt due to heat caused by friction and/or pressure. In such cases, liquid bridges develop which solidify quickly due to the large heat sink provided by the solids themselves. This mechanism, called partial melting, is often responsible for unwanted agglomeration and caking of substances with low melting point or softening temperature. 3./4. The formation of solid bridges by chemical reaction or hardening binders depends only on the participating materials, their reactivity, and their tendency to harden. Elevated temperature and/or pressure may improve the reaction and result in a modified, potentially stronger bridge structure. These binding mechanisms are often activated by moisture.
5.1 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
Temperature fluctuations can result in recrystallization and bridge formation within otherwise stable or sealed bulk particulate solids. The temperature induced physical recrystallization of some substances may extend through the interface at contact points causing solid particles to grow together. Salts or mixtures of salts that contain some free moisture may cake when exposed to varying temperatures, even if the amount of moisture is very small and the material is packed in airtight enclosures. This is because, often, more salt dissolves at higher temperature which recrystallizes if the temperature drops, forming crystal bridges between the solid particles in the bulk. During temperature fluctuations caused, for example, by day and night or seasonal differences, this is a continuing process that will, with time, result in more and stronger caking (see also Section 5.5). 6. The more common method of forming solid bridges by recrystallization of dissolved substances or deposition of suspended colloidal particles is to evaporate the liquid. The strength of crystal bridges depends not only on the amount of the dissolved and recrystallizing material but also on the speed of crystallization. At higher crystallization rates a finer bridge structure is formed which results in higher strength (see also Section 5.2.2). Colloidal particles form solid bridges if the liquid between the macroscopic particles of a disperse system consists of a colloidal suspension. During drying the colloidal particles concentrate in diminishing liquid bridges and the pressure caused by the liquid’s surface tension compacts the colloidal particles. After complete evaporation of the liquid, solid bridges remain which are made up of colloidal particles. Adhesion in the bridges is mostly caused by molecular forces which may be enhanced by electrical and magnetic effects (see Group IV below). 5.
11. Adhesion and Cohesion Forces
1. If highly viscous binders, such as bitumen, honey, pitch, tar, etc., are applied, adhesion forces at the solid-binder interface and cohesion forces within the viscous material can be fully exploited for agglomerate strength until the weaker of the two fails. Highly viscous binders are often used as matrix binders (see also Sections 5.1 and 5.2.1). 2. Most finely divided solids easily attract free atoms or molecules from the surrounding atmosphere. The thin adsorption layers thus formed are not mobile. However, they can contact and penetrate each other. It can be assumed that molecular forces can be fully transmitted if the adsorption layer is thinner than 3 nm. Such forces are often high enough to cause deformation of solid particles at the contact points (Fig. 5.9) thus increasing the contact area and, therefore, strength of the bond between adhering partners. The application of external forces and/or elevated temperatures may increase the contact area and strength further [B.14, pp 97-1291.
I
37
38
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
X
Fig. 5.9 Viscoelastic deformation at the contact point between tW0 glass spheres due t o molecular attraction.
Adsorption layers may also increase adhesion forces if the layers do not contact or touch each other (see Section 5.2.1). 111. Surface Tension and Capillary Forces One of the most common binding mechanism of wet agglomeration is liquid bridges at the coordination points between the particles forming the agglomerate. Liquid bridges can develop from free water or by capillary condensation. They are often the precondition for the formation of solid bridges (see above, 1.G). If the entire pore volume between the particles of a disperse system is filled with a liquid and concave menisci form at the pore ends on the surface of the system, a negative capillary pressure exists in the interior causing strength. Wet agglomerates are very often bonded by a combination of the above two mechanisms. In that case partial volumes exist which are completely filled with the liquid while in others liquid bridges prevail. Technically it is almost impossible to attain 100 % saturation because there is a high probability that during the agglomeration process air is trapped in some pores. IV. Attraction Forces Between Solid Particles Attraction forces between solid particles are often the cause for unwanted agglomeration: bridging, caking, coating, and build-up. The most important binding mechanisms in this category are molecular, electric, and magnetic forces (Fig. 5.10). At extremely small distances between the adhesion partners these forces can be very high but, due to their short range effect, they diminish quickly with increasing distance at the coordination points. Since particles approach each other with roughness peaks (Fig. 5.11) and the absolute roughness of smaller particles is less than that of larger ones, the adhesion probability, i.e. the chance of such particles moving closer together, increases as powders become finer. High adhesion forces are obtained if fine and ultrafine or nano-sized particles are involved.
5.I The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
Molecular Forces van-der-Waals Forces
1.a.
Valence Forces at newly created surfaces (Recombination Bonding)
1. b.
Nonvalence Association e.g., Hydrogen bridges betweenoxygenand hydroxyl radicals
a: Association - H interacts with nonbinding electron pair of oxygen b: Water molecules intensify association c: Bridging by nonvalence association of bipolar (water) molecules
Electrostatic Forces
2.
-_-_--
Fig. 5.10
Attraction forces between solid surfaces or particles
1.a) Van-der-Waals forces are naturally occurring forces at the surfaces of all solid materials. The molecules, atoms, or ions in the interior of a solid interact with each other such that they retain their relative, equilibrium positions. At the surface of, for example, a particle, the molecular forces that are directed to the outside are not satisfied and produce a force field that interacts with that of other particles.
I
39
40
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.11 Model depicting the true situation at a coordination point between two particles. Roughness exists on all real particles. a9: is the representative distance between the particles.
Then, van-der-Waals forces arise because of the electric polarization induced in each of the particles by the presence of the other ones. Forces are in the order of 0.1 eV and decrease with the sixth power of the distance between the partners. The maximum range of the van-der-Waals interaction is in the order of 100 n m which, compared to chemical bonds (valence forces), is large. 1.b) During size reduction (comminution)bonds between the atoms and molecules of a solid are stressed and ultimately part creating new surfaces. Immediately after separation, unsatisfied valences exist on these newly created surfaces. Normally, the free radicals quickly combine with atoms and molecules from the surrounding atmosphere, thereby becoming neutralized. However, conditions exist where either the newly created surface area is so large at any given moment that the number of atoms and molecules that are available in the immediate vicinity is too small to satisfy all the available valences or mobile, reactive atoms and molecules that could neutralize the free radicals are not present. In those cases, the valences themselves may recombine if newly created surfaces come close to each other. Such recombination bonding occurs during fine grinding due to the first mechanism, eventually resulting in an equilibrium between size reduction by comminution and size enlargement by agglomeration (“grindinglimit”) (see also Section 5.5). Recombination bonding also occurs during high-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.1). If brittle particles break in the compact under the influence of high forces, new surfaces are created within a densifying mass of particulate solids where the possibilities are limited to satisfy the exposed free valences with gaseous atoms or molecules. At the same time, high compaction forces cause particle surfaces, including the newly created, reactive ones, to approach each other so closely that, after some lateral movement of the fractured pieces, free valences recombine, forming strong, permanent bonds. 1.c) Nonvalence associations of certain molecular groups can also cause bonding and provide strength to a particulate bulk solid. One important phenomenon, hydrogen bridges, is, for example, the prevailing, naturally occurring binding mechanisms between organic macromolecules in coal. Hydrogen bridges form if a hydrogen atom is bonded to a strongly electronegative atom, such as oxygen in a typical OH group, and the hydrogen atom interacts with the non-binding electron pair of another electronegative atom, e.g. oxygen of a COOH group. Water
5.7 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
(H - 0 - H) intensifies this association and the bipolar molecules can also form
nonvalence association bridges which participate in the development of strength (see also Fig. 5.10, l.c, b and c). 2. At their surfaces, ionic solids possess an unsatisfied electrostatic field which is superimposed on that produced by the van-der-Waals forces. The strength of this field diminishes rapidly with distance from the surface and is soon negligible. However, this external electrical field can induce a dipole or a higher order moment in the charge distribution of the molecules in an adsorbed layer thus participating in adhesion. When two solid surfaces come in contact with each other, electrostatic forces of attraction arise as a result of the contact potential, forming electrical double layers. The physical cause for the transfer of electrons when two solid bodies come into contact is the difference between their electron work functions. Electrons migrate from the body with the smaller work function to the one with the larger one until equilibrium is reached (double layer). The action of this mechanism is permanent. Particles also can be charged by providing electrons from external sources (e.g. spray electrodes). Such excess charges can also cause attraction (or repulsion). Because of the field character of this binding mechanism, strength is independent of particle size. Also, the strength due to excess charges is very small and the charges tend to equalize (disappear) with time. Therefore, this mechanism is, in most cases, only significant for initial, temporary bonding (typical application: electrostatic precipitatorslfilters). As mentioned before, it is also possible that bonding between two oppositely charged solid surfaces is caused by the nonvalence association of bi- or multipolar molecules or radicals. Hydrogen bonding is a well known example. 3. The attraction mechanism caused by magnetic forces is similar to that of electrostatic forces. The presence of magnetic forces is limited to ferromagnetic particles although, recently, based on the understanding ofthe nature ofmagnetism, it was reported that it is now possible to engineer completely man-made plastic materials with magnetic properties. The latter may enlarge the applicability of this mechanism in the future. V. Interlocking Bonds Normally, interlocking bonds occur if the particulate solids have the shape of, for example, fibers, threads, or lamellae that twist, weave, and bend about each other or entangle during agglomeration. Sometimes interlocking bonds of elongated, fibrous additives are used to strengthen agglomerates which are otherwise too weak (see also Section 5.3.1). In high-pressure agglomeration, another interlocking mechanism may occur if a mixture of rigid and plastic materials is compacted. In this situation, the plastic component flows into recesses and, more generally, envelopes the exterior structure of harder particles, thus producing a strong structural bond that resembles the effect of a matrix binder (see also Section 8.1).
I
41
42
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Figs 5.8 and 5.10 describe pictorially the binding mechanisms that were reviewed above. It should be pointed out that only the two-dimensional situation at one coordination point between two particles or solid surfaces is shown. In reality, each particle has many interaction sites (coordination points) with other particles in the three-dimensional structure. It should be further understood that in typical particulate bulk solids and agglomerates large numbers of particles are present per unit volume (see also Section 5.3.1) and participate in bonding due to the binding mechanisms presented above. With exception of capillary and matrix bonded structures of particulate solids, it is unlikely that only one binding mechanism acts on all the coordination points within a mass. If molecular and electric forces as well as liquid bridges and the solid bridges, resulting from the latter by one or the other of the mechanisms that were discussed above, are considered, it must be assumed that the effect of each binding mechanism is different at essentially every coordination point due to varying microscopic surface structures and distances at each interaction point (see also Section 5.2.1). 5.1.2
Binders, Lubricants, and Other Additives
If size enlargement by agglomeration is desired and the correct agglomeration technique is selected, many of the binding mechanisms described in the previous Section 5.1.1 are inherently available or can be activated. Under certain conditions, some binding mechanisms also act naturally to produce undesirable agglomeration phenomena. Generally speaking, if agglomeration is wanted, means to enhance the available binding mechanisms must be developed and applied, while the effect of binding mechanisms must be eliminated or reduced to avoid unwanted agglomeration. Both aspects will be covered in much more detail in Section 5.5. As will be shown in Sections 5.2 and 5.3, particle size of the particulate solids plays an important role in agglomeration. While the surface area of particles, the interface at which all binding mechanisms act, decreases with the second power of particle size, volume and, therefore also, mass, the most important particle properties which result in forces that challenge adhesion and cause separation of bonds, diminish with the third power of the particle size. If the particle size reaches a few pm or is in the n m range, the natural adhesion forces dominate and particles which contact each other or come into close proximity adhere to one another. This phenomenon can not be economically eliminated so that very fine particles always adhere and form loose agglomerates which may be desirable or undesirable (see Section 5.5). Naturally available adhesion tendencies can be considerably increased if moisture is added during the agglomeration process. Application of external forces can contribute to the enhancement of inherently present binding mechanisms. Depending on the magnitude and nature of these forces, improved structure (by shear and low to medium compression) or plastic deformation and brittle breakage (due to high external forces) can occur. Plasticity, an often preferred response to external forces that results in high agglomerate strength (see Section 8.1),increases with many solids if the temperature of the material rises. Therefore, hot densification is often a desirable agglomeration technology, particularly for minerals and metal bearing materials.
5.1 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
Since all binding mechanisms rely on molecular interactions on and between surfaces or interfaces, the structure and distance at these points is of great importance for the ability of powders to agglomerate. Often, the presence of ultra fine particles facilitates size enlargement of coarser particulate matter. Fines that are suspended in a liquid accumulate during drying at coordination points and form solid bridges which are bonded by molecular forces. Dry fines may fill areas with high surface energy, such as holes and depressions, thus reducing the effective distance between larger particles and increasing the attraction force (similar to the influence of adsorption layers; see Section 5.2.1). With other materials, e.g. certain coals and chemicals with low softening or melting points or containing such components, mechanical energy, introduced by dynamic forces, compression, or shear and converted into thermal energy, activates the inherently available binding properties. Under this influence, momentary softening and melting can occur upon contact at minute roughness peaks which, after almost instantaneous solidification, produce a small solid bridge between the powder particles. Similar mechanisms are responsible for the bonding of soluble materials in the presence of moisture. Mechanical energy converted into heat or the direct external supply of thermal energy result first in dissolution and then in recrystallization at the coordination points. The larger the number of coordination points in a unit volume (increasing with decreasing size of the agglomerate forming particles), the higher will be the strength of the agglomerated part. In spite of the availability of all these “natural”binding mechanisms and the various possibilities to enhance them for the desirable production of agglomerates, sometimes no economic method can be found to process a specific material and form a product with sufficient strength. Grinding the particulate solid to a sufficient fineness for strong molecular bonding and/or heating it to high enough temperatures that result in either sufficient dissolution for recrystallization, plasticity for large area contact and bonding, or sintering and melt solidification, would be too expensive and, therefore, prohibit economic processing. In those cases where no bonding can be achieved, particle size is relatively large, or specific product characteristics must be obtained, binders, mostly for higher strength, lubricants, mostly for improved density and structure, and other additives, which produce special properties, can or must be used. Binders are components which are added prior or during agglomeration to increase the strength of the agglomerated product at otherwise unchanged processing conditions. They can affect strength directly or after a curing step. Binder selection depends on many considerations which are specific for the particular application. They must be compatible with the materials to be agglomerated and the proposed uses of the product. For example, for pharmaceutical and food applications only officially approved materials may be used and for the agglomeration of metal bearing dusts which are intended for recirculation into steel mills, sulfur containing binders are normally prohibited. Many such limitations can be defined for specific materials and applications.
I
43
44
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
For those reasons, binder development can not be generally treated. Rather, each individual case must be evaluated separately. However, a few common characteristics can be considered before starting a specific development program. Binders can be divided into inorganic or organic components and their distribution in the agglomerate structure may be in the form of films and bridges or a matrix. Film or bridge type additives are normally fluids which coat particles or are drawn to the coordination points where they form bridges. If applicable, only relatively small additions are required; porosity of the agglomerates as well as their freely accessible surface area (including internal surfaces, see also Section 5.3.2) are only insignificantly changed. Water is the most well known film and bridge forming binder. Matrix forming binder components, on the other hand, more or less fill the entire pore space and, therefore drastically reduce porosity and accessible surface area. Cement is a typical matrix forming additive. Water or other liquids may act as matrix binder in fully saturated wet agglomerates (capillarystate, see Section 5.1). However, this is only a temporary binding mechanism and the liquid will disappear naturally or during a posttreatment step (see Section 7.3) so that pores open up and surfaces become accessible again. Still other binders will react chemically with different components of the additive mixture or with some or all of the materials to be processed. Such reactions can result in high strength products with, for example, waterproof bonds. Tab. 5.2 lists examples of organic and inorganic binders that were previously employed in agglomeration. It shows that many different substances and materials have already been used. Commonly available and applied binders are printed in italic letters. Investigation of by-products or wastes as binders may result in the discovery of cheap and very acceptable additives. For example, molasses, a by-product of sugar making, is an excellent and nutritionally beneficial binder for animal feed and organic wastes can be incorporated in fertilizers as nutrient and binder. Binder development must take into consideration the availability of the substance at the point of ultimate use and over time. Normally, evaluations begin at a vendor facility with traditional and/or new materials that are available at that time and location. Often such developments become unacceptable when during the final cost analysis the binder turns out to be excessively expensive due to the need for its transportation to the location of the planned industrial agglomeration facility. A recent example for the “drying out” of a binder source with time is Brewex, the somewhat modified by-product of a specific beer brewing technology. The material, a liquid starch material, which was available at reasonable cost in the USA and quickly enjoyed a relatively widespread use, had to be taken off the market when the beer brewing technology changed and the by-product source disappeared. In such a situation, the operator of an already established agglomeration process has to search for a replacement binder with similar properties, acceptable price, and good availability to be able to remain in business and continue to be profitable. Therefore, unless there is a safe and unlimited binder supply for a particular application, it is prudent to continuously observe the market, evaluate new developments, and be ready for change.
5. I The Development of Strength of Agglomerates Examples of organic and inorganic binders that were previously employed in agglomeration (in alphabetical order).
Tab. 5.2
Organic binders
Inorganic binders
Albumates (Albuminates) Alcohols Alcotaca Alginates Asphalt/Asphalt EmulsionslRefined Asphalts Brewex Carnauba Wax Caseins CAFA (Chemically Activated FlyAsh) Cellulose Compounds Chicken Manure CMC (Carbo-Methyl Cellulose) Coal Tar, Pitch, and Creosote Coke Oven Tar Covol Crude Oil Dextnne Drying Oils ElVerona Fir Tar (Pine Wood Tar) Fish Waste Gelatine GilsoniteO (Natural Asphalt) Glues Gums (e.g. Arabic) Humates (Humic Acid) Lignins (Liquor and Powder) Lignite Lignite Tar Lignosulfonates Maltose Molasses OrimulsiorP Paper Pulp (from secondary paper making) Paraffin Peat Petroleum Pitch PeriduP Pittsburgh F l u Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) Resins (Natural and Synthetic) Rosin Sawdust Seaweed Slaughterhouse Refuse Starches, pregelatinized (e.g. Corn, Potato, Tapioca Wheat) Straw (Ground or Pulped) Sucrose
Alkali Silicates (e.g. Sodium, Potassium) Alum Alumina (see Colloidal ..) Attapulgite (Clay) Bentonite (Montmorillonite Clay) Caustic Soda Cements (e.g. Portland, Slag) Clays Colloidal Alumina, Silica, etc. Dolomite Fuller’s Earth Gypsum Lime Lime Hydrate (often as hardener) Magnesia/Magnesium Oxide Magnesium Chloride Metal Swarf Metal Fibers Plaster of Paris Salts Silica (see Colloidal ..) Silicates (see Alkali Silicates) Sodium Borate Sulfates (e.g. Copper) Water
I
45
46
I
5 Agglomeration Theories Organic binders (cont'd)
Sugars
Tanning Liquors (Tannic Acid) Terravest (Liquid Polybutadiene Emulsion) Thermoplastic Powders Tree Sap Vegetable Pulp Waxes and Wax Tailings
Wood Pulp
Lubricants may be either liquid or solid additives (Tab. 5.3). They reduce the coefficient of friction between the particles of a bulk mass and, therefore, result in a somewhat higher agglomerate density or lower porosity, E . According to the relationship k E = n (see Section 5.2.1) additional adhesion sites (characterized by the coordination number, k ) are activated by which increased agglomerate strength is expected. Tab. 5.3
Examples of some typical liquid and solid lubricants.
Liquids
Solids
Glycerine Oil/Water Emulsions Water Dry Starch Molybdenum Disulfide Stearates (Metallic, e.g. Magnesium Stearate) Talc Etylene Glycol Oils Silicones
Graphite Paraffin Stearic Acid Waxes
In pressure agglomeration, lubricants also reduce the coefficient of friction between the material to be compacted and the tooling. This results in a more uniform structure of the compact and in less density variation (see also Section 8.2). During ejection from a die or release from a mold lower forces are required for separation and, therefore, higher survival rates are obtained. Development and selection of lubricants must apply the same considerations as discussed for binders above. While, in some cases, binders may be valuable ingredients of the final product or disappear during post-treatment, lubricants are almost always contaminants. For this reason and to keep costs down, the most acceptable lubricants are those that are effective in very small amounts. In former times lubricants were mixed into the formulation prior to, for example, tabletting, even if the lubricant was only meant to reduce the friction between the solids and the tooling. Newer developments came-up with applicators that deposit the lubricant on the surfaces of the tooling thus decreasing amount, cost, and product contamination considerably (see also Section 8.4.3).
5. I The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
With the growing importance of size enlargement by agglomeration for the manufacturing of engineered products (see also Chapter 12), many other additives are used as “functional” components. Particularly in the food industry (Fig. 5.12), but also in other, by the public less well known applications, materials with specific, predetermined, and controlled properties are formulated from particulate ingredients and then agglomerated to yield consumer products that feature desirable characteristics. For example, convenience foods can be easily and quickly used such as “instant” soups, sauces, and drinks or products that were recombined from fine, ground food stuffs, contain already the correct amount of spices as well as other aromas, and, after preparation, feature a texture and taste that pleases the palate. Functional foods, also called designer foods on the other hand, have been treated to eliminate unhealthy ingredients, such as fat. They are then recombined with additives that replace the removed components without sacrificing the “mouthfeel” that is expected from the untreated food. Functional foods may also contain dietary additives that make a product particularly acceptable for a special group of often chronically sick people, such as, for example, diabetics. For those reasons, the market for food additives is growing overproportionately, largely due to the increasing production of more nutritious and better balanced designer foods whereby calorie reduction agents are the largest segment. Fun foods are the wide range of modern sweets and snacks where mostly sugar and fat based binders are applied to obtain agglomerates or, for example, bar shaped products from a multitude of ingredients for the consumer martket. A more complete coverage of these fast growing technologies is far beyond the scope of this book. They are mentioned to demonstrate the wide range of applications of agglomeration in areas that are not immediately recognized as common uses of the unit operation. Still other additives are more generally introduced to overcome problems caused by the need to obtain sufficient strength for packaging, handling, and storage. Special components may have to be added to the formulation which assist in the break-up of the agglomerated product when it comes into contact with water or other liquids. Such materials are commonly starches or their derivatives and other compounds that swell when absorbing liquids. Fibers may be added for a number of reasons, for example, as a dry binder, a structural component, a moisture absorbent, and a conduit for liquid. Mixtures of carbonates will produce carbon dioxide with water and result in the well known effect of effervescence. Fig. 5.13 shows schematically the influence of wicking by fibers or swelling of suitable components on the dispersion of agglomerates in liquids. Both effects may be also used together. Produced from renewable resources, organic fibers and their derivatives have a wide range of functional applications. In the pharmaceutical and food industries, the presently best known cellulosic additive is microcrystalline cellulose (MCC). It is obtained from wood cellulose by acidic hydrolysis. The product does no longer contain lignins, hemicelluloses, or other impurities and is bleached to produce a high degree of brightness. In a cellulose molecule, approx. 15,000 D-glucose units are connected in a 1.4-pglucosidic linear arrangement to form a filamentary molecule. Individual molecules of Other Additives
I
47
48
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.12 A few examples o f modern food products that were manufactured using agglomeration technologies. (a.1-a.4) Cereals and cereal bars (courtesy Kellog Co., Battle Creek, MI, USA); (b) cubed and granulated beef bouillon, both with "instant" (see Section 5.4) characteristics (courtesy Borden Foods/Wyler's, Columbus, OH/Chicago, IL, USA); (c.1-c.3) various snack bars f r o m cereals, whole grains, nuts, dried fruit, and processed food materials (courtesy Hosokawa Bepex/Hutt, Leingarten, Germany); (c.4) various dumplings (courtesy Hosokawa Bepex/Hutt, Leingarten, Germany).
5. I The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
WlCKlNG
SWELLING
Fig. 5.13 Schematic representation o f the influence o f wicking and swelling on the dispersion of agglomerates in liquids.
cellulose are bonded together by hydrogen bridges yielding pseudo crystalline structures. Although the hydrogen bonding is not destroyed by acidic hydrolysis, the cellulose chains are depolymerized and form “microcrystallites”. Fig. 5.14 depicts the structural and molecular formulas. n is 500 and 1,000, respectively. MCC is insoluble, physiologically inert, has high microbial purity, and is no substrate for microorganisms.
Structural formula:
Molecular formula: (C,H,O,), Fig. 5.14
Chemical composition o f cellulose
I
49
50
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.15 Examples of PC cellulosic fibers (Vivapur 101, courtesy J.Rettenrnaier & Sohne, Rosenberg. Germany).
Powdered cellulose (PC) is also prepared from plant material by chemical digestion and purification processes. Further mechanical processing, without the use of chemical additives, yields high purity fibers. They are chemically inert and insoluble in water, organic solvents, and dilute acids or alkaline liquors. Depending on the specific technical requirement of a customer, different qualities of PC fibers can be developed and manufactured (Fig. 5.15). Today, both MCC and PC fiber grades are widely used in tabletting. Depending on the composition of the formulation, one or the other cellulose product results in better hardness, friability, and disintegration values. However, the quantity of MCC required to yield comparable tablet properties is normally at least one-third higher than that of PC fibers. Since, because of a more economical production process, the cost of PC fibers is also lower than that of MCC, monetary advantages can be derived from using powdered cellulose. Other organic fiber products which are mostly used in foods as “dietary” ballast additives are made from wheat, oats, tomato, apples, and citrus. Such dietary fibers are “non-starch” polysaccharides obtained from cell walls only, which can not be broken down by the digestive enzymes of the human organism and, therefore, constitute inert ballast materials. Color, taste, and odor relate to the fiber source. Unlike cereal brans or dietary fibers derived from, for example, sugar beets, which are often rejected by consumers because of their specific taste, wheat, oat, tomato, apple, and citrus fibers offer physiological properties that are much more readily accepted. Although these fibers are primarily used in foods, there are also applications in other industries. Functional characteristics of the fibers include high water binding and retention capacity (as a rule: the longer the fibre, the more water it retains), no synergy effect with thickening agents in the normal dosage range (for example, up to 10 % of wheat fiber can be added to absorb and bind liquids and oils before a thickening effect can be detected), improvement of the rheological properties of various thickening agents (e.g., improvement of the thixotropic qualities of carbomethyl cellulose (CMC)),and free flow/anticaking agent (with very low dust content). Starches and compounds derived from starches have long been known as additives in many industry. These materials improve flowability and act as binders as well as disintegrants.
5.1 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
A particularly interesting newer starch derivative is sodium starch glycolate (SSG). It is the sodium salt of the carboxymethylether of potato starch or other starches (e.g. wheat, maize (corn), rice, etc.) and is a fine, almost white, odorless and tasteless, free flowing powder. Because of the low degree of substitution (see Fig. 5.16), the form and particle size of the original starch remains almost unchanged. SSG is practically insoluble in organic solvents and forms translucent suspensions or clear gels with water. Until recently, sodium starch glycolate has been used exclusively as a disintegrant in pharmaceutical solid dosage forms. Since it was found that the manufacturing process can be modified, specific SSG grades are produced for different new applications (Tab. 5.4). Finally, as further examples in the context of this chapter, the beneficial use of totally different fibers than discussed above shall be mentioned and reviewed. Metal swarf, fine, elongated grindings and turnings which are fibers in a generic sense, may be applied to “mechanically reinforce” briquettes made from metal bearing dusts for recycling into metal making processes. For this application, it is important to produce high strength of which at least a certain part is retained at high temperatures, until melting occurs, so that secondary contamination due to premature release of dust is avoided. The influence of these fibers on briquette strength is demonstrated in Fig. 5.17 which depicts that the strength of briquettes increases with growing addition of swarfwhile the necessary amount of chemical binder, constituting contamination and non temperature resistant bonding, decreases [B.42]. Fig. 5.17 also shows a broken cylindrical compact (a) that was manufactured with a laboratory piston press during process development (see also Section 11.2) and actual HO
Fig. 5.16
Structural formula of sodium starch glycolate (SSG).
I
51
52
I
5 Agglomeration Theories Tab. 5.4
New applications of sodium starch glycolate (SSG), according to J. Rettenmaier 6.Sohne (JRS). Application as
Disintegrant
Quasi soluble disintegrant
Wet granulation Taste masking binder
Thickening agent Gel former
Grade P ”)
Grade P5000
Grades P1500, P5000
Grades P1000, P3500, P5000
Guarantees excellent disintegration times of tablets, (film-)coated tablets, capsules, and granules.
Swells very much in water and forms translucent gels. These are particularly suitable to improve disintegration of tablets, effervescent tablets, soluble tablets, granules, etc.
Is used because Have very good adhesion proper- of its gel forming ties and are sui- properties to table as binding mask the taste agents with in lozenges and disintegration chewable tablets. properties in wet granulation. They can be added in powder form and granulated with water.
Grade PSOOO
Grade PO100
Are used as Forms clear gels thickening and which are stable stabilizing agents within a wide in juices, suspen- range of sions, emulsions, temperatures. ointments, creams, etc.
Typical dosage
1-5 %
2-20 %
u p to 5 %
5-20 %
2-5 % in special 5-20 % cases also higher
in the grade designation refers to potato starch as origin. All grades can also be made from other starches (“M” = maize (corn), “ R ” = rice, “W” =wheat, etc.). For formulations that are incompatible with alcohol the grade designation “SF” guarantees an alcohol content below 1 %.
7’:)”P”
briquettes (b) obtained in the industrial plant. Concerns that the swarf “fibers” would prohibit separation of briquettes that are produced with a roller press did not turn out to be a problem. Similar to concrete, refractory linings and components are agglomerates in which highly temperature resistant aggregates and mortars represent a system which is shaped and fired to yield bricks or other components that are then set into mortar for mounting, or is applied by casting or gunning. Today’s high temperature processing industries demand high performance and predictable service life from the refractory. The latest generation of low cement, ultra-low cement, and self-flow castables, which are resistant to high temperatures, continue to be weak in tension and offer minimal resistance to damage from sudden changes in stress. Thermal cycling or shock as well as mechanical impact or vibration can all cause cracking, which, in turn, may lead to premature failure and substantial costs. Because the development of cracks can not be avoided in the rough environments of the typical applications of refractories, the probability must be reduced that such cracks result in failure. This is possible by reinforcement with fibers. Some materials that have been added to accomplish this are stiff, needle-like chopped wire or slit sheet fibers which are sometimes even supplied with, for example, hooks on their ends to increase anchorage. As schematically shown in Fig. 5.18 steel fibers in the refractory structure arrest the cracks and prohibit their propagation. Newer reinforcement
5.7 The Development of Strength of Agglomerates
L
3parts sutfite-waste powder a s a binder -
140
/30%
content of
Hardening duration ( d a y s )
Fig. 5.17 Cold crushing strength o f briquettes from metal bearing dust, containing different amounts of dry lignosulfonate binder (called "sulfite waste"), with and without swarf reinforcement, as a function o f (natural) curing time. Photographs o f "reinforced" metal bearing dust briquettes (scales not identical). (a) Cylindrical test briquette and fracture surface, (b) commercial pillow-shaped briquettes.
-I
I
53
54
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
materials use direct spun stainless fibers that are rapidly cooled. The resulting products are fully annealed and, therefore, more pliable and ductile, feature better flow characteristics and an improved aspect ratio that results in optimum dispersion due to easy disentanglement of the fibers during mixing with the wet refractory system, and offer exceptional resistance to high temperature corrosion since a beneficial metallurgical structure is “frozen” during the ultra-rapid cooling process. The photograph in Fig. 5.18 shows a representative selection of some of these stainless steel fibers for the refractory industry.
Fig. 5.18 Schematic depiction o f the crack stopping mechanism o f steel fibers in a refractory. Photographs of some typical stainless steel fibers for the reinforcement o f refractories (courtesy RIBTEC, Cahanna, OH, USA).
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
5.2
Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
The most important property of all agglomerates, desired or undesired, is their strength. For the practical and industrial investigation of agglomerate strength, stresses that occur in reality during storage and handling are experimentally simulated (see Section 5.2.2). In addition to the frequently used crushing, drop, and abrasion tests, methods for the determination of impact, bending, cutting or shear strength are employed. All values obtained by these methods are strictly empirical and cannot be predicted by theory because it is not known which component of the applied stresses causes the agglomerate to fail. For the same reason, the experimental results from different methods can not be compared with each other. Therefore, Rumpf (see Chapter 1) proposed to determine the tensile strength of agglomerates. It is defined by the tensile force at failure divided by the cross section or, if the test body has no uniform shape, the area of the failure plane(s) of the agglomerate(s) (see Section 5.2.2). Because failure occurs in all stressing situations with great probability under the influence of the highest tensile force, this proposal is justified. Moreover, tensile force and strength can be approximated by models and theoretical calculations. 5.2.1
Theoretical Considerations
All binding mechanisms of agglomeration (see Section 5.1.1) can be described by one of three models (see Section 5.1, Fig. 5.4): 1. The entire pore volume of the agglomerate is filled with a substance that can transmit forces and, thereby, causes strength (matrix binder, Fig. 5.421). 2. The pore volume of the agglomerate is entirely filled with a liquid (Fig. 5.41). 3 . Binding forces are transmitted at the coordination points of the primary particles forming the agglomerate (Fig. 5.4d).
Liquid bridges at the coordination points (Figs 5 . 4 ~ and 5 . 7 ~are ) described by model (3) while the transitional state (Fig. 5.7d) is connected with model (2) through the liquid saturation, S (see Section 5.1). ad 1) Maximum tensile strength ifthe pore volume isjlled with a strength-transmitting substance If the pore volume of the agglomerate is completely filled with a stress transmitting substance, e.g. a hardened binder, three strength components can define agglomerate strength: (a) q, (pore volume strength) = tensile strength of the binder substance, (b) ota(grain boundary strength) = tensile strength caused by the adhesion between binder and particulate solids forming the agglomerate,
I
55
56
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
4
n
Fig. 5.19 Two-dimensional schematic representation of the failure lines derived from the three models describing strength o f agglomerates with a matrix binder.
(c) ot(l-E) = strength of the particulate solids forming the agglomerate. The relatively lowest component determines the agglomerate strength. Fig. 5.19 depicts schematically the expected failure lines in a two dimensional schematic representation.
ad 2) Maximum tensile strength ifthe pore volume is filled with a liquid If a liquid that wets the solid(s)fills the entire pore volume of an agglomerate to such a degree that concave menisci are formed at the pore ends on the surface, a negative capillary pressure p, develops in the interior of the agglomerate. Because the membrane forces at the surface are negligibly small in relation to the capillary pressure, the tensile strength qcof agglomerates that are completely filled with a liquid can be approximated by the capillary pressure: otc
- Pc
(Eq. 5.1)
Assuming that the pore diameter is characterized by the mean half hydraulic radius of the pore system, further assuming perfect wetting and spherical monosized particles, the following formula is obtained:
-
otc
pc = a’ ( 1 - E ) / E ax
(Eq. 5.2)
The maximum tensile strength of agglomerates that are completely filled with a perfectly wetting liquid depends on the porosity of the agglomerate, characterized by the strong term (1 - E ) / E , the surface tension a of the liquid, and the size x of the particles forming the agglomerate. The empirical correction factor a’ has values between G and 8. An approximation of the agglomerate strength ott in the transitional (“funicular”) state, in which a certain percentage S (= saturation, see Section 5.1) of the pore volume is filled with liquid, is possible by multiplying the maximum strength otcwith the appropriate saturation S:
(Eq. 5.3)
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
ad 3 ) M a x i m u m tensile strength $forces are transmitted at the coordination points of the particles forming the agglomerate Estimation of the strength of agglomerates which is caused by solid bridges at the coordination points assumes that the entire solid binder material is uniformly distributed at all coordination points and forms bridges with constant strength oB.If, in addition, failure only occurs through solid bridges, the relative cross section of that material defines the agglomerate strength: (Eq. 5.4) MBis the mass of the bridge building material and M p the mass of the agglomerate building particulate solids, pBand pp are the densities of the respective solid materials, 1 - E is the relative volume of the particulate solids building the agglomerate, E is the specific void volume (porosity) ofthe agglomerate, and vBis the fraction ofvoids in the agglomerate that is filled with the bridge building material. Strength may be also caused by adhesion forces A acting at the coordination points of the particles forming the agglomerate. Based on statistical considerations and a simple model, Rumpf [5.l] developed a general formula that is often used to describe agglomerate strength: ot = (1 -
E)/X
k A/x2
(Eq. 5.5)
E is the specific void volume (porosity) of the agglomerate and (1- E ) the respective volume of the particulate solids, x = 3.14...., k the average coordination number, and x the representative size of the particulate solids forming the agglomerate. For k an empirical approximation exists:
kE
N
x
(Eq. 5.6)
with which Equation 5.5 is simplified to: ot = (1 -
E)/E
A/x2
(Eq. 5.7)
Theoretical Approximation o f Adhesion Forces The still unknown term in Equation
5.7 is the adhesion force A. Firstly, it must be recognized that, normally, more than one binding mechanism participates in the production of agglomerate strength. Secondly, due to differences in micro conditions, it must be expected that the adhesion force Ai at each coordination point is different. Therefore, Equation 5.7 becomes in its most general form: ot = (1 -
E)/E
CA,/x2
(Eq. 5.8)
Work of many researchers concentrates on modelling and calculating adhesion forces that are caused by the different binding mechanisms IB.421. So far, all models are based on simplified conditions at the coordination points. For example, modelling of the adhesion force of a liquid bridge is based on two monosized spherical particles with a distance a from each other (Fig. 5.20). Adding the two adhesion force components, one caused by the negative capillary pressure in the bridge and the other by the boundary force at the solid/liquid/gas
I
57
58
I
5 Agglomeration Theories I
I
Fig. 5.20 particles
Liquid bridge between two monosized spherical
contact line, a general formula for the adhesion force of a liquid bridge AiLcan be derived: AIL= a x f(pAa/x)
(Eq. 5.9)
The adhesion force of a liquid bridge between two monosized spherical particles depends on the surface tension of the liquid a, the particle diameter x, and a function of the angle p which defines the size of the bridge, the angle of contact or “wetting angle” 6, and a dimensionless term a/x which represents the distance at the coordination point. Obviously, a large number of different partner shapes, other than sphere to sphere, are possible and, normally, the size of the partners will be different and can vary infinitely. As already mentioned in Section 5.1.1 and shown schematically in Fig. 5.11 all particles also feature rough surfaces. Proving roughness, even on the macroscopically smoothest surfaces, depends only on the magnification. Therefore, when modelling surface interactions, this can be done macroscopically, disregarding surface roughness (for example the liquid bridge model above), or microscopically. In the case of liquid bridges the latter means that the distance a is an average as depicted in Fig. 5.11 and the angle of contact depends on the microscopic topography and, therefore, results in very complicated bridge geometries which can not be modelled. Generally, the description of the true shape of a particle, including surface roughness can not yet be described unequivocally. New techniques, such as fractal dimensions [B.37], may be applied in the future to solve this problem. As another example of modelling efforts, the estimation of the van-der-Waals adhesion force will be discussed. Three different situations at the coordination point, two flat surfaces, a spherical particle opposing a flat surface, and two spherical particles, are presented. Because van-der-Waals forces are field forces, models take into consideration the atomic and molecular interactions between the two entities. A microscopic
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
theorie (Hamaker [5.2])assumes that all interactions may be added up and obtains the van-der-Waals adhesion force AiYdWby integrating over all pairs of atoms and molecules. The characteristic term His the “Hamakerconstant” with a value ofapprox. lo-” to lo-’’ J. The macroscopic theorie (Lifshitz [5.3], Krupp [5.4]) calculates the interaction force from the energy dissipation of the electromagnetic fields that emanate from the bodies and obtains a similar van-der-Waals adhesion force. In this case ho is the Lifshitz-van-der-Waals constant with a value of approx. 1.G.10-20 to l.G.lO-l’ J. Fig. 5.21 summarizes the model conditions and the results. 0 is the respective unit area on the opposing flat surfaces. The equations in Fig. 5.21 are only valid for distances a that are less than 150 nm. However, because already at much smaller distances at the coordination points the contribution of van-der-Waals adhesion to the strength of agglomerates becomes insignificant, this limitation is of no concern. It should be also noted that for very small distances, the “Born repulsion” is predominant as shown in Fig. 5.22. In addition to the already discussed influence of the actual micro topography at the coordination point, other conditions may influence the true adhesion forces that act between the solid partners. In the case of van-der-Waals forces the average distance a as shown in Section 5.1.1, Fig. 5.11, may be changed by the presence of adsorption layers (Fig. 5.23). From an adhesion physics point of view, adsorption layers with a thickness of less than 3 n m are so strongly bonded that they are immobile and can be considered as part of the solid. Because adsorption occurs primarily at energetically favorable locations, such as in depressions or valleys, it tends to smooth-out the surface roughness resulting in a reduction of the actual distance between the particles at the coordination point
Hamaker microscopic
Lifshitz macroscopic
AlVdw/O = H/6rra’
A,,,/O
Fig. 5.21 Three model conditions forthe estimation ofthe van-derWaals adhesion force and the results o f two theories.
=
hw/8n2a3
(Eq. 5.10)
I
59
60
I
5 Agglomeration Theories ARepulsion
A
van- der-Waals Adhesion
AAdhesion
*
Fig. 5.22
Relationship o f Born repulsion and van-der-Waals adhesion as a function o f the distance a at the coordination point
(Fig. 5.23) and an increased adhesion force. At ambient conditions the adsorption of atoms and/or molecules from the atmosphere is a natural phenomenon. Therefore, it can also happen during storage in bulk solids and even within agglomerates. While in the latter case agglomerate strength is enhanced which, in most cases, is not detrimental, the development of adsorption layers in bulk solids can lead to difficulties during discharge, feeding, and metering.
Fig. 5.23 Model explaining the increase in strength due to adsorption layers during van-der-Waals bonding [5.1].
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
5.2.2 Laboratory and Industrial Evaluations
Major parameters determining the properties of agglomerates are: 0 0 0
0
The primary particle size, x, distribution, Ax),surface area, s(x),and shape. The agglomerate size, d, distribution, j d ) , and shape. The apparent and bulk densities as well as the porosity E (= voids between the primary particles), also the pore sizes and their distribution in the agglomerate. The strength of the agglomerate.
Primary particle size, distribution, surface area as well as micro (= surface structure) and macro shape, define the agglomerative behavior of a given type of particulate solids. The agglomerate (used as a generic term) size, distribution, and shape together with the characteristics discussed in Section 5.3 determine most of the advantages of agglomerated materials. The apparent density describes the mass of the agglomerates themselves, and the bulk density delineates the space filling behavior (e.g. the packing volume) of an agglomerated product. The porosity of agglomerates (see Section 5.3.2) is another method of describing their apparent density; it is the void volume between the primary particles forming the agglomerate and defines the accessibility of the internal surface area while the pore sizes and their distribution regulate the capillary suction which is responsible for “takingup” liquids (as in absorbents). The strength of agglomerates is one of their most important properties and may have many different meanings. In most cases the attribute “strength” defines a survival characteristic and may be defined as crushing, bending, cutting, shear, or tensile strength, as tolerance to one or several drops from a specific height, thereby reproducing stresses experienced at transfer points, or as resistance to attrition and the formation of dust [B.42].For special applications still other measures of “strength” may be elaborated that simulate the real handling or processing conditions. Scientifically the only unequivocally defined and reproducible strength, that is ultimately and with a high degree of probability responsible for all failure modes and can be also approximated by theoretical calculations, is the tensile strength. A general formula describing the tensile strength ot of agglomerates, which are held together by binding mechanisms acting at the coordination points, was given in Section 5.2.1, Equation 5.8. The equation shows, that the porosity of agglomerates plays the most important role for their strength. The lower the porosity or, in other words, the higher the apparent density of the agglomerate, the stronger is the agglomerate. Since many of the desirable characteristics of agglomerated products require high porosity, sufficient strength is obtained in such cases by selecting a suitable binding mechanism featuring high adhesion or binding forces, using a powder with a small representative particle size, applying suitable curing techniques that produce permanent bonds with high strength (e.g. by sintering), and/or incorporating temporary additives in the feed. During or after the curing step such components are removed by melting, evaporation, or combustion (see Section 5.3.2).
I
62
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Results of experimental determinations of agglomerate strength have been published in many scientific works and were summarized in numerous specific books on agglomeration or in major chapters of more general handbooks (see Section 13.1). In the following, a few examples will be presented to describe generally important trends. For a more detailed coverage, the literature, particularly also the proceedings of the International Symposia on Agglomeration [B.4, B.14, B.18, B.23, B.35, B.48, B.701 should be consulted. Because strength depends critically on porosity, this property should be always measured first. To allow a comparison of individual strength values which were determined on different agglomerates they must be adjusted to fit a representative porosity. Then a larger number of results should be averaged and presented together with the statistical standard deviation or the minimum and maximum deviation of single values. If the density (specific mass ps) of of the solid particles forming the agglomerate (composite density if more than one material participates) is known and the volume of the agglomerate can be accurately determined, the porosity can be calculated as: Some Results of Laboratory Determinations of Agglomerate Strength
Agglomerates often contain moisture. If this is the case, they must be dried prior to the determination of the solid mass, M,. Also, with the exception of flat, cylindrical tablettes (see Section 8.4.3) and similarly well defined shapes, agglomerate volume can not be easily calculated. In those cases, the buoyancy of the agglomerate in a liquid is often measured. Since, according to the principle of Archimedes, the buoyancy is equal to the mass of the displaced liquid (under the assumption that the liquid does not penetrate into the agglomerate) the volume can be calculated as: (Eq. 5.14)
M,is the mass of the liquid which is displaced by the agglomerate during the buoyancy test and pL is the liquid's specific mass. The requirement that the liquid must not penetrate into the liquid can be met by using of a non wetting liquid (mercury was applied widely, also because of its high specific mass, by coating the surface of the agglomerate with a liquid repellant (e.g. oil)), or by painting a thin film of lacquer onto the agglomerate. The error caused by any of the protective measures is insignificant. If the binding mechanism between the agglomerate forming particles is not destroyed by the liquid, it is also possible to totally saturate the porous body and then reimmerse it to determine the buoyancy. By inserting Equation 5.14 into 5.13 another formula for determining porosity is obtained: & =
1 - (PdPS)
(Ms/ML)
(Eq. 5.15)
Porosity can be also measured by pressure permeation methods [B.GO] ifthe agglomerate can not be treated and submerged in a liquid without losing its integrity. Fig. 5.24 depicts some laboratory methods for the determination of the strength of agglomerates and cohesive powders. Often, even in a scientific environment, the transversal crushing force is measured (Fig. 5.24a). This method is quite acceptable for
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
Agglomerate
Adhesive
I
R
Fig. 5.24 Laboratory methods for the determination o f t h e strength of agglomerates or cohesive powders [B.42].
1
I
63
64
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
perfect cylinders, such as tablettes and some extrudates. However, any spheroidal agglomerate is so irregular that a perfect diametral loading is impossible. This results in undefined stressing with compression, shear, and tensile forces acting in unknown ratios so that a wide scatter of data is obtained from undefined sources. Also, the definition of a compression “strength”by dividing the force at failure by the projection area of the agglomerate is, from a scientific point of view, not acceptable. Normally, the statistical mean force at failure of testing a large number of agglomerates is reported. Crushing a sheet or cylindrical agglomerate by loading parallel opposite flat surfaces between plates is even more problematic because in very few cases the faces of the agglomerate are truly parallel resulting in uneven loading or the lateral expansion is blocked by friction between the agglomerate and the plates so that uncontrolled stress concentrations build up which may be the true cause for failure. As a consequence, data obtained from transversal crushing tests are seldom comparable. More reproducible results are obtained if the shear strength of a well defined, often specially prepared agglomerate is measured (Fig. 5.24b). This method was adapted from the well known shear cell for the evaluation of cohesive particulate solids (Jenike shear cell and derivatives [5.5]). During fundamental work on the binding mechanisms and strength of model agglomerates or cohesive powders, most of the laboratory evaluations determine tensile strength (Fig.s 5 . 2 4 ~- 8). Machinable agglomerates are converted into cylinders that are glued between two adapters (Fig. 5.24~)and torn apart in a standard tensile test machine (e.g. Frank, Instron, see also Section 11.2). Other methods use “split” dies, with or without mandrils, for the manufacturing of a compacted agglomerate which is then pulled apart at a cross section which is defined by the split mold. Low strength caused by various binding mechanisms with or without prior densification is measured in flat split containers of which one part is fixed and the other part is movable with insignificant frictional resistance. The load can be applied by slowly lifting up the support table (Fig. 5.24e) or providing an incrementally increasing horizontal force (Fig. 5.24f). Often, it is desirable or necessary to measure the strength of agglomerates which are partially or completely filled with a liquid. Particularly, in the high range of saturation the correlation of strength with the capillary pressure and their change during wetting or drying of the bed (hysteresis effect) is of interest. For this purpose, the simple method shown in Fig. 5.24fwas modified as shown in Fig. 5.248 [B.42]. The most reliable results of tests determining agglomerate or cohesive powder strength that can be also interpreted best are those in which the binding mechanism is caused by the surface tension of liquids and/or the resulting capillary forces (see Section 5.1.1, I11 in Tab. 5.1). With a high degree of probability the influence of other binding mechanisms can be excluded in agglomerates or powders that are bonded by a liquid. As shown in Equations 5.2, 5 . 3 , and 5.7 together with 5.9 (see Section 5.2.1), this binding mechanism in defined by the surface tension a as well as other characteristics of the liquid and the solid, such as the wetting angle 6, the porosity E, and the representative size of the particles forming the agglomerate. Fig. 5.25 depicts the tensile strength, determined in the laboratory according to the method shown in Fig. 5.24c, of nearly saturated agglomerates made from narrowly distributed quartz and limestone powders as a function of the size x of the particles
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
; ! , !
Quartz
Limestone
0.4 -
-
N
E
. E z
0.2 -
c
0.1 0.080.06-
;;
0.OL -
e-
5 Ol
2
a, .-
,"
0.02-
a,
c Fig. 5.25 Tensile strength oI o f nearly saturated agglomerates as a function o f the size x o f the particles forming the agglomerate. Porosity adjusted to E = 0.35. oIcaccording to Eq. 5.2.
0.008 0.0°6
LL
0.OOL 1 1
I
2
I
I
l
l
I
I
L 6 8 10 20 40 P a r t i c l e s i z e x lpm)
1
60
L
forming the agglomerate. The porosities of the individual agglomerates were adjusted arithmetically to E = 35 %. The diagonal lines represent the theoretical tensile strengths according to Equation 5.2 with a' = G and a' = 8, respectively. The diagram shows that the relationship 'T, l / x is fulfilled. The actual values are lower than theoretically predicted because the agglomerates which were produced in a pan (see Section 7.4.1) are not fully saturated with water and the structure of technically manufactured agglomerates is not perfect. Although not unequivocally visible in Fig. 5.25, regression analyses of these and many more sets of data revealed that the representative particle size for agglomeration processes is the surface equivalent diameter, x,. The importance of this representative diameter for the unit operation is not surprising as structure and bonding of the products critically depend on the surfaces of the particles forming an agglomerate as well as on the surfaces' microscopic and macroscopic conditions. Of course, only the exterior particle surface is responsible for the effects; potentially internal surface area of the agglomerate forming particles must not be included when calculating the surface equivalent diameter of a particulate mass. Therefore, experimentally, surface area should be determined by permeametry, for example the well known and in the cement industry universally applied Blaine method [ B.GO]. The data in Fig. 5.26 confirm that the relationship between tensile strength q,agglomerate forming particle size x, and surface tension of the binder liquid a and the porosity function (1- & ) / I as per Equation 5.2 is correct and Fig. 5.27 proves that the (compression) strength of agglomerates increases linearly with the surface tension of the binder liquid as indicated by Eq. 5.2. Finally, Fig. 5.28 presents the tensile strength 'T,of moist and wet agglomerates as a function of liquid saturation S. At the two extremes S = 0 % and S = 100 % the strength N
I
65
5 Agglomeration Theories -c c
0
i
C
E
c
m
U a ’-
\
c“*
2tY a .-
c
-0a
21.o . !
I I :
I
I
I
0.L
0.6
0.8
I
I
I
1.0 1.2 Porosity f u n c t i o n (1 - E ) / E
l.L
Fig. 5.26 Relative tensile strength crt x/a o f agglomerates made from sperical glass powder related to the porosity function (1 --E)/E and compared with the theory (Eq. 5.2) [B.42].
1.0,
I
I
I
I
I
Surface tension a x
I
lo5
I
1
(Nlcrn)
Fig. 5.27 Compression strength (r of spherical wet agglomerates as a function o f the surface tension a o f the liquid [B.42]. Surface tensions are that o f pure alcohol and water and o f 30/70 and 10/90 vol.% mixtures o f alcohol and water.
is close to zero. “Bone dry” powders feature very low tensile strength unless they are compacted or the representative size of the agglomerate forming particles is < 1 Fm. If it is assumed that at S = 100 % concave menisci are no longer formed at the pore ends on the agglomerate’s surface, capillary pressure is zero which, according to Equation 5.1 also lets strength go to zero. Between those extremes the conditions of Fig. 5.7 (c, d, and e) (Section 5.1) exist. On the left, Fig. 5.28 shows three curves for different dimensionless values a / x that were calculated using Equations 5.7 and 5.9. It can be assumed that up to a saturation of S = 30-40 % discrete liquid bridges prevail at the coordination points between the particles forming the agglomerate. In the right part of Fig. 5.28 the experimentally determined capillary pressure is plotted (solid dots). This curve is obtained when
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength 167
N
N
.. E E E E
zz --
1
0
Fig. 5.28
Tensile strength
‘T,and
20
I
I
LO 60 L i q u i d saturation qL
I
80
100
(YO)
capillary pressure pc as functions
of liquid saturation 5 [B.42].
the liquid from a totally saturated agglomerate is drained, for example, in an arrangement as shown in Fig. 5.248. As mentioned before, at S = 100 % the capillary pressure is zero. If, starting at this point, the agglomerate is drained, the capillary pressure rises steeply (development of concave menisci at the pore ends on the surface of the agglomerate) and then turns to a much slower rate of increase. The point at which the tangents to both curves intersect is defined as the entry suction pressure pe at which liquid begins to recede into the agglomerate. It is generally located at S>90 %. At approximately that point the maximum tensile strength of wet agglomerates exists. The circular and square open symbols represent average values of experimental results of measurements of tensile strength with their standard deviation. In the bridge model (“pendular”)state the results seem to fit the curve for a / x = 0.02 best and for high saturations (“capillary”state) they approach pe. In the transition (“funicular”) range between 30 % < S < 95 % both binding mechanisms, liquid bridges and saturated pores, contribute to the development of strength. The fact that in the transition range a difference exists between the strength ofagglomerates to which liquid was added (e.g. during agglomerate growth, circular open symbols) and agglomerates from which liquid was drained (square open symbols) confirms that liquid can only be drained from saturated pores and liquid bridges are not influenced. The mechanism of capillary flow in wet agglomerates is an important factor if the liquid is a solution or becomes one (because all or some of the agglomerate forming particles are soluble) and the dissolved material recrystallizes during drying [1.1,B.421. If the agglomerate is highly saturated, drying takes place only on the surface. Liquid moves by capillary flow to the surface where evaporation occurs and recrystallizing substances deposit. The formation of a crust may influence further drying of the porous body considerably. The developing crust reduces the drying rate and may, after
68
I
5 Agglomeration Theorks
forming a dense crust, stop drying altogether. Since the crystal structure is influenced by the drying rate, the strength of recrystallizing substances in agglomerates during drying will be controlled by either the drying temperature, the crust, or both. Fig. 5.29 presents the tensile strength ot of the core of dry agglomerates with recrystallized salt bridges which was obtained after removing a surface layer (including a crust, if applicable). The diagram shows that for agglomerates with very low initial moisture contents (curves 1 and 2) the strength increases as expected, almost linearly with an increasing amount of available salt (rising saturation) and with the drying temperature. At higher drying rate, finer and stronger crystallites grow at the coordination points in the agglomerate and, because the liquid (solution) was concentrated in discrete, immobile bridges, no crust had developed. At an initial saturation of 20 % (curve 3) the formation of a crust begins to influence strength at high drying temperatures while for the highest liquid saturations (S = 45 % and GO %) the dense crust, formed at all temperatures, is the deciding factor for drying and development of strength (curves 5 and 6). Above 175 -200 "C the temperature within the porous body rises so quickly that the vapor pressure building up below the dense crust causes the agglomerate to burst (Fig. 5.30). The unexpectedly high tensile strength obtained at a liquid saturation of 30 % and a drying temperature of 350 "C is due to the formation of a network of small cracks in the crust that did not cause the agglomerate to fracture but increased the drying rate and, thus, the tensile strength ofthe dry agglomerate core. I
I
I
0.L
-
N
. - 0.3 E E Z
L
b
5 ol C
E
+. 0.2 cn
AVO
.(u
1
VI
2
C (u
t-
0.1
7,6/ OOL
P e l l e t s burst I 0 300
Drying temperature t d
(OC)
Fig. 5.29 Tensile strength q o f the core o f agglomerates with salt bridges as a function ofthe drying temperature td for different liquid saturations S prior to drying [l.l, 6.421.
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength 169
Fig. 5.30 Photographs of cylindrical agglomerates which contained a high amount o f a nearly saturated salt solution and burst during drying.
The above mentioned incrustation may be positive or negative. On the positive side, the phenomenon can be used as a method to achieve encapsulation of agglomerates if a film forming, easily soluble polymer is dissolved in the liquid phase. On the other hand, if a dryer is controlled by sensing the moisture content in the off-gas, the process instrumentation may mistakenly identify a heavily encrusted product as being dry when, underneath of the crust, moisture still remains. Such a product can, of course, cause a whole host of problems, such as caking during storage when the liquid slowly redistributes and problems during a secondary process, for example tabletting of a still partially moist granulated pharmaceutical formulation, as well as many more difficulties. During the initial phase of drying, when all evaporation occurs on the surface o f the porous bodies, the temperature o f the material to be dried stays at or below 100 “C. For highly temperature sensitive materials this temperature can be lowered by the application of vacuum. However, if incrustation occurs, the temperature of the mass to be dried increases to the temperature of the drying gas and can cause damage to the material. A considerable amount of fundamental research is going on in many places of the world trying to increase knowledge of all binding mechanisms and develop numerical methods to calculate or at least estimate binding forces as well as agglomerate strength. In addition to the “classic” standard methods discussed above many novel technologies, such as, for example, application of the atomic force microscope (AFM) (also called lateral force microscope (LFM)or scanning probe microscope (SPM)) for the measurement o f adhesion in the micron and submicron particle range, and new theories, for instance, Fractals [B.37] and the Chaos Theory, are applied to agglomeration research. However, as mentioned earlier (see Section 5.1.1), it is unlikely that only
70
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
one binding mechanism acts on all coordination points within even a single agglomerate. Moreover, the microscopic conditions at each coordination point are so diverse that bonding at virtually each individual coordination point is different. Therefore, although big advances are being made, the science of agglomeration is still far away from formulating a useful general theory. Furthermore, this book is devoted to a more practical coverage of agglomeration. Therefore, the reader is encouraged to search for and study the increasing number of publications that report on the advances in this area (see Sections 13.1 and 13.2). Industrial Evalutations of Agglomerate Strength Determination of agglomerate strength in industry is much more pragmatic [B.42]. Although knowledge and understanding of the fundamentals of agglomeration, particularly the nature and effect of the binding mechanisms and how they can be influenced, become more and more important during the development of new and for the optimization of existing agglomeration processes, agglomeration as a unit operation is still more an art than a science. While an increasing number of criteria are known for the preselection of the most suitable agglomeration process for a specific application (see Chapter 11),it is still necessary to test the selected equipment in the laboratories of vendors or development organizations (see Section 11.2). Often, if the process is a new one, it is even desirable to operate a smaller pilot plant or to involve a “toller”, an outside processor for hire, prior to an investment decision for a large scale plant (see Section 11.2). Agglomerate strength in industry is defined as a commercial or process characteristic of the particular intermediate or final product. For example, if the agglomerated material is a final product, strength may be defined as resistance to breakage, chipping, or abrasion. The definition of this property and of other strength related requirements will differ whether it is an industrial bulk material or a consumer product. While the former may break down to a certain extent, as long as it remains free flowing and dust free, a consumer product must have perfect and pleasing appearance where even minimal chipping or breakage into large chunks must be avoided. Intermediate products must have characteristics that are suitable for the intended further processing. For example, a material may have to be strong enough and abrasion resistant for storage and handling to avoid bridging, flow problems, dusting and segregation of components. If it is a feed material for tabletting or other pressure agglomeration methods, the agglomerates must break down totally under pressure and produce a uniform final product structure. Other agglomerated intermediates may have to feature the opposite property, i.e. to yield a filter with bimodal pore size distribution it must retain its shape and structure during pressing (see also Section 5.3.2). For those reasons, “strength” means many different things in industry. Typically, measurement of strength is based on a simulation of the stresses which a particular agglomerated product must withstand. Very few industrial methods for the determination of this property are standardized or even known. In a competitive environment it is of less interest to compare quality between rivals than to make sure internally that the product properties that are expected by the industrial or public consumer are maintained. Therefore, most measurements of strength are undertaken as quality assurance. A few will be described below as examples.
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
A general problem associated with the determination of product properties in industry is sampling [B.24, B.271. Particularly the measurement of strength is in most cases based on totally or partially destructive methods. If taken during production, these “lost” samples are extracted from the product stream in a random but representative manner and either tested directly “in-line” or, sometimes after again sampling the sample, in a quality assurance laboratory which is associated with production. Afterwards they are discarded. During initial and occasionally repeated process optimization, the influence of different process parameters on agglomerate strength is determined. Results of the measurement of strength are often used to adjust process parameters as required. If there is a difference between “green”and “cured” or final strength, both strength values may have to be evaluated to allow adjustment of the respective process steps. Even bigger problems exist iflarge bulk masses (e.g. stock piles, silos, ship loads, rail cars, trucks, etc.) must be sampled. This is done to guarantee product quality prior to or after shipment and at the point of consumption. Results of those tests are only of commercial value because, typically, they can no longer be corrected but may influence acceptability or price of the commodity. Often, if quality is below standard but does not meet the guarantee, the price will have to be adjusted by offering discounts or rebates. Among the few standardized methods for determining agglomerate strength are the compression strength (IS0 TC 102/Sc 3 DP 4700 and ASTM E 382-97) and tumble ( I S 0 3271 1975 E and ASTM E 279-97)tests for iron ore pellets as well as the “tumbler test” for coke (ASTM D 294-72). In this case, a group of consumers (steel companies) forced a growing number of independent suppliers to test and guarantee agglomerated bulk commodities by formulating the standards. For iron ore the tests are on finished pellets, either prior to shipment or at the consumer’s facility and, therefore, are not intended or even suitable for process control. It will be shown later that iron ore pellets are first produced as “green” agglomerates and then indurated by sintering. For the determination of compression strength, a bulk sample is first screened and at least 600 pellets are taken from the size range in which the maximum is found. In a “Riffle” splitter [B.24, B.271 four samples, containing at least 100 pellets each are prepared. From two of the samples, individual pellets are placed between the parallel, surface-hardened platens of a compression testing machine, loaded with a constant speed, and crushed. The maximum force at which each pellet breaks is determined and recorded. After testing 100 pellets of each of the two samples, the arithmetic averages for the batches are calculated. If they deviate by more than a predetermined amount, another 100 pellets are tested to confirm one or the other value. In the tumble test the abrasion resistance of the pellets is measured. The “ASTM drum” is a cylindrical container with specific dimensions which is rotated around its horizontal axis at a predetermined speed and for a defined number of revolutions. A given mass containing a representative sample of clean pellets is filled into the drum, tumbled for so many revolutions at the constant speed, removed and screened at 600 m. The “strength”of the pellets is defined by the amount of “fines” smaller than 600 m that was abraded during the test. For coke, the “tumbler test” is carried out correspondingly in a similar drum (Fig. 5.31).
I
71
72
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
SIOC CLLVATIOY.
Fig. 5.31
mur IN sccncw ON ma
W CCCVAIIW
.
W F I N Y R I O t I ON a A
Sketch o f the ASTM “tumbler test apparatus” for coke
Both compression and tumble tests have been widely used and modified for other applications. The crushing test can be utilized for any agglomerate that is large enough for individual testing and, sometimes, a single layer of many narrowly sized granules is crushed by this method. However, as discussed above, in most cases, due to a more or less irregular macroscopic and microscopic shape of the agglomerates, stressing is not uniform or reproducible and, therefore, the results can not be used for scientific or general purposes. If large enough numbers are crushed and the results are statistically treated and evaluated, the average values are good enough for quality control in a specific plant. It has been repeatedly shown, however, that a comparison of data between different plants, laboratories, and even between technicians in the same laboratory (often referred to as the “human effect”) is not possible. Many publications also report on the fact, that most agglomerates do not break under the influence of a single, well defined force. Rather, because agglomerates are porous bodies, which are made up from particulate solids with binding mechanisms acting between them, and often feature irregularities in their structure, they will disintegrate in steps. It is possible, that several small pieces break from the agglomerate before it finally fails catastrophically. Other products, particularly wet agglomerates, deform plastically before failure occurs. Some binding mechanism, for example those caused by highly viscous binders or capillary forces (see Section 5.1.1), can also produce a “self healing” effect after a first, smaller crack has developed. Therefore, even an unequivocal definition of the crushing strength is problematic. For the testing of other agglomerates by tumbling, the drum shape and execution is often modified. To avoid a sliding motion and produce cascading during the test, square drums have been designed or varying numbers of differently designed lifters have been built into cylindrical drums. The composition and mass of the sample to be tested, the rotational speed, the duration of the test, and the screen size defining “fines” are varied to fit particular needs.
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
If the abrasion resistance of smaller granules, for example of fertilizers, agrochemicals, intermediate products, etc., must be tested, specific, often smaller drums can be used as described above. Recently, based on this technique, again influenced by pressure from consumers and the desire to develop a quality assurance plan, the Saskatchewan Potash Producers Association has defined a standard procedure for the determination of degradation characteristics (= “strength”)of this granulated bulk fertilizer [5.G]. More often however, a representative sample is placed on the particular test screen that defines the “fines” and vibrated or shaken in a laboratory screening machine (e.g. Rotap, Fritsch, etc.) for a predetermined time [5.7]. To produce a sufficiently significant amount of abrasion for quality control, “grinding media”, such as a specific number of steel bearing balls of a particular size or other pieces with the same purpose, are added to the granular sample. If the separation size defining “fines”is very small and, therefore, the screen is delicate, the test can be carried out in the pan. The amount of fines is then determined in a separate screening step. Because of the well defined shape of tablets, crushing tests are regularly and with great success used in the pharmaceutical industry in-line or off-line and often automatically, in combination with an automatic sampler, for monitoring tablet strength. Other modern, fully automated equipment measures tablet weight, thickness, diameter, and hardness for quality control and validation (Fig. 5.32). For some agglomerated products it is important to make sure that they meet certain strength related characteristics. For example, many animal feeds are pelleted by extruding mixtures of conditioned components through cylindrical bores in flat or cylindrical dies (see also Section 8.4.2). While pelleted food for fowl or fish is swallowed whole, products for feeding mammals need to be chewable. A compromise must be found between high strength and abrasion resistance, which allows storage, transportation, and handling without breakdown and/or the production of fines, and the requirement that pellets must be safely crushed between the teeth of the animal. A crushing test to measure this type of crushing strength was developed (Fig. 5.33) and is used for quality control in feed mills.
Fig. 5.32 Photograph of the “Schleuniger Autotest 4” tablet testing system for the quick and automatic measurement o f tablet weight, thickness, diameter, and hardness (courtesy Dr. Schleuniger Pharmatron, Manchester, NH. USA).
I
73
74
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.33 Handheld (a) and automated (b) crushingtest equipment for the determination of strength of pelleted animal feed (courtesy Amandus Kahl, Reinbek. Germany).
In many industries, the requirements on product quality are not very stringent. The agglomerates must withstand handling, including the loading of silos and transport vessels, as well as transfers. Generally speaking, they must survive several drops with only limited breakage and the creation of a minimum of fines. For the measurement of this characteristic “drop tests” are carried out. The actual equipment and procedure may vary widely and is normally a simulation of the expected “abuse” which the material will encounter on its way from production to consumption or use. Fig. 5.34 is the sketch of a typical arrangement. A drop test arrangement can be easily built and applied in the field. The “equipment” consists of a heavy plate (1)made from steel with at least 20 m m thickness, a concrete slab, or - in the most simple case - a stone laboratory floor on which a
5.2 Estimation of Agglomerate Strength
Fig. 5.34
Sketch of a drop test arrangement (explanations see text).
tube or some kind of collar (2) is placed to contain the sample after the drop and avoid material losses. Diameter, height, and material of construction of the retaining wall must be such that, after impact, pieces can dissipate without experiencing secondary breakage. A vertical pipe ( 3 ) ,the upper end ofwhich is at a distance h from the impact plate on the floor, extends into the retaining container. Length and diameter of the pipe depend on the size of the agglomerates to be tested. The diameter should be at least 5times or, even better, lotimes greater than the largest agglomerate dimension. The length is simulating the expected drops during further handling of the product. The pipe must end at a sufficient distance from the impact plate to allow free lateral movement of the mass upon impacting the plate. The test itself can be carried out in different ways. One method is to drop batches, each, for example, consisting of five large agglomerates (in most cases briquettes), one after the other, from different, increasing heights. “Strength”is defined as that height from which all five agglomerates still survive the drops without damage. This test determines the maximum drop height that can be tolerated in a plant which must produce whole agglomerates and handle them without breakage. Such a requirement may exist if products are manufactured that must have a certain appeal such as charcoal briquettes for barbecueing, salt briquettes for the regeneration of home water softeners, or, generally, consumer products. The test as described before is carriedout during system development, prior to plant design; later, for quality control during operation, representative samples are extracted in regular intervals from the product stream and dropped from the predetermined height to recheck and confirm their survival. Often it is not necessary to produce industrial agglomerates that must survive all handling completely intact. In this case, a relatively great drop height is selected
I
75
76
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
and individual agglomerates are tested. The particle size distribution of the broken pieces is determined by screening and the result of the drop test is judged based on the amount of “fines”that is produced during impact. The definition of what constitutes fines and their permissible amount depend on the application. In still other cases, the collective behavior of a large number of agglomerates is of interest. Then, a sample, sometimes weighing several kilograms, is dropped, all at once, from a bucket through the pipe. This setup simulates the “cushioning” effect of a bed of material at the impact point. The evaluation is again carried out by screening and determining the amount of “fines”.During an alternative procedure the entire sample or only pieces larger than “fines” are dropped again or repeatedly for a specific number of times. The evaluation of the test is done in the same way as before whereby data are determined either after each drop or after a certain number of drops. These few examples of industrial methods for the determination of agglomerate strength and descriptions of how these test may be carried out shall suffice. The technicalliterature ofthe past century is full ofreports that cover industrial plants producing agglomerates and evaluations of their “strength”, whatever that characteristic may mean in a particular case. Readers who wish to know more are encouraged to seek out these publications whereby it should be recognized that, in the past, most papers have appeared in application oriented journals and proceedings of conferences. The above descriptions of alternatives that are possible in the execution of the same test to obtain specific information for agglomerate handling or use should also help to understand how existing methods, which may have been used in a completely different context for other agglomerates, can be adapted interdisciplinarily to fit new requirements.
5.3
Structure of Agglomerates
Agglomerates are bodies that are, often artificially and with purpose, produced from individual “small” particles. The term “small” is to be understood in relation to the agglomerate. Although there are agglomerates, for example in the food industry (see Section 5.1.2 and Fig. 5.12), or natural, often undesired agglomerates (see Section 5.5), which consist of only a few particles, typical agglomerates contain very large numbers of particles (see Section 5.3.1, Table 5.6) with sizes that are orders of magnitude smaller than that of the agglomerate. Binding mechanisms (see Section 5.1.1) cause these particles to temporarily or permanently stick together and form a lose or porous entity (see Section 5.3.2). Since binding mechanisms act in different ways (see Section 5.1), the structure of agglomerates is of great importance for all properties of agglomerates. The sketch in Fig. 5.35 depicts a random cut through an agglomerate. The area within the heavy solid lines is arbitrarily defined as “one”. Fig. 5.35 seems to show particles and their distribution. In reality, what is visible are cross sections through particles at a random level. If another random cut through the same agglomerate is made, a totally different picture is obtained. Moreover, particles that seem to float in space are in contact with other particles at some level. For example, the shaded cross section may be the result of cutting the particle, shown in elevation on
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Examples of:
@
Contact points
0 Nearpoints
Elevation (Side View)
Fig. 5.35 Sketch of a random cut through an agglomerate.
the side of Fig. 5.35, at the indicated line. Obviously this particle will have a completely different outline at another level. The same observation is true for the void spaces (= porosity) that are visible between the particle cross sections. If the heavily bordered square in Fig. 5.35, which represents the area “one”,is large enough and contains a great number of the two significant structural characteristics, i.e. outlines of cross sections through particles and of pores between the particles, a statistical evaluation of any random cut will produce generally valid results with an accuracy that can be described by the standard deviation which is associated with that statistical treatment. Therefore, for example, scanning the picture of the cut will produce information on particle size and distribution, porosity, E , solids content, 1 - E , and, with the appropriate software, a shape factor and the specific surface area of the particles (B.601. Accuracy can be increased by investigating multiple cuts through the same agglomerate and determining the statistical averages for all of them. A visual evaluation of the enlarged picture of the cut through an agglomerate also reveals certain other features, although the observations can only be used to explain phenomena and do not serve any scientific purpose. The shaded circles in Fig. 5.35 indicate, for example, some of the contact points between particles in this particular cross section and the open circles depict some of the “near points” at which a binding mechanism, such as liquid bridges or one of the field forces (see Section 5.1.1), could develop. The average of the sum of both types of interaction points for one particle defines the coordination number k . Taking into consideration the statements made above in regard to random cuts, it is of course possible that “near points” in a particular cut are actually contact points in a level slightly above or below and it is impossible to determine all the interaction points which are distributed three-dimensionally around a particle.
I
77
78
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
5.3.1
General Considerations
The structure of agglomerates depends on many different parameters. Generally, they are parameters related to the particles building and all the processes involved in forming the green and final agglomerate. Particularly during high-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.2) and various post-treatment (curing) processes (see Sections 5.3.2,7.3, and 8.3) parameters that relate to the original feed particles may change. Parameters Related to Particles Building an Agglomerate. The most important particle related parameters that influence agglomerate structure are:
Particle size, Particle size distribution, Macroscopic particle shape, Microscopic particle shape (surface configuration, e.g. roughness). With the exception of geometrically well defined particles, particularly spheres and cubes, it is difficult to describe with one dimension and measure particle size (Fig. 5.36). During particle size analysis [B.GO], the response of each particle to a physical effect is determined; for example, whether a particle will pass a defined opening (screening), how fast a particle will settle in a stationary fluid under the influence of gravity or centrifugal force (sedimentation), at what speed of a gas flow a particle will be entrained (sifting), how much extinction will be caused by a particle passing through a sensing zone (sensor output),what is the outline of a picture or projection of a particle (scanning),how much energy is reflected from a particle at a particular angle (scattering), etc., etc. Only absolutely spherical, microscopically smooth particles will produce results with which particle size (diameter of the sphere) is determined unequivocally and by modifying the effect which determines size, the distribution of the sizes of spherical particles can be determined, if dilute samples are analyzed where the particles do not influence each other during the test. For all other situations, particle shape has an overwhelming effect on how they behave during a test or in any process. Shape is characterized by form and proportions. Form refers to the degree to which a particle approaches a definite form, such as a sphere, cube, tetrahedron (Fig. 5.36),or higher order polyhedron. The relative proportions distinguish one spheroid, cuboid, tetrahedron, or polyhedron from another of the same class. Macroscopically, shape may be described rather subjectively by comparison with “standard shapes” or defined by coefficients (Fig. 5.37). The major problem of characterizing the three-dimensional shape of a particle by its size is that size is one-dimensional and coefficients of “standard shapes” are two-dimensional. To overcome this problem, particles may be described by polar coordinates, for example, radius vectors from the center of gravity extending to any point of the surface. By using the radius and the two polar coordinate angles, the shape of the particle surface can be described to any desired degree of accuracy. Obviously, for the time being, this technique is limited to scientific work.
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Microscopically, particle shape, particularly surface texture, may be defined by fractals or Fourier functions. It must be realized that in nature no absolutely smooth surfaces exist. With increasing magnification macroscopically smooth, e.g. polished, surfaces first reveal scratches, caused by the polishing media, and later “natural”roughness with peaks and valleys. Since the size of small particles which are interacting with other, larger particles extends into the nano range and, therefore, such particles are themselves similar to or potentially smaller than many surface features on other particles, it is understandable that knowledge of the microscopic particle texture is of great importance for agglomeration. However, even with the quickly growing technological advances in the nano scale it is still impossible in practice to apply the information for general theories with which agglomerate characteristics can be predicted. As will be shown below, the extremely large number of particles that are involved and their variability (it can be assumed that no two particles are exactly alike) is another reason for today’s inability to generally and unequivocally describe the interactions between particles in an agglomerate.
Fig. 5.37 “Standard set o f shapes” for the determination of particle sphericity according t o Rittenhouse [B.42].
I
79
80
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
All that is normally known about a particle is its silhouette, projection, or profile or, in those cases where size is derived from other physical effects, such as, for example, the settling velocity, a dimension related to volume, mass, or surface texture. Therefore, methods must be found that interpret information from cuts through the particle, scans of portions of the surface area, or information from particle behavior in, for example, fluids and connect it with overall shape. Unless the measured outline of the particle misses a unique, dominant feature of the particle shape, the result will be representative of the particle. The methods are still very complicated and require a large number of discrete items of information to describe a particle signature reasonably well. Shape influences particle behavior in powder packings and the representative (particle) equivalent diameter changes with the physical situation. In agglomeration, in addition to the surface equivalent diameter of an entire particle size distribution, which is the representative value for estimating the strength of agglomerates (see Section 5.2.2), for the packing structure, the diameter of an inscribed average circle representing the particle projection is less significant than that of the circle enveloping all peaks and protrusions (Fig. 5.38). This is particularly true for loose packings (Fig. 5.38, top). A different equivalent diameter would be representative for closely packed particles (Fig. 5.38, bottom). It appears possible that, in the future, equivalent particle diameters can be computed for loose and dense packings. Furthermore, it should become feasible to calculate the work that is required to go from one packing structure to another, the resistance of a powder to penetration, and its angle of repose. It is already possible to characterize the pore structure of a particle system by using automatic scans of a cross section and employing fractals to analyze the data. Nevertheless, the characterization of particulate matter and the structure of particle systems is still at the beginning of becoming an exact and widely used science.
Particle size versus packing r a d i u s Size Packing radius-
Close packed p a r t i c l e s
Fig. 5.38
Effect o f particle shape on its packing behavior.
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Much of the industrial research of packing structures is still based on spherical particles. The most fundamental information is obtained if the regular packings of monosized spheres are evaluated. Fig. 5.39 shows the six regular packing structures of monosized spheres. For the packings depicted in Fig. 5.39 porosity E, the void volume between the monosized spherical particles, and the coordination number k, the number of interaction points of a sphere in the structure with neighboring spheres, can be exactly determined (Tab. 5.5). All coordination points in these structures are contact points.
Fig. 5.39 Systematic arrangements of spherical particles (“regular packings”). For explanations see text and Table 5.5.
I
82
I
5 Agglomeration Theories Tab. 5.5 Porosities, coordination numbers, and approximations according to Eq. 5.6 for the “regular packings” shown in Figure 5.39. Geometric arrangement
-
Coordination number, k
k
&
Cubic (Figure 5.39a)
0.476
6
6.599
Orthorhombic, two alternatives (Figure 5.39b)
0.395
8
7.953
(Figure 5.39~)
0.395
8
7.953
Tetragonal-spheroidal (Figure 5.39d)
0.302
10
10.40
Rhombohedral (pyramidal) (Fig. 5.39e)
0.260
12
12.08
Rhombohedral (hexagonal) (Fig. 5.394
0.260
12
12.08
Porosity
ir/c
(Eq. 5.6)
Tab. 5.5 shows that the porosity of regular packings ranges from 47.6 % for the most open structure to 26 % for the densest packing. Real packings of monosized spheres are called irregular packings. Unlike the specified location of each sphere in a regular packing (deterministic system), the position of any sphere in a randomly packed bed can only be described by a probability distribution (stochastic system). Moreover, the density (or porosity) of a randomly packed bed depends on the mode of packing. Normally, in freely developing, infinite beds two structures are distinguished: a very loose random packing with a typical porosity of 40-43 % and a lose random packing with 39-41 % porosity. If packings are produced in a container they are influenced by the “wall effect” (Fig. 5.40). On and near rigid walls the positioning of the spherical particles can not occur freely and this disturbance is continuing into the packing, creating voids and other irregularities. Nevertheless, poured random packings in containers may attain 37 - 39 % porosity, depending on the dimensions of the container in relation to the size of the spheres and, if the container is vibrated or vigorously shaken, a porosity of approx. 36 % may be obtained. Tab. 5.5 also shows that the coordination numbers for regular packings of monosized spheres are 6, 8, 10, and 12 and that even for these unique conditions the approximation of Equation 5.6 is rather good. Therefore, it can be assumed that Equation 5.6 results in a close approximation of k which indicates that, based on a purely mathematical estimation, high densities of <10 %, which are, for example, obtained during high-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.2), are associated with coordination numbers of >30, explaining, among other reasons, the immediate high strength of agglomerates produced by these methods. Even though many studies have been and are being carried out to characterize packings derived from two or more sphere sizes, there is still no theory that satisfactorily describes the structure and allows an universally valid prediction of density or porosity, pore sizes and distribution as well as the coordination number of specific packings. For particles with irregular shape and a particle size distribution, the typical case in industry, a general understanding of structure and its characteristics is still remote. If
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Fig. 5.40 [5.8].
Examples o f packings demonstrating the "wall effect"
packing parameters need to be known they must be determined experimentally. Nevertheless, some interesting information has evolved from the many tests that were carried out over time. It relates to so called optimum packings. The most important optimum packing is the densest regular packing of spherical particles. It can be most easily derived from the two loosest regular packings (a and c in Fig. 5.39) of the largest spherical particles in a mixture (Fig. 5.41). It is obtained by inscribing the largest possible spherical particle into the void between the four or three larger spheres (depending on the model used) and adding the appropriate amount of these smaller spherical particles to fill all the voids between the larger ones. This method is then continued as shown in Fig. 5.41.
I
83
84
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
--r-- t---I
I
Fig. 5.41 Sketches o f the systematic arrangements o f differently sized spherical particles t o obtain the densest possible packing.
Obviously, the resulting particle sizes and their relative masses do not fit a continuous distribution. The mixture consists of discrete classes of particles. In reality, where such densest packings are desired for a number of reasons, for example in the production of high quality concrete to obtain high strength and water impermeability by minimizing porosity and the presence of interconnected pores (see Section 5.3.2), narrow size ranges of aggregate particles are mixed in the appropriate amounts as
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
prescribed by the model. Although neither particle size nor shape of the components correspond with the assumptions of the model (spherical monosized particles in different classes) the real random packing produces the desired high density and strength. To obtain the best possible impermeability in concrete, the smallest particles that are added today feature particle sizes <SO0 n m (e.g. silica fume). In those cases where it is not practical to mix discrete classes of narrowly sized particles, an approximation yields a continuous particle size distribution. Mathematically, it is described by the “Fuller distribution” [B.42],an exponential distribution in which the exponent must be between 1/3 and 213. For agglomerates, strength depends primarily on porosity and particle size (see Section 5.2.1). The smaller they are, the higher is the expected strength. This is due to the fact that, with reduced particle size, the number of particles per unit volume increases and with decreasing porosity the coordination number increases. Both effects multiply the binding forces to sometimes very high levels resulting in considerable agglomerate strength. For example, iron ore pellets which, for other reasons (see Section 11.8),are produced from concentrate particles <44 pm, are so strong after sintering that they will not be crushed by truck or front end loader tires. The effect of porosity on the coordination number has been discussed above. Tab. 5.6 shows that if a 1 g sphere, made of a material with a specific mass of 1 g/cm3, is converted into spherical particles (for example by melting, spraying, and consolidation) with 1 pm diameter, 1.9 billion (1.9 trillion according to the American system) particles are produced. Dividing the same mass into spherical particles with 0.5 m m (500 pm) diameter still yields 15,000 particles. These relations have to be kept in mind when considering the effects of binding mechanisms on agglomerates. Since the structure of agglomerates is so important for many properties of agglomerates and scientific or theoretical predictions or descriptions are not yet possible, empirical approaches must be taken to understand and evaluate agglomerate structure. This is particularly true when real particles, i.e. those with irregular shape and an often wide, sometimes multimodal size distribution are involved. As will be obvious in this book, scanning electron microscopy (SEM) is a very powerful tool for the observation of surface and/or interior structures of most solids, including agglomerates. The main advantage of the scanning electron microscope is, that it can not only enlarge the field of vision such that even submicron features are clearly visible but that it also provides depth of focus which allows a three dimensional evaluation. Tab. 5.6 Some properties o f spherical particles (density 1 g/cm3) and o f agglomerates made from these particles. Mass Diameters
Volume
Porosity
kl
Imml
[cm3i
w r
1
p--12.4 a:
1
p = 10.’ a--14.75
1
p
p
=
=
-
0.5 a-14.34
particle(s), a
=
p
=
0; a:
p : - ; a-1.67
p
=
0; a
p : - ; a-1.54
p = 0; a
agglomerate
1; a:
-
Spec. Surface
p=l
~ - 4 . 8 . 1 0 - ~a: ; -
p-l.9.10’2
p : - ; a-5.97-6
p-1.5.104
p : - ; a-1.2.10
[m2lg1
p
=
Numbers
= 40 =
35
~
I
85
86
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Since they were first invented the size and cost of scanning electron microscopes has come down considerably, the time for sample preparation has been shortened, and other complications of the procedure have been reduced. Today, relatively low priced desk top microscopes are available and many scientific or corporate laboratories are equipped with larger units so that this technology is accessible to almost everyone. Parameters Related to Processes Forming Agglomerates. Processes applied for the manufacturing of green or final (after post-treatment) agglomerates strongly influence agglomerate structure. As will be shown in more detail later (see Chapter G), agglomeration processes generally belong to three disparate technological fields:
Tumble/Growth Agglomeration Pressure Agglomeration Agglomeration by HeatlSintering According to the mechanisms that prevail in each of these technologies, the structure of agglomerates is different. Tumble/Growth Agglomeration. As the name implies, in tumblelgrowth agglomera-
tion small particles adhere to each other after colliding during their irregular, stochastic motion in a particle bed and form a new entity that is held together by binding forces. After passing the difficult and critical stage of seed formation (see Section 7.1) the particle assembly grows by the attachment of additional particles to its surface. The structure of agglomerates resulting from growth during tumbling depends on the density of the particle bed, the energy imparted the tumbling mass, the acting binding mechanisms, and the time, among others. Agglomerates formed in a low density cloud of particles, for example in a fluidized bed or other low density tumblelgrowth agglomerators (see Sections 7.4.4 and 7.4.5), feature a very loose structure, high porosity, far beyond that of even the most open regular packing (Fig. 5.39 and Tab. 5.5), and contain few particles. In high density tumbling beds of particles, as realized, for example, in disc, drum, or cone agglomerators (see Section 7.4.1), and even more so if mixing tools provide additional energy and shear, such as in mixer agglomerators (see Section 7.4.2), particles that have attached themselves to the surface are either torn off again or moved to an energetically more favorable location as shown in Fig. 5.42. This results in dense structures with porosities between that of the cubic and orthorhombic regular packings (Fig. 5.39a - c and Tab. 5.5). It must be realized, however, that once particles are incorporated in the structure, a change of that arrangement is only possible during secondary processing or post-treatment.
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates 187
Fig. 5.42 Conceptual model depicting how a small particle is incorporated into the surface o f a (wet) agglomerate in a high density tumbling bed o f particles during tumble/growth agglomeration.
Pressure Agglomeration During pressure agglomeration external forces act on an at least partially confined mass of particles. As shown in Fig. 5.43 two different densification phases are conceivable (see Section 8.1),influencing the structure of agglomerates obtained by pressure. First, requiring relatively little force, particle adhesion and interparticle friction are overcome and some densification of the particle mass is realized. The amount of densification depends on the bulk density of the original feed particle mass. Sometimes the bulk density is very low, corresponding to high bulk volume, because natural adhesion forces are high, for example due to the presence of very small particles, and/or because considerable interparticle friction occurs which is caused, for example, by irregular shape and/or significant surface roughness of the powder particles. During this initial densification phase, the sizes and shapes of the feed particles are not altered or only very little, for example by breaking off some roughness peaks. Some of the pressure agglomeration techniques which make use of binders or inherent binding mechanisms do not apply forces that densify to or far beyond this point (see Sections 8.4.1 and 8.4.2). Once the densest packing of the unaltered feed particles in a confined space is obtained, - which, by the way, does not correspond to the absolutely highest density because solid particles can not flow freely into still available voids as would the molecules of liquids or gases -, once this density is reached and the external forces are
88
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
fP A
c‘ Fig. 5.43
Mechanisms of densification of particulate solids
continuing to increase, particles deform and/or break. During this phase of compaction, structure is changed drastically and void space is reduced until the “hydrostatic” state is reached at which no further densification occurs and the compact responds like an incompressible solid (see Section 8.1). Porosity of agglomerates that are produced at high pressure is in the 10 to 20 % range or may be as low as 5 % and many closed pores have developed. Therefore, for some agglomerates resulting from high-pressure agglomeration, it may be necessary to introduce porosity that may be required or desired during post-treatment processes (see Sections 5.3.2 and 8.3).
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
During sintering, atoms and molecules move at elevated temperatures across the interface at the contact points between two solid particles and form a bridge (see Sections 5.3.2 and 9.1). This process is influenced by temperature, contact area, and pressure as well as time. As a primary technology, agglomeration by heat occurs in bulk masses which are deposited onto a stationary or moving (“travelling”)grate. Heat is provided by hot flue gases or burning solid fuel which has been mixed into the bulk mass. As a result, the structure of “sinter”is relatively open, particularly if the heat was caused by solid fuel which disappears to a large extent (only leaving ashes) during burning. Often, sintering is used as a post-treatment process to provide strength to agglomerates (see Sections 7.3 and 8.3) or modify the porosity. Depending on how the sintering process is controlled, the agglomerate shrinks and densifies (up to almost 100 % density or 0 % porosity) or porosity is maintained and, sometimes, even increased (see Section 5.3.2). Agglomeration by Heat/Sintering
5.3.2
Porosity and Techniques That Influence Porosity
The properties of materials that are produced from fine (FP) and ultrafine (UFP) or “nano”particles by agglomeration are critically influenced by the void volume between the particles forming the agglomerate. This product attribute is called porosity and is defined by the presence, size, shape, and distribution of pores. To a considerable extent, the following text is based on two recently published books [B.61, B.621 which are recommended for further reading. Generally, there are two types of pores (Fig. 5.44). Open pores are connected with the body’s surface while closed pores are isolated within and may be filled with a fluid. Penetrating pores are a special type of open pores; they feature at least two ends and connect opposing surfaces of the porous body. Pore models are typically based on cylindrical tubes (Fig. 5.45a). In reality, pores are produced by voids between particles and, therefore, feature narrow necks and wider parts (Fig. 5.45b) and form a complicated network which is strongly dependent on the
Open pores
Fig. 5.44
Schematic representation o f different pore types [8.61].
Closed pores
I
89
90
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.45
Pore models. (a) Cylindrical, (b) realistic.
size, shape, and distribution of the particles forming the agglomerate (Fig. 5.46).Another special type of open pores are “inkbottle” pores (see Fig. 5.44) which have a narrow opening and expand below the surface. Porous materials are solids which contain void spaces. Agglomerates are special in that the particles forming the porous body must not be uniform. In fact, it is more common that the primary particles which are loosely or rigidly joint together by binding mechanisms are different in size, shape, structure, and composition. For most industrial applications, for example those that make use ofthe accessibility of the large specific surface area of the primary FPs and/or UFPs in agglomerates, open pores are required. Penetrating pores are necessary if fluids must flow through agglomerates in, for example, filters, fluid distributors, or catalyst carriers. Agglomerates with closed pores are primarily used for sonic and thermal insulators and for light weight building materials. Many of the statements and explanations in the following subchapters are similar to treatments already covered in the previous section (Section 5.3.1). For reasons of clarity and to better connect the items, a certain amount of redundancy will be found. Structure and porosity of agglomerates are very closely related. Porosity and Agglomerate Strength One of the equations that is most commonly used to describe the strength of agglomerates (see Section 5.2.1) connects the porosity, E, with the coordination number, k, the sum of all adhesion forces at each coordination point, Ai, and the particle size, x, (Eq. 5.8). The term (1 - E ) / E indicates that the strength of agglomerates which are held together by binding mechanisms acting at the coordination points within the aggglomerates is strongly dependent on porosity. Unless special efforts are made, high porosity, a feature of agglomerates that is often desired, results in low agglomerate strength, which is equally as often not acceptable in agglomerated industrial products such as, for example, catalyst carriers. The same influence of porosity on strength is obtained for agglomerates that are completely saturated with a wetting liquid (for example water). In this case, the sum of all adhesion forces, Ai, is replaced by the liquid’s surface tension, a (Eq. 5.2).
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Fig. 5.46 Schematic representation o f pore configurations (adapted from [B.61]). (a) Most agglomerates have a geometry o f openings between particles. Fundamentally the pore shape is angular. (b) Agglomerates produced from or containing plate-like particles have a geometry of openings between plates. When the platelets pile up, porosity becomes less. (c) Agglomerates consisting o f or containing elongated particles usually feature high porosity which becomes less when fibers pile up. (d) An interconnected network o f
homogeneous pores is observed if, for example, in glassy agglomerates a leaching technique decomposes spinodal components. (e) In this pore geometry, large pores are connected by small ones. The removal of pore forming agents during a posttreatment o f agglomerates results in this structure. (f) Agglomerates that are produced from porous particles have a pore structure with networks o f both large and small pores.
I
91
92
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
If in matrix bonded agglomerates (see Section 5.1), such as, for example, concrete (matrix: cement) and road surfaces (matrix: asphalt),a single, narrowly sized aggregate would be used, large pores result requiring much binder to fill them and yielding low quality products. In addition to the possibility of many faults in the matrix (incomplete filling, gas bubbles, etc.) which act as stress raisers and cause failure, the binder becomes the quality determining part of the system and causes low strength in concrete and insufficient hardness at elevated temperatures in road surfaces. The densest packing of aggregate (= particles forming the agglomerate structure) in such materials can be determined by considering models that are based on regular packings of monosized spheres (see Section 5.3.1, Fig. 5.41). Although, in reality, neither monosized spherical particles nor regular packings are obtained, the gradation (= size fraction) of the aggregate and the respective amounts of each to achieve dense packing or low porosity and, with it, high product quality can be determined. In addition to obtaining good strength and other mechanical quality specifications, introduction of UFPs (as, for example, nano-sized silica fume) in the above mentioned models and during formulation, results in high impermeability for water in ultra high quality concrete for e.g. prestressed structures and airport runways. Typical Agglomerate Porosities Different agglomeration methods yield different por-
osities of the resulting agglomerates. In this respect, three methods with several subgroups can be distinguished: I. Growth or tumble agglomeration (Chapter 7) 1. High density tumbling bed (Section 7.4.1) 2. High shear tumbling bed (Section 7.4.2) 3. High densitylhigh shear with abrasion or crushing transfer (Section 7.4.2) 4. Low density fluidized bed (Section 7.4.4) 5. Low density particle clouds (Section 7.4.5) 6. Agglomeration in stirred suspensions (Section 7.4.6) 7. Immiscible liquid agglomeration (Section 7.4.6) 11. Pressure agglomeration (Chapter 8) 1. Low-pressure agglomeration: Extrusion through screens (Section 8.4.1) 2. Medium-pressure agglomeration: Pelleting, extrusion through perforates die plates (Section 8.4.2) 3. High pressure extrusion: Ram presses (Section 8.4.3) 4. High-pressure agglomeration a) In confined spaces: Punch-and-die pressing, tabletting (Section 8.4.3) b) In confined spaces: Isostatic pressing (Section 8.4.4) c) In semi-confined spaces: Roller presses (Section 8.4.3) 111. Agglomeration by heat/sintering (Chapter 9) 1. Growth or Tumble Agglomeration (see Chapter 7) The mechanism of growth (see Section 7.1) of this method, the addition of single or aggregated particles to the outside of an agglomerate that increases in size, results in a typical structure with rather constant porosity. Porosity depends mostly on the size, distribution, shape, and surface
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
morphology of the particles forming the agglomerate and very little on the growth mechanism itself. The only difference in agglomerate structure results from whether dense particle beds and suspensions (1.1, 6, and 7) or low density fluidized particle beds, clouds, and suspensions (1.4- 7) are present during agglomeration. In dense environments, where many particles are tumbling in close proximity, the separating forces are more pronounced, particularly if shear is induced by mixing tools (1.2). In this case, weakly attached particles or loosely associated particle assemblies are removed by attrition and have a chance to become reconnected in a more favorable, normally closer position resulting in higher density or lower porosity. In low density fluidized beds, clouds, or suspensions, on the other hand, even weak, loosely bonded agglomerates with very high porosity survive. Once definite positioning of particles in the structure of a growing agglomerate is obtained, it is virtually impossible to change the size and network of pores unless very high external forces are applied (see, for example, 11.3 and 4). Another possibility to increase density and decrease porosity during growth is to introduce high shear through mixing tools (1.2) or to install high speed choppers that are integrally mounted but individually powered and rotate at several thousand RPM to achieve abrasion or crushing transfer (1.3, see also Section 7.1). Even if forced abrasion and crushing transfer are applied, the feed particle size distribution is chosen to form dense structures, and selective agglomeration of the fine components is avoided, growth or tumble agglomeration very infrequently produces agglomerates with porosities of less than 40 % but may yield very loose structures with porosities as high as 95 % if UFPs agglomerate in low density particle clouds. II. Pressure Agglomeration (see Chapter 8) Pressure agglomeration applies external forces to shape and densify particle masses, with or without a binder, and to produce strength. Low-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.4.1) is carried out by passing (extruding) plastic and sticky particle masses through screens or contoured, thin, perforated metal sheets (11.1),whereby mostly shaping with very little densification occurs. It results in agglomerates which, after drying, typically have a porosity of between 40 and 60 %. No change of this porosity is possible after extrusion. Some reshaping and surface densification is achieved during spheronizing, a rounding process that may be applied to still plastic extrudates (see Section 8.3). In medium-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.4.2), the extrusion through perforated die plates (11.2), higher densification can be obtained by two effects. First, the feed, that must have binding characteristics and be somewhat plastic, is predensified prior to extrusion by the screw(s) or between the press roller(s) and the die. Secondly, the material is passed through holes in the die where pressure builds up due to wall friction. The length over diameter ratio of the hole (= extrusion channel) and its shape as well as the properties of the feed determine final densification. Because of the wall friction, the surface of the extrudate is always denser than the center (see also Section 8.2). After production, no change in porosity other than potentially caused by some shrinking during drying is possible. Porosity is typically in the range of 30 to 50 %.
I
93
94
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
During high-pressure agglomeration (see Section 8.4.3) the forces may be so high that plastic deformation and flow or breakage of brittle particles followed by rearrangement can occur (see also Sections 5.3.1 and 8.2). Correspondingly, porosities can be as low as 5 % or even less, approaching theoretical density. On the other hand, it is relatively difficult to produce compacts with porosities of more than 30 % without resorting to some post-treatment method. Such possibilities (see below) are rather important because punch-and-die and isostatic pressing methods (II.4.a and b) are often used to produce green bodies, particularly in ceramics and powder metallurgy, which may require a controlled network of pores in the final product with larger porosity than originally obtained in the green part. A particular characteristic of all pressure agglomeration methods is that the density of a compacted body made from particulate solids is not uniform (see Section 8.2). This is due to the presence of adhesion and frictional forces between the particulate mass and the pressing tools, the existence of interparticle friction, and the division of force at the points of contact between the particles. This phenomenon is most pronounced in products from high-pressure agglomeration in confined spaces (11.4.a) which is the method of choice for “near-net-shape” green parts in the ceramics and powder metal industries. Because non uniform density leads to deformation during the post-treatment process that is required to obtain final strength and properties, isostatic pressing (11.4.b),both cold and hot, has been developed in which the pressure acts from all sides through a fluid in an autoclave thus producing green bodies with uniform density distribution. This does not mean that density and porosity are constant throughout the body; density is still higher at the surface and less in the center due to the dissipation of forces and interparticle friction. However their distribution is uniform and, therefore, does not cause uncontrolled deformation during post-treatment. Elastic and/or fibrous materials such as many organic materials (peat, lignite, straw, hay, wood, vegetable, and other plant materials as well as their wastes, etc.) pose a particular problem in agglomeration. Unless powdered in some way, which is expensive, such materials can not be agglomerated by growth and tumble agglomeration. It is also difficult to successfully use pressure agglomeration because after the typically very short application of force, deformation and densification are not permanent and elastic spring back occurs after pressure release (see Section 8.1).For such materials ram presses (11.3) are used. They feature a long extrusion channel in which many compacts are held under pressure by the influence of elastic forces and wall friction. These compacts undergo repeated new densification and deformation phases when moving forward with each ram stroke, thus producing stable briquettes even from highly elastic materials (see Section 8.4.3). Because of the particular shaping and densification process, porosity is very low on all surfaces but relatively high inside. Products are ideally suited as primary or secondary fuels. Ill. Agglomeration by Heat (see Chapter 9) At elevated temperatures, close to the melting point or softening range of a material, the atoms and molecules at the surface of a solid particle become so mobile that they can move across the interface at a contact point between two particles; solid bridges, so called sinter bridges, develop.
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Although this phenomenon may occur with any material at the appropriate temperature (including relatively low ones for e.g. some man-made plastic and other organic materials), sintering was originally invented as an agglomeration method for metal ores. In this process, ore fines are mixed with a solid fuel (e.g. coal); the mixture is then loosely deposited as a futed bed on a stationary or moving grate, ignited, and kept burning by passing air through the bed. As a result, sinter bridges develop while the fuel is consumed and leaves large voids. After cooling, the agglomerate is broken into suitable pieces and used as feed for blast furnaces. During the reduction process, the large voids and a relatively open pore network provide good access of reducing gases to the ore particles in the sinter structure. sintering is also used as a post-treatment process to obtain final and permanent strength and structure of green bodies which were formed by agglomeration (see Sections 7.3 and 8.3). Methods for Influencing the Porosity of Agglomerates It is possible to produce, for example, quickly disolvable, “instant”,or easily dispersible granules (so called water soluble or dispersible granules, WSGs and WDGs) with sufficient strength for storage, handling, and application by tumble or growth agglomeration, particularly in low density fluidized bed agglomerators. It is also feasible to manufacture agglomerates with pores of atomic scale for gas separation or catalysis from zeolites, silica gel and other similar materials featuring such small pores by sticking the nanoporous primary particles together and connecting them with the relatively large interparticle voids of the agglomerate (Fig. 5.4Gf). In one application, hardening binders, that ultimately result in high strength and also seal the large voids between the particles, are used to avoid a partially penetrating open network of coarse pores, and pressure agglomeration methods are selected to obtain well formed product shapes as designed for a particular application. In another case, a bimodal pore structure, in which a penetrating network of large pores is maintained by selecting a suitable binder that acts only at the coordination points between the particles, allows selective filtration. Such structures are, for instance, used in bioreactors. Enzymes or bacteria are immobilized in the small pores and the large pores are used as channels for transporting reactants and products
[B.bl].
The large group of agglomerated materials with high permanent strength, large porosity, and mostly open or even penetrating pores require post-treatment methods to achieve the theoretically impossible: high strength and a large amount of voids. In the following, some such methods will be discussed. For more information, the book “Porous Materials” [B.Gl] is recommended as additional reading material. An important mechanism for the production of porous products during a post-treatment process is sintering of green agglomerated bodies. The driving force for sintering is the reduction of surface area that is associated with pores. The free surface of the particles in the agglomerate has a specific surface energy which is caused by the atoms in the surface and the lack of opposing atoms. A decrease of the surface results in a reduction of surface energy. Therefore, the total free energy of an agglomerate decreases during sintering. At the same time the body often becomes denser. This phenomenon is shown in Fig. 5.47 in a very basic configuration of three spheres.
I
95
96
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Particles in contact
Particles adhere and form necks
Necks grow and open porosity decreases
Necks become large and pores change Open pores disappear and closed shape to spheroidal pores appear Grain boundary migration occurs leaving spherical closed pores isolated from grain boundary diffusion routes
Fig. 5.47 The phases ofsintering that are associated with shrinkage as shown in a simple model involving three spherical particles; adapted from [B.61].
Fig. 5.48 depicts schematically the sintering processes that can occur between two spherical particles. The numbers correspond to those in Tab. 5.7. It can be concluded that several mechanisms causing material transport (= diffusion paths) do not produce densification. While sintering which results in densification is well researched (see Section 9.1), diffusion phenomena which do not cause shrinkage and are, therefore, important for the production of porous products are less known. For the realisation of porous products during sintering two important preconditions must be fulfilled. One is the manufacturing of green agglomerates with homogeneous packing structure and low density. The other is the necessity to influence the sintering process such that no significant densification occurs but strong, well shaped bridges
Fig. 5.48 Model of the sintering processes that can occur between two particles [8.61]. (a) Depicts schematically bonding. X, Y, a, and p are: bridge radius, penetration depth, particle radius, and neck radius, respectively. (b) Is the bonding area in more detail showing the diffusion paths (Tab. 5.7).
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates Tab. 5.7
Description of path routes of diffusion during sintering.
No.
Diffusion path routes
Diffusion source
Diffusion sink
Densification
1
Surface diffusion
Surface
Neck
No
2
Volume diffusion
Surface
Neck
No
3
Evaporation/condensation
Surface
Neck
No
4
Grain boundary diffusion
Grain boundary
Neck
Yes
5
Volume diffusion
Grain boundary
Neck
Yes
G
Volume diffusion
Dislocation
Neck
No
develop. The first precondition is obtained by adjusting and controlling the powder characteristics and by CIPing (cold isostatic pressing; see II.4.h above, and also Section 8.4.4) with low pressure. The second is accomplished by using sintering conditions during which surface diffusion and evaporation/ condensation prevail. These requirements differ considerably from those of “normal” sintering for the production of dense products. Porous structures in green agglomerates can be achieved if the feed particles are preagglomerated (Fig. 5.49) or consist of bi- or multi-modal particle size fractions. Another method is the production of loose packings by sedimentation. Then, to retain the open porosity, the sintering process must be carried out at a low temperature and for a short time or, to obtain more open pores, pore forming additives are mixed with the powder. Pore forming additives can be either liquids or solids. Liquid additives are used if the green agglomerate is produced by either extrusion, injection molding, or casting. In those cases, the porosity of the green body is controlled by the amount of liquid in the viscous mix. Because liquids are not compressible they occupy volume elements which
Fig. 5.49 Pores in a structure made up of pre-agglomerated particles [8.61].
I
97
98
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
remain as pores after drying. If the liquid is a solution, strength is produced during drying by recrystallization. Depending on the final application and strength requirements, the dry agglomerate can be further strengthened by sintering. Solid pore forming additives (Tab. 5.8) are mixed with the primary particles and the blend is then agglomerated with any of the different available methods. As discussed above, agglomeration by heat (111, Sintering) produces directly a porous agglomerate when the solid fuel burns and, with exception of its ashes, disappears. Green agglomerates obtained by other methods are subjected to one or more post-treatments during which final strength develops and the pore forming agent burns, evaporates, or is removed from the structure as a liquid leaving pores behind (Fig. 5.50). It is difficult to produce small pores with this technique because very fine pore forming solids tend to selectively agglomerate during mixing so that they do not distribute uniformly. The low cost method is, however, very good for the production of porous materials with large, open pores. Tab. 5.8
Examples from literature of solid pore forming additives (for refs. see [8.61]).
Ammonium tetrachloride Carbonyl Coal Iodine fluoride Paraffin Petroleum coke Spherical polymer (PMMA) Wood dust
Carbon black Charcoal Dextrin Melamine Perid& Salicylic acid Starch
Another possibility for the manufacturing of solid and permanently porous agglomerates is the utilization of binders which melt during post-treatment at high temperatures and solidify during cooling to solid bridges (so called vitrification). Fig. 5.51 explains the process schematically. Reaction sintering is another technology that can be used for the production of solid, porous materials. By this means, chemicals in the powder mixture react under specific conditions with the atmosphere and/or other particles whereby solid bridges are formed. Porous ceramics may be produced by reaction sintering which is then called reaction bonding.
Fig. 5.50 Schematic representation of pore forming with solid additives [B.61].
5.3 Structure of Agglomerates
Fig. 5.51 Schematic representation o f pore forming by vitrification [B.61].
It is often difficult to produce a highly porous body, which, in the green state, has little strength, and to sinter it without destroying its shape during handling and losing porosity. One possibility to overcome these problems is to sinter the green compact in the pressing tool by passing electric current through it. A new technology which is particularly suitable for the production of porous products is pulsed electric current sintering (PECS) which is sometimes also called spark plasma sintering (SPS). Hot isostatic pressing (HIP) is often applied to densify sintered materials and to correct casting defects. Recently a new HIP process for the production of porous materials was developed. Partially densified compacts are sintered in a high pressure atmosphere. The pressurized gas in the open pores delays densification and porosity remains largely intact. Finally, the so called Sol-gel processes should be mentioned in which porosity, pore size, and polarity of products manufactured by this method can be controlled. Processing begins with a solution (= sol) which becomes a gel. The solution can be prepared from either inorganic salts or organic compounds. It is then hydrolized to a sol or condensed to form a gel. The process can be terminated in the sol-phase, where a dispersion of colloidal particles in a liquid exists, or continued to the gel-phase, the development of a three-dimensional, linked solid structure in which the pores are filled with a liquid. In the wet gel-phase, the pores are interconnected. The process of gel forming or gelation involves first the formation of particle clusters which are held together by hydrogen bonds with silanol groups (Fig. 5.52) followed by the development of a three-dimensional network which is strengthened by bridge growth between the particles. The size of the primary particles and their coordination number determine the porosity and the average pore diameter. In addition to a large number of parameters that control “Sol-Gel’’processing, the drying conditions are most important for the production of porous materials. During “normal” drying, considerable shrinkage occurs which is attributed to the negative capillary pressure which depends on the liquid’s surface tension. To minimize this effect, the original liquid which may have high surface tension can be exchanged by one with lower surface tension prior to drying. As mentioned previously, for additional information the book “Porous Materials” [B.G1] should be consulted.
I
99
100
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Si
\
GEL
SOL Fig. 5.52 Schematic representation of changes during the gelation of particulate sols. Dots represent hydrogen bonds: curved lines are
micelle surfaces.
5.4
Other Characteristics of Agglomerates
As the particle size of solids decreases, many characteristics of individual units change. Particle behavior in bulk masses also changes. Tab. 5.9 illustrates the influence of particle size, listing some important examples. In this context it is immaterial how size is defined: the table considers the relative decrease of a linear particle dimension which is randomly called "particle size". The upper part of Tab. 5.9 presents Influence of particle size on some important characteristics of fine particulate solids <0.5 mm.
Tab. 5.9
Characteristicsof Single Particles
With Decreasing Particle Size
Homogeneity Elastic/plastic behavior Probability of breakage Strength Resistance to attrition Vapor pressure, solubility, reactivity, etc. Color perception and intensity
Increasing Increasing ductility Decreasing Increasing Increasing Increasing Changing
Characteristicsof Bulk Masses
With Decreasing Particle Size
Bulk density (space-filling behavior) Flow characteristics, Flowability (of particles) Mixing efficiency Separating efficiency Ease of fluidization Occurrence of undesired agglomeration Dusting - Losses - Ignition Behavior/Explosiveness
Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Decreasing Increasing Increasing Increasing
5.4 Other Characteristics of Agglomerates
characteristics of single (individual) particles, while the lower describes the behavior of bulk masses. The most important single particle characteristics are homogeneity and specific surface area. Both increase with decreasing particle size. Homogeneity improves because, during size reduction, breakage begins preferably at faults (pores, microcracks, imperfections, contaminants, and others) leaving the resulting smaller particle more and more without flaws until a perfect structure is obtained. Therefore, as size reduction progresses, materials that first exhibit brittle behavior become increasing ductile, the probability of breakage decreases, and strength or resistance to attrition increase. And, if fine or ultrafine particles are produced directly, for example by precipitation, the probability that imperfections develop decreases with smaller particle size. Since volume and mass decrease with the third power of the characteristic linear particle dimension and surface area is only proportional to the square of that particle property, the specific surface area, expressed in m2/cm3or m2/g, increases with decreasing particle size. This results in higher vapor pressure, improved solubility, and increased reactivity as well as related changes of other, more complex properties. Also related to size and surface characteristics are the changes of color perception and intensity. As knowledge of these and other particle characteristics became more readily available by applying new and powerful microscopes, miniaturized tools, and novel methods of investigation, interest increased in the production and use of ultra-fine particles (UFPs) with physically predictable and sometimes new properties (so-called Nan0 Technology). Many particles that require extreme cleanliness in, for example, the food, pharmaceutical, fine chemicals, and metals industries are obtained by precipitation from gases or liquids yielding UFPs [B.55]. Fig. 5.53 depicts the size ranges of particulate matter in process technologies together with some reference points (i.e. radii of atoms, sizes of viruses, wave lengths of visible light). The particle size range of mechanical processes and of all mechanical unit operations (see Chapter 1, Fig. 1.1)now extends down to nano meters. Although, in comparison with the atomic scale, ultra-fine particles <0.1 pm or
Processes with changes in atomic structure
Processes of colloid physics and biochemistry Viruses
--
---
Mechanical processes Including electrical + magnetic separation Thermal processes
--- Wave lengths of visible light
Macromolecules __-___ + -Radii of atoms
Molecular disperse
Disperse systems
Colloid ,0-13
10-12
lfm
Fig. 5.53
10-l~ 1pm
+
Fine
1 0 . ~ lo-@ 1 0 . ~ I O - ~ 1 0 . ~ lo4 10” I A Inrn 1Pm
Particle sizes of various disperse systems
.+ Coarse
10.’
10.’ l o o 10‘ 10’ [cm] Imrn Icrn Idrn I r n
I
lo’
102
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
bodies, their size is less than optical wave lengths and, therefore, require electron microscopy to make them visible, i.e. individual nano-particles can not be observed optically. Since the smallest UFPs only contain approx. 100 atoms, new particle qualities may be defined by answers to questions such as: “How many atoms are required for a particle to exhibit characteristics that are common to a metal?”or “When does a particle begin to show biological interactions and functions?” [B.55]. UFPs of a particular size are the smallest units of solids, just as the smallest unit in the world of microorganisms today is thought to be the virus, a “particle” about the same size as that of UFPs. Therefore, further to the changes of properties with decreasing size of single fine particles as shown in Tab. 5.9, additional, new, and desirable characteristics are attributed to nano-particles. They also include, for example, biochemical interactions with microbes [B.55]. The disadvantages of fine and ultra-fine particles in bulk relate mostly to the storage, handling, and processing of such disperse systems. Interactions of extremely small particles with each other or various components in bulk masses cause a number of problems. Many result from the changing competition between volume and surface related forces. For example, since the weight or mass of particles decreases faster (volume related) than the adhesion force between particles (surface related), very fine particles adhere naturally to each other or to larger entities. This phenomenon causes decreased bulk density or increased bulk volume, reduced flowability, lower mixing or separation efficiencies, reduced ease of fluidization, increased tendency for undesired agglomeration (such as bridging, caking, build-up, etc.). Material losses due to dusting result from small size and mass while increased selfignition behavior and explosiveness (dust explosions) or, generally, high reactivity relate to the large specific surface area of fine powders. As shown in Tab. 5.10, size enlargement by agglomeration can improve the bulk properties of particulate solids in many ways. Agglomeration is characterized by an increase of the apparent size so that, for example, dusting or material losses are reduced and flowability is improved. At the same time the characteristics of the single particles, such as surface area and, with this, solubility, reactivity, and other
Tab. 5.10
Some of the most important advantages of agglomerated products.
No or low content of dust; therefore, increased safety during handling of, for example toxic or explosive materials, and, generally, fewer losses which may cause primary or secondary pollution. Freely flowing. Improved storage and handling characteristics. Improved metering and dosing capabilities. No segregation of co-agglomerated materials. Increased bulk density and lower bulk volume. Defined size and shape. Sometimes, defined weight of each agglomerate. Within limits, porosity or density can be controlled; thus, dispersibility, solubility, reactivity, heat conductivity, and other properties can be influenced. Improved product appeal. Increased sales value.
5.4 Other Characteristics of Agglomerates
related properties, are maintained. This is due to the fact that agglomerates are porous bodies, in which the primary particles, held together by binding mechanisms, are still identifiable and retain most of their individual qualities. Depending on the specific use of agglomerates,the typical advantages listed in Tab. 5.10 may have different importance. For example, in waste treatment, recycling, or pollution control, the low content of dust and, respectively,reduced dustiness are generally important, also to prevent secondary pollution. Flowability, on the other hand, often has little priority in these applications. The same is true for improved metering and dosing capabilities as well as for defined shape and weight. Quite significant are, however, improved handling and storage characteristics,often due to increased bulk density and lower bulk volume. Co-agglomerated materials, from mixtures containing many different components with often considerable differences in characteristics and amount, do not segregate. This plays a role in the pharmaceutical industry where the active drug component and various excipients are co-agglomerated to form a free flowing, dust free, non segregating feed material for high speed tabletting presses. It is also important when hazardous materials are incorporated into concrete blocks. In such cases it is often also necessary that the hazardous components will not leach and that the binder does not age and disintegrate. If wastes become secondary raw materials, improved characteristics resulting in enhanced appeal and increased value are often desirable. These are just a few examples with many more in existence. In the next decades, particulate solids processing will focus on a shift away from just attaining size and distribution of products toward the more fundamental area of microstructure and morphology. The emphasis of new products and processes will be on better control of primary particle physical properties, highly specific product size and composition, as well as the creation of desirable characteristics. This will lead to an increased demand for “engineered particulate materials with high value that are produced in low tonnages. In the future, for many products special consideration will be on high value and special effects rather than “simple” bulk commodities. In general, the industry will have to cater increasingly to the needs of the end user. Agglomeration science and technology will play a vital role in the search for such novel, differentiated particulate products and the means for making them. A major requirement in these new areas is for a much greater degree of flexibility in regard to agglomerate structure and morphology. This will not only require a deeper understanding of the fundamentals of agglomeration but also an interdisciplinary effort of mechanical, chemical, and process engineers with physical chemists, colloid and biochemical scientists as well as other researchers in various industries. Among the many “engineered” products that exhibit specific properties after size enlargement by agglomeration are the following: 0
Easily soluble (“instant”)products Easily dispersible products Easily degradable products Highly absorbent, stable products Highly porous, stable products
I
103
104
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Products with controlled reactivity Controlled high reactivity - Precisely controlled reactivity - Reduced reactivity
-
This list is by no means exhaustive and new “engineered”,agglomerated materials with specific characteristics are being developed at an accelerating pace. Many of the new products are results of or influenced by advances in nano-technologies. Easily Soluble (“Instant”) Products The manufacturing of easily soluble, “instant” granules is one of the oldest and most thoroughly researched applications of “engineered” products. The term “instant” is normally used in the food industry and related fields, such as pharmaceuticals and animal feeds, to describe characteristics of drink powders (including coffee, tea milk, milk replacers, soft drinks, vitamins, medicated powders, etc.), soups, sauces and the like. Instant agglomerates are also desirable for pigments and other chemicals that are ultimately dissolved in a diluent. All instant products must quickly dissolve in a specified solvent or, more generally, in liquids of any kind and temperature (particularly also at ambient or even cold conditions) without residue or sediment. Each industry has a more or less well defined procedure to determine the maximum allowable time. Typically, complete dissolution should be accomplished within a few seconds in warm liquid and approx. 30-GO s in cold liquid. Special drink powders will have to meet the shorter times, even in cold liquids. Such instant granules may contain certain substances that assist in the breakup of the granules during the dispersion phase (see Section 5.1.2). Easily Dispersible Products Easily dispersible products are very similar to “instant” products. The only difference is in the fact that the primary particles are not soluble. Typical examples are pigments, carbon black, silica fume, etc. There are two different applications for easily dispersible agglomerated products: 1. Products that are dispersible in liquid phase. 2. Products that are dispersible in solid phase.
In addition, transitional applications exist which require that agglomerated products must be dispersible in wet bulk solids or slurries. ad 1) Dispersion in liquid phase must achieve complete separation of the primary particles to obtain statistically uniform mixing with other solid particles that are present in the liquid phase, or, if the particles are small enough, to produce a suspension. Suspensions should be stable indefinitely or for a long time and not form sediments. To further reduce the formation of a sediment, the viscosity of the liquid can be increased by incorporating so called stabilizers into the agglomerate which are liberated during dispersion and “thicken” the liquid. Such materials may be pregelatinized starch, pectines, alginates, and the like. Because the primary particles are not soluble, the break-up of agglomerates must occur only by a weakening or destruction of the binding mechan-
5.4 Other Characteristics of Agglomerates
ism(s). For that reason, it is much more common in dispersion that high shear forces are applied by liquid mixing techniques. The effect of shearing is often enhanced by a high viscosity of the liquid or the developing suspension. ad 2) Other easily dispersible agglomerated materials are manufactured to improve the storage, transportation, and metering characteristics of an intermediate product. During the mixing with bulk solids that are dry or contain various amounts of moisture (e.g. slurry) such agglomerates must disintegrate into the primary, finely divided or nano particles. In addition to considerable shear forces, mass related forces are created which help to overcome the binding mechanisms in the agglomerates. If moisture is present (for example during the production of concrete) the influence of liquid on the strength and survival of binding mechanisms should be also considered during product design. Easily Degradable Products Typical examples are carrier materials for fertilizers, insectizides, fungizides, and many other chemicals. In liquid phase the active substance is highly concentrated and, in most cases, toxic. By adsorbing these liquids on the mostly inner surface of granules that are manufactured from fine particles by agglomeration, the toxin is diluted and the products are rendered safe for handling and application. For example, spreading of granular agro-chemicals by conventional equipment is possible. Newer applications of the technology also include special micronutrients. Easily degradable carrier materials must feature a large accessible (inner) surface area, i.e. high porosity, and sufficient strength to withstand processing, storage, and handling. The binding mechanism must survive the impregnation process with the active substance. For example, if molecular or electric forces were used for dry agglomeration, it is possible that, after impregnation, the active substance replaces (e.g. by recrystallisation during a drying step) or enhances (e.g. by viscous liquid bonding and/or chemical reaction) the original binding mechanism. On the other hand, the granules must break down easily and quickly under the influence of moisture either from the soil or the atmosphere (rain or dew). Therefore, the product must easily wet and even small amounts of moisture should reduce the strength. Surfactants improve wetting and components that swell in the presence of moisture may assist breakdown. Sometimes, particularly in the case of fertilizers and micronutrients, interactions with bacteria participate in the breakdown. Highly Absorbent, Stable Products The basic requirements for these materials are the same as for the previous ones. However, as compared with “easily degradable” products, after absorbing liquids the granules must not disintegrate. For easy application and disposal, they should not be as hard and stable as the “highly porous, stable” carrier materials (see below). Typical examples are cat litter and absorbents for nuisance liquids (e.g. spilled oil).
Most absorbents are consumer products. For that reason, a new requirement is customer appeal. For absorbents this means that the material must be uniform, easily spreadable, and completely dust free with high abrasion resistance. In both areas
106
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
of main interest, cat litter and absorbents for spilled liquids, considerable research and development have been carried out in recent years to “engineer”the product for specific uses. One major requirement is particle size; an optimal size exists for perfect wetting. Another is particle shape. For cat litter and for some liquid absorbents spherical shape is undesirable. It has been found that cats tend to play with spherical particles, and round liquid absorbents scatter too widely during application thus, in both cases, causing widespread contamination. On the other hand, some absorbents are round to allow easier distribution into far corners and to produce a more uniform layer at the spill site. While, nowadays, cat litter is supposed to lump for easy removal of the used portion from the litter box, granules applied for the clean-up of liquid spills are supposed to remain separate for effective gathering with mechanical cleaning equipment. Although all absorbents must retain some strength and not convert to slush, mud, or slurry they must disintegrate when being stepped on to avoid accidents by slipping. Particularly cat litter must also absorb odors and/or provide a pleasent smell. Therefore, antibacterial and odor-suppressing substances or perfumes are added whereby it is more important that the smell pleases the cat than the human owner. Highly Porous, Stable Products Another group of agglomerated materials is used, for example, as carriers for catalysts. These products must feature high, easily accessible surface area before and after impregnation with the catalyst. In contrast to the “easily degradable” or “highly absorbent” products discussed above, these carrier materials must be permanently strong and stable. They should not break down during the chemical process which is often accompanied by harsh conditions, particularly high temperatures and aggressive chemicals. The primary particles forming the carrier itself need to be inert in respect to the chemicals used for impregnation and during reaction. In addition, the shape and structure of the carrier must be defined and uniform and the strength high to guarantee good permeability of the activated carrier (catalyst)bed. Little or no mechanical breakdown must occur due to the overburden pressure in the column. Products With Controlled Reactivity This group of agglomerated materials with adjustable, specific characteristics includes the widest range of choices. Products may have controlled high reactivity, for example explosives as well as specialty products, such as airbag chemicals, precisely predetermined reactivity, e.g. chemical oxygen generators and pyrotechnic components, or drastically reduced reactivity as, for instance, densified iron and titanium sponges (the products resulting from direct reduction of the oxides of these metals) or hazardous (including toxic and radioactive) wastes. In contrast to the previously discussed products, no common requirements can be defined for materials with controlled reactivity. Therefore, a few examples in the areas of:
Products with controlled high reactivity Products with precisely predetermined reactivity Products with drastically reduced reactivity will be discussed in the following.
5.4 Other Characteristics $Agglomerates
Products With Controlled High Reactivity High reactivity of particulate solids is connected with large specific surface area and, respectively, small primary particle size. Because reactions take place on the surface of solids, agglomerated products with high reactivity must feature voids which are interconnected with a continuous network of pores that is accessible from the outside. In this respect, their structure is similar to those that are easily wettable. The main difference is, that, in most cases, the chemicals reacting with the solid are gases. The most common reactions are oxidation and reduction. In the case of explosives or, for example, chemicals that activate airbags, large amounts of gas (products of combustion) are produced during a very fast reaction which, in addition, expand because of high system temperatures thereby creating the destructive forces or the pressure in an airbag. After activating a primary detonation, the chemical reaction of these explosives is a rapid decomposition by oxidation whereby the necessary oxygen may be part of the material itself or made available from oxygen-rich molecules such as chlorates. The effect of an explosive depends on its density, the energy produced during reaction, and the speed of reaction. Particularly if oxygen is made available from separate oxygen carriers in a mixture, it is necessary to provide good contact between the components. Product characteristics can be adjusted by modifying the degree of densification. At higher density the stored energy concentration increases but, because of lower surface area, the unassisted reactivity decreases. The reaction of such explosives must be initiated with primers. A primer is a highly reactive material that is easily ignited by friction, percussion, or electricity and will, in turn, set off a less reactive explosive. High reactivity is also desirable of other agglomerated products. One of the most important large scale application of size enlargement by agglomeration is the pelletization of iron oxides (see also Section 11.8).The technology was first developed for iron ores the concentration or purity of which are too low for economic processing in the blast furnace. Typical examples for such ores are the Taconites with large reserves in North America or the Itabirites. To make these ores economically useful, they must be upgraded. Prior to any of several concentration processes the ore must be ground to below separation fineness which is defined by the ore structure and the requirement that each particle contains only iron oxide or gangue. With the before mentioned ores this particle size is <45 Fm (<425 mesh). Such concentrates can not be fed to and reduced in the blast furnace. To overcome this problem, iron ore pelletizing was developed. Because the size range of the resulting pellets is very narrow, new important advantages in the blast furnace were obtained. One results from the more uniform bed structure which increases permeability and thereby process speed (production capacity). The other is due to the fact that, in comparison with the performance of dense, natural lump ore, the porous agglomerates, which consist of small primary particles, feature a significantly better reducibility. The latter is so important that, in the meantime, iron ores which do not need upgrading are also pelletized. In that case, the ore concentrate must be ground to the particle size that is required for tumble and growth agglomeration.
1
107
108
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Products With Precisely Predetermined Reactivity To this group belong, for example, pyrotechnic articles or components and chemical oxygen generators. These materials must feature precisely predetermined, reproducible, and often variable speed(s) of reaction. Pyrotechnic articles contain components that transmit ignition and produce light, sound, fire, and explosion effects such as coal, sulfur, milk sugar, resins, etc. as easily combustible materials, nitrates and chlorates as oxygen sources, and various chemicals for special effects. Among others, antimony sulfide and aluminum or magnesium powders emit white light while colored light is produced by sodium (yellow), strontium nitrate (red),barium nitrate (green),and caustic copper carbonate (blue); aluminum, magnesium, and iron filings exhibit sparks and mixtures of potassium nitrate and potassium picrate result in hissing sounds. In the pyrotechnic article these components are packed with materials that provide ignition, fire, explosion and, in the case of rockets, propulsion. The other product featured in this group is the chemical oxygen generator. These “oxygen candles”, which are, for example, installed in aircraft to provide each passenger with oxygen if an emergency arises, must produce a variable amount of oxygen during a period of time in which the plane descends to lower altitudes. The production of oxygen occurs during the thermal dissociation of chlorates and perchlorates. Therefore, the oxygen candle is an agglomerate containing chlorate, fuel, and catalyst and is ignited by a primer charge that is activated when the oxygen mask is pulled down. It is a requirement that immediately after decompression a large amount of oxygen is made available as it is assumed that the emergency begins at great altitude. Because it is assumed that the aircraft quickly descends to a denser atmosphere, during the “candle’s’’ 12 to 25 min of burning time, the production of oxygen can diminish. Products With Drastically Reduced Reactivity There are many products which, immediately after manufacturing, are highly reactive mainly because of their small particle size and/or large specific surface area. The greatest danger with such materials exists in potential self ignition and/or spontaneous combustion. Since many such reactions are exothermic, the reaction may accelerate and result in a catastrophic development of heat. In other cases, if, for example, water provides oxygen for the reaction, hydrogen is liberated which may produce explosive mixtures with air. In recent years an important development in the field of iron and steel production is the direct reduction of iron ore. In this technology iron oxide is reduced to virgin iron in the presence of suitable reductants (often C O and/or H,) and at elevated temperatures (but still in solid state). After the removal of oxygen a highly porous, sponge-like iron product remains that features a very high specific surface area. Depending on its microstructure, DRI (direct reduced iron) or “sponge iron” has a self ignition temperature in the order of 150 to 230°C [5.9, 5.101. Even at ambient temperaures a slow reoxidation occurs. With water as oxygen carrier, sponge iron reacts quickly thereby producing heat and hydrogen. Sea water, an electrolyte, accelerates this process. Because all reactions proceed exothermically and due to its structure, direct reduced iron is a heat insulator, in the core of a bulk mass (e.g. storage piles or ship holds) a catastrophic heating can occur that stops only if the source of oxygen (i.e. water and air) is
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
removed or replaced. Without passivation, fine sponge iron from fluidized bed reduction processes can not be stored and handled openly. To overcome this problem, the spongy structure is destroyed and the specific surface area, particularly on the exterior of the product, is reduced so that it becomes inert at all technically relevant transport, storage, and handling conditions. In other examples of this group, toxic, radioactive, or hazardous particulate solids of any size, from large pieces with dimensions of several centimeters to dusts and nanosized particles, are agglomerated to render them safe for disposal. In those cases it is necessary to produce an “agglomerate” which is stable for long periods of time, does not emit radiation or gaseous components and is not leached by liquids.
5.5
Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
Agglomeration is a natural phenomenon. Therefore, under certain conditions, it happens, whether it is desired or not [for specific ref. see B.561. Tab. 5.11 lists the operations of Mechanical Process Technologies (see Chapter 1, Fig. 1.1)and indicates if agglomeration is desired or undesired or, sometimes, both. During separation unwanted agglomeration may occur and must be avoided if a particle collective is to be divided into well defined classes. The separation curve is a measure for separation quality. In a diagram the degree of separation (the percentage amounts of particles above and below the desired separation size) is plotted versus the particle size. Fig. 5.54 is a qualitative presentation of several separation curves. Line (a) in Fig. 5.54 represents the ideal or perfect separation of a particle size distribution x,,,<x<x,, at cut size xtl which is possible only in theory. In industrial separation equipment, curves of the type (b)are obtained. The cut size is that particle Separation
100 I I
%
Ideal separation at xl, Technical separation at Ideal separation Technical separation; separation limit xln Technical separation with agglomeration separation limit X , ~ .
6-
.E 75 I
e
Fi v) L
50 g! 0)
0”
I
.
.
I
I
I I
Fig. 5.54 Examples o f separation curves.
I
109
110
I
5 Agglomeration Theories Tab. 5.11 The occurrence of undesired and desired agglomeration
in mechanical and related process technologies. Unit Operation
Process
Agglomeration Undesirable
Separation
Mixing
Comminution Particle size enlargement
Conveying
Storage Batching, metering Drying
Screening, sieving Classifying, sorting Flotation Dust precipitation Clarification, thickening Particle size analysis Dry mixing Wet mixing Stirring Suspending, dispersing Fluidized bed Dry grinding Wet grinding Agglomeration Briquetting Granulating Pelletizing Pelleting Sintering Tabletting Mechanical conveying Vibratory conveying Pneumatic conveying Silos, hoppers, stockpiles
Desirable
+ + + +
+ + +
+ +
++ ++ ++
-
+ + + + + +
++ ++ ++ ++
(+I (+I -
Explanations: (+) sometimes yes, + yes, ++ decisively yes, (-) sometimes no, - no, - - decisively no
size of which half end up in the coarse fraction and half in the fine. The sharpness of separation increases with the slope of the curve. If the abscissa uses a logarithmic scale, separation curves representing similar separation efficiencies at different cut sizes are parallel to each other. The influence of agglomeration must be judged differently. If the separation task is to remove all particles xmin<x<xm, from a fluid the desired cut size is xmin.Line (c) in Fig. 5.54 describes the ideal, only theoretically possible separation curve. In reality, a certain amount of smaller particles remains suspended in the fluid and the actual cut size is xt2>xmin(curve d). If agglomeration occurs, the finest particles may form larger entities or attach themselves to larger particles thereby changing the separation curve in Fig. 5.54 to (e).The new cut size xt2.is still somewhat larger than the desired xmin. where all particles would have been removed from the fluid, but agglomeration definitely helps to move the actual cut size closer to the ideal one. In general, as described above, whenever the task is to remove all particulate solids from a fluid, agglomeration will be advantageous. Since particularly the smallest, low
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
mass particles are, on one hand, the most difficult to remove and, on the other hand, feature the highest natural adhesion tendency, the chance agglomeration of these particles improves separation efficiency. As will be shown later (see Sections 7.4.5 and 7.4.6) techniques for enhancing the natural agglomeration tendency of very fine particles are often applied during gas and liquid cleaning. Even relatively loose conglomerates of particles behave according to their combined weight during, for example, settling and particularly in the centrifugal fields of cyclone separators. For all those separation cases, however, which attempt to separate a particle collective according to certain properties of the particulate solids, agglomeration is most often undesired. Techniques for which this statement is true include screening, sifting, classification, sorting, flotation, and, as a general analytical method, particle size characterization. It should also be realized that the respective separation property is not only size; it could be density, shape, color, chemical composition, and others. During screening, unwanted agglomeration is often facilitated by the motion of the material on the screen; spherical agglomerates are frequently formed from material containing fines or featuring other binding characteristics, for example if it is moist. Among others, binding mechanisms are: 0 0
0
For finely divided solids, molecular and electrical forces and/or adsorption layers, for plastics, electrostatic forces, for ores, magnetic forces, for moist powders, liquid bridges and capillary forces, for fibers, interlocking, and for materials with low melting points, partial melting and solidification.
In some substances several bonding mechanisms may occur simultaneously. In all cases, the result of screening is distorted because agglomerated fines are classified as coarse. The immediate and complete removal by dedusting or “scalping” of the finest fraction prior to screening into the desired property classes is one practical method to avoid selective agglomeration of the fines or adhesion of fines to larger particles. During screening itself, the effect of adhesion is reduced by mechanical destruction of agglomerates with, for example, rubber cubes or balls placed on or under the screen decks, the application of brushes, air jets, or ultrasound, or the modification of screen amplitude or, respectively, frequency (e.g. ultrasonic screen excitation). During the screening of moist bulk materials, difficulties increase with moisture content, but agglomeration tendencies are almost completely eliminated during wet screening when the particles are suspended in a liquid. Since, in moist screening, particles are often held in the mesh openings by liquid bridges, by direct resistance heating, inductive heating, or by modifying the wetting angle and/or the surface tension with surfactants the separation of such materials is facilitated and blinding of the screen is avoided. In air classijcation, products from, for example, dry fine grinding are separated. Particular problems arise if the material to be separated contains agglomerates that were formed during comminution. Conglomerates would be recirculated into the mill and “overgrinding” occurs. Therefore, attempts are made to destroy them by spe-
I
’11
112
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
cia1 feeder designs. Destructive forces are caused by, for example, sudden changes in speed or direction of flow and by installing air jet mills in front of the classifier. When classifying cement, it was determined that grinding aids, used during comminution to avoid agglomeration, also improve separation in the classifier. In the classifier itself, agglomerates are formed by molecular forces that may be reinforced by adsorption layers if separation is carried out with ambient air, by liquid bridges if moist materials are processed, and by electrostatic forces in a dry environment. As an example, Fig. 5.55 depicts separation curves of various air classifiers. With decreasing particle size, the amount found in the coarse fraction increases, which is due to agglomeration, whereby fine particles adhere to larger ones and conglomerates of fines behave as if they were coarser particles. Both effects reduce the separation efficiency and can be avoided only if the causes for adhesion are removed, that is, mostly by eliminating moisture in the material and humidity in the air. Sorting processes that separate materials according to particle characteristics other than size are often carried out in liquids. During flotation, one of the technologies, the relative capacity of light components to float is enhanced by the addition of chemicals which form bubbles that attach selectively to one component. Agglomeration can again reduce the separation efficiency when smaller particles of other components stick to larger ones of the floating type or to bubbles. By using modified chemicals, processing very dilute suspensions, or applying multiple separation steps efficiency can be improved. On the other hand, agglomeration can be also beneficial in dense media sink/ swim separation, centrifugal separation, or during jigging if particles of a particular ingredient can be made to selectively adhere to each other and form larger, heavier agglomerates. During particle size analysis, in addition to screening, sifting, and counting, sedimentation techniques are often used which produce unequivocal results only if the individual particles can move without influencing each other. For that reason, very dilute suspensions are used. Nevertheless, it is possible that agglomerates form or already
Particle size x Fig. 5.55
Separation curves of different air classifiers.
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
present conglomerates do not disperse completely. Therefore, dispersion aids are often added which reduce particle affinity (see also Section 7.4.6). The molecules of dispersion aids attach to the particles, eliminating polarities and/or reducing interfacial tensions. Separation forces, such as ultrasonic vibrations, can be also introduced for improved desagglomeration and dispersion. In connection with particle size analysis, the importance of correct sample preparation must be stressed. Because natural, unintentionally formed agglomerates always incorporate a larger than average number of the finest particles, the result of particle size analysis will be incorrect if preexisting agglomerates are not destroyed or conditions prevail during testing that promote agglomeration. Mixing Many of the previously mentioned considerations apply to the formation and prevention of undesired agglomerates during mixing. Little needs to be added concerning mixing in liquids by stirring or methods for the production of suspensions and dispersions. The addition of dispersion agents is always recommended if the tendency of the solid particles to agglomerate is high. Agglomerates or flocs that are already intentionally, for example to improve handling characteristics of fine powders, or unintentionally present prior to mixing can be destroyed by shear forces in the liquid. Consequently, the generation of the highest possible shear gradient is often considered advantageous when selecting agitators. During extended storage, the particles in (pharmaceutical) suspensions often form agglomerates that can be no longer destroyed by shaking the preparation. This is of particular concern in, for example, eye drops. The problem can be avoided by controlled flocculation of the solids. After the addition of an electrolyte,the fine particles aggregate to loose flocs that can be easily redispersed by shaking the dispenser prior to application. When mixing dry or moist bulk solids, agglomerates may form which originate from the finest components of the mixture. They are held together by molecular and electrostatic as well as capillary forces. These undesired agglomerates should be broken up by shear or frictional stresses, generated by the motion of the bulk mass, or by special disintegration devices that are built into the blender (see Section 7.4.2). Comminution Duringfinegrindingin roller crushers and tube mills containing grind-
ing media, with all materials certain problems begin to develop at a certain fineness of the solids to be milled. Two types of phenomena can be distinguished. In the first case, the finest particles start to adhere to walls and the grinding media in the mill. On this first coating,even coarser particles find excellent conditions for adhesion and massive deposits form rapidly. Experiments, during which the particle size distribution across thick layers of build-up were investigated, showed that the finest particles are indeed found in the lowest layers. Fig. 5.5G is the photograph of clean grinding balls and of those which, after a short period of operation, are already covered with a light primary deposit upon which additional layers will build during extended grinding. Fig. 5.57 are the photographs of the interior side of a manhole cover of a ball mill before and after use illustrating the extent of such deposits. These layers adhering to the inside walls and the grinding media produce a cushioning effect which lowers the intensity of stressing and, therefore, increase the duration of grinding and decrease efficiency.
I
113
114
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Fig. 5.56
Grinding balls before (right) and after (left) brief milling.
The second phenomenon during dry fine grinding is the occurrence of agglomerates in the freely moving charge itself. Formation of such agglomerates is associated with the so called limit of grinding. For each material a fineness exists at which, in spite of continued consumption of energy, the finest particles in the charge do not seem to become finer. Agglomeration and adhesion in mills can be attributed to various binding mechanisms (see Section 5.1.1). Since the mill housing may become highly charged by the friction between its contents and the walls, electrostatic forces are often the cause for initial build-up. This effect can be eliminated quite easily by grounding the mill. In
Fig. 5.57 Manhole cover o f a ball mill before (top) and after (bottom) grinding.
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
other cases, wall deposits will begin with particles of the size that generally corresponds to that of the wall roughness. The strength of the layer depends on the contact pressure which is magnified by the mill charge consisting of grinding media and material to be crushed. Adhesion is largely affected by molecular forces; however, partial melting and sintering are also possible. Agglomerates are formed in the freely moving charge of a tube mill by the compaction of fine particles between the grinding media and by recombination bonding (see also Section 5.1.1). Adhesion is affected by van-der-Waals forces between the particles that have been compressed very tightly and by the recombination of free valence forces at newly created surfaces. Since these agglomerates are very strong, a grinding equilibrium exists which has been observed and described by many. It means, that in fine grinding, after a certain time, a state of equilibrium between size reduction and size enlargement by agglomeration occurs. From that point on, agglomerates are formed, crushed, and re-formed so that the apparent particle size does not change. However, since destruction of particles continues to occur, a growing amorphization of the material can be observed which also results in increasing specific surface area and is often called mechanical activation as, in many cases, higher reactivity is obtained. Every form of agglomeration during size reduction reduces the efficiency of grinding and the fineness obtained at the limit of grinding is often insufficient for many tasks, even though the agglomerates actually contain much smaller particles. Therefore, it is desirable to prevent or, at least, reduce these effects. In milling, one possibility to achieve less unwanted agglomeration is to add surface-active substances, so called surfactants or grinding aids. It has long been known that small amounts of such additives may reduce the grinding time required to reach a particular fineness by 2030 %. Molecules ofthese substances, which are present in a gas or vapor phase, quickly saturate free valences at the newly created surfaces and avoid recombination bonding. The effect of some of these grinding aids on the fineness of cement after a specific grinding time is depicted in Fig. 5.58. It can be seen that with the exception of soot, the desired effect is produced only if the amount used is very small. At higher concentrations the agglomeration tendency increases due to the formation of adsorption layers and liquid bridges. In the case of soot a greater quantity is required because it is a solid which, as compared with molecules in the form of gas or vapor, is not very mobile. As a rule, grinding aids also reduce caking. Fig. 5.59 demonstrates the effect of 0.1 % sodium stearate during the grinding of cement clinker. Other surface-active substances can delay build-up for longer periods or prevent them entirely up to a certain fineness (for cement clinker 0.1 % triethanol-amine, for example, Fig. 5.60). Fig. 5.59 also shows that the specific surface, which is a measure of the fineness of cement, increases when 0.1 % sodium stearate is added and the build-up consists of finer particles.
I
115
116
I
5 Agglomeration Theon'es 3500
cm2/g
3000
'5v1
2500
0
5
0
2
0
2000
1500
1000
.
e a: 0 b: @ c: 8 d: 0 e:
Acetone Sodium stearate Water Naphthenic acids
0.5 .. Addition of auxiliary grinding agent
I O. h_ 1
Fig. 5.58 Effect of some "grinding aids" on the fineness o f cement after grinding clinker for the same time in a rod mill.
The formation of lamellar flakes or flat agglomerates in tube mills has been attributed to compaction between the grinding media during impact. The same mechanism occurs in all comminution processes in which the material to be crushed is subjected to stresses between two surfaces, for example in roller mills. Since the second condition
Fig. 5.59 Specific surface o f the build-up (= accretion) and o f the free charge as well as amount o f the build-up (= accretion quantity) with and without the use o f a grinding aid during size reduction o f cement clinker in a rod mill.
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration YO
100
-2
.-b C
80
W
a
F
2060 0
.-E
40
-2. E
IL20 Fig. 5.60 Changes in the amount o f freely moving charge during the grinding o f cement in a laboratory ball mill with and without the addition of triethanolamine.
Limestone
s = 122, 'l?!m
or
I
/
;
2
4
6
8
1
/
5'
' '
'rO1m
'
Cement clinker
x=96Opm
s = 12?, 5pm
pm
Aw9,5
A 4
X
De ree of re uktion
B
--
0
Grinding duration
-As I--~
A = -X S
-
Fig. 5.61 Agglomerates produced during the grinding o f limestone and cement clinker in a roller mill with a high reduction ratio.
1
I
117
118
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
for the formation of agglomerates is a sufficient fineness of the particles that are involved, the occurrence of strong, flat flakes is mostly observed during fine grinding. One measure for the fineness, the intensity of stressing, and the unintentional formation of agglomerates is the so called reduction ratio, that is, the quotient of maximum feed particle size and gap between the rollers. Fig. 5.61 depicts typical agglomerates produced in a roller mill with a high reduction ratio. Since the fine material is immediately compacted, almost all free valences at the newly created surfaces participate in recombination bonding. Consequently, the formation of agglomerates in roller mills can be only avoided if a smaller reduction ratio is chosen or by applying friction between the rollers. More recently it was found that, as compared with the stochastic crushing process in a tube mill with grinding media, the combination of the well defined stressing in a high pressure roller mill with large reduction ratio and the ensueing desagglomeration of the conglomerated flakes that were produced in the mill result in a significantly lower overall energy consumption during fine grinding of brittle materials, such as cement clinker and many ores; in those cases the unintentional and unavoidable agglomeration of the fine particles is not only tolerable but also results in a more economical fine grinding method. Agglomerates can be also formed during impact grinding. Fig. 5.62a shows schematically the fracture lines that develop during impact stressing of a glass sphere. A cone of fine material is created at the impact point and is compacted by the pressure resulting from the kinetic energy of the system into an agglomerated mass (Fig. 5.62b and c). Here too, the effect of free valence forces on newly created surfaces is used to its almost complete extent, yielding a quite strong agglomerate. It is very difficult to avoid this type of agglomeration; it can be affected only by reducing the impact velocity
a: Restkegel b: Seilenspliffer c: Feingutkegel
Fig. 5.62 (a) Schematic representation of the fracture lines caused in a glass sphere by impact stressing. (b) Agglomerated cone o f fines created during the impact stressing of a glass sphere (sphere dia.: 8 mm, impact velocity approx. 150 m/s). (c) Agglomerated cone of fines created during impact stressing of a sugar crystal (shown on the left).
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
which, in turn, results in a lower degree of comminution. For glass spheres, for example, the formation of agglomerates was observed only at impact speeds exceeding 80 m/s. During the impact crushing of thermoplastic materials or inorganic substances with low melting points, solidified bridges of partially melted material may further increase adhesion and the strength of agglomerated fines. Since the rise in temperature depends on the energy input and is constant for a given impact velocity, cryogenic milling, whereby the particles to be crushed are cooled prior to feeding into the mill, not only results in an increased brittleness but may also avoid partial melting and unwanted agglomeration. In wet grinding, as a rule, agglomeration is avoided by suspending the particles in liquid. Sometimes, the product of dry fine grinding is subjected to a brief final wet grinding to destroy the previously formed agglomerates. Nevertheless, some materials also tend to flocculate in wet grinding. Since the adhesion forces causing flocs are mostly electrical in nature, the addition of a small amount of electrolyte to the suspending liquid nearly always suffices to prevent flocculation. Agglomeration By definition, the unit operation size enlargement by agglomeration
makes use of all binding mechanisms and often enhances them in suitable environments and equipment. All agglomerates that are produced are made intentionally and are desired. Nevertheless, there are instances where adhesion and agglomeration are unwanted and undesired. Because, particularly in tumble/growth agglomeration, binders are added, the effect of these binders is still present on the surface of green agglomerates and during post-treatment new binding mechanisms between the agglomerates may develop which result in the formation of clusters of agglomerates. Of course, because agglomerates are larger bodies and only a few interaction points ( = coordination points) are present in a unit volume, even relatively strong solid bridges which may have developed by recrystallisation, chemical reaction, or sintering during post-treatment can be broken relatively easily. Nevertheless, such clusters could be detrimental during storage, feeding, or metering and, therefore, should be avoided or broken up prior to a following process step. More information on potential problems is given in the subchapter on Storage below. Transportation During the conveying ojparticulate solids, especially of finely dispersed powders, the unintentional formation of agglomerates and (sometimes thick) coatings on walls is often observed. Whereas agglomerates occur mostly on vibrating or shaking conveyors and inclined conveyors or chutes, wall build-up is more common in pneumatic conveyors. The main causes of agglomeration during the conveying of fine particulate solids are molecular and electric forces as well as binding mechanisms related to moisture and, as a result of mechanical or thermal energy input, binding mechanisms such as partial melting and solidification can be activated, too. Although it is very difficult to avoid agglomeration on vibrating or shaking conveyors, several possibilities exist for the prevention of wall build-up and deposits during pneumatic transport. Since the adhesion of the finest particles always begins in the roughness depres-
I
119
120
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
sions, one of the most important conditions to avoid a common reason for initial build-up is to provide smooth inner wall surfaces of pneumatic conveying lines. Because high drag forces tend to remove particles that have already adhered to the walls, high transport velocities also reduce the danger of build-up. Deposits preferably start in dead or calm flow zones; therefore, when designing such systems, low speed areas must be avoided. On the other hand, sudden changes in the direction of flow will cause high energy impacts of particles with the wall, causing build-up. Friction between particulate solids and pneumatic conveyor walls may result in high electrostatic charges on both partners. They depend to a large extent on whether the particles and/or the walls are electrically conductive and the lines are grounded or not. System design must take these conditions into consideration. To further explain some of the phenomena that occur during pneumatic conveying, the results of some pilot investigations will be summarized and presented in the following. Pneumatic transportation tests were carried out in a 58.51 m long horizontal pipe with a diameter of 0.7 m. The pressure within the system was determined at seven locations which were distributed along the measured length of the pipe. Ap = p1- p7 is the total pressure drop in the conveying system. In Fig. 5.63 the pressures at three different location are plotted over time. Since the fan located behind the dust collector at the end of the conveyor generates a slight negative pressure in the filter housing this also can be measured in the pipe as long as it is clean. After a few seconds, however, pressure p1 rises and the other locations follow after a short delay. Part of the pressure increase is caused by loading the air with particles, but a major portion is due to the build-up of deposits in the pipe. If the pipe was inspected after runs of 20 s and 50 s, respectively, no deposit was found after the short duration but after the longer run deposits had build up in the feed end portion while the part closer to the end still remained clean.
Tube diameter: D = 0.7m "ip= 1440kg/hr mplrnf= 40
I
hrf=36kg/hr
..
U=2.11m/s
Time t [sec]
Fig. 5.63 Pressure changes at three locations o f a pilot pneumatic conveying system during the first 150 s of a test run.
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
Fig. 5.64 Pressure drop along the measured pipe length o f a pilot pneumatic conveying system a s a function of time.
Fig. 5.64 depicts the total pressure drop between both ends of the pipe. The lower diagram represents results of the same test as shown in Fig. 5.63. After about 2.5 min, the system is in equilibrium and the total pressure drop in the systems remains almost constant. This indicates that, at least macroscopically, no further build-up takes place after this time. The upper diagram in Fig. 5.64 represents a different behavior. The total pressure drop increases more slowly. This is mostly due to a lower solids/fluid ratio and a higher transport velocity than used during the experiment depicted in the lower part of Fig. 5.64. In rather regular time intervals, however, a high pressure peak developed which was first measured at the feed end and propagated quickly to the discharge end. This behavior, together with some other observations, indicated that deposits fall off and are pushed along the pipe, thus momentarily increasing the pressure drop. If the system is opened immediately after such a pressure wave, the inner walls are found almost completely clean.
I ’*’
122
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
At high conveying velocities or in vertical pipes, deposits build up uniformly and, in the following, shall be called “crusts”. In horizontal pipes, bonds between particles and the wall are stressed by the weight of the build-up in the upper part while they are strengthened in the lower part by the gravitational forces. Therefore, especially during conveying at low velocities and high solidslfluid ratios, a second type of build-up is observed in horizontal pipes that shall be called “massy” deposits. The lower part of Fig. 5.65 describes schematically the different types ofbuild-ups in horizontal pneumatic transport pipes. They are affected by gravity, grow in the direction of mass flow, and are composed of finer particles because these particles exhibit a higher adhesion tendency and a “sieving” or classification effect takes place in the charge by which finer components move to the bottom layer of the moving mass. The upper part of Fig. 5.65 is a photograph taken during a model experiment. With exception of the formation of a crust, all other stages, including a “dune” of freely mobile particles moving over the deposits, can be distinguished. Fig. 5.66 is the view into a pipe after pneumatically conveying a slightly moist, finely divided quartz powder showing the heavy build-up in crust and massy deposit as well as the remainder of a dune. Massy deposits can be also formed by the action of other influences, such as centrifugal and inertial forces at elbows. Another important agglomeration phenomenon is that deposits may be shaped such that they yield a more effective flow channel. This can be explained by the fact that separation and drag forces influence adhesion. Particles preferably build up in zones without flow or where the direction of flow is changed by, for example, eddies. A typical example is shown in Fig. 5.67. On the bottom the partial cross section of a Moller pump is presented. Such pumps are used for feeding powders into a pneumatic conveying system. Powder and air enter a mixing chamber through a screw and a nozzle, respectively, and are then forced into the piping. The photograph in the upper part of
Growing “massy“
deposits
\
‘&.sy’ deposit
Crust
Fig. 5.65 Sketch and photograph o f a model experiment explaining the different types of build-up in a horizontal pneumatic conveying Pipe
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
Fig. 5.66 View into the pipe of a horizontal pneumatic conveyor after conveying a slightly moist, finely divided quartz powder at low velocity.
Fig. 5.67 is a view (in direction A-A) of such a mixing chamber which was opened after conveying fine zinc oxide. Opposite the nozzle a deposit in a Venturi-like shape has built up which defines the most effective flow channel at this point. Similar deposits can be found along the line in pneumatic systems that were not optimally designed and/or arranged. Storage Adhesion phenomena are involved in, for example, the bridging ofparticulate
solids in hoppers. In the case of relatively coarse materials, bridge formation is caused by dome-like structures which are supported on the inclined walls in the lower conical part of bins. With decreasing particle size, the participation of true adhesion forces in bridging and agglomeration increases. Binding mechanisms are molecular forces and adsorption layers or liquid bridges. The latter often play an important role whereby liquid bridges form by capillary condensation at the coordination points. For example, feeding warm and moist material into silos must be avoided, even if its moisture content is very low. Evaporating moisture condenses on the cooler silo walls and drips into the charge forming wet agglomerates and causes strong capillary adhesion bonding of particles on the walls. Insulation of the silos and/or forced large volume venting can be employed to avoid condensation and agglomeration problems. Bridging can totally block the discharge from silos, thus causing severe operating problems. Because adhesion even of finely dispersed DRY solids can not be avoided, agglomerates and bridges must be destroyed by special devices. For this purpose, inflatable cushions are mounted to the inside walls of silos or the material is momentarily fluidized by the (pulsed) injection of air jets. In the case or coarser solids, which tend to form domes, it is often sufficient to select a cone with steeper sides (= “mass flow” design). Small remaining flow problems due to adhesion can be overcome by installing vibrators or “hammers” on the outside silo walls. Unwanted agglomeration is often observed if the particulate materials are soluble or if chemical reactions can occur, particularly in the presence of moisture. These phenomena are very common in the fertilizer industry and are called caking if they occur in bulk masses or bag-set if material solidifies in bags. Caking of fertilizers and of other soluble materials has long been and still is a great problem. To get an idea about its importance and scale, three examples shall be pre-
I
123
124
I
5 Agglomeration Theories
Moller pumL) (schematically) Mixture solids/air -
Fig. 5.67 Photograph and sketch of a "Moller pump". The photograph shows Venturi-like deposits after conveying finely divided zinc oxide.
5.5 Undesired and Desired Agglomeration
Fig. 5.68
Manually unloading a shiplead of caked sylvite