Wolfgang Pietsch Agglomeration in Industry Occurrence and Applications
Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Cop...
82 downloads
1886 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Wolfgang Pietsch Agglomeration in Industry Occurrence and Applications
Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
Also of Interest: Pietsch, W.
Smulders, E.
Agglomeration Processes
Laundry Detergents
2002
2002
ISBN 3-527-30369-3
ISBN 3-527-30520-3
Kaye, B. H.
Smith, H. M. (Ed.)
Characterization of Powders and Aerosols
High Performance Pigments
1999
2002
ISBN 3-527-28853-8
ISBN 3-527-30204-2
Zlokarnik, M.
Albrecht, W., Fuchs, H., Kittelmann, W. (Eds.)
Scale-up in Chemical Engineering 2002
Nonwoven Fabrics 2003
ISBN 3-527-30406-1 ISBN 3-527-30266-2
Ko¨hler, M., Fritzsche, W.
Nanotechnology 2004
ISBN 3-527-30750-8
Wolfgang Pietsch
Agglomeration in Industry Occurrence and Applications
Dr.-Ing. Wolfgang Pietsch, EUR ING COMPACTCONSULT, INC. 2614 N. Tamiami Trail, #520 Naples, Florida 34103-4409 USA In Europe: Holzweg 127 67098 Bad Du¨rkheim Germany
All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully produced. Nevertheless, author and publisher do not warrant the information contained in these books, including this book, to be free of errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or other items may inadvertently be inaccurate. Library of Congress Card No. applied for. British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication Data: A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Bibliothek Die Deutsche Bibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data is available in the Internet at . ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim All rights reserved (including those of translation into other languages). No part of this book may be reproduced in any form – by photoprinting, microfilm, or any other means – nor transmitted or translated into a machine language without written permission from the publishers. Registered names, trademarks, etc. used in this book, even when not specifically marked as such, are not to be considered unprotected by law. Printed in the Federal Republic of Germany Printed on acid-free paper Typesetting Mitterweger & Partner, Kommunikationsgesellschaft mbH, Plankstadt Printing Strauss GmbH, Mo¨rlenbach Bookbinding Litges & Dopf Buchbinderei GmbH, Heppenheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
V
Contents Preface IX Volume 1 1
Introduction
2
Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science 3
1
3
Agglomeration Fundamentals
3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7
Structure and Bonding 7 Binding Mechanisms 11 Particle Size of the Particulate Solid Binders and Additives 14 Strength 15 Determination of Strength 18 Porosity 21
7
14
4
Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
Separation 23 Mixing 27 Comminution 27 Agglomeration 30 Transportation 30 Storage 31
23
5
Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4
Tumble or Growth Agglomeration 38 Pressure Agglomeration 47 Agglomeration by Heat/Sintering 53 Technologies Using the Phenomena and Fundamentals of Agglomeration for Purposes other than Size Enlargement 54
Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
37
VI
Contents
6
Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
6.1
General Applications
6.1.1 6.1.2 6.1.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 77 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 83
61 80
6.2
Pharmaceutical Applications
6.2.1 6.2.2 6.2.3
Tumble/Growth Agglomeration Technologies Pressure Agglomeration Technologies 114 Other Technologies 147
85
6.3
Applications in the Chemical Industry
6.3.1 6.3.2 6.3.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 169 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 202
90
167
6.4
Applications in the Food Industry
6.4.1 6.4.2 6.4.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 215 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 244
181
206
6.5
Applications for Animal Feeds
6.5.1 6.5.2 6.5.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 248 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 266
229
247
6.6
Fertilizers and Agrochemicals
6.6.1 6.6.2 6.6.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 270 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 297
252
266
6.7
Building Materials and Ceramics
6.7.1 6.7.2 6.7.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 304 Pressure Agglomeration Techniques Other Technologies 333
281
303 313
6.8
Applications in the Mining Industry (Minerals and Ores)
6.8.1 6.8.2 6.8.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 349 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 381
374
6.9
Applications in the Metallurgical Industry 385
6.9.1 6.9.2 6.9.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 386 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 412
386
347
59
Contents
6.10
Applications for Solid Fuels
6.10.1 6.10.2 6.10.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 417 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies Other Technologies 455
415
6.11
Special Applications
6.11.1 6.11.2 6.11.3
Tumble/Growth Technologies 459 Pressure Agglomeration Techniques Other Technologies 469 Indexes
419
459 464
I1
List of Vendors I 1 Subject Index I 53 List of Figures I 80 List of Tables I 103 Volume 2 7
Powder Metallurgy
479
8
Applications in Environmental Control
8.1 8.1.1
Collection, Stabilization, and Deposition of Particulate Solids 489 Size Enlargement by Agglomeration during the Collection of Particulate Solids 489 Size Enlargement by Agglomeration for the Stabilization and Disposal of Particulate Solid Wastes 499 Recycling/Secondary Raw Materials 502 Historical Review of Waste Production 502 Agglomeration Technologies for the Size Enlargement of Wastes 504 Applications in the Mineral, Metallurgical, and Energy Related Industries 505 Applications in Regional and Municipal Material Recycling Plants 518 Other Applications 533 Recycling of Polymers 537
8.1.2 8.2 8.2.1 8.2.2 8.2.3 8.2.4 8.2.5 8.2.6
485
9
Development of Industrial Applications
9.1 9.2 9.3
Test Facilities 545 Tolling Operations: Contract Manufacturing Scale-Up 573
541 566
10
Optimization and Troubleshooting of Agglomeration Systems
10.1 10.1.1 10.1.2 10.1.3 10.1.4
Tumble/Growth Technologies 596 Particle Size 597 Particle Size Distribution 597 Particle Shape 599 Chemical and Physical Surface Properties
601
589
VII
VIII
Contents
10.1.5 10.1.6 10.1.7 10.1.8 10.2 10.2.1 10.2.2 10.3
Binder Interaction 601 Equipment Type and/or Size 601 Optimization 602 Troubleshooting 604 Pressure Agglomeration Technologies 616 Low- and Medium-Pressure Methods 618 High-Pressure Agglomeration Methods 621 Other Technologies 630
11
Applications of Agglomeration Phenomena for Single Particles and in Nanotechnologies 633
11.1
11.2 11.3
Occurrence and Applications of Agglomeration Phenomena for the Attachment and Bonding of Single Particles to Surfaces and Substrates 639 Some Examples of Nanoparticles with Special Characteristics 642 Applications of Agglomeration in Nanotechnologies 644
12
Outlook
655
13
Bibliography
13.1 13.2 13.3
List of Books or Major Chapters on Agglomeration and Related Subjects 662 References 669 Author’s Biography, Patents, and Publications 676
14
Glossary of Application-Related Terms Associated with Agglomeration
661
15
Indexes
15.1 15.2 15.3 15.4
List of Vendors 721 Subject Index 773 List of Figures 800 List of Tables 823
721
693
IX
Preface When this book was first planned, the idea was to combine in one volume concise descriptions of agglomeration phenomena, technologies, equipment, and systems as well as a compilation of the applications of agglomeration techniques in industry. The latter was intended to demonstrate the widespread natural, mostly undesired occurrences of the phenomena and possible ways of avoiding them as well as the old, conventional, and new, varied beneficial uses of the technologies. However, it soon became obvious that, in its entirety, this project was too extensive and required much more time than anticipated. Therefore, it was decided to split the subject into two complementary books. The first book, Agglomeration Processes – Phenomena, Technologies, Equipment (ISBN 3-527-30369-3) was published by Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany, in 2002. It covers the fundamental phenomena that define agglomeration and industrial technologies and equipment for size enlargement by agglomeration. Applications are mentioned in a general way throughout this text but without going into details. This second book is an up-to-date overview dealing with the occurrence and key applications of agglomeration, including size enlargement in pharmaceutical, food and animal feed, chemical, fertilizer and agrochemical, mineral, building material and ceramic, metal, solid fuel, and other industries. Furthermore, the book emphasizes recent developments at the level of single particles and applications of agglomeration phenomena in nanotechnologies. Many people, institutions, and companies have contributed to the two books. First and foremost, I wish to thank my wife Hannelore for her support and understanding, particularly during the years when I was compiling these books. They are both dedicated to her. Without my wife’s active participation in preparing almost all my publications, including the first textbook entitled Size Enlargement by Agglomeration, which is a major reference for the current two books, and her acceptance that I was not available for many hours almost every day during much of two decades, these publications could not have been completed. It is impossible to acknowledge all the help that was provided by a large number of individuals and companies. Chapter 15.1 is a list of vendors and other organizations, which mentions those who have, in one way or another, contributed as well as some others that might be of interest as potential contacts for the readers of these books. While I have decided not to clutter the text with references, sources have been acknowl-
X
Preface
edged if figures or tables were provided by or are based on input from particular companies. The Disclaimer at the beginning of this book should be referred to when using such information. Chapter 13 lists literature references. The earlier textbook, Size Enlargement by Agglomeration, contains treatments and many references relating to the developing science of the unit operation and covers the sizing of agglomeration equipment in some detail. Since the emphasis of the new books is on industrial applications, rather than theory, the earlier book should be referred to for the theoretical background. Information on the availability of reprinted copies of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration (Wiley, 1991) is available in Chapter 13.1 as a footnote. I have also contributed major chapters on agglomeration to two other books, portions of which are used in this book. The other books are: Handbook of Powder Science and Technology (Eds: M. E. Fayed, L. Otten), 1st edn, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York (1983) and 2nd edn, Chapman & Hall, New York (1997). Full references can be found in Chapter 13.1. Since size enlargement by agglomeration is one of the four unit operations of Mechanical Process Technology (see Chapters 1 and 2) and, for the design and construction of agglomeration systems and plants of any kind, many or all of the other unit operations are required together with the associated transport and storage technologies, often even in multiplicity, and the analytical methods are applied for process evaluation and control, the reader who is interested in the topic of this book should also learn about or have access to information on the other fields of Mechanical Process Technology (references in Chapter 13). Finally, I wish to thank the following individuals who, as professionals and experts in their own fields, are or have been colleagues and/or partners in several continuing education courses over many years in the USA and in Europe and have agreed that their presentations and course notes can be used directly, adopted, or modified for this book. They are, in alphabetical order: T. van Doorslaer, W. E. Engelleitner, B. J. Ennis, M. E. Fayed, M. Gursch, D. C. Hicks, S. Jagnow, R. H. Leaver, R. Lo¨be, K. Masters, S. Mortensen, H. B. Ries, F. V. Shaw, N. Stanley-Wood, J. Storm, R. Wicke, and the late R. Zisselmar. Other major contributors were M. Karel, Y. Kawashima, the late B. Kaye, and H. Schubert.
Wolfgang Pietsch, Naples, FL, USA, September 2004
1
1
Introduction This book is complementary to the author’s earlier books, Roll Pressing (1976/1987) [B.13b], Size Enlargement by Agglomeration (1991) [B.48], and Agglomeration Processes – Phenomena, Technologies, Equipment (2001) [B.97], as well as some major contributions to professional handbooks, such as Size Enlargement by Agglomeration (1997) [B. 71]. While Roll Pressing [B.13b] dealt exclusively with aspects of pressure agglomeration in roller presses, Size Enlargement by Agglomeration [B.48] covered the entire operation and some related fields from a fundamental view point. It described in much detail the newly evolving science of the natural phenomenon “Agglomeration”, which has been used by living creatures, including humans and modern mankind, for thousands of years, and the technologies that were derived from it. In contrast, Agglomeration Processes – Phenomena, Technologies, Equipment [B.97] was trying to offer a complete, up-todate compilation of the various agglomeration techniques and, in general terms only, their applications. To that end, in addition to introducing the properties of agglomerates and the specific characteristics of the different technologies, descriptions of equipment and their special features for particular uses as well as engineering know-how and information on specific peripheral equipment were the main topic of the book. Emphasis was on up-to-date practical knowledge, not theory. The present book again does not claim to be a scientific publication. Agglomeration, both as a phenomenon and as the beneficial size enlargement of particulate solids, has become part of the newly defined interdisciplinary technical field of Mechanical Process Engineering and a science in its own right, as described earlier [B.97], (Chapter 2). Nevertheless, much of the research and development are phenomenological in nature and most of the designs for equipment and industrial plant still rely heavily on the experience and know-how of vendors as well as experts in the field. Therefore, after again reviewing the fundamentals of agglomeration in an even more abbreviated form, this book attempts to summarize and describe the occurrence of agglomeration in industry, the industrial applications of size enlargement by agglomeration, and other beneficial uses of particle adhesion. The latter, in particular, is found increasingly in new fields such as nanotechnology, life sciences, and even the communication industry (nanoelectronics). Obviously, it is not possible to describe all the many occurrences of agglomeration and to cover every application of size enlargement by agglomeration in industry. ParAgglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
2
1 Introduction
ticularly during the past 50 years, because of an increase in the production of fine and ultra-fine primary, intermediate, and final solid materials as well as the collection of ever finer particulate wastes, circumstances of undesired build-up, lumping, and other troublesome aggregations have increased tremendously. During that same period of time, a better understanding of the agglomeration phenomenon has led to many beneficial applications of desired and controlled size enlargement to obtain an increasing number of benefits (Chapter 6, Tab. 6.1). Therefore, in planning the contents of this book, in spite of its growing importance, just one chapter was allocated to deal with the undesired occurrences of agglomeration and the most common methods to avoid or at least lessen its effect. For the presentation of desirable size enlargement processes in industry, the entire field was sub-divided into a number of segments. In each, the most important application(s) is (are) being presented in considerable detail as examples, describing the history, development, and present state of the technique(s). From this, knowledge and guidance may be gleaned for interdisciplinary use during the evaluation of similar applications in other industries and/or for different materials. In some areas, the author has decided to describe or indicate in varying detail some less well known, normally more partial methods for size enlargement by agglomeration. These were selected to broaden understanding of the possibilities for beneficially applying the phenomenon for obtaining specific product characteristics and may suggest the use of similar approaches for other cases.
3
2
Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science Agglomeration, the sticking together of particulate matter, is a natural phenomenon and is as old as the existence of solids. Originally, it happened during the development of soil, stone, and rock formations. Later, unwanted agglomeration occurred during handling and storage of particulate matter by humans, especially when hygroscopic and/or soluble materials (such as salt) set into lumps or large more-or-less solidified masses. In the animal world agglomeration was and is used to develop protective coatings, to build nests, and to provide a nourishing and protective environment for the offspring (e.g., by the legendary Scarabaeus Sacer, the dung beetle, Fig. 2.1, the mascot of this agglomeration expert). “Size enlargement by agglomeration” is the generic term for the operation in Mechanical Process Engineering that is characterized by the descriptions “combination with change in particle size” (Fig. 2.2). It is distinguished from the more general “size enlargement” such that particle growth occurring, for example, during crystallization
Fig. 2.1 Beetle, Scarabaeus Sacer, “pelletizing” dung and an artist’s impression of this animal’s procedure Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
4
2 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
Separation
Combination
Without Change in Particle Size
Mechanical Separation (Filters, Classifiers, Screens, Sifters)
Powder Mixing and Blending
With Change in Particle Size
Size Reduction (Crushing and Grinding)
Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Particle and Bulk Material Characterization (Size, Distribution Shape, Volume, Surface, Density, Mass, Porosity, Moisture Content, etc.)
Transport and Storage of Bulk Materials
Fig. 2.2 Operations of Mechanical Process Technology and associated techniques
or the production of particulate solids by melt solidification are not part of this operation [B.97]. Most probably, humans first used agglomeration during the making of bread. The technology of bread making combines all components of a complex agglomeration process including preparation of solid feed particles by milling (adjustment of particle size and activation of the inherent binder, starch), mixing of particulate solids with additional binder(s), forming the mass into a green agglomerate, and a post-treatment (curing = baking = heating and cooling) to provide strength and texture. Very early it was also found that the porosity and, thus, the ease and enjoyment of consumption of the final product could be modified (increased) by making use of gases that are produced during fermentation (initiated by sourdough or yeast) and result in bubbles in the green mass. These voids are stabilized by strengthening the bread during posttreatment (baking). For the construction of permanent shelter, humans may have observed the activities of animals that formed nests and protective “walls” from wet clay, which hardened during drying. By copying this behavior, wet clay, which was soon reinforced and made more water resistant by mixing-in straw or other fibrous material, was filled into a framework of wood branches and let harden during natural drying. To make building activities independent of the location of stone quarries, during prehistoric times bricks were already produced from clay and sand when rock was not easily available, thus allowing the development of villages and, during the 4th millennium BC in Mesopotamia, cities (e.g., Uruk) with large brick structures. By experience, humans learned that certain natural materials helped cure specific illnesses. Minerals as well as dried animal and plant matter were ground to powder and formulated to yield medicines. Since powders cannot be easily consumed orally, natural binders, such as honey which, incidentally, also masked the unpleasant taste of some of the medicinal components, were mixed with the powder and the resulting plastic mass was rolled by hand into little balls (pills). The sticky binder(s) caused pills to adhere to each other; therefore, it was soon found that coating the pills by rolling them in flour or pollen solved this problem.
2 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
These three well-known ancient agglomeration techniques were used with little change through the ages of human history. Many other, lesser known or more recent processes could be added and some will be mentioned later in the appropriate sections of this book. At this point, the short review and the examples relating to three major modern industries (food, building materials, and health products) were selected to show that humans always lived with and used agglomeration. As a result, technologies for the mechanical processing of solids were considered normal activities, which, with the beginning of industrialization in the 18th and 19th centuries, were merely mechanized by simulating what was done manually before. During these early modernization efforts it was not considered necessary to question the fundamentals of the processes and improvements were based on empirical developments. Until very recently, agglomeration technologies, as all the other unit operations and associated techniques of Mechanical Process Technology (Fig. 2.2), had been developed independently by the particular industries in which they were applied. Because the process requirements are very different in such unlike industries handling, for example, coal and ores on one hand or food and pharmaceuticals on the other, no interdisciplinary contact and exchange of information took place. In fact, although agglomeration techniques developed along similar lines, application related theories were defined, which were derived from investigations of specific requirements. Solutions of such work were not universally useable and the terminology was often incomprehensible to the agglomeration expert of another industry. Agglomeration as a science began when an effort was made to interdisciplinarily combine the extensive knowledge that had been accumulated during sometimes hundreds of years in specific fields of human activities. It was found that, in all the different environments, agglomeration methods follow the same fundamentals, apply the same rules, and use essentially the same equipment and systems if looked at from a basic interdisciplinary point of view. Although these facts become more and more known, there is still the understandable preconceived notion of, for example, somebody working in an ultra-clean environment, such as pharmaceutical, food, or electronic industries, that developments, expertise, and know-how gained in the dirty plants of, for example, minerals or metals production and processing, can not be considered as generally valid information and, therefore, may not be applied for the solution of a clean problem, and vice versa. In dirty industries, a typical concern is that the often much more deeply and completely investigated technologies that originate in clean industries can not be applied because the production capacities are too small, the process may be batch, the equipment too complex, the execution and the materials of construction too expensive and so on. However, as has been shown among other topics in the author’s previous book [B.97], methods for the selection of the most suitable agglomeration process for a specific application are the same for all projects. While some requirements, for example in regard to equipment or system capacity or on the shape, size, and special properties of the products, may already in the pre-selection phase result in the definition of cleaner or more heavy-duty, rugged processes, the normal approach is to determine the preferred method and/or technique by considering the fundamentals as well as an
5
6
2 Agglomeration as a Generic, Independent, and Interdisciplinary Field of Science
interdisciplinary pool of expertise and know-how first. Special conditions of the particular application, such as, for example, hot and dusty large volume processing, or the opposite, clean, small capacity operation with cGMP (current good manufacturing practice) and CIP (cleaning in place) capabilities, are special design criteria that can be added to most of the systems later during the engineering phase. Nevertheless, for manufacturing reasons and sometimes also because of special requirements on the company’s test facilities (Chapter 9.1), some vendors specialize in equipment for one or the other industry. This is a decision of convenience by the individual supplier and does not indicate the existence of a fundamentally different technology. In fact, techniques or apparatus that were developed for a specific industry can be adopted for use in areas with different environment and requirements while still maintaining the fundamental underlying principle as well as the general machinery and process. Examples are crushing with high pressure roller presses, flaking, instantizing, spheronizing, and agglomeration with spray dryers.
Further Reading
For further reading the following books are recommended: B.3, B.4, B.6, B.7, B.8, B.12, B.13a through e, B.15, B.16, B.17, B.19, B.21, B.22, B.24, B.26, B.35, B.36, B.40, B.41, B.48, B.49, B.51, B.52, B.55, B.56, B.58, B.63, B.66, B.67, B.68, B.70, B.72, B.73, B.82, B.83, B.89, B.93, B.94, B.97, B.99, B.106 (Chapter 13.1). Books mainly devoted to the subject matter are printed bold.
7
3
Agglomeration Fundamentals The major distinguishing characteristic of agglomeration is the formation of larger entities from particulate materials. The particles stick together by short-range physical forces between the solids themselves or through binders: substances that adhere chemically or physically to the surfaces and form a material bridge between the particles. The components of an agglomerate are often widely disparate and, except if matrix binders are applied or after shrinkage during sintering, voids between the particles forming an agglomerate are present in the product. As will be shown later (Chapter 11), an increasing number of occurrences of agglomeration relate to single, often nanosized particles, and new techniques make use of the adhesion of individual particles to substrates for the manufacturing of materials with unique properties. All apply the same agglomeration phenomena, fundamentals, relationships, and rules.
3.1
Structure and Bonding
Fig. 3.1 shows random sections through a part of an agglomerate; the structure is really three dimensional. In such a body, strength can arise in several ways. In Fig. 3.1a the entire pore space is filled with a matrix binder. Typical examples of agglomerates held together in this manner are concrete, where the matrix between the aggregate particles consists of hardened cement, or road surfaces, in which bitumen occupies the volume between crushed stone or other aggregate. Fig. 3.1b looks very similar to Fig. 3.1a but represents an agglomerate structure in which the entire void volume is filled with a liquid that wets the solid particles. If concave menisci form at the pore ends on the surface of the agglomerate a (negative) capillary pressure develops within the pores, which gives strength to the body. As explained in Fig. 3.2, depicting a series of situations representing different liquid saturations in particulate bulk solids or of agglomerates, distinct distribution models exist that depend on the amount of liquid in the structure. The term “liquid saturation” is defined as the percentage of total void space that is filled with the liquid. A precondition for cohesiveness of particulate solids due to the presence of liquid is that the liquid wets the solids. Although, depending on the application, other liquids may be used to Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
8
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
Fig. 3.1 Random sections through part of an agglomerate or a particulate bulk solid mass: a) pore volume filled with a matrix binder; b) pore volume filled with a wetting liquid; c) liquid bridges at the coordination points; d) adhesion forces at the coordination points
completely or partially fill the voids between the particles, in agglomeration water is used most commonly. Referring to Fig. 3.2, absolutely dry particulate bulk solids (Fig. 3.2a) are non-existent under normal atmospheric conditions. The water molecules of adsorption layers (Fig. 3.2b), which, under ambient atmospheric conditions, form quickly on solid surfaces, are bonded so strongly that they are not mobile, and, therefore, do not cause “liquid saturation” or moisture content that can be measured with “normal” laboratory equipment. However, adsorption layers can participate in the development of strength by enhancing molecular (van der Waals) forces [B.48, B.97]. With small amounts of “free” water (i.e., producing moisture contents of little more than a few tenth of a percent) and, correspondingly, very small “saturation”, liquid bridges begin to form at the contact points between particles. With increasing moisture content or saturation, liquid bridges become present at all coordination points (see below) in the structure (Fig. 3.1c and 3.2c). A further increase in liquid saturation produces a transitional situation in which liquid bridges and void spaces that are filled with liquid coexist (Fig. 3.2d). The theoretically highest saturation (100 %) is reached when all voids within a bulk mass or an agglomerate are filled (Fig. 3.1b) and concave menisci are formed at the pore ends (Fig. 3.2e). Beyond complete saturation, liquid droplets, shaped by the surface tension, may enclose solid particles (Fig. 3.2f). Slurries, defined as bulk particulate solids containing an excess of water, are shapeless. All the above
3.1 Structure and Bonding Fig. 3.2 Diagrams of different liquid saturations in particulate bulk solids or agglomerates: a) dry; b) adsorption layers; c) liquid bridges (“pendular” state); d) transitional (“funicular” state); e) fully saturated (“capillary” state); f) droplet
models exist in “wet agglomeration”, methods that are based on the processing of slurries, suspensions, solutions, or the presence of liquids as binders. Fig. 3.1d depicts the action of solid bridges or forces at the coordination points of a particle with all other particles surrounding it. Coordination points are points of contact with other particles and “near points”, areas of the particle surface that are so close to a neighboring particle surface that significant adhesion forces act or bridges can form. The coordination number is the average of the sum of all contact and near points of each particle with others surrounding it in a particular agglomerate structure. Typical examples of agglomerates bonded in this manner are “natural” aggregates of very fine particles that are held together by molecular forces, agglomerates with solid bridges at the coordination points that have formed during drying of originally wet agglomerates by recrystallizing dissolved materials, or products of pressure agglomeration in which the distance at the coordination points has been reduced by the effect of external forces.
9
10
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
Agglomerates are bodies that are, often artificially and with purpose, produced from individual “small” particles. The term “small” is to be understood in relation to the agglomerate. Although there are agglomerates, for example in the food industry (Section 6.4), or natural, often undesired agglomerates (Chapter 4), which consist of only a few particles, typical agglomerates contain very large numbers of particles with sizes that are orders of magnitude smaller than that of the agglomerate. Binding mechanisms (see below) cause these particles to temporarily or permanently stick together and form a lose or porous entity. Since binding mechanisms act in different ways, the structure of agglomerates is of great importance for all their properties. The sketch in Fig. 3.3 depicts a random section through an agglomerate. The area within the heavy solid lines is arbitrarily defined as “one”. Fig. 3.3 seems to show particles and their distribution. In reality, what is visible are cross sections through particles at a specific level. If another random section through the same agglomerate is made, a totally different image is obtained. Moreover, particles that seem to float in space are in contact with other particles at some level. For example, the shaded cross section may be the result of cutting the particle shown in elevation on the side of Fig. 3.3, at the indicated line. Obviously this particle will have a completely different outline at another level. The same observation is true for the void spaces (porosity) that are visible between the particle cross sections. If the heavily bordered square in Fig. 3.3 that represents the area “one”, is large enough and contains a great number of the two significant structural characteristics, i.e. outlines of cross sections through particles and of empty space (pores) between the particles, a statistical evaluation of any random section will produce generally valid results with an accuracy that can be described by the standard deviation that is associated with that statistical treatment. Therefore, for example, scanning the
Fig. 3.3
Sketch of a random section through an agglomerate
3.2 Binding Mechanisms
image of the section will produce information on particle size and distribution, porosity (e), solid content (1 – e), and, with the appropriate software, a shape factor and the specific surface area of the particles [B.75]. Accuracy can be increased by investigating multiple sections through the same agglomerate and determining the statistical average for all of them. A visual evaluation of the enlarged image of the section through an agglomerate also reveals certain other features, although the observations can only be used to explain phenomena and do not serve any scientific purpose. The circles in Fig. 3.3 indicate, for example, some of the contact points between particles in this particular cross section and the rectangular boxes depict some of the “near points” at which a binding mechanism, such as liquid bridges or one of the field forces (see below), could develop. The average of the sum of both types of interaction points for one particle defines the coordination number k. Taking into consideration the statements made above in regard to random sections, it is of course possible that “near points” in a particular section become actually contact points in a level slightly above or below and it is impossible to determine all the interaction points that are distributed three-dimensionally around a particle in such a cross section.
3.2
Binding Mechanisms
The binding mechanisms of agglomeration (Tab. 3.1) are divided into five major groups (Roman numerals) and several subgroups (Arabic numerals). They have been described and discussed in detail elsewhere [B.48, B.71, B.97]. Fig. 3.4 and 3.5 describe pictorially the binding mechanisms. It should be pointed out that only the two-dimensional situation at one coordination point between two particles or two solid surfaces is shown. In reality, each particle has many interaction sites (coordination points) with other particles in the three-dimensional structure. It should be further understood that in typical particulate bulk solids and agglomerates large numbers of particles that participate in bonding are present per unit volume. With the exception of capillary and matrix bonded structures of particulate solids (Fig. 3.1a and b), it is unlikely that only one binding mechanism acts on all the coordination points within a mass. If molecular and electric forces as well as liquid bridges and the solid bridges, resulting from the latter by one or the other of the mechanisms that were indicated above and discussed elsewhere [B.48, B.71, B.97], are considered, it must be also assumed that the effect of each binding mechanism is different at every coordination point because of varying microscopic surface structures and distances at each interaction point. If size enlargement by agglomeration is desired and the correct agglomeration technique is selected, many of the binding mechanisms described above are inherently available or can be activated. Under certain conditions, some binding mechanisms also act naturally to produce undesirable agglomeration phenomena (Chapter 4). Generally speaking, if agglomeration is wanted, means to enhance the available binding
11
12
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals Tab. 3.1
Binding mechanisms of agglomeration
I
Solid bridges, caused by 1 Sintering 2 Partial melting 3 Chemical reaction 4 Hardening binders 5 Recrystallization 6 Drying a Recrystallization (dissolved substances) b Deposition (colloidal particles)
II
Adhesion and cohesion forces 1 Highly viscous binders 2 Adsorption layers (< 3 nm thickness)
III Surface tension and capillary pressure 1 Liquid bridges 2 Capillary pressure IV Attraction forces between solids 1 Molecular forces a van-der-Waals forces b Free chemical bonds (valence forces) c Associations (non-valence); hydrogen bridges 2 Electric forces (electrostatic, electrical double layers, excess charges) 3 Magnetic forces V
Interlocking bonds
Fig. 3.4
Pictorial representation of the binding mechanisms of agglomeration
3.2 Binding Mechanisms Fig. 3.5 Attraction forces between solid surfaces or particles
mechanisms must be developed and applied, while the effect of binding mechanisms must be eliminated or reduced to avoid unwanted agglomeration. Adhesion of individual particles to each other or to solid surfaces is controlled by the competition between volume and surface related forces. To cause permanent adhesion, certain criteria must be fulfilled. The most important is that any system force (e.g., caused by gravity, inertia, drag, etc.) must be smaller than the attraction forces between the adhering partners According to Fig. 3.6, the ratio between the binding forces Bi(x) and the sum of the active components of all ambient forces Fjy(x) is a measure of the adhesion tendency Ta (Chapter 5 [B.48, B.97]).
13
14
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
Fig. 3.6
Diagram of the adhesion tendency of a spherical particle on a flat surface
3.3
Particle Size of the Particulate Solid
Both the attraction and the ambient forces are mainly dependent on the size x of the powder particle(s). While the surface area of individual particles, the interface at which all binding mechanisms act, decreases with the second power of particle size, volume and consequently also mass, the most important particle properties that result in forces that challenge adhesion and may cause separation of bonds, diminish with the third power of the particle size. Therefore, if the particle size reaches a few micrometers or is in the nanometer range, the natural adhesion forces dominate and particles that contact each other or come into close proximity adhere to one another. This phenomenon can not be economically eliminated, so very fine particles always adhere and form loose agglomerates, which may be desirable (Chapter 5) or undesirable (Chapter 4). Since all binding mechanisms rely on molecular interactions on and between surfaces or interfaces, the structure and distance at these points is of great importance for the ability of powders to agglomerate. Often, the presence of ultra fine particles facilitates size enlargement of coarser particulate matter. Fine particles that are suspended in a binder liquid accumulate during drying in liquid bridges at coordination points and eventually form solid bridges, which are bonded by molecular forces. Dry fine particles may fill areas with high surface energy, such as holes and depressions, thus reducing the effective distance between larger particles and increasing the attraction force (similar to the influence of adsorption layers, [B.48]).
3.4
Binders and Additives
Naturally available adhesion tendencies can be considerably increased if moisture is added during the agglomeration process. Application of external forces can contribute to the enhancement of inherently present binding mechanisms. Depending on the
3.5 Strength
magnitude and nature of these forces, improved structure (by shear and low-to-medium compression) or plastic deformation and brittle breakage (due to high external forces) can occur. Plasticity, an often-preferred response to external forces that results in high agglomerate strength (Chapter 5), increases in many solids if the temperature of the material rises. Therefore, hot densification is often a desirable agglomeration technology, particularly for metals, minerals, and metal-bearing materials. With other materials, featuring low softening or melting points or containing such components, mechanical energy, introduced by dynamic forces, compression, or shear and converted into thermal energy, activates the inherently available binding properties. Under this influence, momentary softening or melting can occur upon contact at minute roughness peaks which, after almost instantaneous solidification, produce a small solid bridge between the powder particles. Similar mechanisms are responsible for the bonding of soluble materials in the presence of moisture. There, mechanical energy converted into heat or the direct external supply of thermal energy result first in additional dissolution and then in recrystallization at the coordination points, even in airtight containers and without changing the moisture content. In both cases, the higher the number of coordination points in a unit volume (increasing with decreasing size of the agglomerate forming particles), the higher will be the strength of the resulting agglomerated part. In spite of the availability of these “natural” binding mechanisms and the various possibilities to enhance them for the desirable production of agglomerates, sometimes no economic method can be found to process a specific material and form a product with sufficient strength. Grinding the particulate solid to a sufficient fineness for strong molecular bonding and/or heating it to high enough temperatures that result in either sufficient dissolution for recrystallization, plasticity for large area contact and bonding, partial melting followed by solidification, or solid state sintering would be too expensive and, therefore, prohibit economic processing. In those cases where no bonding can be achieved by the above-mentioned measures, particle size is relatively large, or specific product characteristics must be obtained, binders, mostly for higher strength, lubricants, mostly for improved density and structure, and other additives that produce special properties, can or must be used [B.48, B.97].
3.5
Strength
The most important property of all agglomerates, desired or undesired, is their strength. To obtain a physically meaningful value of strength it was proposed to determine the tensile strength of agglomerates [B.12]. It is defined by the tensile force at failure divided by the cross section or, if the test body has no uniform shape, the area of the failure plane(s) of the agglomerate(s). Because in all stressing situations failure occurs with great probability under the influence of the highest tensile force, this proposal is justified. Moreover, tensile force and strength can be approximated by models and theoretical calculations.
15
16
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
All binding mechanisms of agglomeration (Tab. 3.1, and Fig. 3.4 and 3.5) can be described by one of three models. 1. The entire pore volume of the agglomerate is filled with a substance that can transmit forces and, thereby, causes strength (matrix binder, Fig. 3.1a). 2. The pore volume of the agglomerate is entirely filled with a liquid (Fig. 3.1b). 3. Binding forces are transmitted at the coordination points of the primary particles forming the agglomerate (Fig. 3.1d). Liquid bridges at the coordination points (Fig. 3.1c and 3.2c) are described by Model 3 while the transitional state (Fig. 3.2d) is connected with Model 2 through the liquid saturation, S. If the pore volume of the agglomerate is completely filled with a stress-transmitting substance (Fig. 3.1a), such as a hardened binder, three strength components can define agglomerate strength. (a) rte (pore volume strength) = tensile strength of the binder substance (b) rta (grain boundary strength) = tensile strength caused by the adhesion between binder and particulate solids forming the agglomerate (c) rt(1 – e) = strength of the particulate solids forming the agglomerate. The relatively lowest component determines the agglomerate strength. Fig. 3.7 depicts schematically the expected failure lines in a two-dimensional schematic representation [B.97]. If a liquid that wets the solid(s) fills the entire pore volume of an agglomerate to such a degree that concave menisci are formed at the pore ends on the surface (Fig. 3.1b), a negative capillary pressure pc develops in the interior of the agglomerate. Because the membrane forces at the surface are negligibly small in relation to the capillary pressure, the tensile strength rtc of agglomerates that are completely filled with a liquid can be approximated by the capillary pressure [B.97] rtc pc = a’ (1 – e)/e a/x
(3.1)
Fig. 3.7 Two-dimensional diagram of the failure lines derived from the three models describing strength of agglomerates with a matrix binder (Fig. 3.1a)
3.5 Strength
The maximum tensile strength of agglomerates that are completely filled with a perfectly wetting liquid depends on the porosity of the agglomerate, characterized by the strong term (1 – e)/e, the surface tension a of the liquid, and the size x of the particles forming the agglomerate. The empirical correction factor a’ has values between 6 and 8. An approximation of the agglomerate strength rtt in the transitional (“funicular”) state (Fig. 3.2d), in which a certain percentage S (saturation) of the pore volume is filled with liquid, is possible by multiplying the maximum strength rtc by the appropriate saturation S rtt Srtc
(3.2)
Strength may be also caused by adhesive forces A acting at the coordination points of the particles forming the agglomerate (Fig. 3.1d). Based on statistical considerations and a simple model, a general formula was developed that is often used to describe agglomerate strength [B.48] rt = (1 – e)/p kA/x2 (1 – e)/e A/x2
(3.3)
where e is the specific void volume (porosity) of the agglomerate and (1 – e) the respective volume of the particulate solids, k the average coordination number (ke p), and x the representative size of the particulate solids forming the agglomerate The still unknown term in Equation 3.3 is the adhesion force A. As already mentioned above, it must be recognized that, normally, more than one binding mechanism participates in the production of agglomerate strength and that, due to differences in distance and micro conditions, the adhesion force Ai at each coordination point is different. Therefore, Equation 3.3 becomes in its most general form rt = (1 – e)/eRAi/x2
(3.4)
The work of many researchers has concentrated on modeling and calculating adhesion forces that are caused by the different binding mechanisms [B.48, B.97]. So far, all models are based on simplified conditions at the coordination points. A large number of different partner shapes is possible, other than, for example, sphere to sphere, the simplest model that is often used, and, normally, the size of the partners will be different and can vary infinitely. Particles also feature rough surfaces. Therefore, when modeling surface interactions, this can be done macroscopically, disregarding surface roughness, or microscopically. Generally, the true shape of a particle, including surface roughness, can not yet be described unequivocally. New techniques, such as fractal dimensions [B.42], may be applied in the future to solve this problem. Estimation of the strength of agglomerates, which is caused by solid bridges at the coordination points (similar to Figures 3.1c and 3.2c) assumes that the entire solid binder material is uniformly distributed at all coordination points and forms bridges with constant strength, rB. If, in addition, failure only occurs through solid bridges, meaning that the strengths of the particle and of the adhesion bond at the interface are
17
18
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
higher than that of the binder (solid bridge), the relative cross section of that material defines the agglomerate strength rtB (MBqp/MpqB)(1 – e)rB = wBerB
(3.5)
where MB is the mass of the bridge building material and Mp the mass of the agglomerate building particulate solids, qB and qp are the densities of the respective solid materials, 1 – e is the relative volume of the particulate solids building the agglomerate, e is the specific void volume (porosity) of the agglomerate, and wB is the fraction of voids in the agglomerate that is filled with the bridge building material.
3.6
Determination of Strength
“Strength of agglomerates” may have many different meanings. In most cases the attribute “strength” defines a survival characteristic and may be defined as crushing, bending, cutting, shear, or tensile strength, as tolerance to one or several drops from a specific height, thereby reproducing stresses experienced at transfer points, or as resistance to attrition and the formation of dust [B.48, B.97]. For special applications still other measures of “strength” may be elaborated that simulate the real handling or processing conditions. Scientifically the only unequivocally defined and reproducible strength, which is ultimately and with a high degree of probability responsible for all failure modes and can be also approximated by theoretical calculations, is the tensile strength (see above). Results of experimental determinations of agglomerate strength have been published in many scientific works and were summarized in numerous specific books on agglomeration or in major chapters of more general handbooks (Section 13.1). In particular, the proceedings of the International Symposia on Agglomeration [B.4, B.16, B.21, B.26, B.40, B.56, B.94] should be consulted. A considerable amount of fundamental research is going on in many places of the world trying to increase knowledge of all binding mechanisms and develop numerical methods to calculate or at least estimate binding forces as well as agglomerate strength. In addition to the “classic” methods mentioned above, many novel technologies, such as, for example, application of the atomic force microscope [AFM] (also called lateral force microscope [LFM] or scanning probe microscope [SPM]) for the measurement of adhesion in the micron and submicron particle range, and new theories, for instance, fractals [B.42] and the chaos theory, are applied to agglomeration research. However, as mentioned earlier, it is unlikely that only one binding mechanism acts on all coordination points within even a single agglomerate. Moreover, the microscopic conditions at each coordination point are so diverse that bonding at virtually each individual coordination point is different. Therefore, although big advances have been and are being made, the science of agglomeration is still far away from formulating a useful general theory. Furthermore, this book is devoted to a more practical coverage of agglomeration. Therefore, the reader is encouraged to search for and
3.6 Determination of Strength
study the increasing number of publications that report on the advances in this area (Section 13.1). Determination of agglomerate strength in industry is rather pragmatic [B.48]. For the practical and industrial investigation of agglomerate strength, stresses that occur during storage and handling are experimentally simulated. In addition to the frequently used crushing, drop, and abrasion tests, methods for the determination of impact, bending, cutting, or shear strength are employed [B.97]. All values obtained by these methods are strictly empirical and cannot be predicted by theory because it is not known which component of the applied stresses causes the agglomerate to fail. For the same reason, the experimental results from different methods can not be compared with each other. It is even possible that results obtained with the same method but carried out by different laboratories and/or different technicians are not compatible because of characteristic procedures that are inadvertently used by different people. A further problem that is associated with any determination of agglomerate strength stems from the fact that agglomerates are not uniform bodies. Many have no welldefined size or shape and, even if this is the case (such as with, for example, cylindrical compacts or spherical pellets) or if a test specimen is made to specific directions, they are all made from a large number of particulate solids, held together by widely varying binding mechanisms, have void spaces (pores) between the particles, and often feature many structural faults, including cracks, density variations, and others. As a result, there is no well-defined circumstance of failure. The curve in Fig. 3.8 shows a possible results from a compression test with a spherical pellet (assumed to be a perfect sphere). The heavy solid line represents the theoretical increase of force as provided by the test equipment (constant rate). At the beginning, the compression force increases steadily and then begins to deviate slightly from the theoretical curve due to some deformation, mostly at the contact points. At (1) a bulk densification be-
Fig. 3.8 Diagram of force against time curves that may be obtained during the compression strength test of spherical agglomerates
19
20
3 Agglomeration Fundamentals
gins, which is arrested at (2) and the compression strength continues to increase without causing an appreciable densification of the agglomerate. At point (3) different conditions may arise. Pieces of a brittle agglomerate may break off, indicating a first failure. However, it is possible that most of the agglomerate remains intact and, after some densification between (3a) and (4), can be compressed further until final catastrophic disintegration occurs at (5). Plastic agglomerates, on the other hand, may never come apart. After considerable densification (between (3) and (6)) the compression force may increase more or less steeply, indicating formation of a less compressible cake. With this type of agglomerates, “strength” can be only determined by defining a maximum degree of deformation and associating the measured force at this point. For this evaluation a force/displacement curve must be determined (which is similar to the force/time graph shown in Fig. 3.8). While for some applications it is important to know the force causing final catastrophic failure, particularly in such cases where the production of fines from brittle agglomerates must be avoided during handling, the first indication of partial breakage could be selected to determine the strength. This opens the reporting of test results to a wide range of operator-dependent interpretations. Although knowledge and understanding of the fundamentals of agglomeration, particularly the nature and effect of the binding mechanisms and how they can be influenced, become more and more important during the development of new and for the optimization of existing agglomeration processes, agglomeration as a unit operation is still more an art than a science. While an increasing number of criteria are known for the preselection of the most suitable agglomeration process for a specific application [B.97], it is still necessary to test the selected equipment in the laboratories of vendors or development organizations (Section 9.1). Often, if the process is a new one, it is even desirable to operate a smaller pilot plant or to involve a “toller”, an outside processor for hire (Section 9.2), prior to an investment decision for a large scale plant. Agglomerate strength in industry is also defined as a commercial or process characteristic of the particular intermediate or final product. For example, if the agglomerated material is a final product, strength may be defined as resistance to breakage, chipping, or abrasion. The definition of this property and of other strength-related requirements will differ whether it is an industrial bulk material or a consumer product. While the former may break down to a certain extent, it is acceptable as long as it remains free-flowing and dust-free. A consumer product, on the other hand, must have perfect and pleasing appearance where even minimal chipping or breakage into large chunks must be avoided. Intermediate products must have characteristics that are suitable for the intended further processing. For example, a material may have to be strong enough and abrasion resistant for storage and handling to avoid bridging, flow problems, dusting, and segregation of components. However, if it is a feed material for tabletting or other pressure agglomeration methods (Chapter 5), the agglomerates must break down totally under pressure and produce a uniform final product structure. Other agglomerated intermediates may have to feature the opposite property, i.e. they must retain their shape and structure during pressing, for example to yield a filter with bimodal pore size distribution (Chapter 7).
3.7 Porosity
For those reasons, “strength” means many different things in industry. Typically, measurement of strength is based on a simulation of the stresses that a particular agglomerated product must withstand. Very few industrial methods for the determination of this property are standardized or even publicly known. In a competitive environment it is of less interest to compare quality between rivals than to make sure internally that the product properties that are expected by the industrial or public consumer are maintained. Therefore, most measurements of strength are undertaken as quality assurance.
3.7
Porosity
All previously presented equations for strength show that the porosity of agglomerates plays a very important role for their strength. The lower the porosity or, in other words, the higher the apparent density of the agglomerate, the stronger it is. Since many of the desirable characteristics of agglomerated products require high porosity, sufficient strength is obtained in such cases by selecting a suitable binding mechanism featuring high adhesion or binding forces, using a powder with a small representative particle size, applying suitable curing techniques that produce permanent bonds with high strength (sintering), and/or incorporating temporary additives in the feed. During or after the curing step the latter are removed by melting, evaporation, or combustion [B.97].
Further Reading
For further reading the following books are recommended: B.1, B.3, B.4, B.6, B.7, B.8, B.9, B.12, B.13a through e, B.15, B.16, B.17, B.19, B.21, B.22, B.23, B.24, B.26, B.29, B.35, B.36, B.40, B.41, B.42, B.44, B.48, B.49, B.51, B.52, B.55, B.56, B.58, B.64, B.66, B.67, B.68, B.70, B.71, B.72, B.73, B.78, B.82, B.83, B.86, B.88, B.89, B.90, B.92, B.93, B.94, B.97, B.99, B.106, B.107 (Chapter 13.1). Books mainly devoted to the subject matter are printed bold.
21
23
4
Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect Agglomeration is a natural phenomenon. Under certain conditions, it happens, whether it is desired or not [B.71, B.97]. The adhesion of small particles is the most basic mechanism of agglomeration, which is most often responsible for unwanted build-up and the conglomeration of fine particles that is frequently observed when handling particulate solids. Tab. 4.1 lists the operations of mechanical process technologies (Chapter 2, Fig. 2.2) and indicates if agglomeration is desired or undesired or, sometimes, both.
4.1
Separation
During separation unwanted agglomeration may occur and must be avoided if a particle collective is to be divided into well-defined classes. The separation curve is a measure of separation quality. In a diagram the degree of separation the percentage amounts of particles above and below the desired separation size) is plotted against the particle size. Fig. 4.1 is a qualitative presentation of several separation curves. Line (a) in Fig. 4.1 represents the ideal or perfect separation of a particle size distribution xmin < x < xmax at cut size xt1 (possible only in theory). In industrial separation equipment, curves of type (b) are obtained. Then, the cut size is that particle size of which half end up in the coarse fraction and half in the fine. The sharpness of separation increases with the slope of the curve. If the abscissa uses a logarithmic scale, separation curves representing similar separation efficiencies at different cut sizes are parallel to each other. The influence of agglomeration must be judged differently. If the separation task is to remove all particles x < xmin from a fluid the desired cut size is xmin. Line (c) in Fig. 2.1 describes the ideal (only theoretically possible) separation curve. In reality, some small particles remain suspended in the fluid and the actual cut size is xt2 > xmin, curve (d). If agglomeration occurs, the finest particles may form larger entities or attach themselves to larger particles, thereby changing the separation curve in Fig. 2.1 to (e). The new cut size xt2’ is still somewhat larger than the desired xmin, at which all particles would have been removed from the fluid, but agglomeration definitely helps to move the actual cut size closer to the ideal one. Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
24
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect Tab. 4.1 The occurrence of undesired and desired agglomeration in mechanical and related process technologies Unit operation
Process
Separation
Mixing
Comminution Particle size enlargement
Conveying
Storage Batching, metering Drying Explanations
Agglomeration
Screening, Sieving Classifying, Sorting Flotation Dust Precipitation Clarification, Thickening Particle Size Analysis Dry Mixing Wet Mixing Stirring Suspending, Dispersing Fluidized Bed Dry Grinding Wet Grinding Agglomeration } Briquetting } Granulating } Pelletizing } Pelleting } Sintering Tabletting Mechanical Conveying Vibratory Conveying Pneumatic Conveying Silos, Hoppers, Stockpiles
(+) sometimes YES ( ) sometimes NO
+ YES NO
Undesirable
Desirable
+ + + (-) (-) ++ + + + + + + +
(+) (+) + + -(+) + (+) + -
(+)
++
+ + + + + +
++ ++ (+) (+) --+
++ decisively YES - - decisively NO
In general, whenever the task is to remove all particulate solids from a fluid, agglomeration will be advantageous. Since the smallest, low-mass particles are, on one hand, the most difficult to remove and, on the other hand, have the highest natural adhesion tendency, the chance agglomeration of these particles improves separation efficiency. Therefore, techniques for enhancing the natural agglomeration tendency of very fine particles are often applied during gas and liquid cleaning. Even relatively loose conglomerates behave according to the combined weight of all adhering particles during, for example, settling or in the centrifugal fields of cyclone separators. For all those separation cases that attempt to separate a particle collective according to certain properties of the particulate solids, agglomeration is most often undesired. Techniques for which this statement is true include screening, sifting, classification, sorting, flotation, and, as a general analytical method, particle size characterization. It should also be realized that the respective separation property does not have to be size; it could be density, shape, color, chemical composition, and others.
4.1 Separation Fig. 4.1 curves
Examples of separation
During screening, unwanted agglomeration is often facilitated by the motion of the material on the screen; spheroidal agglomerates are frequently formed from material containing fines or featuring other binding characteristics, for example if it is moist. Among others, binding mechanisms are: for finely divided solids, molecular and electrical forces and/or adsorption layers; for plastics, electrostatic forces; for ores, magnetic forces; for moist powders, liquid bridges and capillary forces; for fibers, interlocking; and for materials with low melting points, partial melting and solidification. With some substances several bonding mechanisms may occur simultaneously. In all cases, the result of screening is distorted because agglomerated fines are classified as coarse. The immediate and complete removal by dedusting or “scalping” of the finest fraction prior to screening into the desired property classes is one practical method of avoiding selective agglomeration of the fines or adhesion of fines to larger particles. During screening itself, the effect of adhesion is reduced by mechanical destruction of agglomerates with, for example, rubber cubes or balls placed on or under the screen decks, the application of brushes, air jets, or ultrasound, and the modification of screen amplitude or frequency (e.g., ultrasonic screen excitation). During the screening of moist bulk materials, difficulties increase with moisture content, but agglomeration tendencies are almost completely eliminated during wet screening when the particles are suspended in a liquid. Since, in moist screening, particles are often held in the mesh openings by liquid bridges, the separation of such materials is facilitated by direct resistance heating, inductive heating, or by modifying the wetting angle and/or the surface tension with surfactants, and blinding of the screen is avoided. In air classification, products from, for example, dry fine grinding are separated. Particular problems arise if the material to be separated contains agglomerates that were formed during comminution. Such conglomerates would be recirculated into the mill and “overgrinding” occurs. Therefore, attempts are made to destroy them by special feeder designs. Destructive forces are caused by, for example, sudden
25
26
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
changes in speed or direction of flow and by installing air jet mills in front of the classifier. In the classifier itself, agglomerates are formed by molecular forces that may be reinforced by adsorption layers if separation is carried out with ambient air, by liquid bridges if moist materials are processed, and by electrostatic forces in a dry environment. As an example, Fig. 4.2 depicts separation curves of various air classifiers. With decreasing particle size, due to agglomeration, the amount found in the coarse fraction increases, because fine particles adhere to larger ones and conglomerates of fines behave as if they were coarser particles. Both effects reduce the separation efficiency and can be avoided only if the causes for adhesion are removed, mostly by eliminating moisture in the material and humidity in the air. Sorting processes that separate materials according to particle characteristics other than size are often carried out in liquids. Agglomeration can again reduce the separation efficiency when smaller particles of other components stick to larger ones. On the other hand, agglomeration can be also beneficial in dense media sink/swim separation, centrifugal separation, or during jigging if particles of a particular ingredient can be made to selectively adhere to each other and form larger, heavier agglomerates. During particle size analysis, in addition to screening, air sifting, and counting, sedimentation in liquids is often applied, which produces unequivocal results only if the individual particles can move without influencing each other. For that reason, very dilute suspensions are used. Nevertheless, it is possible that agglomerates form or conglomerates that are already present do not disintegrate completely. Therefore, dispersion aids are often added, which reduce particle affinity. The molecules of dispersion aids attach to the particles, eliminating polarities and/or reducing interfacial tensions. Separation forces, such as ultrasonic vibrations, can be also introduced for improved disagglomeration and dispersion. In connection with particle size analysis, the importance of correct sample preparation must be stressed. Because natural, unintentionally formed agglomerates always incorporate a larger than average number of the finest particles, the result of particle size analysis will be incorrect if pre-existing agglomerates are not destroyed or conditions prevail during testing that promote agglomeration.
Fig. 4.2 Separation curves of different air classifiers [B.71, B.97]
4.3 Comminution
4.2
Mixing
Many of the previously mentioned considerations apply to the formation and prevention of undesired agglomerates during mixing. Little needs to be added concerning mixing in liquids by stirring or methods for the production of suspensions and dispersions. The addition of dispersion agents is always recommended if the tendency of the solid particles to agglomerate is high. Agglomerates or flocs that are already intentionally, for example to improve handling characteristics of fine powders, or unintentionally present prior to mixing can be destroyed by shear forces in the liquid. Consequently, the generation of the highest possible shear gradient is often considered advantageous when selecting agitators. During extended storage, the particles in pharmaceutical suspensions often form agglomerates that can no longer be destroyed by shaking the preparation. This is of particular concern in, for example, eye drops. The problem can be avoided by controlled flocculation of the solids. After the addition of an electrolyte, the fine particles aggregate to loose flocs that can be easily redispersed by shaking the dispenser prior to application. When mixing dry or moist bulk solids, agglomerates may form, which originate from the finest components of the mixture. They are held together by molecular and electrostatic as well as capillary forces. These undesired agglomerates should be broken up by shear or frictional stresses, generated by the motion of the bulk mass, or by special disintegration devices that are built into the blender [B.97].
4.3
Comminution
During fine grinding in roller crushers and tube mills containing grinding media, with all materials problems begin to develop at a certain fineness of the solids to be milled. Two types of phenomena can be distinguished. In the first case, the finest particles start to adhere to walls and the grinding media in the mill. On this first coating, even coarser particles find excellent conditions for adhesion and massive deposits form rapidly. These layers adhering to the inside walls and the grinding media produce a cushioning effect, which lowers the intensity of stressing and, therefore, increase the duration of grinding and decrease efficiency. The second phenomenon during dry fine grinding is the occurrence of agglomerates in the freely moving charge itself. Formation of such agglomerates is associated with the so called “limit of grinding”. For each material a fineness exists at which, in spite of continued consumption of energy, the finest particles in the charge do not seem to become finer. Agglomeration and adhesion in mills can be attributed to various binding mechanisms. Since the mill housing may become highly charged by the friction between its contents and the walls, electric forces are often the cause for the initial build-up. This effect can be eliminated quite easily by grounding the mill. In other cases, wall deposits
27
28
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
will begin with particles of a size that generally corresponds to that of the wall roughness. The strength of the layer depends on the contact pressure, which is magnified by the mill charge consisting of grinding media and material to be crushed. Adhesion is largely affected by molecular forces; however, partial melting and sintering are also possible. Agglomerates are formed in the freely moving charge of a tube mill by the compaction of fine particles between the grinding media and by recombination bonding (Chapter 5). Adhesion is affected by van-der-Waals forces between the particles that have been compressed very tightly and by the recombination of free valence forces at newly created surfaces. Since these agglomerates are very strong, a “grinding equilibrium” exists, which has been observed and described by many. It means that in fine grinding, after a certain time, a state of equilibrium between size reduction and size enlargement by agglomeration occurs. From that point on, agglomerates are formed, crushed, and re-formed so that the apparent particle size does not change. However, since destruction of particles continues to occur, a growing amorphization of the material can be observed, which also results in increasing specific surface area and is often called “mechanical activation” as, in many cases, higher reactivity is obtained. Every form of agglomeration during size reduction reduces the efficiency of grinding and the fineness obtained at the limit of grinding is often insufficient for many
Fig. 4.3 Agglomerates produced during grinding in a roller mill with a high reduction ratio
4.3 Comminution
tasks, even though the agglomerates actually contain much smaller particles. Therefore, it is desirable to prevent or, at least, reduce these effects. In milling, one possibility to achieve less unwanted agglomeration is to add surface-active substances, so called surfactants or “grinding aids”. It has long been known that small amounts of such additives may reduce the grinding time required to reach a particular fineness by 20–30 %. Molecules of these substances, which are present in a gas or vapor phase, quickly saturate free valences at the newly created surfaces and avoid recombination bonding. As a rule, grinding aids also reduce caking. The formation of lamellar flakes or flat agglomerates in tube mills has been attributed to compaction between the grinding media during impact. The same mechanism occurs in all comminution processes in which the material to be crushed is subjected to stresses between two surfaces, for example in roller mills. Since the second condition for the formation of agglomerates is a sufficient fineness of the particles that are involved, the occurrence of flat flakes is mostly observed during fine grinding. One measure for the fineness, the intensity of stressing, and the unintentional formation of agglomerates is the so called “reduction ratio” that is, the quotient of maximum feed particle size and gap between the rollers. Fig. 4.3 depicts typical agglomerates produced in a roller mill with a high reduction ratio. Since the fine material is immediately compacted, almost all free valences at the newly created surfaces participate in recombination bonding. Consequently, the formation of agglomerates in roller mills can be avoided only if a smaller reduction ratio is chosen or by applying friction between the rollers. Agglomerates can be also formed during impact grinding. Fig. 4.4a shows the fracture lines that develop during impact stressing of a glass sphere. A cone of fine material is created at the impact point and is compacted into an agglomerated mass by the pressure resulting from the kinetic energy of the system (Fig. 4.4b and c). Here too, the effect of free valence forces on newly created surfaces is used to its almost complete extent yielding a quite strong agglomerate. It is very difficult to avoid this type of agglomeration; it can be affected only by reducing the impact velocity which, in turn, results in a lower degree of comminution. For glass spheres, for example, the formation of agglomerates was observed only at impact speeds exceeding 80 m/s.
Fig. 4.4 a) Schematic representation of the fracture lines caused in a glass sphere by impact stress. b) Agglomerated cone of fines created during the impact stressing of a glass sphere (sphere diameter 8 mm, impact velocity 150 m/s). c) Agglomerated cone of fines created during impact stressing of a sugar crystal (shown on the left)
29
30
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
During the impact crushing of thermoplastic materials or inorganic substances with low melting points, solidified bridges of partially melted material may further increase adhesion and the strength of agglomerated fines. Since the increase in temperature depends on the energy input and is constant for a given impact velocity, cryogenic milling, whereby the particles to be crushed are cooled prior to feeding into the mill, not only results in an increased brittleness but may also avoid partial melting and unwanted agglomeration. In wet grinding, as a rule, agglomeration is avoided by suspending the particles in liquid. Sometimes, the product of dry fine grinding is subjected to a brief final wet grinding to destroy the previously formed agglomerates. Nevertheless, some materials also tend to flocculate in wet grinding. Since the adhesion forces causing flocs are mostly electrical in nature, the addition of a small amount of electrolyte to the suspending liquid nearly always suffices to prevent flocculation.
4.4
Agglomeration
By definition, the size enlargement by agglomeration operation makes use of all binding mechanisms and often enhances them in suitable environments and equipment. All agglomerates that are manufactured are made intentionally and are desired. Nevertheless, there are instances where adhesion and agglomeration are unwanted and undesired. Because, particularly in tumble/growth agglomeration, binders are added, the effect of these binders is still present on the surface of green agglomerates and during post-treatment new binding mechanisms between the agglomerates may develop, which result in the formation of clusters. Of course, because agglomerates are larger bodies and only a few interaction points (coordination points) are present in a unit volume of the cluster, even relatively strong solid bridges, which may have developed by recrystallization, chemical reaction, or sintering during post-treatment can be broken relatively easily. Nevertheless, such clusters could be detrimental during storage, feeding, or metering and, therefore, should be avoided or broken up prior to a following process step. More information on potential problems is given in the section 4.6 on storage.
4.5
Transportation
During the conveying of particulate solids, especially of finely dispersed powders, the unintentional formation of agglomerates and (sometimes thick) coatings on walls is often observed. Whereas agglomerates occur mostly on vibrating or shaking conveyors and inclined conveyors or chutes, build-up on walls is more common in pneumatic conveyors. The main causes of agglomeration during the conveying of fine particulate solids are molecular and electric forces as well as binding mechanisms related
4.6 Storage
to moisture and, as a result of mechanical or thermal energy input, binding mechanisms such as partial melting and solidification can occur, too. Although it is very difficult to avoid agglomeration on vibrating or shaking conveyors, several possibilities exist for the prevention of wall build-up and deposits during pneumatic transport. Since the adhesion of the finest particles always begins in the roughness depressions, one of the most important conditions for avoiding a common reason for initial build-up is to provide smooth inner wall surfaces of pneumatic conveying lines. Because high drag forces tend to remove particles that have already adhered to the walls, high transport velocities also reduce the danger of build-up. Deposits preferably start in dead or calm flow zones; therefore, when designing such systems, low speed areas must be avoided. On the other hand, sudden changes in the direction of flow will cause high energy impacts of particles with the wall, causing build-up. Friction between particulate solids and pneumatic conveyor walls may result in high electrostatic charges on both partners. They depend to a large extent on whether the particles and/or the walls are electrically conductive and if the lines are grounded or not. System design must take these conditions into consideration.
4.6
Storage
Adhesion phenomena are involved in, for example, the bridging of particulate solids in hoppers. In the case of relatively coarse materials, bridge formation is caused by domelike structures, which are supported on the inclined walls in the lower conical part of bins. With decreasing particle size, the participation of adhesion forces in bridging and agglomeration increases. Binding mechanisms are molecular forces and adsorption layers or liquid bridges. The latter often play an important role whereby liquid bridges form by capillary condensation at the coordination points. Feeding warm and moist material into silos must be avoided, even if the moisture content is very low. Evaporating moisture may condense on the cooler silo walls and drip into the charge, forming wet agglomerates and causing strong capillary adhesion bonding of particles on the walls. Insulation of the silo and/or forced large volume venting can be employed to avoid condensation and agglomeration problems. Bridging can totally block the discharge from silos, thus causing severe operating problems. Because adhesion even of finely dispersed dry solids cannot be avoided, agglomerates and bridges must be destroyed by special devices. For this purpose, inflatable cushions are mounted to the inside walls of silos or the material is momentarily fluidized by the (pulsed) injection of air. In the case of coarser solids, which tend to form domes, it is often sufficient to select a cone with steeper sides (“mass flow” design). Small remaining flow problems due to adhesion can be overcome by installing vibrators or “hammers” on the outside silo walls. Unwanted agglomeration is often observed if the particulate materials are soluble or if chemical reactions can occur, particularly in the presence of moisture. These phenomena are very common and are called caking if they occur in bulk masses or bag-set if material solidifies in bags.
31
32
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
Different materials become caked during various storage and handling procedures but caking itself is almost exclusively by solid bridges or, more specifically, by chemical reaction and crystallization of dissolved substances. Other binding mechanisms contribute only slightly to caking. The rate and extent to which caking takes place depends on the moisture content, the particle size or specific surface area, the pressure under which the material is stored (e.g., top or bottom of the pile), the temperature and its variation during storage, as well as the time. The influence of temperature and temperature variations depends on the solubility of the solids. Fig. 4.5 shows four different temperature–solubility curves. Whereas the solubility of sodium chloride changes little with temperature, this is not true for potassium chloride (or potash) and potassium nitrate, for example. The latter features a very steep curve. Some salts, such as sodium sulfate, exhibit various temperature-dependent solubility ranges. Salts or mixtures of different salts containing a small amount of moisture, may cake during storage and/or transport if exposed to changing temperatures even if the moisture content is very small and the material is packed in airtight containers. In many cases (Fig. 4.5), more salt will be dissolved at higher temperatures, which recrystallizes and forms solid bridges between the particles when the temperature drops again. Repeated cycling, for instance due to climatic changes or differences in day and night temperatures, reinforces this bonding and causes bag-set.
Fig. 4.5 Solubility curves of four different salts
4.6 Storage
The crushing strength of caked materials depends on the number of bridges formed per unit volume and, therefore, decreases with increasing particle size. As mentioned earlier, mixtures of powdered soluble materials that were granulated by agglomeration may still set up somewhat due to the mechanism described above. However normally, the granulated material can be broken and disagglomerated easily. The answer to what can be done to avoid or, at least, lessen caking is complex but generally the same as in all other cases where unwanted adhesion or agglomeration occurs: Detect the binding mechanism that is responsible and the parameters that influence the process. Then try to reduce their effect. In the following some examples will be discussed briefly. If (unobjectional) chemical reactions between components of a mixture do occur, these components should be mixed separately until the reaction is completed. The resulting intermediate product can then be blended with the other components and no longer induces caking. An almost trivial precaution is very often to lower the moisture content. However, this is not always necessary. Different maximum moisture levels exist that depend on the material. It was found during microscopic studies that caking usually resulted from bonding by the crystals of soluble salts. These crystals often covered the entire granule surface in the form of a veneer or hull. Those salts migrated to the surface of the granule as a solution, leaving numerous small cavities within. Since this mechanism requires water, drying should reduce caking. Some materials respond favorably to several days of curing prior to bagging. Such products cake in a few days to their final strength and the resulting lumps are broken up before the cured materials are bagged and put into long term storage. Curing can even accelerate hull formation owing to heat and moisture retention. In products that respond well to curing, additional development of crystals on the granule surfaces during subsequent storage is not sufficient to cause significant caking. However, many products do not improve during this type of curing. Another curing method will be described below. The oldest method of conditioning granular materials is coating with a parting agent. Storage properties are improved after the addition of up to 3 % of an extremely fine particulate solid such as pollen, diatomaceous earth, kaolin, vermiculite, pulverized limestone, magnesium oxide, and a variety of other inexpensive, very fine powders. Again, microscopic studies revealed the fundamental properties of a conditioner, which are threefold. 1. The powder coating acts as a separator and prevents crystal bridge growth between the individual granules during and after drying. 2. The hull crystals from beneath the coating rarely project beyond the layer of conditioner. 3. The moisture is distributed uniformly over the surface of the granules due to the high sorptive capacity of the finely porous coating. Thus the localized growth of crystals at the coordination points is prevented and the surface hulls are much finer grained, more intergrown, and more densely packed than those covering un-
33
34
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
conditioned products. Such anticaking conditioning agents are usually applied by mixing them with the granular material in a rotary tumbler (typically a drum) prior to bagging. A modern variation of the above mentioned conditioning process is the coating with surface-active organic chemicals. It was found, however, that not all surfactants improve the physical conditions of granules. It was reported that the caking tendencies can be reduced by as much as 45 % if non-ionic chemicals were used but increased by as much as 37 % with the use of anionic materials. Where in the process the surfaceactive agents were applied was also found to be of decisive importance. Typical cationic anticaking agents are fatty amines with a general formula R-NH2 with R representing C16 and C18 chains. they are believed to attach directly to the particles with their surface-active amine group. The fatty, hydrophobic part of the molecule extends outward, thus preventing hygroscopic products from attracting moisture. Of course, this is only true if a monomolecular layer covers the granules and all amine molecules extend their hydrophobic portion outward. Therefore, too much conditioner may cause rather than prevent caking. Multiple layers are alternately hydrophobic and hydrophilic. The above makes an alternative curing process advantageous: The molecules of a second molecular layer, if attached, would position themselves with the amine group extending outward. These amine groups are free to interact with other particles. Pressure intensifies this effect. The resulting chemical “bridge” is not as strong as a recrystallized salt bridge and the “set” can be broken easily. Sometimes a combination of the two types of conditioners is used. An example of this approach is finely divided kaolin or talcum powder treated with surfactant. A last but not least method is granulation by agglomeration. Today, for very fine solids, this technology is almost obligatory, particularly for powder mixtures. Size-enlarged, granular products offer fewer coordination points per unit volume where solid bridges can develop. If the strength of the bridges is low anyway, granulation alone is sufficient to prevent severe caking. Agglomeration also prevents segregation during storage. The above examples were selected to demonstrate how unwanted agglomeration problems can be studied and how possible remediation methods and techniques
Tab. 4.2
Some dvantages of uncontrolled, natural agglomeration
Separation
Mixing Comminution Agglomeration Transportation Storage
After agglomeration, size enlarged ultrafine particles can be removed by conventional separation equipment. Selective agglomeration of specific particles in liquid suspensions (immiscible binder agglomeration. Selective agglomeration (powder coating). Mechanical activation (amorphization by crushing and recombination bonding). See Table 6.1 Larger, heavier particles. Smaller number of coordination points per unit volume.
4.6 Storage
can be determined. They date back to a point in time when the fundamentals of unwanted agglomeration in different industries were first investigated and means were developed to avoid some of these phenomena. Tab. 4.2 and 4.3 summarize what has been discussed. Tab. 4.2 shows that some of the uncontrolled, natural agglomeration phenomena are not necessarily detrimental. Tab. 4.3 lists a few of the possibilities to avoid or at least lessen the effect of unwanted agglomeration. While undesired agglomeration is often very important, because its effects may result in considerable losses of production and profit, most of the past and present Tab. 4.3 Summary of some of the possibilities to avoid or at least lessen the effect of unwanted agglomeration Separation
Mixing
Dry/moist Wet
Comminution
Agglomeration Transportation
Storage
Remove or “scalp-off” fines (immediately) at the source. Destroy agglomerates mechanically (rubber cubes/balls, shear, impact, brushes, gas (air) jets, ultrasound, etc.) Modify amplitude and/or frequency. Remove moisture from material and/or gas (air) environment. Heat (direct resistance/inductive). Modify wetting angle and/or surface tension of liquid (surfactants). Disperse particulate solids in suitable liquid (wet separation). Ground equipment (removal of electric charges). Use dispersion aids (chemicals, mechanical {e.g. stirring, ultrasound}). Apply shear or frictional stresses (tumbling mass, mixing tools, special accessories (e.g. shredders, baffles) Use shear (stirring) or dispersion agents. Utilize controlled flocculation (addition of electrolyte) that allows repeatable redispersion by shaking. Remove fines and/or moisture. Ground equipment (removal of electric charges). Coating of the inner walls of mills and crushers (elastic or non-stick). Add grinding aids (steam, vapors, surface-active substances). Lower reduction ratio (potentially multiple grinding steps). Use cryogenic milling (making use of material brittleness at low temperatures). Apply wet grinding (possibly with the addition of a small amount of electrolyte). Use drying and other post treatment measures. Modify surfaces by coating or encapsulation. Remove fines and/or moisture. Ground all lines (removal of electric charges). Make equipment, chutes, and pipes from (grounded) electrically conducting materials (avoid plastics). Finish inner walls smooth or with coating (e.g. Teflon). Remove fines and/or moisture. Cool materials to ambient conditions prior to storage. Insulate and/or heat walls. Ground (electrically conductive) hoppers, silos, and storage containers. Smooth and/or coat (e.g. with Teflon) all inner walls. Use steep (as close to vertical) walls, especially towards discharge openings. Employ mechanical bridge breakers (vibration, shock, {pulsed} air jets, inflatable inserts, etc.). Apply load (overburden) relieving means (e.g. “chinese hats”, baffles, etc.). Carry-out conditioning/curing prior to storage.
35
36
4 Undesired Agglomeration: Methods of Avoiding or Lessening its Effect
major publications deal only with methods, equipment, and systems for the production of agglomerates with beneficial properties. Therefore, it is an important achievement that a book authored by Griffith and entitled Cake Formation in Particulate Systems [B.50] was published that discusses especially the unwanted adhesion and agglomeration phenomena. The author distinguishes four major classes of caking in particulate systems: * * * *
mechanical caking, plastic-flow caking, chemical caking, and electrical caking.
In addition, several sub-classes are defined whereby specific properties of components, either pure substances or part(s) of a formulation, can be expected to cause caking under certain conditions. After describing the above, considerable emphasis is given in the book to laboratory techniques and test procedures that need to be considered by those engaged in solving caking problems. Griffith [B.50] states that one of the greatest difficulties in classifying caking (undesired agglomeration) problems comes from the very large number of variables that can contribute to its occurrence. They include material type and composition, including modifications by trace elements, which may be desired ingredients or contaminants, moisture, temperature, pressure, motion, and others. Therefore, in the section that deals with the experimental design of laboratory studies a few of the statistical methods of identifying and ranking variables are also discussed along with an evaluation of possible interactions.
Further Reading
The book [B.50] is recommended for further reading.
37
5
Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods Three technologies are available for the desired size enlargement of small particulate solids by agglomeration: * * *
tumble/growth agglomeration, pressure agglomeration, and agglomeration by heat/sintering.
They can be divided into the following sub-groups [B.97]. A 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Tumble or growth agglomeration: high-density tumbling bed, high-shear tumbling bed, high-density/high-shear with abrasion or crushing transfer, low-density fluidized bed, low-density particle clouds, agglomeration in stirred suspensions, immiscible liquid agglomeration.
B Pressure agglomeration: 1. low-pressure agglomeration, extrusion through screens, 2. medium-pressure agglomeration, pelleting, extrusion through perforates die plates, 3. high-pressure extrusion, ram presses, 4. high-pressure agglomeration, – in confined spaces, punch-and-die pressing, tabletting, – in confined spaces, isostatic pressing, – in semi-confined spaces, roller presses. C Agglomeration by heat/sintering: 1. agglomeration of stationary particle beds by sintering, 2. bonding of pre-agglomerated bodies or parts during post-treatment to obtain final product properties, 3. agglomeration and bonding during special pressure agglomeration processes (i.e., hot isostatic pressing). Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
38
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
In addition, existing and new innovative technologies use the phenomena and fundamentals of agglomeration for purposes other than size enlargement. Specifically, they produce changes or improvements of the properties of particulate solids or achieve modifications of the surfaces of solids. Others manipulate individual particles or deposit ultrafine particles onto substrates in a controlled manner and subsequently bond them with the base material and/or with each other. D Technologies using the phenomena and fundamentals of agglomeration for purposes other than size enlargement: 1. coating, 2. hybridization, mechanofusion, 3. deposition and/or manipulation of individual particles. Most technologies in categories (A) to (D) can be subdivided into two techniques: * *
those utilizing no binder, and those requiring a binder.
It should be pointed out that the binding mechanism in binderless agglomeration often resembles that of bonding with a binder. This is due to the fact that binders are sometimes inherently available and act during agglomeration and/or post-treatment. A typical example of this process is the wet agglomeration (Fig. 5.2, left) of materials that are easily soluble in the liquid. The modified surface tension of the solution may already influence the strength of the green agglomerate and during drying (the necessary post-treatment to convert the intermediate wet agglomerate into the dry, final product) solid bridges develop by recrystallization of the dissolved substance(s). Other inherently available binders have to be activated by a so-called conditioning process prior to agglomeration. A typical example of this technique is in the pelleting (Fig. 5.10, b1–b6) of animal feed where the starchy component of feed grains becomes plastic and sticky during moistening and heating with steam while mixing the formulation in a kneader. After this conditioning, the starch provides plasticity that is required for extrusion through bores in the dies of pelleters as well as green and dry product strengths (see Section 6.5.2).
5.1
Tumble or Growth Agglomeration
The basic mechanism of tumble/growth agglomeration is shown in Fig. 5.1. Adhesion of individual particles to each other or to solid surfaces is controlled by the competition between volume-related separation and surface-related adhesion forces [B.48, B.97]. To cause permanent adhesion, certain criteria must be fulfilled. The most important is that the sum of all separation forces in the system (e.g., caused by gravity, inertia, drag, etc.) must be smaller than the attraction forces that act between the adhering
5.1 Tumble or Growth Agglomeration
partners. According to Fig. 3.6 and Equation 5.1, the ratio between the binding forces Bi(x) and the sum of the active components of all ambient forces Fjy(x) is a measure of the adhesion tendency Ta Ta = RBi(x)/RFjy(x) > 1
(5.1)
Both the attraction and the ambient forces are mainly dependent on the size x of the powder particle(s). To cause adhesion, Ta must be larger than one. In most cases, to keep the particle(s) adhering, the sum of all moments Qj(x) must be zero, too: Qj(x) = x/2 RFjx(x) = 0
(5.2)
Most of the attraction forces (Tab. 3.1) have only a short range; their magnitude and strength decreases quickly with increasing distance. Therefore, because the surfaces of all particulates are, at least microscopically, rough, and the mass of the particles decreases with the third power of the particle size, the adhesion tendency increases with decreasing particle dimensions. The mechanism as depicted in Fig. 5.1 occurs naturally if the agglomerate forming particles are micron and submicron or nanosized solids (beginning at about <10 lm), even if they are dry. In the case of larger particles, the adhesion forces must be produced by the addition of binders (mostly water and other liquids) or enhanced by conditioning and the probability of collision must be increased by providing a high concentration of particles. Such conditions are obtained (Fig. 5.2) in inclined discs (pans), rotating drums, and any kind of powder mixer. Relatively lose agglomerates are obtained in fluidized beds, which realize an irregularly moving particle bed with lower concentrations. Sometimes, simple rolling and tumbling motions, for example on inclined stationary or moving surfaces, are sufficient for the cheap formation of crude agglomerates [B.48, B.97]. In most instances, tumble/growth agglomeration processes yield first so-called green agglomerates (see below) after growing nuclei into larger, nearly spherical aggregates by coalescence and/or layering (Fig. 5.1). These wet agglomerates are temporarily bonded by the effects of surface tension and capillary forces of the liquid binder. While, occasionally, components within the green agglomerate naturally produce permanent bonds by, for example, cementitious reactions, in most cases post-treatments consisting of all or some of the following processes are required to obtain permanent and final strength (right hand side of Fig. 5.2): heating, potentially chemically reacting,
Fig. 5.1 Basic mechanism of tumble/growth agglomeration
39
40
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods Fig. 5.2 Diagram of typical equipment for size enlargement by tumble/growth agglomeration (left) and the post-treatment steps required to obtain a final product (right). Left, from the top: inclined disc (pan), drum, continuous mixer, batch mixer, fluidized bed. 1) liquid binder (spray), 2) fresh feed, 3) recirculating fines, 4) dryer, 5) cooler, 6) double deck screen, 7) mill, 8) conditioning drum
drying, and, sometimes, sintering or partial melting, cooling, screening, adjustment of product properties by crushing and conditioning as well as recirculating of undersized material. Since it is difficult, if not impossible, to screen green (wet) agglomerates without blinding the screen cloths, separation of undersize material for recycling occurs normally after drying, reacting (if applicable), and cooling. Although the mostly pre-agglomerated recirculating particles often play an important role in tumble/ growth agglomeration, because they provide most of the nuclei that are necessary for an accelerated growth of product-size agglomerates (B.97], the sometimes very large percentage recycled (often > 300 %) must be again activated for agglomeration by rewetting and needs to pass once more through the entire process, including heating, drying, and cooling, which, in the final analysis, may render the technology uneconomical [B.97]. To arrive at the methods that achieve size enlargement by agglomeration in a desired and controlled manner, both a movement of particles and binding mechanisms must be created and enhanced. As the solids move in relation to each other, for example in the relatively dense bed of a rotating or otherwise actuated containment of some sort or in a low-density suspension, particles of any size and kind will collide from time to time and, if the attraction force at the collision site is high enough, coalesce.
5.1 Tumble or Growth Agglomeration
Theoretically, for this phenomenon to occur, no specific piece of equipment is necessary. As long as the solid particles are kept in irregular, stochastic motion, the probability of collision and coalescence exists. If, additionally, the binding force that has developed upon impact is strong enough to withstand the separating effects of all system forces (above and Fig. 3.6, Chapter 3) and does not disappear with time without being replaced by some other binding mechanism, the “seed agglomerate” will survive and eventually collide with other particles or agglomerates (Fig. 5.1). At each instance of collision the bonding criterion as defined in Equations 5.1 and 5.2 will be tested, leading to either growth, indifference, that is, the colliding partners will separate again and remain single, or the destruction of weaker agglomerates. To achieve growth, the individual mass of adhering particles must be small and their surface large. This is equivalent to the requirement that the size of agglomerating particles must be small. Typically, the surface equivalent diameter [B.48, B.75, B.97] should be in a range below about 100–200 lm. The limitation to small dimensions of the particles forming the agglomerate and the fact that, in most cases, only temporary bonds are formed constitute major drawbacks of all tumble/growth agglomeration methods. If particles are larger than required, crushing to achieve the necessary fineness is normally uneconomical. Immediately after growth agglomeration, in the green (moist or wet) stage, the main binding mechanisms (Chapter 3) are caused by bridges of freely movable liquids, capillary pressure at the surface of particle conglomerates that are filled with a freely movable liquid, or adhesion caused by viscous binders and slurries. To a lesser degree, other binding mechanisms, such as van-der-Waals, electric, and magnetic forces, may also participate. After curing, which often results also in a considerable strengthening of the agglomerates, bonding is achieved by solid bridges resulting form sintering, chemical reactions, partial melting and solidification, or recrystallization of dissolved substances. Some tumble/growth agglomeration equipment can handle large volumes effectively if the above requirements (small primary particle size and instantaneous bonding with high strength) are fulfilled. The apparatus is simple and the design is unsophisticated but control depends largely on operator experience. Curing is normally the expensive part of plant investment and also contributes to a large extent to operating costs, both of which may render an otherwise perfect technology uneconomical. However, if very large amounts of solids must be agglomerated and the finely divided particulate form of the primary particles is required for other reasons, for example, the concentration of valuable components of ores (Section 6.8), tumble agglomeration is the preferred technology. In those cases the main binder is water. At production capacities exceeding 1 million t per year, the curing facilities become cheaper and more economical and methods for, for example, the recuperation of heat to make the process more efficient and reduce operating costs become feasible. Other reasons for the application of tumble/growth agglomeration, even at small capacities, may be the high porosity of the agglomerates with other attendant beneficial product characteristics, such as high surface area, e.g., for catalyst carriers, and easy solubility, e.g., for food (drink) and pharmaceutical products (Sections 6.2.1, 6.3.1, and 6.4.1). These advantages may be so valuable that additional costs for grinding to
41
42
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
obtain the necessary small particle size for agglomeration will be acceptable and high operating costs can be absorbed. In these cases, even the agglomeration liquids (binders for the formation of green agglomerates) may be so costly that they are condensed from the dryer off-gas and recirculated. In tumble/growth agglomeration distinct process steps can be defined in which (Fig. 5.2): 1. green agglomerates are formed from solid particles and binder, 2. green agglomerates are cured, 3. if necessary, the cured agglomerates are sized (undersized material is recirculated and oversized agglomerates are crushed and rescreened or recirculated), 4. if desired, post-treatment takes place, for example, the application of anticaking agents, coating, etc. Steps 3 and 4 may sometimes move ahead of step 2 to avoid the energy cost of repeated drying and rewetting of large circulating streams of material. However, since sticking and other unwanted agglomeration problems may be encountered during sizing and oversize crushing, application of this alternative may not always be feasible. In a broad sense, equipment for the tumble/growth agglomeration process itself may be divided into the following. I. Dense Phase Tumble/Growth Agglomeration: apparatus producing movement of a densely dispersed mass of particulate solids. II. Suspended Solids Agglomeration: apparatus producing movement while keeping solid particulate matter suspended or dispersed in a fluid. In both cases, finely divided binder is added in a suitable manner to the turbulently agitated mass of particles. If solid particles are suspended in a liquid, agglomerates may be formed after adding a second, immiscible bridging (binder) liquid. In the widest sense, this technology (called Immiscible Binder Agglomeration) belongs to the type II processes. Generally, the basic process, described in Fig. 5.1, continues, causing size enlargement by agglomerate growth. However, as it proceeds, somewhat more complicated mechanisms evolve. Fig. 5.3 and 5.4 [B.48, B.97] present almost identical explanations of what is happening. While Fig. 5.3 is the more easily understandable series of sketches defining nucleation, random coalescence, abrasion transfer, as well as crushing and layering (preferential coalescence), Fig. 5.4 distinguishes between size enlargement and size reduction phenomena, both of which take place simultaneously. Nucleation, the production of primary agglomerates or “seeds”, occurs when several individual particles adhere to each other. Nucleation is the most difficult and time consuming part of any tumble/growth agglomeration process. Since only a small number of nuclei survives at any given time, this initial part of the growth process is time consuming. As long as individual particles are available they tend to adhere, trying to form nuclei or attach themselves to larger agglomerates. The latter becomes the preferential pro-
5.1 Tumble or Growth Agglomeration Fig. 5.3 Sketches explaining the different processes taking place during tumble/ growth agglomeration [B.48, B.97]
Fig. 5.4 Diagram of the mechanisms involved in size changes during tumble/growth agglomeration [B.48, B.97]
43
44
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
cess because the larger entities with more mass and higher kinetic energy easily “pickup” individual particles and incorporate them into their surface structure. Therefore, to accelerate the tumble/growth agglomeration process specific operating strategies that influence the nucleation stage are commonly applied [B.97]. Most of the industrial tumble/growth agglomeration methods require liquid binders to achieve satisfactory bonding for nucleation and continuing size enlargement. Although these liquids are suitably dispersed, for example by atomization [B.97], the size of the droplets produced by even the finest liquid spray nozzles is often much larger than that of the agglomerate forming primary particles. Therefore, as described by Ennis [5.1], nucleus formation in a dense tumbling particle bed (type I process) occurs as depicted in Fig. 5.5. As a droplet contacts fine particulate solids, the initial distribution of binding liquid, which depends on its wetting characteristics, influences the sizes of the resulting nuclei. Perfect wetting results in relatively strong large primary agglomerates that are saturated with liquid and are consolidated and held together by capillary forces, while imperfect wetting produces moistened particles, which may coalesce later and produce much weaker nuclei with different sizes which, in addition, are prone to attrition. If, on the other hand, a droplet makes contact with a larger entity, i.e., an agglomerate, wetting either results in spreading of the liquid on the surface or, at least partially, penetration into empty pore spaces below (Fig. 5.6). Both result in a moistening of the surface, which then attracts and captures other units, single particles or agglomerates, causing growth. Fig. 5.7 explains schematically the processes [5.1]. As the mass of the growing agglomerates increases they may break apart at structurally weaker areas or as a result of the force of impact. Abrasion will also take place resulting in newly liberated primary particles or small conglomerates, which then try
Fig. 5.5 Nucleus formation in a dense tumbling bed of fine particles [5.1]
5.1 Tumble or Growth Agglomeration Fig. 5.6 Spreading or penetration of a droplet into a powder bed [5.1]
to attach themselves to entities offering better binding conditions (Fig. 5.3 and 5.4). Particularly in batch operations, both mechanisms help to prevent the growth of a few agglomerates to excessively large sizes. To make sure that the production of oversized agglomerates is avoided or, at least, reduced, individually controlled cutting or shredding devices are often installed, which will continuously or intermittently operate and mechanically assist the breakdown of agglomerates (high-density/high-shear methods with abrasion or crushing transfer [B.97]). Depending on the density of the tumbling material, the (changing) mass of the individual agglomerates, and the type of equipment causing agitation, the growth phenomena and, herewith, the agglomerate properties will differ. One reason for change is the varying extent of the previously mentioned naturally occurring or mechanically induced abrasion, break-down, and reagglomeration. Another is how new particles are attached and incorporated into the structure. It is obvious that particle beds, tumbling in rotating equipment or agitated by mixing tools, will produce denser agglomerates than obtained in the low-density particle clouds of fluidized beds.
Fig. 5.7 Processes occurring between particles of a tumbling powder bed after wetting with droplets of a binder liquid [5.1]
45
46
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods Fig. 5.8 Diagram of particle and droplet distribution in a low-density fluidized bed and of particle penetration into a liquid [5.1]
Referring to Fig. 5.8 and comparing it with Fig. 5.6, in low-density fluidized particle beds (type II process), particles and droplets coexist and, in most cases, agglomerates form by particles penetrating into the liquid. This is the prevailing growth phenomenon in re-wet fluidized bed agglomerators, were growth is limited by the requirements of particle fluidization. A more basic growth mechanism in fluidized beds, which resembles that of “natural” agglomeration is obtained if the particle surfaces are moistened by condensing steam in “steam jet agglomeration” [B.97] or by ultrafine liquid droplets (including solutions and suspensions) produced with the “RESS process” [5.2].
Tab. 5.1 Some conditions, reasons, and requirements for the selection of tumble/growth agglomeration. Process conditions Small feed particle size (xo < 100–200 lm) Wet processing Normally, (liquid) binder(s) is (are) required Green (wet) agglomerates with low initial strength Post-treatment for final strength and properties Simple equipment design Control depends largely on operator experience Difficult to clean (danger of cross-contamination) Not amenable to quick turn-over. Product characteristics Irregular (overall spheroidal) shape Final strength depends on binder(s) and post-treatment Wide distribution of agglomerate sizes and weights High porosity High solubility, dispersibility, reactivity, etc. Shelf-life often limited
Cold processing
System “footprint” is large
Small pieces
Low density
5.2 Pressure Agglomeration
During the agglomeration by growth in tumbling particle beds, “natural” adhesion forces, which are either totally inherent, enhanced by suitable methods, introduced by binders, or acting as a combination of two or all of these effects, cause particles to stick together when they collide in a stochastically moving mass of particulate solids. With the exception of forces that are exerted during the interaction between the particles, the environment and equipment walls as well as, in some cases, various mixing and/or shredding tools, no externally induced directional forces or pressures act on the growing agglomerates and no shaping, other than caused by attrition, occurs. As a result, depending on the level of interaction, which is largely influenced by the tumbling bed density, more or less spherical agglomerates are grown featuring a size distribution that depends on the system properties. Because of the relatively small forces caused by interactions in and with the tumbling charge, porosity of the agglomerates is high and increases as bed density decreases. Also, since the adhesion forces are small, too, and separation forces, which try to destroy the growing agglomerates, are mass related, the primary particles forming the agglomerate must be small. Typically, with a few exceptions, temporarily bonded “green” agglomerates are produced, which require posttreatment to achieve permanent, final strength. Narrowly sized products are obtained by additional processing such as sizing, crushing, and shaping or attrition. In summary, Tab. 5.1 compiles some of the conditions, reasons, and requirements that are typical of tumble/growth agglomeration. Of course, this table does not claim to be complete but is meant to provide some guidelines that can be also gleaned in more detail from the discussion above and from other sources (Section 13.1).
5.2
Pressure Agglomeration
In pressure agglomeration, new, enlarged entities are formed by applying external forces to particulate solids in more or less closed dies that define the shape of the agglomerated product. In contrast to tumble/growth agglomeration, pressure agglomeration is used to achieve one or more and sometimes all process conditions and product characteristics summarized in Tab. 5.2. The level of force that is applied during densification and shaping is the most distinguishing factor in pressure agglomeration. Therefore, the technology is subdivided into low-, medium-, and high-pressure techniques. Of course, as will be shown later, certain conditions and characteristics are better obtained with one or the other pressure agglomeration process and, sometimes, one or more of the parameters of Tab. 5.2 can not be met with a specific technique and/or equipment, system, or plant. Each of the great variety of pressure agglomeration methods corresponds to one or more of the binding mechanisms of agglomeration (Chapter 3, Tab. 3.1, Fig. 3.4 and 3.5). While in low- and medium-pressure agglomeration all binding mechanisms are equally possible, in high-pressure agglomeration attraction forces (Fig. 3.5) provide the most common bonding. According to the mechanisms involved, the processes can be again further categorized as those using binders and those without binders. However, all have in common a basic compaction mechanism.
47
48
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods Tab. 5.2 Some conditions, reasons, and requirements for the selection of pressure agglomeration. Process conditions Larger feed particle size Dry processing Hot processing Processing of elastic materials Easy clean-out Product characteristics Specific shape Specific mass (or weight) Low porosity Long shelf-life Amenable to the production of near-net-shape parts
High initial strength No or little binder No post-treatment Automatic operation Quick turn-over Large pieces High density High final strength
The upper part of Fig. 5.9 shows with four model sketches the structural change of a bulk mass of particulate matter during densification in a die, the attendant change in volume, and an indication of the modifications of particle shape and size that occur at high pressure. The lower part of Fig. 5.9 depicts the build-up of pressing force with time under the assumption that the forward movement of the punch occurs with a constant rate until pmax is reached, at which point the direction of movement reverses and the punch retracts with the same or a higher speed. Referring to Fig. 5.9, as a first step, pressure agglomeration achieves a rearrangement of particles that requires little force and does not change particle shape and size. This is followed by a steep rise of pressing force during which brittle particles break and malleable particles deform. Sketches 3 (brittle) and 4 (plastic) occur either/or and often simultaneously if both brittle and malleable particles are present in the mix.
Fig. 5.9
Sketches explaining the mechanism of pressure agglomeration
5.2 Pressure Agglomeration
Two important phenomena limit the speed of compaction and, therefore, the capacity of any pressure agglomeration equipment: compressed residual gas (in most cases air) in the pores and elastic springback. Both cause different, equipment specific cracking and a weakening or, sometimes, total destruction of the products [B.13(b), B.48, B.97]. Low- and medium-pressure agglomeration apply small forces (up to about the beginning of the steep slope of the curve in Fig. 5.9) but, nevertheless, the removal of a relatively large amount of gas must be guaranteed (the time axis is directly proportional to the volume change since the punch advances with constant speed). Development of compressed gas pockets within the densifying product can be avoided if compaction occurs slowly enough for all gas to escape from the diminishing pore space. High-pressure agglomeration extends into the steep increase of the pressing force. In this range, particle size and shape change by breakage and or deformation and porosity is further reduced. The maximum pressing force is normally defined by an overload feature of the equipment. Since a predetermined final strength and structure must be reached, equipment selection must take into consideration that a sufficiently high maximum pressing force can be attained. After arriving at the maximum pressing force, pressure is released. If, as shown in Fig. 5.9, compaction is performed by a punch in a die, the direction of travel of the piston reverses and, when no expansion of the densified body occurs, the pressing force should drop to zero immediately. In reality, there is always a more or less pronounced rebound, which is caused by the expansion of compressed gas and the relaxation of elastic deformation. This effect becomes more pronounced with increasing speed of densification until, at a certain compression rate, the compacted body disintegrates partially or totally upon de-pressurization. Therefore, it is often necessary to find an optimal compromise between densification speed (capacity) and product integrity (quality). The problem becomes greater with finer particles because such materials are naturally more cohesive and, therefore, in the feed state, feature lower bulk density or higher bulk volume. In these cases, cohesive arches will collapse at low pressure whereby large amounts of gas are driven out. At the same time, pores between fine particles are small, which results in low diffusivity so it takes a relatively long time for the large amount of displaced gas to escape. To help overcome problems associated with degassing or deaeration, special design features, such as force feeders and/or various provisions for venting, are applied with all pressure agglomeration methods, particularly if fine powders must be processed [B.97]. If the mechanism of densification is considered (refer to the sketches in the upper part of Fig. 5.9), it becomes clear that the pores in the feed to a pressure agglomeration process of any kind must not be filled completely (saturated) with a liquid. An example of such a material would be a normal filter cake: one that has not been blown dry or otherwise further de-watered. Since liquids are incompressible, the pressing force would increase quickly and mechanical de-watering would have to occur, which further reduces the speed of densification. It would also require an effective separation of solids and liquid during the densification process; this is a problem that has not yet been solved. Therefore, with increasing pressure applied to the particulate solids, which typically results in higher densification or lower porosity, the moisture content
49
50
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods Fig. 5.10 Diagram of equipment for: a) low-; b) medium-pressure agglomeration: a1, screen; a2, basket; a3, radial; a4, dome; a5, axial; b1, screw; b2, flat die; b3–b5, different designs of cylindrical dies; b6, gear
of the feed must diminish. In high-pressure agglomeration the feed must be essentially dry. The equipment in which pressure agglomeration occurs is a machine that operates with well-defined mechanical parameters that are independent of the performance and characteristics of the particulate solids to be processed. Therefore, pressure agglomeration techniques lend themselves readily to automation and remote control and are essentially independent of operator presence and/or skill. Because the equipment is relatively complex and the throughput per unit is often limited, this technology finds its greatest usage in low- to medium-sized applications (about 0.1–50 t/h). Of course, this statement is relative. Specialty products, such as those in the pharmaceutical industry (Section 6.2.2), may be processed in very small and sophisticated machinery, handling only a few kilograms per hour, while certain high-tonnage materials, for example some fertilizer, refractory, and mineral materials, are briquetted or compacted in large facilities employing multiple units (Sections 6.6.2 to 6.10.2). Relatively uniformly shaped and sized agglomerates can be obtained with low- and medium-pressure agglomeration. For these processes, the feed mixture must still be made-up of relatively small particles and inherently available, activated, or externally added binders (above). The moist, often sticky mass of particulate solids as well as plastic and liquid binders is extruded through holes in differently shaped screens or perforated dies (Fig. 5.10). Agglomeration and shaping are caused by the pressure
5.2 Pressure Agglomeration
forcing the mass through the holes and by the frictional forces developing during the material’s passage. Depending on the plasticity of the feed mix and the dimensions of the holes, short “crumbly”, elongated “spaghetti-like”, or cylindrical green extrudates are produced. Particularly the thin, string shaped agglomerates that are obtained from low-pressure agglomeration (Fig. 5.10, a1–a5) are often spheronized, that is, rolled into small spherical particles while the product is still plastic [B.48, B.97]. In most cases a post-treatment (typically drying and cooling) is required to yield final, permanent strength. As far as applicability is concerned, high-pressure agglomeration (Fig. 5.11) is the most versatile technique for the size enlargement of particulate solids by agglomeration. If certain characteristics of the feed materials and conditions occurring during densification are considered during equipment selection as well as plant design and operation, dry particulate solids of any kind and size, from nanometers to centimeters, and at any condition, for example with temperatures from below freezing to 1000 8C, can be successfully processed. Typically, the products from high-pressure agglomeration feature high strength immediately after discharge from the equipment. Nevertheless, to further increase strength, addition of a small amount of binder and/or post-treatment methods are possible. An advantage of high-pressure agglomeration is that, as discussed above, in most cases, essentially dry solids are processed, which do not tend to set, so that the process can be stopped at almost any time and re-started easily; also, the amount of material in the system is relatively small. Therefore, pressure agglomeration methods, specifically those applying high pressure, lend themselves particularly well to batch or shift operation and to applications in which several products must be manufactured from different feed mixtures in the same unit. At the end of a campaign, the system can be easily and completely emptied in a relatively short time. If the danger for crosscontamination is unimportant, for example in the fertilizer industry, a new campaign
Fig. 5.11 Diagram of equipment for high-pressure agglomeration. Ram press (upper left), punch and die press (upper right), roller presses for compaction (lower left) and briquetting (lower right)
51
52
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
Fig. 5.12 Cycles of force build-up in the three different high-pressure agglomeration techniques
with a different feed can be started immediately (Section 6.6.2). Another possibility for fast and quick change-over is to install different feed and product discharge/handling systems as, in most cases (for example the pharmaceutical industry, Section 6.2.2), the expensive pressure densification/shaping equipment itself can be easily cleaned or adapted to the manufacturing of a new product. The above-mentioned destructive effects of expanding compressed air and relaxation of elastic deformation can be reduced if the maximum pressure is held for some time, called dwell time, before it is released. Fig. 5.12 shows that, without special
5.3 Agglomeration by Heat/Sintering
technical provisions, this is only achieved in ram extruders (Fig. 5.11, upper left). In such equipment, a number of briquettes are retained in the long pressing channel and are redensified during each stroke. After the wall friction is overcome and the entire line of briquettes moves forward, the pressing force remains almost constant (Fig. 5.12b). A similar, but much smaller effect is obtained in pellet presses (Fig. 5.10, b1–b6). Since a dwell time and, particularly, the application of several densification cycles also helps to convert temporary elastic deformation into permanent plastic deformation, these techniques are especially suitable for the densification of elastic materials such as, for example, biomass. If a dwell time is required or desired in punch-and-die presses (Fig. 5.11, upper right), special drive systems must be used [B.48, B.97]. It is obvious from Fig. 5.11, lower left and right, that no such possibility exists in roller presses where a continuous rolling action densifies the material between approaching surfaces until, immediately after passing the point of closest approximation, the relative motion is reversed, the surfaces retract, and the pressing force drops, ideally to zero if no expansion due to compressed gas and/or stored elastic energy takes place.
5.3
Agglomeration by Heat/Sintering
At a certain elevated temperature, which is different for various materials and can be quite low for organic products or very high for minerals, atoms and molecules begin to migrate across the interface where particles touch each other. While still in solid state, depending on temperature, time, and intensity of contact (caused by pressure during the manufacturing of a pre-form or the sintering process itself), diffusion of matter forms bridge-like structures between the surfaces, which solidify upon cooling. The process may also result in a densification of the compact, which is due to an elimination of pores and associated shrinkage. The entire group of phenomena is called sintering [B.13(c), B.97]. Agglomeration by heat or sintering has been developed and is applied mostly in industries processing minerals and ores for the size enlargement of fines before further use (Section 6.8.3). Because the technology requires large amounts of thermal energy, special efforts are made to recover heat or use sources of waste heat. The resulting agglomerates are crude but meet the requirements of the industry. Another large application of sintering in agglomeration is in post-treatment where the phenomenon is used to produce strong permanent bonds and/or specific final properties in many parts that may have been manufactured by virtually any one of the other agglomeration techniques. Particularly in powder metallurgy, sintering is the most important finishing process for the achievement of final strength and structure (Chapter 7). More recently, in this field and for other post-treatment processes, it has been found that several mechanisms exist that cause material transport at elevated temperatures for bridging and, thus, strengthening of the preform or the agglomerate, but do not result in shrinkage. Therefore, sintering can also yield strong final products with high porosity [B.78, B.97].
53
54
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
5.4
Technologies Using the Phenomena and Fundamentals of Agglomeration for Purposes other than Size Enlargement
Among the technologies that use the phenomena and fundamentals of agglomeration for purposes other than size enlargement the oldest is coating, which was first used to avoid the sticking together of pills and/or to mask the taste of the often unpleasantly tasting medicinal remedies. The coating material was either applied as a fine naturally occurring powder (such as pollen) together with some moisture or as a natural (e.g., nectar) or man-made sugar solution. The coating was made permanent by drying (originally by the heat of the sun). Today this technology has evolved into an important field of solids processing [B.48, B.97]. It is used in almost all industries that are specifically covered in Chapter 6 and has further potentials in many other applications. The most common modern methods employ equipment similar to that utilized in tumble agglomeration [B.97]. Inclined pans, often pear shaped, are applied for simple coatings (for example in the food industry for sugar or chocolate covers, Section 6.4.3) and sophisticated drum designs are used widely if coatings with uniform distribution and well-controlled thickness are required (for example in the pharmaceutical industry for functional layers, Section 6.2.3). Fine solid particles and a liquid binder, solutions, or suspensions are sprayed onto or into the tumbling bed of solids that are to be coated and form a temporary wet layer on their surface. Gas (normally dry hot air) is simultaneously passed through the bed, evaporating the liquid and leaving a solid coating,
Fig. 5.13 Sketch of the material processing section of a bottom spray fluidized bed coater (Wurster coating system) [B.97]
5.4 Technologies Using the Phenomena and Fundamentals of Agglomeration for Purposes
Fig. 5.14
Diagram of possible structures of microcapsules [B.97]
the thickness of which grows as the process continues. Unique design features have been developed with regard to the shape of the container used for tumbling, the feeding of solids (if any), the spraying of the liquid, and the input as well as exhaust of the drying gas [B.97]. Another technique sprays melts onto the moving bed of particles, which form a coat that solidifies upon cooling with a flow of ambient air (Section 6.6.3). The stochastic movement in low-density fluidized beds is used for coating relatively small particles with narrow particle size distribution. Many of the newer designs use some modification of the Wurster coater [B.48, B.97] (Fig. 5.13).
55
56
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
Fig. 5.15 Diagram depicting the process of hybridization and microphotographs showing particles with intermediate as well as final coating [B.97]
A further coating method is encapsulation, most commonly called microencapsulation [B.48, B.97]. It is a packaging technique that enrobes powders, particles, liquids, or even gases and forms free flowing, dustfree particulate products. The most basic method makes use of the capillary flow of liquid and the recrystallization of dissolved (or deposition of colloidal) solids on the surface of saturated wet agglomerates during drying. More recently, technologies are being developed in which the capsule features a specific, well-defined functionality. The capsule material may offer controlled-release characteristics (e.g., pharmaceutical products, Section 6.2.3), insolubility and well-defined bursting strength (e.g., “dry” inks and toners, Section 6.11.3), delayed availability (e.g., agrochemicals, Section 6.6.3), and other properties. Fig. 5.14 describes schematically the possible structures of microcapsules. As shown in Fig. 5.14d, bottom, heterogeneous coatings on a core can be also fixed by embedding. The processes that accomplish this are called mechanofusion or hybridization [B.97]. Mechanical forces act either on a previously deposited layer or on systems consisting of larger core and ultrafine coating particles. Often the core particles are relatively soft and inert with the coating providing functionality (for example
5.4 Technologies Using the Phenomena and Fundamentals of Agglomeration for Purposes
Fig. 5.16 Overview diagram describing manipulation techniques for small solid particles [5.3]
Fig. 5.17 Precise arrangement of SiO2 spheres on pinpointed locations: a) voltage contrast image of a dotted line; b) silica spheres arranged on the dotted line [5.3]
57
58
5 Beneficial Uses of Agglomeration: Agglomeration Technologies and Methods
electrical conductivity, Section 6.11.3) by embedding in the surface (Fig. 5.15). Because the coating particles are often so small that no dislocations are present in their structure, they behave as very hard entities. Therefore, it is, for example, possible to embed ultrafine titanium particles in the surface of glass spheres. A very new group of methods for the deposition and bonding of particulate solids onto surfaces assembles nano- to micrometer sized particles in a predetermined and orderly fashion onto substrates [5.3]. Fig. 5.16 gives an overview of the two groups of manipulation techniques that are available. While with the upper methods particles can be deposited with great accuracy but low rate, with the lower ones larger numbers of particles can be delivered with less accuracy. The limitations of both can be overcome if the intended locations of the particles are predetermined by electrification with a focused ion beam (FIB). Fig. 5.17a is the voltage contrast image of a line in which the dots where formed by the impingement of a Ga+-FIB. The spacing of the dots is 5 lm. As shown in Fig. 5.17b, 5 lm silica spheres are attracted to the dotted electrified line and form an almost perfect array of particles. Microdevices or microstructures with multi-functions (Chapter 11) can be obtained after permanently fastening and interconnecting the particles with the substrate and with each other, for example by sintering.
Further Reading
With exception of the following: B.14, B.20, B.23, B.27, B.30, B.42, B.75, B.81, B.91, B.103, B.104, all publications listed in Chapter 13.1 are recommended for further reading.
59
6
Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration All techniques of beneficial size enlargement by agglomeration yield products that feature some or all of the advantages listed in Tab. 6.1. In certain cases many of the characteristics are desired, but sometimes one specific requirement may be the sole reason for adopting a suitable agglomeration method in a manufacturing line. Agglomerated materials may constitute final products, such as tabletted pharmaceutical specialties (Section 6.2), pelleted animal feed (Section 6.5), instant drink concentrates (Section 6.4), briquetted solid fuels (Section 6.10) and so on, or intermediate products, such as granulated pharmaceutical formulations as feed for tabletting
Tab. 6.1
General advantages of agglomerated products
Enlarged apparent size. No or low content of dust. Increased safety during the handling of, for example, toxic or explosive (highly reactive) materials. Fewer losses (by dusting or elutriation). Less primary and/or secondary pollution. Freely flowing. Improved storage and handling characteristics. Better metering and dosing capabilities. Reduced tendency of unwanted agglomeration. Increased bulk density and reduced bulk volume. Smaller size of packages and storage or transportation volume. No segregation of co-agglomerated materials. More uniform supply of multi-component materials to users. Defined size and shape. Sometimes defined weight of each agglomerate (dosage form). Distribution may be narrowed by post treatment (sizing). Shape may be modified by post treatment (e.g. spheronizing). Within limits, porosity or density can be controlled. Possibility to influence dispersibility, solubility, reactivity, heat conductivity, or other related properties. Improved product appeal Material properties can be adjusted to meet government, local, or industry standards or requirements. Higher sales value and increased profit potential. Agglomeration in Industry. Wolfgang Pietsch Copyright ª 2005 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ISBN 3-527-30582-3
60
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
presses (Section 6.2), briquetted DMT (di-methyl therephtalate) flakes for safe and economic shipment to the fiber production plants (Section 6.3), agglomerated silica fume to reduce its volume and improve the handling characteristics during transportation (Section 6.7), and so on. The most common reason for size enlargement by agglomeration is, as the term implies, the desire or need to obtain a product with larger particle dimensions. As described in Chapter 3, the resulting entity is only apparently a new unit. The original solid particles are still present in the structure [B.97], often with a completely unaltered shape and size, and are held together by binding mechanisms. Furthermore, the new entity features porosity: voids between the agglomerate-forming particles (Chapter 3). This is beneficial in some cases, for example, for easily dispersible food (Section 6.4) and pigment (Section 6.3) granules, for “designer” foods (Section 6.4), and for catalyst carriers (Section 6.11), or undesirable in others, as in hot densification of sponge iron (DRI) to reduce reactivity (Section 6.9) and high-density ceramic (Section 6.7) and powder metallurgical (Chapter 7) parts. As a further result of this modification of the original particulate solids, many bulk characteristics of the new product are changed too, mostly for the better. For example, larger particles have less dust, exhibit improved flow behavior, and feature much-reduced sticking tendencies. Therefore, storage, handling, and feeding is less risky, even for “difficult” materials. After production, many modern particulate solid materials are very aerated and remain loose, largely due to their small particle size and high surface area, which cause instant, natural adhesion and prohibit consolidation by settling. If packaged, loaded, or stored, such products occupy large volumes and require excessively large containers for packaging or big silos. During agglomeration the natural adhesive bonds are broken and the individual particles are bonded more closely together, resulting in higher density, so that the aforementioned problems are eliminated. If mixtures are agglomerated after blending, the distribution of the different components is fixed in the agglomerates and thereafter segregation is avoided. Agglomerated products are better sized and shaped and often can be used as solid dosage forms. Their properties may be adjusted to meet specific requirements by influencing the agglomerate structure, either directly or by post-treatments. Generally, many agglomerated materials have better appeal and command higher prices and profits. After agglomeration some particulate solids exhibit properties that are undesirable for their use or application. In most cases, these negative characteristics relate to the new porosity of the agglomerate, which may be, for example, too low for easy dispersibility, or too high, resulting in excessive reactivity. Bad product properties can also be caused by unsuitable binding mechanisms, for example absorbents for liquids may disintegrate when wetted or, vice versa, a binder in water-dispersible granules may not dissolve when the product is submerged in the liquid. More recently, agglomeration has entered new fields in which individual particles, mostly in the nanometer size range, are attached to each other or to substrates in a controlled fashion (Chapter 11). Areas of application include the manufacturing of new composite materials with novel characteristics and of microscopic structures for electrical circuits or material associations on a molecular level. The latter result
6.1 General Applications
in the evolution of unique drug-delivery systems or life-science products, while the former is increasingly used for electronics and in the communication industries. In the following sections examples of specific applications of beneficial agglomeration by size enlargement in different industries are presented. According to the commonly used classification of the available methods (Chapter 5) they are subdivided into tumble/growth, pressure, and other agglomeration technologies. The latter include agglomeration by heat/sintering and technologies using the phenomena and fundamentals of agglomeration for purposes other than size enlargement, such as coating and some of the already industrially applied technologies involving nanoparticles for the building of new engineered materials and novel particle-modification technologies.
6.1
General Applications The most general application of beneficial size enlargement by agglomeration is the granulation of powders. Basically, the terms “granules” or “granulate” mean relatively coarse (0.1–10 mm) particulate solids (Chapter 14). Contrary to the often performed granulation of solids by crushing (the size reduction of larger solid pieces), granulation of powders uses the technologies of size enlargement to achieve the same goal, the production of a “granular” product. Although with regard to the overall granulometry both products are similar or even identical, physically they are different. Granular material obtained by the crushing of solids consists of particles that have similar structure to the solid from which they were produced. Because failure during crushing begins preferentially at imperfections (dislocations, faults, cracks, inclusions, and other defects), the smaller particles become increasingly more homogeneous and, with decreasing size, approach the structure of the ideal solid. In contrast, the granulation of powders involves binding mechanisms and suitable processing of fine and/or ultrafine particulate solids. The individual particles are brought closely together during impacts or by applying external forces. At that instant, binding forces that are larger than the separating forces caused by the ambient conditions (Fig. 3.6 and [B.48, B.97]), develop between the solid surfaces, resulting in particles sticking together. By these mechanisms, larger units develop by growth or as defined by a die in or by which they are formed. However, the new entities are only seemingly solid. In reality, unless modified by a post-treatment procedure (Chapter 7), the resulting agglomerates are made-up from the largely unaltered powder particles, retaining most of these particle characteristics, and feature porosity, that is interconnected voids, which may represent a volume percentage as high as 95 % or more and as low as 5 % or less. Granular products from powders may be produced by tumble/growth agglomeration (Section 6.1.1); while some are immediately in the correct size range, others re-
61
62
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
quire post-treatment and/or sizing to remove over- and under-sized materials. In the latter case, it is necessary to consider what to do with the rejects. In many cases, large agglomerates are produced first, to make use of economical tumble/growth and pressure agglomeration or sintering methods (Sections 6.1.1, 6.1.2 and 6.1.3); the pieces resulting from these procedures are then crushed to form the granular material. Effective size reduction into a defined size range (granulation), whereby over- and undersized particles must be kept within certain narrow limits, is a fundamental problem of fracture mechanics. Moreover the failure mode of solids is different from that of agglomerates. Therefore, these phenomena and how they influence granulation will be described in more detail below. Granulation of solids by crushing, results in a product distribution that typically includes oversized and undersized particles. The size distribution of the discharge from a crusher depends (among many other parameters) on the stressing mechanism (Figs. 4.3 and 4.4, Chapter 4). Other important influences are the feed size and shape, the energy input, the crushing tool and chamber configuration, and the reduction ratio, which is a characteristic derived from the previous variables. The larger the reduction ratio (the difference between feed and product size, Fig. 4.3), the higher the energy input must be and the more fines are produced. When a solid body is stressed, which requires the addition of energy from the outside, the tensions that are produced within stretch all bonds between the molecules. Theoretically, if the solid features an ideal structure with no imperfections and only tensile forces are applied, the bonds separate in a structural plane in which the load exceeds the bond strength and the solid splits cleanly into two parts. Then all other areas return to their equilibrium structure, and the unused energy is freed and converted into other forms: kinetic and thermal energy and/or sound. However, real solids contain many flaws, which become stress raisers and initiate cracks at loads much below those required for the separation of an ideal body, even if only tensile forces are applied. The stressed system is unstable and cracks expand rapidly, accelerating to high propagation velocities: only the bonds at the crack tips are breaking at any instant. Under combined stresses, the normal condition in an industrial crushing situation, many cracks will be initiated and propagate in a direction perpendicular to the local tensile stress but, sooner or later, they run into a region of compression, which stops further crack growth [B.12]. Therefore, the highest number of cracks will be initiated and cause failure near the point(s) of energy input. Also, if primary fractures relieve the
Fig. 6.1-1 Diagram of failure lines in single spherical and irregular particles during: left) compression. right) impact crushing [B.12]
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-2 Photographs of: a) the fines cone; b) coarse residual pieces obtained during impact crushing of a single glass sphere [6.1.1]
stress sufficiently rapidly, vibrations are induced that result in new tensile stresses and may cause secondary fractures. As shown in Fig. 6.1-1, mainly fine material is produced when a high energy density is released at or near the point(s) of energy input. The volume of the fines cones and, therefore, the mass of fines grow with increasing energy input or, in other words, with larger reduction ratio. Fig. 6.1-2 shows the fines cone and coarse residual pieces obtained during the impact-crushing of a single glass sphere [6.1.1]. Since the main objective of the crushing of solids is to achieve a certain fineness and avoid oversized particles, many impact crushers and mills (e.g., hammer mills) feature some sort of a restriction (bar cage, screen, or perforated plate) at the discharge from the chamber in which the material is stressed. This exit grate, screen, or perforated plate retains material in the chamber until it is small enough to pass through the openings. Although this eliminates the presence of oversized particles in the product, a number of problems can or will arise. *
*
*
*
Such a measure will increase the amount of fines, as each stressing event will produce fines as discussed above. A finer than desired product may be produced because particles that are just below the size of the openings have a low probability of exiting it and, therefore, are retained, stressed again, and broken to finer sizes. To reduce this effect, the exit grid may be increased which, of course, increases the danger of oversized particles in the product. Depending on the requirements on size distribution this measure may not be acceptable. If crushers operate near their upper capacity limit, temporary or permanent choking of the grinding chamber may occur, requiring downtimes for clean-out.
63
64
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration *
*
If the solid feed contains hard inclusions, selective crushing may occur. Hard, difficult-to-crush particles may remain larger than the openings of the exit grid and accumulate within the chamber, eventually also causing choking. Finally, but not least important, the exit restriction is a highly stressed part. It needs frequent maintenance (exchange or rebuilding) and, in some cases, for example in the ultraclean food and pharmaceutical industries but also in other applications where minute contaminations with iron or alloying components cause problems (for example, discoloration of glass when small amounts of iron are present), are not acceptable.
Large amounts of fines are produced by different mechanisms and increase with energy input or larger reduction ratio. They are often undesirable in the final product, so most of them must be removed by sizing, for example by screening or air classification. Although these fines normally have the same composition as the solid and, therefore are potentially valuable, they were traditionally discarded as waste. Size enlargement by agglomeration makes it possible to produce materials from fines for recycling or for use as undesirableecondary raw materials (Section 8.2). Nevertheless, since the conversion of fines into products for beneficial use is costly, it is more economical to minimize the production of fines during crushing. When the mechanisms that occur during size reduction of solids were first described by Rittinger [6.1.2] and later modified by Griffith [6.1.3] it became clear that to minimize fines production, a low energy input must be used. While this measure reduces fines, a substantial amount of oversized material is also obtained, which must be restressed. As shown in Fig. 6.1-3aa the simplest solution to this problem is to separate the larger pieces from the discharge and recirculate them to the mill, which must be oversized to be capable of handling the considerably greater throughput. As mentioned before, particles (of any size) in the milled product tend to be stronger because imperfections have been removed. Therefore, the optimal energy input for crushing oversized particles that resulted from a primary size-reduction event is increased. The arrangement shown in Fig. 6.1-3ab, whereby the second mill operates at a higher energy input than the first one, would seem to be appropriate. Although a somewhat improved result (narrower product size distribution with less fines) is obtained from both mills, they do not represent an optimized solution, because system ab still produces some oversized particles, which may have to be removed and otherwise used or (Fig. 6.1-3ac), possibly recirculated to the second mill (“closed loop” handling of larger pieces). Today it is commonly understood [6.1.4] that, from an energetic point of view, sizereduction processes are considered optimal when: *
* *
the particles to be crushed obtain a specific stressing energy directly from the milling tools (which may include grinding media and specially designed chamber walls) an undefined interaction between particles does not occur energy is not wasted on particles that are already fine enough – such materials are removed from the chamber
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-3 Diagrams of a crusher with oversize recycling and various two- or three-stage crushing circuits [6.1.4]. Circles represent crushers or mills; horizontal lines flanked by + and – represent classifiers (screens) that split the crushed material into over- and undersized particles. “A” is an air-classifier that removes fines by entrainment
65
66
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration *
fines that tend to interfere with the controlled energy input are eliminated, both prior to and during size reduction.
With this in mind, Fig. 6.1-3ba depicts a much better system, which can be further improved (if all particles above a certain size must be eliminated) by recirculating the secondary crusher discharge into the classifier (Fig. 6.1-3bb). Alternatively, a second classifier separates oversized particles from the secondary crusher and only recirculates this portion to the secondary crusher (Fig. 6.1-3bc). If the emphasis is on reducing fines in the product and optimizing performance of the secondary crusher, an air classifier to remove fines by entrainment could be installed between the primary and secondary crushers (Fig. 6.1-3bd). Figs. 6.1-3ca, cb, and cc show the next step of optimization, which is three-stage crushing. Depending on the quality requirements on the final product, more grinding steps and/or additional closed loops can be added, on the understanding that crushing circuits become more expensive with each step. Therefore, a compromise between best result and cost must be found. In the sketches of Fig. 6.1-3 it has been assumed that by optimizing crushing the amount of fines has been reduced to such an extent that they can remain in the product, but fines elimination at the end of the circuit, possibly by installing a screen or similar separator for fines, may be necessary as a final quality adjustment step. As defined by the method of energy input, excluding shear, there are two main crushing mechanisms: compression and impact (Fig. 6.1-1). Although the above comments are valid for both mechanisms, the explanations referred more directly to impact stressing. As shown in Fig. 4.3 (Chapter 4), the importance of the reduction ratio for the outcome of milling is even more important when compression is applied. If the reduction ratio is too high, flat agglomerates are formed in which coarser pieces that are in at least one dimension smaller than the narrowest final distance or gap, are embedded in fines. Since the fine particles are immediately compacted after formation, almost all free valences at the newly created surfaces participate in recombination bonding [Chapter 3, B.48]. Recently it was found that compared with the stochastic milling process in a tube mill with grinding media, the combination of well-defined compression stressing in a high-pressure roller mill with large reduction ratio (Fig. 4.3) and the ensuing disagglomeration of the compacted flakes that were produced result in a significantly lower overall energy consumption during the fine grinding of brittle materials, such as cement clinker and many ores. Nevertheless, during “normal” crushing of solids by compression, either between two approaching flat (jaw crusher) or curved (roller mill) surfaces, the formation of compacted flakes or similar agglomerates must be avoided. This can be only achieved if relatively small reduction ratios are applied. In Fig. 6.1-3 it can be seen that a certain amount of oversized material is produced after a particular crushing step and the corresponding system sketches of Fig. 6.1-3 can be applied whereby the second, third, or potentially higher-stage compression crushers feature decreasing gap sizes (as compared with higher energy input, mostly defined by speed, in the case of impact crushers).
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-4 Diagram of multi-stage crushing between three sets of rollers and photographs of two-stage and three-stage Gran-U-Lizer roller mills (courtesy Modern Process Equipment, Inc. (MPE), Chicago, IL, USA)
If rollers are used for crushing, several sets with decreasing gaps can be installed in the same housing (Fig. 6.1-4). Because the material flows through the machine under the influence of gravity, and if the throughput is such that the nip area is not overfed (no pile-up), fines produced in the first stage that are smaller than the gap width of the second stage pass it without additional stressing while larger particles are crushed. This is demonstrated in Fig. 6.1-5, which shows the comparison of typical cumulative particle size distributions after crushing solids in a single stage roller mill and an MPE
Fig. 6.1-5 Comparison of typical cumulative particle size distributions after crushing solids in a singlestage roller mill and an MPE Gran-U-Lizer with three sets of rollers. Note the much reduced amount of oversize (shaded area) and the almost unchanged amount of fines (courtesy Modern Process Equipment, Inc. (MPE), Chicago, IL, USA)
67
68
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.1-6 Diagrams of various arrangements of profiled rolls for roller mills: a) peak-to-valley arrangement showing the “cracking” of a particle; b) parameters determining control of the particle size in a peak-to-valley arrangement; c) peak-to-peak arrangement; d) example of a peak-to-valley arrangement with modified pitch and gap (courtesy Modern Process Equipment, Inc. (MPE), Chicago, IL, USA)
Gran-U-Lizer with three sets of rollers. The shaded area, upper right, depicts the much-reduced amount of oversize material after three-stage roller mill crushing, while the amount of fines (lower left) remains almost unchanged. For certain materials and applications, the result of crushing in roller mills can be improved by using profiled roller surfaces. Fig. 6.1-6a shows a circumferentially grooved pair of rollers with a “peak-to-valley” arrangement and how a particle is crushed between such rollers. The mating peaks and valleys on the rollers act as fulcrum points that actually “crack” a particle that is bridged as shown. Variables that influence the result of crushing are: the pitch and gap adjustment (Fig. 6.1-6b) and the positioning of the matching rollers. Fig. 6.1-6a and b describe the staggered arrangement (peak-to-valley); another possibility is a directly opposed arrangement (peak-to-peak, Fig. 6.1-6c. Fig. 6.1-6d shows, as an example, another pitch and gap in a peak-to-valley arrangement. The granulation of powders by size enlargement, whereby agglomerates are first formed, then crushed into the desired particle size range, and finally classified to obtain the desired product size distribution, is even more difficult to analyze than the complex size reduction of solids. The reason for this is twofold. 1. During the crushing of solids the production of fines is expected, often with a certain amount desired, and in other cases the production of fine particles is the sole objective of the operation, but the optimal result of the granulation of powders by agglomeration and crushing would be to produce no fines at all. This is understandable as powders are, by definition, fines and granulation is performed to produce larger particles. However, since the formation of fines can not be totally avoided, it is most important to select methods that minimize this effect.
6.1 General Applications
2. Agglomerates are assemblages of powder particles that are joined together by binding mechanisms. If compared with the (ideal) structure of the solid itself, where atoms and molecules are held together by intermolecular attraction forces (valence forces) and form regular arrangements, which depend on the type of the atoms and molecules and on the formation mechanism, the structure of agglomerates is made up of irregularly arranged small particles with different size and shape and features void spaces (porosity). Because small particles contain few structural irregularities and flaws, their strength is high and always exceeds that of the binding mechanism acting between the solids. As a result of this characteristic property of all agglomerates, it is easy to break them into the powder particles from which they were originally made. Therefore, breaking down larger agglomerates into smaller, but still agglomerated granules (featuring sizes that are greater than those of the agglomerate-forming primary particles) must be done with gentle, low-energy methods to avoid the formation of excessive amounts of fines. Harsh methods of stressing and high energy input may
Fig. 6.1-7 Diagram of the structure of different agglomerates: a) tumble/growth agglomeration; b) low- and medium-pressure agglomeration (extrusion); c) high-pressure agglomeration
69
70
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
easily produce solids that are, at least partially, finer than the particles from which the agglomerates were originally made. Generally, the same measures must be applied for agglomerates as described above for solids to obtain a good result from granulation without the production of excessive amounts of fines. This means that the energy input should be selected so that the agglomerate to be granulated breaks into as many large fragments as possible with minimum fines production at the points of stress initiation. Because of the porous structure and the method of creating strength (bonding at coordination points, Chapter 3), application of shear is particularly detrimental to avoiding fines. Powder particles can be easily removed from agglomerates by abrasion, especially from the surfaces of freshly produced fragments. Therefore, the use of exit grates or screens in crushers to retain larger material in the milling chamber and avoid oversized particles in the product is a sure way of creating additional fines when granulating agglomerates. Referring back to Fig. 6.1-3, single-stage impact milling of agglomerates should employ the system depicted in aa. In single-stage compression crushing, recirculation of oversized particles is ineffective. Both types of crushing can be optimized by applying two or more crushing stages. Systems bc and cd are particularly well-suited if impact milling is used, while compression stressing is best carried out in roller mills with multiple sets of rolls (Fig. 6.1-4) and profiled roll surface (Fig. 6.1-6). An additional peculiarity of the granulation of powders by agglomeration and crushing is due to the fact that most agglomerates to be reduced in size feature different structure, strength, and/or density over the cross section of the body. Large agglomerates resulting from tumble/growth agglomeration are produced in dense moving particle beds (in drum or mixer agglomerators [B.48, B.97]). According to the agglomeration mechanism in such equipment (Chapter 5), powder particles adhere to the outside surface of nuclei or intermediate aggregates and, if the bond is stronger than the sum of all separating system forces (Fig. 3.6) become an integral part of the growing entity. As the mass of the agglomerate becomes larger, under the influence of kinetic and reaction forces from the surrounding material and equipment walls, the newly attached particles may be more tightly embedded in the current surface structure of the agglomerate. Therefore, it is possible that the density and strength are increasing towards the surface of large agglomerates that have been produced by tumble/growth mechanisms in dense particle beds, particularly if these bodies feature onion-skin structure (Fig. 6.1-7a1) [B.48]. As described in Chapter 5, tumble/growth agglomeration occurs almost always in the presence of a liquid binder, which wets the solid particles and derives strength from surface tension and capillary forces. Such bonding is only temporary because if the liquid evaporates and no other binding mechanism takes over, the agglomerate looses its entire strength. The most common secondary binding mechanisms that develop during drying of wet or moist agglomerates are the recrystallization of dissolved substances or the deposition of colloidal particles at coordination points within the agglomerate (Chapter 3, [B.48, B.71]). If the pores within an agglomerate are completely or partly filled with liquid (Fig. 3-1b and Fig. 3-2d and e, Chapter 3), drying
6.1 General Applications
begins on the surface of the body and the drying zone remains there as long as liquid is replenished from the interior by capillary flow. Only when pores cease to be filled continuously, will the drying zone move into the agglomerate. During the first phase of drying, which takes place only on the entity surface, dissolved substances or suspended particles will deposit on or near the surface, resulting in a strong and dense crust [B.48, B.71]. Since large agglomerates made by tumble/growth methods require a high moisture content to reach bigger sizes and crushing for the production of a granular product always occurs after drying, when the permanent binding mechanism has developed, it is common that such agglomerates feature a strong surface layer and a looser core (Fig. 6.1-7a2). In extrusion (low- and medium-pressure agglomeration, Fig. 5-10, Chapter 5) the force causing densification results from friction between the material and the die channel. In addition to a somewhat higher density close to the die wall, as compared with the center of the extrudate, due to force dissipation, shear from the sliding motion of the material in the channel produces a “skin” on the surface (Fig. 6.1-7b). The extent of this effect depends on the forces applied, which are a function of the equipment and the material characteristics, and on the length of the extrusion mold. It is more pronounced in products from medium-pressure agglomeration and almost not noticeable if wet powder masses are passed through screens (low-pressure agglomeration). In high-pressure agglomeration, particulate solids are compressed and densified in confined-volume, open-ended, or converging dies (Fig. 5.12, Chapter 5). When forces (or pressures) are applied onto particulate solids they dissipate at the contact points of one particle with other particles surrounding it. Because each particle contacts several others and the number of contact points increases during densification, the forces decrease quickly towards the center of the compact. This dissipation becomes larger with smaller particles, and if forces are introduced from opposite sides, a neutral plane exists where the directional sign of the acting forces changes. The location of the neutral plane depends on the size and direction of the opposing forces [B.28, B.48]. As a result of this dissipation of forces, particulate solids are more densified near the points or planes where the external forces are exerted onto the particulate mass and less dense in more distant locations. While, normally, there is a rather well-defined highly densified surface layer, overall a density gradient exists towards the center or the agglomerate. Because strength is strongly dependent on porosity (the opposite of density) and decreases with increasing porosity (or lower density), a strength gradient also exists across the agglomerated body. Fig. 6.1-7 shows the situations; the shaded areas feature high density and strength: c1, briquette from high-pressure ram extrusion or cylindrical compact from punch-and-die pressing; c2, briquettes from roller pressing; c3, flat sheet from roller pressing; c4, corrugated sheet from roller pressing. With this understanding of how agglomerates are structured and considering the laws of fracture mechanics it is now possible to define phenomenologically how the granulation of powders by crushing agglomerates should be best carried out. By now it should be obvious that a direct, single-stage reduction of the particle size from the agglomerated feed to the granulated product will normally result in an excessive amount of fines. Therefore, in a first step, agglomerates from any process source must be cracked, taking into consideration the surface layer with higher
71
72
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
strength (Fig. 6.1-7), to form as many particles as possible, including oversized pieces. During this crushing step the energy input must be selected to minimize the amount of fines. The discharge must be separated to yield fines, correctly sized product, and oversized particles. Most of the oversized pieces are the strongest parts of the agglomerate. They must be recirculated to the crushing equipment or fed to another sizereduction process. If, depending on the system used, oversized particles are again obtained after restressing, they will be even stronger and require additional size reduction. This can be accomplished with various systems using different methods of disintegration. Beginning with compression stressing, the aforementioned multiple-pass roller mills (Fig. 6.1-4) promise best results. These mills are designed so that the gap between the rollers can be easily adjusted (Fig. 6.1-8), even during operation, to allow optimization of the product particle size distribution. The gap of the last set of rollers defines the maximum particle size and is normally adjusted such that no oversized material is obtained. Depending on requirements on the product particle size distribution, fines may have to be removed and discarded or otherwise used, including recirculation into the agglomeration process. Differently profiled rollers (Fig. 6.1-6) may be advantageous in certain cases. Today, by far the largest number of granulation systems that crush agglomerates into a specific particle size range use some kind of impact mill. Hammer mills are most commonly applied but other types, notably cage mills with one static bar cage and one or more rotating one(s), may be selected. As mentioned before, to avoid the production of excessive amounts of fines, if this is a requirement, agglomerated solids should be stressed once, thereafter immediately removed from the grinding chamber, and separated into at least three fractions containing undersized (fines), correctly sized (product), and oversized particles. Because larger than desired pieces are always unacceptable, this fraction is either recirculated or fed to a secondary crusher. Fig. 6.1-9 is a simplified comparison of the results of granulation by crushing agglomerates, using three different milling circuits. In all cases hammermills are utilized. All diagrams depict the agglomerated feed with 100 % in a relatively narrow, large particle size range and the desired (shaded) particle size of the granular product. For the result shown in Fig. 6.1-9a, a hammermill with discharge restriction in the form of a bar cage or a screen was used (Fig. 6.1-10). The restriction is meant to avoid oversized pieces in the discharge of the mill and the opening size of this feature is selected such that nothing leaves the milling chamber with a size larger than the
Fig. 6.1-8 Automatic adjustment with pneumatic servomotors and micrometer or digital readout in multi-stage roller mills (courtesy Modern Process Equipment, Inc. (MPE), Chicago, IL, USA)
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-9 Comparison of the results of granulation by crushing agglomerates: a) a mill with exit grate or screen, b) an impact (hammer) mill with unobstructed discharge and recirculation of oversized particles (Fig. 6.1-3aa), and c) two-stage crushing (Fig. 6.1-3bb) applying two individually controlled impact mills with unobstructed discharge (for explanations see text)
upper limit of the granular range. Oversized material, including already sufficiently reduced pieces and fines, which can not immediately clear the discharge openings, remain in the milling zone and experience turbulent movement and a multitude of stressing events, including shear. In addition to clean impacts from the hammers, largely undefined energy input occurs, mostly between the hammers, the chamber walls, and the discharge restriction that leads to the production of fines, particularly since the material to be crushed consists of agglomerates. The example in Fig. 6.19a assumes that the acceptable granular size range is relatively narrow. Therefore, only 40 % product and 60 % fines (undersized particles) are obtained. This represents an ineffective method of granulation.
73
74
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.1-10 Diagram of an impact mill with hinged or fixed hammers on a horizontal rotor and discharge restriction (bar cage or screen) to avoid oversized particles in the product: a) grate bars, b) cage with axially elongated holes, c) cage with round holes
It should be mentioned, however, that in some applications, especially those in which the granular material represents an intermediate product, manufactured as a freely flowing, essentially dustfree, non-segregating, directly compressible feed for punch-and-die presses (for example in the pharmaceutical industry, Section 6.2), the entire output from such a mill, including all of the fines, may be adequate for further use. Also if, in other cases, the granular size range can be wider, the yield of acceptable product becomes larger so that the correspondingly smaller amount of fines may be recirculated or otherwise used without sacrificing the economics of the process. In Fig. 6.1-9b it may be assumed that the same mill as used in example A is employed but without discharge restriction. The tip speed of the hammers (defining the energy input) is selected such that during crushing a wide size range of broken pieces, including oversized ones, is produced. After separation into undersized (fines, 25 %), correctly sized (product, 40 %), and oversized (35 %) particles, the large pieces are recirculated to the mill (Fig. 6.1-3aa) where it is assumed that they will disintegrate into the same particle size distribution as experienced before with the whole agglomerates. From the discussion above, which stated that oversized particles after the crushing of agglomerates represent the stronger parts of the structure, this assumption is not totally correct. If the oversized particles are recirculated into the same mill, exerting an identical energy input as during the first crushing event, the stronger pieces should produce a somewhat different size distribution. For the sake of this presentation the difference is disregarded. Since the oversized fraction, which, in a closed loop recirculation layout, results from a multitude of cycles, produces material fitting the three size fractions during every stressing event, the final yield of product and fines, the only two streams discharging from the system, comes from an infinite accumulation of iterative amounts whereby all the coarse particles are ultimately converted such that they fall into the two size ranges. As compared with Fig. 6.1-9a, 21.5 % more product (61.5 %) and, correspondingly, 21.5 % less fines (38.5 %) are produced with the granulation method shown in Fig. 6.1-9b. As discussed before, this result can be further improved if the granular size range is wider and, depending on the requirements on the granulated material, the now much-smaller percentage of fines may actually be an acceptable component of the product.
6.1 General Applications
Because after the first crushing step the oversized particles represent the strongest portions of the agglomerates, a further improvement of granular yield and reduction of fines can be obtained if, instead of returning this size fraction back to the same mill (Fig. 6.1-3aa) another similar or identical mill, the latter employing modified energy input, is installed to crush the oversized portion. This second-stage mill could be in a straight through arrangement (Fig. 6.1-3ba), employ an internal closed loop (Fig. 6.1-3bb), or feature a separate closed loop for the still-remaining oversized pieces (Fig.s 6.1-3 bc and bd). By being able to control the energy input of the second mill, which now receives only the oversized particles from previous crushing events, it can be assumed that the particle size distribution of the discharge is improved in regard to product and fines (for example: undersized (fines, 25 %, unchanged), correctly sized (product, 50 % instead of 40 %), and oversized (25 % instead of 35 %) particles). With this and using crushing systems according to Fig. 6.1-3bb or bc, Fig. 6.1-9c shows that a further small increase in product yield of 1.9 % to 63.4 % and the corresponding reduction in fines (to 36.6 %) can be achieved. Instead of recirculating the coarse fraction from the second mill to that same one (Fig. 6.1-3bb, bc, or bd), a third crushing stage could be added (Fig. 6.1-3ca, cb, and cc) and even higher-order multi-stage systems are conceivable. Based on the small improvement of granular yield by adding a second mill (comparison between Fig. 6.19b and Fig. 6.1-9c) it may seem uneconomical to use two or higher order granulating circuits. However, with different agglomerates, employing other types of crushers, and by optimizing the results of crushing in each milling stage through modified energy input, it is possible to achieve dramatic improvements of the yield from the granulation of powders via agglomeration and controlled size reduction. It should be pointed out that the maximization of granular product yield may not always be the preferred solution. As will be described later (Section 6.6.2), granular yield can be maximized by employing gentle crushing methods, low energy input, and multi-stage milling but, at the same time, weaker parts of the original agglomerates may survive and become product. Such granules feature lower abrasion resistance and produce dust during bulk storage, transshipment, and distribution, which is objectionable for some materials, leading to complaints from the customers. Although specific applications of granulation by agglomeration and crushing will be described in many of the sections covering different industries, in Sections 6.1.1, 6.1.2, and 6.1.3 some generic flowcharts will be introduced and discussed. They are mostly applied to generally improve the handling characteristics of finely divided particulate solids in mechanical process technologies without trying to modify other properties of the materials or obtain special, beneficial product qualities. In most cases, the reason for increasing the size of fine or ultrafine particles by agglomeration is to avoid undesired adhesion or agglomeration (Chapter 4). To achieve this, the particle size of the material is commonly adjusted to 0.1–1.0 mm. In this size range solids, whether naturally compact or agglomerated, have insufficient mass for the always-present adhesion forces to cause permanent bonding between the granular particles or with surfaces of any kind. If bonding occurs due to the presence of binders (moisture) or extraneous binding mechanisms (e.g., electrostatic charges), the strength of the agglomerate is low and the aggregation can be easily destroyed or build-ups and coatings can be removed without difficulties.
75
76
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
To explain this in the context of common incidents occurring in the process industry, two examples are discussed in more detail. The first example refers to the adhesion of fine particles to walls of storage, transfer, or processing contrivances. Although ultrafine particles may permanently stick to technically smooth surfaces due to natural adhesion forces, an even stronger bond is obtained if the size of the solids is in the range of or smaller than the roughness of the substrate. Because all technical surfaces feature a microscopic texture that results from the machining or polishing technology used, powders will always contain some particles, which, in addition to the action of molecular forces, will interact mechanically with the surface topography. On such a first layer of adhering particles, more of the very small particles will attach themselves. Because a large number of bonding sites exist per unit volume and weakly bonded particles are removed by external forces so that only strong bonds survive, such a build-up will continue to grow and will be difficult to remove by methods other than mechanical cleaning and, potentially, washing.
Fig. 6.1-11 Glass cylinders filled with the same gravimetric amount of a powder having different particle sizes (a) from left to right: 4 mm, 1.5 mm, 100 lm, 12 lm, 5 lm, 28 nm, 18 nm, 16 nm, 12 nm and (b) left 4 mm, right 12 nm
6.1 General Applications
On the other hand, when the powder particles have been agglomerated into granules with somewhat larger size, these new entities may still adhere to walls if the conditions are favorable. However, because the number of bonds between the particles is smaller and since the agglomerates have greater mass, the cohesion of the build-up is so small that it will break-off under its own weight when it reaches a certain thickness. The second example relates to agglomerates that form in a particulate mass. Apart from the fact that the previously discussed build-up grows on a substrate (wall), similar conditions apply. If the particles are very small, a large number of bonds exist per unit volume rendering the resulting agglomerate strong and difficult to destroy. Secondary agglomerates from larger sized granulated powders are weaker and can be easily dispersed by the forces prevailing, for example, in a moving mass of particulate solids. At the same time, it is a precondition that the agglomerated granules, making-up the easily dispersible secondary agglomerate, are so strong that they withstand those same forces without breaking-up. A further problem that is associated with fine and ultrafine solids and can be remedied by size enlargement is that the entire mass of powder particles responds to the presence of the naturally existing molecular adhesion. This means that, in bulk, they adhere to each other and do not settle under the influence of gravity. This effect increases with diminishing particle size and is particularly pronounced when the solids are in the nanometer range. Primarily this results in a large, often excessive bulk volume (low bulk density) (Fig. 6.1-11) but also in bad flowability and in discharge difficulties. As shown in Tab. 6.1, size enlargement by agglomeration can overcome these handling and process problems.
6.1.1
Tumble/Growth Technologies
As discussed before, size enlargement by agglomeration for general applications is typically used to improve the handling characteristics of finely divided particulate solids in mechanical process technologies without trying to modify other properties of the materials or obtain special, beneficial product qualities. In most cases, the reason for increasing the size of fine or ultrafine particles by agglomeration is to avoid undesired adhesion or agglomeration (Chapter 4). To achieve this, the particle size of the material is commonly adjusted to 0.1–1.0 mm. In Chapter 5 the following methods of tumble/growth agglomeration were listed. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
high-density tumbling bed high-shear tumbling bed high density/high shear with abrasion or crushing transfer low-density fluidized bed low-density particle clouds agglomeration in stirred suspensions immiscible liquid agglomeration
77
78
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
A detailed discussion of these methods and of the equipment used to accomplish them can be found in the author’s earlier books on the subject [B.48, B.71, B.97]. Although in Section 6.1 it was indicated that, theoretically, granular products can be made by crushing cured (dried) large agglomerates from tumble/growth technologies, the problems inherent with these procedures were also mentioned which, in most cases, prohibit the use of such a technique. Therefore, the granulation of powders by tumble/growth agglomeration for the improvement of general handling properties in the process industry normally tries to manufacture directly the desired particle size. Owing to this requirement some of the above seven methods are preferred for this task while others are normally not used. At “normal” operating conditions, the high density tumbling bed obtained in discs, cones, and drums best produces agglomerates in the range 10–15 mm. In addition, particularly from drums, a wide agglomerate size distribution is obtained. Therefore drums are not used for the granulation of powders by agglomeration. Under certain conditions and with continuous, extensive observation and control by experienced operators, discs with low rim height [B.48] can be applied for “micro-agglomeration” (often called “micropelletizing”) yielding particles in the range 1–3 mm. However, because of the costly operator involvement, this technique is only used for materials with high value, for example the granulation of certain agrochemicals (Section 6.6.1), or if a worker is required at the pan for other reasons (for example, packing the discharge into drying trays, see Section 6.11.1) who will observe and control the operation. High shear tumbling beds are produced in mixer agglomerators with rotating tools [B.48, B.71, B.97]. The small size and relatively narrow distribution requested for the granulation of powders can be produced best if agglomeration occurs in high density/ high shear particle beds with abrasion or crushing transfer (Figs. 5-3 and 5-4, Chapter 5). This procedure applies shear plates between the mixing tools or independently driven, high speed knife heads (also called shredders or chopper elements), which are periodically operated [B.48, B.71, B.97]. These provisions are used to destroy oversized agglomerates and make the fragments available for new growth within the desired size range. Although, with good preparation and control, batch or continuous mixer agglomerators can produce rather well-defined granular materials from powders they are infrequently used for general applications. Since in this rather unpretentious field the emphasis is on large throughput capacity and low cost processing, mixer agglomerators do not normally meet these conditions. Because of the mechanisms defining agglomeration in low-density fluidized beds or particle clouds [B.48, B.71, B.97], where only relatively small, narrowly sized granules can be manufactured and kept suspended without either settling or becoming entrained, this group of processes seems to be well suited for converting fine or ultrafine particles into granular products. However the motions, forces, and growth mechanisms that are at work result also in relatively weak agglomerates with low density, which are not suitable to withstand the stresses encountered during regular handling in mechanical processing plants. The structure of agglomerates obtained in low density fluidized beds or particle clouds yield other beneficial product qualities, which make them more suitable for specific applications, for example in the food (Section 6.4.1)
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-12 Block diagram of a powder granulation system by tumble/growth agglomeration for general applications also showing various optional features
or pharmaceutical industries (Section 6.2.1). Nevertheless, certain solids, which are prepared by spray drying of solutions, suspensions, or slurries are granulated by simultaneously agglomerating them in a fluidized bed that is associated with the spray dryer (Section 6.7.1) to make them more easily handleable. Agglomeration in stirred suspensions and immiscible liquid agglomeration are always used to produce special, beneficial material qualities and, therefore are not of interest for general applications. With exception of the dry granulation of carbon black (Section 6.11.1) and silica fume (Section 6.7.1) all tumble/growth processes that are employed for granulation just to obtain improved handling properties of powders make use of wet agglomeration. Therefore, they include drying as a post-treatment process because the temporary bonding provided by liquids must be converted into a permanent strength producing mechanism. As a result, a block diagram for these general applications is as depicted in Fig. 6.1-12. If different powders are to be granulated they are proportioned (metered) from day bins into a blender, which may operate in batches or continuously. It is also possible to install a mill instead, especially if the various raw feeds have different particle size distributions that might lead to segregation and selective agglomeration in the size enlargement step. Particularly if a blender is applied, it is feasible to introduce additives and/or some of the liquid binder(s) at this point (preconditioning). However, care must be taken that not all of the binder liquid is added, which would eliminate an important control factor for size adjustment in the tumble/growth agglomerator.
79
80
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
A single component or homogeneous material feed is directly metered into the unit accomplishing size enlargement by tumble/growth agglomeration. The remaining binder liquid, normally atomized by suitable means (spray nozzles), is added and causes the tumbling particle mass to coalesce and form the desired granules. In dense beds of particulate solids a wide distribution of agglomerates, including oversized ones, is developing. The application of high shear or the operation of intensifier bars and intermittent use of knife heads [B.48, B.97] specifically results in the destruction of large agglomerates and of new growth from the fragments. In size enlargement by tumble/growth in any of the processes, green (moist or wet) agglomerates are formed, which are held together by temporary binding mechanisms. If natural curing, for example the hydration of cementitious components, does not take place, some post-treatment is required, almost always encompassing the elimination of the binder liquid and, at the same time, the development of a new, permanent binding mechanism (e.g., the recrystallization of a dissolved solid). Particularly if the granules are highly saturated, which is typical if size enlargement has occurred in a dense tumbling bed, liquid travels to the surface of the agglomerates during drying by capillary flow. Since, on the other hand, the green granules are weak and often become weaker during drying before a new bond takes over, curing takes often place in a stationary bed in which, caused by the previously described mechanisms, the aggregates may stick together and form oversized lumps. This is normally not observed with granules that were obtained in fluidized particle beds or clouds as drying takes place simultaneously or in another fluidized bed that is closely associated with the agglomerator. In such an arrangement, the particles are in constant motion and do not stick together. While for general applications the presence of some over and under sized particulates is often not objectionable, as an option the discharge from post-treatment may be separated into two or three size fractions. Fines (undersized particles) are discarded, used elsewhere, or recirculated to the agglomerator and coarse pieces (oversized particles and lumps) may be crushed in a closed loop whereby the fragments, which typically include again all three fractions, are recirculated to the sizing operation. Selection criteria for the crusher have been discussed in Section 6.1.
6.1.2
Pressure Agglomeration Technologies
Pressure agglomeration is also frequently used to produce granular materials for general applications. The same improvements of the powder properties as discussed in Section 6.1.1 are sought, which means that the particle size of the material is typically adjusted to 0.1–1.0 mm by granulation. In Chapter 5 the following methods of pressure agglomeration were listed. 1. low-pressure agglomeration: extrusion through screens 2. medium-pressure agglomeration: pelleting, extrusion through perforates die plates 3. high-pressure extrusion: ram presses
6.1 General Applications
4. high-pressure agglomeration – in confined spaces: punch-and-die pressing, tabletting – in confined spaces: isostatic pressing – in semi-confined spaces: roller presses A detailed discussion of these methods and of the equipment used to accomplish them can be found in the author’s earlier books on the subject [B.13b, B.48, B.71, B.97]. Only with low-pressure agglomeration can small extrudates with diameters < 1 mm be manufactured directly by passing formable (normally moist) particulate masses through screens. Because these machines are delicate and feature low capacity they are not used for general applications. All other pressure-agglomeration equipment produces relatively large, more-or-less densified pieces called briquettes, compacts, extrudates, pellets, sheets, slabs, and similar names. To meet the requirement that most of the granular materials, manufactured solely to improve the handling behavior of finely divided particular solids (general applications), should be in a particle size range of < 1 mm, the regular products from medium- and high-pressure agglomeration must be crushed. A plant embodying such a process, irrespective of which type of pressure agglomeration equipment is used, is called a compaction/granulation system. Fig. 6.1-13 is the block diagram of a typical compaction/granulation system. Right away it should be mentioned that the advantage of this technique of granulating powders is that any product size and distribution can be obtained. The final quality only depends on the crusher(s) and the sizing method(s) used. In this connection the discussion of Section 6.1 must be considered. A disadvantage is that always fines are also
Fig. 6.1-13 Block diagram of a powder granulation system by pressure agglomeration (compaction/granulation) for general applications also showing various optional features
81
82
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
produced, the amount of which depends on the cut size (Chapter 4) that is associated with this property and whether or not undersized particles are detrimental and must be removed. If the granular material must be free of fines, the rejected percentage increases with narrower product size distribution. As discussed in Section 6.1, the granulation of agglomerates by crushing is a difficult undertaking. It is, of course, always the primary requirement of a compaction/ granulation plant to produce the highest possible yield of high-quality granules in the desired particle size range. To accomplish this it is necessary to define and obtain the granule quality and size range. Both properties may differ widely. The quality of granules that are produced solely to improve the handling characteristics of fine particulate solids may be defined such that they just survive the stresses, for example at transfer points or in feeders, but easily disperse when finally processed or, in the other extreme, they must be hard and abrasion resistant if they are, for example, produced to facilitate safe disposal. The size range of the granulated solids may be wide and consist of the entire output from the granulator, even including the unavoidable fine particles, or narrowed down to a small fraction by sizing. This can be accomplished by merely removing the undersized portion from a granulator discharge that contains no coarse particles because, for example, a screen or bar cage are installed in the crusher exit. As discussed in Section 6.1, when agglomerates are stressed in such a mill, excessive amounts of fines must be expected, which have to be used or discarded elsewhere or recirculated. The latter increases the equipment sizes in the system considerably. Therefore, if a narrow size range of the granular product is required, in keeping with the explanations of Section 6.1, the optional closed crushing loop for oversized particles featuring a secondary optimized crusher and twin separation steps (with a double deck screen) should be considered. It has been mentioned in Section 6.1 that the products of medium- and high-pressure agglomeration feature a well defined density and, therefore, strength gradient. Both density and strength decrease from the surface of the compact to its center. The effect depends on the size (thickness) and the shape of the pressure agglomerate (Fig. 6.1-7). As will be shown in more detail in Section 6.6.2, where it has been a common problem, crushing the compacts too gently results in relatively soft parts of the agglomerate becoming part of the final product. This may not be objectionable if granulation is solely performed to improve, often only temporarily, the storage and handling problems of fine particulate solids. However, the fact that efforts to maximize the yield of granular material may lead to the presence of soft, low-strength granules should be acknowledged and remedied if the production of (additional) fines during handling becomes a problem. Even though general applications of size enlargement by agglomeration normally do not require special or high granule quality and are often only produced as an intermediate product with temporary life, sometimes the irregular shape featuring corners and edges (Fig. 6.1-14) is undesirable, mostly because these parts rub-off easily and create particles that are so small that they become airborne. In such cases conditioning may be added. Conditioning typically happens in rotating drums where the granules are rounded during tumbling and the abraded fines are separated by entrainment in an
6.1 General Applications
Fig. 6.1-14 Typical granules from compaction/granulation showing the irregular shape of the unconditioned particles
air stream or afterwards mechanically on a screen; alternatively, a small amount of mostly liquid coating may be added to provide either adhesion properties for fines, which are then picked-up by the moistened agglomerates, or to smoothen and/or strengthen the surface of the granules.
6.1.3
Other Technologies
“Other technologies” comprise agglomeration by heat, also called sintering, and methods that manipulate fine particulate solids such that specific structures are produced. They are not normally used to produce granular materials for general applications
83
84
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
because the first, requiring a large amount of thermal energy, is too expensive and the second does not manufacture agglomerates solely to improve the handling behavior; in fact, particle manipulation procedures and the use of binding mechanisms of agglomeration are always applied in specific industries to engineer products with defined new properties. One technique that is being described in more detail in Section 6.9.2 as a preparatory step for the hot briquetting of steel mill dusts for recycling shall be mentioned here, also to introduce the idea for future use with a variety of materials. The process could be conceived simply for the conversion of fine, reactive (e.g., metal-bearing) dusts, which are not valuable enough for reuse as secondary raw material (Chapter 8), into dustfree, easily handleable granular aggregate for safe disposal. In this respect it meets the requirement of “general applications” because no specific characteristics in regard to size, structure, or properties are necessary other than the need to be dust free, of sufficient strength, and easily handleable. During the production of, for example, metals by the liquid route, particularly in gasblown converters, ultrafine particles are produced that are so small that they are difficult to capture with conventional methods, become airborne, and, for example, were responsible for the brownish atmosphere in and around steel mills during the late 19th and the early part of the 20th centuries. Although most of these pollutants are oxidized impurities, tiny droplets of metal are also produced, which quickly solidify and become part of the dust. Because these particles are very small their specific surface area is so large that the smallest ones feature self-ignition characteristics. This means that, in the presence of oxygen, they are liable to oxidize, even at ambient temperatures. This chemical reaction is exothermic (producing heat). In an effort to clean the air in and around metal producing centers, improved dry dust collection systems were and are being developed, which remove the particulate contaminants but, at the same time, result in large volumes of difficult to handle dust. It is possible to use the auto-oxidation behavior of such materials beneficially for the production of agglomerates by sintering. For this purpose, the dust is tumbled in an inclined steel drum and air (or oxygen) is introduced into the bed by a suitable sparger pipe. The reoxidation reaction produces heat, the level of which is controlled by the supply of oxygen, and sintering into agglomerates of various sizes occurs. While the binding mechanism is that of sintering, the agglomeration mechanism is that of tumble/growth. Typically, this process operates continuously and fines discharging with the agglomerates may be separated and reintroduced into the feed end of the drum. Because more and more of the particulate solids that are removed from plant effluents are or contain ultrafine particles and legislation requires the safe disposal of these materials to avoid recontamination of air and/or water (Chapter 8), the high reactivity of these particles and the exothermic production of heat during oxidation can be generally used to achieve low cost granulation by heat. In this context it should be remembered that, while for the sintering of metal and mineral particles very high temperatures (typically exceeding 1200 8C) are required, the sintering mechanism begins at about two thirds of the melting or softening temperature of a particular solid. Therefore, it is feasible to apply the technology for the granulation of other reactive ultrafine particles at much lower temperatures.
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
6.2
Pharmaceutical Applications
By trial and error, humans found that certain herbs and other organic materials and some minerals can be used to alleviate or cure ailments. Early physicians dried the materials, ground them to yield fine powders, proportioned and blended different ingredients, and finally administered the remedy in a traditional way. Since some of these medications were given orally, “solid dosage forms” were already prepared early in human history by the tribal medicine people, because fine powders can not be swallowed easily and the concoctions often had a bad taste. To that end, the powdered drugs were mixed with binders, for example starch (flour) and water or honey, and rolled into spherical pills. Honey was often also used to mask the taste. Because the pills thus produced were still sticky after rolling, they were sometimes coated, for example with pollen, to render them dry and easily storable. Even today, in many rural dispensing pharmacies, in developed countries for homeopathic remedies, and in lesser developed parts on Earth for many, often natural drugs, the ancient pill making is still performed by producing a formable mixture from the ingredients, proportioning the mass into the dosage size, and manually rolling these pieces into spherical pills (Fig. 6.2-1) [6.2.1]. During the 10th century AD, Arabs used a simple press to form a moist medicinal powder into shapes [6.2.2]. The mixture was “compacted” by hand between the two halves of a tongue-shaped tool, which was made from bone, ivory, wood, or stone. For many centuries, pills and manually produced compacts were well accepted by the patients as solid medicines for oral application. Nevertheless, the invention of the tabletting press during the middle of the 19th century in the UK and the USA initiated a veritable revolution in the fledgling pharmaceutical industry. Aside from the production of previously unheard of numbers of tablets, the major difference between today’s manufacturing of oral dosage forms and the technology that was successfully performed for centuries is that many powders are agglomerated dry. Tab. 6.2-1 summarizes the reasons for and/or results of size enlargement by agglomeration in pharmaceutical applications. Since larger amounts and numbers of different powders, which for reasons of uniform product composition are very fine [B.48], had to be tabletted in machines operating with ever increasing speed, flowability, determining the ease of filling the die, and compactibility, controlling the production of high-quality tablets during very short densification cycles, must be often improved. This is accomplished by pre-agglomeration into a free-flowing granular feed. It was originally carried-out by wet agglomeration, another centuries-old method, and is now increasingly done by dry compaction/ granulation. Under certain conditions, a single modern rotating table tabletting machine is now capable of producing more than 1 million tablets per hour [B.97]. The two most important aspects of agglomerated pharmaceutical products are the following.
85
86
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-1 Sketches of tools for manual pill making [6.2.1]. 1, “Pill machine”: a) rolling plate, b) rope cutter, lower part, c) rope cutter, upper part, d) rolling board, e) area for ropes and finished pills. 2, Mortar (with pestle). 3, Pill rolling (disc) tool *
*
They are intermediate or final dosage forms, which must carry reliably and reproducibly the required amount of active substance. Final dosage forms are consumer products; therefore, consumer appeal is of great concern, which means for agglomerated specialties that they must have uniform, aesthetically pleasing, and reproducible shape and weight.
Tab. 6.2-1 Reasons for and/or results of size enlargement by agglomeration in pharmaceutical applications Agglomerated particulate solids contain no or low amounts of dust; therefore, they provide increased safety during the handling and processing of toxic or medicinally active materials, cause no workplace pollution or operator health risks, and, generally, result in fewer losses. Agglomerated mixtures of different particulate solids do not segregate. Agglomerated finely dispersed solids are freely flowing, therefore: Storage and handling characteristics are improved, Metering and dosing properties are better, Bulk density is increased and bulk volume is smaller. Within limits, the strength and porosity or density of agglomerates can be controlled; thus: disintegration, dispersibility, solubility, reactivity, and other properties of agglomerated intermediate or final products can be influenced. By coating or encapsulating, the agglomerate characteristics can be modified further; for example, solubility may be delayed or drug components activated by or in certain environments. Agglomerates may feature a specific shape, e.g. tablettes. Agglomerates have defined sizes and their distribution can be controlled. Monosized products or a defined amount of smaller agglomerates, the latter often enclosed in, for example, gelatine capsules, represent the dosage size. The final product has high consumer appeal and increased sales value.
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
The above are essential requirements because agglomerated products are supposed to facilitate measurement of or, in the case of tablets, define the dosage unit. Particularly for tablets and capsules, accurate weight is of utmost importance. Since, in most cases, the medicinally active component represents only a small fraction of the commercial drug form, uniform mixing and stabilization of the mixture (by pre-agglomeration) are necessary to avoid segregation. During manufacturing of the agglomerated specialties, a number of potential problems may have to be considered and overcome. These result from the specific properties of the highly sophisticated and often very sensitive active drug component. For example, the natural or chemically derived materials may not tolerate the presence of water or other liquids and may be sensitive to heat and/or pressure; for some substances shear forces must be avoided while still other materials are unstable or may discolor if they are brought in contact with certain chemical elements such as iron or various metal compounds. If intermediate or final pharmaceutical agglomerates are produced by tumbling, accretion, and growth, involving binder liquids, drying is required to obtain final and permanent bonding and strength (Section 6.2.1). Because many of the components of commercial drug systems are to a certain extent soluble in the liquid, not only the special case of drying of a porous body must be considered but also crust formation. Particularly if materials are temperature sensitive, which is often the case in pharmaceutical agglomeration, the phenomenon of incrustation during drying is of special importance. Agglomerates are porous bodies. The accretion and growth processes are normally controlled such that highly saturated agglomerates are produced; this means that a large portion (80–90 %) of the pore space is filled with the liquid. During drying, evaporation occurs at first only on the surface and liquid moves from the interior by capillary flow. This mechanism continues until, at about 15–25 % saturation, only liquid bridges remain at the coordination points between the particles forming the agglomerate. If the liquid flowing to the surface and evaporating there contains dissolved substances, these substances will crystallize at the pore ends and form a crust. As long as evaporation takes place, the temperature of the agglomerate remains low due to the heat of evaporation that is consumed during drying. Vacuum drying enhances this effect. However, it is possible that the crust becomes so dense that no additional liquid can reach the surface of the agglomerate from within while the core is still wet. If this happens, two alternative processes may occur. *
Because many dryers are controlled by the partial vapor pressure in the drying chamber or the dryer off-gas and will cease heating if this parameter falls below a certain value, the granules may be dry on the surface but still contain appreciable amounts of liquid inside. The same will be the case in vacuum dryers where low temperatures prevail. With time, for instance during storage of such insufficiently dried material, the residual moisture will migrate and cause lumping or, if the granules are destroyed, for example during tabletting, liquid will be liberated and cause a number of different problems.
87
88
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration *
If drying is carried-out at relatively high temperatures and, for temperature sensitive materials, the cooling effect caused by the removal of the heat of evaporation is used to keep the temperature of the granular mass at acceptable levels, this benefit is lost when formation of a dense crust occurs. As evaporation at the surface ceases the temperature in the agglomerate rises until the build-up of internal vapor pressure results in cracking of the crust and, at least temporarily, a continuation of drying, or the temperature will reach that of the dryer atmosphere. Both can be high enough to damage heat sensitive materials.
To avoid these problems care must be taken that crust formation is light. This can be accomplished by either limiting the contents of soluble materials in the formulation or producing agglomerates that contain only small percentages of liquid, thus realizing the bridge model. Incrustation can be also avoided if agglomeration and drying are taking place at the same time as, for example, in fluidized bed agglomeration when hot gas is used for fluidization. In this case drying and recrystallization of the dissolved substance(s) begin directly after liquid bridge bonding so that agglomerates never reach high liquid saturation, which is the precondition for capillary flow and crust formation. All concerns with drying and incrustation are eliminated if agglomeration is carried out dry by compaction/granulation or tabletting (Section 6.2.3). Other problems encountered in pharmaceutical applications are associated with the need to process small batches and to avoid cross-contamination when switching from one formulation to another. Therefore, equipment is typically small, designed for quick, easy, and complete cleaning, and frequently made from stainless steel or special materials with and without protective coatings (e.g., plating with chromium, nickel, or, in extreme cases, noble metals). Increasing concerns about worker protection lead to one-pot-technologies, in which several process steps, for example mixing, stabilization by agglomeration, drying, cooling, and de-dusting, are carried-out without the necessity to open the equipment to transfer the charge, and complete containment during operation is realized. “Through-the-wall designs”, whereby parts handling and processing the drug are totally separated from the technical components by an impermeable wall until a final, safe dosage form is produced, become increasingly common. This development requires new cleaning methods such as WIP (washing in place) and CIP (cleaning in place). For some applications where successful CIP is not possible and cross-contamination must be absolutely avoided, the use of specific equipment must be limited to only one formulation. Agglomeration is a technique by which particulate solids, comprising one or multiple components, are bonded together to form larger entities (granules, extrudates, tablets). According to the binding mechanisms of agglomeration, such permanent bonding can be accomplished by solid bridges or physical adhesion and chemical or molecular forces. Because of their short range, the latter require densification of the particulate mass to produce sufficient strength. Although, today, from dosage and/or marketing (appeal, acceptance) points of view, agglomeration of solid drugs is a necessity in most cases, compromises in regard to product characteristics must be often accepted. For instance, high strength (for stability during handling, packa-
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
ging, and storage) requires high density obtained, for example, by compaction or matrix binders which, in turn, results in reduced solubility. Therefore, special components are sometimes added, which assist in the break-up of the agglomerated product when it comes in contact with water or other liquids (e.g., effervescent or swelling components, fibers) [B.97]. On the other hand, agglomerated pharmaceutical formulations are ideally suited for the application of coatings to accomplish a multitude of tasks (Section 6.2.3). Such coatings may simply furnish a more pleasing shape and color, or enhance or mask the taste (e.g., by applying sugar coatings), and, generally, facilitate swallowing. Coatings can also provide characteristics that are required to render the drug medicinally more effective by, for example, retarding dissolution in the digestive system. These coatings are also applied by agglomeration methods (Section 6.2.3). Another “coating” technique is microencapsulation. It coats liquid droplets or solid particles with a skin and forms “microcapsules” with dimensions in the range 1– 5000 lm. The skin consists of natural or synthetic polymers and may be dense, permeable, or semi-permeable. Therefore, this technology allows the production of microcapsules containing a reactive substance, which can be liberated in a controlled fashion by destruction of the skin or by permeation. It is also possible to carry-out reactions within the capsules after permeation of reaction partners from the outside. The outer shape of the microcapsules depends on the type of material in the core and the method of depositing the wall material. Microcapsules may be smooth, spherical particles and grape-like conglomerates or irregular particulates with smooth or rough surfaces. Since all methods of size enlargement by agglomeration still need to be fine tuned by experimentation in a vendor’s testing facility (Section 9.1) or corresponding installations at an engineering company or the final user [B.97], the new, very strict requirements for process validation, which is part of the permitting and ongoing quality control in the pharmaceutical industry, put a severe burden on the development of new pharmaceutical products and the processes that include one or more agglomeration steps for manufacturing them. Because validation also includes the need to select and define equipment sizes and operating parameters of the final commercial systems already during the permitting phase (development) and scale-up is often not easy, definition of all the requirements that must be satisfied by the mechanical processes is challenging, to say the least. Also, difficulties with scale-up do normally not allow to build a larger plant if a new drug experiences unexpected success in the market. For these reasons, the trend in the pharmaceutical industry for the production of solid dosage forms is towards relatively small, standardized systems and processes, which can be already used and optimized during the development phase. Larger capacities that may become necessary during commercialization are obtained by installing identical additional systems at a central location or in regional facilities. Contract manufacturing (Section 9.2), where the burden of equipment validation is shifted to external manufacturers (Section 15.1), is also becoming more and more attractive and important. The manufacturing of primary components, both drugs and excipients, and intermediate feed materials, such as pre-agglomerated powders and powder mixtures, may still be produced in large central locations for a multitude of finishing plants.
89
90
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
As will be shown in the following sections 6.2.1, 6.2.2, and 6.2.3 all the main types of processes and techniques of size enlargement by agglomeration (Chapter 5) are being used in the pharmaceutical industry. Characteristic design features are based on what has been discussed above. The equipment is typically small, built from stainless steel, and can be cleaned easily inside and out to avoid cross-contamination. In addition, more and more installations are executed with a physical separation between the (dirty) drives and other mechanical parts that require technical maintenance and the containments that process the charge. Sophisticated control and recording devices are a common part of all systems, in part to satisfy the requirements of process validation. In accordance with the importance in the pharmaceutical industry of size enlargement by agglomeration and the use of agglomeration phenomena for other purposes, an increasing number of publications becomes available, particularly also in book form. Section 13.2 lists many of the more important books although it is not exhaustive and does not include works that where undoubtedly published in other languages.
Further Reading
For further reading the following books are recommended: B.3, B.6, B.7, B.8, B.16, B.19, B.21, B.22, B.24, B.26, B.33, B.34, B.36, B.40, B.41, B.48, B.49, B.51, B.56, B.58, B.64, B.66, B.67, B.68, B.70, B.71, B.72, B.73, B.78, B.82, B.89, B.93, B.94, B.95, B.97, B.99 (Chapter 13.1). Books mostly devoted to the subject matter are printed bold.
6.2.1
Tumble/Growth Agglomeration Technologies
As discussed in Chapter 2 and Section 6.2, the very first use of agglomeration in medicine was the making of pills from ground dry animal and plant matter, minerals, and other solid remedies to define the dosage and improve ingestion. Pills are spheroidal bodies that are produced from portioned moist, formable material by rolling with the flat hand or between two flat boards (Fig. 6.2-1). While wetting the medicinal mixture with water is often sufficient to render the material plastic and suitable for pill making, more sticky binders, such as honey, were frequently used. The sweet and relatively strong flavor of honey was also used to mask the often unpleasant taste of the concoctions. Although, in some countries and/or pharmacies, pill forming was and still is carried out by manual pressure during rolling, this technique can be considered the first application of wet agglomeration in pharmacy because the binding mechanism is caused by a liquid or viscous binder and, at least directly after manufacturing, a “green” agglomerate is obtained, which may be cured by drying or coated with a dry powder to reduce the product’s stickiness. Apprentice pharmacists still learn to manually make pills with the “pill machine” (Fig. 6.2-1). Since the first step of forming the mixture, which has been moistened in a mortar, is the production of a rope, which is then
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
divided into the portions to be rolled, today, industrial manufacturing of spherical dosage forms is performed by extrusion and spheronizing (Section 6.2.2). Granulation, to yield a free-flowing, dust-free, and non-segregating product, was also carried out by wet agglomeration for a long time. The formulation is blended, moistened, and passed through a screen by hand, and then dried to yield the granular product. Today, this is accomplished by low-pressure agglomeration with modern mechanized and typically motorized equipment (Section 6.2.2). Other wet agglomeration techniques, which were developed during recent decades for different applications, have been modified for use in the pharmaceutical industry and become important, as they can be particularly well designed to meet the special new requirements of validation, control, and documentation. They employ tumble/ growth agglomeration and are almost exclusively used for granulation [B.48, B.68]. In most cases, contemporary pharmaceutical wet agglomeration processes yield granules from pharmaceutical blends that are directly compressible and are, therefore, produced as free-flowing, dust-free, and non-segregating feeds for the modern high-speed tabletting machines (Section 6.2.2). Other applications manufacture a limited number of granular products that are either used directly, that is, for dosage by spoon or packaged in small envelopes, or as fill for gelatin capsules. Most other pharmaceutical specialties resulting from wet agglomeration feature instant characteristics (Section 6.4.1), for example mineral supplements and vitamin drink formulations. Shangraw [6.2.1.1] stated that the process of (pre-)granulation is historically embedded in the pharmaceutical industry. It produces in a single process (although many steps may be involved, see Fig. 6.1-13 and 6.1-14, and below) the two primary requisites for reproducibly making a high-quality compact/tablet (Section 6.2.2), that is, good flowability and compressibility. In more detail, the advantages of granulating a pharmaceutical press feed are summarized in Tab. 6.2-2. When all particles of a mixture are proportionally incorporated in agglomerates, thereby effectively stabilizing the blend, each granule has the ideal composition and any segregation of the granulated product has no effect on the ingredients in a tablet (1). By increasing the apparent particle size and sometimes also the sphericity of the granulated feed, the material becomes free-flowing, thus guaranteeing a conTab. 6.2-2 Advantages of (pre-) granulation in the pharmaceutical industry (adapted from Shangraw [6.2.1.1]) 1. No segregation: Permits handling and feeding without loss of mix quality. 2. Freely flowing: Improves flow of powders by increasing the particle size. 3. No dust: Reduces the level of workplace dust and cross-contamination. 4. Good bulk density: Increases and improves uniformity of feed density. 5. Improved degassing: Reduces the amount of air entrapment. And for wet granulation processes only 6. Better bonding: Improves cohesion during and after compaction. 7. Liquid addition: Allows for (small!) addition of liquid phase to powders. 8. Surface modification: Makes hydrophobic surfaces hydrophilic.
91
92
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
stant fill of a container (for example gelatin capsule) or the die cavity(ies) of a tabletting machine (Section 6.2.2) even at very high fill speeds (2). Since, by definition, dust particles are bonded within the agglomerate and attrition is minimized, the level of dust in the manufacturing area is low. Health risks to the workers and cross-contamination between production lines is essentially eliminated (3). Although components of the formulation may have different densities, all are incorporated in the granules, which themselves feature a uniform, average density. Within limits, the bulk density of the granulated feed can be adjusted by controlling the agglomerate size range through post-treatments (e.g., screening) or directly in the process (4). Because the agglomerates are porous and feature a certain strength, densification first takes place by rearrangement of the relatively big granules (Fig. 5-9 and Fig. 10-15) whereby the large amount of gas (air), expelled in this phase, can easily escape from the diminishing interparticle volume. Only when the pressing force approaches the high-pressure region (Fig. 5-9 and Fig. 10-15), are the granules destroyed and the original powder particles incorporated into the uniform tablet structure. Porosity and pore sizes are drastically reduced resulting in a considerable increase in diffusion resistance. However, because in this final densification phase only a relatively small amount of air remains to be displaced, the volume of trapped, compressed gas in isolated pores, if any, is small and does not negatively influence tablet quality (5). The above are valid for all granulation processes, wet or dry (below and Section 6.2.2). If wet granulation is selected, additional advantages may apply. In many cases, a thin layer of binder (added as a liquid, in suspension, or in solution) forms around substances that have poor bonding characteristics. This effect, often called functionalizing (Fig. 10-14), improves cohesion during and after tabletting (6). Although, typically, granulated products are dried prior to their use in compaction, liquids are added during mixing and/or agglomeration. This allows for the addition of drugs or other ingredients (e.g., dyes) in solution thereby achieving a more homogeneous distribution (7). By chemical or physical surface modification, initiated by special liquid phases added during wet granulation, hydrophobic substances can be made more hydrophilic (Section 10.1), which improves the dissolution rate of the tabletted products (8). One technology is wet granulation by mixer agglomeration [B.48, B.68, B.97] which, after adaptation from other industries, has evolved from simple drums with mixing elements and integrated spray-nozzles for liquid additives and/or binders to highly sophisticated, specially designed, equipped, and instrumented “one pot” granulating and processing systems. Another utilizes spray drying and/or fluid-bed agglomeration [B.48, B.49, B.68, B.93, B.97] One of the first high-shear mixers, suitable for pharmaceutical applications, was the L€odige drum with plows as mixing tools on a horizontal shaft and high-speed choppers in the drum shell. After expiration of the basic patents, in addition to the original manufacturer, this design is now offered by many vendors worldwide. Fig. 6.2-2 shows this equipment. The size, number, positioning, geometric shape, and peripheral speed of the mixing elements are selected to achieve a three-dimensional movement of the particulate solids within the mixing drum [6.2.1.2]. The resultant turbulence with total particle mobility prevents the formation of dead zones and results in gentle precision mixing and agglomeration within the shortest possible time. During
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
wet granulation, particularly if liquid is added, the separately driven high-speed choppers are operated to destroy larger lumps that may have formed and control agglomerate size [B.48, B.97]. For pharmaceutical applications small to medium sized, versatile, and often modular equipment is desired that must meet extreme cleanliness requirements (below). Fig. 6.2-3 shows a laboratory or small production dust-tight plow mixer/agglomerator with cantilevered shaft, interchangeable drum, easy and quick opening front door for good accessibility, chopper, and liquid addition. Larger cantilevered units are often mounted on the wall to separate the potentially contaminating technical parts, such as drives, from the clean room in which the pharmaceutical formulations are handled and processed (Fig. 6.2-4). In Fig. 6.2-4, right, the front door is opened, allowing a view into the interior of the polished stainless steel drum with shaft, plows, and chopper element. To further facilitate cleaning, the shaft with the mixing elements may be fitted with a pull-out mechanism (Fig. 6.2-5). Furthermore, particularly for larger mixer/granulators, WIP (washing-in-place) can be added: Fig. 6.2-6 is a P&I (process and instrumentation) diagram of such a machine. Horizontal, batch and continuously operating drum mixer/agglomerators with plows and many other mixing tools and chopper elements [B.48, B.68, B.97] are widely used in the pharmaceutical industry, mostly for the pre-granulation of formulations prior to tabletting. The addition of steam jackets or other heat sources and/or the application of vacuum allows single-pot processing (below), which is a fast growing technology in the pharmaceutical industry. Because the equipment must not be opened between different process steps, it avoids or minimizes contamination of both the charge and the workplace. A newer, but widely applied design is the vertical high-shear system, often called “bowl” mixer/agglomerator (Fig. 6.2-7) The shape of the container promotes formation of a vortex flow and the mixing tool has minimum clearances to the inner equipment walls for maximum product yield. This mode of operation assures rapid, inten-
Fig. 6.2-2 Diagram of the operating principle of a horizontal plow mixer/agglomerator with chopper, and two alternative means of liquid addition (courtesy L€ odige, Paderborn, Germany)
93
94
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-3 Laboratory or small production dust-tight plow mixer/ agglomerator with cantilevered shaft, interchangeable drum, front opening door, chopper, and liquid addition (courtesy L€ odige, Paderborn, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-4 Wall mounting of larger cantilevered mixer/agglomerators in a pharmaceutical manufacturing facility (courtesy L€ odige, Paderborn, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-5 The activated pull-out mechanism, exposing the shaft and plow mixing elements of a mixer/agglomerator for easy cleaning (courtesy L€ odige, Paderborn, Germany)
sive movement of the entire charge even if components have diverse bulk densities and particles feature widely different shapes and sizes. Often, as shown in Fig. 6.2-7a, the impeller can be lifted, sometimes hydraulically, for improved cleaning. A chopper (or multiple ones) is located such that it extends into the zone of greatest material velocity to perform the same functions as described previously.
Fig. 6.2-6 P&ID of a horizontal, batch operating plow mixer/agglomerator, equipped for WIP (courtesy L€ odige, Paderborn, Germany)
95
96
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-7 Typical designs of vertical high-shear (bowl) mixer/agglomerators: a) basic design, b) equipment for “one-pot processing”, c) process diagram (courtesy Diosna, Osnabr€ uck, Germany)
Cleaning requirements in the pharmaceutical industry may necessitate installation of the chopper(s) through a removable roof as shown in Fig. 6.2-7c. This apparatus is also designed for efficient mixing, granulating, gas stripping, and vacuum drying in a “one pot” manner. In this case, to avoid condensation, the bowl and lid are doublewalled and heated. Fig. 6.2-8 depicts the complete design of a modern one-pot mixing, granulating, and drying system in which the particular advantages of microwave drying are utilized. In this drying method, the internationally standardized microwave energy of 2450 MHz causes the water molecules in the moist agglomerates to vibrate at high speed. Heat that results in evaporation is generated by friction between the water molecules throughout the mass to be dried. Therefore, drying does no longer occur from the outside by transfer and conduction of heat; it now proceeds at a faster rate, particularly if the solids exhibit poor heat conductivity. For pharmaceutical applications, cleanliness and avoiding cross-contamination are important requirements. Fig. 6.2-9 shows that even the smallest vertical high-shear mixers can be executed such that the stainless steel vessels are exchangeable to accommodate different materials by dedicating a specific bowl to a particular formulation or to allow easy external cleaning. Larger units may feature a similar design. Although
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-8 Diagram of one-pot mixing, granulating, and drying system featuring microwave drying (courtesy FUKAE Powtec Corp., Kobe City, Japan)
Fig. 6.2-9 Small vertical highshear mixer/agglomerator with exchangeable stainless steel vessels of 1, 2, 4, and 8 L volumes (courtesy Diosna, Osnabr€ uck, Germany)
97
98
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-10 Typical through-thewall installation of a mid-sized vertical high-shear mixer/agglomerator (600 L bowl) with container feeding through the ceiling in a pharmaceutical processing plant (courtesy Diosna, Osnabr€ uck, Germany)
vertical high-shear mixer/agglomerators always operate in batch mode, new equipment sometimes has a rather large volume (up to 2000 L) of which, depending on the material and application, 30–80 % is useable per batch. This allows large production rates because, typically, processing times are short (Fig. 6.2-10). In addition, if the drying process is carried-out externally, as shown in Fig. 6.2-11, in which a fluidized bed dryer is applied in line, a quasi-continuous process is obtained. In such an arrangement, a closed system from loading the raw materials to the discharge of dry granular product is also achieved. It has been already mentioned that in order to maintain a clean room environment in the processing department, “through-the-wall installation” is increasingly applied. The execution of all equipment for the granulation of pharmaceutical formulations, whether employing wet tumble/growth or any of the pressure agglomeration methods, can be either free-standing or through-the-wall, depending on the specific cleanliness requirements. Fig. 6.2-12 depicts the difference between the two system designs, using a simple vertical high-shear mixer/agglomerator as example.
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-11 A quasi-continuous system for mixing, granulating, and drying in a pharmaceutical setting featuring a bowl mixer/granulator of 600 L volume
and an external fluidized bed dryer (courtesy Diosna, Osnabr€ uck, Germany)
Another commonly desired equipment feature in the pharmaceutical industry is a modular design. As already shown (Fig. 6.2-9) one of the reasons for this is the easy exchange of machine parts for cleaning or the commitment of, for example, a vessel or tooling to only one material to avoid any cross-contamination. The latter is particularly necessary if the machine parts are complicated and not easily washed and/or disinfected. Modular attachments (Fig. 6.2-13) also allow modifications to include, for
99
100
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-12 Diagram of through-the-wall and free-standing installations of a vertical high-shear mixer/agglomerator (courtesy Diosna, Osnabr€ uck, Germany)
example, vacuum processing with and without solvent recovery, CIP, different lids with or without filter attachments, various internal tools, instrumentation and so on. Although the above discussions were limited to two types of high-shear mixer/agglomerator, the irregular, stochastic movement that is required for high-performance blending of particulate solids in all types of blenders also produces ideal conditions for growth agglomeration by coalescence. Agglomeration (granulation) is achieved in the apparatus during or after the mixing phase by a controlled addition of binder. In the pharmaceutical industry, maintaining a uniform distribution of all components in the granular product is of particular interest since an often extremely small amount of very finely divided active substance (the drug) must be mixed uniformly and reliably with a relatively large amount of inert filler material (excipient) and segregation avoided by stabilization through agglomeration.
Fig. 6.2-13 Diagram of modular design features offered with a vertical high-shear mixer/agglomerator (courtesy H€ uttlin, Steinen, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-14 Diagrams, including indication of particle movements, and photographs of different batch-operating low-shear mixer/ agglomerators: a) double-cone (courtesy Abbe´, Little Falls, NJ, USA), b) slanted-cone (courtesy Gemco, Middlesex, NJ, USA), c) V-shape (courtesy Abbe´, Little Falls, NJ, USA) [B.97]
For some applications, low-shear, batch-operating mixer/agglomerators, such as double-cone, slanted-cone, or V-shape blenders (Fig. 6.2-14) are successfully applied in the pharmaceutical industry if the particles are soft or brittle and degradation during blending should be avoided. However, considerable problems can arise if components of the mixing and agglomerating tumbling mass have different characteristics and/or sizes. In such cases, particles that, for any reason whatsoever, feature higher adhesion tendency and/or the smaller size fraction(s) of the formulation may selectively agglomerate, thus making it impossible to achieve the ideal mixture in the granulates. The gentle tumbling in low-shear mixers does not produce sufficiently high forces to destroy these agglomerate and make the particles available for renewed, more uniform attachment to granules. The incorporation of choppers, which in mixers with stationary vessels and moving tools help in the destruction and rebuilding of agglomerates, is difficult but can be accomplished if absolutely necessary (Fig. 10-11). Aside from the gentler processing, the low-shear mixer/agglomerators produce loosely assembled granules with low density and high bulk volume. The first increases somewhat as larger agglomerates acquire more mass (Fig. 6.2-15). Furthermore, it is more difficult to achieve uniform distribution of the binder liquid. Upon impact with the powder mass, droplets wet larger areas (Fig. 5-5) and, because of the low shear, the
101
102
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
liquid remains trapped in this volume. Although, during tabletting, the low-density intermediate products require longer punch strokes and higher amounts of gas need to be removed, necessitating some dwell time (Section 10.2), the compacted solid dosage forms obtained from such granules often feature improved structure, higher porosity, and better dispersibility. Combinations of high-shear blender and low-shear agglomerator, the P-K blender agglomerator, for example, unite continuous operation with a more uniform binder distribution. As shown in Fig. 6.2-16, this design consists of a slowly turning eccentric drum to which a V-shaped (zigzag) shell is mounted. Inside the drum is a dispersion head that rotates at high speed, aerates the powder, and supplies finely atomized liquid via special slots [B.97]. The charge is uniformly wetted and seeds are formed, which through repeated internal recycle from the zigzag portion back into the drum, grow uniformly into loosely bonded agglomerates. During the forward flow in the final part of the V-tube, granules are rounded and grow somewhat more. Because near the discharge end of the machine essentially no shear occurs, some segregation and selective agglomeration may still be experienced. If granulated pharmaceutical formulations with uniform composition and low density are required, application of the fluidized bed [B.41, B.48, B.49, B.68, B.93, B.97] has become increasingly prevalent. The technology, in this industry originally mostly used for the gentle and uniform drying of green agglomerates (Fig. 6.2-11), has lately emerged as an important method for the production of granulated formulations. Because the agglomerated particles are relatively small and have low density, most of the instant pharmaceutical specialties are now produced by fluidized bed processes. Particularly if dry powder is produced in a spray dryer plant from solutions, suspensions, or slurries, agglomeration can be accomplished if the partially solidified but still moist particles are tumbled in an associated fluidized bed where, in most cases, final drying also takes place. Fig. 6.2-17 is the schematic flow diagram of a continuous fluidized spray dryer (FSD). As compared with the conventional spray dryer [B.48, B.49, B.71, B.93], a somewhat modified gas handling system is the most obvious new feature of the FSD. Drying gas (9) not only enters the top of the tower for cocurrent drying but also a so-called “plenum”, a specially designed chamber at the bot-
Fig. 6.2-15 Typical agglomerates that were produced in a batch low-shear mixer/agglomerator with V-shaped shell. Agglomerate sizes: left, about
0.750 mm; right, about 4 mm (courtesy PattersonKelly, East Stroudsburg, PA, USA)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-16 A P-K zigzag continuous blender/agglomerator (courtesy Patterson-Kelly, East Stroudsburg, PA, USA)
tom of the tower, from which the hot gas is introduced through a distribution plate. The amount of drying gas entering with the dispersed feed (3) is controlled so that, while the droplets descend in the tower, only partial drying is accomplished. The still partially wet, slightly sticky particles are captured in a fluidized bed (5) where they
Fig. 6.2-17 Diagram of a continuous fluidized spray dryer (FSD) with open plant gas flow (courtesy GEA/NIRO, S€ oborg, Denmark) [B.97]
103
104
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
collide and form larger agglomerates. Fines (7) that are removed from the off-gas (10) in a dust collector (6) are recirculated to the fluidized bed where they are attached to the growing agglomerates. While the solids tumble in the fluidized bed and grow by agglomeration they are also dried with the hot fluidizing gas. Dry, agglomerated product (8) is removed from the fluidized bed in a suitable manner [B.97]. In the pharmaceutical industry, fluidized bed technology is also commonly used for the granulation of powders or mixed powder formulations by re-wet agglomeration. For reasons of containment and cleanliness, batch operating is the preferred process execution. Fig. 6.2-18 shows the principle of the process (right) and the outline of an apparatus (left) depicting, from bottom to top, a container for collecting the product, the plenum with gas distribution plate, the tower in which the fluidized bed develops and liquid binder is sprayed onto the charge and integral bag filters for capturing
Fig. 6.2-18 left) The principle of batch fluidbed granulation; right) the outline of an apparatus (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-19 P&ID of a typical batch fluid-bed granulation system (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-20 Germany)
Two batch fluid-bed granulation units (courtesy Glatt, Binzen,
entrained fines. Fig. 6.2-19 is the process and instrumentation diagram of a typical installation showing the supply of hot air into the plenum at the bottom and the discharge of gas through filters at the top. The flow is adjusted and balanced by means of a number of automatically controlled dampers (called “control flaps” in the figure). The top-spray arrangement for binder liquid is clearly visible. Fig. 6.2-20 shows actual equipment and Fig. 6.2-21 presents a typical product. Another advantage of the fluidized bed technology is the relatively simple shape of the processing chamber which, in general terms, is a vertical tower consisting of several easily removable and exchangeable sections. For example, as seen in Fig. 6.2-22, two mid-sections may be installed on the frame of the apparatus, designed for quick exchange. While one is in operation the other can be cleaned or modified. It is also easy to perform CIP, a fully automatic, reproducible cleaning process without the need to open the apparatus (Fig. 6.2-23a). Of course, problem zones such as the filters, distribution plate, sealing joints, and bulls eye windows must be specially adapted.
105
106
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-21 Acetaminophen (paracetamol) granules produced in a top-spray fluid-bed processor: a) surface, b) cross section, revealing internal voids (compare with Fig. 6.2-32). Magnification 60 (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-22 Batch fluid-bed granulation unit with two mid-sections installed on the frame for easy and quick exchange (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-23 CIP of fluid-bed granulation units: a) principle of automatic cleaning, b) principle of washable pulse blow-back filters and view into the filter area of a unit, c) metal cartridge filter, d) hydraulically extendable washing nozzles (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
The filters are a particular concern. Fig. 6.2-23b shows schematically and as a view into the filter area the washable pulse blow-back filters of one manufacturer. The shape of the metal filter cartridge (Fig. 6.2-23c), which is entirely made from stainless steel, combines optimum filtration with outstanding cleaning properties and maximum durability. The spray nozzles for washing are installed in the shell of the apparatus but, because they would disturb the material and gas flows if they were protruding into the chamber during operation of the fluidized bed, they are retracted or flush with the wall inside when not in use and extend automatically if connected with the line providing pressurized cleaning liquid (Fig. 6.2-23d).
107
108
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-24 SC (“SuperClean”) fluidized bed granulator equipped for CIP and total containment (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
The ability to perform WIP or CIP is part of the process validation in the pharmaceutical industry. While WIP means a thorough automatic pre-cleaning but, to achieve the required results, still needs opening of the unit for a manual final cleaning, CIP is a fully automated, reproducible cleaning process with a defined result. Both are applied depending on machine design and material to be processed. Equipment for the latter is specially executed (Fig. 6.2-24) and must not be opened between campaigns or when changing from one formulation to the other. Because there may be several units in a production facility that periodically undergo WIP or CIP, the equipment supplying washing liquid with the required quantity, pressure, and temperature is often mounted on a skid (Fig. 6.2-25), which is moved and connected to a particular apparatus as required. The unit may also include the metering of the correct amount of cleaning agent(s) into the liquid.
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-25
WIP/CIP skid (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-26 Diagram of the principle of continuous fluid-bed drying and granulation (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
109
110
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
For certain applications, the fluid bed can be operated continuously. Fig. 6.2-26 depicts the principle of this design. In most units a liquid raw material is dried while particle size is building up. Entrained fines, collected with external filters, are recirculated. It is also possible to continuously add other particulate solids. Both act as seed material for the granulation process. The fluid bed guarantees that all raw materials are homogeneously mixed in the agglomerates, which are discharged continuously through a centrally arranged pipe in the circular distribution plate. The final product size is determined by the velocity of air flowing upwards in the discharge pipe. Fluidized bed equipment lends itself particularly well to vacuum processing. Fig. 6.227 is the process and instrumentation diagram of a batch vacuum top-spray fluid-bed granulator with liquid (solvent, binder) recovery. The advantages of vacuum processing are: * *
* *
*
constant conditions, independent of atmospheric influences, a reduction of the vaporization temperature and shortening, up to 90 %, of the drying time (Fig. 6.2-28), the production of granules with higher porosity (Fig. 6.2-29), an expensive system to provide an inert gas atmosphere, if necessary in “open” systems, is not required, and up to 99 % of the liquid used in the process can be recovered and, in most cases, reused.
Fig. 6.2-30 shows photographs of two batch vacuum fluid-bed granulators with liquid recovery, indicating the extent of the vacuum and recovery systems. In a relatively new development, the distribution plate in a batch fluid-bed granulator is replaced by a solid rotating plate fitted into a conical bottom section [B.97]. Process air enters the apparatus through the annular space between the plate and the container walls. Its amount can be varied by changing the annular gap width
Fig. 6.2-27 P&ID of a batch vacuum top-spray fluid-bed granulator with solvent recovery (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-28 Comparison of the drying temperatures and times achieved in contact and vacuum fluid-bed dryers (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
by moving the plate up or down. Fig. 6.2-31 depicts the principle and the outline of an apparatus. The rotation of the plate produces a torus-like movement, which rounds and densifies agglomerates much in the same manner as in a spheronizer (Fig. 6.2-65). Fig. 6.2-32 shows microphotographs of a pharmaceutical product which, in spite of some densification, still features a considerable amount of internal void spaces. A similar rounding effect but without the same high densification can be obtained in a continuous fluid-bed drying/granulation process in which the bottom plate features rings of different perforations to modify airflow (Fig. 6.2-33). The airflow pattern induces a rotating ring of material in which the liquid droplets impinge solids and are dried. Granules are growing, rounded, and classified before they dis-
Fig. 6.2-29 SEM image of a granule produced in a vacuum fluid-bed granulator (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
111
112
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-30 Two vacuum batch fluid-bed units with closed loop and solvent recovery systems (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
charge through the central exit pipe (Fig. 6.2-26) and are cooled in an external fluid-bed cooler. Fig. 6.2-34 depicts the process and instrumentation diagram of such a process and Fig. 6.2-35 shows photographs of an apparatus and a typical product. Worldwide, there is a growing number of manufacturers that offer specialized equipment for the pharmaceutical industry using tumble/growth agglomeration/ granulation, particularly in mixers and fluid beds. Special process and equipment execution of all types in this industry (see also Sections 6.2.2 and 6.2.3) is driven by an extreme need for cleanliness and containment and by government-imposed registration and validation [6.2.1.3]. Stainless steel and other, sometimes exotic materials of construction, smooth external and internal surfaces, special seals, valves, probes and instrumentation, modular design, and one-pot processing, during which multiple steps are performed in one container or a sealed production line without the
Fig. 6.2-31 Diagrams of the principle and outline of a fluid-bed granulator with solid rotating bottom plate (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-32 Acetaminophen (paracetamol) granules produced in a rotary fluid-bed processor: a) surface, b) cross section, still revealing internal voids (compare with Fig. 6.2-21), magnification 60 (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-33 Principle of a special rounding continuous fluid-bed drying/granulation process (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-34 P&ID of a rounding continuous fluid-bed drying/ granulation process (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
113
114
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-35 A rounding continuous fluid-bed drying/granulation process apparatus and a typical product at two different magnifications (courtesy Glatt, Binzen, Germany)
need to open, handle, and transfer intermediate product forms, are the most distinguishing characteristics of pharmaceutical processing and equipment. While the techniques of only a few vendors are being introduced and discussed above and in Sections 6.2.2 and 6.2.3, many additional suppliers are available, some of which are mentioned in Section 15.1.
6.2.2
Pressure Agglomeration Technologies
As already discussed, the rolling of pills from moist and sticky medicinal blends is most probably the oldest application of agglomeration in pharmacy although, to the author’s knowledge, there is no historical document available that proves its exact origin. These older forms of solid dosage are the direct precursors of today’s primary solid pharmaceutical product, the tablet, in all its forms and presentations. While references in the Egyptian “Papyrus Ebers” already seem to confirm the use of some sort of agglomerated preparation, the manufacturing of “pills” was first reported by the Greeks and Romans well before the beginning of our calendar and in Persia and Arabia in the 9th and 10th centuries AD (Tab. 6.2-3). Such agglomerates were also often coated to improve their taste and/or appeal. Originally pills were, and sometimes still today are, rolled by hand whereby manual pressure is applied directly or with rolling boards and discs (Fig. 6.2-1). During the
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Tab. 6.2-3 [B.48]
Early history of tabletting for pharmaceutical specialties
Time
Source/Inventor(s)
Shape or manufacturing method
BC BC 850 – 923 980 – 1037 Tenth century 1448 1606 1837 1837
Greeks Romans Rhazes al-Razi (Persia) Avicenna (Perisa) Al-Zahrawie (Arabia) Apothecary, Florence (Italy) Jean de Renou (France) M. Labelonie (France) A. Fortin (France)
1838 1840
M. Deschamps (France) E. Mayer, F. Roman (France)
1843 1848 1874
W. Brockedon (England) US Dispensatory, 12th edition (USA) J.A. McFerran (USA)
1874
Th.J. Young (USA)
1875 1876
J.P. Remington (USA) J. Dunton (USA)
1877 1877
G. Gercke, Jr (Germany) Th.J. Young (USA)
1878
Ch. Charter (USA)
1881
A. Edler von Hofmann (Germany)
1882
J.T. Jones (USA) Ch.T. Jones
1885 1889
J. Lusby (USA) O. Smith (USA) H.K. Mulford
1891 1894 1895 1896 – 7
W. Kilian P.M. Justice (England) F. Kilian (Germany) P.J. Noyes (USA)
1897 1898 1898
P.E.M. Jamain (France) W. Kra¨mer (Germany) W.R. Dodd (USA)
1900
F. Kilian (Germany)
1901
Allen and Hanburys Ltd (England)
1903
Henning and Martin (Germany)
’Katapotia’ ’Pilulae’ Pills with Psyllium seed Silver- and gold-coated pills Pastille shapes Silver- and gold-coated pills in Europe ’Tabellae’ Sugar-coated polls (dragees) Patent 5116 for the manufacture of sugar coatings of pills Honey and Acacia powder Patents 6222 and 6449 for the manufacture of pill coatings of sugar and Acacia powder English Patens 9977 for a tabletting press Manufacturing of dragees US Patent 152666, tabletting press (improvement in pill machines) US Patent 156398, improvement in machines for making pills, lizenges, etc. Tabletting press US Patent 174790, tabletting press (improvement in pill machines) German Patent 5006, rotating press US Patent 189005, improvement in machines for marking pills US Patent 207013, improvement in coated, compressed pills, lozenges, etc. German Patent 15535, machine for pressing of flowery, powdery, or grainy materials US Patent 256573, machine for making pills, lozenges, etc. US Patent 323349, pill-making machine German Patent 54817, machine for the production of pills German Patent 63185, ’pastille’ press German Patent 81470 pastille and pill press German Patent 88514, ’pastille’ press US Patents 568488 and 582794, press for sugar-coating pills, pill machine German Patent 99282, pastille press German Patent 112286, tablette press German Patent 113018, press for the manufacturing of pills, pastilles, tabletts, etc. German Patents 120903 and 126493, rotating table press German Patent 146340, press for the manufacture of medicinal tablettes German Patent 158023, press with rotating table and punches
115
116
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Tab. 6.2-3
(continued)
Time
Source/Inventor(s)
Shape or manufacturing method
1904
F. Kilian (Germany)
1906
F.F.W. Stieler (Germany)
1907
Th. O. Kend (England)
1908
F. Kilian (Germany)
1914 1917
Tietz and Co. (Germany) F.J. Stokes (USA)
German Patents 160550 and 165401, press with rotating table German Patent 190355, method for making pastilles in presses with movable upper and lower punches German Patent 202270, manufacture of pharmacuetical tablettes with a movable upper and lower punch German Patent 204824, press with rotating table and upper punches which are held coaxially in relation to the respective lower punch German Patent 287776, coating press US Patent 1248571, press for the manufacture of coated tablets
second part of the 10th century AD, Arabian “pharmacists” used a simple manually operated press to form moist powder [6.2.2]. Material was compacted between the two halves of a tongue-shaped tool made of bone, ivory, or wood. For many centuries, these forms of solid medicines for oral application had been well accepted by the patients and were produced in relatively large numbers. Nevertheless, the invention of the tabletting die press in 1843 by William Brockedon (Tab. 6.2-3) initiated a revolution in the manufacturing of pharmaceutical solid dosage forms. Although very simple and manually operated, his patent (British Patent 9977, 1843) entitled Shaping pills, lozenges, and black lead by pressure described the still-valid basic principle of punch-and-die presses, Fig. 6.2-36 [6.2.2.1]. It took some time until this method was accepted but the pace accelerated in 1874 when two additional patents for “improved pill machines” were granted in the USA. Both new machines were suitable for use with a belt drive. Thomas J. Young’s patent (US Patent 156 398, Fig. 6.2-37 [6.2.2.1]) used an eccentric movement that was disengaged when the upper punch reached its highest position. After manually filling the cavity with powder, the operator connected the eccentric drive with the fly-wheel causing the upper punch to descend, compact the powder, and then withdraw to the highest position where the drive was automatically disengaged. After manually pushing out the tablet, the cycle could begin once more. Joseph A. McFerran’s machine (US Patent 152 666, Fig. 6.2-38 [6.2.2.1]) already used a round, indexed table carrying several dies with their associated lower punches. A spindle drive, automatically turning left and right, moved the upper punch up and down and the press table was moved ahead by one step when the upper punch reached its highest point. Both filling the die and removal of the finished tablet were also already accomplished automatically. After that time, further improvements were invented around the world in rapid succession (Tab. 6.2-3). They were aimed at more accurate tablet shape and weight and increased the capacity of each unit, mostly by additional state-of-the-art automa-
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-36 Patent drawing of Brockedon’s hand tool for tabletting. British Patent 9977, 1843
Fig. 6.2-37 Patent drawing of Young’s eccentric drive tabletting machine. US Patent 156 398, 1874
117
118
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-38 Patent drawing of McFerran’s indexed table tabletting machine. US Patent 152 666, 1874
tion. While the basic principles, defined in the early inventions, remained largely unchanged, improvements which, during the past decades, have been strongly influenced by Government imposed cGMP (current good manufacturing practice), validation, and cleanliness requirements, result in the design and offering of quickly and perpetually improved compaction equipment for the pharmaceutical industry [B.34, B.41, B.48, B.66, B.71, B.97, B.99, B.105]. Today, high-pressure agglomeration is still the most widely used technology for obtaining dry pharmaceutical dryosage forms, so-called tablets. Because individual units are small, with diameters usually in the range 5–17 mm and weights of 0.1– 1.0 g, and must be of uniform, highly reproducible shape, only machines operating with punches and dies are applicable. Although other punch-and-die presses, such as simple ejection and withdrawal machines [B.97], are used for special applications and for research and development, to meet the throughput requirements of modern pharmaceutical production, measured by the number of tablets made per unit time, special equipment, so-called rotary tabletting machines [B.6, B.48, B.66, B.97, B.99, B.105], has been introduced, which is capable of producing up to 1 million compacts per hour.
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-39 The layout of a rotary punch-and-die press [B.71, B.97]
The basic operating principle of rotary punch-and-die presses is similar to that of all reciprocating ejection machines. The difference lies in the fact that a series of dies is mounted into a circular steel table (the so-called “turret”) near its periphery (Fig. 6.239) and that two punches (one upper and one lower, Fig. 6.2-40) are associated with each die. The punches are moved by stationary cams while the turret with the dies and punches is rotating. An evoluted presentation of one pressing cycle is shown in Fig. 6.2-40. Feed is supplied to the table through a frame, often called the “feed shoe”, which may include a mechanical, in most cases rotating flow stimulator. The feeder is connected to a hopper above. When a particular die moves under the feed shoe, the bottom punch that is associated with that die is pulled down to its lowest position by its cam thus allowing the die to fill with powder. The punch then rises up an adjustable ramp to eject excessive powder from the die. The powder surplus is scraped off flush with the top of the turret at the highest point of the “weight adjustment ramp”. Assuming uniform fill density, this always leaves the same volume of powder to be compacted in the die. It is common practice to let the lower punch drop down slightly after the surplus material has been scraped off. This is done to prevent uncontrolled displacement or “blow-out” of powder from the die when the upper punch enters. Both punches are then moved together by their cams to achieve densification and compaction. If, optionally, the ramps moving the punches remain parallel for some distance after reaching maximum densification, a so-called ’dwell time” is introduced. During this time, the compact remains under pressure so that additional deaeration and conversion of elastic deformation into permanent plastic deformation can occur and expansion upon pressure relief is minimized (below and Section 10.2). The overall opposing movements of both punches during densification and compaction produce the effect of double pressure and, therefore result in a relatively uniform structure of the tabletted product (Fig. 6.7-23). Finally, the upper punch is lifted from the die and the lower punch travels up to eject the finished compact. As shown in Fig. 6.2-40b, another but more technically detailed evoluted presentation of a typical high speed, high-pressure rotary tabletting machine, quite often, the maximum pressure is produced by one (or two) set(s) of press rollers that oppose each other. One or both are supported by springs to provide overload protection. In such machines, the final compaction takes place very quickly and is followed by a sudden
119
120
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-40 a) Evoluted (straightened) diagram of a rotary punch-and-die press. b) Paths of the punches in rotary punch-and-die (tabletting)
presses with one or two sets of press rollers in evoluted presentation [B.71, B.97]
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
pressure relief. This is similar to what happens in roller presses [B.13b, B.48, B.97] but, because in tabletting machines the roller diameter is very small and the table speed is high, this process takes place extremely fast. Therefore, capping (below) is a commonly observed problem in high-speed tabletting. To avoid this and still maintain high-production capacity, the preparation of special particulate feeds by pre-granulation (below) is frequently a necessity to overcome this defect. The simplest type of rotary machine is “single sided” with one feed location and a certain number (as few as four) of “stations” (dies) on the table. One rotation of the turret produces as many compacts as there are dies (and punch sets) on the machine. Therefore, the output of single sided rotary machines depends on the maximum allowable speed of and the number of stations on the table. It is normally in the range 300–800 tablets per minute. It can be doubled by installing two feed locations. In this case, the stations are filled twice on opposite sides of the rotating table and two compressions are carried out in each die per revolution of the turret. Obviously, to maintain the rate of densification and compaction the number of stations on the correspondingly larger table would have to be doubled, too. Outputs of more than 3000 tablets per minute can be obtained from well compacting material with double sided machines. Although the above production numbers also seem to indicate large volumetric capacities this is not the case because the individual compacts often weigh less than 1 g each. For example, with a tablet weight of one gram an output of 3000 tablets per minute translates to a capacity of 180 kg/h. A further increase in numbers of (typically small) compacts produced per minute in rotary punch-anddie presses can be achieved by dual or multiple tooling (two or more die sets) per station (below and, for example, Section 6.3.2). In many reciprocating and most rotary presses for the pharmaceutical and similar industries, the original and still most common “standard” shape of compacts is a more or less cylindrical tablet. As depicted in Fig. 6.2-41, this description includes flat, faceted, and crowned products. For these shapes, simple die and punch configurations are applicable. Since tabletted dry dosage forms in the pharmaceutical industry are consumer products, aesthetics and requirements that are dictated by the medical application (easy identification of a particular formulation by the user) and the marketing-driven desire to distinguish between manufacturers have more recently resulted in the development of special shapes, some of which are shown in Fig. 6.2-42. Additionally, the punches may be engraved as demonstrated, for example, in Fig. 6.2-43. Finally, as already mentioned above, the tooling for smaller tablets can be designed such that in a single pressing station two or more die cavities are associated with correspondingly shaped punches to produce several compacts at once (Section 6.3.2, Fig. 6.3-14). Of course, such punch and die designs are very delicate and require high-precision press designs and excellent maintenance. Expulsion of entrapped gas (air) from granulated or (particularly) powder feeds is very important because it reduces lamination and capping of the tablets. As repeatedly mentioned (also, for example, Section 10.2 and [B.48, B.97]), if gas is entrapped in compacts where it becomes compressed in the residual pore spaces and/or elastic deformation is still present when the compaction pressure is released, products from pressure agglomeration methods are partially or totally destroyed during ejec-
121
122
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-41
“Standard” tablet shapes [B.48, B.97]
tion. During the manufacturing of pharmaceutical dry dosage forms with high-speed rotary tabletting presses, capping, the separation of a thin layer of material from the main body of the tablet on one or both faces (Fig. 6.2-44), is a particular problem. It is caused by particulate solid feeds that are not suitable for quick, high-pressure densification or, in other words, by too high compaction forces and/or excessive speed of densification (Section 10.2).
Fig. 6.2-42 Some special tablet shapes [B.97]
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-43 An assortment of engraved punches (courtesy Kilian, K€ oln, Germany)
Raw particulate solids for tabletting may be of three types: (1) non-compressible powders, (2) compresssible powders possessing poor flow characteristics, and (3) compressible powders featuring good flow properties. Non-compressible powders are either pre-granulated wet, which, in some cases, may add a binder component that also renders the granulate better compressible (Section 6.2.1, Tab. 6.2-2), or, if the dosage level is sufficiently low, they are mixed with a powder excipient of type (3) so that the blend becomes compressible and free-flowing. The same methods are used to improve the characteristics of type (2) whereby, if pre-granulation is selected, application of the dry compaction/granulation methods (below) may be advantageous. Type (3) powders are called directly compressible. Validation and cleanliness requirements considerably burden the designs of all equipment for the pharmaceutical industry. To avoid cross-contamination it is necessary to include on modern machines CIP or at least WIP features. It is easily understandable that such techniques are difficult, to say the least, when considering the com-
Fig. 6.2-44 Tablets with “capping” and sketch explaining the capping phenomenon [B.48]
123
124
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-45 Glove box design of the processing part of a rotary punch-and-die tabletting machine demonstrating WIP (courtesy Fette, Schwarzenbek, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-46 Photographs showing: a) complete turret assembly, b) handling of the turret assembly in a smaller machine, c) turret assembly removal from a larger press, d) special handling system (courtesy Fette, Schwarzenbek, Germany)
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
plicated mechanical design of multi-station (up to more than 75 per turret [B.66, B.97, B.99, B.105]) rotary tabletting presses. Nevertheless, WIP is one of the latest features of such machines (Fig. 6.2-45). To meet the stringent requirements of the regulatory authorities and reduce downtimes, from newer machines (that were designed during the last decade or so) the entire turret assembly, complete with die table, upper and lower punches and upper and lower cam tracks (Fig. 6.2-46a) can be removed for cleaning, exchange, or maintenance. Smaller machines are equipped with integrated handling and mounting devices (Fig. 6.2-46b) while the assemblies of larger machines require separate handling systems (Fig. 6.2-46c and d).
Fig. 6.2-47 a) Modular system concept; b) modern automated standard tabletting system with rotary tabletting machine and tablet discharge units (courtesy Kilian, K€ oln, Germany)
125
126
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
The available space for and requirements of tabletting lines vary greatly. This is why many manufacturers have adopted a modular concept consisting of presses with various feed systems, tablet discharge, de-dusting, de-burring, metalcheck, and collection devices, automatic sampling and analysis, and in-process control and documentation (Fig. 6.2-47a). Fig. 6.2-47b shows a modern automated standard tabletting system. Depending on the equipment used, such lines feature good tablet unloading, bad tablet channel, and sample extractor. Electromagnetic gates may also separate tablets that are off-specification during machine start-ups and shut-down. Since punch-and-die presses of various designs are widely used in the pharmaceutical industry and represent the most important equipment for the manufacturing of solid dosage forms, many books have been published on the subject in essentially all languages around the world. It exceeds the context of this book to go into more detail. Rather, the specialized literature should be sought and reviewed, which can be obtained from the pharmaceutical associations existing in all major countries, from international sellers of academic, scientific, and technical books that can be found on the Internet, and from vendors (Section 15.1). The books cited by the author [B.6, B.34, B.41, B.48, B.66, B.97, B.99, B.105] are those that are in his personal library. Originally, when tabletting was first introduced, the powder feeds to the machines were almost always somewhat moist. While, normally, for punch-and-die presses with relatively few strokes per minute accurate and reproducible filling of the die is not a problem and the rate of densification in those machines can be adjusted to match the compressibility of the particulate feed, the very high speed of rotary presses often causes problems. As finer, dry mixtures had to be tabletted and an ever increasing pressing speed was used to optimize the machines’ production rates, it was found that some excipients which, up to that point, behaved very well during densification did not yield products with acceptable quality. At that time (the early 20th century), without knowing all the reasons for this behavior, the term “direct compression” was coined and later (after 1950 [6.2.1.1]) used to identify a process by which tablets are pressed directly from powder blends of the active ingredient and suitable excipients without any pretreatment. With time, the composition of solid drug forms became more complex and feed mixtures for direct compression now also include fillers, disintegrants, and lubricants. It is now increasingly difficult to formulate suitable blends even though directly compressible tablet vehicles (excipients), such as spray-dried lactose, microcrystalline cellulose (MCC), modified starches, and others, are commercially available, increasingly and cheaply. Although the simplicity of the direct compression process is obvious, if pharmaceutical blends are pre-treated in one way or another prior to tabletting, flow characteristics can be improved, compressibility adjusted, and a good particle size and distribution can be selected that yields an optimal feed bulk density. However, the pretreatment of dry dosage formulations becomes more and more complicated to render them suitable for use with the sophisticated high-speed tabletting machines [B.34, B.41, B.48, B.66, B.71, B.97, B.99, B.105]. In simple terms, for those presses it is a requirement that the feed flows quickly and uniformly into the die cavities where it can be converted into well-shaped and firm compacts in a very short time. Tablet quality is a result of the blend’s “compressibility”. This characteristic not only includes an excel-
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
lent densification behavior, obtained by low interparticle friction, possibly assisted by the addition of lubricants, and suitable deformation properties, often defined by the nature of the main excipient, but also the quick and complete escape of air that is displaced during the fast densification stroke. For that, the absence of elasticity, which may be associated with large crystallites, and a uniformly diminishing porosity are required so that no elastic spring-back occurs upon pressure release and no isolated pores are formed in which air could be trapped and end-up as compressed gas pockets. As the active components in solid dosage forms become more potent and represent a decreasing percentage of the overall composition, an extremely uniform distribution is required to guarantee the correct content of the drug in each individual tablet [B.48]. Therefore, an increasingly important reason for pre-treatment is the necessity of avoiding segregation after mixing during handling and while feeding the press. (Pre-) Granulation of the powder feed blends for tabletting machines solves all above mentioned potential problems (Tab. 6.2-2). Flow characteristics of pre-granulated formulations, owing to the larger apparent (agglomerate) size, are usually superior, even to those of naturally free-flowing powders. While there are indications that some dry granulation for tabletting was already performed by “slugging” (below) prior to 1900 in the pharmaceutical industry, the “classic” process is carried-out by wet granulation (Section 6.2.1). Alternatively, the formulation is blended, moistened, and originally was passed through a screen by the eminence of the hand; drying then yields the granular product. Technically however, this is a low-pressure agglomeration method; modern mechanized and typically motorized equipment is shown schematically in Fig. 6.2-48. Since it is possible that lumps are produced during drying, an optional mill may be used to obtain a uniform, granular product (Fig. 6.2-49). Fig. 6.2-50 and 6.2-51 show of equipment according to 6.2-48 (b) and (c) [B.48, B.68, B.97]. While, as shown in Tab. 6.2-3, wet granulation may offer certain advantages, the addition of liquid(s), which is required to initiate agglomeration, is often objectionable. With liquid addition care must be taken: *
*
*
that the pharmaceutical components are not modified, for example by chemical reaction(s), (partial) dissolution and/or recrystallization, or physical changes, the liquid must be removed after granulation by drying and, if clean and/or expensive liquids are used, should or must be recovered and recirculated, which adds to the cost of the process, and control of particle size of the granular product is difficult; if sizing is required prior to further use, the rejected portion(s) must be recirculated to avoid excessive losses due to the often very high cost of the pharmaceutical formulation and to eliminate contamination or disposal problems caused by toxic drugs.
The modernized equipment depicted in Fig. 6.2-48 is still used for the granulation of certain powder mixtures in the pharmaceutical industry. However, other agglomeration methods, which were developed during the 19th and 20th centuries for different applications, have been modified for use as (pre-)granulation techniques in the pharmaceutical industry and have become more important, as they can be particularly well
127
128
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-48 Diagram of low-pressure agglomeration equipment using gravity feed and screens or thin perforated sheets: a) screen, b) trough, c) basket [B.97]
Fig. 6.2-49 Sketch of a low-pressure agglomeration system with screen granulator, dryer, and (optional) mill: 1) wet feed mixture, 2) granular product including fines [B.97]
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-50 Small trough-type granulator with horizontal rotor axis (courtesy Erweka, Heusenstamm, Germany)
designed to meet the special new requirements of validation, control, and documentation. In view of the above mentioned concerns that are associated with wet granulation, improved granulation processes make use of dry powder compaction. Historically, “slugging” was the first such technique. For this, as shown in Fig. 6.2-52, left, large (in diameter and thickness) tablets were made with often old punch-and-die machines, so-called slugging presses, that are no longer suitable for the manufacturing of highquality pharmaceutical dry dosage forms and, therefore, operated relatively cheaply. The compacts were broken to yield a granular feed forgranular feed for tabletting machines. At the beginning, this was mostly done to pre-densify the powder, thereby reducing the press stroke during tabletting, and speed-up the process. Later, the additional advantages described in Tab. 6.2-3 led to a quickly increasing use of the technology. To meet the industry’s capacity requirements, slugging presses
Fig. 6.2-51 The major components (feed hopper, extrusion blades, and perforated die) of a small basket extruder (Bextruder BX 150, Courtesy Hosokawa Bepex GmbH, Leingarten, Germany)
129
130
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration Fig. 6.2-52 Simplified flow diagram of dry granulation in the pharmaceutical industry using slugging or roller presses with optional circuit alternatives [Section 13.3, ref. 147]
must produce large compacts. While, at the beginning, the tablets were crushed by hand with mortar and pestle, eventually, specially designed motorized screen granulators with oscillating or rotating rod cages (Fig. 6.2-53) as breaking tools were developed to arrive at a semi-continuous operation. The final tablets made from the crushed “slugs” (dry granulated feed) often showed a “checkered” appearance, that is, the surface featured alternating dull and shiny areas. Since pharmaceutical specialties are health remedies and consumer products that are closely scrutinized by the patient, the customers frequently rejected such tablets, resulting in call-backs by and financial losses to the manufacturer. Although other industries (e.g., ceramics) had already realized that density variations exist in pressure compacted powder masses (Section 6.7.2) which, for example, cause the distortion of parts during sintering and, eventually, triggered the development of isostatic pressing in the 1920/30s [B.13a, B.48, B.97], the pharmaceutical industry was unaware of this fact. In 1957 the English pharmacologist Train [6.2.2.2] determined and published lines of constant density in compacts after applying various pressures from the top in a cylindrical die (Fig. 6.2-54). He found that, even in such
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications Fig. 6.2-53 a) Granulator for pharmaceutical applications with screen and rod cage, b) designed for easy cleaning by disassembly (courtesy Alexanderwerk, Remscheid, Germany)
Fig. 6.2-54 Density distribution in cylindrical compacts [6.2.2.2]. Progressive stages of compaction from the top after applying the indicated
pressures. The curves in the compact are lines of constant density (1 – e) in % (e = porosity)
131
132
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
simple shapes, due to the presence of frictional forces in the mass and on the tooling surfaces, considerable density differences and gradients develop. Because the largest density variations occur if a great volume of particulate solids is densified with the application of high forces, this behavior applies particularly to the products of slugging presses. It was then realized that, during granulation (i.e., the break-up of large tablets or slugs), hard pieces were obtained from the “press-skin” and other highly densified parts of the compact while weak granules resulted from the less densified interior. During final tabletting, hard granules on the surface were compacted again and created the shiny spots in a matrix of less, but still sufficiently compacted material, explaining the “checkered” appearance. A number of other disadvantages of using slugging presses also existed. For example, they generate large amounts of dust during compaction, resulting in workplace contamination and high material losses. Since the machines are mechanically complex, they require extensive cleaning when changing from one formulation to another and cross-contamination must be avoided. The operating costs are high because of piston and die wear, and lubricants are often necessary to obtain the required compaction ratio. However the greatest disadvantage of using slugging presses is that, in addition to the above mentioned effects of friction, density and hardness also vary from compact to compact because of feeding problems associated with fine powders. This further amplifies the variations in quality of both the granulate and the final tablets. Remedying these problems is very difficult. Today, dry granulation has become a well-accepted method for the processing of powder blends prior to tabletting but slugging has been replaced in most locations by compacting roller presses (Fig. 6.2-52, right). Up to the 1960s, roller presses were almost exclusively used for “dirty” applications in the coal (Section 6.10.2), mineral (Section 6.8.2), and metallurgical (Section 6.9.2) industries. They were typically large, heavy-duty machines and it was thought that they are not particularly well suited for the compaction of very fine powders since the need to operate the rollers at low speed for successful deaeration results in small unit capacities [B.97]. The latter, however, is of no concern for the pharmaceutical industry. Individual batches for the production of a single tabletted formulation are small, often only a few hundred kilograms and sometimes even less. In addition, the value of the material to be processed and the profit margins are much higher than in most other industries. Therefore, roller speeds can be low and capacities small while still maintaining profitability. All roller compacting presses in the pharmaceutical industry use one or multiple force feeder(s) to deliver the blend to the nip between the rollers and to keep the powder firmly pressed into the nip against the flow of air expelled during compaction. The roller surfaces are smooth or slightly profiled to improve the pull of material into the nip and are set at a narrow gap, producing a thin sheet. Feeder and rollers are driven independently with variable speed drives. The feeder/roller speed ratio determines the degree of densification and the hardness of the compacted powder. Product quality can be kept constant by employing an automatic control device by which the feeder motor is slaved to the current drawn by the roll drive motor. The roller presses for pharmaceutical applications are relatively small (Fig. 6.2-55), made of stainless steel, and designed for easy cleaning (Fig. 6.2-56) to avoid cross-
6.2 Pharmaceutical Applications
Fig. 6.2-55 Four small roller presses with: a) one, b) two integrated in-line granulators for the manufacturing of tabletting feed in the pharmaceutical industry (courtesy: a1) Powtec, Remscheid, Germany; a2) Vector, Marion, IA, USA; b1) Alexanderwerk, Remscheid, Germany; b2) Riva, Buenos Aires, Argentina)
133
134
6 Industrial Applications of Size Enlargement by Agglomeration
Fig. 6.2-56 Design features for easy cleaning of roller presses for pharmaceutical applications (courtesy: a) Hosokawa Bepex, Leingarten, Germany; b) Powtec, Remscheid, Germany; c) Bonals, Barcelona, Spain)
contamination when switching from one formulation to another. To eliminate contact with oil or grease, the rollers are often fixed in the frame. This design is acceptable in the pharmaceutical industry because the blends are extremely fine, clean, and free of tramp materials. Compared with the large-scale, heavy-duty applications in other industries, the compaction forces are relatively low so that torque limiting safety features are sufficient to protect the machines mechanically. The rollers are completely enclosed in a dust