Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR VOLUME 15
Contributors to This Volume WILLIAM W. BEATTY T. M. CAR0 W. J . CARR DAR...
19 downloads
1026 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR VOLUME 15
Contributors to This Volume WILLIAM W. BEATTY T. M. CAR0 W. J . CARR DARLENE F. KENNEDY S. N . KHAYUTIN PAUL MARTIN MICHAEL J . MEANEY KLAUS R. SCHERER DAVID F. SHERRY JANE STEWART
Advances in THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR Edited by
JAY S . ROSENBLATT Institute of Animal Behavior Rutgers University Newark, New Jersey
COLINBEER Institute of Animal Behavior Rutgers University Newark, New Jersey MARIE-CLAIRE BUSNEL Laboratoire de Physiologie Di@&entielle Groupe Ge'ne'tique et Comportements Paris, France PETERJ . B. SLATER Department of Zoology The University St. Andrews Fife, Scotland
VOLUME 15 1985
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publi\her\)
Orlando San Diego New York London Toronto Montreal Sydney Tokyo
COPYRIGHT @ 1985, BY ACADEMIC PRESS. INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECI'RONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. Orlando. Florida 32887
United Kingdom Edition published by
ACADEMIC PRESS WC. (LONDON) LTD. 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER:
ISBN 0-12-004515-X PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
85 86 87 88
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
6 4-803 I
Contents
CotitriBic/or.s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pr+uce . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix xi
Sex Differences in Social Play: The Socialization of Sex Roles MICHAEL J . MEANEY. JANE STEWART. AND WILLIAM W . BEATTY I. I1 . I11. IV .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Determinants of Sex Differences in Social Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Function of Social Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 4 32 45 48
On the Functions of Play and Its Role in Behavioral Development PAUL MARTIN AND T . M . C A R 0 I. I1 . I11. IV . V. VI . V11.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Defining Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Existing Evidence Concerning the Functions of Play . . . . . . . . . . Play May Have No Major Benefits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Theoretical Problems in Detecting the Benefits of Play . . . . . . . . Methodological Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V
59 61 66 78 85 93 97 98
v1
CONTENTS
Sensory Factors in the Behavioral Ontogeny of Altricial Birds S . N . KHAYUTIN
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 I1. Organization of Natural Behavior in the Nestling . . . . . . . . . . . . . 108 111. Development of Acoustic Sensitivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Role of Audition in the Organization of Defense Behavior . . . . . . V . Ontogeny of Some Visual Mechanisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V1. Complexity of Behavior Organization in Early Postembryonic Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Discussion and Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
118 128 134 138 143 149
Food Storage by Birds and Mammals DAVID F . SHERRY
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153 I1. Memory and the Recovery of Stored Food . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160 111. Social Consequences of Caching . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 168 IV . Economics and Decision Making . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 V . Food Storing and Food Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 176 VI . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
181 183
Vocal Affect Signaling: A Comparative Approach KLAUS R . SCHERER
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 189 I1 . Empirical Evidence on Vocal Indicators of Emotion . . . . . . . . . . . 191 111. A Psychobiological Approach to Emotion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Emotional Determinants of Vocalization .................... V . The Component Patterning Theory of Vocal Affect Expression . . VI . Cross-Species Universality in the Component Patterning of Vocal Expression . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI1. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
198 206 215 235 237 238
CONTENTS
vii
A Response-Competition Model Designed to Account for the Aversion to Feed on Conspecific Flesh W. J . CARR AND DARLENE F. KENNEDY
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. The Aversion by Norway Rats to Feed on Conspecific Flesh . . . . III. A Response-Competition Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Constraining Intraspecific Predation via Response-Competition . .
References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Contents of Previous Volumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . , . . , . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . , . . , . .
245 248 263 268 270
215 279
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin
WILLIAM W. BEATTY ( I ) , Departtnent University, Fargo, North Dakota 58105
of Psychology, North Dakota State
T. M. C A R 0 (59), Sub-Department of Animal Behuviour, University of Cambridge, Madingley, Cambridge CB3 8AA, England
W. J. CARR (245), Department of Psychology, Beaver College, Glenside, Pennsylvania I9038 DARLENE F. KENNEDY (245), Department of Psychology, Beaver College, Glenside, Pennsylvania I9038
S. N. KHAYUTIN (103, USSR Academy of Sciences, Institute of Higher Nervous Activity and Neurophysiology, Moscow I 1 7485, USSR PAUL MARTIN (59), Sub-Department of Animal Behaviour, University of Cambridge, Madingley, Cambridge CB3 8AA, England MICHAEL J . MEANEY ( l ) , Center for Studies in Behavioral Neurobiology, Department of Psychology, Concordia University, Montreal H3G I M 8 , Canada KLAUS R. SCHERER (189), Department of Psychology, University of Giessen, 0-6300 Giessen, Federal Republic of Germany DAVID F. SHERRY (153), Department of Psychology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S I A l , Canada JANE STEWART ( l ) , Center for Studies in Behavioral Neurobiology, Department of Psychology, Concordia University, Montreal H3G l M 8 , Canada
ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface The aim of Advances in the Study of Behavior is to serve the increasing number of scientists who are engaged in the study of animal behavior by presenting their theoretical ideas and research to their colleagues and to those in neighboring fields. Since its inception in 1965, this publication has not changed its aim, to serve “. . . as a contribution to the development of cooperation and communication among scientists in our field.” We acknowledge that in the interim new vigor has been given to traditional fields of animal behavior by their coalescence with closely related fields and by the closer relationship that now exists between those studying animal and human subjects. Scientists studying animal behavior now range from ecologists to evolutionary biologists, geneticists, endocrinologists, ethologists, comparative and developmental psychobiologists, and those doing research in the neurosciences. As the task of developing cooperation and communication among scientists whose skills and concepts necessarily differ in accordance with the diversity of phenomena that they study has become more difficult, the need to do so has become greater. The Editors and publisher of Advances in the Study of Behavior will continue to provide the means to meet this need by publishing critical reviews, by inviting extended presentations of significant research programs, by encouraging the writing of theoretical syntheses and reformulations of persistent problems, and by highlighting especially penetrating research that introduces important new concepts.
xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR. VOL. 15
Sex Differences in Social Play: T h e Socialization of Sex Roles* MICHAEL J. MEANEYAND JANE STEWART CENTER FOR STUDIES IN BEHAVIORAL NEUROBIOLOGY DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY CONCORDIA UNIVERSITY MONTREAL, CANADA
WILLIAMW . BEATTY DEPARTMENT OF PSYCHOLOGY NORTH DAKOTA STATE UNIVERSITY FARGO, NORTH DAKOTA
Introduction ........................ ............ Determinants fferences in Social Play . . . . ...... A. Social Play in Mammals.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Sex Differences in Social Pla ..................... C. Neuroendocrine Basis of Sex rences in Social Play.. . . . . . . . . . . D. Social Influences in Social Play.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. The Function of Social Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Developmental Significance of Social Play. . . . B. Relationship between Sex Differences in Adult Behavior and the Nature of the Contribution of Social Play to Social Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Sex Differences in the Response to Social Deprivation.. . . . . . . . . . . . D. Possibility of Immediate Consequence of Social Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . .................................... References . . . . . . . . . ....... ............. I.
11.
2 4 4 14 17 28 31 32 32
34 44 45 46 48
*We are publishing two articles on the subject of play in this volume of Advances in rhe Srudy of Behavior. The two articles are quite different from one another and, since this series has not published any articles on play in previous volumes, we felt that having these two articles would provide our readers with a limited survey of this interesting and important topic in animal behavior [the Editors].
I
Copyright 0 198.5 hy Acddcmic Press. Inc. All rights of reproductinn In any forni reserved. ISBN 0-12-004.515-X
2
MICHAEL J. MEANEY ET AL.
I.
INTRODUCTION
Sex differences in social behavior exist in all mammalian species. The very act of copulation requires that the participants be engaged in different behaviors. These differences also extend to courtship or proceptive behaviors, such that males are normally attracted to the social cues of females and females are normally attracted to the social cues of males. In most species, however, there are sex differences in social behavior that extend beyond these rather obvious differences in mating behavior. Reports of sex differences in behaviors such as social grooming, infant care, territorial defense, and dominance-related activities are common, especially in primate species (for a review, see Mitchell, 1979). Variations occur across species in the extent to which the occurrence of these and other nonsexual, social behaviors are sexually dimorphic. Nevertheless, in most species of social-living mammals, there exist sex roles within groups. One problem that has received considerable attention has been the description of the factors that influence the development of sex differences in social behavior. The majority of the work on this problem has focused on the influence of perinatal hormonal events and, in particular, on the influence of gonadal steroids. Thus, in many species the expression of a particular, sexually dimorphic behavior has been associated with the early exposure to gonadal hormones (for reviews, see Beatty, 1979; Goy & McEwen, 1980). This developmental influence has been attributed to an organizational effect of gonadal hormones (Phoenix, Goy, Gerall, & Young, 1959). According to this organizational hypothesis, hormones act during an early period of neurogenesis to organize the CNS in such a way that an individual is predisposed to respond to a particular stimulus in a certain way. An organizational effect is an empirical concept, and it is defined by instances in which the probability of the occurrence of a particular behavior can be statistically related to the presence or absence of a hormone during some previous period of development. In examining this hypothesis, behavioral endocrinologists have described several hormonal events that, in part, account for the development of sex differences in social behavior. The development of social behavior, including behaviors that are sexually dimorphic, is also dependent on the early social experience of an animal. There is strong evidence from several mammalian species, and in particular from rhesus monkeys, that the deprivation of social contact during the preadult period interferes with the ability of an animal to exhibit normal social behavior. Behaviors such as male mounting (e.g., Harlow, 1969; Gerall, Ward, & Gerall, 1967; Hard & Larsson, 1968), female presenting (Harlow, 1969), agonistic behavior (Lore & Flannelly, 1977; Mason, 1961), and affiliative behaviors (Harlow, 1969) have all been found to be influenced by the absence of early social contact. Thus, in many species the ability to express male-typical or female-typical patterns of behavior is dependent on certain early experiences with other animals.
SOCIAL PLAY
3
Considered in this way, the degree to which an animal expresses the behaviors typical of the male or female role within any group is dependent on early social interactions with conspecifics as well as on perinatal and concurrent hormonal events. In most species these early social interactions occur in the context of play behavior, and it is interesting to note that there are, in many species, sex differences in the social play of young animals (see Table I). The range of species (literally from pinnipeds to primates) in which sex differences in social play have been observed is impressive. These sex differences in the social play of infant and juvenile animals suggest that the opportunities for early social learning may depend on the gender of the young. The possibility exists, then, that these sex differences in social play contribute directly to sex differences in adult social behavior. The two questions that emerge from these considerations, and the questions upon which we have focused this article, are (1) what are the determinants of sex differences in social play and (2) what are the functions of sex differences in the socialization process as a whole. In the pages that follow we shall argue that social play does serve to facilitate the social development of young animals and that sex differences in social play are directly related to sex differences in adult social behavior. In answer to the question of the determinants of sex differences in social play, it appears that perinatal hormones, independent of their actions on adult social behaviors, exert organizational effects on social play. The sex differences observed in one form of social play, play-fighting, appear to be due, in part, to the actions of perinatal androgens. Sex differences in social play, however, also seem to be influenced by the differential behavior of the adults, especially the mother, toward the male and female infants. The behavior of the adults toward male infants appears to enhance the forms of social interactions that best serve the social development of males, and the same appears to be true of the behavior of adults toward female infants. Thus, both perinatal hormone actions and adult-infant interactions serve to promote sex differences in social Play. This illustration of sex differences in the socialization of infant and juvenile behavior is not universal across species. Likewise, sex differences in adult social behavior also vary across species. This variation can serve as the basis for a comparative analysis. The approach taken here with respect to the function of play has been to compare the social play of males and females in species in which there are well-documented sex differences in adult social behavior with that of species in which sex differences in adult social behavior are far less pronounced. We believe that this form of analysis may be one of a few ways in which to address meaningfully the question of the function of social play. There are several pitfalls in attempting to generate conclusions based on the behavior of species that vary greatly in their morphology, ecology, and social organization. It is unlikely that we have avoided all of them. The present analysis
4
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
TABLE I S U M M A R Y OF
EVIDENCE FOR
S t X D l b F E R t N C t S IN
PLAY-FIGHTING ACROSSSPECIES Finding
6>9
Species studied
6-9
Primate Hominoideu (apes and man)
Humans
Blurton-Jones (1976); Braggio et a / . (1978); Blurton-Jones and Konner ( 1 973) van Lawick-Goodall (1968)
Chimpanzees Cercopithecoideu (old-world
monkeys) Cercopithecinae
Rhesus monkey
Bonnet monkey Stumptail monkey
Harlow ( I 965); Hinde and Spencer-Booth (1967); Symons ( 1974) Simonds (1977) Bertrand (1969)
Olive baboon Hamadryas baboon
Owens (1975a.b) Kummer 1968)
Pupio
Cercopithecus
Vervet monkey
Bramlett (1978); Raleigh
Talapoin monkey Patas monkey
Wolfheim ( 1977) Seay et al. (1972)
(1979)
Colobinae
Hanuman langurs
Jay (1963); Hrdy (1977)
does, however, provide a number of hypotheses that can in the future be directly refuted by observations from the appropriate species. In this way we believe that the analysis provided in this article forms a context within which a fruitful debate about social development might occur.
11.
A.
DETERMINANTS OF SEXDIFFERENCES I N SOCIAL PLAY
SOCIALPLAYI N MAMMALS
In this section we shall outline the various forms of social play that have been reported to occur among juvenile mammals. In addition, we shall consider the problem traditionally associated with play behavior, that of the definition of play as a behavioral category.
5
SOCIAL PLAY
TABLE I (Continued) Finding Species studied
Ceboideu (new-world monkeys) Suirniri Squirrel monkey Cullitrichinue Common marmoset Nonprimate species Cunis Timber wolf Coyote Domestic dog F r lidue Domestic cat Rodentiu Norway rat
Golden hamster
d > ?
6 5 9
Baldwin and Baldwin ( 1974) Abbott (1978)
Bekoff (1974, P.c.; Traylor, 1982) Bekoff (1974) Bekoff ( 1974) Barrett and Bateson (1978) Meaney and Stewart (1981a,b); Poole and Fish (1976); Olioff and Stewart (1978) Goldman and Swanson (1975)
Mongolian gerbil
Meaney (unpublished)
OViS
Domestic sheep Pinniped Stellar sea lion
Sachs and Harris ( 1978) Gentry (1974)
1. Play-Fighting
The most commonly reported form of social play is that of play-fighting, this behavior has also been referred to as rough-and-tumble play (e.g., BlurtonJones, 1976; Harlow, 1969) or as mock combat (Calhoun, 1962). The behavioral components of play-fighting vary from species to species but are generally predictable from a knowledge of those components involved in the fighting of adults. As Aldis (1975) has noted, the apparent “goal” of the participants involved in play-bout is to “mouth” or to play-bite an opponent (see Figs. 1-3). Both of these behaviors may be interpreted as an inhibited form of biting. In many species play-fighting also involves an attempt to get on top of (to dominate) the other animal, and descriptions of play-fighting invariably include a reference to wrestling-like behaviors (see Figs. 4-6).
6
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
FIGS. 1-3. Play-fighting in wolf cubs and in juvenile vervet monkeys. Note the open mouth approach in each case. All photographs in the text are by M. Meaney and D. Cantin.
SOCIAL PLAY
7
Fig. 3.
This apparent similarity between the behavioral components that make up play-fighting and those that constitute one feature of the agonistic encounters of adults, then, is one of the defining features of play-fighting. Naturally this raises the question of how one in turn can discriminate between play-fighting and intraspecific aggression. Traditionally, play-fighting has been distinguished from “real” fighting by its seeming lack of seriousness. Even though this may appear a somewhat nebulous and unsatisfying description, it is not hard to find evidence for the differences between play-fighting and intraspecies aggression. An example comes from the work of Poole (1966) with polecats (Mustella putorius). Poole reports that five out of seven of the behaviors that appear in the attack component of the agonistic encounters of adults also appear in the play-fighting of juveniles, as do three out of four of the behaviors that constitute the defensive components. The two attack behaviors that were absent in play-fighting (sustained neck-biting and sideways attack) are behaviors that serve the function of inflicting injury on an opponent. The defensive behavior not seen in play-fighting was that of defensive threat. The “screaming” vocalization recorded from attacked adults was also not heard during play-fighting. These latter two behaviors may be seen as a response to the attack components of neck-biting and sideways attack. Thus, in the play-fighting of polecats, the more extreme forms of both the attack and the defensive components of adult aggression are not observed. Similarly, in the play-fights of juvenile Norway rats, the distress vocalizations that are common in the agonistic encounters of adults are rarely
8
MICHAEL J . MEANEY E T AL.
FIGS.4-6. Play-fights in several species (shown here in wolf cubs, hamadryas baboons, and Norway rats) culminate in one animal on top of another.
SOCIAL PLAY
9
Fig. 6.
recorded (Calhoun, 1962; Meaney & Stewart, 198 la). Another distinguishing feature of play-fighting among rats is that, unlike adult agonistic encounters, roles (i.e., attacker/target) are frequently reversed; an animal that is dominated for a brief period during a play-bout will often immediately pounce on the other animal and then dominate it (Poole & Fish, 1976). Symons (1974) has reported that in the rhesus monkeys the facial expressions that characterize the combatants in an aggressive encounter are not seen in the play-fighting of juveniles. Particularly noteworthy is that in the play-fighting of rhesus monkeys “there are no gestures of threat or submission” (p. 321). Rather, in many species there are facial expressions (van Hoof, 1972; Symons, 1974) and body postures (Bekoff, 1974) that are unique to play-fighting. In children (Blurton-Jones & Konner, 1973) the feature most commonly associated with play-fighting is a laugh-play face. Thus, while play-fighting is similar to the fighring components of an agonistic encounter, it bears little resemblance to the ritualized forms of intraspecies aggression (particularly the communication of threat) that predominate within the stable social groups of most mammals. In addition, play-fighting contains only the milder forms of attack and defense seen in the fighting of adult animals. Most notably absent in play-fighting are components that lead to the infliction of injury in an opponent and, thus, the components associated with “defeat.” It is probable that, although one animal may gain the upper hand in the course of a wrestling bout, there is no defeat or complete submission. Thus,
10
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
the immediate function for the participants of a play-fight is apparently different from that for animals involved in an agonistic encounter whether it involves direct fighting or ritualized gestures.
2.
Chase Play
Harlow (1969) has described a form of play that occurs between juvenile rhesus monkeys and that has been termed approach-avoidance play. This form of play involves one animal approaching and then quickly retreating from another animal. The end point of this sequence is often a chase in which the animal that has been approached chases the animal that has withdrawn. Owens (1975a) has described a very similar pattern of social play in juvenile olive baboons, referred to as dodging play. Here again the pattern seems to be an invitation for chase. We have observed a similar form of social play in juvenile Norway rats. Among rats the sequence involves an approach and pounce followed almost immediately (<.5 sec) by a quick retreat that usually involves two leaps away from the target animal. Once again the pattern is often followed by a chase. This form of play is similar to the solicitation pattern of the adult female rat (see McClintock & Adler, 1978). The immediate consequence of this form of play is also the same as that of the solicitation pattern of the adult female since both behaviors often elicit a chase response (see also Thor & Holloway, 1983). Among adults the entire sequence seems to facilitate copulatory behavior in male rats (Caggiula, Shaw, Antelman, & Edwards, 1976).
3 . Play-Mothering Lancaster (1971), working with vervet monkeys, has provided the most detailed descriptions of this form of play. Play-mothering emerges from the attraction of juveniles toward the infants in the group. The juveniles often sit beside the mother, awaiting the opportunity to “play” with the infant. Once with the infant, under the scrutiny of the mother, the juvenile engages in several of the species-specific, behavioral components of maternal behavior (e.g., carrying, grooming). Probably the most complex skill involved here is in procuring the infant from its mother. In our studies with vervets we have found that for the younger females only about one-third of these attempts to secure the infant are successful and that about the same portion result in the mother threatening the juvenile (see Figs. 7-10). The period of time the juvenile is afforded with the infant seems to depend on its ability to keep the infant acquiescent, since at the infant’s cry the mother reclaims her offspring. Thus, in our work with this species we have found that the older, subadult females are able to hold onto the infant for a much longer period of time than the younger, juvenile females. Play-mothering has been reported in several other primate species (also see Hrdy, 1976), including chimpanzees (van Lawick-Goodall, 1968), rhesus
SOCIAL PLAY
11
monkeys (Chamove, Harlow, & Mitchell, 1967), barbary apes (Burton, 1972), squirrel monkeys (Baldwin, 1969),olive baboons (Owens, 1975a), and hanuman langurs (Hrdy, 1977; Jay, 1963). In general, the descriptions of play-mothering in these species are similar, focusing on holding, carrying, and grooming of infants. The greatest species variation in this form of play appears to be the degree of reluctance of the mother to part with her infant rather than in the behavior of the juveniles toward the infants (see Hinde, 1971). Most reports of play-mothering refer to the persistence of the juveniles in obtaining access to infants. In the vervet monkeys, females from 6 months to 4 years of age interact more often with infants than do adult females (Struhsaker, 1967). We find that among adult females, nulliparous females spend more time with the infants than do multiparous females (including multiparous females who do not have infants at the time). 4.
Play in General
These, then, are the three most prominent forms of social play that occur among juvenile mammals. In each case some argument might be raised to defend the application of the term play to these behavior patterns. Indeed, much has been written debating the merits of considering play as a definable behavioral category. Problems relating to the defining of boundaries around play as a behavior have emerged from the apparent absence of any immediate biological significance. Recent attempts to define play have ignored this feature and concentrated on behavioral differences (e.g., play markers such as the play faces of several primate species). These attempts to define play, however, fly in the face of the fact that there are age changes in social play: The play behavior of animals at one age is different from that of animals at a later age (see Chalmers, 1980; Meaney & Stewart, 1981a; Owens, 1975a). An example of such an age-related change can be seen in the play-fighting of rats. As described earlier, in young rats (between 21 and 45 days of age) play-fighting is marked by dominance reversal (Poole & Fish, 1976). Between 45 and 55 days of age, however, stable dominance relations begin to emerge from the play-fights of male pups. Typically, during this later age one male pup dominates a play-fight far more often than does any other (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a). The role-reversal marker of play-fighting in juvenile male rats is absent after day 45. Other markers, such as the absence of distress vocalizations, remain, and play-bouts appear to the casual observer to be the same throughout the juvenile period. Age-related changes are not unique to rodents. Several authors have reported that the vigor of playfighting in juvenile males in many primate species increases with age (the physical strength of the animals is also increasing). These age-related changes challenge strict definitions of play based on the presence or absence of behavioral markers. As Chalmers (1980) has pointed out, it is fruitless to devote time and effort to defining what play is and what it is not.
12
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
FIGS.7-10. In the vervet monkey, as in several primate species, juvenile females show an intense interest in the infants of the group. It is common to see a mother-infant pair in the company of juvenile females. The juveniles sit beside the pair and often attempt to
SOCIAL PLAY
13
touch or hold the infant. This frequently results in the mother being groomed by juvenile females.
14
MICHAEL I . MEANEY ET AL.
Rather it would appear to be more useful to dedicate efforts to describing patterns of social development in a species and to identifying, at many levels, the factors that influence the performance of particular early social behaviors (cf. Lazar & Beckhorn, 1974). By deemphasizing the label play, it might be easier to get on with the problem of studying the development of social behavior. This would appear true regardless of whether one’s interests are phylogenetic or ontogenetic. Play is, then, what many young animals do, and the question is how does this behavior and the socialization process as a whole contribute to social development?
B.
SEXDIFFERENCES I N SOCIALPLAY
In most of the mammalian species in which the social play of males and females has been compared, sex differences have been found. Although there are more data on play-fighting than on either play-mothering or chase play, this holds true for each of the three forms of social play that were discussed in the previous section. Fortunately, the direction and degree of these sex differences are not universal, and thus a comparative approach is an interesting venture. 1 . Pluy-Fighting
A summary of the data on sex differences in play-fighting is presented in Table I. It can be seen that in most of the species in which this question has been examined males engage in more play-fighting than do females. This sex difference has been observed in several primate species and also in two rodent species (the golden hamster and the Norway rat) as well as in domestic sheep and in sea lions. In each of the studies summarized in Table I, the sex difference has been established on the basis of differences in the frequency with which juvenile males and females have been observed to engage in play-fighting. Several papers have also reported a sex difference in the intensity of playfighting. Typically, it is claimed that males play-fight more vigorously than do females. A common finding among various primate species is that among animals of less than 1 year, play groups are composed of both males and females; as the animals grow older and as the intensity with which the male play increases, the females leave the play groups. Play groups of juveniles are reported to be composed of males only (see DeVore, 1963; Kummer, 1968; Owens, 1975a). In these primate species, then, the factors that seem to contribute to the sex difference in play-fighting appear to be characterized by the intensity with which males play-fight and, possibly, by the tendency of females to avoid play-fights of male-typical intensity. These features do not account for the sex difference in the play-fighting of subadult primates. First, Goy (1978) has found that in rhesus monkeys the sex difference in play-fighting is apparent prior to the period when females and males form separate play groups (i.e., during the infant stage).
15
SOCIAL PLAY
Second, Goldfoot and Wallen (1978) found that female rhesus monkeys reared only with females did not differ from females reared with males in the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting. Thus, apart from sex differences in the intensity with which juveniles engage in play-fighting, there is very likely also a sex difference in the tendency to initiate and become involved in a play-fight. The nature of the sex difference in play-fighting has also been examined in the Norway rat. In this species, unlike most primate species, males and females play together throughout the preadult period. The difference, however, is one of degree since, as in several primates, male pups tend to play-fight more with males than with females whereas female pups tend to play-fight no more with females than with males (the exception to this is during the period just prior to puberty when both males and females play-fight more with animals of the opposite sex than with animals of the same sex; Meaney & Stewart, 1981a). Over all ages studied, males initiate (i.e., pounce on another animal) more play-fights than do females (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a; Poole & Fish, 1976). In contrast, females are more likely to withdraw from a play-initiation (i.e., immediately after being pounced on) than are males. In addition, once involved in a playfight, females are more likely to withdraw prior to the formation of a “dominance” relation (i.e., one animal on top of another; see Fig. 11) than are males (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a). In the Norway rat, then, the difference in the frequency with which male and female pups are observed to be engaged in playfighting is due to the tendency of males to initiate play-fights more often than females and the tendency of females to withdraw from play-fights more than males. Apart from the purported sex difference in the intensity of play-fighting in some primate species, there is no evidence that when females do engage in playfights they do so in a manner that is otherwise qualitatively different from that of males (also see Goy, 1970). In the Norway rat the behavioral components of play-fighting are the same for both males and females (Meaney & Stewart,
9 FIG. 1 I . Depicted here is a summary of the sex differences in the social play of the Norway rat. The top sequence shows the pattern of play most commonly seen in males, that of the complete play-fight sequence. The lower sequence shows the hit-and-run pattern of social play (pounce + withdrawal) and the withdrawal prior to the completion of the play-fight sequence. Both of these behaviors are observed considerably more often in females than in males.
16
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
1981a; Poole & Fish, 1976). Thus far, it appears reasonable to conclude that the sex differences in play-fighting do not include differences in the manner in which animals play-fight. Females do not differ from males in their potential to playfight. It is, therefore, unlikely that there are sex differences in the motor systems involved in play-fighting. The greater tendency of females to withdraw from play-fights suggests that females may react differently from males to the tactile stimulation derived from play-fighting (see Bell & Costello, 1964; Wolff, 1966). Table 1 also reveals that there are some conspicuous exceptions to the sex differences just discussed. Although the studies with canids involved small sample sizes, the results consistently show that females engage in play-fighting as frequently as do males. Moreover, in our work with wolves (Traylor, 1982), we have found that there are no sex differences in the behavioral components of play-fighting in this species. The absence of sex differences in the play-fighting of these carnivores does not appear to be due to the inclusion of predatory patterns of behavior (e.g., stalking) that might mask sex differences in intraspecies patterns of social behavior. Even when predatory patterns are excluded, there are still no sex differences in the frequency with which juvenile male and female wolves engage in play-fighting. Likewise there appears to be no sex difference in the frequency of play-fighting in kittens. Given the apparent absence of sex differences in play-fighting in four species of carnivores, it is interesting to note that in preliminary studies on juvenile northern grasshopper mice (Onychomys Ieucogaster), a predatory rodent species, Davies and Kemble ( I 983) have observed that juvenile males and females engage in play-fighting at similar rates. Thus, although sex differences in play-fighting are common in mammalian species, they are not universal.
2.
Chase Play
This pattern of play has been far less well studied than has play-fighting. Nevertheless, sex differences have also been reported in chase play, particularly among primates. Harlow ( 1969) reports that among juvenile rhesus monkeys females engage in more approach-avoidance play than do males. Owens (1975a) has presented a similar finding with olive baboons with respect to dodging play. In some recent work we have found that female Norway rat pups exhibit more hit-and-run play than do male pups. In both olive baboons and Norway rats, it appears that males are most often the targets of this play and do most of the chasing.
3. Pkuy-Mothering This intriguing pattern of juvenile activity has been most often observed in primate species. In the species in which this pattern of play has been scored, it has been found to be predominantly a female-performed activity. Among hu-
SOCIAL PLAY
17
mans a large number of studies (reviewed by Berman, 1980) have found that juvenile females are more responsive to infants than are same-aged males. Moreover, fantasy play with infant-like dolls is far more common among young females than among young males. Similar results have also been reported for vervet monkeys (Lancaster, 1971), rhesus monkeys (Chamove et al., 1967), and squirrel monkeys (Baldwin, 1969). In the vervet we found that males account for less than 5% of the play-mothering directed toward infants. In the rhesus monkey there appears to be a qualitative difference in the response of male and female juveniles to infants. Whereas females exhibit care-giving behaviors, the males are often hostile and aggressive toward the infants. As is the case with play-fighting, however, the pattern of sex differences described above is not universal. Among juvenile Barbary apes, it is the males that exhibit the greater interest in the infants (Burton, 1972). It is noteworthy that in this species the adult males participate a great deal in the care and the socialization of the infants (Burton, 1972). Among nonprimates the response of juveniles to infants has been little studied. This, of course, might be simply because there is little if any significant interaction between the two age groups. One, possibly analogous behavior has been reported by Schaller (1972) in his work with lions. Schaller reported that juvenile lionesses spend more time play-fighting with young cubs than do males. Although the infant-directed behavior in this case is not what is traditionally considered as care-giving, it suggests that juvenile lionesses are more responsive to cubs than are same-aged males. In the Norway rat, prepubescent males and females are strongly attracted to neonates and will engage in many components of maternal behavior if exposed to pups for a few hours (Bridges, Zarrow, Denenberg, 1973; Mayer & Rosenblatt, 1979a,b). Contact seeking declines sharply in animals tested first around 24 to 25 days of age, but animals exposed at an earlier age remain responsive while females become more responsive under the influence of ovarian estrogens (Mayer, Freeman, & Rosenblatt, 1979; Mayer & Rosenblatt, 1979b).
C . NECJROENDOCRINE BASISOF SEXDIFFERENCES I N SOCIAL PLAY In this section we shall present a review of the research that has examined the influence of gonadal and adrenal steroid hormones on social play, as well as some preliminary work describing the neural system(s) that underlie social play. The work done on this topic has focused primarily on play-fighting in species in which males engage in a higher frequency of play-fighting. The following analysis, therefore, deals mostly with the development of this more male-typical form of social play. Future efforts should address this issue with respect to other forms
18
MICHAEL J . MEANEY E T AL.
of social play, such as play-mothering, that are observed to occur more often in females than in males, and this is one of the goals of our vervet project.
I.
Hormonal Influences on Play-Fighting
When trying to determine the relationship between hormones and play-fighting, the first step is simply to identify those hormones that influence the playfighting of young animals. The second step is to determine the temporal characteristics of any hormonal influence on play-fighting. The literature on hormonebehavior interaction (for reviews see Beatty, 1979; Eleftheriou & Sprott, 1975a,b; Goy & McEwen, 1980) demonstrates that there are, generally speaking, two ways in which hormones influence behavior. The first concerns the activational effects of hormones on behavior. When the presence or absence of a hormone at or near the time of observation can be related to the probability of occurrence of a behavior, the hormone can be said to have an activational effect. That is, the hormone is considered to “activate” or in some cases to “deactivate” a particular behavior. The effects of hormone replacement therapy following castration on the sexual behavior of adult male and female rats (e.g., Beach, 1956) are classic examples of activational effects. The second way in which hormones are said to influence behavior is by their organizational actions on the CNS during some early developmental period (i.e., a period of neurogenesis). Such actions are thought to predispose an individual to respond preferentially to particular external stimuli and to the effects of circulating hormones (Phoenix et al., 1959). Instances in which the probability of the occurrence of a particular behavior can be related to the presence or absence of a hormone during some previous period of development represents an organizational effect. The altered sexual behavior of adult female rats treated neonatally with testosterone (see Baum, 1979, for a review) is an example of an organizational effect. It should be noted that neither organizational nor activational effects are defined by the processes by which they influence behavior because these hormonal effects may be mediated by various neurochemical events (both intracellular and extracellular). Rather they are defined by the temporal characteristics of the hormonal effects. It is for this reason that much of the research described in this section has focused on the temporal boundary of a hormonal effect.
2. Gonadal Steroids In the rhesus monkey juvenile males engage in far more play-fighting than do their female peers (see Table I). Goy and Phoenix (1971) found that genetic females that were exposed prenatally to high levels of testosterone (the major testicular androgen circulating in the blood) engaged in play-fighting at rates that were indistinguishable from those of normal males. Similarly, in the Norway rat, females treated with testosterone on days I and 2 of life did not differ from normal male pups in the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting
SOCIAL PLAY
19
(Meaney & Stewart, 198 I b; Olioff & Stewart, 1978). Male rat pups castrated on day I (thus eliminating the primary source of endogenous testosterone) engaged in play-fighting at rates that were significantly less than those of intact males and that were not different from those of normal females (Meaney & Stewart, 1981b). Finally, male pups treated on days 1 to 10 with the antiandrogen Flutamide engaged in play-fighting at rates that were less than those of control males and that were similar to those of normal females (Meaney, Stewart, Poulin, & McEwen, 1983). These results with Flutamide are identical to those with day 1 castration. Thus, in both the rhesus monkey and the Norway rat, the early exposure to androgens during a critical period for brain development' appears to influence the frequency of play-fighting seen during the juvenile period. Since neonatally androgen-treated females, otherwise lacking testicular secretions, engaged in male-typical levels of play-fighting, it seems as though later circulating levels of androgens do not influence the expression of play-fighting. Direct tests have supported this conclusion. Joslyn (1973) has found that in contrast to prenatal treatment, the postnatal testosterone treatment of female rhesus monkeys did not influence the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting. Similarly, Goy (1970) has reported that male rhesus monkeys that were castrated at birth play-fought as frequently as did intact males. In the rhesus monkey, then, androgen exposure beyond the critical period for sexual differentiation did not affect the expression of play-fighting. A similar finding has emerged from studies with Norway rat pups. Male rat pups castrated on either days 10, 20, or 23 did not differ from intact males in the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting (Beatty, Dodge, Traylor, & Meaney, 1981; Meaney & Stewart, 1981b). Moreover, intact male pups injected daily with 200 k g of testosterone did not differ from controls in their play-fighting (Meaney & Stewart, 1983). Thus, in neither the rhesus monkey nor the Norway rat was the expression of male-typical levels of play-fighting found to be dependent on the presence of testosterone during the juvenile period (i.e., during that period when the sex difference is observed). Androgens are secreted not only by the testes but also by the adrenals. In humans some data relevant to the present question have been collected in children with an adrenal abnormality that results in a high exposure to adrenal androgens. This condition has been referred to as congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) and is a genetic abnormality in which the adrenal cortex fails to produce cortisone. Instead there is an excessive secretion of adrenal androgens from the 'It is important to note that the carly neonatal period in the Norway rat and prenatal period in the rhesus monkey are periods of neurogenesis. These periods have also been found to be critical periods for the sexual differentiation of copulatory behavior and of its putative neural substrates (for a review, see Coy & McEwen, 1980).
20
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
prenatal period up until the time when the disorder is detected and treated. CAH females are born with masculinized genitalia and unless the condition is detected early they are often reared as males. The population of interest here are CAH females in which the detection has occurred early. There are two advantages to studying these children. First, when the detection occurs early in postnatal life, the endocrine condition can be rectified, thus limiting the period of excessive androgen exposure primarily to the prenatal stage. Second, these females are reared as females. Such girls have been found to engage in male-typical forms of play and to be identified as “tomboys” more often than control subjects (usually unaffected, same-sex siblings) (Ehrhardt, Epstein, & Money, 1968; Ehrhardt & Baker, 1974). These results are, of course, similar to those of Goy (1978) and of Meaney & Stewart (198 1 b) with perinatally androgenized female monkeys and rats. Taken together these findings present strong evidence for an organizational effect of testicular androgens on the tendency of an animal to engage in playfighting. In contrast to this developmental effect, there is, apparently, no activational influence of circulating testosterone on play-fighting. The expression of ma1e;typical levels of play-fighting is dependent on the presence of androgens during a critical period for neural differentiation but not during the period when the behavior is actually observed. Although this pattern of androgen effects is rare (usually behaviors that are influenced by testicular steroids during a perinatal period are also activated by these hormones), it is not surprising when one considers the changes in androgen levels that normally take place between the time of birth and that of puberty. Thus, Resko, Feder, and Goy (1968) found that while androgen titers are high at the time of birth in the Norway rat, there begins a period of quiescence by about days 8 to 10 that is uninterrupted until just prior to puberty. The sex difference in play-fighting is, of course, observed well before puberty. It is unlikely, then, that the expression of play-fighting could be dependent on the presence of androgens since androgen levels are very low during the prepubertal period. Organizational effects, however, are entirely plausible since androgen levels are reasonably high for at least the first week after birth [note that Beatty et a / . (198 I ) found that castration on days 1 or 6, but not later, decreased the frequency of play-fighting in male pups]. Even though perinatal androgens influence the social play of both rhesus monkeys and Norway rats, in neither species does there appear to be any suppressive effects of ovarian hormones on females. In the rhesus monkey, females ovariectomized on the day of birth play-fought as often as did intact females (Goy, 1970). Also in the Norway rat, day 1 ovariectoniy did not influence the frequency of play-fighting of female pups (Meaney & Stewart, 1981b). Thus, the sex differences in the play-fighting of these species is apparently not due to any obvious influence of ovarian hormones on females. Birke and Sadler (1983) have reported that neonatal exposure to the synthetic
SOCIAL PLAY
21
progestin medroxyprogesterone decreases play-fighting in general and play-initiation in particular in both male and female rat pups. The mechanism underlying this effect is as yet unclear; progestins act at a variety of androgen-sensitive target sites and in some cases mimic or potentiate the effects of androgens, whereas in other cases they antagonize androgenic effects (see Bardin & Catterall, 1981; Janne, Kontula, Vihko, Feil, & Bardin, 1978). It is interesting, however, that during the neonatal period in the rat, both serum and adrenal progesterone levels are higher in females than in males (Shapiro, Goldman, Bongiovanni, & Marino, 1976). Thus, progesterone may act as an endogenous “antiandrogen,” at least with respect of play-fighting and may serve to promote female-typical play-fighting. Because this sex difference in progesterone levels seems to be due to adrenal rather than ovarian secretions, the absence of an effect of neonatal ovariectomy reported by Meaney and Stewart (198 1b) is not necessarily inconsistent with the findings of Birke and Sadler (1983). At the very least these findings leave open the possibility that the development of female-typical play-fighting is not merely due to the relative absence of androgenic stimulation. This question should be reevaluated in studies that examine play-fighting in greater detail and do rely simply on the frequency with which play-bouts occur. One question that arises concerning testosterone effects is its mechanism of action at the intracellular level (see Fig. 12). Testosterone is a prohormone; that is, once inside a cell, testosterone can be converted into an estrogen (estradiol) through an aromatization pathway or into another androgen form (usually 5adihydrotestosterone) through a Sa-reductase pathway. Both forms of testosterone conversion have been found to occur in the neonatal rat brain (George & Ojeda, 1982; Martini, 1978; McEwen, Lieberburg, Chaptal, & Krey, 1977). Moreover, the neonatal rat brain also contains functional receptors for both androgens and estrogens (Fox, Vito, & Wieland, 1978; Lieberburg, MacLusky, Roy, & McEwen, 1978; Meaney, McGinnis, & McEwen, 1982; Vito, Wieland, & Fox, 1979), an observation supporting the possibility that one or both of these testosterone metabolites might be involved in the sexual differentiation of play-fighting. This question is of particular interest to behavioral endocrinologists in view of the major organizational role attributed to testosterone-derived estradiol in the sexual differentiation of copulatory behavior in the Norway rat (e.g., McEwen et al., 1977). In a broader sense an examination of this issue also allows for a more detailed comparison between the neuroendocrine determinants of play-fighting and those of what might be functionally related behaviors (see later). Given the aforementioned considerations, it is conceivable that the organizational effect of testosterone on play-fighting might be due to ( 1 ) testosteronederived estrogen, (2) testosterone-derived Sa-dihydrotestosterone, or (3) testosterone itself. To examine these possibilities Meaney and Stewart (1981b) compared the frequency of play-fighting of female pups treated on days 1 and 2 with either testosterone, Sa-dihydrotestosterone, or with estradiol to that of intact
22
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
Cellular membrane
.
Nuclear membrane
Blood stream
..... + + t o new
E 3
plasma binding protein cytoplasmic receptor protein
4
steroid hormone
-
FIG. 12. A current model of steroid hormone action. ( I ) The free steroid (i.e., that not bound to plasma binding proteins) diffuses into the cell (2), where it binds to a cytosolic receptor protein forming an “activated” hormone-receptor complex. (3-4) The hormone-receptor complex is then able to cross the nuclear membrane, where it binds to the chromatin (5) resulting in messenger RNA (mRNA) production. (6) The mRNA diffuses into the cytosol, where it induces the synthesis of new proteins.
male and female pups. The results showed that neither testosterone-treated females nor 5a-dihydrotestosterone-treated females differed from intact males in the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting. Each of these three groups engaged in more play-fighting than did either estrogen-treated or control females. These results with the Norway rat parallel those previously found with the rhesus monkey. Goy (1978) also found that Sa-dihydrotestosterone as well as testosterone masculinized the play-fighting of female rhesus monkeys. In both the Norway rat and the rhesus monkey, then, the testosterone effect on playfighting is a “true” androgen effect (i.e., it is not mediated by testosteronederived estradiol).
SOCIAL PLAY
23
The nature of this androgenic effect has been further characterized in studies examining the role of the intracellular androgen-receptor system in the brain. Within various brain regions of the neonatal rat-notably the hypothalamus, septum, preoptic region, and amygdala-there exist intracellular receptor proteins that bind specifically and with high affinity to testosterone and Sa-dihydrotestosterone (Lieberburg, MacClusky, & McEwen, 1980; Meaney, McGinnis, Aitken, & McEwen, 1984a). The apparent mechanism of hormonereceptor interaction is summarized in Fig. 12. The importance of the androgenreceptor system in the sexual differentiation of play-fighting was first indicated by the finding that Flutamide, which seems to block the translocation of androgen receptors into the nuclear compartment (see Meaney et a l . , 1983), prevents the masculinization of play-fighting (Meaney et ul., 1983). This was confirmed in a study examining play-fighting in male rat pups bearing the Xlinked Tfm mutation. Tfm rats exhibit a profound deficiency in neural, androgen receptors (McGinnis, Davis, Meaney, Singer, & McEwen, 1983; Naess, Hang, Attramadal, Aakvaag, Hanson, & French, 1976). Meaney et ul. (1983) found that Tfm males engaged in play-fighting significantly less frequently than did normal males and no more frequently than females. These findings suggest that the effects of testosterone or Sa-dihydrotestosterone on the development of maletypical play-fighting are mediated by the androgen-receptor system. Moreover, recent data (cited later in the text) suggest that the brain is the critical target site for this androgenic effect. 3. Adrenal Hormones
The influence of neonatal hormones on social play is not limited to androgens. Meaney, Stewart, and Beatty (1982) have found that glucocorticoids administered neonatally also influence the development of play-fighting in the Norway rat and that the effect is sex dependent. Prepubertal male rats that were injected either on days 1 and 2 or on days 3 and 4 with corticosterone engaged in less play-fighting than did control males (dexamethasone, a synthetic glucocorticoid, produced a comparable effect). Males treated with corticosterone on days 9 and 10 were unaffected. Thus, as with the androgen effect, glucocorticoids are effective only within the first week of life. Corticosterone treatment of females at any one of these ages did not affect the frequency with which they engaged in playfighting. Thus, the effect was both time dependent and sex dependent. Also, as was the case with testosterone, corticosterone has no activational, or “deactivational,” effect on the play-fighting of male pups. Males injected with corticosterone daily between day 26 and day 40 play-fought as frequently as did control males (Meaney & Stewart, 1983). There currently exists evidence for the idea that this organizational, glucocorticoid effect on play-fighting is mediated by intracellular glucocorticoid receptor proteins (see Fig. 12) and that it is not due to any interference by adrenal
24
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
hormones with androgen secretion or with the interaction between androgens and their receptors, First, glucocorticoids do not affect circulating testosterone levels in neonatal rats (Meaney et a l . , 1982). Second, corticosterone, unlike the androgen receptor-blocker Flutamide, does not block the translocation of androgen receptors into the cell nucleus in testosterone-primed rats (Meaney, unpublished). Moreover, there are glucocorticoid receptors in the neonatal rat brain (within the hippocampus, septum, and amygdala) that bind with high affinity and specificity to both corticosterone and dexamethasone (Meaney, Sapolsky, & McEwen, 1985). Thus, there exists the intracellular mechanisms by which these adrenal hormones might independently exert their effects on the neural circuitry that underlies play-fighting.
4 . Neural Basis of Play-Fighting Play-fighting represents one of the few behaviors that is organized by early hormone exposure but the expression of which is independent of later activational effects of hormones. What probably occurs is that the exposure to high levels of androgens during a period of neural differentiation promotes the growth of a sex-specific neural circuitry and that this circuitry in turn mediates the sex difference in play-fighting that is observed in juvenile animals. Our still preliminary investigation into the neural system that underlies play-fighting has revealed evidence that supports this hypothesis. Meaney, Dodge, and Beatty (1981) found a sex-dependent effect of amygdaloid lesions on the play-fighting of juvenile Norway rats. Amygdaloid lesions made on days 21 or 22 reduced the levels of play-fighting in male pups to those of normal females. The same lesions had no effect on female pups. This finding suggests that an androgen-related sex difference in some portion of the amygdaloid complex might, in part at least, mediate the sex difference that is observed in the play-fighting ofjuvenile Norway rats. Because the amygdala is a target site for both testosterone and 5a-dihydrotestosterone, it is possible that androgens might act directly on this limbic region to masculinize play-fighting. Meaney and McEwen ( 1984) examined this question by studying the play-fighting of females that received bilaterate implants of testosterone-bearing cannulae ( 1 :5/testosterone:cholesterol) in the amygdala between day 1 and day 5 of life (the cannulae were removed on day 5). Testosterone-implanted females actually engaged in somewhat more play-fighting than did male pups and, of course, substantially more than did control females who received cholesterol implants. This finding further suggests that the amygdala is a critical target site for the androgenic effect on play-fighting. At this point it is worth considering what occurs at the cellular level. As outlined in Fig. 12, the concentration of androgen receptors in the nuclear compartment of the cell is a function of the free, plasma androgen levels to which the cell is exposed as well as of the concentration of androgen receptors available in
SOCIAL PLAY
25
the cytoplasm. There do not appear to be sex differences in cytosolic androgen receptor concentrations in the amygdala during the first week of life (Meaney et a / ., 1984a); however, circulating testosterone levels are higher in males than in females during this period (Resko et al., 1968; Weisz & Ward, 1979). This sex difference in testosterone levels provides a mechanism whereby there would be greater androgen receptor occupancy in males than in females. Indeed we (Meaney et a / . . 1982, 1984a) have recently found that during the first week of life androgen receptor occupancy in nuclear fractions prepared from various brain regions is higher in male pups than in female pups. This sex difference in nuclear androgen receptor concentrations was greatest in the amgydala. These data provide more direct support for the idea that under the conditions of normal development, androgenic action within the amygdala is greater in males than in females and thus that there exists a neuroendocrine mechanism by which an anatomical/neurochemical sex difference might develop within this limbic region. In this regard it is interesting to note that there is evidence of hormonedependent sex differences in amygdaloid morphology. Staudt and Dorner (1976) have found a sex difference in the nuclear cell size in the central and medial portions of the amygdala. Dyer, MacLeod, and Ellendorf (1976) found a sex difference in the efferent projections of the corticomedial nucleus of the amygdala. Nishizuka and Arai (1981) found a greater number of shaft synapses (i.e., synapses on the shafts of dendrites) in cells of the medial amygdaloid nucleus of male rats. Significantly, all of these sex differences in the structure of the amygdala were shown to depend on the presence of androgen during the neonatal period. What is not clear is whether changes in the anatomy of the developing amygdala are produced by a direct action of androgens (presumably involving an androgen receptor mechanism) or depend upon the aromatization of testosterone to estradiol. Estradiol is known to stimulate the growth of neural processes (neurites) in cultures of hypothalamic tissue from the brains of neonatal mice (Toran-Allerand, 1976) and may be responsible for the differentiation of the sexually dimorphic nucleus in the preoptic area of the rat brain recently described by Gorski, Gordon, Shyrne, and Southam (1978). With this caveat in mind it is still tempting to speculate that androgen-dependent changes in the development of the amygdala may be responsible, in part, for the sex differences in playfighting. Because the amygdala in the neonatal rat also contains receptors for corticosterone (e.g., Meaney et al., 1984a), this structure may also be involved in the sex-dependent effects of neonatal exposure to corticosterone on playfighting. It is possible, then, that androgens and glucocorticoids might act at the same neural site(s) to influence the development of play-fighting. Certainly this idea is consistent with the findings that the temporal boundary for the androgen effect on play-fighting coincides with that for glucocorticoids (i.e., the first week of life). Here again, it is important to note that within the amygdala there exists both
26
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
androgen and glucocorticoid receptors. With these considerations in mind, it is interesting to note the effects of these steroids on peripheral tissue. In thymic lymphocytes, glucocorticoids stimulate the degradation of RNA and cell death (Cidlowski, 1982), and this action is antagonized by androgens (Sasson & Mayer, 1981). In several tissue preparations, androgens have been shown to stimulate RNA synthesis (see Fig. 12). In skeletal muscle, androgens have protein anabolic effects and glucocorticoids protein catabolic effects (e.g., Mayer & Rosen, 1975), and Dahlberg, Snochowski, and Gustafsson (1981) have reported evidence for the idea that these hormonal effects on muscle tissue are mediated by androgen and glucocorticoid receptors. Although we know of no comparable evidence that implicates a similar role for androgens in the CNS, there exist considerable data suggesting that glucocorticoids exert a catabolic effect on the CNS during the neonatal period (e.g., Cotterrell, Balazs, & Johnson, 1972; Balazs & Cotterrell, 1972; Weichsel, 1974). It is, therefore, possible that within particular limbic regions, such as the amygdala (specifically the corticomedial region of the amygdala, which contains both androgen and glucocorticoid receptors), endogenously elevated glucocorticoids may antagonize the cellular actions of the higher, circulating androgen levels in neonatal males and, thus, block the masculinization of those neural structures that underlie the sex differences in play-fighting. This hypothesis forms the basis of some of our current work on this question. Additional studies on the effects of brain lesions made shortly after weaning have revealed qualitatively similar influences on the play of males and females. Septa1 lesions increase play-fighting in both sexes (Beatty, Dodge, Traylor, Donegan, & Godding, 1982) while extensive damage to the medial preopticanterior hypothalamus has the opposite effect (Dodge, 198 1). More restricted lesions, confined to the medial preoptic area, did not affect play-fighting in young male rats (Leedy, Vela, Popolow, & Gerall, 1980) or in rhesus monkeys (Goy, Kemnitz, Slimp, Irving, & Neff, 1979). Preliminary studies indicate that ventromedial hypothalamic lesions do not affect play-fighting in juvenile rats of either sex. On the basis of these and other findings, it is possible to dissociate the endocrine influences on play-fighting from those on other forms of social behavior. Joslyn (1973), for example, found that while juvenile female rhesus monkeys injected regularly with 2 mg of testosterone exhibited a dramatic increase in social rank, eventually dominating their male peers, they showed no increase in the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting. Moreover, while the potential of an animal to engage in intraspecies aggression has been related to concurrent levels of both androgens (e.g., Beeman, 1947; Brain & Nowell, 1969; Rose, Gordon, & Bernstein, 1972) and glucocorticoids (see Leshner, 1975), play-fighting occurs independent of the circulating levels of
SOCIAL PLAY
27
these hormones (Meaney & Stewart, 1983). Meaney et 01. (1982) found that while the neonatal exposure of male rats to corticosterone decreased the frequency with which they engaged in play-fighting, it did not affect the potential of the animals to exhibit either male or female copulatory behavior. Meaney and Stewart (1983) found that although testosterone treatment of juveniles resulted in precocious male copulatory behavior (cf. Bauni, 1972), i t did not affect playfighting. Although the study of the neurology of play is just beginning, it is already apparent that the neural control of play is different from that of sexual and aggressive behavior. This is probably not surprising since the endocrine influences are different as well. Thus, the neuroendocrine factors that influence the occurrence of play-fighting can be dissociated from those that influence other forms of social behavior. That is an important point when one considers the potential developmental consequence of play-fighting, for it allows us to discount the possibility that a relationship between play-fighting and, say, later success in adult agonistic encounters (see Taylor, 1980) is simply due to the fact the two behaviors share the same neuroendocrine mechanisms. Play-fighting, then, may be considered as an independent behavioral system and not merely as the immature version of some form of adult social behavior.
5 . Hortnonul Influences on Play-Mothering The question of hormonal influences on play-mothering has been examined in humans and the data here are derived from work with clinical populations. In CAH children, girls have been found to engage in less mothering behavior, such 1968; as doll play and baby care, than do normal controls (Ehrhardt et d., Ehrhardt & Baker, 1974). It will be recalled that these children were exposed to high levels of adrenal androgens. Again, it is interesting to note that the CAH children in this study were reared as females and developed a female gender identity (Ehrhardt & Baker, 1974). Ehrhardt and Money (1967) found that girls whose mothers were treated with “masculinizing progestogens” (these are progestogens that have androgenic as well as progestational actions) showed less doll play than did normal controls. In both of these studies, then, the perinatal exposure to androgens or to androgen-like substances decreased the maternallike behaviors of young girls. It is important to note that in both of these studies the “androgenic” treatment was confined to the perinatal period. These studies, then, appear to offer evidence for an organizational effect of steroid hormones on play-mothering in children. Similarly, genetic males with the androgen-insensitivity syndrome (i.e., genetic males that are functionally deprived of androgen due to insensitivity to their own androgens, whose external genitalia are female, and who are thus raised as girls) have been found to engage in doll play more frequently than control females and to exhibit a greater interest in infant care
28
MICHAEL .I.MEANEY ET AL.
(Money, Ehrhardt, & Masica, 1968). In the genetic males, this insensitivity to androgens appears to be related to female patterns of responsiveness to infants or infant-like objects. Although this question has not been directly examined in other species, it is noteworthy that in both the vervet monkey (Gartlan, 1968; Lancaster, 1971) and the rhesus monkey (Chamove et al., 1967) play-mothering has been observed in females long before puberty. Since the prepubertal period is characterized by a general gonadal quiescence, it is unlikely that the behavior is activated by gonadal hormones. The human data do make it appear that sex differences in playmothering, like those in play-fighting, are associated with the perinatal exposure to the sex steroids. Furthermore, it would appear that as is the case with playfighting, there are organizational effects, but no activational ones.
INFLUENCESI N SOCIAL PLAY D. SOCIAL The argument presented in the preceding section stressed the role of perinatal hormones in determining sex differences in social play. This should not be interpreted to mean that sex differences in social play are the inevitable consequence of early hormonal events. Rather, it appears that the adults (often, but not exclusively the mother), through the differential treatment of male and female infants, also promote the pattern of sex differences that was outlined earlier. Certainly, to those who have embraced social learning theories as explanations for sex differences in human social behavior, this is not a revelation. What is interesting though is that analogous social processes also occur in nonhuman species. In humans, mothers have been found to behave differently toward their male and female offspring, even early in infancy (Goldberg & Lewis, 1969; Levine, Fishman, & Kagan, 1967; Moss, 1967; Thomas, Leiderman, & Olson, 1972). For instance, mothers vocalize and smile more to their female infants than to their male infants. Fagot (1974) observed that, among children of a similar age, mothers left their sons to play on their own more often than their daughters. Evidence of differential treatment by mothers of male and female infants has also been observed in several other species. Even shortly after birth mothers behave differently toward male and female offspring. In the Norway rat, the mothers spend more time licking the anogenital region of their male pups than of their female pups (Moore, 1981; Moore & Morelli, 1979). Similarily, in bonnet macaques (Simonds, 1974), the mother as well as neighboring adult females exhibit an intense interest in the genitalia of newborn, male infants. In several primate species, as the infants grow older, this gender-dependent maternal behavior takes on a form that more directly contributes to sex differences in the juveniles’ social interactions. In the rhesus monkey, Mitchell ( I 968) found that mothers of male infants withdrew from, played with, and presented to their
SOCIAL PLAY
29
infants more often than did mothers of females. Mothers of females protected and restrained their infants more than did mothers of males. Similarly, in both the Japanese (Itani, 1959) and pigtail monkey (Jensen, Bobbitt, & Gordon, 1967), mothers have been observed to withdraw from male infants earlier and more often than from female infants. Also in pigtail monkeys, mothers bite male infants more frequently than they do female infants, and in general there is a greater mutual antagonism in mother-male infant pairs than in mother-female infant pairs (Jensen, 1966). In the rhesus monkey, mothers reject their sons more frequently than their daughters (e.g., Hinde & Spencer-Booth, 1967; White & Hinde, 1975). Given these findings, it is not surprising that there is a sex difference in both the degree to which infants become independent of their mother and the age at which they achieve this independence. In chimpanzees (Nicolson, 1977), pigtail monkeys (Erwin, Anderson, & Bunger, 1975; Jensen et al., 1967), Japanese monkeys (Itani, 1959), bonnet monkeys (Simonds, 1974), and rhesus monkeys (Hinde, 1971), males become independent of their mothers sooner than do females. In contrast, in many species females tend to remain in proximity with their mothers for long periods after sexual maturity (Kummer, 1968; Pusey, 1978; Rowell, Din, & Omar, 1968). In these species, then, mothers seem to promote the independence of male infants and to remain in closer contact with female infants.2 These differences in maternal behavior toward male and female offspring appear to be related to sex differences in the behavior of the young. Thus, Mitchell (1968) found that male rhesus monkeys bit their mothers more often than did female infants (seemingly a reasonable way to “assure” one’s independence). In chimpanzees, male infants have also been observed to behave more aggressively toward their mother than do female infants (Clark, 1977). In the Norway rat, juvenile males attempt to mount and to play-fight with their mother more so than do females. In contrast, females groom their mother more than do males (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a). Perhaps not surprisingly, in this rodent 21n their cross-cultural studies, the Whitings and their colleagues have reported that mothers are much more likely to delegate their work to their daughters than to their sons (see Ember, 1973). and one common explanation for this finding is simply that the daughters are, generally, close by. Indeed, in the African cultures studied, young girls do remain closer to the home than do the males (e.g., Draper, 1973; Ember, 1973; Munroe & Munroe, 1971; Nerlove, Munroe, & Munroe, 1971). Thus, girls engage more often in household chores and infant-care than do males (e.g., Ember, 1973; Whiting & Edwards, 1973). The process whereby daughters remain in close proximity to their mothers (seemingly a function of both the daughter’s seeking proximity to the mother and the mother’s restraint on her daughter) facilitates the socialization of the daughter into the female role. Likewise the boys’ movement away from the home leads to increased contact with male peers (see Whiting & Edwards, 1973; Clark P? a / . . 1969) and, eventually, with adult males. This male-peer contact may be enhanced by a preference for similar activities, such as play-fighting. This male-male contact, then, would facilitate the socialization of the sons into the male role. In the following section we argue that the primary function of social play is to facilitate this acculrururion process.
30
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
species as well, female offspring remain with their mother longer than do male offspring (Calhoun, 1962). In humans also there are sex differences in the behavior of infants that may serve to elicit differential maternal behavior (see Bell, 1971; Harper, 1971, for reviews). Newborn females exhibit higher rates of reflexive smiling than do newborn males (Freedman, 1974). In contrast, male infants have been found to be more irritable than female infants (Moss, 1974). Observations of mother-child dyads in natural settings have shown that young boys (12-36 months) left their mothers more often than did young girls (Anderson, 1972; Ley & Koepke, 1982). Considered in this way the behavior of both the mother and the infant can be seen as contributing to sex differences in mother-infant interactions. Male and female infants also elicit differential behavior from adults other than their mother. In rhesus monkeys (Breuggeman, 1964), stumptail monkeys (Estrada, 1978), and baboons (Rowell et a/., 1968), there is evidence that adult males exhibit more infant care and general interest toward male infants than toward female infants. In addition, adult male rhesus monkeys have also been observed to initiate play-fighting with male infants more often than with female infants (Hinde & Spencer-Booth, 1967; Redican & Mitchell, 1974). Thus, Redican (1976) observed that, among wild-born rhesus monkeys, “mothers interacted more positively with female infants and adult males with male infants.” In studies of humans, Tasch (1952) and Kotelchuck (1976) found that fathers engaged more often in play with their sons than with their daughters. Lamb (1977) and Rebelsky and Hanks (1971) reported that fathers vocalized more with their sons than with their daughters. In general, fathers seem to spend more time with their sons than with their daughters (cf. Parke & Suomi, 1981). Again the role of the infant needs to be considered in the context of these findings. Mitchell (1968) has reported that male rhesus infants elicit more play-fighting from adults than d o female infants. Thus, in these species the interaction between adult males and male infants would seem to enhance the play-fighting behavior of male infants. Immature males and females also differ in the behavior that they direct toward the adults in their group, other than their mother. One intriguing example of this has been reported by Seyfarth, Cheney, and Hinde (1978) in free-ranging baboons. They observed that while both immature males and females directed a considerable amount of grooming toward adult females, the young females tended to groom adult females that ranked higher than their mother and were most likely to groom lactating mothers. This attention to lactating mothers served to bring the immature female into contact with the infants and provided an opportunity for infant care. Also, it afforded the opportunity for amicable contact with higher-ranking adult females. This type of social interaction might well benefit the subadult female, considering that in most species of old world monkeys females tend to remain in their natal group (Seyfarth et id., 1978).
SOCIAL PLAY
31
These sex differences in adult-infant interactions appear to promote sex differences in the social experiences of the young. Field studies of several primate species (e.g., DeVore, 1963; Jay, 1963) have confirmed that females tend to spend more time with their mothers and other adult females, whereas males spend more time at the periphery of the group where they form same-sexed play groups (see Clark, Wyon, & Richards, 1969, for a similar finding in humans). This pattern would result in a greater exposure of juvenile females to mothers and their infants (thus providing the opportunity for play-mothering) and males would experience greater contact with same-sexed peers (providing a greater opportunity for play-fighting and greater contact with other subadult and adult males). This behavior would enhance the familiarity between adult and juvenile males and thus facilitate the integration of the juveniles into the group. As Simonds (1974) writes, “Females establish their network primarily through grooming and remain closely associated with their mother. Males rely more heavily on the play group, which includes participating sub-adult and adult males” (p. 15). Thus, the early social interactions of male infants seem to bring them into contact with adult males, whereas those of female infants keep them in contact with their own mothers and other adult females. These findings suggest that sex differences in the social behavior of infants and juveniles emerge, in part, through the social interactions with the mother and other adults. Direct evidence for the contribution of the mother to the socialization of her offspring can be seen in findings of Mitchell, Ruppenthal, Raymond, and Harlow (1966). Primiparous rhesus mothers restrained male infants as much or more so than female infants, thus retarding the independence of their male young. Sons of primiparous mothers engaged in very little play-fighting and “cooed” frequently (“cooing” is generally more common in female infants). The male offspring of these overprotective mothers were, then, more female-like in their early social behavior than were the infants of more experienced mothers. The influence of adults is also seen in a study of Milch and Missakian-Quinn (1977) with children that were reared with minimal contact with adults (peer reared). The absence of adults was associated with a decrease in the sex differences in play roles and in assertiveness. Suomi (cited in Parke & Suomi, 1981) has also addressed this issue based on some preliminary findings which suggested that sex differences in the social behavior of juvenile rhesus monkeys are enhanced by the presence of adult males.
E.
SUMMARY
As discussed earlier, sex differences in the social play (and thus in the social experiences) of juveniles have been found to be influenced by the actions of perinatal hormones. The nature of this influence appears to be in organizing the circuitry of the CNS such that animals are predisposed to respond to a particular
32
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET
AL.
stimulus in a certain way (see Phoenix et al., 1959). The result of this early hormonal experience is that males and females seem to differ in their preferred forms of social play. The study by Mitchell et al. (1966) with primiparous mothers suggest that these sex differences in social play are not the inevitable consequence of hormonal events. Note, however, that in juveniles reared in peer groups sex differences in play-fighting have been observed (Goldfoot & Wallen, 1978; Goy & Phoenix, 1971; Meaney & Stewart, 1981b). Thus, while the behavior of the mother and other adults may to some extent override the influence of early hormonal events, their influence is not absolutely necessary for the development of sex differences in social play. In the normal socialization process, however, both the influence of the mother and other adults, and of early hormonal events seem to contribute in the same direction to the pattern of sex differences in social play described earlier.
111.
THEFUNCTION OF SOCIAL PLAY
Certainly one of the most conspicuous features of social play is the apparent lack of any immediate consequence it holds for the participants. For some, this has actually been considered as a defining feature of play (see Loizos, 1967). What remains puzzling is that young animals devote so much time and energy to behavior of such dubious value. How might the potential for the expression of such a behavior have evolved? The absence of any observable, immediate function for social play has led many researchers to consider the possible developmental consequences of social play. The focus here is on the preparatory function of social play, the suggestion being that social development is somehow facilitated through the experiences afforded during play encounters. Thus, it is argued that in the course of social play, animals learn skills that prepare them for the social life of an adult. This argument suggests an adaptive value for social play and therefore an answer to the question of how play might have evolved. But what of the actual evidence in favor of such a developmental role for social play'? A.
DEVELOPMENTAL SIGNIFICANCE OF SOCIAL PLAY
The strongest evidence for a developmental role for social play is that which has come from the work of Harlow, Mason, and their associates at Wisconsin. This research has involved a social deprivation paradigm in which young rhesus monkeys have been deprived of contact with their mother, peers, or both for varying periods of time. The effects of these procedures have been examined in animals from the infant to the adult stages. The resulting behavioral anomalies (and there are many) have been related to the absence of certain forms of social
SOCIAL PLAY
33
contact. Particularly relevant for the present discussion are the findings of pronounced sociopathology in monkeys deprived of contact, and thus also of play, with peers. While this paradigm has resulted in some truly intriguing findings, its usefulness has been questioned. As Lehrman (1953), Bekoff (l976), and many others have argued, the interpretation of findings from deprivation paradigms is difficult since it is hard to identify exactly what the animal is being deprived of. Certainly an animal deprived of any interaction with peers is an animal without social play (as Suomi & Harlow, 1976, have argued), but it is also an animal without other forms of social contact, including simply the visual, olfactory, auditory, and tactile stimuli associated with another animal. “The problem remains whether it is peer contact or the act of playing that results in normal behavior, and this would be very difficult to test experimentally” (Dolhinow & Bishop, 1970, p. 175). For, as Symons (1974) has stated, when you do allow immature monkeys contact with peers-they play. This problem has shrouded the interpretation of the peer-deprivation findings as definitive evidence for a role for social play in normal social development. With respect to the more general question of whether social play serves a developmental function in the normal socialization process, however, the problems presented here may not necessarily be relevant. These problems refer to the question of identifying the critical factors that contribute directly to the development of social behavior. In addressing this question, the social deprivation studies have failed to identify social play as a critical factor for the reasons cited earlier. It is possible, however, that a factor can indirectly serve to promote social development simply by leading to the experiences that do themselves directly contribute. We argue here that there is evidence for such a role for social play. This argument is based on the assumption that the social deprivation studies have established the importance of peer-peer interaction, albeit without identifying the critical component of these interactions. In most, if not all, of the species listed in Table I, the most predominant form of peer-peer interaction is that of social play. In many species, peer-peer interactions may almost be equated with social play. Considered another way, it is the tendency of young animals to engage in social play that leads to peer-peer contact. Thus, even if it is peer contact and not the act of playing itself that facilitates social development, social play can be seen as being functional in that it enhances the level of peer interactions that an animal experiences. An analogous argument could be made for the role of exploration in object learning. The tendency to explore may not contribute directly to object learning, but it does indirectly, by bringing an animal into contact with salient objects. In a similar way social play can be considered as serving a role in social learning. The question, then, concerns the function of these early social experiences that occur during social play. If one is concerned with normal social development, then the findings of
34
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
sociopathology in rhesus monkeys deprived of peer contact have established a role for social play in the socialization process. As a conclusion to this arguement, it may be more correct to state that the tendency or the motivation to engage in social play leads to the social interactions that are necessary for normal socialization to occur. It is yet another question as to how these social interactions contribute to social development and what is the critical feature of the interaction.
BETWEEN SEX DIFFERENCES I N ADULTAND B . RELATIONSHIP JUVENILE SOCIALBEHAVIORAND THE NATUREOF THE CONTRIBUTION OF SOCIAL PLAYTO SOCIALDEVELOPMENT
There are two ways in which social play may contribute to social development. The first concerns the function discussed in the previous section. Social play might serve to increase the social interactions between a young animal and significant others. Through this contact an animal might become familiar with the other animals in its group, this we refer to as an acculturation function (see Bekoff, 1976, 1978). The second way that social play may contribute to social development is through the learning of specific motor patterns that are involved in social behavior-a motor-learning function. This motor learning would be a function attributable to the act of playing. In this section we shall consider playmothering and play-fighting in relation to these two possible functions. In addition we also shall examine the relationship between sex differences in social play and sex differences in adult social behavior. If we assume for a moment that the social interactions of juveniles serve some developmental function for adult social behavior, then to the degree that there are sex differences in the adult social behavior of a particular species so too should there be sex differences in the forms of social play that contribute to the development of adult social behavior. Specifically, we might expect that juvenile males would engage more frequently in those forms of social play that contribute to male-typical, adult social behavior and that juvenile females would engage more frequently in those forms of social play that contribute to female-typical, adult social behavior. From a knowledge of the sex differences in adult social behavior, then, we should be able to predict sex differences in juvenile social behavior. There is a corollary to this reasoning that bears directly on our original question of whether there is a function for social play. If play is without any developmental consequence for adult social behavior, then it is most unlikely that there should be any meaningful relationship between sex differences in adult social behavior and sex differences in social play. The existence of such a relationship would argue for a developmental role for social play, since it is improbable that
SOCIAL PLAY
35
any such relationship would exist unless the behaviors were functionally related.3 1. Play-Mothering
Lancaster (1971) and, more recently, Meaney, Stewart, Lozos and Ervin (submitted) have presented some rather clear evidence for a motor-learning function for play-mothering. Lancaster reported that young female vervet monkeys were rather clumsy in their initial efforts to care for an infant. They had difficulty in orienting the infant's body and in getting the infant to cling to them. Often this resulted in the juvenile carrying the infant with one leg while walking along on the remaining three (see Figs. 13 and 14). Soon, however, the juveniles learned how to carry the infant properly and to instill sufficient confidence in the infant that it would cling when the juvenile tried to walk with it. At this stage the juveniles had developed adequate maternal skills such that they could pacify the infant and thus avoid having the mother attempt to retrieve her offspring. Meaney er a / . observed the infant care of juvenile (2-4 years of age) and subadult (5-6 years of age) females in a captive troop of vervet monkeys through two birthing seasons (over a period of 14 months). For the 2 years prior to the study, infants had been removed from the troop. Thus, the first birthing season represented a renewed, or in the case of certain juveniles, a new opportunity for exposure to infants. Over the first birthing season and through the following autumn, these nulliparous females improved in their ability to carry infants to the point that, by the second birthing season they were indistinguishable from multiparous females. Jay (1963) also has reported that in langurs females that had experience with infants were better at keeping infants quiet and were able to hold them for a longer period of time than were inexperienced females. Play-mothering, then, affords the opportunity for juveniles to gain what might be valuable experience in infant care in a relatively benign setting. This may be especially important for primates considering their low reproductive rate (compared with rodents, for example). It would be interesting to examine, across primate species, the relationship between the degree of play-mothering in juveniles and the competency of primiparous mothers. This attraction of juveniles toward infants results not only in interactions with the infants but also in interactions with the mothers of infants. In free-ranging baboons (Cheney, 1978; Seyfarth et al., 1978), Juvenile females are highly attracted toward the infants in the group and, in particular, toward the infants of high-ranking adult females. In the course of these interactions, juveniles spend a considerable amount of time grooming the adult females. Thus, the Juveniles are "Note that we have already dismissed the possibility that this relationship exists simply because the behaviors share a common ncuroendocrine basis (see Section II,C,4).
36
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
FIGS. 13- 14. The juvenile vervet females in our troop are quick to retrievt: and carry an unattended infant (in this sequence the mother, not seen, was about 3-4 m away). The carrying of infants by juveniles is often clumsy, and the juvenile often must support the infant who commonly does not cling to the inexperienced female.
37
SOCIAL PLAY
SUMMARY OF EVIDENCE tOR
SEX
TABLE I1 DlbFERENCtS IN PLAY-MOTHERING ACROSSSPtClES Finding
Species studied Hominoidea Humans Cercopithecoidea Rhesus monkey Olive baboon Vervet monkey Barbary ape Ceboidea Squirrel monkey
P > 6
P = 6
Berman ( 1980, for a review) Chamove et ul. (1972) Owens (1975a.b) Gartlan ( 1968); Lancaster (1971) Burton (1965) Baldwin and Baldwin ( 1974)
afforded a form of amicable contact with high-ranking females that would otherwise be unlikely to occur (cf. Weisbard & Goy, 1976). Cheney (1978) has suggested two very plausible functions for this adult-juvenile interaction. First, it may facilitate the integration of the juvenile females into the adult female structure (an acculturation function). Second, the interactions between juvenile females and high-ranking adult females may allow the former to establish a relationship with dominant animals and thereby, through association, derive some of the benefits connected with a high social status. Thus, Cheney (1978) observed that juvenile females interact more often with the infants of highranking mothers than with those of low-ranking mothers. In considering these arguments, it is important to remember that in baboons, as with most old-world monkeys, females rarely migrate from their natal group (Packer, 1975, 1978). The relationship between sex differences in play-mothering and sex differences in the parental behavior of adults appears to be rather clear. Presented in Table I1 are the results of studies with various species in which play-mothering and related infant-directed activities4 have been observed in juveniles. Note that in all but one of these species play-mothering is performed almost exclusively by juvenile females. The exception is found in the juvenile Barbary macaques. It is interesting that in this species the adult male performs a crucial role in the socialization of the infant (Burton, 1972) as well as a considerable amount of infant care (Burton, 1972; Lahiri & Southwick, 1966). In some baboon species 41n some cases the studies listed here (i.e., Cheney, 1978; some of the work in the Berman, 1980, review) refer to reports of attraction toward infants rather than actual parental behavior.
38
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
(chacma and olive) as well there is a certain amount of paternal behaviorhowever, probably much less than in Barbary macaques (Bolwig, 1959; DeVore, 1963). It is interesting to note, then, that Owens (1975a) has observed infant-care behavior in juvenile male olive baboons, although less so than in juvenile females. In the remaining species listed in Table 11, the role of the adult male is far less pronounced and the role of primary infant caretaker is performed by the female. Among humans, for example, there is no known society in which infant care is primarily the role of the male (e.g., Whiting & Whiting, 1974). Rossi (1977) makes the point from cross-cultural studies of foster parenting (e.g., occasioned by the death of the natural mother) that without exception the foster parent is a woman. In summary, then, the juvenile female’s attraction to infants provides for experience in infant care and for social interactions with adult females. These experiences are of dubious value to the juvenile male, since in most species adult males participate in infant care much less than do adult females. An exception, of course, is the adult male Barbary macaque, and thus it is interesting that in this species juvenile males have considerable contact with infants.
2 . Play-Fighting The most obvious hypothesis regarding play-fighting is that it provides a context in which animals may learn the skills necessary to behave appropriately in agonistic encounters. In most socially living, mammalian species the agonistic encounters of adults are characterized by ritualized forms of aggression, including specialized vocalizations, facial expressions, body postures, or attacks to nonvital areas of the body that serve the function of defeating an opponent without causing serious injury. Often the simple expression of threat is sufficient. These behaviors serve as a form of social communication (see Altmann, 1967). Successful adult social behavior, then, can be seen as including the ability to communicate and to interpret the communications of conspecifics. In this regard it is interesting to note that animals reared in the absence of peer contact have been found to behave inappropriately in agonistic conflicts. In particular they seem less able to inhibit the attack of other animals than are socially reared animals (e.g., Mason, 1961, with rhesus monkeys; Lore & Flannelly, 1977, with Norway rats). Some authors have attributed this social-skill deficit to the inadequate learning of the communicative skills used in the course of aggression. In addition, there is direct experimental evidence that peer-deprived rhesus monkeys are unable to interpret the facial expressions of conspecifics (Miller, Caul, & Mirsky, 1967) and that they exhibit inappropriate facial expressions such as staring (threat communication) at a dominant male (Mitchell, 1972). Taken together these findings have led some to propose that one of the learning experiences associated with play-fighting is the development
SOCIAL PLAY
39
of communicative abilities, particularly those that are relevant to agonistic bouts (e.g., Dolhinow, 1971; Jolly, 1972; Mason, 1965). This proposed relationship between play-fighting and adult aggression can be considered both in terms of the motor-learning function and the acculturation function that were described earlier. If play-fighting was a context in which an animal might learn motor skills used in aggression, then we might expect to observe components of these skills, especially communicative skills, in the play-fights of juveniles. A comparison of play-fighting and adult aggression, however, reveals considerable dissimilarity. Symons (1974), for instance, has described how the facial expressions commonly seen in the agonistic encounters of adult rhesus monkeys are not expressed during the play-fighting of young rhesus. Moreover, in the course of playfighting, both participants behave offensively and there is little evidence of the submissive gestures that among adults seem to inhibit the attack of an opponent. The agonistic bouts of older animals usually involve a “threat” display and a “submissive” response such that direct fighting in most species does not frequently occur. As Symons points out, in the play-fighting of rhesus monkeys “there are no gestures of threat or submission” (1974, p. 321). Rather, the facial expressions (van Hoof, 1972; Symons, 1974) and body postures (e.g., Bekoff, 1974) that are observed during play-fighting are unique to the play context. If these gestures serve any communicative function at all it is to signal to another animal that what follows is playful (see Bekoff, 1977) and nor aggressive! It is also improbable that play-fighting serves as a context in which the motor skills that are used in the direct fighting of adult animals are learned. Rather, it appears that in most species these skills emerge early in life in their adult form. Thus, rhesus monkeys begin to exhibit adult-like aggression by about 7 months of age (Symons, 1978). Wolves exhibit intraspecies aggression even as young cubs that is marked by elevated hackles (piloerection) and the “agonisticpucker” expression (facial expression) components of fighting in adults (see Bekoff, 1974; Mech, 1970). In coyotes, cubs actually go through a period of intense fighting prior to the onset of play-fighting (Rekoff, 1974; Ryon, 1979).s In fact the Norway rat is one of the few species in which a juvenile period of play-fighting actually precedes the onset of adult-like aggression. Even in the Norway rat, however, the behavioral components of play-fighting that are used in aggression appear in their adult form even at the very onset of play-fighting
51t is interesting to note that the potential for the expression of both play-fighting and aggression coexist in animals of the same age. This is not unique to subadults. The adult males and/or females in many species play-fight with subadults and in some cases among themselves. At the same time, of course, they are capable of exhibiting aggression. These observations argue against the idea that a motivational system for aggression emerges from a system for play-fighting. It also further supports the notion proffered earlier-that play-fighting represents an independent behavioral system.
40
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
(Meaney & Stewart, 1981a; Poole & Fish, 1976). The same is true in young polecats (Poole, 1966). Taken together these observations argue strongly against a motor-learning role for play-fighting, at least with respect to adult aggression. This appears to be the case with regard to both the communicative and the physical fighting components of aggressive behavior. The final problem associated with a possible relationship between play-fighting and aggression is the apparent inconsistency within species in the degree to which these behaviors are sexually dimorphic. For example, while juvenile male hamsters engage in more play-fighting than do juvenile females (Goldman & Swanson, 1975), among adults the female is far more pugnacious than is the male (Payne & Swanson, 1972). Similar inconsistencies have also been reported in vervet and talapoin monkeys (Raleigh, Flannery, & Ervin, 1979; Wolfheim, 1977). An analogous finding is reported by Blurton-Jones and Konner (1973) in their study of London and !Kung (an African hunter-gatherer group) children. They report that !Kung girls play-fight more frequently than do London girls; however, the English girls show a greater frequency of aggressive acts than do the !Kung girls. Clearly there is no easily identified relationship between sex differences in play-fighting and sex differences in aggression.h Rather, what we have chosen to consider here is the relationship between sex differences in play-fighting and sex differences in dominance-related b e h a v i ~ r s What . ~ we argue here is that on the basis of comparative data such a relationship does exist and that an analysis of the nature of this relationship reveals a possible acculturation function of playfighting. There are two basic sex differences in dominance-related behavior that have been reported across several species. The first is a sex difference in the way in which males and females achieve status or rank within a dominance hierarchy. The factors that Contribute to the status of males are, seemingly, different from those that contribute to the female's status, Among primates this issue has been 6Apart from these empirical considerations, there are also conceptual problems in considering a relationship between sex differences in play-fighting and sex differences in aggression. These problems concern formulating general statements about sex differences in aggression. This seems to be more of a question of sex differences in the conditions that elicit aggression rather than sex differences in thc tendency to engage in aggressive behavior. In the Norway rat, for example, male aggression tends to occur in situations that involve territorial intrusion or the maintenance of withingroup social structure. In females, conspecific aggression is usually associated with the defense of young (see Barnett, 1975). Thus, a sex difference in the overall frequency with which aggression occurs probably reflects the fact that the situations that elicit aggression in males occur more frequently than do those that elicit aggression in females. 'We use the term dominance to refer to a relationship between two or more animals and not to the aggressiveness of an animal (cf. Hinde, 1974). In this sense the term is best considered as reflecting the social structure of a group and the relationship bctween the animals in the groups.
SOCIAL PLAY
41
studied in rhesus and Japanese macaques (Kawai, 1958; Loy, 1975; Sade, 1967) and in the yellow baboon (Papio cyrzocephalus; Lee & Oliver, 1979). In each of these species, prepubertal animals, regardless of gender, rank just below their mothers (i.e., “dependent rank,” see Kawai, 1958). Females maintain this rank as adults. Accordingly, females defeat other females that rank below their mothers, including the daughters of lower-ranking females. These relationships tend to remain stable (e.g., Owens, 1975b) although some changes may occur through affiliative behaviors such as social grooming (Rowell, 1966). In contrast, once males are sexually mature they achieve a rank that is independent of that of their mother. In males, the ultimate rank achieved is usually associated with age/size and success in direct confrontation with other males (i.e., “basic rank,” see Kawai, 1958). Thus, in the rhesus monkey, for example, only males establish dominance through physical aggression (Angermeir, Phelps, Murray, & Howanstine, 1968).8 A relationship between the rank of a mother and that of her daughter has also been reported in Norway rats (Calhoun, 1962). In this species, daughters inherit nesting sites (a resource, that at least in fixed colonies, is dependent on rank) from their mothers. In the Norway rat, there is no evidence of a relationship between the rank of a mother and that of her male offspring. Another factor that in some species has been found to contribute to the dominance status of females is that of “reproductive value” (Hrdy & Hrdy, 1976). In hanuman langurs, reproductive value declines with age, thus younger adult females are dominant over older females. In the male, however, younger males usually defer to older males and may be peripheralized (Mohnot, 1978; a reasonably common pattern among males of many species, both primate and nonprimate). Thus, at least in the hanuman langur, the relationship between age and dominance status is qualitatively different for males and females. Although common, this pattern of sex differences in the achievement of dominance status is not universal. The best-studied exceptions are the canids. In wolf packs, usually only the alpha female gives birth to a litter (Mech, 1970; Rabb, Woolpy, & Ginsburg, 1967). Hence, all the cubs within a pack share the same matrilineal association. In wolves, both males and females achieve dominance status through agonistic encounters with siblings. The same appears to be true, at least for the strains that have been studied, in the domestic dog (Scott & Fuller, 1965). Among coyotes, the dominance hierarchies of females are characterized by higher levels of aggression than are those of males (Ryon, 1979). Thus, in these canid species there do not appear to be sex differences in the manner in which animals achieve dominance status. It is interesting to note that in these species there are no sex differences in play8Whiting and Edwards (1973). in their cross-cultural studies on socialization, have described a similar sex difference among children in the achievement of dominance.
42
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
fighting (see Table I). It appears, then, that the presence or absence of sex differences in play-fighting may be predicted from a knowledge of how males and females achieve dominance status. The second sex difference in dominance-related behavior concerns the function of dominance relationships in general. Loy (1973, on the basis of longitudinal studies with rhesus and Japanese monkeys, has argued that dominance relations have the important function of providing for an “orderly integration of new individuals” into the group. The problem of integrating into a group as well as the cost for males of not belonging to a group (we refer, here, only to mixed-sex groups) seems to be different from what it is for females. In many species, males are often peripheralized or dispersed from the natal group (Dittus, 1975; Drickamer & Vessey, 1973; Sade, 1980; Packer, 1973, whereas female dispersion from the natal group is rare (Dittus, 1975; Packer, 1975). Moreover, the integration of females into a group seems, by existing accounts, to be less difficult than the integration of a new male (Packer, 1978). In some species, such as hamadryas baboons (Kummer, 1968), females may actually be “kidnapped” into groups. Since reproductive success in socially living mammals is usually dependent on membership in a mixed-sex group, group integration becomes a problem central to the overall fitness of a male. Again an exception to this general pattern can be found in a canid species. In wolf packs, dispersion from the natal group can occur in both males and females (e.g., Mech, 1970). In addition, the integration into a pack appears to be no less problematic for females than it is for males. Females can be peripheralized by other females (e.g., Rabb, Ginsburg, & Andrews, 1962). This is no doubt related to the intense reproductive competition and suppression among adult female wolves (Rabb et a / . , 1967). Again, it is interesting to note that in this species there are no sex differences in play-fighting. The hypothesis that emerges here is that sex differences in play-fighting may be related to sex differences in both the dispersion from the natal group and the integration into either the natal group or another unit.y While the comparative data on species in which there are no sex differences in group integration are limited, there are other data that address the issue of a relationship between playfighting and group integration. Simonds (1977) has reported that in bonnet monkeys young males typically join play groups where they experience substantial contact with other subadult males as well as with the dominant males in the group. In these troops the integration of subadult males into the existing dominance hierarchy begins from the time the males join the play group. Thus, by the time the males are sexually mature they are already recognized and treated as 9There is a somewhat of a tautology involved in distinguishing these two factors since the difficulty of integrating into the natal group may be due to pressure on an animal to disperse from that group.
SOCIAL PLAY
43
members of the social structure of the group. Simonds reports that in one bonnet troop (the “Moyar River” troop) this pattern of male-male contact is absent. Interestingly, in this troop young males leave the group. Although this may be an isolated observation, it serves to underscore the importance of male-male interaction. The importance of social contact with dominant males for subadult males is further emphasized by the recent findings of Harcourt and Stewart (1981) on gorillas. They found that some young males emigrated and others remained in their natal group. Their data suggest that the males remaining in the group are those that as juveniles had very close contact with the dominant male, and they go on to suggest that this close relationship may predispose the young male to remain in the group. Comparative data also suggest a relationship between early social interactions and later integration into a group. Altmann (1963) found that elk (Cer.vi4s cunuclerisis nelsoni) young played with other calves, yearlings, and cows, whereas moose (Alces ulces strussi) young rarely engaged in social play. At about 3 to 4 weeks of age, elk young are integrated into the herd. Moose calves, in contrast, gain only limited integration. Bekoff (1977) has observed that social play in canids appears to be related to the social structure of the species. Thus, in the red fox (Vulpes,fulvu; a solitary-living species), social play is less frequent than in the semisolitary coyote. In turn, social play is less frequent in coyotes than in the highly social wolf. The data presented here suggest that sex differences in social play are related to sex differences in both the degree of difficulty in integrating into a social structure and in achieving status within that structure. Although these data argue for a relationship between play-fighting and dominance-related behavior, the nature of this relationship remains obscurc. One feature of the contact derived from play-fighting, however, may simply be to familiarize the participants with one another (cf. Bekoff, 1978). The significance of this can best be appreciated by considering the response of the animals in a group to an unfamiliar conspecific. In this situation the dominant animals in the group usually behave aggressively toward the intruder (Barnett, 1958; Bernstein, 1964; among others). However, in most cases this is only so for male intruders. In the Norway rat, for instance, female intruders are normally accepted into the group (Barnett, 1958). Thus, the cost of not being familiar to the members of a group may be greater for males (which, of course, refers to one original claim about sex differences in group integration). One feature of dominance hierarchies is that they tend to occur within, and not between, sexes. Although there are examples of cross-sex dominance, in most cases the status of an animal within a particular group is dependent on its relations with others of the same sex. Thus, if play-fighting is a behavior that is related to dominance activity, then we might expect animals to play-fight more often with peers of the same sex than with peers of the opposite sex. Indeed, such
44
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
same-sex, play-partner preferences have been reported in several species. In children (Clark e t a / ., 1969), bonnet monkeys (Simonds, 1974), rhesus monkeys (Ruppenthal, Harlow, Eisele, Harlow, & Suomi, 1974; Suomi, 1977), olive baboons (Owens, 1975a), and Norway rats (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a), juvenile males initiate and become involved in play-fights more often with males than with females.'O In contrast, there is evidence to suggest that females do not exhibit play-partner preferences either for males or for other females (Meaney & Stewart, 1981a; Ruppenthal el ul., 1974; Owens, 1975a). These findings suggest that play-fighting may be related to dominance-behavior in males more than in females. In females, soical contact with same-sex peers may be gained through grooming networks (see Simonds, 1977) rather than through play-fighting. In this context it is interesting that social grooming has been reported to occur more often in juvenile females than in juvenile males (e.g., Meaney & Stewart, 1981a; Simonds, 1974, 1977). C.
SEXDIFFERENCES IN
THE
RESPONSETO SOCIAL DEPRIVATION
Another, perhaps, more general, context in which to consider the question of sex differences in social play is that of the rather basic function of play addressed at the beginning of this section, that of enhancing the social contact an animal experiences. This function of play has been analyzed in social deprivation studies with rhesus monkeys. Sackett (1974) has shown that the effects of socially isolated rearing on the eventual social development of males are far more pronounced than on that of females. Taken together, the findings outlined below suggest that social contact may be more important in the social development of males than in that of females. While the sexual behavior of male and female rhesus monkeys reared in isolation is deficient compared to that of controls, females are less affected than are males. Sackett (1974) reports that, in repeated testing, 30% of socially isolated females eventually exhibited species- and gender-typical copulatory behavior, and 20% of the sessions resulted in the insemination of the female. In contrast, not one of the socially isolated males copulated. In tests of affiliative behavior with feral monkeys, both male and female isolates were found to display extreme social fear and to be hyperaggressive, Again, however, the male isolates were significantly more antisocial than were the female isolates (Pratt, cited in Sackett, 1974). This pattern of results was also observed in tests for exploratory behavior and for autoaggression. Finally, it is interesting to note the results of a study examining the survival 'OThis play-partner preference of males for other males is probably not simply due to a preference for a partner of the same size or strength. In Norway rat pups, males and females do not differ in body size until after puberty. Play-partner preferences, however, are observed well before puberty.
SOCIAL PLAY
45
ability of differentially reared male and female monkeys under free-ranging conditions (Sackett, 1974). These results are interesting not only within the present context but also in relation to the arguments made in the preceding section. Of the four female isolates that were released, two survived. One female joined a small group and remained an accepted group member despite exhibiting many of the behavioral anomalies associated with isolated rearing (e.g., selfclasping, rocking, stereotyped locomotor activities). All five of the socially reared females survived. Two of the three socially reared males survived, one actually becoming a dominant male within a native group. None of the three isolation-reared males survived, and it is implied that they were attacked by resident males. First, it is noteworthy that a greater proportion of females, and in particular isolation-reared females, survived than did males. The results from laboratory studies certainly suggest that the social skills of the female isolates are, by comparison, better than those of male isolates. These results, however, are also consistent with the notion that the integration of males into existing social groups is more difficult than is that of females. The thrust of the studies presented by Sackett (1974) is simply that males are more affected by the absence of social contact than are females. Thus, sex differences in the frequency of play-fighting, certainly a contact form of play, may be related to the relatively greater importance for social contact in the social development of males compared to females." In turn, recall that the argument presented in the preceding section stressed the importance of early social contact in males based on what we speculated to be a more arduous integration process than that for females. D.
POSSIBILITY OF IMMEDIATE CONSEQUENCE OF SO C I A L PLA Y
As mentioned earlier one of the features that is presumed to be basic to social play is that it is of little immediate value. Several researchers (e.g., Fagen, 1981) have stressed that social play may involve a cost for the participants (e.g., high energy expenditure, risk of injury, greater visibility to predators). But is social play really of no immediate value? The argument presented above, as well as that of Bekoff (1976, 1978), have stressed the acculturation value of social play both for males and for females: that social play serves to increase the social interactions that familiarize the young with other members of the group. Dittus (1979) has reported that among toque monkeys, during a period of drought, there was an exceptionally high mortality rate among juveniles. This high mortality appears to "The sex-dependent response to social deprivation does not appear to be restricted to early stages of life. In Norway rats, adult animals deprived of social contact even for relatively short periods exhibit an increased tendency to seek out contact with conspecifics. This effect is much greater in males than in females (Meaney & Stewart, 1979).
46
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
have been due to the fact that the juveniles were excluded from the feeding sites. Yamada (1963) has shown that among Japanese macaques adults are more tolerant of juveniles at feeding sites if they are familiar with them. These findings suggest a possible immediate function for the social interactions of juveniles. This possibility merits further investigation, especially with primates where the juvenile period is prolonged and where the juvenile's survival may depend upon its integration into the group.
1V. CONCLUSION In many mammalian species the socialization process for males is d from that for females. In addition to the contact with their mother, young males interact most frequently with other males, whereas young females interact more often with infants and other females. These social interactions serve the acculturation and, to a lesser extent, the motor-learning functions defined earlier. Sex differences in social play contribute to the socialization process by enhancing the appropriate forms of social interactions for each sex. These sex differences in social play emerge, in part, from the influence of hormonal events during the perinatal period. The critical feature of this hormonal action seems to be on the development of the neural systems that later regulate social play. Sex differences in adult-infant interactions also contribute to differences between the social play of males and females. The nature of these interactions is a function of both the behavior of the adult and that of the infant. One question that remains, however, concerns the sex difference in the topography of the preferred forms of social play. It is understandable that in several species females engage in play-mothering since this behavior probably serves a motor-learning function. But why do young females play-fight less and groom more among themselves and adults than do males if the function of both activities is simply to enhance social interaction'? One plausible answer might lie in differences in the preference for different activities. Goldberg and Lewis (1969) have shown that 1-year-old girls prefer fine motor activities while boys spend more time in gross motor activities. Studies with nursery school children have reported similar findings (Clark et a l . , 1969). Thus, the fine motor activities of social grooming may be more intrinsically rewarding to females, while the reverse may be true for play-fighting. As suggested by Goy (1970), sex differences in juvenile behavior might be due to sex differences in the neural substrates that underlie the endogenous reward mechanisms. Considered in this way, play-fighting for young males might not simply be an opportunity to interact with other males, but it might also be the occasion for a good time. There is some support for this notion. Certainly there is evidence that play-
SOCIAL PLAY
47
fighting is rewarding. Mason, Hollis, and Sharpe (1962) found that young chimpanzees preferred a handler that would play-fight with them to one that simply held them. Humphreys and Einon ( 198 1) have shown that juvenile rats prefer the companionship of a playful partner to that of a social, but nonplayful partner. Thus, the act of play-fighting itself appears to be rewarding. One interesting ramification here is that sex differences in the preferred forms of early activity that are of developmental significance might lead to sex differences in adult social skills. The studies reviewed in this article also suggest an understandably high degree of concordance between the social activities of young animals and the experiences from which they benefit most. Thus, for example, among those species in which there are sex differences in dominance-related behavior, males engage most in those forms of social play that provide for the type of social interactions from which they are most likely to benefit (e.g., interactions with males). The processes involved in such social development may be seen as being somewhat analogous to those involved in the development of the visual system. In kittens the time between 7 and 9 weeks of age is a critical period for the development of binocular vision. Monocular or binocular deprivation even for brief periods (4 to 7 days) during this time has an irreversible effect on the visual system. Barrett and Bateson (1978) found that the visual exploration of objects by kittens is greatest during this time when normal visual development is dependent on environmental input. Timney, Emerson, and Dodwell (1979) found that kittens raised in the dark would bar-press to gain visual stimulation and began to do so during the period between 7 and 9 weeks of age. Thus, the period at which visual stimulation was most rewarding corresponded to the period when, in terms ofthe development of the visual cortex, it was most influential. As in the case of social development, animals seem to seek out the forms of experience from which they benefit (in a developmental sense). This close relationship between a preferred activity and its developmental consequence may be considered as a developmental strategy in the evolutionary sense. The term strategy describes the fact that an animal engages in those activities that best contribute to its development. An animal that does so would have an advantage over animals that engage more often in activities that are less relevant to their adult roles. Through an evolutionary feedback system the behavior of the young of a species would come to be typified by those forms of activity most likely to contribute to development. At a motivational level this strategy may be expressed in subtle differences in the neural mechanisms underlying reward and which in turn determines which activities are preferred. In this sense social development is, in part, self-regulated. Sex differences in social play may be seen as differences in the developmental strategies that have evolved to conform to the sex roles typical of the species. Where large sex differences in the social roles of the adults exist, there would be
48
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
sex differences in developmental strategies. These developmental strategies are expressed as sex differences in preferred activities which appear to be a function of perinatal hormones. Likewise, the behavior of the mother should conform to the developmental strategies of her offspring. That is, the behavior of the infant caretakers should serve to promote those activities in their young that provide for the developmentally most relevant forms of experience. As seen earlier this appears to be the case. In this sense, the role of the mother and related adults in promoting sex differences in social play is understandable. Acknowledgments The preparation of this manuscript was supported by Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada Grants (E0300) to MJM, (A0156) to JS, and by National Institute of Child Health and Development (HD12620) and National Science Foundation (BNS-8201448) to WWB.
References Abbot, D. H. (1978). Hormones and behavior during puberty in the marmoset. Reccnr Adv. Primatol. 1, 497-500. Aldis, 0. (1975). Playfighting. New York: Academic Press. Altmann, M. (1963). Naturalistic studies of maternal care in moose and elk. In H. Rheingold (Ed.), Maternal behavior in mamnials (pp. 233-253). New York: Wiley. Altmann, S . A. (1967). The structure of primate social communication. In S. A. Altmann (Ed.), Communication among primates (pp. 325-362). Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Anderson, J . W. (1972). On the psychological attachment of infants to their mothers. J . Biosocial Sci. 10, 554-558. Angermeir, W. F., Phelps, J. B., Murray, D., & Howanstine, J . (1968). Dominance in monkeys: Sex differences. Psychonorn. Sci. 12, 344. Balazs, R., & Cotterrell, M. (1972). Effect of hormonal state on cell number and functional maturation of the brain. Nature (London) 236, 348-350. Baldwin, J. D. (1969). The ontogeny of social behavior of squirrel monkeys (Saimiri Scirrreus) in a seminatural environment. Folia Primatol. 11, 35-79. Baldwin, J . D., & Baldwin, J. J. (1974). Exploration and social play in squirrel monkey (Saimiri). Am. Zool. 14, 303-314. Bardin, C. W., & Catterall, J. F. (1981). Testosterone: A major determinant of extragenital sexual dimorphism. Science 211, 1285-1294. Barnett, S. A. (1958). An analysis of social behaviour in wild rats. Proc. Zool. Soc. London 130, 107- 152. Barnett, S . A. (1975). The rat: A stud.y in behavior. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Barrett, P. T., & Bateson, P. P. G. (1978). Development of play in cats. Behaviour 66, 106- 120. Baum, M. J. (1972). Precocious mating in male rats following treatment with androgen or estrogen. J . Comp. Physinl. Psychol. 78, 356-367. Baum, M. J. (1979). Differentiation of coital behavior in mammals: A comparative analysis. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev. 3, 265-284. Beach, F. A. (1956). Characteristics of masculine sex drive. In M. R. Jones (Ed.), Nebraska symposium on motivation (pp. 1-31). Lincoln, Nebraska: Univ. of Nebraska Press.
SOCIAL PLAY
49
Beatty. W. W. (1979). Gonadal hormones and sex differences in nonreproductive behaviors in rodents: Organizational and activational influences. Horm. Behav. 12, I 12- 163. Beatty, W. W., Dodge, A. M., Traylor, K . L., Donegan, J. C.. & Godding, P. R. (1982). Septa1 lesions increase play-fighting in juvenile rats. Physiol. Behuv. 28, 649-652. Beatty. W. W., Dodge, A. M., Traylor, K . L., & Meaney, M . J . ( 198 I ). Temporal boundary of the sensitive period for hormonal organization of social play in juvenile rats. Physiol. Behav. 26, 24 1-243. Beeman, E. A. (1947). The effect of male hormone on aggressive behavior in mice. Physiol. Zoo/. 20, 373-405. Bekoff, M. (1974). Social play and play-soliciting by infant canids. Am. Zoo/. 14, 323-341. Bekoff. M. (1976). The social deprivation paradigm: Who’s being deprived of what? Dev. Psychob i d . 9, 499-500. Bekoff. M. (1977). Socialization in mammals, with an emphasis on non-primates. In S. ChevalierSkolnikoff & F. E. Poirier (Eds.), Primate bio-social development (pp. 603-636). New York: Garland. Bekoff, M. (1978). Social play: Structure, function, and the evolution of cooperative social behavior. In G . M. Brughardt & M. Bekoff (Eds.), The developmenr ofbehuvior (pp. 367-384). New York: Garland. Bell, R. Q. (1971). Stimulus control of parent or caretaker behavior of offspring. Dev. Psychol. 4, 63-72. Bell, R . W.. & Costello, N. (1964). Three teats for sex differences in tactile sensitivity in the new born. B i d . Neonar. 7, 335-347. Berman, P. W. (1980). Are women more responsive than men to the young’?A review of developmental and situational variables. Psychol. Bull. 88, 668-695. Bernstein, I. S. (1964). Role of the dominant male rhesus monkey in response to external challenges to the group. J . Comp. Physiol. Psychol. 57, 404-406. Bemstein, 1. S. (1967). A field study of the pigtail monkey. Primates 8, 217-228. Bemstein, I . S . (1968). The lutong of kuola selangor. Behuviour 32, 1-16. Bertrand, M . (1969). The behaviorul repertoire o f t h e stionp/ail macaque. New York: Karger. Birke, L. 1. A.. & Sadler, D. (1983). Progestin-induced changes in play behavior of the prepubertal rat. Physiol. Behav. 30, 341-347. Blurton-Jones, N. (1976). Rough-and-tumble play among nursery school children. In J . S . Bruner, A. Jolly, & K. Sylva (Eds.), PIuy (pp. 352-363). New York: Penguin. Blurton-Jones, N. G . , and Konner, M. J. (1973). Sex differences in behaviour of London and Bushman children. In R. P. Michael & J . H. Crook (Eds.). Compurutive ecologyund behaviour of’primates (pp. 689-750). New York: Academic Press. Bolwig, N . (1959). A study of the behavior of the chacma baboon, Pupio urisinus. Behaviorrr 14, 136- 163. Braggio. J. T., Nadler, R. D., Lance, J., & Miseyko. D. (1978). Sex differences in apes and children. Recent Adv. Primutol. I , 529-532. Brain, P. F.. & Nowell, N. W. (1969). Some behavioral and endocrine relationships in adult male, laboratory mice subjected to open-field and aggression tests. Physiol. Behav. 4, 945-947. Bramblett, C. A . (1973). Social organization as an expression of role behavior among old world monkeys. Primates 14, 101-1 12. Bramblett. C. A. (1978). Sex differences in the acquisition of play among juvenile vervet monkeys. In E. 0. Smith (Ed.), Sociul play in primates (pp. 33-48). New York: Academic Press. Breuggenian, J. A. (1964). Parental care in a groups of free-ranging rhesus monkeys (Macucu mulatta). Foliu Primutol. 2, 93- 110. Bridges, R. S . , Zarrow, M . X . . & Dcncnberg. R. H. (1973). The role of neonatal androgen in the
50
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
expression of hormonal induced maternal responsiveness in the adult rat. Horm. Eehuv. 4, 315322. Burton, F. D. (1972). The integration of biology and behavior in the socialization of Mucucu sylvana of Gibraltar. In F. E. Poirier (Ed.), Primate socializarion (pp. 29-62). New York: Random House. Caggiula, A. R., Shaw, D. H., Antelman, S . M., & Edwards, D. J. (1976). Interactive effects of brain catecholamines and variations in sexual and nonsexual arousal on copulatory behavior of male rats. Brain Res. 111, 321-336. Calhoun, J . B., (1962). The ecology and.wciology UftheNorwuy rut. Bethesda, MD: U . S . Dept. of Health, Education and Welfare. Chalmers, N. R. (1980). The ontogeny of play in feral olive baboons (Papio anuhis).Anim. Eehav. 28, 570-585. Chamove, A,, Harlow, H. F., & Mitchell, G. (1967). Sex differences in the infant-directed behavior of preadolescent rhesus monkeys. Child Dev. 38, 329-335. Cheney, D. L. (1978). Interactions of male and female baboons with adult females. Anim. Eehtrv. 26, 389-408. Cidlowski, J. A . (1982). Glucocorticoids stimulate ribonucleic acid degradation in isolated rat thymic lymphocytes in virro. Endocrinology 111, 184- 190. Clark, A. H., Wyon, S . M., & Richards, M. P. M. (1969). Free-play in nursery school children. J. Child Psycho/. Psychiar. 10, 205-216. Clark, C. B. (1977). A preliminary report on weaning among chimpanzees of the Gombe National Park, Tanzania. In S . Chevalier-Skolnikoff & F. E. Poirier (Eds.), Primute bio-social development (pp. 235-260). New York: Garland. Cotterrell, M., Balazs, R., & Johnson, A. L. (1972). Effects of corticosteroids on the biochemical maturation of rat brain: Postnatal cell formation. J. Neurochem. 19, 2 I5 1-2167. Dahlherg, E., Snochowski, M., & Gustafsson, J.-A. (1981). Regulation of the androgen and glucocorticoid receptors in rat and mouse skeletal mouse cytosol. Endocrinulogy 108, 143I 1440. Davies, J . A,, & Kemble, E. D. (1983). Social play behaviors and insect predation in northern grasshopper mice (Onychomys leucoguster). Eehuv. Proc. 8, 197-204. DeVore, I . T. (1963). Mother-infant relations in baboons. In H. Rheingold (Ed.), Maternal Behavior in mammals (pp. 305-335). New York: Wiley. Dittus, W. P. J. (1975). Population dynamics of the Togue monkey, Mucacu simica. In R. H. Tuttle (Ed.), S O C ~ O C . C O /and O ~ ~psychology V primates (pp. 125- 151). The Hague: Mouton. Dodge, A. M. (1981). An invcstigation of the effects of ventromedial hypothalamic and medial preoptic area lesions on play-fighting in juvenile rats. Unpublished MA thesis, North Dakota State University. Dolhinow, P. (1971). At play in the fields. Nat. Hisr. 80, 66-71. Dolhinow, P. J . , & Bishop, N. (1970). The developmcnt of motor skills and social relationships among primates through play. In J. P. Hill (Ed.), Minnesotu symposia on childpsychology Vol. IV, pp. 141-198). Minneapolis: Univ. of Minnesota Press. Draper, P. (1973). Crowding among hunter-gatherers: The !Kung. Science 182, 301-303. Drickamer, L. C., & Vessey, S. H. (1973). Group changing in free-ranging male rhesus monkeys. Primates 14, 359-368. Dyer, R. G . , MacLeod, N. K., & Ellendorff, F. (1976). Electrophysiological evidence for sexual dimorphism and synaptic convergence in the preoptic anterior hypothalamic areas of the rat. Proc. R . Soc. London Ser. E 193, 421-440. Ehrhardt, A. A,, & Baker, S . W. (1974). Fetal androgens, human CNS differentiation, and behavior sex differences. In R. C. Friedman, R. M. Richart, & R . L. Vande Wiele (Eds.). SexdifSererices in behavior (pp. 53-76). Ncw York: Wiley.
SOCIAL PLAY
51
Ehrhardt, A. A , , & Money, J . ( 1967). Progestin-induced hermaphroditism: IQ and psychosexual identity in a study of ten girls. J . Ser Res. 3, 83- 100. Ehrhardt, A. A,, Epstein, R., & Money, J. (1968). Fetal androgens and female gender identity in the early treated adrenogenital syndrome. Johns Hopkins Med. J. 122, 160- 167. Eleftheriou, B. E., & Sprott. R. L. (1975a). Hormonul correlaies of heliuvior, V d . I : A l;fi~.spun view. New York: Plenum. Eleftheriou, B. E., & Sprott. R. L. (197%). Homionul correlutes qfbehiivior. Vol 2: An o r p k w n i c view. New York: Plenum. Ember, C. (1973). Female task assignment and the social behavior of boys. Ethos 1, 424-439. Erwin, J . , Anderson, B., & Bunger, D. (1975). Nursing behavior of infant pigtail monkeys (Macacu nemestrina): Preferences for nipples. Percept. Motor Skills 40, 592-594. Estrada. A. (1978). Social relations in a free-ranging troop of Muciicu urcroides. Recenr Advu. Primufol. I , 55-58. Fagen. R. (1981). Animal P l q Behavior. London and New York: Oxford Univ. Press. Fagot, B. 1. (1974). Sex differences in toddlers' behavior and parental reaction. Dev. Psycho/. 10, 554-558. Fox, T. 0.. Vito, C. C., & Wieland, S . J . (1978). Estrogen and androgen receptor proteins in embryonic and neonatal brain: Hypotheses for roles in sexual differentiation of behavior. Am. Zoo/. 18, 525-537. Freedman, D. G. ( 1974). Human iifuncy: An evolrttioriar~p":~l~eetirv. New York: Halstead. Freeman, H. E., & Alcock, J . (1973). Play behaviour of a mixed group of juvenile gorillas and orangutans. In/. Z o o Yeurh. 13, 189-194. Gartlan, J. S . (1968). Structure and function in primate society. Foliu Priinutol. 8, 89-120. Gentry. R. L. (1974). The development of social behavior through play in the stellar sea lion. Am. Zoo/. 14, 391-403. George, F. W., & Ojeda S. R. (1982). Changes in aromatase activity in the rat brain during embryonic, neonatal, and infantile development. Endocrinology I I I , 522-529. Gerall, H. D., Ward, I . L., & Gerall, A. A. (1967). Disruption of the male rat's sexual behaviour induced by social isolation. Ariim. Behav. 15, 54-58. Goldberg. S..& Lewis, M. (1969). Play behavior in the year-old infant: Early sex differences. Child Dev. 40, 21-31. Goldfoot, D. A,, & Wallen. K. (1978). Development of gender role behaviors in heterosexual and isosexual groups of infant rhesus monkeys. Recent Adv. Prirnarol. 1, 155- 160. Goldman, L., & Swanson, H. H. (1975). Developmental changes in pre-adult behavior in confined colonies of golden hamsters. Dev. PsycAoDiol. 8, 137- 150. Gorski, R . A. (1973). Perinatal effects of sex steroids on brain development and function. Prog. Bruin Res. 39, 149- 162. Gorski. R. A , , Gordon, J . H., Shyrne, .I.E., & Southam. A . M. (1978). Evidence for a morphological sex difference within the medial preoptic area of the rat brain. Bruin Res. 148, 333346. Goy, R. W. (1970). Early hormonal influences on the development of sexual and sex-related behavior. In F. 0 . Schmitt (Ed.), The neurosciences: Second study program (pp. 196-206). New York: Rockefeller Univ. Press. Goy. R. W. (1978). Development of play and mounting behavior in female rhesus virilized prenatally with esters of testosterone or dihydrotestosterone. Recent A&. Prirnutol. I , 449-462. Goy. R . W . , & Goldfoot, D. A. (1974).Experiential and hormonal factors influencing development of sexual behavior in the male rhesus monkey. In F. 0. Schmitt (Ed.), The ~ I ~ U ~ O S C Third ~~IICPS: study program ( p p ~571-582). New York: Rockefeller Univ. Press. Goy. R. W., Kemnitz, J . W., Slimp, J . C., Irving, S. M., & Neff, D. A . (lY79).friwpric lesions in pri~puhertulrnule rtie.sus und developrrwnt of testiculur endocrine f i t r m i o n arid behtivior. Pre-
52
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET A L .
sented at the 11th annual meeting of the Eastern Conference on Reproductive Behavior, New Orleans, LA. Goy, R. W., & McEwen, B. S . (1980). Sexual diflerentiation of the brain. Cambridge. MA: MIT Press. Goy, R. W., & Phoenix, C. H. (1971). The effects of testosterone propionate administered before birth on the development of behavior in genetic female rhesus monkeys. In C. Sawyer & R. Gorski (Eds.), Steroid hormones and brain function (pp. 193-202). Berkeley: Univ. of California Press. Harper, L. V . (1971). The young as a source of stimuli controlling caretaker behavior. Dev. Psyc-hol. 4, 73-88. Harcourt, A. H., & Stewart, K. J . (1981). Gorilla male relationship: Can differences during immaturity lead to contrasting reproductive tactics in adulthood. Adult Behav. 29, 206-210. Hard, E., & Larsson, K. (1968). Dependence of adult mating behavior in male rats on the presence of littermates in infancy. Brain Behav. Evol. 1, 405-419. Harlow, H. F. (1965). Sexual behavior in rhesus monkeys. In F. A. Beach (Ed.), Sex and behavior. (pp, 234-265). New York: Wiley. Harlow, H. F. (1969). Age-mate or peer affectional system. Adv. Study Behuv. 2, 333-383. Harlow, H. F., & Harlow (1970). Harlow, H. F., & Lauersdorf, H. E. (1974). Sex differences in passion and play. Perspecr. B i d . Med. 17, 348-60. Hinde, R. A. (1971). Development of social behavior. In A. M. Schrier & F. Stolhitz (Eds.), Behavior of nonhuman primates (Vol. 3 , pp. 1-68). New York: Academic Press. Hinde, R. A. (1974). Biological basis of human social behaviour. New York: McGrdw-Hill. Hinde, R. A., & Spencer-Booth, Y. (1967). The behavior of socially living rhesus monkeys in their first two and a half years. Anim. Behav. 15, 169-196. Hoof, I. A. R. A. M., van (1972). A comparative approach to the phylogeny of laughter and smiling. In R. A. Hinde (Ed.), Non-verbal communication (pp. 209-2371, New York: Cambridge Univ. Press. Hrdy, S. B. (1976). Care and exploitation of nonhuman primate infants by conspecifics other than the mother. Adv. Study Behav. 6 , 101-158. Hrdy, S. B. (1977). The Langurs of Abu. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press. Hrdy, S. B., & Hrdy, D. B. (1977). Hierarchical relations among female Hanuinan langurs (Primates: Colobinue. Presbytis ente/lus). Science 193, 913-915. Humphreys, A. P., & Einon, D. F. (1981). Play as a reinforcer for maze-learning in juvenile rats. Anim. Behav. 29, 259-270. Itani, J . (1959). Paternal care in the wild Japanese monkey, Macacufuscutu fuscuta. Primates 2,6193. Janne, 0 . .Kontula, K . , Vihko, R . , Feil, P. D., & Bardin, C. W. (1978). Progesterone receptor and regulation of progestin action in mammalian tissues. Med. Biol. 56, 225-248. Jay, P. (1963). Mother-infant relation in langurs. In H. Rheingold (Ed.), Murernal behavior in mammals (pp. 282-304). New York: Wiley. Jensen, G. D. (1966). Sex differences in developmental trends of mother-infant monkey behavior ( M . nemestrina). Primates 7 , 403. Jensen, G . D., Bobbitt, R. A,, & Gordon, B. N. (1967). The development of maternal independence in mother-infant pigtailed monkeys, Macuca nemesrrina. In S. A. Altmann (Ed.), Social communication among primates (pp. 43-54). Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Jolly, A. (1972). The evolution ofprimate behavior. New York: Macmillan. Joslyn, W. D. (1973). Androgen-induced social dominance in infant female rhesus monkeys. J . Child Psychol. Psychiat. 14, 137- 145.
SOCIAL PLAY
53
Kawai, M. (1958). On the rank system in a natural group of Japanese monkeys: 1. Basic and dependent rank. Primates I , I 11-150. Kotelchuck. M. (1976). The infant's relationship to the father: Experimental evidence. In M. E. Lamb (Ed.), The role of the father in child development. New York: Wiley. Kummer, H. (1968). Social organizarion of hamudryus buboons: A ,field study. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Lahiri, R . K . , & Southwick, C. H. (1966). Parental care inMacam slvvuna. FoliaPrimurol. 4 , 257264. Lamb, M. E. (1977). Father-infant and mother-infant interaction in the first year of life. Child Dev. 48, 167-181. Lancaster, J. B. (1971 ). Play-mothering: The relations between juvenile females and young infants among free-ranging vervet monkeys (Cercopifhecus uethiops). Folia Primarol. 15, I61- 182. Lawick-Goodall, J . , van (1968). The behaviour of free-living chimpanzees in the Gonibe Stream area. Anim. Behav. Monogr. 1, 161-311. Lazar, J . W., & Beckhorn, G . C. (1974). Social play or the development of social behaviour in ferrets (Mustela putorious). Am. Zool. 14, 405-414. Lee, P. C., & Oliver. J. 1. (1979). Competition, dominance and the acquisition of rank in juvenile yellow baboons (Papio cytiocephalus). Anim. Behav. 27, 576-585. Leedy, M. G., Vela, E. A,, Popolow, H. B., & Gerall, A. A. (1980). Effects of prepubertal medial preoptic area lesions on male sexual behavior. Physiol. Behav. 24, 341 -346. Lehrman, D. S. (1953). A critique of Konrad Lorenz's theory of instinctive behavior. Q. Rev. Biol. 28, 337-363. Leshner, A. 1. (1975). A model of hormones and agonistic behavior. Physiol. Behav. 15, 225-235. Levine, J . , Fishman, C., & Kagan, J. (1967). Social class and sex as determinants of maternal behavior. Am. J . Orthnpsychiat. 37, 397. Ley, R. G . , & Koepke, J. E. (1982). Attachment behavior outdoors: Naturalistic observations of sex and age differences in the separation behavior of young children. Infant Behav. DPV.5 , 195201.
Lieberburg, 1.. MacLusky. N., & McEwen, B. S . (1980). Androgen receptors in perinatal rat brain. Brain Res. 196, 125-138. Lieberburg, I., MacLusky, N. J . , Roy, E. J . , & McEwen, B. S. (1978). Sex steroid receptors in the perinatal rat brain. Am. Zoo/. 18, 539-544. Loizos, C. (1967). Play behaviour in higher primates: A review. In D. Morris (Ed.). Primate erhologv (pp. 176-218). London: Wiedenfield & Nicolson. Lore, R., & Flannelly, W. (1977). Rat societies. Sci. Am. 236, 106-118. Loy, I . (1975). The descent of dominance in Mac.acut Insights into the structure of human societies. In R. N. Tuttle (Ed.), Socioecology andpsychologv ofprimates (pp, 153- 180). Paris: Mouton. MacRoberts, M. H. (1970). The social organization of the Barbary apes on Gilbraltar. Am. J . Phvs. Anthropol. 33, 83-99. Martini. L. (1978). Role of the metabolism of steroid hormones in the brain in sex differentiation and sexual maturation. In G. Dorner & M. Kawakarni (Eds.), Hormones and brain developmenf (pp. 3- 12). Amsterdam: Elsevier. Mason, W. A. (1961). The effects of social restriction on the behavior of rhesus monkeys: 111 dominance tests. J. Comp. Physiol. Psychol. 54, 694-699. Mason, W. A . (1965). The social development of monkeys and apes. In I. Devore (Ed.), Primare behavior: Field srudies of monkeys arid apes (pp. 514-543). New York: Holt. Mason, W. A., Hollis, J . H.. & Sharpe, L. G . (1962). Differential rehponses of chimpanzees to social stimulation, J. Comnp. Phvsiol. Psychol. 55, 1105-1 110. Mayer, A. D., Freeman, N . C. G . , & Rosenblatt, J. S . (1979). Ontogeny of maternal behaviour:
54
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
Factors underlying changes in responsiveness from thirty to ninety days. Uev. Psychobiol. 12, 425-439. Mayer, A. D., & Rosenblatt, J . S . (1979a). Ontogeny of maternal behaviour in the laboratory rat: Early origins in eighteen- to twenty-seven day old young. Dev. Psychobiol. 12, 407-424. Mayer, A. D., & Rosenblatt, J . S . (1979b). Hormonal influences during the ontogeny of female maternal behaviour in juvenile rats. J . Comp. Physiol. Psychol. 93, 879-898. Mayer, M., & Rosen, F. (1975). Interaction of anabolic steroids with glucocorticoid receptor sites in rat muscle cytosol. Am. J . Physiol. 229, 1381-1386. McClintock, M. K., & Adler, N. T. (1978). The role of the female during copulation in wild and domestic Norway rats (Rattus norvegicus). Behaviour 61, 67-96. McEwen B . S . (1977). Glucocorticoid receptors in neuroendocrine tissues. In V. H. T. James (Ed.), Endocrinology (Vol. 1). Amsterdam: Exerpta Medica. McEwen, B. S . , Lieberburg, I . , Chaptal, C., & Krey, L. C. (1977). Aromatization: Important for sexual differentiation of the neonatal rat brain. Horm. Behav. 9, 249-263. McGinnis, M. Y., Davis, P. G., Meaney, M. J . , Singer, M . , & McEwen, B. S . (1983). In vitro measurement of cytosol and cell nuclear androgen receptors in male rat brain and pituitary. Brain Res. 215, 75-82. Meaney, M. J . , Dodge. A. M., & Beatty, W. W. (1981). Sex dependent effects of amygdaloid lesions on the social play of prepubertal rats. Physiol. Behav. 26, 467-472. Meaney, M. J., & McEwen, B. S. (1984). Androgen implants into the amygdala during the neonutal period masculinize the play-fighting qfjemale rat pups. (Submitted) Meaney, M. J., McGinnis, M. Y., Aitken, D., & McEwen, B . S . (1984). Sexdiferences in nuclear androgen-receptor concentrations during the neonatal period in the rat brain. (Submitted) Meaney, M. J . , McGinnis, M. Y., & McEwen, B . S . (1982). The sexual differentiation of social play in Norway rat pups is mediated by the androgen receptor system. Soc. Neurosci. Abstr. 8, 611. Meaney, M. J . , Sapolsky, R. M., & McEwen, B . S . (1985). The development of the glucocorticoid receptor system. I : Ontogeny and autoregulation. Dev. Brain Res. (in press). Meaney, M. J., & Stewart, J. (1979). Environmental factors influencing the affiliative behavior of male and female rats (Raftusnorvegicus). Anim. Learn. Behav. 7 , 397-405. Meaney, M. J . , & Stewart, J . (1981a). A descriptive study of social development in the rat Rattus norvegicus. Anirn. Behav. 29, 34-45. Meaney, M. J., & Stewart, J . (1981b). Neonatal androgens influence the social play of prepubescent male and female rats. Horm. Behav. 15, 197-213. Meaney, M. J . , & Stewart, J . (1983). The influence of exogenous testosterone and corticosterone on the social behavior of prepubertal male rats. Bull. Psychonom. SOC. 21, 232-234. Meaney, M. I . . Stewart, J . , & Beatty, W. W. (1982). The effects of neonatal glucocorticoids on the social play of Juvenile rats. Horm. Behav. 16, 475-491. Meaney, M. J . , Stewart, J., Losos, E., & Ervin, F. ( 1 9 8 4 ~ )Infunt . carrying bv nulliparous, fernule vervet monkeys (Cercopirhecus aethiops). (Submitted) Meaney, M. J . , Stewart, J., Poulin, P., & McEwen, B . S. (1983). Sexual differentiation of social play in rat pups is mediated by the neonatal androgen-receptor system. Neuroendocrinolo~.~ 37, 85-90. Mech, L. D. (1970). The wolf? The eco1og.y and behaviour ofan endangered species. New York: Natural History Press. Milch, K. H., & Missakian-Quinn, L. E. (1977). Longitrmdinul studv of social play in peer-reared children. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Animal Behavior Society, University Park, Pennsylvania. Miller, R. E., Caul. W. F., & Mirsky. I . A. (1967). Communication of affects between feral and socially isolated monkeys. J . Personal. Soc. Psycho/. 7 , 23 1-239.
SOCIAL PLAY
55
Mitchell, G . D. (1968). Attachment differences in male and female infant monkeys. ChildDev. 39, 61 1-620. Mitchell, G . (1969). Paternalistic behavior in primates. Psychol. Bull. 71, 399-417. Mitchell, G . (1972). Looking behaviour in the rhesus monkey. J . Phenom. Psychol. 3, 53-67. Mitchell, G. ( 1979). Behavioral sex direrences in nonhuman primutes. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand Reinhold. Mitchell, G . D., Ruppenthal, G . C . , Raymond, E. J . , & Harlow, H. F. (1966). Long-term effects of multiparous and primiparous monkey mother rearing. Child Dev. 37, 781-791. Mohnot, S. M. ( 1978). Peripheralisation of weaned male juveniles in Presbvris entellus. Recenr Adv. Primatol. I , 87-92. Money, J., Ehrhardt, A. A , , & Masica, D. N. (1968). Fetal feminization induced by androgen insensitivity in the testicular feminizing syndrome: Effect on marriage and maternalism. Johns Hopkins Med. J . 123, 105- 114. Moore, C. L. (1981). An olfactory basis for maternal discrimination of sex of offspring in rats (Rattus norvegicus). Anim. Behav. 29, 383-386. Moore, C. L., & Morelli, G . L. (1979). Mother rats interact differently with male and female offspring. J . Comp. Phvsiol. Psychol. 93, 677-684. Moss. H. (1967). Sex, age and state as determinants of mother-infant interaction. Merrill-Palmer Q . 13, 19-36. Moss, H. (1974). Early sex differences and mother-infant interaction. In R. M. Richart & R. L. Van de Wiele (Eds.), Sex di@rences in behuvior (pp. 149-164). New York: Wiley. Munroe, R . L., & Munme, R. H. (1971). Effect ofenvironmental experience of spatial ability in an East African society. J . Soc. Psychol. 83, 15-22. Nadler, R. D., & Braggio, J . T. (1974). Sex and species differences in captive-reared juvenile chimpanzees and orangutans. J. Hum. Evol. 3, 541-550. Naess, D.,Haug. E., Attrramadal, A , , AaKvaag. A , , Hansson, V., & French, F. (1976). Androgen receptors in the anterior pituitary and central nervous system of the androgen “insensitive” (Tfni) rat: Correlation between receptor binding and effects of androgens on gonadotropin secretion. Endocrinology 99, 1295- 1303. Nerlove, S. B., Munroe, R. H., & Munroe, R. L. (1971). Effect of environmental experience on spatial ability: A replication. J . Soc. Psychol. 84, 3-10. Nicolson. N. A. (1977). A comparison of early behavioral development in wild and captive chimpanzees. In S. Chevalier-Skilnikoff & F. E. Poirier (Eds.), Primure bi(~-sociddevelopment (pp. 529-562). New York: Garland. Nishizuka, M., & Arai, Y. (1981). Sexual dimorphism in synaptic organization in the aniygdala and its dependence on neonatal hormonal environment. Bruin Res. 212, 31-38. Olioff, M., & Stewart, J. (1978). Sex differences in the play behavior of preubescent rats. Physiol. Behuv. 20, 113-115. Owens, N. W. (l975a). Social play behaviour in free-living baboons, Papio anubis. Anim. Behuv. 23, 387-408. Owens, N. W. (1975b). A comparison of aggressive play and aggression in free-living baboons, Papio unubis. Anim. Behav. 23, 575-165. Packer, C. (1975). Male transfer in olive baboons. Nulure (London) 255, 219-220. Packer, C. (1977). Reciprocal altruism in Papio anuhis. Naritre (London) 265, 441-443. Packer, C. (1978). Behavior affecting immigration of male baboons at Gombe National Park. Recent Adv. Primatol. 1, 75-78. Parke, R. D., & Suomi, S . J. (1981). Adult male infant relationships: Human and nonhuman primate evidence. In K. Immelman, G . W. Barlow. L. Petrinovitch, & M. Main (Eds.), Behaviorul devc,lopmerzr (pp. 700-725). New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
56
MICHAEL J . MEANEY ET AL.
Payne, A. P., & Swanson, H. H. (1972). The effcct of sex hormones on the aggressive behavior of the female golden hamster (Mesocricerus aratus watcrhousc). Anim. Brhuv. 20, 782-787. Phoenix, C. H., Goy, R. W., Gerall, A. A , , & Young, W. C. (1959). Organizational action of prenatally administered testosterone propionate on the tissues mediating behavior in the female guinea pig. Enducrinologv 65, 369-382. Poirier, F. E. (1972). Nilgiri langur behavior and social organization. In F. W. Voget & R . L. Stephenson (Eds.), For the chief: Essuys in honor of Luther S . Cressman (pp. 119-134). Eugene, Oregon: Univ. of Orcgon Anthropology Papers. Poole. T. B. (1966). Aggressive play in polecats. Symp. 2001.Sue. London 18, 23-44. Poole, T. B., & Fish, J . (1976). An investigation of individual, age, and sexual diffcrences in the play of Rattus norvegicus (Murnmaliu: Rodenria). Pruc. Zool. Soc. London 179, 249-260. Pusey. A. (1978). Age changes in the mother-offspring association of wild chimpanzees. Recent Adv. Primutol. I , 119-124. Rabb, G. B., Ginsburg, B. E., & Andrews, S . (1962). Comparative studies of Canid behavior, IV. Mating behavior in relation to social structure in wolves. Am. Zool. 2, 440. Rabb, C. B., Woolpy, J . H., & Ginsburg, B. E. (1967). Social relationships in a group of captive wolves. Am. Zool. 7, 305-31 I . Raleigh, M. J . , Flannery, I. W., & Ervin, F. R. (1979). Sex differences in behavior among juvenile vervet monkeys (Cercopithecus aethicips sabncus). Behav. Neural Biol. 26, 455-465. Rebelsky, F., & Hanks, C. (1971). Father’s verbal interactions with infants in the first three months of life. Child Dev. 42, 63-68. Redican, W. K. (1976). Adult male-infant interactions in non-human primates. In M. E. Lamb (Ed.), The role of the father in child development. New York: Wiley. Redican, W. K., & Mitchell, G. (1974). Play between adult male and female rhesus monkeys. Am. ZOO^. 14, 295-302. Resko, J . A . , Feder, H. H., &Goy, R. W. (1968). Androgen concentrations in plasma and tcstes of developing rats. J . Endrocinol. 40, 485-49 I . Rose, R. M., Gordon, T. P., & Bernstein, 1. S. (1972). Plasma testosterone levels in male rhesus: Influences of social and sexual stimuli. Science 178, 643-645. Rosenblum, L. A. (1974). Sex differences in mother-infant attachment in monkeys. In R. C. Friedman, R . M. Richart, & R. L. Van de Wiele (Eds.), Sexdiflerences in behavior New York: Wiley. Rosenblum, L. A . (1974). Sex differences, environmental complexity, and mother-infant relations. Arch. Sex Behuv. 3, 117-128. Rossi, A. S. (1977). A biosocial perspective on parenting. Duedalus 106, 1-31. Rowell, T. E. (1966). Hierarchy in the organization of a captive baboon group. Anim. Behav. 14, 430-443. Rowell, T. E., Din, N. A,, & Omar, A. (1968). The social development of baboons in their first three months. J . Zool. 155, 461-483. Ruppenthal, G. C., Harlow, M. K . , Eisele, C. D., Harlow, H. F., & Suomi, S. J . (1974). Development of peer interactions of monkeys reared in a nuclear family environment. Child Dev. 45, 670-682. Ryon, C. J . (1979). Aspects of dominance behavior in groups of sibling coyoteired wolf hybrids. Behav. Neural Biol. 24, 69-78. Sachs, B. D., & Harris, V. S. (1978). Sex differences and developmental changes in selected juvenile activities (play) of domestic lambs. Anim. Behav. 26, 678-684. Sackett, G. P. (1974). Sex differences in rhesus monkeys following varied rearing experiences. In R. C. Friedman, R. M. Riehart, & R. L. Van de Wiele (Eds.), Sex differences in behavior (pp. 99112). New York: Wiley. Sade, D. S . (1967). Determinants of dominance in a group of free-ranging rhesus monkeys. In S. A.
SOCIAL PLAY
57
Altmann (Ed.), Social conimrrnicution among primates (pp. 99-1 14). Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Sade, D. S. (1967). Determinants of dominance in a group of free-ranging rhesus monkeys. In S . A. Altmann (Ed.). Social communication among primutes (pp. 99-1 14). Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Sade, D. S . (1980). Population biology of free-ranging rhesus monkeys on Cayo Santiago, Puerto Rico. In M. N. Cohen, R. S. Malpass, & H. G. Klein (Eds.), Biosociul mechunisms of’ populution regulation (pp. 171-188). New Haven, Conn.: Yale Univ. Press. Sasson, S., & Mayer, M. (1981). Antiglucocorticoid activity of androgens in rat thymus lymphocytes. Endocrinologv 108, 760-766. Schaller, G. B. (1972). The Serengeti lion: A stud,v of predutor-prev relations. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Scott, J. P., & Fuller, J. L. (1965). Genetics and soc.ial behavior ofthe dog. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. Seay, B. M., Schlottman, R . S., & Gandolfo, R. (1972). Early social interaction in two monkey species. .I. Genet. Psychol. 87, 37-43. Seyfarth, R. M., Cheney, D. L., & Hinde, R. A. (1978). Some principles relating social interactions and social structure among primates. Recent Adv. Primutol. 1, 39-54. Shapiro, B. H., Goldman. A. S . , Bongiovanni, A . M., & Marino, J. M. (1976). Neonatal progesterone and feminine sexual development. Nature (London)264, 795-796. Simonds, P. E. (1974). Sex differences in bonnet macaque networks and social structure. Arch. Sex Behuv. 3, 151-165. Simonds, P. E. (1977). Peers, parents and primates: The developing network of attachments. In T. Alloway, P. Pliner & L. Krames (Eds.), Attachment behavior: Advances in the studv of communication and aflect (Vol. 3, pp. 145-176). New York: Plenum. Staudt, J . , & Dorner, G. (1976). Structural changes in the medial and central amygdala of the male rat following neonatal castration and androgen treatment. Endokrinologie 67, 296-300. Struhsaker, T. (1967). Social structure among vervet monkeys, Cercopirhecus aethoips. Behaviour 29, 83-121. Suomi, S. J. (1977). Development of attachment and other social behaviors in rhesus monkeys. In T. Alloway, P. Pliner & L. Krames (Eds.), Aftachmerrt behavior: Advances in the study of communication and aflect (Vol. 3, pp. 197-224). New York: Plenum. Suomi, S . J., & Harlow, H . F. (1976). Monkeys without play. In J . S . Bruner, A. Jolly, & K. Sylva (Eds.), Play (pp. 490-495). New York: Penguin. Symons, D. (1974). Aggressive play and communication in rhesus monkeys (Macacu mulatfa).Am. 2001. 14, 317-322. Symons, D. (1978). Pluv and aggression: A s1ud.v of rhesus monkeys. New York: Columbia Univ. Press. Tasch, R. J . (1952). The role of the father in the family. J . Exp. Educ. 20, 319-361. Taylor, G. T. (1980). Fighting in juvenile rats and the ontogeny of agonistic behavior. J . Comp. Physiol. P.y.ycho1. 94, 953-961. Thoman. E. B., Leiderman, P. H., & Olson, J. P. (1972). Neonate-mother interaction during breast feeding. Dev. Psychol. 6 , 110- 118. Thor, D. H., & Holloway, W. R. (1983). Play-solicitation behavior in juvenile male and female rats. Anim. Learn. Behuv. 11, 173-178. Timney, B. N., Emerson, V. F., & Dodwell, P. S. (1979). Development of visual stimulus-seeking in kittens. Q . J . Exp. Psycho/. 31, 63-81. Toran-Allerand, C. D. (1976). Sex steroids and the development of the newborn mouse hypothalamus and preoptic area in vitro: Implications for sexual differentiation. Bruin Res. 106, 407-4 12.
58
MICHAEL J. MEANEY ET A L .
Traylor, K . L. ( 1982). Social interactions a r n o n ~cuptiw ,cvlves (Cariis lupus). Unpublished MA thesis, North Dakota State University. Vito, C. C., Wieland, S. J., & Fox, T. P. (1979). Androgen receptors exist throughout the ‘critical period’ of brain sexual differentiation. Nature (London) 282, 308-3 10. Weichsel, M. E. (1974). Glucocorticoid effect upon thymidine kinase in the developing cerebellum. Pediatr. Res. 8, 843-847. Weisbard, C., & Goy, R. W. (1976). Effects of parturition and group composition on competitive drinking order in stumptail macaques (Mucaca arctoidrs). Folia Prirnurol. 25, 95-121. Weisz, I., & Ward, I . L. (1979). Plasma testosterone and progesterone titers of pregnant rats, their male and female fetuses. and neonatal offspring. Endocrinology 106, 306-3 16. White, L. E., & Hinde, R . A . (1975). Some factors influencing mother-infant relations in rhesus monkeys. Anirn. Brhav. 23, 527-542. Whiting, B . , and Edwards, C. P. (1973). A cross-cultural analysis of sex differences in the behavior of children aged three to eleven. J . Soc. Psvchol. 91, 171-188. Whiting, B. B., & Whiting, J . W. M. (1974). Childrcw q f s i x culrures: A psvchoculturul unalysis. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press. Wolff, P. H. (1966). The causes, controls. and organization of behavior in the neonate. Psycho/. Issues 5 , Monogr. 17. Wolfheim, J. H . (1977). Sex differences in behavior in a group of captive juvenile talapoin monkeys (Miopirhrcus takapoiti). Brhavinur 63, 1 10- 128. Yaniada, M. (1963). A study of blood relationships in the natural society of the Japanese monkey. Primates 4, 43-65.
ADVANCES IN THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR. VOL I S
On the Functions of Play and Its Role in Behavioral Development PAULMARTINAND T. M . CARO SUB-DEPARTMENT OF ANIMAL BEHAVIOUR UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE CAMBRIDGE, ENGLAND
I.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Defining P l a y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Existing Evidence Concerning the Functions of Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Experimental Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Correlational Studies.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Optimal Design Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ......... D. Human Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......................... IV. Play May Have No Major Benefits A. The Costs and Benefits of P l a y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . The Lability of Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Adult Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Theoretical Problems in Detecting the Benefits of Play . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Short-Term versus Long-Term Effects of P l a y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Equifinality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Nonequivalence.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Nonspecificity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Threshold Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Interactions between Developmental Determinants. . . . . VI. Methodological Issucs . . . . . . . . . . . . .................... A. Confounding Variables. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Choosing Outcome Variables. . . . . . ...................... VII. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............................................. 11.
I.
59 61 66 67 69 72 75 78
85 85 88 91
95 97 98
INTRODUCTION
The biological functions and evolutionary origins of animal play behavior are issues which generate considerable debate, yet both remain shrouded in uncertainty (for recent general reviews, see Bekoff & Byers, 1981; Fagen, 1981; Smith, 1982). In this respect play is not unique among behavioral research topics. Play does, however, merit particular attention for at least two reasons. 59
Copyright
ti,
I Y X S b) Acadcniic. Pre\\. Inr 111 m) li,rni rwcrvcd ISBN 0-12-OOJ515-X
All nghh 01 repriiductiiin
60
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M. C A R 0
First, play is predominantly a characteristic of young, developing animals rather than of adults and is widely believed to have an important role in the assembly of adult behavior. Thus, play may be of particular relevance to understanding some of the processes of mammalian behavioral development. Second, play holds a particular fascination for those interested in the biological functions of behavior patterns, that is, in answering the question, “What is it for?” Quite simply, the functions of play behavior are not known. Biologists generally assume that for a behavior pattern to have evolved and be maintained by natural selection, it must have biological benefits which, on average, outweigh its costs. Speculation as to the possible function’ of play behavior has been wide-ranging and inventive. One review (Baldwin & Baldwin, 1977) lists 30 functions that have variously been ascribed to play. Although there exists a wealth of descriptive information about play, there have, unfortunately, been very few direct empirical tests of any functional hypothesis. Furthermore, as we shall argue here, the experiments that have been carried out have generally failed to support any of the hypotheses. Thus, the contributions which play presumably makes to an individual’s survival and reproduction remain at present the subject of guesswork and speculation. It is our goal to review the limited empirical evidence concerning the functions of play and to suggest some possible reasons, both theoretical and methodologi‘Some confusion surrounds the termfunction as it is variously used by biologists and psychologists (Hinde, 1975, 1982; Clutton-Brock, 1981; Lewin, 1982). By function, we mean the particular consequences of a behavior pattern which currently increase the individual’s chances of survival and reproduction in the natural environment and upon which natural selection acts to maintain that behavior pattern. Not all consequences of a behavior pattern constitute functions sensu srricto. For example, one consequence of incubating an egg is that the egg shell becomes warm and expands slightly, but it would be misleading to regard this as afunction of incubation (Tinbergen, cited by Hinde, 1982, p.102). It is often extremely difficult to distinguish between a function (sensu stricto) and an incidental benefit of a behavior pattern. The distinction frequently relies on little more than plausibility. Thus, in this article we generally refer to the benefits or beneficial effects of play, although the implication is that beneficial effects of major importance, and for which play has the appropriate structural characteristics or “design features,” are likely to constitute its functions (sensu stricro). Since selection may act on more than one consequence of a behavior pattern and all behavior patterns have multiple consequences. A separate point is that selection may currently be acting on different consequences from those for which the behavior pattern was originally selected. In other words, its function(s) may have changed during the course of evolutionary history. Could and Vrba (1982) have proposed the term exuptation (in contradistinction to adaptation) for any phenotypic character which did not originally evolve through natural selection for its current role, but which has subsequently been “co-opted” and now helps to maximize inclusive fitness in a new manner. As Could and Vrba point out, it is crucial that we distinguish the current utility (function) of a phenotypic character from its historical genesis (evolution) (see also Lewin, 1982; Caro, 1984). Thus, for example, play behavior in the higher primates might originally have evolved because of one set of beneficial effects-say , the physical exercise effect-but is currently maintained by selection for a different set of benefits-say, the acquisition of complex social or cognitive skills. Benefits of play in this article refer only to current utility and not to historical origin.
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
61
cal, why evidence in support of functional hypotheses has not been forthcoming. In addition, we shall describe certain assumptions about play which pervade the biological literature, for example, that early play experience is crucial for normal development and that play is a very “costly” activity and so must have major benefits. We shall argue that these assumptions are mostly without empirical support and reflect an underlying (and usually unstated) view of behavioral development that is highly questionable. First, though, we shall address the question of what is actually meant by the term play. Confusion about the definition of play reflects an even greater confusion in the way play is thought about. As such, the issue of definition needs to be tackled. Criticisms of current explanations of play are presented here in a constructive spirit, in the hope that they will provoke further enquiry and not in an attempt to relegate play to the status of a wastebasket category or to treat it as a functionless epiphenomenon. Play remains a biological enigma which demands closer scrutiny.
11.
DEFINING PLAY
Attempting to define play-once a popular pastime engendering much heated debate-has become unfashionable, despite a marked failure to reach any consensus. Many biologists, including Lorenz (1956), Hinde (1970, 1974), and E. 0. Wilson (1975), have repeatedly pointed to the immense problems surrounding the notion of play. Yet most contemporary workers shun the issue of definition, taking the pragmatic line that it is possible to study play empirically without a satisfactory definition (e.g., Gentry, 1974; Byers, 1977; Chalmers, 1980). There is certainly some sense in the attitude that semantic quibbling alone will not advance our understanding of behavior, and the present authors agree with Kenneth Craik’s (1943) assertion that “the final road to progress will lie not in the search for analytical exactitude in verbal definition but in the self-validatory procedure of experiment and hypothesis. Nonetheless, confusion over the meaning of the term play is so profound that the problem should not be dismissed merely because semantic issues are unfashionable. A definition is, after all, a distillation of current understanding, so an inability to define play must cast considerable doubt on the degree to which it is understood. Because of this, we shall briefly describe some of the problems surrounding the definition of play and propose a definition which we believe reflects current understanding. Failing to define play has often led to its being applied in such a broad sense as to be meaningless. The word play is frequently used, with no further clarification, as a blanket term to describe a wide range of juvenile behavior, as though its meaning were self-evident. Indeed, the term is sometimes used so loosely that ”
62
PAUL MARTIN A N D T. M . C A R 0
it would appear as though play is the on/y thing that young mammals do. As such, it is hardly surprising that play has become the sine qua non of mammalian behavioral development as far as some writers are concerned and that statements to the effect that play is essential for normal development abound in the literature.2 Clearly, if play is to have any practical use as a behavioral category, its meaning must be restricted to something more specific than “all juvenile behavior.” One factor contributing to the emphasis on the importance of play has undoubtedly been the widespread tendency to confound play-in some restricted sense-with other forms of early experience. Certain general properties of play behavior are widely recognized, for example, the use of motor patterns from several serious functional contexts; exaggeration and repetition of motor acts; and the reordering of behavioral sequences (Loizos, 1967; Hinde, 1970; Fagen, 1981; Bekoff, 1984). In addition, many other criteria-functional, structural, and motivational-have variously been used to typify play: for example, play is “fun”; play occurs only when all basic needs are satisfied and the animal is “relaxed”; sequences of motor acts are incomplete and fragmented; role reversal and self-handicapping occur; and specific “play signals” are present (Loizos, 1967; Bekoff, 1976b; Bekoff & Byers, 1981; see Fagen, 1981, Ch. 2). However, no single characteristic from this list is either necessary or sufficient to define play, so play is polythetically defined. That is, a large proportion of these characteristic properties may be shared by various examples of play, but no single property defines the class “play” (Sokal, 1974). Furthermore, it is uncertain whether play actually has these proposed characteristic properties in many cases. In their study of coyotes, for example, Hill and Bekoff (1977) found that motor acts were actually less exaggerated (in terms of duration) and more stereotyped when performed during social play than during serious agonistic encounters. Henry and Herrero (1974) similarly found little evidence for exaggeration of movements in the social play of bear cubs. There is, however, considerable evidence that play is a spontaneous and rewarding activity with its own motivation and that it does not result merely from the absence of motivation to perform other behavior patterns (e.g., Humphreys & Einon, 1981; Martin & Bateson, 1985; Rasa, 1984). 2We shall give only two examples, referring to the importance of play in human development. Fagen (1981, p. viii) quotes the following statement from the First National Conference on the Vital Role of Play in Learning, Development, and Survival, held in Washington, DC in 1979: “Play is vital to the healthy development of all so-called higher animals. Play is a biological imperative. Play heals, naturally and as a tool in psychotherapy with children. Play for your life: the stakes are survival.” A less lurid example is the following passage from a British government document. cited by Smith (1982): “The realisation that play is essential to development has slowly but surely permeated our educational system and cultural heritage.” Both passages, though overstatements given the paucity of our current knowledge about play, do represent a widely held opinion about the importance of play, for which biological research is often cited as support.
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
63
Most definitions of play can themselves be classified as either functional or structural in nature: the former being concerned with the consequences of play, the latter with its physical form and appearance (Fagen, 1974). Definitions based specifically on function are not possible at present because the functions of play are not known. Play is not a general class of behavior that can readily be defined by some obvious consequence in the way that, for example, aggression, communication, mating, or feeding behavior can be distinguished. Equally, as Bekoff and Byers (198 1) and others have pointed out, definitions of play based solely on its structure are invariably weak because of the immense diversity of motor patterns that are commonly classified as play in various species (see also Bekoff, 1984). Even when discussion is restricted to a single species, a purely structural definition is inadequate if (as is generally the case) it fails to distinguish playful motor patterns from the same motor patterns performed seriously (that is, with their normal functional consequences). This is a distinction which observers can, in practice, usually recognize. Many empirical papers that describe play in a particular species simply list a variety of structurally defined motor patterns under the rubric play but give no explanation as to why these particular motor patterns were called play in the first place (e.g., West, 1974; Gard & Meier, 1977; Guyot, Bennett, & Cross, 1980; Bateson, Martin, & Young, 1981; Davies & Kemble, 1983). In some cases, playful and serious behavior can be given the same structural definitions. For example, children’s rough-and-tumble play draws on the same repertoire of motor patterns as serious aggressive fighting-yet the two can readily be distinguished in young children (Humphreys & Smith, 1984). In an account of social and predatory behavior in cats, Car0 ( 1979) defined several motor patterns in terms of their structure and referred to these as predatory behavior when they were directed in an apparently serious manner at prey. When directed at other cats, though, the same motor patterns were called play, without further explanation. In their study of coyotes, Vincent and Bekoff (1978) also used the same structural definitions for prey-killing actions which occurred both during play and during agonistic interactions. Schaller (1972, p. 165) similarly comments that the predatory behavior and the play of lions are indistinguishable in terms of the motor patterns involved. The point here is that predatory behavior is readily distinguished by its obvious consequences-catching and killing prey-even when these are not explicitly stated. No such obvious consequences distinguish play, however. In fact, the unstated hallmark of play in these examples (and, we suspect, in most other cases) is its very luck of obvious consequences. In other words, the motor patterns were called play because they did not result in the usual consequences of biting injuriously or killing. It is rare for play to be defined explicitly in terms of its consequences or lack of consequences. Some empirical papers include an admission that the standard
64
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M. C A R 0
structural definitions are not in themselves wholly adequate. For example, Barrett and Bateson (1978) defined several categories of play behavior in terms of the structure of the constituent motor acts, using the criteria suggested by Loizos (1967), but they added that “to a large extent we had to rely on contextual cues.” An exception to this rule was Biben’s (1979) criterion for distinguishing when cats were playing with prey. Behavior was classified as play when prey was actively approached or manipulated, but not injured. Play was, therefore, explicitly contrasted with the same motor patterns performed seriously (predation) and defined by its lack of functional consequences. Finally, some definitions of play, whether functional or structural, can be dismissed immediately because they are recursive, that is, the thing to be defined (play) is itself used in the definition. Some definitions of play, regrettably, boil down to little more than statements that “play is playful behavior.” Despite these problems with defining play, humans clearly can and do recognize when an animal is playing. Moreover, there is usually a reasonably high level of agreement between different observers about when play is occurring (e.g., Caro, Roper, Young, & Dank, 1979; Guyot et al., 1980; Rasa, 1984; see Fagen, 1981, p. 5 1). It would obviously be foolish to deny the existence of play simply because it cannot be defined. Yet what is it that enables an observer to be confident that an animal is playing? It cannot be just the structural characteristics of the motor acts because the same motor patterns may also be called “serious” behavior. Rather, the distinguishing feature of play seems to be the subjective sense on the part of the observer that the behavior lacks any obvious purpose or immediate benefit (see Schlosberg, 1947; Hinde, 1970; Symons, 1978; Bekoff & Byers, 1981; Smith, 1982). Perhaps one reason why the most obvious characteristic of play-its apparent lack of purpose-is often ignored is that it appears to generate a paradox. On the one hand, motor patterns are called play because they appear to have no obvious purpose or immediate benefits. On the other hand, biologists assume that animals do not do something unless (on average) the overall benefits of this behavior exceed its costs. Hence, there is a superficial contradiction between the notion that play has no obvious benefits (otherwise it would not be called play) and the evolutionary logic which requires that play must have benefits which exceed its costs. This apparent paradox is made to seem more compelling if it is also assumed that the costs of play (and therefore its benefits) must be very large-an assumption that is widespread, but, as we shall argue later, probably wrong. One way of reconciling these apparently contradictory statements is to assert that play does have benefits but that these are delayed in ontogeny and accrue to the adult. The notion of delayed benefits is central to all functional theories which see play as a form of training and may explain their popularity. Yet the contradiction between the axiom that play has benefits which exceed its costs and the notion that play has no obvious benefits vanishes if two points are recognized. First,
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
65
play may not have large costs and so may have only small benefits. Second, the notion that play has no obvious benefits involves a subjective interpretation on the part of the observer; in other words, the emphasis should be on the word obvious rather than on the word no. Our suggestion is, then, that play has a variety of benefits-some or all of which might be immediate-but that these benefits may be small and so not easily detectable. Thus, play appears to an observer to be without any obvious benefits or purpose, in specific contrast to “serious” behavior, whose consequences are obvious. This view is incorporated in the following definition, which is a modified version of the definition proposed by Bekoff and Byers ( 198I): Play is all locomotor activity performed postnatally that uppeurs to an observer to have no obvious immediate benefits for the player, in which motor patterns resembling those used in serious functional contexts may be used in modified forms. The motor acts constituting play have some or all of the following structural features: exaggeration of movements, repetition of motor acts, and fragmentation or disordering of sequences of motor acts. Social play refers to play directed at conspecifics; object play refers to play directed at inanimate objects: locomotor play refers to apparently spontaneous movements which carry the individual about its environment; and predatory play refers to play directed toward living or dead prey.
A final point concerns the possible heterogeneity of the category “play.” It seems increasingly likely that in many cases play will prove to be heterogeneous in terms of its evolution, function, development, and proximate causation. Thus, it may be misleading to refer to play as though it were a single, unitary phenomenon. Play may have more than one function in a particular species, for example, and different aspects of play (such as social, object, and locomotor play) may have separate motivations, different developmental courses, and different evolutionary origins. For example, Barrett and Bateson (1978) found that the play of domestic kittens changes markedly around the end of weaning, when social play starts to decline and object play increases sharply. Correlations between different measures of play also break down at the end of the weaning period. Moreover, some aspects of social play, such as pawing and biting, become increasingly associated with predatory behavior in older kittens, whereas other aspects, such as arching and chasing, become dissociated from predatory measures (Caro, 1981 ) . One suggestion here is that play becomes differentiated at around the end of weaning, with different aspects of play coming under the control of different types of serious behavior such as predation and intraspecific aggression. It is widely reported that rough-and-tumble social play in humans and other species becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish from genuine aggression later in ontogeny (e.g., Aldis, 1975; Caro, 1981; Humphreys & Smith, 1984; Martin, 1984a). Cluster analysis indicates that in rhesus macaques, social play is actually
66
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M. C A R 0
composed of at least five temporally distinct types of behavior (Smith & Fraser, 1978). Chalmers (1980) has also suggested that the play of olive baboons can be dissociated into at least two distinct components, each with its own underlying control mechanisms. In conclusion, although empirical evidence for the heterogeneity of play at various levels (function, evolution, causation, and development) is limited, the issue is certainly worth considering.
EVIDENCE CONCERNING THEFUNCTIONS OF PLAY 111. EXISTING Many different hypotheses have been advanced concerning the biological functions of play in different species, including the provision of physical exercise (Brownlee, 1954; Fagen, 1976), various aspects of socialization and the acquisition of social skills (Dolhinow & Bishop, 1970; Poirier & Smith, 1974), and even the learning of mothering skills (Lancaster, 1971). Bekoff and Byers (1981) have distilled the many hypotheses into three main classes: play as motor training, play as socialization, and play as cognitive or sensorimotor training. All have in common the notion that, as a result of playing when young, the individual is better able to perform some form of serious behavior later in ontogeny. In essence, play is seen as a specific developmental determinant (Bateson, 1976a) of adult behavior. For example, it is commonly held that the principal function of play in young carnivores is to develop adult predatory abilities (e.g., Egan, 1976; Leyhausen, 1979; Moelk, 1979; see Martin, 1984a). This can be tested empirically by investigating the relations between early play experience and the relevant serious behavior patterns (in this case, predatory skills) later in ontogeny. We shall refer to the serious behavior patterns, of which play is thought to be a developmental determinant, as the “outcome variables” in any test of a functional hypothesis. Three major lines of approach have been taken in empirical studies of play (see Byers, 1977; Chalmers & Locke-Haydon, 1984): ( I ) experimental manipulation of early play experience; for example, to give fewer or more opportunities for particular types of play; (2) searching for correlations between play and other forms of behavior, exploiting natural variation within populations; and (3) using the indirect “argument from design” approach, in which the observed structure of play is matched against the requirements of its hypothesized function (“Can it do the job?”). We shall refer to these three approaches as experimental, correlational, and optimal design studies. Clearly, evidence from experimental studies is generally more compelling than that from correlational or optimal design studies. We shall also distinguish between two levels of evidence:(l) studies in which a particular hypothesis was explicitly stated and where the evidence could have refuted the hypothesis (the criterion of falsifiability); and (2) studies in which indirect or circumstantial evidence that is relevant to a particular hypoth-
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
67
esis is obtained but cannot conclusively refute the hypothesis or enable the investigators to choose between alternative hypotheses. Most evidence in the current play literature is, unfortunately, in the second category, although we shall concentrate here on the first. A.
EXPERIMENTAL STUDIES
Possibly the earliest experimental test of a play hypothesis was that of Thomas and Schaller (1954), who used the “Kaspar Hauser” isolation-rearing technique with domestic cats. The hypothesis was that play in cats serves as practice for prey-catching motor patterns. Kittens were raised from birth under conditions of both social isolation and visual deprivation (they were either fitted with translucent goggles or raised in a visually barren enclosure). The deprived cats therefore lacked, among many other things, the opportunities for both social play and visually guided object play throughout their early development. The Kaspar Hauser cats and their normally reared siblings were compared, when 1 1 weeks old, on the basis of their ability to exhibit the species-typical prey-catching movements, as elicited by a moving dummy mouse. Thomas and Schaller reported that the isolation-reared cats exhibited the typical prey-catching movements-fixating; lying in wait; jumping at, biting, and clasping the dummy-in the same way as their normally reared siblings. However, the account was without detail and no quantitative evidence was provided in support of this statement. Clearly, an anecdotal report based on a crude deprivation experiment must be treated with considerable caution. It is likely that the Kaspar Hauser cats would, if tested, have exhibited numerous subtle differences in behavior, and it remains uncertain whether they could have used the typical prey-catching movements in the correct context and sequence and with the same degree of skill as normally reared cats. We can, however, conclude that play experience during the first I 1 weeks of life is not necessury for the development of at least the basic prey-catching movements in cats. In an unpublished study, Hopf (1972, cited by Baldwin & Baldwin, 1974) also reported that social play is not essential for “normal development” in squirrel monkeys. Infants raised in laboratory environments without peers showed “no marked differences” from animals raised with peers. These results are in line with a general finding that most of the basic motor patterns forming an animal’s behavioral repertoire can develop normally in social isolates (Marler, 1975). Play may not be necessary for the rudiments of normal behavior to develop, but it might nonetheless improve those skills which are already developing. Such is the tenor of most modern functional theories of play. The issue of whether object play experience quantitatively improves adult predatory skills in domestic cats has been addressed in one experimental study (Caro, 1980a). Eleven kittens between 4 and I2 weeks after birth were repeatedly given the opportunity to play
68
PAUL MARTIN A N D T. M . C A R 0
with toys. Kittens were given a total of 34 exposures to the toys, each lasting 30 or 40 min. These object-playing (OP) kittens were reared with their mothers and littermates and so had unlimited opportunities for social play. Eight control ( C ) kittens were also reared with their mothers and littermates but never received any opportunities for object play with toys. All the kittens were individually tested, when they were 6 months old, on their ability to catch and kill four different types of live prey. A fine-grained analysis of the cats’ predatory behavior was used: 13 different categories of predatory motor patterns (Caro, 1979) were recorded, from which 25 different frequency and latency measures were derived. Car0 compared the OP kittens with the controls on each of the 25 predatory measures for each of the four prey types. Of the 100 comparisons made between the OP and C kittens, only five were significantly different, that is, no more than would be expected by chance. Moreover, these few differences were not clustered in any meaningful way and were not consistent across prey type. Object play did not appear to make any quantitative difference to the development of adult predation. Caro (1980a) has discussed some of the many possible reasons why no relation was found between prey-catching behavior and play in this experiment (see also Martin, 1984a). For example, both groups had opportunities for social play and this may have compensated for the lack of object play; both groups had opportunities for locomotor play; the control cats may have had some object play experience with wood shavings or other unintended toys in their home pen; kittens may need only a minimal amount of object play experience to become competent predators and the controls may already have attained this level; the tests used to assess prey-catching skills may not have been sufficiently sensitive or demanding; inappropriate measures of predatory skill may have been used; the OP kittens may have received too little object play experience or the wrong type of toys for any improvement in their predatory skills to have occurred. However, the most reasonable interpretation of Caro’s results is that playing with objects when young does not significantly affect a cat’s ability to catch and dispatch prey when adult. The third experimental study we shall describe (Einon, Morgan, & Kibbler, 1978) did find evidence for some differences between animals whose previous play opportunities had differed. However, its results are somewhat difficult to interpret for our present purpose since the study was not aimed at testing a particular functional hypothesis about play. Rats raised in social isolation subsequently behave differently in many respects compared with those raised socially (e.g., Einon & Morgan, 1977). In open-field tests of behavior, for example, their locomotor activity and rate of object contact are slower to habituate. Partial isolate (PI) rats, which are allowed 1 hour of social contact per day, are intermediate in their behavior between socially reared rats and those raised in complete isolation. Einon et al. (1978)
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
69
used drugged social play-partners, which had been injected with chlorpromazine or amphetamine, in order to manipulate the quality of social play experienced by PI rats. When subsequently tested in the open field, PI rats which had interacted with drugged rats behaved more like complete isolates than those which had played with undrugged partners. In other words, the qualiry of social interaction was important as far as later differences in behavior were concerned. Of course, the drugged partners were presumably different in many respects, as Einon et a1. point out, so more than just social play experience was altered for the experimental rats. Nonetheless, this study does offer strong (though not conclusive) evidence for some relations between early social play experience and later behavior. Unfortunately, the use of open-field outcome measures makes it difficult to relate these results to most conventional hypotheses about the functions of play, except the behavioral flexibility hypothesis (Einon et al., 1978; Fagen, 1982; see Section V1,B).
B.
CORRELATIONAL STUDIES
The possible connection between play and behavioral skills has also been investigated in three correlational studies (Vincent & Bekoff, 1978; Davies & Kemble, 1983; Chalmers & Locke-Haydon, 19841, all of which failed to find any strong relation between the two. In a study of coyotes, Vincent and Bekoff (1978) recorded the frequency of social play patterns directed toward littermates by each of the four pups from a single litter. Play was observed between 20 and 34 days after birth. Shortly after this (35-45 days after birth), the predatory ability of each pup was assessed by giving it ten 10-min trials, during each of which a live adult mouse was presented. Predatory success was measured as the percentage of trials in which the prey was killed. Vincent and Bekoff found no correlation between the frequency of play behavior and subsequent predatory success: the pup which had played most was not the most successful predator. Although consistent with Caro’s (1980a) findings, the results of this study are far from conclusive for a number of reasons. The sample size (four pups) was very small, and significant correlations might well have emerged if more animals had been studied. Clearly, it is wrong to place much weight on a negative finding unless the test was adequate to find an effect. Second, a correlational approach was used which exploited natural variation in the independent variable (play), so there is a possibility that other factors might also have been involved. Third, the outcome variable (percentage success in killing prey) was a relatively crude measure of predatory skill and was unlikely to have picked up any subtle differences in the pups’ abilities. Fourth, the pups’ predatory skills were tested only a few days after their play had been studied, while they were still young, so the study did not actually assess the relation between play and adult predatory skills. Possible benefits of play may not
70
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . C A R 0
emerge until later in ontogeny. Despite all these criticisms, though, Vincent and Bekoff‘s study did at least indicate that individual differences in play experience had no major effect on the ability of coyote pups to kill prey. Davies and Kemble (1983) performed a similar correlational study with northe m grasshopper mice. Twenty-nine mice from seven different litters were raised in social groups, and various measures of their social play behavior were recorded between 27 and 61 days of age. Following this (at 68-7 1 days), predatory behavior was assessed by presenting the mice with live crickets on eight occasions. The mice were tested as groups (which raises problems of interpretation regarding the independence of their behavior), and individuals’ predatory success was measured as the number of crickets killed. No relation was found between any measure of play behavior and predatory behavior. Most of the criticisms leveled at Vincent and Bekoff‘s (1978) study apply in this case as well. In addition, it would seem that the predatory success of groups, rather than individual mice, was actually being tested. Littermates are known to behave more like one another than like members of another litter (e.g., Barrett & Bateson, 1978, for play in cats), and a more appropriate approach might be to study differences between litters rather than between individuals (Abbey & Howard, 1973). Nonetheless, much the same conclusion may be drawn from this study, namely, that there appeared to be no discernible relation between individual differences in social play experience and predatory success in this species. More recently, Chalmers and Locke-Haydon (1984) have reported the results of a detailed correlational study which analyzed the relations between social play and the development of sensorimotor and social skills in captive infant marmosets. Skills were generally defined as any behavior that helped the infant to gain a desirable resource, location, interaction, or goal (or to avoid an undesirable one). Many specific outcome measures of skill were recorded, including the infant’s ability to take food from others and resist having its own food taken; its success in attempting to climb onto parents and older siblings; and its ability to reach a food reward through a narrow aperture or over a moving obstacle. Skill outcome measures were recorded at 4-week intervals from 6 to 22 weeks of age inclusive, and various play measures were recorded during the intervening periods. The results were analyzed by searching for correlations between skills (or improvements in skills) at one age and the amount of play performed at earlier ages. Most of the many correlations that were calculated did not differ significantly from zero. The authors commented that “a major feature of our results is the absence of correlations between many measures of social play and skills. Some skills were significantly correlated only with nonplay behavior, and only one outcome measure (taking food from the mother) correlated significantly and exclusively with play. Nonetheless, there were some associations between play and certain outcome ”
TABLE I SUMMARY OF EXPERIMENTAL A N D CORRELATIONAL STUDIES(NONHUMAN) DISCUSSED I N THE TEXT ~
~~~~
~
~
~~
~
Sample size"
Type of play
~
Age play measured
Study
Species
Thomas and Schaller
Domestic cat (Felis curus. captive)
10 ( 6 E + 4 C)
Object (t Social)
Caro (1980a)
Domestic cat (Felis cums. captive)
19 ( I 1 OP + 8CI
Object
4- I 2 weeks
Einon CI ul. (1978)
Hooded rat (Rairus nor\,egicu.\; captive females)
30- I05 (total)
Social
23-45 days
Vincent and Bekoff (1978)
Coyote (Canis lununs; captive)
4 ( I litter)
Social
20-34 days
Daviea and Kemble
29 ( 7 litters) Northern grasshopper mouse ( 0ti~chornv.v Ii~uc~o~us~er.: captive) 10 (from 3 Common martamilies) moset (Cull-
Social
27-6 I day\
Social
6-22 weeks
(1954)
~~
Outcome variables
Experimental studies 0- II weeks Predatory behavior (response to moving dummy mouse) Predatory behavior (25 measures of 13 motor patterns; 4 types of prey) Open field (habituation of object contact and locomotion)
~~
~
~~~
Age 0 . V . measured
Hypothesis
I I weeks
Motor training
6 months
Motor training
45- I20 days
Behavioral flexibility
Results
Kaspar Hauser cats showed "normal" predatory movements No difference in predatory behavior between OP and C kittens Quality of social interactions was important
Correlational studies
(1983)
Chalmera and LocheHaydon (1984)
i0it-i.t ,jucchii.\ jucckio ; captive
"E. Experimental. C. control: OP, object-playing
Prey-killing success ( % of 10 x 10-niin trials in which adult mouse killed) Predatory behavior (latency to kill cricket: 8 trials: tested as a group)
Sensorimotor and social skills
35-45 days
Motor training
68-7 I days
Motor training
6-22 weeks
Practice (skill development)
N o correlation between prey-killing success and play frequency No relation between any play measure and predation
Few correlations between play and skill measures: no evidence for delayed benefits
72
PAUL MARTIN A N D T. M . C A R 0
measures. Specifically, sociai play at 11-13 weeks of age was significantly correlated with performance at 14 weeks, both in a competitive food test with the mother and in negotiating a moving obstacle to obtain food. In discussing these correlations, Chalmers and Locke-Haydon pointed to two plausible alternatives to the most obvious interpretation-that play serves to practice these skills. These are, first, that the skills serve to promote play (rather than vice versa) and, second, that play and skills are functionally unrelated but simply share some common causal mechanisms. A striking feature of these results was that all significant correlations between play and skill measures were restricted to the same age period, from I 1 to 14 weeks after birth. There were no correlations, for example, between play during this period and any skills later in development (at 22 weeks). As the authors concluded, “There is thus little evidence to support the hypothesis that the promotional effects of play on skill development are delayed, at least across the age range used in this study.” On the contrary, the results suggest that any effects which play might have on skills are short term rather than delayed until adulthood as the practice hypothesis suggests.
C. OPTIMAL DESIGNSTUDIES A third, and less direct, approach to investigating functional hypotheses about play is the optimal design approach, that is, to observe whether the form or structure of play is consistent with its proposed function (“Can it do the job’?’’). Byers (1977) employed this method to test the hypothesis that the play of ibex kids serves as practice for the locomotor skills which they presumably need as adults in order to negotiate steeply sloped terrain. The specific prediction tested was that locomotor play patterns should occur mainly on sloped (as opposed to flat) surfaces, when both were available. Observations of ibex kids in a zoo confirmed that some forms of locomotor play did indeed occur more often on sloping terrain, in line with the motor training hypothesis. Taking a similar approach, Symons (1974) discussed the hypothesis that aggressive social play (play-fighting and play-chasing) in rhesus monkeys serves to learn, refine, or practice agonistic communication skills. (The improvement of communication skills has frequently been suggested as a function of play in primates, e.g., Mason, 1965; Jolly, 1972.) Symons noted that nearly all serious agonistic interactions involve gesturing of threat and submission rather than fighting. These agonistic signals are generally absent from aggressive social play in rhesus monkeys, and furthermore, signals used during social play are not used during fighting. In addition, Symons argued, the appropriate responses to agonistic signals are absent during play. In play, for example, one individual does not consistently adopt a submissive role; rather, roles alternate. Symons concluded from this and other circumstantial evidence that aggressive social play in
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
73
rhesus monkeys is an “unpromising candidate” as a means of practicing communications skills, and he cast doubt on the plausibility of the communication hypothesis (but see Section V,B). As with Byers’ (1977) study, evidence of this type can lend more or less support to a particular hypothesis but cannot in itself refute or demonstrate the correctness of an hypothesis. Byers’ (1977) results indicate that locomotor play in ibex kids has some of the structural properties needed to perform a particular function, but they do not demonstrate that play is necessarily performing that function. For example, the exercise hypothesis would also predict that locomotor play should preferentially occur on sloped terrain, since this would provide more opportunities for physical exercise. Optimal design studies can, however, demonstrate that a particular hypothesis is probably not correct. Thus, Symons’ argument-that aggressive social play in rhesus monkeys is unlikely to be involved solely in practicing communication skills-is a compelling one. Similar conclusions can be drawn from Schaller’s (1972, pp. 165-166) observations about the play of lion cubs, which resembles adult hunting behavior. Schaller notes that wrestling (which is the commonest motor pattern in play) is rarely used by adults, whereas stalking (an important component of hunting) is not a prominent feature of play. Another valuable source of circumstantial evidence is the comparison of play and serious behavior, either within species (for example, between sexes or populations) or between species. A good example of intraspecific comparison comes from the work of Baldwin and Baldwin (1973, 1974), who studied the exploratory behavior, play, and social interactions of squirrel monkeys in a variety of natural environments. Baldwin and Baldwin (1974) reported that both the frequency and form of social play varied enormously between different populations of squirrel monkeys, with play accounting for anything from 0 to 3 hr per day of young monkeys’ time. In one population living in Panama, no social play whatsoever was observed during 261 hr of observation over a 10-week period. The monkeys at this site spent 95% of their waking time foraging or traveling, leaving little time for play. Despite this, their social behavior appeared normal, and the troop was cohesive and stable. As the Baldwins (1974, p.314) noted, these observations suggest that “social organization and many normal social behaviors can develop in squirrel monkeys without social play,” although play might improve the competence with which they are performed. Evidence such as this, like the results of laboratory deprivation experiments, demonstrates that an adaptive modicum of competence can develop in the absence of play, but it usually leaves open the possibility that play may subtly improve certain skills. Only through fine-grained experimental studies, such as Caro’s (1980a), can this second possibility be investigated. In a study of two canid species, Biben (1982a) found that interspecific differences in juvenile play could be related to the species’ different treatments of
74
PAUL MARTIN AND T . M . C A R 0
prey when adult. Crab-eating foxes hunt individually and engage in extensive solitary object play when young, whereas bush dogs (which hunt cooperatively in social groups) show little object play and share, rather than compete for, objects when young. Similarly, sex differences in play can be compared with sex differences in adult behavior. For example, young male ferrets perform more neck-bites during play and are also more aggressive than females when adult (Biben, 1982b). The existence of such interspecific or intraspecific differences in juvenile play that correspond to differences in adult behavior is certainly consistent with the practice hypothesis of play but by no means constitutes strong evidence in its support (Caro & Alawi, 1985). Various factors might commonly affect both juvenile play and adult behavior even if there is no direct relation between the two. For example, males might be more aggressive than females throughout life for a variety of reasons, irrespective of whether play functions as practice for adult aggression. Equally, some features of social organization (such as social versus solitary living) will be exhibited both in juvenile play and adult behavior whether or not the two are directly related. Animals might simply behave socially throughout life, for example, even if play has no long-term benefits. All of the studies described so far addressed the issue of whether play is a specific developmental determinant of one type of adult behavior (for example, predation or communication skills). A different sort of hypothesis, originally formulated by Brownlee (1954), is that rather than providing training for one particular form of adult behavior, play has a generally beneficial effect by improving the efficiency of skeletal muscles and the cardiopulmonary system. This is the exercise hypothesis of play, which essentially proposes that play enhances an individual’s Darwinian fitness by improving its physical fitness. The exercise hypothesis has been discussed in detail by Fagen (1976), who is a notable and rare proponent of the hypothetico-deductive method in play research. Fagen formulated a list of specific and empirically testable predictions stemming from the exercise hypothesis, one of which has been tested empirically (McDonald, 1977). The maximum physiological training effect of physical exercise occurs when muscles are exercised near to fatigue. Hence, if play serves to exercise muscles then, Fagen argues, bouts of play should last long enough to exercise muscles near to fatigue (but no longer) and the duration of play bouts should follow a nonrandom statistical distribution. To test this prediction, McDonald (1977) recorded the duration of 127 bouts of social play in young California ground squirrels under natural conditions and analyzed their distribution using a log-survivorship technique. The results did not support the exercise hypothesis. Bout durations followed a simple exponential decay model, a finding suggesting that the duration of play bouts was under the control of random events. McDonald’s finding does not, of course, constitute a conclusive falsification of the exercise hypothesis. Only one of its many predictions was tested for
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
75
only one species, and the assumptions behind the test may themselves have been wrong.
D.
HUMANPLAY
The play behavior of children has been studied extensively. Before subsuming evidence from studies of human play into our main argument, however, we should first sound a strong note of caution. Glib generalizations about human nature based on dubious evidence from other species are rightly censured, and the converse should be no less true. There are likely to be profound differences between human play and that of other mammals, in its form, control, development, and consequences. Indeed, the differences between humans and other mammals may often be more informative than the similarities (Hinde, 1974). For example, no obvious parallels exist between the linguistic, fantasy, and sociodramatic play of children and play in other species (Smith, 1983). As a result, most hypotheses about the effects of human play (as opposed to biological functions, senm stricto) are qualitatively different from those applied to play in other species. Notwithstanding these problems, the study of play in humans can and should be related, where possible, to our knowledge of play in other mammals. One commonly espoused hypothesis about play in human infants is that it aids creative thinking and behavioral flexibility (e.g., Piaget, 1962, p. 155; SuttonSmith, 1967). This hypothesis is actually of considerable relevance to animal studies because play is often held to be a source of novel and innovative behavior in nonhuman species (see Fagen, 1981, 1982). Another common hypothesis is that children’s play aids problem solving and, once again, parallels exist with phenomena observed in other species. Numerous experimental studies have tested hypotheses about play in humans, with mixed results (e.g., Pepler & Ross, 1981; Vandenberg, 1981; Cheyne & Rubin, 1983; reviewed by Smith & Simon, 1984), although we shall only outline two representative studies here. Dansky and Silverman (1973, 1975) investigated the notion that object play in children is related to their ability to name novel uses for these objects, or “associative fluency” (a measure of creative or divergent thinking). Thirty nursery school children were individually allowed to play freely with a variety of objects for a 10-min period. Thirty different children were given the same objects for 10 min and told to use them in an imitative manner, copying an adult experimenter. Finally, 30 controls were given a “neutral experience” not involving the objects for 10 min. Immediately following the 10-min period, all children were individually tested on their associative fluency using an alternative uses test, in which the child was asked to name as many nonstandard uses for the objects as possible. The 30 children who had played with the objects immediately prior to testing had higher associative fluency scores (that is, named more
76
PAUL MARTIN A N D T . M . C A R 0
novel uses for the objects) than children in the other two groups. In this sense, the results supported the idea that playing facilitates creative thinking immediately after the play experience. The experiment did not, however, address the issue of whether play is either necessary or beneficial for the development of creative thinking, and no conclusions can be drawn from it about the long-term effects of early individual differences in children’s play experience. As Dansky and Silverman themselves pointed out, a playful attitude engendered by the 10-min play period may have lowered the threshold for forming unusual associations during the subsequent test, but “no claim has been made regarding any increase or decrease in the actual creative ability of the children in this study.” At most, this experiment indicated that children are more likely to form unusual associations when in a playful mood, although this may, in turn, support the suggestion that play is beneficial in the development of creative thinking abilities. Another study by Sylva (1977; Sylva, Bruner, & Genova, 1976) tested the hypothesis that prior experience playing with the components of a “lure-retrieval” problem would improve a child’s subsequent ability to solve that problem. Children were given different forms of prior experience, both playful and nonplayful, with the components of a mechanical problem, which was to retrieve an object from an out-of-reach container using a tool assembled from available components (sticks and clamps). Children who had played with the sticks and clamps for 10 min prior to being tested showed more goal-directed responses, were less likely to opt out, and were better able to use hints given by an adult than children who had merely observed an adult manipulating the sticks and clamps. Prior play also tended to lead to a different style of problem solving: a “bottom-up’ ’ progression from simpler to more complete partial solutions, rather than trying immediately for a complete solution. However, prior play did not result in more spontaneous solutions to the problem, nor did children who had played solve the problem more rapidly than those who had only observed. Thus, it would be misleading to state that play improved problem-solving ability. Rather, play changed the way in which children solved the problem (see Cheyne, 1982). Subsequent studies of similar design have also failed to find clear-cut evidence for facilitatory effects of object play on children’s problem-solving abilities (e.g., Cheyne & Rubin, 1983). Just as with Dansky and Silverman’s work described earlier, Sylva’s experiment investigated only the immediate effects of a brief period of play and can tell us little about the long-term effects of early play experience on the development of other forms of behavior. Christie (1983) makes a similar point about most studies investigating the effects of “play tutoring” on children’s cognitive abilities, commenting that it is unclear whether “play tutoring truly promotes children’s cognitive development or merely results in inconsequential, short term gains in cognitive performance. The results of many experimental studies of children’s object play are ambigu”
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
77
ous because of uncertainties of experimental design and procedure (Cheyne, 1982; Simon & Smith, 1983; Smith & Simon, 1984). In particular, when alternative-treatment (rather than no-treatment) controls have been used, significant differences have often failed to emerge. In many lure-retrieval tests of problem solving, it was not known whether the children had actually played with the objects. In addition, the effects of observer bias have not always been adequately accounted for. Indeed, when possible observer bias was controlled for, Simon and Smith (1983) were unable to replicate the findings of a previous study (Smith & Dutton, 1979) in which play experience had proved to be markedly superior to training for innovative problem solving. In common with many studies, Simon & Smith (1983) found that, in most respects, the effects of play experience did not differ from those of training directly related to the problem. Similarly, many experimental studies investigating the effects of play tutoring on children’s cognitive and linguistic skills have lacked appropriate controls, with the consequence that some apparent improvements may have resulted from increased contact with adults rather than from any specific effects of play per se (Smith, Dalgleish, & Herzmark, 1981; Christie, 1983). Where control groups have been included, few differences have been found between the effects of play tutoring and straightforward skills tutoring (Smith ef al., 1981; Christie, 1983). For convergent problem solving, certainly, play experience is not significantly more effective than comparable nonplay experiences (such as imitation or observation), although a superiority of play over nonplay has been found for some divergent problem-solving tasks (Smith & Simon, 1984). However, the relevance and importance of some of these tasks (such as the alternative uses test) are questionable, and Smith and Simon (1984) rightly point to the need for “ecologically valid” play experiences and outcome variables in such experiments (see Section VI, B). In conclusion, no consistent evidence has yet emerged to indicate that the effects of play experience on children’s problem-solving or other skills is markedly superior to the effects of other forms of experience, such as direct training (Vandenberg, 1981; Cheyne, 1982; Christie, 1983; Simon & Smith, 1983; Smith & Simon, 1984). The method used in these lure-retrieval, problem-solving studies is, interestingly, a modern variant of Kohler’s ( 1 925) classic “stick-as-rake’’ problem, which was originally used to study insightful problem solving in chimpanzees. Numerous animal studies, both with primates (e.g., chimpanzees: Birch, 1945) and with other species (e.g., polecats: Weiss-Burger, 1981; pigeons: Epstein, Kirshnit, Lanza, & Rubin, 1984) have found that animals are better able to solve a problem or perform a task if they have received prior experience (which may include play) with the elements of that task. Yet even the immediate effects of children’s play are not always beneficial, as illustrated by Hutt’s (1966) study of play and exploration in nursery school children. Hutt found that play could actually impede learning. Children were
78
PAUL MARTIN A N D T . M . C A R 0
presented with a novel and complex object (a box with a lever that operated a bell, a buzzer, and four counters), whose properties they were allowed to investigate freely. Hutt found that the object was not incorporated into play until the child had discovered all of its salient physical properties. After this, she argued, learning was incidental. Indeed, one boy who started a game with the object after only a brief period of investigation failed completely to discover one of its major properties (the buzzer). Hutt (1966, p.76) concluded that “by being repetitive, play is by definition a highly redundant activity, and can actually prevent learning.” Similarly, in his famous study of play and mechanical problem solving in chimpanzees, Schiller ( 1957) concluded that previous play often impeded rather than facilitated problem solving. Indeed, one chimp failed to use a stick in a food-retrieval problem, even after several hours of fasting, because he was preoccupied by playing with it (Schiller, 1957, p.272). We have summarized the evidence from studies which have directly tested a functional hypothesis of play and have found little solid evidence upon which to base a conclusion about the functions of play. To explain this lack of evidence for any beneficial effects of play, we can appeal to two suggestions, which we shall discuss in turn. The first is that play does not actually have any major longterm benefits but is a facilitative developmental determinant of minor importance. The second is that the beneficial effects of play have not yet been detected for a variety of methodological and theoretical reasons. We certainly do not wish to dismiss this second possibility, and it would clearly be wrong to conclude that an absence of empirical evidence proves an absence of any benefits-particularly when so few experiments have actually been performed. Moreover, these two suggestions are not mutually exclusive. For example, play may have only minor benefits, and these have not yet been detected because of the way in which the experiments were performed.
1V. PLAYMAY HAVEN o MAJORBENEFITS Two lines of circumstantial evidence support the notion that play has relatively small benefits, and a third counters the view that play is an important developmental determinant of adult behavior. The first is the cost-benefit argument, which asserts that, contrary to prevailing dogma, play probably has relatively minor biological costs and may therefore have only minor benefits (as long as these exceed the costs). The second is the lability argument. This asserts that play is extremely sensitive to prevailing conditions and is a low-priority activity which may be suppressed or completely absent under natural conditions, implying that play is unlikely to be essential for normal development. Third, there is the often neglected point that adults of many species also play. We shall consider each of these arguments separately.
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
79
A . THE COSTSAND BENEFITSOF PLAY One of the few generalizations about play which is widely agreed upon is that play is a very “costly” activity. It is frequently asserted that play consumes large amounts of an animal’s time and energy and may involve risk of injury, so it must be highly beneficial. Fagen (198 1, p.3 1 I ) , for example, speculates at one point about the likely consequences of a young animal devoting “95 or perhaps even 99% of its daily caloric expenditure (excluding thermoregulatory and digestive metabolism) to play.” Hinde (1974, p. 227) succinctly summarizes the view of the overwhelming majority when he writes that “play consumes so much time and energy that it must be of crucial adaptive importance in development.” (Further examples appear elsewhere.3) Certainly, in order for a behavior pattern to be maintained by natural selection it must have beneficial consequences which, on average, exceed its costs. Therefore, the axiom that play is very costly necessarily implies that play must have large benefits, otherwise animals simply would not be selected to play. Unfortunately, there is no convincing evidence that the absolute time and energy costs of play are in fact great. Indeed, the results of some recent work (Martin, 1982, 1984b) suggest quite the contrary. The terms energy and costly are used inconsistently and with a wide variety of different meanings in the behavioral literature (see Hinde, 1960; Burghardt, 1984), and it is often unclear what is actually meant by statements such as ‘‘play is energetically costly” (Martin, 1984b). One suggestion has been to define the energy cost of play (ECP) as the net daily energy expenditure (in excess of resting metabolism) that is due to play. expressed as a percentage of the total daily energy budget (Martin, ‘There is no need to search far in the biological literature on play to find play described as “costly,” or to encounter a clear implication that play involves a substantial expenditure of time and/or energy (e.g., Beach. 1945; Berlyne. 1966: Loizos, 1966, 1967: Dolhinow & Bishop, 1970, 1972; Bekoff, 1972, 1976b; Farentinos, 1971; Hinde, 1974, p. 227: Poirier & Smith, 1974; Symons, 1974; Poole & Fish, 1975; White, 1977: Berger. 1980; Immelmann, 1980, p. 101: Bateson & Young, 1981; Bekoff& Byers. 1981, p. 315: Byers. 1981: Fagen, 1981, pp. 272. 311, 312, 314; Suonii, 1982). Numerous authors have developed this supposition about the costliness of play into an informal cost-benefit analysis which seenis to have become one of the central tenets of play research: Play has large costs and must, therefore. have large benefits (e.g.. Dolhinow & Bishop, 1970, p. 192: Farentinos, 1971: Hinde, 1974. p. 227: Poirier & Smith, 1974, p. 277; Symons. 1974. p.317; Poole & Fish. 1975: Bekoff& Byers, 1981, p.325; Fagen, 1981, pp.19.482; Smith, 1982). For example. Symons (1974. p.317) argues. “Since immature animals of many species spend so much time and energy playing, play must be adaptive.” We do not wish to imply that previous writers have been uncritical. Some have recognized that the costliness of play is only an assumption. For example, Fagen (1981, p.24) write,, “Time, energy. growth. and survivorship costs of play are generally recognized, if not rigorously demonstrated in all cases,” and later (p.313) he points out that, at the time of writing, “direct measurement of caloric expenditure in play remains to be performed.” Similarly. Bekoff and Byers (1981) make it clear that the costliness of play is only an assumption rather than an empirically dcrnonstrated fact.
80
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . CAR0
1982). This is numerically equal to the net percentage reduction in the mean daily rate of energy expenditure that would result from resting instead of playing, given that all other activities remained unaltered. Using this definition, Martin (1982) initially estimated the energy cost of play for most mammals to be of the order of 2.5%, with an upper limit of 15%. The substantial cost of growth (typically around 30% of total energy intake) is excluded from the total energy expenditure in this formulation of ECP, which therefore tends to underestimate the relative energy expenditure on play. One possible objection to using ECP as an index of energy cost is that other, patently beneficial activities (such as copulation) probably also have a small energy cost relative to total expenditure. However, energy cost is not by itself used to justify the view that, say, copulating is biologically beneficial, whereas for play it often is. Similar logic applies to the use of time as a measure of importance. Clearly, some manifestly beneficial activities do not consume a great deal of time. Again, though, play is different in so far as assumptions about its costs are often the only arguments used to support the view that play is highly beneficial. In an attempt to question the consensus view about the costliness of play, Martin (1984b) measured the amount of time and energy that young domestic cats devote to play, using a variety of empirical methods. Both time-lapse photography and time-sampling observations were used to estimate the proportion of total time spent in social or object play by sibling-pairs of kittens living with their mothers in their own large indoor pen. Food was available ad libitum, a variety of toys were provided, and the animals were undisturbed. Under these ideal conditions, kittens were found to spend on average 9% of total time (per 24 hr) playing. In a separate set of measurements, indirect (oxygen consumption) calorimetry was used to record kittens’ metabolic rates when resting and playing. The likely upper limit of play metabolic rate was also independently estimated, using a published numerical model of metabolism. The amount of energy expended on play (in excess of resting expenditure) was found to account for about 4%, and at most 9%, of total daily energy expenditure (Martin, 1984b). If anything, these are overestimates of ECP since the large costs of growth were excluded from total expenditure and, second, the upper limit of ECP was estimated on the unrealistic assumption that play consisted entirely of running. These empirical results confirmed earlier speculation by Blaxter (1962, p. 108) and Martin (1982) that play accounts for only a small proportion (less than 10%) of total daily energy expenditure in most mammals. The time budget results were also consistent with Fagen’s (1981, p.273) conclusion that play accounts for 110% of total time in most species that have so far been studied. Thus, Martin’s (1984b) results show that play accounts for less than 10% of a kitten’s total time and involves an additional energy expenditure (over and above the minimum that would occur anyway) that is about 4%, and certainly less than lo%, of its total daily output. Moreover, in this experiment the subjects were
81
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
well-fed, disease-free, and predator-free juveniles of a domesticated species noted for its playfulness, living with their mothers in spacious, heated rooms containing a variety of toys-all optimal conditions for eliciting play according to the available evidence (see Fagen, 1981, p.361; and Section IV, B). It is likely that the time and energy expenditure on play would generally be lower in other species and in domestic kittens living under less favorable conditions. Juvenile mammals spend little or no time engaging in adult activities such as mating, hunting, or defending territory and are probably less constrained by time and energy considerations than adults of the same species. Thus, the numerically small expenditures on play of time and energy are likely to be of limited importance in terms of the juvenile’s eventual survival and reproduction. Nonetheless, it must be admitted that there is no simple answer to the question of to what extent a particular time or energy cost should be regarded as costly. A third potential effect of play is a survivorship cost, resulting from an increase in the risk of injury, predation, or separation from the parent (Fagen, 1981, p.275; Bekoff & Byers, 1981). There have been many anecdotal accounts of animals falling or in some other way exposing themselves to risks when playing (e.g., Byers, 1977; reviewed by Fagen, 1981, Table 5-2). So far, though, the survivorship cost of play has not been quantitatively defined, estimated, or measured, and its possible magnitude and biological significance remain unknown. Clearly, though, an absence of empirical data does not entitle us to infer an absence of cost. The survivorship cost of play is certainly an issue that warrants much more research. As R . Fagen (personal communication) correctly points out, “If play were as interesting to certain field biologists as infanticide, we would have plenty of information about survivorship costs of play-and this information would be just as hotly contested. To summarize, an animal which plays does not necessarily incur large time or energy costs. Under most circumstances play probably accounts for less than 10% of total time and involves an additional energy expenditure which is less than 10% of total output. Unless it is found that play per se frequently results in injury or death, it is reasonable to conclude that its immediate biological costs may not be large. If so, then play need only have minor biological benefits in order to be maintained by natural selection. The only requirement in evolutionary terms is that the benefits should, on average, exceed the costs. Thus, there are no grounds for ussuming that play is of major adaptive importance solely on the basis of its costs. We hasten to add that of course it does not necessarily follow that because play has small costs it must have small benefits. The logic of any such cost-benefit argument is not reversible, and there remains a logical possibility that play has small costs but large benefits. However, given the evidence summarized in Section 111, we can find no compelling reason to suppose that play does necessarily have large benefits. At present, therefore, it is reasonable to propose that play may have relatively ”
82
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . C A R 0
minor (and therefore not easily detectable) benefits, which nonetheless outweigh its minor biological costs. This suggestion could potentially be refuted empirically in a number of different ways, for example ( I ) by demonstrating that animals uniquely acquire valuable skills or experience from play; (2) by showing that play is a significant cause of death or injury under natural conditions; (3) by demonstrating that young animals play at the expense of a reduction in their growth rate; or (4) by showing that play directly prevents other manifestly beneficial activities. If play has only minor benefits, animals would be predicted not to play when, for example, this necessitated reducing their food intake-an expectation which is largely born out by existing evidence (e.g., Chavez, Martinez, & Yaschine, 1975; Baldwin & Baldwin, 1976; Miiller-Schwarze, Stagge, & Miiller-Schwarze, 1982; see Section IV, B). It must be stressed that assessing the true biological significance of the time, energy, and survivorship costs of play is not a straightforward matter. It is difficult to translate proximate costs (such as time, energy, and risk of injury) into ultimate costs (their consequences for lifetime reproductive success). The importance of proximate costs will certainly depend upon environmental conditions. For example, an additional daily energy requirement of, say, 4% might be inconsequential when excess food is available but might be of critical importance when an animal is already starving. Yet starving animals generally do not playand it is this closely related issue which we deal with in Section IV, B. Finally, we wish to emphasize that these arguments about the costs of play are put forward to generate further debate, not to stifle it. The hope is that, rather than using dubious notions about the costliness of play to support assumptions about its benefits, direct evidence for these proposed benefits will instead be sought empirically. B.
OF PLAY THE LABILITY
Another reason for suggesting that play may not be of crucial adaptive importance is its absence in many species of mammal and its extreme sensitivity to prevailing conditions in those species which do play. Play is highly variable in its distribution, both interspecifically and intraspecifically. In his masterly review, Fagen ( 198 1, Ch. 3) has comprehensively documented the phylogenetic distribution of play, demonstrating that play (as commonly defined) seems to be present in many-but not all- mammals and some birds but is completely absent from other taxonomic groups such as the reptiles and insects (see also Burghardt, 1984). Furthermore, there are often substantial differences in both the amount and nature of play between taxonomically closely related species (Smith, 1982). For example, rats engage in social play, but social play is rarely, if ever, observed in mice (Poole & Fish, 1975; Einon, Humphreys, Chivers, Field, &
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
83
Naylor, 1981). It seems implausible that play should be of vital importance in the ontogeny of some species but not in other, closely related species. A second and more important point is that play is also very variable within those species which do play. A well-known feature of play is that animals will play only when they are “relaxed” and free from threats, discomfort, hunger, danger, and illness (e.g., Hutt, 1966; Bekoff, 1972; Schaller, 1972, p.165; Fagen, 1981, p.361; Suomi, Kraemer, Baysinger, & DeLizio, 1981). Indeed, many writers have held the view that play is a sensitive indicator of an animals’s general state of physical and mental well-being, and Fagen (1981, p.361) notes that, in the experience of many veterinarians and pediatricians, a reduction in the amount of play “is the first and most obvious sign of illness in an animal that may otherwise appear very healthy” (see also Suomi et al., 1981). An illustration of the intraspecific lability of play is provided by the field observations of Baldwin and Baldwin (1973, 1974), discussed earlier. Some wild populations of squirrel monkeys were found to exhibit extensive social play, whereas in other groups play was rare or completely absent. A subsequent laboratory experiment with squirrel monkeys showed that if food was made difficult and time-consuming to obtain, social play rapidly dropped to about 1% of its former level (Baldwin & Baldwin, 1976). As in the field studies, “no pathological or dysfunctional consequences were observed in any of the circumstances when play was reduced to zero or near zero.” Numerous field studies of other species have also found sharp reductions in play associated with changes in the abundance or quality of food (e.g., rhesus monkeys: Loy, 1970: lions: Schaller, 1972, p.165; vervet monkeys: Lee, 1983; children: Chavez et al., 1975; see Fagen, 1981, p.370). Another example of the lability of play comes from Berger’s (1979, 1980) study of populations of bighorn sheep inhabiting different natural environments. Major differences in the quantity and quality of play behavior were found between the different study populations. For example, playful interactions were drastically curtailed in sheep inhabiting a desert environment and play was at least nine times more frequent in a northern study population. Changes in the ease of food availability can also lead to a large reduction in the incidence of play. For example, Muller-Schwarze et al. (1982) studied the locomotor play of five white-tailed deer fawns when their food was changed from milk to grass. The fawns were initially bottle-fed with milk but could also graze in their enclosure. When their milk supply was subsequently reduced to twothirds of the previous ad libitum intake, the fawns increased their grazing by 62% and almost exactly compensated for the loss of calories from milk. Their total energy intake remained at 99% of the ad libiturn level. This change in food source led to a reduction in their general locomotor activity of about 9%, but their play fell by 35%. Such a disproportionately large reduction in play, result-
84
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . C A R 0
ing from a minor ( 1 %) reduction in total calorific intake, points both to the sensitivity of play and to its low priority relative to other forms of activity. Surprisingly, though, Muller-Schwarze et a f . concluded from these results that “the persistence of play . . . points to the importance of play.” Play may also be curtailed for a variety of other reasons, such as overcrowding (Leyhausen, 1979), inclement weather (Rasa, 1971; Card & Meier, 19771, and the presence of a human observer (Sugiyama, 1965; see Fagen, 1981, pp.302, 361, 370). Play may also vary intraspecifically for reasons other than short-term changes in environmental conditions. Young voles born in the spring and early summer play extensively, whereas those born in the autumn seldom, if ever, play (Wilson, 1973). Similarly, there are often marked individual differences in play, for example, in the locomotor play of domestic kittens and their mothers (Martin & Bateson, 1985) and in the play of yellow-bellied marmots (Nowicki & Armitage, 1979). In conclusion, play is absent from the behavioral repertoire of some species, and, more importantly, the incidence of play is extremely variable within those species which do play. Play may be suppressed by a variety of factors which occur relatively often in natural environments, yet we know of no evidence that its absence has any major effects. Play appears to be an activity of low priority, since it is dropped in preference to virtually all other forms of activity. We know of no instances in the literature, for example, where animals have been found to continue playing yet have curtailed their foraging or other aspects of social behavior as a result of minor food shortages. Play may be less prominent than is often assumed in many wild populations of mammals. In passing, it should be said that the lability of play might also point to its having very large costs, since the most costly activities (as well as the least important) might also be dropped temporarily during conditions of stress. Nevertheless, we tend to discount this alternative explanation for the lability of play because independent empirical evidence (see Section IV, A) suggests that play has low time and energy costs. Furthermore, it is not immediately obvious why play should be far more costly in some species than in other, closely related species. In summary, the interspecific and intraspecific variability of play suggest that it is unlikely to be a crucial ingredient of normal behavioral development. A more plausible view is that play is a facilitatory developmental determinant whose benefits outweigh its costs in some favorable environments but not in others.
C . ADULTPLAY Adults of many species also play, both socially and with objects (see Fagen, 1981; Smith, 1982), and it is clearly mistaken to assume that play is solely the province of juveniles. The existence of adult play is another piece of circumstan-
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
85
tial evidence against practice hypotheses because skilled serious behavior patterns are already present in the repertoire of adults. Of course, the same behavior can have different functions at different stages of ontogeny-as, for example, shown by the differences between filial and sexual imprinting in birds (Bateson, 1979)-and the functions of play in adulthood might be different from those earlier in ontogeny. Adult play might maintain specific behavior patterns rather than facilitate their development, for example. Whatever the case, it seems likely that adult play is selected for because of its immediate benefits. As such, it is not unreasonable to suggest that the play of juveniles might also have immediate benefits.
V.
THEORETICAL PROBLEMS I N DETECTING THE BENEFITSOF PLAY
The benefits of play, though manifold according to prevailing theories, are not obvious in practice and, as we have seen, have so far evaded most attempts to elucidate their nature. In the first half of this article, we proposed that one reason why no major benefits of play have yet been uncovered might be that there are none; the minor costs and lability of play point toward its having a relatively small role in behavioral development. Nonetheless, there are several other factors which might also contribute to difficulties in uncovering the benefits of play. Discussion of these factors raises theoretical issues about behavioral development, such as when in ontogeny the benefits of play manifest themselves, as well as some methodological points. These issues are addressed here in order to generate suggestions for future empirical research. A.
VERSUS LONG-TERM EFFECTSOF PLAY SHORT-TERM
Most theories about the functions of play assert that play has immediate costs and delayed benefits. The young animal, it is argued, plays at the immediate expense of time and energy expenditure but subsequently benefits from, say, improvements in predatory or social skills later in ontogeny (e.g., Groos, 1898; Fagen, 1981, pp. 355, 362; Smith, 1982, p. 149). This conventional view-that play is practice for some form of serious behavior later in ontogeny-is represented in Fig. la. Here, the outcome variable (that is, a measure of the serious behavior purportedly practiced by playing) is shown as a function of age for two hypothetical animals: one which plays during a period early in ontogeny and one which does not play but is otherwise similar. A concrete example can be chosen from Caro’s (1980a) work on the role of object play in the development of predatory skills in domestic cats. Here, the outcome variable would be a measure of adult predatory behavior (say, percentage success in killing prey), and the two
86
PAUL MARTIN A N D T . M . C A R 0
w
FIG. I . Hypothesized differences in a behavioral outcome variable (a measure of the serious behavior) between playing (dotted line) and nonplaying (continuous line) subjects, as a function of age. (a) Conventional practice model; long-term benefits. (b) Immediate benefits only. (c) Acceleration of normal development; short-term benefits.
curves would represent animals which had and had not received opportunities for object play when young. In fact, Car0 failed to find any such difference between the two groups of cats. Note that in this case the adult behavior pattern is assumed to develop to some extent even in the complete absence of prior play, since most practice theories now postulate that play improves adult skills rather than being absolutely necessary for the development of adult behavior. In its simplest form, then, the conventional practice theory predicts that a quantitative difference between the Play and No Play groups first starts to emerge when the relevant adult behavior pattern has begun to develop (point 3 in Fig. la) and persists to some extent thereafter (e.g., point 4,in adulthood). According to this model, experimental or correlational studies should be able to detect the consequences of differences in early play experience at any stage in ontogeny after the serious adult behavior has developed. The pattern of development shown in Fig. l a would be one way of accounting for the negative results of the correlational studies we described earlier. In these cases, the outcome variables (predatory success or other skills) were measured while the animals were still young (point 2
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
87
in Fig. la). The model does not, however, explain Caro’s (1980a) failure to find any long-term consequences in kittens of not playing since, in his experiment, the outcome variables were actually measured in early adulthood. Yet there are no compelling grounds for assuming that the principal benefits of play must be delayed in ontogeny. Indeed, because of the cumulative effects of mortality, any benefit would have a larger selective advantage the earlier in ontogeny it acted. Thus, it could equally well be proposed that play is adaptive because it has immediate beneficial consequences for the juvenile. This possibility is lent further credence if, as we argued earlier, the benefits of play are neither very large nor important. For example, the experimental studies of children’s play we described found that play has certain immediate beneficial effects on children’s problem-solving abilities and creative thinking. If we suppose (as in fact seems likely) that these differences result from the immediate mood induced by playing, then there need be no long-term benefits for adult problemsolving or creative-thinking abilities. This possibility is represented in Fig. 1 b. Here, differences can be detected only during the same stage in ontogeny when differential play experience occurs (point I), but not thereafter. Thus, if the principal benefits of play accrue to the juvenile as an immediate consequence of playing, then any experiment which searched for major differences in adult skills might prove fruitless. (Of course, even if most benefits of play do occur immediately. some long-term comequences might be detectable later in ontogeny . The point is, though, that these would not in general be functionally related to the prior play patterns in any obvious or easily predictable way.) In conclusion, it would appear that too little attention has been paid by ethologists to the possibility that play may have immediate benefits (see Bekoff & Byers, 198 1 , for a similar view). A third possibility is that play serves to accelerate the development of adult behavioral capabilities but neither is necessary for their eventual development nor improves their final performance when they have fully developed. This is represented in Fig. lc, which again illustrates the point that behavioral differences resulting from differences in play experience might be detectable only during a restricted phase in ontogeny (e.g., point 3). For example, let us suppose that the principal effect of playing with dead prey or prey-like objects is to reduce young kittens’ fear of live prey and thereby to hasten slightly their first successful prey killing attempt (Martin, 1984a). The idea here is that all kittens would eventually become competent predators, regardless of whether or not they had previously played, but that the onset of successful predation would occur slightly earlier in ontogeny if they had played. Kittens which had played less or not at all would be slightly older when they first successfully dealt with prey but would do this equally competently on average. This speculative suggestion is consistent with current knowledge of how predatory behavior actually develops in domestic cats. For example, individual differences in predatory behavior are most promi-
88
PAUL MARTIN A N D T . M . C A R 0
nent, not in the final predatory acts themselves, but in the time needed to become a competent predator and in the developmental route leading up to this (Baerendsvan Roon & Baerends, 1979, pp.75-78). The prevalence of the view that play has delayed benefits and is involved in the development of adult behavior raises a broader point about behavioral development. There has long been a tendency to regard juvenile behavior solely in terms of its relation to adult behavior (see Bateson, 1976b; Oppenheim, 1980; Galef, 1981). Sometimes, as in practice theories of play, juvenile behavior is seen specifically as a means of developing adult behavior, or “behavior used in development” as Bateson (1976b) has termed it. Yet natural selection acts at all stages in ontogeny-not just on the adult phenotype-and the developing organism must be adapted at every stage in ontogeny (Hamilton, 1966; Williams, 1966, p.44; Galef, 1981). The juvenile is not a miniature adult, and it can be highly misleading to regard its behavior as no more than an incompetent version of adult behavior. For example, numerous experiments have now established that the suckling of rat pups is in many respects qualitatively distinct from adult feeding (Drewett, 1978; Hall & Williams, 1983). Some aspects of juvenile behavior might specifically be concerned with problems that are unique to that stage in ontogeny and have no direct role in the development of adult behavior. Play could be an example of a “juvenile adaptation” (Oppenheim, 1980), in which case the relation between play and structurally similar forms of adult behavior would be unpredictable and difficult to establish. Of course, we are not suggesting that no attempts should be made to analyze the long-term consequences of play. The point is that efforts should also be directed toward investigating its consequences for the juvenile. B.
EQUIFINALITY
Another reason why individual differences in play apparently have few major consequences later in ontogeny might be that development is well buffered against such variation in early experience. This point is encapsulated in the system theory concept of equifinality, which asserts that in an open system (such as a living organism) the same steady state in development can be reached from different initial conditions and in different ways (Bertalanffy, 1968, p.40; Bateson, 1976b). Thus, the same state in behavioral development-say, the attainment of adult predatory skills-could be achieved via a variety of different developmental histories. In other words, different developmental routes involving different amounts and types of play, or perhaps none at all, might converge on the same developmental end point, and playing when young might be only one way of achieving predatory competence. Thus, an alternative to the suggestion that play has no major benefits is that play does have important benefits under some circumstances, but these benefits can also be obtained in other ways.
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
89
Once again, we may illustrate this point using Caro’s work on the developmental determinants of predatory behavior in domestic cats. Adult predation is influenced by numerous factors which act early in ontogeny, such as manipulation of prey when young (Caro, 1980b), the presence and behavior of the mother during exposure to prey (Caro, 1980a), and the possible effects of competition between siblings during exposure to prey (Caro, 1980~).In addition, experience with prey when adult also enhances adult predatory skills (Caro, 1980a). These findings are illustrated in Fig. 2 . The point here is that a given set of adult behavior patterns, in this case predatory behavior, has multiple developmental determinants, and variation in one of these (play, for example) might be compensated for by variation in another. This type of buffering would clearly be adaptive, in so far as it would allow competence to develop despite environmental variation during ontogeny. Car0 (1980a) found no differences between the adult predatory skills of cats which had and had not received opportunities to play with objects when young. One explanation of this is simply that object play is not involved in the development of predation. An alternative explanation, suggested by the idea of equifinality, is that early differences in play opportunities were compensated for by other factors, such as increased attention to the mother’s prey handling. Similarly, predators living in a natural environment would be able to improve their predatory skills by increased experience of prey when adult. The development of predation could be buffered against normal variation in opportunities for play when young, in which case related differences in adult behavior would not emerge as a result of many experimental manipulations. Initial differences in kittens’ predatory skills do in fact tend to disappear later in ontogeny, as individuals who are poor predators when young catch up as adults (Baerendsvan Roon & Baerends, 1979, p.77; Caro, 1979). The notion of equifinality has also proved useful in studies of child development where it has become clear, for example, that there is more than one way to acquire language and that early traumatic experiences do not necessarily have immutable, long-term effects (Clarke & Clarke, 1976; Dunn, 1976; Kagan, 1978). It would be surprising-given the variability of play and its apparent sensitivity to variation in environmental conditions-if the development of vital adult behavioral capabilities were to depend critically on playing during early ontogeny . Some theoretical support for the notion of equifinality in relation to play is provided by Fagen’s computer models, in which the development of play was analyzed in cost-benefit terms as a life-history strategy (Fagen, 1977; 1981, Ch.6). Some of the general predictions of Fagen’s models were that (1) not all species will exhibit play; (2) within a species, play is an optimal strategy in some environments but not in others; and (3) within a particular environment, play may not be a unique optimal strategy, that is, play may evolve in some subpopulations but not in others inhabiting the same environment. The evolution of
I
<
-
-_---- -
-\-
\
-
P
h)
-
I
4
SIBLING COMPETITION
I
I
I
SlBLiNGS
OBSERVE
OBSERVE MOTHER
MOTHER BRINGS IN PREY
PREDATORY MANIPULATION
OBJECT PLAY
OTHER SOURCES OF VARIATION. INCLUDING GENETIC DET€RMINANTS
3
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
91
multiple optimal strategies, some not involving play at all, was a common feature of Fagen’s models and emphasized that play is often not a unique optimal strategy (Fagen, 1981, p.375).
C. NONEQUIVALENCE Another assumption in most functional theories of play is that play must be practice for structurally similar behavior patterns. For example, the play of kittens is frequently held to be practice for adult predatory behavior because the motor acts used in the two contexts look somewhat similar (e.g., Egan, 1976). However, two behavior patterns can have similar structures yet serve different functions, and vice versa. For instance, suckling and lapping milk have the same consequences for rat pups (Hall & Williams, 1983). Functional similarities cannot simply be inferred from structural similarities between two behavior patterns, particularly when (as in the case of play and adult predation) they occur at different stages in ontogeny. Structural similarity between object play and adult predatory patterns does constitute a reason for hypothesizing that the two are functionally related but is not in itself a sufficient reason for assuming this relationship (see also Car0 & Alawi, 1985). This line of reasoning raises the disheartening possibility that play could be a developmental determinant of adult behavior patterns which look entirely different. If, for example, the social play of primates has a socializing function, then the detailed form of playful motor patterns would, to a large extent, be irrelevant. This argument seems particularly compelling in the case of children’s play, where the important factor may be just that the children engage in activities with their peers. The precise form of those activities may, within certain limits, be of no great importance. In the case of motor training theories of play, though, it is reasonable to hope that play will resemble in form the adult behavior it is purported to practice. If not, it is difficult to know which adult behavior patterns should be chosen as the outcome variable in an experimental study.
D. NONSPECIFICITY All practice or motor training theories of play postulate that play is a developmental determinant which has specific effects on a particular type of serious adult behavior. Many developmental deterniinants of behavior have general effects, however (Bateson, 1976a, 1981). For example, simple exposure to patterned light during early development can affect many aspects of chicks’ behavior, including the rate at which they learn about visual targets, their readiness to approach an imprinting stimulus, and their accuracy of pecking at seeds (Bateson, 1976a). The possibility that play may exert general rather than specific
92
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . C A R 0
effects on adult behavior is embodied in one functional theory of play, the exercise hypothesis. The exercise hypothesis postulates that the principal benefits of play result from physiological training effects which improve the overall efficiency and stamina of skeletal muscles and the cardiopulmonary system (Brownlee, 1954; Fagen, 1976; Fagen & George, 1977). If play does act mainly to improve general physical fitness, then early play activity would exert a broad range of nonspecific effects on many types of adult behavior rather than specifically improving one particular type of adult skill. The summed effects of many small improvements in the efficiency with which all motor acts were performed would constitute a significant selective advantage, even though the effect on any one adult behavior pattern might be suble and difficult to detect experimentally. Once again this theoretical possibility, if true, would have disheartening consequences for practical research because it implies a need to search for subtle differences in behavior across a broad range of behavior patterns rather than dramatic changes in a single outcome variable. At the very least, the possibility that play has beneficial physical training effects suggests that experiments should be fine grained and use multiple, sensitive measures. A single, relatively crude outcome variable, such as percentage success in killing prey, is unlikely to pick up subtle differences in the speed or efficiency with which the prey-killing motor acts are performed.
E. THRESHOLD EFFECTS Another theoretical possibility is that some threshold amount of play experience may be necessary before any changes in adult behavior occur. If so, one explanation for failing to find an effect of differences in early play experience could be that none of the animals had played enough for this threshold to be exceeded. In Caro’s (1980a) study, for example, the kittens which were allowed to play with objects might not have played enough for any improvement in predatory skills to have occurred-a so-called floor effect. Conversely, play can probably improve adult skills only by a finite amount, and once an animal has received a certain amount of play experience, adult skills may cease to be improved any further-a ceiling effect. In Caro’s experiment it is possible (though unlikely) that the control animals received sufficient opportunities for object play (for example, with wood shavings from their litter trays) that they attained the maximum possible improvement in predatory skills, thereby obscuring any difference relative to the object-playing kittens. Clearly, in any such experiment it is necessary to manipulate play experience to a sufficient extent that differences in outcome variables can emerge.
F. INTERACTIONS
BETWEEN
DEVELOPMENTAL DETERMINANTS
In so far as there are any valid generalizations about behavioral ontogeny, one is that the development of all behavior is influenced by many factors (Bateson,
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
93
1981). For example, the predatory behavior of adult cats is influenced by a variety of factors which operate earlier in ontogeny (Fig. 2), although object play does not seem to be one of these (Caro, 1980a). As a general principle, developmental determinants cannot be assumed to operate independently of one another, and it has become clear that they often interact in important ways (Bateson, 1976a). To take an example from human development, a longitudinal study (Werner, Bierman, & French, 1971) found that the effects of severe perinatal stress on later measures of children’s physical and psychological well-being depended greatly on social and economic factors (see Dunn, 1976). In the case of Caro’s (1980a) cats, it could be that object play early in ontogeny exerts a beneficial effect on adult predatory skills only when it occurs in conjunction with some other form of early experience, for example, manipulation of dead prey or observing the mother deal with prey (Caro, 1980a,b). It certainly seems plausible that playing with objects might improve adult predation only if kittens concurrently achieve a certain degree of competence or familiarity with prey items. Bruner (1973) has postulated a similar set of interactions between “mastery play” and other factors involved in the development of skilled manipulative actions in human infants. Specifically, Bruner suggests that a child’s ability to copy adult behavior and incorporate it into play (whereby manipulative skills can be developed) depends on the child initially having a certain degree of competence at the task in question. In addition, Bruner argues, the child’s ability to develop skilled action through play will undoubtedly be affected by a variety of social factors such as maternal encouragement and other aspects of the home environment.
VI.
METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES
It should be apparent from our survey that few general statements about the functions of play can currently be supported by any solid empirical evidence. Very little is actually known about either the biological costs and benefits of play or its role in development. In particular, the following questions can currently be answered only tentatively and incompletely: (1) What are the benefits of play? (2) Does play have one or more beneficial effects-in other words, is play a developmental determinant with specific or general effects on behavior? (3) Are the beneficial effects of play immediate or are they delayed in ontogeny, accruing mostly to the adult’? (4) What are the biological costs of play and how important are they relative to other forms of activity’? In particular, does play incur significant survivorship costs’? ( 5 ) Is play a homogeneous set of behavior patterns in terms of its proximate causation, development, and function, or are several unrelated types of behavior being mistakenly lumped together‘? Clearly, there is a pressing need for these and other questions to be addressed empirically. In the hope that such experimental work will be carried out, we offer some
94
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M . C A R 0
methodological suggestions which stem directly from the views advanced in this article.
A. CONFOUNDING VARIABLES To answer questions about the functions of play it will, of course, be necessary to perform experiments in which various aspects of early play experience are manipulated and the consequences for other forms of behavior are assessed. Crude deprivation experiments, in which animals are deprived of all opportunities for play, suffer considerably from the problem of confounding variables. Any procedure which deprives a young mammal of all opportunities for, say, social play will inevitably alter many other potentially important factors as well, including all other forms of social experience, motor activity, sensory stimulation, stress, and (probably) nutrition and temperature (see Bekoff, 1976a). Thus, if differences are found between play-deprived and normally reared animals, this alone does not constitute evidence for the importance of play per se. In Bekoff‘s (1976a) phraseology, it is difficult to know “who is being deprived of what” in such a deprivation study. Nonetheless, the deprivation procedure should not be dismissed out of hand, since this method is in principle capable of providing useful i n f ~ r m a t i o n In . ~ particular, a series of selective deprivation experiments, each focusing on a different aspect of playful experience, could be very informative. A subtle approach is needed, in which specific components of play experience are manipulated and a variety of other behavior patterns (the outcome variables) are measured quantitatively. A number of different experimental techniques appear promising, including ( 1) selective enrichment or selective deprivation of opportunities for particular types of play (e.g., Caro, 1980a); (2) the use of drugs such as chlorpromazine and amphetamine to modify the behavior of social play partners (Einon et al., 1978); (3) the use of objects with different physical properties in studies of object play, for example, comparing the consequences of playing with toys which are predictable versus unpredictable, hazardous versus safe, preylike versus nonpreylike, fast-moving versus slow, complex versus simple, or passive versus reactive; and (4) altering the rearing environment so as 4Specifically. a deprivation experiment can demonstrate that a particular type of early experience (such as play) is nor necessary for some other form of behavior (such as predation) to develop (Lorenz, 1965, p.107). However, it is important not to confuse outcome (which is measured) with process (which is not). A deprivation experiment cannot show that an early experience is not involvcd in development under normal circumstances, since the deprived animal might have been forced to develop in a different way. In other words, there may be more than one developmental route leading to the same end point (see Section V , B). As Bateson (1981) points out, to contend that an early experience is not involved in development when it is available “would be like arguing that travellers who are forced to use bicycles because of a fuel shortage do not need petrol to run their cars.”
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
95
to vary the opportunities for particular types of locomotor play, for example, manipulating the ease with which running, climbing, or balancing on narrow surfaces is possible. Valuable information can also come from comparisons of natural populations of a species which live in different habitats (e.g., Baldwin & Baldwin, 1974, for squirrel monkeys; Berger, 1979, 1980, for bighorn sheep). Even in the most refined and carefully controlled experiment, however, some confounding variables are likely to be present. For example, in the study by Einon er al. (1978) described earlier, drugs were used to modify the behavior of rats’ social play partners, and the drugged rats presumably differed from normal social companions in many ways besides just playing differently. Hence, as the authors point out, it is incorrect to conclude from this one experiment that the lack of social play per s e affected the subsequent behavior of the experimental rats. Play cannot easily be isolated from other forms of experience, so no single experiment is likely by itself to settle a functional question conclusively. Rather, several related experiments will generally be needed, each experiment controlling for certain factors, excluding certain competing possibilities, and narrowing the range of possible explanations. In this sense, research on the functions of play is akin to work on the neural basis of memory, where detailed understanding has begun to emerge only as a result of performing a systematic series of experiments (see Horn, 1981). B.
CHOOSING OUTCOMEVARIABLES
Investigating the functions of play requires first choosing the serious behavior patterns of which play is supposed to be a developmental determinant, that is, choosing the correct outcome variables. The view of play proposed in this article suggests that outcome variables should be (a) multiple; (b) sensitive; and (c) clearly related to the hypothesized biological benefits. The need for multiple outcome variables arises because current functional hypotheses are not sufficiently specific to make precise predictions about the detailed effects of play on subsequent behavior. Several components of the serious behavior must therefore be rneasured in order to assess the role of play in its development. For example, to test the hypothesis that kittens’ object play functions as training for adult predatory behavior would require measuring several components of predation. since there are at present no n priori grounds for deciding precisely which aspects of predation may be affected by play. The need for multiple outcome measures is even more obvious in tests of the exercise hypothesis, since this predicts that play exerts beneficial effects on the performance of many motor patterns. Indeed, the more general the effects of play are predicted to be (or the vaguer the hypothesis) the more outcome variables are necessary. The need for sensitive and subtle outcome measures arises because play is,
96
PAUL MARTIN AND T. M. C A R 0
according to the arguments presented here, unlikely to be of major importance in behavioral development and may have only minor benefits. If play subtly affects the efficiency with which an act is performed or facilitates its development, rather than determining whether or not the act is performed at all, then behavioral analysis of the subsequent acts must be detailed. Crude outcome variables, such as the percentage of prey killed, are unlikely to uncover small differences between animals with different histories of play experience. A more fruitful strategy would be to search for subtle differences in, say, the efficiency with which components of predatory behavior were performed, or in the accuracy and speed of predatory motor patterns. Finally, changes in the quality or ordering of behavior patterns will not be revealed by simple frequency or latency measures-a consideration that is all the more relevant if another of play’s hypothesized functions is as a source of innovative behavior (Fagen, 1981, 1982). A third requirement is that outcome variables should be functionally relevant, that is, direct and easily interpretable measures of the hypothesized biological benefits. Any functional hypothesis makes certain predictions about the biological benefits of play, and it is these benefits which should be assessed as directly as possible. In theory, the function of any behavior pattern ought ultimately to be measured in terms of its contribution to the individual’s inclusive fitness or, more tangibly, to its lifetime reproductive success (Grafen, 1982). In experimental situations, lifetime reproductive success will usually be impossible to measure, but assessing an adaptation in terms of its proximate beneficial consequences will sometimes be a reasonable approximation (see Clutton-Brock, 1983). Some otherwise informative experiments have used outcome measures that were not directly relevant to any functional hypothesis, as, for example, in the elegant work by Einon and colleagues described earlier. These experiments showed that social isolation can produce long-term behavioral changes in rats, some of which can partially be annulled by brief periods of social contact later in development. Unfortunately, the consequences of isolation were assessed in terms of openfield measures such as habituation of object contact and locomotor activity. However, differences in open-field behavior cannot readily be interpreted in terms of biological benefits or deficits. It is far from obvious, for example, why an increase in “timidity” (as measured by slower habituation of open-field activity and object contact, or slower emergence into an unfamiliar environment) should necessarily be regarded as a behavioral deficit. Indeed, Daly (1973) has convincingly argued the converse: any small rodent which fearlessly enters a brightly lit and novel arena is, arguably, acting rnakadaptively. Thus, it is not possible to conclude from these experiments that play has particular adaptive consequences. Measures of open-field behavior, although pertinent to questions of motivation and emotionality, are difficult to assess in terms of biological function and, accordingly, are unsuitable outcome variables for the present pur-
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
97
pose (see Hinde, 1970, p.535, and, especially, Daly, 1973, for criticisms of open-field measures and their frequent misinterpretation).
VII.
SUMMARY
Play is widely assumed to be a costly juvenile activity, crucially involved in the development of adult behavioral skills and exerting major beneficial effects on serious behavior later in ontogeny. However, a review of the limited evidence reveals no strong empirical support for this view. At present, there is no direct evidence that play has any important benefits, with the possible exception of some immediate effects on children’s behavior. One explanation for this is that play does not have major benefits but is instead a facilitative developmental determinant of minor importance. In support of this view is evidence that play has only minor time and energy costs and so need have only minor benefits to be maintained by natural selection. In addition, play is highly variable and labile, both interspecifically and intraspecifically, and is very sensitive to prevailing conditions. Because play is curtailed or absent under many naturally occurring conditions, it seems unlikely that it is essential for normal development. Adults of many species also play. We see no compelling reason to assume that the principal benefits of play, whatever they may be, are delayed in ontogeny and accrue only to the adult as improved skills. This widespread assumption, embodied in all practice theories, reflects a misleading view of ontogeny in which all juvenile behavior is seen as a preparation for adulthood. On the contrary, play may be adaptive because of its immediate or short-term benefits to the juvenile and may have no consistent, important, or predictable long-term consequences. At the very least, more attention should be paid to the consequences of play for the juvenile. Other possible reasons why no benefits of play have yet been detected are also discussed. Behavioral development may be well buffered against variation in play experience (equifinality); the effects of play may be nonspecific; the benefits of play may be manifested in structurally dissimilar forms of adult behavior; and the benefits may only be realized through interaction with other variables or if particular thresholds are attained. Current definitions of play are inadequate and reflect a deep conceptual muddle. In practice, the essence of the current concept of play seems to be a subjective interpretation on the part of the observer that the behavior has no obvious immediate benefits. A general definition of play is proposed which explicitly incorporates this notion. Methodological issues are also discussed, including the problem of confounding variables and the need for multiple, sensitive, and functionally relevant outcome measures in future experiments. If, as we suggest, play is a marginal activity, performed only as long as its benefits outweigh its costs, then play may be a
98
PAUL M A R T I N A N D T. M . C A R 0
useful and sensitive index of other aspects of behavioral development. These arguments are presented in the hope that they will provoke further enquiry. Play remains a biological enigma and deserves the serious attention of anyone seeking to understand the development and functions of behavior.
Acknowledgments The first draft of this article was written while PM was a Harkness Fellow at Stanford University and while TMC held a Royal Society scientific investigations grant. We are very grateful to the following people for kindly reading and commenting on the manuscript: Patrick Bateson, Marc Bekoff, Gordon Burghardt, Robert Fagen, Robert Hinde, Harriet Sants, and Peter Smith.
References Abbey, H., & Howard, E. (1973). Statistical procedures in developmental studies on species with multiple offspring. Dev. Psyclzobiol. 6, 329-335. Aldis, 0. (1975). “Play Fighting.” New York: Academic Press. Baerends-van Roon, J. M., & Baerends, G. P. (1979). The morphogenesis of’the behuvior ofthe domestic cut. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ. Baldwin, J . D., & Baldwin. J. I. (1973). The role of play in social organization: Comparative observations of squirrel monkeys (Suimiri). Primates 14, 369-38 I . Baldwin, J . D., & Baldwin, J . I . (1974). Exploration and social play in squirrel monkeys (Suimiri). Am. Zoo/. 14, 303-315. Baldwin, J. D., & Baldwin, J . I . (1976). Effects of food ecology o n social play: A laboratory simulation. Z. Tierp.rvchul. 40, I - 14. Baldwin, J . D., & Baldwin, J. 1. (1977). The role of learning phenomena in the ontogeny of exploration and play. In S. Chevalier-Skolnikoff & F. E. Poirier (Eds. ), Prirnute hio-sociul developmen/ (pp.343-406). New York: Garland. Barrett, P., & Bateson. P. (1978). The development of play in cats. Behuviour 66, 106-120. Bateson, P. P. G. (1976a). Spec ity and the origins of behavior. Adv. Stucfv Behav. 6, 1-20. Bateson, P. P. G . (l976b). Rules and reciprocity in behavioural development. In P. P. G. Bateson & R. A. Hinde (Eds.), Growing points in ethnlogv. (pp.401-421). London and New York: Cambridge Univ. Press. Bateson, P. P. G. (1979). How do sensitive periods arise and what are they for’?Anim. Behuv. 27, 470-486. Bateson, P. (1981). Ontogeny. In D. McFarland (Ed.), The Oxford conipunion t o unifnul behuviour (pp.414-426). London and New York: Oxford Univ. Press. Bateson, P., Martin, P., & Young, M. (1981). Effects of interrupting cat mothers’ I bromocriptine on the subsequent play of their kittens. Physiol. Belruv. 27, 841-845. Bateson, P., & Young. M. (1981). Separation from the mother and the development of play in cats. Anbn. Behuv. 29, 173-180. Beach, F. A . (1945). Current concepts of play in animals. Am Nut. 79, 523-541. Bekoff. M. (1972). The development of social interaction, play and metacommunication in mammals: An ethological perspective. Q . Rev. B i d . 47, 412-434. Bekoff. M. (1976a). The social deprivation paradigm: Who’s being deprived of what? Dev. Psvchoh i d . 9. 499-500.
PLAY IN BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT
99
Bekoff, M. (1976b). Animal play: Probrems and perspectives. In P. P. G . Bateson & P. H. Klopfer (Eds.), Perspectives in ethology (Vol. 2, pp. 165-188). New York: Plenum. Bekoff. M. (1984). Social play behavior. BioScience 34, 228-233. Bekoff, M., & Byers, J. A. (1981). A critical reanalysis of the ontogeny and phylogeny of mammalian social and locomotor play: An ethological hornet's nest. In K . Immelmann, G . W. Barlow, L. Petrinovich, & M. Main (Eds.), Behavioral development (pp.296-337). London and New York: Cambridge Univ. Press. Berger. I. (1979). Social ontogeny and behavioural diversity: Consequences for Bighorn Sheep Ovis canadensis inhabiting desert and mountain environments.