ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR A N D CELL BIOLOGY
Volume 75B
1996
BIOCHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank...
58 downloads
1838 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR A N D CELL BIOLOGY
Volume 75B
1996
BIOCHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN MOLECULAR AND CELL BIOLOGY BIOCHEMICAL TECHNOLOGY Series Editor: E. EDWARD BITTAR Department of Physiology University of Wisconsin Madison, Wisconsin
Guest Editors: BENGT DANIELSSON LElF BULOW Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center Lund University Lund, Sweden
VOLUME 15B
1996
@ JAl PRESS INC. Greenwich, Connecticut
London, England
Copyright 0 1996 by ]A/ PRESS INC. 55 Old Post Road No. 2 Greenwich, Connecticut 06836 JAl PRESS LTD. The Courtyard 28 High Street Hampton Hill, Middlesex TW12 1PD England All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored on a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, filming, recording, or otherwise, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. ISBN: 0-7623-01 14-7 Manufactured in the United States of America
CONTENTS (Volume 15B) ...
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Xlll
PREFACE Klaus Mosbach
xxvii
INTRODUCTION
xxxiii IV. BIOSENSORS
BIOSENSORS: AN INTRODUCTION Bengt Danielsson
349
OVERVIEW OF BIOSENSOR TECHNOLOGY Frieder W. Scheller, Ulla Wollenberger, Dorothy Pfeiffer, and Florian Schubert
353
CURRENT STATE OF BIOSENSORS George G. Guilbault
365
BIOSENSORS AND MICROMACHINING lsao Karube, Kenji Yokoyama, Yuji Murakami, and Masayuki Suda
375
RECYCLING SENSORS BASED ON KINASES Ulla Wollenberger, Florian Schubert, Dorothea Pfeiffer, and Frieder W. Scheller
381
ELECTRON CONDUCTING ADDUCTS OF WATER-SOLUBLE REDOX POLYELECTROLYTES AND ENZYMES loanis Katakis, Mark Vreeke, Ling Ye, Atsushi Aoki, and Adam Heller
391
CONTENTS (Volume 156)
vi
SCREENING AND DESIGN OF IMMOBILIZED BIOCATALYSTS BY MEANS OF KINETIC CHARACTERIZATION ON ENZYME THERMISTOWHERMAL ASSAY PROBE Peter Germeiner, Vladimir Stefuca, and Bengt Danielsson
41 1
AMPEROMETRIC BIOSENSORS BASED ON CARBON PASTE ELECTRODES CHEMICALLY MODIFIED WITH REDOX ENZYMES L. Gorton, G. Marko-Varga, 6. Persson, Z. Huan, H. Lid& E. Burestedt, S. Ghobadi, M. Smolander, S. Sahni, and T. Skotheim
42 1
ENZYME BASED DIFFUSION BADGE FOR THE DETECTION OF FORMALDEHYDE R. Feldbrugge, K.P. Rindt, and A. Borchert
45 1
BlOSENSlNG OF HEAVY METAL IONS BASED ON SPECIFIC INTERACTIONS WITH APOENZYMES lkuo Satoh
461
DESIGN OF HIGH-ANNEALING TEMPERATURE PCR PRIMERS AND THEIR USE IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF A VERSATILE LOW-COPY NUMBER AMPLIFICATION PROTOCOL Michael W. Mecklenburg
473
ON-LINE MONITORING OF INDUSTRIAL FERMENTATIONSUSING A SPLIT-FLOW MODIFIED THERMAL BIOSENSOR M. Rank and B. Danielsson
491
MINIATURlZED THERMAL BIOSENSORS U. Hedberg, B. Xie, and B. Danielsson
499
V. AFFINITY TECHNIQUES FOR SEPARATION A N D BlORECOCNlTlON INTRODUCTORY REMARKS Per-Olof Larsson
509
Contents (Volume 158)
vii
AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY A N D RELATED TECHNIQUES, PERSPECTIVES, A N D TRENDS Christopher R. Lowe
51 3
ONE-STEP AFFINITY PURIFICATION OF A RECOMBINANT CYCLODEXTRIN GLYCOSYL TRANSFERASE BY (Cu[IIl, Zn[IIl TANDEM COLUMN) IMMOBILIZED METAL ION AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY F! Berna, F.F. Moraes, J.N. Barbotin, D. Thomas, and M.A. Vijayalakshmi
523
AFFINITY PURIFICATION OF ENZYMES USING TEMPERAT URE-I NDUC ED PHASE S EPARATION Folke Tjerneld
539
POSSIBLE BINDING SITES ON PROTEINS INVOLVED IN THlOPHlLlC ADSORPTION Alexander Schwarz and Meir Wilchek
547
NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR USING IMMOBILIZED LIGANDS TO CHARACTERIZE MACROMOLECULAR RECOGNITION A N D DESIGN RECOGNITION MOLECULES Irwin Chaiken, David Myszyka, and Thomas Morton
553
PEPTIDES: MULTIPLE PURPOSE TOOLS Jean-Luc Fauch&re
569
SUPERPOROUS AGAROSE--A NEW MATERIAL FOR CHROMATOGRAPHY Per-Olof Larsson
585
HYDROPHILIC A N D AMPHIPHATIC MONOMERS AND USE OF THEIR GELS AS SEPARATION MEDIA Branko Kozulic and Urs Heimgartner
593
AN INTEGRATED APPROACH IN THE ANALYTICAL DESCRIPTION OF AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY, BIOSENSORS, IMMOBILIZED BIOCATALYSTS, A N D SIMILAR SYSTEMS Volker Kasche
605
CONTENTS (Volume 15B)
viii
VI. MOLECULAR RECOGNITION MOLECULAR RECOGNITION: AN INTRODUCTION Ian A. Nicholls
62 1
THE ROLE OF GEOMETRIC FIT BETWEEN PROTEIN MOLECULES AND THEIR LIGANDS IN DETERMINING BIOLOGICAL SPEC1FlClTY Ephraim Katchalski-Katzir, lssac Shariv, Miriam Eisenstein, Asher A. Friesem, Claude Aflalo, and llya A. Vakser
623
MODELS OF THE BINDING SITES OF ENZYMES: TEMPLATE INDUCED PREPARATION OF SPECIFIC BINDING SITES IN CROSSLINKED POLYMERS Gunter Wulff
639
MOLECULAR IMPRINTING: THE CURRENT STATUS AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENT OF POLYMER-BASED RECOGNITION SYSTEMS Lars I. Andersson, Ian A. Nicholls, and Klaus Mosbach
65 1
AN APPROACH TOWARD THE SEMIQUANTITATION OF MOLECULAR RECOGNITION PHENOMENA IN NON-COVALENT MOLECULARLY IMPRINTED POLYMER SYSTEMS: CONSEQUENCES FOR MOLECULARLY IMPRINTED POLYMER DESIGN Ian A. Nicholls
669
CONTENTS (Volume 15A) ...
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Xlll
PREFACE Klaus Mosbach
xxvii
INTRODUTION
xxxiii
1. ENZYME TECHNOLOGY ENZYMOLOGY-AN INTRODUCTION Mats-Olle Mdnsson
3
TAILORING THE MICROENVIRONMENT OF ENZYMES IN WATER-POOR MEDIA Bo Mattiasson, Patrick Adlercreutz, Ernst Wehtje, and Marina Otamiri
5
MODIFICATION OF ENZYMES AND PROTEINS WITH BlOlMPRlNTlNG PROCEDURES Mats-Olle Mdnsson
15
A NEW KIND OF ABZYMES: ANTI-IDIOTYPIC ANTIBODIES EXHIBITING CATALYTIC ACTIVITIES Alain Friboulet, Catherine Bedel-Cloutour, and Daniel Thomas
23
MODULATION OF THE CATALYTIC PATHWAY OF CARBOXYPEPTIDASE A BY CONJUGATION WITH POLYVINYLALCOHOLS Beka Solomon and Leon Goldstein
33
NEURAL NETWORKS IN ENZYMOLOGY Yi-HongZhu, Susan Linko, and Pekka Linko
47
ix
CONTENTS (Volume 15A)
X
MODERN ENZYMOLOGY OF PLANT PEROXIDASES I.G. Gazaryan and A.M. Egorov
59
CAPACITY OF THE YEAST TRIGONOPSIS VARIABILIS (DSM 70714) FOR THE ENANTIOSELECTIVE REDUCTION OF ORGANOSILICON COMPOUNDS Lutz Fischer
69
TWO-STEP SULFATE-ENHANCED REFOLDING: RECOMBI NANT Pneumocystis carinii DIHYDROFOLATE REDUCTASE Michel Goldberg, Lawrence A. Greenstein, Avigdor Levanon, and Moshe M. Werber
79
MARINE BIOTECHNOLOGY BASED ON MARINE MICROORGANISMS Koji Sode, 1. Grant Burgess, and Tadashi Matsunaga
95
ENZYME ENGINEERING-THEN AND N O W PV: Sundaram
103
REFLECTIONS ON THE HISTORY A N D SCIENTIFIC CHARACTER OF BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING Klaus Buchholz
117
PART II. IMMOBILIZED CATALYSTS
IMMOBILIZED BIOCATALYSTS: A N INTRODUCTION Staffan Birnbaum
137
B I OT RA NS FORMAT10NS USING IMM0B ILIZED BIOCATALYSTS-PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE Malcolm D. Lilly
141
INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS OF IMMOBILIZED BIOCATALYSTS AND BIOMATERIALS lchiro Chibata
151
PREPARATION OF IMMOBILIZED PROTEINS COVALENTLY COUPLED THROUGH SILANE COUPLING AGENTS TO INORGANIC SUPPORTS Howard H. Weetall
161
Contents (Volume 75B)
xi
LONG -T ERM STA BI LI TY 0F C0NTI NU0USLY PERFUSED ANIMAL CELLS IMMOBILIZED ON NOVEL MACROPOROUS MICROCA RR I ERS H.Katinger, A. Assadian, G. Bliiml, N. Borth, A. Buchacher, 0. Doblhoff, T. Gaida, M. Reiter, C. Schmatz, K. Strutzenberger, W. Steinfellner, F. Unterluggauer, and N. Zach
193
EFFECTS OF IMMOBILIZATION ON THE CATALYTIC PROPERTIES A N D STABILITIES OF ENZYMES. A SURVEY B. Szajdni, L. Boross, M. Abrahdm, and L.M. Simon
209
CHARACTERISTICS OF LACCASE IMMOBILIZED ON DIFFERENT SUPPORTS FOR WINE-MAKING TECHNOLOGY A. Lante, A. Crapisi, G. Pasini, A. Zamorani, and P Spettoli
229
LlGNlN PEROXIDASE PRODUCTION WITH A N IMMOBILIZED FUNGUS BIOREACTOR Susan Linko and Reetta Haapala
237
CHELATE MEDl ATE D I MMOBI L lZATl0N 0F PROTEINS Dieter Kirstein
247
111. ENZYMATIC ASPECTS OF CELLULAR METABOLISM
ENZYMATIC ASPECTS OF CELLULAR METABOLISM: AN INTRODUCTION Leif Bulow
259
ARE SUBSTRATES CHANNELED IN THE KREBS CITRIC ACID CYCLE? Paul A. Srere, Richard D. Brodeur, Craig R. Malloy, A. Dean Sherry, and Balazs Sumegi
263
xii
CONTENTS (Volume 15A)
INTERACTION BETWEEN CH LOROPLAST PHOSPHOGLYCERATE KINASE A N D GLYCERALDEHYDE-3-PHOSPHATE DEHYDROC ENASE Louise E. Anderson, Xiao-yi Tang, Gote Johansson, Xingwu Wang, lvano A. Marques, and jerzy Macioszek
2 73
METABOLIC CONTROL ANALYSIS IN SITU: PROBLEMS AND PARADIGMS G. Rickey Welch
281
METABOLIC ENGl NEERlN G James E. Bailey
289
"TOGETHERNESS" BETWEEN PROTEINS GENERATED BY GENE FUSION Leif Bulow, Helen Carlsson, Peter Ljungcrantz, Mats Persson, and Christer Lindbladh
297
THE ESCHERlCHlA COLl CHAPERONE DNAK: PROPERTIES AND POTENTIALS Sven-Olof Enfors, Kristina Gustavsson, Shaojun Yang, and Andres Veide
31 1
ELICITATION OF CULTIVATED PLANT CELLS AS A TOOL IN BIOTECHNOLOGY AND BASIC BIOCHEMISTRY Peter E. Brodelius
319
INHIBITION OF PLANT GROWTH BY THE TETRAPEPTIDE DES-ARC ENTEROSTATIN (VPDP) Charlotte Erlanson-Albertssonand Per-Ake Albertsson
341
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
M. Abraha’m
Department of Biochemistry Attila J6zsef University, Szeged, Hungary
Patrick Adlecreutz
Department of Biotechnology Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Claude A flalo
Department of Biochemistry The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
Per-Ake Albertsson
Department of Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Louise E. Anderson
Department of Biological Sciences University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, I IIinois
Lars 1. Anderson
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University, Lund, Sweden
Atsushi Aoki
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Texas Austin, Texas
A. Assadian
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agricu I tu re Vienna, Austria
lames E. Bailey
Institute of Biotechnology ETH-Honggerberg Zurich, Switzerland
...
Xlll
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
xiv
J. N. Barbotin
Laboratoire de Technologie Enzymatique Universite de Technologie de Compiegne Centre de Recherche de Royallieu G6nie Biologique Compiegne, France
P. Bema
Laboratoire Interaction M o l h l a i r e et de Technologie de Separation Universite de Technologie de Compiegne Centre de Recherche de Royallieu Genie Biologique Compiegne, France
Staffan Birnbaum
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
G.Bluml
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
A. Borchert
FH-Ostfriesland Emden, Germany
L. Bososs
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry University for Horticulture and Food Industry Budapest, Hungary
N. Borth
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
Peter E. Brodelius
Department of Plant Biochemistry Lund University Lund, Sweden
Richard D. Brodeur
Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center Dallas, Texas
A. Buchacher
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
xv
List of Contributors Klaus Buchholz
lnstitut fur Landwirdschaftlische Technologie und Zuckerindustrie Technical University Braunschweig Braunschweig, Germany
). Grant Burgess
Department of Biotechnology Faculty of Technology Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology Tokyo, Japan
Leif Bulow
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
E. Burestedt
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
He/& Carlsson
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Irwin Chaiken
SmithKline Beecham Pharmaceuticals King of Prussia, Pennsylvania
lchiro Chibata
Tanabe Seiyako Co. Ltd. Osaka, Japan
A. Crapisi
Dipartimento di Biotecnologie Agrarie Universiti di Padova Padova, Italy
Bengt Danielsson
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
0. Doblhoff
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
xv i
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
A. M . Egorov
Chemical Department Moscow State University Moscow, Russia
Miriam Eisenstein
Department of Structural Biology The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
Sven-Olof Enfors
Department of Biochemistry and Biotechnology Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden
Charlotte Erlanson-Albertsson
Department of Medical and Physiological Chemistry Lund University Lund, Sweden
Jean-Luc FauchPre
lnstitut de Recherches Servier Paris, France
R. Feldbrijgge
lnstitut fur Chemo- and Biosensorik Munster Roxel, Germany
Lutz Fischer
Institute of Biochemistry and 6 iotechnology Technical University of Braunschweig Braunschweig, Germany
Alain Friboulet
Laboratoire de Technologie Enzymatique Universitt5 de Technologie de Compiegne Compiegne, Cedex, France
Asher A. Friesem
Department of Electronics The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
7;
Gaida
1. G. Gazaryan
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria Chemical Department Moscow State University Moscow, Russia
xvii
List of Contributors Peter Gernejner
Institute of Chemistry Slovak Academy of Sciences B ratislava, Slovakia
S. Ghobadi
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Michel Goldberg
Bio-Technology General Kiryat Weitzman Rehovot, Israel
Leon Goldstein
Department of Molecular Microbiology and Biotechnology Tel Aviv University Ramat Aviv, Israel
Lo Gorton
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center Lund University Lund, Sweden
Lawrence A. Greenstein
Bio-Technology General Kiryat Weitzman Rehovot, Israel
George Guilbault
Department of Chemistry University of New Orleans New Orleans, Louisiana
Kristina Gustavsson
Department of Biochemistry and B iotechnology Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden
Reetta Haapala
Laboratory of Biotechnology and Food Engineering Helsinki University Espoo, Finland
Ulrika Harborn
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center Lund. Sweden
xviii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTOR!
Urs Heimgartner
Elchrom AG Horgen, Switzerland
Adam Heller
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Texas Austin, Texas
Z. Huan
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Gote Johansson
Department of Biochemistry University of Lund Lund. Sweden
lsao Karube
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology University of Tokyo Tokyo, japan
Volker Kasche
AB Biotechnologie I I Hamburg, Germany
loanis Katakis
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Texas Austin, Texas
Ephraim KatchaIski- Katzir
Department of Membrane Research and Biophysics The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
H. Katinger
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
Dieter Kirstein
Max Delbruck Center for Molecular Medicine University of Potsdam lnstiutte of Biochemistry and Molecular Physiology Berlin, Germany
Branko Kozulic
Elchrom AG Horgen, Switzerland
xix
List of Contributors
A. Lante
Dipartimento d i B iotecnologie Agra r ie Universith di Padova Padova, Italy
Per-Olof Larsson
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
A. Levanon
Bio-technology General Kiryat Weizman Rehovot, Israel
G. Lilius
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Malcolm D. Lilly
The Advanced Centre for Biochemical Engineering Department of Chemical and Biochemical Engineering University College London London, England
Christer Lindbladh
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
H. Lind6n
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Pekka Linko
Laboratory of Biotechnology and Food Engineering Helsinki University of Technology Espoo, Finland
Susan Linko
Laboratory of Biotechnology and Food Engineering Helsinki University of Technology, ESPOO, Finland
xx
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Peter Ljungcrantz
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center,-Lund University Lund, Sweden
Christopher R. Lowe
Institute of Biotechnology University of Cambridge Cambridge, England
Jerzy Maciozek
Department of Biological Sciences University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, IIIinois
Craig R. Malloy
The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas Rogers Magnetic Resonance Center Dallas, Texas
Mats-Olfe Mdnsson
Department of Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
G. Marko-Varga
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
fvano A. Marques
Department of Biological Sciences University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, I I Iinois
Tadashi Matsunaga
Department of Biotechnology Faculty of Technology Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology Tokyo, Japan
Bo Mattiasson
Department of Biotechnology Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Michael Mecklenburg
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
xxi
List of Contributors
F. F. Moraes
Departamento Engenharia Quimica Universidad Estadual de Maringa Maringa, Parana, Brasil
Klaus Mosbach
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Thomas Morton
SmithKline Beecham Pharmaceuticals King of Prussia, Pennsylvania
Yuji Murakami
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology University of Tokyo 441 Komaba, Tokyo 153, Japan
David Myszka
SmithKline Beecham Pharmaceuticals King of Prussia, Pennsylvania
Ian A. Nicholls
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Marina Otamiri
Department of Biotechnology Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
G. Pasini
Dipartimento di Biotecnologie Agrarie UniversitA di Padova Padova, Italy
Mats Persson
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University L und, Sweden
B. Persson
Department of Analytical Chemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
Dorothea Pfeiffer
Max Delbruck Center for Molecular Medicine Berlin, Germany
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
xxii
M. Rank
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
M. Reiter
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
Klaus P Rindt
Dragenwerk AG Lubeck, Germany
S. Sahni
Moltech Corporation Stony Brook, New York
lkuo Satoh
Department of Chemical Technology Kanagawa Institute of Technology Kanagawa-ken, Japan
Frieder W. Scheller
Max Delbruck Center for Molecular Medicine Berlin, Germany
C. Schmatz
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
Florian Schubert
Physikal isch-Technische Bundesanstalt Berlin, Germany
Alexander Schwarz
Department of Membrane Research and Biophysics Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
Isaac Shariv
Department of Electronics The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
A. Dean Sherry
Department of Chemistry The University of Texas at Dallas Richardson, Texas
L. M. Simon
Department of Biochemistry Attila Jdzsef University Szeged, Hungary
xxiii
List of Contributors
T. Skotheim
Moltech Corporation Stony Brook, New York
M. Smolander
Biotechnical Laboratory Technical Research Centre ESPOO, Finland
Koji Sode
Department of Biotechnology Faculty of Technology Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology Tokyo, Japan
Beka Solomon
Department of Molecular Microbiology and Biotechnology Tel Aviv University Ramat Aviv, Israel
P. Spettoli
Oipartimento di Biotecnologie Agrarie Universita di Padova Padova, Italy
Paul A. Srere
Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center Dallas, Texas
Vladimir Stefuca
Institute of Chemistry Slovak Academy of Sciences Bratislava, Slovakia
W. Steinfellner
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
K. Strutzenberger
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agricu Iture Vienna, Austria
M. Suda
Seiko Instruments Inc. Chiba, Japan
Balasz Sumegi
Department of Biochemistry University Medical School Pecs, Hungary
xxiv
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
P.V. Sundaram
Centre for Protein Engineering and Biomedical Research The Voluntary Health Services Madras, India
8.Szajdni
Reanal Factory of Laboratory Chemicals Budapest, Hungary
Xiao-yi Tang
Shanghai Institute of Plant Physiology Academia Sinica Shanghai, China
0. Thomas
Laboratoire de Technologie Enzymatique Universite de Technologie de Compiegne Centre de Recherche de Royallieu, Genie Biologique Compiegne, Cedex, France
Folke oerneld
Department of Biochemistry Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
F. Unterluggauer
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
llya A. Vakser
Department of Membrane Research and Biophysics The Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
Andres Veide
Department of Biochemistry and Biotechnology Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden
M. A. VQayalakshmi
Laboratoire Interaction Moleculaire et de Technologie de Sbparation Universite de Technologie de Compikgne Centre de Recherche de Royallieu Genie Biologique Compiegne, Cedex, France
Mark Vreeke
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Texas Austin, Texas
xxv
List of Contributors
Xingwu Wang
Department of Biological Sciences University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, Illinois
Howard H. Weetall
National Institute of Standards and Technology Biotechnology Division Gaithersburg, Maryland
Ernst Wehtje
Department of Biotechnology Chemical Center, Lund University Lund, Sweden
G. Rickey Welch
Department of Biological Sciences University of New Orleans New Orleans. Louisiana
Moshe M. Werber
Bio-Technology General (Israel), Ltd. Kiryat Weizmann Rehovot, Israel
Meir Wilchek
Department of Membrane Research and Biophysics Weizmann Institute of Science Rehovot, Israel
Ulla Wollenberger
Frauenhofer Institute for Microstructure Technique Berlin, Germany
Gunter Wulff
Institute of Organic Chemistry and Macromolecular Chemistry Heinrich-Heine University Dusseldorf, Germany
9.Xie
Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden
Shaojun Yang
Department of Biochemistry and Biotechnology Royal Institute of Technology Stockholm, Sweden
xxvi
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS
Ling Ye
Department of Chemical Engineering University of Texas Austin, Texas
Zhu Yi-Hong
Laboratory of Biotechnology and Food Engineering Helsinki University of Technology ESPOO, Finland
Kenji Yokoyama
Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology University of Tokyo Tokyo, Japan
N. Zach
Institute of Applied Microbiology University of Agriculture Vienna, Austria
A. Zamorani
Dipartimento di Biotecnologie Agrarie Universiti di Padova Padova, Italy
PREFACE I understand it to be quite unusual for a man to whom a Festschrift has been dedicated to contribute himself. However, as I listened during the symposium to the many superb lectures in various disciplines, areas in which we have worked over the years, a number ofreflections came to my mind which I would like to share with the reader. Maybe some lessons can be learned from “our past” which may be of guidance for others in their planning for the future, both positive and negative experiences. First, though, I would like to take the opportunity to thank all the contributors and guests, from Sweden and abroad, and to express my sincerest gratitude to the organizers of the symposium. These were very intense days for me. During conferences or symposia I normally slip away from some lectures simply to have a break. On this occasion this would have seemed very impolite of me (and to make things worse I was seated in the front row). However, during this symposium there was not even a thought in this direction, all the lecturers influenced me greatly and left me with a deep sense of indebtedness to them for taking the time from their many other pressing tasks to participate in this Symposium. Well, a year ahead of the symposium, I was puzzled to notice that my senior co-workers, Professors Bulow, Danielsson, Larsson and Mhsson, were holding frequent meetings in our small library. Each time I entered the room they turned completely quiet. At one time I was even afraid they were plotting against me, maybe because they felt neglected due to my heavy travelling commitments and wanted another head of the department. I then found out, however, that they were xxvii
xxviii
PREFACE
planning for this symposium, which they as organizers chose to call “Symposium on Biochemical Technology.” I feel they chose a worthwhile title and I will return to this aspect later. How did it all start? I spent most of my initial research life working with secondary natural products, in particular on their biosynthesis in fungi and lichens, the latter representing fascinating symbiotic organisms comprisingalga and fungus, of which more than 20,000 species are known today. Prior to our chancy approach using 14C-labeledC02 and other precursors, they were not considered amenable to scientific investigationsbecause of their extremely slow growth. This work resulted in an assistant professorship at the University of Lund in 1964. On the side, I spent many evenings in my father’s company in Malmo doing “moonshineresearch.” My father’s work on the use of various acrylates as polymer components in paints and in transparent coatings, made me think of trying to entrap lichen cells or enzymes in such gels. Would such entrapped biomolecules still be active? There was not much thought on how this could be used initially-it was simply fun and “play” research. Anyhow, it resulted eventually in the first publication on the use of immobilized, and more specifically entrapped, enzymes and cells for biochemical production (Mosbach and Mosbach, 1966). Slowly but surely interest grew in such immobilized preparations, and new applications were discovered. Along with these “trial and error” experiments, arising from a rather playful approach (perhaps a consequence of my music teacher’s desire to make me a concert pianist) and my later concentration on more specific applications,I have always been concerned by fundamental scientific questions. A particular interest of mine has been to try to understand the many aspects of metabolic events and cycles taking place in a living cell; this is an interest the foundation for which was laid down by my late teacher, professor Gosta Ehrensviird. Later on, when founding our institute I deliberately chose the name Pure and Applied Biochemistry,reflecting both of these aspects, a combination of mutual benefit scientifically, and useful not least from a funding point of view. The variety of topics the organizers have included in this symposium, enzyme technology, immobilized biocatalysts, enzymatic aspects of cellular metabolism, biosensors, separation and molecular recognition seems heterogeneous at first sight. However, there is a common “thread” or denominator for all the different aspects as they practically all concern binding or immobilization in some manner. Thus, having come to grips with immobilization technology per se, we started applying this know-how in many areas. 1will mention only briefly here some early efforts carried out mainly with the organizers of this meeting or former students. For instance, once we understood how to immobilize enzymes (immobilized biocatalysts), an obvious extension was to immobilize two or more acting in sequence in proximity to one another, thereby mimicking metabolic multi-step systems (Mosbach and Mattiasson, 1970). Later, as an extension of these studies,
Preface
xxix
and as a reflection of our interest in the topic of enzymatic aspects of cellular metabolism, the preparation of enzyme complexes by gene fusion was undertaken (Bulow et al., 1985). Living microorganisms were applied for steroid transformations followed by many other studies in the area of enzyme technology (Mosbach and Larsson, 1970). Subsequently plant cells were immobilized (Brodelius et al., 1979) as well as animal cells (Nilsson et al., 1983). Influenced by the strong tradition at Lund University in microcalorimetry pioneered by Professor I. Wadso, and having the techniqueof immobilization at hand, it was only obvious to combine these two technologies. This led to the development of the enzyme thermistor, a new biosensor, capable of measuring heat evolved from enzymic or metabolic reactions (Mosbach and Danielsson, 1974). During the most hectic period in which we “played” with immobilization of all sorts of molecules, the potential of such preparations for purification purposes became obvious. I must say, though, that these studies were initially met with skepticism. I particularly remember one Nobel laureate, with whom I worked for some time, telling me when I asked whether he believed this concept could be of any use, “Why complicate things by binding an inhibitor to a bead to purify an enzyme? Look, we get our enzyme in pure crystalline form simply by ammonium sulfate precipitation.” Perhaps in those days I had too much respect for authority, so I waited for a while, during which the area, later to become known as affinity chromatography, gained popularity and recognition. Thus, I decided to focus on more general aspects of this technique; for instance, the affinity ligand. With new enzymes which have to be isolated it is uncommon to have an inhibitor initially, rather, only the substrate is known (Brodelius and Mosbach, 1973).Another aspect studied was the use of general ligands such as coenzymes, as they can be applied potentially for many enzymes (Mosbach et al., 1971). Thus, our interest inseparation developed in the department. In parallel with these investigations we looked into various ways of achieving the ultimate goal in separation technology, that is being able to design tailor-made specific adsorbents.We tested and pursued several approaches over many years and with varying intensity. One has been to make specific imprints in plastics of the molecule later to be “fished out,” an area only recently to have achieved practical utility. In order to be able to design more powerful affinity ligands and better understand these interactions, molecular recognition became of growing importance to us. After this brief account of “our history,” I would like to comment on the title. The organizers have deliberately chosen as a general title for this symposium “Biochemical Technology.” I consider this an appropriate one, as it should not be as broad a term as biotechnology. For instance, it precludes engineeringaspects and large-scale operations, and correctly reflects the ongoing work at this department. An alternativetitle would have been “applied biochemistry” but this does not sound as “catchy.” In this context, I mention a meeting to which I was invited and which
xxx
PREFACE
was organized as early as 1981 in Japan on “towards the establishment of biomolecular technology.” This title, “biomolecular technology,” has also its merits (although it may appear less multidisciplinary than biochemical technology. For example, the area of biosensors would not fit into it as well). (Incidentally, the meeting dealt with two aspects, genetic engineering with invited lectures by Professors C. Weissmann, S . Numa, J. Schell and D.V. Goeddel and enzyme technology with Professor Fukui as chairman and apart from myself Dr. I. Chibata and Professor E. Katchalski-Katzir,both of whom have taken the time to attend this meeting.) Together with the organizers of this symposium I feel that we should continue having meetings on “biochemical technology,” which should be multidisciplinary in nature and concern the search for new concepts in this field. In reflecting on our studies, we should pose the question: Have any really useful results come from them over the years? The answer is definitely yes. We have received many patents, Swedish and international companies have adopted and exploited techniques and procedures in various areas. Our approach has been to find interested partners as soon as possible as we do not (and are not supposed to) have experience of optimization or scale-up technology. At times the search for partners has been very diffkult and time-consuming. In a few cases the formation of start-up companies has been chosen as an alternative. This too, however, has not always been easy. It is a source of constant frustration that Europe does not have a tradition of capital investment like the United States. In closing, let me express my thoughts on what direction(s) I would like the department to pursue in the future. I feel strongly that aspects of biomolecular recognition will increase in importance both for the understandingof biomolecules and for their increased application. Increasingly, we will make use of ways to manipulate biomolecules, for instance enzymes and polynucleotides, to change their properties. We may do this indirectly by means of genetic engineeringbut also directly, physically, using for instance atomic force microscopy or similar techniques. With all due respect for Mother Nature it should be possible to change even lifeforms. This may be done for example by creating new and more efficient biochemical pathways or multienzyme-coenzymecomplexes using fused enzymes. Not only the “normal” biochemical building blocks, amino acids, sugars, nucleotides etc. should be used; these may in part be replaced by “unnatural” molecules obtained from polymer or organic chemistry. Utilizing molecular diversity, new useful entities, for instance, drugs, may be created. We should try to overcome our conventional thinking, and not be guilty of a modern phlogiston complex. We should begin to judge compounds by looking at their functionality and shape and forget their biological or non-biological origin.
Preface
xxxi
Let me close by thanking again all of the participants, all my good friends who came, as well as my present and former co-workers and students alike for what they have done for me over the years. Klaus Mosbach University of Lund Lund, Sweden
REFERENCES Brodelius, P., & Mosbach, K. (1973). The utilization of immobilized substratdproduct in affinity chromatography. A model study using a-chymotrypsin. Acta Chem. Scand. 27.263&2638. Brodelius, P., Deus, B., Mosbach, K., & Zenk, M.H. (1979). Immobilized plant cells for the production and transformation of natural products. FEBS Lett. 103,93-97. Biilow, L., Ljungcrantz, P., & Mosbach, K. (1985). Preparation of a soluble bifunctional enzyme by gene fusion. Bio/Technology 3,821-823. Mosbach, K. & Mosbach, R. (1966). Entrapment of enzymes and microorganisms in synthetic crosslinked polymers and their application in column techniques. Acta Chem. Scand. 20.2807-2810. Mosbach, K. & Larsson, P.-0. (1970). Preparation and application of polymer-entrapped enzymes and microorganisms in microbial transformation processes with special reference to steroid 1 I -phydroxylation and A'-dehydrogenation. Biotechnol. Bioeng. XII, 19-27. Mosbach, K., & Mattiasson, B. (1970). Matrix-bound enzymes. Part 11. Studies on a matrix-bound two-enzyme-system. Acta Chem. Scand. 24,2093-2 100. Mosbach, K., Guilford, H., Ohlsson, R., & Scott, M. (1971). General ligands and (co)substrate elusion in affinity chromatography. Biochem. J. 127, 12-13. Mosbach, K., & Danielsson, B. (1974). An enzyme thermistor. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 364, 14&145. Nilsson, K., Scheirer, W., Merten, O.W., Ostberg, L., Liehl, E., Katinger, H.W.D., & Mosbach, K. (1983). Entrapment ofanimal cells for production ofmonoclonal antibodiesand other biomolecules. Nature 302,629-630.
KLAUS MOSBACH
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
INTRODUCTION In December 1992, the Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry at the Chemical Center in Lund, Sweden, organized an international meeting, the Mosbach Symposium on Biochemical Technology, to celebrate the 60th birthday of professor Klaus Mosbach, one of the founders of modern biotechnology. The history of Pure and Applied Biochemistry had its start in 1970, a couple of years after the foundation of the Chemical Center. Klaus Mosbach has been its professor and head of Pure and Applied Biochemistry since its start. During the 1980s he also maintained a professorship at the ETH in Ziirich, Switzerland.Professor Mosbach has, so far, supervised a remarkable number of Ph.D. studentsapproximately 60! Professor Mosbach is internationally well-known and he has world-leading position within the field of immobilization of bioactive substancesand cells as well as affinity chromatography. He has published about 300 original articles (not including abstracts or conference reports), about 110 review articles and he holds about 35 patents. In 1990, Professor Mosbach was awarded the gold medal by the Royal Swedish Academy of Engineering Sciences for his contributionsto biotechnology, especially on the immobilization of bioactive substances. The research activities of the Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry cover a broad area, such as affinity and separation techniques, bioprocess control, biosensors, development of new carriers and new immobilization procedures for small molecules as well as proteins and cells, including animal and plant cells, gene technology, processes based on immobilized biocatalysts, and construction of xxxiii
INTRODUCTION
xxxiv
organic polymers with enzyme-like properties. The hallmark of the department is its diversified research that generates considerable synergistic effects that are manifested by many new techniques and concepts emanating from the laboratory during the last 20 years. Several of these are marketed by various biotechnology companies. At this meeting we therefore arranged for some of the world’s leading experts in biochemistry and biotechnology to give lectures. The topics covered comprise enzyme technology, immobilization of enzymes and cells, abzymes, metabolic engineering, biosensors, and molecular recognition. No doubt much of Professor Mosbach’s success depends on his astounding profusion of ideas and his ambition to test the “impossible.” This wealth of ideas in combination with a cheerful temperament is the foundation of creativity. However, the development of half-crazy ideas into functional procedures and industrial processes can be excruciating. Everyone of his graduate students has experienced this difficult and often frustrating route to learn independence of thought. Nevertheless, their satisfaction when after years of exertion things are operating properly can be indescribable. Without such efforts the development of society would cease and life would be no fun . . . The official gift from the symposium committee and the participants is this ‘‘Festschrift”which covers several important fields of research within the area of biochemical technology. We have made a very unusual approach and have let the “hero of the occasion” present the history of his research. On behalf of all participants it is an honor to congratulate Mosbach to an extremely successful scientific career. We all hope for many more years of original ideas, laughter, enthusiasm, and thought provoking comments in the laboratory, in Mosbach’s home, at conferences and of course at night clubs.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The organizing committee gratefully acknowledgesthe financial support from the following companies and organizations: Wenner-Gren Center Foundation for Scientific Research The Biotechnology Research Foundation Perstorp Biotec Pierce Chemical Company Hyclone Laboratories Pernovo
Novo Nordisk A/S Norsk Hydro as. Bioinvent International AB Ferring AB Pharmacia Lund University
xxxv
Introduction
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Staffan Birnbaum Elisabet Bulow (conference secretary) Leif Bulow (chairman) Bengt Danielsson Per-Olof Larsson Mats-Olle Mhnsson Leif Bulow and Ben@ Danielsson
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PART IV
B IOSENSORS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
B IOSENSORS: AN INTRODUCTION
Bengt Danielsson
Biosensors have always played an important role in research in the Department of Pure and Applied Biochemistry. The enzyme thermistor and several other contributions of fundamental importance to the biosensor field were developed here. Biosensors are very suitable to demonstrate and quantitate interactions related to various biochemical phenomena such as molecular recognition or biocatalysis. Unfortunately,we have not yet seen the biosensor which lives up to all expectations. This is at least in part due to advancements in competing technologies that have been characterized by more successful instrumental developments such as high performance liquid chromatographyand high performance capillary electrophoresis. Nevertheless, many workers in this area including the session chairman, Professor G. Guilbault, hold that the biosensor market will now take off to become a multibillion dollar market before the turn of the century. Guilbault rounded off the session with a summary of the current status of biosensors worldwide. Referringto a recent survey ofbiosensor research in Europe, comparisons were made between the situation in the USA and Japan where the achievements to date have been much more significant. The situation is, however, Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 34e352. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
349
350
BENGT DANIELSSON
rapidly changing, as exemplified by the commercial exploitation of the Exactech pen-sized glucose meter and the BIAcore instrument from the PharmaciaBiosensor
co. Professor F. Scheller presented an overview of modem biosensor technology including aspects of molecular recognition, transducers, immobilization, signal transfer, organic phase operation, and applications in various fields. Enzymes are the dominating type of biocomponents used for molecular recognition, whereas intact cells are suitable for quantifying biological effects. Antibodies are also used in various immunosensing situations; for example, the use of different antibody fragments including single chain antibodies or the binding domain alone, is becoming increasingly popular. Miniaturization is a common feature of modem transducer design, from field-effect transistors to thin-film electrodes. Miniaturization poses special problems concerning the immobilized biolayer. Microelectronic production technology is employed in the fabrication of such sensors. Efficient transfer of the chemical signal to the transducer is especially important in connection with amperometric biosensors. A great deal of effort has been devoted to designs that eliminate interference from disturbing electroactive substances. In order to improve electron transfer various mediators or mediator-free electrodes have been employed as well as alternative enzymes with better electron transfer properties, such as PQQ-containing dehydrogenases. Biosensors operational in organic media offer special qualitiesthat may be of special interest in environmental analysis. Finally, typical biosensor applications were presented together with a display of commercial biosensor devices. Micromachining of biosensors was the focus of the paper presented by Professor I. Karube. A 20 nL electrochemical flow cell with an integrated enzyme column etched into the silicon substrate and an integrated enzyme reactor with a chemiluminescence detector were described. The biosensor research in Japan has always been directed towards very practical applications, and one large project that may seem somewhat amusing but has serious and important implications is the mounting of (bio)sensors in toilets for automatic health control. The age distribution of the Japanese population is shifting towards ever higher average ages, which makes the costs for health care skyrocket. Areliable system for automatic health control could help keep costs under control. Sensors for some key metabolites and proteins connected to a computer at the health center could keep track of the health status of an aging population (or anybody who wants to be connected)and bring abnormal values to immediate attention. An advantage of such a system would be that old people could be treated in their homes longer and transferred to hospitals later and still feel safer than without the automatic health control. Professor A. Heller is well known for his work on “wiring” redox enzymes to electrodes at the molecular level resulting in amperometric probes with higher sensitivities.For this purpose electron relaying polymers complexed with osmium compounds have been designed to efficiently lead electrons from the enzyme to the electrode. Several groups of enzymes have been connected through such electron-
Biosensors: An Introduction
351
conducting hydrogels including flavoenzymes such as glucose oxidase, quinoprotein (PQQ) enzymes, and heme peroxidases. High current densities were realized by immobilizing the enzymes in hydrogels with a polymer skeleton that permitted efficient electron diffusion at the same time that water soluble reactants could rapidly difise through the gel. The peroxidase electrodes were also found useful for sensitive detection of NAD(P)H using N-methyl phenazonium salts as mediators that could be oxidized with oxygen to produce hydrogen peroxide. U. Wollenberger presented a paper on recycling sensors based on kinases in various analytical arrangements with electrochemical, optical, and thermometric detection. The biosensor group in Berlin has developed considerable expertise in exploitingrecycling systems to increase the analytical sensitivity.Up to 48,000-fold signal enhancement has been noted for an enzyme electrode with a lactate oxidasellactate dehydrogenase membrane. An amplification factor of 5000 was obtained using the same couple in an enzyme thermistor reactor. P. Gemeiner and co-workers at the Slovak Academy of Sciences in Bratislava have developed methods for the characterization of the micro-kineticproperties of immobilized biocatalysts using enzyme flow calorimetry. The immobilized biocatalyst is placed in an enzyme thermistor column and the catalytic activity can be directly derived from the heat signal. Coupling of the mathematical description of the reaction-diffusion phenomena in the reactor with the heat balance provides kinetic data about the biocatalyst. The method has been tested on various enzymes, including invertase, D-amino acid oxidase and penicillin amidase. In the last two cases, immobilized cells have been used as well. The main advantages of the technique are the simplicity, general applicability, and reagentless operation (no chromogenic substrates, etc. are required). L. Gorton and co-workers provide an exhaustive account of the state of amperometric electrodesmodified with redox enzymes. Sensors for L-lactate, aldoses, alcohol, D-amino acid, and L-glutamate were produced by immobilizingthe appropriate enzymes in carbon paste electrodes operating at about zero mV versus SCE. In the two first cases, dehydrogenase enzymes were used while in the others oxidases coimmobilized with peroxidases were used. R. Feldbrtigge, K.P. Rindt, and A. Borchert describe an enzyme-based diffusion badge for the detection of formaldehyde. The badge is intended for the detection of formaldehyde in the atmosphere in working places and at home. It uses formaldehyde immobilized on sintered glass with diaphorase that transfers the NADH formed and a tetrazolium salt into colored formazan. The device is simple to operate and capable of detecting 100 ppb of formaldehyde within 15 minutes. It can be stored at least 18 months. I. Satoh describes biosensing of heavy metal ions based on their specific interactions with apoenzymes. Metalloenzymes are made inactive by removing the metal ion coordinated in the active center with use of strong chelating agents. The apoenzyme can be reactivated by exposure to samples containing the proper metal(s). The degree of activation depends on the metal ion concentration. Ther-
352
BENGT DANIELSSON
mometric as well as electrochemical and photometric detection has been used. This technique is highly selective and specific. The enzyme reactor operates under mild conditions and is reusable. M. Mecklenburg who investigates developments of the PCR technology has designed high-annealing-temperature(HAT) primers that drasticallyreduce cycling times and nonspecific amplification products. Other modifications lead to more efficient use of the polymerase enzyme and reduced primer oligomer formation. HAT primers were used to develop a highly specific, low-copy-number PCR assay for human cytomegalovirus. M. Rank and B. Danielsson have adopted and adapted a split-flow thermal biosensor system for on-line monitoring of industrial fermentations. The system has been thoroughly tested in real industrial environments at pilot-plant and production-scale fermentations. Excellent results were obtained for penicillin V, ethanol, glucose, and lactate. B. Xie has developed different designs of miniaturized thermal biosensors with surprisingly good performance, including devices made by micromachining of silicon or quartz. The paper submitted by U. Hedberg and B. Xie focusses on the use of such sensors for the measurement of glucose in whole blood. The present state of the technology permits fabrication of portable instruments for home monitoring of glucose.
OVERVIEW OF BIOSENSOR TECHNOLOGY
Frieder W. Scheller, Ulla Wollenberger, Dorothea Pfeiffer, and Florian Schubert
I. 11. 111. IV. V.' VI.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 353 INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 354 BIOMOLECULESUSEDFORMOLECULARRECOGNITION . . . . . . 354 OPTIMIZATION OF TRANSDUCERSAND OF IMMOBILIZATION . . . 355 TRANSFER OF THE CHEMICAL. SIGNAL TO THE TRANSDUCER . . . 356 ORGANIC PHASE BIOSENSORS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 358 APPLICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 361
ABSTRACT Biosensors for about 140 different analytes have been described in the literature. Among them are low molecular weight substances (metabolites, drugs, nutrients, gases, metal ions, coenzymes, enzyme activators, and vitamins) as well as macromolecules (enzymes, lectins, nucleic acids, polymeric carbohydrates like starch, and cellulose), viruses, and microorganisms. Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 353-363. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
353
SCHELLER, WOLLENBERCER, PFEIFFER, and SCHUBERT
354
1. INTRODUCTION Biosensors are in the forefront of current bioanalytical chemistry. Even though a definition by the IUPAC has not yet been established, the spatial unity of biomolecules with a signal transducer has been accepted to be the main feature of biosensors (Lowe, 1985). According to L. Clark, biosensorics is a combination of science and art. This statement is obviously true for the initial phase of research, but mass production for widespread application requires developments in technological areas. Two major branches-biotechnology and microsystem technology will contribute to future progress in biosensorics.
II. BIOMOLECULES USED FOR MOLECULAR RECOGNITION In order to cover the whole spectrum of analytes within an extremely large concentration range, different biomolecules have been used for molecular recognition. These include: (i) Enzymes that dominate in the determination of low molecular weight analytesin the micro and millimolar range. (ii) Intact cells that are suited to quantify biological effects, e.g., nutritivity, taste, odor, and mutagenicity. And (iii) Antibodies for the analysis of both high and low molecular weight compounds down to subnanomolar concentrations (see Table I).
Table 1. Fields of Applications Medical Diagnostics [g c
0
-2
Bioprocess Control
-1 2
Meiabolites
Arninoacids Inorg. Salts
Drugs Salicylate
Glucose Urea Lactate Creatinine
Antibiotics
Inorg. Cornp.
Theophylline
aP GOT Cortisone
Antibodies Enzymes
-8 -10
Enzymes/ Hormones
Organic Acids Carbohydrates Degradable Org. Cornp.
4 -6
Environmental Control
Digoxin
Toxins Hormones Vitamins Toxins
Insulin T4
HCG
Overview of Biosensor Technology
355
Considerable efforts in industry and academia are being made to discover novel enzymes.Both oxidases (e.g., for glutamate,NADH, phenylalanine,acylcoenzyme A, bilirubin, glycerol, and theophylline)and PQQ-containing dehydrogenases (e.g., for oligosaccharides, aldoses, fructose, methylamine, and aliphatic alcohols) have been used successfully for biosensor development. On the other hand, the arsenal of catalytic antibodies (abzymes) occupies only marginal interest in biosensors. Significant alternatives to molecular recognition by biomolecules are offered by “biomimetic” (binding) molecules and “molecular imprinted” polymers. In immunosensor development monoclonal antibodies allow screening for high affinity and appropriate kinetic parameters. Different fragments (e.g., the Fab part) and the sole binding domain (“mini-antibodies”) or natural binding proteins (e.g., for the low density lipoprotein) are promising candidates for reducing the nonspecific binding effects.
111. OPTIMIZATION OF TRANSDUCERS AND OF IMMOBILIZATION Chemical sensors, that is, potentiometric, amperometric, and impedimetric electrodes, various optical detectorsusing colored indicators as well as physical sensors, that is, piezoelectric crystals, thermistors, and reagent-free optical sensors, have been combined with appropriate biocomponents. Potentiometric and amperometric enzyme electrodes are at the leading edge of biosensors when considering the body of scientific publications and commercially available devices. Only few conductometric enzyme electrodes have been described, but the relevance of this sensor type may increase because of the relative ease of their production (Watson et al., 1988). The goals of miniaturizing biosensors are the reduction of the required sample volume, the multicomponent analysis of complex chemical substances by multiple microsensors, and cost reduction by mass production. Three basic types of microsensors have been used: l . pH- or pF-sensitive field-effect transistors (ISFETs). 2 . gas-sensitive metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) capacitors. And 3. thin-film electrodes. Besides the common antimony oxide electrode,platinum oxide and iridium oxide probes have been coupled to immobilized enzymesto give miniaturized biosensors. The light-addressable biosensor provides a measurement of the photocurrent generated by illumination of the back side by an array of light-emitting diodes. The signal reflects the local pH or redox potential at the surface. In this way changes of the surface potential by enzyme reactions, microorganisms, or the action of receptors can be measured with high sensitivity(Owicki and Parce, 1990).More recently, thermistors, integrated optical sensors, and surface acoustic devices have also been included in the development of microbiosensors (Karube et al., 1990). These sensors are fabricated by microelectronic productiontechnology, such as thick- and thin-film deposition, photolithographic reduction, and chemical and plasma etch-
356
SCHELLER, WOLLENBERGER, PFEIFFER, and SCHUBERT
ing, which permit well-delineated patterning of metallic, insulating, and semiconducting surface layers. In this way arrays of identical or different sensors can be produced, thus enhancing the reliability, repeatability, and versatility of the sensor. Most problems arise from the manufacturing technique for the formation of the immobilized biolayer. Layers of polymers, for example, polypyrrole or polyaniline, are deposited on conducting areas by electropolymerization. The biomolecules are either entrapped in the polymer matrix during the layer formation (Foulds and Lowe, 1988) or coupled to the layer via typical chemical reactions. Structuring of uniformly deposited biocomponent-containing layers is also possible when photodeactivation of passive regions is performed. For this purpose, illumination with UV light is applied (Van der Schoot and Bergveld, 1987).Alternatively, enzymes are deposited only at the sensitive region by using an enzyme solution in a negative photoresist. Using glow discharge in combination with the mask technique, plasma polymers can be deposited on the active sensor region. In a second procedure the enzymes or antibodies are covalently bound via bifunctional reagents.
IV. TRANSFER OF THE CHEMICAL SIGNAL TO THE TRANSDUCER Enzyme electrodes based on oxidases combined with amperometric H,O, measurement are the most common among biosensors. However, an electroactive substance being converted at lower potential contributes to the total current. To eliminate these interferences by co-oxidizable sample constituents, the electrode potential is kept as low as possible. Therefore,one chooses a reaction partner which is converted at the lowest possible potential. The natural electron acceptors of many oxidoreductases, for example methanol dehydrogenase, alcohol dehydrogenase, cytochrome b,, and the oxidases of glucose, lactate, pyruvate, glycolate, sarcosine, and galactose can be replaced by redox-active dyes or other reversible electron mediators. With these mediators, an electrode potential around +200 mV can be applied; this decreases interferences by ascorbic acid and enables one to couple such enzymes with electrodes in oxygen-free solution. For this reason chemically modified electrodes where the mediator is integrated with the amperometric electrode have been combined with immobilized, mediator-dependent enzymes. In the simplest approach the solid mediator was introduced in crevices of the carbon electrode body, and a dialysis membrane prevented it from leaching out. In the next stage the mediator was admixed to the carbon paste ofthe electrode body and finally all reagents-enzyme, mediator, and cosubstrate-were integrated into the top of the electrode (Figure 1). Similar to mediators, enzymes may be covalently bound to the electrode surface, thus giving chemically modified enzyme electrodes.Adsorption of redox polymers containing benzoquinone or heavy metal ion complexes at carbon electrodes resulted in the catalysis of the electron transfer by wiring the enzyme molecules to
Overview of Biosensor Technology
357
I k d n nnd Sendo ( 1
Kulys ond Svirnlickar (198
G u s .Hill I Higgin
Racinc and M n d f (I97
Torslensson, Johansson I Morboch el Drgoni ond lleller ( 1 9 8 7 )
Figure 1. Types of mediated enzyme electrodes.
the electrode. When enzymes and mediators are coimmobilized at the surface or within the electrode, addition of auxiliary substances during the measuring process can be avoided, thus a reagentless measuring regime becomes feasible. An alternative to the application of mediators is the direct electron transfer between the prosthetic group ofthe enzyme and the redox electrode.Heterogeneous electron transfer reactions have been realized with more than 30 different proteins, mainly electron transferases, but also substrate-convertingoxidoreductases.At bare metal electrodes irreversible adsorption accompanied with denaturation prevents a fast electron transfer to the protein molecules. Adsorption of modifiers that promote an appropriate orientation of the protein resulted in a facilitated direct electron transfer with different redox enzymes, for example, cytochromes and ferrodoxins. The mediator-free electron transfer within bulk modified carbon paste electrodes has been used for sensor application. Peroxidase and the PQQ-containing fructose dehydrogenase have been applied in reagentless sensor arrangements for hydroperoxides and fructose, respectively (Ikeda et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1992). Dual sensor systems have been developed both with amperometric and potentiometric electrodes. These dual sensor systems use one enzyme loaded sensor and one blank sensor as a reference in order to eliminate erroneous readings because of differences in the background current and sample pH. Problems arise from the independent fluctuations of the sensor's characteristics. Changes in buffer capacity ofthe sample cannot be compensated for by this arrangement. ThepHstatic enzyme sensor (van der Schoot and Bergveld, 1987/88) circumvents this disturbance: The Hf or OH- ions generated in the enzyme reaction are consumed in the reaction of water electrolysis. The charge necessary for maintaining a constant pH represents
358
SCHELLER, WOLLENBERGER, PFEIFFER, and SCHUBERT
the amount of ions formed and is independent of the buffer capacity. The device contains in addition to the enzyme covered pH-FET, a pair of amperometric electrodes for 0, or H, generation which are controlled by an on-chip pH static coulometer system. Coulometric generation of the cosubstrate oxygen is the basis of the ovgen-stabilized glucose electrode. The oxygen consumed in the enzyme reaction is regenerated by water electrolysis at an auxiliary electrode. The consumed charge reflects the amount of the converted substrate and this principle allows measurement even in solutions of changing oxygen content (Cleland and Enfors, 1984).
V. ORGANIC PHASE BIOSENSORS The potential advantages of using enzymes in organic as opposed to aqueous solutions include increased solubility of many organic substrates, reversion of hydrolytic reactions, relative ease of enzyme immobilization based on their insolubility in organic solvents, elimination of microbial contamination,and reduction of side reactions. The employment of immobilized enzymes directly in the organic phase for analytical purposes began with a study of a system consisting of horseradish peroxidase (HRP) and cholesterol oxidase (COD) for cholesterol analysis in toluene (Kazandjian et al., 1986).The enzymes were adsorbed onto glass beads and detection was carried out spectrophotometrically. Danielsson and Flygare (1 989) found that the sensitivity of a HRP thermistor operating in organic solvents increased compared with operation in water because of the lower heat capacity of organic solvents. A two-channel enzyme thermistor configuration has been em-
Table 2. Organic Solvent Biosensors Sensor-type
Transducer
Enzyme sensor
electrode
thermistor
Microbial sensor
electrode
Immunosensor
fluorescence detector
Notes: AAO - Aminoacid Oxidase
AOD - Alcohol Oxidase
Receptor
chymotrypsin tyrosinase COD HRP AOD HRP AAOlchymohypsin Alkaligensis spec. Corynebacter MB 1 Pseudomonas spec. polyclonal AB
Analyte
peptides phenols cholesterol peroxides CI-C4alcohols enantiomeric aminoacid ester xenobiotics. PCB
atrazine
Table 3. Enzyme-Electrode Based Analyzers Sample Frequency Company
Yellow Springs Instruments, USA
Model
Analyte
Linear Range (mM)
23 A 23 L 27 2000
glucose lactate ethanol lactose galactose sucrose
145 0.1-15
0-l)
40
Serial
cv PA)
Stabilig
<2
300 samples
M O
40 20
C-55
20
2
0-27
M
8C-90 30 3
4-5
UA-300A
glucose a-amylase uric acid
Auto-STAT
glucose
140
6C-120
1
Stat Analyzer S 80
glucose
C-50
120
2
STAT-Profile 5
glucose lactate
1-25 C-15
3%38 3%38
4.1
Satellite G
glucose
2-33
1s-17
ABD Amperometric Biosensor Detector
glucose urea uric acid lactate
0.003-3.0
Inst. Biochem., Lithuania
EXAN-G
glucose
2.530.0
20
Omron Tateisi, Japan Seres, France
HER- 100 Enzymat
lactate glucose
w.3 0.%22
60
Fuji Electric, Japan
Daiichi, Japan
GLUCO 20
1.7
> 500 samples
GA-112
Analytical Instruments, Japan NOVA Biomedical. USA
2
7d 7d
Analysator MediSense, England Universal Sensors. USA
disposables 500 samples SO0 samples 500 samples 500 samples
0.1-10.0
O.OOW.6 0.01-2.5
> IOd (continued)
Table 3. (Continued) Company
Model
Sample Frequency
Serial
Analyie
Linear Range (mM)
Wi)
cv PA)
Stability
choline
1.0-29 0.1-2 0-1.5
60 60 3s
<2
7 200 samples
2.5-25
35 90 120-130 120 80 20 20
<2 <2 < 1.5 <2 <2 5%
(15 d) samples > 2000 samples 10 d 14 d IOd 14 d 30 d
L-1ysine
SGI Setric Genie Industriel, France
Tacussel, France Priifgefite-Werk Medingen, FRGEppendorf, FRG
EKF Magdeburg, FRG
DOSIVIT Nantes, France
Microzym-L
Gluco-processeur ESAT 6660/61 EBIO Biosen. 6020 G Biosen. 5020 L
lactate glucose glucose glucose lactate uric acid glucose lactate glucose lactate disaccharides
0.055 0.MO
1-30 0.1-1.2 0.S25 1-25
5%
7 400
disposables
Overview of Biosensor Technology
361
ployed for the enantioselectiveanalysis of D- and L-amino acid esters in mixtures containing up to 40% dimethylformamide (Hundeck et al., 1992). The first organic phase enzyme electrode was based on polyphenol oxidase for the measurement of phenolic compounds in chloroform (Hall et al., 1988). The sensor could be employed for the detection of very small amounts of phenolic contamination of waste water by using the extraction of the analyte from a large aqueous volume into a small organic volume. A potentiometric chymotrypsin sensor has been devised for monitoring ester synthesis in organic media (Miyabayashi et al., 1989). It was found that the enzyme-associated hydration was the most important parameter affectingthe response of the sensor.Applicability in the organic phase has also been demonstrated for microbial and immunosensors (Table 2).
VI. APPLICATION The most relevant fields of practical application of enzyme electrodes are medical diagnostics, process control, food analysis, and environmental monitoring (Table 1). To meet the high demand for glucose determination in the blood of diabetic patients, different types of analyzers have been developed. In total, analyzers for about 12 different analytes have been made commercial with an increasing importance of nonmedical applications (Table 3). Compared with conventional enzymatic analysis, the main advantages of such analyzers are the extremely low enzyme demand (a few milliunits per sample), the simplicity to operate them, the high analysis speed, and the high analytical quality. In the medical field, a trend towards hand-held devices based on either reusable or disposable glucose and lactate enzyme electrodes for home control of diabetics and for on-site monitoring of surgery and exercise is evident (Table 4).
Table 4. Pocket Devices Based on Enzyme Electrodes
Company
Medi Sense, England Eli Lilly/ELCO, USA Med Test Systems, USA EKF Industrie Elektronik, FRG I-STAT Corp.
Model
Analyte
Sample Linear Frequency Serial CV Range (mM) (h-‘) PA)
Stability
ExacTech
glucose
1.1-33.3
2C30
3.3-8.1
disposables
Direct 30/30
glucose
2.5-28
30
2-8
30 d 500 samples disposables
<5
10 d
medisensor” glucose 200 1 urea BIOSEN 2000 lactate i-STAT
glucose urea
60
1-15
> 30 40
disposables
362
SCHELLER, WOLLENBERGER, PFEIFFER, and SCHUBERT
In process control and the food industry, enzyme electrodesare employed mainly for the determination of carbohydrates, ascorbic acids, amino acids, and penicillin. However, the application of sensors in situ in bioreactors is associated with significant difficulties. Environmental control will benefit from enzyme electrode based measurements of toxic compounds such as heavy metals, fumes from organic wastes, and pesticides in water, air, and soil.
REFERENCES a s s , A.E.G., Davis, G., Francis, G.D., Hill, H.A.O., Aston, W.J., Higgins, I.J., Plotkin. E.V., Scott, L.D.L., & Turner, A.P.F. (1984). Ferrocene-mediated enzyme electrode for amperometric determination of glucose. Anal. Chem. 46,667-671. Cenas, N.K., Pocius. A.K., & Kulys, J.J. (1983). Biosensors based on redox polymers. Bioelectrochern. Bioenerg. lI,61-73. Cleland, N. & Enfors, S O . (1984). The oxygen stabilized enzyme electrode. Anal. Chem. 56, 188G1886. Danielsson, B. & Flygare, L. (1989). Biothemal analysis performed in organic solvents. Anal. Lett. 22, 1417-1428. Degani, Y.& Heller, A. (1987). Direct electrical communication between chemically modified enzymes and metal electrodes. J. Phys. Chem. 91, 12851289. Durliat, H. & Comtat, M. (1984). Amperometric enzyme electrode for determination of glucose based on thin-layer specnoelectrochemistry of glucose oxidase. Anal. Chem. 56, 148-1 52. Foulds, N.C. & Lowe, C.R. (1988). Immobilization of glucose oxidase in ferrocene-modified pyrrole polymers. Anal. Chem. 60,247S2478. Gorton, L., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Csoregi, E.. Johansson, K., Dominguez. E., & Marko-Varga, G. ( 1992).Amperometric biosensors based on an apparent direct electron transfer between electrodes and immobilized peroxidases. Analyst 117, 12351241. Hall, G.F., Best, D.J.. &Turner. A.P.F. (1988). Amperometric enzyme electrode for the determination of phenols in chloroform. Enzyme Microbiol. Technol. 10,542-546. Hundeck, H.G., Scheper, T., Lubbert, A., Schmidt, J., & Schubert, F. (1992). Application of a 4-channel enzyme thermistor in biotechnology. In: Biosensors: Fundamentals, Technologies and Applications (Scheller, F. & Schmidt. R.D., Eds.), GBF Monogr. 17, VCH, Weinheim, New York. Ikeda, T., Katasho, I., Kame, M., & Senda, M. (1984). Glucose oxidase-immobilized benzoquinonemixed carbon paste electrode. Agric. Biol. Chem. 48. 196S1975. Ikeda, T., Matsushita. F.. & Senda, M. (1991). Amperometric fructose sensor based on direct bioelectro-catalysis. Biosensors Bioelectronics 6,29%304. Karube, I., Sode, K.. & Tamiya, E. (1990). Microbiosensors. J. Biotechnol. 15,267-282. Kazandjian, R.Z., Dordick, J.S., & Klibanov, A.M. (1986). Enzymatic analyses in organic solvents. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 28,417421. Kulys, J.J. & Svirmickas, G.-J.S. (1980). Reagentless lactate sensor based on cytochrome b2. Anal. Chim. Acta 117, 115120. Lowe, C.R. (1985). An introduction to the concepts and technology of biosensors. Biosensors 1, S 1 6 . Miyabayashi, A., Reslow, M., Adlercreutz, P., & Mattiasson, B. (1989). A potentiometric enzyme electrode for monitoring in organic solvents. Anal. Chim. Acta 219,27-36. Owicki, J.C. & Parce, J.W. (1990). Bioassays with a microphysiometer. Nature 344,271-272. Racine, P. & Mindt, W. (1971). Enzyme Electrode, Swiss Patent 13,211/71, US. 3,838,033. Scheller, F., Stmad, G.,Neumann, B., Kiihn, M., & Ostrowski, W. (1979). Polarographic reduction of the prosthetics groups in flavoproteins. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 6. 117-122.
Overview of Biosensor Technology
363
Torstensson, A,, Johansson, G., Mansson, M.-0.. Larsson, P.-O., & Mosbach, K. (1980). Electrochemical regeneration of NAD covalently bound to liver alcohol dehydrogenase. Anal. Lett. 13, 837-850. van der Schoot, B.H. & Bergveld, P. (1987/88). ISFET based sensors. Biosensors 3, 161-186. Watson, L.D., Maynard, P., Cullen,D.C., Sethi, R.S., Brettle, J., & Lowe, C.R. (1988). Amicroelectronic conductimetric biosensor. Biosensors 3, 101-1 16. Wingard, L.B., Jr. (1984). Cofactor modified electrodes. Trends Anal. Chem. 3,235-238.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CURRENT STATE OF BIOSENSORS
George G. Guilbault
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. NEW AREAS OF BIOSENSORS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. STATUS OF BIOSENSOR SALES AND RESEARCH . . . . . . . . . .
.
365 366 366 . 370
ABSTRACT Biosensors, first described in the early 1960s,have advanced in 30 years to an age of sophistication. Electrochemical biosensors, the first of such sensors, have become with improved methods of electron transfer, better immobilization procedures, and miniaturization a 500 million dollar business. New immuno-electrobiosensors and noninvasive sensing methods have brought the technology to a new frontier. In addition, other useful biosensors based on highly sensitivepiezoelectriccrystal-based biosensors and fiber optrodes have gained importance.
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 365-373. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
365
366
GEORGE G . GUILBAULT
Table 1. History of Biosensor Development Enzyme Electrodes
Amperometric Biosensor Potentiometric Biosensor
- Clark, 1962 - Guilbault, 1969
Immobilized Enzyme Systems in Flow Analysis
- Hornby, Miles Catalinks
Enzyme Coils
- Horvath, Technicon Enzyme Thermistor Probes Mass Biosensors Fiber Optic Sensors
- Cambiaghi. Carlo Erba - FIA - Ruzicka, Hansen - Danielsson - Shons, 1971 - Guilbault, 1986 - 1985
1. INTRODUCTION Biosensors, consisting of a biologically active compound (an enzyme, antibody, antigen, whole cell suspension, or receptor) coupled to a transducer (which converts the biological signal into an electronic signal) were first described in the early 1960s.Table 1 gives a history of biosensor development. The first transducer used was an amperometric electrode, and the biological compound was soluble glucose oxidase in the construction of a glucose biosensor (Clark and Lyons, 1962).In 1965 Guilbault et al. described the first biosensor, a cholinesterase based nerve agent detector using an amperometric readout. In 1969 Guilbault and Montalvo built the first potentiometric biosensor for urea using a cation electrode and immobilized urease. Immobilized enzyme systems were used in flow analysis, first described by Homby using the Technicon Auto Analyzer approach and then flow injection analysis as introduced by Ruzicka and Hansen.
11. N E W AREAS OF BIOSENSORS Electrochemical sensors are still the most popular, with rapid growth in the fields of mass-sensitive sensors (Ngeh-Ngwainbi et al., 1989; Guilbault and Schmid, 1990) and fiber optrode sensors (Arnold, 1990).It is predicted by many that optical based biosensors and mass sensors will occupy a significant portion of the current market in biosensors in the next decade. New areas ofresearch in biosensors are listed in Table 2. Immunological sensors, in which antigens or antibodies are used to assay analytespresent in a sample, offer high selectivity and high sensitivity. Table 3 lists the principles underlying two
Current State of Biosensors
367
Table 2. New Areas of Biosensors A . Immunological Sensors
-Antigens -Antibodies B. Receptor Sensors C. Micro Electrodes
- Miniaturization (1-50 Microns) - Direct Sampling in Tissues, Brain Cells, etc. D. Noninvasive Sensors
- Saliva (Lactate, Alcohol) - Sweat (Lactate) - Transbuccal Mucosa (Glucose) E. Nonclinical Applications
- Food and Agricultural Analysis - Environmental Testing For: Pesticides, Bacterial Contamination, Toxins
approache-lectrochemical and piezocrystal, while in Table 4 some of the applications of immunobiosensors are listed. Applications to pesticides are now fairly well worked out, as illustrated by a recent paper describing the assay of atrazine at concentrationsas low as 0.0 1 ppb in water (Guilbault et al., 1992b). We have done preliminary work on the assay of toxins-such as brevitoxin and saxitoxin-at part per billion levels in food and environmental samples (e.g., linearity for saxitoxin 2 ppb to 1 ppm). We can certainly expect much more in this area in the very near future. Another very exciting area of research is bacterial detection in food samples-E. coli, Listeria, and Salmonella are organisms that are of extreme importance to assess the quality of food against contamination. Current methods are long (72 hr) and require extensive manpower.
Table 3. lmmunobiosensor Principles:
A.
B.
Electrochemical - Enzyme linked to antibody is attached to surface of Pt or C electrode. Follow change in current. Piezoelectric Crystal - Look at direct reaction of antigen and antibody by weight change and resulting AF.
3 68
GEORGE G. GUILBAULT Table 4. lmmunosensors A.
Pesticides
- Organophosphorus
- Carbamates - Herbicides B.
Toxins
- Saxitoxin
- Brevitoxin - Aflatoxin C.
Drugs
- Cocaine - Pharmaceuticals D.
Bacteria
- E. coli - Listeria - Salmonella We have developed a rapid PZ based immunosystem capable of detecting E. coli at low concentrations(Guilbault et al., 1992a). In current research we have shown that as little as 100 celldwell of E. coZi can be detected in food by an ELISA based immunosensor (Figure 1).
1.2 h
E C
v) 0 Q,
9
__
/=
1. -
0.8
a-
d.'
,.-
0.6
1
0.4
!
0
2 -E g
-~ ~
r
J'
i
0.2
1 0
01 -0.2
!
I
100
. . 1E4 1E6 1E8 I E I O 1E12 cfulwel I
Figure 1. The relationship between absorbance and cfdwell obtained with an ELISA immunosensor.
Current State of Biosensors
369
Another very interesting area of current research is the use of microelectrodes (1-50 p) for direct sampling in tissues and brain cells. We have demonstrated that glutamate biosensors (based on glutamate oxidase), choline and acetylcholine biosensors (using choline oxidase and acetycholinesterase),and L-alanine sensors (based on L-alanine dehydrogenase and NAD) can be built as small as 25 microns using C fibers and Pt wires for direct insertion into the brains of rats and mice. Finally, noninvasive sensors, in which the sensor is placed on external parts of the body, are capable of performing the same functions as invasive sensors (i.e., blood). A direct correlation of lactate and alcohol in saliva compared with blood exists, making possible a very easy assay of these metabolites. In meat we have been able to assay lactate, a metabolite of great use in sports medicine because it indicates the physical condition of the body (Guilbault et al., 1991). In the transbuccal mucosa we have shown that glucose can be measured as reliably as it can in blood. Another approach to noninvasive sensing of glucose is infrared (IR) spectroscopy, where a near IR scan of the glucose content in the finger of an individual was correlated with the blood level (Arnold, 1990).
50
40
30
20
1c
c
SW
AU
Figure 2. Number of centers dealing with biosensor research. From Mascini, 1992
GEORGE G. GUILBAULT
3 70
111. STATUS OF BIOSENSOR SALES AND RESEARCH A recent survey was conducted by the European Economic Community (EEC) of biosensor research in the USA, Japan and the EEC countries. The entire study was published (Mascini, 1992). The number of centers dealing with Biosensor Research are listed in Figure 2. The total number, 264, represents 70 centers in the United States, 62 in Japan, and 132 in the EEC countries-breakdown of work in each of the EEC countries is given in this figure. Figure 3 showsthe total number ofbiosensor projects in Europe, the United States, Canada, and Japan. Figures 4 and 5 show a breakdown of the total publications in biosensors in each of the EEC countries the United States and Japan. From this objective search (conducted in the period January, 1987 to February, 1992 by Professor R. Schmid of the GBF in Braunschweig) (Mascini, 1992), we can see how the United States and Japan are important as single nations, but, also, how the EEC is highly productive as a whole (1244 entries vs. 1284 in Japan and 864 in the United States). In a comparison of patent productivity in the EEC, Japan, and the United States, only 183 patents in this period were obtained by the whole of Europe vs. 551 in Japan. Germany, the United Kingdom, France, and Italy dominate the scene, but if the figures are divided by the number of inhabitants the results show that some small countries have excellent centers that are very active in biosensor technology.
-
EEC
USA
JAP
Figure 3. Total number of biosensor projects in Europe, USA, Canada, and Japan. From Mascini, 1992
Current State of Biosensors
Switz. Italy F rance
\
371
Swed.
I
/Mhers
\ UK
JAPAN
Ger
USA figure 4. A breakdown of the total number of publications dealing with biosensors in the EEC, USA and Japan. From Mascini, 1992
Finally, let us consider the market for biosensors. The majority of commercially available biosensors have been designed specifically for the clinical market and mainly for the determination of glucose concentrations.
Figure5 A breakdown of the publications including papers and patents coming from Europe. From Mascini, 1992
3 72
GEORGE G. GUILBAULT
Table 5. Growth Areas within lmrnunodiagnosticMarket Segments in the U.S. (in millions of dollars) I985 Diagnostic Category
Therapeutic drug monitoring Infectious diseases Thyroid function Immunoproteins Tumor markers Drugs of abuse Reproductive hormones Allergy Total
Doctor i Office
5 9 2 1 1 1
1990
Clinical Laboratory
Doctor's Office
Clinical Laboratory
1 4
34 24 20 24 6
75 55 10 2 1 15 5 12
325 196 70 49 49 40 39 13
24
427
175
78 1
165 106 106
From Mascini, 1992
In 1987, a new concept in biosensor design was developed in England and commercially exploited principally in the United States. The ExacTech pen-sized glucose sensor may be considered to be a second generation amperometric biosensor. It was developed especially for self monitoring of blood glucose and addresses a home test market worth about US 800 million dollars worldwide. The total world market for diagnostics is currently estimated to be about five billion dollars of which 2.1 to 2.8 US billion dollars falls into the immunochemical sector. Table 5 reports the predicted growth areas within immunoassay testing in the USA, many of which may be addressed with biosensor technology. Another significantmarket sector is that of rapidmicrobiologicaltesting. In 1983, the market was valued at 542 million dollars, by 1988 the same report stated that the number oftests had increased from 996 million tests to 1347million, an increase of 35% over that period. Japan and the United States have dominated the biosensor industry in the Western World. A U.S. company (Yellow Springs Instrument Co.) held the biggest market share prior to the introduction of the Exactech, but the Japanese have the greatest number of manufacturers. The market for biosensors in Europe in 1984 was reported as only 362,000 dollars. This figure was predicted to grow steadily in the early years of the forecast period ( 1984-1 990) before being replaced by explosive growth in the later years, resulting in a market of over 8.6 million dollars by 1990. The European market is far less significant than the U S . market over a similar period (19861991). A report entitled The Biosensor Market in the United States estimated the 1986 market size at 14.4 million dollars but realized a huge market increase to 365 million dollars by 1991 (actually about 400 million dollars), followed by explosive growth thereafter (Figure 6).
Current State of Biosensors
3 73
350 ...........
.......
"
300 ..................
.......................................
250
z
9 -
200
i e
150
.....................
................................
2
.......................
100
50 0 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 Figure 6. The current growth rate of the biosensor market in the United States.
REFERENCES Arnold, M. (1990). Fibre Optic Biosensors. Journal of Biotechnology 15,21%228. Clark, L. & Lyons, L. (1962). Glucose enzyme electrode. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 102,582-585. Guilbault, G., Kramer, D., Goodson, L., & Bauman, E. (1965). The preparation of immobilized cholinesterase for use in analytical chemistry. Analyt. Chem. 37, 1378-1381. Guilbault, G. & Montalvo, J. (1969). A urea specific enzyme electrode. J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 91, 2 164-2 167. Guilbault, G. & Schmid, R.D. (1990). Electrochemical,piezoelectric and fibre optic biosensors. Adv. Biosens. 1,257-289. Guilbault, G.G., Faridnia, M., Palleschi, G., & Lubrano, G. (1991). Determination of lactate in human saliva with an electrochemicalenzyme probe. Analyt. Chim. Acta 245, 151-157. Guilbault, G.G., Hock, B., & Plomber, M. (1992a). Development of a piezoelectric immunosensor for the detection of enterobacteria.Enzyme and Microbial Technology 14,23&235. Guilbault, G.G., Schmid, R., & Hock, B. (1992b). A piezoelectric immunobiosensor for atrazine in drinking water. Biosens. Bioelectronics 7,411419. Mascini, M. (1992). Biosensor technology in the USA, Japan and Europe. EEC Special Report, EEC, Brussels, Belgium. Ngeh-Ngwainbi, J., Suleiman, A., & Guilbault, G.G. (1989). Piezoelectric crystal biosensors. Biosens. Bioelectronics 5, 1326.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
BIOSENSORS AND MICROMACHINING
lsao Karube, Kenji Yokoyama, Yuji Murakami, and Masayuki Suda
I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375 11. ELECTROCHEMICAL FLOW CELL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376 111. INTEGRATION OF ENZYME IMMOBILIZED COLUMN AND ELECTROCHEMICAL FLOW CELL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 376 IV. INTEGRATION OF ENZYMATIC REACTOR AND CHEMILUMINESCENCE DETECTOR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 377 V. CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 378
1. INTRODUCTION In recent years, microfabrication techniquesbased on integrated circuit technology, such as photolithography and etching, have been applied to other fields. These techniques, which are used to make some small and efficient three-dimensional devices, are called micromachining (Borky and Wise, 1979; Roylance and Angell, Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 375-379. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
375
376
I . KARUBE, K. YOKOYAMA, Y. MURAKAMI, and M. SUDA A'
PYREX
A
A'
A
figure 1. Structure of the electrochemical flow cell. From Suda et al., 1990.
1979; Fan et al., 1989; Shoji et al., 1990). Furthermore, some studies to make miniaturized chemical analysis systems were already reported (Terry et al., 1979; Manz et al., 1990). These analysis systems have many advantages such as fast response, small amount of sample, and low consumption of reagents as compared With the conventional one. We applied the micromachining technique to make a miniaturized enzyme-based sensor system.
II. ELECTROCHEMICAL FLOW CELL An electrochemical flow cell that has a very small inner volume of about 20 nl was
fabricated (Suda et al., 1990). Figure 1 shows a structure of the micro electrochemical flow cell. This flow cell can be used as an electrochemical detector for liquid chromatography or flow injection analysis (FIA). The enzyme-immobilized flow cell can be employed as an electrochemical biosensor. Glucose oxidase was immobilized onto the sample inlet hole of the cell using glutaraldehydeand bovine serum albumin. Glucose was calibrated in the range of 30 to 1000 mg/dl when 0.2 pl of the sample was injected.
111. INTEGRATION OF ENZYME IMMOBILIZED COLUMN A N D ELECTROCHEMICAL FLOW CELL A long open-tubular column was fabricated on the silicon substrate (Murakami et al., 1993). A glucose sensor was integrated with both an enzyme immobilized column and an electrochemical flow cell (Figure 2). The column was made by anisotropic silicon etching to be 100 pm wide, 70 pm deep, 1 m long, and a total volume of 5 yl. Four gold electrodes were formed on the glass substrate. Both of the two substrates were anodically bonded. Connecting unions to the pump and
Biosensors and Micromachining
377 A
PYREX A
5
Slllcon
I
Inlet
,
,I E
I
R
L
E
#
I
P Column
Outl&
I
-7
/
A'
Electrodes
A'
figure 2. Electrochemical detector integratedwith enzyme column. From Murakami et al., 1993.
sample injector were glued on the inlet and outlet holes with epoxy resin. Glucose oxidase (GOD) was immobilized on the inner wall of the column using 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane and glutaraldehyde. This device was applied to a conventional FIA system.
IV. INTEGRATION OF ENZYMATIC REACTOR AND CHEMILUMINESCENCE DETECTOR An enzymatic reactor and a chemiluminescence detector were integrated on the
same chip (Figure 3) (Suda et al., 1992). The reactor consists of a silicon and glass substrate. On the silicon substrate, an enzymatic reaction column, a mixing chamber, a spiral flow cell were added by anisotropic etching. The total size of the measuring unit was 15 mm x 20 mm, and the total internal volume of the device was about 15 yl. Enzyme-immobilized glass beads were packed into the column, and a photodiode was placed onto the spiral flow cell. Using GOD-immobilized glass beads, determinationof glucose concentration was carried out in the range of 10 to 300 mg/dl. Glucose in human serum and urine was measured by a chemiluminescence detector. The correlation coefficient between this chemiluminescence
3 78
I. KARUBE, K. YOKOYAMA, Y. MURAKAMI, and M. SUDA Splral flow cell
T E
E
z
I-
I
\ A'
/
Mlxlng chamber
ErKyWWk mctor
Enzyme lmmobillzed beads
, , PYREX
/,'
J
A
/
\******.**.,~*J-
v
A
.
Figure 3. Chemiluminescence detector integrated with enzyme reactor. From Suda et at., 1992.
method and the conventional method was 0.99. Lactic acid contained in human serum was quantitated using the same procedure as the glucose determination. Samples containing L-lactic acid at concentrations from 4 to 50 mg/dl could be measured. The correlation coefficient between this chemiluminescencemethod and the conventional method was 0.98.
V. CONCLUSION Detection units for enzyme-based FIA were fabricated using micromachining techniques. Since these micromachined devices are batch-processed, they can be made at low cost and with good reproducibility. The signal from the detector decreases as the detector size decreases. However, the electrochemical and chemiluminescence methods are more sensitive than the spectroscopic method. Hence, the measurable range of the micromachined detector is almost the same as for the conventional method. Additionally,the measurement could be carried out at a flow rate of less than 50 pl/min and yet the pressure drop over the column was less than 0.1 atm. This suggests the possibility of applying a micromachined pump. Thus, the conventional plunger pump and sample injector used in the experiments described above will be replaced by micromachined devices in the near future.
Biosensors and Micromachining
3 79
REFERENCES Borky, J.M. & Wise, K.D. (1979). Integrated signal conditioning for silicon pressure sensors. IEEE Trans. Electron Devices ED-26, 1906-191 1. Fan, L.S., Tai, Y.C., & Muller, R.S. (1989). IC-processed electrostatic micromotors. Sensors and Actuators 2 0 , 4 1 4 8 . Manz, A,, Graber, N., & Widmer, H.M. (1990). Miniaturized total chemical analysis system: a novel concept for chemical sensing. Sensors and Actuators B1,244-248. Murakami, Y., Suda, M., Takeuchi, T., Yokoyama, K.. Tamiya, E.. & Karube, I. (1993). Integration of enzyme-immobilized column with electrochemical flow cell using micromachining techniques for a glucose detection system. Anal. Chem. 65,273 1-2735. Roylance, L.M. & Angell, J.B. (1979). A batch-fabricated silicon accelerometer. IEEE Trans. Electron Devices ED-26, 1911-1917. Suda, M., Muramatsu, H., Sakuhara, T., Ataka, T., Uchida, T., Murakami. Y.. Suzuki, M.. Tamiya, E.. Masuda, Y., & Karube, I. (1990). Glucose sensor processed with IC technology for microanalysis. Proc. Electrochem. Conf. Sept. 2%30,33. Chiba, Japan. Suda, M., Sakuhara, T., Suzuki, M., Tamiya, E., & Karube, I. (1992). Micromachined biosensors. Proc. 2nd World Congr. Biosensors, 4 0 M 0 6 . Shoji, S., Nakagawa, S., & Esashi, M. (1990). Micropump and sample-injector for integral chemical analyzing systems. Sensors and Actuators A2 1-A23, 18W92. Teny, S.C., Jerman, J.H., & Angell, J.B. (1979). Gaschromatographicairanalyzer fabricatedon a silicon wafer. IEEE Trans. Electron Devices ED-26, 1880-1 886.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
RECYCLING SENSORS BASED ON KINASES
Ulla Wollenberger, Florian Schubert, Dorothea Pfeiffer, and Frieder W. Scheller
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. THEREACTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. THE ENZYME ELECTRODES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. THE ENZYME OPTODE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. THE ANALYTICAL REACTOR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. THE ENZYME THERMISTOR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
381 382 383 384 385 386 388 388
ABSTRACT The sensitivity of enzyme sensors can be substantially increased by using substrate recycling. This paper summarizes studies on highly sensitive measurements of ADP and ATP based on immobilized hexokinase and pyruvate kinase in various types of analytical arrangements. The analytical techniques applied include electrochemical, optical, and thermometric methods. Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 381-390. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
381
382
WOLLENBERGER, SCHUBERT, PFEIFFER, and SCHELLER
1. INTRODUCTION Analyte recycling is a well studied way to evaluate enzymatic systems that can serve as biochemical amplifiers in enzymatic analysis of very low analyte quantities. The sensitivity enhancement is provided by shuttling the analyte between enzymes acting in a cyclic series of reactions (Lowry and Passonneau, 1972). The basic system consists of an enzyme couple where one enzyme catalyzes the regeneration of the substrate for the other enzyme (see Figure 1). S1 and S2 are depicted as substrates or coenzymes of the respective enzyme. Assuming a sufficiently high activity of enzyme 1 in the presence of its cosubstrate (Cl) and an analyte (Sl) (the concentration of which is far below its Michaelis constant), an amplification is achieved by switching on enzyme 2 by addition of its cosubstrate, C2. The analyte is then cycled between the two enzymes. Consequentlymuch more of the cosubstrates will be converted to the respective products (P1 and P2) than the analyte present, with the overall reaction being: c 1 + C 2 + P 1 +P2 The number of cycles in which the substrate is turned over within a given time is a function of the substrate concentration. While the total concentration of the substrate(s) (S1 + S2) in the reaction cycle is constant, the concentrations of the coreactants increase (P 1, P2) or decrease (C 1, C2) linearly with time. By measuring the concentration change of one of the coreactants directly or in an additional analytical step, the recycling system is used as a biochemical amplifier for the analyte (S 1 or S2). With soluble enzymes at steady state, the overall cycling constant that represents the amplification is that given by Lowry and Passonneau (1972). That is,
k = k,k,/(k,
+ k2)
with ki being the apparent first order constant Vm,i/KM,i. When the enzymes are used in membrane-immobilized form (as in an electrochemical biosensor), the ratio of the sensitivities in the linear measuring range of the amplified and unamplified
enzyme 1 P1
P2
*
enzyme 2
9,.
figure 7. Schematic illustration of enzymatic substrate recycling.
Recycling Sensors Based on Kinases
3 83
regime is called amplification factor, G, which is under steady state conditions (Kulys et al., 1986) expressed by:
G = L2k,k,/ 2D(k, + k2) where L is the membrane thickness and D the diffusion coefficient. The possible amplification is very large. In solution, an amplification rate of 20,000 per hour was obtained (Lowry and Passonneau, 1972), whereas in a membrane of an enzyme electrode up to 48,000-fold signal enhancement was achieved (Scheller et al., 1992). This concept of enzymatic signal amplification has been applied to a number of bioanalytical systems. For example, Lowry et al. (196 1) used enzymatic coenzyme recycling in solution for the determination of pyridine dinucleotides in the lower nanomolar range. In 1974, Davies and Mosbach utilized the regeneration of NAD(H) in enzyme electrodes for the determination of glutamate and pyruvate. Several enzyme electrodes based on recycling of the substrate to be measured have been described (e.g., Schubert et al., 1985, 1986; Kulys et al., 1986; Mizutani et al., 1985; Wollenberger et al., 1987b; Yang et al., 1991a), but there have also been reports on the use of the enzymes in a column combined with a thermistor (Scheller et al., 1985; Kirstein et al., 1989) and in a flow injection system with amperometric detection (Asouzu et al., 1990; Hansen et al., 1990; Yang et al., 1991b). Kinase reactions, owing to their mostly favorable equilibrium constants, are well suited to recycling experiments. Recycling of ATP with immobilized enzymes was first achieved using coencapsulated hexokinase and pyruvate kinase (Campbell and Chang, 1975). However, these investigations were aimed at the regeneration of cofactors. This particular paper summarizes studies on highly sensitive measurements of ADP and ATP based on immobilized hexokinase andpyruvate kinase in various types of analytical arrangements. The analytical techniques applied include electrochemical, optical, and thermometric methods.
II. THE REACTION For the recycling experiments hexokinase (HK) and pyruvate kinase (PK) have been coimmobilized. The basic reaction cycle is HK
ATP + glucose -+ ADP + glucose-6-phosphate PK
ADP + phosphoenolpyruvate + ATP + pyruvate In the unamplified mode only one ofthe reactions is used. For example, unamplified (usual) ADP measurements can be performed in the presence of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP). One molecule of pyruvate and ATP are formed per molecule ADP converted.
3 84
WOLLENBERGER, SCHUBERT, PFEIFFER, and SCHELLER
Amplification is obtained when, in addition to PEP, glucose is introduced in the bulk solution. Now, HK is switched on; consequently, ATP is converted back to ADP, which again enters the PK reaction, and so forth. Any ADP or ATP diffusing to the enzymes is recycled many times during formation of one molecule of pyruvate (in the PK-reaction) and glucose-6-phosphate (in the HK-reaction) per cycle. The amplification can be detected via glucose-6-phosphate or pyruvate measurement or, more directly, with registration of the reaction heat.
111. THE ENZYME ELECTRODES The sensitive measurement of ADP/ATP with the enzyme electrode is based on the transformation of the tremendous amount of pyruvate formed in the recycling reaction involving oxygen consumption by the sequence of lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) and lactate monooxygenase (LMO) (Wollenberger et al., 1987a). Pyruvate + NADH 3 lactate + NAD+ LMO
Lactate + 0, -+ acetate + CO,
+ H,O
An appropriate biosensor has been constructed by combining an oxygen electrode and a gelatin layer comprising the four enzymes. In the presence of nonlimiting amounts of PEP and NADH (2.5 mM each), the sensor works as a three enzyme sequence electrode for ADP. The oxygen consumption depends linearly on ADP concentration up to 1 mM. When an excess of glucose (4.4 mM) is added, the sensitivity ofthe electrode to ADP is significantly increased, thus indicating analyte recycling between PK and HK. The corresponding current decrease is completed after 4 to 10 min. In a typical experiment 1.25 pM ADP caused the same current change in the amplification system as 300 pM did with the unamplified enzyme sequence. The detection limit with substrate amplification is 0.25 pM ADP and 0.1 pM ATP, whereas 50 pM is the limit of the ADP-sequence electrode without recycling. The calculated average amplification factor is 220 in the linear range of the ADP concentration dependence (Figure 2). The LDWLMO detector enzymes have been substituted with pyruvate oxidase (Schubert and Kehr, unpublished) or glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PDH). The latter has been utilized with an indication of NADH at a chemically modified graphite electrode (Yang et al., 1991a). For this purpose, heat treated graphite rods were immersed into an acetonic modifier solution [0.5% bis(benzophenoxazinyl) derivative of terephthaloic acid] for 5 s and covered with a layer of gelatin entrapped G6PDH, PK, and HK. The recycling process produces glucose6-phosphate, which is oxidized by G6PDH in the formation of NADH. Glucose-6-phosphate + NAD'
G6PDH
-+ gluconate-6-phosphate + NADH
Recycling Sensors Based on Kinases
385
current. nA
1 031
ATP ADP amplified 1
rnpIified 10
100
loo0
loo00
concentration, pmol/l Figure2. Relationship between the steady state current ofthe PWHWLDHILMO-fourenzymeelectrode and the concentrationof ADP (withand without PEP), and ATP (with PEP).
At a working potential of 0 mV vs. SCE the mediated oxidation of NADH is monitored. With all substrates present in sufficient amounts (3 mM PEP, 1.25 mM glucose, 1mM NAD'), a response to ATP was observed in 2 to 10min. The calibration graph is linear up to about 0.4 pM. ATP concentrations as low as 1 nM were detected. Comparing the slopes of the ATP calibration graph with and without (i.e., without PEP) recycling, a ratio of 1450 was calculated. This value represents the amplification factor of the given electrode.
IV. THE ENZYME OPTODE Because the combination of biochemical recognition elements with optical transducers has gained increasingimportance during the last years, it was of interest to couple the present kinase cycle with a fiber optic detector in order to obtain an enzyme amplification optode (Schubert, 1993).The reaction of G6PDH, which can be conveniently coupled to the kinases, lends itself to optical signal generation through the fluorescence of the formed NADH. The optode was constructed by fixing a polyurethane membrane containing coimmobilized PK, HK, and G6PDH to the tip of a fiber optic fluorescenceprobe, the Ingold FluorosensorTM.Optode function is based on the fact that NADH
386
WOLLENBERGER, SCHUBERT, PFEIFFER, and SCHELLER -3-
ADP, pmol/l
10
20
30
40
50
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
0.2
0.L
I
-x-
0.6 0.8 ATP, mmol/l
1
I
1.0
Figure 3. Calibration graphs for ADP (with PEP) and ATP (without PEP) using the PKIHWCGPDH optode.
fluoresces at 460 nm when excited at around 360 nm whereas its oxidized form does not. Fluorosensor light from a low-pressure mercury lamp is passed through interference filters to produce a light beam at 360 nm, which is guided through the probe tip into the surrounding medium by a quartz fiber bundle. The radiation emanating from the tip causes NADH to fluoresce, and the resulting emission is detected via a parallel fiber bundle, appropriate filters, and a photomultiplier tube. Operation of the enzyme optode as a linear two-enzyme sequence sensor for ATP results in a calibration curve that is linear up to 0.6 mM, the lower limit of detection being 10 pM. If, in addition to NAD' and glucose required for this measurement, PEP is present in the background solution (optimum concentration, 0.8 mM), the optode responds to ADP. The calibration graph (Figure 3) shows a short linear portion, up to 5 pM, with a slope about 90 times as large as that for ATP. This amplification permits ADP concentrations as low as 100 nM to be determined. Saturation for both analytes is reached at the same signal magnitude, thus giving evidence for diffusion limitation. The relative standard deviation for 10 successive assays of 2.5 pM ADP was determined to be 5.9%.
V. THE ANALYTICAL REACTOR An alternative way to use enzymatic substrate amplification is the separation of enzyme recycling and detection. For this purpose PK, HK, and G6PDH, which were also used in an enzyme electrode (see above), were coimmobilized on porous glass (Serva CPG-l0,0.75-0.125 mm, pore diameter 50 nm) and filled into a miniaturized column (Yang et al., 1991b). The enzyme column was then applied to a flow injection systemwith amperometricNADH indication using a phenazinium-modified graphite
RecyclingSensors Based on Kinases
387
working electrode. Oxidation of NADH is monitored at 0 V vs. Ag/AgCl(sat. KCl) reference electrode. In the presence of 1 mM NAD' the indicator reaction depends linearly on the concentration of glucose-6-phosphate up to 400 pM. The operation of the enzyme column under nonamplified conditions (presence of 1 mM glucose) was stable for more than 2 months. No significant variation of the sensitivity has been found at different flow rates. This lack of variation might be due to the compensation of two opposite effects, a reduced sensitivity at increasing flow rates, i.e., higher dispersion, and an increased sensitivity based on improved mass transfer. The recycling system is switched on by addition of PEP (3 mM). The response was linear over more than three decades, from 1 nM to 5 pM.In contrast to enzyme electrodes, the amplification factor for recycling in an enzyme reactor is not fixed, it depends on the residence time T of the substrate in the column (Yang et al., 1991b): G = Tk,k,/(k, + k2)
Obviously, the residence time plays the same role as the characteristic diffusion term L2/2D in enzyme electrodes with internal analyte recycling. The residence time for 25 p1 of 1 p M ATP has been increased to 70 s by decreasing the flow rate from 0.98 ml/min to 0.07 ml/min. This caused a linear increase of the oxidation current from 10 nA to nearly 150 nA. At this low flow rate the amplification factor became 350. The logical continuation of these experiments is the complete stop of the analyte flow within the column. A 5-min stop time resulted in a 12-times higher value than current, nA I
Figure 4. Effect of the controlled stop-time of the analyte flow (0.22 ml/min) on the response to 10 nM ATP of a substrate recycling analytical reactor in combination with a chemically modified electrode for NADH.
388
WOLLENBERGER, SCHUBERT, PFEIFFER, and SCHELLER
that obtained for 10 nh4 ATP using a continuous flow of 0.22 d m i n (Figure 4). An amplification factor of 1200 could be achieved at the controlled stop-time of 12 min.
VI. THE ENZYME THERMISTOR One enzyme thermistor probe experiment involved an enzyme column with coimmobilized kinases, a thermistor at the outlet of the reactor, and a reference thermistor, both arranged in a flow-through setup (Danielsson and Mosbach, 1988; Kirstein et al., 1989). The heat produced by the enzymatic reactions in the column was monitored. PK and HK were coimmobilized with high activities (44 U HK, 5 1 U PK per 1 g) on aminopropyl controlled pore glass. The PK/HK couple combines an exothermic and an endothermic reaction. The calorimetric signal of the HK catalyzed reaction is positive (about 75 kJ/mol in TRIS buffer) and depends linearly on the ATP signal up to 1 mM. The enthalpy change of the PK reaction is positive (about +30 kJ/mol). With cofactor recycling (Le., in the presence of PEP and glucose) at 10 pM ADP or ATP the signal is as high as that obtained for 300 pM ATP with HK alone, i.e., an amplification factor of 30, was reached. Since the absolute value of the negative enthalpy of the HK reaction is higher than that of the PK reaction, the net heat change, which is amplified is also negative. However, the calibration curves for ADP and ATP are nonlinear. Considerable enhancement of the sensitivity for the cofactors was achieved by double amplification in a two-reactor system. A lactate oxidase (LOD)/LDW catalase reactor, as has been described for pyruvate amplification (Scheller et al., 1985), was inserted into the flow between the PUHK reactor and the thermistor. For this further amplification, it is advantageous that both enzyme reactions are exothermic (LDH AH = -62.1 kJ/mol, LOD AH = -100 kJ/mol). The pyruvate leaving the first column is recycled in the second reactor. Pyruvate + NADH L3 lactate + NAD+ LOD
Lactate + 0,+ pyruvate + H,O, In the LDWLOD/catalase reactor (in the presence of 2 mM NADH) an amplification factor for the pyruvate response of about 55 was obtained. The amplification factor of the HKPK cycle was 30. Thus the combination of both recycling systems provided an overall amplification of the sensitivity for ADP/ATP up to 1700 and a detection limit of 10 nM.
VII. CONCLUSIONS The common principle for all the sensors presented here is the recycling of the analyte between pyruvate kinase and hexokinase. Apart from the different transduc-
Recycling Sensors Based on Kinases
389
tion schemes, a variety of immobilization matrices using different specific enzyme activities have been employed.Therefore it appears difficult to compare the sensors in terms of quantitative data. The differences in the amplification factors between the two enzyme electrodes rely mainly on different membrane thicknesses and the higher enzyme activities used in the three-enzyme electrode. However, the threeenzyme electrode and the enzyme optode, both employing the HWPWG6PDH system, exhibit very different recycling efficiencies. This may be due to the different membrane materials used. Furthermore, the lower overall sensitivity of the optode may be a result of the poor (large and flat) geometry of the sensor tip and the fact that, in contrast to the electrochemicalsensor, NADH is accumulated in the membrane, thereby slowing down the G6PDH reaction. In the reactor the immobilization of high kinase activities results in an extended operational stability. However, the efficiency of the enzymatic analyte recycling is restricted by the volume of the column and the residence time of the analyte within the column. Consequently, the accumulation of a product of the recycling process and its subsequent stripping is a way to improve the amplified sensor operation. The multiplication of the amplification by a second recycling enzyme pair yields a futher increase in sensitivity. It is quite clear that enzymatic recycling provides a potent and universal method for amplification of the response of biosensors that is applicable to all types of transducer. The coupling of the recycling system with additional enzymatic reactions by coimmobilizingall the required enzymes in the sensor membrane demonstrates that enzymatic amplification sensors do not necessarily require recycling systems that produce directly transducable species. This considerably extends the concept of enzymatic analyte amplification in electrochemical biosensors.
REFERENCES Asouzu, M.U., Nonidez, W.K.. & Ho, M.H. (1990). Flow injection analysis of L-lactate with enzyme amplification and amperometric detection. Anal. Chem. 62, 70g712. Campbell, J. & Chang, T.M.S. (1975). Enzymatic recycling of coenzymes by a multi-enzyme system immobilized within semipermeable collodion microcapsules. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 397, 101120. Danielsson, B. & Mosbach, K. (1988). In: Methods in Enzymology, Vol. 137 (Mosbach. K., Ed.), Academic Press, New York. Davies, P. & Mosbach, K. (1974). The application of immobilized NAD' in an enzyme electrode and in model enzyme reactors. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 370,329-338. Hansen, E.H., Amdal, A,, & Norgaard, L. (1990). Exploitation of the flow injection approach for analytical procedures based on enzymatic amplification reactions. Anal. Lett. 23,225-240. Kirstein, D., Danielsson, B., Scheller, F.W., & Mosbach, K. (1989). Highly sensitive enzyme thermistor determination of ADP and ATP by multiple recycling enzyme systems. Biosensors 4,231-239. Kulys, J.J., Sorochinskii, V.V., & Vidziunaite, R.A. (1986). Transient response of bienzyme electrodes. Biosensors 2, 135146. Lowry, O.H. & Passonneau, J.V. (1972). In: AFlexible System ofEnzymatic Analysis. Academic Press, New York.
390
WOLLENBERCER, SCHUBERT, PFEIFFER, and SCHELLER
Lowry, O.H., Passonneau, J.V., Schulz, D.W., & Rock, M.K. (1961). The measurement of pyridine nucleotides by enzymatic cycling. J. Biol. Chem. 236,274&2755. Mizutani, F., Yamanaka, T., Tanabe, Y., & Tsuda. K. (1985). An enzyme electrode for L-lactate with a chemically-amplified response. Anal. Chim. Acta 177, 153-1 66. Scheller, F.W., Schubert, F., Pfeiffer, D., Wollenberger, U., Renneberg, R., Hintsche, R., & Kiihn, M. (1992). In: Biosensors: Fundamentals, Technologies and Applications (Scheller. F.W. & Schmid, R.D., Eds.), GBF Monographs Voi. 17, 3-10, Scheller, F.W., Siegbahn, N., Danielsson, B., & Mosbach, K. (1985). High-sensitive enzyme thermistor determination of L-lactate by substrate recycling. Anal. Chem. 57, 174k1743. Schubert, F, (1993). A fiber-optic enzyme sensor for the determination of adenosine diphosphate using internal analyte recycling. Sensors Actuat. B. 11,53 1-535. Schubert, F., Kirstein, D., Schroder. K.L.. & Scheller, F.W. (1985). Enzyme electrodes with substrate and co-enzyme amplification, Anal. Chirn. Acta 169,391-396. Schubert, F., Kirstein, D., Scheller, F., Appelqvist, R., Gorton, L., & Johansson, G. (1986). Enzyme electrodes for L-glutamate using chemical redox mediators and enzymatic substrateamplification. Anal. Lett. 19, 1273-1288. Schubert, F. & Kehr, S., unpublished. Wollenberger, U., Schubert, F., Scheller, F.W., Danielsson, B., & Mosbach, K. (1987a). Abiosensor for ADP with internal substrate amplification. Anal. Lett. 20.657468. Wollenberger, U., Schubert, F., Scheller, F.W., Danielsson, B., & Mosbach, K. (1987b). Coupled reactions with immobilized enzymes in biosensors. Studia Biophys. 119. 167-170. Yang, X., Pfeiffer, D., Johansson, G., & Scheller, F.W. (1991a). Enzyme electrodes for ADPIATP with enhanced sensitivity due to chemical amplification and intermediate accumulation. Electroanalysis 3,659663. Yang, X., Pfeiffer, D., Johansson, G., & Scheller. F.W. (1991b). Nanomolar level amperometric determination of ATP through substrate recycling in an enzyme reactor in a FIA system. Anal. Lett. 24, 1401-1417.
ELECTRON CONDUCTING ADDUCTS OF WATER-SOLUBLE REDOX POLYELECTROLYTES A N D ENZYMES
loanis Katakis, Mark Vreeke, Ling Ye, Atsushi Aoki, and Adam Heller
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 392 I. INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 392 11. ELECTRON DIFFUSION IN REDOX HYDROGELS . . . . . . . . . . . . 393 111. ELECTRON CONNECTION OF FLAVOENZYME REDOX CENTERS TO ELECTRODES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 396 IV. ELECTRICAL CONNECTION OF PYRROLOQUINOLINE 401 QUINONE REDOX CENTERS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v. ELECTRICAL CONNECTION OF HEMEPROTEIN PEROXIDASES . . . 403 VI. ASSAY OF NAD(P)H THROUGH QUANTITATIVE TRANSLATION TO H202 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 405
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 391409. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press h e . All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
391
392
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
ABSTRACT Biochemical fluxes were transduced to electrical currents through catalytic centers of oxidoreductases, that were electrically connected to electrodes with crosslinked hydrogel forming redox polymers. The enzymes were covalently bound to the hydrogels through which the electrons diffuse. The electron difision coeficients, reaching lo4 cm2sec-' in the redox polymer gels, were high enough to allow efficient collection of the electronstransferred during the electrooxidationor electroreduction of substrates. The adequate electron diffusion through the polymer skeleton of the hydrogel and the rapid diffusion of water-soluble substrates and products in the gels led to high current density enzyme electrodes. These included electrodes with electrically connected flavoenzymes (e.g., sarcosine, glutamate, lactate and glucose oxidases), quinoprotein enzymes (e.g., PQQ glucose dehydrogenase) and heme enzymes (e.g. peroxidases). The peroxidase electrodes were useful in the sensing of NAD(P)H that reacted with oxygen in the presence of N-methyl phenazonium salts to form NAD(P)+ and H202.
1. INTRODUCTION AND SCOPE In this chapter, dedicated to Klaus Mosbach on his 60th birthday, we consider the non-diffusional relaying of electrons between redox enzymes and electrodes through hydrogels, built with crosslinked polymer networks. As will be seen, even though these gels contain predominantly water, their 3-dimensional redox-polymer network, to which the enzymes are covalently bound, conducts electrons. Electrochemical biosensors, such as amperometric biosensors based on such gels have some rather unique properties. On the one side, water soluble substrates and products permeate through the hydrogels. On the other, electrons, originating in an oxidizable substrate, or delivered to a reducible substrate, diffuse through the network. Because the electrons are efficiently collected or delivered and because the diffusion of water soluble molecules through the gel does not differ excessively from that through a plain aqueous solution, the current densities flowing through hydrogel-coated electrodesare high. The high current densities translate to substantial sensitivitiesin the transduction of the flux of biochemicals to electrical currents as reviewed by Heller (1992). The group of enzymes that has been electrically connected through electron-conducting hydrogels to electrodes includes now flavoenzymes (Foulds and Lowe, 1988; Gregg and Heller, 1990, 1991a,b;, Katakis and Heller, 1992),quinoprotein (pyrroloquinoline, PQQ) enzymes (Ye et al., 1993), and heme peroxidases (Vreeke et al., 1993). As will be seen, the hydrogels also allow transduction of NAD(P)H fluxes, after translation to hydrogen peroxide fluxes, to electrical currents (Vreeke et al., 1993). We shall review the electron diffusionin redox-polymer skeleton based hydrogels (Aoki and Heller, 1993),then discuss the electrical connection of flavoenzymes (Foulds and Lowe, 1988; Gregg
Electron Conducting Adducts
393
and Heller, 1990, 1991a,b; Katakis and Heller, 1992), heme enzymes (Vreeke et al., 1993), PQQ-enzymes (Ye et al., 1993) via these hydrogels to electrodes.
II. ELECTRON DIFFUSION IN REDOX HYDROGELS Cross-linked redox polymer films in which redox enzymes are immobilized relay electrons between oxidoreductases such as glucose oxidase and electrodes. An effective electron relaying polymer is poly(4-vinylpyridine)partially complexed with osmium bis(bipyridine) dichloride and quatemized with 2-bromoethylamine (POs-EA) (Figure 1) (Gregg and Heller, 199la,b). A key parameter in defining the electron relaying behavior of a redox polymer is its electron diffusion coefficient (De).We measured D, for POs-EA, cross-linked with poly(ethy1ene glycol) diglycidyl ether (PEGDE),using steady state voltammetry at interdigitated array (IDA) electrodes (Chidsey et al., 1986; Feldman and Murray, 1986, 1987; Dalton et al., 1990; Sunidge et al., 1992; Nishihara et al., 1991; Kittlesen et al., 1985; Belanger et al., 1987; Smith et al., 1988; Shu and Wrighton, 1988; Goss and Majda, 1991). D, depends on the ionic strength,anion, pH, and degree of cross-linking of POs-EA. D, was measured by the steady state voltammetry at interdigitated array (IDA) electrodes as follows: IDAgold electrodeson glass were fabricated by conventional photolithography and sputter-deposition of gold onto chromium primed glass
i
C&OCCH2CH2N PA2 (I)
3l3
l!3POA""y-v PEGDE (b)
Figure 1. Structure of the water soluble, enzyme complexing redox "wire" POs-EA. m = 1, n = 1, p = 3 or 2. The polymer-enzyme complexes are crosslinked with either: (a) a polyfunctional aziridine (PAZ), or (b) poly(ethy1ene glycol) diglycidyl ether (PEGDE)to yield hydrogel-forming networks.
394
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
substrates. The electrodes consisted of 100 (N), 5.0 pm wide fingers (w), separated by 5.0 pm gaps (gap), that were 2.0 mm long. The narrow widths and gaps of the 100 fingers allowed measurement of electron diffusion coefficients, that were much lower than ion diffusion coefficients. When the potential at one of the IDA electrodes was swept from reducing to oxidizing, while the other electrode was maintained at a reducing potential (generator-collector experiment), an anodic steady state current (Is,) was observed upon redox cycling, because the electrode at the fixed reducing potential generated an oxidizable species. The total charge associated with the redox centers (Q) was obtained by integrating the area of the surface wave voltammogram when the potential of both of the IDA electrodes was scanned (generator-generatorexperiment). From I,, and Q, D, is obtained through equation 1 (Chidsey et al. 1986, Feldman and Murray, 1986, 1987). De = (IJQ gap (W )+ gap) NlCN-1)
(1)
The attractive feature of this technique was that D, was derived of I,,, Q and the IDA geometry, and did not require knowledge of either the film thickness or of the concentration ofthe redox species. Furthermore,because the technique was a steady state method, the current was not affected by diffusion of ions into and out of the redox polymer network, that necessarily takes place in transient experiments. Typical cyclic voltammograms for POs-EA, cross-linked with 5.0 wt% PEGDE, on IDA electrodes at a 1.O mV/s scan rate are shown in Figure 2a. The voltammograms in generator-collector experiments (solid line) had a sigmoidal shape; They showed the expected Os2+oxidation at the generator, transport of electrons through the redox polymer (by electron hopping or electron self-exchange between neighboring Os3+and 0s'' sites) and re-reduction of Os3+sites at the collector (so called redox cycling). The anodic limiting current was identical with the cathodic one, and the limiting current was independent of scan rate. These results indicated the ' ~ ratio ' between the existence of a linear concentration variation in the 0 ~ ~ 'site generator and the collector electrodes at the 1.O mVs-' scan rate, and established that charge transport through the POs-EA polymer limited the current. In contrast, the voltammograms in generator-generatorexperiment (dotted lines) showed welldefined surface waves. As the voltammetric wave was symmetrical and the peak current was proportional to the scan rate, the total charge of POs-EApolymer coated IDA electrode (Q) could be calculated by integrating the current of the voltammogram. From equation 1, D, at 0.1 M NaCl was calculated to be 4.8 x lo-' cm2s-'. The voltammograms of Figure 2 reveal a strong ionic strength dependence of D,. When the concentration ofNaCl was changed from 0.1 M to 1.O M, Q was constant but I,, decreased. Moreover, when the potential of one IDA electrode was swept, while the other of IDA electrode was disconnected (generator-open circuit experiment, dashed line), a shoulder, indicating lateral electron diffusion between fingers was seen. This shoulder was sharp in 0.1 M NaCl but had, in 1.0 M NaCl, a diffusional tail, leading us to conclude that De of POs-EA decreases upon increasing
Electron Conducting Adducts
395
b
a -0.1
0.1
0.3
0.5
Potentlat, V vs SCE
I
01
03
05
7
Potential. V vs SCE
Figure 2. Ionic strength dependence of cyclic voltammograms for POs-EA crosslinked with 5.0 wt% PEGDE coated on IDA electrodes, at an Os3+’*+site coverage of r = 1.93 x mol cm-2 in 20 mM phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 and at 1 .O rnV s-’ scan rate. Generator-collector (solid line), generator-open circuit (dashed line), generator-generator (dotted line) voltammograms are shown for (a), 0.1 M; (b), 1 .O M NaCI.
with the ionic strength. Evidently, dehydration of POs-EA at increasing ionic strengths made the cross-linked structure more rigid. Figure 3 presents the pH dependence of D, for POs-EAcross-linked with 5.0 wt% PEGDE. D, changes remarkably near pH 4, close to pKa of the pyridine nitrogen, from 4.5 x lop9to 1.6 x lo4 cm2s-’. Evidently, the polymer film was swollen and the backbone of the polymer was flexible when the pyridines were protonated at a pH below pKa,where D, was high. We conclude that D, is determined by the degree of swelling of the cross-linked POs-EApolymer. D, values of the POs-EApolymer at various concentrations of cross-linker are summarized in Table 1. For the network made with 5.0 wt% cross-linker D, was pH dependent. D, was, however, almost independent of pH at 25 wt% cross-linker. When the concentration of cross-linker reached 25 wt%, 32 % of the pyridines in the polymer were cross-linked with the diepoxide. Because the polymer could not swell even at low pH, D, became independent of pH. We conclude that in cross-linked POs-EA the electron diffusion coefficients increase upon hydration of the network and that electron transport through networks is controlled by segmental motion of the polymer backbone.
396
I . KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
1.5
.-
r
'cn
N5 m -
E
1 . 0 -.
X
ow 0.5
-.
0
0
2
6
4
8
10
12
PH
Figure 3. pH dependence of the electron diffusion coefficient of POs-EA cross-linked with 5.0 wt% PEGDE, = 4.35 x 1 O-' mol cm-2 in 20 mM phosphatebuffer containing 0.1 M NaCl at 2.0 mV s-' scan rate.
Table 1. Effect of the Extent of Cross Linking on the Electron Diffusion Coefficient (D,) ~
Cross Linker wt%
p H 3.0
p H 7.0
5
1.6 x 10-8
4.5 x 10-9
25
4.2 x lo4
3.2 x 10")
111. ELECTRON CONNECTION OF FLAVOENZYME REDOX CENTERS TO ELECTRODES We have described previously the synthetic procedure for hydrogel-formingredox polymers (Gregg and Heller, 1991b). Poly(viny1pyridine) can be derivatized with Os(bpy),Cl, in ethylene glycol or ethanol under reflux. The osmium derivatized polymer can be reacted with bromoethylamine at 60°C. It has been found that the polymer containing a molar substitutionratio near 1: 1:3 osmium :ethylamhe :non substituted pyridines, meets requirements relevant to enzyme electrodes, such as solubility in water, high charge density, high osmium loading, and crosslinkable
Electron Conducting Adducts
397
side chains. For effectiveelectricalconnectionof enzyme redox centers the polymer must be flexible so that it can penetratethe proteins. We have found that the polymer POs-EA (Figure 1) electrically “wires” redox enzymes. The hydrogel networks are formed by crosslinking POs-EA at or near ambient temperature and in aqueous solution with the diepoxide polyethylene glycol diglycidyl ether (PEGDE) (Figure 1b) or a polyfunctional aziridine (PAZ) (Figure 1a). The crosslinker is chosen so as to avoid reaction of amino-acids that are critical for the fknction of the enzyme. With polymeric “wires” virtually all flavoproteins,that can transfer one electron at a time from their reduced active centers to an electron acceptor, have been shown to be “wireable” and useful in the construction of enzyme electrodes. Selectivity of the electrodes requires absence of direct electrooxidationof the substrate on the electrode surface itself, or in the redox hydrogel, directly by the oxidized osmium complex, at the applied usually 0.45 V vs. SCE for POs-EA. High catalytic current density (1@-lod3Acm-’) enzyme electrodes have been constructedby “wiring” glucose oxidase, lactate, or L-a-glycerophosphateoxidase (Gregg and Heller, 1991b; Katakis and Heller, 1992); moderate current densities ( 104-1 OP5 AcmP2)resulted form “wiring”glycolate, theophylline, D-amino acid, sarcosine, L-glutamicacid, or cholesterol oxidase. The catalyticcurrents of L-amino acid and choline oxidase electrodes were very low. For xanthine oxidase the catalytic current was almost indistinguishable from the background current associated with nonenzymatic electrooxidation of xanthine by the oxidized redox polymer. Examination of the significance of complex formation between the redox polymers and the enzymes on the efficiency of current collection shows that electrostatic complexation is important for efficient communication between the enzymes and the polymers (Katakis et al., 1994), but other kinds of interactions may also be relevant. Figure 4 shows the response of a sarcosine oxidase electrode and the variation of its current density with the electrode construction parameters. The response of the electrode under anaerobic conditions and under oxygen are shown in Figure 4a. Figure 4b shows the variation of the current density with the enzyme content of the hydrogel. Figure 4c shows that by changing the enzyme content of the gel one can adjust the dynamic range (apparent Michaelis constant, Km) of the sensor. Figure 4d shows that increasing the thickness of the enzyme-polymer film results in an almost linear increase of the maximum current density obtained, up to about 200 pg cm-2 loading, where the film thickness reaches about 2 pm. Sarcosine oxidase has been used in bilayer electrodes for the detection of creatine (Motonaka et al., 1990). Creatine was converted in an outer creatine amidinohydrolase film into sarcosine, which was sensed by an inner layer of sarcosine oxidase-redox polymer hydrogel. The response of such an electrode is compared to one without the creatine amidinohydrolase in Figure 5. The electrode might be applicable in the direct determination of creatine phosphokinase activity in serum or whole blood.
150
a
20
0
60
40
[Sucosine],
80
100
120
mM
0.0
2 0 4 . 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.2
0.6
0.4
0.8
1.0
Enzyme Weight Wction in Hydrogel
0.8
1.0
Enzyme Weight Fraction in Hydrogel
0
I
100
.
,
200
.
, 300
.
I 400
Leading, pg em-'
Figure 4. (a) Dependence of the current density of a sarcosine oxidase electrode on sarcosine concentration. Open circles, Ar atmosphere; solid circles, 0 2 atmosphere; glassy carbon electrode; 20 weight OO/ enzyme; 200 pg cm-2 loading; 0.45 V (SCE); pH 7.2 phosphate buffer, 0.1 M NaCI; 1000 rpm; 22°C. (b) Dependence of the maximum current density of sarcosine oxidase electrodes on the enzyme content of the hydrogel at 150 pg crK2 loading. Conditions same as above. Jmax determined from Eadie-Hofstee plots. (c) Dependence of the apparent Michaelis constants of sarcosine oxidase electrodes on the enzyme content of the hydrogel. (d) Dependence of the maximum current density of sarcosine electrodes made with 20 weight YOenzyme on the thickness of the hydrogel-films.
Electron Conducting Adducts
0
399
10
20
D
[Creatine], mM
Figure 5. Response of a bilayer sarcosine - creatine amidinohydrolase electrode (open circles) to creatine. The solid circles show the creatine-responseof a sarcosine electrode made without the hydrolase. The hydrogel-forming polymer contained 26% sarcosine oxidase, 20% PAZ crosslinker, and 54% POs-EA. Loading was 50 pg cm-2.The bilayer electrode had an exterior film of 40 pg of creatine amidinohydrolase (0.5 units) crosslinked with PAZ and poly(viny1pyridine) quaternized with bromoethylamine.
In some of the flavoenzymes, for example in glycerophosphate oxidase, the semiquinone form of FADH. could not be observed during the normal catalytic cycle when dioxygen was the electron acceptor (Claibome, 1986; Jacobs and VanDemark, 1960). From the efficient electron transfer to Os(II1) relays that were observed, it was evident nevertheless that the substrate-reduced enzyme was reoxidized in two sequential electron-proton transfer steps. The rate limiting step in the multistep electron transfer from lactate oxidase to an electrode was the electron transfer between reduced FADH, centers and 0 s relays in the hydrogel. Figure 6 shows the pH response of a glucose oxidase electrode. Different pH maxima exist for the redox-hydrogel electrodeand the natural enzyme activity. This shift in pH is consistent with the proposal that electron transfer between FADH, or FADH. and Os(III), which is pH independent, is rate limiting. In the natural enzymatic reaction the pH dependent reduction of 0, to H,O, is rate limiting. The key determinants in realization of high current densities are the turnover number and specific activity of the enzyme, and the strength of the complex between the enzyme and the redox polymer (Table 2). In general enzymeswith high turnover numbers and high complex formation constants with POs-EA give the highest current densities. The unexpectedly high current density of sarcosine oxidase and low current density of glutamate oxidase show, however, that the two parameters are not the only ones that are important. It is conceivable that the aberrations result from a specific interaction of the polymer with the catalytically active site of the enzyme, or from particularly deep protein penetration of an electron relay, or from deactivation of the enzyme upon immobilization.
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
400 1.1
1
5
i
6
0
7
9
10
PH Figure 6. pH dependence of the glucose-produced current of a glassy carbon electrode, modified with the hydrogel formed of glucose oxidase, POs-EA and PEGDE under argon (open circles) and of a hydrogen peroxide detecting platinum electrode modified with the same gel, except for having the POs-EA analog without the osmium complex under oxygen (solid circles). 10% weight glucose oxidase, 80 pg cm-2 loading.
The turnover number and specific activity of the enzyme define the number of electronsproduced per unit volume. In extreme cases of low turnover numbers, the volume fraction of protein necessary for the production of a detectable current is so high that the hydrogel no longer contains a hgh enough density of electron relaying centers and electron diffusion through the film becomes rate limiting. Table 2 shows Table 2. Response of "Wired" Flavin Oxidase Electrodes and its Relationship to Kinetics of the Enzyme, Strength of Enzyme-Polymercomplex and Crosslinker Used* Highest Current Density (PA cm-=,
Enzyme'
GOx LOX GPO GLUx
sox THOx CHOx DAAOx Notes:
290 120 83 6.5 90 2 1 7
% Enzyme Content of
Turnover Number
Complex at Sawration"
(s-')
73 >68 81
203 144 30 79 14 ? 8 3.5
75 73 >56
62 86
Crosslinke;"
PEGDE PEGDE,PAZ PEGDE PEGDE PAZ PAZ PEGDE PAZ
Electrodes so constructed as to be kinetically limited and have 0.1 k 0.02 units immobilized. Abbreviations : GOx, glucose oxidase; LOX,lactate oxidase; GPO, L-a-glycerophosphateoxidase; GLUx, L-glutamic acid oxidase; SOX,sarcosine oxidase; THOx, theophyline oxidase; CHOx, cholesterol oxidase; DAAOx, D-amino acid oxidase ** As determined by iwlectric focusing experiments. .I. PAZ: polyfunctional aziridine, PEGDE : poly(ethy1ene glycol) diglycidyl ether.
Electron Conducting Adducts
401
the strength of the complexes formed between POs-EA and enzymes on a scale built on detection by isoelectric focusing of migration of free enzyme from the complex (Katakis et al., 1994). The values in the table indicate the % enzyme content of the complex when unbound enzyme is first observed. Usually, the higher this number, the stronger the complex, and the stronger the complex, the higher the current density. Formation of a stronger complex can result in a shorter electron transfer distance between the redox center of the enzyme and a relay ofthe polymer, or an increase in the density of electrically connected enzyme centers in the hydrogel.
IV. ELECTRICAL CONNECTION OF PYRROLOQUlNOLlNE QUINONE REDOX CENTERS Several groups of quinonprotein enzymes have been isolated and characterized in recent years (Duine et al., 1987). These enzymes have either pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ), topaquinone (TPQ) or tryptophanyl-tryptophan quinone (TTQ) cofactors (Duine, 1991). Glucose dehydrogenase GDH (EC 1.1.99.17), that was successfidly wired through the POs-EA based hydrogel (Ye et al., 1993)belongs to the group of PQQ-containing quinoproteins (Duine et al. 1979). The apo-enzyme (Van der Meer et al., 1990)of GDH was reconstituted by incorporating PQQ (Duine et al., 1979) in the presence of Ca2' (Geiger and Goerish, 1989). PQQ and Ca2+are firmly bound in the reconstituted enzyme. The activity of the reconstituted holoenzyme, 250 units mg-', was measured spectrophotometrically by monitoring the decoloration of Wurster's Blue (Dokter, et al., 1986). The reconstituted GDH can be stored at 4°C for more than two months without measurable loss of activity. The dependence of the current density on glucose concentration for POsENPEGDE-wired GDH and similarly wired glucose oxidase (GOX) electrodes is shown in Figure 7. The current density ofthe GDH electrode substantiallyexceeded that of the GOX electrode, reaching 1.8 mA cm-2 at 70 mM glucose. This current density was about three times higher than that of the electrode made with GOX. The sensitivity of the wired GDH electrode at 5 mM glucose was 165 pA cmP2M-' . The higher current density of the GDH electrode, relative to that of the GOX electrode, derived from the faster rate of electron transfer from the PQQH, centers than from FADH, centers to the osmium complex in the redox polymer/enzyme network. That the 3-dimensional redox network based hydrogel is effective in collecting and carrying electrons from GDH is seen from the fact that in electrodesmade with the electron shuttling diffusional mediator 1,l '-dimethylferrocene, the current density was only 54 pA cmP2at 4 mM glucose (D'Costa et al., 1986) versus 724 pA cmP2 for the redox hydrogel at the same glucose concentration. The current density of the redox-hydrogel based GDH electrode changed relatively little between pH 6.3 and 8.8.
402
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER 2ooo 1500
lo00
500
0
0
20
40
60
80
100
glucose Concentration, m M
Figure 7. Comparison of the current output and the sensitivity for GDH and GOX electrodes. Open square: GDH electrode; Solid diamonds: GOX electrode. 0.4 V (SCE); 1000 rpm; air atmosphere.
The half-life of the dissolved enzyme in 10 mh4 HEPES pH 7.3 buffer at room temperature was 5 days (Ye et al., 1993). The decay of the current of the GDH electrodes in 10 mM glucose at 25”C, pH 7.3 was, however, faster (Fig. 8, open squares), dropping to one half of its initial value in about 8 hours under continuous operation. The operational stability of the “wired” GDH electrode was found to be glucose concentration dependent, the output declining more rapidly at higher glucose concentrations. Fig. 8 shows the rates of decline for GDH electrodes in an electrochemical cell where the glucose concentration was held at 10 mM, and in a flow injection analyzer where a computer controlled injection system injected fixed volumes of 10 mh4 glucose once every 60 minutes. Under the conditions of the
0
10
20
30
40
time, hours
Figure 8. Time dependence of the output of GDH electrode at 0.4 V (SCE). Continuous operation at constant 10 mM glucose concentration (open squares) and in a flow injection analyzer where 30 second 10 mM glucose pulses were injected once per hour (solid diamonds).
Electron Conducting Adducts
403
experiment, it took less than 3 minutes for the sample to pass through the cell, i.e., the electrode was in 10 mh4 glucose for only 3 minutes each hour. Evidently, the rate of current loss depended on the amount of glucose electrooxidized(Figure 8).
V. ELECTRICAL CONNECTION OF HEMEPROTEIN PEROXlDASES Most peroxidases have catalytic sites containing covalently bound iron porphyrins. In peroxidases the iron heme is positioned close to the surface of the enzyme. The near surfaceposition of the catalytic site allows direct, non-mediated, electroreduction of the enzymes on graphite electrodesand thus the construction of direct H202 sensors (Kulys and Schmid, 1990, Jonsson-Pettersson, 1991). Many diagnostic tests ultimately rely on amperometric or colorimetricdetection of H202.Although feasible, enzymatic amperometric H202 detection is not commercially used. The most common amperometric H202assays involve use of a Pt anode held at an oxidizing potential, where not only H202, but also a variety of interferants are electrooxidized. Electron conducting POs-EA and PEGDE (Figure 1) redox-hydrogel based H202 sensors, involving electroreduction of lactoperoxidase (LOP), Arthromyces ramosus peroxidase (ARP), or horseradish peroxidase (HRP) have been made (Vreeke et al., 1993). In these, the H202fluxes were connected to currents by electrocatalytically reducing H20, according to the scheme shown in Figure 9. These enzymes were covalently bound to the 3-dimensional redox epoxy based hydrogel. Upon such immobilization the ensemble of enzyme molecules in the gel volume was electrically connected to the electrode. The amperometric measurements were performed in a standard 3-electrode cell, with the working electrode maintained at 0.OV (SCE) and rotated at 1000 RPM. H202 was catalytically electroreduced at the operating potential. The dependence ofthe catalytic H202electroreduction currents on the H202 concentration in pH 7.4
Figure 9. Scheme of cathodic assay of hydrogen peroxide using POs-EA-based electron conducting hydrogels to which a peroxidase is covalently bound. 0 ~ ~ ' ' ~ ' denotes gel-bound redox centers.
I . KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
404 loo0
r . 4
‘ 06 100
a
E
G
10
1
1 .i! ,001
I
....-..., . . .4
. . . . . . . . I
.01
.l
1
H202,
Figure 10. Arnperometric response of peroxide sensing cathodes built with different peroxidases covalently bound to electron conducting hydrogels based on POs-EA. Closed circles, HRP; open circles, N a l 0 4 oxidized HRP; squares, LOP; triangles, ARP.
phosphate buffer is seen in Figure 10 for four enzymes A m , LOP, HRP, and periodate-oxidized HRP. Although immobilization of lactoperoxidase in the redox hydrogel resulted in substantialreduction currents,the currents rapidly decayed when the H,O, concentration exceeded 10 pM, because of reversible substrate inhibition of the enzyme (Polis and Shmukler, 1955). Wiring of the peroxidase from Arthromyces ramosus in the electron-conductinghydrogel led to the highest current density > ImA cm-’. The current density increased linearly with the H,O, concentration from 0.1 yM to 500 pM.The current was remarkably stable, decaying only a few percent per hour. The horseradish peroxidase (HRP)containing electrodes did not exhibit either the high current density nor the exceptional linear range of the Arthromyces ramosus peroxidase based electrodes. Nevertheless, when NaIO, oxidized HRP was used, the sensors’performance improved. The aldehydes formed upon NaIO, oxidation of HRP sugar residues formed Schiff bases with the POs-EA amines, coupling the enzyme’s redox centers with those of the hydrogel and shortening the electron transfer distances. The currents in electrodesmodified with hydrogels with NaIO, oxidized HRP exceeded by a factor of 5 those observed in electrodes with untreated HRP, and the sensitivity reached 1 AM-‘ crn-,. The NaIO, oxidized HRP based electrode was operable at potentials between -O.lSV(SCE) and +0.3V(SCE). The wide potential window allowed choice of potentials where non-enzyme specific electrode reaction rates were slow, i.e. where interferant caused currents were low. The useful pH range of the sensors was 3.8 to 9.6, remaining within 10% of the maximum response throughout this range. Transient exposure of the sensors to solutions that were strongly acidic (PH < 3.8) reduced their response, but upon returning to a neutral pH the sensors recovered. Exposure to strong bases @H > 9.6) caused irreversibledecomposition of their gel.
Electron Conducting Adducts
405
VI. ASSAY OF NAD(P)H THROUGH QUANTITATIVE TRANSLATION T O H 2 0 2 Quinones and molecules with quinoid structures have been reduced in two electron transfer reactions by NAD(P)H (Kitani et al., 1981; Ito et al., 1989; Ottaway, 1966; Jones and Taylor, 1976). Amperometric NAD(P)H sensors based on such reduction have been described by Degrand and Miller (1980) and Fukui et al. (1 982), Gorton et al. (1991) and Cenas et al. (1985) and Kulys (1986). An example of a water soluble quinoid that is readily reduced by NAD(P)H is the N-methylphenazonium ion NMP+: NAD(P)H + NMP'
-+
NAD(P)+ + NMPH
The reduced phenazine, NMPH is reoxidized by molecular oxygen to NMP' in the H,O, generating reaction: NMPH + 0, 4 NMP'
+ H,O,
The sum of these reactions is the catalytic reduction of 0, to H,O, by NAD(P)H: NAD(P)H + O , N z * NAD(P)++ H,O, Because the reaction is fast and stoichiometric, NAD(P)H sensors based on amperometric assays of the depletion of 0, (Polster and Schmidt, 1989; Huck et al., 1976) and the colorimetric assay of the H,O, generated (Williams and Seitz, 1976) have been built. The translation of NAD(P)H into H,O, through the above reaction sequence allowed the sensing of NAD(P)H with the peroxidase electrodes with 1 AM-' cmP2 sensitivity and with a 0.1 to 200 pM linear range, similar to those of the H,O, sensors (Vreeke et al., 1993). Figure 11 shows the steady state alcohol response of
I
-
i 100
0 O O
0
-
0 0
0
e
E
0 0O0
u
O O O O
0
--,
- .-..-. . ...._ . . ....
. .-
% ethanol
Figure 77. Steady state alcohol response for alcohol dehydrogenase with the "wired" peroxidase cathode. 0 V (SCE);1000 rprn; pH 7.4 phosphate buffer.
406
1
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
homogeneous solution reaction
I
HRP modified electrode
I
Figure 12. Electron transfer sequence in the transduction of the concentration dependent alcohol flux to a cathodic current. Even though 7 electron transfer steps are involved in the transduction, these are so efficient that the current represents about 10% of the electron pairs transferred in the oxidation of ethanol to acetaldehyde.
a sensor with NAD+/NADH dependent alcohol dehydrogenase, pH 7.4 solution containing 7.1 x 1OdM N-methylphenazonium methosulfate, 13 units/mL alcohol dehydrogenase and 1.3 x 104M NAD+.Figure 12 summarizes the electron transfer sequence in the sensing of alcohol.
CONCLUSION Electrons difise in hydrogels built with redox polymer skeletons at sufficient rates to allow interception of electrons transferred between oxidoreductases and their substrates. Their transfer to electrodes results in the transduction of biochemical fluxes to electrical currents. Electrical currents are produced by substrates of flavoenzymes, heme enzymes and quinoprotein enzymes. Through catalytic reaction of NAD(P)H with 0, in an NAD(P)+ and H,O, producing reaction and electroreduction of H,O, in peroxidase-containing redox hydrogels NAD(P)H concentrations can also be translated to electrical currents.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work is supported by grants from Office of Naval Research, National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health Grant No. 1-R01-DK42015-01, and the Robert A. Welch Foundation.
REFERENCES Aoki, A. & Adam Heller, A. (1993). Measurement of electron diffusion coeflicients in redox polymers by steady state voltammetry with interdigitated array electrodes. In: Extended Abstracts of the Joint Meeting of the Electrochemical Society and the Electrochemical Society of Japan, Honolulu, Hawaii. Belanger, D. & Wrighton, M.S. (1987). Microelectrochemical transistors based on electrostaticbinding of electroactivemetal complexes in protonated poly(4-vinylpyridine): Devices that respond to two chemical stimuli. Anal. Chem. 59, 14261432.
Electron Conducting Adducts
407
Cenas, N.K., Kanapieniene, J.J., & Kulys, J.J. (1985). Electrocatalytic oxidation of NADH on carbon black electrodes. J. Electroanal. Electrochem. 189, 163-1 69. Chidsey, C.E., Feldman, B.J., Lundgren, C., & Murray, R.W. (1986). Micrometer-spaced platinum interdigitated array electrode: Fabrication, theory, and initial use. Anal. Chem. 58.60 1 4 0 7 . Claiborne, A. (1 986). Studies on the structure and mechanism of Streptococcusfaeciurn L-a-glycerophosphate oxidase. J. Biol. Chem. 261, 14398407. D’Costa, E.J., Higgins, I.J., & Turner, A.P.F. (1986). Quinoprotein glucose dehydrogenase and its application in an amperometric glucose sensor. Biosensors 2, 7 1-87. Dalton,E.F., Surridge, N.A., Jernigan, J.C., Wilbourn,K.O., Facci, J.S.,&Murray, R.W.(1990). Charge transport in electroactive polymers consisting of fixed molecular redox sites. Chem. Phys. 141, 14S157. Degrand, C. & Miller, L.L. (1980). An electrode modified with polymer bound dopamine which catalyzes NADH oxidation. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 102,572t332. Dokter, P., Frank, J., & Duine, J.A. (1986). Purification and characterization of quinoprotein glucose dehydrogenase from Acinatobacter calcoaceticus L.M.D.79.4 1. Biochem. J. 239, 16S167. Duine, J.A., Frank, J., & Jongejan, J.A. (1987). Enzymology of quinoproteins. Adv. Enzymol. 59, 169-2 12. Duine, J.A. (I99 1). Quinoproteins: enzymes containing the quinonoid cofactor pyrroloquinoline quinone, topaquinone or tryptophan-tryptophan quinone. Eur. J. Biochem. 200,27 1-284. Duine, J.A., Frank, J., & Van Zeeland, J.K. (1979). Glucose dehydrogenase from Acinatobuctor calcoaceticus. FEBS Lett. 1 0 8 , 4 4 W 6 . Feldman, B.J. & Royce W. Murray, (1986). Measurement of electron diffusion coefficients through prussian blue electroactive films electrodeposited on interdigitated array platinum electrodes. Anal. Chem. 58,2844-2847. Feldman, B.J. & Murray, R.W. (1987). Electron diffusion in wet and dry prussian blue films on interdigitated array electrodes. Inorg. Chem. 26, 1702-1 708. Foulds, N.C. & Lowe, C.R. (1988). Immobilization of glucose oxidase in ferrocene-modified pyrrole polymers. Anal. Chem. 60,247S2478. Fukui, M., Kitani, A,, Degrand, C., & Miller, L.L. (1982). Propogation of a redox reaction through a quinoid polymer film on an electrode. J. Am. Chem. SOC.104,2%33. Geiger, 0. & Goerisch, H. (1989). Reversible thermal inactivation of the quinoprotein glucose dehydrogenase from Acinatobacter calcoaceticus. Biochem. J. 261,415-421. Gorton, L., Csoregi, E., Dominguez, E., Emneus, J., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Marko-Varga, G.. & Persson, B. (1991). Selective detection in flow analysis based on the combination of immobilized enzymes and chemically modified electrodes. Chim. Acta 250,203-248. Goss, C.A. & Majda, M. (1991). Lateral diffusion in organized bilayer assemblies of electroactive amphiphiles influence of the oxidation state of the amphiphile investigated by steady-state methods involving an interdigitated miro-electrode array device. J. Electroanal. Chem. 300, 377-405. Gregg, B.A. & Heller, A. (1990). Cross-linked redox gels containing glucose oxidase for amperometric biosensor applications. Anal. Chem. 62,25%263. Gregg, B.A. & Heller, A. (1991a). Redox polymer films containing enzymes. 1. A redox-conducting epoxy cement: synthesis. characterization, and electrocatalytic oxidation ofhydroquinone. J. Phys. Chem. 95,5970-5975. Gregg, B.A. & Heller, A. (1991b). Redox polymer films containing enzymes. 2. Glucose oxidasecontaining enzyme electrodes. J. Phys. Chem. 95,576-580. Heller, A. (1992). Electrical connection of enzyme redox centers to electrodes. J. Phys. Chem. 96, 3579-3587. Huck, H., Schelter-Graf, A., Danzer, J., Kirch, P., & Schmidt, H.L. (1984). Bioelectrochemical detection systems for substrates of dehydrogenases. Analyst, 109, 147-1 50.
408
I. KATAKIS, M. VREEKE, L. YE, A. AOKI, and A. HELLER
Itoh, S., Kinugawa, M., Mita, N.. & Ohshiro, Y. (1989). Efficient NAD’ regeneration system with heteroaromatic o-quinones and molecular oxygen. J. Chem. SOC.Chem. Commun. 694-695. Jacobs, N.J. & VanDemark, P.J. (1960). The purification and properties ofthe a-glycerophosphate-oxidizing enzyme of StreptococcusJuecal. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 88,25&255. Jones, J.B. & Taylor, K.E. (1976). Nicotinamide coenzyme regeneration. Flavin mononucleotide (riboflavin phosphate) as an efficient, economical, and enzyme-compatible recycling agent. Can. J. Chem., 54,2969-2973. Jonsson-Pettersson, G. ( 199 I). Reagentless hydrogen peroxide and glucose sensors based on peroxidase immobilized on graphite electrodes. Electroanalysis 3,741-750. Katakis, I. & Heller, A. (1992). L-a-Glycerophosphate and L-lactate electrodes based on the electrochemical “wiring” of oxidases. Anal. Chem. 64,1008-lO13. Katakis, I., Ve, L., & Heller, A. (1994). Electrostatic control of electron transfer enabling binding of redox polyelectrolytes and glucose oxidase. J. Am. Chem. SOC.116,3617-3618. Kitani, A., So, Y.-H., & Miller, L.L. (1981). An electrochemical study of the kinetics ofNADH being oxidized by diimines derived from diaminobenzine and diaminopyrimidines. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 103,76367641. Kittlesen, G.P., White, H.S., & Wrighton, M.S. (1985). A microelectrochemical diode with submicron contact spacing based on the connection of two microelectordes using dissimilar redox polymers. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 107,7373-7380. Kulys, J.J. (1986). Enzyme electrodes based on organic metals. Biosensors 2.3-13. Kulys, J.J. & Schmid, R.D. (1990). Mediatorless peroxide electrode and preparation of bienzyme sensors. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 24,305-31 1 . Motonaka, J., Takabayashi, H., Ikeda, S., & Tanaka, N. (1990). Preparation and properties of a micro enzyme sensor for creatine. Anal. Lett. 23, 1981-1991. Nishihara, H., Dalton, F., &Murray, R.W. (1991). Interdigitated array electrode diffusion measurements in donor/acceptor solutions in polyether electrolyte solvents. Anal. Chem. 63,2955-2960. Ottaway, J.H. (1966). Some rate constants for the phenazine methosulfate-catalysed oxidation of reduced nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide. Biochem. J. 99,253-256. Polis, D. & Shmukler, H.W. (1955). Lactoperoxidase. Meth. Enzymol. 2, 813417. Polster, J. & Schmidt, H.L. (1989). Determination of dehydrogenase substrates by Clark type oxygen electrodes and photosensitized coenzyme oxidation. Talanta, 36,864-866. Shu, C.-F. & Wrighton. M.S. (1988). Synthesis and charge-transport properties of polymers derived from the oxidation of I-hydro-I ‘-(6-(pyrrol-l-yl)hexyl)-4,4’-bipyridinium bis(hexafluorophosphate) and demonstration of apH-sensitive microelectrochemical transistor derived from the redox properties of a conventional redox center. J. Phys. Chem. 92,5221-5229. Smith, D.K., Lane, G.A., & Wrighton, M.S. (1988). Charge-transport properties ofan electrode-confined redox polymer derived from a monomer consisting of a quinone flanked by two benzylviologen subunits. J. Phys. Chem. 92,2616-2628. Surridge, N.A., Zvanut, M.E., Keene, F.R., Sosnoff, C.S., Silver, M., & Murray, R.W. (1992). Effects of mixed-valent composition and bathing environment on solid-state electron self-exchanges in osmium bipyridine redox polymer films. J. Phys. Chem. 96,962-970. Tse, D.C.-S. & Kuwana, T. (1978). Electrocatalysis of dihydronicotinamide adenosine diphosphate with quinones and modified quinone electrodes. Anal. Chem. 50, 13 15-13 18. Van der Meer, R.A., Groen, B.W., Van Kleef, M.A.G., Frank, J., Jongejan, J.A., & Duine, J.A. (1990). Isolation, preparation, and assay of pyrroloquinoline quinone. Meth. Enzymol. 188,260-283. Vreeke, M., Maidan, R., & Heller, A. (1993). Hydrogen peroxide and P-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide sensing amperometric electrodes based on electrical connection of horseradish peroxidase redox centers to electrodes through a three-dimensional electron relaying polymer network. Anal. Chem. 64,3084-3090.
Electron Conducting Adducts
409
Williams, D.C. I11 & Seitz, R.W. (1976). Automated chemiluminescence method for determining the reduced form of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide coupled to the measurement of lactate dehydrogenase activity. Anal. Chem. 48, 147S148 1. Ye, L., Hammerle, M., Olsthoom, A.J.J., Schuhmann, W., Schmidt, H.-L., Duine, J.A., & Heller, A. (1993). High current density “wired” quinoprotein glucose dehydrogenase electrode. Anal. Chem. 65,23%241.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
SCREENING A N D DESIGN OF JMMOBlLlZED BIOCATALYSTS BY MEANS OF KINETIC CHARACTERIZATION ON ENZYME TH ERMISTOR/THE RMAL ASSAY PROB E
Peter Gemeiner, Vladimir Stefuca, and Bengt Danielsson
I. 11. 111. IV.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . INTRODUCTION. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MATHEMATICAL MODEL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume ISB,pages 411-419. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
41 1
412 412 4 13 4 15 418
41 2
P. GEMEINER, V. STEFUCA, and B. DANIELSSON
ABSTRACT Screening and design of immobilized biocatalysts (IMB) is a time-consuming process; ideally, the process should be universal, fast, convenient, precise, and sufficiently reproducible. These requirements are met by enzymic flow (micro)calorimetry (EFMC) also known as “enzyme thermistor” or “thermal assay probe.” Adaptation of EFMC to real measurements of the reaction rates requires coupling of the mathematical description of the reaction-diffusion phenomena in the EFMC column with heat balance and, subsequently, experimental verification of the mathematical model. This paper presents a brief review of the results obtained during the adaptation of EFMC for the characterization of the microkinetic properties of IMB and their further application for screening and design of IMB.
1. INTRODUCTION Complete design of the optimum immobilized biocatalyst (IMB) seems still to be a matter of the future. To be successful, it will require numerical determination of all significant parameters at each enzyme engineering phase, for example, at the design of the carriers, immobilized biocatalysts, and immobilized reactors. Therefore, there is an urgent need for procedures that rationalize the design of optimum IMB in the individual phases (Gemeiner, 1992; Gemeiner et al., 1993a). One procedure is a uniform characterization of the microkinetic properties of IMB. Primary demands for its application are universality of the detection principle, definite system configuration, and facile adaptability to different IMB, as well as a transparent software for the transformation of the experimental data into the real kinetic constants. The majority of the above demands are met by the EFMC in the so-called enzyme thermistor (Danielsson and Mosbach, 1987; 1988; Danielsson, 1990; 1992) originally designed for measurement of metabolite content in the flow-injection analysis mode. Adjustment of EFMC for the direct measurement of the kinetic properties of IMB required, in particular, coupling of the mathematical description of the reaction-diffusion phenomena in the IMB minicolumn with heat balance. A mathematical model has been put forward and gradually verified experimentally (Stehca et al., 1990; Gemeiner et al., 1993b; DoEolomanskf et al., 1994). Adaptation of EMFC to the screening and design of IMB via determination of the microkinetic properties of IMB thus demanded (a) transformation of the experimental thermochemical data into the lunetic data, (b) determination of the real kinetic constants of IMB, (c) screening, and (d) design of IMB by means of the kinetic parameters and constants. This paper presents the results obtained from an adaptation of the flow (micro)calorimetry.
Design of Immobilized Biocatalysts
41 3
II. MATHEMATICAL MODEL Mathematical modeling of microkinetic phenomena in an EFMC is based on chemical engineering principles for the modeling of the reaction-diffusion phenomena in heterogeneous catalytic reactions. Thus, in the case of a reaction catalyzed within the pores of the particles containing IMB, the substrate steadystate mass balance can be written in the following form:
where cs, r, and De are substrate concentration,particle coordinate and the effective difision coefficient of the substrate, respectively. Parameter n depends on the particle geometry and equals 0, 1, or 2 for planar, cylinder and spheric geometry, respectively. The right side of the equation expresses the kinetic form. Solution of Equation 1 enables one to calculate a so-called effectiveness factor, 7, defined as: q=-'obs 'kin
[z)
where the observed reaction rate, vobs,is defined as vobs= A . D, VL
r=R
and represents the total rate ofthe reaction catalyzed by the particles of surface area A in a reactor with liquid volume V,. The kinetic reaction rate is the rate in the reactor with no diffusional limitation present. The particle substrate concentration in this case is therefore the same as the bulk substrate concentration,C,b, and hence Vkin =
V
VL
. V(C,)
(4)
where V, is the total IMB particle volume. Once the effectiveness factor value is known, the observed reaction rate can be calculated from 'obs
= q . 'kin
(5)
When the process in the EFMC is modeled, the introduced mass balance equations should be coupled with mass and heat balances in the EFMC column. The mass balance equations in the EFMC column have been derived, verified experimentally (Stefuca et al., 1990), and coupled with the particle mass balance equations for the case of first order kinetics (Gemeiner et al., 199313). The mathematical modeling was based on the following assumptions:
P. GEMEINER, V. STEFUCA, and B. DANIELSSON
41 4
1. Changes in the substrate concentration and temperature change along the reactor are so small that the reaction rate change is insignificant and the molar reaction enthalpy is constant, 2. plug flow occurs in the reactor, 3. the superficial flow rate is high enough to prevent reaction rate limitation by external mass transfer, and 4. heat losses from the reactor are negligible and the reactor is considered to be adiabatic. Under these assumptions, the steady state substrate balance in the reactor can be presented as follows:
where z, w, and E are the axial coordinate, superficial velocity, and void fraction, respectively; whereas, p, cp, T, and AHf represent fluid density, heat capacity, temperature, and molar reaction enthalpy, respectively. Since the reaction rate in the reactor is considered to be constant,differential equation (6) can be transformed into the following difference equation: dT
AT
dz-Az
(1 - E l 1 1 (-AHf) -rl
w P cp
(8) . rkin
After introduction of the parameter, v,, defined as V, (- AHf) (1 - E) AZ , V
=
w P cp Equation 8 can be simplified to AT=-
rlnr'
rkin
(10)
vln
The meaning of the last equation can be illustrated by an example in which the kinetic term is substituted for the enzyme kinetic equation. Thus, in the case of substrate inhibition kinetics, Equation 10 will appear as follows: AT=q
Vm
S
I<,+ c, + (c%/Ki)
Equation 10 or 1 1 represents a mathematical basis for the formulation of EFMC applications for the investigation of microkinetic properties of an IMB. This
Design of Immobilized Biocatalysts
41 5
requires calibration of the EFMC column, that is, establishment of the relation between the reaction rate, robs,and the thermometric signal, AT. One possible method for processing experimental data is described below.
111. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION One example of the application of the foregoing model is a study of the kinetics of the enzyme immobilized on the surface of the spherical particles of bead cellulose (Stefuca et al., 1990) (Table 1) where no internal diffusion was present (q = 1). Calibration of the EFMC enabled rapid screening of the preparations of the immobilized invertase using its specific activity on a carrier (DoEolomanskg et al., 1993). Incorporation of the internal diffusion term into the model for cases with first order kinetics has been verified using a cell biocatalyst possessing a substantial D-amino acid oxidase activity entrapped in calcium pectate gel (CPG) particles (Gemeiner et al., 1993b) (Table 1). Improved mathematical solution (Satterfield, 1976) using Equation 11 led to a more detailed description of the kinetic data for gel-entrapped cells. This approach was used for the evaluation of kinetic data for a cell biocatalyst using penicillin G acylase activity immobilized in CPG beads (Stehca et al., 1994) (Figure 1). Kinetic data shown in Figure 1 were described by means of Equation 11, whereas the effectiveness factor was calculated by solving the particle mass balance equation 1. Kinetic parameter values were estimated by means of mathematical optimization. The experimental data represented by the pairs (cSbi,ATi)were used and parameter values optimized using a Gauss-Newton nonlinear regression procedure (Ramachandran, 1975; KubiEek, 1983). Once kinetic data are estimated, the mathematical design of the biocatalyst particle can be provided. Plotting the effectiveness factor values as the fhction of
Table 7. Screening of Immobilized Biocatalysts by Means of Microkinetic Characterization Using the Enzyme Flow (Microkalorimeter Biocatulyst
Form
Mode of Immobilization
Origin ~~
Invertase enzyme D-Amino enzyme, acid oxidase cells
~~
Reference
~
Ddolomanskj et al., 1993 S. cerevisiae biospecific 2: variabilisa entrapment + cross-linking Gemeiner et al., 1993b
I: variabilis
cross-linking
Gemeiner et al., 1993b Gemeiner et al., 1993b entrapment + cross-linking Gemeiner et al., 1993b entrapment + cross-linking Welwardova et al., 1993
T variabilis entrapment Penicillin G acylase
2: variubilis enzyme cells E. coli
E. coli E. coli Notes: ‘Trigoflopsisvariabilis
entrapment + cross-linking Welwardova et al., 1993 entrapment Stefuca et al., 1994
P. GEMEINER, V. STEFUCA, and B. DANIELSSON
41 6 I..0 1
8
h
W
6
E
W
4
2
O ! 0
1
I
I
I
I
20
40
60
80
100
Substrate concentration (mM) Figure 7. Measurement of the kinetics of penicillin G hydrolysis catalyzed by the immobilized biocatalyst cells performed in the EFMC column. Cell loading concen39.2; (A) 29.6; (0) 23.7; (0) tration (mg of dry weight per ml of gelling suspension):(0) 11.9.
the parameters that can be modified, that is, particle dimension (R) and biocatalyst concentration the value of which is integrated in the parameter V,, is a powerful tool. This procedure is demonstrated in Figures 2a and 2b. Thus, the optimum particle dimension and the magnitude of the immobilized activity can be designed for a chosen substrate concentration. From Figure 2b one can conclude that for a low substrate concentration, the smaller a particle, the higher its efficiency (optimum Thiele modulus = 0). In the case of a substrate inhibition reaction, however, overstepping of a definite bulk substrate concentration causes inhibition of the reaction by the substrate. Consequently, the mass transfer resistance leads to a decrease in the effective substrate concentration in the IMB particle. Thus, the catalyst effectiveness is increased when a suitable value for the Thiele modulus is generated. This can be obtained by controlling the particle dimension (Figure 2b). This type of study requires reliable experimental data if the results are to correspond to a real situation. However, it is possible to characterize the kinetic properties of the non-immobilized catalyst that enable it to avoid problems associated with the mass transfer interferences. From our experience, however, when results obtained in this manner have been applied to describing the kinetic data of IMB, some discrepancies owing to losses during the immobilization by deactiva-
Design of Immobilized Biocatalysts
41 7
a)
0.0 0
I
I
20
40
1
$0
80
Thiele modulus
Substrate concentration (mM) Figure 2. Reaction - mass transfer phenomena analysis of the spherical biocatalyst particle for substrate inhibited reaction - kinetic model represented by Equation 11. Parameter values were estimated from the experimental data shown in Figure 1 : Km = 1.3 mM, Ki = 570 mM. a. Effectiveness factor as a function of Thiele modulus = R (Vm / Km De)0.5at the substrate concentration (mM) 1, 10, 20, 30,40, 50, 60, 70, 80 ( i i upward direction); b. Optimum Thiele modulus corresponding to the maximum cffectivenessfactor values at varying bulk substrate concentration.
41 8
P. GEMEINER, V. STEFUCA, and B. DANIELSSON
tion, inclusion of the biocatalyst into the inaccessible parts of the gel structure, changes of the cell wall permeability, or biocatalyst modification by the covalent linkage were observed. For this reason a more preferable method is to study the biocatalyst properties by means of the kinetic measurements after the immobilization. The EFMC in connection with the mathematical model described above provides a powerful technique for obtaining essential experimental data extremely rapidly and easily.
IV. CONCLUSION The EFMC provides a powerful tool for rapid and convenient investigation of the kinetic properties of IMB. Such investigations include measurement of the reaction rate that depends on the substrate concentration with the aim to determine kinetic parameters. As soon as the reaction rate is established, many very precise kinetic measurements can be carried out in one day. This procedure enables optimum biocatalyst configuration design.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT We are indebted t o Professor Klaus Mosbach for inspiring discussions. O n e of us (P.G.) is indebted to The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel, for the Max Varon Professorship that gave him the excellent opportunity to consult on problems and gain further insight into the literature. This work w a s supported, in part, by the Slovak Grant Agency for Science (Grant No. 2/1238/95).
REFERENCES Danielsson, B. & Mosbach, K. (1987). In: Biosensors: Fundamentals and Applications (Turner, A.P.F., Karube, I. & Wilson, G.S., Eds.), pp. 575595. Oxford University, Oxford. Danielsson, B. & Mosbach, K. (1988). In: Methods in Enzymology: Vol. 137, Pt. D: Immobilized Enzymes and Cells (Mosbach, K., Ed.), pp. 181-197, San Diego. Academic Press. Danielsson, B. (1990). Calorimetric biosensors. J. Biotechnol. 15, 187-200. Danielsson, B., Hedberg, U., Rank, M., & Xie, B. (1992). Recent investigations on calorimetric biosensors. Sensors & Actuators B 6, 13S142. DoEolomanskg, P., Gemeiner, P., MisloviEovB, D., Stefuca, V., & Danielsson, B. (1994). Screening of Concanavalin A - bead cellulose conjugates using an enzyme thermistor with immobilized invertase as the reporter catalyst. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 43,286-292. Gemeiner, P. (1992). In: Enzyme Engineering. Immobilized Biosystems (Gemeiner, P., Ed.), Chapter 4.2, Ellis Horwood Series in Biochemistry and Biotechnology (Wiseman, A., Ed.), Ellis Horwood, Chichester & Alfa Publishers, Bratislava. Gemeiner, P., Stefuca, V., & Bale;, V. (1 993a). Biochemical engineering of biocatalysts immobilized on cellulosic materials. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 15, 55 1-566. Gemeiner, P., Stefuca, V., Welwardova, A,, Michalkova, E., Welward, L., Kurillova, L., & Danielsson, B. (1993b). Direct determination of the cephalosporin transforming activity of immobilized cells with use of an enzyme thermistor. I. Verification of the mathematical model. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 15, 30-35.
Design of Immobilized Biocatalysts
41 9
KubiEek, M. (1983). Numerickt Algoritmy ReSeni Chemicko-Inienirskjch Uloh (Numeric Algorithms for Solutions of Problems in Chemical Engineering) (in Czech), Stitni nakladatelstvi technicke literatury (SNTL-Alfa), Prague. Ramachandran, P.A. (1975). Solution of immobilized enzyme problems by collocation methods. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 17.21 1-226. Sattertield, Ch.N. (1976). MassoperedaEa v geterogennom katalize (Mass Transfer in Heterogeneous Catalysis) (in Russian), p. 133, Izdatelstvo Chimija, Moskva. Stehca, V.. Gemeiner, P., Kurillova, i.,Danielsson, B., & Bales, V. (1990). Application ofthe enzyme thermistor to the direct estimation of intrinsic kinetics using the saccharose-immobilized invertase system. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 12,83&835. Stefuca, V., Welwardova, A., Gemeiner, P., & Jakubova, A. (1994). Application of enzyme flow microcalorimeter to the study of microkinetic properties of immobilized biocatalyst. Biotechnol. Tech. 8,497-502. Welwardova, A,, Gemeiner, P., Michalkova, E., Welward, L.. & Jakubova. A. (1993). Gel-entrapped penicillin G acylase optimized by an enzyme thermistor. Biotechnol. Tech. 7, 80- 14.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
AMPEROMETRIC B IOSE NSORS BASED ON CARBON PASTE ELECTRODES C HEMICA L LY MODIF IE D WITH REDOX-ENZYMES
L. Gorton, G. Marko-Varga, B. Persson, Z. Huan, H. Lindbn, E. Burestedt, S. Ghobadi, M. Smolander, S. Sahni, and T. Skotheim
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. EXPERIMENTAL.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Carbon Paste Electrodes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. L-Lactate Sensor Based on L-Lactate Dehydrogenase . . . . . . . . . C. Aldose Sensor Based on Aldose Dehydrogenase . . . . . . . . . . . D. Alcohol Sensor Based on Alcohol Oxidase Coimmobilized with Horseradish Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. D - h i n 0 Acid Sensor Based on Coimmobilized D - h i n o Acid Oxidase and Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 421-450. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 1-7623-0114-7
42 1
. .
422 422 423 423 . 424 . 424 425 425
L. GORTON ET AL.
422
F. L-Glutamate Sensor Based on Coimmobilized L-Glutamate .421 Oxidase and Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ,427 A. L-Lactate Sensor Based on L-Lactate Dehydrogenase . . . . . . . . . . .427 B. Aldose Sensor Based on Aldose Dehydrogenase . . . . . . . . . . . . . .432 C. Sensors Based on Coimmobilized Hydrogen Peroxide Producing .434 Oxidases and Peroxidases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Alcohol Sensor Based on Coimmobilized Alcohol .438 Oxidase and Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. D-Amino Acid Sensors Based on Coimmobilized D - h i n O Acid ,440 Oxidase and Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. L-Glutamate Sensor Based on Coimmobilized L-Glutamate .445 Oxidase and Peroxidase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ABSTRACT A number of redox enzymes have been immobilized in carbon paste electrodes operating around 0 mV versus saturated calomel electrode (SCE). Examples will be given of an L-lactate sensor based on L-lactate dehydrogenase, an aldose sensor based on aldose dehydrogenase, alcohol sensors based on coimmobilized alcohol oxidase and peroxidase, D-amino acid sensors based on coimmobilized D-amino acid oxidase and peroxidase, and L-glutamate sensors based on coimmobilized L-glutamate oxidase and peroxidase. The positive effects on the sensor performances upon the addition of various amine-containing polymers will be demonstrated.
1. INTRODUCTION Enzymes have been used in conjunction with various electrodesfor the construction of enzyme electrodes for more than two decades since the first enzyme electrode was reported by Updike and Hicks (1967). The use of amperometnc enzyme electrodes is rationalized by the proposed use of the inherent selectivity shown by the enzyme to promote a selective detection of the enzyme substrate. However, in most instances the necessary applied potential of the enzyme electrode is either too low o r too high to allow the electrochemical reaction to occur without interfering reactions or excessive background currents. The optimal potential range for an amperometric biosensor to promote sensitive and selective detection should be between -200 and 0 mV versus SCE where the background current switches signs and thus takes its lowest value. Electrochemical reduction of molecular oxygen and oxidation of easily oxidizable species (e.g., ascorbate,urate, paracetamol, catecholamines, etc.) are negligible and do not contribute to the response signal. Oxidoreductases or redox-enzymes are of particular interest for the construction of amperometric enzyme electrodes because an electron transfer reaction takes place in the enzymatic conversion of the substrate. Many investigationshave been
423
Amperometric Biosensors
performed to try to obtain direct electron transfer between the redox cofactor of the oxidoreductase and an electrode at a low overpotential (Frew and Hill, 1987; Armstrong et al., 1988). In most instances, however, a direct electron transfer is hindered because steric or kinetic barriers prevail. To circumvent these effects, small molecules acting as charge transfer mediators can be used to shuttle the charge to/fiom the active site ofthe redox-enzyme fiom/to the electrode. The great interest shown in the construction and studies of chemically modified electrodes (CMEs) has provided an impetus to recent developments in the immobilization of active mediators and enzymes on electrodes (Murray et al., 1987; Baldwin and Thomsen, 1990;Labuda, 1992;Wing and Hart, 1992).The use of mediators and mediator-modified electrodes for amperometricbiosensors was reviewed by Bartlett et al. (199 1). Immobilization of the enzyme in close conjunction either directly on the electrode surface or in a composite electrode are recent ways to promote fast overall reaction kinetics in contrast to immobilizing the enzyme in a separate membrane, which is after fabrication put in place on the electrode surface. In most cases, however, these electrodes suffer from not having long-term stability. Some attempts have been made to stabilize the immobilized enzyme in amperometric biosensor configurations(Bahulekar et al., 1991;Gorton et al., 1992a;Kacaniklic et al., 1994). However, only recently has systematic research been focused on how to stabilize the immobilized enzyme (Gibson et al., 1992; Gibson and Woodward, 1992). Similarly, little attention has been paid to how to fbrther speed up the overall reaction kinetics of the enzyme probe. This paper gives details on some recent results obtained for a number of enzymes of different classes of redox-enzymes immobilized either on or in graphite paste electrodes, all operating within the optimal potential range. Some results are also presented on the effect of adding polymeric stabilizers to the paste, thereby also enhancing the reaction kinetics of the probes.
II. EXPERIMENTAL A. Carbon Paste Electrodes
Plain graphite-paraffin oil paste was prepared by thorough mixing of 40 pl of paraffin oil (Fluka, cat. no. 76235) with 100 mg of graphite powder (Fluka, cat. no. 50870). Plastic syringes (1 .Oml syringe, Brunswick 81/79503,with a tip of 7.0 mm OD and 1.8 mm ID) were filled with the graphite-paraffin oil paste leaving about 3 to 4 mm empty in the top to be filled with enzyme modified carbon paste for producing the final electrode. Electric contact was provided by inserting a gold or a silver thread into the paste. After aliquots of enzyme modified pastes (see below) were filled into the ends of the syringes, the end was gently rubbed on glass to produce a flat shining electrode surface with an area of about 0.024 cm2.The final electrodes were mounted in a flow-through amperometric cell of the wall-jet type (Appelqvist et al., 1985) under three electrode potentiostatic control using a
potentiostat (Zata Electronics, Lund, Sweden). When not in use the enzyme electrodeswere stored in a dry state at 4 "C. Aplatinum wire and a saturatedcalomel electrode (SCE) served as the counter and reference electrodes, respectively. The cell was connected to a single line flow injection (FI) system using either an Automated Sample Injection Analyser (Ismatec, SA, Glattburg-Ziirich, Switzerland) or an in-lab made system described earlier (Appelqvist et al., 1985).Connections between the various parts of the FI systems were made with Teflon tubings, ID 0.5 mm, and Altex screw couplings. In one instance a liquid chromatographic system was used. In this case a liquid chromatographic pump (model 2 150, LKB, Bromma, Sweden) delivered a 0.05 M phosphate buffer at pH 8.0 with a flow rate of 0.5 ml m i d . An injector (Reodyne, model 7000, injection volume 15.4 pl) and a polymer separation column (PLRP-S, 5 pm, 100 A, 100 x 0.4 mm ID, Church Stretton, Shropshire, UK) were used. All solutions were degassed before use to prevent microbubble formation in the flow system. B. L-Lactate Sensor Based on L-Lactate Dehydrogenase
L-lactate dehydrogenase, EC 1.1.1.27, type XI, from rabbit muscle (LDH, Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. L-1254) was obtained as a lyophilized powder with an activity of 7 10 U mg-' solid and 729 U mg-' protein. The chemically modified carbon paste was manufactured by first thoroughly mixing 4% (wlw) of the redox polymer (microcrystalline powder) containing covalently bound Toluidine Blue 0 as the mediating active moiety with graphite (see Results and Discussion). One hundred mg of this powder was added to 1.O ml of 0.1 M sodium phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 containing 2.3 mg of LDH, 50 mg of NAD' (Sigma Chem. Co., Grade 111, cat. no. N-15 1l), and 100 pl of a 2.6 %aqueous polyethylenimine (PEI) solution (Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. P-3 143, 50% aqueous solution). After stirring for 2 h at 4 "C, the mixture was dried in a desiccator under reduced pressure. Finally, a paste was obtained by mixing the dry chemically modified graphite with 40 pl of paraffin oil. Some properties of the Toluidine Blue 0 (TBO) containing polymer for the electrocatalytic oxidation of NADH (Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. N-8129) were investigated when used as a modifier on solid graphite electrodes (RingsdorffWerke, GmbH, type RW 00 1). Cyclic voltammetry (BAS Electrochemical Analyzer, 100 B) and a rotating ring disk device (Tacussel,model EDI) using a platinum gauze and an SCE as the counter and reference electrodes, respectively. The solid graphite electrodes were pretreated as reported previously (Persson, 1990) and the polymer coating was obtained by drop coating the electrode surface with a dimethylsulfoxide polymer solution and allowing the solvent to evaporate at reduced pressure for 4 h. C. Aldose Sensor Based on Aldose Dehydrogenase
D-aldose dehydrogenase (ALDH, from Gluconobucter oxydans. ATCC 62 1) (no EC number given yet) was purified as described previously (Smolander et al.,
Arnperometric Biosensors
42 5
1993a). The enzyme was stored in 10 mM sodium acetate at pH 5.0 containing at least 0.1% Triton X- 100 (iso-octylphenoxypolyethoxyethanol,BDH, cat. no. 30632). Plain carbon paste electrodes were prepared as above by mixing 100 mg of heat treated graphite powder with 40 p1 of parafin oil. Some of the electrodes were also modified with the addition of an electron transfer mediator by adding 2.0 mg of ferrocene monocarboxylic acid (Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. F-2641) to 100 mg of graphite prior to the addition ofthe pasting liquid. Aportion of 10 pl ofALDH (glucose oxidizing activity; 7 U ml-') was added to the surface of a carbon paste electrode and allowed to dry in air. Some electrodes were prepared by mixing 400 p1 of ALDH (6 U ml-') with 100 mg of heat treated graphite powder and 2 mg of ferrocene monocarboxylic acid and letting the enzyme immobilize for 2 h at 4 "C. After that, the mixture was allowed to dry in a desiccator under reduced pressure before the addition of 40 p1 of parafin oil as the pasting liquid. D. Alcohol Sensor Based on Alcohol Oxidase Coimmobilized with HRP
Three.differentalcohol oxidases were investigated. The amount of enzyme used was adjusted so that each graphite paste contained 137 U of alcohol oxidase (AOD, EC 1.1.3.13).Horseradish peroxidase (1.37 mg) (HFW, Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. P-8375,288 U mg-I solid) was dissolved in 200 pl of a 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. Alcohol oxidase (1 13.0 p1) (from Cundidu boidinii, obtained as a solution in phosphate buffered 60% sucrose from Serva, cat. no. 12085,30.3 U mg-l protein) and 100 mg of heat treated graphite powder were added to the solution. While stirring, 200 pl of a 0.32% aqueous solution of PEI in 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 were added. The mixture was stirred for 16 h at 4 "C and thereafter dried in a desiccator under reduced pressure for 4.5 h. Finally, 40 pl of phenylmethylsilicon oil (Silicone DC 710, Alltech Associates, Arlington Heights, IL, USA) (Gorton et al., 1992a)were thoroughly mixed with the enzyme-modified graphite. To a second batch, 125 pl of AOD from Pichia pastoris (obtained as a solution in phosphate buffered 60% sucrose from Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. A-2404, 24 U mg-') were used with the same immobilization procedure. To a third batch, 115 mg of AOD from Candida boidinii (obtained as a lyophilized powder from Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. A-0763, 10 U mg-') were first dissolved in 100 p1 of the phosphate buffer before addition to the HRP, which was dissolved in 150 p1 of the same buffer. The rest of the immobilization procedure was identical to the first one described above. E. D-Amino Acid Sensor Based on Coimmobilized D-Amino Acid Oxidase and Peroxidase
D-aminO acid oxidase (1.0 mg) (D-AAOD, EC 1.4.3.3, from porcine kidney, Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. A-1789) was dissolved in 1.0 ml of 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. The activity of the D-AAOD was determined according to the following: To a cuvette were added 1.4 ml of a solution containing 4-minoantipyrin (4-AP) and phenol (2.5 mM 4-AP, Merck cat. no. 27128 and 0.17 mM
426
L. GORTON ET AL.
phenol, Merck cat. no. 206) dissolved in 0.1 M Tris buffer (Tris[hydroxymethyl]aminomethane, Merck cat. no. 8382) at pH 8.0,25 pl of a HRP solution [ 1 mg (270 U) were dissolved in 250 p1 of 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.01, and 1.5 ml of a solution containing 2.5 mM D-phenylalanine (D-Phe, Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. P-1751, in 0.1 M Tris buffer at pH 8.0). This reaction mixture was incubated in a spectrophotometerat 25 OC for 3 min to reach temperature equilibrium. Thereafter, 35 pl of the D-AAOD solution were added to the cuvette and the increase in the absorbance at 5 10 nm (E = 6 580 1 mol-' cm-') was followed for 5 min. The activity was calculated from the linear part of the slope of the increase in absorbance. The results obtained with four different sets of immobilizations were as follows: Set 1: The following two different D-AAOD carbon paste electrodes were made. To one batch, 1 mg (288 U) of HRP dissolved in 2 16 pl of 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0, 1.O ml(2.7 U mg-') of a D-AAOD solution, and 553 p1 of a 0.32% PEI solution were added to coimmobilize on 100 mg of heat treated graphite powder for 2 h by stirring the reaction mixture at 4 "C. Thereafter the reaction mixture was allowed to dry in a desiccator under reduced pressure before addition of 40 p1 of paraffin oil as above. To a second batch, an equivalent enzyme paste was prepared but exchanging HRP for fungal peroxidase (ARP, from Arthromyces ramosus, EC 1.11.1.7, kindly provided as a gift from Suntory Ltd., Japan, lot no. 9005 11, obtained as a lyophilized powder with an activity of 250 U mg-') using 1 mg of the enzyme. Set 2: The following 8 D-AAOD containing pastes were prepared using paraffin oil as the pasting liquid. To 6 batches 1.0 mg (250 U) of ARF' and 1.0 mg (2.7 U mg-') of D-AAOD were added per 100 mg of heat treated graphite powder. To the first batch, 230 p1 of 1.3% PEI were also added; to the second batch, 227 p1 of 1.3% quaternized PEI (kindly obtained from Dr. M. G. Venegas, the Proctor and Gamble Distribution Company, 5299 Spring Grove Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 4521 7-1087, USA); to the third batch, 195 pl of 1.5% ethoxylated PEI (kindly obtained from Dr. M. G. Venegas); to the fourth batch, 220 p1 of Gafquat 734 (a quaternized copolymer of vinylpyrrolidone and dimethylaminoethyl-methacrylatewith an average molecular weight of lo5 Da, CAS reg. no. 53 633-54-8, obtained as a 50% active solution in water, kindly provided as a gift from Dr. T. D. Gibson, University of Leeds, UK); to the fifth batch, 219 p1 of 1.4% chitosan glutamate (Pronova LV chitosan glutamate, Protan Biopolymer NS,Drammen, Norway); to the sixth batch, 230 pl of a 1.3% mixture of 5050 chitosan glutamate and Gafquat 734. To the remaining 2 batches 1.0 mg of ARP and 2.1 mg (1.3 U mg-I) of D-AAOD were added and additionally to the first 97 p1 of 5% gentamicin (Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. G-1397) and to the second 584 p1 of 1% neomycin (Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. N-1142). Set 3: The following paste was prepared. 1.0 mg of ARP (250 U), 1.0 mg of D-AAOD (2.2 U), and 300 pl of 1% neomycin added to 100 mg of graphite. Set 4: The following pastes were made: to one batch, 1.0 mg of ARP (250 U), 1.O mg of D-AAOD (2.2 U) and 300 p1 of 1% neomycin were taken to 100 mg of graphite;
Amperometric Biosensors
42 7
and to a second batch, 1 mg of HRP (288 U), 1 mg of D-AAOD (2.2 U) and 300 p1 of 1% neomycin added to 100 mg of graphite.
F. L-Glutarnate Sensor Based on Coimrnobilized L-Glutamate Oxidase and Peroxidase 1.O mg of L-glutamate oxidase (GluOD, from Streptomyces sp., EC 1.4.3.11, kindly provided as a gift from Yamasa Shoyu Co., Ltd., Japan, cat. no. 7804, obtained as a lyophilized powder with an activity of 8 U mg-') and 1.O mg of HRP (EC 1.11.1.7, Sigma Chem. Co., cat. no. P 8375, obtained as a powder with an activity of 270 U mg-') were dissolved in 200 plO.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. A0.32% solution ofPEI (200 p1) were added to the enzyme solutionwhile allowing the mixture to immobilize on 100 mg of heat treated (700 "C, 15 s) graphite for 2 h at 4 "C. The enzyme-graphite was then allowed to dry under vacuum before addition of the pasting liquid, 40 p1 of paraffin oil. In a second immobilization experiment, L-glutamate oxidase was coimmobilized with ARP (1 mg, 250 U) in an equivalent procedure as described above with HRP.
111. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Dehydrogenases constitute one major class of redox-enzymes, characterized by catalyzed reactions that are unaffected by molecular oxygen. Dehydrogenases can be further differentiated into two main groups, those with the cofactor strongly bound within the enzyme structureand those depending on a solublecofactor acting as a soluble cosubstrate. Enzymes of the former group contain either a flavin based cofactor alone or in combination with other redox-active compounds such as heme groups, e.g., L-lactate dehydrogenase (cytochrome b2)and diaphorase, or a pyrroloquinolinequinone (PQQ) group. These enzymes were recently discovered and are usually denoted PQQ-dehydrogenases (Duine et al., 1987; Davidson, 1992). Today, several enzymes of this group have been characterizedand are known to be active on glucose, methanol, fructose, L-lactate, and aldose. Some PPQ-dehydrogenases have also been investigated in biosensor configurations (Bartlett. 1991; Gorton et al., 1993; Smolander et al., 1992). Enzymes of the latter group are all dependent on a soluble nicotinamide dinucleotide cofactor for activity with NAD' or NADP+acting as a soluble cosubstrate. They include some 400 enzymes which is the largest group of redox-enzymes known today. A. L-Lactate Sensor Based on L-Lactate Dehydrogenase
The construction of a reagentless amperometric biosensor based on a NAD+dependent dehydrogenase faces three major obstacles. First, as the cofactor is soluble it needs to be immobilized in close proximity to the enzyme so that its continuous addition is ruled out. Second, the electrochemistry of both the oxidized
(NAD') and reduced (NADH) form of the cofactor suffers from high overvoltages and side reactions leading to electrode fouling (Chenault and Whitesides, 1987; Gorton et al., 199la; 1991b; 1992b).Third, the formal potential (E"') of the cofactor redox couple (NAD'NADH) is relatively low, -560 mV vs SCE at pH 7.0, indicating the low oxidizing power of NAD'. This results in that the equilibrium of many dehydrogenase-catalyzed reactions favors the substrate rather than the product formation. The oxidation of L-lactate with LDH is such an example: L-lactate + NAD'
LDH
(>) pyruvate + NADH
(1)
The equilibrium constant for Reaction 1 is 2.76 x lo4 M at pH 7.0 (Barman, 1969). By coimmobilizing both the enzyme and the cofactor in close proximity to the electrode surface, the NADH initially formed in Reaction 1 will be electrochemically oxidized and drive the reaction to the product side. This was demonstrated by Blaedel and Engstrom (1980). We have focused on solving this problem by coimmobilizing the dehydrogenase and the cofactor in carbon paste electrodes and by use of an immobilized redox-mediator added to the paste electrode to facilitate the electrochemical oxidation of NADH to decrease the overvoltage and prevent electrode fouling. The redox mediator in its oxidized form, Med,,, will react with the NADH initially formed in the enzymatic process as follows: NADH + Med,,
+NAD' +
MedEd
(2)
Next, the reduced form of the mediator, Med,,, will be rapidly electrochemically reoxidized if the Eapp,is higher than the E"' of the mediator: Eapp,>Eo'
Med,
+
Med,, + H' + 2e-
(3)
Bycoimmobilizingtheenzyme, thecofactor, and themediator in thesamepaste electrode, the reaction sites for the enzymatic, redox-mediated, and the electrochemical reactions are very closely situated, and apossible unfavorable equilibrium of the enzymatic reaction will be counteracted by the immediate reoxidation of the reduced cofactor initially produced. Thus, a net driving force will be established shifting the enzymatic reaction to the product side. Electrode fouling is circumvented by the use of mediators. The mediators studied by the authors for electrocatalytic NADH oxidation are based on phenoxazine or phenothiazine skeletons incorporating a charged paraphenylenediamine structure essential for their catalytic and reversible electrochemical properties (Gorton, 1987; Gorton et al., 1991a; 1991b; Gorton et al., 1992b). Previous work in this field has included studies on the mechanism of reaction (Reaction 2), on how to increase the reaction rate between the mediator and NADH, and on how to accomplish a stable immobilization of the mediator on or in electrode configurations with retained catalytic properties (Gorton, 1987;
Amperometric Biosensors
429
Bremle et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991a; 1991b; 1992b). It was concluded that NADH and Med,, first form a charge transfer complex (CT), which rapidly decomposes into NADf and Me4,,. With these mediators Reaction 2 should therefore be written as: NADH + Med,,
G+
CT -+NAD+ + Med,,
(4)
The E"' values of the mediators fall in the range of -200 and 0 mV vs SCE at pH 7.0. The second order rate constant between NADH and the immobilized mediator is in the order of lo4 to lo5 M-'s-', thus allowing the electrocatalytic oxidation of NADH to proceed in a near mass transfer limited step and below 0 mV versus SCE (Gorton, 1987; Gorton et al., 1991b; 1992b). Most of our studies have been focused on irreversibly adsorbed mediators (Gorton et al., 199lb; 1992b). The phenoxazine and phenothiazine mediators strongly adsorb on carbon electrodes. Synthetic work was done to increase the number of aromatic rings of the mediator to promote adsorption on solid graphite electrodes to reach a state where it can be considered fully irreversible (Gorton et al., 1991b; 1992b). In carbon paste electrodes, however, one portion ofthe mediator seems to be solubilized in the pasting liquid and will slowly leak into the contacting solution, thus decreasing the catalytic activity for NADH oxidation with time (Bremle et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991a). We were, however, able to show that phenoxazine and phenothiazine were incorporated into virtually aqueous insoluble polymeric backbones, which could be used as electrode modifiers with retained electrocatalytic activity for NADH oxidation (Gorton et al., 1992b). A new TBOconthining polymer (see Figure 1) has more recently been synthesized. A preliminary E"' value of -100 mV versus SCE at pH 7.0 was obtained from cyclic voltammetry of films cast on solid electrodes, the E"' value being similar to what has been found for other TBO-containing polymers (Persson et al., 1993). The ability of this polymer to electrocatalytically oxidize NADH is shown in Figure 2. Because both the enzyme and the cofactor are aqueous soluble species when added to the paste, precautions have to be taken to prevent them from leaking out into the contacting solution. In some studies the electrode surface was covered by an insoluble membrane (Bremle et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991a). Here we report on the possibilities to construct L-lactate sensors based on carbon paste chemically modified with LDH, NAD', PEI, and a phenothiazine based mediator covalently bound to a polymeric backbone. Figure 1 shows a representation of the chemically modified carbon paste electrode, the reaction cycle, and the structural formula of the polymer-bound mediator. The current response for L-lactate and NADH in the concentration range 0.1 to 12 mM using two electrodes prepared from the same batch of chemically modified graphite paste is shown in Figures 3a and 3b. The current response is presented as the average peak height for triplicate FI recordings for electrodes not covered with an outer membrane. The validity of a stable response current for shorter periods of
L. GORTON ET AL
430
PYRUVATE
2e-
NAD+
Polymer red
Enzyme and Cofnclur Modified Carbun Pnste Electrode
+-
+CH,CH+CH,CH-+CH,CH
$ 0 8 +CHz '
CI FHZ
'
CHz-NH c H ' a ; ' n N ( C H , ) ,
c~H,+C,H, c,- CzHs
CI-
Figure 1. Schematic representationof the reaction cycle in an L-lactate sensor based on LDH and NAD' coimmobilized in a mediator-polymer modified carbon paste electrode. The structural formula of the mediator polymer is also given x: 0.28, y: 0.60, and a:0.1 2.
40
30
lo 0 0
1
2 3 [NADH] I m M
4
5
Figure 2. The NADH response current at a rotating polymer modified solid graphite disk electrode (area 0.0731 cm2) in batch of 0.25 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. Polymer coating, 1.7 pg (obtained by evaporation of a dimethylsulfoxide polymer solution). Rotation rate: 100 rad s-' . Applied potential: 0 mV vs SCE.
431
Arnperometric Biosensors
0.4
0.3
4 .
.-
0.2
0.1
0
4 6 8 [L-lactate] I mM
2
0
10
12
. .4
0
2
4
6 8 10 [NADH] I mM
12
14
Figure 3. The current response for various concentrations of (a) L-lactate and (b) NADH for two equivalently prepared L-lactate sensors in a FI system. Carrier: 0.25 M phosphate buffer at p H 7.0. Flow rate: 1.1 rnl rnin-'. Injection volume; 50 pl. Applied potential: 0 mV vs SCE.
time using electrodes without a covering membrane was shown earlier using alcohol and glucose sensors based on carbon paste and alcohol and glucose dehydrogenase,respectively (Dominguez et al., 1993; Persson et al., 1993). From Figures 3a and b a linear current response is suggested in the range 0.1 to 1 mM and 0.1 to 2 mM for L-lactate and NADH, respectively. In these ranges, the average sensitivity for two electrodes was 104 nA/mh4 for L-lactate and 1190 nA/mM for NADH, that is, the L-lactate response is about 9% of that for NADH. The peak width at 10% of full peak height, t w,o.l, differed substantiallyfor the two analytes. Typical values in the 5 mM range was 12 s and 40 s for NADH and L-lactate, respectively.
L. GORTON
432
FT AL
As shown earlier (Dominguez et al., 1993; Gorton et al., 1993), the addition of cationic polymers to the paste can increase not only the sensor stability but also the overall observed kinetics of both the electrocatalytic oxidation of NADH and the reaction catalyzed by the dehydrogenase. It should be mentioned that mass transfer effects and the intrinsic kinetics at the paste solution interface cannot be distinguished in our investigations. The redox polymer used for the electrocatalytic oxidation of NADH incorporates positively charged moieties. However, the cationic charge of the redox polymer seems not to be sufficient to activate the reactions because attempts to compare the response current when PEI was not added failed as the L-lactate current response was almost absent. Both L-lactate and NADH have net negative charges at pH 7.0. The different values of tw,O.,observed in the FI recordings for L-lactate and NADH indicate kinetic limitations mainly in the enzymatic reaction. Substrate inhibition by too high an NAD' concentration in the paste may be one reason for this limitation. These results show that LDH can be incorporated into carbon paste electrodes with retained activity, as was previously shown for other NAD+-dependent dehydrogenases, glucose, and yeast alcohol dehydrogenase (Bremle et al., 199 1; Gorton et al., 1991a; Dominguez et al., 1993; Gorton et al., 1993; Persson et al., 1993). B. Aldose Sensor Based on Aldose Dehydrogenase
A PQQ-containing ALDH capable of oxidizing sugars, especially glucose, xylose, galactose, and mannose was reported by Buchert (199 1). This ALDH has been purified with a simple large-scale procedure and characterized hrther by Smolander et al. (1993a). ALDH catalyzes the oxidation of aldoses in the reaction where the cofactor of the enzyme, PQQ, is reduced. The reaction is exemplified by the oxidation of P-D-glucose (as with other glucose oxidizing enzymes we found that ALDH is specific for the p-anomeric form of glucose). ALDH
P-D-glucose + ALDH-PQQ
+
6-gluconolactone + ALDH-PQQH,
(5)
The reoxidation of the reduced enzyme (ALDH-PQQH,) into the oxidized form (ALDH-PQQ) can be accomplished by the use of various electron acceptors, for example, dichlorophenol indophenol, N-methylphenazine, benzoquinone, and ferrocene derivatives; that is, ALDH-PQQH, + Med,,
-+
ALDH-PQQ + Med,
(6)
The charge will next be delivered to an electrode with the necessary applied potential, compare Reaction 2 above. Contrary to the NADH system, both one and two electron acceptors work well with the reduced form of the PQQ-cofactor of these dehydrogenases (Bartlett et al., 1991; Davidson, 1992).
Amperometric Biosensors
433
a
M
bP
50nA
250nA
-
0
10 20 t i min
Figure 4. Peak arising on the injection of 5 m M glucose into the FI system containing an ALDH electrode as a working electrode. 50 m M sodium phosphate buffer at pH 6.5 was used as the carrier and 200 mV versus Ag/AgCI was used as the reference electrode. (a) response obtained with ALDH adsorbed on the carbon paste electrode with no mediator; (b) response obtained with ALDH mixed into the carbon paste containing 2% ferrocene carboxylic acid, and (c) response obtained with ALDH adsorbed on the carbon paste electrode containing 2% ferrocene carboxylic acid.
ALDH has been previously used for the construction of enzyme based detection devices, either contained in an immobilized enzyme reactor (Smolander et al., 1993b) or in amperometric biosensors by its covalent immobilization on a graphite electrode using adsorbed dimethylferrocene or soluble N-methylphenazine as mediators (Smolander et al., 1992). Here, in a first attempt, we tried to immobilize ALDH in plain graphite paste, but no direct electron transfer could be obtained in the absence of a mediator. However, when ferrocene monocarboxylic acid was included in the paste, a current response could be obtained by the injection of glucose into the FI system (see Figure 4). It was previously discovered that a membrane-bound fructose dehydrogenase is not catalytically active when immobilized into the carbon paste, but is capable of a direct communication with the electrode when adsorbed on the surface of a plain carbon paste electrode (Gorton et al., 1993). The same phenomenon was seen with ALDH. A concentration-dependentdirect catalyticcurrent for glucosewas obtained with ALDH immobilized on the surface of a plain carbon paste electrode (Figures 4 and 5). Apotential of +200 mV versus Ag/AgCl was required to obtain this current response indicating a difference in the electron transfer mechanism compared with fructose dehydrogenase for which the response for fructose was noticed previously at around 0 mV (Gorton et al., 1993). When ALDH was adsorbed on a graphite paste containing 2% ferrocene monocarboxylic acid, the catalytic currents obtained were around 100-fold higher than
relative response (YO) *0°
? _ _ _.../.. _.
0.2
_ _. _ .
. . .. . .. . . . , . . _ . . . . . . .. . . . . .
. . . ..I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
0.5
1
2
5
10
20
50
100
glucose (mM) Figure 5. Direct electron transfer between PQQ-dependent ALDH and carbon paste electrode; current response as a function of glucoseconcentration. The measurements, were performed in an FI system and the electrode potential was +200 mV versus Ag/AgCI and a 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 6.5 was used as the carrier. (0) and (A) denote peak height and peak area, respectively.
those obtained without a mediator (Figure 4). This clearly indicates the nature of the electron transfer as a limiting factor in the sensor performance. The dependence of the current on the concentration of glucose and xylose is shown in Figure 6. In Figure 7 is shown the response current to glucose injections (50 FL, 0.5 mM) with the applied potential of the ferrocene monocarboxylic acid containing carbon paste electrode with adsorbed ALDH on the surface. The E"' of the mediator was evaluated with cyclic voltammetry and found to be + 300 mV versus Ag/AgCl. The figure shows that at +200 mV maximum response current is already obtained, even though not all of the mediator is in its active oxidized form. C. Sensors Based on Coimmobilized Hydrogen Peroxide Producing Oxidases and Peroxidases
All oxidases depend on a cofactor strongly bound within the enzyme structure. The nature of the cofactor may be of different chemical structure (e.g., flavins or copper-containing structures). What they all share, and in contrast to the dehydrogenases, is that they make use of molecular oxygen as the natural reoxidation agent in the enzyme catalyzed reaction. Depending on the class of oxidase, molecular oxygen is either reduced to form hydrogen peroxide or water. Well-known hydro-
Amperometric Biosensors
435
10,000 I
8,000
6.000
.-
Y
4,000
2,000
0
glucose (mM) 700
b 600
500 h
P.- 4oa v
300
200
100
0
I
I
I
I
I
10
20
30
40
50
60
xylose (mM) Figure 6. Current response as a function of aldose concentration: (a) glucose and (b) xylose. ALDH was adsorbed on the carbon paste electrode containing 2% ferrocene carboxylic acid as a mediator. Measurement potential was +300 rnV vs Ag/AgCI and a 50 rnM phosphate buffer at pH 6.5 was used as the carrier.
relative response (YO)
c .,
120 100 -
80
?-.
+3
-
60 -
40
-
0 0
I
I
I
I
I
I
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
measurement potential (mV) Figure 7. Current response for 0.5 mM glucose as a function of the applied potential. ALDH was adsorbed on the carbon paste electrode. A 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 6.5 was used as the carrier.
gen peroxide producing oxidases are glucose, L- and D-amino acids, galactose, alcohol, and choline oxidase, and water producing oxidases, such as, tyrosinase and ascorbate oxidase (Bartlett et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991b). As molecular oxygen is a strong oxidizing agent, all oxidase catalyzed reactions can be regarded as chemically irreversible (c.f. above Reaction 1). A general reaction for an oxidase catalyzed reaction can thus be written: oxidase
substrate + 0,
+
product + H,O, (or H,O)
(7)
From Reaction 7 it is obvious that the reaction can be followed electrochemically either by sensing the decrease in oxygen tension or by the increase in hydrogen peroxide concentration. The necessary applied potentials to either of the electrochemical detection reactions (reduction of molecular oxygen at 4 0 0 mV or oxidation of hydrogen peroxide at +600 mV) are, however, far too low or too high to allow very sensitive and/or interference free detection of the substrate for the oxidase. Much research has therefore been focused on trying to amperometrically follow oxidase based reactions at more optimal potentials (Bartlett et al., 1991). This can be achieved for example by the use of chemically modified electrodeswith electrocatalytic activity for hydrogen peroxide oxidation (Baldwin and Thomsen, 1990; Gorton et al., 1991b; 1992b) or with mediating functionalities acting as alternative electron acceptors to molecular oxygen (Bartlett et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991b).
Amperometric Biosensors
437
Horseradish peroxidase and other peroxidases have often been used in conjunction with oxidase based reactions to promote selective and sensitive detection of the substrate for the oxidase, be it spectrophotometrically or electrochemically (Gorton et al., 1991b). Recently it was found that an apparent direct and very efficient electron transfer could be obtained primarily between various carbon electrode materials and immobilized peroxidases in the presence of hydrogen peroxide (Yaropolovet al., 1979; Jonsson and Gorton, 1989; Paddock and Bowden, 1989;Kulys and Schmid, 1990; Kulys et al., 1991;Wollenbergeret al., 1990,1991; Gorton et al., 1991a, 1991b; Tatsuma and Watanabe, 1991; Csoregi et al., 1993a, 1993b). In the presence of hydrogen peroxide a bioelectrocatalytic reduction current of hydrogen peroxide starts to appear at about +600 mV versus SCE at pH 7.0. As the Eapp,is made more negative, the response current increases and reaches a steady state plateau at about -150 mV. The mechanism for this behavior, a truly direct electron transfer or a mediated one brought about by oxygen containing functionalities (quinones) is much debated (Yaropolov et al., 1979; Paddock and Bowden, 1989; Kulys and Schmid, 1990; Wollenberger et al., 1990; Tatsuma and Watanabe, 1991; Csoregi et al., 1993a). Peroxidases contain a heme group, most often ferriprotoporphyrin IX, as the redox-active prosthetic group contained in the active site. When the native form of the peroxidase reacts with hydrogen peroxide, the prosthetic group is oxidized in a single two-electron step, transforming the native form into compound-I, that is,
+ compound-I
native form + H,O,
(8)
The rereduction of compound-I to the native form occurs in two separate oneelectron steps with the intermediate formation of compound-11: compound-I + 1 e-
-+
compound-I1+ 1 e-
compound-I1
(9)
+ native form
(10)
Obviously Reactions 9 and 10 can occur at the electrode surface without the deliberate attachmentof mediating fimctionalities. In the presence of high concentrations of hydrogen peroxide there is a risk of an irreversible deactivation of the peroxidase due to the transformation of the prosthetic group into a higher oxidation stage. This form of the peroxidase is denoted compound-
m.
Peroxidase-modified electrodes were shown to work successfully as electrochemical sensors for hydrogen peroxide monitoring within the optimal potential range for an amperometric sensor. Several papers have appeared regarding the construction of such sensors based on a solid (Jonsson and Gorton, 1989; Paddock and Bowden, 1989; Kulys and Schmid, 1990; Kulys et al., 1991; Wollenberger et al., 1990; Tatsuma and Watanabe, 1991; Csoregi et al., 1993a), carbon fibers (Gorton et al., 1992a; Csoregi et al., 1993b), carbon paste (Gorton et al., 1991b,
Figure 8. Schematic representationof the reaction sequence of a sensor based on an oxidase coimmobilized with peroxidase in carbon paste.
1992a; Wollenberger et al., 1991), or composite electrodes (Wollenberger et al., 1991). A number of papers also reported the coimmobilization of a hydrogen peroxide producing oxidase with a peroxidase on a solid (Kulys and Schmid, 1990; Kylus et al., 1991; Gorton et al., 1991a; Jonsson-Pettersson, 1991) or in carbon paste electrodes (Gorton et al., 1992a, 1993; Johansson et al., 1993; Kacaniklic et al., 1993). Figure 8 shows the reaction cycle for a carbon paste electrode containing a hydrogen producing oxidase coimmobilized with HRP.From the group in Lund, glucose (Gorton et al., 1992a), alcohol (Gorton et al., 1992a; Johansson et al., 1993), L-amino acid, and D-amino acid (Gorton et al., 1992a;Kacaniklic et al., 1993) sensors based on the corresponding oxidase coimmobilized with HRP in carbon paste electrodes were reported. As in the case of LDH, the addition of PEI was shown to very efficiently promote stability and high reaction kinetics. Here we report sensors for alcohols, D-amino acids, L-glutamate, on the reaction cycle shown in Figure 8 and using alcohol, D-amino acid, and L-glutamate, coimmobilized with either H R P or peroxidase from Arthromyces rumosus (ARP)(Shinmen et al., 1986), respectively. A series of analytes, of high interest in food, medical, and biotechnological areas, can be selectively determined with these sensors. The examples chosen in this paper illustrate that D-amino acid oxidase and alcohol oxidase are group selective rather than one-substrate specific enzymes. Electrodes based on these enzymes should find use as semiselective bioelectrochemical detectors in conjunction with column liquid chromatography (Yao and Wasa, 1988; Johansson et al., 1993; Marko-Varga et al., 1993). Enzyme electrodes based on L-glutamate oxidase, however, are much more one-substrate specific sensors that need no separation step prior to detection and should find use as sensors in flow injection. D. Alcohol Sensors Based on Coimmobilized Alcohol Oxidases and Peroxidases
Alcohol oxidase (AOD) is a flavin containing enzyme active for a variety of alcohols and similar substrates containing hydroxyl groups. When the enzyme oxidizes the substrate, the corresponding aldehyde and the reduced form of the
Amperometric Biosensors
439
enzyme are produced. Molecular oxygen serves as the natural electron acceptor for the reduced form of the enzyme returning it to its oxidized state whereby hydrogen peroxide is produced. The net reaction, exemplified below by the oxidation of ethanol, is as follows (c.f Reaction 7): AOD
ethanol + 0, + acetaldehyde + H,O,
(11)
We previously showed that AOD from Candida boidinii (obtained from Serva) can be coimmobilized with HRP in carbon paste electrodes (Gorton et al., 1992a; Johansson et al., 1993; Marko-Varga et al., 1993). Of great importance for the performance, and both sensitivity and long-term stability, was the addition of PEI to the immobilization reaction mixture (Gorton et al., 1992a).It was also found that using a combination of covalent reagents, carbodiimide and glutaraldehyde, was beneficial for the stabilization of the sensor. As stated above, the enzyme is group rather that strictly substrate selective, and a sensor based on coimmobilized AOD/HRP was shown to be a very good semiselective sensor in liquid chromatography for the determination of alcohols and related analytes. In earlier reports (Johansson et al., 1993; Marko-Varga et al., 1993; Buttler et al., 1993), we showed that with this type of sensor, the production of ethanol in a biotechnological process is selectively followed chromatographically on-line for 24 h without fouling the electrode. In these reports, the AOD used was obtained from one manufacturer. To further investigatethe selectivityof sensorsbased on the combination ofAOD and a peroxidase, we report here on results obtained with two isoenzyme preparations from Candida boidinii but from different sources and one preparation from Pichia pastoris. In this paper, the use of covalent immobilization reagents are omitted and the only reagent added to the graphite, except the pasting liquid and the enzymes, is PEL Table 1 shows the relative responses of a set of three different electrodesprepared with the different isoenzymes for a variety of possible substrates. As can be seen, there are a number of differences in performance of these equivalently prepared electrodes. A difference in selectivity between the isoenzymes from Candida and Pichia is expected. The two sets of preparations based on enzymes from Candida biodinii reveal, however, unexpectedly large differences. No explanation for this difference can be given at this time, unless different strains of Candida boidinii were used by the two manufacturers. Figure 9 shows a chromatogram obtained when the sensor based on AOD from Pichia pastoris was used. The separation of methanol, ethanol, allylalcohol, and 2-chloroethanol is an example of an enzyme-based detection system in LC. A polymer-based separation column was used (PLRP-S) in reversed phase separations with phosphate buffer as the mobile phase. The separation was optimized on a small analytical column (50 x 4.0 mm I. D.) resulting in fast chromatographic separations. Ion exchange phases with similar sizes can be used for the separation
440
Table 1. Comparative Responses of a Number of Substrates and Possible lnterferants with Electrodes Containing Coimmobilized HRP and Three Different lsoenzyrnesof AOD Relative Response 96 Sample (0.5 mM)
ethanol H 2 0 2 (0. I mM) methanol formaldehyde acetaldehyde propionaldehyde butyraldehyde formic acid acetic acid propionic acid butyric acid monochloracetic acid citric acid lactic acid malic acid pyruvic acid inositol triphosphate allylalcohol 2-butanol 2-chloroethanol dihydroxyacetone
Candida boidinii (Serva) Pichia pastoris Candida boidinii (Sigma) 100
100
75 540 22 15 29 <1
189 282 99 c5 94 652 c5 19 56 41 11
151 68 79 22 4.6
159 55 470 24 57
100 866 252 58 10 163 378 <7 34 51 44 60 <7 <7 31 <7 217 46 377 15 57
of other solutes (shown in Table 1). Selective and sensitive separations in combination with catalytic reaction detection can be performed on a large number of analytes. The selectivity, but mostly the sensitivity, can be governed by the choice of sensor listed in Table 1. The choice of possible substrates for these three isoenzymes was chosen based upon the possible applications in the biotechnological and clinical fields. Current studies are being performed for the analysis in many of the listed analytes present in biological fluids like urine and plasma and in fermentation substrates and broths. E. D-Amino Acid Sensors Based on Coimmobilized D-Amino Acid Oxidase and Peroxidase Similar to the case for AOD, D-amino acid oxidase (D-AAOD) is an enzyme with a rather broad specificity. However, it is believed to be an absolute enantiomer specific for the D-amino acids, just as the corresponding L-amino acid oxidase
Amperornetric Biosensors
44 1 1
-
0
5
TIME /min
Figure 9. Chromatogram of 0.5 mM solutions of (1) methanol; (2) ethanol; (3) allylalcohol; and (4) 2-chloroethanol, using an AOD (Pichia pasforidlHRP coimmobilized carbon paste electrode as the sensing device. Chromatographic conditions; mobile phase, 0.05 M phosphate buffer at pH 8.0, flow rate, 0.5 ml min-’, injection volume, 15.4 pl, and an applied potential of -50 mV vs SCE (500 nA full scale).
(L-AAOD) is for the L-amino acids. The net enzymatic reaction can be described as follows: D-AAOD
D-amino acid + H,O
+ 0, -+ 2-0x0-acid + H,O, + NH,
(12)
In previous investigations of the immobilization of both L-AAOD and D-AAOD (Gorton et al., 1992a; Kacaniklic et al., 1994), it was noticed that when coimmobilizing these enzymes in carbon pastes with HRP,the use of covalent immobilization reagents such as carbodiimide and/or glutaraldehyde, resulted in an almost total inactivation of the oxidase. However, as found for many different redox-enzymes (c.f. above) the addition of PEI was beneficial not only for the stability but also for the response for the substrate of the oxidase (Gorton et al., 1992a, 1993; Kacaniklic et al., 1994). An interesting effect was also noticed for the selectivity of L-AAOD. When immobilized within the organic nature of carbon paste, the enzyme is much more active for a number of L-amino acids shown to have no or little reactivity with the enzyme in aqueous solutions or when immobilized on an inert hydrophilic carrier (Kacaniklic et al., 1994). In aqueous solutions or when immobilized on an inert carrier, D-AAOD is reported not to be highly active for all the biologically most important 20 amino acids (Dominguez et al., 1990). Previous preliminary investigations on the immobilization of D-AAOD in carbon pastes were not as successful as with the corresponding L-AAOD in terms ofresponse and stability (Kacaniklic et al., 1994). With the prospect of constructing a highly responding and long-term stable D-amino acid selective sensor based on coimmobilization ofD-AAOD and a peroxidase in carbon
Table 2. FI responses to 0.1 mM hydrogen peroxide (i (H,02)/nA) and 1 .O m M D-phenylalanine (i(D-Phe)/nA)for coimmobilized D-AAOD/HRP and D-AAOD/ARP, respectively. Each value is the average response obtained for two equivalent electrodes. Flow parameters: carrier, 0.1 M Tris buffer at pH 8.0, 0.6 ml min-’, injection volume, 50 PI, applied potential -50 mV versus Ag/AgCI. The electrodes used are those of set 1 described on p. 424. Coimmobilization
D-AAOD/HRP D-AAOD/ARP
i (H202)/nA
i(D-Phe)/nA
562 503
88 154
paste, we here report on the effects of the addition of a number of different cationic polymeric additives to the immobilization reaction mixture and on the choice of peroxidase. The choices of additives and peroxidases are based on previous results by others as well as by the authors (Atmstrong and Lannon, 1987, 1988; Kulys and Schmid, 1990; Wollenberger et al., 1991; Gibson et al., 1992; Gibson and Woodward, 1992; Gorton et al., 1992a, 1993). Table 2 shows the effect of the chosen peroxidase (HRP or ARP) on the response to H202and D-phenylalanine, a substrate with a high turnover rate with D-MOD, when PEI was used as the additive. As can be seen, almost equal amounts (in units) of HRP or ARP applied to the paste reveal similar responses to H20,, whereas the response
Table 3. FI responses to 0.1 mM hydrogen peroxide (i (H,O,)/nA) and 1.O m M D-phenylalanine (i(D-Phe)/nA)for differents additives. Each immobilization is an average of three equivalent electrodes. All electrodes are based on 1 .O mg of D-AAOD, 1.O mg of ARP and 3.0 mg of additive except the ones containing gentamicin and neomycin. The added amounts in these cases were 2.1 mg of D-AAOD, 1 .O mg of ARP, 5.0 mg of gentamicin, and 6.0 mg of neomycin. For further details, see electrodes of set 2 in Experimental. Flow parameters: carrier, 0.1 M Tris buffer at pH 8.0, 0.6 ml min-’, injection volume, 50 pl, applied potential -50 mV vs AglAgCI. Additive
polyethyleneimine ethoxylated polyethyleneimine quaternized polyethyleneimine Gafquat 734 chitosan glutamate gentamicin neomycin mixture of 50% chitosan glutamate and 50% Gafquat 734
i (H202)/nA
i(D-Phe)/nA
313 178 147 442 522 I93 222 191
84 57 43 95 66 89 106
53
Polyethylenlmlne
Gsfaust 734
400
400
350
350
300 4
5
2 - 300 250
250
4 200 I,
0; 200
E
150
'-
150
100 50
loo 50
0
0 0
20
P
P
40
60 80 Time / min
100
120
140
1 0
20
40
60 80 Time I min
100
120
Gentamicin
w
240
100
200
80
.
2
_. I
160
60
p
-3
0 : 150 I .-,
2 lD
-
$120
.-
40
80
.
0
200
100
20
40
0
0
20
60 Time / min
40
80
0 100
0
20
40 60 Time I rnin
80
100
Figure 10. Stability of a series of D-amino acid sensors using different promoters. The electrodes used were those described as set 2 additives on p. 424. Responses for (0)hydrogen peroxide and (0) D-phenylalanine are shown.
L. GORTON ET-AL
444
to D-phenylalanine is twice as high when using ARP. ARP, therefore, in a first evaluation is a more promising candidate than HRP for further experiments. Table 3 shows the effect with different types of additives obtained with newly made electrodes on the response to H202 and D-phenylalanine. As shown in the table, the additive yielding the highest response to H202(chitosanglutamate)does not necessarily give the highest response to D-phenylalanine. Neomycin was previously shown to be a strong promoter for obtaining good electrochemical contact between cytochrome c peroxidase and carbon electrodes (Armstrong and Lannon, 1987,1988) and is the best choice to achieve a high response to D-phenyl-alanine. In Figure 10 one can also see that neomycin has a superior effect on the long-term stability of the response to the amino acid compared with other additives. For Gafquat 734, gentamicin, and neomycin the stability of the responses for H202and D-phenylalanine follow each other whereas for PEI the response for H202 is stable and the response to D-phenylalanine gradually declines. Figure 11 shows the log-log plots of the calibration curves obtained for H202 and D-phenylalanine obtained at pH 8.0 using coimmobilized D-AAOD/ARP with neomycin as the additive. Near linear response behaviors were found between 5 and 1000 pM for hydrogen peroxide and between 0.1 and 14 mM for D-phenylalanine, respectively. The detection limit of D-phenylalanine was found to be 0.1 mM with a signal to noise ratio of 2: 1.
0.5
0
i
L
0
Figure 11. Log-log plots of calibration curves for (0) hydrogen peroxide and (0) D-phenylalanine. The electrodes used were prepared using 1 .O mg of ARP, 1 .O mg of D-AAOD, and 3.0 mg of neomycin er 100 mg of graphite (set 3, p. 424). Carrier; 0.1 M Tris buffer at pH 8.0, 0.6 ml n ,i-! Applied potential -50 mV vs Ag/AgCI. Injection volume 50 pl.
Amperometric Biosensors
445
.
E
g
1
Q, 0.8
0.8
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
1
4
m
T
0.2
1.2 1
-. z 0.8 0.4 0.2 0
5.5
6
65
7
75 PH
8
85
9
9.5
Figure 72. FI responsesfor (0)0.1 rnM hydrogen peroxide and (0)1.O rnM D-phenylalanine as a function of pH obtained for (a) a D-AAOD/HRP and (b) a D-AAOD/ARP coirnrnobilized carbon paste electrode prepared according to set 4 described on p. 424. Carrier (0.6 rnl min-'); at pH 6.0 and 7.0 a 0.1 M phosphate buffer, and at pH 8.0 and 9.0 a 0.1 M Tris buffer. Injection volume 50 pl. Applied potential, -50 mV vs AgIAgCI.
Figures 12a and 12b show the variation of the responses to H,O, and D-phenylalanine with two electrodes, one with HRP (Figure 12a)and one with ARP (Figure 12b) and with the use of neomycin as the additive. The responses to H,O, follow each other irrespective of the choice of peroxidase, having for both peroxidases a pH optimum at pH 7. The responses to D-phenylalanine, however, drastically differ above pH 8 and is much higher at pH 9 when ARP is used. F. g glut am ate Sensor Based on Coimmobilized L-Glutamate Oxidase and Horseradish Peroxidase
L-glutamate oxidase (L-GLUOD) is a much more substrate specific oxidase than L-AAOD. It oxidizes selectively L-glutamate in the presence of oxygen to form a-ketoglutarate and hydrogen peroxide in a reaction analogous with Reaction 12:
L-GLUOD
L-glutamate + H,O + 0, +
a-ketoglutarate + H,O,
+ NH,
(13)
Due to its importance in food, biotechnology, and medicine, several papers have appeared on the making of selective biosensors for L-glutamate based on LGLUOD (Wollenberger et al., 1989; Yao et al., 1990; Villarta et al., 1991). Figures 13a and 13b show calibration curves (loglog plots) for both L-glutamate and hydrogen peroxide obtained with one GLUOD/ARP (Figure 13a) and one GLUOD/HRP(Figure 13b)modified carbon paste electrode. As can be seen, almost strictly linear response ranges were obtained for both L-glutamate and hydrogen peroxide with the GLUOD/HRP electrode, whereas with the GLUOD/ARP electrode deviations from strict linearity are obvious. The slopes of the loglog plots
1.5
0.5
,-l
0.5
L__-
1
i
>
1.5
2
2.5
3
35
4
3
3.5
4
Log (conc /vM)
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
Log (conc./uM)
Figure 13. Log-log plots of calibration curves for (a) (0)hydrogen peroxide and (0) L-glutamate obtained with a GLUOD/HRP-PEI modified carbon paste electrode and (b) (0) hydrogen peroxide and (0)L-glutamate obtained with a GLUOD/ARP-PEI modified carbon paste electrode. Carrier (0.6 ml min-'); a 0.1 M phosphate buffer at pH 7.0. Injection volume 50 pl. Applied potential -50 mV vs Ag/AgCI.
Arnperometric Biosensors
447
for hydrogen peroxide and L-glutamate for the GLUODHRF' electrode were close to identical (0.80 and 0.78, respectively). In this case, the response to the substrate of the oxidase is somewhat closer to the response to hydrogen peroxide than those obtained for other oxidase/peroxidaseelectrodesreported from this laboratory,even though comparable or even higher amounts of the oxidases were added to 100 mg of graphite compared with the amount of GLUOD (8 U mg-').
ACKNOWLEDGMENT Financial support from the Swedish Natural Science Research Council (NFR), the Swedish Research Council for the Engineering Sciences (TFR), the Swedish National Board for Technical and Industrial Development (NUTEK), Direktor Albert Phhlsson's Foundation for Scientific Research is gratefully acknowledged. The authors also thank Suntory Ltd., Japan, and Yamasa Shoyu Co., Ltd., Japan; Dr. T. D. Gibson, UK,Dr. M. G. Venegas, USA for their generous gifts of t h e k t r o r n y c e s rarnosus peroxidase, L-glutamate oxidase, Gafquat 755N,and quaternized a n d ethoxylated polyethyleneimines, respectively; and Labinett AB, Sweden for the loan of the Automated Sample Injection Analyser. Acta Chemica Scandinavica and the Foundation for Biotechnical and Industrial Fermentation Research (Finland) are thanked for personal grants to M. Smolander and the Swedish Institute for personal grants to Z. Huan.
REFERENCES Appelqvist, R., Marko-Varga, G., Gorton. L., Torstensson, A,. & Johansson, G. (1985). Enzymatic determination of glucose in a flow system by catalytic oxidation of the nicotinamide coenzyme at a chemically modified electrode. Anal. Chim. Acta 169,237-247. Armstrong, F.A., Hill, H.A.O., & Walton, N.J. (1988). Direct electrochemistry of redox proteins. Acc. Chem. Res. 21,407413. Armstrong, F.A. & Lannon, A.M. (1987). Fast interfacial electron transfer between cytochrome c peroxidase and graphite electrodes promoted by aminoglycosides: Novel electroenzymic catalysis of H202reduction. J. Am. Chem. SOC. 109,721 1-7212. Armstrong, F.A. & Lannon, A.M. (1988). Towards macromolecular recognition at electrodes: Fast interfacial electron transfer to cytochrome c peroxidase at graphite electrodes is promoted by aminoglycosides. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 16,842-844. Bahulekar, R., Ayyangar N.R., & Ponrathnam, S. (1991). Polyethyleneimine in immobilization of biocatalysts. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 13,85%868. Baldwin, R.P. & Thomson, K.N. (1990). Chemically modified electrodes in liquid chromatography detection: A review. Talanta 38. 1-16. Bartlett, P.N., Tebbutt. P., & Whitaker. R.G. (1991). Kinetic aspects of the use of modified electrodes and mediators in bioelectrochemistry. Progr. React. Kinet. 16, 55-156. Barman, T.E. (1969). Enzyme Handbook, Vol. 1, p. 47. Springer-Verlag, New York. Blaedel, W.J. & Engstom, R.C. (1980). Reagentless enzyme electrodes for ethanol, lactate, and malate. Anal. Chem. 52, 1691-1697. Bremle, G., Persson, B., & Gorton, L. (1991). Anamperometricglucose electrode basedon carbon paste, chemically modified with glucose dehydrogenase, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide and a phenoxazine mediator, coated with a poly(ester-sulfonic acid) cation-exchanger. Electroanalysis 3,7746.
Buchert, J. (199 I). A xylose-oxidizing membrane-bound aldose dehydrogenase of Gluconobucrer oxyduns ATCC 621. J. Biotechnol. 18, 103114. Buttler, T.A., Johansson, K.A.J., Gorton, L.G.O., & Marko-Varga, G. (1993). On-line fermentation process monitoring of carbohydrates and ethanol using tangential flow filtration and column liquid chromatography. Anal. Chem. 65,262%2636. Chenault , H.K. & Whitesides, G.M. (1987). Regeneration ofnicotinamide cofactors for use in organic synthesis. Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol. 14, 147-197. Csoregi, E., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., & Gorton, L. (1993a). Mediatorless electrocatalytic reduction of hydrogen peroxide at graphite electrodes chemically modified with peroxidases. J. Biotechnol., 36,315-337. Csoregi, E., Gorton, L., & Marko-Varga, G. (1993b). Carbon fibre as electrode materials for the construction of peroxidase modified amperometric biosensors. Anal. Chim. Acta 273.59-70. Davidson, V.L. (1992). Principles and Applications of Quinoproteins. Dekker, New York. Dominguez, E., Marko-Varga, G., Carlsson, M., & Gorton, L. (1990). Liquid chromatographic separation and stereo detection of L- and D-amino acids with catalytic reaction detection using immobilized enzymes. J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 8, 82-30, Dominguez, E., Lan, H.L., Okamoto, Y., Hale, P.D., Skotheim, T., & Gorton, L. (1993). Acarbonpaste electrode chemically modified with a phenothiazine polymer derivative and yeast alcohol dehydrogenase for the analysis of ethanol. Biosens. Bioelectron. 8, 167. Duine, J.A., Frank, J., & Jongejan, J.A. (1987). Enzymology of quinoproteins. Adv. Enzymol. Relat. Areas Mol. Biol. 59, 165-212. Frew, J.E. & Hill, H.A.O. (1987). Electrochemical biosensors. Anal. Chem. 59,933A-944A. Gibson, T.D. (1992). University of Leeds, Leeds, UK, personal communication. Gibson, T.D., Higgins, I.J., & Woodward, J.R. (1992). Stabilization ofanalytical enzymes using a novel polymer-carbohydrate system and the production of a stabilized single reagent for alcohol analysis. Analyst 117, 1293-1297. Gibson, T.D. & Woodward, J.R. (1992). Protein stabilization in biosensor systems. In: Biosensors and Chemical Sensors. ACS Symp. Ser. (Edelman, P.G. & Wang, J., Eds.), Vol. 487, pp. 4&55. Am. Chem. Society, Washington, D.C. Gorton, L. (1986). Chemically modified electrodes for the electrocatalytic oxidation of nicotinamide coenzymes. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., I, 82, 1245-1258. Gorton, L., Bremle, G., Csoregi, E., Persson, B., & Jonsson-Pettersson, G. (1991a). Amperometric glucose sensors based on immobilised glucose oxidising enzymes and chemically modified electrodes. Anal. Chim. Acta 249,4%54. Gorton, L., Csoregi, E., Dominguez, E., Emneus. J., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Marko-Varga, G., & Persson, B. (I991 b). Selective detection in flow analysis based on the combination of immobilised enzymes and chemically modified electrodes. Anal. Chim. Acta 250,203-248. Gorton, L., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Csoregi, E., Dominguez, E., Johansson, K., & Marko-Varga, G. (1992a). Amperometric biosensors based on an apparent direct electron transfer between electrodes and immobilized peroxidases. Analyst 117,1231-1241. Gorton, L., Persson, B., Hale, P.D., Bouguslavsky, L.I., b r a n , H.I., Lee, H.S., Skotheim, T., Lan, H.L., & Okamoto, Y. (1992b). Electrocatalytic oxidation of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide cofactor at chemically modified electrodes. In: Biosensors and Chemical Sensors, ACS Symp. Ser. (Edelman, P.G. & Wang, J., Eds.), Vol. 487, pp. 5 6 4 3 . Gorton, L., Dominguez, E., Marko-Varga, G., Persson, B., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Csoregi, E., Johansson K., Narasaiah, D., Ghobadi, S., Kacaniklic, V., Skotheim, T., Hale, P., Okamoto, Y., & Lan, H.-S. (1 993). Amperometric biosensors based on immobilized redox-enzymes in carbon paste electrodes. Bioelectroanalysis, 2, Akademiai Kiddb, Budapest, Hungary. Johanson, K., Jonsson-Pettersson, G., Gorton, L., Marko-Varga, G., & Csoregi, E. (1993). A reagentless amperometric biosensor for alcohol detection in liquid chromatography based on co-immobilized peroxidase and alcohol oxidase in carbon paste. J. Biotechnol. 31, 301-316.
Amperometric Biosensors
449
Jonsson, G. & Gorton, L. (1989). An Electrochemical sensor for hydrogen peroxide based onperoxidase adsorbed on a spectrographic graphite electrode. Electroanalysis I , 46-68, Jonsson-Pettersson, G. (1991). Reagentless hydrogen peroxide and glucose sensors based on peroxidase immobilized on graphite electrodes. Electroanalysis 3, 74 1-750. Kacaniklic, V., Johansson, K., Marko-Varga, G., Gorton. L.. Jonsson-Pettersson, G., & Csoregi, E. (1994). Amperometric biosensors for detection of L- and D-amino acids based on coinmobilized peroxidase and L- and D-amino acid oxidases in carbon paste electrodes. Biosens. Bioelectron.. Electroanalysis 6, 38 1-390. Kylus, J., Bilitewski, U., & Schmid, R.D. (1991). Robust graphite-based bienzyme sensors., Sens.Act. B, 3,227-234. Kylus, J. & Schmid, R.D. (1990). Mediatorless peroxidase electrode and preparation of bienzyme sensors. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 24,305-3 11. Labuda, J. (1992). Chemically modified electrodes as sensors in analytical chemistry. Selective Electrode Rev. 14, 3 3 4 6 . Marko-Varga, G. Johansson, K., & Gorton, G. (1993). A reagentless coimmobilized alcohol biosensor as a detection unit in column liquid chromatography for the determination of methanol and ethanol. Quim. Anal. 12,74-79. Murray R.W., Ewing, A.G., & Durst, R.A. (1987). Chemically modified electrodes. Molecular design for electrocatalysis. Anal. Chem. 59,379A-39OA. Paddock, R.M. & Bowden, E.F. (1989). Electrocatalytic reduction of hydrogen peroxide via direct electron transfer from pyrolytic graphite electrodes to irreversibly adsorbed cytochrome c peroxidase. J. Electroanal. Chem. 260,487494, Persson, B. (1990). A chemically modified graphite electrode for electrocatalytic oxidation of reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide based on a phenothiazine derivative, 3-P-naphthoyl-toluidine Blue 0. J. Electroanal. Chem. 287, 61-80. Persson, B., Lan, H.L., Gorton, L., Okamoto, Y., Hale, P.D., Boguslavsky, L.I., & Skotheim, T. (1993). Amperometric biosensors based on electrocatalytic regeneration ofNAD' at redox polymer-modified electrodes. Biosens. Bioe1ectron.g 8 , 8 1-88, Shinmen, Y., Asami, S., Amachi, T., Stimizu, S., & Yamada, H. (1986). Crystallization and characterization of an extracellular hngal peroxidase. Agric. Biol. Chem. 50,247-249. Smolander,. M., Buchert, J., & Viikari, L. (1993a). Large-scale applicable purification and characterization of a membrane-bound PQQ-dependent aldose dehydrogenase. J. Biotechnol. 29,287292. Smolander, M., Cooper, J., Schuhmann, W., H h m e r l e , M., & Schmidt, H.-L. (1993b). Determination of xylose and glucose in a flow-injection system with PQQ-dependent aldose dehydrogenase. Anal. Chim. Acta 280. 119-127. Smolander, M., Livio, H.-L., & Rasanen, L. (1992). Mediated amperometric determination of xylose and glucose with an immobilized aldose dehydrogenase electrode. Biosens. Bioelectron. 7, 637-643. Tatsuma, T. & Watanabe, T. (1 99 I). Peroxidase model electrodes: Heme peptide modified electrodes as reagentless sensors for hydrogen peroxide. Anal. Chem. 63, 1580-1585. Updike, S.J. &Hicks, G.P. (1967). The enzyme electrode. Nature 214,986-988. Villarta, R.L., Cunningham, D.D., & Guilbault, G.G. (1991). Amperometric enzyme electrode for the determination of L-glutamate. Talanta 38,49-55. Wing, S.A. & Hart, J.P. (1992). Chemically modified carbon-based electrodes and their applications as electrochemical sensors for the analysis ofbiologically important compounds. A Review. Analyst 117, 12151229. Wollenberger, U.,Scheller, F.W., Bohmer, A,, Passarge, M., & Muller, H.-G. (1989). Aspecific enzyme electrode for L-glutamate development and application. Biosensors 4,38 1-391. V'ollenberger, U., Bogdanovskaya, V., Bobrin, S., Scheller, F., & Tarsevich, M. (1990). Enzyme electrodes using bioelectrocatalytic reduction of hydrogen peroxide. Anal. Lett. 23, 1 7 9 5 4808.
Wollenberger, U., Wang, J., Ozsoz, M., Gonzalez-Romero, E., & Scheller, F. (1991). Bulk modified enzyme electrodes for reagentless detection ofperoxides. Bioelectrochem. Bioenerg. 26.287-296. Yao, T. & Wasa, T. (1988). High-performance liquid chromatographic detection of L- and D-amino acid by use of immobilized enzyme electrodes as detectors. Anal. Chim. Acta 209,259-264. Yao, T., Kobayashi, N., & Wasa, T. (1990). Flow-injection analysis for L-glutamate using immobilized L-glutamate oxidase: Comparison of an enzyme reactor and enzyme electrode. Anal. Chim. Acta 231, 121-124. Yaropolov, A.I., Malovik, V., Varfolomeev, S.D., & Berezin, 1.V. (1979). Electroreduction of hydrogen peroxide on an electrode with immobilizedperoxidase. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 249, 1399-1401.
ENZYME BASED DIFFUSION BADGE FOR THE DETECTION OF FORMALDEHYDE
R. Feldbrugge, K. P. Rindt, and A. Borchert
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. PRINCIPLES OF OPERATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. STABILIZATION OF ENZYMES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. ELIMINATION OF NONSPECIFIC COLOR FORMATION . . . . . . . V. PRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
451 452 452 455
. . 456 457 457
ABSTRACT The development of economical, easy to handle enzyme sensors for the colorimetric detection of gaseous toxic compounds is based on a patent for enzymatic gas measurement by Dr. Rindt. The present investigations have resulted in a one-way biosensor for selective detection of formaldehyde in a few minutes. The problems
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 451459. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
45 1
452
R. FELDBRUGGE, K.P. RINDT, and A. BORCHERT
with nonspecific color formation and storage stability over 12 months at room temperature were solved. Many possibilities have arisen for economic production on a large scale. We conclude that such an enzyme diffusion Badge can be conveniently applied for the detection of various gaseous substances.
1. INTRODUCTION Nowadays people are surrounded by formaldehyde in the working place, at home, and even during their fkee time, which can have a negative influence on their health (Bundesgesundheitsamt, 1984, 1987; Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, 1987). Thus there is an interest in the detection of such toxic compounds in a very reliable and simple manner (report 1986). A lot of gas detection tubes for the measurement of different gaseous substances by chemical reaction and color formation are now on the market. But due to low specificity it is not possible to detect one single toxic substance. By using enzymes, the selectivity of the reaction is very high. The enzyme formaldehyde dehydrogenase allows specific and quantitative oxidation of formaldehydewith NAD' to formic acid and NADH. Diaphorase transfers NADH and colorless tetrazolium salt in NAD+ and colorful formazan can be observed. The main aims of this investigation are: 1. stability of the enzymes, 2. specific color formation, and 3. production of the sensor. Inexpensive components and simple production methods were needed for the preparation of a biosensor as a product for single use. The user thus has a tool for uncomplicated applications. To date, such an enzyme badge for colorimetric detection of toxic compounds of air pollutants has not been on the market.
11. PRINCIPLES OF OPERATION The main functional part of the diffusion enzyme badge is a porous, absorbing rod of sintered glass. At the surface, the catalytic conversion of the gaseous substance and color compounds take place. The underlying principle is shown in Figure 1. At the top of the sintered glass rod, the enzymes and stabilizer are absorbed and lyophilized on the opposite site for the color compounds and the reagents. This rod is placed in a recyclable case together with a glass ampoule containing the activating buffer (see Figure 2). For activation of the biosensor, the glass ampoule is broken and the buffer sucked onto the bottom of the porous rod. Capillary forces and evaporation produce a flow of activating solution to the top of the rod. With this flow, the reagent and color compounds are transported to the activated and concentrated enzymes. Formaldehydemolecules in the atmosphere reach the active surface by diffusion. This exposure starts the specific reaction with formaldehyde dehydro-
substrate molecules
s
S
s
s
--
sinterglass
K.-P. Rindt Dragorwork AG
11i"lli activating solution
Figure 7. Functional part of the enzyme badge.
ampoule support
sinterglass r o d activating solution
connecting channel
Figure 2. Construction of the badge. 453
454
R. FELDBRUGGE, K.P. RINDT, and A. BORCHERT
Biosensor
Enzym-Diffusion-Badge ___ (Example)
-
-+NAD+
HCHO
i
1
visual Analysis
1. 1.
Signal
Figure 3. Reaction scheme of an enzyme - diffusion badge and a biosensor.
genase (EC 1.2.1.46)that generatesthe interesting product NADH. Diffusion is the limiting step of the reaction and this is directly stoichiometric to the atmospheric concentration of the gas compound. In a second reaction the fixed enzyme diaphorase (EC 1.6.4.3) in the enzyme layer reoxidizes the NADH to NADf and leads to color formation. The resulting color intensity depends on the formaldehyde concentration and exposure time. The product of time and concentration yields a color intensity that can be visualized by color comparison against a color code. The reaction scheme is shown in Figure 3. Both products, NADH and dye as first and second signals, are formed as a result of an enzymatic reaction and therefore this formaldehyde badge represents a special modification of a biosensor (Scholtissek et al., 1990).
Enzyme Based Detection of Formaldehyde
455
111. STABILIZATION OF ENZYMES The technical demands of a biosensor are as follows: 1. storage stability for 6 to 12 months, 2. transportation without refkigeration, and 3. stability in case of a short temperature rise up to 60 "C. For these purposes, enzymes must be stabilized and nonspecific color change of the dye has to be prevented. Known stabilizers for dehydrogenases often contain mercapto groups. They block the oxidation of the active center of the enzyme and regenerate the activity of the enzyme by reduction (Ogushi et al., 1984, 1986). These known substances, however, show nonspecific interaction with the color compound tetrazolium salt. This is also the case with serum albumin as a standard protein stabilizer (Europaische Patentanmeldung).In principle, the substrates and products can have a stabilizingeffect. In this case only NAD' is applicable and it needs costabilizers to meet the requirements for a commercial product. Several proteins and polyethyleneglycol (PEG) showed sufficient stabilizationin long time storageexperiments. Both enzymes, formaldehyde dehydrogenase and diaphorase, were tested with such mixtures over a 100-day period or longer at temperatures of 4 to 60 "C. Figures 4 and 5 show the results thus obtained. The temperature dependence is visible in spite of stabilization and decreases the activity, especially in the case of formaldehyde dehydrogenase. The remaining FormaldehydeDHmU/sensor 140 130 120 110 100 90. 80. 70. 60. 4 50. 40. 0. 30. n -.. 20. - - ' '.-. ....... 10. -.
* 1: 6
>.
-4°C
-
27°C.
+
37°C.
-
60°C.
Figure 4. Stability of fixed formaldehyde dehydrogenase.
R. FELDBRUGGE, K.P. RINDT, and A. BORCHERT
456 140 130 120 110 100
Diaphorase mU/sensor
90. 80. 70. 60. 50. 40.
30. 20. 10.
0 0
10.
20.
30.
40.
50.
60.
70.
80.
90.
100
days
Figure 5. Stability of fixed diaphorase.
activities of the compounds were, however, sufficient for more than one year and could be reproduced.
IV. ELIMINATION OF NONSPECIFIC COLOR FORMATION Apart from the stabilization of delicate substances present in a measuring system, there is the problem of blank reactions. The problem involves the signal being present or emerging in the absence ofthe specimen to be measured. In this particular instance, this means color formation without formaldehyde being present in the surrounding air. To achieve a high measurement accuracy this source of error must be minimized, or better, eliminated. The reasons for this inaccuracy of the biosensor can be attributed to a limited number of sources. In general the enzymes (formaldehyde dehydrogenase, diaphorase), the reagents @ADf, stabilizer), the dye (formazan) or its precursor (INT), the carrier substance (sintered glass), and the buffer substance (phosphate)may be responsible for nonspecific side reactions. In addition, it is reasonable to suspect the existence of unknown additives or impurities in the substances. Other possible reasons for this blank reaction might be the operations during the manufacturing of the biosensor as well as physical conditions of the air like temperature,humidity, and concentration of formaldehyde. The natural background level of formaldehyde due to the photochemical degradation of natural organic substances is about 0.1 pg/m3 in maritime air, and about 1 pg/m3 in continental air.
Enzyme Based Detection of Formaldehyde
457
To eliminate pollution of the biosensor by formaldehyde, a laminar-flow box was used to which clean air was permanently supplied via a special formaldehyde filter. Within this box, the sensors were prepared and genuine blank reactions were measured. The considerably reduced blank reaction data of sensors produced in this way show that their production in air free of formaldehyde is of indispensable necessity. The purity of the applied batches of sintered glass was investigated. By soaking up organic solvents, a yellowish band at the solvent front was observed. This color reaction was distinct when arriving at the top area and provides considerableblank reaction data. The color reaction results from residues coming from the production of the sintered glass bars and probably also from the absorption of substances from the packaging. Methanol turned out to be a suitable eluent. Thus, methanol washing used before the subsequent treatment of the sintered glass provided optimum conditions. Another processing step leading to different blank reaction data was found to be lyophilization of the components on the sintered material. Therefore, different lyophilization parameters were tested. An optimization and a shorter drying time process eliminated this nonspecific color formation (Golker, 1987; Willemer, 1989).
V. PRODUCTION The main factor for economical use is the price of the sensor. Therefore, it was necessary to minimize the amount of coupled enzyme. Placing a high local concentration only at the top of the sintered glass rods allows reduction in enzyme costs, but the handling of very small volumes (20 pl) is not easy and, therefore, constitutes an expensive production step, especially in large scale production. One way of overcoming this problem is the preparation of the porous sintered glass on one end with buffer and the color compounds in a microtiter plate for 96 rods. The wells of a second titer plate were filled with the concentrated enzyme solution. By turning the 96 rods into this second plate, the enzyme was homogeneously adsorbed at the opposite site of the sintered glass rods. The pipetting can be performed automatically by commercial machines. After lyophilization,the active part of the enzyme badge can be stored separately or put into the case of the sensor. This method of preparation minimized enzyme consumption and production costs and improved the quality of the sensors.
VI. CONCLUSIONS The present work has led to a number of conclusions.First, the sensor can be used by laymen: no additional equipment is required, activation is simple, and evaluation is performed visually by comparison against a color code. Second, the color of the exposed area accumulates over more than 2 hours depending on the atmospheric
458
R. FELDBRUGGE, K.P. RINDT, and A. BORCHERT
concentration of the species to be measured (dose dependence). Third, the system was shown to be very sensitiveindicating 100ppb formaldehyde within 15minutes. Fourth, the substance to be measured is the substrate of the correspondingenzyme. Thus, the enzymatic reaction is highly selective. Some cross-reactions, however, based on the chemical indicator reaction may occur. Fifth, enzymes and reagents can be separately stored on one single structure. And sixth, under optimum conditions, color formation is immediate. Above a definite enzyme activity level that is characteristic of aparticular enzyme system,color formation dependent on atmospheric substrate concentration does not depend on enzyme concentration. Thus, enzyme can be added in excess, and partial loss of enzyme activity does not influence the result. Furthermore, the permanent solvent stream caused by capillary forces during activation and later by evaporation has several functions: (1) During the activation process it hrther concentrates the enzymes in a minute volume at the surface to be exposed, i.e. exactly in that place where the enzymes are required. (2) During measurement it prevents the enzymecontaining surface from drying and serves as a permanent reagent supply. And (3) It prevents colored products from diffusing back into the structure, thus allowing also the use of such chromogens that give rise to water-soluble color products. The same system is easily adaptable from spot to long-term measurement, for example, by covering the exposed area with a partially gas-permeable membrane. As for storage, use of a special stabilizing cocktail revealed that lyophilizedenzyme diffision badges for formaldehyde stored at 37 "C for 18 months remained fully functional. However, the activity of formaldehyde dehydrogenase dropped at the same time to 30% of its original activity.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work is part of a diploma work (Diplomarbeit) done at the Dragerwerk AG Liibeck. More details of the design and manufacturing of these enzyme badges and also a list of the specific literature can be found in the Diplomarbeit (Feldbriigge, 1991).
REFERENCES Bundesgesundheitsamt:Formaldehyd.Gemeinsamer Bericht des Bundesgesundheitsamtes, der Bundesanstalt fiirArbeitsschutz unddes Umweltbundesamtes. (1 984). Familie und Gesundheit. Vol. 148, Verlag Kohlhammer, Stuttgart. Bundesgesundheitsblatt 30 Nr. 8, (1987). Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft. Maximale Arbeitsplatzkonzentrationen und Biologische Arbeitsstofftoleramen (1987). Mitteilung XXIII. Europaische Patentanmeldung, Veroffentlichungsnuer: 0054689 B 1, StabilisierteZubereitung von Tetrazoliumsalzen. Feldbriigge, R. (1991). Diplomarbeit, WS 90/91, Fachhochschule Ostfriesland. Gdlker, C.: Trochung biotechnologischer Produkte (1987). Biotech-Forum 4,4. Ogushi, S., Ando, M., & Tsuru,D. (1986). Formaldehyde dehydrogenase from Pseudomonas putida. The role of a cysteinyl residue in the enzyme activity. Agric. Biol. Chem. 50,250%2507.
Enzyme Based Detection of Formaldehyde
459
Ogushi, S., Ando, M., & Tsuru, D. (1984). Formaldehyde. dehydrogenase from Pseudomonusputidu: A zinc metalloenzyme.J. Biochem. 96, 1587-1591. Report forecasts explosive growth of European market in biosensors. (1986). Biosensors 2, 145. Scholtissek, S., Rindt, K.P., & Schlfer, G. (1990). Biosensoren. Focus Medizinische Hochschule Lubeck, 7. Jahrg. 172-179. Willemer,H.: PhysikalischeGrundlagender GefiiertrocknungFortschritteund Entwicklungstendenzen. Firmenschrift, Leybold AG, Koln.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
BIOSENSING OF HEAVY METAL IONS BASED ON SPECIFIC INTERACTIONS WITH APOENZYMES
lkuo Satoh Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. PRINCIPLE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. CHARACTERISTICS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. PROCEDURE.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. BIOSENSING OF HEAVY METAL IONS . . . . . A. Apoenzyme Beads as Sensing Elements . . . . B. Apoenzyme Membrane as the Sensing Element VI. CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...... . .. ... ... ... .. . ...
. .... .... .... .... .... ....
....... .......
. . . . . . . 461 . . . . . . . 462 . . . . . . . 462 . . . . . . . 463 . . . . . . . 466 . . . . . . . 467 . . . . . . . 467 . . . . . . . 470 . . . . . . . 471
ABSTRACT The present work led to a novel idea about the biosensing of heavy metal ions based on apoenzyme reactivation methods. Several kinds of immobilized metalloenzymes
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 461472. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
46 1
IKUO SATOH
462
as recognition elements for each metal ion were applied in the microdetermination of heavy metal ions in flow streams. Regeneration of the metal-free enzymes (apoenzymes) was made by loading chelating agents to the metal-bound enzymes (holoenzymes). The apoenzymes were positively reactivated by adding trace amounts of heavy metals. The recovery depended on metals trapped in the enzymes, which was shown to be a practical index for microanalysis of heavy metal ions. The proposed method was demonstrated to be convenient, safe, specific, and highly sensitive.
1. INTRODUCTION A great number of metal-dependent enzymes have already been identified (Vallee, 1980).Heavy metal ions coordinated in the active site of these enzymes play a very important role in the catalytic process. These heavy metal ions are intrinsic to each of the enzymes and most of them can be reversibly removed from the catalytic site of the enzymes. Therefore, metal-free enzymes (apoenzymes) can be used as specific and selective recognition elements for heavy metal ions in an enzymatic analysis. Use of enzymes as highly sensitive reagents is common in food and clinical analyses. Currently,immobilized enzymes in combination with transducers for monitoring their enzymatic activity are used for the construction of biosensors, and many of them are commercially available (Satoh, 1989a). Analytes have been mostly limited to substrates, products, activators, and inhibitorsin the enzyme-catalyzed reactions. In sharp contrast, we have adopted flow-injectionmicroassay for cofactors, namely heavy metal ions, based on apoenzyme reactivation (Satoh et al., 1986, 1987, 1988, 1989b, 1990ste, 1991a-e, 1992, 1993). We have tried to regenerate cofactor-free enzymes from cofactor-bound enzymes (holotype of metalloenzymes) and use them as the recognition elements for heavy metal ions in flow streams. The apoenzyme reactivation methods for flow-injection microdetermination of heavy metal ions are summarized in this paper with a special focus on our current studies.
II. PRINCIPLE Cofactors such as heaG metal ions and nucleotides are generally complexed in the active site of the metalloenzymes and flavin enzymes, respectively, and the cofactors are directly responsible for the activity of the enzymes. Therefore, these enzymes need the cofactors for expressing catalytic activity. The cofactor-bound enzyme is usually called a holoenzyme, whereas the cofactor-free enzyme is called an apoenzyme. Figure 1 schematically shows the correlation between the holoenzyme and the apoenzyme. The metalloenzymes capture the metal ions so tightly (dissociation constant: Kd< lo4 M) that they hold them throughout the purification process. In contrast with the metalloenzymes, metal-activated enzymes bind the
Biosensing of Heavy Metals
Cofactor-bound enzyme catalytically
463
Cofactor-free enzyme catalytically
[ active
[ inactive
Figure 1. lnterconversion between the holoenzyme and the apoenzyme. Cofactor: Heavy metal ions; r(lr(lS catalytic site; 000 substrate-binding site.
metal ions rather weakly (Kd < 1C3to 1O4 M), and then, the enzymes tend to lose the metal ions during purification (Wagner, 1988). Preparation of the apoenzyme lacking its catalytic activity can be made by removing the metal ion from the corresponding holoenzyme with strong chelating agents. The apoenzyme is reactivated by exposing it to the metal-containing sample so that metal ions can be taken up and trapped in the active site. Thus, the amount of metals coordinated in the catalytic center of the enzyme molecules may be closely related to the enzyme activity expressed and, in turn, be proportional to the added amount of the metals. The content of the trace metals can eventually be determined by monitoring the induced activity attributable to the reactivation of the apoenzyme. The metal ions responsible for the catalytic activity of the metalloenzymes vary with the type of enzyme. Selective determination of the metal ions depends upon choosing the appropriate metalloenzyme in which its catalytic site fits well with each metal ion.
111. CHARACTERISTICS In practice, use of metalloenzymes immobilized on supporting materials such as small glass beads and a thin polymer membrane can make assays continuous and, moreover, enhance the feasibility of handling in the process between regeneration and reactivation of the apoenzymes. Reusability and long-term stability of the immobilized enzymes may be expected. Microdetermination of heavy metal ions based on spectrophotometric monitoring was tried (Townshend and Vaugham, 1970) and a microassay for zinc(I1) ions using high performance liquid chroma-
IKUO SATOH
464
tographic methods (Risinger et al., 1983) as well as an electrochemical method (Mattiasson et al., 1979) were reported. We have originally developed unique biosensing of heavy metal ions based on flow-injectioncalorimetry (Satoh et al., 1986).Thermometric flow-injectionanalysis of biorelated compounds in combination with the use of a high performance semiadiabatic calorimeter were pioneered by Mosbach et al. (Danielsson and Mosbach, 1988; Danielsson, 1990). The flow-measuring system, that is, a thermal bioanalyzer, is better known as an “enzyme thermistor.” We used the calorimeter for monitoring the enzymatic activity in the assay cycle including regeneration and reactivation. The calorimetric biosensing system is schematically presented in Figure 2. The column packed with immobilized enzyme beads is interchangeable and, therefore, different kinds of metals are readily determined. In addition, other monitoring methods such as amperometry, potentiometry, and spectrophotometry are available by exchanging the thermistor with other transducers, for example, electrodes,photomultipliers, etc. The proposed biosensing methods in microanalysis of heavy metal ions do not require expensive instruments based on atomic absorption spectrophotometryand inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrophotometry.Furthermore, this
chela3nt
9substrate lons
I If
A k m i n m bath
Figure 2. Flow-calorimetric biosensing system for heavy metal ions based on the apoenzyme reactivation method. Carrier reservoir (buffer solution), pump (flow rate 1.O ml min-’), heat exchanger (thin-walled acid-proof steel tubing: 0.8 mm, i.d.), bath (80Q x 250 mm; 303 K), enzyme column (packed with metalloenzymes immobilized on porous beads), thermistor (attachedto a gold capillary placed in a polymer holder), WB/Amp. (DC-type Wheatstone bridge with a chopper stabilized operational amplifier), Rec. (pen recorder).
Biosensing of Heavy Metals
465
novel method does not involve pollution problems due to exhaust fumes. The characteristics of the proposed methods can be summarized as follows: 0
0 0 0
Mild assay conditions High sensitivity High selectivity Reusability of the immobilized enzymes Continuous flow use
0 0
0
0
Compact assay system Feasibility of handling Feasibility of field work Low-priced assay Separability of the metaltrapping and the activitymonitoring process
Procedure
Phenomena
Substrate
response t o Iiolocnzymcs
t Carrior
washing
t ChelatinE t . Carrier
aRcnt
t
r c g c n c r a t ion o f apociixymos washing
Subs t r a t c
response t o apocnzymcs
t Carricr
washing
Heavy mctal i o n s
p a r t i a l a c t i v a t i o n of apocnzymes
t
washing
Carrier
t
Substrate
response a t t r i b u t a b l c t o metal i o n s c o o r d i n a t c d i n Clic enzymes
Carrier
c
washing
Complctc r c a c t i v d t i o i i of apocnzymcs ( c o n v c r s i o o t o Iiolocnzymcs)
Carrier
washing
Figure 3. Flow chart for the assay procedure.
466
IKUO SATOH
IV. PROCEDURE A flowchart for the assay procedure is shown in Figure 3. Three rotary valves for injection are connected in series between a damper and a drain valve to avoid their mutual contamination. At first the catalytic activity of the immobilized holoenzymes at the reactor (column or membrane) is measured by injecting its substrate. The change in output is a measure of the activity attributable to the holoenzymes, as schematically illustrated in Figure 4. After exposing the enzymesto the chelating agent, a drastic decrease in the activity is observed. This means that the cofactors, namely heavy metal ions complexed in the catalytic site of the holoenzymes, are mostly removed. The amount of chelating agent required for regenerating the
Scan L
60 min
Y
Figure 4. Schematic presentation of response curves for a reaction cycle.
Biosensing of Heavy Metals
467
apoenzymes varies with the kind of metalloenzyme and with the conditions of the chelating agents (variables such as concentration, pH, volume, etc.). Subsequent injection of a trace amount of the cofactors reactivates the apoenzymes. Thus, the recovery of the activity is determined by adding the substrate. While sufficient cofactors are introduced to the mixture of the cofactor-free and cofactor-bound enzymes, all of the enzymes may be completelyconverted to the holoenzymes. The system is then ready for another assay. A reaction cycle generally takes 40 to 60 minutes, but application of a membrane-type reactor reduces the cycle time (within 30 min).
V. BIOSENSING OF HEAVY METAL IONS A. Apoenzyme Beads as Sensing Elements Alkaline Phosphatase as the Recognition Element
Alkaline phosphatase as the recognition element in combination with a couple of monitoring devices was feasible in the most sensitive assay of zinc(I1) and cobalt(I1) ions. The enzyme purified from Escherichia cofi (EC 3.1.3.1., Asahi Chemical Industry Co., Ltd., Ohito-cho, Tagata-gun, Shizuoka-ken, Japan) was immobilized on epoxide acrylic beads (Eupergit C: 100-200 pm particle diameter; 40 nm pore diameter; 180m2g-' surface area; Rohm Pharma, Darmstadt, Germany) and then packed into a small polymer column (0.3 ml). The enzyme is often employed as a labeling reagent for enzyme immunoassay. Hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl phosphate top-nitrophenol and orthophosphate was monitored for measuring the enzyme activity: p-nitrophenyl phosphate + H,O
+ p-nitrophenol + orthophosphate
(1)
Tris-HC1 100mM buffer @H 8.0, containing 1.OM NaC1) was used and the catalytic activity was calorimetrically determined by injecting 0.1 ml of 100 mM substrate (p-nitrophenylphosphate) (Satoh et al., 1991d). Exposing the column to 5 ml of20 mM 2,6-pyridine dicarboxylate solution (PH 6.0) as the cofactor-complexingagent almost virtually converted the holoenzymes to the apoenzymes. The effect of pH on the chelating agent in the regeneration reaction was tested. No noticeable variation in the level of the regeneration was observed over the pH range of 4.0 to 8.0. The recovery of the activity attributable to the partial reactivation of the apoenzymes was a function of the added amount of zinc(I1) ions. The calibration graph for zinc(I1) ions demonstrated a sigmoidal curve. Zinc(I1) ions ranging from 0.01 to 1.O mM were calorimetrically determined for a 0.5 ml injection. The effect of pH on the reactivation of the apoenzyme was investigated in the weakly acidic pH region (from 4.0 to 6.0 in steps of 0.5). The recovery was unaffected by variations
IKUO SATOH
468
in pH; this means the proposed biosensing using alkalinephosphatasedoes not need any critical pH adjustment, which is very practical. The column retained much more long-term stability than that of a column packed with immobilized bovine carbonic anhydrase. The reactor was repeated over 120 times during the two months of operation. The spectrophotometric approach to measuring enzyme activity based on detecting changes in absorbance at 405 nm attributable to p-nitrophenol formation provided similar results, except for the highly sensitive assay for zinc(I1) ions in submicromolar levels (Satoh et al., 1990b, c). Potentiometric monitoring of the activity with a flow-through ISFET for detecting pH shifts attributable to orthophosphate released in the hydrolytic reaction was also carried out to determine zinc(I1) ion concentrations in the range of 0.01 to 1.O mM (Satoh et al., 1990d). Cobalt-substituted alkaline phosphatase is also capable of hydrolyzing the orthophosphate ester. Therefore, the same immobilized preparations were applied in the microdetermination of cobalt(I1) ions. Biosensing based on spectrophotometry gave excellent results (Satoh, 1992b),and cobalt(I1) ions ranging in concentration from 1-200 pM were determined. Use of a calorimetric sensing system was possible in the concentration range of 0.04 to 1.O mM. Ascorbate Oxidase as the Recognition Element
Ascorbate oxidase is one of the most typical copper-dependentenzymes involved in the oxidation of L-ascorbate to dehydroascorbate. The reaction is described by 2L-Ascorbate + 0, + 2dehydroascorbate + 2H,O
(2)
Ascorbate oxidase from cucumber (EC 1.10.3.3, Asahi Chemical Industry Co., Ltd.) immobilized onto porous glass beads with controlled pore size (CPG; 5 1.5 nm pore diameter, 120-200 mesh, 44 m'g-', Electronucleonics Inc., Fairfield, NJ, USA) was packed into a column and then mounted in the proposed flow-calorimetric system (Satoh et al., 1987). Since oxidative reactions involving molecular oxygen are usually accompanied by considerable heat generation, highly sensitive and precise biosensing of copper(I1) ions attributable to the significant exothermic reaction was anticipated. Thus, micromolar levels of copper(I1) ions were calorimetrically determined. Regeneration of the apoenzymes was achieved with exposure of 20 mM NJV-diethyldithiocarbamate solution (PH 8.0) to the column. The apoenzymes derived from the ascorbate oxidase was selectively responsive to copper(I1) ions and not to divalent cations in 1 mM level such as Ca(II), Co(II), Mg(II), Ni(II), and zinc(I1). Trace amounts of copper(I1) ions in human blood sera were analyzed by the calorimetric method and compared with those obtained by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. There was satisfactory agreement between these methods. Amperometric monitoring of the enzyme activity with a polarographic oxygen electrode showed a more rapid and sensitive determination of copper(I1) ions. The
Biosensing of Heavy Metals
469
assay covered concentrationsranging from 0.5 to 2.0 pM and required about half an hour. L-Ascorbate can be determined by detectingabsorbance at 265 nm, which is used for monitoring the oxidase activity.Thus, copper(I1)ions measured photometrically ranged from 0.1 to 10 pM. A series of these monitoring methods validated the use of immobilized ascorbate oxidase beads as an excellent recognition element for copper(I1) ions. Carbonic Anhydrase as the Recognition Element
Carbonic anhydrase purified from erythrocytes (EC 4.2. 1.1) is known for its remarkably high turnover numbers. The enzyme is a dominant factor in equilibrium between carbon dioxide and bicarbonate in blood as shown in Equation 3, which also expresses esterase activity as seen in Equation 4. CO, + H,O p-nitrophenyl acetate + H,O
-+
H,CO,
(31
3
p-nitrophenol + acetate
(4)
Application of bovine carbonic anhydrase immobilized on the same sort of porous glass beads (CPG) for the specific determination of zinc(I1) and cobalt(I1) ions in combination with flow-calorimetric monitoring turned out to be feasible for the first time (Satoh et al., 1986, 1989b). Injection of 0.5 ml ofp-nitrophenyl acetate into the carrier streams (Tris-HC1 buffer, 0.1 M, pH 8.0) in the calorimetric system resulted in an exothermic response. Since values of changes in enthalpy for ester hydrolysis are normally zero, we considered that the exothermic change resulted from the protonizing heat of acetic acid enzymatically formed in the tris buffer. Exposing the immobilized enzyme beads in a column (packed volume, 0.3 ml) to 5 ml of 10 mM 2,6-pyridine dicarboxylate solution (pH 5.0) as the chelating agent caused regeneration of the apoenzymes. Zinc(I1) ions in the range of 25 to 250 pM could be calorimetrically measured using 0.5 ml injections. Generally, zinc(I1) ions complexed in the active site of zinc enzymes (e.g., hydrolases) are reversibly exchanged with cobalt(I1) ions, and the cobalt-coordinated enzymes still retain their catalytic activity. We also succeeded in assaying submillimolar levels of cobalt(I1) ions (0.05 to 0.2 mM) using cobalt-substituted enzymes (Satoh, 1989b). In this case, less volume of the chelating agent (2.5 ml) was sufficient for regeneration of the enzymes. Galactose Oxidase as the Recognition Element
Galactose oxidase (EC 1.1.3.9) catalyzes oxidation of D-galactose as follows: D-Galactose + 0, 3 D-galacto-hexodialdose + H,O,
(5)
IKUO SATOH
470
This enzyme isolated from Dactilium dendroidesreadily converted to the apoenzyme under water soluble conditions while it takes a much longer time for reactivation of the apoenzyme. Utilization of the immobilized preparation in combination with the flow-injection technique for monitoring of enzyme activity resolved the problem. Copper(I1) ions were calorimetrically determined in millimolar levels (Satoh, 1990e). Amperometric monitoring with an oxygen electrode and a hydrogen peroxide electrode made the assay more sensitive and rapid (Satoh et al., 1990a). There is room for improvement for a more sensitive response.
B. Apoenzyme Membrane as the Sensing Element Table 1 summarizes successful biosensing of heavy metal ions based on the apoenzyme reactivation method using bead-type immobilized enzymes. Application of the apoenzyme column to flow-injection biosensing demonstrated their long-term stability. Practical use has already been found in clinical and food analyses. In order to obtain a more rapid assay, a contact type of apoenzyme sensor has been developed (Satoh et al., 1992, 1993). Ascorbate oxidase immobilized onto a porous polymer membrane (partially aminated polyacrylonitrile,50 pm thickness, Asahi Chemical Industry Co. Ltd.) was directly attached to a flow-through polarographic oxygen electrode and used as the recognition element for copper(I1)
Table 1. Flow-Injection Biosensing of Heavy Metal Ions Based on the Apoenzyme Reactivation Methods Metal
Zn(I1) Zn(I1) Zn(I1) Zn(I1) Cu(I1) Cu(I1) Cu(I1) CU(I1) Cu(I1) Cu(I1) Co(I1) Co(I1) Co(I1)
Recognition Element
ALP ALP ALP BCA ASOD ASOD ASOD GalOD GalOD GalOD ALP ALP BCA
Monitoring Method
Ranae lmMl
Calonmetry Potentiometry Spectrophotometry Calorimetry Amperometry Calorimetry spectrophotometry Amperometry Amperometry Calorimetry Calorimetry Spectrophotometry Calorimetry
/T /I /P /T 10 /T /P
0.010-1.0 0.010-1.0
0.00014.010 0.0254.25
0.000~.002 0.0014.05
0.00014.010
10
0.1-10.0
/H /T
0.01-10.0 5.0-20.0 O.O&I.O 0.0014.2 0.0054.2
/T /P /T
Nofes: Enzyme:ALP, alkalinephosphatase; ASOD, Ascorbate oxidase; IBCA, Bovine carbonic anhydrase; GalOD,
Galactose oxidase. Method T (thermistor), I (pH-ISFET),P (photomultiplier), 0 (polarographic oxygen electrode), H (hydrogen peroxide electrode).
Biosensing of Heavy Metals
471
ions (Satoh et al., 1992a). Use of the system mounted with the apoenzymemembrane sensor resulted in a more rapid assay (26 min). Furthermore, microdetermination of dual heavy metal ions was tried with hybrid enzymes immobilized onto the same kind of membrane (Satoh, 1993). Alkaline phosphatase and ascorbate oxidase were coimmobilized onto the polymer membrane and tightly attached to a polarographic oxygen electrode. Ascorbate oxidase functioned not only as the recognition element for copper(I1) ions but also as an indicator enzyme for amperometric monitoring of alkaline phosphatase activity on the same membrane. For sensing zinc(I1) ions, the following coupled reactions were amperometrically monitored: L-Ascorbyl-2 phosphate + H,O
-+ L-ascorbate + orthophosphate
(6)
2 L-Ascorbate + 0, + 2 dehydroascorbate + 2 H,O
(7) The apoenzyme membrane was regenerated by pumping cofactor-complexing agents for removing each cofactor, namely copper(I1) and zinc(I1) ion from the catalytic site of alkaline phosphatase or ascorbate oxidase. Thus, zinc(I1) ions in 2 to 200 pM concentrations and copper(I1) ions in 2 to 100 pM concentrations were determined through activation of each of the immobilized apoenzymes on the same supporting membrane.
VI. CONCLUSION Flow-injection microassay of heavy metal ions such as cobalt(II), copper(II), and zinc(I1) ions based on apoenzyme reactivation methods was found feasible with immobilized metalloenzymes. Regardless of the shape of the immobilized metalloenzymes, that is, beads or membrane, this method of unique monitoring is now widely applied in several analytical areas. Further developmental studies towards establishing the generality and versatility of these analytical techniques involving immobilized apoenzymes in flow systems are currently in progress.
REFERENCES Danielsson, B. (1990). Calorimetric biosensors. J. Biotechnol. 15, 187-200. Danielsson, B. & Mosbach, K. (1988). Enzyme thermistors. In: Methods in Enzymology (Mosbach, K., Ed.), Vol. 137, pp. 181-197. Academic Press, New York. Mattiasson, B., Nilsson, H., & Olsson, B. (1979). An apoenzyme electrode. J. Appl. Biochem. I , 377-3 84. Risinger, L., Ogren. L., & Johansson, G. (1983). Determination ofzinc(I1) ions with a reactor containing immobilized carboxypeptidase A in a flow system. Anal. Chim. Acta 154,251-257. Satoh, I. (1989a). Biosensing using calorimetric devices. In: Chemical Sensor Technology (Seiyama, T., Ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 26%282. Kodansha Ltd., Tokyo, Japan. Satoh, I. (1989b). Continuous biosensing of heavy metal ions with use of immobilized enzyme-reactors as recognition elements. In: Proceedings of the MRS International Meeting on Advanced Materi-
472
IKUO SATOH
als, Vol. 14 (Biosensors, Karube, I., Ed.), pp. 4550. Material Research Society, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA. Satoh, I. (19904. Apoenzyme reactivation microassay for zinc(1I) ions with flow-through transducers. In: Proceedings of the 3rd International Meeting on Chemical Sensors, pp. P/lO&P/l07. The Organizing Committee of the 3rd International Meeting on Chemical Sensors, Cleveland, OH, USA. Satoh, I. (1990e). Calorimetric biosensing of heavy metal ions with the reactors containing the immobilized apoenzymes. AM. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 613,401404. Satoh, I. (1991d). An apoenzyme thermistor microanalysis for zinc(I1) ions with use of an immobilized alkaline phosphatase reactor in a flow system. Biosensors and Bioelectronics6(4), 375-379. Satoh, I. (1991a). Flow-injection calorimetry of heavy metal ions using apoenzyme-reactors. Netsusokutei (Calorimetry and Thermal Analysis) (in Japanese) 18(2), 89-96. Satoh, I. (1991e). Flow-injection microdetermination of heavy metal ions using a column packed with immobilized apoenzyme beads. J. Flow Injection Anal. 8(2), 111-126. Satoh, I. (1993). Amperometric biosensing of heavy metal ions using a hybrid type of apoenzyme membrane in flow streams. Sensors and Actuators, in press. Satoh, I. (1992b). Use of immobilized alkaline phosphatase as an analytical tool for flow-injection biosensing of zinc(I1) and cobalt(I1) ions. AM. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 672,240-244. Satoh, I., Abe, R., & Nambu, T. (1988). Bioelectrochemical sensing of copper(I1) ions using an immobilized apoenzyme column. Denki Kagaku 56(12), 10451049. Satoh, I. & Aoki, Y. (1990d). Biosensing of zinc(I1) ions using an apoenzyme reactor and an ISFET detector inflow streams. DenkiKagaku58(12), 1114-1118. Satoh, I., Ikeda, K., & Watanabe, N. (1986). Microanalysis of zinc@) ion by using an apoenzyme thermistor. In: Proceedings of the 6th Sensor Symposium (Takahashi, K., Ed.), pp. 203206. Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, Tokyo, Japan. Satoh, I., Itoh, H., & Anzai, H. (1992a). Flow-injection amperometric biosensing of copper (11) ions using a contact-type of an apoenzyme sensor. In: Proceedings of the 2nd World Congress on Biosensors, pp. 1 8 H 9 0 . Elsevier Advanced Technology, Oxford. UK. Satoh, I., Kasahara, T., & Goi, N. (199Oa). Amperometric biosensing of copper(I1) ions with use of an immobilized apoenzyme reactor. Sensors and Actuators BI, 499-503. Satoh, I., Kimura, S., & Nambu, T. (1987). Biosensing of copper(I1) ions with an apoenzymethermistor containing immobilized metalloenzymes in flow system. In: Digest of Technical Papers, The 4th International Conference on Solid-state Sensors and Actuators (Transducers '87, Matsuo, T., Ed.), pp. 789-790. Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, Tokyo, Japan. Satoh, I. & Masumura, T. (1990b). Flow-injection biosensing of zinc(I1) ions with use ofan immobilized alkaline phosphatase reactor. In: Technical Digest of the 9th Sensor Symposium (Sasaki, A., Ed.), pp. 197-200. Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, Tokyo, Japan. Satoh, I. & Nambu, T. (1991b). Flow-injection photometric biosensing of copper(I1) ions with use of an immobilized ascorbate oxidase column. In: Technical Digest of the 10th Sensor Symposium (Nakamura, T., Ed.), pp. 77-80. Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan, Tokyo, Japan. Satoh, I. & Yamada, Y. (1991~).Flow-injection biosensing of cobalt(I1) ions with use of an immobilized alkaline phosphatase reactor in a flow system. In: Digest of Technical Papers of the 6th International Conferenceon Solid-state Sensorsand Actuators (Transducers '91, Chang, S.-C., Ed.), pp. 699-702. The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc. Piscataway, NJ, USA. Townshend, A. & Vaugham, A. (1970). Application of enzyme-catalysed reactions in trace analysis - V Determination of zinc and calcium by their activation of the apoenzyme of calf-intestinal alkaline phosphatase. Talanta 17,289-298. Vallee, B.L. (1980). Zinc and other active metals as probes of local conformation and htnction of enzymes. Carlsberg Res. Commun., 15,423-441. Wagner, F.W. (1988). Preparation of metal-free enzymes. In: Methods in Enzymology (Riordan, J.F. & Vallee, B.L., Eds.), Vol. 158 A, pp. 21-32. Academic Press, San Diego.
DESIGN OF HIGH-ANNEALlNG-TEMPERATURE PCR PRIMERS AND THEIR USE IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF A VERSATILE LOW-COPY-N UMBER AMPLI F ICATION PROTOCOL
Michael W. Meckl enburg
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. MATERIALS AND METHODS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Oligodeoxynucleotide Synthesis and Purification . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Purification of HCMV DNA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Preparation and Use of PCR Master Mix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. The Amplification Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Analysis of the PCR Amplified Material . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 473-490. Copyright 8 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
473
474 474 476 477 477 477 478 479
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
4 74
111. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Primer Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Amplification Protocol Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Detection of HCMV . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,480 .480 .482
.484 ,486
ABSTRACT High-annealing-temperature (HAT) primers for polymerase chain reaction (PCR) were designed and tested. These HAT primers were used to develop an amplification procedure that employs hypervariable extension times in combination with two temperature amplification cycles, master mixes and hot start to achieve highly reproducible, low-copy-number PCR amplification. The employment of HATprimers drastically reduced cycling times and essentially eliminated nonspecific amplification products even in the presence of vast excesses of nonspecific DNA sequences. Hypervariable extension times provided a simple, noninvasive approach for dynamically modifying the reaction environment during amplification. In addition, this procedure makes extremely efficient use of enzyme, reducing the amount of Taq or Replitherm polymerase to 0.4 and 0.12 U per 50 p1 reaction, respectively. The use of PCR master mixes increased the reproducibility and portability of the assay. And finally, a modified form of hot sturt was employed to reduce primer oligomer formation. HAT primers were designed for the amplification of human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). These primers were used to develop a highly specific, low-copynumber PCR assay that employed a combined annealing/extension temperature of 70 "C or 72 "C. Nonspecific bands, other than primer oligomer bands, were not detected even in the presence of a vast excess of human genomic DNA. These primers can be employed to calibrate the temperature on different thermocylcers as well as to take into account environmental factors that influence amplification. This would be especially advantageous when porting protocols to different machines and simplifying the use of PCR in field studies as well as for identifying factors that influence the local stability at the 3' end of primers.
1. INTRODUCTION Advancements in DNA probe technology have led to the development of simple, nonisotopic detection systems for use in basic research and clinical diagnostics (Wetmur, 1991; Fernandes and Coffman, 1992; Kricka, 1992; Kessler, 1993). Although numerous ideas have been put forward to improve the sensitivity of nucleic acid based detection assays, none has had a more dramatic effect than PCR (Saiki et al., 1985; Innis et al., 1990). In essence, PCR takes advantage of the inherent genetic capability that nature has endowed upon nucleic acids, namely its ability to replicate itself. This ability, upon which all life depends, is both obvious in its simplicity and staggering in its implications. Since its introduction, PCR has
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
4 75
transformed the way DNA analysis is carried out in both research and clinical laboratories. In this procedure, the target DNA sequences are amplified by sequential rounds of polymerization using two oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) primers complimentary to opposite strands of the target region. The procedure can amplify a single target sequence up to lo9 molecules in a few hours. PCR is now routinely employed to manipulate and detect specific DNA sequences. In many cases, the sensitivity of the PCR technique has surpassed that of even the most sensitive ELISAs and biological assays (Arnhein and Erlich, 1992; Rapley et al., 1992; Lew et al., 1992; Rolfs et al., 1993). PCR demonstrated the fundamental principles involved in nucleic acid based amplification and it was not long before variations on this basic theme were developed (Kwok et al., 1989; Wu and Wallace, 1989; Duck et al., 1990; Guatelli et al., 1990; Barany, 1992; Walker et al., 1992; Segev, 1993). The potential of these new nucleic acid based amplification techniques has only begun to be assessed, but they will undoubtedly lead to the development of additional low-copy-number detection systems (Gingeras et al., 1991; Bush et al., 1992; Kalin et al., 1992; Carpenter et al., 1993; Devlin et al., 1993). PCR has also been used as a generalized reporter system (Sano et al., 1992; Mecklenburg, 1995a). The realization that nucleic acid based amplification procedures can be used as highly sensitive universal reporter systems will have dramatic effects both in basic research and clinical diagnostics. Nucleic acid amplification procedures have provided us with techniques that allow the detection ofjust a few copies of a specific nucleic acid sequence. Employment of these techniques has the potential to significantly increase the sensitivity of immunoassays, as well as for nucleic acid probe detection. Nucleic acid based amplification techniques are dependent upon the cooperative, reversible nature of DNA duplex formation. The ability to accurately predict the overall stability of duplexed ODN from base sequence data is an essential prerequisite in the development of a knowledge based strategy for the construction of high-annealing-temperature PCR primers. Most precise methods for calculating helix stability are based upon empirically determined nearest neighbor thermodynamic parameters using di- or trinucleotides (Breslauer et al., 1986: Freier et al., 1986). These methods are surprisingly accurate at predicting the T, of DNA and RNA duplexes. However, not all the sequences that function efficiently as probes make good PCR primers. This is, at least in part, due to the fact that PCR primers are not only required to hybridize but are also required to function as efficient substrates for primer extension. It has been shown that the initiation of polymerization is highly dependent upon the stable association of the 3' end of the primer with the template (Rychlik and Rhoads, 1989). It is, therefore, not surprising that primers designed using standard probe methodology do not always function efficiently in PCR. Thermal denaturation data derived from di- and trinucleotide studies reflect the average dynamic equilibrium over the entire length of the DNA
476
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
duplex and has no mechanism for taking into account the local stability at the 3' ends of DNA duplexes. This issue has led to the development of a number of computer programs for the design of PCR primers (Lowe et al., 1990; Hillier and Green, 1991; Lucas et al., 1991; Montpetit et al., 1992). These programs analyze parameters such as hair-pin formation, overall GC content, primer-primer annealing, etc. Primer annealing temperatures are calculated by, in one way or another, skewing the standard nearest neighbor analysis predictions so as to take the stability at the 3' ends of the primers into account.These methods can therefore only serve as guidelines for the construction of PCR primers. Refinement of these methods requires expanding our understanding of the local stability of primers in duplexes. Ideally, one would like to develop a nearest neighbor analysis that employs a measurement parameter that is sensitive to the stability of the terminal 3' nucleotides in DNA duplexes. This in turn requires the development of a technique that is capable of quantitating the local stability at the 3' ends of primers hybridized to their templates. One approach would be to perform a thermal amplification profile for a particular primer pair and determine the temperature at which amplificationno longer occurs. The presence of specific PCR amplification product would be used as the indicative measurement parameter. A T,, could be derived in much the same way T, is derived for the thermal denaturation of primers (Mecklenburg, 1995b).The empirical TPCRdata derived from systematically exchanging the 3' terminal nucleotides in the primerltemplate would provide the data required for the development of a PCR-based nearest neighbor analysis. The accurate determination of TPCRwould require the development of a highly reproducible amplification procedure and thermocycling conditions. Here, I present the integration of HAT PCR primers into a highly standardized amplification protocol capable of amplifying low-copy-number sequences with a high degree of reproducibility. HCMV was used as the model system in these studies. HCMV is a member of the herpes group and is a ubiquitous human pathogen that causes a wide variety of ailments (Stagno et al., 1982). HCMV has a genome of linear double-stranded DNA of about 235 kb. The detection of the virus using PCR is of clinical interest (Pillay and Griffiths, 1992; The et al., 1992).
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS The Taq thermostable polymerase and the human genomic DNA were obtained from Promega. Replitherm, a thermostable polymerase, was obtained from Epicenter. The T7 DNA polymerase and BSA (RIA grade) were purchased from US Biochemical Corp. Agarose was supplied by Sigma. The nucleotide triphosphates digoxygenin-labeleddUTP, alkaline phosphatase labeled antidigoxygeninantibodies and salmon sperm DNAwere purchased from Boehringer Mannheim. Low-peroxide Tween 20 and NP-40 (protein grade) were bought from Calbiochem. The
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
477
AMPPD [di-sodium 3-(4-methoxyspiro-(1,2-dioxetane-3-2'-tricylo[3.3.1.13.7]decan)4-yl]phenyl phosphate) was obtained from Tropix, USA. The single-sided X-ray film was bought from Kodak. The Zetaprobe hybridization membrane was purchased from Bio-Rad. All other reagents were purchased from Merck and were ofpro analysis grade. Phenol (Merck, p.a.) was redistilled as follows: 10 pl of dH,O was added to 100 g of solid phenol and melted at 65 "C. Once melted, 0.5 g tin powder, 100 mg NaHCO, and 10 boiling chips were added and the distillation started. After the temperature had reached 170 "C, the phenol was collected in a dark glass bottle containing 0.1 M Tris buffer, pH 8, and stored at -20 "C. A. Oligodeoxynucleotide Synthesis and Purification
The ODNs were synthesizedon an Applied Biosystems 380A synthesizer by the author at the Biomedical Center Unit, Lurid, Sweden according to the instructions supplied by the manufacturer. ODNs were purified by ion exchange fast protein liquid chromatography (FPLC) on a Mono Q column (Pharmacia LKB Biotechnology, Inc.) using a 0.05 to 1 M potassium phosphate, pH 6.5 gradient containing 20% acetonitrile.The samples were concentrated on a Speed-Vacand desalted using an ultrafiltration unit with a molecular weight cut-off of 5,000 daltons (Ultrafree, Millipore). The concentration was determined by measuring the OD,,,, and the volume was adjusted to give a final concentration of 0.5 mg/ml.
B. Purification of HCMV DNA The HCMV was grown on human foreskin fibroblasts according to standard procedures (DeMarchi and Kaplan, 1976; Stinski, 1978). The HCMV genomic DNA was isolated as described (Stinski et al., 1979; DeMarchi, 1981; Sambrook et al., 1989). The virus preparation was extracted three times with an equal volume of phenokhloroforrn (1: 1, vol/vol) and once with chloroform-isoamyl alcohol (24: 1, vol/vol). The DNA was precipitated by the addition 0.5 volumes of 7.5 M ammonium acetate and 2 volumes of 96% ethanol. After centrihgation, the pellets were washed with 70% ethanol, dried, and resuspended in DNA buffer (1 mM EDTA, 10 mM Tris, pH 8). The DNA concentration was determined by measuring the OD,,,. C. Preparation and Use of PCR Master Mix
In order to reduce the risk of carry-over contamination a number of precautions were taken. Stock solutionswere prepared in sterile tissue culture facilitiesthat had not been exposed to amplified material. The solutions were prepared using individually wrapped UV irradiated plastic disposables,baked glassware (300 OC, 4 h) or autoclaved materials, which have been exposed to UV irradiation packaged in UV transparent material (15 W, 30 cm, 60 min). Only pipette tips with aerosol
478
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
barriers were used (Continental Labs, California, USA).The buffer components were prepared from bottles specifically for PCR use only. Stock solutions of Tris (1 M, pH 8.4), KC1 (1 M), MgCl, (1 M), BSA (10 mg/ml), dNTPs (10 mM of each deoxynucleotide), and primers (0.5 mg/ml) were prepared. The 10 mM dNTP solution was prepared in 10 mM Tris, pH 8 using the sodium salt of the nucleotide triphosphates, except in the case of dGTP in that the lithium salt was used and the pH was adjusted to 7 with LiOH. The solutionswere aliquoted into microfuge tubes in appropriate volumes and stored at -20 "C. Each tube was used only once and then discarded. Different master mix preparations were used for the Taq and Replitherm polymerases. One milliliter of Taq master mix was prepared by combining the following: 20 p1 Tris, 50 p1 KCl, 4 pl MgCl,, 20 p1 BSA,50 pl dNTP, and 772 p1 distilled water. One milliliter of the Replitherm master mix was prepared as follows: 100 pl lox buffer from Epicenter (15 mM MgCl,, 500 mM KC1,0.05% Tween 20,0.05% NP-40,0.01% gelatin, and 100 mM Tris, pH 8.3), 10 pl Tris, 2.5 pl MgCl,, 20 p1 BSA, 50 pl dNTP, and 733.5 pl distilled water. It is essential that the lox buffer from Epicenter be used for the preparation ofthe Replitherm master mix. Typically, 50 ml of master mix was prepared, aliquoted into 916 pl portions (equivalent to 1 ml or 20 x 50 pl reactions) and stored at -20 "C. The primers ( 2 pl of each primer/$ 16 pl portion) were added subsequently in order to increase the flexibility and portability of the master mixes. Each primer pair received a unique number that was used to identify the master mixes once primers have been added. The master mixes were stable for at least 9 months when stored at -20 "C. The mixes could be freeze-thawed at least three times without any detectable loss of sensitivity.
D. The Amplification Procedure The amplification was performed using the in the tube temperature sensing thermocycler from Cambio, Cambridge, UK.The calibration was performed using a digital microthermometer (Tradoterm, Sweden). A drop of paraffin oil was added to each well to ensure proper thermal contact. In the standard protocol, 46 pl of the master mix was transferred into a 1.2 ml microfbge tube (Sarstedt). The 2 pl DNA sample was added, followed by two drops of baked paraffin oil (300 "C, 4 hr). The tubes were placed in the thermocycler and the denaturation step initiated. After denaturation, 2 pl of the diluted Taq polymerase (0.2 U/pI) or Replitherm (0.06 U/pl) were added to each tube. The reaction tubes remained in the thermocycler during the addition of polymerase (Ward et al., 1989). Two temperature PCR was employed in these studies. The standard procedure employed 60 cycles. The anneaIing/extension temperature was 70 "C and the cycling denaturation temperature was 92 "C. The annealing/extension step was carried out for 15 s for the first 25 cycles, 60 s for the next 30 cycles and 420 s for the last 5 cycles. The denaturation step was carried out for 15 s throughout the
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
479
amplification procedure, except for the initial denaturation step that was carried out for 5 min at 95 OC.
E. Analysis of the PCR Amplified Material Analysis of the amplified material was performed in separate, self-contained facilities that were UV irradiated on a routine basis. The equipment used in this facility was dedicated for this purpose. A method of testing for contamination was developed. Asmall piece of W-treated ( 15 min on a Transilluminator model TM36, W P , California, USA) filter paper (2 x 3 mm) was used to wipe the surface to be tested. The paper was placed in a microhge tube and a standard PCR amplification was run. The detection limit of the contamination test was 200 copies. The test was run once a week at 10 predetermined locations and 10 randomly chosen locations. The procedure was also used to identify contaminated individuals. The PCR amplification products were analyzed on 3% agarose gels. The gels were prepared as follows: 100 mL of TAE buffer (1 mMEDTA, 40 mM Tris-acetate, pH 8) was thoroughly degassed and 3 g of agarose were added. The aluminum foil covered beaker was swirled immediately prior to being microwave irradiated for 3 min at maximum intensity (800 W). The gel was stirred while cooling to 55 "C and 5 pL of an EtBr solution (1 0 mg/mL,) was added. The gel was poured and allowed to cure at 4 "C for 30 min. The PCR-amplified material (9 p1) was mixed with 1 pl of the dye buffer (0.0 1% bromphenol blue, 30% glycerol, 50 mM EDTA, pH 8) on a virgin piece of parafilm. The sample was loaded onto the gel and electrophoresis carried out for 2 h at 90 V. The size marker was MspI cut pBR322 (New England Biolabs). The DNA bands were visualized on a UV table and photographed with a Polaroid camera using Polaroid 665 film. The Southern transfer onto the Zeta Probe membranes was carried out according to the manufacturers' instructions. The gel was soaked for 15 min in transfer solution (0.4 N NaOH, 1.5 M NaC1) and blotted onto to the nylon membrane. The membrane was rinsed with neutralizing solution (1 M NaC1, 0.5 M Tris, pH 7.2), dried at room temperature for 60 min, and finally W irradiated face down on a Transilluminator UV light table for 90 s (Khadjian, 1987; Chou et al., 1992). The end labeling of the OD" with digoxygenin-tagged dUTP was performed using a terminal deoxynucleotide transferase labeling kit (Boehringer Mannheim). The blocking, hybridization, and immunological procedures were performed as described (Boehringer Mannheim). The membranes were blocked for 1 h at 55 "C in hybridization solution (4 x SSPE, 1% sodium lauryl sulfate, 1% (wh) powdered nonfat dry milk, and 100 yg/ml sheared salmon sperm DNA). The solution was replaced with fresh hybridization solution containing 20 ng/ml digoxygenin-labeled probe and incubated at 55 "C for 2 h with agitation. The membranes were rinsed twice with hybridization solution at room temperature. Two high stringency washes were performed at 55 "C using 0.2 x SSPE containing 0.1% sodium lauryl sulfate for 20 min (Sambrook et al., 1989). The membranes were rinsed twice with
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
480
antibody buffer (0.1% Tween 20,0.15 M NaC1, 0.1 M Tris, pH 7.5), blocked for 30 min with antibody buffer containing 0.5% (w/v) powdered nonfat dry milk. The solution was replaced with fresh antibody buffer containing alkaline phosphatase labeled antidigoxygenin antibodies (1 50 mU/mL) and incubated for 1 h at room temperature. The membranes were washed 3 x 10 min in antibody buffer and then rinsed twice with assay buffer (50 mM MgCI,, 0.1 M NaC1, 0.1 M Tris, pH 9.5). The membrane was then wetted with assay buffer containing 0.1 m g / d AMPPD, wrapped in plastic wrap, and exposed to X-ray film for 2 h (Bronstein et al., 1990).
111. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION PCR is very sensitive to the stability of the DNA duplex at the 3' ends of primers. This makes PCR an ideal model system to study the subtle factors that influence local denaturation at the 3' ends of primers hybridized to target templates. This requires the development of techniques that can be used to calculate the ability of This in turn requires a primer pair to amplify as a function of temperature, T,. the development of a highly reproducible amplification procedure and thermocycling conditions. The purpose of this investigation was to develop an amplification protocol that can be used as a tool for accurately and reproducibly determining the ability of primer pairs to amplify as a function of the annealing temperature. The procedure employs hypervariable extension times in combination with HAT primers, two temperature amplification cycles, master mixes and hot start to achieve low-copynumber sensitivity. Two HAT primer pairs were designed and used to develop the amplification protocol for the detection of HCMV described here. A. Primer Design
The primer pairs were chosen to amplify regions ranging in size from 200 to 500 basepairs, having a GC content ranging from 60% to 65% and a theoretical melting temperature of about 78 "C (Suggs et al., 1981). In addition, a number of other standard parameters were also checked, such as hairpin formation, 3' end homologies, GC content balancing and a general control for homologous sequences in the EMBL nucleic acid database (Williams, 1989; Rychlik et al., 1990; Lowe et al., 1990). The minimal fragment size was chosen to be 200 basepairs for two reasons. First, the analysis of fragments below this size requires the use of polyacrylamide gels or very high agarose concentrations, both of which increase the labor and expense of the analysis. Second, many primer pairs produce a detectable primer oligomer band(s) when low-copy-number amplification protocols are employed (Li et al., 1990; Chou et al., 1992). These oligomer bands are typically 50 to 100 basepairs in length. Thus, by maintaining a minimum fragment size of 200 basepairs, nonspecific primer dimer bands can easily be differentiated from specific amplifi-
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
48 1
cation products. The maximal fragment size was chosen to allow the employment of short extension times and to minimize the risk that minor degradation of the template would affect the sensitivity of the assay. The GC content of the primers was chosen to lie between 60% and 65% in order to minimize primer length. A theoretical annealing temperature of 78 "C was chosen because it was the maximal temperature at which an acceptable number of primers in the size range 22 to 26 nucleotides could be selected in the HCMV regions targeted for analysis. These constraintsprovided a way of maintaining the overall uniformity between primers, which simplified performing and analyzing their thermal amplification profiles. The use of HAT primers was considered to be of central importance for several reasons. First, increasing the annealing temperature reduces the maximal temperature differential during the amplification cycle, that in turn reduced cycling times. Second, primer pairs that are capable of amplifying at 65 "C or higher can use a two-temperature cycling scheme in that the annealing and extension steps are combined (Kim and Smithies, 1988).This combined annealing/extension step shall hereafter be referred to as the annealing step. In order to maximize the efficiency of this scheme, the annealing temperature should be as close to 75 "C as possible (the temperature at that thermostable polymerases have maximal enzymatic activity). Third, the employment of HAT primers generally improved sensitivity, increased reproducibility, and reduced nonspecific amplification products (Chou et al., 1992; Mecklenburg, 1995b). Two distinct regions of the HCMV genome were targeted (Table 1). Each region has been shown to code for mRNAs that are expressed during viral infection (Stenberg et al., 1984; Hutchinson and Tocci, 1986). Expressed regions of the HCMV genome were chosen since they are generally more genetically stable. In addition, placement of the 3' end of a primer at the third position of the tRNA recognition sequence, the wobble codon, was avoided for similar reasons. The two primer pairs, 9/5 and 13/7chosen for this studyuse an in-the-tubeannealingtemperature of 70 "C and 72 "C, respectively.
Table 1. HCMV Primer and Probe Sequences Prirner/Probe Sequence 5'-3' Name
MMC9 MMC5 probe: MMC6 MMC13 MMC7 pobe: h4MC8
AGGTTCGAGTGGACATGGTGCGGC AGCGGCGCCCTTGCTCACATCATG GGGAGGATGTTTGCAGAATGCCTTAGATATC ACAAGGCGTTGTCAAGCGTGCGGC CGCCGCAGCTGTGGCAGTTAACGT CGTGGGTGGTGCGAGAGTACACGATGGGTG
Target Primary Length(nt) Source
278
this paper
224
thispaper
482
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
In order to obtain maximal sensitivity using the amplification protocol described here, a thermal annealing temperature profile must be empirically determined for each new primer pair. This profile is constructed by performing amplifications at 5 "C intervals until the maximal annealing temperature is found. A detailed thermal profile is then performed at 2 OC intervals in the appropriate region. The optimal annealing temperature is usually chosen to be 4 "C below the temperature at which the PCR signal disappears completely. This approach greatly simplifies the process of porting amplification procedures to different environments and/or thermocyclers. New systems are calibrated simply by determining the temperature profile for a single primer pair. Once calibrated, other primer pairs then merely need be adjusted accordingly. One could envisage the development of a series of primer pairs that could be used to compare and calibrate thermocyclers over a range of temperatures. This would be ideal for calibrating portable systems and would be especially advantageous in field studies. B. Amplification Protocol Design
All low-copy-number amplification protocols must address the fact that the conditions in the reaction tube are constantly changing during the amplification. A balance must be maintained between the synthetic capacity of the system and the amount of synthesis required during any given cycle. Excess synthetic capacity will lead to the development of nonspecific amplification products, whereas insufficient synthetic capacity will result in a decrease in sensitivity. In order to determine the amount of synthetic capacity required during any given cycle, a number of factors such as the size of the fragment to be extended, the concentration of primerhemplate complex, the relative activity of the polymerase at a particular annealing temperature, the effect of thermal inactivation of the polymerase during amplification, and the length of the extension step must be taken into account. The synthetic capacity and the amount of synthesis required during a given cycle must be balanced. During the initial rounds of amplification, primers and Taq polymerase are in excess, while only a few copies of target DNA are present. The combination of excess synthetic capacity and primers drastically increases the chance that nonspecific primer oligomers and/or other nonspecific amplification products will form. Once formed, these eficiently amplified products compete with the target fragment for primers and enzyme. In low-copy-number reactions the formation of primer oligomers is the single most important factor affecting low-copy-number amplification reactions (Li et al., 1990; Mullis, 1991; Chou et al., 1992). Primer oligomer formation must be suppressed until a critical concentration of the target sequence has been reached. Low-copy-number amplification protocols must incorporate a mechanism that maintains maximal sensitivity while minimizing the risk for primer oligomer forination. This requires adjusting the synthetic capacity of the reaction mixture during amplification.
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
483
A number of approaches have been developed to resolve this problem such as multiple additions of Taq polymerase (Powell et al., 1987; Kim and Smithies, 1988), booster PCR (Ruano et al., 1989), reamplification (Higuchi et al., 1988; Li et al., 1990), nested PCR (Mullis and Faloona, 1987; Haqqi et al., 1988; Kemp et al., 1989; Albert and Fenyo, 1990) and heminested PCR (Li et al., 1990; Witsell et al., 1990). These approaches involve either the addition of components during the amplification reaction or performing a second amplification reaction. This increases the labor involved as well as the overall complexity of the amplification procedure. In addition, the manipulation of amplified material may in some cases increase the risk of carryover contamination. The amplification procedure described in this paper employs hypervariable extension times in order to address this problem. The protocol modulates the synthetic capacity by varying the extension time. This provides a noninvasive, programmable protocol that is simple to implement and modify. While other amplification protocols have employed variable extension times (Demmler et al., 1988; Bradbury et al., 1990), none have consequently employed hypervariable extension times in the way described here. In order for this scheme to achieve maximal effect, the largest possible annealing time differential must be employed. This requires determining the smallest time interval necessary to achieve a stable in-the-tube temperature at every position in the thermocycler using standard cycling temperatures. External thermocouple devices were employed to empirically determine this value. The minimal time was determined to be 8 s (+/- 1 "C). In order to ensure a high degree of reproducibility the minimum time was chosen to be 15 s. The thermocycler was set to start counting the time when the in-the-tube temperature was within 1 O C of the set temperature. The importance of testing across-the-block temperature variation cannot be overstated (Resendez-Perez and Barrera-Saldana, 1990). Over 100 different time extension protocols were tested with a number of different HAT primer pairs (two of which are described in this paper). The scheme that resulted in the most consistent
Table 2. Amplification Cycling Scheme # of Cycles
1
Time (s)
T (''c)
300
95
HOLD at 70 "C, add Taq polymerase 25 30 5
15 15 15 60 15 420
92 70172 92 70172 92 70172
484
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
amplification of low-copy-numbersamples is shown in Table 2. The annealing time was varied from 15 to 420 s. Primer oligomer formation during the addition of polymerase has been shown to markedly influence the sensitivity and reproducibility of low-copy-number amplification procedures (Li et al., 1990; Mullis, 1991; Chou et al., 1992). In order to achieve low-copy-number sensitivity and a high degree of reproducibility, it is absolutely necessary to use some sort of hot start procedure. The protocol described here employs a manual hot start procedure that involves inserting a hold step at 70 "C after the denaturation step. It is during this hold step that polymerase is added to each tube. It is important that the tubes remain physically seated in the thermocycler block during this procedure. When this procedure is employed with primers, that have annealing temperatures of at least 70 "C, primer oligomer formation that interferes with the amplification of the specific band has not been detected. The use of HAT primers also increases the overall efficiency of the protocol by allowing the incorporation of a combined annealing/extension step. This not only decreases the cycling time but also increases the eaciency of the amplification procedure. This is due to the fact that a three temperature cycle requiring primers (primers with annealing temperatures below 65 "C) must be extended at least partially if they are to remain bound when the temperature is increased to the extension step. In the initial cycles, when the polymerase saturates the primerhemplate complexes all the annealed primers are easily extended (adequately to make them stable during the extension step), even though polymerase has significantly lower activity. However, as the polymerase concentration gradually becomes limiting, the efficiency of the amplification gradually decreases because the number of annealed primers that are not extended sufficiently to make them stable at the extensionstep increases.This effectbecomeseven more pronouncedat lower annealing temperatures since polymerase activity is strongly temperature dependent. High combined annealinglextensiontemperature increases the overall efficiency of the amplification procedure since the primerhemplate complexesremain available for extension during a longer period of time. Moreover, the procedure makes very efficient use of enzymeby graduallyincreasingthe extensiontimes in order to fulfillthe ever increasing demands the system places upon the synthetic machinery. C. Detection of HCMV
A general amplification procedure has been developed based upon using master mixes and the amplification protocol described above. The sensitivity, specificity, and reproducibility of two primer pairs targeted against HCMV were analyzed (Figure IA). The 60 cycle amplification procedure took 3.5 h to complete and gave good yields of product of the expected size. Both primer pairs had low-copy-number sensitivity (Figure lA, lanes 2, 8). On occasion, the intensity of the PCR fragment band can decrease slightly in samples containing 1000 copies or more (see Figure 1, lane 10). The drop-out rate for these primers was tested using samples
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
485
Figure 1. (A) An ethidium stained agarose gel showing the DNA products obtained after amplification of HCMV with MMC9/MMC5 (lanes 1-6) and MMCl3/MMC7 (lanes 7-12). No DNA control (lanes 1, 7), 10 copies HCMV (lanes 2, 8), 100 copies HCMV (lanes 3, 9), 1000 copies HCMV (lanes 4, 1O), 1 pg Human DNA (lanes 5 , 11), and 10 copies HCMV + 1 pg Human DNA (lanes 6,12). After blotting the membrane was divided. (6)The MMC9/MMC5 amplificate was probed with MMC6 and (C) the MMCl3/MMC7 amplificate was probed with MMC8 as described in Materials and Methods.
that contained 10 and 1000 copies. No dropouts were detected in the 100 samples that were run at each target concentration (data not shown). In this system primer oligomer bands were always detected in controls that contained no target DNA. The presence of this band was used as a functional control for the master mixes and the polymerase. The presence of nonspecific human DNA did not affect the sensitivityor the specificityofthe amplificationprocedure (Figure 1A, lanes 6,12).
486
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURC
No amplification products were detected in the presence of human DNA sequences (Figure 1A, lanes 5, 11). Both the Taq and Replitherm polymerases gave equivalent results when used as described in Material and Methods. It is important to note that when a homemade lox buffer was substituted for the Epicenter lox buffer, the concentration of enzyme had to be increased from 0.12 to 0.24 Ui50 p1 in order to obtain equivalent results. At present, no explanation for this can be given. When purified template was employed, low-copy-number sensitivity was obtained using a 45-cycle procedure. In this procedure only ten 15 s-cycles were used. However, the 60-cycle procedure was shown to give more consistent results when amplifying clinical material (Mecklenburg, 1995b). In order to ensure that the amplification products were authentic, Southern analysis was carried out (Figures 1B and C). After blotting the gel, the membrane was cut into two pieces and probed with the appropriate digoxygenin-labeled ODN (see Table 1). The results confirm that the amplification products from both primer pairs were authentic. No spurious bands were detected. A detailed analysis of the effect of annealing temperature on PCR dependency of these primers will be published elsewhere (Mecklenburg, 1995b).
IV. CONCLUSIONS PCR is very sensitive to the stability at the 3' ends of primers. This makes PCR an ideal model system to study the subtle factors that influence local denaturation at the 3' ends ofprimers hybridized to target templates. This requires the development of techniques that can be used to calculate the ability of a primer pair to amplify as a function of temperature, TPCR.This in turn requires the development of a highly reproducible amplification procedure and thermocycling conditions. The protocol described here provides such a tool. Thus, the purpose of this investigation was to develop a highly reproducible amplification protocol as a tool to probe the stability at the 3' ends of DNA duplexes. The procedure employs hypervariable extension times in combination with HAT primers, two temperature amplification cycles, master mixes, and hot start to achieve low-copy-number sensitivity. Hypervariable extension times provide a simple, versatile approach for dynamically modifying the reaction environment. In addition, this noninvasive approach is simple to implement. HAT PCR primers have the added advantage of reducing cycling times and, in general, eliminate nonspecific amplification bands even in the presence of excess nonspecific DNA. In addition, the increase in amplification efficiency that results from employing this protocol reduces the amount of thermostable polymerase required in the amplification procedure. The HCMV was chosen as the model system in these studies because detection of the virus using PCR is of clinical interest. Two HAT primer pairs were designed and used to develop the amplification protocol for the detection of HCMV described
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
487
here. The primer pairs described here were shown to have low-copy-number sensitivityand to be specific for HCMV. No spurious bands, other than primer dimer bands, were detected even in the presence of a vast excess of human genomic DNA. A highly reproducible PCR amplification protocol has been developed with low-copy-number sensitivity. In order to obtain optimal sensitivity, a thermal annealing temperature analysis must be performed for each new primer pair. In addition to increasing the sensitivity of the assay, this approach greatly simplifies the process of porting amplification procedures to different environments andor thermocyclers.The new system is calibratedsimply by determining the temperature profile for a single primer pair. The other primer pairs then merely need be adjusted accordingly. One could envisage the development of a series of primer pairs that could be used to calibrate thermocyclers, an amplification based thermometer. This would provide a built-in system for the calibration of portable systems that would be especiallyadvantageous in field studies. Moreover, this design strategy enhances the reproducibility and the portability of the amplification protocol. The development of a nearest neighbor analysis employing a measurement parameter sensitive to the stability of the terminal 3’ nucleotides in DNA duplexes would provide a very useful tool for studying DNA duplex stability. This would compliment more standard nearest neighbor analyses and provide a more accurate picture of local DNA duplex stability. Results from these studies would be of great interest to those working with other nucleic acid based amplification procedures, large scale sequencing projects, as well as those involved in studying replication and repair mechanisms.
REFERENCES Albert, J. & Fenyo, E.M. (1990). Simple, sensitive, and specific detection of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 in clinical specimens by polymerase chain reaction with nested primers. J. Clin. Microbiol. 28, 15661564. Amheim, N. & Erlich, H. (1992). Polymerase chain-reaction strategy. Ann. Rev. Biochem. 61, 131-156. Barany, F. (1991). Genetic disease detection and DNA amplification using cloned thermostable ligase. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88, 18s-193. Boehringer Mannheim (1989). Dig DNA labeling and detection nonradioactive: applications manual. Biochemica, Beohringer Mannbein, Germany. Bradbury, M.W., isola, L.M., & Gondon. J.W. (1990). Enzymatic amplification of a Y chromosome repeat in a single blastomere allows identification of the sex preimplantation mouse embryos. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 87,4053-4057. Breslauer, K.J., Frank, R., Blocker, H.. & Marky, L.A. (1986). Predicting DNA duplex stability from the base sequence. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83,37463750. Bronstein, I., Voyta, J.C., Lazzari, K.G., Murphy, O., Edwards, B., & Kricka, L.J. (1990). Rapid and sensitive detection ofDNAin Southern blots with chemiluminescence. Biotechniques 8,3 10-3 14. Bush, C.E., Donovan, R.M., Peterson, W.R., Jennings, M.B., Bolton, V, Sherman, D.G., Vnader-Brink, K.M., Beninsig, L.A., & Godsey, J.H. (1992). Detection of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA in plasma samples from high-risk pediatric patients by using self-sustaining sequence replication reaction. J. Clin. Microbiol. 30, 28 1-286.
488
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
Carpenter, W.R., Schutzbank, T.E., Tevere, V.J., Tocyloski,K.R., Dattagupta, N. andYeung,K.K. (1993). A transcriptionally amplified DNA probe assay with ligatable probes and immunochemical detection. Clin. Chem. 39, 193&1938. Chou, Q., Russel, M., Birch, D.E., Raymond, J., &Bloch. W. (1992). Preventionofpre-PCRmis-priming and primer dimerization improves low-copy-number amplifications. Nucleic Acids Res. 20, 1717-1723. DeMarchi, J.M. & Kaplan, S.A. (1976). Replication of human cytomegalovims DNA: lack ofdependence on cell DNA synthesis.J. Virol. 18, 10631070. DeMarchi, J.M. (1981). Human cytomegalovims DNA: restriction enzyme cleavage maps and map locations for immediate-early, early, and late RNAs. Virology 114,2>38. Demmler, G.J., Buffone, G.J., Schimbor. C.M., & May, R.A. (1988). Detection of cytomegalovirusin urine from newborns by using polymerse chain reaction DNA amplification.J. Infect. Dis. 158, 1177-1 184. Devlin, R., Sfudhohe, R.M., Dandliker, W.B., Fahy, E., Blumeyer, K., & Ghosh, S.S. (1993). Homogeneous detection of nucleic acids by transient-state polarized fluorescence. Clin. Chem. 39, 193el943. Duck, P., Alvarado-Urbina, G., Burdick. B., & Collier, B. (1990). Probe amplifier system based on chimeric cycling oligonucleotides. Biotechniques 9, 142-1 49. Femandes, J.J. & Cofhan, N.B. (1992). DNA technology. J. Am. Osteopath. Assoc. 92,777-783. Freier, S.M., Keirzek, R., Jaeger, J.A., Sugimoto, N., Caruthers, M.H., Neilsen, T., & Turner, D.H. (1986). Improved free-energy parameters for predicts of RNA duplex stability. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (USA). Gingeras, T.R., Prodanovich, P., Latimer, T., Guatelli, J.C., Richman, D.D., & Barringer, K.J. (1991). Use of self-sustained replication amplification reaction to analyze and detect mutations in zidovudine-resistant human immunodeficiency virus. J. Infect. Dis. 164, 1066-1074. Guatelli, J.C., Whitfield, K.M., Kwok, D.Y., Barringer, K.J., Richman, D.D., & Gingeras, T.R. (1990). Isothermal, in vitro amplification of nucleic acids by a multienzyme reaction modeled after retroviral replication. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 87, 1874-1878. Haqqi, T.M., Sarkar, G., David, C.S., & Sommer, S.S. (1988). Specific amplification with PCR of a refractoly segment of genomic DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 24, 11844-1 1844. Higuchi, R., von Beroldingen, C.H., Sensabaugh, G.F., & Erlich, H.A. (1988). DNA typing from single hairs. Nature 332,543-546. Hillier, L. & Green, P. (1992). OSP: a computer program for choosing PCR and DNA sequencing primers. PCR Methods Appl. 1, 124-128. Hutchinson, N.I. & Tocci, M.J. (1986). Characterization of a major early gene form the human cytomegaloviruslong inverted repeat; predicted amino acid sequenceof a 30-kDa protein encoded by the 1.2-kb mRNA. Virology 155, 172-182. Innis, M.A., Gelfand, D.H., Sninsky, J.J., &White, T.J. (1990). PCR Protocols In: AGuide to Methods and Applications. Academic Press, New York. Ishikawa, E., Hashida, S., Kohno, T.. & Hirota, K. (1990). Ultrasensitive enzyme immunoassay. Clin. Chim. Acta 194,51-72. Kalin, I., Shepard, S., & Candrian, U. (1992). Evaluation of the ligase chain reaction (LCR) for the detection of point mutations. Mutat. Res. 283, 11%123. Kemp, D.J., Smith, D.B., Foote, S.J., Samaras, N., & Peterson, M.G. (1989). Colorimetricdetection of specific DNA segments amplified by polymerase chain reaction. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 242S2427. Kessler, C. (1993). Nonradioactive Labeling and Detection of Biomolecules. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Khandjian, E.W. (1987). Optimizedhybridization of DNA blotted and fixed to nitrocelluloseand nylon membranes. BioiTechnology 5, 165-169. Kim, H.S. & Smithies, 0. (1988). Recombinant fragment assay for gene targeting based on the polyemase chain reaction. Nucleic Acids Res. 16,211-216.
Design and Use of HAT PCR Primers
489
Kricka, L. (1992). Nonisotopic DNA Probe Techniques. Academic Press, New York. Kwok, D.Y., Davis, G.R., Whitfield, K.M., Chappelle, H.L., DiMichelle, L.J., & Gingeras, T.R. (1989). Transcription-based amplification system and detection of amplified human immunodeficiency virus type I with a bead-based sandwich hybridization format. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 1173-1177.
Lew, A.M., Brandon, R.B., Panaccio, M., & Morrow, C.J. (1992). The polymerase chain reaction and other amplification techniques in immunological research and diagnosis. Immnology 75,3-9. Li, H., Cui, X., & Arnheim, N. (1990). Direct electrophoretic detection of theallelic state of single DNA molecules in human sperm by using the polymerase chain reaction. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 87,4580-4584.
Lowe, T., Sharefkin, J., Yang, S.Q., & Dieffenbach, C.W. (1990). A computer program for selection of oligonucleotide primers for polymerase chain reactions. Nucleic Acids Res. 18, 1757-1 761. Lucas, K., Busch, M., Mossinger, S., & Thompson, J.A. (1991). An improved microcomputer program for finding gene- or gene family-specific oligonucleotides suitable as primers for polymerase chain reaction or as probes. Comput. Appl. Biosci. 7, 525-529. Mecklenburg, M. (1995a). Application of PCR as a reporter system. In: Preparation, Analyses, and Applications of Synthetic Oligonucleotides: A Laboratory Manual (Guameros, G., De LaVega, EM., Eds.), in press, Springer Verlag, Berlin. Mecklenburg, M. (1995b). Manuscript in preparation. Montpetit, M.L.. Cassol, S., Salas, T.,& O’Shaughnessey, M.V. (1992). OLIGOSCAN: a computer program to assist in the design of PCR primers homologous to multiple DNA sequences. J. Virol. Methods 36, 119-128. Mullis, K.B. & Faloona, F. (1987). Specific synthesis of DNA in vitro via a polymerase-catalyzed chain reaction. Meth. Enzymol. 155, 335-350. Pillay, D. & Griffiths, D.P. (1992). Diagnosis of cytomegalovirus infection: a review. Genitourin Med. 68, 183-188.
Powell, L.M., Wallis, S.C., Pease, R.J., Edwards, Y.H., Knott, T.J., & Scott, J. (1987). Anovel form of tissue-specific RNA processing produces apolipoprotein-B48 in intestine. Cell 50,83 1-840. Rapley, R., Theophilus, B.D.M., Bevan, 1,s..&Walker, M.R. (1992). Fundamentalsofpolymerase chain reactiofuture in clinical diagnostics. Med. Lab. Sci. 49, 119-128. Resendez-Perez, D., & Barrera-Saldana, H.A. (1990). Thermocylcer temperature variation invalidates PCR results. Biotechniques 9,286-294. Rolfs, A,, Schuller, I., Finckh, U., & Weber-Rolfs, I. (1993). PCR Clinical Diagnostics and Research. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany. Ruano, G., Fenton, W., & Kidd, K.K. (1989). Biphasic amplification of very dilute DNA samples via ‘Booster’ PCR. Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 5407-5416. Rychlik, W. & Rhoads, R.E. (1989). A computer program for choosing optimal oligonucleotides for filter hybridization, sequencing and in vim amplification of DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 8543-855 1 .
Saiki, R.K., Scarf, S., Faloona, K.B., Mullis, K.B., Horn, G.T., Erlich, H.A., & Amhein, N. (1985). Enzymatic amplification of beta-globin genomic sequences and restriction site analyses for diagnosis of sickle cell anemia. Science 230, 1350-1354. Rychlik, W., Spencer, W.J., & Rhoads, R.E. (1990). Optimization ofthe annealing temperature for DNA amplification in vitro. Nucleic Acids Res. 18,6409-6412. Sambrook, J., Fritsch, E.F., & Maniatis, T. (1989). Molecular Cloning: A Laboratory Manual, 2nd edition. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, New York. Sano, T., Smith, C.L., & Cantor, C.R. (1992). Immuno-PCR: very sensitive antigen detection by means of specific antibody-DNA conjugates. Science 258, 12C122. Segev, D. (1993). Amplification of nucleic acid sequences by the repair chain reaction. In: Nonradioactive Labeling and Detection of Biomolecules (Kricka, C., Ed.), Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
490
MICHAEL W. MECKLENBURG
Stagno, S., Pass, R.F., Dworsky, M.E., Henderson, R.E., Moore, E.G., Walton, P.D., & Alford, C.A.
(1982). Congenital cytomegalovirus infection: the relative importance of primary and recurrent maternal infections. N. Engl. J. Med. 306,945-949. Stenberg, R.M., Thomsen, D.R., & Stinski, M.F. (1984). Structural analyses of the major immediate early gene of human cytomegalovirus. J. Virol. 49, 190-199. Stinski, M.F. (1978). Sequence of protein synthesis in cells infected by human cytomegalovirus: early and late virus-induced polypeptides. J. Virol. 26,686701. Stinski, M.F., Mocarski, E.S., Thomsen, D.R. (1979). DNA of human cytomegalovirus: size heterogeneity and defectiveness resulting fiom serial undiluted passage. J. Virol. 3 1.23 1-239. Suggs, S.V., Hirose, T., Miyake, T., Kawashima, E.H., Johnson, M.J., Itakura, K., & Wallace, R.B. (1981). Use of synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotides for the isolation of specific cloned DNA sequences. In: Developmental Biology Using Purified Genes (Brown, D.D. Fox, C.F., Eds), pp. 683-693. Academic Press, New York. The, T.H., van der Ploeg, M., vander Berg, A.P.. Vlieger, A.M., van der Giessen, M., & van Son, W.J. (1992). Direct detection of cytomegalovirus in peripheral blood leukocytesa review of the antigenemia assay and polymerase chain reaction. Transplantation 54, 193-1 98. Walker, G.T., Little, M.C., Nadeau, J.G.. & Shank, D.D. (1992). Isothermal in vitro amplification of DNA by a restriction enzymeiDNA polymerase system. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89,392-396. Ward, E.S., Gussow, D., Griffiths, A.D., JonesP.T., & Winter, G. (1989). Bindingactivitiesofarepertoire of single immunoglobulin variable domains secreted fiom Escherichia coli [see comments]. Nature 341,54&546. Wetmur, J.G. (1991). DNA probes: application of the principles of nucleic acid hybridization. Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol. 26,227-259. Williams, J.F. ( 1989). Optimization strategies for the polymerase chain reaction. BioTechniques 7, 762-768. Witsell, A.L. & Schook, L.B. (1990). Clonal analyses of gene expression by PCR. BioTechniques 9, 318-322. Wu, D.Y. & Wallace, R.B. (1989). The ligation amplification reaction (LAR)-amplification ofspecific sequences using sequential rounds of template-dependent ligation. Genomics 4,560-569.
ON-LINE MONITORING OF INDUSTRIAL FERMENTATIONS USING A SPLIT-FLOW MODIFIED THERMAL BIOSENSOR
M. Rank and B. Danielsson
I. 11. 111. IV.
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 491 INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 492 INSTRUMENTS AND SAMPLING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 493 ANALYSIS AND ENZYME COLUMNS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 493 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 495
ABSTRACT A biosensor was modified in several ways in order to adapt it for use in industrial scale automated broth culture monitoring. All instrumentation was assembled inside a steel cabinet and controlled by a PC situated at a safe distance from the fermentors. Penicillin V, glucose, and ethanol were monitored on-line in 0.5 and 2.5 m3 bioreactors
Advances in Molecuiar and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 491497. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN0-7623-0114-7
49 1
492
M. RANK and B. DANIELSSON
using an enzyme thermistor modified for split-flow analysis. Penicillin V and L-lactate were also monitored in 160 m3bioreactors. The work was performed at Novo Nordisk A/S in the fermentation pilot plant in Bagsvaerd or in the production plant in Kalundborg, Denmark. The injected samples were split into two equal streams immediately before simultaneously entering the enzyme column and the identical reference column (with immobilized BSA instead of enzyme). This results in a temperature response (6T) without the nonspecific heat arising from mixing and solvation effects from the fermentation broth. Only the enzymatic hydrolysis is reflected in the 6T, and all calculated values correlated very well with off-line HPLC determinations. Instead of the previously used j3-lactamase, three penicillin productions in 160 m3 bioreactors were monitored on-line using penicillin V acylase. This enzyme was purified from a broth supernatant. The L-lactate concentration was monitored from the start in another Penicillum fermentation. Glucose was monitored from start in a Saccharomyces fermentation and after five hours the analysis was switched to ethanol monitoring.
I. INTRODUCTION An elegant combination of theory and craftsmanship some 20 years ago resulted in
the birth of the enzyme thermistor (Mosbach and Danielsson, 1974).The instrument described in this paper is the outcome of several years of improvement and fine tuning. The enzyme thermistor, a calorimetric biosensor, has to date been employed in 50 different applications in the fields of biochemistry and biotechnology (Danielsson, 1990). Since almost all enzymatic reactions are exothermic, the only limitation is the availability of a purified and fairly cheap enzyme specific for the substrate of interest (Danielsson and Mosbach, 1986).Abiosensor that can measure fermentation broth metabolites in combination with an automated and computerized flow injection analysis would prove a very valuable tool for the industry (Brooks et al., 1991). The use of the split-flow technique is a convenient method for subtracting the nonspecific heat that is associated with complex samples such as fermentation broths (Mattiasson et al., 1976).A trouble-free sampling device is necessary if a whole fermentation is to be monitored without fouling or changes due to altered broth viscosity (Mattiasson et al., 1981). Due to the duration of an average fermentation, only a fully automatic computerized system can handle the amount of data and control the fully automatic FIA analysis. Rather than adapt the instruments to 100% humidity, vibrations and temperature variations between 10 and 35 "C that may be encountered in the fermentor hall, the cool dry environment of a separate cabinet is used to provide a more practical and cheaper solution. Novo Nordisk A/S is an international pharmaceutical company whose major production is based on fermentation. On-line monitoring of new microorganisms and of expensive large-scale productions have never been more important, especially with the rapid development of new products through recombinant gene technology. Knowledge of the concentrations of substrates, products, inhibitors,
On-line Monitoring of Industrial Fermentations
493
and other metabolites is of vital importance to carefully control industrial fermentations. The model system of choice for the on-line monitoring is based on the easy access to Penicillum fermentation projects at Novo Nordisk.
II. INSTRUMENTS A N D SAMPLING At first, on-line sampling was performed by using a monopump to pump broth through an external loop connected to a modified tangential flow filtrationunit from Millipore (Gram et al., 1990). On-line sampling of the fermentation broth was later performed with a hydrophilized polypropylene filtration probe from Advanced Biotechnology Corporation (Puchheim Germany). The filtrating part of the ABC probe was inserted through the bioreactor wall using a fitting normally employed in pH- electrodes. About 1 to 3 ml/min of a clear 0.2 pm filtered sample was continuously aspirated to the outside of the bioreactor using a peristaltic pump. The sample stream was then led to the analyzing FIA-system placed inside a steel cabinet flushed with cool dry air (see Figure 1). A split-flow bottom plate was constructed and installed at the bottom of the calorimeter in order to split the buffer stream immediatelybefore entering the two columns. The initial experimentsin the pilot plant were recorded with an integrator inside the cabinet. Later, the signals from the amplifier were transferred to a Datalogger. All information was then transferred via a local modem connection to a software program from Labtech Notebook, Wilmington,USA, installed in a PC located 60 m away in a control room.
111. ANALYSIS A N D ENZYME COLUMNS The eluting phosphate buffer contained 2 mM azide to prevent microbial contamination. The azide was exchanged with benzoic acid when columns with catalase were used. In order to prevent nucleophilic breakdown ofpenicillin V in phosphate buffer, all standards were made in 10-times diluted phosphate buffer that was kept cold in an insulated box filled with ice (Bundgaard and Hansen, 1981). The enzyme matrix was controlled pore glass and all enzyme immobilizations were performed on glutaraldehyde-activated silanized glass beads (Weetall, 1976). All enzymes were dialyzed before coupling. In earlier studies, penicillin V was monitored with immobilized p-lactamase. The reference column was made in an identical way except bovine serum albumin instead of enzyme was bound. Later, penicillin V determinations utilized a purified Penicillin V acylase. This enzyme was purified from a broth supernatant supplied by Novo Nordisk A / S (Hussey et al., 1983). The enzyme activity was determined spectrophotometrically by measuring the amount of 6-APA formed using p-dimethyl aminobenzaldehyde as the color reagent. The assay was a (6-aminopenicillanicacid) modified procedure (Balasingham et al., 1972). On-line enzyme thermistor values from penicillin fermentations were compared with manually withdrawn samples analyzed by off-line HPLC. The broth concen-
M. RANK and B. DANIELSSON
494
&
STANDARDS TWO
WASH SOLUTION
ELUENT
('I
Figure 7. Schematic representation of the set-up. A continuous sample stream was aspirated from the bioreactor using a filtration probe and a peristaltic pump. The filtered broth sample was pumped into a six-position pneumatic sample selector. The same multichannel peristaltic pump also aspirated the carrier buffer through the sample valve and further into the thermostated calorimeter with the two columns. The split-flow system divides the sample immediately before it enters the enzyme column and the inactive reference column. The signals were recorded with an amplifier and an interface enabled computer monitoring. The whole analysis was followed and controlled from the PC. Samples were injected every 10 min in the order: low concentration standard, broth sample, and high concentration standard. The broth concentrations were calculated by linear regression from an average of the three latest values of each standard (From Rank et al., 1992).
On-line Monitoring of Industrial Fermentations
495
trations of penicillin V, penicilloic acid, p-hydroxy penicillin V, and 6-APA were determined. The assay was performed at the analytical laboratories of Novo Nordisk A/S using a modified method (Hussey et al., 1983). Glucose was monitored by glucose oxidase from Aspergihs niger coimmobilized with 40,000 units of catalase from bovine liver. Ethanol was monitored with alcohol oxidase from Pichiapastoris. For comparison broth samples were analyzed by gas chromatography at Novo Nordisk NS. Lactate was monitored with lactate oxidase from Pediococcus sp. Once every day on-line samples were also analyzed using a UV method kit from Boehringer Mannheim Biochemica.
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION So far, eight complete fermentations have been monitored on-line. The first tests at the University of Lund proved valuable for the development of a working instrument, but the important information concerning enzyme specificity and reproducibility was obtained later in the fermentor hall. The ABC-sampling probe provides a clear microfiltrate throughout the fermentations with PenicilIum or Sacharomyces. The delay from sample withdrawal to the registered peak was determined to be five minutes. In the first three fermentation experiments, filtered samples were collected on-line with a modified tangential flow filtration unit from Millipore together with a monopump. Immobilized p-lactamase was then used as the detecting biocatalyst. The linear range for on-line monitoring of penicillin V with p-lactamase was 0.1 to 500 mM with sample volumes of 20 to 500 pl. The concentration of the two p-lactam substrates penicillin and p-hydroxypenicillin V were determined by HPLC. When the two values were added and plotted against the on-line biosensor values, a deviation of 10% was observed (Rank et al., 1992). It was later discovered that the sample pump had a grinding effect on the fungi mycelia and intracellular j3-lactams such as 6-APA were released into the broth. This may explain the 10% higher values. Penicillin V acylase, however, hydrolyzed the side chain of penicillin, which is a four times less exothermic reaction than that of P-lactamase. Penicillin V acylase was purified and immobilized before use for on-line monitoring of penicillin production in a 160 m3 bioreactor. The linear range was 0.5 to 150 mM using sample volumes between 20 and 500 pl. The sum of the concentrations of the three side chain penicillin V acylase substrates in the fermentation broth, penicillin V, penicilloic acid, and p-hydroxy penicillin V, were determined by off-line HPLC, and when compared with the on-line biosensor values they correlated very well. Glucose was monitored from the start in a Saccharomyces cerevisae fermentation. After seven hours the column was exchanged and ethanol was monitored. The time from the exchange of columns and standards to the first on-line ethanol value was 60 minutes (Rank, 1993). Early experiments with alcohol oxidase (Pichia pastoris) revealed a slightly higher exothermic response for methanol and a poor
M. RANK and B. DANIELSSON
496 100
0 90 80
JO 60 !>I2 40 30
20 10
I
20
0
40
bO
80
I00
rci I,me
Ll
oriiiiic
CT
+
0550"
(Unchruiqcr)
figure 2. On-line monitoring of L-lactate during penicillin production in a 160 m3 bioreactor using an enzyme column with lactate oxidase coimmobilized with catalase. Values from fermentation broth samples were calculated every 30 min and samples were collected manually and analyzed using a spectrophotometric assay kit. The accuracy of the kit assay is not satisfactory and is only used as an indication. The lactate concentration slowly declines until midway into the fermentation when it falls below 0.1 5 mM and can no longer be measured with a minimal error constant.
affinity for I-butanol (Danielsson, 1991). A broad substrate specificity was experienced with other alcohol oxidases and this has to be considered when searching for the most suitable enzyme. Results using an alcohol oxidase from Candida boidinii (Boehringer Mannheim) showed that ethanol instead of methanol is the best substrate for this enzyme (Guilbaultet al., 1983).L-lactate was monitored from start in a Penicillurn fermentation. The lactate slowly declined until halfway into the fermentation when the concentration fell below 0.15 mM and could no longer be monitored (see Figure 2). The limitations of this system are mainly the insufficient availabilityof pure and specific enzymes. Although many enzymes involved in the important citric acid cycle and amino acid synthesis pathways are available, they are very expensive.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This project was supported by a grant from the Nordic program on bioprocess engineering under the auspices of NI (The Nordic Fund for Technology and Industrial Development).
On-line Monitoring of Industrial Fermentations
497
The authors especially thank Michael O’Reilly of Novo Nordisk and Birgitta Rees-Jonsson of the Biosensor Group for their help and cooperation.
REFERENCES Balasingham, K., Warburton. D., Dunnill, P., & Lilly, D.M. (1972). The isolation and kinetics of penicillin amidase from E. coli. Biochem. Biophys. Acta 276,25&256 Brooks, S.L., Higgins, I.J., Newman, J.D., & Turner, A.P.F. (1991). Biosensors for process control. Enzyme. Microb. Technol. 13,946955. Bundgaard, H. & Hansen, J. (I98 I). Nucleophilic phosphate-catalyzed degradation of penicillins: demonstration of a penicilloyl phosphate intermediate and transformation of ampicillin to a piperazinedione Int. J. Pharm. 9,27>283. Danielsson, B. (1990). Calorimetric biosensors. J. Biotech. 15, 187-200. Danielsson, B. (I99 I). Enzyme thermistor devices. In: Biosensors Principles and Applications (Blum. L.J. & Coulet, P.R., Eds.), pp. 83105. Marcel Dekker Inc., New York. Danielsson, B. & Mosbach, M. (1986). Theory and applications of calorimetric sensors. In: Biosensors: Fundamentals and Applications (Turner, A.P.F.. Karube, I., & Wilson, G.S., Eds.), pp. 575595 Oxford University Press, Oxford. Decristoforo, G. & Danielsson, B. (1984). Flow injection analysis with enzyme thermistor detector for automated determination of p-lactams. Anal. Chem. 56,263268. Gram, J., Nikolajsen, K., Holm, K., & De Bang, M. (1990). Automated sampling and glucose analysis for a pilot-plant penicillin V production. Abstract presentation ECB 5, p. 3 11 Copenhagen. Guilbault, G.G., Danielsson, B., Mandenius, C.-F., & Mosbach, K. (1983). A comparison of enzyme electrode and thermistor probes for assay of alcohols using alcohol oxidase. Anal. Chem. 55, 1582-1 585. Hussey, R.L., Mascher, W.G., & L a g , A.L. (1983). Determination of p-hydroxy penicillin V p-hydroxyphenoxy acetic acid, phenoxyacetic acid and penicillin V in production fermentation broth. J. Chrom. 268, 12&124. Mattiasson B., Danielsson. B., & Mosbach, K. (1976). A split-flow enzyme thermistor. Anal. Lett. 9. 8674389. Mattiasson, B., Danielson. B., Winquist, F., Nilsson, H., & Mosbach, K. (1981). Enzyme thermistor analysis of penicillin G in standard solutions and in fermentation broth. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 41,90>908. Mosbach, K. & Danielsson, B. (1974). An enzyme thermistor. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 364, 140-145. Rank, M., Gram, J., & Danielsson, B. (1992). Implementation of a thermal biosensor in a process environment: on-line monitoring of penicillin V in production-scale fermentations. Biosens. Bioelectr. 7, 9, !A. Rank, M., Gram, J., & Danielsson, B. (1993). Industrial on-line monitoring ofpenicillin V, glucose and ethanol using a split-flow modified thermal biosensor. Anal. Chim. Acta 281,521-526. Weetall, H.H. (1976). Covalent coupling methods for inorganic support materials. Meth. Enzymol. (Mosbach, K., Ed.), vol. 44, 134-148. Academic Press, New York.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
MINIATURlZE D THERMAL BIOSENSORS
U. Hedberg, B. Xie, and B. Danielsson
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONSTRUCTION 1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONSTRUCTION 2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONSTRUCTION 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I. 11. 111. IV.
499 500 500 501 503 505
ABSTRACT A summary of our efforts to develop miniaturized biosensors based on the enzyme thermistor is presented. T h e e constructions are described. The work focuses on the measurement of glucose in whole blood. The first biosensor was used to analyze concentrated and tenfold diluted blood samples. The glucose concentration obtained using this construction correlated well with the reference method.
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 499-505. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
499
500
U. HEDBERG, B. XI€, and B. DANIELSSON
Using the second biosensor, the response time could be reduced from 3 minutes down to 30 seconds using a sample volume of 1 pl. The relative standard deviation for 100 blood samples (3.8 mM) was 3.7%. Micromachining technology was used to construct the third thermal biosensor on a silicon chip. Enzymes were immobilized directly onto the 30 parallel flow channels. Injection of 200 samples containing 10 mM hydrogen peroxide gave a relative standard deviation of 3%.
1. INTRODUCTION The enzyme thermistor is a thermometric biosensor that has been developed in our department. This biosensor detects the heat evolved during enzyme catalysis. The instrument has been used for many applications over the years (Danielsson, 1990; Rank, 1992). We have now made several miniaturized enzyme thermistor constructions. Miniaturization allows these sensors to be used in portable instrumentation for applications such as measurement of various metabolites in body fluids. Here we describe our attempts at developing a miniaturized instrument. Blood glucose determinations using two miniaturized constructions are described. An account of the technique of micromachining to construct a thermal biosensor on a small silicon chip is also described here.
II. CONSTRUCTION 1 This device is 54 mm long and 24 mm in diameter. The fluid temperature is equilibrated when the buffer solution passes through the steel tubing wound inside an aluminum cylinder surrounding the column (Figure 1).After passing the column,
Adiabatic shield Enzyme column
\
Parallel coil
Figure 7. Schematic figure of construction 1.
Miniaturized Thermal Biosensors
501
Table 1. Blood Glucose Concentrations (Means of 10 Determinations) Measured with Construction 1 and with the Boehringer Reflolux Instrument Group
Refrolux
1
5.1 4.5 4.6 5.6
2 3 4 5
4.6
Miniaturized Enzyme Thermistor 5.0 4.5 4.2 5.7 4.5
the buffer flows through a piece of tubing placed around a copper cylinder next to the column (adiabatic shield). The stainless steel column (1.5 x 15 mm) containing the immobilized enzyme is sealed with a polyethylene filter in both ends. The construction is insulated with air, aluminum, and Plexiglas. Glucose Determination in Diluted Whole Blood
Glucose oxidase and catalase were coimmobilized on superporousagarose beads (106-180 pm). Buffer containing sodium fluoride and EDTA was continuously pumped through the column via a six-way injection valve at a flow rate of 50 pVmin. The sample volume was 20 pl. Blood was collected from the fingertips of human volunteers on five different occasions and the glucose concentration was measured with the Reflolux S glucose analyzer from Boehringer Mannheim. The injected samples were divided into five different groups. After diluting the samples tenfold, the blood glucose concentrations were measured. The response time was about 3 minutes. The system gave a linear response up to 1.6 mM glucose. With a tenfold dilution, blood glucose concentrationsas high as 16 mM were recorded. The results of the glucose measurementsare shown in Table 1.
111. CONSTRUCTION 2 This construction was made in order to improve the response time (Xie, 1993). A schematic drawing of the construction is shown in Figure 2. The diameter of the column was reduced from 1.5 mm to 0.6 mm and the length was 15 mm. Thermistors were mounted on gold capillary tubings in close proximity to the column. The column was placed inside an inner plastic jacket and then covered with an outer jacket. Stainless steel tubing was mounted on a small aluminum block that acted as a heat sink. This arrangement increased the stability of the baseline.
U. HEDBERG, B. XIE, and B. DANIELSSON
502
External
Micro-
Thermistor Outlet tubing
I
I
/
P1exigl ass adaptor
Internal jacket
Gold capillary
5 mm
H
Figure 2. Schematic figure of construction 2 (Xie, 1993).
Glucose Determination i n Whole Blood
Using a sample volume of 1 pl and a flow rate of 50 pl/min, the system had a linear range of up to 20 mM glucose. The response time was about 30 seconds. Human blood collected from the vein was put in heparinized tubes containing sodium fluoride. After two hours the glucose concentration was analyzed using Reflolux S from Boehringer Mannheim and a miniaturized biosensor. The relative standard deviation was 3.7% when over 100blood samples (3.8 mM glucose) were injected as shown in Figure 3.
0.0
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Number of blood samples Figure3. Temperature responses obtained for over 100 repeated injections of a blood sample containing 3.8 mM glucose (Xie, 1993).
Miniaturized ThermaI Biosensors
503
20
04 0
I
i
10
20
Blood glucose (mM) with the sensor Figure 4. Correlation between construction 2 and Reflolux S in the concentration range from 3.6 to 19.3 mM glucose (Xie, 1993).
Small volumes of a 200 mM glucose solution were added to the blood in order to obtain glucose concentrationsranging from 3.6 to 19.3 mM. The results obtained with the miniaturized biosensor and Reflolux S were compared over a concentration range as shown in Figure 4. Acorrelation coefficient of 0.980 was obtained for the 37 blood samples.
IV. CONSTRUCTION 3 The biosensor shown in Figure 5 was designed and fabricated on a silicon wafer (14 x 6 x 0.4 mm) with minimal heat capacity. The total volume of the reactor cell (5 x 1 x 0.014 mm) was 0.02 pl and consisted of 30 parallel channels. The cell was Glass cover
Inlet
Thermistor
Channels
Gold tubing
Silicon chip
Outlet
Connecting film
Figure 5. Schematic figure of the thermal biosensor fabricated onto a silicon chip (Xie, 1992).
U. HEDBERG, B. XIE, and 8. DANIELSSON
504
30
c? I
0 v 7
t-
10
Q
0
1
Penicillin with the enzyme thermistor EI
Penicillin with the silicon based device
v
HP0
9
10
2
/
with the silicon based device
I
I
I
I
4
6
8
10
Sample Conc.
(mM)
Figure 6. Sensitivity comparison between the silicon-based thermal biosensor and the conventional enzyme thermistor (Xie, 1992).
constructed by anisotropic etching of the silicon wafer surface. At the inlet and outlet of the cell ultramicrobead thermistors were placed on gold capillary tubings (Xie, 1992). Enzymes (catalase and penicillinase) were immobilized directly on the silanized (3-aminopropyl-triethoxysilane)silicon chip using glutaraldehyde.The sensor was
1 "
I
0
1
100
200
Number of batches Figure 7. Reproducibility obtained with immobilized catalase injecting samples of 10 m M hydrogen peroxide (Xie, 1992).
Miniaturized Thermal Biosensors
505
placed in an aluminum box insulated with polyurethane foam. In order to compare the sensitivity of the silicon chip with that of the conventional enzyme thermistor, 20 pl samples of different penicillin concentration were injected (Figure 6 ) . The flow rate was 20 pl/min for the silicon chip construction and 500 pl/min for the enzyme thermistor. The reproducibility of the sensor was tested using immobilized catalase by continuously injecting 10 mM hydrogen peroxide (Figure 7). After 200 injections, the loss of enzyme activity was seen as a decrease in the temperature response. For the first 200 injections the standard deviation was 3%.
V. CONCLUSIONS During our initial studies, the blood was diluted tenfold and 20 pl were injected. At least 100 samples were injected into a column containing glucose oxidase and catalase immobilized on superporous agarose. The measured glucose concentration correlated well with the reference method (Reflolux S). The response time was reduced to 30 seconds using a simpler construction.The column size, the tubing diameter, and the distance between the injection valve and the column were minimized. Instead of injecting 20 pl tenfold diluted blood, 1 p1 samples of undiluted blood were injected. Eliminating the dilution step simplifies sample handling and reduces the overall response time. These results indicate that thermal biosensors can be miniaturized without any significant loss in sensitivity.In the case of the silicon chip based thermal biosensor, the sensitivity was identical to that obtained with the conventional enzyme thermistor.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work was supported in part by grants from the National Swedish Board for Technical Development (NUTEK) and Novo Nordisk N S .
REFERENCES Danielsson, B. (1990). Calorimetric biosensors. J. Biotechnol. 15, 187-190. Rank, M., Gram, J., & Danielsson, B. (1992). Implementation of a thermal biosensor in a process environment: on-line monitoring of penicillin V in production scale fermentors. Biosensors Bioelectronics 7,63 1 4 3 5 . Xie, B., Danielsson, B., Norberg, P., Winquist, F., & Lundstrom, I. (1992). Development of a thermal microbiosensor fabricated on a silicon chip. Sensors Actuators B 6, 127-130. Xie, B., Hedberg, U., Mecklenburg, M., & Danielsson, B. (1993). Fast determination ofwhole blood glucose with a calorimetric micro-biosensor. Sensors Actuators B, 15-16, 141-144ss.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PART V
AFFINITY TECHNIQUES FOR SEPARATION AND BIORECOGN ITION
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
AFFINITY TECHNIQUES FOR SEPARATION AND BIORECOGNITION: INTRODUCTORY REMARKS
Per-Olof Larsson
Isolation of@protein from a cell homogenate is certainly not a trivial task. Often the protein is present in small amounts and mixed with thousands of other protein species that have very similar physical properties, making it difficult to find a discriminating separation method. Traditional purification techniques (precipitation, ion exchange chromatography, etc.) therefore require many steps before a sufficientlypurified protein is obtained. The introduction of affinity chromatography in the late sixties and seventies changed the situation dramatically. Affinity chromatography relies on the specific interaction between the protein and a complementary ligand attached to the affinity adsorbent and therefore offers unique opportunities for selecting one desired protein from a complex mixture. During the last 25 years numerous examples of impressive purification achievements with
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 50%511. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. AIL rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
509
51 0
PER-OLOF LARSSON
affinity chromatography have been reported, and the technique is now one of the most used. In the first chapter of this section, Lowe gives an historic overview of the field starting as far back as 1910 with Starkenstein’s affinity purification of a-amylase. Lowe continues with modem rrequirements of the affinity chromatography technique considering upstream engineering, adsorbent design, and process development. Some emphasis is put on the development of new biomimetic dyes, which act as efficient ligandsthey may be tailored to high specificity and are comparatively much more stable than derivatives of natural ligands, e.g., nucleotides. In the next chapter Berna, Moraes, Barbotin, Thomas, and Vijayalakshmi give experimental details about the rapid purification of a recombinant enzyme to homogeneity, cyclodextrin glycosyl transferase. The purification is based on metal ion affinity chromatographyusing two tandemly coupled columns.The first column [Zn(II)]has a negative affinity (removingrelated proteins but not the desired one), whereas the second column [Cu(II)] has a positive affinity for the desired enzyme. Tjerneld describes an alternative affinity technique for purification, namely aqueous two-phase affinity separation. The technique is now well established and is based on the fact that two properly prepared aqueous polymer solutions are easy to mix but will, upon standing, spontaneously separate into two phases. If one of the polymers is derivatized with an affinity ligand, an affinity purification system is obtained. Tjerneld describes here how the concept of aqueous two-phase affinity separations can be extended by using polymers whose phase-forming properties are temperature dependent. For example, an enzyme that has been partitioned to an affinity polymer phase in an initial step may then be released in a second step by merely raising the temperature of the affinity polymer phase. In this way a pure enzyme is obtained, free from contaminating polymers. Schwarz and Wilchek reveal the mysteries of thiophilic adsorption, an affinity technique originally proposed by Porath. The technique has special importance when isolating immunoglobulins, e.g., monoclonal antibodies.Very strong binding occurs between certain sulfur-containing ligands and immunoglobulins,indicating a specific binding mechanism. Schwarz and Wilchek present an array of evidence that collectively suggest the chemical nature of the binding site and where it is situated on immunoglobulins. In the next chapter affinity chromatography is used for fundamental studies instead of purification and isolation of proteins. The fact that true affinity chromatography is based on the defined molecular interaction between two (sometimes three) molecules soon attracted researchers to use the technique as a means of characterizing and quantifying interactions between proteins and their ligands, e.g., cofactors, substrates, and inhibitors. Easily measured quantities such as retention times, break-through curves, and peak widths could be mathematically transformed into Kdconstantsand even rate constants. Here Chaiken, Myszka, and Morton give a short overview of analytical affinity chromatography. They continue to describe new applications where, in particular, interactions between HIV proteins and
Affinity Techniques for Separation and Biorecognition
51 1
immune system components are studied with the aid of analytical affinity chromatography. The results are compared with results obtained with a biosensorAhe BIAcore machine. This biosensor directly measures the interaction between an immobilized ligand and a protein via the resulting increase of refractive index close to the biosensor surface. Fauchere describes peptides as multiple purpose tools. Peptides, natural or modified, may be used in a number of applications, e.g., as drugs, inhibitors, and affinity ligands to name a few. Fauchere gives a thorough overview of applications, synthetic methods, design strategies for obtaining a secondary structure that will give the peptide the desired biorecognition properties, and finally, the special problems encountered in drug design. In the next chapter Larsson describes superporous agarose. Significantly, this new material contains two kinds of pores, diffusion pores and flow pores. When the material is used in chromatographic beds it gives high chromatographic efficiency. The new material can be derivatized with ion exchange groups, affinity ligands, etc. Kozulic and Heimgartner describe the properties of several hydrophilic and amphiphatic gels related to polyacrylamide. Gel electrophoresis with these new gels gives superior results compared with standard polyacrylamide. Some of the gels may be used for hydrophobic interaction electrophoresis. The introduction gives us a rather full background to the project, where we can learn that research by-products may be very important. In the final chapter of this section, Kasche takes a broad view of immobilized systems. He notes the similarities of the processes occurring in affinity chromatography, in biosensors, and in immobilized biocatalysts, namely the diffusion distances and the ligate (or biocatalyst) density. These considerations provide an integrated approach to the analytical description of these systems.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
AFFl NITY CHROMATOGRAPHY AND RELATED TECHNIQUES: PERSPECTIVES AND TRENDS
Christopher R. Lowe
I. 11. 111. IV.
v.
VI .
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 513 INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 14 MODERN REQUIREMENTS FOR AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY . . . 5 16 5 17 UPSTREAM ENGINEERING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ADSORBENT DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 17 5 19 PROCESS DEVELOPMENT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 520
ABSTRACT Few of the recent advances in biotechnology would be commercially viable without effective methods of protein purification. Affinity techniques exploit specific biorecognition phenomena and are ideally suited to the purification of high value pharmaceutical proteins. This review focuses on the technique of affinity chromatography,
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology VoIume 153, pages 513-522. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. SBN: 0-7623-0114-7
51 3
CHRISTOPHER R. LOWE
514
provides a historical perspective, and describes the current status of the technique and its future prospects. It is anticipated that new developments in affinity chromatography will lead to new separation media better able to withstand the rigorous conditions required for sanitization and cleaning in situ of industrial scale processes but still retaining the high resolution, capacity, and yield of classical affinity media.
1. INTRODUCTION Protein purification has until recently remained one of the more empirical aspects of modern biotechnology. Traditional techniques based on precipitation with pH, temperature, salts, organic solvents, or high molecular weight polymers are being replaced by sophisticated chromatographic techniques based on biological specificity (Cuatrecasas et al., 1968; Cuatrecasas and Anfinsen, 1971; Lowe and Dean, 1974). The technique of affinity chromatography exploits the unique capacity of biological macromolecules to being complementary substrates, hormones, repressors, coenzymes, allosteric effectors, oligonucleotides, and other ligands, specifically and reversibly. The technique has now been exploited to resolve and purify enzymes, genetically and chemically modified proteins, cells and viruses, supramolecular structures and organelles, and to investigate and explore a wide variety of binding sites, topographies, and kinetic mechanisms (Lowe, 1977). The potentially facile, rapid, and virtually limitless application of affinity chromatography has prompted an almost exponential growth in use of the technique over the last two decades. The concept of separating macromolecules by means of biospecific interactions with immobilized substrates is not new: Starkenstein (19 10) reported the isolation of a-amylase by adsorption onto insoluble starch, while Willstatter et al. (1923) appreciably enriched lipase by adsorption onto powdered stearic acid. Likewise, Campbell et al. (195 1) isolated rabbit anti (bovine serum albumin) antibodies using a specific immunoadsorbent comprising bovine serum albumin coupled to diazotized p-aminoebenzylcellulose, and Lerman (1953) isolated mushroom tyrosinase on variousp-azophenol-substituted cellulose columns. Subsequently, Arsenis and McCormick (1964, 1966) purified liver flavokinase and other flavin mononucleotide-dependentenzymes on flavin-substituted celluloses. However, despite the fact that the antecedents of affinity chromatography clearly reach back to the beginning of the twentieth century, it was only in 1968 that the immense power of biospecificity as a means of purification was appreciated and the term “affinity chromatography” was coined (Cuatrecasas et al., 1968). Since then, thousands of proteins and other biomolecules have been isolated by this technique using almost every conceivable class of biochemical as the immobilized ligand. A recent survey found that affinity chromatography was the second most widely used purification technique after ion exchange chromatography and was used in 60% of the purification schemes investigated (Bonnerjea et al., 1986).This astounding technological
51 5
Affinity Techniques
success story can be attributed to several factors:the exquisite selectivityof affinity chromatography, the commercial availability of suitable matrix materials, the development of facile methods for activating these supports to attach appropriate ligands, and the market-pull exerted by the nascent biological industries. The key developments responsible for the successhl introduction of affinity chromatography as the method of choice are shown in Figure 1. For example, Cuatrecasas et al. Year 1900
a-amylase purified on starch
1910
1920
=-Lipase
purification on powdered stearic acid
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
--
immunoaffinity Chromatography Purification of tyrosinase
-
-
CNBr Activation and Poi saccharides Modern Concept of Affinyty Chromatography (Blospeclflcedsoorbents) Group specific Adsorbents (C4enzymes,lectlns,nuclelcaclds etc) Reactive Dyes High Performance Liquid Affinity Chromatography 'Biomimetic' Dyes
+Purification 'tags'
1990
p e novo Ligand design
2000
Figure 1. Historical perspective and key milestones in the development of affinity chromatography.
CHRISTOPHER R. LOWE
51 6
(1968) introduced agarose as a matrix and the insertion of a spacer molecule between the ligand and the matrix to relieve steric hindrance (Cuatrecasas and Anfinsen, 1971). Other developments including introduction of the cyanogen bromide procedure for activation of polysaccharide matrices (Axen et al., 1967), the concept of group-specific or general ligand adsorbents (Lowe and Dean, 1971; Mosbach et al., 1972), identification of the problem of nonspecific adsorption (O’Carra et al., 1973), the use of reactive dyes (Lowe, 1984), and the introduction of the related technique of high performance liquid affinity chromatography (Ohlson et al., 1978) have all contributed significantlyto the establishment of the approach. Despite its acknowledged advantages, the use of affinity chromatographyis still largely limited to research laboratories and is only recently beginning to make an impact in industry for the purification ofhigh-value biopharmaceuticals.The reason for this lies in the high cost and lability of traditional ligands, the presence of troublesome nonspecific adsorption, and fouling problems and the severe difficulties associated with sterilization and cleaning in situ. This review describes new developments in affinity chromatography and related techniques that should offset some of the previous shortcomings of the technique and establish it finally as the routine tool for large-scale protein purification (Clonis, 1987).
II. MODERN REQUIREMENTS FOR AFFINITY CHROMATOCRAPHY Substantial worldwide markets exist for highly purified pharmaceutical proteins, enzymes, vaccines, antibodies, and hormones. Clinical validation of such products is an absolute requirement by the regulatory authorities and all steps in the production must be in compliance with current Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP). Steps must be taken to ensure that the final therapeutic product is hlly active and unadulterated with potentially lethal contaminants. For example, biological molecules isolated from natural sources,or most commonly,expressed from recombinant DNA systems, must carry documentation to show that they have acceptably low levels of biologically active contaminants such as DNA (
51 7
Affinity Techniques
by the initial concentration of the target protein in the mother liquor (Knight, 1989) and the yields from multistage outmoded purification protocols. Consequently, the development of new, robust purification procedures that possess high resolution, high recovery, and high throughput is the most critical area demanding innovative upstream engineering,adsorbent design, and constructionand process development (Luong et al., 1987; Lowe, et al., 1990; Sassenfeld, 1990).
111. UPSTREAM ENGINEERING The advent of sophisticated recombinant DNA techniques has led to the idea that such approaches may well be applied to the source of the target protein in such a way as to facilitate the subsequent downstream processing steps involved in the purification of the protein. In one such technique, DNA encoding additional polypeptide or protein tags, is fused either to the 5' or 3' end of the gene of interest (Sassenfeld, 1990; Ford et al., 1991). Expression of these gene fusions results in the hybrid protein comprising the target protein and a purification tag that may be removed by enzymic or chemical cleavage. Purification tags have been devised to facilitate separation by affinity, ion exchange, hydrophobic, covalent, immunoaffinity, and metal chelate chromatography (Ford et al., 1991). Choice of the most appropriate tag will depend on individual requirements, scale, and selection of the expression system. However, removal of the purification tag still presents a significant hurdle to further exploitation,because, althoughmany methods have been used successfully in the research environment, seemingly intractable problems like denaturation,heterogeneity,and low yield still arise and are exacerbated on scale-up (Sassenfeld, 1990). Nevertheless, if such problems could be resolved purification tag technology may save prodigious amounts of time; purification effort is directed and rational and does not involve random screening and optimization.Nevertheless, even if such upstream events could be optimized, there is still a pressing requirement for durable, high capacity affinity adsorbents to form the key component of any downstream processing protocol.
IV. ADSORBENT DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION Originally, selective adsorbents were constructed with natural biological ligands (Lowe and Dean, 1974); the exquisite specificity of enzymes, polynucleotides, enzyme substrates, and antibodies offered a beguiling prospect. Experience has shown that most mono- and group-specific biological ligands are fragile, tend to be difficult to immobilize with retention of activity, and lead to expensive adsorbents (McLoughlin and Lowe, 1988; Lowe et al., 1990). Consequently, despite the obvious attractions of the technique, the large-scale exploitation of affinity chromatography has been hampered by two problems: the high cost of current affinity media and the difficultiesof making such media operate stably with high throughput in a multicycle sterile environment. Paradoxically, the high selectivity of affinity
518
-
CHRISTOPHER R. LOWE
Affinity Chromatography
9 Biornirnetic Pseudospecific
Biospecific
I
I
Monospecific
Group Specific
A
I
Antibodies Substrates Receptors Products Coenzymes Nucleotides
I
I
Dyes Designer Dyes De novo ligands
Metal Chelate Hydrophobic thiol
Lectins Heparin
Oligo-
Polynucleotides
Figure 2. Classification of affinity chromatography adsorbents on the basis of the specificity of the immobilized ligand.
chromatography is also its most profound weakness because suitable of-the-shelf adsorbents are often unavailable. Ideal media should incorporate elements of both selective and non-selective absorbents, be stable, and have general applicability (Figure 2). Specially synthesized ligands offer the best hope of finding general purpose, inexpensive and stable ligands. The reactive textile dyes are a group of synthetic ligands that have been responsible for purifying an astounding range of individual proteins and are now exploited in over 75% of all affinity separations (Figure 3) (Lowe, 1984; Clonis, 1987). However, despite the fact that thousands of research papers have been published, textile dyes have not yet proved to be the panacea originally envisaged. This is because textile dyes are relatively impure bulk chemicals and bonding processes Gelatin Metalchelate
IgG
\
\
Other Protein A
Other triazin dyes
C1 Reactive Blue 2
Figure 3. Comparison of usage of affinity ligands for large scale affinity chromatography. Data from Clonis (1 987).
Affinity Techniques
519
between dye and matrix poorly developed such that there is a near universal perception that all synthetic ligand products are toxic and leak into the product stream. Substantialresearch effort on the nature of dye-protein interactions(Small et al., 1982; Lowe and Pearson, 1984; Mcloughlin and Lowe, 1988; Lowe et al., 1990) and the use of purified dyes and improved coupling procedures has virtually eliminated ligand leakage and significantly increased column life-time capacity, batch-to-batch reproducibility, and sterilizability (Stewart et al., 1992). Furthermore, by exploiting a combination of empirical observation and computer-assisted molecular modeling, novel dye ligands could be designed and synthesized, which retained all the cost and stability advantages of textile dyes but yet more nearly mimicked the binding behavior and specificityof natural biological ligands (Lowe et al., 1986;Burton et al., 1988, 1990; Lowe et al., 1992). More recent studies have shown that ligands may be designed de novo by computer-aided molecular design. The ligands were designed to mimic the side chains of a number of arginyl dipeptides for the selectivepurificationof trypsin-like proteases (Burton and Lowe, 1992). The ligand with the highest affinity for the enzyme, an analogueof a Phe-Arg dipeptide, when immobilizedto sepharose CL4B via a hexamethylene spacer arm, purified pancreatic rallikrein 110-fold in one step from a crude pancreatic acetone extract. This study clearly demonstrates the value in exploiting computer modeling for the design of novel biomimetic ligands for affinity chromatography. Stable and sterilizable support matrices are also an essential ingredient for the large-scale use of affinity chromatography for the purification of pharmaceutical proteins. Porous supports for affinity chromatography have traditionally comprised beaded polysaccharides,synthetic polymers, and inorganic oxides (Knight, 1989). Very few of the commercially available affinity media satisfy the criteria for affinity and adsorbents (Groman and Wilchek, 1987) and display clear deficiencies with respect to degradation of the ligand and support under conditions used for sanitization and sterilization(Knight, 1989).Newer materials are now beginning to make an impact (Narayanan and Crane, 1990); a new generation of ultrastable, nontoxic perfluoropolymer supports was developed (Stewart et al., 1989, 1990).These new affinity adsorbents display exceedingly low rates of leakage of immobilized ligands under conditions of exposure to chaotropes (5 M sodium thiocyanate), acid (1 M HCl), and base (1 M NaOH) (Stewart et al., 1992). Shortly, these materials are expected to be available in a porous, beaded, format.
V. PROCESS DEVELOPMENT To date, affinity adsorbents have nearly always been operated under batchwise conditions with packed beads that become liable to fouling and plugging (Luong et al., 1987). Consequently,pretreatment to remove solid debris is a prerequisite to the effective use of affinity chromatography. Unfortunately, the low throughput creates a very low productivity system with processing rates as low as 10 kg h-', compared to >lo00 kg h-' for conventional precipitation procedures. The technique
CHRISTOPHER R. LOWE
520
has, thus far, been applied only to high-value, low-volume pharmaceuticalproducts such as urokinase, interferon, factor VIII, and antithrombin 111. Fluidized bed arrangements may obviate the problems associated with fouling and entry streams containing particulates and may permit affinity separations to be moved more upstream from their current position as a polishing step. Recent work has demonstrated the value of exploitingperfluorocarbon affinity emulsions in fluidized beds for the semi-continuous recovery of human serum albumin from blood plasma (McCreath et al., 1992). The affinity emulsion was generated by homogenization of perfluorodecalin with a dyed polymeric fluorosurfactant (Stewart et al., 1989, 1990). Under fluidized bed conditions, the emulsions behave as normal chromatographicmaterials and are stableunder operational conditionswith no coalescence being observed for periods greater than one year. These novel high density liquid affinity supportspresent excitingopportunitiesto develop a range of unit operations for the continuous purification of proteins (McCreath et al., 1992). The productivity of affinity separations may also be improved by increasing the flow rates as in high performance liquid affinity chromatography (Ohlson et al., 1978; Clonis et al., 1986) or be exploiting related high capacity techniques such as affinity cross-flow filtration (Mattiasson and Ling, 1986), affinity two-phase partition (Johansson, 1985), and affinity precipitation (Larsson and Mosbach, 1979; Pearson et al., 1986). Indeed, in the latter case, productivity compares favorably with classical precipitation techniques, while retaining all the advantages of selectivity created by the exploitation of specific biological interactions.
VI. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS The unique specificity and reversibility of biological interactions have opened new horizons for the development of purification strategies. Affinity chromatography and related techniques display qualities of scale, resolution, recovery, yield, and capacity and are likely to displace existing process technologies. However, the requirements for protein purification are also becoming increasingly stringent at an equally alarming rate. The approval of any pharmaceutical by the FDA relies on a convincing demonstration by the manufacturer of the safety and efficacy of the product (Anicetti et al., 1989). Sophisticated electrophoretic,chromatographic,and mass spectrometric techniques are now available to assess product purity, although
Table 1. Common Impurities in Pharmaceutical Proteins Produced by Recombinant DNA Technology Endotoxin Host cell and media proteins DNA Infectious agents
Product isofotms / variants Aggregated forms Proteolytic products Leachates from separationmedia
521
Affinity Techniques
in general, preparative procedureshave yet to match such analyticalprecision. Table 1 lists some typical impuritiesto be found in protein pharmaceuticals.Clearly, new high resolution preparative chromatographictechniques will have to be developed to resolve deleterious contaminants such as pyrogens, host cell and media proteins, infectious agents, and the plethora of potential product variants that are known to exist in recombinant proteins (Anicetti et al., 1989).Novel adsorbents for resolving protein and glycoprotein isoforms and the variety of oxidation, deamidation, aggregated, proteolysed, and mutant forms of the protein product will be required. Needless to say, such problems will pose new challenges to the bioprocess engineer well into the next century.
REFERENCES Anicetti, V.R., Keyt, B.A., & Hancock, W.S. (1989). Purity analysisofproteinpharmaceuticalsproduced by recombinant DNA technology, Trends Biotechnol. 7,342-349. Arsenis, C. & McCormick, D.B. (1964). Purification of liver flavokinase by column chromatography on flaviwellulose compounds. J. Biol. Chem. 241,33&334. Arsenis, C. & McCormick, D.B. (1966). Purification of flavin mononucleotide-dependent enzymes by column chromatography on flavin phosphate cellulose compounds. J. Biol. Chem. 239,3093-3097. Axen, R., Porath, J., & Emback, S. (1967).Chemical couplingofpeptides and proteins to polysaccarides by means of cyanogen halides. Nature 214. 1302-1304. Bonnejea, J., Oh, S., Hoare, M.. & Dunnill, P. (1986). Protein purification: The right step at the right time. Bio/Technology 4,954-958. Burton, N.P. & Lowe, C.R. (1992). Design of novel affinity adsorbentsfor the purification of trypsinlike proteases. J. Mol. Recognit. 5 , 5 5 6 8 . Burton, S.J., Stead, C.V., & Lowe, C.R. (1988). Design and applications of biomimetic anthraquinone dyes. 111. Anthraquinone immobilized C.I. reactive Blue 2 analogues and their interaction with horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase and other adenine nucleotide binding proteins. J. Chromatogr. 508, 109-125. Campbell, D.H., Luescher, E.L., & Lerman, L.S. (1951). Immunologic adsorbents 1. Isolation of antibody by means of a cellulose protein antigen. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 37.575-578. Clonis, Y.D. (1987). Large scale affinity chromatography Bio/Technology 5 , 1290-1293. Clonis, Y.D., Jones, K., & Lowe, C.R. (1986). Process scale high performance liquid affinity chromatography. J. Chromatogr. 363,31-36. Cuatrecasas, P. & Anfinsen, C.B. (1971). Affinity chromatography. Ann. Rev. Biochem. 40,25%278. Cuatrecasas, P., Wilchek. M., & Anfinsen, C.B. (1968). Selective enzyme purification by affinity chromatography. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 61,636-643. Ford, C.F., Suominen, I., & Glatz, C.E. (1991). Fusion tails for the recovery and purification of recombinant proteins. Prot. Exp. Pur. 2,95107. Groman, E.V. & Wilchek, M. (1987). Recent developmentsin affinity chromatographysupports.Trends Biotechnol. 5,220-224. Johansson, G. (1985). Aqueous two-phase systems in protein purification. J. Biotechnol. 3, 11-18. Knight, P. (1989). Chromatography: 1989. Report. BiolTechnology 7,24>249. Larsson, P.-0. & Mosbach, K. (1979). Afinity precipitationof enzymes. FEBS Lett. 98,333-338. Lerman, L.S. (1953). A biochemically specificmethod for enzyme isolation.Proc.Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 39,232-236. Lowe, C.R. (1977). Affinity chromatography: the current status. Int. J. Biochem. 8,177-181. Lowe, C.R. (1984). Applications of reactive dyes in biotechnology. In: Enzyme and Fermentation Biotechnology(Wiseman, A., Ed.), Vol. 9, pp. 78-161. Ellis Honvood, Chichester.
522
CHRISTOPHER R. LOWE
Lowe, C.R., Burton, S.J., Burton, N.P., Alderton, W.K., Pitts, J.M., & Thomas, J.A. (1992). Designer dyes: biomimetic ligands for the purification of pharmaceutical proteins by affinity chromatography. Trends Biotechnol. 1 0 , 4 4 2 4 8 . Lowe, C.R., Burton, S.J., Burton, N.P., Steart, D.J., Purvis, D.R., Pitfield, I., & Eapen, S. (1990). New developments in affinity chromatography. J. Mol. Recognit. 3. 117-122. Lowe, C.R., Burton, S.J., Pearson, J.C., Clonis, Y.D., & Stead, C.V. (1986). Design and application of biomimetic dyes in biotechnology. J. Chromatogr. 376, 121-130. Lowe, C.R. & Dean, P.D.G. (1971). Affinity chromatography of enzymes on insolubilized cofactors. FEBS Lett. 14.313316. Lowe, C.R. & Dean, P.D.G. (1974). Affinity chromatography. John Wiley, London. Lowe, C.R. & Pearson, J.C. (1984). Affinity chromatography on immobilized dyes. Methods Enzymol. l04,97-111. Luong, J.H.T., Nguyen, A.L., & Male, K.B. (1987). Recent developments in downstream processing based on affinity interactions. Trends Bitechnol. 5.28 1-286. Mattiasson, B. & Ling, T.G.I. (1986). In: Membrane Separation in Biotechnology (McGregor, W.C., Ed.). Marcel Dekker. McCreath, G.E., Chase, H.A., Purvis, D.R.. & Lowe. C.R. (1992). Novel afinity separations basedon perfluorocarbon emulsions. Use of a perfluorocarbon affinity emulsion for the purification of human serum from blood plasma in a fluidised bed. J. Chromatogr. 597, 18P-196. McLoughlin, S.B. & Lowe, C.R. (1988). Applications of triazinyl dyes in protein purification. Rev. Prog. Coloration 18, 247-259. Mosbach, K., Guildford, H., Ohlsson, R., & Scott, M. (1972). General ligands in affinity chromatography: Co-factor substrate elution of enzymes to the immobilized nucleotides adenosine 5'-mOnOphosphate and nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide. Biochem. J. 127, 625-63 1. Narayanan, S.R. & Crane, L.J. (1990). Affinity chromatography supports: a look at performance requirements. Trends Biotechnol. 8, 12-1 6. O'Carra, P., Bany, S., & Griffin, T. (1973). Spacer arms in affinity chromatography: the need for a more rigorous approach. Biochem. SOC. Trans. 1,28P-290. Ohlson, S., Hansson, L., Larsson, P-O., & Mosbach. K. (1978). High performance liquid affinity chromatography (HPLAC) and its application to the separation of enzymes and antigens. FEBS Lett. 9 3 , 5 9 . Pearson, J.C., Burton, S.J., & Lowe, C.R. (1986). Affinity precipitation of lactate dehydrogenase with a triazine dye derivative. Anal. Biochern. 15,382-389. Sassenfeld, H.M. (1990). Engineering proteins for purification. Trends Biotechnol. 8,88-93. Small, D.A.P., Lowe, C.R., Atkinson, A., & Bruton, C.J. (1982). Affinity labelling of enzymes with triazine dyes. Isolation of a peptide in the catalytic domain of horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase using Procion Blue MX-R as a structural probe. Eur. J. Biochem. 128, 11P-123. Starkenstein, E.V. (19 10). ijber Fermtenwir-Kung und deren Beeinflussung durch Neutralsalze. Biochem. Z. 24, 14. Stewart, D.J., Hughes, P., & Lowe, C.R. (1989). Afinity chromatography on triazine dyes immobilised on novel perfluorocarbon suppons. J. Biotechnol. 11,253266. Stewart, D.J., Purvis, D.R., & Lowe, C.R. (1990). Affinity chromatography on novel perfluorocarbon supports. Immobilization of C.I. Reactive Blue 2 on a poly(viny1 alcohol)-coated perfluoropolymer support and its application in affinity chromatography. J. Chromatogr. 5 10, 177-187. Stewart, D.J., Purvis, D.R., Pitts, J.M., & Lowe, C.R. (1992). Development of an enzyme-linked immunoadsorbent assay for C.I. reactive Blue 2 and its application to a comparison of the stability and performance ofa perfluorocarbon support with other immobilised C.I. Reactive Blue 2 affinity adsorbents. J. Chromatogr. 623, 1-14. Willsriitter, R., Waldschmidt-Leitz, E., & Memman, F. (1923). Bestimmung der Pankreatischen Fettspaltung. Erste Abhandlang Uber Pankreasenzyme. Z. Physiol. Chem. 125.93.
0NE-STEP AF F I NITY PURI F I CAT10N OF A RECOMBINANT CYCLODEXTRIN CLYCOSYL TRANSFERASE BY (CU(II), Zn(ir) TANDEM COLUMN) IMMOBILIZED METAL ION AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY
P. Berna, F.F. Moraes, J.N. Barbotin, D. Thomas, and M.A. Vijayalakshmi
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. MATERIALS AND METHODS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Chemicals.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. EnzymeSource.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Matrix Denvatization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Chromatographic Procedure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume lSB, pages 523-537. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press h e . All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
523
524 524 525 525 525 526 526
524
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
E. Biospecific Affinity Chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Pseudobiospecific Affinity Chromatography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. ProteinAssay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H. Activity Assay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. Electrophoresis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. RESULTS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. IMAC on Cu(n)-IDA Sepharose 6B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. IMAC on Zn(n)-IDA Sepharose 6B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . IMAC on Tandem Cu(rr)/Zn(rr)IDA-Sepharose 6B . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Biospecific Affinity Chromatography on P CD-Sepharose 6B . . . . . . E. Electrophoresis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. CGTase capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Enzyme Stability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,526
. 526 .526 .527 .527 .527 .527 ,530 . 530 .531 .531 ,532 .532 .533
ABSTRACT The one step purification to homogeneity using immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography (IMAC) of a recombinant cyclodextrin glycosyl transferase (rCGTase) from alkalophillic Bacillus cloned in Escherichia coli is described. Tandem columns with copper and zinc were used. Negative affinity on Zn(l1) and positive affinity on Cu(I1) were observed. We compared this pseudobiospecific affinity chromatography technique with the biospecific affinity chromatography using P cyclodextrin (CD) as the immobilized ligand in terms of purification factor and activity recovery. We obtained the same purification factor in both cases but with 79% activity recovery with the P CD ligand against 89% enzymatic activity recovery for IMAC. No further treatment of the enzyme was necessary for pseudobiospecific affinity chromatography because the elution conditions used did not inhibit the enzyme, as opposed to the biospecific approach. The presence of 10 mg/ml of p CD or 150 mM of P-D-glucose in the adsorption buffer did not disturb rCGTase adsorption on Cu(I1) columns. These facts suggested that at least one histidine outside of the active site is accessible on the surface of the rCGTase molecule for binding on Cu(1I).
1. INTRODUCTION Cyclodextrin glycosyl transferase (CGTase) is an enzyme which produces cyclodextrins from starch. This enzyme has an industrial importance since various applications of the CD have been found (Bender, 1986; Szejtli, 1990). CGTase purification was usually achieved by multiple step processes involving non-specific precipitation with acetone or ammonium sulfate (French, 1962),nonspecific sorption on ion exchange and size exclusion chromatography (Horikoshi et al., 1973; Kitahata et al., 1974) or biospecific sorption on native (Norberg and French, 1950) or modified starch (Gottvaldova et al., 1988). Biospecific affinity chromatography
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by IMAC
525
using a CD (Lazslo et al., 1981) or j3 CD (Makela et al., 1988), products of the enzyme, is the most utilized purification process at present on an analytical scale. As described by Vijayalakshmi (1989), pseudobiospecific ligand affinity chromatography has many advantagesover biospecific ligand affinity chromatography. Immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography (IMAC) is one of the most potent pseudobiospecific affinity systems. M A C was introduced by Porath (Porath et al., 1975) who used the affinity of proteins for metal ion immobilized on a chromatographic matrix via a chelating agent. Further work by Sulkowski with several model proteins established the ground rules for protein recognition by immobilized metal ion [CU(II),Ni(rI), Zn(II), Co(Ir)] on iminodiacetic acid chelating matrices (Sulkowski, 1985; 1989). IMAC is based on the accessible histidine content of protein that can form coordinate bonds with the immobilized metal ion under appropriate conditions. Therefore, since its creation, IMAC has been used not only for the purification of histidine-containing proteins (Krishnan and Vijayalakshmi, 1985; Anderson et al., 1987)but also for histidine residues surface topography of those proteins (Hemdan et al., 1989; Zhao et al., 1991). The recombinant CGTase used has 12 histidine residues in its primary sequence (Schmid et al., 1988). However, the degree of accessibilityof the histidine residues is not known. Hence, we decided to exploit IMAC as an alternative to the biospecific ligand affinity chromatography for CGTase purification and to study its accessible histidine content.
II. MATERIALS A N D METHODS A. Chemicals
Sepharose 6B and electrophoresis calibration kits for molecular weight determination were from Pharmacia fine chemicals AE3 (Uppsala, Sweden). 1,CButanediol diglycidyl ether, epichlorhydrine, and zinc sulfate were obtained fiom Merck (Darmstadt, Germany).Bovine serum albumin (Fraction V), copper sulfate, soluble starch, and iminodiacetic acid (IDA) were products of Sigma Chemical Co. (St. Louis, MO, USA). The p CDs were from Chinoin (Budapest, Hungary). All other chemicals used were of reagent grade. B. Enzyme Source
rcCGTase from alkalophillicBacillus (strain 1.1) cloned in Escherichiu coli was a gift from the Consortium f3r elektrochemische Industrie GmbH (Munich, Germany). This filtrate of E. coli culture broth had a protein content of 1.4 mg/ml and a specific activity of 4 1 U / d .
526
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
C. Matrix Derivatization
The p CD-Sepharose 6B was prepared according to Lazslo (Lazslo et al., 1981) using 1,Cbutanediol diglycidyl ether (bisoxirane)and p CD instead of a CD as the ligand. The IDA-Sepharose 6B was prepared as described by Porath and Olin (1983). CU(II)capacity for this gel was about 60 pmol Cu(Ir)/mlof gel bed. D. Chromatographic Procedure
All the chromatographic procedures used a linear flow of 25 c d h on a colllmn of 1.13 x 9 cm (9 ml) and were carried out at 4 "C with a low pressure liquid chromatography system (Minipuls I1 Gilson peristaltic pump, Uvicord SII LKB U.V. detector, wavelength set at 278 nm, Redirac 2 112 LKB fraction collector)with degassed buffer. Aprotein sample, 1 ml of filtered culture broth containing approximately 1.4 mg of protein and 41 units of activity was applied on the column. The column was washed with the adsorption buffer until all unbound material was eluted. The adsorbed protein was then displaced by the desorption buffer. 2.5 ml fractions were collected and analyzed for activity and protein content.
E. Biospecific Affinity Chromatography Tris-HC150 mM, pH 8 , 5 mM CaC1, used as the adsorption buffer. The gel was washed with ten column volumes of adsorption buffer before chromatography.The elution was carried out by adding 10 mg/ml of p CD in the adsorption buffer.
F. PseudobiospecificAffinity Chromatography The IDA-Sepharose 6B column was loaded with a solution of CuSC, or ZnSO, (50 mM) in distilled water until the saturation of the gel, and equilibrated with the adsorption buffer (Tris-HC1 50 mM, pH 7, 1 M NaC1) prior to chromatography. Competitive elution with a Tris-HC1 buffer, 50 mM, pH 7, containing 0.5 M NaCl and 25 mM imidazole, was used to elute the bound proteins. For tandem chromatography a Zn(I1)-IDA column was placed before the CU(II)-IDA column. The sample was loaded on the Zn(Ir)--IDA column and washing done in the tandem mode. Then the columns were disconnected and only the CU(II)-IDAcolumn was eluted. After each chromatography the metal ions on the gels were displaced by 50 mM EDTA and the gels thoroughly washed before a new metal load was applied. G. Protein Assay
Protein content was estimated by the micro-Bradford assay (Bradford, 1976). The values were compared to a standard curve obtained with bovine serum albumin.
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by IMAC
527
H. Activity Assay Cyclization activity was assayed with soluble starch as substrate by measuring the production of p CD using a modification of the method of Vikmon (1982). This method followed the activity by the decrease in absorption (550 nm) of phenolphthalein when complexing with p CD. The reaction mixture (1 ml total) containing the enzyme suitably diluted with distilled water to a volume of 0.5 ml, and 0.5 ml of 1% starch solution in 10 mM Tris-HC1 buffer (PH8) containing 5 mM CaCl, was incubated at 50 "C for 20 minutes. The reaction mixture was immersed in a boiling water bath for five minutes to stop the reaction. To 0.5 ml of a dilution of the above reaction mixture 2.5 rnl of a phenolphthalein working solution was added to develop the color. The reactants were mixed. Absorption at 550 nm was measured and compared to a calibration curve made with p CD in water (0-400 pM). The phenolphthalein working solution contained 60 pM phenolphthalein and 1.9% ethanol in sodium carbonate buffer (120 mM pH 10.5). One activity unit is equivalent to the formation of 1 pmol of p CD per minute under the chosen conditions. I. Electrophoresis
Sodium dodecyl sulfate poly acrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) on 10% acrylamide gel was performed according to Laemmli (Laemmli, 1970) on a Biorad Protean 11. Coomassie blue was used for staining.
111. RESULTS A. IMAC on C u w I D A Sepharose 6B
Immobilized CU(II)-IDAis known to bind proteins that have accessible histidine on their surface, with a minimum requirement of a single accessible histidine (Sulkowski, 1989).After injection of the culture filtrate on the Cu(I1)-IDAcolumn, all the rCGTase was considered bound to the gel because no activity was found during the wash (Figure 1). The elution by Tris-HCl buffer, 50 mM, pH 7,0.5 M NaCl containing 25 mM imidazole, gave a 100% activity recovery of the enzyme with a purification factor of 1.29 (Table 1). The chromatography of rCGTase in the presence of 10 mg/ml of p CD, or different concentrations of p-D glucose up to 150 mM did not disturb the binding of the enzyme on the CU(II)column (data not shown). It was recommended by Sulkowski (1985) that when competitive elusion with imidazole is used, one should presaturate the Cu(I1)-IDA-sepharose6B column with 1 mM imidazole solution. However, the presaturation of the gel with imidazole before chromatography of the rCGTase did not change anything concerning adsorption, but the amount of imidazole necessary to elute the bound proteins was reduced resulting in a time gain on the elusion operation.
528
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI 140
I20
5
100
4
no 3 60 2
40
1
20 0
0 60
40
20
Elution volume (ml)
figure 1. Immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography of crude rCGTase from Alkalophilic Bacillus cloned in E. coli on a Cu(ii)-IDA-Sepharose66 column. Column 1.1 3 x 9 cm; adsorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 7 , 1 M NaCI; desorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 7, 0.5 M NaCI, 25 m M imidazole; protein applied, 1.4 mg, 40 U in 1 ml buffer. Protein determination by micro-Bradford assay. A, protein (pghnl); 0, activity (U/ml).
Table 1. Purification by Affinity Chromatography of Recombinant Cyclodextrin Glycosyl Transferase on Different Pseudobiospecific and Biospecific Ligands
Ligand
Cu(I1)
Zn(I1) Tandem Zn(II)+ Cu(I1)
P CD
Fraction
Sample Wash Eluted Sample Wash Eluted Sample Wash Eluted* Sample Wash Eluted
Total Total Protein (mg) Activiry (v)
1.36 0.15 1.05 1.36 1.10 0.20 1.20 0.11 0.76 1.38 0.43 0.78
40.0 0 40.0 40.0 35.0 0 40.0 0 35.8 40.0 0 31.7
SpeciJic Activity
Total Activity Recovev
(U/mg)
PW
29.4 0 38.1 29.4 31.8 0 33.4 0 46.8 29.0 0 40.6
100 0 100 100 87 0 100 0 89 100
Note: 'This represents the elution from the Cu(I1) column only, see text for details.
0 79
Purijkation Factor 1.oo 0
1.29 1.oo 1.08 0 1.oo 0 1.40 1.oo 0 1.40
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by IMAC
529
From the SDS-PAGE electrophoregram (Figure 2, Lane 5 ) we could see that some of the contaminants from the culture filtrate were bound also to the CU(II)-IDA column and therefore should also possess histidine residues on their surface. It is known that the later elements in the first transition series of the periodic classification have different histidine topography requirements for protein adsorption. Sulkowski reported that zinc required the presence on the protein of at least two
Figure 2. SDS-polyacrylamide vertical gel electrophoresis pattern of the crude and purified rCGTase on 10% acrylamide gel. Coomassie blue staining. Lane 1 to 4, eluted fraction from p CD biospecific affinity chromatography at different concentrations; Lane 5, eluted fraction from immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography on Cu(ii)-IDA; Lane 6, crude extract, filtrate from E. coli culture broth; Lane 7, low molecular weight markers (From the top: 94 kD, 67 kD, 43 kD, 30 kD, 20.1 kD, 14.4 kD); Lane 8, eluted fraction from tandem immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography on Zn(ll)/Cu(ll)-IDA.
530
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
accessible histidines in cluster for binding, whereas CU(II)needed only one accessible histidine (Sulkowski, 1989).Therefore, the presence of two (His-His) doublets in the primary sequence of the rCGTase (Schmid et al., 1988) led us to try chromatography on Zn(I1).
B. IMAC on Zn(il)-IDA Sepharose 6 B We injected the filtrate of the E. coli culture broth on Zn(I1)-IDASepharose 6B expecting to discriminate between proteins with and without histidine clusters. No binding of rCGTase was observed under the conditions chosen because 87% of the activity was recovered during the wash (Figure 3). Some of the impurities bound to the column gave a purification factor of 1.08 (Table 1), which was even lower than that obtained with the CU(II)-IDAcolumn. Whereas we could partially purify the rCGTase on Zn(I1)-IDAby negative affinity, it was of interest to arrange the two columns [Zn(rI)-IDAand Cu(I1)-IDA]in tandem. The Zn column was arranged first in sequence to exploit the negative afinity.
C. IMAC on Tandem Cu(rr)/Zn(ll) IDA-Sepharose 6 B Figure 4 shows the elusion pattern in the tandem mode. As expected, rCGTase passed through the Zn(II)-IDAcolumn and bound to the CU(II)-IDAcolumn. After 6
5
4
3 2 1
0
20
Elution volume
40
0 60
(ml)
Figure 3. Negative immobilized metal ion affinity chromatographyof crude rCGTase from Alkalophilic Bacillus cloned in E. coli on a ZnWDA-Sepharose 66 column. Column 1.1 3 x 9 cm; adsorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50mM, pH 7, 1 M NaCI; desorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 7, 0.5 M NaCI, 25 mM imidazole; Protein applied, 1.4 mg, 40 U in 1 ml buffer. Protein determination by micro-Bradford assay. A, protein (pghl);0, activity (U/ml).
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by /MAC r
I40 7
531 6
120
5
100
4
80
3 60 2
40
1
20 0
0
20
40
60
0
80
Elution volume (ml) Figure 4. Tandem immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography of crude rCGTase from Alkalophilic Bacillus cloned in E. colion Zncit)/Curti)-IDA-Sepharose68 columns. Columns 1.13 x 9 cm; adsorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 7 , l M NaCI; desorption buffer for the Cucii)-IDA-Sepharose6B column, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 7, 0.5 M NaCI, 25 mM imidazole; Protein applied: 1.4 mg, 40 U in 1 ml buffer. Protein determination by micro-Bradford assay. A, protein (pglrnl);0, activity (U/ml).
disconnection of the two columns, the rCGTase was eluted from the CU(II)-IDA column under the same conditions as previously described. The purification factor was 1.4 and the activity recovery was about 89% (Table 1). D. Biospecific Affinity Chromatography on p CD-Sepharose 6B
Biospecific affinity chromatography with immobilized p CD was run in order to compare the results with the above data. All the rCGTase bound to the column under the conditions used. Ten mg of p CDIml of buffer eluted the enzyme (Figure 5). Under these conditions only 79% activity recovery was found. The purification factor was 1.4 (Table l), a value identical to that observed with the tandem chromatography on Zn(II)-IDAplus CU(II)-IDA. Other attempts to elute the enzyme without cyclodextrins failed. In fact, no leaking of enzyme was observed during a wash with distilled water at room temperature in contrast to that reported by Makela et al. (1988), and removing the CaC1, from the adsorption buffer did not elute the rCGTase.
E. EI ectrophoresis The SDS-PAGE electrophoregram (Figure 2) showed that the eluted fractions from the p CD-column or from the Cu(Ir)-IDAcolumnof the tandem procedure had
532
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
the same purity and were homogeneous. Adensitometryreading ofthe crude extract pattern on the gel showed that the rCGTase band represented 70% of the total protein. This was not unexpected since the CGTase is a recombinant protein excreted in the medium. The estimated molecular weight of the enzyme was about 75,000 Da, which is consistent with the molecular weight calculated from the primary sequence (75,400 Da).
F. CGTase capacity Culture medium was passed through the affinity columns until CGTase activity was found at the outlet. The enzyme was adsorbed from the fluid with a binding capacity of 33 mg CGTase/ml of gel bed for the p CD-column and with 13 mg of CGTase/ml of gel bed for the CU(II)-IDAcolumn. G. Enzyme Stability
It is interesting to note that the rCGTase showed a loss of only 10% of activity after 3 years of storage at -20 "C.
Elution volume
(ml)
Figure 5. Biospecific affinity chromatography of crude rCGTase from Alkalophilic Bacilluscloned in E. colion immobilized p cyclodextrin-Sepharose66. Column 1.1 3 x 9 cm; adsorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 8, 5 mM CaC12; desorption buffer, Tris-HCI 50 mM, pH 8, 5 mM CaC12, 10 mg/ml of p CD. Protein applied, 1.4 mg, 40 U in 1 ml buffer. Protein determination by micro-Bradford assay. A, protein (pg/ml); 0, activity (U/ml).
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by M A C
533
IV. DISCUSSION Tandem pseudobiospecificand biospecific affinity chromatography gave the same purification factor of 1.4. This purification factor is small but consistent with the fact that rCGTase represents 70% of the protein in the starting material. Both purified rCGTases were homogeneous on SDS-PAGE; therefore, IMAC is as efficient as biospecific chromatography for the purification of rCGTase. Activity recovery was about 90% in the tandem pseudobiospecific chromatography and 80% in the biospecific one. However, 90% activity recovery for biospecific chromatography was previously reported but this involved an additional dialysis step (Laszlo et al., 1981) in order to remove the eluting agent P CD from the CGTase fractions because P CD is an inhibitor of the enzyme (French, 1962). The same yield was also observed after dialysis when either urea or ethanol was used as eluent (Makela et al., 1988). The lower yield observedby us may be at least partially explained by the omission of the post chromatographic dialysis step. Therefore, the pseudobiospecific affinity chromatography is as good as biospecific chromatography regarding activity recovery, with the important advantage of avoiding a dialysis step because the eluting agent used, namely imidazole, did not show any inhibitory effect. Several authors reported that soluble CU(II)and Zn(I1) were strong inhibitors of CGTase (French, 1962; Akimura et al., 1991). During IMAC on CU(II),we did not see a deleterious effect on enzyme activity because 100% of the activity was recovered. Furthermore, any final problem resulting from metal leakage can be easily taken care of by addition of a short, metal ion-free chelating bed after the affinitycolumns. The free matrix removes any eventual metal ion from the solution and avoids the inhibition. We reported a CGTase capacity that found in of 33 m g / d of gel bed for biospecific chromatography, which was equivalent to previous studies (Laszlo et al., 1981; Makela et al., 1988).Nevertheless, Villette et al. (199 1) reported a drastic decrease in capacity (0.3 mg/ml of gel bed) and a marginal activity recovery (only 10%) during their attempt to scale up biospecific affinity chromatography. For IMAC the capacity on a CU(II)column was 13 mg/ml of gel bed, 2.5-times less than biospecific chromatography on a laboratory scale but 10-times more than that reported by Villette et al. (199 1) on epichlorhydrin reticulated copolymer of beta cyclodextrin. Villette et al. (1991) also reported a total absence of CGTase binding to the affinity sorbent with P CD as ligand when the total neutral carbohydrate content of the injected extract was above 35 mM. In that case, they had to prepurify the crude extract before loading on the column. Absence of CGTase binding was certainly due to the maslung of the P CD binding site in CGTase. In the case of chromatography of rCGTase on Cu(I1)-IDA-Sepharose6B, 10 mg/ml of P CD or different concentrations of P-D-glucose up to 150 mM did not compete with the potential sites for IDA-CU(II)binding. Hence, the CGTase binding on the CU(II)column was
534
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
not affected by these carbohydrates. This implies that the accessible histidine residues involved in immobilized IDA-CU(II)recognition are not at or near the active site. Control columns with free Sepharose6B and Sepharose6B-IDA(data not shown) did not show nonspecific binding of rCGTase on those gels. Therefore, the immobilized metal ion was responsible for enzyme binding. If we refer to Sulkowski’s rules (histidine accessibility requirement for binding on Cup), N~(II),Zn(II), or CO(II)-IDA), the binding of rCGTase on the Cu(n)-IDAcolumnsuggests that at least one histidine amongthe twelve present on the molecule is accessibleon the surface. It seemed reasonable to use the data obtained on CGTase from other species, as we compared six available primary sequences (Table 2) and found that five histidine residues were always conserved in each of the six studied CGTases (His 98, 140, 176, 177, and 327, Bacillus circulans numeration) (Binder et al., 1986; Takano et al., 1986; Kimura et al., 1987; Kaneko et al., 1988; Schmid et al., 1988; Nitschke et al., 1990). Studies of CGTase histidine residue modification by diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC) (Villette et al., 1992) showed the modification of seven histidine residues that are accessible on the surface. Two of them (1.5 for Bender) (Bender, 1991) were faster reacting and seemed to be involved in the active site catalytic mechanism because their modification suppressed enzymaticactivity. In our case, we saw that 10 mg/ml of p CD or glucose at 150 mM were inefficient to elute the enzyme bound to CU(II)columns. This observation again demonstrated that the binding between rCGTase and the CU(II)which occurred via histidine did not involve the active site. Hence, histidines suggested by Bender (1991) to be involved in the active site, namely His-327 and His-I76 or 177, which are conserved in our rCGTase, are not the ones that bind to the immobilized CU(II).It would be interesting to study the catalytic behavior of rCGTase immobilized on Cu(II) columns, since the active site seems not to be involved in the metal binding site. The nonbinding of rCGTase on Zn(m) gave additional information. It is known that protein with the accessible sequence (His-(X)2,3-His)in an a helix configuration or (-His His-) by folding binds to Zn(n) (Sulkowski, 1989). In our case, the (His-His) sequence is present in the primary structure of the enzyme, this sequence is conserved in the six different CGTases, and from Bender (199 1) we know that they should be implicated in the active site and hence present on the surface.Further, Hofmann et al., (1989) described the three-dimensional structure of one CGTase, showing this histidine doublet on the edge of the molecule suggesting its accessibility. So the (His-His) sequence in our enzyme should be available for binding, but the rCGTase did not show any retention on Zn(I1). Sulkowski observed the same phenomena with human myoglobin, which presented His-His in a p turn of the protein, but here again, no binding was observed on Zn@)-IDA columns (Sulkowski, personal communication). One explanation could be that structural requirements on the His-His doublet are not hlfilled for binding on Zn(II)-IDA. This implies that a histidine doublet does not bind to
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CGTase by IMAC
535
Table 2. Comparison of the Histidine Residue Position in 6 Different CGTases Alkalophillic bacillus strain 1011 CGTase Alkalophillic bacillus 38-2 CGTase Alkalophillic bacillus strain 1- 1 CGTase cloned in E. coli Bacillus circulans strain 8 CGTase Bacillus macerans CGTase Klebsiella pneumoniae M5 CGTase Alkalophillic bacillus strain 1011 CGTase Alkalophillic bacillus 38-2 CGTase Alkalophillic bacillus strain 1-1 CGTase cloned in E. coli Bacillus circulans strain 8 CGTase Bacillus macerans CGTase Klebsiella pneumoniae M5 CGTase
93 43
83
78
98
126 128 140 176 177 202
98
126 128 140 176 177 203
91
119
133 169 170
98
126
140 176 177 202
98
140 176 177 202
91 104 119
135 169 170 186
233
270
327 333
233
270
327 333
410
226 242 263 264 327 233 244
327
25 1
328 332
227
502 630 667 669 390
Note: *References are in the text; conserved histidines in the 6 CGTases are in hold letters.
Zn(II)-IDAand needs at least to be separated by an amino acid residue, as suggested by Sulkowski (1989). Finally, IMAC was once again demonstrated to be a competitive technique that can score over biospecific affinity chromatographybecause it gives the same purity and activity recovery with no additional steps required either to prepare the crude extract free from neutral carbohydrates or to eliminate the specific eluant (e.g., p CD). These are major advantages in view of a future industrial application. IMAC has the additional advantage of giving information on the histidine content of the protein. Furthermore, the noninvolvement of the active site in the binding mechanism predicts an easy method for CGTase immobilization without loss of activity.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors thank the Consortium fiir elektrochemische Industrie GmbH (Miinich, Germany) for providing the filtrate culture broth of recombinant E. coli. This work was supported in part by a grant from the E.E.C.
536
BERNA, MORAES, BARBOTIN, THOMAS, and VIJAYALAKSHMI
REFERENCES Akimura, K., Yagi. T., & Yamamoto, S. (1991). Purification and properties of Bacillus coagulans cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferase. J. Ferment. Bioeng. 7 1(5), 322-328. Anderson, L., Sulkowski. E., & Porath. J. (1987). Facile resolution of a fetoproteins and s e w albumins by immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography. Cancer Res. 47, 3624-3626. Bender, H. (1986). Production, characterization and application of cyclodextrins. Adv. Biotechnol. Process. 6, 31-71. Bender, H. (1991). On the role of histidine residues in cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase: chemical modification with ðyl pyrocarbonate. Carbohydr. Res. 209, 145453. Binder, F., Huber, O., &Bock, A. (1986). Cyclodextrin- glycosyltransferasefrom Klebsiellapneumoniae M5al: cloning, nucleotide sequence and expression. Gene 47,26%277. Bradford, M. ( 1976).Arapidand sensitivemethod for the quantitationof microgram quantitiesof protein utilizing the principle of protein-dye binding. Anal. Biochem. 72,248-254. French, D. (1 962). Cyclodextrin transglycosylase (Bacillus rnacerans Amylase) In: Methods in Enzymology (Colowick, S.P., & Kaplan, N.O., Eds.), Vol. V, pp. 48-155. Academic Press, New York. Gottvaldova, M., Hrabova, H., Sillinger, V., & Kucera, J. (1988). Biospecific sorption of cyclodextrin glucosyltransferase on physically modified starch. J. Chromatogr. 427,33 1-334. Hemdan, E.S., Zhao, Y.J., Sulkowski, E., & Porath, J. (1989). Surfacetopography of histidine residues: A facile probe by immobilized metal ion affinity Chromatography. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 86,1811-1815. Hofmann, B.E., Bender, H., & Schulz, G.E. (1989). Three dimensional structure of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferasefrom Bacillus circulans at 3.4 angstrbmresolution. J. Mol. Biol. 209,793-800. Horikoshi, K., Ando, T.K., Yoshida,N.,Nakamura,N., & Kunitachi, N. (1973). Japanpatent 2.453.860. Kaneko, T., Hamamoto, T., & Horikoshi, K. (1988). Molecular cloning and nucleotide sequence of the cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferase gene from the alkalophilic Bacillus sp. strain N o 38-2. J. Gen. Microbiol. 134,97405. Kimura, K., Kataoka, S.. Ishii, Y., Takano, T., & Yamane, K. (1987). Nucleotide sequence of the j3 cyclodedextrin glucanotransferase gene of alkalophillicBacillus sp. strain 1011 and similarity of its amino acid sequence to those of a amylases. J. Bacteriol. 169(9),4 3 9 W 0 2 . Kitahata, S., Tsuyama, N., & Okada, S. (1974). Purification and some properties of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase from a strain of Bacillus species. Agric. Biol. Chem. 38,387-389. Krishnan, S. & Vijayalakshmi, M.A. (1985). Purificationof an acid protease and a serine carboxypeptidase from Aspergillus niger using metal chelate affinity chromatography. J. Chromatogr. 329, 165170. Laemmli, U.K. (1970). Cleavage of structural proteins during the assembly of the head of bacteriophage T4. Nature 227,680-685. Laszlo, E., Banky, B., Seres, G., & Szejtli, J. (1981). Purification of cyclodextrin-glycosyltransferase enzyme by affinity chromatography. Starch 33,281-283. Makela, M., Mattsson, P., Schinina, M.E., & Korpela T. (1988). Purificationand properties of cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferase from an alkalophilic Bacillus. Biotechnol. Appl. Biochem. 10, 414427. Nitschke, L., Heeger, K., Bender, H., & Schulz, G.E. (1990). Molecular cloning, nucleotide sequence and expression in Escherichia coli of the p cyclodextrin glycosyltransferasegene from Bacillus circulans strain No 8. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 33,542-546. Norberg, E. & French, D. (1950). Studies on the Schardinger dextrins 111, redistributionsreactions of B. maceram amylase. J. Am. Chem. SOC.72,1202-1206. Porath, J., Carlsson, I., Olsson, I., & Belfrage, G. (1975). Metal chelate affinity chromatography, a new approach to protein fractionation.Nature 258,598-599. Porath, J. & O h , B. (1983). Immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography of biomaterials. Serum proteins affinities for gel-immobilized iron and nickel ions. Biochem. 22, 1621-1630.
One-Step Affinity Purification of a Recombinant CCTase by /MAC
537
Schmid, G., Engelbrecht, A., & Schmid, D. (1988). Cloning and nucleotide sequence of a cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase gene fiom the alkalophilic Bacillus 1-1. In: Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium on Cyclodextrins (Huber, O., & Szejtli, J. Eds.), pp. 71-76. Kluwer Academic Press, Dordrecht, Netherlands. Sulkowski, E. (1985). Purification ofproteins by IMAC. Trends Biotechnol. 3(1), 1-7. Sulkowski, E. (1989). The saga of IMAC and MIT. Bioessays 10, 17&175. Szejtli, J. (1990). The cyclodextrins and their applications in biotechnology. Carbohydr. Polym. 12(4), 375-392. Takano, T., Fukuda, M., Monma, M., Kobayashi, S., Kainuma, K., & Yamane, K. (1986). Molecular cloning, DNA nucleotide sequencing and expression in Bacillus subtilis cells of the Bacillus maceruns cyclodextrin glucanotransferase gene. J. Bacteriol. 166(3), 11 1S1122. Vijayalakshmi, M.A. (1989). Pseudobiospecific ligand affinity chromatography. Trends Biotechnol. 713,71-76. V i h o n M. (1982). Rapid and simple spectrophotometric method for determination of microamounts of cyclodextrins. In: Proceedings of the First International Symposium on Cyclodextrins (Szejtli J., Ed.), pp. 69-74. Reidel, D., Dordrechf Netherlands. Villette, D.P., Looten, J., & Bouquelet, S.J.-L. (1991). Fast purification of cyclodextrin-glucosyltransferase from Bacillus circulans E 192 by affinity chromatography using an epichlorhydnn-reticulated copolymer of beta-cyclodextrin. Chromatographia 32(7/8), 341-344. Villette, J.R., Sicard, P.J., & Bouquelet, S.J.-L. (1992). Cyclomaltodextrin glucanotransferase from Bacillus circulans E 192: 111, Chemical modification by diethyl pyrocarbonate: evidence for an induced fit at the active site resulting from the binding of an acceptor. Biotechnol. Appl. Biochem. 15, 69-79. Zhao, Y.J., Sulkowski, E., & Porath, J. (1991). Surface topography of histidine residues in lysozymes. Europ. J. Biochem. 202, 1 1 1 5 1 1 19.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
AFFl NITY PURIFICATION OF ENZYMES USING TEMPERATURE-INDUCED PHASE SEPARATION
Folke Tjerneld
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 539 I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 540 11. TEMPERATURE-INDUCED PHASE SEPARATION APPLIED TO PROTEIN PURIFICATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 1 111. AFFINITY PARTITIONING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 543 Iv. AFFINITY PARTITIONING COMBINED WITH TEMPERATURE-INDUCED PHASE SEPARATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . 544 V. PURIFICATION OF ENZYME FROM YEAST EXTRACT . . . . . . . . . 545 VI. CONCLUDING REMARKS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 546
ABSTRACT Temperature-induced phase separation can be made with polymers which have a cloudpoint, that is, which phase separate in water after a temperature increase. An
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 53-46. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press h e . All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-7623-0114-7
539
540
FOLKE TJERNELD
ethylene oxide/propylene oxide random copolymer (UCON) was used for protein purification. Target proteins were first partitioned to the UCON phase of a UCON/dextran aqueous two-phase system. The UCON phase was removed and isolated in a separate container. The temperature was increased above the cloud point of UCON, which leads to the formation of a new two-phase system with an upper water phase and a lower UCONiwater phase. The proteins were recovered in the water phase free ofpolymer. The UCON/water phase was free ofprotein and easily recycled. Temperature-induced phase separation was used with the affinity ligand Procion Yellow HE3G coupled to UCON. An initial affinity partitioning was made in a phase system containing UCON, UCON-ligand, and dextran. The upper UCON phase containing the UCON-ligand-enzyme complex was removed. A small amount of salt was added to the UCON phase. After temperature increase above the cloud point of UCON (40 "C), the enzyme was recovered in the water phase and the UCON-ligand in the UCON phase. Temperature-induced phase separation is a very promising purification technique where the ligand carrying polymer is easily and effectively removed from the isolated protein by a mild temperature increase.
1.
INTRODUCTION
A number of polymers exist which in water solution have a lower critical solution temperature (LCST). These polymers display inverse solubility in water, that is, as temperature increases they become increasingly insoluble. At temperatures below the LCST the solution is a one-phase system. Above the critical temperature the solution separates into a polymer-rich phase and a water-rich phase. This temperature is called the cloud point of the system. The most well-studied polymer with this property is polyethylene glycol (PEG). At temperatures above the cloud point of a PEG solution, a liquid PEG-rich lower phase is formed that is in equilibrium with a water-rich upper phase (Saeki et al., 1976).Theoretical explanations for the LCST of PEG have been given by Kjellander and Florin (198 l), and Karlstrom (1985). Other examples of polymers with LCST in water are ethyl(hydroxyethy1) cellulose (EHEC) (Carlsson, 1988) and polyvinyl caprolactam (Galaev and Mattiasson, 1992). In contrast to PEG, when heated above the cloud point these two polymers form a precipitate rather than a liquid polymer-rich phase. The cloud point of PEG is influenced by the molecular weight of the polymer and by addition of salts to the solution (Kjellander and Florin, 1981; Karlstrom, 1985). PEG of MW 20,000 has a cloud point of 112 "C, which is too high for most biomolecules. A method for lowering the cloud point of PEG is to introduce propylene oxide groups into the polymer. With a random copolymer composed of 50% ethylene oxide (EO) and 50% propylene oxide (PO) groups, with MW of4000, a cloud poinf of 50 "C is obtained (see Figu're 1) (Harris et al., 1991; Alred et al., 1993). This polymer is commercially available as UCON 50-HB-5 100. The phase behavior of random EOPO copolymers is similar to PEG. Above the cloud point a phase separation into a liquid copolymer-rich lower phase and a water-rich upper
541
45 0.
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Conc. of UCON 50-HB-5100 In w/w%
Figure 1. Temperature-concentration phase diagram for the binary system UCON 50-HB-51 OO/water. Molecular weight of the polymer is 4000. All concentrations above the solid line are in the two-phase region. Tie-line at 53 "C (----). As indicated by (-) a 10% UCON solution at 53 "C will separate in one phase with 1YO UCON, 99% water, and one phase with 37% UCON, 63% water. From Johanssonet al. (1993).
phase is obtained. The copolymer-rich phase contains about 60% water at 4 "C above the cloud point (Figure 1) (Johansson et al., 1993).
II. TEMPERATURE-INDUCED PHASE SEPARATION APPLIED T O PROTEIN PURIFICATION Temperature-induced phase formation with an EOPO copolymer (UCON) was studied for protein purification (Harris et al., 1991). As a first step an aqueous two-phase system of UCON/dextran was used (Figure 2). In the phase system the UCON polymer is enriched in the top phase and dextran in the bottom phase. This phase system resembles the conventional PEG/dextran aqueous two-phase system, which has widespread use for separation of biomolecules and cell particles (Walter et al., 1985; Albertsson, 1986). UCON is here used instead of PEG as top-phase polymer. In order to lower the cloud point of UCON, 0.2 M Na$O, was added to the system. The target protein is partitioned preferentially to the UCON phase whereas bulk proteins and cell debris are partitioned to the dextran phase. The
542
FOLKE TJERNELD
.
h
3 3
5 8
-
?
m
?
0
m
z
8 3
"
0
5
10
15
20
25
Dextran T500 (% w/w)
Figure 2. Phase diagram for the system UCON 50-HB-5100 (MW 4000), Dextran T500 (MW 500,000) and water at 22 "C. Tie-lines connecting compositions of top and From Harris et al. (1991). bottom phases (u).
UCON phase is withdrawn and isolated in a separate vessel. The temperature is raised to 40 "C, which is above the cloud point of UCON, resulting in a phase separation with a lower UCON-rich phase and an upper water-rich phase. In this new two-phase system the protein partitions exclusively to the upper water phase. The protein has been totally separated from the polymer. The polymer can easily be recycled and used for a second extraction (Harris et al., 1991). Table 1 shows Table 7. Partition of 3-PhosphoglycerateKinase and Hexokinase* Enzyme 3-PGK Hexokinase Note:
K(22 "C) 0.90 0.76
K(40 "C) >I00 >loo
*Primary phase system: 6% UCON 50-HB-5100,3% Dextran T500,90units 3-phosphoglyceratekinase, 16 units hexokinase, and 0.01 M sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0. K and G values at 40 "C are for the partition between the water and UCON phases formed by the increase in temperature. From Hams et al. (1991).
Temperature-Induced Phase Separation
543
the partition of two enzymes at 22 "C in the UCON/dextran system and at 40 "C in the waterAJCON system formed by the increase in temperature.
111. AFFINITY PARTITIONING AUCON conjugatewith the affinity ligand Procion Yellow HE-3G was synthesized and used for enzyme purification (Alred et al., 1992). The enzyme was first partitioned in a two-phase system composed of UCON, UCON-ligand, and dextran. The enzyme was extracted into the UCON-ligand carrying upper phase. This is analogous to earlier work using PEG with bound affinity ligands in aqueous two-phase systems (Johansson, 1984).
M
s
-1.5
, . . , . I
u.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
%UCON-Procion Yellow H E 3 G Figure 3. Affinity partitioning of glucose-6-phosphatedehydrogenase. The partition coefficient (K)as a function of the concentration of UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G. (H) is the line obtained in the system 5.1% UCON 50-HB-5100, 7.0% Dextran T500 and 0.01 M sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0. (a)is the line obtained in the system 7.0% PEG 4000, 7.0% Dextran T500 and 0.01 M sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0. Temperature: 22 "C. From Alred et al. (1 992).
FOLKE TJERNELD
544
The logarithm of the partition coefficient (K) for glucose-6-phosphatedehydrogenase is shown in Figure 3 as a h c t i o n of the amount of UCON-ligand included in UCON/dextran and PEG/dextran two-phase systems. The ligand-enzyme complex partitions to the top (UCON or PEG) phases of the two systems. The figure shows that by using only 0.2% UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G in the system the enzyme is effectively extracted into the top phase. Log K is changed from -1.2 to + 1.1 when 0.4% UCON-ligand is included in the UCON/dextran system (Alred et al., 1992).
IV. AFFINITY PARTITIONING COMBINED W I T H TEMPERATURE-I NDUCED PHASE SEPARATION Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase was partitioned in a UCON/dextran phase system with 0.2% UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G (Table 2) (Alred et al., 1992).In this phase system G6PDH was partitioned to the top UCON-rich phase (K = 4.5). After phase separation had occurred at 22 "C, the UCON-containing phase was removed and isolated in a separate container. Sodium sulfate was added to this UCON-phase to a concentration of 0.2 M. The solution was then placed in a water bath at 40 "C for 15 minutes. The increase in temperature caused formation of a new phase system with an upper phase composed of water, buffer, and salt and a lower phase composed of UCON (approximately 40%) and water. By the salt addition and temperature increase the enzyme was dissociated from the affinity ligand. In the new phase system, glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase was totally partitioned to the upper water-salt phase. The enzyme was recovered (88%) in the water phase. The UCON-Procion Yellow partitioned to the lower, UCON-rich phase (KL = 0.06) and could be recovered along with UCON for recycling (77%). There was no enzyme present in the lower UCON and UCON-Procion Yellow phase at 40 "C (Alred et al., 1992).
Table 2. Affinity Partition of Glucose-6-PhosphateDehydrogenasewith Recovery of UCON 50-HB-5100-Procion Yellow HE-3G'
K ~ ( 4 0"C)
KL(40 oC)b
Water Phase
% UCON-Pry Recovered in UCON Phase
>loo
0.06
88.0%
77.1?o'
% G6PDH Recovered in
KE(22 oC)a 4.51 Notes:
K, is the partition coefficient for G6PDH. K, is the partition coefficient for UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G. 'System is 5.1% UCON 50-HB-5100,7% Dextran T500,0.2% UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G. and 0.01M sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0. The amount of glucose-6-phosphatedehydrogenase was 34 units. K values at 40 "C are for the partition between the water and UCON phase formed by the increase in temperature. From Alred et al. (1992).
a
Temperature-lnduced Phase Separation
545
Table 3. Purification of Glucose-6-PhosphateDehydrogenasefrom Yeast Extract' K (22 QC)
Sample
G6PDH Protein UCON-PrY
12.4 0.32
24.6
K (40 "C)
>I00 >loo 0.32
Purification FactoP (40 "C)
% Recovered ar
4.2
78.gb
40 'C
-
-
-
84.6'
Notes: aThespecific activity of G6PDH in the PEG precipitated homogenate was 0.475 units mg-' protein, equivalent to a purification factor of I. bRecovered in water phase at 40 'C. CRecoveredin UCON phase at 40 "C. 'System is 6.3% UCON 50-HEi-5100.9% DextranT40,0.2% UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G. 0.02 M sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7.0,, and 5.7% yeast extract. K values at 40 "C are for the partition between the water and UCON phase formed by the increase in temperature. K is the partition coefficient, CJC,. From Alred et al. (1992).
V. PURIFICATION OF ENZYME FROM YEAST EXTRACT Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase was purified from yeast extract in a UCON/dextran aqueous two-phase system using 0.2% UCON-Procion Yellow HE3G (Table 3) (Alred et al., 1992). The purification scheme is shown in Figure 4. In the initial phase system, the enzyme was extracted by the UCON-ligand to the top phase (K = 12). The bulk proteins were partitioned to the bottom phase (K = 0.32). The upper phase was isolated in a separate container. Sodium sulfate and sodium chloride were added, both at 0.2 M, and the temperature was raised to 40 "C. In the new two-phase system formed at 40 OC, the enzyme was recovered in the water phase with a yield of 79% and a purification factor of4.2. The partition coefficient for the enzyme in the water/UCON phase system was >loo. UCONProcion Yellow was recovered in the lower UCON phase with a yield of 85%. No protein could be detected in this UCON phase.
d
RecycleUCON 5OHBd100 and UCON-Pry HE3C
1
Figure 4. Enzyme purification scheme using affinity extraction of target enzyme with UCON-Procion Yellow HE-3G. Temperature-induced phase separation is used for eizyme recovery and recycling of UCON 50-HB-5100 and UCON-ligand. From (Ilred et al. (1 992).
546
FOLKE TJERNELD
VI. CONCLUDING REMARKS A new protein purification technique is demonstrated in these examples where the protein after only two purification steps is obtained in a waterbuffer solution with a high degree of purification and free of contaminating polymers (see Figure 4). The polymer that carries the affinity ligand can be separated from the protein by raising the temperature above the cloud point of the polymer. Thus, both protein recovery and recycling of affinity ligand are much facilitated by temperature-induced phase separation. An ethylene oxide-propylene oxide random copolymer with a cloud point of 18 "C was recently synthesized and used for protein purification (Alred et al., 1994).With polymers that have low cloud point temperature-induced phase separation can be made at room temperature.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author gratefully acknowledges the financial support of the Swedish Research Council for Engineering Sciences (TFR).
REFERENCES Albertsson, P.-.k(1986). Partition of Cell Particles and Macromolecules, 3rd ed., Wiley, New York. Alred P.A., Tjerneld F., Kozlowski A,, & Harris J.M. (1992). Synthesis of dye conjugates of ethylene oxide-propylene oxide copolymers and application in temperature-induced phase partitioning. Bioseparation 2,363373. Alred, P.A., Tjerneld, F., & Modlin. R.F. (1993). Partitioning of ecdysteroids using temperature-induced phase separation. J. Chromatogr. 628,205-214. Alred, P.A., Kozlowski, A., Harris, J.M., & Tjerneld, F. (1994). Application of temperature-induced phase partitioning at ambient temperature for enzyme purification. J. Chromatogr. 659.28P-298. Carlsson, A. (1988). Interaction between ethyl(hydroxyethy1)cellulose and sodium dodecyl sulphate in aqueous solution. Colloid Polym. Sci. 266, 1031-1036. Galaev, I.Yu. & Mattiasson, B. (1992). Affinity thermoprecipitation of trypsin using soybean hypsin inhibitor conjugated with a thermo-reactive polymer. poly(N-vinyl caprolactam). Biotechnol. Techniques 6,35>358. Harris P.A., Karlstrom, G., & Tjerneld, F. (199 I). Enzyme purification using temperature-induced phase formation. Bioseparation 2,237-246. Johansson, G. (1984). In: Methods inEnzymology (Jakoby, W.B., Ed.), Vol. 104, pp. 356364. Academic Press, New York. Johansson, H.-O., Karlstrom, G., & Tjemeld, F. (1993). Experimental and theoretical study of phase separation in aqueous solutions of clouding polymers and carboxylic acids. Macromolecules 26, 447W83. Karlstrom, G. (1985). A new model for upper and lower critical solution temperatures in poly(ethy1ene oxide) solutions. J. Phys. Chem. 89,4962-4964. Kjellander R. & Florin, E. (1981). Water structure and changes in thermal stability of the system poly(ethylene oxide)-water. J. Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans. I , 77, 205S2077. Saeki, S., Kuwahara, N., Nakata, M., & Kaneko, M. (1976). Upper and lower critical solution temperatures in poly(ethy1ene glycol) solutions. Polymer 17,685489. Walter, H., Brooks, D.E., & Fisher, D. (Eds.) (1985). In: Partitioning in Aqueous Two-Phase Systems: Theory, Methods, Uses, and Applications to Biotechnology, Academic Press, New York.
POSSIBLE SITES ON ANTIBODIES INVOLVED IN THIOPHILIC ADSORPTION
Alexander Schwarz and Meir Wilchek
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
547
548 548
ABSTRACT A possible binding site of antibodies involved in thiophilic binding is deduced from experimental and theoretical work. A possible general mechanism of thiophilic interaction chromatography is suggested.
Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 547-551. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-01 14-7
547
548
ALEXANDER SCHWARZ and MElR WILCHEK
1. INTRODUCTION Mononclonal and polyclonal antibodies have many applications in biotechnology such as immunoaffinity chromatography, immunodiagnostics, drug targeting, biosensors, and many more applications. For all these purposes homogeneous antibody preparations are needed. Conventional purification methods like protein A, protein G, hydroxyapatite, and ion exchange are either expensive or time consuming. Thiophilic adsorption chromatography (TAC), a chromatographic method introduced by J. Porath et al. in 1985, shows selective binding of immunoglobulins in the presence of structure-forming salts. Different sulfur-containing ligands were found to promote this type of adsorption. The types of ligand suitable for TAC consist oftwo parts. One part can be characterized as a hydrophilicelectron acceptor like a sulfone or pyridine, whereas the other part is an electron donor like a sulfur, nitrogen, or oxygen molecule. The best electron donor seems to be su1fi.u whereas the electron acceptor can be varied, provided it is of hydrophilic nature (Porath et al., 1985; Nopper et al., 1989; Oscarsson et al., 1990). Porath et al. (1987) undertook a study trying to correlate overall structural features like net surface charge, isoelectric point, molecular mass, carbohydrate content, and disulfide linkage with thiophilic adsorption and found no correlation. The results obtained in our studies may shed some light on a possible mechanism and on the location of binding sites on the immunoglobulin molecules.
11. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Thiophilic adsorption chromatography is highly selective for immunoglobulins with affinity constants ranging in the lod to M range as shown in Figure 1 for some thiophilic smctures. The ability of such simple, chemically well defined ligands to recognize specific surface properties of proteins is not understood. It is believed to be a charge transfer mechanism because studies with aromatic peptides found them to bind strongly to the thiophilic matrix. In our studies, we found that if BSA is dinitrophenylated this derivative binds strongly to thiophilic matrices whereas BSAdoes not interact with the matrix. This experiment supportsthe notion that exposed aromatic moieties are responsible for the interaction. First, we med to locate the approximate binding site or sites on the immunoglobulin molecule. We loaded a monoclonal mouse IgG,, antibody against biotin on the 3s column and injected BSA. The BSA was not bound to the column, whereas in a similar experiment with biotinylated BSA, the protein was bound. Approximately 1.5 molecules of biotinylated BSA were bound per anti-biotin antibody, indicating that the variable part of the antibody is free for antigen binding and does not participate in the binding of the antibody to the thiophilic matrix. Protein A also does not bind to the thiophilic matrix under optimized conditions for antibody binding. Again, loading a mouse IgG,, antibody to the column and
Thiophilic Adsorption Sites on Proteins
Structure
SUPPORT SOLID
iixsa
SOLID
SUPPORT
SUPPORT
549
Name Kd [MI
PYS
'.o
Thia
4.1
lo-'
-2s
1.5 10"
3s
8.7
4s
2.4
I0I
SUPPORT
Figure 7. Structure, name, and Kd of some thiophilic structures.
then injecting protein A resulted in its binding to the column. Approximately 0.8 molecules of protein A were bound per IgG,, indicating that the binding of the antibody is not promoted through its F, region. Furthermore, purified Fab and F(ab), fragments also bound to the thiophilic matrix, albeit under slightly higher Na2S0, concentrations than needed for the binding of whole antibodies. Thus, excluding the variable part from the first experiment and the CH2 and CH3 part of the F, of an antibody from the second and third experiment outlined above, these experiments indicated that the possible binding site or sites are located at the CHI or H region. As all IgGs from a variety of species bind to the thiophilic matrix, we proceeded to investigate common sequences of these antibodies. We believed that there must be a common sequence responsible for the binding. Bearing in mind that a possible mechanism is charge transfer, we looked for exposed aromatic sequences in the
550
ALEXANDER SCHWARZ and MElR WILCHEK
antibody molecule. Furthermore, consideringthe selectivity of TAC for antibodies, we postulated that one exposed aromatic amino acid is not enough for the observed selectivity, whereas at least two exposed residues might explain it. From our above outlined experiments, we concentrated our search for the CH1 and H regions of the antibodies. Comparing the antibody sequences of the CH1 and H regions of all antibodies stored in the Swiss Protein data bank, we found one exposed aromatic sequence in the CH1 region in position 150-15 1 of the heavy chain, which exists in all but IgM antibodies. The sequence G/DF/YFP is located directly in a loop and is therefore highly exposed. There are a number of other proteins that bind with equal strength to thiophilic matrices. These proteins are listed in Table 1. We compared the known sequences of these proteins with our initial result from our sequence comparison and found several exposed aromatic dipeptides that are located in a loop structure. We chose soybean trypsin inhibitor (SBTI) for hrther evaluation of our hypothesis. SBTI can be conveniently cleaved by CNBr into two fragments of similar size, and both fragments contain an exposed aromatic dipeptide sequence. According to our hypothesis, both fragments should bind and, in fact, we found both fragments bound to the thiophilic matrix. Principally, many proteins can be adsorbed to thiophilic matrices depending on the salt content of the solution. Using a gradient system many proteins can be purified on thiophilic matrices (Lihme et al., 1991). There is a whole spectrum of interactions ranging from proteins like cytochrome c, RNase A, and myoglobin that do not interact with the thiophilic matrix to very strong interactions like those found with antibodies. Many proteins interact at intermediate strength with the thiophilic column. We postulate that the mechanism by which thiophilicadsorption chromatography works is a measure of the exposure of aromatic amino acids on the surface or in
Table 1. Proteins which Strongly Interact with Thiophilic Matrices and Their Proposed Binding Sites Protein
IgG SBTI Lysozyme Sweet potato amylase Lens culinaris lectin Carboxypeptidase A Alkaline phosphatase Insulin Hemopexin
Sequence
DGWFR
EWFWD
DlGYFF'E GTYYI SRWWCN PFPWYD DTFYN GVWFA DDYFD GFFYTP RDYFMP
Thiophilic Adsorption Sites on Proteins
551
accessible cavities of proteins. The aromatic sites on the protein interact via their n-electron system with the electron acceptor site like the sulfone or the heterocyclus on the ligand, while the electron donor interacts with the now electron acceptor site on the protein. The chaotropic salt, which is essential for this interaction, helps to remove surface-bound water molecules from these aromatic sites rendering them accessible to the thiophilic interaction. The interaction can be reversed by deletion of the salt when the water returns to the protein surface and the thiophilic interaction is interrupted.Another possibility is to add an electron donor to the elution solution, also interrupting the thiophilic interaction. For the strong interaction seen in antibodies, we postulate that they have a two aromaticamino acid sequence exposed to the aqueous surroundingand are therefore able to strongly interact with thiophilic matrices. We explain the intermediate interactionby a mechanism whereby these proteins have only one exposed aromatic amino acid or two aromatic amino acids that are interrupted by a nonaromatic amino acid. There are several proteins that do not bind to the matrix, and this can be explained by the above outlined mechanism. They do not possess any accessible aromatic amino acids and are therefore not able to interact with the matrix.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS A. S. thanks the Minerva Foundation for a postdoctoral fellowship and Steven Becker for linguistic advice.
REFERENCES Lihme, A. & Heegaard, P.M.H. (1991). Thiophilic adsorption chromatography, the separation of serum proteins, Anal. Biochem. 192,6449. Nopper, B., Kohen, F., & Wilchek, M. (1989). A thiophilic adsorbent for the one-step high performance liquid chromatography purification of monoclonal antibodies. Anal. Biochem. 1 8 0 , 6 6 7 1. Oscarsson, S. & Porath, J. (1990). Protein chromatography with pyridine and alkylthioether-based agarose adsorbents. J. Chromatogr. 499,235-247. Porath, J. & Hutchens, T.W. (1987). Thiophilic adsorption: Anew kind ofmolecular interaction revealed by chromatography. Intern. J. Quantum Chem., Quantum Biol. Symp. 14,297-315. new method for protein Porath, J., Maisano, F., & Belew, M. (1985). Thiophilic adsorptiofractionation. FEBS Lett. 185,306310.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
NEW OPPORTUNITIES FOR USING IMMOBILIZED LIGANDS TO CHARACTERIZE MACROMOLECULAR RECOGNITION AND DESIGN RECOGNITION MOLECULES
Irwin Chaiken, David Myszka, and Thomas Morton
Abstract . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 554 I. INTRODUCTION: PROTEIN HEAVEN AND THE UNIFYING THEME OF PROTEIN RECOGNITION . . . . . . . . . . . . . 554 11. OFUGINSOFANALYTICALAFFINITYCHROMATOGRAPHY . . . . . . 555 111. SOME RECENT APPLICATIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 556 A. HIV Envelope gp120 - T Cell CD4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 557 B. HIV gag p24 Self-Association . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 557 IV. ADVENT OF THE BIOSENSOR. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 561 A. New Capabilities in Recognition Analysis Using Immobilized Ligands . 561 B. Comparative Studies with sCD4-gp120 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 564 C. Human Interleukin 5 Interaction with its Receptor . . . . . . . . . . . . 566 V. PROSPECTS FOR BIOLOGY AND BIOTECHNOLOGY . . . . . . . . . . 566 567 NOTEINPROOF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Advances in Molecular and Cell Biology Volume 15B, pages 553468. Copyright 0 1996 by JAI Press Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN: 0-7623-0114-7
553
554
IRWIN CHAIKEN, DAVID MYSZKA, and THOMAS MORTON
ABSTRACT Characterization of protein interactions and interaction sites can provide a means both to learn about molecular recognition and assembly processes in biology and to identify and evaluate new recognition molecules of practical use in biotechnology. We have had a long-standing interest in using immobilized ligands as analytical tools for characterizing recognition mechanisms of proteins and other biological macromolecules. This interest started with analytical affinity chromatography (AAC). Recently, a newcomer among analytical technologies using immobilized ligands has appeared, namely the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor. The SPR biosensor, as AAC, enables detection and measurement of noncovalent interaction of a soluble macromolecule with a solid phase containing covalently attached ligand. Importantly, the biosensor offers several unique features including access to kinetics (hence deeper mechanistic understanding), ability to analyze molecules in mixtures (hence access to more biologically relevant conditions), and real-time observation of the interaction process (hence ability to observe interacting molecules as they form or are added). Recent results with HIV proteins including p24 self assembly and CD4-a120 interactions, as well as with interleukin 5 and its receptor reflect some of the growing uses of both AAC and the SPR biosensor as macromolecular recognition tools. Overall, the advent of the SPR biosensor and the likely follow-up development of other automated devices promise to stimulate evolution of the analytical use of immobilized ligands that started with AAC into a broad-based analytical solid phase science for the field of biomolecular recognition.
1. INTRODUCTION: PROTEIN HEAVEN AND THE UNIFYING THEME OF PROTEIN RECOGNITION One of the challenges-and pleasures-of current biotechnology drug discovery is being able to find solutions to practical problems in medicine against the backdrop of “protein heaven”, the explosion in biological sciences of newly discovered proteins and newly revealed principles of protein structureand function. A unifying feature which provides a useful paradigm to assemble this wealth of new knowledge in biology and to conceive technological solutions is molecular recognition. Protein interactions are at the root of virtually all biological processes including chromosomal organization and gene expression, assembly of cell organelles and metabolic pathways, the immune response, cell signaling and trafficking, and development. We are learning a lot about the identity of biological macromolecules-synthetases and proteases; adhesion receptors and counterreceptors; nucleosome assembly proteins and transcriptional activators; antibodies and antibody receptors; cytokines, cytokine receptors and signal transducers; and on and on. Normal interactions of such proteins and other macromolecules are what keep a biological system going, whereas inappropriate recognition events, due to too much of a normal recognition molecule or its loss or mutation to a form with altered interaction properties, lead to disease. Thus, mimicking protein recognition and
Macromolecular Recognition and Design Recognition Molecules
555
antagonizing it are practical goals common to much of therapeutics discovery. As a consequence, we seek methods to detect proteins with specific interaction properties, to characterize protein interactions at the molecular and structural level and to design mimics and antagonists. Some time ago, we became interested in immobilized ligands to characterize macromolecular interactions. Our work started with ligands on chromatographic supports and evolved into analytical affinity chromatography.The recent discovery and development of the surface plasmon resonance biosensor has led us to explore this new technology, using BIAcoreTMof Pharmacia Biosensor, for macromolecular recognition studies. The intent of this paper is to describe our recent experiences with both technologies and ideas on their use to discover and characterize interactions of biological macromolecules and to identify new recognition molecules as potential mimetics and antagonists.
II. ORIGINS OF ANALYTICAL AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY The idea that affinity chromatography could be used as an analytical method arose largely from its success as a preparative method. The laboratory of Porath had discovered chromatographic supports and activationprocedures amenable to covalent attachment of ligands with selective affinity for proteins (Axen et al., 1967; Porath and Kristianson, 1975), while Anfinsen’s laboratory had demonstrated the use of such an affinity support to purify staphylococcal nuclease (Cuatrecasas et al., 1968). The power of preparative affinity chromatography, seen repeatedly for a wide range of proteins and other biomolecules (Jakoby and Wilchek, 1974; Dean et al., 1985), argues that a high level of fidelity must occur in the interactions that take place between proteins and ligands immobilized on affinity supports. Figure 1Aand 1B show several key features ofaffinity chromatographic interaction which, based on the above noted fidelity of protein interactions with immobilized ligands, no doubt operate in preparative affinity chromatography for proteins. These key features are: (1) accessibility of the immobilized ligand to protein active sites; (2) selectivity of ligands to discriminate between proteins with different binding sites; and (3) reversibility of proteirr--affinity support interaction allowing elution under gentle conditions. Accessibility, selectivity, and reversibility also provide the underlying basis for analytical affinity chromatography.Based on these properties, it was predicted that chromatographic elution volume of a protein on an affinity support would be a faithful reflection of its biologically relevant interaction affinity and that the conditions of binding to affinity support would allow nonchaotropic elution to measure such elution volumes. We therefore devised a strategy of isocratic elution under binding conditions, along with competitive elution, to measure interaction properties of eluting proteins through the measurement of their elution volumes (Figure 1C). Isocratic elution of macromolecules on the affinity support yields
IRWIN CHAIKEN, DAVID MYSZKA, and THOMAS MORTON
556
A. BINDING: ACCESSIBILITY. SELECTIVITY
B. ELUTION: REVERSlBlLlTY
C. ANALYTICAL AFFINITY CHROMATOGRAPHY
4
isocratic
elution
competitive
b
elution
-
Figure 7. Scheme depicting the key features of accessibility and specificity (A) and reversibility (B), which are common to preparative and analytical affinity chromatography. (C) Scheme depicting isocratic elution and competitive elution that are the major experimental strategies of analytical affinity chromatography.
elution volumes that allow equilibrium binding afinity to be determined as KMR. Competitive elution, isocratic elution in the presence of soluble ligand competing with matrix ligand, allows simultaneous measurementof both the matrix interaction (KMp) and interaction in solution (KLIp).Descriptions of this methodology have been presented (Dunn and Chaiken, 1974;Chaiken, 1979; Swaisgood and Chaiken, 1987; Chaiken et al., 1992). Similar approaches have been devised in other laboratories (Lowe et al., 1974;Nichol et al., 1974;Kasai and Ishii, 1975;Brodelius and Mosbach, 1976).
111. SOME RECENT APPLICATIONS Understanding and controlling protein recognition are dominant themes in such present-day therapeutics discovery efforts as the characterization of the human
Macromolecular Recognition and Design Recognition Molecules
557
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and the search for therapeutics approaches for HIV-mediated acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS). The protein components of HIV are known and their interactions are integral to such events as viral invasion of T cells (through envelope protein gp120 recognition of CD4), viral propogation (includingreverse transcriptaseheterodimer formation and interaction with RNA and DNA), and viral maturation (including p24 self-association in nucleocapsid assembly and protease dimerization and recognition of gag precursor protein substrates). All of these processes represent targets for therapeutics development. We have established analytical affinity chromatographic assays for characterizing some of these protein-protein recognition processes and potentially for identifying antagonists or modulators of these interactions. A. HIV Envelope gpl20 - T Cell CD4
We have devised a frontal elution AAC method using immobilized gp120 to measure interactions of envelope protein with soluble CD4 (sCD4) as well as with domain constructs of sCD4 and their sequence mutants. Figure 2 shows schematic views of the g p 1 2 M D 4 interaction (as it would occur biologically as well as on an affinity chromatographic support) and elution data obtained. The dissociation values determined are denoted as Kw’s for P (sCD4 or VlV2) interaction with matrix bound gp120 (M). The affinities measured here are quite strong with dissociation constants in the nM range. The chromatographic affinities are similar to those determined by antibody-based assays (Arthos et al., 1989; Moebius et al., 1992). The close-to-sCD4-magnitude binding affinity of V1V2 is consistent with crystal structure and mutagenesis studies of VlV2, which show that the amino terminal two-domain molecule is quite rigid and contains the major residues responsible for gp120 recognition (Arthos et al., 1989; Ryu et al., 1990). Several single site mutants with changes in putative binding site residues Phe-43 and Ala-55 show undetectable binding to immobilized gp120 (D. Myszka, data not shown). Beyond the determinationof interaction properties of sCD4 and its mutants, elution of CDCrelated molecules also could be a convenient, sensitive, and direct means to determine the efficacies of small molecules as mimetics of sCD4 (or of gp120 for that matter) by their ability to antagonize the extent of sCD4 (or VlV2) chromatographic retardation on immobilized gp 120. B. HIV gag p24 Self-Association
For nucleocapsid assembly studies, we have immobilized p24 as its monomer and found that soluble p24 can interact with the affinity support (Rose et al., 1992). The interactions envisioned and examples of elution data are shown in Figure 3. Here, we have been able to perform both zonal and frontal elutions of p24, with the affinities determined by both methods being closely similar to one another. As denoted in Figure 3A, the chromatographic method leaves open the possibility to identify small molecule agents that would antagonize or otherwise alter p24
558
IRWIN CHAIKEN, DAVID MYSZKA, and THOMAS MORTON
A. HIV docking
on Tcell
bB
B. Solid phase affinity analysis
(continued
Figure 2. Frontal elution analytical affinity chromatographic measurements of interaction of soluble CD4 (sCD4) with human immunodeficiency virus envelope protein gpl20 (strain BHlO). A: Schematic diagram of HIV-1 docking onto CDCbearing T cell through CD4-gpl20 recognition. B: Scheme of solid phase affinity system with immobilized gp120 and soluble CD4. C: Frontal elution profiles for sCD4 at a concentration range of 22 to 440 nM. Vo is the elution volume for a nonretarded protein of similar size to sCD4 (ovalbumin). BH1Ogpl20 was immobilized to Affiprep -1 0 through amines (Pierce). Experimental conditions were: chromatography buffer 20 mM sodium phosphate, pH 7.4, 150 mM sodium chloride and 0.01 % Tween 20; flow rate 0.05 ml/min; temperature 20 "C; detection by absorbance at 21 0 nm; the gp120 surface was regenerated between elutions using 0.1 M phosphoric acid in 2 ml. D: Linearized replot of AAC data using the procedure described by Rose et al. (1 992). These data led to a calculated KM = 20 nM.
interaction and hence might antagonize either normal nucleocapsid formation during viral maturation or nucleocapsid disassembly during cell infection. Viral uncoating inhibitors (stabilizers of nucleocapsid) have been identified for the nucleocapsid protein of rhinovirus (Smith et al., 1986; Diana et al., 1989) and proposed to function in a similar way with HIVgag 24 (Rossman, 1988).
Macromolecular Recognition and Design Recognition Molecules
559
C. Frontal Elution Profiles 440
nM
0.14 vo
0.12
E
0 v
-
0.10
h(
3C
0.08
$
0.06
m
u)
n
a
0.04 0.02 0
0
20
40
80
60
100
120
140
Time minutes
D. Linearized Replot of AAC data 6000
-
5000 -
-
4000
-
3000
-
2000
-
7
2
I
1
0
?
.
L 7
K M ~ 20 = nM
1000 -
0
1
2
3
4
sCD4 concentration [M x 1W7]
Figure 2. (Continued)
5
220 nM
IRWIN CHAIKEN, DAVID MYSZKA, and THOMAS MORTON
560
A) Scheme Immobilized p24 (M)
Soluble p24 (P)
p
B) Frontal Elution K~~ = 3.7 x
C) Zonal Elution K~~ = 3.0 x 10-5 M
105M
I
0
10 Time (min)
+ EFFECTORS
20
0
V.
1.78 rnl
I
5
10
Time (min)
figure 3. Analysis of HIV-1 p24 selfassociationand screening for effectors of selfassociation by elution of soluble p24 (P) on immobilized p24 (M).A: scheme showing the dimerization interactions of p24 in solution (defined by the dissociation constant Kpp) and on the solid phase (defined by dissociation constant Kwp). Parts B and C show typical analytical chromatographic elution profiles for the p24 system described in A. The Km values shown were determined from elution data obtained over a range of p24 concentrations. B: frontal chromatography profile for p24 at a concentration of 80 ug/ml (continuous line); the minimum of the first derivative of the elution profile (dashed line) defines the experimental elution volume Ve. Experimental conditions were: buffer, PBS - pH 7.0; flow rate, 0.25 ml/min; temperature, 20 "C; detection by absorbance at 280 nm. C: zonal chromatography profile for p24 at the same experimental conditions as in B. VOis the nonretarded elution volume. (Figure adapted from Rose et al., 1992).
Macrornolecular Recognition and Design Recognition Molecules
561
IV. ADVENT OF THE BIOSENSOR A. N e w Capabilities in Recognition Analysis Using I m m o b i l i z e d Ligands
We investigated the use of the SPR biosensor as a tool to characterize protein interactions and compared the results obtained with data using AAC. We have focused our work so far on the system from Pharmacia called BIAcore. Its configurationinvolves the interaction of solublemacromolecules in a flow cell with ligands immobilized on the dextran coating of a gold chip. The interaction is measured directly as an increase in refractive index, a change directly related to an increase of molecular mass on the chip. In principle, the SPR and AAC methods for interaction analysis have several common features including interaction of soluble macromolecule with immobiCommon Features of AAC and BIA as Tools in Molecular Recognition o Solid phase immobilized ligand o Flow through o