Advances in
INSECT PHYSIOLOGY
VOLUME 7
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Insect Physiology Edited b...
32 downloads
1196 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
INSECT PHYSIOLOGY
VOLUME 7
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Insect Physiology Edited by
J . W. L. BEAMENT, J. E. TREHERNE and V. B. WIGGLESWORTH Department of Zoology, The University, Cambridge, England
VOLUME 7
1970
ACADEMIC PRESS London and New York
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD Berkeley Square House Berkeley Square London, W1X 6BA
US.Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
Copyright @ 1970 by Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd
All Rights Resewed NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
L i b r a v of Congress Catalog Card Number: 63-14039 SBN: 12-024207-9
Printed in Great Britain by The Whitefriars Press Ltd London and Tonbridge
List of Contributors toVolume 7 M. ASHBURNER, Department of Genetics, University of Cambridge, England (P. 1) L. J . GOODMAN, Department of Zoology, Queen Mary College, University of London, England (p. 97) G. HOYLE, Department of Biology, University of Oregon, Eugene, Oregon, U.S.A. (p. 35 1) P. A. LAWRENCE, Department of Genetics, University of Cambridge, England (P. 197) B. SACKTOR, Gerontology Research Center, National Institutes of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Baltimore, Maryland, U.S.A. (p. 267)
V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 7
. . . . . . . . . .
V
FUNCTION AND STRUCTURE OF POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES DURING INSECT DEVELOPMENT MICHAEL ASHBURNER I. I1. 111. IV .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Polytene Chromosome Structure . . . . . . . . . . . Polyteny and Endopolyploidy during Insect Development . . The Occurrence of Polytene Chromosomes . . . . . . . A . Larval Tissues of Diptera . . . . . . . . . . . B. Pupal and Adult Tissues of Diptera . . . . . . . . C . Polytene Chromosomes in other Organisms . . . . . V . Puffs: Introduction and Biochemistry . . . . . . . . . A . The Unit Hypothesis of the Chromomere . . . . . . B . Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. RNA Synthesis and Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . D . RNA Transport from the Nucleus and Nucleocytoplasmic Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . The “Puff Proteins” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F . Histones and Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . DNA Synthesis and Puffing . . . . . . . . . . . H . “DNA Puffs” . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Puffs: Developmental Physiology . . . . . . . . . . A . Developmental Specificity . . . . . . . . . . . B. Intragland Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Tissue Specificity of Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . The Endocrine Control of Puffing Activity . . . . . . . . A . Ecdysone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Mechanism of Ecdysone Action . . . . . . . . . C. JuvenileHormone . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . The Experimental Modification of Puffing Activity . . . . . IX . Modification of Polytene Chromosome Structure and Function as the Result of Infection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X . The Physiology of Nurse Cell Polytene Chromosomes . . . . XI . The Physiology of Epidermal Cell Polytene Chromosomes . . XI1. The Physiological and Functional Significance of Puffing . . . A . Salivary Gland Function . . . . . . . . . . . B . Specific Correlations of Puffs and Salivary Gland Function C . General Considerations on the Physiological Function of Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI11. Conclusions and Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Notes Added in Proof . . . . . . . . . . . . . .‘ . . . vii
2 2 4 7 7 8 9 10 10 11 12 17 18 19 21 21 24 24 28 31 32 32 40 46 47 51 54 56 59 59 64 68 69 71 93
...
Vlll
CONTENTS
THE STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF THE INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS LESLEY J . GOODMAN
I . Introduction . . . . I1. Distribution and Structure A.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Distribution and Development of Dorsal Ocelli within the Class Insecta . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. The Visual Field of the Ocelli . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Form Perception 111. Behavioural Studies on the Role of the Ocelli . . . . . . . A . Early Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. The Ocelli as Stimulatory Organs . . . . . . . . . C . The Ocellar Contribution to Phototactic Orientation . . D . Detection of thePlaneofPolarized Light . . . . . . E . Registration of Intensity Level and of Changes of Intensity IV . Electrical Activity in the Ocellus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . The Electrical Response of the Visualcells B. Electrical Activity in the Second Order Neurons . . . . C. Sensitivity, Light and Dark Adaptation and Flicker Fusion Frequency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . The Spectral Sensitivity of Ocelli . . . . . . . . V . Ocellar Units in the Brain and Ventral Nerve Cord . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Ocellar Units in the Brain . . . . . . B. Ocellar Unitsin the Ventral Nerve Cord C. The Effect of Ocellar Input on Compound Eye Units . . D. The Influence of the Ocelli on Motor Activity in the Thoracic Ganglia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
97 99 99 101 131 131 132 132 133 141 147 148 152 152 161 164 170 171 171 173 182 184 188 190
POLARITY AND PATTERNS IN THE POSTEMBRYONIC DEVELOPMENT OF INSECTS PETER A . LAWRENCE I. I1 .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cell Polarity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Insect Segmental Gradients . . . . . . . . . . B. Origin of the Segmental Gradient . . . . . . . . C . Polarized Transmission of Information During Growth and Regeneration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Growth and Gradients . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Gradients and Patterns . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Insect Segmental Gradient: a Summary of the Working Hypothesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . Gradient Phenomena in Other Organisms: a Comparison .
197 198 199 206 207 212 216 220 22 1
CONTENTS
111.
Pattern Formation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . The Development of Spaced Bristles and Hairs in Rhodnius and Oncopeltus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Genetic Mosaics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Determination and Regulation . . . . . . . . . . . A . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Experiments w i t h c u t Discs-Regulation . . . . . . . C. Dissociation Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . D . Changes in the Determined State . . . . . . . . . V . Cellular Differentiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References
ix 224 224 231 235 235 237 247 254 257 259 260 260
REGULATION OF INTERMEDIARY METABOLISM. WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE CONTROL MECHANISMS IN INSECT FLIGHT MUSCLE BERTRAM SACKTOR I. I1.
111.
IV .
V.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 268 Physiological Properties and Structural Organization of Insect Flight Muscle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 269 A . Utilization of Oxygen during Flight . . . . . . . . 269 . . . 269 B. Supply of Oxygen and Fuel t o the Flight Muscle C . Nature of the Substrate Consumed during Flight . . . 271 D . Properties of the Contractile Proteins . . . . . . . 271 E . Morphological Organization of Flight Muscle . . . . . 275 F. Structural-Functional Correlates . . . . . . . . . 281 Regulation of Carbohydrate Metabolism . . . . . . . . 281 A . Glycogenolysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 283 B. Phosphorylase b Kinase . . . . . . . . . . . . 295 C. Glycogen Synthetase . . . . . . . . . . . . . 295 D . Trehalase . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 296 E . Biosynthesis of Trehalose . . . . . . . . . . . 300 F . Glycolysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 303 . 310 G . Identification of Other Loci of Control of Metabolism Regulation of Fat Metabolism . . . . . . . . . . . 312 A . Fatty Acid Catabolism . . . . . . . . . . . . 313 B . The Role of Carnitine . . . . . . . . . . . . 314 C. Biosynthesis of Fat . . . . . . . . . . . . . 316 D . Mobilization and Transport of Fat . . . . . . . . 319 Regulation of Mitochondria1 Metabolism . . . . . . . . 322 . 323 A . The Respiratory Chain and Oxidative Phosphorylation . . . . . . . . . 325 B. Control of Pyruvate Oxidation C. Control of Proline Oxidation . . . . . . . . . . 330 D . Control of cwGlycero-P Oxidation . . . . . . . . 332 . . 333 E . The Energy-Dependent Accumulation of Ca2+and Pi
A.1.P.-I*
X
CONTENTS
F.
Interactions of Metabolic Effectors with the Respiratory Chain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 334 VI . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 336 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 338 CELLULAR MECHANISMS UNDERLYING BEHAVIOR -NEUROETHOLOGY GRAHAM HOYLE Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Insects and Ethology . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Behavior Amenable to Analysis: Defining Neuroethology I1 . Neural Architecture and Physiology . . . . . . . . . A . Anatomy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Cellular Physiology of Motorneurons . . . . . . C. The Electrical Activity of Neuropil . . . . . . . D . Mechanism of Habituation . . . . . . . . . . E. Memory and “Learning” Machinery . . . . . . . 111. Motor Mechanisms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Respiration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Perambulatory Locomotion . . . . . . . . . D. Flight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Insect Song: Crickets . . . . . . . . . . . F . Courtship Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Modelsof Neural Activity and Terminology . . . . . . V . Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Note Added in Proof . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I.
AUTHOR INDEX . . . . . . . . . . SUBJECT INDEX . . . . . . . . . . . CUMULATIVE LIST OF AUTHORS . . . . CUMULATIVE LIST OF CHAPTER TITLES . .
.
. . .
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
349 349 353 356 356 361 375 387 392 398 398 401 403 408 412 417 420 425 430 431 439
. . . . . . . . . . 445 . . . . . . . . . 457
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
471 473
ERRATUM TO VOLUME 6
Page 241, lines 32 and 33 should read:
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Function and Structure of Polytene Chromosomes During Insect Development MICHAEL ASHBURNER Department of Genetics, University of Cambridge, England Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Polytene Chromosome Structure . . . . . . . . . . . Polyteny and Endopolyploidy during Insect Development . . The Occurrence of Polytene Chromosomes . . . . . . . A. Larval Tissues of Diptera . . . . . . . . . . . B. Pupal and Adult Tissues of Diptera . . . . . . . . C. Polytene Chromosomes in other Organisms . . . . . V. Puffs: Introduction and Biochemistry . . . . . . . . . A. The Unit Hypothesis of t h e Chromomere . . . . . . B. Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. RNA Synthesis and Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . D. RNA Transport from the Nucleus and Nucleocytoplasmic Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. The “Puff Proteins”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Histones and Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. DNA Synthesis and Puffing . . . . . . . . . . . H. “DNA Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Puffs: Developmental Physiology . . . . . . . . . . A. Developmental Specificity . . . . . . . . . . . B. Intragland Variation . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Tissue Specificity of Puffs. . . . . . . . . . . . VII. The Endocrine Control of Puffing Activity . . . . . . . . A. Ecdysone . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Mechanism of Ecdysone Action . . . . . . . . . . C. Juvenile Hormone . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII., The Experimental Modification of Puffing Activity . . . . . IX. Modification of Polytene Chromosome Structure and Function as the Result of Infection . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. The Physiology of Nurse Cell Polytene Chromosomes . . . . XI. The Physiology of Epidermal Cell Polytene Chromosomes . . . XII. The Physiological and Functional Significance of Puffing . . . A. Salivary Gland Function . . . . . . . . . . . B. Specific Correlations of Puffs and Salivary Gland Function c. General Considerations on the Physiological Function of Puffs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XIII. Conclusions and Outlook References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Notes Added in Proof . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I. 11. 111. IV.
1
2 2 4 7
7 8 9 10 10 11 12 17 18 19 21 21 24 24 28 31 32 32 40 46 47 51 54 56
59 59 64 68 69 71 93
2
M. ASHBURNER
I. INTRODUCTION “How do the adult characteristics lie latent in the germ cell; and how d o they become patent as development proceeds? This is the final question that looms in the background of every investigation of the cell.” E. B. Wilson: “The Cell in Development and Inheritance”, 1896.
With characteristic insight Edmund Wilson, over half a century ago, posed a question that is still unanswered and still remains central to many investigations into the biology of cells and organisms. It is now widely recognized that an answer to this question must be sought through an understanding of the mechanisms of control of gene activity. A wide variety of “model systems” are currently under close scrutiny with an equally wide variety of experimental techniques. Only in exceptional circumstance has nature provided us with a “system” in which differential gene activity, and its control, can be analysed directly at the level of the genes themselves. The giant chromosomes of Diptera afford one such example and their contribution to the problems of gene control and of the control of development is the subject of the present review. For earlier reviews the reader is referred to: Beermann (1956, 1959, 1962, 1965b); Berendes and Beermann (1969); Clever (1966a, 1968); Kroeger and Lezzi (1966); Laufer (1968) and Swift (1 962).
11. POLYTENE CHROMOSOME STRUCTURE
Balbiani (1881), during a histological study of the nuclei of the salivary glands of larval chironomids, was impressed by the presence, in these nuclei, of “un corps pile, qui a la forme d’un cordon cylindrique diversement enroulC sur lui-mCme A la manicre d’un intestin”. The significance of the structures observed by Balbiani was to remain enigmatic for over 50 years, despite occasional researches (see Tanzer, 1922; Makino, 1938). In 1933 Heitz and Bauer, and Painter independently rediscovered Balbiani’s “cordon nuclCaire” in the Malpighian tubules of Bibio hortulanus” and in the larval salivary glands of Drosophila melanogaster respectively. The intranuclear structures observed by Balbiani and subsequent cytologists were shown, by both investigations, to be homologous with mitotic chromosomes. Considerable controversy developed as to the exact *In all cases the taxonomic nomenclature of the original publications has been retained.
PUFFS
3
structure of these “giant chromosomes” and their relationship to regular mitotic chromosomes but the “polytene hypothesis”, originally proposed by Koltzoff ( 1 934) and modified by Bauer (1935), is now fully accepted (Bauer and Beermann, 1952; Beermann and Pelling, 1965). The reviews of Alfert (1954) and Beermann (1962) may be consulted for a complete consideration of the evidence as the following is only a brief account. Polytene chromosomes develop from the chromosomes of diploid nuclei by successive duplication of each chromosome element. Usually the homologous chromosomes pair early during this process and remain paired throughout polytenization. The chromosome duplication involved differs from that typical of a normal mitotic cycle in many respects: (i) the homologues remain paired, (ii) the chromosomes fail to participate in the normal mitotic cycle of coiling and uncoiling, (iii) daughter chromosomes do not segregate but remain intimately paired with each other at the end of each replication cycle, and (iv) the nuclear membrane and nucleoli remain intact throughout the replication cycles. The final product of the 9 or 10 cycles of replication characteristic of the salivary gland nuclei of Drosophila, for example, is a nucleus containing the haploid number of giant chromosome elements each composed of from 1000-2000 individual “chromosomes” in intimate apposition-as if a multistranded cable. Along the linear axis of each constituent chromosome (often known, in this context as “chromonemata”) variation in the extent of coiling (tertiary structure) of the DNA and its associated histones leads to variation in the concentration of these substances. Regions of high concentrations are known as chromomeres. For each chromosome the pattern of chromomeres is highly specific so that in the polytene chromosome homologous chromomeres align alongside each other exactly and usually appear to fuse as a band across the polytene element. The banding pattern of polytene chromosomes is such a stable and specific feature of their organization that the individual bands can be recognized, mapped and assigned reference numbers. In the interchromomeric, or interband, regions the DNA and histone concentration is lower than in the bands; the DNA content of bands and interbands being in the ratio of 20 : 1 in Drosophila rnelanogaster (Paul and Mateyko, 1967). In contrast to the highly-coiled state of the DNA-protein fibres in the bands they are aligned more or less parallel to the long axis of the chromosomes in the interband regions (MacInnes and Uretz, 1966; but see Wetzel
4
M. ASHBURNER
et al., 1969), although small local variations in coiling do occur here also (Sorsa and Sorsa, 1967). Claims (e.g. Steffenson, 1963) that DNA is absent from the interbands are now known to be incorrect (Swift, 1962; Lezzi, 1965; Wolstenholme, 1965, 1966). The pattern of bands and interbands of each polytene chromosome is not only specific for the species but is characteristic of that particular chromosome no matter in which tissue of the animal it is found. The “Istanbul hypothesis” of tissue specific variability in banding patterns (e.g. Kosswig and Sengun, 1947; Sengun, 1954) is incorrect (Berger, 1940; Beermann, 1950; Dreyfus et al., 195 1; Slizinski, 1950) at least insofar as the larval tissues of Diptera are concerned. The level of polyteny attained in any particular tissue is usually characteristic-for example by the end of the third larval instar the fat body of D. melanogaster possesses polytene chromosomes with a 64C DNA value whilst the salivary gland chromosomes reach the 1024C level (Alfert, 1954; Rodman, 1967b). As a general rule the number of duplications is identical for each chromosome of a particular nucleus; exceptions have been described by Melland (1942) for the chironomid Anatopynia varius and by White (1948) for the cecidomyiid Camptomyia sp. In both of these species one chromosome (the smallest of the complement in each case) appears to be of a higher level of polyteny than the other chromosomes.
111. POLYTENY AND ENDOPOLYF’LOIDY DURING
INSECT DEVELOPMENT
Growth resulting from an increase in the size of relatively few cells, rather than an increase in cell number through cell division, is a phenomenon well known in the Insecta (Trager, 1937). Such growth is, of course, accompanied by a parallel increase in nuclear size and DNA content. In most groups of the Insecta, other than the Diptera, the mechanism of nuclear. growth involves the reduplication of each chromosome within an intact nuclear membrane, the individuality of each chromosome being retained. Such a process is known as endomitosis and has been reviewed by Geitler (1953) and more recently studied by Nur ( 1968). Endopolyploid nuclei attain DNA contents often of the same order of magnitude as polytene nuclei. Endopolyploidy and polyteny are not mutually exclusive
PUFFS
5
mechanisms of nuclear growth as the following discussion will illustrate. Furthermore under certain circumstances transitions from endopolyploidy to polyteny, and vice versa, occur during development. The functional significance of polyteny vs. endopolyploidy is obscure; presumably the available surface area of chromatin in an endopolyploid nucleus of a given ploidy is greater than that in a polytene nucleus of similar DNA content. A further factor may be that extensive invagination and lobulation of the nuclear membrane of a polytene nucleus may lead to such compartmentalization of the nucleus that the transfer of substances between different chromosomes and different chromosome regions would be impeded. In an endopolyploid nucleus with each chromosome represented individually many times no such barrier would exist. While polytene nuclei are usually spherical or approximately so in form, endopolyploid nuclei often assume bizarre shapes (for example the spinning gland nuclei of Lepidoptera and Trichoptera), a consequence of which is an extensive increase in their surface area. The interrelationship between endopolyploidy and polyteny is perhaps best studied in the salivary gland nuclei of larval Cecidomyiidae. In the predacious genus Lestodiplosis the larval salivary gland possesses, in its anterior region, one or two “super giant” cells containing from 16 to 32 representatives of each of the four chromosomes-each of these elements themselves being polytene, i.e. these nuclei are endopolyploid polytene nuclei. In Lestodiplosis a single super giant cell is present containing numerous chromosomes, while the nuclei of the main region of the gland have four normal polytene elements (White, 1946). Henderson (1967a) has described another example of endopolyploid polytene nuclei in the super giant cells of the salivary gland of Lestodiplosis pisi, whilst Ashburner and Henderson ( 1969) have studied further examples. From a study of the development of these nuclei Henderson ( 1967a) concludes that the endopolyploidy results from the progressive splitting of the four chromosome elements of a standard polytene nucleus with the haploid number of chromosomes. In addition to this he suggested that the fusion of two cells into a single one may have contributed to the growth and development of the single super giant cell found by White. Coincident endopolyploidy and polyteny in larvae of Dmyneuru urticue (Cecidomyiidae) parasitized by platygasterids has been studied by Matuszewski (1964). The nuclei of the cells which surround the developing hymenopteran embryos possess up to 240
6
M. ASHBURNER
polytene chromosome elements, suggesting that they are either 60n or 120n nuclei ( n = 4). In this particular case it is likely that polytenization has followed endopolyploidy by the polytenic replication of a large number of individual chromosome elements. The disintegration, by fibrillation, of polytene chromosomes resulting in typical reticular endopolyploid nuclei appears to be a sequence normal to salivary-gland nuclear development in many Cecidomyiid larvae. This occurrence was first suggested by White (1948) on the basis of the nuclear morphology of the “transitional zone” in salivary glands of Dasyneura affinis. It has been subsequently confirmed and studied by Matuszewski (1 965) in D. urticae, by Henderson (1967b) in D. crataegi and by Ashburner and Henderson (1969) in a variety of Cecidomyiinae. While the range of chromosome behaviour is extraordinary, the developmental sequence is basically as follows. In first instar larvae the linear posterior region of the gland (approximately 6 4 cells) is very small in relation to the wide anterior region of 8-32 cells. All gland nuclei possess polytene chromosomes, usually four elements. As growth proceeds the posterior region becomes much larger than the anterior region. Indeed in many species the anterior region collapses, and its nuclei degenerate, near pupation. During this growth phase the two smallest polytene chromosomes of the posterior region may fibrillate into bundles of smaller and smaller multiplicity and finally into their constituent haploid elements. Whether or not this process is accompanied by chromosome replication is unknown. When the fibrillation of these small elements is well advanced the larger chromosomes (which usually bear nucleoli) may also. go through a similar process and the nuclei become completely endopolyploid. In some species (e.g. Putoniella marsupialis) a similar sequence of events may occur, but later during development, in the anterior gland nuclei. The speed or completeness of these cytological changes, relative to gross morphological development, varies greatly between different species. They may also be modified by, for example, secondary polytenization of endopolyploid posterior gland nuclei (in Perrisia ulmariae, Ashburner and Henderson, 1969) or by transverse chromosome fragmentation, described in Mikiola fagi and Rhabdophaga saliciperda by Kraczkiewicz and Matuszewski ( 1958). The organization of chromosomes in polyploid nuclei can also be influenced by environmental circumstances. The salivary-gland nuclei of larval Aphiochaeta xanthina (Phoridae) are typically polytene only when the larvae are grown under optimal nutritional conditions.
PUFFS
7
When either protein or fat are in short supply these nuclei are endopolyploid (Barigozzi and Semenza, 1952). Transitions between endopolyploidy and poly teny in the nurse cell nuclei of Diptera were first described by Bauer (1938) and have been studied recently by Bier. This work will be discussed below. IV. THE OCCURRENCE OF POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES A. LARVAL TISSUES OF DIPTERA
Polytene chromosomes have been reported in many families of Diptera in both larval tissues destined for histolysis at metamorphosis (e.g. salivary gland, midgut, rectum, fat body and muscle cells) and in larval tissues that persist intact into the imago (e.g. Malpighian tubules, brain) (Makino, 1938). These polytene chromosomes have been studied in the following families: NEMATOCERA; Psychodidae (Pavan et ul., 1968), Mycetophilidae (including Sciarinae) (e.g. Metz, 1 9 3 9 , Bibionidae (Heitz and Bauer, 1933), Cecidomiidae (e.g. White, 1948), Chironomidae, Scatopsidae (Mainx, 1949), Ptychopteridae (Mainx, 1949), Limnobiidae (Mainx, 1949), Culicidae (e.g. Sutton, 1942; Kitzmiller, 1968; Kiknadze, 1967), and Simuliidae (e.g. Painter and Griffen, 1937; Rothfels and Dunbar, 1953); BRACHYCERA; Leptidae (Mainx, 1949), Scenopinidae (Mainx, 1949); ASCHIZA; Phoridae (Mainx, 1949; Barigozzi and Semenza, 1953); ACALYPTRATAE; Coelopidae (Philip, 1966), Trypetidae (Frizzi and Springhetti, 1953; Krimbas, 1963), Drosophilidae, and Agromyzidae (Mainx, 195 1 ; Block, 1969). The various larval tissues of Drosophilu virilis were surveyed by Makino ( 1938) who found polytene chromosomes of varying sizes in: salivary gland, oesophagus, proventriculus, gastric caecae, midgut, Malpighian tubules, fat body, trachael wall cells, muscle cells and posterior ganglion. More recent investigations allow the addition to this list of: nerve cells and anal gill nuclei in Chironomids (Melland, 1942), rectal gland nuclei and the nuclei of the cell complex associated with the humeral imaginal disc in D. rnelunogaster (Lamprecht and Remensberger, 1966). Not all larval tissues of Diptera have polytene chromosomes; for example the binucleate “Guirlandzellen” of Weismann have endopolyploid nuclei in Drosophilu (Ashburner, unpublished), while the larval salivary gland nuclei of some families (e.g. Tipulidae) are endopolyploid.
8
M. ASHBURNER
B. PUPAL AND ADULT TISSUES OF DIPTERA
In their study of bristle differentiation of Drosophila melanogaster, Lees and Waddington (1942) noted that the nuclei of both trichogen and tormogen cells “become very large, and contain deeply staining threads which show much the same structure as the salivary gland nuclei”. Although these authors appear to be in two minds as to the exact nature of these nuclei-whether polytene or endopolyploid-there is no doubt from the recent work of Ribbert and of Whitten that, in the Calliphoridae, at least, large polytene chromosomes develop in the nuclei of many epidermal cells during the period of secretion of the adult cuticle and its appendages. These studies, with Calliphora erythrocephala (Ribbert, 1967), C. stygia (Thomson, 1969),Surcophaga bullata (Whitten, l963,1964a, 1969d), and Lucilia cuprina (Childress, 1969) will be fully considered below (Section XI). The occurrence of polytene chromosomes in the ovarian nurse cells of Diptera, and their discovery by Bauer (1938) have already been mentioned. Bauer (1938) and later Painter and Reindorp ( 1939) have described polytene chromosomes of low multiplicity during the early growth period of the nurse cell nuclei of Lucilia and Drosophila melanogaster respectively. Later during development these poly tene elements fall apart into their constituent chromosomes, a process recalling that described for the salivary-gland nuclei of Cecidomyiidae, and the nuclei subsequently grow by endomitotic duplication. This process has been studied in detail by Bier (1957, 1958, 1959, 1960) in the nurse cell nuclei of Calliphora erythrocephala. Up to the 16C-32C stage these nuclei possess well-developed polytene chromosomes. Normally these chromosomes fibrillate and subsequent growth is, as described by Bauer and by Painter and Reindorp, by endoduplication. Under certain conditions however nuclei of 512C to 2048C develop typical polytene chromosomes from endopolyploid nuclei. These polytene chromosomes are known as secondary polytene chromosomes. Functional aspects of nurse cell chromosome behaviour will be discussed in Section X. In Drosophila melanogaster the nurse cell nuclei of certain female sterile mutants develop polytene chromosomes during advanced growth stages. They have been described by King et al. (1961), and Klug et al. (1 968), and further studied by Schultz (1965). Various experimental treatments also result in the formation of polytene nurse cell chromosomes in D. melanogaster, e.g. X-rays (King, 1957
PUFFS
9
quoted in Jacob and Sirlin, 1959) or the feeding of 5-aminouracil. Nurse cell polytene chromosomes have been described from a number of families of Diptera by Stalker (1954), e.g.: Cecidomyiidae, Empididae, Dolichopodae, Agromyzidae, and Tachinidae. In Rhynchosciara angelae (Sciarinae) Basile (quoted by Pavan, 1965b) claims that the nurse cell nuclei are of the endopolyploid polytene type. Other tissues of Diptera with polytene nuclei include the adult Malpighian tubules, the vesiculae seminales (in Rhynchosciara angelae, Pavan and Breuer, 1955), the pupal heart (in Sarcophaga bullata, Whitten, 1963), and adult salivary glands in the Simuliid Boophthora erythrocephala (Welsch e t al., 1968). C. POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES IN OTHER ORGANISMS
With the exception of the well-known instances in higher plants (e.g. Nagl, 1969a, b), it was, until recently, considered that polytene chromosomes were not to be found outside the Diptera. We now know that they occur in the macronuclei of some Ciliates (Golikova, 1964; Alanso and P6rez-Silva, 1965; Ammermann, 1965; Radzikowski, 1967) and also in another insect group, the Collembola. The polytene chromosomes of the salivary gland cells of adult Collembolla were first described by Prabhoo ( 1961) in Womersleya sp., but have been more closely studied by Cassagnau in various species of Neonura and in Bilobella massoudi (Cassagnau, 1966, 1968). In the last-named species large polytene chromosomes, with characteristic banding patterns, occur in the distal region of the posterior salivary gland. These polytene chromosomes possess some unique morphological features, most strikingly the “echarpe hCtCrochromatique” which are regions of the chromosomes swollen to 3-5 times the normal chromosome diameter whilst retaining a typical banding pattern. Cassagnau ( 1968) is of the opinion that these specializations of the chromosomes represent the centromeric regions. In contrast to the typical Dipteran condition of complete pairing between homologues (although this is not always so in the Simuliids) the polytene chromosomes of the Collembolla are unpaired and the nuclei contain the diploid number (2n = 14 in Bilobella massoudi) of polytene elements. In other families of Collembolla (e.g. Pseudachorutini) the salivary gland nuclei are endopolyploid while an intermediate condition in the evolution of Collembolla polytene chromosomes is found in the Protanurini (Cassagnau, 1969).
10
M. ASHBURNER
V. PUFFS: INTRODUCTION AND BIOCHEMISTRY A. THE UNIT HYPOTHESIS OF THE CHROMOMERE
The pattern of bands (chromomeres) and interbands (interchromomeres) along polytene chromosomes is a constant enough character to allow these patterns to be mapped (Painter, 1933) and for each band to be assigned a reference number (Bridges, 1935). A very major advance in the study of these chromosomes was the demonstration of the colinearity of these cytogenetic maps and of the standard genetic map of mutant loci in D. melanogaster (Bridges, 1937). By a variety of genetic techniques it has proven possible to map mutant loci to small regions or even to single polytene chromosome bands (summarized in Lindsley and Grell, 1968). For technical reasons this analysis has been most extensive for the X chromosome of D. melanogaster (Sutton, 1943), and in the region of the white and Notch loci the phenotypic effects of the deletion or duplication of any one of a number of bands has been studied (Beermann, 1967a, b reviews the literature; see also Rayle and Green, 1969). The “one-to-one correspondence” (Beermann, 1967b) of bands and classical genes is a popular hypothesis that has considerable heuristic value. That it can only be an approximation to the true state of affairs is illustrated by the following considerations. Estimates of the DNA content of individual bands are technically extremely tedious and involve a number of assumptions. Despite this the results of two independent investigations have been published and agree remarkably well. Rudkin ( 1965) used microspectrophotometry to estimate that an average band of the D. melanogaster polytene chromosome has a DNA content of 0.3 x g/haploid unit. The smallest measurable bands contained 0.05 x g DNA/haploid unit. By chemical means Daneholt and Edstrom (1 967) estimated that the average Chironomus tentuns salivary gland chromosome band had a DNA content of 1 x g/haploid unit. Both groups of data are approximations in part due to the difficulties of experimental technique and in part to assumptions about the actual number of bands and about the DNA content of the interband and heterochromatic regions. However they are unlikely to be in error by more than one order of magnitude. g as the average DNA content per haploid unit of a Taking band this is equivalent to a linear length of DNA of 40 1-1 corresponding to lo5 base pairs (Daneholt and Edstrom, 1967; Panitz, 1968), sufficient to code for 30,000 amino acids.
PUFFS
11
Wolstenholme e t al. ( 1 968) and Berendes (cited in Berendes and Beermann, 1969) have measured the lengths of DNA strands prepared from salivary gland nuclei by the Kleinschmid t technique. In Chironomus tentans the mean strand length was 46.7 p (Wolstenholme e t al., 1968) and in Drosophila melanogaster the mean length was 37 p. In both studies the range of sizes of DNA molecules varied over an order of magnitude or more. These data are in apparent conflict with the cytogenetic evidence which leads to the conclusion “one band; one gene”. The paradox has been succinctly stated by Daneholt and Edstrom (1967): “this g) is an unlikely high number for a cistron and suggests that bands either represent operational units of great complexity or that a large part of the DNA is non-functional in the informational sense”. Evidence for the unitary function of bands extends beyond the cytogenetic data. Bands also behave as units with respect to both RNA and DNA synthesis (Pelling, 1965). It is unlikely that bands are units of “great functional complexity” yet despite considerable speculation (Beermann, 1965a; Callan, 1967), and some elegant observations (Keyl, 1965) the organization of the DNA within the bands, and the relation between its organization and its function, remains obscure (see discussion in Berendes, 1969). This fact should be borne in mind during the following discussion. B. PUFFS
Polytene chromosome puffs may be defined as structural modifications of the DNA and its associated substances of single bands which involve an uncoiling of the chromosome fibres allowing the synthesis of specific RNA species and the accumulation of RNA and other substances at that site. This accumulation often results in the enlargement of the specific chromosome region. This definition excludes the DNA puffs of the Sciarinae. The DNA puffs will be discussed more completely below but due t o their historical importance the following facts are of particular significance: DNA puffs are found only in this one family of Diptera and, like normal puffs, arise from individual polytene chromosome bands. The puffed chromosome region enlarges largely as the result of accumulation of DNA at the puff site not, as in the case of normal puffs, as the result of the accumulation of RNA and protein at the puff site. It should be pointed out that in addition t o DNA puffs the polytene chromosomes of the Sciarinae also form RNA puffs (often known as “bulbs” in this group).
12
M. ASHBURNER
The first study of puffs was that of Poulson and Metz ( 1 938) with Sciara ocellaris. They observed that the DNA puffs were modifications of particular bands or groups of bands and that they apparently underwent cyclical changes in size so that the appearance of the post-puff chromosome region differed only slightly from the pre-puff chromosome region. Poulson and Metz made the observation that within any single salivary gland all nuclei possessed the same spectrum of puffs yet there was considerable variability in the sites puffed between different individuals. They concluded that this variability was probably due to environmental differences, e.g. “extreme conditions, such as food, humidity or temperature”. Largely through the work of Beermann (1952a, b) Mechelke (1952) and of Pavan and Breuer (1952) it is now known that the reason for the variation in puffing observed by Poulson and Metz is the fact that there is very marked developmental specificity in the time of appearance and regression of puffs. Indeed, anticipating a later discussion, the DNA puffs of Sciara d o not form until very late in the last (fourth) larval instar (Breuer and Pavan, 1955; Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1964). As the result of his study of structural modifications of the polytene salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus tentans Beermann ( 1952b) proposed the hypothesis that “puffing indicates changes, most probably increases, in the activity of gene loci” (Beermann, 1956). We must now consider this hypothesis in the light of the results of recent investigations into the biochemistry and developmental physiology of puffs.
C. RNA SYNTHESIS AND PUFFS
Our current understanding of gene action demands, as a consequence of Beermann’s hypothesis, the synthesis of RNA at puff sites. Beermann himself showed that puffs, unlike unpuffed chromosome regions, stained metachromatically with toluidine blue (Beermann, 1952b) and Breuer and Pavan (1955) found that the DNA puffs of Rhynchosciara angelae exhibited an RNA reaction with methyl-green pyronin. Following the demonstration of a high rate of nuclear RNA synthesis in Drosophila salivary gland nuclei by Taylor (1953), Gross (1957) showed in the chironomid Metriocnemus hygropetricus that puffs selectively incorporated RNAse sensitive P3’. With the advent of more specific tritium labelled precursors Pelling (1959, 1964) analysed in great detail the
PUFFS
13
chromosomal incorporation of H3-uridine by salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus tentans. Pelling confirmed the earlier finding of Beermann that the puffs and Balbiani Rings (a name given to the few extraordinarily large puffs of Chironomids) of C. tentans stained red with toluidine blue while unpuffed regions stained blue. After treatment of the chromosomes with RNAse only the blue staining, due to DNA, remained. Like puffs, the RNA containing sites, as determined by toluidine blue metachromasia, were identical in each nucleus of an individual salivary gland, yet differed between the glands of different animals. In vivo incorporation of tritiated uridine into chromosomes was completely restricted to those sites that showed the RNA reaction with toluidine blue. Only a proportion of these sites were visibly puffed. This fact is important since it emphasizes that there is a continual gradation between condensed, inactive, bands and fully enlarged puffs. Cytological studies of puffing very often ignore many small puffs, or unpuffed active sites, due to the difficulty of unambiguous classification. It is usually assumed that the sample of sites observed cytologically as puffs is a random selection, at least with respect to physiological function, of all the active sites. The total number of active sites can only be determined by very detailed cytochemical and autoradiographic procedures such as those used by Pelling (1964). The use of these techniques allowed Pelling to estimate that, of the 1900 or so bands of the C. tentans salivary gland chromosomes, only 272 (1 5%) were ever active in the synthesis or accumulation of RNA during the last (fourth) larval instar. In general Pelling observed a good correlation between puff size and rate of incorporation of RNAse sensitive label after exposure to H3-uridine. In the salivary glands of C. tentans the smallest chromosome, chromosome IV, is notable in possessing three Balbiani rings (BR); incorporation of label into these three puffs accounted for approximately 25% of the total nuclear incorporation (which included label into two nucleoli). The largest of the BR was the most heavily labelled. In contrast the number of grains due to all of the puffs on the long chromosome I only accounted for some 20% of the total nuclear grain count. Puff formation was accompanied by an increase in synthesis, and puff regression by a decrease and eventual cessation of locus specific incorporation. Although the general relationship between puff size and rate of RNA synthesis is readily interpretable, Pelling did observe that between different individuals there were sometimes marked differences in the number
14
M. ASHBURNER
of grains over given BR despite an equivalence in the size of these puffs in the different animals. Similar observations were made by Gaudecker ( 1967). Such differences may be due to variations in, for example, pool size or in the accessibility of label, as suggested by Pelling (1964), but it is apparent that factors other than the rate of locus specific RNA synthesis may well be involved in the control of puff size (see Section D). The observation that puffs are sites of rapid and specific incorporation of RNA precursors has been amply confirmed, although not as thoroughly studied, in other Dipteran polytene chromosomes (Rudkin and Woods, 1959; Sirlin, 1960; Ritossa, 1962a; Fujita and Takemoto, 1963; Clever, 1964a; Berendes, 1967a, 1968a). Rudkin ( 1962) showed, in Drosophila melanogaster, a parallel increase in puff size and RNA content as determined by cy tophotometric techniques. He also showed the locus specific incorporation of H3-cytidine into puff RNA. The antibiotic actinomycin D is commonly used to suppress DNA dependent RNA synthesis. At concentrations between 0.1 and 1 pg/ml the incorporation of H3-uridine into puffs and the formation of new puffs is inhibited by actinomycin D (Ritossa and Pulitzer, 1963; Clever, 1967). However, not all puffs are affected equally by the drug (Beermann, 1965b; Clever, 1967). In Chironomus concentrations of actinomycin D of the order mentioned cause the actual regression of the BR, in addition to stopping RNA synthesis (Beermann, 1965b; Lauferetal., 1964; Kiknadze, 1965; Clever, 1967) yet the smaller puffs remain expanded (Clever, 1964a; but see Clever, 1967). After removal of actinomycin RNA synthesis slowly recovers in parallel with the reformation of the BR (Clever, 1964b; Clever and Romball, 1966). The process of normal puff regression is also sensitive to actinomycin D (Clever, 1967). High (e.g. 20 pglml) concentrations of actinomycin D do not result in BR regression in Chironomus despite the inhibition of RNA synthesis (Beermann, 1965b; Kiknadze, 1965). This is probably due to the binding of the actinomycin to the guanine residues of the DNA to such an extent that recoiling of the DNA is no longer possible; the DNA is thus “frozen” in its extended position. Actinomycin D has one further effect on polytene chromosomes. Both Kiknadze (1965) and Serfling (personal communication) have observed “puff” induction in Chironomus salivary gland and Malpighian tubule chromosomes after the treatment of larvae with actinomycin D. This occurs especially at the heterochromatic
PUFFS
15
centromere regions of the chromosomes and involves the accumulation, but apparently not the synthesis, of RNA and protein. It is presumably due in some way to disturbances in the normal mechanisms of transport of RNA and protein from the chromosomes (see p. 18). I t cannot necessarily be assumed that the RNA accumulating in these “centromeric puffs” reflects the activity of these chromosome regions themselves. In C. thurnmi identical puffs are induced by several acridines (Serfling, personal communication). The rate of RNA synthesis a t puff sites has not been accurately determined. Clearly it is rapid in view of the results of, for example, Ritossa’s experiments showing the appearance of label at puffs after only 30 s of in vitro availability (Ritossa, 1962a; also Gay, 1964; Arnold, 1965). Recently two groups of workers have published information pertinent to the problem of RNA stability in salivary glands of Chironornus. It has been known for some time that intermoult Chironornus larvae are relatively insensitive t o actinomycin D, metamorphic stages having a much greater sensitivity (Laufer et al., 1964). Clever et al. ( 1 969b) and Doyle and Laufer (1969b) have both now shown that protein synthesis continues in salivary glands of intermoult C. tentans larvae after considerable periods (up to 48 hr in the experiments of Clever et al.) of actinomycin D treatment. Furthermore Clever ( 1969) demonstrated that this protein synthesis, which continued in the absence of detectable RNA synthesis, included the synthesis of a specific secretory product-the “SZ” granules of C. palliduvitatus (see p. 64). Young fourth instar larvae and prepupae are more sensitive t o actinomycin D and drug treatment results in a reduction of protein synthesis and the inhibition of developmentally specific increases in the rate of protein synthesis (Clever et a l , 1969b). It can be concluded from these experiments that in intermoult larvae salivary gland secretion synthesis proceeds on relatively stable RNA templates yet during periods of rapid change in gene (puffing) activity there is some indication for the existence of more unstable species of template. Technical difficulties have so far prevented detailed analysis of the species and properties of RNA synthesized at individual puff loci. Such results that are available are from analyses of C. tentans RNA, and especially of the RNA of isolated fourth chromosomes and its Balbiani rings. The standard method of chromosome and BR isolation is by microdissection. Edstrom and Beermann (1962) subjected the RNA’s of various nuclear and cytoplasmic fractions t o
16
M. ASHBURNER
base frequency analysis by the microelectrophoretic techniques developed by Edstrom (1964b). They found that the base composition of the RNA’s from different chromosomes differed significantly from each other and from nucleolar and cytoplasmic RNA’s. Moreover three regions of the fourth chromosome, each carrying a single BR, had RNA’s of characteristic base composition, which in some instances differed from each other. The G C ratios of chromosomal RNA’s were unlike that of chromosomal DNA, and this fact, coupled with the lack of base symmetry of the RNA’s, suggested that they might be transcribed from one or other DNA chains, but not from both, along any particular nucleotide sequence (Edstrom, 1964a). To conclude that the RNA species studied by Edstrom and Beermann are messenger RNA’s would be premature on the basis of available evidence. Messenger RNA’s can only be identified operationally if they can be shown to be translatable into specific sequences of amino acids. Edstrom has recently extended his analysis of RNA’s from Chironomus salivary glands by a study of its physical characteristics through sedimentation behaviour in sucrose gradients (Edstrom and Daneholt, 1967). The RNA of the largest BR of chromosome IV of C. tentuns (BR2) is polydisperse in a sucrose gradient with sedimentation constants from 10s t o 70s. These results d o not warrant the conclusion that the RNA synthesized at the site of BR2 is similarly heterogeneous. Even assuming that the RNA profiles observed on the gradients represent species of RNA made at this site during the in vitro incubation period it is unlikely that a single BR can be isolated by microsurgery without the inclusion of adjacent active sites. Although Edstrom and Daneholt do not record the exact chromosome regions included in their “BR2” fraction this can be estimated from the data of Edstrom and Beermann ( 1 962). Figure 2(b) of this paper would indicate that at least six of Pelling’s (1964) active sites, in addition t o BR2, were included and may, therefore, have contributed RNA species to the material analysed. Analysis of the experiment of Edstrom and Daneholt is complicated further by our ignorance of (a) the effects of in vitro incubation on the types of RNA synthesized by the glands (see Greenberg, 1967) and (b) of the effects of fixatives (e.g. formalin used during the procedure of Edstrom and Daneholt) on the macromolecular structure of RNA. Although the identity of the RNA made at puff sites is far from being rigorously established, as is clear from the above discussion, we
PUFFS
17
can at least exclude the possibility that it is ribosomal RNA. In Drosophila melanogaster experiments of Ritossa and Spiegelman (1965) clearly indicate that the ribosomal RNA is synthesized under the direction of the DNA of the nucleolar organizer region, located at the base of the X and Y chromosomes. It seems rather unlikely (at least to this reviewer), that the remaining characterized class of major RNA’s, the transfer RNA’s, are the exclusive product of puffed sites. Several ancillary questions concerning the nature and function of puff RNA remain unanswered, for example: does the DNA of one puff code for one or more than one species of RNA? does all of the RNA made at puff sites reach the cytoplasm and function as template for protein synthesis? (see Harris, 1968); does some puff RNA have an intranuclear regulatory function? and so on. D. RNA TRANSPORT FROM THE NUCLEUS AND NUCLEOCYTOPLASMIC INTERACTIONS
Assuming that at least a fraction of puff RNA serves as messenger RNA it is necessary to postulate some mechanism for the transfer of this RNA from its site of synthesis (the chromosomes) to its site of function (the endoplasmic reticulum of the cytoplasm). Several studies of the ultrastructure of puffs have noted the presence, in these regions, of electron dense granules which have often been implicated in this transport process (Beermann and Bahr, 1954; Schurin, 1959; Swift, 1959, 1962, 1963; Berendes and de Bruyn, 1963; Jacob and Sirlin, 1963; Stevens, 1964; Kalnins et al., 1964a, b; Abramyan and Reingol’d, 1965; Stevens and Swift, 1966; Berry and Dietz, 1968; Smith, 1969; Sorsa, 1969). In Chironomus the diameter of the granules associated with the BR is of the order of 300-500 A. In Drosophila virilis Swift ( 1962, 1963) claims to have evidence that the size of the puff granules is a characteristic of particular puff sites. The attachment of the granules to thin ( 100 A ) chromatin fibres has been reported by a number of workers (Beermann and Bahr, 1954; Jacob and Sirlin, 1963; Kalnins et al., 1964a; Stevens and Swift, 1966). Enzyme digestion studies have led to the conclusion that chemically the granules are ribonucleoproteins (Swift, 1963). After actinomycin D treatment of salivary glands (1 pg/ml) alterations in granule morphology were found by Stevens ( 1964). Although predominant in puffed regions granules of very similar morphology are also present in the nuclear sap, in particular in
18
M . ASHBURNER
association with the nuclear membrane (Beermann and Bahr, 1954; Jacob and Sirlin, 1963; Abramyan and Reingol’d, 1965; Stevens and Swift, 1966; Beermann, 1966; Berry and Dietz, 1968). Stevens and Swift ( 1966), studying the granules of Chironomus thummi salivary gland nuclei describe a phenomenon interpreted as granule transfer from the nucleus through the membrane into the cytoplasm. After actinomycin D treatment the association of the BR granules with the nuclear membrane could no longer be detected in Chironomus by Stevens et al. (1965). Since naked informational RNA would presumably be vulnerable to hydrolytic breakdown within the cell it has been suggested that a complex of this RNA with the granules may be important for its protection and transport (see also the discussion in Spirin, 1966). Neither the site of manufacture of puff granules, nor their relation to the ribosomes (if any) is known. Lezzi (1967a) has discussed the possible role of ribosomes in RNA transport from puff sites. 0ther ultrastructural features of the Dipteran salivary gland nucleus have been described and considered to play a role in nucleocytoplasmic transport. Gay ( 1956, 1959) describes outpocketings of the salivary gland nuclear membrane of D. melanogaster and other species and suggests that the frequency of these “nuclear blebs” is correlated with the secretory activity of the gland, although no quantitative data have been published. In support of the idea that these blebs are concerned with nucleocytoplasmic transport Gay finds that they are often associated with chromosomal material. Similar blebs have been described by Berendes and de Bruyn (1963) in D. hydei, by Swift (1959) in D. virilis and by Kimoto (1958) in Chironomus dorsalis. Both Swift and Kimoto report an association of chromosomal material with the blebs (see also Section XI, below). E. THE “PUFF PROTEINS”
In addition to the accumulation of RNA-largely the result of “on site” synthesis-puffs are also characterized by the accumulation of a family of proteins which may be stained with fast green or light green at acid pH (Rudkin, 1955; Swift, 1959, 1962; Schurin, 1959; Clever, 1961, 1962a, 1964a). Newly activated puffs appear to contain especially large quantities of these “puff proteins” (Berendes, 1968a; Clever, 1965b) but their nature is far from being fully understood. The “puff proteins” differ from the chromosomal histones not only in the pH optimum for their stainability with fast
PUFFS
19
green, but also by the fact that, unlike histones, they are insoluble in 0.2 M HCI (Swift, 1964, see Black and Ansley, 1964). “Puff proteins” are apparently low in the proportion of cyclic amino acids (Rudkin, 1964). During puff induction the accumulation of puff proteins precedes any visible change in chromosome structure and detectable RNA synthesis (Berendes, 1968c, 1969; Pettit and Rasch, 1966). Lezzi (1967b) studied the effects of various enzymes on the puff proteins and as the result of these, and other cytochemical experiments, concluded that, as a class, the puff proteins closely resembled the proteins of ribosomes. It is probable that much of the acid protein detected in puffs is, in fact, associated with the ribonucleoprotein granules described above (Swift, 1964). Some part of the puff protein fraction, however, presumably plays other roles, e.g. RNA polymerase and regulatory functions. Ribonucleoprotein granules are not detectable until 20 min after puff induction although “puff proteins” are found within 3 min (Berendes, 1969). Unlike puff RNA the puff proteins are not synthesized at the puff site (Pelling, 1959; Sirlin, 1960; Ritossa and Pulitzer, 1963; Ritossa et al., 1965; Clever, 1964a; Berendes, 1967b; Cave, 1968). Puff induction does not involve protein synthesis (Clever and Beermann, 1963; Clever and Romball, 1964; Ritossa and Pulitzer, 1963; but see Pettit and Rasch, 1966), and will occur during the experimental inhibition of protein synthesis by antibiotics (loc. cit. and Ashburner, unpublished). Localized protein synthesis at puff sites has been described in isolated salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus tentans by Lezzi but is clearly a result of very abnormal physiological conditions perhaps leading to messenger translation at the puff site (Lezzi, 1967a). Recently Berendes (1968a) has published the results of an interesting experiment describing apparent puff induction whilst RNA synthesis was inhibited by actinomycin D. In fact it appears that most of the induction observed by Berendes in these experiments involved locus specific accumulation of puff proteins. F. HISTONES AND PUFFS
The histones of polytene chromosomes have been reviewed by Swift (1964) and in other studies from the same laboratory. The distribution of histones along polytene chromosomes parallels the distribution of DNA (Horn and Ward, 1957; Black and Ansley, 1964; Swift, 1964); that is the histone concentration is high in the bands
20
M. ASHBURNER
and low in the interbands. During the transformation of a band into a puff the histone concentration, like the DNA concentration, decreases as the chromatin involved expands to cover a larger area. The actual amount of histones remains unchanged during this process however. Gorovsky and Woodward (1966, 1967) measured the histone : DNA ratios of various bands and puffs in Drosophila virilis. This ratio was almost identical (0.36) in both condensed bands and expanded puffs. The theory that histones are important factors in the control of gene activity has been widely considered since its proposal by Stedman and Stedman (195 1) (e.g. Bonner, 1965 and de Reuck and Knight, 1966). The failure to find any substantial qualitative or quantitative variation in the histones of differentiated nuclei [for example the electrophoretic pattern of histones from Drosophila salivary gland nuclei and imaginal disc nuclei cannot be distinguished (Cohen and Gotchel, 1969)] has led recently to the proposal that perhaps more subtle changes of the histones are important for their supposed regulatory role. In particular Allfrey and his colleagues have suggested that the acetylation of histones is of great functional significance and claim a positive correlation between the extent of histone acetylation and the capacity for RNA synthesis of the DNA : histone complex (Allfrey et al., 1966). Of direct relevance to this interesting proposal are the experiments of Clever (1967) and Ellgaard (1967) who have both failed to find any selective chromosomal or puff incorporation of H3 -acetate during puff formation. Allfrey et al. (1 968) contested the significance of these results on the grounds that the fixation methods used (acetic acid/alcohol) would have dissolved the histones away. Despite this objection the cytochemical detection of histones is very satisfactory after treatment of the chromosomes with 45% acetic acid (Swift, 1964; Black and Ansley, 1964). Using acetic-alcohol as a fixative Allfrey et al. (1968) claim to have demonstrated the chromosomal incorporation of H3 -acetate into Chironomus thummi salivary gland chromosomes, but their data are by no means unequivocal. Benjamin et al. (1968) have recently published a preliminary report which suggests that the phosphorylation of polytene chromosome histones (in Sciara) may be important in the supposed regulatory role of histones. Robert and Kroeger (1965) have been successful in injecting trypsin into individual living salivary gland nuclei of Chironomus thummi. The effect of the enzyme is to increase the size, and rate of
PUFFS
21
H3-uridine incorporation into RNA, of preexisting puffs by a factor of 3. These authors interpret these results to indicate that in the puffs the tertiary structure of the histones is altered in some way so that it is more susceptible to trypsin attack than it is in unpuffed regions. The experimental results have been confirmed by Desai and Tencer (1968), after injection of trypsin into larvae. They also claim that injection of histones into the haemolymph of C. thummi larvae inhibits RNA synthesis in the salivary gland chromosomes. The rate of RNA synthesis in these experiments was followed autoradiographically with H3-uridine but in the absence of some measure of the ribonuclease activity of the histone preparations used the results are not readily interpretable. G. DNA SYNTHESIS AND PUFFING
It is not the aim of this review t o consider the large body of data concerning DNA synthesis and chromosome replication in polytene chromosomes. However a few remarks about the relationship between DNA synthesis and puffing are relevant. Excluding from consideration the DNA puffs of the Sciarinae (see below) no correlation between the time of DNA synthesis and puffing has ever been observed (Pelc and Howard, 1956; Schurin, 1957, quoted in Pavan, 1958; Rudkin and Woods, 1959; Ritossa, 1962a, 1964b; Schultz, in Pavan, 1965b; Sebeleva et al., 1965; Sebeleva, 1968) in either Drosophila or Chironomus. In a brief abstract Schultz and Rudkin (1960) published preliminary indications that there was disproportionately high early DNA synthesis at sites which form puffs in D. melunoguster but this observation was never confirmed. The report of Stich and Naylor (1958) of DNA accumulation at puff sites in the chironomid Glypotendipes was not sustained by Key1 ( 1963). H. “DNA PUFFS”
The sub-family Sciarinae appears to be unique amongst the Diptera in possessing “DNA puffs”. Studied by Poulson and Metz (1938) in Sciaru ocellaris and later by Pavan’s group in Rhynchosciura angelae and R. millen’ these puffs are characterized by the accumulation, at the sites of certain bands of polytene chromosomes, of large quantities of DNA. This accumulation results in the expansion of these chromosome regions. Typically DNA puffs exhibit a high degree of developmental specificity-only appearing at the end of the final (fourth) larval instar (often called the “prepupal A.I.P.-2
22
M. ASHBURNER
period” but not homologous with the prepupal stage of the cyclorrhaphan Diptera) (Dreyfus e t ul., 195 1 ; Pavan and Breuer, 1952; Breuer and Pavan, 1955; Pavan and Breuer, 1955; Mattingly and Parker, 1968a; Pavan and da Cunha, 1969b). The accumulation of DNA at puff sites in Rhynchosciuru was deduced on purely histochemical grounds by Breuer and Pavan (1955). This proposal met, originally, with some scepticism as it contravened the so-called rule of DNA constancy. Two types of experiment have, however, confirmed that DNA puffing does indeed result from the localized disproportionate synthesis of DNA. Cytophotometric measurements indicated “at least a doubling” of the DNA of puffed regions in R. ungelue during puff formation (Rudkin and Corlette, 1957). Later Rasch (quoted by Swift, 1962 and Rasch, 1966) measured the DNA content of individual Sciuru coprophilu salivary gland nuclei by similar methods. Before DNA puff formation the DNA measurements for the nuclei fell into a geometric series of classes with 256C : 512C; 1024C and 2048C DNA values. After the formation of the DNA puffs, late in the fourth larval instar, these classes were still discrete yet the distribution had become considerably skewed due t o the extra DNA synthesis at the puff loci. By measuring the relative DNA content of individual loci before, and during, puff formation Rasch confirmed the observations of Rudkin and Corlette. More recently Crouse and Key1 (1968) found, in Sciuru coprophilu, that disproportionate DNA synthesis at DNA puff sites involves complete rounds of replication-that is the DNA content of these puffs increases geometrically during puff formation. The second approach to this problem was that of Ficq and Pavan (1957, 1961) and Ficq e t ul. (1958), who demonstrated the local incorporation of radioactive thymidine into the DNA puff loci during puff formation. In addition to being sites of disproportionate DNA synthesis the DNA puffs are also sites of RNA synthesis (Ficq e t u l , 1958; Pavan, 1965a, b) and of histone (Swift, 1962) and non-histone protein synthesis (Ficq and Pavan, 1961; Ficq et ul., 1958; Mattingly, 1966). In the latter respects the DNA puffs differ from the normal, RNA, puffs. The RNA synthesized at the DNA puff sites may be eliminated from the chromosomes as small globules known as “micronucleoli” (Swift, 1962; Pavan, 1965a, b; Gabrusewycz-Garcia and Kleinfeld, 1966). The latter authors made a careful study of micronucleolar formation in Sciara coprophila. They found that
PUFFS
23
approximately 18% of the polytene chromosome bands were potential sites of micronucleolar formation, but that most of the sites were those involved in the formation of DNA puffs or were “heterochromatic” chromosome regions. With respect to RNA synthesis, greatest activity was found just prior to, and during, the early stages of DNA puff formation. At their maximum expansion the DNA puffs were not very active in RNA synthesis (but see Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1964). Granules, similar to those seen in Balbiani rings, are present at DNA puff sites (Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1968). Prior to pupation the DNA puffs regress. No transport of DNA from the puff sites has been observed in Rhynchosciara or Sciara sp. (Pavan, 1965b; Rasch and Pettit, 1967; Crouse and Keyl. 1968; Mattingly and Parker, 1968b), yet the majority of the DNA puffs do return to the normal banded chromosome condition. In the case of the largest puffs the post-puff band has a higher DNA content than before puff formation. In Hybosciara fragilis extrusion of DNA and associated ribonucleoprotein from DNA puff sites has been reported (da Cunha et al., 1969). This results in the formation of “micronucleoli” in the nuclear sap. These observations raise the question as to the exact nature of the “micronucleoli” of other species-perhaps these too contain DNA (see Ribbert and Bier, 1969). The exact relationship of the various “micronucleoli” of Sciarids to discrete chromosomal loci and to the nucleolus proper is an open question which should be resolved. It is clear that DNA puffing is a mechanism involving the amplification of localized regions of the genome. It is a phenomenon, therefore, which may well be functionally similar to nucleolar DNA amplification in the oocytes of amphibia (e.g. Gall, 1968) and insects (Bier et al., 1967; Gall et al., 1969). Perhaps related to DNA puff formation in the Sciarinae is the so-called “heterochromatin proliferation” described by Keyl and Hagele (1966). In the salivary gland chromosomes of some individuals of Chironomus melanotus large masses of DNA (and presumably of associated protein) were found t o be “budding off” from the heterochromatic kinetochore regions. These DNA bodies often severed their connections with the chromosomes to lie free in the nucleoplasm. Their subsequent fate was not clear. A similar process has been described in the cecidomyiid Dasyneura crataegi by Henderson ( 1967b), and in the epidermal cell polytene chromosomes
24
M. ASHBURNER
of Sarcophaga by Whitten ( 1 965) and Roberts (1 968) (see Section
XI). VI. PUFFS: DEVELOPMENTAL PHYSIOLOGY A. DEVELOPMENTAL SPECIFICITY
Puffs are transient modifications of polytene chromosome regions. Many, if not all, of them appear at specific stages during development, are active for varying periods of time, and then regress. These characteristics of puffs may be well illustrated by a general description of the changes in puffing that occur during larval development of Drosophila melanogaster (Becker, 1959; Ashburner, 1967a, 1969a). T o set this description in context it will first be necessary to give an abbreviated account of the development of Drosophila. After eclosion from the egg the larvae proceed through three larval stages of which the third is the longest and the period of most rapid growth. Near the end of the third larval instar the larvae migrate from the food and begin a period of wandering. Eventually they settle down (usually when 120 hr old), become immobile and form a puparium by the contraction and subsequent tanning of their cuticle. Within this puparium the epidermis soon separates from the larval cuticle to secrete a new, extremely delicate, cuticle. This event occurs 4 hr after puparium formation and the animals are now pharate fourth instar larvae (Snodgrass, 1924). Eight hours later the pharate larva moults again into the true pupa. The period between puparium formation and pupation is commonly, although loosely, called the “prepupal stage”. The salivary gland chromosomes of young third instar larvae possess few-perhaps five-obvious puffs. Not until some 10 hr before puparium formation d o any clear changes in the puffing pattern occur. Then, quite suddenly, puffs form, in a characteristic and regular sequence at a number of loci whilst some of the puffs active in younger stages regress. These changes continue, with new puffs appearing and some puffs regressing until, at puparium formation, some 70 sites are puffed. After puparium formation the actual number of sites puffed decreases although new puffs continue to appear. The period between 3 and 5 hr after puparium formation is one of generally low puffing activity. From 6 hr after puparium formation the number of puffs increases again reaching a peak in 8 hr prepupae. This is followed by a slow decline in puffing as pupation is approached. In D . melanogaster peak periods of puffing activity precede the
PUFFS
25
subsequent moults by 4 hr. With respect to these moults the puffs may be grouped into three classes: (i) those active at both periods, yet inactive in the intervening interval (44% of puffs), (ii) those active exclusively during one or other period (42%), and (iii) those puffs whose activity is not clearly related to the moults ( 14%). Similar changes in puffing activity with development have been described in other species of Drosophila, e.g. D. simulans (Ashburner, 1969a, b), D. hydei (Berendes, 1965a), D. busckii (Kroeger, 1960; Ashburner, unpublished), D. anannassae and D. takahashii (Ashburner, unpublished). The occurrence of very active periods of puffing activity during moulting has been studied in detail by Clever in Chironomus tentans. In contrast to the Acalyptrate Diptera (e.g. Drosophila) some Nematocera have a mobile pupal instar. In Chironomus there are four larval instars; the morphological changes, especially in the thoracic region, of old fourth instar larvae have often resulted in this stage being called a “prepupa”. This stage is not, however, completely homologous with the prepupal stage of Drosophila. Clever analysed changes in puffing activity of salivary gland chromosomes occurring during the moult from the third to four larval instars (Clever, 1963a) and during the larval/pupal moult (Clever, 1962a). He has also (Clever, 1962b) studied the puffing patterns of diapausing fourth instar larvae. From an analysis of the data presented by Clever for Chironomus tentans and of the Drosophila data, one major difference in the developmental behaviour of puffs in these two groups is apparent. The puffing patterns of three species of Drosophila have been more or less completely analysed ( 0 . melanogaster, D. simulans and D. hydei) and the results clearly show that the great majority (over 80%) of the puffs are active only at specific stages of development. In Chironomus, on the other hand, Clever stresses, and his data certainly confirm, that only a minority (perhaps 1Wo) of the puffs show such developmental specificity. In Chironomus the remaining puff sites are active more or less continuously and fail to show any variation in their activity that can be correlated with developmental events. Clever ( 1962a) thus distinguishes two classes of puffs: “entwicklungsspezifische Puffs” and “entwicklungsunspezifische Puffs”. It should be pointed out that this classification is by no means absolute: some of the “unspecific” puffs (e.g. 1-17B, I-19A) do show marked changes in size at certain developmental stages. This difference in puff behaviour between Drosophila and Chironomus is
26
M. ASHBURNER
probably of little physiological significance, and indeed may be more apparent than real. Clever routinely uses a sensitive cytochemical technique (orcein-light green) for the detection and scoring of puffs while workers with Drosophila rely, for technical reasons, largely on morphological criteria. Clever’s method probably detects a much higher proportion of the total number of active chromosome sites than would be seen on morphological criteria alone. In Drosophila there may well be a large number of puff sites, which are very small and not obvious by their effect on chromosome diameter, and whose activity is, in Clever’s sense developmentally unspecific. This point can only be settled by a very detailed analysis of puff sites in Drosophila, preferably by high resolution autoradiographic studies after uridine incorporation. Cytologically the first changes detectable in the puffing patterns of the salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus tentans before either the larval/larval or larval/pupal moults is the appearance of a puff at 18C on chromosome I, followed by puffing at 2B on chromosome IV and at 14A on chromosome I. During the moult from third to fourth instar larvae these are the only major puffing changes, the activity of most of the other puffs remaining unchanged throughout the moult. With the completion of ecdysis the puffs at I-l8C, IV-2B and I-14A regress. Only one puff, II14A2 was found by Clever to be specific for the larval/larval moult, although even this puff does show some activity at the subsequent larval/pupal moult. Whilst initially the changes in puffing that precede pupation are similar to those that preceded the larval/larval moult (i.e. activation of I-18C, IV-2B and I-14A) puffs appear later at at least four sites (1-1 1B2, I-A1, 11-14A and 111-9B) that have not been active during previous development. In addition Clever describes two groups of puffs active in late fourth instar larvae. The first group (I-17B and 1-19A) are puffs that were active since the third larval instar but did not increase in size during the larval/larval moult. They enlarge in late fourth instar larvae yet regress before pupation itself. The second group (e.g. I-13B and 11-6A) were not active previously, enlarge in the prepupal stage and continue active throughout the moult. After pupation the salivary glands of both Drosophila and Chironomus histolyse. In Chironomus, but not in Drosophila (Ashburner, 1967a), there is a very great reduction in puffing activity (especially at the “developmentally unspecific” sites) just prior to pupation. In diapausing fourth instar larvae the spectrum of potentially
PUFFS
27
active puff sites is identical t o that of non-diapause animals. There is, however, a marked reduction in the frequency of sites actually puffed. On initiation of metamorphosis in the diapause larvae the pattern of moult specific puff changes does not differ from that found in larvae which develop without a diapause (Clever, 1962b). Data comparable t o that of Clever are not available for any other species of Chironomid although some information has been published concerning the puffing patterns of two species, C. thummi and C. dorsulis. For C. thummi Kroeger (1964) described the activities of seven puffs during the pupal moult. Four of these puffs regress before the moult while three become active. One of these (puff IIIdl) woiild appear to be homologous with the puff I - l K of C. tentuns. According t o information published in Kroeger and Lezzi (1966) of 27 puffs investigated in C. thummi the activity of seven was developmen tally specific. In C. dorsulis Kiknadze and Filatova (1963) studied a total of 28 puffs on chromosomes I and 111. Ten of these were active in prepupae, but not earlier in the fourth instar, 14 larval puffs regressed before pupation, while the activities of the remaining three puffs remained unchanged during these periods. All puffs except one regressed after pupation (see Clever, 1962a). The exceptional puff ( 12A on chromosome I) was active only after the pupal ecdysis. The puffing patterns of another chironomid, Acricotopus lucidus, have been analysed by Mechelke (1952, 1958, 1962) and Panitz (1964). The salivary gland of this species is of great interest for, as will be discussed in detail below, it consists of three lobes, each lobe possessing a unique pattern of Balbiani rings. The BR3 and BR4 are present only in the anterior lobe of the gland and are active throughout the fourth larval instar. Just prior to pupation they regress (Mechelke, 1952, 1958). These BR are also active in third @star larvae and show some slight reduction in their activity during the moult to the fourth instar (Panitz, 1964). The BR of the other lobes of the gland (the side and main lobes) (i.e. B R l , BR2, and BR6) d o not show changes in activity correlated with gross developmental events. The DNA puffs of Sciarids show a developmental specificity similar to that described above. In Rhynchosciuru ungelue three major DNA puffs (on chromosomes B and C) form about midway through the prepupal stage (i.e. late fourth instar larvae). One puff on chromosome B reaches its maximum size first and is followed by the puff on chromosome C. By pupation both DNA puffs have
28
M. ASHBURNER
regressed (Breuer and Pavan, 1952). Similar events were found in R . milleri (Pavan and Breuer, 1955). More recently Mattingly and Parker (1968a) have studied a third species in this genus and analysed the behaviour of 13 DNA puffs through the fourth larval instar and pupation. These puffs appear and regress in an ordered fashion in a manner familiar from studies on Drosophila and Chironomus. There is a marked peak in puffing activity in 54-day-old larvae-that is the day prior to pupation. In passing it may be noted that Rhynchosciara larvae develop gregariously and that the larvae of any one group (the progeny of a single female) exhibit an almost incredible synchrony in their development throughout the long (50-60 day) larval period. Extensive DNA puff formation prior to pupation is typical also of Sciara ocellaris and S. coprophila (Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1964; Crouse, 1968). Gabrusewycz-Garcia ( 1964) also noted the developmental specificity of normal RNA puffs (“bulbs”) in S. coprophila. DNA puff formation at larval moults in Sciarids remains to be investigated . B. INTRAGLAND VARIATION
One approach in the study of puffs and their functional significance has been the comparison of puffing activities in the various regions of the salivary glands of those species whose glands show some morphological complexity. Dipteran larval salivary glands are paired ectodermal structures usually with a relatively low cell number that remains constant throughout the functional life of the gland. Frequently (e.g. in the drosophilids) the gland is asymmetric, one lobe being larger than the other. Even in those species where this asymmetry is particularly evident [ e.g. D. victoria (Wharton, 1943), D. lebanonensis (Ward, 1949)] no difference in puffing activity has been found between the two lobes (Berendes, personal communication). In the chironomid Prodiamesia olivacea the left and right lobes of the gland differ greatly in their shape (Melland, 1941) although no puff studies have been undertaken with this species. In many Chironomids, however, the individual lobes show some morphological specialization and the different regions of the gland differ in their pattern of puffing activities. The external form of the salivary glands of the closely related species Chironomus tentans and C. palliduvitatus is very similar. Yet in C. palliduvitatus a group of four cells (Sonderzellen) close to the duct differ from the remainder of the cells in possessing a particular type of secretion granule. In C. tentans the homologous group of cells do not differ in their
PUFFS
29
histological structure from the major part of the gland in this way. Beermann (1956, 1959) surveyed various species of Chironomus and discovered glands with Sonderzellen in representatives of the following genera: Cryptochironomus, Trichocludius (see Beermann, 1952a). Acricotopus and Zavrelia. In the subgenus Chironomus sensu strictu Beermann (1961) notes that all species studied, except C. tentans, possess from 4 to 6 Sonderzellen in the anterior region of the gland. Salivary gland organization in another chironomid (Orthocladid), Acricotopus lucidus is more complex: the gland has three distinct lobes. The anterior lobe accumulates beta-carotinoids during the prepupal stage (Mechelke, 1952; Baudisch, 1960, 1963a, 1967). The main and side lobes both differ from the anterior lobe in their high content of hydroxyprohne (Baudisch, 1960, 1963c, 1967). These differences in cell morphology and function within the salivary glands of Chironomids are reflected in differences in the pattern of activities of the Balbiani rings. In the nuclei of the Sonderzellen of C. palliduvitatus a small BR on chromosome IV is puffed; this locus is inactive in the other nuclei of the gland and is not present in any nucleus of the gland of C. tentans. Hybridization of the two species is possible in the laboratory and by virtue of species specific inversions their IVth chromosomes are distinguishable. Four Sonderzellen are seen in salivary glands of hybrid larvae but the number of cytoplasmic granules is lower than in C. palliduvitatus. Of the two fourth chromosomes in the hybrid the special BR SZ is active only on the C. palliduvitatus homologue. In segregating generations the ability to make the Sonderzellen granules and the inheritance of the SZ Balbiani ring parallel each other exactly. The Mendelian factor responsible for granule production in the Sonderzellen maps genetically at a site coincident with the location of the BR SZ (Beermann, 1961). There are, therefore, good reasons for proposing a causal relationship between the activity of the special BR and the differentiation of the Sonderzellen as witnessed by granule production (Beermann, 1961, see also Grossbach, 1968 and Section XII). Trichocladius vitripennis (Chironomid : Orthocladid) is another species with a group of special salivary gland cells. In this species the six Sonderzellen (which possess a granular cytoplasmic secretion) differ from the main gland in the activities of two BR. Furthermore a third BR, active in the “normal” cells is inactive in the special cells (Beermann, 1952a). A.I.P.-2*
30
M. ASHBURNER
Changes in the activities of the BR with the development of fourth instar larvae and prepupae complicates the pattern of intragland variation of BR in Acricotopus lucidus. In the carotin accumulating anterior lobe two BR (BR3 and BR4) are active in fourth instar larvae, but regress before pupation. Three other Balbiani rings show no obvious change in their activities with development. Two (BRl and BR2) are common to both the main and side lobes, whilst the third (BR6) is active only in the side lobe (Mechelke, 1952, 1958, 1962). Intragland variation in puffing activity has also been described in species which lack any clear morphological differentiation of their salivary glands. The sac-like gland of the Drosophilids is a case in point. In the repletu species group the distal salivary gland cells of mid third-instar larvae often possess cytoplasmic granules clearly visible in living preparations under phase contrast. With increasing age the boundary between these granule containing cells and the cells lacking the granules moves anteriorly and eventually nearly all of the cells contain granules (McMaster-Kaye, 1962; Berendes, 1965a). In D. hydei there is a correlation between the activity of a particular puff (47B) and the presence, in the cytoplasm, of the granules (Berendes, 1965a). Although salivary gland differentiation in D. melunoguster is not as clear as in D. hydei Becker (1 959) recorded that the X chromosome puff 15BC is larger in the proximal cells of the gland. The cytoplasm of these proximal cells is considerably more basophilic than that of the more distal, larger, cells. The salivary gland of Sciuru coprophilu is linear in form consisting of two rows of cells surrounding the lumen. The cells of the anterior region of the gland are larger than those of the posterior region, from which they are separated by a narrow neck. The DNA puffs of prepupae are active in both anterior and posterior regions (Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1964) but not in the neck cells (Crouse, 1968). Differences in the spectrum of DNA puffs active in the two main regions were noted by GabrusewyczGarcia ( 1964). In addition one RNA puff (bulb 111-15B) is only active in the anterior cells. Despite its enormous length (circa 2 cm) the salivary gland of Rhynchosciuru angelue is not differentiated and the DNA puff pattern of all nuclei is identical. The formation of the DNA puffs does, however, start slightly earlier during development in the anterior cells (Breuer and Pavan, 1955; Pavan, 1965a). Considerable intragland variation in DNA puff activity is found in certain abnormal individuals of this species (Pavan, 1965a).
PUFFS
31
C. TISSUE SPECIFICITY O F PUFFS
Differences in the activity of Balbiani rings distinguishing different larval tissues of Chironomus tentans was first studied by Beermann (1 952b). Although similar tissue specificity has been noticed by other workers (e.g. for the DNA puffs of Rhyncosciara by Breuer and Pavan, 1955) only Berendes (1965b, 1966) has studied this phenomenon in detail. Berendes compared the puffing patterns of the salivary gland, Malpighian tubule and midgut chromosomes of Drosophila hydei. In the first of these papers (Berendes, 1965b) he compared the puffing activities in salivary gland and stomach cells during the period 10-6 hr before puparium formation. A total of 116 different puffs were scored and of these 14 were active in the salivary gland, but not the stomach and eight were active in the stomach cells but not the salivary gland. Analysis of the puffing patterns of the chromosomes of these tissues at different ages, however, demonstrated that several of these 22 puffs were active in both tissues but that they differed in the time of their activity relative to the time of puparium formation. In fact only five puffs (four in the salivary gland and one in the stomach cells) were truly tissue specific when such timing differences were taken into account. In D. hydei the activity of those puffs common to both salivary gland and stomach cells commences earlier during development in the latter tissue. This is especially true of those puffs which, in the salivary gland, are most active at puparium formation (Berendes, 1965b). This emphasizes the difficulty in rigorously determining whether or not a particular puff is tissue specific. Indeed many of the puffs originally considered by Beermann (1952b) to be tissue specific are now known to be not so (Clever, 1962a). Berendes later (1966) extended his analysis to include the Malpighian tubules of both larval and adult D. hydei. His data indicate that the great majority (7%) of puffs are common to the three tissues studied. Only 14/116 puffs are specific to a single tissue and a further 19 puffs are specific to two of the three tissues. Of 22 salivary gland puffs considered by Berendes to be specific for the period of puparium formation only six showed similar changes in their activity at puparium formation in stomach and Malpighian tubule cells. There were no puffs specific for the adult Malpighian tubules although many puffs (22) active in this tissue in the larvae were not present in adult chromosomes. In Chironomus tentans Beermann (1952b) noted differences in the
32
M. ASHBURNER
pattern of puffing activities between the distal and proximal regions of the larval Malpighian tubules. Recently Buetti (1968) has followed the Malpighian tubule chromosomes of C. thummi throughout pupal development and described changes in the puffs correlated with certain morphological stages of pupal differentiation. It appears that the midpupal period is one of low puffing activity and that a dramatic increase in the size of certain puffs occurs just prior to the adult ecdysis. The general conclusions of this study are in accord with those drawn from the analysis of puffing patterns during earlier developmental stages (see Section VI(A)). In Rhynchosciuru ungelue the DNA puffs are highly specific-no single puff having been identified in more than one tissue type (Breuer and Pavan, 1955). VII. THE ENDOCRINE CONTROL OF PUFFING ACTIVITY A. ECDYSONE
The correlation between periods of intense puffing activity and moults led Clever and Karlson (1 960) and Becker (1959,1962a) to implicate the moulting hormone ecdysone in the control of this puffing activity. Becker (1962a) ligatured third instar D. mehogaster larvae behind the ring gland in such a way that ligature divided the salivary gland into two regions. When the ligature was applied before the time of moulting hormone release by the ring gland (see Fraenkel, 1935) the posterior part of the salivary gland was separated from the hormonal source. Analysis of the puffing patterns from such larvae showed that the nuclei of the anterior part of the gland possessed puffing patterns characteristic of the time of puparium formation yet the puffing pattern of the posterior nuclei had not advanced beyond the typical intermoult stage. I have confirmed these results (Ashburner, unpublished). In a second series of experiments salivary glands were transplanted between animals of differing age (Becker, 1962a, b), and puffs characteristic of the host animals induced. The role of ecdysone in the control of puffing was more directly studied by Clever and Karlson ( 1960) and later Clever published the results of his extensive experiments in a series of papers (Clever, 1961, 1962b, 1963b, c). In the preliminary communication Clever and Karlson ( 1960) injected 10-20 Calliphora Units (C.U.) (see
PUFFS
33
Karlson, 1966); 1 C.U. = 0.01 pg) of an ecdysone preparation into intermoult fourth instar Chironomus tentans larvae. As a result of this treatment there was a marked induction of puffing at one site-I-18C while the puff I-19A present at the time of injection regressed. In a further series of experiments Clever ( 196 1 ) found that the reaction of puff I-18C to ecdysone was rapid-the puff was visible within 10-15 min after injection. Closely following the appearance of I-18C a second puff, IV-2B, was induced by ecdysone. It will be recalled that the two puffs I-18C and IV-2B of C. tentans are the first to appear, during normal development, prior to the moults (see page 26). The sequence of their induction by ecdysone in intermoult larvae is identical to the sequence seen during normal development. At moderate doses of ecdysone (e.g. l0C.U.) both I-1% and IV-2B reach their maximum activity within a few hours of the injection and then regress. At higher doses (e.g. 45 C.U.) they remain active for considerably longer periods (48 hr in the case of IV-2B and over 72 hr in the case of I-18C). If, after the regression of the two puffs following a 10 C.U. injection the animals are reinjected with ecdysone both puffs are induced a second time. The dose response relationships for the ecdysone induction of I-18C and IV-2B were investigated by Clever in a later paper (Clever, 1963b). Intermoult fourth instar C. tentans larvae were used as the test animals and were injected with ecdysone with the doses ranging from 2.10-7 pg to 2.10-' pg/animal. The mean wet weight of the larvae being in the order of 20 mg these doses correspond to and pg/mg respectively. The reaction thresholds of the two puffs differed; that for I-18C was pg/mg and that for IV-2B pg/mg. Higher doses were necessary if the puffs were to attain their maximum size: lo-' to pg/mg for I-18C and pg/mg for IV-2B. The threshold doses were calculated to correspond to some 10-100 molecules of ecdysone per haploid genome. These results were interpreted by Clever to indicate that during normal development the two puff loci respond to a gradual increase in ecdysone titre which precedes the moult, the puffs reacting as their respective threshold concentrations are reached. These conclusions were tested in a further series of experiments (Clever, 1964a; Clever and Beermann, 1963). Haemolymph was taken from animals at four ages, (i) fourth instar larvae immediately after the moult from the third instar, (ii) intermoult fourth instar larvae, (iii) young prepupae just before the activation of 1-18C, and (iv) old prepupae. These haemolymph samples were injected into intermoult
34
M. ASHBURNER
fourth instar larvae and their effect on puffing at I-18C and IV-2B assessed. The results of these experiments were that late prepupal haemolymph always induced both puffs whilst young prepupal haemolymph and haemolymph from immediately post-moult fourth instar larvae sometimes induced 1-18C but never IV-2B. Haemolymph from intermoult larvae was without effect on puffing at these loci. The injection of ecdysone into either post-moult fourth instar larvae or into young prepupae enlarged (if possible) the size of the puff at 1-18C and, in animals of an appropriate age, induced puffing at IV-2B which, during normal development regresses earlier than the 1-18C puff. The situation found after the injection of ecdysone into older prepupae is more complicated. In contrast to the pattern found after the third larval moult the puff I-18C does not regress in old prepupae. This observation is consistent with the finding that the ecdysone titre in these animals is high (the haemolymph experiments). Despite this IV-2B does regress in old prepupae and this fact seemingly contradicts the hypothesis that the activity of these two puffs is dependent upon the haemolymph ecdysone titre. Injection of ecdysone into old prepupae does not induce IV-2B (Clever, 1961, 1964a). These results suggest that some other factor controls the regression of IV-2B prior to pupation. Since treatment of old prepupae with cycloheximide, an inhibitor of protein synthesis, can result in IV-2B induction in these animals, Clever ( 1966b) has suggested that the regression of IV-2B at this stage is due to the action of some unspecified substance, whose metabolic survival is dependent upon protein synthesis. Ecdysone will also induce puffing at I-18C and IV-2B in vitro but only when the glands are incubated in relatively complex media, and even then the results are erratic (Clever, 1965b). So far only the initial chromosomal response to ecdysone has been considered. However apart from I-18C and IV-2B a large number of puff loci react and d o so in a sequence similar to that found during normal prepupal development (Clever, 196 1). The reaction of these loci is, however, considerably delayed; the first (I-8A) being activated more than 5 hr after the injection of 45 C.U. of ecdysone and the last group (e.g. III4A) some 7 2 hr after injection. Some of the puffs that react are not classified by Clever as moult specific puffs (e.g. I-17B, 11-16A). The puff I-19A is of interest as within 2-8 hr after ecdysone injection it regresses (see Clever and Karlson, 1960) yet later, at 15 hr, its activity increases. The effects of ecdysone on puffing have been examined in two
PUFFS
35
other species of Chironomus, C. palliduvitatus and C. thummi, although less comprehensively than in the C. tentans. In C. palliduvitatus, a sibling species of C. tentans, the puff homologous to I-18C of C. tentuns shows a similar ecdysone response (Clever, 1961). The transplantation of intermoult fourth instar larval salivary glands of C. thummi into prepupae results in the induction of the puff IIId 1. During normal development IIId 1 displays a similar pattern of activity to I-18C of C. tentans and the two puffs are presumably homologous (Kroeger, 1964; Pelling, 1965). Induction of IIId 1 can also be achieved in vitro by adding ecdysone to cultured salivary glands of C. thummi (Kroeger, 1966). This response, however, is very sensitive to such factors as oxygen availability in the medium-an observation that may account for Clever’s (1965b) difficulty in achieving a reliable effect of ecdysone in vitro. C. Davis (personal communication) has also found difficulty in inducing puffing with ecdysone in vitro, perhaps suggesting the necessity of other substances for the ecdysone response. No effect of ecdysone on puffing in isolated salivary gland nuclei of D.hydei could be found by Berendes and Boyd (1969). The regression, in prepupae, of two Balbiani rings (BR3 and BR4) of the anterior salivary gland lobe of Acricotopus lucidus has already been mentioned (page 30). Panitz (1964) used a variety of experimental techniques to demonstrate that this inactivation is dependent upon a high ecdysone titre. Interestingly he demonstrated that an in terspecific transplant of larval salivary glands in to prepupae of Calliphora would result in BR regression. Similarly the incubation of the glands in the presence of Calliphoru prothoracic glands (i.e. the side limbs of the ring gland) would produce the same result. Recently Panitz (personal communication) has shown the inactivation of BR3 and BR4 following the injection of ecdysone into larvae. In addition to causing regression of BR3 and BR4 the rising ecdysone titre in Acricotopus prepupae also leads to the regression of puff I/H-l8 and the induction of puff II/Q-32. Induction of specific puffing patterns by ecdysone in Drosophilids has been studied by Berendes ( 1967a) in D. hydei and by Ashburner (1969f) in D. melanogaster. In D.hydei the consequence of injecting 33 C.U. of ecdysone into 136-140 hr third instar larvae (i.e. 20 hr before puparium formation) is to produce changes in puffing activity which “show only minor differences” from those changes that normally occur before puparium formation (Berendes, 1967a). The changes are first evident within 15-30min of the injection and
36
M. ASHBURNER
include the de novo induction of puffs (3 puffs), and both the enlargement ( 18 puffs) and regression ( 12 puffs) of preexisting puffs. A group of five puffs do not react within the first 60 min after injection of ecdysone but do react several hours later. The results of the short term ecdysone induction experiments of Berendes (1967a, Table 1) should be compared closely with the normal behaviour of the puffs prior to puparium formation (Berendes, 1965a, Table 5). Fourteen puffs are listed by Berendes as increasing in activity before or during puparium formation; only five of these are ecdysone inducible. Of 15 puffs that decrease in activity before or during puparium formation four are ecdysone inducible, and four regress after ecdysone injection. It appears that in D. hydei there are considerable differences between the normal puffing patterns and those induced by ecdysone. One further paradox is apparent from the data of Berendes (1967a). A total of 2 1 puffs either appear de novo or enlarge shortly after the injection of ecdysone into 136-140 hr larvae; 14 of these show considerable activity in the polytene chromosomes of the Malpighian tubule nuclei of adult flies, a stage expected to have a very low ecdysone titre (see e.g. Shaaya and Karlson, 1965). Because of the ambiguities of the D. hydei data it is important t o know the ecdysone response of puffs in other, related, species. So far only the incomplete data from a study of D. melanogaster are available (Ashburner, 1969f). In this study 90 hr old third instar larvae were injected with the 2 x pg of ecdysone and the puffing response followed for several hours subsequent t o the time of injection. The results clearly indicate that at this dose ecdysone initiates the complete sequence of changes in puffing activity that would normally occur before puparium formation some 20-30 hr later. The first visible effects are evident within 15 min with the induction of puffing at four loci: 2B5-6, 23E, 74EF and 75B. These puffs are the first to appear during normal development (Ashburner, 1967a, 1969a). Although the changes in puffing activity induced by ecdysone injection in 90 hr larvae are identical to the normal developmental sequence they become out of step with the gross developmental physiology of the animals. The amounts of ecdysone injected do not accelerate puparium formation and 10-14 hr after ecdysone injection third instar larvae, of normal external appearance, possess puffing patterns typical of prepupal animals. Many of the puffs inducible by ecdysone in both D. hydei and D. melanogaster are, during normal development, active at both
PUFFS
37
puparium formation and, later, prior to pupation. Yet attempts to induce them in prepupae by ecdysone injection have not been completely successful in either species (Berendes, 1967a; Ashburner, 19690. Furthermore in D. melanogaster I have found that very young third instar larvae are refractory to ecdysone (contra Berendes, 1967a). The failure of prepupae and young third instar larvae to react to ecdysone may be suggested to be due to the presence in these animals of enzymes destroying ecdysone (see Ohtaki et al., 1968; Karlson and Bode, 1969). It is not unreasonable to assume that such enzymes would be active immediately following ecdysis. The central role of ecdysone in the control of puffing activity is further exemplified by the mutant lethal-giant-larvae (Zgl) of D. melanogaster. This mutant is a larval lethal, the animals failing to form normal puparia or to pass through the prepupal moult. The animals live as larvae for several days and either die as larvae or as very abnormal animals known as “pseudopupae”. The results of ring gland transplant experiments (Scharrer and Hadorn, 1938) and of the injection of ecdysone preparations (Karlson and Hanser, 1952), together with the phenotypic characteristics of the mutant suggest that lgl is defective in some part of its ecdysone endocrine system. Mutant larvae almost completely lack puffing activity even during pseudopuparium formation (Becker, 1959; Ashburner, unpublished). They can, however, be induced to form salivary gland chromosome puffs after various experimental treatments, such as temperature shock. After such treatments the reaction of lgl larvae is qualitatively similar to that of normal larvae (see page 50 and Ashburner, 1969d). Attempts at inducing puffs in lgZ third instar larvae with ecdysone have so far been unsuccessful (Ashburner, unpublished). The kinetics of puff induction and the dose response relationships for several puffs were analysed by Berendes (1967a) in D. hydei. Loci differed in their reaction thresholds but these were generally in C.U. per larva (i.e. 5 x the order of pglmg). The dose response curves for the several puffs tested were not linear-in particular high concentrations of ecdysone (e.g. 33 C.U. per larva) had less effect than concentrations lower by several orders of magnitude [contrast with the linear response of I-18C and IV-2B in C. tentans (Clever, 1963b)l. The effect of ecdysone on puffing appears to be similar in all larval tissues of an organism so far studied, i.e. salivary gland, midgut, Malpighian tubules, of D. hydei (Berendes, 1967a), and salivary
38
M. ASHBURNER
gland, rectum and Malpighian tubules of C. tentans (Clever, 1961). The DNA puffs of the Sciarinae are also ecdysone inducible; as might perhaps have been expected in view of their appearance before pupation. Cannon (1 965) cultured the salivary gland of S. coprophila in vitro and provided circumstantial evidence of the inducibility of the DNA puffs. Recently Crouse ( 1968) injected S. coprophila larvae with 3.3C.U. of ecdysone and within 24 hr observed DNA puff formation, and marked DNA synthesis at these sites. After ecdysone injection the puffing patterns became uncoupled with gross developmental events (see above). The mode of action of ecdysone in inducing specific puffing activity is still unclear and will be discussed below. But one approach to this problem could possibly be by a comparison of the effects of a range of related compounds on puffing. Since the elucidation of the structural formula of ecdysone by Karlson’s group (see Karlson, 1966) many different “ecdysones” have been isolated, especially from plants. While few studies have as yet been completed available information indicates that there are no qualitative differences in the effects on puffing of the compounds tested. For example Berendes (1 968b) tested ecdysterone (20-OH ecdysone) and 2p 30 dihydroxySa-choleston-( 6) with D. hydei, Ashburner (unpublished) 20-OH ecdysone with D. melanogaster, and Panitz (personal communication) 20-OH ecdysone and inokosterone (20,26-dihydroxy25-deoxy-ecdysone) with Acricotopus lucidus; in all instances the effects of these steroids was the same as found with ecdysone itself. The compound 20 30 14a trihydroxy-5P-pregn-7-ene,6,20dione, a possible candidate in the metabolism of ecdysone (Horn et al., 1966), does not induce puffing in D. melanogaster (Ashburner, unpublished). There is clearly one great difficulty in the interpretation of the results of in vivo experiments such as those described. The conversion of the test compounds into a common substance which exerts the physiological effect may confound the results. Indeed there is little evidence to suggest that ecdysone itself does not become converted after injection. Recently King and Siddall ( 1969) demonstrated the conversion of ecdysone to 20-OH ecdysone in Calliphora larvae, clearly indicating that such events are possible. In Drosophila, at least, it is clear from the results of the experiments described above that ecdysone does not induce puffing activity at particular individual loci; rather it induces a whole sequence of changes in puffing pattern and this sequence at least approximates to that observed prior to puparium formation. The
PUFFS
39
question clearly arises as t o the causal relationship, if any, between the activities of early reacting loci and the activities of late reacting loci. Clever ( 1964b) and Clever and Romball ( 1966) have approached this problem experimentally. The induction, in C. tentuns, of puffs I-18C and IV-2B by ecdysone is sensitive to actinomycin D. Pretreatment of larvae with actinomycin D for 6 hr (at 0.2 pg/ml in the culture water) results in the inhibition of salivary gland RNA synthesis for about 24 hr. Injection of ecdysone immediately following actinomycin D treatment is without effect on puffing as long as the inhibition of RNA synthesis persists. With the gradual recommencement of RNA synthesis the puffs I-18C and IV-2B appear in their normal sequence to be followed by puffing at the later reacting sites. In some ways this is a surprising result as it implies either a long survival of the injected ecdysone in the haemolymph (in contrast to the results of Ohtaki et ul., 1968) or perhaps the stimulation by the injected ecdysone of the host prothoracic glands t o release further quantities of the hormone. Compare the results of actinomycin D inhibition experiments with those using inhibitors of protein synthesis such as puromycin (Clever, 1964b) or cycloheximide (Clever and Romball, 1966). In the first series of experiments larvae were treated with puromycin for 1 hr and then injected with ecdysone. This was followed by an apparently normal induction of 1-18C and IV-2B but the later reacting puffs failed to appear, at least within 24 hr (Clever, 1964b). Essentially the same results were obtained using cycloheximide (Clever and Romball, 1966) although in these experiments a third puff (I-8A) was induced following I-18C and IV-2B. Although the interpretation favoured by Clever is “that as one of the early cellular reactions to ecdysone, specific genes are induced, and that it is by the reaction of these genes that the subsequent changes of cell metabolism (i.e. the induction of the later puffs) are controlled” (Clever and Romball, 1966) there are several factors which complicate the interpretation of the results of these and similar experiments. One such complication is the observation that treatment of fourth instar larvae with cycloheximide (and other inhibitors of protein synthesis) alone results in considerable changes in puffing activity including the induction of puff 1-18C (Clever, 1967). Similarly in Drosophilu melunoguster the injection of 90 hr third instar larvae with either cycloheximide or puromycin alone results in alteration of the puffing pattern including the induction of
40
M. ASHBURNER
puffs at novel sites and the induction of puffs at 74EF and 75B-two of the earliest puffs to react to ecdysone (Ashburner and Mitchell, unpublished). The recent results of Berendes (1968a) have also confused the interpretation of actinomycin D experiments. He finds that it is possible to induce puffs, or at least acid protein accumulation at puff sites, by ecdysone and other agents even under conditions where the incorporation of uridine into RNA (as detectable by autoradiography) is inhibited by actinomycin D (see Clever, 1968; Clever et al., 1969a). A great handicap to our interpretation of experiments using metabolic inhibitors is our ignorance of the precise metabolic consequences of their presence within the cells. For example it is difficult to discount the possibility that treatment of Chironomus larvae with cycloheximide results in the blocking of particular metabolic processes, unrelated to the action of puffs I - l 8 d and IV-2B, and that the failure of subsequent puff induction by ecdysone is a consequence of this effect. As an illustration we can imagine that the cycloheximide stops the synthesis of RNA polymerase and of the ribonucleoprotein puff granules-both presumably necessary components for puff induction. Subsequent to the induction of I-18C and IV-2B the cells may run short of these components and further puff induction would not take place. The causal relationship between the induction of I-18C and IV-2B and the induction of the later puffs, or the causal relationship between the activities of any groups of puffs cannot therefore be assumed. As an alternative hypothesis the complete sequence of gene activations may be pre-programmed within the chromosomes themselves, the activities of individual loci being essentially independent of each other. If such were the case then ecdysone or any other external inducer may only be acting as the trigger for the initiation of this programme (see Kroeger, 1963a, 1964). B. MECHANISM OF ECDYSONE ACTION
Considerable controversy has arisen concerning the molecular basis of ecdysone action, particularly in respect of the induction of specific puffing activity. Two main views have been proposed and discussed by Karlson (e.g. 1965, 1966) and Clever ( 1 9 6 4 ~ )on the one hand and by Kroeger (e.g. 1968) on the other. The publication of the initial finding of ecdysone induction of puffing in Chironomus tentans coincided with the announcement of
PUFFS
41
a general theory of gene control by Jacob and Monod (1961a, b). The mechanism of ecdysone action was interpreted within the framework of this model by Karlson and Clever. In the terms of Jacob and Monod’s hypothesis ecdysone was thought to act as an effector molecule which bound to repressor molecules resulting in their detachment from specific DNA regions allowing subsequent DNA transcription (see Beermann, 1963). Rigorous proof that ecdysone acts in this way would require extensive genetic and biochemical analysis; analysis which is so far not forthcoming. However, the model makes one prediction which should be easily testable with the availability of labelled ecdysone. That is the site of action of ecdysone will be intranuclear. The model does not predict, as is often assumed (e.g. Clever, 1964a; Kroeger, 1964) the chromosomal binding of ecdysone. Karlson et al. (1964) followed the fate of unspecifically tritium labelled ecdysone in Calliphora larvae with particular attention to the epidermal cells. Although label was recovered from the nuclear fraction a very considerable (60%) proportion remained in other cell components. More recently Milkman ( 1 968, quoted by Williams and Robbins, 1968) and Emmerich ( 1969) have made use of the recently available specifically labelled ecdysones t o follow the cellular distribution of the hormone. Neither group have been able to report any marked preferential incorporation of ecdysone into either nuclei or chromosomes of Drosophila salivary glands. In the absence of experimental data it is difficult to evaluate the hypothesis of Karlson further. The interaction of physiologically active steroids with cellular membrane systems and their effects on the permeability of these membranes to small ions is well known (see Willmer, 1961). The hypothesis that ecdysone is acting at the level of the cellular membranes and changing the selective permeabilities of these membranes to small ions (Kroeger, 1963b, 1966, 1967, 1968) has, therefore, a general basis although it has met with considerable scepticism and controversy. Specifically Kroeger suggests that ecdysone acts on the plasma/nuclear membranes and results in a rise in the intranuclear concentration of potassium ions. As a direct consequence of this effect induction of puffing activity at specific chromosome sites results. Explantation of the salivary glands from late fourth instar Chironomus thummi larvae into haemolymph or saline led to specific changes in the puffing patterns. In particular Kroeger ( 1963b)
42
M. ASHBURNER
observed that the puffing pattern underwent an apparent reversionexisting puffs regressing and puffs characteristic of younger stages in development appearing in a regular sequence. This reversion of puffing patterns on explantation was called rejuvenation by Kroeger (1963b) and is probably similar to the phenomenon of “rollback” (Ruckwarstslaufen) noted some years earlier in D. melanogaster by Becker ( I 959). [Miss C. Davis ( I 967, unpublished observations) has been unable to confirm “rollback” of puffing in D. melanoguster.] The important fact concerning Kroeger’s rejuvenation phenomenon is that, in C. thummi at least, it involves a more or less precise reversal of the ecdysone initiated puffing patterns and that during reversal, as during normal development, the puffs appear in progression. Subsequently Kroeger ( I 963a, 1964) analysed the cellular components whose presence was necessary for rejuvenation to occur. In fact it occurred with equal facility in isolated nuclei and in whole glands (Lezzi, 196 1 ). Kroeger ( 1964) then demonstrated that the activation or regression of any particular puff locus during rejuvenation was independent of the presence of any specific chromosome region other than, naturally, the puff locus itself. He concluded, therefore, that the “control system’’ responsible for gene activation and repression during rejuvenation lies in the nuclear sap (Kroeger, 1963a, 1964) and assumed that this control system would be identical to that operating during normal development in the intact animal. What is this control system? Although demonstrating that a number of compounds (e.g. ZnCI, , urethane) could, in explanted glands, counteract rejuvenation and even advance the puffing pattern to that characteristic of older animals (Kroeger, 1964) these were clearly a-physiological agents. [The effect of ZnCl, on puffing could not be confirmed by Clever (1965b) using C. tentuns but has been confirmed by Berendes (personal communication) with C. thummi. ] According to results first published in 1963 (Kroeger, 1963b) the control system is the intranuclear concentration of particular species of ions-especially potassium and sodium ions. The replacement of sodium by potassium in the explant medium led to a progression of the puffing pattern closely resembling that thought in normal animals to be due to the rising titre of ecdysone. One puff, IIId1, which can be induced rapidly with ecdysone treatment (see page 35) was also inducible, in intermoult fourth instar larvae, by
PUFFS
43
explantation of salivary glands into a medium containing a relatively high (e.g. 120 mM) potassium concentration. The induction of puff IIId1 b y potassium ions has been confirmed b y Berendes (personal communication). Similarly puffs characteristic of younger stages were inducible by particular concentrations (e.g. 100 mM) of sodium ions. On this basis the rejuvenation phenomenon observed on explantation into regular (i.e. high sodium) media o r on wounding of the glands was viewed as the result of an influx of sodium ions into the gland nuclei (Lezzi and Kroeger, 1966). During normal development the sodium concentration within the nuclei would be high during the intermoult stages, b u t with the approach of a moult the rising ecdysone titre would change the membrane permeabilities in favour of a high intranuclear potassium ion concentration. Specific activation of moult specific puffing patterns would result. Clever ( 1965b) attempted to repeat Kroeger’s observations and explanted the salivary glands of C. tentans into a variety of media. Although he observed many changes in puffing activity as a consequence of such experiments he was unable to find any specific puff induction by particular ions. Clever attributes the effects observed by Kroeger to unspecific changes in osmotic pressure since he observed identical effects of isotonic NaCl and KCI solutions. Alteration of the osmotic pressure of the medium by ions or by larger molecules certainly does produce drastic changes in puffing activity in explanted salivary glands of C. thummi (Kroeger, 1967) yet there remain a small number of loci which only respond t o changes in the concentration of particular ions. Four puffs react to a high sodium concentration, one t o a high potassium concentration and one to magnesium ions (see also Lezzi, 1967c for an account of BR induction in C. thummi and C. tentans by magnesium ions). These particular ions will also produce identical effects with isolated salivary gland nuclei (Lezzi, 1966, 1967c) of C. thummi. Furthermore, Lezzi has been able to induce puffing at I-18C and IV-2B of C. tentans by incubation of isolated nuclei in a potassium-rich medium (Lezzi, 1966, 1967), and a larval puff, 1-19A, with a sodium-rich medium. One puff (IV-5C) of C. tentans also reacts to magnesium ions. There appear to be real differences in the membrane permeabilities of the two species which account for the differences of the experimental results obtained using whole salivary glands. Such differences have also been found between C. thummi
44
M. ASHBURNER
and C. tentans with respect to uridine permeability (Berendes, personal communication). Berendes et al. ( 1965) also tested the effects of K'ions on puffing in D. hydrei. Their experimental results were ambiguous and have been interpreted both in favour (e.g. Berendes et al., loc. cit.) and against (e.g. Pelling, 1965; Clever, 1965b; Berendes, 1968a) Kroeger's ideas. If ecdysone is indeed causing a redistribution of ion species across the cellular membranes then this should be reflected in the electrophysiological parameters of these membranes. Kroeger ( 1966) measured the potential difference across the plasma membrane in explanted salivary glands of C. thurnrni. After explantation he found a progressive depolarization of the membrane; the extent of this process apparently correlated with the degree of puff rejuvenation. More importantly on addition of ecdysone to the explant medium the plasma membrane potential difference increased and only after this reached -35 mV was the puff IIId1 induced. Kroeger argues that the potential difference across the plasma membrane is a result of the asymmetrical distribution of potassium ions be tween the cells and their surrounding medium. Ito and Loewenstein ( 1 9 6 3 , on the other hand, although finding a change, attributable to ecdysone, in the resistance of the nuclear membrane of C. thurnmi salivary gland cells, failed to find evidence for related changes in the plasma membrane resting potential. It is important to recall in this discussion that studies by Loewenstein and his co-workers have shown that the membrane resistance between adjacent cells of the Drosophila salivary gland is so low that virtually no barrier exists to the free diffusion of ions and larger molecules (e.g. flourescein labelled serum albumin, mol. wt 69,000) between cells (Loewenstein and Kanno, 1964; Kanno and Loewenstein, 1966). This permeability depends upon free calcium ions and is sensitive to agents that uncouple oxidative phosphorylation (Politoff et al., 1969). There is, however, a considerable barrier to the diffusion of ions between the outside surface of the cells and the external environment of the gland. In view of this it is unlikely that differences in ion concentration can be maintained between different cells of the same gland, and unless special permeability barriers within the gland exist, it is hard to see just how differences in ion concentration could account for intragland variation in puffing activities (see page 28). It would be
PUFFS
45
interesting t o study the nature of the cellular junctions between, for example, the Sonderzellen and the main gland cells of C. palliduvitatus (see Wiener et al., 1964). One of Kroeger’s objections to Karlson’s theory was that “it is difficult to see how such a small molecule (i.e. ecdysone) could harbour the specificity for singling out a specific base sequence in order t o activate it” (Kroeger, 1963a). Despite the fact that such an event is not necessitated by the theory the objection applies with equal validity t o the proposal that particular ion concentrations control specific gene activities. Kroeger ( 1 967) argues that they do so by displacing histones from particular chromosome regions. It is well known that high salt concentrations will disassociate the DNAhistone complex. However, even if the role of histones in the regulation of gene action were fully acceptable the recognition mechanism is neither defined nor obvious. At present we may summarize this rather unsatisfactory state of affairs by saying that the mode of ecdysone action at the puff level is unknown. Neither of the predominant ideas have a firm enough theoretical or experimental basis for acceptance. Before leaving the subject of the mode of action of ecdysone mention should be made of some recent reports of the effects of vertebrate corticosteroids on puffing activity. Gilbert and Pistey (1966) claim to have induced specific puffs in isolated D. melanogaster salivary glands after incubation in the presence of hydrocortisone (250 pg/ml). However, there is no evidence from the data published to substantiate their claim since untimed larvae were used and since an essential control (incubation of sister salivary glands) was omitted. The effects of a related steroid, cortisone, on DNA puffing have also been studied recently. Addition of cortisone acetate (70 mg/g) or hydrocortisone to the food medium of Sciara coprophila for the complete period of larval development did not, apparently, influence either developmental rate or the viability and subsequent fertility of the flies (Goodman et al., 1967). Yet, it was claimed, this treatment resulted in the complete absence of the normal DNA puffing cycle characteristic of prepupal development. Prior t o and during the period of DNA puffing there normally occurs an increase in the nuclear DNA content. This increase could not be detected in those larvae fed cortisone acetate. It must be stressed, however, that there is no evidence that RNA synthesis was affected by the treatment. In
46
M. ASHBURNER
fact the published autoradiographs give little indication of any difference in uridine incorporation over the DNA puff loci between the control and cortisone-fed animals. The conclusion of Goodman e t al. that “the significance of large chromosome puffs for normal development is questionable” cannot be justified by the data published. Crouse ( 1 968) has been unable to repeat the essential observations. She both injected and fed Sciara larvae with cortisone acetate and examined its effect on DNA puffing. Her results indicate that (a) the injection of cortisone had no effect on DNA puff induction, (b) that cortisone injected simultaneously with ecdysone did not modify the chromosomal response to ecdysone (see page 38), and (c) that DNA puff formation was normal in larvae fed cortisone acetate under either of two different conditions. In contrast to the experience of Goodman e t al., Crouse finds that at the concentrations used by the first authors cortisone does delay development by several days. Crouse concludes that the failure of Goodman e t al. to detect DNA puff formation after cortisone feeding is the result of this developmental delay so that the animals scored by them were too young for puff formation to have occurred. Similarly Rasch and Lewis (1968) fed cortisone to S. coprophila larvae and failed to observe any effect on DNA puff formation. Agreeing with the results of Crouse these authors did find that cortisone treatment resulted in delayed larval development. In D. melanogaster, Smith e t al. ( 1 968) and Sang ( 1 968) have failed to produce any modification of larval/prepupal puffing patterns following cortisone feeding. Both studies note that cortisone feeding results in delayed development. Similar findings were briefly reported by Midelfort and Rasch ( 1 968) working with D. virilis. C. JUVENILE HORMONE
Comparison of moult specific puffing patterns at larval/larval and larval/pupal moults has lead to the implication of juvenile hormone in the control of puffing activity (Becker, 1962a: Clever, 1964a; Ashburner, 1967a; Kroeger, 1968). Although many puffs are common to both moults there remain several whose activity is restricted t o one or other stages. For example in D. melanogaster Ashburner ( 1967a) found 30/87 puffs active at puparium formation (i.e. before the moult of the third instar larvae to the pharate fourth instar), and again before the pupal moult, 12/87 puffs active only at puparium formation and 13/87 only before the pupal moult.
PUFFS
47
Interestingly the relative sequence of activation of many of the puffs common to both processes differed before the pupal moult from that found a t puparium formation. Despite the frequent suggestion that these differences in puffing activity are d u e t o differences in juvenile hormone titre the results of experimental investigation of this point have been disappointing. Attempts t o modify puffing patterns by injection of juvenile hormone preparations (Clever, I963a), by the injection of juvenile hormone analogues (Ashburner, unpublished) o r by the implantation of corpora allata (e.g. Kroeger and Lezzi, 1966) were for a long time without success. Recent experiments briefly reported by Laufer and Holt ( 1 969) are likely t o lead t o a reappraisal of this situation. These authors fed prepupae of C. thummi with chlorinated farnesoic acid derivatives and, after prolonged treatment, observed both abnormalities of metamorphosis and effects on puffing. The effects on puffing were of two types: (a) an inhibition of the development of some late prepupal puffs and (b) the enlargement of a specific BR (BR IVb) which, during normal development, regresses in the late prepupal stage. No general return of the puffing pattern t o that characteristic of younger animals was observed (contra Kroeger, 1963a). The many negative results found previous to the report of Laufer and Holt were probably due t o inadequacies of experimental design. Many of the experiments used intermoult larvae, a period of low ecdysone activity. Since juvenile hormone is without effect, in the immature insect, in the absence of ecdysone it is of little surprise that n o effects of juvenile hormone could be detected. Significantly Laufer and Holt (1969) have found their effects in prepupaeanimals with a high ecdysone titre. It will be of great interest now t o know how juvenile hormone modifies the ecdysone response of the chromosomes when both compounds are injected into intermoult larvae. VIII. THE EXPERIMENTAL MODIFICATION OF PUFFING ACTIVITY
A large variety of experimental agents, other than those discussed previously, have been found t o influence puffing activity. Beermann (1952b) subjected larvae of C. tentans to cold treatment (5°C)for several hours and observed, after the return of the animals t o room temperature for 1 hr or more, the accumulation of droplets in the nucleoplasm adjacent to the puff sites. These droplets contain both RNA and protein (Beermann, 1959). Similar droplets have been found
Table I Puff induction by miscellaneous agents Agent
Species
Effect
Reference
Remarks
1. Ribonuclease
D. busckii
Specific puff induction after in vitro treatment of glands.
Ritossa and von Borstel, 1964; Ritossa e t al., 1964; Ritossa e t al., 1965.
2 . Thioacetamide
C. dorsalis
Specific puff induction after feeding.
Kiknadze and Filatova, 1963.
-
3. Tryptophan
D. melanogaster
Specific puff induction. I n vitro treatment of glands.
Federoff and Milkman, 1964. 1965.
Milkman (personal communication) and Ashburner (unpublished) unable t o confirm.
4. Dicyandiamide
D. melanogaster
General increase in puffing after in vitro incubation of glands.
Mukherjee, 1968.
5. Gibberellin A
Acricotopus lucidus
Specific puff regression after feeding.
Panitz, 1967.
Not confirmed by Prostakova (1968) with C. plumosus, by Paul (1965) with D. melanogaster or by Smith (1969) with D. virilis.
See page 65. Rasch and Lewis, 1968 did not observe any effect after feeding to Sciara coprophila.
6. Actinomycin D
Chironomus sp.
Specific induction of puffs.
Kiknadze, 1965; Serfling (personal communication).
See page 15.
7. Acridines (e.g. proflavin)
Chironomus thummi
Specific puff induction.
Serfling (personal communication).
See page 15.
8. Oxytetracycline
C. thummi
Specific puff induction and general puff enlargement after feeding.
Serfling et al., 1969.
About 30 puffs induced many heterozygous in different wild strains. C. strenzkei does not react.
9. I n vivo culture in adult abdomens.
D. melanogaster
Specific induction of puffs.
Staub. 1969.
Actual puffs induced dependent upon age of glands at transplantation.
10. I n vivo culture D. busckii in D. melanogaster egg cytoplasm.
Specific puff induction Kroeger, 1960. and regression in isolated salivary gland nuclei.
1 1. Various Ringertype solutions.
D. melanogaster
Specific puff induction after in vitro treatment of glands or after injection of larvae.
Becker, 1959; Ashburner (unpublished observations).
12. Various media
C. tentans
Puff induction.
Clever, 1965b.
13. Puromycin and cycloheximide
D. melanogaster
Specific puff induction after injection.
Ashburner and Mitchell (unpublished).
Exact pattern depends on age of donor glands and developmental stage of eggs used.
See also Clever, 1967, and page 39.
50
M. ASHBURNER
by Paul (1965) after cold treatment of D. melanogaster larvae and this author also concluded that the droplets have a high RNA content. From the published descriptions these droplets appear to resemble the micronucleoli of Sciarids (see p. 23) and are probably the result of a disturbance of the normal process of transport of RNA and protein from puff sites. Kiknadze (1965) reportedly induced a new puff in C. dorsalis as the result of low temperature treatment. The effect of heat shock on puffing is very much more dramatic than that of cold shock. The specific induction, and regression, of puffs due to a 12°C heat shock (25-37°C) was observed initially by Ritossa ( 1962b) in Drosophila busckii and has been studied subsequently by Berendes and Holt (1964), Berendes et al. (1965) and van Breugel (1966) in D. hydei, and by Ritossa (1963a), Ashburner (1969d) and Ellgaard (1969) in D. melanoguster. In D. melanoguster a continuous heat shock (2537°C) results in the induction of puffs at nine loci within 5-10 min. These puffs reach their maximum sizes rapidly and are active for 30-60 min and then regress. The shock also causes the regression of all puffs, apart from these nine, present at the time of transfer to the high temperature. Of the nine puffs induced four are at sites not seen to be active during normal development (Ashburner, 1969d). Similar changes in puffing activity also occur during recovery from anoxia (Ritossa, 1964a; Burdette and Anderson, 1965 ; van Breugel, 1966; Ashburner, 1969d). During the period of anoxia itself no changes in puffing take place, but after the return of the animals to air or oxygen specific induction at a limited number of chromosome sites begins within minutes. The puffs remain active for several hours after a 3 hr period of anoxia. Initially the induced puffs are at an identical spectrum of sites to those active during heat treatment (Ritossa, 1964a; van Breugel, 1966) but later additional puffs appear (Ashburner, 1969d), some of which are at loci not active during normal development. The pattern of puff induction by heat treatment is identical in viuo, in uitro (Ritossa, 1964a; Berendes and Holt, 1964; Ashburner, 1969d) and in larval salivary glands transplanted to adult abdomens (Berendes and Holt, 1964). The induction is not dependent on protein synthesis (Ashburner, 1969d; Ellgaard, 1969) but is inhibited by actinomycin D (Ritossa and Pulitzer, 1963, but see Berendes, 1968a and p. 19). The mechanism of induction of puffing by temperature treatment
PUFFS
51
or during recovery from anoxia is not understood. Experiments of Ritossa ( 1964a) are, however, suggestive. He induced the same puffs with heat shock and with a variety of chemicals whose common characteristic was their ability to uncouple oxidative phosphorylation (e.g. sodium azide, 24,dinitrophenol, dicoumarol). Since both heat shock and anoxia are expected to result in some disturbance of the respiratory metabolism the changes in gene activity may be a consequence of this effect. However, since such a disturbance would be expected to have manifold effects on general cellular metabolism the causal connection between it and the puff induction may be tenuous. In addition to heat shocks and anoxia a miscellaneous collection of agents have been found to produce qualitative changes in puffing activity but there is little indication of either the mechanism of action of any of these agents or any clue as to the functional significance of the observed changes. Some of these agents and their effects are listed in the accompanying table (see also Table IV of Kroeger and Lezzi, 1966). IX. MODIFICATION OF POLYTENE CHROMOSOME STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION AS THE RESULT OF INFECTION
The infection of Dipteran larvae by various organisms has frequently been found to have an effect on polytene chromosome morphology and activity. Most of our knowledge of the results of infection on giant chromosome structure and function is due to the researches of Pavan and his colleagues. Two types of infection of last instar larvae of Rhynchosciara angelae have been studied. Infection of larval tissues (e.g. mid-intestine) by a polyhedral virus results in considerable hypertrophy of both cells and polytene chromosomes. Although measurements of the DNA content of the nuclei of these cells is complicated by the presence of the viral DNA it is clear that the enlargement of the chromosomes has involved extensive DNA synthesis (Diaz and Pavan, 1965). Considerable degenerative changes occur in infected cells including chromosome fragmentation at specific loci and eventual pycnosis. The chromosomes of viral infected cells have few puffs (Pavan and Basile, 1966a, b; Pavan and da Cunha, 1969a). Microsporidia are responsible for a second type of infection which also results in cellular and chromosome hypertrophy (Diaz and
52
M. ASHBURNER
Pavan, 1965; Pavan and Basile, 1966a). The great increase in size of the polytene chromosomes occurring in infected cells is due t o extra rounds of DNA synthesis and these chromosomes have DNA contents that are 2” times the DNA content of normal chromosomes, the value of n varying from two to five (Roberts et al., 1967). Some control is clearly still exercised over these extra rounds of DNA replication since the proportion of the total nuclear DNA content accounted for by each individual chromosome remains constant. In striking contrast to the hypertrophied chromosomes in viral infected cells those in microsporidian infected cells are highly active with respect to RNA synthesis and have been said t o show “generalized puffing” (Roberts et al., 1967). This is especially striking on the X-chromosome of male larvae. Although a detailed analysis of the puffing activities of these chromosomes has not been published there is considerable specificity as to the site of the puffs and the chromosomes from different infected tissues (e.g. salivary gland, gut) show some differences in their puffing patterns (Pavan and Basile, 1966a). The DNA puffs normally active in Rhynchosciara prepupae are not seen in infected cells (Pavan and Perondini, quoted by Jurand et al., 1967; Pavan and da Cunha, 1969a, b). The effects of protozoan infection have been studied in other Sciarinae by Pavan and Perondini (1966) and by da Cunha e t al. ( 1968). In addition to polytene chromosome hypertrophy the infection of a sciarid Trichosia sp. by a gregarine eventually results in the complete fibrillation of the polytene chromosomes, a process recalling the chromosome behaviour of cecidomyiids (see page 6 ) . Jurand et al. (1967) examined the changes in ultrastructure in the salivary glands of Sciara ocellaris infected by Thelophania sp. (microsporidian). Widespread changes were found especially in the endoplasmic reticulum, its associated ribosomes and in the mitochondria. In addition to the examples studied by Pavan et al., chromosome hypertrophy resulting from infection has been described in Simuliids (Debaisieux and Gastaldi, 19 19), Chironomus melanotus (Keyl, 1960), and in Dasyneura urticae by Matuszewski (1964, see page 5). Severe abnormalities of polytene chromosome organization were found in individuals of Drosophila willistoni suffering from unidentified infections (da Cunha e t al., 1967). It has generally been accepted that the cellular and chromosomal hypertrophy in infected tissues results from an increase in gene activity which supplies the needs of the multiplying parasites
PUFFS
53
(Roberts et al., 1967). The molecular basis of these changes is unknown. However, it is probably of significance that at least one microsporidian, Nosema sp., which infects insects, is known to produce juvenile hormone or a substance with juvenile hormone activity. Infected animals fail to metamorphose or show derangements of metamorphosis such as the production of larval/pupal intermediates (Finlayson and Walters, 1957; Fisher and Sanborn, 1962). The possibility that the microsporidia infecting Pavan’s cultures also produce juvenile hormone should be investigated. It is interesting to note, however, that Pavan and Basile (1966a) have found that infected Rhynchosciara often “give rise to phenocopies, many of which d o not pass the beginning of metamorphosis”. The suggestion might be made that the observed changes in chromosome structure and function result from severe hormonal imbalance in the infected individuals, specifically from a high juvenile hormone titre. In this context it is relevant t o consider other examples of polytene chromosome hypertrophy which are not the result of infection. In Drosophila two different situations have been found to result in polytene chromosome hypertrophy. Firstly, several mutant stocks in which metamorphosis is blocked and the larval period greatly extended have chromosomes that are much shorter, but also much wider, than normal. Examples are the tu-h stock studied by Rodman and Kopac ( 1964) and Rodman (1964, 1967a) and the related lethal-tumerous (ZtZ) stock studied by Kobel and van Breugel (1 968). Rodman and Kopac (1 964) were inclined to suggest that the increase in chromosome diameter in tu-h larvae was due to “swelling” of the chromosomes but Rodman ( 1967a) later demonstrated that at least one extra round of DNA replication takes place in these larvae and that an increase in the degree of polyteny occurs. Rodman (1 964) claims that the puffing patterns of the tu-h larvae are abnormal but her data are not unequivocal. The polytene chromosomes of the It1 mutant of D. melanogaster have a similar morphology to those of the tu-h strain (Kobel and van Breugel, 1968). These authors note that shortened polytene chromosomes occur in other tissues of the It1 stock, e.g. Malpighian tubules and mid-gut. Larvae of D. hydei injected with 5-fluorouracil or larvae of the pci mutant stock of this species also have hypertrophied salivary gland chromosomes-both the analogue-treated larvae and the mutant stock have an extended larval development. Not all conditions which result in extended larval development or failure of metamorphosis result in chromosome hypertrophy. For example the A.1.P.-3
54
M. ASHBURNER
lgl mutant of D. melunoguster fails to pupate due to a deficiency in ecdysone (see page 37) and the larvae remain alive for up to 15 days. The polytene chromosomes of lgl do not show abnormalities of structure similar to those described (Ashburner, unpublished). The mutant giant of D. melunoguster also has an extended larval development yet normal salivary gland chromosomes and puffing patterns (Becker, 1959). The second situation that leads to polytene chromosome hypertrophy in Drosophilu is the culture of larval salivary glands in the abdomen of adult flies (Hadorn et ul., 1963). After prolonged culture (e.g. 20 to 50 days) many nuclei of the glands possess “supergiant” chromosomes and Hadorn e t ul. (1 964) demonstrated the occurrence of extra DNA replication under these conditions. These results were confirmed by Berendes and Holt (1965) who transplanted the larval salivary glands of D. hydei into adult hosts and studied patterns of DNA synthesis. Garcia-Bellido (1965) discovered that if the head region of a newly enclosed first instar larva of Drosophilu is implanted into an adult abdomen considerable growth and differentiation of larval tissues occurs including the development of polytene salivary gland chromosomes. Staub ( 1969) made a further study of this phenomenon and obtained successful polytene chromosome differentiation from the implantation of half embryos as early as 4 hr old. Many of the salivary gland nuclei developing under such conditions had supergiant chromosomes resembling those previously described. One common feature to all of these experiments, both those of nature and those performed in the laboratory, appears to be that the nuclei are developing in an abnormal hormonal environment. Circumstantial evidence indicates that, in particular, levels of juvenile hormone are high. Just how this hormonal imbalance produces its effect at the level of the chromosomes is a question that would repay study. X. THE PHYSIOLOGY OF NURSE CELL POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES
The ovaries of the higher Diptera are meroistic-that is each oocyte is provided with a number of nurse cells, usually IS. A single oocyte and its 15 nurse cells are the mitotic products of a particular oogonial cell. Due to incompleteness of cell divisions canals connect all of the nurse cells with the oocyte thus enabling the transfer of substances from the nurse cells to their oocyte (see King, 1964; Bier,
PUFFS
55
1967). In Drosophila the growth of the nurse cells during oogenesis is initially accompanied by the development of small polytene chromosomes. Later these chromosomes fall apart and the individual chromosomes replicate, presumably by endomitosis. In some mutants of D. melanogaster this process is disturbed and aberrant nurse cells with small (as in the mutant su2-Hw)or large polytene chromosomes (as in the mutant fes) occur (King et al., 1961; Klug et al., 1968). The polytene chromosomes of the fes mutant were studied by Schultz (1965) who noted that although their banding patterns differed in many details from those of the salivary gland chromosomes the individual chromosome arms were identifiable. On cytological grounds the X chromosome of fes nurse cell nuclei appears to be very active since, in contrast with the autosomes, it is very diffuse and is the major site of H3 -uridine incorporation. In Calliphora erythrocephala secondary polytenization of the endopolyploid nurse cell nuclei occurs spontaneously at low frequency during late growth stages (Bier, 1957). The frequency can be increased by low culture temperature, by inbreeding of the cultures and by the correct nutritional conditions (Bier, 1959). Secondary poly tene chromosomes have a well-defined banded structure, characteristic puffed regions and Balbiani rings (Bier, 1960). The banding pattern of the polytene chromosomes of nurse cells cannot, however, be homologized with that of the epidermal cell polytene chromosomes of the same species. The secondary nurse cell polytene chromosomes of Calliphora erythrocephala differ in one fundamental respect from the polytene chromosomes of larval tissues. Even after short periods of incorporation of H3-uridine into RNA the nurse cell chromosomes show a continuous pattern of labelling-the total length of the chromosome is covered with silver grains and puffed chromosome regions are not necessarily more heavily labelled than structurally unmodified regions (Bier et al., 1967; Ribbert and Bier, 1969). Furthermore, numerous irregular ribonucleoprotein aggregations adhere to several chromosome loci. Functionally the nurse cell polytene chromosomes bear a greater similarity to the lampbmsh chromosomes of oocytes of vertebrates (Callan, 1963) and of the oocytes of insects with panoistic ovaries (Kunz, 1967a, b) than to the polytene chromosomes of the larval and pupal tissues of Diptera. The difference in behaviour of the nucleoli of the polytene nuclei of these two cell types in Calliphora emphasizes this point. In
56
M. ASHBURNER
polytene nurse cell nuclei the nucleolus organizer fragments in some way to produce multiple nucleoli each containing DNA and synthesizing RNA. In the trichogen cells of pupae only a single nucleolus is visible. The proportion of the total nuclear RNA synthesized in the nucleoli of nurse cell nuclei is 72% and in trichogen nuclei 13%(Ribbert and Bier, 1969). In the polytene nurse cell nuclei, as in the oocytes of insects with panoistic ovaries, ribosomal RNA synthesis is a, if not the, major cellular function. XI. THE PHYSIOLOGY OF EPIDERMAL CELL POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES
The development of polytene chromosomes in epidermal cell nuclei during pupal differentiation was first described by Whitten (1 963) from Sarcophagn bullata. As Whitten has emphasized, the behaviour of these chromosomes is of particular importance since they occur in tissues whose function-that is the secretion of the adult cuticle and its appendages-is well known and to a certain extent understood. Furthermore, the epidermis itself is a “target organ” of ecdysone. The analysis of puffing patterns in the nuclei of the giant cells which secrete the dorsal cuticle of the pulvilli may prove to be very important for our understanding of the regulation and functional significance of puffing. The development of the foot pads (the pulvilli of the pretarsus) of Sarcophaga bullata has been described in detail by Whitten in a series of papers (Whitten, 1968, 1969a, b, c). A resume of the more important events is, however, essential for an understanding of the behaviour of the giant chromosomes. After eversion of the leg imaginal disc (on day 1 of pupal development) the foot is a sac of uniform epidermal cells filled with haemolymph and blood cells. These epidermal cells secrete a pupal cuticle from which they later retract on day 2. Cell divisions cease on the dorsal surface of the foot on day 2, yet continue on the ventral surface for a further day. Dorsally, on day 3, two groups of cells on each half of the foot can be distinguished by their size and by their migratory movements. The first group, of five cells, will form the pretarsal claws while the second group, of two cells, grow enormously through days 3 and 4 to cover the entire dorsal surface of the foot. The nuclei of the giant cells start to become polytene on day 2, and by day 4, when growth has ceased, they contain well-developed polytene chromosomes, with a 1024C DNA value (Roberts, 1968). Starting on day 5 secretion of
PUFFS
57
cuticle begins; on the dorsal surface of the foot pad by the two giant cells, and on the ventral surface by the many thousand small “tenant” cells. At least five layers of cuticle are synthesized by day 7. They are, in order of laying down (1) ecdysial membrane (day 5), (2) cuticulin (day 6), (3) dense exocuticle (days 6-7), (4) homogeneous exocuticle (day 7), and (5) “mesocuticle” (day 7). On day 9 histolysis of the tenant cells begins, aided by the phagocytic activity of the haemocytes. The tenant cells have disappeared by days 1O/1 1 and many thousands of hairs are all that remain witness to their activity. On day 11 endocuticle deposition and sclerotization commences and the giant cells begin to be histolysed. By emergence on day 11-12 the giant cells have gone and the adult pulvillus with its ridged dorsal cuticle and the many thousand tenant hairs on its ventral and lateral surfaces is completed (Whitten, 1968, 1969a, c). Growth of the flat dorsal giant cells and polytenization of their chromosomes is essentially complete by day 4 although further cycles of replication d o occur late in development (Roberts, 1968). From the time that cytological analysis of the chromosomes is possible many puffs are visible in these chromosomes and throughout days 4 t o 11 a large number of puffs appear, regress and in some cases reappear in a sequence that is highly co-ordinated with such events as the phases of cuticle deposition and cell histolysis. The majority of the 80 or so puffs studied by Whitten (1969d) would appear to be typical RNA puffs. The number of active sites increases to a maximum at day 5-that is just prior to the maximum phase of cuticle synthesis-and then decreases. The nucleolus is also largest on day 5 (Clever et ul., 1969a). From the diagrams published by Whitten (1969d, Figs 15-19) it is clear that the number of puffs active on day 5 is about three times the number active from days 9 to 11. However, as Whitten points out even during histolysis of the giant cells many puffs continue to be active, and new puffs appear. This situation resembles that described by Ashburner ( 1967a) during the breakdown of the salivary gland of Drosophilu melunoguster. Similar observations on puffing patterns in foot pad nuclei of S. bullutu have been made by Bultmann (Clever et ul., 1969a). Over 600 puffs have been recorded by Bultmann, the activity of each changing in a regular manner during the various stages of foot pad development. It is of great interest that although the puffing pattern of each of the 24 foot pad nuclei of an individual are identical they are not exactly synchronous-the cells of the hind legs lagging behind the cells of the front legs and the outer cells of each foot pad lagging
58
M. ASHBURNER
behind the inner ones. This observation may be of significance to speculation concerning the endocrine control of puffing (see p. 40). In addition t o the RNA puffs typical of polytene chromosomes the foot pad chromosomes also show a phenomenon related to DNA puffing (see Section V(H), p. 23) (Whitten, 1965). Although obvious DNA puffs are relatively few, disproportionate DNA synthesis, at certain loci, is common and is characterized by the budding off, from these chromosome regions, of DNA granules (Whitten, 1965). A close association of these granules and the nuclear membrane has been noted (Whitten, 1965; Roberts, 1968). DNA granule production occurs at a limited number of chromosome loci and the frequency of granules at each site is subject to variation correlated with development. The granules themselves appear to have a DNA core surrounded by a matrix of ribonucleoprotein. They incorporate both H3 -thymidine and H3 -uridine, although it is not clear whether either DNA or RNA can be synthesized by the granules after their detachment from the chromosomes. The extra DNA synthesis involved in the production of the granules results in a skewing of the DNA values measured from foot pad giant cell nuclei (Roberts, 1968). Puffing patterns in the foot pad giant cell nuclei of S. bullutu can be compared with puffing patterns of the polytene chromosomes of the bristle initial cells. The trichogen and tormogen cells are also modified epidermal cells concerned with the synthesis and secretion of cuticle. In S. bullutu preliminary observations (Whitten, 1969d) indicate that the banding patterns of the chromosomes of foot pad and trichogen cells are identical and that many puffs are active in both tissues. The similarity of puffing patterns of foot pad and trichogen chromosomes is especially evident during the early stages of differentiation. Later, however, many puffs are active in the foot pad that are absent from the trichogen nuclei. In particular many puffs active in the foot pad cells during their histolysis are not active in the trichogen nuclei. Significantly the trichogen cells d o not histolyse on emergence of the adult (Whitten, 1969d) and the differences in puffing activity may well reflect the differences in developmental fate of the two cell types. The polytene chromosomes of the thoracic trichogen cells of Culliphoru erythrocephula have been extensively studied by Ribbert ( 1967); Ribbert and Bier ( 1969). The polytene chromosomes of the tormogen (bristle socket) cells are, in this species, not very suitable for detailed analysis. In C. erythrocephala polytenization of
PUFFS
59
trichogen chromosomes accompanies growth of the cell and its nucleus; final DNA contents are in the 2048C range. Maximum nuclear size is accompanied by maximum puffing activity of these chromosomes. A number of puffs have been followed and they exhibit considerable developmental specificity. All of these puffs appear to be RNA puffs. Neither DNA puffs nor DNA granule formation were described by Ribbert ( 1 967). In general the frequency of active chromosome sites correlated with the changes in ecdysone titre as measured by Shaaya and Karlson (1965). Towards the end of imaginal differentiation the puffing frequency, and the ecdysone titre, decrease. Several puffs are, however, characteristic of these late stages in development. The results of experimental induction of puffing in these chromosomes by hormones have not yet been published. XII. THE PHYSIOLOGICAL AND FUNCTIONAL SIGNIFICANCE OF PUFFING A. SALIVARY GLAND FUNCTION
Despite its name the salivary gland of larval Diptera is not usually regarded as playing a major role in digestion. At least in Drosophila recent studies have shown that digestion occurs in the mid-intestine and that many enzymes characteristic of digestion are virtually absent from the larval salivary gland [e.g. amylases (Doane, 1969), alkaline DNAse (Boyd and Boyd, 1969), and trypsin-like proteases (Waldner-Steifelmeier, 1967)], but are very active in the midintestine. Similar findings were reported for the salivary gland of Acricotopus lucidus by Baudisch ( 1 963a). Many histological studies of the salivary gland of Drosophila larvae have noted the accumulation in the cytoplasm of large granules or vacuoles during the period of the late third instar. These have been given various names by, for example Painter (1946, secretory globules), Hsu (1 948, food vacuoles), Lesher (195 1, 1952, deuteroplasmic substances) and assigned an equally wide variety of functions, e.g. digestive, food storage, as a precursor of chitin or as evidence of histolytic changes. The true nature and significance of the secretion of late larval salivary glands of Drosophila was only realized by Fraenkel and Brookes ( 1 953). They demonstrated that the secretion is stored in the lumen of the salivary gland until puparium formation when it is expectorated and serves as a glue to affix the puparium to its substrate. These authors also noted that the salivary
60
M. ASHBURNER
glands of cyclorraphous Diptera which d o not fix their puparium in this way d o not show the massive accumulation of secretion prior to puparium formation characteristic of, for example, Drosophila. Although suitable ultrastructural studies have not been carried out it is clear that during the last half of the third larval instar a secretion accumulates in large membrane bound cytoplasmic vesicles which migrate to the luminal cell border and discharge their contents into the gland lumen (Gay, 1956; Swift, 1962; Berendes, 1965a; Rizki, 1967). The light microscope study of Hsu (1948) implicated the Golgi apparatus in the formation of these vesicles in common with the secretory process of many other cell types (see below). Histochemical studies of the cytoplasmic granules demonstrated that, like the glue, they were PAS positive (Lesher, 1952; Swift, 1962; Berendes, 1965a) and it was suggested that the material of the granules was neutral mucopolysaccharide (Lesher, 1952) or mucoprotein (Berendes, 1965a) in nature. A biochemical study of the secretion by Kodani (1948) characterized the glue as a mucoprotein; Kodani detected several amino acids in hydrolysates of the secretion and in addition the amino sugar glucosamine. Recent studies (Ashburner and Blumenthal, unpublished) have confirmed much of Kodani’s analysis. The glue of D. rnelunogaster is a mucoprotein or complex of mucoproteins with a composition 70% amino acids and 30% sugars. The amino acid analysis is notable in the very high proportion of serine, threonine, glutamate, aspartate and proline and the low amounts of cyclic and sulphur amino acids. It is interesting that serine, threonine and aspartate are the three major amino acids involved in the linkage of the carbohydrate moeties to the protein backbone of mucoproteins (Gottschalk, 1966). A complex mixture of sugars was detected including several hexoses, aminohexoses, N-acetyl aminohexoses and hexuronic acids. A partial biochemical and immunological analysis of the glue of D. virilis was published by Perkowska (1 963a). The salivary glands of many other families of Diptera also appear to be largely involved in the production of one major secretion. The function of this secretion is varied: tube building and feeding (e.g. Chironomidae), slime and coccoon formation (e.g. Mycetophilidae, Cecidomyiidae) or as a “life line” (e.g. Simuliidae). Very little information is available concerning the compositions of these secretions, with the exception of the work of Laufer and his group which will be discussed below (page 66) (see Kato and Sirlin, 1963; Kato e t al., 1963; Yoshimatsu and Uehawa, 1968).
PUFFS
61
Electron microscopic studies of salivary gland structure have been published for several species: Simulium niditifrons (Macgregor and Mackie, 1967), Brudysia mycorum (Sciarinae) (Jacob and Jurand, 1963), Sciuru coprophilu (Phillips and Swift, 1965), S. ocelluris (Jurand e t ul., 1967), Chironomus tentuns (Schin and Clever, 1968a), C. thummi (Kloetzel and Laufer, 1968), C. dorsulis (Yoshimatsu, 1962) and Smittiu purthenogenetica (Chironomidae) (Jacob and Jurand, 1965). A full account of these studies will not be given in this review since there has been little correlation of the ultrastructural observations with the physiology of the gland itself. However in all species examined a variety of “secretory granules” have been figured and the Golgi apparatus implicated in their genesis. Typically these granules release their contents into the gland lumen, presumably through reverse pinocytosis. The lumenal border of the gland cells is usually modified as a brush border with numerous microvilli. The salivary gland of Sciuru coprophilu, studied by Phillips and Swift (1965) is of interest in possessing a wide variety of different secretory granules each with a corresponding type of Golgi apparatus. Marked changes in the frequency of two of the three main types of granule were found to occur before pupation. The electron-lucid granules, common in early fourth instar larvae, disappear during the prepupal period, while the electron dense granules are only found in the late fourth instar larvae and prepupae. Phillips and Swift suggest that the electron dense granules are the precursors of the acid mucoprotein used for coccoon formation in this species. In contrast to the situation described for Sciuru only one type of secretory granule was seen in the salivary glands of the larvae of Simulium niditifrons by Macgregor and Mackie ( 1967). In addition to the major secretory products of the larval salivary gland a wide variety of enzymes of the salivary glands have been studied and changes in enzyme activity have often been found to be correlated with development. Patterson e t ul. ( 1949a, b) were the first to study salivary gland enzymes in Drosophilu melanoguster. In particular they followed the changes in activity of various peptidases. A peptidase which hydrolysed alanyl-glycine with a pH optimum of pH 7.65 was found to increase in activity throughout the first 6 hr of the prepupal period and then to decrease. The function of this enzyme is obscure since its optimal pH is not that expected for an enzyme concerned with salivary gland histolysis (see below). Laufer and his colleagues have followed the activities of eight enzymes in the salivary gland of Chironomus thummi. Three A.1.P.-3
*
62
M. ASHBURNER
enzymes (RNAse, “esterase” and “phosphatase”) showed n o change in specific activity during the development of fourth instar larvae and prepupae. The activities of malate dehydrogenase, trehalase, hyaluronidase, and a protease (see Rodems e t al., 1969) all doubled from mid-fourth instar larvae to early prepupae and then decreased in the late prepupae (Laufer, 1963, 1965). These increases in activity were sensitive to both inhibitors of protein synthesis (puromycin, Laufer, 1965) and inhibitors of RNA synthesis (actinomycin D, Laufer et al., 1964). In addition to being present in the salivary gland the trehalase, protease and hyaluronidase activities have also been detected by Laufer in the salivary gland secretion itself (Laufer and Nakase, 1965a). In the salivary gland of Sciara coprophila the activity of glucose-6-phosphatase shows complex changes with the development of the larvae (Terner e t al., 1965, 1967; Goodman e t al.. 1968). Three peaks of activity, in 12-, 16- and 19day-old animals, have been described and these authors have studied the effect of cortisone feeding on this activity. Apparently the different peaks are affected in dissimilar ways; the 13day peak is unaffected, the 16day peak increased and the 19day peak reduced (Goodman et al., 1968). Parallel changes in the activity of RNA polymerase were also reported (Terner et al., 1967). In the salivary glands of Drosophila changes in the distribution of beta-galactosidase were followed histochemically by Ritossa ( 1963b). Present in all cells of young third instar larvae, activity disappeared from the distal cells in older larvae only to reappear in these cells just before pupation (sic). The study of DNA% activity in salivary glands of C. thummi by Laufer is of great interest as it highlights a function of the salivary gland which has yet to be discussed; i.e. its histolysis. In common with most larval tissues the dipteran salivary gland is completely histolysed shortly after pupation although both biochemical and cytological changes preparative for this event can be detected many hours earlier. In C. thummi DNAse (pH optimum 7.0 with native DNA as substrate) activity increases seven-fold in late prepupae (Laufer and Nakase, 1965b). The activity of all other enzymes studied decreases at this time. Following the increase in DNAse activity the DNA content of the individual salivary gland nuclei decreases (Laufer et al., 1968). Laufer draws the reasonable conclusion from these data that the increase in DNAse activity at this time is intimately concerned with the process of salivary gland
PUFFS
63
histolysis. However the changes in DNAse activity are probably very much more complex than described. This is apparent from a detailed analysis of the DNAse of Drosophila by Boyd ( 1969) and Boyd and Boyd (1969). Larval salivary glands of D. hydei have one major DNAse activity; the enzyme has a low pH optimum ( p H 4 ) and migrates on electrophoresis with a Rm of 0.64. The prepupal salivary glands, on the other hand, have five bands of DNAse activity with acid pH optima but differing in their electrophoretic mobilities and other characteristics. The prepupal salivary gland also has a sixth DNAse with an alkaline pH optimum. It is of great interest, and this point will be discussed below, that very similar changes in DNAse activity, after puparium formation, are found even in tissues that do not undergo histolysis, e.g. Malpighian tubules (Boyd and Boyd, 1969). The role of the lysosomes in tissue destruction has been reviewed by de Duve (1963) and their importance in tissue histolysis in insects emphasized by the studies of Lockschin and Williams ( 1965a, b) and of Osinchack (1966). Misch (1962) was the first author to note an increase in the activity of lysosomes, as visualized by the standard Gomori reaction for acid phosphatase, prior t o metamorphosis in the salivary glands of Sarcophaga. Later Rasch and Gawlik ( 1964) noted a similar phenomenon in the salivary glands of Sciara coprophila prepupae and further found two types of “acid phosphatase” granule in an electron microscope study. Jacob and Jurand (1965) described lysosome-like bodies in the gland of Smittia parthenogenetica. The only comprehensive account of salivary gland histolysis is, however, that of Schin and Clever (1965, 1968a) for Chironomus tentans. A variety of cytoplasmic bodies showed a positive acid phosphatase reaction, but two main classes were distinguished (see Rasch and Gawlik, 1964). The larger bodies (interpreted as lysosomes) were 0.5 p to 1 p in diameter and were electron lucid. They were bounded by a single membrane and were not sensitive to cycloheximide. The lysosomes were found mainly in the basal region of the cells (an observation confirmed by Rasch and Gawlik, 1964). The small bodies, on the other hand, were sensitive to cycloheximide, were electron dense and were frequently associated with the Golgi complex. They were considered, by Schin and Clever, to be a precursor of the secretory material. The frequency of lysosomes, per unit area of cytoplasm, was found to change dramatically with development. Rare in third instar or young fourth instar larvae they became more frequent as the time of pupation approached and were
64
M. ASHBURNER
most frequent just prior to the start of cytolysis. The actual breakdown of the salivary gland cells in young pupae involves not only the lysosomes but- also other cell organelles. In histolysing glands considerable free acid phosphatase activity was found. Schin and Clever suggest that the lysosomes may be functional in the salivary glands of younger animals also, for example they may be involved in such activities as the uptake of foreign proteins (see Schin and Clever, 1968b and below). A third enzyme, a protease with an optimal pH of 3.5, probably involved in tissue destruction has been studied in the salivary glands of C. tentans by Rodems et al. ( 1969). During prepupal development the specific activity of this enzyme increases three-fold. B. SPECIFIC CORRELATIONS OF PUFFS AND SALIVARY GLAND FUNCTION
The correlation of the activities of specific puffs with particular salivary gland functions has only been thoroughly analysed in three instances. The first example is in the sibling species Chironomus palliduvitatusltentans where the production of the special secretory granules of the “Sonderzellen” of C. palliduvitatus is dependent upon the activity, in these cells, of a fourth chromosome Balbiani ring “BR sz” (Beermann, 196 1). Extensive cytogenetic investigation of the BR sz and special secretion production in the Sonderzellen by Beermann established that the genetic difference responsible for variation in the ability to make the secretion and the locus of the BR sz mapped coincidentally near the end of chromosome IV (see page 29). The BR sz is not active in the normal cells of the salivary gland of C. palliduvitatus nor in any of the cells of the gland of C. tentans. These cell types lack the special secretion. Comparison of the proteins of the normal cells and the Sonderzellen of the palliduvitatus salivary gland has shown a unique protein fraction in the Sonderzellen (Grossbach quoted by Beermann, 1967b). Biochemical analysis of the secretion of the salivary glands of C. palliduvitatus and C. tentans has further implicated the BR in controlling the nature of the main gland secretion (Grossbach, 1968). Electrophoresis of the secretion of C. tentans salivary glands separated six main protein components each of high molecular weight (above 5 x l o 5 daltons). These components can be dissociated, by the reduction of S-S bonds and by alkylation, into a greater number of subunits each of which is probably equivalent to a single polypeptide.
PUFFS
65
The electrophoretic pattern of reduced proteins from the main gland secretion of C. tentans and C. palliduvitatus is similar except that an extra protein band is found in the secretion of the latter species. The presence of this protein is dependent upon the presence in the salivary gland nuclei of at least one palliduvitatus fourth chromosome and preliminary evidence suggests strongly that only the distal end of this chromosome-which bears a Balbiani ring (BR3)-is necessary for the production of this particular component of the secretion. The structure of the salivary gland of Acricotopus lucidus and the intragland variation in Balbiani ring formation in this species has been discussed in a previous section of this review (page 29). Of the three lobes of the salivary gland of this species two, the main lobe and the side lobe, are characterized by the presence of hydroxyproline detected after hydrolysis and chromatography. This amino acid is not found in hydrolysates of the anterior lobe nor is it present in other organs of the larvae (Baudisch, 1960, 1963b) nor in the food (Baudisch, 1964). Salivary glands take up C14 labelled proline from the food (Baudisch, 1964) and will convert labelled proline into hydroxyproline during in vitro incubation (Baudisch, 1967). The two lobes also to convert proline to hydroxyproline differ from the anterior lobe in the possession of the two Balbiani rings BRl and BR2. Panitz (1967) discovered that the plant hormones gibberellin A3 and gibberellin A4, on addition to the culture medium of fourth instar larvae, caused regression of both BR1 and BR2 but not of BR3 and BR4 of the anterior lobe. At the concentrations of gibberellin used ( 1500 pg/ml) the effect took many hours to become apparent. The regression of these BR due to gibberellin treatment was paralleled by a reduction of H3 -uridine incorporation into RNA at these loci. The two Balbiani rings differed in their response to the gibberellins, BR2 being considerably more sensitive. Baudisch and Panitz ( 1968) studied in vitro proline hydroxylation in salivary glands from animals pretreated for 48 hr with gibberellin A3. The BR2 was inhibited in the main and side lobes of these glands. In contrast to salivary glands from untreated larvae those from gibberellin treated larvae were unable to convert proline to hydroxyproline. Since proline hydroxylation occurs after the incorporation of proline into polypeptides these authors conclude that BR2 is involved in the control of production of a secretory protein containing hydroxyproline residues (see Panitz, 1968). These two examples are the only well studied correlations of
66
M. ASHBURNER
particular salivary gland function and the activity at particular puff loci. In neither case has the causal relationship between the activity of the puff and the presence in the secretion of a particular protein been rigorously proved, although the published data are very suggestive that such causal relationships do exist. In addition t o these examples Berendes ( 1965a) has demonstrated a correlation between the activity of the puff 47B in Drosophila hydei and the presence in the cells of PAS positive secretion granules. The discovery that the salivary gland secretion of Chironomus thummi possessed several enzyme activities and the failure to find any antigens specific to either salivary glands or their secretion led Laufer (1965) and Laufer and Nakase (1964, 1965a) t o suggest that the salivary gland does not synthesize its secretion itself but acts as a transport organ sequestering the components of the secretion from the haemolymph and elaborating them into the final secretory product. The Balbiani rings and other puffs were, it was proposed, not coding for the synthesis of the secretion but for the “permeases” necessary for the uptake by the gland of macromolecules. Six enzymes (hyaluronidase, DNAse, RNAse, trehalase, esterase, and protease) were detected in the salivary gland secretion, in the salivary gland itself, and in the haemolymph (Laufer and Nakase, 1965a) (recently Rodems et al., 1969 have been unable to detect the presence of any significant protease activity in C. tentuns haemolymph). The six antigens detected in the secretion were also common to the haemolymph although later a secretion specific antigen was discovered (Laufer, 1968). Electrophoresis of salivary gland proteins led to the separation of 11 major bands of which 5 appear to be haemoglobin proteins. All of these are also found in the haemolymph although their relative proportions differ (Doyle and Laufer, 1968). Furthermore C14 labelled haemolymph proteins injected into larvae were secreted by the salivary glands. Human albumin protein injected into larvae was also detectable in the secretion with its antigenic properties conserved. Uptake of macromolecules by the salivary gland does not depend on either RNA or protein synthesis (Doyle and Laufer, 1969b). In later papers Doyle and Laufer (1968, 1969a) modify their position and demonstrate that some proportion of the salivary gland secretion is synthesized in the gland itself; the major portion however appears to be synthesized in other tissues. Ultrastructural studies of the salivary gland by Laufer and Goldsmith (1965) and by Kloetzel and Laufer (1968) have been used
PUFFS
67
to support the hypothesis that the gland is a transport organ. The mechanism of transport of macromolecules into the gland is claimed to be a pynocytosis-like process occurring along the haemal cell borders, the substances being sequestered in the salivary gland cytoplasm in small membrane bound vesicles. Macgregor and Mackie (1967) have challenged this interpretation of the structure of the gland claiming that similar specializations of the plasmalemma are to be found in tissues that are manifestly synthesizing proteins for export. Protein tracer molecules (e.g. ferritin, peroxidase), but not non-proteinaceous substances such as colloidal gold, are also taken up by a similar process and are to be found, within the cell, in a variety of types of vesicles including lysosomes and the Golgi apparatus (Kloetzel and Laufer, 1968) and eventually the secretion itself (Laufer, 1965). Similar results were reported by Schin and Clever (1 96813) although these authors failed to find any evidence that ferritin was ever associated with the Golgi or secreted into the gland lumen. Indeed the amount of ferritin found to be taken up by the salivary gland was small compared to the amount taken up by the larval fat body. Pertinent to Laufer’s hypothesis are the recent studies of Wobus (1969). Wobus has followed the changing patterns of proteins with development in the haemolymph and salivary gland of various chironomids by the technique of disc electrophoresis. While the proteins of the haemolymph showed considerable, and characteristic, changes with development of the fourth instar larvae and prepupae no parallel changes could be observed in the proteins of the salivary glands. There is no indication that Laufer’s hypothesis can be generalized to other groups of Diptera. Indeed the significance of the ability of the Chironornus salivary gland to take up macromolecules from the haemolymph may perhaps be seen from a consideration of the feeding biology of Chironomus larvae. In species such as C. tentans and C. thumrni the larvae inhabit tubes in mud etc.; these tubes are coated with salivary gland secretion. To feed the larvae spin a net of secretion across the mouth of their tube and use this to trap their food. Water is drawn across the net by movements of the larvae. The larvae then proceed to eat the net and the entrapped food (Walshe, 1947). At least under laboratory conditions this process is repeated with extreme rapidity and the possibility arises that some of the secretion can be recycled without degradation through the gut and back to the salivary gland for re-use. The gland may lack the suitable
68
M. ASHBURNER
specificity to avoid taking up other haemolymph proteins as well. Otherwise it is not clear why minor haemoglobins should accumulate in the gland, or why the gland should take up completely foreign proteins such as human albumin. There is no evidence at all that the Balbiani rings and the puffs are directly involved in this process of macromolecule uptake by the salivary glands. C. GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS ON THE PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION O F PUFFS
There is no need to attempt a general hypothesis concerning the function of puffs. Doubtless puffs are concerned with all of the manifold aspects of cellular and tissue function. There are, however, some aspects of the developmental physiology of puffs which require closer examination. In particular the very striking increases in puffing activity that occur during the moults and prior to metamorphosis. In many species a major secretory product is synthesized by the salivary gland at the end of larval development and functions, for example as the puparial glue in Drosophila or as coccoon material in many Nematocera. But in Drosophila considerable puffing activity continues during the prepupal period, after release from the gland of the puparial glue, and many puffs active at this time were also active, earlier in development, in third instar larvae. In D. rnelanogaster, and probably other species, the situation is even more striking since regular changes in puffing pattern occur after the initiation of salivary gland histolysis (Bodenstein, 1943). Indeed the salivary glands of animals just prior to pupation are in an advanced stage of histolysis with many pycnotic nuclei. Yet the functional nuclei of these glands have a characteristic puffing pattern (see discussion in Laufer, 1968). What is the function of this gene activity? I t was suggested (Ashburner, 1967a) that during the prepupal period at least the salivary gland, and other larval tissues, synthesize proteins and other materials of n o particular functional significance for the tissues themselves. These materials were considered t o be exported from the tissues and to be utilized by the imaginal tissues during their histogenesis. At that time this idea was put forward largely as the result of the studies of Mitchell (1966) and Geiger and Mitchell (1966) on the S protein component of the Drosophila phenol oxidase enzyme. This protein, essential for phenol oxidase activity, could only be detected in the salivary glands of young and old prepupae; in the salivary glands from midprepupal animals no activity was found. The changes in S protein activity with time
PUFFS
69
closely resembled the changes in activity of a large group of moult specific puffs. No other tissue was found to possess S protein activity and it is difficult t o avoid the conclusion that this protein must be exported from the gland since by far the most important site of action of phenol oxidase is the cuticle. Support for this idea is gained from the studies of Whitten (1 964b, 1969a, c) who has emphasized the role of the haemocytes in the transfer of materials from histolysing larval tissues to the developing imaginal tissues. During histolysis the granular haemocytes send out cytoplasmic processes which attach to and ingest fragments of histolysing larval tissues. These granular haemocytes subsequently change their form to the spherules which are often closely associated with differentiating imaginal tissues (Whitten, 1964b). The very close association of the spherules with the development of the leg, and evidence for the transfer of materials from the blood cells, has been described by Whitten (1969a). The fact that the puffing patterns of the Malpighian tubules of Drosophilu were very similar to those of the salivary glands provided an objection to these general ideas since the Malpighian tubules do not histolyse at metamorphosis. However considerable reorganization of these structures does take place after puparium formation. Boyd and Boyd (1969) have shown that in one respect at least, that is changes in the spectrum of DNAses, the behaviour of the Malpighian tubules after puparium formation closely resembles that of the salivary glands. For example larval salivary glands and larval Malpighian tubules have identical DNAse patterns-that is a single enzyme with an acid pH optimum. After puparium formation both tissues possess at least four enzymes with acid pH optima. These enzymes differ in their electrophoretic mobility and in other ways. Rasch and Gawlik (1964) also find an increase in acid phosphatase granules in the Malpighian tubules of Sciuru coprophilu prepupae.
XIII. CONCLUSIONS AND OUTLOOK
In addition to summarizing the extant literature I have attempted, in this review, t o highlight some of the more important lacunae in our knowledge of polytene chromosome puffs, their physiology and biochemistry. While there can be little doubt that Beermann’s hypothesis “that puffs represent active gene loci” is essentially correct and that puffs are regions of RNA synthesis, the molecular
70
M. ASHBURNER
basis of puff information is still obscure. Several processes are presumably involved, (i) the recognition of specific chromosomal sites by controlling elements resulting in (ii) a change in the tertiary structure of the DNA-protein complex of the chromosome such that (iii) specific RNA synthesis can now take place, (iv) the control of the transport of the RNA from the puff site perhaps involving some change in the molecular structure of the RNA itself, (v) the cessation of RNA synthesis as the result of specific signals and (vi) the return of the DNA-protein complex to the pre-active state. The precise molecular events involved in these processes, and even, in some cases, the relative order of the events, is unknown. New techniques are continually being involved for an attack on these problems; two may, perhaps, be mentioned. First methods for the mass isolation of salivary glands, their nuclei and their polytene chromosomes from Dipteran larvae (Sirlin and Schor, 1962; Karlson and Loffler, 1962; Ristow and Arends, 1968; Boyd e t ul., 1968; Boyd and Berendes, 1968; Berendes and Boyd, 1969; Cohen and Gotchel, 1969). The availability of nuclei and chromosomes in quantities sufficient for biochemistry can only lead to a furthering of our knowledge of the puffs. The second technique, the in vitro hybridization of RNA to polytene chromosome DNA, now under active investigation in several laboratories, may well answer many of our queries concerning the nature and behaviour of the RNA synthesized at the puff loci. However neither of these approaches is likely fully to satisfy our curiosity as t o the nature of the control systems, and their integration, which result in the very precise co-ordination of activities of many individual puff loci during development. Another approach, used with success in other “systems”, involves the genetic analysis of the control of puffing activity. This has already met with some success in Chironomus (Beermann, 196 1 ; Grossbach, 1968), Drosophilu (Ashburner, 1967b, 1969b, c, e; Rayle, 1967) and Sciuru (Perondini and Dessen, 1969), with the identificatibn of various mutants lacking individual puffs and an analysis of their genetic behaviour. The importance of understanding the phenomenon of puffing in all its aspects lies in the general applicability of the conclusions. There are no reasons to believe that puffs are in any way exceptional phenomena except for the fact that they are studied in chromosomes of a high degree of polyteny. Polyteny itself is probably more related to the functional problems in producing a large amount of secretion
PUFFS
71
for export by an organ with a relatively small number of cells than anything else. Were they visible by standard microscopical techniques doubtless all active gene loci of interphase chromosomes would show structural modifications directly comparable with the puffs of polytene chromosomes.
REFERENCES Abramyan, K. S . and Reingol’d, W.N. (1965). Electron microscopic study of the interrelations of the nucleolus and cytoplasm. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. S.S.S.R. 161, 160-163 (English Translation Edition (1966)). Alanso, P. and PBrez-Silva, J. (1965). Giant chromosomes in protozoa. Nature, Lond. 205, 313-314. Alfert, M. (1954). Composition and structure of giant chromosomes. Int. Rev. Cytol. 3, 131-175. Allfrey, V. G., Pogo, B. G. T., Littau, V. C., Gershey, E. C. and Mirsky, A. E. (1968). Histone acetylation in insect chromosomes. Science, N . Y. 159, 3 14-3 16. Allfrey, V. G., Pogo, B. G. T., Pogo, A. O., Kleinsmith, L. J. and Mirsky, A. E. ( 1966). The metabolic behaviour of chromatin. In “Histones: Their Role in the Transfer of Genetic Information” (A. V. S . de Reuck and J. Knight, eds). J. & A. Churchill, London. Ammermann, D. (1965). Cytologische und genetische Untersuchungen an dem Ciliaten Stylonychia mytilus Ehrenberg. Arch. Protistenk. 108, 109-152. Arnold, G. (1965). An autoradiographic study of RNA synthesis in isolated salivary glands of Drosophila hydei. I. Autoradiographic studies. J. Morph. 116, 65-88. Ashburner, M. (1967a). Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. I. Autosomal puffing patterns in a laboratory stock of D. melanogaster. Chromosoma 21,398428. Ashburner, M. (1967b). Gene activity dependent on chromosome synapsis in polytene chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster. Nature, Lond. 214, 1159-1 160. Ashburner M. (1969a). Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. 11. X chromosome puffing patterns in D. melanogaster and D. simulans. Chromosoma 2 7 , 4 7 4 3 . Ashburner, M. (1969b). Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. 111. A comparison of the puffing patterns of the sibling species D . melanogaster and D. simulans. Chromosoma 27, 64-8 5 . Ashburner, M. ( 1 9 6 9 ~ ) . Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. IV. Variability of puffing patterns. Chromosoma 27, 156-177. Ashburner, M. (1969d). Patterns of puffing activity in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. V. The responses to environmental shocks. (In preparation).
72
M. ASHBURNER
Ashburner, M. (1969e). The genetic control of puffing in polytene chromosomes. In “Chromosomes Today” (C. D. Darlington and K. R. Lewis, eds). Vol. 2, pp. 99-106. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh. Ashburner, M. (1969f). Ecdysone induction of puffing in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster. (In preparation.) Ashburner, M. and Henderson, S. A. (1969). Chromosome organisation and behaviour in the salivary glands of larval Cecidomyiidae (Diptera). (In preparation.) Bahr, G. F. and Beermann, W. (1954). The fine structure of the nuclear membrane in the larval salivary gland and midgut of Chironomus. Expl. Cell. Res. 6, 5 19-522. Balbiani E. G. (1881). Sur la structure du noyau des cellules salivaires chez les larves de Chironomus. 2001.Anz. IV, 637-641 and 662-666. Barigozzi, C. and Semenza, L. (1952). A preliminary note on the biology and chromosome cycle of Aphiochaeta xanthina Sp. Am. Nut. 86, 123-124. Baudisch, W. ( 1960). Spezifisches Vorkommen von Carotinoiden und Oxyprolin in den Speicheldriisen von Acricotopus lucidus. Nahtnvissenschaften 47, 498-499. Baudisch, W. ( 1963a). Chemisch-physiologische Untersuchungen an den Speicheldrusen von A cricotopus lucidus. 100 Jahre Landwirtschaftl. Institut der Universitat Halle, pp. 152-159. Baudisch, W. ( 1963b). Untersuchungen zur physiologischen Charakterisierung der einzelnen Speicheldriisenlappen von Acricotopus lucidus. In “Struktur und Funktion des genetischen Materials”. Bd 111, pp. 231-233. ErwinBaurGedachtnisvorlesungen.Akademie-Verlag, Berlin. Baudisch, W. ( 1963c). Aminosaurezusammensetzung der Speicheldriisen von Acricotopus lucidus. Biol. Zbl. 82, 35 1-36 1. Baudisch, W. (1964). Einbau von W-Prulhi in die Speicheldriisen von Acricotopus lucidus (Chkonomidae). In “Second International Congress of Histo- and Cytochemistry”, p. 236. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Baudisch, W. ( 1967). Spezifische Hydroxyprolinsynthese in den Speicheldriisen von Acricotopus lucidus. Biol. Zbl. 86 (Suppl), 157-162. Baudisch, W. and Panitz, R. (1968). Kontrolle eines biochemischen Merkmals in den Speicheldriisen von Acricotopus lucidus durch einen Balbiani-Ring. Expl. Cell Res. 49,470-476. Bauer, H. (1935). Der Aufbau der Chromosomen aus den Speicheldrusen von Chironomus thummi Kiefer (Untersuchungen an den Riesenchromosomen der Diptera I). Z. Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 23, 280-313. Bauer, H. ( 1938). Die polyploide Natur der Riesenchromosomen. Naturwissenschaften 26,77-78. Bauer, H. and Beermann, W. (1952). Die Polytanie der Riesenchromosomen. Chromosoma 4,6304548. Becker, H. J. ( 1959). Die Puffs der Speicheldrusenchromosomen von Drosophila melanogaster. I. Beobachtungen zum Verhalten des Puffmusters im Normalstamm und bei zwei Mutanten, giant und lethal-giant-larvae. Chromosoma 10,6544578. Becker, H. J. ( 1962a). Die Puffs der Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Drosophila melanogaster. 11. Die Auslosung der Puffbildung, ihre Spezifitat und ihre Beziehung zur Funktion der Ringdriise. Chromosoma 13, 341-384.
PUFFS
73
Becker, H. J. ( 1962b). Stadienspezifische Genaktivierung in Speicheldrusen nach Transplantation bei Drosophila melanogaster. Zool. Anz., Suppl. 25, 92-101. Beermann, W. ( 1950). Chromomerenkonstanz bei Chironomus. Naturwissenschaften 37,543-544. Beermann, W. (1 952a). Chromosomenstruktur und Zelldifferenzierung in der Speicheldriise von Trichocladius vitripennis. Z. Naturf. 7b, 237-242. Beermann, W. ( 1952b). Chromomerenkonstanz und spezifische Modifikation der Chromosomenstruktur in der Entwicklung und Organdifferenzierung von Chironomus tentans. Chromosoma 5, 139-198. Beermann, W. ( 1956). Nuclear differentiation and functional morphology of chromosomes. Cold Spring Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol. 2 1 , 2 17-232. Beermann, W. ( 1959). Chromosomal differentiation in insects. In “Developmental Cytology” (D. Rudnick, ed.), pp. 83-103. Ronald, New York. Beermann, W. (1961). Ein Balbiani-ring als Locus einer Speicheldriisen-Mutation. Chromosoma 12, 1-25. Beermann, W. ( 1962). Riesenchromosomen. Protoplasmatologia VI/D. SpringerVerlag, Vienna. Beermann, W. (1963). Cytological aspects of information transfer in cellular differentiation. A m . Zool. 3, 23-32. Beermann, W. ( 1965a). Operative Gliederung der Chromosomen. Nafurwissenschaften 52, 365-375. Beermann, W. (1965b). Structure and function of interphase chromosomes. In “Genetics Today”. Proc. XI Internat. Congress o f Genetics, Vol. 2 (S. J. Geerts, ed.), pp. 375-384. Beermann, W. (1 966). Differentiation at the level of the chromosomes. In “Cell Differentiation and Morphogenesis”. North Holland, Amsterdam. Beermann, W. (1967a). Gene action at the level of the chromosome. In “Heritage from Mendel” (R. A. Brink, ed.), pp. 179-210. University of Wisconsin, Madison. Beermann, W. ( 1967b). Gene-Regulation in Chromosomen hohere Organismen. Jahrbuch 1966 der Max-PlanckGesellschaft, pp. 69-87. Beermann, W. and Bahr G. F. (1954). Submicroscopic structure of the Balbiani-ring. Expl. Cell R es. 6, 195-20 1. Beermann, W. and Pelling, C. (1965). H3-Thymidin-markierung einzelner Chromatiden in Riesenchromosomen. Chromosoma 16,l-2 1. Benjamin, W., Goodman, R. M. and Gellhorn, A. (1968). Studies on the phosphorylation of Dipteran chromosomes and rat liver chromatin. J. Cell Biol. 39, 12A. Berendes, H. D. (1965a). Salivary gland function and chromosomal puffing patterns in Drosophila hydei. Chromosoma 17,3577. Berendes, H. D. (1965b). The induction of changes in chromosomal activity in different polytene types of cell in Drosophila hydei. Devl. Biol. 11, 37 1-384. Berendes, H. D. (1966). Gene activities in the Malpighian tubules of Drosophila hydei at different stages. J. exp. Zool. 162,209-218. Berendes, H. D. (1967a). The hormone ecdysone as effector of specific changes in the pattern of gene activities of Drosophila hydei. Chromosoma 22, 274-293.
74
M. ASHBURNER
Berendes, H. D. (1967b). Aminoacid incorporation into giant chromosomes of D. hydei. Drosoph. Znf. Serv. 42, 102-103. Berendes, H. D. (1968a). Factors involved in the expression of gene activity in polytene chromosomes. Chromosoma 24,418-437. Berendes, H. D. (1968b). The effect of ecdysone analogues on the puffing pattern of D . hydei. Drosoph. Znf. S e n . 43, 145. Berendes, H. D. (1968~ ) .Controlled induction of gene activity in polytene chromosomes. Atti del “Le basi molecolari del differenziamento”. Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei. Berendes, H. D. (1969). Induction and control of puffing. Ann. Embryol. Morph. (In press.) Berendes, H. D. and Beermann, W. (1969). Biochemical activity of interphase chromosomes. Zn “Handbook of Molecular Cytology” (A. Limade-Faria, ed.). North Holland, Amsterdam. Berendes, H. D. and Boyd, J. B. (1969). Structural and functional properties of polytene nuclei isolated from salivary glands of Drosophila hydei. J. Cell Biol. 41,591-599. Berendes, H. D. and de Bruyn, W. C. (1963). Submicroscopic structure of Drosophila hydei salivary gland cells. Z. Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 59, 142-152. Berendes, H. D. and Holt, Th. K. H. (1964). The induction of chromosomal activities by temperature shocks. Genen. Phaenen 9 , 1-7. Berendes, H. D. and Holt, Th. K. H. (1965). Differentiation of transplanted larval salivary glands of Drosophila hydei in adults of the same species. J. exp. Zool. 160,299-318. Berendes, H. D., Breugel, F. M. A. van and Holt, Th. K. H. (1965). Experimental puffs in salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila hydei. Chromosoma 16,3546. Berger, C. A. (1940). The uniformity of the gene complex in nuclei of different tissues. J. Hered. 31, 3-4. Berry, S. J. and Dietz, W. (1 968). The action of dimethyl sdphoxide and DNAse on the fine structure of Chironomus salivary gland cells. J. Insect Physiol. 14,847-854. Bier, K. (1957). Endomitose und Polyttinie in den Ngihrzellkernen von Calliphora erythrocephala Miegen. Chromosoma 8,493-522. Bier, K. ( 1958). Beziehungen zwischen Wachstumsgeschwindigkeit, endometaphasischer Kontraktion und der Bildung von Riesenchromosomen in den Nihrzellen von Calliphora. Z. Naturf. 13b, 85-93. Bier, K. (1959). Quantitative Untersuchungen uber die Variabilitat der Niihrzellkernstruktur und ihre Beeinflussung durch die Temperatur. Chromosoma 10,619453. Bier, K. (1960). Der Karyotyp von Calliphora erythrocephala Meigen unter besonderer Beriicksichtigung der Nihrzellkernchromosomen im gebundelten und gepaarten Zustand. Chromosoma 11,335-364. Bier, K. ( 1967). Oogenese, das Wachstum von Riesenzellen. Naturwissenschaften 54, 189-195. Bier, K., Kunz, W. and Ribbert, D. (1967). Struktur und Funktion der Oocytenchromosomen und Nukleolen sowie der Extra-DNS wihrend der Oogenese panoistischer und meroistischer Insekten. Chromosoma 23, 2 14-254.
PUFFS
75
Bier, K., Kunz, W. and Ribbed, D. (1969). Insect oogenesis with and without lampbrush chromosomes. In “Chromosomes Today” (C. D. Darlington and K. R. Lewis, eds), Vol. 2, pp. 107-1 15. Oliver and Boyd, Edinburgh. Black, M. M. and Ansley, H. R. (1964). Histone staining with ammoniacal silver. Science, N.Y. 143, 693-695. Block, K. (1969). Chromosomal variation in Agromyzidae. I. Phytomyza abdominalis Zeitt. Two incipient species and their natural hybrid. Hereditas 62, 131-152. Bodenstein, D. (1943). Factors influencing growth and metamorphosis of the salivary gland in Drosophila. Biol. Bull. Mar. Biol. Lab., Woods Hole 84, 13-33. Bonner, J. ( 1965). “The Molecular Biology of Development”. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Boyd, J. B. ( 1969). Drosophila deoxyribonucleases. I. Variation of deoxyribonucleases in Drosophila melanogaster. Biochim. biophys. Acta 17 1, 103-112. Boyd, J. B. and Berendes, H. D. (1968). Nuclei isolated from salivary glands of Drosophila hydei-structural and functional aspects. Genetics 60, 164. Boyd, J. B. and Boyd, H. (1969). Drosophila deoxyribonucleases. 11. Deoxyribonucleases of the organs of Drosophila hydei at the onset of metamorphosis. (In press.) Boyd, J. B., Berendes, H. D. and Boyd, H. (1968). Mass preparation of nuclei from the larval salivary glands of Drosophila hydei. J. Cell, Biol. 38, 369-376. Breuer, M. E. and Pavan, C. (1954). Salivary chromosomes and differentiation. Proc. IX Internat. Congress Genetics, Caryologia (Suppl.) 2, 778. Breuer, M. E. and Pavan, C. (1955). Behaviour of polytene chromosomes of Rhynchosciara angelae at different stages of development. Chromosoma 7, 37 1-386. Breugel, F. M. A. van (1966). Puff induction in larval salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila hydei Sturtevant. Genetica 37, 17-28. Bridges, C. B. (1935). Salivary chromosome maps. J. Hered. 26,6064. Bridges, C. B. (1937). Correspondences between linkage maps and salivary chromosome structure, as illustrated in the tip of 2R of Drosophila melanogaster. Cytologia, Fujii Jubilee Vol. pp. 745-755. Buetti, E. (1968). Einfluss von Elektrolyten auf das Puff-Muster der Riesenchromosomen in den Malpighigefassen von Chironomus thummi. Diploma-Thesis Eidgenossischen Technischen Hochschule, Zurich. Burdette, W. J. and Anderson, R.(1965). Puffing of salivary gland chromosomes after treatment with carbon dioxide. Nature, Lond. 208.409410. Callan, H. G. (1963). The nature of lampbrush chromosomes. Int. Rev. Cytol. 15, 1-34. Callan, H. G. (1967). The organisation of genetic units in chromosomes. J. Cell Sci. 2 , 1-7. Cannon, G. B. (1964). Culture of insect salivary glands in a chemically defined medium. Science, N . Y. 146, 1063. Cannon, G. B. (1965). Puff development and DNA synthesis in Sciara salivary gland chromosomes in tissue culture. J . cell. Comp. Physiol. 65, 163-182. Cassagnau, P. (1966). Presence de chromosomes geants dans les glandes salivaires des Neanura (Collembole suceurs). C.r. hebd. Seanc. Acad. Sci., Paris 262, 168-170.
76
M. ASHBURNER
Cassagnau, P. (1968). Sur la structure des chromosomes salivaires de Bilobella massoudi Cassagnau (Collembola: Neanuridae). Chromosoma 24,42-58. Cassagnau, P. (1969). Phyloghie et chromosomes polytknes chez les Collemboles Neanuridae. (In press.) Cave, M. D. (1968). Chromosomal replication and synthesis of non-histone proteins in giant polytene chromosomes. Chromosoma 25,392-40 1. Childress, D. ( 1969). Polytene chromosomes and linkage group-chromosome correlations in the Australian Sheep Blowfly Lucilia cuprina (Diptera: Calliphoridae). Chromosoma 26,208-214. Clever, U. ( 1961). Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus tentans und ihre Beziehungen zur Entwicklung. I. Genaktivierungen durch Ecdyson. Chromosoma 12,607-675. Clever, U. ( 1962a). Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus tentans und ihre Beziehungen zur Entwicklung. 11. Das Verhalten der Puffs wiihrend des letzen Larvenstadiums und der Puppenhautung. Chromosoma 13,385436. Clever, U. ( 1962b). Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus ten tans und ihre Beziehungen zur Entwicklung. 111. Das Aktivitatsmuster in Phasen der Entwicklungsruhe. J. Insect Physiol. 8,357-376. Clever, U. (1963a). Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus tentans und ihre Beziehungen zur Entwicklung. IV. Das Verhalten der Puffs in der Larvenhautung. Chromosoma 14,65 1-675. Clever, U. ( 1963b). Von der Ecdysonkonzentration abhangige Genaktivitatsmuster in den Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Chironomus tentans. Devl. Biol. 6,73-98. Clever, U. (1963~).Einige Bemerkungen uber die Regulation von Genaktivaten in Riesenchromosomen. In “Funktionelle und Morphologische Organisation der Zelle”. Wjssenschaftliche Konferenz der Gesellschaft Deutscher Naturforscher und Arzte 1962. Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg. Clever, U. (1964a). Puffing in giant chromosomes of Diptera and the mechanisms of its control. In “Nucleohistones” (J. Bonner and P. Ts’o, eds) Holden-Day, San Francisco. Clever, U. (1964b). Actinomycin and puromycin: Effects on sequential gene activation by ecdysone. Science, N.Y. 146,794-795. Clever, U. (1964~). Genaktivitaten und ihre Kontrolle in der tierischen Entwicklung. Nahtrwissenschaften 5 1,449-459. Clever, U. (1965a). The control of gene activity as a factor in cell differentiation in insect development. In “Developmental and Metabolic Control Mechanisms and Neoplasia”, Nineteenth Annual Symposium on Fundamental Cancer Research 1965. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore. Clever, U. (1965b). Puffing changes in incubated and in ecdysone treated Chironomus tentans salivary glands. Chromosoma 17,309-322. Clever, U. (1966a). Gene activity patterns and cellular differentiation. Am. 2001. 6,3341. Clever, U. (1966b). Induction and repression of a puff in Chironomus. Devl. Biol. 14,42 1-438. Clever, U. (1967). Control of chromosome puffing. In “The Control of Nuclear Activity” (L. Goldstein, ed.). Prentice Hall,Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Clever, U. (1968). Regulation of chromosome function. A. Rev. Genetics 2, 11-30.
PUFFS
77
Clever, U. (1969). Chromosome activity and cell function in polytenic cells. 11. The formation of secretion in the salivary glands of Chironomus. Expl. Cell Res. 55, 3 17-322. Clever, U. and Beermann, W. (1963). Studies of nucleo-cytoplasmic interrelations in giant chromosomes of Diptera. Proc. XVZ Znternat. Congress Zoology, Washington, 3, 21 0-21 5. Clever, U. and Karlson, P. (1960). Induktion von Puff-veranderungen in den Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Chironomus ten tans durch Ecdyson. Expl. Cell Res. 20,623-626. Clever, U. and Romball, C. G. (1966). RNA and protein synthesis in the cellular response to a hormone, ecdysone. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U S A . 56, 1470-1476. Clever, U., Bultmann, H. and Darrow, J. M. (1969a). The immediacy of genomic control in polytenic cells. In “RNA in Development”. First International Park City Symposium on Problems in Biology (E. W. Hanly, ed.). (In press.) Clever, U., Storbeck, I. and Romball, C. G. (1969b). Chromosome activity and cell function in polytenic cells. I. Protein synthesis at various stages of larval development. Expl. Cell Res. 55,306-316. Cohen, L. H. and Gotchel, B. V. (1969). Histones and other proteins in Drosophila polytene nuclei. Fedn. Proc. Fedn. A m . SOCS.exp. Biol. 28, 600. Crouse, H. V. (1968). The role of ecdysone in DNA-puff formation and DNA synthesis in the polytene chromosomes of Sciara coprophila. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 61, 971-978. Crouse, H. V. and Keyl, H. G. ( 1968). Extra replications in the “DNA-puffs” of Sciara coprophila. Chromosoma 2 5 , 357-364. da Cunha, A. B., Franca, Z. M., GonGalves, A. M. A., Hitelman, A. and Garrido, M. C. (1967). Chromosomal diseases in Drosophila willistoni Sturtevant. Revta. bras. Biol. 2 7 , 1 13-124. da Cunha, A. B., Morgante, J. S., Pavan, C. and Garrido, M. C. (1968). Studies on the cytology and differentiation in Sciaridae. I. Chromosome changes induced by gregarine in Trichosia sp. (Diptera; Sciaridae). Caryologia 21, 27 1-282. da Cunha, A. B., Pavan, C., Morgante, J. S. and Garrido, M. C. (1969). Studies on cytology and differentiation in Sciaridae. 11. DNA redundancy in salivary gland cells of Hybosciara fragilis (Diptera; Sciaridae). Proc. Symp. Nuclear Physiology and Differentiation. Belo Horizonte, Genetics, 6 1, Suppl. 1, 335-349. Daneholt, B. and Edstrom, J.-E. (1967). The content of deoxyribonucleic acid in individual polytene chromosomes of Chironomus tentans. Cytogenetics 6, 35 0-356. Debaisieux, P. and Gastaldi, L. (1919). Les microsporidies parasites des larves de Simulium. La Cellule 30, 187-2 13. de Duve, C. (1963). General properties of lysosomes. Zn “Lysosomes”. CIBA Foundation Symposium (A. V.S. de Reuck and M. Cameron, eds). J. & A. Churchill, London. de Reuck, A. V. S. and Knight, J. (eds) (1966). “Histones: Their Role in the Transfer of Genetic Information”. CIBA Foundation Study Group. J. & A. Churchill, London.
78
M. ASHBURNER
Desai, L. and Tencer, R. (1968). Effects of histones and polylysine on the synthetic activity of the giant chromosomes of salivary glands of Dipteran larvae. Expl. Cell Res. 52, 185-197. Diaz, M. and Pavan, C. (1965). Changes in chromosomes induced by micro-organism infection. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 54, 1321-1327. Doane, W . (1969). Drosophila amylase and problems in cellular differentiation. In “RNA in Development”. First International Park City Symposium on Problems in Biology (E. W.Hanly, ed.). (In press.) Doyle, D. and Laufer, H. (1968). Analysis of secretory processes in Dipteran salivary glands. In “In Vitro”, Vol. 3; Differentiation and Defense Mechanisms in Lower Organisms. Symposium of the Tissue Culture Association (M. M. Siegel, ed.). Doyle, D. and Laufer, H.(1969a). Sources of larval salivary gland secretion in the Dipteran Chironomus tentans. J. Cell Biol. 40,61-78. Doyle, D. and Laufer, H. (1969b). Requirements of ribonucleic acid synthesis for the formation of salivary gland specific proteins in larval Chironomus tentans. (In press.) Dreyfus, A., Nonato, E., Breuer, M. E. and Pavan, C. (1951). Cromosomas politenicos em virios 6rgHos de Rhynchosciara angelae Nonato and Pavan (Diptera). Revta bras. Biol. 11,439-450. Edstrom, J.-E. (1964a). Chromosomal RNA and other nuclear RNA fractions. In “Role of Chromosomes in Development” (M. Locke, ed.), pp. 137-152. Academic Press, New York. Edstrom, J.-E. ( 1964b). Microextraction and microelectrophoresis for determination and analysis of nucleic acids in isolated cellular units. In “Methods in Cell Physiology”, Vol. I (D. M. Prescott, ed.). Academic Press, New York. Edstrom, J.-E. and Beermann, W. (1962). The base composition of nucleic acids in chromosomes, puffs, nucleoli and cytoplasm of Chironomus salivary gland cells. J. Cell Biol. 14, 37 1-379. Edstrom. J.-E. and Daneholt, B. (1967). Sedimentation properties of the newly synthesised RNA from isolated nuclear components of Chironomus tentans salivary gland cells. J. molec. Biol. 28, 331-343. Ellgaard, E. G. (1967). Gene activation without histone acetylation in Drosophila melanogaster. Science, N . Y . 157, 1070-1072. Ellgaard, E. G. (1969). In preparation. Emmerich, H. (1969). Distribution of tritiated ecdysone in salivary gland cells of Drosophila. Nature, Lond. 22 1, 954. Federoff, N. and Milkman, R. D. (1 964). Specific puff induction by tryptophan in Drosophila salivary chromosomes. Biol. Bull. Mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole 127, 369. Federoff, N. and Milkman, R. D. (1965). Induction of puffs in Drosophila salivary chromosomes by amino acids. Drosoph. In$ Serv. 40,48. Ficq, A. and Pavan, C. (1957). Autoradiography of polytene chromosomes of Rhynchosciara angelae at different stages of development. Nafure, Lond. 180, 983-984. Ficq, A. and Pavan, C. (1961). Mktabolisme des acides nuclkiques et des protkines dans les chromosomes gkants. Path. Biol., Paris 9,756-757. Ficq, A., Pavan, C. and Brachet, J . (1958). Metabolic processes in chromosomes. Expl. Cell Res. Suppl. 6 , 105-1 14.
PUFFS
79
Finlayson, L. H. and Walters, V. A. (1957). Abnormal metamorphosis in Saturniid moths infected by a microsporidian. Nature, Lond. 180, 7 13-7 14. Fischer, F. M. and Sanborn, R. C. (1962). Production of insect juvenile hormone by the microsporidian parasite Nosema. Nature, Lond. 194, 1193. Fraenkel, G. (1935). A hormone causing pupation in the blowfly Calliphora erythrocephala. Proc. R . SOC. B118, 1-12. Fraenkel. G. and Brookes, V. J. (1953). The process by which the puparia of many species of flies become fixed t o a substrate. Biol. Bull. Mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole 105,442-449. Frizzi, G. and Springhetti, A. (1953). Prime richerche citogenetiche sul Dacus oleae Gmel. La Ricerca Scientifica 23, 1613-1620. Fujita, S. and Takemoto, K. (1963). Synthesis of messenger RNA on the polytene chromosomes of Dipteran salivary gland. Nature, Lond. 200, 494-495. GabrusewyczGarcia, N. ( 1964). Cytological and autoradiographic studies in Sciara coprophila salivary chromosomes. Chromosoma 15, 3 12-344. GabrusewyczGarcia, N. (1968). RNA metabolism of polytene chromosomes of Sciara coprophila. J. Cell Biol. 39,49A. Gabrusewycz-Garcia, N. and Kleinfeld, R. G. (1966). A study of the nucleolar material in Sciara coprophila. J. Cell Biol. 29, 347-359. Gall, J. G. (1968). Differential synthesis of the genes for ribosomal RNA during amphibian oogenesis. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 60, 553-560. Gall, J. G., MacGregor, H. C. and Kidston, M. E. (1969). Gene amplification in the oocytes of Dytiscid water beetles. Chromosoma 26, 169-187. Garcia-Bellido, A. (1965). Larvalentwicklung transplantierter organe von Drosophila melanogaster im Adultmileu. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 1071-1078. Gaudecker, B. von (1967). RNA synthesis in the nucleolus of Chironomus thummi as studied by high resolution autoradiography. Z . Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 82, 536-557. Gay, H. ( 1956). Nucleocytoplasmic relations in Drosophila. Cold Spring Harb. Symp. quant. Biol. 21, 257-269. Gay, H. (1959). In “The Nature of the Materials of Heredity” (B. P. Kaufman, H. Gay, M. K. Dutt, A. K. Bal and J. Buchanan, eds). Yb. Carnegie Instn. Wash. 58,440-449. Gay, H. (1964). Chromosome structure and function. Y b . Carnegie Instn. Wash. 63,605-614. Geiger, H. R. and Mitchell, H. K. (1966). Salivary gland function in phenoloxidase production in Drosophila melanogaster. J. Insect Physiol. 12,747-754. Geitler, L. ( 1953). Endomitose und endomitotische Polyploidisierung. Protoplasmatologia VI/C. Springer-Verlag, Vienna. Gilbert, E. F. and Pistey, W. R. (1966). Chromosomal puffs in Drosophila induced by hydrocortisone phosphate. Proc. SOC. exp. Biol. Med. 121, 831-832. Golikowa, M. N. (1964). Polytene chromosomes in the developing macronucleus of a ciliate. Tsitologia 6, 250-253. Goodman, R. M., Goidl, J. and Richart, R. M. (1967). Larval development in Sciara coprophila without the formation of chromosomal puffs. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. Wash. 58, 553-559.
80
M. ASHBU RN ER
Goodman, R. M., Terner, J. Y. and Spiro, D. (1968). The effect of cortisone on glucose-6-phosphatase during development. Expl. Cell Res. 49, 504-5 12. Gorovsky, M. A. and Woodward, J. (1966). Hivtone : DNA ratios in five regions of a polytene chromosome of Drosophila virilis. J. Cell Biol. 31,41A42A. Gorovsky, M. A. and Woodward, J. (1967). Histone content of chromosomal loci active and inactive in RNA synthesis. J. Cell Biol. 33,723-728. Gottschalk, A. ( 1966). “Glycoproteins”. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Greenberg, J. R. (1967). Sedimentation studies on Drosophila virilis salivary gland RNA. J. Cell Biol. 35,49A-5OA. Gross, J. D. ( 1957). Incorporation of phosphorus-32 into salivary-type chromosomes which exhibit puffs. Nature, Lond. 180,440. Grossbach, U. (1968). Cell differentiation in the salivary glands of Camptochironomus tentans and C. palliduvitatus. Ann. Zool. Fennici 5 , 37-40. Hadorn, E., Gehring, W. and Staub, M. (1963). Extensives Grossenwachstum larvaler Speicheldrusenchromosomen von Drosophila melanogaster im Adultmilieu. Experientia 19,530-531. Hadorn, E., Ruch, F. and Staub, M. (1964). Zum DNS Gehalt in Speicheldriisenkernen mit “iibergrossen Riesenchromosomen” von Drosophila melanogaster. Experientia 20, 566. Hams, H. (1968). “Nucleus and Cytoplasm”. Clarendon Press, Oxford. Heitz, E. and Bauer, H. (1933). Beweise fur die Chromosomennatur der Kernschleifen in den Knauelkernen von Bibio hortulanus L. Z. Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 17,67-82. Henderson, S. A. (1967a). A second example of normal coincident endopolyploidy and polyteny in salivary gland nuclei. Caryologia 2 0 , 181-186. Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J. and Wunderlich, J. A. (1966). Identity of the moulting hormone of insects and crustaceans. Chem. Comm. 1966, 3 39-34 1. Henderson, S . A. (1967b). The salivary gland chromosomes of Dasyneura crataegi (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae). Chromosoma 23, 38-58. Horn, E. C. and Ward, C. L. (1957). The localization of basic proteins in the nuclei of larval Drosophila salivary glands. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 43,776-779. Hsu, W. S. (1948). The Golgi material and mitochondria in the salivary glands of the larva of Drosophila melanogaster. Q. Jl. microsc. Sci. 89,401414. Ito, S . and Loewenstein, W. R. (1965). Permeability of a nuclear membrane: Changes during normal development and changes induced by growth hormone. Science, N. Y. 150, 909-910. Jacob, F. and Monod, J. (1961a). Genetic regulatory mechanisms in the synthesis of proteins. J. molec. Biol. 3 , 3 18-356. Jacob, F. and Monod, J. (1961b). On the regulation of gene activity. Cold Spring Harb. Symp. quant. Biol. 26, 193-2 11. Jacob, J. and Jurand, A. (1963). Electron microscope studies on salivary gland cells of Bradysia mycorum Frey (Sciaridae). 111. The structure of the cytoplasm. J. Insect Physiol. 9,849-857. Jacob, J. and Jurand, A. (1965). Electron microscope studies on salivary gland cells. V. The cytoplasm of Smittia parthenogenetica (Chironomidae). J. Insect Physiol. 11, 1337-1343.
PUFFS
81
Jacob, J. and Sirlin, J. L. (1959). Cell function in the ovary of Drosophilu. I. DNA classes in nurse cell nuclei as determined by autoradiography. Chromosoma 1 0 , 2 10-228. Jacob, J. and Sirlin, J. L. (1963). Electron microscope studies on salivary gland cells. I. The nucleus of Brudysia mycorum Frey (Sciaridae) with special reference to the nucleolus. J. Cell Biol. 17, 153-165. Jacob, J . and Sirlin, J. L. (1964). Electron microscope studies on salivary gland cells. IV. The nucleus of Smittiu parthenogeneticu (Chironomidae) with special reference to the nucleolus and the effects of actinomycin thereon. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 11, 315-328. Jurand, A., Simoes, L. C. and Pavan, C. (1967). Changes in the ultrastructure of salivary gland cytoplasm in Sciara ocellaris (Comstock, 1882) due to microsporidian infection. J. Insect Physiol. 13,795-803. Kalnins, V. I., Stich, H. F. and Bencosme, S. A. (1964a). Fine structure of nucleoli and RNA-containing chromosome regions of salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus and their interrelationships. Can. J. Zool. 42, 1147-1155. Kalnins, V. I., Stich, H. F. and Bencosme, S. A. (1964b). Fine structure of the nucleolar organiser of salivary gland chromosome of Chironomids. J. Ultrustruct. Res. 11, 282-29 1. Kanno, Y. and Loewenstein, W. R. (1966). Cell-to-cell passage of large molecules. Nature, Lond. 212, 629-630. Karlson, P. (1965). Biochemical studies of ecdysone control of chromosomal activity. J. cell. comp. Physiol. 66, 69-76. Karlson, P. ( 1966). Ecdyson, das Hautungshormon der Insekten. Nuturwissenschuften 53,445453. Karlson, P. and Bode, C. (1969). Die Inaktivierung des Ecdysons bei der Schmeissfliege CUlliphOrU erythrocephdu Meigen. J. Insect Physiol. 15, 11 1-118. Karlson, P. and Hanser, G. (1952). Uber die Wirkung des Puparisierungshormons bei der Wildforms und der Mutante lgl von Drosophilu melanogaster. Z. Nuturforsch. 7b, 80-83. Karlson, P. and Loffler, U. (1962). Isolierung von Speicheldrusenchromosomen durch differentiefie Zentrifugation. Hoppe-Seyler 's 2.physiol. Chem. 321, 28 6-288. Karlson, P., Sekeris, C. E. and Maurer, R. (1964). Zum Wirkungsmechanismus der Hormone. I. Verteilung von Tritium-markiertem Ecdyson in Larven von Calliphoru erythrocephdu. Hoppe-Seyler 's 2. physiol. Chem. 336, 100-106. Kato, K.4. and Sirlin, J. L. (1963). Aspects of mucopolysaccharide production in larval insect salivary cells. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 11, 163-168. Kato, K.-I., Perkowska, E. and Sirlin, J. L. (1963). Electro- and immunoelectrophoretic patterns in the larval salivary secretion of Chironomus thummi. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 11,485488. Keyl, H. G. (1960). Ehrohung der chromosomalen replikationsrate durch Mikrosporidieninfektion in Speicheldrusenzellen von Chironomus. Naturwissenschaften 4 1 , 212-213. Keyl, H.G. (1963). DNS-Konstanz in Heterochromatin von Glyptotendipes. Expl. Cell Res. 30, 245-247. Keyl, H.G. (1965). Duplikationen von Untereinheiten der Chromosomalen DNS
82
M. ASHBURNER
w a r e n d der Evolution von Chironomus thummi. Chromosoma 17, 139- 180. Keyl, H.G. and Hagele, K. ( 1966). Heterochromatin-proliferation an den Speicheldriisen-chromosomen von Chironomus melanotus. Chromosoma 19,223-230. Kiknadze, I. I. (1965). Functional changes of giant chromosome under conditions of inhibited RNA synthesis. Tsitologia 7 , 3 1 1-3 18 (Russian with English summary). Kiknadze, I. I. (1967). Chromosomes of Diptera. I. Culicidae (evolutionary and practical importance of studying the karyotypes). Genetika (U.S.S.R.) 1967( 1 l) , 145-165 (Russian with English summary). Kiknadze, I. I. and Filatova, I. T. (1963). Changes in the RNA of giant chromosomes of Chironomus dorsalis during metamorphosis and under experimental conditions. Dokl. Acad. Nauk. S.S.S.R. 152, 1276-1279 (English Translation Edition). Kimoto, Y. (1958). An attachment of the salivary gland chromosomes to the nuclear membrane found in Chironomus dorsalis. Cytologia 23, 478-484. King, D. S. and Siddall, J. B. (1969). Conversion of @cdysone to pecdysone by crustaceans and insects. Nature, Lond. 221,955-956. King, R. C. (1964). Studies on early stages of insect oogenesis. In “Insect Reproduction”: Symposia of the Royal Entomological Society, 2 (K. C. Highnam, ed.). London. King, R. C., Sang, J. H. and Leth, C. B. (1961). The hereditary ovarian tumours of the fes mutant of Drosophila rnelanogaster. Expl. Cell Res. 23, 108-1 17. Kitzmiller J. B. ( 1967). Mosquito cytogenetics. In “Genetics of Insect Vectors of Disease” (J. W. Wright and R. Pal, eds). Elsevier, Amsterdam. Kloetzel, J. A. and Laufer, H. (1968). Fine structural analysis of larval salivary gland function in Chironomus thummi. J. Cell Biol. 39,74A. Klug, W. S., Bodenstein, D. and King, R. C. (1968). Oogenesis in the su2-Hw mutant of Drosophila melanogaster. I. Phenotypic characterization and transplantation experiments. J. exp. 2001.167, 15 1-156. Kobel, H. R. and Breugel, F. M. A. van (1968). Observations on It1 (lethal tumorous larvae) of Drosophila melanogaster. Genetica 38,305-327. Kodani, M. (1948). The protein of the salivary gland secretion in Drosophila. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 34, 131-135. Koltzoff, N. (1934). The structure of the chromosomes in the salivary glands of Drosophila. Science, N . Y . 8 0 , 312-313. Kosswig, C. and Sengiin, A. (1947). Neuere Untersuchungen uber den Bau der Riesenchromosomen der Dipteren. Rev. Fac. Sci. Univ. Istanbul B12, 107- 12 1. Kraczkiewicz, Z. and Matuszewski, B. (1958). Observations sur une structure atypique des chromosomes salivaires de certains cbcidomyides. Chromosoma 9,484-492. Krimbas, C. B. (1963). A contribution to the cytogenetics of Dacus oleae (Gmel) (Diptera, Trypetidae): The salivary gland and mitotic chromosomes. Caryologia 16,37 1-375. Kroeger, H. (1960). The induction of new puffing patterns by transplantation of salivary gland nuclei into egg cytoplasm of Drosophila. Chromosoma 11, 129-145. Kroeger, H. (1963a). Experiments on the extranuclear control of gene activity in
PUFFS
83
Dipteran polytene chromosomes. J. cell. comp. Physiol. 62 (Suppl. l), 45-59. Kroeger, H. (1963b). Chemical nature of the system controlling gene activities in insect cells. Nature, Lond. 200, 1234-1235. Kroeger, H. ( 1964). Zellphysiologische mechanismen bei der Regulation von Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus thummi. Chromosoma 15, 36-70. Kroeger, H. ( 1966). Potentialdifferenz und Puffmuster. Electrophysiologische und Cytologische Untersuchungen an der Speicheldriisen von Chironomus thummi. Expl. CellRes. 41, 64-80. Kroeger, H. (1967). Hormones, ion balances and gene activity in Dipteran chromosomes. Mem. SOC.Endocr. 15, 5566. Kroeger, H. (1968). Gene activities during insect metamorphosis and their control by hormones. Zn “Metamorphosis: A Problem in Developmental Biology” (W. Etkin and L. I. Gilbert, eds). North Holland, Amsterdam. Kroeger, H. and Lezzi, M. (1966). Regulation of gene action in insect development. A . Rev. Ent. 11, 1-22. Kunz, W. (1967a). Funktionsstrukturen im Oocytenkern von Locusta migratoria. Chromosoma 20, 332-370. Kunz, W. ( 1967b). Lampenburstenchromosomen und multiple Nukleolen bei Orthopteren. Chromosoma 2 1,446462. Lamprecht, J. and Remensberger, P. (1966). Polytane Chromosomen im Bereiche der Prothoracal-dorsal-Imaginalscheibe von Drosophila melanogaster. Experientia 22, 293. Laufer, H. (1963). Hormones and the development of insects. Proc. XVZ Znt. Congr. Zool. 4 , 2 15-220. Laufer, H. (1965). Developmental studies of the Dipteran salivary gland. 111. Relationships between chromosomal puffing and cellular function during development. Zn “Developmental and Metabolic Control Mechanisms and Neoplasia”. Nineteenth Annual Symposium of Fundamental Cancer Research. Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore. Laufer, H. (1968). Developmental interactions in the Dipteran salivary gland. A m . Zool. 8,257-271. Laufer, H. and Goldsmith, M. (1965). Ultrastructural evidence for a protein transport system in Chironomus salivary glands and its implication for chromosomal puffing. J. Cell Biol. 27,57A. Laufer, H. and Holt, Th. K. H. (1969). Arch. d’anat. Microsc. (In press.) Laufer, H. and Nakase, Y. (1964). Chromosomal puffing as an expression of protein transport by the Dipteran salivary gland. J. Cell Biol. 23,52A. Laufer, H. and Nakase, Y.(1965a). Salivary gland secretion and its relation to chromosomal puffing in the Dipteran, Chironomus thummi. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 53,511-516. Laufer, H. and Nakase, Y. (1965b). Developmental studies of the Dipteran salivary gland. 11. DNAse activity in Chironomus thummi. J. Cell Biol. 25, 97-102. Laufer,H., Nakase, Y. and Vanderberg, J. (1964). Developmental studies of the Dipteran salivary gland. I. The effects of Actinomycin D on larval development, enzyme activity and chromosomal differentiation in Chironomus thummi. Devl. Biol. 9 , 367-384. Laufer, H., Rao, B. and Nakase, Y. (1965). Dipteran salivary gland metamorphosis, a self-regulating system. A m . Zool. 5 , 642.
84
M. ASHBURNER
Laufer, H., Rao, B. and Nakase, Y. (1968). Developmental studies of the Dipteran salivary gland. IV. Changes in DNA content. J. exp. Zool. 166, 7 1-76. Lees, A. D. and Waddington, C. H. (1942). The development of bristles in normal and some mutant types of Drosophila melanogaster. Proc. R . SOC. B131,87-110. Lesher, S . (1951). Studies on the larval salivary gland of Drosophila. I. The nucleic acids. Expl. Cell Res. 2, 577-585. Lesher, S. (1962). Studies on the larval salivary gland of Drosophila. 111. The histochemical localization and possible significance of ribonucleic acid, alkaline phosphatase and polysaccharide. Anat. Rec. 114,63345 1. Lezzi, M. (1961). Das Verhalten des Puffmusters der Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Chironomus unter dem Einfluss von DrosophilaEinhalt. Diploma-Thesis, Eidgenossischen Technischen Hochschule, Zurich. Lezzi, M. (1965). Die Wirkung von DNAse auf isolierte Polytlinchromosomen. Expl. Cell Res. 39, 289-292. Lezzi, M. (1966). Induktion eines Ecdyson-aktivierbaren Puff in isolierten Zellkernen von Chironomus durch KC1. Expl. Cell Res. 43, 57 1-577. Lezzi, M. ( 1967a). RNS-und Protein-synthese in Puffs isolierter Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Chironomus. Chromosoma 21,72-88. Lezzi, M. (1967b). Cytochemische Untersuchungen an Puffs isolierter Speicheldriisen-chromosomen von Chironomus. Chromosoma 2 1, 89-108. Le'zzi, M. ( 1 9 6 7 ~ ) .Spezifische Aktivitatssteigerung eines Balbianiringes durch Mg2+ in isolierten Zellkernen von Chironomus. Chromosoma 2 1, 109-122. Lezzi, M. and Kroeger, H. (1966). Aufnahme von 22Na in die Zellkerne der Speicheldriisen von Chironomus thummi. Z. Naturf. 21 b, 274-277. Lindsley, D. L. and Grell, E. H. (1968). Genetic variations of Drosophila melanogaster. Publs. Carnegie Instn 627. Lockschin, R. A. and Williams, C. M. (1965a). Programmed cell death. I. Cytology of degeneration in the intersegmental muscles of the pernyi silkmoth. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 123-133. Lockschin, R. A. and Williams, C. M. (1965b). Programmed cell death. V. Cytolytic enzymes in relation to the breakdown of the intersegmental muscles of silkmoths. J. Insect Physiol. 11,831-844. Loewenstein, W. R. and Kanno, Y.(1964). Studies on an epithelial (gland) cell junction. I. Modifications of surface membrane permeability. J. Cell Biol. 22, 565-586. MacGregor, H. C . and Mackie, J. B. (1967). Fine structure of the cytoplasm in salivary glands of Simulium. J. Cell Sci. 2 , 137-144. MacInnes, J. W. and Uretz, R. B. (1966). Organization of DNA in Dipteran polytene chromosomes as indicated by polarized fluorescence microscopy. Science, N.Y. 151,689-691. Mainx, F. (1949). The structure of the giant chromosomes in some Diptera. Proc. VZI Internat. Congress Genetics, Hereditas (Suppl.), 622-623. Mainx, F. (195 1). Die Verbeitung von Chromosomendislokationen in Natiirlichen Population von Liriomyza urophonna MIK. Chromosoma 4, 5 2 1-534. Makino, S . (1938). A morphological study of the nucleus in various kinds of somatic cells of Drosophila virilis. Cytologia 9,272-282.
PUFFS
85
Mattingly, E. (1966). Variations in metabolic activity during the larval development of Rhynchosciara. J. Cell Biol. 31,74A. Mattingly, E. and Parker, C. (1968a). Sequence of puff formation in Rhynchosciara polytene chromosomes. Chromosoma 23,255-270. Mattingly, E. and Parker, C. (196813). Nucleic acid synthesis during larval development of Rhynchosciara. J. Insect Physiol. 14, 1077-1083. Matuszewski, B. (1964). Polyploidy and polyteny induced by a hymenopteran parasite in Dasyneura urticae (Diptera; Cecidomyiidae). Chromosoma 15, 31-35. Matuszewski, B. (1965). Transition from polyteny to polyploidy in salivary glands of Cecidomyiidae. Chromosoma 16,22-34. McMaster-Kaye, R. (1962). The metabolism of nuclear ribonucleic acid in salivary glands of Drosophila repleta. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 10, 154- 16 1. Mechelke, F. ( 1952). Reversible Strukturmodifikationen der Speicheldriisenchromosomen von Acricotopus lucidus. Chromosoma 5, 5 11-543. Mechelke, F. (1958). The timetable of physiological activity of several loci in the salivary gland of Acricotopus lucidus. Proc. X Znt. Congress Genet. 2, 185. Mechelke, F. (1962). Spezielle Funktionszustande des genetischen Materials. In “Funktionelle und Morphologische Organisation der Zelle”. Wissenschaftliche Konferenz der Gesellschaft Deutscher Naturforscher und Arzte. Springer-Verlag, Heidelbefg. Melland, A. M. (1941). The salivary glands of Prodiamesia olivacea. J. Hered. 32, 165-167. Melland, A. M. (1942). Types of development of polytene chromosomes. Proc. R . SOC.Edinb. B61, 316-327. Metz, C. W. (1935). Structure of the salivary gland chromosomes in Sciara. J. Hered. 26, 176-188. Midelfort, M. E. and Rasch, R. W. (1968). The effect of exogenous cortisone acetate on development and “chromosome puffing” in Drosophila virilis. J. Cell Biol. 39, 91A. Misch, D. W. (1962). Localisation of acid phosphatase in tissues of metamorphosing flesh fly larvae. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 10,666. Mitchell, H . K. (1966). Phenol oxidases and Drosophila development. J. Insect Physiol. 12,755-765. Mukhejee, A. S. (1968). Effect of Dicyandiamide on puffing activity and morphology of salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster. Znd. J . Exp. Biol. 6,49-5 1. Nagl, W. (1969a). Banded polytene chromosomes in the legume Phaseolus vulgaris. Nature, Lond. 22 1,70-7 1. Nagl, W. (1969b). Puffing of polytene chromosomes in a plant (Phaseolus vulgaris). Naturwissenschaften 56, 22 1-222. Nur, U. (1968). Endomitosis in the Mealy Bug, Planococcus citri (Hornoptera: Coccoidea). Chromosoma 24,202-209. Ohtaki, T., Milkman, R. D. and Williams, C. M. (1968). Dynamics of ecdysone secretion and action in the flesh fly Sarcophaga peregrina. Biol. Bull. Mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole 135,322-334. Osinchack, J. (1966). Ultrastructural localisation of some phosphatases in the prothoracic gland of the insect Leucophaea maderea. 2. Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 72,236-248. A.I.P.4
86
M. ASHBURNER
Painter, T. S . (1933). A new method for the study of chromosome rearrangements and the plotting of chromosome maps. Science, N. Y. 78, 585-586. Painter, T. S . (1946). Nuclear phenomena associated with secretion in certain gland cells with especial reference to the origin of cytoplasmic ribonucleic acid. J. exp. 2001.100, 523-547. Painter, T. S . and Griffen, A. B. (1937). The structure and the development of the salivary gland chromosomes of Simulium. Genetics 2 2 , 6 12-633. Painter, T. S . and Reindorp, E. C. (1939). Endomitosis in the nurse cells of the ovary of Drosophila melanogaster. Chromosoma 1, 276-283. Panitz, R. ( 1964). Hormonkontrollierte Genaktivitaten in den Riesenchromosomen von Acricotopus lucidus. Biol. Zbl. 83, 197-230. Panitz, R. ( 1967). Funktionelle Verlinderungen an Riesenchromosomen nach Behandlung mit Gibberellinen. Biol. Zbl. 86 (Suppl.), 147-156. Panitz, R. (1968). Uber die Rolle der Chromosomen bei der Informationsubertragung in hoheren Organismen. Biol. Zbl. 87,545-565. Patterson, E. K., Dackerman, M. E. and Schultz, J. (1949a). Peptidase activities of extracts of salivary glands of Drosophila melanogaster. J. gen. Physiol. 32,607-622. Patterson, E. K. Dackerman, M. E. and Schultz, J. (1949b). Peptidase increase accompanying growth of the larval salivary gland of Drosophila melanogaster. J. gen. Physiol. 32, 623-645. Paul, J. S . (1965). Quantitative biophysical and cytochemical studies of polytene chromosomes. Ph.D. Thesis, New York University. University Microfilms, Ann Arbor. Paul, J. S. and Mateyko, G. M. (1967). Quantitative cytochemical studies on polytene chromosomes. J. Cell Biol. 35, 183A. Pavan, C. (1958). Morphological and physiological aspects of chromosomal activities. Proc. X Znt. Congress Genet. 1, 321-336. Pavan, C. (1965a). Nucleic acid metabolism in polytene chromosomes and the problem of differentiation. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 18, 222-24 1. Pavan, C. (1965b). Chromosomal differentiation. Natn. Cancer Znst. Monogr. 18, 309-323. Pavan, C. and Bade, R. (1966a). Chromosome changes induced by infections in tissues of Rhynchosciara angelae. Science, N.Y. 151, 1556-1558. Pavan, C. and Bade, R. (1966b). Invertebrate pathology, cytology, and development. J. Invert. Path. 8 , 131-132. Pavan, C. and Breuer, M. E. (1952). Polytene chromosomes in different tissues of Rhynchosciara angelae. J. Hered. 43, 150-157. Pavan, C. and Breuer, M. E. (1955). Polytene chromosomes of Rhynchosciara milleri sp. n. (Diptera; Mycetophilidae). Revta. bras. Biol. 15,329-339. Pavan, C. and da Cunha, A. B. (1969a). Chromosome activities in normal and infected cells of Sciaridae. Nucleus (In press). Pavan, C. and da Cunha, A. B. (1969b). Chromosomal activities in Rhynchosciara and other Sciaridae. A . Rev. Genetics 3, 425450. Pavan, C. and da Cunha, A. B. ( 1969~ ) .Gene amplification in ontogeny and phylogeny of animals. Proc. Symp. Nuclear Physiology and Differentiation-Belo Horizonte. Genetics 6 l , Suppl. l , 289-304.
PUFFS
87
Pavan, C. and Perondini, A. L. P. (1966). Changes in chromosomes induced by infection in cells of Sciara. Genetics 54, 353. Pavan, C., Perondini, A. L. P. and Amabis, J. M. (1968). Heterozygous puffs, bands, heterochromatin and nucleolus in natural population of Diptera. Proc. XII Int. Congress Genet. 1, 14. Pelc, S. and Howard, A. (1956). Metabolic activity of salivary gland chromosomes in Diptera. Expl. Cell Rex 10, 549-552. Pelling, C. (1959). Chromosomal synthesis of ribonucleic acid as shown by incorporation of uridine labelled with tritium. Nature, Lond. 184, 655-656. Pelling, C. ( 1964). Ribonucleinsaure-synthese der Riesenchromosomen. Autoradiographische Untersuchungen an Chironomus ten tans. Chromosoma 15, 71-122. Pelling, C . (1965). A replicative and synthetic chromosomal unit-the modern concept of the chromomere. Proc. R. Soc. B164, 279-289. Perkowska, E. (1963a). Some characteristics of the salivary gland secretion of Drosophila virilis. Expl. Cell Res. 32, 259-27 1. Perkowska, E. (1963b). The salivary gland secretion in Bradysia. Expl. Cell Res. 30,432-436. Perondini, A. L. P. and Dessen, E. M. (1969). Heterozygous puffs in Sciara ocellaris. Proc. Symp. Nuclear Physiology and Differentiation-Belo Horizonte. Genetics 6 1, Suppl. 1, 25 1-260. Pettit, B. J. and Rasch, R. W. (1966). Tritiated-histidine incorporation into Drosphila salivary chromosomes. J. Cell. Physiol. 68, 325-334. Philip, U. ( 1966). Chromosomal polymorphism in Coelopa frigida (Fabricus) (Diptera). Heredity, 21, 167-168. Phillips, D. M. and Swift, H. (1965). Cytoplasmic fine structure of Sciara salivary glands. I. Secretion. J. Cell Biol. 27, 395-409. Politoff, A., Socolar, S. J. and Loewenstein, W.R. (1969). Permeability of a cell membrane junction: Dependence on energy metabolism. J. gen. Physiol. 53,498-5 15. Poulson, D. and Metz, C. W. (1938). Studies on the structure of nucleolus forming regions and related structures in the giant salivary gland chromosomes of Diptera. J. Morph. 63,363-395. Prabhoo, N. R. (1961). A note on the giant chromosomes in the salivary glands of Womersleya sp. (Collembola: Insecta). Bull. Ent. Madras No. 2, 21-22. Prostakova, T. M. (1968). A study of the action of ribonuclease on RNA synthesis in giant chromosomes of Tendipes plumosus. Tsitologia 10, 157-161. Radzikowski, S. (1967). Nuclear behaviour during conjugation and polytene chromosomes in the exconjugants of Chilodonelia cucullalius (0. F. Muler). Bull. Acad. pol. Sci. C1. II S b . Sci. biol. 15, 749. Rasch, E. M. (1966). Developmental changes in patterns of DNA synthesis by polytene chromosomes in Sciara coprophila. J. Cell Biol. 31,91A. Rasch, E. M. and Gawlik, S. (1964). Cytolysosomes in tissues of metamorphosing Sciarid larvae. J. Cell Biol. 23, 123A. Rasch, E. M. and Lewis, A. L. (1968). Effects of cortisone, gibberellic acid and starvation on puffing patterns in polytene chromosomes of Sciara. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 16,508.
88
M. ASHBURNER
Rasch, E. M. and Pettit, B. J. (1967). Nucleoprotein metabolism in salivary gland chromosomes of Sciara during pupation. J. Cell Biol. 35, 110A. Rayle, R. E. (1967). A new mutant in Drosophila melanogaster causing an ecdysonecurable interruption of the prepupal molt. Genetics, 56, 583. Rayle, R. E. and Green, M. M. (1969). A contribution to the genetic fine structure of the region adjacent to white in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetica 39,497-507. Ribbert, D. ( 1967). Polytihchromosomen der Borstenbildungszellen von Calliphora erythrocephala. Unter besonder Beriicksichtigung der geschlechtsgebundenen Strukturheterozygotie und des Puffmusters wahrend der Metamorphose. Chromosoma 21,296-344. Ribbert, D. and Bier, K . (1969). Multiple nucleoli and enhanced nucleolar activity in the nurse cells of the insect ovary. Chromosoma 27, 178-197. Ristow, H. and Arends, S. (1968). A system in vitro for the synthesis of RNA and protein by isolated salivary glands and by nuclei from Chironomus larvae. Biochim. biophys. Acta 157, 178-186. Ritossa, F. (1962a). Attivita’ sintetiche al livello dei puffs in Drosophila busckii. A t t i Ass. genet. ital. 7, 147-156. Ritossa, F. (1962b). A new puffing pattern induced by temperature shock and DNP in Drosophila. Experientia 18, 571-573. Ritossa, F. (1963a). New puffs induced by temperature shock, DNP and salicilate in salivary chromosomes of D. melanogaster. Drosoph. Inf Serv. 37, 122-123. Ritossa, F. (1963b). Beta-galactosidase distribution in various organs of D . busckii and melanogaster. Drosoph. Inf. Serv. 37, 122. Ritossa, F. (1964a). Experimental activation of specific loci in polytene chromosomes of Drosophila. Expl. Cell Res. 35,601-607. Ritossa, F. (1964b). Behaviour of RNA and DNA synthesis at the puff level in salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila. Expl. Cell Res. 36, 5 15-523. Ritossa, F. and Pulitzer, 5 . F. (1963). Aspects of structure of polytene chromosome puffs of Drosophila busckii derived from experiments with antibiotics. J. Cell Biol. 19, 6QA. Ritossa, F. and Spiegelman, S. (1965). Localisation of DNA complementary to ribosomal RNA in the nucleolus organiser region of Drosophila melanogaster. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 53,737-745. Ritossa, F. and von Borstel, R. C. (1964). Chromosome puffs in Drosophila induced by ribonuclease. Science, N. Y. 145, 5 13-5 14. Ritossa, F., von Borstel, R. C. and Swift, H. (1964). The action of ribonuclease on salivary gland cells of Drosophila. Genetics 50,279. Ritossa, F., Pulitzer, J. F., Swift, H. and von Borstel, R. C. (1965). On the action of ribonuclease in salivary gland cells of Drosophila. Chromosoma 16, 144-15 1. Rizki, T . M. (1967). Ultrastructure of the secretory inclusions of the salivary gland cell in Drosophila. J. Cell Biol. 32,531-534. Robert, M. (1964). Activation de genes chez Chironomus thummi par injection de Trypsine dans le noyau cellulaire. Diploma-Thesis Eidgenossischen Technischen Hochschule. Zurich. 27 pp. Robert, M. and Kroeger, H. (1965). Lokalisation zusatzlicher RNS-Synthese in
PUFFS
89
Trypsin-behandelten Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus thummi. Experien tia 2 1, 3 26. Roberts, B. (1968). DNA granule synthesis in the giant foot pad nuclei of Sarcophaga bullata. J. Cell Biol. 39, 112A. Roberts, P. A., Kimball, R. F. and Pavan, C. (1967). Response of Rhynchosciara chromosomes to microsporidian infection. Increased polyteny and generalized puffing. Expl Cell Res. 47,408-422. Rodems, A. E., Henderson, P. A. and Clever, U. (1969). Proteolytic enzymes in the salivary gland of Chironomus tentans. Experientia 25,686-687. Rodman, T. C. (1964). The larval characteristics and salivary gland chromosomes of a tumorigenic strain of Drosophila melanogaster. J. Morph. 115, 4 19-446. Rodman, T. C. (1967a). Control of polytenic replication in Dipteran larvae. I. Increased number of cycles in a mutant strain of Drosophila melanogaster. J. Cell. Physiol. 70, 179-186. Rodman, T. C. (1967b). DNA replication in salivary gland nuclei of Drosophila melanogaster at successive larval and prepupal stages. Genetics 55, 375-386. Rodman, T. C. and Kopac, M. J. (1964). Alterations in morphology of polytene chromosomes. Nature, Lond. 202,876-877. Rothfels, K. M. and Dunbar, R. W. (1953). The salivary gland chromosomes of the blackfly Simulium vittatum Zett. Can. J. 2001.31,226-241. Rudkin, G. T. (1955). The ultraviolet absorption of puffed and unpuffed homologous regions in the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosphila melanogaster. Genetics 40,593. Rudkin, G. T. (1962). Nucleic acid metabolism in giant chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster. Annls Histochim. Suppl. 2 (1962), 77-84. Rudkin, G. T. (1964). The proteins of polytene chromosomes. In “Nucleohistones” (J. Bonner and P. Ts’o, eds). Holden-Day, San Francisco. Rudkin, G. T. (1965). The relative mutabilities of DNA in regions of the X chromosome of Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 52,665-68 1. Rudkin, G. T. and Corlette, S. L. (1957). Disproportionate synthesis of DNA in a polytene chromosome region. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 43,964-968. Rudkin, G . T. and Woods, P. S. (1959). Incorporation of H3cytidine and H3-thymidine into giant chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster during puff formation. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 45, 997-1003. Sang, J. H. (1968). Lack of cortisone inhibition of chromosomal puffing in Drosophila melanogaster. Experientia 24, 1064. Scharrer, B. and Hadorn, E. (1938). The structure of the ring gland (corpus allatum) in normal and lethal larvae of Drosphila melunogaster. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 24,236-242. Schin, K. S. and Clever, U. (1965). Lysosomal and free acid phosphatase in salivary glands of Chironomus tentans. Science, N. Y. 150, 1053-1055. Schin, K. S. and Clever, U. (1968a). Ultrastructural and cytochemical studies of salivary gland regression in Chironomus tentans. Z . Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 86,262-279. Schin, K. S. and Clever, U. (1968b). Ferritin-uptake by salivary glands of Chironomus tentans and its intracellular localisation. Expl. Cell Res. 49, 208-2 1 1.
90
M. ASHBURNER
Schultz, J. ( 1965). Genes, differentiation, and animal development. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. No. 18, 116-147. Schultz, J. and Rudkin, G. T. (1960). Direct measurement of deoxyribonucleic acid content of genetic loci in Drosophila. Science, N . Y . 132, 1499-1500. Schurin, M. F. ( 1959). Localised cytochemical and submicroscopic differentiation in Drosophila virilis salivary gland chromosomes. Genetics 44, 534. Sebeleva, T. E. (1968). Quantitative determination of DNA content during formation of one of the puffs and one of the Balbiani rings in Chironomus dorsalis. Tsitologia 10, 765-769 (Russian with English summary). Sebeleva, T. E., Sherudilo, A. I. and Kiknadze, I. I. (1965). Quantitative estimation of DNA in puff formation in Chironomus dorsalis. Genetika (U.S.S.R.)(1965) 2, 101-105. Sengiin, A. (1954). Variability of the banding patterns of giant chromosomes. J. Hered. 45, 119-122. Serfling, E., Panitz, R. and Wobus, U. (1969). Die experimentelle Beinflussung des Puffmusters von Riesenchromosomen. I. Puffinduktion durch Oxytetracyclin bei Chironomus thummi. Chromosoma 28, 107-1 19. Shaaya, E. and Karlson, P. (1965). Die Ecdysontiter wihrend InsektenEntwicklung. 11. Die Postembryonale Entwicklung der Schmeissfliege Calliphora erythrocephala Meig. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 6569. Sirlin, J. L. (1960). Cell sites of RNA and protein syntheses in the salivary gland of Smittia (Chironomidae). Expl. Cell Res. 19, 177-180. Sirlin, J. L. and Schor, N. A. (1962). Macromolecular syntheses in isolated polytene nuclei. Expl. Cell Res. 27, 165-167. Slizynski, B. M. (1950). Chironomus versus Drosophila. J. Genet. 50,77-78. Smith, P. D., Koenig, P. B. and Lucchesi, J. C. (1968). Inhibition of development in Drosophila by cortisone. Nature, Lond. 217, 1286. Smith, W. J. (1969). Effects of ribonuclease on nuclear ultrastructure in larval Drosophila salivary glands. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 27, 168-18 1. Snodgrass, R. E. (1924). Anatomy and metamorphosis of the apple maggot, Rhagoletis pomonella Walsh. J. agric. Res. 29, 1-36. Sorsa, M. (1969). Ultrastructure of puffs in the proximal part of chromosome 3R in Drosophila melanogaster. Ann. Acad. Sci. Fennicae, A IV Biol. 150, 1-21. Sorsa, M. and Sorsa, V. (1967). Electron microscopic observations on interband fibrils in Drosophila salivary chromosomes. Chromosoma 22, 32-4 1. Spirin, A. S. (1966). On “masked” forms of messenger RNA in early embryogenesis and in other differentiating systems. In “Current Problems in Developmental Biology’’, Vol. 1, 2-38. Stalker, H. D. (1954). Banded polytene chromosomes in the ovarian nurse cells of adult Diptera. J. Hered. 45,259-264. Staub, M. (1969). Veranderungen im Puffmuster und das Wachstum der Riesenchromosomen in Speicheldriisen von Drosophila melanogaster aus spatlarvalen und embryonalen Spendern nach Kultur in vivo. Chromosoma 26,76-104. Stedman, E. and Stedman, E. (1951). The basic proteins of cell nuclei. Phil. Trans. R. SOC.Lond. B235,565-595. Steffenson, D. M. (1963). Evidence for the apparent absence of DNA in the interbands of Drosophila salivary chromosomes. Genetics 48, 1289-1301.
PUFFS
91
Stevens, B. J. (1964). The effect of actinomycin D on nucleolar and nuclear fine structure in the salivary gland cell of Chironomus thummi. J. Ultrastruct. Res. 11, 329-353. Stevens, B. J. and Swift, H. (1966). RNA transport from the nucleus to cytoplasm in Chironomus salivary glands. J. Cell Biol. 31,55-77. Stevens, B. J.. Swift, H. and Adams, B. A. (1965). Fine structure and cytochemistry of Balbiani ring granules in Chironomus J. Cell Biol. 27, 1OOA . Stich, H. F. and Naylor, J. M. (1958). Variation of deoxyribonucleic acid content of specific chromosome regions. Expl. Cell Res. 14,442-445. Sutton, E. (1942). Salivary gland type chromosomes in mosquitoes. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 28, 268-272. Sutton, E. (1943). A cytogenetic study of the yellow-scute region of the X chromosome in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 2 8 , 2 10-2 17. Swift, H. (1959). Studies on nuclear fine structure. Brookhaven Symp. Biol. 12, 134-152. Swift, H. (1962). Nucleic acids and cell morphology in Dipteran salivary glands. In “Molecular Control of Gene Activity” (J. Allen, ed.). McGraw Hill, New York. Swift, H. (1963). Cytochemical studies on nuclear fine structure. Expl. Cell Res. Suppl. 9 , 5 4 6 7 . Swift, H. (1964). The histones of polytene chromosomes. In “Nucleohistones” (J. Bonner and P. Ts’o, eds). Holden Day, San Francisco. Swift, H. (1965). Molecular morphology of the chromosomes. “In Vitro”, Vol. 1. “The Chromosomes: Structural and Functional Aspects”. Tissue Culture Association. Tanzer, E. (1922). Die Zellkeme einiger Dipterenlarven und ihre Entwicklung. Z. wiss. Zool. 119, 114-153. Taylor, J. H. ( 1953). Intracellular localisation of labeled nucleic acid determined by autoradiographs. Science, N . Y . 118, 555-557. Terner, J. Y., Goodman, R. M. and Spiro, D. (1965). Glucose-6-phosphatase in the salivary gland of Sciara coprophila: A histochemical and biochemical study. J. Histochem. Cytochem. 13, 168-181. Terner, J. Y., Goodman, R. M. and Spiro, D. (1967). The effect of cortisone on ribonucleic acid polymerase and ribonuclease during development : Coincidental evidence for the identity of ribonucleic acid polymerase with the “operator” gene. Expl. Cell Res. 45, 550-558. Thomson, J. A. (1969). The interpretation of puff patterns in polytene chromosomes. Currents in Modern Biology 3 (In press). Trager, W. (1937). Cell size in relation to the growth and metamorphosis of the mosquito, Aedes aegypti. J. exp. Zool. 76,467489. Waldner-Stiefelmeier, R. D. (1967). Untersuchungen uber die Proteasen im Wildtyp und in den Letalmutanten (lme und Itr) von Drosophila melanogaster. Z. vergleich. Physiol. 56, 268-289. Walsche, B. M. (1947). Feeding mechanisms of Chironomus larvae. Nature, Lond. 160,474. Ward, C . L. (1949). Karyotype variation in Drosophila. Univ. Tex. Publs. 4920, 70-79. Welsch, U., Wachtler, K. and Riihm, W. (1968). Die Feinstruktur der
92
M. ASHBURNER
Speicheldriise von Boophthora erythrocephala (Simuliidae, Diptera) vor und nach der Blutaufnahme. 2.Zellforsch. Mikrosk. Anat. 88,340-352. Wetzel, R., Buder, E., Schiilike, W. and Zirwer, D. (1969). Linearer Dichroismus bei Riesenchromosomen von Chironomus. Chromosoma 26,201-207. Wharton, L. T. (1943). Analysis of the metaphase and salivary gland chromosome morphology with the genus Drosophila. Univ. Tex. Publs. 4313, 282-319. White, M. J. D. (1946). The cytology of the Cecidomyidae (Diptera). I. Polyploidy and polyteny in salivary gland cells of Lestodiplosis spp. J. Morph. 78, 201-220. White, M. J. D. (1948). The cytology of the Cecidomyidae (Diptera). IV. The salivary gland chromosomes of several species. J. Morph. 87, 53-80. Whitten, J. M. (1963). Giant polytene chromosome development in the cells of the hypodermis and heart of fly pupae. Proc. XVZ Znt. Congr. Zool. 2, 276. Whitten, J. M. (1964a). Giant polytene chromosomes in hypodermal cells of developing foot pads of Dipteran pupae. Science, N. Y. 143, 1437-1438. Whitten, J. M. (1964b). Haemocytes and the metamorphosing tissues in Sarcophaga bullata, Drosophila melanogaster, and other cyclorrhaphous Diptera. J. Insect Physiol. 10,447-469. Whitten, J. M. (1965). Differential deoxyribonucleic acid replication in the giant foot-pad cells of Sarcophaga bullata. Nature, Lond. 208, 1019-102 1. Whitten, J. M. (1968). Metamorphic changes in insects. Zn “Metamorphosis. A Problem in Developmental Biology” (W. Etkin and L. I. Gilbert, eds). North Holland, Amsterdam. Whitten, J. M. (1969a). Haemocyte activity in relation to epidermal cell growth, cuticle secretion, and cell death in a metamorphosing cyclorrhaphan pupa. J. Insect Physiol. 15, 763-778. Whitten, J. M. (1969b). Cell death during early morphogenesis: Parallels between insect limb and vertebrate limb development. Science, N.Y. 163, 1456-1457. Whitten, J. M. (1969~).Coordinated development in the fly foot: Sequential cuticle secretion. J. Morph. 127,73-104. Whitten, J. M. (1969d). Coordinated development in the foot pad of the fly Sarcophaga bullata during metamorphosis: Changing puffing patterns of the giant cell chromosomes. Chromosoma 26,215-244. Wiener, J., Spiro, D. and Loewenstein, W. R. (1964). Studies on an epithelial (gland) cell junction. 11. Surface structure. J. Cell Biol. 22,587-598. Williams, C. M. and Robbins, W. E. (1968). Conference on insect-plant interactions. BioScience 18,791-792,797-799. Willmer, E. N. (1961). Steroids and cell surfaces. Biol. Rev. 36,368-398. Wobus, U. ( 1969). Chromosomale Differenzierung und Proteinmuster bei Chironomiden. Verh. dt. Ges. explt. Med. (In press). Wolstenholme, D. R. (1965). The distribution of DNA and RNA in salivary gland chromosomes of Chironomus ten tans as revealed by fluorescence microscopy. Chromosoma 1 7 , 2 19-229. Wolstenholme, D. R. (1966). Direct evidence for the presence of DNA in interbands of Drosophila salivary gland chromosomes. Genetics 53, 357-360. Wolstenholme, D. R., Dawid, I. B. and Ristow, H. J. (1968). An electron
PUFFS
93
microscope study of DNA molecules from Chironomus tentans and C. thummi. Genetics 60,759-770. Yoshimatsu, H. (1962). Electron microscopy of salivary gland cells of Chironomus larvae. Ann. Zool. Japan 35,89-94. Yoshimatsu, H. and Uehawa, M. (1968). Some fibrin-like properties of the secretion of the salivary gland of Chironomus larvae. Ann. Zool. Japan 4 1, 107-112. NOTES ADDED IN PROOF The following notes detail some of the papers received since the completion of the review. P. 9 Basile (1969) describes the development of the polytene chromosomes of the endopolyploid nurse cells of Rhynchosciara angelae. P. 16 Four recent publications from Edstrom’s group extend our knowledge of the RNA metabolism of Chironomus tentans salivary glands. Egyhlzi et al. (1969) report further on the 4s RNA of chromosomes, nuclear sap and cytoplasm, and find it to be methylated, probably derived from a larger precursor and to be distinct from the 4s RNA of the nucleolus. Daneholt et al. (1969a) provide the controls to show that the heterodisperse (H) chromosomal RNA( 10s-90s) is composed of unbroken molecules and that neither aggregation nor complex formation contribute significantly to its heterogeneity. The kinetics of chromosomal RNA synthesis and metabolism are considered in Daneholt et al. (1969b). The H RNA of chromosomes I, I1 and I11 has a rapid turnover (less than 45 m) and leaves the chromosomes for the nuclear sap intact. Some of this H RNA reaches the cytoplasm but the majority is degraded within the nucleus. The RNA of the BR2 of chromosome IV is heterogeneous with respect to size but the amount of very heavy material is larger than that found from chromosomes I, I1 and 111. Within salivary glands the rate of H RNA synthesis on the chromosome IV BR correlates with the actual size of the BR (Daneholt et al., 1 9 6 9 ~ ) . P . 3 8 The induction of DNA puffs in Sciara by 20GH ecdysone has been reported by GabrusewyczGarcia and Margles (1 969). P. 38 Further metabolic conversions of ecdysones are reported by Thomson et al. ( 1969) and by Kaplanis et al. ( 1969). P . 4 1 Weirich and Karlson (1969) have also failed to find any marked heterogeneity in the distribution of H3-ecdysone in salivary glands of Chironomus or Rhynchosciara. However from Emmerich’s recent paper (1969) there is evidence that in larval salivary glands of D. hydei more ecdysone is bound by the nucleus than by the cytoplasm. No marked chromosomal binding was detected in either study. P. 47 Laufer and Greenwood (1969) confirm that Cecropia juvenile hormone, like the farnesoic acid derivative, alters puffing when fed to late prepupae of Chironomus thummi at a concentration of 3000 T.U./ml. After 6 hr treatment the activity of at least 7 puffs is altered and BR IVB not only fails to regress, as would normally occur at this stage of development, but actually increases in size. P. 52 The salivary gland chromosomes of Sciara ocellaris respond to microA.1.P.-4*
94
M. ASHBURNER
sporidian infection in a manner similar to that described above. In the fat body infection may result in coincident polyploidy and polyteny and the development of highly condensed “brachy polytene” chromosomes. Infected salivary gland cells survive metamorphosis whilst uninfected cells of the same gland proceed to their usual fate and histolyse (Pavan et al., 1969). P. 57 In the giant food pad nuclei of Sarcophaga bullata studied by Bultmann and Clever (1969) the peak puffing activity occurs on days 6-7 of pupal development. The autonomy of the timing of puffing patterns of the foot pad nuclei and the implication of this finding for theories of the hormonal control of puffing is further discussed in this paper. p. 61 The salivary gland of Bradysia sp. is differentiated into four regions each unique with respect to chromosome morphology, patterns of nucleic acid synthesis, and cytoplasmic secretory inclusions (da Cunha et al., 1969). P. 64 The role of the BR in the control of secretory protein synthesis in the salivary gland of Chironomus tentans and C. palliduvitatus is considered fully by Grossbach (1969). P. 67 Grossbach (1969) claims that the conditions used by Laufer will not dissolve the major secretory proteins of C. tentans. P. 67 Martin e t al. (1969) studying patterns of protein synthesis in larval salivary glands and other tissues of Calliphora stygia were unable t o find any evidence for the large scale transport of proteins into the salivary gland. P. 68 Bultmann [Ph.D. Thesis quoted by Bultmann and Clever (1969)l finds that degenerating foot pad nuclei have a specific puffing pattern and continue to incorporate H3uridine. P. 70 Successful RNA-DNA hydridization in cytological preparations is reported by Gall (19691, Gall and Pardue (1969) and by John et al. (1969). The latter paper reports preliminary work by Jones and Robertson on the hybridization of RNA to Drosophila salivary gland chromosomes. Basile, R. (1969). Nucleic acid synthesis in nurse cells of Rhynchosciara angelae Nonato and Pavan, 195 1. Proc. Symp. Nuclear Physiology and Differentiation. Belo Horizonte. Genetics 61, Suppl. l , 261-273. Bultmann, H. and Clever, U. (1969). Chromosomal control of foot pad development in Sarcophaga bullata. I. The puffing patterns. Chromosoma 28, 120-135. da Cunha, A. B., Morgante, J. S., Pavan, C. and Garrido, M. C. (1969). Studies on cytology and differentiation in Sciaridae. 111. Nuclear and cytoplasmic differentiation in the salivary glands of Bradysia sp. Univ. Tex. Publs. 6918, 1-1 1. Daneholt, B., Edstrom, J-E., Egyhizi, E., Lambert, B. and Ringborg, U.(1969a). Physico-chemical properties of chromosomal RNA in Chironomus tentuns polytene chromosomes. Chromosoma 28, 379-398. Daneholt, B., Edstrom, J-E., Egyhlzi, E., Lambert, B. and Ringborg, U. (1969b). Chromosomal RNA synthesis in polytene chromosomes of Chironomus tentans. Chromosoma 28,399417. Daneholt, B., Edstrom, J-E., Egyhizi, E., Lambert, B. and Ringborg U. ( 1 9 6 9 ~ ) . RNA synthesis in a Balbiani Ring in Chironomus tentans salivary gland cells. Chromosoma 28,418429.
PUFFS
95
Egyhazi, E., Daneholt, B., Edstrom, J-E., Lambert, B. and Ringborg, U. (1969). Low molecular weight RNA in cell components of Chironornus tentans salivary glands. J. Molec. Biol. 44, 517-532. Emmerich, H. (1 969). Anreicherung von tritiummarkiertem Ecdyson in den Zellkernen der Speicheldriisen von Drosophila hydei. Expl. Cell Res. 58, 261-270. GabrusewyczGarcia, N. and Margles, S. (1969). Induction of DNA puffs by ecdysterone. J. Cell Biol. 43,41A. Gall, J. G. ( 1969). The genes for ribosomal RNA during oogenesis. Proc. Symp. Nuclear Physiology and Differentiation. Belo Horizonte. Genetics 6 1, Suppl. 1, 121-132. Gall, J. G. and Pardue, M. L. (1969). Formation and detection of RNA-DNA hybrid molecules in cytological preparations. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 63, 378-383. Grossbach, U. ( 1969). Chromosome-Aktivitat und biochemische Zelldifferentzierung in der Speicheldriisen von Carnptochironornus. Chrornosorna 28, 136-187. John, H. A., Birnsteil, M. L. and Jones, K. W. (1969). RNA-DNA hybrids at the cytological level. Nature, Lond. 223, 582-587. Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E., Thompson, M. J. and Baumhover, A. H. (1969). Ecdysone analog: conversion to alpha ecdysone and 20-hydroxyecdysone by an insect. Science, N.Y. 166, 1540-1541. Laufer, H. and Greenwood, H. (1969). The effects of juvenile hormone on larvae of the Dipteran Chironomus thurnrni. A m . Zool. 9, 603. Martin, M. D., Kinnear, J. F. and Thomson, J. A. (1969). Developmental changes in the late larvae of Calliphora stygia. 11. Protein synthesis. Aust. J. biol. Sci. 22, 935-945. Pavan, C., Perondini, A. L. P. and Picard, T. (1969). Changes in chromosomes and in the development of cells of Sciara ocellaris induced by microsporidian infection. Chrornosoma 28,328-345. Thomson, J. A., Siddall, J. B., Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S. and Middleton, E. J. (1969). The biosynthesis of ecdysones in the blowfly Calliphora stygia. Chem. Cornrn. 1969, 669-670. Weirich, G. and Karlson, P. (1969). Distribution of tritiated ecdysone in salivary glands and other tissues of Rhvnchosciara and Chironornus larvae. An autoradiographic study. Wilhelm Roux’ Arch. EntwMech. Org. 164, 170-18 1.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Structure and Function of the Insect Dorsal Ocellus LESLEY J. GOODMAN Department of Zoology, Queen Mary College University of London, England Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 Distribution and Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 A. Distribution and Development of Dorsal Ocelli within the . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 Class Insecta B. Structure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 C. The Visual Field of the Ocelli . . . . . . . . . . . 131 D. Form Perception . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131 111. Behavioural Studies on the Role of the Ocelli . . . . . . . . 132 A. Early Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 B. The Ocelli as Stimulatory Organs . . . . . . . . . 133 C. The Ocellar Contribution to Phototactic Orientation . . . 141 . . . . . . . 147 D. Detection of the Plane of Polarized Light E. Registration of Intensity Level and of Changes of Intensity . 148 IV. Electrical Activity in the Ocellus . . . . . . . . . . . 152 A. The Electrical Response of the Visual Cells . . . . . . 152 B. Electrical Activity in the Second Order Neurons . . . . 161 C. Sensitivity, Light and Dark Adaptation and Flicker Fusion Frequency . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164 D. The Spectral Sensitivity of Ocelli . . . . . . . . . . 170 V. Ocellar Units in the Brain and Ventral Nerve Cord . . . . . . 171 A. Ocellar Units in the Brain . . . . . . . . . . . . 171 B. Ocellar Units in the Ventral Nerve Cord . . . . . . . 173 C. The Effect of Ocellar Input on Compound Eye Units . . . 182 D. The Influence of the Ocelli on Motor Activity in the Thoracic Ganglia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 184 VI. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 188 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 190
I. 11.
I. INTRODUCTION
In addition to their large compound eyes adult insects typically possess simple cup-shaped eyes on the dorsal region of the head composed of a few hundred visual cells beneath a common lens. Known as the dorsal ocelli, they are of distinct ontogenetical origin 97
98
LESLEY J . GOODMAN
from the compound eyes and are innervated directly from the ocellar lobes located in the protocerebrum between the mushroom bodies. Generally three are present, a median receptor on the frons and two lateral receptors on the suture between the frons and the vertex, although one, two, four and more are characteristic of some species. In the Plecoptera all the ocelli are borne on the frons, in the Blattoidea they have become somewhat degenerate and are known as fenestrae, whilst in the higher insects they frequently form a compact triangle or row on top of the vertex. This article is concerned solely with the functions of the dorsal ocelli and excludes any consideration of other simple eyes such as the lateral ocelli or stemmata which may sometimes be retained in adult insects or certain atypical eyes, such as those of Pediculus, which have an ocelliform structure but whose relationship to the compound eyes or to the dorsal ocelli is in doubt. The role of the dorsal ocelli in insect behaviour has never been satisfactorily established. N o clue is afforded by examining their distribution within the Class and no very obvious differences of behaviour be tween ocellate and anocellate species have been reported. Once the optical system of a number of dorsal ocelli had been examined it became apparent that they were not important in form vision since the image formed by the lens system did not fall within the retinal layer. Behavioural studies confirmed this and showed their inability to mediate photic orientation reactions although it was increasingly noted that the accuracy of such reactions mediated by the compound eyes was reduced if the ocelli were occluded. Many authors found that the ocelli had a positive photokinetic effect on locomotory activity and they were thus classed as “stimulatory organs” under which title they are still briefly dismissed in many texts. Several electrophysiological studies have yielded interesting information on the way in which certain ocelli respond to light and on the type of information which they signal. Recently it has become apparent that the ocelli probably have distinct functions in different groups of insects. Behavioural and electrophysiological studies have given some insight into the way in which compound eyes and ocelli can interact to influence motor activity. However we are still far from understanding the full role of the dorsal ocelli as photoreceptors. It is hoped that by focusing attention on the many gaps in our knowledge of the physiological properties of rhe ocellus and by indicating current areas of interest the deficiencibs may be made good and the possibility of an ocellar
99
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
contribution may automatically be considered when any visual dependent behaviour in insects is being examined. 11. DISTRIBUTION AND STRUCTURE A. DISTRIBUTION AND DEVELOPMENT O F DORSAL OCELLI WITHIN THE CLASS INSECTA
Distribution of the dorsal ocelli within the Class is erratic. Some insect orders lack ocelli completely, others, such as beetles, have few ocellate species and within an order members of the same species, genus or family may be ocellate or anocellate. Ocelli are common amongst good fliers and, indeed, a connection between wings and ocelli has been made in insects (Priesner, 1928; Kalmus, 1948). If the orders of insects are grouped according to the presence or absence of ocelli and wings and the resulting table (Table I) treated as a Table I The distribution of wings and ocelli in the insect orders (from Kalmus, 1945) Wings Present Ocelli present
Ephemerop tera 0don at a 2
Ocelli present or absent
Neuroptera Trichop tera
Present or absent
Orthoptera Dermaptera Plecop tera Isoptera Psocoptera Thysanoptera
2 Ocelli absent
-
Hemiptera Mecoptera Lepidoptera Coleoptera Hymenoptera Diptera
Absent
Thysanura Collembola
12
2
2
Protura Anoplura Aphanip tera 3
Em bioptera Strepsip tera
contingency table, a strong association between wings and ocelli is indicated. N o insect order is completely ocellate and wingless or anocellate and winged, neither is there an order in which all species are ocellate but some wingless. The correlation can be seen very
100
LESLEY J GOODMAN
clearly in families with sexually dimorphic forms (Table 11). However, not only the ocelli but the complete visual system can be linked with wings since size and facet number in the compound eye is frequently associated with wing development. Kalmus has pointed out that n o single gene difference can be responsible for the presence or absence of wings and ocelli or for the good or poor differentiation Table I1 The distribution of wings and ocelli among 135 species of the Thysanoptera (from Kalmus, 1945). The terms macropterous, brachypterous and micropterous refer to the relative development of the wings '
Monomorphic forms
Dimorphic forms
Ocelli
Wings Monomorphic: Macropterous Micropterous Apterous Sexually dimorphic: Macropt. ? apt. d Macropt. ? micropt. d Macropt. and brachypt. ? apt. d Brachypt. ? micropt. d Dimorphic : Macropt. and brachypt. 0 Macropt. and brachypt. 0 and d Macropt. and micropt. ? Macropt. and apt. 0 Trimorphic: Macropt., brachypt. and micropt. 9
83 1
1 1
1 7
4 1 4
1 1
1
1
1 1 2
1
1
1
1
of wings and compound eyes; indeed he finds no chromosome mechanism which could affect the many co-variant intraspecific differences in wingedness and degree of eye development which d o occur. Since the full development of the ocelli and the wings and the
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
101
complexity of the lateral eye are all imaginal characters, Kalmus has suggested that neotony might provide an explanation of the wing eye relationship; an insect which showed some degree of neotony having less well developed compound eyes and wings and lacking, or having poorly developed, ocelli. Development of the ocelli does vary between groups which are good fliers, suggesting that they may have different roles in different insects. The Hymenoptera are the only order which have been examined in any detail from this point of view. Gotze (1927-28) found that the ocelli were normally larger and the lenses more convex in males. In night flying Hymenoptera where the compound eyes are rudimentary, the ocelli have also become much reduced and sunk into the cuticle. However, reduction of the compound eyes is not always accompanied by reduction of the ocelli, in Dorylus, for example, where the compound eyes are completely rudimentary, the ocelli are fairly well developed. In some Hymenoptera groups, Ichneumonids and Braconids for example, the ocelli appear particularly well developed in forms which fly at twilight having large, highly convex lenses (Fig. 1). This is not true of the Lepidoptera where ocelli are not often present in twilight and night flying moths and are notably absent in the swiftly flying Sphingids. Ocelli appear to be equally well developed in day flying and in dusk flying dragonflies, but no detailed studies have been made. In the Diptera they are commonly well developed in good daylight fliers but are oddly absent from the strongly flying Tabanids. An investigation of the relationship between the development of the ocelli and the flight habits of the insects might indicate a starting point in the search for the role of the ocelli within a particular group. B. STRUCTURE
1. Dioptric Apparatus The dioptric apparatus is commonly a transparent layer of cuticle above the layer of retinal cells which becomes thickened to varying degrees in different ocelli by the underlying layer of corneageneal cells. In some Collembola the cuticle remains thin and differs from the surrounding cuticle only in that it lacks pigment and so provides a transparent window for the entry of light to the few retinal cells lying underneath. In all Pterygote ocelli the cuticular window is thickened to some extent by additional chitin laid down by the corneageneal cells (Fig. 3). In the Blattoidea, whose ocelli are regarded as degenerate, the cuticular window is simply thickened
102
LESLEY J . GOODMAN
K
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
103
(Fig. 1 ) but more commonly it forms a domed shape or a planoconvex or biconvex lens as in Schistocerca gregaria, Lucilia sericata, Zygaena sp. and the majority of Lepidoptera with ocelli (Figs 1 and 2). After secreting the lens the corneagenous cells frequently become reduced to a thin transparent layer which alone separates the cuticular lens from the retinal cells beneath (Fig. 1). In other ocelli the corneagenous cells provide an auxiliary refractory organ which can take a variety of forms. In Vespa crabo there is a crystalline body beneath the lens. In Schistocerca and Lucilia the cup-shaped region between lens and retinal cells is filled with large, elongated vitreous cells (Figs 2 and 4) or more rarely with a vitreous fluid. Occasionally a cuticular lens is absent and a crystalline body, formed by the corneagenous cells, lies beneath a thin, transparent cuticle as in Cloeon (Fig. 1).
2. The Screening Pigment Dark screening pigment is entirely absent in some ocelli as in Periplaneta americana (Ruck, 1958a) and variously distributed in others. In S. gregaria the pigment granules are confined to the peripheral cells of the corneagenous layer just above the distal ends of the retinal cells. This thin ring of pigment cells, some six to seven cells thick and ten to twelve cells deep, is called the “iris” since it is presumed to limit the angle of light acceptance of the ocellus. Within the pigment cells of S. gregaria formation of vesicles from the endoplasmic reticulum can be observed (Fig. 5). The vesicles increase in size as material is deposited in them until they reach the order of 0.6 p, when they appear densely packed with what is believed to be Fig. 1. A-E. A, a-f shows differences in the development of the ocelli in certain Hymenoptera. (From Gotze, 1927.) (a) Astutu sp. the lateral ocelli, though well developed, are triangular in shape and have no frontal view. (b) In Apis sp. all three ocelli are particularly well developed in drones. (c) In Tuchysphex pectinepes the median ocellus is reduced and the lateral ocelli are spindle shaped and flattened. This has been carried even further in (d) Tuchytes europaeu where the lateral ocelli form a flat crescent shaped slit. (e) Moneduh sp. have large, circular ocelli with a covering of fine hairs. In Steniolu sp. (f) lateral ocelli are much reduced and the elongated median ocellus forms a slit parallel to the long axis of the head. B, C and D show differences in the dioptric apparatus of ocelli. In B there is simply a flattened transparent cornea above the layer of retinal cells in Periphnetu umericunu. (After Ruck, 1957.) C. Aphrophoru spumariu possesses a well developed corneal lens (1) with a thin layer of corneageal cells beneath (c.n.) seperating it from the retinal layer (rh). D. CZoeon lacks a cuticular lens having a thin transparent layer of cuticle (c) overlying a crystalline body (1) secreted by the underlying corneagel cells (v). E illustrates the partial decussation which takes place as the ocellar nerves enter the brain, in this case in the Hymenoptera. (After Miiller, 1931) L 0, Lateral ocelli. M 0, Median ocellus. TI, Trachea. Oe. Oesophagus. P, Corpora pedunculata.
Fig. 2. L.S. through the median ocellus of a newly fledged locust, Schisrocercagregaria. x 240. ch. transparent chitin being laid down by corneageal cells (see Fig. 3) will gradually thicken to form the corneageal lens. cor, corneageal cells v. elongated vitreous cells with prominent nuclei. p.c, pigment cells. ret, visual layer showing retinular cells at different depths. tap, tapetal layer. ret. ax, axons of retinula cells descending through the tapetal layer. memb. comp, membrane complex. fib. cap, fibrous capsule. oc, ocellar nerve. as, air sacs. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970).
Fig. 3. Formation of the cuticular lens in the median ocellus of Schistocercugregaritz. c, cuticle. cor, corneageal cells. mv, microvilli of corneageal cells lying beneath newly secreted granular endocuticle. g, golgi apparatus. gr., granular material. m. tub., microtubules. x 30,000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
Fig. 4. Cells from the vitreous body lying between the lens and the retinal layer in the median ocellus of Schistocercu greguria. v, very large fluid filled vitreous cells. cell memb., convoluted cell membrane. nuc, large nucleus. Nuclei of these cells are concentrated in one zone (see Fig. 2). x 12,000 (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
Fig. 5. Ocellar pigment cells in S. gregariu. P.c., pigment cell. v., neighbouring vitreous cells. p.p.g, primary pigment granule. d.p.g, developing pigment granule. m.p.g, mature pigment granule. er., endoplasmic reticulum. nuc., nucleus. x 9000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
I08
LESLEY J. GOODMAN
melanin (Goodman and Kirkham, 1970). In some ocelli the retinal cells themselves contain dark pigment granules usually proximal to the rhabdomere region, as in Helophilus and Syconastes marginatus (Hesse, 1901) and Zygaena (Link, 1909). Others have such granules present in the sheath cells through which the retinal axons run as in Sympetrum (Ruck and Edwards, 1964). In Cloeon, Ceratopsyllus canis and Agrion a densely pigmented epithelium invests the whole eye and a rapid movement of the pigment in this sheath has been reported in response to changing light intensity (Lammert, 1925). Pigment migration has not been reported in other ocelli, certainly no migration of granules or movement of cells has been observed in the pigment ring of Schistocerca in response to changes of light intensity. The principal function of the pigment granules of the ocelli thus seems to be to prevent light from entering the photoreceptor except through the frontal lens aperture.
3. The Retinular Cells There are commonly between 500 and 1000 retinular cells lying in a shallow layer or arranged around a cup-shaped depression beneath the dioptric apparatus. The cells may occur at different depths within the retinal cell layer (Blaberus craniifer, Fig. 1, Schistocerca, Fig. 2 ) but in no case do they appear to be organized into separate distal and proximal layers as was once suggested for the dragonfly, Agrion, by Hesse (1901). The unipolar sense cells are grouped together in twos, threes, fours and fives, the number can vary within a given ocellus. The proximal ends of these primary sense cells narrow into short axons which synapse with the dendrites of second order neurons whose cell bodies are situated in the pars intercerebralis of the brain. Some portion of the inner limiting membrane of each cell is modified to form a rhabdomere. In insect eyes there is a certain amount of variety in the relationship of the rhabdomere to the photoreceptor of which it is a part. In ocelli the rhabdomere is commonly a narrow V-shaped strip on the inner surface of the cell embedded within the cytoplasm (Schistocerca, Fig. 6). Usually this strip extends to the distal limit of the cell and in Fig. 6. T.S.through the visual cell layer of the light adapted median ocellus of S.gregurk showing retinular cells. rh., rhabdomere. mit., mitochondria. ax., group of four retinular cell axons descending from a higher level surrounded by a glial sheath, gls. ur. sp., urate spheres within the glial membranes. I . er., rough endoplasmic reticulum, probably site of retinular cell axon formation. g, golgi apparatus, generally found between the nucleus and the cell membrane in a position removed from the rhabdom. n., nucleus. x 8000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
110
LESLEY J GOODMAN
a number of cases the rhabdomere completely surrounds the distal end of the cell, Eristalis, Syrphus (Redikorzew, 1900) and Drosophila (Hertweck, 193 1 ). In cross-sections through the distal region of these ocelli the rhabdomeres have the appearance of a continuous hexagonal mesh. Similar effects are seen in some insect compound eyes and in spider eyes (Ruck, 1964; Curtis, 1969). The syrphid Helophilus, has retinal cells with the rhabdomeres confined solely to the distal margin of the cell in one region of the ocellus whilst in other regions the rhabdomeres form “sleeves” around the distal end of the cell open at both ends. The significance of these differences in rhabdomeric disposition is not known, possibly where the rhabdomere surrounds the distal end of the cell this may serve to increase the sensitivity of the photoreceptor. In those ocelli so far examined the retinular cells form compact groups with the rhabdomeres fused and forming a central rayed rhabdom (Fig. 6). The rhabdomeres resemble those of other arthropod eyes being composed of closely packed parallel microvilli, finger-like evaginations of the cell membrane. In Schistocerca the microvilli are between 0.4 and 0.5 p long with an overall diameter of 900 A” and an internal diameter of 300 A ” , (Fig. 8). No basal retinular cells lacking or having a very small rhabdomere have been found in E.M. studies. A central process is seen occasionally in the centre of the retinulae of Schistocerca which is believed to be a downward extension of the vitreous cells between the distal ends of the retinular cells (Fig. 7). The cell nuclei are large ovoid structures situated distally in Schistocerca and proximally in Libellula. The cells are comparatively rich in cytoplasmic organelles including numerous mitochondria, endoplasmic reticulum, multi-vesicular bodies, Golgi complexes and “onion bodies”.
4. Membrane Systems Within the Cell At present a threedimensional picture of the cytoplasmic contents of the retinular cells is lacking and there are conflicting reports on the disposition of membrane systems within the cell, probably due in part to real differences between the eyes studied. Endoplasmic reticulum is conspicuous in the distal rhabdomere bearing ends of the Fig.7 . T.S.through a group of four light adapted retinular cells from the median ocellus of S. greguria showing the rhabdomere regions. rh, rhabdom. int. sp, intercellular space, possibly a downward extension of the vitreous cells. er, endoplasmic reticulum occurring near the microvilli of the rhabdomeres and extending through the cell towards the site of the developing axons. ax. st, site of developing axon. mit mitochondria x 15,000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
111
Fig. 8. Rhabdomere region of dark adapted retinular cells from the median ocellus of S. gregaria. rh, rhabdom cut longitudinally. mit, mitochondria. cist, cisternae, fluid filled intracellular cavities. x 20,000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
Fig. 9. T.S. through the retinular cell region of a dark adapted ocellus showing the palisade layer of cisternae adjacent to the rhabdomeres (cf. Fig. 7). rh, rhabdom. pl, palisade layer. mit, mitochondria. ax, descending retinular cell axon. glm, glial membranes. x 12,000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
114
LESLEY J . GOODMAN
cells in both ocelli and compound eyes. Ruck and Edwards ( 1 964) have suggested that there is a connection between the endoplasmic reticular system and the extracellular space surrounding the cell in the ocellar retinular cells of the dragonfly, Libellulu. They were able to trace pairs of membranes in the endoplasmic reticulum some few microns away from the rhabdomere delimiting channels which extended uninterruptedly for some distance in longitudinal sections. Below the level of the rhabdomere the channels, whose widths are reported as varying from between 100 A"-1 500 A" and more, wrap around the interior of the cell like concentric cylinders. This system extends as far as the region of the origin of the retinular cell axon where it becomes restricted to the area just inside the outer limiting membrane. Here Ruck and Edwards find difficulty in making a distinction between the channels of the endoplasmic reticulum and extracellular space and they believe that the channels are in fact confluent with extracellular space. Ruck ( 1 964) cites as a further example in which internal cytoplasmic membranes appear to be confluent with conventional extracellular spaces the membrane bound tubules of Dissosteiru, Anux and Apis, tentatively described as ultra-tracheoles by Fernandez-Morin ( 1958). In the skipper butterfly these tubules, approximately 250-300 A" in diameter, extend from the rhabdomeres through the cytoplasm to the outer membrane of the retinular cells through rows of mitochondria. In Musca similar structures are reported to connect the rhabdomeres with spaces between contiguous retinular cells. Since the microvilli of the rhabdomeres are open to the cellular cytoplasm at 'their basal ends Ruck claims that the membrane system derived from the endoplasmic reticulum could put the rhabdomeres in close proximity to a significant volume of extracellular space within the cell. In many cases extracellular space is very limited around insect photoreceptor cells. In the ocellus of Blaberus the outer limiting membranes of neighbouring cells are only about 100 A" apart and Ruck has questioned the sufficiency of this space as an ion store for maintaining a prolonged positive ion entry phase and suggests that the intracellular membrane system could greatly supplement the volume of extracellular space and might prove the most likely site of the generator potential. A number of objections can be made to Fig. 10. Site of retinular cell axon formation. er, endoplasmic reticulum forming the site of axon development. Note proximity to rhabdomere and to extracellular space. f.rib, free ribosomes. at.rib, attached ribosomes. des, desmosomes. x 30,000 (see also Fig. 11, A, B and C). (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
117
Ruck’s proposals. In the ocellar retinular cells of Schistocercu the site of axonal development is clearly marked by concentric rings of endoplasmic reticulum (Figs 10, 1 1 A, B and C) but although the channels appear to be confluent in some cases with larger intracellular vacuoles or lacunae no continuity with extracellular space can be found (Fig. 1 1 C) and no such continuity has been reported from other studies of retinular cells. Possibly treatment with ferratin might establish whether such continuity does in fact exist. Even if continuity existed it is difficult to see that it could be an effective way of increasing the useful volume of extracellular space since it is the volume per unit area of membrane which is of significance in the ionic exchange and this is not increased by proliferating relatively narrow tubules within the cell. In any case in view of a comparable lack of extracellular space in other parts of the central nervous system it is probable that Ruck’s doubts about the sufficiency of available space between the retinal cells are unfounded. Horridge and Barnard ( 1965) have provided an alternative suggestion as to the function of some of the larger vacuoles or lacunae present in the retinular cell cytoplasm including those of Dissosteiru and Muscu. They have reported a zone of vacuoles, 2-4 p across, in the cytoplasm adjacent to the rhabdomeres in the dark adapted compound eye of Locustu forming a clear zone or palisade around the rhabdom and they have found instances in which the central spaces of these vacuoles are continuous with the space between the paired membranes of the endoplasmic reticulum. In the light adapted eye the lacunae are distributed in the cytoplasm and the mitochondria are crowded close to the rhabdomeres. The same effect has been noted in the median ocellus of Schistocercu (Figs 6 , 8 and 9). These endoplasmic lacunae or cisternae appear to be filled with fluid and because comparisons of cross-sections show that the volume of lacunae plus palisade remains constant Horridge and Barnard believe that the lacunae move centrally towards the rhabdomeres in bulk as the eye becomes dark adapted, displacing the ~~~
~
Fig. 1 1 . A, L.S. through the base of a retinular cell. ax, retinular cell axon descending through tapetal layer. tap, tapetal layer. rh, rhabdom. nt., neurotubules. x 8000. B, Oblique section through lower portion of a retinular cell. er, concentric rings of endoplasmic reticulum surrounding early stage axon material. x 8000. C. Oblique section through a retinular cell at a lower level showing concentric rings of endoplasmic reticulum, er, surrounding axon material which includes mitochondria, mit. Space bounded by endoplasmic reticulum membranes appears to be in continuity with intracellular cistemae. x 1800. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.) A.1.P.-5
118
LESLEY J . GOODMAN
mitochondria towards the periphery of the cell. A loose structure of lacunae is thus formed around the rhabdom transversed by a thin cytoplasmic bridge connecting the rhabdomeres with the rest of the cell. Horridge and Barnard suggest that the clear zone around the rhabdomeres of Dissosteira and Musca in fact represent palisade layers. No mechanism for palisade forma tion and mitochondria1 movements has yet been suggested. The effect of palisade formation in the dark adapted eye is to bring about an increase in sensitivity. Measurements of the refractive index in the region immediately surrounding the rhabdom in light and dark adapted eyes of Locusta indicated that the palisade layer must increase the difference in refractive index between the rhabdom and the surrounding cytoplasm, thus tending to keep light within the rhabdom by internal reflection. The angle of acceptance of light of individual cells is increased so that in the dark adapted eye more light enters and is kept within the rhabdom. In the light adapted eye the palisade is replaced by a layer of mitochondria having a high refractive index similar to that of the rhabdom, thus tending to prevent internal reflection and to decrease the angle of light acceptance of the cell. Horridge and Barnard point out that these changes would scarcely be sufficient to account for the changes in sensitivity of three to four orders of magnitude that accompany light and dark adaptation in the compound eye of Locusta. The limited amount of pigment movement that occurs in response to illumination would probably also be insufficient. The change in sensitivity accompanying adaptation of the ocelli of Schistocercu is at least as great as that in the compound eye of Locusta but no changes in cellular organization which might promote sensitivity changes have been noted other than palisade formation. 5. Multivesicular Systems Spherical multivesicular bodies containing many small vesicles of the order of 500-600A" have been found in various types of arthropod retinular cell and the ocelli are no exception (Fig. 6). Fig. 12. A, B and C show the multivesicular system found within the glial membranes. A. ret, retinular cell. er, endoplasmic reticulum. glm, glial membranes. ax, retinular cell axons. nt. neurotubules. mit mitochondria. x 11,000. B. shows the glial membranes associated with the ends of the rhabdomeres. glm, glial membranes. des, desmosomes. er, endoplasmic reticulum within the glial membranes adjacent to the rhabdomeres. rh, rhabdom. x 3400. C. rh, rhabdom. des, desmosome. glm, glial membranes. ax, axon. ves, vesicles within the glial membranes (see also Fig. 13). x 48,000. (From Goodman and Kirkham, 1970.)
STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF INSECT DORSAL OCELLUS
121
Though commonly bounded by a membrane, groups of vesicles may sometimes be seen lying free in the cytoplasm and individual vesicles may be dispersed throughout it (Fig. 8). The multivesicular bodies are usually closely associated with the rhabdomeres, indeed Waddington and Perry (1 96 l), who first reported them in Drosphila, suggested that they participate in the formation of the membrane of the rhabdom tubules; later workers however have not supported this view (Baccetti and Bedini, 1964; Rutherford and Horridge, 1965; Trujillo€en6z, 1965). Curtis (1 969) has recently found both vesicular and tubular elements forming a peri-rhabdomeric reticulum in the retinular cells of the phalangid, Mitopus morio, with vesicles occurring within the microvilli. He has demonstrated the presence of a presumed acetylcholinesterase in these vesicles and suggests that acetylcholinerase activity in vesicles so closely associated with the rhabdomere indicates that the ace tylcholine/acetylcholinesterase system is involved at some stage in the transduction of photic stimulation into a receptor potential. In Schistocerca an interesting association between the membraneous sheaths surrounding the visual cells and the rhabdomeres has been observed. The lower half of the retinulae and their axons are supported by a meshwork of cells having the extensive and intricate shape characteristic of glial cells (Fig. 14). The glial cells continue upwards to form membraneous sheaths around the retinular cells. They extend between adjacent cells to the ends of the rhabdomeres, becoming intimately associated with the retinular cells at thi