Advances in
INSECT PHYSIOLOGY
VOLUME 2
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Insect Physiology Edited b...
28 downloads
1155 Views
20MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
INSECT PHYSIOLOGY
VOLUME 2
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Insect Physiology Edited by J. W. L. BEAMENT, J. E. TREHERNE
and V. B. WIGGLESWORTH Department of Zoology, The University, Cambridge, England
VOLUME 2
AN ACADEMIC PRESS REPLICA REPRINT
This is an Academic Press Replica Reprint reproduced directly from the pages of a title for which type, plates, or film no longer exist. Although not up to the standards of the original, this method of reproduction makes it possible to provide copies of books which otherwise would be out of print.
Copyright 0 1964 By Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd. Second printing 1968 ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London N W 1
US.Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, N e w York. N e w York 10003
All Rights Reserved NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OF ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMSSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 63-14039
REPRODUCED PHOTOLITHO I N GREAT BRITAIN BY J. W. ARROWRMITH LTD..HRIRTOL 3 808182
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
Contributors to Volume 2 SVENDOLAI' ANDERSEN,Zoophysiological Laboratory B, Copenhagen University, Denmark J. W. L. BEAMENT, Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, England DIETRICH BURSHARDT,Zoological Institute, University of Munich, Germany C. B. COTTRELL, Department of Zoology, University College of Rhodesia and Nyasalsnd, Salisbury, Southern Rhodesia K. G . DAVEY, Institute of Parasitology, McGill University, Montreal, Canada TORKEL WEIS-FOGH, Zoophysiological Laboratory B, Capenhagen University, Denmark V. B. WIGGLESWORTH, Agricultural Research Council Unit of Insect Physiology, Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, England
V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME2
.
V
RESILIN.A RUBBERLIKE PROTEININ ARTHROPOD CUTICLE SVEN OLAV ANDERSEN
and TORKEL WEIS-FOGH 1
I. Introduction + 11. Identification, Occurrence and Function A. Working Definition . B, Rubberlike Cuticle . C. Function of Resilin 111. Physical Properties of Resilin A. Fundamental Properties , B. Molecular Interpretation . IV. Chemical Properties of Resilin . A. Amino Acid Composition . 73. Swelling in Different Media C. Enzymic Hydrolysis D. Fluorescent Amino Acids V. General Discussion . A. What makes a Protein Rubberlike? B. How are the Networks Formed? . C. Resilin and Insect Cuticle References
.
3 3 4
17 18 20 28 33 33 36 40 41
.
.
.
. .
50 51
53 57 62
.
.
THEACTIVETRANSPORT AND PASSIVE MOVEMENT OF WATER IN
INSECTS
J. W. L. BEAMENT
I. Introduction . 11. The Active Transport of Water A. Basic Premises . B. Active Uptake from the Air . C. Active Transport of Water in the Gut D. Water and the Tracheal System
.
.
vii
.
67 69 69 72 76 78
viii
111.
IV.
V.
VI. VII.
VIII.
IX.
X.
C O N T 11 N TS
E. The Living Cuticle and Liquid Water . F. Conclusions An Interrelation between Grease and Absorbtion . A. A Model Absorbing Water . The Physical Chemistry of the Cuticle . A. The Cuticle other than Lipid Layer . B. The Hydration of Procuticle . C. Control of Procuticle by the Epidermis . The Cuticular Lipid . A. A New Interpretation of Transition in Monolayer Films . B. Monolayer Inversion . C. Conclusions The Asymmetry of Cuticle . A. Thermodynamic Validity of Asymmetry. . Electrical Properties of Cuticular Lipids A. The Electrical Inversion of a Monolayer. B. Mechanical Distortion . C. The Passage of Substances through Monolayers . On Pumps. A. The Electret Ion-pump . B. Continuous-flow Water-pumps . C. Is the Lipid the Water-valve? . Wider Implications . Summary . References.
88 91 92 94 94 95 96 97 98 101 105 107 107 111 111 112 115 115 117 118 120 122 123 124 125
COLOUR DISCRIMINATION IN INSECTS DIETRICH BURKHARDT
. I. Historical Background . 11. Terminology 111. Current State of Knowledge A. Spectral Range Visible for Insects, the Spectral Sensitivity Curves . B. The Question of the Screening Pigments. C. Visual Pigments in Insects D. Wavelength Discrimination and Central Mechanisms of Colour Vision . References.
.
131 135 137
.
137 157 158 159 169
ix
CONTENTS
INSECT ECDYSIS WITH PARTICULAR EMPHASIS ON CUTICULAR
HARDENING AND DARKENING C. B. COTTRELL
. I. Introduction 11. An Outline of Ecdysis . 111. The Hardening and Darkening of Cuticular Arcas prior to Ecdysis . . 1v. The Splitting and Shedding of the Old Cuticle . V. The Mechanism of Expansion VI. The Muscular System Involved in Ecdysis . VII. The Components of thc Sclerotizing System . A. The Tanning Agent . B. The Protein Precursor of Sclerotin . C. Enzymes Concerned in Sclerotization . VIII. The Relationship between Hardening and Darkening . IX. ‘The Control of Various Processes Associated with Ecdysis A , Hardening and Darkening . B. Air Swallowing . C. Mechanical Properties of the Cuticle . D. “Shut off” of Ecdysial Muscles E. Absorption of Fluid from Tracheae . F. Other Processes . X. Some Factors Involved in the Production of the Definitive Body Form at Ecdysis . References.
.
175 175
176 178 179 181 183 184 185 185 199
204 204 208
208 209 209
209 210 21 2
THECONTROL OF V~SCEKAL MUSCLFSIN INSECTS K. G. DAVEY
.
I. Introduction 11. The Heart. A. Muscles of the Heart . B. Pharmacology . C. Nervous Control . D. Endocrine Control . 111. The Ventral Diaphragm . IV. The Muscles of the Alimentary Canal A. General Remarks. B. The Fore-gut . C. The Mid-gut .
219
220 220 22 1
.
223 225 23 1 232 232 233 236
X
CONTENTS
D. The Hind-gut . V. The Muscles of the Malpighian Tubules VI. The Muscles of the Oviducts . VII. The Actonomic Nervous System in Insects References.
236 238 240 240 242
.
.
THEHORMONAL REGULATION OF GROWTH AND REPRODUCTI( IN INSECTS V. B. WIGCLESWORTH
I. Introduction . 11. The Neuro-endocrine System . A. Histology of the Neurosecretory Cells . B. The Role of the Neurosecretory Cells in Moulting . C. The Liberation of the Neurosecretory Product . D. Cycles of Activity in the Neurosecretory Cells. E. The Stimulus to Liberation of the Brain Hormone . F. The Action of the Brain Hormone G . The Chemical Nature of the Brain Hormone . 111. The Thoracic Gland System . A. Anatomy and Histology . B. Activation and Function of the Thoracic Glands . C. Metabolic and Cytological Effects of the Thoracic Gland Hormone . D. Moulting Hormone, Mitosis, Growth and Differentiation E. The Chemical Nature of the Moulting Hormone . IV. Hormones and Diapause . A. Endocrine Organs in Diapause . B. Physiological Changes during Chilling . C. Injury and Diapause . D. The Nature of the Diapause State . E. The Role of Hormones in the Maternal Control of Diapause . V. The Corpus Allatum and the Control of Metamorphosis A. The Corpus Allatum and Juvenile Hormone Secretion B. The Effects of the Juvenile Hormone . C. The Mode of Action of the Juvenile Hormone D. Histology and Histochemistry of the Corpus Allaturn E. The Chemical Nature of the Juvenile Hormone
.
248 248 248 249 250 25 1 252 254 256 258 258 260 263 267 270 27 1 27 1 275 277 278 279 280 280 283 286 29 1 29 1
xi
CONTENTS
VI. Hormonal Control of Reproduction . A. Corpus Allatum and Reproduction . Role of the Nervous System and Neurosecretory Cells B. in Ovarian Development . C. Control of Ovulation and Oviposition VII. Metabolic Hormones and Hormonal Integration . A. Metabolic Hormones B. Homeostasis and Hormonal Action C. Humoral Integration . References. Addenda .
296 296
. .
337 345
.
.
AUTHORINDEX . SUBJECTINDEX .
.
30 1 306 307 308 311 3 14 316 335
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Resi lin. A Ruhlwrlike Protein in Arthropod Cuticle SVEND OLAV ANDERSEN and TORKEL WEIS-FOGH ZooplzjssiufogicafLaboratory B, Copenhagen University, Denmurk 1. Introduction . . . 11. Identification, Occurrence and Function A. Working Definition . R. Rubberlike Cuticle . C. Function of Resilin I l l . Physical Properties of Resilin . . A. Fundamental Properties . B. Molecular Interpretation . 1V. Chemical Properties of Resilin . A. Aniino Acid Composition . B. Swelling in Different Media . C . Enzymic Hydrolysis . D. Fluorescent Amino Acids . V. General L)iscussion . A. What Makes a Protein Rubberlihe? B. Holv are the Networks Formed'? C. Resilin and Insect Cuticle References .
. .
. .
. .
. . . . .
. .
.
. .
. . . . .
.
1 3 3 4
17 18
20 28 33 33 36 40 41 50 51 53 57 62
I . 1 N T K O 11u C T I O N Resilin is a structural protein whose name is derived from the Latin rcsiliw, to j u m p back. It was discovcrcd recently as a major constituent of
certain clastic hingcs and tendons in the cuticle of locusts and dragonflies (Wcis-Fogh, 1960) but, a$ we shall scc, it occurs widely and exhibits propcrtios which arc unusual and of gcneral interest to students of protcins and elastomers and to biologists. Wc shall therefore discuss the results obtained so far from many dilferent points of view andalso include somc un pu blishcd materia I. Thc wings of locusts are suspcndcd clastically from the strong thoracic box; i t was at f i n t thought that the elastic recoil of a wing which is moved away from its equilibrium position (Fig. 1A) was due exclusively to 'elastic deformations of the solid cuticle of the box, but it turned out that one-quarter to one-third of the energy is stored in the elastic hinge 1
mtitcrial itsclf. It was the cxpcrimcnts illustretcd in big. 1 which led to the discovcry of rcdin ( Weis-Fogh, 1959, 1961c, and unpublishcd). A large part of the suspending ligaments and hinges consists of a colourless
A
D FIG. 1 . The elastic recoil of the forewings in the isolated thorax of a desert locust, drawn from multiple-flashphotographs. (A) Unstrained intact thorax; (B) recoil in intact thorax; (C)recoil after removal of the wing muscles; (D) recoil of the rubberlike wing-hinges. The wings are mutilated and provided with an artificial mass (from Weis-Fogh, 196 1 c).
C
transparent protein, redin, with rubberlike properties (Weis-Fogh, 1960) and with a characteristic amino acid composition (Bailey and Weis-Fogh, 1961). In certain places it is present in pure isotropic form which is suitable for physical and chemical analyses without further purification.
RESILIN
3
In many respects it resembles elastin from vertebrates and may well be called “arthropod elastin” but, as will be shown, it differs from elastin in many important ways and lends itself more easily to studies of the rubberlike state in proteins, the number and nature of cross-links, and the formation of three-dimensional networks in biological structures. N, A N D FUNCTION 11. I D E N T I F I C A T I O OCCURRENCE Resilin is present as an insoluble gel-like component in certain patches of the cuticle of insects and crayfish. In order to identify it we must have some criteria by means of which it can be characterized and distinguished from other members of these compound structures. In view of the detailed treatment in succeeding parts of this review, we shall only give a qualitative working definition here (based mainly on Weis-Fogh, 1960; Bailey and Weis-Fogh, 1961;Andersen, 1961, 1963; Elliott et al., 1964). A . W O R K I N G DEFINITION
1. Both in situ and when dissected free, pure unstrained resilin appears as a mass of optically and mechanically isotropic protein. In the dry state it is hard and brittle and is insoluble in all solvents which do not break peptide bonds. In aqueous media and also in many anhydrous hydrophilic liquids it swells isotropically and reversibly; it then becomes rubbery and exhibits typically long-range deformability and complete elastic recovery. In water the swelling depends on pH, with minimum swclling about pH 4. It is devoid of colour, is transparent and shows no visible structure under the light microscope or electron microscope. 2. Swollen resilin becomes birefringent when strained, being positive in the direction of extension. 3. In water resilin stains with methylene blue and toluidine blue but shows no metachromasia. It stains red with the histological colour reactions of Masson and Mallory. 4. In ultraviolet light (UV-light), resilin fluoresces with a strong bluish colox with maximum intensity of about 420 mp. The intensity increases iri alkaline media. 5. Both in sirir and when free, resilin is easily digested by all proteinases. After complete acid or basic hydrolysis it yields only amino acids, of which fifteen are ordinary amino acids (but no sulphur-containing ones and no tryptophan or hydroxyproline) and two are unusual and specific. The latter are responsible for the characteristic fluorescence both of native resilin and of the hydrolyzate.
4
SVBNU
OLAV ANDERSEN A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
6. So far resilin has only bccn found in specific parts of the cuticle in insects and crustacea, i t . a\ cxtracellular deposits secreted by the epidermis. In certain structures i t is secreted in a pure form but in most cases together with chitin and fibrous proteins. Wher- resilin is mixed with other substances, the bulk properties of the cuticle question may of course differ appreciably from those of the pure material, but in most cases its presence can be established by means of simple tests, such as mechanical behaviour, strain birefringence, colour reactions, swelling and fluorescence. However, it is not safe to use only one or two of these tests. B. R U B B E R L I K E C U T I C L E
Arthropod cuticle is an extracellular product of the single-layered epidermis. The thin epicuticle, the often hard and coloured exocuticle, the softer endocuticle and the flexible membranes are made up mainly of materials in the solid state of matter (chitin, lipoprotein, tanned or fibrous proteins, inorganic crystals; for reviews see Richards, 1958; Wigglesworth, i 957 ; Dennell, 1960). These products are therefore called solid cuticle, but besides water some soluble protein is often present. In contrast to this, La Greca (1947) described the thick wing-hinge ligaments in locusts as being highly elastic, transparent and without colour. An analysis of these and similar structures disclosed that in all cases the elasticity and the great deformability is due to the presence of a large amount of resilin ( Weis-Fogh, 1960) and that swollen resilin is an almost ideal rubber in the physical sense of this word (Weis-Fogh, 1961a). Cuticle which shows long-range elasticity and a large content of resilin is therefore called rubberlike cuticle (Weis-Fogh, 1960). It is easy to demonstrate that the elasticity is caused by resilin since the structures become soft and flabby when treated with proteases and loose their swelling properties, fluorescence and strain birefringence.
I . How to j t i d rubberlike cuticle: a simple colour test The reasons why rubberlike cuticle was not discovered much earlier are undoubtedly due to the smallness of the patches, their transparency, lack of colour and softness-all of which remain unchanged after treatment with heat, alcohols and most other fixatives. However, it is easy to stain resilin almost selectively in fresh cuticle and then apply the other tests for the final identification. A living insect or crayfish is killed by immersion in hot buffered water for a few minutes (pH 6.7, 95-100°C). After opening the body, the soft
TABLF I Colour reactions of locust cuticle dyed in a mikture of 5 mg toltitdine blue and 5 mg light green in 100 ml bufTer solution \ \ l 2 0 ) for 40 h and examined after 6 h washing in pure buffer solutions Type of cuticle Rubberli he : Hinges and ligaments, wing system Transitional : Clypeo-la bra1 spring Outer endocuticle of ocelli and ommatidia Inner endocuticle of hind margin of abdominal tergi tes Tough ligaments: Wing system and mandible Arthrodial membranes: Outer part Inner part Thin inner lamina Tough inextensible tendons: (hardened) Sclerotized cuticle : Exocuticle Outer endocuticle Inner endocuticle Most hairs and bristles:
pH 4.6
Colour at pH 6.1
pH 7.1
Sapphire
Deep sapphire
Deep sapphire
Sky blue Green-blue ( f m t ) Blue
Sapphire Sapphire N o or faint green-blue Faint skj blue Blue Blue
A F
-m
Green
Green
Green. tinge o f blue
Green Green (faint) No or greenish Green
Green Green (faint) Purple Green
No No Purple Green
No or faint N o or blue (faint) No or green Green or green-blue
No N o or blue (faint) Green Green or green-blue
No No or blue (f,iint) Green Green
z
6
S V L N I ) 0 I . A V A N D E K S C N A N D T O R K E I . WEIS-FOGH
parts are removed and the cuticle freed from the epidermis (hypoderm) by means of a thin, strong jet of tap water. The rinsed cuticle is placed for 2 4 4 8 h at room temperature in dilute phosphate buffer (M/20, pH about 7) to which is added 5 mg toluidine blue (British Drug Houses) and 5 mg light green (E. Gurr) per 100 ml buffer. A crystal of thymol is
FIG. 2. Thc tluorcscent rubbcrlikeligarnents in the wing systernof the desert locust, photographed in UV-light through a 420 mp interference filter (A and C ) , as compared with ordinary light ( B and 11). The upper figures show the dorsal cuticle from the outside and the lower figures from the inside.
sufticient to prevent microbial growth. After rinsing in pure buffer for some hours, typical rubberlike cuticle appears as translucent, brilliant blue patches. Table I indicates that the staining reaction of locust cuticle
K I.s i I. I N
7
no! Jcpcnd much o n p!l and that thc typical sapphirc blue colour p t i 0 7 is l.ound o n l y in piltchc\ whcrc additional tcstc 4howcd the prcscncc ,)f' Inrgc amounts of' rcsilin, i.c. in typical ruhbcrlike cuticlc
doe5 ;it
where thcrc is no cover of' tanned exocuticle but only the thin epicuticle. The term frun.\itionu/ cuficle is used only tentatively. In the case of the clypeo-labral spring, which is described later, the thickened part fluoresces strongly and complies with all thc tests for resilin, including the presence of the specific amino acids. The hind margins and the midline of the abdominal tergitcs also fluoresce, they stain blue and contain the two unusual amino acids. There is therefore no doubt about the presence of resilin in these parts. Some of the transparent endocuticle which covers the compound eyes and the ocelli stained faintly blue and showed some elasticity and the usual swelling behaviour, but since it did not fluoresce re!,ilin may not be present or its fluorescence may be quenched by other mate ria Is. Sincc the strong blue colour is contined to the patches which contain resilin, the method is reasonably selective but it should always be supplemented by additional tests. For anatomical work, it is sometimes convenient simply to use a mixture of glycerol and water I : 1 to which is added a few drops of a mcthylene blue solution (British Drug Houses) and a crystal of thymol. The rubberlike parts stain deep blue and the tough ligaments green while the rest remains unstained. The wide distribution of rubbcrlikc pads and ligaments in the wing machinery and tergites of locusts, thus made visible, corresponds in detail to the picture obtained by photographing the untreated cuticle in UV-light through a 420 mp interfercnce filter (Fig. 2). I t is characteristic that resilin is stained selectively by the two basic dyes, methylene blue and toluidine blue (coloured cations), at least from pH 3 to pH 9.5. while basic fuchsin is useless and none of the acid dyes tested staincd selectively if at all (coloured anions; acid fuchsin, eosin, light green). I t is obvims that resilin-containing cuticle is widespread in the locust but, before we discuss the occurrence of the protein in more detail, it is reasonable to describe the three test pieces upon which most of the anidytical work has been done.
2. Thrw t(i.vt piccw As far as resilin is concerned, the simplest structure in Fig. 3 is the elastic tendon of dragonflies (C) and the most complicated is the winghinge (B). It is noticeable that the structures are readily deformed and snap back immediately to their original shape when unloaded. The
x
S V I h i ) 0 l . A V A V I ) I KS1.N A N I )
I O I < K I . l . \YI.IS-l O(it1
description\ arc h s e d upon Weis-Fogh (1960). unless othcrwise stated. ;rnd i n cach C;IX ~ h prcscncc c of resilin has been established by all methods av;iiliiblc, including amino acid :inalyscs (Bailey and Wcis-Fogh, 1961 ; Anderscn, lO(x3). , Ekusric t c ~ i t k w .Most wing muscles in dragonflies run in the dorsalventral ditcction and are attached directly to thc ventral wall. Thcy insert on cuticular tcndons. which are hollow air-filled invaginations from the dorsal cuticle, the so-called cap tendons. The elastic tendon for the C
/
I,.IG.3. The three test pieccs used i n n m t experiments. The prealar arm (A) and the main winghinge of the forewing(E3)from the descrt locust (Sclrisrocercu greguriu). (C') The elastic tcntlon froin the hindwing of a dragonfly (Aeslttr CJYJMJO). All the samples were placcd in dilute buller at pti 7 and are drawn both in the unstrained and in the strained state. (From Weis-Fogh, 1960.)
pleuro-subalar muscle (the third suhalar) is no exception, but in contradistinction to the rcmaining tendons the middle part is swollen like a snusagc and extremely extensible while both ends consist of the usual tough and almost inextcnsible cuticle (see Fig. 6). Being an invagination, the air-filled central canal is lined with a thin folded epicuticle and the periphery is covered by a single layer of the epidermal cells which formed the tendon, apparently in the course of the 3 days prior to the final moult (Neville, 1963a). The tough ends are composed mainly of chitin and
K I.SI I.IN
9
prolcit) clillcrcnt from rc4lin and they rewnblc ordinary lamcllatc ;irthroclial cuticlc (I:ig. 4/11.At thc tran4itioiis bctwccn the tough and thc cl:i\lic p a r t \ . rcsilin hcpiiis t o appear i n thc form of aniorphoub tnasscs hctween rhc other clcment~(13). A I?\v microiis nearer the s\vclling. the othcr protcins disappear aiid u'c arc left w i t h ;I hell-shaped concentric system ol'chitin lamcllac scpar;itcd by and glued togcthcr w i t h isotropic
FIG.4. l'ransvcrsc p:wiitlin scctions ( 4p thich) ofthedragonfly tendon, stained with M;tsson's triplc stain i n WIII~IIrcsilin bcconies rcd (here white). ( A ) Through tough tciitlon dorsiii l o Ihc clii\tic part. (13) l'rarisitional zone in which "flakes" of resilin appear. (< 1 Anclictriny z o ~ i cwith rcsilin atid chitin lamellac. (D) Pure resilin devoid of structure. Thc cpidcrnial ccils ;irc indicated. (From Weis-Fogh, 1960.)
and structurclcss n i x m of rcsilin. This is the anchoring zone (C) and it is confined to the cnds. The major part of the swelling consists of a cylindrical piece of purc rcsilin covered towards the central canal by a thin buckled cpicuticle and by an cqually thin but badly defined cover towards the peripheral cells (D). Neither of these membranes convey any mechanical strength to the tendon, as is easily seen when resilin is removed by digestion with trypsin or othcr proteases. When the cells are stripped
Fit;. 5. Electron micrograph of a .mgitudinal section of an osmium-hxed elastic tendon. The upper part is the central canal filled with the embedding methacrylate and separated from the structureless resilin by the dark wavy epicuticle. (By courtesy of Dr. D. S. Smith.)
FIG.6. Elastic tendon from the forewing of A e . hra cyuticci, dehydrated itr .\i/ii and mounted in Canada balsam. Note the central canal. (From Weis-Fogh, 1960.) FIG.7. A fresh, stripped elastic tendon from Ae.!h u g r c t ~ d i splaced in neutral saline between crossed Nicols in the unstrained state (h = 1) and when stretched up to h = 2.48. Unstrained resilin is optically isotropic, but becomes birsfringent when deforniated, positive in the direction of extension. (From Weis-Fogh, 1960.)
12
svi.Ni) OI.AV
ANIII.RSI.N
ANI)
r o i < ~ t .W ~ ,E I S - I ( ) ( ; t i
oll, the tendon c;in thcrcfc)re bc con\idcrcd a \ ;I cylindrical piccc of purc rcsilin suspended a t either cnd by mean\ o f tough cuticle. Both i n the light and in the electron tnicroscopc (Elliott c / ol., 1964) resilin appears complctcly devoid o f structure (Fig. 5). The cpicuticle is
thin (about 200 mp)and buckled so that it docs not tighten until stretched about three times. Pieces of pure rcsilin can bc broken off. They have sharp edges, chonchoidal surfaces of fracture and fit exactly together when reassembled. Even at break there is thercforc n o sign of flow. Isolated pieces and intact tendons arc optically isotropic at all degrees of swelling but become birefringcnt when strained (Fig. 7). Since the
I
500p A
FIG.8. Frozen scction of thc wing-hinge from a forewing of the dcsert locust. The dark sclerotizcd cuticle is double hatched. the tough fibrillar part is striped, the laniellae of the rubberlikc part are indicated. and the pure pad of resilin is white. (A) Wholchinge. (B)PnI.tofthe1amellarcuticle.asindicated. (FromWeis-Fogh,1960.)
swelling is equal in all directions, pure rcsilin is also mechanically isotropic. The rubbcrlikc part of the tendon is small, 0-7mm long, 0.1 5 mm wide, 5-7 pg of rcsilin in the big Acdzna species. It is present in all dragonfly groups. Prealur arm. In grasshoppers, the anterior edge of the dorsal plate between thc forewings (the mesotergum) is suspended elastically at either side by means of two transparent, hyalinc pegs which extend abruptly from the dark and hard cuticle, the prealar arms (Fig. 3A). The tip continues as a tough flexible ligament attached to the first basalar sclerite
RESILIN
13
of the side wall. In histological transverse sections it is seen tfiat the elastic peg consists of thin concentric lamellae of chitin, less than 0.2 p thick, separated and glued together by 1-3 p thick continuous sheets of pure resilin. As to internal structure, the entire peg resembles the anchoring zone of the elastic tendon (Fig. 32). When the resilin is removed by means of enzymes or by mild acid or alkaline hydrolysis (0.1 N HC1 or NaOH at 96°C for 5-6 h), the continuous chitin lamellae remain as glossy sheets and the structure lacks rigidity in a direction normal to the sheets (indicated by the direction of pull in Fig. 3A). It remains tough however when stretched in a longitudinal direction. Thus during bending and compression, resilin then dominates the elastic behaviour while chitin does so in extension (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962). Under the electron microscope the thin chitin lamellae (about 50 mp thick) are distinct while resilin shows no structure and, as in the case of the tendon, very little contrast (Elliott et al., 1964). The lamellae appear to continue into the solid, dark cuticle and therefore to anchor the peg firmly to its base at the very sharp transition between the two types of cuticle. The wing-hinge. The third structure is the main wing-hinge ligament of grasshoppers. It is more complicated than the other two both with respect to shape and structure (Figs. 3B and 8; see also Neville, 1963a). The major external part consists of a tough ventral ligament with fibrous proteins and chitin which continues dorsally into rubberlike cuticle consisting only of chitin lamellae and resilin, as in the prealar arm. In addition, the part of the ligament closest to the cells is deposited as a pure piece of resilin-the pad. It is particularly interesting that this pad and also some of the lamellar parts are laid down in the course of several days after the final moult, so that it lends itself to studies on the biogenesis of pure resilin (Weis-Fogh, 1960; Neville, 1963b). In addition to these three structures, several other examples are now known and should be mentioned briefly. 3. Miscellaneous examples The cuticles from a number of winged insects and also from a crayfish (Asracus fluviutilis) and some spiders were tested for the presence of resilin. The main results are summarized in Table 11. It is obvious that resilin and rubberlike cuticle may be found in any part of the exoskeleton of insects and presumably also of Crustacea but, according to our very scanty information, it seems to be absent in Arachnida. The different findingsneed some comment because they indicate the biological function of resilin. The main wing-hinge ligumenrs connect the pleural wing process with
TABLE 11 Colour reactions and some other tests for milin in typical rubberlike cuticle performed on rinsed samples from winged insects and from a crayfish(Astacusfiviarilis, Cmtacea, Decapoda) (The insbas were: Aeshna cyanea (Odo~ta).P e r i p k t a Mvricrma CDictyoptcra), Schirtoerm gregaria (Orthoptera), Sphinx spp. (Lepidoptem), Oryctes rhinoceros and Meblontha vdgaris (Caleoptem), Bombus spp. and Apis mellvera (Hymenoptera),Calliphoraeryrhrp cephla (Diptera). So far, we have not found any rubberlike cuticle in the spiders tested (unknown species, cbelicerata, Arachnids).)
Structure, animal
(and systematic group)
pH 4.6
Colour at pH 4 6
pH 7.1
Fluorescence
L
=b
smw3 specific andstrain -o bireacids fringence
Main wing-hinge ligaments: Aeshna cyanea
(Odonata) Perijdaneta americana (Dictyoptera) Schisrocerca gregaria (Orthoptera) Minor wing-hinge ligaments: All insects tested Elastic tendons : Aeshna cyanea (Odonata) calhphora erythrocephala Other structures: Clypeo-labral spring and abdominal tergites of Schistocerca (Orthoptera) Abdominal spring of Oryctes and Melolontha (Coieoptera) Hinge between mems and ischiurn inaphalothoracic leg of
R s C u Z - ~ ffUYiC+lU
Sky blue to sapphire! Sky blue
Sky blue to sapphire Sapphire
Sky blue to sapphire Sapphire
Sapphire
Deep sapphire
Deep sapphire
+ + +
+ + +
>
2 tl
All gradations from sky blue to deep sapphire Outer purple, inner greenish Green-blue
Outer sapphire, Outer sapphire, inner bluegreen inner sky blue Sky blue Sky blue
Sky blue
sapphire
sapphire
Sapphire
Deep sapphire
Deep sapphire
+
+
sapphire
sapphire
+
+
-
+
KESILIN
15
the wing sclerites (second axillary and tip of radial vein). In the three orders in which the plate between the wings (pterotergum) is not rigidly connected with the side walls in front and behmd (Odonata, Dictyoptera, Orthoptera), the ligaments are thick cushions of rubberlike cuticle which act as springy hinges and which take up both compressive and tensile forces. In insects with a strong sclerotized connection (Lepidoptera, some Coleoptera, Hymenoptera), these ligaments are tough, inextensible tension strands which stain green. It is possible that in certain Diptera some of them are rubberlike. When all the ligaments are of the tough type, any elastic recoil must be caused by deformation of the solid thoracic box, in contrast to the rubberlike ligaments of locusts which are known to contribute by significant amounts (see Fig. 1). Most small wing-hinge ligaments are of the tough type, but in all insects studied we have found some rubberlike ones. The elastic ligaments in grasshoppers are too numerous to be listed but their abundance may be judged from Fig. 2. They are often shaped like pads or cushions and can take up both push and pull. It is therefore of particular interest to notice their presence in Calliphora (between Subalar sclerite and second axillary, between subalar sclerite and third axillary), in Bombus (between third and fourth axillaries, and between the basalar sclerite and the humeral wing complex), and in Orvctes (between pleural process and basalar sclerite, along posterior-lateral edge of third axillary). Any interpretation of the wing mechanism must now take the existence of push ligaments into account. Elastic tendons were found in dipteran flies besides the one already described from dragonflies. In Calliphora there are two elastic and rather irregularly shaped tendons to which the “ slow” controller muscles attach (the pleuroaxillary muscle (Bonhag, 1949; No. 35a) and the tergopleural muscle (Bonhag, 1949; No. 42)). There is no doubt about the function of these tendons. In dragonflies and other primitive insects there are no muscles which can control the wing twist during the upstroke (Weis-Fogh, unpublished), but in order to hover and perform similarly refined manoeuvres this is imperative. The dragonflies have solved the problem in two ways (Neville, 1960): (a) by inserting a phasic upstroke muscle at the end of a spring system in such a way that the anterior part of the wing becomes supinated, and (b) by transforming an original downstroke muscle into a slow muscle which is then connected to the posterior part of the wing via the elastic tendon. This means that the muscle does not oscillate in length during flight but only keeps the tendon at a certain average length and tension, the movements being taken up by the spring. Similarly, the rapid
16
S V E N D O L A V A N D E K S E N A N D I ’ O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
oscillations of the diptcran wing do not permit time for a phasic control of the twisting movcmcnts but, by means of similar elastic tendons and “slow” rnusclcs, tlight can be fully controlled in spite of the fact that the main wing muscles are myogenic, i.e. their oscillations bear no dircct rclationship to the nervous impulses which activate them. The dypeo-lubrul spring of grasshoppers is a pair of rib-shaped swellings on the.ora1 aspect of clypeus and labrum. These plates cover the mouthparts anteriorly and the springs serve to keep the labrum against the mandibles when feeding and at rest. The swellings consist of lamellate rubberlike cuticle and a cross-section is seen in Fig. 9.
FIG.9. Frozen section of the clypeo-labral spring of a desert locust, photographed in UV-light to show the fluorescence.
The abdominal springs of beetles are interesting. It is well known that these insects have only expiratory muscles and that the inspiration is due to elasticity. In fact, we found that each pair of tergites and sternites are kept in the inspiratory position relative to each other by means of a pair of elastic ribs which begin as an endocuticular swelling under the exocuticle and continue across the soft arthrodial membrane and end as a similar swelling under the exocuticle of the sternites. These swellings are composed of typical rubberlike cuticle.
RESILIN
17
The elaslie leg-hingc In the crayfish is situated between merus and ischiurn, a hingc which has a flexor muscle but no extensor, so that the pad-likc ligament acts as an extensor. In this case, the resilin is present in the external layer which is flush with the tanned “exocuticie” whereas the innermost layer of the hinge is tough and flush with the calcified “endocuticle”. It is also characteristic that the resilin swells more than in any insect structure when it is placed in alkaline media: the thickness of the rubberlike part increases eight times from pH 1 to 13. Otherwise, all reactions are the same as in insect resilin. Other examples. There is no doubt that resilin will be found in many other places and there are a few additional observations in the literature. Thus Miller (1960) observed that the cuticle of the apparently fused pleura of the pterothorax of locusts dorsal to the second spiracle appears to be rubberlike and is partly responsible for the wide-opening reaction of this valve during flight. An interesting example is offered by Dr. F. S . Edwards (personal communication) who found that the precise spitting of certain predacious bugs is caused by an elastic cuticular pump, partly mzde from rubberlike cuticle. The pump resembles a gastrula in which the invaginated wall is rubberlike and supplied with a muscle which tends to pull the two blades from each other. The saliva is contained between the blades and the volume is controlled by means of the muscle. When it relaxes, the inner blade moves towards the outer and the saliva is driven out by elastic forces alone. Since resilin neither flows nor suffers any permanent deformation, it is particularly interesting that Thurm (1963) recently found that the base of each hair in the sensory hair fields of bees is highly elastic and stains with methylene blue like resilin. In fact, a material like resilin would be an absolute frame of reference for a mechanical sense organ in a way almost no other known material could. A more detailed investigation would obviously be fruitful. So far, it is not known whether resilin is present in the wingless insects (Collembola) although some staining reactions indicate its presence (Noble-Nesbitt, 1963a). We did not find any indication of it in lycosid spiders. C. F U N C T I O N O F R E S I L I N
With a few possible exceptions, resilin has been found to act as an elastic material from which the epidermal cells of arthropods “construct” mechanical springs of great deformability and perfect elastic recovery, i.e. its function is mechanical and is bound up with long-range deformations and the storage and release of mechanical energy. It seems to
18
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
be metabolically inert but this does not exclude the fact that simple chemical modifications may take place after deposition and thereby alter the mechanical properties slightly (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962). So far, there is no direct proof of this. It is certain, however, that no major changes occur after deposition and this is probably connected with the remarkable stability of resilin compared with other structural proteins. In fact, its physical properties are so unchangeable that they make it an almost ideal object for studies on rubberlike elasticity. Resilin or related proteins may play an optical role in the transparent cuticle over the eyes and ocelli, but nothing is known about this at the time of writing. It is also possible that similar deformable networks are present as a matrix for some parts of the new cuticle when it is being secreted and before it becomes tanned after a moult (Jensen and WeisFogh, 1962), as discussed on p. 62.
RESILIN Organic polymers are often divided into two main groups according to their mechanical properties. The elastomers are rubbery elastic materials in contrast to plastomers which do not exhibit much recovery after deformation, but it should be emphasized that the same material may be rubberlike at certain temperatures and swelling, and either plastic or giasslike under other conditions. We shall now analyse resilin as an elastomer, or as a rubber in the physical sense of the word. Since Meyer et al. (1932) first offered a clear interpretation of the rubberlike state of matter in molecular terms, there has been general agreement about the qualitative description although the quantitative formulations differ as to detail (see Treloar, 1958). The chemical nature is immaterial and a typical unstrained rubber consists of a three-dimensional network of randomly kinked and randomly orientated long-chain molecules. Such a three-dimensional network is optically and mechanically isotropic in the glassy state, in the rubberlike state and at all degrees of swelling in an indifferent liquid (i.e. in a liquid which would be a good indifferent solvent for the chains if they were free). The term rubberlike refers to a specific state of the network. Below a certain temperature or in the absence of plasticizers, the interaction between the chains is so strong that they act as solid isotropic glass but when the bonds are broken or weakened in some way the material may become plastic. If, moreover, rotation is possible between the members of the chain and the interaction between them is insignificant compared with the disruptive forces due to thermal movements, a typical rubber may 111.
PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF
RESILIN
19
result. It is characterized as follows. The network is highly and reversibly deformable. If the junction points are represented by simple physical entanglements, the strained network is likely to flow with time and to acquire a permanent deformation. If, on the other hand, the major part of the junction points consist of stable chemical cross-links between the linear chains, as in a vulcanizate, perfect elastic recovery is possible. The chains between junction points must be relatively long and possess many freely rotating links so that, in the absence of significant attractive forces, thermal agitation tends to make the chains take up a randomly kinked and constantly changing configuration, i.e. in an unstrained network the configurational entropy of the assembly of chains is maximum. The network owes its great deformability to the fact that the most probable distance between the end points of a long flexible randomly kinked chain is many times smaller than its contour length (extended length). When strained, the chains are removed from their statistically most probable configuration to which thermal agitation tends to bring them back. This means a decrease in entropy and it is the main reason why the mechanical energy used in straining the rubber can be stored as elastic energy and released again, i.e. the elastic forces depend mainly on entropy changes-in the ideal rubber only on entropy changes. In contrast to this, the elastic forces of an ordinary solid are due mainly to the straining of interatomic bonds, i.e. to changes in internal energy. Since the chains between junction points must be long and flexible, the number of cross-links per unit volume must be rather small. If there are too many the material becomes hard like ebonite and tanned cuticle, and if there are too few the material does not recover after deformation but flows to some extent. In typical rubbers theoretical as well as experimental estimates of the elastic modulus indicate a range from 5 to 30 kg cm-2 which is several orders of magnitude less than for most solid materials. Even in a good vulcanized rubber it takes time to reach the final state after loading, deformation or release and this gives rise to the phenomena of creep, stress relaxation and delayed recovery respectively. These viscoelastic properties also cause hysteresis and damping when the sample is subject to an oscillating strain or stress and they are due, in part, to a finite adjustment time which is of the order of minutes in good vulcanizates of natural rubber. Gent (1962) extended such samples to about twice their unstrained length and found that both the creep and the relaxation increased linearly with the logarithm of time, by a few per cent in 10-100 min, until a finite value was reached. In a swollen rubber, damping should also depend on the friction between the chains
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH 20 and the liquid and on the movement of liquid in and out of the rubber due to changes in the hydrostatic pressure, but nothing seems to be known about these phenomena. In any case, a good swelling agent is likely to reduce the adjustment time and therefore the damping and hysteresis but at the same time it introduces a new loss factor due to viscous resistance. Most structural proteins do not conform to this picture at all and it was therefore surprising to find that the properties of resilin are in complete agreement with it. In fact, resilin turned out to approach the ideal rubber to a higher degree than any natural or synthetic rubber known so far. Since, moreover, the quantitative theories of rubber elasticity are applicable to this protein, simple mechanical and optical observations offer quantitative information, otherwise difficultto obtain, about the molecular weight of the chains between the junction points, about their flexibility and how it alters with temperature and pH, and about the number of cross-links present. The latter point is particularly interesting because the cross-links are extremely stable and therefore of a co-valent nature, but they are different from the -S-S-bridges commonly found in proteins and must be of a hitherto unknown type (Weis-Fogh, 1960). A. F U N D A M E N T A L PROPERTIES
It is most likely that the macroscopic behaviour of resilin is shared by elastin and the two will be compared, as far as possible.
I . Deformability and stability The elastic tendon shown in Fig. 7 can be extended to almost three times its unstrained swollen length before it breaks at about 40 kg swollen unstrained area (90 kg cm-2 dry cross-sectional area). These figures are somewhat higher than those previously published (WeisFogh, 1961a). As already mentioned, the broken surfaces of the unstrained pieces fit exactly together and show that the material is unchanged even after maximum stress and this extraordinary stability is found under all conditions. In Fig. 10, for example, two pieces plus an intact tendon were placed in 70% ethanol where they were completely rubbery (A). They were then deformed and strained extensively by means of forceps while being placed in absolute ethanol where they quickly became dehydrated and hard, retaining the grotesque forms in (B). However, when returned to 70% ethanol they swelled, became rubbery within a few seconds and resumed their former properties and shapes (C). Such
21
RESILIN
experiments can be repeated indefinitely with the same pieces, also after treatment with protein coagulants and histological fixatives. In fact, no treatment short of chain rupture due to hydrolysis, strong oxidation or temperatures in excess of 140°C have been found to alter the state of swollen resilin. It is not known at which temperature water begins to freeze in the network but, as we have seen, the transition from the swollen rubbery state to the glassy state of the dehydrated material is entirely reversible, with a plastic state in between (Weis-Fogh, 1960). In the following section we are dealing only with resilin swollen in buffered water at different pH where it remains rubbery. It is not known A
6
C
FIG. 10. Samples of elastic tendons: (A) unstrained in 70% ethanol; (B) strained in absolute ethanol, and (C)after recovery in 70% ethanol. (From Weis-Fogh, 196n.)
with certainty whether elastin behaves in a similar way but it is also extremely heat resistant (Partridge et al., 1955) and only rubbery when swollen. Isolated single fibres can then be extended reversibly up to twice the unstrained length (Carton el al., 1962). 2. Elastic recovery and damping Resilin is unusual in showing elastic recovery and no sign of creep or stress relaxation after an imposed change for periods longer than 1 sec (Weis-Fogh, 1961a). It is not known how quickly equilibrium is attained but it must be within the range of milliseconds. A dragonfly tendon may be extended to twice its length under a constant load for months
SVEND OLAV ANDERSEN A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH 22 on end without any change of length and it witl snap back to its unstrained length and properties immediately the load is removed. No other biological material is known to be as perfect with respect to elasticity. The ‘fibrous nature of elastin ligaments makes similar tests difficult. The full recovery of locust resilin is also apparent in the composite cuticle of the prealar arm (Fig. 11). In contrast to solid cuticle, the prealar arm does not experience any permanent deformation or change in stiffness although the recovery is slower than in pure resilin. This is attributed to the presence of chitin lamellae made up of a feltlike entanglement of fibrils which can slide relative to each other but which are brought back eventually by the stress set up in the neighbouring resilin (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962).
I
0
I
I
20
I
1
I
40
I
60
I
I
80
I
I
100
Time (mid
FIG.11. The angular deflection of a prealar arm (&-) 88 a function of the duration of the load (minutes).Note the full elastic recovery. (From Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962.)
When a rubber is used for mechanical springs in a dynamic system, its fitness can be expressed in terms of damping, i.e. the amount of energy lost as heat in proportion to the amount of energy stored during the deformation and later released as mechanical work. At very low frequencies of deformation, the “ static” experiments just described show that the loss is zero but, as in all rubbers, it increases with the speed of deformation. In the experiments illustrated in Fig. 1, the Wings were suddenly lifted up from the resting position (A) to the upper position and the amount of energy fed into the system was measured. At the top, the mutilated wing (to reduce air resistance) With an artificial mass attached was immediately released and the kinetic energy estimated
23
RESILIN
during the recoil downstroke. The ratio between the kinetic energy and the spent energy is the elastic efficiencyr] of the system. It is a measure similar to the so-called resilience in rubber technology. We may call (1 -7) the loss factor. It can be seen from Table I11 (Weis-Fogh, unTABLE 111 Elastic efficiency of locust thorax at normal conditions of work Intact thorax Empty box Elastic hinges Non-active muscle
0.86 0.02 0.88f 0.02 097 f 002 0.8 f0.2
published) that the intact complex thorax has an elastic efficiency corresponding to the resilience of most rubbers (Buist, 1961) but the complicated rubberlike wing-hinge ligaments have an efficiency as high as 0-97 under normal conditions of operation at 20 c/s. This shows that resilin itself exhibits less damping than other known elastomers. It has
Fnqurmy of altemting rtroln
(a
FIG.12. The elastic loss factor in the prealar arm as a function of the frequency of the sinusiodal strain (c/s). at two different amplitudes (010 and 005 mm). (From Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962.)
not been possible as yet to measure 7 in the elastic tendon but only in the isolated preaiar arm of locusts. The results are seen in Fig. 12 (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962). The sample was strained sinusoidalIy and the stress was measured in phase and 90" out of phase with the displacement at two different amplitudes. The biological range of
24
S V E N D OLAV ANDERSEN A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
frequency and deformation is indicated and it is seen that the loss factor is as small as that found in the wing-hinge (2-479, in spite of the fact that the uveruge speed of deformation of the resilin was about 6 lengths per sec when averaged over the entire content and during one complete cycle. In order to compare these low values for the damping with recently published figures for carefully vulcanized natural rubber (Gent, 1962), the ratio FJF, of the imaginary component Fi of the oscillating stress and the real component F, has been plotted as a function of the logarithm of the frequency in Fig. 13. Gent’s results for 0.1 c/s are indicated, sample (A) having the highest cross-link density and (C) the smallest
Frequency (ch)
FIG.13. The same data as in Fig. 12. The ordinate is theratiobetween the imaginary and the real component of the oscillating force (F,/F,) and the abscissa the logarithm of the frequency (log c/s). Gent’s (1 962)results with rubber vulcanizates are shown at the extreme left.
(M,from about 4 0oO in (A) to 10 OOO in (C);Gent, personal communication). Unfortunately there are no values for frequencies higher than 0.1 c/s but it is seen (a) that the damping or the loss factor for natural rubber is significantly higher than for swollen resilin at similar frequencies, and (b) that an increased degree of cross-linking has a tendency to decrease the damping. It will be shown below that the average molecular weight of the chains between junction points, M,, is of the same order of magnitude in sample (A) as in resilin so that the results should be comparable. In spite of being a polyamide with bulky side groups and many potential sites for the formation of hydrogen bonds, swollen resilin
RESILIN
25
behaves as a more ideal rubber than other natural or synthetic materials as far as clastic recovery and damping are concerned. It is not known
how good elastin is in thcsc respects but the results emphasize the desirability of more detailed investigations of this protein and similar polyamides both from a theoretical and from a technological point of view.
3. Thermoelasticity Since the elastic force of a strained ideal rubber is due entirely to thermal agitation of the individual members which make up the flexible chains, in the same way as the pressure of a gas is due to the movements
O
1.0
l
Egtenrion ratio pc
FIG.14. The force-extension diagram of an elastic tendon measured at high and low temperature. (From Weis-Fogh, 1961a.)
of its molecules, the elastic force at a given strain willincrease in proportion to the absolute temperature. No material complies completely with this requirement because, ultimately, the stresses must be borne by the chains and must therefore affect their internal energy. Moreover, in concentrated materials like rubbers there will be some weak forces between the chains or between the groups inside the chain. Nevertheless,
26
S V i NI) 0 1 A V A N I ) L R S t N A N D ’ I O R K C I , W E I S - F O G H
a typical rubber can be shown to behave almost like such an entropy system provided it is not extcnded so much that crystallization begins to occur. All quantitative molecular theories of rubberlike elasticity are based upon this fundamental property which distinguishes rubber from other solids whose elastic behaviour is dominated by changes in internal energy. It is, therefore, important that it has now been shown beyond doubt that both elastin (Hoeve and Flory, 1958) and resilin (Weis-Fogh, 1961a)behave like true rubbers in the thermodynamic sense. The theoretical and experimental difiiculties are due to the fact that both proteins
t
I S 2 (1.19)
<--%--<->-<--------3--
0
+--<--->
>-
1
I
300
320 Temperature
340
360
(OK)
FIG.15. The isometric force of an elastic tendon at different degrees of extension as a function of the absolute temperature. (From Weis-Fogh, 1961a.)
are swollen so that the experimental system is an open one. The fact that the swelling depends on temperature was overlooked by previous investigators on elastin, supercontracted collagen and keratin, but was realized and overcome independently by the above authors. Fig. 14 shows the relationship between the force of an elastic tendon and the degree of stretch expressed as the extension ratio a, i.e. the length in units of the unstrained dry length. The tendon was placed in unbuffered
RESILIN
27
water and it can be seen that it swells slightly when the temperature is increased. Nevertheless, the slope increases with temperature. In the case of elastin placed in a mixture of glycol and water where changes in swelling do not occur, Hoeve and Flory (1958) found a similar increase, the magnitude of which corresponded to theoretical predictions based upon an entropy model. The only deviation concerns the shape of the formextension curve which was linear in elastin in contrast to that of Extension mtio A
Extension ratio Q
no.16. The forceatension
curve of an elastic tendon resolved into its two components, the entropy term and the internal energy term. (From Weis-Fogh, 1961a.)
resilin and other rubbers, but this is probably due to the fact that the elastin preparation consisted of many parallel fibres at different degrees of stretch. However, this fact makes further interpretations difficult. When an elastic tendon was placed in a dilute buffer in which the changes in swelling with temperature are insignificant, it was found that the isometric force (constant length) increased linearly with the absolute temperature over a wide range of extensions and temperatures (Fig. 15), so that the non-linear force-extension curve in Fig. 16 could be resolved into the two components in the Wiegand-Snyder equation, an inkrnal
28
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
encrgy term and an entropy term (Weis-Fogh, 1961a). It is secn that the shape of the curve is dominated by thc latter over the entire range of extension. There is therefore no doubt that both proteins must be considered true rubbers, as was alrcady claimed for elastin by Meyer and Ferri (1936) on the basis of unconvincing thermoelastic measurements. Whereas the complicated structure of elastin preparations prevent us from going much further, the dragonfly tendon iends itself to more detailed investigations of the only other rubberlike protein known. B. M O L E C U L A R I N T E R P R E T A T I O N
The following discussion is based on Weis-Fogh (1961b). The exact quantitative formulation of the kinetic theory of rubberlike behaviour r
I
4-
Compression
1-
-
h
-
h
Y
; o
I
0
-
-
-
-
c
-u .n c 2
-2
-
-4
0.5
1.o
I
I
1.5
20
25
Extension ratio A
Fro. 17. The relationship between the elastic force of tendon milin and the degree of simple compression or extension. The experimental points and the sequence of measurements are indicated. The smooth curve is drawn according to the simple kinetic theory of rubberlike elasticity (long-chain networks). (From Weis-Fogh, 1961b.)
depends on the assumption made about the properties of the network. If the number of random links in a chain between two junction points is large, the theoretically calculated force increases with extension but
RESILIN
29
with monotonic decreasing slope, as is seen from the unbroken curve in Fig. 17. It has the following form (with slight variations):
I; = NkTY'(X - h-*)
=
N~T(uv'- c'v-'),
wheref, is the force per unit unstrained swollen area, N is the number of chains per unit volume, k is Boltzmann's constant, T is the absolute temperature, Y is the volume fraction and is the ratio between the unswollen and the swollen volume, h is the extension ratio in units of the unstrained swollen length, and (L the extension ratio in units of the unstrained dry length. The product NkT is called the elastic modulus G and depends on the degree of cross-linking, G = pRT/M,, where p is the density of the unswollen material, R the gas constant and M, the number-averagemolecular weight of the chains between junction points. It is seen that an estimation of G gives information about the degree of cross-linking and therefore of M,. It is also seen that if the swelling is isotropic and does not alter the state of the chains, it influences only the geometrical parameter Y so that, if it is known for a single stress-strain diagram, the elastic behaviour can be predicted for any value of v. Similar relationships hold for the photoelastic properties.
1. Cross-links and chain flexibility Figure 17 also shows that the mechanical behaviour of tendon resilin only follows the simple theory up to a certain extension, after which the force increases more steeply than predicted. This is typical of short-chain networks, both in theory and in practice, when the number n of random links per chain decreases. The smaller n is, the steeper the curve becomes but the slope near to the unstrained length is altered only to a small extent. It is, therefore, possible to obtain information both about the number of cross-links and about the flexibility, provided that a suitable specific network model is applied for the latter estimates. In the case of resilin, Treloar's (1954) model of a short-chain network with non-affine displacementhas been adopted since it presupposes that four chains meet at each junction point and that the chains are of about equal length. This would not apply to a rubber vulcanized by some random bulk process, but as we shall see in Section IV,D, the majority of the cross-links are of this type in resilin. Moreover, its very high elastic efficiency points towards the cross-links being introduced at regular distances and not in a random way. The average modulus for tendon resilin thus estimated is 6-7 kg cm-% (against 9 kg cm-2 in locust resilin; Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962), corresponding to Me-5 OOO, so that there are about 60 amino acid
S V E N D OLAV A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH 30 residues between junction points. As to the flexibility of these chains, the shape of the measured curves indicates that there are more than 5 and less than 25 random links per chain, say about 15. Since it takes at least 3-4 actual links with free rotation to make up for one (ideal) random link, it is seen that there must be about as many links with rotation as there 8 f e amino acid residues in a chain. This means that there can be almost no hydrogen bonds present between any two members of a chain b u s e
I v = 0.52
I
Extension ratio QI
Fro. 18. The relationship between the stress (kg/cml swollen strainod araa) and the extension in a dragonfly tendon swollen at pH 1.8 (v = 0.52), pH 6 7 (v = 0.38) and pH 1 2 3 (v = 0.19). "he smoothcwt8are drawn aocordinoto the simple theory. (From Weis-Po&, 1961b.)
even a few bonds would stiffen that part of the chain lying between the groups which react with each other. The conclusionthen is that the amino acid sequence of the resilin chains is such that intrachain hydrogen bonding is prevented, at least in neutral water. We shall now see that this must also be the case under other conditions of pH and temperature. The evidence derives both from swelling experiments and from photoelastic measurements. Fig. 18 shows that differences
RESILIN
31
in swelling caused by varying pH from 1.8 to 12.3 did not change the initial course in any other way than that predicted from the equation on p. 29. In other words, while v had been altered 2.7 times other parameters had not changed. Similarly, the initial slope of the stress birefringence curves (Fig. 19) remained the same so that the drastic variations in pH had no effect upon the state of the chains, as would have been the case if hydrogen bonds had been formed or broken. The same applies to the effect of increasing temperature on the stress-optical ratio (1.3 x lo-' cm*kg-'
Stress t, (kg/crn'j
FIG. 19. Three stress-birefringence curves from a dragonfly tendon at the same degrees of swelling as in Fig. 18. Each curve is displaced one unit along the ordinate in order to avoid coincidence, the birefringenceof unstrained resilin being zero at all degrees of swelling. (From Weis-Fogh, 1961b.)
at room temperature; for detailed discussion, see Weis-Fogh, 1961b). The photoelastic measurements also confirmed that the number of random links per chain must be somewhere between 5 and 25 (Fig. 20). It is interesting to note that the curve is non-linear and of the shape predicted for the model adopted by Treloar (1 954). Measurements on short-chain natural and synthetic rubbers have resulted in straight lines (Saunders,
32
S V ~ N L )O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L W E I S - F O G H
1956r1, b) but this is probably due to random cross-linking and, again, it points towards resilin being cross-linked at regular intervals.
I
I
I
I
5
10
IS
20
Stress. t,v-2b/G
FIG. 20. The stress-birefringence of dragonfly resilin as compared with that of t w o short-chain networks. (From Weis-Fogh, 1961b.)
2. Sfructurc We have already seen that electron micrographs fail to demonstrate any structure in resilin whatsoever. It was thought that extensive stretching and slow drying would produce some crystallinity in the dragonfly tendon but the best X-ray evidence available is completely negative on this point. Both in relaxed and in highly extended dry tendons, there is no indication of chains being able to take up any regular secondary structure, neither at low-angle nor wide-angle diffraction (Elliott et a!., 1964). Apart from a diffuse ring corresponding to about 4 A at all lengths, there are a pair of equatorial spots in the most extended specimens, corresponding to a spacing between longitudinally oriented parts of the
33
RESI LI N
chains of about 4.5 A. It must bc concluded that the hydrogen bonds formed during drying are located at random and that this protein cannot click into any secondary structure, a result in full agreement with its exceptionally good qualities as a rubber. Since resilin has a characteristic and specific amino acid composition, we must assume that its primary structure, i.e. the sequence of residues, is specific. Its secondary structure is the randomly kinked configuration (if one prefers to call it so) and the cross-links represent the tertiary structure and give it the character of a giant network, or a giant molecule, which may extend in all directions of space like a cross-linked resin.
Iv.
C H E M I C A L P R O P E R T I E S OF
RESILIN
The main features of amino acid composition are the same in the different members of a group of proteins but there may be differences as to detail, depending upon the source from which the protein has been isolated. All collagens, for instance, have a high content of glycyl and prolyl and contain two unusual amino acid residues, hydroxyprolyl and hydroxylysyl, the relative amounts of which may vary appreciably (cf. Gustavson, 1956). We must therefore expect that resilin from different systematic groups will differ to some extent, so that we are dealing not with a single compound but with a group ofclosely related proteins. A . A M I N O A C I D COMPOSITION
The only quantitative analyses made so far have been performed on material isolated from two sources i n the desert locust (Schistocerca gregurin), the prealar arm and the main wing-hinge. Bailey and Weis-Fogh (1961) found no significant differences between these samples so that their results have been pooled and averaged in Table IV in which similar figures are presented for bovine elastin. It is obvious that the gross composition of resilin is quite difTerent from that of other structural proteins, although it bears some resemblance to the collagens, without containing any hydroxyprolyl or hydroxylysyl, however. The amount of glycyl residues is particularly high in resilin (38 out of 100) and the other prominent ones are alanyl ( I l ) , aspartyl (lo), seryl (8) and prolyl (7-6). The complete absence of sulphur-containing residues and of tryptophyl is noticeable and it is important that 34% of the side chains carry hydrophilic polar groups, in contrast to 5 in elastin. The number of asprtrtyl and glutamyl residues carrying amide groups in resilin was calculated to about 120 per 105 g resilin, but this number cannot be very
TABLE IV Amino acid composition of resilin (averaged from Bailey and Weis-Fogh, 1961) compared with that of elastin (averaged from Partridge, 1962) Resilin from locust ligaments residues per residues per 105 g protein 100 residues
Elastin from bovine ligamentum nuchae residues per residues per 10s g protein 100 residues ~-
____.____ ~
Glycine Alanine Valine Leucine Isoleucine Proline Phenylalanine Methionine Serine Threonine Hydroxyproline Tyrosine Aspartic acid Glutamic acid Lysine Histidine Arginine Fluorescent Compound I Fluorescent Compound I1 Total Average residue weight
437 I 26 32 26 19
88 29 Nil 91 35 Nil 31 116 53 6 10
37.9 10.9 2.8 2.3 1.6 7.6 2.5
-
7.9 3.0
-
2.7 1 01
4.6 0 5
09
40
3.5
4 9
0.3
1152 86.8
0.8
99.9
356 239 151 69 29 117 38 Trace 9 9 12 8 8 16
33.2 22.3 14.1 6.4 2.1 10.9 3.5
-
0.8
0-8 1.1 0.7 0.7 I .5 4 0.4 0.6 0.1 7 0.7 Small unknown amounts of fluorescent compounds (Partridge, 1962; Loomeijer, 1961) 1073 99.9 93.2
w
P
RESILIN
35
precise (Bailey and Weis-Fogh, 1961). In addition to the usual amino acids, later analyses disclosed the presence of small amounts of two new amino acids in a full hydrolyzate of resilin, the fluorescent Compounds I and I1 listed at the bottom of column I (Andersen, 1961, 1963). They were not noticed in the quantitative assay because they are strongly adsorbed to the ion exchange material used (Amberlite CG 120). Their properties and their role as cross-linking agents will be discussed in a separate section. The amino acid composition of resilin from dragonflies and from crayfish has been estimated by paper chromatography and we can only state here that they exhibit all the main features of locust resilin, including the presence of the two fluorescent amino acids. The latter compounds are also present in the other resilin samples where we have looked for them (see Table 11) but they have not been found in any part of any arthropod cuticle where the presence of resilin could not be detected by other means. This strongly indicates that the fluorescent amino acids are specific for resilin, but it may of course be that they will be found in some structural proteins which, for other reasons, cannot be classified as resilin. A more extensive search is obviously needed. It appears from Table IV that resilin resembles elastin in having a high content of glycyl, alanyl and prolyl but otherwise they differ in most other respects. It has already been mentioned that resilin has a high proportion of residues with polar side chains whereas elastin has an unusually small amount. Nevertheless, they are both rubberlike and have very similar physical properties. The scarcity of polar groups in elastin has been considered essential for its rubberlike properties (Lloyd and Garrod, 1946; Kendrew, 1954) but since such groups are abundant in resilin, their absence cannot be very important in this respect. Purified elastin preparations are faintly yellow and show fluorescence in UV-light, and several attempts have been made to isolate and characterize the compounds responsible for these properties. Loomeijer (1958) hydrolyzed elastin with papain and found that in thedigest the fluorescent component is strongly bound to peptide material. A similar conclusion has been reached by LaBella (1961) who used pancreatic elastase. Even after prolonged digestion most of the fluorescencewas found to be bound to non-dialyzable peptides. He therefore suggested that the fluorescent component is involved in the cross-linking of the peptide chains. Partridge at al. (1963) have recently succeeded in isolating a fluorescent yellow peptide which per mole contains two different NH,-terminal residues. From this peptide an U V-absorbing component was isolated after strong acid hydrolysis and found to consist of two closely related
36
S V E N U OLAV A N D E R S E N A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
compounds each containing a heterocyclic nucleus, four amino groups and four carboxylic groups. The strong hydrolysis destroyed the yellow colour and may therefore have changed the structure to some unknown extent in contrast to the fluorescent compounds in resilin. The results obtained by Partridge and his collaborators are in strong contrast to the findings of Loomeijer (1961) who concludes that the fluorescent components are lipids with an aliphatic structure, and probably containing a carbonyl group. Although there is some disagreement about the nature of the fluorescent components in elastin, it is reasonable to assume that they act as cross-links between the peptidechains. As will beseenlater, the fluorescent compounds isolated from resilin are distinctly different from those in elastin, but the function of both types may well be the same. €3. S W E L L I N G I N D I F F E R E N T
MEDIA
Resilin is only rubberlike when swollen, i.e. a liquid must be present which solvates the peptide chains and breaks the secondary bonds so that the chains become flexible and free of each other (Weis-Fogh, 1960). It is therefore of interest to investigate the swelling properties since it may offer some information about the chains once the solubility of proteins in anhydrous media becomes better understood (Singer, 1962). We have therefore re-investigated the problem. 1. Swcllitig in aqireoirs media
Although resilin does not dissolve, it swells strongly in water and in water-containing media, and the degree of swelling depends on the pH, as one should expect from the high content of different acid and basic groups which dissociate over a wide range of pH: the carboxyl groups (end groups, non-amidized groups in aspartyl and glutamyl) at pH 2-5, the imidazol group in histidyl at pH 6-7, phenolic groups in the fluorescent Compounds I and I 1 about pH 7, the amino groups (end groups, r-groups in lysyl) at pH 8-9, the phenol group in tyrosyl at pH 10, and the guanidino group in arginyl at pH 11-13. In accordance with the spccttum of pK values, the relative volume of small pieces of native dragonfly rcsilin varies almost smoothly with the pH of the dilute buffers with which they were brought into equilibrium, with a minimum at the isoelectric point about pH 4 (Fig. 21A). It is also understandable that treatments which aimed at blocking the free amino groups have relatively little effect since they are rather few compared with the other protolytic groups, but the shoulder seen at about pH 8-9 in samples treated with
37
RESILIN
dinitrofluorobenzene(FDNB),nitrous acid or benzoquinone is probably due toancliminationofthefreeaminogroups(Fig.21B-D).The blocking experiments are not quite specific, however, and give rise to the following comments. The piece which was treated with FDNB deviated most from the native sample. It had a strong yellow colour and from comparison with similarly treated locust resilin (Andersen, 1963) it can be concluded that both the amino groups and the phenolic groups in tyrosyl residues and in the fluorescent compounds had reacted. Since, moreover, a rather large
1
0
I
I
2
I
I
4
I
I
I
6
I
8
I
I
10
I
I
12
PH
FIG. 21. Swelling of native and modified resilin from Aeshna grandis tendons in dilute buffers at room temperature. The volume is relative to the air-dried samples. (A) Native tendon; (B) tendon treated with dinitrofluorobenzene; (C)tendon treated with nitrous acid, and (D) tendon treated with benzoquinone. (A) and (D) a n the average of two determinations. (B)and ( C ) are single determinations.
hydrop,hobic group has been introduced, the modified protein has become less hydrophilic at all pH values, but it is still rubberlike although it was rather slow in reaching its equilibrium length after a deformation. Tendons treated kith nitrous acid at pH 4 and room temperature became dark red-brown which indicates that the aromatic residues have becn affected besides the transformation of free amino groups into alcohol groups. Apart from the “shoulder”, the swelling behaviour and the elastic properties were unchanged in this case. Treatment of the tendons with benzoquinone was also without any pronounced effects. There is a decrease in the swelling which is more
38
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
pronounced on the acid side ofthe isoelectric point than on the alkaline side. Similar results were found when pieces cut out from locust prealar arms were treated with benzoquinone. This makes it rather difficult to explain the increase in stiffnessobserved in the prealar arm of locusts after treatment with benzoquinone. It was supposed to be due to a change in the isoelectric point combined with an increased swelling at high pHvalues (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962). It should be remembered that resilin is rubberlike at all pH-values, also at the isoelectric point, so that electrostatic forces cannot be responsible for this property (Weis-Fogh, 1960). This result is corroborated by experiments with water-free media. 2. Swelling in non-aqueous media Resilin is able to swell in many anhydrous solvents which shows that the polypeptide chains have a tendency to dissolve but are prevented from doing so by the cross-links. In agreement with this, most of the solvents which cause resilin to swell can be used as solvents for other proteins. In Table V the different solvents used are listed in two groups, strongly protic and weakly protic (Singer, 1962), and the solubility of the solvents in water are given in the last column. The samples used in Table V were pieces of pure dragonfly resilin which were air-dried before being placed in the solvent. In some (formic acid, formamide), they became fully swollen in the course of a few minutes even at room temperature. In other solvents, the process is much slower and heating to 60-70°C may be necessary (propyleneglycol, glycerol) but they remain swollen also at room temperature. The solvents which are solid at 20°C (trichloracetic acid, acetamide, phenol) were used a few degrees above their melting points. Whether or not resilin swells in a given solvent obviously depends on the combined effect of different factors. In a strongly protic solvent, the protein chains carry a surplus of either positive or negative charges and they will therefore repulse each other, in this way making the swelling more easy. Corresponding to this, most of such solvents turned out to be rather good swelling agents for resilin, acid solvents being better than alkaline ones, but neither diethylamine nor triethylamine caused any swelling. It should be mentioned that concentrated sulphuric acid (98 %) swells resilin strongly and makes it rubbery until it finally degrades. In the weakly protic media, the protein will be near its isoelectric point so that, on average, the chains have no charge. Nevertheless, it is seen that many of them are equally good or better swelling agents than water. The rubberiness does not depend on electrostatic forces but on other
TABLE V Swelling of small pieces of dragonfly resilin in non-aqueous solvents Solvent strongly protic
Formic acid Acetic acid Dichloracetic acid Trichloracttic acid Phenol O-CrcsOl m-crcsOl Diethylamine Triethylamine Ethanolamine E t h y h diamine Fyridine
g solvent soluble in 100 ml water at Swelling of resilin temperature indicated
++ ++ + + ++ (+) (+)
Nil Nil
++ ++
W
03
8-63 120 (25°C) 6.7 (r6"C) 3.1 (40°C) 2-35 (20°C) 81-5 1-5 (20°C) 00 00
(+i
+ + Rcsilin smlls considerably more than it does in neutral water.
Solvent weakly protic
g solvent soluble in Swelling 100 ml water at of resilin temperature indicated
Methanol Ethanol 2-Methox yethanol 2-Chlorethanol Tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol Ethylene glycol Propylene glycol Glycerol Forrnamide Dimethylf'ormamide Acetamide Chloracctamide Tetrahydrofuran Dioxan Diethylether Acetone Dimethylsulphoxid
+ Swelling is similarto that in water. (+I The pica btcomes plasticized and can be deformated but docs not return to its former shape.
Nil: 'flu piece remains hard and brittk.
Nil Nil Nil
(+I Nil
+ + + ++ + ++ + Nil Nil Nil Nil
+
dD W
m
co 00 00
97.5 (20°C) 10 (24OC)
Very soluble 00
7-5 (20°C) 00
soluble
40
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T U R K E L WEIS-FOGIf
forccs active between solvent and protein chains. They may dcpend on the specific amino acid sequence and on the location of the cross-links in the chains. This makes it difficult to predict which solvents will be effective for the swelling, but some general features can be seen from Table V. Monovalent alcohols are very poor swelling agents while di- and polyvalent alcohols act well, as do amides and substituted amides. It is of interest that phenol is much more effective than are alcohols and this can hardly be due to phenol being a stronger protic solvent since the cresols are rather poor swelling agents. Like the amides, the phenol molecule seems to fit into the peptide structure (Gustavson, 1956). C. ENZYMIC H Y D R O L Y S I S
Conflicting reports have been published concerning the digestibility of elastin by proteolytic enzymes. It may be due both to impure enzyme preparations and to slight degradation of the elastin preparations used.
Hwrs
FIG.22. Digestion of 10 mg locust resilin by 3 mgsubtilisin in 3 mI 0-2M phosphate buffer, pH 8.0 at 30°C. At intervals samples were withdrawn and the absorption was measured at 280 mp at acid reaction ( x 1 and at 320 mp at alkaline reaction( 0 ) . The measurements were corrected for the absorption due to subtilisin and for the volume changes. The fluorescence (+) was measured at alkaline reaction with activation at 320 mp.
Thus, undegraded elastin cannot be attacked by pure trypsin but when it has been brought into solution by means of elastases, trypsin can split it further down (LaBella, 1961). This shows that bonds are present in elastin which can be split by trypsin but that they are inaccessible in the
R ESI LI N
41
undcgradcd protein. The enzymes from pancreatic juice which readily digest ciastin (elastases) also attack other proteins and are therefore not spccific, but a bactcrial enzyme which is specific has now been isolated from Fkrvoharw-ium elnsrolyticum (Mandl and Cohen, 1960). In contrast to elastin, resilin is readily digested by all proteases investigated so far ( Weis-Fogh, 1960). The list now includes trypsin, chymotrypsin, pepsin, papain, subtilisin, and pancreatic elastase. This difference between the two elastic proteins can be due both to the presence in resilin of more peptide bonds conforming to the specificity of the enzymes in question and to a higher degree of accessibility of the sites. Figure 22 shows the time course of the digestion of resilin with the bacterial protease subtilisin. Samples were withdrawn at intervals and the UV-absorption measured at acid and alkaline reaction. The fluorescence was measured after dilution of the alkaline samples. In spite of the fact that resiiin is present in small lumps which must be attacked from the outside, the digestion is surprisingly rapid. The curve for the absorption at 320 mp in alkaline solution is a measure of the liberation of the fluorescent compounds, whereas the curve for the acid samples measures the fluorescent compounds and tyrosyl residues together. It is seen that the tyrosyl and the fluorescent compounds are liberated at equal rates during the entire period of digestion, and that there is no lag-period in the beginning. This is also the case when other proteases are used and it is therefore clear that fluorescent peptides are being liberated at maximum rate right from the beginning of hydrolysis. In elastin there is a marked lag-phase at the beginning of the digestion. D. FLUORESCENT A M I N O ACIDS
1. Properties and isolation As has been mentioned several times, resilin contains two fluorescent
amino acids not present in other proteins. Their structure is not known in detail as yet but there is a large amount of evidence which indicates that they function as cross-links between the protein chains. They were first discovered as two fluorescent spots on paper chromatograms of resilin hydrolyzate and from their position on the chromatogram they were named Compounds I and 11, Compound I having the smallest Rf value. Later work has shown that this numbering can be a little troublesome, since Compound I1 is the main substance and has the simplest structure (Andersen, 1961, 1963). Both compounds react as a-amino acids and have characteristic absorption and activation spectra (Figs. 23 and 24) which closely resemble
42
SVEND O L A V ANDERSEN A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
miil
w
B FIG.23. (A) UV-absorption spectra for Compound I in (1) acid solution and (2) alkaline solution. (B) Same for Compound II. (From Andemen, 1963.) A
m/l Fig. 24. Activation spectra (uncorrected) for Compound I at pH 8 Compound I1 at pH 1 1 (0). (From Andersen, 1963.)
( 0 ) and
for
RESILIN
43
PH FIG.25. (A) pH-dependence of the fluorescence of Compound I when activated at 285 mp ( c ) , at 325 mp (01, and at 325 mp after blocking the amino groups with methoxycarbonylchloride (+ ). (B) Same for Compound 11. (From Andersen, 1963.)
FIG.26. Separation of Compounds I and I1 on celldosephosphate (1 x 40 cm)at room temperature. The column was equilibrated with 0.2 M acetic acid and elution was perfoxled by a sodiumchloride gradient established by running 500 mll M NaCl into 300 rill 0.2 M acetic acid. Ordinate, left hand side: Absorbancy at 280 mp,right hand side: Conductivity of effluent (lo-' Q-1).
44
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
those of tyrosine, indicating that they are phenols, but the shift from the acid to the alkaline form of the spectra of Compounds I and I1 occurs near pH 7 (Fig. 25), in contrast to tyrosine where it occurs at about pH 10. The phenciic character of the compounds is confirmed by their ability to coople with diazotized sulphanilic acid, to give colour reaction with Folin’s rcagent for phenols and with nitrosonaphthol. They give no colour with Gibb’s reagent so that the para-position to the phenolic group seems to be blocked (Fearon, 1944). Tests for polyphenols were negative.
mP
FIG.27. Spectra of the fluorescent light emitted from alkaline solutions of Compound I (0) and Compound 11 ( C J ) and from pieces of native resilin (+). In all cases activation was performed at 253.7 mp.(From Andersen, 1963.)
The two compounds can be separated from each other and from the other amino acids present in a resilin hydrolyzate by means of paper chromatography, but for larger amounts it is necessary to use column chromatography on ion-exchange material. Originally Andersen (1 963) used DEAE-cellulose but later he has got more reproducible results with the following method based on cellulosephosphate (Fig. 26). This ion exchanger is brought in equilibrium with dilute acetic acid and the resilin hydrolyzate i s placed on the column in acid solution. The amino acids are elutcd from the column by using a salt-gradient whereby the monoamino acids are eluted first, followed by the basic amino acids, and close
RESILIN
45
to them, Compound I€,while Compound I comes later and well separated from the other amino acids. After Compound I a minor peak is seen which apparently represents a third fluorescent compound of the Same family. Before discussing the possible function of these compounds in resilin, it is important to ascertain whether they occur in the unmodified protein or are artifacts produced during the hydrolysis. All evidence shows that they are present in native resilin, linked to the other amino acids by means of normal pcptide links which became broken during the hydrolysis. The
I't
FIG. 28. pH-dependence of the fluorescence of an enzymic digest of redin, ( x ) when activated at 285 mp,(c) when activated at 320 mp.
best evidence is that (1) the spectrum of the fluorescent light emitted from whole pieces of resilin is identical with the fluorescent spectra of the isolated compounds (Fig. 27) ;(2) the fluorescent peptides released during enzymic digestion have absorption and activation spectra closely resembling those of the isolated compounds and with the same pHdependence (Fig. 28) (Anderscn, unpublished); (3) alkaline hydrolysis liberates the same two fluorescent compounds as does acid hydrolysis (Andersen, 1963). 2. Number of albhatic chains Titration of the isolated compounds shows that both of them contain groups Cissociating near pH 2, 7, and 10; in Compound I1 their relative numbers are 2: 1 :2, while they are 3: 1 :3 in Compound I (Andersen, 1963). The groups which dissociate near pH 2 can be assumed to be carboxyiic and those dissociating near pH 10 to be amino groups. Those which dissociate near neutrality must be identical with the groups
46
SVEND OLAV ANDERSEN A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
responsible for the shift in the absorption spectra and in fluorescence. They are tentatively identified as being phenolic. The relative numbers of the groups strongly indicate that Compound I1 is a dicarboxylic diamino acid, and that Compound I is a tricarboxylic triamino acid. This result is confirmed by experiments with partial dinitrophenylation (Andersen, 1963). When Compound I1 had reacted with FDNB under controlled conditions, the reaction mixture could be separated in three
cm
Fro. 29. Paper electrophoretic separation of the reaction mixtures from partial dinitrophenylation of Compound II (A) and of Compound I 03).The fully drawn lines show the light absorption at 420 mp, and the broken lines show the fluorescence when activation is performed at 285 mp. (From Andersen, 1963.)
components by paper electrophoresis in acid medium (Fig. 29). One of them corresponded to the unmodified fluorescent compound, one reacted as if all amino groups had been blocked, and the third migrated with half the velocity of the unmodified compound, it was yellow but ninhydrinpositive so that one of the amino groups appeared to have become dinitrophenylated but the other was free. For Compound I, the number of reaction products corresponded to the presence of three amino groups since two partially and one fully dinitrophenylated compounds were found. From these results combined with the titration experiments, the molar
RESfLIN
47
absorption coefficient at the wavelength for maximum absorption was calculated to 8 OOO for Compound I and 5 400 for Compound 11. By measuring both the UV absorption and the ninhydrin colour yield of a sample of pure compound, the molar ninhydrin colour yield can be calculated and compared with the yield of some standard substance. Different &-aminoacids have almost the same colour yield in this modification o f t e ninhydrin method (Rosen, 1957). Whenisoleucine was used for compa ison, it was found that Compound I1 reacted as if it contains 1.9 amiris groups per molecule and Compound I 2.6 amino groups, confirming the conclusion that I1 contains 2 and I 3 amino groups (Andersen, unpublished).
!
3. Precursors of fluorescent amino acids In an attempt to get some information about the aromatic nucleus in the fluorescent compounds, we have recently injected immature adult locusts with tyrosine or phenylalanine uniformly labelled with '4c and afterwards isolated the fluorescent compounds and tyrosine from the resilin (Andersen and Kristensen, 1963).The two fluorescent compounds became rzdioactive both with phenylalanine and with tyrosine as precursors so that either of these can be used for the biosynthesis. Also, the relative distribution of the radioactivity between the fluorescent compounds on the one side and tyrosine on the other was independent of whether the parent compound was tyrosine or phenylalanine, so that the synthesis from phenylalanine seems to take place with tyrosine as an intermediate: Phenylalanine -+tyrosine -*Compounds I and 11.
The specific activity of the isolated fluorescent compounds, expressed as counts/min/pmole, was surprisingly high as compared with that of the isolated tyrosine. For Compound I1 it was about three times higher and for Compound I about six times higher than for tyrosine. This was true whether the precursor was given as a single largeinjection or as many small injections spread out over the whole period of resilin deposition (i.e. in the course of 10-14 days). As there seems to be no turnover of resilin when it has been laid down, it is very improbable that this relative enrichment of radioactivity in the fluorescent compounds is due to the existence of different tyrosine pools of which only one is mixed up with the injected tyrosine. A mcch more probable explanation is that Compound I1 is synthesized from three tyrosine molecules. Since the final compound contains two aliphatic chains, each with a carboxyl and an a-amino group, the third
48
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOCH
tyrosine molecule may have lost this chain during biosynthesis. The structure for Compound 11 may therefore be as follows:
CH- N I
H ~
CH-NH2
COOH
6OOH
It must be stressed, however, that we have no direct evidence for the presence of ether-bridges between the benzene rings other than the fact that the ccnriections between the rings must be very stable. Also, we have no reason for assuming that the free phenolic group is placed on the second ring. Moreover, this structure gives no explanation of the low pK-value of the phenolic group but it is useful as a working model. Preliminary determinations of the molecular weight do not disagree with the model According to the above suggestion, the more complicated Compound I should consist of about six benzene rings derived from tyrosine and contain three end chains. 4. Fluoresccnt amino acids as cross-links
Provided that the amino and the carboxyfic groups are built into the protein chahs by means of peptide links, the fluorescent amino acids are able to function as stable chemical cross-links, in the case of Compound I1 as follows: Compound I1 residue Ri --NH-JH-CO-~
_ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ Rz NH-CH-CO
j -NH-CH-co I RI
I
1
ci‘‘
-INH-CH-CO~-NH--CH-CO-
&-&--coII
I
I
___.__ I _ _ _ _ _ _
R4
Similarly, Compound I should be able to link three peptide chains together. To demonstrate the existence of such structures in the native protein it will be necessary to show (1) that neither the amino groups nor the carboxylic groups of the fluorescent compounds are free in the protein, (2) that they are connected to other amino acids through normal peptide links, and (3) that the aliphatic chains from one compound are built into two (three) different protein chains. We have some evidence bearing on the first point but none on the other two. In order to show that the amino groups of both compounds are
R ESI LI N
49
blocked in some way, native resilin was treated with FDNB and it was found that no N-DNP-derivatives of the fluorescent compounds were formed. The failure to react could be due to difficulties for the FDNB molecule to get access to the amino groups, but since all the r-amino groups of lysine and all the phenolic groups in tyrosine as well as in the fluorescent compounds themselves had reacted, this explanation seems unreasonable (Andersen, 1963). As FDNB reacts with phenolic groups, it was impossible to isolate unchanged fluorescent compounds from DNP-resilin. Ninhydrin will react with all free amino groups but should not affect other groups present. if, therefore, the amino groups of the fluorescent compounds are blocked in resilin, it should be possible to isolate the unmodified amino acids after treatment. This turned out to be the case. The ninhydrin colour yield corresponded to about 7 amino groups per 10s g protein, which agrees with about 6 +amino groups present in lysyl and a single NH,-terminal group. From hydrolyzates of ninhydrin-treated resilin, the two fluorescent amino acids could be isolated both by means of paper chromatography and column chromatography. The positions of the compounds had not been changed so their amino groups were intact and therefore not free in native resilin (Andersen, unpublished). It is possible to get some indirect information about the carboxylic groups in Compound I1 and the amino groups in Compound I. From the curves in Fig. 25 showing the pH-dependence of the fluorescence of the free compounds, it can be observed that for Compound I there is a decrease in fluorescence about pH 9 which is due apparently to the presence of a free amino group. Similarly, Compound I1 shows a decrease in fluorescence below pH 3 which could be due to a carboxylic group. The peptide mixture obtained by digesting resilin with proteases shows no decrease at pH 9 and only a very slight decrease below pH 3 in spite of the fact that there is a pronounced increase in fluorescence about pH 7 and some decrease above pH 12 (Fig. 28). This decrease is due to Compound I and its magnitude corresponds to the presence of about half as much Compound I as Compound I1 in locust resilin. The small difference in fluorescent behaviour between the peptides and the free compounds therefore indicate that, in the peptides, at least one amino group in Compound I and one carboxyiic group in Compound 11 arc blocked (Andersen, unpublished). Although all our evidence confirms that the fluorescent compounds are peptide-linked to other amino acids through all their end chains, we have no final proof. The best way to demonstrate it would be to isolate a single fluorescent peptide from an enzymic digest of resilin and show
50
SVEND O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D Y O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
that it ha5 two (three) NH,terminal residues and the same number of COOH-terminal residues. This would indicate that there is some sort of cross-link present in the peptide. Thereafter it should be possible to elucidate t k complete structure of the peptide. From elastin such a peptide has now been isolated (Partridge, 1962), and we have also tried to separate similar fluorescent peptides from resilin digests but, although we have got fractions very enriched as to fluorescence, we are not convinced that any of them consist of a single peptide. 5 . Degree of cross-linking Since the amount of the two fluorescent compounds can be measured by simple spectroscopic measurements, it should be possible to calculate how tightly cross-linked the protein is and compare the determination with the results from the physical measurements. We know that 10s g locust resiiin contains about 4 residues of Compound I and 9 residues of Compound I1 (Andersen, 1963). If the compounds are involved in the cross-linking in such a way that Compound I links three different chains together and Compound I1 two, the average molecular weight of that part of a peptide chain which is located between two neighbouring crosslinks will be 3 300. The average residue wcight of the amino acids in resilin is 87 so, according to this, there are 38 amino acid residues between two cross-links on the average. This result must be a minimum value since any defects in the cross-linking will give higher values for the average distance between cross-links. From the physical measurements it was estimated that there are about 60 amino acid residues between two junction points but these measurements wer:: performed on dragonfly tendons. Since the elastic modulus of locust resilin is about 30% higher than that of dragonflies (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962), the higher elastic modulus corresponds to about 40 amino acid residues between two cross-links in locust resilin. The agreement between the physical and chemical estimates of the crosslinking i s so close that there can hardly be room for many defects in the network, and it strongly indicates that the fluorescent amino acids do in fact act as cross-linking agents in the manner proposed here.
V. G E N E R ADISCUSSION L It has been stressed repeatedly that resilin shares many properties with elastin and these similarities will be treated first followed bya discussioii of problems related to insect cuticle.
RESILIN A. WHAT
51
MAKES A PROTEIN RUBBERLIKE?
Elastin and resilin are both isotropic three-dimensional networks of polypeptide chains held together by means of stable covalent crosslinks. Thsy are both hard, like resin or glass, when dry and become rubberlike when swollen so that the swelling agent must break the weak bonds which give the dry material its solid character. These bonds may be hydrogen bonds and salt linkages (both called secondary bonds in the following account). The problem is how the formation of secondary bonds is prevented when the chains are solvated, since helical chains due to intrachain hydrogen bonding and crystalline areas due to interchain bonding characterize most structural proteins, also in an aqueous environment at room temperature. Much of what follows is speculative but may hclp to guide further thinking. The fact that extended and slowly dried tendon resilin gives a diffuse X-ray diagram with no sign of crystallinity shows that neither the individud polypeptide chains nor the assembly of chains have any tendency to click into regular patterns (Elliott et al., 1964). The same applies to elastin (Cox and Little, 1961) and the conclusion is that the secondary bonds are formed at random. The explanation must be sought in the amino acid sequence which is not known for either of the two proteics, but one may obtain some useful information from Table VI in which the average composition of the chains between the cross-links is set out. In resilin we have seen that the number of junction points corresponds approximately to the number of cross-linking groups so that physical entanglements seem to be reduced in number compared with ordinary rubbers, and we shall also assume that this is the case in elastin. The density of cross-links in elastin has not been estimated as accurately (Partridge, 1962) and may well be somewhat less than indicated in the Table. First of all, it is seen that the number-average molecular weight of the chains M, is relatively small so that the rather bulky cross-linking groups may prevent contact between chains as well as intrachain bonding in their neighbourhood. Since, however, the chains are flexible, being randomly coiled and thermally agitated in the swollen state, the major part of the residues must have the ability to react with each other both within and between chains. As to reaction between chains, it can only be said that flexibility and agitation mean that all possible configurations of bond foimation pust occur so that it is the swelling agent which prevents their actual formation. As to intrachain bonding, the absence of regular order in the dried protein indicates that it is the amino acid
VI
N
TABLE VI Tentative description of the amino acid composition of thz chains between the chemical cross-lin!ts and between the prolyl residues, respectively, ill tesilin arid elastin
--$z 5
Dragonfly tendon
_____ Molecular weight M, of chains between cross-links (aver.) Average number of amino acid residues between cross-links: Total Pro Average number of residues between equally spaced Pro: Total GlY
Ala Val ASP Ser Other
Locust ligaments -~
___~
5 Ooo*
3 soot
60
40 3
c c
Ox ligamentum nuchae ~
2m s
>< >
z z
Tr,
4.5
30 3
0
z
m
z >
3.8
9 3.4
1-1
1
0.3
0.3
1-0 0.8
0.9
-
0.7
0 1
3.0
2,l
2.I
10
.o
7
2.3
1.5 1 .o
-z ci
-!
0
P
x
m
r
s c v, I
Weis-Fogh (l%lb). T 0 t Jensen and Weis-Fogh (1962). 3 According to Partridge (1962) M, is 2 600 as estimated from mechanical tests, but due to the untypical stress-strain diagram (Hoeve $ and Flory, 1958) this figure can only be very approximate.
H I.SI 1 . 1 N
53
i i d l ' wliich i \ the main factor. In resilin the ideal physical propcriich ;LIX h o t cxplititicd i f wc aswine that the network is free of dt.f;.c.ts ;tnd i h c l i a r a c t c r i d by an almost equal spacing of chemical SCC~~ICIICC
crosc-links with no phy\ical entanglements. If this view is adopted and if, furthcrmorc. we assumc that the prolyl residues are distributed almost evenly between the cross-links, there is a marked similarity between resilin and elastin which may be significant (Table VI). Since prolyl cannot bc fitted into the a-helix, it is seen that the average chain between prolyl rcsidues consists of only 7--10 residues of which more than half carry no o r short aliphatic non-polar side groups. It is assumed (Schellman. 1955) that an a-hclix rcyuircs at least 15-20 residues in succession i n order to bc stable, although intrachain hydrogen bonds are formed between -NHand >C=O only three residues away. I t is possible, mnrco\er. that the 2-5 residues other than the simple aliphatic ones are spaced to as to prevent such hydrogen bonding, because we have seen that almost no hydrogen bonds can he present in swollen resilin. Obviously, i n order to go further it is necessary to know the actual amino acid sequence i n both proteins. 1%. IIOW A R I : 'IHF. N E T W O R K S FORMED'.)
Thc precursors of rcsilin and elastin are presumably linear soluble protein\ buf they have not becn isolatcd. Determinations of NH,-end groups in the final product indicate a molecular weight of about 350 OOO for elastin (Partridge and Davis, 1955) and 80-120 OOO for resilin (Andersen, unpublished). I t is therefore clear that each original chain is likely to become cross-linked with other chains at several points (20150), explaining the complete insolubility of both proteins. Although there are terminal NH,-groups present it may be argued, nevertheless, that the rubberlike proteins consist of interwoven polypeptide rings where mcst junction points are simple physical entanglements (as in a ring mail) and, also, that the so-called cross-links either serve to close the rings or are of no real consequence. However, as pointed out by Weis-Fogh !1961b), such a model is untenable because we are dealing with a n isc:ropic network of randomly kinked chains formed in a watery medium. If the chains should be transformed into rings, they can only become interwoven provided that ork end is free to dip through already f,xmed rings and then to react with the other end, but in randomly kinked and agitated chains the probability is zero for the configuration that thc two ends of the chain will occupy the same volume clement. We must, therefore, conclude that the networks are formed
5.1
S V E N D O L A V A N D E R S E N A N D TORKEL WEIS-FOGH
from long Aexiblc chains which become cross-linked while they are in the random1y kin ked configuration. The cross-linking process may proceed either as a bulk process similar to ttic vulcanization of technological rubbers or it may be an additive process similar to growth and crystallization whereby the newly liberated chains bcconie fixed to the surface of already formed crosslinked material. There does not seem to bc any observations bearing upon elastin and speculations arc also hampcrcd by the fact that sonic authors state that the isotropic fibres ;ire, i n fact, made up of submicroscopic fibrils abcut 100 A thick (Gottc ct d., 1963), while other investigators
3
C
F H , . 30. ‘The average incrcase in the total dry weight of a locust wing-hinge (wH) and 0 1 a prealar arm (prA) as ;i function of adult ,rge (A). Similar figures for resilin and chitin in the prenlar a r m (B)and in the wing-hinge (c‘).(From Neville 1963b.)
have failed to see any submicroscopic structure (Cox and Little, 1961). It seems certain, however, that the final product is present (and formed?) outside the cells. As far as resilin is concerned, it is possible to follow the formation as a growth process since it is deposited in the course of several days (Weis-Fogh, f960) and is found as an extracellular product totally devoid of any submicroscopic structure (Elliott et al., 1964). According to Neville (1963b), the deposition of locust resilin starts 3 days before the final moult and is not complete until 15-20 days after (Fig. 30). In spite of sinall variations in the fluorescence which manifest
55
KI-SI 1.1 N
them\clvc\ a\ daily growth layers (Neville, 1963a; see also Fig. 32). there is n o difkrence in the yield of fluorescent material between new and old resilin so that the degree of cross-linking remains the same and specifically fixed (Fig. 31). From experiments with tritiated tyrosine injected at different time intervals. we know that the radioactive tracer is being incorporated in thc course of 2-3 h after the injection and that the radioactivity remains irt srtu for the rest of the animal's life (Fig. 32; Kristensen, unpublished). The secreting epidermal cells in which the
..,,,,.I,
t!,,
.,. ,
I,
'
V'l',Yl,'
1.y;
FIG.31. Optical density at 315 m p of resilin ligament hydrolyzates made alkaline. l h e ordinate is a measure of the amount of the lluorescent compounds since they are the only amino acids prcsent which have absorption at this wavelength. The abscissa gives the iictuitl weight of resilin in samples at known ages. Circles: prealar arms; crosses: wing-hinges; ( I ) and (2) from very young animals, (3) and (4) from fully grow;] animals. (From Neville, 1963b.)
precurscrs pile up do not cxhibit the characteristic blue fluorescence, neither after formaldehyde fixation nor when examined in the fresh statc (unpublished ; cf. Fig. 3 3 ) . Finally, both microdissection, ordinary microscopic investigations ( Weis-Fogh, 1960; Neville, I963b) and electron microscopy (Elliott ef a/., 1964) show that there is only a very thin zone of tran5ition between the cell surface and the fully formed fluorescent resilin. The picture which emerges is that resilin is being secreted in the form of dissolved, large, randomly kinked linear molecules which
Fici. 32. Autoradiograph rnadc from ii section of a prealar arm, photographed both in direct and in UV-light. Thc iiiiinial reccivcd sevcn injections of tritiurnlahellcd tyrosinc with regular intervals o f 2 days. thc lirst injection was given 24 h after thc final moult. Activity froin the first six injections has been incorporated in narrow bands. which coincidc with evcry second of' the brighter fluorescent daily growth layers. (By courtesy of H. Kristcnsen.)
RESlLlN
57
iirc lihcr;iic.tl i t l t o i h c n;irro\v spitcc hctwccn t h e plasmu mcnihranc and I I K prcvi:)u\ly cro\+linhcd rc\ilin. 'l'hc wrfitcc o f the rcsiliti mu\t be
utiutur;itcd w i t h cro\\-link\ ;ind tlic new molcculcs become attached by means o f ;I spccific cross-linking process almost as soon a s they have left the cell. I n othcr words, a l l acnilable evidence points towards the network being formed by a molecular growth process entirely controlled by the rate of liberation of 11ic prccursor. I h i s rnodc o f formation has some features which arc unique as comparcd with technological rubbers and which may explain some of the outstarlding qualities of rcsilin. Being a protein, it is reasonable to assunic that the cross-links are introduced a t specific predetermined sites but this would not in itself prcvcnt network defects. However. if the cross-linking process occurs only at the surface and resilin grows in a way remhiscent of a crystal, electrostatic forces from the charged end groups may prevent the ends from dipping into the already formed material, and a network without physical entanglements will result. So f>r, wc have not discussed the chemical processes involved in cross-linking and it is futile to speculate much further until the chemical structurcs of Compounds I and I I arc known. It should only be mentioned that tho lir:ks seem to be formed between tyrosyl groups on neighbouring chains by means of a modified derivative of tyrosine which may either be free in solution o r attached t o one of the chains. C. R E S l L l N A N D I N S E C T C U T I C L E
One of the most striking features of insect cuticle is its bariability and the exactness with which these extracellular structures are constructed, also at the submicroscopic level. The extremes may be illustrated by the hard dark and sclerotized exocuticle of a mandible on the one sidc and a patch of pure rcsilin on the other, but there are all grades i n between. Moreover. numerous composite structures are known from elab,xitcly built bristles (Slifcr, 1961) to complicated sheets of cuticle with lamellae, pore-canals, ducts and sculpturing (cf. Locke, 1961). It 1\ n o t intcndcd to discuss this enormous complex here (for gencral rcv;cws, bee Hackman. 1959: Richards, 1951, 1958; Wigglesworth, !04X, 1957) but o n l y t o cmph;isir.e some general problems related to thc properties and formation of rcsiiin. Although ;I fair amount of solublc protein is present in some mature cuticles (Wackman, 1953, 1059), tlic characteristic feature of the complex i s that of insolubility brought about hy cross-linking processes, but there must bc it considcrable chemical difl'crcnce between the sclerotization
58
SVI:Nl)
0 1 AC’ A h 1 ) l . H S t . h A N I > ‘ I O K K I . 1 . W F I S - I O G H
of hard cklticle and the similar process in rcsilin. Moreover, next to nothing is hnown about thc endocuticle deposited after moulting and it is likely that othcr types of cross-links will be discovered both i n cuticle and elsewhere (Weis-Fogh, 1963). The sclerctized parts of the exocuticle are secreted in a soft state often in :he course of several days before the moult, extended and stretched during moulting. and fixed and stabilized by the subsequent tanning which is believed to be effected by local liberation of phenolic compounds via the pore canals. These microscopic or submicroscopic canals run normal to the cuticle and begin as extensions of the epidermal cells although they may later become occluded. Unfortunately, as to the tanning process itself, the two best investigated preparations cannot be considered as typical examples of hard cuticle-the ootheca of the cockroach and the puparium of thc ,blowtly. Since, however, the fundamental processes rnay be similar in ordinary “living” cuticle and in these samples, in which tanning occurs uftcr they have lost all direct contact with living cclls, they will be described in some detail. T h c oo;hcc;i of the cockroiich has mainly bcen investigated by Pryor (1940), Brunet and Kent (1955) and Kent and Brunet (1959; see also Pryor, 1962). The left collaterial gland secretes a protein, a phenoloxidase and a /3-glucosidc of protocatechuic acid while the right gland secretes a P-glucosidase so that, when the secretions of the two glands are mixed, protocatechuic acid is liberated from the glucoside and oxidized IG a o-quinone by means of the phenoloxidase present. This o-yuinone apparently reacts with the free amino groups in the protein, i n this way hiking the chains together and transforming the protein into an insoluble hard and dark resin. In the blowfly the metabolism of tyrosine changes just before pupation so that most of the tyrosinc is metabolized according to the scheme: tyrosinc
dopa. +dop;imin
b
N-acetyldopamin
(Karlson and Sckeris, 1962; Sckeris and Karlson 1962). During the pupation, iin inactive I.)rophenoIoxidase becomes activated (Schweiger and kirlson, 1962). It oxidilcs the N-acetyldopamin to an o-quinone which then tans the soft cuticle, forming the hard dark insoluble pu piriuni. In model cxpcrinicti~s,lrcatnicnt o f untanned proteins with quinones results in dark inwlublc products due to cross-linking between free amino groups. Most expcrimcnts on ordinary cuticles indicate that the tanning processes follow a similar course. Thus, various di-phenols and also phenoloxidasc activity are usually present, and it has recently been
RESlLlN
59
ili;.t 'Y-tyrosinc atid ' I ( - d o p arc incurporatcd in the cuticle of S(.hi\/ocwcu Krcgoritr during the first hours after the final moult
found
(Karlson and Schlossbcraer-Kaeche, 1962). Since N-acetyldopamin is also prcsent, liarlson and Sekcrts (1962) propose that the processes in the pupnrium arc also rcprcscntatiw for those in ordinary cuticle. Whatevcr tlic dctails, all cvidencc indicates a bulk-process in which the inaterial t n he tanned is first laid down i n the amount needed and is then impxgnatcd will1 thc tanning agents which react with the free amino groups i n such a way that adjacent protein chains become coniicctcd through \tublc cross-links. The degree of tanning can then be controlled cithcr by thc amount of tannage or by the number of reactive groups or both, hut since the reactions will occur completely at random it seems iiiipos\iblc t o makc regular molecular networks in this way. The most outmnding difrerences between the sclerotization and the formaticn of resilin are (a) that the cross-linking of resilin is a continuous process taking place whenever the precursors are liberated into the extracdlular space. and (b) that it involves the tyrosyl residues and not the free amino groups. However, the systems may be similar in principlc since i n both the cross-linking could depend on sinall reactive molecules in solution. So far, we have not discussed thc uncoloured lamellate endocuticle which is two to three times more abundant i n mature locusts than the sclerotit-cd exocuticlc and which is formed i n the course of several days after thc final moult (Neville, 1963~).According to Jensen and WeisFogh (1902). the clastic modulus in extension is of the same order of magnitude i n thc t w o types, 800 IOW kg/mm2 against 0.2 kg/mm2 in rubbcrlikc cuticle, but endocuticle is undoubtedly the softer in compressior. normal to thc surface. However. i n principle endocuticle behaves a s ;[ solid although it exhibits some properties reminiscent of rubberlike cuticle. I t is devoid of colour, it swclls and shrinks normal to the lamellac to ;in appreciahlc extent when the pH is changed and it exhibits rypical strain-birefringencc when deformed under the polarizing microsccpc. It docs not, however, fluoresce with the typical bluish colour of resilin; it is somewhat plastic and stains blue with Mallory and Masson and grcen with light grccn. As to cross-links there are a t least four possibilities: (a) that they are similar to those found in resilin although slightly modified since Coinpounds I and I1 have not been found; ( h ) that they arc due to the libernlion of small amounts of quinonch without this resulting in any darkening (Dennell, 1958; Malek, 1961 1; ( c ) that specific bonds are formed between chitin and protein as propowl by Hackman (1059); and (d) that the epidermal
ti(;. 33. Section of LL part of the cuticlc from the transition between the dorsal part of the radial vein and the tirst median plate in a forewing of a desert locust. The sample was fixed in 47; neutral formaldehyde and frozen-sectioned (6 p thick). Photographed in UV-light to show fluorescence (A) and in phase-contrast (B). The resilin-containing part is brightly fluorescent and the endocuticle fluoresces only weakly and with another colour. The epidermal cells are non-fluorescent. Notice that resilin has been deposited beneath both dark exocuticle and non-coloured endocuticle.
R E S 11-1 N
61
cells arc. ablc tu produce a third, unknown system for cross-linking proteins. I t may be instructive to consider the relationship between the three types of cuticle just discussed as illustrated in Fig. 33. I t is a transverse frozen section (6 p thick) of formaldehyde-fixed cuticle from the transition between the dorsal part of the radial vein and the first median plate in a forewing of a desert locust (the resilin fluoresces strongly and it is just visible in Fig. 2). The fluorescing rubberlike cuticle is lamellate throughout and, although its outer part is formed before the final moult simultaneously with the prospective exocuticle (Neville, 1963c), there is a sharp bomdary between the two types. After the moult, the endocuticle is laid down together with rubberlike cuticle but, again, the boundaries remain sharp and distinct. It is also seen that the rubberlike cuticle lacks pare canals (Weis-Fogh, 1960) although they are present in neighbouring endocuticle. Finally, in spite of the sharp lines of separation, the epidermal cells in the region of overlap must have produced exocuticie, endocuticle and rubberlike cuticle in succession. This is another demonstration of the almost omnipotent qualities of these cells (Wigglesworth, 1961), and it indicates that the same cell may be able to cross-link proteins in two or three different ways, but perhaps not at the same time. The lzck of pore canals and the sharp boundaries between rubberlike cuticle and the other types may be due to the small meshes of the network combined with the fact that resilin is cross-linked while being formed. Thus, the amount of fluorescent amino acids seen in Table 1V corresponds to an average distance between neighbouring cross-links of about 2%A in normally swollen locust resilin (v=0.4). This means that ordinary protein molecules cannot diffuse through it, particularly not since a considerable part of the volume is occupied by the network chains themselves. In other words, after the network has been formed resilin acts as a barrier for the passage of ordinary macromolecules. This restriction also concerns chitin which, when present, is arranged in regular continuous lamellae in rubberlike cuticle. It is obvious that a dense network starting at the cell surface will prevent mixing of chitin molecules with resilin and resist the intrusion of chitin crystallites. Since chitin lainellae seem to be formed by simultaneous excretion over large areas (Noble-Nesbitt, 1963b) and i n discontinuous fixed amounts (quanta1 growth; Neville, 1963b), it is understandable that the chitin in rubberlike cuticle forms thin continuous sheets (Elliott et al., 1964) of long crystallites oriented at random in the planes of the sheets (Clark and Smith, 1936). The lamellae do not touch each other and the chitin
62
S V E N I ) 0 I . A V A N D E R S E N A N D TORKLL. W E i S - F O G H
rcmains confined lo discrcte laycrs and not distributed among the protein, as in certain farms of solid cuticle (Lockc, 1961 ; Neville, 1963d). While a resilin network can exclude other macromolecules from entering, i.; may of course also function as a matrix for soluble protein molecules which become entrapped in the meshes during secretion and which are tanned later (Jensen and Weis-Fogh, 1962). Scales (Picken, 1949), hairs, bristles (Slifer, 1961 : Noble-Nesbitt, 1963b) and other "critical" structures are formed early during ecdysis and undergo tanning before the rest of the cuticle (Cottretl, 1968, cited from NobleNesbitt, 1963b; and our own observations on locusts). They are characterized by x i extraordinarily refined molecular architecture which may be understcod not only as a result of spontaneous crystallization but also of the formation of such mixed networks growing by addition from the surfaccs and moulded by the cell membranes due to an exact determination of time and amount of secretion. REFERENCES Andersen, S 0. (1961). Fluorescent components from resilin. Abstr. Commun. V. in/. Congr. Biorheni. 21. Andersen, S. 0. (1963). Characterization of a new type of cross-linkage in resilin, a rubber-like protein. Biothim. biophys. Actu 69, 249-262. Andersen, 5. 0.and Kristensen, B. (1963). Incorporation of phenylalanine and tyrosine in the cross-linkages of a protein, resilin. Acta physiol. srund. 59, Suppl. 213, 15. Bailey, K. and Weis-Fogh. T. (1961).Amino acid composition of a new rubber-like protein, resilin. Biochini. hiophys. Artu 4 8 , 4 5 2 4 9 . Bonhag, P. F. (1949). The thoracic mechanism of the adult horsefly (Diptera: Tabanidae). Cornell Utaiv. AKric. Exp. SIU.Mem. 285, 1-39. Brunet, P. C. J. and Kent, P. W. (1955). Observations on the mechanism of a tanning reaction in Peripbrieta and Bluttu. Pror. m y . Sor. B 144, 259-274. Buist, J. M . (1961). Physical testing of rubber. In "The Applied Science of Rubber" (W. J. S. Naunton. ed.), pp. 709-776. Arnold, London. Carton, R . W., Dainauskas. J. and Clark, J. W. (1962). Elastic properties of single elastic fibres. J. uppl. Physiol. 17, 547-551. Clark, G. L. and Smith, A. F. (1936). X-ray diffraction of chitin, chitosan and derivatives. J. phvs. Chem. 40, 863-879. Cotterell, C . B. ( I 960). Thesis, Cambridge University. Cited from Noble-Nesbitt (1963b). Cox, R. C. an.? Little, K. (1961). An electron microscope study of elastic tissue. Pror. roy. S x . B 155, 232-242. Dennell, R. 11958). The hardening of insect cuticle. Biol. Rev. 33, 178-196. Dennell, R. (1960). Integument and exoskeleton. /ti "The Physiology of Crustacea" (T. H. Waterman. ed.), Vol. I , pp. 449-472. Academic Press. New York and London.. Elliott, Ci. U., Huxley, A. F. and Weis-Fogh. T. (1964). In preparation.
RESILIN
63
Fearon, W. it. (1944).The detection and estimation of uric acid by 2:6-dichloroquinone-cbloroimide. Biochem. J. 38, 399402. Gent, A. N. (1962).Relaxation processes in vulcanized rubber. 1. Relation among stress relaxation, creep, recovery. and hysteresis.J. appl. Polymer Sri. 6,433-441. Gotte, L., Stern, P., Elsden. D. F. and Partridge, S. M. (1963).The chemistry of connective tissues. 8. The composition of elastin from three bovine tissues. Biochem. J. 87. 344-35I . Gustavson, K. H. (1956).“The Chemistry and Reactivity of Collagen”. Academic Press, New York. Hackman, R. H. (1953).Chemistry of insect cuticle. I. The water-soluble proteins. Bioche.71. J. 54, 362L367. Hackman, R. H. (1959). Biochemistry of the insect cuticle. I n “Biochemistry of Insects”, Proc. I V . int. Congr. Biochem., Vienna (L.Levenbook, ed.), pp. 48-72. Pergamon Press, London. Hoeve. C . A. J. and Flory, P. J. (1958). The elastic properties of elastin. J. Amer. chcm. S,K. (10. 6523-6526. Jensen, M. and Weis-Fogh, T. ( 1962).Biologyand physics oflocust flight. V. Strength and elasticity of locust cuticlc. Phil. Truns. B 245, 137-169. Karlson, P. and Schlossberger-Raecke. I. ( 1962). Zum Tyrosinstoffwechsel der Insektrn---VIll. Die Sklerotisierung der Cuticula bei der Wildform und der Albinomutante von Schistocercu greguria Forsk. J. Insect Physiol. 8, 441-452. Karlson, P.and Sekeris, C. E. ( I 962).N-acetyl-dopamine as sclerotizing agent of the insect cuticle. Nctture. Lond. 195, 183-1 84. Kendrew, J. C.(1954).Structure proteins. 1. In “The Proteins, Chemistry, Biological Acti./lty. and Methods” (H. Neurath and K. Bailey, eds.), Vol. 2,B, pp. 845-950. Academic Press, New York. Kent, P. W. and Brunet. P. C. J. (1959).The occurrence of protocatechuic acid and its aOB-D-glucoside in Blartu and Periplaneta. Tetrahedron 7 , 252-256. LaBella, F. S. ( 1961 1. Studies on the soluble products released from purified elastic fibers by pancreatic elastase. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 93, 72-79. La Cireca, hl. ( 1947).Morfologia funzionale dell’articolazione alare degli Ortotteri. Arch.
70d.
(itirl.) Napoli 33,
271-327.
Lloyd, D. J . and Garrod, M.(1946).The rubber-like condition of the fibres of animal skin. Fihruus proteir/s. I n “The Society of Dyers and Colourists Symposium”, 1946,rsp. 24-29. I-ocke. M.(1961).Pore canals and related structures in insect cuticle. J. biophys. biocl/c,:n.C)ftnl.10. 5 8 9 4 1 8. Loonieijer. F. J. (1058). A yellow fluorescent pigment in elastin. Nature, Lond. 182, I 82-1 83. Loomeijer, F. J . (1961). The lipid compound of elastin. J. Atheroscler. Res. 1,62-66. Malek. S. R. A . (1961). Polyphenols and their quinone derivatives in the cuticle of the deser! locust. Schistocercu Kreguria (Forskill). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 2,35-50. Mandl, I. and Cohen, B. B. (1960). Bacterial elastase. 1. Isolation, purification and propcr:ics. Arch. Biuchem. Biophys. 91,47-53. Meyer, K. t4. and Ferri, C. (1936).Die elastischen Eigenschaften der elastischen und der kollaaenen Fasern und ihre molekulare Deutung. PjYiig. Arrh:ges. Physiol. 238. 18 -90 Meyer. K. H., Susich, G. v. and Valko, E. 11932). Dieeiastischen Eigenschaften der organischen Hochpolymeren und ihre kinetische Deutung. Kolhidzschr. 59, 208 -216.
64
SVENII O L A V A N D E H S E N A N D T O R K E L WEIS-FOGH
Miller, P. L. (1960). Respiration in the desert locust. I I . The control of the spiracles. J . cxp. B i d . 37, 237-263. Neville, A. C. (1960). Aspects of flight mechanics in anisopterous dragonflies. J . exp. Bb!. 37, 631-656. Neville, A. C. (1963a). Daily growth layers in locust rubber-like cuticle influenced by an extcrnal rhythm. J. Irtwct Physiol. 9. 177-186. Neville. A . C. (1963b). Growth and deposition of resilin and chitin in locust rubberlike cuticl:. J. Irrsrc/ Phjsiol. 9. 265-278. Neville, A. C . (1963~).Daily growth layers for determining the age of grasshopper populations. Oikos 14, 1--8. Neville, A. C . (1963d). Daily growth zones in insect skeletons. Acta ph.vsio/. scund. 59, Suppl. 213. 107. Noble-Neshitt. J. { 1963a). The fully formed intermoult cuticle and associated structures of Poduru uyuu/ic~u(C’ollembola). Quart. J . micr. Sci. 104, 253-270. Noble-Nesbitt, J. (1963b). The cuticle and associated structures of Poduru aquatica at the mcult. Quar./. J . 1nic.r. .‘%.104, 369-391. Partridge, S. M. (1962). Elastin. Adranc. Protein Chern. 17, 227-302. Partridge, S. M. and Davis, H. F. (1955). The chemistry of connective tissues. 3. Composition of the soluble proteins derived from elastin. Biochem. J. 61, 2 I -30. Patridge. S. M., Davis, H. F. and Adair, G . S. (1955). The chemistry of connective tissues. 2 . Soluble proteins derived from partial hydrolysis of elastin. Biochem. J. 61, I I -21. Partridge, S. M., Elsden, D. F. and Thomas, J. (1963). Constitution of the crosslinkages in elastin. Nature. Lond. 197, 1297-1298. Picken, L. E. R. (1949). Shape and molecular orientation in lepidopteran scales. Phil. Trwrs. B 234. 1-28. Pryor. M. G . M. (1940). On the hardening of the ootheca of Bluttu orientulis. Proc. roy. Soc. B 128. 378-393. Pryor, M. C. kl. (1962).Sclerotization. In “Comparative Biochemistry“ (M. Florkin and H. S. Mason, eds.). Vol. 4, pp. 371--396. Academic Press, New York and Londo,i. Richards, A. G . (1951). “The Integument of Arthropods”. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis. Richards, A . G. I 1958). The cuticle of arthropods. Erg&. Biol. 20, 1-26. Rosen, H. (1957). A modified ninhydrin colorimetric analysis for amino acids. Arch. Biochtvn. Biophys. 67, 10--I5 . Saunders, D. W. (l956a). The photo-elastic properties of cross-linked amorphous polymers. 1. Natural rubber and gutta-percha. Trans. Furaday Soc. 52, 14141425. Saunders, L). W. ( I956b). The photo-elastic properties of cross-linked amorphous polymers. 2. Polythene and polymethylene. Trans. Faraduy Soc. 52, 1425-1431. Schellman, J. A. (1955). The stability of hydrogen-bonded peptide structures in aqueoiss solution. C. R. Lub. Curlsberg 29, 230-259. Schweiger, A. and Karlson, P. (1962). Zum Tyrosinstoffwechsel der Insekten. X. Die Aktivierung der PrCphenoloxydase und das Aktivator-Enzym. Hoppe-Seyl. Z. 329, 210-221. Sekeris, C. E. and Karlson. P. (1962). Zum Tyrosinstoffwechsel der Insekten. VII. Der katabolische Abbau des Tyrosins und die Biogenese der Sklerotisierungssubstam N-Acetyl-dopamin. Rioc~hini.hioph,~..\.Actu 62. 103-1 13.
R ESI 1. I N
65
Singer, S. J. (1062). Thc propertics of proteins in nonaqueous solvents. Advanc. Prokin (‘hcm. 17. 1 68. Slifer, F,. H . (1961j. The finc structure of insect sense organs. In!. Rev. Cytol. 11, 125 159. Thurm, L‘. (1963). Ilie Bezeihungen zwischen mechanischen Reizgrossen und stationiren E.rregungszustanden bci Borstenfeld-Sensillen von Bienen. Z . w r g l . Physiol. 46, 351-382. Treloar, L. R. G . (1954). Photoelastic properties of short-chain molecular networks. 7”. Furciclay SOC.50, 88 1-896. Treloar, t. R . G. (1958). “The Physics of Rubber Elasticity”, 2nd ed. Clarendon Press. 3xford. Weis-Fogn, T. ( 1959). Etlasticity in arthropod locomotion : a neglected subject, illustrated by the wing system of insects. Proc. XV. itit. Congr. Zool. (1958), 393-;95. Weis-Fogh, T. ( 1960). A rubber-like protein in insect cuticle../. exp. Biol. 37,889-907. Weis-Fogh, T. (1961a). Thermodynamic properties of resilin, a rubber-like protein. J . mol. Biol. 3. 520-53 1 . Weis-Fogh, T. ( I 961 b). Molecular interpretation of the elasticity of resilin, a rubberlike protein. ./. mol. B i d . 3, 648-667. Weis-Fogh, T. (1961~).Power in flapping flight. In “The Cell and the Organism” (J. A . Ranisay and V. B. Wigglesworth, cds.). pp. 283-300. Cambridge University Press. Weis-Fogh, T. (1963). Resilin, a rubber-like protein, and its significance. In “Aspects of Protein Structure” (G. N. Ramachandran,ed.), pp. 337-341. Academic Press, London and New York. Wiggleswxth, V. B. (1948). The insect cuticle. B i d . Rev. 2 3 . 4 0 8 4 1 . Wiggles*ucrth.V. B. (1957).The physiology of insect cuticle. Annu. Rev. Ent. 2.37-54. Wigglesworth. V. B. (1961). The epidermal cell. In “The Cells and the Organism” (J. A. Rainsay and V. B. Wigglesworth, eds.), pp. 127-143. Cambridge University Presc.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Active Transport and Passive Movement of Water in Insects J. W. L. BEAMENT Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge,
England I. Inkduction . . . 11. The Active Transport of Water . A. BasicPremises . B. Active Uptake from the Air . C. Active Transport of Water in the Gut . D. Water and the Tracheal System . E. The Living Cuticle and Liquid Water . F. Conclusions . 111. 1.n Interrelation between Grease and Absorbtion . A. A Model Absorbing Water . IV. The Physical Chemistry of the Cuticle . A. The Cuticle other than Lipid Layer . B. The Hydration of Procuticle C. Control of Procuticle by the Epidermis . V. Tne Cuticular Lipid . A. A New Interpretation of Transition in Monolayer Films B. Monolayer Inversion . C. Conclusions. . VI. The Asymmetry of Cuticle A. Thermodynamic Validity of Asymmetry . V11. Eirctrical Properties of Cuticular Lipids . A. The Electrical Inversion of a Monolayer . B. Mechanical Distortion C. The Passage of Substances through Monolayers . VIII. On Pumps A. The Electret Ion-pu.np B. Continuous-flow Water-pumps , C. Is the Lipid the Water-valve? . 1X. N'ider Implications . X. Summary . References
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . * . . . . .
. .
. . .
. . . .
67 69 69 72 76 78 88 91 92
9 4 94 95 96 97 98 101
I05 107 107 111 111 112 115 115 117 118 120 122 123 124 125
I. I N T R O D U C T I O N Water is actively transported by insects. Direct evidence for this statement relies on a small number of experiments involving only some half-dczen species and is especially associated with the external cuticle 67
68
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
and the gut linings. However a critical evaluation of this work will show that the evidence is beyond reasonable doubt. As a statement of physiological fact this discovery is of enormous importance. An active transport ~f ions and of unionized material is a well substantiated phenomer-on in all kinds of living material, and it is commonplace to assume such processes in explaining the functioning of nerve, of muscle, of digestive, excretory and osmoregulatory devices and of every kind of cellular traisporting phenomenon. The movement of water, however, seems always to be assumed to follow an osmotic gradient, to be incidental to the active transport of a hydrated particle, or it is neglected altogether. Sometimes even the possibility of a n active transport of water per se is bluntly denied. Yet it would be most surprising if living systems which have devised methods of transporting so many biological substances against concentration gradients had not found a means of handling &becommonest of all biological chemicals-water. If it can be shown bejjond reasonable doubt that any one organism can actively transport water, then an independent mechanism for water-transport may not be eliminated from studies of physiological systems simply on grounds of minimum hypothesis. In most physiological systems a redistributim of water accompanies the transport of other materials, so that a discussion of water transport must include some consideration of mechanisms which would transport ionized particles and unionized materials; it is even possible that some substances could be passively redistributed as a result of an active transport of water. It is the author’s belief that the literature on the tracheal system contains evidztice suggesting an active transport of water; when these findings are considered in conjunction with some hitherto anpublished experimental evidence briefly reported here, one may make a case for the active transport of water in many insects and perhaps sugest that this is a basic ability of the class, if not of the Arthropoda as a whole. The first section of this paper aims to make this case. The water movements under discussion all take place through an integumental membrane of some kind. In recent years we have obtained some insight into the physicrt-chemical nature of these membranes, especially into their relationship to water. Organized lipids play the most important role in the passive regulation of water movement and in modifying the adhesion of water to the surface of cuticular membranes; the molecular arrangement within thc lipid may change and in doing so greatly modify the relationship of the membrane with water. Tbere is reason for believing that some part of the essential mechanism for regulating and perhaps transporting water involves organized lipids.
A C T I V E TRANSPORT O F WATER I N INSECTS
69
The most recent development in this field of investigation concerns the clectric dipoles of polar lipid and the consequent presence of an electrostatic field of great strength, associated with the cuticular membrane. The physiological consequences of such a system are by no means fully realized; two possibilities which are apparent are: (a) the separation of two solutions of different ionic composition without the continiicus expenditure of energy even though the solutions are in diffusive communication, and (b) the facilitation of the movement of ions of particular charge in a particular direction. In other words, this electrostaticfield can be the basis of an ion pump. Another problem in this field has frequently been called the “asymmetry” of insect cuticle. We must examine whether it is physically reasonable for the cuticle membrane to have greater permeability to water in one direction through it than another. New experimental evidence about the physicochemical construction of the lipid layer makes possible the development of a theory that the lipid can act as a “valve” or “rectifier”, whence one can outline a mechanism which will actively pump water. Finally one must consider whether such a pump has chamteristics similar to any of the systems which appear to be transporting water actively in the insect. We have not yet reached the stage where one mechanism provides a universal answer to all these transport phenomena. Nevertheless it should be borne in mind when reading this paper that all cell membranes contain, as an essential central constituent, a bi-molecular leaflet of organized lipid. While the utmost caution must be exercised in extending any analogy between the cuticle of the insect and the cell membrane, it must be apparent that this research on the cuticle could be useful as a model when thinking about similar processes which occur at the membrane of every cell, and even within cells. 11. THEA CT I V ET R A N S P OOF R TW A T E R A. B A S I C P R E M I S E S
Unless energy is supplied from some external source, materials tend to migrate from a higher into a lower concentration; the movement may
be by simple diffusion or, in more complex systems, by special transporting mechanisms commonly called “activated” or “facilitated” diffusion (e.g. Bayliss, 1959; Davson, 1959; Harris, 1960). But when a material passes from a place where it is at lower concentration into a place where it is at a higher concentration involving, as this must, a
70
J . W . L. B E A M E N T
supply of energy, then the process is called a c t k transport. The term is a physiological one. Transport may bc achieved, for example, by a temporary reversal of the gradient which is not observable. Movement may thcn bc achieved by simple or complex diffusion down the temporary gradient, but work is done in changing the gradient temporarily. Alternately, models have been proposed in which chains of molecules are pushed or pulled through specific channels connecting the two concentrations. Energy is fed into this transport system and the measurable concentratioit difference is not changed. The gradient to be considered is not necessarily simple : an ion may move up a concentration gradient if, at the same time, it is moving down an electro-potential gradient, and energy is provided in setting up the potential gradient. But, whatever actual physical processes are at work, if one can establish that a substance moves from a lower to a higher concentration, then one can automatically assume that energy is provided to move that substance. Nevertheless this is a limited view of the use of physical forces in moving materials in biological systems. There are occasions where substances move down a concentration gradient, but against other kinds of force or at rates much higher than can be accounted for by the concentration difference. Bath these phenomena also require a supply of energy, and it is only the conventional use of the term “active transport” which prevents the inclusion of all kinds of similar processes, probably based upon similar physical mechanisms. In this review we shall examine movement 9f water in this wider sense. Physiological studies to date on active transport have almost exclusively considered the passage, for example, of specific ions across the cell membrane of nerve or muscle, or similar cellular systems. The actual flux and gross amount of the ion which is moved is usually minute and the transport is a reversible process depending on the state of a cell membrane; indeed the cell membrane itself is usually regarded as the actual physical site of the pump mechanism (e.g. reviews by Hodgkin, 1951, 1958; Nachmansohn, 1961). Although eventually it may prove that the sodium pump of a membrane like that of a nerve or muscle has molecular mzchanics very similar to the sodium pump of a system involved in thz osmoregulation of the body fluids of a fresh-water animal, there is a difference of degree between these two kinds of phenomena which could allow their mechanisms to be fundamentally different. In an osmoregulatory device, such as those associated with the gill structures, active transport maintains a concentration difference between an ion in the fresh-water environment continuously in one direction with a relatively high flux. In colloquial terms, we could postulate the same
A< I I V F 7HANTI’OKJ
0 1
W A f b R I N INSECTS
71
mechanism inside the cell membranes causing sodium to move into a nerve and into a gill epithelial cell. In the nerve the mechanism can be turned off, and the sodium return through the cell membrane again; the same amount of sodium shuttles back and forth. But in osmoregulation, either the mechanism can never be turned off, or if it must be turned off for re-activation and for transferring sodium into the blood, something must prevent sodium from returning to the outside world. The sodiumattractiiig device of an osmoregulator is only one of the essential components; a continuous-flow system needs additional components to those basically required by a nerve. The situation we shall discuss in relation to water transport is generally more comprrable with the osmoregulatory device. Many suggestions can be made, and have been made, of mechanisms capable of causing water tc move into a cell (e.g. Harris, 1960), ranging from simple ideas of osrwsis, hydrostatic pressure or electro-osmosisto anomolous osmosis and counter-flow systems, or marginal processes based on minute thermal differences to the folding and unfolding of proteins and “colloidal pressures”. The terminologies are various and in some cases incomprehensible either in the context of the period in which they were advacced, or in the light of later developments. Therefore amongst our basic prexises it must be clearly understood that the key to continuousflow active transport which has so far been overlooked is the means of maintainifig the attracting system despite uptake, and/or preventing a reversal of flow when the attracting system is regenerated. As with osmoregulation, the reason for postulating an active transport of water in an arthropod usually derives from a consideration of a concentration difference between the blood and the external medium : that is to say, active transport takes place across a cellular layer (two cell membranes and the cell content) together with an inert integumental or extracellular membrane. But whether transport occurs across a single cell membrane, or a more complex series of membranes, most of the physiological circumstances in which an active transport of water might occur include the possibility of moving the water in association with some other substance, as water of hydration of an ion, for example, thus preventing the establishment of a clear-cut case. This is where the terrestrial animal is of critical importance. Consider an insect confined in air, without food or accessible liquid. The air has a relative humidity substantially lower than that which would be in equilibrium with the insect’s blood fluids. By respiration the insect will lose some weight. But the insect gains in total weight. The only substance it can obtain is water from the air, and this water must
72
J. W. I.. B E A M E N T
have been ac!ively transported from thc air into the blood. The use of the blood as thc intcrnal refcrencc level in this type of experiment is particulariy significant when the animal is an insect. Many animals exercise careful control over the composition of their blood, but it is well known that the insect uses its haemolymph as a variable reservoir for water 2nd for many other substances. Any change in the water balance of an insect is generally reflected as a change in the concentration of the blood fluids. Physiologically there is the implication in this statement that the insect has the general ability to exercise control over water transport into and out of the blood. Physically it is necessary to consider thz activity level of water in the blood as the ultimate level of the gradient up which the water is pumped. B. A C T I V E U P T A K E F R O M THE A I R
There are many reports of insects and their eggs gaining weight when in saturated or almost saturated air, or when in contact with soil, blotting paper etc. Eggs often show the interesting property of being able to live for days, submerged in distilled water, without changing in volume, then to take up water and perhaps even double their volume, later to stup expanding and maintain constant volume for several days; and these various conditions are not accompanied by any demonstrable change in the physical permeability of the membrane of the egg-shell. In all probability there are all kinds of processes involving water regulation in the insect which are based upon mechanisms similar to those which are t k direct object of our discussion, but at present they must be discounted as evidence for active uptake of water. It is extremely difficult to obtain and to maintain an air system at 99% relative humilet alone at saturation point, and be sure that no particles dity (R.H.), of liquid water are ever present. The margin of activity difference between the ends of the gradient we consider, must be large enough to exclude any possibility that small thermal cycles could promote humidity cycles, precipitation or any similar objection. The earliest work on the uptake of atmospheric moisture is that of Buxton (1930) on the mealworm Tenebrio molitor, subsequently confirmed by Mellanby (1932), Browning (1957) and Edney (1957). All these worbers agree that in humidities at or above 88% R.H. starved mealworm larvae gain weight, and it has been shown by direct measurement that an increase in real body water-content has occurred. The equilibrium value for their blood (and that of insects in general) may be taken as 99 % R.H. Mellanby believed that equilibrium between the
A< I
ivr. I H A N S I V ) I ~ Ioi.
WA*IF:R
IN INS~CTS
73
animal and atmospheric water was established at 88% R.H. over a wide biological range of temperature. Should it prove that equilibrium is a function of relative humidity rather than of saturation deficit, this is an important discovery and it niust be a characteristic of any “pump” mechanism which may be proposed. Similar experiments have been performed on other arthropods: Chorrophaga gains weight when without food and in humidities above 82% R.H. (Ludwig, 1937); a number of species of Ixodid (Lees, 1946, 1947) and Argasid (Browning, 1954) ticks obtain water down to 92% R.H., while the pre-pupa of the flea Xenopsylla can show this ability with the remarkably low level of 50% R.H.(Edney, 1947). Very recently, the author heard from Dr. A. D. Lees of a conference at which a number of workers reported similar findings in various mites, while the apterygote Thermobia can certainly take up water from sub-saturated air (Beament et al., 1964). The list of experimenta! animals given there shows a wide distribution of this property amongst the terrestrial arthropods and it will be surprising if further investigation does not reveal many more examples. But the species listed there also show that an active water transporting mechanism is not entirely confined to animals in which obtaining or retaining water is a matter of extreme necessity. An alternative kind of experimental method comprises the confining of an insect in a small sealed volume of air which has a known initial humidity, subsequently measuring the humidity of that air when it comes into equilibrium with the living animal. Kalmus (1936) showed that TeneErio larvae bring their surrounding air to approximately 90% R.H. regardless of whether it starts well beiow or above this level of moisture, but the air becomes nearly saturated when the animal dies. The rat-flea pre-pupa, whether starting in dry air or in water-saturated air, is said to produce 50% R.H. in its micro-environment for so long as that Darticular stadium lasts; if it dies or changes to the pupa, the humidity rises to a value close to saturation (Edney, 1947). It may not be irrelevant that pupae have generally a far more impermeable cuticle than other instars (Beament, 1959). We have to scrutinize the experimental evidence most carefully, but it is dificult to find any flaw in the simple procedure of weighing an animal to determine its increased water content; artificial control of a constant relative humidity is difficult and humidity gradients can occur, but almost all the experiments reported used the reliable method of confining the specimens in air over saturated solutions of various salts, with an excess of solid salt present (e.g. Buxton and Mellanby, 1934). 3 is also difficult to measure relative humidity accurately over
74
J. W. L. D E A M E N T
any range of humidity (see Beament, 1958b), but there are simple and reliable ways of calibrating 3 hygrometer for one particular relative humidity and wing it to detect with great sensitivity any very small departure from the calibration value. This method has been employed in the second category of experiments described above. Differences between 94%. 88%, and 50% R.H. and the blood equilibrium figure of 99 % R.H. cannot be challenged on grounds of experimental error or thermal and random fluctuation of environmental conditions. The two facts which emerge are that certain insects can actively take up water, and that they can control the humidity of the air in a small space around them to levels in striking contrast with the humidity which is in equilibrium with the dead body, or with the same animal in a different physiological state. Now another interesting characteristic of all the many insects which have so far been investigated (Ramsay, 1935; Wigglesworth, 1945, etc.) is that there is no significant difference between the rate at which they evaporate water into completely dry air when they are alive or when they are dead. Tenebrio and Ixodes were included in these experiments. Davies and Edney (1952) do suggest that there i s a difference between water loss in dry air from dead and from living spiders; the explanation might for example lie in the appearance of free water over the lung books of dead spiders. But no one has published any information which suggests that spiders are capable of that kind of active uptake of water which we are at present discussing. So we must accept another curious feature of the arthropod water-pump: it can direct water inwards from air of humidities down to a level which would seem to be species-specific, but the pump has no “purchase” when trying to work against humidities substantially below the equilibrium figure. Put another way, the pump does not seem capable of reducing the rate of outward flow of water when high transpiration is experienced. We have next to consider whether we can associate the water-pump with any specific anatomical part of the animal. Buxton (1930) originally attributed the increased water content of Tenebrio to “metabolic water ”-water produced by the metabolism of food. Mellanby (1932) demonstrated that this could not account for the increase, and that water must be taken up from the atmosphere. He believed that absorbtion occurred through the spiracles via the respiratory system. While Mellanby’s suggestion of an uptake of atmospheric water seems abundantly proved, it is shown from first principles in Section 11, D that uptake through the tracheal system is impossible. In most instances attempts to demonstrate the role of the tracheal system by blocking the
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F W A T E R I N INSECTS
75
spiracles have failed (Browning, 1954; Locke, private communication). It is diFcult in such circumstances to differentiate between the effects of anoxia and internally accumulated carbon dioxide. Browning did, however, show that in Ornithodorus a large concentration of C o t which produces direct anaesthesia also prevented water uptake in any case with spiracles open. But Ixodes can apparently respire sufficiently through the cuticle when the spiracles are blocked and Lees demonstrated thvt this did not interfere with active uptake. On the other hand, the animai must be healthy and active: cyanide, oxygen-lack and severe desiccation all prevent water from being absorbed. Also, a number of workers have reported that uptake is “spasmodic” giving the impression that in some instances there is a mechanism which is capable of being switched ‘‘on and off ”. All this evidence is consistent with the existence of an inzegral metabolic process. Lees (1947) has calculated (admittedly on a basis of complete efficiency) that the tick could easily afford to burn fat at the rate necessary to provide the energy for water uptake from 94% R.H. into its blood. If we can eliminate the tracheal system, we must next consider the gut, with which certain forms of active transport are certainly associated; in Section 11, C, it will appear that active transport of water does occur in the hind-gut of certain insects. Consequently, one possible mechanism for obtaining atmospheric water would be for an animal to produce hygroscopic faeces, to re-ingest these after exposure to the air, and use the hind-gut to obtain the water. However, in the experiments we have been considering, mealworms increase in weight when they do not eat their f3ecal material (Wigglesworth, unpublished), ticks are incapable of taking in any solid material through their sucking mouthparts, and the flea pre-pupa does not feed at all. No evidence has been produced, and no suggestion made, that any specialized region of the animal‘s surface is specifically responsible for water uptake, so at the present time w:: must implicate the whole of the external integument. Lees (1947) showed that uptake in Ixodes ceases if the cuticle is subjected to minute abrasion sufficient only to interrupt the superficial wax layer and only over a limited area of the animal’s surface. Two interpretations of this discovery have been put forward. Either the great water loss through the abraded area masks any actual uptake which is occurring elsewhere, or the whole epidermis (which is well known to act as a unit in the arthropods) stops its pump for the period of time during which repair of the wax is taking place. In either eventuality it is the integument-the cuticular membrane plus its epidermis-which is likely to be the seat of the active transport.
76
J. W. L. B E A M E N T @. A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F W A T E R IN T H E G U T
There i s ample evidence that insects can produce a urine hypertonic to their blood. Experiments giving such indications start from the work of Wigglesworth (1934), and centre upon the enormous body of evidence presented by Ramsay (e.g. 1950, 1954) supplemented by such recent workers as SutclSe (1 360). But whatever the true state of affairs, almost all of the events taking place in these insect rectal systems could be explained on the basis of the absorbtion of salts. The exception, which pointed the way to the need for different kinds of investigation, was the demonstration by Ramsay (1954) that the stick insect Dixippus rnorosus could secrete against a hydrostatic pressure of 20 cm of water. The thesis of Phillips (1961), however, clearly proposes an active secretion of water. Briefly, the rectum of the locust Schistocercu gregariu is exceedingly impermeable to small water-soluble molecules, including amino acids, monosaccharides and dyes (Treherne, 1957a, b, 1958). An uptake which is almost certainly an active absorbtion of sodium and potassium goes on through the hind-gut wall, but by feeding the locust on a diet uf pure water and by washing out the rectum it is possible to reduce the zmount of ionic material there to negligible proportions. T h e rectum can then be ligatured anteriorly in such a way as to prevent any ionic material secreted into the gut from the Malpighian tubules from reaching it. Fluids are introduced into this sealed sac through the anus. Phillips reports that the animals remained in good physiological condition throughout these experiments, and he made careful checks on the composition of the blood which remained normal. Solutions of material known not to penetrate the hind-gut wall were introduced into the rectum at known concentration and volume; some of these were isotope-labelled as an additional check on any absorbtion of substances other than water. The rate of decrease in volume of the sealed hind-gut content at various osmotic pressures was obtained by sampling.The locust can certainly absorb water against osmoticpressures of 11 atm without taking in any other substance, and osmotic gradients of twice this value were recorded between the rectal content and the blood at the end of an experiment in which the animal had concentrated the solute from dilutions below the osmotic pressure of the blood. Phillips 'concluded that when the blood exceeded the rectal content in osmotic activity by 0.5 osmoles there could be a large exchange of water with no net transfer; when there was no osmotic pressure difference, water was transferred into the blood at a rate of 17 mg water/cma/h. (These are not the units used by Phillips; the values are given in this
A(
’r ivf
’I R A N S P O R I I
oi
WATE‘R I N iNsr,cTs
77
form to enable direct comparison with othcr rates of transport given in thi\ rcvicw.) With certain rcscrvations, the system appcarcd to behave a5 though the active uptake of water occurred at a fixed rate independent of the actual osmotic pressure prevailing, including the condition in which both the active process and the osmoticactivitymoved water in the same direction. At very high and probably completely unphysiological gradients af osmotic pressure this apparent relationship did break down. This work cstablishes another irrefutable example of the active uptake of water independent of the movement of another material, and it is important to note the apparent independence of the active transport from the diffusive (osmotic) exchange, regardless of the latter’s direction. If we atLempt to explain this phenomenon in terms of “pores” we may have to postulate two kinds of pores: one for osmosis and another for active transport. This situation might be no different to the alternative postulate of Lees (1947) mentioncd above, except that the rate of uptake by the tick was too small to be measured in the presence of evaporative loss through abrasions. Phillips measurcd t hc hydrostatic pressure in the hind-gut where there is a cyclical change of about 4 cm watcr pressure and a maximum value of 12 cm watcr (0.02 atm). This is insignificant in comparison with the pressurcs theoretically needed to move water against thc osmotic pressures encountered i n thc rcctnl system. In experiments with the isolated rectal mcm branc, comparable rates of transmission of water were obtained with 2 cm hydrostatic water pressure and with a n osmotic gradient. equivalent to 56 cm water pressure, while a hydrostatic pressure of 56 cm water produced four times the rate of flow of its osmotic equivalent. This result must be compared with the theory of Pappenheimer (1953) that osmotic and hydrostatic flow should be identical for pressurcs opcrating across large pores, but that hydrostatic pressure should have the greater effcct across small pores; further experiments bearing on this subject are rcported and discussed in Section VI. Phillips, with an extreme caution characteristic of his whole thesis, is not preparcd to attach great significance to the differences he measured betwecn hydrostatic and osmotic cffects through the isolated rectal preparation. He believed he was working with a system of ‘‘large’’ pores by Pappcnheimer standards. But if the membrane is as impermeable to small water-wlublc moleculcs as the work of Treherne suggests, and if Phillips cxpcrimcnts were carried out as carefully as one has zvcry reason to know they wcrc, it does really look as though this is a “small” pore systcm. Somc indication of the mcaning to be attached to the terms “large” and “small” in this context may be
78
J. W. I.. B E A M E N T
obtained f';om t h c work of Rcnkin (1954), who studied diffusion through porous cellulo~emcnibtanes. If a pore is 40 A in radius, there is only a factor of tW(J bctwccn its pcrmcability to water and to a much larger mc/!cc.uk like sucrosc; if the pore has only a 10 A radius, its permeability to watcr is an order greater than to sucrose. There is every possibility i h a t in the rectal membranc, and in the other membranes we are discussing in this paper, which are virtually impermeable to sucrose and similar s i ~ e dmoleculcs, the pores will be much smaller than 10 A. There is ;r staiiding potential of the order of 30 mV across the hindgut membrane, bctwccn blood and rectal content. Active uptake is not afrected i n any way by balancing out or by augmenting this potential. We agree with Phillips that the application of an external voltage source may not have more than a proportional effect on any potentials actually across the walls of the rectal epithelial cells. Nevertheless, it does not seem that electro-osmosis can be the primary cause of the movement of water in this system. Finally, Phillips calculated on a basis of only ZCS'.!, efficicncy, that the observed rate of transfer of water is metabolically feasible against thc gradients theoretically present, and he points to the rich trachciition of the hind-gut as evidence of high nietabolism involved i i i the process of water secretion. From the point of view of the present rcvicw, his subscquent denionstration that prccisely similar events occur i n the hind-gut of the blowfly Culliphoru crythrocephala is especially interesting because of thc very different nature of the diets and environments of thew two animals, and because of the taxonomic separation of this dipteran from the Orthoptera. It is to be hoped that other workers will now re-invcbtigatc the process of production of hypertonic urine-not only i n the insects--in cases where events can be explained on a basis of reabsorbtion of salts, to see whether such a doctrine of minimum hypothesis has not been misapplied. I).
W A l r K A N D T H E T R A C ' H E A L SYSTEM
Does an active l r a n q m r t of water occur in the tracheal system? This question is directly rclcvaiit in two ways: watcr uptake from the atmosphere (Sectior: I f , 13) could occur through the tracheal system and, again, active transport may bc involved i n the normal process of moving the fuid i n r h r trdcheole. Our discussion will start at a more elementary level than might seem necessary because no one has directly demonstratcd the precise nature of the moving substance in the tracheole of insect \. Consider threc moleculcs : oxygen, water and carbon dioxide. Water
A('l I V k 'IRANSPORT 01. WAlER
IN INSECTS
79
is the sniallcst in si/e whilc oxygcn lies about midway between water and C ' 0 2 . So far a \ ;ictual physical dill'usion is conccrncd it would heem a scnsiblc working a~wtnptiontllilt through membranes, biological or othcrwisc, water should pass about ten times as quickly as oxygen, while C O , would move correspondingly more slowly, when equivalent concentration gradients are disposed across a given membrane. We should be able to make useful inferences about the functioning of the tracheal system by piecing together isolated knowledge about one or other of these molecules into a general picture of the permeability of the whole system. But we run into anomalies from the start. As we have already noted, any attempt to demonstrate directly the respiratory function of the tracheal system by sealing the spiracular openings usually fails. Experiments such as those of Schneiderman (1953), who showed that the diapausing cecropia pupa opens its spiracles only occasionally to release accumulated CO,, similarly imply that the external cuticle is thoroughly impermeable to CO,. If the cuticle by virtue of its wax layer is extremely impermeable to water, which seems so very well established, then it ought to be two orders more impermeable to CO?. Yet there are some surprising exceptions. We can of course discount the generalization, which is not at all uncommon in elementary texts, that "insects lose their C'O, through the general body surface", and which almost certainly stenis from some early cxperimcnts on aquatic insects whose cuticles (t-!oldgatc, 1956; Bcument, 1961a) are now known to have thoroughly watcr-pcrmcablc areas through which oxygen and CO, must be able t o cxchttngc cfticicntly. H u t Wigglesworth ( I 954) summarizes data abcut a number of insects with quite high CO, transfer through the body surface of terrestrial forms including animals believed t o be really waterproof. Thorpe (1928) says that adult beetles loose CO, more through thc intcr-segmental membranes than the dark sclerotized regions; i!' both regions are covered by the epicuticular lipid laver one wonders w5y any <:02 at all should escape there. The author has found that one can rub a stag-beetle with coarse emery paper without getting detectable water-loss from it in dry .-if! Clearly, some fresh and very critical work is needed to elucidate this picture we have o f CO, physiology, but fortunately no such paradoxes mar thc correlation hctween oxygcn and water permeabilities. The supcr1ici:tl wax hycr is impcrmc:iblc to both. while the underlying bulk of the cuticlc is watcr-saturated, and will no doubt allow both oxygen and ('0,t o pas'; Ihrough it frccly. N o w the tracheal system is ;I modified and iiillcctcd cuticle. I-ockc ( 19%) has cxarnincd its relationship to cxtcrnal cuticle in grcat dctail :tiid one may conclude from the homology
ur A M E N T that the bulk of the tracheal tube is composed of protein, partly tanned 80
J.
w.
I..
and intercrystallized with some chitin. Thc layer immediately next the lumcn of the tube is an “epicuticle”; this has a “cuticulin” laminaa tanned and polymeriscd lipoprotein. There are no dermal cementforming glands such as are associated with the external integument, so that if a wax layer is present which is at all comparable with that of the main cuticle it will be exposed at the surface of the lumen. In the absence of any direct method for demonstrating this we must proceed by inference. Onc of the very few ways of showing the site of oxygen exchange in a tracheal system involves the injection of reduced methylcne blue into the haenlocoel (Martin, 1893); it is re-oxidized only at the stellate end cclls containing the trachcoles, and remains reduced even when very close to the tracheal tubcs themselves. From this we infer that water can readily pass through the tracheolc but not through a trachea. (The trachea is extracellular and formed similarly to the general cuticle; the tracheole is intracellular and is not moulted. Little is known of the chemistry of the tracheolar membrane but it is apparently not chitinous and it may very well consist of a single layer of protein.) It is true that claims have been made for experiments demonstrating the exchange of gases through the trachea, but all relate to aquatic insects or to dipterans which seem able to provide exceptions to every entomological generalization. On grounds of oxygen permeability it does look as though the tracheal tubes could have a wax layer which must be absent from the tracheole. Tt is most difficult to persuade liquid water to enter the tracheal system through thc spiracles. This fact has not only been demonstrated repeatedly in all kinds of experiments, i t is also an essential feature of the success of tracheal respiration with open spiracles in tlic aquatic medium (e.g. Brocher, I9 IS ; Beamcnt, 1962). Many aquatic insect larvae have cxternal cuticles which are readily wetted by water and some of them are also rcadily pcrmcated by water, but their spiracles and trachea1 tubes arc cxtrcmely hydrofuge. The nature of these surfaces, which retain a very low adhesion to water although continually submerged in it, can only bc explained by assuming a molecular surface of closely packed --(--I I:, groups of paraflinic matcrial (see Section V, B). One must equally presume that such a surface of highly organized lipid must be present on the luminal surface of tracheal tubes of terrestrial insects so as to give them thcir wetting propcrtics, especially since the air in these tubes may bc permanently saturated with water vapour. If watcr is forccd into the tracheal system it is not possible to observe the form of the meniscus, in part because of the corrugation of the tubes,
A C ' I I V E T R A N S P O R T OF W A ' I E R I N I N S E C T S
81
so that the rtdhcsion of the surface cannot thus be directly measured. An alternative approach is however posGble, starting from an interesting and hitherto uncxplained phenomenon first reported by Pal (1950). If a drop of watcr is placed, for example, on the external cuticle of the leg of a cockroach and in close proximity to a large tracheal trunk, minute water droplcts appear inside the trachcal tube near the external drop. Such explanation as has so far been offered seems to suggest that watcr is transferred through the cuticlt, across the blood and then secreted into the nearest trachea-as remarkable a case of the active transport of water as could be envisaged. Leaving any of the implicd mcmbranc phenomena on one side, the assimilation of the water into thc blood would in itself prevent any localized action at the nearest trachea. Unpublishcd experirncnts by the author indicate a rather different explanation. Droplets can be produccd in trachcal tubes by placing methyl or ethyl alcohd, acetone, ether, or any of these in dilution with water on an area of external cuticle adjacent to a trachea. Some of these substances :ire admittedly efficient wax solvents when i n the pure state, but they h a w little effcct on wax when diluted with a n equal quantity of water. The phenomenon is most marked when very volatile liquids are used : many droplets are formed in the tube and they drip into the lumen. On the oth'yr hand, neither glycerine nor liquid paraffin produce detectable effect Wow if a cockroach is so held that one limb can be inserted into a thiii-bhl;illcd glass tube which has one side flattened, reasonable obscrvation by microscope of thc tracheal trunks in the leg may be made through the flattened region even if the tubc is filled with water. In thcse experiments, the obscrvation tube was connected through a Y-junctim and taps to two rcservoirs each containing water whose tcmpcraiurc was c;ircl'ully cnntrollcd. Thc tcnipcrature of the animal's limb couid thus he :tdjustcd by Ilowing watcr through the surrounding jacket. Idc;il cxpcrimcntal circirmstanccs obtain if one vcssel of water is at 0.2 C'cntigradc clcgrec above mnbicnt, thc otlier a similar interval of tcmpcr;tturc bclow ambicnt. If thc coldcr watcr is run i n t o the glass tube, droplcts imtnediiitcly appear throughout thc tr;1cheiil trunks of the leg ;ind drip continuously. If' the flow is switchcd to the hotter supply, all droplcts disippcar at once. The proccss can be reversed and repeated at will. Thc evidcncc suggcsts that precipitation in a tracheal tube can be produced by ;I very small reduction in temperature-by applying a cooler fuid or through thc latent heat of cvaporation of fluid on the surface. Liquids at the same tcmpcrature as the insect which are not volatile do not produce cooling and thus no condensation.
82
J. W. L. 1 3 E A M E N T
Of course the temperature of thc tracheal lumen will not change to exactly that of thc surrounding water jacket so that a very small decrease indeed suficcs to produce condensation. From dew-point tables one finds that the reduction in temperature at 2 0 T , needed to cause condensation from 99 R.H., is 0.13 Centigrade degree. The experiments make it clear that for all practical purposes the air in the tracheal system is williin 1 Po of saturation with water vapour. Several points of interest follow from these experiments. Since many minute droplets form and remain discrete, dripping rather than coalescing, the surface against which they form must have a high contact angle; the maintenance of this high contact angle in the presence of saturated or near-saturated air in turn requires something like the system of packed -CH, groups which one postulated on the evidence of the difficulty of introducing water into the spiracle. The general picture we have developed matches the scheme proposed (Beament, 1962) for the evolution of hydrofuge wax layers and for the physiological emptying of the tracheal systcni by overturning an inverted monolayer while the lumen of the tubc is still filled with water (see Section V, B). Next, if the walls of the tracheal tubes are so waxed and thus so impermeable to water, then elsewhcre in the respiratory system there must bc some surface sufficiently permeable to provide the saturated conditions throughout. The only source for such evaporation of water is the tracheoles, but before wc consider them further, we have already established a most importmt point in relation to Section 11, B above. In a purely physical system, water vapour will not have a net rate of transfer by diffusion into the near-saturated air of the tracheal lumen, except from air of an even higher humidity, whatever may go on in the tracheole. In other words, even if experiments such as those of Govaerts and Leclercq (1946) showed that there is a very high rate of exchange between atmospheric water and the body fluids of insects, almost certainly through the tracheal system, there is no possibility that the tracheal system can act as part of a mechanism for the active uptake of atmospheric water from the air. We must therefore concentrate our attention an thc gcncral external cuticle when we subsequently come to discuss pumps working against the atmosphere. The tracheole wall must bc freely permeable to oxygen and thus correspondingly we now bclicve t o water; its walls must therefore be saturated with water and hc readily wetted by water. Is the substance which is seen to movc in the trachcole liquid water? The external diameter of the largest tracheole which can be examined by the light microscope is well below Ip, and the lumen will be still smaller. Thc external
<:
A ( ' I I V I . 'I I < h N S I ' O K ' I 0 1 . WA'I E R I N I N S E C T S
83
di;ttiictcr 01 ;i typicid tubc I s 0.4 0.2 1 4 tapering down to 0.05 p, with corres~~c~ritliri~ly \iniillcl- internal diitmctcrs. The resolving power of the light microwope is 0.2 p , and no othcr mcthod of direct observation can be uscJ on living tiiatcrial; greater magnification requires the use of dehydratcd 1ni~tcri;iI.What one usually sees under the light microscope i s ;in interfc'rcncc pattern: air from the trachea continucs into the tracheole so that it contains distally a niedium of refractive index very dill'erent to the surrounding ccllular material. There is a sharp boundary between the air and tltc content of thc portion of the tracheole towards its inner end, whcrc the substance has a refrxtive index close to that of water or cell content, and when so filled the tracheole cannot necessarily be clearly discerned. The sharp boundary is seen to movc under conditions of respiratory necd and obvious!! the length of the air column in the tube incrcascs, but it will never be possible to see the meniscus or the appearance o f the natural fluid content. This tracheolar Huid must be aqueous and if it is in equilibrium with at least 90'';j K . f 1 . i t cannot contain more dissolved substance than would givc i \ n osmotic prcssure of about 10 atm. I t may be even more dilute. 'I'hc lluid i n the tritchcolc moves in a rational manner correlated with thc oxygen rcquircnient o f thc animal and with a n increase in the osmotic pressure of the ilnit11;tl's blood through thc accumulation of n~ctitholitcs(Wigglcswort h, 1954). Now however thc force moving the fluid is produced, i t will only move ifthat force isgreater than thecapillary forcc acting u p thc tube; for any given static position within the tube, thcrc m u a t be a i i cquilibrium between thc forcc inwards and the capillary forcc ;it that particular intcrnal diameter of tube. The pressure up a c:ipill;iry i4 given h!, tlic rrlationship:
p
2 TcosO -:
j.
wherc P is pressure 7' is surface tension (/ is angle of contact I' is riidius of tubc.
I t wnuld appear jusiilicd (see Adam, 1948; Champion and Davy, 1941) to use this rclationship to sires of tube down to 0.05 p diameter, but with tubes of thc order of041 p diaincter there will be circumstances in which the h~hitviourof individual niolccules enters into the considerat i o n ol' tlic incniscus ;IS it htatisticiil assemblage. There is no simple trc:il n i w t ol'tlic movcniont of capilhry lluids in an annularly corrugated fiihc hut twtain awtnptions c;in I ~ Cmade (Fig. 1). For angles ofcontact /c'ro and c l o x to K I - O . tlicrc will bc t w o positions wifiiin each cycle of cc)rrtipiltion iii whit% tlic \urt'acc tcn\iori forcc will be acting along the
84
J . W. L. B E A M E N T
direction of the tube: wherc thc angle of contact is zero with respect to the axis of t11e tube. One of these will be of maximal force (minimum diamctcr) and the other of smaller force (maximum diameter). The part of the tube between maximum and minimum radius will behave just as a tapering tube. When the fluid is being caused to retreat down the tube, it will be thc maximum forcc which has to be overcome, and the fluid will retrcat in a series of minute steps corresponding to annuli. Provided thc angle of contact is low or tero, the effective capillary force will therefore be that in a parallel-sided tube of diameter equal to the minimum intcrniil radius of the annular constrictions. Because the proteinaccous walls are freely pcrmcable to water and saturated with it thc angle of contact must be closc to zcro, and because we are dealing
I-IG. I . Pixitions of ;I meniscus in an annularly corrugated tube, seen in longitudinal section. (A) Contact angle: 0 . Maximum capillary force at minimum diameter; lower capillary forcc at iiiaximiim diametcr. (B)Contact angle small.
with a cosine function thc cRect of small departures from zero will have a ncgligiblc clrccl o n t h s ciipillary force in any case. What is the moving substance in the tracheole? Bult (1939) made the suggcstion that thc tracheolc could be open at its inner end, from which it could follow that thcrc could he a pseudopodium working by protoplasmic or amoeboid movcmcnt. As the so-called surface tension of a naked cell is 0.2 dync/cni (cf. some 72 dync/cm for water) this would solve all problems. Hut the original electron micrograph (Fig. 2) shows no protoplasmic or other solid inclusion in the tube, and the tracheole tcrminatcs blindly in the closing of a single annulus. This picture of a tracheole of R h d n h s also suggests that the annuli are equally spaced regardless of diameter and are very regular, and it shows the extent of
A < . I I V t T R A N S P O R T O F W A I E R 1'4 I N S E C T S
85
the restriction of the lumen by the annular folds. The end and side wall are not visibly diffcrcntiatcd so that we must assume equal activity in the transport of fluids across the whole tracheolar wall. If the tracheole is intracellular, there is no cell membrane outside it. This is important when considering the speed at which fluid passes through the walls, for ordinary cell membranes can be comparatively impermeable to water. Thus if we convert the units of values obtained by Kitching (1954) for the cell wall of protozoa to rng water transferred through 1 cm2 surfa'ce per h we find : Amoeba (fresh water: say 10 atm 0.p. difference) Ciliates (from figures quoted per atm) Impermeable insect (Rhodnius) in dry air Tracheole emptying in 6 sec
0.3 units 0.72 units 0-1 units 6.0 units
I'Ici. 2. A n original electron micrograph of the end of a tracheole of Rhodnius, showing the blind ending and annular corrugation. Taken on an electron microscope in thc Cavcndish Laboratory, Cambridge. x 37500.
This docs not mean to say that a cell membrane is comparable in permeability with an insect cuticlc; but it does mean either that a trachcole wall i s an order more permeable than a protozoan cell
86
J. W . I . . I S 1 A M I N ' I
tiicnihraiic o r t h a t tlic l'otcc n i o ~ i t i pwater through i t is ,)f'thc order of I00 at I l l . tact L I t~ i n t siipposc [ h i i t ;I simple ori m ) l i c' systcni i \ working: thiit tlic tr;ichcolc yall i 4 sciiii-pet nicablL-. 'Then for i i n y position i n thc tubc there will be a n equilibrium bctwcen t h e t//#crcwc.t~in intcrnal i L t I C 1 rxtcnial osmotic prcssurcs (ccll contcnt and fluid i n tube) ~ i n dthe capillary forcc up the tube. If, when the tube is full, it contains f u i d of osmotic pressure cqual to t h a t i n the cell, therc bill be no net osmotic pressure to meet the capillary force. Such a systcni will require a lower osmotic pressure in thc tube even at equilibrium with the tube full. Next, if only water is removed from tlie tube its contents will concentrate. Considering only tlie situation i n ;I pnrallel-sided tubc. and hence constant capillary
force. a niassivc increase in celluliir osniot ic pressure due t o accumulation of metabolites, such a s from 10 to 17 a t n i osmotic pressure. would only ;illow n small percent;ige of traclicoltir water to be removed before equilibrium wcrc re-established: X",, if the tracheole fluid starts a t 10 atm. 5 0 " , if the fluid has as little osmotic pressure as 2 atm when the tube is full. Therefore, t o obtain the observed degree of rcmoval of fluid from a parallel-sided tracheolar tube, it must contain effectively pure wdter. If it contains pure water, we must then see if that transport must be active. Suppose, on tlie other hand, that there is a n aqueous solution which is pumped. solute and solvent together, through the walls so that there is no concentration effect. This rules out classical osmosis. So long as surface-active agents are not present, pure water o r a solution of salts of the order of I p'; concentration will have a surface tension of the order of 72 dynes/cm. O n the assumption of contact angles close t o zero, the capillary pressure for tubes of various sizes will have orders: Diameter ( p ) 0.4 0.2 0.1
0.05
Capillary force (atm) 7.5 15
30 60
As the effective diameter of the corrugated capillary is its minimal internal diameter, these figures for pressures may have t o be doubled. O n the other hand. a surface active agent could reduce the surface tension by a factor of two or three at most (see suggestion made by the author, reported in Wigglesworth, 1953). Such an agent would have to work without reducing water and oxygen permeability and without any risk of interfering with waterproofing waxes. But even supposing a
,A(
I IVI., I R A N S I * O Rr O I W A T C K I N I N S I ; C ~ S
87
surface-activc agcnt, the c:ipilliiry force in thc fine endings of the Lrachcolc will t,c at Icast twicc thc osmotic pressure of the cell. The othcr fcaturc pre\cnted by the Table is even morc significant: whatever the surface tension, in a tapering tube the change in capillary force covers an eight- or ten-fold range, so that the cellular force must also change over this range, regardless of any concentration erect discussed in the previous paragraph. Continuing with the suggestion that a solution occurs in the tube, the solute will collide randomly with the walls. If only one molecule of solute in every million collisions is actively removed through the wall, then 9 5 % of solute will be removed from a tube 0-5 p diameter in 1 msec and from a tube 0.05 p diameter in 0.1 msec. There would be no difficulty in visualizing the active removal of the solute. The demonstration by Bult (1939) that substances interfering with cell membrane ionic transport prevent tracheoles from emptying is only very indirectly relevant; it may indicate the importance of the tracheolc cell-wall pumping into the blood, but there is no suggestion that such materials could interfere with the permeability of the tracheole wai I. We conclude that the tracheole cannot work by classical osmosis, and that the minimal force, assuming the best of all circumstances, which must be provided in the tracheole cell to remove the content of the tube must vary between 2 and 20 atm, with the possibility of being three times this. The limited concept of “active transport” defined earlier required that water moved from a place where it was at a lower concentration to a place where it was at a higher concentration. This is an “energy” concept-the energy could be put in by moving a second substance which passively carried the water. In the tracheole, water either moves from a higher concentration into a lower one, or the levels of activity are identical on both sides of the membrane, but in moving great capillary forces are overcome. So far as the specification of an energy consuming process is concerned, the idea of “active transport” is equally applicable to any case in which either the movement of water takes place contrary to the physical forces working in the system, or even where the rate at which water moves is greater than that calculated from the physical forces in the system. Within this context, water is moved against forces varying between wide limits, and certainly against 20 atm capillary pressure. If the liquid in the tracheole is pure water, the case for active transport is absolute. If a solute is present, it cannot occur in greater quantity than say one molecule (or ion) to every 100 of water, so that in the most
xx
J . W. 1.. B I : A M E N T
favourablc circumstawcs cach unit of' actively transported solute would havc to movc ICK) niolecules of water against capillary pressures of 10 or 20 atm. At the end of this Section we shall briefly consider the codiffusion system of Diamond (1962), but even if we take the most favourable conditions, co-diffusion will not transport water on this scale against such forces. Until proved otherwise, it is sensible to adopt the attitude that the movement of fluid through the wall of the tracheole involves a n active transport of water. Wigglesworth's conclusions in 1951, arrived at by other arguments, were not as outspoken but may be interpreted as implying the same thing. What is of more general import is that the movement of fluid in tracheoles is probably commonplace in insects. Wigglesworth (1954) states that there are insects in which the tracheoles are always found full, or always empty; but this in itself must mean that osmosis cannot be playing any part in the mechanism.
E. T H E L I V I N G C U T I C L E A N D L I Q U I D WATER
Before we turn to physical experiments and possible mechanisms for directing the movement of water, some simple biological experiments which have not previously been reported are relevant. They form a direct link between the biological and physical aspects of this discussion. The physico-chemical nature of cuticular lipid is reviewed below in some detail, and in order to understand these new experiments it is necessary only to know that the cuticle of the living cockroach has, exposed at its surface, a layer of grease of the order of 0.2-03 p thick, i.e. several times thicker than a vertically orientated monolayer of that grease, and that the grease will spread over the surface of water at biological temperatures (Ranisay, 1935). The grease molecules have one paraffinic ending which is very hydrofuge, and one polar ending attracting water strongly. If a drop of water is placed on a suitable impermeable solid surface, and grease applied to it, a film spreads over the drop (Beament, 1958a). This film is probably one monolayer thick, but tightly packed and organized, so that it has great impermeability to water. As a result, the droplet takes a very long time to evaporate in dust-free dry air at temperatures below 30"C, compared with an ungreased droplet: a drop of volume 0.5 mm3 would requirc hours to evaporate completely instead of a fcw minutes. Thus when similar drops of water are directly applied to the surface of a living cockroach, grease spreads over the water; the drop is sitting on a layer of grease which from experiments on rates
A C T I V E TRANSPORT OF WATER I N INSECTS
89
of evaporation from living or dead cockroaches (Ramsay, 1935; Wigglesworth, 1945; Beament, 1945, 1958a) is presumed to be very impermeable to water. Thus, as Ramsay found in 1935, drops can remain in dry air for several hours, while the water evaporates slowly. But some of these droplets do disappear in about 10 min: this will happen with a drop of 0.5 mm3 at laboratory temperatures of about 15°C.
If this water travels into the animal (and one can prove that this is what happens), the actual rate of transfer through the cuticle is between lo3 and lo4 times as rapid as the rate of transfer outwards when the animal is losing water into dry air. So either the permeability of the cuticle changes in some way, or the actual forces moving the water must be enormously greater than those governing evaporative transpiration, or something more complex occurs. Perhaps the most striking indication that vital activities are involved in this phenomenon is given by the discovery that there is an anatomical pattern of areas with different rates of uptake : identical sized droplets placed simultaneously on one living cockroach disappear in times varying from 10 min to 2 or 3 h, depending on the part of the cuticle they cover. The pattern is relatively consistent from one individual to another, and it may be described most concisely by saying that water disappears most quickly through the hard, dark, thick parts of the cuticle, most slowly where the cuticle is pale, soft and thin. The same principle appears to hold whether nymphs or adults are used; intersegmental membranes of nymphs and the thin dorsal abdominal cuticle of adults behave similarly, while the tegmen, and the head or dorsal sclerites of nymphs and adults, are areas where water disappears quickly. At first sight the correlation between the nature of the underlying cuticle and the rate of removal of water is completely contrary to expectation. But the living epidermis must be involved in the phenomenon, for droplets disappear at the same rate regardless of site on anaesthetized animals. If one uses an animal whose two cuticles have separated prior to ecdysis, the droplets shrink so slowly that one can account for their disappearance byevaporation into the air. This last observation confirms the proposal that a droplet placed on the animal is completely waterproofed on its external surface, just as is a greased droplet on an impervious plate. The spreading of grease over such a small surface is accomplished in a fraction of a second. A naive investigation into the nature of a force causing water to move inwards from a droplet on the surface of the living animal has produced much of interest if little in explanation. If the inward force is
90
I W . I-. I % I . A M I Y I
“osmotic” ,ind arises from the internal concentration of solutes in cell or blood or even inner cuticlc, thcn one should be able to place a solution of such strength on the animal’s surface that a droplet remains constant in sim, and indeed a droplet of such concentration that it would swell by drawing water out of the animal. Surprising as is the discovery that a droplet of 1 ”/, NaCl disappears from the cuticle in a time sensibly the same as that in which a droplet of pure water would have been removed from such a site, it is not as difficult to comprehend as the culminating experiment in which water is removed from saturated salt solutions through the hard dark cuticle, leaving solid crystals of sodium chloride on the outside of the animal-circumstances in which the animal is working against “osmotic pressures” of the order of 300 atm. A very significant fact emergcs from this kind of experiment: cockroaches will remove water from saturated solutions of sodium cyanide and sodium fluoride placed on their cuticles, again leaving the salt on the surface, in circumstances where the quantities of these poisons which were applied far exceeded the lethal dose. The animals showed no harmf u l symptoms. Solutions of sodium azide did produce rapid death but this azide is appreciably oil-soluble. Therefore, from the point of view of function as an ion-filter, the grease film under the droplet must be an almost perfect semi-permeable membrane, even if the nature of the transporting machinery acting through that film is completely outside the range of conventional osmosis. Once again we have an example here of the uptake of water by an insect which must unquestionably involve the expenditure of energy from an outside source. In circumstances which are far simpler for us to appreciate, it outlines much of the phenomena we have suspected in the tracheole, and demonstrates even more clearly the need for the extended view of “active” transport. When pure water is placed on the animal it moves down a concentration gradient, but it does so at rates which vary considerably, and the fastest of these is much greater than the physical circumstances would predict. When there is no concentration difference, defined in terms of osmotic pressures of the external solution and the blood, the water still moves quickly; when there is an enormous concentration gradient against which the water moves, we have active transport in its narrowest sense unaccompanied by ions or other transport. Obviously the same forces and the samevital mechanism arc acting in all instances, and all merit the description “active transport” even if only the experiments using strong solutions do on inspeclion justify the description active transport of water itself.
A C T I V E T K A N S P O R ’ I Of I,.
W A T E R I N INSECTS
91
cot-.<; L u s I O N S
A nunibcr o f terrestrial arthropods show the facility to move water by thc expenditure of cnergy under circumstances which grade continuously from simple examples of the movement of water alone up a concentration gradient, through examples where the rates of movement arc high in comparison with expectcd diffusive and osmotic movement, to those whcrc salts are also involved, or where large forces other than those represented by concentration difference are easily overcome. In most Circumstances movement takes place through a cuticular type of membrane backed by a cellular layer such as an epidermis. Expressed in conventional terms the cuticle extracting water from saturated salt solutions or from air of less than 70% R.H. exhibits “osmosis” equivalent to 300 atm; the tracheole may produce 60-100 atm pressure and the hind-gut up to 20 atm pressure. The blood and cellular osmotic pressure of insects is of the order of 10 atm. It remains to be seen whether all these different phenomena could be explained in terms of one mechanism. As Diamond (1962) clearly points out, the demonstration that water will move up a concentration gradient is not necessarily a demonstration of the active transport of water itself if anything else is moved at the same time. In the roach (the fish Rirfilusrutilus) water is carried through the wall of the gall-bladder against a concentration gradient. Diamond shows that thc transport of water could not be accounted for by filtration, classical osmosis or electro-osmosis. He then applies the irreversible thermodynamics of Kedem and Katchalsky (1 958) and concludes that his observed rate of water movement could be accounted for by co-diffusion, the energy being provided in the transport of ions in the water. This carries onc stage further the general contention that if physiological plicnomena can be explained without assuming a n active transport of water itself, then an active transport of water per se is ruled out of consideration. Howevcr, we claim in the preceding discussion to have established two kinds of instance-atmospheric absorbtion and rectal absorbtionin which water moves up a concentration gradient without being associated with other transported substance. Here, active transport of water in its own right surely cannot he denied! Closely parallel with these eases we have examples of water transport involving ions, but some have perfectly semi-permeable membranes in the system: others do not. The circumstances fall outside the Kedem-Katchalsky system and merge into them. Consequently, we are prepared to argue that not only in all
92
J . W. L. REAMENT
thcse systems, active transport of water must be considered, but also that others who have so far eliminated active water transport on a basis of minimum hypothesis should be prepared to reconsider. We shall now turn to a discussion of the mechanisms involved in the active transport of water.
IIr. A N
I N T E R R E L A T I O N B E T W E E N G R E A SAE ND
ABSORBTION
This short section outlines evidence suggesting a very clear relationship between water uptake through the cuticle and the behaviour of grease molecules. The contact angle between water and a surface gives a direct measure of .the adhesion of water to that surface. Thus, both theoretically and practically, when water is placed on the exposed monolayer of an aquatic insect (Holdgate, 1955 as interpreted by Beament, 1960a) and therefore against a packed array of -CH3 groups of organized lipid, there is a contact angle of the order of 130" (Fig. 3C). If a
I
B
A
D
E
C
F
FIG.3. Behaviour of small water-droplets on a living cockroach, interpreted in terms of rearrangement of the polar lipid. The convention used for a lipid molecule is shown on the extreme left. For further explanation, see text.
surface is made up entirely of the polar groups (Fig. 3B) it should attract so milch water that the contact angle should be at or below 30". The grease on a cockroach is thick, and in molecular terms thermal agitation produces a random arrangement in the bulk of the grease above a basal monolayer. Statistically, therefore, the molecules in the outermost surface onto which a water-droplet is applied should present some hydrofuge -CH3 endings, some hydrophil polar endings, and some chains sideways on. This ought to have a contact angle intermediate between the extreme cases, and indeed the contact angle on immediate application of a waterdroplet is about 80"(Fig. 3A).
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T OF W A T E R IN INSECTS
93
However, the contact angle does not remain constant; over the following 3 min or so (depending on tcmperature) from the moment of application, the contact angle falls to around 30', indicating that in the presence of water the hydrophilic endings are preferentially held in the interface, so that an "inverted" monolayer is formed under the droplet (Fig. 3B). Now from the profile of the droplet its volume can also be determined, and it is important to observe that while this change in the underlying surface is taking place the drop does not change in volume. Only after the surface beneath the drop has reached maximum hydrophilic property does it appear that water can move into the animal at the surprisingly high rate described in Section 11, E. It has already been suggested that grease spreads over a water-droplet on the cuticle and forms a packed and orientated monolayer (Fig. 3D). Thus, immediately a droplet has been absorbed by the animal, the molecular surface of the area of absorbtion should be this collapsed monolaycr surface (Fig. 3E). If one adds a further droplet to this site immediately, the contact angle is at first 130" (Fig. 3F). More grease spreads from the surrounding area onto the droplet outer surface. Now the contact angle over 3 min or so falls to 80" indicating a breakdown in the erect monolayer under the water, and, over a further interval of time, it falls to 30 ' indicating complete inversion of the lipid molecules. Throughout this preliminary period of 6 or 7 min, the drop does not decrease in volume. On the other hand, if one places a droplet on a fresh surface, allows grcasc orientation under it to occur, and the droplet to be almost completely absorbed, and then introduces a second volume of water into the rapidly disappearing droplet, absorbtion continues unabated and the contact angle remains steady at around 30". Whatevcr preparation for fast absorbtion is necessary, it includes the formation of an inverted monolayer at the interface between the water and the rest of the animal. Also, because of the interval of time for monolayer inversion, the period of 10 min on a fast absorbing area, from the time of application of the drop to its disappearance, contains only perhaps 7 min for actual uptake. So far as can be seen, over the areas of the animal where absorbtion is very slow, the molecular rearrangements are nevertheless complcted in about 3 min; it is the actual process of absorbtion which is slow. Temperaturc has only a small cffect on the rate of overturning of the grease molecules, presumably because the basic process is a kinetic one of random movement. But over the range 15-25"C, there is Q,,, of the order of three-suggesting a high temperature sensitivity of the absorbtion mechanism. This need not indicate a "biological" reaction as is
94
J. W. L. ISEAMENT
sometimes automatically claimed from such evidence. Danielli and Davson (1952) show that high temperature coefficients may be associated with, for cxamplc, transport through relatively impermeable lipid films which involve activated diffusion : where only those molecules of sufficiently high energy amongst the difiusant can pass through a resistant barrier in a membrane. A. A MODEL A B S O R B I N G WATER
A model of the system described in the previous section can be set up by removing the epidermis from a thoracic tergite of a cockroach and mounting it as a membrane, with its grease layer intact. The epidermis side is completely enclosed with a small volume of air, containing a pellet of phosphorus pentoxide, and then the whole preparation placed in a desiccator so as to remove all free water from the membrane. With the dry membrane, a water-droplet placed on the greasy side is waterproofed by grease spreading over its surface. It remains for so long that its disappearance can be accounted for by evaporation. If a little water is now sprayed against the epidermis-side, a droplet on the grease disappears very quickly indeed. On adding fresh droplets of water, similar phenomena to those observed on the living cuticle occur; after initial molecular reorganization water is absorbed, but the rate of absorbtion falls as the cuticle membrane becomes saturdted with water. However interesting the anomolous behaviour of this model when the cuticle is completely dry, that is outside the range of biological possibility. Water deficient cuticle in the dead state can provide sufficient force to absorb liquid water through a thick grease film at rates which are comparable with the living integument.
I V . T H EP H Y S I C ACLH E M I S T ROYF THE CUTICLE A certain amount is known about the materials in the bulk of the insect cuticle, and a great deal has been discovered about the epidermis (e.g. reviews by Wigglcsworth, 1948, 1957; Richards, 1951, 1958). Much has recently been discovered about the waterproofing lipids on thecuticle (c.g. review by Bcamcnt, 1961b). Little indeed is known in comparison about the tracheole or the gut-linings. The external cuticle obviously represents the bcst matcrial for invcstigating possible mechanisms of water regulation and active transport, and offers the possibility that discoveries or principles could be applied to the other systems.
A < ” I I V f : ‘I H A N S P O K ’ I 0 1 ; W A T E R I N I N S E C T S
95
A . ’rI1E C I J I I C L oTHtK ~ THAN LIPID LAYER
Watcr is to be transferred from the outside environment through a layer of lipid, layers of epicuticle, layers of protein-chitin complex, the cell membrane and cytoplasm of the epidermal cell, another cell membrane, and thence to the blood (Fig. 4). Whatever energy-consuming process we postulate for active transport must be spatially associated with the living material. Thus (e.g. Beament, 1960b), an actual physical gradient of water-activity, down which water will move by normal physical process, must be created through the non-living layers which are extracellular. We can now specify this prerequisite in addition to molecular rearrangement of the lipid in the example of uptake from liquid water against the surface. }Lipid 0 2p ]Lipoprotein epicuticle
1
.
1 1
0
1 A
0
1
0
o 2~
Procuticle 1-2O/r -Pore conols
Cellular
epidermis
A-.-
FIG.4. A diagrammatic section through an insect cuticle indicating the main layers referred to in the text, and their order of thickness.
The lipoprotein epicuticle or “cuticulin” (Wigglesworth, 1947) is an extremely inelastic substance (Bennet-Clark, 1962) corresponding to the physico-chemical properties one would predict from its composition: the protein is so tightly bound and cross-linked with both lipid and poly-phenolic tanning materials that it cannot swell, and most of the hydratable groups of the original protein will have been used up in the cross-iinking proccss. Therefore if a gradient is to be created in the purcly physical part of the system, it must be produced by lowering the watcr activity in the protein-chitin complex of exo- and endo-cuticle (rcfcrrcd to below by Richards’ term “procuticle”) and this in turn must be mediatcd through the action of the living cells upon it. In this connection, the curious disposition of that characteristic structure of many insect cuticles, the pore canals, may be significant. Although many functions have been ascribed to pore canals (see reviews
96
J. W. L. BEAMENT
quoted above), cuticles devoid of such structures, as, for example, those of the silkworm (Ito, 1953), are entirely morphologically homologous and very largely physiologically analogous with cuticles containing pore canals. But pore canals with cytoplasmic filling are present in the cuticles of animals showing active uptake of water, and would enable the living material to make the most intimate contact throughout the thickness of the chitin-protein complexes, to modify it for the creation of the necessary physical gradient. This view is supported by the evidence of Lees (1947) who showed that the ageing adult tick, which can no longer extract water from sub-saturated atmospheres, has filled its pore canals with solid and probably chitinous material ;it also tallies with the discovery reported earlier that liquid water is not absorbed by the cockroach when in the pre-ecdysial state of having two cuticles and when the pore canal content has been withdrawn from the outer cuticle. B. T H E H Y D R A T l O N O F P R O C U T I C L E
Both the characteristic protein arthropodin, and the polysaccharide chitin, have many hydratable side-chains and groupings. They differ in that those of chitin are not usually considered to be strongly ionizable, so that water associated with chitin will be bound by van der Waals forces, whereas the protein with its strong acidic and basic groups binds water through electrical forces as well as through London and similar forces. The indications of experiments with models (Beament, 1954; Section 111, A) are that a comparatively small degree of dehydration will produce great imbibitional forces with respect to water; all the water which is associated with the chitin-protein complex is strongly attracted. Of course arthropodin (see Rudall, 1963) is very different from the kinds of protein which have recently been suggested as models for the active transport of sugars, ions etc., and in mechanisms such as chelation (e.g. Christensen, 1962; Harris, 1960; Bayliss, 1959). Cellular proteins, perhaps even the special class of cell-membrane proteins, may change their properties by actually folding and unfolding their secondary organization cyclically, thus presenting different configurations and templates for adsorption and desorption, or as carrier substrates. Such proteins may be further unfolded or rearranged, often by quite small changes in circumstances, so as to destroy their biological function entirely in the process commonly called denaturation. The late Sir William Astbury once referred to arthropodin as a protein “always in the denatured state”, which anachronism may be interpreted in modern terminology as meaning that it does not occur in a complexly folded
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T 01 W A T E R I N I N S E C T S
97
secondary structure. Arthropodin is intercrystallized with chitin, in a very stable association with both sets of chains straight, and can, for example, be compared with Pauling and Corey's (1951) model for &keratin. It is exceptionally stable; it does not appear to be changed in any way when, for example, it is heated by a 70 kV beam in the electron microscope or when the dead cuticle is stored for a long period. Chitin is likewise a most stable substance. For these reasons, membrane preparations of insect cuticle have the great advantage that they may be used for several days without any apparent decay of property. C. C O N T R O L O F P R O C U T l C L E B Y THE E P I D E R M I S
The elasticity of the chitinous cuticle of Rhodnius is under the control of the epidermis (Bennet-Clark, 1961, 1962). In preparation for the plastic expansion of the cuticle by the blood-meal, the animal can convert the chitin-protein part of the cuticle from a material resisting an inflationary pressure of some atmospheres to one which is expanded by an excess abdominal internal pressure of a fraction of an atmosphere. The nature of the control mechanism, which is brought about in life through the action of a plasma dialysate on the epidermal cell, is not fully understood; but in model experiments such changes in the procuticle can be produced in a number of ways, and can be explained on the general assumption that the hydration of the cuticle is altered with a consequent change in the intermolecular binding of the untanned protein and chitin complex. The cuticulin layer is not involved in these changes; it is complexly folded before expansion, and is unfolded when plastic extension of the underlying material takes place. Furthermore, it is the tensile strength of the inelastic cuticulin which sets the ultimate limit on the expansion of the abdomen by blood, despite the minute thickness of the epicuticle. Tanned lipoprotein is thus not under the control of the epidermal cell in this system, and Bennet-Clark's findings agree with thc suggcstions about the properties of this layer made in Section TV, A. It would now appear justified to propose that an epidermal cell can create changes in parts of the cuticle with which it makes direct contact, and that these changes can include control of hydration. Dehydration of the cuticle under the lipid can produce sufficient force to cause an inward current of water at a high rate. We have now to distinguish two effects rather carefully. The condition of hydration of a protein can be modified without nccessarily adding or extracting water; for example least water is bound by a protein at its iso-electric point, and the amount of water
98
J . W. L. B E A M E N T
associated with it incrcases rapidly as its pH is changed in either direction. A strong force, attracting water, can thus be produced or destroyed. Clearly an enormous force is nceded to remove the water bound onto protein by siniplc dehydration-thc force with which dehydrated protein attracts water. Thus one explanation which may be offered for the different rates at which water is taken up by thc different areas of the cockroach (Section 11, E) is that the underlying protein has different degrees of hydration. Indeed, if thc animal were actively making the hard, mechanically rigid cuticlc least plastic, we might expect it to keep the water-content of these areas at a low level while it maintained a very high level of hydration in the soft elastic cuticle for maximum plasticity. Such vital activity would-and does-disappear with anaesthesia or death. But we must not visualize such a mechanism as a simple removal of water, keeping the whole of the protein identical in property; the animal is more likely to adjust the hydration by adjusting the environment of the protein. Even if we have found a mechanism producing sufficient force to transport water inwards through the lipid, we still have not the basis of a continuous-flow active transport mechanism. Any force attracting water inwards through the lipid must act simultaneously in likewise drawing water out of the epidermal cell. We do not know the permeability of the epidermal cell membrane to water, or even if, in the pore canal, there is anything corresponding to a cell membrane-the pore canal is very small to contain a double cell membrane. Should the cell membrane prove as impermeable to water as that of a protozoan (Section IT, D), it is still perhaps one order more permeable than the outer lipid layer, and we must remember that transpiration from the whole animal appears unchanged when the insect dies (Section 11, B). Unless we can find an additional mechanism in the cuticle system, we can only propose the means of discontinuous uptake.
V. T H EC U T I C U L ALRI P I D Much of the evidence for the physico-chemical state and behaviour of cuticular lipid has been given in recent papers by the author (Beament, 1955, 1958a, 1959, 1960a, 1961a, b, c, d, 1962). Summarizing briefly, there is a sharp transition phenomenon in the relationship between tempcrature and permeability for many intact insect cuticles (Fig. 5). Using insects such as the cockroach, where the lipid is a mobile grease, the form of thc tcmperaturelpermeability relationship can be explained
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F W A T E R IN INSECTS
99
if one assumcs: one monolayer of lipid molecules against the cuticulin surface, which are so organized that the chains are tightly packed; overlying this monolayer, grease 20-30 times in thickness but with a random arrangement of molecules due to thermal agitation; the monolayer is five times as impermeable to water as is the randomly arranged grease; the monolayer is stable because of the special adhesion of its polar groups to its cuticulin substrate. When transition obtains (c. 30°C in Peripluneta umericana), the particular packing of the monolayer which produces its great impermeability is thermalfy destroyed and water traverses this region at approximately the same rate as through randomly arranged molecules. But it must be noted that, contrary to
Temperature ---t F~G. 5. Graph showing the form of the relationship between permeability of a monolayer of inscct grease on cuticle and its temperature. previous explanations which have been advanced (Beament 1958a, 1961b), evidence is given below suggesting that the change produced in the monolayer by heat is not its random disorganization. By comparison, an aquatic insect whose surface is extremely and permanently hydrofuge (such as Gyrinus) shows a transition increment with temperature, and an actual permeability, compatible with there being only one monolaycr of grease altogether on its cuticle surface. By extracting thc cuticular grease with solvents, and compressing it on a Langmuir Trough, thc area corrcsponds to the expected surface area of
100
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
the insect. The irregular surface of an insect is very difficult to assess (see also Lockey, 1960) but there is every possibility that the cuticle of a hydrofuge insect is covered by only one monolayer, and that the area of the extracted grease on a Trough is by far the most accurate assessment of the true surface area of an insect. Now it is the outer surface of this layer of grease molecules, with closely packed -CH,groups exposed, which gives the property of low adhesion to water on an aquatic insect. The presence of such a monolayer on a cockroach can be directly demonstrated by washing the animal (Fig. 6) with a spray of waterdroplets. Each droplet falling on the animal is coated with grease,
0
i
FIG.6. Method of washing acockroachwith a water-spray which (a) collects grease uncontaminated by solvents, and (b) produces an extremely hydrofuse surface covered by one monolayer.
which is carried away when the droplet falls off. After a time the whole of the thick grease is carried away; the animal then has a permanent high contact angle such as we associate with an insect like Gyrinus, an actual permeability similar to that of Cyrinus, a very large and sharp transitional break in its permeabilityltemperature relationship which we associate with one monolayer alone, and one can strip from it with solvents a quantity of grease which has the order of one cockroach surface-area when spread as a monolayer on a Trough. By washing with water one can similarly prepare dead cuticle membranes of the cockroach. These preparations are extremely important when considering the special physical properties of monolayers, which will be described below.
A C I I V I : T R A N S P O R T 0 1 W A T E R IN INSECTS
101
A. A NE W I N T E R P R E T A T I O N O t T K A N S l T l O N I N M O N O L A Y E R FILMS
The theory put forward (Beamcnt, 1958a, 1961b) to explain the transition phenomenon of sudden increase in thc permeability of the cockroach cuticle at about 30T, suggested that the organization in the monolayer was thermally destroyed : it became a random assemblage of molecules like the grease which is not in contact with an organizing substrate. Using the preparation described in the previous paragraph, this theory can be directly tested: the monolayer exposed by washing has a contact angle of 130" to a drop of clean water. But if such a preparation is heated complete with water-drop, to a temperature above transition (c. 35"C), the contact angle ought to fall at least to a value of about 80" as the grease molecules become disorganized, and perhaps to 30" through reorientation of the polar groups towards the water, just as happens when water-droplets are placed on the thick grease of the animal (Section 111; Fig. 3A-C). But no such change occurs. The contact angle falls by only perhaps some 10 degrees from 130".Transit.ion therefore occurs without the disorganization of the monolayer, at least in so far as that the -CH3 ends remain externally exposed, and the polar groups are still tied down to the substrate. Now different terrestrial arthropods display transition temperatures covering a very wide range (Beament, 1958, 1959, 1961), from as low as 22°C for Djvtiscus to values around 70°C for resistant pupae and some Argasids. There is a general correlation between the melting point of extracted lipid, the probable length of the paraffinic chain, and the transition temperature: the longer the chain, the higher the transition temperature. The stability of the monolayer depends on the van der Waals forces between the adjacent chains, and the link between the polar groups and the substrate. The link of the polar groups must be very strong-stronger for example than the affinity of a polar group for water; we would expect the polar groups of the waxes from many insects to be very similar, and hence to be alike in their affinity for a cuticulin type of substrate. Hence if thermal agitation were to overcome the adhesion of the polar group to the substrate we should expect all cuticular lipids to show transition at approximately the same temperature. We must however expect the much weaker van der Waals forces to be disrupted first, and the correlation indicates that the shorter chains with less inter-chain forces do go through transition at much lower temperatures than thc long-chain lipids. How can the disruption
102
J . W. L. D P A M E N T
of only the van der Wads forces give rise to a fivefold increase in permeability to water ? The conventional drawing of a monolayer of polar lipid (Fig. 7) shows the molccules as cigar-shaped cylinders with bulbous polar groups, standing vertically with respect to their long axes. Surface chemistry gave the first direct measurements of molecular dimensions and these representations are satisfactory diagrammatizations of the impressions thus obtained of molecules. The dangers of making too literal use of such models is no less great in the field of surface chemistry than in, for example, the contemporary plethora of models which give the principle but not the mechanism of the replication of protein by R.N.A. Nevertheless most surface chemists believe that molecules in a
FIG.7. Conventional drawing of molecules of a polar monolayer; cf. models in Fig. 8.
monolayer do stand exactly vertically, and whenever alternative suggestions have been made in the past, the pioneer of the science, N. K. Adam, always defended the principle of verticality. But it is obvious from these simple models that if the polar groups are larger in crosssection than the parafin chains, the chains cannot be tightly packed. Consider now a more up-todate molecular model of such a molecule (Fig. 8a) which is mainly based upon X-ray crystallography, electronbeam diffraction and similar techniques, and uses dimensions calculated by such workers as Pauling and his colleagues. The paraffin chain is a zig-zag of carbon atoms. The polar groups, especially if surrounded by hydration shells, are certainly larger in cross-section than the chains. But if one manipulates models of these molecules, one can find an arrangement with the axis of the chains at about 244' to the vertical, where the carbon atoms of adjacent chains inter-fit, with the chains off-set by one pair of carbons with respect to their neighbours (Fig. 8b)
A('1 IVI
I R A N S P O R T O F W A T F R IN I S S E C T S
103
F K , . 8. Models o f polar lipid. (a) A polar niolcculc. (b) A row o f molecules i n closcst packing inclined at 24; t o the vcrtical: suggested form below transition. (c) '1-hc samc molecules above transition, uitli iiiean vertical spacing.
104
J . W. 1,. I%! A M L N I
and with the polar group\ in equally closc contact. Such an arrangement will achievc closc packing o f chains, and bring the atoms within an atomic diameter of each other, so that strong van der Wads forces will bc dcveloped. On this basis, impermeability would be expected to be very high, and the arrangement still leaves the -CH, groups exposed at the outer surface. On the basis of a model of this kind it is also much easier to understand the wide differences in the permeability of monolayers of different substances, which differ only by small substitutions in the polar groups (e.g. Adamson, 1960). In conjunction with the radical suggestion made in the previous paragraph, it may be significant that saturated n-paraffins in bulk do crystallize with the long axis of the chain at an angle of 63' 20' to the plane passing through corresponding carbon atoms in adjacent chains, i.e. at an angle very similar indeed to that we propose from our models (Miiller, 1927); while the inter-fit of the zig-zag chains allows such a form of crystallization, it is not necessarily straightforward to see why this form of obliqueness occurs in the absence of polar groups. For clarity, a description has been given of a proposed molecular packing in one particular plane perpendicular to the substrate of the monolayer; a full treatment of this subject is ohviously beyond the scope of the present article (Beament, unpublished work): it must suffice to say that the crystal form in the monolayer must be monoclinic, and that thc model shown in Fig. 8 illustrates the principle. We must now consider what may happen when this newly proposed system is heated. The van der Waals forces along the chains are the weakest in the structure, and thermal agitation will break them first. The molecules can then display their increased thermal energy by vibrating the chains on their fixed polar ends, occupying a tnean vertical position (Fig. 8c) but statistically occupying the space between adjacent chains. Only the fixed nature of the substrate linkage would differentiate this state from a compressed liquid monolayer film on a water surface: the state could be referred to as a one-dimensional liquid. Between the chains there will therefore be much greater space, statistically, for the migration of water, as compared with the tily-packed solid state of the film. Yet the -CH8 groups continue to be exposed at the outer surface to give a high contact angle, and the maintenance of the position of the polar groups ensures immediate return to the solid state on cooling below transition-a characteristic feature of the grease-covered cuticle. A simplified treatment of the change in permeability to be expected when transition occurs from the tilt-packed system to the meanvertical system could be based on the size of the holes between the
AC"I I V I 3 H A N S I * O W I
oi
wA'rI:H
I N iNsEc'is
I05
chains of thc niodcl in the two sfatcs. A water molcculc in such a hole is travclling i n ;I porc o f i t \ o w n ordcr of dimcnsions and according lo Barrcr (194X) the pcrmcability might be governed by an equation of the general form suggcstcd by Knudsen (1909).This states that the rate of flow will be proportional to the cube of the radius of the hole. Such calculations give mean radii of holes of 0.338 and 0.59 A, and therefore a ratio of permeabilities of I :4.8.This is a remarkably close fit with experimentally determined values of fivefold increases for monolayers on water and on cuticles with monolayers, (Beament, 1958a, 1961a, and unpublished work) and the deduced increase in permeability of the monolayer beneath the thick grease of the intact cockroach. In truth, a relationship adequately describing the transferrence of a molecule through a system of this kind might very well contain a term involving the cubc of the radius of the pore, measured when the long-chain molccules arc i n a mean static position, but the idea that a water molecule does actually travel through a hole smaller than itself or even precisely of its own dimensions is hardly in keeping with modern ways of thinking. Molecules and their component atoms are not static in the solid state; water is likely to traverse the monolayer through holes temporarily occurring bCCdUSe of kinetic activity : holes which in the immediate vicinity of the water molecule will be bigger than the water. An individual hole may have only a transient existence, but provided we consider a sufficient area of monolayer we can say that a t any instant of time below transition holes will occur with a certain frequency per unit area. Above transition holes will occur with a greater frequency, and somc of these holes may be significantly larger. But the holes will occur with greater frequency because the van der Waals forces have decreased, and although the mean separation of the chains might have increased by a very small amount, we must remember that van der Waals forces are inversely proportional to the order of the sixth power , o f the distance separating the atoms, so that a small increment in separation may have a surprisingly large effect.
R. M O N O L A Y E R I N V E R S I O N
Based upon permeability measurements, insects such as Dytiscus appear to have one orientated monolayer on their surface (Beament, 1961a). If this is a normal monolayer, the whole surface should be permanently hydrofuge : the respiratory reservoirs are so covered but regions such as the outer surfaces of the elytra are readily wetted by
106.
J . W. I.. 1 1 f A M E N T
watcr. Thc only aolution t o this apparent paradox is the proposal that wettable areas have an inverted monolayer, with the polar groups on the outsidc (Beament, 1960a). The physical demonstration that a monolayer can be produced in the inverted state and is stable is illustrated ir! Fig. 9. The argument is that if the stability of a normal monolayer depends on the high attraction’of its polar groups to their substrate, then a suitable substrate for an inverted monolayer would be a saturated n-paraffin itself which would attract the -CH, endings and not the polar
FIG.9. Right: a ball of pure paraffin wax, coatcd in cockroachpolar grease,washed until no further grease spreads away, dried and dipped in pure water. Low contact angle indicates an inverted monolayer with polar groups outwards. Left: a control of pure paraffin wax without grease, otherwise similarly treated. High contact angle.
groups. The Figurc \bows a ball of dry paraffin wax, coated with cockroach grease and washed in water until all unattached grease has been removed. Thc prcparation has been dried and photographed immediately after placing i n a water surface. It has a very low contact angle, compared with the control of dry paraffin wax. Since the polar groups arc the only wcttable parts of the entire preparation, they must be disposed on the outside. From this follows the suggestion that changes in the natural substrate on the cuticle in the form of the introduction of
A C T I V E 1 K A N S P O R T O F W A T E R IN INSECTS
107
tanning quinoncs into the lipoprotein of the epicuticle causes a monolaycr of lipid, first laid down in the inverted state because of the attraction of (’I I , to lipoprotein, to turn over and form a hydrofuge normal monolaycr (Dcament, 1961b). flccause the removal of water from the tracheal system at hatching and moulting coincides with the tanning of the tracheal cuticle, and because there are parallel systems in the emptying of the respiratory sponge of eggshells (Wigglesworth and Beament, 1950) and in plastrons (Thorpe, 1950), it has been suggested that monolayer inversion provides the mechanism and perhaps gives evidence suggesting that insects may have become air-breathing before they became terrestrial animals (Beament, 1962). Experiments showing for the first time that a monolayer of stearic acid could be inverted on a mica substrate were published in the same issue of the journal carrying the preliminary note on the inversion of insect monolayers (Gaines, 1960). C. CONCLUSIONS
In comparison with the relatively low resistance to the passage of water presented by all other cuticular components, the resistance of the lipid is high and for all ordinary purposes is the controlling factor in the passivc permeability of the cuticle. But the lipid itself can exist in a number of different molecular arrangements which may have very different permeabilities and adhesions, and some lipids are so mobile that their rearrangement in vivo is possible and could even be integral to the regulation of water movement through the cuticle.
VI. THEASYMMETRY OF C U T I C L E Experiments by Hurst (1941, 1948) and Beament (1945, 1948) indicated that under certain conditions water would pass through an isolated piece of insect cuticle more rapidly in one direction than the other and this phenomenon has attracted the slightly unfortunate description : the “asymmetry” of insect cuticle. It is neither an unusual nor a surprising thing that a compound membrane (one consisting of two or more laminae of different property) should allow water or any other diffusant to pass at different rates in the two directions when the driving gradients are identical at the outsides; this has been described in detail for other biological and synthetic systems and the evidence is reviewed by Bcament (1961b). There is, however, one feature of the phenomenon manifest by the insect cuticle which distinguishes it from
108
J . W. L. B E A M E N T
all other such systems which have been investigated, and which therefore requires special attention. An cxplanation of the usual phenomenon encountered in compound membranes has been offered by Hartley (1948), and for brevity this will be referred to as the “Hartley Effect”. Consider (Fig. 10A) a membrane consisting of two components: one lamina is of hydratable material which does not obey Fick’s Law; the other lamina does not hydrate and does obey Fick’s Law. At dynamic equilibrium, the outer surface of the hydratable lamina will have a water-content determined by the
Water
Dry
air
D‘Y
air
*-
A B FIG.10. Diagram representing the “Hartley” effect in a compound membrane, consisting of a swelling phase with large “pores” and a lamina of high resistance to water movement, which obeys Fick’s Law (hatched region). (A) With swollen phase against pure water: large pores and higher rate of flow into dry air. (B) With desiccated phase against dry air: small pores and low rate of flow. Insect cuticle appears to have this form of construction, but the measured rates of flow are the inverse of expectation.
environment with which it is in contact. In general, the degree of hydration will be higher when this side of the membrane faces a higher concentration of water, and lower when next to a lower concentration. The greater the degree of hydration, the larger the pores in the material and the lower the resistance to water; the permeability of the whole membrane is thus related to the swelling of the hydratable lamina. Therefore if we create a gradient through the membrane by disposing a particular concentration of water on one side, and a lower concentration on the other side, the rate of flow through the membrane will be highest if the hydratable lamina faces the high concentration: it will be lower when it faces the low concentration. The resistance of the second lamina will remain constant throughout.
ACTIVE T R A N S P O R T O F WATER IN INSECTS
109
In terms of our previous discussion, the insect pro-cuticle is a hydratable lamina, and the lipid (and probably lipoprotein tanned cuticulin) is not. So long as it does not indulge in molecular rearrangement, we would expect the lipid to obey Fick’s Law. Thus if distilled water is placed against the procuticle, and dry air against the lipid, we would expect much higher transpiration than if there is pure water against the lipid and the proteinaceous inside cuticle is air-dried. But the inverse is usually found. Water passes inwards more readily than outwards in an evaporating system, using cuticles of the cockroach, Rhodnius or the blowfly (Beament, 1948, and unpublished work; Hurst, 1941, 1948; Richards et al., 1953). This we shall call “anomalous asymmetry”. The asymmetry ratio (giving the inwards figure first) reported in the early work varied between 100: 1 and 2 : 1, and all the work was carried out using the gradient between pure liquid water and dry air. The very high vslues of the ratio can almost certainly be explained by bad experimental technique, but values of between 1.2 :1 and 2 :1 have been obtained with the most stringent modern methods (Beament, unpublished work), using desiccation (Fig. 10B). Some experiments by Richards and Fan (1949), using heavy water as a tracer, suggested that when water on both sides of the cuticle was in the liquid phase (instead of one gas phase-air) there was no asymmetry. These experiments were not amenable ;o the calculation of flux rates, and it is doubtful if the results justified so firm a conclusion. But on the same cuticle of a blowfly larva, using the evaporation method, they not only demonstrated very significant anomolous asymmetry, but suggested that the whole of the “lipid epicuticle” had mechanically to be destroyed before anomalous asyrnmctry disappeared. This could prove a very important experiment: our difficulty is that there is no precise homology between the sarcophagan cuticle and that of other orders of insect; from the work of Wolfe (1954) and of Dennell (1946) the dipteran epicuticle cannot be treated as having separatc laminae of cuticulin and free lipid, such as we believe to be the state of affairs in other insects. Now the Hartley effect is real: it can be readily demonstrated with artificial membranes, and we can scarce envisage a situation which would produce a greater effect than the one which contrasts a membrane with its hydratable phasc against distilled water, and that membrane with its hydratable phase against dry air, especially when the lipid lamina cf the membrane has a high water-resistance. Thus there has got to be a Hartlcy effect present in the permeability ratios of these insect cuticle preparations. We have no idca of the relationships to employ in combining a Hartley effect simultaneously with an anomalous asym-
I10
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
metry, but it is safe to say that the true size of the anomalous asymmetry ratio must be higher than we ever mcasure by the evaporation method, and that a membrane which shows no asymmetry must have anomolous properties sufficient to cancel the Hartley effect. We must in fact be surprised if any compound membranc shows no asymmetry at all. Whether the mechanism which gives rise to anomalous asymmetry will prove an important factor in cuticular water regulation or transport only the future can tell; at the present time it has served to draw our attention to phenomena which indicate even greater complication. Just as we have suggested that dry air should desiccate the protein phase strongly and produce an extreme Hartley effect, so also we can suggest (supported by the argument in Section IV, B) that a solution of sucrose with 10 atm osmotic pressure ought not to produce much dehydration of protein in contact with it. Therefore in some recent experiments (Beament, 1964) using dead cockroach cuticle as the membrane in an osmometer, the Hartley effect will be small. Unfortunately, whether salt or sugar solutions arc used to provide an osmotic gradient, using xembranes which do not transmit isotopes and are sensibly perfectly semi-permeable, and taking experimental readings over periods of days, ?he asymmetry ratio can be as high as 10: 1. This ratio is substantially higher than that obtaincd on the self-same pieces of cuticle using ar, evaporation method. Argument as to how much of the experinental values should be attributed to a Hartlcj effect can be avoided by a simple expedient; if we place distilled water on both sides of the membrane and apply small hydrostatic pressures, there is unlikely to be any change in the state of hydration of the protein whichever way the water is moving, in so far as its swelling and permeability is concerned. But there can be very significant differences between the rates of 8ow inwards and outwards through the cuticle, corresponding with the etkct determined by osmosis. We are obliged to infer that the cuticle contains a valve: a device which offers greater resistance to the passage nf watcr i n one direction than the other. There may well be more than one valve; it is impossible at the present time to obtain quantitative relationships betwecii the effects of osmotic pressure, hydrostatic pressure and evaporation gradients, but the behaviour of many pieces of cuticle is consistent. Much difficult experimental work must ensue before this situation is disentangled, but one clue already seems reasonably well established : however the measurements are made, the asymmetry is greatly reduced and may even be reversed in sense by the removal of the free lipid. We have already seen how readily lipid molecules can be reorganized, with consequent very real changes in
AC1 IVE
I RANSI’OR
01. W A I
EK IN lNSECTS
111
permeability. Does thc lipid act as a ‘‘molecular valve”? It certainly can be used to act as a molecular valve to ions (Section VIII, A). H.
T H E R M O D Y N A M I C V A L I D I T Y OF A S Y M M E T R Y
It cannot bc stressed too strongly that there is nothing in principle about the concept that a membrane can have greater permeability in one direction through it than in the other, which is at variance with thermodynamic consideration. To say that there is a “valve” or “rectifier” present in the cuticle instead of talking about asymmetry merely replaces one word by another, and contributes nothing to mechanism. But one cannot make a perpetual motion machine with such a valve, any more than one can with such analogues as a friction band on a pulley or an electronic vacuum tube. But the experiments which indicate :hat the lipid molecules may rcally be capable of acting as a valve stem from the discovery of strong fixed electrical fields in the lipid laycr of the cuticle (Reament, 1961~). V I I. E L E C T R I C PARLO P E R T I E OF S C U T I C U L ALIPIDS R
Since polar molcculcs such as long-chain paraffinic alcohols have slightly displaced electron ficlds, through the presence at one end only of the parafin chain, of the polar group, the molecules carry an electrical dipole moment, which is the causc of the well-known electrical phenomena at the surface of a monolayer on water. The great difficulty of experimenting with monolayers at an air-water interface arises from having to use techniques involving such things as ionizing air-electrodes. If, however, as we have seen, the lipid monolayer is so firmly bound by the links of the polar groups to their substrate that it remains stable even when liquid water is placed at the non-polar end of the monolayer, then the grcat problcm of liquid-air interface surface electro-chemistry is overconic: one should be able to measure surface potential simply by introducing suitable electrodes into aqueous conducting phases on cithcr sidc of .in in\cct cuticle prcpriration. It proved (Beament, 1961c) that between identical solutions of I ‘4, NaCl on cither side of a piece of dead cockroach cuticlc: tlicrc was often a potential difference of the order of 150-200 m V , and that this voltage could be detected on preparations which had been soaked in sodium cyanide and had been dead fcr 110 days. Thc idcntification o f this vollagc with the lipid is readily demonstrated by the simplc expcdicnt of rcmoving the grease. Voltages have also been
112
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
produced on artificial mcmbrancs spread with grease from the cockroach. Similar voltagcs are present on an intact membrane having 0.2 p of grease and those washcd down to a single monolayer : we hduce both that one monolayer only is present in the grease when thick, and that thc monolayer is the source of the potential difference. The original report includes reference to the “electret” or permanently electrostatically charged object, often produced in the past by allowing beeswax or a plant wax in the molten state to solidify in a strong electric field. Such waxes show strong crystallization in powder X-ray diagrams when they have had no special treatment and show no net electretic effect; a reconciliation of these two facts is obtained by using the principle of the “domain”, first derived in the theory of magnetism. Instead of visualizing randomness at the level of individual molecules, one cons i d m supra-molecular aggregations : crystallites with aligned molecules, which havc magnetic, or in this case “electretic”, moments, and randomness occurs at this level of organization. Such devices may be important when considering the effect of applying a strong electrical field across the thick grease of intact cockroach cuticle; 6 V applied momentarily across 0.2 p of grease produces residual electretic voltage of 4 V, fitting closely with the proposed 200 mV per monolayer, on the basis that the whole of the grease molecules have now been aligned. But over a space of some 10 min from the time of removal of the polarizing voltage, the system decays back to 200 mV. Decay is exponential, which is what we would expect if the randomization had been produced thermally. Whether this randomization is at molecular level or domain levcl remains to be seen: the actual phenomenon and the time scale of events parallel closely the suggested process (Section III) for the reorientation of grease molecules under a water droplet. Thick grease can be temporarily polarized into an electret of either sign, according to the sense of the polarizing voltage, but always decays back to the condition of the single monolayer of natural cuticle. A. T H E E L E C T R I C A L I N V E R S I O N OF A M O N O L A Y E R
It will already be apparent that the electrical properties of the cuticular lipid are going to provide a powerful tool for further investigation into the various problems of the control of cuticular transport. One obvious application (Beament, unpublished work) is to test the relatively novel proposition of Section V, B that a monolayer can be inverted. Fig. 11 shows a rcsult of a typical expcriment on a dead cockroach cuticle washed down to a monolayer. As the applied electrical field, tending to
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F WATER IN I N S E C T S
113
FICAI 1. Current flowing through a monolayer-cuticle preparation mounted betwecn identical solutions of NaCI, when potential differences are applied across the preparation. Below each graph, an interpretation of events in the monolayer. (A) Applied voltage tending to invert the monolayer: current rises, falls as though packing is increased, then rises when the electretic voltage indicates monolayer inversion. (B) The preparation with inverted monolayer, subject to an applied potential tending to revert the monolayer. Similar events occur, but the reversion voltage is much smaller than the inversion voltage.
114
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
invert the monolayer, is increased, the electric current passed by the prcparation does not increase proportionally; thc preparation appears to increasc its resistance..Assuming that the resistance of the grease will be several orders higher than that of the rest of the preparation, the local potential gradient tending to invert the monolayer may be more than 1 MV/cm. Up to a certain value of applied voltage the reduction in electret voltage is temporary; after removing the applied voltage the preparation will recover. But beyond this range of polarizing field, the current falls sharply and then rises in a fashion more resembling an Ohm's Law: the permanent electretic voltage has now been reversed and the monolayer has been inverted. If this preparation with an inverted monolayer is now subjected to an applied field tending to turn the polar molecules back into normal orientation, a similar kind of phenomenon occurs: the current rises, then falls sharply and rises again, and an electretic voltage of normal sense reappears; the monolayer has been restored to normal state but only about one-fifth of the applied voltage needed to invert the monolayer is required to turn it back again.
FIG.l'!. Indicating that if monolayer molecules were most stable when vertical, an applied force acting perpendicular to the monolayer would produce no turning movement and inversion would be sudden; if molecules are tilted in most stable position, the applied force will produce increasing turning movements.
This kind of experiment gives independent confirmation of some of the theoretical principles upon which the whole of these ideas about waterproofing have been based. Far greater electrical force is needed to dislodge the polar group from its substrate than to dislodge the -CH, group of the inverted monolayer. rndecd with refinement of technique it might be possible directly to measure the strength of the polar bond, and of the adhesion of -CH, in this fashion. More important however may be the implication of the increase in impedance as the applied voltage is increased. Suppose (Fig. 12) the most stable position of a molecule in a natural monolayer had been with the long axis perpendicular to the substrate plane. One would not have expected any change in the Properties of the monolayer until inversion occurred suddenly.
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F W A T E R IN I N S E C T S
115
Suppow o n the other hand, as is cssential to our general theory, that thc mol:culcs arc packed tilted; the resolved part of the applied field acting at right-angles to the axis of the lipid will produce a turning moment tending to increase the packing. Packing, electrical impedance
and permeability are obviously interrelated properties, and the experiment is best interpreted on the assumption of molecules initially tilted. B. M E C H A N I C A L DI S TO RTIO N
The monolayer preparation shows electrical changes with mechanical distortion, i.e. piezo-electric phenomena. This must follow from the proposed construction of the monolayer, since mechanical displacement of the dipole of the lipid molecule will change the electretic field. At the present time this phenomenon is primarily an experimental hazard ; in the long-term view a molecular mechanism linking together mechanical distortion, electrical changes in a membrane, and permeability changes, may be helpful in interpreting the functioning of senseorgans and perhaps even of sensory nerve-endings. C. T H E P A S S A G L OF S U B S T A N C E S T H R O U G H M O N O L A Y E R S
Assuming a monolayer to have thickness of the order of 50 A, an object passing through it must experience a potential gradient of the order of 2-300000 V/cm. While this would be expected to produce certain effects o n a particle carrying a single charge, such as an ion, inspection of the molecular model suggests that, difficult as it may be to produce a space for the translation of a water molecule, the chance that there would be a hole big enough for a hydrated ion to pass between packed lipid molecules is remote indeed. This suggestion is borne out by the physiological experiments of Section 11, E, and by experiments (Beament, 1961c, and unpublished work) using the cuticle as the semipermeable membrane in osmometers, with isotope-labelled ions. In fact, membrane preparations fall into two categories: those with lower electrical impedance which under certain circumstances will transmit ions, and those of higher electrical impedance which are permeable to water but show exceptional resistance to the passage of ions and larger particles. If we are practical, we cannot assume perfect organization of a monolayer over the area of a membrane preparation 0.25 cm2, and if the rnoleculcs are packcd tilted, it is even more remote to think that over the wholc ;ma they will tilt the ~aiiieway! One interpretation of the
116
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
idea of domains is to consider the existence of micro-areas where all the molecules point the same way, with discontinuities at the junctions of differently orientated domains. This will give rise to pores of greater permeability and areas of high impermeability. Thus if the mechanism for actively transporting water is associated with the monolayer, it will always work in parallel with pores for free diffusion. Such a scheme fits with much of the available evidence: a water-pump and independent osmotic or diffusive leakage. Phillips’ (1964) work on the locust hindgut for example illustrates this. The possibility of an ion pump based upon the electret potential is discussed in thc next section. Here, we must consider theoretically the effect on a polar molecule-water, of the electret field; a qualitative discussion is appropriate. For its size, the unionized water molecule has a remarkably high dipole moment; this contributes substantially to the whole range of unexpected physical properties of water which are otherwise so out of keeping with the simple formula H,O. In the ordinary liquid state, these dipoles produce statistical aggregations. When a molecule passes through a space between two orientated lipid molecules, its freedom of movement is so restricted that in the plane at right-angles to the length of the pore it cannot exhibit the properties of a liquid or gas. It is from this kind of argument, as well as from experimental evidence, that one refers to water in transit through certain forms of membrane as “ice”, though it may be more correct to visualize a twodimensional solid-one-dimensional liquid : a state perhaps analogous to the anchored monolayer molecule above its transition temperature. Experiments indicating “ single-file” water molecules in a membrane are described, for example, by Diamond (1962). Consider however the condition of a diffusing molecule of high dipole meeting with a pore in an electret field. There will be two separate additional factors because of the dipole (Fig. 13). The water molecule arriving at the lipid with appropriate dipole orientation will be attracted into the electret field, whercas the water molecule arriving in reverse orientation will experience a repulsion. There will also be a rotational effect: the electret field will tend to orientate the water molecule so as to attract it into the field. Thus the selection of appropriate molecules and the regimentation of partly orientated molecules will result in a higher probability of linked single-file molecules of water in a pore through the grease. The importance of this concept of a “string” of water molecules can be seen in relation to any mechanism for its active transport. In all the systems where the diffusant moves down the concentration or activity
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF W A T E R IN INSECTS
117
gradient, the ultimate source of the energy is kinetic. In simple diffusion more molecules randomly move down the gradient than up it; in activated diflusion more molecules of higher energy move down the gradient than up it; in facilitated diffusion, more molecules of higher energy get onto the higher end of the carrier system and displace molecules at the lower end of the carrier, than get onto the lower end of the carrier and displace molecules at the higher end. (“Carrier” is used in the simple sense of a static substrate providing a preferential linkage for the d8usant : the diffusant moves along it, and there is no suggestion in this paper of a “carrier” which moves or oscillateswithin amembrane.) All three varieties of passive transport contain the analogue of a pressure pushing molecules through the membrane, and therefore requiring no attraction between the diffusing molecules. Active transport in the sense used in this paper visualizes an energy-producing system at the higher
t
0”
- 1
+0-
9+
I-
FIG.13. Suggesting the effect on a polar diffusingmolecule of water (circle with line through dipole axis) of the electret field of a monolayer, tending to produce single-file. water crystals in a “pore”. For further explanation, see text.
end of a gradient (within the cell with respect to its membrane: deep in the integument with respect to the monolayer of lipid) and requires the analogue of pulling the translated molecule from the inside of the membrane. Jt is obvious therefore that the active removal of molecules from one erd of a “string” tends to produce an overall inward movement in the string, and that processes increasing inter-molecular attraction of the diffusant can be important. VIII.
O N PUMPS
Harris (1960) in his book on transport in biological systems surveys knowr! methods of producing a movement of water. These include hydrostatic pressure, diffusion promoted by osmosis, anomolous osmosis, electro-osmosis, transfer by ions and “pumping by contractile
118
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
structures”. From the systems we have been discussing we can eliminate hydrostatic pressure and simple osmosis ; anomolous osmosis is in general 2 transient phenomenon while counter-flow requires a second diffusant. Electro-osmosis would require water to have a net charge instead of a dipole, together with a continuous supply of electrical current. Under the heading of “pumping movements” he describes the contractilc vacuole and admits that the reason for its filling with water is unknowii; he includes Kitching’s (1954) suggestion that a secretory mechanism must be involved. Harris’s novel suggestion of pumping by changing the shape of a cell, exposing first a greater area to one solution and then to another, cannot apply to a system including rigid membranes in any case. It does seem that any attempt to provide a mechanism for the active transport of water per se must involve some new concepts or principles. A. T H E E L E C T R E T I O N - P U M P
Beament (1961~)points out that two solutions of different ionic composition, separated by a. permeable barrier, will inter-diffuse to produce two solutions of the same composition, but (Fig. 14) in this diffusion cell the potential difference between the two sides decreases to zero in the process. If, however, the products of diffusion are removed by, for example, perfusion, thus maintaining the composition of the two sides, the potential difference is maintained. The energy is provided by the perfusion process. If the potential difference is balanced out by an externally connected source of electrical potential (not of energy) ’10 current flows in the system: this is an equilibrium state in which no energy can be derived from the difference between the solutions. The source of balancing potential can be the electret voltage across the membrane. Since this state of affairs represents equilibrium, it follows that when two identical solutions are placed on either side a membrane having such an electrostatic potential, they will tend to change towards the equilibrium state: two solutions of different composition. The device will therefore tend to transport ions of opposite charge in opposite directions, and this is substantiated in experiments with membranes reported in that paper. In the light of further experiments, it appears that pumping of ions is achieved with membranes which have a relatively lower electrical impedame; they probably have larger pores or imperfections in the monolayer, through which the actual transport of the ions occurred. Membranes of high impedance do not transmit ions. In a whole series
A C T l V E T R A N S P O R T OF WATER IN I N S E C T S
m
119
Perneobie membrane
1.,A
lhe product$ of
ddfu',!on
Or
Permeable charged membrone
m
Moximum entropy
FIG. 14. The clcctret ion pump. Upper diaflms: a concentration cell, with a permeable but uncharged membrane, will run down until solutions on either side arc of identical concentration, when there is no volate act- the membrane. This is accelerated if the solutions are stirred by internal perfmion. If the two sides arc continuously perfused with new solutions, the voltage is maintained; energy is provided by removing the products of diffusion. Lower diagrams: if the membrane has a permanent electrostatic potential across it, this will appear on a volt.meter of suitably high impedance. One may not draw energy continuously from this system.If one introduces a source of potential to balance out the static membrane potential. the solutions remain identical on either side. If one stirs (introducing energy) selective diffusion will occur, giving two different solutions whose concentration potentiel balances out the membrane potential. If om continually remom the products of diffusion by perfusing with fresh solution, energy is supplied, and on0 may use the maintained membrane potential to perform work.
I20
J. W. L. B E A M E N T
of experiments with such mcmbrancs (Beament, unpublished work), using NaCl labcllcd iis sodium or as chloride, the transport with the electrct voltage and the diffusion against the electret voltage was measured. There was no significant transfer of ions over periods of 24 h. Potentials of up to 4 V were then placed across the membrane preparation, and the movement of sodium and of chloride separately determined in either direction. Only in two conditions were significant quantities of ion moved from one side of the membrane to the other. Sodium and chloride ions each respectively moved down the electro-potential gradient of 4 V when this also had inverted the monolayer. These experiments confirm the remarkable impermeability of the monolayer to larger particles; they indicate that the lipid may be made very significantly more permeable by rearranging the lipid monolayer. But they also indicate that when water is moved through this system it cannot be in association with an ion because an ion will not be transmitted. B. CONTINUOUS-FLOW WATER-PUMPS
We have already seen that the proteinaceous cuticle may be under the control of the epidermal cell, and that its hydration may be modified by vital action (Section TV, C). By dehydration sufficient force attracting
A
E
FIG. 15.
B
C
F
G
D
H
An active-transport water-pump. For explanation, see text.
water may be developed in cuticular protein to parallel the circumstances of active uptake (Section IV, B). Complex as the events may be, the study of the “asymmetry” of the cuticle shows the presence of one or more “valves”--devices which have a greater resistance to the passage of water in one direction than the other (Section VI), and molecular rearrangement of the lipid monolayer is associated with a change in
ACTIVE TRANSPORT OF WATER I N INSECTS
121
rate of water absorbtion (Section 111). Can we combine these properties to form a continuous-flowwater-pump ? Consider (Fig. 15) a sheet of protein separating two identical aqueous solutions. The protein is at its iso-electric point and water is in equilibrium distribution between the protein and the solutions. By the application of energy the circumstances within the protein are changed (Fig. 15B) so that it is moved away from its iso-electric point; its hydration potential increases and it takes up water with considerable force equally through both sides from the solutions. The protein is now returned ?o its iso-electric point; equilibrium is restored by passage of water back into the solutions (Fig. 1SC). There is no net change over the cycle. Now (Fig. l5D) add to w e surface of the protein, a valve of such a kind that its resistance to water passing into the protein is less than its resistance to water passing from the protein back into the solution. The hydration-dehydration cycle of the protein is now repeated. As the hydration potential of the protein is increased, water is drawn in from both solutions; because even in its “open” state the valve still represents a resistance not present in the situation of Fig. ISA-C, more water may be drawn in from the solution on the free side of the protein (Fig. 15E). But on returning the prQtein to its initial state, water endeavouring to pass back through the valve encounters a high resistance, and even more water is transferred back into the solution on the free side (Fig. 15F). The amount transferred in each cycle will, inter alia, be proportional to the back-to-front ratio, i.e. the asymmetry ratio, of the valve. Of course an extremely efficient pump could be produced by having a valve on either side of the protein membrane, and by multiplying this in a laminar system (Fig. 15G and H), but the principle has already been made plain. We must confine. our attention to the simplest model outlined above which has one particular property similar to the specification of the transporting devices we were considering in Section 11. The model pump (as with all suction pumps) cannot draw water in through the valve unless the pressure inside (the activity level of the water) is reduced below the level outside, for otherwise there will be no gradient between the outside world and the protein. If the activity level of the outside world is not reached, the whole of the dehydration of the protein must be satisfied by the transference of water from the solution of free access. On the other hand, the valve can still allow water to travel outwards, and when the protein is re-hydrated on the sccond half of the cycle there could be a quite substantial leakage into a phase with very low activity-dry air for example. Thus this pump would have an
122
J . W. L. R E A M E N T
equilibrium condition in which it would establish, for example, a certain humidity in surrounding air; if thc level of activity of the water outside the valve werc very low, thc amount of leakage outwards might not be significantly different whether the protein was going through a cycle or not. Thus one would not expect to find a difference in the rates of evaporation from live animals with a pump trying to work, compared with that from similar dead animals, in such an extreme condition as desiccation in dry air. C. I S THE L I P I D THE W A T E R - V A L V E ?
A great deal of work must be done before one could be sure that the pump outlined in the previous section existed in the material of the cuticle. There are interesting pointers ; they could have entirely different explanations. Thus in Section 11, B we noted the proposal, originally of Mellanby (1932) taken up by others, that when one determines the equilibrinm condition of an animal regulating the water-content in the air surrounding it at different temperatures, equilibrium is established at a particular relative humidity rather than at a particular saturation deficit. Now the passage of water through a lipid is almost certainly an activated diffusion (e.g. Danielli and Davson, 1952) and is therefore exponentially related to temperature. The amount of water vapour in saturated air is also an activation process, similarly exponentially related to temperature. Thus even though the cuticle, and the physicochemical processes going on in it, are complex, if the lipid does occupy a dominant place in the pump-mechanism we should not be surprised to find this particular relationship to relative humidity. With a theory of this kind, one is tempted to make short-cuts, so that the follcwing observation could be meaningless or it could be most significant. In Section 111 we discussed the uptake of liquid water and noted the disappearance of a differential pattern of absorbtion when a cockroach was anaesthetized. If a cockroach is subjected to a very heavy dose of carbon dioxide, we would expect the pH of its tissues and of the cuticle to be shifted considerably. When one does this the animal “sweats”-small droplets of water appear on the surface of the cuticle, and are resorbed when it recovers. Has this brought the protein to the lowest hydration-potential, or is the whole situation far more complex? As the author pointed out first in 1945, if the rates of passage of water through the cuticle are different in the two directions and if the structure has asymmetric permeability, it must itself be asymmetric in construction. With our present knowledge, no single structure is more
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T O F W A T E R I N INSECTS
123
asymmetric than the monolayer itself; water experiences an entirely different sequence of events passing through a monolayer in one direction than in the other. Another obvious feature of the phenomena discussed in Section 111 is that liquid water is not absorbed until the monolayer beneath it is inverted. Very little has been said in this review about experimental difficulties or experimental methods; some of these were examined critically in another paper (Beament, 1961b). It is, however, worth recording that dynamic flow methods using osmotic forces in non-equilibrium conditions are exceptionally difficult. Much has been written about the experimental uncooperativeness of semi-permeable membranes ;preparations of cockroach cuticle have none of these drawbacks, and with them one may verify most elegantly that osmotic solutions obey the gas laws when under static conditions, counterbalancing osmotic pressure by a hydrostatic force. But however carefully and efficiently one perfuses surfaces, a minute hydrostatic pressure will move far more water through a cuticle than a theoretically large osmotic force. This is why, in the discussion above, great emphasis was placed on the future value of the use of hydrostatic pressure as a research tool ;preliminary experiments suggest that in one direction through the cuticle transfer is proportional to pressure, but in the other direction it cedinly is not. This again is a characteristic of a valve. XI. WIDERIMPLICATIONS
In our opening paragraphs, and in another paper (Beament, 1961c), we suggested that the cuticle might prove a model from which to develop theories of importance to the general functioning of the cell membrane. The lipid in cell membrane may be chemically very different to the lipid on cuticle, and it almost certainly occurs in bimolecular leaflets. But in principle the idea that potentials and ion-distributions can arise from a net electretic potential still holds. Such systems are piezo-electric as in the broadest sense are mechano-receptors. An imposed electrical field brings about rearrangement in the lipid and a change in permeability to ions, sometimes with a consequent transfer of ions; conversely a change in the organization of the lipid produces a change in the electropotential across the monolayer membrane. These suggestions alone should be sufficient to convince the reader that the study of the permeability of insect cuticle could prove to have wide implications for general physiology and biophysics.
124
1. W.
L. BEAMEN?
X. S U M M A R Y 1. Insects transfer water into their blood (R.H. equivalent 99 %) from air of relative humidity as low as 70%. Water can be taken up through the rectum against large concentration gradients. In both instances there is an active transport of water without transport of other materials. 2. Uptake of water from the tracheole and from solutions in contact with the mticle require a supply of energy. The cuticle can be perfectly semi-permeable. The circumstances grade continuously from active transport in the narrowest sense into those where energy must be supplied although an activity gradient is not established. 3. The facility to transport water actively may be a common property of insects; the particular examples which are discussed are free from objection on grounds that complementary processes could hate promoted the movement of water passively. 4. The absorbtion of liquid water into the cuticle is accompanied by temporary reorganization of lipid molecules. Water-uptake can be imitated with models of cuticle; the force moving the water is produced by dehydrating protein. 5. A careful distinction is drawn between an absorbtion process which stops when saturated, and a continuous-flow transporting mechanism. 6. The cuticular protein is under an active control by the epidermis and there is specific evidence that it can modify the hydration of the cuticle. The pore canals may be important in this process. This may allow temporary absorbtion of water, but does not provide a continuousflow pump. 7.Changes in permeability of cuticular lipids and especially of monolayers are brought about by thermal agitation. A new explanation of the phase transition in monolayers is advanced, based upon the theory that monolayers are constructed with long-chain molecules inclined at about 25” to the vertical. 8. Monolayers can be inverted in natural circumstances, and by the application of electrical forces. Natural inversion may account for the prcduction of hydrofuge areas in insect respiratory systems. The experiments with electric fields confirm the arrangement of the cuticular lipids which has been postulated from experiments on permeability. 9. The evidence for “asymmetric” permeability of insect cuticle is discussed and new experiments are described. The cuticle contains a valve having a greater resistance to water in one direction than the other.
A C T I V E TRANSPORT OF WATER IN INSECTS
125
10.The monolayer is an electret; this may be used as the basis of an ion pump, and may have an effect on the state of water traversing the lipid. 11. The various elements now known to be present in the integument may be combined together to produce a pump actively transporting water. The working of this pump is described. Some of its properties correspond with the general phenomenon of active uptake of water by an insect: it works down to a specific IeveI of water-activity, which would be proFortiona1 to relative humidity rather than saturation deficit, and though endeavouring to work, it would not have any effect against very low activity levels such as dry air. 12. Some of the wider implications of the cuticle model upon the general field of cellular transport and electrical phenomena are briefly discussed. I have received advice and criticism from many colleagues during these researches and I am grateful for the privilege of referring to the unpublished work of others. I wish especially to acknowledge the advice of Professor H. C. Longuet-Higgins, F.R.S.,and the many hours of discussion I have spent with Dr. K. E. Machin. In this review I have made xithout reference, a number of generalizations about insect physiology, and usually these will have stemmed from Professor Wigglesworth’s textbooks, if not from his conversations and own researches. I am grateful to him for this, as well as for the freedom with which he has allowed me to pursue in his Sub-Department, a field which has sometimes seemed far removed from classical insect physiology. REFERENCES Adam, N. K.(1948).In the reported discussion of papers. Disc. Furuduy Soc. 3,lO. Adamson, A. W. (1 960).“Physical Chemistry of Surfaces”. Interscience, New York. Barrer, R. M. (1 948). Fluid flow in porous media. Disc. Faruhy Soc. 3,61-72. Bayliss, L.E.(1959).“Principles of General Physiology”. London, Longmans. Beament, J. W. L. (1945).The cuticular lipoids of,insects. J. exp. Biol. 21,115-131. Beament, J. W. L. (1948). The role of wax layers in the waterproofing of insect cuticle and eggshell. Disc. Faraday SOC.3, 177-182. Beament, J. W. L. (1954).Water transport in insects. Symp. SOC.exp. Bfol.8.94-117. Eeament, J. W. L. (1955).Wax secretion in the cockroach. J. exp. Biol. 32,514-538. Beament, J. W.L. (1958a).The effect oftemperature on the waterproofing mechanism of an insect. J. exp. B i d . 35,494-519. Beament, J. W. L. (1958b).The measurement and control of humidity. I n “Electronic Apparatus for Biological Research”. Butterworth, London. Beament, J. W. L. (1959). The waterproofing mechanisms of arthropods. I. The effect of temperature on cuticle permeability in terrestrial insects and ticks. J. exp. Biol. 36, 391-422.
126
J. W.L. B E A M E N T
Beament, J. W. L. (1960a). Wetting properties of insect cuticle. Nature, Lond. 186, 4084. Bearnent, 4. W. L. (1960b). Physical models in biology. Synrp. SOC.exp. Biol. 10,14. Beament, J. W. L. (1961a). The waterproofing mechanism of arthropods 11. The permeability of the cuticle of some aquatic insects. J. exp. Biol. 38,277-290. Bearnent, J. W. L. (1 961b).The water relations of insect cuticle. Biol. Rev. 36,281-320. Beament, J. W. L. (1961~).Electrical properties of orientated lipid on a biological membrane: an electrostatic diffusion barrier and ion pump. Nature, Lond, 191, 217-221. Beament, J. W. L. (1961d). The role of physiological mechanism in animal competition. Syrnp. SOC.exp. Biol. 15, 61-71. Beament, J. W. L. (1962). The surface properties of insects-some evolutionary and ecological implications. Proc. Linn. SOC.Lond. 173, 115-119. Beament, J. W. L., Noble-Nesbitt, J. J. and Watson, J. A. L. (1964). The waterproofing mechanisms of arthropods IV. J. exp. Biol. (in press). Bennet-Clark, H.C. (1961). The physiological mechanisms of feeding in bloodsucking bug, Rhodnius prolixus. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Bennet-Clark, H. C. (1962). Active control of the mechanical properties of insect cuticle. J. Insect Physiol. 8, 227. Brocher, F. (1915). Recherches sur la respiration des insectesaquatiques. Rev. suisse Zool. 23,401-438. Browning, T. 0.(1 954). Waterbalance in the tick OrnithodorusmoubufaMurray with particular reference to the influence of carbon dioxide on the uptake and loss of water. J. exp. Bid. 31, 331-340. Browning, T. 0.(1957). Quoted by Edney (1957). Bult, T. (1939). Over de Beweging der Vloeistof in de Tracheolein der Insecten. Thesis,University of Groningen. Bwton, P.A. (1930). Evaporation from the mealworm and atmospheric humidity. Proc. TOY. SOC.B 106, 560-577. Bwton, P. A. (1931). The law governing the loss of water from an insect. Proc. roy. enf. SOC.Lond. 6, 27-3 1. Buxton, P. A. and Mellanby, K. (1934). The measurement and control of humidity. Bull. ent. Res. 25, 171-175. Champion, F. C. and Davy, N. (1941). “Properties of Matter”, pp. 99-164. Blackie, London. Christensen, H. N. (1962). “Biological Transport”. Benjamin, New York. Danielli, J. F. and Davson, H. (1952). “The Permeability of Natural Membranes”. Cambridge University Prus. Davies, M.E. and Edney, E. B. (1952). The evaporation of water from spiders. J. exp. Biol. 29, 571-582. Davson, H. (1 959). “Textbook of General Physiology”. Churchill, London. Dennell, R. (1946). A study of an insect cuticlc: the larval cuticle of Surcophugu falculata Pand. (Dipt.). Proc. roy. SOC.B 133, 348-373. Diamond, J. M . (1962). The reabsorptive function of the gall-bladder. J. Physiol 161,474-502. Edney, E. B. (1947). Laboratory studies of the bionomics of the rat fleas, Xenopsylla brasiliensis Baker and X . cheopis Roths. 11. Bull. ent. Res. 38, 263-280. Edney, E. B. (1957). ‘“TheWater Relations of Terrestrial Arthropods”. Cambridge University Press.
A C T I V E T R A N S P O R T OF WATER IN INSECTS
127
Gaines, G. L. Jr. (1960). Overturning of stearic acid molecules in monolayers. Nutwe, Lond. 186, 3114385. Govaerts, J. and Leclercq, 1. (1946).Waterexchangebetween insects andair moisture. Nature, Lond. 157, 483. Harris, E. J. (1960). “Transport and Accumulation in Biological Systems”. Butterworth, London. Hartley, Ci. S . (1948).Contribution to a discussion on asymmetry. Disc.Faraday Soc. 3, 223. Hodgkin, A. L. (1951). The ionic basis of electrical activity in nerve and muscle. Biol. Rev. 26, 339-409. Hodgkin, A. L. (1958).Ionic movements and electrical activity in giant nerve fibres. Proc. roy. SOC.B 148, 1-37. Holdgate, M. W. (1955). The wetting of insect cuticles by water. J. exp. Bwf. 32, 591-617. Holdgate, M.W. (1956).Transpiration through the cuticles of some aquatic insects. J. ex9. Biol. 33, 107-1 18. Hurst, H. (1941). Insect cuticle as an asymmetric membrane. Nature, Lond. 147, 388-389. Hurst, H. (1948). Asymmetrical behaviour of insect cuticle in relation to water permeability. Disc. Furaday Sac. 3, 193-210. Ito, T. (1953). Studies on the integument of the silkworm, Bombyx mori, 7 . Biol. Rev. 105, 308-3 15. Kalmus, H. (1936). Die Venvendung der Tracheenblasm dcr Corethralarve als Mihohygrometer. 2. wiss. Mikr. 53, 215-219. Kedem, 0.and Katchalsky, A. (1958).Thermodynamic analysis of the permeability of bidogical membranes to nonelectrolytes. Biochim.biophys. Acta 27,229-236. Kitching, J. A. (1954). The physiology of contractile vacuoles IX. Effects of sudden changes in temperature on the contractile vacuoles of a suctorian. J. exp. Biol. 31,68-75. Knudsen, M. (1909). Die Gesetze der Molekulantromung und der inneren Reibungsstromung der Gase durch Rohren. Ann. Physik. 28, 75. Lees, A. D. (1 946). The water balance in Ixodes ricinus L. and certain other species of ticks. Purisitology 37, 1-20. Lees, A. D. (1947). Transpiration and the structure of the epicuticle in ticks. J. exp. Biol. 23, 379410. Locke, M. (1958). The formation of tracheae and tracheoles in Rhodnius prolixus. Quart. J. mirr. Sci. 99, 2 9 4 6 . Lockey, Y.H. (1960). The thickness of some insect epicuticular wax layers. J. exp. Biol. 37, 3 16429. Ludwig, D. (1937). The effect of different relative humidities on respiratory metabolism and survival of the grasshopper Chortophaga viridifasciata. Physiol. 2001. 10, 342-35 1. Martin, J. (1893).Les tracheeset respiration trachenne. C. R. SOC.Philomat. Paris6.3. Mellanby, K. (1932).The effect of atmospheric humidity on the metabolism of the fasting mealworm Genebrio molitor). Proc. roy. SOC.B 111, 376390. Milllet, A. (1927). An X-ray investigation of certain longchain compounds. Prm. roy. SOC.A 114, 542. Nachmansohn, D. (1961). “Molecular Biology”. Academic Press, New York and London.
I28
J.
W. L. BEAMENT
Pal, R.(1950). The wetting of insect cuticle. Bull ent. Res. 41, 121-139. Pappenheimer, J. R. (1953). Passage of molecules through capillary walls. Physiol. Rev. 33, 387-423. Pauling, L. and Corey, R. B. (1951). The structure of keratin. Proc. not. Acad. Sci., Wash. 37, 729. Phillips, J. E. (1964). Rectal absorbtion in the Desert Locust. I. J. exp. Biol. 41,15-38. Phillips, J. E.(1961). Studies on the rectal absorbtion of water and salts in the locust Schistorerca gregaria and the blowfly Calliphora erythrocephala. Thesis, University of Cambridge. Ramsay, J. A. (1935). (2). The evaporation of water from the cockroach. J. exp. Biol. 12,373-383. Ramsay, J. A. (1950). Osmotic regulation in mosquito larvae. J. exp. Biol. 27, 145-1 57.
Ramsay, J. A. (1954). Active transport of water by the Malpighian tubules of the stick insect Dixippus morosus. J. exp. Biol. 31, 104-1 13. Renkin, E. M. (1954). Filtration diffusion and molecular sieving through porous cellulose membranes. J. gen. Physiol. 38, 225-243. Richards, A. G. (1951). “The Integument of Arthropods”. University of Minnesota press. Richards, A. G. (1958). The cuticle of arthropods. Ergebu. Biol. 20, 1-26. Richards, A. G. and Fan, H.Y.(1949). Studies on arthropod cuticle V .J. cefl.comg. Physiol. 33, 177-198. Richards, A. G., Clawen, M.B. and Smith, M. N. (1953). Studies on arthropod cuticle. X. The asymmetrical penetration of water. J. cell. romp. Physiol. 42, 395413. Rudall, K. M. (1963). The chitin/protein complexes of insect cuticle. I n “Advances in Insect Physiology” (J. W. L.Beament, J. E. Treherne and V.B.Wigglesworth, eds.), vol. 1, pp. 257-313. Academic Press, London and New York. Schneiderman, H. A. (1953). The discontinuous release of carbon dioxide by diapausing pupae insects. Anat. Rec. 117, 540. SutclifTe D. W.(1961). Studies on salty water balance in Caddis larvae. I. Osmotic and ionic regulations of body fluids in Limnephilus uffnis. J. exp. Biol. 38, 501-519.
Thorpe, W.H. (1928). The elimination of carbon dioxide in the insecta. Science, 68,433443.
Thorpe, W. H.(1950). Plastron respiration in aquatic insects. Biol. Rev. 25,344-390. Treherne, J. E. (1957a). The diffusion of non-electrolytes through the isolated cuticle of Schistocerca gregaria. J . Insect Physiol. 1, 178-186. Treherne, J. E. (1 957b). Glucoseabsorbtion in thecockroach. J. exp. Biol.34,478485. Treherne, J. E.(1958). The absorbtion of metabolism of some sugars in the locust Schistocerca gregaria. J. exp. Biol. 35, 611-625. Treherne, :. E. (1961). The kinetics of sodium transfer in the central nervous system of the cockroach Periplaneta americana. J. exp. Biol. 38, 737-746. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1931). The physiology of excretion in a blood-sucking insect, Rhodnius prolixus. J. exp. Biol. 7, 41 1451, Wigglesworth, V. B. (1934). The function of the anal gills of the mosquito larva. J. exp. Biol. 10, 1626. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1938). The regulation of osmotic pressure and chloride concentration in the haemolymph of mosquito larvae. J. exp. Biol. 15,235-247.
ACTIVE TRANSPORT O F WATER I N INSECTS
129
Wigglesworth, V. B. (1945). Transpiration through the cuticle of insects. J. exp. Biol. 21,97-114. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1947). The epicuticle of an insect, Rhodniusprolixus. Proc. roy. SOC.B 134, 163-181.
Wigglesworth, V. B. (1953). Surface forces in the trachael system of insects. Quurr. J. micr. Sci. W,507-522. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1954). “The Principles of Insect Physiology”. Methuen, London. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1957). The physiology of insect cuticle. Annu. Rev. f i t . 2,37-54. Wigglesworth, V. B. and Beament, J. W. L. (1950). The respiratory mechanisms of some insect eggs. Quart. J . micr. Sci. 91, 429-452. Wolfe, L. S. (1954). The deposition of the third instar larval cuticle of Calliphora erythrocephala. Quart. J . micr. Sci. 95,49.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Colour Discrimination in Insects DIETRICH BURKHARDT Zoological Institute, University of Munich, Germany 131 135 137 137 157 158
I. Historical Background
11. Terminology. . 111. Current State of Knowledge
.
Spectral Range Visible for Insects, the Spectral Sensitivity Curves The Question of the Screening Pigments . Visual Pigments in Insects . Wavelength Discrimination and Central M e c h a n h s of Colour 159 Vision . 169 References . A. B. C. D.
I. H I S T O R I C ABACKGROUND L
The ebility of insects to discriminate between different colours was established beyond doubt just fifty years ago. Scientists and amateurs had investigated colour vision, or discussed it, before this but the final proof was lacking. Thus, for example, the Munich ophthalmologist von Hess in 1913 still claimed that all invertebrates and the fishes were d o u r blind. According to his theory these animals responded to different colours not by discriminating wavelengths but by determining the relative brightness of the different stimuli. The decisive proof was an experiment in which the possibility of brightness-discrimination was excluded. In 1913 von Frisch solved this problem by presenting a set of grey papers of differing reflectances with one coloured paper among them to bees. The bees were trained to search for food placed in a small bowl on the coloured paper. When the bowl with food was removed, the searching bees always gathered on the coloured paper but never on any of the grey papers, one of which must have had the same brightness as the coloured paper. Colour vision was thus proved beyond all doubt for the bee. The same basic method of examining colour vision within the animal kingdom still holds: that is to determine whether the experimental subject is able to discriminate between two visual stirnuti of different wavelengths-or wavelength composition-but independently of their brightness. Unfortunately, there is no similar conclusive proof for colour blindness in animals. If an animal does not react to different colours in any experimental situation, this does not reveal anything about 131
132
DIETRICH BWRKHARDT
colour blindness. It might well be, for example, that the same species could react to colours in some other situation. Several cases are known where animals do react to colours only under very special conditions. Following the pioneer work of von Frisch several other principles were developed to examine colour vision in insects. While the bee is a favourable experimental animal, because it is easily conditioned, other insects are not conditionable. Different methods, therefore, have to be applied using, for example, the optomotor responses. Schlieper (1927) developed a rotating drum with alternating vertical stripes of coloured papers and greys of a certain reflectance. He found that for each given colour a grey of a certain reflectance could be selected so that the animal no longer responded by optomotor reactions (running or making movements with its limbs or body appendages to follow the turn of the drum). Schlieper investigated crustaceans and concluded that for this type of response all animals tested behaved as though colour blind. Von Buddenbrock and Friedrich (1933) improved the method and investigated crabs. First a grey was selected which evoked no alteration in response with a given colour. Next, a second colour was selected of a brightness such that no response occurred if this colour was used in alternation with the grey already given from the first set of experiments. Finally, they used a pattern of alternating stripes of the two colours which gave no response if each of them was used against the reference grey. In spite of the fact that the two colours were equal in brightness in respect to the reference grey, a response could be observed. Obviously, the animals did distinguish different colours from each other despite their equal brightness. This improved method proved to be a powerful tool in examining colour vision in lower animals. While the first experiments of this type were done with crustaceans, Schlegtendahl (1934) and Moller-Racke (1952) showed that several species of insects were able to discriminate colours. Knoll (1921, 1922, 1925, 1927) and later Ilse (1928, 1934, 1937) made use of the spontaneous preference of some insects for certain colours. These insects visited flowers or dummy flowers of the preference colour more frequently than those of any other colours or of greys of different reflectances. Yet another method was used by Hamilton in 1922. He utilized first the phototactic response and second the principle of selective adaptation (the method itself was fist introduced by von Frisch and Kupelwieser (1913) in investigating Crustacea). Drosophilu were presented with two light stimuli of different wavelengths but so matched in brightness that they attracted equal numbers of individuals. Adapting the
C O L O U R D I S C R I M I N A T I O N , I N INSECTS
133
animals before the test to one of the colours resulted in a preference for the colour to which they were not adapted. Evidently, this could not have happened if the animals were colour blind. This basic method of wavelength-dependent adaptation was later modified by other authors. The method most recently introduced is the electrophysiological approach. While Jahn and Crescitelli (1939) did not find any differences in the shape of action potentials elicited by differing wavelengths in the eye of :he moth Cecropia, Walther (1958a, b) was able to prove wavelength-specific time courses of action potentials in the cockroach eye. These differences in the shape of the mass-response were considered to be due to the action of specific receptors for different regions of the spectrum. Walther also showed that in the cockroaqh the electrical response changed in a specific manner due to wavelength-dependent adaptation. Autrum and Stumpf (1 953) combined the electrophysiological method with heterochromatic flickering. Two light sources flickering out of phase and being controlled independently from each other in intensity and wavelength were used. For many combinatiops of wavelengths it proved to be impossible to match the intensities of two intermittent stimuli so that they would be equivalent to a continuously lasting stimulus. In summary it can be said that measurements of heterochromatic flicker-responses, wavelength-selective adaptation and wavelengthdependent shapes of action-potentials may be an indication of colour visioh-if certain methodological limits are kept in mind. In general most of the electrophysiological approaches to this problem do not show whether colour vision is present or not, but they do give information regarding the extent of the visible spectrum and the effectiveness of different stimuli in eliciting responses. With these refinements in methods our knowledge of colour discrimination in insects increased rapidly. In 1886 Lubbock (cited in Lubbock, 1929)found that in ants the visible spectrum did not end in the violet, as in man, but extended further down into the ultraviolet range. This ultraviolet-sensitivity of insects was investigated carefully in bees by Kuhn and Pohl(1921), who also introduced the use of pure spectral lights to replace the broad-band reflected light from coloured papers. Von Frisch demonstrated that bees can distinguish at least two hues (namely those regions of the spectrum apparent to us as orange, yellow and green from those we call blue and violet) and Kiihn and Pohl subsequently demonstrated a much finer wavelength-discrimination. According to their results the bee distinguishes ultraviolet, also bluish green, as separate qualities and
134
1 ) I i l RICH IilJRKHARDT
von Frisch had iipparently neglected the ultraviolet reflectance of the pigment papers used and was therefore misled in his interpretations. Ultraviolet is the complementary region of the spectrum to bluish green for the bee. The paper appearing to us as bluish green must accordingly have appeared nearly colourless to the bee, as proved by M. Hertz (1937). Using pure spectral lights K u h n and Pohl trained the bees to distinguish the blue-green region of the spectrum from other stimuli as a distinct category of colour. I n 1956 Daumer (a co-worker of von Frisch) reinvestigated the bee using an ingenious colorimeter. He found that there are two additional qualities of colours distinguishable by the bee, namely violet and “bees’ purple”, a mixture of yellow and ultraviolet. Thus, the bee is capable of distinguishing at least six major categories of colours : yellow, blue-green, blue, violet, ultraviolet and “bees’ purple”. It is thus established that colour vision in bees is highly developed and is somewhat comparable to colour vision in man. This finding cannot be emphasized enough, for some physiologists and psychologists, experimenting chiefly with humans and higher mammals, are inclined to deny that invcrtebrates may possess such capabilities (cf. Bartley, 1959). The bee’s colour vision is comparatively well known, certainly better than that of other insects. During the last forty years colour discrimination per se has been investigated for many species of several orders of insects, yet very rarely was any additional information gained. Thus we do know that these species are able to discriminate colours but we do not know the hues discriminated, only in a few cases the major categories of colours have been described, but in no single case does the amount of information available compare with that in the case of the bee. In general it is evident that the visible spectrum of insects is shortened at long wavelengths as compared to man but does extend further down in the short wavelength region, i.e. the ultraviolet. Perhaps a few exceptions from this general rule are possible; certain butterflies and possibly the firefly Photinus are for example reported to visualize red stimuli (cf. Kiihn and Ilse, 1925; Ilse, 1928; Buck, 1937). A new field for research was opened very recently, when it proved possible to trace the activity of single photoreceptor cells by means of intracelldar electrodes. The first to do this were workers from a Japanese group (Naka and Kuwabara, 1959a). Almost simultaneously Burkhardt and Autrum (1960) and Burkhardt and Wendler (1960) succeeded in penetrating single photoreceptor units in insects. It therefore became possible to investigate the spectral sensitivity of singlevisual cells in animals which are able to discriminate colours (Autrum and
C O L O U K D I S C R I M I N A T I O N IN I N S E C T S
135
Burkhardt, 1960, 1961 ; Liurkhardk, 1962; Autrum and von Zwehl, 1962; Autrum, 1063). The results of furthcr work along these lines may make a thorodgh understanding of the basic mechanism of colour vision possible at the level of the receptor cells and associated neurons. 11. T E R M I N O L O G Y
In the past much misunderstanding has resulted from the improper use of terms in the field of d o u r vision. A few of the more frequently used ones will therefore be defined here. Intensity. The term light intensity refers to the physical energy-content of the photo-stimulus applied. Intensity may be quantified either in terms of energy (watts) or numbers of quanta, or it may be defined in multiples of a given reference-intensity. In the first case it is referred to as the intensity level, in the second as the quantum level, in the third as the relative intensity level. Since the equation E = h .c / hgives the energy, of any quantum of given wavelength it may readily be calculated that spectral lights of equal energy content mean increasing numbers of quanta with increasing wavelength ;conversely, spectral stimuli of equal quanta decrease in energy content with increasing wavelength. Most modern work refers to stimuli of equal quanta. Brightness is distinguished from intensity of a given stimulus and is measured subjectively in man or behaviourally by an animal's reaction. At any given wavelength the reaction increases normally with intensity, and the relation is a logarithmic one in most cases. Brightness (as indicated by the magnitude of the reaction) therefore increases with the logarithm of intensity. Furthermore, when stimuli of differing wavelengths are compared, the brightness depends not only on intensity, but on the wavelength used. A highly effective wavelength elicits a stronger reaction than a less effective one. At equal physical intensities the more effective stimulus is therefore the brighter one. Wavelength-content. Distinction must also be made between colow and wavelength-content of the stimulus. The wavelength-content describes the physical nature of the stimulus, while the colour is judged by the animal's reaction. Two stimuli of differing wavelength-content may be equal in appearance to the animal (for example, a pure spectral light of 580 mp looks equally yellow to us as does an appropriate mixture of 520 and 640 mp). On the other hand, two stimuli of differing wavelengths may he perceived as similar or equal colours (as, for example, 650 and 750 mp both elicit the sensation red in man). Colour. The term colour is used here chiefly to describe a range of
136
DIETRICH B U R K H A R D T
differing hues, which are nevertheless related. For convenience, in this paper regions of the spectrum are named by their appearance to the human cye. Thus, words like yellow, red and so on are frequently used to describe certain regions of the spectrum. If exceptions are made and the term yellow does not refer to wavelengths between 510 and 575 mp but to the appearance of a composite stimulus it is expressly referred to as yellow-sensation. Furthermore, if any name for a colour does not refer to man but to an animal, it is expressly stated; for example, the word “bees’ purple” does not refer to purple as perceived by man but to a mixture of yellow and ultraviolet, which has stimulating effects to the bee similar to those of a mixture between red and violet to our eye. Spectiul eficiency. The term spectral efficiency (or action spectrum) is described by the following curve. The size of response is plotted against wavelength, while the energy-(or quantum-) level is kept constant. The term spectral sensitivity refers to the curve obtained by noting a constant response and plotting the reciprocal of the intensity necessary to elicit this response against the wavelength used. The spectral sensitivity curve may be constructed also from a set of curves showing the size of response as dependent on intensity at several wavelengths. Finally, this curve may be constructed from the spectral efficiency-curve and one response-intensity-curve for a certain wavelength but this only under some conditions 1 the system dealt with must be a homogeneous population of receptors or a single receptor cell. If this is the case, the size of response to any one wavelength is transferred from the efficiency curve to the response-intensity-curve and the corresponding intensity is read off. These corresponding intensities are replotted versus wavelength and thus reveal the sensitivity curve. If receptors differing in their characteristics are involved, obviously this method is not applicable: the response-intensity-curvesmay differ with wavelength. Colour vision. An animal which does not react in a specific manner to different wavelengths independently from the stimulus-intensity is called colour blind (in the experimental situation, cf. p. 132). Correspondingly an animal which is able to discriminate differing wavelengths or mixtures of them is said to have colour vision. Some physiologists and psychologists are inclined to restrict the term colour vision to man and here to the reactions within the highest cerebral levels. According to their opinion reactions of animals ought to be called spectral vision, and finally reactions within the retinal levels ought to be referred to as spectral responses (cf. Bartley, 1959). But this proposal is not thoroughly useful. Experimental situations not only deal with pure spectral lights, but with mixtures of them in addition. These mixtures may give rise to
C O L O U R DISCRlMINATlON IN INSECTS
137
the same reactions as a pure spectral light of wavelengths quite different from any of the components of the mixed stimulus. Hence the term spectral vision or spectral response does not apply to the topics under consideration. Certainly the term colour as used in general refers to the appearance of wavelength-regions or mixtures of spectral lights to the human eye and under no circumstances can we state anything about the animal’s impressions. But keeping this in mind, the term colour discrimination may well be applied to the ability of animals to distinguish differing spectral lights or mixtures of them from each other and independently from intensity. Even the term colour vision might be applied if the experimental material indicates strongly enough that integrative actions are taking place within the central nervous system of the animal which are comparable to the events in the human brain. As will be discussed later in full detail, at least in the honeybee this is definitely the case. While discussing these matters, it might be useful to indicate where some of the misunderstandings arise. Investigating the range of spectral lights visible to an insect or determining the spectral sensitivity (or efficiency) curve does not tell anything about colour vision. But some authors entitle their work on range of visible spectrum as investigations on colour vision. If the animal does visualize red light this does not tell anythiiig about colour vision and the ability of this species to discriminate red light as a quality of colour, but only indicates that the eyes of this animal are sensitive to long wavelengths. 111.
C U R R E N T S T A T E OF
KNOWLEDGE
A. SPECTRAL RANGE VISIBLE FOR INSECTS, THE SPECTRAL SENSITIVITY CURVES
1, General considerations
Sevzral methods have been applied to determine the spectral range visualized by insects : phototactic reactions, behavioural preference of a colour, optomotor responses, conditioning and electrophysiological methods. It turned out that all insect species investigated in this respect arecapable of visualizing ultraviolet within the range from 300 to 400 mp or even below, cf. Bertholf (1932) (data are listed in papers by Goldsmith, 1961; Weiss et at., 1942, 1943). The values of long wavelength limits sre not so clearly defined. In general, the long end of the spectrum visible to insects seems to be shifted 100 mp towards shorter wavelengths as compared with the spectrum visible to man. The bee does not react
138
DIETRICH R U K K H A R D T
to wavelengths above about 600 mp (cf. Daumer, 1956), nor do most other insects investigated unless extreme intensities are applied. Some exceptions to this state of affairs are certain in diurnal butterflies (which are reported to be attracted by red-coloured natural or experimental stimuli), a firefly and a few other species (cf. von Frisch, 1960; Autrum, 1960). How uncertain this question may be is shown by the results obtained from several authors on Vespidae: while Armbruster (1922) and Molitor (1939) claim that Vespa vulgaris and V. germanica are able to distinguish red as a colour (and hence their visible spectrum must extend to this region), Schremmer in 1941 found that V.rufu confused red and black pigmented papers. The red-sensitivity of flies is also questionable even though often reported (Autrum and Stumpf, 1953; Walther and Dodt, 1959; Mazokhin-Porshniakov, 1960a, b) and it is considered to be an indication for a special red-receptor-system. This problem will be discussed in more detail on page 143. It appears likely however, that these species are not any more sensitive at the long-wavelengths-end of the spectrum than the bee, i.e. the range of the spectrum visible to them .i cut off at approximately 650 mp (Autrum, 1955; Hoffmann and ,anger, 1961;Burkhardt, 1962). While each method will give valid results in determining the cut-off ends of the visible spectrum, only a very few methods are adequate to determine the exact shape of the spectral sensitivity (or efficiency) curve. To do this, a response must be chosen as a test, which is dependent in a graded fashion on the effectiveness of the stimulus. This may be a reaction graded either by itself or by the statistical probability of all-or-none responses in single animals or in a population. Two possible cases can be distinguished. (a) The response of the animal may be mediated by a receptor system containing only one type of receptor in respect to spectral sensitivity. In this casc the effects of wavelength and intensity of the stimuli applied will be interchangeable, so that alternation of each of the two parameters will result in a change of brightness and nothing else. Any reaction depending in a graded fashion on intensity will give in this case an undistorted picture of the spectral sensitivity, if the wavelength is changed. (b) In the second type of system under consideration the receptorsystem mediating the reaction consists of two or more different types of receptor elements with differing spectral characteristics. In principle such a system is capable of colour discrimination. Stimuli of different wavelengths and intensities are not interchangeable. At a given wavelength, for example, there will be a certain ratio between the sizes of ill response of the two differing receptors. Increasing the intensity w increase the responses of both the receptors, while the ratio between them
C O L O U R D I S C R I M I N A T I O N IN INSECTS
139
will stay the same or similar. Alternating the wavelength of the stimulus while its intensity is kept constant will change the sizes of individual responscs and in addition the ratio between them. A reaction chosen for theexperimental test may depend not only on the intensity, but inaddition or solely on the spectral characteristics of the stimulus. It might well be., that only the excitation of one type of receptor-element elicits a certain response of the animal. If this reaction is used, the spectral sensitivity of the eye as a whole is not measured, but the spectral sensitivity of this particular receptor type. Furthermore, quite complex central integrative mechanisms may introduce distortions in the shape of the responsecurve. For example, it is reported that the cabbage-butterfly, Pieris