n
Advances in Genetics
Volume 37
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
n
Volume 37
Advances in Genetics Edited by ...
26 downloads
1612 Views
30MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
n
Advances in Genetics
Volume 37
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
n
Volume 37
Advances in Genetics Edited by Jeffery C. Hall
Jay C. Dunlap
Department of Biology Brandeis University Waltham, Massachusetts
Department of Biochemistry Dartmouth Medical School Hanover, New Hampshire
Theodore Friedmann
Francesco Giannelli
Department of Pediatrics Center for Molecular Genetics School of Medicine University of California, San Diego La Jolla, California
Division of Medical and Molecular Genetics United Medical and Dental Schools of Guy’s and St. Thomas’ Hospital London Bridge, London, United Kingdom
W
Academic Press San Diego
London
Boston
New York
Sydney
Tokyo
Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
@
Copyright 0 1998 by ACADEMIC PRESS All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Publisher. The appearance of the code at the bottom of the first page of a chapter in this book indicates the Publisher’s consent that copies of the chapter may be made for personal or internal use of specific clients. This consent is given on the condition, however, that the copier pay the stated per copy fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, Massachusetts 01923). for copying beyond that permitted by Sections 107 or 108 of the US. Copyright Law. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying, such as copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for creating new collective works, or for resale. Copy fees for pre-1998 chapters are as shown on the title pages. If no fee code appears on the title page, the copy fee is the same as for current chapters. 0065-2660/98 $25.00
Academic Press a division of Harcourt Brace & Company
525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA
http://www.apnet.com Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ International Standard Book Number: 0-12-017637-8 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 97 98 9 9 0 0 01 0 2 B C 9 8 7 6
5
4
3 2 1
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, 1 and Position Effect Variegation I. E Zhimulev 1. General Remarks 1 11. Morphology of the Heterochromatic Regions of the Chromosomes in Dividing Cells 5 111. Repetitive Sequences 43 IV. Genetic Content of Heterochromatic Regions 55 of Mitotic Chromosomes V. Diminution of Chromatin and Chromosomes 78 VI. Centromeric Heterochromatin in Polytene Chromosomes 90 VII. Intercalary Heterochromatin 134 VIII. Telomeric Heterochromatin 238 IX. The B Chromosomes 282 X. Heterochromatin of Chromosomes Restricted to Germline Cells
304
XI. Changes in Expression of Genes Dependent on Their Position in the Genome 306 XII. Genetic Inactivation under Position Effect Variegation 309 XIII. Modification of Gene Expression under Position Effect 334 XIV. Time of Genetic Inactivation in Development 355 XV. Unusual Cases of Position Effect 357 XVI. Molecular and Cytogenetic Aspects of Position Effect Variegation
376
XVII. Current Concepts of the Mechanism of Position Effect 422 Variegation XVIII. Heterochromatization of Chromosome Regions and Regulation of Gene Activity 435 References
Index
557
444
V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation 1. F. Zhimulev Institute of Cytology and Genetics Siberian Division of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk 630090 Russia
1. GENERAL REMARKS A. Foreword Problems relating to the organization of heterochromatin are prominent in our general thinking about the organization of genetic material in chromosomes. Although investigators continue to focus attention on these problems, there is, as yet, no comprehensive account of all the facts. It is little wonder that Shah et al. (1973) mention Pontecorvo’s statement made 15 years earlier: “studies on heterochromatin are at the prescientific level . . . and we have no other alternative as to ignore it” (p. 467). In recent years, it has been demonstrated that the features of DNA primary structure, in particular the repetitiveness of nucleotide sequences, underlie heterochromatin structure. Quite reasonably, John and Miklos (1979) commence their review with Walker’s epigraph that we know so much about the structure, variability, and localization of satellite DNA that it becomes all the more remarkable that we know nothing about the origin and functions of these specific DNA sequences (p. 1). In this monograph various aspects of heterochromatin organization in the mitotic and interphase polytene chromosomes are considered. As a rule, a multitude of details pertaining to the organization of heterochromatin at the high resolution achievable with the use of highly decondensed chromosomes are analyzed. The effect of heterochromatin on fragments of euchromatic regions transposed to close proximity under position effect is treated. The book is the second authored by Dr. Zhimulev concerned with polyAdvances in Genetics, Vol. 37 Copyright 0 1998 by Academic Press. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. 0065-2660198 $25.00
1
2
1. F. Zhimulev
tene chromosomes. The first volume, “Morphology and Structure of Polytene Chromosomes” (Zhimulev, 1996), has been published as Volume 34 of Advances in Genetics; in addition a series of short versions of these reviews have been published in Russian (Zhimulev, 199213, 1993, 1994). The author is faithful to his style: detailed accounts are combined with extensive references to the treated topics. The accounts are restricted to analysis of facts obtained with animal and plant species possessing polytene chromosomes. This is done so as to make possible comparisons of the results obtained with the compact mitotic and the decondensed interphase (polytene) chromosomes.
B. Introduction Our body of knowledge of heterochromatin was gleaned unhurriedly through a protracted course of time. In the past century, cytologists were aware of the existence of various heavily staining bodies appearing as clumps, rods, or drops in the interphase nuclei (for a more detailed historical account, see Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1986, p. 15-19). In the 1920s and 1930s, having studied the behavior of chromosomes during the cell cycle, E. Heitz demonstrated that these enigmatic bodies are either specific chromosomes or chromosome regions retaining a compact state and, therefore, stronger stainability during the entire cell cycle. Starting from the formation of the nucleus in telophase, they remain compact until the beginning of the successive division, they then decondense for a brief time and assume anew (earlier than the rest of chromosome material) the compact state. By analogy with the accepted term “heterochromosome,” referring to the sex chromosomes, which retained increased compaction and stainability throughout the cell cycle in some insect species, the concept of heterochromatin was suggested for these bodies. The remaining chromatin was called euchromatin, the condensation-decondensationcycle of which underlies mitotic division (Heitz, 1928,1929,1930, 1932, 1933a,b, 1934, 1935). Comparisons of the properties of heterochromatin in mitotic and polytene chromosomes led Heitz to the conclusion that there exist two types of heterochromatin that differ in degree of compaction: a-heterochromatin, the more compact, heavily staining and, presumably, the less decondensed in the mitotic cycle; and P-heterochromatin, the more diffuse, loose, and weakly staining. At first, Heitz made a distinction between heterochromatin and euchromatin relying on the criterion of degree of compaction, or, as he put it, the degree of heteropycnosis. He also suggested that the heterochromatic regions are genetically inert because loss of these regions or decrease in their size was inconsequential. Furthermore, according to the concepts accepted in those years, the chromosomes are “genetically active” only in the nucleus itself, not at mitosis, and, hence, the heterochromatic regions resembling mitotic chromosomes in compaction degree should, in his view, be “genetically inert.” This prediction was
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
3
brilliantly confirmed by Muller and Painter (1932), who have demonstrated that almost all the then-known genes residing on the X chromosome are located only in its euchromatic portion. Subsequently, it was shown that genes are, nevertheless, present in heterochromatin, although with an occurrence frequency lower by two orders of magnitude than in euchromatin (see reviews in Hilliker and Sharp, 1988; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992; Zhimulev, 1993). There followed a continual discovery of new properties ofheterochromatin. In 1959, it became apparent that heterochromatin replicates at the end of the S phase (“late replication”) (Lima-de-Faria, 1959a,b; for review, see Lima-de-Faria and Jaworska, 1968). There is considerably less heterochromatin in the polytene than the mitotic chromosomes (Painter, 1933). This was found to be due to incomplete poly’ tenization of a part of the chromatids constituting heterochromatin during the formation of polytene chromosomes (Rudkin, 1965a, 1969). A property of heterochromatin, such as its “fragility,” may possibly be explained by underpolytenization: the chromosomes are most frequently ruptured in regions of centromeric heterochromatin during the making of squash chromosome preparations. Another property, higher concentration of chromosomal rearrangements, has also been related to heterochromatin (Kaufmann, 1939; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya and Khvostova, 1939; Mukhina et al., 1981). The finding of repetitive DNA sequences in the eukaryotic genome (Britten and Kohne, 1968)and the method of in situ hybridization (Gall and Pardue, 1969) provided a broader basis for an understanding of heterochromatin structure and detection of its richness in repetitive DNA sequences (Lohe and Roberts, 1988; Lohe et al., 1993). Numerous regions intercalated into euchromatin and showing all the properties of heterochromatin were identified in polytene chromosomes: the socalled intercalary heterochromatin. According to the view taken by Ananiev et al. (1978; Gvozdev, 1981a,b), it consists of material of mobile genetic elements, it is the view of Zhimulev et al. (1982) that it is composed of tandem repeats. The existence of intercalary heterochromatin was even in doubt (Spofford, 1976; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992). Specific molecular genetic structures, the telomeres, were detected in the interphase polytene chromosomes at the chromosomes’ tips (Muller, 1932, 1941; Rubin, 1978) that possess all the morphological features of heterochromatin. Many reviews are concerned with the properties of heterochromatin; the following deserve mention: Frolova (1934), Gershenzon (1940), Schultz (1941b, 1943a, 1947, 1956, 1965), Pontecorvo (1944), Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1945, 1947, 1977a,b, 1981, 1986), Resende (1949, Barigozzi (1950), Hannah (1951), Alfert (1954, Cooper (1959), Beermann (1962), Rudkin (1965b,1972), Brown (1966), Yunis and Yasmineh (1971), Berendes (1973), Shah et al. (1973), White (1973), Sandler (1975), Back (1976), Spofford (1976), John and Miklos (1979,
4
I. F. Zhirnulev
1988), Smirnov and Smaragdov (19791, Stahl and Hartung (1981), Rocchi (1982), Babu and Verma (1987), Hilliker and Sharp (1988),John (1988), Verma (1988), Pardue and Hennig (1990), Belyaeva and Zhimulev (1991), Dryanovska etal. (1991), Bataninetal. (19921,GattiandPimpinelli(19921, Zhimulev (1992a, 1993), Gvozdev (1993), Cook and Karpen (1994), Eissenberg et al. (1995) Lohe and Hilliker (19959, Weiler and Wakimoto (1995), Zacharias (1995), Zuckerkandl and Hennig (1995), and Elgin (1996). A remarkable experimental model for studying the physiological role of heterochromatin is position effect. When a euchromatic region is transposed to heterochromatin, the genes immediately adjacent to it can become inactivated under position effect (Muller, 1930). The degree of genetic inactivation can be modified by various agents, including variation in heterochromatin amount in the cell. Thus, by taking advantage of position effect, the influence of gene activity in both trans and cis positions can be clarified (Belgovsky, 1944;Lewis, 1950; Hannah, 1951; Baker, 1968; Zakharov, 1968; Birstein, 1976; Spofford, 1976; Becker, 1978;Lima-de-Faria, 1986; Babu and Verma, 1987; Eissenberg, 1989; Tartof et al., 1989; Spradling and Karpen, 1990; Henikoff, 1992; Reuter and Spierer, 1992; Zhimulev, 1992a, 1993; Henikoff et al., 1993; Spradling, 1993; Karpen, 1994; Eissenbergetal., 1995;Elgin, 1996). It was Noujdin’s (1947) opinion that, withstudies on position effect, “the time, when heterochromatic (inert) regions of the chromosome were regarded as inactive regions, not playing any role in heredity and development, was left far behind. Research on mosaicism established the exclusive significance of heterochromatic material in the processes of intracellular metabolism, and, concomitantly, in hereditary changes” (p. 192). Studies on the morphological and morphofunctional organization of chromosomefragments in close proximity to heterochromatin demonstrated that genetic inactivation is related to compaction of the chromosome region (Schultz, 1965; Zhimulev et al., 1986; Belyaeva and Zhimulev, 1991) and to the acquisition of the properties of a-heterochromatin. However, the manifestation of the properties of heterochromatin, at least the intercalary type, is modified by the same factors that affect degree of compaction of euchromatin under position effect. This may be evidence for the close similarity between the DNA inactivation mechanisms in heterochromatin and adjacent euchromatin (Zhimulev et al., 1989a,b). A major breakthrough in studies of heterochromatin and position effect came with the discovery of the complex gene system affecting the expression of genetic inactivation and, consequently, the compaction degree of chromatin (Spofford, 1967; Reuter and Wolff, 1981; Sinclair et al., 1983; Eissenberg, 1989; Tartoff et al., 1989; Reuter et al., 1990). Modifiers show dose transitions: a gene can suppress genetic activation in one dose, give rise to the normal phenotype in two doses, and enhance the normal phenotype in three doses. This becomes comprehensible in view of the remarkable consequences of the action of the position
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
5
effect modifier genes on the structure of chromatin proteins. To illustrate, one of these genes affects the acetylation of histones (Dorn et al., 1986),and the product of another gene is a protein contained by heterochromatin and, presumably, providing its compaction (Eissenberg e t al., 1987; James et al., 1989). These data may provide evidence for universality of the mechanisms providing compaction of chromosome material in eu- and heterochromatin, and pose in a new light the problem of what constitutes eu- and heterochromatin. White (1945) holds the view that heterochromatin may be any region of a chromosome that has become heteropycnotic at certain stages of the cell cycle. In contrast, Schultz (1947) defined heterochromatin as chromosome regions that have the specific property of remaining in compact blocks in the intermitotic state. The more profound concept of heterochromatin as both a substance (constitutive heterochromatin) and a condition (facultative heterochromatin) suggested by Brown (1966)was strongly criticized by Prokofieva-Belgovskaya (1977a, 1986). In the meantime, the acquisition of the features of heterochromatin by one of the female X chromosomes has remained beyond doubt (Lyon, 1961). From this brief outline, it is apparent that new information calling for closer scrutiny has accumulated in the research area of heterochromatin.
II. MORPHOLOGY OF THE HETEROCHROMATIC REGIONS OF THE CHROMOSOMES IN DIVIDING CELLS A. Change in compaction degree during the cell cycle It was known in the beginning of this century that particular chromosomes or their fragments appear more condensed and deeply stained than the rest of the chromosome material during the cell cycle. This differential condition was called heteropycnosis (Gutherz, 1907). Heteropycnosis is negative when staining is light, and it is positive when staining is heavy. Heitz (1928) coined the term “heterochromatin” to draw a distinction between the chromosome regions that show positive heteropycnosis at certain stages of the mitotic cycle and the rest of the chromosome material passing through usual compaction-decompaction cycles of cell division, called euchromatin. In the majority of eukaryotic species, the chromosomes contain both euand heterochromatic regions, with the latter constituting, as a rule, the bulk of the genome. Thus, in Drosophila mekmoguster, the male Y chromosome is almost completely heteropycnotic, whereas heterochromatin makes up to 40-50% of the length of the X chromosome (Hannah, 1951; Ananiev et al., 1973) and 29% of that of the third chromosome. Presumably, the fourth chromosome is almost completely heterochromatic. The total percentage of heterochromatin in the karyotype is 33% of chromosome length (Ananiev et al., 1973; Gatti e t al., 1976).
6
1.
F. Zhimulev
In several species, this percentage is rather high, being 30% for Dosophila simulans, 52% for D. uirilis, 47% for D. texanu, 30% for D. hydei, 33% for D. ezoana (Gatti et al., 1976; Pimpinelli et al., 1976), 40% for D. na~uta(Lakhotia and Kumar, 1978), 45% for D. grimshawi, and 55-60% for D. cyrtoloma (Clayton, 1985). Concepts of changes in the compaction condition of the heterochromatic regions during the cell cycle, the major feature of heterochromatin accompanying its description, are rather controversial. According to the data of Heitz and other authors, starting from the early prophase, the heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes become readily identified and different in staining from the euchromatic regions (Figure 1).These differences disappear by the end of the rnetaphase. At the next interphase, the heterochromatic regions are represented by numerous heavily staining grains or large blocks of heteropycnotic material (see Figure I), which have long been termed “chromocenters” (Heitz, 1928, 1929, 1930, 1932, 1933a, 193313, 1934, 1935; Kaufmann, 1934; Frolova, 1934; Dobzhansky, 1944). In Glossina austeni, differences in the compaction rate of the usual and supernumerary chromosomes (or the S chromosome, see Section IX), rich in heterochromatin, were detected. The S and Y chromosomes are condensed as early as the beginning of early prophase, and they appear as condensed, heavily staining bodies at the middle of the prophase (Southern et al., 1972). At meiosis, heterochromatic regions become conspicuous as early as the stage of leptotene (Huettner, 1930). Schultz (1947) was thus led to formulate the concept of heterochomatin: chromosome regions that possess the specific property of retaining a blocklike appearance at the intermitotic stage. Euchromatin and heterochromatin differ in cycles of compaction: while the former passes through the entire cycle of compaction-decompaction from interphase, the latter remains in a comparatively compacted state. These differences have long been called allocycly (Darlington and La Cour, 1940). The compaction degree of the packaging of heterochromatin at a particular stage of the cell cycle may be considerable; thus, for example, the integrity and general morphology of the chromocenters in mouse liver cells are retained during preparative isolation involving procedures such as treatment with DNase I1 and ultrasound (Stephanova and Pashev, 1988). However, “permanence” of tight packaging of material in the heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes is relative:
1. Kaufmann (1934) did not detect heavy staining of heterochromatin of the autosomes at the prophase stage, while the heterochromatin of the X and Y chromosomes appearing as heteropycnotic blocks differs in the neuroblast cells in interphase. Permanent heteropycnosis of heterochromatic elements also was not identified in gonial cells (Cooper, 1959). 2. Heteropycnotic regions are not identified in the interphase nuclei of embryos at any of the cleavage stages (see Section 11,G).
Figure 1. Heterochromatin in Drosophila in the early (A, 8,E-G), middle (C, D, H-J, L), and late (K) prophase and metaphase ( M a ) of mitosis, and heterochromatic blocks in interphase (P-R). (A-D) after Kaufmann (1934); (E-L) after Cooper (1959); (M-R) after Heitz (1933a).
8
1. F. Zhimulev
3. In the interphase nuclei of Drosophikz, the number of chromocenters varies from 0 to 5. Their absence may be evidence for complete decompaction of heterochromatin at any of the interphase stages, possibly at the end of the S phase, when chromatin DNA replicates (Smimov and Smaragdov, 1979).
4. Measurements of the lengths of the mitotic chromosomes of Drosophila at different stages of decompaction have demonstrated that the ability of the chromosome to shorten diminishes with increased heterochromatin content in it (Figure 2). Measurements of the total length of heterochromatin in all the chromosomes demonstrated that they vary in the range of 4.7-7.2 pm, while the absolute length of the haploid set lies in the range of 13.5-67 pm (Ananiev et at., 1973). These data support first the concept of the considerable compaction of heterochromatin at the early stages of mitosis and, second, that of impermanent compaction of heterochromatin during the cell cycle. 5. Various factors affecting compaction degree have been identified. These include various DNA ligands binding to the AT-rich regions of double-strand-
-.-.
-*-----------.
d . .
I
so il 7a Figure 2. Correlation between changes in the absolute length of the mitotic chromosomes (ordinate) and the total length of the haploid set (abscissa)of the chromosomesof Dosophila neuroblasts. Numbers and letters designate the third, the second, the X, the Y, and the fourth chromosomes.After Ananiev et al. (1973). Il,
20
Jo
W
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
9
ed DNA (distamycin A, Hoechst 33258, DAPI I), treatment with these ligands in interphase leads to inhibition of compaction at the next prophase.
1. Factors affecting compaction degree All data show that the heterochromatic fragments of chromosomes during the cell cycle appear more condensed than the rest of the chromosome material. Numerous factors can change the degree of compaction.
a. Hoechst 33258 Treatment of Drosophila cells at the subsequent mitotic cycle revealed a delay in compaction (Figure 3 ) of various heterochromatic regions (Pimpinelli et al., 1975; Gatti et al., 1976; Lakhotia and Roy, 1981; Roy et al., 1982; Felcher et al., 1982; Smirnov, 1984; Smirnov et al., 1986). The pattern of compaction delay is species specific, for example, in D. mehnoguster, the distal region of heterochromatin of chromosome 3L and the centromeric block of the Y chromosome, as well as the proximal part of the heterochromatin of the X and Y chromosomes, are the most decompacted. In D. simulans, heterochromatin is almost completely decompacted (Gatti et al., 1976). According to other data, the frequency of compaction delay in D. melamgmer was the highest in the X chromosome, the Y chromosome ranked next, and chromosome 3L was the last (Felcher et al., 1982; Smirnov et al., 1986).To compare, compaction delay was identified in metaphases at frequencies of 48% in D. melanoguster and 2.5% in D. simulans, and it was not identified in the third related species, D. mauritiunu (Smirnov et al., 1986). Only a certain part of heterochomatin is subject to the decompacting effect of the Hoechst stain-for example, only 13% of metaphases of the third chromosome of D. melanoguster. This allowed Felcher et al. (1982) to make the conclusion that “the relation between heterochromatin in interphase and mitosis is much more complicated than appeared to be within the framework of the concept of permanent compaction of heterochromatin during the cell cycle” (p. 1144). As suggested by Felcher et ul., interphase chromocenters do not represent the entire heterochromatin identified in mitosis. The composition of the karyotype affects the frequency of compaction delay produced by the Hoechst 33258 stain. In D. melanoguster, the occurrence frequency of abnormal metaphases is the highest in XX and very low in XO males (Felcher et al., 1982, Smirnov et al., 1986). When the embryonic cells of D. nusuta, were treated with Hoechst in conjunction with 5-bromodeoxyuridine, compaction was inhibited in fewer cells, and heterochromatin was more decompacted in those in which it was. However, treatment of neuroblast cells with 5-bromodeoxyuridine neutralizes the effect of the Hoechst stain (Lakhotia and Roy, 1981).
10
1. F. Zhirnulev
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
11
When cells are sequentially treated with hypotonic saline and the Hoechst stain, or with other DNA-specific ligands such as distamycin A, netropsin, and olivomycin, interphase heterochromatin sharply condenses (Figure 4). It is known that the Hoechst stain preferentially binds to the AT-rich regions of DNA (see Section 11,B). Delay in decompaction attributable to this agent was detected only in species that have AT-rich satellites (D. melanogaster, D. simulans, D.uin'lis, D.texana). In D. hydei and D. ezoana, weak decompaction was revealed only in the Y chromosome (Pimpinelli et al., 1975; Gatti et al., 1976;Felcher et al., 1982; Smimov et al., 1986). It was suggested that during the S phase the Hoechst stain preferentially binds to the specific regions of the chromosomes interacting with the proteins that determine the mitotic compaction of chromatin (Gatti et al., 1976).
b. Distamycin A In four species of Drosophila, the pattern of compaction delay of the chromosomes from embryonic and neuroblast cells produced by treatment with distamycin A correlated with the distribution of AT-rich regions (Q-bands, see Section II,B) and satellite DNA. The correlation was most clear cut for D. uirilis, in whose chromosomes compaction was incomplete both in the Q+ and Q+ regions. In D. melanogaster, the Q++ region was more frequently and the Q + region was less frequently decompacted; in D. hycki and D. funebns, the correlation between compaction delay and Q+staining was less distinct (Faccio Dolfini and Bonifazio Razzini, 1983; Faccio Dolfini, 1987). +
c. Low temperature It was shown in the 1940s that certain regions of the mitotic chromosomes of plants and amphibia, which appear euchromatic at normal temperature, become heterochromatic when temperature is lowered (Darlington and La Cour, 1940; Callan, 1942). After exposure of the larvae of Drosophila to low temperature (6°C for 24 hr), the metaphase chromosomes sharply shorten while the regions of centromeric Figure 3. Changes in the compaction state of heterochromatin in D. melanogaster under ( A ) the effect of low temperature, (RE)treatment of living material with Hoechst 33258, and (F-K) the mw-lOl" mutation. (A) Karyotype of a female; arrow indicates the decompacted regions of heterochromatin of the X chromosomes. (B and C) Controls: (B) karyotype of a male; (C) karyotype of a female. (D) Karyotype of a male after 4 hr of treatment. Arrows indicate the decompacted regions of an arm of the third chromosome, arrowheads indicate the decompacted regions of the X chromosome, and letters and numbers designate chromosomes. (F) Control (18°C). (G-K) At 29°C; arrows indicate the decompacted regions of heterochromatin in the Y chromosome (G-I), in one of the autosomes (J), and in the X chromosome (K). (A) after Brosseau (1967); ( R E ) after Pimpinelli et nl. (1975); (F-K) after Gatti ec al. (1983).
Figure 4. Changes in the compaction state of heterochromatin under the effect of irradiation with y-rays in Akodon molinae (Rodentia, Cricetidae) (a) and combined treatment with hypotonic saline and Hoechst 33258 in D. nmuta (b-f). (a) Arrow indicates a decompacted chromosome. (b) Control interphase nuclei with large loose chromocenters. (c) Treatment with Hoechst for 4 hr. (d) Treatment with hypotonic saline. (e and f) Compact chromocenters after treatment with hypotonic saline and Hoechst. (a) after Bianchi (1982); (b-f) after Lakhotia and Roy (1981). 12
Polylene Chromosomes, Helerochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
13
heterochromatin remain decompacted (see Figure 3). T h e Occurrence frequency of metaphases with such chromosomes was high, although not 100% (Brosseau,
1967).
d. Anoxia In embryos of Drosophila (at the blastoderm stage) deprived of oxygen, development is rapidly arrested. The interphase chromosomes are compacted, each becoming visible during the arrest (Foe and Alberts, 1985). e. Radiation effect In y-irradiated mammalian cells, single compact chromosomes are identified in 0.33% of metaphase spreads, while the rest of the chromosomes of the set are typically metaphase (see Figure 4).Three hypotheses have been advanced to account for this phenomenon: (1 ) numerous breaks may arise in the DNA molecule during irradiation; (2) the protein scaffold, which is possibly involved in the process of chromosome compaction, may be impaired; and (3) mutations may arise at loci controlling compaction. If the latter hypothesis is correct, the existence of such loci in every chromosome should be accepted (Bianchi, 1982).
f. Genetic control of compaction In homozygotes for the lethal temperature-sensitive mutation mapped to the X chromosome of Drosophila, ms-l Olrsl, all the mitotic chromosomes are normal at 18°C. However, after exposure to high temperature (29°C) for 2 hr, the Y chromosome becomes longer and, in many cases, elongated stretches appear in twothirds of metaphase spreads (see Figure 3). In a small number of cells, incomplete compaction of heterochromatin is revealed in autosomes. After longer exposure, heterochromatin is incompletely compacted in the Y chromosome in almost all the spreads and in all the chromosomes in some spreads. The patterns of compaction delay produced by mutation or treatment with the Hoechst stain are diverse (Gatti et al., 1983). In l(2)gl mutants, compaction of mitotic chromosomes varies in a very wide range from superdecompacted to supershort (Radhakrisnan and Sinha, 1987).
2. Mechanisms of compaction Little is known about the molecular mechanisms of heterochromatin compaction. Muller and Prokofyeva (1935, p. 658) believed that a heterochromatic region “does not coil into a spiral, when the chromosome undergoes changes preparative to mitosis. . . . The chromonema in this region should be, for this reason, amidst a great mass of accessory (non-genic) chromatic material, which makes it about as thick as the coiled into spiral” euchromatic region of the chromosome. T h e view that accumulation of “accessory material” remaining in the heterochromat-
14
I. F. Zhimulev
ic regions is possible even during mitotic compaction of the chromosomes was shared by Cooper (1959). Muller and Prokofyeva ( 1935) believed that, insofar as heterochromatin occupies only a small portion of the polytene chromosomes, there should not be much “genic material” in the mitotic chromosomes either (underreplication of heterochromatic DNA in polytene chromosomes was then not yet established) (see Section VI,C). From their point of view, the comparatively voluminous heterochromatic fragment of the mitotic chromosome can be accounted for by accumulation of accessory material. However, calculations demonstrate that only satellite DNA fills to a great extent the heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes of Drosophila: 77,67, 54,22, and 79% (Smirnov, 1984). What role proteins play in compaction is unclear. Large amounts of nonhistone proteins were not detected in heterochromatin of the embryonic cells of D. virilis (Comings et al., 1977). However, there are suggestions that nonhistone proteins may also be involved in compaction (Burkholder and Weaver, 1977; Burkholder and Duczek, 1982).
8. Differential staining
1. C-staining In 1970 Pardue and Gall (1970) noted that centromeric heterochromatin in mouse chromosomes stained more heavily with Giemsa after DNA denaturation-renaturation in in situ hybridization. Hsu and Arrighi (1971; Arrighi and Hsu, 1971; Hsu, 1973) suggested a technique for treating chromosome preparations permitting differential staining of eu- and heterochromatin. The main steps of the procedure included denaturation of chromosomal DNA by treatment with 0.07M NaOH, renaturation (65”C), and staining with a Giemsa solution. Having thus treated chromosome preparations of 20 mammalian species, they demonstrated that the regions of centromeric heterochromatin more densely stained by the conventional methods also stained heavily with Giemsa, whereas euchromatin remained lightly stained. The investigators called the procedure of staining for constitutive (C) heterochromatin the C-staining technique, or C-banding. The technique has since been modified (Sumner, 1978). C-heterochromatin has been described in dipteran species of the Calliphoridae (Ullerich, 1976, Bedo, 1980, 1991), Cecidomyiidae (Bregman, 19751, Chironomidae (Hagele and Speier, 1988), and Culicidae families (Motara and Rai, 1977, 1978); in D. funebns (Faccio Dolfini, 1987); in D. hydei (Pimpinelli et al., 1976; Beck and Srdic, 1979; Faccio Dolfini, 1987); in D. melanogaster (Hsu, 1971;Pimpinelliet al., 1976; Halfer and Barigozzi, 1977; Faccio Dolfini and Halfer, 1978; Sved and Verlin, 1980; Faccio Dolfini, 1987; Vlassova et al., 1991a,b); in the species of the rnelanoguster group (Lemeunier et al., 1978); in D. m u t a
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
15
Figure 5. Localization ofeu- and heterochromatin in Drosophifadetected by the criterion ofcompaction (a) and according to the results ofC-banding (band c). Numbers and letters designate chromosomes. Karyotypes: (b) female; ( c )male. Scale is 5 pm. a after Heitz ( 1933b); band c after Faccio Dolfini (1974).
(Wheeler and Altenburg, 1977; Lakhotia and Kumar, 1978); in D. simuhns (Pimpinelli et al., 1976); in the species of the virilis group (Pimpinelli et al., 1976; Faccio Dolfini, 1987); in Hawaiian Drosophih (Clayton, 1985); and in species of the Glossinidae (Davies and Southern, 1976), Sarcophagidae (Kaul et al., 1978, 1989a; Samols and Swift, 1979a), Sciaridae (Eastman et al., 1980), and Tephritidae (Bedo, 1986, 1989) families. There is, as a rule, a good agreement between the location of heterochromatic regions identified by allocycly of compaction (staining with orcein) and C-banding in all the studied species (Figure 5). The mechanism of C-staining is unclear. In the majority of cases, the position of the C-stained regions of the chromosomes is coincident with the location of satellite DNA (see Section 111). There are very important exceptions, for example, the Y chromosome of D. hydei does not contain highly repetitive DNA (Hennig, 1973), yet shows distinct C-staining. Similar inconsistencies were found for the chromosomes of several other species (see Pimpinelli et al., 1976).
2. Q- and H- staining In 1969, in Caspersson’s laboratory, a method of differential staining of chromosomes based on preferential banding of various fluorochromes to chromosomal
16
I. F. Zhirnulev
DNA was developed (Caspersson et al., 1969). Some of the fluorochromes proved to be very effective in identification of heterochromatin. The first fluorochrome used was quinacrine, hence the name Q-staining (Figure 6). In the chromosomes treated with the reagent, fluorescence was revealed in the region of centromeric heterochromatin (see Figure 6)--or not revealed, as, for example, in D. ananassae (Adkisson et al., 1971). Q-staining varies considerably along the length of the metaphase chromosome (Figure 7). Regions that fluoresce brightest with quinacrine have been tentatively designated as Q++,the regions that do not fluoresce as Q--, and the intermediate variants as Q' and Q-. It is believed that quinacrine intercalates in the DNA without any specificity to base pairs; however, fluorescence is detected mainly in the AT-rich regions, because the neighboring GC-rich DNA quenches fluorescence. The following facts support the concept of the specificity of fluorescence in the AT-rich regions:
1. In Samoaia konensis (Drosophilidae), the content of AT pairs is highest in the regions that fluoresce brightly after staining with quinacrine (Ellison and Barr, 1972a,b).
Figure 6. Staining of the male (a and b) and female (c and d) chromosomes of Drosophila with the fluorochrome quinacrine. Numbers and letters designate chromosomes. (a and c) Staining with quinacrine. (b and d) Staining with orcein. After Faccio Dolfini (1976).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
17
Figure 7. Fluorescence intensity levels ( b and c ) of the regions of the Y (left) and the second (right) (a) chromosomes of Drosophila. Abscissa, chromosome regions; ordinate, fluorescence intensity; Q+,Q-, and Q--, different fluorescence levels. After Gatti et al. (1976).
a++,
2. In DrosophiIa of the vin'lis group, six types of satellite DNA are detected in the genomes, three large (designated as I, 11, and 111 in Figure 8) and three small, the latter constituting together less than 5% of the genome (designated according to their buoyant density values in Figure 8). When large ATrich satellites are present in the genome, heterochromatin in the metaphase chromosomes and the chromocenters in interphase show heavy staining (see Figure 8). Species that have no satellites do not show Q-staining (Holmquist, 1975a). 3. A similar correlation between the presence of AT-rich satellites and H- or Q-banding of the chromosomes was detected in many species of Drosophila (Gatti et al., 1976; Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991; Lohe et al., 1993). 4. With the use of various polynucleotides, it was demonstrated that preparations of poly(dA-dT), poly(dA) x poly(dC), or AT-rich DNA satellites showed fluorescence. However, these single-stranded polynucleotides, as well as poly(dC), poly(rC), and GC-rich satellites, were not fluorescent (Weisblum and de Haseth, 1972, 1973; Comings et al., 1975; Comings and Drets, 1976; Moutschen, 1976; Comings, 1978). 5. In studies of transcription in vino (an Escherichia coli EWA-polymerase system was applied to fixed polytene chromosomes) in the presence of actinomycin
18
1. F. Zhimulev Satellite I
D . virilis
mo~itunu
U
IU
Metaphase
Interphase
1.721 1.712 1676
tt tt tt
-
-
-
tt
-
-
t
-
+
-
- -
-
+ - sQ5 .35
D. virilis Satellites Sequence 1 5' ACAAACT II 5' ATAAACT III 5' ACAAATT
':,Genome 25% 8% 8% 4 1 010
Metaphase chromosomes Stain ",,Genome Q-H27.5% Q*H* 12.5'10 O*H5 - 8 "10 4 5 -48%
Figure 8. Relation between satellite DNAs and heterochromatin in closely related species of Drosophila of the virilis group. (Left) An evolutionary tree of species of the virilis group. (Center) Presence ( + +, + 1 or absence (-) of various satellite DNA in species. (Right) Amount of heterochromatin and degree of its fluorescence in metaphase chromosomes and interphase nuclei. The amount of heterochromatin in Drosophila virilis is taken as unit. aI,proximal, brightly fluorescent block of heterochromatin; a*,distal, nonfluorescent block of heterochromatin. After Holmquisit (1975a).
D binding to GC pairs, 3H-ATPwas shown to incorporate into the Q' regions only (Leibovitch et al., 1974). Heterochromatic regions that fluoresce after staining with quinacrine were detected in many dipteran species of the Calliphoridae (Bedo, 1980, 1991)) Cecidomyiidae (Bregman, 1975)) and Culicidae families (Diaz and Lewis, 1975; Steiniger and Mukherjee, 1975; Tiepolo et al., 1975); in D. melanoguster (Becker, 1970; Vosa, 1970; Adkisson et al., 1971; Ellison and Barr, 1971a; Lewis and Craymer, 1971; Zuffardi et al., 1971; Faccio Dolfini, 1974, 1976; Gatti et al., 1976; Barigozzi et al., 1977;Faccio Dolfini and Halfer, 1978;Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1983); in D. simulans (Adkisson et al., 1971; Barr and Ellison, 1971b; Ellison and Barr, 1971a; Gatti et al., 1976); in the species of the melanogaster group (Lemeunier et al., 1978); in the species of the virilis group (Barr and Ellison, 1971b; Holmquist, 1975a;Gatti etal., 1976;Abrahamet al., 1983); in other species of Drosophila (Barr
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
19
and Ellison, 1971b; Ellison and Barr, 1972b; Gatti et al., 1976; Bonaccorsi et al., 1981); and in Sarcophagidae (Samols and Swift, 197913; Kaul et al., 1989a). Analysis of the distribution of fluorescent regions in mitotic chromosomes demonstrated that the Q' regions are consistently located in constitutive (C') heterochromatin (Figure 9). However, not all the C' regions show Q-fluorescence. Such fluorescence is related to the presence or absence of AT-rich satellites in particular regions of heterochromatin. There are exceptions, however. In D. nasutoides, the C- regions fluoresce brightly after staining with quinacrine (see Figure 13). Unlike the Q-stain, the H-stain (Hoechst 33258) preferentially binds to AT-rich nucleotide regions owing to external attachment to the DNA double helix (Comings, 1975; Latt and Wohlleb, 1975; Comings and Drets, 1976). According to the model of Mikhailov et al. (1981), the Hoechst molecule is located in a narrow groove of DNA occupying four base pairs. The AT specificity of the binding of this compound to DNA is provided by the formation of hydrogen bonds between the molecules of the stain and AT pairs.
Figure 9. A comparison of Q+ and C' regions in the mitotic chromosomes of Drosophila of the mekmogaster group. X, Y, 4 , 2 , 3 , chromosome numbers; Q and C, Q+-and C+-banding, respectively. After Lemeunier et al. (1978).
20
1. F. Zhimulev
H-heterochromatin has been described in many dipteran species of the Calliphoridae (Bedo, 1980) and Culicidae (Gatti et al., 1977; Bonaccorsi et al., 1980) families; in the Drosophila hydei group (Holmquist, 1975b; Gatti et al., 1976), D. mehogaster (Holmquist, 1975b; Gatti et al., 1976; Smaragdov, 1977, 1978; Smaragdov et al., 1980a; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1983), D. simulans (Gatti et
Figure 10. A comparison of the localization of (2- (1) and H- ( 2 ) staining in the chromosomes of D. virilis. Numbers and letters designate the chromosomes. ( 3 ) The same chromosomes under phase contrast. Scale is 3.8 km. After Holmquist (197%).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
21
Figure 11. Localization of the C-, Q-,and H-bands and satellite in the chromosomes of Drosophila nasutoides. (a) Q- and H-bands. (b) C-banding and localization of the satellite. After Wheeler and Altenburg (1977).
al., 1976; Smaragdov, 1978),D. wirilis (Holmquist, 197513,Gatti et al., 1976; Abraham et al., 1983), and other species of Drosophih (Wheeler and Altenburg, 1977; Lakhotia and Mishra, 1980; Singh and Gupta, 1982), and in the Sarcophagidae (Kaul et al., 1989b). The location of Q- and H-stains is generally coincident (Figure 10); there are differences, however (Figure 11). As in the case of Q- staining, H+ fragments occur mainly in the regions of C-heterochromatin, although not in all cases (Figures 12 and 13).An exception is D. nasutoides (see Figure 11).
3. N-staining After sequential removal of DNA, RNA, and acid-soluble proteins, the region of the nucleolar organizers retains its capacity to stain positively with the Giemsa reagent. In subsequent studies, it was found that this staining technique permits the identification of constitutive heterochromatin as well as the nucleolar organizers (Bianchi et al., 1971; Matsui and Sasaki, 1973; Matsui, 1974; Pimpinellietal., 1976; Hagele, 1977a; Beck and Srdic, 1979; Clayton, 1985;Kaulet al., 198913).These data may indicate that heterochromatic regions are rich in nonhistone proteins. A good correlation was found between the N-banded region and 1.705 repeats (AAGAG) in D. mehogaster (Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991; Lohe et al., 1993). Comparison of the location of the N+ regions of the chromosomes (Figure 14) reveals a strong correlation with other kinds of dyes, although not consistently (see also Gatti et al., 1976).
22
1. F. Zhimulev
Figure 12. Localization of H- and Giemsa (G) staining for constitutive heterochromatin bands in mitotic chromosomes of various Drosophifu species. After Lakhotia and Mishra (1980).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation (c+,H--,Q+)
0c+
. .......... ..........
tjH+++ (c- lH+++1Q++++ 1 (c- ,H+++,Q++) Figure 13. A scheme of the distribution of various heterochromatin types (C-,Q-,and H-banding) in a n arm of the fourth chromosome of D. nasutoides. After Wheeler e t nl. (1978).
Hoechst 33258
Quinacrine
1
hr1.696
hr1.714
mr 1.702
I
Figure 14. Localization of regions detected by various differential staining techniques in the mitotic chromosomes of D. hydei. X, Y, A, X and Y chromosomes and autosomes, respectively; G, C, N , AgNO,, Hoechst 33258, quinacrine, stain types; TAG, combined treatment with trichlordcetic acid, AgNO, and Giemsa staining; hr 1.696, hr 1.714 and mr 1.702: localization of the corresponding satellites. After Beck and Srdic (1979).
23
24
4.
1. F. Zhimulev
Differential enzymatic digestion of chromosomes
Heterogeneous distribution of nucleotide pairs in mitotic chromosomes is detected by digestion with restriction enzymes. The repeat-rich regions of the chromosomes not containing restriction sites for particular enzymes remain undamaged, and they are identified with any dye staining DNA, for example, ethidium bromide (Mezzanotte and Ferrucci, 1983; Mezzanotte, 1986). In the chromosomes of Diptera, these regions are coincident with heterochromatic regions (Mezzanotte and Ferrucci, 1983, Mezzanotte, 1986; Mezzanotte et al., 1986; Marchi and Mezzanotte, 1988; Faccio Dolfini, 1990;Tewari and Lakhotia, 1991).
5. Other treatments Among the other agents that are used to identify the heterogeneous distribution of chromosome material, mention may be made of acridine orange (Stockert and Lisanti, 1972; Lakhotia and Kumar, 1978; Mezzanotte, 1978; Smaragdov, 1978; Kaul e t al., 1989b), distamycin A binding to AT sequences (Faccio Dolfini and Bonifazio Razzini, 1983; Bedo, 1989), and diamidinophenylindol (DAPI) (Eastman et al., 1980; Abbott et al., 1981; Abraham et al., 1983; Bedo, 1989), as well as of various agents specific to GC sequences, such as antibodies to GC pairs (Eastman et al., 1980),mitramycin and chromomycin A, (Eastman et al., 1980;Abraham et al., 1983), binding to 3H-actinornycin D (Pirnpinelli et al., 1978), methylation of bases (Bianchi et al., 1986), or combined treatment with these agents (Beck and Srdic, 1979; Lakhotia et al., 1979; Hagele and Ranganath, 1983; Bedo, 1989).
6. Heterogeneity of heterochromatin Use of agents specifically binding to the various components of heterochromatin also reveals the considerable heterogeneity of the chromosome regions that are in a compacted state during most of the mitotic cycle (see Figure 14). Such examples are numerous (Gatti et al., 1976; Mezzanotte et al., 1979a-c; Abraham et al., 1983; Bedo, 1989; Kaul et al., 1989b).
C. Pairing of the heterochromatic regions of chromosomes A specific property of the heterochromatic regions is their capacity to establish contacts with one another.
1. Formation of chromocenters in interphase Data on the structure of interphase nuclei (Vosa, 1970; Ellison and Barr, 1971a, 1972b; Lewis and Craymer, 1971; Lakhotia and Kumar, 1980) provide evidence
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
25
for the presence of one or several chromocenters that arise by a fusion of the heterochromatic regions (Figure 15). The presence of more than one chromocenter (Figure 16) shows that the heterochromatic regions do not consistently fuse together to form a single chromocenter. In in situ hybridization of clones of DNA from the regions of the centromeric heterochromatin of Drosophikz, up to three labeling sites are detected in interphase nuclei (Lifschytz and Hareven,
198215). The centromeres are usually located at the nuclear envelope (see Figure
15) (Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1965; Diaz and Lewis, 1975; Semionov and Smirnov, 1979,1984).
Figure 15. The chromocenters in the interphase nuclei of the neuroblasts of Drosophila melanogaster (A and B), D. simulans (C and D) and Anopheks aaoparwus (E-G). (A-D) After Ellison and Barr (1971a); (E-G) after Diaz and Lewis (1975). (A-D) Q-staining. (E-G) Phase contrast. (G) The location of the chromocenter at the nuclear envelope is seen. Scale is 10 k m (E-G).
26
1. F. Zhimuleu I
I
4oI
C
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
8
Figure 16. Number of chromocenters in the interphase nuclei of Drosophila neuroblasts. Ordinate, occurrence frequency of nuclei with the respective number of chromocenters (%I; abscissa, number of H’ chromocenters in the nuclei. (I) The preparations were made without the use of hypotonic solutions and colchicine. Total nuclei examined: a, 835 nuclei in XY males; b, 860 nuclei in XX females; c, 1636 nuclei in XO males. (11) The preparations were made with hypotonic solution; 103 nuclei in XX females were examined. After Smaragdov et al. (1980b).
2. Pairing in mitosis In the early prophase, the heterochromatic regions still join together in the chromocenter, subsequently, the euchromatic parts of sister chromatids, which were already tightly paired at the prophase of mitosis, separate (Figure 17), while the heterochromatic regions remain conjugated to the beginning of anaphase (this phenomenon is termed “chromatid apposition,” or adhesion). Chromatids of the chromosomes containing large quantities of heterochromatin (e.g., the Y or the fourth chromosome of D. melanogaster) never disjunct before the beginning of anaphase. Conjugation of chromatids is based on the features of heterochromatin itself but not those of the centromere. This appear to be so because fragments of heterochromatin, when transposed by the In( J)scv2 inversion to the distal end of the D. melanogaster X chromosome, pair exactly as though they are near the centromere (Smaragdov, 1978; Smirnov and Smaragdov, 1979). Data on the induction of mitotic crossing over favor the idea that the heterochromatic regions are in close proximity from the S phase to metaphase. Higher frequencies of mosaics for the genes in the X chromosome were obtained in strains containing more heterochromatin in this chromosome (Becker, 1969). At prophase of mitosis, homologous chromosomes become very closely approximated in Diptera and plants (somatic pairing; see Zhimulev, 1992b), frequently reminiscent of meiotic pachytene. There is no evidence indicating that the eu- and heterochromatic parts of the chromosomes differ in synaptic state (Nichols et al., 1972; Semionov and Smirnov, 1984).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
Figure 17. Pairing of heterochromatic regions of sister chromatids in the karyotype ofDsosophilnarhabarca(a) and D. nusum (h). Numbers and letters designate chromosomes. (a) Staining with orcein. (h), C-handing. (a) after Paika and Miller (1974); (h) after Lakhotia and Kumar (1978).
27
28
I. F. Zhimulev
In preparations made with the use of colchicine and hypotonic solution, the heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes do not pair, whereas the condition of tight synapsis is characteristic of euchromatin. The sex chromosomes of females and males containing large amounts of heterochromatin are consistently asynaptic at this stage. With increasing degree of compaction, synapsis of euchromatin weakens, and homologs lie at some distance from each another as early as at prometaphase (Halfer and Barigozzi, 1972, 1973, 1977; Guest, 1975; Smaragdov, 1978; Smaragdov et al., 1980a). In homozygotes for the In(l)scv2 inversion, separating the heterochromatic block of the X chromosome and transposing it to the telomeric tip of the chromosome, the homologous chromosomes are asynapsed at both the distal and proximal heterochromatic blocks (Smaragdov et al., 1980a). Because the association of heterochromatic regions with the membrane persists to prometaphase (Zatsepina et al., 1977), it follows that the surface area of the membrane increases under the effect of hypotony; the widening membrane expands the heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes (Smaragdov et al., 1980a). Heterochromatin of homologous or nonhomologous metaphase chromosomes can associate under normal conditions (Semionov and Smimov, 1979, 1984) and after experimental treatment. When cell cultures of Drosophila are treated with distamycin A, chromocenters occur in 6.5% of metaphases (Faccio Dolfini and Bonifazio Razzini, 1983; Faccio Dolfini, 1987).
3, Pairing in meiosis At prophase I of meiosis, centromeric heterochromatin appears united in a dense, darkly staining body, the chromocenter (Figure 18). Chromocenters were described in the mosquitoes Anopkks atroparvus and Cukx pipiens (Diaz and Lewis, 1975; Fiil, 1978) and in Drosophila (Davring and Sunner, 1976, 1979; Nokkala and Puro, 1976; Chubykin and Chadov, 1987). It is Moens’ (1973) view that the chromocenter is a structure that can play a role in orientation of the chromosomes during the prophase of meiosis. By contrast, Chadov ( 1989) believes that events determining coorientation of the chromosomes do not occur before the chromosomes start to pair. Hence, the role of the chromocenter in meiosis at this stage is unclear. Pairing of nonhomologous X and Y chromosomes during the first division of meiosis in males of Drosophila is provided by specific recognition sites located in heterochromatin (Cooper, 1948,1949,1951,1964; de Marco et al., 1975; Yamamoto and Miklos, 1977, see Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992, for review). There are specific sites responsible for pairing of nonhomologous sex chromosomes in Lucilia cuprina males (Bedo, 1987b).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
29
Figure 18. Integration into the chromocenter of diplotene chromosomes at prophase of meiosis in Drosophila. After Nokkala and Puro (1976).
D. Localization of chromosomal rearrangements Concepts of the important role of heterochromatic regions in karyotype evolution have long been well known. In certain heterochromatic regions, chromosome arms become fused and separate, and this produces change in the morphology and number of chromosomes (Patterson and Stone, 1952; Swanson, 1957; Pathak et al., 1973; White, 1973). Intraspecific karyotype variation is largely the sum total of the contributions of chromosomal rearrangements with breakpoints in heterochromatin. Studies of 14 strains of Anopheles stephenst with chromosomal rearrangements resulted in mapping of three breakpoints to heterochromatin of the Y and second chromosomes (Sakai et al., 1983). The heterochromatic regions of the chromosomes of certain endemic species of Hawaiian Drosophila contain a high proportion of inversion breakpoints (Baimai, 1975a,b, 1977). In cell cultures of Drosophila, spontaneous rearrangements are most frequently formed in heterochromatic regions (Faccio Dolfini, 1976). There are data indicating that the occurrence frequency of breaks arising during the formation of induced chromosomal rearrangements is higher in the heterochromatic regions
30
I. F. Zhlrnulev
(see Hannah, 1951, for review). The suggested explanations are conflicting. Muller (1954) held the view that heterochromatin is more sensitive to the effect of radiation, opposed to this view Kaufmann (1954), who believed that heterochromatin possesses no particular susceptibility to this effect. Both conclusions were based on the results of studies of rearrangements induced in polytene chromosomes (see Section VII,C,4). Experimental data obtained with mitotic chromosomes are very scant. In analysis of metaphase plates of the neural ganglia of D. melanogaster larvae 2-14 hr after irradiation, it was found that the frequencies of terminal and isochromatid deletions are higher in the heterochromatic regions. Because the heterochromatin amount is about 20% in the autosomes and approximately 50% in the X chromosome, break frequencies corresponding to these percentages would be expected. However, the frequencies were 29.7-56.1% and 50.0-70.8% for the heterochromatin of the autosomes and the X chromosomes, respectively, while the frequencies of the formation of rearrangements in the almost entirely heterochromatic Y chromosome were considerably reduced. The authors explain it by the circumstance that heterochromatin in the Y chromosome is different from that in the other chromosomes (Gatti et al., 1974). In somatic cell cultures of D. melanogaster, ultraviolet light (uv)-induced chromosomal rearrangements are formed for the most part in the heterochromatin of the X and Y chromosomes and also in autosomes. The rearrangements induced by methylmethane sulfonate and x-rays are clustered on the heterochromatin of the autosomes and the X chromosome (Pimpinelli et al., 1977). When treating Drosophilidae carrying mutations for disturbed recombination and sensitivity to mutagens, it was found that about 80% of induced breaks map to chromatin in mus 109 mutants. In all the mutants approximately 80% of the “heterochromatic” breaks occur at the junction between eu- and heterochromatin (Gatti, 1979).
E. Late replication In his study of label distribution on autographs after incorporation of 3H-thymidine into the spermatocyte cells of the grasshopper Melanoplus differentialis, Limade-Faria (1959a,b) revealed four types of labeling: (1) no labeling, (2) labeling of only the euchromatin of the autosomes, ( 3 )continuous labeling, and (4) labeling of only a heterochromatic block of the sex chromosomes (Figure 19). Since the testicles of males of this species consist of a group of follicles in which spermatids are united into cysts synchronously passing through the stages of meiosis, Limade-Faria succeeded in demonstrating that the fourth type of labeling corresponds to the late stage of the S phase. The results of studies on many species of animals and plants allowed the general conclusion that the termination of DNA replication in the heterochro-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
31
Figure 19. Types of 3H-thymidineincorporation into the nuclei at early pachytene of meiosis in Melanoplus differendis. The sex chromosomes of this species form the chromocenter, which is seen at the lefr part of the nucleus in all the figures. After Lima-de-Faria (1959a).
matic regions of the chromosomes is delayed (Lima-de-Faria and Jaworska, 1968; Shah et al., 1973; Back, 1976). Back (1976) even concluded that late DNA synthesis is the only invariable characteristic of heterochromatizable chromosomes known so far. This conclusion has been confirmed mainly in representatives of the Diptera order. In D. melanogaster, all the regions of heterochromatin (the Y and
32
1. F. Zhimulev
the fourth chromosomes, the proximal region of the X chromosome, and the centromeric regions of the second and the third chromosomes) replicate late. The location sites of Q+, H+, and C+ fragments and those of late replication are coincident (Barigozzi et al., 1966a, b, 1967, 1969, 1977; Barigozzi, 1968; HaIfer et al., 1969, 1970; Dolfini, 1971; Barigozzi and Halfer, 1972). Similar data (Figure 20) were obtained in Samoaia konensis (Ellison and Barr, 1972b), another representative of Drosophilidae. In Anopheles amoparvus, the long arms of the X and Y chromosomes containing Q' and C' fragments replicate late (Tiepolo et al., 1975). In D. virilis, heterochromatin constitutes approximately half of the genome. When 3H-thymidine is incorporated, labeled nuclei of three types are detected: the entire nucleus only, euchromatin, or heterochromatin. It was established that only euchromatin replicates during the first hour of the S phase; then the replication period of both eu- and heterochromatin proceeds for another 8 hr, and only heterochromatin replicates for 3 hr. Thus, the euchromatic part of the genome replicates for 9 hr while the heterochromatic part replicates 2 hr longer; consequently, heterochromatin replicates not only late, but also for a longer period. The heterochromatic regions terminate replicating asynchronously in different heterochromatic regions (Steinemann, 1980). These data provide evidence for a highly significant correlation between the location of heterochromatic regions and late replication.
Figure 20. A metaphase plate from Samaia leonensis fluorescent Q-staining, negative (a), and 120 min after incorporation of )H-thyrnidine (b). After Ellison and Barr (1972b).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
33
However, the late-replicating regions are exceptionally, not consistent-
ly, heterochromatic (for review, see Lima-de-Faria and Jaworska, 1968). ConverseIy, not a 1 heterochromatic regions are late replicating, for example, the sex chromosomes (ZW) forming the heteropycnotic body replicate early in some snake species. In a number of angiospermous plants and several species of the bryophyte, including members of the Pellia genus, whose heterochromatin additionally shows C-banding (Heitz, 1928), the heterochromatic regions terminate replication early (see references in the review of John, 1988). In John’s opinion (1988) the replication time of chromatin depends on when it becomes decompacted in interphase. For example, in several bryophytes heterochromatin is compact in the G, phase but becomes diffuse from the beginning of the S phase; replication ceases in the middle of the S phase, and then it becomes compact again (John, 1988).
F. Variation in the amount of heterochromatin Two races differing only in the shape of the Y chromosome were identified in populations of D. pseudoobscura;the arms were of unequal length in the representatives of one race and they had the appearance of the Latin letter J, whereas their lengths were almost equal in those of the second race (V-shaped) (Lancefield, 1929). Dobzhansky’s (1935a, 1937) later studies proved that there may be as many as seven morphological types of Y chromosomes in this species and that the length of the chromosome can differ by twofold and more (Figure 21). A definite morphology is characteristic of each strain isolated from natural populations. Based on these differences, the original species was subdivided into two, D. pseudoobscura and D. prsimilis (Dobzhansky and Epling, 1944). At the end of the 1920s and the beginning of the 1930s, intraspecific differences in the sizes of the Y chromosome were detected in D. simulans (Sturtevant, 1929; Heitz, 1933a). A great deal of research has been done on the subject of karyotypes. Data on the karyotypes of 215 species of Drosophilu are given in Patterson and Stone’s (1952), and up to 513 species in Clayton and Wheeler’s (1979, catalogs. The karyotypes of approximately 150 species of Hawaiian Drosophila were described
I
m
P
Figure 21. Seven morphological types (Roman letters) of the Y chromosome of Drosophila pseudoobscura. After Dobzhansky (1937).
34
1. F. Zhimulev
(Clayton, 1968,1969,1971; Clayton etal., 1972; Carson, 1981; Carson and Yoon, 1982). Extensive studies of the karyotypes of other dipteran species are available (Boyes and Wilkes, 1953; Boyes, l953,1954a,b; Boyes and van Brink, 1964,1965, 1967,1970; Boyesetal., 1973; Boyes and Boyes, 1975; Boyes and Shewell, 1975). Four types of chromosomes are distinguished in karyotypes: two- armed (metacentrics, or V-shaped), chromosomes with arms of unequal lengths (submetacentrics, or J-shaped), one-armed (telocentrics, or rodlike); and microchromosomes (dotlike). Variation in karyotypes is due mainly to centromeric fusion of telocentrics associated with the formation of V- and J-shaped variants and inversions. Wide variations in the sizes of the X, Y and microchromosomes (Figure 22), which are generally believed to be rich in heterochromatin, were concomitantly found (Clayton and Wheeler, 1975). With the use of specific stains, it was shown that the varying component is in fact heterochromatin (Figure 23), and a correlation between varying amount of heterochromatin and satellite DNA was established in some cases (Holmquist, 1975a) (see also Figure 8). In many species of Drosophila, particularly Hawaiian, polytene chromosomes show exactly the same banding pattern (the euchromatic part of the chromosome). They do not differ even in inversions (homosequential species), while exhibiting great differences in heterochromatin amount or satellite DNA (Craddock, 1973; Carson, 1981; White, 1982; Chang and Carson, 1985). The information given in Table 1 shows that this phenomenon is widespread. Data on variations in heterochromatin amount in other species of animals and plants may be found in published reviews (Battaglia, 1964; Brown, 1966; Yunis and Yasmineh, 1972; White, 1973; Evans, 1976; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 197713, 1986; Bostock, 1980). It is unclear why heterochromatin amount is not constant. One cause may be variation in the copy number of repetitive DNAs abundant in the heterochromatic regions. An understanding of the causes may be approached through the correlation established between the formation of inversions with a single breakpoint in a heterochromatic region and heterochromatin amount. The karyotype of
0
St
Mt
Lt Mm Lm Ssm Msm Lsm
Figure 22. Different types of the fourth microchromosome of D. kikkawai occurring in natural populations. Letter designations: D, dot; t, telomeric; sm, subtelomeric; m, metacentric. T h e chromosome sizes of small, medium, and large are designated by S, M, and L, respectively. After Baimai et al. (1986).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
35
Figure 23. Differences in the amount of C-heterochromatin in a Chironomw thummi (th) X Ch. th. piger (pi) hybrid. After Hagele and Speier (1988).
Drosophila formella contains an inordinately large amount of heterochromatin in the autosomes, the X and the Y chromosomes. In karyotypes with paracentric inversions, no changes in heterochromatin amount occur; however, once an inversion break occurs in heterochromatin, one might expect a virtually new chromosome arm composed of heterochromatin to arise. Similar correlations were found in D. recticilia (Figure 24) and D. disjuncta (Baimai, 1975a,b, 1977).
G. Formation of heterochromatic regions of chromosomes during deve Iopm e nt Studies carried out in fishes, amphibia, and mammals have led Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1960, 1982, 1986) to the conclusion that the early metaphase chromosomes are much different in morphology from those at the later developmental stages: they are more slender, they are decompacted to a very high degree, and they lack heterochromatin blocks. She has called such chromosomes juvenile (Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya 1960, 1982, 1986). In Drosophila, eight synchronous divisions of nuclei occur during early embryonic development; subsequently, the nuclei start to migrate to the egg surface during ongoing division. Later, near the surface, four additional divisions take place (the 10th through 13th cycles), and, as a result, blastoderm is formed from one layer of the nuclei. After the formation of cell membranes around the nuclei in the interphase of the 14th cycle, cell blastoderm is layered. Cell cleavage divisions proceed rapidly. One mitotic cycle takes 10 min, on average (Table 2). Starting from the 12th division, the duration of each cycle increases: from 12.4 min in the 12th division and to 21.1 min in the 13th (Foe and Alberts, 1983). In both the early cytological and the more recent electron microscopic studies on Drosophila, it was noted that there are no nucleoli and chromocenters in
36
1. F. Zhimulev
Table 1 Variation in the Amount of Centromeric Heterochromatin in Mitotic Chromosomes of Diptera Species
Variation types
References
Anopheles complex balabacensis
Variation in the amount of constitutive heterochromatin
Baimai et al. (1981)
A. gambiae and arubiensis
Interspecific differences in the amount of H-heterochromatin in the Y chromosome
Bonaccorsi et al. (1980)
A. dims
Variation in constitutive heterochromatin of the sex chromosomes (5 types of the X chromosome, 4 types of fourth chromosome)
Baimai et al. (1984a) Baimai and Traipakvasin (1987)
A. maculatus
Three types of variation in C-heterochromatin in the X chromosome and 4 types in the Y chromosome
Greenet al. (1985)
Anopheles
Variation in heterochromatin in the sex chromosomes Variation in the size of the X chromosome
Baimai et al., (198413) Boyes and Wilkes (1953)
Variations in the length of the sex chromosomes
Boyes and Shewell (1975)
Large blocks of C-heterochromatin in Ch. th. thummi and almost complete absence in Ch. th. piger (see Figure 23) Variation in morphology of the Y chromosome
Hagele and Speier (1988)
Of 152 studied species, variation in heterochromatin amount was detected in the microchromosomes of 14 species Of 103 species, heterochromatin amount varies in 9
Yoon and Richardson (1978b), Carson and Yoon (1982)
Comparisons of species reveal large differences in the amount of heterochromatin with the same polytene chromosomes
Baimai and Aheam (1978), Aheam and Baimai (1987)
D. afinis
Intraspecific polymorphism for size and morphology of the Y chromosome
Miller and Stone (1962), Miller and Roy (1964)
D. albumicans
lntraspecific variation in the Y and the fourth chromosomes; variation in C-heterochromatin (from complete absence to large block) Various morphological types of the Y chromosome
Wilson et al. (1969), Clyde (1980), Hatsumi (1987)
Species of the Aplomya genus Species of the Calliphoridae family subspecies Chironomus thummi thummi, Ch. th. piger Closely related species Cnephia dacotensis and C. omitophilia Drosophila (Hawaiian species) Drosophila (picturewinged Hawaiian species) D. afinidis-juncta. D. bosqcha, D. disjuncta
D. algonquin
Procunier (1975a)
Clayton (1988)
Miller and Roy (1964)
continued
37
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation Table 1 Continued Species
Variation types
References
D. athabasca
Same as D. algonquin
Miller (19571, Miller and Stone (1962), Miller and Roy (1963)
D. azteca D. bifurca D. birchii
Same as D. algonquin
Miller and Roy (1964)
Same as D. algonquin
Ward (1949)
Four types of the X, three types and two types of the fourth chromosomes
Baimai (1969a)
D. brunnei-palpa
Very small, almost dotlike Y chromosomes
Dobzhansky and Pavan (1943a, b)
D. cardini
Addition of heterochromatin on the microchromosome
Ward ( 1949)
D. cyrtoknna
Increase in the size of heterochromatic regions of the microchromosomes compared to D. grimshawi
Clayton (1985)
D . disjuncta
Variations in the amount of hererochromatin correlate with the formation of inversions, with breakpoint in heterochromatin
Baimai (1975a)
D. formella D. furvifacies
Same as D. disjuncta
Baimai (197513)
Interspecific variations in the amount of heterochromatin
Yoon et al. (1972)
Variation in the shape and size of the Y chromosomes Variation in heterochromatin of the Y and fourth chromosomes
Mather (1962)
in comparison with related species D. biseriata, D. hysaicosa, D. mitchelli
D. gr. immigrans
Wakahama et al. (1983)
D. gr. melanogaster
Interspecific variation in Q- and C-heterochromatin (see Figure 9)
Lemeunier et al. (1978)
D. hernipem
Less C-heterochromatin in the X chromosome, but more in the microchromosome than in related species D. silwesais, D. heteroneura, D. differens, D. pianitibia
Chang (1984), Chang and Carson (1985)
D. kikkawai
Variation in constitutive heterochromatin and in the microchromosomes (9 types of morphology) and the Y chromosome (4 types) (see Figure 22)
Baimai (1973), Baimai and Chumchong (1980), Baimai et al. (1986)
D. kontia
Variation in constitutive heterochromatin of the microchromosomes and the Y chromosome
Baimai et al. (1986)
continued
38
1. F. Zhirnulev
~~~~
Table 1 Continued Species
Variation types
References
D. leontia and D . kikkawai D. melanica
Interspecific differences in the Y and microchromosomes
David et al. (1978)
Increase in heterochromatin amount in the microchromosome
Ward (1949)
D. melanagaster
Some Q' fragments lose fluorescence in cell culture during translocation formation Increase in blocks of centromeric heterochromatin after long-term culturing of cells Interstrain differences in Q-heterochromatin amount in the Y (3 types), the second (2 types) and the X (2 types) chromosomes
Zuffardi et al. (1971)
D. mehnura
Shape and size variation in the fourth and the Y chromosomes
Ward (1949)
D. rneridionalis
Differences in the size of blocks of structural heterochromatin of sex chromosomes and/ or microchromosomes
Baimai et al. (1983)
D. micromelanica
Increase in heterochromatin amount in the microchromosomes
Ward (1949)
D. montium
Shape and size variation in the fourth and the Y chromosomes
D. narmagansett
Shape and size variation in the Y-chromosome
Kikkawa (1936), Ward (1949), Baimai (196913) Ward (1949)
D. w u t a
Variation in heterochromatin amount in the X-chromosome Differences in the size of heterochromatic regions of homologous chromosomes of two subspecies Large variation in size and shape of the Y chromosome both between and within species Differences in the length of the Y chromosome in related species
D. m u t a m u t a and D. m u t a albomicana D. of nasufa subgroup
D. pachea, D . acanthoptera and D. nannoptera D. paranaensis
Variation in size of the microchromosomes
D. pseudoobscura
Seven types of morphology and size of the Y chromosome (see fig. 21)
Halfer et d.( 1980)
Halfer (1981)
Lakhotia and Roy (1981) Ranganath and Hagele (1982) 4
Wilson eta[. (1969)
Ward and Heed (1970)
Wasserman and Wilson (1957) Lancefield (1929), Dobzhansky and Boche (1933), Dobzhansky (1935a, 1937) continued
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
39
Table 1 Continued Species
Variation types
References
D. recticilia
Variation in heterochromatin amount correlates with the presence of inversions having a single breakpoint in heterochromatin
Baimai (1977)
D.serldo
Differences in block size of structural heterochromatin in the sex chromosomes and/or in microchromosomes
Baimai et al. (1983)
D. simuhns
lntraspecific differences in the size of the Y chromosome
Sturtevant (1929), Heitz (1933a)
Glossina mursirans Interspecific variations in the size and mursitans, G . m. subamount ofC-heterochromatin in the morsitans, G . austeni Y chromosomes Parasarcophaga
In five species, enormous differences in the size of the X and Y chromosomes from dot like in P. albicens to giant rods in P. knabi
Pel1 et d. (1972), Davies and Southern (19761, Jordan et al. (1977)
Kaul et al. (1978)
the interphase nuclei involved in the first 11-12 cleavage divisions. Chromatin is represented by a finely dispersed network (Figure 25), and heterochromatin is not detected in mitotic chromosomes (Huettner, 1933a; Rabinowitz, 1941; Sonnenblick, 1950;Mahowald, 1963b, 1968;Illmensee, 1972;Mahowald and Hardy, 1985).
1
V
t
I ~
t
Q S
Figure 24. A scheme demonstrating increase in heterochromatin amount (from a to c) as a result of formation of chromosomal rearrangements in D. recticilia. g, s, v, inversions. After Baimai (1977).
40
1. F. Zhimulev
Nucleoli and chromocenters appear only at the blastoderm stage (Mahowald, 1963a). In blastoderm nuclei transplant into unfertilized eggs, chromocenters and nucleoli rapidly disappear, chromatin is converted into a finely dispersed network (see Figure 25), and cleavage division starts as early as after 15 min (Illmensee, 1972). When stained for C-heterochromatin, the metaphase chromosomes passing through the first four to five divisions (30-60 min after fertilization) differ from those at the blastoderm stage or the neuroblast chromosomes (Figure 26). They have the appearance of long, slender, weakly condensed fibrils. Only the Y chromosome stains quite distinctly in the karyotype, and mere "traces" of stain are seen in the centromeric regions of the other chromosomes. Metaphase chromosomes are in a state of weak compaction for a brief period, and they assume their usual appearance after 4-5 divisions (Vlassova et al., 1991a,b). The distinctive features of differentiation of the chromosomes into euand heterochromatin during early cleavage divisions are presumably due to the specificity of their organization and functioning. It is known that development during early embryogenesis is effected by maternal RNA and proteins stored in the egg. There is no transcriptional activity or it is very weak to the ninth division cycle. At this developmental stage, there are no nucleoli, and there is no incorporation of labeled amino acids and uridine. Chromatin is almost completely switched off from transcription (Mahowald, 1963a; McKnight and Miller, 1976; Zalokar, 1976; McKnight et al., 1978). Transcription is sharply enhanced (about fivefold) during the 10th cycle at the blastoderm stage, when synthesis of ribosomal RNA starts and nucleoli are formed (Mahowald, 1963a;McKnight and Miller, 1976; Zalokar, 1976; McKnight et al., 1978; Anderson and Lengyel, 1979; Foe et al., 1982; Edgar and Schubiger, 1986; Underwood and Lengyel, 1988; Wieshaus and Sweeton, 1988). The start of transcription is coincident with the beginning of the lengthening of cell cycle and differentiation of the chromosomes into zones of strong (hetTable 2 Duration (rnin) of the Mitotic Cycle Stages in the First 11 Cleavage Divisions in D. melanogaster" ~
~
Temperature
Stage of the mitotic cycle
24°C
29°C
30°C
Complete cycle Interphase Prophase Metaphase Anaphase Telophase
9.5 3.4 4.0 0.3 1.0 0.9
8.9 2.5 3.6 0.5 1.4 0.8
8.8 2.7 3.0 0.7 1.1 1.4
"After Rabinowitz (1941).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
41
Figure 25. Ultrastructure of the hlastoderm cell nucleus before (a) and 15 min after (h) transplantation into an unfertilized egg of Drosophila. no, nucleus; ch, chromatin, nm,nuclear membrane. After Illmensee (1972).
Figure 26. Constitutive heterochromatin of Drosophila in neuroblasts (a and b), in blastoderm (c and d), and at early stages of cleavage division (e-i). (a, c, e-i) Metaphase. (bd) Prometaphase. ( e and f) G-banding. (g-i) C-banding. Bold arrows indicate the centromeric regions of the chromosomes; thin arrows indicate the Y chromosome. After Vlassova et al. (1991a,b).
Polytene Chromosomes, Hetarochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
43
erochromatin) and weak (euchromatin) compaction. In the meantime, changes in chromosome composition take place, unusual histones (juvenile) that stain neither with alkaline fast green, as do the usual histones, nor with bromphenol blue occur in the dividing nuclei up to the end of blastocyst formation. Staining with fast green appears before the actual formation of blastoderm (Das et al., 1964). A similar substitution of lysine-rich histones was detected in the sea urchin (Hieter et al., 1979) and the snail Helix aspersa (Bloch and Hew, 1960) during embryonic development. A nonhistone protein, HP1, that is identified mainly in heterochromatin is not detected in the nuclei up to the 5th-6th division cycles. It is consistently detected at the 10th-1 Ith stages (James et al., 1989; Kellum et al., 1995).This corresponds to the stage of development of increased phosphorylation of HP1 (Eissenberg et al., 1994).
111. REPETITIVE SEQUENCES In eukaryotes, specific portions of a given genome are composed of short, multiply repetitive sequences with base compositions different from that of the bulk of the genome. Repeated DNA sequences can be isolated with the use of two approaches: one based on their exceptionally high renaturation rate and the other on gradient density centrifugation. In the latter case, the greater part of the DNA constitutes the major precipitation band (the main band) and the repetitive fraction, because of its richness in a particular nucleotide set and, consequently, having a different molecular weight, yields a single or several additional (satellite) bands (Figure 27). Problems relating to satellite DNA have been dealt with in many reviews (Bostock, 1971; Walker, 1971; Yunis and Yasmineh, 1971; Chaudhuri, 1975; Lindsley, 1975; Tartof, 1975; Appels and Peacock, 1978; Panitz, 1978; John and Miklos, 1979; Brutlag, 1980; Peacock et al., 1981b; Beridze, 1982; Singer, 1982; Ginatulin, 1984; Hardman, 1986; Miklos, 1987; Lohe and Roberts, 1988; Lohe and Hilliker, 1995). The main information concerning the molecular organization, as well as the chromosomal location of satellite DNA and its relevance to heterochromatin, is presented in this section. From the results of studies on numerous animal and plant species, it may be concluded that, on average, approximately 30% of genomic DNA consists of satellites, although considerable deviations therefrom are known. Satellites have been described in detail in D. mehogaster and closely relatedspecies (Fansleretal., 1970; Rae, 1970; Botchanetal., 1971; Galletal., 1971; Kram et al., 1972; Travaglini et al., 1972; Peacock et al., 1974, 1977, 1978; Brutlag and Peacock, 1975, 1979; Endow et al., 1975; Brutlag et al., 1977, 1978; Carlson and Brutlag, 1977, 1979; Wollenzien et al., 1977; Barnes et al., 1978; Fry and Brutlag, 1979; Hsieh and Brutlag, 1979a; Donnelly and Kiefer, 1986; Abad et al., 1992;Lohe et al., 1993; Lohe and Hilliker, 1995; Makunin et al., 1995, 1996); in Drosophila gr. virilis (Gall et al., 1971, 1974; Blumenfeld and Forrest, 1972; Blu-
44
1.
F. ZhimUlRV
30
I I 692
I
I688
1
1671
": (C)
Dvmh a D anwictm
I691
1 I 687
Buoyant density
Figure 27. Distribution of DNA fractions in D. wirilis (a), D. americana (b), and their hybrid (c) in a neutral CsCl gradient. Abscissa, buoyant density; ordinate, optic density. After Gall and Atherton (1974).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
45
menfeld et al., 1973;Blumenfeld, 1974; Gall and Atherton, 1974; Schweber, 1974; Steinemann, 1976; Mullins and Blumenfeld, 1979; Cohen and Kaplan, 1982); in D. hydei and related species (Hennig et al., 1970; Dickson et al., 1971, Hennig, 1972a,b; Renkawitz, 1978a,b); in D. nasutu and related species (Cordeiro et al., 1975; Cordeiro-Stone and Lee, 1976; Lee, 1978; Ranganath et al., 1982); in Hawaiian Drosophila (Miklos and Gill, 1981); in D. quanche (Bachmann et al., 1989); and in Glossina (Amos and Dover, 1981), Heterogera (Kunz and Eckhardt, 1974), Anopheks (Redfern, 1981a), Chironomus (Steinemann, 1978), Rhynchosciaru (Eckhardt and Gall, 1971), Sciara (Abbott et al., 1981), Surcophaga (Bultmann and Mezzanotte, 1987), and Lucilia cuprinu (Perkins et al., 1992). All the data obtained so far (Figure 28) indicate that satellite DNA is located in the regions of centromeric heterochromatin of the metaphase chromosomes (Jones and Robertson, 1970; Gall et al., 1971; Goldring et al., 1975; Peacock et al., 1977, 1978; Perreault et al., 1978; Renkawitz, 1978a,b; Wheeler et al., 1978; Samols and Swift, 1979a; Steffensen et al., 1981; Lifschytz and Hareven, 1982a,b; Ranganath et al., 1982; Bachmann et al., 1989) or in the chromocenters of interphase nuclei (Gall et al., 1971; Kunz and Eckhardt, 1974; Cordeiro-Stone and Lee, 1976). There are satellite DNAs located not only in centromeric heterochromatin, but also in the euchromatic regions. For example, the 1.672, 1.686, and 1.705 satellites of D. melanoguster are located in the 21D region of chromosome 2L (Rae, 1970; Goldring et al., 1975; Sederoff et at., 1975a;Peacock et al., 1978); one of the satellites has an additional location site in telomeres (Peacock et al., 1978; Traverse and Pardue, 1989). Sequences related to the 1.688 satellite (63-81% homologous) and arranged in short (two to four copies) arrays are present in several different regions of the D. melanogaster X chromosome (Waring and Pollack, 1987; DiBartolomeis et al., 1992; Losada et al., 1995; Kokoza et al., 1997). In D. simulans, the 1.696 satellite, consisting of a repeat 15 bp long, maps to three euchromatic regions in addition to the chromocenter (Appels and Peacock, 1978; Lohe and Roberts, 1988). In Anopheks stephemi, satellite I maps to the centromeric regions and the euchromatic part of the third chromosome (Redfern, 1981a). In D. uirilis, certain satellites are also mapped to positions in the euchromatic (polytenizing) regions of the chromosomes (Cohen and Bowman, 1979; Cohen and Kaplan, 1982). In Glossinu awteni a large amount of satellite DNA is detected in the B chromosomes (see Figure 28), in addition to centromeric regions, and in the gall midge Heteropeza pygmeu, satellite DNA is identified in the chromosomes restricted to the germline tissues (see Section v) (Kunz and Eckhardt, 1974). In the polytene chromosomes of Phaseolus coccinew suspensors, satellite DNA hybridizes with the regions of centromeric heterochromatin, blocks of intercalary heterochromatin, and presumably telomeric heterochromatin (Tagliasacchi et al., 1984).
Figure 28. Localization of satellite DNAs in centromeric regions of the metaphase chromosomes of D. mekanogastes (a and b), in centromeric regions and heterochromatic chromosomes of D. nasutoides (c-g), and in centromeric regions of the chromosomes of the main set (h) and in B chromosomes (i) of Glossinu awteni. Numbers and letters designate chromosomes (B, supernumerary chromosomes). (c and e ) T h e chromosomes after C- and G-banding, respectively. The scale is 5 pm. (a and b) after Perreault et al. (1978); (c-g) after Wheeler er al. (1978); (h and i) after Amos and Dover (1981).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
47
Figure 28. Continued
In addition to satellites, rDNA (Hilliker and Appels, 1982), rDNA spacers (Lohe and Roberts, 1990), and other repeats (Huijser and Hennig, 1987, Linares et al., 1994) are identified in the regions of centromeric heterochromatin (see Section IV,A). The molecular organization of satellite DNA and its location in the heterochromatin of D. melanogaster and closely related species have been analyzed in detail. When centrifuged in CsCl density gradient with the addition of antibiotics, DNA from diploid cells is separable into a major fraction and five satellites. The satellites are divided into three groups according to base composition and complexity of repeating sequences: 1. The fraction sedimenting at the zone of the 1.679 g/cm3 gradient (or the 1.679 satellite) and consisting of ribosomal DNA sequences (Peacock et al., 1974, 1978). 2. Satellites (1.672, 1.686, 1.705) consisting of multiply repeated short (5-10 bp) fragments (Peacock et al., 1974, 1978; Brutlag and Peacock, 1975; Endow et al., 1975; Sederoff et al., 1875a; Endow, 1977; Leemann and Ruch, 1984; Lohe and Roberts, 1988). 3. The 1.688 satellite, primarily an array of tandem repeats 359 bp long (Hsieh and Brutlag, 1979a; Lohe and Roberts, 1988; Lohe et al., 1993). Data on representation of various fractions in the Drosophila genome are given in Table 3. The total amount of satellite DNA is close to that calculated as constituting centromeric heterochromatin (see Lohe et al., 1993). Cloning of short (300-600 bp) fragments isolated from various satellites (Lohe and Brutlag, 1986), followed by determination of their nucleotide se-
48
I. F. Zhimulev
Table 3 Amount (kb) and Distribution of Satellites in the Chromosomes of D. mekmogasterR Chromosome Satellite 1.672 1.686 1.688 1.697 1.705 1.690 rDNA Total: Calculated amount of DNA in heterochromatin
X
Y
2nd
3rd
4th
?
380 640 6830 4000 660 2800 15,310 13,00016,000
5140 4620 6260 3400 6820 2200 28,440 39,000
75 2220 570 1300 4320 8490 800015,000
300 1660 430 765 1180 -
1650 91 560 130
5100
-
2430 30004500
4340 13,00016,000
-
-
5100
"After Peacock et al. (1978)
quences, demonstrated that each satellite consists of several types of simple sequences multiply repeated in tandem arrays. Eleven sequences were identified in four satellites (Table 4),with each satellite having a major and several minor fractions, which constitute a small portion of the genome. Minor fractions are also repeated in tandem and form long tracts. When centrifuged, these fractions separate as individual satellites (see Table 4). Because only a relatively small number of clones was derived from satelTable 4 Representation (%) of Different Types of Sequences Composing Satellite DNA in the Genomes of D. rnelanogaster and Closely Related Species" Nucleotide sequence of the repetitive unit, 5'-3'
Buoyant density (gm/cm3)
D. rnelanogaster
D. sirnulam
D. erecta
AATAT AATAG AATAC AAGAC AAGAG AACAA AATAAAC AATAG A C AAGAGAG AATAACATAG 359 bp
1.672 1.693 1.680 1.689; 1.701 1.705 1.663 1.669 1.688 1.686 1.688
3.1 0.23 0.52 2.4 5.6 0.06 0.23 0.23 1.5 2.1 5.1
1.9 2.4 0.0065 0.71
0.0088 0.041 0.00 18 0.01 1 0.55 0.0015 0.0016 0.0070 0.0091 0.24
~
~
0.10 0.036 0.074 0.11 ~
"After Lohe and Brutlag (1987a) and Lohe and Roberts (1988).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
49
lite DNA, it was expected that a large number of new minor fractions would be identified, up to 100 or more, as estimated by Lohe and Roberts (1988). A new satellite sequence (AACAC) has been described that is located mainly in the 2R heterochromatin and comprise about 1000 kb (Makunin er al., 1995, 1997). Nucleotide composition within cloned sequences is mostly homogeneous (Lohe and Brutlag, 1987a,b; Lohe and Roberts, 1988).A single nucleotide substitution has been identified per l-kb repeat (Figure 29a and c); however, substitution frequency can be 100-fold greater and more in a few clones (see Figure 29b and 29d). The greater part of the 1.688 satellite is represented by a tract 359 bp long. In contrast to satellites composed of short sequences, the repeating units of the 1.688 satellite are dissimilar and show a 4-5% variation in nucleotide composition (Carlson and Brutlag, 1979; Lohe and Brutlag, 1986; Hsieh and Brutlag, 1979a; Lohe and Roberts, 1988). It was demonstrated that the satellite sequences are complex. Retrotransposon Doc was present in three of the eight plasmids chosen from a genomic library of plasmids containing satellite DNA of density 1.688.In one of the plasmids, two copies of Doc were in the opposite orientation at the 3’ end bounding the repeated monomer (359 bp) at both flanks (Slobodkin and Alatortsev, 1992). Transposable element insertions (including copia and 297) are ocassionally found in clones of satellite DNA (Carlson and Brutlag, 1978;Lohe and Brutlag, 1987a,b; Lohe et al., 1993). The AACAC satellite, located within the 2R heterochromatin, is related to the Stalker mobile element (Makuninetal., 1995,1997). Extensive analysis of the distribution of 11 different transposable elements (TEs) of the D. melanogaster mitotic chromosomes has shown that 9 are clustered into one or more discrete heterochromatic regions. The locations of the mobile elements are highly conserved in geographically distant strains. Most of the heterochromatic regions contain one or more TE families. All the heterochromatic blocks are enriched in satellite DNA sequences. Only a few blocks are devoid of TEs (Pimpinelli et al.,1995; Carmena and Gonzalez, 1995). These data show that the DNAs of the mobile elements intersperse the satellite DNAs. The Dp(I ;f) f 187 duplication, a minichromosome, contains the normal components and functions associated with eukaryotic chromosomes. It is small, about 1.3 Mb or 1/30th of the normal X chromosome, including 1 Mb of centric heterochromatin and a 290-kbsegment from the normal tip of the X chromosome. Early restriction mapping suggested that a cluster of restricted sites, termed an “island of complex DNA,” was present within 50-100 kb of the Dp 1 187 euchromatin-heterochromatin junction (Karpen and Spradling, 1990, 1992; Spradling et al., 1992; Spradling, 1994; Thompson-Stewart et al.,1994; Le et al., 1995). Irradiation mutagenesis of Dp J 187 and pulse-field restriction mapping revealed that this part of Drosophila melanogaster (heterochromatin) is organized alternating blocks of complex islands (Tahiti, Moorea, and Bora Bora) and satellite DNA. Each island is hundreds of kilobase pairs in length, constituting approxi-
50
1. F. Zhimulev
a.
b. A A T A AC ATAG
A A T A A C AT A G
50
--G- * -G-
loo
100
d.
C. AATAG
AATAG
-
Figure 29. Nucleotide composition of various DNA clones isolated from the 1.686 (a and b) and 1.672 (c and d) satellites. The adjacent repeats are ordered one under another, and they are represented by a horizontal line. Nucleotide substitutions are designated by letters at the lines. After Lohe and Brutlag (1987b) and Lohe and Roberts (1988).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
51
mately one-half of the Dp 1 187 heterochromatin. Cloning and sequencing of a small part of one island, Tahiti,demonstrated the presence of a Doc retroposon connected to a 359-bp satellite (Le et al., 1995). However, analysis of DNA sequences flanking P element insertions into numerous regions of mitotic heterochromatin revealed that middle repetitive or unique sequence DNAs are frequently interspersed with satellite DNAs (Zhang and Spradling, 1994, 1995). Repeated sequences have been found in the most distal part of the X heterochromatin of D. melanoguster within 60 kb of SCLR. The repeated unit contains 1150 bp of Stellate repeat; a copia-like retrotransposon;an element of LINE type, including amplified insertions of type I into the rRNA genes, and fragments of the rRNA genes themselves (Nurminsky and Shevelyov, 1992; Shevelyov, 1992; Nurminsky et d., 1994; Tulin et al., 1997). The heterochromatic h39 region of the second chromosome of D.melanoguster contains Rsp-associated Xba I repeats and tandemly repeated Bari-I mobile elements (Caizzi et al., 1993). The Aurora mobile element inserts into the highly repeated DNA of the Stellate locus (Shevelyov, 1993). A DNA fragment containing four different repeats, including Rsp, Bari1 and AT-rich repeated sequence, Porto-l , is located very close to the centromere of chromosome 2 in D. melanoguster (Coelho et at., 1996). Fine mapping of the location of DNA of the various satellites in the metaphase chromosomes of D. melanoguster was performed with the use of in situ hybridization (Peacock et al., 1977, 1978; Appels and Peacock, 1978; Steffensen et al., 1981; Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991; Lohe et al., 1993).Localization was performed with accuracy for several megabases (Figure 30), and the following conclusions may be made:
1. Five major satellites exhibit a multichromosome distribution. Five minor satellites were found in single site of the Y chromosome. 2. The closely related satellites are often located on nearly the same chromosome.
3. About 80% of Y chromosome DNA is composed of nine simple repeated sequences, among them: AAGAC (8 Mb), AAGAG ( 7 Mb), and AATAT (6 Mb). More than 70% of the heterochromatin of the second chromosome is composed of five simple repeating sequences (Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991; Lohe et al., 1993). The repeated DNAs are thought to be the most rapidly evolving parts of the genome (Peacock et al., 1981b). Comparisons of the satellite profiles of even very closely related species (see Figure 27) reveal great differences. For example, approximately 40% of DNA is composed of satellites in D. uirilis, and 35% in D. texam, but, with different sedimentation constants, no satellite DNAs were identified in a third closely related species (Gall et al., 1971, 1974; Gall and Atherton,
52
1. F. Zhimulev 26
27 28
X L --
29
30 31
32
3334
XA
-
-
~
1 2 345678
YL-
- -
9 10 11121314
-
15
t.kW N
1617 18 19
rDNh 359bp hAGhG hATAT
20
21 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5
m -u Y S &TAT - MGhG - MGAC - AhGhGhG
i
-
MThC MThG .UThGhC hAT'4hAC rDNh
35 36 37
Z L ---
383941 41 4344 45 46
Rig--- 2R
IF
- -
- .
-
...-...
3L ---
4758495051 52 53 >*q, 6 %4
5455 56 57 58
--
-
-
MGhG AAGhGhG MGhC MThG AAThAChThG R8p AAChC
3R
AATAAChThG MGAG
.L4TL4T MG4G
Figure 30. Map of major satellite locations in D. melanogaster heternchromatin (according to Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991; Lohe et al., 1993, modified). Localization of AACAC satellite is according to Makunin et al. (1995, 1997). Numbers and letters designate chromosomes.
1974). Great differences in the profiles of satellites were detected in two subspecies, Dosophila nasuta nasuta. and D. n. albomicuna (Ranganath et al., 1982); in the closely related species of the melanogaster group (Travaglini et al., 1972; Peacock et al., 1974; Lohe, 1981; Barnes et al., 1978; Lohe and Roberts, 1988), and in the hydei group (Hennig et al., 1970). The data in Table 4 allow us to follow how sharply the occurrence of particular sequences making up satellites decreases in the genomes of D. melanogaster,
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
53
D.simulans, and the more remote species D. erecta. We are dealing here with variation in copy number in related species. In in situ hybridization, the satellites identified in the mehogaster group are also identified in other species, when the preparations are very overexposed. For example, in hybridization of a clone with DNA containing a sequence of the 1.672 satellite, the distribution of label on the metaphase chromosomes of D.mehogaster, D. simuhns, D. mauritiana,D. yakuba, and D. teisszeri was found to be the same (Lohe and Roberts, 1988). Cases of “slipping” are known: certain sequences (5’-AACAA-3’,5‘AAGAC-3‘, 5 ‘-AATAACATAG-3’) of D. mehogaster that are not identified in the closely related species D. simuhns are detectable in D. erecta (see Table 4). Similar results were obtained in an analysis of the occurrence of the polypyrimidine repeat composing the 1.705 satellite. It was found to occur in the closely related species D. melanoguster, D. simufans, and D. mauritiana, as well as in the remote D.varians species, a member of another group (D. anamsue), and not to occur in the rest of the related species (Cseko et at., 1979). In D. gwmche, heterochromatin is composed mainly of a satellite represented by a sequence 290 bp long and repeated about 80,000 times. This sequence is species specific, not occurring in the sibling species D. subobscura and D. madeirensis (Bachmann et al., 1989). Variation in sequence abundance of highly repeated DNA between strains of Aedes albopictus was as great as between it and six other species of the complex (McLain et al., 1987). There is a specificity in the protein composition of chromatin containing satellite DNAs (for review, see Zhimulev, 1992b). The fraction of HI histone that is involved in compaction of chromatin brought about by aggregation of nucleosomes is underrepresented in chromatin at the early stage of embryonic development (Elgin and Hood, 1973), when the chromosomes have not yet differentiated into eu- and heterochromatin. There is reason for believing that the phosphorylated H1 histones can specifically bind the repeated DNA sequences involved in their compaction into heterochromatin. In in vitro experiments, H 1 histone of D. virilis preferentially binds satellite DNAs; the decrease in affinity can be ordered as satellite III>satellite Ibsatellite bmajor DNA peak (Blumenfeld et al., 1978a,b). In the embryonic cells of D. viriiis, 45% of DNA is composed of satellites, and approximately 50% of H1 histones present are phosphorylated. In the polytene chromosomes of this species, satellites and phosphorylated H1 histones constitute 1.0% and less than 10% of DNA, respectively (Billings et d., 1979). In the cells of embryos and adults of D. melanogaster, phosphorylated H1 histone is 30-40%, and this correlates also with the amount of satellite DNAs (Blumenfeld, 1979). Immunolocalization studies using antibodies specific for H4 histone isoforms acetylated at each of four N-terminal lysine residues showed that the pericentric heterochromatin is relatively enriched in the H4 isoform acetylated at lysinel2 (Turner et al., 1992).
54
1.
F. Zhimulev
The nuclear protein D1 (molecular mass 50 kDa), rich in both essential and acid amino acids, predominantly binds the AT-rich heterochromatin regions. D1 makes up 10% of the content of histone H1 in the nucleus (Rodrigues Alfageme et al., 1976,1980; Levinger and Varshavsky, 1982a,b). Protein D1 binds to AT-rich DNA in viwo, and it is the component of nucleosomes containing ATrich satellites in the native nucleus. Binding is the highest to sequence AATAT (the 1.672 satellite); it is lower to the 1.688 satellite and minimal (almost none) to AAGAG (1.705) (Levinger and Varshavsky, 1982b; Levinger, 1985a,b). An acid-soluble protein with a molecular mass of 17.3 kDa was isolated from chromatin containing satellite DNA in D. uirilis. Insofar as the 17.3-kDa protein is present in the core nucleosome, there is reason for supposing that it is a specific variant of the histone binding to satellite DNA, One molecule per 20 nucleosomes occurs in chromatin (Viglianti and Blumenfeld, 1986). A nonhistone protein specifically binding to a restricted DNA region of the 1.688 satellite is characteristic of Drosophila embryos. When a complex of this protein with DNA is formed, temperature and salt composition must be normal. However, the formed complex becomes very stable, and it is not destroyed even at very high salt concentrations (1M NaC1) or low temperatures (Hsieh and Brutlag, 197913).The latter property distinguishes this protein from D1 (Levinger and Varshavsky, 1982b). Probably the best-characterized heterochromatic associated protein in Drosophila is HPl (heterochromatic protein) (see for details sections XIIIF and
XVIIA). An in uiuo cleavage site for topoisomerase I1 has been mapped in the region where a 359-bp satellite is located (Kas and Laemmli, 1992). Additional nonhistone proteins presumably bind to satellite DNAs (Will and Bautz, 1980). Although there is no direct evidence, the assumption appears plausible when considering that the proteins are located in the regions of centromeric heterochromatin on polytene chromosomes. A comparison of the distribution profiles of the nonhistone proteins from the polytene and diploid nuclei of D . mehnogaster revealed that protein bands psi, lambda, and kuppa3 in particular are severely underrepresented in the polytene nonhistone preparations, thereby suggesting that they may preferentially bind to underreplicated heterochromatin (Elgin and Hood, 1973; Elgin et al., 1974; Elgin and Boyd, 1975). The GAGA transcription factor encoded by the Trithorax-like (Trl) gene in D.melamguster (Farkas et al., 19941, and acting as dominant enhancer of position effect variegation, binds to specific heterochromatic regions (Raffet al., 1994). These regions correspond to the sites of localization of the AAGAG and AAGAGAG satellites, according to Lohe et d. (1993). Because GAGA factor binds to GA/CT rich-elements within gene promoters, it has been suggested that the binding of GAGA factor to heterochromatin could be important for the expression of some gene located there, such as rl or kl-s (Raff et d., 1994; Lohe and Hilliker, 1995).
Polylene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
55
Taken together, the data indicate that there are considerable differences in the structures of eu- and heterochomatin. The system providing compaction of heterochromatin includes modified histones, histone-like proteins, and nonhistone proteins.
IV. GENETIC CONTENT OF HETEROCHROMATIC REGIONS OF MITOTIC CHROMOSOMES The different compaction degrees of eu- and heterochromatin prompted Heitz (1929,1932) to conclude that heterochromatin is genetically inert by analogy with the compact mitotic chromosome. However, in the early genetic studies on D. ampebphila (mehogaster), it was established that, in the case of chromosome nondisjunction in meiosis, males without the Y chromosome (XO), which are viable although sterile, appear among progeny (Bridges, 1916). Thus it was demonstrated that the heterochromatic Y chromosome carries factors responsible for fertility. Somewhat later, gene localization on the map of the mitotic X chromosome with the use of chromosomal rearrangements demonstrated that actually all the genetic map fit into the euchromatic part (Figure 31). Bobbed was the only locus mapped to the heterochromatic region of the X chromosome. Relying on these data, the heterochromatic parts of the chromosomes were thought to be genetically inert (Painter and Muller, 1929; Painter, 1931; Muller and Painter, 1932). Still later, it was demonstrated that loss of heterochromatic blocks is lethal (Schultz, 1941b) or leads to consideral derangements of morphology in adult flies (Morganet al., 1941). This was further evidence that genetic factors are present in the heterochromatin regions. Change in heterochromatin dosage produces change in the course of many genetic processes and, consequently, in the expression of phenotypes-in some quantitative traits, for example (Mather, 1941, 1944; Portin et al., 1983; Jokela and Portin, 1991): the phenotypic expression in the podoptera (GoldSchmidt, 1955), scute, Dichaete, Freckled, vestigial (Mampell, 1965b), sparkling (Morgan, 1947), and hairy (Green, 1960) mutations, the size of cells and ommatidia (Barigozzi, 1951); crossing-over frequencies (Schultz and Redfield, 1951); pairing of homologous polytene chromosomes (Gersh, 1959; Zhimulev and Vagapova, 1991); and mutation frequencies in males (Kerschner, 1949). Schultz (1956) has demonstrated that variation in the number of the Y chromosomes has an influence on the shape of the telomeres in males of D. mehogaster, the development of the ovaries in females, and the processes of DNA synthesis, although without effect on DNA content (Patterson et al., 1954). A large excess of Y chromosomes in the Drosophila genome, namely XXZY or X3Y, differentially affects gene expression and leads to various phenotypic effects: mosaicism of eye color, sterilization, irregularity of facets, shortening of leg, and abnormality of wing membrane. This was shown for many unrelated
56
1. F. Zhimulev I1
111
Mutation
Estimated size of
friqiienoy
frrquency
fragmenta
(Linknge)
(New,Ilethocl)
(Cytologicnl)
I Croesovrr
44.
*I-
--
\ \
\
\ \ \
\
\ \
\
\ \
\
Figure 31. A comparison of maps of gene location (I), distribution of mutation frequencies (]I), and a cytological map (111) of the mitotic X chromosome of Drosophila melanogasrer. Numbers at vertical lines designate position of the genes on the genetic map (I) and distribution of mutation frequencies (%) (11). Gene symbols are designated by letters. A-G, breakpoints of translocations and deletions on genetic and cytological maps. After Muller and Painter (1932).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
57
strains and the Y chromosomes isolated from various strains (Cooper, 1956). In the normal genotypes, two supernumerary Y chromosomes induce mosaicism (Cooper, 1949) and sterility in males (Schultz, 1941b). In flies with a supernumerary Y chromosome, there presumably occurs an increase in the number of the histone genes in the genome (Chemyshev et al., 1980). There is no associated influence on the activity of single genes of the Y chromosome, since a decrease in the activity of tryptophan pyrrolase was not detected in v+ males without the Y chromosome when compared to XY males (Tobler et al., 1971). In w+/O males, eyes are uniformely red without any phenotypic variation (Tartof et al., 1984). Change in heterochromatin dose also has an enormous influence on the expression of position effect. The following sections present a summary of the relevant studies.
A. The X chromosome The organization of the heterochromatic regions of the X chromosome has been more thoroughly analyzed than those regions on other chromosomes (for reviews, see Sandler, 1975; Hilliker et al., 1980; Hilliker and Appels, 1982; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988, Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992). This is because a set of inversion sites are available and also because deletions and duplications of various heterochromatic fragments can be generated by crossing over between the chromosomes and the inversions (Gershenzon, 1933a,b, 1940; Sivertzev-Dobzhanskyand Dobzhansky, 1933). The presence of rearrangements makes possible performance of genetic analysis and in situ hybridization of various DNA segments composing heterochromatin (Steffensen et al., 1981; Appels and Hilliker, 1982; Hilliker and Appels, 1982; Lifschytz and Hareven, 198213; Lindsley et al., 1982). A general scheme of the organization of the heterochromatic region of the X chromosome is given in Figure 32. The locus of the X chromosome nearest to the centromere, su(f), is presumed to lie at the eu- and heterochromatin junction (Schalet and Lefevre, 1976; Hilliker et al., 1980; Yamamotoetal., 1990).This gene is transcribed to produce a major 2.6-kb RNA and minor RNAs of 1.3 and 2.9 kb, which are present throughout development and most abundant in embryos, pupae, and adult females. The major predicted gene product is an 84-kDa protein that is a homolog of RNA14 of Sacchurornyces cerevisiae, a vital gene the mutation of which affects mRNA stability (Mitchelson et al., 1993). In heterochromatin proper, bobbed is the only vital locus (Gerschenzon, 1940; Schalet and Lefevre, 1973, 1976); it is a cluster of 150- to 250-fold repeated genes of 18s and 28s rRNAs (Ritossa et al., 1966; Tartof, 1973; Wellauer et al., 1978; Hilliker et al., 1980; Long and Dawid, 1980; Tautz et al., 1988; Hawley and Marcus, 1989). In sciarids, the nucleolus-forming region is also located in a large block of heterochromatin (Gabrusewycz-Garciaand Kleinfeld, 1966; Pardue et al., 1970; Gerbi, 1971; Gambarini and Meneghini, 1972; Pardue and Gall, 1972;
58
I. F. Zhimulev
b C
XL--
26
27 28
- ABO -
scm ste e
29
col
Rex S*X)
30 31
32
33 34
XR
w 359 bp
-. .
Figure 32. Functional sites in Drosophifu mefunogastes X chromosome heterochromatin. (a) Breakpoints of inversions (Lindsley and Zimm, 1992). (b) Cytological map of het-
erochromatic blocks (h26h34) according to differential staining (Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992). (c) Mapping the functional sites: su(fl, cr, ABO, bb, and col (from review by Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992); Zhr (Sawamura and Yamamoto, 1993);SCLR sequences (Nurminsky et al., 1994); Ste (Palumbo et al., 1994a); and Rex and Su(Rex) (Rasooly and Robbins, 1991). (d) Regions modifying position effect variegation (Hilliker and Sharp, 1988). (e) Regions influencingendoreplication of rDNA in salivary gland cells (Hilliker and Sharp, 1988). See text for details.
Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1975; Dessen and Perondini, 1976, 1985; Crouse et al., 1977; Zegarelli-Schmidt and Goodman, 1981). Many 28s rRNA genes contain an insert of element I (R2) at a distance of 1.2 kb from the distal end of the gene (Glover and Hogness, 1977; Pellegrini et al., 1977; Wellauer and Dawid, 1977; Peacock et d., 1981a; Jakubczak et al., 1990; George et al., 1996), with 35% of the genes containing an insert of 4.1-6.5 kb, 16% containing another of 1.5-4.0 kb, and 14% yet another of 0-1.4 kb (Wellauer et al., 1978).Inserts of elements of this family also occur in small amounts in other regions of the genome (Dawid and Botchan, 1977; Kidd and Glover, 1980), for example, in the heterochromatin of the autosomes and in the 102C8-12 region (Peacock et al., 1981a). Insertions in the ribosomal RNA genes were also found in other dipteran species (Rae et al., 1980; Renkawitz-Pohl et al., 1980, 1981a,b; French et al., 1981; Kunz et al., 1981a)b;Beckingham, 1982; Beckingham and Thompson, 1982). The size of the cluster of genes of ribosomal RNA, together with the associated sequences and insertions, constitutes approximately 50% of the DNA of the centromeric heterochromatic region of the X chromosome (Peacock et al., 1978; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988). There are data (Appels and Hilliker, 1982) indicating that the cluster has been mapped between the breakpoints of the In(l )wm4 and In( I )wIn5lh inversions (see Figure 32). Based on cytological data, this block of genes has all the features of heterochromatin, although a small re-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochrornatin, and Position Effect Variegation
59
gion in late prophase seems to remain in a decondensed state, forming a secondary constriction (Hannah, 1951). A region of heterochromatin controlling the disproportionate replication of the ribosomal genes, cr (compensation response) is located between the breakpoints of the sc4 and wm4 inversions (see Figure 32) (Procunier and Tartof, 1978).In the salivary glands of XY males and XX females, the 18sand 28s rRNA genes usually constitute 0.08% of the DNA of polytene chromosomes. They make up 0.42% of DNA in diploid cells (Spear and Gall, 1973). When a homolog (XO) containing these genes or a part of the cluster is deleted, the gene number in the remaining polytene homolog is restored to 0.08%. When the cr+ region is transposed to another site of the genome, there is no compensation (Procunier and Tartof, 1978). Rex (Ribosomal exchange) and Su(Rex) elements are located within the nucleolar organizer. Rex induces mitotic exchange between two separated ribosomal DNA arrays on a single chromosome. Exchange takes place in the offspring of Rex mothers and very early, before the third mitotic division (Robbins, 1981; Swanson, 1987; Rasooly and Robbins, 1991; Robbins and Pimpinelli, 1994). Hybrid females from mating of D. simulans females to D. melanogaster males die as embryos, whereas hybrid males from the reciprocal cross die as larvae. A mutation in D. mehogaster was recovered (Zhr; see Figure 32) that rescues the hybrid females from induced embryonic lethality. The mutation is located on the X chromosome at a position near the centromere in the region covered by Dp(l ;f)I 162,not by Dp(I ;flI205. T h e latter chromosome carries a duplication of heterochromatin located distal to the In( I )sc8 heterochromatic breakpoint (Sawamura et al., 1993; Sawamura and Yamamoto, 1993). It would seem that rather large deletions have no genetic function since they are without phenotypic effect even when homozygous. However, one such region proved to be functioning. The autosomal recessive mutation abo (abnormal oocyte), which was mapped to the 31F-32E region, exerts a maternal effect; that is, it decreases the number of d o / + progeny from mating of abolabo females and +/+ males. However, an increasing proportion of abo/+ progeny can be obtained by increasing doses of a small heterochromatin fragment of the X chromosome between sc4 and wm4 (see Figure 32), which the zygote inherits from the male having, for example, attached XY chromosomes. Survival percentage was 70% for X/XY daughters from mating to abolabo, and it was only 6% for X/O males (Sandler, 1970, 1975; Mange and Sandler, 1973).These heterochromatic elements were designated as Xhaho, or ABO (Parry and Sandler, 1974; Yedvobnick et al., 1980; Pimpinelli et al., 1985). The maternal effect mutation abo is less severe when the abo strain is maintained in homozygous condition for a number of generations (Krider and Levine, 1975; Sullivan and Pimpinelli, 1986).Factors affecting i t act zygotically, dominantly, or additively. The X and the second chromosomes (but not the Y and the third chromosomes) isolated from such homozygotes for abo and transmitted
60
1.
F. Zhlmulev
by males are more effective in reducing the mutant effect when isolated from d o / + (Sullivan and Pimpinelli, 1986). ABO maps between the sc4 and wm4breakpoints (see Figure 32; see also Malva et al., 1985). Possibly, there is yet another ABO locus proximal to wm4(Hilliker and Sharp, 1988). Regions homologous to ABO are present in each arm of the Y chromosome and in heterochromatin of chromosome 2R (Sandler, 1977; Pimpinelli et al., 1985, 1986; Tomkiel et al., 1991; Palumbo et al., 1994a). Two ABO doses, one in the heterochromatin of the X chromosome and the other in that of chromosome 2R, suffice to provide normal survival of progeny of abolabo females. A twofold decrease in ABO dose decreases survival probability correspondingly (twofold). The more recent experiments suggest that simultaneous deletion of four ABO loci results in embryonic lethality (Palumbo et al., 1994a). Flies without the ABO have not been detected, this condition is lethal (Pimpinelli et al., 1986). These data indicate that the heterochromatic element abo, as received by the zygote from the father, accomplishes its effect as early as during the first cleavage divisions (i.e., much earlier than the zygotic genome starts to function); this suggests that heterochromatin contains elements functioning when the euchromatic genes are silent (Pimpinelli et al., 1986;Tomkiel et al., 1991). It was Sandler’s view (1970) that components of the abo/ABO system control the quantity of ribosomal RNA in the cells; in fact, there is a line of evidence (Krider and Levine, 1975) indicating that the amount of rRNA genes in each X chromosome increases about threefold with weakening expression of the abo phenotype in homozygotes. This increase in rDNA amount is associated with variation in the restriction pattern of nontranscribed spacers of ribosomal cistrons, presumably due to a selective increase in certain repeats in the block of the ribosomal RNA genes (Graziani et al., 1981). According to another line of evidence (Manzi et al., 1986), when the expression of the abo phenotype is weakened, the amount of rDNA and its restriction patterns remain unaltered. Molecular characterization has shown that the aba gene encodes a protein sharing homologies with the product of DETl , a negative regulator of gene expression in Arabidopsis (Tomkiel et al., 1995). Maternal mutations closely linked to abo and interacting with heterochrornatin were isolated. The mutations are dal, wdl, and hup (Sandler, 1975, 1977; Palumbo et al., 1994a). During polytenization of the chromosomes in the salivary gland cells of at least some of the strains of Drosophila the nucleolar organizer of only the sex chromosome partly polytenizes (Endow and Glover, 1979; Endow, 1980). Later studies demonstrated that the DNA responsible for this dominance of the nucleolar organizer is located between the proximal breaks of the sc4 and wm51binversions. Another function of heterochromatin, modification of the expression of position effect variegation (see Sections XI-XVI), can be mapped by portions. By generating deletions and duplications of various heterochromatin fragments, the
61
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
heterochromatin amount can be varied in the nucleus, and the expression of position effect can thus be affected. At least three regions of heterochromatin can act independently as modifiers of position effect variegation (see Figure 32).
B. The autosomes As a result of genetic saturation of the regions of the second chromosome deleted from centromeric heterochromatin, 1 13 mutations were identified. After complementation analysis, these were assigned to 13 loci (Figure 33), taking into account the E(SD), Rsp, It, rl, and some other loci, 18 loci in all have been identified in the heterochromatin of the second chromosome (Hilliker and Holm, 1975; Hilliker, 1976; Hilliker et al., 1980; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988; Hearn et al., 1991; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992; Eberl et al., 1993; Russel and Kaiser, 1994). The location of functional elements in the heterochromatin of the other chromosomes is schematically represented in Figures 34 through 36. The occurrence frequencies of genes per unit length of DNA in the heterochromatin of the second chromosome make up approximately 1% of those estimated for euchromatin (Hilliker, 1976). Several genes of the heterochromatic region have been characterized: concertina (cta), ci (cubitw interruptus), light, and rolled. The rolled gene encodes a homolog of mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase (Biggs e t al., 1994; Brunner et al., 1994), ci occupies about a 13.7-kb DNA region (Orenic e t al., 1990; Locke
3536 37
a
2L
-- Z R
4OFEta 4OFc It 4OFd msQ)H1 dnF~
b
383941 4243 44 45 4 6
--
2.L --
41Ad
4ifi 4iia rl
--
-5, 8 470
4T-h 41Ah
ZR
6
423
1, 11
Figure 33. Functional sites in Drosophila melanogaster second chromosome heterochromatin. (a) Functional sites are situated above and below the heterochromatin map (h35-h46 according to Dimitri, 1991). After Hearn et al. (1991), Gatti and Pimpinelli (1992), Eberl rt al. (1993),and Russell and Kaiser (1994). See text for details. (h) Location of P-element insertions in heterochromatic regions. After Zhang and Spradling (1995).
62
I. F. Zhimulev
9-52 5-84
10-39
a
'-'16
1-16 10-58
8A-80
b
80Fa
2-66
-
l80FclSOFe
9-56
3-9
-
I 80~11
8OFj
4748495051 52
3L
C
47 10-65
81Fa 81F1, 5455 56 57
53
--
58 --
A7148
336
5
d
3R
1
ce&mere
33Jir
Figure 34. Genetic and cytological maps of Drosophila melanogaster third chromosome heterochromatin. (a and b) Mapping the genetic loci (b) within limits of deficiencies (a). After Marchant and Holm (l988a,b). (c) Map of heterochromatin blocks (h47-h58). After Gatti and Pimpinelli ( 1992). The correspondence between the genes and heterochromatin blocks has not been determined. (d) Insertions of P-elements (Zhang and Spradling, 1995).
ci ....
59 60 61
4R
4dTJmlQ---
a
ABO
1 2 3 4 5 678
b C
d
YL,
9
Figure 35. Map of fourth chromosome heterochromatin (h59-h61). After Gatti and Pimpinelli (1992). Tentative location of ci is after Lindsley and Zimm (1992).
-
cry -
MstlY)
AEO
-
10 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4
15
1 6 1 7 18 19
col bb 20
21 22 23 24 25
YS
[SyKa
k
-
kl-5 kl-5 A teloiiiere
kl-3 kl-3
kl-2
ks-I
kl-I
B
ks-I C
centrzmere
10 16 c2: c3
-
364
121
4
I
. .
.
ks-2
telokere
95-2
-~ 2.12. 13.17.
512
c8 302 Figure 36. The Y chromosome map of Drosophila melanogaster showing the localization of the heterochromatic functional elements. (a) Genetic sites. (b) Heterochromatic blocks (hlLh25). (c) Thick and thin lines show minimal and maximal limits of fertility factors. A, B, C, loop-forming sites of kl-5, kl-3, and k s - I , respectively. (d) P element insertions (Zhang and Spradling, 1995). After Pimpinelli et al. (1985, 1986),Toinkiel et al. (19911, Gatti and Pimpinelli (1992) and Russell and Kaiser (1993).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
63
and Tartof, 1994), and cta encodes the a-subunit of a G-protein playing a role in cell-cell communication during embryonic development (Parks and Wieshaus, 1991). The length of the light gene is at least 17 kb (Devlin et al., 1990a,b). Of particular interest is the system of SD-Rsp (see Lyttle, 1991, 1993; Teminetd., 1991; Palumboet al., 1994a; Palopolietal., 1996,for review). The point is that, in the 37DZ-D6 region of one of the second chromosomes isolated from a population by Y. Hiraizumi in 1956, the SD (Segregation Distortion) factor was disclosed (Sandler et al., 1959). Its presence in SdlSd' males leads to a substantial increase in the number of gametes with the Sd mutation compared to the Sd' gametes. Electron microscopic studies have demonstrated that spermiogenesis of Sd' gametes in SdlSd' genotypes is aberrant due to decompaction of chromatin (Sandler et al., 1959; Hartl et al., 1967; Hartl and Hiraizumi, 1976; Tokuyasu er al., 1977; Sandler and Golic, 1985). Segregation distortion is due to the interaction of three elements: Sd itself; Rsp (Responder)and E(Sd) (EnhancerofSd). Two major Rspalleles are known: RspS (sensitive) and Rspi (insensitive). In strains with distorted segregation, the chromosomes have the constitution Sd, Rsp'lSd', RspS (Figure 37). The condition providing aberrant spermiogenesis is the presence of allele SD and heteroallelism in Rsp (Ganetzky, 1977; Brittnacher and Ganetzky, 1983; Sharp et al., 1985). SD chromosomes also carry several linked drive enhancers, such as M(SD) and
sd
SD +
Rsp-i
t sd'
RSP-s
Figure 37. Schematic representation of SD complex. Sd and Sd', distorting and nondistorting alleles of Sd locus, respectively; Rsp-i and Rsps, insensitive and sensitive alleles of the Rsp locus, respectively. Sd renders Rsp-s-bearing sperm nonfunctional during spermatogenesis (postmeiotically). After Doshi et al. (1991).
64
I. F. Zhimulev
S t ( S D ) (Hiraizumi et al., 1980, 1994; Hiraizumi, 1990; Lyttle, 1991). E(SD) not only enhances the action of Sd, but also independently behaves as a segregation distorter (Sharp et al., 1985; Temin, 1991). Based on cytogenetic and genetic data, the Rsp locus has been mapped to the h35 block of the 2R heterochromatin (see Figure 33), and Sd to the euchromatic part of chromosome 2L (the 37D2-D6 region). The third component, E(Sd), was mapped to the heterochromatic part of the 2L heterochromatin (Ganetzky, 1977; Hiraizumi, 1981; Brittnacher and Ganetzky, 1983, 1989; Sharp et al., 1985;Lyttle, 1989; Pimpinelli and Dimitri, 1989). A cluster of Rsp sequences is also located in the third chromosome (80C region) (Moschetti et ul., 1996). The Rsp locus presumably is a region of reiterated DNA with repeating units of 120-bpfragments. These fragments are enriched in AT, with the general structure of satellite DNA, and organized mainly as dimers consisting of two 120bp repeats with dimers delineated by TCTAGA sequences (the Xba I restriction site) at each end. There are central TCTACA sequences that are less frequently cut by Xba I to result in 120-bp monomers (Wu et al., 1988). The repeats usually have a dimeric structure with an average difference of 16-20% between the left and right halves (Cabot et al., 1993; Lyttle, 1993). Rsp repeats isolated from the same chromosome are not more similar than those from different chromosomes. The whole Rsp locus extends over a region of 600 kb on a standard sensitive (Rsps) chromosome. Within the region, Rsp repeat arrays are interspersed with non-Rsp sequences and account for 10-20% of all sequences (Cabot et al., 1993). The XbaI repeat of Rsp exhibits DNA curvature; nucleosomes containing this DNA are spaced at 240 bp (the size of the dimeric repeated unit) rather
Figure 38. Variation of copy numbers of the Rsp repeat in Drosophila melanogasm stocks differing in Rsp sensitivity. Restriction Xba I digest of DNA from supersensitive (lpcb), sensitive (a bw), and partially sensitive (Canton S) stocks, probed with the DNA Ho clone containing XbaI repeated unit. After Wu et d . (1988).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
65
than the 190 bp for bulk DNA. Three DNA-nonhistone protein complexes were identified by means of gel-shift assays involving protein extracts from pupal nuclei combined with labeled Rsp DNA (Doshi et al., 1991). The Sd chromosome has a deletion of the Rsp region (Rsp-) and less than 20 copies of a Rsp-associated 120-bp satellite repeat. Sd' chromosomes sensitive to Sd action carry Rsp" with more than 700 repeats (Figure 38). Insensitive Sd' (Rsp') chromosomes carry
Rsp DNA.
66
I. F. Zhimulev
It was also suggested that the SD phenomenon depends on the interaction of some sort of transposable elements (Sandler and Golic, 1985).
C. The Y chromosome The genetic organization of the Y chromosome in various species of Drosophila has been the subject of many reviews (Williamson, 1976;Leibovitch, 1977;Hess, 1980; Hillikeret al., 1980; Hennig, 1985,1987,1988,1990,1993; Pimpinelli etal., 1986; Hennig et al., 1987;Lifschytz, 1987; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988; Hennig and Ktemer, 1990; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992; Zhimulev, 1993; Palumbo et al., 1994a). After Bridges (1916) concluded that the Y chromosome plays a tole in the control of fertility in males of D. melanogaster, nine genes were identified in the entire Y chromosome (Stem, 1929; Neuhaus, 1938; Btosseau, 1960a;Williamson, 1972; Ayles et al., 1973; Sanders and Ayles, 1974; Kennison, 1981; Hazelrigg et al., 1982;Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1983;Hardy etal., 1984;Pimpinelli et al., 1986), which include bobbed, two loci affecting the course of meiosis, and six fertility factors in males (see Figure 36). The bobbed locus constitutes approximately 5% of the total DNA in the Y chromosome (Pimpinelli et al., 1986). The collochore locus is needed for regular pairing and, therefore, disjunction of the sex chromosomes in meiosis (Cooper, 1964). It makes up approximately 7% of the Y chromosome (Pimpinelli et al., 1986). Primary spermatocytes of D. melanogaster males lacking the Y chromosome exhibit proteinaceous crystals (Cox et al., 1976; Hardy et al., 1981, 1984). When chromosome regions occupied by the crystal (cry) locus break (see Figure 36), there is no associated phenotypic expression. However, with deletions in the region, protein-like crystals appear in the primary oocytes, and chromosome segregation is disturbed in meiosis (Hardy et al., 1984). It is noteworthy that, when the normal allele of the Stellate' gene is present in the X chromosome, the crystals are needle shaped, whereas when Ste- is present, they are star shaped (Hardy et al., 1984; see also Meyer et al., 1961). Males carrying cry Y and Ste X are sterile; the cry, Ste+ males are somewhat fertile but show chromosome nondisjunction (Hardy et al., 1984). I t is evident that the cry referred to as Su(Ste) (Livak, 1990) and Ste form a system of interacting genes (Pimpinelli et al., 1986; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992; Palumbo et al., 1994a). By genetic methods and in situ hybridization, Ste was mapped to the 12E1-2 band (Palumbo et al., 1994b), and cry to the h l l heterochromatic block of the Y chromosome (see Figure 36) (Hardy et al., 1984; Palumbo et al., 1994a,b). At the molecular level cry is an array of tandemly repeated (80 copies) Cfo I ftagment that is 800 bp long (Livak, 1984). In several populations 240 copies of cry were found (Lyckergaard and Clark, 1989). According to other data (Balakireva et al., 1992; McKee and Satter,
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
67
1996), the 2500- to 2800-bp repeats of the cry sequence consist of three main elements: the region of homology of the Ste gene, which is 800 bp long, an adjacent AT-rich Y chromosome-specificsegment, and a 1360-bp mobile element inserted into the Ste sequence (Balakireva et al., 1992). Some of the Ste sequences share homology with the DNA of the HeT family (Danilevskaya et al., 1991). The DNA of the Ste gene has been cloned (Lovett et al., 1980; Livak, 1984).The Ste DNA contains three classes of tandem repeats of 950, 1100, and 1150 bp after Cfo I digestion; they are partially homologous to the cry repeat (Livak, 1984; Palumbo et al., 1994b), and they are present in about 200 copies in Ste and at an order of magnitude less abundant in Ste' (Livak, 1984, 1990; Palumbo et al., 1994a,b). A part of the Ste sequence is located in the third locus of the genome. Although the majority, if not all, of the 1250-bp Xba I Ste fragments are mapped to the 12E region, almost all 1150-bp Xba I fragments are concentrated in the X chromosome heterochromatin (Shevelyov, 1992). These Ste sequences are located in SCLR elements comprising numerous middle repetitive sequences (Shevelyov, 1992,1993; Nurminsky et al., 1994). The SCRL elements were mapped in the distal region of the X chromosome heterochromatin between the right breakpoint of duplication BSYy and the left breakpoint of Df(l)b-3 (Nurminsky et al., 1994), or in the h27 heterochromatic region (Palumbo et al., 1994a,b) (see Figure 3 2 ) . According to other data (Tulin et al., 1997), one cluster of Stellate sequences is located in h26 and another in h27 heterochromatic blocks. The Ste sequences containing two introns are abundantly transcribed only in testes of cry- males; the corresponding 750-bp poly(A)+ RNA was not found in XY males. This sequence encodes a 19.5-kDa protein sharing homology with the p-subunit of casein-kinase 2 (Livak, 1990).The enzyme may be involved in chromosome condensation and segregation (see Palumbo et al., 1994a, for discussion). Ste' transcripts are detected in testicles. The presence of the normal Su(Ste) allele (=crystal) inhibits the accumulation of Ste' RNA. It has been suggested that Su(Ste) controls the activity of Ste'; removal of the Y chromosome leads to overproduction of Ste+ RNA (Livak, 1990), and, as a result, excess Ste' protein is crystallized in spermatocytes (Coyne, 1986). In analysis of the genetic bearing of the cry-Ste system, it should be borne in mind that Ste protein was not found in normal spermatogenesis (Bozzetti et al., 1995). Moreover, the Ste sequences are present only at reduced copy numbers and only on the Y chromosome in D. simulans and D. mauritiana. The sequence is apparently not present at all in D. erecta, D. teissieri, and D. yakuba (Livak, 1984). In Drosophila melanoguster males deficient for one or more fertility factors or lacking the entire Y chromosome, spermatids undergo an extensive elongation process, but spermiogenesis is not completed and sperm degenerates before maturation (Kiefer, 1966, 1973; Meyer, 1968; Hardy et al., 1981).
68
I. F. Zhlmulev
Of the six fertility factors, three (kl-5, kl-3, and ks-l ) each occupy about 10% (approximately 4000 kb) of the Y chromosome (Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1983; Pimpinelli et al., 1986; Bonaccorsi et al., 1988). A similar principle of genetic organization of the Y chromosome has been detected in D. busckii: removal of the left arm and three-fourths of the right leads only to sterility. The rest of the chromosome contains factors essential for survival (Krivshenko, 1952). The activity of fertility factors is manifested by the Y chromosome in a remarkable way. In 1961, Meyer and colleagues described peculiar stage-specific threadlike structures in the nuclei of D. melanogaster spermatocytes, which have been detected later in more than 50 other Dosophila species (Figure 39). Subsequently, success was achieved in demonstrating that these are decompacted regions of the Y chromosome (“loops”) in which RNA is synthesized and proteins accumulate (Hennig, 1967; Hess, 1973). Each loop in the nucleus is unique with respect to size, ultrastructure, differential staining, and appearance; in addition, the morphology of the loops is in general species specific as well (Meyer, 1963; Hess, 1967, 1973; Yamasaki, 1977, 1981). There is evidence that the loops are formed from the material of the Y chromosome: 1. In males without the Y chromosome (XO),there are no loops, and in XYY males, they are present in two sets (Figure 40). When a part of the Y chromosome is deleted, not all the loops are detected; in strains with duplications, the number of loops correspondingly increases (Hess and Meyer, 1963, 1968; Hess, 1965a, 1974; Bonaccorsi et al., 1988). 2. In interspecific hybrids with a Y chromosome inherited from D. neohydei, the morphology of the loops is the same as in the donor species of the Y chromosome (Hess, 1974). Evidence that the fertility genes are located in loops is as follows: 1. When at least one loop is deleted, the male is rendered sterile (Hess, 1965a).
2. At first, a correlation between the number of genes and loops was revealed (Hess and Meyer, 1963; Hennig et al., 1974; Ayles et al., 1973; Sanders and Ayles, 1974; Leoncini, 1977). Then, with the use of chromosomal rearrangements, a direct correspondence was established between factors and loops: the kl-5 factor to loop A, the kl-3 to loop B, and the ks-l to loop C in D. melanogaster. This correspondence is incomplete, however, because the chromosome regions occupied by the kl-5 and ks-I factors are much longer than the loop-forming site. The minimum size of the kl-5 factor corresponds to the size of the loop-forming site (Bonaccorsi et al., 1988). Deletion or mutation of the loop-forming gene kl-5 results in the absence of outer dynein arms in each peripheral microtubule in the sperm tail axoneme,
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
69
Figure 39. Organization of the Y chromosome in D. hydei. (a) General appearance of a spermatocyte nucleus. The regions occupied by loops are designated (Tr, Th, Ps, CI, Ns); Nu, nucleolus. (b) Scheme of loops location in the nucleus of a spermatocyte. (c and d ) Location and designation of loops ( c ) and also their location on the map of differential staining of the mitotic chromosome (d). After Hennig (1985).
the structure that provides the mechanical force for sperm movement (Hardy et al., 1981, 1984; Goldstein et al., 1982; Hepner and Hays, 1993). The Y chromosome of D. hydei has 7-16 complementation groups need-
70
1. F. Zhimulev
Figure 40. Variation in number and morphology of loops in D. hydei strains with translocarions between the Y chromosome and autosome. A, the autosome, the normal partner of the chromosome with translocation; F L p . A , ,long, and A,.YL”,short elements of translocation; Fd, Fk,p, T,K, loops; N, nucleolus. After Hess (1965a).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
71
ed for male fertility, 5 of which are related with lampbrush loops (Hennig, 1985; Hackstein, 1987). After the generation of clones of DNA from the Y chromosome (Lifschytz, 1979; Vogt er al., 1982; Hennig er al., 1983), analysis of its molecular organization became feasible (see reviews by Hennig, 1985; Hennig et al., 1987). Both the loop-forming (kl-5, kl-3, and ks-I ) and the non-loop-forming (kl-2 and ks-2) fertility genes in D. mehnogmter contain substantial amounts of satellite DNA. Moreover, each fertility region is characterized by a specific combination of satellite sequences (Bonaccorsi and Lohe, 1991). The total length of all the loops in D. hyd-ei makes up approximately 1000 km, or 1/12th of the total length of DNA in the Y chromosome. The functions of the remaining 11/12ths are unknown (Hennig et al., 1974). The DNA of the Y chromosome of D. hydei comprises repetitive sequences of two types:
1. The Y-specific,satellite-like sequences; these occur only in this particular chromosome, and are represented by families of 200-2000 copies. They are organized in clusters of tandemly repetitive units arranged in loops. The ayl family provides the best studied example (Vogt er al., 1982; Vogt and Hennig, 1986a). It is transcribed in the Q fertility gene forming the Nooses lampbrush loop. These repeats do not show protein-coding capacity (Lifschytz et
al., 1983; Vogt and Hennig, 1983;Hennig et al., 1987, 1989; Huijser and Hennig, 1987; Huijser et ul., 1988; Trapitz et al., 1988, 1992; Wlashek et al., 1988). 2. The Y-linked sequences; these occur in both the Y and other chromosomes, but less frequently. Their number in a site varies from several to 50 copies of different lengths (Vogt and Hennig, 1986b; Vogt et al., 1986; Hennig et al., 1987). In at least three of the five loop-forming genes of D. hydei, retrotransposons have been identified as Y-linked loop constituents. Members of the micropia family are located in the fertility genes forming the loop pairs Threads and Pseudonuckolus. In the X chromosomes and autosomes, 2-1 1 copies of the micropia are found, while their number varies from SO to 100 in the Y chromosome. The Y-linked members of the retrotransposon family are defective. Micropiacopies have been found in D. melanogaster (Huijser et al., 1988; D.-H. Lankenau et al., 1988,1989,1990;Lankenau and Hennig, 1990; Lankenau, 1993; S. Lankenau et al., 1994). Retrotransposons of the gypsy family are found in the Nooses lampbrush pair, where they occupy about one-third of the Y-linked DNA of the loop (approximately 40-50 kb of DNA). Most, if not all, gypsy elements within the loop are truncated and defective. The gypsy sequences occur interspersed between the Y-specific loop constituents, the ayl repeats (Hochstenbach et ul., 1993a,b, 1994a-c). Repeats specific to the Y chromosome were found in other dipterans (e.g., Ceratitis capitata (Anleitner and Heymer, 1992). The sequences specific to
72
1. F. Zhimulev
the Y chromosome are not evolutionary conserved because many occur either in closely related species or only in D. hydei (Huijser and Hennig, 1987). The Ylinked sequences are more conserved because many are identifiable in the genomes of remote species (Vogt et al., 1986). In some cases, the Y chromosome contains remarkable repeats; thus, in D. simulans, a genotype was identified lacking the cluster of rRNA genes, yet possessing a repeat composed of a nontranscribed spacer (240 bp), reiterated about 12,500 times, which ultimately generates a tract approximately 3000-kb long (Lohe and Roberts, 1990). Danilevskaya et al. (1991) have sequenced DNA from the cry region, which not only shows homology to Ste but is also related to the HeT family of repetitive sequences (Traverse and Pardue, 1989). HeT-A is a novel transposable element that appears to form part of the telomeres of D. melanogaster chromosomes. It occurs in nontelomeric regions of the heterochromatic Y chromosome in regular tandem repeats of parts of the HeT-A sequence joined to nonrelated sequences (Danilevskaya et al., 1993). Evidence for the genetic activation of loops is RNA synthesis: about 50% of extranuclear RNA is synthesized in the loops. The remaining 50% of the label is incorporated into the transcriptionally active regions of the X chromosome and the autosomes not forming the loops. After pulse incorporation of 3H-uridine, radioactive RNA is retained in loops for 30-40 hr (Meyer and Hess, 1965; Hennig, 1967). Under the effect of actinomycin D (Meyer and Hess, 1965; Hess and Meyer, 1968) or irradiation (Hess, 1965b), the loops disappear. a-Amanitin exerts a similar action (Hennig et al., 1974). The presence of RNA polymerase I1 has been demonstrated with the use of the method of indirect immunofluorescence (Rungger-Brandle et al., 1981). In loop material of D. hydei spread by Miller’s technique, the formation of a gradient of distribution of chromosome material is seen along the loop axis, like that characteristic of transcription visualization (Hennig et al., 1974; Grond et al., 1983). The loop transcripts are usually long. Judging by ultrastructural data, the Nooses, Threads, and Pseudonucleolus loops represent transcription units with lengths of 260 to more than 1500 kb (Meyer and Hennig, 1974; Glatzer and Meyer, 1981; Grond et al., 1983,1984; DeLoos et al., 1985; Hochstenbach et al., 1996). From in situ hybridization of DNA clones isolated from various loops of the Y chromosome of D. hydei with nuclear RNA, each clone was shown to hybridize with its own nuclear domain (Lifschytz et al., 1983; Trapitz et al., 1992; Hochstenbach et al., 1994a, 1996). Different types of repeats, including those composed of satellites, are transcribed in loops. The repeat of sequence AAGAG (the 1.686 satellite) hybridizes in situ and on Northern blots with the RNA of the kl-5 and ks-l loops in D. melanogaster. It is noteworthy in this respect that transcript sizes vary from maximum (with migration at limiting mobility in gels) to less than 1 kb (Bonaccorsi eta[., 1990). Repeats of both types are transcribed in D. hydei, the Y specific and the
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
73
Y linked, with transcripts from 260 to more than 1500 kb identified on Northern blots (Vogt et al., 1982; Lifschytz et al., 1983; Vogt and Hennig, 1983, 1986a,b; Lifschytz and Hareven, 1985; DeLoos et al., 1985; Hareven et al., 1986; Huijser and Hennig, 1987; Huijser et al., 1987, 1988, 1990; Trapitz et al., 1988, 1992; Wlaschek et al., 1988; Hochstenbach et al., 1993a,b, 1994a,c). The mobile micropia and gypsy elements are expressed as constituents of lampbrush loops (S. Lankenau et al., 1994; Hochstenbach et al., 1994b, 1996). In addition, micmpia encodes full-length RNA that extends between the two long terminal repeats of the element (S. Lankenau et al., 1994). Other repeats are transcribed, too. For example, the T14 clone isolated from a cDNA library, derived from testis poly(A)+ RNA of D. hydei, has a multiple location in the Y chromosome and in salivary gland polytene chromosomes (Brand and Hennig, 1989). In spite of the active transcription of loop DNA, sequence determination gives no reason for believing that the loops can encode proteins (Hennig et al., 1987). Large amounts of various proteins, which constitute the bulk of proteins in the nuclei of spermatocytes, accumulate in loops (Grond et al., 1983, 1984; Glatzer, 1984; Hulsebos et al., 1984; Hennig, 1985; Glatzer and Kloetzel, 1986; Tschendorf et al., 1989; Pisano et al., 1993). A part of the proteins is included in RNP particles filling the matrix of the loops (Glatzer and Kloetzel, 1985; Meltzer and Glatzer, 1985; Bonaccorsi et al., 1988). The proteins accumulated in the loops of the Y chromosomes are encoded by the genes of the other chromosomes. The following is adduced as supporting evidence:
1. Autosomal recessive mutations, whose action leads to the disappearance of the corresponding loops, were identified (Hackstein et al., 1982, 1987). 2. Males receiving the Y chromosome from D. neohydei and the autosomes from D. hydei can be obtained from interspecific crosses (Hennig, 1977). The structure of loops in such males resembles that in D. hydei, although it is clear that loop morphology depends not only on protein composition, but also on transcription intensity, transcript size, and morphology of RNP-containing particles (Hennig, 1985). 3. With the use of antibodies, certain loop proteins are identified in spermatocyte nuclei in individuals without the Y chromosome, and, consequently, not forming loops (Kloetzel et al., 1981; Bonaccorsi et al., 1988; Tischendorfet al., 1989; Pisano e t al., 1993).Certain loop-associated proteins are testis specific: 80-kDa testis protein (Hulsebos et al., 1983, 1984) and T53-1 tektinlike protein (Pisano et al., 1993). Antisera raised against proteins from synaptonemal complexes (sc) from rat spermatocytesreact strongly with Y chromosomal lampbrush loops in D. mlanogaster and D. hydei. Each serum recognizes one or two loops (Hennig et al., 1995).
74
1.
F. Zhimulev
Lifschytz (1987) holds the view that the loops may have a dual function: (1) they regulate the development of spermatids, forming the regular nuclear matrix specific to spermatocytes; and (2) loop formation is a consequence of decompaction and transcription of repeats. Gatti and Pimpinelli (1992) speculate that Y loops fulfill protein-binding functions. According to Pisano et al. (1993), loops present only in the Drosophila genus have evolved to facilitate the development of the giant sperm tails (2 mm in D. mehogaster and 1 cm in D. hydei) characteristic of this genus (Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992). The DNA coding for a set of transcripts expressed in the germline of D. melanogater males has been found in the Y chromosome heterochromatic regions h18-hl9. In contrast to D. mehogaster, where Y-linked copies were found in nine different wild-type strains, no Y-linked copies were found in sibling species (Russell and Kaiser, 1993).
D. Genetic degeneration of the neo-Y chromosome in Drosophila miranda Drosophitamiran& males show only nine chromosomes in metaphase because they are apparently monosomic for one of the autosomes (Figure 41). This autosome has been designated X2 and corresponds to the third chromosome in D. pseudoobscum and 2R in D. melanogater (Dobzhansky, 1935b; MacKnight, 1939; Steinemann, 1982b; Steinemann et al., 1984). The homolog of X2 has been attached to the Y chromosome and is now referred to as the neo-Y chromosome. In situ hybridization of telomeric DNA to male metaphase spreads reveals a massive labeling block within the neo-Y in addition to the labeling sites at chromosome ends, thus implying an “end-to-end” fusion mechanism (Steinemann, 1984). The neo-Y is polytenized in the salivary gland cells (MacKnight, 1939; Steinemann, 1982a).
aX’ \
R4
b X’ \
44
Figure 41. Diagram of the Drosophila miranda female (a) and male (b)
karyotypes. After Steinemann and Steinemann (19911.
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
75
The attached autosome is gradually acquiring the features of the Y chromosome, displaying changes in chromosome structure and loss of gene activity. The X2chromosome is evolving into an X chromosome. Certain genes on the X2 are now capable of dosage compensation and enhanced transcription in males that compensate for the inactivity of the homologous gene on the neo-Y. Thus the system is a very good model of genetic degeneration of the Y chromosome. In situ hybridization using cRNA transcribed from unfractionated D. mirun& DNA reveals hybridization to the neo-Y with dispersed label distributed over the entire chromosome. The former partner chromosome, X2, is essentially unlabeled. This suggests that repetitive DNA sequences “invade” the translocated chromosome (Steinemann, 1982a). One of the repeats, a BumHl element, is predominantly associated with degenerating neo-Y chromosome, but absent in the D. melanoguster genome (Ganguly et ul., 1992). The TRAM transposable element was found in neo Y chromosome. Its size is 3,452 bp, including long terminal direct repeat of 372 bp on both sides. In situ hybridization with TRAM subclones showed massive accumulation of TRAM in the neo-Y chromosome (50-60 labeled sites), while the former homologue, the X2 chromosome, contains no TRAM .sites (Steinemann and Steinemann, 1997). Staining D. mirunda with antibodies against isoform of histone H4 acetylated at lysine 16, showed that the X2 shows much brighter staining over 90% chromosome length than neo-Y (Steinemann et al., 1996). Steinemann and Steinemann (1990, 1992) have analyzed the region around the four larval cuticle proteins (Lcp) from the X2and compared it with the homologous region from the neo-Y chromosome. The striking difference between the two chromosome regions is the large number of insertions on the neo-Y but not on the X2. Sequence analysis of Lcp locus cloned from the X2and Y chromosomes reveals a massive accumulation of inserted DNA sequences (ISYs) in the Y chromosome Lcp region (Figure 42). In situ hybridization with the TRIM retrotransposon (Steinemann and Steinemann, 1991) and ISYs insertions show a differential distribution of these transposable elements on the X2 and the neo-Y chromosomes. The transposable elements show heavy hybridization over the formerly autosomal sequences that are now on the neo-Y. In contrast, the X2 homolog shows approximately the same density of sites of hybridization as do the autosomes and the X chromosome (see Figure 42). There are insertions of many other transposing elements in this region (Steinemann and Steinemann, 1992, 1993).Thus, in the neo-Y chromosome, all the four Lcp genes are embedded within a dense cluster of transposable elements. Numerous deletions and a large duplication were found on the neo-Y chromosome in comparison with the X2 chromosomes (Steinemann and Steinemann, 1993). As a result, while the X2 Lcp-l through Lcp4 loci are expressed, the Y chromosomal Lcp-3 locus shows only reduced activity and the Lcpl , Lcp-2, and Lcp-4 are completely inactive. The ob-
76
I. F. Zhimulev
C
x2 Lcp 1
H H C h
1 kb
LCp REGION C
XhH
Lcp 2
R
H
Lep 3
C Sa
B
XhXh
Lcp 4
r----------4
‘
:
DUPLICA
Y
Dv4
la
DV6
Figure 42. Schematic view representing the Lcp region at the X2 and neo-Y chromosomesof D. miranda. Unsequenced DNA sections are indicated by lines flanked by arrowheads at both sides. Large open arrowheads indicate the direction of transcription. neo-Y chromosome sequences (ISYs)additional to X2 chromosomeare shown by stippled boxes. The ISY2X2, ISYZY, and ISY2/3 insertions are indicated by hatched boxes. The large 1SY4 and ISY5 insertions identified as retrotransposons are designated TRIM and TRAM. Missing DNA sequences in the neo-Y chromosomal region are indicated as deletions (DY). The duplication is indicated by a dashed box. After Steinemann and Steinemann (1992,1993) and Steinemann et al. (1993).
tained results suggest that neo-Y Lcp-f and Lcp-3 loci are silenced by neighboring transposable elements (Steinemann and Steinemann, 1992; Steinemann et al., 1993,1996a,b). Thus, in a relatively short evolutionary span from the time the autosome was translocated onto the Y chromosome, the sequence of the homologs has evolved very differently. The sequence on the neo-Y has acquired many more copies of insertions than X2 homolog, and Y chromosome degeneration is driven by the accumulation of transposable elements, especially retrotransposons. In the evolutionary process of Y chromosome degeneration, the mechanism of silencing might be the first step and could even be a prerequisite for degradation (Steinemann et al., 1993; Steinemann and Steinemann, 1997). In other species, Drosophila americanaamen’canu, three loci, coding for the enzymes enolase, phosphoglycerate kinase and alcohol dehydrogenase, are located in the chromosome 4,which forms the neo-Y and neo-X chromosomes. Genes coding for these enzymes carry active alleles on the neo-Y chromosome. These data suggest that the neo-Y chromosome has undergone very little degeneration (Charlesworth et al., 1997).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
77
E. Other features of the genetic organization of heterochromatin One genetic feature of the heterochromatin of D. melanogaiter is low frequency of crossing over (Muller and Painter, 1932; Mather, 1939; Baker, 1958; Roberts, 1965; Schalet and Lefevre, 1976; Carpenter and Baker, 1982; Charlesworth et al., 1986; Lake, 1986; McKee and Handel, 1993. For example, the distance between the genes car+ (18D1-2 region) and su(f)+, located at the eu- and heterochromatin junction, is 3.54 m.u., while the distance between the su(f>+and they+ genes, transposed to the right arm of chromosome XR, is 0.04 m.u. It should be noted that there are, in all, about 60 bands between the genes in the former case, and the entire heterochromatin (i.e., 40% of all the X chromosome) between su(f)+ and y’ in the latter case (Roberts, 1965). Using a similar approach, Baker (1958) revealed an analogous phenomenon in
D. virilis. A comparison of crossing-over frequencies in blocks of centromeric and intercalary heterochromatin is of interest. Recombination frequency between the bristle’ and light’ genes lying at the boundary of the repeat cluster of the histone genes (approximately 500 kb), was 0.042%, and that between the light’ and straw+ genes (between which the entire block of centromeric heterochromatin of the second chromosome is located) was 0.047%. When pupae ages 126-168 hr (the primary oocytes are layered at the age of 126-132 hr) are treated with high temperature (35”C), crossing-over frequencies increase 30- to 35-fold in both regions (Grell, 1978). The presence of sites of meiotic pairing in the sex chromosomes may be regarded as another feature of the genetic organization of heterochromatin. Gershenzon ( 1933a,b, 1940) established that the heterochromatic (“inert”) regions of the X chromosome are important for meiotic pairing. Cooper (1964) called these loci “collochores” (col). Since the X and Y chromosomes of Drosophita are very different morphologically and functionally, the question of the mechanisms of pairing of these elements at prophase I of meiosis is quite timely. Much evidence exists for the presence of pairing sites in heterochromatin of the X chromosome (Muller and Painter, 1932; Gershenzon, 1933a,b, 1940; Sandler and Braver, 1954; Cooper, 1964; Peacock, 1965; Peacock and Miklos, 1973; Yamamoto and Miklos, 1977; Karpen et al., 1996), particularly in the region of the nucleolar organizer (Cooper, 1964; Merriam, 1968; Sandler, 1975; Peacock et al., 1975; Appels and Hilliker, 1982; McKee, 1984, 1987, 1996; McKee and Lindsley, 1987; Dernburg et al., 1996). McKee and Karpen (1990) demonstrated that proper X-Y recognition and segregation in male meiosis is dependent upon ribosomal DNA repeats. Using P-element-mediated transformation, McKee et al. ( 1992) further demonstrated that this recognition is due to 240-bp repeats in the nontranscribed spacer, which is present in tandemly repeated copies (IGS) between each of the rDNA repeats. While a single copy of the IGS element inserted ectopically into the
78
1.
F. Zhimulev
X-euchromatin provides a significant rescue of X-Y pairing, proper recognition and segregation improves with increased numbers of these repeats. Internally deleted copies of an IGS with fewer than six repeats of the 240-bp element were unable to ensure X-Y segregation (McKee and Karpen, 1990; McKee et al., 1992). Some cytogenetic data run counter to this hypothesis. According to Park and Yamamoto (1993, the pairing site is in the region distal to the In(l)scv2 breakpoint within the cluster of rRNA genes. Attempts to detect sites of meiotic pairing in the autosomal heterochromatin of Drosophila were unsuccessful (Yamamoto, 1979; Hilliker, 1981a,b; Hilliker et al., 1982; McKee et al., 1993), although heterochromatic homology seems responsible for the segregation of the achiasmate X and fourth chromosomes (Hawley et al., 1993; Irick, 1994). One of the peculiarities of heterochromatin is its tight contact with the nuclear envelope (see Zhimulev, 1993, 1996, for review). DNA sequences associated with nuclear lamina were found within p-heterochromatin of Drosophila melanogaster (20CD, 40EF, and 41AB, 81 and 101 regions). They are represented by two repeated HindIII-EcoRI fragments 1.4 and 1.6 kb long. About 120 copies of these sequences were detected per haploid genome (Baricheva et al., 1995, 1996; Sharakhov, 1995, 1997; Bogachev et al., 1996).
V. DIMINUTION OF CHROMATIN AND CHROMOSOMES Differentiation of the germ and somatic cell lines, associated with loss of a part of the genetic material during early embryonic development (chromatin diminution, chromosome elimination), is quite widespread in nature. Different degrees of diminution occur in certain species of ascarids, cyclops, infusoria, fishs, ticks, beetles, butterflies, and flies (for review, see Wilson, 1936; Beams and Kessel, 1974; John and Miklos, 1979; Stanley et al., 1984; Ammermann, 1985, 1987; Hennig, 1986; Tobler, 1986; Pimpinelli and Goday, 1989; Tobler et al., 1992).
A. Chromatin diminution in ascarids (Nematoda) In Ascaris megalocephalu ( =Parascaris univakns), the zygote contains two chromosomes, a thin centromeric and a thicker terminal region can be identified in each (Figure 43). Boveri (1887) found that, as early as at the second cleavage, the thick ends of the chromosomes in a cell of the cleaving zygote separate from the middle part and, having no centromeres, remain in the regions of the equator of the mitotic spindle, where they eventually degenerate. As a result, a substantial portion of the chromosome is lost, chromatin diminution, as Boveri has termed it, takes place. The cell that underwent diminution gives rise to a cell clone (Figure 44)with much shorter chromosomes. Chromosome diminution does not take place in the second daughter cell, and it will give rise to two new cells: one will
Poiytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
79
Figure 43. C-banding of the mitotic chromosomes of Parascaris univalens (2n = 2) (a) and P. equorum (2n = 4) (b) before diminution. After Goday et al. (1985).
undergo diminution, the other will not. As a consequence, at the 32-cell stage the embryo consists of two cells with the complete set of DNA sequences (see Figure 44), and these two will form the germlines. The remaining 30 will give rise to all the somatic cells. A similar diminution pattern has been described for another species, A. lumbricoides (Bonnevie, 1902). In 11 other nematode species chromatin diminution occurs during the fifth through eighth cleavage divisions (Tobler et al., 1992). It was shown that in ascarids the centromere is holocentric and the threads of the spindle are attached to numerous regions along the entire length of the chromosome. In presomatic cells of the early cleavage divisions, the microtubes of the spindle are attached only to the euchromatic regions (Goday et al., 1992), and this presumably is the reason why diminution takes place. In P. univukns, the ends of the chromosomes cast off during diminution (up to 80% of all chromatin; see Moritz, 1970a) have the features of heterochromatin, such as H- or C-stainability (Goday and Pimpinelli, 1984, 1986; Goday et al., 1985; Pimpinelli and Goday, 1989; see Figure 43) and the capacity to hybridize in situ with satellite DNA (Goday and Pimpinelli, 1989; Pimpinelli and Gcday, 1989). The amount of heterochromatin can vary, as judged by the fact that eggs obtained from the same female differ considerably in DNA amounts; after the first cleavage division, such differences are found between homologous chromosomes. DNA content in the spermatozoa of different males varies as well (Moritz, 1970b).The central part of the chromosome not eliminated during diminution does not stain for H- and Cheterochromatin, and it does not hybridize with satellite DNA (Goday and Pimpinelli, 1984, 1989;Goday et al., 1985; Pimpinelli and Goday, 1989). In P. equorum (=A. megalocephala bivalens), the terminal portions of the
80
1. F. Zhimulev
GERM LINE
.
Mesoderm 1
I
SOMA CELLS
Figure 44. Schematic representation of the cell lineage and segregation of germline and somatic cells in Ascaris lumbricoides mum. The presumptive primordial germ cells (P,-P,) are indicated by half-filled circles, and primordial germ cells (P4,P5a, P5& giving rise to all germ cells by filled circles. The presomatic cells S,, S,,, and S,-S, undergoing chromatin diminution are represented by open circles surrounded by black dots. These cells eventually form, in a precisely determined manner, the various parts of the embryo that are indicated. After Tobler et al. (1992), modified from Boveri (1904), and Beams and Kessel(1974).
chromosomes are also thicker; in addition, there are numerous tangles of dense material in their middle section (Navashin, 1936).Thickenings of all types show C- and H-banding (see Figure 43); these thickenings are eliminated during diminution (Goday and Pimpinelli, 1984;Goday et al., 1985).The eliminated DNA is enriched in repeats. Thus, in P. equorum, germline cells contain two light satellites, which together make up approximately 85% of zygotic DNA. Precisely these satellites are eliminated from somatic cells (Moritz and Roth, 1976). In Ascaris suum ( = A . lumbn'coides), the amount of eliminated DNA varies 2.5-fold: 22% (Moritz and Roth, 1976),27% (Tobler et al., 1972,1985), 34% (Pastemak and Barrell, 1976),and 56% (Davies and Carter, 1980).It is noteworthy in this respect that, according to the data of Roth and Moritz (Moritz and Roth, 1976;Roth, 1979;Roth and Moritz, 1981),the highly repetitive DNA with repeat units 125 and 134 bp long is mainly eliminated. According to the data of Mueller et al. (1982),repetitive DNA contains a set of different, yet sharing some similarities, sequences with a unit length of 120 bp.
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
81
Tasl and Tas2 middle repetitive retrotransposons are present at about 50 copies per haploid germline genome. Approximately 25% of Tasl and 100% of Tas2 are expelled from somatic cell lineages (Aeby et al., 1986; Felder et al., 1994). The ratio of repetitive to unique sequences in the eliminated DNA has been estimated as 1:l (Tobler et al., 1972; Goldstein and Straus, 1978). A cluster containing at least two different single-copy genes eliminated during chromatin diminution was found. One is the ALEP-1 gene encoding the 148-amino-acid protein RpS19G, homologous to the small ribosomal subunit protein S19 of eukaryotes (Etter et al., 1991). The gene is normally expressed in Ascaris germline cells (Etter et al., 1991,1994;Tobler et al., 1992).A t least one more single-copy gene, fert- I , becomes eliminated from all somatic cells during chromatin diminution in A. lumbncoides (Spicher et al., 1994). Approximately 99% of satellite DNA present in the germline cells is eventually eliminated during diminution. The proportion of the 18s and 28s rRNA genes in the pre- and postdiminution nuclei is the same; this indicates that at least large blocks of the rRNA genes are not eliminated (Tobler et al., 1985; Landolt and Tobler, 1988). Clones with small copy number, or unique DNA not present in somatic cells, were isolated from germline cells (Muller et al., 1986). Elimination results in the formation of somatic nuclei consisting of 90% unique sequences and 10% repetitive DNA. Only 0.01-0.05% of DNA is highly repetitive (Roth and Moritz, 1981; Mueller et al., 1982). After removal of heterochromatin fragments, chromosomal fragmentation at CBR (the chromosome break region) is followed by the addition of about 2-4 kb of telomeric TTAGGC repeats (Muller et al., 1991).
B. Chromatin diminution in Cyclops Chromatin diminution was detected in at least 12 species of Cyclops, in addition to ascarids (S. Beermann, 1959, 1960, 1977, 1984; Stich, 1962; Kiknadze, 1972; Akifjev, 1974; Beermann and Meyer, 1980; Akifjev and Grishanin, 1993; Grishanin et d., 1996). The course of diminution is restricted to presumptive somatic cells, and it occurs in various species during the fourth through seventh cleavage divisions. The diploid chromosome number in C. strenuus is 22. It does not change during chromatin diminution, although chromosome diameter becomes twofold shorter (from 0.8 to 0.2 pm). The chromosomes of C. strenuus at the stage of 32-64 blastomeres are 2.5-3.0 times shorter and 3.0-4.0 times thinner than the chromosomes at the first cleavage division (Kiknadze, 1972) (Figure 45). Chromosome length decreases from 11-22 to 2.6-7 pm (Grishanin and Akifjev, 1993; Grishanin, 1995) and diameter of nuclei decreases from 10.6 to 3.4 p m (Grishanin, 1995). In C. kolensis, the time interval between the third (prediminutive) and
Figure 45. Diminution of chromatin in Cyclops furcifer (a and b) and C. strenuus (c-0. (a) The chromosomes before diminution. K, centromeres; T,telomeric regions. (b) Chromatin to be eliminated in the equatorial zone of late anaphase. (c and d) Chromosomes before (c) and after (d) diminution. (e and f) Droplets of eliminated chromatin in the nucleus ( e ) and cytoplasm (0. Pairs a and b, as well as c and d, are at the same magnification. (a and b) after S. Ekermann (1966); (c-f) after Akifjev and Grishanin (1993).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
Figure 45. Continued
83
84
I. F. Zhimulev
fourth cleavage divisions is 6 times longer than that between the first three divisions and 10 times longer than intervals between following divisions (Grishanin, 1996a). The chromosomes at the third cleavage division (prediminutive) show differential banding even after simple acetoorcein staining. In interphase prediminutive nuclei no chromocenters were found, in spite of abundant heterochromatin (Grishanin and Akifjev, 1993). Chromatin is eliminated from different regions of the chromosomes: terminal heteropycnotic fragments in Cyclops divulsus and C. furcifer or intercalary fragments in C. strenuus. It remains as large blocks, drops, or granules of Feulgenpositive material in the equatorial part of the division spindle (see Figure 45). The number of granules at the beginning of diminution is about 600 in C. koknsis and 150 in C. strenuus; subsequently, they fuse and their number reduces to 150. The granules are rounded or elongated structures distinctly separated from cytoplasm by a membrane 50 nm thick. Chromatin is exceptionally condensed. After two to three cell divisions, the drops degenerate. The large number of granules at the early steps of diminution provides evidence for the numerous start points of elimination (Akifjev and Grishanin, 1993; Grishanin and Akifjev, 1993; Grishanin, 1995, 1996a,b). It is believed that the diminution process is generally similar to the excision mechanism of bacteriophages from the Escherichia coli genome, that is, formation of loops and recombination at the point where the bases of the loops come into contact (S. Beermann, 1966; W. Beermann, 1966; Akifjev, 1974). When nuclei at the interphase, the stage preceding division, are spread, chromatin rings composed of fibrils 25-30 nm thick and 0.6-16 km long are identifiable in C. divulsus, and 0.4-40 pm in length in C. furcifer (Beermann and Meyer, 1980; Beermann, 1984).When nucleosomal chromatin isolated at the diminution stage is spread by Miller’s technique, rings ranging in length from 0.6 to 100 pm can be seen (Beermann, 1984). According to cytophotometric data, 65-75% of DNA is eliminated in C. furcifer during diminution (S. Beermann, 1966). The ratio of haploid DNA content in germline cells to DNA content in somatic cells is 2.2:0.9 pg for C. strenuus, 2.9:1.44 for C. furcifer, and 3.1:1.8 for C. divulsus (Beermann, 1977). Grishanin et al. (1994) and Grishanin (1995) have shown that 94% of DNA are eliminated in C. koknsis (the species is C. strenuus in their paper, but the correct species assignment is C. koknsis, according to A. P. Akifjev, personal communication), and in real C. strenuus 75% of DNA is eliminated (Grishanin et al., 1996). Special tests were not done to refer the eliminated parts of the chromosomes to heterochromatin; nevertheless, it is believed that it is precisely heterochromatin that undergoes diminution because these regions are heavily heteropycnotic (S. Beermann, 1966;W. Beermann, 1966) (see Figure 45). According to the view of Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya(19861, the genetically inactivated regions of eu- and heterochromatin are eliminated.
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
85
Akifjev and Grishanin (1993) suggest that the diminution process may arise under the effect of a single mutation activating the diminution enzyme. All the remaining steps of the process, in their view, unfold under normal conditions.
C. Elimination of chromosomes in dipteran insects In 1908, W. Kahle detected chromatin diminution in the gall midge Miastor me~raloasthat, as proved later, is associated with loss of whole chromosomes (Huettner, 193313; Reitberger, 1934, 1940; Kraczkiewicz, 1935, 1936, 1937; Metcalfe, 1935; White, 1946). This phenomenon occurs in the representatives of three families of the Diptera order. A distinction is made between the B chromosomes and the chromosomes restricted to germline cells; the latter are given different names: E chromosomes in the representatives of the Cecidomyiidae, K chromosomes in those of the Chironomidae and Orthocladiinae, and L chromosomes in those of the Sciaridae families. The chromosomes of the main set are termed the S (somatic) chromosomes (White, 1950, 1954). The elimination process may be considered by referring to the exemplary representatives of the Orthocladiinae subfamily, whose differentiation of germline cells has three distinguishing features:
1. Elimination of all the germline-restricted chromosomes takes place at the fifth through seventh cleavage divisions in somatic chromosomes.
2. When division of germline cells resumes after hatching, the K chromosome is reduced to half in the zygotes due to partial losses at anaphases. 3. This decrease in number is compensated for by a specific duplication at the differentiation stage of spermatocytes and oocytes, when all the spermatogonia and oogonia undergo one differential division. The K chromosomes reduplicate at prophase, then, with omission of chromatid division, they assemble at one pole of the spindle. As a result of the next meiosis, one daughter cell has the complete set of the K and the S chromosomes, while the other possesses only the somatic set. One cell will give rise to the oocyte in females and to the spermatozoid in males; the other will give rise to the nurse cell of the oocyte in females and to the degenerating spermatocyte in males (Beermann, 1956). Other features were revealed in the midges: the E chromosomes are completely eliminated as early as during spermiogenesis and partly during oogenesis, and, for this reason, the mature spermatozoon contains only the S chromosomes, and the oocyte contains the S and a part of the E chromosomes (White, 1950, 1973; Geyer-Duszynska, 1961; Stuart and Hatchett, 1988b). Furthermore, it is believed that in the midges the S chromosomes represent the diploid set segregating from the octaploid, and elimination of the E chromosomes means removal of the hexaploid set (Huettner, 1934; Kraczkiewicz, 1935, 1936; Reitberger, 1940; White, 1946,1947; Camenzind, 1966; Panelius, 1971; Bregman, 1975;Sager and
86
1.
F. Zhimulev
Kitchin, 1975). It has not been clarified if this is, indeed, the case. The results of cytological analysis of chromosome behavior in midge species argue against this possibility (White, 1950; Nicklas, 1959). Noteworthy in this respect is that Ortiz (see Beermann, 1956) obtained translocations of sections of K chromosomes to the S chromosomes in Memiomemus hygropenicus (Orthocladiinae). Polytene fragments of the K chromosomes were formed in some translocations of this kind. Their banding pattern had no homology with that of the S chromosomes. The other sections of the E chromosomes were completely heterochromatic (for greater detail, see Section X). In contrast, in similar translocations generated in Acricotopus lucidus, nine fragments of the K chromosomes had a banding pattern identical to that shown by the corresponding regions of the S chromosomes (32% of bands of the set) (Staiber, 1 9 9 1 ~ ) . The number of eliminated chromosomes can be large (Table 5). At anaphase of the eliminating division (at the third through seventh cleavage divisions), eight daughter chromatids continue moving to the poles, and the eliminated chromosomes remain at the position they have occupied at the early anaphase, while the S chromosomes, having reached the poles, enter the telomere (Figure 46). According to different estimates, approximately half of chromatin in Sciara copophikz (Du Bois, 1933), and 74% of DNA in Miastor sp. (Nicklas, 19591, is eliminated. In Hetmopeza pygmaea, 15% of genomic DNA is composed of the 1.716 satellite, Complementary RNA, transcribed from satellite DNA, isolated from somatic cells and not containing E chromosomes, hybridizes with centromeric heterochromatin of both types of chromosomes. Counts of silver grains established identical satellite distribution over the chromosomes of both types (Kunz and Eckhardt, 1974). It is unclear whether or not the E chromosome is enriched in any other sequences. Certain findings reveal enrichment of the eliminated chromosomes in heterochromatin. Transpositions of material from the K to the E chromosome in polytene chromosomes frequently transfer giant blocks of a-heterochromatin (see Section X). In the L chromosomes of Sciara coprophila, DNA synthesis proceeds at the end of the S phase (Rieffel and Crouse, 1966). However, the distinction between eu- and heterochromatin is rather tentative in the midges. The point is that in oogonia and spermatogonia-for example, of Trishormomyia helianthi and Miastor-specifically the somatic, and not the eliminated, chromosomes, undergo complete positive heteropycnosis (White, 1946,1950,1973). In Mikiokzfagi, all the S chromosomes in the interphase oogonial nuclei are heteropycnotic (Matuszewski, 1962). In Wachtliella persicaria, the S chromosomes are heteropycnotic in the interphase nuclei, and the E chromosomes are loose and incorporate 3H-uridine (Kunz, 1970; Kunz et al., 1970). In Mayeti& destructor, the E chromosomes are not only entirely heteropycnotic, but also stain completely for C-heterochromatin; the E chromosomes in somatic cells have only blocks ofcentromeric C-heterochromatin (Stuart and Hatchett, 1988a,b).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
87
Table 5 Occurrence of Germline Limited Chromosomes in Representatives of the Diptera Order
Species Cecidornyiidae Heteropeza pygmaea
Number of germline limited chromosomes
References
Up to 48
Hauschteck (1962). Camenzind (1966, 1974), Panelius (1968, 1971), Kunz and Eckhardt (1974)
Mayetiola destructor
35-45 20-35 28
Bantock (1970) Stuart and Hatchett (1988h) Bregman (1975)
Miastor sp.
30-32
Nicklas (1959)
Mikiola fagi
16
Matuszewski (1962)
Mycophila speyeri
-23
Nicklas (1960)
Oligarces paradoxus Rhabdaphaga batatas
-60 -30
Geyer-Duszynska (1961)
R . saliciperda
8
Wachtliella persicariae
More than 30
-30
Kraczkiewicz (1966) Geyer-Duszynska (1959) Kunz et al. (1970)
Chironomidae Acricotopw lucens
Reitberger (1940)
5-6
Michailova and Dimitrova (1984)
A. lucidw
17-19 4-19
Bauer and Beermann (1952) Staiber and Thudium (1986)
Cardiocladius sp.
Up to 80
Beermann (1956)
Clunio marinus
-8
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
Eucricotopus artritarsis
-9
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
E. silwestris
10-12
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
Limnophyes sp.
-8 12-26
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
M. inopinatus
1-4 6-8
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
M. sp.
2-3
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
Psectrocladius obwiw
1-4 3-5 10-14
Bauer and Beermann (1952)
Metriocnemus cavicola M. hydropeeicus
P. platypus P. rematus P. sp. Smittia parthenogenetica
-6 To 15
Trichocladiw wieipennis
5-7
Sciaridae Sciara coprophila
1-2 3
Bauer and Beermann (1952) Bauer and Beermann (1952)
Bauer and Beermann (1952) Bauer and Beermann ( 1952) Bauer and Beerrnann (1952) Bauer (1970) Bauer and Beermann (1952) Merzand Schmuck (1931), n u Bois (1933) Pavan eta/ (1975)
88
1.
F. Zhlmulev
Figure 46. Elimination of the chromosomesduring the third cleavage division in Miastor sp. (a) Anaphase. (b) Telophase. After Nicklas (1959).
D. Elimination of chromatin in infusoria The complex sexual processes of the formation of the micronucleus (Mi) and maturation of the macronucleus (Ma), controlling somatic cell functions as well as DNA elimination in somatic cells, have been described in a number of reviews (Ammermann, 1985; Steinbruck, 1986; Zhimulev, 199213).The micronuclei of all the flagellates contain germline-restricted DNA and the DNA that functions in the somatic macronucleus. The diminution of Ma takes place twice during its maturation: whole chromosomes are removed at the first diminution. Ten to 15 hr after the exconjugants have disjuncted in Stylonichiu lemnae, about 140 chromosomes (ranging from 100 to 180 in different strains) become more compact, pass to the inner membrane of the nuclear envelope, and then degenerate (Ammermann, 1985,1987). The remaining 35-36 chromosomes gradually polytenize, and interchromosomal elimination of DNA takes place a day later: single bands or groups are surrounded by membrane-like material forming the “substance” of the bands. The whole polytene chromosome breaks down into numerous independent vesicles in which a substantial part of DNA is lysed; only the genetically significant sequences remain. Telomeric DNA joins them at both ends and the Ma is con-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
89
verted into a “bag with genes.” As a result of the two diminution events, only 2% of the DNA sequences present in the Mi remain in the mature Ma (Ammermann et al., 1974). A large copy number of repetitive DNA is removed in the meantime. The DNA from Mi S. mytilw consists of 55% repeats; in contrast, repeats make up only 2% of the mature Ma (Ammermann, 1985). Chromatin elimination has been described in many other infusorian species (for review, see John and Miklos, 1979; Ammerrnann, 1985; Steinbruck, 1986; Zhimulev, 199213).
E. Physiological significance of diminution In 1904, Boveri suggested that there may be a correlation between chromation diminution and the structural features of the oocyte and sperm in ascarids. Neifakh and Timofeeva (1977) expressed the view that “the genes located in that part of DNA, which is retained in germ-line cells, are not directly involved in the control of embryogenesis, larval development and regulation of the functions of the adult organism. It appears natural to assume that these genes are involved in the processes of oogenesis and spermatogenesis.” A point of view akin to this is that of Hennig (19861, who believes that heterochromatin should be directly related to particular functions of the germline cells. Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya( 1986) assumed that the heterochromatin regions of the ascarid chromosomes may be needed only for the accomplishment of meiotic processes. However, it appeared unlikely to Akifjev and Grishanin (1993) that 50% of the genome of Cyclops and 98% of that of Stylonichia mytilus encode only functions specific to the sex cells, with the remainder encoding all the rest. Little is known also about the functions of the E chromosome. With respect to Mayetiola and Wachttielh,Bantock ( 1961) and Geyer-Duszynska (1966) showed that germline cells without E chromosomes are smaller, and they do not form gametes in the latter species. The same was detected for Trichocladius triannuhtus (Beermann, 1956). Possibly, the material of the E chromosome can restrain the somatic genes from becoming active in germline cells (Beermann, 1956).White ( 1954) believes that elimination of the E chromosome provides the contribution of a specific nucleoprotein to the formation of segmenting oocyte. In the view of Cavalier-Smith (1978), the eliminated chromosomes are needed excusively for increasing DNA amount in the cell, resulting in a sharp increase in the size of the oocyte nucleus; this, in turn, accelerates maturation of the oocyte. According to Spradling ( 1993), elimination in somatic cells might function in such a manner that repetitive DNA around the active gene regulates its activity. “The amount and nature of the interspersed and flanking repeats are proposed to regulate activity of rDNA at appropriate levels in different cell types.” Changes in the amount of repetitive DNA may result in changes of neighboring gene activity (Spradling, 1993). These are all mere hypotheses.
90
I. F. Zhlmulev
VI. CENTROMERIC HETEROCHROMATIN IN POLYTENE CHROMOSOMES A. Morphological characteristics The question of the correspondence of regions of centromeric heterochromatin, identified in mitotic chromosomes, to a particular structure in polytene chromosomes is resolved in its own way for each species. Inasmuch as polytene chromosomes are not involved in cell division, the position of centromeres and, accordingly, of centromeric heterochromatin is not always easy to determine. Position of the centromeric region in polytene chromosomes can be determined according to the arm ratio in the mitotic chromosomes, the presence of bulky masses of heterochromatin and, quite rarely, on chromosomal rearrangements whose breakpoints in mitotic and polytene chromosomes have been localized (Beermann, 1962). Centromeric heterochromatin has been most accurately mapped in Dosophila because, first, localization can be aided by the use of rearrangements, and, second, heterochromatic regions of nonhomologous chromosomes pair ectopically, forming a chromocenter (Figure 47). There are chromocenters in representatives of many families of the Diptera order (for review, see Zhimulev, 1992b). In many other species, although the chromocenter does form, centromeric blocks of heterochromatin, differing in tighter compaction (stainability), nevertheless are frequently connected by long loose strands of ectopic contacts-for example, in Chironomus crmsimunus (Keyl, 1961), Ch. cucini (Martin, 1979), Ch. plumosus (Michailova, 1989a), and Anopheles species (Rishikesh, 1959; Coluzzi and Cancrini, 1971).Occasionally, these contacts are extremely infrequent, as in Ch. thumrni (Badaev et al., 1973). Cases were described in which closely related species differ in chromocenter organization: Eusimulium costaturn is homosequential with E. wemum, but the first of these species is chromocentric, whereas the last is not (Hunter, 1987). Centromeric heterochromatin is often observed to be such bulky blocks (Figure 48) that the heterochromatic nature of this material is not in doubt-for example, in Glyptotendipes barbipes (Bauer, 193613; Basrur, 1957; Michailova, 1993), Orthocladius bipunctellw (Michailova, 1982; Michailova and Belcheva, 1982), and Demeijerea rufipes (Belyanina, 1993). Moreover, these regions are also involved in chromosomal contacts (Wen et al., 1974; Belyanina, 1993). A small band, somewhat more compact than the others or positively staining for C-heterochromatin, quite frequently is mistaken for centromeric heterochromatin (Hagele, 1977a; Belyanina and Sigareva, 1978; Sigareva, 1981; Michailova, 3987a). In many cases, the chromosomes contain no particular bands to which the role of centromeric heterochromatin may be ascribed. Thus, cyto-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
91
logical studies did not reveal heterochromatin in the polytene chromosomes of many of the 13 studied chironomid species (Keyl, 1960) (see also Michailova, 1989a). In some instances, the position of centromeres is precisely mapped to chromosomal rearrangements, as, for example, in various species of Drosophila or Sciara copophila (Crouse, 1977). Heitz (1934) has found two types of heterochromatin. A very dense, heavily staining vacuolized body refracting light can be seen in the chromocenters (see Figure 47). Heitz has referred to it as a-heterochromatin. Two facts are relevant to the compaction degree of a-heterochromatin. When isolated nuclei of Ch. tentans are treated with salt solutions containing 20-3OmM NaCl, the chromosomes rapidly swell and lose their stainability and banding pattern, and the nucleus becomes homogeneous and structureless. Only a-heterochromatin remains heavily stained (Sass, 1980a). When a squash preparation is maintained in 55% lactic acid (removing RNA and proteins), bands become structureless. Only a-heterochromatin exhibits a condensed, heavily staining structure (Figure 49) (see also Koryakov etal., 1996; Belyaeva etal., 1997). Longterm (several years) keeping of constant preparations of Anopheles messae nurse cell polytene chromosomes stained with orcein results in almost complete loss of staining in all chromosome regions but centromeric heterochromatin (Stegniy and Sharakhova, 1990; Sharakhova et al., 1997). The reticular granular grayish formation constituting the greatest part of the chromocenter and characterized by lower compaction degree (see Figure 47) represents P-heterochromatin (Heitz, 1934). In certain species its content is very high-for example, at the base of the X chromosome of D. funebris (Tinyakov, 1936, 1965; Emmens, 1937b; Perje, 1955) and in the chromosomes of D. oiritis (Fujii, 1942) (see also Figure 47), D. psewloobscura (Bauer, 1936a), D. nebulosa (Pavan, 1946a), and D. orena (Lemeunier and Ashburner, 1984). In D. funebris, P-heterochromatin frequently establishes ectopic contacts with the euchromatic regions of the X chromosomes (Tinyakov, 1965). When these results are taken together, one concludes that there is invariably less a-than P-heterochromatin. Thus electron microscopic (EM) analysis of thin sections revealed that the area of p-heterochromatin is 1639.84 Fm2, whereas that ofa-heterochromatin is 26.48 Fm2 (Lakhotia and Jacob, 1974). According to other data, these values are 1542.06 and 61.66 pm2, respectively. The cross section of an a-heterochromatin block is usually 3-4 pm (Lakhotia, 1974a). Morphology of the chromocentre heterochromatin in the larval salivary gland chromosomes of D. hydei shows remarkable similarity with that of D. melanoguster (Lakhotia, 1974b). In some organisms, in particular Drosophila, both a-and P-heterochromatin are represented in considerably smaller amounts in the polytene than the mitotic chromosomes (Painter, 1933, 1934a,c; Heitz, 1934), that is, heterochromatic regions partially polytenize (for greater detail, see Section V1,D).
92
1. F. Zhimulev
Figure 47. a-And P-heterochromatin in D. wirilis (a and b) and D. mekmoguster in XY (c), XO (d), XYY ( e ) ,XX (0,and XXY (g). Chromosomes in c-g were kept in lactic acid ac-
cording to E. S. Belyaeva. (a) Long arrow designates a-heterochromatin; short arrows designate p-heterochromatin. (c-g) Arrows indicate a-heterochromatin. (a) after Heitz (1934); (b) reprinted by permissionfrom Gall et al. (1971); (c-g) after Koryakov et al. (1995).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
93
Figure 47. Continued
The chromocenter is formed at the very earliest developmental stages, and it can be seen in the nuclei of the smallest salivary gland cells amenable to examination (Frolova, 1938). The chromocenters include the centromeric a-and P-heterochromatic fragments of the chromosomes, as well as the Y chromosome (Painter and Stone, 1935; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1935a-c, 1937a,b; Kaufmann, 1937). The contribution of any given chromosome to the pericentric heterochromatin formation in polytene sets is different (Heitz, 1934, for D. oin'lis; Pavan, 1946a, for D. nebulosa). Analysis of heterochromatin in the salivary gland cells of XO, XU, and XYY males as well XX and XXY females after aging the squashes in lactic acid
94
1. F. Zhimulev
Figure 48. Pericentric heterochromatin in Chironomus melanotus (a) and Glyptot e n d i p s bnrbiper (b). C, centromere; N, nucleoli; numbers and letters designate chromosomes. Labeling of heterochromatin after application of labeled DNA on the chromosomes treated with DNase is shown in b. (a)
reprinted by permission from Hagele (1977b); (b) reprinted by permission from Schmidt and Key1 (1981).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
95
Figure 49. Morphology of D. melanogaster a-heterochromatin after lengthy treatment of salivary gland squashes with 50% lactic acid. ( a ) Fresh preparation of salivary gland chromosomes of bwD, containing insertion of pericentric heterochromatin (het) into the 59 region of the 2R chromosome. (h) After 5 days in 50% lactic acid at room temperature. After E. S. Belyaeva (unpublished ohservations).
showed no differences in the amount of a-heterochromatin in all genotypes examined. This indicates that the Y chromosome does not substantially contribute to the formation of a-heterochromatin (Koryakov et al., 1996). In D. pallidtpennis and D. ananassae, the chromocenter contains a microchromosome that resembles p-heterochromatin in structure (Dobzhansky, 1944; Moriwaki and Tobari, 1975). Painter and Stone’s (1935) idea that the heterochromatin of the chromocenter is not associated with individual chromosomes, but rather forms a common mass dipped into the centromeric regions of all the chromosomes, has not been supported. The Y chromosome appears as a dense rounded body composed of a-heterochromatin (Heitz, 1934; Kaufmann, 1937).The Y chromosome in the salivary gland nuclei of Phryne cincta is represented by a rounded and tightly packed formation ofthe same kind (Wolf, 1957,1970). InD. nebulosa,this chromosome cor-
96
1. F. Zhlmulev
responds to a series of small, dense, compact granules (Pavan, 1946a). The hypothesis of Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya (1935b) and Frolova (1936a) that a part of the Y chromosome (in the region of the bb locus) has a banding pattern was not confirmed in later studies. In D. busckii, a small fragment of the salivary gland Y-chromosome shows a banding pattern. Its length is 1/24th that of the X chromosome, and it contains 14-15 bands. The vital genes presumably map to this element since XO males die at early developmental stages. A similar fragment is also present in the X chromosome. Presumably, these fragments are homologous to the microchromosomes of the other Drosophila species, and they are irrelevant to heterochromatin (Sirotina, 1938; Krivshenko, 1939, 1941, 1950, 1955). In polytene chromosomes, the boundaries between euchromatin and aand P-heterochromatin are rather blurred. It is not always distinctly seen where a-heterochromatin ends and P-heterochromatin starts, or where p-heterochromatin terminates and the euchromatic part proper first makes its appearance (Figure 50). Moreover, the morphology of bands at the boundary with the p-heterochromatin network is frequently abnormal (diffusion, bends, breakages, reticulation). It is noteworthy in this regard that the boundary between bands and the fbheterochromatin network can pass through a certain region in one preparation and through a region several bands distal or proximal in another preparation (I. F. Zhimulev, unpublished observations).
Figure 50. The chrornocenter in the salivary gland cells of Drosophila according to data from electron microscopy. X, 2L, 2R, chromosome numbers; thin arrows indicates the eu- and heterochromatic junction, bold arrow indicates a-heterochromatin. After Sorsa (1969).
Polytene Chromosomes, Hetarochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
97
In an attempt to precisely map the point nearest to the heterochromatin in the D. pallidipennis X chromosome, it was found that its localization varies widely from one cell to another. For this reason, rather extensive regions of the chromosomes occasionally either show a well-defined banding pattern or appear structureless and “foamy” (Dobzhansky, 1944). The chromocenter, and correspondingly P-heterochromatin, were not observed in certain mutants of D. mehogaster: l(3)tl (Kobe1 and Breugel, 1967; Zhimulev etal., 1976) andfs 231 (King etal., 1981). According to Heino (1989), there is no chromocenter in pseudo-nurse cells of the otu mutants in D. mehogaster. However, as shown later, pericentric heterochromatin in these mutants occurs even more extensively than in salivary gland cells (Mal’ceva and Zhimulev, 1993, 1997; Mal’ceva et al., 1995; Koryakov and Zhimulev, 1995; Koryakov et al., 1996, 1997). These data also demonstrate tissue differences in the amount of pericentric heterochromatin. There are differences in chromocentric structure between larval organs. Thus there is no chromocenter in D. melanogarter midgut cells (Hochstrasser and Sedat, 1987a). It was found that, at varying temperatures, different numbers of bands are detectable in the nearest-to-heterochromatin region of chromosome 3R of D. melanogaster: 46% of the nuclei had a more compact shape at 15°C and only 20% at 25”C,whereas a more elongated base with the formation of an additional band formed in the greater part of nuclei (32%) (Lovering, 1986). Taking into account these uncertainties, it may be noted that p-heterochromatin in the polytene chromosomes of D. mehogaster is accurately mapped only to the regions proximal to certain segments: segment 20 in the X chromosome, segment 40C in chromosome 2L, segment 41D in chromosome 2R, segment 80C in chromosome 3L, segment 81F in chromosome 3R, and segment 101 in the fourth chromosome. In certain species of the Calliphoridae, Tephritidae, Glossinidae, and Sarcophagidae families, the X and Y chromosomes are not represented by polytene elements in the bristle-forming cells. There is a granular reticular mass and frequently a dense compact body instead (Figure 51). Such structures were found in Surcophagu bullata (Trepte, 1976), Lucilia cuprha (Childress, 1969; Bedo, 1982b), representatives of the Parasarcophugu genus (Srivastava et al., 1982; Kaul et al., 1983, 1989a), Ceratitis capitata (Bedo, 1986, 1987a; Zacharopoulou et al., 1991a,b), Cochliomyia hominivorax (Dev et al., 1986), Chrysomia species (Puchalla, 1994), and Dacw oka (Mavragani-Tsipidou et al., 1992; Zambetakietal., 1995). In Ceratitis capituta, the granular reticular mass is identified with the X and the dense compact body with the Y chromosome (Bedo, 1987a; Zacharopoulou, 1987; Bedo and Zacharopoulou, 1988; Kerremans et al., 1990; Zacharopoulou et al., 1991a,b; Semeshin et al., 1995). In experimentally produced XXY individuals, one of the Xs is converted into the usual banded polytene chromosome and the other remains reticular (Bedo, 1982b). Tissue specificity in the morphology of the sex chromosomes was found in this species. In trichogen cells, the
98
1. F. Zhimulev
Figure 51. A complex of heterochromatized X and Y chromosomes in the trichogen cells of Ceratitis capitam. S, Y chromosome; G, X chromosome; N, nucleolus (dotted line); C, intranucleolar chromatin. After Bedo (1987a).
Y chromosome is represented by a compact block of chromatin united with the nucleolus (see Figure 51), and the X chromosome is represented by a granular mass brightly fluorescing after staining with quinacrine. Only separate Q' granules are present in the salivary gland chromosomes (Bedo and Zacharopoulou, 1988; Semeshin et al., 1995). In Glossina morsituns and G. austeni, the X chromosome is represented by a polytene element, and the Y and B chromosomes are represented by a pycnotic reticular mass (Southern et al., 1973; Southern and Pell, 1974). A stable chromocenter of a-heterochromatin is formed in Ch. melanotus (see Figure 48) (Keyl, 1961; Hagele, 1977b; Sass, 1980b) and some Yakutian Chironomidae (Kiknadze et al., 1996). The DNA included in the chromocenter of Ch. melanotus is presumably completely polytenized (Steinemann, 1978). In thin EM sections, a-heterochromatin of this species is represented by tightly packed
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
99
and heavily staining chromatin in which 20- to 25-nm fibrils are distinguished (Sass, 1980b), although the high degree of compaction of this material makes it doubtful whether distinction is possible. In other species, centromeric heterochromatin not included in the chromocenters can be represented by a-heterochromatin (e.g., in Glyptotendipes, Orthocladius, and certain midges; Chubareva, 1979) and p-heterochromatin (e.g., in mosquitoes; Moeur and Istock, 1982; Munstermann and Marchi, 1986). In the polytene chromosomes of bean haustorium (Phaseolus coccineus), the chromocenter is not formed; however, compact a-and loose P-heterochromatin is distinguished in the chromosomes (Brady and Clutter, 1974). Heterochromatin and the chromocenters of polytene chromosomes lie at the inner membrane of the nuclear envelope (for review, see Zhimulev, 199213). Presumably, there is an affinity of proteins involved in compaction of DNA sequences making up heterochromatin for components of the membranes.
B. Structural components of centromeric heterochromatin Differences in structure between eu- and heterochromatin were first described in 1950. After treatment of the larvae of D. virilis with ultrasound, the centromeres, which stained purple-red (like the euchromatic regions of the chromosomes), assumed an orange-red color. Forty-five minutes or later after a salivary gland preparation was made, the differences in color were abolished. The causes of differential staining of this kind are unclear (Yasuzumi and Yoshida, 1950). Great progress in studies of DNA and proteins has allowed thorough analysis of the structural organization of centromeric heterochromatin in polytene chromosomes.
1. DNA In the various species of Diptera, satellite and highly repetitive DNAs hybridize
in situ mainly with the regions of the chromocenters, and label is distributed quite uniformly (Hennig et al., 1970; Jones and Robertson, 1970; Botchan et al., 1971; Sederoff et al., 1975a; Cordeiro-Stone and Lee, 1976; Swift et al., 1978; Samols and Swift, 1979a; Chernyshev and Leibovitch, 1981; Ranganath et al., 1982; Lohe and Roberts, 1988; Stegniy and Sharakhova, 1990,1991). In in situ hybridization of DNA from single satellites or cRNA transcribed from them, it was found that chromocenters label nonuniformly. At first for D. virilis (see Figure 60) and then for many other species of the virilis group, it was demonstrated that satellite DNAs do not label the whole chromocenter, only the a-heterochromatic block, and they additionaly label one to two zones in the region of P-heterochromatin (Steinemann, 1976; Cohen and Bowman, 1979;Cohen and Kaplan, 1982; Mezzanotte et al., 1987).
100
1.
F. Zhlmulev
Likewise, the highest repetitive DNA in D. mehogaster is localized in a-heterochromatin (Rae, 1970; Hennig, 1973). The strictly local regions of the chromocenter label the DNA of the 1.705 satellite (Steffensenet al., 1981). Only the region of the eu- and heterochromatin junction in chromosome 3R is labeled by the DNA of the 1.672 satellite (Steffensen et al., 1981; Donnelly and Kiefer, 1986).A satellite of D. hydei (1.714) hybridizes only with a-heterochromatin, and the 1.696 satellite hybridizes with a-heterochromatin and the base of the X chromosome (Renkawitz, 1978b). What sequences is p-heterochromatin composed of? Centrifugation of the DNA from D. hydei yielded two middle repetitive fractions, one of which (1.702 in a CsCl density gradient) hybridized with the heterochromatin of virtually all the chromosomes,with the exception of the X. This DNA underwent polytenization. The other fraction (1.697) hybridized with the chromocenter and the nucleolar organizer (Renkawitz, 1978a). In D. simulans, the 1.696 satellite uniformly labels the whole chromocenter and, presumably, the base of the arms of all the chromosomes (Appels and Peacock, 1978). Of the middle repeats hybridizing with p-heterochromatin, mobile genetic elements (MGE) play the most important role. In Ashburner’s laboratory handbook, there is information that more than 40 families of the MGE have been identified in Drosophih. Their size varies in the 0.3-8.8 kb range, and a duplication from 4 to 12-14 bp is formed in the insertion sites in chromosomal DNA; copy number in the genomes varies from 0-6 to 50-100 in different strains (Ashburner, 1989). The portion of the genome occupied by the MGE is about 15,000 kb (Ashbumer, 1989), or approximately 10%of the genome (Spradling and Rubin, 1981). A schematic representation of these elements is given in Figure 52. The organizational features of the MGE are considered in greater detail in a number of reviews (Ilyin, 1982; Ananiev, 1984; Finnegan and Fawsett, 1986; Ashbumer, 1989; Blackman and Gelbart, 1989; Bingham and Zachar, 1989; Engels, 1989; Finnegan, 1989; Louis and Yannopoulos, 1991; Busseau et al., 1994; Coen et al., 1994; DiNocera et al., 1994; Kidwell, 1994; Ladeveze et d., 1994; Periquet et al., 1994). In situ hybridization analysis demonstrated that various MGEs, besides many other sites, in the euchromaticregions of the chromosomesof D. melanogmter heavily label chromocenters (Figure 53), as well as the nearest chromosome regions, which are suggested to be p-heterochromatic (regions 20,40,41, 80, and 81) (Wensink et al., 1974; Young, 1979; Kidd and Glover, 1980; Pardue and Dawid, 1981; Dowsett and Young, 1982; Ananiev et al., 1984a; Ananiev and Barsky, 1985; Bucheton et al., 1986; Biemont and Gautier, 1988; Kholodilov et d., 1988; Charlesworth et al., 1994; Coelho et al., 1996). According to Ananiev and Barsky (1985), who have studied the localization of many MGE families, a total of 11%of all the copies of mobile elements
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation +-+
+
+
-7200bp
-----------
101
MDG-1
+++ .--$
copia H.M.S. Beagle
+
Figure 52. A scheme of the structure of mobile genetic elements. 1, Chromosomal DNA; 2, duplication of the chromosome region in the integration site of the mobile element; 3, internal region of the mobile element; 4,direct long terminal repeats; 5, inverted repetitive sequences. After Ananiev (1984).
are assigned to the chromosome regions closely adjacent to the chromocenter (regions 20AB, 4OABC, 41AB, 80ABC, 8lEE and 101EF) (see also Ananiev et al., 1984a-c). They have localized 16 mobile elements in the 20,40, and 41AB regions. p-Heterochromatin labels heavily when DNA from the Stalker genetic element is used as a probe (Georgiev et al., 1990; Simonova, 1992). In the in situ localization experiments of one of the DNA clones isolated, presumably, from the Drosophita Y chromosome (Lifschytz and Hareven, 1982b) in the polytene chromosomes, the following features were identified:
The clone hybridizes with the chromocenter and the regions of the arm base of all the chromosomes showing the usual banding pattern (20AF, 39E-40F, 41AE 80AC, and 81F). The entire fourth chromosome labels. Of the euchromatic regions, the 12E1-2 band remains consistently labeled in all the studied strains. Based on sequence data, it was concluded that the clone includes a mobile element called the “1360 element” (Kholodilov et al., 1987, 1988).
Figure 53. In situ hybridization of element 1360 to polytene chromosomes of gt/gtf37larvae of D. melanogaster. (a) Labeling of chromosomal bases (designated with figures and letters), the chromocenter (cc), chromosome 4, and some sites on the third chromosome. (b) Multiple sites of labeling on chromosome 4.(c-e) Labeled ectopic stretches (arrows)to unlabeled IH region 11A6-9, from labeled regions 12E (c)and 40A-F (d) and from labeled sites on chromosome 4 (e) to the laheled chromocenter (cc). Bar represents3 km (a, c-e) and 1 km (b). Reprinted by permission from Kholodilov et al.
(1988).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
103
These data provide evidence for homology of P-heterochromatin of all the chromosome arms and the whole fourth chromosome because all have sites of 1360 mobile element. The presence of the 1360 element (or hopel, according to Kurenova et al., 1990; Leibovitch et al., 1991) in repeated units of Ste and Su(Ste) (Balakireva et al., 1992) may be the reason why the euchromatic region 12E1-2, where Ste is located, is labeled (Palumbo et al., 199413). Microdissection and microcloning of section 20 of the X chromosome revealed that 60% of the generated clones contain repetitive elements, when the 19EF region was cloned, 40% contained these elements. The size of the inserts was, on average, 4.5 kb. These repeats showed homology neither with satellite DNA nor with scrambled repeats. In in situ hybridization of one of the clones (Dr.D),as with 1360,the whole chromocenter, the 20AF, 40DF, 4lAF, 80AC, and 81F regions, and the whole fourth chromosome labeled (Miklos et al., 1988). These results provide evidence for the high homology of the chromosome regions composing P-heterochromatin. Several clones taken from microdissection library of the region 20 exist as a 12.5 kb island of unique DNA surrounded by repetitive DNA (Andrewset al., 1996). As for the other species, P-element insertions are mainly restricted to the heterochromatin in four Drosophila species of the willistoni-salturn group (Lansman et al., 1985; Daniels and Strausbaugh, 1986). In D. wirilis, in situ hybridization of clone v68-52 was shown primarily with the chromocenter and the base of chromosome 6 (Lozovskayaet al., 1993). A repetitive clone 2 labels about 60 sites, as well as the telomeric regions and the chromocenter in D. subobscura (Felger and Sperlich, 1989). Insertions of the first type into the 28s rRNA gene are located mainly in the chromocenter in Drosophila. The flanking sequences, isolated and cloned together with the insertions, are the mobile elements themselves (Pardue and Daw-
id, 1981). Data on cloning of the I-element in Drosophila, which is mainly located in the chromocenter, also favor the saturation of p-heterochromatin with mobile elements. I t was found that the DNA sequences flanking the normal I-element are defective, being immobilized copies from representatives of families such as mdg4,297, i 731F, and Doc (Crozatier et al., 1988; Vaury etal., 1989, 1990, 1994). Presumably, the immobilized m d g l elements are located in p-heterochromatin because their copy number is reduced in the DNA of salivary glands. This is indicative of their incomplete polytenization and their resulting disposition in heterochromatin (Shevelyov et al., 1987, 1989). I-elements are located in the pericentric heterochromatin in all the melanogaster subgroup species, in the other melanogaster group species, and in Scaptomyza pallida (Drosophilidae) (Bucheton et al., 1986; Simonelig et al., 1988). In D. subobscura, P-element located in p-heterochromatin is degraded (Paricio et al., 1991, 1994).
104
1. F. Zhimulev
The distal part of the X chromosome heterochromatin contains repeated SCLR elements (Shevelyov, 1992; Nurminsky et al., 1994); scrambled structures built from middle repetitive DNAs, such as copia-like elements (aurora, mdglhet, GATE) (DiNocera et al., 1986; Nurminsky, 1993; Shevelyov, 1993); LINE (G-element, type I rDNA insertions) (Roiha et al., 1981; DiNocera et al., 1986;Jakubczaket al., 1990); and Stellate (Shevelyov, 1992). The first three groups of DNA elements are immobilized in heterochromatin only (DiNocera and Dawid, 1983; Shevelyov et al., 1989; Shevelyov, 1993). A relatively new family of M repeats has been detected in D. melanogaster. These fragments are 200-3000 bp, representing three to four families arranged in blocks with one representative of each family. The blocks have mobile element mdgl at each flank. The latter occasionally inserts into one of the M sequences. The primary structure of the M sequences shows no considerable homology with the known sequences; it contains neither an extensive reading frame nor motifs characteristic of the promoters of RNA polymerase 11. The clusters of M sequences do not polytenize to any great extent (Balakireva et al., 1988). One may suggest that heterochromatin could function either as a trap where transposing elements are immobilized and start to degenerate, or as a chromosome region containing insertional hot spots (Lansman et al., 1987; Bucheton et al., 1992). The above data allow one to share the view of Miklos et al. (1988) that “the bulk of the p-heterochromatin is largely the end product of the insertion, deletion, and amplification of mobile elements into each other, as well as into regions containing unique sequences.” It is unclear, however, to what extent the mobile elements can be the structural components of (3-heterochromatin because of their varying localization. Comparisons of the genomes of D. mehnogaster with those of the sibling species D. simulans revealed that the former contain approximately three times more middle repeats than the latter (Dowsett and Young, 1982). A relevant finding is that a small number of the MGE families detected in D. mehmgaster, occur in other subspecies of the melanogaster subgroup, while D. erecta virtually lacks such elements. However, this species has many other MGE families unidentified in D. melanogaster (Dowsett, 1983). In addition to the mobile elements, labeling sites of some other repeats were found in pericentric heterochromatin. D. melanogaster HeT element is found exclusively in telomeric regions, in proximal heterochromatin, and on the Y chromosome (Traverse and Pardue, 1988; Valgeirsdottir et al., 1990; Danilevskaya et al., 1992, 1993). A middle repeat, present as 200 copies in the D. melanogaster genome in DNA fragments isolated from nuclear lamina, was located in P-het. erochromatin (Baiborodin et al., 1993a,b; Sharakhov et al., 1993, 1997; Baricheva et al., 1995, 1996; Sharakhov, 1995; Bogachev et al., 1996). Unknown repeats were found on squash preparations after digestion with A h I and Hae 111 restric-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
105
tases (Mezzanotte, 1986).In D. simulans, the insertion of the ribosomal genes of the second type is mapped in the heterochromatin of the 80BC region (Mecheva, 1990). Somewhat distal to P-heterochromatin in the 19E8 region, which already shows a clear-cut banding pattern (the locus of the uncoordinated gene) as a consequence of “walking,”an approximately 60-kb DNA was cloned. The cloned sequences fall distinctly into two classes. The first class includes sequences with small copy number, or that are unique and conserved to a great extent, which is revealed by comparing various strains. The second class is composed of tandemly repetitive units, which are polymorphic both within and between strains. The repetitive unit is separated by insertions of the first type in the ribosomal cistron (Healy et al., 1988). In the 19F-20AB region of the X chromosome of Drosophila, there are sequences homologous to satellite DNAs (1.709) from the C- heterochromatic part of the sex chromosomes of snakes (Singh et al., 1981). The structural unit of the repeat is tetranucleotide GATA. It has a potential open reading frame: three copies of the nucleotide yield four amino acids, Ile-Ser-Leu-Tyr (Singh et al., 1984; Simpson, 1990). In species in whose polytene chromosomes chromocenters are not formed, centromeric heterochromatin is also rich in highly repetitive sequences, for example, in Rhynchosciara americana (Eckhardt and Gall, 1971; Machado-Santelli et al., 1979), Chironomus thummi thummi (Schmidt et al., 1980; Zainiev et at., 1986; see also Section VII,C,6), Glyptotendipes barbipes (Schmidt, 1980), Sciara coprophila (Abbott et al., 1981) and Anopheles messeae (Sharakhova, 1997; Sharakhova et al., 1997).
2. Proteins Using a modified Giemsa staining technique (N-staining), which includes sequential removal of DNA, RNA, and acid-soluble proteins from the chromosomes, C+-banding is, nevertheless, identified at sites where C-staining for constitutive heterochromatin is detected (Matsui and Sasaki, 1973; Matsui, 1974). The nonrandom distribution of nonhistone proteins presumably causes such staining. In the salivary gland nuclei of Drosophila, a-heterochromatin in the chromocenter stains positively with this stain (Matsui, 1974; Hagele, 1977b). When one of the treatments is omitted (tetrachloracetic acid or HCl), the puffs intercalary heterochromatic bands 74A and 75C as well as the stain. However, when treatment with these acids continues for a sufficient span of time, only a-heterochromatin shows N- banding (Hagele, 1977b). It is tempting to suggest that C+-banding or large heterochromatic blocks (Hagele, 1977a; Belyanina and Sigareva, 1978; Sigareva, 1981; Michailova and Belcheva, 1982; Recco-Pimentel and Mello, 1986) may be due to the presence of specific proteins.
106
1.
F. Zhimulev
However, in three species of Chironomus (Ch. melanotus, Ch. thummi thumrni, and Ch. th. piger), positive N-staining was detected in the active regions: puffs, Balbiani rings, and nucleoli. The loose heterochromatic chromocenters of Ch. melanotus were completely unstained (Hagele, 197713). Definitive evidence has been provided to demonstrate that the centromeric regions differ in particular protein composition from euchromatin. HI histones included in nucleosomes having satellite DN As are phosphorylated. Certain types of nucleosomes possessing the 1.672 satellite (AATAT) contain protein D1 (see Section IV). Furthermore, the molecules of histone H1 are packaged in a specific manner. Thus, in Glyptotendipes barbipes, histone HI in the giant blocks of centromeric heterochromatin is not identified after application of antibodies to this protein in squash preparations. However, the results of electrophoresis of histones isolated microsurgically from centromeric proteins show that this protein is normally represented (Nonchev et al., 1989). It has been reported that the Cla-repeat-containing centromeres of Ch. th. thummi (see Section VII,C,B) are rich in a particular fraction of histone, HI11, identified with the use of monoclonal antibodies (Mohr et al., 1989; Schulze et al., 1993). Antibodies to HI-I1 were not detected in homologous regions of Ch. th. piger, where these repeats are not identified. A particular set of nonhistone proteins has been identified, in addition to modification of histones in chromocenters. A comparison of protein patterns yielded by the embryonic diploid cells and salivary glands of D. hydei revealed that the latter lack fractions psi, lambda, and kappa3. Presumably, they bind to heterochromatin, which is underreplicated in salivary gland cells (Elgin and Boyd, 1975). Of the nonhistone proteins identified, one with a molecular mass of 38 kDa lies in the chromocenters of Dosophila melanogaster and several intercalary sites. It is noteworthy that the largest amount of protein was in a-heterochromatin (Will and Bautz, 1980). The heterochromatin-specificprotein with a molecular mass of 19 kDa, HP1 (heterochromatic protein), is located in the chromocenters (a-and p-heterochromatin) and also at the bases of the chromosome arms (the 41AF and 80AC regions), in the whole fourth chromosome, and in several other regions (Figure 54) (see Powers and Eissenberg, 1993; Zhimulev, 1996; and Sections XIII,F, and XVII,A, for references). Another protein binding to polytene heterochromatin is Mod, encoded by the Su(var)moduEo gene (Garzino et d., 1992) (see Section XII1,F). There is great affinity between nonhistone proteins of heterochromatin and DNA, and the DNA-protein complex dissociates with difficulty (Hsieh and Brutlag, 1979b; Will and Bautz, 1980; James et al., 1989). This property is presumably retained in vitro, too. In any event, the satellite DNA from the giant heterochromatic proteins of Glyptotendipes barbipes hybridizes with the protein com-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
107
Figure 54. Location of antibodies on HPl protein (right) in the polytene chromosome of D. melanogaster (left). Labeling of chromocenters in squashed and unsquashed nuclei. (Courtesy of C. Craig and S. C. R. Elgin).
ponent of these blocks (see Figure 48). It should be noted that t3H]DNAbinds to protein only under the condition that chromosomal DNA is digested with DNase I (Schmidt and Keyl, 1981).
3. Structural changes in heterochromatin Several instances are known in which sharp changes in the structure (compaction degree) of chromatin are related to environmental conditions. According to Stich and Naylor (1958), when the larvae of Glyptotendipes barbipes are grown at 6-8"C, no heterochromatic blocks are formed; puffs develop in these chromosomal regions instead. Two to 3 days after transfer of the larvae to a temperature of 18°C
108
1. F. Zhimulev
large heterochromatic blocks are formed in the puffed regions. This is associated with a 10-fold increase in DNA amount. Key1 (1963) observed that, in this species, heterochromatin is expressed as a puff at 18°C and as a compact block at 6°C (Figure 55); there is no associated change in DNA amount during the transition. Puffs in the centromeric heterochromatic blocks of Glyptotendipes burbipes are inducible by heat shock (37°C) and x-ray irradiation (10,000 rad). RNA synthesis was not demonstrated in the formed puffs (Walter, 1973). Puffs arise in the centromeric heterochromatic blocks in Ch. th. thummi (Figure 56) after prolonged maintenance of larvae in a solution of actinomycin D (1-50 p,g/ml) or a-amanitin (for 24 hr and longer) (Kiknadze, 1965,1972; Valeyeva et al., 1979, 1984; Perov and Kiknadze, 1980; Kiknadze and Valeyeva, 1983; Kiknadze et ul., 1983; Valeyeva, 1991). The degree of inducibility is high: 82-100% of glands have puffed chromosomes in the centromeric regions at all developmental stages, except for a 24-hr period after the molt (19%). The percentage of chromosomes with puffs varies from 20% to 91% (with the exception of the 24-hr stage, when it is 9%) (Kiknadze and Valeyeva, 1983). These puffs do not incorporate [3H]uridine (Valeyeva et al., 1979; Kiknadze and Valeyeva, 1983), nor do they bind antibodies to DNA-RNA hybrids
Figure 55. Changes in the morphology of the heterochromatic block in the second chromosome of Glyptotendipes barbipes at different temperatures.
(a) pl appears as a Balbiani ring (18°C).(b) Transitional state at 18°C. (c) p l appears as a dense block (6°C). After Key1 (1963).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
109
Figure 56. Pseudopuffs (indicated by arrows) arising in blocks ofcentromeric heterochromatin of Ch. th. thummi under long-term inhibition of RNA synthesis by actinomycin D. After Valeyeva (1991).
(Valeyeva, 1991), and this makes their suggested transcriptional activity uncredible. At the electron microscopic level, a specific ultrastructure is detected when these puffs are induced; the material separates into two components in the centromeric region: an electron-dense component similar to band material and a thin fibrillar component (Perov and Kiknadze, 1980). Puffs are formed i n c h . th. thummi only, in hybrids between this species and Ch. th. piger. For this reason, proof of puff formation relies on the heterochromatin amount in a block. No preferential binding of actinomycin D to the heterochromatin of this species was detected (Valeyeva et al., 1984; Stepanova et al., 1985). The suggestion (Kiknadze, 1965) that puffs arise as a result of impaired RNA transport is likely in error (Valeyeva et al., 1979), because puffs develop in a background of completely inhibited RNA synthesis. Presumably, the antibiotic inhibits the synthesis of proteins involved in heterochromatin compaction and, as a consequence, heterochromatin becomes decompacted.
C. Variation in the amount of centromeric heterochromatin A distinguishing feature of heterochromatin is variation in its amount (see also Section 11,F). The variability in polytene chromosomes is manifested as incom-
110
I. F. Zhimulev
plete polytenization of different degrees (underrepresentation) or increased number of copies (amplification) (for review, see Pavan and da Cuhna, 1969; Rudkin, 1969, 1972, 1973; Berendes, 1973; Steinemann, 1978; Richards, 1985; Korge, 1987; Spradling, 1987; Spradling and Orr-Weaver, 1987). After the discovery of polytene chromosomes, it became clear that not all regions polytenize to the same degree. Painter (1933, 1934c), Heitz (1934), Hinton (1942b), and Hannah (1951) noted that the giant fragments of heterochromatin seen in the mitotic chromosome are, in fact, not present in the polytene chromosome of Drosophila. It was a widely held notion that the Drosophila Y chromosome contributes only a little material to the chromocenter (Bridges, 193%; ProkofyevaBelgovskaya, 1935a-c, 1937a, Pavan, 1946a,b), and it is therefore almost come pletely underrepresented. Analysis of flanking DNA after insertion of P-elements into the Y chromosome has shown that all nine Y chromosome insertion sites were underrepresented more than 20-fold in Southern blots of polytene DNA (Zhang and Spradling, 1994, 1995). One arm of chromosome I is not represented in polytene elements in the salivary gland, in larval malpighian tubule cells, or in imago ovarian nurse cells of mosquitoes of the Anopheles genus (Kitzmiller and Baker, 1963; Coluzzi and Kitzmiller, 1975;Stegniy, 1981). In Prodiumesa olioacea, only a part of an arm polytenizes in females, and it is completely underrepresented in males (Zacharias, 1979, 1981). In another chironomid, Pseudodiumesu brunickii, the fourth, nucleolus-forming chromosome is underrepresented. It contains 11.4% of the DNA in metaphase chromosomes and 3.7% in polytene chromosomes (Zacharias, 1984). An interesting case of underrepresentation was found during polytenization of one of the arms of the fourth chromosome of D. rnelanoguster. It has long been recognized that this is a small, one-armed chromosome with 25-50 bands in salivary gland cells (Bridges, 1935c), which starts with the lOlD dense band from the chromocenter (Figure 57). Later, on the basis of genetic data, the conclusion was made that there exists a second arm of the fourth chromosome, not completely polytenized in the salivary gland cells (Panshin and Khvostova, 1938;Griffen and Stone, 1939a, 1940b). Roberts ( 1969a, 1972b,c) generated several remarkable translocations between the third and fourth chromosomes, a break in which was located in the nonpolytenized part of the fourth chromosome proximal to the lOlD band. As a result of transfer of this part of the chromosome from the neighborhood of heterochromatin, additional bands, located to the left of IOID, became visible: 10-12 dark bands in the T(3;4)10 translocation (see Figure 57) and a small light region in T(3;4)83 that even occasionally formed an enormous puff. The lOlC band appeared in another translocation, T(2;4)14. It may be suggested that the fourth chromosome consists of three regions (see Figure 57):
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
111
1. Heterochromatin, owing to which the dot fourth chromosome in mitotic spreads stains for C+-heterochromatin. It replicates late and contains satellite DNA. 2. The region lying between lOlA and IOlD, that is, presumably between the centromere and the normally polytenizing part. This region seems to underreplicate under the usual conditions because, even in EM sections, it is not seen immersed in the chromocenter. 3. The euchromatic part proper (see Figure 57). Transfer of the 101A-101D region from the vicinity of heterochromatin to euchromatin makes normal replication possible. It is unclear whether the centromere is located in lOlA or 101D. One arm or one and one-half of the fourth chromosome underreplicates depending on its location. Cases in which heterochromatin amount varies widely in the mitotic chromosomes are known. However, the variants do not affect the sizes of the replicating parts of the polytene chromosome. For example, there is three times less heterochromatin in the D. ezoana than the D. virilis genome; however, the sizes of the banded parts of the polytene chromosome, and even the banding patterns (with the exception of inversions), are the same in these species (Holmquist,
1975a). In 14 species of Hawaiian Drosophila, the heterochromatin amount is so enormous that they have become the largest chromosome of the karyotype in several cases. This was not due to change in banding pattern (Yoon and Richardson,
197813). There are well-known instances of underrepresentation of whole chromosomes. For example, the B (see Section IX) or the Y chromosomes of Drosophila and Phryne cincta (Sokoloff and Zacharias, 1977) and of the mosquitoes of the Anopheles genus (Coluzzi and Kitzmiller, 1975) frequently do not polytenize. In D. pallidipennis, five pairs of rodlike chromosomes, a pair of dot microchromosomes, and a pair of giant V-shaped chromosomes the length of which is almost that of the total length of all the other chromosomes are identified in mitotic spreads. Thus the detection of seven large polytene elements would be expected in the salivary gland nuclei. However, there are only five elements; the giant V-shaped chromosome is presumably underrepresented (Dobzhansky, 1944). In D. nasutoides, the fourth chromosome pair contains 65% of all genomic DNA, but it is heteropycnotic and entirely unpolytenized (Zacharias, 1990). In flies of the Calliphoridae, Tephritidae, Glossinidae, and Sarcophagidae families, differences in polytenization degree of the sex chromosome were revealed. The pertinent data are controversial. It has been reported that the X and Y chromosomes are represented by polytene elements in the salivary gland nuclei or bristle-forming cells (Sharma et al., 1976; Handa et al., 1980, 1981). They are
112
1. F. Zhimulev ~
nonpolytenized, as may be judged from other data (Bultmann, Clever, 1969; Clever et al., 1969; Whitten, 1969; Samols and Swift, 1979a; Kaul and Tewari, 1978; Perkins et al., 1992). Cytophotometric evidence indicates that the same amount of DNA is retained in the heterochromatin of polytene chromosomes as is contained in the diploid nuclei of Drosophila (i.e., 2C-4C) (Rudkin and Schultz, 1961; Rudkin, 1965a,b, 1969; Berendes and KeyI, 1967; Mulder et al., 1968; Zacharias, 1986, 1990,1993),while the polytenization level of euchromatin is 1000-2OOOC. As determined by Southern blotting, restriction fragments comprising mainly centromeric heterochromatin near the euchromatin-heterochromatin breakpoint of the Dp 1187 were drastically reduced (more than 50-fold) in salivary gland and ovarian DNA (Karpenand Spradling, 1990; Spradling et al., 1992). Furthermore, euchromatic sequences even 50 kb or 100 kb from the breakpoint were still underrepresented.
Figure 57. Structure of the fourth microchromosome of D. mefumgaster. (A) Electron microscopic section of a normal chromosome. (B)T(3;4)10.(C and D)T(3;4)83 with puff (shown by arrow in C) and without puff (D). (E) A scheme of the location of nonpolytenizing C+-heterochromatin (1 ) and polytenizing euchromatin ( 3 ) and a region (2) polytenizing in translocations. Numbers and letters designate chromosome regions. (A) after V. E Semeshin (unpublished observations); ( E D ) after Roberts (1972~);(E)after I. E Zhimulev (unpublishedobservations).
2 Figure 57. Continued
3
114
I. F. Zhimulev
-
Based on cytophotometric analysis of Feulgen-stained chromosomes, Dennhofer (1981, 1982a,b) obtained data indicating that all the chromosome regions are polytenized to the same degree. Later, Lamb (1982) found that adult malpighian tubules and midgut nuclei contain DNA doublings of the diploid value during replication. This finding conflicts with the known facts, and is difficult to interpret. It is believed that the three components of the mitotic chromosomethe bulk of the heterochromatin (or a-heterochromatin), the euchromatin, and the P-heterochromatin lying between them (see Figure 64)-behave differently during polytenization: euchromatin completely replicates, a-heterochromatin is represented by the same amount as in the mitotic chromosome, and P-heterochromatin partly replicates (Heitz, 1934; Gall, 1973). The highly repetitive DNAs are strongly underrepresented in the polytene chromosomes of the salivary glands of many dipteran species (Hennig et d., 1970; JonesandRobertson, 1970;Rae, 1970;Botchanetul., 1971; Dicksonetal., 1971;Gall et d., 1971; Blumenfeld and Forrest, 1972;Hennig, 1972a,b;Balsamoet d., 1973a-c; Cordeiro et d., 1975; Spear, 1977; Wollenzien et al., 1977; Peacock et d., 1978; Steinemann, 1978; Miklos and Gill, 1981; Redfem, 1981a; Nazimiec and Beckingham, 1986,1989; Perkins et d., 1992). In the polyploid nurse cells of D. mehnoguster satellite sequence replicate only partially (Hammond and Laird, 1985a). Figure 58 presents an illustrative pattern of the sedimentation profiles of DNA fragments in diploid and polytene tissues. The various satellites in the various tissues underreplicate differently (Figure 59). Comparisons of chromatin composition in the nuclei of salivary glands and embryos demonstrated that several fractions of nonhistone protein are missing in polytene nuclei. These proteins are possibly important components of underrepresented constitutive heterochromatin (Elgin and Boyd, 1975). In situ hybridization experiments have shown that the amount of satellite DNA in diploid cells and a-heterochromatic blocks in the polytene chromosomes of D. virilis is virtually the same (Figure 60, see also Peacock et ul., 1974). This has led Gall et al. (1971) to the conclusion that a-and P-heterochromatin are differentially polytenized. While the amount of a-heterochromatin remained at 2 4 2 , P-heterochromatin polytenized more effectively. The following facts support this conclusion: 1. In an EM autoradiographic study after pulse incorporation of [3H]thymidine, there was fivefold less label per unit area in a-than P-heterochromatin. This is evidence of decreased involvement of the former in replication and of continuing replication in the latter (Lakhotia, 1974a). 2. After treatment of the salivary glands of D. nasuta with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (5-BrdU) during the last one to two replication cycles, only a-heterochromatin (the Hoechst 33258 stain at pH 7.0) fluoresces. Inasmuch as 5-
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation M 1.702
115
I
Figure 58. Profiles of DNA distribution in D. m u toides in a CsCl density gradient isolated from the cells of brain (a), adult nuclei (b), embryonic nuclei (c), and larval salivary glands (d). M, major fraction; Roman and Arabic numerals designate satellite numbers. Reprinted by permission from Cordeiro et al. (1975).
BrdU can substitute for DNA during replication and H-fluorescence is quenched as a consequence, fluorescence shows that a-heterochromatin is not involved at least during the last replication cycles (Kumar and Lakhotia, 1977). Similar results were obtained in other species of Drosophilu (Lakhotia and Mishra, 1980). 3. In D. muta, the Hoechst 33258-staining a-heterochromatin block is virtually of the same size in the nonpolytene cells of imaginal disc salivary glands and the polytene cells of larval salivary glands and malpighian tubules (Lakhotia, 1984). In the case of long-term incorporation (46 hr) of [3H]thymidine into the cells of imaginal discs, approximately 100% of interphases label; however, the chromocenters remain unlabeled in approximately 50% of nuclei (Lakhotia, 1981).
116
1. F. Zhimulev
Thoracic
Midgut
Molpighion Tubulr
AJL Adult Ovary
Broin
Wholr Adult Pupal Ovary
Figure 59. Representation of satellites in various tissues of adult flies and pupae of D. vinlis. Reprinted by permission from Endow and Gall (1975).
There are data mainly confirming the idea that there is no polytenization in a-heterochromatin, yet they are somewhat at variance from the following facts: (1 ) the areas of the chromocenters in the interphase nuclei are larger in neuroblast cells of third instar larvae than in 6-hr embryos of D. muta (Lakhotia and Kumar, 1980); and (2) t3H]thymidineis incorporated into the chromocenter in some cases (Plaut, 1963, 1968; Swift, 1964), although it is possibly incorporated into the DNA of the ribosomal genes included in heterochromatin. The DNAs enriched in transposing elements and composingmost P-hetetochromatin are underrepresented in the Drosophih mekmogaster polytene chtomosomes as well. Nonmobile heterochromatic mdgl her, SCLR, and aurora are underrepresented in the DNA of salivary gland cells compared with those isolated from flies (Shevelyov et al., 1989; Shevelyov, 1992, 1993).The repeats of the 18s and 28s rRNA genes, which are included in the heterochromatin of the mitotic chromosomes, are considerably underrepresented in salivary gland cells, in addition to satellites. The DNA content of the genes in the highly polytenized cells is 20-28%
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
117
Figure 60. Location of satellite DNA in chromocenters of polytene chromosomes ( a x , e ) and diploid cells of salivary glands (d) and larvae of D. virilis. Reprinted by permission from Gall et al. (1971).
of that in diploid cells (Hennig and Meer, 1971; Spear and Gall, 1973; Gambari-
ni and Lara, 1974; Spear, 1974; Mohan, 1977;Jacobs-Lorena, 1980; Sinibaldi and Cummings, 1981; Lifschytz, 1983; Beckingham and Rubacha, 1984). This is associated with polytenization of the ribosomal DNA of only one of the two X chromosome in females and of only the X chromosome in males (Spear and Gall, 1973; Endow and Glover, 1979; Endow, 1980). The genes, which contain insertions of element I, are mainly underrepresented (Endow and Glover, 1979; Kunz et al., 1981a,b; Beckingham and Thompson, 1982; Kalumuck et al., 1990). Figure 61 is a scheme of the polytenization levels in euchromatin ( I ) , the nucleolar organizers (2), heterochromatin (3), and the telomeres (4). In Ch. tenturn, the location
118 4
1. F. Zhimulev
1
3
r-
1
2
3
Figure 61. A scheme of polytenization levels in the euchromatic part of the chromosome (11, in the region of the nucleolar organizer (2), in centromeric heterochromatin ( 3 ) , and presumably in the telomeric region (4). After Laird et al. (1974).
site of rRNA genes shows no features of heterochromatin and rDNA is proportionately represented in polytene chromosomes (Hollenberg, 1976). As for unique DNA, which is present in heterochromatin, at least several “hetetochromatic” (It) genes are highly represented in salivary gland cells (Devlin et al., 1990b). The DNA su(f) locus is 80% polytenized with respect to euchromatin (Yamamoto et al., 1990). It has been shown at the cytological and molecular levels that the proximal heterochtomatic gene rolled (see Figure 33) undergoes significant replication during polytenization with respect to the Ban-1 or AAGAG repeats, which are thought to be as underrepresented (Berghella and Dimitri, 1996). The ci gene located near the edge of the mitotic heterochromatin shows a normal level of in situ hybridization in salivary gland chromosomes (Locke and Tartof, 1994). Analysis of DNA sequences flanking 16 P-element insertions into mitotic heterochromatin has shown that in situ hybridization signals in the polytene chromosomes were observed in all of these lines. Nine tested insertion sites in autosomal heterochromatin were represented fully in salivary gland DNA. Moreover, P-elements themselves, after insertion into autosomal heterochromatin, become highly polytenized and form part of the chromocenter. Insertions form unusual shapes for chromocenter structures: bands, clusters of dots, and split bands (Zhang and Spradling, 1995). The accepted model implies that heterochromatin underrepresentation is due to underreplication of heterochromatic DNA (Gall, 1973; Rudkin, 1969). However, more recent experiments suggest that heterochromatin reduction results from DNA elimination rather than underreplication (Karpen and Spradling, 1990; Glaser et al., 1992; Spradling et al., 1992). Repeats behave differently during polytenizaton of the chromosomes of Chironomus. Satellite DNA replicates completely in all six studied species (Ch.
plumosus, Ch. nuditarsis, Ch. th. thummi, Ch. melanotus, Camptochironomus pallidivittatus, and Glyptotendipes barbipes) (Walter, 1973; Steinemann, 1978; Schmidt, 1980), and this seems to explain why there exist large heterochromatin blocks in centromeric regions. In Ch. tentans, the tRNA genes are located in euchromatin of the second chromosome and they replicate proportionately through the entire genome (Hollenberg, 1976).
Polytene Chromosomes, Hoterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
119
In giant cells of mammalian trophoblast containing cryptic polytene chromosomes, satellites also completely replicate (Sherman et al., 1972; Barlow and Sherman, 1974). In plant polytene chromosomes, differential DNA replication may include underrepresentation of pericentric heterochromatin and extra replication of another portion of the genome (see Nagl, 1982a,b, for review). Inasmuch as germline cells execute particular functions, information regarding the replication of repeats in polyploid ovarian nurse cells should be considered separately. It was an early observation that they contain more heterochromatin (Schultz, 1965). The data obtained using molecular biological methods show that underrepresentation is expressed more weakly in these cells. In a number of cases, such as in salivary gland cells, whole chromosomes or their arms underreplicate-for example, the Y chromosome of Drosophih (Schultz, 1956)or the chromosomes ofcerodonta dorsalis (Stalker, 1954),Anopheks stephensi (Redfern, 1981a), and Prodiumesa olivacea (Zacharias, 1979). The chromocenters do not increase in size with increasing polyploidy degree (e.g., in Mwca domestica; Bier, 1961. [jH]thymidine is not actually incorporated into the heterochromatic blocks of the ovarian nurse cells of Brudysia hygida (Sauaia and Alves, 1969). According to cytophotometric data, in females of the wild-type and the 0tu7 mutant of D. mehogaster, DNA content is close to 1024C or 2048C in the nuclei of ovarian nurse cells, although it corresponds to the expected amount provided that replication is complete within the first six replication cycles (Rasch et al., 1984).In the subsequent cycles, DNA content no longer conforms to the expected values; it becomes smaller. It is believed that 10-30% of the genome can underreplicate (Mulligan et al., 1981; Rasch et al., 1984; Hammond and Laird, 1985b; Mulligan and Rasch, 1985). According to other data, underrepresentation in nurse cells occurs neither in strains of the wild type nor in mutants; moreover, overreplication was detected in strains such as dic, spiC, and gt (Bohrmann er al., 1986). The underrepresentation degree of the 1.705 satellite is lower than in the salivary glands in D. mehogaster. Its amount remains at the level of three or four replications in the mitotic cells (Hammond and Laird, 1985a,b). A 30% higher copy number of satellites was detected in the pupal ovaries versus diploid cells of the brain of adults of D. oirilis. The number of satellites in the ovary of the adult fly is the same as in diploid tissue, or somewhat higher (Endow and Gall, 1975). Conversely, it was demonstrated that, in this species, satellite sequences constitute 44% of the genome in diploid cells, but only 16% of the DNA in the ovaries at the age of 2 days (Renkawitz-Pohl and Kunz, 1975). In D. hydei, satellites constitute 13% of DNA in diploid cells and only 2.2% of DNA in nurse cells (Renkawitz and Kunz, 1975).Underreplication of satellite DNA in nurse cells was detected in D. oirilis (Renkawitz-Pohland Kunz, 1975). In the highly polyploid ovarian nurse cells of Culliphoru erythrocephah,
120
1. F. Zhlmulev
satellite sequences are completely represented, although they are underreplicated in the polytene chromosomes of trichogen cells (D. Ribbert and G. Dover, 1980, personal communication). A 200-bp sequence of the 3B55 centromeric satellite, which is highly underrepresented in larval salivary glands, is proportionally represented in nurse cell nuclei: there are 15,000, 17,800, and 48 copies/haploid genome in embryonic cells, nurse cells, and salivary gland cells, respectively (Nazimiec and Beckingham, 1986, 1989). Similar results were obtained for Prodiamesa oliuacea: satellites replicate completely in nurse, but not in salivary gland, cells (Zacharias, 1979). P-Heterochromatin in polytene chromosomes of pseudo-nurse cells of Drosophih melanoguster otu mutants is represented in much larger amounts than in larval salivary gland cells of the same mutant. Large new pieces of pericentric p-heterochromatin were found in the X, 3L, and 3R chromosomes of this cell type (Mal’ceva and Zhimulev, 1993; Koryakov and Zhimulev, 1995; Mal’ceva et al., 1995; Koryakov et al., 1996, 1997). The underrepresentation degree of DNA of the 18s and 28s rRNA genes is lower in ovarian nurse than polytene chromosome cells. Accepting the representation of the ribosomal genes in the diploid cells of D. mehnoguster as loo%, the corresponding values are 20% in salivary glands cells and 80-82% (Jacobs-Lorena, 1980; Mohan, 1977; Hammond and Laird, 1985a) in nurse cells. In D. hydei degree of representation of 28s 18s rDNA in the nurse cells may reach 85% (Renkawitz-Pohl, 1978). The DNA of these genes occurs in similar proportions in the ovaries: 135% in Calliphora erythrocephah, 51% in D. hydei, and 47% in Sarcophuga barbata (Renkawitz and Kunz, 1975). In Rhynchosciara angelae, the number of rRNA genes is about 100 in the salivary gland DNA, and it is 220 in the mature ovary tissue (Gambarini and Meneghini, 1972). Both homologous nucleolar organizers replicate in the ovarian nurse cells of Calliphora erythrocephah (Belikoff and Beckingham, 1985). Inconstancy of centromeric heterochromatin amount is not manifest only as incomplete polytenization. Its other manifestations include variation in DNA content along the chromatid and DNA overreplication. Instances of variation in the thickness of centromeric bands or heterochrornatic blocks (Figure 62) are widely known (Table 6). The DNA of heterochromatin occasionally overreplicates. Larvae developing much slower than the rest (3 months instead of the usual 3 weeks) were encountered in a collection of Chironomus melanotus. Material was “released”from the centromeric regions in some salivary gland cells during the fourth larval instar (Figure 63). The “released” heterochromatic bodies (H-bodies) consisted of a dense, rounded centromeric mass surrounded by a concentric circle of condensed chromatin. The H-bodies were not detected in all individuals with extended development, and their number varied in cells. Spectrophotometric measurements in normal larvae of Chironomus
+
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
121
Figure 62. Variation in the size of centromeric heterochromatin in heterozygous individuals of Chirmomus plumosus. Reprinted by permission from Key1 (1965b).
melanotw demonstrated that the proportion of heterochromatin in the chromosomes at this developmental stage varies from 7 to 13%, and this may be the precondition requisite for overreplication (Key1 and Hagele, 1966). Extra droplets of centromeric heterochromatin were described in Chironomw sp. Yul from Yakutian population (Kiknadze et d.,1996). A similar event was detected in the giant foot pad cells of pulvilli of the Sarcophagidae family. Numerous granules are seen even in unsquashed nuclei in Sarcophaga bullata. They lie freely in nucleoplasm, unite into groups, and come into contact with the membrane or many regions of the chromosomes (Whitten, 1964, 1965; Roberts, 1968).The granules have a core composed of DNA, which is surrounded by ribonucleoproteins (staining with Azure B). The diameters of the core vary from 0.445 to 1.389 pm in Tricholioprocta impatiens (B. Roberts, 1975). It is believed that the granules result from (1) overreplication and “budding-off from many chromosomal regions (Whitten, 1965; Roberts et al., 1976); (2) the partly underreplicated sex chromosomes (Trepte, 1976); and (3) amplified ribosomal cistrons (Roberts et al., 1976). The first assumption appears quite unlikely because no homology is found between the DNA granules and the polytene chromosome bands with which they come into contact. When the chromosomes of S. bullata are stained with quinacrine, most granules fluoresce, while the bands contacting the granules
122
1. F. Zhlmulev
Table 6 Variation in Amount of Centromeric Heterochromatin in Polytene Chromosomes in Representatives of the Diptera Order Species
Varying heterochromatin
References
Cecidomyiidae Dasyneura mame@ Chironomidae
Baeotendipes taurica
Ch. kiknadzeae
In 14-16% of larvae the size of centromeric heterochromatin in 2 chromosome AB is increased. Variation in thickness of centromere heterochromatic blocks between two karyotypes 1 and 2
Kiknadze et al. (1993)
Variation in centromeric heterochro. matin in the fourth chromosome
Michailova and Belyanina ( 1984) Key1 (1965b), Michailova and Ficher (1984, 1986), Kiknadze et al. (1987b), Michailova and Petrova (1991), Petrova (1991), Ilyinskaya (1992, 1993) Michailova (1987a) Kiknadze and Siirin (1991, 1993)
Variation in C-heterochromatin Sizes of centromeric blocks in each of the four pairs vary; in no examined nuclei were they increased at the same time; for each of the 9 sibling species blocks of the same size class as detected in Ch. plumosus are characteristic
Related species Chironomus of the pseudochummi complex (Ch. cloacalis, Ch. dupkx, Ch. tepperi) Ch. th. thummi x Ch. th. piger
Kiknadze et al. (1991c, 1996)
Heterozygosity in thickness of pericentric heterochromatin blocks in 25-33% of larvae
Ch. plumosus
Hybrids Ch. plumosus x Ch vancouveri
Kiknadze et al. (1991b)
In the former species, the centromeric block and C-heterochromatin are much thicker
Michailova (1987a)
Considerable interspecific differences in the thickness of the centromeric band
Lentzios and Stocker (1979)
In the chromosomes of the former species, Key1 (1965a,b), Hagele there is considerably more (by 16 (1977a), Gunderina and times) DNA including C-heteroAimanova (1996) chromatin In the former species, DNA replication Key1 and Pelling (1963), in centromeric blocks terminates later Hagele (1970, 1976)
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
123
Table 6 Continued Species
Varying heterochromatin
References
Centrometic blocks of heterochromatin of the former species contain considerably more AT repeats
Schmidt (1980, 1981, 1984), Schmidt et al. (1980,
Ch. sp. Yal Ch. sp. Ya2
-
Glyprotendipes barbipesl G . salinus
Twofold excess of DNA in heterochromatin of the former species in comparison with the latter
Kiknadze et al. (1996) Kiknadze et al. (1996) Michailova (1989b), Michailova and Nikolov
G . gripekoveni
-
-
1982)
(1992) Michailova and Petrova
(1984) Culicidae Anopheles messeae
Differences in quality of pericentric C+/- heterochrornatic blocks in different populations of Tomsk
Sharakhova (1997)
-
Bedo (1975b)
Simuliidae Simulium pictipes
do not. Label was observed also over the majority of granules in in situ hybridization of fast renaturating DNA. Labeling sites in the chromosomes were found only in the centromeric heterochromatin of the regions of the C and E chromosomes (Swift et al., 1978; Samols and Swift, 1979b). There are no granules in the giant foot pad cells on the third day of development; Q’ granules occur only in association with Q’ regions of C and E chromosomes on the fourth day, and Q’ granules can contact with Q- bands of polytene chromosomes on the fifth day (Samols and Swift, 197913). The granules are not digested with endonucleases Hue 111, Alu I, or Hind111 in squash preparations. These enzymes do not digest the 1.663, 1.670, or 1.692 satellites (Bultmann and Mezzanotte, 1987). Presumably, overreplication of repetitive DNA is a specific feature of the nuclei of giant pulvillar cells only, inasmuch as there were no reports concerning granules of this kind in cells of other types, especially bristle-forming cells (Ribbert, 1967; Whitten, 1969). There is information that similar granules occur in Drosophila. Outpocketings of the nuclear membranes, which protrude into the cytoplasm (20-200 calculated outpocketings per nucleus, according to calculations), were detected in salivary gland cells. DNA material of the chromosomes “from reverted cytological repeats” (possibly from intercalary heterochromatin) or terminal chromosome regions is frequently found in the formed blebs (Gay, 1956; Kaufmann and Gay, 1958).
124
1.
F. Zhimulev
Figure 63. Formation of “drops”ofheterochromatic material released from blocks of centrorneric hetrochromatin (a-c), and freely floating (d) in the nuclei of salivary gland cells of Chiraomus melanotus. Reprinted by permission from Key1 and Hagele (1966).
There is no reasonable argument for suggesting that extrachromosomal bodies may be present in the nuclei of the salivary gland cells of the adults of Lathriopygu rnonticola (the lnsecta class, the Collembola) (Cassagnau, 1968). In fact, the X chromosome in this species can be pompon-like with a large a-heterochromatin block in the center. “Extrachromosomal”DNA and the X chromosome are very similar in morphological appearance, as may be judged by the illustrations (Cassagnau, 1974a).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
125
In one case variability of the quantity of the pericentric heterochromatin was correlated with resistance to bacterial infection in Anopheks messeae. Midges with smaller blocks of the heterochromatin in ovarian nurse cell polytene chromosomes appeared to be less sensitive to infection by Bacillus thun‘ngiensis (Timofeyeva et al., 1997).
D. Cytogenetics of (Y- and p-heterochromatin In the mid-I 930s, Muller-then working in Russia-suggested that chromosome regions covering the nucleolar organizer may be genetically organized. Although not confirmed later, his idea was a strong impetus to research along this line (for discussion, see Schalet and Lefevre, 1976). Briefly, his idea was that the inert regions are composed of nongenic material. Few in number in a region, the genes are represented by relatively large amounts of chromosomal material. Inertness of a region is manifested as a considerably higher proportion of substances extrinsic to the genes at metaphase in the inert compared to the “active” regions. The chromosome is not inert and the genes in it are normally located, but they are covered with a “crust” that makes their coiling into a helix at mitosis impossible (Muller and Gershenzon, 1935; Muller and Prokofyeva, 1935; Muller et at., 1937). In contrast, Fujii (1938) did not believe that at least p-heterochromatin is an intrinsically inert region (i.e., heterochromatic). Figures 64 and 65 show models of the correspondence between the heterochromatin of mitotic and polytene chromosomes. In the first model (Figure 64), a-and P-heterochromatin are present in both mitotic and polytene chromosomes. In the second (Figure 65), p-heterochromatin completely replicates and is saturated with genes; 6-heterochromatin and euchromatin are functionally indistinguishable. a-Heterochromatin, with the exception of the nucleolar organizer, does not contain any other genes and it does not polytenize (Miklos and Cotsell, 1990). According to the model of Spradling et al. (1992), a-heterochromatin is formed from a large central block including all satellite DNAs. The more
Euchrornatin
Helerochrornatin
CenlrOmere
Figure 64. Distribution of euchromatin and a-and p-hetrochromatin in the mitotic (top) and polytene (bottom) chromosomes of Drosophila. After Gall (1973).
126
1. F. Zhimulev ouchromrlin
mitotic heterochromatin
mitotic
X -chromosome
x .cI%%me
.-
Figure 65. A scheme of the cytogenetic organization of the transitional region from euchromatin to a-heterochromatin in the X chromosome of D. mekmogaster. After Yamamoto et al. (1990).
distant parts of repeated DNA form p-heterochromatin. P-Heterochromatin is densely populated with complementation groups. In large-scale genetic experiments designed to study the most proximal region of the X chromosome, about 40 deletions and duplications were generated; the majority had both breakpoints proximal to the 19D2-El region at the position of the mehizedlike-mell. T h e numerous mutations mapped using these rearrangements were assigned to 15 complementation groups. Five genes identified in section 20 (Schalet and Lefevre, 1973, 1976) showed the features of p-heterochromatin: unusual banding pattern and richness in mobile elements. Based on data obtained subsequently (Lifschytz, 1978; Miklos et al., 1987; Perrimon et al., 1989; Yamamoto et al., 1990), a cytogenetic map was built for the most proximal region (Figure 66). Thirteen loci were detected in section 20. A new gene, flamenco, that seems to control mobility properties of gypsy was found in the 20A1-3 region (Prud’homme et al., 1995). T h e suppressor offorked, su(f), gene is the most proximal gene on the X chromosome. By using a DNA fragment that encompasses the entire su(f), its cytological location was determined in situ to be in the chromocenter of the polytene chromosome, presumably very close to the a-and P-heterochromatin junction region of the X chromosome (Yamamoto et al., 1990). According to in situ hybridization of DNA of this gene in polytene chromosomes of pseudo-nurse cells, su(f) is located in the banded part
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
127
Figure 66. A cytogenetic map of the proximal region of the X chromosome of D. melanogaster. (a) Regions of the X chromosome. (b) Gene symbols. (c) Symbols and extension of deletions (white bands) and duplications (black bands). After Perrimon et nl. (1989).
of the 20th region, in the 20C (D. E. Koryakov, A. A. Alekseyenko, E. S. Belyaeva and I. F. Zhimulev, 1996, unpublished). It was suggested that there is a distinct boundary between the eu- and heterochromatin of the mitotic chromosome passing in the 20DE region in the
128
I. F. Zhimulev
polytene X chromosome (Schalet and Lefevre, 1976). However, Lifschytz (1978) believes that there is no such readily perceived boundary and that the base of the polytene chromosome is composed of heterochromatic segments of different lengths that alternate with euchromatic segments. Thus far, the region of the polytene chromosome to which the distal end of the mitotic heterochromatin corresponds has not been defined. Changes in the banded part of polytene chromosomes were usually not seen when chromosomal rearrangements with one of the breakpoints in centromeric heterochromatin were used (Hinton, 194210; Holm et al., 1969; Hilliker et al., 1980). Section 20 is the most proximal to a-heterochromatin in the X chromosome of Drosophikz. This banded region differs in morphology from the others: it contains bands that are numerous and small, twisted, and often involved in ectopic pairing. The region frequently breaks off from both the chromocenter and euchromatin (Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1 9 3 7 ~ )However, . the wm4 inversion, the proximal breakpoint of which is in heterochromatin (see Figure 32), does not affect any band in section 20 in the polytene chromosome, and hence it has a break residing in the more proximal heterochromatin (Figure 67). In the sc4sc8 chromosomal rearrangement with almost completely removed heterochromatin, section 20 is also completely retained. However, there is some uncertainty as to whether segment 20 is a polytenized fragment of heterochromatin located between the sc4 breakpoint and its distal part (see Figure 32). In reviewing these data, the conclusion is reached that the bulk ofa-heterochromatin of the X chromosome is not represented by bands of the polytene chromosome (Schalet and Lefevre, 1973, 1976). The proximal breakpoint of the Df(ZR)Z4,mapped in the middle of the het46 block (see Figure 33), is located in the 41C region of the polytene chromosome. This means that the most distal heterochromatic region (the middle of the het46 block) corresponds to the banded part of chromosome 2R. The distal part of the het46 block can give only the banded part of the polytene chromosome distal to the 41C region. In such cases there is no material on the distal end of the mitotic 2R heterochromatin to form P-heterochromatin (Koryakov et al., 1996). Data have clarified the organization of a- and P-heterochromatin. Analysis of the distribution of HeT DNA sequences in pericentric heterochromatin of Drosophila chromosomes demonstrated their interspersion with satellite DNAs. During the formation of the chromacenter, the satellite DNAs aggregate into the a-heterochromatin, leaving the interspersed regions of the other sequences, including HeT DNA, looped out of the blocks of a-heterochromatin to form P-heterochromatin (Traverse and Pardue, 1989). This interpretation is supported by the behavior of the rRNA genes also located within heterochromatin. The rDNA is pulled out from the chromocenter into the nucleolus (Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
129
Figure 67. Morphology of the closest-to-heterochromatin2OAD region of the X chromosome in wm4/+ (a) and sc4sca/y Drosophila (b). Reprinted by permission from Schalet and Lefevre, 1973).
Numerous nonsatellite sequences including genes were found in heterochromatic regions of mitotic chromosomes (Devlin et al., 1990a,b; Dimitri, 1991; Eberl e t al., 1993; Brunner et al., 1994; Biggs e t al., 1994; Zhang and Spradling, 1995). They form “islands”containing middle-repetitive and/or singlecopy sequences in a “sea” of satellite DNAs (Karpen and Spradling, 1990; Karpen, 1994; Le et al., 1995; Zhang and Spradling, 1995). Unique sequences found in autosomal heterochromatin in sites of P-element insertions are represented fully in the salivary gland polytene chromosomes. These sequences dispersed at multiple sires of mitotic heterochromatin may contribute to p-heterochromatin (Zhang and Spradling, 1995). Underrepresentation of heterochromatic DNA is reduced in the pseudo-
130
1. F. Zhimulev
nurse chromosomes (PNC) of the otu mutant of D. melanogaster. As a result, pheterochromatin is represented much more abundantly in the PNC than in salivary glands cells. The additional blocks of heterochromatin (1 and 2) located proximal to the 80AC region in the 3L chromosome and the one block (3) proximal to 8 1F in 3R are clearly discerned in PNC polytene chromosomes (Mal’ceva and Zhimulev, 1993). There are differences in molecular organization between these three additional blocks of p-heterochromatin. The DNA of the 20p1 .4 clone, which makes contact with nuclear lamina, hybridized in situ only with block 3; the Dm 12 clone DNA (mobile element 1360) hybridized in 80AC and blocks 1 and 2 (Sharakhov, 1995). Morphological analysis of chromocenters and cytogenetic mapping of several inversion breakpoints showed that the second chromosome heterochromatin in the PNC is represented by interspersed meshlike (p-heterochromatin) and compacted (a-heterochromatin) material (Figure 68). Mapping the DNA clones and chromosomal rearrangement breakpoints in the mitotic heterochromatin of the second chromosome demonstrated that the polytene chromosome region 4OD-F corresponds to mitotic heterochromatin h35. The phB block is almost completely formed by the h39-h42B regions (RspVDe2). The proximal half of phC is formed by h43-h44 (VDe2-VDe1). This means that in the PNC proximal mitotic heterochromatin of chromosome 2 appears as nonpolytenized a-heterochromatin and polytenized p-heterochromatin. In the SG chromosomes, however, material of the mitotic regions h43-h44 appears not to be polytenized at all. This was confirmed by dot hybridization of the AAGAC satellite DNA clone 35 36
37
38 C
3940 41
42
A
B
43 44
45
46
B
C
Figure 68. The scheme of polytenization of different parts of pericentric heterochromatin in pseudonurse cells of the otu” mutant in Drosophila melanogarter. ( A ) Heterochromatin map. (B and C ) Location of inversion and clones on mitotic (B) and polytene ( C )chromosome maps. phA, phB, and phC, heterochromatic blocks visible in pseudo-nurse cell chromosomes, forming from deep heterochromatin. After Koryakov and Zhimulev (1995).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
131
1.686 (Koryakov and Zhimulev, 1995; Koryakov et al., 1996), which maps to region h44 of 2Rh and to the Y chromosome (Lohe et al., 1993). These experiments performed using XX females showed similar hybridization rates with DNA from the head, ovaries, and PNCs, and almost no hybridization with SG DNA (Koryakov et al., 1996). Whereas in the SG cells one can see a body (bodies) of a-heterochromatin mainly in the middle of the common chromocenter, the chromosome 2 pericentric region in PNC blocks has the appearance of a linear sequence of structures of a-heterochromatin (phA and constrictions) and p-heterochromatin (blocks phB and phC in Figure 68). When taken together, these data suggest a scheme for the organization of a-and P-heterochromatin and the junction between eu- and heterochromatin (Figure 69). Mitotic heterochromatin is represented as an array of segments, tentatively numbered 1 through 8 in Figure 69a. This heterochromatin obviously performs different functions and, accordingly, shows different replicative and other properties in various cell lines. In the SG chromosomes (Figure 69b), regions 1,
Polytene chromosome in SG 1 2
-
3 4 5 6
7
8
Heterochromatin Euchromatin
Mit4lt.k
a chromosome
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
= *
1 2 3 4 5 6
chromosome Polytene in PNC
d
L*
7 8
Figure 69. General scheme of chromocenter organization in Drosophila melanoguster (a) Blocks of pericentric heterochromatin (1-8) in mitotic chromosome. (b) Chromocenter. Fragments of tightly packed heterochromatin (1, 3 , 5, and 7) are underreplicated and collected together, forming a-heterochromatin. Loops of heterochromatin blocks that are less compact are more represented in polytene chromosomes (2,4, and 6 ) . 8, boundary between euchromatin and deep heterochromatin, partly underreplicated. Reprinted by permission from Koryakov et al. (1996h).
132
1. F. Zhimulev
3, 5 and 7 remain underpolytenized and compacted. Segment 8 is a euchromatin-heterochromatin transition zone developing the base of the polytene arm similar to the map regions 40 or 41. The compact and underpolytenized segments associate tightly, forming a-heterochromatin (Figure 69c), while the partly polytenized regions loop out to form diffuse p-heterochromatin, as Traverse and Pardue suggested (1989). In PNC (Figure 69d), certain segments (e.g., 5), that are compacted in SGs replicate to some extent and become diffuse; the same region can be present as a type in one tissue (5 in Figure 69b and 69c) and as p type in another (5 in Figure 69d) (Koryakov et al., 1996, 1997). So, the nature of alphaand beta-heterochromatin is dynamic. In general, heterochromatin passes through more endoreplication rounds in the PNCs than in the SG cells (Mal’ceva and Zhimulev, 1993; Mal’ceva et al., 1995). There is a similar view about heterochromatin in the SG chromosomes (Traverse and Pardye, 1989; Berghella and Dimitri, 1996). However, Traverse and Pardue (1989) as well as Devlin et al. (1990b) thought that a-heterochromatin develops from nonreplicated satellites, while p-heterochromatin is formed from other interspersed DNA sequences. It would be more correct to be concerned with sequences having different replication properties rather than with the satellite versus nonsatellite sequences or, for instance, with differently staining regions. Indeed, in the SG chromosomes of D. melanogaster, certain nonsatellite sequences are not polytenized-for example, the mobile elements mdgl (Shevelyov et al., 1989) and aurora (Shevelyov, 1993) and the heterochromatic copies of the Ste gene (Shevelyov, 1992). In contrast, satellite sequences replicate in polyploid nurse cell nuclei of D. virilis (Gall et al., 1971). Certain P-element insertions into pericentric heterochromatin polytenize at the level of euchromatin (Zhang and Spradling, 1995). It was proposed that heterochromatic state (compaction, underpolytenization of a type, or fragility and partial polytenization of p type) depends not only on nucleotide sequence, but also on functional specificities of different heterochromatin regions (Koryakov et al., 1996, 1997). The model accommodates very well the numerous data on transcriptional activity found in chromocentral DNA. As follows from EM autoradiographic data, a-heterochromatin is transcriptionally inactive, and no RNP particles are identified in it (Lakhotia and Jacob, 1974). Furthermore, ultrastructural study of unsquashed nuclei of the salivary glands of Dosophila revealed RNP granules of two types in P-heterochromatin: (1) particles 25 nm in size, making contacts with chromocentral heterochromatin; and (2) particles 45-50 nm in size, organized in clusters and located near or within the transition zones of P-heterochromatin and the chromosome arms (Lakhotia, 1974b; Lakhotia and Jacob, 1974). Granules of two kinds (approximately 35 nm and from 50 to 60 nm) were identified in the EM studies of the chromocenters of Drosophila when the chromosomes were isolated from the nuclei by microdissection (Mott et d., 1980). ---
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
133
Incorporation of [3H]uridine was observed in the 80AC region of chromosome 3L of larvae and prepupae and also in the 41AF region of chromosome 2R of O-hr prepupae of D. rnelanogaster (Zhimulev and Lychev, 1972; Zhimulev and Belyaeva, 1974, 1975). Both regions are considered as P-heterochromatin. Incorporation of [3H]uridine into 6-heterochromatin was observed in the EM sections of the chromosomes (Lakhotia and Jacob, 1974; Kerkis et al., 1977). The total area of a-heterochromatin on sections of unsquashed nuclei was 26.48 Fm2, and that of P-heterochromatin was 1639.84 FmZ. No silver grains were detected over a-heterochromatin, and 774 silver grains were observed over p-heterochromatin (Lakhotia and Jacob, 1974). Localization of antibodies on DNA-RNA hybrids supports the notion that P-heterochromatin is transcriptionally active. They tightly bind in segment 40 of chromosome 2L and in 41AB of chromosome 2R (Vlassovaet at., 1984,1985). In in situ hybridization of labeled poly(A)+ RNA isolated from a cell culture of Drosophila, a heavily labeling site, besides the numerous regions in the euchromatic part of the chromosomes as well as regions 41AF, 40AF, 81F, and 19E-20F, were found to be P-heterochromatin (Spradling et al., 1975; Gvozdev et al., 1980a,b). A genomic DNA clone of Drosoghila, 4.4 kb in size and mapped to the 80C region, encodes poly(A)+ RNA of 1.4 kb; it is abundantly represented in cytoplasm (0.6% in clusters of cells and embryonic cells). The RNA encodes a protein with a molecular mass of 16 kDa (Biessmann et al., 1981). The GATA repeat lying in the 19F-20AB region is also transcribed (Singh et al., 1984). The Mts40 gene expressed in primary spermatocytes is located in region 40C a t the base of chromosome 2L, very close to or within P-heterochromatin, or at the junction between eu- and p-heterochromatin (Russell and Kaiser, 1994). Expression was also found for the l(l)B214 locus located in the immediate vicinity of p-heterochromatin of the X chromosome (19Fl-2 region) (Russell et al., 1992). In insects, in which chromocenters are not formed and heterochromatin polytenizes completely (e.g., in sciarids), the nucleolar organizer also lie in the centromeric blocks of heterochromatin (see Section IV,A). In Rhynchosciara a n g e h , the largest blocks of heterochromatin lie in the centromeric regions of chromosomes B, C, and X. After in witro incubation of the salivary glands for several hours to 12 days, puffs arise in 3-15% of cells (depending on larval age) in the heterochromatin of chromosomes A, B, and X (Simoes et al., 1974; Simoes and Cestari, 1982). Puffs similar in morphology and location are induced in cells infected with viruses and microsporidia (Diaz et al., 1969). These so-called heterochromatic puffs are also induced by heat shock when culturing conditions are poor (temperature or medium pH change) (Simoes et al., 1969). The induced puffs intensely incorporate [)H]uridine (Simoes and Cestari, 1982). [3H]uridine is also intensively incorporated into the kinetochore regions
134
I. F. Zhimulev
of the nurse cell chromosomes of Culliphoru erythrocephala (Ribbert, 1979). Nazimiec and Beckingham (1986, 1989) demonstrated that the 3B55 satellite sequence is transcribed in nurse cells but not in 9- to 10-hr embryos in this species. In Cerutitis cupitata, heterochromatic meshwork representing the X chromosome in prepupal orbital trichogen and larval salivary gland cells is surrounded by 25- to 30-nm RNP granules. Similar granules were found around the spherical, compact Y chromosome of this species (Semeshin et al., 1995). As for replication organization in centromeric heterochromatin, it may be noted that, without exception, both centromeric heterochromatin in species lacking the chromocenter and chromocentral p-heterochromatin are late replicating (Pavan, 1959; Key1 and Pelling, 1963; Gabrusewycz-Garcia, 1964; Tulchin et ul., 1967; Hagele, 1970; Gubenko, 1974a,b, 1976a; Mukherjee et al., 1977; Sokoloff, 1977; Stocker et al., 1978; Zacharias, 1979; Steinemann, 1981; Zhimulev et al., 1989a,b; Bolshakov and Zhimulev, 1990). In the polytene chromosomes of bean haustorium (Pheolus coccineus), the chromocenter is not formed, but the chromosomes differ in denser a- and more loosely compacted P-heterochromatin. At the beginning of the S phase, euchromatin replicates first, then P-heterochromatin, and a-heterochromatin replicates last (Brady and Clutter, 1974).
VII. INTERCALARY HETEROCHROMATIN Bridges encountered difficulties in assigning the proximal part of chromosome 2L on the cytological map of polytene chromosomeof Drosophla. The bands of the 32F-33C region were connected with the those of the 34F-35C region by fibers, obscuring the morphology of the chromosomes. There were also a number of ambiguities in mapping the 37F-38A and 39CE regions (Bridges, 1935c, 1936; Morgan et d., 1937). At the distal (telomeric) end of the fourth microchromosome, a region was identified attracted to the proximal (centromeric) region of the same chromosome with the result that the chromosome bent like a horseshoe (Bridges, 193513). In the same year, pairing contacts were detected in D. psewloobscura and Ch. thummi (Bauer, 1935; Tan, 1935).Soon thereafter, it became clear that such regions are present at the ends of the chromosomes in many species and that they can be involved in pairing with the terminal regions of other chromosomes; with the internal sites, lying in different regions of polytene chromosomes; and with pericentromeric heterochromatin (Bauer, 1936a; Tinyakov, 1936;Frolova, 1936b; Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya,193713,1938,1939d).Pairing between the nonhomologous regions of the chromosomes was called ectopic (Slizynski, 1945). In their studies of the distribution of the ends of radiation-induced chromosomal rearrangements, Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya and Khvostova ( 1939) and, independently, Kaufmann ( 1939) demonstrated that the rearrangements occur much more frequently in some regions than others. The localizations of the “hot
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
135
spots” of chromosomal rearrangements in ectopic pairing regions were coincident to a large extent (Slizynski, 1945). By analogy with pericentromericheterochromatin, where chromosomal rearrangements are frequent, Kauhann (1939) suggested that higher fragility of the regions of ectopic contacts is due to the presence of heterochromatin intercalated in euchromatin (i.e., intercalary heterochromatin). Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya(193713) suggested that these regions be called “inert”; however, this term did not take root. In support of the existence of intercalary heterochromatin was the thenwidespread notion that ectopic pairing conforms to the rule “similar with similar” (Prokofyeva-Belgovskaya, 1941), and that the regions making contacts with pericentromeric heterochromatin may be heterochromatic, although intercalary. It became further evident that the notion of intercalary heterochromatin (IH) covers a group of chromosome regions with a large set of properties distinguishing them from the neighboring so-called euchromatic regions and often from one another. In addition to the mentioned ectopic pairing and fragility arising during the formation of rearrangements in these regions, other findings included, as a rule, high compaction level of chromatin, late termination of DNA replication during the S phase, and high frequencies of mechanical breaks. In some cases, these regions stained differently with specific dyes. Discussion of the real existence of IH continued unabated. While in extensive reviews facts have been gleaned in favor of the presence of the IH in chromosomes (Hannah, 1951; Beermann, 1962; Kaufmann and Iddles, 1963; Ananiev et al., 1978; Gvozdev, 1981a,b; Zhimulev et al., 1981, 1982, 1989a,b), in other papers it was in strong doubt. It is Back’s (1976, p. 32) opinion that “the hypothetic intercalary heterochromatin (Hannah, 1951) cannot be demonstrated cytologically. Its existence is deduced from the increased tendency toward breaking of certain chromosome regions of Drosophila.” Spofford (1976) called attenion to the fact that the formation frequency of rearrangements correlates with DNA amount in a region; rearrangements are formed in the large bands. Other authors believe that the ectopic pairing region cannot be called heterochromatic; these regions do not appear as such in the mitotic chromosomes, they are incapable of inducing genetic inactivation resulting from position effect variegation, and satellite DNAs are not detected in them (Hilliker et al., 1980; Hilliker and Sharp, 1988; Miklos and Cotsell, 1990; Gatti and Pimpinelli, 1992). It is Laird’s view (Laird et al., 1987a,b; Laird, 1989) that DNA sequences possessing properties of the IH are underrepresented in polytene chromosomes, they presumably have no other features of centromeric heterochromatin. At least a part of the IH regions represent normal euchromatic DNA the replication cycle of which is delayed in some cell types. For this reason, the new term “fragile sites” can indeed be useful (Laird, 1989). A number of erroneous hypotheses have been proposed to explain the relation of the IH to some of the structural-functional features of polytene chromosomes. Criticism of these hypotheses has also made more vulnerable the whole
136
1. F. Zhimulev
concept of the IH. Thus Bridges (1935c, 1936) suggested that ectopic pairing occurs between identical band sets or cytological repeats, as they are frequently called. Subsequently, various authors have discussed these “repeats” as a diagnostic feature of the IH (Hannah, 1951; Kaufmann and Iddles, 1963; Ananiev et al., 1978, 1979a; Gvozdev, 1981a,b). However, it became still further evident that cytological repeats in the regions Bridges has indicated are nonexistent, being mostly artifacts (for discussion, see Zhimulev, 199213). Likewise, no support was provided for Hannah’s (1951) suggestion that the Minute genes map to heterochromatic regions (see Section VII,C,8). Section VII presents a description of the organizational features of intercalary heterochromatin of various types, and it is also concerned with controversial interpretations.
A. Intercalary a-heterochromatin 1. Dipteran insects a. Phryne cincta In an alpine population of Phryne cincta, individuals were encountered whose male and female X chromosomes had several (one to three) additional blocks of heterochromatin (see a-1, 01-2, and a.3 in Figure 70), appearing as heavily staining heterochromatic vacuolar masses intercalated in the euchromatic parts of the chromosome. Only two a-blocks were sufficient for producing a twofold elongation of the X chromosomes (X1 in Figure 70) as compared to the normal (Xs). Individuals of the most various genotypes (Xl/Xl, Xl/Xs, and Xs/Xs) occur in the alpine population, while there were only Xs/Xs individuals in the Berlin population. Because of incomplete polytenization of intercalary a-heterochromatin in polytene chromosomes, there was almost no difference in X chromosome length. Several small a-blocks were localized in the autosomes (Wolf and Struck, 1960; Wolf, 1963, 1970; Wolf and Wolf, 1969; Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973, 1976). Breaks and morphology of blocks of heterochromatin can vary from exceptionally large to very small. The material can stretch out to form threads or bulky protuberances, which occasionally break loose from the block, freely wandering out of the nucleus (“a-migration”; Wolf, 1970; Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973). Loss of integrity of a-blocks, presumably due to incomplete polytenization, leads to the fragmentation of polytene chromosomes whose frequency correlates with change in temperature: 84% of the chromosomes remained intact at 18”C,and 86% fragmented at 2°C (Wolf, 1970; Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973). Fragmentation is tissue specific: the number of unfragmented X chromosomes was twice as great in the midgut as in salivary glands in the same individuals (Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973).No differences in the frequenciesof fragmented chromosomes were found between males hemizygous for the X chromosome and homozygous females, although a-blocks appear bulkier in males (Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973).
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
137
Figure 70. Intercalary a-heterochromatin in the polytene chromosomes of the salivary glands ( a x , f-h) and mitotic (d and e ) chromosomes in Phryne cincta. a-1, a-2, a-3, Blocks of heterochromatin; arrows indicate material extruded from a-blocks (f and g) or a break along the a-block region (0. (d and e ) Numbers designate chromosomes; the X chromosomes are depicted black. After Wolf and Sokoloff (1973).
In addition to compact state, blocks of intercalary a-heterochromatin show features of heterochromatin, such as ectopic pairing (Wolf and Sokoloff, 1973, 1976; Sokoloff, 1977). The considerable decrease in the amount of a-heterochromatin in polytene compared to mitotic chromosomes, and their incorporation of [3H]thymidine, indicate that they are polytenized, but not completely (Sokoloff, 1977). Blocks of intercalary heterochromatin have a strong effect on crossing over. XI/Xs females with autosomes of the wild type were crossed to Xs males homozygous for four inversions in the second and third chromosomes (2a2b/2a2band 3a3b/3a3b). The progeny were heterozygous for these inversions (SS/2a2b, SS/3a3b). Some in-
138
I. F. Zhimulev
Figure 70. Continued
dividuals were homozygous and some heterozygous for Xs/Xs. Females of these types were mated to males without inversions. Evidence for crossing over was the appearance of individuals having only a single inversion on the chromosome. Crossovers for the second chromosome were recovered at a frequency of 2% and those for the third chromosome at 0% among progeny of Xs/Xs females. The respective values were 42% and 13%for progeny of Xl/Xs females (Wolf, 1963, 1970). No incorporationof PHIuridine into a-blockswas detected (Sokoloff,1977).
b. Drosophila heretensis (littoralis) Polymorphism for the heterochromatin region H-2 in the short arm of the second chromosome was detected in some populations of this species (Mitrofanov and Poleuktova, 1982).The majority of individuals (68.9%) of the population of the Mirniy settlement lacks the block; the remaining individuals are homozygous (14.3%) or heterozygous (16.8%). In the authors’ view this region is similar in
Polytene Chromosomes, Heterochromatin, and Position Effect Variegation
139
staining and structure to the region of p-heterochromatin (Mitrofanov and Poluektova, 1982), although its general compacted state and deep staining allow it to be referred to as a-heterochromatin. Individuals without a block predominate in natural conditions, however, the frequency of the block is severalfold higher in laboratory conditions. Presumably, this is due to the elimination of unfavorable effects of the laboratory conditions (Poluektovaetd.,1984).It is believed that the presence of blocks of heterochromatin can modify the expression of the activities of certain genes (Korochkin et d., 1983). a-NM4 and a-Ltl 1 DNA clones most strongly hybridize in situ with the DNA of chromocenters, dispersely along chromosome length, and they intensely label the previously mentioned block of heterochromatin (Sayanova et al., 1987).
c. Some species of Chironomus “Dark knobs” are seen in ea