ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 43
CONTRIBUTORS TO
THISVOLUME
G. Donelli L. Fiermans John M. H...
83 downloads
979 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 43
CONTRIBUTORS TO
THISVOLUME
G. Donelli L. Fiermans John M. Houston John Kelly L. Paoletti Robert K. Swank J. Vennik Kirby G. Vosburgh
Advances in
Electronics and Electron Physics EDITEDBY L. MARTON Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. Assistant Editor
CLAIRE MARTON EDITORIAL BOARD E. R. Piore T. E. Allibone M. Ponte H. B. G. Casimir A. Rose W. G. Dow L. P. Smith A. 0.C. Nier F. K. Willenbrock
VOLUME 43
1977
ACADEMIC PRESS New York San Francisco London A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT 0 1977, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN A N Y FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDINQ, O R ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRlTlNQ FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue,New York. New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London NWI
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG
CARD
NUMBER: 49-7504
ISBN 0-12-014643-6 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME43 . . . . . FOREWORD . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
vii
ix
Electron Micrograph Analysis by Optical Transforms G . DONELLI A N D L. PAOLEITI I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Image Formation in an Electron Microscope . . I11. Optical Processing of Electron Microscopic Data IV. Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 2 12 23 40
Recent Advwes in Electron Beam Addreesed Memories JOHNKELLY
.
I Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Background . . . . . . . . . . . 111. StorageMedia . . . . . . . . . . IV. Surface Charge Storage . . . . . . V. Bulk Charge Storage . . . . . . . VI. Alternative Storage Media . . . . . VII. Electron-Optical Systems . . . . . VIII. Beam Memory Systems . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
43
44
. . . . .
51 56 81
99 112 129 135
Electron Beam as Analytical Tods in Surface Research: LEED and AES L. FIERMANS AND J. VENNIK I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Low Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED) . I11 Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
139 141 164 198
X-Ray Image Intensifiers KIRBYG . VOSBURGH.ROBERTK. SWANK. AND JOHNM . HOUSTON I . Introduction . . . I1. Input Phosphors . 111. Electron Optics . . IV. Output Phosphors . V XRII Performance .
.
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
205
207 216 226 231
vi
CONTENTS
VI . FutureTrends
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Selected Bibliography . References . . . . .
AUTHOR INWX SUBJECT INDEX
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
238 242 243 245 253
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 43 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
G. DONELLI, Physics Laboratory, Istituto Superiore di Sanita, Rome, Italy (1)
L. FIERMANS, Laboratorium voor Kristallografie en Studie van de Vaste Stof, Rijksuniversiteit Gent, Gent, Belgium (139) JOHNM. HOUSTON, Corporate Research and Development, General Electric Company, Schenectady, New York (205) JOHNKELLY,* Stanford Research Institute, Menlo Park, California (43)
L. PAOLEITI,Physics Laboratory, Istituto Superiore di Sanita, Rome, Italy (1) ROBERTK.SWANK, Corporate Research and Development, General Electric Company, Schenectady, New York (205) J. VENNIK, Laboratorium voor Kristallografie en Studie van de Vaste Stof, Rijksuniversiteit Gent, Gent, Belgium (139) KIRBYG. VOSBURGH, Corporate Research and Development, General Electric Company, Schenectady, New York (205)
* Present address: HP Laboratories, Hewlett-Packard Company, 1501 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, California, 94304. vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank THIS PAGE INTENTIOALLY LEFT BLANK .
FOREWORD Due to the entirely different physical processes governing the image formation in light and electron microscopes, new methods are needed for the interpretation of electron micrographs. G. Donelli and L. Paoletti review the application of optical transforms to their analysis. They discuss the numerous applications of optical processing, such as contrast transfer functions, defects of the images, periodical structure analysis, three-dimensional reconstruction, and optical spatial filtering. In the past we have published only one review on memory devices [in Volume 21 (1965)l.That review was limited to magnetic core technology. J. Kelly presents in this volume a review of electron beam addressed memories. These latter may have originated earlier than the magnetic core memories but were supplanted for a while by the magnetic ones. The trend has now reversed and electron beam addressed memories have taken a great step forward. The many aspects and devices are described in detail. L. Fiermans and J. Vennik examine the use of electron beams as analytical tools, in particular in low-energy electron diffraction and in Auger electron spectroscopy. The emphasis is on the practical applications of LEED and AES, such as the interpretation of a LEED pattern or the analysis of an Auger spectrum. Whereas ample space was devoted in earlier volumes to image intensifiers for visible infrared and ultraviolet light, practically nothing was said about X-ray image intensifiers. This gap is now filled by the review written by K. G. Vosburgh, R. K. Swank, and J. M. Houston. They discuss the components of such devices, by breaking them down to input phosphors, electron optics, and output phosphors. The performance of one particular design is analyzed and predictions are offered for the future. Following a long established practice we would like to list here the reviews, with their authors, which we expect to publish in future volumes: Time Measurements on Radiation Detector Signals In Situ Electron Microscopy of Thin Films Electron Bombardment Semiconductor Devices
Atomic Photoelectron Spectroscopy. I1 Light-Emitting Devices. 11: Applications ix
S. Cova A. Barna, P. B. Barna, J. P. Pocza and I. Pozsgai D. J. Bates, R. Knight and S. Spinella S. T. Manson H. F. Matarl:
X
FOREWORD
Nonlinear Atomic Processes Righ Injection in a Two-Dimensional Transistor Semiconductor Microwave Power Devices. I1 Basic Concepts of Minicomputers Physics of Ion Beams from a Discharge Source Physics of Ion Source Discharges Auger Electron Spectroscopy High Power Electron Beams as Power Tools Terminology and Claskification of Particle Beams On Teaching of Electronics Wave Propagation and Instability in Thin Film Semiconductor Structures The Gunn-Hilson Effect A Review of Applications of Superconductivity Minicomputer Technology Digital Filters Physical Electronics and Modeling of MOS Devices Measurement and Application of Precise Time Thin Film Electronics Technology Characterization of MOSFETs Operating in Weak Inversion Electron Impact Processes Sonar Microchannel Electron Multipliers The Negative Hydrogen Ion Electron Attachment and Detachment Noise in Solid State Devices Radar Signal Processing Electron Beam Controlled Lasers Amorphous Semiconductors Electron Beams in Microfabrication. I and I1 Photoacoustic Spectroscopy Design Automation of Digital Systems. I and I1
J. Bakos W. L. Engl S.Teszner and J. L. Teszner L. Kusak G. Gautherin and C. Lejeune G. Gautherin and C. Lejeune N. C. Macdonald and P. W. Palm berg B. W. Schumacher 8. W. Schumacher and J. H. Fink H. E. Bergeson and G. Cassidy A. A. Barybin M. P. Shaw W. B. Fowler C. W. Rose S. A. White J. N. Churchill, T. W. Collins, and F. E. Holmstrom G. M. R. Winkler T. P. Brody R. J. Van Overstraeten
S. Chung F. N. Spiess R. F. Potter R. Geballe R. S. Berry E. R. Chenette and A. van der Ziel Merrill I. Skolnik Charles Cason H. Scher and G. Pfister P. R. Thornton A. Rosencwaig W. G. Magnuson and Robert J. Smith
Supplementary Volumes:
Sequency Theory Computer Techniques for Image Processing in Electron Microscopy High Voltage and High Power Applications of Thyristors
H. F. Harmuth W. G. Saxton G. Karady
We wish to express our best thanks to the many friends whose help makes it possible to produce these volumes. As in the past we would be very grateful for further advice and constructive criticism.
L. MARTON C. MARTON
ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 43
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Electron Micrograph Analysis by Optical Transforms G. DONELLI
AND
L. PAOLETTI
Physics Laboratory Istituto Superiore di Sanita Rome, Italy
.........................................................
1
D. Three-Dimensional Reconstruction ............................................ E. Optical Spatial Filtering ............... ......
29
I. Introduction.
B. Defects of Electron Im
References..
......................................................................
35 40
I. INTRODUCTION An electron micrograph, because of the great depth of field of an electron microscope, is the projection on the image plane of the three-dimensional structure of the specimen. It consequently contains all of the information relative to the various levels of the specimen itself. In the case of a specimen for which a low resolution is required, the interpretation of the electron micrograph, i.e., the extraction of structural information relative to the specimen, is a fairly easy operation which generally leads to correct results even when the electron images are considered as common photographic images. The analysis of high resolution micrographs, on the other hand, is extremely complex and subject to gross misinterpretation. In this case, to trace back to a correct structural definition of the specimen based on the image contrast distribution it must be remembered that the image is due to different contrast formation processes-scattering contrast, phase contrast, and amplitude contrast-which depend critically on the specimen observed and on the working conditions. This problem can be solved by using two alternative ways of describing 1
2
G. DONELLI AND
L. PAOLETTI
contrast formation: the method of weak object of phase and amplitude or the incoherent method. It must be emphasized, however, that we are dealing with approximate methods. Furthermore, the theory of the formation of contrast in neither one nor the other approximation leads to a simple linear relationship between the structure of the specimen (mass thickness or projected density) and the image contrast. Another factor that makes interpretation of high resolution images of biological specimens particularly difficult is that such specimens are usually made up of light atoms. These are capable of producing only an extremely low contrast in the image, and staining or shadowing techniques must be used to produce enough contrast for observation. It is generally difficult to determine the exact interaction of the stain and the specimen (degree of penetration of the stain into the structure, degree of symmetry and uniformity with which different sides of the specimen have been stained) and thus to decode the structural information provided by the electron image without a “staining theory” which allows us to know exactly how the stain “ changes ” the specimen. In the past ten years a number of techniques for analysis of high resolution micrographs have been proposed and widely used; in particular, methods of Fourier analysis of images have been developed. Among the methods for obtaining the Fourier transform (Bracewell, 1965) of an electron micrograph we would like to discuss the optical transform technique (Taylor and Lipson, 1964; Markham, 1968; Klug, 1971; Horne and Markham, 1972; Donelli and Paoletti, 1972; Lipson, 1972). Applied for the first time by Klug and Berger (1964) as a method of micrograph analysis of periodical structures, this technique turns out to be extremely useful because of its ease and rapidity. However, this method has the disadvantage that the quantity that can be effectively recorded and’measured is the square modulus of the transform, and thus any information relative to the phase of the spatial frequencies present in the transform itself is lost. IN AN ELECTRON MICROSCOPE 11. IMAGE FORMATION
In a transmission electron microscope, information concerning the structure of the specimen is transferred to the electron beam by means of the interaction between the specimen and the beam itself (Cosslett, 1965; Glick, 1965; Lenz, 1965; Marton, 1965; Scherzer, 1965; Zeitler, 1965, 1968; Hawkes, 1973). The signal carrying the information (the transmitted beam) is then transferred by the electron-optical channel to the image plane. In this transfer, the signal is modified by the characteristics of the electron-optical channel, and this modified signal then becomes available on the image plane in the form of a distribution of intensity.
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
3
The problem of interpreting an electron micrograph thus consists in deducing information about the structure of a given specimen based on the distribution of intensity available on the image plane, in addition to adequate knowledge of details concerning the specimen-beam interaction. In practice, this problem can be resolved (Hall, 1953; Heidenreich, 1964; Burge, 1973; Misell, 1973) by reducing the specimen-beam interaction process to one of the following approximations: a. The “scattering contrast” or “intensity absorption” approximation (Crick and Misell, 1971), which starts from the hypothesis that incoherent scattering phenomena are prevalent: the production of the image contrast is then described using an exponential absorption law. b. The approximation of the weak object of phase and amplitude (Lenz, 1970; Hanszen, 1971), in which coherent scattering phenomena are considered to be prevalent: the production of the contrast is then described using a small variation of the amplitude and phase of the incident electron wave. A . Transfer Function of an Electron-Optical Channel
1. Scattering Contrast Images The structure of the specimen is represented by the variation of its mass thickness w = pt, where p is the density and t the thickness of the specimen itself. Each element of the specimen (object point) transmits a fraction j , of within the objective lens the incident beam intensity j , equal to j, = j , ,-‘Iw aperture, where c, is the total cross section for scattering outside of the objective lens. The distribution of intensity on the image plane is obtained by summing the intensities transmitted from all of the object points. The approximtion is essentially correct if it is assumed that the incident beam scattering due to the specimen gives an incoherent transmitted beam. Because of the great depth of field of an electron microscope, the specimen can be described by a bidimensional function o(xo, y o ) = o(ro), defined as projected density, expressed in atoms per unit area. For a specimen having an atomic weight A, the image produced by an ideal electron-optical system will be, at a magnification M , given by
with N being Avogadro’s number. In reality, because of aberrations of the objective lens and other instrumental factors, such as instability in high voltage and in the excitation
4
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
current of the lenses, the observed imageji is given rather by
in which the convolution function S(ri)represents the intensity distribution which, on the image plane, corresponds to an object point. The function S(ri)can be calculated when the angle and energy distribution of each of the three components, elastic, inelastic, and transmitted, of the electron beam scattered by the specimen are known (Crick and Misell, 1971) and it is taken into account that electrons scattered with an angle 3 and with an energy spreading equal to AU/U are focused on the image plane at a distance r from the ideal gaussian point given by r = M ( C , 9’
+ C, 9 AUIU)
(3) with C, being the coefficient of spherical aberration and C, the coefficient of chromatic aberration of the objective lens (Heidenreich, 1964). More strictly, the image must be considered as the sum of three integrals such as that in Eq. (2), corresponding to the three components of the scattered beam, with the convolution function in each integral appropriate to the relative component. Such functions evidently will then also depend on the specimen, in addition to the characteristics of the electronoptical system, and in particular on the thickness and atomic number of the specimen. In the less strict description of using only the integral (2), with the convolution function Smax(ri)corresponding to the “disk of confusion whose radius is obtained assuming, in Eq. (3), the angular semiaperture of the objective in place of 3 and with the more probable fraction ofenergy lost by the inelastic electrons in place of AU/U, the contrast Ci(ri)on the image will turn out to be ”
where (ji) indicates the average value of the intensity on the image plane, c, indicates the total cross section for elastic and inelastic scattering outside the objective, and A a indicates the variations of the projected density of the specimen from the average. The operations of the electron-optical system can be better described by the Fourier transform of Eq. (4). In this case we have A
3[Ci(ri)]= - - c, Tm,,(v)S N
in which Tma.(vx, \I,.) = Tmax(v) = T[Smax(ri)].
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
5
If the contrast transfer function TmaX(v) were constant for all of the spatial frequency values, the electron microscope would be an ideal electron-optical in Eq. (4) is differsystem; in practice, since the convolution function Smax(ri) ent from zero on the “disk of confusion” having a finite radius rmpx,the acts as a low-pass filter, attenuating the high transfer function Tmax(v) frequencies and transferring, with negligible contrast, the frequency band that falls beyond ,v N 1/rmax. The experimental conditions under which the approximation of the scattering contrast can be considered good, i.e., the conditions in which inelastic scattering is the dominant process, correspond to the observation of relatively thick amorphous objects (thickness > 500 A with an incident beam energy between 20 and 100 keV) with variations in their thickness of small magnitude with respect to the average thickness (Burge, 1973). 2 . Phase Contrast Images The interaction between the incident electron wave Yo(xo,y o , z o ) = Yo(ro)and the specimen is described as a small phase shift qo(ro)and a small attenuation of the incident wave amplitude Eo(ro). The wave function immediately following interaction with the specimen can thus be written ’Y,(ro) = 1 + ivo(r0) - co(r0)
(6)
where qo 4 272 and E~ 4 1 (weak object of phase and amplitude). The functions qo and c0 depend on the structure of the specimen. Assuming that qo is always 4 272 and neglecting the phase shift due to the thickness f of the specimen, the phase shift qo of Yo(ro) after passing through the specimen can be written proportionally (Lenz, 1970) to the projection of the potential distribution V ( x o , y o , z o ) of the specimen in the zo direction of the wave propagation:
where h is Planck’s constant and m, e, 1,are respectively mass, charge, and wavelength of the beam electrons. The potential distribution V(ro) can be written, at least in the tight binding approximation, V ( x o , y o , zo)
=
<(XI,
y’, z’) d(xo - x’, yo - y‘, zo - z‘) dx‘ dy’ dz‘
(8)
where d ( x o , y o , zo) is the density in atoms per unit of volume of the y’, z’) is the atomic potential. From specimen at the point ro and <(XI,
6
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
Eq. (8) it is seen that Eq. (7) can be written
.I‘
qo(ro)= - wa(r’)a(ro - r’) dr’
(9)
where a(r0)is the density of the specimen projected in the direction of the zo axis and o,(r’) is the atomic potential projected in the same direction and normalized by the constant 2nrneA/hz. The effect of scattering on the incident beam can be represented by a complex potential (Yoshioka, 1957) V = V + iV’in which the real part V is that considered in Eqs. (7) and (8) and represents elastic scattering; the imaginary component iV‘ represents the effect of absorption and can be calculated from inelastic effects such as the excitation of phonons (Radi, 1970), plasmons (Radi, 1970), and internal electrons (Whelan, 1965). As for Eq. (8), it can be written Vi(ro) = J Va(r‘) d(ro - r’) dr’, having introduced an “imaginary atomic potential” iVi ; we then have Eo(ro)=
-[ w;(r’)a(r, - r’) dr’
(10)
the symbols having the same meanings as in Eq: (9). If Y,(ro)given by Eq. (6) is the wave function after interaction with the specimen, the diffracted wave function on the second focal plane of the objective will be = 6(v)
+ iA(v) - E(v)
(11) where A(v) and E(v) are respectively the Fourier transforms of qo and c0 and the delta function represents the unscattered beam. Considering Eqs. (9) and (10) we then have Yd(V)
+
Yd(v)= 6(v) - iF[wa(ro)] * F[o(ro)] F[o:(r,)] * F[a(ro)] (12) The effect of the electron-optical channel (aberrations, defocusing, objective aperture) can be described (Born and Wolf, 1959; Lenz, 1970; Hanszen, 1971) using the transfer function T,,(v) of the microscope. The wave function on the second focal plane is then modified to: (13)
W V ) =~ d ( V ) L ( V )
where (Lenz, 1970; Hanszen, 1971):
M with (2a/A)W(v)representing the phase shift due to aberrations; B(v) = 1 on the objective aperture and B(v) = 0 elsewhere. W(v), in the presence of spherical aberration C,, of defocusing A$ and of astigmatism C, , can be written (Born and Wolf, 1959; Lenz, 1970)
cs A4v4 W ( v )= 4
Af A 2 V Z - Ca +2 2
-
- v;)
(15)
7
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
In conclusion, for the modified wave function on the diffraction plane: %(v)
=
T,m(v)'(v) + iT,m(V)A(v)- T,m(v)E(v)
and for the wave function ",(Ti)
Yi(ri)= Y [ Y i ( v ) = ] <,(O) 1 =M
+ iF[T,(v)
*
on the image plane,
+ i F [ T m ( v ) . A(v)]- Y [ x , ( v ) - ~ ( v ) ] A(v)]- F [ T m ( v )E(v)] .
(17)
where it is held that, for the amplitude T,,(O) of the background,
1 T,,(v)G(v)exp [ -i2n (v .
s)]
dv = T,,(O)
1
=-
M
The intensity on the image plane will be given byj,(r,) = [Yi(ri)I2. Considering that (ji) = 1/M2 and neglecting second-order terms, the contrast on the image will be C,(r,) = [lYi(ri)12- 1 / M 2 ] / ( 1 / M 2 ) = i M { F [ T , ( V ) . A(v)]- S * [ T , ( V ) . A(v)]} - M { ~ [ T , ( V ) E ( V ) I+ s * [ T , ( v ) E ( v ) ] )
= iMF[Tm(v)A(v) - Tzm(-v)A*( - v ) ]
- MF[T,,(v)E(v)
+ T:, ( - v)E*(- v ) ]
(19)
Since A(v) = A( -v)* and E(v) = E( -v)*, assuming that the transfer function has cylindrical symmetry around the optical axis, T,,(v) = T,,( - v ) , and considering Eq. (14), Eq. (19)can be finally rewritten
(20)
From Eq. (20) we can obtain a simple relationship between the contrast transform and the specimen transform: F[Ci(ri)] = A(v)2 sin
B(v) - E(v)2 cos
8
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
and considering Eqs. (9) and (lo), y[Ci(ri)] = -2 sin
r: r:
-
+ 2 cos
1 1
W(v) B(v)s[wa(r,)]s[o(r,)]
-
W(v) B ( v ) . ~ [ ~ ~ ( r , ) ] ~ [ o ( r , ) ]
In conclusion, the image transform is simply the specimen transform multiplied by a transfer function T(v) given by
+ T[oi,(ro)] cos (23) The function T(v) is essentially determined by the two terms sin[(2n/A)W(v)] and cos[(2n/A)W(v)] since both .T[w,] and F[oa]are slowly varying functions of v (Eisenhandler and Siegel, 1966; Burge, 1973). Assuming that the astigmatism is correct, sin[(2n/l)W(v)] and cos[(2lt/A)W(v)] have the shape shown in Figs. 1 and 2. As can be seen, the amplitude contrast (cos[(2n/A)W(v)]) will contribute significantly only at low resolutions, while the phase contrast (sin[(2n/A)W(v)])will be the main mechanism for the production of contrast at high and medium resolutions.
004
aoe
012
016
020
024
02e
SPATIAL FREQUENCIES
032
036 v ( 8-l)
FIG. 1. The contrast transfer function (CTF) in the case ofa weak phase object for defocus values A f = 0 and Af = -800 A. Electron energy = 100 keV; spherical aberration coefficient = 1.6 mm.
9
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
c
SPATIAL FREQUENCIES
2 h
v &’I
FIG.2. The contrast transfer function (CTF) in the case of a weak amplitude object for defocus values Af = 0 and Af= -800 A. Electron energy = 100 keV; spherical aberration coefficient = 1.6 m m .
In order to valuate the relative contribution of phase and amplitude contrast to the final image we can rewrite T ( v ) in the form T ( v ) = 2 B ( v ) . F [ ~ o ~ ( r ,, ) ]s~i n p W ( v ) ] + P ( v ) cos
I
W ( v ) ] ) (24)
where P ( v ) now represents the “percentage” of amplitude contrast in relation to the total contrast. Some experimental data indicate that P ( v ) should have a value of about 0.1 for light elements and reach values of about 0.4 for the heavier atoms (Erickson and Klug, 1971). The experimental conditions under which the approximation of the weak object of phase and amplitude can be considered satisfactory correspond to those conditions in which the incoherent scattering processes are negligible and the image is formed essentially by the elastic component, i.e., the observation of a thin specimen ( c100-200 A) whose density variations are fast and relatively large (Burge, 1973). In these conditions, the image depends critically on focus and lens aberrations. B. Photographic Recording of Electron-Optical Data Information concerning the observed specimen is available on the output plane of the electron-optical channel in the form of a distribution of electron intensity j ( r ) or rather as electron image contrast, C , ( r )= [ j ( r )- ( j ) ] / < j ) . Photographic recording of electron-optical data makes the information concerning the specimen available in the form of a modulation of the optical density D(r) of a photographic plate, or, more precisely, as the micrograph contrast C,(r) = [ D ( r )- ( D ) ] / ( D ) , where ( D ) indicates the average value of the optical density of the micrograph itself.
10
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
The “large area” response of photographic emulsion to the incident electrons (Zeitler and Hayes, 1965; Burge et al., 1968; Valentine, 1969) is characterized, under the working conditions used in electron microscopy, by an approximately linear relationship between the optical density D(r) of the exposed and developed plate and the exposure e(r), defined as the product of the intensity j of the incident electron beam for the time t of exposure: e = j t ; ie.,
with the exact value of the constant y depending on the characteristics of the particular emulsion utilized and on the energy of the incident electrons. The simple linear relationship of Eq. (25) between optical density and exposure can be considered rigorously valid (Burge et al., 1968; Valentine, 1969) up to an optical density equal to D,/4,D, being the saturation density of the considered emulsion; and it can be considered to be valid with good approximation up to a density equal to D,/2; i.e., Eq. (25) can be considered satisfied in the usual applications of an electron microscope. If the “small area” response of a photographic emulsion could be i.e., if the latter continued to be described still using the relationship (3), satisfied even in the presence of rapid fluctuations of exposure from one point to another of the emulsion between the image contrast C,(r) and the photographic contrast C,,(r), we would obviously find
and the information concerning the specimen contained in the micrograph would turn out to be exactly equivalent to that contained on the output plane of the electron-optical channel. Nonetheless, Eqs. (25) and (26) are not adequate to describe the “small area” response of the emulsion (Burge and Garrard, 1968; Zeitler and Hayes, 1965; Zeitler, 1968); in the transfer through the photographic channel the signal which contains information can be degraded by various factors. Each electron incident on the emulsion can make more than one silver halide grain developable during its passage in the emulsion. The electron path is not straight because of the multiple scattering that the electron itself undergoes. During development the halide grains change form and dimension in a random way. During fixation and drying of the emulsion, developed grains can change from their original position due to deformations that the gelatine support may undergo. Random variations in the developer concentration can cause variations in contrast. All of these effects contribute to modifying the photographic channel response with respect to the ideal situation which would correspond to
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
11
Eq. (26) and can be adequately described only by substituting this latter with the more general
where Sp(r’ - r ) indicates the spread function of the photographic channel, i.e., its response to an impulsive input signal. We then see that for Eq. (27) the photographic contrast at a point r of the micrograph also depends on the image contrast in the nearby points in a way that depends on the function S(r’ - r), On the basis of Eq. (27), the information contained in the image is modified in the transfer through the photographic channel since the spatial frequency spectra of Ci(r) and of C,(r) do not turn out to be equal on their entire bandwidth. Taking the Fourier transform of the two members of Eq. (27) we have, in fact, F[Cp(r)l = Tp(v) * S[Ci(r)l
(28)
having indicated by T,(v) the transfer function of the photographic channel, i.e., the transform of S p ( t ) . For emulsions exposed to electrons through narrow slits, the experimental data (Zeitler and Hayes, 1965) relative to the contrast produced qear the slit on the zone of the emulsion not exposed can be adequately described by
I
S,b) = exp[ - x I /KI
(29)
where 1 x 1 represents the distance from the edge of the slit and the constant K is the radius at which the “spurious” contrast is reduced to l/e of its initial value. The value of the constant K depends essentially on the energy of the incident electrons and the thickness of the sensitive emulsion. In conditions normally used in electron microscopy, K can be assigned a value of about 10 p (Zeitler, 1968). The Fourier transform of Eq. (29) can be used to evaluate the transfer function T ( v ) in Eq. (28). The result of the transform can be written: 2K/(4rc2K4v2 + 1); this function rapidly decreases at high frequencies and for v ‘v 1/60 pm- it is already reduced to 50% of its original value, having assumed K = 10 pm. This means that 60-pm details found in the image plane of the electron-optical system are recorded on the micrograph with a contrast of about half of the “electron contrast.” Finally, the photographic channel acts like a low-pass filter, and the higher spatial frequencies of the electron image are transferred with reduced contrast or else not transferred at all in the micrograph.
12
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
If details of the observed specimen are to be maintained on the micrograph, it is necessary that the spatial frequency band corresponding to those details not be filtered by Tp(v).In the usual working conditions of electron microscopy this limitation is not excessively pressing. As long as a 20-A detail of the observed specimen, for example, is found on the micrograph with a contrast not less than 50% of the contrast on the electron image, it is sufficient to work with an instrumental magnification of not less than 3 x lo4, which is a relatively low magnification for electron microscopes presently in use. Thus, for sufficiently high instrumental magnifications, the transfer function Tp(v) of the photographic channel, at least in the spatial frequency band that effectively transports information concerning the specimen, can be considered as a constant, with not more than 20-30”/, error, and Eq. (28) can be replaced by the simpler expression r[Cp(r)] = F[Ci(r)] 111. OPTICAL PROCESSING OF ELECTRON MICROSCOPIC DATA
The processing of electron microscopic data has been successfully carried out using both computers (Klug, 1971; Frank, 1973; Hawkes, 1973) and coherent optical systems (Klug and Berger, 1964; Markham, 1968; Berger, 1972; Donnelli and Paoletti, 1972; Horne and Markham, 1972; Lake, 1972). Nonetheless, the techniques of optical processing hold a fundamental advantage over other methods of processing since the data are, in most cases, already available in suitable form to be introduced in the optical system. Optical processing of data with coherent systems, in fact, requires that the input data be in the form of an amplitude transmittance (Vander Lugt, 1968; Thompson, 1972); the light modulator can be constituted directly by an electron micrograph. Being able to avoid the “translation of data into a suitable “format for processing has obvious advantages, saving both time and equipment and, in addition, avoiding possible degradation of the data in the translation process. The purpose of processing electron microscopic images is that of restoring data degraded by aberrations of the electron-optical channel and disturbed by noise coming from various sources, or at least of evaluating some parameters contained in the data themselves. To realize this purpose, a coherent optical system (Born and Wolf, 1959; Stroke, 1966; Collier et al., 1971) is such that it is possible to carry out a frequency analysis of the image through its Fourier transform, or to carry out spatial filtering of the image itself through control of the transfer function of the optical system with suitable filters. Data processed in this way are then available in the form of a light intensity distribution on the output plane of the optical system. ”
”
13
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
A . Coherent Optical Data-Processing Systems 1. Elements of a
Coherent Optical System and
Their Operational
Characterization
In the discussion of a coherent optical data-processing system in terms of the light intensity distribution produced on any one of its optical planes, it is useful to characterize from an operational point of view all of the elements of the system itself. This latter, in general, along with one or more spherical lenses and a coherent light source, will be made up of a light modulator through which the data to be processed are introduced into the system and free spaces which separate the lenses, the modulator, and the planes of the optical system on which the light intensity distribution is to be observed. In a first-order analysis (i.e., neglecting aberrations) and supposing an infinite lens aperture, a thin spherical lens (Born and Wolf, 1959) can be described by a quadratic phase factor given by
“
”
wherefis the focal length of the lens and I the wavelength of the light. The light wave function immediately after the lens is the product of the phase factor in Eq. (31) and the wave function incident on the lens. Furthermore, the light wave function is changed by its propagation through a “free space” along the axis of the optical system. From the Fresnel-Kirchhoff integral, in the paraxial approximation, it follows that if Y(x, y) is the wave function on a given plane ofthe system, the new wave function Y(u, v ) on a plane at a distance 1 from the first is given (Born and Wolf, 1959) by i
1
Y ( uU) , = - Y(x, y) exp
I1
[(u - x)’
+
(1)
I
- Y ) ~ ]dx dy
(32)
where u, v are the coordinates in the new plane. The propagation of a wave function Y(x, y ) through a distance 1 can then be described, for Eq. (32), using the convolution of the latter with the phase term T‘:
14
G . D O N E L L I A N D L. PAOLETTI
Because of the similarity between Eqs. (31) and (33) it would be convenient to define the operator O ( x , y ; Q ) (Vander Lugt, 1966) using O(X, y ; Q ) = exp
(34)
in which Q is a parameter that can assume suitable real values. For Eq.,(34), then, the phase factor that describes the operations ofa lens can be represented by the operator @(x, y; - F), having F = 1/1; while the propagation of the wave function Y ( x , y ) through a distance 1 can be described using the convolution of Y(x, y ) itself with the operator (iL/A)@(x,y; L), assuming L = 1/1. 2 . Optical Systems for Frequency Analysis and Spatial Filtering The fundamental system for optical data processing as shown in Fig. 3, is made up of: a light modulator, characterized by a complex amplitude transmittance a,(x,, y,) and through which the input signal is introduced into the system; a free space lI that separates the modulator from a spherical lens with a focal lengthf; and a free space 1, that separates the lens from the output plane on which the signal is available as a light intensity distribution.
.L
11
I
FIG.3. An optical system for frequency analysis and spatial filtering of the data.
If the modulator is then illuminated by a monochromatic wave of unit amplitude, diverging from a point source at a distance l o , the wave function Y , ( x l ,y l ) transmitted by the modulator itself will be:
having Lo = l / l o
15
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
The convolution of Y , ( x , , y , ) with (iL,/A)Q,(x,,y,; L l ) , where L, = 1/11, gives the wave function Y i ( x 2 y, z ) incident on the lens:
The product of Y i ( x , , y 2 ) with @ ( x 2 y, , ; - F ) provides the wave function Y f ( x 2 , y,) coming out of the lens: Y f ( x 2 ~ 2 =) Yi(x2 Y ~ ) Q , ( x~ ~ 2 - ;F ) (37) and finally the convolution of Y f ( x 2 y,) , with (iL,/A)Q,(x,,y , ; L,), where L, = l/lz, gives the wave function Y u ( x 3 y, 3 ) on the output plane of the optical system: 7
3
Yu(x3
9
y3)
=
iL2 11
yf(x2
9
Y2)Q,(x3
- xZ
3
Y3
- y2;
L2) dx2
dy2
(38)
Explaining Eq. (38) through Eqs. (35k(37) and keeping Eq. (34) in mind, the output signal can be written
If the conditions for imaging obtained from geometrical optics are valid, i.e., if L2
= F - L1
(40) it is easy to verify that the output signal of Eq. (39) (Vander Lugt, 1966), aside from a phase factor, has the form of the input signal a,(x,, y , ) . More exactly, in this case it can be seen that
(41)
From Eq. (41) the output signal turns out to be equal to the input signal inverted with respect to the origin of the coordinates, enlarged by M = - L1/L2, and multiplied by a spherical phase factor dependent on the
16
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
cuivature of the wave function incident on the modulator. Since, in general, the signal is recorded as an intensity distribution YuY,*,the operations of the optical system, at least as far as the imaging of the input signal is concerned, are independent of the curvature Lo of the illuminating wave. A fundamental property of the optical system under discussion is that of being able to produce the Fourier transform of the input signal; it can in fact be verified that if the following condition is valid:
the wave function of Eq. (39), assumes the form
where A,(u, u ) indicates the Fourier transform of a,(x,, y,). The transformable properties of the optical system are satisfied independently of the distance 1/L, between the modulator and spherical lens. The phase factor can be reduced to 1 if the further condition L , = F is satisfied. In addition to the frequency analysis of the input signal the optical system allows for spatial filtering of the signal. In fact, on the basis of Eqs. (40) and (42) the plane of the optical system on which the input signal is reproduced is always situated after the plane on which the transform is produced. Inserting appropriate filters (Vander Lugt, 1968; Thompson, 1972) on the transform plane it is possible to obtain an output signal for which the intensity or the phase of the spatial frequencies has been changed on the basis of selected filter. This discussion of the operations of the optical system is not completely general insofar as it neglects the effects of aberrations and of the finite aperture of the lenses; the latter limitation, in particular, has important consequences on the operations of the system itself (Vander Lugt, 1966). In order to evaluate such consequences on the Fourier transformable properties let us consider the very simple optical system of Fig. 4. A light modulator a,(x,, y , ) is illuminated by a spherical wave converging in a point, at a distance 1, situated after the modulator itself. If the system has a limited aperture, the incident wave is described on the plane of the modulator by the wave function
Y b , ?Y , ) = b b , ,
Y,)@(Xl?
y,; -L)
(44)
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
17
FIG.4. An optical system for performing the Fourier transform ofdata. The finite aperture of the system implies an indeterminancy in the representation on the output plane of the system itself of the spatial frequencies contained in the input signal.
where b(x,, y , ) indicates a function other than zero on the aperture and equal to zero elsewhere. On the basis of Eq. (32), it is then seen that the wave function on the x z y z plane at a distance 1 from the modulator is given by
(45 )
where B(u, v ) and A,(u, u ) indicate respectively the transforms of b(x,, y , ) and Ofa,(xi, ~ 1 ) . Because of the convolution operation indicated in Eq. (45), a spatial frequency found in the spectrum of a,(x,, y , ) is no longer represented on the x , y , plane by a delta function, i.e., by a geometrical point but rather by a light distribution represented by B[( - L/A)x, ,( - L/A)y,] whose spreading on the plane of the transform is inversely proportional to the aperture b(x,, y , ) of the optical system. B[( - L / A ) x , , (- L/A)y,] itself can thus be considered a measure of the indeterminancy with which a point on the output plane of the optical system represents a spatial frequency present in the spectrum of the input signal because of the finite dimensions of the elements of the optical system itself. B. Fourier Transforms of Electron Micrographs
In a coherent optical system, the electron micrograph is used as a wave amplitude modulator characterized by its complex amplitude transmittance a, = lal/eie. Bearing in mind that we want to obtain the transform of the electron image 9 C i , it would be appropriate to consider as parasite signal or noise anything that is different from or additional to 9 C i . From this
18
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
point of view, assuming as eliminated or negligible bad alignment, mechanical instability, dust on the lens of the optical bench, etc., the main factors to be taken into account can be described as follows: a. The modulus la,/ of the micrograph’s amplitude transmittance (Collier et al., 1971 ; Shamir, 1972) is not a linear function of the photographic contrast C , but rather depends exponentially on this latter. b. The “photographic channel” (Zeitler and Hayes, 1965; Burge and Garrand, 1968) acts as a low-pass filter, that is, its transfer function Tp goes to zero with high spatial frequencies; c. The amplitude transmittance of the micrograph has a phase 0 not related to the information contained by the contrast on the micrograph itself. d. The optical density and the contrast of the micrograph (Zeitler and Hayes, 1965; Valentine, 1969) are subjected to fluctuations which are due to the statistical distribution of the electrons. In spite of this discouraging list of factors contributing to degradation of the output signal, the optical elaboration of the data obtained from a micrograph can, nevertheless, provide a good approximation to the spectrum of the electron image, i.e., of the F C i , as can be seen from a discussion of the factors just mentioned. 1. Optical Analysis of Electron Microscopic Data
The modulus I a, 1 of the complex amplitude transmittance is defined in such a way that i, = (a,12i,
(46)
where io and i, are respectively the intensity of the incident light and that of the light transmitted from the micrograph. Since the optical density D of the micrograph is given by D = -loglo(il/io)
(47)
it can then be seen from Eqs. (46) and (47) that
la,( = 10-D’2
(481
Taking into account the definition of the photographic contrast C,, we then have
19
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
where I a, I depends exponentially on C, . Expanding I a, 1 into a series of C, powers, the modulus of the amplitude transmittance is lull = 10-(D)/2[1- f(D)(ln lO)C,
+ $(D)’(ln
10)2C:
+ ...I
(50)
Ignoring the phase of the amplitude transmittance, the output signal of the optical system is given by S[la,1] and can be written
Y[ I a, I] = 1 0 - ( ~ ) / ~ [ 6 ( uu), - j(D>(ln 1o)SC,
+ +(D)’(ln
10)2FC, 0 YC,
+ .**I
(51)
The optical system thus provides the micrograph’s contrast transform, with the approximation that corresponds to neglecting all of the terms following the second one in the expansion of I a, I in a power series. In fact, higher terms such as F C , 0 SC,,, Y C , 0 YC, @ YC,, etc., can be found in the output signal of the optical system. Since the width of the spectral band of these terms is two or three times the width of the SC, (Bracewell, 1965), these terms generate parasite signals. Nevertheless, these signals are smaller, by at least one order of magnitude, than those which correspond to YC, . This is true for electron micrograph density values included in the usual range. Considering that Eq. (51) represents the wave amplitude on the output plane of the optical system, the light intensity on this same plane, that is to say, the quantity that can actually be observed, will be given by
I S [ la,l] 1’
= 10-‘D’{6(u,
u)
+ q 2 I F C , l2 + iq41SC, 0 SC,12
- f q ~ S * C , ( Y C ,0 YC,) - $q3SCp(YC, @ YC,)*
+ ...}
(52)
where 6(u, u ) represents the component scattered in the incidence direction and the cross products, like
the interference between the terms of Eq. (51); the constant q is defined by q = $(D) In 10. The total power W on the output plane uu of the optical system, aside from a proportionality constant, is given by W = f 1 S[la, I ] l2 du du. The integral must be considered to be extended over the entire bandwidth of F [la, I], i.e., over the entire area of the output plane in which S[Ia, 11 # 0. It can be seen from Eq. ( 5 2 ) that, apart from the component diffused in the direction of incident light represented by the delta function, the power
20
G . DONELLI A N D L . PAOLETTI
W can be thought of as a sum of terms. The first two of these terms correspond respectively to
w,= ). IFC,12 Wz-. -
du du
I IYC, @ FC,Iz du du
(53) (54)
Since the function under the integral sign can be expressed by the autoconvolution of F C , , it is evident that the integral W, is extended over a bandwidth twice as large as the one that corresponds to W,. On the other hand, it is easy to verify that W, 2 W, . In fact,
w,= 1 IFC,(2 du d" = C(C,I2dxdy2
( l C , Z 1 2 d x d y = CJFC,Z12dud~= W,
(55)
having taken into account Rayleigh's theorem and considering the fact that C , is a real function such that - 1 < C, < + 1. It is also clear that the smaller W, is with respect to W, and the more extended its bandwidth with respect to that of W,, the more negligible is the term of Eq. (52) corresponding to W, (i.e., the term in which we find autoconvolution) with respect to the first-order term I3C,I2. The terms of Eq. (52) in which convolutions of higher order are present will be similarly negligible with respect to I Y C , 1.' Limiting ourselves to a unidimensional case, we see, for example, that a micrograph whose contrast C, varies sinusoidally with a period p will have C, = cos 2nx/p. Considering that 3 C , = ;S(u + l/p) + ;S(u - l/p) and that F C , @ F C , = *6(u) + $6(u + 2/p) + $S(u - 2/p), from Eq. (51) and ignoring the finite dimensions of the micrograph, we find
For Eq. (52) the ratio r between the intensity of the components 6(u + 2/p) and 6(u - 2/p) of the output signal, corresponding to 3 C , @ YC,, and the intensity of the components 6 ( u + l/p) and 6 ( u - l/p), corresponding to F C , , is r = 16q 1 2 = n(D)2(ln 1 lo),. For an average optical density, (D)= 1, it will be r 2 804;for (D)= 0.6, it will be r z 5%. We thus see that the intensity of the parasite signals corresponding to the term YC, @ YC, in the expansion of Eq. (5 1 ) is less, by a factor of 10 or 20, than the intensity of the signal corresponding to YC,.
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
21
If we then keep in mind that the spectrum of the micrograph F C p can be considered with the approximation of Eq. (30) equal to the spectrum of the electron image 9-Ci we can suppose that
is sufficiently verified, at least in the optical Fourier analysis of electron micrographs obtained in standard working conditions (average value of 1.0 and instrumental magnification not optical density not higher than lower than 3 * lo4.
-
-
2. Phase Noise
As a light modulator, the electron micrograph acts either by attenuating the wave amplitude or by modulating the phase of the transmitted wave. Since the phase 0 of the complex amplitude transmittance a, = la,leie of the micrograph does not in any way depend on the electron image C i , but rather depends on factors such as variations in thickness and microdefects of the photographic plate, the corresponding modulation of phase gives rise to components in the output signal of the optical system which represent parasite signals and background noise superimposed on the image spectrum. A notable phase effect is the asymmetry of the diffraction pattern; in fact, a real amplitude transmittance would have a hermitian transform (Bracewell, 1965), and the square of the modulus of such a transform, i.e., the corresponding diffraction pattern, would be centrosymmetric. The phase modulations can be partially avoided using such techniques as the “optical sandwich” (Harburn and Ranniko, 1971), which allow for the elimination of phase effects due to variations in the thickness of the plate glass or of the emulsion. The phase effects due to microdefects cannot be eliminated, however, and they thus represent a constant noise component present on the optical transform of an electron image. Such microdefects, distributed randomly over the plate, act as (Goldfischer, 1965; Enloe, 1967; Collier et al., 1971) scattering centers that diffuse the coherent incident light with random phase angles; the plate can thus be considered as a random distribution of spherical wave sources whose relative phase differences are such that any value from 0 to 2n is equally probable. In order to discuss noise due to phase effects, let us consider the optical system described in Fig. 4, assuming the micrograph situated on the x 1 y 1 plane.
22
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
The wave function on the x 2 y 2 plane resulting from the scattered spherical waves will be given by
where ( x ! , y ! ) are the coordinates and a,, the relative phase of the h th scattering center. The intensity on the x 2 y , plane is then the square modulus of the wave function. If we indicate by (I) the average intensity and by T ( x 2 , y , ) the variable part of intensity we have
If we consider the summation of the second member of Eq. (59), which represents the intensity fluctuations, it is seen that for each pair of scatterers there is a series of interference fringes that go along the x 2 y 2 plane in directions perpendicular to the vector of components x: - x: and y: - y : . Equation (59) gives rise to an intensity pattern whose aspect is that of a distribution of light speckles all over the x 2 y , plane. Information on the statistical characteristics (Goldfischer, 1965) of this speckle pattern can be obtained from the autocorrelation R(u, 0) of the variable part T ( x 2 , y 2 ) of Eq. (59). Averaging over the variables x 2 and y 2 , we then find
+ u, y , + c))
(60) In the likely hypothesis that the scattering centers due to microdefects in the plate are extremely numerous, the preceding relation is to be considered in the limit when the number N of the scatterers approaches infinity, and the power scattered by each of these approaches zero. In such a way the average intensity on the x , y 2 plane remains constant, and from Eqs. (58), (59), and (a),it can thus be seen that R(u, 0) = ( r 7 . 2 ,
y,)T(x,
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
23
and that R(u,~)=($!ilL S ( ~ Lu , ~ u ) I where B(u, u ) = Y [ b ( x , ,y , ) ] and /lis the coherently illuminated surface of the plate. In conclusion we can say, based on Eq. (61), that the mean square value of the intensity fluctuations on the output plane of the optical system is equal to the square of the average intensity on the same plane. Based on Eq. (62), it can then be seen that the autocorrelation function of phase noise is proportional to the diffraction pattern of the system aperture. Qualitatively, this means that the average dimensions of the speckles constituting the pattern defined by Eq. (59) are inversely proportional to the dimensions of the system aperture, i.e., to the dimensions of b ( x , , yl). IV. APPLICATIONS A . Contrast Transfer Function of an Electron Microscope
A correct interpretation of the phase contrast image is subordinate to adequate knowledge of contrast transfer function (CTF) of the electron-optical channel under the specific operating conditions. For a weak object of phase the CTF can be written (Lenz, 1970)
2n T ( v )= sin - W ( v )= sin ;1
where the astigmatism is supposed correct and the effects of partial coherence and chromatic aberration are considered negligible. Experimental determination of the CTF is a relatively simple operation using the method introduced by Thon (1966). Thin carbon films can be considered phase objects whose spectrum, due to the presence of local and random variations in the electron refraction index, contains every possible spatial frequency. The Fourier spectrum of the electron image of such films can thus be described as a “white” spectrum (i.e., containing every spatial frequency) modulated by Eq. (63). On the optical transform of a carbon film micrograph it is possible to measure the spatial frequencies in correspondence with which the CTF reaches maximal and zero values. For a fixed defocusing Af of the objective lens the spatial frequencies in correspondence with which the CTF gives maximal contrast are those that satisfy the equation 271 II - W ( v )= ( 2 n - 1 ) fl 2 with n a whole number.
24
G . DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
Figure 5 shows the curves corresponding to Eq. (64) for some values of n along with the curves corresponding to the zero contrast values. For a given defocusing, the contrast on the image changes sign when the C T F passes through its zero values. Consequently, we should expect to find on the image artifacts that reduce the resolution to the spatial frequency band that precedes the first zero of the CTF. A technique for the critical evaluation of the information contained in a phase image thus consists in the study of the optical transform of a carbon film micrograph obtained under the same instrumental conditions. The spatial frequencies in correspondence with which the contrast becomes inverted
overbcus
d f ( ~ l underfocus
FIG.5. The dependence on defocusing of the contrast with which the spatial frequencies in a phase image are transferred.The contrast is maximal in correspondence with the solid lines; zero contrast corresponds to the dashed lines. Electron energy = 100 keV; spherical aberration coefficient = 1.6 mm.
are clearly observable on the optical transform, corresponding to low intensity zones. This technique can be used also in the determination of optimal conditions in phase contrast observation (Johansen, 1973). These conditions correspond to the degree of underfocusing for which the widest spatial frequency band is transferred with the same sign. For a weak object of phase and amplitude, the CTF can be written
where P(v) represents the percentage of amplitude contrast with respect to the total contrast. It is difficult to give a sufficiently exact evaluation of P(v). Its weight will depend both on the atomic number of the elements present in the sample and on instrumental factors such as acceleration voltage, lens
25
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
aperture, etc. A theoretical estimate (Erickson, 1973), confirmed by experimental results (Erickson and Klug, 197 l), obtained under normal working conditions valuates P ( v ) as included in the interval between 0.1 and 0.4, going from light elements (carbon) to heavy elements (uranium). Since P ( v ) is generally small, Eq. (65) can be written in the alternative form
1
where the effect of amplitude contrast is described as a further phase shift q ( v ) . The zero and maximal values of Eq. (63), just as the curves in Fig. 5, must then be thought of as shifted toward the low spatial frequencies. Similarly to the case of carbon film, in a phase and amplitude image the random fluctuations in beam absorption and in the refraction index of the sample generate a background noise whose spectrum contains every possible spatial frequency. This spectrum modulated by Eq. (65) can be observed on the optical transform of the image. Considering the theoretical uncertainty with which Eqs. (65) and (66) can be valuated because of limited knowledge regarding the beam-specimen interaction, it is particularly interesting to observe that using the optical transform of the image background noise it is possible to valuate experimentally the CTF in the actual observation conditions.
B. Defects of Electron Images 1 . Astigmatism
In the presence of objective residual astigmatism, the CTF of the electron-optical channel does not depend only on the radial coordinate I v I on the spatial frequency plane, but must be written, more generally, as a function of I v 1 and of the azimuthal coordinate w (Lenz, 1970). Due to aberrations and objective defocusing, the CTF in this case will be 211
I“
~ ( l v lw, ) = sin-- W( I v J ,w ) = sin - -R4v4 2K 1 4 R
-
c.2
A2V’
+ Af -1’v2 2
1
cos(20)
(671
where the symbols have the same meaning as in Eq. (15). Theopticaldiffraction pattern will be modulated by [sin(2n/A)W( I v 1, w)]’. Consequently, the zones of the spatial frequency plane on which the contrast has maximum and minimum values no longer have rotational symmetry
26
G . DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
around the origin of the coordinates (Thon, 1966). For example, the zones corresponding to the zeros of the CTF, which on the diffraction pattern are found as areas of weak intensity, will be those corresponding to the condition
and to W ( I v l , w ) = nA/2
(69)
Equation (69) can be satisfied by suitable whole number values of n. For each of these values the optical transform presents intensity minima which are described by the equation
c.2n
13v4
+ A-?Av2 n
c.n
1v2
cos(2w) = 1
If the residual astigmatism is completely correct we shall find C , = 0 and the points of the v w plane whose coordinates satisfy Eq. (70) will be found on circumferences centered on the origin. In the presence of astigmatism, from Eq. (70) it can be verified that there are two perpendicular directions on the v w plane along which the zero values of the CTF have respectively maximum and minimum distances from the origin. It is for this reason that the bandwidth of the frequencies transferred with the same contrast is different according to the direction on the spatial frequency plane. 2. Mechanical Instability and Magnetic Disturbance
The effects of electron-optical image drift, due to movement of the specimen, vibrations of the microscope column, or varying magnetic fields, can be difficult to recognize if, for example, they are of small magnitude and the image already possesses directional characteristics. Observation of the image optical transform can then be a simple method for measuring the direction and magnitude of such drifts. A blurred image M ( x ) can be considered as the superimposition of two identical images m ( x ) reciprocally translated by a distance 2d, and the corresponding micrograph can be represented by M(x)=fm(x d ) fm(x - d) (71) Equation (7 1) can more conveniently be written
+ +
M ( x ) = m ( x )0 [ @ ( x
+ d ) + @(x - d)]
(72)
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
27
The Fourier transform of Eq. (72) is then simply F [ M ( x ) ]= F [ m ( x ) ]cos(2nvd) and the intensity on the diffraction pattern will be given by
I F [ M ( x ) ]I*
(73)
1 F [ m ( x ) ]1’
cos’(2nvd) (74) If, more generally, the image is blurred by a linear drift of amplitude 2d, the micrograph can be represented using =
M ( x ) = m ( x )0 D ( x ) (75) where D ( x ) indicates a rectangular function, constant in the interval -d. + d and zero elsewhere. The transform of Eq. (75) can thus be written sin(2nvd) F [ M ( x ) ]= F [ m ( x ) ] 2nvd
and the intensity on the diffraction pattern will be (77) To determine the amplitude and direction of the drift, Eq. (74) or (77), respectively, must be considered; the continuous intensity distribution on the optical transform pattern will turn out to be modulated by a series of parallel fringes, perpendicular to the direction of the drift. The width of such fringes in the first case, Eq. (74), is uniform and equal to Av = 1/2d. In the second case, Eq. (77), the intensity minima will be found at distances from the center of the diffraction pattern: Avl = & 1/2d, Av, = +2/2d, Av3 = i~ 3/2d, etc., and consequently we shall find a central fringe with a width double that of the secondary lateral fringes.
C . Periodical Structure Analysis The use of optical transforms is a particularly potent method when applied to the analysis of a periodical structure (Klug and Berger, 1964; Donelliand Paoletti, 1972; Horne and Markham, 1972).The purpose of such an analysis can be summarized in the singling out and measuring of all of the periodicit ies. The value of each spacing should be considered as a nonlocal property that depends on the total characteristics of the image. The best way to measure this parameter is then simply a spatial frequency analysis of the entire image using its Fourier transform. A periodical image m(x, y) can be described as the repetition of a
G . DONELLI AND L. PA~LETTI
28
“motif ” according to a given mono- or bidimensional scheme and consequently can be represented by the following equation :
where g(x, y) indicates the repeated “motif ”, r(x, y) is the lattice plane that describes the periodicities present on the image, and b(x, y) is a function describing the actual extension of the image. Taking into consideration Eq. (78), the Fourier transform will be
m(vs v,) 9
[r(vr
=
3
v,) 0 &J< > v,)]
. d v r v,)
(79)
Y
where vt and v,, indicate the coordinates in the spatial frequency plane, and m(ve, v,,), i‘(vs,v,), 6(vc, v,,), and g(vr, v,) indicate respectively the Fourier transforms of m(x, y), r(x, y), b(x, y), and g(x, y). The optical transform thus turns out to be
I m(vs
9
I2
v,)
I
= [fly{
9
v,) 0 QV,
9
v,)l l2 I B(vr
9
v,)
I2
(80)
This equation can be more easily discussed by explicating the convolution. More exactly, if a and b are two vectors that describe the unit cell of the lattice r(x, y), a point of the latter is singled out by the vector v = ha + kb where h and k are whole numbers. The term [r(x, y) . b(x, y)] in Eq. (78) can then be written in the form r(x, y ) * b(x, Y)
=
0,111-1
0 . n ~ - 1
h
k
1
c
S(X- 0,; Y - 0,)
0.n l - 1 0, n 2 - 1
=
1
1
h
S[X - (ha, + kb,); y - (ha, + kb,)]
(81)
k
where the h and k indices vary respectively from 0 to n , - 1, and from 0 to n, - 1, describing the actual extension of the periodical image. For Eq. (81), we have F[r(x, y ) . b(x, y)] = i‘(v< v,) 0 &(V< , v,) 3
0.n,
=
-1
1
0 . nz- 1
exp[i27rh(vca,
h
+ v,,a,)] 2
exp[i2nk(vrb,
+ v,b,)]
(82)
k
and for the second term of Eq. (80) we have vs)o 6(Vr’
vv)12
+
sin2[n,n(v,:a, v,a,)] sin2[n27r(vsbx+ v,,b,)] = sin2[n(vFa, + v,a,)] sin2[n(vcb, v,,b,)]
+
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
29
If we assume that n , and n, are sufficiently large, it can be seen that the second term of Eq. (83) is different from zero only at those points of the v5 v,, plane whose coordinates satisfy the equations v5 a ,
+ v,,a y = I,
v5:b,
+ v,,by = m
(84)
with 1 and rn whole numbers. It can be verified that the solutions to the equations in (84) are given by those vectors v that can be written in the form v = la
where the vectors a and
+ mb
(85)
are determined by the conditions
a-a=B*b=l,
a*b=b*a=O
(86)
The vectors defined in Eq. (85) individuate a lattice7 on the v5 v,, plane whose elementary translations a and B depend, through Eqs. (86), on the translations of the r(x, y) lattice. This lattice is generally defined as the “reciprocal” of the r ( x , y) lattice and has some well-known geometric properties (Donelli and Paoletti, 1972). Going by Eq. (83) we can thus see that the intensity on the optical ‘transform is different from zero only on the points of the reciprocal lattice 7. The intensity at these points, however, is weighted by the term Ig(vtE’ ~ ,,)1~, i.e., by the “motif” transform of the periodical image. Measuring the highest spatial frequencies on the optical transform, it is possible to valuate the bandwidth of g(vC,v,) and thus the image resolution. This information is particularly significant for biological specimens in that the resolution with which these specimens are observed depends both on the characteristics of the electron-optical channel and, even more, on the preparation methods, staining, and damage undergone by the specimens during interaction with the electron beam. It is important to emphasize that generally the factors that effectively limit resolution are, in the case of biological samples, precisely those mentioned above. Nonetheless, it is extremely difficult to evaluate a priori the limits imposed on the resolution by such factors; they are, in fact, limits that can vary greatly with the type of sample studied and with the preparation techniques used.
D. Three-Dimensional Reconstruction The electron image of a specimen must be considered as the projection of the structure of the specimen itself onto the image plane. Information coming from all of the structure levels thus appears superimposed,and it can be difficult to deduce at which level observed details are located and to
30
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
reconstruct a three-dimensional model. Serial sections (Williams and Kallman, 1955; Sjostrand, 1958; Donelli et al., 1970), shadow techniques (Hall, 1953; Bradley, 1967; Henderson and Griffiths, 1972; Ageno er al., 1973),and stereomicrographs (Garrod and Nankivell, 1958 ; Wells, 1960; Helmcke, 1965; Ageno et al., 1973) have been used successfully for low resolution structural studies. At higher resolutions these methods become less accurate, if not totally useless, for three-dimensional reconstruction. A useful method in high resolution studies is that of first reconstructing the three-dimensional Fourier transform of specimen structure using the “projection theorem ” and then, on this basis, calculating the requested three-dimensional structural parameters (De Rosier and Klug, 1968 ; Crowther et d., 1970; Klug, 1971; Lake, 1972). The “projection theorem” can be stated as follows: the transform of the projection of a three-dimensional structure onto a plane coincides with a plane section, passing through the center of the three-dimensional Fourier transform of the structure itself. In fact, if s(x, y, z ) is a three-dimensional structure, its projection a(y, z ) on the yz plane is given by
Its transform is then
=
5 s(x,
y , z ) exp[ - i2n(yvI
+ zvr)] dx dy dz = s(0, vI , vy)
(88)
where the transform of s(x, y, z ) is indicated by S ( v r , v,,, v~). The method of reconstruction of the transform is applicable to any specimen for which a sufficient number of micrographs from different and known directions are available. The very large quantity of data to be evaluated generally requires the use of electronic computers (Frank, 1973). For specimens whose structural symmetries are known, such as crystal lattices and helical structures, it is nonetheless possible to reconstruct the three-dimensional transform directly with the data obtained from the optical transforms of micrographs. In this case, the resolution with which the sample is reconstructed turns out to be much lower; the most meaningful structural parameters can, however, be obtained in a simple and rapid way. 1. Crystal Lattice A three-dimensional crystal lattice M ( x , y, z ) can be described using M ( x , y, z ) = [ R ( x , y, z ) . B(x, Y , 211 0 G(x9 Y , z )
(89)
31
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
where C(x, y,z ) indicates the content of the unit cell, R ( x , y, z ) the threedimensional lattice, and B(x, y, z ) a function describing the effective form and dimension of the crystal lattice. The transform of Eq. (89) can thus be written
where M = F M , R = F R , B = .FB, and G = F G . If the vectors a, b, c are three elementary translations of the R(x, y, z ) lattice, the latter can be described by a vector of the form V = ia + hb kc, with i, h, k whole numbers. The transform R(v,,, v,,, vi) of the lattice still has the form of a three-dimensional lattice, the reciprocal lattice, which can be described by a vector v = la rn’ ny, with I, m, and n whole numbers and the vectors a, p, and y related to the vectors a, b, and c through
+
+
a=-
bxc a * (b x c) ’
+
’
cxa = a * (b x c ) ’
axb = a (b x c)
’
-
(91)
The optical transform of a crystal lattice micrograph is a section through the origin of the reciprocal lattice of the crystal itself (Berger, 1969; Reimer et al., 1973; Donelli et al., 1975). If the crystal lattice projection is chosen at random, any one of the following situations may be found: (1) the section intersects the reciprocal lattice only in the origin; (2) the section intersects the reciprocal lattice along a lattice line (unidimensional section); (3) the section intersects the reciprocal lattice along a lattice plane (bidimensional section). If we were to consider the reciprocal lattice as made up of geometric points without dimension, the most probable of the above-mentioned possibilities would be the first, and we would rarely find sections passing through more than one lattice point. Nonetheless, because of the finite dimensions of the crystal lattice M ( x , y , z ) its transform M(v,, v,,, vi) is given by Eq. (W), and it is made up of points [the terms B(v,, v,,, vJ] “expanded” in the reciprocal space in the direction in which M ( x , y , z ) is limited. For this reason optical transforms of M ( x , y, z ) micrographs will, effectively, provide a collection of uni- and bidimensional sections of A7(vt, v,,, vs). This latter can thus be reconstructed taking into account that any two different bidimensional sections must have a lattice line in common, while there is only one way to orient three different bidimensional sections reciprocally. This is achievable given the hypothesis that it is possible to recognize and measure the spacings present in the reciprocal lattice M . We must consider, in fact, that because of a series of sources of error, each spacing of M will be present on the optical transforms with a distribution o f values. We must include in the causes of error the different inclinations of
32
G. DONELLI A N D L . PAOLETTI
sections that intersect a given lattice plane of M (Ohlendorf et al., 1975) the degree of indeterminancy in the knowledge of the actual magnification of each section of A,and the compressions and distortions of the lattice as a consequence of the specimen preparation procedures. These are all causes that will make for different values for the same spacing. In spite of the limitations due to these sources of error, it is generally possible to reconstruct the reciprocal lattice M and from this to calculate the lattice M . This method makes it possible to trace back to a series of structural parameters, such as dimensions and volume of the crystal unit cell. If the resolution on the electron micrograph is sufficient to distinguish, in the unit cell, an asymmetric subunit from its specular image or from the rotated subunit itself, further structural data such as the presence of screw axes or minor planes in the spatial group of the crystal lattice, can be derived also from (Donelli et al., 1975) systematic absences of reflexes on the optical transforms. 2. Helical Structures
The parameters that are necessary to describe the three-dimensional structure of a specimen made up of subunits regularly distributed along a helix (in the approximation of disregarding the content of the repeated asymmetric subunit) are the following: the radius p of the helix, the period c after which the structure repeats itself exactly along the helical axis, the number of turns t that the helix makes over the period c, and the number u of asymmetric subunits contained in t turns. Another parameter, the pitch p of the helix, is obviously related to the ones mentioned above by the relation p = c/t. It is convenient, to treat the helix transform problem in cylindrical coordinates. In this case it can be seen that the transform of a helical structure (Cochran et al., 1952), whose axis coincides with the axis z, is different from zero only on the reciprocal space planes perpendicular to the axis Z , which satisfy 2 = l/c with 1 a whole number. On these planes the transform F ( R , (D, I/c) of a helix passing through the point ( p o , 'po, zo) can be written
(92) where f indicates the transform of the asymmetric subunit, J , the Bessel function of order n, and the summation is extended to all the numbers n that satisfy the selection rule 1 = tn
+ urn
(93)
33
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
+
where rn may assume any integer value from - 03 to 03. A geometric interpretation of the selection rule can be given considering the reciprocal lattice of the radial projection of the helix. It has been shown (Klug et al., 1958) that if we introduce a coordinate system onto the reciprocal lattice in such a way that each point is characterized by a pair of whole numbers n, 1, these latter satisfy Eq. (93). This means that the existence of a point (n, 1) on the reciprocal lattice implies the presence of the Bessel function of order n on the lth plane of the transform F ( R , 0,l/c). When the helical structure consists of many different asymmetric subunits that are not all at one radius, the transform will be the sum of the contributions of each of the subunits:
(94) where the index n takes on the values provided by Eq. (93) and the summation is extended over all the asymmetric subunits. If we rewrite the transform separating the part that depends on the azimuthal coordinate @ from the rest, Eq. (94) takes on the form F ( R , 0,l/c) =
1 Tn,, ( R ) exp
(95)
n
where the part that depends on the radial coordinate is given by
An important case is that in which the helical structure also possesses, among its elements of symmetry, an N-fold parallel rotation axis (Klug et al., 1958; Donelli and Paoletti, 1972), i.e., when the structure can be described as a family of N identical parallel helices. In this case it is easy to verify that in Eqs. (95) or (92) the terms whose order n is not an integer multiple of N become zero. We thus see that in this case the transform is still given by Eqs. (95) and (96) or by Eq. (92), where the index n, however, is selected by the two rules
1 = tn + urn,
n
=
KN
(97)
with K a whole number. The micrograph of a helical structure (Moody, 1967, 1971; De Rosier and Moore, 1970; Donelli et al., 1972; Donelli and Paoletti, 1972) can be considered as a projection perpendicular to the axis of the helix, and its transform can be obtained from Eqs. (95) or (92) for a fixed value of the azimuthal coordinate @. What can be observed on the optical transform of
34
G. DONELLI A N D L. PAOLETTI
the micrograph is the square of the modulus of such a section of the threedimensional transform. Limiting ourselves to the simplest case of Eq. ( 1 13), the optical transform is then given by
1F(R
0,l/c) 1’
=
C f2Jn(2npnR)Jp(2nppR)e x ~ [ i ( n- P ) ( @ + n/i2 - ~ 0 ) l n. P
(98)
where the n and p indices take on all of the integer values provided by Eqs. (97). Separating‘ in Eq. (98) the terms with the same values for the n and p indices from the other terms, we obtain a more meaningful form for the square of the modulus:
I F ( R 0,l/c l2
=
Cf’ 1 Jn(27rp,R)l2 n
+ 2 1 f 2 J , ( 2 x P f l R ) J p ( 2 V pcos[(n R) - P) (0+ 4
2 - V0)l
n f p
(99)
where the second summation is extended to all possible combinations of values for n and p on the condition that n # p . As can be seen from Eq. (99), a simple inspection of the optical transform can furnish the axial period c of the helical structure measuring the spacing between the layer lines on which the transform is different from zero. Disregarding the second summation in Eq. (99), which represents the interference between the various diffraction orders, it can be seen that the strongest intensity maxima on the layer lines of the optical transform correspond to the principal maxima ofthe Bessel functions present on those layer lines; then such maxima fall near the points of the reciprocal lattice of the axial helical projection. If we take into account the cylindrical symmetry of the term In f 2 I Jn(2nRp)l2 of Eq. (99), it can be seen that the optical transform is actually formed by two reciprocal lattices related to each other by a mirror plane along the meridian of the optical transform itself. To index the optical transform, the most efficient system is the direct reconstruction of the reciprocal lattice on the basis of the criteria just discussed. Once the lattice itself is known, the Bessel function orders can be estimated from the position of the maxima on each layer line. Since the Bessel function orders must satisfy Eqs. (97), it is generally possible to obtain one or at most a few alternatives. The indexing of the reciprocal lattice of the helical axial projection allows us to obtain, aside from the axial period c, other geometric parameters of the structure: the number t of turns, the number u of subunits
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
35
contained in c, and the degree of symmetry N of the rotational axis. The interference between the various diffraction orders described by the second summation of Eq. (99) is generally negligible in the analysis of an optical transform on which only the Bessel functions of lower order are observable. The higher orders, in fact, fall in zones of the transform that correspond to a higher resolution than that obtainable on electron micrographs. We must keep in mind, however, the possibility of observing phase cancellations between Bessel functions of close order, but of opposite sign, which are found on the same layer line. The reconstruction of the reciprocal lattice may help in recognizing the presence of Bessel functions that have been attenuated by such effects.
E . Optical Spatial Filtering Beyond the analysis in spatial frequency of an electron image a coherent optical system can be used for restoration of the image itself with the technique of optical spatial filtering. This technique consists in processing the transform with suitable filters and reconstructing the image with the relative spatial frequency spectrum modified correspondingly to the filter used. A filter may work (Vander Lugt, 1968; Thompson, 1972) both on the amplitude of the spatial frequencies and the phase with which these contribute to the image spectrum. Such a filter can be described on the spatial frequency plane by a complex function H ( v , , v,) = I H ( v , , v,) 1 exp icp(v,, v,) whose modulus I H ( v , , v,) I and whose phase q ( v c , v,) represent respectively the amplitude and phase response of the filter itself. It may then be held, since filters are normally passive elements, that for the modulus I H ( v c , v,)I < 1 is valid. If we then consider M ( x , y ) as representing the image to be elaborated and A ( v c , v,) = F [ M ( x , y ) ] as its spatial spectrum, the operation of the H ( v c , ' v , ) filter is described by the product H ( v , , v,) . M ( v , , v,), while the reconstructed image is M , ( x , , y , ) = . F - l [ H ( v , v,) . q v < , v,)] 1
=
F ' - - l [ H ( V , ,v,)] 0 M ( x , y ) .
For this reason, the spatial filtering operation may be alternatively considered a convolution operation of the image with a suitable function R(x, y ) = F - - l [ H ( v , , v,)]. The optical spatial filtering technique can be used for the restoration of electron micrographs for three purposes: improvement of the signalhoise ratio; restoration of phase images; and separation of superimposed images.
36
G . DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
The filters used in each case are simple binary amplitude filters, i.e., the function H ( v g , v,) takes on only real values equal to zero or equal to one. Filters of this type are particularly easy to construct since they are opaque screens with apertures arranged on the diffraction plane of the optical system. The construction of a filter is possible only if we have some a priori information concerning the specimen structure and the causes of degradation of its image. The image information content will probably be changed by using the filter. With this technique it is not the quantity of the available information concerning the specimen structure represented in the image that is increased, but rather its accessibility, i.e., the ability to utilize this same information. 1. Noise Filtering for Periodical Structures
Among many factors that can contribute to the degradation of the image recorded on an electron micrograph, those that have the common characteristic of being generated by random processes are generally described as image “noise.” The main noise sources we may consider are the following: the structure of the film support whose image is superimposed on the micrograph over that of the specimen; the damage that the specimen itself undergoes due to its interaction with the electron beam ; the electron noise from which arises the micrograph granularity. The noise spectrum of an image disturbed by the preceding factors contributes to the “white” and continuous part of the spectrum of the image itself. This allows for a noticeable improvement of the signal/noise ratio (Fraser and Millward, 1970; Donelli and Paoletti, 1972; Frank, 1973) in the image of a periodical structure for which we know the spacing values. In fact, the spectrum of a periodical structure is different from zero only on the points of the reciprocal lattice of the structure itself, while it is practically equal to zero elsewhere. A binary amplitude filter, constructed in such a way as to have its apertures in correspondence with the reciprocal points, allows for the reconstruction of the image after having filtered out most of the noise components. If M ( r )represents the electron-optical image of a periodical structure m(r) disturbed by a noise n(r) we can write M ( r ) = m(r) + n(r), with the hypothesis that the noise can be considered additive, i.e., independent and superimposed on the signal. We consequently have &f(v) = ~ ( v+) n(v), having respectively defined M(v) = T [ M ( r ) ] ,~ ( v=) Y [ m ( r ) ] ,and ~ ( v=) Y [ n ( r ) ] . Before spatial filtering the signal/noise ratio can be written (100)
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
37
where W,(v) = lfi(v)I2 and Wn(v) = Ifi(v)lz indicate respectively the power spectrum of the structure and of the noise. After the use of the H(v) filter we shall have fi(v).H(v) = M(v).H(v)+ n(v). H(v)and the signal/noise ratio becomes
If we then consider that IH(v)lzis equal to one in correspondence with the reciprocal lattice m(v)and equal to zero elsewhere, Eq. (100) can also be written
where A i denote the integration areas around the points of the reciprocal lattice and whose size is a property of the particular filter chosen. The signal/noise ratio turns out to be clearly improved by the factor
As can be seen from Eq. (103), such a factor can reach high values when the A iareas of the spatial frequency plane are very small with respect to the frequency band on which the power spectrum of the noise is different from zero. As we have already observed, the use of an H(v)filter on the spatial frequency plane is equivalent, on the image plane, to a convolution operaa periodical tion of the image itself with a function h(r) = Y-'[H(v)].For structure, the H(v)filter is different from zero only on the points of the reciprocal lattice, and the convolution function in fact becomes the lattice of the structure itself. In this case the convolution is simply the superimposition of the image on itself, successively translated by whole multiples of its spacing. The result of this filtering procedure consists in obtaining an idealized version of the image (Taylor and Ranniko, 1974) in which the imperfections and irregularities are almost eliminated. When carrying out this type of image processing, however, it is reasonable to remember that the results may be considered satisfactory only if we have good reason to believe that the studied structure is effectively regular and ordered and that the defects d o not have a structural meaning. 2 . Zonal Filter'ing of Phase Images
The spectrum of the electron-optical image produced by a weak object of phase is adequately described (see Section II,A) by
.F[Ci(r)] = A(v).T(v)
(104)
38
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
where A(v) is the Fourier spectrum of the object of phase and T ( v )is the C T F of the electron-optical channel. In the band of spatial frequencies that fall within the objective aperture the CTF usually has several zeros, in correspondence with which it changes sign (see, for example, Fig. 1). The frequencies transferred on the image with an inverted sign limit the resolution within the spatial frequency band that precedes the first zero of the CTF. We must then expect that the contrast of structural details, the size of which corresponds to higher frequencies, is greatly lowered if not actually inverted in sign. Consequently, one way of improving image resolution is that ofeliminating the frequencies transferred with inverted contrast (Hoppe, 1963, 1971 ; Mollenstadt et al., 1968). The filtering of these frequencies can be obtained by a binary amplitude filter H ( v ) designed in such a way as to have its apertures in correspondence with the spatial frequencies transferred with the same sign (Thon and Siegel, 1970; Hanszen, 1973). The corrected image, as it results from zonal filtering on the focal plane, is then given by ci(r) = F-' [ H ( v ). T(v) ~ ( v ) ]
(105) In the case of a point object, the restoration of the image thus performed optimizes the contrast (Lenz, 1970). In effect the spectrum of a point object is a constant, A(v) = c 0 , and its reconstructed image after zonal filtering, from Eq. (126), is given by ci(r) = e0 * r ' [ H ( v )* T ( v ) ] (106) +
The contrast at the center of the image is then simply Cl(0) = const. x ( H ( v ) . T ( v ) ) (107) taking into account that the Fourier transform in the origin is proportional to the mean value of the function on which it operates. Obviously, if H ( v ) = 1 for all of the frequencies present on the image (no filtering), the contrast Ci(0) will turn out to be lowered because of the contributions of the opposite signs in the average. On the other hand, Cl(0) will be a maximum if the filter H(v) is designed in such a way as to eliminate either all of the negative contribution (maximum positive contrast) or else all of the positive contributions (maximum negative contrast) from the average given by Eq. (107). For the correct design of a zonal filter it is necessary to know the CTF in the working conditions in which the image was obtained. This is because the positions of the zeros of the CTF depend on the particular image defocusing. Furthermore, when the astigmatism is not exactly compensated the CTF no longer has rotational symmetry and this introduces the critical problem of the azimuthal orientation of the filter.
39
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
3. Separation of Superimposed Images It has already been discussed in the preceding sections that an electron micrograph is a projection of the specimen on the plane of the photographic plate. For example, in the case of a specimen observed in negative contrast, for which the image is that provided from the distribution of the negative stain around the specimen, both the near and far surfaces with respect to the supporting film contribute to the final image on which they turn out to be superimposed (Klug and De Rosier, 1966). Considering a case like the preceding one in which the final image M ( x , y) is provided by two independent components spatially superimposed M , ( x , y) and M , ( x , y) (this type of reasoning could be extended to any number of components), we can write M(x9 Y ) = M l b , Y) + M , ( x , Y ) The spatial spectrum of the image will be
F[M(x, Y)] = =
7
+ M,(V< v,) I f=P[icpl(V< > VJI
v,)
I Ml(V<
>
(108)
9
VJ
(109) + I M,(vt v,) I exP[icp2(v< 4 1 in which F M l = I A?, I exp icpl and F M , = I M , I exp icp, . The intensity distribution on the opticil transform is then given by 7
IS[M(x,
Y ) l l2 = 1 A&
2
7
v,)
+ 2IMAve
I' + I @,(Vt v,)l lM,(VC
3
v,)
3
v,)l
x COS['Pl ( V < ? v,) - 432(V< 9
v,)l
9
l2 (110)
If the transforms of the two component images are spatially separate, i.e., if the term of interference 21M,I IM,I cos(cp, - cp,) of Eq. (110) is everywhere zero on the plane of spatial frequencies, it is possible to contruct an amplitude filter that completely eliminates the contribution of one of the component images, for example 1 A,12, leaving the contribution of the other 1 M , l2 unchanged. In this case, the resulting reconstructed image contains only the M , ( x , y) component of the original image. We must observe, nonetheless, that the interference term in Eq. (110) can never be supposed identically zero. In fact, in the origin of the spatial frequency plane, the transforms MI and M 2 turn out to be necessarily different from zero and the reconstructed one-side image will have a continuous component increased in amplitude. This will bring about a reduction of contrast, especially for the higher frequencies. Also assuming this effect as negligible, it is possible to realize the separation of the component images only if the latter are periodical and very regular (Klug and De Rosier, 1966;
40
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
Donelli and Paoletti, 1972; Horne and Markham, 1972; Lake, 1972). In such conditions, in fact, the transforms correspond to lattices which, being constituted by discrete points, can result as separate. Even in this case, however, we can imagine situations in which there is notable interference (Taylor and Ranniko, 1974). In spite of its limitations, the described technique can be useful when the filtering is carried out correctly, i.e., when the reciprocal lattices of the two images are exactly indexed. The reconstructed image, however, must be used with great caution, keeping in mind that such an image is substantially predetermined by the filter used (Taylor and Ranniko, 1974). In cases in which the superimposed images do not present elements of periodicity, the interference cannot in any way be considered negligible and a simple binary filter will not allow for a correct separation of the image.
REFERENCES Ageno, M., Donelli G, and Guglielmi F. (1973). Micron 4, 376. Berger, J. E. (1969). J . Cell B i d . 43, 442. Berger, J. E. (1972). In “Optical Transforms” (M. Lipson, ed.), p. 401. Academic Press, New York. Born, M., and Wolf, E. (1959). “Principles of Optics.” Pergamon, Oxford. Bracewell, R. (1965). “The Fourier Transform and its Applications.” McGraw-Hill, New York. Bradley, D. E. (1967). In “Techniques for Electron Microscopy” (D. Kay, ed.), p. 96. Blackwell, Oxford. Burge, R. E. (1973). J . Microsc. (Oxford) 98, 251. Burge, R. E., and Garrard, D. F. (1968). J . Phys. E 1, 715. Burge, R. E., Garrard, D. F., and Browne, M. T. (1968). J. Phys. E 1, 707. Cochran, W., Crick, F. H. C., and Vand, V. (1952). Acta Crystallogr. 5, 581. Collier, R. I., Burckhardt, C. B., and Lin, L. H. (1971). “Optical Holography.” Academic Press, New York. Cosslett, V. E. (1965). In “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. H. Zeitler, eds.), p. 24. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Crick, R. A., and Misell, D. L. (1971). J. Phys. D 4, 1. Crowther, R. A., De Rosier, D. J., and Klug, A. (1970). Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 317, 319. De Rosier, D. J., and Klug, A. (1968). Nature (London)217, 130. De Rosier, D. J., and Moore, P. B. (1970). J. Mol. Biol. 52, 355. Donelli G., and Paoletti L. (1972). Ann. 1st. Super. Sanitd 8, 197. Donelli G., Guglielmi F., Rosati Valente, F., and Tangucci, F. (1970). Ann. 1st. Super. Sanitd 6, 88. Donelli G., Guglielmi, F., and Paoletti L. (1972). J. Mol. Biol. 71, 113. Donelli G., DUva, V., and Paoletti, L. (1975). J. Ultrastruct. Res. 50, 253. Eisenhandler, C. B., and Siegel, 9. M. (1966). J . Appl. Phys. 37, 1613. Enloe, L. H. (1967). Bell Syst. Tech. J . 46, 1479. Erickson, H. P. (1973). Adu. Opt. Electron Microsc. 5, 163. Erickson, H. P., and Klug, A. (1971). Phil. Trans. R . SOC.London, Ser. B 261, 105.
ELECTRON MICROGRAPH ANALYSIS
41
Frank, J. (1973). In “Advanced Techniques in Biological Electron Microscopy” (I. K. Koehler, ed.), p. 215. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. Fraser, R. D. B., and Millward, G. R. (1970). J. Ultrastruct. Res. 31, 203. Garrod, R. J., and Nankivell, J. F. (1958). Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 9, 214. Glick, A. J. (1965). In “Qualitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. M. Zeitler, eds.), p. 49. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Goldfischer, L. I. (1965). J . Opt. SOC.Am. 55, 247. Hall, C. E. (1953). “Introduction to Electron Microscopy.” McGraw-Hill, New York. Hanszen, K. J. (197 1). Adu. Opt. Electron Microsc. 4, 1. Hanszen, K. J. (1973). In “Image Processing and Computer-aided Design in Electron Optics” (P. W. Hawkes, ed.), p. 16. Academic Press, New York. Harburn, G., and Ranniko, J. K. (1971). J . Phys. E 4, 394. Hawkes, P. W. (1973). “Image Processing and Computer-aided Design in Electron Optics.” Academic Press, New York. Heidenreich, R. D. (1964). ‘‘ Fundamentals of Transmission Electron Microscopy.” Wiley (Interscience), New York. Helmcke, J. C. (1965). I n “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. M. Zeitler, eds.), p. 195. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Henderson, W. J., and Griffiths, K. (1972). I n “Principles and Techniques of Electron Microscopy” (M. A. Hayat, ed.), p. 151. Van Nostrand-Reinhold, New York. Hoppe, W. (1963). Optik 20, 599. Hoppe, W. (1971). Phil. Trans. R. SOC.London, Ser. B 261, 71. Horne, R. W, and Markham, R. (1972). I n “Practical Methods in Electron Microscopy” (A. M. Glauert, ed.), vol. 1, Part 11, p. 327. North-Holland Publ., Amsterdam. Johansen, B. V. (1973). Micron 4, 446. Klug, A. (1971). Phil. Trans. R. SOC.London, Ser. B 261, 173. Klug, A,, and Berger, J. E. (1964). J . Mol. Biol. 10, 565. Klug, A., and De Rosier, D. J. (1966). Nature (London)212, 29. Klug, A., Crick, F. H. C., and Wyckoff, H. W. (1958). Acta Crystallogr. 11, 199. Lake, J. A. (1972). I n “Optical Transforms” (H. Lipson, ed.), p. 153. Academic Press, New York. Lenz, F. (1965). In “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. H. Zeitler, eds.), p. 70. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Len& F. (1970). Lect. Inr. Summer Sch. Electron Microsc., Erice, April, 1970. Lipson, H. (1972). “Optical Transforms.” Academic Press, New York. Markham, R. (1968). Methods Yirol. 4, 503. Marton, L. L. (1965). I n “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. M. Zeitler, eds.), p. 1. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Misell, D. L. (1973). Adu. Electron. Electron Phys. 32, 64. Mollenstadt, G., Speidel, R., Hoppe, W., Langer, R., Katerban, K. K., and Thon, F. (1968). Electron Microsc., Proc. Eur. Reg. Con& 4th, Rome 1, 125. Moody, M. F. (1967). J . Mol. Biol. 25, 167. Moody, M. F. (1971). Phil. Trans. R. SOC.London, Ser. B 261, 181. Ohlendorf, D. H., Collins, M. L., and Banaszak, L. J. (1975). J . Mol. Biol. 99, 143. Radi, G. (1970). Acta Crystallogr., Sect. A 26, 41. Reimer, L., Roessner, A., Themann, M., and von Bassewitz, D. B. (1973). J. Ultrastruct. Res. 45, 356.
Scherzer, 0. (1965). In “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. M. Zeitler, eds.), p. 59. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland.
42
G. DONELLI AND L. PAOLETTI
Shamir, J. (1972). I n “Optical Transforms” (H. Lipson, ed.), p. 299. Academic Press, New York. Sjostrand, F. S . (1958). J . Llltrastruct. Res. 2, 122. Stroke, G. W. (1966). “An Introduction to Coherent Optics and Holography.” Academic Press, New York. Taylor, C. A., and Lipson, H. (1964). “Optical Transforms.” Bell, London. Taylor, C. A., and Ranniko, J. K. (1974). J . Microsc. (Oxford) 100. 307. Thompson, B. J. (1972). I n “Optical Transforms” (H. Lipson, ed.), p. 267. Academic Press, New York. Thon, F. (1966). 2. Naturforsch. A 21, 476. Thon, F., and Siegel, B. M. (1970). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 74, 1116. Valentine, R. C. (1969). Adv. Opt. Electron Microsc. 1, 180. Vander Lugt, A. (1966). Proc. I E E E 54, 1055. Vander, Lugt, A. (1968). Opt. Acta 15, 1. Wells, 0. C. (1960). Brit. J. Appl. Phys. 11, 199. Whelan, M. J. (1965). J. Appl. Phys. 36,2099. Williams, R., and Kallman, F. (1955). J . Biophys. Biochem. Cytol. 1, 301. Yoshioka, H. (1957). J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 12, 618. Zeitler, E. (1965). I n “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. H. Zeitler, eds.), p. 36. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland. Zeitler, E.(1968). Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 25, 277. Zeitler, E., and Hayes, J. R. (1965). I n “Quantitative Electron Microscopy” (G. F. Bahr and E. M. Zeitler, eds.), p. 586. Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Maryland.
Recent Advances in Electron Beam Addressed Memories JOHN KELLY* Stanford Research Institute, Menlo Park, California
........................
43
................................
44
I. Introduction .............................. B. Motivation ........................................... 111. Storage Media . . . . . . A. Requirements . . . B. Media Types . . . . . . . IV. Surface Charge Storage A. Williams Storage ...........................
............ VI. Alternative Storage A. Amorphous Sem B. Magnetic Storag
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56
. . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 ............. 99 .............
D. Ferroelectric Media .................................. VII. Electron-Optical Systems ............................................
............................
112 112
......................
135
ents .........
.I. INTRODUCTION
The promise of the electron beam as a means of addressing large quantities of digital information with high speed and low systems cost has intrigued many workers since the early days of modern computing machines. The major advantage of any beam memory, whether photons, electrons, or
* Present address: HP Laboratories, Hewlett-Packard Company, 1501 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, California, 94304. 43
44
JOHN KELLY
ions, lies in its ability to address a location (or locations) on a storage surface randomly from the third dimension. The beam is a flexible interconnection that eliminates the need for extensive hard wiring and, as such, introduces considerable flexibility into the memory design itself. Additionally, relatively large amounts of data can be stored, using few components, with the consequent advantage of low cost. This review is limited to electron beam addressed memories (EBAMs) with emphasis focused on write/read systems rather than on data recording. The objective is to review the current status of research and, in so doing, stimulate activity in an area that appears fundamentally attractive. The references are extensive but not exhaustive. Unfortunately, because much of the work in this field has not been published, it is not generally available to the researcher. It is also significant that a memory device that achieves the fundamental limits of beam physics is still a long way from being realized. It is now possible, however, to predict the appearance of 10’ ’-lO1’-bit memory systems, with access times in the range of 1-10 p e c for the smaller systems and on the order of 1 msec for the larger. Systems of 107-109 bits are already in commercial development.
11. BACKGROUND A . Early Developments
In 1948, F. C. Williams and T. Kilburn ( I ) of the University of ManChester, England, reported the storage of digital information as a charge pattern on the screen of a cathode-ray tube. Eckert, Lukof€, and Smoliar published similar findings in 1950 (2) and referred to work dating back to 1946 at the University of Pennsylvania. At MIT, J. W. Forrester discussed high-speed electrostatic storage at a symposium in January 1947 (3). The tube developed used charge stored on conducting islands on a dielectric plate and was described by Dodd et al. in 1950 (4). These tubes were employed in the first Whirlwind computer in 1951 (5). During the following years, considerable activity was directed toward the application of the so-called “ Williams tube ” to information storage. In many cases, the tube was no more than a standard oscillograph tube, such as the 3KP1 (6).An improved Williams tube was developed by Mutter (7) and used in the IBM 701 computer in 1953 (8, 9 ) .The reason cited by Buchholz for the use of the electrostatic memory was the “practical combination of high operating speed and adequate storage capacity,” plus a short randomaccess time that “permitted instructions to be stored at any location and in any order without affecting speed or performance.” The IBM 701 electrosta-
45
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
tic memory consisted of 72 tubes, making a total of 2048 words of 36 bits each, and the effective cycle time was 12 psec. The Williams tubes (IBM 85s) were mounted in pairs in 36 pluggable drawers. The basic components of nearly all EBAM tubes can be illustrated by the Williams tube shown in Fig. 1. An electron gun generates a beam of elec-
OUTPUT READOUT SYSTEM ELECTRON GUN
LENS
STORAGE TARGET
FIG. 1. The basic components of an electron beam addressed memory (EBAM) tube.
trons, which is focused by a lens into a small diameter on the storage target. The beam size in the target plane is usually close to the actual data-bit size. The beam stores information by causing some physical change in the storage medium that can be detected at a later time by the reading beam. The location of information in the target plane is determined by directing the beam by means of an appropriate deflector to a particular bit site. This is the random-access mode. Alternatively, scanning in a TV rasterlike mode is also possible and can be used to achieve very high operating speeds in a block-oriented mode. For readout, a means for detecting the stored physical change must be provided. In the Williams tube, charge was stored on the insulating phosphor surface (often willemite). The presence of this charge could be determined by monitoring the ac target current on a collector electrode located on the faceplate of the tube. Signals were detected by capacitative coupling through the glass of the faceplate. A number of major problems were associated with the basic Williams tube. The major difficulty was the effect of “spill ” or read-around ratio, which is a form of bit interference in which repeated addressing of a particular storage location can modify nearby information. This occurs because of electron scattering and redistribution effects within the tube and because the beam itself may have long tails (a small but finite current outside its nominal radius). In the 701, this problem was largely eliminated by scattering sequential addresses throughout the memory. Other problems often encountered were the result of the relatively high incidence of phosphor defects and the occurrence of extraneous noise. The fact that information was stored for only a few tenths of a second motivated several ingenious schemes for regenerating the stored data. In the 701, regeneration was designed in as part of each instruction cycle; one spot
46
JOHN KELLY
in each of the 72 tubes was regenerated during each cycle, in accordance with a counter that specified the location of the next word to be regenerated. Normal operation ensured the regeneration of three locations (216 bits) per instruction executed. Other computers using the Williams tube storage system included the National Bureau of Standards computers SWAC (10)and SEAC (11).These systems used a number of tubes operating in parallel. Typical access times were in the range of 12-16 psec. In addition to the Williams tube developments, there were many related activities, such as the development of the Selectron by Rajchman (12), which, although an extremely complex tube, obviated the need for a precise deflection system. A flood beam uniformly illuminated a matrix consisting of two orthogonal sets of bars. Voltages applied to these bars suppressed the electron emission except in the one area addressed. The information was stored on an “eyelet” located behind the bars. This could be charged to either of two stable states, one more negative than the cathode, so that when subsequently addressed in the read mode, electrons were either permitted to pass or not, depending on the stored charge. The transmitted beam was collected in an array of Faraday cells for readout, or could be viewed on a phosphor screen for monitoring. The selection mechanism appears to be the most significant aspect of the tube design because it is unique. Figure 2 illustrates how electrons are transmitted only when the four address bars surrounding the selected window are made positive. If one bar (or more) is negative, the electrons are either repelled or collected on the positive bars. The number of leads required to operate this address system is 4N’’4,where N is the number of windows. As a result, 16 leads are required for a 256-bit tube, 32 for a 4096-bit tube, or 128 for 1 Mbit. Other advantages of this tube included indefinite information storage by means of a holding beam, an access time of approximately 5 psec, and the possibility of nondestructive readout. In practice, the tube capacity is severely limited by the complexity and hence by the ultimate bit cost. Another development was the Radechon, or barrier grid storage tube, which was developed initially for the comparison of successive signals. [For a review, see Kazan and Knoll (13).]The storage of binary information was investigated by several workers, including Hines et al. ( 2 4 ) and Greenwood and Staehler (15). This tube uses a dielectric target with a fine-mesh barrier grid in contact with the surface, and it operates in the region for which the secondary emission coefficient is greater than unity. In binary storage, the surface is charged either to ground or slightly negative potential. Readout is accomplished by capacitative coupling to the target or by the collection of secondary electrons from the front of the target. In operation, it was found possible to store considerably more information (16,OOO bits) per tube than
47
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
SELECTING GRID Y DIRECTION
SELECTING G R I D
) t t t t t t t I, \
V
/
O V E R A L L ELECTRON B O M B A R D M E N T
FIG. 2. The unique address mechanism as used in the Selectron. Individual windows are opened by the biasing of the four neighboring selection bars [Rajchman (12)].
in the Williams devices, and a memory cycle time of 2.5 psec, including regeneration, was achieved. In certain applications, however, read-around problems became a major limitation. B. Motivation
In the early 1950s there were few good memory devices. The magnetic core [see Forrester (16)] was just beginning to appear, and the only other systems in regular use were magnetic drums and acoustic delay lines. As a result, the development of the Williams tube as a random-access high-speed
48
JOHN KELLY
memory was significant; memories of 2000 words, as in the IBM 701, were considered large. Today, a wealth of on-the-shelf memory technologies is available. This is illustrated in Fig. 3, where memory capacity is shown as a function of access time for a variety of technologies; at the slow-access end are the mechanical
1014
1012
OPTICAL-
1o4
102
10-8
10-6
o-~
1 10-2 ACCESS TIME - seconds
1
102
FIG.3. Memory technologies; capacity and access time.
devices (disks, drums, and the laser type of film storage memory) and a t the fast-access end are the mainframe memories (bipolar, MOS, and core). The emerging memory technologies (EBAMs, charge-coupled devices, and bubbles) appear in the so-called “access gap” ( 1 7 ) between 1 psec and 10 msec. The EBAM “bubble” represents 10’- to 109-bit systems currently in development or preproduction phases. Not shown are the fast-access optical memories that have reached the preproduction stage (18-20), but
49
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
may eventually compete directly with EBAMs below a capacity of 10"bits. Figure 4 illustrates the development of the beam-addressed memory technology, from the first Williams tubes at the bottom, to the projected developments at the top. The zone between lo9 and 10'' bits represents memory systems with totally electronic access that may be developed
10'2
-
10'0
-
1014
c n .n
I
Y
108
> 0
106
lo4
1
FUTURE EBAMS (with mechanical motion)
FUTURE EBAMS (no mechanical motion)
-
-
-
-
-
E
!
1
I
-
> k
$
1
EBAMS I N DEVELOPMENT
-
I
FIRST WILLIAMS
102
10-8
10-6
1o
-~
ACCESS TIME
10-2
1
102
- seconds
FIG.4. EBAM technology: past, present, and future?
through emerging technologies. The use of mechanical motion must be invoked somewhere between 10' and loi3 bits, thereby slowing the access time by several orders of magnitude. EBAMs have the largest advantage for systems of 1010-1015bits because it appears practical to fabricate these systems a t low cost and with an absolute minimum of mechanical movement. Such systems could also have low volume, high data rates, and excellent reliability.
50
JOHN KELLY
The major reasoning for this projection is based on the knowledge that the present concepts still d o not approach the basic physical limits of an electron beam system. Consider the properties of a 1-keV electron beam: equivalent wavelength: 12 A ; beam velocity: 1.88 cm/nsec; beam current in 100-h; spot at 500 A/cmZ (already approached in some commercially available scanning electron microscopes): 3.95 x 10- l o A, or 25 electrons/lO nsec; deflection speed: an amplifier with a slew rate of loo0 V/psec (some EBS devices already achieve lo5 V/psec) and a deflector sensitivity of 10 V/cm would produce a scan rate of lo* bits/psec for 100-h; bits; depth of focus: 100r (or better), where r is the spot radius. These considerations lead one to believe that systems with 100-A bit size, achieving 10' bits/cm2 and access times of less than 1 psec, may be possible in the foreseeable future. However, the technology has not reached that level; and it is an objective of this review to indicate the level of current achievement, study some projections, and point out a few of the hazards. It is interesting to consider what it is that makes this technology appear much more attractive now than it was in the late 1950s.The fact is that there have been major advances in the following supporting technologies that greatly enhance the performance, reliability, and other specifications of these systems: Electronics. An EBAM relies heavily on highly stable electronic components, such as have only recently become available. For example, it is now possible to purchase, off the shelf and at low cost, the required high-voltage power supplies with stabilities of better than 1 part in lo4. It is also possible to obtain sufficiently precise digital-to-analog converters with settling times in the microsecond range. Electron optics. The art of gun-and-lens design has improved substantially with the use of computers to aid in the theoretical design. The factors necessary to produce reliable stable performance are now understood ; this knowledge has been gained in the tube industry and from the development of such instruments as the scanning electron microscope. In addition, there have been major improvements in deflector design, such as the octupole (21, 22) and the deflectron by Schlesinger (23). Cathode life. Dispenser cathodes with a proven life in excess of 10,000 hr and a potential of 50,000 hr are now available. Historically, the cathode has been a limiting factor in the operational life of a tube. The availability of these cathodes has resolved this problem. Silicon technology. Advances in methods of fabrication and understanding of material properties have not only aided the construction of better
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
51
support electronics, but have revealed new opportunities for the storage medium itself. Vacuum technology. This technology has advanced steadily over the past ten years. Economical and rugged construction methods, in addition to better materials, are now available.
MEDIA 111. STORAGE A. Requirements
The selection of a suitable storage medium is probably the most important factor in the design of an EBAM because the storage target determines most of the parameters of memory construction and performance, including volatility, error rate, temperature range, beam diameter and energy, current density, electronics requirements, and readout configuration. It may also govern the life of the tube. A storage medium should be composed of inherently good vacuum materials that will not contaminate the other components in the system. It must operate efficiently over a wide temperature range, preferably centered on room temperature. It should represent only a small fraction of the overall cost of the memory tube and should have an operational life of at least five to ten years of continuous use. Even in a write-once system, the need for any type of development process should be avoided so that information is available immediately after being written. An adequate shelf life for unused media is also desirable. An ideal storage target would present a structureless surface to the electron beam so that an address location would be determined by the impact point of the deflected beam and not by the structure on the target. The alternatives are to make the structure fine in comparison t o the beam dimensions and then treat the surface as continuous (the quasi-continuous mode) or provide some fiducial mark system on the target to assist in locating the stored information. The structure on the target itself might be used for addressing and data tracking. Many materials and operating systems have been proposed for use in EBAMs. The principal efforts, however, are currently focused on silicon targets and electrostatic charge storage. The properties of an ideal storage target are described below. 1. Volatility
Any medium used for a very large memory should offer nonvolatile storage. If an archival capability is not required, however, a storage time of
52
JOHN KELLY
several hours may constitute nonvolatility, particularly if a .means can be provided for regenerating or refreshing the stored information. 2. WritelReadlErase Cycling Very large memories (such as 10" bits and more) may be acceptable as write-once systems; however, the ability to use the medium in a read-mostly situation adds considerable flexibility. In systems on the order of 108-10' bits, erasable memory is very desirable. There is increasing emphasis on the achievement of high data rates (100 Mbitlsec or more), and the medium should be capable of high operating speeds or parallel usage. Access times should also be considered. Clear distinction must be made between any limitations imposed by the electronics and the electron-optical system and those related to the beam-interaction properties of the medium itself. A major application of the intermediate size of memory (108-10'obits) appears to be in secondary mainframe storage, and therefore an access time of approximately 1 psec appears desirable. 3. Discrimination and Signal-to-Noise Ratio
Any storage medium in combination with the readout system must provide adequate discrimination between binary ONES and ZEROS and an adequate signal-to-noise ratio to obtain acceptably low error rates. When very high bit densities are required and beams of very high resolution are used, device performance will often be limited by quantum statistics. As a result, in the limiting system, a design should evolve that would obtain an optimal error rate with the minimum number of signal particles; this can be achieved when the contrast ratio is maximized. To further illustrate, the expected error rate can be calculated under the following conditions ( 2 4 ) : Elements are either ONE or ZERO, with a probability of 0.5 for each state. The mean numbers ofelectrons arriving in the readout system are n, from the ONE state and no from the ZERO state, n, > n o . The readout system, including the amplifier, contributes negligible noise compared to n o . Based on the number of electrons arriving in the readout system, a decision must be made concerning the ONE or ZERO condition. If a Poisson distribution is assumed, the probability of collecting & electrons is P ( k 1 ni) = ( ni)'ee-"'I&! where i = 0 or 1 depending on the stored information.
(1)
53
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
An appropriate decision strategy is to select the state with the highest posterior probability. A level A can be determined so that the following choice can be made:
ONE
if k 2 A
ZERO
if k c A
The decision mechanism is illustrated in Fig. 5. The curves represent the I 0.3
I
I
I
1
I
*A f’ A
CHOOSE
ZERO
:i:
1
I
I
1
CHOOSE ONE
m
g
0.2
g W
F
4,
=
0.1
0
2
FIG. 5. Decision strategy employed in determining ZEROs and ONEs. The curves plotted are for equal occurrences of ONEs and ZEROs; an expected count of 10 for a ONE, and 3 for a ZERO.
probability that a given number of counts will be made. The shaded areas therefore denote the probability of an error. The probability that a ONE will be read as a ZERO is
A similar probability exists that ZERO will be interpreted as ONE:
P(k > A 1 no) =
x
C ni k = ~
e-no ~
k!
54
JOHN KELLY
Because it has been assumed that the two states occur with equal frequency,
Values of P , are plotted in Fig. 6 as a function of the contrast ratio n, /no. lo-loo
a
0
a
IT:
10-4
w
U
0
10-2
> k
J
m
0.1
20
0.2
E
0.3 0.5 1
2
5
10
20
CONTRAST R A T I O
50
100
200
500
- nl/nO
FIG.6. The probability of error in making a ONEjZERO decision, plotted as a function of contrast ratio for a given number of ONE state counts.
Each curve indicates a given number of signal events n,. The value of these calculations is that they show dramatically how the contrast ratio n, /no becomes increasingly significant as the number of events is reduced. The curves indicate that an error rate of is possible with only 100 signal electrons if a contrast ratio of 100: 1 is achieved. These requirements may be relaxed if error-correcting codes are used. 4. Destructive and Nondestructive Readout
Stored information should not be destroyed during readout. This is obviously true in archival systems, and it can also be significant in nonarchival systems when extremely low error rates are required because it is then possible to reread data on the detection of a parity error.
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
55
5 . I n Situ Gain The signals derived from storage media used at high bit density are apt to be small. To optimize the statistics of the readout system, a localized gain mechanism is desirable. In some systems, such gain can be provided by hole-electron pair production from the incident beam or by a built-in electron multiplier. 6 . Beam Energy
The choice of beam energy is largely determined by the storage target and its mode of operation. It is generally better, however, to minimize the required voltage because high voltages are a source of unreliability, and even microdischarges may be detected by a sensitive readout system. On the other hand, one of the factors that limits current density at the target is beam brightness. The Langmuir limit is J , = J,[(eV/kT) = /3(
+ 11 sin2 a,
V) n sin2 a,
where J o is the cathode current density, V the beam voltage, T the effective cathode temperature, and a, the beam half-angle at the target. In most cases, the brightness is proportional to the voltage, and the current density and the writing rate increase proportionately. This is an oversimplification and will be discussed further in Section VII.
B. Media Types In principle, a wide selection of storage media is available. Most media fall into two categories: those suitable for read/write systems and those suitable for archival memories. In read/write systems, there are three principal methods for storing information: charge storage in a dielectric surface (used directly or to modify some other physical property, such as conductivity or optical properties); the use of thermal effects to cause physical change (in semiconductor or magnetic surfaces); radiation damage (e.g., inhibition of color center luminescence in the alkali halides). The actual mode of usage depends on the selection of a readout technique, such as secondary electron emission, induced target current, photon emission, or optical absorption properties. In archival storage, it is possible to consider the following additional processes :
56
JOHN KELLY
selective removal by: sputtering removal of the surface films or adsorbed layers; electron-stimulated chemical reaction; electron desorption; preferential deposition: activated nucleation by preactivation or simultaneous bombardment with ionization; ion deposition, at low energy, or involving some endothermal reaction to assist in localization; physical change: ion-bombardment damage or implantation; radiation damage of molecules or structures. Although there are many possibilities for archival storage, nearly all the research to date has centered on the use of film (e.g., the IBM 1360 Photo Store) or thermoplastic materials (25). The most thoroughly explored area for read/write erasable stores has been that of charge storage. It is also significant that much of the recent work in this area involves charge storage in or on the dielectric grown on a siIicon wafer. This is due to both the excellent silicon technoldgy available and the fine qualities of thermally grown silicon dioxide (dielectric strength greater than 10’ V/cm, loss factor resistivity up to 10l6Q cm). In related, but unpublished work at CBS Labs, charge storage in SiO, deposited on a variety of substrates, including metal foils and glass, has created the possibility of high-density storage (- lo7 bits/cm2) over large surface areas.
-
IV. SURFACE CHARGE STORAGE The basis of charge storage has evolved from the Williams and Radechon storage concepts. These will be described briefly as an introduction to the later microcapacitor and MOS storage media. A . Williams Storage
In the Williams concept, the charge pattern is stored on the phosphor of a CRT (usually willemite) (1). It is well known (13, 26) that many materials have a total secondary emission coefficient 6 that is greater than unity for primary beam energies of 1-2 keV. Thus when a surface is bombarded with a primary beam for which 6 > 1, more electrons leave than arrive and the target tends to charge positively. If the beam is stationary, it creates a “well” for electrons as shown in Fig. 7. The negative potential ring around the well is created by some of the slower secondary electrons which are drawn back to the phosphor by the positive potential of the well. If they have an energy that produces a secondary emission coefficient of less than unity (6 < l), they will produce a net negative charge. This particular condition results in a stable state because the depth of the well is determined by the secondary emission coefficient and
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
57
PRIMARY BEAM
DIELECTRIC SURFACE
+ + + + +
FIG.7. The creation of a potential well (for electrons) by the bombardment of a dielectric surface having 6 > 1 [Williams and Kilburn ( I ) ] .
the associated velocity spread. As the well becomes increasingly positive, progressively more secondary electrons are prevented from escaping. The final depth is reached when the effective secondary emission coefficient drops to unity at a typical potential of 3.eV. Readout of this state is illustrated in Figs. 8a and 8b. As stated above, this potential “well” is a stable condition and, on being “interrogated” by the read beam, only a small negative pulse is detected by the output amplifier. This was attributed by Williams to the arrival of negative charge in the vicinity of the screen when the beam was turned on.
58
JOHN KELLY
The provision of a second state relies on the interaction between an existing potential well and the creation of a nearby potential well (Fig. 8c). Because the existing well at site 1 is positive, it attracts some of the lowvelocity secondary electrons from the well being created at site 2. These electrons charge the first well negatively (fill it). Consequently, a reading beam that addresses site 1 first, then site 2 produces a positive going pulse as
TIME
-
FIG.8. Stored potentials and readout process used in the Williams tube: (a) ZERO state, single charged potential well; (b) output detected during bombardment of a single isolated (ZERO state) potential well; (c) ONE state, double spot potential distribution; (d) output detected during bombardment of locations ( 1 ) then (2). After Williams and Kilburn ( I ) .
a result of the re-creation of the well at site 1, then a longer low-level negative pulse caused by the refilling of the well as site 2 is bombarded (Fig, 8d). The negative pulse shown in Fig. 8b is swamped by the positive pulse. Williams found that the effect was maximized at a separation of approximately l.ld, where d is the beam diameter. In memory operation the ONE state can be generated by a moving beam that progresses from site 1 to site 2, thereby writing a dash; therefore, ZEROS and ONES correspond to dots and dashes. The reading process can be used to regenerate the stored information because the existence of a dot or a dash is detected whenever site 1 is addressed. If a dash is detected, the beam is left on as it moves to site 2, thereby refilling the initial well and rewriting the. ONE.
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
59
B. The Radechon
In the Radechon information is stored on a bare dielectric (often mica) with a so-called “barrier grid in coincidence with the surface, as illustrated in Fig. 9 (13). As in the Williams tubes, 6 > 1; however, the presence of the ”
ELECTRON BEAM
G R I DER BARRl
U
M E T A L BACKPLATE
FIG.9. The Radechon storage target. A barrier grid in contact with the dielectric target surface creates a stable potential to which the dielectric surface is always returned under electron bombardment [Kazan and Knoll (13)].
barrier grid modifies the charging process. Under bombardment the isolated surface tends to equilibrium at the potential of the most positive electrode in the vicinity of the target (the barrier grid). If the dielectric surface is negative with respect to the grid, secondary electrons will emerge from the surface and, if 6 > 1, it will charge positively. On the other hand, if the surface is positive with respect to the grid, secondary electrons from the dielectric surface and from the grid will be drawn back to the dielectric, thereby reducing 6 below 1 and causing the surface to charge negatively. Both operations equilibrate with the dielectric at a small positive voltage, at which point the effective secondary emission coefficient 6 is unity. The actual voltage (V,,), typically 2 V, depends on the velocity spread of the emission and the geometry. The dielectric surface is coupled capacitatively to the backplate such that a positive potential applied to the backplate sets an initially uncharged dielectric surface positive, and locations bombarded with the electron beam are set back to t,.Subsequent removal of the backplate bias leaves the
60
JOHN KELLY
surface with a pattern of charges-negative where bombardment occurred and zero elsewhere. The beam therefore tends to set the surface to a potential ( - Vbias), and both positive and negative charges can be stored depending on the sign of I/bias. Readout is accomplished by monitoring the capacitative current flowing through the backplate as the beam discharges the charge pattern to Kq. In digital storage, ZEROs and ONEs are typically represented by stored potentials of Kq and - Kimso that a ZERO gives essentially no output and a ONE produces a positive pulse (14). An alternative method of readout depends on the collection of secondary electrons by means of a collector placed in front of the target. Because more secondary electrons escape the target when it is negatively charged than , and ZEROs can be distinguished by means of a when it is at t qONEs discriminator. Typical ratios achieved are only 1.5 : 1 or 1.3 : 1 [Greenwood and Staehler (15)], thus making adequate discrimination difficult. Typical problems with the Radechon were caused by variations in the secondary emission coefficient across the surfaces. Mica was often used as the dielectric target, and it was found that the nonuniformity could be improved by evaporating a thin layer of magnesium fluoride onto the surface (27). Other problems encountered included “shading,” or variation of the signals across the target surface, and relatively poor read-around numbers. Many of these difficulties have been resolved by the application of modern technology and materials. C . The Microcapacitor (or “ Mucap”) Storage Medium
The microcapacitor (“ mucap ”) storage medium was originally proposed by Shoulders in 1964 (28); and although it is somewhat similar to the Radechon target, it avoids many of the problems. Recent work on this storage MUCAP (MICROCAPACITOR) STORAGE ELECTRODES METAL GATE
1.4 pm
FIG. 10. The microcapacitor or “ mucap” storage medium. Typical mucap dimensions are 0.5-6 pm, hence the name “ mucap.”
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
61
medium and its application to an experimental memory system have been described by Kelly et al. (22, 29, 128, 129). The mucap target (Fig. 10)consists of a metal-oxide-silicon sandwich in which holes have been etched through the metal gate and part way through the dielectric layer. In the bottom of each hole is an isolated metallic electrode, the mucap. The base is low-resistivity silicon and acts solely in a conductive mode. As in the Radechon, the secondary emission coefficient must be greater than unity (6 > 1) for the writing beam (approximately 2 keV). The base potential VB determines the final mucap potential because the mucap is more closely coupled capacitatively to the base than to the gate. The ONE state corresponds to a negative stored charge (with respect to the gate), and a ZERO state corresponds to a small positive charge. The writing process is illustrated in Fig. 11. Initially, the application ofa negative bias V,, (typically -50 V) to the base causes the uncharged mucaps to be set to negative value V, (typically -40 V). This is the ONEstate condition. The write-ZERO sequence is shown in Fig. 1la. Bombardment of the negatively charged mucap with a beam having 6 > 1 charges the target positively until it stabilizes at V,, which is just a few volts positive with respect to the gate potential; V,, therefore represents the ZERO state. This operation is exactly parallel to the stabilization in the Radechon. The second sequence shown in Fig. 1lb is the process of writing a ONE. The first step is to switch the base potential to V , , (0 V). The ZERO-state elements at V, (- 2 eV) initially are thus switched positive by Vo + V, or AV, as given by
A V = (bl - VBO)cb/ca (6) where C, and C, are the capacitances from the mucap to base and mucap to gate, respectively. For typical target geometries, the ratio Cb/Ca has a value close to 0.84, giving A V = 42 V for V,, = -50 V and V,, = 0. The beam is then turned on and, because the mucaps are positive, charge is collected until the stable potential of V, (- 2 V) is reached, as above. At this point, the beam is turned off and the base potential is switched' back to VBo TABLE I READ-WRITEOPERATION REQUIREMENTS FOR MUCAP OPERATION
Operation
Target bias (volts)
Beam on (relative time)
Write ONE Write ZERO Read
0 -50 - 50
100t, 100t,
',
VBo (-50V ) ’1’ STATE
VBO
VBO
‘0’ STATE
BEAM ON
(a)
WRITE ZERO
I “e
VBo (-50 V )
‘ 0 STATE
VB1 = 0
v
VBl = 0
SWITCH BASE
v
BEAM ON
VBo (-50 V )
’1‘ STATE
(b) W R I T E O N E
FIG.11. Writing sequences for ZEROS and ONES: (a)shows the write-ZERO sequence; (b) shows the write-ONE sequence. A secondary emission coefficient of greater than unity is assumed (6 > 1).
63
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
WRITE READ
vss-.,
o,
ZERO
R,
1 I
WRITE ZERO
-
WRITE ONE
-v* A
A
-
A
- -
==ca
FIG.12. The equivalent circuit of the mucap storage medium.
(-50 V). The mucaps are switched through - A V and will be set to V, (-40 V) which is the ONE state. This sequence appears to be rather complex, but in operation it is rather simple. The required switching is illustrated in Table I. A simple analysis of these writing processes is instructive. The equivalent circuit for this target is shown in Fig. 12 in which the principal capacitances are: C,, between the microcapacitor and gate; C b ,between the microcapacitor and base; and C,, between the gate and base. Associated with these capacitances are leakage resistances R , , R, ,and R, . In operation, C, and C , are the most important. Rb and R, are normally high as compared to R, which includes any surface leakage along the walls of the hole. The mucap potential is represented by V, and the capacitance to be charged is the combined capacitances C, and C, (Cab).The beam injects or removes current at point s. 1. Write-ONE Process In the following discussion, a careful distinction must be observed between the emission coefficients for the elastically scattered electrons with roughly primary energy q and the true secondary electrons with low energy 6,. The total secondary emission coefficient is denoted by 6. Assume a beam with current density p, at the storage target surface. As described above, because the mucap is initially positive after switching the base to 0 V (V,,), it collects nearly all the secondaries generated. Elastics and high-velocity secondaries, however, will still escape. The net charge being collected per unit area is - p , t( 1 - q), where t is time and q is the backscattering coefficient. As a result, if the target is initially at a potential V,, the potential changes according to
64
JOHN KELLY
& is determined by the initial mucap potential V, and by the change resulting from switching the base from V,, to VB1,and A V is defined by Eq. (6); therefore,
As V, approaches Vo, an increasing number of secondary electrons escape from the mucap until equilibrium is achieved when V, is reached. (This is implicit in the definition of Vo .) Assume that all secondaries with energy greater than eV, escape. The number of secondaries with energy between eV and e( V + 6 V ) can be represented by N e ( V ) SV, and the fractional number of electrons with energy greater than eV, is
The function F( V,) reduces the net charge being delivered to the mucap at a given time to - p,[l - q - 6, F ( V,)]. It can be seen that the nature of F( V,) ultimately determines the limiting value of V, and the rate at which it is approached. The full equation is
Unfortunately, V, is implicit in this equation, but it can be solved by successive approximations. Applicable data concerning the secondary electron energy distribution are difficult to obtain; however, Stehberger's data for gold (30) can be used and scaled to produce a reasonable approximation. Recent mucaps were made with a platinum surface. The total secondary electron emission and the elastically scattered yield for platinum are plotted in Figs. 13 and 14, respectively. There is a large scatter in the data from Bronshtein and Segal (31, 35), Sternglass (32), Warnecke (33), Copeland ( 3 9 and Palluel (36), and the following representative values were used in the calculation: 6 = 1.60 at 2 keV (total secondaries) q
= 0.43
at 2 keV (elastics)
6, = 1.17 at 2 keV (true secondaries) Cab= 6.27 x F/cm2 p, = 1 A/cm2
Figure 15 shows the calculated solution for the fill1 equation. The straight line illustrates how the mucap potential V, varies with time if F ( V , ) is
65
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES 2.0
I
I
I
I
I
a
1.8
-
1.6
1.4 6
1.2
I
1.o
o Bronshtein (Ref. 31) o Sternglass (Ref. 32) 0Warnecke (Ref. 33) ACopeland (Ref. 34)
0.8
0.6
0
6
12
18
-
24
30
36
PRIMARY ENERGY ( x 100) eV
FIG.13. Total secondary electron emission for platinum, plotted as a function of primary beam energy. Data abstracted from refs. (31-34).
ignored. The final potential V, is 2.7 V. The write time is 0.5 psec for the ONE state (measured to the 10% level). This figure is inversely proportional to the beam current density at the target so that 10 A/cmZ should permit 20-MHz write rates under laboratory conditions and probably 10 MHz in practice. 2. Write-ZERO Process
Analysis of the write-ZERO process is similar to the write-ONE process; however, the mucap is initially negative and, as a result, more electrons will escape than are delivered (6 > 1). The net charge delivered per unit time is +p,(q + 6, - 1 ) or + p , ( 6 - 1). For a target initially at V,, the potential
0.5
0.4
0.3 rl
0.2
0.1
0 0
500
1000
1500
2000 2500 3000 PRIMARY ENERGY - e V
FIG. 14. Elastically scattered electrons for platinum. Electron yield of from Sternglass ( 3 2 ) . Bronshtein and Segal (35),and Palluel (36).
3500
4000
4500
5000
plotted as a function of primary voltage. Data drawn
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES 50
I
I
40
I
pt
-
=
q = 0.43
B
6 = 1.60
I
6 , = 1.17
i 9
c,
I
1A/crn2
2
>- 30
67
= 6.27
1 0 - 9 ~ / ~ ~ 2
Vo = 2.7 V
I2
w I-
2
20
fi
U 0
!i 10
VO
0 TIME
- wsec
FIG. 15. Write ONE curve. The solution of Eq. (12). plotted as a function of time for the inset parameters.
changes according to .
c
v, = v, + p,r q + 0 , - 1
*
cab
As V, approaches V , , however, fewer true secondaries escape until, when V, is a few volts positive, the effective secondary electron emission coefficient is reduced to unity. This can be described in terms of the same function F ( K). The instantaneous charge density delivered to the target is p , [ q 6, F( V,) - 13; therefore, the full equation becomes
+
As before, V, is implicit in this equation and it must be solved by successive approximations. The solution is shown in Fig. 16. The mucap potential
68
JOHN KELLY +lo
"(
C
v)
-
: I
'
-10
1
L 5
+ 2
pt = 1A/crn2
w b
II = 0.43 h, = 1.17
n -20
cab = 6.27 x
w
F
/
~
~
~
a
0
6
-30
-40
0.2
0.4 TIME - psec
0.6
0.8
FIG.16. Write-ZERO curve. The solution to Eq. (14) plotted as a function of time for the inset parameters.
increases in a positive direction until it reaches approximately 2.7 V. The write time for ZEROS, again measured to the 10%level, is 0.42 p e c which is slightly faster than the write time for ONES.This implies that 10 MHz write rates should also be practicable if 10 A/cm2 can be obtained. 3. Discussion It is informative to compare the initial charging rates for the mucap medium:
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
Write ONE: Write ZERO:
69
-Pt(l - q)/cab
pt(q + 6, - l)/Cab In most write-read random-access systems, it is desirable to have approximately equal writing rates for ONES and ZEROs. This requires
6, = 2(1 - q) (13) and the highest writing rates will be obtained with q = 0 and 6, = 2. In the special case of transient storage, however, it would be possible to prime the target to the ONE state and then write ZEROs only, using a high 6, to obtain fast writing. Because secondary emission coefficients as high as 1000 can be obtained with specially prepared surfaces, data rates up to 1 GHz should be obtainable. Restricting the discussion to systems with equal write rates results in a conflict. In practice, the number of elastics q is a well-defined function of atomic number (2)( 3 2 ) and, for 2 > 30, tends to increase with primary beam energy in the region 0-5 keV, as shown in Fig. 14. For 2 < 30, q is fairly constant above 500 eV. To minimize q, a low-atomic-number material is required. On the other hand, Sternglass (37) has shown that, among the elements, the maximum true secondary emission yield can be obtained with the higher atomic number materials and bears a strong relationship to the atomic shell structure. Platinum appears to offer the best life stability and vacuum compatibility of all the metals despite the rather large elastic coefficient. The relative performance figures for platinum, molybdenum, gold, silver, and tungsten are listed in Table 11. One possibility considered is a sandwich construction with a thin secondary-emission-producing layer over a low-atomic-number material. Because the elastics are produced deeper in the material than the true secondaries, it is to be expected that q can be reduced without affecting the true secondary emission significantly. Because it may be advantageous to reduce the number of elastically scattered electrons (for other reasons such as background-noise level), this multilayer construction is very attractive. The concept of a two-layer secondary-emission surface has been used as a means for measuring electron-penetration depths and for studying secondary electron emission (31, 35). 4. Readout
Information stored on mucaps can be read out in several ways, including the capacitative pickup and secondary electron collection methods used in the Radechon. Energy analysis of the secondary electron emission, however, offers particular advantages.
JOHN KELLY
70
TABLE 11 SECONDARY EMISSION PARAMETERS OF VARIOUS MATERIALS AND THE CORRESPONDING WRITING EFFICIENCES (FOR MUCAPOPERATION)
Material Platinum Platinum Platinum Molybdenum Molybdenum Molybdenum Gold Gold Gold Silver Silver Silver Tungsten Tungsten Tungsten
Electron energy (keV) 2 1 0.5 2 1 0.5 2 1 0.5 2 1 0.5 2 1 0.5
Elastics
Total secondaries
Write-ONE efficiency
(d
(4
(1 - d
Write-ZERO efficiency ( 6 - 1)
0.43 0.36 0.24 0.30 0.22 0.17 0.34 0.28 0.20 0.32 0.25 0.21 0.35 0.28 0.20
1.68 1.80 1.56 0.8 1.15 1.26 1.30 1.40 1.35 1.20 1.48 1.42 ? 1.30 1.30
0.57 0.64 0.16 0.70 0.78 0.83 0.66 0.12 0.80 0.68 0.75 0.79 0.65 0.72 0.80
0.68 0.80 0.56 -.0.20 0.15 0.26 0.30 0.40 0.35 0.2 0.48 0.42 ? 0.30 0.30
~
The mucaps are charged to different potentials ( f 2 and -40 V) for ZEROS and ONES, and secondary electrons created a t the mucap surface therefore emerge through the grounded gate electrode with corresponding energy, as illustrated in Fig. 17. The secondary emission from the target will consist, therefore, of the following groups: elastically scattered electrons with energy approximating the primary beam ; secondary electrons from the gate electrode with a mean energy of approximately 2 eV; secondary electrons from the mucap storage elements having the following most probable energies with respect to ground: ONE state, 2 - V, eV ( - 42 eV); ZERO state, 2 - V, eV ( - 0 eV). One method of readout is to use a bandpass filter that accepts only the 42-eV ONE-state electrons and rejects all others, as illustrated in Fig. 18 which shows the relative energy distributions for the two states. A small noise signal will be contributed by the electrons in the tail of the energy distribution from ZERO-state elements. Several schemes have been used (38, 39), but the most successful is the energy-barrier system (22) illustrated in Fig. 19. Electrons from the storage target first pass through the ZERO collector which is normally operated a
PRIMARY READ BEAM 12 V)
PRIMARY READ BEAM ( 2 KeVl
rn
42 eV
G ctrn
SIGNAL ELECTRON
(-0 e V )
/ \ \ / \\ I Y 1 /- m\\\ - -
0
z
SIGNAL ELECTRON
W
rn
I
ov
2 v
*d
\
GATE-DIELECTRIC-
~/////////////////////' / V B (-50 V )
BASE
}
-4ov
f
...................... V B (-50 V )
(a)
ZERO
Ibl
ONE
FIG.17. The ZERO and O N E states, illustrating the differences in secondary emission used in readout. In the ONEstate secondary electrons are accelerated through a 40-V potential change, and emerge with approximately 42 eV energy.
I
/
E V
v)
72
JOHN KELLY v)
2
0 K I-
2J
PASS BAND
u
B K
w m
Iz
2
"1
(a) READ ONE
v)
2
-1
2
'VP
"I
ENERGY
Ib) READ ZERO
FIG.18. Energy spectra created by the bombardment of ONE and ZERO state mucaps.
V, represents the primary beam energy. few volts positive with respect to the gate electrode. This electrode collects a large percentage of the slow electrons ( < 10 eV) and ensures that relatively few return to the storage target to cause redistribution problems. Electrodes A and B form an electron " mirror " that reflects all electrons below approximately 50 eV. Elastically scattered electrons, however, pass through this mirror. The barrier electrode B produces a potential barrier in front of the predynode D, thereby excluding all secondaries below approximately 20 eV. Most of the electrons in the 20-50-eV range pass the barrier and strike the predynode D. Elastically scattered electrons from the storage target are screened geometrically from entering the predynode ; however, doubly reflected elastics-particularly from the deflector shield-contribute to the background noise. Electrons passed by the analyzer system enter an electron multiplier that provides high bandwidth gain where it is most needed. The performance of this analyzer system is illustrated in Fig. 20 which
B (BARRIER ELECTRODE)
A (MIRROR ELECTRODE)
TARGET
r
D IPREDYNODE)
II I
L
'p--80 V \ r
\
I
\
-
DEFLECTOR SHIELD
I
E (MULTIPLIER FRONT END)
MU LTlP LI ER
nOUTPUT COLLECTOR FIG.19. The energy barrier system used for readout of binary data stored in a mucap target [Kelly el al. (29)]
V,
=
-150
vc
=
+2
-100
h
VD = 0 V E = +50
-40
0
20
40 ELECTRON VOLTAGE
60
80
- eV
FIG.20. Multiplier output shown as a function of electron energy with V,, the barrier electrode bias as parameter [Kelly et al. (29)].
74
JOHN KELLY
shows the multiplier output as a function of electron energy. The parameter used is the barrier-electrode potential V,. It can be seen that the threshold potential (the low-energy cutoff of the analyzer) has an approximately linear relationship to V, as might be expected; the measured cutoff across the threshold was always in excess of 100 : 1 and usually in excess of 500 : 1. Apart from the potentially high contrast of this type of readout, there are other significant advantages. An electron multiplier provides high signal gain with low noise and, because it is a current amplifier, it eliminates the usual problems associated with amplifier input capacitance. This readout is also good in a random-access mode because it is completely isolated from the writing bias circuit which can necessitate a delay when detecting target currents [see, e.g., Speliotis (58)].The only delays encountered in the analyzer system are associated with the time required to address a particular location and the time of flight of the signal electrons through the analyzer and electron multiplier. This is estimated to be sec in typical practical geometries. Readout involves just the determination of the potential stored. It is only necessary, therefore, to sample the stored charge to obtain readout, and operation in a nondestructive readout mode is possible. This enables the recovery of certain statistical errors by rereading in the event of parity failure. If N , electrons are required to enter the readout system to obtain the required error rate, the mucap potential will be changed by N , e(6 - 1)/6,Cab(mr,2)ec,where E, is the analyzer collection efficiency, e is the electronic charge, and is the effective mucap area per bit. If the potential stored is allowed to drop through A V before the error rate becomes too high, the number of reads ( R ) available before refreshing is necessary, is given by
Assuming an effective bit area of 4 pm’, a collection efficiency of 0.1, a permissible potential drop of 20 V, a target capacitance of F/m’, 6 = 1.5, 6, = 1.1, and N , = 100 electrons per read, Eq. (14) gives R = 110 reads per write. Up to 100 reads/write have been obtained in the laboratory. 5. Mucap Targets and Their Mode of Usage The criticism most often raised against the mucap target is the existence of a microstructure; however, this structure is repetitive and is not difficult or expensive to construct. Mucap targets have been made and used in two modes: the bit-per-mucap and the quasi-continuous modes. In both, an accurate highly regular near-perfect array of holes is required. To achieve this, Westerberg et a f .(38,40,41) developed the screen-lens technique for the exposure of repetitious patterns in an electron-sensitive resist.
15
E L E C T R O N BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
In this technique, a fine-mesh grid creates an array of miniature lenses, each of which can focus its own image of an object mask or crossover onto the target, as illustrated in Fig. 21. The lens action occurs when an accelerating field is applied between the screen and target so that the equipotentials
OBJECT POSITION
300 eV ELECTRONS F R O M OBJECT
SCREEN 1300 V )
TARGET I 2 5 kVI
(a)
U
lb)
21. Formation of multiple electron images by the screen lens technique. The field between the screen and target creates an array ofaperture lenses which reproduce an image o f a single aperture or crossover as in (a), or a more complex image such a s an electron transparent mask as in (b) [Heynick er a / . (42)]. FIG.
76
JOHN KELLY
bulge through the apertures in the screen as displayed in the inset. Figure 21a shows the formation of many images of a single aperture or crossoverone image per lenslet-and Fig. 21b shows the formation of more complex images by each lenslet. This second technique has been used to produce the exposure illustrated in Fig. 22. Each block of 100 mucaps is a field exposed
FIG.22. Arrays of mucaps made using the screen lens technique. Each block of 100 represents a single lenslet field. Holes are 0.5 pm on 1.2-hlm centers. The screen was a standard loo0 Ipi grid.
by a single lenslet. These mucaps are 0.5 pm in diameter and 1.2 pm center to center. Each subfield is very precise within itself because it is a single parallel exposure and is a demagnified image of a precise object mask. The accuracy between subfields is less good, being on the same order as the screen itself. This technique is promising for making targets suitable for “one bit per mucap” storage because a fiducial mark (Fig. 23) can be included in the mucap field (42). The marker can be made as a permanent ONE-state element by etching completely through the silicon dioxide to the silicon base; it can also be made a part ofeach subfield, thereby providing an accurate method for locating the data. A single scan across the marker can determine the beam location with sufficient accuracy. This method requires reasonable alignment between the beam deflection and the mucap array.
77
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
loooo
FIRST/ BIT
I
P
00000000000 00000 0000 0000 0 MATRIX 0 0
0 0 FIG.23. The use of a fiducial mark to locate the first bit in a data block. The mark in this case is a permanent ONE-state element.
Storing a single bit/mucap requires a moderate degree of target perfection even if encoding techniques employing a high degree of redundancy are used. The principal advantage is the high data-packing density achievable. An alternative is to use a group of mucaps for each bit by making the structure fine as compared to beam size [see, e.g., Dodd et al. ( 4 ) ] . By using this " quasi-continuous mode," infrequent imperfect elements can be ignored if approximately nine elements are covered by the beam. This technique has the further advantages that it is no longer necessary to make the deflection system precisely linear and that data can be written as an encoded string of transitions. Random access to the start of the track can be achieved digitally, and the track can be scanned on the fly with the beam remaining on continuously. This is illustrated in Fig. 24 in which the upper part displays a data pattern written as a string of individual bits and the corresponding charge pattern; the lower section displays the same data written with MFM or Miller encoding [see, e.g., Tamura et al. (130)]. In this case, the ONES are represented by a transition (in either direction) and ZEROs by the lack of a transition, as in NRZ (non-return-to-zero) writing on a magnetic surface. When there is a string of ZEROs, transitions are placed between bits to assist in timing or synchronizing the data flow. As noted earlier, reading partially destroys the stored information. A succession of reads on ONE-state elements will convert it into the ZERO
78
JOHN KELLY 1
MFM
1
-
0
0
0
-
0
1
0
0
-
1
1
0
-
RECORD I N G
FIG.24. Operation in the quasi-continuous mode, using approximately nine elements per bit.
state. This is shown schematically in Fig. 25, where the discharge curve from the ONE state into the ZERO state is a function of the number of reads. In the simplest system, a single comparator is used to distinguish between ONES and ZEROS; however, the incorporation of a second comparator level enables the need to refresh the data to be determined. Pulses falling in the regions between levels 1 and 2 would logically be assigned ONE, but would cause refresh of that particular piece of data. An automatic refresh technique, probably combined with a periodic refresh, has the following implications for this type of memory device: The memory becomes effectively NDRO (nondestructive readout). The loss of information through charge leakage is eliminated. Bit interference or read-around problems are minimized. The effects of small drifts in the beam-positioning system (which cause reduction in the ONE-level sigiials and eventual loss of information) are reduced because the refresh action rewrites the data in the new (drifted) location.
6 . Recent Experimental Data Bit-by-bit storage was demonstrated in a recent experimental system developed to show the operation of the mucap medium in a memory mode (22, 29, 42). Targets were prepared on a relatively coarse scale, using the screen-lens exposure technique. The high quality of the targets is illustrated by the scanning electron micrograph in Fig. 26. The tube was an electronoptical bench type described by Kelly, Moore, and Thornton (29). A standard commercial memory exerciser was used to operate the tube through an interface and control unit (see Section VIII). Write-read operation in the quasi-continuous mode was demonstrated with this system. Typical data-storage times of approximately 2 hr were
79
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES NUMBER OF R E A D S
ZERO
-
LEVEL 1
-LEVEL
2
FIG.25. ONE-state readout signal as a function of the number of reads. Two comparator levels are shown illustrating the possibility of automatic refresh.
regularly achieved (42), although it was later determined that some areas of the target could store for as long as 65 hr (43). This is not completely surprising because some silicon vidicon targets can retain information for several days with power on and up to one month under power-off conditions.
FIG.26. A scanning electron micrograph of a mucap target. The holes are 6-pm diameter and are on 8.8-pm centers.
80
JOHN KELLY
The possible factors that could limit the useful life of this medium were considered in detail by Kelly and Moore ( 4 2 ) . The chief uncertainty is related to the life of the secondary emitting surface under electron bombardment. Over an extended exposure to the electron beam, the secondary emission coefficient of the surface is gradually reduced and this can be attributed to the formation of a polymerized layer of organic material over the emitting surface (29, 42-44). The most likely form of contamination is hydrocarbons, either present on the target from a previous processing step or present in the vacuum as a result of inadequate cleaning. In recent work in which degradation of the target was known to proceed at a fairly high rate, targets were removed from the memory tube and subjected to Auger analysis. It was found (42, 4 3 ) that all areas of the target, whether degraded or not, displayed large carbon and small platinum peaks, typically in the ratio of 27 : 1 ; in degraded areas, the ratio was even higher (55 : 1). The source of this contamination is not known, but it appears likely 0.20
I
I
I
RUN RUN 0 RUN A RUN 0
0.15
811 812 812 9
h 0
v1
&2
w0
rr.
0.10
LL
w
u
zc
I 0.05
0
0
0.5
1 .o
1.5
2.0
TARGET EXPOSURE C/crn2
FIG.27. Writing efficiency plotted as a function of electron exposure. The targets were platinum-coated molybdenum with 6-pm mucaps on 8.8-pm centers. The target was known to be contaminated with organic material (see text) [Kelly and Moore (42)].
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
81
that most of the contamination was introduced during fabrication of the target because the actual partial pressures measured by a quadrupole residual gas analyzer were quite low. Further attempts to clean up the targets have not been made. Some metal oxides and compound semiconductors are very good secondary emitters and could possibly be used to improve writing efficiency; however, certain oxide (A1,0,) surfaces exhibit a greatly reduced secondary yield after prolonged irradiation in good vacuum probably because of beam enhanced reduction of the oxide. Care should be taken to select a material, such as the lead glasses, in which this effect is small. The net result of this form of degradation is progressive reduction in the readout signals and in writing efficiency. Writing-efficiency data obtained from early targets are plotted in Fig. 27 as a function of exposure to the electron beam. The gradual reduction in the readout contrast results in an eventual sharp increase in the measured error rate, corresponding to the end of the useful life of a target. Further details are discussed in (42). This whole area is extremely complex because there are so many variables. Clearly, degradation can be controlled by the nature and source of the contaminant, the nature of the secondary emitting surface, sticking factors, and the effect of the beam on the surface. V. BULKCHARGE STORAGE
The discussion in the previous section was concerned with the storage of charge on surfaces. In this section, the storage of charge in the bulk of a dielectric film will be considered. The storage of positive charge in the dielectric of a metal-insulatorsemiconductor (MIS) sandwich has been observed by many researchers (45-49, 52). The first detailed study was made by MacDonald and Everhart (50) who measured the buildup of positive charge in MOS transistors with a positive gate bias by measuring the threshold voltage for turn-on after bombardment under different conditions of bias. The bombarding electron beam produces electron-hole pairs within the oxide and, with a positive gate bias, the electrons move toward the gate electrode and are collected. The holes, however, appear to be captured at deep trapping centers in the oxide, close to the Si/SiO, interface. This accumulation of positive charge continues to increase ‘until the full gate-bias potential is dropped close to the silicon interface and the field over the bulk of the oxide is neutralized. This phenomenon is illustrated in Fig. 28. The reversal of this process (apparent removal of the stored positive charge) occurs under conditions of negative bias. A typical charge/discharge curve for biases of k0.8 V is plotted in Fig. 29. The charge was measured as
82
JOHN KELLY INCIDENT ELECTRON BEAM
lA#k--
FIG.28. Charge storage in the oxide ofan MOS sandwich under conditions ofpositive bias (qualitative): (a) the geometry, (b) qualitative space charge distribution, (c) electric field in the oxide, (d) electric potential in the oxide. After MacDonald and Everhart (50).
83
E L E C T R O N BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
0
1
2
3
TIME - sec
Charge/discharge curve for an MOS target, bombarded with a 200-pA. 12-kV electron beam (experimental data). Curve A is the charge buildup with positive bias V,, = +0.8 V. Curve B is the charge decay V , , = -0.8 V. After MacDonald and Everhart (50).
the corresponding charge induced in the silicon beneath the gate. Beam exposures to achieve saturation are on the order of 10- C/cm2. MacDonald and Everhart ( 5 1 ) considered the possible use of this mechanism for digital information storage, as illustrated in Fig. 30. The device is basically an extended MOS transistor biased in such a manner that positive charge must be stored in both locations a, and b j , where i = j , for a current to flow. Information is stored in a, as illustrated, and addressing is achieved by temporarily bombarding bj . In an experiment using continuous electron bombardment, an MOS transistor used in this mode revealed no deterioration after 600 cycles; however, a 30% reduction in signal amplitude occurred after lo6 cycles. This was attributed, in part, to possible degradation of the storage process. This storage technique is relatively complex and wasteful of packing density because space must be provided not only for the stored bit, but also for the source, drain, island, and address bit. A. The Depletion-Mode Medium
Huber, Cohen, and Smith ( 5 2 ) suggested an alternative method for readout. The presence of a positive charge in the oxide close to the silicon interface causes inversion in a p-type silicon substrate. In the presence of stored positive charge in the oxide the bombarding electron beam creates electron-hole pairs in the silicon, which are separated by the depletion field. This charge separation results in a current flow between gate and substrate. If there is no depletion layer, the electrons and holes recombine rapidly and
84
JOHN KELLY ,SOURCE
METALIZATION
D R A I N METALIZATION,
INFORMATION LOCATIONS
P+ SO?IRCE
"
Pi
Pt
P+ ISLANDS
DRAIN
FIG. 30. MOS storage concept, using charge stored in the gate oxide. Charge stored at sites a irepresents the stored data. The information stored at site aiis addressed by bombarding site
bi, thereby completing the channel connection if positive charge is stored at site from MacDonald and Everhart (51).
a , . Adapted
a negligible current flows through the silicon base. This storage technique is illustrated in Fig. 31. This type of storage medium has a number of important advantages. Not only is the information relatively nonvolatile, but the target is structureless and therefore potentially very cheap. Each bombarding electron produces many electron-hole pairs in the silicon dioxide and in the silicon. This provides a useful gain mechanism in both writing and reading processes. It is well established that the penetrating beam produces one pair for approximately every 3.7 eV dissipated in the silicon at room temperature (53,5 4 ) . Thus gains on the order of lo00 can be achieved. Cohen and Moore ( 5 5 ) estimated a gain of 540 could be produced by a 10-kV beam in a target having a 4OOO-Aaluminum gate and a 2500-A thermally grown oxide layer. Hughes el al. ( 5 6 ) calculated the electron-hole pair gain in the silicon as
85
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES ELECTRON BEAM
w+++++
DEPLETION REGION
P-TYPE Si
SIGNAL OUT
FIG.31. The depletion-mode MOS target. Stored positive charge causes inversion of the p-type silicon substrate. Subsequent electron bombardment causes differences in the current Rowing in the base circuit because of the carrier separation across the depletion field. Adapted from Speliotis (58).
a function of beam voltage and the effective oxide thickness T, (the equivalent thickness of oxide having the same beam retardation as the combined gate and oxide layers). This information is shown in Fig. 32, together with the average penetration into the silicon TA. Cohen and Moore have considered the behavior of the depletion-mode target in a format suitable for a practical memory application (55). To obtain a large readout signal, it was determined that the target must first be set to the ONE condition, with positive charge stored everywhere. This charge must be large enough to ensure a highly conductive inversion layer at the surface of the silicon. ZEROS are then represented by isolated areas of zero or small positive charge. During the readout of a ONE, the electronhole pairs are separated across the depletion region and the electrons travel toward the Si/SiO, interface. Instead of piling up at the interface causing flattening of the bands and subsequent reduction of the signal current, these electrons flow laterally through the interconnected inversion layer. Figure 33 represents the equivalent circuit for this type of MOS storage medium. The beam action on the target can be represented as a current
JOHN KELLY
86 0.6
5 I
0.5
U
c
I
0.4
2
0
c a 0.3 a
L
2 a Lu
0.2
Lu (3
Q
5
>
0.1
U
0
0.2
0
0.6
0.4
0.8
E FFE CTIV E OXIDE THICKNESS - T o x p r n
FIG.32. The calculated relationship between the maximum gain G,, beam energy, average penetration depth into the silicon ( T J , and effective oxide thickness T,. From Hughes et ol. (56).
,,
---
hCo
IiIi.
Ic
*E
*E
WA
D
Rl
RL
--
€ ?L I--
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
87
generator feeding into a circularly symmetric RC transmission line. The magnitude of the current is the beam current I , multiplied by the effective gain G . The inversion layer is represented by a sheet of resistivity pE (R/square). The oxide layer is represented by the distributed capacitance SC, (F/cm2), and the depletion layer by SC, (F/cm2) and the equivalent diodes D ;also shown is a finite resistance R, corresponding to the beaminduced conductivity in the oxide layer. Not shown is the potential distribution created by the stored positive charge which will tend to cause a current flow in R, in the direction indicated by the arrow. During bombardment with the electron beam, the electrons from electron-hole pairs created near the depletion field flow toward the silicon-silicon dioxide interface. They cannot flow through the oxide even though bombardment-induced conductivity (BIC) provides a conductive path because the potential across the oxide created by the stored charge is in the wrong direction. The BIC electron current also tends to flow toward the interface. It is important, therefore, to consider the lateral electron flow in the inversion layer. Cohen and Moore ( 5 5 ) divide the problem into two distinct phases. First, a lateral flow of carriers, so rapid that space charge does not build up and the diodes D do not become forward biased. Second, the capacitors become charged and the diodes are forward biased, thereby short-circuiting the current generator. In the first phase the existence of the diodes and R, are ignored, and R, is assumed to be small so that C , and C , act in parallel. The current flowing in the inversion layer I(r, t ) is given by I(r, t ) = I,Gu(t) exp(-pEC,r2/4t)
(15)
where r is the radial distance from the origin, t is the time since the beam was turned on, ~ ( tis) the unit step function, and C , is the combined capacitances ( C , = SC, + K,). The solution to Eq. (15) is shown in Fig. 34 where the normalized inversion layer current is given as a function of radius. It will be seen that the wavefront travels outward with a steadily decreasing velocity. In the second phase, the capacitors C , become charged and the diode action must be considered. Using the lumped equivalent circuit in Fig. 35, the following expression for the load current i, has been attributed to Fu and Sah [see Cohen and Moore ( 5 5 ) ] : i,
=
(I
+ &)( C o" + Cw )I.Gu(t) IGB
JOHN KELLY
88 I
I
I
I
10-2
10-1
1
1 .o
-u .
; ; 0.5 i
-
-
0
10-~
10-~
10
RADIUS -- rlcrn)
FIG.34. Normalized inversion-layer current as a function of radial distance from the origin, for a selection ofdifierent times after beam turn-on. C, = 8 x lo-' F/cm2, pE = 3 x lo3 fI/square. From Cohen and Moore (55).
EQUIVALENT GENE RATOR
FIG.35. Equivalent circuit used to calculate the load current i, during the second phase [Cohen and Moore ( 5 5 ) ] .
where m is a constant between 1 and 2, T is the absolute temperature, and I, is the diode current defined as i, = I,[exp(eV/mkT) - 11
(17)
in which V is the inversion-layer potential and ID is a constant. Equation (16) represents a transient current, initially large and then gradually decreasing as the capacitors become charged and the diodes forward biased. Theoretical and experimental data are plotted in Fig. 36. It can be seen that the peak readout current is approximately proportional to the beam current and that the length of the transient decreases correspondingly. Cohen and
89
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
Moore noted that a similar negative transient exists on turn-off as C, and C , discharge through the equivalent diode. The relatively long time constants associated with the forward biasing of the depletion diode do not limit the readout rate. This rate is limited by the rise and fall times of the readout current i, as seen in the load resistor. If R , is fairly low, this becomes
to a good approximation. Typically, the parallel combination of C, and Cw F, giving a time constant of 1.0 psec with a 100-R load resistor. is
-
----
--
-\
-- 0
200
iB
I -
60 n A
iB =
29 n A
iB =
5 nA
z I
400
-s.
600
TIME -- psec
FIG.36. Readout current as a function of time for 5-, 29-, and 60-nA beam currents. Solid line calculated from Eq. (18). Points are experimental data: read bias, + 10 V ; target, 0.5 R cm Si; 2300-A oxide; 600-A molybdenum gate. After Cohen and Moore (55).
Cohen and Moore also measured write sensitivity. The data in Fig. 37 were measured by monitoring the readout current as a function of read bias for a prescribed write exposure. This set of curves is extremely informative. There is a threshold read bias for each write exposure. Below this voltage, a
90
JOHN KELLY
readout current is not detected because the inversion layer has insufficient conductivity to prevent charge buildup close to the beam landing position. The equivalent diode rapidly becomes forward biased and the output shortcircuits. At more positive bias, the inversion is stronger and the readout current can build up.
t
---
I
I
I
-
2.4 x 10-8C/crn2
--4.9
+2
x 10-9~1crn~
o
C/crn2
I----
w
E3 4
I
I
1.5 x 10-8Clcrn2
A-
u
3 0
.2
9
w
U
0 -40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
R E A D B I A S - volts
FIG.37. Readout current as a function of read bias voltage for different levels of beam exposure. Write bias, +20 V; beam current, 2 nA; target, 0.5 R cm Si; 2500-A oxide; 1600-A polysilicon gate. After Cohen and Moore (55).
For high write exposures, the output becomes saturated at a level that depends on the bombarding beam current. A beam current of 20 nA yields a saturation current of approximately 6.1 pA for the target under investigation-a gain of 305. This statement is supported by the data in Fig. 38 where the charge density stored is shown as a function of the writebeam exposure. These data were calculated from the readout threshold bias by the relation Q = C , V,, where V, is the read bias. The stored charge is strictly proportional to the write dose in this graph and shows no sign of saturating. The write-ONE and erase (write-ZERO) doses are plotted as a function of bias in Fig. 39. Here, the write dose was defined as that necessary to produce a readout signal of 50% the saturation value at 0-V read bias. This target required a write exposure approximately one order of magnitude larger than the target used in obtaining the data for Figs. 37 and 38. The erase exposure was measured in a similar manner and is seen to be smaller than the write-ONE dose.
91
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
The only factor that has not been considered in depth is the read-ZERO process. The original explanation offered by Huber et al. ( 5 2 ) appears inadequate because, even after erase, a small positive charge left in the oxide causes a slight inversion to remain. If the diameter is sufficiently larger than the read-beam diameter, the inversion-layer impedance will be high enough to cause forward biasing of the diodes and short-circuiting of the readout signal. N
5 . C
e
"
-
6
x
10l2
U
E X
0
f
a
4
U
lx
0
m l-
w
c7
a: a
2
I
V
U
1 L
m
B
0
0
0.5
1 .o
1.5
2.0
x 10-8
W R I T E EXPOSURE -- C/crn2
FIG.38. Positive charge buildup as a function of write exposure. Details as in Fig. 36. After Cohen and Moore (55).
The normalized readout signal SZERO/SONE is shown in Fig. 40 as a function of ZERO diameter. These measurements were made using a nominal 3-pm diameter read beam. The logarithmic dependence of the readout current on the ZERO diameter can be related directly to the logarithmic dependence of the inversion-layer resistance on the ZERO diameter. Care must be taken when optimizing the design parameters because the ZERO diameter required to achieve a 3 : 1 discrimination ratio must be eight times the nominal beam diameter (at 0-V read bias). Careful optimization is required to maximize the data-packing density unless an alternative operating mode can be found.
92
JOHN KELLY
10-6
N
i . u I Lu
\
BO
WRITE
W v)
Q
a
UJ
a
0 Lu
L
5
10-~
ERASE
0
20
W R I T E OR E R A S E B I A S
40
-
volts
FIG.39. Write and erase exposures as a function of write (erase) bias. Beam current, 20 nA; target, 0.5 i2 cm Si; 2300-A oxide; 600-Amolybdenum gate. After Cohen and Moore (55).
B. The Accumulation-Mode Medium
An interesting alternative that resolves some of the difficulties with the depletion-mode medium is the three-terminal accumulation-mode target described by Ellis et al. (57). The target has a thin n-type silicon layer
93
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES 1 .o
k
'
z
W
a a:
\\ -\ \ \
3 V
I-
3
0
'\ \\B
\
0 Q
Lu
\
a
\
0
a:
\
W
N
0
-
0.1
J
a
\
2
a 0 z
\
'
\
\
\ \ B\
'\ \ ' \
' \
'
\
\
\
R E A D BIAS
- o vv ----- v -- +lo -10
+
\
-\
@ \
-20. -30 V
0
20 ZERO DIAMETER
\" 40
- prn
FIG.40. Normalized readout current as a function of Z E R O diameter, for various value of read bias. Beam diameter, 3 pm; target, 0.5 R cm Si; 2500-A oxide; 1600-A polysilicon gate. After Cohen and Moore (55).
94
JOHN KELLY
between the oxide and the p-type silicon substrate (see Fig. 41). Positive charge is again stored in the insulator layer; however, the positive charge is now used to modulate the surface recombination velocity and hence the number of minority carriers collected by the reverse-biased p-n junction. The excess holes created by the electron beam in the silicon can recombine with electrons in the bulk of the silicon, i.e., in the thin n-layer or at the ELECTRON BEAM
METAL\
I)
c
+++++
N - T Y P E SI
0
0
$ 8 77 DIODE BACK BIAS
P-TYPE Si
FIG.41. Three-terminal accumulation-mode medium. The target operation relies on the change in junction collection efficiency of minority carriers when a positive charge is stored in the oxide. Adapted from Hughes er a/. (56, 225).
Si-Si02 interface, or they can be collected by the junction and thereby produce an output current. Ellis et al. (57) concluded that the bulk recombination of the carriers in the silicon is insignificant when using an n-type layer of 10-pm thickness or less. The effective surface-recombination velocity S, on the other hand, varies considerably with the charge stored in the oxide. In the flatband condition or in depletion, S can be on the order of lo6 cm/sec for an interface state density of 10'2/cm2; however, when a positive charge stored in the oxide causes accumulation in the n-type layer, S is on the order of lo3 cm/sec. This large reduction occurs because most of the interface states are occupied by electrons and hence are unavailable as recombination centers.
95
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
Ellis derived the following equation from a one-dimensional diffusion calculation for the probability P that a hole created a distance x from the Si-SiO, interface will be collected and hence contribute to the output current: P=
1 1
+ (S/D)x + (S/D)d
where D is the hole-diffusion constant and d is the thickness of the n-type layer. Assuming D = 10 cm2/sec for 1 R cm n-type silicon, x = 0.4 pm, and d = 2 pm, Eq. (19) gives P = 0.98 for accumulation and P = 0.24 for the flatband condition. The actual gain is P times G,, where G , is the number of electron-hole pairs created in the silicon (see Fig. 42) and is clearly the maximum gain obtainable for S = 0 ( P = 1). Early measurements of the gain have been reported (57) for a target with a 10-pm n-type layer and a 0.6-pm oxide layer. The gate was 800-A of aluminum. The measured diode gain is plotted in Fig. 42 as a function of electron exposure under two conditions of gate bias, V, = 45 and 0 V. These curves, therefore, are a direct measurement of writing sensitivity in addition
I
I
I
4
5
I
I
I
7
8
9
I
400 t
u
a.
100
0 0
1
2
3
6
-
COULOMBS~C~
1 0 1 1
Xio-*
FIG.42. Diode gain in the accumulation mode MOS target as a function of electron exposure. (a) Bias = 45 V; (b) bias = 0 V. Target, 0.6 pm oxide; gate, 800-A aluminum; silicon 1 R cm, n-type, 10-pm thick on p-type substrate; beam, 10 k V [Ellis er al. (57)].
96
JOHN KELLY
to contrast and output signal. Gains of 1400 have been reported more recently (56) using a 10-kV beam on a target with a 0.4-pm oxide layer and a thin gate. C/cm2 is It can be seen in Fig. 42 that a net exposure of 1.2 x required to write the ONE state to 50% of saturation level and 2.4 x lo-' C/cm2 to write the ZERO state. Comparative data for the depletion and accumulation modes are shown in Table 111. The data are somewhat scattered because of the many variables and differences in measuring methods. Given the identical conditions, it appears however that both modes require similar write exposures. The significant physical difference between . the depletion- and accumulation-mode MOS media, as described here, lies in the contrastcreating mechanisms. Charge carrier separation occurs in both modes. In the depletion mode, the output is limited by the conductivity in the inversion layer; however, in the accumulation mode, the n-type surface layer can have low resistivity ( - 1 R cm) and does not limit the output. The bit size and packing density are set by different factors in the two modes. The ZEROS in the depletion mode target must be significantly larger than the beam size so that adequate contrast can be achieved during readout. The accumulationmode target, however, appears to be limited only by electron scattering in the target and by the lateral diffusion of the holes created in the n-layer. Measurements of the electron scattering (56) indicate that the effective increase in beam size is approximately 0.5 pm. Calculations of the lateral diffusion indicate that the optimal n-layer thickness is less than one-third of the bit spacing. Considerations of this type indicate that a bit spacing of 1 pm (perhaps less) should be achievable by using appropriately thin oxide and n-layers. For example, a 0.6-pm beam at 5 keV might be used with an 0.1-pm effective oxide thickness and an 0.3-pm n-type layer. Measurements of readout response made by Hughes et al. ( 5 6 ) on the accumulation-mode target are largely independent of frequency up to 20 MHz. It is anticipated that the ultimate limit will be determined by the hole diffusion time in the n-type layer, d2/D, which is approximately 1 nsec for a 1-pm-thick n-type layer. This appears to be rather faster than the depletion mode. Both the depletion- and accumulation-mode targets can be used in a partially destructive readout mode (PDRO). The number of reads before refresh becomes necessary depends on the write exposure and bias. The normalized readout gain is shown in Fig. 43 as a function of the number of reads. Perhaps the major limitation on both the depletion- and accumulationmode MOS media is associated with the delay required between writing and reading operations. In both cases, readout involves the detection of a small
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
97
98
JOHN KELLY
+
current flowing in the silicon substrate. Switching the gate from the 45 V write-ONE bias to 0 V for reading involves charging the MOS capacitance through the associated impedances. This introduces in the readout circuit a disturbance that must be reduced to a low level before readout can begin. The problem can be largely circumvented by dividing the silicon target into a number of reasonably sized pieces and by careful design of the switching and readout circuitry. Typical delay times are in the range of 10-30 p e c (56, 58).
lo-“ C/crn2, + 15 V
1.0
0.8 0
$ . z
u
c7
0.6 C / c m 2 , + 40 V
0.4 lo-’
C/cm2, t 60
-
v
0.2 0 0
10
20
30
40
NO. READS
FIG.43. Signal reduction as a function of the number of read operations. The parameters are write exposure and write bias. Read exposure, 5 x lo-’ C/cmz/read [Hughes et al. ( 5 6 ) ] .
In the discussion of the mucap medium, a fatigue or degradation mechanism was described that involved the decrease of the secondary emission coefficient with exposure to electrons. The MOS media discussed above store charge in the oxide and suffer from a different form of fatigue (55, 57). The bombardment of the oxide layer by electrons introduces localized states, and those close enough to the silicon substrate to interact electrically, are known as interface states. These interface states alter the bias conditions at the silicon surface and, consequently, the readout gain. At approximately 1 C/cm2, this damage reaches a point at which the read signals have significantly decreased. It is reported however that the fatigue can be removed by annealing at 320°C for a short time (57). The importance of this level of fatigue depends on the mode of target usage. In a block-oriented mode where the target can be used uniformly, a 30,000-hr life has been predicted for a 32 x lo6 bit tube operating at lo7 bits/sec. In a random-
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
99
access mode where it is impossible to make the usage uniform, fatigue may become a problem more rapidly. It is reasonable to ask if there is any useful degree of annealing at room temperature or if the beam itself could be used to heat and anneal the target locally.
VI. ALTERNATIVESTORAGE MEDIA This section describes some of the alternative storage media that are generally less fully developed than the charge-storage media described previously. They appear also to be more ideally suited to read-mostly or archival memories. Relative performance of the various media is summarized in Table VI. A . Amorphous Semiconductor
In 1971, Chen et al. ( 5 9 ) proposed the use of the transformation from the amorphous state to the crystalline state in the chalcogenide glasses as a means of storing data. Such information would be nonvolatile and suitable for archival storage. The basic storage mechanism involves raising the temperature of the amorphous thin film to the crystallization temperature. Localization of the required heating effect and crystallization within a microsecond have been demonstrated with laser (60) and electron beams (59). The possibility of a fast erase or write-ZERO process also exists. To achieve this, however, the chalcogenide glass must be heated to above' the melting point and then rapidly cooled. 1. Electron Beam Writing
The major questions concerning electron beam writing are the time necessary to heat the amorphous film locally to the transition temperature, the time for the transition to occur, and the time to subsequently dissipate the heat. Fortunately, the transverse conductivity in the glassy material Ge-Te-As is relatively low, while the heat conduction out through the substrate can be relatively high. The problem of electron beam heating has been considered by several authors (61-63) but without consideration of the variations in the thermal properties with temperature. Chen ( 6 4 ) used a detailed computer-simulation model and derived a set of heating and cooling curves for a thin amorphous layer located on top of a conducting substrate. Electron penetration is included, but the energy loss is assumed to be uniform with penetration depth. The beam is also assumed to have a uniform current density. As may be expected, the data concerning the thermal properties are inadequate, and
100
JOHN KELLY
simplifying assumptions were necessary. Nevertheless, the resulting heat-flow curves are very instructive. The calculated surface temperature of a silicon substrate coated with 4OOO A of molybdenum and 3750 A of chalcogenide glass is shown in Fig. 44,as a function of time. The 5-kV 2-pm beam is turned on for 1 psec at t = 0. The transition temperature was assumed to be 315"C, and the melting 700
I
I
1
I
I
1
1
-
-
500 -
-
600
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
TIME - psec
FIG.44. The surface temperature in a chalcogenide glass film (3750-A thick) as a function of time for various beam currents. Beam, 5 keV; 2 pm diameter; exposure, 1 psec; substrate, 4000-A molybdenum on silicon [Chen (64)].
point was 425°C. Because writing occurs a t the lower temperature, it would appear possible to achieve the required heating in a tenth of a microsecond. Cooling generally takes slightly longer. The 0.2-pA beam current corresponds to approximately 6 A cm2. Writing currents are necessarily fairly high because the maximum temperature that can be reached by the target under the beam is determined by a balance between the energy delivered by the beam and the heat conduction away from the beam location. As a result, current and time are not completely interchangeable as with electrostatic targets. The other parameter of interest is the spread of the " hot spot" that will limit the final bit size. The temperature distribution in the target is shown in Fig. 45 for the time t = 1.0 psec. Even with a 1-pA beam, the spread is less than 0.5 pm. This spread will continue after the beam is turned off; however, the effect is not large because the transverse conductivity is relatively poor in the chalcogenide layer.
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES 700
I
I
I
I
I
10s I
600
500
0
400
I
c
300
200
100
n 0
1 .o R A D I A L DISTANCE
2.0
3.0
- krn
FIG.45. The surface temperature in a chalcogenideglass film (3750-Athick) after exposure to beam currents of various magnitudes for 1 psec. Beam, 5 keV; 2 pm diameter; substrate, 4000-A molybdenum on silicon [Chen ( 6 4 ) )
2. Electron Beam ErasurelWrite ZERO As explained earlier, this process involves heating the chalcogenide layer above its melting point and subsequent rapid cooling. This was assumed to be 425°C in calculating the curves in Figs. 44 and 45. These figures demonstrate that a beam current approaching 1 pA must be used to heat the full 2-pm spot to this temperature in 1 psec. Subsequent cooling requires approximately 1 psec, largely because the latent heat must first be dissipated. Very few data on the erase process have been published. 3. Readout One proposed method for readout relies on the change in the secondary electron emission coefficient between the amorphous and crystalline phases
102
JOHN KELLY
(64). This has been investigated by Chen et al. (65), who showed that, in many cases, the actual change is on the order of 10%. Because this modulation is rather low, readout and discrimination are difficult. A method that improves the signals uses the surface deformation that results from the phase change (66, 67). The secondary emission yield increases as the primary beam strikes the surface at smaller glancing angles. The relationship was derived by Bruining (68) as 6,/& = exp[aX,( 1 - cos O)] (20) where a is the secondary electron absorption coefficient, x,,, is the mean depth from which secondary electrons can escape into the vacuum, and O is the angle with the normal to the surface. Chen and Wang (66) measured the modulation efficiency for several beam voltages (see Table IV) using a target coated with a 100-A layer of molybdenum before exposure to the beam. This metallization enhances the signal output. Chen et al. (67) calculated that to achieve a modulation efficiency of 50% a surface deformation of 45" will be required. TABLE IV MODULATION EFFICIENCY OBTAINED FROM A GIVENREAD-BEAM VOLTAGE FOR AN AMORPHOUS SEMICONDUCTOR TARGE~ Beam voltage
(kV)
Modulation efficiency
10 5 3
0.14 0.17 1.43
The measurements were made in a scanning electron microscope with a 1-pm diameter, &nA, 10-keV write beam. From Chen and Wang (66).
Chen and Wang (66)also calculated the maximum readout rate based on beam and secondary emission limitations at an error rate of lo-'. The calculated rate depends on bit size and cathode loading as may be expected. The data are listed in Table V. The amorphous semiconductor memory mechanism appears promising for archival or read-mostly systems but is not currently suitable for write/read operation. Small bits (1.4 pm) have been observed (66),and high densities are possible but at the expense of the readout rate. From published information, the major limitation appears to be the relatively poor signal-tonoise and discrimination ratios.
103
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES TABLE V
CALCULATED READOUTRATEAND OTHER PARAMETERS FOR AN AMORPHOUS SEMICONDUCTOR ELECTRON BEAMMEMORY' Cathode loading Bit size (pm) Density ( b / h 2 ) Data rate (Mb/sec) Target current readout Secondary electron readout
3 A/cm2 0.5 109
1 .o 2.5 x 108
10 A/cm2
0.5 109
0.2
1.o
1.o
10.0
80.0
50.0
1 .o 2.5 x 108
7 .O
100 A/cm2
lo9
1 .o 2.5 x 108
10.0
60.0
0.5
300.0
Assumptions: error rate = lo-'; spherical aberration coefficient C, = 25 cm; target capacitance C, = 25 pF; beam voltage V = 3-10 kV;modulation coefficient M = 0.1 + 0.4.
B. Magnetic Storage Media The storage of information in a magnetic medium has many advantages, particularly nonvolatility and archival possibilities. The writing and reading of magnetically stored information by means of electron beams have been considered by many workers (69, 71, 78-81), and methods for writing (controlling the direction of magnetization) are fairly well established. Unfortunately, most readout techniques result in rather poor output signals with low signal-to-noise ratios. 1. Curie-Point Writing
In 1958, Mayer (69) described Curie-point writing in a MnBi film deposited on cover glass disks. The MnBi film was deposited with an easy direction of magnetization normal to the film surface. The beam was used to heat the film locally to the Curie point (350°C)at which temperature the magnetic film reverses through the demagnetized region to minimize the magnetic energy. As the demagnetized region cools, the magnetization is locked in, in reverse polarity. Mayer was able to demonstrate this reversal by means of the Kerr magnetooptic effect and electron mirror microscopy. He also determined that erasing could be carried out by saturating the magnetic field in the forward direction. The Kerr effect has also been considered by Mee and Fan (70) as a means of readout for a laser-beam memory. The major disadvantage is the weak magnetooptical interaction. Typical conversion efficiencies are 10-4-10-
104
JOHN KELLY
unless the user is prepared to cool the magnetic material to cryogenic temperatures when efficiencesof the order of 0.01-0.1 may be obtained (e.g., with EuO at 60°K).
2. Photon and Electron Beam Access (PEBA) In 1967, Smith ( 7 1 ) proposed a magnetic-film memory addressed by combined photon and electron beams. The basic concept required the use of an electron beam to heat the selected bit, thereby lowering the switching threshold. The final direction of magnetization was controlled by the direction of an external magnetic field. For readout, a magnetooptical output (modulated thermally by a fast series of electron beam pulses) was proposed. The bit address was then determined by the point of impact of the electron beam on the target, whereas the photon beam could illuminate a much larger area. This ingenious scheme requires a magnetooptical coefficient and coerciveforce that are appropriately dependent on the temperature. The magnetooptical temperature coefficient 6k is required to be large so as to obtain good readout signals. Typically, 6k becomes large as the Curie point is approached ;however, the coercive force must remain high enough to ensure data retention. Normally, this force tends to zero at the Curie point and, as a result, these two requirements are in opposition. Smith ( 7 1 ) proposed to achieve the required performance by using composite films consisting of several layers of different materials. The effect is illustrated in Fig. 46 which shows the combined temperature dependence of two films having magnetizations MI and M , . The film M I produces a high temperature coefficient 6k at V,, suitable for reading purposes, and M , maintains a level of magnetization sufficient for data stability. In a subsequent paper, Smith ( 7 2 ) discusses the problems of achieving a satisfactory output signal and signal-to-noise ratio in this type of memory. He notes that the proposed photon and electron beam access technique provides an adequate bit-selection mechanism and adequate discrimination against surface noise ; however, it is deficient in that no provision was made to reduce the shot noise associated with the photon illumination of the unselected bits to an acceptable level. Smith then suggests a modified approach, using the magnetooptical spectra in the rareearth iron garnets (REIG). These materials have a window in the near infrared from 1.5 to 5.0 pm in which the adsorption is zero, apart from a line spectrum associated with electronic transitions in the rareearth ions (73, 74). By exchange interaction with the iron sublattices, these line spectra cause magnetooptical effects (75, 76). Smith considers two possible methods for reducing background
105
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
"b
vc 1
vc2
TEMPERATURE
FIG.46. The magnetization of a two-layer structure as a function of temperature, qualitative [Smith (7f)I.
or array shot noise, both based on the use of temperature effects to control the REIG spectra : thermal shifting of the spectral lines, and thermal pumping to a state at which absorption is to take place. He rules out the first alternative but concludes that thermal pumping could be effective and practical. A three-state system is proposed in Fig. 47. As in the original proposal, bit selection is performed by the electron beam, and the photon beam covers a larger area. In this modified version, however, the electron beam also heats the selected site locally and pumps it into the excited state from which absorption can occur. Smith calculates that qz more bits may be illuminated through thermal pumping, where q = N , / N , ; N , and N , are the populations of the storage and read levels
106
JOHN KELLY
READOUT (Optical absorption1
A € > > kT,
3
ES
t
\
-
BIT SELECTION (Thermal Pumping)
FIG.47. The use of thermal pumping to achieve bit selection with reduced background shot noise. After Smith (72).
respectively, and q is defined as
where AE is the energy difference between the storage and read states. With a storage temperature of 77°K and a read temperature of 377°K q can be computed to be 3 x if a value of AE = 500 cm-' is used (77). By means of these figures, approximately lo7 more bits could be illuminated through thermal pumping. This storage technique is interesting; however, there are many practical materials problems, and the hybrid system is relatively complex. Perhaps the major limitation is the need to cool the target. 3. Lorentz Readout The possibility of readout using the action of Lorentz forces on the electron beam has been considered by Cohen (79) who examined and rejected the following four methods: (1) electron transmission through a magnetic film; (2) secondary electron analysis; (3) mirror microscopy, using a retarded beam; (4) reflection microscopy at shallow angles of incidence. His conclusions were based on the impracticality of achieving an adequate readout signal. In the transmission mode the power density required is prohibitive; secondary electron scanning requires more current density than can be obtained, and mirror microscopy has limited resolution. Cohen also
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
107
ruled out reflection microscopy because a high-intensity field-emission source would be required, and many other factors were marginal. Despite Cohen’s negative conclusions, the Lorentz approach should be reanalyzed as new methods and materials appear. For example, Cohen’s analysis of the transmission mode assumes a target without a substrate so that all the energy is dissipated in a thin film. Berkowitz (80),however, has proposed a magnetic film memory in which, on reading, the beam actually passes through a hole in the magnetic film, thereby eliminating Cohen’s principal objection. Writing is achieved by heating an annular ring around the hole above the Curie point. A magnetic field applied during cooling determines the direction of magnetization that can deflect the readout beam through a small angle. Berkowitz demonstrated a deflection of 2.5 x rad, using l-mil holes in a CrO, magnetic tape. Reading and writing rates up to 1 MHz are predicted. The major difficulty appears to be in fabricating a target with the required structure. C . Cathodoluminescence
In 1940, the use of color centers in reversible information storage was suggested by Rosenthal (82) who employed the F-centers created in alkali halides by electron irradiation for dark-trace display. Recent improvements have used sodalites as the storage medium in preference to the alkali halides (83, 84), and related work (85-87) uses these or similar materials in optical storage. In 1972, Bishop et al. (88) described a storage medium based on the inhibition of cathodoluminescence by the introduction of radiation-induced defects in the alkali halides. Most of the work used potassium iodide doped with thallium [KI(Tl)] although many of the alkali halides exhibit related phenomena. Potassium iodide containing thallium ions (TI’) luminesces at room temperature when excited by ultraviolet light or by electron irradiation (89, 90). Electron irradiation, however, also creates defects that inhibit the luminescence associated with the TI+ ions. The initial radiation occurs in a broad band centered on 420 nm and has a fast component with a half-life of 200 nsec useful for readout; a slow component with a half-life of 200 psec or more must be ignored. Following our terminology (ONES represented by signal output), the decrease in luminescence with radiation dose is the write-ZERO process. The procedure is approximately exponential and is illustrated in Fig. 48. These measurements were made with a 200-keV beam at 17 W/cm3. If these values are scaled for a medium penetration depth of 1 pm, the equivalent exposure in coulombs per square centimeter can be determined. As a result,
108
JOHN KELLY 1 .o
1
>
y w u
::
I -
\
0.2
w
g E
I
0.5
0.1
$
0.05
z =3
0.02
w
1
0.01
4
0.005
I-
w
a 0.002
t 0
20
40
60
ao
100
RADIATION DOSE - k J c r K 3
FIG.48. Relative luminescence efficiency of KI(T1) as a function of electron exposure. Beam at 200 keV, 17 W/cm3 [Bishop et al. (88)].
the radiation efficiency drops to 10% after a dose of 32 kJ cm-3 or an equivalent of 1.6 x lo-’ C cm-’. The write-ZERO process (inhibition) is attributed to the creation of interstitial iodine atoms. These atoms are reported to be very mobile at room temperature (91, 92) and attach themselves to the T1’ ions, thereby inhibiting the luminescence. The inhibition process is reversible. The radiation-induced defects can be annealed out by heating the alkali halide for a suitable time. Annealing occurs very slowly at room temperature (approximately 2000 years are required) but at very much higher rates at elevated temperatures ;however, thermal annealing at the melting point of the crystal still requires 2.5 msec. When annealing with an intense beam of electrons, the process occurs up to six orders of magnitude faster, presumably because of the effectively high temperatures of the electrons that are not in equilibrium with the lattice. Measurements of the thermal annealing properties indicate an activation energy of 1.1 eV, which is considerably less than the average energy loss by the beam per electron-hole pair (3.7 eV). In practice, anneal times of 2 p e c have been achieved (88,132). This medium is ideal in many ways because it offers good performance with a clean separation of writing and reading functions. For example, writing is achieved by bombardment of the crystal with the electron beam, and readout can be obtained by observation of the photon emission from the reverse side. Unfortunately, only several hundred write/read cycles or 10’
TABLE VI SUMMARY OF STORAGE MEDIAPERFORMANCE
Mucap (42)
Depletion mode MOS (55)
Accumulation mode (56)
Amorphous semiconductor (59)
Write-ONE sensitivity
Type
Read rate
Negative charge storage on surface
> 100 MHz (using electron multiplier)
Positive charge storage in oxide
2 MHz
-
Positive charge storage in oxide
20 M H ~
-
-
-
Medium
Amorphous to crystal-
C/cm2 4 x lo-’ C/cm2 1 day (calculated) (calculated)
10-7-10-8
10-7-10-8
1 MHz at lo-’ C/cm2 3 A/cm2 at 10 A/cmZ
-
10-8
10-8
Life
> 1 C/cm2
-
1 month
1 C/cm2 (anneala ble above 320’C)
-
-
1 month
I C/cm2 (annealable above 320’C)
-
-
Archival
?
C/cm2 a t I A/cm2
-
Archival
?
1 . 2 ~
Long
C/cm2 at 10 A/cmZ
Bit size
Write rate
- 4 pm (9 per bit) - 1 pm
I MHz at 1 A/cm2 - I kMHz (1 per bit) after priming
Limitation on Probable access time applications
-
10 nsec (time of flight)
Read-write systems
- 4 pm
-
10 MHz
15-30 psec Read-write (Switching and systems readout amplifier stabilization
< 1 pm
-
10 MHz
-
-
15-30 psec Read-write (Switching and systems readout amplifier stabilization)
1 MHz
Time of flight
Archival
1 MHz
Time of flight
Archival?
Fast
Read-write ?
Fast
Read mostly
I pm
line phase change
-
Beam de- I MHz a t lo-‘ Cicrn’ flection in 3 A/cmz a t 1 A/cm’ hole in film Curie point writing
Ferroelectrics
Switching bismuth titanate
Luminescent KI (TI) (88)
Storage time
5x
Magnetic film (80)
(94)
Write-ZERO sensitivity
Radiation damage in
KI
?
-
1 MHz
1 . 2 ~
- 4 pm
m
centers
Archival
?
lo5 cycles
2x2pm
- 1 pm
?
-100 kHz
110
JOHN KELLY
read/refresh cycles have been obtained, before fatigue starts to develop. This level of fatigue is much too high for the construction of an acceptable memory. The fatigue has not been explained in the literature, but it is to be hoped that alternative materials could be found or developed not exhibiting the same phenomenon. Even within the alkali halides there is a large selection of possible candidates from which to choose.
D. Ferroelectric Media Several attempts have been made to apply ferroelectrics to information storage (91-99). Storage in bismuth titanate has been proposed by Cummins (93) and demonstrated (94).The storage principle relies on the fact that there is a large difference in extinction direction on switching the polarization. This change is approximately 40"as opposed to the 180" switch (not optically detectable) that occurs in barium titanate and triglycine sulfate. This unique switching process has been described by Cummins and Cross (95). During normal switching, with a field applied along the c axis, the large polarization vector rocks through an angle of lo", causing the large change in optical properties. In Fig. 49, two states are shown that correspond to the two possible polarization states. The X and Y axes represent the two indicatrix positions. It can be seen that the light path is along the a, axis; and, if optical polarizers are aligned on one of the two possible extinction positions, the other will produce maximum transmission. Cummins (96) has also determined that domains of opposing polarity are distinguishable when the light is incident at 10"-15" with the co direction. Cummins and Hill (94)were able to write optically detectable domains in bismuth titanate by scanning the (001) surface with approximately C/cm2 at 23 kV. Domains with a 2-pm width in the a direction 1.2 x were written by scanning in the b direction; however, resolution for adirection scanning was believed to be limited to approximately 12 pm unless thinner crystals or an alternative writing scheme could be found. The major advantage of this technique is the permanence of the stored information which is in the form of a switched domain and does not rely on holding the electron charge. Other work is based on the electrooptic light-valve approach (98, 99) that relies on the birefringence introduced in a ferroelectric crystal (such as KDP) when an electric field is applied. Wieder et al. (98)made simple spatial filters by writing charge patterns on a dielectric surface deposited on a KDP crystal. Figure 50 is a schematic of the system. Polarized light from the laser passes through an object pattern, and the ferroelectric storage tube is positioned in the Fourier plane. The dielectric behind the KDP layer acts as a mirror. The birefringence in the KDP causes rotation of the plane of polarization; this can be analyzed by the polarizer, and the resulting filtered image
'DOMAIN WALL
FIG.49. A bismuth titanate crystal viewed along the a. axis. The axes x-y indicate the two possible positions of the optical indicatrix for opposite saturation states on the hysteresis loop [Cummins (9311. LASER INPUT
OBJECT
TRANSPARENT CONDUCTOR
DIELECTRIC
I OUTPUT PLANE (IMAGE)
POLARIZER
KDP' BEAM SPLITTER ELECTRON BEAM UNIT
FIG. 50. Method of generating and using electrooptic spatial filters using a ferroelectric beam memory tube [Wieder et ol. (98)].
112
JOHN KELLY
appears in the output plane. Recently, Casasent and Casasayas (99) used a transmission-mode device with separate write and erase guns. Unlike Cummins’ domain-switching technique, the information is not permanent and must be retained by refresh techniques.
SYSTEMS VII. ELECTRON-OPTICAL A . Basic Limitations
In this section, the limitations imposed by electron optics are discussed. A typical TV tube can scan approximately 500 to 600 lines; however, a high-quality CRT can scan perhaps 1000 lines, and 2000-line tubes are available. Electron-optical systems have been constructed with over 10,OOO lines in a single image field (100, 115), but the technology becomes increasingly difficult and expensive. To achieve increased resolution, it is necessary to limit the beam current severely and often to impose dynamic corrections. In a memory tube, this also limits the writing and reading rates. Difficulties in the electronics area also limit the number of bits addressable in open-loop fashion. For example, 16-bit D/A systems (65,536 lines) are relatively slow, and the necessary high-stability power supplies are very expensive. On the other hand, 12-bit D/A systems (4096 lines) are much faster, and the necessary power supplies are available at reasonable cost. It therefore can be concluded that it is practical to store between one and four million bits per image field with the current state-of-the-art electronics technology. The factors that limit beam current in the on-axis position are chromatic and spherical aberrations, space-charge repulsion, and diffraction. Because, generally, diffraction can be ignored in beams of the size range under discussion (approximately 100 A to 10 pm), the beam current is usually determined by a compromise between the Langmuir limitation (101) and spherical aberration. In some cases, space-charge repulsion is also significant. The Langmuir limitation (as noted in Section 111) imposes an upper limit on the current density attainable in the focused spot. Basically, this limit implies that the brightness of any focused image in a system is invariant although changes in refractive index (or velocity) must be taken into account.* The standard form for the Langmuir limitation is
(,“T
Ji=Jc -+1
sin2 a, )sin2 a. ~
Consequently, a brightness measurement should always be quoted with the appropriate voltage .
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
113
where Ji is the current density in the probe formed from a cathode having a current loading J , , temperature T, and the accelerating voltage V,; ai is the half-angle subtended at the focused spot, and a. is the half-angle at the cathode prior to acceleration. a. is usually taken to be W",but this is not necessarily the case for field emission cathodes. This equation indicates that the largest values of Ji can be obtained when ai is maximized. However, ai must be limited because of the lens aberrations. The spherical aberration gives rise to a circle of least confusion, with diameter
d, = fC,a?
(23)
where C, is the spherical aberration constant. The optimal semiangle can be determined by combining Eqs. (22) and (23) and solving to derive the condition for maximum density. Einstein et al. (102) defined the optimal halfangle as
and the corrresponding current density as
J,,,
= 0.34(5, V,/kT)(d/C,)z'3
The approach used is a modification of the method developed by Mulvey (103) and Castaing (104). Small differences in the final equations depend on the detailed assumptions made and, in particular, on the method used for compounding the spherical aberration with the Langmuir limited beam. Other differences occur because cathodes impose different constraints on the system (105,206). Equation (25) is often expressed in terms of cathode or gun brightness rather than current density. The most useful form depends on the type of cathode. Because the life of most cathodes can be related directly to the current density required, J, is often a limiting factor. It will be noted that the maximized current density increases slowly with beam diameter but decreases with increased values of the spherical aberration constant. In some instances, however, one basic assumption in the derivation of Eq.(25) is invalid; C, is not a constant but is a function of the focal length and conjugate positions. Typically, a value of C, for one conjugate at infinity is used; however, when approaching unit magnification, it is more correct to use a value of
c, = C,( a)(1 + M)4
(26)
where M is the magnification (38, 233, 134). In a beam-memory device, the primary concern is beam performance across a finite field and not just on-axis. This leads to other restrictions on
114
JOHN KELLY
the design. The actual deflection of a ray is determined by the third-order equation as Y = 3 a Y i bY& cY,az (271 where 5 is the gaussian deflection and aiis the beam half-angle; the principal aberration constants a, b, and c for the deflector are complex integrals of the deflection field and are constant for a particular geometry and deflection distance. The term aYp” produces a raster distortion or nonlinearity; bYia, results in deflection defocusing that appears as an astigmatismlike aberration, and cU,a; gives rise to a comalike term. The deflection parameters and the formation of distortion and deflection defocusing are illustrated in Fig. 51. The distortion term a Y i is equivalent to an additional deflection in the Y direction, which results in the typical pincushion or barrel shape of a raster scan. The astigmatismlike or deflection-defocusing term b Yiai results in the beam developing an elliptical shape that is larger than the focused spot. Two line foci are formed (F, and F,) on the deflector side of the target, and between them is a circle of least confusion. The ellipse in the gaussian deflection plane has semiaxes b, Y i ai, and b, Y i ai,when the gaussian or paraxial image dimensions are ignored. The comalike term cY,az can usually be neglected, unless the beam enters the deflector off-axis. These parameters restrict the number of lines in an image field. In many situations, a certain degree of raster distortion can be tolerated, and the field is limited by spot growth caused by deflection defocusing. This latter term is proportional to ai, and the number of lines can be increased by reducing ai.
+
+
+
ASTl GMATl SM OR DEFLECTION DEFOCUSING
+VV
I
I
\
I I
ISSIAN LECTION
CONFUSION
~
-VV
FIG. 51. A deflected electron beam showing the character of deflection defocusing and raster distortion. F , and F , are the two line foci associated with the astigmatismlike deflection defocusing.
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
115
This will result in a deviation from the optimal conditions defined by Eq. (25) and a consequent reduction in beam current. The increased number of lines is N 2 , where N Z / N , = (ail/ai2)1’2 (28) Because the maximum permissible astigmatism will be the same in both cases (Yil ail = Yi2ai2), the beam current density will be reduced by (ai2/ail)’ unless the system is reoptimized. The relative importance of spherical aberration and deflection defocusing depends on the values of C, for the focusing system and bi for the deflector. Fortunately, both raster distortion and astigmatism are amenable to dynamic correction signals and the use of a stigmator generally in the form of an octupole lens. It is apparent that the choice of cathode, the deflector design, and the lens system are of key importance in the design of a beam-addressed memory. In the following sections, these critical factors are considered, with emphasis on recent developments. Traditional electron optics are described in such standard texts as Klemperer and Barnett (107).
B. Cathodes The selection of a cathode in a beam-addressed memory is critical because beam brightness (A/cm2 sr) and source current density are of fundamental importance; in most systems, lifetime is also significant. Brightness data are often misapplied because brightness is not the only parameter that controls current density in a focused spot. For example, field emission produces extremely high brightness ; however, being a very small source, it cannot always be used in an optimal configuration. Typically, therefore, it is possible to apply only a small portion of the beam and, for on-axis beams above 1 pm, the field emitter offers little or no advantage over the conventional thermionic cathode (106).Recent advances in field emission (108, 109) and such considerations as off-axis performance modify these arguments and tend to improve the relative performance of the field emitter. In many cases, device lifetime is the overriding consideration, and it is now accepted that the dispenser cathode (1 10) offers excellent performance. Lifetimes of up to 50,000 hr at 3 A/cm2 are claimed, and higher current densities are available if a shorter life is acceptable (111, 112). The osmiumcoated cathode produces a further significant increase in available current density (113); however, the osmium gradually reacts with the tungsten matrix and the advantage is eventually lost (114). These complexities make it clear that, in defining the performance of a cathode, the brightness at a particular beam voltage and the corresponding lifetime should be quoted together. In many cases, the source size or specific emission should also be included. Some representative figures are listed in Table VII.
116
JOHN KELLY
TABLE VII REPRESENTATIVE CATHODE PERFORMANCE
Cathode
Brightness (A/cm2 sr at 10 kV)
Life (hr)
Current density (A/cm2)
Source size
Oxide
104
10,000
1
Tungsten hairpin Dispenser type
105
500
10
3 x 104
50,000
3
25-50pm crossover 25 pm crossover 12-25 pm
106-109
300-io,~ depending on conditions
-lo7
200-1000A
100
5-50 pm crossover
Field emitter
lo6
1000
-
Comments Well established Bright but short-lived Reliable in clean vacuum Requires special care and handling Problems of instability; requires good vacuum
C. Deflector Developments Over the past ten years, there have been several significant developments in deflector design. The deflection requirements are emphasized in beam memory devices because off-axis performance is as important as on-axis. In such systems, it is also convenient to have x, y deflection with equal sensitivities and a common center of deflection. The theory of deflection has been considered by many workers; however, the results are not generally adaptable to design methods. Haanjes and Lubben (116, 1 1 7 ) considered a magnetic deflector and its application to CRT design for color television. This theory only considers third-order aberrations but is amenable to design methods because the aberrations are expressed as a function of the deflection field on-axis E,(O, 0, z) and the second derivative of the field dZE,(O, 0, z)/dx2, where y is the direction of deflection. These parameters express the problem completely for the third-order solution because E, defines the field on-axis and its strength at all points and d Z E , / d x Z defines the distribution in the x, y plane. This theory was extended to electrostatic deflection by Kelly [see Heynick (21, 38)] and by Wang (118). The major difficulty in electrostatic deflection is the limited scope for shaping the field distribution. In magnetic deflection, it is possible to overlap coils to adjust the distribution in the x, y plane.
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
117
Recent work with the octupole deflector was stimulated by the desire to achieve a degree of field shaping to minimize the aberrations and the need for high sensitivity and a common center of deflection. Multielectrode deflectors have been known for many years (1 19) but have received relatively little attention until recently. In 1969, Kelly proposed the use of the octupole to minimize aberrations (21), and he designed and tested one to reduce raster distortion (38). Figure 52 shows a cross section of the general octupole deflector. The deflection voltages applied for x deflection and the summed voltages
(C)
FIG.52. The octupole deflector: (a) voltages required for y deflection; (b) summed voltages required for simultaneous x and y deflection; (c) a method of providing the summed voltages
. ...
.L..:J--
118
JOHN KELLY
required for simultaneous x-y deflection are illustrated in Figs. 52a and 52b; one method of providing the necessary voltages by means of a resistive bridge is shown in Fig. 52c. The ratio parameter ( a ) sets the fraction of the primary deflection voltage applied to the side electrodes and, therefore, the distribution of the field in the x, y plane. This field varies across a complete spectrum from a = 0 (corresponding to a quadrupole deflector) to a = 1 (the split-cylinder case). For a = 0.414 (actually - l), the system is symmetrical about the x = 0, y = 0, and x = y directions, and the field is very close to uniform over more than one-half the deflector diameter. Generally, the optimal configuration uses a ratio-parameter value close but not equal to 0.414,and both the aberration constants and the deflector sensitivity vary with this parameter. Figure 53 shows the relative field distributions for different values, and Fig. 54 illustrates the linear relationship between the ratio parameter and a Z E , / a x z for an infinitely long cylindrical octupole. These data were derived from the computed solution to Laplace’s equation, which was obtained by relaxation methods. Also plotted is relative deflection sensitivity. Figure 55 illustrates the variation in raster distortion with the ratio parameter a. Similar relationships can be plotted for other aberrations. Some details of the minimization of astigmatism have been discussed by Wang (118). An alternative approach to deflector design is the deflectron developed by Schlesinger (120). Originally proposed to achieve a common center of deflection and equal x-y sensitivities, this deflector has proved to offer very good aberration performance. The deflectron has interleaved x-y electrodes arranged in a periodic pattern on the inside of a cone or cylinder. The deflection field is not constant along the z axis but varies in a periodic fashion. A typical deflector pattern is illustrated in unrolled form in Fig. 56. It is difficult to find actual performance data in the literature ;however, the deflectron has been applied successfully in a number of tubes. A detailed comparison of octupole and deflectron performance would be interesting, but adequate data are not available at this time. Much of the work on EBAM devices has focused on electrostatic deflection despite the fact that magnetic systems.generallyhave lower aberrations. Most arguments for the electrostatic deflector are based on the relative speeds required for driving the deflector. A better argument is the need to produce a small, low-weight, low-power device with adequate mechanical stability. It is acceptable therefore to use a deflector made as part of the tube structure, but it is debatable whether a separate coil hung on the outside of the vacuum envelope can be satisfactory. [For a recent review of deflection studies, see Hutter and Ritterman (121).]
fi
119
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES 1.8
1.6
1.4
1.2
1 .o
E" 0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
t
0 0
I
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1 .o
1.2
TRANSVERSE DISTANCE
axis
FIG.53. Variation of the deflection field as a function of transverse position for various values of the ratio parameter a.
D. Matrix Lenses Having considered the performance of single-lens systems, it can be concluded that it is possible to store between one and four million bits per image field with the current state-of-the-art technology. The simplest approach is to create a memory system from a number of tubes working either serially or in parallel if higher data rates are required. The next level is to construct a number of channels within a single
120
JOHN KELLY 1.4
N
1.2
1.4
1.0
1.3
0.8
1.2
t 2 k
0.6
1.1
:
. fi X
w
>
>
N
,=
I
2 wLL
h
v)
2
w
0.4
1.0
w
I-
a
u w
-I
LL
w
:
4
0.2
0.9
0
0.8
0 LL
0 w
I
c
Ia
-0.2
E
w
0
0 -0.4 2
8w
-0.6
-0.8
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
RATIO PARAMETER a
FIG.54. Normalized second derivative of the deflection field (l/V)a'E,/~x2and relative deflector sensitivity as a function of the ratio parameter a.
vacuum envelope. The multiplicity of lenses has been explored by Newberry et al. (222) and, more recently, by Lemmond et al. (223). The problem of lenslet interaction has been considered by Harte (124). The fly's eye (or
matrix-lens) system consists of an array of lenses that can be illuminated either individually or simultaneously by a double deflection system (Fig. 57). Deflection within each lens field is achieved by means of two sets of deflecting bars connected alternately to positive and negative amplifiers. Hughes et al. have applied a modified version of the fly's-eye lens to the design of an EBAM and reported (56, 125) a 32-Mbit tube that uses an
121
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES 0.014
I
0.012
3
OCTUPOLE DEFLECTOR 2.5 cm LONG, 0.5 cm DIAMETER
0.010
0.006 c
n
0.004
2
0.002
a li 8 2
0 L
b, = +0.0004
-
0
a I
-
-
0.008
I-
4
-0.002
-
-0.004
-
-0.006
-
-0.008
-
-0.01 0
-
n
-
-0.01 2
0.3
0.4
0.5 0.6 RATIO PARAMETER a
0.7
FIG.55. Raster distortion constant b , as a function of ratio parameter a for a deflector 2.5-cm long and O S t m diameter, working at a throw distance of 7 cm.
18 x 18 matrix of lenses. The basic matrix-lens system is illustrated in Fig. 58. The storage target is at the left. The beam coming from the electron gun is focused and directed through a double-deflection system to a particular lenslet that further focuses the beam onto the target with appropriate demagnfication. Deflection within the lenslet field is achieved by the deflectors located between the lens and the target. In this way the address requirements imposed on the electronics and electron optics are divided between the two sets of deflectors. The first set of deflectors (lenslet selector) moves the beam off-axis in such a way that it enters the desired lenslet normally and on its optic axis. The accuracy with which the lenslet address
JOHN KELLY
122
t
BEAM
FIG.56. The deflectron-deflector patterns for a beam traveling toward the top of the page. The patterns shown are formed on the inside of a cylinder or cone [Schlesinger (12011.
must be achieved is relatively low because it is movement of the source or object position that causes a shift of the image, not movement of the illumination alone. This is illustrated in Fig. 59. The postlens deflector still carries the burden of reproducibly scanning the data within the addressed lenslet field. In the present tube with 110 kbits per lenslet, this requires only an 800-line resolution (9- to 10-bit accuracy). It is anticipated that it will be possible to increase the number of bits per lenslet considerably and that it is reasonable to consider a matrix of 32 x 32 (1024) lenslets, each storing lo6 bits (lo9 bits/tube). The possibility of using a number of lenslets simultaneously has been considered by Wang et al. (126),who designed a collimating lens to provide parallel illumination of such an array. The so-called Kan lens is capable of alignment within 0.005 mrads but has rather high chromatic aberration and necessitates a beam with low energy spread. The major problem with this type of lens structure is the difficulty in fabricating and aligning the lens plates with sufficient accuracy for all (or nearly all) of the lenslets to function satisfactorily. Earlier matrix or fly’s-eye lenses were threeelectrode Einzel lenses, which meant the accurate alignment of four plates-the electrodes plus the aperture plate (122). Later arrays have been made in the form of an immersion lens with only two
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
-RECORDING
I
123
PLATE
I
FLY‘S EYE LENS
-
UPPER DEFLECTRON
-LOWER
DEFLECTRON
CONDENSER LENS
LIMITING APERTURE/ FARADAY CUP
BLANKING PLATES
STEERING PLATES IMAGE APERTURE ELECTRON GUN
FIG.57. Electron-optical system for a fly’seye lens artwork camera [Lemmond (123)i.
et
01.
electrodes. A further advantage of the twoelectrode lens is that it has lower spherical aberration for a given midfocal length (the distance from the physical center of the lens to the focal plane). This is illustrated in Fig. 60 in which the normalized spherical aberration constant C, / R is plotted as a function of normalized midfocal length Z , / R . Except a t very short focal lengths, C, is reduced by a factor of approximately 5.
124
JOHN KELLY OXIDE
PAGE
LENS
RECORD AMP
-1
I DISPENSER CATHODE
AMP
IO U l l
BEAM
ELECTRON BEAM SOURCE
LENSLET SELECTOR SELECTOR MEMORY PLANE
FIG.58. Electron-optical system of the BEAMOS storage tube. A double deflectron illuminates a single element of the 18 x 18 matrix lens, at normal incidence [Hughes et a!. (56, 125)].
TARGET OBJECT
I
c
ADDRESSING BEAM
FIG.59. Illustrating the relaxed deflection stability requirement obtained by using a two-stage deflection system. If the illuminating beam is misaligned with the lenslet by S r , , the object is also displaced Sr,, and the image by Sr, = MSr, . The magnification M is usually much less than unity, and hence Sr, 4 Sr,. (a) Accurately aligned beam, (b) beam misaligned by Sr, .
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
125
1o4
. [r
0"
I
z
2 I-
a
E
103
2 -I
uaa W
X
v) 0.
102
10 10 FOCAL LENGTH
102
- Z,lR
FIG.60. Spherical aberration for electrostatic matrix lenses plotted as a function of normalized midfocal length: (A) three-electrode Einzel lens, center plate aperture radius R = 1.5 mils, gap S = 60 mils, outer plate aperture 2-mils radius; (B) two-electrode lens; ( + ) aperture lens. Adapted from Hughes er a/. (56) and Heynick er a / . (41).
126
JOHN KELLY
10-1
10-2
10-6
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.o
aIR
FIG.61. Radius of the circle of least confusion for an aperture lens versus radius of the beam-limiting aperture, both normalized to the aperture of the lens. 2, is the distance between the aperture lens and the target. C,is the calculated third-order spherical aberration constant. Adapted from Heynick et al. (41).
ELECTRON BEAM A D D R E S S E D MEMORIES
127
A further extension of the matrix lens approach is the so-called “screen lens” referred to earlier (Section IV,C) and illustrated in Fig. 21. This scheme can be used, in principle, to address a very large array of data, using the lenslets either singly or in groups. The lens system offers the same advantages as those described above, and requires essentially no alignment. The principle by which focusing is achieved results in the name “aperture lens.” The spherical aberration of these lenses has been calculated by Westerberg ( 4 1 ) and is shown in Fig. 61 as a function of the ray position in the aperture lens. Rays close to the axis and up to approximately one-half the aperture radius are subject to third-order aberration only; beyond, no further increase in spherical aberration appears because the fifth-order term is negative. Toward the edge of the aperture, seventh order aberration takes over and adds to the overall aberration. Westerberg’s data have been analyzed and superimposed on Fig. 60. It can be seen that, for a given midfocal length, the spherical aberration (third order) is almost identical to that of the three-electrode Einzel lens. Because the “center” of the lens is in the plane of the screen, however, the spherical aberration for a given free working distance is somewhat lower. Although this lens system has not been applied to the addressing of a memory plane, it does appear very attractive. A resolution of about 500 A
FIG.62. A conceptual digital deflector scheme, using a sequence of deflectors scaled in length and driven from a set of fixed voltage sources which are selected by a set of fast transistor switches.
0
OTONS
ADDRESSING BEAM (Electrons or Ions)
SUBSTRATE ACTIVE SURFACE
\
INFORMATION PATTERN
ADDRESSING BEAM
>I
I
__
-
i
-SOURCE
-' MULTIPLIER
DEFLECTOR SYSTEM
STORAGE TARGET (lo6 Subfields Each of lo6 Units]
SCREEN LENS (106 Lenslets)
FIG.63. A proposed beam memory concept using a screen or aperture lens, addressed by a double deflector. A second double deflector scans the target within each lenslet.
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
129
has already been demonstrated and lenslets spaced on 12.5- and 25-pm centers investigated. Potentially a screen of lo6 lenslets, each addressing a subfield of lo6 bits, appears possible although the practical difficulties are considerable. If the bits are on 100-A centers, the lenses would be approximately 10 pm apart and the bit density 1012/cm2.Bit and lenslet addressing could be determined through a sequence of electrostatic deflectors; the first two would address a single lenslet, and the last two would scan the beam within the subfield. This form of sequential deflection could be practical, using octupole deflectors in sequence. The deflectors themselves could be of the digital type illustrated in Fig. 62. Each deflector is subdivided into a series of subdeflectors, probably made as thin film conductors on the inside of a ceramic tube. The deflection voltages are fixed (V, to V') and are selected by fast switches controlled by the address logic. The success of a complex scheme such as this depends on many factors. The biggest uncertainty is the availability of a suitable storage medium, despite the wide variety available for investigation. An archival memory using a cathodoluminescent target with the information pattern superimposed is used to illustrate the principle of address using the screen lens in Fig. 63. It is interesting to note that this scheme bears a strong relationship to that proposed by Bryan and Focht in 1962 (127) for the addressing of 4 x lo6 bits! SYSTEMS VIII. BEAMMEMORY
This article has been largely concerned with the technology required to fabricate practical EBAM systems. The survey would not be complete without some discussion on recent systems work. Kelly et al. (29) described an experimental memory module, designed for testing at the USAF Avionics Laboratory at Wright-Patterson AFB. The system uses the electrostatic mucap storage medium in a single-channel demountable tube. The module was constructed as a laboratory tool so that such significant parameters as writing speeds, target life, and error rates could be measured. The tube is a modular construction, some key components of which are illustrated in Fig. 64. The single tube is operated from a standard off-the-shelf memory exerciser and is set up so that random access to any bit can be achieved. Figure 65 is a schematic of the electronics. Under microprogram control, the memory exerciser can provide data patterns, address information, control commands, and read and compare operations in parallel. The 16-bit address word from the exerciser is decoded into two %bit addresses corresponding to the x, y coordinates, and these are
130
JOHN KELLY
FIG.64. Components of an experimental beam addressed memory tube: (a) the assembly, (b) the target plane, (c) the octupole deflector [Kelly (12811.
passed to the D/A converters and deflection amplifiers. At the same time, the read/write control and the information to be written determine the target bias required. After suitable settling times, the beam is pulsed on and the operation is carried out. During the read operation, the information from the readout amplifier and comparator is stored in a buffer before being passed back to the exerciser for comparison to the data written originally. All timing operations are conducted in the digital interface. The tube control unit produces the necessary analog signals from the interface inputs.
m
z
0
E
B
E
2
m
132
JOHN KELLY
This simple system is capable of gathering a large amount of data in a short period of time-including measurements of practical operating speeds-and of providing a first look at error rates. The latter was particularly encouraging. In measurements on small data blocks, error rates of better than lo-’ were encountered; however, the system was not adequately isolated from line noise, and there were periods when errors were accumplated through switching transients. This problem was eliminated by programming the memory exerciser to reread whenever an error was encountered. This enabled the system to run free of error up to the point at which target fatigue had reduced the output signal quality to a marginal condition. This terminated the useful life of that area of the target. Typical data are illustrated in Fig. 66. Further details of the system and its operation are available in reports by Kelly and Moore (42) and Nicastri (43), and a summary can be found in (128). In a second development, Speliotis described a single-channel approach to the EBAM system, using the MOS depletion-mode storage target (58). Details of this work have not been published; however, a 1.2-Mbit system consisting of nine 128-kbit tubes operating in parallel was delivered to Control Data early in 1975 and has been reported operating on a CDC Star 1B computer. In the third development, Hughes et al. (56, 125) described the development and testing of a 32-Mbit tube. This tube uses an accumulation-mode MOS storage target and is addressed by means of a double deflectron and an 18 x 18 matrix lens. The data are block-oriented in such a way that each lenslet field is divided into 13 8448-bit pages. In a proposed multimodule system (Fig. 67) separate signals are provided for lenslet selection, page selection, and data scan. Representative performance figures are as follows : tube capacity system capacity access time data transfer rate
32 x lo6 bits 32-600 x lo6 bits 30 psec 10 Mbits/sec
Based on a (32 x 106)-bit tube operated in a block-oriented mode with uniform target usage at a 10-MHz data rate, a 30,000-hr target life is predicted. This is comparable to the 30,000-hr MTBF predicted for the digital circuits and to only 20,000 hr for the power supplies. The life situation for small blocks of random-access data is much more severe. The problem becomes less significant as the memory is made larger, provided that the bit size remains the same. In itself, however, the life of the tube is not vital-it is much more critical to be able to detect deterioration so as to make replacements before system failure.
133
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES 100,000
I
I
I
)
I
’
10,000
v1
U 0 U U
1000
w
n
RUN 5
w U w
RUN
1
,
>
0
YU
z
100
3
(
10
1
0
0.3
0.6
0.9
1.2
1.5
1.8
2.1
109
READlREFRESH CYCLES
FIG.66. Unrecoverederrors as a function of the number of read-refresh cycles as measured on the EBAM module. Useful life was terminated by fatigue of the target due to organic contamination.
The activity represented in this article corresponds to a considerable renewed interest in EBAM technology. There is still plenty of scope for invention. One feature of nearly all EBAMs has not yet been given the attention it deserves. The structure of most memories is determined in the detailed wiring and in the way it is fabricated. In the EBAM the information is stored in a two-dimensional plane. The format and data organization can be determined by the supporting hardware and software.
OXIDE BIAS
aX z
n
CONTROL REGISTER
I
n CONTROL ClRCUlTS
t1
FUNCTION READ
CHARACTER lSTlCS ACCESS TIME DATA RATE D A T A CAPACITY
30 psec 10 MBIsec 30 x lo6
IINTERFACE
FIG.67. A multimodule system for serial operation, using up to 20 BEAMOS matrix lens tubes of 3 x lo7 bits each [Hughes e r a / . (125)].
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
135
In this review actual applications for these memories have not been discussed. For a discussion on this subject, the reader is referred to a discussion on the impact of “electronic disks” by Wensley (131). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author would like to acknowledge the help of J. S. Moore and P. R. Thornton for reading and commenting on various parts of the manuscript. Thanks are also due to I. Brodie for suggesting the review and for his support and encouragement throughout; also to Joyce Garbutt for coordinating and typing the manuscript and to Hortense Shirley for her editorial comments. Part of the work on the “mucap” medium at SRI was supported by the U.S. Air Force Avionics Laboratory under Contrast F33615-72-C-1906.Early work was supported by the US. Army Electronics Command under Contract DA28-043 AMC 01261(E).
REFERENCES 1 . F. C. Williams, and T. Kilburn, Proc. Inst. Electr. Eng. 96, Part 111, 81-100 (1949). 2 . J. P. Eckert, Jr, H. LukolT, and G. Smoliar, Proc. I R E 38, 498-510 (1950). 3 . J. W. Forrester, Proc. Symp. Large Scale Digifal Calculating Mach., 1947 16, 125-129. Ann. Computation Lab. Harvard Univ., Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts (1948). 4. S. H. Dodd, H. Klemperer, and P. Youtz, Electr. Eng. (Amer. Instr. Electr. Eng.) 69, 990-995 (1950). 5. R. R. Everett, East. Jr. Comput. Conf. p. 70 (1951); Electr. Eng. 71, 681-686 (1952). 6. D. J. Wheeler, and J. E. Robertson, Proc. I R E 41, 1320-1325 (1953). 7. W. E. Mutter, Electr. Eng. ( A m . Inst. Electr. Eng.) 71, 352-356 (1952). 8. W. Buchholz, Proc. IRE 41( lo), 1262-1275 (1953). 9. C. E. Frizzell, Proc. I R E 41( lo), 1275-1287 (1953). 10. H. D. Huskey, R. Thorenson, B. F. Ambrosio, and E. C. Yowell, Proc. I R E 41(10), 12941299 (1953). 11. S. Greenwald, R. C. Haueter, and S . N. Alexander, Proc. IRE 41(10), 1300-1312 (1953). 12. J. Rajchman, R C A Rev. 12, 53-97 (1951). 13. B. Kazan and M. Knoll, “Electronic Image Storage.” Academic Press, New York, 1968. 14. M. E. Hines, M. Chruney, and J. A. McCarthy, Bell Sysr. Tech. J . 34, 1241-1264 (1955). 15. T. S. Greenwood, and R. E. Staehler, Bell Syst. Tech. J . 37, 1195-1220 (1958). 16. J. W. Forrester, J. Appl. Phys. 22, 4 4 4 8 (1951). 17. E. W. Pugh, IEEE Trans. Magn. 7, 810 (1971). 18. J. Rajchman, J . Appl. Phys. 41, 1376 (1970). 19. G. Knight, Appl. O p t . 13, 904 (1974). 20. A. Vander Lugt, Appl. Opr. 12(7), 1675 (1973). 21. L. N. Heynick, ed., “ High-Information-Density Storage Surfaces,’’ 17th Quart. Rep., ECOM Contract DA 28-043 AMC-01261 (E), SRI Proj. 5444. Stanford Res. Inst., Menlo Park, California (1969). 22. J. Kelly, IEDM Tech. Dig. 592-595 (1974). 23. K. Schlesinger, Elecrronics 25, 105 (1952). 24. D. G. Cogswell, unpublished observations (1967). 25. W. E. Glenn, J . SMPTE 74, 663-665 (1965).
136
JOHN KELLY
26. H. Bruining, “Physics and Applications of Secondary Emission.” Pergamon, Oxford, 1954. 27. A. S. Jensen, and R. L. Stow, I R E PGED Meet., Washington, D.C., 1958. 28. K. R. Shoulders, US. Patent 3,398,317 (1968). 29. J. Kelly, J. S. Moore, and P . R. Thornton, Proc. IEEE Natl. Aerosp. Electron. Con$ p. 55 (1974). 30. K. H. Stehberger, Ann. Phys. (Leiprig) 86, 825 (1928). 31. 1. M. Bronshtein, and R. B. Segal, Sou. Phys.-Dokl. 3(6), 1185- 1 I87 (1958). 32. E. J. Sternglass, Phys. Rev. 95(2), 345 (1954). 33. R. Warnecke, J. Phys. Radium 7 , 270 (1936). 34. P. L. Copeland, Phys. Rev. 40, 122 (1932). 35. I. M. Bronshtein, and R. B. Segal, Sou. Phys. Solid State 1( 10). 1365 (1960). 36. P. Palluel, C . R . Acad. Sci. 224, 1492 (1947). 37. E. J. Sternglass, Phys. Reu. 80(2), 925 (1950). 38. L. N. Heynick, ed., High-Information-Density-Storage Surfaces,” Final Rep., ECOM 01261-F, Contract DA 28-043 AMC 01261(E).Stanford Res. Inst., Menlo Park, California (1970). 39. K. R. Shoulders, K. T.Rogers, and J. Kelly, US. Patent 3,500,112 (1970). 40. E. R. Westerberg, US. Patent 3,619,608 (1971). 41. L. N. Heynick, E. R. Westerberg, C. C. Hartelius, Jr., and R. E. Lee, IEEE Trans. Electron Deoices 22(7), 399-409 (1975). 42. J. Kelly, and J. S. Moore, Tech. Rep. AFAL-TR-74-176. U.S. Air Force Avionics Lab., Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio (1974). (Unlimited distribution.) 43. E. D. Nicastri, M.S. Thesis, GE/EE74-58, Air Force Inst. Tech. Sch. Eng., WrightPatterson AFB, Ohio (1974). (Unlimited distribution.) 44. H. Seiler, and M. Stark, Z . Phys. 183, 527 (1965). 45. J. R. Szedon, and J. E. Sandor, Appl. Phys. Len. 6, 181 (1965). 46. N. C. MacDonald, and T. E. Everhart, Appl. Phys. Lett. 7,267-269 (1965). 47. E. H. Snow, A. S. Grove, and D. J. Fitzgerald, Proc. IEEE 55, 1168 (1967). 48. K. H. Zaininger and A. G . Holmes-Siedle, R C A Reo. 28, 208 (1967). 49. J. P. Mitchell and D. K.Wilson, Bell Syst. Tech. J . 46, 1 (1967). 50. N. C. MacDonald and T. E. Everhart, J. Appl. Phys. 39(5), 2433-2447 (1968). 51. N. C. MacDonald and T. E. Everhart, Proc. IEEE 56(2), 158 (1968). 52. E. E. Huber, Jr., M. S. Cohen, and D. 0. Smith, Appl. Phys. Left. 16(4), 147-149 (1970). 53. D. W. Aitken, D. W. Emerson, and H. R. Zulliger, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 15(1), 456 (1967). 54. R. H. Pehl, F. S. Goulding, D. A. Landis, and M. Lenslinger, Nucl. Inst. Methods 59(45) (1968). 55. M. S. Cohen and J. S. Moore, J. Appl. Phys. 45(12), 5335-5348 (1974). 56. W. C. Hughes, C. Q. Lemmond, H. G. Parks, G.W.Ellis, G. E. Possin, and R. H. Wilson, Proc. I E E E 63(8), 1230-1240 (1975). 57. G. W. Ellis, G. E. Possin, and R. H. Wilson, Appl. Phys. Lett. 24(9), 419-421 (1974). 58. D. E. Speliotis, AFIPS Con$ Proc., 1975 Natl. Comput. Coni pp. 501-508 (1975). 59. A. C. M. Chen, J. F. Norton, and J. M. Wan& J . Non-Cryst. Solids p. 917 (1971). 60. J. Feinleib, J. de Neufville, S.C. Moss, and S. R. Ovshinsky, Appl. Phys. Lett. 18, 254-257 (1971). 61. L. G. Pittaway, Brir. J . Appl. Phys. 15, 967-982 (1964). 62. T. P. Lin, IBM J. Res. Deu. 11, 527-536 (1967). 63. J. A. Morrison and S. P. Morgan, Bell Sysr. Tech. J . 45, 661-684 (1960). 64. A. C. M. Chen, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 20(2), 160-169 (1973). ‘I
ELECTRON BEAM ADDRESSED MEMORIES
137
65. A. C. M. Chen, J. F. Norton, and J. M. Wan& Appl. Phys. Lett. 18, 443-444 (1971). 66. A. C. M. Chen and J. M. Wang, IEEE. Trans. Magn. 8(3), 312-314 (1972). 67. A. C. M. Chen, A. Dunham, and J. M. Wang, J . Appl. Phys. 44(4), 1936-1937 ( 1 973). 68. J. Bruining, Physica (Utrechr) 3, 1046 (1936). 69. L. Mayer, J . Appl. Phys. 29, 1454-1456 (1958). 70. C. D. Mee and G. J. Fan, I E E E Trans. Mag. 3, 72-76 (1967). 7 1 . D. 0. Smith, I E E E Trans. Magn. 3(4), 593-599 (1967). 72. D. 0. Smith, IEEE Trans. M a g . 4(4), 634-639 (1968). 73. R. C. LeCraw, D. L. Wood, J. F. Dillon, Jr., and J. P. Remeika, Appl. Phys. Leu. 7,27-28 (1965). 74. D. L. Wood and J. P. Remeika, J. Appl. Phys. 38, 1038-1045 (1967). 75. M. V. Chetkin and A. N. Shalygin, Sou. Phys.-JETP 25, 580-581 (1967). 76. G. S. Krinchik and G. K. Tjutneva, J. Appl. Phys. 35, 1014-1917 (1964). 77. H. M. Crosswhite and H. W. Moos, eds., “Optical Properties of Ions in Crystals.” Wiley (Interscience), New York, (1967). 78. D. 0. Smith, I E E E Trans. M a g . 3, 433-452 (1967). 79. M. S. Cohen, IEEE Trans. M a g . 4, 639-645 (1968). 80. A. Berkowitz, W. C. Hughes, J. L. Lawson, and W.H. Meiklejohn, 1 1 t h Symp. Electron, Ion Laser Beam Techno/. pp. 1-8 (1971). 81. D. E. Speliotis, 27th Ann. E M S A Meet. p. 152 (1969). 82. A. H. Rosenthal, Proc. IRE 28(5), 203-212 (1940). 83. W. Phillips and Z . J. Kiss, Proc. IEEE 56( 1I), 2072-2073 (1968). 84. H. F. Ivey, Proc. IEEE 57. 853 (1969). 85. I. Schneider, Appl. Opt. 6( 12). 2197-2198 (1967). 86. I. Schneider, M. Marrone, and M . N. Kabler, Appl. Opt. 9(5), 1163-1 166 (1970). 87. Z. J. Kiss, IEEE J . Quantum Electron. 5(1), 12-17 (1969). 88. H. E. Bishop, R. P. Henderson, P. Iredale, and D. Pooley, Appl. Phys. Lett. 20(12), 504-506 (1972). 89. R. Illingworth, Phys. Rev. 136, 508A (1964). 90. W. B. Hadley, S. Polich, R. G. Kaufmann, and H.N. Hersh, J . Chem. Phys. 45, 2040 (1966). 91. D. Pooley, Proc. Phys. Soc., London 87, 245 (1966). 92. L. W. Hobbs, A. E. Hughes, and D. Pooley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 28(4). 234-236 (1972). 93. S. E. Cummins, Proc. 1 / 3 3 55, 1536-1537 (1967). 94. S. E. Cummins and B. H. Hill, Proc. IEEE 58, 938, 939 (1970). 95. S. E. Cummins and L. E. Cross, Appl. Phys. Lett. 10, 14-16 (1967). 96. S. E . Cummins, J . Appl. Phys. 37, 2510 (1966). 97. D. 0. Smith, US.Patent 3,710,352 (1973). 98. H. Wieder, R. V. Pole, and P. F. Heidrich, IBM J . Res. Deu. 13, 169-171. 99. D. Casasent and F. Casasayas, Appl. Opt. 14(6), 1364-1372 (1975). 100. 0. H. Schade, Sr., RCA Reu. 31, 60- I19 (1970). 101. D. B. Langmuir, Proc. IRE 25, 977 (1937). 102. P. A. Einstein, D. R. Harvey, and P. J. Simmons, J. Sci. Instrum. 40, 562-567 (1963). 103. J. Mulvey, J . Sci. Instrum. 36, 350 (1959). 104. R. Castaing, Adu. Electron. Electron Phys. 13, 317 (1962). 105. V. E. Cosslett and M. E. Haine, Proc. Int. Con/.Electron Microsc. p. 639. R. Microsc. SOC.,London (1954). 106. M. Drechsler, V. E. Cosslett. and W. C. Nixon, Proc. Int. Conf Electron Microsc., 4th p. 13 (1958).
138
JOHN KELLY
107. 0 . Klemperer and M. E. Barnett, “Electron Optics,” 3rd Ed. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York, 1971. 108. L. W. Swanson and A. E. Bell Adv. Electron. Electron Phys. 32, 194 (1973). 109. C. A. Spindt, J . Appl. Phys. 39(7), 3504 (1968). 110. R. Levi, J. Appl. Phys. 26, 639 (1955). 111. W. C. Hughes, Symp. Electron Ion Laser Beam Technol., 10th p. 441-452 (1967). 112. 1. Brodie, unpublished observations (1964). 113. P. Zalm and A. J. A. van Stratum, Phillips Tech. Rev. 27(3/4), 69 (1966). 114. A. J. A. Stratum and P. N. Kuin, J . Appl. Phys. 42(11), 4436 (1971). 115. R. F. Wolter, Symp. Electron Ion Laser Beam Technol., 10th p. 435 (1967). 116. J. Haanjes and G. J. Lubben, Philips Res. Rep. 12, 46 (1957). 11 7. J. Haanjes and G. J. Lubben, Philips Res. Rep. 13, 65 (1959). 118. C. C. T. Wang, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 18(4), 258-274 (1971). 119. H. W. G. Salinger and H. W. Beach, U.S. Patent 2,472,727 (1949). 120. K. Schlesinger, Proc. I R E 44, 659-667 (1956). 121. R. G. E. Hutter and M. B. Ritterman, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 19(6), 731-745 (1972). 122. S. P. Newberry, T. H. Klotz, Jr., and E. C. Buschmann, Prc. Natl. Electron. Conf:23,76 (1967). 123. C. Q. Lemmond, E. C. Buschmann, T. H. Klotz and G. M. White, IEEE Trans. Electron Devices 21, 598 (1974). 124. K. J. Harte, Symp. Electron Ion Photon Beam Technol., 13th p.1160 (1975). 125. W. C. Hughes, C. Q. Lemmond, H. G. Parks, G. W. Ellis, G. W. Possin, and R. H. Wilson, AFIPS Con$ Proc. 1975, Natl. Comput. Con$ pp. 541-548 (1975). 126. C. C. T. Wan& K. J. Harte, N. Curland, R. K. Likuski, and E. C. Dougherty, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. 10(6), 1 1 10-1 112 (1973). 127. J. S. Bryan and L. R. Focht, In “Large Capacity Memory Techniques for Computing
Systems” (M. Yovits, ed.), Macmillan, New York. 128. J. Kelly, Computer 8(2), 32 (1975). 129. J. Kelly, Proc. Con$ Appl. Small Accelerators, 3rd CONF-741040-P2. Natl. Tech. Inform. Serv. (1975). 130. T. Tamura, M. Tsutsumi, H. Aoi, H. Matsubhi, K. Nakagoshi, S. Kawano, and M. Makita, IEEE Trans. Mag. 8, 612-614 (1972). 131. J. H. Wensley, Computer 8(2), 44-48 (1975). 132. H. E. Bishop, P. Iredale, and D. Pooley, Intl. Symp. Colour Cent., Reading, Engl., 1971. 133. D. P. R. Petrie, Electron Microsc., Proc. Int. Congr., 5 t h Philadelphia 1, KK-2 (1962). 134. P. W. Hawkes, “Electron Optics and Electron Microscopy.” Barnes & Noble, New York, 1972.
Electron Beams as Analytical Tools in Surface Research: LEED and AES L. FIERMANS
AND
J. VENNIK
hboratorium tioor Kristallografe en Studie van de Vaste StoJ Rijksuniversiteit Gent, Gent, Belgium;
I. Introduction., .................................................................... 11. Low Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED) A. Introduction .......................................... B. Experiments .......
.............
139
142
sities ........ 148
.
...................................
155
E. Extra Features in Auger Spectra. .............................................. F. Lifetime Broadening and Coster-Kronig Transitions e Shape ......................... H. Crossover Transitions . ..................................
181
E. Results Obtained with LEED
A. Introduction
........................
C. Basic Principles of the Auger Process
.........................
.....................................
184 185 185 198
I. INTRODUCTION A space lattice, i.e., a three-dimensional periodic array of points indefinitely extended in space, is the geometrical analog of a perfect crystal. Departures from that mathematically perfect model are known as lattice defects. A discontinuity such as a surface is therefore a lattice defect on purely formal grounds. But it is a!so so on physical grounds because it confers to the solid, due to the presence of unsaturated bonds, properties that are solely due to its presence, just as other lattice defects do. The surface, the agent through which the solid reacts with is surroundings, has been intensively studied; but we still can state that it is the least known defect. The main reason for this was the impossibility of obtaining a clean surface and of keeping it uncontaminated for a sufficiently long period 139
140
L. FIERMANS A N D J. VENNIK
of time in order to make reliable measurements. The possibility of obtaining clean vacua of the order of lo-'' torr changed this situation. Examples of processes where the surface plays a major role are found in a wide variety of phenomena; adsorption is one example that is important in oxidation, corrosion, lubrication, catalysis, etc. In the semiconductor field, the surface to bulk ratios are increasing and so consequently does the importance of surface contamination. Surface treatments and cleaning procedures are therefore important factors in device fabrication. In a general paper on methods for the investigation of surfaces, Duke and Park ( 1 ) state that, when problems and phenomena related to a surface are considered, the following questions have to be answered : What is its structure? What is the origin of this structure, i.e., what are the bonding characteristics at the surface? What impurities and imperfections are present? What are the atomic motions experienced by the surface species? The two-dimensional structure of the clean surface is determined by its bonding characteristics. The asymmetrical forces can produce a displacement of the surface atoms relative to their normal sites, giving rise to structures different from the two-dimensional structure of a parallel lattice plane in the bulk. These structures are usually determined using low energy electron diffraction (LEED), although ion scattering spectroscopy (ISS) has recently also been used for this purpose. Auger electron emission spectroscopy (AES) is the most widely used method for determining cleanliness. The four questions that we mentioned above can, in principle, be answered by combining LEED and AES only. It is nevertheless desirable to have other analysis techniques in the same instrument. In choosing a technique to answer the four basic questions, one has in mind a series of criteria to which it should comply regarding sensitivity in general, resolution, sensitivity to elements and their compounds, capacity to separate isotopes, possibility for obtaining information concerning the chemical bonding of the species at the surface, and most important of all, limitation of the analysis to the surface, i.e., the uppermost layers of a solid. Another very important point is the fact that the method should give not only qualitative, but also quantitative data. In this review the emphasis is put on the practical applications of LEED and AES; i.e., How is a LEED pattern interpreted? How is an Auger spectrum analyzed, etc. Both LEED and AES remain the most widely used methods in surface research because of their relative instrumental simplicity.
ELECTRON BEAMS IN SURFACE RESEARCH
141
11. Low ENERGY ELECTRON DIFFRACTION (LEED) A . Introduction
The famous experiment in 1927 of Davisson and Germer by which the wave nature of moving electrons was demonstrated can be considered to be the first low energy electron diffraction experiment. Technical difficulties prevented the further development of this technique until the late 1950s, when a direct display apparatus was built by Germer and co-workers. A decisive factor in this development was the advent of ion-getter pumps, to obtain and sustain a vacuum in the lO-’’-torr range for periods sufficient to study clean surfaces. LEED has led to the discovery of new surface properties. One of the most interesting has already been mentioned, namely the fact that surfaces do not necessarily have the same structure as parallel planes in the bulk. Surface structure transformations, known in the LEED literature as surface reconstructions, can occur. Another important result concerns adsorption. It has been found that ordered adsorption occurs, i.e., well-defined two-dimensional structures can be formed depending on the coverage and type of impurity. Structural information alone however is generally not sufficient to describe surface phenomena completely. This is the reason LEED is used mostly in conjunction with other surface techniques, for instance Auger electron spectroscopy (AES). Until recently LEED was mainly used to determine surface periodicities because a complete structural analysis requires the interpretation not only of the positions of the LEED spots, but also of their intensities. An adequate theory to account for the latter has emerged only recently. It can now be stated that LEED has matured into a tool with which “surface crystallography” can be adequately practiced. The emphasis in this section is put on the information that can readily be obtained from LEED data, namely surface periodicity. This will be illustrated by a summary of the results obtained on clean surfaces (metals, semiconductors, oxides, insulators), on adsorption and chemisorption (and related subjects such as corrosion), on catalysis, and on a range of miscellaneous topics (surface melting, magnetic structures, etc.). The interpretation of spot intensities will also be discussed; a complete account of the details of the dynamical theory however falls beyond the scope of this review. B. Experiments
A LEED instrument consists of a spherical fluorescent screen, a grid system, and an electron gun (see Fig. 1). The electron gun produces a
142
L. FIERMANS A N D J. VENNIK
1
kV
FIG.1. Schematic representation of LEED electron optics: 1, specimen; 2, 3, grids; 4, screen; 5, third anode; 6, second anode; 7, first anode; 8, Wehnelt; 9, filament.
focused beam of low energy electrons ( < 500 eV), the diameter of which is approximately 1 mm. The electrons impinge on the specimen which, mounted on a specimen holder allowing rotations and translations, is positioned in the center of the fluorescent screen. The grid system is in fact a high-pass filter, repulsing the major part of the inelastically scattered electrons by biasing the first grid at a potential slightly less than that of the accelerator. The second grid is at ground potential, while the screen is set at high voltage in order to postaccelerate the electrons contributing to the diffraction pattern. The latter is directly visible through a viewing port of the ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) system. Figure 2 shows a typical LEED pattern recorded on a V,O,(OlO) surface, cleaved in UHV. Specimen cleaning in situ usually consists of one, or a combination of, the following operations: cleaving in UHV, flash heating, argon-ion bombardment, annealing. The cleanliness of the examined surface is determined either by an auxiliary technique such as AES or on the basis of LEED spot intensities. When the latter remain constant after repetitive cleaning cycles of different natures, the surface is considered to be virtually clean. C . Geometrical Interpretation of a LEED Pattern
1. Dejnitions and Notation The surface of a cleaved crystal is a net plane of which the unit mesh is determined by the smallest parallelogram reproducing the lattice using only
ELECTRON BEAMS IN SURFACE RESEARCH
143
FIG.2. LEED pattern recorded on a V,O,(OlO) surface, cleaved in ultrahigh vacuum, at 6 3 e V primary beam energy.
translations. The surface structure consists of this mesh, a Bravais lattice in two dimensions, and a base. The latter can be one atom or a more complicated molecule. The determination of the base is the problem of structure analysis. The unit or primitive mesh is determined by two unit vectors al, a2 (see
FIG.3. Direct and reciprocal unit meshes of a two-dimensional lattice.
Fig. 3). For a plane lattice, only a limited number of allowed rotations and reflections in the plane leave the lattice invariant. They are the 10 crystallographic two-dimensional point groups: 1,2, lrn, 2mm, 4,4rnrn, 3, 3m, 6,6mrn ( m represents a mirror reflection). This restricts the number of primitive
144
L. FIERMANS AND J. VENNIK
meshes to the five Bravais lattices. Their corresponding symmetries are 2, 2mm, 4mm, and 6mm (see Fig. 4). Adding the base to the five Bravais lattices
/7 f-----a =goo
d
c2
52
7 FIG.4. The five two-dimensional Bravais lattices.
results in the different surface structures. There are 17 space groups in two dimensions to describe the symmetries of these structures: P1, P2, Pm, Pg, Cm, Pmm, Pmg, Pgg, Cmm, P4, P4m, P4g, P3, P3m1, P31m, P6, P6m (g is the notation for a glide mirror plane or glide line). Next to the primitive lattice or direct net, a reciprocal lattice with unit vectors a: satisfying the conditions is defined. The construction of the reciprocal net is also represented in Fig. 3. A reciprocal lattice vector is defined by ghk
= h,a:
+ k,at,
h , = nh, k , = nk
(2)
It can easily be shown that in this case
I g h k I = 27Ln/dhk
(3) where d h k represents the spacing between the atom rows with Miller indices (hk), and that &hk is perpendicular to the direction of these rows. The reciprocal space of a surface consists of the set of perpendicular lines to the surface, constructed at the reciprocal lattice points. These are the so-called reciprocal lattice rods. From ( 1 ) it follows that if upon adsorption the dimensions of the direct lattice increase in both directions, the reciprocal lattice dimensions will decrease accordingly.
145
ELECTRON BEAMS IN SURFACE RESEARCH
In the LEED literature two kinds of notation are used to describe this phenomenon. The simplest notation includes the multiplication factors explicitly, e.g., Si(111)-(7 x 7) signifies a structure of the Si(l11) plane corresponding to a unit mesh which is seven times larger in both dimensions than the primitive one. One usually adds the symbol for the adsorbate responsible for the structure, e.g., Ni( 100)-0-(2 x 2) signifies a (2 x 2) structure occurring as a consequence of oxygen adsorption on a clean Ni(100) surface. The x f i ) R 45" notation implies a rotation over 45" of the new mesh with respect to the original one. It is often replaced by the notation c(2 x 2), meaning a centered (2 x 2) structure. The former notation was introduced by Wood (2). It is however inadequate to describe all kinds of adsorption structures, i.e., those that are not simply related or coherent with the substrate structure. In this case the transformation matrix relating the adsorbed layer unit vectors with those of the substrate is useful. If b,, b, are the unit vectors of the adsorbed layer, and
(fi
b, = h l a , + h2a,, b2 = h2,a1 + h2, a, (4) the value of the determinant of the transformation matrix determines the nature of the adsorbed layer (3). If det H = integer, the nets a and b are simply related and the superposition is sometimes called a true superstructure. The notation for the previous example, Ni(100)-0-(2 x 2) for instance, now becomes Ni(100)-0and ($
x
1 1,
f i )45" in this notation becomes
If det H is a rational fraction, the nets a and b are said to be rationally related, and the superposition is called a coincidence-site structure (4, 5 ) . The Si(ll1)-(7 x 7) structure, which we shall discuss in more detail in what follows, is considered by some authors to be a simple superstructure, for which det H = 1: I, while other authors assume it to be a coincidence structure, for which det H,for instance, could be equal to I 'h5 I. If det H is an irrational fraction, the adsorbed layer is unrelated to the substrate and the superposition is called incoherent; it is not describable by a net (6). As we shall see in what follows, adsorbed layers tend to arrange in register with the substrate because at low coverage the substrate-adsorbate interaction is usually much larger than the adsorbate-adsorbate interaction.
s,,
146
L. FIERMANS A N D J. VENNIK
2. Difiaction Conditions. Bragg’s Law and Ewald Construction The diffraction conditions can easily be deduced from a purely kinematical analysis (7). If a plane wave A(r) = A, exp i(k * r - at)
(5)
is incident on a surface, as represented by Fig. 5, the amplitude of the
FIG.5
scattered wave in R is proportional to
JJ dS n(r) exp i(k - r - kr cos(r, R))
(6)
where n(r) represents the electron density at the point r. If k represents the wave vector of the scattered wave in the direction R, the phase factor reduces to - i r . A k , where A k = k - k and Ikl = Ikl =2n/A (as a result of energy conservation in elastic diffraction). Introducing the atomic scattering factorfand taking into account that the scatterers on a surface are located at the lattice points, one obtains
A(R) = A,f
c c exp -i(ma, + .a2) m
n
*
Ak
(7)
and
assuming there are M x N unit meshes on the surface. The intensity shows sharp maxima when
-
a 1 Ak = 2nh,
-
a2 Ak = 2nk
(9)
ELECTRON BEAMS IN SURFACE RESEARCH
which reduces to
-
a, A&
a2 * Ak, = 2nk
= 2nh,
147
(10)
where Aks is the component of Ak parallel to the surface. These are the two Laue diffraction conditions. Taking into account that ghk
*
r = 271 x integer
(11)
-r
(12)
one obtains exp ig,,
=1
Consequently A k = ghk satisfies the Laue conditions, i.e.,
kl = ks + ghk
(13) This is the diffraction condition, which states that the value of the component of the wave vector parallel to the surface is constrained to within a reciprocal lattice vector. This is also th