Advances in
ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH VOLUME 21
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH Edit...
21 downloads
1406 Views
21MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH VOLUME 21
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH Edited by
M. BEGON Depnrtmenf of Zoology, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 S B X , U K
A. H. FITTER Department of Biology, University of York, York, YO1 5 D D , U K
A. MACFADYEN 23 Mountsandel Road, Coleraine, Northern Ireland
VOLUME 21
ACADEMIC PRESS Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers London San Diego New York Boston Sydney T o k y o Toronto
ACADEMIC PRESS LTD. 24/28 Oval Road London NWl 7DX United Stares Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. San Diego, CA 92101
Copyright @ 1991 by ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED
All Rights Reserved No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publishers
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Advances in ecological research. VOl. 21 1. Ecology 1. Begon, Michael 574.5 ISBN 0-12-013921-9
This book is printed on acid-free paper Editorial and production services by Fisher Duncan 10 Barley Mow Passage, Chiswick. London W4 4PH, UK Printed in Great Britain by St Edmundsbury Press Limited, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk
Contributors to Volume 21 L. I . BABBAR, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, M I 48109, USA. M. BRUNDREIT, Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, The University of Western Australia, Nedlands, W A 6009, Australia. C . P. CHANWAY, Department of Forest Sciences, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V6T 1W5. A . J . GRAY, Institute of Terrestrial Research, Furzebrook Research Station, Wareham, Dorset BH2 5AJ, U K . F . B. HOLL, Department of Plant Science, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V6T 2 A l . D . F . MARSHALL, Institute of Terrestrial Research, Furzebrook Research Station, Wareham, Dorset BH2 5AJ, UK. A. F . RAYBOULD, Institute of Terrestrial Research, Furzebrook Research Station, Wareham, Dorset BH2 5AJ, UK. D. D . RICHTER, School of Forestry & Environmental Studies, Duke University, 214 Biological Sciences Building, Durham, NC 27706, USA. R. H. SMITH, Department of Pure and Applied Zoology, University of Reading, Whiteknights, PO Box 228, Reading RG6 2AJ, UK. R. TURKINGTON, Department of Botany, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V6T 2 B l .
V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface This volume of Advances in Ecological Research contains five papers, two of which have an evolutionary slant, and two of which are concerned with plant-microbe interactions. The fifth paper, by Richter and Babbar reviews the diversity of tropical soils. There has long been a failure of communication between soil scientists and ecologists, made more serious by the simultaneous use of four different soil science taxonomies with numerous subsidiary dialects. The consequences have been particularly serious in the field of tropical ecosystem studies, where concepts developed outside the tropics have sometimes forcibly been imposed on unfamiliar soil types. One consequence of Richter and Babbar’s approach to clarifying the situation will certainly be that adherents among the soil science fraternity who espouse one of the existing systems will object to “oversimplification” and other misinterpretations of their discipline. If this article reveals that the emperor has n o clothes and stimulates discussion, it will achieve a useful function and may lead to a clearer view of the diversity of tropical soils. Certainly there is a need for soil scientists and ecologists to develop a better working relationship, as it is increasingly recognized how many fundamental ecological processes occur in the soil. Both Brundrett and Chanway, and his colleagues, examine aspects of the interactions between plants and soil micro-organisms. The mycorrhizal symbiosis is certainly the most widespread of all symbioses, but although a good physiological explanation of the function of most types of mycorrhiza has been achieved, their ecological significance is much less clear. Brundrett’s wide-ranging review pulls together a very diverse literature and points to important patterns in the mycorrhizal relationship on a global scale. Interactions between plants and other soil microbes are even less well understood, the Rhizobiurn symbiosis excepted. Chanway, Turkington and Holl look at a number of these interactions and consider the significance of specificity in determining their ecological behaviour. There are a priori expectations as to the relationship between the extent of mutualism and of specificity in these interactions, but the ecological consequences are less clear. There are a number of intriguing results in the literature, which are discussed in this article, which suggest that a vii
...
Vlll
PKEFAC’E
degree of specificity may occur in some of these interactions and may have important effects on plant-plant competition. Chanway and colleagues point to an important future area of research activity. The application of evolutionary ideas to such areas as this seems likely to bring considerable benefits; in evolutionary ecology in general, it is perhaps the study of life history patterns that has seen the greatest intellectual activity over the last twenty years. Nevertheless, a number of areas of confusion and deep uncertainty remain, including the questions of whether attention should be focussed on genotypes or phenotypes, and how these are likely to interrelate. In his paper, Smith makes great steps towards dispelling this confusion, by a careful and balanced exposition of the underlying ideas, and by a close look at one particular experimental system, from which he and his colleagues have obtained extensive and very pertinent data. One of the central questions of evolutionary biology is in practice an ecological one: how do species originate? One of the few documented cases of speciation in the last hundred years is that of Spartina anglica, the saltmarsh grass which has been so spectacularly successful at colonizing previously unoccupied regions of salt marshes in many temperate regions of the world. In effect, it appears to have occupied a vacant niche. Fortunately, its origin and spread have been carefully documented, and Gray, Marshall and Raybould give the first detailed account of its origin, spread and ecology. One striking feature that emerges is its extraordinary lack of genetic variability, which seems to have important implications for its future status and ability to withstand pathogens, as well as allowing its niche to be defined with remarkable precision. These papers form a group that represent several actively developing areas of ecology, but have no common theme. We make no particular effort to ensure that individual volumes of Advances in Ecological Research have such a theme, though we may from time to time put together special volumes on especially topical themes. One such that will shortly be appearing is on Global Change and is edited by a guest editor, Professor Ian Woodward. If readers have ideas on topics that would be appropriate to such treatment, we will always be happy to consider them. A . H. Fitter M. Begon A . Macfadyen
Contents Contributors to Volume 21 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v
vii
A Century of Evolution in Spartina anglica A . J . GRAY. D . F . MARSHALL and A . F . RAYBOULD
I . Summary .......................................................... I1. Introduction 111. The History of Spartina anglica .................................... A . The Discovery and Spread of Spartina x townsendii B . The Discovery and Spread of Spartina anglica .............. IV . The Origin of Spartina anglica A . Early Ideas on the Origin B . Evidence for the Origin C . "Spartinu x neyrautii" D . Problems over the Origin V . Variation in Sparrina anglica ...................................... A . Sources of Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica B . Evidence for Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica ......... VI . The Ecology of Spartina anglica A . Rates and Pattern of Spread and Dispersal B . Growth and Production C . The Niche of Spartina anglica D . Interactions with Other Species E . Die.back. Control and Conservation VII . The Future of Spartina anglica ..................................... Acknowledgements ...................................................... References
....................................................... ........ ..................................... .................................. .................................... ..................................... .................................. ........... ................................... ................. .................................... .............................. ............................ .......................
..............................................................
1 3 4 4 7 10 10 12 20 21 21 21 23 27 27 30 35 39 45 49 51 51
Genetic and Phenotypic Aspects of Life-history Evolution in Animals
R . H . SMITH I . Summary .......................................................... I1 . Introduction ....................................................... A . The Pieris rapae Problem .................................. B . Aims of This Review
...................................... ix
63 64 65 67
x
C'ON7'ENTS
111. Conccptual Framcworks ........................................... A . Lifc-history Theory ........................................ B . Quantitative Genetics., .................................... C . Multivariatc Selcction ...................................... D . Gcnc-Environment Interactions ............................ E . Thc G and E Matrices ..................................... 1V . Experimental Approaches Illustrated by CNllosohrirc/iiis ........... A . Phenotypic Correlation .................................... B . Experimental Manipulations ............................... C . Breeding Designs .......................................... D . Selection Experimcnts E . Mapping the Options Set .................................. V . Discussion ......................................................... Acknowledgements., .................................................... References ..............................................................
.....................................
68 69
77 83 88 91
93 94 97 100 106 109 110
112 113
Ecological Implications of Specificity Between Plants and Rhizosphere Micro-organisms
C . P . CHANWAY. R . 'TURKINGTON. and F . B . HOLL I . Introduction. ...................................................... 122 I1 . Specificity Betwcen Plants and Beneficial Micro-organisms ......... 127
111.
R/l;:oh;~ittz
........................................................
.................................................. .............
A . Infectivity B . Effectiveness ............................................... C . The Relationship of Infectivity to Effectiveness
129
129 133 135
........................................................... 136 A . Infectivity .................................................. 137 B . Effectiveness ............................................... 138 V . Associative Rhizosphere Bacteria .................................. 139 139 A . Infectivity .................................................. B . Effectiveness ............................................... 140 143 VI . Ectomycorrhizal Fungi ............................................ A . Infectivity .................................................. 144 B . Effectiveness ............................................... 144 VII . Vesicular-Arbuscular Mycorrhizal (VAM) Fungi .................. 146 A . Infectivity .................................................. 146 B . Effectivencss ............................................... 147 VI11 . Effects on Plant C'ompctition ...................................... 147 A . Symbiotic Bacteria ......................................... 147 150 B . Associative Rhizosphere Bacteria .......................... C . Mycorrhizal Fungi ......................................... 152 IX . Consequences of Specificity on Plant Community Structure ........ 153 X . Conclusions ....................................................... 156 Acknowledgements ...................................................... 157 liefercncos .............................................................. 157 IV .
Frritikiri
CONTENTS
Xi
Mycorrhizes in Natural Ecosystems
.
M BRUNDRETT 1. Summary .......................................................... I1 . Introduction ....................................................... 111. Mycorrhizal Ecology .............................................. A . Mycorrhizal Fungi ......................................... B . Edaphic or Climatic Factors and Mycorrhizal Fungi ........ C . The Host Plant ............................................ D . Plants and Mycorrhizal Fungi .............................. E . Edaphic/Environmental Factors. Plants and Mycorrhizas ... F . The Ecology of Mycorrhizal Plants ......................... IV . Conclusions V . Appendix 1 ....................................................... Acknowledgements ...................................................... References ..............................................................
.......................................................
171 172 173 175 176 194 196 202 235 257 262 271 271
Soil Diversity in the Tropics
D . D . RICHTER and L . I . BABBAR I . Introduction and Objectives ....................................... I1 . Changing Perspectives about Soil Taxonomy ....................... 111. The Development of Misconceptions about “Tropical Soil” ........ A . The Enormous Challenge of Mapping Soils on the 5-Billion Hectare Tropical Landscape ............................... B . Interdisciplinary Miscommunication about Soils in the Tropics .................................................... C . The Tower of Babel Effect of Too Many Taxonomies and Nomenclatures ........................................ D . Emphasis on Factors Rather than on Effects of Soil Formation: The 1938 Soil Classification .................... IV . Advances in Soil Taxonomy and the Creation of the World Soil Map ......................................................... A . Soil Taxonomy: A New Scientific Paradigm ................ B . FAO/UNESCO Soil Map of the World V . Diversity of Soil Taxa in the Tropics .............................. A . General Soil Taxonomic Variation in Tropical Africa, America and Asia ......................................... B . Ferralsols: Modern Inheritors of the Latisol Concept ...... C . Acrisols: the Underestimated Soil Order .................. D . Lithosols. Arenosols and Luvisols: From Extremely Fertile to Infertile. 500 Million Hectares Each .................... E . Regosols. Yermosols and Cambisols: Weakly Developed Soils ...................................................... F . The Other 1 Billion Hectares: Extreme Variation ..........
....................
316 320 322 332 333 333 336 342 342 346 350 356 357 359 360 361 362
xii
CONTENTS
VI . How Much Area in the Tropics Is Covered by Oxisols?: Results of the First Soil Surveys of the Amazon Basin A . Background ............................................... B . Some Common Properties of Amazonian Soils ............ C . The New Soils Map of the Brazilian Amazon .............. D . How Much Area in the Tropics Is Covered by Oxisols? .... E . A Realistic Concept of Soil Diversity in the Humid Tropics VII . Meso- and Local-scale Soil Variation in the Tropics VIII . Conclusions ...................................................... Acknowledgements ...................................................... References
.......................
...................................................
...............
..............................................................
Index ................................................................... Cumulative List of Titles ................................................
367 367 369 370 377 378 370 381 382 383 391 40 I
A Century of Evolution in Spartina anglica A . J . GRAY. D . F . MARSHALL and A . F . RAYBOULD
I . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. The History of Spartina anglica ........................ A . The Discovery and Spread of Spartina X townsendii . . . . . B . The Discovery and Spread of Spartina anglica IV . The Origin of Spartina anglica ........................ A . Early Ideas on the Origin ....................... B . Evidence for the Origin ........................ C . “Spartina x neyrautii” ........................ D . Problems over the Origin ....................... V . Variation in Spartina anglica ......................... A . Sources of Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica . . . . . . . B . Evidence for Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica VI . The Ecology of Spartina anglica ....................... A . Rates and Pattern of Spread and Dispersal . . . . . . . . . . . B . Growth and Production ........................ C . The Niche of Spartina anglica .................... D . Interactions with Other Species . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Die.back. Control and Conservation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . The Future of Spartina anglica Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.........
......
........................
1
3 4 4 7 10 10 12 20 21 21 21 23 27 27 30 35 39 45 49 51 51
.
I SUMMARY This review describes the origin and spread of the salt marsh grass Spartina anglica. the first specimen of which was collected from Lymington. Hampshire in 1892. and presents new material relating to its ecology and evolution . Using electrophoretically detectable variation. we confirm the strong circumstantial evidence that S . anglica originated by Copyright 0 1991 Academic Press Liniired All rights of reprodrrcrion i n any form reserved
ADVANCES IN ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH VOL . 21 ISBN 0-12-013921-9
1
2
A . J . GRAY E T A I . .
chromosome doubling of the sterile hybrid between the Old World species Spartina maritima and the North American Spartina alterniflora . In addition, extensive analysis of isoenzyme and seed protein phenotypes indicates that S . anglica is almost totally lacking in genetic variation. This may result from a narrow genetic base following a single origin or from a multiple origin from the uniform parents. It is likely to be maintained by the extensive clonal spread of most populations from a few, often deliberately introduced, founders and by preferential pairing at meiosis between identical homologous chromosomes preventing recombination between the component genomes. The implications of these findings are manifold. For example, the genetic uniformity of the species may help to explain why it has a relatively narrow ecological amplitude. A simple multiple-regression model incorporating largely physical, tide-related variables indicates that the distributional limits of Spartina in metres above Ordnance Datum are predicted remarkably well by tidal range, with variation in fetch, estuary area and position on the estuarine gradient significantly improving the prediction (generating equations explaining more than 90% of the variation in both the upper and lower limits). That the niche of the species can be so well defined is most probably due to its recent evolution and its lack of genetic differentiation as well as the predominance of physical, as opposed to biological, factors limiting its downshore spread. The species’ genetic uniformity, coupled with its frequent occurrence as dense, monospecific stands, may also account for the recent rapid spread in several populations of the ergot fungus, Claviceps purpurea. For example, in Poole Harbour, Dorset, the average level of infected inflorescences rose from 36% in 1983 to more than 85% in 1988. Spartina anglica is, unusually among temperate grasses, a C4 species (one of only eight such species in Britain), and the implications of this method of carbon fixation in a species whose biomass production and possible northward spread may be limited by early spring and summer temperatures is considered, particularly in relation to projected climatic warming. The short-term causes and consequences of die-back in the southern parts of the plant’s range are described, including the changes in low water tidal channels accompanying the invasion and subsequent decline of Spartina in a south coast harbour. In a section describing the species’ interaction with other species we discuss the effects of Spartina’s invasion on aerial and benthic invertebrates and on overwintering wading birds, particularly the dunlin, Calidris alpina, the decline in numbers of which correlates with the spread of the grass in British estuaries. Soil conditions, grazing and temperature are important factors affecting the competitive interaction
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN S P A R T I N A A N C L I C A
3
of S. anglica with Puccinellia maritima, the latter invading S. anglica swards more rapidly in sandier, grazed marshes in more northern latitudes. The consequences of the genetic bottleneck that occurred during the speciation process and the relative youth of S. anglica in evolutionary terms are emphasized throughout by comparing the species with P. maritima. The greater variation, population differentiation and niche breadth of the latter species are particularly evident. Finally, we look forward to the changes which may occur with global warming and rising sea levels and how they may affect the second century of the species' evolution.
11. INTRODUCTION The perennial salt marsh grass Spartina anglica C.E. Hubbard has become the textbook example of allopolyploid speciation and successful invasion by a new species (Fig. 1). First recorded from Lymington, Hampshire, in 1892, it now occurs in temperate zones throughout the world, mainly because it has been widely planted to stabilize tidal mud flats. It has profoundly altered the ecology of mud flats and salt marshes over many thousands of hectares.
Fig. 1. S. anglicn.
4
A . J . GRAY ET A L .
The first one hundred years of the “Spartina story” (Lambert, 1964) have produced an extensive literature -a bibliography with more than 480 references was compiled by J.C.E. Hubbard more than 25 years ago (Hubbard, 1965, unpublished). In this contribution we do not attempt a comprehensive review of that literature, but highlight the important landmarks in the study of the species. These include its discovery and spread in the early part of the century, the detective work in the late 1950s and early 1960s on its origins, the extensive research during the same period on its ecology, particularly in southern England where S. anglica-dominated marshes were already showing extensive die-back, and the demonstration in 1975 that the species utilizes the C4 photosynthetic pathway. These findings are discussed in the light of recent significant advances in several research areas. Among the most illuminating of these are biochemical confirmation of the species’ origins and the evidence of a narrow genetic base. The latter is particularly relevant in considering the development of the species’ niche, its interaction with other species, especially pathogens, and its future evolution. The following sections bring together these recent findings and attempt to demonstrate that S. anglica continues to provide a rare and fascinating opportunity to gain insight into the early stages of species evolution. In examining this continuing and dynamic process we also look forward to the possibility of cycles of invasion and decline, of northward spread under global warming, and of changing relationships with pathogens and competitors.
111. THE HISTORY OF SPARTZNA ANGLZCA A. The Discovery and Spread of Spartina
X
townsendii”
In 1879, H. and J. Groves described a plant growing on mud flats at Hythe, Hampshire “. . . which, by the majority of characters given in British works, would be S. alterniflora rather than S. stricta [= S. rnaritirna], yet which we now consider to be the latter”. By 1880, however, the Groves had revised their opinion that the plant was a form *Nore on nomenclarure: For many years it was thought that there was only one form of the hybrid between S. marifima and S. alrerniflora. namely the fertile amphidiploid. In 1957, however, C.E. Hubbard showed that there still existed the F1 hybrid between S. maririma and S. alterniflora. H e stated that this form was the one described by the Groves, and. therefore, the name “rownsendii” should only be applied t o the initial hybrid rather than its amphidiploid derivative. This left the amphidiploid without a name. Hubbard (1968) invalidly published the name S. anglica for the amphidiploid. although later (in Heywood. 1978, p. 364) he published a valid diagnosis. so legitimizing the name. The term ”S. ariglica agg.” will be used in this article when referring specifically to both forms together.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANCLICA
5
of Spartina stricta and wrote that it “. . . occupies so intermediate a position between that species and S. alterniflora, that it appears desirable not to include it in either”. The Groves (1880, 1882) named this plant Spartina fownsendi (spelt initially with one “i”; the second was added by other authors and is now the accepted spelling) in honour of Frederick Townsend, author of the Flora of Hampshire (Britten, 1906). There is some dispute as to how long these forms of Spartina had been at Hythe before the Groves described them as a new species. According to Hubbard (1965a), the Groves collected the plants on which they based their descriptions in 1877. Hubbard states, however, that a Mr R.S. Hill had collected specimens of the same plant at Hythe in 1870, but that the plant was thought to be a luxuriant form of Spartina rnaritima. Sutherland and Eastwood (1916) also gave 1870 as the first date of collection of S . X townsendii based on a specimen in the Warner Herbarium, University of Southampton. They suggest, moreover, that descriptions of Spartina alterniflora from near Southampton given by Sowerby in his “Grasses of Great Britain”, published in 1861, are very close to those of S. x townsendii published by the Groves. The earliest confirmed date for the discovery of S. x townsendii, however, remains 1870. The plant spread relatively slowly at first and had not reached Cracknore Hard (2 miles north of Hythe) by 1883 (Stapf, 1908), but was recorded from Southampton in 1887 (Stapf, 1913). Stapf (1913), however, describes how “. . . towards the end of the eighties, something occurred that favoured the spreading of the grass”. Marchant (1967) correlates this with the formation of the seed-bearing amphidiploid S. anglica. Indeed, the first confirmed record for S . anglica is from 1892 at Lymington, Hampshire. After this date it often becomes difficult to know whether records are referring to S . X townsendii or S . anglica as the distinction between the two was not recognized until 1957 (see footnote p.4). Goodman et al. (1969) state that sterile material features largely, though not exclusively, in collections from 1892 to 1910, such as those from Yarmouth, Isle of Wight (1893), Poole Harbour (1905), and Lymington (1893 and 1907). After 1910 it is likely that as S . anglica was deliberately introduced into other parts of the British Isles for coastal protection and land reclamation (see below). Spartina X townsendii was also introduced into some areas due to mixed collections of both species being made, especially as many collections were made from Poole Harbour where S. x townsendii was still present in several sites in the 1960s (Hubbard, 1965a). Spartina x townsendii is still present as substantial swards at Hythe and has been found on the landward edge of S. anglica swards in Norfolk (Swann, 1965), Poole Harbour (Hubbard, 1965a) and the
6
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
Bristol Channel (Holland, 1982). The preference of S . x rownsendii for these higher, more stable habitats also occurs in Holland (Drok, 1979). Hubbard and Stebbings (1967) estimated that the total area covered by S. x townsendii in Britain was only 20 ha compared with about 12000 ha of S. anglica. As in the British Isles, S . anglica has been used overseas for land reclamation and coastal defence, and it seems inevitable that some S. x townsendii has been introduced along with it, especially when the material had been taken as cuttings from Poole Harbour. Spartinu x townsendii has been recorded from Holland on the basis of cytological data (Drok, 1979, 1983) and may also occur in New Zealand. The presence of S. x townsendii there is based on the fact that much " S . anglica" in New Zealand produces no seed (Allan, 1930; observations of C. E. Hubbard in Ranwell, 1967); however, the erratic nature of seed set in S . anglica (see below) makes this a poor diagnostic character. The other confirmed site for S . x townsendii is in the extreme south west of France and north east of Spain around Hendaye and San Sebastian, although it has only just been recognized as such. In 1892 Neyraut collected an unusual form of Spartina at Hendaye and these plants were named S . x neyrautii by Foucaud in 1894 (Mobberley, 1956). This species has long been regarded as a hybrid between S. maritima and S . afterniflora and recent evidence from isozyme studies has confirmed this (see below). Under the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature, therefore, S. x neyrautii must be regarded as a synonym of S. x rownsendii as it was the later of the two names to be published (Raybould et al., 1990). Although S . x townsendii occurred in several locations in this area, extensive land reclamation reduced it to a single site near San Sebastian Airport (Hubbard et al., 1978). Another complication when considering the distribution of S . x townsendii is the occurrence of polyhaploids derived from S. anglica. Marchant (1967) described a seedling of S . anglica that was morphologically very close to S . X townsendii rather than its S . anglica parent. A chromosome count of this plant gave 2n = 61, which was exactly half the number of the parent clone (Marchant, 1968). This seedling was produced presumably by the development of an unfertilized egg cell (agamospermy), and its similarity to S . x townsendii is to be expected as homologous chromosomes in S. anglica are identical and chromosome pairing is predominantly as bivalents (see below). Spartinu anglica gametes, therefore, will be very similar genetically to S . x townsendii. Marchant (1975) has suggested that S . x townsendii in some parts of the country may be secondarily derived from S. anglica by polyhaploidy. The occurrence of dwarf, densely tillering forms of S . anglica that have been described from the Bristol Channel and the Dovey Estuary (Chater
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
7
and Jones, 1951; Chater, 1965), from areas north of Dublin (Boyle, 1976a), south west Holland (Drok, 1979, 1983) and New Zealand (Allan, 1930; Bascand, 1970) may represent polyhaploid clones; careful cytological examinations are required, however, to confirm this suggestion.
B. The Discovery and Spread of Spartina anglica As stated above, the first record for S . anglica is from Lymington in 1892 and after this date there is uncertainty as to whether records refer to the sterile F1 or the amphidiploid. The exact place and date of the origin is unknown. Although the rate of spread in the 1890s and 1900s was rapid, suggesting spread by seed, Goodman et al., (1969) believe that in many areas the F l was predominant. Whatever the proportions, by 1899 either S. anglica or S . X townsendii had begun to colonize Poole Harbour in the west and Chichester Harbour in the east, and many intervening areas (Stapf, 1908). On the north coast of the Isle of Wight there were populations at Yarmouth by 1893, on the River Medina in 1895, and on several marshes between Ryde and Cowes in 1907 (Stapf, 1908). Back on the mainland, Christchurch Harbour was beginning to be colonized by 1913 (Oliver, 1920) and Pagham Harbour by 1918 (Oliver, 1925). Oliver (1925) also gives a record from the mouth of the River Rother at Rye. The colonization of salt marshes between Poole and Rye probably represents the extent of completely natural spread of S . anglica in the British Isles, although extensive secondary natural spread following deliberate introductions has occurred (e.g. Goodman et al., 1959). Spartina anglica also spread to the north coast of France by natural means (or by accidental spread through shipping activity; there is no record of S . anglica ever having been deliberately introduced into France (Ranwell, 1967)). The first records are from Reville, on the north east tip of the Cotentin Peninsula, and Carentan at the mouth of the River Vire in 1906; slightly further east, the species was found at Sallenelles on the River Orne just north of Caen in 1918 (Oliver, 1925). By 1926 there were 1000 ha of S . anglica at Carentan (Oliver, 1926). The other area where S. anglica has been very successful in France is on the marshes at the mouth of the River Seine. The first record is from Tancarville in 1915 and from Harve and Deauville in 1922 (Oliver, 1925). Oliver (1926) says that the rate of spread of S . anglica on the Seine marshes was the fastest he had ever seen, and Senay (1934) estimated that the plant covered 1000 ha. Spartina anglica seems to have colonized many of the estuaries on the northern coast of France and
8
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
Ranwell (1967) estimated that there were between 4000 and 8000 ha of Spartina by the mid-1960s. The distribution of S. anglica, both in the British Isles and around the world, has been radically altered by deliberate introductions of the species. In the 1900s it was realised that S. anglica was very efficient at stabilizing bare mud flats (Stapf, 1907). This led to its utilization by private landowners as a method of reclaiming mud flats for agriculture and by coastal defence authorities for coastal protection. Many introductions of the species have been made around Great Britain and they have been thoroughly catalogued by Goodman et al. (1959) and Hubbard and Stebbings (1967). The first record of deliberate planting of S. anglica is from the Beaulieu Estuary in 1898, and this was followed by north Norfolk in 1907 and the Lincolnshire Wash in 1910. Most of the planting, however, was carried out in the 1920s (e.g. Bryce, 1936) with major efforts (utilizing 2000 or more cuttings (Ranwell, 1967)) in the Thames and Blackwater Estuaries, the Exe, the Severn Estuary (especially on the Somerset coast), the Dee, and the Humber. The east coast plantings were very successful, and during the 1930s virtually every estuary in Essex and southern Suffolk was either planted with Spartinu or was colonized as the result of natural spread from the introduced material (Goodman et al., 1959). The other major population of S. anglica on the east coast is in the Wash with further smaller populations as far north as Udale Bay in the Cromarty Firth (Smith, 1982). The plant has also been introduced successfully on the west coast. Hubbard and Stebbings (1967) record that the estuaries of the Severn, the Burry, the Dovey, the Mawddach, the Dee, the Ribble, and the Wyre all have populations of S. anglica in excess of 100 ha. Numerous other estuaries and salt marshes between these major sites have S. anglica populations, with the furthest north being the Isle of Harris in the Outer Hebrides. Goodman et al. (1959), Hubbard and Stebbings (1967) and Ranwell (1967) all estimated the total area of S. anglica in Great Britain to be about 12000 ha. This has been revised recently by Charman (1990) to 10000 ha, though Charman points out that part of the disparity may lie in differing estimation procedures. What is clear, nevertheless, is that there have been significant changes in the distribution of S. anglica since 1967. Charman records a 44% reduction in cover on the east coast, an 11% reduction on the south coast, and a 40% increase on the west coast. The south and east coast populations of S. anglica are some of the oldest, whilst those on the west coast are much younger. Indeed, Charman reports that 20 new S. anglica populations have become established on the west coast since Hubbard and Stebbings’ survey. This is evidence that S. anglica populations undergo a change from invasion and sward formation to regression (often termed “die-back”) . Reasons
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
9
for this are discussed in later sections. The current distribution of S. angfica in Great Britain is shown in Fig. 2. In Ireland, S. angfica was first introduced on the south coast in the River Lee in 1925 (Cummins, 1930). Further introductions were made on the west coast in the Shannon and Fergus in 1928, 1931 and 1932
Fig. 2. The distribution of S. anglica (including records of Spartinu X townsendii) in the British Isles (GB-204, Ir-27, Ch.Is-1). Map supplied by the Biological Records Centre, ITE, Monks Wood.
10
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
(Praeger, 1932). On the east coast, introductions were made in the Dublin Bay area in 1932 (Boyle, 1976a) and in Belfast Lough in 1929 (Praeger, 1932). Ranwell (1967) estimated that there were between 200 and 400 ha of S. anglica in Ireland. Spartinu angfica has now been successfully introduced into many areas outside the British Isles, notably Holland (4000-5000 ha), Germany (400-800 ha) and Denmark (500 ha), with smaller introductions in Australia and New Zealand (Ranwell, 1967). The most remarkable spread has been that following the introduction of the species to China. The descendents of only 21 individuals, survivors of a batch of 35 sent as seed in thermos flasks by D. S. Ranwell in 1963, have spread, mainly by planting, along almost the entire Chinese coast to occupy, by 1980, more than 36000 ha (Chung, 1990). Spartina anglica's present geographical range is from 57.5 "N to 48 "N in Europe, 46 "S to 35 "S in New Zealand and Australia (Ranwell, 1967), and from 41 ON tQ 21 ON in China (Chung, 1990). Unsuccessful introductions of S. angfica have been made on the eastern seaboard of the USA, in the Caribbean and the Guianas, India and South Africa. Ranwell (1967) has suggested that winter temperature may be the crucial factor in whether establishment is successful; the species is damaged by frost, and warm winter temperatures are said to impede development. It is worth remembering, however, that S. anglica survived for nearly 2 years in British Guiana and was only exterminated after it was overrun by a native Spartinu species, Spartina brasifiensis (Lambert, 1964). To conclude, it is interesting to note the role of Poole Harbour in the spread of S. angfica, especially in the light of the scarcity of genetic variation in the species (see below). Hubbard (1965a) estimated that between 1924 and 1936 over 175000 cuttings were exported from material derived from Poole Harbour, and of these 46000 were planted in the British Isles. This figure does not include numerous batches of seed from this material that were also dispatched. This must represent a severe genetic bottleneck for the species.
IV. THE ORIGIN OF SPARTZNA ANGLZCA A. Early Ideas on the Origin Despite the fact that the Groves' descriptions of S. X townsendii had emphasized that the plant had many morphological characters intermediate between those of S.maritima and S. alternifloru, it is surprising how little the possibility of a hybrid origin is considered in the early literature. Most authors tried to fit the new form into previously
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
11
decribed taxa. Boswell (in Groves and Groves 1882) suggested that the plant might be ”true” Spartina glabra, and Townsend (1883) thought that the plant was a variety of S. maritima. Corbibe and Chevalier, writing in 1906 about the appearance of Spartina in Normandy, claimed that S. angfica could not be a hybrid as it had fertile pollen and seeds, and because S. alterniflora did not occur in northern France (Oliver, 1925); they thought the plant to be S.glabra var. pilosa. Many of the early explanations of the appearance of the S . angfica agg. were based on the possibility of a direct introduction of foreign Spartina taxa, usually one of the numerous named varieties in the S . alterniflora/S. glabra complex. This is probably more a reflection of the confused state of the taxonomy of S. alternifloru at that time than to any great resemblance of the S . anglica agg. to the published descriptions of other taxa (see Mobberley (1956) for a review of the ideas on the taxonomy of S. alterniflora). The introduction of a foreign species theory was disposed of by Stapf (1908), who found that no species of Spartinu exactly matched the forms that had first appeared at Hythe. Stapf proposed that the most plausible alternative was that the S. anglica agg. had arisen by hybridization between S . maritima and S. alterniflora, given the intermediate morphology of the plants and their similarity to “S. x neyrautii” which had arisen in the only other location where S. maritima and S. alterniflora co-existed (Stapf, 1908). This idea rapidly became accepted, although the uniformity of seed progenies of S . anglica created problems because if the species was a hybrid, segregation of parental traits would be expected. The situation was summed up by Oliver (1925) who wrote: If it [ S . anglica] is a hybrid, then it should betray its hybrid constitution. In one respect it does this, viz. in the extreme vegetative vigour which it displays. A vigorous constitution of this kind is not unusual in a first cross; what is surprising is that not only is this vigour maintained through many seed generations but that the plant should remain substantially uniform. There is no evidence of segregation, which is to be expected in an ordinary hybrid.
Oliver goes on to say that the lack of segregation may not necessarily be a problem and appears to propose the possibility that the characteristics of s. anglica could be explained by allopolyploidy: This circumstance [lack of segregation], which at first sight seems to negative the hybrid theory, does not however absolutely close the door to i t , because there exists a class of hybrids characterized by perfect stability. But it would be premature to assert that S . townsendii belonged to this class, without the production of evidence.
Huskins (1930a,b) finally provided this evidence when he made chromosome counts on S. anglica and its putative parents, and found them to
12
A . J . G R A Y ET A L .
be in perfect agreement with the theory of an allopolyploid origin. Although Huskins’ figures have proved to be inaccurate (see below), the publication of his papers firmly established allopolyploidy as the prevailing theory to account for the origin of S . anglica, and this theory has never been in serious doubt. There is now a wealth of evidence to show that S . x townsendii is a hybrid between S . maritima and S . alterniflora, and that chromosome doubling in S . X townsendii, either in somatic tissue or by the fusion of unreduced gametes, produced S. anglica. This evidence can be split broadly in four categories: morphological, historical, cytological and biochemical.
B. Evidence for the Origin
1 . Morphological Evidence As noted in a previous section, when the Groves first described S. X townsendii they thought that the plant was S. alterniflora but then decided that it was S. maritima (Groves and Groves, 1879), before eventually deciding that the plant was neither of these species. The reasons for thinking initially that the plants were S . alterniflora were that the specimens were too tall to be S. maritima and that the panicles consisted of four to six spikes rather than the two usually present in S. maritima. In addition, the spikes were longer and had more spikelets than usual for S . maritima. The Groves thought, however, that these were unreliable characters for distinguishing between S . alterniflora and S . maritima. The decision to assign the forms found at Hythe to S. maritima was based on them having leaves distinctly articulated with the leaf sheaths and flag leaves that did not overtop the spikes, both characters of S . maritima. Spartina alterniflora, on the other hand, has leaves that are more continuous with the sheaths and flag leaves that always extend beyond the spikes. It can be seen from the early confusion that S. x townsendii has many characteristics in common with both S. maritima and S . alterniflora, tending towards S . alrerniflora in inflorescence structure, and towards S. maritima in foliage characters. These hybrid characteristics are borne out by the data of Marchant (1967) and Hubbard (1968). Other characteristics given as evidence of hybrid origin are the prolific rhizome production, as in S. alterniflora. and the dense tillering, as in S. maritima. The morphological evidence is, therefore, consistent with S . X townsendii being a hybrid between S. alterniflora and S . maritima. This being the case, we may ask whether the morphology of S.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N G L I C A
13
angfica is consistent with it being the product of chromosome doubling in S . x townsendii. The failure to distinguish between the two for over 50 years shows that they have many features in common. In most respects apart from height, however, S. angfica is larger than S . x townsendii (Marchant, 1967; Hubbard, 1968). Spartina anglica leaves tend to be longer and wider, the ligules are longer, and the spikes are longer as are the spikelets. This is suggestive of the so-called “gigas” morphology of increased size of plant organs resulting from increased cell size due to polyploidy. Marchant (1967) also found that the volume of pollen grains of S . angfica is twice that of S . x townsendii, a strong indication that chromosome doubling in S . X townsendii gave rise to S . angfica. Thus, the morphological data are entirely consistent with the classical theory.
2. Historical Evidence From information on the historical distribution of S . afterniflora and S. maritima it can be shown that the two species co-existed in Southampton Water immediately prior to the discovery of S . x townsendii. Spartina maritima occurs from Britain and the Low Countries in the north, through France, Spain and Portugal, and into the Mediterranean: further south the plant occurs in rather isolated populations down the west coast of Africa from Morocco to the Cape of Good Hope. Spartina maritima is usually thought of as a native of the British Isles. Throughout northern Europe, however, it shows a lack of vigour in comparison with specimens from Spain and Africa. This led Chevalier (1923) to suggest that it may only be native to Africa and was introduced into northern Europe by shipping. The first record for S . maritima in Britain is from northern Kent in 1629 (Hubbard, 1965b). Bromfield (1836) recorded it from the mouth of the River Itchen and Hythe, and Townsend (1883) described it as being “rather common” in Hampshire. By the 1900s the species had been recorded from Lincolnshire to north Kent on the east coast, and from Chichester to the Exe on the south coast (Stapf, 1908). This probably represented the greatest limit of S . maritima in Britain and by the 1930s it was becoming quite rare. Hall (1934) records that it had been “practically exterminated” in Hampshire, and in a recent survey the only location for the plant on the south coast was Hayling Island (Raybould et al., 1991b). The pattern is similar on the east coast, where since 1950 the plant appears to have been lost from Lincolnshire, Norfolk and Kent and now occurs only on high level salt marshes in Essex and southern Suffolk (Raybould et al., 1991~). There appear to be several reasons for the decline of S . maritima. On the south coast many habitats have been destroyed through land
14
A. J . GRAY E T A L .
reclamation for agriculture or industrial development; this is especially so in Southampton Water (Marchant, 1967; Raybould et a[., 1991b). On the east coast, although some populations may have been lost through land reclamation, the major factors have been erosion and successional change, the invasion of high-level S. maritima habitats by Halimione portulacoides being a particularly common cause of its decline (Raybould et al., 1991b). It has often been assumed that the spread of S. anglica has been important in the decline of S. maritima. These species rarely co-occur, however, and the spread of S. anglica and the decline of S. maritima are probably two independent indicators of ecological, sedimentary and sea level changes, rather than cause and effect. Spartina alterniflora is a native of the eastern seaboard of North America where it grows in large monospecific swards from Newfoundland in the north to the Gulf of Mexico in the south. The species is also recorded from tropical South America, although some botanists consider these records refer to the closely related species S. glabra Muhl. Sparrina alterniflora was probably introduced into Southampton Water from the USA by shipping. Bromfield (1836) suggests that the species may have been in the River Itchen since 1816. Townsend (1883) records that in 1879 it was “abundant by the Itchen from the sea upwards to beyond Southton [Southampton]”. Stapf (1908) also recorded that the plant was abundant in the Itchen and Southampton Water. The range of the species extended ultimately from Lymington in the west to the mouth of the River Meon in the east (Hall, 1934). As is the case with S. maritima, S. alterniflora has undergone a major decrease in distribution since the turn of the century. Industrial development has played a large part in this regression, although some populations were lost due to being overrun by S. anglica (Marchant, 1967). Since 1963 the species has existed at only one site, at Marchwood on the west shore of Southampton Water (Marchant and Goodman, 1969). From the records available, there appear to be two places where S. maritima and S. alterniflora occurred together, namely at the mouth of the Itchen and at Hythe. Bromfield (1836) wrote that where the Itchen entered Southampton Water “Sp. stricta grows close to patches of Sp. alrerniflora”. Townsend (1883) also recorded both species from this location. Townsend also reported S. alterniflora and S . maritimu as growing together at Hythe, and the Groves (1879) found specimens of S. X townsendii growing amongst stands of S. alterniflora. If it is assumed that S. maritima was growing at the mouth of the Itchen when S . alterniflora was first introduced, then the species could have existed together for over 50 years before the discovery of S . x rownsendii. Historical records show, therefore, that the origin of the S. anglica agg. through hybridization was feasible.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
15
3. Cytological Evidence The first work on the cytology of the S. anglica complex was by Huskins (1930a,b). Using mitotic cells from root tip meristems, he found S . maritima had 2n = 56, S. alterniflora 2n = 70 and S. anglica 2n = 126. These counts fit exactly with the theory that S . anglica is the amphidiploid derivative of the other two species. Huskins used plants of S. alterniflora from New York State rather than British material, which left him open to the criticism that he may have examined a different cytotype from the one involved in the origin of S. anglica (Marchant, 1963). Nevertheless, the results seemed so conclusive that for nearly 30 years the question of the origin of S. anglica was not re-examined. The work of Hubbard (1957) in pointing out that an F1 hybrid existed at one time probably sparked a new interest in the cytology of the S. anglica complex. Boyle and Kavanagh (1961) counted 2n = 126 for S. anglica from Ireland, although they later corrected this to 2n = 124 by the re-interpretation of multivalents (Boyle, 1973). Marchant (1963) showed that Huskins’ counts were inaccurate, and gave counts for S. maritima of 2n = 60, for S. alterniflora of 2n = 62, and for S. anglica a range from 2n = 120 to 124. He also found sterile plants at Hythe with 2n = 62 and these were designated S. x townsendii. These counts were in good, though not in perfect agreement with the classical theory. Marchant (1968) gives a detailed account of the cytology of the complex. Spartina maritima almost always forms 30 bivalents at meiosis and all mitotic cells had 2n = 60. In S . alterniflora from Britain, Marchant found some inconstancy in chromosome number in some tillers. In one tiller there was a range from 2n = 61 to 2n = 66 with a mode of 62. Meiotic counts were always n = 31 with a maximum of two multivalents per cell, suggesting a polysomic constitution of 6x + 2. Marchant (1970) also counted S. alterniflora material from North America and found 2n = 62 in all cases. This ended speculation that S. alterniflora existed as two chromosome races of 2n = 8x = 56 and 2n = lox = 70 (until the 1960s it was thought that the genus Spartina had a basic number of 7 rather than 10). In S. x townsendii Marchant (1968) found some variation in chromosome number within tillers, with a mode of 62. As with S . alterniflora, he suggested that the variation had a physiological basis as plants that had weak growth had most variation. Meiosis was shown to be complex with numerous univalents and multivalents at metaphase I (Fig. 3 ) . Trivalents were the most common multiples, although quadrivalents and other arrangements occurred, and usually less than half of the chromosomes were left unpaired. Chiasma frequencies ranged from 0.53 to 0.75
16
A. J . GRAY E T A L .
Fig. 3. Metaphase 1 at meiosis in Spartinu = 62).
X
townsendii ( 2 n = 6111
+ 1511+
per paired chromosome, and from 17.4 to 31.3 per cell, depending on univalent frequency. The highest pairing was in plants with the “dwarf brown” phenotype first described from the Dovey Estuary and the Bristol Channel by Chater and Jones (1951). Marchant found a range of chromosome numbers in S. anglica from 2n = 120 - 127, with the great majority of clones having 120, 122 or 124. All clones showed almost regular meiotic pairing (Fig. 4) with a high chiasma frequency of 0.74-0.86 per paired chromosome. Univalents occurred up to a maximum of ten per cell in aneusomatous plants due to some chromosomes having no homologue with which to pair. Quadrivalents occurred up to a maximum of five per cell, and trivalents to a lesser extent. Marchant also described possible backcrosses of S. anglica to a parental species. Two unusual clones were found in Southampton Water. One clone gave a count of 2n = ca 90 at meiosis, with a
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
Fig. 4. Diakinesis at meoisis in S. anglica (2n = 61fI
17
+ 2 , = 124).
maximum of 16 univalents and only rare multivalents. There was relatively little lagging at anaphase, and the second division was more or less regular, giving tetrads that appeared normal. Seed set in the clone was described as “abundant”. The other clone gave counts of 2n = ca 76 from mitotic cells. At meiosis up to 19 univalents were found with few multivalents. At anaphase laggards were common with as many as 11 univalents being excluded from daughter nuclei. Tetrads were irregular but seed was set occasionally. Both these clones resembled S. alterniflora in morphology (Marchant, 1967) and possibly represent a backcross of S. anglica to this parent. The genome relationships elucidated by Marchant’s work are shown in Fig. 5 , and strongly support the theory of the origin as outlined previously. Despite the very strong evidence, from several sources, some doubts still remained over the origin of S. a n g b . First, it had not proved possible to resynthesize the species from the putative parents. Marchant (1964) attempted to cross S. maritima and S. alterniflora by bagging
18
A. J . G R A Y E T A L .
I I
S. martfirnu x 2n = 6x = 6 0
Salfernifforu 2n = 6x
+ 2 =62
S. x rownsendii 2n =ca 6x = 6 2
2 nd backcross 2n = ca 7 6
chromosome doubling
S onqlica 2 n = c a 12x=120,122 8 124-
agamospermy
J
polyhaploids
1st backcross 2n=cu 90
chromosome loss
\ oneuploids
Fig. 5. Genome relationships in Sparfina (based on Marchant, 1968).
flowering heads together and by placing pots in which the species were growing adjacent to each other. In neither set of experiments was seed set on either species. Marchant (1964) also used colchicine in an attempt to double the chromosome number of S. x rownsendii to produce S . anglica. Treatments included immersion of tiller and rhizome apices in colchicine solution, application of colchicine-containing agar blocks to growing points, and injection of colchicine solution inside the leaf sheath enclosing the flowering spikes. In no instance was chromosome doubling induced. Also, Raybould (1989) found that the pollen of both S. alrerniflora and S . maritirna grown in a glasshouse was completely sterile on the basis of the fluoroscein diacetate test (Heslop-Harrison et al., 1984), so that experiments to resynthesize S. x rownsendii could not be performed. A second doubt was raised by the revised chromosome counts presented by Marchant. The counts of Huskins meant the possibility that S. anglica could have arisen directly from either S. alterniflora or S. rnarifima through autopolyploidy could be discounted. The new counts made by Marchant. in which the chromosome numbers of both S. maritirna and S. alterniflora are roughly half those of S. anglica, meant that autopolyploidy must be considered.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N G L I C A
19
The available evidence was largely against an autopolyploid origin. First, the karyotype of S. anglica appeared to be a combination of the karyotypes of S. maritirna and S . alterniflora (Marchant, 1968). The chromosomes of Spartina are, however, very small and Marchant could not unequivocally confirm an allopolyploid origin on the basis of chromosome morphology. Secondly, the chiasma frequency in both putative parents is high (Marchant, 1968) and thus an autopolyploid produced from either of these species might be expected to have a high frequency of multivalents. Spartina anglica forms multivalents rarely (see Fig. 4, for example) and so the case for alloployploidy seemed strong. There are several cases documented, however, where autopolyploids form only bivalents. This phenomenon has been observed, for example, in Lotus corniculatus (Dawson, 1941), Tolmeia menziesii (Soltis and Soltis, 1988), the fern genera Asplenium and Adianturn (Lovis, 1964; Vida, 1970; Manton et al., 1970) and in several artificially produced autotetraploid crops (Timmis and Rees, 1971; Armstrong, 1971; de Wet and Harlan, 1972). Thus, autopolyploidy could not be rejected completely.
4. Biochemical Evidence The evidence that finally confirmed the allopolyploid origin came from isozyme electrophoresis. In newly formed allopolyploids the component diploid genomes are often expressed entirely (Gottlieb, 1982). Thus an allopolyploid species would have isozyme phenotypes that are the product of the addition of parental polypeptide subunits, resulting in all the parental bands being present, plus possible new hybrid bands in multimeric enzymes (Roose and Gottlieb, 1976). In newly formed autotetraploids it is assumed that no bands could be present that were not present in the parental species, and this is borne out by the evidence available (Crawford and Smith, 1984; Soltis and Soltis, 1988). It has recently been shown (Gray 1986; Raybould 1987, 1989; Gray et a f . , 1990a; Raybould et al., 1991b) that British material of S. maritima and S. alterniflora possess unique bands in several isozyme systems and that S . x townsendii contains all of these bands (see Fig. 6). In addition, S. x townsendii showed several novel hybrid bands in systems where multimeric enzymes are formed. In all systems S. anglica had phenotypes identical to S . X townsendii. This evidence completely confirmed the allopolyploid origin of S. anglica. Guenegou et al. (1988) found similar results using French material, although certain features of this work suggest that the genotypes of the parental material they examined were not those involved in the origin of S. anglica. For example, in superoxide dismutase they found that both S. alterniflora and S.
20
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
Fig. 6. Isozyme phenotypes in Spartina demonstrating that S . anglica phenotypes are those expected if the species is an allopolyploid derivative of S. alterniflora and S . maritima. a (Upper): Esterase (1-4 S. maritima, 5-6 S. x townsendii, 7-8 S. anglica, 9-11 S. alterniflora, 12 S . glabra) b. (Lower): Phosphoglucose isomerase (1-3 S. alterniflora, 4-9 S . anglica, (10-13 S . maritima) (with permission from Raybould el al., 1991a).
maritima had bands that were not present in S . anglica, whereas Raybould et al. found that in British material of the parental species all of the parental bands in this system are found in the hybrids. A similar position occurred with acid phosphatases. Guenegou et al. also found esterase phenotypes with non-parental bands, which, since most esterase enzymes are monomeric (Gottlieb, 1981), further suggests that their material was not involved in the origin of S. anglica.
C . ‘Spartina
X
neyrautii”
The evidence reviewed in the preceeding sections confirms beyond reasonable doubt the nature of the origin of S . anglica. There is, however, further evidence from a plant known as S. x neyrautii. In south west France there was also an accidental introduction of S. alterniflora. It was discovered by Loiseleur in the Ardour Estuary near Bayonne in 1803. By the early 1900s it had spread along the coast for about 25 miles from Capbreton to the Bidassoa Estuary (Stapf, 1908). S.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
21
maritima is native to this area (Mobberley, 1956). In 1892, Neyraut collected an unusual form of Spartina from Hendaye (Mobberley, 1956) and the status of this plant and similar types found in the area caused much confusion. When Neyraut discovered the plant he though it to be identical to S. x townsendii (Chevalier, 1923). In 1894 Foucaud described it as a hybrid between S. maritima and S. afterniflora (Stapf, 1908), but named it S. x neyrautii as he believed it had certain differences from S. x townsendii. The hybrid nature of S. x neyrautii was confirmed by Marchant (1977), who found that it had the same chromosome number and meiotic behaviour as S. X townsendii and also very similar morphology. Raybould et af. (1991a) confirmed that the plant is a S. maritima x S. afterniflora hybrid using isozyme phenotypes, and showed that S. X neyrautii must be considered as a synonym of S. X townsendii. The fact that S. X townsendii has been discovered in the only two places where the distributions of S. afterniflora and S. maritima are known to have overlapped is a further confirmation of the nature of its origin.
D. Problems Over the Origin Two questions remain to be answered over the origins of the S. angfica agg. First, did S. angfica sensu strict0 arise more than once, and second, do the two independent origins of S. X townsendii represent reciprocal hybridizations, as suggested by Arber (1934). The first question has been addressed by Raybould et al., (1991a). They found that S. angfica has extremely low levels of genetic variation at isozyme loci (see below), suggesting a single origin. The parental species and S. x townsendii, however, also show little variation and so a multiple origin from uniform parents cannot be discounted. Further research using more sensitive methods of detecting genetic variation (such as “genetic fingerprinting”) may resolve this problem. There is no available information on the second question. A possible solution, however, may be a study of the inheritance of chloroplast or mitochondria1 markers, which have been used recently to demonstrate reciprocal origins for Tragopogon species in the USA (Soltis and Soltis, 1989).
V. VARIATION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
A. Sources of Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica The available evidence on the levels of genetic variation in British populations of the parental species of S. angfica is limited to an isozyme
22
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
survey by Raybould et al. (1991b). This found that the single extant population of S. alterniflora was monomorphic, and, although there was some evidence of variation in S. maritima, British material of this species also appeared to be largely monomorphic with isozyme variation limited to two comparatively rare forms of the enzymes shikimic acid dehydrogenase and glutamate oxalacetate transaminase. As indicated earlier, this lack of significant levels of isozyme polymorphism in the parental species means that it is not possible to distinguish between single or multiple occurrences of either the original hybridization event which produced S. X townsendii or the subsequent chromosome doubling which produced S. anglica (as has been done with other allopolyploid species such as Senecio cambrensis (Abbott and Ashton, 1989), Tragopogon (Roose and Gottleib, 1976) and Pfagiomnium medium (Wyatt et al., 1988)). However, the lack of enzyme polymorphism in the parental species does at least suggest that even if multiple events have occurred, they are likely to have resulted in genetically identical forms of S. anglica. Since the original formation of the species, the generation of variation in S. anglica may have occurred in a number of ways apart from conventional mutation. One possible source of variation is through backcrossing and subsequent introgression with one of the parental species. Some evidence of the type of chromosomal polymorphism that might be associated with such events exists (see Section IV above). Two further potential sources of variation are chromosomal in origin. In an allopolyploid species such as S. anglica, in which chromosome doubling has restored fertility, pairing at metaphase I of meiosis often only occurs between homologous chromosomes, i.e. equivalent chromosomes from the same parental genome. This phenomenon, known as preferential pairing, has been extensively studied in polyploids such as wheat (e.g. Riley and Chapman, 1958). Strict preferential pairing maintains the variation between the parental genomes in the form of fixed heterozygosity (e.g. Aung and Evans, 1987). In contrast, if homeologous pairing. i .e. pairing between the equivalent chromosome from different parental genomes, occurs, recombination between the parental genomes is possible. Homeologous pairing- even at relatively low frequenciescould lead to the gradual release of genetic variation from recombine? tion between the parental genomes. A second chromosomal source of variation is through aneuploidy (i.e. the gain or loss of chromosomes) as the result of either unbalanced segregation at meiosis or somatic events. In general, plant species, especially high polyploids such as S. anglica, are relatively tolerant of the resulting unbalanced chromosome dosage that results from aneuploidy, at least through the vegetative stages of their life cycle. However,
A C E N T U R Y OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
23
the resulting complications at meiosis normally lead to at least some level of reduced sexual fertility. This is not a problem in species which, like S. anglica, propagate extensively by asexual means (Gibbs et al., 1978).
B. Evidence for Genetic Variation in Spartina anglica 1. Morphological Variation Although many authors have reported field observations of morphological variation in S . anglica, it has only recently been systematically studied. Some evidence of phenotypic variation comes from piants which appear “distinct” under field conditions, for example the “brown dwarf” type identified by Chater and Jones (1951). Marchant (1968) has shown that many dwarf forms have a chromosome number of 2n = 62, suggesting that they have a polyhaploid origin. Some other “distinct” types have been shown to revert to typical S. anglica morphology when brought into artificial cultivation (Raybould, 1989). Spartina anglica has also been observed to display zonal variation in morphology across some salt marshes. For example, Marks and Mullins (1984) and Marks and Truscott (1985) have reported the zonation of S. anglica on the salt marshes of the southern shore of the Ribble estuary, in north west England. They recognized four zones on the basis of shoot density and vegetative vigour. Zonation of S. anglica has also been extensively studied on the salt marshes of the north shore of the Dee estuary in Cheshire. Taylor and Burrows (1968) identified differences in time of flowering, seed production, rates of tillering and number of overwintering shoots across this marsh. If these zonal differences are genetic in origin and the result of adaptive differentiation in response to different environmentally induced selection pressures across the marsh, extremely rapid microevolution must have occurred since the original colonization of the Cheshire marshes on the Dee in 1945. However, genetic variation cannot be inferred from such observed zonal differentiation alone since any genetic effects will be confounded with age effects and a range of environmental effects. Material from the Dee estuary salt marsh has been subjected to careful study in a series of common garden experiments. Plants derived from single tillers, from distinct zones showed significant differences even after 2 years of cultivation under common environmental conditions (Hill, 1990). In addition, plants transplanted into the zones from which they originated showed significantly greater rates of survival than plants transplanted between zones. This appears to indicate that there may be a genetic component to the observed zonal differentiation across the Dee estuary salt marsh. However, the unambiguous resolution of
24
A . J . G R A Y ET AL.
such morphological variation into its genetic and non-genetic components in such a phenotypically plastic species as S. anglica poses a number of major experimental problems. Since individual clones may be long-lived, there is considerable potential for carry-over effects into clonal trials under common garden conditions. Carry-over effects may arise in several ways. For example, differences in the nutritional status of the clones can produce effects, as in the differences in salt tolerance among clonal lines of Puccinellia maritima which were found to be caused by variation in the salt concentration of the soils from which the clones were sampled rather than by differences in genotype (Gray and Scott, 1977). Carry-over effects may also occur in perennials from differences in clone age, older ramets being less able to change their phenotypes in response to environmental change (Breese et al., 1965). Different levels of viral infection, to which long-lived clonal plants are especially prone, may also lead to non-genetic differences in gross morphology, yield and competitive ability (Silander, 1985)-although its effects on growth are unknown, a leaf mottling virus, spartina mottle virus, was identified by Jones (1980) and isolated from plants in several populations. Unfortunately, the differences in morphological variation in S. anglica populations, both zonally in the Dee and Ribble estuaries, and within and between complementary zones on different salt marshes (Thompson, 1990), are largely of the type which could arise from differences in clonal age or viral infection levels. Although there is no direct evidence of such effects, plants from the lower zones, which are usually younger, are generally more vigorous and have greater phenotypic plasticity (Thompson, 1989, 1990; Thompson et al., 1990, 1991 a,b,c. Thompson et al. (1990, 1991a,b,c), on the basis of further common garden, reciprocal transplant and genotype/environment experiments, suggest that most of the variation is due to age-related decline in vigour, and thus to somatic rather than genetic differences between populations. The only way to resolve this variation into its genetic and environmental components would be to carry out an appropriately designed trial of seed progenies (using the type of experimental designs summarized in Lawrence (1984)). This has not proved possible in S. anglica because of the unpredictable pattern of seed set in recent seasons, the problems of controlled germination of seed, and the difficulties of growing such a large, vigorous, rhizomatous salt marsh perennial grass in a fully randomized field trial. Ideally, seed progenies produced under glasshouse conditions should be used, to avoid environmental differences during seed maturation, which can cause carry-over effects (e.g. Funk et al., 1962; Nelson et al., 1970). Even strong short-term environmental stimuli at the seedling stage can influence the phenotype of that plant’s seed progeny (Hague and Jones, 1987).
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
25
2. Biochemical Variation Although high levels of seed protein variation and extensive isozyme polymorphism are features of many higher plant populations (e.g. Gepts, 1990; Hamrick and Godt, 1990), an extensive study of protein variation in S. anglica conducted by Raybould et al. (1990b) found no evidence of seed protein variation, and found only a single GOT isozyme variant in a survey of 12 different enzyme systems. In contrast, the polyploid grass P. rnaritirna was found to be highly polymorphic for every isozyme system studied in the population coexisting with monomorphic S. anglica on the Dee estuary salt marshes (Raybould et al., 1991a) (Fig.7), and in several other populations (Gray et al., 1979). It
Fig.7. Comparison of the variation in esterase isozymes in clones of (a) (Upper): S. angfica and (b) (Lower): P. rnaritirna collected along the same 300 m transect on the Dee estuary (with permission from Raybould et af., 1991a).
26
A . J . G R A Y ET A L .
appears, therefore, that at the protein level S. anglica has extremely low levels of genetic variation. The single G O T variant identified by Raybould et al. (1991a) was characterized by the loss of several G O T bands which correlated with a small reduction in chromosome number, suggesting an aneuploid origin. The variant appeared to be largely confined to Poole Harbour and showed considerable variation in frequency between creeks. Its sporadic distribution elsewhere may reflect either a series of sampling events, as Poole material has been distributed throughout Britain, or alternatively a series of independent aneuploid origins. Of course, a lack of electrophoretically detectable variation does not conclusively signify an absence of genetic variation. Isozyme markers may show lower levels of variation than quantitative traits, as in Hordeum mitrinum (Giles, 1984) and Xanthium strumarium (Moran and Marshall, 1978; Moran et al., 1981). In general, however, seed proteins tend to be more variable than isozymes, probably because of fewer functional constraints on seed protein structures (Gillespie and Blagrove, 1975; Righetti et al., 1977). For example, Doll and Brown (1979) estimated that hordeins were 10-30 times as variable as isozymes in barley. The completely invariate protein profiles of S. anglica seeds are therefore strong indicators of genetic uniformity in the species-particularly as we assume the seeds to be produced sexually, whereas common garden trials use vegetative tillers which could be entirely clonal. The general conclusion that can be drawn from the existing information is that, apart from the sporadic occurrence of chromosome variation resulting from aneuploidy, polyhaploidy and back-crossing (see above), there is little unambiguous evidence of genetic variation in S. anglica. This is what one might expect from both its origin and the pattern of its subsequent spread, since British material of both parental species shows little evidence of variation; the original hybridization event and the subsequent chromosome doubling appear to have occurred at very low frequency, possibly only once, and the process of small-scale clonal sampling and subsequent multiplication which has been used to plant out new sites would have dramatically reduced any variation which might have been present. Finally, conventional mutation is unlikely to have led to the generation of significant levels of genetic variation over such a short evolutionary timescale.
3. Genetic Variation in Other Clonal Salt Marsh Grasses The lack of genetic variation in S. anglica which is likely to be a major factor in the future evolutionary success of the species, is in contrast to at least some other clonal salt marsh grasses. Genetic differentiation, some of adaptive significance, has been demonstrated in P. maritima
A C E N T U R Y OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
27
using clonal and seed progeny trials and isozyme studies (Gray, 1985a, Gray er al., 1979, Gray and Scott, 1980), as has genetic variation in salt tolerance in salt marsh Festuca rcibra using clonal and seed progeny material (Rhebergen and Nelisson, 1985). Perhaps more significantly, Silander (1984, 1985; Silander and Antonovics, 1979) provided evidence for adaptive genetic variation in North Carolina populations of the related Spartina patens, which, although based on trials of clonal material, was supported by isozyme variation. Indeed, clonal plants generally are found to possess genetic variation, most having multiclonal populations with most clones restricted to one or a few populations and rarely being widespread (Ellstrand and Roose, 1987).
VI. THE ECOLOGY OF SPARTINA ANGLICA
A. Rates and Pattern of Spread and Dispersal As detailed above, S. anglica was successfully introduced to coastal and estuarine mudflats throughout the world, especially during the 1920s and 1930s. Natural dispersal of seed, usually in entire spikelets, over long distances may have occurred by tidal currents, shipping, or on the feet of wading birds (as suggested by Hardaker (1942) as the means by which it reached an inland site on the Droitwich Canal (Goodman et al., 1969)). The rate of spread at individual sites has varied greatly but in many areas has involved the rapid spread from transplants or other propagating units to form a continuous sward. This process has acquired a terminology (Hubbard, 1965a), young plants derived from seedlings or plant fragments expanding into more or less circular “tussocks” which fuse to form “clumps”, often of irregular outline, with clumps finally coalescing to form a “sward”. Caldwell (1957) noted a pattern of concentric rings of different shoot density distribution in expanding tussocks (which she termed “auxoclones”), growing without competition on open mudflats. The rings are produced annually by the peripheral growth of rhizomes but are not detectable in all expanding tussocks. The formation of swards is not always a rapid or continuous process. Many of the early transplants failed or appeared to be held at the tussock phase. The known reasons for failure include inappropriate site conditions (too unstable, too sandy) and frost, particularly at the northern edge of the species’ range; the death of transplants by frost has been recorded from Scotland (J. Bryce, unpublished), the north Netherlands (Kamps, 1962), north Germany (Konig, 1948) and China (Chung, 1990). The very slow spread in some areas may have been due to the introduction of only S. x townsendii plants, which are both less vigorous
28
A. J . GRAY E 7 A L .
vegetatively and unable to spread by seedlings. This is believed to account for the slow expansion of populations in several Australian and New Zealand marshes (Ranwell, 1967). Even where the fertile amphidiploid has been introduced and has become successfully established, the rate of spread may be remarkably discontinuous. Particularly characteristic of western and northern sites in Britain is a pattern where initial colonization, whether slow or rapid, is followed by a long period of around 20, 30 or even 40 years during which there is little or no expansion in area of the tussocks or swards. This is then followed by a sudden burst of population growth. Gray et al., (1990a) have documented such a pattern in the Conwy estuary in North Wales, where the rapid colonization of a large mudflat in the upper estuary occurred in the early 1970s, adjacent to a sward which had not grown much in area for almost 20 years. Deadman (1984) records a similar rapid expansion between the mid-1960s (the Hubbard and Stebbings (1967) estimate) and 1982 in several other Welsh estuaries to which the plant had been introduced in the 1930s. In Morecambe Bay there has been rapid colonization in recent years of parts of the River Kent estuary, where only isolated clumps were present up to 1982 (R. Scott, pers. comm.; Whiteside, 1984). Further north, in the Cromarty Firth (57.5 O N ) , the populations at Dingwall Bay, planted in 1932, had not increased much in size by 1955 but were expanding by around 2 m per year (with a maximum of 8 m in 1976) during the 1970s (Smith, 1982). Similarly, at nearby Udale Bay, populations established in 1948 expanded in area from 1358m’ in 1970 to 4228m’ a decade later (Smith, 1982). The causes of this pattern are unknown, but evidence from several sites indicates that sudden spread is marked by a successful phase of seedling establishment, lasting only 1 or 2 years, followed by expansion of the more-or-less evenly aged tussocks to eventually form a sward. These events require the coincidence of high seed production and suitable conditions both for seedling establishment and subsequent tussock expansion. It is not clear which of these conditions is most frequently absent in sites where S. anglica is failing to spread. Although the species is noted for the unpredictable production, viability and germination of its seeds (Hubbard, 1970; and below), it is equally clear that in some areas changes in the sedimentary regime have preceded the expansion of the population. For example, the tidal flats recently colonized in Morecambe Bay became notably muddier, due to a change in position of the River Kent low-water channel, before they were invaded. In some areas, colonization of the tidal flats below an existing sward occurs by the successful establishment of plant fragments. This may
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
29
follow uprooting by storms, as at Bridgwater Bay (Ranwell, 1964a), or by grazing animals, as at Udale Bay (Smith, 1982). Both plant fragments and seedlings may occur as propagating units in the same area (Chater and Jones, 1957; Taylor and Burrows, 1968). Under suitable conditions, seedlings may occur at densities up to 13000 m-’ on bare mud and up to 9750m-’ in the sward, where most die, the sward being maintained by rhizome formation and tillering (Goodman, 1960; Goodman et al., 1969). The factors affecting seedling establishment on bare mud have been studied experimentally by Groenendijk (1986), who demonstrated a critical interaction between mudflat elevation, and hence hydrodynamic stability, and seed burial depth in determining seedling emergence and growth. Seeds buried between 1 and 3 c m had the greatest chance of establishing as seedlings, those nearer the surface being lost through desiccation or sediment movement, and deeper buried seeds deteriorating rapidly in viability. The lower elevational limits of S. anglica in Groenendijk’s study area (the Oosterschelde in the south west Netherlands) were controlled mainly by wave action uprooting seedlings, supporting Morley’s (1973) suggestion that this is a major limiting factor. Seed production in S. anglica is extremely variable, both temporally and spatially. Goodman er al., (1969) recorded 92% seed-set at Lymington in 1954, followed by 18% the next year. Taylor and Burrows (1968) found both seasonal (15%, 38% and 64% in successive years) and tussock to tussock variation in the Dee estuary. Detailed studies of the Ribble estuary marshes have revealed zonal variation in filled spikelet production, Marks and Truscott (1985) recording in 1978 2.3%, 77.1%, 16.9% and 3.7% in successive zones from the pioneer to the upper limit of S. anglica. However, less than 5% of the filled spikelets produced seed which germinated. Mullins and Marks (1987) recorded values ranging from 3.1 to 6.8%, from 6.7 to 25.8%, from 2.1 to 4.5% and from 4.0 to 5.7% over three years in the comparable zones of a nearby marsh. Although filled spikelet production in Poole Harbour populations averaged 27% in 1984, no seed germinated, and viable seed production has been exceptionally low in every year since 1983 (Gray el a f . , 1990b). It is not surprising that seed does not set in most years since seed production may involve the breakdown of a self-incompatibility system. Raybould (1989) used the petri-dish method of Lundqvist (1961) to examine cross-pollination of S. anglica from geographically widely separated populations. In all cases, growth of the pollen was arrested rapidly and the pollen tubes had the typical curled appearance found in a “weak” self-incompatibility reaction (sensu Shivanna et al. , 1982). Grasses have a two-locus self-incompatibility system, and in polyploid grasses only one allele needs to be matched at each locus in the pollen
30
A. J. GRAY E 7 A L .
and stigma for a self-incompatibility reaction to result (Fearon el ul., 1984a,b,c). As S. anglica is a duodecaploid with a very narrow genetic base, it is extremely unlikely, that there are any cross-compatible genotypes within the species. When seed is produced, it is only in inflorescences which appear relatively early in the year. Inflorescences emerging after August on the Ribble marshes all failed to produce mature filled seed, irrespective of their position on the marsh (Mullins and Marks, 1987; Marks and Mullins, 1984). The delayed development of inflorescences in the higher parts of the marsh was thus a major factor in the much lower proportion of seed produced in this zone. The conditions under which the self-incompatibility system may break down, sporadically producing large numbers of viable seed, are unknown. The occasional production of seed in glasshouse-cultivated plants suggests that higher than average temperatures and humidity may be a factor. High temperatures are known to lead to a breakdown in self-incompatibility in other species, for example Trifolium repens (Chen and Gibson, 1973) and Lilium longiflorum (Ascher and Peloquin, 1966). Additionally, Stapf (1913) noted that high seed set occurred following a hot, dry summer in 1911. In summary, the natural spread of S. anglica populations characteristically comprises two phases: the initial invasion and establishment of seedlings on open mudflats. and the subsequent radial expansion of tussocks to form clumps and ultimately a sward. Seedling establishment is a rare event in most populations and often follows many years of purely clonal expansion. This may be when mudflat conditions reach a threshhold of sediment type or stability or following a year in which, unusually, there is high seed production (or when both circumstances coincide). In the 1970s and 1980s there appears to have been a sudden expansion of several populations in estuaries in the west and north of Britain to which the plant may have been introduced in the 1930s and 1940s. Of the factors related to tidal submergence which may limit the seaward spread of populations, the tidal uprooting of seedlings is known to be particularly effective.
B. Growth and Production The annual cycle of growth in S. anglica comprises the production in leaf axils in November of overwintering buds which then grow fast and flower in the long days of summer and early autumn, the flowering culms dying as a new generation of buds is formed the following November (Goodman et al., 1969). Rhizomes develop during the winter, in response to short days (Goodman 1960). Flowering extends from July to November and even, in mild winters, into the following year.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
31
Spartina anglica swards occur across a wide range of sediments ranging from clays, fine silts and organic muds to more sandy substrata and even shingle where it is regularly inundated by the tide. They also experience a wide range of sediment accretion rates, generally varying from 3 mm year-' to as much as 8-10 cm year-' (Bird and Ranwell, 1964; Ranwell, 1964a; Lee and Partridge, 1983), but extremely high annual rates recorded for short periods in actively growing swards include 17 cm at Bridgwater Bay, England (Ranwell, 1964a), 20.cm l,at Sloedam, the Netherlands (Verhoeven, 1951), and 24 cm and 26 cm at Qidong and Rudong, respectively, in China (Chung, 1990). This range of conditions is reflected in the variation in productivity. Estimates of above-ground standing crop from British marshes include an average of around 825 gm-2 (dry weight) on high marshes and a range from 418 gm-2 to 1232 gm-' at Bridgwater Bay (Ranwell, 1961, 1964b), an average of 1145 gm-2 (Dunn et a f . , 198l), from the Ribble estuary marshes, and a range of values from 400-500 gm-' for Seafield Bay in Essex (Long et al., 1990). Estimates of above-ground net primary production range from 475-700 gm-' year-' at Seafield Bay to 1600-1850 gm-2 year-' in the Ribble (Scott et al., 1990; Scott in Marks and Truscott, 1985). Groenendijk (1984) reported an annual aboveground net primary production of 1162-1649gm-2 in a Dutch salt marsh. All these figures are considerably lower than those reported for S. alterniflora marshes in North America (e.g. Turner, 1976) where maximum values of 4 800 g me2 of annual above-ground net productivity may be reached in tall creek-edge stands (Gallagher et al., 1980). In one of very few studies of below-ground biomass in S. anglica, Dunn (1981) and Long et al., (1990) have shown that, although there is much year-to-year variation, on average 75% of the biomass was below ground, with rhizomes accounting for around half the below-ground total, and that peak below-ground biomass was reached in the early winter. They also estimated that gross primary production, which takes account of the turnover of shoots, roots and rhizomes between samples, in the Seafield Bay marsh was around 4500gm-2year-', some three times the estimate of net production. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the growth of S. anglica is the late annual development and temperature dependence which stem essentially from its utilization of the C4 photosynthetic pathway. The species is one of a small number of C4 species in the British flora (eight known, of which at least three are introductions-Long (1983)) and is exceptional among them in being a dominant component of large areas of vegetation (Long et al., 1975). The C4 species, in which the first product of photosynthetic C 0 2 fixation is oxaloacetate, in contrast to phosphoglycerate in C3 species, mostly occur in tropical and subtropical regions and are rare in cool, temperate
32
A . J . G R A Y ET A L .
climates. The "Kranz" leaf anatomy (numerous chloroplasts in the bundle sheath cells) and low C 0 2 compensation point (the ambient concentration of C 0 2 at which the net flux of C 0 2 at the leaf surface in the light is zero) typically found in C4 species was reported for S . anglica in 1975 (seemingly independently by Long er al. (1975) and Mallott et al. (1975)). Further work by S. P. Long and his colleagues has established that S. anglica shows at least partial adaptation to cooler climates, being able to tolerate, and maintain photosynthesis at, lower air temperatures than nearly all other C4 species (Dunn et al., 1981; Long and Woolhouse, 1978; Long and Incoll; 1979, Long, 1983; Thomas and Long 1978). Although at optimum temperatures C4 species exhibit greater nitrogen and water-use efficiency than comparable C3 species, a factor which may be important in the high tolerance of salinity in S. anglica and its relatives, their photosynthetic rates are generally inferior at 1 6 ° C and at 7-9°C photosynthetic C 0 2 assimilation ceases. In S. anglica, however, photosynthetic rates of individual leaves equal those of the C3 species P. maritima at 5 "C and 10 "C and exceed them above 1O"C, reaching to 50% higher at 25 "C. (Similar results have been obtained from one of the other temperate perennial C4 species, Cyperus longus (Jones et al., 1981.)) Despite this partial adaptation, demonstrated in the laboratory in plants grown at temperatures above 12 "C, detailed field studies in south east England have shown that, whilst some leaf growth may occur throughout the year, significant canopy development does not begin until the mean air temperature exceeds 9 "C (Dunn, 1981; Dunn et al., 1981; Long, 1983). This is revealed in the contrast in growth pattern with P. maririma shown in Fig. 8. P. maritima shows an increase in shoot weight in March, when air temperatures rise above 5 "C, growth peaking in June and July, whereas S. anglica does not show an increase until June, when temperatures exceed 9 "C, and peaks in October. Despite this, both species have a similar net primary production, that in S . anglica being produced over a shorter and later period (Hussey and Long, 1982). Indeed, Long (1983) concludes that adaptation of S. anglica, and other C4 perennials, to cool climates has been through their ability to grow and reproduce during the relatively short part of the year when average temperatures rise above 9-10"C, as well as the partial adaptation of C02-assimilatory capacity to low temperatures. This feature of the growth of S. anglica may be reflected in the zonal pattern of seed production in more northerly populations, described above, where the later flowering of the high marsh plants was attributed by Mullins and Marks (1987) to the delay of tiller development by depressed spring and early summer soil temperatures in this zone (Marks and Mullins, 1990). Detailed studies of the tiller dynamics of the
33
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
I
I
M
1
A
I
M
1
J
1
J
1977
1
A
1
S
1
O
1
N
1
O
I
J
I
1
F
M
1978
Fig. 8. The dry weights of living shoot material in monotypic stands of S. anglica and P. mnritima in northeast Essex; also shown is mean air temperature. Modified from Long (1983).
Dee estuary population lend support to this idea. Taylor and Burrows (1968) report earlier and more vigorous shoot production in lower marsh populations, as do Hill (1990), Thompson (1989), and Thompson et al. (1991a,b), who show that shoot production also continues later in the pioneer zone and that there are clear zonal differences in tiller demography. The more vigorous growth in the pioneer zone is marked by higher tiller production and the greater proportion of tillers which flower within a year. Thompson el al. (1991a) also reports markedly later flowering in a population of S. anglica in the Cromarty Firth, a similar trend of later flowering in northern populations having been
34
A . J . G R A Y ET AL.
observed for S. alterniflora on the east coast of the USA (Somers and Grant, 1981). The contrast in seasonal growth and production between S. anglica and P . rnaririrna consequent upon their utilization of different photosynthetic pathways suggests that the outcome of their competitive interaction will be strongly influenced by climate, and particularly spring and early summer temperatures and the length of the growing season. Although confounded by variation in sediment type and grazing, there is evidence that the ability of P . rnaririrria to replace S. anglica on the northern Dutch marshes of the Waddensea area is related to its relatively early seasonal development, and thus shading of young S. anglica shoots (Scholten and Rozema, 1990). In the south Netherlands Delta area, dense monospecific swards of S. anglica are currently persisting or, as in southern Britain, are only slowly being invaded by P. maririrna and other species. The rate at which S. anglica is being replaced by P . niaritirna and other species, notably Aster tripoliurn and Suaeda rnaritima, in the north Ribble marshes (Hill, 1987), and the decreasing upper limit to S. ariglica swards with increasing latitude (described below), are also indicators of climatic effects on the species' growth and competitive ability. Recently, Long (1990; Long er al., 1990) has examined the intriguing consequences of projected climatic changes, due to the accumulation of so-called greenhouse gases, on the primary productivity of S. anglica and P. rnaritirna using a simple analytical model. The model, which predicts primary production from light interception and conversion efficiencies, suggests that production in both species will increase, but for different reasons. The C 3 species may be expected to increase primary production principally by increased conversion efficiency in a high C 0 2 environment through reduced photorespiratory losses. However, of greatest significance in the C4 species is the effect of elevated temperatures which would enable it to increase early spring growth (reaching the point where leaf area index is sufficient to intercept 30% of the incoming radiation 50 days earlier with a 3 "C temperature increase), and thus the size and photosynthetic capacity of the canopy. This gives a predicted increase in annual production from 1.3 kgm-2 in 1978 to 2.1 kgm-' in 2050 (Long, 1990). Although produced relatively late and over a short period, the high and uniformly dense biomass presented by S. anglica swards has attracted various forms of exploitation. These include cropping for silage (Hubbard and Ranwell, 1966), paper-making (Chung, 1990), and, more recently, as a potential biofuel crop (Scott et al., 1990). Although Bryce (1941) reported no diminution in yield during 3 successive years' cropping of an English south coast marsh. Scott er al. (1990), again
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLIC‘A
35
working on the Ribble marshes, demonstrated a decline in yield from 16 dry tonnes ha-’ year-’ to 8 tonnes ha-’ year-’ after 3 years in autumnand winter-harvested plots. Harvesting plots early in the season resulted in their colonization by P. maririrvia, whilst cuts in January maintained S. anglica cover (by increased stem density). The production of a P. maritima-dominated salt marsh by repeated summer and early autumn croppings on the Ribble parallels the effects of grazing, there and on other marshes. Puccinellia maritima replaces S . anglica at a greater rate in marshes grazed by sheep, the rate depending on local site conditions (Ranwell, 1961, 1964b, 1967).
C. The Niche of Spartina anglica The establishment of S . anglica swards on mudflats throughout northern Europe has led to the view that the species is phytosociologically in some way out of equilibrium with or is a “disharmonic element” (Beeftink, 1975, p. 431) in its environment, both by blocking the “natural” succession to other communities and exhibiting extensive die-back in the longer established sites (Beeftink, 1975, 1977). As indicated above, however, examples of succession from S . anglica swards are fairly widespread and are increasingly being reported from studies of permanent plots (Hill, 1987). The replacement of S . anglica by P. maririma was reported from the French coast as early as 1926 (Oliver, 1926). Ranwell’s (1964b) studies at Bridgwater Bay charted the invasion of swards by (usually taller) species such as Scirpus maritimus, Phragmites australis and Elymus pycnanthus (= Agropyron pungens). Under brackish conditions, S. anglica may be succeeded by Juncus maritimus and F. rubra (Packham and Liddle, 1970), and even in the south coast sites where it is dying back in the lower zones, the upper limit of the species may be invaded by P. maritima and Halimione portulacoides (Gray and Pearson, 1984). Whether it is in the active sward-building phase or is dying back, S. anglica is now found throughout most of its range as a belt of vegetation immediately seaward of the other salt marsh communities. Although individual clumps may be found at higher elevations, particularly in low-lying areas such as creek edges or pans, and may even occur around pools within reclaimed land, the upper limit of the sward is commonly marked by a gradual but often clear transition to other perennial vegetation (Fig. 9). The boundary between S. anglica swards and the landward vegetation tends to be more obvious in areas of high tidal range and on more steeply sloping marshes (see, e.g., Plate 1 in Armstrong et al., 1985). The upper limit of S . anglica is likely to be determined by its competitive interaction with the species to landward
36
A. J . GRAY E T A L .
Fig. 9. Diagrammatic representation of the zone typically occupied by S. anglica in British salt marshes.
(listed above) under conditions which increasingly favour the competitor over S. anglica as mudflat levels rise due to sediment accretion. The factors related, to increasing tidal submergence which appear to determine the lower limit of individual salt marsh species will affect both the outcome of competition between S. anglica and the species above it, and also the lower limit of S . anglica itself (Gray, 1985a). In some areas, as demonstrated in a classic study of Salicornia species by Wiehe (1935), and by Groenendijk (1986) for S. anglica, the physical effects of tidal submergence are important in limiting the plant’s seaward spread. The effects of frequency and periodicity of tidal submergence are also likely to be important. For example, Armstrong et al. (1985) showed that, in the S. anglica zone of an English east coast marsh, reducing conditions persisted throughout much of the soil profile and were indifferent to periods of exposure, there being phases of oxidation only near the surface and at neap tide periods. By contrast in the zones above S. anglica soil redox potentials were either lowered monthly during the high spring tides or there were longer periods of oxidation. Such tide-related limiting factors were presumably important in restricting the seaward advance of pioneer species such as P. maritima, Aster tripolium and Salicornia species before the advent of S. anglica. The ability of S. anglica to colonize the zone below these species (and in
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
37
some cases to invade upwards into the Puccinellia zone) stems from the suite of evolved physiological and physical attributes of the genus conferring salinity- and flooding-tolerance. These include not only the utilization of the C4 photosynthetic pathway but also the ability to oxidize phytotoxins such as Fe(I1) compounds and sulphides (Carlson and Forrest, 1982; van Diggelen, et al., 1986) and the vigour and tolerance of sediment accretion, greater in the allopolyploid than its native progenitor. Together these attributes have enabled S. angficu to invade a zone which was formerly unoccupied, at least by perennial vegetation, and could be regarded as a vacant niche (i.e. unexploited space and resources, usually only recognized when it has been occupied-Gray, 1986). A recent attempt to quantify the niche of S. anglica in terms of physical and tide-related variables is described by Gray et al. (unpublished). Their data set comprised measurements of the upper and lower limit of S. anglica along 107 levelled line transects across salt marshes in 19 estuaries in south and west Britain from Poole Harbour to Morecambe Bay. A close relationship was observed between both the upper and lower limits and the tidal range of the estuary (Fig. 10). Indeed, simple linear regressions of distribution limits against spring tidal range indicated that 88% and 86% of the variation in upper and lower limits, respectively, could be accounted for by variation in tidal range alone. Other variables which significantly improved the ability of multiple regression equations to account for the variation in distribution limits were “fetch in the direction of the transect” (a measure of exposure), “estuary area”, “estuarineness” (the position of the transect along the gradient from estuary mouth to upstream tidal limit), and, in the case of upper limits, “latitude”. The lower limit (LL) of S. anglica (in metres OD Newlyn) was best described by the equation
LL = -0.805 + 0.366 (SR) (0.102) (0.019) ( R 2 = 93.7, S = 0.35)”
+
0.053 (F) + 0.135 (log,A) (0.016) (0.025)
where SR = spring tidal range (m), F = fetch in the direction of the transect (km) and A = estuary area (km’). Spartinu therefore extended further down the shore than would be predicted from tidal range effects alone on those transects with a shorter seaward fetch and in smaller estuaries. * In the equations above, the standard errors of the regression coefficients are given in brackets below each coefficient -the significance of the particular variable can be tested using Student’s I computed as I = b / S E ( b ) which is distributed as I with N - I - p degrees of freedom, where N = the number of transects and p = the number of regressor variables in the equation. S = Residual standard deviation in metres.
38
A . J . G R A Y ET A L .
The upper limit (UL) of Sparrinn was described by:
U L = 4.74 + 0.483 ( S R ) + 0.068 ( F ) - 0.099 ( L ) (2.29) (0.028) (0.020) (0.045) (R' = 90.2, S = 0.50) where SR =range and F = fetch, as in the equation above, and L = latitude (in degrees N expressed as a decimal). The upper limit was similarly affected by fetch but also varied significantly with latitude: the further north the marsh, the lower down the shore relatively speaking was the upper limit of the Spartina sward. Both equations accounted for more than 90% of the variation in the upper or lower limits of the species, a remarkably high proportion for a biological model. The lower limit could also be predicted in relation to its deviation from the Mean High Water Neap tides (MHWN)-tidal range again accounting for most of the variation. In general, S. anglica was able to extend below MHWN in estuaries with a spring tidal range of less than 7 m (Fig. 10). The reasons advanced for the precision with which the vertical limits of S. anglica could be predicted were threefold (Gray et al., unpublished). First, tidal range provides a good general estimator of the complex of interacting factors which are likely to be determining the limits of the species distribution, encompassing variation in turbidity and in mechanical factors such as water depth and current speed. Second, such physical factors clearly control S. anglica limits, particularly the lower limits, to a degree unusual in natural vegetation. In the absence of biological competitors, the species has extended seawards to the point where tide-related variables limit its further spread (Hubbard, 1969; Morley, 1973; Groenendijk, 1986). Significantly, the upper limit, where S. anglica may interact with a number of different species, is likely to be fixed partly by competition, and thus by biological as well as physical factors. These factors are less easy to quantify. Interestingly, the downshore movement of the upper limit which occurs with increasing latitude may reflect overall changes in competitive ability of S. anglica under lower temperatures and a shorter growing season. Third, the relatively recent evolution of the species and its apparent genetic uniformity (Raybould et al., 1990b, and above) have precluded extensive population differentiation of the type which enables species such as P . rnaritima and Aster tripolium to increase their amplitude in salt marsh habitats (Gray et al., 1979; Gray and Scott, 1980; Gray, 1985a, 1987). It is probable that the realised niche (sensu Hutchinson (1957)) of S. anglica is changing more rapidly than in these, and other older, species. The die-back of swards in the lower zones of marshes in the south of
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
76-
- 50
0
-z 4E
!
Vertical range of Spurtinu
I
, Extreme lower limit of Spurlina '(a few isolated plants present)
tt
Mean high water springs (MHWS) A
Mean high water neaps (MHWN )
P
I
0
I
3-
I
2-
1-
+I I
1
I
2
4
6
I
8
I
I
10
12
Spring tidal range ( m )
Fig. 10. Vertical range of S. anglica marsh and spring tidal range for 32 sites from 20 estuaries. (From left to right: Poole Harbour (two lines. the first from Ranwell er al., 1964), Foryd Bay. Teign, Dovey. Mawddach. Traeth Bach. Tamar, Tavy, Milford Haven (two), Tywi, Taf, Red Wharf Bay, Conwy, Lavan Sands, Loughor, Dee, Ribble, Mersey, Shepperdine, Morecambe Bay, Severn (ten sites)).
England and elsewhere, and the changes resulting from competitive interactions at the upper limit throughout its range, are part of this highly dynamic process as the niche of the species evolves.
D. Interactions with Other Species 1. Competition with Puccinellia maritima As described above, the invasion of established S. anglica swards by other vascular plants has been observed throughout the species' range. The major perennial occupant of the lowest salt marsh zones in western Europe prior to the arrival of S. anglica was P. maritima (Adam, 1981; Dijkema, 1984). In some areas S. anglica has invaded former P. maritima-dominated vegetation, and is perceived as a threat to salt marsh pasture (Ranwell, 1972), whilst in others P. maritima invades and
40
A . 1. G R A Y E T A L .
replaces S. anglica. The tendency for P. maritima to replace S. anglica in more northern marshes in Britain is also seen in the Netherlands, where there is a marked contrast between the Waddensea marshes in the north and those of the Delta area in the south west (Beeftink, 1977; Dijkema, 1984; Scholten and Rozema, 1990). The north/south variation in both Britain and the Netherlands is unfortunately largely confounded with variation in soil type and grazing pressure. The northern marshes are generally sandier and more heavily grazed. Recently, Scholten and Rozema (1990, and Scholten et al., 1987) have examined competition between S. anglica and P. rnaritima in the field and laboratory. Removal experiments in the area of the species’ overlap on a Waddensea salt marsh indicated that S. anglica growth is suppressed by P. maritima at the higher levels (showing a significantly higher biomass production when P. maritima was removed), and vice versa lower down. The interacting effects of soil type (sand vs clay), salinity (saline, 400mM NaCl vs brackish, 200mM NaCI), and soil moisture (dry vs waterlogged) were analysed in a competition experiment using a replacement series design (de Wit, 1960) and the effects of nutrients and grazing were investigated by adding KN03 and KH2P04 and by clipping. The overall results indicated that P. maritima was a better competitor under most conditions, gaining an advantage by early growth that pre-empts space and shades emergent S. anglica shoots. The advantage of P. maritima increased progressively with time, especially on sand. Spartina anglica grew better on clay than on sand, and growth on clay was better under dry conditions, whereas on sand it was better under waterlogged conditions. Saline conditions reduced growth in both species more or less equally, added nutrients had little effect on either monocultures or mixtures, and clipping almost completely suppressed the growth of young S. anglica shoots, whereas P. maritima was less affected, especially on brackish dry sand (Scholten and Rozema, 1990). These experiments accord well with field distributions and help to explain how P. maritima is able to invade an S. anglica sward, particularly under lower spring temperatures and on sandier soils. S. anglica also facilitates the establishment of P. maritima (and other species) by the protection it provides against uprooting by tidal currents, the increased surface elevation by accretion of silt around the shoots, structural improvement of the upper layers of sediment by litter accumulation, and by radial oxygen loss from the rhizomes (Rozema et al., 1985; Scholten and Rozema, 1990).
2. The Ergot Fungus Claviceps purpurea In recent years, and especially during the past decade, many populations of S. anglica become heavily infected with Claviceps purpurea (Fr.)
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION
41
IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
Tul., a pyrenomycete fungus which causes ergot disease. The fungus is most visible during the sclerotial phase when the sclerotia, or ergots, may be seen protruding from the inflorescence (Fig. 11). Overwintering on or below the mud surface, the ergots germinate in late spring and, via a primary infection by the sexual ascospores, the fungus can spread rapidly through the summer by means of asexual conidia extruded from infected florets in a sticky honeydew. Claviceps displays a certain amount of host specificity (Mantle, 1980), and Loveless (1971) suggested that the strain parasitizing S . anglica probably differs sufficiently to be regarded as a distinct taxon. Spartina anglica ergots have exceptionally high alkaloid content (0.91%), consisting of the lysergic acid derivatives ergotamine and ergotoxine (Mantle, 1969). Although reported on S. alterniflora in the USA as long ago as 1895 (Eleuterius, 1970), C . purpurea does not appear to have been recorded in Europe before 1960, where it occurred at a low level on S. x townsendii near Dublin (Boyle, 1976b). Several records of light infections in the early 1960s are recorded before the first heavy infections, in Poole Harbour in 1971 and in Ireland in 1975 and 1976 (Boyle, 1976b;
k
Germinating sclerotium (May/June)
9-10 months Overwintering
II
P.
3 A
__I__
9 - 0 WBBKS
and pre-chilling
(June/July)
L
Sexual oscospores
Differentiation
Primary infection bv
jf
7-10 days
4
(July - November 7)
Sphacelial stage extrusion of honeydew containingasexual conidia
Fig. 11. Life cycle of C. purpurea on S . anglica (reproduced with permission from Gray et al., 1990b).
42
A . .I. G R A Y E T A L .
Gray et al., 1990b). By the 1980s, heavy infection was apparent in several areas including Poole Harbour, the Dee and the Ribble estuaries. In 20 “populations” (each comprising a 0.5 ha area of S. anglica sward) in Poole Harbour, infection rose from a mean of 36.4% of all inflorescences containing at least one ergot (or honeydew) in 1983 to a mean of 85.2% in 1988 (Gray et al., 1990b). More than 90% of all flowering heads were infected in several populations. In the Ribble estuary, infection rose from less than 1% of infected inflorescences in 1981 to as high as 52% in the main sward in 1986, and similar increases were recorded in the Dee between 1986 and 1988 (Thompson in Gray et al., 1990b). These exceptionally high, even epidemic, levels of disease are relatively rare in natural plant communities (Burdon, 1987; Clarke e[ a l . , 1987) and prompt at least two important questions: what are the effects of the pathogenon the host? and why are infection levels so high? The first question is difficult to resolve. Although there is a clear effect on fecundity, in that every ergotized floret reduces potential seed production by one, the extremely low levels of seed-set in most populations and the possible effects on seed production in uninfected florets make measurement of the actual effect on fecundity extremely difficult. An estimate for Poole Harbour populations in 1985 indicated that potential seed production was reduced by 16% on average, but by as much as 47% in some populations, and there were eight ergots for every filled spikelet (Gray et a l . . 1990b). In addition, there is limited evidence that the demand of the fungus on the host’s resources may lead to host damage-a significant negative relationship between mean ergot weight and number of ergots per inflorescence suggesting that developing sclerotia compete for limited nutrients. The extent of the effect is impossible to measure in field populations because it is not possible to recognize individual plants (ramets). The uncharacteristically heavy infection in S . anglica is most obviously related to the fact that the species tends to occur as dense, monospecific swards, and thus resembles an agricultural crop in its vulnerability to epidemics (Burdon and Chilvers, 1982). Furthermore, the apparent genetic uniformity of S. anglica, its proliferation mainly by clonal expansion, and its extended period of flowering from July to November make it especially vulnerable to pathogen attack. Speculation as the the future development of the disease must take account of the species’ current inability to evolve resistance, of the possible effects of unusual weather conditions which might break the cycle of infection, and of the recently discovered presence of a hyperparasite, the fungus Fusarium hererosporurn, which is a potential agent of biological control of Claviceps (Gray et a l . , 1990b).
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N C L I C A
43
3. Invertebrates The fauna of S. anglica marshes has received very little attention, in contrast to that of the S. alterniflora-dominated marshes of North America (e.g. Teal, 1962; Daiber, 1982). Payne (1973) noted only four insect species commonly occurring in S. anglica swards in Poole Harbour. These were a leafhopper, Euscelis obsolerus, a herbivorous grasshopper, Chorrhippus albomarginatus, an omnivorous grasshopper, Conocephalus dorsalis, and a predatory damsel bug, Dolichonabis linearus. The first three appeared to be feeding on S. anglica, although C. dorsalis fed also on E. obsolerus, as did D. lineatus. This rather skeletal insect food-chain mirrors, but is less rich than, S. alterniflora marshes. Other insects found in Poole Harbour S. anglica marshes included three species of shorebug (Saldidae) and several spider species, including Argiope bruennichi. Jackson and his colleagues (Jackson, 1984; Jackson et al., 1985, 1986) also found relatively few species of macroinvertebrates in the S. anglica canopy of a marsh at Seafield Bay in East Anglia-13 taxa in all, and only six occurring regularly. Of these, only one, the sap-feeding spittlebug Philaenus spumarius, was a significant consumer of live S. anglica material, and the consumption of this species was a very small fraction of the plant's annual production. The total annual assimilation by all canopy invertebrates amounted to less than 0.3% of the total annual above-ground net primary production, with P. spumarius assimilating 0.4g of a canopy-species total of OSgcm-*year-'). As in North American marshes, the assimilation of Sparrina material was dominated by sediment-associated detritivores (assimilating more than 40 gcm-' year-'), of which the dominant species was the polychaete worm Nereis diversicolor, accounting for more than 85% of all S. anglica material assimilated. Although dominated quantitatively by N . diversicolor, the invertebrate fauna associated with the sediments in this marsh was surprisingly rich in species, at least in the lower zones, with a total of 15 species of which 12 occurred regularly. Although this is a similar level of diversity to S. alterniflora marshes, Jackson et al. (1985) suggest that the inequitable density distributions, in which one species dominated, reflects the recent origin of S. anglica marshes. Observations elsewhere (Millard and Evans, 1984; S. McGrorty, pers. comm.) indicate that the benthic fauna of advancing or stable S. anglica marshes is generally depleted in relation to the nearby tidal flats, and that although epibenthic species may be present in S. anglica swards, the Seafield Bay site may not be characteristic. Interestingly, because it is the only C, species present, Jackson's study of the fate of S. anglica in the food chain was able to exploit the
44
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
differences in carbon isotope utilization between C3 and C4 species and the tendency for animals to reflect the I3C/l2C ratio of their food sources (Teeri and Schoeller, 1979). His finding that few of the canopy species utilize S. anglica as a major food source may reflect the relative indigestibility of C4 species as a whole (Caswell and Reed, 1976) or the relatively recent origin of the species. Of the annual net primary production of S. anglica at Seafield Bay, between 14% and 20% was assimilated by invertebrates (> 85% of that by N . diversicolor), mostly as detritus in situ, about 30% was dissipated by micro-organisms and meiofauna, and of the rest around 15-22% is exported away from the site as detritus or live material and is available for incorporation into estuarine food-chains (Jackson, 1984).
4. Spartina anglica and the Decline of the Dunlin. Calidris alpina Whatever its richness and density, the invertebrate fauna of S. anglica swards is much less available as food to wading birds (Charadrii) than that of the nearby tidal flats. Indeed, the major threat which S. anglica is perceived to pose in European estuaries is its invasion of bird feeding-grounds-either the eelgrass (Zostera spp.) and algal (Enteromorpha spp.) beds utilized by herbivorous wildfowl such as the Brent goose, Branta bernicla, and widgeon, Anus penelope, or the invertebrate-rich mudflats used by waders (Doody, 1990; Nairn, 1986; Ranwell and Downing, 1959). Despite this perception, documented evidence of an effect on birds is rare, and the overwintering populations of most species of waders have remained constant or have increased in size since nationwide counts began in the early-1970s (Goss-Custard and Moser, 1988). A notable exception is the dunlin, Calidris alpina, the overwintering numbers of which had declined up to 1988 by almost a half since 1973/74 (Salmon and Moser, 1985). The dunlin was among the species which fed particularly at the tide edge and on the higher parts of the flats in the Dyfi estuary and whose numbers declined during the period of S . anglica expansion there in the early and mid-1970s (Davis and Moss, 1984). (The other species were oystercatcher, Haematopus ostralegus, ringed plover, Charadrius hiaticula, and sanderling, Calidris alba .) Millard and Evans (1984) also noted that dunlin, and other flock-feeding species, prefer to feed on open mud and, unlike redshank, Tringa totanus, were rarely found among S . anglica clumps or in the sward at Lindisfarne in northern England. Goss-Custard and Moser (1988, 1990) compared the different rates of decline of dunlin numbers in different British estuaries to the changes in abundance of S. anglica in those estuaries during the period 1971/72 to 1985/86. Numbers had declined at the greatest rate in
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN S P A R T I N A A N G L I C A
45
estuaries where S. anglica had expanded most during that period and, with some exception, had hardly changed in those where S. anglica populations were static. It is suggested that S. anglica both removes feeding areas and reduces feeding time, both of which would increase rates of emigration and mortality. However, as the authors point out, the decline of dunlin and the spread of S. anglica may have occurred independently, or may be linked by a third factor such as sedimentary or nutritional changes in the estuaries. The removal of S. anglica using herbicides has resulted in the return of waders, including dunlin, to formerly vegetated areas at Lindisfarne (Corkhill, 1984; Evans, 1986), but areas from which the grass had died back along the English south coast are not being exploited. This may be because these sediments are unsuitable for invertebrates to colonize or are covered with mats of algae (Tubbs, 1977).
E. Die-back, Control and Conservation Although S. anglica spread rapidly in the early decades of this century and continues to spread in western and northern estuaries, the degeneration of swards along the south coast of England was noted as early as the mid-1920s. Patchy degeneration was reported from the Beaulieu estuary in 1928 and by the mid-1950s about 60 ha of S. anglica marsh had been lost in the Hampshire Basin (Manners, 1975). Die-back began in Poole Harbour in the mid-l920s, where S. anglica was first recorded in 1890, had spread to cover more than 775 ha by 1924. but had declined to around 415 ha by 1980 (Gray and Pearson, 1984). Other detailed studies of decline have been made from Langstone Harbour (Haynes and Coulson, 1982) and from Milford Haven in South Wales (Dalby, 1970; Baker, 1976; Baker et a f . , 1990). Decline in area of S. anglica swards has been recorded from many English south and east coast estuaries and from some in south west Britain, from northern France and from the south west Netherlands. Investigations into die-back, mainly carried out at Southampton University between 1953 and 1965, did not conclusively provide a proximal causative agent but clearly characterized the conditions under which die-back occurs (Goodman, 1960; Goodman and Williams, 1961; Goodman et a f . , 1959; Sivaneson and Manners, 1972). These include badly drained, usually waterlogged, highly anaerobic soils with a high proportion of fine particles and a high sulphide content. The high organic levels which result from initial S. anglica decay may increase the rate of die-back by increasing the water-retaining ability of the muds. Both toxic levels of sulphide (Goodman and Williams, 1961) and anoxia
46
A . J . GRAY ET A L .
in the rhizomes (Barker, 1963) have been directly implicated in the death of plants in die-back areas. Whatever the immediate cause of die-back, its interest from a broader perspective comes from the series of physiographical and physical changes which follow the invasion of S. anglica, particularly the creation by rapid sediment accretion of a series of badly drained marshes, often with a concave profile. Replacing more gradually sloping mudflats, these marshes remove from circulation extremely large volumes of sediment. Depths of up to 1.8 m of accreted sediment have been recorded below S . anglica marshes in Poole Harbour (Hubbard and Stebbings, 1968). Thus, when die-back begins, the sediments (and presumably nutrients) released are likely to have a major impact on the intertidal area to seaward. This is illustrated by the changes in the bed levels of major navigating channels within Poole Harbour between 1849 and 1980, during which period S . anglica invaded and subsequently died back (Fig. 12). Die-back can therefore be viewed as a ‘natural’ process in which a newly evolved species has dramatically altered the sedimentary and
-800
c m
-600
v
-
.-
L
m
P
-
II]
0
-400
m U
-200
-0
Fig. 12. The percentage change in bed levels of four major channels in Poole
Harbour. Dorset, between the Admiralty Surveys of 1849 and those of 1934, 1954 and 1980. (-m- Wytch Lake, -0- Middlebere Lake, -0- Wareham Channel, -0- South Deep). Also shown is the change in area of S. anglica marsh (. . . A . . .). Modified from Gray et a/., 1990a.
A CENTURY
O F EVOLUTION IN S P A R T I N A A N G L I C A
47
drainage characteristics of the marshes, and created the anaerobic, waterlogged conditions which led to its own destruction. Whether this process will occur on the generally sandier marshes in the west and north, and whether it will be a cyclic process in the south, S. anglica reinvading newly accreted mudflats, are extremely interesting questions (the lack of reinvasion thus far may be because mudflat levels are too low or unstable). The answers to them will determine the eventual niche which the species occupies. Whilst extensive die-back occurs in the south (and several local agencies responsible for sea defence contemplate replanting S. anglica to protect sea walls), elsewhere the continued spread of the plant has prompted attempts to control it. Of ten control programmes reviewed by Way (1987), four were to prevent encroachment onto amenitybeaches, three were to prevent colonization of bird-feeding areas, two were to preserve the floristic diversity of adjacent salt marsh, and one was to clear a harbour prior to the creation of an amenity beach. Most programmes involved a combination of physical removal (by digging or bulldozing tussocks and clumps) and herbicide spraying, either with a backpack, a tractor-mounted boom, or aerial spraying. The most commonly used herbicide has been glyphosate (Roundup@), and the most frequently recommended has been Dalapon@,a sodium salt of dichloropropionic acid. Way (1987) suggests there is a need to conduct trials using low dosages of more modern herbicides. Only partial success in controlling the plant is reported from most areas, and eradication once it has become established is extremely difficult and costly. However, providing a long-term commitment is made, S. anglica can usually be contained by repeated spraying. Significantly, half of the reasons given above for controlling S. anglica relate to aspects of nature conservation. In deciding whether the species was harmful or not to nature conservation interests. Doody (1990) lists its beneficial effects as: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
preventing coastal erosion and stabilizing mudflats; aiding reclamation for agriculture: its high productivity in the estuarine ecosystem; the creation, via succession, of grazing marsh; and its value for research.
Against this, he balances the harmful effects of 1 . invading intertidal flats rich in invertebrates and utilized by overwintering waders and wildfowl; 2. replacing more diverse plant communities; 3. producing dense, monspecific swards which alter succession and
48
A. J. GRAY E T A L .
are replaced in ungrazed areas by equally species-poor communities: and 4. promoting agricultural reclamation, and thus the destruction of species-rich, high-level salt marsh. On balance, Doody concludes that S . anglica must be regarded as a threat in estuaries of high wildlife interest, both to bird populations and to ‘natural’ salt marsh succession.
VII. THE FUTURE OF SPARTZNA ANGLZCA Human intervention has played a key role in the initial speciation process which created S. anglica and in the subsequent success of the species through extensive planting. It is also clear that the intervention of man, both direct and indirect, is likely to have a major effect on the immediate future of S . anglica and on its long-term evolutionary survival. Human intervention apart, it is likely that the two main factors that will determine the long-term success of the species are its occupation of a vacant niche which exists on the seaward edge of salt marshes and its high levels of phenotypic plasticity (Thompson, 1989). It appears likely that the species will continue to expand its total area in Britain and northern Europe to occupy much of the potential salt marsh habitat that is available to it, subject only to the continued loss of salt marsh resulting from estuarine development or rising sea levels. On the basis of current evidence, attempts to limit this spread on a large scale, or even to totally eradicate S. anglica by extensive treatment with herbicides, are futile. Once the species is established there appears to be little that can be done to eradicate it totally from an estuary, and the development of a management plan for salt marsh habitats and estuaries which takes account of its presence would appear to be the only economically sensible strategy. The full extent of the possible range that is available for colonization by S. anglica remains to be determined. The success of introductions in northern Europe and as far afield as Australia (Ranwell, 1967) and China (Chung, 1990) suggests that the species has the potential to occupy and dominate the equivalent niche on mudflats in estuarine environments throughout the cool temperate regions of the world, subject only to competition from other Spartina species and climatic limitations. Though the physiological evidence strongly suggests that there will be a climatically defined limit to its northern expansion through the influence of cool spring temperatures which limit early season growth (Long, 1983), there is as yet no clear information available with which to predict the extent of its southern
A CENTURY
O F EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
49
expansion into warmer climates, although Ranwell (1967) does suggest that winter temperatures may be important. The rate at which future expansion of S. anglica may take place is difficult to predict, Whilst direct human intervention has been the major factor in its long-distance dispersal within the short timescale over which it has existed, there is clear evidence that, once established, the species is able to spread efficiently and occupy an individual estuary (although there may be a significant lag phase from its original colonization to its full occupation of all the available sites). Because of the widespread planting of the species throughout the British Isles. it is not yet apparent how efficient it is at independent dispersal between estuaries through seed or clonal fragments unless the estuaries are adjacent or are linked by intermediate areas of salt marsh. However, it did spread successfully, apparently unaided, more than 150 km eastwards along the coast and more than 100 km across the English Channel from its point of origin in the early part of the century. The efficiency of such “independent dispersal” will be important in determining the rate at which the species can expand to colonize available habitats and will be a major factor in the future spread of the species from introduced sites throughout the world. In the longer term it appears likely that the process of global warming may have a major effect on the future of S. anglica. There are two main consequences of global warming which may have a direct impact. The predicted rise in sea levels will result in the destruction of some coastal habitats through inundation, and although new ones will replace them, a long time may pass before new stable habitats become established (Rowntree, 1990). The second likely consequence of global warming is that S. anglica (in common with many other species, e.g. see Grime (1990)) may alter its geographical range and become of increasing importance in north European estuaries as temperatures increase and allow improved early season growth at northern latitudes. The likely timescale of such predicted changes in global temperature and erosion of salt marsh in the face of rising sea level will be important in determining how well S. anglica is able to repeatedly recolonize available habitats in the face of such dynamic changes to the environment. The success of S. anglica so far is due in part to its great flexibility, its highly plastic phenotype enabling it to tolerate a wide range of substrates and conditions, including high accretion rates. It is at least tempting to speculate that this flexibility may in part be due to the high levels of fixed heterozygosity which exist in such a high polyploid of hybrid origin. Although such flexibility may account for its short-term success, the evolutionary success of the species on a much longer timescale will
50
A . J . G R A Y ET A L .
depend greatly on its ability to generate genetic variation. Such variations will be required to enable it to evolve adaptively in response to evolutionary pressures from pests and pathogens. Since all the current evidence suggests that the existing levels of variation are extremely low as a direct consequence of the genetic bottleneck that occurred during the speciation process (Raybould et al., 1990b), S. anglica is faced with a major evolutionary problem. The conventional processes, such as mutation, which create suitable adaptive variation for a species, occur over a relatively long timescale, though in S. anglica there is some potential for the generation of variation by either the breakdown of preferential pairing or by backcrossing with one or other parental species (see above). S. anglica is nevertheless faced with the evolutionary risk of surviving through a period of severely reduced genetic resources. The current dominance of S. anglica swards by what appears to be a single genotype may be an inherently unstable situation since, like many agricultural crops, it will be vulnerable to epidemics (Burdon and Chilvers 1982). Indeed, it might be argued that the current vigour and dominance of S. anglica in salt marsh habitats may in part be the result of the relative absence of a natural complement of adapted herbivore, pest and disease organisms, as has been suggested, for example, to explain the vigour of Eucalyptus species in alien habitats (Pryor, 1976). This temporary escape from enemies may mean that not only the S. anglica swards themselves but also the entire salt marsh communities which they protect from erosion, may in the long-term be vulnerable to the evolution and spread of Sparrina pests or pathogens. The potential danger of such epidemics is well illustrated by the recent dramatic spread of ergot fungus through many UK S. anglica swards since the early 1960s (see Section VI above). Apart from its immediate effect, this pathogen may have a direct bearing on the evolutionary future of the species by severely limiting seed-set. The resulting reduction in sexual reproduction, though of comparatively minor significance in the shortterm survival of aspecies such as S. anglica, which efficiently reproduces itself asexually, may drastically limit the rate at which the species can evolve to combat successfully this and any future pest and disease epidemics. The future of S. anglica will therefore not only provide us with a unique opportunity to study many important ecological processes as the species and its niche develop together, but also will provide us with an important evolutionary laboratory to investigate the initial processes in the success or failure of a new species. The key elements in the second century of this ecological and evolutionary drama are likely to be the role of human intervention, both direct and indirect, and the ability of
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN S P A R T I N A ANGLICA
51
the species to respond to evolutionary pressures in the face of its current severely limited genetic variability.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are especially pleased to acknowledge the help we have received from other ‘Sparrina scientists’ including Paulina Benham, Ralph Clarke, Mick Drury, Maggie Hill, Mike Lawrence, Steve Long, Tom McNeilly, Karen Myers, Judith Pearson, the late Derek Ranwell, John Thompson and Liz Warman. We are grateful to Mary Perkins for her hard work in producing the manuscript. The support of the Natural Environment Research Council (grant to A. F. Raybould), the Energy Technology Support Unit of the Department of Energy (funds for work on Spartina niche), and BP Petroleum Development Ltd (student grants) is also much appreciated. Alastair Fitter and an anonymous referee made helpful comments on the text.
REFERENCES Abbott, R. J. and Ashton, P. S. (1989). Evolution of the Welsh ragwort (Senecio cumbrensis). Am. J. Bot. 76 (Supp.), 73. Adam, P. (1981). The vegetation of British salt marshes, New Phytol. 88, 143- 196. Allan, H. H. (1930), Spartina townsendii, A valuable grass for reclamation of tidal mud-flats. N. Z . J . Agric. 40, 189-196. Arber, A. (1934). The Gramineae. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Armstrong, K. C. (1971). Chromosome associations at pachytene and metaphase in Medicago sativa. Can. J. Genet. Cytol. 13, 697-702. Armstrong, W., Wright, E . J., Lythe, S. and Gaynard, T. J . (1985). Plant zonation and the effects of the spring-neap tidal cycle on soil aeration in a Humber salt marsh. J. Ecol. 73, 323-339. Ascher, P. D. and Peloquin, S. J . (1966). Influence of temperature on incompatible and compatible pollen tube growth in Lilium longiflorum. Can. J . Genet. Cytol. 8, 661-664. Aung, T. and Evans, G. M . (1987). Segregation of isozyme markers and meiotic pairing control genes in Lolium. Heredity 59, 129-134. Baker, J. M. (1976). Ecological changes in Milford Haven during its history as an oil port. In: Marine Ecology and Oil Pollution (Ed. by J. M. Baker), pp. 55-66. Applied Science Publishers, Barking. Baker, J. M . , Oldham, J. H . , Wilson, C. M., Dicks, B., Little, D. I. and Lovell, D. (1990). Spartinu anglica and oil: spill and effluent effects, clean-up and rehabilitation. In: Spartina anglica-A Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M . Benham), pp. 52-61. HMSO, London.
52
A . J . GRAY ET A L .
Barker, S. (1963). A study of competition between Juncus maritimits and Spartina townsendii agg., with special reference to the causes of rhizome apex failure. MSc Thesis. University of Southampton. Bascand, L. D. (1970). The roles of Spartina species in New Zealand. Proc. N . Z . ECOISOC. 17, 33-40. Beeftink, W. G. (1975). The ecological significance of embankment and drainage with respect to the vegetation of the south west Netherlands. J. Ecol. 63, 423-458. Beeftink, W. G. (1977). The coastal salt marshes of western and northern Europe; an ecological and phytosociological approach. In: Ecosystems of the World. I . Wet Coastal Ecosystems (Ed. by V. J. Chapman), pp. 109-155. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, Amsterdam. Bird, E. C. F. and Ranwell, D. S. (1964). Spartinu salt marshes in southern England. IV. The physiography of Poole-Harbour, Dorset. J. Ecol. 52, 355-366. Boyle, P. (1973). Corrected chromosome number for Spartina in Ireland. Nature 244, 311. Boyle, P. (1976a). Spartinu M9. A variant Spartina in three regions north of Dublin. Sci. Proc. R. Dublin SOC.A, 5, 415-427. Boyle, P. (1976b). Ergot epiphytotic on Spartina spp. in Ireland. Ir. J. Agric. Res. 15, 419-425. Boyle, P. and Kavanagh, J. A. (1961). A spartinetum at Baldoyle in Ireland. Nature 192, 81-82. Breese, E. L., Hayward, M. D. and Thomas, A. C. (1965). Somatic selection in perennial ryegrass. Heredity 20, 367-379. Britten, J. (1906). Frederick Townsend (1822-1905). J. Bot. 44, 113-115. Bromfield, W. A. (1836). A description of Spartina alterniflora at Loiseleur, a new British species. In: J. D. Hooker: Companion to Curtis’s Bot. Mag. 2, 254-263. Bryce, J. (1936). The economic possibilities of rice grass. Agric. Prog. 13, 72-76. Bryce, J. (1941). Rice grass as a fodder plant. J. Minist. Agric. Fish 48, 40-42. Burdon, J. J. (1987). Diseases and Plant Population Biology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 208 pp. Burdon, J. J. and Chilvers, A. A. (1982). Host density as a factor in plant disease ecology. Ann. Rev. Phytopathol. 20, 143-166. Caldwell, P. A . (1957). The spatial development of Spartina colonies growing without competition. Ann. Bot. N. S. 21, 203-214. Carlson, P. R. J. and Forrest, J. (1982). Uptake of dissolved sulphide by Spartina alterniflora: evidence from natural sulphur isotope abundance ratios. Science 216, 633-635. Caswell, H. and Reed, F. (1976). Plant herbivore interactions. The indigestibility of Cd bundle sheath cells by grasshoppers. Oecologia ( B e d . ) 26, 151-156. Charman, K. (1990). The current status of Spartina anglica in Great Britain. In: Spartina anglica - A Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E . M. Benham), pp. 11-14. HMSO, London. Chater, E. H. (1965). Ecological aspects of the dwarf brown form of Spartina in the Dovey Estuary. J. Ecol. 53, 789-797. Chater, E. H. and Jones, H. (1951). New forms of Spartina townsendii (Groves). Nature 168, 126. Chater, E. H. and Jones, H. (1957). Some observations on Spartina townsendii H. and J. Groves in the Dovey Estuary. J. Ecol. 45, 157-167.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN S P A R T I N A A N G L I C A
53
Chen, C.-C. and Gibson, P. B. (1973).Effect of pollen tube growth in Trifolium repens after cross- and self-pollinations. Crop Sci. 13 563-566. Chevalier, A. (1923).Note sur les Spartina de la flore francaise. Bull. SOC. Bot. Fr. 70,54-63. Chung, C . H. (1990).Twenty-five years of introduced Sparrina anglica in China. In: Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 72-76. HMSO, London. Clarke, D. D., Bevan, J. R. and Crute, I. R. (1987). Genetic interactions between wild plants and their parasites. In: Genetics and Plant Pathogenesis (Ed. by P. R. Day and G . J. Jellis), pp. 195-206. Blackwell, Oxford. Corkhill, P. (1984). Spartina at Lindisfarne NNR and details of recent attempts to control its spread. In: Spartina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by J. P. Doody), pp. 60-63. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Crawford, D. J. and Smith, E. B. (1984). Allozyme divergence and intraspecific a Syst. Bat. 9,219-225. variation in Coreopsis g r ~ n d i ~ o r(Compositae). Cummins, H. (1930). Experiments on establishment of ricegrass in the Lee. Econ. Proc. R . Dubl. SOC. 2,419-421. Daiber, F. C. (1982).Animals of the Tidal Marsh. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 422 pp. Dalby, D. H. (1970). The salt marshes of Milford Haven, Pembrokeshire. Field Stud. 3 , 297-330. Davis, P. and Moss. D. (1984).Spartina and waders - the Dyfi Estuary. In: Sparfina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by P. J. Doody), pp. 37-40. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5 . Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Dawson, C. D. R. (1941).Tetrasomic inheritance in Lotus corniculatus L. J . Genet. 42,49-72. Deadrnan, A. (1984). Recent history of Spartina in north-west England and in north Wales and its possible future development. In: Spartina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by J. P. Doody), pp. 22- 24. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. van Diggelen, J., Rozema, J., Dickson, D. M. J. and Broekman. R. (1986). Beta-3-Dimethylsulphoniopropionate, proline and quaternary ammonium compounds in Spartina anglica in relation to sodium chloride, nitrogen and sulphur. New Phytol. 103,573-586. Dijkema, K. S. (Ed.) (1984). Salt ~ a ~ s h in e sEurope. Nature and ~nvironment Series No. 30. Council of Europe, Strasbourg, 178 pp. Doll, H. and Brown, A. D. H. (1979). Hordein variation in wild (Hordeum s p o n t a n e i ~ ~and ) cultivated ( N . vulgare) barley. Can. J. Genet. Cytol. 21, 391-404. Doody, P. J. (1990).Spartina - friend or foe? A conservation viewpoint. In: Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A . J . Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 77-79. HMSO, London. s.1. in the Drok, W. J. A. (1979).Studies in the taxonomy of Spartina to~~n.~endii S.W. part of the Netherlands. Delta Institute for Hydrobiological Research Progress Report 1979. p.48. Drok, W. J. A. (1983). Is Spari~na anglica Hubbard we1 een goode soort? Corteria 11, 243-252. Dunn. R. (1981).The effects of temperature on the photosynthesis, growth and productivity of Sparrina fown.sendi~(sensu lato) in controlled and natural environments. PhD Thesis, University of Essex. Dunn, R., Long, S. P. and Thomas, S. M. (1981).The effect of temperature on
54
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
the growth and photosynthesis of the temperate C4 grass Spartina townsendii. In: Plants and Their Atmospheric Environment (Ed. by J. Grace, E. D. Ford and P. G. Jarvis), pp. 303-312. Blackwell, Oxford. Eleuterius, L. N. (1970). Observations on Claviceps purpurea on Spartina alterniflora. Gulf Res. Rep. 3, 105-109. Ellstrand, N. C. and Roose, M. L. (1987). Patterns of genotypic diversity in clonal plant species. A m . J. Bot. 74, 123-131. Evans, P. R. (1986). Use of the herbicide ‘Dalapon’ for control of Spartina encroaching on intertidal mudflats: beneficial effects on shore birds. Colon. Warbirds 9 171-175. Fearon, C. H. Hayward, M. D. and Lawrence, M. J. (1984a). Self-incompatibility in rye grass. VII. The determination of incompatibility genotypes i n autotetraploid families of Lolium perenne L. Heredity 53, 403-413. Fearon, C. H., Hayward, M. D. and Lawrence, M. J. (1984b). Self-incompatibility in rye grass. VIII. The mode of action of the S and Z alleles in the pollen of autotetraploids of Lolium perenne L. Heredity 53, 415-422. Fearon, C. H., Hayward, M. D. and Lawrence, M. J. (1984~).Self-incompatibility in rye grass. IX. Cross-compatibility and seed set in autotetraploid Lolium perenne L. Heredity 53, 423-434. Funk, C. R., Anderson, J. C., Johnson, M. W. and Atkinson, R. W. (1962). Effect of seed source and seed age on field and laboratory performance of field corn. Crop Sci. 2 , 318-320. Gallagher, J. L., Linthurst, R. A. and Pfeiffer, W. J. (1980). Aerial production, mortality and mineral accumulation dynamics in Spartina alterniflora and Juncus roemerianus in a Georgia salt marsh. Ecology 61, 303-312. Gepts, P. (1990). Genetic diversity of seed storage proteins in plants. In: Plant Population Genetics, Breeding and Genetic Resources (Ed. by A.H.D. Brown, M.T. Clegg. A.L. Kahler and B.S. Weir), pp. 64-82. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Ma. Gibbs, P. E., Marshall, D. and Brunton, D. (1978). Studies on the cytology of Oxalis tuberosa and Tropaeolum tuberosum. Notes R . Bot. C d n Edinb. 37, 215-219. Giles, B. (1984). A comparison between quantitative and biochemical variation in the wild barley Hordeum murinum. Evolution 38, 34-41. Gillespie, J. M. and Blagrove, R. J. (1975). Variability in the proportion and type of subunits in lupin storage globulins. Aust. J. Plant Physiol. 2 , 29-39. Goodman, P. J. (1960). Investigations into ‘die-back’ in Spartina townsendii agg. 11. The morphological structure of the Lymington sward. J. Ecol. 48, 711-724. Goodman, P. J. and Williams, W. T. (1961). Investigations into ‘die-back’ in Spartina townsendii agg. 111. Physiological correlates of ‘die-back’. J. Ecol. 49, 391-398. Goodman, P. J., Braybrooks, E. M. and Lambert, J. H. (1959). Investigations into ‘die-back’ in Spartina townsendii agg. I. The present status of Spartina townsendii in Britain. J . Ecol. 47, 651-677. Goodman, P. J., Braybrooks, E. M., Marchant, C. J. and Lambert, J. M. (1969). Spartina X townsendii H. and J. Groves sensu laro. Biological Flora of the British Isles. J . Ecol. 57, 298-313. Goss-Custard, J. D. and Moser, M. E. (1988). Rates of change in the numbers of dunlin Calidris alpina wintering in British estuaries in relation to the spread of Spartina anglica. J . Appl. Ecol. 25, 95-109. Goss-Custard, J. D. and Moser, M. E. (1990). Changes in the numbers of dunlin
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N G L I C A
55
(Calidris alpina) in British estuaries in relation to changes in the abundance of Spartina. In: Spartina anglica - A Research Review (Ed. by A . J. Gray and P. E . M. Benham), pp. 69-71. HMSO, London. Gottlieb, L. D. (1981). Electrophoretic evidence and plant populations. Prog. Phytochem. 7, 1-46. Gottlieb, L. D. (1982). Conservation and duplication of isozymes in plants. Science 216, 373-380. Gray, A. J. (1985a). Adaptation in perennial coastal plants - with particular reference to heritable variation in Puccinellia maritima and Ammophila arenaria. Vegetatio 61, 179-188. Gray, A. J. (1985b). Poole Harbour. Ecological Sensitivity Analysis of the Shoreline. Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Huntingdon. 36 pp. Gray, A. J. (1986). Do invading species have definable genetic characteristics? Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 314, 655-674. Gray, A. J. (1987). Genetic change during succession in plants. In: Colonization, Succession and Stability (Ed. by A. J. Gray, A. J. Crawley and P. J. Edwards). pp. 273-293. Blackwell, Oxford. Gray, A. J. and Pearson, R. J . (1984). Spartina marshes in Poole Harbour, Dorset, with particular reference to Holes Bay. In: Spartina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by P. J. Doody). pp. 11-14. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Gray, A. J. and Scott, R. (1977). Puccinellia maritima (Huds.) Parl. (Poa maritima Huds.; Glyceria maritima (Huds.) Wahlb.). Biological flora of the British Isles. J . Ecol. 65, 699-716. Gray, A. J. and Scott, R. (1980). A genecological study of Puccinellia maritima (Huds.) Parl. I . Variation estimated from single-plant samples from British populations. New Phytol. 85, 89-107. Gray, A. J., Parsell, R. J. and Scott, R. (1979). The genetic structure of plant populations in relation to the development of salt marshes. In: Ecological Processes in Coastal Environments (Ed. by R. L. Jeffries and A. J. Davy), pp. 43-64. Blackwell, Oxford. Gray, A. J., Benham, P. E. M. and Raybould, A. F. (1990a). Spartina anglica the evolutionary and ecological background. In: Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A . J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 5-10. HMSO, London. Gray, A. J., Drury, M. G. and Raybould, A. F. (1990b). Spartina and the ergot fungus Claviceps purpurea - a singular contest? In: Pests, Pathogens and Plant Communities (Ed. by J. J. Burdon and S. R. Leather), pp. 63-79. Blackwell, Oxford. Gray, A. J., Warman, E . A., Clarke, R. T. and Johnson, P. (1991). The niche of Spartina anglica in south and west Britain. (submitted manuscript). Grime, J. P. (1990). Ecological effects of climate change on plant population and vegetation composition with particular reference to the British flora. In: Climate Change and Plant Genetic Resources (Ed. by M. T. Jackson, B. T. Ford-Lloyd and M. L. Parry), pp. 44-60. Belhaven Press, London. Groenendijk, A. M. (1984). Primary production in four dominant angiosperms in the SW Netherlands. Vegetatio 57, 143-152. Groenendijk, A . M. (1986). Establishment of a Spartina anglica population on a tidal mudflat: a field experiment. J . Envir. Mgmt. 22, 1-12. Groves, H. and Groves, J. (1879). The Spartinas of Southampton Water. J. Bot. 17, 277. Groves, H. and Groves, J. (1880). Spartina townsendi nobis. Rep. Botl. SOC.
56
A . J . GRAY
E7
ill-.
Exch. Club. Br. Is/. 1, 37. Groves, H. and Groves, J. (1882). On Spartinu towwsendi Groves. J. Bot. 20, 1-2. Guenegou, M. C., Citharel, J . and Levasseur, J. E. (1988). The hybrid status of Spartina anglica (Poaceae), enzymic analysis of the species and of the presumed parents. Can. J. Bot. 66, 1830-1833. Hague, L. M. and Jones, R. N. (1987). Cytogenetics of Lolium perenne. IV. Colchicine induced variation in diploids. Theor. Appl. Genet. 74, 233-241. Hall, P. M. (1934). A note on the genus Spartina. Rep. Botl SOC. Exch. Club Br. Isl. 10, 889-892. Hamrick, J. L. and Godt, M. J. W . (1990). Allozyme diversity in plant species. In: Plant Population Genetics. Breeding and Genetic Resources (Ed. by A. H. D. Brown, M. T. Clegg, A. L. Kahler and B. S. Weir), pp. 43-63. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Ma. Hardaker, W. H. (1942). Spartina townsendii. Rep. Botl. SOC. Exch. Club Br. Is/. 12, 302. Haynes, F. N . and Coulson, M. G. (1982). The decline of Spartina in Langstone Harbour, Hampshire. Proc. Humps. Fld CI. Archueol. SOC.38, 5-18. Heslop-Harrison, J., Heslop-Harrison, Y . and Shivanna, K . R. (1984). The evaluation of pollen quality, and a further appraisal of the fluorochrornatic (FCR) test procedure. Theor. appl. Genet. 67, 367-375. Heywood, V. H. (1978). Notulae systematicae ad floram europaearn spectantes. Bot. J. Lint?. SOC. 76, 297-384. Hill, M. I . (1987). Vegetation change in communities of Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard in salt marshes in north-west England. Contract Survey No. 9. Nature Conservancy Council, Peterborough. Hill, M. I . (1990). Population differentiation in Spartina in the Dee estuary common garden and reciprocal transplant experiments. In: Spartina anglica a Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 15-19. HMSO, London. Holland, S. C. (1982). Sparfina of the Severn estuary. Watsonia 14, 70-71. Hubbard, C. E. (1957). In: report of the British Ecological Society Symposium on Spartinu. J . Ecol. 45, 612-616. Hubbard, C. E. (1968). Grasses 2nd edition. Penguin, London. 463 pp. Hubbard, J . C. E . (1965a). Spartina marshes in southern England. VI. Pattern of invasion in Poole Harbour. J. Ecol. 53, 799-813. Hubbard, J . C. E. (1965b). The earliest record of Spartina maritirna in Britain. Proc. Botl SOC. Br. Isl. 6, 119. Hubbard, J. C. E. (1969). Light in relation to tidal immersion and the growth of Spartina townsendii (s.1.) J. Ecol. 57, 795-804. Hubbard, J . C. E. (1970). Effects of cutting and seed production in Spartina anglica. J. E c o ~ 58, . 329-334. Hubbard, J . C. E. and Ranwell, D. S. (1966). Cropping Spartina marsh for silage. J. Br. Grassltid SOC.21, 214-217. Hubbard, J . C. E. and Stebbings, R. E. (1967). Distribution, dates of origin, and acreage of Spartina townsendii ( s . 1 . ) marshes in Great Britain. Proc. Botl. SOC. Br. Isl. 7, 1-7. Hubbard, J. C. E. and Stebbings, R. E. (1968). Spartina marshes in southern England. VII. Stratigraphy of the Keysworth Marsh, Poole Harbour. J . Ecol. 56, 707-722. Hubbard, J. C. E . . Grimes, B. H . and Marchant, C. J . (1978). Some observations on the ecology and taxonomy of Spartina x neyrautii and
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA A N G L I C A
57
Spartina alterniflora growing in France and Spain and comparison with Spartina x townsendii and Spartina anglica. Doc. Phytosociol. N . S . 2, 273-282. Huskins, C. L. (1930a). Origin of Spartina townsendii. Nature 127, 781. Huskins, C. L. (1930b). The origin of Spartina townsendii. Genetica 12, 531-538. Hussey, A. and Long, S. P. (1982). Seasonal change in weight of above and below-ground vegetation and dead plant material in a salt marsh at Colne Point, Essex. J . Ecol. 70, 757-772. Hutchinson, G. E. (1957). Concluding remarks. Cold Spring Harb. Symp. Quant. Biol. 22, 415-427. Jackson, D. (1984). Salt-marsh populations and the fate of organic matter produced by Spartina anglica. B. E. S . Bull. 15, 192-196. Jackson, D. Mason, C. F. and Long, S. P. (1985). Macro-invertebrate populations and production on a salt-marsh in east England dominated by Spartina anglica. Oecologia (Berl.) 65, 406- 411. Jackson, D., Harkness, D. D., Mason, C. F. and Long, S . P. (1986). Spartina anglica as a carbon source for salt-marsh invertebrates: a study using 13C values. Oikos 46, 163-170. Jones, P. (1980). Leaf mottling of Spartina species caused by a newly recognised virus, spartina mottle virus. Ann. Appl. Biol. 94, 77-81. Jones, M. B., Hannon, G. E . and Coffey, M. D. (1981). C4 photosynthesis in Cyperus longus L., a species occurring in temperate climates. PI. Cell Environ. 4, 161-168. Kamps, L. F. (1962). Mud distribution and land reclamation in the eastern Wadden shallows. Rijkswaterstaat Commun. 4, 1-73. Konig, D. (1948). Spartina townsendii an der Westkuste von Schleswig-Holstein. Planta 46, 34-70. Lambert, J. M. (1964). The Spartina story. Nature 204, 1136-1138. Lawrence, M. J. (1984). The genetic analysis of ecological traits. In: Evolutionary Ecology (Ed. by B. Shorrocks), pp. 27-64. Blackwell, Oxford. Lee, W. G. and Partridge, T. R. (1983). Rates of spread of Spartina anclica and sediment accretion in the New River estuary, Invercargill, New Zealand. N . Z . J . Bot. 21, 231-236. Long, S. P. (1983). C4 photosynthesis at low temperatures. PI. Cell Environ. 6 , 345 -363. Long, S . P. (1990). The primary productivity of Puccinellia maritima and Spartina anglica: a simple predictive model of response to climatic change. In: Expected Effects of Climatic Change on Marine Coastal Ecosystems (Ed. by J. J. Beukema, W. J. Wolff and J. J. W. M. Brouns). pp. 33-39. Kluwer, Dordrecht. Long, S. P. and Incoll, L. D. (1979). The prediction and measurement of photosynthetic rate of Spartina townsendii in the field. J . Appl. Ecol. 16, 879-891. Long, S . P. and Woolhouse, H. W. (1978). The responses of net photosynthesis to light and temperature in Spartina townsendii (senw lato), a C, species from a cool temperate climate. J . Exp. Bot. 29, 803-814. Long, S. P . , Incoll, L. D. and Woolhouse, H. W. (1975). C4 photosynthesis in plants from cool temperate regions with particular reference to Spartinn townsendii. Nature. 257, 622-624. Long, S. P., Dunn, R., Jackson, D., Othman, S. B. and Yaakub, M. H. (1990). The primary productivity of Spartina anglica on an East Anglian estuary. In:
58
A . J. G R A Y E T A L .
Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham). pp. 34-38. HMSO, London. Loveless, A. R. (1971). Conidial evidence for host restriction in Claviceps purpurea. Trans, Br. Mycol. Soc. 52, 381-392. Lovis, J. D . (1964). Autopolyploidy in Asplenium. Nature 203, 324-325. Lundqvist, A. (1961). A rapid method for the analysis of incompatibility in grasses. Hereditas 47, 705-707. Mallott, P. G., Davy A. J., Jefferies, R. L. and Hutton, M. J. (1975). Carbon dioxide exchange in leaves of Spartina anglica Hubbard. Oecologia (Berl.) 20, 351-358. Manners, J. G. (1975). Die-back of Spartina in the Solent. In: Spartina in the Solent (Ed, by F. Stranack and J. Coughlan), pp. 7-10. Solent Protection Society, Exbury, Hants. Mantle, P. G. (1969). Development of alkaloid production in vitro by a strain of Claviceps purpurea from Spartina townsendii. Trans. Br. Mycol. SOC.52, 381-392. Mantle, P. G. (1980). Effects of weed grasses on the ecology and distribution of Claviceps purpurea. In: Pests, Pathogens and Vegetation (Ed. by J. M. Thresh), pp. 437-442. Pitman, New York. Manton, I., Sinha, B. M. B. and Vida, G. (1970). Cytotaxonomic studies in the Adiantum caudatum complex of Africa and Asia. 11. Autoploidy and alloploidy in African representatives of A . incisum. Bot. J . Linn. Soc. 63, 1-21. Marchant, C. J. (1963). Corrected chromosome numbers for Spartina X townsendii and its parent species. Nature 199, 929. Marchant, C. J. (1964). Cytotaxonomic studies in the genus Spartinu Schreb. PhD Thesis. University of Southampton. Marchant, C. J. (1967). Evolution in Spartina (Gramineae). I. History and morphology of the genus in Britain. Bof. J . Linn. SOC.60, 1-24. Marchant, C. J. (1968). Evolution in Spartina (Gramineae). 11. Chromosomes, basic relationships and the problem of the S. X townsendii agg. Bot. J . Linn. SOC.60, 381-409. Marchant, C. J. (1970). Evolution in Spartina (Gramineae). IV. The cytology of S. alterniflora Loisel. in North America. Bot. J. Linn. SOC.63, 321-326. Marchant, C. J. (1975). Spartina Schreb. In: Hybridisation and the Flora of the British Isles (Ed. by C. A. Stace), pp. 586-587. Academic Press, London. Marchant, C. J. (1977). Hybrid characters in Spartina x neyrautii Fouc., a taxon rediscovered in northern Spain. Bot. J . Linn. SOC.74, 289-296. Marchant, C. J. and Goodman, P. J. (1969). Spartina alterniflora Loisel. Biological Flora of the British Isles. J . Ecol. 57, 291-295. Marks, T. C. and Mullins, P. H. (1984). Population studies on the Ribble estuary. In: Spartina anglica in Greaf Britain (Ed. by J. P. Doody), pp. 50-52. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Marks, T. C. and Mullins, P. H. (1990). The seed biology of Spartina anglica. In: Spartina anglica - A Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 20-25. HMSO, London. Marks, T. C. and Truscott, A. J. (1985). Variation in seed production and germination of Spartina anglica within a zoned salt marsh. J. Ecol. 73, 695-705. Millard, A. V. and Evans, P. R. (1984). Colonization of mudflats by Spartina anglica; some effects on invertebrate and shorebird populations at Lindisfarne. In: Spartina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by J. P. Doody), pp. 41-48.
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANCLICA
59
Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Mobberley, D. G. (1956). Taxonomy and distribution of the genus Spartina. Iowa St. Coll. J . Sci. 30, 471-574. Moran, G. F. and Marshall, D. R. (1978). Allozyme uniformity within and variation between races of the colonising species Xanthium strumarium L. (Noogoora burr.). Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 31, 283-291. Moran, G. F., Marshall, D. R. and Muller, W. J. (1981). Phenotypic variation and plasticity in the colonising species Xanthium strumarium L. (Noogoora burr.) Aust. J . Biol. Sci. 34, 639-648. Morley, J. V. (1973). Tidal immersion of Spartina marsh at Bridgwater Bay. Somerset. J. Ecol. 61, 383-386. Mullins, P. H. and Marks, T. C. (1987). Flowering phenology and seed production of Spartina anglica. J. Ecol. 7 5 , 1037-1048. Nairn, R. G. W. (1986). Spartinu anglica in Ireland and its potential impact on wildfowl and waders - a review. Ir. Birds 3 , 215-228. Nelson, J. R., Harris, G. A. and Goebel, C. J. (1970). Genetic vs. environmentally induced variation in medusa head ( Taenianthemum asperum [Simonkai] Nevski). Ecology 51, 526-529. Oliver, F. W. (1920). Spartina problems. Ann. Appl. Biol. 7 , 25-39. Oliver, F. W. (1925). Spartina townsendii; its mode of establishment, economic uses, and taxonomic status. J . Ecol. 13, 74-91. Oliver, F. W. (1926). Spartina in France. Gdnrs’ Chron. 7 , 212- 213. Packham, J. R. and Liddle, M. J. (1970). The Cefni salt marsh, Anglesey. N d Stud. 3 , 331-356. Payne, J. (1973). A survey of the Spartina-feeding insects in Poole Harbour, Dorset. Ent. Mon. Mag. 108, 66-79. Praeger, R. L. (1932). Spartina townsendii introduced into Ireland. Proc. R. Zr. Acad. 41, Sect. B. 119-122. Pryor, L. D. (1976). The Biology of Eucalypts. Arnold, London, 82 pp. Arnold. Ranwell, D. S. (1961). Spartina salt marshes in southern England. I. The effects of sheep grazing at the upper limits of Spartina marsh in Bridgwater Bay. J. EcoI. 49, 325-340. Ranwell, D. S. (1964a). Spartina salt marshes in southern England. 11. Rate and seasonal pattern of sediment accretion. J . Ecol. 52, 79-94. Ranwell, D. S . (1964b). Spartina salt marshes in southern England. 111. Rates of establishment, succession and nutrient supply at Bridgwater Bay, Somerset. J. EcoI. 52, 95-105. Ranwell, D. S . (1967). World resources of Spartina townsendii (s.1. and economic use of Spartina marshland. J. Appl. Ecol. 4, 239-256. Ranwell, D. S. (1972). Ecology of Salt Marshes and Sand Dunes. Chapman and Hall, London, 258 pp. Ranwell, D. S . and Downing, B. M. (1959). Brent Goose (Branta bernicla (L.)) winter feeding pattern and Zostera resources at Scolt Head Island. Norfolk. Anim. Behav. 7 , 42-56. Raybould, A. F. (1987). The Population Genetics of Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard. MSc Thesis, University of Birmingham. Raybould, A. F. (1989). The Population Genetics of Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard. PhD Thesis, University of Birmingham. Raybould, A. F., Gray, A. J., Lawrence, M. J. and Marshall, D. F. (1990). The taxonomy and status of Spartina x neyrauti. Watsonia 18, 207-209. Raybould, A. F., Gray, A. J., Lawrence, M. J. and Marshall, D. F. (1991a).
60
A. J . GRAY E T A L .
The evolution of Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard (Gramineae): origin and genetic variation. Biol. J. Linn. SOC. (in press). Raybould, A. F., Gray, A. J., Lawrence, M. J. and Marshall, D. F. (1991b) The evolution of Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard (Gramineae); variation and status of the parental species in Britain. Biol. J . Linn. SOC. (in press). Rhebergen, L. J. and Nelissen, J. M. (1985). Ecotypic differentiation within Festuca rubra L. occurring in a heterogeneous coastal environment. Vegetatio, 61, 197-202. Righetti, P. G., Gianazza, E., Viotti, A. and Soave, C. (1977). Heterogeneity of storage proteins in maize. Planta 136, 115-123. Riley, R. and Chapman, V. (1958). Genetic control of cytologically diploid behaviour of hexaploid wheat. Nature 182, 713-715. Roose, M. L. and Gottlieb, L. D. (1976). Genetic and biochemical consequences of polyploidy in Tragopogon. Evolution 30, 818- 830. Rowntree, P. R. (1990). Predicted climate changes under ‘greenhouse gas’ warming. In: Climatic Change and Plant Genetic Resources (Ed. by M. T. Jackson, B. V. Ford-Lloyd and M. L. Parry), pp. 18-33. Belhaven Press., London. Rozema, J., Luppes, E. and Broekman, R. (1985). Differential response of salt-marsh species to variation of iron and manganese. Vegetatio 62, 293-301. Salmon, D. G. and Moser, M. E. (1985). Wildfowl and Wader Counts, 1984-1985. Wildfowl Trust, Slimbridge. Scholten, M. C. T. and Rozema. J. (1990). The competitive ability of Spartina anglica on Dutch salt marshes. In: Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 39-47. HMSO, London. Scholten, M. C. T., Blaaww, P., Stroedenga, M. and Rozema, J. (1987) The impact of competitive interactions on the growth and distribution of plant species in saltmarshes. In: Vegetation Between Land and Sea (Ed. by A. H. L. Huiskes, C. W. P. M. Blom and J. Rozema), pp. 260-279. W. Junk, Dordrecht . Scott, R., Callaghan, T. V. and Lawson, G. J. (1990). Spartina as a biofuel. In: Spartina anglica - a Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham). pp. 48-51. HMSO, London. Senay, P. (1934). Spartina townsendii, son extension a I’embouchure de la Seine. Observations sur son origine et son mode de dissemination. Bull. SOC.Bot. Fr. 81, 633-643. Shivanna, K. R., Heslop-Harrison, Y. and Heslop-Harrison, J. (1982). The pollen-stigma interaction in grasses. 111. Features of the self-incompatibility response. Acta. Bot. Neerl. 31, 307-319. Silander, J. A. (1984). The genetic basis of the ecological amplitude of Spartinn patens. 111. Allozyme variation. Bot. G a z . 145, 569-577. Silander, J. A. (1985). The genetic basis of the ecological amplitude of Spartina patens 11. Variance and correlation analysis. Evolution 39, 1034-1052. Silander, J. A. and Antonovics, J. (1979). The genetic basis of the ecological amplitude of Spartina patens. I. Morphometric and physiological traits. Evolution 33, 11 14-1 127. Sivanesan, A. and Manners, J. G. (1972). Bacteria of muds colonized by Spartina townsendii and their possible role in Spartina ’die-back’. PI. Soil 36, 349-36 1. Smith, J. S. (1982). The Spartina communities of the Cromarty Firth. Trans. Bot. SOC.Edinb. 44, 27-30. Soltis, D. E . and Soltis, P. S. (1988). Electrophoretic evidence for tetrasomic
A CENTURY OF EVOLUTION IN SPARTINA ANGLICA
61
inheritance in Tolmeia menziesii. Heredity 60, 375-382. Soltis, D. E. and Soltis, P. S. (1989). Allopolyploid speciation in Tragopogon: insights from chloroplast DNA. A m . J . Bot. 76, 1119-1124. Somers, G. F. and Grant, D. (1981). Influence of seed source upon phenology of flowering of Spartina alterniflora Loisel. and the likelihood of cross-pollination. A m . J . Bot. 68, 6-9. Stapf, 0. (1907). Mud binding grasses. Kew Bull, 5 190-197 Stapf, 0. (1908). Spartina townsendii. Gdnrs’ Chron. 43, 33-35. Stapf, 0. (1913). Townsend’s grass or rice grass. Proc. Bournemouth Nut. Sci. SOC. 5 , 76-82. Sutherland, G . K. and Eastwood, A. (1916). The physiological anatomy of Spartina townsendii. Ann. Bot. 30, 333-351. Swann, E. L. (1965). Spartina in west Norfolk. Proc. Botl. SOC. Br. Isl. 6, 46-47. Taylor, M. C. and Burrows, E. M. (1968). Studies on the biology of Spartina in the Dee Estuary, Cheshire. J . Ecol. 56, 795-809. Teal, J. M. (1962). Energy flow in the salt marsh ecosystem of Georgia. Ecology 43, 614-624. Teeri, J. A. and Schoeller, D. A. (1979).I3C values of an herbivore and the ratio of C3 to C4 plant carbon in its diet. Oecologia (Berl.) 39, 197-200. Thomas, S. M. and Long, S. P. (1978). C4 photosynthesis in Spartina townsendii at low and high temperatures. Planta 142, 171-174. Thompson, J. D. (1989). Population variation in Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard. PhD Thesis, University of Liverpool. Thompson, J. D. (1990). Morphological variation among natural populations of Spartina anglica. In: Spartina anglica - A Research Review (Ed. by A. J. Gray and P. E. M. Benham), pp. 26-33. HMSO, London. Thompson, J . D., Gray, A. J. and McNeilly, T. (1990). The effects of density on the population dynamics of Spartina anglica. Acta Oecologica 11, 669-682. Thompson, J. D., McNeilly, T. and Gray, A. J. (1991a). Population variation in Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard. I, Evidence from a common garden experiment. New Phytol. 117, 115-128. Thompson, J. D., McNeilly, T. and Gray, A. J. (1991b). Population variation in Spartina anglica C. E. Hubbard. 11. Reciprocal transplants among three successional populations. New Phytof. 117, 129-139. Thompson, J . D.. McNeilly, T. and Gray, A. J. (1991~).Population variation in Spartina anglica C . E. Hubbard. 111. Response to substrate variation in a glasshouse experiment. New Phytol. 117, 141-152. Timmis, J. N . and Rees, H. (1971). A pairing restriction at pachytene upon multivalent formation in autotetraploids. Heredity 26, 269-275. Townsend, F. (1883). Flora of Hampshire, pp. 400-401. Reeve, London. Tubbs, C. (1977). Wildfowl and waders in Langstone Harbour. Br. Birds 70, 177-199. Turner, R. E. (1976). Geographic variation in salt marsh macrophyte production: a review. Contr. Mar. Sci. 20, 47-68. Verhoeven, A. G . (1951). Bevordering der landaanwinning in en impoldering van een gedeelte van het Zuider-Sloe. Voordr. K . Inst. Ing. Utrecht 36, 579-604. Vida, G. (1970). The nature of polyploidy in Asplenium ruta-muraria and A . lepidum C. Presl. Caryologia 23, 525-547. Way, L. (1987). A Review of Spartina Control Methods. Unpublished report to the Nature Conservancy Council, Peterborough.
62
A . J . GRAY E T A L .
de Wet, J. M. J. and Harlan, J. R. (1972). Chromosome pairing and phytogenetic affinities. Taxon 21, 67-70. Whiteside, M. (1984). Spartina in Morecambe Bay. In: Spartina anglica in Great Britain (Ed. by P. Doody), pp. 30-33. Focus on Nature Conservation No. 5. Nature Conservancy Council, Huntingdon. Wiehe, P. 0. (1935). A quantitative study of the influence of the tide upon populations of Salicornia europaea. J . Ecol. 23, 323-333. de Wit, C. T. (1960). On competition. Versl. Landb. Onderz. Wugeningen 66, 1-82. Wyatt, R., Odrzykowski, I. J., Stoneburner, A., Bars, H. W. and Galan, G. A. (1988). Allopolyplody in bryophytes: multiple origins of Plagiornniurn medium. Proc. Natn. Acad. Sci. USA 85, 5601-5604.
Genetic and Phenotypic Aspects of Life-history Evolution in Animals R . H . SMITH
...................................... .................................... A . The fieris rupae Problem ....................... B . Aims of This Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Conceptual Frameworks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Life-history Theory ........................... B . Quantitative Genetics ......................... C . Multivariate Selection ......................... D . Gene-Environment Interactions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . The G and E Matrices ......................... IV . Experimental Approaches Illustrated by Cullosobruchus . . . . . . . A . Phenotypic Correlation ........................ B . Experimental Manipulation ..................... C . Breeding Designs ............................ D . Selection Experiments ......................... E . Mapping the Options Set ....................... V . Discussion., . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . Summary
I1 . Introduction
63
64
65 67 68 69 77 83 88 91 93 94 97 100 106 109 110 112 113
.
I SUMMARY Fitness is determined by survival rate and fecundity at different ages . Life-history theory is concerned with how constraints lead to optimal combinations of age-specific survival and fecundity. that is combinations which maximize fitness in a given environment. The optimization approach emphasizes constraints of resource allocation. often described as physiological trade-offs . Experimental examination of trade-offs has 0
ADVANCES IN ECOLOGICAL RESEARCH VOL 21 ISBN 0-12-013921-9
Copyright 1991 Aiademri PraS Lrntrrrcl All rights ofreprodtrilrori i n ariv furni rrsericd
63
64
R. H. SMITH
often involved physiological manipulations. In contrast, geneticists emphasize genetical constraints (genetic correlations resulting from pleiotropy and linkage, and epistatic interactions between loci). Genetical constraints are conventionally examined by quantitative genetic analysis. Some recent papers have successfully reconciled the two approaches, and in particular Charlesworth (1990) has explicitly examined the relationships between functional constraints on life-history characters and the genetic variances and covariances at equilibrium. In this paper the optimization approach is exemplified by the general iteroparous life-cycle model of Sibly and Calow (1983). The quantitative genetics description of life-history evolution is developed in relation to a bivariate case of the general iteroparous life-cycle model, and the recent results of Pease and Bull (1988) and Charlesworth (1990) are outlined. The importance of gene-environment interactions is stressed, especially in relation to variation in population density. Although the theory of negative pleiotropy as a means of maintaining genetic variation in components of fitness has become widely accepted, it is noted that positive genetic correlations between constrained variables at equilibrium can arise in the multivariate case, depending on the pattern of relationships between functional constraints. Different experimental approaches to investigating life-history evolution in animals are compared by reference to a series of papers on the seed beetle Callosohruclius macirlatus, a semelparous species with a relatively simple life-history. The data illustrate some of the predictions of multivariate selection theory, including the existence of both positive and negative correlations between components of fitness at genetic equilibrium. Also, it is shown that experimental manipulation can reveal a trade-off in resource allocation when genetic analysis failed to reveal a trade-off because of lack of genetic variation. Charlesworth (1990) showed that the multivariate selection model leads to the same predictions of mean phenotype as the optimization approach for both simple optimization and frequency-dependent selection (ESS predictions). It is suggested that frequency-dependent selection and the existence of alternative ESS life histories with different equilibrium genetic constraints may be an important consequence of environmental patchiness.
11. INTRODUCTION Fitness in natural populations is clearly some combination of survivorship to ( I , ) and fecundity at ( m , )different ages. However fitness is defined (Nur, 1987; Caswell, 1989a; Sibly, 1989; Parker and Maynard
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
65
Smith, 1990), maximising fitness by differential selection on combinations of (/,, m,)is the natural tendency of natural selection (Fisher, 1930), even though the direction of selection may change because of temporal changes in the external environment, population density (Charlesworth, 1980) and the frequency of different genes (Maynard Smith, 1989a,b). One of the guiding principles of theories of life-history evolution is that you cannot get something for nothing, that is an increase in one component of fitness is expected to be at the expense of another (Sibly and Calow, 1986). Geneticists stress genetic constraints (Loeschke, 1987) that act on top of physiological or other functional constraints (Maynard Smith, 1989b), and one important issue is the relationship between genetic and functional constraints (Charlesworth, 1990). Another concerns genetic variation in fitness (supposed to disappear inevitably under natural selection; Fisher, 1930) as opposed to variation in components of fitness (Smith et a l . , 1987). In this area, ecologists have gained a great deal from the accumulated theory and experience of animal and plant breeders (e.g. Falconer, 1989a,b). In practical breeding, a selection index is often established, based on genetic constraints (genetic correlations) as well as an economics-linked quantity to be maximized; in life-history evolution, the quantity to be maximized happens to be fitness. Therefore artificial selection in the context of, for example, animal breeding has close analogies with life-history evolution (Hill and Mackay, 1989).
A. The Pieris rupue Problem Evolutionary biologists tend to accept that life is governed by neo-Darwinian principles, perhaps rather uncritically (Gould and Lewontin, 1979). Few biologists question the central dogma of neo-Darwinism, that evolution is the process and consequence of maximizing individual fitness. However, in a series of papers on the small white butterfly Pieris rapae L., Gilbert (1984a,b,c, 1986) suggested that his data on the distribution of size and fecundity in field populations of P. rapae were inconsistent with conventional evolutionary theory. The arguments can be summarized as follows:
I . Gilbert's Thesis ( a ) Observation: body size is heritable. In a population of butterflies recently derived from wild-caught parents, there was a significant regression of pupal weight of offspring on pupal weight of parents. From the slope of the regression, the heritability of pupal weight was estimated as h 2 = 0.45 (Gilbert, 1984a). Heritability h' measures the proportion of phenotypic variation in a character expressed in the test
66
R. H . SMITH
environment which results from genetic differences between individuals (Section 1II.B). Thus there must have been considerable genetic variation between individual butterflies to give rise to the observed heritable variation in body weight. Gilbert (1984a) confirmed that the genetic variation in body weight was additive (Falconer, 1989a) by selection experiments on his base-line strain (B). Selecting upwards for large pupae produced a strain (C) in which mean pupal weight was 20% higher, and selecting downwards produced a small strain (A).
(b) Observation: body size is related to fecundity. Pieris rapae follows the general rule in insects that heavier females lay more eggs (e.g. Credland et al., 1986; Li, 1988; Smith and Lessells, 1985; Wrelton, 1987). In the unselected line (B), Gilbert (1984a) found a correlation between pupal weight and lifetime fecundity and predicted that butterflies in the large strain (C) had a potential average increase in fecundity of 20%. Note that this prediction is based on a simple (phenotypic) correlation between fecundity and weight.
(c) Deduction: there is heritable variation in a component of fitness. Putting together observations 1 and 2, Gilbert (1984a) concluded that there was heritable variation in fecundity, which is a component of fitness. Gilbert found no evidence of a trade-off in other components of fitness, and concluded that his results contradicted Fisher’s (1930) Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection which says that the rate of evolution is proportional to additive genetic variance in fitness, with the corollary that a population that is not evolving should have no genetic variation in fitness.
2 . The Optimality View Smith et al., (1987) suggested an alternative interpretation of the P. rapae data. Their approach was first to derive an expression for fitness that included the major events in the life-cycle of P . rupae, then to establish what quantitative relationships would be necessary to balance (or trade-off) components of fitness, and finally to examine the data to see whether there was evidence of such trade-offs. In their re-analysis of Gilbert’s data, they found some evidence for a trade-off between fecundity and juvenile survival (the selected, large C line had a higher juvenile mortality rate; see their (Fig. l ) , but the results were not consistent for both selection regimes (the downwards-selected, small A line also had a higher juvenile mortality rate). In their discussion, they suggested how a genetic trade-off might be identified by searching for a negative genetic correlation (the negative pleiotropy of Rose, 1982), but no data were available to do this.
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
67
3. Comment In fact, neither Gilbert (1984a,b,c) nor Smith et ul. (1987) had established that there was a problem about fitness to address, since the correlation between weight (which was heritable) and fecundity (which may or may not have been heritable) was phenotypic; no genetic correlation was established then or since (Moller et al., 1989a), though the relationship between genetic and phenotypic correlations highlighted by Bell and Koufopanou (1986) suggests that there was likely to be a positive genetic correlation (see Section 111) and therefore that there probably was also heritable variation in fecundity. The debate about P. r a p e highlights some important questions which will be discussed below. These include: (i) can optimality theory help us to understand life-history evolution? (ii) what is the relationship between fitness and its components? (iii) how do genetic constraints relate to the underlying trade-off constraints assumed in optimality theory? (iv) how will evolution proceed under genetic constraints, and does it matter whether all the constrained variables have been measured? (v) what data must be recorded to test the theory?
B. Aims of This Review There is now an extensive empirical and theoretical literature relating to the above questions. The main aim of this review is to guide animal ecologists through the important theoretical results and to attempt synthesis where it seems appropriate. The next section sets up the conceptual frameworks, and the generalized iteroparous life-history model discussed by Sibly and Calow (1983, 1986) will be used to link optimality theory with quantitative genetics. The section on experimental approaches is related back to the theory, in particular the recent important paper by Charlesworth (1990). Data collected at the University of Reading in a series of studies (Moller et ul., 1989a,b, 1990; Sibly et ul.,' 1991) on Cullosobruchus muculutus are used to illustrate the utility of different experimental approaches. This case study provides a contrast to the many studies on Drosophilu melunoguster and, being a semelparous species, the fundamental constraints on C. muculutus are more easily understood. The discussion briefly introduces two new topics; frequency-dependent selection and environmental patchiness. These are highlighted as the areas requiring further theoretical and experimental work.
68
K. H. SMITH
111. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORKS The questions raised by Gilbert (1984a,b,c) relate to two aspects of population biology: life-history theory (questions about the allocation of resources in observed phenotypes) and population genetics (concerned with changes in gene frequency in relation to variation in fitness between individuals). Clearly, both topics are concerned with evolution and yet theory has been developed for both with rather little cross-reference and even less integration until recently (e.g. Roughgarden, 1979). Life-history theorists have mostly used phenotypic optimization models (e.g. Cole, 1954; Charnov and Schaffer, 1973) based on the core concept of the trade-off as a constraint on evolution (e.g. Levins, 1968; Charnov, 1982; Sibly and Calow, 1983). Population geneticists have been concerned with the dynamics of gene frequencies and how they are affected by patterns of genetic correlation, epistasis and pleiotropy. The quantitative genetics extension to continuously varying characters assumes constraints but may not describe them as trade-offs (e.g. Lande, 1979; Falconer, 1989a). There are a few examples in the earlier literature of papers that demonstrate outstanding intuitive understanding of the links between optimization and genetics, for example Lewontin’s (1965) discussion on the effects of selection of life-cycle components on genetic variance in different components of life-history (see also Cole (1954) and Caswell (1978)). Geneticists seem generally to have felt that trade-off constraints are only of evolutionary interest if they are genetically based (i.e. they exist because of negative genetic correlations-Charlesworth, 1984; Reznick, 1985) and that evidence for trade-offs based on phenotypic correlations (e.g. Calow. 1979) is therefore suspect. However, Bell and Koufopanou (1986) have argued persuasively that estimating phenotypic correlations may in practice often be more useful than attempting to estimate negative correlations because there is a range of circumstances where genetic correlations may be inferred directly from phenotypic correlations (Falconer, 1989a. p.315). Mdler et a l . , (1989b) argued that there may be a contingent (phenotypic) response (a physiological trade-off) that complements the evolved (genotypic) response (the genetic tradeoff) yet may not be detected by quantitative genetic analysis; they distinguished between genetic adaptations of, and phenotypic plasticity within genotypes. Pease and Bull (1988) used an explicit linear model of trade-offs to illustrate their discussion of how phenotypic correlations may legitimately identify trade-offs, and Charnov (1989) argued in favour of the optimization approach, and emphasized both the dynamic nature of the genetic constraints (genetic covariances) and that the
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
69
genetic covariance matrix is a linear approximation of true trade-off relationships that may disguise too much of basic interest (the shape of the trade-off relationship-Bell and Koufopanou, 1986, p.123). The most recent and important paper to relate optimization models to quantitative genetics is by Charlesworth (1990), and will be discussed in Section 1II.C.
A. Life-history Theory
1. Background Caswell (1989a) has reviewed the development of life-history theory since Fisher’s (1930, p. 47) characteristically terse statement of the problem of how much resource to allocate to gonads vs soma. Caswell (1989a) highlighted three important early studies that have stimulated much later research, the first of which is briefly described below. Lack (1947) was interested in why birds lay fewer eggs than they are capable of physiologically, and suggested that there was a constraint on offspring survival because parents are unable adequately to feed and rear too large a number of offspring. Thus there is a trade-off expressed as a negative correlation between realized (as opposed to potential) fecundity and juvenile survival. Lack suggested that the number of surviving offspring would therefore be maximized at an intermediate rather than maximal clutch size, and Lack’s hypothesis has been examined in a number of studies since he elaborated it in his 1954 book. Cody (1966) broadened Lack’s hypothesis to incorporate other calls on an animal’s time and energy. Klomp (1970) reviewed the available data on birds in 1970, and there have been more detailed long-term and manipulative studies of optimal clutch size in a few species since then (e.g. Dhondt et a l . , 1990; Nur, 1984; Pettifor et a l . , 1988). Lack’s hypothesis has been at the core of clutch size models proposed for animals far removed from birds, for example seed beetles (Smith and Lessells, 1985), parasitoids (Charnov and Skinner, 1984; Waage and Godfray, 1985) and general models of insect oviposition (Parker and Courtney, 1984). The models all derive from Lack’s notion of a most productive clutch size (Charnov and Krebs, 1974) which provides a theoretical upper limit to individual clutch size in species that lay more than one clutch of eggs. It should be noted that most tests of predictions relating to Lack’s hypothesis assume that individual animals are able to adjust their behaviour in response to prevailing circumstances (adaptive phenotypic plasticity) rather than being rigidly programmed to lay a certain number of eggs according to genotype, and experimental manipulation has therefore been the main tool used to test the predictions of
70
R. H . SMITH
the theory. In one animal (the seed beetle C. maculatus (F.)) there is also evidence of genetic variability in behaviour determining clutch size both between populations (Messina, 1989) and within populations (Messina, 1990); the beetle will be discussed further in Section IV. However, in general, derivatives of Lack’s hypothesis have been tested by examination of phenotypic relationships with varying degrees of rigour (Pease and Bull, 1988). Williams (1957) followed Medawar (1946, 1952) in considering the evolution of senescence in terms of selection acting on individual fitness rather than for the good of the species. Williams’ (1957) paper is described by Charnov (1982) as the type specimen for the use of selection to understand a major biological problem. He blends together physiological and environmental constraints on development and life span, pleiotropy of reproductive function, and a precise definition of soma , . . combined with one simple fitness observation to produce a theory of senescence . . . that reproduction later in life is worth less to an individual simply because the individual is less likely to be alive at the older age.
The idea of an interaction constraint or trade-off between two components of fitness (early reproduction vs later survival) is the primary concept in life-history theory; the importance of timing of life events (Cole, 1954) and the genetic expression of trade-offs as pleiotropy (Rose, 1983a,b) may be regarded as two secondary concepts that are consequences of the first. This broad outline will be developed below in relation to a particular category of optimization model before moving on to other approaches and some case studies in Sections 111 and IV.
2. Trade-offs in Optimization Models The approach used here follows Sibly and Calow (1983, 1986). The primary components of fitness are the probability 1, that an individual survives from age 0 to age x , and the fecundity m,r at age x . It is assumed that there are constraints on the 1, and m, values beyond the trivial constraints 0 s 1, S 1 and m, 3 0. What might be the nature of these further constraints? Clearly there are ultimate constraints determined by the laws of physics and chemistry that are believed to constrain all organisms within the universe and a subset of developmental constraints that prohibit certain combinations of 1, and m, for particular organisms, at least in the short term (Maynard Smith et al., 1985). Because the resources available to an individual are finite, there must be some physiological constraints of the sort envisaged by Williams (1957) and Cody (1966), and these constraints of resource allocation (in part a consequence of constrained resource acquisition) have an obvious
71
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
intuitive appeal as an explanation of observed (or hypothetical) tradeoffs (Gadgil and Bossert, 1970; Calow and Sibly, 1983; Bell and Koufopanou, 1986; Sibly and Calow, 1986). Of course, there may also be various genetic constraints (Gould and Lewontin, 1979; Barker and Thomas, 1987), including the random, temporary loss of genetic variance, but these will not be considered until later sections. Whatever the explanation, the assumption is usually made that an organism is constrained in the values of 1, and rn, that it can achieve such that it only has a limited set of evolutionary options (the options set in Fig. 1). Although the options set (sometimes called the fitness set (Levins, 1968) or trade-off (Charnov, 1982)) has been a key concept in life-history theory, it lacks a precise definition and there is as yet no common agreement on how it should be measured.
3. Defining Fitness Given a set of possible options, some or many of which may actually be observed in a population, which combinations of 1, and m, are expected to emerge as a consequence of natural selection? The combination of I, and m, that is the optimal life history is that which maximizes fitness 1.oo
-N
0.80
00
P
.-G>
0.60
>
5
0.40
0.00 0
2
4
6
8
10
Fecundity (m)
Fig. 1. The options set between two components of fitness, as generally assumed in the optimality approach. The curve that bounds the options set (shaded) is known as the trade-off curve. Fitness is a function of adult survivorship between breeding attempts and fecundity at each breeding attempt, and increases away from the origin.
72
R. H . SMITH
subject to the constraints of the options set. Definition of fitness has been a vexed question (Nur, 1987), but there is now a general consensus that the Malthusian parameter or intrinsic rate of increase r defined as the root of the Euler-Lotka equation is the most appropriate (if cumbersome; Parker and Maynard Smith, 1990) measure of fitness (Fisher, 1930; Charlesworth, 1980, 1984; Lande, 1982; Sibly and Calow, 1983; Sibly, 1989); see Sibly and Calow (1986, p. 11) or Maynard Smith (1989a, p. 39) for straightforward justifications. If m,r is taken to be the number of female offspring, the Euler-Lotka equation is:
There are implicit assumptions in the definition of fitness as r (or its discrete-time analogue A = e r , useful for populations structured by stage rather than age; Caswell, 1989b), in particular the demographic assumption of stable age-structure. Caswell (1989b, p. 171) provided an informal justification for the use of stable age-structure theory in the above definition of fitness, as well as a discussion (p. 176) about when maximizing Fisher’s (1930) reproductive value (sometimes presented as a measure of fitness) is equivalent to maximizing r . Up to now, fitness has been defined as a rate of increase without specifying to what that rate refers. Sibly and Calow (1986) specifically defined r as the rate of increase of a dominant gene, in contrast with most other authors who talk about genotypic rates of increase (e.g. Charlesworth, 1984). Population geneticists conventionally formulate models in terms of fitnesses of genotypes, though reformulation using average fitnesses of genes gives equivalent equilibrium results (R.M. Sibly and R.N. Curnow. pers. comm.). In his chapter: The Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection, Fisher (1930) may have caused some confusion by basing his derivation on the average fitnesses of alleles (e.g. p. 37) but referring to the fitnesses of genotypes in his Summary (p. 50); Crow (1986, p. 84) states very clearly that the genetic variance referred to by Fisher is the variance of the average fitnesses of alleles rather than of genotypes. However, for the purposes of the optimization approach described below, it is sufficient to think initially in terms of comparing phenotypic variants with one another (Sibly and Calow, 1983).
4. Optimal Life-history The approach adopted here is taken from Sibly and Calow (1983, 1986). In a simplified life-cycle, m offspring are produced at each breeding attempt (Fig. 2). Survivorship from when an offspring is produced until first breeding at age t , is s I and survivorship between successive
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
Time
Survivorship
73
Breeding
Juveniles
t t*
t t*
Fig. 2 The generalized iteroparous life-cycle (after Sibly and Calow, 1986). In the text, t i and t 2 are assumed to be equal, and juvenile survivorship to first breeding is treated as a parameter determined by the environment. Adult survivorship between breeding attempts is assumed to be a decreasing function of fecundity, as in Fig. 1.
breedings at intervals t 2 is s 2 . Then the fitness r is related to the life-cycle variables as follows (Charlesworth, 1980, p. 226). 1 = e-“ls,m + e-“?s2
(2) For simplicity, consider the case where t l = t 2 = 1 (e.g. annual breeders that start breeding at 1 year old) such that: er = slm
+ s2
(3)
Clearly, fitness increases with survivorship of juveniles, survivorship of adults, and fecundity per breeding attempt. There are several assumptions implicit in Eq. (3); two obvious ones that ecologists might object to are that fecundity is independent of age (the rn, curve is horizontal), as is survivorship once offspring are reproductive ( I , is a negative exponential function of age x ) . Equation (3) implicitly assumes what is termed “absorption-costing’’ rather than direct-costing (Sibly and Calow, 1986). Nevertheless, Eq. (3) is a useful metaphor for “the iteroparous life-cycle”, and will be used to make a number of general points in what follows. The life-history characters that define the life-cycle in Eq. (3) can be thought of as elements of a vector z, where z1 = sl, z 2 = s2 and z 3 = rn. The classic “cost of reproduction” trade-off concept is that there is an interdependence between s2 and rn such that if resources are put into increasing m, then less resources are available for s2 which in consequence decreases; the function f l ( z 2 , z 3 )= 0 that relates s2 and m is
74
R. H . SMITH
one life-history constraint or trade-off. There could be another constraint, for example f 2 ( z z 3 ) might specify that production of more offspring per breeding attempt leads to a reduction in survivorship of each offspring (a formulation that leads to Lack’s hypothesis about optimal clutch size). Note that in a three variable case there can be no more than two independent constraints else the vector z is fully determined and there is no optimization problem to solve (Charlesworth, 1990). Sibly and Calow (1983) looked at several pair-wise combinations of life-history characters in the more general formulation Eq. (2) in order to predict the progress of life-history evolution in different circumstances. Here, we will take as an example Eq. (3) with only one functional constraint:
(Boundary conditions on s2 require that 1 3 k l s:/(46,).) Juvenile survivorship is taken to be a feature of the external environment, and the constraint f l says that the trade-off curve between m and s2 is convex upwards such that s 2 approaches k , as m approaches 0, and m approaches (kl/bl)lDas s2 approaches 0. Thus f l is the trade-off curve that defines the boundary of the options set for ( s 2 ,m ) . All phenotypes must lie within the options set, defined by the boundary conditions ( m3 0; 0 zz s2 zz 1) and the trade-off constraint ( f l : s2 b l m 2- k l = 0); this options set is shown in Fig. 1. Sibly and Calow (1983) used a simple graphical method to show how the optimal life-history ( s 2*, m*) depends on the juvenile survivorship sl, assumed to be environmentally determined (Fig. 3). From Eq. ( 3 ) , a given fitness r in a given environment characterized by juvenile survivorship s1 is a linear combination of s2 and m . Therefore, lines of equal fitness with slope -sl can be plotted onto the ( s 2 ,m ) plane and the phenotype z* with greatest fitness is the tangent of a fitness contour to the trade-off curve. Figure 3 illustrates the well-known result that low juvenile survivorship should lead to evolution of iteroparity, and high juvenile survivorship to semelparity (Cole, 1954; Bell, 1980; Sibly and Calow , 1983). The graphical solution can be formalized as follows. Maximizing 1 is convenient in this case and is equivalent to maximizing r . The optimal solution must lie on the boundary of the options set, defined by f l . Replace s2 by f l ( m ) = k l - b l m 2 in Eq. (3), then A=e‘ = s l m + f l ( m ) . Setting aA/am = 0 to maximize A gives s1 + ( f l / m )= 0. Hence, for the particular constraint function f l, the optimal life-history is m* = s1/(2b1)and s2* = k , - b,m*2.
+
75
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
1.oo
0.80
0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00 0
2
4
6
8
10
8
10
Fecundity (m)
1.oo
-(Y
0.80
00
P
5
0.60
b>
.->
0.40 c
3
0.20
0.00
0
2
4
6
Fecundity (m)
Fig. 3 The dependence of optimal life history on environment: (a) low juvenile survivorship (s,) favours low fecundity ( m ) and high adult survivorship ($2); (b) high juvenile survivorship favours high fecundity and low adult survivorship. The parallel straight lines are equal fitness contours, and the optimal life-history (sz*, m*) is starred (after Sibly and Calow, 1983).
76
R. H. SMITH
The above graphical method is appropriate for the phenotypic optimization approach, where it is legitimate to consider pair-wise trade-offs between variables taken two at a time. However, it will be seen in Section 1II.C that the genetic formulation requires a more formal description of how natural selection acts on z, the vector of life-history characters. Specifically, it will be necessary to define a selection gradient vector V W , containing the partial derivatives of fitness with respect to each element of the life-history vector z. For Eq. (3), it is easiest first to evaluate the vector of derivatives of A = e' :
VAT = [aA/az]' = [ m ,1, s l ]
(5)
Then since VW = V r = A-'VA (Caswell, 1989a), the elements of V W are: ar/asl = rn/(slm + s2)
ar/as2 = I/(sIrn + s 2 )
(6)
ar/arn = sl/(sIm + s 2 ) It is clear from Eq. ( 6 ) that maximization without trade-off constraints is trivial (sl, s2, m tend to increase indefinitely when a r / a z , = 0 for all z,). Fitness maximization in practice must take into account trade-off constraints (e.g. Eq. (4)). Charlesworth (1990) gave a formal definition of the definition of the optimal solution using the selection gradient VW and the constraints fi(z) on z, and also showed how the optimality criterion (an expression involving the ar/az, and af,/az, terms) is modified by boundary conditions on the z , . At this stage, we simply note that the selection gradient V W specifies the direction of steepest ascent up the surface of increasing fitness r ( t ) and therefore relates to the progress of natural selection (changes in mean phenotype) as well as the long-term outcome (selective equilibrium at z*).
5. Population Dynamics and Life-history Evolution Clearly there is feed-back from life-history evolution to population dynamics via the l,r, m , curves, but population dynamics must also in part determine life-history evolution through definition of the biotic environment. Charlesworth (1980) provided the authoritative account of these links (though few have come to grips with all of Charlesworth's book), and Caswell (1989b) gave an excellent review of more recent results in his treatment of matrix population models. A brief summary of the main features is given below. The life-history characters used in Eq. (3) fit directly into the familiar Leslie matrix model of stage-structured population dynamics: n/+1 =
Ln,
(7)
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
77
For the iteroparous life cycle described by Eq. (3) there are only two distinct stages, juveniles and adults, and therefore n, and n,+l are two-element vectors containing the numbers of juveniles and adults in a population at times t and t + 1 respectively. The projection matrix L is:
At stable age-structure, the finite rate of increase is the dominant eigenvalue (A1) of L and the stable age structure is the corresponding eigenvector. The second eigenvalue (A,) of L is in tension with A , , and the progress of the oscillatory approach to stable age-structure is more rapid the larger is the difference between A1 and A,. The eigenvalues are the roots of det IL - AZ I = 0, giving
A
= i(S2
f (S:
+ 4mS1)1’2)
(9) Hence we see that the trade-offs that determine the optimal combination of (sl. s2, rn) eventually determine the rate of decline of age-structure oscillations (Caswell, 1989b). Population dynamics may feed-back on life-history evolution by imposing additional, population-level ecological constraints on life-histories. If intraspecific competition constrains population size to be at or close to equilibrium, survivorship and fecundity values are also constrained such that variation in one must be followed by compensatory (density-dependent) variation in another. Sibly and Calow (1986, 1987) refer to this as “ecological Compensation”, and show that some analyses that ignore this complication are not strictly correct for populations at stable equilibrium if the fitness components involved in trade-off constraints show density-dependent compensation. For Eq. (7), stable equilibrium means that ~t,,+~ = n, and the dominant eigenvalue of L is 1. Thus the stable population constraint is ms,+ s2 = 1. Putting msl= 1 - s2 into Eq. (9) gives A1 = 1 and A, = s2 - 1 = -ms,< 0. Hence A2 << Al, and therefore the return to stable age-structure following perturbation will be relatively rapid as a consequence of ecological compensation. The asumption of stable age-structure is implicit in the use of r as a measure of fitness in Eq. (1) (Caswell, 1989b) and it is comforting that there is internal consistency in this part of the formulation for the ecologically realistic restriction of a stable population where A = 1.
B. Quantitative Genetics The essential assumption in all but the most trivial life-history theory is that components of fitness z, cannot evolve independently to their
78
R. H. SMITH
selective optima. These constraints on the z , are referred to as trade-offs (Stearns, 1989) and there has been some disagreement on how precisely they should be defined, and how best to measure them. What is the relationship, if any, between apparent trade-offs recorded by observations of phenotypic correlations in unmanipulated populations in the field (Clutton-Brock et a l . , 1983), in the laboratory (Bell, 19d4a,b), and in manipulated populations (Partridge and Farquhar, 1981; Mdler et al., 1989b), or by genetic correlations (Rose and Charlesworth, 1981a,b; Maller el al., 1989a)? Is there a rigorous definition of a genetic trade-off (Smith et al., 1987) as opposed to a physiological trade-off (Calow and Sibly, 1983), and can we say that only one sort of trade-off is worth measuring, or that one sort is always the best (Reznick, 1985; Sibly and Calow, 1986)? Whatever else a trade-off measures, it must involve covariation or correlation in some form. A simple (phenotypic) correlation may be the result of a number of causes, and should ideally be broken down into better defined components. It is always useful to be able to split covariation into different components based on some sort of structuring or classification of data (e.g. intra- and interfamily, or between manipulations). The quantitative genetics formulation is one way of structuring data that leads to definition and estimation of quantities like heritability and genetic correlation that figure so largely in the life-history literature. As shall be seen later, this formulation also throws light on the nature of the non-genetic components of variation and covariation (Section
1II.E). It should be pointed out, however, that quantitative genetics theory is a statistical description of variation that we invoke only because (a) it is useful for some defined purpose, and (b) because we do not know the nature and number of genes underlying what we observe in the phenotype. It is very rare to be able to identify a particular gene or genes that determine variation and covariation in life-history parameters (e.g. Kallman and Borski, 1978). Polygenic models are sometimes presented as if they are some sort of alternative to Mendelian genetics, but of course they are just an elaboration of Mendelian genetics with a number of assumptions about how the different gene loci contribute to the observed phenotype. In fact, the use of polygenic models of inheritance is an admission of ignorance, though it cannot be denied that great strides have been made in animal and plant breeding because of development of quantitative genetics theory (a simple review can be found in Bowman, 1974). In the simplified description that follows, terminology will be based on definitions given by Falconer (1989a). Further details of theory can be found in Kempthorne (1957), Bulmer (1985) and Falconer (1989a).
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
79
1. Assumptions Of the many implicit assumptions, the most important in quantitative genetics are as follows: a character such as fecundity or weight is controlled by the action of many genes at several loci, each with a small, additive effect; the genes are inherited as normal Mendelian genes; there is an environmental effect on a character that is independent of (i.e. uncorrelated with and additive to) genotype; the population is random mating and the relevant genotype frequencies are in Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium; there are no interactive effects either between alleles at a locus (dominance) or between genes at different loci (epistasis). Quantitative genetics theory was developed in the applied fields of plant and animal breeding where these assumptions are not critical provided violations are not too extreme. However, those who believe that a quantitative genetic approach to life-history evolution in some way reveals fundamental truths should beware; the theory is an approximate statistical model that describes phenotypes and should not be treated as anything more.
2. Model A life-history character zi has a value zik in the kth individual in a population with mean Zi described as the sum of total genetic effects gik and environmental effects eik: Zjk
- 21 = g,k
+ ejk
(10)
Hence the phenotypic variance V , in the population is the sum of the genetic variance Vc and the environmental variance V,; Vc and V Eare uncorrelated by definition and therefore there is no covariance term:
v, = v c + v, If there were correlations or an interaction between g, and eik, the effects on V p would as a first approximation be assumed t o be part of V,. Genetic interactions are conventionally separated out of VG (Falconer, 1989a) because only the additive genetic variance V , contributes to long-term evolution (dominance variance V , and epistasis variance V , only affect the process, not the outcome of evolution
v,
= VA
+ v, + V [
80
R. H. SMITH
The distinction between additive and interactive effects of genetic variation is important. Fisher’s (1930) Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection says that the rate of change in mean fitness of a population equals the additive genetic variance for fitness, and some breeding designs used to estimate genetic and environmental components of phenotypic variance (and covariance) do not separate V , from other parts of VG (Section 1V.C). The standard text where these topics are discussed in more detail is Falconer (1989a), while Crow (1986) and Maynard Smith (1989a) also give very good introductions. Evolutionary biologists are often more concerned with correlations of life-history characters with each other and with fitness than with the variance of a single trait. Equations (10) to (12) can be used to describe variation in other traits z j , and the covariance between z , and z j (or between ziand r ) can be described in a similar way:
Caswell (1989a) suggested that the so-called Secondary Theorem of Natural Selection (Robertson, 1968) is a more useful generalization than Fisher’s Fundamental Theorem. The Secondary Theorem relates the rate of change in the mean phenotypic value z, of a trait to the genetic covariance of z, with fitness r :
k ;= CA(Z;,r ) = (a rlaz;)V,( 2;)
(14)
Equation (14) shows why the selection gradient (introduced in Section III.A.4) is so important. Equation (14) will be considered further in Section 1II.C.
3. Dimensions and Dimensionless Quantities: h2 and
rA
Variances and covariances are measured in units that are the square or the product of the units the z,, ti are measured in. This rather obvious point is worth emphasizing since it allows values that some authors seem to treat as pure numbers to be related to the phenotypic means of the populations to which they refer. Charlesworth (1984) used this approach to describe the relative importance of components of genetic variability for several characters in a population of D . melunoguster; he used what might be called a “coefficient of additive genetic variation” ( V A 1 p ( z , ) / 2 ia) ,dimensionless quantity which vaned from 5 to 26% for various characters in Drosophilu in the study described by Charlesworth (1984). The most commonly estimated dimensionless quantity in quantitative
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
81
genetics is heritability h 2 , defined as the proportion of observed phenotypic variation attributable to genetic differences between individuals in a population. The “narrow-sense” heritability uses only additive genetic variance and equals V A / V p . Published estimates of heritability will not be reviewed here; a recent review by Roff (1990, Table 1.1) gives a reasonably up-to-date list of published heritability estimates for life-cycle and morphological traits in insects. Essentially, heritability estimates measure correlations among relatives to estimate how much of the phenotypic variation measurable in one population at one time is attributable to genetic variation that cannot be measured directly (see Section 1V.C). The value of h2 in practical breeding programmes is to predict a short-term response to artificial selection (Falconer, 1989a). Several authors have stressed the limitations of heritability estimates in understanding evolution by natural selection (e.g. Barker and Thomas, 1987). Keeping V , and V E separate rather than automatically combining them in h2 is always advisable, and the dynamics of life-history evolution depend directly on the variances and covariances (Lande, 1979; Caswell, 1989a; Charlesworth, 1984, 1990) rather than on any ratios derived from them. Here, it is worth noting four important limitations of heritability estimates: differences in h 2 between populations may reflect differences in either V Aor V Eor both; laboratory studies control V E and therefore h 2 estimates may be higher in laboratory studies than in natural populations (Atkinson. 1979); h 2 changes under natural or artificial selection, and therefore predictions based on h 2 are only valid in the short term; if the primary interest is in whether genetic variation is significantly different from zero, V A estimates should be relatively more precise than h2 estimates and therefore more powerful in hypothesis testing; this is because the h2 estimate suffers from sampling variation in both V A and V E . Genetic and environmental correlation coefficients are also dimensionless quantities that are perhaps more useful than h 2 . In particular, the genetic correlation rA is the simplest expression of a genetic constraint on evolution (Clark, 1987) while the environmental correlation r E contains information about resource allocation (physiological trade-offs), though it may be difficult to disentangle from variation in resource acquisition (see Section 1II.E). However, the variance-covariance matrix from which a correlation is derived contains more information than the matrix of genetic correlations and is more directly related to the dynamics of evolution (see Section 1II.C).
82
K. H. SMITH
4. Direct and Indirect Selection The primary aim of animal and plant breeding is to use artificial selection to improve some aspect of yield. Direct selection on a trait usually involves choosing a selection of individuals as parents whose mean phenotypic value in a desired character is S units higher than the mean of the population from which they were selected (S is the selection differential). The response to selection R is the difference in mean phenotypic value between offspring of selected parents and the whole of the parental population before selection. Provided there is no additional (e.g. natural) selection on characters correlated with the directly selected character, the response is:
R
=
h2S
(15)
Heritability will change with selection; although it may rise in the early stages, it would eventually fall towards zero if there were no remaining additive genetic variation in the character selected (Falconer, 1989a,b). Directional, artificial selection, however, sometimes leads to no response ( R = 0) even when heritability is significantly non-zero. One explanation relevant here is that the directly selected character may be genetically correlated with components of fitness (fecundity or viability) such that natural selection opposes artificial selection (Falconer, 1989a); that is, there is a genetic constraint on evolution in the selected populations. This explanation is supported by the observation that reversed selection often produces a rapid response even when the response to directional selection has fallen to zero (Falconer, 1989b). Breeders sometimes use genetic correlations to increase the efficiency of selection for a character with low heritability (Falconer, 1989a, p.320). Indirect selection on a correlated character z j with high heritability h ; should yield a more rapid response than direct selection on the character z i of interest if rA > ( h f / h ; ) @ . The relevance of indirect selection and genetic correlations to life-history evolution will be spelled out in Section 1II.C. Falconer (1989a, p.318) gives expressions for the correlated response to selection. Standard formulae involving the selection differential S can be applied to truncation selection (e.g. artificial selection) where only a selected part of a population is allowed to breed. Natural selection, where most or maybe all members of a population breed but with varying success, is less straightforward. However, rearrangement of the formulae (Charlesworth, 1984) gives the correlated response R j of a trait t i to the direct response to selection Ri of a trait z i :
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
83
Equation (16) can then be used to check that the outcome of natural selection on correlated characters is in accord with estimates of genetic parameters (see Section 1V.D); if there is a substantial discrepancy, then selection may be acting on other genetically correlated characters that had not been considered.
C. Multivariate Selection The concept of a trade-off in optimization theory is clearly related to the genetic correlation in quantitative genetics. When selection favours two traits simultaneously (e.g. two components of fitness), a positive genetic correlation will increase the rate of evolution (the increase in mean fitness) while a negative genetic correlation will slow it down; thus a negative genetic correlation between two traits favoured by selection is sometimes referred to as antagonistic pleiotropy, or negative pleiotropy. Genes that contribute to positive correlations will rapidly become fixed, while those that increase one selected trait but reduce the other tend to be maintained because their “antagonistic” effects cancel out. Thus simple, qualitative theory predicts that negative rather than positive genetic correlations should be found between components of fitness. Some authors have argued that negative pleiotropy is the main or only point of interest in empirical studies of trade-offs (e.g. Reznick, 1985; Rose et a l . , 1987), though we shall see that the multivariate case is more complicated than indicated by the simple bivariate argument above (Pease and Bull, 1988; Charlesworth, 1990).
1. Evolution of Negative Genetic Correlation in Two Dimensions Charnov (1989) used a generalized two-dimensional example to demonstrate the relationship between a functional constraint on two life-history variables and the genetic covariance between them at selective equilibrium, He argued in favour of the optimization approach because, provided there is additive genetic variance in both traits, the population mean values at selective equilibrium are close to the optimization predictions and they should show a negative genetic correlation of - 1 . The terms V A ( z l ) , v A ( z 2 ) and the covariance C A ( z I z, 2 ) must satisfy a particular form because selection pushes up towards the constraint boundary z 2 = f(zl). Using a linearized version of Fisher’s Fundamental Theorem, Charnov (1989) obtained the same dynamical equations for phenotypic evolution as in Lande’s (1982) approach for weak selection. If all the variance V is additive genetic, writing VI1 for VA(zl), V z 2for V A ( z z ) ,V12 for C A ( z lz, 2 ) , the equilibrium condition in the region of selective equilibrium is:
84
R . H . SMITH v22
=
(af/azl)*2vll
=
-(af/aZl)*VII
and v12
where * denotes that a quantity is evaluated at equilibrium. Thus the genetic variance-covariance matrix G at equilibrium has the form:
For the iteroparous life-cycle exemplified by Eq. (3), taking s1 as fixed and considering only s2 and m with the constraint f l , the equilibrium G matrix for z T = [m, s2]is:
This result may seem trivial, but it makes very clear the relationship between the graphical optimality analysis of Sibly and Calow (1986) and the equilibrium genetic analysis. The slope of the fitness contour -sl that determines the optimal solution is the slope of the regression of VA(sZ)on VA(m) at equilibrium. Thus if s 1 is high (predicted to lead to semelparity), we expect the genetic variance of s2 to be larger (relative to the genetic variance in m) than if s 1 were low (iteroparity). However, this result says nothing about absolute values of the genetic variances and covariances at equilibrium, and the equilibrium condition (17) is only satisfied when the curvature of the trade-off curve in the region of the optimal life-history is negligible. The equilibrium conditions are, of course, determined by the selection gradient VW; at equilibrium, the changes Az in the mean values of the z , are zero (Lande, 1979, 1982; Lande and Arnold, 1983) because:
Az
=
GVW
=
GV1A-I
(20)
Since V17 = [ s l ,11 for z T = [m, s2], simple matrix multiplication shows that A z T = [O,O]. What about variance in fitness in this scheme? From Eq. (3): vA(A) = s:VA(m) =
s:VA(m)
+ vA(s2) + 2CA(slmr s2)
+
(21)
vA(s2) -k 2slCA(m, s2)
Substitution from Eq. (19) confirms that there is zero variance in A (and therefore in r ) at equilibrium, Thus the genetic correlation between components of fitness means that variance can be maintained in those components at equilibrium even though the variance in fitness is zero.
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
85
Charnov (1989) emphasized that the genetic covariance structure is not necessarily fixed and is likely to evolve as selection proceeds; this is not always made clear in other formulations based on Eq. (20) or similar. Also, the G matrix is a linear representation of the underlying trade-off relationship and can therefore give only a limited (and somewhat distorted) view of the underlying trade-off constraint (cf. Bell and Koufopanou, 1986, p. 127). Evolution towards genetic equilibrium is slowed down by its own progress. The negative genetic correlation evolves by differential selection against those genotypes that are not pushed up against the trade-off curve and are not in the region of the optimal life-history (zy, z z ) . As evolution of a negative correlation occurs, the variance in fitness VA(r ) decreases asymptotically towards zero much more rapidly than the variances in fitness components, VI1 and V 2 2 .In a multi-allelic, two-variable, deterministic simulation model based on Eq. (3) and a constraint similar to Eq. (4), L. R. Linton (pers. comm.) found that r, evolved from 0 to -0.9 in a matter of tens of generations, but did not go beyond about -0.95 after several hundred generations. In these circumstances, V , , and V22also decline slowly and the linearized predictions about their relative magnitudes and that of their covariance are approximately correct. However, we should not expect negative genetic correlations always to evolve because of underlying functional constraints, as seems to be implied by proponents of negative pleiotropy (e.g. Rose, 1983a; Reznick, 1985; Rose er al. 1987; Smith et al., 1987; Mgller ef al., 1989a). The two dimensional case is deceptively straightforward, and Pease and Bull (1988) and Charlesworth (1990) have shown that trade-off constraints may combine to lead to positive as well as negative genetic correlations.
2. More than Two Variables The properties of the general multivariate case are too complicated to describe in full here. The theory is a development of Robertson’s (1968) Secondary Theorem of Natural Selection and assumes that z for a given population follows a multivariate normal distribution with a variancecovariance matrix P which is the sum of genetic effects (G) and environmental effects (E). Lande (1979, 1982) is largely responsible for this approach, encapsulated in Eq. (20) and discussed recently by Lande (1988), Turelli (1988) and Caswell (1989b). The problem with generalizing from the two-dimensional case with one constraint is that the relationship between functional constraints and genetic correlations at equilibrium becomes complex. Pease and Bull (1988) noted that a subset of traits comprising a trade-off may have positive covariances even though they are part of a wider genetic trade-off that generates negative covariances with other characters; thus
86
R. H . SMITH
they urged experimentalists to measure too many rather than too few traits in the search for trade-offs. Without writing down specific mathematical functions, it is possible to illustrate this in a rough and ready way (Fig. 4). In both Fig. 4(a) and 4(e), there is the constraint z 1 + z 2 z 3 = k such that all phenotypes lie on or below a plane. However, in Fig. 4(e), an additional constraint of the sort used by Charlesworth (1990) for illustration maintains negative genetic correlations between ( z l , z 2 ) and ( z l r z 3 ) but generates a positive genetic correlation between ( z 2 ,z 3 ) as shown by the projections in Fig. 4(f)-(h)* Charlesworth’s (1990) mathematical formulation is based on n variables with p constraints f, (p < n), so that the components of z can be arbitrarily treated as either constrained or free variables (the n-p free variables are uncorrelated amongst themselves). At equilibrium, the product of the G matrix and the gradient vector is zero (Eq.(20)) implying either that all the variances Vii are zero or that the genetic variance-covariance matrix is singular (there is a linear dependence between the rows and columns of G such that detlGl = 0). Charlesworth (1990) showed that, although some of the genetic covariances V,i must be negative, not all must be, and there are some conditions which imply that some genetic correlations must be positive. Genetic correlations are only constrained to be negative (for constrained pairs of variables) and zero (for pairs of unconstrained variables) if the separate pairs of variables are subject to independent constraints e.g. z I = fl(z2); z 3 = fZ(z4) etc. This shows the limitation of only examining pair-wise trade-offs between variables taken two at a time and highlights the practical problem of deciding how many, and which, variables to measure.
+
3. Selection, Mutation and Non-additive Effects Although the linearized, multivariate selection model allows genetic variation to be maintained in components of variation, trade-offs with monotonic curvature would lead to eventual loss of genetic variation in a wholly deterministic world because the curvature would lead to reduced fitness for any point away from the optimum on the curve. The multivariate selection model alone is therefore lacking as a full explanation of maintenance of variation. It is now accepted that recurrent mutation may play a role in maintaining quantitative variation in traits subject to normalizing selection. Following Lande (1975), a number of theoretical and simulation studies have lead to some agreement and some conflict (Rose et a l . , 1987; Lande, 1988; Turelli, 1988). Estimates of variance generated by new mutation in several traits in different X V E (Maynard Smith, species indicate results of the order of
I
I
Fig. 4 Constraints on life-history variables give rise to different equilibrium genetic correlations (Charlesworth, 1990): (a) and (e) show the pattern of genotypic variation for a trivariate system subject to constraints of the type used by Charlesworth (1990) to illustrate how both positive and genetic correlations can arise at genetic equilibrium; (b), (c) and (d) are the bivariate projections of (a) and all show negative genetic correlations; (f), (g) and (h) are the corresponding projections of (e) and, while two show negative genetic correlations, the genetic correlation between z2 and z3 at equilibrium is positive.
88
R. H . SMITH
1989a) and these values suggest that mutation may be more important than was once thought. However, Charlesworth (1990) found that mutations are unlikely to affect greatly the pattern of genetic correlations in a random-mating population. Mutation may contribute to observed variation in life-history characters but is otherwise of little immediate interest in ecological studies of life history and will not be considered further here. Non-additive effects are important (Rose, 1982, 1983b, 1985). A range of population genetics models with dominance, epistasis and other complications known to occur in real populations give rise to antagonistic pleiotropy, though there is little empirical evidence for the pattern of dominance required by the theory (Rose et a l . , 1987). Unfortunately the multivariate selection model does not easily generalize to include such interactions.
D. Gene-Environment Interactions As noted earlier, the basic quantitative genetics model assumes that there is no association between the genotypic effect g j k of an individual on a character z i , and the environmental effect ejk. If there is such interaction, the set of phenotypes produced by a genotype in different environments is known as the norm of reaction (Schmalhausen, 1949) of a genotype. The gene-environment interaction may mean that a particular difference in environment eik has a greater effect on some genotypes than on others, or there may be a change in the ranking of a series of genotypes measured on some phenotypic scale in different environments. For example, Falconer (1989a) compared the growth of young mice in two strains A and B under conditions of good and bad nutrition. In a good nutritional environment, strain A grew faster than strain B while in a bad nutritional environment, strain B grew faster than strain A. Note that this is a comparison of estimates of the mean value of ( r i + g i k ) in Eq. (lo), and that there could be an interaction of eik with either Z i (assumed constant within a strain) or gik (maybe variable within a strain) or both. Although the gene-environment interaction is logically regarded as part of the environmental variance (Falconer, 1989a, p. 135), because individuals experience different environments in nature, gene-environment interactions affect the realised phenotypes and hence the selection gradients for different genotypes. Indeed, Lewontin (1974) rejected simple partitioning of phenotypic variance into genetic and environmental components as a means of understanding why particular phenotypes have evolved, and argued that the norm of reaction is the real point of interest.
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
89
1. The Norm of Reaction and Adaptive Evolution Via and Lande (1985) and Via (1987) have discussed the norm of reaction as a potentially adaptive trait that can allow adaptive phenotypic plasticity (Bradshaw, 1965; Caswell, 1983; Moller et a l . , 1989b), and Stearns and Koella (1986) have developed an optimization model for a specific norm of reaction. Baker (1988) treated gene-environment interactions as individual responses to environmental stress and discussed their relevance to plant breeding. Defining and measuring a norm of reaction is not straightforward. The different environments (two or more) first have to be defined if gene-environment interactions are to be separated out in a structured account of phenotypic variance. Analysis of variance may then separate out gene-environment effects as a component of variance (Falconer, 1989a), but Via (1987) argued that this traditional approach is not very informative. An alternative approach is to treat a single character z , expressed in two environments e , and e2 as two character states (Falconer, 1952), each expressed in only one environment. The two states z , ( E , ) and z , ( E z ) may have some common genetic determination and hence there is a sort of genetic correlation ( I C E ) . Via (1987; Fig. 3) showed how i G E measures the gene-environment interaction. If the variance among genotypes V, is the same in each environment, the gene-environment interaction variance VGEis related to i G E as follows (Yamada, 1962):
In a designed breeding experiment, for example half-sib/full-sib families (see Section IV.C), ?-GE is estimated by the correlation of family means or breeding values (Falconer, 1989a) in the two character states. Interestingly, although r G E = - 1 represents the greatest gene-environment interactions, both positive and negative r G E constrain independent evolution of the two character states (Fig. 5 ) ; the greatest opportunity for phenotypic plasticity is when rGE = 0 (Via, 1987). For the multivariate case, Via and Lande (1985) noted that the evolution of a set of character states expressed in different environments depends critically upon the pattern of genetic correlations between states, rcE. Via and Lande (1985) extended Lande’s (1979, 1982) multivariate selection model to two environments using a matrix formulation incorporating I C E . Just as the change in a single character under natural selection is affected by selection on correlated characters (Section III.C), so the dynamics of evolution in each character state depend both on a direct response to selection in that environment and on correlated responses to selection in other environments experienced by the population (Via, 1987).
90
R . H . SMITH
2. Relevance to Ecologists? It is clear that the mathematical theory outlined in this section goes well beyond the data available to test the predictions. Ecologists will think in terms of, not just two or three, but many micro-environments, potentially giving rise to a vast array of rcE values that can never be estimated in practice. Because the environment experienced by an animal population varies both in space and in time, is there any value in separating VcE from V E and developing a theory of gene-environment interactions when the rate of change of environment experienced by different genotypes is so rapid compared with the potential rate of evolution of norms of reaction? There are two particular sorts of environmental variation that are likely to be important in this context. One is externally imposed stress due to environmental toxins; an example of this sort of variability is the range of host plants that might be available to a polyphagous insect, and this is the context in which Via and Lande (1985) developed the above theory (Via, 1984a, b). When larval stages cannot move from a host plant chosen for them by their mother from a range of options, phenotypic plasticity is clearly at a premium as a means of coping with plant secondary toxins even though there may be a cost of plasticity (and hence a trade-off) compared with obligate monophagy. Holloway et af ., (1990a,b) have examined character states in toxin-stressed environments by quantitative genetic analysis in the rice weevil Sitophifus oryzae, though they do not discuss their data in terms of gene-environment interactions but rather as effects of novel environments on genetic trade-offs (Service and Rose, 1985). The other environmental variation is internally imposed because of population pressure. Population density with its effects on I, and m, has been one of the main foci of attention of animal ecologists for decades, yet interactions of density with genetics have hardly been explored (Charlesworth, 1980). Many animals exploit patchily distributed resources, for example insect larvae that develop in seeds, fungi, carcases or dung. Even with adaptive oviposition behaviour to minimize adverse effects of larval competition (Smith and Lessells, 1985), the spatial distribution of patches of resources will result in patches at high and low larval density. Gene-density interactions may constrain the expression of genetic variation in, for example, body size and a correlated character at high density (see Section 1V.E). Holloway et al. (1990a) found that genetic correlations between fitness components were changed by larval density in S. oryzae, a species in which larval density (larvae/seed) is found t o vary substantially in a non-adaptive way (Smith and Lessells, 1985). The effect of high larval density on most species exploiting a patchy resource is to
91
(a)
Environment
E,
Environment
Environment
E:
E:
(b)
(c)
Fig. 5 The gene-environment (GE) interaction may take several forms. The phenotypic values of a character z 1 are plotted for several genotypes in two environments El and E z (after Via, 1987). By way of example, zl could be body weight at emergence in an insect at two population densities, high ( E 2 ) and low ( E l ) . In (a), there is no gene-environment interaction ( r G E = l), while in (b) the gene-environment interaction is so strong ( r G E = -1) that there is a complete reversal of ranked performance in the two environments. In (c), rGE = 0 because none of the genetic variation in z1 is expressed in the high-density environment Ez The gene-environment interaction in (c) means that selection would only act on z 1 in the low-density environment E 1.
reduce juvenile survivorship; thus the selection gradient will be changed (Eq. (17)), and there may be a change in the G matrix (effectively a gene-environment interaction). Estimation of genetic variances and covariances ought therefore to be carried out separately over a range of realistic densities, though in practice this is a mammoth task.
E. The G and E Matrices Section 1II.C concentrated on the genetic variances and covariances at equilibrium, given a selection differential VW and functional constraints
92
R. H . SMITH
fi. The rate of progress towards equilibrium also depends on non-genetic (environmental) variances and covariances. The multivariate analogue of Eq. (15) is (Lande, 1979): z = GP-‘S
where P - ’ is the inverse of the phenotypic variance-covariance matrix and S is the vector of selection differentials, typically defined in a truncation selection experiment as described in Section III.B.4. Thus the selection gradient VW is equivalent to the vector product P - ‘ S . Cheverud (1984) discussed the distinction between the selection gradient and the selection differential in relation to direct and indirect effects of selection. As discussed in Section IV.A, although phenotypic correlations can be quite different from genetic correlations (Cheverud, 1982), P and G will be very similar if heritabilities of the component traits are high (Bell and Koufopanou, 1986, p.104) because the multivariate analogue of Eq.( 11) is: P = G + E
(24)
As noted previously in relation to heritability, there are advantages in separating G from E and breaking these matrices down further where possible. Cheverud (1984) suggested that, because environmentally caused variations must act via the same development pathways as genetically caused variations, environmental correlations might be expected to show patterns similar to phenotypic correlations. Hegmann and DeFries (1970) suggested that environmental and genetic correlations are themselves correlated, though the available data show no clear pattern (Bell and Koufopanou, 1986, Fig. 9; Falconer, 1989a; Table 19.1). What use, if any, is the E matrix? Bell and Koufopanou (1986) noted that environmental correlation is regarded by geneticists as a nuisance because it obscures genetic correlation and reduces the selection response (Eq. (15)); they argued (pp. 105-108) that environmental correlations between components of fitness may be positive or negative if the components have different optima along an environmental gradient, or they may be positive or zero if the optima coincide. On this basis, the E matrix would seem to be just a nuisance! However, the E matrix must contain some information about physiological trade-offs within genotypes, that is developmental and resource-allocation constraints (Cheverud, 1984). The problem is how to separate the effects of resource allocation constraints from those of variation in resource acquisition (van Noordwijk and de Jong, 1986) and other effects such as gene-environment interaction. Individuals that are “lucky” for some non-genetic reason will tend to perform better in several components of
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
93
fitness than others that by chance are less fortunate. It is the confounding of effects of luck with those of constraints within individuals that make the simple E matrix hard to interpret (Table 4). Although there is as yet no clear solution to the problem of how to structure the E matrix into resource allocation vs resource acquisition components, some sort of manipulation experiment (Section 1V.B) within families in a designed breeding experiment (Section 1V.C) may be one answer. Experimental manipulations involving resource provision should mask chance variation in resource acquisition while designed breeding experiments take out genetic effects. Taking out gene-environment interactions as genetic covariation between character states (Via, 1987) should allow fundamental resource allocation constraints within individuals to be identified. Similar ideas to these are explored from a slightly different viewpoint by Stearns (1989).
IV. EXPERIMENTAL APPROACHES ILLUSTRATED BY CALLOSOBRUCHUS Life-history evolution can only be understood by identifying constraints-functional constraints that are related to development, physiology and resource allocation, and genetic constraints (Gould and Lewontin, 1979; Loeschke, 1987) that affect the potential of natural selection to drive the mean phenotype up the most direct route to an optimum (the selection gradient). Life-history trade-off constraints have been studied using a variety of methods (reviewed by Bell, 1980; Reznick, 1985; Bell and Koufopanou, 1986; Partridge and Harvey, 1988; Pease and Bull, 1988; Stearns, 1989). Reznick (1985) considered four methods (see below) but argued that only trade-offs with a genetic basis would constrain evolution, and therefore only the demonstration of additive genetic correlation o r of correlated response to selection were valid demonstrations of trade-offs. However, Bell and Koufopanou (1986) argued persuasively in favour of experimental manipulation, and Partridge and Harvey (1988) and Moller et al. (1989b) presented a case for carefully designed manipulations as means of measuring trade-off constraints. Only in a few studies have more than one of the four methods below been examined in the same population. The best-known demonstration of genetic trade-offs is the Drosophilu study by Rose and Charlesworth (1981a,b) who used a breeding experiment to estimate additive genetic correlations, and a selection experiment to evaluate the consequences; their results showed mainly negative correlations between components
94
R. H . SMITH
of fitness, though some were positive. Berven (1982) and Berven and Gill (1982) found additive genetic correlations indicative of a developmental constraint between developmental period and larval body size in the wood frog R a m sylvatica; however, they found a correlation between habitat and r A , which was positive in lowland and strongly negative in mountain populations. The milkweed bugs Oncopeltus spp. have been studied by Dingle and co-workers using both phenotypic and genetic methods (Dingle et af., 1982; Dingle, 1986; Scott and Dingle, 1990). While some authors argue strongly in favour of a particular approach to the exclusion of others, most agree that different approaches yield different sorts of complementary information (e.g. Stearns, 1989). Clearly, it is easier to work on a species that can be successfully reared in the laboratory, and more useful if the laboratory environment is near-identical or at least similar to some of the environments experienced by ancestral populations in the wild. That is why Drosophifu and pests of stored seeds are widely used, though we should always remember that concentrating on such species may give us an oversimplified and probably biased view of the natural world. In the brief outline of experimental approaches below, studies on the seed beetle C. rnaculatus will provide the main examples used for illustration.
A. Phenotypic Correlation Correlations between phenotypes may be carried out at a number of different levels: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv)
between species comparisons; between populations of the same species; between unspecified genotypes within species; between genetically identical members of a clone in species that reproduce asexually.
Although spurned by many, broad correlations across species generate most of the interesting questions about evolution of life-histories. Without such observations, strict experimentalists would not know where to start. There are problems with statistical analysis and interpretation (Clutton-Brock and Harvey, 1979). Perhaps the biggest problem is the widespread tendency to treat everything as a consequence of body size rather than question whether evolution of body size might not have been driven by other aspects of life history (Partridge and Harvey, 1988; Caswell, 1989a; Sibly et a [ . , 1991).
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
95
An example of the use of between-species comparisons to try to understand life-history evolution is the development of the idea of rand K-strategies. The conce?t of r- vs K-selection spawned a growth industry of studies of correlations across species in the 1970s, following Pianka’s (1970) expansion of the original idea. Weeds and pest species were generally described as r-strategists, and pest ecology is a field where between-species comparisons arise naturally because of the need to predict, understand and control the distribution of damaging pests. For example, Giga and Smith (1983) studied comparative aspects of life histories in four species of seed beetle, Callosobruchus spp. Some of their results will be described below because C. maculafus is used as an example in Sections 1V.B-E. Callosobruchus species are beetles of the family Bruchidae and are pests of stored legume seeds in the tropics and sub-tropics. Eggs are laid onto the surface of seeds or seed-pods, and the larvae develop within a single seed and can cause substantial loss of quality and quantity of seeds. Adult beetles do not normally feed in stores but may take nectar or similar sources of energy in the field. Giga and Smith (1983) estimated the following components of fitness in four Callosobruchus species under different environmental conditions in the laboratory: (i) development rate (ii) survivorship from egg to adult (iii) lifetime fecundity (iv) adult female longevity. Using an approximate expression (Howe, 1953), they estimated r for the different environmental conditions, and found that temperature (not unexpectedly) was the main determinant of r . The interest here in this standard approach is that it revealed a species-environment interaction, showing that of two closely related species, Callosobruchus rhodesianus was better adapted to cool conditions than C. macularus. The study also compared two geographical strains of C . maculatus, but these were hardly different (Table 1) although later studies (Credland et al., 1986) showed much greater divergence in other geographical strains of the same species. The life-cycle of the four Callosobruchus species is summarized in Table 1. Points to note from Giga and Smith (1983) are that all species are semelparous, though Callosobruchus analis has a greatly extended oviposition period and longevity compared with the other species, and a correspondingly reduced lifetime fecundity (see Section 1V.B for a physiological explanation); this tendency towards iteroparity is correlated with low juvenile survivorship, itself a consequence of intense larval competition (Smith and Lessells, 1985; Smith, 1990). Thus phenotypic correlations reveal a suite or syndrome of life-history correlates (Bradshaw, 1990) and suggest where effort should be directed in more focussed investigation of genetic and physiological constraints.
96
K . ti. SMITH
Table 1 Life-history of four Callosobruchus species. Callosobruchus species
C. analis
C. chinensis C. tnaculatus C.rhodesianus (a) Life-history at 25 "C
Life-history character Egg-adult developmental period (days) Egg-adult survivorship ( % ) Lifetime fecundity Oviposition period (days) Female longevity (days)
40.5
31.4
28.0
35.9
22.6 48.5 12.9 15.3
67.3 70.7 6.2 7.5
82.9 67.4 6.2 6.3
66.3 49.0 5.9 8.5
(b) Intrinsic rate of increase (r) per female per calendar month Temp
("C)
20 25 30
35
-
-
1.06 1.37 0.44
2.76 4.03 2.91
0.48 3.20 3.60 3.60
0.60 2.15 2.73 0.60
Avoid High
Avoid High
Avoid High
5
4
5
Scramble
Scramble
Scramble
(c) Behaviour and dynamics Characteristic
Larval competition strategy
Attack Oviposition site selectivity Very high Time to lay 90% of eggs at 11 25 "C (days) Populationdynamicoutcome Contest
Results for C. macuhtus are for a Brazilian (Campinas) strain. Females attach eggs to the surface of dry legume seeds of which the cowpea Vigna unguicu/ara is the most suitable. Hatched larvae tunnel into the seed where development to pupation and adult emergence is completed. When there are several larvae within a single seed, larval competition causes increased mortality (Smith and Lessells. 1985). Emerged adults mate and lay eggs without delay. Adults do not normally feed. (a) Mean values of life-history characters recorded at low density on cowpeas at 25 "C (after Giga and Smith, 1983); (b) effect of temperature on the intrinsic rates of increase per calendar month, estimated using Howe's (1953) approximation; (c) summary of oviposition behaviour and population dynamics (Smith and Lessells, 1985). The data show that C. macularus is the best adapted to high temperature and C. rhodesianus to low temperature; C. analis has a substantially lower rate of increase because of extreme larval competition (Smith and Lessells, 1985) and consequently greater selectivity of oviposition site, greater longevity and reduced fecundity.
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
97
B. Experimental Manipulation Mdler et al. (1989a) argued that manipulation experiments are useful in at least two ways. First, they reveal parts of the options set that other approaches cannot reach (for example, genetic analysis is restricted to the range of genetic variation present in a study population at one time; Partridge and Harvey, 1988). Second, they measure contingent responses of individuals to a range of immediate circumstances; if this plastic response of the phenotype increases fitness and has a genetic basis, it will be favoured by selection (Caswell, 1983). Reznick (1985) argued that phenotypic plasticity does not reflect the response of organisms to natural selection and that only genetical analyses are of evolutionary interest because only genetically coded options take part in the evolutionary process. Bell and Koufopanou (1986) provided strong counter-arguments, pointing out that in general an experimental approach is more powerful than an observational one, and that properly designed experiments have provided a reasonably consistent, empirical basis for the theory of trade-offs, in contrast with estimation of genetic correlations. Partridge et al. (1986, 1987) successfully investigated fitness costs of reproduction in female D. rnelunogusfer, though Partridge (1989a,b) added the cautionary note that it is not yet clear to what extent responses to manipulation are similar to genetic effects. Manipulative studies in the field were reviewed by Partridge and Harvey (1988). Not surprisingly, many involve clutch or brood manipulation in birds (Nur, 1988) and data analysis has required fairly sophisticated model fitting (Pettifor et a1 ., 1988).
1 . Types of Manipulation Bell and Koufopanou (1986) categorized manipulations in two ways. First, similar groups may be given different treatments, e.g. brood size (Nur, 1984, 1988). opportunity to oviposit (Mdler et al., 1989b), mating opportunities (Partridge and Farquhar, 1981). Second, different groups may receive the same treatment, e.g. predation (Koufopanou and Bell, 1984), temperature manipulation (Giga and Smith, 1983). Bell and Koufopanou (1986, p.88) discussed problems of logic with the first category, though in general they regard the manipulative approach as having shed most light on the hypothesized cost of reproduction trade-off. There is a fair measure of agreement that manipulation experiments can successfully reveal physiological constraints provided experiments are carefully designed to control confounding variables such as phenotypic quality and environmental variation (Partridge 1989a,b; Partridge and Harvey, 1985, 1988).
98
R. H . SMITH
2. Changing the Options Set? It is implicit in the manipulative approach that the experiment should be exploring the options set (Fig. 6a) rather than creating new ones (Fig. 6b,c). The trade-off hypothesis is that there exists an options set bounded by the trade-off curve, and that manipulating a change in one character leads to a shift in the balance of resources allocated to different functions (Calow and Sibly, 1983) and a change in another character within the options set (Fig. 6a). However, an experimental manipulation might create a new environment with a changed options set. Figure 6b shows how creation of new options sets could give a spurious similarity to a trade-off within an options set. In contrast, Fig.
2,
(c)
Fig. 6. The effect of different experimental manipulations may be to create new options sets as in (b) and (c) rather than to move the mean values of a pair of characters along the trade-off curve as in (a). The arrows point to mean values observed in an unmanipulated ancestral environment (A) and in two manipulations (B and C). In (b) the new options sets created give a spurious similarity to the trade-off hypothesis (a negative correlation between components of fitness), while in (c) the new options sets apparently contradict the trade-off hypothesis. Only in (a) are the manipulations valid (after Moiler et al., 1989b).
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
99
6c shows how new environments could give a picture that apparently contradicts the trade-off hypothesis; this can often arise if a manipulation affects resource availability (cf. van Noordwijk and de Jong, 1986) and variation in resource availability can mask variation in resource allocation. Because new options sets have been created, neither situation (Fig. 6b or 6c) provides information about trade-offs within an options set (Calow and Sibly, 1983; Fig. 4). In practice, it may not be straightforward to decide which manipulations are appropriate.
3. Callosobruchus maculatus The cowpea weevil C. maculatus has a fairly simple, semelparous life-history, and the ancestral environment is well known and easily replicated in laboratory conditions. Accordingly, Maller et al. (1989b) were able to design manipulations of juveniles and adults separately that fell into three categories: Normal environmental variation; juvenile density and opportunities for oviposition by adult females were manipulated within the range likely to be encountered in culture conditions. (ii) Temperature variation; temperature was varied above (30 "C) and below (23 "C) the normal culture temperature (25 "C) experienced over the previous 32 generations in the laboratory. (iii) Nutritional variation; juvenile nutrition was varied by changing the host plant seed that larvae were reared in, and adult nutrition by providing unusual feeding and drinking opportunities (food and water are not normally available for adults in culture). (i)
The full results are given in Mdler et al. (1989b; Fig. 2 , Tables 3 and 4). The broad pattern of correlations in the different categories of manipulation is summarized in Table 2. The results are in accord with a priori predictions about options sets (Fig. 6), and caution against uncritical use of manipulations. The main problem in manipulation experiments is deciding which characters to measure (and how many), and has not been addressed by theory as it has for genetic correlations (Charlesworth, 1990). It is worth noting that the negative correlation found between lifetime fecundity and adult longevity in C. maculatus using manipulation (Table 2) demonstrated a cost of reproduction trade-off that was not revealed by genetic analysis (Mdler et a l . , 1989a) because of lack of genetic variation. The physiological mechanism underlying this trade-off is easily understood; adults do not normally have feeding opportunities in
100
K. H. SMITH
Table 2 Results of manipulative experiments in Caflosobruchus maculutus Characters examined
Manipulations (No.) Correlation
(5) Emergence weight (z4) a. Density vs development rate ( z 2 )b.Temperature (3) (2) (juvenile) c. Nutrition
-
(4) a. Density b.Temperature (3) (5) c. Nutrition
-
Lifetime fecundity ( z , ) vs longevity ( z 3 ) (adults)
-
+ -
+
Interpretation Physiological trade-off Spurious ‘trade-off‘ New options set Physiological trade off Spurious ‘trade-off‘ New options set
The table (after Moller el al.. 1989b) summarizes the effects of three types of experimental manipulation on pairs of life-history characters in juveniles and adults. The trade-off hypothesis predicts a negative correlation between the characters examined as a consequence of a resource-allocation decision. It is argued by M ~ l l e rer al., (1989b) that only the density manipulations represented variation within the normal environment of the beetle; the temperature and nutrition manipulations d o not test the trade-off hypothesis because they create new environments and altered options sets.
culture, and have to use reserves accumulated during larval development for both maintenance and reproduction. When oviposition opportunities are not available, adults live longer at the cost of producing less eggs, and therefore can exploit opportunities for oviposition as and when they arise (e.g. by transfer to fresh seeds; Sibly et a l . , 1991). Thus there is adaptive value in this phenotypic plasticity, and the energy reserves that a beetle has at emergence represent a genuine constraint (Smith and Lessells, 1985).
C. Breeding Designs Genetic variances and covariances are estimated from phenotypic data, structured in such away as to allow estimation of correlation between relatives (Falconer, 1989a). The choice of experimental designs is greater in most plant species than in most animals because of the wider opportunities for cloning, selfing etc. in plants (Lawrence, 1984). A weakness in quantitative genetic studies, emphasized by Bell and Koufopanou (1986), is that, unless they involve selection or measurement of character states in different environments, they are essentially correlational, even though they involve “treatments” (familial relationships) in the statistical sense. In this sense, they are in the same category as phenotypic correlation studies. Indeed, given sufficiently high heritabilities, genetic correlations can be inferred quite accurately from phenotypic correlations (Bell and Koufopanou, 1986, p. 103) using standard formulae (Falconer, 1989a, p.315).
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
101
The basic problem in estimating genetic parameters is that of separating out the genotypic effects g,k in Eq. (9) (the breeding value of the kth individual; Falconer, 1989a, p. 117). The genetic correlation is the correlation between breeding values, and genetic variance and heritability of course relate directly to the g,. There are very many examples of breeding experiments that estimate these genetic parameters in the animal and plant breeding literature (Falconer, 1989a), and too many even in the ecological and evolutionary literature to review here. Wright (1978), Law (1979), Dingle and Hegmann (1982) and Rose (1983a) give reviews, and Roff (1990) has recently summarized quantitative genetic studies of insect life-cycles. Overall, it seems that genetic correlation studies have often not identified the anticipated trade-offs (Bell and Koufopanou, 1986). In designing breeding experiments to estimate genetic parameters, a few basic rules need to be observed by those investigating life-history evolution: the study environment should be the same as (or as similar as possible to) the ancestral environment of the study species (Service and Rose, 1985; Clark, 1987; Holloway et a l . , 1990); the study population should be large and outbred, else there are likely to be artefactual correlations (see Rose (1984a,b) for a criticism of experiments by Giesel (1979), Giesel and Zettler (1980) and Giesel ef al. (1982a,b) who used inbred populations); also, linkage disequilibrium in small populations might give rise to genetic correlations that are interpreted as apparent pleiotropy (Rose et a l . , 1990); sample sizes must be large if estimates are to have anything like enough precision for inferences to be made; because variances and covariances are being compared, the sample size needs to be about the square of what would be regarded as a reasonable sample size when comparing means by normal distribution theory, that is n = 900 rather than n = 30 (Rose and Charlesworth, 1981a; Mdler er a l . , 1989a); the accumulated wisdom of decades of experience in animal and plant breeding should be drawn upon (Falconer, 1989a; Thompson, 1989).
1. Choice of Design Different experimental designs incorporate different causal components of variance in the observational components of phenotypic variance (Falconer, 1989a, Ch. 9). Relationships examined in different designs
102
R . H . SMITH
compare offspring with parents, half-sibs and full-sibs. Causal components of variance that should not be included in estimates of V A and r A are interaction effects (especially dominance deviations V,) and environmental covariance (especially maternal effects). The design of choice because it avoids bias is the half-sib design. An example is the design used by Mgller et af. (1989a) and is summarized in Table 3. A full-sib comparison should be avoided because, although the estimates are apparently precise, they are biased to an unknown degree by interaction variance and covariance, as well as maternal effects. Offspring-parent regression (either on single parent or on mid-parental value) does not suffer much from interaction effects, but can be complicated by maternal effects (if regression is on the mother) and by the offspring being measured in an environment that is not identical to that of their parents. All the above implies that choices are possible. Ecologists will often have to be opportunistic and make observations of similarity between relatives according to whatever comes up. While sample sizes are rarely sufficiently large in field studies, some long-term studies have generated estimates of genetic parameters (e.g. van Noordwijk et af., 1980). Modern computational methods that allow optimal analysis of data from different sorts of familial comparison offer better possibilities for the future study of field populations (Meyer, 1989), though there may often be a problem of non-random mating (e.g. large may tend to mate with large) that could lead to bias.
2. Statistical Analysis and Estimation Full-sibhalf-sib designs are conventionally analysed by nested analysis of variance. Unbalanced data sets can now be analysed using a statistical package such as SAS (SAS Institute Inc., 1985) with appropriate procedures (GLM and NESTED). Computing standard errors requires a theoretical approximation (e.g. Becker, 1984), and it is implicit in most analyses that the distribution of eik about gik is approximately normal. Standard errors are not always computed because the expressions are felt to be unreliable (e.g. Rose and Charlesworth, 1981a); it often turns out that the estimated standard errors are about as large as the estimates of h2 and r A , even with large sample sizes. Ecologists find more disconcerting the cases where point estimates of h 2 and r A are outside the feasible range (0-1 for h2 and -1 to +1 for r A ) ! This arises because of the way that components of variance are estimated by subtraction in nested analysis of variance, and one consequence is that sample estimates of VA and V E are likely to be negatively correlated even though by definition the population values are not. Unbalanced designs are prone to give biased estimates of variances, and it is
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
103
sometimes difficult to achieve statistical balance in breeding experiments on animals where fecundity and viability are variable. An alternative estimation procedure to theoretical approximations is a non-parametric resampling method such as the jackknife or the bootstrap (Efron, 1982); resampling methods avoid the usual assumptions such as independence of parameters, normality and small variances, and are feasible nowadays because of the ready availability of fast computers. However, there are still problems about choosing appropriate transformations, especially if hypothesis testing is intended. Arvesen and Schmitz (1970) and Holloway ec a l . , (1990b) have used jacknife estimates in the analysis of quantitative genetic data. The introduction of restricted maximum likelihood estimation (REML) and best linear unbiased prediction methods (Meyer, 1989), again made possible by advances in computer technology, make it possible to analyse data involving more than one generation (Kennedy and Sorensen, 1988). Two further advantages of REML programs are that unbalanced data sets can be dealt with, and point estimates and confidence intervals can be constrained within the feasible range (W. G. Hill, pers. comm.).
3. Callosobruchus maculatus Mdler ef al. (1989a) used a full-sibhalf-sib breeding design to estimate heritabilities of and genetic correlations between life-history characters in C. maculatus. Two potential trade-offs were selected for investigation. The first was a constraint on fecundity and development rate. Fecundity is correlated with body weight at emergence in the Brazilian strain of C. maculatus studied (Smith and Lessells, 1985). However, large body size might be achieved only at the cost of slow development. Since body weight is likely to be the physiological link between fecundity and development rate, body weight at emergence was recorded as well as egg-to-adult development rate and fecundity. The second trade-off examined was between lifetime fecundity and adult longevity. As described in Section IV.B, adults have a finite amount of resource to allocate between fecundity and maintenance. Thus highly fecund genotypes may not be able to live as long as less fecund ones. In iteroparous species where the adults feed, the constraint would be more complicated. Moller et al. (1989a) analysed data on four measurements made on 761 offspring of 30 males, each mated to six females. Development rate had negative genetic correlations with both adult longevity and fecundity (Table 4), while longevity and fecundity had a positive genetic correlation. Being larger genetically increases the fitness of adults in two ways, by increasing both fecundity and longevity. In order to remove the joint
104
K. H . SMITH
dependence on weight, residual fecundity and residual adult longevity were calculated for each individual after removing the effects of weight by linear regression. The genetic correlation between residual fecundity and residual adult longevity was not significantly different from zero, indicating that there was no genetic trade-off, though experimental manipulation did reveal a physiological trade-off (Mdler et al., 1989b). Overall, the results did show some genetic trade-offs, and emphasized the central role of body weight as an apparently causal link between components of fitness. Messina (1989, 1990) has also examined quantitative genetic parameters in C . macufarus, though his results cannot be compared directly because he measured different variables in a different population. The paper by Charlesworth (1990) now provides expressions that allow further analysis of multivariate genetic data. For C. macufarus, the estimated values of V, and VE can be calculated from the published values of r p , rA and h2 (Mgiller et a f . , 1989a; Table 4) and of V,, (Mplller et a f . , 1989a; Table 3, where the standard deviations are mis-labelled as standard errors; H. Moller, pers. comm.). The estimates of the causal components of variance are given in Table 3 along with the coefficient of genetic variation, which ranged from 3% for development rate to 12% for fecundity (cf. comparable figures for D . mefanogaster in Charlesworth, 1984). The phenotypic, genetic and environmental variance-covariance matrices are given in Table 4, with the corresponding correlations in the lower half of each tabulated matrix. The figures are given here to two decimal places without any measure of precision. Using the estimated G matrix (Table 4b), it is possible to test whether the estimated figures indicate genetic equilibrium or not. For example, Eq. (14) of Charlesworth (1990) for the covariance between constrained variables as a function of other variances and covariances is:
For the covariance between fecundity (zl) and development rate ( z 2 ) which were suggested a priori to be constrained, Ct2 should be approximately (C13x C23)/V33+ (C14 x C24)/V44, if weight and adult longevity are treated as free variables. The predicted C12 is -4.18, which is within 7% of the observed estimate (-3.90); this good agreement supports the premise that the estimated G matrix represents equilibrium variances and covariances, and perhaps suggests that the totality of the estimated genetic correlation matrix is more reliable than the approximate standard errors of individual point estimates suggest. Note that if weight had not been measured and included in the analysis, the predicted value of C12would have been -2.04, barely 52%
105
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
of the observed estimate. This underlines the importance of measuring all the variables involved in the genetic constraints (Pease and Bull, 1988; Charlesworth, 1990) in order to be able to understand the pattern of genetic correlations and emphasizes the inadequacy of a simple, bivariate approach to genetic trade-offs. Calculation of the determinant of G and of the determinants of sub-sets of G with different variables removed makes the same point (the determinant of G should be close to zero at equilibrium). Table 3 Quantitative genetic analysis of the life-history of Cullosobruchus muculutus
(a) Breeding design Male parent
Female parent
Female offspring
Offspring characters recorded
1
2
E.1
(b) Phenotypic means, heritabilities and variances Life-history character Mean
z1 Fecundity (eggs) z 2 Development rate ( x lo3 days-') 23 Adult longevity (days) 24 Weight at emergence (g)
Heritability
Z
h2
82 34
Variances
v,
v,
0.10 0.23
104 4
10
94
0.124
0.9
3.1
0.028
8.2
0.30
1.0
0.3
0.7
0.067
5.2
0.55
0.22
0.12
0.10
0.067
v,
vyyz
(After Moiler er a / . , 1989a.) (a) The full-sibhalf-sib design used to estimate genetic and environmental components of variances and covariances. In the hierarchical design, 30 males were mated with six females each, and four life-history characters were recorded for each of five female offspring per female parent. (b) Summary of narrow-sense heritability estimates, taken from Mdler er al. (1989a). The additive genetic (V,) and environmental (V,) components of phenotypic (V,) variance were calculated using the standard deviations of the mean phenotypic values in Table 3 of Mdler et al. (1989a). The quantity V y z / i varies from 3 to 12% and is a relative measure of the genetic contribution to the mean phenotype.
106
R. H. SMITH
Table 4 The phenotypic, genetic and environmental variance-covariance matrices estimated for the reduced data set (761 offspring) of Moller et al., (1989a). In each case, the variances (italicized) are on the diagonal, the covariances are above the diagonal, and the correlations are below the diagonal
z1
z2
z3
7-4
104.04 -0.04 +0.43 +0.61
-0.82 4.00 +0.06 -0.02
+4.39 +0.12 1.00 +0.33
+2.92 -0.02 +O. 16 0.22
10.40 +0.91 +0.68
-3.90 0.92 -0.73 - 1.01
+1.61 -0.38 0.30 +0.76
-0.76 -0.34 +O. 15 0.12
93.64 +0.18 +0.34 t-0.71
+3.08 3.08 +0.34 -0.58
+2.78 +0.50 0.70 +0.04
+2.16 +0.32
(a) P Matrix ZI 22 z3 z4
(b) G Matrix 21
22 z3 z4
- 1.26
(c) E Matrix
+0.01 0.10
One of the most important results of multivariate selection theory highlighted by Pease and Bull (1988) and Charlesworth (1990) is illustrated by the G matrix of C. mucufurus and should be emphasized once again: at equilibrium, a positive genetic correlation may evolve between two components of fitness even though the underlying constraints in the whole set of components of fitness are negative constraints of the trade-off type. In C. macufutus, fecundity and adult longevity were positively genetically correlated (Table 4b) although the underlying physiological trade-off constraint reflecting resource allocation was negative (Table 2).
D. Selection Experiments Changing the selection gradient should lead to observable changes in mean values of ti(and possibly in the G matrix). If genetic correlations are real, direct selection on a variable may be constrained and there should be a correlated response to selection in other variables. Bell and Koufopanou (1986) argued in favour of selection experiments rather
LIFE-HISTORY EVOLUTION
107
than breeding designs because a correlated response to selection demonstrates additive genetic correlation without ambiguity, and selection experiments seem to have demonstrated trade-offs more consistently. Rose and Charlesworth (1981a) found a correlated response to selection for early and late life-history characters in D . melanogaster, and Luckinbill et al. (1984) and Rose (1984b) confirmed these results.
1. Callosobruchus maculatus Having demonstrated additive genetic variation and covariation in C. maculatus, Mqjller et al. (1990) reported on a laboratory natural selection experiment where selection was exercised by using a culture interval (the time between transferring adult insects onto a fresh set of seeds) that was either very short or very long. Individuals that emerge just before transfer will have highest fitness. Those that emerge too late for transfer perish, while those that emerge too early miss the opportunity for additional growth (and fecundity), use up resources in staying alive, and perhaps waste eggs on old seeds that will be discarded. Thus short culture intervals favour fast developers which suffer a cost of light body weight, low lifetime fecundity and reduced adult longevity. In contrast, long culture intervals favour slow developers with heavy body weight, high lifetime fecundity and increased adult longevity. Each selection reg